Monographs in Mathematics Vol. 96
Managing Editors: H. Amann Universität Zürich, Switzerland J.-P. Bourguignon IHES, Bures-sur-Yvette, France K. Grove University of Maryland, College Park, USA P.-L. Lions Université de Paris-Dauphine, France Associate Editors: H. Araki, Kyoto University F. Brezzi, Università di Pavia K.C. Chang, Peking University N. Hitchin, University of Warwick H. Hofer, Courant Institute, New York H. Knörrer, ETH Zürich K. Masuda, University of Tokyo D. Zagier, Max-Planck-Institut Bonn
Wolfgang Arendt Charles J.K. Batty Matthias Hieber Frank Neubrander
Vector-valued Laplace Transforms and Cauchy Problems Second Edition
Wolfgang Arendt Angewandte Analysis Universität Ulm 89069 Ulm Germany
[email protected]
Charles J.K. Batty St. John’s College Oxford OX1 3JP UK
[email protected]
Matthias Hieber Fachbereich Mathematik TU Darmstadt Schlossgartenstr. 7 64289 Darmstadt Germany
[email protected]
Frank Neubrander Department of Mathematics Louisiana State University Baton Rouge, LA 70803 USA
[email protected]
2010 Mathematics Subject Classification: 35A22, 46F12, 35K25 ISBN 978-3-0348-0086-0 e-ISBN 978-3-0348-0087-7 DOI 10.1007/978-3-0348-0087-7 Library of Congress Control Number: 2011924209 © Springer Basel AG 2011 This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, re-use of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilms or in other ways, and storage in data banks. For any kind of use permission of the copyright owner must be obtained. Cover design: deblik, Berlin Printed on acid-free paper Springer Basel AG is part of Springer Science+Business Media www.birkhauser-science.com
Contents Preface to the First Edition
ix
Preface to the Second Edition
xii
I
Laplace Transforms and Well-Posedness of Cauchy Problems
1
The Laplace Integral 1.1 The Bochner Integral . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2 The Radon-Nikodym Property . . . . . . . . . . 1.3 Convolutions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4 Existence of the Laplace Integral . . . . . . . . . 1.5 Analytic Behaviour . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.6 Operational Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.7 Uniqueness, Approximation and Inversion . . . . 1.8 The Fourier Transform and Plancherel’s Theorem 1.9 The Riemann-Stieltjes Integral . . . . . . . . . . 1.10 Laplace-Stieltjes Integrals . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.11 Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
The 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
63 . 65 . 68 . 73 . 77 . 80 . 84 . 89 . 100
2
Laplace Transform Riesz-Stieltjes Representation . . . . . . . . . . . A Real Representation Theorem . . . . . . . . . Real and Complex Inversion . . . . . . . . . . . . Transforms of Exponentially Bounded Functions Complex Conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Laplace Transforms of Holomorphic Functions . . Completely Monotonic Functions . . . . . . . . . Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1 5 6 15 21 27 32 36 40 44 48 55 59
vi 3
CONTENTS Cauchy Problems 3.1 C0 -semigroups and Cauchy Problems . . . . . . . 3.2 Integrated Semigroups and Cauchy Problems . . 3.3 Real Characterization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4 Dissipative Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5 Hille-Yosida Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.6 Approximation of Semigroups . . . . . . . . . . . 3.7 Holomorphic Semigroups . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.8 Fractional Powers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.9 Boundary Values of Holomorphic Semigroups . . 3.10 Intermediate Spaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.11 Resolvent Positive Operators . . . . . . . . . . . 3.12 Complex Inversion and UMD-spaces . . . . . . . 3.13 Norm-continuous Semigroups and Hilbert Spaces 3.14 The Second Order Cauchy Problem . . . . . . . . 3.15 Sine Functions and Real Characterization . . . . 3.16 Square Root Reduction for Cosine Functions . . 3.17 Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
107 108 121 132 137 141 145 148 162 171 184 188 197 201 202 217 222 230
II
Tauberian Theorems and Cauchy Problems
4
Asymptotics of Laplace Transforms 4.1 Abelian Theorems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2 Real Tauberian Theorems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3 Ergodic Semigroups . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4 The Contour Method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.5 Almost Periodic Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6 Countable Spectrum and Almost Periodicity . . . . 4.7 Asymptotically Almost Periodic Functions . . . . . 4.8 Carleman Spectrum and Fourier Transform . . . . 4.9 Complex Tauberian Theorems: the Fourier Method 4.10 Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
243 244 247 261 272 288 295 306 318 325 329
Asymptotics of Solutions of Cauchy Problems 5.1 Growth Bounds and Spectral Bounds . . . . . 5.2 Semigroups on Hilbert Spaces . . . . . . . . . 5.3 Positive Semigroups . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4 Splitting Theorems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.5 Countable Spectral Conditions . . . . . . . . 5.6 Solutions of Inhomogeneous Cauchy Problems 5.7 Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
337 338 351 352 360 371 378 386
5
. . . . . . .
239
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
CONTENTS
III 6
vii
Applications and Examples
397
The 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4
Heat Equation The Laplacian with Dirichlet Boundary Conditions Inhomogeneous Boundary Conditions . . . . . . . . Asymptotic Behaviour . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
7
The 7.1 7.2 7.3
Wave Equation 417 Perturbation of Selfadjoint Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 417 The Wave Equation in L2 (Ω) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 423 Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 427
8
Translation Invariant Operators on Lp (Rn ) 8.1 Translation Invariant Operators and C0 -semigroups 8.2 Fourier Multipliers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3 Lp -spectra and Integrated Semigroups . . . . . . . 8.4 Systems of Differential Operators on Lp -spaces . . 8.5 Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
401 401 408 412 415
429 430 435 441 449 458
A Vector-valued Holomorphic Functions
461
B Closed Operators
467
C Ordered Banach Spaces
477
D Banach Spaces which Contain c0
481
E Distributions and Fourier Multipliers
485
Indexes Bibliography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Notation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
493 493 525 533
Prefaces Preface to the First Edition Linear evolution equations in Banach spaces have seen important developments in the last two decades. This is due to the many different applications in the theory of partial differential equations, probability theory, mathematical physics, and other areas, and also to the development of new techniques. One important technique is given by the Laplace transform. It played an important role in the early development of semigroup theory, as can be seen in the pioneering monograph by Hille and Phillips [HP57]. But many new results and concepts have come from Laplace transform techniques in the last 15 years. In contrast to the classical theory, one particular feature of this method is that functions with values in a Banach space have to be considered. The aim of this book is to present the theory of linear evolution equations in a systematic way by using the methods of vector-valued Laplace transforms. It is simple to describe the basic idea relating these two subjects. Let A be a closed linear operator on a Banach space X. The Cauchy problem defined by A is the initial value problem u (t) = Au(t) (t ≥ 0), (CP ) u(0) = x, where x ∈ X is a given initial value. If u is an exponentially bounded, continuous function, then we may consider the Laplace transform ∞ u ˆ(λ) = e−λt u(t) dt 0
of u for large real λ. It turns out that u is a (mild) solution of (CP ) if and only if (λ − A)ˆ u(λ) = x
(λ large).
(1)
Thus, if λ is in the resolvent set of A, then u ˆ(λ) = (λ − A)−1 x.
(2)
x
PREFACES
Now it is a typical feature of concrete evolution equations that no explicit information on the solution is known and only in exceptional cases can the solution be given by a formula. On the other hand, in many cases much can be said about the resolvent of the given operator. The fact that the Laplace transform allows us to reduce the Cauchy problem (CP ) to the characteristic equation (1) explains its usefulness. The Laplace transform is the link between solutions and resolvents, between Cauchy problems and spectral properties of operators. There are two important themes in the theory of Laplace transforms. The first concerns representation theorems; i.e., results which give criteria to decide whether a given function is a Laplace transform. Clearly, in view of (2), such results, applied to the resolvent of an operator, give information on the solvability of the Cauchy problem. The other important subject is asymptotic behaviour, where the most challenging and delicate results are Tauberian theorems which allow one to deduce asymptotic properties of a function from properties of its transform. Since in the case of solutions of (CP ) the transform is given by the resolvent, such results may allow one to deduce results of asymptotic behaviour from spectral properties of A. These two themes describe the essence of this book, which is divided into three parts. In the first, representation theorems for Laplace transforms are given, and corresponding to this, well-posedness of the Cauchy problem is studied. The second is a systematic study of asymptotic behaviour of Laplace transforms first of arbitrary functions, and then of solutions of (CP ). The last part contains applications and illustrative examples. Each part is preceded by a detailed introduction where we describe the interplay between the diverse subjects and explain how the sections are related. We have assumed that the reader is already familiar with the basic topics of functional analysis and the theory of bounded linear operators, Lebesgue integration and functions of a complex variable. We require some standard facts from Fourier analysis and slightly more advanced areas of functional analysis for which we give references in the text. There are also four appendices (A, B, C and E) which collect together background material on other standard topics for use in various places in the book, while Appendix D gives a proof of a technical result in the geometry of Banach spaces which is needed in Section 4.6. Finally, a few words should be said about the realization of the book. The collaboration of the authors is based on two research activities: the common work of W. Arendt, M. Hieber and F. Neubrander on integrated semigroups and the work of W. Arendt and C. Batty on asymptotic behaviour of semigroups over many years. Laplace transform methods are common to both. The actual contributions are as follows. Part I: All four authors wrote this part. Part II was written by W. Arendt and C. Batty. Part III was written by W. Arendt (Chapters 6 and 7) and M. Hieber (Chapter 8).
PREFACES
xi
C. Batty undertook the coordination needed to make the material into a consistent book. The authors are grateful to many colleagues and friends with whom they had a fruitful cooperation, frequently over many years, which allowed them to discuss the material presented in the book. We would especially like to acknowledge among them H. Amann, B. B¨aumer, Ph. B´enilan, J. van Casteren, R. Chill, O. ElMennaoui, J. Goldstein, H. Kellermann, V. Keyantuo, R. deLaubenfels, G. Lumer, R. Nagel, J. van Neerven, J. Pr¨ uss, F. R¨abiger, A. Rhandi, W. Ruess, Q.P. V˜ u, and L. Weis Special thanks go to S. Bu, R. Chill, M. Haase, R. Nagel and R. Schnaubelt, who read parts of the manuscript and gave very useful comments. The enormous technical work on the computer, in particular typing large parts of the manuscript and unifying 4 different TEX dialects, was done with high competence in a most reliable and efficient way by Mahamadi Warma. To him go our warmest thanks. The authors are grateful to Professor H. Amann, editor of “Monographs in Mathematics”, for his support. The cooperation with Birkh¨ auser Verlag, and with Dr. T. Hintermann in particular, was most enjoyable and efficient. Ulm, Oxford, Darmstadt, Baton Rouge August, 2000
Wolfgang Arendt Charles Batty Matthias Hieber Frank Neubrander
xii
PREFACES
Preface to the Second Edition Ten years after the publication of the first edition of this monograph, it is clear that vector-valued Laplace transform methods continue to play an important role in the analysis of partial differential equations and other disciplines of analysis. Among the most notable new achievements of this period are the characterization of generators of cosine functions on Hilbert space due to Crouzeix, and quantitative Tauberian theorems for Laplace transforms with applications to energy estimates for wave equations. In this second edition, the new developments have been taken into account by updating the Notes on each Chapter and the Bibliography. For example, the characterization of generators of cosine functions on Hilbert space by a purely geometric condition on the numerical range is precisely stated in Theorem 3.17.5. The main text has not been substantially changed, except in Section 4.4 where some results are now presented in quantitative forms. Their applications in the study of damped wave equations are explained in detail in the Notes of the section. A few minor mathematical gaps and typographical errors have been corrected, and we are grateful to M. Haase, J. van Neerven, R. Schumann and D. Seifert for alerting us to some of them. September 2010
The Authors
Part I
Laplace Transforms and Well-Posedness of Cauchy Problems
Part I
3
As a guide-line for Part I, as well as for the entire book, we have in mind the formula u ˆ(λ) = R(λ, A)x (3) saying that a mild solution of the Cauchy problem, u (t) = Au(t) with initial value x, is given by the resolvent of the underlying operator A evaluated at x. Thus, if we want to find solutions, we first have to characterize those functions which are Laplace transforms; i.e., we study representation theorems. Correspondingly, on the side of evolution equations, we investigate existence and uniqueness of solutions of the Cauchy problem. Other subjects treated here include regularity and positivity. Part I contains three chapters as follows: 1. The Laplace Integral 2. The Laplace Transform 3. Cauchy Problems We start with an introduction to the vector-valued Lebesgue integral; i.e., the Bochner integral. For our purposes it suffices to consider functions defined on the real line. Then we introduce the Laplace integral and investigate its analytic properties, giving special attention to its diverse abscissas. This will play an important role when solutions of the Cauchy problem are considered, as the abscissas give information about the asymptotic behaviour for large time. Operational properties of the Laplace integral are also discussed. Finally, we introduce functions of (semi) bounded variation defined on the half-line and the Laplace-Stieltjes transform. They will be needed when we study resolvent positive operators (Section 3.11) and Hille-Yosida operators (Section 3.5). The vector-valued Fourier transform on the line is introduced in Section 1.6 and we prove the Paley-Wiener theorem for functions with values in a Hilbert space. This is the first of several representation theorems for Laplace transforms which we present in this book. In Chapter 2, real representation theorems are the central subject. We prove a vector-valued version of Widder’s classical theorem which describes those functions which are Laplace transforms of bounded measurable functions. The vector-valued version (Section 2.2) will lead directly to generation theorems in Chapter 3 for semigroups and integrated semigroups (Section 3.3) and for cosine functions (Section 3.15). A particularly simple representation theorem is valid for holomorphic functions (Section 2.6). The Laplace transform is an isomorphism between certain classes of holomorphic functions defined on sectors in the complex plane. This will lead directly to the generation theorem for holomorphic semigroups in Section 3.7. The third representation theorem is a vector-valued version of Bernstein’s theorem describing Laplace-Stieljes transforms of monotonic functions (Section 2.7). It
4
Part I
has its counterpart for Cauchy problems in Section 3.11 where resolvent positive operators are considered. The uniqueness theorem for Laplace transforms is easy to prove (Section 1.7), but it has striking consequences. It gives directly an approximation result for sequences of Laplace transforms. In Chapter 3 we find its counterpart for Cauchy problems in the form of the Trotter-Kato theorem (Section 3.6). For Cauchy problems, the most satisfying situation is when there corresponds exactly one (mild) solution to each initial value. This notion of well-posedness is equivalent to existence of a C0 -semigroup (Section 3.1). We also consider weaker forms of well-posedness which are characterized by the existence of integrated semigroups. In applications, they allow one to describe precise regularity for certain partial differential equations in Lp (Rn ), and Chapter 8 is devoted to this. Here in Part I, there are three situations where integrated semigroups occur in a natural way. Operators satisfying the Hille-Yosida condition generate locally Lipschitz continuous integrated semigroups. Using convolution properties established in Section 1.3, we prove a beautiful existence and uniqueness theorem due to Da Prato and Sinestrari for the inhomogeneous Cauchy problem defined by such operators. The second interesting class of examples are resolvent positive operators which always generate twice integrated semigroups. This will be proved in Section 3.11. In Chapter 6 a resolvent positive operator will provide an elegant transition from elliptic to parabolic problems. Finally, in Section 3.14 we show that the second order Cauchy problem is well-posed on a space X if and only if the associated canonical system generates an integrated semigroup on the product space X × X. In Section 3.10 we show that integrated semigroups and semigroups are equivalent, up to the choice of the underlying Banach space. This choice is particularly interesting in the context of the second order Cauchy problem. In Section 3.14 we will show the remarkable result that the space of well-posedness is unique, and we find the phase space associated to the second order problem. In the applications to the wave equation given in Chapter 7 we will see how this space is well adapted to perturbation theory, allowing us to prove well-posedness of the wave equation defined by very general second order elliptic operators. Special attention is given to C0 -groups; i.e., to Cauchy problems allowing unique mild solutions on the line. In Section 3.9 we study when a holomorphic semigroup of angle π/2 has a boundary group. This problem will occur again in Section 3.16 where we investigate which cosine functions allow a square root reduction. A striking theorem due to Fattorini shows that on UMD-spaces a square root reduction is always possible; i.e., each generator A of a cosine function is of the form A = B 2 − ω where B generates a C0 -group and ω ≥ 0. This beautiful result concludes the three sections on the second order Cauchy problem, applications of which will be given in Chapters 7 and 8.
Chapter 1
The Laplace Integral The first three sections of this chapter are of a preliminary nature. There, we collect properties of the Bochner integral of functions of a real variable with values in a Banach space X. We then concentrate on the basic properties of the Laplace integral ∞
fˆ(λ) :=
τ
e−λt f (t) dt := lim
τ →∞
0
e−λt f (t) dt
0
for locally Bochner integrable functions f : R+ → X. In Section 1.4 we describe the set of complex numbers λ for which the Laplace integral converges. It will be shown that the domain of convergence is non-empty if and only if the antiderivative of f is of exponential growth. In Section 1.5 we discuss the holomorphy of λ → fˆ(λ) and in Section 1.7 we show that f is uniquely determined by the Laplace integrals fˆ(λ) (uniqueness and inversion). In Section 1.6 we prove the operational properties of the Laplace integral which are essential in applications to differential and integral equations. In particular, we show that the Laplace integral of the convolution t k ∗ f : t → 0 k(t − s)f (s) ds of a scalar-valued function k with a vector-valued function f is given by ˆ fˆ(λ) (k ∗ f )(λ) = k(λ) ˆ if fˆ(λ) exists and k(λ) exists as an absolutely convergent integral. In Section 1.8 we consider vector-valued Fourier transforms and we show that Plancherel’s theorem and the Paley-Wiener theorem extend to functions with values in a Hilbert space. Finally, after introducing the basic properties of the Riemann-Stieltjes integral in Section 1.9, we extend in Section 1.10 the basic properties of Laplace integrals to Laplace-Stieltjes integrals ∞ τ (λ) := dF e−λt dF (t) := lim e−λt dF (t) 0
τ →∞
0
of functions F of bounded semivariation.
W. Arendt et al., Vector-valued Laplace Transforms and Cauchy Problems: Second Edition, Monographs in Mathematics 96, DOI 10.1007/978-3-0348-0087-7_1, © Springer Basel AG 2011
5
6
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
If f is Bochner integrable, then the normalized antiderivative t → F (t) := (λ) f (s) ds is of bounded variation. We will see that fˆ(λ) exists if and only if dF 0 (λ). Thus, the Laplace-Stieltjes integral is a natexists, and in this case fˆ(λ) = dF ural extension of the Laplace integral. This extension is crucial for our discussion of the Laplace transform in Chapter 2 since there are many functions r : (ω, ∞) → X which can be represented as a Laplace-Stieltjes integral, but not as a Laplace integral of a Bochner integrable function. Examples are, among others, Dirichlet series ∞ (λ), where F is the step function ∞ an χ(n,∞) , or r(λ) = n=1 an e−λn = dF n=1 (λ), where F is of bounded semivariation, but not the any function r(λ) = dF antiderivative of a Bochner integrable function. t
1.1
The Bochner Integral
This section contains some properties of the Bochner integral of vector-valued functions. We shall consider only those properties which are used in later sections, and we shall assume that the reader is familiar with the basic facts about measure and integration of scalar-valued functions. Let X be a complex Banach space, and let I be an interval (bounded or unbounded) in R, or a rectangle in R2 . A function f : I → X is simple if it is n of the form f (t) = r=1 xr χΩr (t) for some n ∈ N := {1, 2, . . .}, xr ∈ X and Lebesgue measurable sets Ωr ⊂ I with finite Lebesgue measure m(Ωr ); f is a step function when each Ωr can be chosen to be an interval, or a rectangle in R2 . Here χΩ denotes the characteristic (indicator) function of Ω. In the representation of a simple function, the sets Ωr may always be arranged to be disjoint, and then xr (t ∈ Ωr ; r = 1, 2, . . . , n) f (t) = 0 otherwise. A function f : I → X is measurable if there is a sequence of simple functions gn such that f (t) = limn→∞ gn (t) for almost all t ∈ I. Since any χΩ for Ω measurable is a pointwise almost everywhere (a.e.) limit of a sequence of step functions, it is not difficult to see that the functions gn can be chosen to be step functions. When X = C, this definition agrees with the usual definition of (Lebesgue) measurable functions. It is easy to see that if f : I → X, g : I → X and h : I → C are measurable, then f + g and h · f are measurable. Moreover, if k : X → Y is continuous (where Y is any Banach space), then k ◦ f is measurable whenever f is measurable. In particular, f is measurable. If X is a closed subspace of Y , and f is measurable as a Y -valued function, then f is also measurable as an X-valued function. To verify measurability of a function we often use the characterization given by Pettis’s theorem below. We say that f : I → X is countably valued if there is a countable partition {Ωn : n ∈ N} of I into subsets Ωn such that f is constant on each Ωn ; it is easy to see that f is measurable if each Ωn is measurable (and
1.1. THE BOCHNER INTEGRAL
7
conversely, {t ∈ I : f (t) = x} is measurable whenever f is measurable and x ∈ X). Also, f : I → X is called almost separably valued if there is a null set Ω0 in I such that f (I \ Ω0 ) := {f (t) : t ∈ I \ Ω0 } is separable (equivalently, f (I \ Ω0 ) is contained in a separable closed subspace of X); f is weakly measurable if x∗ ◦ f : t → f (t), x∗ is Lebesgue measurable for each x∗ in the dual space X ∗ of X. Here and subsequently, ·, · denotes the duality between X and X ∗ . For a subset D of X, we shall denote the closure of D in X by D. For x ∈ X and ε > 0, we shall let BX (x, ε) := B(x, ε) := {y ∈ X : y − x < ε} and B(x, ε) := {y ∈ X :
y − x ≤ ε}. We shall also use this notation when X = Rn or X = C, when it will be implicit that the norm is the Euclidean norm. Theorem 1.1.1 (Pettis). A function f : I → X is measurable if and only if it is weakly measurable and almost separably valued. Proof. If f is measurable, then there exist a null set Ω0 and simple functions gn such that gn → f pointwise on I \ Ω0 . The simple functions x∗ ◦ gn converge to x∗ ◦ f on I \ Ω0 for all x∗ ∈ X ∗ . Therefore, f is weakly measurable. The values taken by the functions gn form a countable set D and f (I \ Ω0 ) ⊂ D. Thus, f is almost separably valued. To prove the converse statement one may replace X by the smallest closed subspace which contains f (I \ Ω0 ) and then choose a countable dense set {xn : n ∈ N}. By the Hahn-Banach theorem, there are unit vectors x∗n ∈ X ∗ with |xn , x∗n | = xn . For any ε > 0 and x ∈ X there exists xk such that x − xk < ε. Hence, sup |x, x∗n | n
≤
x ≤ xk + ε = |xk , x∗k | + ε
≤ |x − xk , x∗k | + |x, x∗k | + ε ≤ sup |x, x∗n | + 2ε. n
So
x = sup |x, x∗n | n
for all x ∈ X.
(1.1)
This implies that t → f (t)−x = supn |f (t)−x, x∗n | is measurable for all x ∈ X. Let Δ := {t ∈ I \ Ω0 : f (t) > 0} and Δn,ε := {t ∈ Δ : f (t) − xn < ε} for ε > 0 and n ∈ N. The sets Δn,ε are measurable and n Δn,ε = Δ. For fixed ε > 0, the sets Ω1,ε := Δ1,ε and Ωn,ε := Δn,ε \ k
f (t) − gε (t) < ε
for all t ∈ I \ Ω0 .
8
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
This shows that f is the uniform limit almost everywhere of a sequence of measurable, countably valued functions. Let (In ) be an increasing sequence of bounded subintervals of I with I = I . For each n ∈ N, define a simple function hn := g2−n χHn , where Hn := In ∩ nkn n −n −n and kn is chosen such that the Lebesgue measure m(In \ Hn ) < 2 . i=1 Ω i,2 ∞ If t ∈ n=k Hn for some k ≥ 1, then
f (t) − hn (t) = f (t) − g2−n (t) < 2−n ∞ ∞ for all n ≥ k. Thus, limn→∞ hn (t) = f (t) for all t ∈ k=1 n=k Hn . For k ≥ j, ∞ ∞
m Ij \ Hn ≤ m(In \ Hn ) < 2−k+1 . n=k
n=k
∞ ∞
Hence, Ij \ k=1 n=k Hn is null, for each j. This shows that limn→∞ hn (t) = f (t) for almost all t ∈ I. Corollary 1.1.2. Let f : I → X. Then the following statements hold: a) The function f is measurable if and only if it is the uniform limit almost everywhere of a sequence of measurable, countably valued functions. b) If X is separable, then f is measurable if and only if it is weakly measurable. c) If f is continuous, then it is measurable. d) If fn : I → X are measurable functions and fn → f pointwise a.e., then f is measurable. Proof. The statement b) is an immediate consequence of Pettis’s Theorem 1.1.1. For d), observe first that f is weakly measurable. Define Ω0 := ∪n Ωn where Ωn is a null set such that fn (I \ Ωn ) is separable. Then m(Ω0 ) = 0 and Δ := n fn (I \ Ω0 ) is separable. Since the least closed subspace containing Δ is separable and contains f (I \ Ω0 ) it follows that f is almost separably valued. Thus, f is measurable. If f is continuous, then f is weakly measurable and the countable set {f (t) : t ∈ Q} is dense in the range of f . Again by Pettis’s theorem, f is measurable. One implication of a) was established in the proof of Pettis’s theorem and the converse follows from d). Pettis’s theorem can be improved considerably in the following way. A subset W of X ∗ is called separating if for all x ∈ X \ {0} there exists x∗ ∈ W such that x, x∗ = 0. Corollary 1.1.3. Let f : I → X be an almost separably valued function. Assume that x∗ ◦ f is measurable for all x∗ in a separating subset W of X ∗ . Then f is measurable.
1.1. THE BOCHNER INTEGRAL
9
Proof. Changing f on a set of measure 0 and replacing X by a subspace, we can assume that X is separable. Let Y := {x∗ ∈ X ∗ : x∗ ◦ f is measurable}. Then Y is a subspace of X ∗ which contains W . By the Hahn-Banach theorem, Y is weak* dense in X ∗ . Let Y1 = Y ∩ B X ∗ (0, 1). We show that Y1 is weak* closed. Let x∗ be in the weak* closure of Y1 . Since X is separable, the weak* topology on B X ∗ (0, 1) is metrizable (see [Meg98, Theorem 2.6.23], for example). Thus, there exists a sequence (x∗n )n∈N in Y1 converging to x∗ . Hence, x∗n ◦ f → x∗ ◦ f as n → ∞ pointwise on I. Thus, x∗ ◦ f is measurable; i.e., x∗ ∈ Y1 . This proves the claim. It follows from the Krein-Smulyan theorem (Theorem A.6) that Y is weak* closed. Since Y is weak* dense, we have Y = X ∗ ; i.e., f is weakly measurable. Now the result follows from Theorem 1.1.1. n For a simple function g : I → X, g = i=1 xi χΩi , we define n g(t) dt := xi m(Ωi ) I
i=1
where m(Ω) is the Lebesgue measure of Ω. It is routine to verify that the definition n is independent of the representation g = i=1 xi χΩi , and the integral so defined is linear. A function f : I → X is called Bochner integrable if there exist simple functions gn such that gn → f pointwise a.e., and limn→∞ I f (t) − gn (t) dt = 0. If f : I → X is Bochner integrable, then the Bochner integral of f on I is f (t) dt := lim gn (t) dt. n→∞
I
I
It is easy to see that this limit exists and is independent of the choice of the sequence (gn ). If Ω is measurable with finite measure, then χΩ can be approximated in L1 -norm by step functions, and it follows that the functions gn can always be chosen to be step functions. The integral I f (t) dt lies in the closed linear span of {f (t) : t ∈ I}. The set of all Bochner integrable functions from I to X is a linear space and the Bochner integral is a linear mapping. When X = C, the definitions of Bochner integrability and integrals agree with those of Lebesgue integration theory. When I is a rectangle, we may denote a Bochner integral by I f (s, t) d(s, t). It is one of the great virtues of the Bochner integral that the class of Bochner integrable functions is easily characterized. Theorem 1.1.4 (Bochner). A function f : I → X is Bochner integrable if and only if f is measurable and f is integrable. If f is Bochner integrable, then
f (t) dt ≤ f (t) dt. (1.2)
I
I
10
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
Proof. If f is Bochner integrable, then there exists an approximating sequence of simple functions gn . Thus f and f are measurable. The integrability of f
follows from
f (t) dt ≤ gn (t) dt + f (t) − gn (t) dt. I
Moreover,
I
I
f (t) dt = lim gn (t) dt
n→∞
I
≤
I
=
lim
gn (t) dt n→∞ I
f (t) dt. I
To prove the converse statement, let (hn ) be a sequence of simple functions approximating f pointwise on I \ Ω0 , where m(Ω0 ) = 0. Define simple functions by hn (t) if hn (t) ≤ f (t) (1 + n−1 ), gn (t) := 0 otherwise. Then gn (t) ≤ f (t) (1 + n−1 ) and limn→∞ gn (t) − f (t) = 0 for all t ∈ I \ Ω0 . Because the functions f and gn − f are integrable and gn (t) − f (t) ≤ 3 f (t) , we can apply the scalar dominated convergence theorem and obtain that limn→∞ I gn (t) − f (t) dt = 0. Example 1.1.5. a) Let X be the Lebesgue space L∞ (0, 1) of all (equivalence classes of) bounded measurable functions from (0, 1) to C. Let f : (0, 1) → L∞ (0, 1) be given by f (t) := χ(0,t) . Then f is not almost separably valued since f (t)−f (s) = 1 for t = s. Thus, f is not measurable and therefore not Bochner integrable. b) Let X be the Banach space c0 of all complex sequences x = (xn )n∈N such that ∗ 1 limn→∞ xn = 0, with x = supn |xn |. Identify ∞ X with the space of all complex sequences a = (an )n∈N such that a := n=1 |an | < ∞. Let f : [0, 1] → c0 be given by f (t) := (fn (t))n∈N where fn (t) := nχ[0, n1 ] (t). Let x∗ = (an )n∈N ∈ 1 . Then ∞ t → f (t), x∗ = n=1 nan χ[0, n1 ] (t) is measurable on [0, 1]. Since c0 is separable, it follows from Pettis’s theorem that f is measurable. Moreover, 1 ∞ |f (t), x∗ | dt ≤ |an | = x∗ < ∞. 0
n=1
1 However, f (t) = n for t ∈ ( n+1 , n1 ], so t → f (t) is not integrable on [0, 1]. Thus, f is not Bochner integrable on [0, 1].
Now we will consider the behaviour of the Bochner integral under linear operators. The following result is a straightforward consequence of the definition of the Bochner integral, and we shall use it frequently without comment, especially in the case of a linear functional (Y = C).
1.1. THE BOCHNER INTEGRAL
11
Proposition 1.1.6. Let T : X → Y be a bounded linear operator between Banach spaces X and Y , and let f : I→ X be Bochner integrable. Then T ◦f : t → T (f (t)) is Bochner integrable and T I f (t) dt = I T (f (t)) dt. We shall also need a version of Proposition 1.1.6 for a closed operator A on X (see Appendix B for notation and terminology). Proposition 1.1.7. Let A be a closed linear operator on X. Let f : I → X be Bochner integrable. Suppose that f (t) ∈ D(A) for all t ∈ I and A ◦ f : I → X is Bochner integrable. Then I f (t) dt ∈ D(A) and A
f (t) dt =
I
A(f (t)) dt. I
Proof. Consider X × X as a Banach space in the norm (x, y) = x + y . The graph G(A) of A is a closed subspace of X × X. Define g : I → G(A) ⊂ X × X by g(t) = (f (t), A(f (t))). It is easy to see that g is measurable and
g(t) dt = f (t) dt + A(f (t)) dt < ∞. I
I
I
By Theorem 1.1.4, g is Bochner integrable. Moreover, I g(t) dt ∈ G(A). Applying Proposition 1.1.6 to the two projection maps of X × X onto X shows that g(t) dt = f (t) dt , A(f (t)) dt . I
I
I
This gives the result. Now we give vector-valued versions of two classical theorems of integration theory. Theorem 1.1.8 (Dominated Convergence). Let fn : I → X (n ∈ N) be Bochner integrable functions. Assume that f (t) := limn→∞ fn (t) exists a.e. and there exists an integrable function g : I → R such that fn (t) ≤ g(t) a.e. for all n ∈ N. Then f is Bochner integrable and f (t) dt = limn→∞ I fn (t) dt. Furthermore, I
f (t) − f (t)
dt → 0 as n → ∞. n I Proof. The function f is Bochner integrable since it is measurable (by Corollary 1.1.2) and since f is integrable (because f (t) ≤ g(t) a.e.). Define hn (t) :=
f (t) − fn (t) for t ∈ I. Since |hn (t)| ≤ 2g(t) and hn (t) → 0 a.e., the scalar dominated convergence theorem implies that I f (t) − fn (t) dt → 0 as n → ∞. By (1.2),
f (t) dt − fn (t) dt → 0.
I
I
12
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
Theorem 1.1.9 (Fubini’s Theorem). Let I = I1 × I2 be a rectangle in R2 , let f : I → X be measurable, and suppose that
f (s, t) dt ds < ∞. I1
I2
Then f is Bochner integrable and the repeated integrals f (s, t) dt ds, f (s, t) ds dt I1
I2
I2
I1
exist and are equal, and they coincide with the double integral
I
f (s, t) d(s, t).
Proof. Since any measurable function is almost separably valued, we may assume that X is separable. The scalar-valued case of Fubini’s theorem implies that f is integrable on I, I2 f (s, t) dt exists for almost all s ∈ I1 , and for each x∗ ∈ X ∗ the repeated integrals f (s, t), x∗ dt ds, f (s, t), x∗ ds dt I1
I2
I2
I1
exist and are equal. It follows from Theorem 1.1.4 that f : I → X is Bochner integrable and I2 f (s, t) dt exists for almost all s ∈ I1 , and from Theorem 1.1.1 that s → I2 f (s, t) dt is measurable. Moreover,
f (s, t) dt ds ≤
f (s, t) dt ds < ∞,
I1
I2
so Theorem 1.1.4 shows that
I1
I1
I2
I2
f (s, t) dt ds exists. Since
f (s, t) ds dt =
I2
I1
it follows similarly that
f (s, t) dt I1
I2
I2
f (s, t) ds dt exists. For any x∗ ∈ X ∗ , I1
I2
f (s, t) dt ds, I1
ds, x∗
=
f (s, t), x∗ dt ds
I1 I2 = f (s, t), x∗ d(s, t) I = f (s, t) d(s, t), x∗ I = f (s, t), x∗ ds dt I2 I1 ∗ = f (s, t) ds dt, x . I2
I1
1.1. THE BOCHNER INTEGRAL
13
The Hahn-Banach theorem implies that f (s, t) dt ds = f (s, t) d(s, t) = f (s, t) ds dt. I1
I2
I
I2
I1
Let L1 (I, X) denote the space of all Bochner integrable functions f : I → X, and let
f 1 := f (t) dt. I
In the usual way, we shall identify functions which differ only on sets of measure zero. Then · 1 is a norm on L1 (I, X). Theorem 1.1.10. The space L1 (I, X) is a Banach space. Proof. Let (fn ) be a sequence in L1 (I, X) with
fn 1 < ∞. Bythe monotone convergence theorem for series of positive scalar-valued functions,
fn (t) < ∞ ∞ a.e., n=1 fn (·) is integrable, and ∞
fn (t) dt =
I n=1
∞ n=1
fn (t) dt.
I
∞ Hence, n=1 fn (t) converges a.e. to a sum g(t) in the Banach space X. By Corol∞ lary 1.1.2, g is measurable. Moreover, g(t) ≤ n=1 fn (t) , so g is integrable. By Theorem 1.1.4, g is integrable. Finally,
k k ∞
fn ≤ g(t) − fn (t) dt ≤
fn (t) dt → 0
g −
I I n=1
1
n=1
n=k+1
as k → ∞. Thus, L1 (I, X) is a Banach space. By the definition of Bochner integrability, the simple functions are dense in L1 (I, X) and, by the remarks following the definition, the step functions are dense. It follows easily that the infinitely differentiable functions of compact support are also dense in L1 (I, X). We shall be particularly interested in the case when I = R+ := [0, ∞). If f ∈ L1 (R+ , X), an application of the Dominated Convergence Theorem shows that ∞ τ f (t) dt = lim f (t) dt. (1.3) 0
τ →∞
0
L1loc (R+ , X)
When f ∈ (i.e., f is Bochner integrable on [0, τ ] for every τ ∈ R+ ), the limit in (1.3) may exist ∞ without f being Bochner integrable on R+ . If the limit exists, we say that 0 f (t) dt converges as an improper (or principal value) integral, and we define ∞ τ f (t) dt := lim f (t) dt. 0
τ →∞
0
14
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
∞ When f ∈ L1 (R+ , X), i.e. 0 f (t) dt < ∞, we say that the integral is absolutely convergent . For 1 < p < ∞, let Lp (I, X) denote the space of all measurable functions f : I → X such that
1/p
f p :=
f (t) p dt
< ∞.
I
Let L∞ (I, X) be the space of all measurable functions f : I → X such that
f ∞ := ess sup f (t) < ∞. t∈I
Note that the spaces Lp (I, C) (1 ≤ p ≤ ∞) are the usual Lebesgue spaces which we shall denote simply by Lp (I). With the usual identifications, each of the spaces Lp (I, X) becomes a Banach space. The proofs of completeness are similar to the scalar-valued cases. The proof of Theorem 1.1.4 shows that the simple functions are dense in Lp (I, X) for 1 < p < ∞ (so Lp (I, X) can also be defined in a similar way to the Bochner integrable functions). It follows that the step functions, and the infinitely differentiable functions of compact support, are also dense. By considering such functions first and then approximating, one may show as in the scalar-valued case, that if f ∈ Lp (I, X) and f (s − t) if s − t ∈ I, ft (s) := 0 otherwise, then t → ft is continuous from R into Lp (I, X) for 1 ≤ p < ∞. We have presented the theory above in the case when I is an interval in R (or, for Fubini’s theorem, I is a rectangle in R2 ). Almost all the integrals which appear in this book will indeed be over intervals in R (or repeated integrals in R2 ). However, the entire theory works, with no changes in the proofs, when I is a measurable set in Rn (or in Rm ×Rn , in Fubini’s theorem). Since the step functions are dense in each of the spaces Lp (I × J, X) for 1 ≤ p < ∞, it is easy to see from Fubini’s theorem that there is an isometric isomorphism between Lp (I × J, X) and Lp (I, Lp (J, X)) given by f → g, where (g(s))(t) := f (s, t). This enables many properties of the spaces Lp (I, X) when I is a rectangle in Rn to be deduced from the case n = 1. Finally in this section, we introduce notation for spaces of continuous and differentiable functions. Let I be an interval in R. We denote by C(I, X) the vector space of all continuous functions f : I → X. For k ∈ N, we denote by C k (I, X) the space of all k-times differentiable functions with continuous kth derivative, and we
1.2. THE RADON-NIKODYM PROPERTY
15
∞ put C ∞ (I, X) := k=1 C k (I, X). When I is compact, C(I, K) is a closed subspace of L∞ (I, X) and therefore a Banach space with respect to the supremum norm
· ∞ . When I is not compact, we let Cc (I, X) be the space of all functions in C(I, X) with compact support, and Cc∞ (I, X) := Cc (I, X) ∩ C ∞ (I, X). Thus Cc∞ (I, X) is a dense subspace of Lp (I, X) for 1 ≤ p < ∞. When I = R+ or I = R, we shall also consider the space C0 (I, X) of all continuous functions f : I → X such that lim|t|→∞,t∈I f (t) = 0 and the space BUC(I, X) of all bounded, uniformly continuous functions f : I → X. These are both Banach spaces with respect to
· ∞ , and C0 (I, X) ⊂ BUC(I, X) ⊂ L∞ (I, X). When X = C, we shall write C(I) in place of C(I, C), etc., and we shall extend this notation to cases when I is replaced by an open subset Ω of Rn . Note that Cc∞ (Ω) coincides with the space D(Ω) of test functions on Ω (see Appendix E), and we shall use both notations according to context. Furthermore, when Ω is any locally compact space, we shall let C0 (Ω) be the Banach space of all continuous complex-valued functions on Ω which vanish at infinity, with the supremum norm. When K is any compact space, we shall let C(K) be the Banach space of all continuous complex-valued functions on K, with the supremum norm.
1.2
The Radon-Nikodym Property
In this section we consider properties of functions F obtained as indefinite integrals. If f : [a, b] → X is Bochner integrable, we say that F : [a, b] → X is an antiderivative or primitive of f if
t
F (t) = F (a) +
f (s) ds
(t ∈ [a, b]).
a
Given a function F : [a, b] → X and a partition π, a = t0 < t1 < . . . < tn = b, let V (π, F ) :=
n
F (ti ) − F (ti−1 ) .
i=1
Then F is said to be of bounded variation if V (F ) := V[a,b] (F ) := sup V (π, F ) < ∞, π
where the supremum is taken over all partitions π of [a, b]. We say that F isabsolutely continuous on [a, b] if for every ε > 0 there exists δ > 0 such that i F (bi ) − F (ai ) < ε for every finite collection {(ai , bi )} of disjoint intervals in [a, b] with i (bi − ai ) < δ. We say that F is Lipschitz continuous if there exists M such that F (t) − F (s) ≤ M |t − s| for all s, t ∈ [a, b]. Clearly, any Lipschitz continuous function is absolutely continuous.
16
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
Proposition 1.2.1. Let F : [a, b] → X be absolutely continuous. Then F is of bounded variation. Moreover, if G(t) := V[a,t] (F ), then G is absolutely continuous on [a, b]. Proof. Take ε > 0, and let δ be as in the definition of absolute continuity of F . Then V (F ) ≤ ε whenever {(ai , bi )} is a finite collection of disjoint subintervals [a i ,bi ] i of [a, b] with i (bi − ai ) < δ. In particular, F is of bounded variation on any subinterval of length less than δ. Since [a, b] is a finite union of such intervals, F is of bounded variation on [a, b]. Moreover,
|G(bi ) − G(ai )| =
i
V[ai ,bi ] (F ) < ε.
i
Thus, G is absolutely continuous. A point t ∈ [a, b] is said to be a Lebesgue point of f ∈ L1 ([a, b], X) if t+h limh→0 h1 t f (s) − f (t) ds = 0. It is easy to see that any point of continuity is a Lebesgue point, and the following proposition shows that almost all points are Lebesgue points. t Proposition 1.2.2. Let f : [a, b] → X be Bochner integrable and F (t) := a f (s) ds (t ∈ [a, b]). Then a) F is differentiable a.e. and F = f a.e. b) limh→0
1 h
t+h t
f (s) − f (t) ds = 0 t-a.e.
c) F is absolutely continuous. d) V[a,b] (F ) =
b a
f (s) ds.
Proof. To show a) and b) let gn be step functions such that f (t) = lim gn (t) a.e. and
lim
n→∞
For h > 0,
1 t+h
f (s) ds − f (t)
h t
≤ ≤
1 h 1 h +
n→∞
t+h
b
f (t) − gn (t) dt = 0.
a
f (s) − f (t) ds
t
t+h
f (s) − gn (s) ds
t
1 h
t+h t
gn (s) − gn (t) ds + gn (t) − f (t) .
1.2. THE RADON-NIKODYM PROPERTY
17
Since gn is a step function and s → fn (s) − gn (s) is Lebesgue integrable, it follows from Lebesgue’s theorem [Rud87, Theorem 8.17] that
1 t+h
1 t+h
lim sup f (s) ds − f (t) ≤ lim sup
f (s) − f (t) ds
h t
h t h↓0 h↓0 ≤ 2 gn (t) − f (t)
for all t ∈ [a, b] \ Ωn and some null set Ωn . Taking the limit as n → ∞ yields the right-differentiability of F and 1 lim h↓0 h
t+h
f (s) − f (t) ds = 0
t
for all t ∈ [a, b] \ n∈N Ωn . The left-hand limits are similar. For c), let ε > 0. There exists δ > 0 such that Ω f (s) ds < ε whenever collection of disjoint subintervals of [a, b] with μ(Ω) < δ. If {(ai , bi )} is a finite i (bi − ai ) < δ, then taking Ω = i (ai , bi ), we deduce that
b
i
F (bi ) − F (ai ) = f (s) ds ≤
f (s) ds < ε.
ai
Ω i
i
To prove the statement d), observe first that, for any partition π of [a, b],
t b
i
V (π, F ) = f (s) ds ≤
f (s) ds.
ti−1
a i
b
Thus, V (F ) ≤ a f (s) ds. Conversely, given ε > 0, we may choose a step function b g such that a f (s) − g(s) ds < ε. There is a partition π of [a, b] such that g is constant on each interval (ti−1 , ti ). Then a
b
f (s) ds − V (F )
≤
b
f (s) ds − V (π, F )
b
t
i
≤
g(s) ds + ε − f (s) ds
ti−1
a i
ti
t
i
= g(s) ds − f (s) ds + ε
ti−1
ti−1
i b ≤
f (s) − g(s) ds + ε a
a
≤ 2ε. Since ε > 0 is arbitrary, this completes the proof of d).
18
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
In the scalar case, the fundamental theorem of calculus [Rud87, Theorem 8.18] states that any absolutely continuous function F : [a, b] → C is differentiable t a.e., f := F is Lebesgue integrable, and F (t) − F (a) = a f (s) ds for all t ∈ [a, b]. We will see below (Example 1.2.8) that the fundamental theorem does not hold for Lipschitz continuous functions with values in arbitrary Banach spaces. The following weaker statement holds for all Banach spaces. Proposition 1.2.3. Let F : [a, b] → X be absolutely continuous, and suppose that t f (t) := F (t) exists a.e. Then f is Bochner integrable and F (t) = F (a)+ a f (s) ds for all t ∈ [a, b]. Proof. Since f (t) = limn→∞ n(F (t + 1/n) − F (t)), it follows from Corollary 1.1.2 that f is measurable. Let G(t) := V[a,t] (F ), so G : [a, b] → R is absolutely continuous by Proposition 1.2.1. Hence G is differentiable a.e. and G ∈ L1 [a, b]. Since
F (t + h) − F (t) ≤ V[t,t+h] (F ) = G(t + h) − G(t),
f (t) ≤ G (t) a.e. Hence f ∈ L1 [a, b], so f is Bochner integrable by Theorem 1.1.4. For x∗ ∈ X ∗ , F (t), x∗ = =
t F (a), x∗ + f (s), x∗ ds a t F (a) + f (s) ds, x∗ a
by the scalar fundamental theorem of calculus. By the Hahn-Banach theorem, t F (t) = F (a) + a f (s) ds. Let I be any interval in R. A function F : I → X is said to be absolutely continuous if it is absolutely continuous on each compact interval of I. We now consider the property that every absolutely continuous function F : I → X is differentiable a.e. It is easy to see that this property is independent of the interval I, so it is a property of X alone. Proposition 1.2.4. For any Banach space X the following are equivalent: (i) Every absolutely continuous function F : R+ → X is differentiable a.e. (ii) Every Lipschitz continuous function F : R+ → X is differentiable a.e. Proof. Clearly, (i) implies (ii). Assume that statement (ii) holds and let F : R+ → X be absolutely continuous. By Proposition 1.2.1, F is locally of bounded variation and G is absolutely continuous where G(t) := V[0,t] (F ). Let h(t) := G(t) + t. Then h is strictly increasing, h(0) = 0, and h(R+ ) = R+ . Moreover,
F (t) − F (s) ≤ G(t) − G(s) ≤ h(t) − h(s)
1.2. THE RADON-NIKODYM PROPERTY
19
for all t ≥ s ≥ 0. Hence, F ◦h−1 : R+ → X is Lipschitz continuous. By assumption, F ◦ h−1 is differentiable a.e. Since |h(t) − h(s)| ≥ |t − s|, h−1 maps null sets to null sets. Moreover, h is differentiable a.e., since G is absolutely continuous. It follows from the chain rule that F is differentiable a.e. Definition 1.2.5. A Banach space X is said to have the Radon-Nikodym property if the equivalent conditions of Proposition 1.2.4 are satisfied. By the remarks above, the space X has the Radon-Nikodym property if and only if every Lipschitz continuous function F : [0, 1] → X is differentiable almost everywhere. It is clear that a closed subspace of a space with the Radon-Nikodym property has the Radon-Nikodym property. Next we exhibit a class of spaces having the Radon-Nikodym property. Theorem 1.2.6 (Dunford-Pettis). Let X = Y ∗ where Y is a Banach space, and suppose that X is separable. Then X has the Radon-Nikodym property. Proof. By Proposition 1.2.4, it suffices to show that every Lipschitz function F : R+ → X is differentiable a.e. We may assume that F (0) = 0 and the Lipschitz constant is 1, so that F (t) − F (s) ≤ |t − s|. For y ∈ Y , the function y, F (·) : R+ → C is Lipschitz with Lipschitz constant y , so there exists gy ∈ L∞ (R+ ) such that gy ∞ ≤ y and t y, F (t) = gy (s) ds (t ∈ R+ ). 0
Moreover, gy is unique up to null sets. Since Y ∗ is separable, Y is also separable (see [Meg98, Theorem 1.12.11]). n Let D be a countable dense subset of Y . Suppose that y = i=1 αi yi for some n ∈ N, αi ∈ Q + iQ and yi ∈ D. Then t n n y, F (t) = αi yi , F (t) = αi gyi (s) ds, so gy (s) =
n i=1
0 i=1
i=1
αi gyi (s) a.e. Hence,
n n
αi gyi (s) ≤ α i yi
i=1
(1.4)
i=1
for almost all s ∈ R+ . This holds for all possible n ∈ N, αi ∈ Q + iQ and yi ∈ D, but there are only countably many such possibilities. Hence there is a null subset Ω of R+ such that (1.4) holds for all s ∈ R+ \ Ω and all n ∈ N, αi ∈ Q + iQ and yi ∈ D. It follows immediately that (1.4) holds for all αi ∈ C. This shows that for s ∈ R+ \ Ω, the map y → gy (s) from D to C extends to a unique f (s) ∈ Y ∗ = X with f (s) ≤ 1. For y ∈ D, y, f (·) is measurable and bounded, and t y, F (t) = y, f (s) ds. (1.5) 0
20
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
By density of D and the dominated convergence theorem, (1.5) is valid for y ∈ Y . Since Y is weak* dense in X ∗ = Y ∗∗ and f is separably valued, it follows from Corollary 1.1.3 that f : R+ → X is measurable. Since f is bounded, f is locally Bochner integrable and it follows from (1.5) that t F (t) = f (s) ds. 0
By Proposition 1.2.2 a), F is differentiable a.e. Corollary 1.2.7. Every reflexive space has the Radon-Nikodym property. Proof. Since a continuous function has separable range, it suffices to show that every separable reflexive space has the Radon-Nikodym property. This follows from Theorem 1.2.6. Next we give some examples of spaces which do not have the Radon-Nikodym property. Example 1.2.8. a) Let X = C[0, 1] and define F (t − s)χ[0,t] (s). For 0 ≤ t1 ≤ t2 ≤ 1, ⎧ ⎪ ⎨t2 − t1 F (t2 )(s) − F (t1 )(s) = t2 − s ⎪ ⎩ 0
: [0, 1] → C[0, 1] by F (t)(s) := (0 ≤ s ≤ t1 ), (t1 < s ≤ t2 ), (t2 < s ≤ 1).
Thus F (t2 ) − F (t1 ) ∞ = |t2 − t1 |, so F is Lipschitz continuous. However, limh→0 h1 (F (t + h) − F (t)) does not exist in the norm topology, so C[0, 1] does not have the Radon-Nikodym property. b) It follows from a) that L∞ (0, 1) does not have the Radon-Nikodym property either. However, when F is as in a) and L∞ (0, 1) is identified with L1 (0, 1)∗ , the weak* derivative Fw∗ (t) := w*- limh→0 h1 (F (t + h) − F (t)) = χ[0,t] exists in ∞ L (0, 1). Note that Fw∗ is not measurable and therefore not Bochner integrable (Example 1.1.5 a)). We shall see in Section 1.9 that Fw∗ is Riemann integrable t and F (t) = 0 Fw∗ (s) ds in the sense of Riemann integrals. More generally, it follows from the next result that every Banach space containing a closed subspace isomorphic to c0 (see Example 1.1.5 b) and Appendix D) does not have the Radon-Nikodym property. Proposition 1.2.9. The space c0 does not have the Radon-Nikodym property. Proof. Let F (t) := (Fn (t))n∈N , where Fn (t) := n1 sin(nt) (n ∈ N). Then F : R+ → c0 is Lipschitz continuous since t |Fn (t) − Fn (s)| = cos(nr) dr ≤ |t − s| (t, s ≥ 0, n ∈ N). s
1.3. CONVOLUTIONS
21
However, F is nowhere differentiable, since Fn (t) = cos(nt) and (cos(nt))n∈N ∈ c0 . Thus, c0 does not have the Radon-Nikodym property. It follows from Theorem 1.2.6 that the space l1 = c∗0 has the Radon-Nikodym property. However, L1 (0, 1) does not, even though c0 is not a closed subspace of L1 (0, 1) (see Appendix D). Proposition 1.2.10. The space L1 (0, 1) does not have the Radon-Nikodym property. Proof. In fact, define F : [0, 1] → L1 (0, 1) by F (t) = χ[0,t] . Then F is clearly Lipschitz continuous. Let 0 < t < 1. Then F is not differentiable at t. In fact,
1
(F (t + h) − F (t)) − 1 (F (t + 2h) − F (t)) = 1
h
2h 1 for 0 < h < (1 − t)/2.
1.3
Convolutions
For k, h ∈ L1 (R), standard arguments with Fubini’s theorem (see [Rud87, Theorem 7.14]) show that the convolution (k ∗ h)(t) := k(t − s)h(s) ds R
exists a.e. and k∗h ∈ L1 (R). Moreover, convolution is commutative and associative. In this section, we consider convolutions involving vector and operator-valued functions. If k : R → C and f : R → X are measurable, we define the convolution by (k ∗ f )(t) = k(t − s)f (s) ds (1.6) R
whenever this exists (as a Bochner integral). Since (k ∗ f )(t) = we may write f ∗ k in place of k ∗ f .
R
k(s)f (t − s) ds,
Proposition 1.3.1. Let k, h ∈ L1 (R) and f ∈ L1 (R, X). Then a) (k ∗ f )(t) exists for almost all t ∈ R and k ∗ f ∈ L1 (R, X). b) h ∗ (k ∗ f ) = (h ∗ k) ∗ f a.e. Proof. These results may be deduced from the vector-valued version of Fubini’s theorem (Theorem 1.1.9) in the same way as in the scalar case. (Alternatively, they may be deduced from their scalar cases, using Theorem 1.1.4 and the Hahn-Banach theorem). Many standard facts about convolutions of scalar-valued functions extend to the vector-valued case. We summarize some of them here.
22
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
Proposition 1.3.2. a) (Young’s inequality) Let 1 ≤ p, q, r ≤ ∞ satisfy 1/p + 1/q = 1 + 1/r. If k ∈ Lp (R) and f ∈ Lq (R, X), then k ∗ f ∈ Lr (R, X) and
k ∗ f r ≤ k p f q .
b) Let 1 < p, p < ∞ satisfy 1/p + 1/p = 1. If k ∈ Lp (R) and f ∈ Lp (R, X), then k ∗ f ∈ C0 (R, X). c) If k ∈ L1 (R) and f ∈ L∞ (R, X), or if k ∈ L∞ (R) and f ∈ L1 (R, X), then k ∗ f ∈ BUC(R, X). d) If k ∈ L1 (R) and f ∈ C0 (R, X), or if k ∈ C0 (R, X) and f ∈ L1 (R), then k ∗ f ∈ C0 (R, X). Proof. Under the assumptions of a), the scalar-valued version of Young’s inequality [RS72, Section IX.4] shows that (|k| ∗ f )(t) exists a.e., and |k| ∗ f ∈ Lr (R). If (|k| ∗ f )(t) exists, then (k ∗ f )(t) exists and
(k ∗ f )(t) ≤ (|k| ∗ f )(t). Moreover, k ∗ f is weakly measurable by the scalar-valued theory, and hence measurable by Pettis’s theorem (Theorem 1.1.1). Thus, k ∗ f ∈ Lr (R, X). The proofs of the remaining parts are similar to the scalar-valued case [Rud62, Theorem 1.1.6]. Suppose that 1 ≤ p < ∞ and 1/p + 1/p = 1. For t, h ∈ R,
(k ∗ f )(t + h) − (k ∗ f )(t) ≤ (k(t + h − s) − k(t − s)) f (s) ds
R
1/p
≤ → 0
|k(s + h) − k(s)| ds p
R
f p
as h → 0. This shows that k ∗ f is uniformly continuous. When k ∈ L∞ (R) and f ∈ L1 (R, X), uniform continuity is established in a similar way with the roles of k and f reversed. Boundedness follows from a). This proves c). For b) and d), observe that k ∗ f has compact support if both k and f have compact support, and then the results follow by density arguments. When k and f are defined on R+ , or on [0, τ ] where τ > 0, then k ∗ f may be defined by (1.6) by taking k(t) and f (t) to be zero for other values of t. Then (k ∗ f )(t) =
0
t
k(t − s)f (s) ds
(t ≥ 0).
It is immediate that Propositions 1.3.1 and 1.3.2 remain valid in these contexts. Note that if k ∈ L1loc (R+ ) and f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X), then k ∗ f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X).
1.3. CONVOLUTIONS
23
As a tool, we shall need the notion of regularization from harmonic analysis. A mollifier is a sequence (ρn )n∈N in L1 (R) of the following form. The function ρ1 ∈ 1 L (R) satisfies R ρ1 (t) dt = 1, and ρn ∈ L1 (R) is given by ρn (t) = nρ1 (nt) (t ∈ R, n ∈ N). The next lemma shows that any mollifier acts as an approximate unit on various function spaces. Lemma 1.3.3. Let (ρn )n∈N be a mollifier. a) Let f ∈ BUC(R, X). Then limn→∞ f ∗ ρn − f ∞ = 0. b) Let f ∈ L1 (R, X). Then limn→∞ f ∗ ρn − f 1 = 0. Proof. a) Let ε > 0. There exists c > 0 such that 2 f ∞ |s|≥c |ρ1 (s)| ds ≤ ε. Then for t ∈ R, n ∈ N,
(f ∗ ρn )(t) − f (t) = (f (t − s) − f (t))ρn (s) ds
R
s
= (f (t − ) − f (t))ρ1 (s) ds
n R
s
≤ − f (t) |ρ1 (s)| ds
f t − n |s|≤c
s
+ − f (t) |ρ1 (s)| ds
f t − n |s|>c ≤
sup f (t − h) − f (t) ρ1 1 + ε
|h|≤c/n
≤ 2ε for all sufficiently large n, since f is uniformly continuous. b) Let f ∈ L1 (R, X). Then
(f (t − s) − f (t))ρn (s) ds dt
f ∗ ρn − f 1 =
R
s
dt = f (t − − f (t))ρ (s) ds 1
n R R
s
≤ − f (t) dt |ρ1 (s)| ds.
f t − n R R As observed in Section 1.1, limn→∞ R f (t − ns ) − f (t) dt = 0 for all s ∈ R. Now the claim follows from the dominated convergence theorem. Lemma 1.3.3 is also valid for the spaces Lp (R, X) (1 < p < ∞) (see Remark 1.3.8 b)). The notion of mollifier can be extended to a family {ρε : 0 < ε ≤ 1} where ρε (t) = ε−1 ρ(t/ε), and Lemma 1.3.3 remains valid in that case. The theory of vector-valued convolutions and mollifiers extends, with almost no changes, to the case of functions on Rn for n ≥ 1.
24
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
Now we move on to consider convolutions of vector-valued functions with operator-valued functions. The space of all bounded linear operators from a Banach space X into a Banach space Y is denoted by L(X, Y ), or simply by L(X) when Y = X. A function T : R+ → L(X, Y ) is strongly continuous if t → T (t)x is continuous for all x ∈ X. By the uniform boundedness principle, a strongly continuous function T is locally bounded. Note also that T is lower semi-continuous and hence measurable. We state the convolution results for strongly continuous functions T : R+ → L(X, Y ), but they are also valid for T : (0, ∞) → L(X, Y ) if T is strongly continuous on (0, ∞) and bounded on (0, 1). There are similar results for compact intervals [0, τ ]. Proposition 1.3.4. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) and let T : R+ → L(X, Y ) be strongly continuous. Then the convolution t (T ∗ f )(t) := T (t − s)f (s) ds 0
exists (as a Bochner integral) and defines a continuous function T ∗ f : R+ → Y . Proof. Fix t ≥ 0. First, we show that s → T (t − s)f (s) is measurable on [0, t]. When f (s) = χΩ (s)x for some measurable Ω ⊂ R+ and x ∈ X, then T (t − s)f (s) = χΩ (s) · T (t − s)x. This is measurable, being the product of a measurable scalar-valued function and a continuous vector-valued function. By linearity, T (t − ·)f (·) is measurable when f is a simple function. For measurable f , there is a sequence of simple functions fn → f a.e. and then T (t − s)fn (s) → T (t − s)f (s) s-a.e., so T (t − ·)f (·) is measurable. Since
T (t − s)f (s) ≤ T (t − s) f (s)
it follows from Theorem 1.1.4 that (T ∗ f )(t) exists. Continuity of T ∗ f follows from the dominated convergence theorem (Theorem 1.1.8). Now we state the analogue of Proposition 1.3.2 for operator-valued functions on R+ . Proposition 1.3.5. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) and T : R+ → L(X, Y ) be strongly continuous. a) (Young’s inequality) Let 1 ≤ p, q, r ≤ ∞ satisfy 1/p + 1/q = 1 + 1/r. If ∞ p
T (t)
dt < ∞ and f ∈ Lq (R+ , X), then T ∗ f ∈ Lr (R+ , Y ) and 0
T ∗ f r ≤ f q
∞ 0
1/p
T (t) dt p
.
1.3. CONVOLUTIONS
25
∞ b) Let 1 < p, p < ∞ satisfy 1/p + 1/p = 1. If 0 T (t) p dt < ∞ and f ∈ Lp (R+ , X), then T ∗ f ∈ C0 (R+ , Y ). ∞ c) If 0 T (t) dt < ∞ and f ∈ BUC(R+ , X), or if T is bounded and f ∈ L1 (R+ , X), then T ∗ f ∈ BUC(R+ , Y ). ∞ d) If 0 T (t) dt < ∞ and f ∈ C0 (R+ , X), or if limt→∞ T (t) = 0 and f ∈ L1 (R+ , X), then T ∗ f ∈ C0 (R+ , Y ). Proof. The proofs are similar to Proposition 1.3.2, with the exception of the uniform continuity of T ∗ f when T is integrable and f is bounded and uniformly continuous. Then, for 0 ≤ t ≤ t + h,
(T ∗ f )(t + h) − (T ∗ f )(t)
t+h
t
≤ T (s)f (t + h − s) ds + T (s)(f (t + h − s) − f (t − s)) ds
t
0 ∞ t+h ≤
T (s) ds f ∞ +
T (s) ds sup f (s + h) − f (s)
0
t
s≥0
→ 0 uniformly in t as h → 0. If f or T is more regular, then T ∗ f is continuously differentiable. We give two such results. Proposition 1.3.6. Let T : R+ → L(X, Y ) be strongly continuous and bounded, t x ∈ X, f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X), f (t) = x + 0 f (s) ds (t ≥ 0). Then T ∗ f ∈ C 1 (R+ , Y ) and (T ∗ f ) (t) = (T ∗ f )(t) + T (t)x. Proof. Let u(t) := (T ∗ f )(t) + T (t)x. Then by Proposition 1.3.4, u ∈ C(R+ , Y ). By Fubini’s theorem we have t t s t u(s) ds = T (r)f (s − r) dr ds + T (s)x ds 0 0 0 0 t t t = T (r)f (s − r) ds dr + T (s)x ds 0 r 0 t t−r t = T (r)f (s) ds dr + T (s)x ds 0 0 0 t t = T (r)(f (t − r) − x) dr + T (s)x ds 0
=
(T ∗ f )(t)
0
(t ≥ 0).
By Proposition 1.2.2 a), this proves the claim.
26
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
Proposition 1.3.7. Let T : [0, τ ] → L(X, Y ) be Lipschitz continuous with T (0) = 0, and let f ∈ L1 ([0, τ ], X). Then T ∗ f ∈ C 1 ([0, τ ], Y ). Proof. First, suppose that f ∈ C 1 ([0, τ ], X). By Proposition 1.3.6, T ∗ f has a derivative g ∈ C([0, τ ], Y ). For 0 ≤ r ≤ t ≤ τ ,
t
= (T ∗ f )(t) − (T ∗ f )(r)
g(s) ds
r
t
≤
T (t − s)f (s) ds +
0
r t
≤
r
L (t − s) f (s) ds +
r 0
r
(T (t − s) − T (r − s))f (s) ds L (t − r) f (s) ds
≤ L (t − r) f 1 , where L is a Lipschitz constant for T , so that T (t2 ) − T (t1 ) ≤ L|t2 − t1 | and, in particular, T (s) ≤ Ls since T (0) = 0. It follows that g(s) ≤ L f 1 for all s ∈ [0, τ ]. Now, consider f ∈ L1 ([0, τ ], X). There is a sequence (fn ) in C 1 ([0, τ ], X) such that fn − f 1 → 0. By Proposition 1.3.5, (T ∗ (fn − f ))(t) → 0. By the first paragraph,
(T ∗ fn ) − (T ∗ fm ) ∞
≤ →
L fn − fm 1 0,
so ((T ∗ fn ) ) converges uniformly to a function g ∈ C([0, τ ], Y ). Since t t (T ∗ f )(t) = lim (T ∗ fn )(t) = lim (T ∗ fn ) (s) ds = g(s) ds, n→∞
n→∞
0
0
it follows that T ∗ f ∈ C 1 ([0, τ ], Y ). Remark 1.3.8. a) There is an analogous theory of operator-valued convolutions on R. One may define (T ∗ f )(t) :=
R
T (t − s)f (s) ds
for almost all t, if T : R → L(X, Y ) is strongly continuous, R T (t) p dt < ∞ and f ∈ Lq (R, X) where 1/p + 1/q ≥ 1, and Proposition 1.3.5 is valid in this case. b) Convolutions of scalar, vector or operator-valued functions can sometimes be considered as Bochner integrals with values in a function space. Suppose that 0 < τ ≤ ∞, k ∈ L1 (0, τ ) and f ∈ Lp ((0, τ ), X) where 1 ≤ p < ∞. Define G : (0, τ ) → Lp ((0, τ ), X) by f (t − s) (0 < s < t < τ ) G(s)(t) := 0 otherwise.
1.4. EXISTENCE OF THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
27
Then G is continuous and G(s) p ≤ f p . We can therefore form the Bochner τ integral 0 k(s)G(s) ds in L1 ((0, τ ), X). Then
τ 0
k(s)G(s) ds = k ∗ f
a.e. in (0, τ ).
This can beproved by first considering step functions, or by considering integrals τ of the form 0 (k ∗ f )(t), x∗ g(t) dt for arbitrary x∗ ∈ X ∗ and g ∈ Lp (0, τ ). Thus,
k ∗ f p ≤ k 1 f p , a special case of Young’s inequality. This approach can also be used for convolutions on R, when the spaces Lp (R, X) can be replaced by BUC(R, X) or C0 (R, X). For example, this leads to a very short proof of Lemma 1.3.3 for all these spaces. The same idea can be used in the operator-valued case. Suppose that 0 < τ ≤ ∞, T : (0, τ ) → L(X, Y ) is strongly continuous and f ∈ Lp ((0, τ ), X), where 1 ≤ p < ∞. Let T (s)f (t − s) (0 < s < t < τ ), H(s)(t) := 0 otherwise. p Then H(s) ∈ Lp ((0, τ ), Y ) τ τ ), Y ), H(s) p ≤ T (s) f p , and H : (0, τ ) → L ((0, τ is continuous. If 0 T (s) ds < ∞, one may form the Bochner integral 0 H(s) ds in Lp ((0, τ ), Y ) and it coincides a.e. with T ∗ f .
1.4
Existence of the Laplace Integral
Let X be a complex Banach space and L1loc (R+ , X) := {f : R+ → X: f is Bochner integrable on [0, τ ] for all τ > 0}. This section is concerned with the existence of the Laplace integral ∞ τ fˆ(λ) := e−λt f (t) dt := lim e−λt f (t) dt 0
τ →∞
0
τ
for f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) and λ ∈ C. Note that 0 e−λt f (t) dt exists as a Bochner ∞ integral, and if 0 e−λt f (t) dt exists as a Bochner integral then it agrees with the definition above, by the dominated convergence theorem. Of special interest will be the abscissa of convergence of fˆ, given by abs(f ) := inf{Re λ : fˆ(λ) exists}. It will be shown that the set of those λ ∈ C for which the Laplace integral converges is either empty or a right half-plane whose left boundary point abs(f ) coincides with the exponential growth bound of the antiderivative t → F (t) − F∞
(t ≥ 0),
28
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
t where F (t) := 0 f (s) ds, F∞ := limt→∞ F (t) if the limit exists, and F∞ := 0 otherwise. Therefore, one particular result of this section will be that a locally Bochner integrable function t f is Laplace transformable if and only if its normalized antiderivative F : t → 0 f (s) ds is exponentially bounded. Proposition 1.4.1. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X). Then the Laplace integral fˆ(λ) converges if Re λ > abs(f ) and diverges if Re λ < abs(f ). Proof. Clearly, fˆ(λ) does not exist if Re λ < abs(f ). For λ0 ∈ C define G0 (t) := t −λ s e 0 f (s) ds (t ≥ 0). Then, for all λ ∈ C and t ≥ 0, integration by parts gives 0
t
e−λs f (s) ds =
0
t
e−(λ−λ0 )s e−λ0 s f (s) ds
0
= e
−(λ−λ0 )t
t G0 (t) + (λ − λ0 ) e−(λ−λ0 )s G0 (s) ds. (1.7) 0
If fˆ(λ0 ) exists, then G0 is bounded. Moreover, it follows from (1.7) that fˆ(λ) exists if Re λ > Re λ0 and ∞ fˆ(λ) = (λ − λ0 ) e−(λ−λ0 )s G0 (s) ds (Re λ > Re λ0 ). (1.8) 0
This shows that fˆ(λ) exists if Re λ > abs(f ). If fˆ(λ) converges for all λ ∈ C, then abs(f ) := −∞. If the domain of convergence is empty, then abs(f ) := ∞. A function f is called Laplace transformable if abs(f ) < ∞. It follows from Proposition 1.4.1 that the interior of the domain of convergence of fˆ(λ) is the open right half-plane {Re λ > abs(f )}. As the following example shows, the domain of convergence may or may not include points on the boundary abs(f ) + iR. Example 1.4.2. Let f (t) := (1 + t)−1 . Then abs(f ) = 0 since the Laplace integral fˆ(λ) converges for λ > 0 but not for λ = 0. If λ = ir (r = 0), then integration by parts implies that fˆ(ir) converges and 1 1 fˆ(ir) = − ir ir
∞ 0
e−irt dt. (1 + t)2
Thus, the domain of convergence of fˆ(λ) is {Re λ ≥ 0, λ = 0}. For f (t) := 1, the domain of convergence of fˆ(λ) is the open half-plane {Re λ > 0}; for f (t) := (1 + t2 )−1 it is the closed half-plane {Re λ ≥ 0}. From the proof of Proposition 1.4.1 and the uniform boundedness principle one also obtains the remarkable result that the abscissa of convergence of fˆ(λ) is
1.4. EXISTENCE OF THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL given by
t −λs ∗ ∗ ∗ abs(f ) = inf λ ∈ R : sup e f (s), x ds < ∞ for all x ∈ X . t>0
29
(1.9)
0
To see this we denote the right-hand side of (1.9) by absw (f ). Clearly, absw (f ) ≤ abs(f ). Assume that absw (f ) < abs(f ). Then there exists λ0 such that absw (f ) < λ0 < abs(f ) and supt>0 |G0 (t), x∗ | < ∞ (x∗ ∈ X ∗ ), where G0 is as in the proof of Proposition 1.4.1. It follows from the uniform boundedness principle that G0 is bounded. Thus, by (1.7), fˆ(λ) exists for all λ > λ0 . Since this contradicts λ0 < abs(f ) one obtains that absw (f ) = abs(f ). Next abs(f ) will be described by the exponential growth of f and its antiderivatives. For f : R+ → X the exponential growth bound is given by ω(f ) := inf ω ∈ R : sup e−ωt f (t) < ∞ . t≥0
It is obvious that abs(f ) ≤ abs( f ) ≤ ω(f ).
(1.10)
It will be shown in Example 1.4.4 below that there are cases in which one has strict inequalities in (1.10). In fact, it is possible that abs(f ) = −∞ and ω(f ) = ∞. It will be shown next that abs(f ) is determined by the exponential growth of t the antiderivative t → F (t) − F∞ (t ≥ 0), where F (t) := 0 f (s) ds, F∞ := limt→∞ F (t) if the limit exists, and F∞ := 0 otherwise. Theorem 1.4.3. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X). Then abs(f ) = ω(F − F∞ ).
t Proof. Suppose that abs(f ) < ∞. For λ0 > abs(f ) define G0 (t) := 0 e−λ0 s f (s) ds (t ≥ 0). Then G0 is continuous and convergent as t → ∞, so G0 is bounded. To prove that abs(f ) ≥ ω(F − F∞ ) one considers the three cases abs(f ) > 0, abs(f ) = 0, and abs(f ) < 0. First, let abs(f ) > 0. Then F∞ = 0 and, for λ0 > abs(f ), integration by parts gives t t t F (t) = f (s) ds = eλ0 s e−λ0 s f (s) ds = eλ0 t G0 (t) − λ0 eλ0 s G0 (s) ds. 0
0
0
It follows that F (t) ≤ Ce + C(e − 1) ≤ 2Ce for t ≥ 0, where C := sups≥0 G0 (s) . This shows that abs(f ) ≥ ω(F − F∞ ) if abs(f ) > 0. Second, let abs(f ) = 0. If F∞ = 0, then the same procedure as above yields abs(f ) ≥ ω(F − F∞ ). If abs(f ) = 0 and limt→∞ F (t) = F∞ exists, then it follows from the continuity of F that supt≥0 F (t) − F∞ < ∞. Thus, abs(f ) = 0 ≥ ω(F − F∞ ). This shows that abs(f ) ≥ ω(F − F∞ ) if abs(f ) = 0. Third, let abs(f ) < 0. Choose abs(f ) < λ0 < 0. For r ≥ t ≥ 0 one has r F (r) − F (t) = eλ0 s e−λ0 s f (s) ds t r λ0 r = e G0 (r) − eλ0 t G0 (t) − λ0 eλ0 s G0 (s) ds. λ0 t
λ0 t
λ0 t
t
30
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
Since G0 is bounded and limr→∞ F (r) = F∞ , it follows that
∞
λt
−|λ0 |s 0
≤ 2Ceλ0 t
F∞ − F (t) = e G (t) + λ e G (s) ds 0 0 0
t
for t ≥ 0. This proves that abs(f ) ≥ ω(F − F∞ ). To show the reverse inequality, suppose that ω(F − F∞ ) < ∞ and let ω > ω(F − F∞ ). Since F is continuous, there exists M ≥ 0 such that F (t) − F∞ ≤ M eωt for all t ≥ 0. Let λ > ω > ω(F − F∞ ). Using the fact that F − F∞ is an antiderivative of f , integration by parts yields t t e−λs f (s) ds = e−λt (F (t) − F∞ ) + F∞ + λ e−λs (F (s) − F∞ ) ds. 0
0
Hence, fˆ(λ) exists for λ > ω(F − F∞ ) and is given by fˆ(λ) = F∞ + λ(F − F∞ )(λ). ∞ −λt This shows that abs(f ) ≤ ω(F − F∞ ). Since λF (λ) = λ e F dt = F∞ if ∞ ∞ 0 Re λ > 0, fˆ(λ) = λFˆ (λ) if Re λ > max{abs(f ), 0}. (1.11) If ω ≥ 0, then the triangle inequality implies that ω(F ) ≤ ω if and only if ω(F − F∞ ) ≤ ω. Thus, a locally Bochner integrable function f is Laplace transt formable if and only if its antiderivative F (t) = 0 f (s) ds is exponentially bounded; and, abs(f ) ≤ ω ⇐⇒ ω(F ) ≤ ω (if ω ≥ 0). (1.12) The following is a first example of a function which is Laplace transformable but not exponentially bounded; i.e., abs(f ) < ω(f ) = ∞. t
t
Example 1.4.4. For t ≥ 0 let f (t) := et ee cos(ee ). Then ω(f ) = ∞. Since
t
F (t) =
f (s) ds = 0
t
s es
es
ee
e e cos (e ) ds = 0
t t
cos(u) du = sin ee − sin(e),
e
it follows that F∞ = 0. Thus, by Theorem 1.4.3, abs(f ) = ω(F ) = 0. Finally, the results of this section will be formulated for strongly continuous operator-valued functions T : R+ → L(X, Y ). We define the exponential growth bound of T by −ωt ω(T ) := ω( T ) = inf ω ∈ R : sup e T (t) < ∞ . t≥0
By the uniform boundedness principle, ω(T ) = sup{ω(ux ) : x ∈ X},
1.4. EXISTENCE OF THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
31
where ux (t) := T (t)x. t If T : R+ → L(X, Y ) is strongly continuous, and λ ∈ C, then 0 e−λs T (s) ds t −λs denotes the bounded operator x → 0 e T (s)x ds, and we define t −λs abs(T ) := inf Re λ : e T (s) ds converges strongly as t → ∞ 0
=
sup{abs(ux ) : x ∈ X}.
Here and in what follows, to say S : R+ → L(X, Y ) converges strongly as t → ∞ refers to the strong operator topology; i.e., it means that limt→∞ S(t)x exists in Y for all x ∈ X. Proposition 1.4.5. Let T : R+ → L(X, Y ) be strongly continuous, let S(t) = t T (s) ds, and S∞ be the strong limit of S(t) as t → ∞ if it exists, and S∞ := 0 0 otherwise. Then t a) limt→∞ 0 e−λs T (s) ds exists in operator norm whenever Re λ > abs(T ). t b) abs(T ) = inf λ ∈ R : supt>0 0 e−λs T (s)x, y ∗ ds < ∞ for all x ∈ X and y ∗ ∈ Y ∗ . c) abs(T ) = ω(S − S∞ ). t Proof. If 0 e−λ0 s T (s) ds converges strongly, then it is uniformly bounded in operator norm. Thus, a) follows from (1.7), while b) is immediate from (1.9). To prove c), it is possible to repeat the proof of Theorem 1.4.3. Alternatively, one may deduce c) from Theorem 1.4.3 as follows. Let ux (t) := T (t)x, vx (t) := S(t)x − S∞ x, and S(t)x − lim S(s)x if the limit exists, s→∞ vx (t) := S(t)x otherwise. By Theorem 1.4.3, abs(ux ) = ω(vx ). Moreover, ω(vx ) and ω(vx ) coincide if either of them is strictly positive, since vx − vx is a constant function. First suppose that abs(T ) < 0. Then ω(vx ) = abs(ux ) ≤ abs(T ) < 0, so limt→∞ vx (t) exists for all x ∈ X. Thus, S(t) converges strongly, so vx = vx and abs(T )
= sup{abs(ux ) : x ∈ X} = sup{ω(vx ) : x ∈ X} = sup{ω(vx ) : x ∈ X} = ω(S − S∞ ).
Next, suppose that ω(S − S∞ ) < 0. Then again, S(t) converges strongly and, as above, abs(T ) = ω(S − S∞ ).
32
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL Next, suppose that abs(T ) > 0. Then abs(T )
=
sup{abs(ux ) : x ∈ X, abs(ux ) > 0}
= =
sup{ω(vx ) : x ∈ X, ω(vx ) > 0} sup{ω(vx ) : x ∈ X, ω(vx ) > 0}
=
ω(S − S∞ ).
Finally, suppose that ω(S − S∞ ) > 0. Then the same argument as in the previous paragraph can be applied to show that abs(T ) = ω(S − S∞ ). Remark 1.4.6. If S∞ is the norm-limit of S(t) as t → ∞ if this exists and S∞ ∈ L(X, Y ) is arbitrary otherwise, and S∞ is as in Proposition 1.4.5, then it is trivial that ω(S − S∞ ) = ω(S − S∞ ). If T : R+ → L(X, Y ) is strongly continuous and abs(T ) < ∞, we define the Laplace integral of T by ∞ t −λs ˆ T (λ) := e T (s) ds := lim e−λs T (s) ds (Re λ > abs(T )), t→∞
0
0
where the right-hand integral is interpreted as above and the limit exists in operator norm (Proposition 1.4.5).
1.5
Analytic Behaviour
Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X). In this section it will be shown that λ → fˆ(λ) is holomorphic for Re λ > abs(f ). In general, fˆ need not have a singularity on the boundary abs(f ) + iR of its domain of convergence and may be extended holomorphically to a strictly larger half-plane. However, it will be shown that abs(f ) is a singularity of fˆ if X is an ordered Banach space with a normal positive cone and f (t) ≥ 0 a.e. (see Appendix C). We put N0 := N ∪ {0}. Theorem 1.5.1. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) with abs(f ) < ∞. Then λ → fˆ(λ) is holomorphic for Re λ > abs(f ) and, for all n ∈ N0 and Re λ > abs(f ), ∞ fˆ(n) (λ) = e−λt (−t)n f (t) dt (1.13) 0
(as an improper Bochner integral). Proof. Define qk : C → X (k ∈ N0 ) by qk (λ) :=
0
k
N λn k (−t)n f (t) dt. N →∞ n! 0 n=0
e−λt f (t) dt = lim
1.5. ANALYTIC BEHAVIOUR
33
The limits exist uniformly for λ in bounded subsets of C. By the Weierstrass convergence theorem (a simple special case of Vitali’s Theorem A.5), the functions k (j) qk are entire and qk (λ) = 0 e−λt (−t)j f (t) dt for all j ∈ N0 . t Let Re λ > λ0 > abs(f ) and define G0 (t) := 0 e−λ0 s f (s) ds. By Proposition 1.4.1, G0 is bounded and integration by parts gives fˆ(λ) − qk (λ)
∞
=
e−(λ−λ0 )s e−λ0 s f (s) ds
k −(λ−λ0 )k
= −e
∞
G0 (k) + (λ − λ0 )
e−(λ−λ0 )s G0 (s) ds.
k
It follows that qk converges to fˆ uniformly on compact subsets of {λ : Re λ > abs(f )}. Again by the Weierstrass convergence theorem, fˆ is holomorphic and (j) qk (λ) → fˆ(j) (λ) as k → ∞, for Re λ > abs(f ). If abs(f ) < ∞, then the abscissa of holomorphy of fˆ is denoted by hol(fˆ) := inf{ω ∈ R : fˆ extends holomorphically for Re λ > ω}. By Theorem 1.5.1, hol(fˆ) ≤ abs(f ).
(1.14)
In general, equality does not hold in (1.14) (see Example 1.5.2 below). However we shall see that equality does hold for positive functions on ordered spaces (Theorem 1.5.3) and for exponentially bounded functions which extend holomorphically into a sector {| arg(λ)| < α} for some 0 < α < π2 (see Section 2.6). Furthermore, in Chapter 4 (Theorem 4.4.19) we shall see that abs(f ) ≤ hol0 (fˆ) whenever f is exponentially bounded, where hol0 (fˆ) := inf{ω ∈ R : fˆ has a bounded holomorphic extension for Re λ > ω} is the abscissa of boundedness of fˆ. The following example shows that it may happen that hol(fˆ) < abs(f ) < ω(f ). Example 1.5.2. Let f (t) = et sin et (t ≥ 0). Obviously, ω(f ) = 1. Since F (t) = t f (s) ds = cos 1 − cos et , one obtains from Theorem 1.4.3 that abs(f ) = 0. It 0 follows from
34
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
t 0
t
d (− cos es ) ds ds 0 t = −e−λt cos et + cos 1 − λe−λs cos es ds 0 t d = −e−λt cos et + cos 1 − λ e−(λ+1)s (sin es ) ds ds 0
e−λs f (s) ds =
e−λs
−e−λt cos et + cos 1 − λe−(λ+1)t sin et t +λ sin 1 − λ(λ + 1) e−(λ+2)s es sin es ds
=
0
that fˆ(λ) = cos 1 + λ sin 1 − λ(λ + 1)fˆ(λ + 2) if Re λ > 0. Thus, fˆ has a holomorphic extension to Re λ > −2, then to Re λ > −4, etc. This shows that hol(fˆ) = −∞. Another of this function is that abs(f ) < abs(|f |). ∞ remarkable property ∞ Clearly, 0 e−λt |f (t)|dt = 1 u−λ | sin u| du converges for λ > 1. Since √ n−1 (4j+3)π/4 √ n−1 nπ 1 2 1 2 2π | sin u| du ≥ du ≥ , u 2 j=1 (4j+1)π/4 u 2 j=1 4j + 3 1 it follows that abs(|f |) = 1. Theorem 1.5.3. Let X be an ordered Banach space with a normal positive cone. Assume that abs(f ) < ∞ and f (t) ≥ 0 a.e. Then hol(fˆ) = abs(f ). If, in addition, abs(f ) > −∞, then fˆ has a singularity at abs(f ). Proof. If abs(f ) = −∞, then the statement follows from (1.14). If abs(f ) > −∞, then one may assume that abs(f ) = 0. Otherwise replace f by t → e−ωt f (t), where ω := abs(f ). By (1.14), λ → fˆ(λ) is holomorphic for Re λ > 0. Assume that fˆ is holomorphic at λ = 0. Then there exists a full circle with centre at 1 and radius 1 + 2λ0 for some λ0 > 0 such that fˆ is holomorphic on it (the extension of fˆ to points in the complex plane with Re λ ≤ 0 is denoted by the same symbol). Hence, fˆ(−λ0 ) = ∞
∞ k=0
(−1)k (1 + λ0 )k
1 ˆ(k) f (1). k!
Next it will be shown that 0 e f (t), x∗ dt converges for all x∗ ∈ X ∗ , which is ∗ a contradiction to (1.9). Let g(t) := f (t), x∗ . Since X+ is generating (Proposition ∗ C.2), one can assume that x ≥ 0 and thus g(t) ≥ 0. Then, by Theorem 1.5.1 and the monotone convergence theorem, ∞ ∞ k 1 gˆ(−λ0 ) = (1 + λ0 ) e−t tk g(t) dt k! 0 k=0 ∞ ∞ −t (1+λ0 )t = e e g(t) dt = eλ0 t g(t) dt. 0
λ0 t
0
1.5. ANALYTIC BEHAVIOUR
35
The following example shows that there are positive functions with hol(fˆ) < ω(f ). 3 2 Example 1.5.4. Let Ω := n∈N [n, n + e−n ) and f (t) := et χΩ (t). Then f (t) ≥ 0 ∞ ∞ n+e−n3 −λs s2 and ω(f ) = ∞. However, 0 e−λs f (s) ds = n=0 n e e ds converges ˆ for all λ ∈ R. Hence, hol(f ) = abs(f ) = −∞. Finally in this section, we consider operator-valued functions. Let T : R+ → L(X, Y ) be strongly continuous, where X and Y are arbitrary Banach spaces, and assume that abs(T ) < ∞. As in Section 1.4, let ux (t) := T (t)x (x ∈ X, t ≥ 0), and t ˆ T (λ) := lim e−λs T (s) ds (Re λ > abs(T )), t→∞
0
where the integral is interpreted as in Section 1.4 and the limit exists in operator norm (Proposition 1.4.5). Since Tˆ(λ)x = u x (λ), it follows from Theorem 1.5.1, (1.8) and Proposition A.3 that Tˆ : {Re λ > abs(T )} → L(X, Y ) is holomorphic. We define hol(Tˆ ) := inf ω ∈ R : Tˆ extends to a holomorphic function from {Re λ > ω} into L(X, Y ) .
Proposition 1.5.5. Let T : R+ → L(X, Y ) be strongly continuous with abs(T ) < ∞. Then hol(Tˆ) = sup {hol( ux ) : x ∈ X} . Proof. Since Tˆ(λ)x = u x (λ) for Re λ > abs(T ), it is clear that hol(Tˆ) ≥ hol( ux ) for all x ∈ X. We have to show that if ω < abs(T ) and each u x extends holomorphically to {Re λ > ω} and Tˆ (λ)x = u x (λ) (Re λ > ω), then Tˆ is a holomorphic function of {Re λ > ω} into L(X, Y ). Take λ0 with Re λ0 > abs(T ). For |λ − λ0 | < abs(T ) − ω, Tˆ (λ)x =
∞ (n) u x (λ0 ) (λ − λ0 )n . n! n=0
Moreover, for 0 < r < abs(T ) − ω,
m (n)
u
x (λ0 )
n sup (λ − λ0 ) : m ∈ N, |λ − λ0 | < r < ∞
n! n=0 for each x ∈ X. By the uniform boundedness principle, Tˆ (λ) ∈ L(X, Y ) and Tˆ is bounded on {|λ − λ0 | < r}. It follows from Proposition A.3 that Tˆ : {Re λ > ω} → L(X, Y ) is holomorphic.
36
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
1.6
Operational Properties
The importance of Laplace integrals in applications to differential equations lies in the fact that they transform the analytic operations of differentiation, integration and convolution into algebraic operations of multiplication. In this section, we establish these and other basic properties of Laplace transforms. Proposition 1.6.1. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X), μ ∈ C and s ∈ R+ . Let g(t) fs (t) hs (t)
:= e−μt f (t) (t ≥ 0), := f (s + t) (t ≥ 0), f (t − s) (t ≥ s), := 0 (0 ≤ t < s).
Let λ ∈ C. Then a) gˆ(λ) exists if and only if fˆ(λ + μ) exists, and then gˆ(λ) = fˆ(λ + μ). b) fs (λ) exists if and only if fˆ(λ) exists, and then s λs −λt ˆ fs (λ) = e f (λ) − e f (t) dt . 0
s (λ) = e−λs fˆ(λ). c) hs (λ) exists if and only if fˆ(λ) exists, and then h Proof. These results follow immediately from the formulae: τ τ −λt e g(t) dt = e−(λ+μ)t f (t) dt, 0 0 s+τ τ s −λt λs −λt −λt e fs (t) dt = e e f (t) dt − e f (t) dt ,
0 τ
0
e−λt hs (t) dt
= e−λs
0 τ −s
0
e−λt f (t) dt
(τ > s).
0
Proposition 1.6.2. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) and T ∈ L(X, Y ), and let (T ◦ f )(t) = T (f (t)). Then T ◦ f ∈ L1loc (R+ , Y ). If fˆ(λ) exists, then T ◦ f (λ) exists and equals T (fˆ(λ)). Proof. By Proposition 1.1.6, T ◦ f ∈ L1loc (R+ , Y ) and τ τ e−λt (T ◦ f )(t) dt = T e−λt f (t) dt. 0
0
The second statement follows on letting τ → ∞.
1.6. OPERATIONAL PROPERTIES
37
Proposition 1.6.3. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) and A be a closed operator on X. Suppose that f (t) ∈ D(A) a.e. and A ◦ f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X). Let λ ∈ C. If fˆ(λ) and A ◦ f (λ) ˆ ˆ both exist, then f (λ) ∈ D(A) and A ◦ f (λ) = A(f (λ)). Proof. By Proposition 1.1.7, τ e−λt (A ◦ f )(t) dt = A 0
τ
e−λt f (t) dt.
0
Since A is closed, the second statement follows on letting τ → ∞. Now we consider convolutions. Proposition 1.6.4. Let k ∈ L1loc (R+ ), f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X), λ ∈ C, and suppose that ˆ fˆ(λ). Re λ > max(abs(|k|), abs(f )). Then (k ∗ f )(λ) exists and (k ∗ f )(λ) = k(λ) Proof. Replacing k(t) by e−λt k(t) and f (t) by e−λt f (t), and using Proposition 1.6.1, we may assume that λ = 0. First, we give the simple proof in the case when f ∈ L1 (R+ , X). Then Fubini’s theorem gives that k ∗ f ∈ L1 (R+ , X) and ∞ (k ∗ f )(0) = (k ∗ f )(t) dt 0 ∞ t = k(t − s)f (s) ds dt 0 0 ∞ ∞ = k(t − s) dt f (s) ds 0
s
ˆ fˆ(0). = k(0) Now, assume only that fˆ(0) exists. Replacing f (t) by f (t) − e−t fˆ(0) (and ˆ using the previous case),
τ
we may assume that f (0) = 0. Let ε > 0. There exists K such that 0 f (s) ds < ε whenever τ > K. Then τ (k ∗ f )(t) dt = (1 ∗ (k ∗ f ))(τ ) = (k ∗ (1 ∗ f ))(τ ). 0
Hence,
τ
(k ∗ f )(t) dt
0
t
K
≤ k(τ − t) f (s) ds dt
0
0
τ t
+ k(τ − t) f (s) ds dt
≤ M
K τ
τ −K
0
|k(s)| ds + ε
τ −K 0
|k(s)| ds,
38
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
t
where M := supt≥0 0 f (s) ds < ∞. Letting τ → ∞,
τ
≤ ε k 1 . lim sup (k ∗ f )(t) dt
τ →∞
0
Since ε > 0 is arbitrary, it follows that (k ∗ f )(0) = 0, as required. As a corollary, we recover a simple result which was already observed in (1.11). Corollary 1.6.5. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) and let F (t) = fˆ(λ) exists, then Fˆ (λ) exists and Fˆ (λ) = fˆ(λ)/λ.
t 0
f (s) ds. If Re λ > 0 and
Proof. This is immediate from Proposition 1.3.1 with k(t) = 1. Corollary 1.6.6. Let f : R+ → X be absolutely continuous and differentiable a.e. If Re λ > 0 and f (λ) exists, then fˆ(λ) exists and f (λ) = λfˆ(λ) − f (0). t Proof. By Proposition 1.2.3, f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) and f (t) − f (0) = 0 f (s) ds. The result follows from Corollary 1.6.5. √ Now we want to consider the substitution of λ for λ; we will find a function √ ˆ h such that h(λ) = fˆ( λ). For this we first calculate the Laplace integral of a special function. Lemma 1.6.7. Let s > 0 and 2
φs (t)
=
e−s /4t √ , πt
ψs (t)
=
se−s /4t √ 2 πt3/2
s (λ) φ
=
√ 1 √ e−s λ , λ
s (λ) ψ
= e−s
2
(t > 0).
Then
√ λ
(Re λ > 0).
Proof. First, we show that, for α > 0,
∞
−((α/u)−u)2
e 0
du = 0
∞
√ α −(v−α/v)2 π e dv = . 2 v 2
The first equality follows from the change of variable v := α/u. Taking the average
1.6. OPERATIONAL PROPERTIES
39
and making the change of variable w := u − α/u, this gives ∞ 2 2 1 ∞ α e−((α/u)−u) du = 1 + 2 e−(u−α/u) du 2 u 0 0 1 ∞ −w2 = e dw 2 −∞ √ π = . 2 Now, for λ > 0, ∞ √ √ √ 2 1 s (λ) = e−s λ √ e−( λt−s/(2 t)) dt φ πt 0 ∞√ √ 2 λ −(s√λ/(2u)−u)2 = e−s λ √ e du πλ 0 2u2 √ √ 2 π = e−s λ √ 2 πλ √
e−s λ √ , = λ √ s (λ) = e−s λ ψ
∞
√ √ 2 s e−( λt−s/(2 t)) dt 3/2 2 πt 0 ∞ √ √ 2 2 = e−s λ √ e−(s λ/(2u)−u) du π 0
= e−s
√ λ
√
.
For Re λ > 0, the results follow by uniqueness of holomorphic extensions. Proposition 1.6.8. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) with ω(f ) < ∞, and let ∞ −s2 /4t e √ g(t) = f (s) ds, πt 0 ∞ −s2 /4t se √ h(t) = f (s) ds. 2 πt3/2 0 √ √ √ ˆ Then gˆ(λ) = fˆ( λ)/ λ and h(λ) = fˆ( λ), whenever Re λ > (max{ω(f ), 0})2 . √ Proof. If Re λ > (max{ω(f ), 0})2 , then Re λ > max{ω(f ), 0}, and Fubini’s theorem and Lemma 1.6.7 give ∞ ∞ −s2 /4t e √ gˆ(λ) = e−λt f (s) dt ds πt 0 0 ∞ −s√λ e √ f (s) ds = λ 0 √ √ = fˆ( λ)/ λ.
40
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
√ ˆ Similarly, h(λ) = fˆ( λ).
1.7
Uniqueness, Approximation and Inversion
In this section we shall show that any f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) with abs(f ) < ∞ is uniquely determined by its Laplace transform fˆ and we shall give the Post-Widder inversion formula (Theorem 1.7.7). Other inversion theorems appear in Section 2.3. The following elementary statement will be used in the proofs of many results in this and the following sections. Lemma 1.7.1. Let a, b > 0 and define λn := a + nb, e−λn (t) := e−λn t (n ∈ N0 , t ≥ 0). Then {e−λn : n ∈ N0 } is total in L1 (R+ ). Proof. By the Stone-Weierstrass theorem, the linear span of the set P := {t → a−1 tbn/a : n ∈ N0 } is dense in C[0, 1] and thus in L1 (0, 1). Now the statement follows from the fact that Φ : L1 (0, 1) → L1 (R+ ) defined by (Φg)(t) := ae−at g(e−at ) is an isometric isomorphism which maps P onto the exponential functions {e−λn : n ∈ N0 }. Proposition 1.7.2. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) with abs(f ) < ∞, let a > abs(f ), b > 0 and λn := a + nb. If fˆ(λn ) = 0 for all n ∈ N, then f (t) = 0 a.e. t Proof. One can assume that a > max{abs(f ), 0}. Define F (t) := 0 f (s) ds (t ≥ 0). Then 0 = fˆ(λn ) = λn Fˆ (λn ) for all n ∈ N0 (see Corollary 1.6.5). It follows from Theorem 1.4.3 that a > ω(F ). Thus G(t) := e−at F (t) is continuous and bounded on R+ , and G(nb) = Fˆ (a+nb) = 0 (n ∈ N). For x∗ ∈ X ∗ define gx∗ (t) := G(t), x∗ (t ≥ 0). Then gx∗ ∈ L∞ (R+ ) = L1 (R+ )∗ and ∞ ˆ e−nb , gx∗ = e−nbt gx∗ (t) dt = G(nb), x∗ = 0. 0
Since {e−nb : n ∈ N} is a total subset of L1 (R+ ) by Lemma 1.7.1, it follows that gx∗ (t) = 0 for all t ≥ 0 and x∗ ∈ X ∗ . This implies that F (t) = eat G(t) = 0 for all t ≥ 0 and thus f (t) = 0 a.e. Because of its importance we reformulate this result in the following form which is used frequently in the book. Theorem 1.7.3 (Uniqueness Theorem). Let f, g ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) with abs(f ) < ∞ and abs(g) < ∞, and let λ0 > max(abs(f ), abs(g)). Suppose that fˆ(λ) = gˆ(λ) whenever λ > λ0 . Then f (t) = g(t) a.e. Remark 1.7.4. A sequence (λn )n∈N of complex numbers is called a uniqueness sequence for the Laplace transform if f = 0 a.e. whenever f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X), abs(f ) < Re λn for all n, and fˆ(λn ) = 0 for all n. It was shown in Proposition 1.7.2 that
1.7. UNIQUENESS, APPROXIMATION AND INVERSION
41
equidistant sequences λn = a + nb (b > 0) are examples of uniqueness sequences. In particular, this shows that a function of the form λ → q(λ) sin(λ) cannot have a representation as a Laplace transform. A finite sequence (λ1 , · · · , λn ) is not a uniqueness sequence since the function λ → (λ+μ)−2n (λ−λ1 ) · · · (λ−λn ) (Re λ > −μ) is the Laplace transform of the convolution product of the functions t → (1 − (λi + μ)t)e−μt (1 ≤ i ≤ n). A characterization of uniqueness sequences will be given in the Notes to this section. One can deduce the following fundamental result on approximation from the uniqueness theorem by a quotient argument (see also the proof of Vitali’s theorem in Appendix A). Theorem 1.7.5 (Approximation). Let fn ∈ C(R+ , X) with fn (t) ≤ M eωt for some M > 0, ω ∈ R and all n ∈ N. Let λ0 ≥ ω. The following are equivalent: (i) The Laplace transforms fˆn converge pointwise on (λ0 , ∞) and the sequence (fn )n∈N is equicontinuous on R+ . (ii) The functions fn converge uniformly on compact subsets of R+ . Moreover, if (ii) holds, then fˆ(λ) = limn→∞ fˆn (λ) for all λ > λ0 , where f (t) := limn→∞ fn (t). Proof. The space c(X) := {(xn )n∈N : xn ∈ X and limn→∞ xn exists} is a closed subspace of l∞ (X) := {(xn )n∈N : xn ∈ X and supn∈N xn < ∞}. Define w : R+ → l∞ (X) by w(t) = (fn (t))n∈N . Assume that (i) holds. The equicontinuity of fn implies the continuity of w, and the convergence of fˆn (λ) implies that w(λ) ˆ = (fˆn (λ))n∈N ∈ c(X) for all λ > λ0 . Consider the quotient mapping q : l∞ (X) → l∞ (X)/c(X). Then (q ◦ w)(λ) = q(w(λ)) ˆ = 0 for all λ > λ0 . Since q ◦ w : R+ → ∞ l (X)/c(X) is continuous, it follows from the uniqueness theorem that q◦w(t) = 0 for all t ≥ 0; i.e., w(t) ∈ c(X) for all t ≥ 0. Hence (fn )n∈N converges pointwise. Since (fn )n∈N is equicontinuous, this implies uniform convergence on each compact subset of R+ . Conversely, assume that (ii) holds. Clearly, uniform convergence implies equiˆ continuity. Let f (t) = limn→∞ fn (t). Then limn→∞ f n (λ) = f (λ) for all λ > λ0 by the dominated convergence theorem. We point out that one cannot omit the condition that the sequence (fn )n∈N is equicontinuous. To give an example, let X = C and fn (t) := eint (t ≥ 0, n ∈ N). 1 Then f n (λ) = λ−in converges to 0 as n → ∞ for all λ > 0. But fn (t) does not converge as n → ∞ if t ∈ R+ \ 2πZ. Another quotient argument enables us to deduce the converse of Proposition 1.6.3 from the uniqueness theorem. Proposition 1.7.6. Let A be a closed linear operator on X, let f, g ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) such that abs(f ) < ∞ and abs(g) < ∞, and let ω > max{abs(f ), abs(g)}. Then the following assertions are equivalent:
42
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
(i) f (t) ∈ D(A) and Af (t) = g(t) a.e. on R+ . (ii) fˆ(λ) ∈ D(A) and Afˆ(λ) = gˆ(λ) for all λ > ω. Proof. The implication (i) ⇒ (ii) has already been proved in Proposition 1.6.3. (ii) ⇒ (i): Let G(A) be the graph of A, which is a closed subspace of X × X, and let q : X × X → (X × X)/G(A) be the quotient map. Define h : R+ → ˆ (X × X)/G(A) by h(t) = q(f (t), g(t)). Then h(λ) = q(fˆ(λ), gˆ(λ)) = 0 for all λ > ω, by (ii). By the uniqueness theorem, h(t) = 0 a.e. This proves that (i) is true. Recall from Proposition 1.2.2 that t is a Lebesgue point of f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) t+h if limh→0 h1 t f (s) − f (t) ds = 0 and that almost all points t are Lebesgue points of f . We now prove the Post-Widder inversion formula. Theorem 1.7.7 (Post-Widder). Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X). Assume that abs(f ) < ∞ and that t > 0 is a Lebesgue point of f . Then f (t) = lim (−1)k k→∞
1 k!
k+1 k k fˆ(k) . t t
Proof. To explain the structure of the proof, we first consider the special case when f is a bounded continuous function. By Theorem 1.5.1, 1 (−1) k! k
k+1 ∞ k k (k) ˆ f = ρk (s)f (s) ds, t t 0
! " 1 k k+1 −ks/t k where ρk (s) := k! e s (s > 0). The functions ρk are “approximate t ∞ Dirac δ-functions”; i.e., ρk ≥ 0, 0 ρk(s) ds = 1, and for all ε > 0 and all open intervals I ⊂ R+ containing t we have s∈I ρk (s) ds < ε for all sufficiently large k / (see below). Since f is assumed to be bounded and continuous, it follows from
∞
∞
ρk (s)f (s) ds − f (t) = ρk (s)(f (s) − f (t)) ds
0 0 ≤ 2 f ∞ ρk (s) ds + sup f (s) − f (t)
s∈I /
∞
s∈I
that 0 ρk (s)f (s) ds → f (t) as k → ∞. This proves the statement for bounded and continuous functions f . Now let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) and max(abs(f ), 0) < ω < ∞. By (1.12), ω > ω(F ), s where F (s) := 0 f (r) dr. In the following let t > 0 be a fixed Lebesgue point of f , and let k ∈ N such that k > ωt. Let s G(s) := (f (r) − f (t)) dr = F (s) − F (t) − f (t)(s − t) (s ≥ 0). t
1.7. UNIQUENESS, APPROXIMATION AND INVERSION
43
ωs Since ω > ω(F ), there exists M > 0 such that G(s) ≤ M e for all s ≥ 0. 1 k+1 ∞ −λs k Since k! λ e s ds = 1 for λ > 0 (by induction and integration by parts), 0 it follows from Theorem 1.5.1 and integration by parts that
Jk
k+1 1 k k (k) ˆ (−1) f − f (t) k! t t k+1 ∞ 1 k e−ks/t sk f (s) ds − f (t) k! t 0 k+1 ∞ 1 k e−ks/t sk (f (s) − f (t)) ds k! t 0 k+1 ∞ s 1 k k e−ks/t sk−1 − 1 G(s) ds k! t t 0 k+2 ∞ k e−ku uk−1 (u − 1)G(ut) du. k!t 0 k
:= = = = =
Let ε > 0. Since t is a Lebesgue point of f , there exists 0 < δ < 1 such that
tu
1
ε 1
G(ut) = (f (r) − f (t)) dr
≤ 3 |u − 1| t t t if |u − 1| ≤ δ. Define J1,k :=
k k+2 k!t
1+δ 1−δ
e−ku uk−1 (u − 1)G(ut) du.
Then
J1,k
≤ ≤ =
ε k k+2 3 k!
1+δ
1−δ k+2 ∞
e−ku uk−1 (u − 1)2 du
! " εk e−ku uk+1 − 2uk + uk−1 du 3 k! 0 ε k k+2 (k + 1)! 2k! (k − 1)! ε − k+1 + = k+2 k 3 k! k k k 3
for all k ∈ N with k > ωt. Let J2,k
k k+2 := k!t
0
1−δ
e−ku uk−1 (u − 1)G(ut) du.
If k > 1/δ, the function u → e−ku uk−1 is increasing on (0, 1 − δ). Thus,
J2,k ≤
k k+2 −k(1−δ) e (1 − δ)k−1 k!t
0
1−δ
(1 − u) G(ut) du =: bk .
44
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
k+2 Since bk+1 /bk = 1 + k1 eδ−1 (1 − δ) → eδ (1 − δ) < 1 as k → ∞, one obtains that J2,k < ε/3 for all sufficiently large k. Finally let 1 1 k+2 ∞ −ku k−1 J3,k := k e u (u − 1)G(ut) du. t k! 1+δ
The function u → e−mu um is decreasing on (1 + δ, ∞) for all m ∈ N. Choose k0 > tω and let k > k0 . Then
k+2 ∞
k
−(k−k0 )u k−k0 −k0 u k0 −1
J3,k = e u e u (u − 1)G(ut) du
k!t 1+δ ∞ k k+2 −(k−k0 )(1+δ) ≤ e (1 + δ)k−k0 e−k0 u uk0 −1 (u − 1)M eωut du k!t 1+δ =: ck . ! "k+2 −1−δ Since ck+1 /ck = 1 + k1 e (1 + δ) → e−δ (1 + δ) < 1, one obtains that
J3,k < ε/3 for all sufficiently large k. It follows from Jk = J1,k + J2,k + J3,k that Jk → 0 as k → ∞.
1.8
The Fourier Transform and Plancherel’s Theorem
In this section, we give a brief summary of the properties of vector-valued Fourier transforms, and we extend Plancherel’s theorem and the Paley-Wiener theorem (characterizing the Laplace transforms of L2 -functions) to functions with values in a Hilbert space. For f ∈ L1 (R, X), the Fourier transform of f is the function Ff : R → X defined by ∞
(Ff )(s) :=
e−ist f (t) dt.
−∞
We also define
∞
(Ff )(s) :=
eist f (t) dt = (Ff )(−s) = (F fˇ)(s),
−∞
where fˇ(t) := f (−t). Many properties of the Fourier transform on L1 (R, X) can be proved in exactly the same way as for the scalar-valued case (some can also be proved by applying linear functionals and using the scalar-valued results and the Hahn-Banach theorem), and we quote some of them here. Proofs of the scalar-valued cases may be found in standard textbooks such as [Rud87], [RS72], [Yos80], [Rud91]. Theorem 1.8.1. Let f ∈ L1 (R, X) and g ∈ L1 (R). a) F(g ∗ f )(s) = (F g)(s)(Ff )(s).
1.8. THE FOURIER TRANSFORM AND PLANCHEREL’S THEOREM b)
∞ −∞
g(t)(F f )(t) dt =
∞ −∞
45
(F g)(t)f (t) dt.
c) (Riemann-Lebesgue Lemma) Ff ∈ C0 (R, X). d) (Inversion Theorem) If Ff ∈ L1 (R, X), then f =
1 2π F(F f )
a.e.
For scalar-valued functions, Plancherel’s theorem [Rud87, Theorem 19.2] √ shows that Ff ∈ L2 (R) and F f 2 = 2π f 2 whenever f ∈ L1 (R) ∩ L2 (R), and hence the restriction of F to L1 (R) ∩ L2 (R) has a unique extension to a bounded linear operator on L2 (R) (also denoted by F ), √12π F is a unitary operator on
L2 (R), and Theorem 1.8.1 b) holds for f, g ∈ L2 (R). Hence, F −1 = (2π)−1 F, where (Ff )(t) = (F f )(−t). Plancherel’s theorem is not true for vector-valued functions, except when the space X is a Hilbert space (see the Notes). If X is a Hilbert space with inner product (·|·)X , then L2 (R, X) is also a Hilbert space with inner product ∞ (f |g)L2 (R,X) := (f (t)|g(t))X dt. −∞
As observed in Section 1.1, the simple functions are dense in L2 (R+ , X). In this Hilbert space context, this can also be shown by computing the orthogonal complement of the simple functions. Theorem 1.8.2 (Plancherel’s Theorem). Let X be a Hilbert space. Then F f ∈ √ L2 (R, X) and Ff L2 (R,X) = 2π f L2 (R,X) for all f ∈ L1 (R, X) ∩ L2 (R, X). The restriction of F to L1 (R, X) ∩ L2 (R, X) extends to a bounded linear operator F on L2 (R, X) and √12π F is a unitary operator on the Hilbert space L2 (R, X). Moreover, ∞
−∞
∞
((F f )(t)|g(t))X dt =
−∞
(f (t)|(Fg)(−t))X dt
(1.15)
for all f, g ∈ L2 (R, X). Proof. Let f ∈ L1 (R, X) ∩ L2 (R, X). To prove that √
Ff L2 (R,X) = 2π f L2 (R,X) , it suffices to assume that X is separable, since f is almost separably valued. Let {en : n ∈ N} be an orthonormal basis of X, and let fn (t) := (f (t)|en )X . Then fn ∈ L1 (R) ∩ L2 (R) and ((F f )(s)|en )X = (F fn )(s). Now, using the scalar-valued Plancherel theorem, ∞ ∞ ∞
(F f )(s) 2 ds = |(Ffn )(s)|2 ds −∞
=
−∞ n=1 ∞ ∞
2π
=
−∞ n=1 ∞
2π −∞
|fn (t)|2 dt
f (t) 2 dt.
46
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
This proves the first part of the result. Since L1 (R+ , X) ∩ L2 (R+ , X) is dense in L2 (R+ , X), F extends uniquely to a bounded linear operator on L2 (R, X) such that √12π F is an isometry. One may prove (1.15) in a similar way, using Parseval’s formula and the corresponding scalar-valued result (Theorem 1.8.1 b)). This implies that the adjoint operator of F in the sense of Hilbert spaces is F, where (Ff )(t) = (Ff )(−t). Hence, FF = 2πI so F is surjective, and it follows that F is surjective. We remark that Plancherel’s theorem extends to functions of several variables with values in a Hilbert space X: the normalized Fourier transform (2π)−n/2 F is a unitary operator on L2 (Rn , X). This can be deduced from the scalar-valued case as in the proof of Theorem 1.8.2. Alternatively, it may be deduced from Theorem 1.8.2 by induction, using the identification L2 (Rn+1 , X) = L2 (R, L2 (Rn , X)). When f ∈ L1 (R+ , X), we consider f as being a member of L1 (R, X) with f (t) = 0 for t < 0, so ∞ (F f )(s) = e−ist f (t) dt = fˆ(is), 0
where, as usual, fˆ is the Laplace transform of f . Similarly, if t → e−at f (t) belongs to L1 (R+ , X) (for example, if f ∈ L2 (R+ , X) and a > 0), then its Fourier transform is s → fˆ(a + is). Thus, Plancherel’s theorem can be used to study Laplace transforms of functions in L2 (R+ , X) when X is a Hilbert space. Let C+ := {λ ∈ C : Re λ > 0} and H 2 (C+ , X) be the space of all holomorphic functions g : C+ → X such that ∞
g 2H 2 (C+ ,X) := sup
g(α + is) 2 ds < ∞. α>0
−∞
For scalar-valued functions, the Paley-Wiener theorem [Rud87, Theorem 9.13] shows that g ∈ H 2 (C+ ) := H 2 (C+ , C) if and only if g = fˆ|C+ for some f ∈ L2 (R+ ). Then ∞ ∞ 2 sup |g(α + is)| ds = lim |g(α + is)|2 ds. α>0
−∞
α↓0
−∞
Moreover, g has Ff as a boundary function in the sense that g(α + is) → (F f )(s) s-a.e. and in L2 -norm, as α ↓ 0. In addition, g is the Poisson integral of F f : α ∞ (Ff )(r) g(α + is) = dr 2 π −∞ α + (s − r)2 [Dur70, Chapter 11], [Koo80, Chapter VI]. Again, these results are not true for vector-valued functions in general, but they are true in the case of Hilbert spaces.
1.8. THE FOURIER TRANSFORM AND PLANCHEREL’S THEOREM
47
Theorem 1.8.3 (Paley-Wiener Theorem). Let X be a Hilbert space. Then the map f → fˆ|C+ is an isometric isomorphism of L2 (R+ , X) onto H 2 (C+ , X). Moreover, for f ∈ L2 (R+ , X), α ∞ (F f )(r) ˆ f (α + is) = dr. (1.16) π −∞ α2 + (s − r)2 ∞ As α ↓ 0, fˆ(α+is)−(F f )(s) → 0 (s)-a.e. and −∞ fˆ(α+is)−(F f )(s) 2 ds → 0. Proof. Let f ∈ L2 (R+ , X). For α > 0, ∞ ! " fˆ(α + is) = e−ist e−αt f (t) dt. 0
By Plancherel’s Theorem 1.8.2, ∞
2
ˆ
f (α + is) ds = 2π −∞
∞
0
e−2αt f (t) 2 dt ≤ 2π f 22 .
Thus fˆ ∈ H 2 (C+ , X). Moreover, Plancherel’s theorem and the dominated convergence theorem give ∞ ∞
fˆ(α + is) − (F f )(s) 2 ds = 2π |e−αt − 1|2 f (t) 2 dt → 0 −∞
0
as α ↓ 0. For α > 0 and x ∈ X, ∞ α ∞ ((F f )(r)|x)X (Ff )(r) x (fˆ(α + is)|x)X = dr = dr , 2 2 2 2 π −∞ α + (s − r) −∞ α + (s − r) X which establishes (1.16). The proof that fˆ(α + is) − (F f )(s) → 0 a.e. is similar to the scalar-valued case. Conversely, let g ∈ H 2 (C+ , X). Then gˆ is separably valued, so we may assume that X is separable. Let {en : n ∈ N} be an orthonormal basis of X, and let gn (λ) = (g(λ)|en )X . Then gn ∈ H 2 (C+ ), so the scalar-valued case implies that there exists fn ∈ L2 (R+ ) such that gn = fn |C+ . Moreover, ∞ ∞ ∞ ∞ 2 |fn (t)| dt = lim e−2αt |fn (t)|2 dt 0
α↓0
n=1
n=1
0
∞ ∞
1 lim |gn (α + is)|2 ds 2π α↓0 n=1 −∞ ∞ 1 = lim
g(α + is) 2 ds < ∞. 2π α↓0 −∞ ∞ ∞ Hence n=1 |fn (t)|2 converges, and therefore n=1 fn (t)en converges to a sum f (t) in X, for almost all t. Now, f ∈ L2 (R+ , X) and, for λ ∈ C+ , =
fˆ(λ) =
∞ n=1
fn (λ)en = g(λ).
48
1.9
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
The Riemann-Stieltjes Integral
b This section is an introduction to the Riemann-Stieltjes integral a g(t) dF (t) of a vector-valued function F and a scalar-valued function g on [a, b]. Such integrals play an important role in the approach to Laplace transform theory taken in Chapter 2. More precisely, let f : R+ → X be a bounded measurable function. t Then t → F (t) := 0 f (s) ds is Lipschitz continuous and we will show in Sections 1.10 and 2.1 that ∞ ∞ fˆ(λ) = e−λt f (t) dt = e−λt dF (t) = TF (e−λ ) 0
∞
0
for all λ > 0, where TF : g → 0 g(t) dF (t) is a bounded linear operator from L1 (R+ ) to X and e−λ (t) := e−λt . Thus, the Laplace integrals fˆ(λ) are evaluations of a bounded linear operator TF at the exponential function e−λ . Since the map ΦS : F → TF turns out to be an isometric isomorphism between the Lipschitz continuous functions F : R+ → X and L(L1 (R+ ), X) (see Section 2.1), many functional analytic arguments can be applied to Laplace transform theory. A function F : [a, b] → X is of bounded semivariation if there exists M ≥ 0 such that i (F (ti ) − F (si )) ≤ M for every choice of a finite number of nonoverlapping intervals (si , ti ) in [a, b]. Recall from Section 1.2 that F is of bounded variation if there exists M ≥ 0 such that i F (ti ) − F (ti−1 ) ≤ M for every finite partition a = t0 < t1 < . . . < tn = b of [a, b]. Further, F is of weak bounded variation if x∗ ◦ F : t → F (t), x∗ is of bounded variation for every x∗ ∈ X ∗ . The set of functions F : [a, b] → X of bounded semivariation is denoted by BSV([a, b], X). A function F : R+ → X is in BSVloc (R+ , X) if it is of bounded semivariation on every compact subinterval of R+ . As remarked in Section 1.2, any Lipschitz function is of bounded variation, and it is easy to see that any function of bounded variation is of bounded semivariation. We show in the following proposition that the function F : [0, 1] → L∞ [0, 1] defined by F (t) = χ[0,t] is of bounded semivariation. Since F (t) − F (s) = 1 for all t = s, F is not of bounded variation, not separably valued, and not measurable (see Example 1.1.5). Hence, functions of bounded semivariation may not be measurable. Proposition 1.9.1. Let X be an ordered Banach space with normal cone. Let F : [a, b] → X be increasing. Then F is of bounded semivariation. Proof. Let (si , ti ) (i = 1, 2, . . . , n) be disjoint intervals in [a, b]. Then 0≤
n
(F (ti ) − F (si )) ≤ F (tn ) − F (s1 ) ≤ F (b) − F (a).
i=1
Hence
n
(F (ti ) − F (si )) ≤ c F (b) − F (a) ,
i=1
1.9. THE RIEMANN-STIELTJES INTEGRAL
49
where c is a constant associated with the normal cone (see Appendix C). In the context of Proposition 1.9.1, it is easy to see directly that F is of weak bounded variation. In fact, there is the following general result. Proposition 1.9.2. A function F : [a, b] → X is of bounded semivariation if and only if it is of weak bounded variation. Proof. Assume that F is of weak bounded variation. Let SΩ := i (F (ti ) − F (si )), where Ω is the union of finitely many disjoint intervals (si , ti ) in [a, b]. For each x∗ ∈ X ∗ , there exists Mx∗ := V[a,b] (x∗ ◦ F ) such that |SΩ , x∗ | ≤ Mx∗ for all such Ω. It follows from the uniform boundedness principle that F is of bounded semivariation. Now, let F be of bounded semivariation. Then there exists a constant M ≥ 0 such that i (F (ti ) − F (si )) ≤ M for any choice of a finite number of disjoint intervals (si , ti ) in [a, b]. To obtain the weak bounded variation, one writes x∗ = x∗1 + ix∗2 , where x∗j is a real-linear functional, and distinguishes between the subintervals on which the numbers F (ti ) − F (ti−1 ), x∗j are either positive or negative. Let F, g be two functions defined on an interval [a, b], one with values in X and the other with values in C. If π denotes a finite partition a = t0 < t1 < . . . < tn = b of [a, b] with partitioning points ti and with some intermediate points si ∈ [ti−1 , ti ] (i = 1, . . . , n), we denote by |π| = maxi (ti − ti−1 ) the norm of π, and by n S(g, F, π) := g(si ) (F (ti ) − F (ti−1 )) i=1
the Riemann-Stieltjes sum associated with g, F and π. We say that g is RiemannStieltjes integrable with respect to F if
b
g(t) dF (t) := lim S(g, F, π) a
|π|→0
exists in the norm topology of X. Here π runs through all partitions of [a, b] with intermediate points, and the limit must be independent of the choice of intermediate points. It is immediate from the definition that the set of all functions g which are Riemann-Stieltjes integrable with respect to a fixed function F is a linear space, and the Riemann-Stieltjes integral is linear in g (and also in F ). If F is of bounded b variation, g is bounded and a g(t) dF (t) exists, then
b
g(t) dF (t) ≤ sup g(t) V[a,b] (F ).
a
t∈[a,b]
(1.17)
50
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
If F is of bounded semivariation, then it follows from the proof of Proposition 1.9.2 that
b
g(t) dF (t) ≤ 4M sup g(t) , (1.18)
a
t∈[a,b] where
M := sup (F (ti ) − F (si )) : (si , ti ) disjoint subintervals of [a, b] .
i (1.19) The Riemann-Stieltjes integral respects closed operators; there are easy analogues of Propositions 1.1.6 and 1.1.7, both when g is scalar-valued and F is vector-valued and in the alternative case. When F (t) = t, we write S(g, π) for S(g, F, π) and call it the Riemann sum associated with g and π. We say that g is Riemann integrable on [a, b] if g is Riemann-Stieltjes integrable with respect to F (t) = t, and we write
b
g(t) dt := lim S(g, π). a
|π|→0
In the scalar-valued case, g : [a, b] → C is Riemann integrable if and only if g is bounded and continuous a.e., and the Riemann and Lebesgue integrals are then equal [Rud76, Theorem 11.33]. By applying linear functionals, it follows that if g : [a, b] → X is Riemann integrable, then it is bounded and weakly measurable. If X is separable, then g is measurable by Pettis’s theorem 1.1.1 and hence Bochner integrable by Theorem 1.1.4. Whenever g is both Riemann and Bochner integrable, the two integrals coincide (so our notation should not cause confusion). However, Riemann integrable functions with values in an inseparable space may be nowhere continuous and not even measurable (see Example 1.9.7 below). Now we return to Riemann-Stieltjes sums and integrals of two functions F and g. Let π be a partition of [a, b] with partitioning points a = t0 < t1 < . . . < tn = b and intermediate points si ∈ [ti−1 , ti ]. If one chooses s0 = a and sn+1 = b, then we obtain a partition π with partitioning points a = s0 ≤ s1 ≤ . . . ≤ sn+1 = b, with intermediate points ti ∈ [si , si+1 ], and |π | ≤ 2|π|. Moreover, S(F, g, π) = g(b)F (b) − g(a)F (a) − S(g, F, π ). It follows that if g is Riemann-Stieltjes integrable with respect to F , then so is F with respect to g (and vice versa, by symmetry) and the following formula of integration by parts holds:
b a
g(t) dF (t) = g(b)F (b) − g(a)F (a) −
b
F (t) dg(t). a
(1.20)
1.9. THE RIEMANN-STIELTJES INTEGRAL
51
Example 1.9.3. Let a ≤ c ≤ d ≤ b and let I be an interval with endpoints c and d. Let F : [a, b] → X. If a ∈ I and b ∈ I, then F and χI are Riemann-Stieltjes integrable with respect to each other if and only if F is continuous at c and d, and then b
b
χI (t) dF (t) = −
a
F (t) dχI (t) = F (d) − F (c).
a
If a = c ∈ I and b ∈ I, then F and χI are Riemann-Stieltjes integrable with respect to each other if and only if F is continuous at d, and then b b χI (t) dF (t) = F (d) − F (a), F (t) dχI (t) = −F (d). a
a
If a ∈ I and b = d ∈ I, then F and χI are Riemann-Stieltjes integrable with respect to each other if and only if F is continuous at c, and then b b χI (t) dF (t) = F (b) − F (c), F (t) dχI (t) = F (c). a
a
Proposition 1.9.4. Let F : [a, b] → X and g : [a, b] → C. If one function is continuous and the other is of bounded semivariation, then F and g are RiemannStieltjes integrable with respect to each other. Proof. a) Assume that F is of bounded semivariation and that g is continuous. Let ε > 0. Then there exists δ > 0 such that |g(s1 ) − g(s2 )| < ε whenever |s1 − s2 | < δ. Let πj , (j = 1, 2), be two partitions of [a, b] with |πj | < δ/2. Let a = t0 < t1 < . . . < tn = b be the partitioning points of π1 and π2 together. Then S(g, F, πj ) =
n
g(sj,i )(F (ti ) − F (ti−1 ))
i=1
where sj,i , ti and ti−1 belong to the same subinterval of πj . In particular, |s1,i − s2,i | < δ. For x∗ ∈ X ∗ , n ∗ ∗ |S(g, F, π1 ) − S(g, F, π2 ), x | = (g(s1,i ) − g(s2,i ))F (ti ) − F (ti−1 ), x <
i=1 n
ε
|F (ti ) − F (ti−1 ), x∗ |
i=1
≤ 4εM x∗ , where M is defined by (1.19). Now, Cauchy’s convergence criterion implies that b g(t) dF (t) exists. a b) Assume that F is continuous and g is of bounded semivariation. By Proposition 1.9.2, g is of bounded variation. Given ε > 0 there exists δ > 0 such that
F (s1 ) − F (s2 ) < ε whenever |s1 − s2 | < δ. Similarly to a), one shows that
S(F, g, π1 ) − S(F, g, π2 ) < εV[a,b] (g)
52
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
whenever |π1 | < δ/2 and |π2 | < δ/2, where V[a,b] (g) is the total variation of g. b Hence a F (t) dg(t) exists. Corollary 1.9.5. Let g : [a, b] → C be piecewise continuous, and F : [a, b] → X be continuous and of bounded semivariation. Then F and g are Riemann-Stieltjes integrable with respect to each other. Proof. Since g is piecewise continuous, g = g1 + g2 where g1 is continuous and g2 is a step function. Now the result follows from Proposition 1.9.4 and Example 1.9.3. Corollary 1.9.6. Let X be an ordered Banach space with normal cone. Let f : [a, b] → X be increasing. Then f is Riemann integrable. Proof. This is immediate from Propositions 1.9.1 and 1.9.4. Example 1.9.7. Let f : [0, 1] → L∞ [0, 1] be defined by f (t) := χ[0,t] , so f is increasing, nowhere continuous and not measurable (Example 1.1.5 a)). By Corollary 1.9.6, f is Riemann integrable and 1 n 1 f (t) dt = lim χ[0,i/n] . n→∞ n 0 This shows that then
1 0
i=1
f (t) dt is the function s → 1−s. Similarly, if F (t) :=
t 0
f (r) dr,
F (t)(s) = (t − s)χ[0,t] (s) (see Example 1.2.8 b)). Proposition 1.9.8. Let F : [a, b] → X be of bounded semivariation and g : [a, b] → C be of bounded variation. Then gF is of bounded semivariation. Proof. There exists M > 0 such that |g(t)| ≤ M and F (t) ≤ M for all t ∈ [a, b]. The function gF is of bounded semivariation since it is of weak bounded variation. This follows from the assumptions and the estimates: |g(ti )F (ti ) − g(ti−1 )F (ti−1 ), x∗ | i
≤
i
+
|(g(ti ) − g(ti−1 ))F (ti ), x∗ |
|g(ti−1 )(F (ti ) − F (ti−1 )), x∗ |
i
≤ M x∗
i
∗
|g(ti ) − g(ti−1 )| + M
|F (ti ) − F (ti−1 ), x∗ | ,
i
∗
for all x ∈ X . In the remainder of this section, we give some results which reduce RiemannStieltjes integrals to Riemann or Bochner integrals when g or F has a derivative in an appropriate sense.
1.9. THE RIEMANN-STIELTJES INTEGRAL
53
Proposition 1.9.9. Let F : [a, b] → X be of bounded semivariation and g ∈ C 1 [a, b]. Then F g is Riemann integrable and
b
F (t) dg(t) = a
b
F (t)g (t) dt.
a
Proof. a) We show that hF is Riemann integrable for each h ∈ C[a, b]. If h is a step function, then hF is of bounded semivariation and hence Riemann integrable, by Proposition 1.9.4. Since each continuous function h on [a, b] is a uniform limit of step functions and F is bounded, the claim follows since a uniform limit of Riemann integrable functions is Riemann integrable. b) There exists M > 0 such that |g (t)| ≤ M and F (t) ≤ M for all t ∈ [a, b]. For ε > 0 there exists δ > 0 such that |g (s) − g (s )| < ε whenever |s − s | < δ. Let π be a partition of [a, b] with |π| < δ and with partitioning points ti and intermediate points si . By the mean value theorem, there exist si ∈ (ti−1 , ti ) such that g(ti ) − g(ti−1 ) = g (si )(ti − ti−1 ). Let π be the partition with partitioning points ti and intermediate points si , so |π | = |π|. Then S(F, g, π )
=
F (si )g (si )(ti − ti−1 )
i
= S(F g , π ). Letting |π| → 0, it follows that
b a
F (t) dg(t) =
b a
F (t)g (t) dt.
Proposition 1.9.10. Let F : [a, b] → X be of bounded semivariation and g, h ∈ t C[a, b]. Then G(t) := a h(s) dF (s) is of bounded semivariation on [a, b] and
b
g(t) dG(t) =
b
g(t)h(t) dF (t).
a
a
Proof. Let M be such that |h(t)| ≤ M for all t ∈ [a, b]. Let π be a partition of [a, b] with partitioning points ti and intermediate points si . By (1.17), for x∗ ∈ X ∗ , i
|G(ti ) − G(ti−1 ), x∗ |
=
ti h(s) dF (s), x∗ ti−1 i
≤ M V[a,b] (x∗ ◦ F ).
It follows from Proposition 1.9.2 that G is of bounded semivariation. By Proposib b tion 1.9.4, a g(t) dG(t) and a g(t)h(t) dF (t) both exist. For ε > 0 there exists δ > 0 such that |g(s ) − g(s)| < ε whenever |s − s| < δ.
54
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
If |π| < δ, then
# $ b ∗ g(t)h(t) dF (t), x S(g, G, π) − a ti ∗ = (g(si ) − g(t))h(t) dF (t), x ti−1 i
≤ εM V[a,b] (x∗ ◦ F ). It follows that
# a
b
$
b
g(t) dG(t) −
∗
g(t)h(t) dF (t), x
= 0.
a
The result follows from the Hahn-Banach theorem. The following result gives analogues of a special case of Proposition 1.9.10 and of Proposition 1.9.9, with Riemann integrals replaced by Bochner integrals. Proposition 1.9.11. Let g : [a, b] → C and F : [a, b] → X. If F is an antiderivative b of a Bochner integrable function f and if g is continuous, then a g(s) dF (s) exists b and equals the Bochner integral a g(s)f (s) ds. If F is continuous and g is absob b lutely continuous, then a F (s) dg(s) equals the Bochner integral a F (s)g (s) ds. Proof. Assume that g is continuous t and that there exists a Bochner integrable function f such that F (t) = F (a) + a f (s) ds for all t ∈ [a, b]. Then F is of bounded b variation (Proposition 1.2.2) and the Riemann-Stieltjes integral a g(s) dF (s) exb ists by Proposition 1.9.4. The Bochner integral a g(s)f (s) ds exists by Theorem 1.1.4, since g is bounded and measurable. For ε > 0 there exists δ > 0 such that |g(s ) − g(s)| < ε whenever |s − s| < δ. For any partition π with |π| < δ,
b
ti
g(s)f (s) ds = (g(si ) − g(s))f (s) ds
S(g, F, π) −
a t i−1 i b ≤ ε
f (s) ds. a
Letting |π| → 0 and ε → 0, the result follows. The proof of the second statement is analogous and is omitted. Combining Propositions 1.9.4, 1.9.8 and 1.9.9 with the integration by parts formula (1.20) one obtains the following statement which will be used frequently in later sections. Let F : [0, t] → X be of bounded semivariation. Then t t e−λs dF (s) = e−λt F (t) − F (0) + λ e−λs F (s) ds (1.21) 0
0
1.10. LAPLACE-STIELTJES INTEGRALS
55
t for all λ ∈ C. One should notice that the integral 0 e−λs F (s) ds is a Riemann integral if F is of bounded semivariation, by Propositions 1.9.4 and 1.9.9. If F is also continuous, then the integral can be taken in the Bochner sense.
1.10 Laplace-Stieltjes Integrals This section contains the essential properties of the Laplace-Stieltjes integral ∞ τ −λt dF (λ) := e dF (t) := lim e−λt dF (t), τ →∞
0
0
where F ∈ BSVloc (R+ , X); i.e., F : R+ → X is of bounded semivariation on each compact subinterval of R+ . First we observe that the Laplace-Stieltjes integral is a generalization of the Laplace integral. t (λ) Proposition 1.10.1. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) and F (t) := 0 f (s) ds. For λ ∈ C, dF (λ) = fˆ(λ). exists if and only if fˆ(λ) exists, and then dF Proof. By Proposition 1.9.11, τ −λt e dF (t) = 0
τ
e−λt f (t) dt
0
(τ ≥ 0),
and the result follows by letting τ → ∞. The results obtained in Sections 1.4, 1.5 and 1.6 for Laplace integrals carry over to Laplace-Stieltjes integrals with only minor modifications of the proofs, and we give these below, starting with elementary properties. Throughout this section, integrals over R+ are to be understood as improper Riemann-Stieltjes (or Riemann) integrals. Thus ∞ τ g(t) dF (t) := lim g(t) dF (t), τ →∞ 0 0 ∞ τ F (t) dt := lim F (t) dt. τ →∞
0
∞
0
It is easy to see that 0 F (t) dt exists if F ∈ BSVloc (R+ , X) and F (t) ≤ h(t) (t ≥ 0) for some h ∈ L1 (R+ ). Recall from Section 1.4 that the exponential growth bound of a function F ∈ BSVloc (R+ , X) is defined by ω(F ) := inf ω ∈ R : sup e−ωt F (t) < ∞ . t≥0
It follows from (1.21) that abs(dF ) ≤ ω(F ) and ∞ (λ) = −F (0) + λ dF e−λt F (t) dt
(Re λ > ω(F )).
0
Note that (1.22) is a generalization of both (1.11) and Corollary 1.6.5.
(1.22)
56
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
Proposition 1.10.2. Let f ∈ BSVloc (R+ , X) and F (t) := locally Lipschitz continuous, and
t 0
f (s) ds. Then F is
(λ) = −f (0) + λ2 Fˆ (λ) df (λ) = −f (0) + λdF whenever Re λ > ω(f ). Proof. Since f is locally bounded, (1.17) implies that F is locally Lipschitz continuous and ω(F ) ≤ ω(f ). In particular, F ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) ∩ BSVloc (R+ , X). By (1.21) and Proposition 1.9.10, τ τ e−λs df (s) = e−λτ f (τ ) − f (0) + λ e−λs dF (s). 0
0
Letting τ → ∞ gives
(λ) df (λ) = −f (0) + λdF
(λ) = λFˆ (λ). whenever Re λ > ω(f ). By (1.22), dF Now we give a generalization of Proposition 1.6.1 a). t Proposition 1.10.3. Let F ∈ BSVloc (R+ , X), μ ∈ C and let G(t) := 0 e−μs dF (s) (λ + μ) exists, and then (t ≥ 0). For λ ∈ C, dG(λ) exists if and only if dF dG(λ) = dF (λ + μ). Proof. By Proposition 1.9.10, τ e−λt dG(t) = 0
τ
e−(λ+μ)t dF (t),
0
and the result follows on letting τ → ∞. For F ∈ BSVloc (R+ , X), let
(λ) exists . abs(dF ) := inf Re λ : dF
(λ) converges if Re λ > Proposition 1.10.4. Let F ∈ BSVloc (R+ , X). Then dF abs(dF ) and diverges if Re λ < abs(dF ). (λ) does not exist if Re λ < abs(dF ). For λ0 ∈ C define G0 (t) := Proof. Clearly, dF t −λ s 0 e dF (s) (λ ∈ C, t ≥ 0). Then, by Proposition 1.9.10, 0 t t −λs e dF (s) = e−(λ−λ0 )s dG0 (s) (λ ∈ C , t ≥ 0). 0
0
Integration by parts (1.20), and Proposition 1.9.9, yield t t e−λs dF (s) = e−(λ−λ0 )t G0 (t) + (λ − λ0 ) e−(λ−λ0 )s G0 (s) ds. 0
0
(1.23)
1.10. LAPLACE-STIELTJES INTEGRALS
57
(λ0 ) exists, then G0 is bounded. Therefore, dF (λ) exists if Re λ > Re λ0 and If dF ∞ (λ) = (λ − λ0 ) dF e−(λ−λ0 )s G0 (s) ds (Re λ > Re λ0 ). (1.24) 0
(λ) exists if Re λ > abs(dF ) and, as for the Laplace integral This shows that dF (see (1.9)), t abs(dF ) = inf λ ∈ R : sup e−λs dF (s), x∗ < ∞ for all x∗ ∈ X ∗ . (1.25) t>0
0
Theorem 1.10.5. Let F ∈ BSVloc (R+ , X) and let F∞ := limt→∞ F (t) if the limit exists, F∞ := 0 otherwise. Then abs(dF ) = ω(F − F∞ ). t Proof. For λ0 > abs(dF ) define G0 (t) := 0 e−λ0 s dF (s) (t ≥ 0). Then G0 is bounded. To prove that abs(dF ) ≥ ω(F − F∞ ) one considers the two cases abs(dF ) ≥ 0 and abs(dF ) < 0. First, let abs(dF ) ≥ 0 and λ0 > abs(dF ). It follows from Proposition 1.9.10, integration by parts (1.20), and Proposition 1.9.9 that t t F (t) = F (0) + eλ0 s dG0 (s) = F (0) + eλ0 t G0 (t) − λ0 eλ0 s G0 (s) ds 0
0
−λ0 t
for all t ≥ 0, so supt≥0 e (F (t) − F∞ ) < ∞. Thus ω(F − F∞ ) ≤ abs(dF ) if abs(dF ) ≥ 0. Second, let abs(dF ) < 0. Choose abs(dF ) < λ0 < 0. For r ≥ t ≥ 0 one has r r λ0 s λ0 r λ0 t F (r) − F (t) = e dG0 (s) = e G0 (r) − e G0 (t) − λ0 eλ0 s G0 (s) ds. t
t
Thus,
lim F (r) = F∞ = F (t) − e
λ0 t
r→∞
∞
G0 (t) − λ0
eλ0 s G0 (s) ds
t
exists and supt≥0 e−λ0 t (F (t) − F∞ ) < ∞. Therefore, ω(F − F∞ ) ≤ abs(dF ) if abs(dF ) < 0. To show the reverse inequality let ω > ω(F − F∞ ). Then there exists M ≥ 0 such that F (t) − F∞ ≤ M eωt for all t ≥ 0. Let λ > ω > ω(F − F∞ ). Integration by parts (see (1.21)) yields t t e−λs dF (s) = e−λt (F (t) − F∞ ) + F∞ − F (0) + λ e−λs (F (s) − F∞ ) ds. 0
0
(λ) exists for λ > ω(F − F∞ ) and is given by Hence, dF ∞ (λ) = F∞ − F (0) + λ dF e−λs (F (s) − F∞ ) ds. 0
This shows that abs(dF ) ≤ ω(F − F∞ ). Note that (1.26) is a generalization of (1.22).
(1.26)
58
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
Theorem 1.10.6. Let F ∈ BSVloc (R+ , X) and assume that abs(dF ) < ∞. Then (λ) is holomorphic for Re λ > abs(dF ), and λ → dF ∞ (n) (λ) = dF e−λt (−t)n dF (t) (Re λ > abs(dF ), n ∈ N0 ) 0
(as an improper Riemann-Stieltjes integral). k Proof. Let qk (λ) := 0 e−λt dF (t). It follows from (1.18) that N λn k (−t)n dF (t). N→∞ n! 0 n=0
qk (λ) = lim
By the Weierstrass convergence theorem (a special case of Vitali’s Theorem A.5), qk is entire and k (j) qk (λ) = e−λt (−t)j dF (t) 0
for all j ∈ N0 . Let Re λ > λ0 > abs(dF ), and define t G0 (t) := e−λ0 s dF (s). 0
Then G0 is bounded and it follows from Proposition 1.9.10, (1.20) and Proposition 1.9.9 that ∞ dF (λ) − qk (λ) = e−(λ−λ0 )s dG0 (s) k ∞ = −e−(λ−λ0 )k G0 (k) + (λ − λ0 ) e−(λ−λ0 )s G0 (s) ds. k
uniformly on compact subsets of {λ : Re λ > abs(dF )}. Hence qk converges to dF is holomorphic and q(j) (λ) → Again by the Weiestrass convergence theorem, dF k (j) dF (λ) as k → ∞, if Re λ > abs(dF ). Finally in this section, we consider operator-valued Laplace-Stieltjes integrals. Let S : R+ → L(X, Y ) be a function. By the uniform boundedness principle, S ∈ BSVloc (R+ , L(X, Y )) if and only if vx := S(·)x ∈ BSV(R+ , Y ) for all x ∈ X. When S ∈ BSVloc (R+ , L(X, Y )), we let −ωt S(t) < ∞ , ω(S) := inf ω ∈ R : sup e abs(dS)
t≥0 t
e−λs dS(s) converges strongly as t → ∞
:=
inf Re λ :
=
sup{abs(dvx ) : x ∈ X}.
0
The following analogue of Proposition 1.4.5 follows from Theorems 1.10.5 and 1.10.6.
1.11. NOTES
59
Proposition 1.10.7. Let S ∈ BSVloc (R+ , L(X, Y )) and let S∞ be the strong limit of S(t) as t → ∞ if it exists, and S∞ := 0 otherwise. Then t a) limt→∞ 0 e−λs dS(s) exists in operator norm whenever Re λ > abs(dS), b) abs(dS) = ω(S − S∞ ). t Proof. If 0 e−λ0 s dS(s) converges strongly as t → ∞, then it is uniformly bounded in operator norm. Thus, a) follows from (1.23). Hence, t −λs abs(dS) = inf Re λ : e dS(s) converges in norm as t → ∞ 0
= ω(S − S∞ ), by Theorem 1.10.6, where S∞ is the norm limit of S(t) as t → ∞, if this exists, S∞ := 0 otherwise. It is trivial that ω(S − S∞ ) = ω(S − S∞ ), so b) is proved.
1.11 Notes Section 1.1 The Bochner integral is an extension of the Lebesgue integral to functions with values in Banach spaces. Introduced around 1930 by Bochner, it has become a widely used integral in infinite dimensional applications. Much of Section 1.1 follows the treatment of the Bochner integral in Chapter III of [HP57], where many references to the original literature can be found. Comprehensive treatments of the Bochner integral and vectorvalued measures, as well as references to the literature are contained in the monograph [DU77] by Diestel and Uhl. Corollary 1.1.3 is taken from [Are01]. One reason for introducing the Riemann integral here is that increasing functions with values in an ordered Banach space with normal cone are always Riemann integrable (Corollary 1.9.6). However, if the space is not separable, Riemann integrable functions are not necessarily Bochner integrable and their antiderivative may be nowhere differentiable. One way to circumvent these difficulties is to consider generalizations of the Riemann integral. This allows a version of the fundamental theorem of calculus where all continuous functions f : [0, 1] → X (where X is a Banach space) with f (0) = 0 are differentiable in the mean and coincide with the generalized Riemann integral of their derivatives (see [BLN99]). Section 1.2 The Radon-Nikodym property was identified in the 1970s as an important property in the theory of vector measures and also in the geometry of Banach spaces. Our treatment is based on [DU77]. Section 1.3 Most of the results are vector-valued versions of standard material. Proposition 1.3.7 is contained in [KH89]. Section 1.4 The Laplace transform has a long history, dating back to Euler’s paper ‘De constructione
60
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
aequationum’ from 1737, Lagrange’s ‘M´emoire sur l’utilit´e de la m´ethode de prendre le milieux entre les r´esultats de plusieurs observations’ from 1773, and Laplace’s ‘M´emoire sur les approximations des formules qui sont finctions de tr`es grands nombres’ from 1785. Since then it has been widely used in mathematics and engineering (in particular in ordinary differential, difference and functional equations, electrical engineering and applications to signal processing problems). Modern Laplace transform theory began to emerge at the end of the 19th century when Heaviside popularized a user-friendly and powerful operational calculus within the engineering community in connection with his research in electromagnetism [Hea93]. Since his methods were to a large degree based on purely formal operations with few mathematical justifications, many mathematicians at the beginning of the 20th century began to strive for a solid mathematical foundation of Heaviside’s operational calculus by virtue of the Laplace transform. These efforts culminated in Widder’s books ‘The Laplace Transform’ [Wid41] and ‘An Introduction to Transform Theory’ [Wid71] as well as Doetsch’s ‘Theorie und Anwendung der LaplaceTransformation’ [Doe37] and his monumental, three volumed ‘Handbuch der LaplaceTransformation’ [Doe50]. These monographs have been among the best introductions to the subject and have become classic texts. A first comprehensive look at Laplace transform theory for functions with values in a Banach space X is contained in Hille’s monograph ‘Functional Analysis and Semi-Groups’ from 1948 [Hil48]. Many historical notes on Laplace transform theory can be found in the books of Doetsch and in survey articles by Deakin [Dea81], [Dea82], and Martis in Biddau [Bid33]. One weakness of Laplace transform theory—compared to Heaviside’s operational calculus—are the restrictions concerning the growth of the functions at infinity. To remove these restrictions, Vignaux introduced in 1939 an asymptotic version of the Laplace transform [Vig39], [VC44]. For an extension of the asymptotic Laplace transform to vector-valued functions, and references to the literature, see [LN99] and [LN01]. The characterization of the abscissa of convergence by the exponential growth of the antiderivative are vector-valued versions of classical results due to Landau (1906) and Pincherle (1913) that can be found in [Doe50, Volume I,Theorems 2.2.7 and 2.2.8], or [HP57, Section 1.6.2]. Section 1.5 Theorem 1.5.1 is due to Pincherle and Landau (1905); Theorem 1.5.3 is due to Landau (1906). The proofs given here, as well as Example 1.5.2, follow [Doe50, Volume I, Sections 3.2–3.4] where further references to the classical literature can be found. Section 1.6 The results of this section are straightforward vector-valued versions of standard results in the classical theory of Laplace transforms (see [Doe50, Volume I, Sections 2.14, 2.15], for example). Section 1.7 Theorem 1.7.5 has been proved by Ti-Jun Xiao and Jin Liang [XL00], but a special case was given by Kurtz [Kur69] and the general result was mentioned by Chernoff [Che74, p.106]. In fact, the proof of [Che68, Proposition] carries over to the case considered in Theorem 1.7.5. The short proof given here appeared in [Bob97b] and [Are01]. The Inversion Theorem 1.7.7 is due to Post (1930) and Widder (1934) (see [Wid41, Section 7.6], and [Doe50, Volume I, Section 8.2]). Numerically more efficient Post-Widder type inversion formulas for the Laplace transform can be found in [Jar08, Theorem 4.1]
1.11. NOTES
61
and [JNO08]. They are derived from rational approximation methods for operator semigroups developed by Hersh and Kato [HK79] and Brenner and Thom´ee [BT79] (see also [Kov07]). The Uniqueness Theorem 1.7.3 was mentioned first by Pastor [Pas19] in 1919 and is a special case of the following result of Shen [She47] (see also [Doe50, Volume I, Section 2.9], [BN94], [Mih09]). Theorem 1.11.1. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) with abs(f ) < ∞. Let (λn ) be an infinite sequence with no accumulation point and Re λn ≥ a > 0 for all n ∈ N and some a > abs(f ). If λn − 1 = ∞, 1 − λn + 1 n=1 ∞
then (λn )n∈N is a uniqueness sequence; i.e., fˆ(λn ) = 0 (n ∈ N) implies that f = 0. Conversely, let (λn ) be a sequence with λn = 0 and | arg(λn )| ≤ θ < π/2 (n ∈ N). If (λn ) has no accumulation point and the sum above is finite, then there exists 0 = f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) with fˆ(λn ) = 0 for all n ∈ N. Consider the horizontal sequences λn := a + nγ b for a, b > 0. If 0 < γ ≤ 1 or γ < 0, then (λn ) is a uniqueness sequence. If γ > 1 or a = 0 and γ < −1, then {λn } is the set of zeros of a non-trivial Laplace transform. For example, if f (t) = √1t sin( 1t ), √ π −√2λ then fˆ(λ) = e sin( 2λ) which has zeros for λn = 2n2 π 2 (n ∈ N). The vertical λ sequences λn = 1 + inγ are uniqueness sequences if 0 < γ ≤ 12 . If γ > 12 , then {λn } is the set of zeros of a non-trivial Laplace transform. Uniqueness sequences are important in the discussion of Cauchy problems which are well-posed in the regularized sense (see [B¨ au01] or [LN99] for definitions and references). Section 1.8 For 1 ≤ p ≤ 2, a Banach space X is said to have Fourier type p if the Fourier transform on L1 (R, X) ∩Lp (R, X) extends to a bounded linear operator of Lp (R, X) into Lp (R, X), where 1/p + 1/p = 1. The Hausdorff-Young inequalities show that C has Fourier type for every p ∈ [1, 2]. Every Banach space has Fourier type 1, and a space with Fourier type p also has Fourier type q whenever 1 ≤ q ≤ p. Theorem 1.8.2 shows that Hilbert spaces have Fourier type 2, and conversely Kwapie´ n [Kwa72] showed that a space with Fourier type 2 is isomorphic to a Hilbert space. A space of the form Lp (Ω, μ), where 1 ≤ p < ∞ and (Ω, μ) is any measure space, has Fourier type min(p, p ). The spaces with non-trivial Fourier type (i.e., Fourier type p for some p > 1) have been characterized by Bourgain [Bou82], [Bou88] (see also [Pis86]). Every superreflexive space (a Banach space with an equivalent uniformly convex norm) has non-trivial Fourier type, but there exist reflexive spaces which do not have non-trivial Fourier type and there exist non-reflexive spaces which do have non-trivial Fourier type. A Banach space X is said to have the analytic Radon-Nikodym property (ARNP) if each function g ∈ H 2 (R, X) has a boundary function, i.e. limα↓0 g(α + is) exists s-a.e. This property was first considered by Bukhvalov [Buk81], [BD82] using functions on the unit disc rather than C+ , and H p -spaces for p = 2, but this formulation is equivalent. Thus, Theorem 1.8.3 shows in particular that Hilbert spaces have the (ARNP). Every reflexive space has the (ARNP), and more generally, any space with the Radon-Nikodym property, and also any space of the form L1 (Ω, μ), has the (ARNP). On the other hand,
62
1. THE LAPLACE INTEGRAL
c0 does not have the (ARNP), and there exist spaces with non-trivial Fourier type which do not have the (ARNP) (see [HN99]). Section 1.9 This section contains some of the basic properties of the Riemann-Stieltjes integral; see [HP57] and [Wid41] for further details and references to the original literature. Section 1.10 In the classical Laplace transform literature, many authors preferred Laplace-Stieltjes ∞ ∞ integrals 0 e−λt dF (t) since they include Laplace integrals 0 e−λt f (t) dt (when F is ∞ −λti differentiable a.e.) and Dirichlet series (when F is a step function). The i=1 ai e importance of the Laplace-Stieltjes integral for our purposes is that many classical results for Laplace-Stieltjes integrals of complex-valued functions F can be extended to functions with values in arbitrary Banach spaces X, whereas vector-valued extensions of the corresponding Laplace transform results often require additional assumptions on X (see, for example, [Zai60]). All results of this section are vector-valued versions of classical results for Laplace-Stieltjes transforms in [Wid41] or [Wid71].
Chapter 2
The Laplace Transform In this chapter the emphasis of the discussion shifts from Laplace integrals fˆ(λ) and (λ) to the Laplace transform L : f → fˆ and to the Laplace-Stieltjes transform dF . The Laplace transform is considered first as an operator acting on LS : F → dF L∞ (R+ , X) and the Laplace-Stieltjes transform as an operator on Lip0 (R+ , X) := F : R+ → X : F (0) = 0, F Lip0 (R+ ,X) :=
F (t) − F (s)
sup <∞ . |t − s| t,s≥0 These domains of L and LS are relatively easy to deal with and have immediate and important applications to abstract differential and integral equations. The following observation is the key to one of the basic structures of Laplace t transform theory. If f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X), then t → F (t) := 0 f (s) ds belongs to Lip0 (R+ , X) and ∞ ∞ L(f )(λ) = e−λt f (t) dt = e−λt dF (t) = TF (e−λ ), ∞
0
0
where TF : g → 0 g(s)dF (s) is a bounded linear operator from L1 (R+ ) into X, and where e−λ denotes the exponential function t → e−λt . The operator TF is fundamental to Laplace transform theory. In Section 2.1 it is shown that ΦS : F → TF is an isometric isomorphism between Lip0 (R+ , X) and L(L1 (R+ ), X) (Riesz-Stieltjes representation theorem). This representation is crucial for the following reason. The main purpose of Laplace transform theory is to translate properties of the generating function F into properties of the resulting ∞ function λ → ∞ r(λ) = 0 e−λt dF (t) and vice versa. Since F (t) = TF χ[0,t] = 0 χ[0,t] (s) dF (s) ∞ and r(λ) = TF e−λ = 0 e−λs dF (s), the generating function F as well as the resulting function r are evaluations of the same bounded linear operator acting on different total subsets of L1 (R+ ).
W. Arendt et al., Vector-valued Laplace Transforms and Cauchy Problems: Second Edition, Monographs in Mathematics 96, DOI 10.1007/978-3-0348-0087-7_2, © Springer Basel AG 2011
63
64
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
In Section 2.2, the range of the Laplace-Stieltjes transform acting on Lip0 (R+ , X) is characterized. It is shown that a function r : R+ → X has a Laplace-Stieltjes representation r = LS (F ) for some F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X) if and only if r is a C ∞ -function whose Taylor coefficients satisfy the estimate λn+1 (n)
r (λ) < ∞. n∈N0 λ>0 n!
r W := sup sup
(2.1)
This can be rephrased by saying that the Laplace-Stieltjes transform is an isometric isomorphism between the Banach spaces Lip0 (R+ , X) and ∞ CW ((0, ∞), X) := {r ∈ C ∞ ((0, ∞), X) : r W < ∞}.
If the Banach space X has the Radon-Nikodym property (see Section 1.2), then (and only then) “Widder’s growth conditions” (2.1) are necessary and sufficient for r to have a Laplace representation r = L(f ) for some f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X); i.e., Banach spaces with the Radon-Nikodym property are precisely those Banach spaces in which the Laplace transform is an isometric isomorphism between L∞ (R+ , X) and ∞ CW ((0, ∞), X). For X = C, this is a classical result usually known as “Widder’s Theorem”. If r = LS (F ) for some F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X), then the inverse Laplace-Stieltjes transform has many different representations. A few of them, such as F (t)
∞ r(λ) dλ = lim (−1)j+1 etnj r(nj) n→∞ λ Γ j=1 k+1 k k d r(λ) k 1 = lim (−1) , k→∞ k! t dtk λ λ=k/t
=
1 2πi
eλt
will be proved in Section 2.3. In Section 2.4, the results of the previous sections are extended to functions with exponential growth at infinity; i.e., we investigate the Laplace transform acting on functions f with ess supt≥0 e−ωt f (t) < ∞. In applications it is usually impossible to verify whether or not a given function r satisfies Widder’s growth conditions (2.1). Thus, in Sections 2.5 and 2.6 some complex growth conditions are discussed which are necessary (and in a certain sense sufficient) for a holomorphic function r : {Re λ > ω} → X to have a Laplace representation. In Section 2.5, the growth condition considered is supRe λ>ω λ1+b r(λ) < ∞ for some b > 0. In Section 2.6, we discuss functions r which are holomorphic in a sector Σ := {| arg(λ)| < π2 + ε} and satisfy supλ∈Σ λr(λ) < ∞. We will see that any such r is the Laplace transform of a function which is holomorphic in the sector {| arg(λ)| < ε}. The final class of functions which we will consider are the completely monotonic ones; i.e., C ∞ -functions r with values in an ordered Banach space such that (−1)n r (n) (λ) ≥ 0 for all n ∈ N0 and λ > ω. In the scalar case,
2.1. RIESZ-STIELTJES REPRESENTATION
65
Bernstein’s theorem states that a function r is completely monotonic if and only if it is the Laplace-Stieltjes transform of an increasing function. In Section 2.7 we investigate for which ordered Banach spaces Bernstein’s theorem holds.
2.1
Riesz-Stieltjes Representation
In the following sections the emphasis will be on the properties of the Laplace . As is transform L : f → fˆ and the Laplace-Stieltjes transform LS : F → dF the case with all linear operators, the choice of the domain is crucial. For the Laplace-Stieltjes transform LS the most convenient choice of the domain space is Lip0 (R+ , X) := F : R+ → X : F (0) = 0, F Lip0 (R+ ,X) :=
F (t) − F (s)
sup <∞ . |t − s| t,s≥0 If F (t) =
t 0
f (s) ds for f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X), then F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X) and
∞
−λt
e 0
∞
dF (t) =
e−λt f (t) dt
(λ > 0),
0
by Proposition 1.10.1. Thus, any result for LS acting on Lip0 (R+ , X) translates into one for L acting on L∞ (R+ , X). However, since there are Banach spaces in which not every Lipschitz continuous function is the antiderivative of an L∞ function (see Section 1.2), the Laplace-Stieltjes transform is a true generalization of the Laplace transform. It is the generalization needed to deal effectively with Laplace transforms of vector-valued functions. In this section we investigate the Riesz-Stieltjes operator ΦS which assigns to F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X) a bounded linear operator TF : L1 (R+ ) → X such that ∞ τ TF f := f (s) dF (s) := lim f (s) dF (s), 0
τ →∞
0
1
when f ∈ L (R+ ) is continuous. It will be shown that ΦS is an isometric isomorphism between Lip0 (R+ , X) and L(L1 (R+ ), X), the space of all bounded linear operators from the Banach space L1 (R+ ) into X (Riesz-Stieltjes representation). This observation is fundamental for the whole chapter. To see why the RieszStieltjes representation is such an important tool, observe that (λ) = TF e−λ (λ > 0). F (t) = TF χ[0,t] (t ≥ 0) , and dF Thus, if one knows F , then the operator TF is specified on the set of characteristic functions χ[0,t] (t > 0), which is total in L1 (R+ ). Therefore, TF and, in partic (λ) (λ > 0) are completely determined. ular, the Laplace integrals TF e−λ = dF
66
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
(λ) determine TF on the set of exponential Conversely, the Laplace integrals dF functions e−λ (λ > 0), which is also total in L1 (R+ ) (Lemma 1.7.1). Hence, the (λ) determine the properties of TF and, in particular, the Laplace integrals dF properties of F (t) = TF χ[0,t] (t ≥ 0). Theorem 2.1.1 (Riesz-Stieltjes Representation). There exists a unique isometric isomorphism ΦS : F → TF from Lip0 (R+ , X) onto L(L1 (R+ ), X) such that TF χ[0,t] = F (t)
(2.2)
for all t ≥ 0 and F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X). Moreover, TF g = lim
t→∞
t
∞
g(s) dF (s) := 0
g(s) dF (s)
(2.3)
0
for all continuous functions g ∈ L1 (R+ ). Note that it is part of the claim that the improper integral in (2.3) converges. We shall call the isomorphism ΦS the Riesz-Stieltjes operator. Proof. Let D := span{χ[0,t) : t > 0}, the space of step functions, which is dense in L1 (R+ ). For each f ∈ D there exists a unique representation f=
n
αi χ[ti−1 ,ti ) ,
i=1
where 0 = t0 < t1 < . . . < tn , αi ∈ C (i = 1, . . . , n). Let F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X). Define TF : D → X by n n TF (f ) = TF αi χ[ti−1 ,ti ) := αi (F (ti ) − F (ti−1 )). i=1
i=1
Then,
TF (f ) ≤ F Lip0 (R+ ,X)
n
|αi |(ti − ti−1 ) = F Lip0 (R+ ,X) f 1 .
i=1
Hence, TF has a unique extension TF ∈ L(L1 (R+ ), X). Moreover,
TF ≤ F Lip0 (R+ ,X) . Conversely, if T ∈ L(L1 (R+ ), X), let F (t) := T χ[0,t) for t ≥ 0. Then for t > s ≥ 0,
F (t) − F (s) = T χ[s,t) ≤ T χ[s,t) 1 = T (t − s).
2.1. RIESZ-STIELTJES REPRESENTATION
67
Thus, F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X) and F Lip0 (R+ ,X) ≤ T . It follows from the definitions that T = TF and if T = TG then F = G. This shows that F → TF is an isometric isomorphism. Finally, let g ∈ L1 (R+ ) be a continuous function and let F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X). Take t > 0, and let π be a partition of [0, t] with partitioning points 0 = t0 < t1 < . . . < tn = t and intermediate points si ∈ [ti−1 , ti ]. Let fπ :=
n
g(si )χ[ti−1 ,ti ) .
i=1
Thus, S(g, F, π) = TF (fπ ). As |π| → 0, fπ − gχ[0,t) 1 → 0, so
t
0
g(s) dF (s) = TF (gχ[0,t) ).
As t → ∞, gχ[0,t) − g 1 → 0, so
∞ 0
g(s) dF (s) = TF (g).
We conclude this section by discussing convergence of functions and their Laplace-Stieltjes transforms. In fact, the Laplace-Stieltjes transform allows us to give a purely operator-theoretic proof of the following approximation theorem. Note, however, that the essential implication (i) ⇒ (iv) can also be obtained with the help of Theorem 1.7.5 (which may easily be strengthened by merely considering convergence on a sequence of equidistant points). Theorem 2.1.2. Let M > 0, Fn ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X) with Fn Lip0 (R+ ,X) ≤ M for all n ∈ N, and rn = LS (Fn ). The following are equivalent: (i) There exist a, b > 0 such that limn→∞ rn (a + kb) exists for all k ∈ N0 . (ii) There exists r ∈ C ∞ ((0, ∞), X) such that rn → r uniformly on compact subsets of (0, ∞). (iii) limn→∞ Fn (t) exists for all t ≥ 0. (iv) There exists F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X) such that Fn → F uniformly on compact subsets of R+ . Moreover, if r and F are as in (ii) and (iv), then r = LS (F ). Proof. By the Riesz-Stieltjes Representation Theorem 2.1.1, there exist Tn ∈ L(L1 (R+ ), X) such that Tn = Fn Lip0 (R+ ,X) ≤ M, Tn e−λ = rn (λ), and Tn χ[0,t] = Fn (t) (n ∈ N, t ≥ 0, λ > 0). Each of the statements imply that the uniformly bounded family of operators Tn converges on a total subset of L1 (R+ )
68
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
(see also Lemma 1.7.1). By equicontinuity (see Proposition B.15), for any uniformly bounded sequence of operators, the topology of simple convergence on a total subset equals the topology of simple convergence and the topology of uniform convergence on compact subsets. Thus there exists T ∈ L(L1 (R+ ), X) such that Tn g → T g as n → ∞ for all g ∈ L1 (R+ ) (simple convergence). For all b > 0 the sets Kb := {χ[0,t] : 0 ≤ t ≤ b} and Eb := {e−λ : 1b ≤ λ ≤ b} are compact in L1 (R+ ) (continuous images of compact sets are compact). Hence, Tn → T uniformly on Kb and Eb (uniform convergence on compact subsets). Now the statements follow from the Riesz-Stieltjes representation.
2.2
A Real Representation Theorem
acting In this section the range of the Laplace-Stieltjes transform LS : F → dF on Lip0 (R+ , X) will be characterized. Since λ → dF (λ) = λF (λ) is holomorphic and, by Proposition 1.7.2, functions like λ → (sin λ)x (x ∈ X) cannot be in the range of LS , the range must be a proper subset of C ∞ ((0, ∞), X). The following observations will lead to a complete description of the range. Let F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X) and TF := ΦS (F ), where ΦS is the Riesz-Stieltjes operator of Section 2.1. Define ∞ (λ) = r(λ) := dF e−λt dF (t) (λ > 0). 0
Then, by Theorem 1.10.6, r ∈ C ∞ ((0, ∞), X) and ∞ (n) r (λ) = e−λt (−t)n dF (t) = TF kn,λ , 0
where kn,λ (t) := e−λt (−t)n (t ≥ 0, λ > 0, n ∈ N0 ). Since kn,λ 1 = = n!/λn+1 and TF = F Lip0 (R+ ,X) , it follows that
∞ 0
e−λt tn dt
r(n) (λ) ≤ F Lip0 (R+ ,X) n!/λn+1 for all n ∈ N0 and λ > 0. Thus, r is a C ∞ -function whose Taylor coefficients satisfy
r W :=
sup λ>0,k∈N0
λk+1 (k)
r (λ) ≤ F Lip0 (R+ ,X) . k!
maps Lip (R+ , X) This shows that the Laplace-Stieltjes transform LS : F → dF 0 into the space ∞ CW ((0, ∞), X) := {r ∈ C ∞ ((0, ∞), X) : r W < ∞}.
In 1936, Widder showed that the Laplace transform maps L∞ (R+ , R) onto ∞ CW ((0, ∞), R). The following result is the vector-valued version of Widder’s classical theorem.
2.2. A REAL REPRESENTATION THEOREM
69
Theorem 2.2.1 (Real Representation Theorem). The Laplace-Stieltjes transform ∞ LS is an isometric isomorphism between Lip0 (R+ , X) and CW ((0, ∞), X). ∞ Proof. We have already shown that LS maps Lip0 (R+ , X) into CW ((0, ∞), X) and = 0 for some F ∈ Lip (R+ , X), that LS (F ) W ≤ F Lip0 (R+ ,X) . If LS (F ) = dF 0 ∞ (λ) = 0 for all λ > 0. Since the exponential then TF e−λ = 0 e−λt dF (t) = dF functions e−λ (λ > 0) are total in L1 (R+ ) (Lemma 1.7.1), it follows that TF = 0. In particular, TF χ[0,t] = F (t) = 0 for all t ≥ 0. Thus, LS is one-to-one. ∞ The hard part of the proof is to show that LS is onto. Let r ∈ CW ((0, ∞), X). 1 Define Tk ∈ L(L (R+ ), X) by k+1 ∞ 1 k k Tk f := f (t)(−1)k r(k) dt (k ∈ N0 ). k! t t 0
The operators Tk are uniformly bounded by r W since Tk f ≤ r W f 1 for all f ∈ L1 (R+ ). We will show below that Tk e−λ → r(λ) as k → ∞ for all λ > 0. Since the exponential functions e−λ (λ > 0) are total in L1 (R+ ) it then follows from Proposition B.15 that there exists T ∈ L(L1 (R+ ), X) with T ≤ r W such that Tk f → T f for all f ∈ L1 (R+ ). In particular, r(λ) = lim Tk e−λ = T e−λ . k→∞
The Riesz-Stieltjes Representation Theorem 2.1.1 then yields the existence ∞ of some F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X) with F Lip0 (R+ ,X) = T ≤ r W such that T g = 0 g(t) dF (t) for all continuous functions g ∈ L1 (R+ ). Hence, for all λ > 0, ∞ (λ). r(λ) = T e−λ = e−λt dF (t) = dF 0
W = F Lip (R ,X) for F ∈ Lip (R+ , X). Thus, LS is onto and LS (F ) W = dF 0 + 0 It remains to be shown that Tk e−λ → r(λ) as k → ∞ for all λ > 0. Observe that k+1 ∞ k k −λt k 1 (k) Tk e−λ = e (−1) r dt k! t t 0 ∞ 1 = (−1)k e−λk/u uk−1 r(k) (u) du (k − 1)! 0 ∞ % k−1 j 1 k j d −λk/u k−1 (k−j−1) = (−1) (−1) e u r (u) (k − 1)! j=0 duj u=0 & ∞ k d +(−1)k e−λk/u uk−1 r(u) du . k 0 du ! "k−1 To discuss the derivatives of u → e−λk/u uk−1 , define G(x, u) := e−x/u ux . Then G(sx, su) = G(x, u) for all s > 0. Differentiating both sides of the last
70
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
∂G equality with respect to s and then setting s = 1 yields x ∂G ∂x (x, u)+u ∂u (x, u) = 0 1 ∂G 1 ∂G or x ∂u (x, u) = − u ∂x (x, u). This implies that k−1 k−2 ∂ ∂ −x/u u −x/u u e =− e . ∂u xk ∂x xk−1
By induction on j, it follows that k−1 j k−j−1 ∂j −x/u u j ∂ −x/u u e = (−1) e ∂uj xk ∂xj xk−j or
(0 ≤ j ≤ k),
−x/u j ∂ j −x/u k−1 e j k k−j−1 ∂ e u = (−1) x u . ∂uj ∂xj xk−j
Hence, h(u)
:=
k−1
(−1)j
j=0
=
k−1
∂ j −x/u k−1 (k−j−1) e u r (u) ∂uj
∂j x ∂xj j=0 k
e−x/u xk−j
Since
uk−j−1 r (k−j−1) (u) ≤
uk−j−1 r (k−j−1) (u).
r W (k − j − 1)! , u
one obtains that
h(u) ≤
k−1 j=0
−x/u
r W (k − j − 1)! k ∂ j e . x j k−j u ∂x x
It follows that limu→∞ h(u) = 0 = limu→0 h(u). Therefore, letting x = λk, ∞ k 1 d −λk/u k−1 Tk e−λ = e u r(u) du. (k − 1)! 0 duk Since by (2.4), k k ∂ k −x/u k−1 xk −x/u kx ∂ −x/u e u = (−1) e = e , ∂uk u ∂xk uk+1 it follows that Tk e−λ
= =
∞ λk k k 1 e−λk/u k+1 r(u) du (k − 1)! 0 u λk k k+1 ∞ −λkt k−1 1 e t r dt. k! t 0
(2.4)
2.2. A REAL REPRESENTATION THEOREM
71
Define f (t) := 1t r( 1t ) and s := λ1 . Then Tk e−λ
k+1 ∞ k e−kt/s tk f (t) dt s 0 k+1 1 k k k (k) ˆ = s(−1) f . k! s s =
s k!
Finally, one concludes from the Post-Widder Inversion Theorem 1.7.7 that 1 lim Tk e−λ = sf (s) = r = r(λ) k→∞ s for all λ > 0. For later use in Section 2.5, we observe that in the Widder conditions it is not necessary to consider all values of k. Proposition 2.2.2. Let r ∈ C ∞ ((0, ∞), X), and suppose that limλ→∞ r(λ) = 0 and m+1 there exist M > 0 and infinitely many integers m such that supλ>0 λ m! r (m) (λ)
∞ ≤ M . Then r ∈ CW ((0, ∞), X) and r W ≤ M . Proof. It suffices to show that if r(m) (λ) ≤ M m!/λm+1 , for all λ > 0, then
r(k) (λ) ≤ M k!/λk+1 for all λ > 0 and 0 ≤ k < m. Let ∞ (−1)m r˜(λ) := (λ − μ)m−1 r(m) (μ) dμ. (m − 1)! λ Note that the integral is absolutely convergent, r˜(m) (λ) = r (m) (λ), and the substitution t = λ/μ gives
˜ r(λ) ≤ M m
∞
λ
(μ − λ)m−1 Mm dμ = μm+1 λ
0
1
(1 − t)m−1 dt =
M . λ
Hence r − r˜ is a polynomial and limλ→∞ (r − r˜)(λ) = 0, so r = r˜. It follows that
∞
(−1)m
(k) m−k−1 (m)
r (λ) = (λ − μ) r (μ) dμ
(m − k − 1)! λ ∞ M m! (μ − λ)m−k−1 ≤ dμ (m − k − 1)! λ μm+1 M k! = λk+1 for λ > 0 and 0 ≤ k < m. Now it will be shown that the Laplace transform is an isometric isomorphism ∞ between L∞ (R+ , X) and CW ((0, ∞), X) if and only if the Banach space X has the
72
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
Radon-Nikodym property. Recall from Section 1.2 that X has the Radon-Nikodym property if every F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X) is differentiable a.e., or equivalently if every absolutely continuous function F : R+ → X is differentiable a.e. As shown in Theorem 1.2.6 and Corollary 1.2.7, every separable dual space (for example, l1 ) and every reflexive Banach space have the Radon-Nikodym property. However, L1 (R+ ) and c0 do not have the property (Propositions 1.2.9 and 1.2.10). Theorem 2.2.3. Let X be a Banach space. The following are equivalent: (i) X has the Radon-Nikodym property. (ii) The Laplace transform L : f → fˆ is an isometric isomorphism between ∞ L∞ (R+ , X) and CW ((0, ∞), X). ∞ (iii) The Riesz operator Φ : f → Rf , Rf g := 0 g(t)f (t) dt is an isometric isomorphism between L∞ (R+ , X) and L(L1 (R+ ), X). Proof. Define the normalized antiderivative I : L∞ (R+ , X) → Lip0 (R+ , X) by t I(f ) := F , F (t) := 0 f (s) ds (t ≥ 0). Then I is one-to-one and I(f ) Lip0 (R+ ,X) ≤
f ∞ for all f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X). If I is onto, then X has the Radon-Nikodym property (see Proposition 1.2.2). Conversely, if X has the Radon-Nikodym property and F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X) then f (t) := F (t) exists for almost all t ≥ 0. Since f (t) = (t) limh→0 F (t+h)−F a.e., one concludes that f ∞ ≤ F Lip0 (R+ ,X) . In particular, h ∞ f ∈ L (R+ , X) and by Proposition 1.2.3, F = I(f ). Thus X has the RadonNikodym property if and only if I is an isometric isomorphism. ∞ The Riesz-Stieltjes operator ΦS : F → TF , where TF g = 0 g(t) dF (t) for 1 all continuous g ∈ L (R+ ), is an isometric isomorphism between Lip0 (R+ , X) and L(L1 (R+ ), X), and the Laplace-Stieltjes transform ∞ , dF (λ) = LS : F → dF e−λt dF (t), 0
∞ is an isometric isomorphism between Lip0 (R+ , X) and CW ((0, ∞), X). When F = ∞ 1 I(f ), TF g = 0 g(t)f (t) dt for all g ∈ L (R+ ), by Proposition 1.9.11 and continuity in L1 -norm. Now the statements follow from the fact that Φ = ΦS ◦ I and L = LS ◦ I on L∞ (R+ , X).
Example 2.2.4. a) Consider X = L1 (R+ ). Let F (t) := χ[0,t] (t ≥ 0) and r(λ) := e−λ (Re λ > 0), where e−λ (t) = e−λt . Then F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , L1 (R+ )) and ∞ (λ). r(λ) = e−λt dF (t) = dF 0
Since F is nowhere differentiable (see Proposition 1.2.10), there does not exist f ∈ L∞ (R+ , L1 (R+ )) such that ∞ r(λ) = e−λt f (t) dt. 0
2.3. REAL AND COMPLEX INVERSION
73
b) Consider C0 (R+ ) as a subspace of L∞ (R+ ). Define F : R+ → C0 (R+ ) by F (t)(s) := (t − s)χ[0,t] (s), and f : R+ → L∞ (R+ ) by f (t) := χ[0,t] . Then F ∈ t Lip0 (R+ , C0 (R+ )) and F (t) = 0 f (s) ds as a Riemann integral in L∞ (R+ ), but F is nowhere differentiable and f is not measurable (see Examples 1.2.8 and 1.9.7). Moreover, ∞ ∞ 1 e−λ = e−λt dF (t) = e−λt f (t) dt λ 0 0 as (improper) Riemann-Stieltjes and Riemann integrals, but λ → λ1 e−λ is not the Laplace transform of any function in L1 (R+ , L∞ (R+ )).
2.3
Real and Complex Inversion
We have shown in Section 2.2 that the Laplace-Stieltjes transform LS is an iso∞ metric isomorphism between Lip0 (R+ , X) and CW ((0, ∞), X). In this section we will derive several representations of the inverse Laplace-Stieltjes transform L−1 S . Theorem 2.3.1 (Post-Widder Inversion). Let F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X), r = LS (F ), and t > 0. Then k+1 k k d r(λ) k 1 F (t) = lim (−1) . k→∞ k! t dλk λ λ=k/t Proof. Since ω(F ) ≤ 0 and F (0) = 0, it follows from (1.22) that ∞ r(λ) = e−λt F (t) dt λ 0 for all λ > 0, where the integral is an absolutely convergent Bochner integral. Now the statement follows from Theorem 1.7.7. k k (k) Applying Leibniz’s rule (f · r) = j=0 f (k−j) r (j) to f (λ) := λ1 and j r one can rewrite the Post-Widder inversion of the Laplace-Stieltjes transform as j k 1 k k F (t) = lim (−1)j r (j) (t > 0). (2.5) k→∞ j! t t j=0 Compared to the Post-Widder inversion, it is remarkable that in the following Phragm´en-Doetsch inversion formula only the values r(k) for large k ∈ N are needed and that the convergence is uniform for all t ≥ 0. Theorem 2.3.2 (Phragm´en-Doetsch Inversion). Let F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X) and r = LS (F ). Then
∞ j+1
(−1) tkj
F (t) −
≤ c r W e r(kj)
k j!
j=1 for all t ≥ 0 and k ∈ N, where c ≈ 1.0159..., and r W = F Lip0 (R+ ,X) .
74
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
Proof. By the Riesz-Stieltjes Representation Theorem 2.1.1 and the Real Representation Theorem 2.2.1, there exists T ∈ L(L1 (R+ ), X) such that r(λ) = ∞ −λt e dF (t) = T e−λ (λ > 0), T χ[0,t] = F (t) (t ≥ 0) and T = r W = 0
F Lip0 (R+ ,X) . Thus,
∞ ∞ j+1
(−1) tkj j+1 1 tkj
F (t) −
≤ T χ[0,t] −
e r(kj) (−1) e e −kj .
j! j!
j=1 j=1 Define pk,t (s) := 1 − e−e
k(t−s)
χ[0,t] − pk,t 1
= =
1
∞
=
j+1 1 tkj e e−kj (s). j=1 (−1) j!
t
Then,
∞
|pk,t (s) − 1| ds + |pk,t (s)| ds 0 t t ∞ k(t−s) k(t−s) e−e ds + 1 − e−e ds 0
=
1 k
≤
1 k
t
ekt
e
1
∞ 1
1 1 1 − e−u du + du u k 0 u 1 e−u 1 − e−u du + du u u 0 −u
∞ for all t ≥ 0 and k ∈ N. Now the claim follows from the fact that 1 u1 e−u du + 1 1−e−u du = −2 Ei(−1) + γ ≈ 1.0159..., where Ei(z) is the exponential integral u 0 and γ is Euler’s constant (see [Leb72, Section 3.1]). The following corollary shows that the Phragm´en-Doetsch inversion is invariant under exponentially decaying perturbations for small values of t. Corollary 2.3.3. Let F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X), r = LS (F ), and q(λ) = r(λ)+a(λ) (λ > 0), where a : (0, ∞) → X is a function such that lim supn→∞ n1 log a(n) ≤ −T for some T > 0. Then ∞ (−1)j+1 tkj F (t) = lim e q(kj) k→∞ j! j=1 for all 0 ≤ t < T . Proof. Let 0 < T0 < T and choose k0 such that a(k) ≤ e−T0 k for all k ≥ k0 . Then,
∞
(−1)j+1 tkj
F (t) − e q(kj)
j! j=1
∞
∞
(−1)j+1 tkj
(−1)j+1 tkj
+
≤ F (t) − e r(kj) e a(kj)
j! j! j=1 j=1 ∞
≤
1 −(T0 −t)k 2 2
r W + etkj e−T0 kj ≤ r W + ee − 1. k j! k j=1
2.3. REAL AND COMPLEX INVERSION
75
The Post-Widder inversion and the Phragm´en-Doetsch inversion are called real inversions of the Laplace-Stieltjes transform since they use only properties of r(λ) for large real λ. For the following complex inversion formula we use the ∞ fact that if r(λ) = 0 e−λt dF (t) (λ > 0) for some F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X), then r admits a holomorphic extension for Re λ > 0 which we denote by the same symbol (see Theorem 1.10.6). We shall give here a proof based on the Riesz-Stieltjes representation, but we shall give another, rather simple, proof in Section 4.2. Theorem 2.3.4 (Complex Inversion). Let F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X) and r = LS (F ). Then c+ik 1 r(λ) F (t) = lim eλt dλ, k→∞ 2πi c−ik λ where the limit is uniform for t ∈ [0, a] for any a > 0, and c > 0 is arbitrary. Proof. By the Riesz-Stieltjes Representation Theorem 2.1.1, there exists T ∈ L(L1 (R+ ), X) such that r(λ) = T e−λ (Re λ > 0) and F (t) = T χ[0,t] (t ≥ 0). Thus,
c+ik c+ik
1 1
λt r(λ) λt e−λ e dλ ≤ T χ[0,t] − e dλ .
F (t) −
2πi c−ik λ 2πi c−ik λ 1
Now the statement follows from the next lemma. Lemma 2.3.5. Let t ≥ 0 and a, c > 0. Then the functions c+ik 1 e−λ hk,t := eλt dλ 2πi c−ik λ converge towards χ[0,t] in L1 (R+ ) as n → ∞, uniformly for t ∈ [0, a]. t Proof. Let hk,t − χ[0,t] 1 = Ak + Bk , where Ak := 0 |hk,t (s) − 1| ds and Bk := ∞ |hk,t (s)| ds. We show first that limk→∞ Ak = 0. The residue of the function t λ → eλ(t−s) /λ at the point 0 is 1. By Cauchy’s theorem, λ(t−s) 1 e hk,t (s) − 1 = − − dλ, 2πi λ Γ+ Γ− Γ0 where Γ± := {λ : λ = u ± ik; 0 ≤ u ≤ c}, Γ0 := {λ : λ = keiu ; π/2 ≤ u ≤ 3π/2}. Along Γ+ , and similarly along Γ− , it follows from 0 ≤ s ≤ t that c e(u+ik)(t−s) eλ(t−s) ec(t−s) dλ = du ≤ c . Γ+ λ u + ik k 0 Along Γ0 , for 0 ≤ s < t, 3π/2 3π/2 λ(t−s) iu e k(t−s)e = dλ e du ek(t−s) cos u du. ≤ λ Γ0 π/2 π/2
76
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
Hence, Ak
=
t
|hk,t (t − s) − 1| ds t cs 3π/2 ce 1 + eks cos u du ds πk 2π π/2 0 0
≤
→ 0 as k → ∞, uniformly for t ∈ [0, a] for all a > 0, by the monotone convergence theorem, or by explicit estimation. ± := {λ : λ = u ± ik ; c ≤ u ≤ k}, Γ 0 := In order estimate Bk , we define Γ √ to iu {λ : λ = k 2e ; −π/4 ≤ u ≤ π/4}. By Cauchy’s theorem, 1 hk,t (s) = 2πi
−
+ Γ
+
− Γ
+
0 Γ
eλ(t−s) dλ. λ
+ , and similarly along Γ − , it follows from s − t ≥ 0 that Along Γ eλ(t−s) dλ Γ+ λ
k e(u+ik)(t−s) 1 k = du ≤ e−u(s−t) du c k c u + ik =
e−c(s−t) − e−k(s−t) . k(s − t)
0, Along Γ eλ(t−s) dλ λ Γ0
π/4 √ π/4 √ iu = ek 2(t−s)e du ≤ ek 2(t−s) cos u du −π/4 −π/4 π/4 √ π √ π = 2 ek 2(t−s) cos(u) du ≤ ek 2(t−s) cos(π/4) = e−k(s−t) . 2 2 0
Hence, for all t ≥ 0,
∞
|hk,t (s)| ds ≤
t
=
1 ∞ e−c(s−t) − e−k(s−t) 1 ∞ −k(s−t) ds + e ds π t k(s − t) 4 t ∞ 1 1 zk (s) ds + , π 0 4k
1 where zk (s) := ks (e−cs − e−ks ) ≤ e−cs for k ≥ c by the mean value theorem −x applied to e over [cs, ks]. By the dominated convergence theorem, or by explicit estimation, Bk → 0 as k → ∞, uniformly for t ∈ [0, a] for all a > 0.
2.4. TRANSFORMS OF EXPONENTIALLY BOUNDED FUNCTIONS
2.4
77
Transforms of Exponentially Bounded Functions
So far in this chapter, Laplace transforms have been considered for bounded or globally Lipschitz continuous functions. We shall now adapt the results of the previous sections to functions with exponential growth at infinity, by an elementary “shifting” procedure (see Proposition 1.6.1 a) and Proposition 1.10.3). More precisely, for ω ∈ R we consider the Laplace-Stieltjes transform acting on Lipω (R+ , X) := G : R+ → X : G(0) = 0,
G(t) − G(s)
G Lipω (R+ ,X) := sup <∞ t t>s≥0 eωr dr s and the Laplace transform acting on ∞ 1 −ωt Lω (R+ , X) := g ∈ Lloc (R+ , X) : g ω,∞ := ess sup e g(t) < ∞ . t≥0
It is easy to see that
G Lipω (R+ ,X)
⎧
G(t) − G(s)
⎪ ⎪ ⎨sup0≤s
G(t) − G(s)
⎪ ⎪ ⎩sup0≤s
if ω ≥ 0, if ω ≤ 0.
It is clear that the multiplication operator Mω : g → e−ω· g(·) is an isometric ∞ isomorphism between L∞ ω (R+ , X) and L (R+ , X), and we now set up the corresponding isomorphism between Lipω (R+ , X) and Lip0 (R+ , X). For G ∈ Lipω (R+ , X) and f ∈ BSVloc (R+ ), it follows from the definition of the Riemann-Stieltjes integral that
b
b
f (t) dG(t) ≤ G Lipω (R+ ,X) |f (t)|eωt dt (0 ≤ a ≤ b). (2.6)
a
a Let
(Iω G)(t) :=
t
e−ωs dG(s).
0
Then (2.6) implies that Iω G ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X) and Iω G Lip0 (R+ ,X) ≤ G Lipω (R+ ,X) . Similarly if F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X) and (Jω F )(t) :=
0
t
eωs dF (s),
78
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
then Jω F ∈ Lipω (R+ , X) and Jω F Lipω (R+ ,X) ≤ F Lip0 (R+ ,X) . Moreover, Jω Iω G = G and Iω Jω F = F , by Proposition 1.9.10. Hence, Iω is an isometric isomorphism of Lipω (R+ , X) onto Lip0 (R+ , X). Note that if G ∈ L∞ ω (R+ , X) then ω(G) ≤ ω and abs(dG) ≤ ω by Theorem 1.10.5. Thus, the Laplace-Stieltjes transform ∞ (LS,ω G)(λ) := dG(λ) = e−λt dG(t) 0
exists for λ > ω. By Proposition 1.10.3, (LS,ω G)(λ) = (LS Iω G)(λ − ω). Let ∞ CW ((ω, ∞), X) :=
(2.7)
r ∈ C ∞ ((ω, ∞), X) :
r W :=
sup λ>ω,k∈N0
(λ − ω)k+1 (k)
r (λ) < ∞ . k!
This is a Banach space, and it is clear that the shift Sω : r → r(· − ω) is an ∞ ∞ isometric isomorphism of CW ((0, ∞), X) onto CW ((ω, ∞), X). The equation (2.7) may be written as LS,ω = Sω ◦ LS ◦ Iω . Now we can give the following reformulation of the Real Representation Theorem 2.2.1. Theorem 2.4.1. Let ω ∈ R. The Laplace-Stieltjes transform is an isometric iso∞ morphism of Lipω (R+ , X) onto CW ((ω, ∞), X). In particular, for M > 0 and ∞ r ∈ CW ((ω, ∞), X), the following are equivalent: 1 (k) (i) (λ − ω)k+1 k! r (λ) ≤ M
(λ > ω, k ∈ N0 ).
(ii) There exists G : R+ → X satisfying G(0) = 0 and G(t + h) − G(t) ≤ t+h ∞ M t eωr dr (t, h ≥ 0), such that r(λ) = 0 e−λt dG(t) for all λ > ω. Proposition 1.6.1 a) gives Lω = Sω ◦ L ◦ Mω where L and Lω are the Laplace transforms on L∞ (R+ , X) and L∞ ω (R+ , X). Hence Theorem 2.2.3 can be reformulated as follows. Theorem 2.4.2. Let M > 0, ω ∈ R. If X has the Radon-Nikodym property then ∞ for any r ∈ CW ((ω, ∞), X) the following are equivalent: 1 (k) (i) (λ − ω)k+1 k! r (λ) ≤ M
(λ > ω, k ∈ N0 ).
(ii) There existsg ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) with g(t) ≤ M eωt for almost all t ≥ 0 such ∞ that r(λ) = 0 e−λt g(t) dt for all λ > ω.
2.4. TRANSFORMS OF EXPONENTIALLY BOUNDED FUNCTIONS
79
As in Theorem 2.1.1 one shows that there exists an isometric isomorphism ΦS,ω between the spaces Lipω (R+ , X) and L(L1ω (R+ ), X), where ∞ L1ω (R+ ) := h ∈ L1loc (R+ ) : h ω,1 := eωt |h(t)| dt < ∞ . 0
The isomorphism ΦS,ω assigns to every function G ∈ Lipω (R+ , X) an operator T ∈ L(L1ω (R+ ), X) with T = G Lipω (R+ ,X) such that ∞ Th = h(t) dG(t) 0
for all continuous functions h ∈ L1ω (R+ ), T χ[0,t] = G(t) for all t ≥ 0, and T e−λ = dG(λ) if Re λ > ω. The inversion theorems in Section 2.3 all remain valid, with almost no changes in the proofs (the version of Theorem 2.3.4 for Lipω (R+ , X) can be deduced directly for some from the case ω = 0 by using the isomorphism Iω ). Thus, if r = dF F ∈ Lipω (R+ , X), then k+1 k k d r(λ) k 1 F (t) = lim (−1) . (2.8) k→∞ k! t dλk λ λ=k/t If c > max(ω, 0), then 1 k→∞ 2πi
c+ik
F (t) = lim
c−ik
eλt
r(λ) dλ, λ
(2.9)
where the limit exists uniformly on compact subsets of R+ . Finally, F (t) = lim
k→∞
∞ j=1
(−1)j+1
1 tkj e r(kj), j!
(2.10)
where the limit exists uniformly on R+ . The following is a consequence of the Phragm´en-Doetsch inversion (2.10). Proposition 2.4.3. Let ε > 0 and f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) with abs(f ) < ∞. The following are equivalent. (i) lim supλ→∞
1 λ
log fˆ(λ) ≤ −ε.
(ii) f = 0 a.e. on [0, ε]. t t Proof. Let F (t) := 0 f (s) ds and G(t) := 0 F (s) ds. Since abs(f ) < ∞, ω(F ) < ∞ by Theorem 1.4.3 and hence G ∈ Lipω (R+ , X) for some ω ∈ R. By Corollary 1.6.5 and Proposition 1.10.1, fˆ(λ) = λF (λ) = λdG(λ) = λ2 G(λ)
80
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
for Re λ > ω. Define
1ˆ f (λ) = F (λ) = dG(λ) λ for λ > ω. If (i) holds, then lim supλ→∞ λ1 log r(λ) ≤ −ε. Let 0 < ξ < ε. Then there exist M, λ0 > 0 such that r(λ) ≤ M e−λξ for all λ > λ0 . Let t ∈ [0, ξ). Then, for λ0 < k ∈ N,
∞
∞ (t−ξ)k
(−1)j+1 tkj
1 (t−ξ)kj e
≤M e r(kj) e = M e − 1 →0
j! j!
j=1
j=1 r(λ) :=
it follows from (2.10) that G = 0 on [0, ξ) for all as k → ∞. Since r = dG, 0 < ξ < ε. Thus, G = 0 on [0, ε] and hence f = 0 a.e. on [0, ε], by Proposition 1.2.2. This proves that (i) ⇒ (ii). Suppose that (ii) holds. Then F = 0 on [0, ε]. Thus ∞ ∞ ∞ r(λ) = e−λt F (t) dt = e−λt F (t) dt = e−λε e−λt F (t + ε) dt. 0
0
ε
∞ Since t → F (t+ε) is exponentially bounded, it follows that 0 e−λt F (t+ε) dt ≤ C for some C > 0 and therefore r(λ) ≤ Ce−ελ for all sufficiently large λ. This proves that (ii) ⇒ (i). If f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) with abs(f ) < ∞, then it follows from Corollary 1.6.5 and the exponential boundedness of F that there exist M, λ0 > 0 such that fˆ(λ) ≤ M for all λ > λ0 . Thus, lim supλ→∞ λ1 log fˆ(λ) ≤ 0. This and the previous proposition yield the following corollary. Corollary 2.4.4. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) with abs(f ) < ∞. Then the following are equivalent: (i) lim supλ→∞
1 λ
log fˆ(λ) = 0.
(ii) For every ε > 0, the restriction of f to [0, ε] does not vanish a.e.
2.5
Complex Conditions
It was shown in the previous section that a holomorphic function q : {Re λ > ω} → X has a Laplace-Stieltjes or multiplied Laplace representation ∞ ∞ q(λ) = e−λt dF (t) = λ e−λt F (t) dt 0
0
1 (k) if there exists a constant M > 0 such that the Taylor coefficients k! q (λ) are k+1 bounded by M/(λ − ω) for all λ > ω and k ∈ N0 . Since only properties of the function q along the real half-line (ω, ∞) are involved, Widder’s growth conditions
2.5. COMPLEX CONDITIONS
81
are also referred to as “real conditions”. In many instances, these real conditions are too difficult to be checked because all derivatives of q have to be considered, whereas the growth of q in a complex half-plane Re λ > ω can be estimated. In these cases one can apply the following representation theorem. Theorem 2.5.1 (Complex Representation). Let ω ≥ 0, let q : {Re λ > ω} → X be a holomorphic function with supRe λ>ω λq(λ) < ∞ and let b > 0. Then there exists f ∈ C(R+ , X) with supt>0 e−ωt t−b f (t) < ∞ such that q(λ) = λb fˆ(λ) for Re λ > ω. Proof. Let α > ω and define 1 f (t) := lim R→∞ 2πi
α+iR
α−iR
q(λ) eλt b λ
1 dλ = 2π
∞
−∞
e(α+ir)t
q(α + ir) dr. (α + ir)b
Observe that the latter integral is absolutely convergent, by the assumption on q, so the limit exists uniformly for t in compact subsets of R+ . Hence, f is continuous on R+ . By applying Cauchy’s theorem over rectangles with vertices α±iR, β±iR, and using the assumption on q, it is easy to see that the definition of f is independent of α > ω. For α > ω and R > 0, let Γα,R be the path consisting of the vertical half-line π {α + ir : r < −R}, the semicircle {α + Reiθ : −π 2 ≤ θ ≤ 2 }, and the half-line {α + ir : r > R}. By Cauchy’s theorem, f (t)
= =
1 q(λ) eλt b dλ 2πi Γα,R λ −R 1 q(α + ir) e(α+ir)t dr 2π −∞ (α + ir)b π/2 iθ 1 q(α + Reiθ ) iθ + e(α+Re )t Re dθ 2π −π/2 (α + Reiθ )b ∞ 1 q(α + ir) + e(α+ir)t dr. 2π R (α + ir)b
Hence,
f (t)
≤ =
dr M π/2 e(α+R cos θ)t + dθ b+1 2π −π/2 Rb R r M eαt M eαt π/2 Rt cos θ + e dθ, πbRb πRb 0 M eαt π
∞
where M := supRe λ>ω λq(λ) . Choosing R = 1/t, we obtain that f (t) ≤ Ctb eαt for some C independent of α > ω. Hence, f (t) ≤ Ctb eωt .
82
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
Given λ with Re λ > ω, choose ω < α < Re λ. By the dominated convergence theorem and Fubini’s theorem, ∞ ∞ α+iR 1 q(z) e−λt f (t) dt = lim e−λt ezt b dz dt R→∞ 2πi z 0 0 α−iR α+iR 1 q(z) = lim dz. R→∞ 2πi α−iR (λ − z)z b By Cauchy’s residue theorem around the path consisting of the semicircle {α + Reiθ : −π/2 ≤ θ ≤ π/2} and the line-segment {α + ir : −R ≤ r ≤ R}, α+iR π/2 1 q(z) 1 q(α + Reiθ )Reiθ q(λ) dz = dθ + b b 2πi α−iR (λ − z)z 2π −π/2 (λ − α − Reiθ )(α + Reiθ )b λ →
q(λ) λb
as R → ∞, using the assumption on q. We mention that Theorem 2.5.1 does not hold for b = 0. In fact, Desch and Pr¨ uss [DP93] construct a scalar-valued holomorphic function q on C+ satisfying sup q(λ) (1 + |λ|) < ∞
Re λ>0
such that q is not the Laplace transform of a function f ∈ L∞ loc (0, ∞). On the other hand, if λq(λ) and λ2 q (λ) are bounded on the right half-plane, then q is the Laplace transform of a bounded continuous function, as we show in the following corollary. Corollary 2.5.2 (Pr¨ uss). Let q : {Re λ > 0} → X be holomorphic. If there exists M > 0 such that λq(λ) ≤ M and λ2 q (λ) ≤ M for Re λ ∞> 0, then there exists a bounded function f ∈ C((0, ∞), X) such that q(λ) = 0 e−λt f (t) dt for ∞ Re λ > 0. In particular, q ∈ CW ((0, ∞), X). Proof. It follows from Theorem 2.5.1 that there are functions fi ∈ C(R+ , X) (i = 0, 1) and C > 0 such that fi (t) ≤ Ct for t > 0, ∞ ∞ q(λ) = λ e−λt f0 (t) dt, and λq (λ) = λ e−λt f1 (t) dt 0
0
for Re λ > 0. By Theorem 1.5.1, ∞ q (λ) = e−λt f0 (t) dt − λ 0
0
∞
e−λt tf0 (t) dt =
Integration by parts (or Corollary 1.6.5) yields t ∞ λ e−λt f0 (s) ds − tf0 (t) dt = λ 0
0
∞ 0
∞ 0
e−λt
e−λt f1 (t) dt.
t 0
f1 (s) ds dt.
2.5. COMPLEX CONDITIONS
83
t Since the Laplace transform is one-to-one, it follows that tf0 (t) = 0 f0 (s) ds − t f (s) ds. Thus, f0 ∈ C 1 ((0, ∞), X) and tf0 (t) = −f1 (t). Therefore, f0 (t) ≤ C 0 1 for all t > 0 and ∞ ∞ −λt q(λ) = λ e f0 (t) dt = e−λt f0 (t) dt (Re λ > 0). 0
0
Remark 2.5.3. If f ∈ L∞ ((0, ∞), X), then r = fˆ is holomorphic on the right half-plane and
λr(λ)
≤
λ2 r (λ)
≤
|λ|
f ∞ , Re λ 2 |λ|
f ∞ Re λ
(Re λ > 0).
In particular, λr(λ) and λ2 r (λ) are bounded on each sector Σα = {reiγ : r > 0, |γ| < α} where α ∈ (0, π/2). In Corollary 2.5.2 the estimate is required uniformly on the right half-plane, which is more. On the other hand, continuity is obtained as an additional result. We close this section with a characterization of Laplace transforms of functions in L1loc (R+ , X) with f (t) ≤ M tn for some M, n ≥ 0 and almost all t ≥ 0 (if X has the Radon-Nikodym property) or the Laplace-Stieltjes transforms of t functions H : R+ → X with H(0) = 0 and H(t) − H(s) ≤ M s r n dr for some M > 0 and all 0 ≤ s ≤ t (for general X). Corollary 2.5.4. Let M > 0, n ∈ N0 , and r ∈ C ∞ ((0, ∞), X). The following are equivalent: k+n+1
(i) λ(k+n)! r (k) (λ) ≤ M
(λ > 0, k ∈ N0 ).
(ii) There exists H : R+ → X satisfying H(0) = 0 and H(t) − H(s) ≤ t ∞ M s r n dr (0 ≤ s ≤ t), such that r(λ) = 0 e−λt dH(t) for all λ > 0. Proof. By the Real Representation Theorem 2.2.1, the statement holds for n = 0. Therefore, let n ≥ 1. To show that (i) implies (ii), define ∞ 1 (u − λ)n−1 r(u) du m(λ) := (−1)n (n − 1)! λ k+1
for λ > 0. Then, m(k) (λ) = r (k−n) (λ) for all k ≥ n and λ > 0. Since λ k! m(k) (λ)
k+1 = λ k! r (k−n) (λ) ≤ M for all λ > 0 and k ≥ n, it follows from Proposition ∞ 2.2.2 that m ∈ CW ((0, ∞), X) and m W ≤ M . By Theorem 2.2.1, there exists G : R+ → X with G(0) = 0 and G(t) − G(s) ≤ M |t − s| for all t, s ≥ 0 such that ∞ m(λ) = 0 e−λt dG(t) for all λ > 0. By Theorem 1.5.1 and Proposition 1.9.10, ∞ ∞ r(λ) = m(n) (λ) = e−λt (−t)n dG(t) = e−λt dH(t), 0
0
84
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
t where H(t) := 0 (−s)n dG(s). Now the statement (ii) follows from H(t)−H(s) = t t
s (−r)n dG(r) ≤ M s r n dr for all 0 ≤ s ≤ t. To show that (ii) implies (i), let x∗ ∈ X ∗ . The function x∗ ◦ H is locally Lipschitz continuous, hence absolutely continuous and differentiable a.e. If ∞ d h(t) := dt H(t), x∗ , then |h(t)| ≤ M tn x∗ and r(λ), x∗ = 0 e−λt h(t) dt, by Proposition 1.9.11. Hence, k+n+1 k+n+1 ∞ λ λ (k) ∗ −λt k r (λ), x = e (−t) h(t) dt (k + n)! (k + n)! 0 ≤ M x∗ . Now (i) follows from the Hahn-Banach theorem.
2.6
Laplace Transforms of Holomorphic Functions
In this section those functions are characterized which are Laplace transforms of holomorphic, exponentially bounded functions defined on some open sector Σα := {reiγ : r > 0, −α < γ < α} for some 0 < α ≤ π/2. The closure of Σα is denoted by Σα . We shall use the same notation for 0 < α < π. Note that Σ π2 = C+ := {Re λ > 0}. Theorem 2.6.1 (Analytic Representation). Let 0 < α ≤ → X. The following are equivalent:
π 2,
ω ∈ R and q : (ω, ∞)
(i) There is a holomorphic function f : Σα → X such that supz∈Σβ e−ωz f (z)
< ∞ for all 0 < β < α and q(λ) = fˆ(λ) for all λ > ω. (ii) The function q has a holomorphic extension q˜ : ω + Σα+ π2 → X such that supλ∈ω+Σγ+ π (λ − ω)˜ q (λ) < ∞ for all 0 < γ < α. 2
Proof. Assume that (i) holds. Let 0 < β < α. Then there exists M > 0 such that
f (z) ≤ M |eωz | for all z ∈ Σβ \ {0}. Define paths Γ± by Γ± := {se±iβ : 0 ≤ s < ∞}. By Cauchy’s theorem, ∞ −λt q(λ) = e f (t) dt = e−λz f (z)dz 0
= e±iβ
∞
Γ±
e−λse
±iβ
f (se±iβ ) ds
(2.11)
0
for all λ > ω. Let 0 < ε < π2 − β, and let λ ∈ C with − π2 − β + ε < arg(λ − ω) < π π π iβ iβ 2 − β −ε. Then − 2 + ε < arg((λ − ω)e ) < 2 − ε, so Re((λ− ω)e ) ≥ |λ− ω| sin ε. It follows that iβ
e−λse f (seiβ ) ≤ M e−s|λ−ω| sin ε .
2.6. LAPLACE TRANSFORMS OF HOLOMORPHIC FUNCTIONS
85
Consequently, the integral q+ (λ) := eiβ
∞
iβ
e−λse f (seiβ ) ds
0
is absolutely convergent and defines a holomorphic function in the region − π2 − β + ε < arg(λ − ω) < π2 − β − ε, with (λ − ω)q+ (λ) ≤ M/ sin ε. Similarly, q− (λ) := e−iβ
∞
e−λse
−iβ
f (se−iβ ) ds
0
defines a holomorphic function in the region − π2 + β + ε < arg(λ − ω) < π2 + β − ε, with (λ − ω)q− (λ) ≤ M/ sin ε. By (2.11), both q+ and q− are extensions of q, and together they define a holomorphic extension q˜ to ω + Σ π2 +β−ε , satisfying
(λ − ω)˜ q (λ) ≤ M/ sin ε in the sector. Since β < α and 0 < ε < π2 − β are arbitrary, this proves (ii). Assume that (ii) holds. Let 0 < γ < α and δ > 0. There exists M > 0 such that (λ − ω)˜ q (λ) ≤ M for all λ ∈ (ω + Σγ+ π2 ) \ {ω}. Consider an oriented path Γ (depending on γ and δ) consisting of ' ( ' ( Γ± := ω + re±i(γ+π/2) : δ ≤ r and Γ0 := ω + δeiθ : −γ − π2 ≤ θ ≤ γ + π2 . Let 0 < ε < γ and consider z ∈ Σγ−ε . For λ = ω + re±i(γ+π/2) ∈ Γ± , Re(λz)
=
ω Re z + r|z| cos(arg z ± (γ + π/2))
≤ ω Re z − r|z| sin ε. Hence,
eλz q˜(λ) ≤ eω Re z e−r|z| sin ε This shows that f (z) :=
1 2πi
M (λ ∈ Γ± ). r
(2.12)
eλz q˜(λ) dλ
(2.13)
Γ
is absolutely convergent, uniformly for z in compact subsets of Σγ , and therefore defines a holomorphic function in Σγ . By Cauchy’s theorem, this function is independent of δ > 0, and also independent of γ < α so long as arg z < γ (here we use the assumption on q˜ to estimate the integral of eλz q˜(λ) over arcs {ω + Reiθ : γ1 + π2 ≤ |θ| ≤ γ2 + π2 }). Hence (2.13) defines a holomorphic function f ∈ Σα . To estimate f (z), we choose δ = |z|−1 , and choose γ and ε such that γ < α and | arg z| < γ − ε. On Γ0 , λ = ω + |z|−1 eiθ (−γ − π/2 ≤ θ ≤ γ + π/2), so
1
2πi
Γ0
eλz q˜(λ) dλ
≤
1 2π
γ+π/2
eω Re z ecos(arg z+θ) M dθ
−γ−π/2
≤ M e1+ω Re z .
(2.14)
86
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
On Γ± , λ = ω + re±i(γ+π/2) , and the estimate (2.12) gives
∞
1
1 M
λz e q ˜ (λ) dλ ≤ eω Re z e−r|z| sin ε dr
2πi Γ±
2π |z|−1 r M eω Re z ∞ e−r sin ε = dr 2π r 1 M eω Re z ≤ . 2π sin ε
(2.15)
Now (2.14) and (2.15) establish that sup e−ωz f (z) < ∞ z∈Σγ−ε
for any 0 < ε < γ < α. Next we will show that fˆ(λ) = q(λ) whenever λ > ω. Given such λ, choose 0 < δ < λ − ω, and 0 < γ < α. Then λ is to the right of the path Γ, and Fubini’s theorem and Cauchy’s residue theorem imply that ∞ 1 fˆ(λ) = e−λt eμt q˜(μ) dμ dt 2πi Γ 0 1 q˜(μ) = dμ 2πi Γ λ − μ 1 q˜(μ) = q˜(λ) + lim dμ, R→∞ 2πi Γ λ −μ R R := {ω + Reiθ : −γ − π/2 ≤ θ ≤ γ + π/2}. Then where Γ
γ+π/2
q˜(μ) M
≤ dμ dθ
λ−μ iθ − λ| |ω + Re ΓR −γ−π/2 → 0 as R → ∞. This proves that fˆ(λ) = q(λ). When f is as in Theorem 2.6.1 (i), it is an easy consequence of Cauchy’s integral formula for derivatives that
sup z k e−ωz f (k) (z) < ∞ z∈Σβ
for all 0 < β < α. Recall from Sections 1.4 and 1.5 that, for f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X), ω(f ) := inf ω ∈ R : sup e−ωt f (t) < ∞ , abs(f ) hol(fˆ)
:= :=
'
t≥0
( inf Re λ : fˆ(λ) exists , ' ( inf ω ∈ R : fˆ has a holomorphic extension for Re λ > ω .
2.6. LAPLACE TRANSFORMS OF HOLOMORPHIC FUNCTIONS
87
Moreover, hol(fˆ) ≤ abs(f ) ≤ ω(f ). We will now show that equalities hold when f is holomorphic and exponentially bounded on a sector. Theorem 2.6.2. Let 0 < α < π/2, let f : Σα → X be holomorphic, and suppose that there exists ω ∈ R such that supz∈Σα e−ωz f (z) < ∞. Then hol(fˆ) = abs(f ) = ω(f ). Proof. By Theorem 2.6.1, there exists γ > 0 such that fˆ has a holomorphic extension (also denoted by fˆ) to ω + Σγ+π/2 and C := supλ∈Σγ+π/2 (λ − ω)fˆ(λ) < ∞. By definition of hol(fˆ), fˆ also has a holomorphic extension to hol(fˆ) + Σπ/2 = {Re λ > hol(fˆ)}. Let ω > hol(fˆ). There exists γ > 0 such that ω + Σγ +π/2 ⊆ (ω + Σγ+π/2 ) ∪ (hol(fˆ) + Σπ/2 ). Hence, fˆ is holomorphic on ω + Σγ +π/2 and continuous on the closure. Let ' ( U := λ ∈ (ω + Σγ +π/2 ) ∩ (ω + Σγ+π/2 ) : |λ − ω | < 2|λ − ω| . If λ ∈ U , then (λ − ω )fˆ(λ) ≤ 2C. Moreover, (ω + Σγ +π/2 ) \ U is compact. Hence, supλ∈ω +Σγ +π/2 (λ−ω )fˆ(λ) < ∞. It follows from Theorem 2.6.1, and the
fact that the Laplace transform is one-to-one, that supz∈Σβ e−ω z f (z) < ∞ for some β > 0, and in particular, ω(f ) ≤ ω . Since this holds whenever ω > hol(fˆ), it follows that ω(f ) ≤ hol(fˆ), completing the proof. In the remainder of this section we will consider asymptotic behaviour of f (t) as t → ∞ and as t → 0. In the case of holomorphic functions defined on a sector it can be described completely in terms of the Laplace transform. This is not the case in general, and in Chapter 4 a systematic treatment of this question will be given. However, here we can use contour arguments directly on the basis of the representation formula (2.13). First we show that asymptotic behaviour along one ray and on the whole sector are equivalent. This is a consequence of Vitali’s theorem (Theorem A.5). Proposition 2.6.3. Let 0 < α ≤ π and let f : Σα → X be holomorphic such that sup f (z) < ∞ z∈Σβ
for all 0 < β < α. Let x ∈ X. a) If limt→∞ f (t) = x, then lim |z|→∞ f (z) = x for all 0 < β < α. z∈Σβ
b) If limt↓0 f (t) = x, then lim |z|→0 f (z) = x for all 0 < β < α. z∈Σβ
88
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
Proof. a) Let fk (z) = f (kz). It follows from Vitali’s theorem that limk→∞ fk (z) = x uniformly on compact subsets of Σα . Let 0 < β < α. Let ε > 0. There exists k0 ∈ N such that fk (z) − x ≤ ε whenever z ∈ Σβ , 1 ≤ |z| ≤ 2, k ≥ k0 . Let z ∈ Σβ , |z| ≥ k0 . Choose k ∈ N such that k ≤ |z| < k + 1. Then
f (z) − x = fk (z/k) − x ≤ ε. This proves a). b) This follows by applying a) to the function z → f (z −1 ). Now we consider the asymptotic behaviour of f (t) as t → ∞ and t ↓ 0. Theorem 2.6.4 (Tauberian Theorem). Consider the situation of Theorem 2.6.1, and let x ∈ X. a) One has limt↓0 f (t) = x if and only if limλ→∞ λq(λ) = x. b) Assume that ω = 0. Then limt→∞ f (t) = x if and only if limλ↓0 λq(λ) = x. Proof. We can assume that ω = 0 for both cases a) and b) by replacing f (z) by e−ωz f (z) otherwise. Replacing f (t) by f (t) − x, we can also assume that x = 0. For simplicity, we shall denote the function q˜ of Theorem 2.6.1 by q. Assume that limλ→∞ λq(λ) = x. Let 0 < γ < α. By Proposition 2.6.3, lim |λ|→∞ λq(λ) = x. Let ε > 0. There exists δ0 > 0 such that λq(λ) ≤ ε λ∈Σγ+π/2
whenever |λ| ≥ δ0 , λ ∈ Σγ+ π2 . Let 0 < t ≤ 1/δ0 . Now we choose the contour Γ as in the proof of Theorem 2.6.1, (ii) ⇒ (i), with δ = 1/t. Then
1 γ+π/2 iθ eiθ ieiθ
1
λt e
e q(λ) dλ = e q dθ
2πi
2πi −γ−π/2
t t Γ0 γ+π/2 ε ≤ ecos θ dθ 2π −γ−π/2 ≤ ε e, and
1
λt e q(λ) dλ
2πi Γ±
1
∞
t·re±i(γ+π/2) ±i(γ+π/2) ±i(γ+π/2) dr = e q(re )re
2πi 1/t r
∞
1 s ±(γ+π/2) s ±i(γ+π/2) ds se±i(γ+π/2)
= e q( e ) e
2πi t t s 1 → 0
as t ↓ 0 by the dominated convergence theorem. It follows from the representation (2.13) that lim supt↓0 f (t) ≤ ε e.
2.7. COMPLETELY MONOTONIC FUNCTIONS
89
The converse implication is easy and does not depend on holomorphy. Assume that limt↓0 f (t) = 0. Let ε > 0. There exists τ > 0 such that f (t) ≤ ε for all t ∈ [0, τ ]. Then lim sup λq(λ)
λ→∞
≤
lim sup λ λ→∞
τ
e 0
≤ ε + lim sup λ λ→∞
= ε + lim sup M λ→∞
−λt
∞
f (t) dt + λ
∞
e
−λt
f (t) dt
τ
e−λt M eωt dt
τ
λ e−(λ−ω)τ = ε, λ−ω
where ω > ω(f ) and M is suitable. This completes the proof of a). The assertion b) is proved in the same way as a).
2.7
Completely Monotonic Functions
Throughout this section, X will be an ordered Banach space with normal cone (see Appendix C). Let f : R+ → X be increasing. Then f is of bounded semivariation on each interval [0, τ ], by Proposition 1.9.1. Assume that ω(f ) < ∞. Then the Laplace-Stieltjes transform τ ∞ df (λ) = lim e−λt df (t) =: e−λt df (t) (2.16) τ →∞
0
0
converges on the half-plane {Re λ > abs(df )}, and defines a holomorphic function df on {Re λ > abs(df )}. Recall from Theorem 1.10.5 that abs(df ) < ∞ if and only if ω(f ) < ∞. Theorem 2.7.1. Let f : R+ → X be an increasing function. Assume that −∞ < abs(df ) < ∞. Then abs(df ) is a singularity of df . t Proof. Replacing f (t) by 0 e− abs(df )s df (s), we can assume that abs(df ) = 0. Assume that df has a holomorphic extension to a neighbourhood of 0. Then there exists δ > 0 such that df (−δ) =
∞ n=0
(−1)n (1 + δ)n
(df )(n) (1) . n!
∗ Let x∗ ∈ X+ . Then
df (−δ), x∗ =
∞ (1 + δ)n ∞ −t n e t df (t), x∗ . n! 0 n=0
90
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
Since all expressions are positive we may interchange the sum and the integral and obtain ∞ ∞ δt ∗ e df (t), x = e−t e(1+δ)t df (t), x∗ 0
0
=
∞ (1 + δ)n ∞ −t n e t df (t), x∗ n! 0 n=0
=
df (−δ), x∗ < ∞.
∗ Since X+ spans X ∗ (see Proposition C.2), it follows that abs(x∗ ◦ f ) ≤ −δ for ∗ all x ∈ X ∗ . It follows from (1.25) that abs(df ) ≤ −δ, which contradicts the assumption.
Corollary 2.7.2. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) such that f (t) ≥ 0 a.e. Assume that −∞ < abs(f ) < ∞. Then abs(f ) is a singularity of fˆ. Hence, hol(fˆ) = abs(f ). Proof. This is immediate from Proposition 1.10.1 and Theorem 2.7.1. Our aim is to characterize functions of the form df where f : R+ → X is increasing. Then ∞ n (n) (−1) df (λ) = e−λt tn df (t) ≥ 0 0
for all n ∈ N0 , λ > ω. Thus df is completely monotonic in the sense of the following definition. Definition 2.7.3. A function r : (ω, ∞) → X is completely monotonic if r is infinitely differentiable and (−1)n r (n) (λ) ≥ 0
for all λ > ω, n ∈ N0 .
(2.17)
In the following, we shall assume that ω = 0 for simplicity (otherwise, we t can replace r(λ) by r(λ + ω) and f (t) by 0 e−ωs df (s)). Recall that by Theorem 1.10.5 abs(df ) ≤ 0 if and only if ω(f ) ≤ 0. Definition 2.7.4. We say that Bernstein’s theorem holds in X if for every completely monotonic function r : (0, ∞) → X there exists an increasing function f : R+ → X such that ω(f ) ≤ 0 and r(λ) = df (λ) for all λ > 0. Bernstein’s theorem does hold in X = R; this is just Bernstein’s classical theorem from 1928 [Ber28]. Here we will prove it, as a special case of Theorem 2.7.7, with the help of the Real Representation Theorem 2.2.1. Definition 2.7.5. The space X has the interpolation property if, given two sequences (xn )n∈N , (yn )n∈N in X such that xn ≤ xn+1 ≤ yn+1 ≤ yn
(n ∈ N)
(2.18)
2.7. COMPLETELY MONOTONIC FUNCTIONS
91
there exists z ∈ X such that xn ≤ z ≤ yn
for all n ∈ N.
(2.19)
Examples 2.7.6. a) Assume that X = Y ∗ where Y is an ordered Banach space with normal cone. Then X has the interpolation property. ∗ Proof. Let x∗n ≤ x∗n+1 ≤ yn+1 ≤ yn∗ (n ∈ N). Replacing x∗n by x∗n − x∗1 and yn∗ by ∗ ∗ yn − x1 we can assume that x∗n ≥ 0. Define z ∗ ∈ X ∗ by x, z ∗ = supn∈N x, x∗n . Then z ∗ is linear and positive, and hence continuous (see Appendix C).
b) If X is reflexive, then X has the interpolation property. This follows from a). c) Each von Neumann algebra (i.e., a ∗-subalgebra of L(H) which is closed in the strong operator topology, where H is a Hilbert space) has the interpolation property. This follows from a) and [Ped89, Theorem 4.6.17]. d) Every σ-order complete Banach lattice (i.e., a Banach lattice in which each countable order-bounded set has a supremum) has the interpolation property. e) If X has order continuous norm (i.e., each decreasing positive sequence converges) then X has the interpolation property. f) The space C[0, 1] does not have the interpolation property. See the Notes for further comments on the interpolation property. Now we can formulate the following characterization, which is the main result of this section. Theorem 2.7.7. Bernstein’s theorem holds in X if and only if X has the interpolation property. The proof of Theorem 2.7.7 will be carried out in several steps. On the way we will prove a characterization of completely monotonic functions which is valid without restrictions on the space. First, we study convex functions. Let J ⊂ R be an interval. A function F : J → X is called convex if F (λs + (1 − λ)t) ≤ λF (s) + (1 − λ)F (t) for all s, t ∈ J, 0 < λ < 1. Many order properties of convex functions carry over from the scalar case since for x ∈ X we have x≥0
if and only if
x, x∗ ≥ 0
∗ for all x∗ ∈ X+ .
For example, a twice differentiable function F is convex if and only if F ≥ 0. Lemma 2.7.8. Let [a, b] be a closed interval in the interior of J and let F : J → X be convex. Then F is Lipschitz continuous on [a, b]. Moreover, if F (J) ⊂ X+ and F (a) = 0, then F is increasing on [a, b].
92
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
Proof. Let c < a, d > b such that [c, d] ⊂ J. Then for a ≤ t < s ≤ b, F (a) − F (c) F (s) − F (t) F (d) − F (b) ≤ ≤ . a−c s−t d−b Since the cone is normal this implies that F is Lipschitz continuous on [a, b]. The second assertion is easy to see. We notice in particular that every convex function defined on an open interval is continuous. Let −∞ < a < b ≤ ∞ and let f : [a, b) → X+ be increasing. Then f is Riemann integrable on [a, t] whenever a ≤ t < b (see Corollary 1.9.6). Let
t
F (t) :=
f (s) ds (a ≤ t < b).
(2.20)
a
Then F : [a, b) → X+ is convex. If X has the interpolation property, then the following converse result holds. Proposition 2.7.9. Assume that X has the interpolation property. Let F : [a, b) → X+ be convex such that F (a) = 0, where −∞ < a < b ≤ ∞. Then there exists an increasing function f : [a, b) → X+ such that (2.20) holds. Proof. The following two properties follow from convexity: a) Let a ≤ s < b. Then the difference quotient 1 (F (s + h) − F (s)) h is positive and increasing for h ∈ (0, b − s). b) Let a ≤ s < s + h ≤ t < t + k < b. Then 1 1 (F (s + h) − F (s)) ≤ (F (t + k) − F (t)) . h k
(2.21)
Put f (a) = 0. It follows from the interpolation property, a) and b) that for each t ∈ (a, b) there exists f (t) ∈ X such that 1 1 (F (s + h) − F (s)) ≤ f (t) ≤ (F (t + k) − F (t)) h k
(2.22)
whenever a ≤ s < s + h ≤ t < t + k < b. It follows from (2.21) and (2.22) that f : [a, b) → X+ is increasing. t Let G(t) := a f (s) ds. We show that F = G. Let a < t < b. Let a ≤ t0 < t1 < . . . < tn = t be a partition of [a, t]. Setting hi := ti − ti−1 , we obtain from
2.7. COMPLETELY MONOTONIC FUNCTIONS
93
(2.22) that n
f (ti−1 )(ti − ti−1 ) ≤
i=1
=
n 1 (F (ti−1 + hi ) − F (ti−1 )) hi h i=1 i n
(F (ti ) − F (ti−1 ))
i=1
= F (t) − F (a) = F (t). It follows from the definition of the Riemann integral that G(t) ≤ F (t). Also by (2.22), n
f (ti )(ti − ti−1 ) ≥
i=1
n F (ti ) − F (ti−1 ) i=1
ti − ti−1
(ti − ti−1 )
= F (t). Hence G(t) ≥ F (t). Next, we prove a converse version of Proposition 2.7.9. Proposition 2.7.10. Assume that for every convex function F : R+ → X+ with F (0) = 0 and ω(F ) = 0 there exists an increasing function f : R+ → X+ such t that F (t) = 0 f (s) ds (t ≥ 0). Then X has the interpolation property. Proof. Let xn ≤ xn+1 ≤ yn+1 ≤ yn (n ∈ N). We can assume that x1 ≥ 0 (replacing xn by xn − x1 and yn by yn − x1 otherwise). Define f : R+ → X by ⎧ n xn if t ∈ [ n−1 , n+1 ); n ≥ 1, ⎪ n ⎪ ⎪ ⎨y n+1 n if t ∈ [ , n n n−1 ); n ≥ 2, f (t) := ⎪ y1 if t ∈ [2, ∞), ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ 0 if t = 1. t Then f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X). Let F (t) := 0 f (s) ds. Then F : R+ → X+ is convex and F (0) = 0. By assumption, there exists an increasing function g : R+ → X such t that F (t) = 0 g(s) ds (t ≥ 0). Then F (t − h) − F (t) F (t + h) − F (t) ≤ g(t) ≤ −h h for all t > 0 and h > 0 small enough. It follows that g(t) = F (t) whenever F n is differentiable at t. Consequently, g(t) = xn if t ∈ ( n−1 , n+1 ) and g(t) = yn if n n+1 n t ∈ ( n , n−1 ). Hence, xn ≤ g(1) ≤ yn . Thus, z := g(1) interpolates between the two sequences. For completeness, we also give the usual representation of convex functions as a corollary of Proposition 2.7.9.
94
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
Corollary 2.7.11. Assume that X has the interpolation property. Let F : (a, b) → X be convex, and let c ∈ (a, b). Then there exist x ∈ X and an increasing function f : (a, b) → X such that t F (t) = F (c) + (t − c)x + f (s) ds c
for all t ∈ (a, b). Proof. We may assume that c = 0. It follows from convexity that 1 1 (F (0) − F (−t)) ≤ (F (s) − F (0)) t s whenever 0 < s < b, 0 < t < −a. Moreover, the left-hand difference quotient is decreasing in t, and the right-hand one is increasing in s. By the interpolation property, there exists x ∈ X such that 1 1 (F (0) − F (−t)) ≤ x ≤ (F (s) − F (0)) t s for all 0 < t < −a, 0 < s < b. In particular, the function G(t) := F (t) − F (0) − tx
(t ∈ (a, b))
is positive, convex and satisfies G(0) = 0. By Proposition 2.7.9, there exist increasing functions f1 : [0, b) → X+ and f2 : [0, −a) → X+ such that t G(t) = f1 (s) ds for t ∈ [0, b) and 0 t G(−t) = f2 (s) ds for t ∈ [0, −a). 0
We can assume that f1 (0) = f2 (0) = 0. Let f (t) := f1 (t) for t ∈ [0, b) and t f (t) := −f2 (−t) for t ∈ (a, 0). Then f is increasing and G(t) = 0 f (s) ds for all t ∈ (a, b). Now we will study completely monotonic functions. We need the following formulas (2.23) and (2.24) (the latter is merely needed for n = 1 and n = 2). In the remainder of this section we shall sometimes use loose notation such as r(λ) to λ (n) r(λ) denote the function λ → r(λ) and r(λ) to denote its derivatives λ , and λ λ of orders 1 and n. Lemma 2.7.12. Let r ∈ C ∞ ((0, ∞), X). Then (n) n (−1)n n+1 r(λ) (−1)m m (m) λ = λ r (λ) n! λ m! m=0
(2.23)
2.7. COMPLETELY MONOTONIC FUNCTIONS and
k+n
λ
r(λ) λn
(k) (n)
= λk r(k+n) (λ)
95
(2.24)
for all λ > 0, k, n ∈ N0 . In particular, if r is completely monotonic, then λ → r(λ)/λ is also completely monotonic. Proof. The first formula (2.23) is immediate from Leibniz’s rule. It follows that if r is completely monotonic, then λ → r(λ)/λ is also completely monotonic. We show by induction over n that (2.24) holds for all k ∈ N0 . It is obvious for n = 0. Moreover, (k+1) (k+1) (k) r(λ) r(λ) r(λ) λk r (k+1) (λ) = λk λ = λk λ + (k + 1) λ λ λ (k) r(λ) = λk+1 λ for λ > 0. This shows that (2.24) holds for n = 1. Now assume that (2.24) holds for a fixed n ∈ N and k ∈ N0 . Then, applying (2.24) to r yields (k) (n) r (λ) λk r (k+n+1) (λ) = λk+n (2.25) λn for λ > 0. Observe that λk+n+1 (r(λ)/λn+1 )(k) = λn · λk+1 (r(λ)/λn+1 )(k) = nλn−1 λk+1 (r(λ)/λn+1 )(k) + λn λk+1 (r(λ)/λn+1 )(k) = nλn−1 λk+1 (r(λ)/λn+1 )(k) + λn λk (r(λ)/λn )(k+1) , by applying (2.24) for n = 1 to the function r(λ)/λn instead of r. Hence, λk+n+1 (r(λ)/λn+1 )(k) ! "(k) ! "(k) = nλn+k r(λ)/λn+1 + λn+k r (λ)/λn − nr(λ)/λn+1 = λn+k (r (λ)/λn )
(k)
for λ > 0. It follows from (2.25) that (n+1) (n) = λn+k (r (λ)/λn )(k) = λk r(λ)(k+n+1) . λk+n+1 (r(λ)/λn+1 )(k) Thus, (2.24) holds when n is replaced by n + 1.
96
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
Proposition 2.7.13. Let F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X) and let ∞ r(λ) = λdF (λ) = λ e−λt dF (t)
(λ > 0).
0
Then r is completely monotonic if and only if F is convex and F (t) ≥ 0 (t ≥ 0). ∞ −λt Proof. Assume that r is completely monotonic. Note that r(λ) dF (t). λ = 0 e Thus, by the Post-Widder formula (Theorem 2.3.1), for t > 0 we have F (t) = limk→∞ Fk (t), where Fk (t) := Gk (k/t),
Gk (λ) :=
"(k) (−1)k k+1 ! λ r(λ)/λ2 . k!
By Lemma 2.7.12, λ → r(λ)/λ2 is completely monotonic, and it follows that ! " Fk (t) ≥ 0. We show that Fk is convex; i.e., that Fk (t) = − kt−2 Gk (k/t) ≥ 0. d Let H(λ) := −λ2 kGk (kλ). Then Fk (t) = dt H(1/t) = −t−2 H (1/t). Thus it suffices to show that H (λ) ≤ 0 or equivalently 2λkGk (kλ) + λ2 k 2 Gk (kλ) ≥ 0 for λ > 0. Letting μ := kλ we have to show that
(μGk (μ)) = 2Gk (μ) + μGk (μ) ≥ 0
(μ > 0).
This is true since (2.24) for n = 2 gives (μGk (μ)) =
(−1)k k+2 (−1)k k (k+2) μ (r(μ)/μ2 )(k) = μ r (μ) ≥ 0 k! k!
(μ > 0).
This proves one implication. ∗ Conversely, suppose that F is convex and F (t) ≥ 0 for all t ≥ 0. Let x∗ ∈ X+ . ∗ Then x ◦ F is convex, positive and Lipschitz continuous. There is an increasing, d bounded function g : R+ → R+ such that g(t) = dt F (t), x∗ a.e., and F (t), x∗ = t g(s) ds for all t ≥ 0 (see Proposition 2.7.9). We may assume that g(0) = 0. By 0 Proposition 1.10.1 and (1.22), (λ), x∗ = λˆ r(λ), x∗ = λdF g (λ) = dg(λ)
(λ > 0).
∗ Hence, x∗ ◦r is completely monotonic for all x∗ ∈ X+ and therefore r is completely monotonic.
Next we prove a representation theorem for completely monotonic functions defined on R+ (and not merely (0, ∞)). Proposition 2.7.14. Let r ∈ C ∞ (R+ , X) such that (−1)n r (n) (λ) ≥ 0 (λ ≥ 0). Then there exists a convex function F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X) such that F (t) ≥ 0 (t ≥ 0) and (λ) r(λ) = λdF
(λ > 0).
(2.26)
2.7. COMPLETELY MONOTONIC FUNCTIONS
97
Proof. It follows from (2.23) that for k ∈ N and λ > 0, (−1)k k+1 pk (λ) := λ k!
r(λ) λ
(k) =
k (−1)m m (m) λ r (λ) ≥ 0. m! m=0
Moreover, limλ↓0 pk (λ) = r(0). It follows from (2.24) for n = 1 that pk (λ) =
(−1)k k (k+1) λ r (λ) ≤ 0 k!
(λ > 0).
Thus 0 ≤ pk (λ) ≤ r(0) for all λ > 0. Since the cone is normal, this implies that the ∞ function r(λ) λ is in CW ((0, ∞), X). By Theorem 2.2.1, there exists F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X) r(λ) such that λ = dF (λ) (λ > 0). It follows from Proposition 2.7.13 that F is positive and convex. Theorem 2.7.15. A function r : (0, ∞) → X is completely monotonic if and only if there exists a convex function F : R+ → X+ satisfying F (0) = 0 and ω(F ) ≤ 0 such that ∞
r(λ) = λ
e−λt dF (t)
(λ > 0).
(2.27)
0
In that case, F is uniquely determined by r. ∗ Proof. a) Assume that r is of the form (2.27). Let x∗ ∈ X+ . Then there exists an increasing function f : R+ → R+ such that f (0) = 0 and
F (t), x∗ = Thus r(λ), x∗ =
0 ∞
t
f (s) ds (t ≥ 0).
e−λt df (t)
(λ > 0).
0
Hence, r(·), x∗ is completely monotonic and (−1)n r (n) (λ), x∗ = (−1)n
d dλ
n
r(λ), x∗ ≥ 0.
∗ Since x∗ ∈ X+ is arbitrary, it follows that r is completely monotonic. b) Conversely, let r be completely monotonic. By Proposition 2.7.14, there exists ∞ a convex function G ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X) such that G(t) ≥ 0 (t ≥ 0) and r(λ+1) = λ 0 e−λt dG(t) (λ > 0). Let
F (t) := 0
t
(1 − (t − s))es dG(s).
98
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
∗ Then F is positive and convex. In fact, let x∗ ∈ X+ . Then there exists an increast ∗ ing function g : R+ → R+ such that G(t), x = 0 g(s) ds and g(0) = 0. By Proposition 1.9.10, Fubini’s Theorem and (1.20),
∗
t
F (t), x =
e g(s) ds − 0 t s = e g(s) − 0
t = 0
t
s
(t − s)es g(s) ds r e g(r) dr ds
0 s
0
s
(t ≥ 0).
er dg(r) ds
0
∗ Thus x∗ ◦ F is positive and convex for all x∗ ∈ X+ , so F is positive and convex. By Proposition 1.10.1 and (1.22),
r(λ + 1), x∗ = λˆ g (λ) =
∞
e−λt dg(t)
0
for λ > 0. By Proposition 1.10.3, for λ > 1, ∞ r(λ), x∗ = e−λt et dg(t) = 0
where
f (t) := 0
t
∞
e−λt df (t),
0
e dg(s) = e g(t) − s
t
t
es g(s) ds,
0
t ∞ by (1.20). Since F (t), x∗ = 0 f (s) ds, it follows that r(λ) = λ 0 e−λt dF (t) . Moreover, applying for λ > 1. By Theorem 2.7.1, abs(dF ) is a singularity of dF Proposition 2.7.14 to r(· + δ) shows that r has a holomorphic extension to {λ ∈ C : Re λ > δ} for all δ > 0, and hence to {λ ∈ C : Re λ > 0}. It follows from (λ) = r(λ) for the uniqueness of holomorphic extensions that abs(dF ) ≤ 0 and dF λ > 0. By Theorem 1.10.5, ω(F ) ≤ 0 (actually, ω(F ) = 0 unless r ≡ 0). Finally, uniqueness of F follows from the Post-Widder formula (Theorem 2.3.1). Theorem 2.7.16. Assume that X has the interpolation property. Let r : (0, ∞) → X be completely monotonic. Then there exists an increasing function f : R+ → X+ such that f (0) = 0, ω(f ) ≤ 0 and r(λ) =
∞
e−λt df (t)
(λ > 0).
0
Proof. By Theorem 2.7.15, there exists a convexfunction F : R+ → X+ satisfying ∞ F (0) = 0 and ω(F ) ≤ 0 such that r(λ) = λ 0 e−λt dF (t) for all λ > 0. By Proposition 2.7.9, there exists an increasing function f : R+ → X+ such that
2.7. COMPLETELY MONOTONIC FUNCTIONS
99
t F (t) = 0 f (s) ds (t ≥ 0). We can assume that f (0) = 0. Let ω > 0. There exists M ≥ 0 such that F (t) ≤ M eωt . Since f is increasing we have
t f (t/2) ≤ 2
t
f (s) ds ≤ F (t).
t/2
It follows that ω(f ) ≤ 0 (actually, ω(f ) = 0 unless r ≡ 0). By Proposition 1.10.2, 0
∞
e−λt df (t) = λ
∞
e−λt dF (t) = r(λ)
(λ > 0).
0
Now we can prove Theorem 2.7.7. Proof of Theorem 2.7.7. One direction is given by Theorem 2.7.16. In order to prove the other, assume that Bernstein’s theorem holds in X. We show that X has the interpolation property. Let F : R+ → X+ be convex such that F (0) = 0 and ω(F ) = t 0. By Proposition 2.7.10, it suffices to show that F (t) = 0 f (s) ds (t ≥ 0) for some ∞ increasing function f : R+ → X. By Proposition 2.7.13, r(λ) := λ 0 e−λt dF (t) defines a completely monotonic function on (0, ∞). By assumption, there exists an increasing function f : R+ → X such that
∞
r(λ) =
e−λt df (t).
0
t We may assume that f (0) = 0. Let H(t) := 0 f (s) ds. Using Proposition 1.10.2 and (1.22), λ2 H(λ) = df (λ) = r(λ) = λ2 F (λ) for all λ > 0. It follows from the uniqueness theorem that H(t) = F (t) for all t ≥ 0. If r : (0, ∞) → X is completely monotonic, there may be many increasing functions f : R+ → X+ such that r = df . However, if X has order continuous norm, then we may pick out a normalized version of f . Let f : R+ → X be increasing and assume that X has order continuous norm. For t ≥ 0 we define f (t+) = lims↓t f (s), and for t > 0 we let f (t−) = lims↑t f (s). We say that f has a jump at t > 0 if f (t+) = f (t−). Lemma 2.7.17. Assume that X has order continuous norm and that f : R+ → X is increasing. Then the number of jumps of f is countable. Proof. Let τ > 0 and J := {t ∈ (0, τ ) : f (t+) = f (t−)}. Let ε > 0 and Jε := {t ∈ J : f (t+) − f (t−) ≥ ε}. We claim that Jε is finite. Otherwise there exist m tn ∈ Jε (n ∈ N), tn = tm for n = m. Let xn = f (tn +) − f (tn −). Then xn ≤ f (τ ) − f (0) for all m ∈ N. Since X has order continuous norm, the n=1 ∞ sum n=1xn converges. Hence, xn → 0 as n → ∞. This is a contradiction. Since J = n∈N J1/n , it follows that J is countable.
100
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
We continue to assume that X has order continuous norm. Let f : R+ → X be increasing. We define the normalization f ∗ : R+ → X of f by f (0+) if t = 0, ∗ f (t) = 1 (f (t+) + f (t−)) if t > 0. 2 The function f is called normalized if f = f ∗ . It follows from the definition of the Riemann-Stieltjes integral that t t g(s) df (s) = g(s) df ∗ (s) 0
0
for every t > 0 and every continuous function g : [0, t] → C. In fact, one may take a sequence of partitions (πn )n∈N with intermediate points which avoid the jumps of f ). Then S(g, f, πn ) = S(g, f ∗ , πn ) for all n ∈ N, and so 0
t
g(s) df (s) = lim S(g, f, πn ) = lim S(g, f ∗ , πn ) = n→∞
n→∞
t
g(s) df ∗ (s).
0
In conclusion, we obtain the following result. Theorem 2.7.18 (Bernstein’s theorem). Assume that X has order continuous norm. Let r : (0, ∞) → X be completely monotonic. Then there exists a unique normalized increasing function f : R+ → X such that f (0) = 0, ω(f ) ≤ 0 and ∞ r(λ) = e−λt df (t) (λ > 0). 0
Proof. Since X has the interpolation property, ∞ existence follows from Theorem 2.7.16. For uniqueness, suppose that r(λ) = 0 e−λt df (t) (λ > 0). By Proposition ∞ t 1.10.2, r(λ) = λ 0 e−λt dF (t) (λ > 0) where F (t) := 0 f (s) ds. It follows from Theorem 2.7.15 that F is uniquely determined by r. Since F (t+) := lim
1 (F (t + h) − F (t)) = f (t+) h
F (t−) := lim
1 (F (t) − F (t − h)) = f (t−) h
h↓0
if t ≥ 0, and h↓0
if t > 0, the normalized function f is also unique.
2.8
Notes
Section 2.1 Representation of operators from a space of the form L1 (Ω, μ) into a Banach space
2.8. NOTES
101
X by vector measures is a classical subject (see [DU77, Section III.1]). In view of the applications to Cauchy problems, Stieltjes integrals seem more appropriate than vector measures in our context. In the context of Laplace transform theory, the Riesz-Stieltjes Representation Theorem 2.1.1 appeared in a paper of Hennig and Neubrander [HN93] (see also [Neu94] and [BN94]). For a discussion of the representation of bounded linear operators in L(Lp (R+ ), X) as functions of bounded p -variation (1/p + 1/p = 1, p > 1), see the work of Weis [Wei93] and Vieten [Vie95]. Section 2.2 For real-valued functions, Theorem 2.2.1 was proved by Widder in 1936 [Wid36] (see also [Wid41]). In trying to extend scalar-valued Laplace transform theory to vector-valued functions, Hille [Hil48] remarks on several occasions that Widder’s theorem can be lifted to infinite dimensions if the space is reflexive, but not in general (see [Hil48, p.213] or [Miy56]). In fact, it was shown by Zaidman [Zai60] (see also [Are87b] or Theorem 2.2.3) that Widder’s theorem extends to a Banach space X if and only if X has the RadonNikodym property (for example, if X is reflexive). In 1965, Berens and Butzer [BB65] gave necessary and sufficient complex conditions for the Laplace-Stieltjes representability of functions in reflexive and uniformly convex Banach spaces. However, these results were of limited applicability. In general, important classes of Banach spaces that appear in studying evolution equations do not possess the Radon-Nikodym property. As a consequence, in the 1960s and 1970s Laplace transform methods were applied mainly to special vector-valued functions, like resolvents and semigroups, which have nice additional algebraic properties. In the theory of C0 -semigroups the link between the generator A and the semigroup T is given via the Laplace transform ∞ (λ − A)−1 x = e−λt T (t)x dt (x ∈ X). 0
The crucial algebraic property which made it possible to extend classical Laplace transform results to this abstract setting is the algebraic semigroup law T (t + s) = T (t)T (s), (t, s ≥ 0). Hille and Phillips comment in the foreword to [HP57] that “.... in keeping with the spirit of the times the algebraic tools now play a major role....” and that “.... the Laplace-Stieltjes transform methods..... have not been replaced but rather supplemented by the new tools.” The major disadvantage of the “algebraic approach” to linear evolution equations becomes obvious if one compares the mathematical theories associated with them (for example, semigroup theories, cosine families, the theory of integro-differential equations, etc.). It is striking how similar the results and techniques are. Still, without a Laplace transform theory for functions with values in arbitrary Banach spaces, every type of linear evolution equation required its own theory because the algebraic properties of the operator families changed from one case to another. In the late 1970s, in search of a general analytic principle behind all these theories, the study of Laplace transforms of functions with values in arbitrary Banach spaces was revitalized by Sova (see [Sov77] up to [Sov82]). An important result for Laplace transforms in Banach spaces is Theorem 2.6.1, proved by Sova in 1979 [Sov79b], [Sov79c]. This analytic representation theorem is behind every generation result for analytic solution families of linear evolution equations. The Real Representation Theorem 2.2.1 shows that the statement of Widder’s Theorem extends to arbitrary Banach spaces if the Laplace transform is replaced by the Laplace-Stieltjes transform. It is due to [Are87b] where it was deduced from the scalar result by Widder [Wid41] by duality arguments. The proof of Theorem 2.2.1 given here is
102
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
a modification of Widder’s original proof given in [Wid41]; see [HN93]. Further extensions of these results are given in [Bob97a], [Bob97b], [Kis00], [Bob01] and [Cho02]. The characterization of the range of the Laplace-Stieltjes transform acting on Lip0 (R+ , X) given in Theorem 2.2.1 is based on the Post-Widder inversion formula in Theorem 1.7.7. Corresponding to other inversion formulas, equivalent descriptions can be formulated. Employing the complex inversion formula (see [Sov80b], [BN94]), or the Phragm´en-Doetsch inversion (see [PC98]), one can prove that the following growth and regularity conditions are equivalent. Theorem 2.8.1. Let r : (0, ∞) → X be continuous. The following are equivalent: (i) r ∈ C ∞ ((0, ∞), X) and
k+1 λ (k) < ∞. sup r (λ) k! λ>0
k∈N0
(ii) limλ→∞ r(λ) = 0 and r has an extension to a holomorphic function r : {Re λ > 0} → X such that, for all γ > 0, supRe λ>γ r(λ) < ∞ and ∞ 1 r(γ + it) < ∞. sup dt 2π k+2 s>0 −∞ (1 − ist) k∈N0
(iii) supλ>0 λr(λ) < ∞ and ∞ (−1)j−1 jk sup e λr(jλ) < ∞. (j − 1)! λ>0 j=1 k∈N
For a discussion of the Lp -conditions ∞ k+1 p 1 (k) k k r dt ≤ M t k! t 0
for all k ≥ 0,
and their connection to the representability of r as the Laplace transform of a function of bounded p-variation (p > 1), see [Wid41, Chapter VII], [Lev69], [Sov81a], [Wei93], and ∞ [Vie95]. It is shown in [KMV03] τ −λtthat a function r ∈ C ((0, ∞), X) is the finite LaplaceStieltjes transform r(λ) = 0 e dF (t) of a Lipschitz continuous function F : [0, τ ] → X with F (t) − F (s) ≤ M |t − s| for all 0 ≤ t, s ≤ τ if and only if k+1 λ (k) ≤M sup sup r (λ) k! k∈N0 λ>k/τ and sup
sup
k∈N λ∈(0,k/τ )
−k λτ (k) τ e r (λ) < ∞.
Section 2.3 Theorem 2.3.2 goes back to Phragm´en’s proof of the Uniqueness Theorem 1.7.3 (see [Phr04]), and to Doetsch [Doe37] who recognized the usefulness of the formula as an inversion procedure (see also [Doe50, Volume I, Section 8.1]). The Phragm´en-Doetsch inversion formula shows that a Laplace transformable function f is determined by the
2.8. NOTES
103
values of fˆ(λn ), where λn = n ≥ n0 . An extension of the Phragm´ en-Doetsch inversion −1 to arbitrary M¨ untz sequences (λn ) ⊂ R+ (i.e., λn+1 − λn ≥ 1 and ∞ n=1 λn = ∞), has been obtained by B¨ aumer [B¨ au03] (see also [BLN99]). There does not seem to be any inversion formula that holds for arbitrary uniqueness sequences (see Theorem 1.11.1). Corollary 2.3.3 is taken from [BN96] and is one of the key ingredients in the theory of asymptotic Laplace transforms (see [LN99], [LN01]). Whereas the complex inversion formula in Theorem 2.3.4 (the proof given here is from [HN93]) is in general affected by exponentially decaying perturbations of the Laplace transform, the following modification, due to Lyubich [Lyu66], gives a complex inversion formula which holds locally even if the transform undergoes such perturbations. ∞ Theorem 2.8.2. Let τ > 0, ω > 0, F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X), and q(λ) = 0 e−λt dF (t) + a(λ) (λ > 0), where a ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) is a function with lim supλ→∞ λ1 log a(λ) ≤ −τ . Then ∞ 1 q(t) H(μ) := eμt dt 2πi ω t is well defined for Re μ < 0, has a holomorphic continuation to the sliced half-plane {μ : Re μ < τ } \ [0, τ ), and F (t) = lim (H(t + iε) − H(t − iε)) ε→0
for all t ∈ [0, τ ).
Haase [Haa08] has given a different approach to Theorem 2.3.4 and Lemma 2.3.5. Section 2.4 With the exception of Proposition 2.4.3 which is due to Doetsch (see [Doe50, Volume I, Section 14.3]) and Corollary 2.4.4, the results are straightforward reformulations of the main theorems of the sections 2.1–2.3. Using a Phragm´ type inversion formula en-Doetsch −1 along sequences (λn ) ⊂ R+ with λn+1 − λn ≥ 1 and ∞ untz sequences), n=1 λn = ∞ (M¨ one can strengthen the statement of Proposition 2.4.3 as follows (see [B¨ au03]). Theorem 2.8.3. Let 0 ≤ τ and let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) with abs(f ) < ∞. Then the following are equivalent: (i) f (t) = 0 almost everywhere on [0, τ ] and τ ∈ supp(f ). (ii) Every M¨ untz sequence (βn ) satisfies lim supn→∞
1 βn
log fˆ(βn ) = −τ.
(iii) For every M¨ untz sequence (βn ) there exists a M¨ untz subsequence (βnk ) such that lim
k→∞
1 log fˆ(βnk ) = −τ. β nk
(iv) There exists a M¨ untz sequence (βn ) with lim supn→∞ (v) lim supλ→∞
1 λ
1 βn
log fˆ(βn ) = −τ.
log fˆ(λ) = −τ .
As a consequence of these equivalences one obtains the following short proof of Titchmarsh’s theorem (see [B¨ au03], [BLN99] or [MB87, Section VI.7]). Corollary 2.8.4 (Titchmarsh’s Theorem). Let k ∈ L1 [0, τ ] with 0 ∈ supp(k) and f ∈ L1 ([0, τ ], X). If k f = 0 on [0, τ ], then f = 0.
104
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
Proof. We extend k and f by zero to R+ . Then, by Proposition 2.4.3 and Corollary ˆ 2.4.4, lim supλ→∞ λ1 log |k(λ)| = 0 and lim supλ→∞ λ1 log k f (λ) ≤ −T . By taking subsequences, it follows from the theorem above that there exists a M¨ untz sequence (βn ) ˆ n )| = 0 and such that limn→∞ β1n log |k(β −τ ≥ lim
n→∞
1 log k f (βn )
βn
= =
1 ˆ n )| + lim 1 log fˆ(βn )
log |k(β n→∞ βn βn 1 lim log fˆ(βn ) . n→∞ βn lim
n→∞
Thus, f = 0 on [0, τ ]. A function k ∈ L1loc (R+ ) with abs(k) < ∞ is a regularizing function if lim sup λ→∞
1 ˆ log |k(λ)| = 0, λ
or, equivalently, if 0 ∈ supp(k) (by Corollary 2.4.4). By the Titchmarsh-Foia¸s theorem (see [BLN99]), the condition 0 ∈ supp(k) t is necessary and sufficient for the convolution operator K : f → k ∗ f , (k ∗ f )(t) := 0 k(t − s)f (s) ds to be an injective operator on C(R+ , X) with dense range in the Fr´echet space C∗ (R+ , X) of all continuous functions g : R+ → X such that g(0) = 0, equipped with the seminorms g n := supt∈[0,n] g(t) . Moreover, f K,n := supt∈[0,n] Kf (t) defines a family of seminorms on C(R+ , X) and K extends to an isomorphism between the Fr echet completion C [k] (R+ , X) of C(R+ , X) with respect to that family of seminorms and the Fr´echet space C∗ (R+ , X). Typical examples of regularizing functions are k(t) =
kδ (t) = Note that k1/2 (t) =
1 2πi
tb−1 Γ(b)
with δ
etλ−λ dλ
1 ˆ k(λ) = b (b > 0), λ with
or δ
ˆδ (λ) = e−λ (0 < δ < 1). k
ω+iR
1 √ t−3/2 e−1/4t 2 π
(see Lemma 1.6.7).
If k is a regularizing function, then the elements of the Fr´echet space C [k] (R+ , X) are called k-generalized functions. A k-generalized function u is said to be Laplace transformable if the continuous function f := k ∗ u ∈ C∗ (R+ , X) is Laplace transformable and the Laplace transform of u is defined as u ˆ(λ) :=
fˆ(λ) . ˆ k(λ)
Let H = {λ : Re λ > ω} and m : H → C be holomorphic. A meromorphic function q : H → X is said to have an m-multiplied Laplace representation if there exists f ∈ ˆ for some regularizing C∗ (R+ , X) with abs(f ) ≤ ω such that mq = fˆ on H. If m = k function k, then the meromorphic function q has a Laplace representation q = u ˆ for u = K−1 f ∈ C [k] (R+ , X) (see [B¨ au97], [BLN99], and [LN99]). Section 2.5 Theorem 2.5.1 is a standard result of Laplace transform theory. Corollary 2.5.2 is due to
2.8. NOTES
105
Pr¨ uss [Pr¨ u93], the proof given here is from [BN94]. Corollary 2.5.4 is a special case of results in [DVW02] (see also [DHW97]). Theorem 2.5.1 can be interpreted in terms of k-generalized functions and Laplace transforms (see the Notes of Section 2.4; we use the same notation here). Let q : H → X be holomorphic with supλ∈H λq(λ) < ∞. As shown in Theorem 2.5.1, for all b > 0 there ˆ exists f ∈ C∗ (R+ , X) such that q(λ) = λb fˆ(λ) on H. Thus, q(λ) = u ˆ(λ) = f (λ) , where ˆ k(λ)
1 k(t) = Γ(b) tb−1 and u = K−1 f ∈ C [k] (R+ , X) coincides with the b-th (distributional) derivative of f . More generally, if q is a meromorphic function on some half-plane H with ˆ0 (λ)q(λ) is holomorphic on H and values in X for which λ → λk
ˆ0 (λ)q(λ) < ∞ sup λk
λ∈H
for some regularizing function k0 , then it follows from Theorem 2.5.1 that there exists ˆ0 (λ)q(λ) = k(λ)q(λ) ˆ f ∈ C∗ (R+ , X) such that λ1 k = fˆ(λ) or q(λ) = u ˆ(λ), where k := [k] 1 ∗ k0 and u ∈ C (R+ , X) is a generalized function such that f = k ∗ u. Notice that if ki are regularizing functions and k1 ∗ k2 = k3 , then C [k1 ] (R+ , X) is continuously embedded in C [k3 ] (R+ , X). Thus, a faster growing q will have a less regular u such that q = u ˆ. Section 2.6 Theorem 2.6.1 is due to Sova [Sov79b] and Theorem 2.6.2 is taken from [Neu89b]. Section 2.7. In 1893, Stieltjes proved in a letter to Hermite that a bounded continuous function f : R+ → R is positive if and only if fˆ(n) (λ) ≥ 0 for all n ∈ N0 and all λ sufficiently large (see [BB05]). Bernstein proved his theorem in 1928 [Ber28]. The characterization of those ordered Banach spaces in which Bernstein’s theorem (Theorem 2.7.7) holds is due to Arendt [Are94a]. The interpolation property is of particular interest for spaces of the form C(K), where K is a compact space. Then it can be described in terms of K: the space C(K) has the interpolation property if and only if K is an F -space (i.e., if A, B ⊂ K are open and disjoint Fσ -sets, then A ∩ B = ∅). Note that C(K) is σ-order complete if and only ¯ is open). For example, if K is quasi-stonean (i.e., if A ⊂ K is an open Fσ -set, then A ˇ K := βN \ N is a F -space which is not quasi-stonean (where βN denotes the Stone-Cech compactification of N). Whereas every quasi-stonean space K is totally disconnected (i.e. the connected component of each point x is {x}), there exist connected compact F spaces. One reason why these spaces have been studied is that C(K) has the Grothendieck property (see Section 4.3) if K is an F -space. We refer to the article by Seever [See68] for this and further information. The interpolation property is also equivalent to two other vector-valued versions of classical theorems; namely, Riesz’s representation theorem for positive functionals on C[0, 1] and Hausdorff’s theorem on the moment problem. More precisely, the following is proved in [Are94a]. Theorem 2.8.5. Let X be an ordered Banach space with normal cone. The following are equivalent: (i) X has the interpolation property. (ii) For every positive T ∈ L(C[0, 1], X) there exists an increasing function f : [0, 1] → 1 X such that T g = 0 g(t) df (t) for all g ∈ C[0, 1].
106
2. THE LAPLACE TRANSFORM
(iii) For each completely monotonic sequence 1 (xn )n∈N in X there exists an increasing function f : [0, 1] → X such that xn = 0 tn df (t) (n ∈ N). Here, a sequence x = (xn )n∈N is called completely monotonic if (−Δ)k x ≥ 0 for all k ∈ N where Δ : X N → X N is given by Δx = (xn+1 − xn )n∈N . Bernstein’s theorem in ordered Banach spaces with order continuous norm (Theorem 2.7.18) is proved in [Are87a] with the help of the classical scalar theorem. A first vector-valued version of Bernstein’s theorem is due to Bochner [Boc42]. But Bochner considered convergence in order, whereas for our purposes norm convergence of RiemannStieltjes sums and improper integrals is essential in order to make the results applicable to operator theory. Here we deduce Bernstein’s theorem from the Real Representation Theorem 2.2.1. One can obtain Widder’s theorem (the scalar case of Theorem 2.2.1) as an easy corollary of Bernstein’s classical result (see [Wid71, Section 6.8]). However this argument is restricted to the scalar case. On the other hand, it is possible to deduce the vectorvalued version of Theorem 2.2.1 from the scalar case by a duality argument (see [Are87b] and the Notes of Section 2.2).
Chapter 3
Cauchy Problems In this chapter we study systematically well-posedness of the Cauchy problem. Given a closed operator A on a Banach space X we will see in Section 3.1 that the abstract Cauchy problem u (t) = Au(t) (t ≥ 0), u(0) = x, is mildly well-posed (i.e., for each x ∈ X there exists a unique mild solution) if and only if the resolvent of A is a Laplace transform; and this in turn is the same as saying that A generates a C0 -semigroup. Well-posedness in a weaker sense will lead to generators of integrated semigroups (Section 3.2). The real representation theorem from Section 2.2 will give us directly the characterization of generators of C0 -semigroups in terms of a resolvent estimate; namely, the Hille-Yosida theorem. When the operators are not densely defined, we obtain Hille-Yosida operators which are studied in detail in Section 3.5. Also for results on approximation of semigroups in Section 3.6 we can use corresponding results on Laplace transforms from Section 1.7. Much attention is given to holomorphic semigroups which are particularly simple to characterize by means of the results of Section 2.6. We consider not only holomorphic semigroups which are strongly continuous at 0, but more general holomorphic semigroups which will be useful in applications to the heat equation with Dirichlet boundary conditions in Chapter 6. When the holomorphic semigroup exists on the right half-plane, the boundary behaviour is of special interest. If the semigroup is locally bounded, then a boundary C0 -group is obtained on the imaginary axis. This case is particularly important for fractional powers (see also the Notes of Section 3.7) and for the second order problem (Section 3.16). When the holomorphic semigroup is polynomially bounded we obtain ktimes integrated semigroups where the k depends on the degree of the polynomial. A typical example is the Gaussian semigroup. Its boundary is governed by the Schr¨ odinger operator iΔ, which we study in Section 3.9 and in Chapter 8. The last
W. Arendt et al., Vector-valued Laplace Transforms and Cauchy Problems: Second Edition, Monographs in Mathematics 96, DOI 10.1007/978-3-0348-0087-7_3, © Springer Basel AG 2011
107
108
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
three sections are devoted to the second order Cauchy problem; i.e., to the theory of cosine functions. A central result will be to establish a unique phase space on which the associated system is well-posed. This is a particularly interesting special case of the intermediate spaces which are constructed in Section 3.10 for integrated semigroups. In two places we will give results for UMD-spaces which are not valid in general Banach spaces: in Section 3.12 where we establish a particularly simple complex inversion formula for semigroups, and in Section 3.16 where we prove Fattorini’s remarkable theorem on the square root reduction. There is no special section on perturbation theory, but we prove perturbation results for Hille-Yosida operators, integrated semigroups and generators of cosine functions in the corresponding sections. For holomorphic semigroups we consider not only “relatively small perturbations” but also “compact perturbations” with respect to A. This chapter contains some interesting examples of holomorphic semigroups in Sections 3.7 and 3.9, but for real applications we refer to Part III. Throughout this chapter we will make extensive use (sometimes without comment) of notation, terminology and basic properties of closed operators which may be found in Appendix B. In some examples we shall use some basic notions of distributions and Sobolev spaces which may be found in Appendix E.
3.1
C0 -semigroups and Cauchy Problems
Let A be a closed operator on a Banach space X. We consider the abstract Cauchy problem u (t) = Au(t) (t ≥ 0), (ACP0 ) u(0) = x, where x ∈ X. By a classical solution of (ACP0 ) we understand a function u ∈ C 1 (R+ , X) such that u(t) ∈ D(A) for all t ≥ 0 and (ACP0 ) holds. If a classical solution exists, then it follows that x = u(0) ∈ D(A). It will be useful to find a weaker notion of solution where x may be arbitrary. This can be done by integrating the equation. Assume that u is a classical solution. Since A is closed, it follows from Proposition 1.1.7 that t t u(s) ds ∈ D(A) and A u(s) ds = u(t) − x (t ≥ 0). (3.1) 0
0
Definition 3.1.1. A function u ∈ C(R+ , X) is called a mild solution of (ACP0 ) if (3.1) holds. The following assertion shows that mild and classical solutions differ merely by regularity. Proposition 3.1.2. A mild solution u of (ACP0 ) is a classical solution if and only if u ∈ C 1 (R+ , X).
3.1. C0 -SEMIGROUPS AND CAUCHY PROBLEMS
109
Proof. Assume that u ∈ C 1 (R+ , X). Let t ≥ 0. Then 1 1 (u(t + h) − u(t)) = A h h
t+h
u(s) ds t
for all h = 0 small enough (h > 0 if t = 0). Since A is closed, it follows that 1 u(t) = lim h→0 h u (t) = Au(t).
t+h
u(s) ds ∈ D(A) and
t
Next we want to characterize mild solutions with the help of Laplace transforms. Let u ∈ C(R+ , X). Recall from (1.12) that abs(u) < ∞ if and only if
t
ωt
u(s) ds (t ≥ 0) (3.2)
≤ Me 0
for some M, ω ≥ 0. As before, we denote by ∞ u ˆ(λ) := e−λt u(t) dt (λ > ω) 0
the Laplace transform of u. Theorem 3.1.3. Let u ∈ C(R+ , X) such that (3.2) holds. Then the following assertions are equivalent: (i) u is a mild solution of (ACP0 ). (ii) u ˆ(λ) ∈ D(A) and λˆ u(λ) − Aˆ u(λ) = x for all λ > ω. Proof. (i) ⇒ (ii): Let u be a mild solution. Let λ > ω. We know from (1.11) that ∞ t −λt u ˆ(λ) = λ e u(s) ds dt. 0
0
Since A is closed, it follows from Proposition 1.6.3 that u ˆ(λ) ∈ D(A) and ∞ t Aˆ u(λ) = λ e−λt A u(s) ds dt 0 0 ∞ = λ e−λt (u(t) − x) dt 0
= (ii) ⇒ (i): Let v(t) :=
t 0
λˆ u(λ) − x.
u(s) ds. Then by (1.11), vˆ(λ) = u ˆ(λ)/λ ∈ D(A) and
Aˆ v (λ) = Aˆ u(λ)/λ = u ˆ(λ) − x/λ = fˆ(λ)
(λ > ω),
110
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
where f (t) := u(t) − x (t ≥ 0). It follows from Proposition 1.7.6 that v(t) ∈ D(A) and Av(t) = f (t) = u(t) − x for all t ≥ 0; i.e., u is a mild solution of (ACP0 ). Let u be a mild solution of (ACP0 ) satisfying (3.2). Assume that ω < λ ∈ ρ(A). Then it follows from Theorem 3.1.3 that u ˆ(λ) = R(λ, A)x. Thus the Laplace transform of a mild solution is the resolvent applied to the initial value. This leads us to consider operators whose resolvent exists on a half-line and is a Laplace transform. For this, let T : R+ → L(X) be strongly continuous. Recall from Proposition 1.4.5 that abs(T ) < ∞ if and only if
t
ωt
T (s)x ds (t ≥ 0, x ∈ X) (3.3)
≤ M e x
0
for some ω ≥ 0, M ≥ 0. In that case, abs(T ) ≤ ω and t ˆ T (λ)x := lim e−λs T (s)x ds t→∞
0
defines a bounded operator Tˆ (λ) ∈ L(X) whenever Re λ > abs(T ). Moreover, Tˆ : {Re λ > abs(T )} → L(X) is holomorphic (see Section 1.5). As in Sections 1.4 and 1.5, we denote by ω(T ) the exponential growth bound of T , and by hol(Tˆ ) the abscissa of holomorphy of Tˆ . Recall that hol(Tˆ) ≤ abs(T ) ≤ ω(T ). We will consider Laplace transforms of operator-valued functions on many occasions in this and subsequent chapters. The following definition will be helpful. Definition 3.1.4. Let λ0 ∈ R and let R : (λ0 , ∞) → L(X) be a function. We say that R is a Laplace transform if there exists a strongly continuous function T : R+ → L(X) such that abs(T ) ≤ λ0 and R(λ) = Tˆ (λ)
(λ > λ0 ).
The following proposition is a simple consequence of the uniqueness theorem. Proposition 3.1.5. Let T : R+ → L(X) be strongly continuous such that abs(T ) < ∞. Let ω > abs(T ). Then the following hold: a) If B ∈ L(X) such that B Tˆ(λ) = Tˆ (λ)B for all λ > ω, then BT (t) = T (t)B for all t ≥ 0. b) In particular, if Tˆ(μ)Tˆ (λ) = Tˆ (λ)Tˆ(μ) for all λ, μ > 0, then T (t)T (s) = T (s)T (t) for all t, s ≥ 0. Proof. a) For x ∈ X and λ > ω, one has ∞ e−λt T (t)Bx dt = Tˆ (λ)Bx = B Tˆ (λ)x = 0
0
∞
e−λt BT (t)x dt.
3.1. C0 -SEMIGROUPS AND CAUCHY PROBLEMS
111
It follows from the uniqueness theorem that T (t)Bx = BT (t)x for all t ≥ 0. b) Let μ > ω. It follows from a) that Tˆ(μ)T (t) = T (t)Tˆ (μ) for all t ≥ 0. Fixing t ≥ 0 and applying a) to B := T (t) shows that T (s)T (t) = T (t)T (s) for all s ≥ 0. Now we introduce C0 -semigroups. Definition 3.1.6. A C0 -semigroup is a strongly continuous function T : R+ → L(X) such that T (t + s) T (0)
= T (t)T (s)
(t, s ≥ 0),
= I.
In the next theorem we show that C0 -semigroups are exactly those strongly continuous operator-valued functions whose Laplace transforms are resolvents. It is remarkable that C0 -semigroups are automatically exponentially bounded. Theorem 3.1.7. Let T : R+ → L(X) be a strongly continuous function. The following assertions are equivalent: (i) abs(T ) < ∞ and there exists an operator A such that (λ0 , ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and Tˆ (λ) = R(λ, A)
(λ > λ0 )
for some λ0 > abs(T ). (ii) T is a C0 -semigroup. In that case, ω(T ) < ∞, {Re λ > hol(Tˆ)} ⊂ ρ(A) and Tˆ(λ) = R(λ, A) whenever Re λ > hol(Tˆ). Proof. a) Let T be a C0 -semigroup. We show first that ω(T ) < ∞. Let M := sup0≤t≤1 T (t) . Then M < ∞ by the uniform boundedness principle. Let ω = log M . Let t ∈ R+ . Take n ∈ N0 and s ∈ [0, 1) such that t = n + s. Then
T (t) = T (s)T (1)n ≤ M M n = M eωn ≤ M eωt . b) Assume that abs(T ) < ∞. Let μ > λ > abs(T ). Then integration by parts yields for x ∈ X, ∞ ∞ Tˆ(λ)x − Tˆ(μ)x 1 = e(λ−μ)t Tˆ (λ)x dt − e(λ−μ)t e−λt T (t)x dt μ−λ μ − λ 0 0 ∞ ∞ (λ−μ)t −λs = e e T (s)x ds dt 0 0 ∞ t − e(λ−μ)t e−λs T (s)x ds dt ∞0 ∞0 (λ−μ)t = e e−λs T (s)x ds dt 0
t
112
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
∞
=
e 0
=
∞
−μt
∞
∞
t
e−μt
0
e−λ(s−t) T (s)x ds dt e−λs T (s + t)x ds dt.
0
On the other hand, Tˆ (μ)Tˆ(λ)x = 0
∞
e−μt
∞
e−λs T (s)T (t)x ds dt.
0
So it follows from the uniqueness theorem (Theorem 1.7.3) that (Tˆ (λ))λ>abs(T ) is a pseudo-resolvent (see Appendix B) if and only if T satisfies T (s + t) = T (s)T (t) (s, t ≥ 0). Now assume that Tˆ is a pseudo-resolvent. Then T (0) is a projection. Moreover, T (0)x = 0 if and only if T (t)x = T (t)T (0)x = 0 for all t ≥ 0. Thus by the uniqueness theorem, T (0)x = 0 if and only if Tˆ (λ)x = 0 (λ > ω(T )). By Proposition B.6, (Tˆ(λ))λ>abs(T ) is a resolvent if and only if T (0) = I. This proves that (i) ⇔ (ii). c) It follows from (i) and Proposition B.5 that {Re λ > hol(Tˆ )} ⊂ ρ(A) and ˆ T (λ) = R(λ, A) whenever Re λ > hol(Tˆ). Definition 3.1.8. Let T be a C0 -semigroup. The generator of T is defined as the operator A on X such that (ω(T ), ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and Tˆ(λ) = R(λ, A) for all λ > ω(T ). Thus, an operator A is the generator of a C0 -semigroup if and only if its resolvent is a Laplace transform in the sense of Definiton 3.1.4. In the following proposition we collect the diverse relations of a C0 -semigroup and its generator. These properties will be used frequently without further reference. Proposition 3.1.9. Let T be a C0 -semigroup on X and let A be its generator. Then the following properties hold: a) limλ→∞ λR(λ, A)x = x for all x ∈ X; in particular, A is densely defined. b) For all x ∈ X, the function ux (t) := T (t)x is a mild solution of (ACP0 ). c) R(λ, A)T (t) = T (t)R(λ, A) for all λ ∈ ρ(A) and t ≥ 0. d) x ∈ D(A) implies T (t)x ∈ D(A) and AT (t)x = T (t)Ax. t t e) 0 T (s)x ds ∈ D(A) and A 0 T (s)x ds = T (t)x − x for all x ∈ X and t ≥ 0. t f) Let x, y ∈ X. Then x ∈ D(A) and Ax = y if and only if 0 T (s)y ds = T (t)x − x for all t ≥ 0. g) Let x ∈ X. Then x ∈ D(A) if and only if y = limt↓0 1t (T (t)x − x) exists. In that case, Ax = y.
3.1. C0 -SEMIGROUPS AND CAUCHY PROBLEMS
113
h) T (·)x is a classical solution of (ACP0 ) if and only if x ∈ D(A). i) If λ ∈ C then (eλt T (t))t≥0 is a C0 -semigroup and A + λ is its generator. j) Let x ∈ X and λ ∈ C. Then x ∈ D(A) and Ax = λx if and only if T (t)x = eλt x for all t ≥ 0. Proof. a) follows from the following Abelian argument. There exist M ≥ 0 and ω ∈ R such that
T (t) ≤ M eωt (t ≥ 0). Let ε > 0 and x ∈ X. There exists τ > 0 such that T (t)x−x ≤ ε for all t ∈ [0, τ ]. Therefore lim sup λR(λ, A)x − x
λ→∞
∞
−λt
≤ lim sup λ e (T (t)x − x) dt
λ→∞ 0 τ ∞ −λt −λt ωt ≤ lim sup λ e ε dt + λ e (M e + 1) dt x
λ→∞
0
τ
= ε.
b) By Theorem 3.1.3, a function u ∈ C(R+ , X) is a mild solution if and only if u ˆ(λ) = R(λ, A)x = Tˆ (λ)x for all λ > ω(T ). So the claim follows from the uniqueness theorem. c) follows from Proposition 3.1.5. d) follows from c) (by Proposition B.7). e) follows from b). t f) Let x ∈ D(A). Then by d), T (s)Ax = AT (s)x. Hence by e), 0 T (s)Ax ds t t = A 0 T (s)x ds = T (t)x − x. Conversely, let x, y ∈ X such that 0 T (s)y ds = T (t)x − x for all t ≥ 0. Then ∞ t −λt R(λ, A)y = λ e T (s)y ds dt 0 0 ∞ = λ e−λt (T (t)x − x) dt 0
= λR(λ, A)x − x. Thus x ∈ D(A) and y = λx − (λ − A)x = Ax. t g) Let x ∈ D(A). Then by f), 1t (T (t)x − x) = 1t 0 T (s)Ax ds → Ax as t → 0. t Conversely, let x, y ∈ X such that y = limt↓0 1t (T (t)x − x) = limt↓0 1t A 0 T (s)x ds. Since A is closed, it follows that x ∈ D(A) and Ax = y. t h) Let x ∈ D(A). Then T (t)x = x + 0 T (s)Ax ds by e). Thus, T (·)x ∈ C 1 (R+ , X) and the claim follows from Proposition 3.1.2. Conversely, if T (·)x is a classical solution, then x = T (0)x ∈ D(A) by definition.
114
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
i) follows from Theorem 3.1.7. j) Replacing A by A − λ we may assume that λ = 0. Now the claim follows from f). Property g) is sometimes expressed by saying that A is the infinitesimal generator of T . Since almost all the C0 -semigroups which arise naturally from differential operators cannot be written down explicitly, we do not give examples in this section. However the reader who wishes to see explicit examples may look already to Examples 3.3.10, 3.4.8, 3.7.5, 3.7.6 and 3.7.9, and to various examples in Chapter 5. We note here that if T : R+ → L(X) satisfies T (t + s) = T (t)T (s) (t, s ≥ 0) and limt↓0 T (t)x − x = 0 (x ∈ X), then T is a C0 -semigroup. To see this, we have to show that T is strongly continuous at t > 0. Right-continuity follows immediately from the estimate T (t + h)x − T (t)x ≤ T (t) T (h)x − x . For left-continuity, note that the assumptions imply that there exist M > 0 and δ > 0 such that T (h) ≤ M whenever 0 < h < δ (otherwise, there exist tn ↓ 0 such that T (tn ) → ∞ and, by the uniform boundedness theorem, there exists x ∈ X such that (T (tn )x) is unbounded, which is a contradiction). Hence for 0 < h < δ, we have (T (t − h)x − T (t)x ≤ T (δ − h) T (t − δ) x − T (h)x → 0 as h ↓ 0. Since T (0)T (t)x = T (t)x, letting t ↓ 0 shows that T (0) = I. The following result characterizes C0 -semigroups which are norm-continuous on R+ . It also describes the situation when the generator A of a C0 -semigroup T is bounded. Since A is closed, this is equivalent to saying that D(A) = X. Theorem 3.1.10. Let A be the generator of a C0 -semigroup T . The following assertions are equivalent: (i) The operator A is bounded; i.e., D(A) = X. (ii) limt↓0 T (t) − I = 0. In that case, T (t) = etA :=
∞ k=0
tk Ak k!
(t ≥ 0).
∞ tk Ak Proof. (i) ⇒ (ii): Assume that A is bounded. Then clearly, T (t) := k=0 k! defines a continuous mapping T : R+ → L(X) such that T (0) = I and T (t) ≤ et A . Let λ > A . Then ∞ ∞ ∞ Ak ∞ −λt k e−λt T (t) dt = e t dt = Ak λ−(k+1) = R(λ, A). k! 0 0 k=0
k=0
Thus, T is a C0 -semigroup and A is its generator by Definition 3.1.8. (ii) ⇒ (i): It follows from Proposition 4.1.3 or direct computation as in the proof of Proposition 3.1.9 a) that limλ→∞ λR(λ, A) − I = 0. Thus, there exists λ > ω(T ) such that λR(λ, A) − I < 1/2. This implies that λR(λ, A) is invertible in L(X). In particular, D(A) = λR(λ, A)X = X. Now we consider uniqueness of mild solutions of (ACP )0 .
3.1. C0 -SEMIGROUPS AND CAUCHY PROBLEMS
115
Proposition 3.1.11. Let T be a C0 -semigroup and A be its generator. Let τ > t 0, x ∈ X. Let u ∈ C([0, τ ], X) such that 0 u(s) ds ∈ D(A) and
t
u(s) ds = u(t) − x
A 0
for all t ∈ [0, τ ]. Then u(t) = T (t)x. t Proof. Let v(t) = 0 (u(s) − T (s)x) ds. Then by hypothesis and by Proposition 3.1.9 e), v(t) ∈ D(A) (0 ≤ t ≤ τ ). Moreover, v (t) = Av(t) (0 ≤ t ≤ τ ) and t v(0) = 0. We show that v ≡ 0. Let S(t)y := 0 T (s)y ds. Then S(t)y ∈ D(A) and AS(t)y = T (t)y − y for all y ∈ X, by Proposition 3.1.9 e). Let 0 < t ≤ τ, w(s) := S(t − s)v(s), 0 ≤ s ≤ t. Then w (s)
= −T (t − s)v(s) + S(t − s)v (s) = −T (t − s)v(s) + S(t − s)Av(s) = −T (t − s)v(s) + AS(t − s)v(s) = −v(s).
Since w(t) = w(0) = 0, we conclude that 0 = w(t) = 0
t
w (s) ds = −
t
v(s) ds. 0
Since t ∈ (0, τ ] is arbitrary, it follows that v(s) = 0 for s ∈ [0, τ ]. Proposition 3.1.9 and Proposition 3.1.11 show in particular that the abstract Cauchy problem (ACP0 ) is well-posed (in the sense of mild solutions) whenever the operator A generates a C0 -semigroup T . Moreover, the orbits are given by T (·)x where x is the initial value. Now we show the converse assertion. If (ACP0 ) is mildly well-posed (i.e., for each x there exists a unique mild solution), then the operator generates a C0 -semigroup. More precisely, we have the following result. Theorem 3.1.12. Let A be a closed operator. The following assertions are equivalent: (i) For all x ∈ X there exists a unique mild solution of (ACP0 ). (ii) The operator A generates a C0 -semigroup. (iii) ρ(A) = ∅ and for all x ∈ D(A) there exists a unique classical solution of (ACP0 ). When these assertions hold, the mild solution of (ACP0 ) is given by u(t) = T (t)x.
116
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Proof. (i) ⇒ (ii): Let ux be the mild solution for the initial value x ∈ X. It follows from uniqueness that ux (t) is linear in x. So for each t ≥ 0 there exists a linear mapping T (t) : X → X such that T (t)x = ux (t) for all x ∈ X. We show that T (t) is continuous. Denote by Φ : X → C(R+ , X) the mapping Φ(x) = ux . Note that C(R+ , X) is a Fr´echet space for the topology of uniform convergence on intervals of the form [0, τ ] where τ > 0. The mapping Φ is linear. We show that Φ has a closed graph. In fact, let xn → x in X and uxn → u in C(R+ , X). Let t > 0. Then t t t u (s) ds converges to 0 u(s) ds as n → ∞. Since A 0 uxn (s) ds = uxn (t) − 0 xn t t xn and since A is closed, it follows that 0 u(s) ds ∈ D(A) and A 0 u(s) ds = limn→∞ uxn (t) − xn = u(t) − x. Thus u(t) = T (t)x; i.e., u = Φ(x). It follows from the closed graph theorem that Φ is continuous. This implies that T (t) ∈ L(X) for all t ≥ 0. Let u be a mild solution of (ACP0 ) with initial value x. Then it is easy to see that u(· + s) is a mild solution for the initial value u(s). So uniqueness implies that T (t + s)x = T (t)T (s)x. We have shown that T is a C0 -semigroup. Let B be the generator of T . Then R(λ, B) = Tˆ(λ) (λ > ω(T )). On the other hand, by Theorem 3.1.3, Tˆ(λ)x ∈ D(A) and (λ − A)Tˆ (λ)x = x for all x ∈ X and λ > ω(T ). Thus, D(B) ⊂ D(A) and (λ − A)R(λ, B)x = x (x ∈ X) if λ > ω(T ). If we show that (λ − A) is injective, then it follows that λ ∈ ρ(A) and R(λ, A) = R(λ, B). Thus, A = B. Assume that λ > ω(T ) and let x ∈ D(A) such that (λ − A)x = 0. Then u(t) := eλt x is a mild solution. Thus, T (t)x = eλt x. Since ω(T ) < λ, it follows that x = 0. (ii) ⇒ (iii) follows from Proposition 3.1.9 b) and Proposition 3.1.11. (iii) ⇒ (i): Let λ ∈ ρ(A). Let x ∈ X. There exists a classical solution v of (ACP0 ) with initial value R(λ, A)x. It is easy to check that u(t) := (λ − A)v(t) defines a mild solution of (ACP0 ) with initial value x. This shows existence. In order toshow uniqueness, let u be a mild solution for the initial value x = 0. Then t v(t) := 0 u(s) ds defines a classical solution for the initial value 0. Hence v(t) = 0 for all t ≥ 0 by assumption. It follows that u(t) = 0 (t ≥ 0). As a corollary of Theorem 3.1.12 we show that one can also characterize C0 semigroups and their generator by property e) of Proposition 3.1.9. This will be useful later. Corollary 3.1.13. Let A be a closed operator on X and T : R+ → L(X) be strongly t continuous such that 0 T (s)x ds ∈ D(A) and
t
A 0
T (s)x ds = T (t)x − x
for all x ∈ X, t ≥ 0. Assume that T (t)x ∈ D(A) and AT (t)x = T (t)Ax for all x ∈ D(A), t ≥ 0. Then T is a C0 -semigroup and A is its generator. Proof. Let x ∈ X. Then u(t) := T (t)x defines a mild solution of (ACP0 ). As in the
3.1. C0 -SEMIGROUPS AND CAUCHY PROBLEMS
117
proof of Proposition 3.1.11, u is the unique mild solution. Now the claim follows from Theorem 3.1.12. We show by an example that the condition that A has non-empty resolvent set cannot be omitted in assertion (iii) of Theorem 3.1.12; i.e., it can happen that the abstract Cauchy problem (ACP0 ) is well-posed in the sense of classical solutions without A being the generator of a C0 -semigroup. Example 3.1.14. Let B be a densely defined closed operator on a Banach space Y such that D(B) = Y . Consider the operator A on X := Y × Y given by 0 B A= 0 0 with domain Y × D(B). Then A is closed and densely defined. Moreover, for all (x, y) ∈ D(A), u(t) = (x + tBy, y) (t ≥ 0) is the unique classical solution of (ACP0 ). However, there does not exist a mild solution for an initial value (x, y) if y ∈ Y \ D(B). This is easy to see. Now we consider the inhomogeneous Cauchy problem. In contrast to the homogeneous case, we consider this on a bounded interval [0, τ ] where τ ∈ (0, ∞), but results on R+ can be deduced by letting τ vary. We shall apply Laplace transform techniques to inhomogeneous Cauchy problems on R+ in Section 5.6. Let A be a closed operator and let f ∈ L1 ([0, τ ], X) where τ > 0. We consider the inhomogeneous Cauchy problem u (t) = Au(t) + f (t) (t ∈ [0, τ ]), (ACPf ) u(0) = x, where x ∈ X. A function u ∈ C([0, τ ], X) is called a mild solution of (ACPf ) if t u(s) ds ∈ D(A) and 0 u(t) = x + A
t
t
u(s) ds + 0
0
f (s) ds (t ∈ [0, τ ]).
Assume that f ∈ C([0, τ ], X). Then we define a classical solution as a function u ∈ C 1 ([0, τ ], X) such that u(t) ∈ D(A) for all t ∈ [0, τ ] and such that (ACPf ) is valid. Note that in that case, since Au(t) = u (t) − f (t) (t ∈ [0, τ ]), one has u ∈ C([0, τ ], D(A)), where D(A) is seen as a Banach space with the graph norm. Since A is closed, the proof of Proposition 3.1.2 is also valid in the inhomogeneous case, so the following holds. Proposition 3.1.15. Let f ∈ C([0, τ ], X) and u ∈ C([0, τ ], X) be a mild solution of (ACPf ). Then u is a classical solution if and only if u ∈ C 1 ([0, τ ], X).
118
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
In the case when A generates a C0 -semigroup there always exists a mild solution. Proposition 3.1.16. Let A be the generator of a C0 -semigroup T on X. Then for every f ∈ L1 ([0, τ ], X) the problem (ACPf ) has a unique mild solution u given by
t
u(t) = T (t)x + 0
T (t − s)f (s) ds
(t ∈ [0, τ ]).
(3.4)
Sometimes, (3.4) is called the variation of constants formula for the solution. Proof. Uniqueness: Let u1 , u2 ∈ C([0, τ ], X) be two mild solutions of (ACPf ). Then t u := u1 − u2 ∈ C([0, τ ], X), u(0) = 0 and A 0 u(s) ds = u(t) for all t ∈ [0, τ ]. It follows from Proposition 3.1.11 that u ≡ 0. Existence: We have seen that T (·)x is a mild solution of the homogeneous t Cauchy problem. It remains to show that v(t) := 0 T (t − s)f (s) ds is a mild solution of (ACPf ) with initial value x = 0. Extending f by 0 to R+ , Proposition 1.3.4 shows that v ∈ C([0, τ ], X). Using Proposition 3.1.9 e) and Fubini’s theorem we obtain t t s A v(s) ds = A T (s − r)f (r) dr ds 0 0 0 t t = A T (s − r)f (r) ds dr
0
t
=
r t−r
A 0
T (s)f (r) ds dr 0
t
(T (t − r)f (r) − f (r)) dr t = v(t) − f (r) dr. =
0
0
This proves the claim. Corollary 3.1.17. Let A be the generator of a C0 -semigroup. Let x ∈ D(A), f0 ∈ t X, f (t) = f0 + 0 f (s) ds (t ∈ [0, τ ]) for some function f ∈ L1 ([0, τ ], X). Then the function u defined by (3.4) is a classical solution of (ACPf ). This follows from Proposition 3.1.16, Proposition 1.3.6 and Proposition 3.1.15. This result will later be extended to a class of operators which are not densely defined (Theorem 3.5.2). Finally, given a closed operator A on X, we consider the Cauchy problem on the line u (t) = Au(t) (t ∈ R), ACP0 (R) u(0) = x,
3.1. C0 -SEMIGROUPS AND CAUCHY PROBLEMS
119
where x ∈ X. A function u ∈ C(R, X) is called a mild solution of ACP0 (R) if t u(s) ds ∈ D(A) and 0 t A u(s) ds = u(t) − x for all t ∈ R. 0
Proposition 3.1.18. Assume that A is an operator such that A generates a C0 semigroup T+ and −A generates a C0 -semigroup T− . Define T+ (t) if t ≥ 0, U (t) = (3.5) T− (−t) if t < 0. Then U : R → L(X) is strongly continuous, U (0) = I and U (t + s) = U (t)U (s) (t, s ∈ R). Proof. Note first that T+ (t)T− (s) = T− (s)T+ (t) for s, t ≥ 0, by Proposition 3.1.5. The only assertion which is not obvious is to show that U (t − s) = U (t)U (−s) if t ≥ 0, s ≥ 0. We can assume that 0 ≤ s ≤ t (replacing A by −A for the other case). Let x ∈ X, t ≥ 0, v(s) := T+ (t − s)x for s ∈ [0, t]. Then for 0 ≤ r ≤ t, r r t −A v(s) ds = −A T+ (t − s)x ds = −A T+ (s)x ds 0
0
t−r
= T+ (t − r)x − T+ (t)x = v(r) − T+ (t)x. Thus, v is a mild solution of the problem v (s) = −Av(s) v(0) = T+ (t)x.
(0 < s ≤ t),
It follows from Proposition 3.1.11 that v(s) = T− (s)T+ (t)x. Hence, U (t − s)x = T+ (t − s)x = v(s) = T− (s)T+ (t)x = U (−s)U (t)x. Definition 3.1.19. An operator A on X is said to generate a C0 -group if A and −A generate C0 -semigroups. In that case, the function U : R → L(X) defined by (3.5) is called the C0 -group generated by A. Proposition 3.1.20. A closed operator A generates a C0 -group if and only if for every x ∈ X there exists a unique mild solution u of ACP0 (R). In that case, u(t) = U (t)x (t ∈ R), where U is the C0 -group generated by A. If x ∈ D(A), then d U (·)x ∈ C 1 (R, X), U (t)x ∈ D(A) for all t ∈ R and dt U (t)x = AU (t)x (t ∈ R). Proof. Assume that ACP0 (R) is mildly well-posed; i.e., for all x ∈ X there exists a unique mild solution of ACP0 (R). Then it is clear that for each x ∈ X there exists a mild solution of u (t) = ±Au(t) (t ≥ 0), (CP )± u(0) = x.
120
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
The solutions of (CP )+ and (CP )− are both unique. In fact, let u ∈ C(R+ , X) be a mild solution of (CP )+ with initial value u(0) = 0. Then extending u by 0 on (−∞, 0) one obtains a mild solution of ACP0 (R). Hence u ≡ 0 by assumption. The same argument is valid for (CP )− . Now it follows from Theorem 3.1.12 that A and −A are both generators of C0 -semigroups. Conversely, if A generates a C0 -group, then it is easy to see that U (·)x is a mild solution of ACP0 (R). The remaining properties follow directly from the corresponding results for semigroups. If A generates a C0 -semigroup T , then mild solutions of ACP0 (R) can be described differently. Definition 3.1.21. A function u ∈ C(R, X) is called a complete orbit of T if u(t + s) = T (t)u(s)
for all t ≥ 0, s ∈ R.
Proposition 3.1.22. Let A be the generator of a C0 -semigroup T and let u ∈ C(R, X), x = u(0). Then u is a mild solution of ACP0 (R) if and only if u is a complete orbit. Proof. Assume that u is a complete orbit. Let x = u(0). Since T (t)x = u(t) for t ≥ 0, we have t A u(s) ds = u(t) − x (t ≥ 0). 0
For t < 0 we have T (−t)u(t) = u(0) = x and t 0 A u(r) dr = A u(r + t) dr = −A 0
−t
= −A
0
−t
−t
u(r + t) dr 0
T (r)u(t) dr = u(t) − T (−t)u(t) = u(t) − x.
Thus u is a mild solution of ACP0 (R). Conversely, assume that u is a mild solution of ACP0 (R) with x = u(0). Let s ∈ R. Then for t ≥ 0, t s+t A u(r + s) dr = A u(r) dr = u(t + s) − u(s). 0
s
Thus u(· + s) is a mild solution of (ACP0 ) for x = u(s). Hence u(t + s) = T (t)u(s) for t ≥ 0. If a C0 -semigroup T extends to a C0 -group, then T (t) is invertible for all t > 0. The following converse statement is sometimes useful (and will be needed in Proposition 4.7.2, for example). Proposition 3.1.23. Let A be the generator of a C0 -semigroup T . If there exists t0 > 0 such that T (t0 ) is invertible, then A generates a C0 -group.
3.2. INTEGRATED SEMIGROUPS AND CAUCHY PROBLEMS
121
Proof. a) Let t > 0. We show that T (t) is invertible. Let T (t)x = 0. Choose n ∈ N such that nt0 > t. Then T (nt0 )x = T (nt0 − t)T (t)x = 0. Since T (nt0 ) = T (t0 )n is invertible, it follows that x = 0. Thus, T (t) is injective. Let y ∈ X. Let x := T (nt0 − t)T (nt0 )−1 y. Then T (t)x = y. Thus, T (t) is surjective. b) Define U (t) := T (t) for t ≥ 0 and U (t) := T (−t)−1 for t < 0. Then U : R → L(X) satisfies U (t + s) = U (t)U (s) for all t, s ∈ R. Let x ∈ X, t0 ∈ R. Let t1 > max{−t0 , 0}. Then lim U (t)x = T (t1 )−1 lim T (t + t1 )x = U (t0 )x.
t→t0
t→t0
Thus U is strongly continuous. c) We show that the generator of (U (−t))t≥0 is −A. Let x ∈ D(A). Then 1 1 lim (U (−t)x − x) = lim U (−1) T (1 − t)x − T (1)x t↓0 t t↓0 t = T (1)−1 (−AT (1)x) = −Ax. Conversely, if x ∈ X such that y := limt↓0 1t (U (−t)x − x) exists, it follows as above that −y = limt↓0 1t (T (t)x − x). Thus, x ∈ D(A) and −Ax = y. Now the claim follows from Proposition 3.1.9.
3.2
Integrated Semigroups and Cauchy Problems
Let T be a C0 -semigroup on a Banach space X with generator A. For k ∈ N we define S : R+ → L(X) by
t
S(t)x := 0
(t − s)k−1 T (s)x ds (k − 1)!
(t ≥ 0, x ∈ X).
By Theorem 3.1.7, there exist M, ω ≥ 0 such that T (t) ≤ M eωt for all t ≥ 0. Taking Laplace transforms and integrating by parts yields ∞ R(λ, A) = λk e−λt S(t) dt (λ > ω). (3.6) 0
Here, the Laplace integral is understood in the sense of Section 1.4, but, for each ∞ x ∈ X and λ > ω, one has R(λ, A)x = λk 0 e−λt S(t)x dt as an absolutely convergent Bochner integral. The above formula (3.6) is the basic idea behind the following definition. Consider an arbitrary strongly continuous function S : R+ → L(X). We recall from Proposition 1.4.5 that abs(S) < ∞ if and only if there exist constants M, ω ≥ 0 such that
t
ωt
S(s) ds (t ≥ 0). (3.7)
≤ Me 0
122
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
In that case, the Laplace integral ∞ ˆ S(λ)x := e−λt S(t)x dt := lim τ →∞
0
τ
e−λt S(t)x dt
0
exists for all λ ∈ C with Re λ > ω and all x ∈ X and defines a bounded operator ˆ S(λ) on X. Hence, the following definition is meaningful. Definition 3.2.1. Let A be an operator on a Banach space X and k ∈ N0 . We call A the generator of a k-times integrated semigroup if there exist ω ≥ 0 and a strongly continuous function S : R+ → L(X) such that abs(S) ≤ ω, (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and ∞ R(λ, A) = λk e−λt S(t) dt (λ > ω). (3.8) 0
In this case, S is called the k-times integrated semigroup generated by A. If k = 1 we also use the notion once integrated semigroup. By Theorem 3.1.7, a 0-times integrated semigroup is the same as a C0 semigroup. The discussion above shows that if A generates a 0-times integrated semigroup, then A generates a k-times integrated semigroup for every k ∈ N. The same argument shows that if A generates a k-times integrated semigroup, then A generates an n-times integrated semigroup for every n > k. As in the situation of C0 -semigroups we collect diverse relations of an integrated semigroup and its generator. Lemma 3.2.2. Let k ∈ N and let S be a k-times integrated semigroup on X with generator A. Then the following hold: a) R(μ, A)S(t) = S(t)R(μ, A)
(t ≥ 0, μ ∈ ρ(A)).
b) If x ∈ D(A), then S(t)x ∈ D(A) and AS(t)x = S(t)Ax for all t ≥ 0. c) Let x ∈ D(A) and t ≥ 0. Then t tk S(s)Ax ds = S(t)x − x. k! 0 In particular,
d dt
(S(t)x) = S(t)Ax +
tk−1 (k−1)! x.
t d) Let x ∈ X and t ≥ 0. Then 0 S(s)x ds ∈ D(A) and t tk A S(s)x ds = S(t)x − x. k! 0 In particular, S(0) = 0. t k e) Let x, y ∈ X such that 0 S(s)y ds = S(t)x− tk! x for all t ≥ 0. Then x ∈ D(A) and Ax = y.
3.2. INTEGRATED SEMIGROUPS AND CAUCHY PROBLEMS
123
Proof. By definition and assertion (3.7), there exist constants M, ω ≥ 0 such that t (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and || 0 S(s) ds|| ≤ M eωt for t ≥ 0. In the following let λ > ω. a) follows from Proposition 3.1.5. b) is implied by a) (by Proposition B.7). c) Let x ∈ D(A). Integrating by parts yields ∞ tk λk+1 e−λt x dt = R(λ, A)(λ − A)x k! 0 ∞ ∞ k+1 −λt k = λ e S(t)x dt − λ e−λt S(t)Ax dt 0 0 ∞ k+1 = λ e−λt S(t)x dt 0 ∞ t k+1 −λt −λ e S(s)Ax ds dt. 0
0
The uniqueness theorem implies the assertion. d) Let μ ∈ ρ(A) and x ∈ X. By a) and c) we have t t tk S(s)x ds = μR(μ, A) S(s)x ds − R(μ, A)S(t)x + R(μ, A)x. k! 0 0 t Hence 0 S(s)x ds ∈ D(A) and t t tk (μ − A) S(s)x ds = μ S(s)x ds − S(t)x + x. k! 0 0 t k e) Let x, y ∈ X such that 0 S(s)y ds = S(t)x − tk! x for all t ≥ 0. Then ∞ ∞ k+1 −λt k R(λ, A)(λx − y) = λ e S(t)x dt − λ e−λt S(t)y dt 0 0 ∞ ∞ t = λk+1 e−λt S(t)x dt − λk+1 e−λt S(s)y ds dt = x.
0
0
0
Hence x ∈ D(A) and λx − y = λx − Ax, which implies that Ax = y. Remark 3.2.3. Observe that in contrast to the situation of C0 -semigroups, generators of k-times integrated semigroups for k ≥ 1 need not be densely defined. However, assertion d) of Lemma 3.2.2 implies that S(t)x ∈ D(A) for t ≥ 0 and x ∈ X. We saw in Theorem 3.1.7 that C0 -semigroups are precisely those operatorvalued functions whose Laplace transforms are resolvents R(λ, A) of operators A. By definition, k-times integrated semigroups are exactly those operator-valued functions whose Laplace transforms are λ−k R(λ, A) for operators A. In the following proposition we show that this property corresponds to the functional equation (3.9) for S.
124
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Proposition 3.2.4. Let S : R+ → L(X) be a strongly continuous function satisfying t
0 S(s) ds ≤ M eωt (t ≥ 0) for some M, ω ≥ 0. Let k ∈ N. For λ > ω set ∞ k R(λ) := λ e−λt S(t) dt. 0
Then the following assertions are equivalent: (i) There exists an operator A such that (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and R(λ) = (λ − A)−1 for λ > ω. (ii) For s, t ≥ 0, S(t)S(s)
=
1 (k − 1)!
)
t+s
(s + t − r)k−1 S(r) dr * s k−1 − (s + t − r) S(r) dr , t
(3.9)
0
and S(t)x = 0 for all t ≥ 0 implies x = 0. Proof. We first claim that {R(λ) : λ > ω} is a pseudo-resolvent if and only if (3.9) holds. Since ∞ ∞ R(λ) R(μ) −λt = e e−μs S(t)S(s) ds dt (λ, μ > ω), λk μk 0 0 the claim follows from the uniqueness theorem (Theorem 1.7.3) provided we are able to prove that 1 1 1 (R(λ) − R(μ)) (3.10) μ − λ λk μk equals the term ∞ ∞ s+t 1 e−λt e−μs (s + t − r)k−1 S(r) dr ds dt (k − 1)! 0 t ∞0 ∞ s 1 −λt −μs − e e (s + t − r)k−1 S(r) dr ds dt. (3.11) (k − 1)! 0 0 0 Notice that (3.10) equals R(λ) R(μ) 1 1 1 1 1 R(μ) − + − =: I + II. μk μ − λ λk μk μ − λ μk λk μk As in the proof of Theorem 3.1.7 we see that term I equals ∞ ∞ 1 −μt e e−λs S(t + s) ds dt μk 0 0 ∞ ∞ t+s (t + s − r)k−1 = e−λt e−μs S(r) dr ds dt. (k − 1)! 0 0 t
3.2. INTEGRATED SEMIGROUPS AND CAUCHY PROBLEMS
125
Hence, it remains to show that term II is equal to the second term in (3.11). This follows from the following computation: −II
=
k−1
ˆ λ−(j+1) μ(j−k) S(μ)
j=0
=
k−1
λ−(j+1)
k−1 ∞
e−λt
j=0 0 ∞ −λt
=
e−μs
0
j=0
=
∞
e
0
0
tj dt j!
∞
s
e−μs
0
∞
(s − r)k−j−1 S(r) dr ds (k − j − 1)!
e−μs
0
s
0
s 0
(s − r)k−j−1 S(r) dr ds (k − j − 1)!
(s + t − r)k−1 S(r) dr ds dt. (k − 1)!
Finally, recall that {R(λ) : λ > ω} is the resolvent of an operator A in X if and only if Ker R(λ) = {0} (see Proposition B.6). This is equivalent to the fact that S(t)x = 0 for all t ≥ 0 implies x = 0. In contrast to the situation for semigroups the functional equation (3.9) in Proposition 3.2.4 does not imply that abs(S) < ∞. This will be shown at the end of this section in Remark 3.2.15. It follows from Proposition 3.1.5 or from the above Proposition 3.2.4 that for a k-times integrated semigroup S we have S(t)S(s) = S(s)S(t)
(s, t ≥ 0).
(3.12)
The above elementary properties of integrated semigroups will be used in the following without further notice. A particular example of an integrated semigroup is the antiderivative of a semigroup which is not necessarily strongly continuous at 0. In order to make this more precise, consider a strongly continuous function T : (0, ∞) → L(X) satisfying a) T (t + s) = T (t)T (s)
(s, t > 0),
b) there exists c > 0 such that ||T (t)|| ≤ c for all t ∈ (0, 1], c) T (t)x = 0 for all t > 0 implies x = 0. Then by the proof of Theorem 3.1.7, there exist constants M, ω ≥ 0 such that ||T (t)|| ≤ M eωt for all t > 0. For t ≥ 0 set t S(t) := T (s) ds. 0
Then (S(t))t≥0 satisfies condition (ii) of Proposition 3.2.4 with k = 1. Hence, there exists an operator A such that (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and ∞ ∞ R(λ, A) = λ e−λt S(t) dt = e−λt T (t) dt (λ > ω). (3.13) 0
0
126
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Definition 3.2.5. Let T : (0, ∞) → L(X) be a strongly continuous function satisfying assumptions a), b) and c) above. Let A be defined as in (3.13). Then T is called a semigroup and A is called its generator. We will see in the following Section 3.3 that a semigroup T on X is a C0 semigroup on X if and only if D(A) = X. Proposition 3.2.6. Let A be the generator of a k-times integrated semigroup S on X for some k ∈ N and let a ∈ C. Then A − a generates a k-times integrated semigroup Sa on X which is given by t k (t − s)j−1 −as k −at Sa (t) = e S(t) + aj e S(s) ds. j (j − 1)! 0 j=1
Proof. Taking Laplace transforms of Sa we obtain, for μ sufficiently large ∞ ∞ −μt e Sa (t) dt = e−(μ+a)t S(t) dt 0
0
+
∞
e−(μ+a)t S(t) dt
0
= =
R(μ + a, A) 1 (μ + a)k μk
k j=0
k k aj μ−j j j=1
k j
aj μk−j
R(μ + a, A) (μ + a)k R(μ, A − a) = . k k (μ + a) μ μk
Hence, the assertion follows directly from Definition 3.2.1. Proposition 3.2.7. Let A be an operator on X and let μ ∈ ρ(A), k ∈ N. Then A generates a k-times integrated semigroup S on X if and only if there exists ω ∈ R such that (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and R(·, A)R(μ, A)k is a Laplace transform Tˆ in the sense of Definition 3.1.4. In that case, ω(T ) < ∞ if and only if ω(S) < ∞. Proof. By Proposition 3.2.6, the operator A generates a k-times integrated semigroup if and only if A−μ does so. By Definition 3.2.1 and Proposition 1.6.1 a), this is equivalent to λ → (λ − μ)−k R(λ, A) being a Laplace transform. The resolvent equation implies that R(λ, A)R(μ, A)k =
R(λ, A) R(μ, A) R(μ, A)2 R(μ, A)k − − −... − (3.14) k k k−1 (μ − λ) (μ − λ) (μ − λ) (μ − λ)
for λ, μ ∈ ρ(A), λ = μ. The first assertion follows easily. Moreover, each step in the passage between S and T preserves exponential boundedness. In the following we characterize those operators which generate a k-times integrated semigroup for some k ∈ N simply by the fact that the resolvent is polynomially bounded on a half-plane. The real characterization given in the next section determines precisely the order of integration.
3.2. INTEGRATED SEMIGROUPS AND CAUCHY PROBLEMS
127
Theorem 3.2.8. Let A be an operator and let k ∈ N. a) Assume that there exists ω ≥ 0, M ≥ 0, b > 0 such that λ ∈ ρ(A) and
R(λ, A) ≤ M |λ|k−1−b whenever Re λ > ω. Then A generates a k-times integrated semigroup S satisfying ω(S) ≤ ω. b) Conversely, if A generates a k-times integrated semigroup S such that ω(S) < ∞, then for ω > max{ω(S), 0} there exists M such that λ ∈ ρ(A) and
R(λ, A) ≤ M |λ|k whenever Re λ > ω. Proof. a) Apply Theorem 2.5.1 to q(λ) := λb R(λ, A)/λk . b) Let max{ω(S), 0} < ω1 < ω. There exists M1 ≥ 0 such that S(t) ≤ M1 eω1 t (t ≥ 0). Hence, by Proposition B.5, λ ∈ ρ(A) and
∞
k
−λt
R(λ, A) = λ e S(t) dt
0
≤
|λ|k M1 (Re λ − ω1 )−1 ≤ |λ|k M1 (ω − ω1 )−1
whenever Re λ > ω. We now turn our attention to the inhomogenous Cauchy problem u (t) = Au(t) + f (t) (t ∈ [0, τ ]), (ACPf ) u(0) = x,
(3.15)
where τ > 0, f ∈ L1 ([0, τ ], X), x ∈ X and A is assumed to be the generator of a k-times integrated semigroup S on X for some k ∈ N. Recall from Section 3.1 that by a mild solution of (ACPf ) we understand a function u ∈ C([0, τ ], X) such t t t that 0 u(s) ds ∈ D(A) and u(t) = A 0 u(s) ds + x + 0 f (s) ds for all t ∈ [0, τ ] and that by a classical solution of (ACPf ) we mean a function u ∈ C 1 ([0, τ ], X) ∩ C([0, τ ], D(A)) satisfying (ACPf ) for all t ∈ [0, τ ]. For x ∈ X consider the function v given by t
v(t) := S(t)x + 0
S(s)f (t − s) ds
(t ∈ [0, τ ]).
(3.16)
It follows from Proposition 1.3.4 that v ∈ C([0, τ ], X). Lemma 3.2.9. a) If there is a mild solution u of (ACPf ), then v ∈ C k ([0, τ ], X) (k) and u = v . b) If there exists a classical solution u of (ACPf ), then v ∈ C k+1 ([0, τ ], X) and u = v (k) . s s Proof. a) For 0 ≤ s ≤ t ≤ τ set w(s) := S(t − s) 0 u(r)dr. Since 0 u(r)dr ∈ D(A) for s ∈ [0, τ ], it follows from Lemma 3.2.2 c) that s (t − s)k−1 s w (s) = −S(t − s)A u(r) dr − u(r) dr + S(t − s)u(s) (k − 1)! 0 0 s (t − s)k−1 s = − u(r) dr + S(t − s) x + f (r) dr (s ∈ [0, t]). (k − 1)! 0 0
128
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Since 0 = w(0) − w(t) = − 0
t
t 0
S(t − s) x +
w (s) ds we have
s
f (r) dr
(t − s)k−1 (k − 1)!
t
ds =
0
0
s
u(r) dr ds. 0
Using this and Proposition 1.3.6, it follows that t dk+1 (t − s)k−1 s u(t) = u(r) dr ds dtk+1 (k − 1)! 0 0 t dk = S(t)x + S(s)f (t − s) ds = v (k) (t). dtk 0 b) This follows immediately from Proposition 3.1.15. Lemma 3.2.10. Let v be defined by (3.16). Assume that v ∈ C k ([0, τ ], X). Then u := v (k) is a mild solution of (ACPf ). Moreover, if v ∈ C k+1 ([0, τ ], X), then u := v (k) is a classical solution of (ACPf ). Proof. By Fubini’s theorem, t t t v(s) ds = S(s)x ds + 0
0
0
t−r
S(s)f (r) ds dr
0
t t−r for t ∈ [0, τ ]. By Lemma 3.2.2 d), 0 S(s)x ds ∈ D(A), 0 S(s)f (r) ds ∈ D(A) t−r t k and A 0 S(s)f (r) ds = S(t−r)f (r)− (t−r) k! f (r). By Proposition 1.1.7, 0 v(s) ds ∈ D(A) and t t tk (t − r)k A v(s) ds = v(t) − x − f (r) dr. (3.17) k! k! 0 0 Since A is closed and v ∈ C k ([0, τ ], X), it follows from (3.17) that v (j−1) (t) ∈ D(A) for t ∈ [0, τ ] and that Av (j−1) (t) = v (j) (t) −
tk−j x− (k − j)!
0
t
(t − r)k−j f (r) dr (k − j)!
(3.18)
for j = 1, . . . , k. Since v(0) = 0, this implies that v (j) (0) = 0 for j = 1, 2, . . . , k − 1. It now follows from (3.18) for j = k that u := v (k) is a mild solution of (ACPf ). If v ∈ C k+1 ([0, τ ], X), we may differentiate (3.18) once more and see that v(k) (t) ∈ D(A) and that Av (k) (t) = v (k+1) (t) − f (t) (t ∈ [0, τ ]). (3.19) Hence u := v (k) satisfies u (t) = Au(t) + f (t) for t ∈ [0, τ ]. Also, by (3.18) for j = k, u(0) = v (k) (0) = x. Combining the above Lemmas 3.2.9 and 3.2.10 with Lemma 3.2.2 c) and Proposition 1.3.6, we obtain the following corollary.
3.2. INTEGRATED SEMIGROUPS AND CAUCHY PROBLEMS
129
Corollary 3.2.11. Let A be the generator of a k-times integrated semigroup on X for some k ∈ N. a) Assume that x ∈ D(Ak+1 ). Then there exists a unique classical solution of (ACP0 ). b) Assume that f ∈ C k+1 ([0, τ ], X) and that there exist xj ∈ D(A) for j = 0, 1, . . . , k satisfying x0 = x, xj+1 = Axj + f (j) (0) (j = 0, 1, . . . , k). Then there exists a unique classical solution of (ACPf ). c) Assume that f ∈ C k ([0, τ ], X) and that there exist xj ∈ D(A) for j = 0, 1, . . . , k − 1 satisfying x0 = x, xj+1 = Axj + f (j) (0) (j = 0, 1, . . . , k − 1). Then there exists a unique mild solution of (ACPf ). Remark 3.2.12. We remark that in contrast to the case of a C0 -semigroup (see Corollary 3.1.17) a mere regularity condition on the function f does not suffice to ensure the existence of a classical solution of (ACPf ). Indeed, let A be the generator of a once integrated semigroup S on X such that A does not generate a C0 -semigroup on X. Then there exists y ∈ X such that S(·)y ∈ / C 1 ([0, τ ], X). Consider the function f defined by f (t) := y for t ∈ [0, τ ]. If x = 0, then v(t) = t S(s)y ds, but v ∈ / C 2 ([0, τ ], X). 0 In the following we turn our attention to the converse of Corollary 3.2.11; i.e., we are aiming to show that A is the generator of an integrated semigroup whenever the associated Cauchy problem (ACP0 ) admits a unique classical solution for all initial data x belonging to the domain of some power of A. To this end, we restrict ourselves to the case of generators of exponentially bounded k-times integrated semigroups; i.e., we assume that the function S in Definition 3.2.1 satisfies in addition the property that S(t) ≤ M eωt for all t ≥ 0 and some suitable constants M, ω ≥ 0. For x ∈ X consider then the “(k + 1)-times integrated version” of (ACP0 ), which is to find v ∈ C 1 (R+ , X) ∩ C(R+ , D(A)) satisfying ⎧ tk ⎨ v (t) = Av(t) + x (t ≥ 0), (ACPk+1 ) (3.20) k! ⎩v(0) = 0. Assume that A generates an exponentially bounded k-times integrated semigroup t S on X and define v by v(t) := 0 S(s)x ds for t ≥ 0. Then by Lemma 3.2.2 d), t tk v (t) = S(t)x = A S(s)x ds + x (t ≥ 0) (3.21) k! 0 and v(0) = 0. Hence v is a classical solution of (ACPk+1 ). It is unique by Lemma 3.2.9 and exponentially bounded since S is so. We have therefore proved the implication (i) ⇒ (ii) of the following result. Recall that a 0-times integrated semigroup is the same as a C0 -semigroup, so the following may be compared with Theorem 3.1.10.
130
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Theorem 3.2.13. Let A be a closed operator on X and let k ∈ N0 . The following assertions are equivalent: (i) A generates an exponentially bounded k-times integrated semigroup on X. (ii) For all x ∈ X there exists a unique classical solution of (ACPk+1 ) which is exponentially bounded. (iii) ρ(A) = ∅ and for every x ∈ D(Ak+1 ) there exists a unique classical solution of (ACP0 ) which is exponentially bounded. Proof. The remarks before Theorem 3.2.13 imply the assertion (i) ⇒ (ii). Moreover, the implication (i) ⇒ (iii) follows from Corollary 3.2.11. For the proof of the implication (ii) ⇒ (i) we need the following “uniform exponential boundedness principle”. Lemma 3.2.14. Let X, Y be Banach spaces and let V : R+ → L(X, Y ) be a function. Assume that V (·)x is exponentially bounded for all x ∈ X. Then there exist constants M ≥ 0, ω ∈ R such that
V (t) ≤ M eωt
(t ≥ 0).
Proof. Observe that, for n ∈ N, the set Xn defined by ' ( Xn := x ∈ X : V (t)x ≤ nent for all t ≥ 0 is a closed subset of X. The hypothesis implies that X = n∈N Xn . Hence, by Baire’s theorem, there exists n0 ∈ N such that Xn0 has non-empty interior. It follows that there exist z ∈ X, ε > 0, M ≥ 0 and ω ∈ R such that
V (t)x ≤ M eωt
(t ≥ 0)
provided x − z ≤ ε. For y ≤ 1 we have εe−ωt V (t)y ≤ e−ωt V (t)(εy + z) + e−ωt V (t)z ≤ 2M for t ≥ 0. Thus V (t) ≤
2M ωt e ε
for t ≥ 0.
The above Lemma 3.2.14 enables us now to prove the implication (ii) ⇒ (i) in Theorem 3.2.13. (ii) ⇒ (i): Denote by V (·)x the solution of (ACPk+1 ). The mapping V (t) : X → D(A) is linear by uniqueness. We even have that V (t) ∈ L(X, D(A)). Indeed, the space C(R+ , D(A)) is a Fr´echet space for the seminorms pm (f ) := sup f (t) D(A) . 0≤t≤m
Define a mapping Φ : X → C(R+ , D(A)) by Φ(x) = V (·)x. Then Φ is closed and the closed graph theorem implies that Φ is continuous (see the proof of Theorem
3.2. INTEGRATED SEMIGROUPS AND CAUCHY PROBLEMS
131
3.1.12). In particular, the mapping X → D(A), x → V (t)x is continuous for t ≥ 0. The hypothesis together with Lemma 3.2.14 implies that V (t) ≤ M eωt (t ≥ 0) ∞ for suitable constants M, ω ≥ 0. Therefore Q(λ)x := λk+1 0 e−λt V (t)x dt is well defined for λ > ω. Since
t
k+1 k+1
= V (t)x − t
≤ M eωt + t AV (s)x ds x
x ,
(k + 1)! (k + 1)! 0 it follows from Theorem 1.4.3 that abs(AV (·)x) ≤ ω. By Proposition 1.6.3, Q(λ)x ∈ D(A) for all x ∈ X, all λ > ω and ∞ ∞ k+2 −λt k+1 (λ − A)Q(λ)x = λ e V (t)x dt − λ e−λt AV (t)x dt 0 0 ∞ ∞ d = λk+2 e−λt V (t)x dt − λk+1 e−λt V (t)x dt dt 0 0 ∞ k t + λk+1 e−λt x dt k! 0 = x for λ > ω. In order to show that λ−A is injective for λ > ω assume that (λ−A)x = 0 for some x ∈ D(A) and λ> ω. Then the solution V (t)x of (ACPk+1 ) is given t k by V (t)x = 0 (t−s) eλs ds x. Since V (t)x ≤ M eωt x for all t ≥ 0, it follows k! that x = 0. Hence, R(λ, A) = Q(λ) for λ > ω and V is a (k + 1)-times integrated k d semigroup generated by A. By hypothesis S(t)x := dt V (t)x = AV (t)x + tk! x exists for all t ≥ 0 and all x ∈ X and V (0) = 0. Integrating by parts shows that ˆ R(λ, A) = λk S(λ), so S is a k-times integrated semigroup generated by A. (iii) ⇒ (ii): For the time being, assume that 0 ∈ ρ(A). Let x ∈ X and let u be the solution of (ACP0 ) with initial value u(0) = A−k−1 x. Then v given by v(t) := u(t) − A−k−1 x − tA−k x − . . . −
tk−1 tk A−2 x − A−1 x (k − 1)! k!
is an exponentially bounded solution of (ACPk+1 ). Let v¯ be another solution of (ACPk+1 ). Then u = v − v¯ solves (ACP0 ) with initial value u(0) = 0. Hence, u ≡ 0 and we have proved (ii) provided 0 ∈ ρ(A). In the case where 0 ∈ ρ(A), we have that 0 ∈ ρ(A − μ) for some μ ∈ C. Hence, the preceding argument shows that (ii) holds for (A − μ). The implication (ii) ⇒ (i) and Proposition 3.2.6 imply that A generates a k-times integrated semigroup which, as we have seen, implies (ii). Remark 3.2.15. a) The assumption that ρ(A) = ∅ in Theorem 3.2.13 (iii) cannot be omitted even if k = 0 (see Example 3.1.11). b) The assumption of exponential boundedness in Theorem 3.2.13 (ii) and (iii) cannot be omitted as the following example shows: Let 1 ≤ p < ∞ and X be the
132
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
space p of all complex sequences x = (xn )n∈N such that x := ( ∞. Define the closed operator A on X by
∞ n=1
1/p
|xn |p )
<
D(A) := {x ∈ X : (an xn ) ∈ X}, where an := n + ien
2
Ax := (an xn )n∈N t for n ∈ N. For t ≥ 0 set S(t)x := ( 0 esan ds)xn . n
Then S(t) ∈ L(X) for t ≥ 0 and S(·)x is strongly continuous. For x ∈ X let t v(t) := 0 S(s)x ds. We verify that v (t) = Av(t) + tx for t ≥ 0; i.e., v is the unique solution of (ACP2 ). However, v is not exponentially bounded if xn = 0 for all s+t t n ∈ N. Observe also that S satisfies S(s)S(t) = s S(r)dr − 0 S(r)dr. However, S is not Laplace transformable since v is not exponentially bounded.
3.3
Real Characterization
In Section 3.1 (respectively, 3.2) we proved that the Cauchy problem u (t) = Au(t)
(t ≥ 0),
u(0) = x,
possesses a unique classical solution for all x ∈ D(A) (respectively, x ∈ D(Ak+1 )) provided the operator A generates a C0 -semigroup (respectively, k-times integrated semigroup) on X. It is therefore interesting to characterize generators of C0 -semigroups (respectively, integrated semigroups) by properties of the operators A or their resolvents. In the following we characterize generators of C0 -semigroups (respectively, exponentially bounded integrated semigroups) in terms of estimates for the resolvents and all their powers for real λ. Recall that an operator A was defined to be the generator of a k-times integrated semigroup S on X for some k ∈ N0 if (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) for some ω ≥ 0 and there exists a strongly continuous function S : R+ → L(X) satisfying abs(S) ≤ ω and ∞ R(λ, A) = λk e−λt S(t) dt (λ > ω). 0
By applying the Real Representation Theorem 2.4.1 to the special case of resolvents, we obtain the following characterization. Here and in what follows, we use the notation (R(λ, A)/λk )(n) to denote the nth derivative of the function λ → R(λ, A)/λk . Note that the first derivative of R(λ, A) is −R(λ, A)2 (see Corollary B.3). Theorem 3.3.1. Let A be a linear operator on X. Let M ≥ 0, ω ∈ R and k ∈ N0 . Then the following assertions are equivalent: (i) (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and sup sup (λ − ω)n+1 (R(λ, A)/λk )(n) /n! ≤ M. n∈N0 λ>ω
3.3. REAL CHARACTERIZATION
133
(ii) A generates a (k + 1)-times integrated semigroup Sk+1 on X satisfying
t
Sk+1 (t) − Sk+1 (s) ≤ M
eωr dr
(0 ≤ s ≤ t).
s
Proof. The implication (i) ⇒ (ii) follows from Theorem 2.4.1 and assertion (1.22). Conversely, assume that (ii) holds. By Definition 3.2.1, there exists ω ≥ ω such ∞ that R(λ,A) = λ 0 e−λt Sk+1 (t) dt for all λ > ω . By Proposition B.5, (ω, ∞) ⊂ λk ρ(A) and (i) follows from Theorem 2.4.1 and (1.22). When k > 0 and X = {0}, conditions (i) and (ii) of Theorem 3.3.1 cannot be satisfied for ω < 0. Note that, given a linear operator A satisfying condition (i) above, one cannot improve the order of integration of Sk+1 , in general (see Example 3.3.10 below). However, if A is densely defined, we obtain the following characterization. Theorem 3.3.2. Let A be a densely defined operator on X. Let M ≥ 0, ω ∈ R and k ∈ N0 . Then the following assertions are equivalent: (i) (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and sup sup (λ − ω)n+1 (R(λ, A)/λk )(n) /n! ≤ M. n∈N0 λ>ω
(ii) A generates a k-times integrated semigroup Sk on X satisfying
Sk (t) ≤ M eωt
(t ≥ 0).
The following lemma will be useful in the proof of Theorem 3.3.2. In addition to the space Lipω (R+ , X) defined in Section 2.4, we also set 1 1 −ωt Cω (R+ , X) := f ∈ C (R+ , X) : f (0) = 0, sup ||e f (t)|| < ∞ t≥0
=
1
C (R+ , X) ∩ Lipω (R+ , X).
Lemma 3.3.3. For ω ∈ R, the space Cω1 (R+ , X) is a closed subspace of Lipω (R+ , X). In particular, if S ∈ Lipω (R+ , L(X)), then {x ∈ X : S(·)x ∈ C 1 (R+ , X)} is a closed subspace of X. Proof. Let (fn ) ⊂ Cω1 (R+ , X) such that (fn ) converges to f in Lipω (R+ , X). t Then fn (t) = 0 fn (s) ds for t ≥ 0. Since sups∈[0,t] fn (s) − fm (s) ≤ eωt fn − fm Lipω (R+ ,X) for n, m ∈ N0 , it follows that (fn ) converges uniformly on comt pact sets to a function g ∈ C(R+ , X) and that f (t) = 0 g(s) ds for t ≥ 0. Hence f ∈ Cω1 (R+ , X). The final statement follows, since x → S(·)x is continuous from X into Lipω (R+ , X).
134
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Proof of Theorem 3.3.2. Assume that (ii) holds. Then A also generates a (k + 1)times integrated semigroup Sk+1 on X which in addition satisfies assertion (ii) of Theorem 3.3.1. Hence assertion (i) follows from that theorem. Conversely, assume that (i) holds. By Theorem 3.3.1, A generates a (k + 1)times integrated semigroup Sk+1 on X such that Sk+1 ∈ Lipω (R+ , L(X)) with
Sk+1 Lipω (R+ ,L(X)) ≤ M . By Lemma 3.2.2 c), Sk (t)x :=
d Sk+1 (t)x dt
(3.22)
exists for all x ∈ D(A) and t → Sk (t)x is continuous. By Lemma 3.3.3, the definition of Sk (t)x given in (3.22) is also meaningful for x ∈ D(A) and t → Sk (t)x is also continuous for x ∈ D(A). By assumption D(A) = X and therefore A is the generator of the k-times integrated semigroup Sk on X which clearly satisfies
Sk (t) ≤ M eωt
(t ≥ 0).
Notice that the special case k = 0 in Theorem 3.3.2 is precisely the classical Hille-Yosida theorem (in the general form presented here due to Hille, Yosida, Feller, Miyadera and Phillips), which we state explicitly due to its special importance. Theorem 3.3.4 (Hille-Yosida). Let A be a densely defined operator on X. Then A generates a C0 -semigroup on X if and only if there exist constants M ≥ 0, ω ∈ R such that (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and
(λ − ω)n+1 R(λ, A)(n) /n! ≤ M
(λ > ω, n ∈ N0 ).
(3.23)
It is immediate from Theorem 3.3.2 and the relation (−1)n R(λ, A)(n) /n! = R(λ, A)n+1
(λ ∈ ρ(A), n ∈ N0 )
(3.24)
(see Corollary B.3) that the generator of a C0 -semigroup T of contractions may be characterized as follows. Corollary 3.3.5. Let A be a densely defined operator on X. Then A generates a C0 -semigroup on X satisfying T (t) ≤ 1 for all t ≥ 0 if and only if (0, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and
λR(λ, A) ≤ 1 (λ > 0). (3.25) It is possible to express the semigroup in terms of the resolvent via “Euler’s formula” for exponentials, which is well known in the scalar case. Corollary 3.3.6. Let A be the generator of a C0 -semigroup T . Then ! "−n T (t)x = lim I − nt A x n→∞
for t > 0 and x ∈ X.
(3.26)
3.3. REAL CHARACTERIZATION
135
Proof. By (3.24) we have ! "−n (−1)n−1 n I − nt A = λn R(λ, A)n = λ R(λ, A)(n−1) (n − 1)! where λ = nt . Thus assertion (3.26) is precisely the Post-Widder inversion formula proved in Theorem 1.7.7. For a densely defined operator A on X denote its adjoint by A∗ . Then R(λ, A)∗ = R(λ, A∗ ) for all λ ∈ ρ(A) = ρ(A∗ ) (see Proposition B.11). As a direct consequence of Theorem 3.3.1 and Theorem 3.3.4 we obtain the following result. Corollary 3.3.7. Let A be the generator of a C0 -semigroup on X. Then the adjoint A∗ of A generates a once integrated semigroup on X ∗ . We remark that if the underlying Banach space X is reflexive, then the adjoint A∗ of A even generates a C0 -semigroup on X ∗ . This follows from Theorem 3.3.4, since A∗ is densely defined (see Proposition B.10). In fact, the following proposition shows that operators satisfying the Hille-Yosida condition (3.23) acting on reflexive spaces are necessarily densely defined. Proposition 3.3.8. Let A be a linear operator on a reflexive Banach space X. Assume that there exist constants M, ω ≥ 0 such that (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and λR(λ, A)
≤ M (λ > ω). Then A is densely defined. Proof. Let x ∈ X and for n ∈ N with n > ω set an := R(n, A)x. By assumption, (nan )n∈N,n>ω is a bounded sequence. Let z be a weak limit point of the relatively weakly compact set {nan : n ∈ N}. Since nan − Aan = x and limn→∞ an = 0, the closedness of A implies that x = z. But z is in the weak closure of D(A) and hence in the norm closure of D(A). Corollary 3.3.9. Let X be a reflexive Banach space and assume that A generates a C0 -semigroup on X. Then the adjoint A∗ of A generates a C0 -semigroup on X ∗ . Example 3.3.10. Let 1 ≤ p < ∞ and X := Lp (R). Consider the operator Ap f := f on Lp (R) with domain D(Ap ) := W 1,p (R). For the definition of the Sobolev space W 1,p (R), see Appendix E. Then Ap generates the C0 -semigroup Tp on Lp (R) given by (Tp (t)f )(x) = f (x + t) (x ∈ R, t ≥ 0).
Identifying Lp (R)∗ with Lp (R) where 1/p + 1/p = 1, Corollary 3.3.9 implies that −Ap generates a C0 -semigroup on Lp (R), provided p > 1. In fact, this is evident since Tp extends to a C0 -group. If p = 1, then by Corollary 3.3.7, −A∞ generates a once integrated semigroup S on L∞ (R), where A∞ f := −f with t domain D(A∞ ) := W 1,∞ (R). This is given by (S(t)g)(x) = 0 g(x − s) ds. As a further consequence of Theorem 3.3.1 and Theorem 3.3.2 we note the following corollary.
136
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Corollary 3.3.11. Let T be a semigroup on X in the sense of Definition 3.2.5 and let A be the generator of T . Then T is a C0 -semigroup on X if and only if D(A) is dense in X. Finally, given an operator A in X and a closed subspace Y of X, we define the part AY of A in Y by := {y ∈ Y ∩ D(A) : Ay ∈ Y }
D(AY ) AY y
:=
Ay.
(3.27)
If D(A) ⊂ Y , then ρ(A) ⊂ ρ(AY ) and R(λ, AY ) = R(λ, A)|Y for all λ ∈ ρ(A). An important case is Y = D(A) when A is not densely defined. Then it may well happen that AY is not densely defined either (a concrete example is the Poisson operator considered in Section 6.1). Nevertheless the following holds true. Lemma 3.3.12. Let A be an operator on X such that (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and M := sup λR(λ, A) < ∞ λ>ω
for some ω ∈ R. Let Y = D(A). Then a) limλ→∞ λR(λ, A)x = x for all x ∈ Y . b) D(AY ) is dense in Y . c) If A satisfies the Hille-Yosida condition (3.23), then AY generates a C0 semigroup on Y . Proof. a) The assumption implies that limλ→∞ R(λ, A)x = 0 for all x ∈ X. Hence, limλ→∞ λR(λ, A)x = limλ→∞ (x + R(λ, A)Ax) = x if x ∈ D(A). Consequently, limλ→∞ λR(λ, A)x = x if x ∈ D(A) = Y . b) Since R(λ, A)x ∈ D(AY ) if x ∈ Y , this follows from a). c) This follows from the Hille-Yosida theorem. Although the part of an operator A in D(A) may not be densely defined, we obtain the following result from the proof of Theorem 3.3.2. Corollary 3.3.13. Let A be an operator satisfying the equivalent conditions of Theorem 3.3.1 for some k ∈ N0 and let Y = D(A). Then the part AY of A in Y generates a k-times integrated semigroup on Y . Proof. By Lemma 3.2.2, Sk+1 (·)x ∈ C 1 (R+ , X) provided x ∈ D(A). It follows from Lemma 3.3.3 that Sk+1 (·)x ∈ Cω1 (R+ , X) for all x ∈ D(A) = Y . For t > 0 and d x ∈ Y let Sk (t)x = dt Sk+1 (t)x. Since Sk+1 (t)D(A) ⊂ D(A) for t > 0, it follows that Sk (t)x ∈ Y for all x ∈ Y . Thus, Sk : R+ → L(Y ) is strongly continuous and ∞ ∞ R(λ, A)x = λk+1 e−λt Sk+1 (t)x dt = λk e−λt Sk (t)x dt 0
for all x ∈ Y and λ sufficiently large.
0
3.4. DISSIPATIVE OPERATORS
137
Proposition 3.3.14. Let T be a C0 -semigroup on X with generator A. Let X := D(A∗ ). Then T (t) := T (t)∗ |X defines a C0 -semigroup whose generator A is the part of A∗ in X . The C0 -semigroup T is known as the sun-dual of T . Proof. It follows from Lemma 3.3.12 that the part of A∗ in X generates a C0 semigroup T on X . For x ∈ X and x∗ ∈ X , Corollary 3.3.6 shows that + , + , x, T (t) x∗ = lim x, (I − nt A )−n x∗ n→∞ + , = lim x, ((I − nt A)−n )∗ x∗ n→∞ + , = lim (I − nt A)−n x, x∗ n→∞
= T (t)x, x∗ = x, T (t)∗ x∗ . It follows that T (t) = T (t)∗ |X for all t > 0.
3.4
Dissipative Operators
In the previous section we saw that, by the Hille-Yosida characterization, the generator of a contraction semigroup may be characterized in terms of a resolvent estimate for real λ. It is the aim of this section to give a second characterization of such semigroups, which turns out to be quite useful in particular when dealing with differential operators. In order to do so, we define for x ∈ X the subdifferential dN(x) of the norm N : X → R+ , N (x) = x at x by dN(x) := {x∗ ∈ X ∗ : x∗ ≤ 1, x, x∗ = x } .
(3.28)
The Hahn-Banach theorem implies that dN(x) = ∅ for all x ∈ X. Definition 3.4.1. An operator A on X is called dissipative if for every x ∈ D(A) there exists x∗ ∈ dN(x) such that ReAx, x∗ ≤ 0.
(3.29)
A useful characterization of dissipative operators is the following. Lemma 3.4.2. An operator A on X is dissipative if and only if
(λ − A)x ≥ λ x
(x ∈ D(A), λ > 0)
or equivalently,
x − tAx ≥ x
(x ∈ D(A), t > 0).
(3.30)
138
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Proof. Assume that A is dissipative. Let x ∈ D(A), t > 0. Let x∗ ∈ dN(x) satisfy (3.29). Then for t > 0,
x − tAx
≥ Rex − tAx, x∗ = x − t ReAx, x∗ ≥ x .
Conversely, let x ∈ D(A) and assume that x − tAx ≥ x (t > 0). Choose x∗t ∈ dN(x − tAx) and let x∗ be a weak* accumulation point of x∗t as t ↓ 0. Then
x∗ ≤ 1. Since x − tAx = x − tAx, x∗t , letting t ↓ 0 shows that x = x, x∗ . Thus, x∗ ∈ dN(x). Moreover,
x ≤ x − tAx
= ≤
Rex, x∗t − t ReAx, x∗t
x − t ReAx, x∗t .
Thus, ReAx, x∗t ≤ 0. Letting t ↓ 0 shows that ReAx, x∗ ≤ 0. Example 3.4.3. a) Dissipative operators acting on Hilbert spaces or Lp -spaces may be characterized as follows: (i) Let A be an operator on a Hilbert space H. Denote by (·|·) the inner product in H. Then A is dissipative if and only if Re(Ax|x) ≤ 0 for all x ∈ D(A). (ii) Let Ω ⊂ Rn be open, 1 < p < ∞, set X := Lp (Ω) and identify X ∗ with Lp (Ω) where 1/p + 1/p = 1. For f ∈ X \ {0} we define sign f ∈ L∞ (Ω) by ⎧ ⎨0 if f (x) = 0, (sign f )(x) := f (x) ⎩ if f (x) = 0. |f (x)| ( −(p−1) ' Then dN(f ) = f p sign f¯ · |f |p−1 , where f¯ denotes the complex conjugate function of f . Therefore an operator A on X is dissipative if and only if Re Af · sign f¯ · |f |p−1 dx ≤ 0 (3.31) Ω
for all f ∈ D(A). b) If A is dissipative, then cA is dissipative for all c > 0. c) If B ∈ L(X), then B − B is dissipative. Lemma 3.4.4. Let A be a densely defined dissipative operator on X. Then A is closable and A is dissipative. Proof. Let (xn ) ⊂ D(A) such that xn → 0 and Axn → y for some y ∈ X as n → ∞. We show that y = 0. To this end, let z ∈ D(A). It follows from Lemma
3.4. DISSIPATIVE OPERATORS
139
3.4.2 that (I − tA)x ≥ x for all t > 0 and all x ∈ D(A). Hence xn + tz ≤ xn + tz − tA(xn + tz) for all n ∈ N and all t > 0. This implies that
tz ≤ tz − ty − t2 Az and hence z ≤ z − y − tAz for all t > 0. Letting t → 0 we obtain z ≤ z − y for all z ∈ D(A). Since D(A) is dense, it follows that y = 0 which means that A is closable. Taking limits in (3.30) shows that A is dissipative. The following theorem due to Lumer and Phillips characterizes generators A of C0 -semigroups of contractions in terms of dissipativity of A. Theorem 3.4.5 (Lumer-Phillips). Let A be a densely defined operator on X. Then A generates a C0 -semigroup of contractions on X if and only if a) A is dissipative, and b) (λ − A)D(A) = X for some (or all) λ > 0. Proof. Let A be the generator of a C0 -semigroup of contractions. Then assertion b) holds by the Hille-Yosida theorem (Corollary 3.3.5). Moreover, the Hille-Yosida theorem combined with Lemma 3.4.2 implies assertion a). In order to prove the converse implication note that by Lemma 3.4.2 we have
(λ − A)x ≥ λ x
(x ∈ D(A), λ > 0).
(3.32)
Since (λ0 − A)D(A) = X for some λ0 > 0, it follows from (3.32) that λ0 − A is invertible and that R(λ0 , A) ≤ λ−1 0 . We show that this property holds for all λ > 0. In fact, let Λ := ρ(A) ∩ (0, ∞). Then Λ = ∅ and therefore A is closed. Furthermore let (λn ) ⊂ Λ such that limn→∞ λn = λ > 0. By Corollary B.3, dist(λn , σ(A)) ≥ R(λn , A) −1 ≥ λn for all n ∈ N and it follows that λ ∈ Λ. This shows that Λ is closed in (0, ∞). Since Λ is obviously open, it follows that Λ = (0, ∞) and therefore (0, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A). Inequality (3.32) implies that R(λ, A) ≤ λ−1 for all λ > 0 and the Hille-Yosida theorem finally implies the assertion. By the same proof with Theorem 3.3.1 replacing the Hille-Yosida theorem we obtain the following characterization in the case when D(A) is not necessarily dense. Corollary 3.4.6. Let A be an operator on X. The following assertions are equivalent: (i) A is dissipative and (λ − A)D(A) = X for some (or all) λ > 0. (ii) A generates a once integrated semigroup S satisfying
S(t) − S(s) ≤ |t − s|
(t, s ≥ 0).
In concrete examples, dissipativity is often relatively easy to verify whereas the range condition b) in Theorem 3.4.5 is hard to show. However, in the following example of the Dirichlet-Laplacian, the range condition is just a consequence of the Riesz-Fr´echet lemma.
140
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Example 3.4.7 (The Laplacian with Dirichlet boundary conditions). Let Ω ⊂ Rn be an open set. Consider the operator A : D(A) → L2 (Ω) defined by D(A)
:= {u ∈ H01 (Ω) : Δu ∈ L2 (Ω)},
Au :=
Δu.
1 Here, n H02 (Ω) is the Sobolev space defined in Appendix E, and Δu is defined to be E). Denoting by (·|·) j=1 Dj u in the sense of distributions (see also Appendix the inner product in L2 (Ω), we see that (Au|u) = Ω (Δu)¯ u = − Ω |∇u|2 ≤ 0 for u ∈ D(A). Hence, by Example 3.4.3 a), the operator A is dissipative. In order to prove the range condition b) of Theorem 3.4.5, let f ∈ L2 (Ω). Then the mapping Φ : v → Ω f v defines a continuous linear functional on the Hilbert space H01 (Ω). By the Riesz-Fr´echet lemma, there exists a unique u ∈ H01 (Ω) such that Φ(v) = (v|¯ u)H01 (Ω) for all v ∈ H01 (Ω). Here,
(v|¯ u)H01 (Ω) :=
uv + Ω
n j=1
Ω
Dj uDj v
denotes the inner product in H01 (Ω). Considering in particular v ∈ D(Ω), it follows that u − Δu = f in D(Ω) . This implies that u ∈ D(A) and u − Au = f . Obviously, D(A) is dense in L2 (Ω) and by the Lumer-Phillips theorem, A generates a contraction semigroup on L2 (Ω). We call A the Laplacian with Dirichlet boundary conditions on L2 (Ω), and we denote it by ΔL2 (Ω) . We remark that in the case where Ω is a bounded domain with boundary of class C 2 , it can be shown (see [Bre83, Th´eor`eme IX.25]) that D(ΔL2 (Ω) ) = H 2 (Ω) ∩ H01 (Ω). Example 3.4.8. Consider the Hilbert space X := L2 (0, 1) and the operator := {u ∈ H 1 (0, 1) : u(0) = 0},
D(A)
:= u .
Au
1 Then Re (u|Au) = 12 0 (u(x)u (x)+u (x)u(x)) dx = 12 |u(1)|2 ≥ 0. For f ∈ L2 (0, 1) and λ ∈ C, define u by x u(x) := e−λ(x−y) f (y) dy (x ∈ (0, 1)). 0
Then u ∈ D(A) and λu + u = f . Hence, the range condition (λ + A)D(A) = X is fulfilled for all λ ∈ C and by the Lumer-Phillips theorem, −A generates a contraction semigroup T on X. It is not difficult to see that T is given by f (x − t) (t ≤ x), (T (t)f )(x) = (3.33) 0 (t > x).
3.5. HILLE-YOSIDA OPERATORS
141
∞ x In fact, the mapping x → 0 e−λt (T (t)f )(x) dt = 0 e−λ(x−y) f (y) dy belongs to ∞ ∂ D(A) and (λ + ∂x ) 0 e−λt (T (t)f )(x) dt = f (x) for x ∈ (0, 1). Since (λ + A) is ∞ invertible for all λ ∈ C, we see that (λ + A)−1 = 0 e−λt T (t) dt. The representation (3.33) implies that T also defines a C0 -semigroup of positive contractions on Lp (0, 1) for 1 ≤ p < ∞. Its generator is given by −Ap where D(Ap ) = {u ∈ W 1,p (0, 1) : u(0) = 0}
3.5
and Ap u = u .
(3.34)
Hille-Yosida Operators
In this section we consider operators which satisfy the Hille-Yosida condition (3.23) but are not necessarily densely defined. Definition 3.5.1. A linear operator A on X is called a Hille-Yosida operator if there exist ω ∈ R, M ≥ 0 such that (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and
(λ − ω)n R(λ, A)n ≤ M
(n ∈ N0 , λ > ω).
(3.35)
We note that by the Hille-Yosida theorem and the identity (−1)n R(λ, A)(n) /n! = R(λ, A)n+1 , the class of densely defined Hille-Yosida operators coincides with the class of generators of C0 -semigroups on X. We also observe that by Theorem 3.3.1 an operator A on X is a Hille-Yosida operator if and only if A generates a once integrated semigroup S on X satisfying t
S(t) − S(s) ≤ M eωr dr (0 ≤ s ≤ t) (3.36) s
for some ω ∈ R, M ≥ 0. The above estimate (3.36) implies in particular that S is a locally Lipschitz continuous function on R+ . This fact will be of crucial importance in the proof of the following result on the inhomogeneous Cauchy problem for operators which are not necessarily densely defined. More precisely, consider the problem u (t) = Au(t) + f (t) (t ∈ [0, τ ]), (ACPf ) (3.37) u(0) = x, where f : [0, τ ] → X is a given function and x ∈ X. When D(A) = X, then the inhomogeneous problem can be solved in the classical sense by means of the variation of constants formula provided x ∈ D(A) and f ∈ C 1 ([0, τ ], X) (see Corollary 3.2.11 b)). Note that this method cannot be used when D(A) = X and when f (t) ∈ D(A). The method which we use in the following to treat (ACPf ) is based
142
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
on the fact that a Hille-Yosida operator generates a once integrated semigroup which is locally Lipschitz continuous. Employing the results of Section 3.2 in the present situation, we see that existence and uniqueness results for (ACPf ) are equivalent to the fact that v given by
t
v(t) = S(t)x + 0
S(t)f (t − s)ds
is sufficiently regular. More precisely, the following holds true. Theorem 3.5.2 (Da Prato-Sinestrari). Let A be a Hille-Yosida operator on X and let τ > 0. a) Let f ∈ L1 ([0, τ ], X) and x ∈ D(A). Then there exists a unique mild solution of (ACPf ). t b) Let f (t) = f0 + 0 g(s) ds where f0 ∈ X and g ∈ L1 ([0, τ ], X). Let x ∈ D(A) and assume that Ax+f0 ∈ D(A). Then there exists a unique classical solution of (ACPf ). Remark 3.5.3. a) Note that x ∈ D(A) is a necessary condition for a mild solution t t u to exist, because limt→0 1t 0 u(s) ds = x and 0 u(s) ds ∈ D(A) by definition of a mild solution. b) If a classical solution u of (ACPf ) exists, then x ∈ D(A) and Ax + f (0) ∈ D(A). In fact,
(3.38)
Au(0) + f (0) = u (0) = lim 1t (u(t) − u(0)) ∈ D(A). t→0
Proof of Theorem 3.5.2. Let A be a Hille-Yosida operator on X. By Theorem 3.3.1, A generates a once integrated semigroup S on X which satisfies estimate (3.36). In order to prove assertion a), it suffices by Lemma 3.2.9, Proposition 1.3.7 and Lemma 3.2.10 to show that t → S(t)x belongs to C 1 ([0, τ ], X). This follows from the assumption that x ∈ D(A), Lemma 3.2.2 c) and Lemma 3.3.3. Thus, we have proved assertion a). In order to prove assertion b), it suffices by Lemma 3.2.9 and Lemma 3.2.10 to verify that v ∈ C 2 ([0, τ ], X). Since x ∈ D(A) it follows from Lemma 3.2.2 c) and Proposition 1.3.6 that v (t) = x + S(t)Ax + S(t)f0 +
t 0
S(s)g(t − s) ds.
Now, by Proposition 1.3.7 the convolution term on the right hand side above belongs to C 1 ([0, τ ], X) and t → S(t)(Ax + f0 ) belongs to C 1 ([0, τ ], X) by the
3.5. HILLE-YOSIDA OPERATORS
143
argument given in the proof of assertion a), since Ax + f0 ∈ D(A) by assumption. Given a Hille-Yosida operator A, we consider now the problem whether or not the sum A + B of A and some operator B is again a Hille-Yosida operator. We start with the following renorming lemma. Lemma 3.5.4. Let A be a Hille-Yosida operator satisfying estimate (3.35) for some M > 0 and ω = 0. Then there exists an equivalent norm | · | on X such that
x ≤ |x| ≤ M x for x ∈ X and |λR(λ, A)x| ≤ |x|
(x ∈ X, λ > 0).
Proof. For μ > 0 and x ∈ X set
x μ := sup μn R(μ, A)n x . n≥0
Then
x ≤ x μ ≤ M x
and
μR(μ, A) μ ≤ 1.
(3.39)
Let λ ∈ (0, μ] and set y := R(λ, A)x. It follows that y = R(μ, A)(x + (μ − λ)y) and hence that y μ ≤ μ1 x μ + (1 − λμ ) y μ . Therefore, λR(λ, A) μ ≤ 1 and it follows from (3.39) that
λn R(λ, A)n x ≤ λn R(λ, A)n x μ ≤ x μ
(0 < λ ≤ μ).
(3.40)
Hence x λ ≤ x μ for 0 < λ ≤ μ. Defining |x| := lim x μ , μ→∞
the assertion follows by taking n = 1 in (3.40) and letting μ → ∞. Theorem 3.5.5. Let A be a Hille-Yosida operator on X and let B ∈ L(D(A), X). Then A + B is a Hille-Yosida operator. Proof. Replacing A by A − ω we may assume that the estimate (3.35) is satisfied for A with ω = 0. Denote by | · | the norm introduced in Lemma 3.5.4. It follows from that lemma that |λR(λ, A)| ≤ 1 (λ > 0). Note that λ−(A+B) = (I −BR(λ, A))(λ−A) for λ > 0. Since |BR(λ, A)| ≤ |B|/λ, the operator I − BR(λ, A) is invertible for λ > |B| and |(λ − (A + B))−1 | ≤ |(λ − A)−1 | |(I − BR(λ))−1 | ≤
1 1 1 = λ 1 − |B|λ−1 λ − |B|
for those λ. Hence |(λ−|B|)R(λ, A+B)| ≤ 1 for λ > |B|. Returning to the original norm we have for x ∈ X,
(λ − |B|)n R(λ, A + B)n x ≤ |(λ − |B|)n R(λ, A + B)n x| ≤ |x| ≤ M x
144
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
for λ > |B|. Thus A + B is a Hille-Yosida operator. Taking into account the Hille-Yosida theorem and the fact that generators of C0 -semigroups are densely defined we obtain the following corollary. Corollary 3.5.6. Let A be the generator of a C0 -semigroup on X and let B ∈ L(X). Then A + B generates a C0 -semigroup. Next we consider perturbation by operators defined on the domain of the given operator. If A is a closed operator, we consider D(A) with the graph norm
x D(A) := x + Ax for which it is a Banach space. Two operators A, defined ˜ defined on a second Banach space X, ˜ are called similar if there exists on X, and A, ˜ such that an isomorphism U : X → X ˜ = U D(A) D(A)
and
˜ x = Ax U −1 AU
for all x ∈ D(A).
In that case, A and A˜ have similar properties. For example, if A generates a C0 ˜ given by semigroup T , then A˜ generates the C0 -semigroup T˜ on X T˜ (t)y = U T (t)U −1 y
˜ t ≥ 0). (y ∈ X,
Similarly, if A generates an integrated semigroup S, then A˜ generates the inte˜ given by grated semigroup S˜ on X ˜ S(t)y = U S(t)U −1 y
˜ t ≥ 0). (y ∈ X,
Theorem 3.5.7. Let A be an operator such that (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and M := supλ>ω λR(λ, A) < ∞ for some ω ∈ R, and let B ∈ L(D(A)). Then there exists a bounded operator C ∈ L(X) such that A + B and A + C are similar. In particular, if A is a Hille-Yosida operator, then A + B is also a Hille-Yosida operator. For the proof we need the following well-known result. Lemma 3.5.8. Let U, V ∈ L(X). If I − U V is invertible, then so is I − V U . Proof. One has (I − V U )−1 = I + V (I − U V )−1 U . Proof of Theorem 3.5.7. Choose λ0 > ω and let S := (λ0 − A)BR(λ0 , A) ∈ L(X). Choose λ > λ0 such that SR(λ, A) < 1. Then I − (λ0 − A)BR(λ, A)R(λ0 , A) = I − SR(λ, A) is invertible. It follows from Lemma 3.5.8 that I − BR(λ, A) is also invertible. Let C := (λ − A)BR(λ, A) ∈ L(X). We show that A + B and A + C are similar. Let U := I − BR(λ, A). Then U is an isomorphism on X such that U D(A) = D(A). Moreover, U (A + C)U −1
= U (A − λ + C)U −1 + λ = U [A − λ − (A − λ)BR(λ, A)]U −1 + λ = U (A − λ)[I − BR(λ, A)]U −1 + λ = U (A − λ) + λ = A − λ + B + λ = A + B.
3.6. APPROXIMATION OF SEMIGROUPS
145
This proves the claim. Now the second assertion follows from Theorem 3.5.5. Finally, we collect several examples of Hille-Yosida operators. Example 3.5.9. a) Let A be the generator of a C0 -semigroup on X. Then the adjoint A∗ of A is a Hille-Yosida operator on X ∗ . b) As a concrete example, consider X = L∞ (R) and define A by Au := −u with D(A) := W 1,∞ (R). By Example 3.3.10, (0, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and R(λ, A) ≤ 1/λ for λ > 0. c) Let A be the generator of a semigroup T in the sense of Definition 3.2.5. Since t S(t) := 0 T (s) ds fulfills assumption (ii) of Theorem 3.3.1 for k = 0 it follows from that theorem that A is a Hille-Yosida operator. d) Let X := C[0, 1] and define an operator A on X by Au D(A)
:= −u ' ( := u ∈ C 1 [0, 1] : u(0) = 0 .
Then D(A) = {u ∈ C[0, 1] : u(0) = 0} = X, (0, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and ||R(λ, A)|| ≤ 1/λ for λ > 0. In fact, for f ∈ X and λ > 0 set x u(x) := e−λy f (x − y) dy (x ∈ [0, 1]). 0
Then u ∈ D(A), (λ − A)u = f and sup |u(x)| ≤ f
x∈[0,1]
∞
e−λy dy =
0
1
f , λ
which implies the assertions above.
3.6
Approximation of Semigroups
In this section we study convergence of semigroups. It is interesting that we obtain the main result (Theorem 3.6.1) directly as a consequence of the approximation theorem for Laplace transforms given in Section 1.7, which in turn was proved by a simple functional analytic argument. At the end of the section we give a second proof of the Hille-Yosida theorem, as a simple corollary of the approximation theorem. Let Tn be a C0 -semigroup on X with generator An (n ∈ N). We suppose that
Tn (t) ≤ M
(t ≥ 0, n ∈ N).
If for each x ∈ X lim Tn (t)x =: T (t)x
n→∞
(3.41)
146
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
converges uniformly on [0, τ ] for each τ > 0, then it is easy to see that T is a C0 -semigroup. Denote its generator by A. Then it follows from the dominated convergence theorem that limn→∞ R(λ, An )x = R(λ, A)x for all x ∈ X, λ > 0. We now show the converse assertion. Theorem 3.6.1 (Trotter-Kato). Let Tn be a C0 -semigroup on X with generator An (n ∈ N) and suppose that (3.41) holds. Let A be a densely defined operator on X. Suppose that there exists ω ≥ 0 such that (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and lim R(λ, An )x = R(λ, A)x
(3.42)
n→∞
for all x ∈ X, λ > ω. Then A is the generator of a C0 -semigroup T and T (t)x = lim Tn (t)x
(3.43)
n→∞
uniformly on [0, τ ] for all τ > 0 and all x ∈ X. Proof. a) Let x ∈ X. We show that the sequence (Tn (·)x)n∈N is equicontinuous on R+ . Since D(A) is dense in X, we can assume that x ∈ D(A). Let ε > 0. Let μ > ω, y := (μ − A)x. Choose n0 ∈ N such that M R(μ, A)y − R(μ, An )y ≤ ε/2 for all n ≥ n0 . Then (by Proposition 3.1.9 f)) for n ≥ n0 ,
Tn (t)x − Tn (s)x = Tn (t)R(μ, A)y − Tn (s)R(μ, A)y
≤
Tn (t)R(μ, An )y − Tn (s)R(μ, An )y + ε/2
t
= Tn (r)An R(μ, An )y dr
0
s
ε − Tn (r)An R(μ, An )y dr
+ 2 0 ≤ M |t − s| An R(μ, An )y + ε/2 = M |t − s| μR(μ, An )y − y + ε/2. Since supn∈N R(μ, An )y < ∞, there exists δ > 0 such that Tn (t)x−Tn (s)x ≤ ε whenever |t − s| ≤ δ and n ≥ n0 . Since Tn (·)x : R+ → X is continuous for n < n0 , this shows that the sequence is equicontinuous. b) Now it follows from Theorem 1.7.5 that Tn (t)x converges uniformly on [0, τ ] as n → ∞ for all x ∈ X and all τ > 0. It is clear that T (t)x := limn→∞ Tn (t)x (x ∈ X) defines a C0 -semigroup T on X. By the dominated convergence theorem one has ∞ ∞ e−λt T (t)x dt = lim e−λt Tn (t)x dt n→∞
0
=
0
lim R(λ, An )x = R(λ, A)x
n→∞
(x ∈ X, λ > ω).
By Definition 3.1.8 this means that A is the generator of T . In order to apply Theorem 3.6.1 it is useful to give other criteria equivalent to (3.42).
3.6. APPROXIMATION OF SEMIGROUPS
147
Proposition 3.6.2. Let ω ∈ R. Let A and An be operators such that (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(An ) for all n ∈ N. Assume that supn∈N R(λ, An ) < ∞ for all λ > ω. Then the following assertions are equivalent: (i) limn→∞ R(μ, An )x = R(μ, A)x for all x ∈ X and all μ > ω. (ii) limn→∞ R(μ, An )x = R(μ, A)x for all x ∈ X and some μ > ω. (iii) For all x ∈ D(A) there exist xn ∈ D(An ) such that limn→∞ xn = x and limn→∞ An xn = Ax. (iv) There exists a core D of A such that for all x ∈ D there exist xn ∈ D(An ) such that limn→∞ xn = x and limn→∞ An xn = Ax. Proof. (i) ⇒ (ii) is trivial. (ii) ⇒ (iii): Let x ∈ D(A). Then xn := R(μ, An )(μ − A)x ∈ D(An ), xn → x by hypothesis, and An xn = μxn − (μ − A)x → Ax as n → ∞. (iii) ⇒ (iv) is trivial. (iv) ⇒ (i): Let μ > ω. Let x ∈ D. By hypothesis, there exist xn ∈ D(An ) such that xn → x and An xn → Ax. Let yn := (μ − An )xn . Then yn → y := (μ − A)x. Hence, lim sup R(μ, An )y − R(μ, A)y
n→∞ ≤ lim sup R(μ, An )(y − yn ) + R(μ, An )yn − R(μ, A)y
n→∞
= lim sup R(μ, An )yn − R(μ, A)y
n→∞
= lim sup xn − x = 0. n→∞
Since D is a core and μ − A is surjective, {(μ − A)x : x ∈ D} is dense in X (see Appendix B), and (i) follows by approximation. Corollary 3.6.3. Let A be a densely defined operator on X. Let An ∈ L(X) such that
etAn ≤ M (t ≥ 0, n ∈ N), where M ≥ 0. Assume that (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and limn→∞ An x = Ax for all x ∈ D(A). Then A generates a C0 -semigroup T and for all x ∈ X, limn→∞ etAn x = T (t)x uniformly for t ∈ [0, τ ] for all τ > 0. It is easy to deduce the Hille-Yosida theorem (Corollary 3.3.5) from Corollary 3.6.3. In fact, let A be a densely defined operator on X such that (0, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and λR(λ, A) ≤ 1 for all λ > 0. Denote by An := n2 R(n, A) − nI
(n ∈ N)
148
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
the Yosida approximation of A. Then
etAn = e−nt etn
2
R(n,A)
2
≤ e−nt etn
R(n,A)
≤1
(t > 0, n ∈ N).
Then limn→∞ An x = Ax for all x ∈ D(A). In fact, An x − Ax = nR(n, A)Ax − Ax → 0 by Lemma 3.3.12. Now it follows from Corollary 3.6.3 that A generates a contractive C0 -semigroup.
3.7
Holomorphic Semigroups
This section is devoted to the study of holomorphic semigroups. This class of semigroups plays an important role in the theory of evolution equations. Indeed, the modern treatment of linear and nonlinear parabolic problems is based on the theory of holomorphic semigroups. When compared with arbitrary C0 -semigroups, holomorphic C0 -semigroups show many special properties. We only mention here a) characterization results involving only a resolvent estimate (for example, Theorem 3.7.11 and Corollary 3.7.17), b) regularity properties of solutions of the Cauchy problem (Corollary 3.7.21 and applications in Chapters 6 and 7), c) determination of the asymptotic behaviour of the C0 -semigroup by spectral conditions on the generator (Theorem 5.1.12 and Theorem 5.6.5). Throughout this section, let Σθ := {z ∈ C \ {0} : | arg z| < θ} be the sector in the complex plane of angle θ ∈ (0, π]. Recall from Definition 3.2.5 that a semigroup T was defined to be a strongly continuous mapping (0, ∞) → L(X) satisfying a) T (t + s) = T (t)T (s) for all s, t > 0; b) T (t) ≤ c for all t ∈ (0, 1] and some c > 0; and c) T (t)x = 0 for all t > 0 implies x = 0. Recall also from Corollary 3.3.11 that a semigroup is a C0 -semigroup if and only if its generator A is densely defined. Definition 3.7.1. Let θ ∈ (0, π2 ]. A semigroup T on X is called holomorphic of angle θ if it has a holomorphic extension to Σθ which is bounded on Σθ ∩ {z ∈ C : |z| ≤ 1} for all θ ∈ (0, θ). If no confusion seems likely, we denote the extension of T to Σθ also by T . Also, if we do not want to specify the angle θ in Definition 3.7.1, we call a semigroup T holomorphic if it is holomorphic of angle θ for some θ ∈ (0, π2 ]. Proposition 3.7.2. Let θ ∈ (0, π2 ] and let T be a semigroup on X with generator A. Assume that T is holomorphic of angle θ. Then the following hold: a) T (z + z ) = T (z)T (z )
(z, z ∈ Σθ ).
b) For all θ ∈ (0, θ) there exist M ≥ 0, ω ≥ 0 such that T (z) ≤ M eω Re z for all z ∈ Σθ .
3.7. HOLOMORPHIC SEMIGROUPS
149
c) Let α ∈ (−θ, θ). Denote by Tα the semigroup given by Tα (t) := T (eiα t) (t ≥ 0). Then eiα A is the generator of Tα . d) If T is a C0 -semigroup, then lim
z→0,z∈Σθ
T (z)x = x
for all x ∈ X and all θ ∈ (0, θ). Proof. a) For fixed z ∈ (0, ∞) consider the holomorphic functions z → T (z + z ) and z → T (z)T (z ) for z ∈ Σθ . Since the two functions coincide on (0, ∞), the identity theorem for holomorphic functions implies that T (z + z ) = T (z)T (z ) for z ∈ Σθ and z ∈ (0, ∞). For fixed z ∈ Σθ the two holomorphic functions z → T (z + z ) and z → T (z)T (z ) coincide for z ∈ (0, ∞) and the assertion follows from the identity theorem for holomorphic functions. b) Let θ ∈ (0, θ), M :=
T (z) ,
sup
ω := max{log M, 0}.
z∈Σθ ,|z|≤1
Then T (z) ≤ M eω |z| for all z ∈ Σθ . In fact, let z = teiβ where |β| ≤ θ . Applying the proof of Theorem 3.1.7 a) to Tβ one obtains
T (z) = Tβ (t) ≤ M eω|z| . Since |z| ≤ Re z/ cos θ for z ∈ Σθ , the claim follows with ω := ω / cos θ. c) Let Aα be the generator of Tα . For R > 0, let ΓR be the contour consisting of the line segments {t : 0 ≤ t ≤ R} and {teiα : 0 ≤ t ≤ R} and the arc {Reiϕ : 0 ≤ ϕ ≤ α}. Cauchy’s theorem implies that ΓR exp(−λe−iα z)T (z)x dz = 0 for λ > 0 and x ∈ X. Letting R → ∞, we obtain ∞ ∞ iα iα −λt e R(λ, Aα )x = e e Tα (t)x dt = exp(−λe−iα t)T (t)x dt 0
0
= R(λe−iα , A)x, by Theorem 3.1.7. This implies that Aα = eiα A. d) Let θ ∈ (0, θ). By b) there exist ω ≥ 0 and M ≥ 0 such that e−ωz T (z) ≤ M for all z ∈ Σθ . It follows from Proposition 2.6.3 b) that lim
z→0,z∈Σθ
e−ωz T (z)x = x
for all x ∈ X. This implies the claim. We note that in the situation of Proposition 3.7.2, Tα is a C0 -semigroup for each α ∈ (−θ, θ) whenever T is a C0 -semigroup; i.e., if D(A) is dense. Next, we define bounded holomorphic semigroups.
150
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Definition 3.7.3. Let θ ∈ (0, π2 ]. A semigroup T is called a bounded holomorphic semigroup of angle θ if T has a bounded holomorphic extension to Σθ for each θ ∈ (0, θ). We denote the extension of T to Σθ by T again. If we do not want to specify the angle, we call T a bounded holomorphic semigroup if T is a bounded holomorphic semigroup of angle θ for some θ ∈ (0, π2 ]. Some caution is required concerning this terminology. If T is a bounded semigroup which is holomorphic, then it is not necessarily a bounded holomorphic semigroup since it is just bounded on R+ and may not be bounded on a sector. For example, let X = C and T (t) = eit (t ≥ 0). The following result is an immediate consequence of Proposition 3.7.2 b). Proposition 3.7.4. An operator A generates a holomorphic semigroup if and only if there exists ω ≥ 0 such that A − ω generates a bounded holomorphic semigroup. Next we give some examples of holomorphic semigroups. Example 3.7.5 (Selfadjoint operators). Let A be a selfadjoint operator on a Hilbert space H. Assume that A is bounded above by ω. Then A generates a bounded holomorphic C0 -semigroup of angle π/2 satisfying
T (z) ≤ eω Re z
(Re z > 0).
Proof. By the Spectral Theorem B.13, we can assume that H = L2 (Ω, μ) and that A is given by D(A) = {f ∈ H : mf ∈ H}, Af = m · f, where m : Ω → (−∞, ω] is measurable. It is easy to see that (T (z)f )(x) := ezm(x) f (x)
(x ∈ Ω, Re z > 0),
defines a holomorphic C0 -semigroup on H, whose generator is A. Example 3.7.6 (Gaussian semigroup). Let X be one of the spaces Lp (Rn ) (1 ≤ p < ∞), C0 (Rn ) or BUC(Rn ). Then 2 (G(t)f )(x) := (4πt)−n/2 f (x − y)e−|y| /4t dy (t > 0, f ∈ X, x ∈ Rn ) Rn
defines a bounded holomorphic C0 -semigroup of angle π/2 on X. Its generator is the Laplacian ΔX on X with maximal domain; i.e., D(ΔX ) = {f ∈ X : Δf ∈ X}, ΔX f = Δf, where we identify X with a subspace of D(Rn ) , and Δf = pendix E).
n j=1
Dj2 f (see Ap-
3.7. HOLOMORPHIC SEMIGROUPS
151
Proof. a) Let kt ∈ S(Rn ) be given by kt (x) =
1 (4πt)
n/2
e−|x|
2
(t > 0, x ∈ Rn ).
/4t
2
Then G(t)f = kt ∗ f ∈ X. Note that F kt = ht , where ht (x) := e−t|x| . Hence, ht+s = ht hs . Recall that F is an isomorphism from S(Rn ) onto S(Rn ) such that F (ψ ∗ f ) = F ψ · F f for all f ∈ S(Rn ) , ψ ∈ S(Rn ) (see Appendix E). Thus, F (G(t)f ) = ht · Ff . It follows that G(t + s) = G(t)G(s) (t, s > 0). Since {kt : t > 0} is an approximate identity (see Lemma 1.3.3), it follows that
kt ∗ f − f X → 0 as t ↓ 0 for all f ∈ X. We have shown that G is a C0 -semigroup. b) The function kz is also defined for Re z > 0 and z → kz : C+ → L1 (Rn ) is a holomorphic function satisfying supz∈Σθ kz L1 (Rn ) < ∞ for each 0 < θ < π/2. This shows that G(z)f := kz ∗ f defines a holomorphic extension of G to C+ with values in L(X) such that supz∈Σθ G(z) < ∞ for each 0 < θ < π/2. c) We identify the generator of G. First step: Let f ∈ X such that Δf ∈ X. We show that Δ(G(t)f ) = G(t)(Δf ). Let m(x) = −|x|2 . Then F(Δ(G(t)f )) = mF(G(t)f ) = mht Ff = ht mFf = ht F(Δf ) = F (G(t)Δf ). This proves the claim. Second step: Let ψ ∈ S(Rn ). Then 0
t
G1 (s)Δψ ds = G1 (t)ψ − ψ,
where G1 is the Gaussian semigroup on L1 (Rn ). In fact, t t F G1 (s)Δψ ds (x) = F (G1 (s)Δψ)(x) ds 0
0
=
t
2
e−s|x| (−|x|)2 (F ψ)(x) ds
0 −t|x|2
− 1)(Fψ)(x)
=
(e
=
(F(G1 (t)ψ − ψ))(x).
The claim follows from the uniqueness of Fourier transforms. Third step: Let f ∈ X, t > 0. We show that t Δ G(s)f ds = G(t)f − f. 0
Then it follows from Corollary 3.1.13 (using also the first step) that the generator of G is the Laplacian with maximal domain. Let ψ ∈ S(Rn ). Then Fubini’s theorem
152
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
gives Δψ, G(s)f = G1 (s)Δψ, f and
ψ, Δ
t
G(s)f ds
=
0
Δψ,
G(s)f ds
0
t
=
t
0 t
= 0
Δψ, G(s)f ds G1 (s)Δψ, f ds
= 0
t
G1 (s)Δψ ds, f
= G1 (t)ψ − ψ, f = ψ, G(t)f − f , by the second step. This proves the claim. Remark 3.7.7. a) Let X = Lp (Rn ) (1 < p < ∞). Then D(ΔX ) = W 2,p (Rn ). In fact, R(1, ΔX ) is given by the Fourier multiplier x → (1 + |x|2 )−1 (see Appendix E). It is easy to see that the function mjk (x) := −xj xk (1 + |x|2 )−1 satisfies the condition of Mikhlin’s theorem (Theorem E.3), so it is a Fourier multiplier for Lp (Rn ) for j, k ∈ {1, . . . , n}. One verifies easily that F (Dj Dk R(1, ΔX )f ) = mjk F f for all f ∈ S(Rn ). Thus Dj Dk R(1, ΔX ) : S(Rn ) → S(Rn ) has a bounded extension to Lp (Rn ). This means that D(ΔX ) = R(1, ΔX )Lp (Rn ) ⊂ W 2,p (Rn ). b) If X = L1 (Rn ), C0 (Rn ) or BUC(Rn ), then D(ΔX ) is not a classical function space. For example, if X = L1 (Rn ), then D(ΔX ) W 2,1 (Rn ). Similarly, if X = C0 (Rn ), then D(ΔX ) contains functions which are not in C 2 (Rn ). See [DL90, Chapter II, Section 3, Remark 5]. Modifying the Banach space in Example 3.7.6 we obtain an example of a holomorphic semigroup which is not a C0 -semigroup. Another example will be given in Chapter 6. Let Cb (Rn ) be the Banach space of all bounded continuous complex-valued functions on Rn with the supremum norm. Example 3.7.8. Let X = Cb (Rn ) or L∞ (Rn ). Define the Gaussian semigroup G on X as in Example 3.7.6. Then G is a bounded holomorphic semigroup which is not a C0 -semigroup. Its generator is the operator ΔX defined as in Example 3.7.6. Example 3.7.9 (Poisson semigroup). Let X be one of the spaces considered in Example 3.7.6. Let pt (x) = cn
(t2
t + |x|2 )(n+1)/2
(x ∈ Rn , t > 0)
3.7. HOLOMORPHIC SEMIGROUPS
153
where cn := Γ((n + 1)/2)/π (n+1)/2 . Then pt ∈ L1 (Rn ) and (Fpt )(x) = e−t|x| (t > 0). Similarly to Example 3.7.6, one shows that T (t)f := pt ∗ f
(t > 0)
defines a C0 -semigroup on X, which is called the Poisson semigroup. It is again a bounded holomorphic C0 -semigroup of angle π/2 on X. Its holomorphic extension to the sector Σπ/2 is bounded on Σθ for θ < π/2 and is given by T (z)f := pz ∗ f, where pz (x) := cn
(z 2
z + |x|2 )(n+1)/2
for x ∈ Rn and Re z > 0. Its generator is the operator AX defined by AX f D(AX )
:=
F −1 (−| · |Ff ),
:= {f ∈ X : F −1 (| · |Ff ) ∈ X},
where F now denotes the Fourier transform in S(Rn ) . A more explicit description of the operator ALp (R) is of particular interest. Observing that −(−i sign(ξ))(iξ) = −|ξ| (ξ ∈ R), it follows from (E.19) that ∂ , ∂x where H denotes the Hilbert transform defined by 1 f (x − y) (Hf )(x) := lim dy. ε→0,R→∞ π ε≤|y|≤R y ALp (R) = −H
Since the Hilbert transform acts as a bounded operator on Lp (R) for 1 < p < ∞ by Proposition E.5, it follows that the domain D(ALp (R) ) of ALp (R) coincides with W 1,p (R). However, ALp (R) is not a first-order differential operator. We shall return to the relationship between the Poisson and Gaussian semigroups in Example 3.8.5. Remark 3.7.10. Let G be the Gaussian semigroup on L1 (Rn ). It follows from the explicit formula for kz given in Example 3.7.6a) that for Re z > 0 n/2 |z|
G(z) L(L1 (Rn )) = kz L1 (Rn ) = . (3.44) Re z Thus, by Proposition 3.7.2c), Gα defined by Gα (t) := G(eiα t) for |α| < π2 is an example of a bounded C0 -semigroup, which due to (3.44), is not a contraction semigroup.
154
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
The following characterization of a bounded holomorphic semigroup in terms of a single resolvent estimate for its generator is of fundamental importance. Theorem 3.7.11. Let A be an operator on X and θ ∈ (0, π2 ]. The following assertions are equivalent: (i) A generates a bounded holomorphic semigroup of angle θ. (ii) Σθ+ π2 ⊂ ρ(A) and sup λ∈Σθ+ π −ε
λR(λ, A) < ∞ for all ε > 0.
2
Proof. In order to prove the assertion (i) ⇒ (ii), note that if λ0 ∈ ρ(A) and λ → R(λ, A) has a holomorphic extension to some open connected set Ω containing λ0 , then by Proposition B.5, Ω ⊂ ρ(A) and the extension is the resolvent. Thus (i) ⇒ (ii) follows immediately from Theorem 2.6.1. In order to prove the converse implication (ii) ⇒ (i), note that by Theorem 2.6.1 there exists a holomorphic function T : Σθ → L(X) which is bounded on Σα for 0 < α < θ such that ∞ R(λ, A) = e−λt T (t) dt (Re λ > 0). (3.45) 0
The proof of Theorem 3.1.7 shows that T is a semigroup. This proves (i). In particular, a densely defined operator A satisfying (ii) of Theorem 3.7.11 is a Hille-Yosida operator, by Example 3.5.9 c). Moreover, the bounded holomorphic semigroup T generated by A is a C0 -semigroup if and only if D(A) is dense in X, by Corollary 3.3.11. We note from (2.13) that the semigroup T generated by A is given by 1 T (z) = eλz R(λ, A) dλ (z ∈ Σα ), (3.46) 2πi Γ if 0 < α < θ, where the contour Γ consists of
Γ± := {re±γ : δ ≤ r} and Γ0 := {δeiθ : |θ | ≤ γ} with α +
π 2
<γ <θ+
π 2
and δ > 0.
If we do not want to specify the angle of holomorphy in the above theorem, then it suffices to verify condition (ii) above on a right half-plane. In fact, the following holds true. Corollary 3.7.12. For an operator A on X the following are equivalent: (i) A generates a bounded holomorphic semigroup on X.
3.7. HOLOMORPHIC SEMIGROUPS
155
(ii) {z ∈ C : Re z > 0} ⊂ ρ(A) and M := sup λR(λ, A) < ∞. Re λ>0
Proof. By Theorem 3.7.11, we only have to prove that (ii) implies the second 1 assertion of Theorem 3.7.11. Set c := 2M . For s ∈ R \ {0} and −c|s| < r ≤ 0, let λ := c|s| + r + is. Then |λ − (r + is)| = c|s| ≤ 12 R(λ, A) −1 . By Corollary B.3, r + is ∈ ρ(A) and
(r + is)R(r + is, A) ≤ 2M
|r + is| ≤ 2M (c + 1). |s|
Thus, (ii) is satisfied with θ = arctan c. Remark 3.7.13. Suppose that an operator A satisfies the equivalent conditions (i) and (ii) of the above corollary. For Y := D(A) let AY be the part of A defined as in (3.27). It follows from Lemma 3.3.12 and Corollary 3.7.12 that in this case AY generates a bounded holomorphic C0 -semigroup TY on Y . Moreover, TY (t) = T (t)|Y for t ≥ 0, where T is the semigroup generated by A. Corollary 3.7.14. Let A be an operator on X such that σ(A) ⊂ iR. Assume that there exists a constant M > 0 such that
R(λ, A) ≤
M | Re λ|
(Re λ = 0).
(3.47)
Then A2 generates a bounded holomorphic semigroup of angle π/2 on X. Proof. Let θ ∈ (0, π/2] and λ ∈ Σθ+π/2 . Then there exist r > 0 and ϕ ∈ (0, π/2) such that λ = r 2 e2iϕ . Observe that λ − A2 = (reiϕ + A)(reiϕ − A). The assumption implies that λ ∈ ρ(A2 ) and that R(λ, A2 ) = −R(reiϕ , A)R(−reiϕ , A). The resolvent estimate (3.47) implies that
R(λ, A2 ) ≤
M2 M2 1 = (r cos ϕ)2 (cos ϕ)2 |λ|
(λ ∈ Σθ+π/2 ).
Hence, the assertion follows from Theorem 3.7.11. Applying Corollary 3.7.14 to the situation of generators of bounded C0 -groups we immediately obtain the following result.
156
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Corollary 3.7.15. Let A be the generator of a bounded C0 -group U on X. Then A2 generates a bounded holomorphic C0 -semigroup T of angle π/2 on X. Moreover, for t > 0, T (t) = R
where kt (s) = (4πt)−1/2 e−|s|
2
/4t
kt (s)U (s) ds,
.
Proof. The fact that A2 generates a bounded holomorphic C0 -semigroup of angle π/2 is immediate from Corollary 3.7.14. Define T (0)x = x and √ T (t)x = kt (s)U (s)x ds = k1 (s)U (s t) ds R R∞ = kt (s)(U (s)x + U (−s)x) ds. 0
Then T is strongly continuous by the dominated convergence theorem. By Proposition 1.6.8, Tˆ (λ)
!√ " !√ " 1 1 √ R λ, A + √ R λ, −A 2 λ 2 λ = R(λ, A2 ) =
for λ > 0. Thus T is a C0 -semigroup generated by A2 . Let X be any of the spaces considered in Example 3.7.6 in the case n = 1, and let U be the shift group: (U (t)f )(x) = f (x − t) (see Example 3.3.10). Then the C0 -semigroup constructed in Corollary 3.7.15 is the Gaussian semigroup. The following proposition will be useful in Chapter 6 when we are dealing with the holomorphic semigroup generated by the Laplacian subject to Dirichlet boundary conditions on spaces of continuous functions. Note that A is not necessarily densely defined. Proposition 3.7.16. Let A be a dissipative operator on X and assume that A generates a holomorphic semigroup T on X. Then T (t) ≤ 1 for all t > 0. Proof. By the remark after Theorem 3.7.11, A is a Hille-Yosida operator. Hence, there exists λ0 > 0 with λ0 ∈ ρ(A). By the proof of the Lumer-Phillips theorem, we have (0, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and ||λR(λ, A)|| ≤ 1 for all λ > 0. By the proof of Corollary 3.3.6, we have T (t)x = limn→∞ (I − nt A)−n x for t > 0 and x ∈ X. Hence,
! "−n
≤1
T (t) ≤ lim sup I − nt A n→∞
for t > 0. Applying Corollary 3.7.12 to the operator A − ω for suitable ω, in view of Proposition 3.7.4, we obtain the following characterization results for holomorphic semigroups.
3.7. HOLOMORPHIC SEMIGROUPS
157
Corollary 3.7.17. Let A be an operator on X, and a ∈ R. Then A generates a holomorphic semigroup if and only if there exists r > 0 such that {λ ∈ C : Re λ > a, |λ| > r} ⊂ ρ(A) and sup λR(λ, A) < ∞.
Re λ>a |λ|>r
Modifying the proof of Corollary 3.7.12 to the situation of holomorphic semigroups which are not necessarily bounded, we obtain the following result. Corollary 3.7.18. Let A be the generator of a semigroup T on X. Then T is holomorphic if and only if there exists r > 0 such that {is : s ∈ R, |s| > r} ⊂ ρ(A) and sup sR(is, A) < ∞. |s|>r
We now characterize bounded holomorphic semigroups in terms of the behaviour of tAT (t) for positive t. Theorem 3.7.19. Let T be a bounded semigroup on X with generator A. Then T is a bounded holomorphic semigroup if and only if T (t)x ∈ D(A) for all t > 0, x ∈ X, and sup tAT (t) < ∞. (3.48) t>0
Proof. Suppose that T is a bounded holomorphic semigroup of angle θ. Then T is norm-differentiable on (0, ∞), so T (t)x ∈ D(A) for t > 0 and x ∈ X. By Cauchy’s integral formula for the derivative, 1 T (z) AT (t) = T (t) = dz. 2πi |z−t|=t sin θ/2 (z − t)2 Hence,
tAT (t) ≤ (sin θ/2)−1 sup T (z) < ∞. z∈Σθ/2
Conversely, let M := supt>0 { T (t) , tAT (t) }. By assumption, T (t)x ∈ D(A) for all t > 0 and x ∈ X. Since An T (t) = (AT (t/n))n ∈ L(X) for n ∈ N, we have
n
n
A T (t) (AT (t/n))n ( nt M )n eM
=
≤ ≤ for all n ∈ N.
n!
n! n! t n ∞ T (t) t If |z| < 2eM , then T˜(t + z) := n=0 z n A n! converges in norm and T˜ (t + z) ≤ t ˜ 1 + M . Then for s ∈ [0, 2eM ), T (t + s) = T (t + s). In fact, let x ∈ D(A) and t u(s) := T˜(t + s)x. Then u(s) ∈ D(A) and u (s) = Au(s) (s ∈ [0, 2eM )). Since u(0) = T (t)x, it follows from Proposition 3.1.11 that u(s) = T (s)T (t)x = T (t+s)x. By uniqueness of analytic extensions, we obtain a bounded, holomorphic extension 1 T˜ of T to the sector Σθ where θ = arctan 2eM .
158
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Remark 3.7.20. A slight modification of the above proof implies the following assertion: Let A be the generator of a bounded holomorphic semigroup T on X. Then T (t)x ∈ D(An ) for all x ∈ X, t > 0 and n ∈ N, and we have sup ||tn An T (t)|| < ∞ t>0
(n ∈ N).
Theorem 3.7.19 and Remark 3.7.20 have several important consequences for the regularity of the solution of the associated Cauchy problem. In contrast to the situation of C0 -semigroups where we obtain a classical solution of the Cauchy problem only if the initial condition x belongs to the domain D(A) of the generator A, we see that if A generates a holomorphic C0 -semigroup, then for all x ∈ X we obtain a solution which is differentiable for t > 0. More precisely, the following holds. Corollary 3.7.21. Let x ∈ X and assume that A generates a holomorphic C0 semigroup on X. Then there exists a unique function u ∈ C ∞ ((0, ∞), X) ∩ C(R+ , X) ∩ C((0, ∞), D(A)) satisfying u (t) = Au(t) (t > 0), u(0) = x. The phenomenon described in Corollary 3.7.21 is frequently called the smoothing effect of holomorphic C0 -semigroups. We now consider the inhomogeneous Cauchy problem u (t) = Au(t) + f (t) (t ∈ [0, τ ]), (ACPf ) u(0) = x, associated with the generator A of a holomorphic semigroup, and we establish that the variation of constants formula holds when x ∈ D(A). Proposition 3.7.22. Let A be the generator of a holomorphic semigroup T on X. Let f ∈ L1 ((0, τ ), X) and x ∈ D(A). Then (ACPf ) has a unique mild solution u which is given by
t
u(t) = T (t)x + 0
T (t − s)f (s) ds.
(t > 0)
Proof. By the remark following Theorem 3.7.11, A is a Hille-Yosida operator. Hence, the first assertion follows from the Da Prato-Sinestrari Theorem 3.5.2. The formula for u follows from Lemma t 3.2.9, since the once integrated semigroup generated by A is given by S(t)x = 0 T (s)x ds and the derivative of S ∗ f is easily seen to be T ∗ f .
3.7. HOLOMORPHIC SEMIGROUPS
159
The following perturbation result for generators of holomorphic semigroups is particularly useful when dealing with lower order perturbations of differential operators. Consider a closed operator A on X. Then a mapping B : D(A) → X is continuous (with respect to the graph norm on D(A)) if and only if
Bx ≤ c Ax + b x
(x ∈ D(A)),
for suitable c, b ≥ 0. One frequently says that B is a relatively bounded perturbation of A in that case. Theorem 3.7.23. Let A be the generator of a holomorphic semigroup on X. Let B : D(A) → X be an operator such that for every ε > 0 there exists a constant b ≥ 0 such that
Bx ≤ ε Ax + b x
(x ∈ D(A)). (3.49) Then A + B generates a holomorphic semigroup. Proof. Assume first that A generates a bounded holomorphic semigroup on X. Corollary 3.7.12 implies that there exists θ ∈ (0, π2 ] such that Σθ+π/2 ⊂ ρ(A) and
λR(λ, A) =: M < ∞.
sup λ∈Σθ+π/2
It follows from the assumption on B that given ε > 0, there exists b ≥ 0 such that for x ∈ X
BR(λ, A)x
≤ ε AR(λ, A)x + b R(λ, A)x
= ε λR(λ, A)x − x + b R(λ, A)x
bM ≤ ε(M + 1) x +
x
(λ ∈ Σθ+π/2 ). |λ|
Choosing ε := (2(M + 1))−1 , it follows that BR(λ, A) < 3/4 whenever |λ| > 4bM and hence that I − BR(λ, A) is invertible, with (I − BR(λ, A))−1 < 4. Since λ − (A + B) = (I − BR(λ, A))(λ − A) (λ ∈ Σθ+π/2 ), it follows that λ − (A + B) is invertible for λ ∈ Σθ+π/2 with |λ| > 4bM and that
R(λ, A + B) ≤
4M |λ|
(λ ∈ Σθ+π/2 , |λ| > 4bM ).
By Corollary 3.7.17, A + B generates a holomorphic semigroup. If A generates a holomorphic semigroup which is not bounded, choose ω ∈ R such that A−ω generates a bounded holomorphic semigroup on X (see Proposition 3.7.4). The first part of the proof implies that A + B − ω, and therefore also A + B, generates a holomorphic semigroup on X. Note that in the situation of Theorem 3.7.23, A and A + B have the same domain. Thus, the semigroup generated by A is a C0 -semigroup if and only if the one generated by A + B is a C0 -semigroup.
160
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Example 3.7.24 (First order perturbations of the Laplacian). Consider the Gaussian semigroup G with generator ΔX on any of the spaces X of Example 3.7.6. For j = 1, 2, . . . , n, let Uj be the C0 -group on X defined by (Uj (t)f )(x) = f (x1 , . . . , xj − t, . . . , xn ) with generator −Dj , and let Tj be the holomorphic C0 -semigroup with generator Dj2 (see Corollary 3.7.15). Then T1 , . . . , Tn commute and G(t) = T1 (t) · · · Tn (t). Since (Tj (t)f )(x)
=
(Dj Tj (t)f )(x)
=
2
(4πt)−1/2 e−(xj −s) /4t f (x1 , . . . , s, . . . , xn ) ds, R (xj − s) −(xj −s)2 /4t √ 3/2 e − f (x1 , . . . , s, . . . , xn ) ds. 4 πt R
Hence by Young’s inequality (see Proposition 1.3.2),
Dj Tj (t) L(X)
≤ = =
2 |s| √ 3/2 e−s /4t ds R 4 πt ∞ 2 2 √ ue−u du πt 0 1 √ . πt
Since Tj (t) L(X) = 1, it follows that Dj G(t) L(X) ≤
Dj R(λ, ΔX ) L(X)
=
0
≤ =
1 √ π c √ λ
∞
√1 , πt
and hence
e−λt Dj G(t) dt
∞ 0
L(X)
e−λt √ dt t
for all λ > 0, for some constant c. Now let B be a first-order differential operator of the form (Bf )(x) =
n
bj (x)(Dj f )(x) + b0 (x)f (x),
j=1
for some bj ∈ L∞ (Rn ) (j = 0, 1, . . . , n) (and bj continuous if X = C0 (Rn ); bj
3.7. HOLOMORPHIC SEMIGROUPS
161
uniformly continuous if X = BUC(Rn )). For f ∈ D(ΔX ),
Bf = BR(λ, ΔX )(λ − ΔX )f
n ≤
bj ∞ Dj R(λ, ΔX ) L(X) (λ − ΔX )f + b0 ∞ f
j=1
⎛ ⎞ n n √
bj ∞ c √ ≤
ΔX f + ⎝
bj ∞ c λ + b0 ∞ ⎠ f . λ j=1 j=1 Since λ may be chosen arbitrary large, this establishes (3.49), and Theorem 3.7.23 shows that ΔX + B generates a holomorphic C0 -semigroup on X. We shall extend Example 3.7.24 to more general differential operators in Section 7.2. We now prove a second perturbation theorem for holomorphic semigroups where the norm estimate (3.49) is replaced by compactness. Theorem 3.7.25 (Desch-Schappacher). Let A be the generator of a holomorphic C0 -semigroup T . Let B : D(A) → X be a compact linear operator where D(A) carries the graph norm. Then A + B generates a holomorphic C0 -semigroup S. Moreover, T (t) − S(t) is compact for each t > 0. Proof. By Corollary 3.7.17, there exist r > 0, M > 0 such that λ ∈ ρ(A) and
λR(λ, A) L(X) ≤ M whenever |λ| ≥ r, Re λ > 0. Since D(A) is dense in X, it follows that lim |λ|→∞ λR(λ, A)x = x for all x ∈ X (see Lemma 3.3.12). Since Re λ>0 λR(λ, A)x − x = AR(λ, A)x, it follows that lim |λ|→∞ R(λ, A)x = 0 in D(A) for all Re λ>0 x ∈ X. By Proposition B.15, the convergence is uniform on compact subsets of X. Since B : D(A) → X is compact, it follows that lim R(λ, A)B L(D(A)) = 0.
|λ|→∞ Re λ>0
Consequently, there exists r1 ≥ r such that R(λ, A)B L(D(A)) ≤ 12 whenever |λ| ≥ r1 , Re λ > 0. Denote by ID(A) the identity map on D(A). It follows that (ID(A) − R(λ, A)B)−1 exists in L(D(A)) and
(ID(A) − R(λ, A)B)−1 L(D(A)) ≤ 2
(|λ| ≥ r1 , Re λ > 0).
Thus (λ − (A + B)) = (λ − A)(I − R(λ, A)B) is invertible and R(λ, A + B) = (ID(A) − R(λ, A)B)−1 R(λ, A)
(Re λ > 0, |λ| ≥ r1 ).
Moreover, for |λ| ≥ r1 , Re λ > 0,
R(λ, A + B) L(X,D(A))
≤ ≤
2 R(λ, A) L(X,D(A)) M M1 := 2 +1+M , r1
162
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
since
R(λ, A)x D(A)
= R(λ, A)x X + AR(λ, A)x X M ≤
x X + λR(λ, A)x − x X |λ| M ≤
x X + (M + 1) x X . r1
Hence for x ∈ X, |λ| ≥ r1 , Re λ > 0,
λR(λ, A + B)x X
= (A + B)R(λ, A + B)x − x X ≤ R(λ, A + B)x D(A) + B L(D(A),X) R(λ, A + B)x D(A) + x X ! " ≤ M1 (1 + B L(D(A),X) ) + 1 x X .
Now it follows from Corollary 3.7.17 that A + B generates a holomorphic C0 semigroup. It remains to show the last assertion. Denote by K(X) the closed subspace of L(X) consisting of all compact operators and by q : L(X) → L(X)/K(X) the quotient mapping. For λ > λ0 := max{ω(T ), ω(S)}, we have
∞ 0
e−λt (S(t) − T (t)) dt = R(λ, A + B) − R(λ, A) = R(λ, A + B)[(λ − A) − (λ − A − B)]R(λ, A) = R(λ, A + B)BR(λ, A) ∈ K(X).
Since S and T are holomorphic, the function U := S − T is norm-continuous on (0, ∞). Since (q ◦ U )(λ) = q(U (λ)) = 0 for all λ > λ0 , it follows from the uniqueness theorem that q ◦ U ≡ 0; i.e., U (t) ∈ K(X) for all t > 0. We should point out that in the situation of Theorem 3.7.25 the norm estimate (3.49) is not true in general; see the Notes for further information.
3.8
Fractional Powers
A particularly interesting example of a holomorphic semigroup is the family of fractional powers of a sectorial operator. Consider an operator B on X for which (−∞, 0] ⊂ ρ(B) and supλ≤0 (1 − λ) R(λ, B) < ∞. It follows from Corollary B.3 that B is sectorial in the sense that there exist constants M > 0, ϕ ∈ (0, π) such that M σ(B) ⊂ Σϕ and R(λ, B) ≤ , λ ∈ C\Σϕ . (3.50) 1 + |λ|
3.8. FRACTIONAL POWERS
163
Let Γ be the downward path consisting of {se±iϕ : s ≥ r} and {reiθ : −ϕ ≤ θ ≤ ϕ}, where r > 0 is chosen so small that σ(B) is to the right of Γ. Then the fractional powers (B −z )Re z>0 of B are defined by 1 B −z := λ−z R(λ, B) dλ, (Re z > 0). (3.51) 2πi Γ Here, λ−z = exp(−z(log |λ|+iθ)) if λ = |λ|eiθ , −π < θ < π. Note that the integral is absolutely convergent, uniformly for z in compact subsets of C+ , and therefore z → B −z is holomorphic from C+ to L(X). By Cauchy’s theorem, the definition of B −z is independent of the choices of ϕ and r. Moreover, when z = n ∈ N, Γ may be replaced by a closed contour around 0 and then the residue theorem shows that n−1 1 d B −z = − R(λ, B) = (−1)n R(0, B)n = B −n (n − 1)! dλ λ=0
in the usual sense. Now, assume for the time being that 0 < Re z < 1. Then 1 B −z = lim λ−z R(λ, B) dλ ϕ↑π 2πi Γ r↓0 e−iπz ∞ −z eiπz ∞ −z −1 = − s (s + B) ds + s (s + B)−1 ds 2πi 0 2πi 0 sin πz ∞ −z = s (s + B)−1 ds. (3.52) π 0 In the particular case when X = C and B = 1, (3.52) gives ∞ π s−z (s + 1)−1 ds = (0 < Re z < 1). sin πz 0
(3.53)
Hence,
B −z ≤
| sin πz| π
0
∞
s− Re z
M | sin πz| ds = M 1+s sin(π Re z)
(0 < Re z < 1).
(3.54)
Theorem 3.8.1. Let B be an operator on X such that (−∞, 0] ⊂ ρ(B) and supλ≤0 (1 − λ) R(λ, B) < ∞. Then the family (B −z )Re z>0 defines a holomorphic semigroup on X of angle π/2. If B is densely defined, then (B −z )Re z>0 is a holomorphic C0 -semigroup. Proof. We have observed above that z → B −z is holomorphic for Re z > 0, and it follows from (3.54) that B −z is uniformly bounded in Σθ ∩ {z ∈ C : |z| < 1} for θ ∈ (0, π/2). To verify the semigroup property, let Γ and Γ be two contours as in
164
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
the definition of B −z , with Γ to the left of Γ . For Re z1 > 0 and Re z2 > 0, the resolvent identity and Fubini’s theorem give 1 B −z1 B −z2 = λ−z1 μ−z2 R(λ, B)R(μ, B) dμ dλ (2πi)2 Γ Γ 1 R(λ, B) − R(μ, B) −z1 −z2 = λ μ dμ dλ (2πi)2 Γ Γ μ−λ 1 1 μ−z2 = λ−z1 dμ R(λ, B) dλ 2πi Γ 2πi Γ μ − λ 1 1 λ−z1 −z2 + μ dλ R(μ, B) dμ 2πi Γ 2πi Γ λ − μ 1 = λ−z1 λ−z2 R(λ, B) dλ 2πi Γ = B −(z1 +z2 ) . Here, we have used Cauchy’s integral formula (after changing to a closed contour around 0) to see that 1 μ−z2 1 λ−z1 dμ = λ−z2 and dλ = 0. 2πi Γ μ − λ 2πi Γ λ − μ This proves the first assertion. −z z→0 B Now suppose that B is densely defined. We have to show that lim z∈Σ x= θ
x, for all θ ∈ (0, π/2) and all x ∈ X. Since B −z is uniformly bounded on Σθ ∩ {z ∈ C : |z| < 1}, we may assume that x ∈ D(B) (see Proposition B.15). For 0 < Re z < 1, it follows from (3.52) and (3.53) that " sin πz ∞ −z ! B −z x − x = s (s + B)−1 x − (s + 1)−1 x ds π 0 sin πz ∞ s−z = (s + B)−1 (I − B)x ds. π s + 1 0 Hence,
B −z x − x ≤ M
| sin πz| π
0
∞
s− Re z ds (I − B)x . (s + 1)2
−z z→0 B It follows that lim z∈Σ x − x = 0 for all θ ∈ (0, π/2). θ
Now suppose that B is an operator on X such that (−∞, 0) ⊂ ρ(B) and M := supλ<0 λR(λ, B) < ∞. We shall show that B has a special type of square root, which has interesting properties for semigroup generators. For ε > 0, (−∞, 0] ⊂ ρ(ε + B) and sup(1 − λ) R(λ, ε + B) = sup(1 − λ) R(λ − ε, B) ≤ M/ε. λ≤0
λ≤0
3.8. FRACTIONAL POWERS
165
Hence we can define (ε + B)−1/2 ∈ L(X) as above, and then ((ε + B)−1/2 )2 = (ε + B)−1 . In particular, (ε + B)−1/2 is injective. Let (ε + B)1/2 be the algebraic inverse of (ε + B)−1/2 , so D((ε + B)1/2 ) (ε + B)1/2 ((ε + B)−1/2 y)
Ran((ε + B)−1/2 ),
=
= y
(y ∈ X).
Then (ε+B)1/2 is a closed operator on X, ((ε+B)1/2 )2 = ε+B, and for x ∈ D(B), x = (ε + B)−1/2 ((ε + B)−1/2 (ε + B)x), so (ε + B)1/2 x = =
(ε + B)−1/2 (ε + B)x 1 ∞ −1/2 s (s + ε + B)−1 (ε + B)x ds. π 0
(3.55)
Proposition 3.8.2. Let B be a densely defined operator on X such that (−∞, 0) ⊂ ρ(B) and supλ<0 λR(λ, B) < ∞. Then there is a unique closed operator B 1/2 such that a) (B 1/2 )2 = B, and b) For x ∈ D(B), B 1/2 x = lim(ε + B)1/2 x = ε↓0
1 π
∞
s−1/2 (s + B)−1 Bx ds.
0
Moreover, D(B) is a core for B 1/2 , and D(B 1/2 ) = D((ε + B)1/2 ) for all ε > 0. Proof. Since
s−1/2 (s + ε + B)−1 (ε + B)x ≤ M s−3/2 ( x + Bx )
(0 < ε < 1)
and
s−1/2 (s + ε + B)−1 (ε + B)x = s−1/2 (x − s(s + ε + B)−1 x)
≤
(M + 1) x s−1/2 ,
one can apply the dominated convergence theorem and take limits in (3.55) as ε ↓ 0. Thus, we let 1 ∞ −1/2 B 1/2 x := lim(ε + B)1/2 x = s (s + B)−1 Bx ds λ↓0 π 0
166
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
for x ∈ D(B). Moreover, for ε > 0, B 1/2 x − (ε + B)1/2 x " 1 ∞ −1/2 ! = s (s + B)−1 Bx − (s + ε + B)−1 (ε + B)x ds π 0 ε ∞ 1/2 = − s (s + ε + B)−1 (s + B)−1 x ds. π 0 Let Sε := −
ε π
∞
s1/2 (s + ε + B)−1 (s + B)−1 ds.
0
Then Sε ∈ L(X), ε
Sε ≤ π
∞
0
M2 ds = M 2 ε1/2 , s1/2 (s + ε)
by (3.53), and B 1/2 x − (ε + B)1/2 x = Sε x
(x ∈ D(B), ε > 0).
We define B 1/2 := (ε + B)1/2 + Sε
with
D(B 1/2 ) = D((ε + B)1/2 ).
Since (ε + B)1/2 is closed and Sε is bounded, B 1/2 is closed. Moreover, b) holds. Since (ε + B)1/2 is densely defined and invertible, D(B) = D(((ε + B)1/2 )2 ) is a core for (ε + B)1/2 (see Appendix B) and hence for B 1/2 . It follows that the definition of B 1/2 is independent of ε. Let x ∈ D(B). Then (ε + B)1/2 x → B 1/2 x and B 1/2 (ε + B)1/2 x = (ε + B)x + Sε (ε + B)1/2 x → Bx as ε ↓ 0. Since B 1/2 is closed, it follows that B 1/2 x ∈ D(B 1/2 ) and (B 1/2 )2 x = Bx. Let y ∈ D((B 1/2 )2 ). By Lemma 3.3.12, ε(ε + B)−1 y → y and B(ε(ε + −1 B) y) = ε(ε + B)−1 (B 1/2 )2 y → (B 1/2 )2 y as ε → ∞. Since B is closed, y ∈ D(B). Thus B = (B 1/2 )2 . be any closed operator such that Bx = B 1/2 x for all x ∈ D(B) Finally, let B 2 2 +i and B = B. Then (B + i)(B − i) = B + I = B + I, which is invertible, so B 2 is invertible. Since B is densely defined and ρ(B) is non-empty, D(B ) = D(B) (see Appendix B). Hence, B is the closure of B 1/2 |D(B) , and this is a core for B proves uniqueness. Now suppose that A is the generator of a bounded C0 -semigroup T on X. If 0 ∈ ρ(A), then the theory above can be applied to B := −A, so (−A)−z is defined
3.8. FRACTIONAL POWERS
167
∞ for Re z > 0. Substituting (s − A)−1 = 0 e−st T (t) dt into (3.52), it is not difficult to see that ∞ 1 (−A)−z = tz−1 T (t) dt (3.56) Γ(z) 0 for 0 < Re z < 1, and hence for Re z > 0 by uniqueness of holomorphic extensions. We shall not use this. Proposition 3.8.2 shows that (−A)1/2 is defined whenever A generates a bounded C0 -semigroup. Theorem 3.8.3. Let A be the generator of a bounded C0 -semigroup T on X, and define ⎧ 2 ∞ ⎪ te−t /4s ⎨ √ T (s)x ds (t > 0), S(t)x = 2 πs3/2 0 ⎪ ⎩x (t = 0). Then S is a bounded holomorphic C0 -semigroup of angle π/4, and the generator of S is −(−A)1/2 . Furthermore, for x ∈ D(A), u(t) := S(t)x is the unique bounded classical solution of the second order Cauchy problem u (t) = −Au(t) (t ≥ 0), (3.57) u(0) = x. Moreover, if T is a bounded holomorphic C0 -semigroup of angle θ ∈ (0, π/2], then S is a bounded holomorphic C0 -semigroup of angle ( θ2 + π4 ). 2
ze−z /4s Proof. For z ∈ Σπ/4 , let ψz (s) = √ 3/2 (s > 0). Then ψz ∈ L1 (R+ ), ψz 1 = 2 πs ∞ ∞ |z| z∈Σθ , ψ (s) ds = 1, and lim |ψz (s)| ds = 0, for δ > 0 and 0 ≤ θ < z Re(z 2 ) 0 δ z→0 π/4. √ ∞ t (λ) = e−t λ (λ > 0) For t ∈ R+ , S(t)x = 0 ψt (s)T (s)x ds (x ∈ X) and ψ (Lemma 1.6.7). Hence (ψt ∗ ψt2 )(λ) = ψ t1 +t2 (λ). It follows from the uniqueness 1 theorem that ψt1 ∗ ψt2 = ψt1 +t2 (t1 , t2 ≥ 0). Now, ∞ ∞ S(t1 )S(t2 )x = ψt1 (s)ψt2 (r)T (s + r)x dr ds 0 0 ∞ t = ψt1 (s)ψt2 (t − s) ds T (t)x dt 0
0
= S(t1 + t2 )x. ∞ For z ∈ Σπ/4 , let S(z)x = 0 ψz (s)T (s)x ds. Then S(·) is holomorphic, S(z) ≤ |z| (Re z)2 sups≥0 T (s) and
∞ e−z 2 /4s
√ 3/2 (T (s)z − z) ds
S(z)x − x =
0 2 πs
→ 0
(z ∈ Σθ , z → 0).
168
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Thus S is a bounded holomorphic C0 -semigroup of angle π/4. Let B be the generator of S and let x ∈ D(A). For t > 0, we can differentiate through the integral sign and obtain BS(t)x =
d (S(t)x) dt 0
∞
=
0 ∞
= 0
Hence
BS(t)x = 0
∞
2
e−t /4s √ 2 πs3/2
2
e−t /4s √ 2 πs3/2 2
e−t /4s √ 2 πs3/2
1−
t2 2s
t2 1− 2s
T (s)x ds, x ds.
t2 1− (T (s)x − x) ds. 2s
Since T (s)x − x ≤ s Ax supt≥0 T (t) , the dominated convergence theorem gives, on letting t ↓ 0, that x ∈ D(B) and ∞ T (s)x − x √ Bx = ds 2 πs3/2 0 ∞ ∞ 1 = λ1/2 e−sλ dλ (T (s)x − x) ds π 0 0 1 ∞ 1/2 = λ (R(λ, A)x − λ−1 x) dλ π 0 1 ∞ −1/2 = λ R(λ, A)Ax dλ π 0 = −(−A)1/2 x. Since D(A) is a core for −(−A)1/2 , it follows that B extends −(−A)1/2 . However, B + i is invertible (since B generates a bounded holomorphic semigroup) and i − (−A)1/2 is invertible (since I − A = ((−A)1/2 − i)((−A)1/2 + i)), so B = −(−A)1/2 . Let x ∈ D(A) = D(((−A)1/2 )2 ). Then it is immediate that u(t) := S(t)x is a bounded classical solution of (3.57). Let u1 be any bounded solution of (3.57). Take μ > 0, and let v(t) := R(μ, A)(u(t) − u1 (t))
(t ≥ 0).
Then v(0) = 0, v is bounded, and v (t) = −Av(t) = (I − μR(μ, A))(u(t) − u1 (t)), which is bounded. Since v (t) = v(t + 1) − v(t) −
1 2
t
t+1
(t + 1 − s)v (s) ds,
3.8. FRACTIONAL POWERS it follows that v is bounded. Let w(t) :=
v (−t) + (−A)1/2 v(−t) S(t)v (0)
169
(t ≤ 0), (t > 0).
Since (−A)1/2 R(μ, A) is bounded (by the closed graph theorem, or by direct calculation), w is bounded. For t ≤ 0, w (t)
= −v (−t) − (−A)1/2 v (−t) = Av(t) − (−A)1/2 v (−t) = −(−A)1/2 w(t).
Also, w (t) = −(−A)1/2 w(t) for all t ≥ 0, since −(−A)1/2 generates S. It follows from Proposition 3.1.11 that w(t + s) = S(t)w(s)
(t ≥ 0, s ∈ R).
Now we extend w to C by (λ ∈ Σπ/4 , s ∈ R).
w(λ + s) := S(λ)w(s)
This is well defined since S(λ1 + λ2 ) = S(λ1 )S(λ2 ). Moreover, w is holomorphic, and bounded since λ may be chosen in Σπ/8 , where S is bounded. By Liouville’s theorem, w is constant, so S(t)v (0) = v (0) for all t ≥ 0. Now, v (t)
= −(−A)1/2 v(t) + w(−t)
v(0)
= −(−A)1/2 v(t) + v (0) = 0.
(t ≥ 0),
By Proposition 3.1.16, v(t) = 0
t
S(t − s)v (0) ds = tv (0).
But v is bounded, so v (0) = 0 and hence v(t) = 0. Since R(μ, A) is injective, it follows that u1 (t) = u(t). Now suppose that T is a bounded holomorphic C0 -semigroup of angle θ ∈ (0, π/2]. Let α ∈ (−θ, θ). An application of Cauchy’s theorem shows that ∞ 2 iα te−t /4re √ 3/2 iα/2 T (reiα ) dr S(t) = (t > 0). 2 πr e 0 Now let
∞
2
iα
ze−z /4re √ S(z) = T (reiα ) dr 2 πr3/2 eiα/2 0 for α2 − π4 < arg z < α2 + π4 . This defines a holomorphic extension of S to this sector, and it is bounded in each proper subsector. Varying α provides a holomorphic extension of S to Σ( θ + π ) which is bounded on Σθ for θ < ( θ2 + π4 ). 2
4
170
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Example 3.8.4. Let (Ω, μ) be a measure space, X := L2 (Ω, μ), m : Ω → R+ be measurable, and A be defined by D(A) := {f ∈ X : mf ∈ X} Af := mf. Then −A generates the C0 -semigroup T (t)f = e−tm f . The operator A1/2 of Proposition 3.8.2 is given by D(A1/2 ) = {f ∈ X : m1/2 f ∈ X} and A1/2 f = m1/2 f. The semigroup S generated by −A1/2 , as in Theorem 3.8.3, is given by S(t)f = 1/2 e−tm f . Example 3.8.5. Let X be any of the spaces of Example 3.7.6, and let T be the 2 Gaussian semigroup on X. Then T (s)f = ks ∗f , where ks (x) = (4πs)−n/2 e−|x| /4s . Hence, the holomorphic semigroup S of Theorem 3.8.3 is given by S(t)f = ht ∗ f , where ∞ −t2 /4s −|x|2 /4s te e √ 3/2 ht (x) = ds. 2 πs (4πs)n/2 0 Putting r = (t2 + |x|2 )/4s gives ht (x) =
Γ( n+1 2 )t . (n+1)/2 2 π (t + |x|2 )(n+1)/2
Thus, S is the Poisson semigroup considered in Example 3.7.9. Note that although the generator ΔX of T is a second order differential operator, the generator AX = −(−ΔX )1/2 of S is not a first order differential operator. It should be mentioned that (3.57) is an abstract elliptic equation. For example, if T is the Gaussian semigroup on C0 (Rn ) (Example 3.8.5), then letting u(t, x) := (S(t)f )(x) for f ∈ C0 (Rn ), x ∈ Rn and t > 0, u is a solution of ∂ 2u ∂2u + =0 ∂t2 ∂x2j j=1 n
utt + Δu :=
on (0, ∞) × Rn ;
i.e., u is a solution of the Laplace equation. The wave equation utt = Δu will be treated in Sections 3.14–3.16 and Chapter 7.
3.9. BOUNDARY VALUES OF HOLOMORPHIC SEMIGROUPS
3.9
171
Boundary Values of Holomorphic Semigroups
Let T be a holomorphic C0 -semigroup on X of angle π2 . In this section we are interested in the behaviour of T (is + t) as t tends to 0 and we ask under what circumstances the “boundary value” T (is) of T (which will be defined precisely below) exists and defines a C0 -group. We also address the converse problem: Which C0 -groups are obtained as boundary values of holomorphic C0 -semigroups? As in Section 3.7, we let Σϕ := {z ∈ C \ {0} : |argz| < ϕ} be the sector in the complex plane of angle ϕ ∈ (0, π). Furthermore, we set Σ+ ϕ := Σϕ ∩{z ∈ C : Im z ≥ 0}, Σ− := Σ ∩ {z ∈ C : Im z ≤ 0} and define D by D := {z ∈ Σπ/2 : |z| ≤ 1}. ϕ ϕ The following result gives an answer to our first question above. Proposition 3.9.1. Let A be the generator of a holomorphic C0 -semigroup T on X of angle ϕ ∈ (0, π/2]. Then the following are equivalent: (i) eiϕ A generates a C0 -semigroup T (eiϕ ·) on X. (ii) supz∈Σ+ ||T (z)|| < ∞. ϕ ∩D In this case, the C0 -semigroup T (eiϕ ·) is given by T (eiϕ s)x = lim T (t + eiϕ s)x t↓0
(x ∈ X, s ≥ 0).
(3.58)
The C0 -semigroup S(s) := T (eiϕ s) defined by (3.58) is called the boundary semigroup of T . The following lemma will be useful in the proof of Proposition 3.9.1. Lemma 3.9.2. Let A be the generator of a holomorphic C0 -semigroup T on X of angle ϕ ∈ (0, π/2]. Assume that eiϕ A generates a C0 -semigroup S on X. Then T (t + eiϕ s) = T (t)S(s)
for all
s, t ≥ 0.
Proof. Obviously, the resolvents of A and eiϕ A commute. By Proposition 3.1.5, S(s)T (t) = T (t)S(s) for all s, t ≥ 0. Fix a, b ≥ 0 and denote by B the generator of the C0 -semigroup V on X defined by V (t) := S(bt)T (at). For x ∈ D(A) we have d d iϕ iϕ dt V (t)x = (a + be )AV (t)x. Hence dt V (t)x|t=0 = (a + be )Ax and therefore B extends (a + beiϕ )A. It follows that V (t) = T ((a + beiϕ )t) for all t ≥ 0 (see Proposition 3.7.2 c)). In particular, we have V (1) = T (a + beiϕ ) = S(b)T (a) = T (a)S(b) for all a, b ≥ 0. Proof of Proposition 3.9.1. Assume that (i) holds. Let z ∈ Σ+ ϕ ∩ D. There exist a, b ∈ [0, 1] such that z = a + beiϕ . It follows from Lemma 3.9.2 that T (z) = T (a + beiϕ ) = T (a)T (beiϕ ). Hence, T (z) ≤ T (a) T (beiϕ ) ≤ M for a suitable M and all z ∈ Σ+ ϕ ∩ D. This implies (ii). In order to prove the converse implication, fix R > 0. Then there exists MR > 0 such that T (z) ≤ MR whenever z ∈ Σ+ ϕ and |z| ≤ R. For x ∈ X,
172
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
0 < t < t ≤ 1 and s ≥ 0 satisfying |t + eiϕ s| ≤ R, we have
! "
T (t + eiϕ s)x − T (t + eiϕ s)x ≤ T (t + eiϕ s) x − T (t − t)x ≤ MR x − T (t − t)x . It thus follows that T (eiϕ s)x := limt↓0 T (t + eiϕ s)x exists uniformly in s ∈ [0, R]. Consequently, the mapping R+ → L(X), s → T (eiϕ s) is strongly continuous. It is easy to see that T (eiϕ ·) is a C0 -semigroup. Denote by B its generator. Let x ∈ D(A) and τ > 0. Then τ τ T (eiϕ s)eiϕ Ax ds = lim eiϕ AT (t + eiϕ s)x ds t↓0 0 0 τ " d ! = lim T (t + eiϕ s)x ds t↓0 0 ds = lim(T (t + eiϕ τ )x − T (t)x) t↓0
= T (eiϕ τ )x − x. It follows from Proposition 3.1.9 f) that x ∈ D(B) and Bx = eiϕ Ax. We have shown that B is an extension of eiϕ A. Since ρ(B) ∩ ρ(eiϕ A) = ∅, it follows that both operators are equal. Remark 3.9.3. Note that the above result may be easily modified to the case where eiϕ A and e−iϕ A generate C0 -semigroups. Indeed, assuming that sup z∈Σϕ ∩D
||T (z)|| < ∞,
(3.59)
it follows that e±iϕ A generate C0 -semigroups on X which are given by T (e±iϕ s)x := limt↓0 T (t + e±iϕ s)x. In particular, if (3.59) is satisfied for ϕ = π2 , then iA and −iA generate C0 -semigroups T (±is) on X and we call S(s) := T (is) (s ∈ R), the boundary group of T . For 1 ≤ p ≤ ∞, let Δp be the Laplacian on Lp (Rn ) with maximal domain: Δp f D(Δp )
:=
Δf,
:= {f ∈ Lp (Rn ) : Δf ∈ Lp (Rn )},
(3.60)
where Δf is defined in the distributional sense. We proved in Example 3.7.6 that for 1 ≤ p < ∞ the operator Δp is the generator of the Gaussian semigroup Tp on Lp (Rn ). Moreover, Δ∗p = Δp , where 1/p + 1/p = 1. Although Δ∞ does not generate a C0 -semigroup on L∞ (Rn ), it does generate a holomorphic semigroup T∞ given by T∞ (z)f := kz ∗ f (f ∈ L∞ (Rn )), (see Example 3.7.8).
3.9. BOUNDARY VALUES OF HOLOMORPHIC SEMIGROUPS
173
We wish to determine whether iΔp generates a C0 -semigroup. By duality, we may restrict ourselves in the following to the case when 1 ≤ p ≤ 2. Since FT2 (z)f = 2 e−z|·| F f and (2π)−n/2 F is unitary on L2 (Rn ), we have ||T2 (z)||L(L2 (Rn )) = 1 for all z ∈ C with Re z > 0. Hence, by Proposition 3.9.1 the operator iΔ2 generates a C0 -semigroup on L2 (Rn ). By Remark 3.7.10,
T1 (z) L(L1 (Rn )) =
|z| Re z
n/2 (Re z > 0).
Hence, by the Riesz-Thorin interpolation theorem (see [H¨ or83, Theorem 7.1.12])
Tp (z) L(Lp (Rn )) ≤
|z| Re z
n(1/p−1/2)
(1 ≤ p ≤ 2, Re z > 0).
(3.61)
In fact, we will now show that a multiple of the above upper bound will also serve as a lower bound for ||Tp (z)||L(Lp (Rn )) . Then we can apply Proposition 3.9.1 and obtain the following result. Theorem 3.9.4 (H¨ormander). Let 1 ≤ p < ∞. Then the operator iΔp generates a C0 -semigroup on Lp (Rn ) if and only if p = 2. Proof. By Proposition 3.9.1, it suffices to show that a multiple of the above upper bound (3.61) will also serve as a lower bound for ||Tp (z)||L(Lp (Rn )) . More precisely, we prove in the following that if 1 ≤ p < ∞, then
Tp (z) L(Lp (Rn )) ≥ 2−n/2p
|z| Re z
n|1/p−1/2| (Re z > 0).
(3.62)
We already observed that it suffices to consider the case where 1 < p ≤ 2. Fix z ∈ C+ and consider the function f : Rn → C defined by f (x) := exp Taking p such that
1 p
+
1 p
−|x|2 z
.
= 1 we verify that
f p =
π p
n/2p
|z|2 Re z
n/2p .
(3.63)
Let x, y ∈ Rn and recall that z ∈ C+ . Then −
|x − y|2 |x|2 = −2 Re − z z
1 x − z
y 2 y 1 |y|2 1 y Im − Re . + 2i x − 2 2 z 2 z
174
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Moreover, Tp (z/4)f (y) 1 |x − y|2 |x|2 = exp − − dx z z (πz)n/2 Rn 1 1 1 2 = exp −2|x| Re + 2ixy Im dx z z (πz)n/2 Rn |y|2 1 × exp − Re 2 z n/2 1 1 |x|2 Im(z −1 ) = exp − exp ixy dx 2 (πz)n/2 4 Re(z −1 ) (Re(z −1 ))1/2 Rn |y|2 1 × exp − Re 2 z n/2 1 1 = (2π)n/2 (πz)n/2 4 Re(z −1 ) |y|2 (Im(z −1 ))2 |y|2 1 × exp − exp − Re , 2 Re(z −1 ) 2 z where in the last step we used the fact that the function x → exp(−|x|2 /2) is an eigenvector of the Fourier transform. Hence, n/2 |z| |y|2 |Tp (z/4)f (y)| = exp − (y ∈ Rn ), 2 Re z 2 Re z and since Rn exp(−|x|2 /2) dx = (2π)n/2 , we obtain
Tp (z/4)f p =
|z| 2 Re z
n/2
2π p
n/2p
(Re z)n/2p .
Combining this equality with (3.63) we see that
Tp (z/4) L(Lq (Rn )) ≥
Tp (z/4)f p = 2−n/2p
f p
|z| Re z
n(1/p−1/2) .
Finally, since Tp (z) L(Lp (Rn )) = Tp (z) L(Lp (Rn )) , it follows that
Tp (z) L(Lp (Rn )) ≥ 2−n/2p
|z| Re z
n|1/p−1/2| (Re z > 0).
Interesting examples of boundary values of holomorphic C0 -semigroups occur also in connection with fractional powers of operators and the so-called RiemannLiouville semigroup. Indeed, consider in Lp (0, 1) the operator Au := u
with domain
D(A) := {u ∈ W 1,p (0, 1) : u(0) = 0}.
(3.64)
3.9. BOUNDARY VALUES OF HOLOMORPHIC SEMIGROUPS
175
We showed in Example 3.4.8 that −A generates a C0 -semigroup T on Lp (0, 1) (1 ≤ p < ∞), which may be represented by f (x − t) (t ≤ x), T (t)f (x) = (3.65) 0 (t > x). Since T (t) = 0 for t ≥ 1, we see that abs(T ) = −∞. Now inserting (3.65) in (3.56) we see that x 1 (x − y)z−1 f (y) dy (x ∈ (0, 1), Re z > 0, f ∈ Lp (0, 1)). A−z f (x) = Γ(z) 0 By Theorem 3.8.1, (A−z )Re z>0 is a holomorphic C0 -semigroup of angle π/2. This C0 -semigroup is called the Riemann-Liouville semigroup. By Proposition 3.9.1 and Remark 3.9.3, the question whether or not the Riemann-Liouville semigroup possesses a boundary group is equivalent to sup
z∈Σπ/2 ∩D
||A−z || < ∞.
(3.66)
When (3.66) holds true, we denote the boundary group by (S(s)) := (Ais )s∈R . In order to show the estimate (3.66) we make use of the transference principle due to Coifman and Weiss [CW77]. We will use it in the following form [Ama95, Chapter III, Example 4.7.3 c)]. For a measure space (Ω, μ) and 1 ≤ p ≤ ∞, we denote by Lp (Ω, μ) the usual Banach space of equivalence classes of p-integrable functions (bounded functions when p = ∞). Theorem 3.9.5 (Coifman-Weiss). Let (Ω, μ) be a σ-finite measure space and let 1 < p < ∞. Assume that 0 ∈ ρ(A) and that −A generates a C0 -semigroup of positive contractions on Lp (Ω, μ). For t > 0 and s ∈ R let A−t+is be defined as in (3.51). Then Ais f := limt↓0 A−t+is f ∈ Lp (Ω, μ) for f ∈ Lp (Ω, μ) and there exists a constant M , depending only on p, such that
Ais L(Lp (Ω,μ)) ≤ M (1 + s2 )eπ|s|/2
(s ∈ R).
Thus, for 1 < p < ∞, the Riemann-Liouville semigroup admits a boundary group. For p = 1 the situation is different. Indeed, 1 1 −z ||A ||L(L1 (0,1)) = sup |(x − y)z−1 | dx y∈[0,1] |Γ(z)| y 1 1 1 1 = sup (x − y)Re z−1 dx = , |Γ(z)| y∈[0,1] y |Γ(z)| Re z which by Proposition 3.9.1 implies that we do not have a boundary value for p = 1. In summary, we have proved the following result for the Riemann-Liouville semigroup on Lp (0, 1).
176
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Theorem 3.9.6. Let 1 ≤ p < ∞ and denote by G the generator of the RiemannLiouville semigroup on Lp (0, 1). Then iG is the generator of a C0 -group on Lp (0, 1) provided 1 < p < ∞. If p = 1, then iG does not generate a C0 -semigroup on L1 (0, 1). We now consider the converse to the situation described in Proposition 3.9.1; namely, we ask for conditions on the boundary group itself which imply that A generates a holomorphic C0 -semigroup. We begin with the following result. Theorem 3.9.7. Let A be an operator on X and let ϕ ∈ (0, π/2). Assume that e±iϕ A generate bounded C0 -semigroups on X. Then A generates a bounded holomorphic C0 -semigroup of angle ϕ. Our proof of Theorem 3.9.7 is based on the following version of the Phragm´enLindel¨ of theorem. Theorem 3.9.8 (Phragm´en-Lindel¨of ). Let ϕ ∈ (0, π/2] and let h : Σϕ → X be π continuous on Σϕ and holomorphic in Σϕ . Set α := 2ϕ . Assume that for all ε > 0 there exists a constant Cε > 0 such that α
h(z) ≤ Cε eε|z|
(z ∈ Σϕ ).
If h(re±iϕ ) ≤ M for all r > 0, then ||h(z)|| ≤ M for all z ∈ Σϕ . For a proof of Theorem 3.9.8 we refer to [Con73, Cor.6.4.4]. Proof of Theorem 3.9.7. Denote by T+ , T− the C0 -semigroups generated by A+ := eiϕ A and A− := e−iϕ A, respectively. Let M ≥ 0 such that ||T± (t)|| ≤ M for all t ≥ 0. Then
∞
M −λt
R(λ, A± ) = e T± (t) dt (Re λ > 0).
≤ Re λ 0 For λ ∈ Σ+ ϕ this implies that
R(λ, A) = R(λ, eiϕ A− ) = R(λe−iϕ , A− ) ≤ Similarly, R(λ, A) ≤
M |λ| cos ϕ
M M ≤ . −iϕ Re(λe ) |λ| cos ϕ
if λ ∈ Σ− ϕ . Thus we have
(I − zA)−1 = z −1 R(z −1 , A) ≤
M cos ϕ
(z ∈ Σϕ ).
For n ∈ N and z ∈ Σϕ set Tn (z) := (I − nz A)−n . Then Tn (z) ≤ M for z = re±iϕ and n M
Tn (z) ≤ for z = re±iα , r ≥ 0, |α| < ϕ. cos ϕ
3.9. BOUNDARY VALUES OF HOLOMORPHIC SEMIGROUPS
177
It follows from the Phragm´en-Lindel¨ of Principle 3.9.8 that Tn (z) ≤ M for all z ∈ Σϕ and all n ∈ N. The Hille-Yosida Theorem 3.3.4 implies now that A generates a C0 -semigroup T . By Corollary 3.3.6, we have limn→∞ Tn (t)x = T (t)x for t ≥ 0 and x ∈ X. It thus follows from Vitali’s theorem (see Theorem A.5 and Proposition A.3) that T has a holomorphic extension T˜ to Σϕ satisfying T˜ (z) ≤ M for all z ∈ Σϕ . Consider now the case where e±iϕ A generate C0 -semigroups T±ϕ which are not necessarily bounded. In this case, there exist constants M, ω ≥ 0 such that
T±ϕ (t) ≤ M eωt for t ≥ 0. It follows that e±iϕ (A − μ) generate bounded C0 semigroups for μ := cosω ϕ . Theorem 3.9.7 implies now that A − μ generates a bounded holomorphic C0 -semigroup of angle ϕ. We have thus proved the following result. Corollary 3.9.9. Let ϕ ∈ (0, π/2) and assume that e±iϕ A generate C0 -semigroups T±ϕ on X. Then A generates a holomorphic C0 -semigroup of angle ϕ with boundary semigroups T±ϕ . The following result is a consequence of the above Corollary 3.9.9 and Proposition 3.9.1. Corollary 3.9.10. Assume that A generates a C0 -semigroup T and that iA generates a C0 -group U . Then T has a holomorphic extension to Σπ/2 and U is the boundary group of T . Proof. By Corollary 3.9.9, the operator e±iπ/4 A generates a holomorphic C0 -semigroup of angle π/4. Thus eiθ A generates a C0 -semigroup for all θ ∈ (−π/2, π/2). It follows from Corollary 3.9.9 again that A generates a holomorphic C0 -semigroup of angle π/2. By Proposition 3.9.1, U is its boundary group. Next we consider spectral conditions on A which imply that A generates a holomorphic C0 -semigroup on X under the assumption that iA generates a C0 group U on X. An obvious necessary condition for this is that the spectrum of A is located in a left half-plane. However, this condition is not sufficient, in general. Indeed, consider the generator G of the Riemann-Liouville semigroup on Lp (0, 1) for 1 < p < ∞ as introduced in Theorem 3.9.6 and let A := −G. Since G generates a C0 -semigroup T with T (t) = 0 for t > 1, σ(A) is empty by Theorem 3.1.7. Moreover, iA generates a group by Theorem 3.9.6. However, A does not generate a C0 -semigroup. Nevertheless, if σ(A) is contained in some left half-plane, then A generates a holomorphic C0 -semigroup on X provided U satisfies a certain growth condition. Theorem 3.9.11. Let A be an operator on X such that iA generates a C0 -group U on X. Assume that there exists a dense subspace Y of X such that for all x ∈ Y there exist constants C ≥ 0 and k ∈ N (depending on x) such that
U (t)x ≤ C(1 + |t|)k
(t ∈ R).
178
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
If σ(A) ⊂ {λ ∈ C : Re λ ≤ b} for some b ∈ R, then A generates a holomorphic C0 -semigroup of angle π/2 on X (whose boundary group is U ). The key of the proof of Theorem 3.9.11 is the following result of Phragm´enLindel¨ of type. Proposition 3.9.12. Let r : Σπ/2 → X be continuous. Assume that r is holomorphic in Σπ/2 and that there exist constants C, M ≥ 0, R0 > 0, k ∈ N such that
r(λ)
≤
r(is)
≤
C (Re λ ≥ 0, Im λ = 0, |λ| ≥ R0 , arg λ = ϕ) | sin ϕ|k M (s ∈ R).
and
Then ||r(λ)|| ≤ M for all λ ∈ C with Re λ ≥ 0. Proof. For R ≥ R0 and k ∈ N consider the holomorphic function 0 Φ : DR := {z ∈ Σπ/2 : |z| < R} → X,
λ →
k λ2 1− 2 r(λ). R
Let λ := Reiϕ for ϕ ∈ (−π/2, π/2). If ϕ = 0, we obtain
Φ(λ) = |1 − ei2ϕ |k r(λ) = 2k | sin ϕ|k r(λ) ≤ 2k C. Moreover, Φ(R) = 0 and !
Φ(is) = 1 +
" s2 k R2
r(is) ≤ 2k M
(|s| ≤ R).
0. The maximum principle implies that Φ(λ) ≤ 2k max{C, M } for all λ ∈ DR k Letting R → ∞, we deduce that ||r(λ)|| ≤ 2 max{C, M } provided Re λ ≥ 0. Now the Phragm´en-Lindel¨of Principle 3.9.8 implies that
r(λ) ≤ M for all λ ∈ C with Re λ ≥ 0. Proof of Theorem 3.9.11. Replacing A by A − ω, we may assume that σ(A) ⊂ {λ ∈ C : Re λ < −δ} for some δ > 0. By assumption, iA generates a group and we therefore have sups∈R,|s|≥w ||sR(is, A)|| < ∞ for suitable w ≥ 0. It follows that M := sup ||sR(is, A)|| < ∞. s∈R
Thus the second assumption of Proposition 3.9.12 is satisfied for the function λ → λR(λ, A)x (x ∈ X). In order to verify the first assumption in this proposition let x ∈ Y . Then, by hypothesis, there exist constants k ∈ N, C ≥ 0 such that
3.9. BOUNDARY VALUES OF HOLOMORPHIC SEMIGROUPS
179
U (t)x ≤ C(1 + |t|)k (t ∈ R). For λ of the form λ = reiϕ , where r ≥ 1 and ϕ ∈ (0, π/2] we therefore obtain
∞
∞
iλt
≤ |λ|C
λR(λ, A)x = λ e U (−t)x dt e−| Im λ|t (1 + tk ) dt
0 0 1 k! C(1 + k!) ≤ C|λ| + ≤ . | Im λ| | Im λ|k+1 | sin ϕ|k+1 Similarly, for λ = reiϕ , with r ≥ 1 and ϕ ∈ [−π/2, 0) we have
λR(λ, A)x ≤
C(1 + k!) . | sin ϕ|k+1
Hence both assumptions of Proposition 3.9.12 are satisfied for the function λ → λR(λ, A)x and it follows from that proposition that
λR(λ, A)x ≤ M x
(Re λ ≥ 0, x ∈ Y ).
Since Y is dense in X, we conclude that
λR(λ, A) ≤ M
(Re λ ≥ 0).
It follows from Corollary 3.7.12 that A generates a bounded holomorphic C0 semigroup and from Corollary 3.8.9 that the angle is π/2 and U is the boundary group. We finally turn our attention back to the question raised at the beginning of this section: under which conditions on the holomorphic C0 -semigroup T the “boundary value” of T exists and is again a C0 -semigroup. In the following, we weaken the sense of “boundary value” of T and also allow integrated semigroups as “boundary values” for holomorphic C0 -semigroups T . We say that an operator A on X generates a k-times integrated group on X for some k ∈ N0 if A and −A generate k-times integrated semigroups on X. A k-times integrated group is called exponentially bounded if the integrated semigroups generated by A and −A are exponentially bounded. Theorem 3.9.13. Let γ ≥ 0 and k ∈ N. Assume that A generates a holomorphic C0 -semigroup T of angle π/2. Then the following assertions hold: a) Assume that there exist constants M, ω ≥ 0 such that
T (z) ≤
M eω|z| (Re z)γ
(Re z > 0).
Then iA generates an exponentially bounded k-times integrated group provided k > γ.
180
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
b) Assume that iA generates an exponentially bounded k-times integrated group on X. Then there exist constants M, ω ≥ 0 such that
T (z) ≤
M eω|z| (Re z)k
(Re z > 0).
Proof. a) Let x ∈ X, k ∈ N and let λ0 > ω. Then k
R(λ0 , A) x =
∞
0
e−λ0 u
uk−1 T (u)x du. (k − 1)!
Hence, R(λ0 , A)k T (z)x =
∞
e−λ0 u
0
uk−1 T (u + z)x du (Re z > 0). (k − 1)!
Setting z = t + is the assumption implies that
R(λ0 , A)k T (z)
≤ ≤
∞ M eω|u+t+is| e−λ0 u uk−1 du (k − 1)! 0 (u + t)γ ∞ M e−λ0 u uk−1−γ eω|u+t+is| du < ∞, (3.67) (k − 1)! 0
provided k > γ. Since z → R(λ0 , A)k T (z) is holomorphic and bounded in a rectangle of the form {t + is : 0 < t < 1, −R < s < R} for some R > 0 it follows by dominated convergence that lim R(λ0 , A)k T (t + is)x t↓0
exists for all s ∈ R and all x ∈ X. For s ∈ R and x ∈ X set ⎧ ⎨i−k lim R(λ0 , A)k T (t + is)x (s ≥ 0), t↓0 S(s)x := ⎩(−i)−k lim R(λ0 , A)k T (t + is)x (s < 0). t↓0
In order to show that iA generates a k-times integrated semigroup it suffices by Proposition 3.2.7 to verify that R(·, iA)R(iλ0 , iA)k is a Laplace transform. Note first that by the estimate (3.67) there exists a constant C ≥ 0 such that S(s) ≤ Ceω|s| for s ∈ R+ . We claim that ˆ S(λ) = R(λ, iA)R(iλ0 , iA)k
(λ > ω).
In fact, by Fubini’s theorem, the representation formula (3.46) for holomorphic
3.9. BOUNDARY VALUES OF HOLOMORPHIC SEMIGROUPS
181
C0 -semigroups and Cauchy’s theorem, we have ∞ ∞ ik e−λs S(s) ds = lim e−λs R(λ0 , A)k T (t + is) ds t↓0 0 0 ∞ = lim e−λs R(λ0 , A)k eμ(t+is) R(μ, A) dμ ds t↓0 0 Γ ∞ = lim e−λs eμis ds eμt R(λ0 , A)k R(μ, A) dμ t↓0 Γ 0 1 = lim eμt R(λ0 , A)k R(μ, A) dμ t↓0 Γ λ − iμ = lim R(λ, iA)R(λ0 , A)k T (t) t↓0
= R(λ, iA)R(λ0 , A)k
(λ > ω),
∞ where Γ denotes the path defined in (3.46). Thus we have 0 e−λs S(s) ds = R(λ, iA)R(iλ0 , iA)k for λ > ω. The corresponding result for −iA is proved in exactly the same way. b) By rescaling, we may assume that σ(A) ⊂ {λ ∈ C : Re λ ≤ −1} (see Proposition 3.1.9 i) and Proposition 3.2.6). We subdivide the proof into two steps. Step 1: By assumption, A generates a holomorphic C0 -semigroup T of angle z (z−ξ) k−1 π/2. Hence, the function S : z → S(z) := 0 (k−1)! T (ξ) dξ is holomorphic in the open right half-plane. We claim that there exist constants M, ω ≥ 0 such that
S(z) ≤ M eω|z| Integrating by parts, using
dn −n dξ n T (ξ)A
S(z)x = T (z)A−k x −
(Re z > 0).
(3.68)
= T (ξ), gives
z k−1 A−1 x − · · · − A−k x (x ∈ X). (k − 1)!
Hence, in order to prove (3.68) it suffices to show that
T (z)A−k ≤ M eω|z|
(Re z > 0),
(3.69)
for suitable constants M, ω ≥ 0. Obviously (S(t))t≥0 is the k-times integrated semigroup generated by A. For z ∈ {μ ∈ C : Re μ > 0} set z = t + is for t > 0 and s ∈ R. Let (R(s))s∈R be the k-times integrated group generated by iA. For x ∈ D(Ak ) set T (is)x :=
k dk sn k R(s)x = R(s)(iA) x + (iA)n−1 x dsk n! n=1
(s ∈ R).
Then T (t + is)x = T (t)T (is)x = T (is)T (t)x (t > 0, s ∈ R),
(3.70)
182
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
because the function v given by v(s) := T (is)T (t)x − T (t + is)x is the unique mild solution of the problem u (s) = iAu(s), u(0) = 0, by Lemma 3.2.9 and Lemma 3.2.10. We consider first the case where Re z ≥ 1. By (3.70) we have for z = t + is
T (z)A−k ≤ T (t − 1/2)A−k T (is)A−k Ak T (1/2) . Since t → T (t − 1/2)A−k and s → T (is)A−k are exponentially bounded we obtain (3.69) in the case where Re z ≥ 1. Next, we consider the case where 0 < Re z ≤ 1. For x ∈ X we have by (3.70): T (z)A−2k x = T (t)A−k T (is)A−k x. It then follows that there exist constants M1 , ω1 ≥ 0 such that
T (z)A−2k ≤ M1 eω1 |z|
and
T (is)A−k ≤ M1 eω1 |s|
(3.71)
for s ∈ R and z ∈ C satisfying Re z > 0. For z ∈ Ω := {μ ∈ C : 0 ≤ Re μ ≤ 1} and x ∈ X set f (z) := (cos z)−2ω1 T (z)A−2k x. Then f is holomorphic in the interior of Ω and continuous on Ω, by (3.70). For |s| ≥ 1 we have
f (z) ≤ 22ω1 T (z)A−2k x |es − e−s |−2ω1 , which by (3.71) implies that z → f (z) is bounded for z ∈ Ω. For z = is and z = 1 + is we have
f (is)
f (1 + is)
≤
22ω1
≤ 22ω1
T (is)A−k A−k x
≤ M2 A−k x
|es + e−s |2ω1
T (is)A−k T (1)A−k x
≤ M2 A−k x
|es + e−2i e−s |2ω1
for a suitable constant M2 ≥ 0. The three-lines lemma [Con73, Theorem VI.3.7] now implies that there exists a constant M ≥ 0 such that
T (z)A−2k x ≤ M e2ω1 |z| A−k x
(Re z > 0).
Since D(Ak ) is dense in X, the claim follows. Step 2: Set z Sk+1 (z) := S(ξ) dξ (Re z > 0). 0
Cauchy’s integral formula implies that (k + 1)! Sk+1 (ξ) T (z) = dξ k+2 2πi γz (ξ − z)
(Re z > 0),
3.9. BOUNDARY VALUES OF HOLOMORPHIC SEMIGROUPS where γz denotes the path defined by the circle with centre z and radius r = It follows that (k + 1)! Sk+1 (ξ) − Sk+1 (z) T (z) = dξ 2πi (ξ − z)k+2 γz " (k + 1)! 2π ! = Sk+1 (z + reiϕ ) − Sk+1 (z) e−iϕ(k+1) dϕ. 2πrk+1 0
183 Re z 2 .
It follows from the definition of Sk+1 and (3.68) that
Sk+1 (z + reiϕ ) − Sk+1 (z) ≤ M3 reω3 |z|
(Re z > 0)
for suitable M3 , ω3 ≥ 0. Inserting this in the above representation of T (z), it follows that eω4 |z| 2k eω4 |z|
T (z) ≤ M4 k = M4 (Re z > 0) r (Re z)k for suitable constants M4 , ω4 ≥ 0. The proof is complete. As an application of Theorem 3.9.13 we consider once again “boundary values” of the Gaussian semigroup. More precisely, let 1 ≤ p < ∞ and let the operator Δp be defined as in (3.60). Then the following corollary holds true. Corollary 3.9.14. Let 1 ≤ p < ∞ and let k ∈ N0 . Then iΔp generates an exponentially bounded k-times integrated group on Lp (Rn ) if k > n| 12 − p1 |. Moreover, the order of integration is optimal in the sense that iΔp does not generate a k-times integrated semigroup on Lp (Rn ) if k < n| 12 − 1p |. Proof. It follows from (3.61) and by duality that the assumption of Theorem 3.9.13 a) is satisfied for γ = n|1/2 − 1/p|. Hence, the first assertion above follows from this theorem. Conversely, suppose that iΔp generates an exponentially bounded k-times integrated semigroup S on Lp (Rn ) for some 1 ≤ p < ∞ and k < n|1/2 − 1/p|. Let J be the conjugation on the complex space Lp (Rn ); Jf = f¯. Then −iΔp = J(iΔp )J, which generates the k-times integrated semigroup JS(·)J, so iΔp generates an exponentially bounded k-times integrated group. By Theorem 3.9.13 b), there exists a constant M > 0 such that Tp (z) ≤ M/(Re z)k for z ∈ Σπ/2 with |z| = 1, where Tp is the Gaussian semigroup as in Example 3.7.6. However, by (3.62) we have
Tp (z) ≥ 2−n/2p (Re z)−n|1/2−1/p|
(z ∈ Σπ/2 , |z| = 1),
which yields a contradiction. More general results for differential and pseudo-differential operators will be given in Section 8.3.
184
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
3.10 Intermediate Spaces It turns out that k-times integrated semigroups are the same as C0 -semigroups up to the choice of the underlying Banach space. This will be made precise in this section. Throughout this section, Z, X and Y are Banach spaces. We write Z → X if Z ⊂ X and there is a constant c such that x X ≤ c x Z for all x ∈ Z. If in d
addition Z is dense in X we write Z → X. The following lemma is a consequence of the closed graph theorem. Lemma 3.10.1. If Z → Y and Z ⊂ X → Y , then Z → X. Let A be an operator on X. If Z → X we denote by AZ the part of A in Z; i.e., D(AZ ) := {x ∈ D(A) ∩ Z : Ax ∈ Z}, AZ x := Ax. If A is closed, then AZ is closed. The following is easy to prove (see also Proposition B.8). Lemma 3.10.2. Let A be an operator on X, Z → X. Let μ ∈ ρ(A) such that R(μ, A)Z ⊂ Z. Let B be an operator on Z. Then B = AZ if and only if μ ∈ ρ(B) and R(μ, B) = R(μ, A)|Z . Let A be a closed operator on X and k ∈ N. Then D(Ak ) is a Banach space for the norm x Ak := x + Ax + . . . + Ak x . Moreover, D(Ak ) → X. We denote by Ak the part of A in D(Ak ); i.e., Ak is the operator on the Banach space D(Ak ) given by Ak x = Ax, D(Ak ) = D(Ak+1 ). If ρ(A) = ∅, then Ak and A are similar (see Section 3.5 for the definition). In fact, Ak = U −1 AU where U may be taken as U = (μ − A)k for any μ ∈ ρ(A). In particular, σ(Ak ) = σ(A) and Ak generates an (exponentially bounded) m-times integrated semigroup on D(Ak ) if and only if A generates an (exponentially bounded) m-times integrated semigroup on X. The following result on the spectrum of intermediate operators is of general interest. Proposition 3.10.3. Let A be an operator on X, Z → X. Assume that R(μ, A)Z ⊂ Z for some μ ∈ ρ(A) and that D(Ak ) ⊂ Z for some k ∈ N. Then σ(AZ ) = σ(A) and R(λ, AZ ) = R(λ, A)|Z for all λ ∈ ρ(A). Proof. a) Let B = AZ and λ ∈ ρ(A). Iterating the resolvent equation R(λ, A) = R(μ, A) + (μ − λ)R(μ, A)R(λ, A) gives R(λ, A) =
k (μ − λ)j−1 R(μ, A)j + (μ − λ)k R(μ, A)k R(λ, A).
(3.72)
j=1
Since R(μ, A)Z ⊂ Z and R(μ, A)k X = D(Ak ) ⊂ Z, it follows that R(λ, A)Z ⊂ Z. Hence by Lemma 3.10.2, λ ∈ ρ(B) and R(λ, B) = R(λ, A)|Z .
3.10. INTERMEDIATE SPACES
185
b) In order to prove the converse, we observe that ρ(A) = ρ(Ak ) since A and Ak are similar operators. Let Y := D(Ak ) with the graph norm. Then Y → Z by Lemma 3.10.1, D(B k ) ⊂ Y and Ak = BY . Moreover, R(μ, B)Y = R(μ, A)Y = D(Ak+1 ) ⊂ Y . It follows from a) (applied to B instead of A) that ρ(B) ⊂ ρ(Ak ) = ρ(A). Our aim is to prove the following result. Theorem 3.10.4 (Sandwich Theorem). Let A be an operator on X and let k ∈ N. The following assertions are equivalent: (i) The operator A generates a k-times integrated semigroup S such that ω(S) < ∞. (ii) There exists a Banach space Y and the generator B of a C0 -semigroup V on Y such that a) D(B k ) ⊂ X → Y , b) R(λ, B)X ⊂ X for some λ ∈ ρ(B), and c) A = BX . (iii) There exists a Banach space Z such that a) D(Ak ) ⊂ Z → X, b) R(λ, A)Z ⊂ Z for some λ ∈ ρ(A), and c) AZ generates a C0 -semigroup U on Z. Proof. (i) ⇒ (ii): Assume that A generates a k-times integrated semigroup S satisfying S(t) ≤ M eωt (t ≥ 0) where M, ω > 0. For x ∈ D(Ak ), let T (t)x := S(t)Ak x +
tk−1 Ak−1 x + . . . + tAx + x (t ≥ 0). (k − 1)!
(3.73)
By Lemma 3.2.2 (see also Lemma 3.2.10), v(t) := T (t)x is a mild solution of (ACP0 ). Hence, s → v(t + s) is a mild solution of (ACP0 ) with initial value T (t)x. By Theorem 3.1.3, ∞ e−λs T (t + s)x ds (t ≥ 0, λ > ω) (3.74) R(λ, A)T (t)x = 0
for all x ∈ D(A ). Fix μ0 > b > ω, and define a norm · Y on X by k
x Y := sup e−bt T (t)R(μ0 , A)k x X ,
(3.75)
t≥0
and let Y be the completion of (X, · Y ). We claim that
(λ − b)R(λ, A)x Y ≤ x Y
(λ > b, x ∈ X).
(3.76)
186
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
In fact,
e−bt T (t)R(μ0 , A)k R(λ, A)x X
−bt ∞ −λs
k
= e e T (s + t)R(μ0 , A) x ds
X
∞ 0
−(λ−b)s −b(t+s) k
= e e T (s + t)R(μ0 , A) x ds
0 X ∞
x
Y ≤ x Y e−(λ−b)s ds = . λ−b 0 Hence R(λ, A) has a unique extension R(λ) ∈ L(Y ) and (λ − b)R(λ) L(Y ) ≤ 1 (λ > b). Then (R(λ))λ>b is a pseudo-resolvent on Y . Next we show that lim λR(λ)y − y Y = 0
(3.77)
λ→∞
for all y ∈ Y . Since lim supλ→∞ λR(λ) L(Y ) < ∞, it suffices to prove (3.77) for y ∈ X, X being dense in Y . Let x := R(μ0 , A)k y. Let ε > 0. There exists M such that T (t)x X ≤ M eωt (t ≥ 0). Then
−bt ∞ −λs
e
λe (T (t + s)x − T (t)x) ds
0 X ∞ −bt −λs ω(t+s) ωt ≤ e λe M e +e ds 0 λ = M e−(b−ω)t +1 . λ−ω Hence, there exists t0 such that
−bt ∞ −λs
sup sup e λe (T (t + s)x − T (t)x) ds
λ>2ω t>t0
0
< ε.
(3.78)
X
Since t → T (t)x is uniformly continuous on [0, t0 + 1], there exists τ > 0 such that
T (t + s)x − T (t)x X < ε whenever s ∈ [0, τ ], t ∈ [0, t0 ]. For λ > 2ω and 0 ≤ t ≤ t0 ,
−bt ∞ −λs
e
λe (T (t + s)x − T (t)x) ds
0 X τ ∞ −bt −λs −bt −λs ≤ e λe ε ds + e λe M (eω(t+s) + eωt ) ds 0 τ λ ≤ ε + M e−(λ−ω)τ + e−λτ . (3.79) λ−ω
3.10. INTERMEDIATE SPACES
187
By (3.74), (3.75), (3.78) and (3.79), lim sup λR(λ, A)y − y Y λ→∞
= lim sup sup e−bt (λR(λ, A)T (t)x − T (t)x) X λ→∞ t≥0
−bt ∞ −λs
= lim sup sup e λe (T (t + s)x − T (t)x) ds
λ→∞ t≥0 0
≤
X
ε.
Since ε > 0 is arbitrary, the claim is proved. It follows from (3.77) and Proposition B.6 that there exists a densely defined operator B on Y such that (b, ∞) ⊂ ρ(B) and R(λ, B) = R(λ) (λ > b). By the Hille-Yosida theorem, B generates a C0 -semigroup V on Y satisfying
V (t) L(Y ) ≤ ebt (t ≥ 0). It follows from Lemma 3.10.2 that A = BX . By definition, R(μ0 , A)k y X ≤ y Y (y ∈ X). Hence, R(μ0 , B)k Y ⊂ X; i.e., D(B k ) ⊂ X and the proof of (ii) is complete. ! " (ii) ⇒ (iii): Let Z := D(B k ), · Bk . Then AZ = Bk which is similar to B, so AZ generates a C0 -semigroup U on Z. By Proposition 3.10.3, ρ(A) = ρ(B) and R(λ, A) = R(λ, B)|X for all λ ∈ ρ(B). It follows that R(λ, A)Z ⊂ Z for all λ ∈ ρ(A). (iii) ⇒ (i): Note that D(Ak ) → Z by Lemma 3.10.1, and R(λ, AZ ) = R(λ, A)|Z for λ ∈ ρ(A) = ρ(AZ ), by Proposition 3.10.3. Let μ ∈ ρ(A). Then λ → R(λ, A)R(μ, A)k is the Laplace transform of t → U (t)R(μ, A)k . Now, (i) follows from Proposition 3.2.7. Corollary 3.10.5. Let A be the generator of an exponentially bounded k-times integrated semigroup T on X and let B ∈ L(X, D(Ak )). Then A + B generates a k-times integrated semigroup S on X satisfying ω(S) < ∞. Proof. We use the notation of Theorem 3.10.4 (iii). The operator B|Z is bounded. By Corollary 3.5.6, AZ + B|Z generates a C0 -semigroup on Z. It is clear that (A + B)Z = AZ + B|Z . So it will follow from Theorem 3.10.4 that A + B generates an exponentially bounded k-times integrated semigroup on X once we have proved that A + B satisfies conditions a) and b) of Theorem 3.10.4 (iii). It is easy to see that D((A + B)k ) ⊂ D(Ak ), so a) is satisfied. In order to show b), take μ ∈ ρ(A). Then C := (μ − A)k B ∈ L(X) and by (3.73) R(λ, A)B
=
R(λ, A)R(μ, A)k C
=
R(λ, A)C − (μ − λ)j−k−1 R(μ, A)j C. (μ − λ)k k
j=1
Since λ → λ−k R(λ, A) is the Laplace transform of an exponentially bounded function, lim supλ→∞ λ1−k R(λ, A) < ∞. This implies that limλ→∞ R(λ, A)B = 0.
188
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Consequently, (I − R(λ, A)B) is invertible for large λ. Then by Lemma 3.5.8, (I − BR(λ, A)) is also invertible for large λ. Hence, (λ−(A+B)) = (I−BR(λ, A))(λ−A) is invertible for large λ. Hence, there exists λ ∈ ρ(A + B) ∩ ρ(AZ + B|Z ) ∩ ρ(A). Let y ∈ Z, x = R(λ, A + B)y. Then (λ − A)x = y + Bx ∈ Z. Hence x = R(λ, A)(y + Bx) ∈ Z by Proposition 3.10.3.
3.11 Resolvent Positive Operators In this section we assume that X is an ordered Banach space with normal cone X+ (see Appendix C). Definition 3.11.1. An operator A on X is called resolvent positive if there exists ω ∈ R such that (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and R(λ, A) ≥ 0 for all λ > ω. If A generates a C0 -semigroup T , then A is resolvent positive if and only if T is positive (i.e. T (t)X+ ⊂ X+ for all t ≥ 0). In fact, if T is positive, then ∞ R(λ, A) = e−λt T (t) dt ≥ 0 0
for all λ > ω(T ). The converse follows from Euler’s formula ! "−n T (t)x = lim I − nt A x n→∞
(see Corollary 3.3.6). But there are interesting examples of resolvent positive operators which do not generate C0 -semigroups; see Section 6.1 for an example. Let A be a resolvent positive operator. Then for λ > ω one has (−1)n R(λ, A)(n) = n!R(λ, A)n+1 ≥ 0
(3.80)
for all n ∈ N (see Appendix B). Thus, the function R(·, A) is completely monotonic (cf. Section 2.7). We first use Bernstein’s theorem for real-valued functions to prove some general properties of resolvent positive operators. Proposition 3.11.2. Let A be a resolvent positive operator. Denote by s(A) := sup{Re λ : λ ∈ σ(A)} the spectral bound of A. Then s(A) < ∞ and R(λ, A) ≥ R(μ, A) ≥ 0 whenever s(A) < λ < μ. Moreover, if λ ∈ R ∩ ρ(A) such that R(λ, A) ≥ 0, then λ > s(A). Finally, s(A) ∈ σ(A) if s(A) > −∞.
3.11. RESOLVENT POSITIVE OPERATORS
189
Proof. Let s := inf{ω : (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and R(λ, A) ≥ 0 for all λ > ω}. By assumption, s < ∞. Replacing A by A − ω, we may assume that s ≤ 0. a) Let s < λ < μ. Then R(λ, A) − R(μ, A) = (μ − λ)R(λ, A)R(μ, A) ≥ 0. Thus, R(·, A) is a decreasing function on (s, ∞). b) Assume that s > −∞. Then s ∈ σ(A). In fact, if s ∈ ρ(A) then R(s, A) ≥ 0. Moreover, for μ < s sufficiently close to μ one has R(μ, A) =
∞
(s − μ)n R(s, A)n+1 ≥ 0.
n=0
This contradicts the definition of s. c) Let Hs := {λ ∈ C : Re λ > s}. We claim that Hs ⊂ ρ(A); this and b) establish that s = s(A). Denote by Ω0 the connected component of Hs ∩ ρ(A) containing (s, ∞). If Hs ⊂ ρ(A), there exist μn ∈ Ω0 such that μ := limn→∞ μn ∈ Hs \ ρ(A). Then by Corollary B.3, sup R(μn , A) = ∞.
n∈N
By the uniform boundedness principle, there exist x ∈ X, x∗ ∈ X ∗ such that ∗ supn∈N |R(μn , A)x, x∗ | = ∞. Since X = span X+ and X ∗ = span X+ (Proposi∗ ∗ tion C.2), we can assume that x ∈ X+ , x ∈ X+ . By Bernstein’s Theorem 2.7.7, there exists an increasing function α : R+ → R such that α(0) = 0 and ∞ R(λ, A)x, x∗ = e−λt dα(t) = dα(λ) 0
for all λ > s. It follows from uniqueness of holomorphic extensions that n) R(μn , A)x, x∗ = dα(μ for all n ∈ N. Consequently, |R(μn , A)x, x∗ | ≤ dα(Re μn ) = R(Re μn , A)x, x∗ ≤ R(λ, A)x, x∗ , where λ := inf n∈N Re μn > s (since Re μ = limn→∞ Re μn > s). This is a contradiction. d) In order to prove the remaining assertion, assume that there exists λ ∈ ρ(A) such that λ < s(A) and R(λ, A) ≥ 0. Let μn ↓ s(A). Since s(A) ∈ σ(A),
R(μn , A) → ∞ as n → ∞.
190
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
As in a), we have R(λ, A) ≥ R(μn , A) ≥ 0
(n ∈ N).
This is impossible. From Theorem 3.11.2 and its proof, we note the following. Corollary 3.11.3. Let A be a resolvent positive operator. Then |R(λ, A)x, x∗ | ≤ R(ω, A)x, x∗
(3.81)
∗ whenever Re λ ≥ ω > s(A), x ∈ X+ and x∗ ∈ X+ . In particular, for each ω > s(A), sup R(λ, A) < ∞. Re λ≥ω
We need the following identity. Lemma 3.11.4. Let A be an operator and λ ∈ ρ(A). Then for all m ∈ N (−1)m λm+1 (R(λ, A)/λ)
(m)
/m! =
m
λk R(λ, A)k+1 .
(3.82)
k=0
Proof. This is immediate from Leibniz’s rule, since (−1)k R(λ, A)(k) /k! = R(λ, A)k+1 . Now we can prove the following generation theorem. Theorem 3.11.5. Let A be a resolvent positive operator. Then A generates a twice integrated semigroup which is Lipschitz continuous on bounded intervals. If D(A) is dense, then A generates a once integrated semigroup. Proof. Considering A − ω instead of A, we can assume that s(A) < 0 (see Proposition 3.2.6). Let m ∈ N, λ ≥ 0. Then m−1
λk R(λ, A)k+1 = R(0, A) − λm R(λ, A)m R(0, A).
(3.83)
k=0
For m = 1, this is just the resolvent equation. Then (3.83) follows by induction. Consequently, m−1 0≤ λk R(λ, A)k+1 ≤ R(0, A) k=0
for m ∈ N, λ ≥ 0. It follows from Lemma 3.11.4 that sup λ>0,m∈N0
λm+1 (R(λ, A)/λ)(m) /m! < ∞.
3.11. RESOLVENT POSITIVE OPERATORS
191
Now the claim follows from Theorem 3.3.1 and Theorem 3.3.2. More generally, if A is resolvent positive, it follows from Corollary 3.3.13 that the part of A in Y = D(A) generates a once integrated semigroup. The following example shows that a resolvent positive operator does not generate a once integrated semigroup in general. Example 3.11.6. Let X = C[−1, 0] × C and A be given by D(A) := C 1 [−1, 0] × {0},
A(f, 0) := (f , −f (0)).
Then ρ(A) = C and R(λ, A)(f, c) = (g, 0) with 0 λx −λy g(x) := e e f (y) dy + c x
for all λ ∈ C. Thus, A is resolvent positive. Let eλ ∈ C[−1, 0] be given by (λ > 0, x ∈ [−1, 0]). ∞ Then (eλ , 0) = R(λ, A)(0, 1). One has eλ = 0 λ2 e−λt kt dt where kt ∈ C[−1, 0] is given by kt (x) := 0 if x + t ≤ 0 and kt (x) := x + t otherwise. If A were the generator of a once integrated semigroup, then λ → eλ /λ would be a Laplace d transform. Hence, k : R+ → C[−1, 0] would be differentiable. But dt kt (x) does not exist at x = −t if t ∈ (0, 1). eλ (x) := eλx
The following result shows that the situation is different if X has order continuous norm. Theorem 3.11.7. Let A be a resolvent positive operator and assume that X has order continuous norm. Then A generates a once integrated semigroup. Proof. Replacing A by A − ω, we may assume that s(A) ≤ 0. Let x ∈ X+ . Then by Theorem 2.7.18, there exists a unique normalized increasing function Fx : R+ → X such that Fx (0) = 0 and ∞ R(λ, A)x = e−λt dFx (t) (λ > s(A)). 0
It follows from uniqueness that Fx (t) is additive and positive homogeneous in x for all t ≥ 0. Hence, there exists a positive linear operator S1 (t) ∈ L(X) such that Fx (t) = S1 (t)x for all t ≥ 0, x ∈ X. Since S1 (·) is increasing, we can define the t Riemann integral S2 (t)x := 0 S1 (s)x ds for all x ∈ X (see Corollary 1.9.6). Then ∞ ∞ R(λ, A)x = λ e−λt S1 (t)x dt = λ2 e−λt S2 (t)x dt 0
0
for all x ∈ X, λ > max{0, s(A)}, where the first integral is understood as an improper Riemann integral (see (1.22) and Proposition 1.10.2). We have to show that S1 is strongly continuous on R+ .
192
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Since S2 (·)x is continuous, S2 is the twice integrated semigroup generated by A. Thus for x ∈ D(A), S2 (·)x is continuously differentiable by Lemma 3.2.2. Hence S1 (·)x is continuous if x ∈ D(A). Let x ∈ X+ and μ > s(A). Then R(μ, A)S1 (·)x is a normalized increasing function on R+ and ∞ ∞ e−λt d(R(μ, A)S1 (t)x) = R(μ, A) e−λt d(S1 (t)x) 0
0
= R(μ, A)R(λ, A)x = =
R(λ, A)R(μ, A)x ∞ e−λt d(S1 (t)R(μ, A)x) 0
for all λ > s(A). It follows from uniqueness of the representation (see Theorem 2.7.18) that S1 (t)R(μ, A)x = R(μ, A)S1 (t)x. Since the norm is order continuous, y+ := lims↓t S1 (s)x exists. Moreover, R(μ, A)y+
= lim R(μ, A)S1 (s)x s↓t
= lim S1 (s)R(μ, A)x s↓t
= S1 (t)R(μ, A)x = R(μ, A)S1 (t)x. Since R(μ, A) is injective, it follows that y+ = S1 (t)x. In the same way one shows that lims↑t S1 (s)x = S1 (t)x if t > 0. We have shown that S1 is strongly continuous on R+ . The closure of the domain of a resolvent positive operator is of a very special nature if the underlying space is a Banach lattice with order continuous norm. Let X be a complex Banach lattice; i.e., the complexification of a real Banach lattice. A subspace J of X is called an ideal if a) x ∈ J implies Re x ∈ J; and b) if x, y ∈ X are real, |y| ≤ |x| and x ∈ J, then it follows that y ∈ J. In a space X := Lp (Ω, μ), where (Ω, μ) is a σ-finite measure space and 1 ≤ p < ∞, every closed ideal J is of the form J = {f ∈ Lp (Ω) : f |Ω0 = 0 a.e.} , where Ω0 is a measurable subset of Ω (see [Sch74, p.157]). Theorem 3.11.8. Let X be a Banach lattice with order continuous norm. If A is a resolvent positive operator, then D(A) is an ideal.
3.11. RESOLVENT POSITIVE OPERATORS
193
Proof. a) Note that by definition X is the complexification of a real Banach lattice XR . Since the resolvent leaves XR invariant we have Re x ∈ D(A) whenever x ∈ D(A). Now observe that if J is a closed ideal of XR , then J ⊕ iJ is a closed ideal of X. These remarks show that we can assume that X is a real Banach lattice, which we do. b) We can also assume that s(A) < 0 (replacing A by A − ω otherwise). c) Let 0 ≤ y ≤ R(0, A)x where x ∈ X+ . We claim that y ∈ D(A). For λ > 0 we have 0 ≤ λR(λ, A)y ≤ λR(λ, A)R(0, A)x = R(0, A)x − R(λ, A)x ≤ R(0, A)x. Since the order interval [0, R(0, A)x] is weakly compact [AB85, Theorem 12.9], there exists a weak limit point z of λR(λ, A)y as λ → ∞. In particular, z ∈ D(A). Then R(0, A)y − R(λ, A)y = λR(0, A)R(λ, A)y has R(0, A)z as weak limit point. By the inequality above, lim R(λ, A)y = 0,
λ→∞
so R(0, A)y = R(0, A)z. Since R(0, A) is injective, it follows that y = z ∈ D(A). d) Let y ∈ D(A). Then |y| ∈ D(A). In fact, there exists x ∈ X such that y = R(0, A)x. Hence, |y| ≤ R(0, A)|x| and the claim follows from c). e) If y ∈ D(A), then |y| ∈ D(A). This follows from d) since the absolute value is a continuous mapping. f) Let 0 ≤ y ≤ x ∈ D(A). Let xn ∈ D(A) such that limn→∞ xn = x. It follows from e) that |xn | ∈ D(A). We have y ∧ |xn | ≤ |xn | = |R(0, A)Axn | ≤ R(0, A)|Axn |. It follows from c) that y ∧ |xn | ∈ D(A). Hence, y = limn→∞ (y ∧ |xn |) ∈ D(A). g) Let |y| ≤ |x|, where x ∈ D(A). Then 0 ≤ y + ≤ |x|, so y + ∈ D(A), by e) and f). Similarly, y − ∈ D(A), and therefore y = y + − y − ∈ D(A). In some special cases, densely defined resolvent positive operators are automatically generators of C0 -semigroups. Theorem 3.11.9. Let X = C(K) where K is a compact space. Let A be a densely defined resolvent positive operator. Then A generates a positive C0 -semigroup. Proof. Since D(A) is dense, there exists a strictly positive function u ∈ D(A); i.e., u(x) ≥ ε > 0 for all x ∈ K and some ε > 0. We can assume that s(A) < 0 (replacing A by A−ω if necessary). There exists v ∈ C(K) such that u = R(0, A)v.
194
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Then for λ > 0, n ∈ N and f ∈ C(K) with f ∞ ≤ 1, |(λR(λ, A))n f |
≤
(λR(λ, A))n |f | 1 ≤ (λR(λ, A))n u ε 1 ≤ (λR(λ, A))n R(0, A)|v| ε n−1 1 k k+1 = R(0, A)|v| − λ R(λ, A) |v| ε k=0
≤
1 R(0, A)|v|, ε
using (3.83). It follows that
1
R(0, A)|v| ∞ ε for all λ > 0 and n ∈ N. Now the claim follows from the Hille-Yosida theorem.
(λR(λ, A))n ≤
Now we return to the case when X is an arbitrary ordered Banach space with normal cone. We consider the inhomogeneous Cauchy problem u (t) = Au(t) + f (t) (t ∈ [0, τ ]), (ACPf ) u(0) = u0 , where A is a closed operator on X, τ > 0 and f ∈ C([0, τ ], X). Recall from Section 3.1 that a mild solution of (ACPf ) is a function u ∈ C([0, τ ], X) such that t t t u(s) ds ∈ D(A) and u(t) − u0 = A u(s) ds + f (s) ds 0
0
0
for all t ∈ [0, τ ]. The function u is called a classical solution if in addition u ∈ C 1 ([0, τ ], X). In that case, since A is closed, it follows that u ∈ C([0, τ ], D(A)) and (ACPf ) is satisfied. The following result is a special case of a sharper version of Corollary 3.2.11 c) which is valid for generators of Lipschitz continuous integrated semigroups. Theorem 3.11.10. Let A be a resolvent positive operator. Let u0 ∈ D(A), f0 ∈ X t such that Au0 + f0 ∈ D(A). Let f (t) = f0 + 0 f (s) ds where f ∈ L1 ((0, τ ), X). Then (ACPf ) has a unique mild solution. Proof. Denote by S the twice integrated semigroup generated by A. Let v(t) = S(t)u0 + (S ∗ f )(t). By Lemmas 3.2.9 and 3.2.10, there exists a unique solution if and only if v ∈ C 2 ([0, τ ], X). By Proposition 1.3.6, one has S ∗ f ∈ C 1 ([0, τ ], X) and d (S ∗ f )(t) = (S ∗ f )(t) + S(t)f0 . dt
3.11. RESOLVENT POSITIVE OPERATORS
195
Now it follows from Lemma 3.2.2 c) that v ∈ C 1 ([0, τ ], X) and v (t) = S(t)(Au0 + f0 ) + tu0 + (S ∗ f )(t). Since S is Lipschitz continuous on [0, τ ] (by Theorem 3.11.5), it follows from Proposition 1.3.7 that S ∗ f ∈ C 1 ([0, τ ], X). Since Au0 + f0 ∈ D(A), it follows from Lemma 3.3.3 that S(·)(Au0 + f0 ) ∈ C 1 ([0, τ ], X). The proof is complete. Theorem 3.11.10 will be used in Section 6.2 to solve the heat equation with inhomogeneous boundary conditions. The following result shows that mild solutions of the inhomogeneous problem are positive if the initial value and the inhomogeneity are positive. In Section 6.2 this will be used to prove the parabolic maximum principle. Theorem 3.11.11. Let A be a resolvent positive operator, τ > 0, f ∈ C([0, τ ], X+ ), and u0 ∈ X+ . Let u be a mild solution of (ACPf ). Then u(t) ≥ 0 for all t ∈ [0, τ ]. Proof. Denote by S the twice integrated semigroup generated by A. It follows from Theorem 2.7.15 that S is an increasing convex function. Let t w(t) := S(t)u0 + S(t − r)f (r) dr. 0
It follows from Lemma suffices to show that w := S(t) for Define S(t) convex and S(0) = 0, it t 0
3.2.9 that w ∈ C 2 ([0, τ ], X) and u(t) = w (t). Thus, it is convex. We know this already for the first term of w. = 0 for t < 0. Since S is increasing and t ≥ 0 and S(t) : R → L(X) is also convex. Hence, follows that S(t) S(t − r)f (r) dr =
∞
0
− r)f (r) dr S(t
is convex in t ≥ 0. Next we consider a simple perturbation result. Proposition 3.11.12. Let A be a resolvent positive operator. Let B : D(A) → X be linear and positive (i.e., Bx ≥ 0 if x ∈ D(A) ∩ X+ ). If the spectral radius r(BR(λ, A)) < 1 for some λ > s(A), then A + B is resolvent positive and s(A + B) < λ. Notice that BR(λ, A) is a linear, positive mapping on X and so it is automatically continuous. Proof. Let x ∈ D(A). Then (λ − (A + B))x = (I − BR(λ, A))(λ − A)x. Let Sλ := (I − BR(λ, A))−1 =
∞ n=0
(BR(λ, A))n .
196
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Then Sλ is a bounded, positive operator on X and R(λ, A)Sλ (λ − (A + B))x = x for all x ∈ X and (λ − (A + B))R(λ, A)Sλ y = y
for all y ∈ X.
Thus, λ ∈ ρ(A + B) and R(λ, A + B) = R(λ, A)Sλ ≥ 0. If μ > λ, then by Proposition 3.11.2, μ ∈ ρ(A) and BR(μ, A) ≤ BR(λ, A) and so r(BR(μ, A)) ≤ r(BR(λ, A)) < 1. Replacing λ by μ, it follows that μ ∈ ρ(A+B) and R(μ, A+B) ≥ 0 for all μ ≥ λ. The following example shows that, in the theorem above, A + B may not be generator of a C0 -semigroup even if A generates a positive C0 -semigroup. Example 3.11.13. Let α ∈ (0, 1). Define the operator A by Af (x) := −f (x) +
α f (x) x
(x ∈ (0, 1])
on C0 (0, 1] := {f ∈ C[0, 1] : f (0) = 0} with domain D(A) := {f ∈ C 1 [0, 1] : f (0) = f (0) = 0}. Then A is resolvent positive but not the generator of a C0 semigroup. Moreover, s(A) = −∞. Proof. Let A0 f := −f with domain D(A0 ) = D(A). Then A0 is the generator of the C0 -semigroup (T (t))t≥0 given by f (x − t) (x ≥ t), (T (t)f )(x) = 0 (x < t). Moreover, σ(A0 ) = ∅ and (R(λ, A0 )f )(x) = e−λx
x
eλy f (y) dy
0
(λ ∈ C, f ∈ C0 (0, 1]).
Let B : D(A0 ) → C0 (0, 1] be given by (Bf )(x) :=
α f (x) x
(x > 0),
(Bf )(0) := 0.
Let g ∈ C0 (0, 1], f := R(0, A)g. Then x α |(Bf )(x)| = g(y) dy ≤ α g ∞ . x 0 Thus BR(0, A0 ) ≤ α < 1. Now Proposition 3.11.12 implies that A = A0 + B is resolvent positive.
3.12. COMPLEX INVERSION AND UMD-SPACES
197
It remains to show that A is not the generator of a C0 -semigroup. One can easily check that for all λ ∈ C one has λ ∈ ρ(A) and (R(λ, A)g)(x)
x e−λx xα y −α eλy g(y) dy 0 x = xα (x − t)−α g(x − t)e−λt dt
=
0
(g ∈ C0 (0, 1]).
Suppose that A generates a C0 -semigroup T . Then
∞
(R(λ, A)g)(x) =
e−λt (T (t)g)(x) dt
0
for sufficiently large λ. It follows from the uniqueness theorem (Theorem 1.7.3) that xα (x − t)−α g(x − t) (x ≥ t), (T (t)g)(x) = 0 (x < t). This does not define a bounded operator on C0 (0, 1].
3.12 Complex Inversion and UMD-spaces In this section, we apply the complex inversion formula for Laplace transforms (Theorem 2.3.4) to orbits of C0 -semigroups; i.e., to solutions of well-posed Cauchy problems. In general this produces a representation only of classical solutions in terms of the resolvent of A, but we shall see in Theorem 3.12.2 that there is a class of Banach spaces where the representation holds for mild solutions. Proposition 3.12.1. Let T be a C0 -semigroup on a Banach space X with generator A, and let ω > ω(T ) and t ≥ 0. Then 1 k→∞ 2π
k
T (t)x = lim
e(ω+is)t R(ω + is, A)x ds
−k
for all x ∈ D(A). Proof. Replacing T (t) by e−αt T (t) where ω(T ) < α < ω, we may assume that ω(T ) < 0 < ω. Let x ∈ D(A) and define F (t) = T (t)x − x. Then F is differentiable with F (t) = T (t)Ax. Since F is bounded, F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X). The Laplace-Stieltjes transform of F is (λ) = R(λ, A)Ax. dF
198
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
By Theorem 2.3.4, 1 k→∞ 2π
k
R(ω + is, A)Ax ds ω + is 1 x (ω+is)t = lim e R(ω + is, A)x − ds k→∞ 2π −k ω + is k 1 = lim e(ω+is)t R(ω + is, A)x ds − x, k→∞ 2π −k
T (t)x − x =
lim
e(ω+is)t
−k k
where we have used a standard contour integral. For f ∈ L2 (R, X) and 0 < ε < R, let (HεR f )(t) := where
1 π
ε≤|t−s|≤R
f (s) ds = (ψεR ∗ f )(t) t−s
⎧ ⎨1 ψεR (t) := πt ⎩0
(t ∈ R),
if ε ≤ |t| ≤ R, otherwise.
Then HεR ∈ L(L2 (R, X)), since ψεR ∈ L1 (R, X) (see Proposition 1.3.2). The Banach space X is said to be a UMD-space if Hf := lim HεR f ε↓0 R→∞
exists in L2 (R, X) for each f ∈ L2 (R, X). Then by the Banach-Steinhaus theorem, H is a bounded linear operator, known as the Hilbert transform, on L2 (R, X). When f (t) = χ[a,b] (t)x, then Hf exists in L2 (R, X). Since the step functions are dense in L2 (R, X), it follows that X is a UMD-space if sup0<ε
ω(T ) and t > 0. Then 1 T (t)x = lim k→∞ 2π for all x ∈ X.
k
−k
e(ω+is)t R(ω + is, A)x ds
3.12. COMPLEX INVERSION AND UMD-SPACES
199
Proof. Replacing T (t) by e−ωt T (t), we may assume that ω(T ) < 0 = ω. For k > 0 and t ∈ R, define k 1 Tk (t) := eist R(is, A) ds, 2π −k k 1 Sk (t) := eist R(is, A)2 ds. 2π −k Since Tk (t)x → T (t)x for all x ∈ D(A) (Proposition 3.12.1) and D(A) is dense, it suffices to show that sup Tk (t) < ∞ k
for each t > 0. Integration by parts gives " 1 1 ! ikt e R(ik, A) − e−ikt R(−ik, A) + Sk (t). 2πit t ∞ Since R(±ik, A) ≤ 0 T (s) ds < ∞, it suffices to show that Tk (t) =
sup Sk (t) < ∞. k
∗
Since X is reflexive, T is strongly continuous (Corollary 3.3.9 and Proposition 3.3.14). Let x ∈ X, x∗ ∈ X ∗ and t ∈ R. Using Fubini’s theorem, x, Tk (t)∗ x∗ =
1 2π
=
1 2π
=
k
∞
eist e−isr x, T (r)∗ x∗ dr ds
−k 0 ∞ ik(t−r)
e
0
lim
ε↓0 R→∞
− e−ik(t−r) x, T (r)∗ x∗ dr i(t − r)
" 1 ! ikt e x, HεR (fk )(t) − e−ikt x, HεR (f−k )(t) , 2i
e−iar T (r)∗ x∗ fa (r) := 0
where
(r ≥ 0), (r < 0).
It follows that Tk (t)∗ x∗ =
" 1 ! ikt e H(fk )(t) − e−ikt H(f−k )(t) 2i
t-a.e.,
where H is the Hilbert transform on L2 (R, X ∗ ). Hence,
∞ −∞
∗ ∗ 2
Tk (t) x dt
1/2
H
( fk 2 + f−k 2 ) 2 ≤ M H x∗ , ≤
200
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
∞ where M := ( 0 T (s) 2 ds)1/2 < ∞. For x ∈ X and x∗ ∈ X ∗ , Fubini’s theorem gives k ∞ 1 Sk (t)x, x∗ = eist R(is, A)e−isr T (r)x, x∗ dr ds 2π −k 0 ∞1 k 2 1 = eis(t−r) R(is, A)T (r)x ds, x∗ dr 2π −k 0 ∞ = T (r)x, Tk (t − r)∗ x∗ dr. 0
Now the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality gives ∞ 1/2 ∗ 2 |Sk (t)x, x | ≤
T (r)x dr 0 2
∞ 0
∗ ∗ 2
1/2
Tk (t − r) x || dr
≤ M H x x∗ . Thus,
Sk (t) ≤ M 2 H .
Example 3.12.3. Theorem 3.12.2 is not valid if the assumption that X is a UMDspace is omitted. Let X := L1 (R) and T be the C0 -semigroup of invertible isometries on X defined by (T (t)f )(r) := f (t + r) (t ≥ 0, r ∈ R). Let 1 Tk (t) := 2π
k
A routine calculation shows that (Tk (t)f ) (r) =
e(1+is)t R(1 + is, A) ds.
−k
1 π
∞
−∞
f (r + s + t)φk,t (s) ds,
⎧ −s ⎨ e sin(ks) φk,t (s) := s ⎩0
where
Hence,
Tk (t) = φk,t 1
∞
=
−s
e −t
≥ e−1
1 0
(s ≥ −t), (s < −t).
sin(ks) s ds
| sin(ks)| ds = e−1 s
k 0
| sin s| ds → ∞ s
as k → ∞. Thus, {Tk (t) : k ≥ 0} is not uniformly bounded and therefore not strongly convergent on X.
3.13. NORM-CONTINUOUS SEMIGROUPS AND HILBERT SPACES
201
3.13 Norm-continuous Semigroups and Hilbert Spaces In this section, we shall consider C0 -semigroups T = (T (t))t≥0 which are normcontinuous for t > 0 . This class contains all holomorphic C0 -semigroups, including many examples arising from differential operators. In general, there is no known characterization of such semigroups in terms of the generator and resolvent, but there is a simple characterization in the case of Hilbert spaces. Proposition 3.13.1. Let T be a C0 -semigroup on a Banach space X with generator A, and suppose that T is norm-continuous for t > 0. Let ω > ω(T ). Then R(ω + is, A) → 0 as |s| → ∞. Proof. Since T : (0, ∞) → L(X) is norm-continuous,
∞
R(ω + is, A) =
e−(ω+is)t T (t) dt
0
as an L(X)-valued Bochner integral. Let H(t) := e−ωt T (t) if t > 0, and H(t) := 0 if t < 0. Then H ∈ L1 (R, L(X)), and R(ω + is, A) = (FH)(s). The result follows from the Riemann-Lebesgue lemma (Theorem 1.8.1). It follows from Neumann series expansions (Corollary B.3) that if R(ω + is, A) → 0 as |s| → ∞, then for any real a, {λ ∈ σ(A) : Re λ ≥ a} is bounded, and R(α + is, A) → 0, uniformly for α > a, as |s| → ∞. The converse of Proposition 3.13.1 does not hold in general, but we will now prove that it is true when X is a Hilbert space. Theorem 3.13.2. Let T be a C0 -semigroup on a Hilbert space X with generator A. Let ω > ω(T ), and suppose that R(ω + is, A) → 0 as |s| → ∞. Then T is norm-continuous for t > 0. Proof. Replacing T (t) by e−ωt T (t), we may assume that ω(T ) < 0 = ω. Let x ∈ D(A) and F (t) := t2 T (t)x. Then F is differentiable and F (t) = 2tT (t)x + t2 T (t)Ax. Hence F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X) with Laplace-Stieltjes transform (λ) dF
= = =
d d2 (R(λ, A)x) + 2 (R(λ, A)Ax) dλ dλ 2R(λ, A)2 x + 2R(λ, A)3 Ax 2λR(λ, A)3 x.
−2
By Theorem 2.3.4, 1 k→∞ π
t2 T (t)x = lim
k
−k
eist R(is, A)3 x ds.
(3.84)
202
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
! ∞ "1/2 Let M :=
T (t) 2 dt < ∞. Given ε > 0, there exists N such that 0
R(is, A) < ε/4M 2 whenever |s| > N . For k > N , t, t0 ≥ 0 and y ∈ X, ! ist " e − eist0 R(is, A)3 x dsy N ≤|s|≤k X ≤ 2
R(is, A)2 x R(is, A)∗ y ds N ≤|s|≤k
∞ 1/2 ∞ 1/2 ε 2 ∗ 2
R(is, A)x
ds
R(is, A) y
ds 2M 2 −∞ −∞ ∞ 1/2 ∞ 1/2 πε 2 ∗ 2 =
T (r)x
dr
T (r) y
dr M2 0 0 ≤ πε x y , ≤
where (·|·)X denotes the inner product on X and we have used the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality and Plancherel’s theorem for Hilbert spaces (Theorem 1.8.2). Hence,
! ist "
e − eist0 R(is, A)3 x ds ≤ πε x .
N ≤|s|≤k
It follows from (3.84) that
2
t T (t)x − t20 T (t0 )x ≤ ε x + 2N x sup eist − eist0 sup R(is, A) 3 , π s∈R |s|≤N so
2
2
t T (t) − t2 T (t0 ) ≤ ε + 2N |t − t0 | 0 π
This shows that
∞ 0
3
T (r) dr
.
lim sup t2 T (t) − t20 T (t0 ) ≤ ε. t→t0
Since ε > 0 is arbitrary, t → t2 T (t) is norm-continuous, and the result is proved.
3.14 The Second Order Cauchy Problem Let A be a closed operator on a Banach problem ⎧ ⎪ ⎨u (t) P 2 (x, y) u(0) ⎪ ⎩ u (0)
space X. Given x, y ∈ X we consider the = Au(t) (t ≥ 0) = x, = y.
3.14. THE SECOND ORDER CAUCHY PROBLEM
203
A classical solution of P 2 (x, y) is a function u ∈ C 2 (R+ , X) such that u(t) ∈ D(A) for all t ≥ 0 and P 2 (x, y) holds. A mild solution is a function u ∈ C(R+ , X) such that t
s
t
u(r) dr ds = 0
0
0
(t − s)u(s) ds ∈ D(A)
and
u(t) = x + ty + A 0
t
(t − s)u(s) ds
(3.85)
for all t ≥ 0. If u is a classical solution, then integrating P 2 (x, y) twice shows that u is a mild solution. Conversely, if u is a mild solution and u ∈ C 2 (R+ , X), then u is a classical solution. This follows from (3.85) and the fact that A is closed. Proposition 3.14.1. Let u ∈ C(R+ , X) with abs(u) < ∞. Let ω > max{abs(u), 0}. Then u is a mild solution of P 2 (x, y) if and only if u ˆ(λ) ∈ D(A) and λx + y = (λ2 − A)ˆ u(λ)
(3.86)
for all λ > ω. Proof. There exists M ≥ 0 such that v(t) ≤ M eωt (t ≥ 0), where v(t) := t u(s) ds. Taking Laplace transforms, Corollary 1.7.6 shows that (3.85) holds if 0 and only if ∞ t u ˆ(λ) −λt = e v(s) ds dt ∈ D(A) λ2 0 0 and u ˆ(λ) =
x y u ˆ(λ) + +A 2 λ λ2 λ
for all λ > ω.
Now let u ∈ C(R+ , X). Assume that abs(u) < ∞, ω > max{abs(u), 0} and (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A). Then Proposition 3.14.1 shows that u is a mild solution of P 2 (x, y) if and only if u ˆ(λ) = λR(λ2 , A)x + R(λ2 , A)y (λ > ω). (3.87) This relation will lead us to consider operators A such that λR(λ2 , A) is a Laplace transform. Definition 3.14.2. A strongly continuous function Cos : R+ → L(X) is called a cosine function if Cos(0) = I and 2 Cos(t) Cos(s) = Cos(t + s) + Cos(t − s) Lemma 3.14.3. Let Cos be a cosine function. a) ω(Cos) < ∞. b) Cos(t) Cos(s) = Cos(s) Cos(t) for all s, t ≥ 0.
(t ≥ s ≥ 0).
(3.88)
204
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
c) Define Cos(−t) = Cos(t) for t ≥ 0. Then Cos is strongly continuous on R, and 2 Cos(t) Cos(s) = Cos(t + s) + Cos(t − s) (s, t ∈ R). (3.89) Proof. a) By the uniform boundedness principle, M := sup Cos(s) < ∞. 0≤s≤2
Choose ω > 0 such that 2 Cos(1) e−ω + e−2ω ≤ 1. We claim that Cos(t) ≤ M eωt (t ≥ 0). This is certainly true for t ∈ [0, 2]. Assume that it holds for t ∈ [0, n], where n ∈ N, n ≥ 2. We claim that it holds for t ∈ [0, n + 1]. Let t ∈ (n − 1, n]. Then
Cos(t + 1) = 2 Cos(t) Cos(1) − Cos(t − 1)
≤ 2 Cos(1) M eωt + M eω(t−1) ! " = 2 Cos(1) e−ω + e−2ω M eω(t+1) ≤ M eω(t+1) . b) Let t ≥ 0. Replacing s and t by t/2 in (3.88) gives Cos(t) = 2 Cos(t/2)2 −I. A simple induction shows that, for each n ≥ 1, Cos(t) is a polynomial in Cos(t/2n ), so they commute. Assume that Cos(t) commutes with Cos(rt/2n ) for r = 1, . . . , k, for some k ≥ 1. Since (k + 1)t kt t (k − 1)t Cos = 2 Cos Cos − Cos , 2n 2n 2n 2n it follows that Cos(t) commutes with Cos((k + 1)t/2n ). By induction, Cos(t) commutes with Cos(rt)/2n for all integers r, n ≥ 1. Now b) holds by strong continuity of Cos. c) This follows easily from b). We will frequently consider a cosine function to be extended to R as in Lemma 3.14.3 c) without further notice. In what follows, the Laplace integrals of operator-valued functions are interpreted as in Sections 1.4 and 1.5. Proposition 3.14.4. Let Cos : R+ → L(X) be strongly continuous. The following assertions are equivalent: (i) Cos is a cosine function. (ii) One has abs(Cos) < ∞, and there exist ω > max{abs(Cos), 0} and an operator A such that (ω 2 , ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and ∞ λR(λ2 , A) = e−λt Cos(t) dt (λ > ω). (3.90) 0
3.14. THE SECOND ORDER CAUCHY PROBLEM
205
In that case, we call A the generator of the cosine function Cos. Proof. We extend Cos to an even function on R. Let ω > max{0, abs(Cos)}. Then for λ, μ > ω with λ = μ, one has ∞ ∞ ! " 2 e−λt e−μs (Cos(t + s) + Cos(t − s)) ds dt = 2 μQ(λ) − λQ(μ) , 2 μ −λ 0 0 (3.91) ∞ where Q(λ) := 0 e−λt Cos(t) dt. In fact, 0
∞
∞
e−λt e−μs (Cos(t + s) + Cos(t − s)) ds dt ∞ ∞ t −λt −μ(r−t) −μ(t−r) = e e Cos(r) dr + e Cos(r) dr dt 0
0
∞
= 0
e−μr
t r
0
∞
0
e(μ−λ)t dt Cos(r) dr +
−∞ ∞
e−λt
0
0
e−μ(t−r) Cos(r) dr dt
−∞
t
+ e−λt e−μ(t−r) Cos(r) dr dt 0 0 ∞ = e−μr (μ − λ)−1 (e(μ−λ)r − 1) Cos(r) dr 0
∞
∞
∞
Cos(r) dr + e−(λ+μ)t dt eμr Cos(r) dr −∞ 0 0 r ∞ " 1 ! 1 −μr Q(λ) − Q(μ) + e Cos(r) dr μ−λ λ+μ 0 ∞ 1 + e−(λ+μ)r eμr Cos(r) dr λ+μ 0 " " 1 ! 1 ! Q(λ) − Q(μ) + Q(μ) + Q(λ) μ−λ λ+μ ! " 2 μQ(λ) − λQ(μ) . 2 2 μ −λ +
=
= =
−(λ+μ)t
e
μr
dt e
Now assume that Q(λ) = λR(λ2 , A) (λ > ω). Then μ2
! " 2 R(λ2 , A) − R(μ2 , A) μQ(λ) − λQ(μ) = 2λμ 2 −λ μ2 − λ2 = 2λμR(λ2 , A)R(μ2 , A) ∞ ∞ −λt = 2 e Cos(t) dt e−μs Cos(s) ds. 0
0
Now (3.91) implies by the Uniqueness Theorem 1.7.3 that Cos(t + s) + Cos(t − s) = 2 Cos(t) Cos(s) for all s, t ∈ R+ .
(3.92)
206
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Conversely, assume that Cos is a cosine function. By Lemma 3.14.3, (3.92) holds, and by (3.91), ∞ ∞ ! " 1 μQ(λ) − λQ(μ) = e−λt e−μs Cos(t) Cos(s) dt ds μ2 − λ2 0 0 = Q(λ)Q(μ). √ Let R(λ) := √1λ Q( λ) for λ > ω 2 . Then R(λ)R(μ)
= = =
√ 1 √ √ √ Q( λ)Q( μ) λ μ √ √ √ 1 1 √ √ √ μ Q( λ) − λ Q( μ) λ μ μ−λ " 1 ! R(λ) − R(μ) (λ, μ > ω 2 ). μ−λ
Thus, {R(λ) : λ > ω 2 } is a pseudo-resolvent. If R(λ)x = 0 for all λ > ω2 , then by the Uniqueness Theorem, Cos(t)x = 0 for all t ∈ R+ . Since Cos(0) = I, this implies that x = 0. By Proposition B.6, there exists an operator A such that (ω 2 , ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and ∞ 2 2 λR(λ , A) = λR(λ ) = Q(λ) = e−λt Cos(t) dt 0
for all λ > ω. Let Cos be a cosine function on X with generator A. The sine function Sin : R → L(X) associated with Cos is defined by t Sin(t) := Cos(s) ds (t ∈ R). (3.93) 0
t
This means that Sin(t)x = 0 Cos(s)x ds (x ∈ X), where the integral is a Bochner integral. Then Sin is an odd function satisfying the functional equation t+s 2 Sin(t) Sin(s) = Sin(r) dr (t, s ∈ R). (3.94) t−s
This follows from integrating (3.89) twice. The following functional equation is also useful: Sin(t + s) = Cos(s) Sin(t) + Sin(s) Cos(t)
(t, s ∈ R).
To see this, differentiate (3.94) to obtain 2 Sin(t) Cos(s) = Sin(t + s) + Sin(t − s).
(3.95)
3.14. THE SECOND ORDER CAUCHY PROBLEM
207
Interchanging s and t gives 2 Sin(s) Cos(t) = Sin(s + t) + Sin(s − t). Since Sin is odd, adding these two equations gives (3.95). Moreover, we deduce from (3.90) that ∞ e−λt Sin(t) dt (λ > max{ω(Cos), 0}). R(λ2 , A) = 0
We collect some further properties of a cosine function Cos and its relations with the generator A, and the associated sine function Sin. Proposition 3.14.5. The following assertions hold: t t a) 0 (t − s) Cos(s)x ds ∈ D(A) and A 0 (t − s) Cos(s)x ds = Cos(t)x − x for all x ∈ X, t ∈ R. b) If x ∈ D(A), then Cos(t)x, Sin(t)x ∈ D(A) and A Cos(t)x = Cos(t)Ax, A Sin(t)x = Sin(t)Ax for all t ∈ R. t c) Let x, y ∈ X. Then x ∈ D(A) and Ax = y if and only if 0 (t−s) Cos(s)y ds = Cos(t)x − x for all t ∈ R. ' ( d) D(A) = x ∈X : limt↓0 t22 (Cos(t)x−x) exists and Ax = limt↓0 t22 (Cos(t)x−x). e) A is densely defined. f) For all x ∈ X, s, t ∈ R, one has Sin(t) Sin(s)x ∈ D(A) and A Sin(t) Sin(s)x =
1 2
(Cos(t + s)x − Cos(t − s)x) .
Proof. a) It follows from Proposition 3.14.1 that Cos(·)x is a mild solution of P 2 (x, 0). This implies a) for t ≥ 0. It follows for t < 0 since Cos is even. b) Let μ ∈ ρ(A). It follows from Proposition 3.1.5 that R(μ, A) Cos(t) = Cos(t)R(μ, A). This clearly implies b) (see Proposition B.7). t c) Assume that 0 (t − s) Cos(s)y ds = Cos(t)x − x (t ≥ 0). Taking Laplace transforms, we obtain 1 x R(λ2 , A)y = λR(λ2 , A)x − λ λ
(λ > max{ω(Cos), 0}).
Hence, x ∈ D(A) and Ax = y. The converse follows from a) and b). d) Let x ∈ D(A), Ax = y. It follows from c) that 2 2 t (Cos(t)x − x) − y = (t − s) Cos(s)y ds − y t2 t2 0 ! " 2 t = 2 (t − s) Cos(s)y − y ds → 0 as t ↓ 0, t 0
208
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
since Cos(t)y → y as t ↓ 0. Conversely, let x, y ∈ X with limt↓0 t22 (Cos(t)x−x) = y. Then by a), 2 t 2 A 2 (t − s) Cos(s)x ds = 2 (Cos(t)x − x) → y as t ↓ 0. t 0 t t Since t22 0 (t − s) Cos(s)x ds → x as t ↓ 0 and since A is closed, it follows that x ∈ D(A) and Ax = y. t e) Since x = limt↓0 t22 0 (t − s) Cos(s)x ds for all x ∈ X, it follows from a) that D(A) = X. f) This follows from (3.94) and a). Using the functional equation (3.88), one sees that a cosine function necessarily has non-negative exponential type. More precisely, the following holds. Proposition 3.14.6. a) Let Cos be a bounded cosine function and x ∈ X. If limt→∞ Cos(t)x = 0, then x = 0. b) In particular, ω(Cos) ≥ 0 for each cosine function Cos. Proof. a) Since Cos is bounded, it follows from the assumption that x = lim (Cos(2t)x + x) = lim 2(Cos(t))2 x = 0. t→∞
t→∞
It is natural to transform the second order problem into a first order system. Let A be an operator on X. Consider the operator A on X × X given by D(A) := D(A) × X, x 0 I x y A := = . y A 0 y Ax
(3.96)
Here, X × X is considered with the norm (x, y) X×X = x X + y X . Let λ ∈ C such that λ2 ∈ ρ(A). Then one easily verifies that λ ∈ ρ(A) and λ ∈ ρ(−A) and λR(λ2 , A) R(λ2 , A) R(λ, A) = , (3.97) AR(λ2 , A) λR(λ2 , A) λR(λ2 , A) −R(λ2 , A) R(λ, −A) = . (3.98) −AR(λ2 , A) λR(λ2 , A) Using this we can prove the following theorem. Theorem 3.14.7. The operator A generates a cosine function Cos on X if and only if A generates a once integrated semigroup S on X × X. In that case, S is given by t Sin(t) Sin(s) ds 0 S(t) = , (3.99) Cos(t) − I Sin(t) t where Sin(t) = 0 Cos(s) ds.
3.14. THE SECOND ORDER CAUCHY PROBLEM
209
Proof. Assume that A generates a cosine function Cos. Then ∞ 2 2 AR(λ , A)/λ = λR(λ , A) − I/λ = e−λt (Cos(t) − I) dt. 0
It follows from (3.97) that ∞ e−λt S(t) dt = R(λ, A)/λ
(λ > ω(Cos)).
0
Thus, S is a once integrated semigroup and A is its generator. Conversely, assume that A generates a once integrated semigroup. Then R(λ, A)/λ and AR(λ2 , A)/λ = λR(λ2 , A) − I/λ is a Laplace transform. ∞hence −λt Since 1/λ = 0 e dt, λR(λ2 , A) is also a Laplace transform; i.e., A is the generator of a cosine function. Corollary 3.14.8. Let A be the generator of a cosine function Cos and let Sin be the associated sine function. Let x, y ∈ X and u(t) := Cos(t)x + Sin(t)y
(t ≥ 0).
Then u is the unique mild solution of P 2 (x, y). Proof. It follows from (3.87) that u is a mild solution. Let v be another one and define t w(t) := (t − s)(u(s) − v(s)) ds. 0
w(t) Then w is a classical solution of P (0, 0). Consider the function φ(t) := . w (t) Then φ is a classical solution of the homogeneous Cauchy problem associated with A with initial value φ(0) = 0. It follows from Lemma 3.2.9 that φ ≡ 0. 2
Let A be a bounded operator. Then Cos(t) :=
∞ t2n n A (2n)! n=0
3 defines a continuous function from R+ into L(X), and for λ > A one has ∞ ∞ ∞ t2n e−λt Cos(t) dt = e−λt dt An (2n)! 0 0 n=0 ∞ An 2n+1 λ n=0 −1 1 A = I− 2 λ λ
=
= λR(λ2 , A).
210
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Thus, Cos is a cosine function and A is its generator. As a consequence of Theorem 3.14.7, we may characterize cosine functions with bounded generators as follows. Corollary 3.14.9. The following assertions are equivalent: (i) The operator A generates a C0 -semigroup on X × X. (ii) A generates a cosine function Cos such that limt↓0 Cos(t) − I = 0. (iii) A is bounded. Proof. (i) ⇒ (ii): If A generates a C0 -semigroup, then limt↓0 S(t) = 0. Now (ii) follows from (3.99). (ii) ⇒ (iii): The Abelian Theorem 4.1.2 implies that limλ↓0 λ2 R(λ2 , A)−I = 0. Hence, λ2 R(λ2 , A) is invertible for large λ. Consequently, D(A) = X. (iii) ⇒ (i): If A is bounded, then A is also bounded. We now deduce a simple perturbation result which will be considerably improved in Corollary 3.14.13. Corollary 3.14.10. Let A be the generator of a cosine function and let B ∈ L(X). Then A + B generates a cosine function. Proof. Consider the operator
B :=
0 B
0 0
on X × X. Then B(X × X) ⊂ {0} × X ⊂ D(A). It follows from Corollary 3.10.5 0 I that A + B = generates a once integrated semigroup. Now the A+B 0 claim follows from Theorem 3.14.7. We have seen that A does not generate a C0 -semigroup on X × X unless A is bounded. However, a semigroup exists on a natural “phase space”. Theorem 3.14.11. The following assertions are equivalent: (i) The operator A generates a cosine function. (ii) There exists a Banach space V such that D(A) → V → X and such that the part B of A in V × X generates a C0 -semigroup. In that case, the Banach space V is uniquely determined by (ii). We call V × X the phase space associated with A. Moreover, one has Sin(·)y ∈ C(R, V ) for all y ∈ X, Cos(·)x ∈ C 1 (R, X) ∩ C(R, V ) for all x ∈ V , Sin(·)x ∈ C(R, D(A)) for all x ∈ V , and B generates a C0 -group J on V × X given by Cos(t) Sin(t) Cos(t) Sin(t) J (t) = = (t ∈ R), (3.100) Cos (t) Cos(t) A Sin(t) Cos(t) where Sin is the sine function associated with Cos, and Cos (t)x := A Sin(t)x (x ∈ V ).
d dt
Cos(t)x =
3.14. THE SECOND ORDER CAUCHY PROBLEM
211
Here, V × X is a Banach space for the norm (x, y) V ×X := x V + y X . Note that the operator B on V × X is defined as follows: D(B) = D(A) × V, x 0 I x y B = = . y A 0 y Ax Proof of Theorem 3.14.11. (i) ⇒ (ii): Assume that A generates a cosine function. Then A generates a once integrated semigroup on X ×X (Theorem 3.14.7). By the Sandwich Theorem 3.10.4, there exists a Banach space Z such that D(A) → Z → X × X and such that the part B of A in Z generates a C0 -semigroup J . Define V := {x ∈ X : (x, 0) ∈ Z} with norm x V := (x, 0) Z . Then Z = V ×X. In fact, let (x, y) ∈ Z. Since (0, y) ∈ D(A) ⊂ Z, it follows that (x, 0) = (x, y) − (0, y) ∈ Z. Hence, x ∈ V and (x, y) ∈ V × X. The converse inclusion is obvious. Since Z is complete and Z → X × X, it follows that V is complete. It follows from the closed graph theorem that the embedding y → (0, y) from X into Z is continuous. So there exists β > 0 such that (0, y) Z ≤ β y X (y ∈ X). Thus,
(x, y) Z ≤ (x, 0) Z + (0, y) Z ≤ x V + β y X . Now it follows from the closed graph theorem that (x, y) V ×X := x V + y X defines a norm on V × X which is equivalent to · Z . Thus, (ii) is proved. (ii) ⇒ (i): Suppose that V is a Banach space such that D(A) → V → X and such that B generates a C0 -semigroup J on V × X. It follows from the Sandwich Theorem 3.10.4 that A generates a once integrated semigroup S. Moreover, S(t)z =
0
t
J (s)z ds for all z ∈ V × X, t ≥ 0.
In particular, S(·)z ∈ C(R+ , D(A) × V ) ∩ C 1 (R+ , V × X) for all z ∈ V × X. By Theorem 3.14.7, the operator A generates a cosine function Cos and S is given by (3.99). Since Sin is odd and Cos is even, this implies that Sin(·)y ∈ C(R, V ) for all y ∈ X, Cos(·)x ∈ C 1 (R, X) ∩ C(R, V ) and Sin(·)x ∈ C(R, D(A)) for all x ∈ V and that J is given by the first matrix in (3.100) for t ≥ 0. In order to prove uniqueness of V , we show that V is equal to the space V := {x ∈ X : Sin(·)x ∈ C([0, 1], D(A))} . Note that V is a Banach space for the norm
x V = x X + sup A Sin(s)x X , 0≤s≤1
and we show that this norm is equivalent to · V . Since V is completely described by the operator A, this proves uniqueness.
212
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
As we noted above, one has V ⊂ V . It follows from the closed graph theorem that the injection is continuous. Next, we show that x V ≤ c x V for all x ∈ V and some constant c ≥ 0. First, since Sin(·)y ∈ C(R, V ) we note that, by the closed graph theorem again,
Sin(t)y V ≤ c1 y X
(3.101)
for all y ∈ X, 0 ≤ t ≤ 2 and some constant c1 ≥ 0. Let x ∈ V . Then by (3.101) and Proposition 3.14.5 f),
x V
2
1
1
= (x − Cos(t)x) dt + Sin(2)x
2 0 2 V
2
1 1
≤
Sin(2)x V + (x − Cos(t)x) dt
2 2 0
≤ c1 x X + sup x − Cos(t)x V
V
0≤t≤2
≤ c1 x X + sup Cos(t + s)x − Cos(t − s)x V 0≤t≤1 0≤s≤1
= c1 x X + 2 sup A Sin(t) Sin(s)x V 0≤t≤1 0≤s≤1
≤ c1 x X + 2c1 sup A Sin(s)x X 0≤s≤1
≤ 2c1 x V . We have shown that the norms · V and · V are equivalent on V . It remains to show that V ⊂ V . Let x ∈ V . Proposition 3.14.5 b) implies that Cos(1)x ∈ V . Since 2 Sin(t) Cos(1)x = Sin(1 + t)x − Sin(1 − t)x (by differentiation of (3.94)), it follows that Sin(·)x ∈ C([0, 2], D(A)). Since the function is odd, one has Sin(·)x ∈ C([−2, 2], D(A)). We have to show that x ∈ V . Since Sin(t)x ∈ V , it suffices to show that limt↓0 1t Sin(t)x − x V = 0. By (3.94), we have
A Sin(s) 1 Sin(t)x − x
t X
s+t
1
= (A Sin(r)x − A Sin(s)x) dr
→0 2t s−t X as t ↓ 0, uniformly for s ∈ [0, 1]. This completes the proof of uniqueness of V . Finally, we show that J extends to a C0 -group. We have seen that the semigroup J is given by (3.100), and we can extend J to R by the same formulae. For λ sufficiently large, ∞ R(λ, A)z = e−λt J (t)z dt 0
3.14. THE SECOND ORDER CAUCHY PROBLEM
213
for z ∈ V × X. Since Sin is odd and Cos is even, it follows from (3.98) that R(λ, −A)z =
0
∞
e−λt J (−t)z dt.
This shows that J defined by (3.100) is a C0 -group on V × X and its generator is the part B of A in V × X. The phase space can be computed in many concrete cases (see Section 7.2 and Examples 3.14.15 and 3.14.16). The phase space is also important in order to obtain classical solutions of the Cauchy problem of second order. Corollary 3.14.12. Let A be the generator of a cosine function Cos on X. Denote the associated phase space by V × X, and the corresponding sine function by Sin. Let x ∈ D(A), y ∈ V . Then u(t) := Cos(t)x + Sin(t)y defines a classical solution of P 2 (x, y). Proof. Since y ∈ V , one has Cos(·)y ∈ C 1 (R, X), and hence Sin(·)y ∈ C 2 (R, X). Since x ∈ D(A), it follows from Proposition 3.14.5 c) that Cos(·)x ∈ C 2 (R, X). Thus, u ∈ C 2 (R, X). Since u is a mild solution and A is closed, it follows that u is a classical solution. The following perturbation result improves Corollary 3.14.10. It will be most useful for applications to elliptic operators given in Chapter 7. Corollary 3.14.13. Let A be the generator of a cosine function with phase space V × X. Let B ∈ L(V, X). Then A + B generates a cosine function with the same phase space. 0 I Proof. The operator A = on V × X with domain D(A) × V generates A 0 0 0 a C0 -semigroup on V × X. Since B = ∈ L(V × X), it follows from B 0 0 I Corollary 3.5.6 that = A + B generates a C0 -semigroup on V × X. A+B 0 It follows from Theorem 3.14.11 that A + B generates a cosine function. The following corollary will have useful applications to hyperbolic equations in Chapter 7. Corollary 3.14.14. Let A be the generator of a cosine function on X with phase space V × X. Then the part AV of A in V generates a cosine function on V with phase space D(A) × V .
214
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
0 I Proof. The operator A = on V × X with domain D(A) = D(A) × V A 0 generates a C0 -semigroup on V × X. Hence the part G of A in D(A) also generates a C0 -semigroup on D(A) × V (see the remarks preceding Proposition 3.10.3). Note that D(G) = {(x, y) ∈ D(A) × V : (y, Ax) ∈ D(A) × V } = D(A) × D(AV ). Moreover, we have the continuous embeddings D(AV ) → D(A) → V . Now replacing X by V and V by D(A) in Theorem 3.14.11 we conclude that AV generates a cosine function on V with phase space D(A) × V . Next, we give two examples where the phase space can be determined easily. Example 3.14.15. Let B be the generator of a C0 -group U on X. Then A := B 2 generates a cosine function Cos on X given by Cos(t) :=
1 (U (t) + U (−t)) 2
(t ∈ R).
The phase space is given by D(B) × X, where D(B) carries the graph norm. Proof. Let M, ω ∈ R such that U (t) ≤ M eω|t| (t ∈ R). Let λ > ω. Then λ ∈ ρ(B) ∩ ρ(−B) and (λ2 − A) = (λ − B)(λ + B). Hence, λ2 ∈ ρ(A) and λR(λ2 , A)
−λR(λ, B)R(−λ, B) 1 = (R(λ, B) − R(−λ, B)) 2 1 ∞ −λt = e (U (t) + U (−t)) dt 2 ∞0 = e−λt Cos(t) dt.
=
0
This shows that Cos is a cosine function with generator A. For x ∈ D(B) one has Cos (t)x = 12 (BU (t)x − BU (−t)x). Thus, (3.100) defines a strongly continuous, exponentially bounded function J : R+ → L(D(B) × X) whose Laplace transform is the restriction of R(λ, A) to D(B) × X, by (3.97). Thus, J is a C0 -semigroup whose generator is the part of A in D(B) × X. So D(B) × X is the phase space, by Theorem 3.14.11. Example 3.14.16. Let A be a selfadjoint operator on a Hilbert space H. Assume that A is bounded above; i.e., (Ax|x)H ≤ ω x 2H for all x ∈ D(A) and some ω ∈ R. Then A generates a cosine function. Proof. By the Spectral Theorem B.13, we can assume that H = L2 (Ω, μ), Af = mf , D(A) = {f ∈ H : mf ∈ H}, where m : Ω → R is a measurable function. Moreover, the boundedness assumption implies that m(y) ≤ ω for μ-almost all y ∈ Ω.
3.14. THE SECOND ORDER CAUCHY PROBLEM
215
3 First case: Assume that m ≤ 0 a.e. Let q(y) := i −m(y), Bf := qf , D(B) := {f ∈ H : qf ∈ H}. Then B generates the C0 -group U given by U (t)f := etq f . Since B 2 = A, it follows from the preceding example that A generates a cosine function Cos. Moreover, (Cos(t)f )(y)
1 ((U (t) + U (−t)) f )(y) 2 √ 1 it√−m(y) = e + e−it −m(y) f (y) 2 3 = cos(t −m(y))f (y) (t ∈ R, f ∈ H, y ∈ Ω).
=
Second case: When m ≤ ω a.e., we can write m = m1 + m2 where m1 ≤ 0, 0 ≤ m2 ≤ ω. Then A = A1 + B where A1 f := m1 f, D(A1 ) = D(A) and Bf := m2 f defines a bounded operator. It follows from Corollary 3.14.10 and the first case that A generates a cosine function. Next, we show that there is always a simple way to go from the second order equation to the first order equation. Theorem 3.14.17. Let A be the generator of a cosine function Cos. Then A generates a holomorphic C0 -semigroup T of angle π/2. We give two different proofs of this theorem. The first uses the characterization theorem for holomorphic semigroups. However, it does not give the best possible angle. First proof. Let M, ω ≥ 0 such that Cos(t) ≤ M eωt (t ≥ 0). Then by holomorphic continuation (Proposition B.5) for Re λ > ω one has λ2 ∈ ρ(A) and
∞
M 2 −λt
λR(λ , A) = e Cos(t) dt
≤ Re λ − ω . 0 Let ω1 := 2ω 2 . Let√μ ∈ C such that Re μ > ω1 . Write μ = reiθ , where −π/2 < θ < π/2, and let λ := reiθ/2 . Then 4 4 4 √ θ √ cos θ + 1 r cos θ ω1 Re λ = r cos = r ≥ ≥ = ω. 2 2 2 2 Hence, μ = λ2 ∈ ρ(A) and
μR(μ, A) ≤ |λ|
√ M M r =√ Re λ − ω r cos(θ/2) − ω
= ≤
if
√1 2
−
ω √ r
≥
1 √ ; 2 2
i.e., if r ≥ 8ω 2 .
M √ cos(θ/2) − ω/ r √ M ≤ M2 2 1 ω √ − √ r 2
216
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
√ We have shown that μ ∈ ρ(A) and μR(μ, A) ≤ M 2 2 whenever Re μ > ω1 and |μ| ≥ 8ω 2 . By Corollary 3.7.17, this implies that A generates a holomorphic semigroup T . Since D(A) is dense, T is a C0 -semigroup. The second proof has the advantage of giving a formula which allows one to compute the semigroup T from the cosine function Cos. In fact, we will prove the Weierstrass formula
∞
T (t)x = 0
2
e−s /4t √ Cos(s)x ds πt
(t > 0).
(3.102)
In the context of Example 3.14.15, this formula was established in Corollary 3.7.15. Second proof of Theorem 3.14.17. Define T by (3.102). Then T (t) ∈ L(X) and T (·)x ∈ C ∞ ((0, ∞), X) √ for all x ∈ X. Let x ∈ X. We show that limt↓0 T (t)x = x. In fact, putting s = r t gives
∞
T (t)x = 0
e−r √
2
/4
π
√ Cos(r t)x dr → x
as t ↓ 0
√ √ by the dominated convergence theorem, since Cos(r t)x → x, Cos(r t) ≤ 2 ∞ M eωr for all 0 < t < 1, for some M and ω, and √1π 0 e−r /4 dr = 1. Let λ > ω. Then by Lemma 1.6.7,
∞
e−λt T (t)x dt =
0
∞
0 ∞ = =
0
∞
2
e−s /4t e−λt √ dt Cos(s)x ds πt
√ 1 √ e− λs Cos(s)x ds λ 0 R(λ, A)x.
It follows from Definition 3.1.8 that T is a C0 -semigroup and A is its generator. In order to show that T is holomorphic of angle π/2, we define ∞ 2 1 T (z)x = √ e−s /4z Cos(s)x ds (Re z > 0). πz 0 Then T : C+ → L(X) is holomorphic. Let θ ∈ (0, π2 ). According to Definition 3.7.1, it remains to show that sup T (z) < ∞.
z∈Σθ |z|≤1
Let z ∈ Σθ , |z| ≤ 1. Let u := Re z/|z|2 . Then
−s2 /4z
2 2 2
e Cos(s) ≤ M e−us /4 eωs = M e−u(s−2ω/u) /4 eω /u .
3.15. SINE FUNCTIONS AND REAL CHARACTERIZATION Hence,
217
1
−s2 /4z
T (z) = √ e Cos(s) ds
2 πz R 2 2 1 M √ ≤ 3 e−u(s−2ω/u) /4 ds eω /u 2 π |z| R 2 2 1 M 1 = 3 √ e−s ds √ eω /u u |z| π R = ≤
M |z| ω2 |z|2 / Re z 3 √ e |z| Re z 2 2 M M √ eω |z|/ cos θ ≤ √ eω / cos θ . cos θ cos θ
This proves the claim. The converse of Theorem 3.14.17 is not true: a generator of a holomorphic C0 -semigroup does not necessarily generate a cosine function. Indeed, generators of cosine functions satisfy a very restrictive spectral condition. Proposition 3.14.18. Let A be the generator of a cosine function Cos. Then there exists ω > 0 such that the spectrum σ(A) of A is contained in the parabola {ξ + iη : η ∈ R, ξ ≤ ω 2 − η 2 /4ω 2 }. Proof. There exist ω, M > 0 such that ∞
Cos(t) ≤ M eωt
(t ≥ 0).
Since λR(λ2 , A) = 0 e−λt Cos(t) dt for λ > ω, it follows from holomorphic continuation (Proposition B.5) that λ2 ∈ ρ(A) whenever Re λ > ω. It is easy to see that ' 2 ( η2 2 λ : λ ∈ C, Re λ > ω ⊃ ξ + iη : η ∈ R, ξ > ω − . 4ω 2 Example 3.14.19. Let H := L2 (R), m(s) := −|s| + is (s ∈ R), (Af )(s) := m(s)f (s),
D(A) := {f ∈ H : mf ∈ H}.
Then A generates a holomorphic C0 -semigroup on H. Since σ(A) = {−s ± is : s ∈ R+ }, the spectrum of A is not contained in any parabola as described in Proposition 3.14.18. Thus, A does not generate a cosine function.
3.15 Sine Functions and Real Characterization In this section, we consider sine functions. These include the integrals of cosine functions as in Section 3.14, and elementary properties of sine functions will be
218
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
used to prove the generation theorem for cosine functions which is analogous to the Hille-Yosida theorem. We shall also establish some useful perturbation results. Examples of sine functions occurring in applications will be given in the Notes of Chapter 7 and in Chapter 8. Definition 3.15.1. An operator A on X generates a sine function if there exist ω, M ≥ 0 and a strongly continuous function Sin : R+ → L(X) such that the following properties are satisfied:
t
a) 0 Sin(s) ds ≤ M eωt (t ≥ 0). b) λ2 ∈ ρ(A) whenever λ > ω. ∞ c) R(λ2 , A) = 0 e−λt Sin(t) dt (λ > ω). We then call Sin the sine function generated by A. If A generates a cosine function Cos, then ∞ t 1 ∞ −λt R(λ2 , A) = e Cos(t) dt = e−λt Cos(s) ds dt λ 0 0 0 for λ > ω(Cos). Thus A generates the sine function Sin given by Sin(t)x := t Cos(s)x ds. In other words, the definition is consistent with the previous notion 0 of Section 3.14. Next, we establish some relations between a sine function and its generator. Proposition 3.15.2. Let Sin be a sine function and A be its generator. Then the following hold: t a) 0 (t − s) Sin(s)x ds ∈ D(A) and A 0
t
(t − s) Sin(s)x ds = Sin(t)x − tx
(3.103)
for all x ∈ X. b) If x ∈ D(A), then Sin(t)x ∈ D(A) and A Sin(t)x = Sin(t)Ax for all t ≥ 0. c) Let x, y ∈ X. Then x ∈ D(A) and Ax = y if and only if
t 0
(t − s) Sin(s)y ds = Sin(t)x − tx
(t ≥ 0).
(3.104)
Proof. a) It follows from (3.87) that S(·)x is a mild solution of P 2 (0, x). This is precisely the claim. b) This follows from Proposition 3.1.5 and Proposition B.7.
3.15. SINE FUNCTIONS AND REAL CHARACTERIZATION
219
c) Let x, y ∈ X such that (3.104) holds. Taking Laplace transforms on both sides gives 1 x R(λ2 , A)y = R(λ2 , A)x − 2 . λ2 λ Hence, x ∈ D(A) and y = λ2 x − (λ2 − A)x = Ax. The converse implication follows from a) and b). We now prove the characterization theorem for generators of cosine functions. It is mainly of theoretical interest since the condition (3.105) seems to be difficult to verify in concrete cases. Theorem 3.15.3. Let A be a densely defined operator on a Banach space X. The following assertions are equivalent: (i) A is the generator of a cosine function. (ii) There exist ω, M ≥ 0 such that (ω 2 , ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and ! "(k) 1
(λ − ω)k+1 λR(λ2 , A)
≤M k!
(3.105)
for all λ > ω and k ∈ N0 . Proof. (i) ⇒ (ii): Assume that A generates a cosine function Cos. There exist M ≥ ∞ 0, ω ≥ 0 such that Cos(t) ≤ M eωt . Since λR(λ2 , A)x = 0 e−λt Cos(t)x dt for all λ > ω and x ∈ X, the claim follows from Theorem 2.4.1. (ii) ⇒ (i): Assume that (ii) is satisfied. By Theorem 2.4.1, there exists a function S : R+ → L(X) satisfying
S(t + h) − S(t) ≤ M
t+h
(t, h ≥ 0)
eωs ds
(3.106)
t
such that R(λ2 , A) =
∞
e−λt S(t) dt
(λ > ω).
0
Thus, S is a sine function and A is its generator. Let x ∈ D(A). Then by Proposition 3.15.2, one has S(t)x − tx =
0
t
(t − s)S(s)Ax ds
(t ≥ 0).
It follows that S(·)x ∈ C 1 (R+ , X). Since D(A) is dense in X, it follows from d Lemma 3.3.3 that S(·)x ∈ C 1 (R+ , X) for all x ∈ X. Let C(t)x := dt S(t)x (x ∈ X, t ≥ 0). It follows that C(t) is linear and by (3.106) that
C(t) ≤ M eωt
(t ≥ 0).
220
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Integration by parts shows that λR(λ2 , A)x =
∞
e−λt C(t)x dt
(λ > ω)
0
for all x ∈ X. Thus, C is a cosine function and A is its generator. Now we resume our investigation of sine functions. The following result parallels Example 3.14.15. Proposition 3.15.4. Let A be an operator such that A and −A generate once integrated semigroups. Then A2 generates a sine function. Moreover, the sine function is exponentially bounded if both integrated semigroups are. Proof. There exists ω ≥ 0 such that (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) ∩ ρ(−A) and λ1 (λ − A)−1 and 1 (λ + A)−1 are Laplace transforms (in the sense of Definition 3.1.4). Thus, λ (λ2 − A2 )−1 = (λ − A)−1 (λ + A)−1 exists for λ > ω, and by the resolvent equation we have (λ2 − A2 )−1 =
" 1 ! (λ + A)−1 + (λ − A)−1 . 2λ
Thus, (λ2 − A2 )−1 is a Laplace transform. This shows that A2 generates a sine function Sin given by Sin(t) = 12 (S+ (t) + S− (t)), where S+ and S− are the once integrated semigroups generated by A and −A, respectively. The next example shows that the generator of a sine function is not necessarily densely defined. Example 3.15.5. Let B be the generator of the translation group U on L1 (R), given by (U (t)f )(x) = f (x − t). Then B ∗ and −B ∗ generate once integrated semigroups on L∞ (R) = L1 (R)∗ (see Corollary 3.3.7 and Example 3.3.10). By Proposition ! " 3.15.4, (B ∗ )2 generates a sine function. However, D (B ∗ )2 ⊂ D(B ∗ ) = W 1,∞ (R), which is not dense in L∞ (R) (cf. also Theorem 4.3.18). Next, we establish a perturbation result for sine functions. Our proof is completely different from the corresponding results on cosine functions (Corollary 3.14.10 and Corollary 3.14.13). Theorem 3.15.6. Let A be the generator of an exponentially bounded sine function and let B ∈ L(D(A), X). Then A + B generates an exponentially bounded sine function. Proof. Denote by Sin the sine function generated by A and let M, ω ≥ 0 such that
Sin(t) ≤ M eωt (t ≥ 0). The idea of the proof is to solve the integral equation t S B (t) = Sin(t) + S B (s)B Sin(t − s) ds. (3.107) 0
3.15. SINE FUNCTIONS AND REAL CHARACTERIZATION
221
First, we remark that Sin(t)x ∈ D(A) for all t ≥ 0, x ∈ X. In fact by Proposition t 3.15.2, 0 (t − s) Sin(t)x ds ∈ D(A) for all t > 0. Differentiating twice we obtain that Sin(t)x ∈ D(A). Let α > 0. Multiplying (3.107) by e−(ω+α)t , we obtain the equivalent integral equation t U (t) = e−(ω+α)t Sin(t) + U (s)Be−(ω+α)(t−s) Sin(t − s) ds. (3.108) 0
Consider now the Banach space C := {V : R+ → L(X) : V is strongly continuous and bounded} with norm V := supt≥0 V (t) . Suppose from now on that α > M B . Then t (JV )(t) := V (s)Be−(ω+α)(t−s) Sin(t − s) ds 0
defines an operator J on C with norm J L(C) ≤ (3.108) can now be written in the form
M B α
< 1. The integral equation
(I − J)U = W with W (t) := e−(ω+α)t Sin(t). Hence, it has a unique solution U (given by (I − J)−1 W ). Therefore S B (t) := e(ω+α)t U (t) defines a solution of (3.107), which is exponentially bounded. ∞ For λ > ω + α, let Q(λ) := 0 e−λt S B (t) dt. Then ∞ Q(λ) − R(λ2 , A) = e−λt (S B (t) − Sin(t)) dt 0 ∞ t −λt = e S B (s)B Sin(t − s) ds dt 0 0 ∞ t = e−λs S B (s)Be−λ(t−s) Sin(t − s) ds dt 0 0 ∞ ∞ = e−λs S B (s)Be−λ(t−s) Sin(t − s) dt ds 0 ∞ s ∞ = e−λs S B (s)B e−λt Sin(t) dt ds 0
0
= Q(λ)BR(λ2 , A). Hence, Q(λ)(I − BR(λ2 , A)) = R(λ2 , A). The operator I − BR(λ2 , A) is invertible since
∞
2 −λt
BR(λ , A) ≤ B e Sin(t) dt
0
≤
B M (λ − ω)−1 < 1.
222
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Since (λ2 − A − B) = (I − BR(λ2 , A))(λ2 − A), it follows that λ2 ∈ ρ(A + B) and R(λ2 , A + B)
= R(λ2 , A)(I − BR(λ2 , A))−1 = Q(λ) ∞ = e−λt S B (t) dt 0
for all λ > ω + α. This shows that S B is a sine function and A + B is its generator.
3.16 Square Root Reduction for Cosine Functions Let B be the generator of a C0 -group and let ω ∈ R. Then by Corollary 3.14.10 and Example 3.14.15, the operator A := B 2 + ω generates a cosine function. The aim of this section is to establish the following remarkable converse result: If A is the generator of a cosine function on a UMD-space X, then there exist a generator B of a C0 -group and a number ω ≥ 0 such that A = B 2 + ω (see Corollary 3.16.8). By the results of Section 3.8, there is a square root B of A − ω for ω sufficiently large. We will show that B and −B always generate integrated semigroups, but the UMD-property is needed in order to obtain a C0 -group. We recall the following lemma which is easy to prove. Lemma 3.16.1. Let B be a closed operator on X, and A := B 2 . Let λ ∈ C. If λ2 ∈ ρ(A), then λ ∈ ρ(±B) and R(λ, B)
=
(λ + B)R(λ2 , A),
R(λ, −B)
=
(λ − B)R(λ2 , A).
Proposition 3.16.2. Let B be a closed operator. Assume that A := B 2 generates a cosine function. Then B and −B generate exponentially bounded once integrated semigroups. Proof. Denote by Cos and Sin the cosine and the sine functions associated with A. t Recall from Proposition 3.14.5 a) that 0 Sin(s)x ds ∈ D(A) and A 0
t
Sin(s)x ds = Cos(t)x − x
for all x ∈ X, t ≥ 0. Define V+ (t)x := Sin(t)x + B
t
Sin(s)x ds 0
(t ≥ 0).
(3.109)
3.16. SQUARE ROOT REDUCTION FOR COSINE FUNCTIONS Let λ ∈ ρ(A). Then t B Sin(s)x ds 0
223
t
= BR(λ, A)(λ − A) Sin(s)x ds 0 t = λBR(λ, A) Sin(s)x ds − BR(λ, A)(Cos(t)x − x) 0
for all x ∈ X. Since BR(λ, A) is bounded, it follows that V+ is strongly continuous and exponentially bounded. Moreover, for large λ > 0, ∞ 1 e−λt V+ (t)x dt = R(λ2 , A)x + BR(λ2 , A)x λ 0 1 1 = (λ + B)R(λ2 , A)x = R(λ, B)x, (3.110) λ λ by the preceding lemma. We have shown that V+ is a once integrated semigroup and B is its generator. Replacing B by −B shows that −B also generates a once integrated semigroup. Now we assume that B is a closed operator such that B 2 generates a cosine function. We want to investigate conditions under which this implies that B generates a C0 -group. Here is a characterization in terms of the behaviour of the sine function on D(B), which is considered as a Banach space for the graph norm. Proposition 3.16.3. Let A be the generator of a cosine function Cos with associated sine function Sin. Assume that B is a closed operator such that B 2 = A. Then the following are equivalent: (i) B generates a C0 -group U . (ii) For all x ∈ X, Sin(t)x ∈ D(B) for almost all t ∈ (0, ∞). (iii) Sin(·)x ∈ C(R, D(B)) for all x ∈ X. (iv) The phase space of Cos is D(B) × X. In that case, the group U is given by U (t)x = Cos(t)x + B Sin(t)x
(3.111)
for all t ∈ R, x ∈ X. For the proof we need the following results which are of independent interest. Lemma 3.16.4. Let U : R → L(X) be a mapping such that a) U (t + s) = U (t)U (s) (t, s ∈ R), b) U (0) = I, and
224
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
c) U (·)x is measurable for all x ∈ X. Then U is strongly continuous. Proof. a) We show that M := sups∈[1,2] U (s) < ∞. Otherwise, by the uniform boundedness principle, there exist x ∈ X, sn ∈ [1, 2] such that U (sn )x ≥ n (n ∈ N). Considering a subsequence if necessary, we can and do assume that limn→∞ sn =: γ exists. Since U (·)x is measurable, there exists a constant M1 ≥ 0 and a measurable set F ⊂ [0, γ] with Lebesgue measure m(F ) > γ/2 such that supt∈F U (t)x ≤ M1 . Let ' ( En := (sn − t) : t ∈ F ∩ [0, sn ] . Then m(En ) ≥ γ/2 for large n ∈ N. Now for t ∈ F ∩ [0, sn ] we have n ≤ U (sn )x
≤ U (sn − t) U (t)x
≤ U (sn − t) M1 . Hence, U (s) ≥ n/M1 for all s ∈ En . Let E = k∈N n≥k En . Then m(E) ≥ γ/2 and U (s) = ∞ for all s ∈ E. This is a contradiction. b) By the group property and a), one has for each t ∈ R,
U (s) =
sup s∈[t+1,t+2]
U (s − t)U (t) ≤ M U (t)
sup
(t ∈ R).
s∈[t+1,t+2]
Thus U is locally bounded. It follows that for each x ∈ X, U (·)x is locally Bochner integrable. c) Let x ∈ X, t0 ∈ R. Then U (t0 )x = U (t)U (t0 − t)x and U (t0 + h)x = U (t)U (t0 + h − t)x
(t ∈ [1, 2], h ∈ R).
Hence,
U (t0 )x − U (t0 + h)x
=
2
1
≤
M
→
0
! " U (t) U (t0 − t)x − U (t0 + h − t)x dt
1
2
U (t0 − t)x − U (t0 + h − t)x dt as h → 0,
using b) and the continuity of shifts on L1 (R, X). Lemma 3.16.5. Let F ⊂ R be a Lebesgue measurable set such that F + F ⊂ F . If R \ F is a null set, then F = R.
3.16. SQUARE ROOT REDUCTION FOR COSINE FUNCTIONS
225
Proof. Assume that N := R \ F = ∅. Let a ∈ N . Then for x ∈ F , the assumption implies that a − x ∈ N (otherwise, a = x + (a − x) ∈ F + F ⊂ F ). We have shown that F ⊂ a − N , which is impossible since a − N is a null set. Proof of Proposition 3.16.3. Assume that (i) holds. One has 1 (U (t)x + U (−t)x) 2
Cos(t)x = and Sin(t)x =
1 2
t
(U (s) + U (−s))x ds. 0
It follows from Proposition 3.1.9 e) that Sin(t)x ∈ D(B) and B Sin(t)x
= =
" 1! U (t)x − x − (U (−t)x − x) 2 1 (U (t)x − U (−t)x). 2
This proves (3.111). We have seen in Example 3.14.15 that (i) implies (iv). Theorem 3.14.11 shows that (iv) implies (iii). The implication (iii) ⇒ (ii) is trivial. It remains to show that (ii) ⇒ (i). It is obvious that for μ ∈ ρ(B) one has R(μ, B)R(λ2 , A) = R(λ2 , A)R(μ, B)
(λ > ω(Cos)).
Thus, by Proposition 3.1.5 and Proposition B.7, x ∈ D(B) implies that Sin(t)x, Cos(t)x ∈ D(B) and B Sin(t)x = Sin(t)Bx,
B Cos(t)x = Cos(t)Bx.
Recall from (3.95) that Sin(t + s) = Cos(s) Sin(t) + Cos(t) Sin(s)
(t, s ∈ R).
(3.112)
Let x ∈ X and F := {t ∈ R : Sin(t)x ∈ D(B)}. By hypothesis, R \ F has Lebesgue measure zero. It follows from (3.112) that F + F ⊂ F . Now we conclude from Lemma 3.16.5 that F = R. Define U (t)x := Cos(t)x + B Sin(t)x for all x ∈ X, t ∈ R. Since B is closed, U (t) is also closed. Hence, U (t) ∈ L(X). If x ∈ D(B), then U (·)x is continuous. Since D(B) ⊃ D(A) which is dense, it follows that U (·)x is measurable for all x ∈ X (in fact, let x ∈ X, xn ∈ D(B) such that limn→∞ xn = x; then U (t)x = limn→∞ U (t)xn ). It remains to show the group property. Recall from Proposition 3.14.5 f) that Sin(t) Sin(s)x ∈ D(A) and A Sin(t) Sin(s)x =
" 1! Cos(t + s)x − Cos(t − s)x 2
(3.113)
226
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
for all t, s ∈ R, x ∈ X. Hence by (3.112), U (t)U (s) = Cos(t) Cos(s) + Cos(t)B Sin(s) + B Sin(t) Cos(s) + B Sin(t)B Sin(s) = Cos(t) Cos(s) + B Sin(t + s) + A Sin(t) Sin(s) 1 1 = (Cos(t + s) + Cos(t − s)) + B Sin(t + s) + (Cos(t + s) − Cos(t − s)) 2 2 = Cos(t + s) + B Sin(t + s) = U (t + s). It follows from Lemma 3.16.4 that U is a C0 -group. Since V+ (t) = t ≥ 0, where V+ is given by (3.109), we have by (3.110), ∞ ∞ e−λt U (t)x dt = λ e−λt V+ (t)x dt = R(λ, B)x 0
t 0
U (s) ds for
0
for large λ. This shows that B is the generator of U . We will show that condition (ii) of Proposition 3.16.3 is automatically satisfied if X is a UMD-space (as defined in Section 3.12), −A satisfies the hypotheses of Proposition 3.8.2, and B = i(−A)1/2 (as defined in Section 3.8). For this we need some preparation concerning the Hilbert transform. For ω ≥ 0 we define ∞ 1 −ω|t| Lω (R, X) := f ∈ Lloc (R, X) : f ω,∞ := ess sup e f (t) < ∞ . t∈R
Then L∞ ω (R, X) is a Banach space for the norm · ω,∞ . Lemma 3.16.6. Let X be a UMD-space and let 0 ≤ ω < c. For f ∈ L∞ ω (R, X) and ε > 0 define the continuous function Hεc f : R → X by (Hεc f )(t) =
|s|≥ε
e−c|s| f (t − s) ds. s
Then for each τ > 0, limε↓0 Hεc f =: H c f exists in L2 ((−τ, τ ), X). Hence, H c is a 2 bounded operator from L∞ ω (R, X) into L ((−τ, τ ), X) for each τ > 0. Proof. Let τ ≥ 1, 0 < ε ≤ 1, |t| ≤ τ . Denote by χ the characteristic function of [−τ − 1, τ + 1]. Then (Hεc f )(t)
= |s−t|≥ε
e−c|t−s| f (s) ds t−s
= h1ε (t) + h2ε (t) + h3ε (t),
3.16. SQUARE ROOT REDUCTION FOR COSINE FUNCTIONS where
h1ε (t)
h2ε (t)
|s−t|≥ε
e−c|t−s| − 1 χ(s)f (s) ds, t−s
|s|≥τ +1
e−c|t−s| f (s) ds. t−s
:=
h3 (t)
|s−t|≥ε
1 χ(s)f (s) ds, t−s
:=
:=
227
It is clear that h3 (t) ≤ c1 f ω,∞ for |t| ≤ τ , where c1 ≥ 0 is a constant. Next, observe that χf ∈ L2 (R, X). If ψ(t) := 1t (e−c|t| − 1), then ψ ∈ L2 (R) and h2ε is the convolution ((1 − χ(−ε,ε) )ψ) ∗ (χf ). It follows from Proposition 1.3.2 that h2ε converges uniformly on [−τ, τ ] to ψ ∗ (χf ) as ε ↓ 0. Finally, let H be the Hilbert transform on L2 (R, X) and HεR be as in Section 3.12. Then h1ε = πHεR (χf )|[−τ,τ ] for R > 2τ + 1. Hence, h1ε → πH(χf)|[−τ,τ ] in L2 ((−τ, τ ), X) as ε ↓ 0. Thus the first assertion is proved. The second now follows from the Banach-Steinhaus theorem. Now we are able to prove the main result. Theorem 3.16.7 (Fattorini). Let A be the generator of a cosine function on a UMDspace X. Assume that (0, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and supλ>0 λR(λ, A) < ∞. Define (−A)1/2 as in Proposition 3.8.2 and let B = i(−A)1/2 . Then B generates a C0 -group and B 2 = A. Proof. It is immediate from Proposition 3.8.2 that B 2 = A. We want to show condition (ii) of Proposition 3.16.3. Let c > ω > ω(Cos). For t > 0 and y ∈ D(A), Proposition 3.8.2 gives ∞ 1 B Sin(t)y = λ−1/2 R(λ, A) Sin(t)Ay dλ πi 0 = I1 (t)y + I2 (t)y, where I1 (t)y
:= =
1 πi 1 πi
c2
λ−1/2 R(λ, A) Sin(t)Ay dλ
0
0
c2
λ−1/2 (λR(λ, A) Sin(t)y − Sin(t)y) dλ
∞ 1 I2 (t)y := λ−1/2 R(λ, A) Sin(t)Ay dλ. πi c2 Since ω > ω(Cos), there exists M ≥ 0 such that Cos(s) ≤ M eωs (s ≥ 0). Consequently, Sin(s) ≤ M seωs (s ≥ 0) and
∞ √
∞ √
1 − λs
e Sin(s) Sin(t)Ay ds ≤ c1 e− λs seωs ds = c1 √
( λ − ω)2 ε 0 and
228
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
√ for all ε > 0, where c1 := M Sin(t)Ay . Since the function λ → λ−1/2 ( λ − ω)−2 is in L1 (c2 , ∞), and since ∞ √ R(λ, A) Sin(t)Ay = e− λs Sin(s) Sin(t)Ay ds, 0
we obtain from the dominated convergence theorem, ∞ ∞ √ 1 I2 (t)y = lim λ−1/2 e− λs Sin(s) Sin(t)Ay ds dλ. ε↓0 πi c2 ε Now we apply Fubini’s theorem and obtain ∞ −cs 2 e I2 (t)y = lim Sin(s) Sin(t)Ay ds. ε↓0 πi ε s By (3.113), this gives I2 (t)y
∞ −cs 1 e = lim (Cos(t + s) − Cos(t − s))y ds ε↓0 πi ε s i e−c|s| = lim Cos(t − s)y ds. ε↓0 π |s|≥ε s
At this point we use that X is a UMD-space, so that we can apply Lemma 3.16.6. We have shown that I2 (·)y = Hc (Cos(·)y) for y ∈ D(A). Let x ∈ X, and let yn ∈ D(A) such that limn→∞ yn = x. Then Cos(·)yn converges to Cos(·)x in 2 L∞ ω (R, X). It follows from Lemma 3.16.6 that I2 (·)yn converges in L ((−τ, τ ), X) as n → ∞ for all τ > 0. Considering a subsequence if necessary, we obtain that I2 (t)yn converges a.e. in X as n → ∞. Since I1 (t) is a bounded operator it follows that there exists a measurable subset F of R such that R\F has Lebesgue measure 0 and B Sin(t)yn converges in X as n → ∞ for all t ∈ F . Since B is closed, this implies that Sin(t)x ∈ D(B) for all t ∈ F . This finishes the proof. Now we obtain the following interesting characterization of generators of cosine functions on UMD-spaces. Corollary 3.16.8. Let A be an operator on a UMD-space. The following assertions are equivalent: (i) A generates a cosine function. (ii) There exist a generator B of a C0 -group and ω ≥ 0 such that A = B 2 + ω. Proof. (ii) ⇒ (i): This follows from Example 3.14.15 and Corollary 3.14.10. (i) ⇒ (ii): Assume that A generates a cosine function Cos. Then A generates a C0 -semigroup by Theorem 3.14.17. Hence, there exists ω ≥ 0 such that (ω, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and supλ>0 λR(λ, A − ω) < ∞. The operator A − ω is also the generator of
3.16. SQUARE ROOT REDUCTION FOR COSINE FUNCTIONS
229
a cosine function by Corollary 3.14.10. It follows from Theorem 3.16.7 that there exists a C0 -group with generator B such that A − ω = B 2 . We conclude this section with some remarks. First, we mention that, given an operator A, there may be infinitely many generators of groups whose square is A. We give an example. Example 3.16.9. Let X = l2 , and define A by ' ( D(A) := x = (xn )n∈N ∈ l2 : (n2 xn )n∈N ∈ l2 , (Ax)n
:=
−n2 xn .
Let (n )n∈N be an arbitrary sequence in {−1, 1}. Define B on X by Bx := (in nxn )n∈N with domain D(B) := {x : (nxn )n∈N ∈ l2 }. Then B generates the C0 -group U given by U (t)x := (ein nt xn )n∈N and B 2 = A. It should be mentioned that even if the generator A of a cosine function has a square root which generates a C0 -group there may be other square roots which do not generate C0 -groups. We give an example. Example 3.16.10. Let A be the generator of a cosine function on a Banach space X. Assume that A is unbounded. Then we know from Theorem 3.14.7 that the operator A on X × X given by D(A)
=
A =
D(A) × X, 0 I , A 0
does not generate a C0 -semigroup. However, the operator A2 is given by D(A2 ) A2
D(A) × D(A); A 0 = . 0 A
=
Thus, A2 generates a cosine function. If A has a square root which generates a C0 -group, then so does A2 , but this square root is different from A. There exists an example of a generator A of a cosine function on a Banach space X (which can even be chosen to be reflexive) such that A − ω = B 2 for each ω ≥ 0 and each generator B of a C0 -group. Of course in that case, X is not a UMD-space. We refer to [Fat85, Section III.8] for such examples.
230
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
It is interesting to observe that the question whether a square root reduction exists for a cosine function is equivalent to the existence of a boundary group for a certain holomorphic semigroup. To be more precise, let A be the generator of a cosine function. Then by Theorem 3.14.17, A generates a holomorphic C0 -semigroup T of angle π/2. Let ω > ω(T ). Then −(ω − A)1/2 generates a C0 -semigroup V (see Theorem 3.8.3). Now it follows from Corollary 3.9.10 that B := i(ω − A)1/2 generates a C0 -group if and only if V is a holomorphic semigroup of angle π/2 and V has a boundary group (in the sense of Proposition 3.9.1). This is not always the case (if X fails to have the UMD property) as we pointed out above. However, we know from Proposition 3.16.2 that V always has an integrated boundary group (in the sense explained in Theorem 3.9.13).
3.17 Notes Section 3.1 The characterization of mild solutions in terms of Laplace transforms given in Theorem 3.1.3 appeared in [Neu94]. It is at the heart of the theory and it may have been known for a long time. Another way to define mild solutions by approximation schemes (“bonnes solutions”) has been given by B´enilan, Crandall and Pazy [BCP88]; see also [BCP90]. This way is most important in non-linear theory where Laplace transforms have not yet been used effectively. The idea of defining semigroups and their generators directly by the property that the Laplace transform is a resolvent, is from [Are87b], but Theorem 3.1.7 is already contained in [DS59, Corollary VIII.1.16]. We should also mention the approach to semigroups by Laplace transforms given by Kisy´ nski [Kis76]. The characterization of generators in terms of well-posedness of the abstract Cauchy problem for classical solutions is contained in [Kre71]. Related results are contained in the lecture notes of van Casteren [Cas85]. Example 3.1.14 is taken from [Nag86, A-II, Example 1.4]. One may modify Theorem 3.1.12 by requiring a less restrictive existence assumption but a stronger uniqueness assumption by considering the Cauchy problem on a bounded interval [0, τ ]: u (t) = Au(t) (t ∈ [0, τ ]), C(τ ) u(0) = x. t As before, we call u ∈ C([0, τ ], X) a mild solution if 0 u(s) ds ∈ D(A) and u(t) − x = t A 0 u(s) ds for all t ∈ [0, τ ]. Then the following holds. Theorem 3.17.1. Let A be a closed operator, τ > 0. The following assertions are equivalent: (i) For all x ∈ X there exists a unique mild solution of C(τ ). (ii) The operator A generates a C0 -semigroup. Other results on the local problem were obtained by Lyubich [Lyu66], Sova [Sov68], Oharu [Oha71] and Sanekata [San75].
3.17. NOTES
231
Section 3.2 Integrated semigroups were introduced by Arendt in [Are84], [Are87a]. The systematic treatment based on techniques of Laplace transforms was developed by Arendt [Are87b], Neubrander [Neu88] and Kellermann [Kel86]. Theorem 3.2.13 is due to Arendt, Neubrander and Schlotterbeck [ANS92] and Lemma 3.2.14 to Arendt, El-Mennaoui and Keyantuo [AEK94]. The theory of integrated semigroups has been developed in many directions and we refer to the monographs of deLaubenfels [deL94] and Xiao and Liang [XL98] for further information. We do not aim to give an account of the many contributions, but we mention here a few extensions of the theory. First, one may consider α-times integrated semigroups for some α ∈ R+ ; i.e., the power k in Definition 3.2.1 is replaced by some α ≥ 0 (see [Hie91a]). This leads to sharper regularity results for the solution of the associated Cauchy problem than those which we have described. Moreover, a modification of the Real Representation Theorem 2.2.1 shows that if a C ∞ -function r : (0, ∞) → X satisfies
sup λα+1 r(n) (λ)/n! : λ > 0, n ∈ N ∪ {0} < ∞ for some α > 0, then there exists a H¨ older continuous function F of exponent α satisfying F (0) = 0 such that ∞
r(λ) = λα
e−λt F (t) dt
(λ > 0)
0
(see [Hie91b]). Integrated Volterra equations were considered by Arendt and Kellermann [AK89] and deLaubenfels [deL90]. Second order problems in integrated form have been developed by Kellermann and Hieber [KH89], Arendt and Kellermann [AK89] and Neubrander [Neu89a]. For integrated solutions of implicit differential equations, see the papers of Arendt and Favini [AF93] and Knuckles and Neubrander [KN94]. Concerning the general theory of degenerate differential equations in Banach spaces we refer to the monograph by Favini and Yagi [FY99]. Many years before integrated semigroups were studied, Lions [Lio60] introduced distribution semigroups. They have been further developed by Chazarain [Cha71] and Beals [Bea72] who also give applications to partial differential equations. Further information can be found for example in the monograph of Fattorini [Fat83]. In terms of integrated semigroups, Lions’s concept may now be described as follows: Let S be a k-times integrated semigroup on X. Denote by D(R+ ) the test functions on R with support in R+ . For ϕ ∈ D(R+ ) define the operator T ∈ L(X) by ∞ T (ϕ) := (−1)k ϕ(k) (t)S(t) dt. 0
Then T : D(R+ ) → L(X) is a mapping satisfying the semigroup property T (ϕ ∗ ψ) = T (ϕ)T (ψ). It turns out that T defined as above is a distribution semigroup of exponential type and that all distribution semigroups of exponential type as defined by Lions in [Lio60] are of this form (see [AK89] for a proof). More generally, arbitrary distribution semigroups are defined as mappings U : D(R+ ) → L(X) such that U (ϕ ∗ ψ) = U (ϕ)U (ψ)
232
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
and several other properties are satisfied. To each distribution semigroup one can associate a generator A. These distribution semigroups are equivalent to local integrated semigroups. More precisely, a closed operator A generates a distribution semigroup U if and only if there exists k ∈ N such that the integrated Cauchy problem (ACP )k+1 (see (3.20)) is well-posed on a bounded interval; i.e., A generates a local integrated semigroup of order k. The generators of local integrated semigroups can be completely characterized by spectral properties. See papers of Arendt, El-Mennaoui and Keyantuo [AEK94] or Okazawa and Tanaka [TanO90] for these and related results. These concepts have been extended further in a series of papers by Lumer [Lum90], [Lum92], [Lum94], [Lum97], Cioranescu and Lumer [CL94] and Lumer and Neubrander [LN99], [LN97], and in the monograph of Melnikova and Filinkov [MF01]. A further concept, namely regularized semigroups, had been developed by Da Prato [DaP66], and was rediscovered by Davies and Pang [DP87]. Regularized semigroups were extensively studied by deLaubenfels [deL94] and Miyadera and Tanaka [TM92], among many others and are now called C-semigroups, in general. Given a bounded operator C one says, in the language of Laplace transforms, that an operator A generates a Csemigroup if CR(λ, A) is a Laplace transform (see [HHN92]). Thus, by Proposition 3.2.7, the generator of a k-times integrated semigroup is the same as a R(μ, A)k -semigroup, where μ ∈ ρ(A). Note, however, that in contrast to the situation of integrated semigroups, the generator of a C-semigroup may have an empty resolvent set. Operators with empty resolvent set occur in particular in the context of Petrovskii correct systems of partial differential equations. Systems of this type can be treated by the theory of Csemigroups in a very efficient manner (see [HHN92]). Again, we refer to the monographs of deLaubenfels [deL94] and Xiao and Liang [XL98] for further information. Another concept, which leads to a generalization of generators of bounded semigroups and groups is the following. A k-times integrated semigroup S is called tempered if S(t) ≤ ctk (t ≥ 0) for some c ≥ 0. Arendt and Kellermann [AK89] showed that a densely defined operator A generates a k-times integrated tempered semigroup if and only if A generates a smooth distribution semigroup of order k as introduced by Balabane and Emami-Rad [BE79], [BE85]. Smooth distribution groups allow a spectral calculus similar to the one known for bounded groups, as shown by Balabane, Emami-Rad and Jazar [BEJ93] and Jazar [Jaz95]. It was established in [KH89] that perturbation theory for integrated semigroups is more complicated than for semigroups. We saw in Proposition 3.2.6 that perturbation by a scalar yields a quite complicated formula for the integrated semigroup. In general, generators of integrated semigroups are not even stable under bounded perturbations (in contrast to generators of C0 -semigoups, by Corollary 3.5.6). For instance, let A be the unbounded generator of a cosine function (see Section 3.14), A be the
operator given x −y by (3.96) and B be the bounded operator on X × X given by B = . Then y 0 A generates a once integrated semigroup, by Theorem 3.14.7. However, the range of μ − (A + B) is contained in D(A) × X for any μ ∈ C, so ρ(A + B) is empty and A + B does not generate a k-times integrated semigroup for any k ∈ N. One perturbation theorem for integrated semigroups can be found in Corollary 3.10.5, and we mention another one here. Using Theorem 3.2.8 and an argument similar to Proposition 3.11.12, Kaiser and Weis [KW03] have shown that A + B generates a
3.17. NOTES
233
(k + 2)-times integrated semigroup if A generates an exponentially bounded k-times integrated semigroup S and B : D(A) → X satisfies sup { BR(λ, A) : Re λ = ω} < 1 for some ω > ω(S). Finally, we mention that, more generally, instead of Cauchy problems involving a function and its derivatives at an instant of time, problems with memory may be considered. They lead to the theory of Volterra equations. Their solutions are governed by one-parameter families of operators, more general than semigroups or cosine functions. Vector-valued Laplace transforms also play a decisive role in this theory. We refer to the monograph of Pr¨ uss [Pr¨ u93] for a comprehensive presentation of Volterra equations. A study of regularized solutions of Volterra equations was initiated in [Liz00]. Section 3.3 The Hille-Yosida theorem (in its general form due to Hille, Yosida, Feller, Miyadera and Phillips) was the starting point of the subsequent development of the theory of semigroups. The classical approach of Yosida using what is now called the Yosida approximation and the classical method of Hille based on the convergence of the exponential formula T (t)x = limn→∞ (I − nt A)−n x can be found in many textbooks on semigroup theory (see, for example, those of Cl´ement et al. [CHA87], Davies [Dav80], [Dav07], Engel and Nagel [EN00], [EN06], Fattorini [Fat83], Goldstein [Gol85], Hille and Phillips [HP57], Kato [Kat66], Nagel et al. [Nag86], Pazy [Paz83] and Yosida [Yos80]). Hille and Phillips already mentioned explicitly on page 364 of [HP57] the problem of how to use Widder’s theorem in the proof of the Hille-Yosida theorem. The approach presented here based on the real representation theorem for Laplace transforms solves this problem. Our presentation follows the lines of Arendt [Are87b]. A different condition which is sufficient for an operator to generate a C0 -semigroup has been given by Gomilko [Gom99] and Shi and Feng [SF00]. This condition has the advantage of involving only the square of the resolvent and not higher powers. Theorem 3.17.2. Let A be a densely defined operator on a Banach space X and suppose that there exist K and ω such that σ(A) ⊂ {λ ∈ C : Re λ ≤ ω} and ∞ ∗ R(a + is, A)2 x, x∗ ds ≤ K x x
a−ω −∞ whenever a > ω, x ∈ X and x∗ ∈ X ∗ . Then A generates a C0 -semigroup T satisfying
T (t) ≤ M eωt (t ≥ 0) for some M . This theorem can be proved by using the Poisson representation of functions in a Hardy space on a half-plane to establish the conditions of the Hille-Yosida theorem. Alternatively, a complex inversion formula can be used to define tT (t)x when x ∈ D(A2 ) and then the operators T (t) extend by continuity to a C0 -semigroup. The converse of the theorem is true in Hilbert spaces. However, the derivative operator generates the C0 -group of translations on Lp (R), but it does not satisfy the hypotheses of Theorem 3.17.2 when p = 2. Proposition 3.3.8 appeared first in a paper of Kato [Kat59]. We mention here that Proposition 3.3.8 is not true if merely the Radon-Nikodym property is assumed instead of reflexivity (see [Are87a]). However, we have the following result [Are87b]. Proposition 3.17.3. Let X be a Banach space with the Radon-Nikodym property. Let A be an operator on X satisfying the Hille-Yosida condition (3.23). Then A generates a semigroup in the sense of Definition 3.2.5.
234
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
The sun-dual T of a C0 -semigroup T was already introduced by Hille and Phillips in [HP57]. Dual semigroups have been investigated systematically by Cl´ement, Dieckmann, Gyllenberg, Thieme and van Neerven. For a comprehensive treatment and precise references, see the monograph by van Neerven [Nee92]. Section 3.4 Dissipative operators and the Lumer-Phillips theorem are classical objects in semigroup theory. Many further results in this direction can be found in the textbooks listed in the Notes of the previous section. It is also possible to characterize generators of positive C0 -semigroups of contractions by a similar notion, namely dispersiveness and a range condition. Even more generally, the norm may be replaced by a “half-norm” as studied by Arendt, Chernoff and Kato [ACK82], Batty and Robinson [BR84] and Nagel et al. [Nag86, Section A-II.2]. If A is a densely defined dissipative operator and x ∈ D(A), then ReAx, x∗ ≤ 0 for all x∗ ∈ dN(x) (instead of merely some x∗ ∈ dN(x) as required by the definition). This is easy to see when A generates a contraction semigroup. For densely defined operators, it was proved in [Bat78]; see also [ACK82, Theorem 2.5]. A very interesting class of contraction semigroups is the class of Ornstein-Uhlenbeck semigroups which arises naturally in the study of stochastic processes. For a thorough study of this class of contraction semigroups, we refer to the book by Lorenzi and Bertoldi [LB07]. The Laplacian with Dirichlet boundary conditions is an easy example of an elliptic operator in divergence form. Generalizations of the arguments used in Example 3.4.7 lead to the theory of quadratic forms. For more information on this topic we refer to the books of Kato [Kat66], Dautray and Lions [DL90] and Davies [Dav80], [Dav95], and the survey article [Are04]. Section 3.5 Hille-Yosida operators were studied by Kato already in [Kat59]. Later, these operators were investigated systematically by Sinestrari [Sin85] and Da Prato and Sinestrari [DS87], where Theorem 3.5.2 was first proved. A proof of the Da Prato-Sinestrari Theorem 3.5.2 based on the theory of integrated semigroups was given by Kellermann and Hieber [KH89]. Theorem 3.5.2 may also be proved via the theory of non-linear semigroups, as shown by B´enilan, Crandall and Pazy [BCP88]. In fact, operators which are not densely defined are natural in the framework of the Crandall-Liggett-B´enilan theorem which corresponds to the Hille-Yosida theorem for non-linear operators. For a third, very different, approach using “abstract Sobolev towers”, see the work of Nagel and Sinestrari [NS94]. The renorming Lemma 3.5.4 can be found in Pazy’s book [Paz83] and the bounded perturbation Theorem 3.5.5 for Hille-Yosida operators is due to Kellermann and Hieber [KH89]. Section 3.6 The Trotter-Kato theorem is a classical result in semigroup theory. It is frequently proved with the help of the Hille-Yosida theorem (see, for example, [Paz83]). The proof which we give here is based on the approximation theorem for Laplace transforms from Section 1.7, and is due to Jun Xiao and Liang [XL00] who also proved a general Trotter-Kato approximation theorem for integrated semigroups after previous work by Lizama [Liz94] and Nicaise [Nic93]. For other variants of the Trotter-Kato theorem, we refer to Bobrowski’s survey article [Bob97b].
3.17. NOTES
235
Section 3.7 The monographs by Amann [Ama95] and Lunardi [Lun95] are specialized texts on holomorphic semigroups and parabolic problems. Much further information, in particular on maximal regularity, interpolation and extrapolation scales of Banach spaces as well as many applications to non-linear problems can be found there. Our proof of the characterization Theorem 3.7.11 uses only Laplace transform theory. Corollary 3.7.14 is taken from the lecture notes of Nagel et al. [Nag86]. The perturbation Theorem 3.7.25 is due to Desch and Schappacher [DS88] with a different proof. If A generates a C0 -semigroup on a reflexive space and B : D(A) → X is compact, then the estimate (3.49) holds (see [DS88]) or [EN00, p.179]). However, this is no longer true if X is not reflexive (see [Hes70] for an example). It was also shown in [DS88] (see also [AB06], [AB07], [DSS09]) that if A + B generates a C0 -semigroup for every B ∈ L(D(A), X) of rank 1, then A generates a holomorphic C0 -semigroup. Section 3.8 Fractional powers of sectorial operators are classical objects in semigroup theory, and they now have a very extensive theory (see [MS01] and [Haa06]). Theorem 3.8.1 and many further results in this direction can be found in the books of Amann [Ama95], Haase [Haa06] and others listed in the Notes on Section 3.3, and in the original papers of Balakrishnan [Bal60], Komatsu [Kom66] and others. The assumption that A is a generator is not essential in Theorem 3.8.3. If A is densely defined and B = −A satisfies the assumptions of Proposition 3.8.2, then −(−A)1/2 generates a bounded holomorphic C0 -semigroup; see for example, the books of Fattorini [Fat83] or Mart´ınez and Sanz [MS01]. For a sectorial operator B and Re z > 0, one may define B z to be the algebraic inverse of B −z . If A generates a bounded C0 -semigroup and 0 < α < 1, then −(−A)α generates a bounded holomorphic C0 -semigroup. Section 3.9 Boundary values of holomorphic C0 -semigroups already appeared in the book of Hille and Phillips [HP57]. The method which we use here is based on Laplace transform techniques. Theorem 3.9.4 was proved by H¨ ormander [H¨ or60], but our approach follows the lines of Arendt, El-Mennaoui and Hieber [AEH97]. Basic information on the Riemann-Liouville semigroup and on fractional integration is in [HP57]; the idea of using the transference principle in this context is in [AEH97]. Results similar to Theorem 3.9.13 were first obtained by Boyadzhiev and deLaubenfels [BdL93] and later improved by El-Mennaoui in [Elm92]. The proof of the implication (ii) ⇒ (i) of Theorem 3.9.13 follows the lines of [Elm92]. Corollary 3.9.14 is due to Hieber [Hie91a] with a different proof using techniques from Fourier multipliers; see also [Lan68] and [Sjo70]. Further results in this direction such as behaviour of the critical exponent k = n|1/2 − 1/p| in Lp (Rn ) and L1 (Rn ), results on more general types of operators such as pseudo-differential operators with symbol a of the form a(ξ) = |ξ|α for some α > 0 can be found in [Sjo70], [Hie91a] and in Chapter 8. For example, if 1 < p < ∞, then iΔp generates a k-times integrated semigroup on Lp (Rn ) if and only if k ≥ n|1/2 − 1/p|. Moreover, iΔ1 and iΔ∞ generate a k-times integrated semigroup on L1 (Rn ) and L∞ (Rn ), respectively, if and only if k > n/2. Further applications of boundaries of holomorphic semigroups are given by El-Mennaoui and Keyantuo, to Schr¨ odinger operators in [EK96a] and to the wave equation in [EK96b]. In particular, they show the remarkable result that the Schr¨ odinger operator iΔ on Lp (Ω), where Ω = (−π, π)n , with Dirichlet or Neumann boundary conditions, generates a k-times integrated group for k > n2 | 12 − p1 |, and that this constant is optimal.
236
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Section 3.10 In this section we follow Arendt, Neubrander and Schlotterbeck [ANS92]. Extensions to fractional integrated semigroups have been given by Keyantuo [Key95a]. The perturbation result Corollary 3.10.5 is due to Kellermann and Hieber [KH89]. Applications of the sandwich theorem to differential operators have been given in [Are91]. Section 3.11 Integrated semigroups were actually introduced first in the context of resolvent positive operators in [Are84]. Theorem 3.11.7 and Proposition 3.11.12 as well as Example 3.11.13 are from [Are87a]. Theorem 3.11.5 and Example 3.11.6 are taken from [Are87b]. Theorem 3.11.9 was proved by Arendt, Chernoff and Kato [ACK82]; it remains valid if X is an ordered Banach space with normal cone X+ which has non-empty interior. Theorem 3.11.10 is from [Are00], but our proof is different from the original one which is based on the construction of an intermediate Banach lattice where Theorem 3.5.2 can be applied. Theorem 3.11.8 is due to Arendt and B´enilan [AB92a]. It is no longer true on arbitrary Banach lattices: Grabosch and Nagel [GN89] showed that there exists a generator A of a positive C0 -semigroup such that D(A∗ ) is not a sublattice of X ∗ . Example 3.11.13 also works on Lp (0, 1) if 1 < p < ∞, but not on L1 (0, 1). In fact, the following result is due to W. Desch (unpublished). It can also be seen in the framework of Miyadera–Voigt perturbation theory (see [Voi89]). Theorem 3.17.4. Let A be the generator of a positive C0 -semigroup on a space X of the form L1 (Ω, μ). Let B : D(A) → X be linear and positive. If A + B is resolvent positive, then A + B generates a C0 -semigroup. The analogous result also holds if X is an arbitrary Banach lattice, but A generates a holomorphic, positive C0 -semigroup, as shown by Arendt and Rhandi [AR91]. The theory of resolvent positive operators has been developed further by Thieme [Thi98a] and [Thi98b], where in particular spectral theory and perturbation theory are studied. One may also study asymptotic behaviour. Assume that A is a resolvent positive operator generating a once integrated semigroup S. Then lim sup λR(λ, A) < ∞ λ→∞
if and only if 1 lim sup S(t) < ∞. t t↓0 Moreover, limt↓0 1t S(t) = I strongly if and only if limλ→∞ λR(λ, A) = I strongly (we refer to [Are87a, Proposition 6.9]). Of course, an important class of resolvent positive operators are generators of positive C0 -semigroups. In the spirit of this book, we have concentrated in this section on those results which are related to Laplace transform techniques. We refer to the book [Nag86] edited by Nagel for the general theory of positive semigroups. Finally, we should mention that there exist natural examples of operators which are not resolvent positive even though the resolvent exists and is positive on some interval [λ1 , λ2 ] where −∞ < λ1 < λ2 < ∞. Examples have been given by Greiner, Voigt and Wolff [GVW81] and Ulm [Ulm99]. Section 3.12 Theorem 3.12.2 and Example 3.12.3 are due to Driouich and El-Mennaoui [DE99]. Extensions to resolvent families associated with Volterra equations are given in [CL03] and [Haa08].
3.17. NOTES
237
The acronym UMD-space stands for “unconditional martingale differences”, reflecting the original probabilistic definition of this class of Banach spaces. Burkholder [Bur81] showed that the probabilistic property implies that the Hilbert transform is bounded on Lp (R, X) for 1 < p < ∞ and Bourgain [Bou83] established the converse. Every UMDspace is superreflexive (i.e., there is an equivalent norm which is uniformly convex), but there are uniformly convex spaces which are not UMD-spaces. These and other properties of UMD-spaces are discussed in the survey article [Fra86] by Rubio de Francia. The UMD-property has proved to be very important for the study of maximal regularity of solutions of inhomogeneous Cauchy problems. See, for example, [KW04], [Are04], [AB04]. Section 3.13 A C0 -semigroup T is said to be eventually norm-continuous if T is norm-continuous on (τ, ∞) for some τ ≥ 0. It was shown in the book of Hille and Phillips [HP57] that if T is eventually norm-continuous, then for any real a, {λ ∈ σ(A) : Re λ ≥ a} is compact. Theorem 3.13.2 was first proved by You [You92], but the simple proof given here is due to El-Mennaoui and Engel [EE94]. With minor modifications, the proof shows that if X is a Hilbert space and T (τ )R(ω + is, A)n → 0 as |s| → ∞ for some n ≥ 1 and τ ≥ 0 then T is norm-continuous for t > τ . Other characterizations of immediately and eventually norm-continuous semigroups on Hilbert space have been given by Blasco and Martinez [BM96] and Blake [Bla01]. The latter characterization does not explicitly involve any decay of the resolvent of A (see also [Ile07]). Goersmeyer and Weis [GW99] have proved that if T is a positive semigroup on an Lp -space and R(ω +is, A) → 0 as |s| → ∞, then T is norm-continuous for t > 0. On the other hand, M´ atrai [Mat08], and Chill and Tomilov [CT09], have constructed examples showing that Theorem 3.13.2 does not extend to all Banach spaces. Section 3.14 For further literature on cosine functions we refer to the monographs of Fattorini [Fat85] and Goldstein [Gol85] and the survey article of Bobrowski [Bob97b], and the references given there. Kellermann and Hieber [KH89] proved the relation between cosine functions and integrated semigroups (Theorem 3.14.7). Uniqueness of the phase space (in Theorem 3.14.11) is due to Kisy´ nski [Kis72]. Further information about the phase space may be found in the Appendix of [Haa07a]. Corollary 3.14.13 seems to be a natural limit for perturbation results of that type. It is shown in [AB06, Theorem 2.2] (and stated in [AB07, Theorem 5.9]) that if A + B generates a cosine function for every bounded operator B : D((ω − A)γ ) → X of rank 1, where γ > 1/2, then A is bounded on X. More general versions of well-posedness of the Cauchy problem of second order (k-times integrated cosine functions) are considered in [AK89] and, using a different approach, by Takenaka and Okazawa [TakO90]. Higher order problems are covered in [XL98]. Let X be a Hilbert space with inner product (·|·). The following result characterizes generators A of cosine functions X, up to choice of inner product, by a condition on the numerical range W (A) := {(Ax|x) : x ∈ X, x = 1} related to the spectral condition of Proposition 3.14.18. Here, part a) is due to Crouzeix [Cro04] who extended it to a remarkable piece of work on numerical range and functional calculus for matrices and operators on Hilbert space [Cro07], [Cro08]. Part b) is due to Haase [Haa06, Corollary 7.4.6].
238
3. CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Theorem 3.17.5. Let A be a densely defined operator on a Hilbert space X. a) If W (A) is contained in the parabola Πω := {ξ + iη : η ∈ R, ξ ≤ ω 2 − η 2 /4ω 2 } for some ω > 0 and there is at least one point in ρ(A) ∩ (C \ Πω ), then A generates a cosine function. b) If A generates a cosine function, then there is an equivalent scalar product on X with respect to which the numerical range of A is contained in Πω for some ω > 0. Section 3.15 Sine functions were introduced by Arendt and Kellermann [AK89] where in particular the perturbation result Theorem 3.15.6 is proved. Moreover, the following holds. Theorem 3.17.6. Let A be a densely defined operator which generates a sine function Sin satisfying lim supt↓0 1t Sin(t) < ∞. Then A generates a C0 -semigroup T . Moreover, T has a holomorphic extension to the right half-plane. The generation theorem for cosine functions (Theorem 3.15.3) is independently due to Da Prato and Giusti [DG67] and Sova [Sov66]. Section 3.16 Theorem 3.16.7 on square root reduction is due to Fattorini [Fat69]. At that time UMD-spaces had not been investigated and Fattorini formulated the result for Lp -spaces (1 < p < ∞). But he clearly pointed out that boundedness of the Hilbert transform is the crucial condition. Haase has given a different approach to Fattorini’s theorem via functional calculus [Haa07a], and he has shown that i(−A)1/2 generates a bounded C0 -group if A generates a bounded cosine function on a UMD-space [Haa09].
Part II
Tauberian Theorems and Cauchy Problems
Part II
241
Again we consider the guide-line of this book, the characteristic equation u ˆ(λ) = R(λ, A)x, where u is a solution of the Cauchy problem u (t) = Au(t) (CP ) u(0) = x,
(t ≥ 0),
and R(λ, A) is the resolvent of the operator A. The aim of this part is to study the asymptotic behaviour of the solution u(t) as t → ∞. In applications, one typically has some information about the spectral behaviour of A. This means that, in many cases, we know the Laplace transform u ˆ(λ) for Re λ > 0. This part is devoted to the problem of determining the relation between the asymptotic behaviour of u(t) as t → ∞ and that of u ˆ(λ) as λ ↓ 0. It contains two chapters. The first, Chapter 4, is devoted to the investigation of arbitrary functions; in Chapter 5 the asymptotic behaviour of solutions of (CP ) is investigated. The Abelian theorems given in Chapter 4 show that convergence of u(t) as t → ∞ implies convergence of λˆ u(λ) as λ ↓ 0. Much more interesting for the applications which we have in mind, are Tauberian theorems, which give statements about the converse implication. However, they do need additional hypotheses, socalled Tauberian conditions. Of particular importance are complex Tauberian theorems where the assumptions involve the behaviour of u ˆ(λ) for λ close to the imaginary axis. Indeed, assumptions of this kind are directly related to spectral properties of the operator via the characteristic equation. We not only consider convergence of functions but we also investigate their periodic behaviour. In fact, Chapter 4 contains an introduction to the theory of almost periodic and asymptotically almost periodic functions. The main results show that under suitable assumptions, countability of the spectrum implies asymptotic almost periodicity. In the second chapter of this part, Chapter 5, the results of Chapter 4 are applied to solutions of the Cauchy problem, and also a variety of new and special results are obtained. The most important framework is given by generators of C0 semigroups, but we also consider individual solutions in more general situations. This will be useful, for example, for the investigation of the heat equation with inhomogeneous boundary conditions which we give in Chapter 6. In the first three sections of Chapter 5 the diverse abscissas of Laplace transform of the semigroup are related to spectral properties. Indeed, it turns out that the relation is not simple, in general. However there are very satisfying results in special cases; for example on Hilbert spaces (Section 5.2) or for positive semigroups (Section 5.3); both are important for applications. The complex Tauberian theorems from Chapter 4 are applied to solutions of (CP ) in many different situations. Asymptotically almost periodic solutions
242
Part II
lead to splitting theorems which are considered in Section 5.4. Countability of the spectrum is a criterion for asymptotic periodicity. This is shown in Section 5.5 by exploiting the results of Chapter 4. Typically, one has to assume boundedness of the solution for these applications. This may be a difficult assumption to verify when the inhomogeneous Cauchy problem is considered, but we show that this is automatic if the underlying semigroup is holomorphic and a certain spectral condition of non-resonance is satisfied. This last topic of Chapter 5 concludes our investigation of the interesting interplay of spectrum and asymptotics.
Chapter 4
Asymptotics of Laplace Transforms Frequently, convergence of a function f : R+ → X for t → ∞ implies convergence of an average of this function. Assertions of this type are called Abelian theorems. A theorem is called Tauberian if, conversely, convergence of the function is deduced from the convergence of an average. The Abelian theorems which we present in Section 4.1 are quite easy to prove. However, the Tauberian theorems corresponding to their converse versions are much more delicate. They need additional hypotheses, so-called Tauberian conditions. Section 4.2 is devoted to Tauberian conditions of real type (for example, boundedness or positivity of f ). Interesting applications of these Abelian and real Tauberian theorems to semigroups are given in Section 4.3 where mean ergodicity is discussed. This interrupts the general theme of this chapter, but the results will be useful in the subsequent sections where the notion of mean ergodicity is needed. In Section 4.4 a complex Tauberian theorem is proved with the help of an elegant contour argument. Here we make assumptions on holomorphic extensions of fˆ on the imaginary axis. We restrict ourselves to the case of one singularity in order to keep the ideas more transparent, but this case is already of special interest. For example, an immediate consequence is Gelfand’s theorem, saying that a bounded C0 -group is trivial (i.e., the identity) if and only if the spectrum of its generator is reduced to {0}. One interesting type of asymptotic behaviour for large time is almost periodicity. The concept is introduced in Section 4.5 where elementary properties are proved for functions on R. In Section 4.6, Loomis’s theorem and its vectorvalued version are proved by an elegant quotient method which allows one to apply Gelfand’s theorem. The basic notion is the Carleman spectrum for a bounded measurable function defined on the line, and Loomis’s theorem states that any
W. Arendt et al., Vector-valued Laplace Transforms and Cauchy Problems: Second Edition, Monographs in Mathematics 96, DOI 10.1007/978-3-0348-0087-7_4, © Springer Basel AG 2011
243
244
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
bounded uniformly continuous function f : R → C with countable spectrum is almost periodic. There is one vector-valued version of Loomis’s theorem, which is valid for every Banach space and involves an ergodicity condition. The other vector-valued version holds without further assumptions on the function but a geometric condition on the Banach space is needed. Functions on the half-line are considered in Section 4.7. The naturally associated “half-line” spectrum is discussed and the main theorem is a complex Tauberian theorem for functions with countable spectrum, which is proved by the same technique as we proved Loomis’s theorem. In Section 4.8 we come back to functions defined on the line showing that the Carleman spectrum (defined by holomorphy) and the Beurling spectrum (defined by the Fourier transform) coincide. This allows us to prove a very general complex Tauberian theorem for functions on the half-line in Section 4.9. Here we use Fourier transform methods which allow one to reduce the problem to an application of Loomis’s theorem (in the scalar case). The structure of this chapter needs some explanation in view of our main purpose, namely the proof of a complex Tauberian theorem on the half-line. We present three different methods by which we prove the result in increasing generality (Theorems 4.4.8, 4.7.7 and 4.9.7); namely, the contour method, the quotient method and the Fourier method. If Loomis’s theorem (Corollary 4.6.4) is accepted, the Fourier method of Section 4.9 is the most general. The contour method, presented as the first approach in Section 4.4, is the most elementary. It gives us Gelfand’s theorem (Corollary 4.4.12) and other interesting consequences. The quotient method uses Gelfand’s theorem. It gives us Loomis’s theorem on the line (Section 4.6), and in an elegant way the fairly general complex Tauberian Theorem 4.7.7 on the half-line.
4.1
Abelian Theorems
Throughout this section, f denotes a function in L1loc (R+ , X), where X is a Banach space and R+ := [0, ∞) is the right half-line. We consider the following three types of averages. Definition 4.1.1. Let f∞ ∈ X. We say that a) f (t) converges to f∞ in the sense of Abel as t → ∞ if abs(f ) ≤ 0 and A- limt→∞ f (t) := limλ↓0 λfˆ(λ) = f∞ ; b) f (t) is B-convergent to f∞ as t → ∞, or simply write B- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ , t+δ if for every δ > 0, limt→∞ 1δ t f (s) ds = f∞ ; c) f (t) converges to f∞ in the sense of Ces` aro as t → ∞ if 1 t C- lim f (t) := lim f (s) ds = f∞ . t→∞ t→∞ t 0
4.1. ABELIAN THEOREMS
245
It will t be convenient to consider the antiderivative of a function f given by F (t) := 0 f (s) ds. Then the following Abelian theorem holds. Theorem 4.1.2. Let f∞ , F∞ ∈ X. a) If limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ , then B- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ . b) If B- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ , then C- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ . c) If C- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ , then A- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ . d) If limt→∞ F (t) = F∞ , then limλ↓0 fˆ(λ) = F∞ . Proof. a) is obvious. b) Replacing f by f − f∞ we can assume that f∞ = 0. Then (taking δ = 1) t+1 we have by assumption that lim
t→∞ t f (s) ds = 0. Let ε > 0. There exists
t+1
t0 ≥ 0 such that t f (s) ds ≤ 2ε for all t ≥ t0 . Moreover, there exists t1 ≥ t0 t +1 such that 1t 0 0 f (s) ds ≤ 2ε for all t ≥ t1 . Let t ≥ t1 . Take n ∈ N such that t − n ≤ t0 ≤ t − n + 1. Then
t
t−n+1
t
1
1
≤ 1
+
f (s) ds f (s) ds f (s) ds
t
t
t
0 0 t−n+1
t−n+k+1 n−1
1 t0 +1
1
≤
f (s) ds + f (s) ds
t t−n+k
t 0 ≤
ε n−1ε + ≤ ε. 2 t 2
k=1
This proves the claim. c) Assume that C- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ . Then F (t) = O(t) as t → ∞, so fˆ(λ) exists for Re λ > 0 by Theorem 1.4.3. Let ε > 0. There exists τ > 0 such that 1t F (t) − f∞ ≤ ε (t ≥ τ ). Hence by integration by parts, lim sup λfˆ(λ) − f∞
λ↓0
∞
−λt
= lim sup λ e (f (t) − f∞ ) dt
λ↓0 0
∞
2
−λt
= lim sup λ e (F (t) − tf ) dt ∞
λ↓0 0
∞
2
1 = lim sup te−λt F (t) − f∞ dt
λ
t λ↓0 0
τ ∞
1
dt + lim ελ2 ≤ lim sup λ2 te−λt F (t) − f te−λt dt ∞
t
λ↓0 λ↓0 0 τ ∞ = lim ελ2 te−λt dt = ε. λ↓0
0
246
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
(λ) = λFˆ (λ) (λ > 0) if abs(f ) ≤ 0, this follows from the d) Since fˆ(λ) = F previous parts since convergence implies A-convergence. Concerning the behaviour for t → 0, we note: Proposition 4.1.3. Let x ∈ X. Assume that abs(f ) < ∞. Then lim sup λfˆ(λ) − x ≤ lim sup f (t) − x . λ→∞
t↓0
In particular, limt↓0 f (t) = x implies limλ→∞ λfˆ(λ) = x. Proof. Since abs(f ) < ∞, there exist M, ω > 0 such that F (t) ≤ M eωt (t ≥ 0). Let b > 0, λ > ω. Then
∞
∞
−λt −λt
= −λe−λb F (b) + λ2
λe f (t) dt e F (t) dt
b
b
≤
−λb
λe
M −(λ−ω)b
F (b) + λ e . λ−ω 2
Hence, lim sup λfˆ(λ) − x
λ→∞
∞
−λt
= lim sup λe (f (t) − x) dt
λ→∞ 0
∞
−λt
≤ lim sup f (t) − x + λe f (t) dt
+ λ→∞
=
0≤t≤b
b
∞
λe
−λt
dt x
b
sup f (t) − x .
0≤t≤b
∞ Here, we used throughout that λ 0 e−λt dt = 1 (λ > 0). More generally, for α > −1 one has ∞ λα+1 e−λt tα dt = 1 (λ > 0). Γ(α + 1) 0 One shows the following in a similar way as above. Proposition 4.1.4. Let f∞ ∈ X, f0 ∈ X, α > −1. a) If C- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ , then limλ↓0 b) If limt↓0 f (t) = f0 , then limλ→∞
λα+1 Γ(α+1)
λα+1 Γ(α+1)
∞ 0
∞ 0
e−λt tα f (t) dt = f∞ .
e−λt tα f (t) dt = f0 .
This allows one to compute the derivative of f at 0 from its Laplace transform: Corollary 4.1.5. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) such that abs(f ) < ∞. Assume that f ∈ C 1 ([0, τ ], X) for some τ > 0. Then lim λ2 fˆ(λ) − λf (0) = f (0). λ→∞
4.2. REAL TAUBERIAN THEOREMS
247
Proof. Let α = 1. Applying Proposition 4.1.4 b) to g(t) := 1t (f (t)−f (0)), we obtain ∞ that limλ→∞ (λ2 fˆ(λ)−λf (0)) = limλ→∞ λ2 0 e−λt t 1t (f (t) −f (0)) dt = f (0). The following theorem gave the name to this type of result, and to this section. We deduce it from the corresponding result for Laplace transforms. Usually, one uses Abel’s “summation by parts” for power series. ∞ Theorem 4.1.6 (Abel’s Continuity Theorem). Let p(z) := n=0 an z n be a power ∞ series, where an ∈ X. If n=0 an = b, then limz↑1 p(z) = b. Proof. Let f (t) = an if t ∈ [n, n + 1). Then limt→∞ F (t) = b. Hence, −λ ∞ −λ n abs(f ) ≤ 0 and fˆ(λ) = 1−eλ ) for all λ > 0. By Theorem 4.1.2 n=0 an (e d), lim p(z) z↑1
= lim z↑1
∞
an z n = lim
n=0
λ↓0
∞
an (e−λ )n
n=0
λ = lim fˆ(λ) = lim fˆ(λ) λ↓0 1 − e−λ λ↓0 = lim F (t) = b. t→∞
4.2
Real Tauberian Theorems
Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X). In the preceding section we established four notions of convergence for f (t) (as t → ∞) of increasing generality: convergence in the usual sense, B-convergence, convergence in the sense of Ces`aro, and convergence in the sense of Abel. None of the implications established in Theorem 4.1.2 is reversible. An additional condition, which allows one to reverse one of the implications is called a Tauberian condition, and the corresponding result a Tauberian theorem. Of particular interest are those results which allow one to deduce convergence in the usual sense from convergence of a mean. In this section we consider assumptions on f (t), i.e. real Tauberian conditions, in contrast to conditions on fˆ(λ), known as complex Tauberian conditions, which will be the subject of the next section. We first consider the reverse implication of Theorem 4.1.2 a). A. Conditions under which B- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ implies limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ . Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X). In general, if B- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ , one cannot conclude that limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ even if f is bounded. A simple example is the function ∞ f = n=1 χ[n,n+1/n] which has B-limit 0 (as t → ∞) but does not converge. Definition 4.2.1. A function g : R+ → X is called slowly oscillating if for all ε > 0 there exist t0 ≥ 0, δ > 0 such that g(t) − g(s) ≤ ε whenever s, t ≥ t0 , |t − s| ≤ δ.
248
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
A bounded continuous function is slowly oscillating if and only if it is uniformly continuous. Indeed, one may think of Definition 4.2.1 as expressing that the function g is uniformly continuous at infinity. This is made more precise by the following characterization. Proposition 4.2.2. A function g : R+ → X is slowly oscillating if and only if g = g0 + g1 where g1 : R+ → X is uniformly continuous and g0 : R → X satisfies limt→∞ g0 (t) = 0. Proof. It is clear that the condition is sufficient. In order to prove the converse, let g be slowly oscillating. Then we find a decreasing sequence (δn )n∈N ⊂ (0, ∞) such that limn→∞ δn = 0 and an increasing sequence (tn )n∈N ⊂ [0, ∞) such that limn→∞ tn = ∞ and f (t + δ) − f (t) ≤ n1 whenever t ≥ tn , 0 < δ ≤ δn . For each n ∈ N, choose a partition of the interval [tn , tn+1 ] so that every subinterval has length smaller than δn . Define g1 to be linear on each subinterval and equal to f at the endpoints of the subintervals. Extend g1 continuously to [0, t1 ]. Then g1 is uniformly continuous and limt→∞ (f (t) − g1 (t)) = 0. We put g0 := f − g1 . The following Tauberian theorem is easy to prove. Theorem 4.2.3. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) be slowly oscillating and f∞ ∈ X. If B- lim f (t) = f∞ , then lim f (t) = f∞ . t→∞
t→∞
Proof. For δ > 0 one has lim sup f (t) − f∞
t→∞
≤ = ≤
1 t+δ
lim sup f (t) − f (s) ds
δ t→∞ t
1 t+δ
lim sup (f (t) − f (s)) ds
t→∞ δ t lim sup sup f (t) − f (s)
t→∞
t≤s≤t+δ
The last expression tends to 0 as δ ↓ 0 since f is slowly oscillating. Next, we consider: B. Conditions under which C- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ implies limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ . First, we notice that, in general, convergence in the sense of Ces` aro does not imply B-convergence even if f is bounded. For example, let f (t) := sin t. Then t t+δ t C- limt→∞ f (t) = limt→∞ 1t 0 sin s ds = limt→∞ 1−cos = 0. But 1δ t sin s ds t = 1δ (cos(t + δ) − cos t), and the B-limit does not exist.
4.2. REAL TAUBERIAN THEOREMS
249
A function f : R+ → X is called feebly oscillating (when t → ∞) if lim f (t) − f (s) = 0.
t,s→∞ t/s→1
It is clear that every feebly oscillating function is slowly oscillating. Example 4.2.4. Assume that there exist τ > 0, M ≥ 0 such that tf (t) ≤ M t (t ≥ τ ). Then F (t) := 0 f (s) ds is feebly oscillating. In fact, F (t) − F (s) ≤ t !t" M s dr r = M log s for t ≥ s ≥ τ . Theorem 4.2.5. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) and f∞ ∈ X. Assume that f is feebly oscillating. If C- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ , then limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ . Proof. Let ε > 0. There exist δ > 0, t0 > 0 such that f (s) − f (t) < ε whenever t ≥ t0 , s ∈ [t − δt, t + δt]. Hence,
t(1+δ)
1 t(1+δ)
1
f (s) ds = (f (t) − f (s)) ds ≤ ε if t ≥ t0 .
f (t) −
2δt t(1−δ)
2δt t(1−δ) The assumption implies that t(1+δ) 1 f (s) ds 2δt t(1−δ) t(1+δ) t(1−δ) 1+δ 1 1−δ 1 = f (s) ds − f (s) ds 2δ t(1 + δ) 0 2δ t(1 − δ) 0 → f∞ as t → ∞. It follows that limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ . In the next theorem the Tauberian condition is of order-theoretic nature. Theorem 4.2.6. Let X be an ordered Banach space with normal cone. Furthermore let f : R+ → X+ be a function such that for some k ∈ N, t → tk f (t) is increasing. Then C- lim f (t) = f∞ implies lim f (t) = f∞ . t→∞
t→∞
Proof. Since the cone is normal, there exists c ≥ 0 such that u ≤ x ≤ v implies
x ≤ c( u + v ) for u, x, v ∈ X (see Appendix C). Let ρ > 1. The assumption implies that ρt 1 ρ 1 ρt 1 1 t f (s) ds = f (s) ds − f (s) ds (ρ − 1)t t ρ − 1 ρt 0 ρ−1 t 0 → f∞ (t → ∞) t ρ and, similarly, (ρ−1)t f (s) ds → f∞ (t → ∞). t/ρ
250
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS Since tk f (t) is increasing, one has
ρt
f (s) ds = t
≥ and
t
ρ
t/ρ −k
ρt
sk f (s)s−k ds
t k
t f (t)(ρt)−k (ρt − t) = f (t)tρ−k (ρ − 1)
f (s) ds ≤ f (t)tρk−1 (ρ − 1). Thus,
ρ (ρ − 1)t
t
1 ≤ρ (ρ − 1)t
f (s) ds − f∞ ≤ f (t) − f∞
ρt
k
t/ρ
f (s) ds − f∞ .
t
Consequently, lim sup f (t) − f∞
t→∞
≤
t
ρ
−k
c lim sup ρ f (s) ds − f∞
(ρ − 1)t t/ρ t→∞
ρt
k
1 + f (s) ds − f∞
ρ (ρ − 1)t
t
≤ c f∞ (1 − ρ−k + ρk − 1). Letting ρ ↓ 1 yields the claim. C. Conditions under which A- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ implies C- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ . In general, Abel convergence does not imply Ces` aro convergence. For example, let f (t) := t sin t (t ≥ 0). Then it is easy to see that A- lim f (t) = lim 2λ2 (1 + λ2 )−2 = 0 t→∞
λ↓0
t but 1t 0 f (s) ds = sint t − cos t does not converge. Thus additional hypotheses are needed. First, we consider a boundedness condition on f . Theorem 4.2.7. Let f∞ ∈ X. Assume that supt≥τ f (t) < ∞ for some τ ≥ 0. If A- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ , then C- lim∞ f (t) = f∞ . Proof. a) We first assume that τ = 0. For β > 0 let eβ (t) := e−βt (t > 0). Then span{eβ : β > 0} is dense in L1 (R+ ) (by Lemma 1.7.1). By hypothesis, lim
α→∞
0
∞
e−s f (αs) ds = lim λ↓0
∞
0
= lim λ λ↓0
0
e−s f
∞
s λ
ds
e−λs f (s) ds = f∞ .
4.2. REAL TAUBERIAN THEOREMS Hence,
251
∞
e−βs f (αs) ds 0 ∞ α e−s f s ds α→∞ 0 β = f∞ = βeβ , f∞ for all β > 0. ∞ It follows that limα→∞ h, f (α ·) = f∞ 0 h(t) dt for all h ∈ L1 (R+ ). Letting h = χ(0,1] , we obtain 1 1 α lim f (s) ds = lim f (αs) ds = lim h, f (α ·) = f∞ . α→∞ α 0 α→∞ 0 α→∞ lim βeβ , f (α ·) =
lim β α→∞ = lim
α→∞
b) If τ > 0 the result follows by applying a) to g(t) = f (t + τ ). Next, we show that positivity is a Tauberian condition. Theorem 4.2.8 (Karamata). Let X be an ordered Banach space with normal cone and let β > −1. Let f∞ ∈ X and f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) such that f (t) ≥ 0 (t ∈ R+ ). Suppose that ∞ a) 0 e−λt tβ f (t) dt exists for all λ > 0; and ∞ −λt β λβ+1 b) limλ↓0 Γ(β+1) e t f (t) dt = f∞ . 0 Then C- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ . This is a converse of Proposition 4.1.4 a). In particular, it follows from Theorem 4.2.8 that for positive f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X), A- lim f (t) = f∞ implies C- lim f (t) = f∞ . t→∞
t→∞
Proof. It follows from the assumption that for n ∈ N0 , ∞ λβ+1 lim e−λt (e−λt )n f (t)tβ dt λ↓0 Γ(β + 1) 0 1 (λ(n + 1))β+1 ∞ −λ(n+1)t = lim e f (t)tβ dt (n + 1)β+1 λ↓0 Γ(β + 1) 0 ∞ 1 1 = f∞ = f∞ tβ e−t (e−t )n dt. (n + 1)β+1 Γ(β + 1) 0 Consequently, for every polynomial p, ∞ ∞ λβ+1 1 lim e−λt p(e−λt )tβ f (t) dt = f∞ tβ e−t p(e−t ) dt. λ↓0 Γ(β + 1) 0 Γ(β + 1) 0 Let q : [0, 1] → R+ be given by q(x) := 0 if x < e−1 , q(x) := x−1 if x ≥ e−1 . Let δ > 0 and let q1 , q2 be continuous functions such that 0 ≤ q1 ≤ q ≤ q2 on [0, 1] and
252
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
a) q1 (x) = q(x) if x ≤ e−1 or x > e−1 + δ, b) q2 (x) = q(x) if x ≤ e−1 − δ or x > e−1 , c) sup0≤x≤1 (q2 (x) − q1 (x)) ≤ e. t2 β −t e Now, let ε > 0. Choose δ > 0 such that Γ(β+1) t e dt < ε, where e−t2 = e−1 −δ t1 −t1 −1 and e = e + δ. By the Stone-Weierstrass theorem, there exist polynomials p1 and p2 such that q1 − ε ≤ p1 ≤ q1 ≤ q ≤ q2 ≤ p2 ≤ q2 + ε on [0, 1]. Define kj : R+ → X (j = 1, 2) and h : (0, ∞) → X by: kj (λ)
:=
kj (0)
:=
h(λ)
:=
∞ λβ+1 tβ e−λt pj (e−λt )f (t) dt (λ > 0), Γ(β + 1) 0 ∞ f∞ e−t pj (e−t )tβ dt, Γ(β + 1) 0 ∞ λβ+1 e−λt q(e−λt )tβ f (t) dt (λ > 0). Γ(β + 1) 0
Since 0 ≤ p2 − p1 ≤ q2 − q1 + 2ε, one has 0 ≤ k2 (0) − k1 (0)
≤ ≤
f∞ e Γ(β + 1) 3 εf∞ .
t2 t1
e−t tβ dt + 2ε
f∞ Γ(β + 1)
∞
e−t tβ dt
0
The first part of the proof shows that limλ↓0 kj (λ) = kj (0). Let λ0 > 0 such that ˆ ≤ λ0 . Then
kj (λ) − kj (0) < ε for 0 < λ ≤ λ0 , j = 1, 2. Let 0 < λ, λ ˆ ≤ h(λ) − h(λ) ˆ ≤ k2 (λ) − k1 (λ). ˆ k1 (λ) − k2 (λ) Hence, for a fixed constant c > 0, ˆ
h(λ) − h(λ)
ˆ + k1 (λ) − k2 (λ) ˆ
≤ c k2 (λ) − k1 (λ) ˆ
≤ c k2 (λ) − k2 (0) + k2 (0) − k1 (0) + k1 (0) − k1 (λ) ˆ
+ k1 (λ) − k1 (0) + k1 (0) − k2 (0) + k2 (0) − k2 (λ)
ˆ ≤ λ0 . ≤ 4 c ε + 2 · 3 c ε f∞ whenever 0 < λ, λ This shows that h(λ) converges as λ ↓ 0. Since h(λ) =
λβ+1 Γ(β+1)
1/λ 0
sβ f (s) ds, it
4.2. REAL TAUBERIAN THEOREMS follows that limt→∞ t−(β+1) f∞
= lim λ↓0
t
sβ f (s) ds =: g exists. Hence,
λβ+1 Γ(β + 1)
= lim(β + 1) λ↓0
=
0
253
∞
0 β+2
e−λt f (t)tβ dt
λ Γ(β + 2)
∞ 0
e−λt tβ+1
1 tβ+1
t
f (s)sβ ds dt
0
(β + 1)g,
f∞ by the Abelian theorem mentioned above (Proposition 4.1.4 a)). Thus, g = β+1 . t f∞ −(β+1) β We have proved that t s f (s) ds → β+1 as t → ∞. Since convergence 1 implies Ces` aro-convergence, we also have s 1 t 1 f∞ lim rβ f (r) dr ds = . t→∞ t 1 sβ+1 1 β+1
Hence, integration by parts yields s 1 t 1 t 1 d f (s) ds = rβ f (r) dr ds t 1 t 1 sβ ds 1 t 1 β t −(β+1) s β β = r f (r) dr + s r f (r) dr ds tβ+1 1 t 1 1 f∞ f∞ → +β = f∞ . β+1 β+1 D. Conditions under which limλ↓0 fˆ(λ) = F∞ implies limt→∞ F (t) = F∞ . The following theorem is due to Hardy t and Littlewood in the scalar-valued case. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) and let F (t) := 0 f (s) ds (t ≥ 0). Theorem 4.2.9 (Hardy-Littlewood). Assume that M := supt≥τ t f (t) < ∞ for some τ ≥ 0 and let F∞ ∈ X. If limλ↓0 fˆ(λ) = F∞ , then limt→∞ F (t) = F∞ . Proof. Replacing f by f (· + τ ) we can assume that τ = 0. For t > 0 we have
t
∞
!1"
−s/t −s/t ˆ
f (s)(1 − e ) ds − f (s)e ds
F (t) − f t =
0
t
∞ 1 − e−s/t −r dr ≤ M sup t + e s r 0<s
Since limt→∞ fˆ( 1t ) = F∞ , it follows that F is bounded. But A- limt→∞ F (t) = limλ↓0 fˆ(λ) = F∞ . It follows from Theorem 4.2.7 that C- limt→∞ F (t) = F∞ . By
254
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
Example 4.2.4, F is feebly oscillating. Now Theorem 4.2.5 implies that limt→∞ F (t) = F∞ . The following classical example is a beautiful application of the HardyLittlewood theorem. Example 4.2.10. Let f (t) := sint t . Then fˆ(λ) = − arctan λ + π2 . In fact, ∞ ∞ d ˆ f (λ) = e−λt (−t)f (t) dt = − e−λt sin t dt dλ 0 0 ∞ 1 = − e−λt (eit − e−it ) dt 2i 0 1 1 1 −1 = − − = 2i λ − i λ + i 1 + λ2 d = − arctan λ. dλ Since limλ→∞ fˆ(λ) = 0, the claim follows. Now by Theorem 4.2.9, it follows that ∞ sin t t sin s dt := limt→∞ ds = limλ↓0 fˆ(λ) = π . 0
0
t
2
s
If f is positive, then fˆ(λ) is decreasing. So in the real-valued case it is clear that
lim fˆ(λ) λ↓0
=
λ>0
=
t
sup fˆ(λ) = sup sup
sup sup t>0 λ>0
λ>0 t>0 t
e−λs f (s) ds
0
e−λs f (s) ds = sup F (t) = lim F (t).
0
t>0
t→∞
If X is an ordered Banach space we cannot argue like this (unless the norm is order continuous). However, using the preceding results we obtain: Theorem 4.2.11. Let X be an ordered Banach space with normal cone. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) and assume that f (t) ≥ 0 (t ≥ 0) and abs(f ) ≤ 0. If limλ↓0 fˆ(λ) = F∞ then limt→∞ F (t) = F∞ . Proof. We have A- limt→∞ F (t) = limλ↓0 λFˆ (λ) = limλ↓0 fˆ(λ) = F∞ . It follows from Karamata’s theorem (Theorem 4.2.8) that C- limt→∞ F (t) = F∞ . Since F is increasing, the claim follows from Theorem 4.2.6. E. Conditions under which A- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ implies limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ . t Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) and F (t) = 0 f (s) ds (t ≥ 0). Assume that abs(f ) ≤ 0. Since λFˆ (λ) = fˆ(λ), every Tauberian theorem of type E yields one of type D. In order to go the other way around, we apply Tauberian theorems of type D to the function fδ defined by fδ (t) :=
1 (f (t + δ) − f (t)) δ
(t ≥ 0).
4.2. REAL TAUBERIAN THEOREMS
255
Lemma 4.2.12. Let f∞ ∈ X, δ > 0. Consider the following assertions: (i) limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ . (ii) limt→∞ (iii) limt→∞
1 δ
t+δ
t 0
t
f (s) ds = f∞ .
fδ (s) ds = f∞ −
(iv) limλ↓0 fδ (λ) = f∞ −
1 δ
δ 0
1 δ
δ 0
f (s) ds.
f (s) ds.
(v) A- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ . Then (i) ⇒ (ii) ⇔ (iii) ⇒ (iv) ⇔ (v). Proof. The implication (i) ⇒ (ii) is obvious, and (ii) is equivalent to (iii) since 0
t
1 fδ (s) ds = δ
t+δ t
1 f (s) ds − δ
Since fδ (λ) =
1 λδ eλδ (e − 1)λfˆ(λ) − λδ δ
δ
f (s) ds. 0
δ
e−λs f (s) ds,
(4.1)
0
(iv) is equivalent to (v). By Theorem 4.1.2, (iii) implies (iv). Remark 4.2.13. It is easy to see that f is B-convergent if (ii) or (iii) of Lemma 4.2.12 holds for all δ ∈ (0, δ0 ] for some δ0 > 0. See also the Notes for more general results. Now we can obtain the following Tauberian theorem by applying the HardyLittlewood Tauberian theorem to fδ . Theorem 4.2.14. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X), f∞ ∈ X, δ0 > 0, τ ≥ 0, M ≥ 0. Assume that t f (t) − f (s) ≤ M
(4.2)
whenever t ≥ τ, |s − t| ≤ δ0 . If A- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ , then limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ . Proof. By the assumption, lim supt→∞ t fδ (t) < ∞ for all δ ∈ (0, δ0 ). Moreover, f is slowly oscillating. Since A- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ , Lemma 4.2.12 gives us δ t limλ↓0 fδ (λ) = f∞ − 1δ 0 f (s) ds. Theorem 4.2.9 implies that limt→∞ 0 fδ (s) ds = δ f∞ − 1δ 0 f (s) ds for all δ ∈ (0, δ0 ). Hence, B- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ by Lemma 4.2.12 and Remark 4.2.13. Now the claim follows from Theorem 4.2.3. Now we can actually use Theorem 4.2.14 to prove a slight improvement of the Hardy-Littlewood theorem; i.e., we deduce a Tauberian theorem of type D from a result of type E as indicated above.
256
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
Theorem 4.2.15. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X), F∞ ∈ X. Assume that for some δ > 0,
t+δ
lim sup t→∞
r f (r) dr < ∞.
t
If limλ↓0 fˆ(λ) = F∞ , then limt→∞ F (t) = F∞ , where F (t) :=
t 0
f (s) ds.
Proof. We have lim sup
sup
t→∞
t≤s≤t+δ
t F (t) − F (s)
t+δ
≤ lim sup t t→∞
≤ lim sup t→∞
f (s) ds
t t+δ
s f (s) ds < ∞.
t
Thus, F satisfies (4.2). Since A- limt→∞ F (t) = limλ↓0 fˆ(λ) = F∞ , it follows from Theorem 4.2.14 that limt→∞ F (t) = F∞ . Next, we consider an order condition. Theorem 4.2.16. Let X be an ordered Banach space with normal cone, let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) such that tk f (t) is positive and increasing on [τ, ∞) for some τ ≥ 0 and some k ∈ N. If A- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ , then limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ . Proof. Replacing f (t) by f (t + τ ) we can assume that τ = 0. Since f is positive, it follows from Karamata’s Theorem 4.2.8 that C- limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ . Now Theorem 4.2.6 implies that limt→∞ f (t) = f∞ . F. Power series. ∞ n Let p(z) := be a power series which converges for |z| < 1, where n=0 an z an ∈ X. Defining f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) by f (t) = an
if
t ∈ [n, n + 1),
(4.3)
the preceding results yield Tauberian theorems for p. In fact, one has abs(f ) ≤ 0 and ∞ 1 − e−λ ˆ f (λ) = an e−λn (Re λ > 0). (4.4) λ n=0 Thus, from Theorem 4.2.9 we obtain the following Tauberian counterpart of Theorem 4.1.6. Theorem 4.2.17 (Hardy). ∞Assume that supn∈N0 n an < ∞, and let b∞ ∈ X. If limz↑1 p(z) = b∞ , then n=0 an = b∞ .
4.2. REAL TAUBERIAN THEOREMS
257
The special case where limn→∞ nan = 0 had been proved by Tauber in 1897 and was the starting point of Tauberian theory. In the case nof power series, theorems of types D and E are equivalent. In fact, let bn := k=0 ak , or equivalently, a0 = b0 , an = bn − bn−1 (n ∈ N). Then ∞ q(z) := n=0 bn z n also converges for |z| < 1. Moreover, ∞
ak z k = (1 − z)
k=0
∞
bk z k
(|z| < 1).
k=0
∞ ∞ Thus, A- limn→∞ bn := limz↑1 (1 − z) k=0 bk z k = limz↑1 k=0 ak z k whenever one of the limits exists. So we obtain the following Corollary 4.2.18. Let bn ∈ X such that sup n bn −bn−1 < ∞. If A- lim bn = b∞ , n→∞
n∈N
then lim bn = b∞ . n→∞
G. Fourier series. Let Y be a Banach space. Let f : R → Y be a continuous 2π-periodic function. π 1 −ikx By ck := 2π f (x)e dx ∈ Y (k ∈ Z), we denote the Fourier coefficients of f −π and by m sm (x) := ck eikx (x ∈ R) k=−m
the Fourier sums. It is well known that, in general, sm (x) does not converge as m → ∞. However, it converges in the sense of Ces`aro. Theorem 4.2.19 (Fej´er). One has 1 n→∞ n+1
lim
n
sm (x) = f (x)
m=0
uniformly in x ∈ R.
m Proof. a) We show that for m ∈ N, y ∈ R, k=−m eiky = Dm (y), where ⎧ ⎨ cos my − cos(m + 1)y (y ∈ 2πZ) 1 − cos y Dm (y) := ⎩ 2m + 1 (y ∈ 2πZ) m m (the so-called Dirichlet kernel). In fact, k=−m eiky = 1 + k=1 (eiky + e−iky ) is real. Thus, m m (1 − cos y) eiky = Re (1 − eiy ) eiky k=−m
k=−m
= =
Re(e−imy − ei(m+1)y ) cos my − cos(m + 1)y.
258
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS b) We obtain from a) and periodicity, sm (x)
m
=
k=−m
1 2π
=
1 2π
π
1 2π
f (t)e−ikt dt eikx =
−π
π
1 f (t)Dm (x − t) dt = 2π −π
π −π
π
f (t) −π
m
eik(x−t) dt
k=−m
f (x − t)Dm (t) dt.
c) Let σn (x)
:=
= = = where
n−1 1 sm (x) n m=0 π n−1 1 1 f (x − t) (cos mt − cos(m + 1)t) dt 2πn −π 1 − cos t m=0 π 1 1 − cos nt f (x − t) dt 2πn −π 1 − cos t π 1 f (x − t)Fn (t) dt, 2π −π
⎧ nt 2 ⎪ ⎨ 1 sin 2 Fn (t) = n sin 2t ⎪ ⎩n
(t ∈ 2πZ) (t ∈ 2πZ)
(the so-called Fej´er kernel). Here, we used that cos a = 1 − 2(sin a2 )2 (a ∈ R). d) We have to show that σn (x) converges π uniformly to f (x). If f ≡ 1, then 1 clearly σn (x) = 1. It follows from c) that 2π F (t) dt = 1 (n ∈ N). Moreover, −π n Fn (t) ≥ 0 (t ∈ (−π, π)). Since Fn (t) = Fn (−t), we have π 1 σn (x) = f (x + t)Fn (t) dt 2π −π π 1 f (x + t) + f (x − t) = Fn (t) dt. 2π −π 2 π 1 Thus, σn (x)−f (x) = 2π F (t)g(t) dt, where g(t) := 12 (f (x+t)+f (x−t))−f (x). −π n Let ε > 0. Since f is uniformly continuous, there exists δ > 0 such that g(t) ≤ ε whenever |t| ≤ δ. Thus,
δ
δ
Fn (t)g(t) dt ≤ Fn (t) g(t) dt
−δ
−δ δ ≤ ε Fn (t) dt ≤ ε · 2π −δ
4.2. REAL TAUBERIAN THEOREMS and
δ
π
259
1 1 π −2 Fn (t)g(t) dt
≤ g ∞ (π − δ) n (sin δ/2)2 < g ∞ n (sin δ/2) .
−δ Similarly, −π Fn (t)g(t) dt ≤ g ∞ πn (sin δ/2)−2 . Hence, σn (x) − f (x) ≤ ε + n−1 g ∞ (sin δ/2)−2 . Consequently, lim supn→∞ σn − f ≤ ε. Now we deduce the following from the Tauberian theorem Corollary 4.2.18. Theorem 4.2.20. Assume that f : R → Y is a continuous 2π-periodic function which is of bounded semivariation on [−π, π]. Then limn→∞ sn (x) = f (x) uniformly in x ∈ R. π −ikx 1 Proof. Let k ∈ Z, k = 0. Then ck = 2πik e df (x) by integration by parts. −π Hence, there exists a constant c ≥ 0 such that |k| ck ≤ c (k ∈ Z). Consequently, m sm −sm−1 ∞ ≤ m( cm + c−m ) ≤ 2c. Now the claim follows from Theorem 4.2.9 and Corollary 4.2.18 by choosing as X the Banach space of all continuous 2π-periodic functions on R with values in Y with the uniform norm · ∞ . H. Inversion of Laplace transforms. Now we give a result for Laplace transforms which corresponds to Theorem 4.2.19 and which leads to a proof of the Complex Inversion Theorem 2.3.4. Here X is any Banach space. Theorem 4.2.21. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) such that abs( f ) < ∞. a) If ω > abs( f ), then
a R ω+ir
1
1 λt ˆ
lim e f (λ) dλ − f (t)
dt = 0 R→∞ 0 R 0 2πi ω−ir for all a > 0. b) If f is continuous and exponentially bounded, f (0) = 0, and ω > ω(f ), then 1 r→∞ 2πi
ω+ir
C- lim
eλt fˆ(λ) dλ = f (t)
ω−ir
uniformly for t ∈ [0, a], for all a ≥ 0. 2 sin(t/2) 1 Proof. Let Φ(t) := 2π (t ∈ R). Then Φ ∈ L1 (R), and the inverse Fourier t/2 transform of Φ is given by 1 (1 − |s|) (|s| ≤ 1), −1 (F Φ)(s) = 2π 0 (|s| > 1).
260
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
Let ΦR (t) := RΦ(Rt), so (F −1 ΦR )(s) = (F −1 Φ)(s/R), and {ΦR } acts an approximate unit on L1 (R, X) and C0 (R, X) as R → ∞ (see Lemma 1.3.3). Consider f as a function on R with f (s) = 0 (s < 0). Let ω > abs( f ), t ≥ 0. Put g(s) := e−ω(s+t) f (s + t) (s ∈ R). Then g ∈ L1 (R, X) and
(F g)(s) = eist fˆ(ω + is).
By Fubini’s theorem and Theorem 1.8.1 b), ω+ir 1 R 1 eλt fˆ(λ) dλ dr R 0 2πi ω−ir 1 ωt 1 R R ist ˆ = e e f (ω + is) dr ds 2π R −R |s| R 1 |s| ωt = e 1− (F g)(s) ds R −R 2π ∞ = eωt ΦR (s)g(s) ds −∞
eωt (ΦR ∗ fω )(t),
=
where fω (s) := e−ωs f (s) (note that ΦR (s) = ΦR (−s)). Now a) and b) follow, since
ΦR ∗fω −fω 1 → 0 if ω > abs( f ) and ΦR ∗fω −fω ∞ → 0 if fω ∈ C0 (R, X). Now we are able to give the following proof of Theorem 2.3.4. Proof of Theorem 2.3.4. Let F ∈ Lip0 (R+ , X). For Re λ = ω > 0, we have Fˆ (λ) = (λ)/λ and dF ∞
dF (λ) ≤ e−ωt F Lip0 (R+ ,X) dt = F Lip0 (R+ ,X) /ω. 0
For 0 ≤ t ≤ a and S > R > 0,
ω+iS
1 ω+iR
1
λt ˆ λt ˆ e F (λ) dλ − e F (λ) dλ
2πi ω−iR
2πi ω−iS eωa S F Lip0 (R+ ,X) ≤ ds π R ω|ω + is| eωa ≤
F Lip0 (R+ ,X) log(S/R). πω ω+iR λ· 1 Hence, R → 2πi e Fˆ (λ) dλ is feebly oscillating as a function from R+ to ω−iR C([0, a], X). It follows from Theorem 4.2.21 and Theorem 4.2.5 that ω+iR 1 eλt Fˆ (λ) dλ → F (t) 2πi ω−iR uniformly for t ∈ [0, a].
4.3. ERGODIC SEMIGROUPS
4.3
261
Ergodic Semigroups
This section interrupts the general theme of this chapter: we consider convergence in mean of semigroups. This is an interesting illustration of some of the results in Sections 4.1 and 4.2. Moreover, the notions introduced here will be useful in the context of almost periodic functions which form the subject of Section 4.5. We also prove a striking result due to Lotz: every C0 -semigroup on an L∞ -space has a bounded generator (Corollary 4.3.19). Let A be an operator on a Banach space X such that (0, λ0 ) ⊂ ρ(A) for some λ0 > 0 and M := sup λR(λ, A) < ∞. (4.5) 0<λ<λ0
Note that (4.5) ∞ is satisfied if A generates a bounded C0 -semigroup T . In fact, then R(λ, A) = 0 e−λt T (t) dt (λ > 0) and (4.5) holds for M = supt≥0 T (t) . Denote by Ker A := {x ∈ D(A) : Ax = 0} the kernel of A and by Ran A := {Ax : x ∈ D(A)} the range of A. Let x ∈ X. Since AR(λ, A)x = λR(λ, A)x − x
(0 < λ < λ0 ),
it follows from (4.5) that x ∈ Ran A if and only if lim λR(λ, A)x = 0.
(4.6)
λR(λ, A)x = x (0 < λ < λ0 ) if and only if x ∈ Ker A.
(4.7)
λ↓0
Moreover,
In particular, Ker A ∩ Ran A = {0}.
(4.8)
In what follows, as elsewhere, limits in Banach spaces are norm-limits unless specified otherwise. Proposition 4.3.1. Let A be an operator satisfying (4.5) and let x ∈ X. a) The following assertions are equivalent: (i) There exist λn ↓ 0 such that λn R(λn , A)x converges weakly as n → ∞. (ii) x0 := limλ↓0 λR(λ, A)x exists. (iii) x ∈ Ker A + Ran A. In that case, x0 ∈ Ker A and x − x0 ∈ Ran A. b) If A generates a bounded C0 -semigroup, then (i)–(iii) are equivalent to t (iv) x1 := limt→∞ 1t 0 T (s)x ds exists.
262
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS In that case, x1 = x0 .
Proof. a) (i) ⇒ (iii): Assume that λn R(λn , A)x converges weakly to y as n → ∞. By the resolvent equation, we have μR(μ, A)λn R(λn , A)x =
μ μλn (λn R(λn , A)x) − R(μ, A)x. μ − λn μ − λn
for all μ ∈ (0, λ0 ). Taking weak limits gives μR(μ, A)y = y. It follows from (4.7) that y ∈ Ker A. Since λn R(λn , A)x − x = AR(λn , A)x ∈ Ran A, it follows that y − x is in the weak closure of Ran A, which coincides with the norm closure. (iii) ⇒ (ii): This follows from (4.6) and (4.7). (ii) ⇒ (i): This is trivial. b) Since the Laplace transform of u(t) := T (t)x is given by u ˆ(λ) = R(λ, A)x, it follows from the Abelian Theorem 4.1.2 that (iv) implies (ii), and from the Tauberian Theorem 4.2.7 that (ii) implies (iv). Corollary 4.3.2. Let A be an operator satisfying (4.5). a) The following assertions are equivalent: (i) P x := limλ↓0 λR(λ, A)x exists for all x ∈ X. (ii) X = Ker A ⊕ Ran A. In that case, P is the projection onto Ker A along Ran A. b) If D(A) is dense, then (i) and (ii) are equivalent to (iii) Ker A separates Ker A∗ . Note that (iii) means, by definition, that for all x∗ ∈ Ker A∗ such that x∗ = 0 there exists x ∈ Ker A such that x, x∗ = 0. Proof. a) follows directly from Proposition 4.3.1 and (4.8). b) Assume that D(A) is dense. (ii) ⇒ (iii): Let x∗ ∈ Ker A∗ , x∗ = 0. Then Ax, x∗ = 0 for all x ∈ D(A). Hence y, x∗ = 0 for all y ∈ Ran A. Since X = Ker A ⊕ Ran A, it follows that x, x∗ = 0 for some x ∈ Ker A. (iii) ⇒ (i): We first show that Ker A + Ran A is dense in X. In fact, otherwise there exists x∗ ∈ X ∗ \ {0} vanishing on Ker A + Ran A. Since x∗ vanishes on Ran A, one has x∗ ∈ Ker A∗ . Thus, condition (iii) is violated, and the claim is proved. It follows from (4.6) and (4.7) that (λR(λ, A)x) converges as λ ↓ 0 for x ∈ Ker A + Ran A. This implies convergence for all x ∈ X by density. Definition 4.3.3. A C0 -semigroup T on X is called Ces` aro-ergodic (or mean-ergodic) if 1 t Qx := lim T (s)x ds (4.9) t→∞ t 0
4.3. ERGODIC SEMIGROUPS
263
exists for all x ∈ X. The semigroup is called Abel-ergodic if its generator A satisfies (4.5) and the equivalent conditions (i), (ii), (iii) of Corollary 4.3.2 are satisfied. Proposition 4.3.4. Let T be a C0 -semigroup with generator A. a) If T is Ces` aro-ergodic, then T is Abel-ergodic and Q given by (4.9) is the projection onto Ker A along Ran A. b) Assume that T is bounded and Abel-ergodic. Then T is Ces` aro-ergodic. Proof. a) Assume that T is Ces` aro-ergodic. It follows from
t the uniform
boundedness principle that there exists M ≥ 0 such that 1t 0 T (s)x ds ≤ M x
for all t > 0, x ∈ X. It follows from Theorem 3.1.7 that (0, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and ∞ R(λ, A)x = 0 e−λt T (t)x dt for all λ > 0, x ∈ X. Integration by parts yields
∞
t
2 −λt
λR(λ, A)x = λ e T (s)x ds dt
0 0 ∞ ≤ M λ2 e−λt t dt x
0
= M x (λ > 0). Thus, condition (4.5) is satisfied. Since u(t) := T (t)x has Laplace tranform u ˆ(λ) = R(λ, A)x, the claim now follows from Theorem 4.1.2 and Proposition 4.3.1 a). b) If T is bounded by M , then condition (4.5) is satisfied. So the claim follows from Proposition 4.3.1. Corollary 4.3.5. Every bounded C0 -semigroup on a reflexive Banach space X is Ces` aro-ergodic. Proof. Let x ∈ X. It follows from reflexivity that condition (i) of Proposition 4.3.1 is satisfied. Thus, T is Abel-ergodic and the claim follows from Proposition 4.3.4. Condition (iii) of Corollary 4.3.2 is frequently the most convenient way to verify Ces`aro-ergodicity of a bounded C0 -semigroup. Note that the dual assertion is always true: the space Ker A∗ separates Ker A whenever A generates a bounded C0 -semigroup. More generally, the following holds. Proposition 4.3.6. Let A be a densely defined operator satisfying (4.5). Let 0 = x ∈ Ker A. Then there exists x∗ ∈ Ker A∗ such that x, x∗ = 0. Proof. Let y ∗ ∈ X ∗ such that x, y ∗ = 1. Let x∗ be a weak* limit point of λR(λ, A)∗ y ∗ as λ ↓ 0. Since λR(λ, A)x = x, it follows that x, x∗ = 1. Let y ∈ D(A). Then lim λR(λ, A)Ay = lim λ(λR(λ, A)y − y) = 0. λ↓0
λ↓0
264
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
Hence,
Ay, x∗ = limλR(λ, A)Ay, y ∗ = 0. λ↓0
∗
∗
Thus, x ∈ Ker A . We have shown that for bounded C0 -semigroups Abel- and Ces`aro-ergodicity are equivalent. This is not always the case for arbitrary C0 -semigroups as the 1 t 2 it following easy example shows: Let X := C , T (t) := e . Then T is 0 1 Abel-ergodic but not Ces`aro-ergodic. However, by Karamata’s theorem (Theorem 4.2.8) both notions do coincide for positive semigroups. Theorem 4.3.7. Let T be a positive C0 -semigroup on an ordered Banach space with normal cone. Then T is Abel-ergodic if and only if T is Ces` aro-ergodic. Next, we extend the results on Ces`aro-ergodicity to Lipschitz continuous integrated semigroups. Let A be an operator on X satisfying the Hille-Yosida condition (0, ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and (λR(λ, A))n ≤ M
(4.10)
for all λ > 0, n ∈ N0 and some M ≥ 0. Then A generates a Lipschitz continuous once integrated semigroup S. More precisely, there exists S : R+ → L(X) satisfying S(0) = 0, S(t) − S(s) ≤ M |t − s| (s, t > 0)
and R(λ, A) = λ
∞
e−λt S(t) dt
(λ > 0);
0
see Theorem 3.3.1 and Section 3.5. If D(A) is dense, then A generates a bounded C0 -semigroup T and 1t S(t) = t 1 aro t 0 T (s) ds. If D(A) is not dense, then T does not exist on X, but the Ces` means 1t S(t) still make sense. Thus, the following theorem generalizes Proposition 4.3.4, but is more complicated to prove in this more general context. Theorem 4.3.8. Let A be the generator of a Lipschitz continuous once integrated semigroup S. The following conditions are equivalent: (i) X = Ker A ⊕ Ran A. (ii) P := limt→∞ 1t S(t) exists in the strong operator topology. In that case, P is the projection onto Ker A along Ran A. Proof. (i) ⇒ (ii): If x ∈ Ker A, then S(t)x = tx (t > 0). Next, let x = Ay ∈ Ran A. We show that 1 lim S(t)x = 0. t→∞ t
4.3. ERGODIC SEMIGROUPS
265
Note that 1t S(t) ≤ M . Since by Lemma 3.2.2,
t
S(t)y = ty +
S(s)Ay ds, 0
one has 1 lim t→∞ t2
t
S(s)Ay ds = 0. 0
By the Abelian Theorem 4.1.2, it follows that 1 t→∞ t
t
lim
0
1 s2
s
1 t→∞ t2
S(r)Ay dr ds = C- lim 0
t
S(s)Ay ds = 0. 0
Integration by parts yields 1 S(t)Ay t→∞ t
C- lim
1 t1 S(s)Ay ds t→∞ t 0 s s 1 t1 d = lim S(r)Ay dr ds t→∞ t 0 s ds 0 t 1 1 t 1 s = lim S(r)Ay dr + S(r)Ay dr ds t→∞ t2 0 t 0 s2 0 = 0. =
lim
Now observe that
1
S(t)x − 1 S(s)x
t
s
1
1 1
≤ (S(t)x − S(s)x) + − S(s)x
t t s 1 ≤ |t − s|2M x . t
Thus, the function 1t S(t)Ay is feebly oscillating. It follows from the Tauberian Theorem 4.2.5 that lim
t→∞
1 1 S(t)Ay = C- lim S(t)Ay = 0. t→∞ t t
We have shown that 1t S(t)x converges to P x as t → ∞ for x ∈ Ker A + Ran A, where P is the projection onto Ker A along Ran A. Since 1t S(t) ≤ M , it follows that limt→∞ 1t S(t)x = P x for all x ∈ X. (ii) ⇒ (i): This is an Abelian theorem whose proof is analogous to Theorem 4.1.2 c): Let x ∈ X. By Corollary 4.3.2, we have to show that lim λR(λ, A)x = lim λ2 λ↓0
λ↓0
∞ 0
e−λt S(t)x dt = P x.
266
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
Let ε > 0. There exists t0 such that 1t S(t)x − P x ≤ ε for all t ≥ t0 . Hence lim sup λR(λ, A)x − P x
λ↓0
∞
1 2 −λt
= lim sup λ e t S(t)x − P x dt
t λ↓0 0
t0
1
≤ lim sup λ2 e−λt t
t S(t)x − P x dt + ε λ↓0 0 = ε.
Example 4.3.9. Consider the operator A on X := C[0, 1] given by ' ( D(A) := f ∈ C 2 [0, 1] : f (0) = f (1), f (0) = 0 , Af := f . It is not difficult to see that A is dissipative and (I − A)D(A) = X. By Corollary 3.4.6, A generates a once integrated semigroup S satisfying
S(t) − S(s) ≤ |t − s|. Let f ∈ X. Then the constant function f (0) ∈ Ker A and f − f (0) = Ag ∈ Ran A, where x t 1 t (f (s) − f (0)) ds dt − x (f (t) − f (0)) ds dt. g(x) := 0
0
0
0
It follows from Theorem 4.3.8 that lim
t→∞
1 (S(t)f )(x) = f (0) t
uniformly for all x ∈ [0, 1], for all f ∈ X. Next, we fix a bounded C0 -semigroup T with generator A. Recall that the operator A − iη generates the C0 -semigroup (e−iηt T (t))t≥0 , and we may consider ergodicity for the rescaled semigroup. Definition 4.3.10. a) Let η ∈ R. A vector x ∈ X is called ergodic at η (with respect to T ) if the mean 1 t −iηs Mη x := lim e T (s)x ds t→∞ t 0 converges in norm. b) A vector x is called totally ergodic (with respect to T ) if x is ergodic at η for all η ∈ R. c) The semigroup T is called totally ergodic if each vector x is totally ergodic; i.e., if the semigroup (e−iηt T (t))t≥0 is Ces` aro-ergodic for all η ∈ R.
4.3. ERGODIC SEMIGROUPS
267
By Xe we denote the space of all totally ergodic vectors in X and by Xe0 the space of all vectors x ∈ Xe such that Mη x = 0 for all η ∈ R. Both spaces Xe and Xe0 are closed and invariant under the semigroup. It follows from Proposition 4.3.1 that a vector x ∈ X is totally ergodic if and only if xη := lim αR(α + iη, A)x α↓0
exists for all η ∈ R. In that case, xη = Mη x. Moreover, Mη x ∈ Ker (A − iη) and x − Mη x ∈ Ran(A − iη). In particular, T (t)Mη x = eiηt Mη x (t ≥ 0), 1 R(λ, A)Mη x = Mη x (λ ∈ ρ(A), λ = iη). λ − iη If x ∈ X is totally ergodic we denote by Freq(x) := {η ∈ R : Mη x = 0} the set of all frequencies of X. Proposition 4.3.11. Let x be totally ergodic (with respect to T ). Then Freq(x) is countable. Proof. We can assume that X is separable, as we may replace X by span{T (t)x : t ≥ 0}. Let M := supt≥0 T (t) . Then
αR(α + iη, A) ≤ M (α > 0, η ∈ R). t Let xη := Mη x = limt→∞ 1t 0 e−iηs T (s)x ds (η ∈ R). For η ∈ Freq(x), let yη := xη / xη . Then yη = 1 and αR(α + iη, A)yη = yη (α > 0) and for μ ∈ Freq(x), μ = η, αR(α + iη, A)yμ =
α yμ α + iη − iμ
(α > 0).
Let μ, η ∈ Freq(x) such that η > μ. Then for α > 0, M yη − yμ
Choosing α = η − μ, we obtain
≥
αR(α + iη, A)(yη − yμ )
α
= yη − yμ α + iη − iμ α ≥ 1− α + iη − iμ 1 . = 1− 1 + i(η − μ)/α
1 1 − i = 1 − √1 > 0. M yη − yμ ≥ 1 − =1− 1+i 2 2
268
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
If Freq(x) is uncountable this contradicts the fact that X is separable. It follows from Corollary 4.3.5 that every bounded C0 -semigroup on a reflexive Banach space is totally ergodic. This can be generalized as follows. Proposition 4.3.12. Assume that the vector x ∈ X has relatively weakly compact orbit {T (t)x : t ≥ 0}. Then x is totally ergodic with respect to T . Proof. It follows from the assumption that {e−iηt T (t)x : t ≥ 0} is relatively weakly compact for all η ∈ R. By Krein’s theorem [Meg98, Theorem 2.8.14], the closed convex K := co{e−iηt T (t)x : t ≥ 0} is weakly compact. Since αR(α + ∞ hull −αt −iηt iη, A)x = 0 αe e T (t)x dt ∈ K for all α > 0, condition (i) of Proposition t 4.3.1 is satisfied and so 1t 0 e−iηt T (t)x dt converges as t → ∞, by Proposition 4.3.1. Next we consider positive C0 -semigroups on L1 -spaces. Proposition 4.3.13. Let X = L1 (Ω, μ) where (Ω, μ) is a σ-finite measure space. Let T be a bounded positive C0 -semigroup on X. If f ∈ X+ is ergodic at 0, then f is totally ergodic. Proof. Since αR(α, A)f converges as α ↓ 0, the set K := {αR(α, A)f : 0 < α ≤ 1} is relatively compact. It follows that the solid hull so(K) := {g ∈ X : |g| ≤ k for some k ∈ K} is relatively weakly compact (by [AB85, Theorem 13.8]). Let η ∈ R. Then ∞ −t(α+iη) |αR(α + iη, A)f | = αe T (t)f dt 0∞ ≤ αe−αt T (t)f dt = αR(α, A)f. 0
Thus, αR(α + iη, A)f ∈ so(K) for 0 < α ≤ 1. Consequently, condition (i) of Proposition 4.3.1 is satisfied. In particular, if T is a positive bounded C0 -semigroup on L1 (Ω, μ), then T is totally ergodic whenever T is Ces`aro-ergodic. Here is a criterion which is sometimes convenient for verifying total ergodicity. Proposition 4.3.14. Let X := L1 (Ω, μ), where (Ω, μ) is a σ-finite measure space. Let T be a positive bounded C0 -semigroup on X. Assume that there exists a function u ∈ X such that u > 0 μ-a.e. and T (t)u ≤ u for all t ≥ 0. Then T is totally ergodic. Proof. Suppose that f ∈ X and 0 ≤ f ≤ u. For α > 0, 0 ≤ αR(α, A)f ≤ αR(α, A)u ≤ u. Since {g ∈ X : 0 ≤ g ≤ u} is weakly compact (see [Sch74, Theorem II.5.10 and Proposition II.8.3]), it follows from Proposition 4.3.1 that limα↓0 αR(α, A)f exists.
4.3. ERGODIC SEMIGROUPS
269
Since {f ∈ X : 0 ≤ f ≤ u} is total in X, it follows that T is Abel-ergodic, and hence totally ergodic by Proposition 4.3.4 and Proposition 4.3.13. In Proposition 4.3.14, the condition of a subinvariant strictly positive function cannot be omitted. For example, the shift semigroup T on L1 (R+ ) given by (T (t)f )(x) = f (x + t) is not Ces`aro-ergodic since Ker A = {0}, but Ker A∗ = C · 1 (where 1 denotes the constant 1 function). Next, we return to general Banach spaces, but we consider the special case where the Abel means in Proposition 4.3.1 converge with respect to the operator norm. Let A be an operator on X. We say that 0 is a simple pole of the resolvent if {λ ∈ C : 0 < |λ| < ε} ⊂ ρ(A) for some ε > 0 and there exists 0 = P ∈ L(X) such that P R(λ, A) − (4.11) λ has a holomorphic extension to the disc B(0, ε) := {λ ∈ C : |λ| < ε}. For example, if A generates a bounded C0 -semigroup T , 0 ∈ σ(A) and A has compact resolvent, then 0 is a simple pole. Indeed, if P is the spectral projection of A associated with {0}, then Am P = 0 for some m ∈ N (see Proposition B.9 and the subsequent remarks). It follows that T (t)P =
m−1 n n=0
t An P n!
(t ≥ 0).
Since T is bounded, AP = 0. Hence, R(λ, A) = R(λ, AZ )(I − P ) + P/λ, where Z = (I − P )(X) and AZ is the part of A in Z. Since 0 ∈ σ(AZ ), the claim follows. Proposition 4.3.15. Let A be an operator on X. The following assertions are equivalent: (i) There exists λ0 > 0 such that (0, λ0 ) ⊂ ρ(A) and P := limλ↓0 λR(λ, A) converges in the operator norm. (ii) 0 is a simple pole of the resolvent, or 0 ∈ ρ(A). (iii) The range Ran A is closed, (0, λ0 ) ⊂ ρ(A) for some λ0 > 0 and λR(λ, A) converges in the strong operator topology as λ ↓ 0.
270
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
Proof. (i) ⇒ (ii): It follows from Proposition 4.3.2 that X = Ker A⊕Ran A and that P is the projection onto Ker A along Y := Ran A. Since P commutes with R(λ, A), we may consider the part AY of A in Y . Then (0, λ0 ) ⊂ ρ(AY ) and R(λ, AY ) = R(λ, A)|Y for λ ∈ (0, λ0 ) (see Proposition B.8). Since P = 0 on Y , it follows that limλ↓0 λR(λ, AY ) = 0. So there exists λ > 0 such that λR(λ, AY ) ≤ 12 . Hence, dist(λ, σ(AY )) ≥ R(λ, AY ) −1 ≥ 2λ (see Corollary B.3). Thus 0 ∈ ρ(AY ), and so R(λ, A)|Y has a holomorphic extension to B(0, ε) for some ε > 0. Since R(λ, A) = P/λ + R(λ, AY )(I − P ) (λ ∈ ρ(AY ), λ = 0), this implies (ii). It also shows that Ran A = Ran(AY ) = Y is closed. (ii) ⇒ (i): It follows from (4.11) that limλ↓0 λR(λ, A) = P in L(X). (i) ⇒ (iii): Strong convergence is trivial from (i). It has been shown above that Ran A is closed. (iii) ⇒ (ii): By assumption, Y := Ran A is closed and X = Ker A ⊕ Y by Corollary 4.3.2. Thus, the part AY in Y is invertible. Let P be the projection onto Ker A along Y . Since R(λ, A) = P/λ + R(λ, AY )(I − P ) (λ ∈ ρ(AY ), λ = 0), the result follows. Next, we show a very peculiar phenomenon on the space X := L∞ (Ω, μ), where (Ω, μ) is a measure space. Such a space has two remarkable properties concerning convergence of sequences, namely xn → 0 weakly in X and x∗n → 0 weakly in X ∗ (DP ) implies xn , x∗n → 0 as n → ∞; and x∗n → 0 weak* in X ∗ implies (G) x∗n → 0 weakly in X ∗ as n → ∞. The first property is called the Dunford-Pettis property. A space having the second property is called a Grothendieck space. It is obvious that the properties (DP) and (G) are inherited by complemented subspaces. We refer to [Sch74, Theorems II.9.7 and II.10.4] for a proof that L∞ (Ω, μ) has these properties. The key argument involving these two properties is expressed in the following lemma. Lemma 4.3.16. Let X be a Banach space such that (G) and (DP) are satisfied. Suppose that Tn ∈ L(X) (n ∈ N) such that lim Tn x = 0 for all x ∈ X
n→∞
and lim Tn∗ x∗ = 0 for all x∗ ∈ X ∗ .
n→∞
Then lim Tn2 = 0.
n→∞
4.3. ERGODIC SEMIGROUPS
271
Proof. Assume that Tn2 does not converge to 0. Then there exist ε > 0 and a subsequence such that Tn2k ≥ 2ε. By the Hahn-Banach theorem, we find xk ∈ X, x∗k ∈ X ∗ such that xk = x∗k = 1 but Tn xk , T ∗ x∗ = T 2 xk , x∗ ≥ ε. (4.12) nk k nk k k Let yk := Tnk xk , yk∗ := Tn∗k x∗k . Then for x∗ ∈ X ∗ , |yk , x∗ | = |xk , Tn∗k x∗ | ≤ Tn∗k x∗ → 0
as k → ∞.
Thus, yk → 0 weakly. Let x ∈ X. Then |x, yk∗ | = |Tnk x, x∗k | ≤ Tnk x → 0
as k → ∞.
Thus, yk∗ → 0 weak*. It follows from (G) that yk∗ → 0 weakly. Now, (DP) implies that yk , yk∗ → 0 as k → ∞. This contradicts (4.12). The following surprising result holds in particular on a space X := L∞ (Ω, μ) for any measure space (Ω, μ). Theorem 4.3.17. Let X be a Banach space satisfying (DP) and (G). Let A be a densely defined operator on X such that (0, λ0 ) ⊂ ρ(A) for some λ0 > 0. If λR(λ, A)x converges weakly as λ ↓ 0 for all x ∈ X, then λR(λ, A) converges in L(X) as λ ↓ 0. Proof. It follows from Corollary 4.3.2 that P x := limλ↓0 λR(λ, A)x converges in norm for all x ∈ X, and that X = Ker A ⊕ Ran A. Replacing A by its part in Ran A, we can assume that Ker A = 0 and so P = 0. Let x∗ ∈ X ∗ . Then for x ∈ X we have x, λR(λ, A)∗ x∗ = λR(λ, A)x, x∗ → 0
as λ ↓ 0.
Hence, λR(λ, A)∗ x∗ → 0 weak* for all x∗ ∈ X ∗ . It follows from (G) that λn R(λn , A)∗ x∗ → 0 weakly whenever λn ↓ 0, for all x∗ ∈ X ∗ . Now Corollary 4.3.2 implies that λR(λ, A)∗ x∗ → 0 as λ ↓ 0, for all x∗ ∈ X ∗ . We have shown that Tn := λn R(λn , A) satisfies the hypotheses of Lemma 4.3.16 whenever λn ↓ 0. It follows that (λR(λ, A))2 → 0 as λ ↓ 0. Since (λR(λ, A))2 = (I + AR(λ, A))2 , it follows that r(I + AR(λ, A)) ≤ (I + AR(λ, A))2 1/2 < 1 for λ > 0 small (where r(I + AR(λ, A)) denotes the spectral radius). This implies that AR(λ, A) is invertible. In particular, Ran A = X. Now the claim follows from Proposition 4.3.15. It is also interesting to consider convergence of λR(λ, A) for λ → ∞. Again, the following result holds in particular on a space X = L∞ (Ω, μ), where (Ω, μ) is a measure space.
272
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
Theorem 4.3.18. Let X be a Banach space satisfying (DP) and (G). Let A be a densely defined operator on X such that (λ0 , ∞) ⊂ ρ(A) and supλ>λ0 λR(λ, A) < ∞ for some λ0 . Then A is bounded. Proof. By Lemma 3.3.12, limn→∞ (nR(n, A)x − x) = 0 for all x ∈ X. Let x∗ ∈ X ∗ . Then it follows that x, nR(n, A)∗ x∗ − x∗ = nR(n, A)x − x, x∗ → 0
as n → ∞,
for all x ∈ X. Thus, (nR(n, A)∗ − I)x∗ → 0 weak* as n → ∞. It follows from (G) that (nR(n, A)∗ − I)x∗ → 0 weakly as n → ∞, for all x∗ ∈ X ∗ . But this implies that x∗ is in the weak closure of D(A∗ ) = R(λ, A∗ )X ∗ (λ ≥ λ0 ) for all x∗ ∈ X ∗ . Since the weak and norm closures coincide, A∗ is densely defined. It follows as above that (nR(n, A)∗ − I)x∗ → 0 as n → ∞, for all x∗ ∈ X ∗ . Now Lemma 4.3.16 implies that (nR(n, A) − I)2 → 0 as n → ∞. In particular, r((nR(n, A) − I)) ≤ (nR(n, A) − I)2 1/2 < 1 for n sufficiently large. This implies that nR(n, A) is invertible. Hence, D(A) = X, so A is bounded by the closed graph theorem. We deduce from Theorem 4.3.18 the following surprising and important result. Corollary 4.3.19 (Lotz). Let T be a C0 -semigroup on the Banach space L∞ (Ω, μ), where (Ω, μ) is a measure space. Then T has a bounded generator. In other words, if a semigroup T defined on X := L∞ (Ω, μ) converges strongly to the identity as t ↓ 0, it converges already in the operator norm.
4.4 Complex Tauberian Theorems: the Contour Method ∞ Let f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X) and let fˆ(λ) = 0 e−λt f (t) dt (Re λ > 0) be its Laplace transform. We define the half-line spectrum sp(f ) of f by sp(f ) := η ∈ R : fˆ does not have a holomorphic extension to an open neighbourhood of iη in C .
It turns out that countability of the spectrum with certain growth conditions is a Tauberian hypothesis. Here we prove a Tauberian theorem of type D by completely elementary contour arguments. For simplicity, we consider first the simplest case where the spectrum is empty, giving a qualitative result (Theorem 4.4.1) and then a quantified version (Theorem 4.4.6). Then we adapt the argument to the case when the spectrum consists of one point (Theorem 4.4.8). This suffices for many interesting applications (see Corollaries 4.4.12 and 4.4.13 and Theorems 4.4.14 and 4.4.16) but we shall prove some more general results in Sections 4.7 and 4.9 by other means. In Theorem 4.4.18 we give a related result under different assumptions on f and fˆ, and using a different contour method.
4.4. THE CONTOUR METHOD
273
Theorem 4.4.1. Let f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X), and assume that sp(f ) is empty. Then t lim f (s) ds = fˆ(0). t→∞
0
Here, fˆ denotes the holomorphic extension of fˆ to a neighbourhood of 0. As usual, we will denote the open right half-plane {λ ∈ C : Re λ > 0} by C+ . Proof. We can assume that fˆ(0) = 0. Otherwise, we replace f by f − χ(0,1) fˆ(0). There is a simply connected open set Ω containing C+ such that fˆ has a holomorphic extension (also denoted by fˆ) to Ω. t Let gt (λ) := 0 e−λs f (s) ds (λ ∈ C, t ≥ 0). Let R > 1, and γ be a contour consisting of the semi-circle {λ ∈ C : |λ| = R, Re λ > 0} and a path γ connecting iR with −iR and lying entirely in Ω ∩ {Re λ < 0} (except at the endpoints). Let λ2 . R2 Since h(0) = 1, it follows from Cauchy’s theorem that 1 dλ eλt fˆ(λ)h(λ) ; 0 = −fˆ(0) = − 2πi γ λ t 1 dλ f (s) ds = gt (0) = eλt gt (λ)h(λ) . 2πi λ 0 |λ|=R h(λ) := 1 +
Adding up, we have t f (s) ds 0
=
1 2πi
|λ|=R Re λ>0
dλ eλt (gt (λ) − fˆ(λ))h(λ) λ
1 dλ eλt fˆ(λ)h(λ) 2πi γ λ 1 dλ + eλt gt (λ)h(λ) |λ|=R 2πi Re λ<0 λ −
=: I1 (t) + I2 (t) + I3 (t).
(4.13)
We estimate these three integrals separately. I1 (t): Let λ := Reiθ , θ ∈ (− π2 , π2 ). Then
∞
λ(t−s)
eλt (gt (λ) − fˆ(λ)) = e f (s) ds
t
∞
−λs
= e f (s + t) ds
0
h(λ) λ
≤
f ∞
f ∞ = ; Re λ R cos θ
≤
|1 + e2iθ |
1 2 cos θ = . R R
274
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
Thus,
1 f ∞ 2
f ∞ πR = (t ≥ 0). 2π R R R I2 (t): Note that limt→∞ I2 (t) = 0 by the dominated convergence theorem. I3 (t): Let λ := Reiθ , θ ∈ ( π2 , 3π ). Then 2
I1 (t) ≤
t
λ(t−s)
e gt (λ) = e f (s) ds
λt
0
h(λ) λ
Hence,
I3 (t) ≤
t
≤
f ∞
≤
2| cos θ| . R
0
eRs cos θ ds ≤
f ∞ ; R | cos θ|
1 f ∞ 2
f ∞ πR = . 2π R R R
These estimates give
t
2 f ∞
lim sup f (s) ds
≤ R . t→∞ 0
(4.14)
Letting R → ∞ proves the claim. From the proof above we deduce the following. Proposition 4.4.2. Let f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X). If R > 0 such that sp(f ) ∩ [−R, R] = ∅, then
t
2 ˆ
lim sup f (s) ds − f (0) ≤ lim sup f (t) .
R t→∞ t→∞ 0 Proof. Let c > lim supt→∞ f (t) . Choose τ ≥ 0 such that f (t+ τ ) ≤ c for all τ t ≥ 0 and apply the estimate (4.14) to f (· + τ ) − χ(0,1) fˆ(0) − 0 f (s) ds . The next two corollaries follow from Proposition 4.4.2 by replacing f (t) by e−iηt f (t). Corollary 4.4.3. Let f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X). If η ∈ sp(f ), then
t
−iηs
sup e f (s) ds
< ∞. t≥0
0
Corollary 4.4.4. Let f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X) such that limt→∞ f (t) = 0. Then
t
fˆ(iη) = lim
t→∞
for all η ∈ R\sp(f ).
0
e−iηs f (s) ds
4.4. THE CONTOUR METHOD
275
Next we give a quantified version of Theorem 4.4.1. When sp(f ) is empty, there is a continuous increasing function M : R+ → (0, ∞) such that fˆ has a holomorphic extension (also denoted by fˆ) to 1 ΩM := λ ∈ C : Re λ > − M (| Im λ|) and fˆ(λ) ≤ M (| Im λ|) for all λ ∈ ΩM . Define Mlog (s) = M (s) [log(1 + M (s)) + log(1 + s)] −1 for s ∈ R+ . The inverse Mlog of Mlog is an increasing function of (Mlog (0), ∞) onto (0, ∞). Although we do not require M to be strictly increasing, we shall let M −1 denote any increasing function from the range of M to R+ such that M (M −1 (t)) = t for all t in the range of M . −1 Example 4.4.5. a) If M is bounded, then Mlog (t) ∼ Cet as t → ∞, for some constant C. b) If M (s) = β(1 + s)α where α, β > 0, then 1/α t −1 Mlog (t) ∼ Cα,β as t → ∞, log t
for some constant Cα,β . −1 c) If M (s) = βeαs where α, β > 0, then Mlog (t) ∼
1 α
log t as t → ∞.
∞
Theorem 4.4.6. Let f ∈ L (R+ , X), and assume that sp(f ) is empty. Let M and Mlog be as above, and c ∈ (0, 1). Then there exist constants C and t0 , depending only on f ∞ , M and c, such that
t
C ˆ
f (s) ds − f (0) (4.15)
≤ M −1 (ct) for all t ≥ t0 . 0 log −1 Remark 4.4.7. In (4.15), the function Mlog cannot be replaced by M −1 in general. For example, if X = C and f (t) = e−t , then the assumptions of Theorem 4.4.6 are satisfied for any continuous increasing function M with M (0) = 1. So M −1 may increase arbitrarily fast, but t f (s) ds − fˆ(0) = −e−t . 0
−1 On the other hand, M −1 and Mlog behave similarly if M increases rapidly and consistently (see Example 4.4.5). We shall see in Theorem 4.4.14 that, in the −1 context of C0 -semigroups, Mlog (ct) can never be replaced in (4.15) by a function −1 increasing faster than M (Ct) if M is chosen in the optimal way. Example 4.4.15 −1 will show that it may not be possible to replace Mlog by M −1 in (4.15) when M increases arbitrarily rapidly but inconsistently.
276
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
Proof of Theorem 4.4.6. We use the same method and notation as in the proof of Theorem 4.4.1, taking Ω = ΩM and choosing γ and R as follows. Let a = c−1/2 > 1 and take γ to be the union of γ0 , γ+ and γ− , where γ0 (s) γ± (τ )
= −
1 aM (|s|)
= τ ± iR
(−R ≤ s ≤ R) , (−(aM (R))−1 ≤ τ ≤ 0) .
On γ± , |h(λ)| ≤ C/R, so we can estimate the norm of the integral I2 (t) over γ± by
(aM (R))−1
dλ 1 e−tτ CM (R)
λt ˆ e f (λ)h(λ) M (R) dτ ≤ .
≤C
γ± λ R R R2 t 0 Here and subsequently, C denotes a constant which may depend only on M , c and f ∞ , although it may vary from place to place. On γ0 , h(λ) is bounded independently of R, and |etλ | ≤ e−t/aM (R) . Hence, we can estimate the norm of the integral over γ0 by
dλ
eλt fˆ(λ)h(λ) dλ ≤ CM (R)e−t/aM (R) ≤ CM (R)(1+log R)e−t/aM (R) .
λ γ0 γ0 λ With these estimates for I2 (t) and those in the proof of Theorem 4.4.1 for I1 (t) and I3 (t), we obtain
t
2 f ∞ M (R) −t/aM (R)
f (s) ds ≤ +C + M (R)(1 + log R)e .
R R2 t 0 −1 Given t > c−1 Mlog (1), choose R = Mlog (ct) > 1. Then
M (R) c C = ≤ , 2 2 R t 2R log ((1 + M (R))(1 + R)) R (1 + M (R))a (1 + R)a C M (R)(1 + log R) ≤ C = et/aM(R) . R R Hence
t
C C
f (s) ds
≤ R = M −1 (ct) . 0 log
Now we consider the case when sp(f ) is a single point, stating only the qualitative result. Theorem 4.4.8. Let f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X), and assume that sp(f ) = {η} and
t
−iηs
sup e f (s) ds
< ∞, t≥0
where η ∈ R\{0}. Then limt→∞
0
t 0
f (s) ds = fˆ(0).
(4.16)
4.4. THE CONTOUR METHOD
277
Remark 4.4.9. The growth condition (4.16) in Theorem 4.4.8 cannot be omitted. For example, let f (t) := eit . Then fˆ(λ) = (λ − i)−1 , so sp(f ) = {1}. However, t f (s) ds = 1i (eit − 1) does not converge as t → ∞. 0 Proof of Theorem 4.4.8. The proof is similar to Theorem 4.4.1, with the following changes. a) We take R > |η| and 0 < ε < min{|η|, R −|η|}. The path γ now consists of two separate paths connecting iR with i(η + ε) and connecting i(η − ε) with −iR. It lies entirely in a simply connected domain where fˆ is defined holomorphically, and also in {Re λ < 0} (except at the four endpoints). The contour γ includes also the semi-circle {λ ∈ C : |λ − iη| = ε, Re λ > 0}. b) Let ε2 η2 λ2 h(λ) := 1 + 1+ 2 . (λ − iη)2 (η 2 − ε2 ) R For λ = Reiθ , we have h(λ) λ
ε2 η2 1 1+ |1 + e2iθ | 2 2 2 (R − |η|) η −ε R 2 2 ε η 2| cos θ| = 1+ . (R − |η|)2 η 2 − ε2 R ≤
(4.17)
c) In (4.13) we have two additional integrals: 1 dλ I4 (t) := eλt (gt (λ) − fˆ(λ))h(λ) ; |λ−iη|=ε 2πi Re λ>0 λ 1 dλ 1 dλ I5 (t) := − eλt gt (λ)h(λ) = eλt gt (λ)h(λ) . |λ−iη|=ε 2πi |λ−iη|=ε λ 2πi λ Re λ>0 Re λ<0 We estimate these integrals as follows: t I4 (t): Let λ := iη + εeiθ , θ ∈ (− π2 , π2 ). Let F1 (t) := 0 e−iηs f (s) ds. Then by assumption (4.16), K := supt≥0 F1 (t) < ∞. We have
λt ∞ −λs
eλt (gt (λ) − fˆ(λ)) = e e f (s) ds
t
∞
λt
−εseiθ d
= e e F (s) ds 1
ds t
∞
λt −εteiθ
λt iθ −εseiθ
= −e e F1 (t) + e εe e F1 (s) ds
t
∞
iθ ≤ K +ε e−εe (s−t) F1 (s) ds
t K 1 ≤ K +ε =K 1+ ; ε cos θ cos θ
278
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS h(λ) λ
≤
|1 + e−2iθ |
η2 1 η2 1 2 = 2 cos θ 2 . η 2 − ε2 |η| − ε η 2 − ε2 |η| − ε
Consequently,
I4 (t) ≤
1 η2 1 η2 1 K2 · 2 2 2 επ = 4Kε . 2π η − ε2 |η| − ε η 2 − ε2 |η| − ε
I5 (t): Let λ := iη + εeiθ , θ ∈ ( π2 , 3π 2 ). Then
e gt (λ)
λt
t
λt −λs
= e e f (s) ds
0
t
λt −εseiθ d
= e e F1 (s) ds
ds 0
t
λt −εteiθ
iθ λt −εseiθ
= e e F1 (t) + εe e e F1 (s) ds
≤ K + εK ≤ K 1+
0
t
e−ε(s−t) cos θ ds 1 . | cos θ| 0
Thus, as for I4 (t) one obtains
I5 (t) ≤ 4Kε
η2
η2 1 . − ε2 |η| − ε
d) The estimates for I1 (t) and I3 (t) now include additional factors appearing in (4.17). The dominated convergence theorem shows that limt→∞ I2 (t) = 0. Thus, we obtain that
t
lim sup f (s) ds
t→∞ 0 2 f ∞ ε2 η2 η2 1 ≤ 1+ + 8Kε . R (R − |η|)2 η 2 − ε2 η 2 − ε2 |η| − ε Letting ε ↓ 0, we obtain
t
2 f ∞
lim sup f (s) ds
≤ R . t→∞ 0 Finally, letting R → ∞ proves the claim. We derive from Theorem 4.4.8 a Tauberian theorem of type E for slowly oscillating functions.
4.4. THE CONTOUR METHOD
279
Corollary 4.4.10. Let f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X) be slowly oscillating. Assume that a) sp(f ) = ∅, or b) sp(f ) = {η} and supt≥0
t 0
e−iηs f (s) ds < ∞, where η ∈ R.
Then limt→∞ f (t) = 0. Proof. We give the proof in the case when sp(f ) = {η}. a) Assume that η = 0. For δ > 0, consider fδ (t) := before. It follows from (4.1) that sp(fδ ) ⊂ {η}. Moreover, t
−iηs
e 0
fδ (s) ds = δ
δ+t
−1
e
iη(δ−s)
f (s) ds −
δ
1 (f (δ δ
+ t) − f (t)) as
t
e
−iηs
f (s) ds ,
0
t which is bounded. It follows from Theorem 4.4.8 that limt→∞ 0 fδ (s) ds = fδ (0) = δ − 1δ 0 f (s) ds (by (4.1)). Hence, B- limt→∞ f (t) = 0 by Lemma 4.2.12. Theorem 4.2.3 implies that limt→∞ f (t) = 0. b) Assume that η = 0. Let g(t) := eit f (t). g is bounded and slowly
Then
t −is
oscillating. Moreover, sp(g) ⊂ {i} and supt≥0 0 e g(s) ds < ∞. It follows from a) that limt→∞ g(t) = 0. Hence, limt→∞ f (t) = 0. Corollary 4.4.11. Let f : R+ → X be Lipschitz continuous such that
t
sup f (s) ds
< ∞. t≥0
(4.18)
0
Assume that sp(f ) ⊂ {0}. Then limt→∞ f (t) = 0. Note that (4.18) implies that C- limt→∞ f (t) = 0. Thus, Corollary 4.4.11 is a Tauberian theorem of type A. Proof of Corollary 4.4.11. We show that f is bounded. Then we can apply Corolt lary 4.4.10. Let F (t) := 0 f (s) ds. By assumption, M := supt≥0 F (t) < ∞. Moreover, there exists L ≥ 0 such that
f (t) − f (s) ≤ L|t − s| (t, s ≥ 0). Let x∗ ∈ X ∗ such that x∗ ≤ 1. Then x∗ ◦ f is differentiable a.e. and d ∗ (x ◦ f ) (t) ≤ L (t ≥ 0). dt The Taylor expansion for x∗ ◦ F yields for s ≥ 0, s+1 d F (s + 1), x∗ = F (s), x∗ + f (s), x∗ + (s + 1 − t) f (t), x∗ dt. dt s
280
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
Hence, ∗
|f (s), x |
≤ 2M +
s+1
(s + 1 − t) · L dt
s
=
2M +
L . 2
The Hahn-Banach theorem implies that f (s) ≤ 2M + 12 L (s ≥ 0). Corollary 4.4.10 and 4.4.11 are first versions of a complex Tauberian theorem where the main hypothesis says that the spectrum is sufficiently small. Generalizations will be given in Section 4.7 (Corollary 4.7.8) and in Section 4.9 (Theorem 4.9.7). The proof of both generalizations will make use of Gelfand’s theorem which we obtain now as another immediate consequence of the contour method. In fact, applying Corollary 4.4.11 to bounded groups we obtain the following result. Corollary 4.4.12 (Gelfand). Let A be the generator of a bounded C0 -group U = (U (t))t∈R on X. If σ(A) ⊂ {0}, then U (t) = I for all t ∈ R. In particular, if σ(A) is empty, then X = {0}. t Proof. Let x ∈ D(A2 ), f (t) := AU (t)x. Then 0 f (s) ds = U (t)x − x, which d is bounded. Since fˆ(λ) = R(λ, A)Ax, we have sp(f ) ⊂ {0}. Since dt f (t) = 2 U (t)A x, the function f is Lipschitz continuous. It follows from Corollary 4.4.11 that limt→∞ f (t) = 0. Let M := supt∈R U (t) . Since Ax = U (−t)U (t)Ax ≤ M U (t)Ax , it follows that Ax = 0. Hence, U (t)x = x for all x ∈ D(A2 ), t ∈ R. Since R(1, A) has dense range D(A), the range D(A2 ) of R(1, A)2 is also dense. It follows that U (t) = I (t ∈ R). When σ(A) is empty, one can also apply the previous case to A − iη for any η ∈ R. Corollary 4.4.13. Let A be the generator of a bounded C0 -group U . Then each isolated point in σ(A) is an eigenvalue. Proof. Let iη ∈ σ(A) be isolated. Consider the spectral projection P associated with iη, and let Y := P X = {0} (see Proposition B.9). Then the group leaves the space Y invariant. Consider the restricted group. The spectrum of its generator is reduced to {iη}. Applying Corollary 4.4.12 to e−iηt U (t)|Y , one obtains that e−iηt U (t)y = y for all y ∈ Y . Next, we prove a result on the asymptotic behaviour of a bounded C0 semigroup T with generator A, specifically the possible decay of T (t)R(μ, A)
for large t, where μ ∈ ρ(A) is fixed. Note that the rate of any such decay is independent of the choice of μ up to multiplicative constants, since (μ − A)R(μ, A) is always a bounded operator. Let m : R+ → (0, ∞) be a continuous decreasing function such that m(t) → 0 as t → ∞. We let m−1 denote any decreasing function from (0, ∞) to R+ such that m(m−1 (t)) = t for all t in the range of m.
4.4. THE CONTOUR METHOD
281
Theorem 4.4.14. Let A be the generator of a bounded C0 -semigroup T , and let μ ∈ ρ(A). The following are equivalent: (i) σ(A) ∩ iR is empty. (ii) limt→∞ T (t)R(μ, A) = 0. More precisely: a) Assume that σ(A) ∩ iR is empty, and let M : R+ → (0, ∞) be a continuous increasing function such that R(is, A) ≤ M (|s|) for all s ∈ R, and let c ∈ (0, 1). Then there exist C and t0 such that
T (t)R(μ, A) ≤
C −1 Mlog (ct)
for all t ≥ t0 .
(4.19)
b) Assume that limt→∞ T (t)R(μ, A) = 0, and let m : R+ → (0, ∞) be a continuous decreasing function such that T (t)R(μ, A) ≤ m(t) for t ≥ 0 and limt→∞ m(t) = 0. Then σ(A) ∩ iR is empty, and for each c ∈ (0, 1) there exist C and s0 such that c
R(is, A) ≤ Cm−1 whenever |s| ≥ s0 . |s| Proof. The implication from (1) to (2) can be seen from Theorem 4.4.1 with f (t) = T (t). Although that function is not measurable from R+ to L(X), its Laplace transform fˆ(λ) = R(λ, A) is holomorphic, and the proof of Theorem 4.4.1 remains valid. Alternatively, we give the following more precise argument for a). We let K = supt≥0 T (t) . a) First, by Corollary B.3, for any a > 1, ΩaM ⊂ ρ(A) and R(λ, A) ≤ a M (| Im λ|) for all λ ∈ ΩaM . a−1 Let x ∈ X with x ≤ (a − 1)/a, and let f (t) = T (t)x (t ≥ 0). Then
f ∞ ≤ K and fˆ(λ) = R(λ, A)x, so fˆ(λ) ≤ M (| Im λ|) for λ ∈ ΩaM . By Proposition 3.1.9 e), t T (t)R(μ, A)x = R(μ, A)x + AR(μ, A) f (s) ds 0 t = AR(μ, A) f (s) ds − fˆ(0) . 0
Since AR(μ, A) is a bounded operator, the result follows from Theorem 4.4.8 and its proof, noting that C and t0 are independent of x for x ≤ (a − 1)/a. b) Take s ∈ R, and consider x∗ ∈ D(A∗ ) with A∗ x∗ = isx∗ . Let x ∈ D(A), and put g(t) = e−ist T (t)x, x∗ (t ≥ 0). Then g (t) = e−ist AT (t)x − isT (t)x, x∗ = 0,
282
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
so g is constant. By the assumption (ii), limt→∞ T (t)x = 0, so limt→∞ g(t) = 0. Hence 0 = g(0) = x, x∗ . Since D(A) is dense, it follows that x∗ = 0. By the Hahn-Banach theorem, A − is has dense range. Let c ∈ (c, 1), and x ∈ D(A). By Proposition 3.1.9 f) applied to the rescaled semigroup, t
0
e−isτ T (τ )(A − is)x dτ = e−ist T (t)x − x
for any t ≥ 0. Hence, Kt (A − is)x
t
−isτ
≥ e T (τ )(A − is)x dτ
0
≥ ≥ ≥
x − T (t)x
x − m(t) (A − μ)x
! "
x − m(t) (A − is)x + (|μ| + |s|) x .
Thus,
(A − is)x ≥
1 − m(t)(|μ| + |s|)
x . Kt + m(t)
Let t = m−1 (c /(|μ| + |s|)), so m(t) ≤ c /(|μ| + |s|). Thus,
(A − is)x ≥
(1 − c ) x
. Km−1 (c /(|μ| + |s|)) + c /(|μ| + |s|)
This implies that A − is has closed range, and hence it is invertible. Moreover, K c c c −1 −1
R(is, A) ≤ m + ≤ Cm 1 − c |μ| + |s| (1 − c )(|μ| + |s|) |s| whenever |s| is sufficiently large. Part a) of Theorem 4.4.14 gives the sharpest result when M is chosen as small as possible, that is, M (s) = sup { R(is , A) : |s | ≤ s} . Then part b) provides the lower bound
T (t)R(μ, A) ≥
c M −1 (Ct)
for t sufficiently large and some constants c > 0 and C, and the sharpest estimate is given by taking M −1 (t) = inf{|s| : R(is, A) ≥ t}. Then the gap between this lower bound and the upper bound in (4.19) is small if M grows rapidly. To understand this more explicitly, we consider diagonal semigroups on Hilbert space.
4.4. THE CONTOUR METHOD
283
Example 4.4.15. Let X = 2 , (αn )n∈N be a strictly decreasing sequence in (0, 1], and λn = −αn + in. A C0 -semigroup of contractions on 2 is defined by ! " T (t)x = eλn t xn (x = (xn ) ∈ 2 ). The generator A is given by ' ( ' ( D(A) = x ∈ 2 : (λn xn ) ∈ 2 = x ∈ 2 : (nxn ) ∈ 2 , Ax = (λn xn ). Moreover, {λn : n ∈ N}, ' (
R(is, A) = sup |λn − is|−1 : n ∈ N . σ(A)
=
Take the optimal definitions of M and M −1 as above. Then M (k) = R(ik, A) = 1/αk (k ∈ N). Let tk = 1/αk . Then λ t −1 e n k e−1 e−1 −1 ≥ e
T (tk )A = sup ∼ = as k → ∞. λn |λk | k M −1 (tk ) n∈N When (αn ) decays regularly and not too slowly, we may have
T (t)A−1 ∼
c M −1 (t)
as t → ∞.
(4.20)
For example, when αn = n−γ where γ > 0,
T (t)A−1 ∼
cγ cγ ∼ −1 . M (t) t1/γ
On the other hand, (4.20) may fail if (αn ) has relatively long periods of slow decay. Suppose for example that (αn ) is strictly decreasing and α(k+1)! ≥
αk!+1 2
(k ≥ 1).
Given c > 0, let tk = 1/(cα(k+1)! ). Then M −1 (ctk ) = (k + 1)!, λ −2/c e k!+1 tk ke−2/c −1 ≥ e
T (tk )A ≥ ∼ . λk!+1 |λk!+1 | M −1 (ctk ) Thus there is no upper bound of the form T (t)A−1 ≤ C/M −1 (ct). By arranging that the subsequence (αk! ) decreases arbitrarily fast, this phenomenon can be found even when M increases arbitrarily fast.
284
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
The next result on asymptotic behaviour of C0 -semigroups is analogous to the Katznelson-Tzafriri theorem for contractions (see the Notes of this chapter). A C0 -semigroup T = (T (t))t≥0 is called eventually differentiable if there exists τ ≥ 0 such that T (τ )X ⊂ D(A). Semigroup properties imply that T (t)X ⊂ D(A) for all t ≥ τ and T (t)X ⊂ D(A2 ) for all t ≥ 2τ . By the closed graph theorem, AT (t) ∈ L(X) for t ≥ τ and A2 T (t) ∈ L(X) for t ≥ 2τ . Theorem 4.4.16. Let A be the generator of an eventually differentiable, bounded C0 -semigroup. The following are equivalent: (i) σ(A) ∩ iR ⊂ {0}. (ii) limt→∞ AT (t) = 0. Proof. Let K := supt≥0 T (t) . Assume that (i) holds. Let f : R+ → L(X) be defined by f (t) := AT (t + 2τ ). For x ∈ X,
s
d
f (t)x − f (s)x = (f (r)x) dr
t dr
s
2
= A T (r + 2τ )x dr
t
s
2
= T (r)A T (2τ )x dr
t
≤ K A2 T (2τ ) |t − s| x
(s, t ≥ 0).
Thus f is Lipschitz continuous. Moreover, fˆ(λ) = R(λ, A)AT (2τ ). Hence, we have t sp(f ) ⊂ {0}. Finally, 0 f (s) ds = T (t + 2τ ) − T (2τ ) ≤ 2K (t ≥ 0). It follows from Corollary 4.4.11 that limt→∞ f (t) = 0. Conversely, assume that (ii) holds. Let iη ∈ σ(A). By Proposition B.2 d), there exist xn ∈ D(A) with xn = 1 such that limn→∞ (A − iη)xn = 0. Then ! iηt " ! " iηe − AT (t) xn = iη eiηt − T (t) xn + T (t) (iη − A) xn t = iηeiηt e−iηs T (s)(iη − A)xn ds + T (t)(iη − A)xn → 0
0
as n → ∞.
Thus, iηeiηt ∈ σ(AT (t)). Hence, |η| = |iηeiηt | ≤ AT (t) for all t ≥ τ . Since limt→∞ AT (t) = 0, we conclude that η = 0. t Theorem 4.4.1 shows that limt→∞ 0 f (s) ds = fˆ(0) if f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X) and sp(f ) is empty. This is not true if the assumption that f is bounded is omitted (see Example 1.5.2). In the final part of this section we shall show that it is true if f is exponentially bounded and fˆ has a bounded holomorphic extension to a half-plane {λ : Re λ > −ε} for some ε > 0. Indeed, we shall show that abs(f ) ≤ hol0 (fˆ)
4.4. THE CONTOUR METHOD
285
whenever f is exponentially bounded, where hol0 (f ) := inf{ω ∈ R : fˆ has a bounded holomorphic extension for Re λ > ω} is the abscissa of boundedness of fˆ. We begin with a general estimate. Proposition 4.4.17. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) be exponentially bounded and suppose that hol(fˆ) ≤ 0 and fˆ is bounded on C+ . Then there is a constant C such that
∞
φ(t)f (t) dt
≤ C F φ 1 0
for all functions φ ∈ L1 (R+ ) such that F φ ∈ L1 (R) and φf ∈ L1 (R+ , X). Proof. First, we assume that φ has compact support and Fφ ∈ L1 (R). The ˆ Laplace transform φˆ is defined on C, and (F φ)(s) = φ(is) = (F φ)(−is). Take −ωt ω > max(0, ω(f )) and 0 < α < ω. The function t → e f (t) belongs to L1 (R+ , X) and its Fourier transform is s → fˆ(ω + is). Let ψ ∈ Cc∞ (R) with ψ(t) = e(ω−α)t whenever t ∈ supp φ. Then (F ψ) ∗ (Fφ) ∈ L1 (R). By the Fourier Inversion Theorem 1.8.1 d), F((Fψ) ∗ (Fφ))(t) = 4π 2 ψ(t)φ(t) = 4π 2 e(ω−α)t φ(t) for all t, and ((F ψ) ∗ (Fφ))(s) = 2π φ(α − ω − is) for all s. By Theorem 1.8.1 b), ∞ ∞ −αt e f (t)φ(t) dt = e−ωt f (t)e(ω−α)t φ(t) dt 0 0 ∞ 1 ˆ − ω − is) ds. = fˆ(ω + is)φ(α (4.21) 2π −∞ Now consider the contour integral ˆ − z) dz fˆ(z)φ(α around the rectangle with vertices α ± ir, ω ± ir, where r > 0. The integral along the bottom edge is ω ˆ − ξ + ir) dξ. fˆ(ξ − ir)φ(α α
For α < ξ < ω, ˆ − ξ + ir) = φ(α
∞
0
e−(α−ξ)t φ(t)e−irt dt → 0
as r → ∞, by the Riemann-Lebesgue lemma. Moreover, ∞ 1/2 1 ˆ 2ωt 2 √ φ(α − ξ + ir) ≤ e |φ(t)| dt , 2α 0
ˆ
f (ξ − ir) ≤ sup fˆ(z) , z∈C+
286
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
whenever r > 0, α < ξ < ω. By the dominated convergence theorem, ω ˆ − ξ + ir) dξ = 0. lim fˆ(ξ − ir)φ(α r→∞
α
A similar argument shows that the integral along the top edge of the rectangle tends to 0 as r → ∞. By Cauchy’s theorem, r r ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ lim f (ω + is)φ(α − ω − is) ds − f (α + is)φ(−is) ds = 0. r→∞
−r
−r
From (4.21),
∞
1 r→∞ 2π
e−αt f (t)φ(t) dt = lim
0
so
∞
0
r
fˆ(α + is)(F φ)(−s) ds,
−r
1
ˆ e−αt φ(t)f (t) dt ≤ sup f (z)
Fφ 1 .
2π z∈C +
Letting α ↓ 0 gives
0
∞
1 φ(t)f (t) dt sup fˆ(z) Fφ 1 .
≤ 2π z∈C +
Now, consider the case when φ is any function in L1 (R+ ) such that Fφ ∈ ∞ L (R) and 0 |φ(t)| f (t) dt < ∞. Let ψ ∈ Cc∞ (R) be any function satisfying ∞ 0 ≤ ψ ≤ 1, ψ(0) = 1 and −∞ ψ(t) dt = 1. Let ψn (t) = ψ(t/n) (t ∈ R) and φn (t) = φ(t)ψn (t). Then (2π)−1 (Fψn )(s) = (2π)−1 n(Fψ)(ns), which forms a mollifier. Hence, Fφn = (2π)−1 F φ ∗ Fψn → F φ in L1 (R) (see Lemma 1.3.3). Applying the previous result to the functions φn and taking the limit provides the result. 1
Next, we show that the antiderivative can grow at most linearly if fˆ is bounded on C+ and f is exponentially bounded. We shall apply this result to C0 -semigroups in Theorem 5.1.8. Theorem 4.4.18. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) be exponentially bounded and suppose that hol(fˆ) ≤ 0 and fˆ is bounded on C+ . Then there is a constant c such that
t
f (s) ds
≤ c(1 + t) 0
for all t ≥ 0.
Proof. Let C be as in Proposition 4.4.17 and let ω > max(0, ω(f )), so there exists M such that f (s) ≤ M eωs for all s ≥ 0. Take t > 0 and let α := 2t e−ωt and
4.4. THE CONTOUR METHOD 1 α χ(0,α)
φ :=
287
∗ χ(0,t) , so ⎧ s/α ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨1 φ(s) = t + α − s ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ α ⎪ ⎩ 0
(0 ≤ s < α), (α ≤ s < t), (t ≤ s < t + α), (t + α ≤ s).
Then α ≤ 1/(2ωe) and 1 1 − e−iαs 1 − e−ist 4e−isα/2 e−ist/2 αs st (F φ)(s) = = sin sin . 2 α is is αs 2 2 Hence,
Fφ 1
= ≤ = ≤ = =
Also, t
so
∞
f (s) ds = 0
α
φ(s)f (s) ds + 0
t
f (s) ds
0
st 4 ∞ | sin αs 2 sin 2 | ds 2 α 0 s 1/α | sin st 4 ∞ ds 2| 2 ds + s α 1/α s2 0 t/2α | sin u| 2 du + 4 u 0 t/2α du +6 u 1 log (t/2α) + 6 ωt + 6.
0
≤
0
∞
s 1− f (s) ds − α
φ(s)f (s) ds
+
α
0
t+α t
t+α−s f (s) ds, α
t+α
f (s) ds +
f (s) ds
t
≤ C(ωt + 6) + M αeωα (1 + eωt ) t ≤ C(ωt + 6) + M e−ωt e1/2e 2eωt 2 =
6C + Cω + M e1/2e t.
Finally, we prove the result comparing abs(f ) and hol0 (fˆ). Theorem 4.4.19. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) be exponentially bounded. Then abs(f ) ≤ hol0 (fˆ).
288
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
ˆ Proof. Let ω > hol0 (fˆ) and let fω (t) := e−ωt f (t). Then f ω (λ) = f (λ + ω), so hol(fω ) < 0 and fω is bounded on C+ . By Theorem 4.4.18 and Theorem 1.4.3, abs(fω ) ≤ 0. Hence, abs(f ) = abs(fω ) + ω ≤ ω whenever ω > hol0 (fˆ). Corollary 4.4.20. Let f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) be exponentially bounded. Assume that fˆ has a bounded holomorphic extension to a half-plane {λ ∈ C : Re λ > −ε} for some ε > 0. Then t lim f (s) ds = fˆ(0). t→∞
4.5
0
Almost Periodic Functions
This section is divided into two parts: in the first we describe relatively compact orbits of C0 -groups. The abstract results which we obtain are applied in the second part to characterize almost periodic functions on the real line. A subset Q of R is called relatively dense if there exists a length l > 0 such that [a, a + l] ∩ Q = ∅ for all a ∈ R. Let U = (U (t))t∈R be a C0 -group of isometries on a Banach space Y . Our aim is to prove the following. Theorem 4.5.1. Let y ∈ Y . The following assertions are equivalent: (i) The set {U (t)y : t ∈ R} is relatively compact in Y . (ii) The set {U (t)y : t ≥ 0} is relatively compact in Y . (iii) For all ε > 0, the set Qε := {τ ∈ R : U (τ )y − y ≤ ε} is relatively dense in R. ' ( (iv) y ∈ span x ∈ Y : there exists η ∈ R such that U (t)x = eiηt x for all t ∈ R . If these four equivalent conditions are satisfied we say that y has a relatively compact orbit. Since Y is complete, a subset K of Y is relatively compact if and only if K is precompact (i.e., for every ε > 0 it can be covered by a finite number of εballs). We shall use this equivalence frequently without comment, and we shall use the terminology “relatively compact” except in some proofs where precompactness is more relevant. The equivalence of the conditions (i), (ii) and (iii) will be proved by simple direct arguments. In order to show that they imply (iv) we need the following basic result of harmonic analysis (see [Rud62, Section 1.5.2]). Proposition 4.5.2. Let G be a compact abelian group with Haar measure dx. Let f : G → C be continuous such that f (x)γ(x) dx = 0 G
4.5. ALMOST PERIODIC FUNCTIONS
289
for every character γ (i.e., every continuous homomorphism γ : G → C \ {0}). Then f (x) = 0 for all x ∈ G. Proof of Theorem 4.5.1. (i) ⇒ (ii): This is trivial. (ii) ⇒ (iii). Let ε > 0. By assumption, there exist t1 , . . . , tm ≥ 0 such that for all t ≥ 0 there exists j ∈ {1, . . . , m} such that U (t)y − U (tj )y ≤ ε. Let l := maxj=1,...,m tj . We show that [t, t + l] ∩ Qε = ∅ for all t ∈ R. Let t ≥ 0. Choose j ∈ {1, . . . , m} such that U (t)y − U (tj )y ≤ ε. Let τ := t − tj . Then
U (τ )y − y = U (−tj )(U (t)y − U (tj )y) = U (t)y − U (tj )y ≤ ε. Thus, τ ∈ Qε ∩ [t − l, t]. Let t < 0. Then there exists j ∈ {1, . . . , m} such that U (−t)y−U (tj )y ≤ ε. Let τ := t + tj . Then U (τ )y − y = U (t)(U (tj )y − U (−t)y) ≤ ε. Thus, τ ∈ Qε and τ ∈ [t, t + l]. We have shown that [t, t + l] ∩ Qε = ∅ for all t ∈ R. (iii) ⇒ (i): Let ε > 0. By assumption, there exists l > 0 such that for all n ∈ Z, [ln, ln + l] ∩ Qε = ∅. Since {U (t)y : t ∈ [0, 2l]} is compact, there exist t1 , . . . , tm ∈ [0, 2l] such that for all s ∈ [0, 2l] there exists j ∈ {1, . . . , m} such that
U (s)y − U (tj )y ≤ ε. Let t ∈ R. Take n ∈ Z such that t ∈ [ln, ln + l] and choose τ ∈ Qε ∩ [−ln, −ln + l]. Then t + τ ∈ [0, 2l]. There exists j ∈ {1, . . . , m} such that
U (t + τ )y − U (tj )y ≤ ε. Thus,
U (t)y − U (tj )y ≤ U (t)y − U (t)U (τ )y + U (t + τ )y − U (tj )y ≤ 2ε. We have shown that the orbit {U (t)y : t ∈ R} is covered by balls B(U (tj )y, 2ε) = {z ∈ Y : U (tj )y − z ≤ 2ε} (j = 1, . . . , m). Thus, (i) holds. (i) ⇒ (iv): Replacing Y by span{U (t)y : t ∈ R}, we can assume that every orbit {U (t)x : t ∈ R} (x ∈ Y ) is relatively compact. Then U is bounded, by the uniform boundedness principle. Denote by G the closure of {U (t) : t ∈ R} in Ls (Y ), the space L(Y ) with respect to the strong operator topology. Then Gx ⊂ K(x) := {U (t)x : t ∈ R}− for all x ∈ Y . By hypothesis, K(x) is compact. We consider the strong operator topology on G, and all limits in this5proof will be in that topology. Then G can be identified with a closed subset of x∈Y K(x) via S ∈ G → {Sx : x ∈ Y }. Hence, G is compact by Tychonov’s theorem. Since multiplication is jointly continuous on bounded subsets of Ls (X), S, T ∈ G implies ST ∈ G. Let T ∈ G. There exists a net (ti )i∈I in R such that T = limi∈I U (ti ). Considering a subnet if necessary, we can assume that S := limi∈I U (−ti ) exists as well. Then T S = ST = I. We show that inversion is continuous. In fact, let limi∈I Ti = T in G. It follows from compactness that every subnet of (Ti )i∈I has a subnet (Tj )j∈J such that limj Tj−1 exists and joint continuity of multiplication implies that limj Tj−1 = T −1 . This implies that limi Ti−1 = T −1 . Thus, G is a compact abelian group with continuous multiplication. ˆ the dual group of G and by dS the Haar measure on G. Denote by G ˆ x ∈ Y define Pγ x := For γ ∈ G, γ(S)Sx dS ∈ Y . Then Pγ ∈ L(Y ) and G T Pγ x = G γ(S)T Sx dS = γ(T ) G γ(T S)T Sx dS = γ(T )Pγ x (T ∈ G). The mapˆ there ping φ(t) := γ(U (t)) is a continuous character on R. Hence, for each γ ∈ G,
290
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
exists η ∈ R such that γ(U (t)) = eiηt (t ∈ R). Thus, F
:= ⊂
ˆ x∈Y} {Pγ x : γ ∈ G, ' ( z ∈ Y : there exists η ∈ R such that U (t)z = eiηt y for all t ∈ R .
∗ It remains to show that span F is dense in Y . Let ψ ∈ Y such that z, ψ = 0 for ˆ Since S → Sx, ψ all z ∈ F . Let x ∈ Y . Then G γ(S)Sx, ψ dS = 0 for all γ ∈ G. is a continuous mapping, it follows from Proposition 4.5.2 that Sx, ψ = 0 for all S ∈ G. In particular, x, ψ = 0. Thus, ψ = 0. It follows from the Hahn-Banach theorem that spanF = Y . (iv) ⇒ (i): It is obvious that the set
Y1 := {x ∈ Y : x has precompact orbit} is a closed subspace of Y . Since x ∈ Y1 whenever U (t)x = eiηt x for all t ∈ R, the implication follows. We recall the following facts from Section 4.3. An element x ∈ Y is called totally ergodic if 1 t −iηs Mη x := lim e U (s)x ds t→∞ t 0 converges for all η ∈ R. In that case, U (t)Mη x = eiηt Mη x (t ∈ R). Moreover, the set of all frequencies Freq(x) := {η ∈ R : Mη x = 0} is countable (by Proposition 4.3.11). It is obvious that the set Ye of all totally ergodic vectors is a closed subspace of Y . We introduce the space Yap of all almost periodic vectors (with respect to U ) defined by Yap
:= {x ∈ Y : x has relatively compact orbit} = span{x ∈ Y : there exists η ∈ R such that U (t)x = eiηt x for all t ∈ R}.
Then Yap is a closed subspace of Y which is invariant under U . If x ∈ Y is a periodic vector, i.e., U (t)x = eiξt x (t ∈ R) for some ξ ∈ R, then Freq(x) ⊂ {ξ} and x Mη x = 0
if η = ξ, if η = ξ.
(4.22)
It follows that all almost periodic vectors are totally ergodic. The following approximation result shows that every x ∈ Yap can be approximated by linear combinations of eigenvectors associated with frequencies of x.
4.5. ALMOST PERIODIC FUNCTIONS
291
Proposition 4.5.3 (Spectral synthesis). Let x ∈ Yap . Then x ∈ span{y ∈ Y : there exists η ∈ Freq(x) such that U (t)y = eiηt y for all t ∈ R}. Proof. The space Z := {y ∈ Yap : Mη y = 0 for all η ∈ R\Freq(x)} is closed and invariant under the group. If η ∈ R\Freq(x) and y ∈ Z such that U (t)y = eiηt y (t ∈ R), then y = Mη y = 0. Now the claim follows from Theorem 4.5.1, applied to the restriction of U to Z. Corollary 4.5.4. Let x ∈ Yap . Then a) x = 0 if and only if Freq(x) = ∅. b) Freq(x) ⊂ {η} if and only if U (t)x = eiηt x (t ∈ R). m c) Freq(x) ⊂ {η1 , . . . , ηm } if and only if x = j=1 xj with U (t)xj = eiηj t xj for all t ∈ R. d) Let τ > 0. Then U (t+τ )x = U (t)x for all t ∈ R if and only if Freq(x) ⊂
2π Z. τ
Proof. a) and b) follow directly from Proposition 4.5.3.If Freq(x) ⊂ {η1 , . . . , ηm }, m then by Proposition 4.5.3, x = limn→∞ xn , where xn = j=1 xnj for some xnj ∈ X such that U (t)xnj = eiηj t xnj (j = 1, . . . , m). We can assume that ηj = ηk for k = j. Then Mηj x = limn→∞ Mηj xn = limn→∞ xnj by (4.22). It follows that m x = j=1 Mηj x. This proves one implication of c). The other follows from (4.22). We prove d). Assume that U (t + τ )x = U (t)x (t ∈ R). Recall that for z ∈ C, |z| = 1, one has n−1 1 if z = 1, 1 k lim z = n→∞ n 0 if z = 1. k=0 Let η ∈ R. Then 1 Mη x = lim n→∞ τ n =
lim
n→∞
1 τn
τn
U (s)xe−iηs ds
0 n−1 (k+1)τ k=0
U (s)xe−iηs ds
kτ
n−1 τ
1 U (s)xe−iηs ds e−ikητ τn k=0 0 τ 1/τ 0 U (s)xe−iηs ds if ητ ∈ 2πZ, = 0 if ητ ∈ 2πZ. =
lim
n→∞
This proves one implication. The other follows directly from Proposition 4.5.3. Now we come to the second part of this section where we consider a special group of operators. Let X be a Banach space. By BUC(R, X) we denote the space
292
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
of all bounded uniformly continuous functions on R with values in X. It is a Banach space for the uniform norm
f ∞ = sup f (t) . t∈R
The shift group on BUC(R, X) defined by (S(t)f )(r) := f (r + t)
(r ∈ R, t ∈ R)
is a C0 -group whose generator is denoted by B. Lemma 4.5.5. For f ∈ BUC(R, X) one has f ∈ D(B) if and only if f is differentiable and f ∈ BUC(R, X). In that case, Bf = f . t Proof. Let f ∈ D(B), g := Bf . Then S(t)f − f = 0 S(s)g ds for all t ≥ 0. In t particular, f (t) = (S(t)f )(0) = f (0) + 0 g(s) ds. This shows one implication of the claim. Conversely, assume that f is differentiable and g := f ∈ BUC(R, X). r+t t Then (S(t)f − f )(r) = f (r + t) − f (r) = r g(s) ds = 0 (S(s)g)(r) ds. Thus, t S(t)f − f = 0 S(s)g ds. Hence, f ∈ D(B) and Bf = g. Let η ∈ R, x ∈ X. By eiη ⊗ x we denote the periodic function given by (eiη ⊗ x)(t) = eiηt x
(t ∈ R).
Linear combinations of functions of the form eiη ⊗ x with η ∈ R, x ∈ X are called trigonometric polynomials. Definition 4.5.6. A function f : R → X is called almost periodic if it can be approximated uniformly on R by trigonometric polynomials. By AP(R, X) := span{eiη ⊗ x : η ∈ R, x ∈ X} we denote the space of all almost periodic functions on R with values in X. Let η ∈ R. A function f ∈ BUC(R, X) satisfies S(t)f = eiηt f for all t ∈ R if and only if f = eiη ⊗ f (0). Thus, considering the group S on Y := BUC(R, X), we have Yap = AP(R, X). Now we can reformulate the results of the first part of this section for this special case. Let f ∈ BUC(R, X). Let ε > 0. A real number τ > 0 is called an ε-period of f if f (τ + s) − f (s) ≤ ε for all s ∈ R. Theorem 4.5.7. Let f ∈ BUC(R, X). The following are equivalent: (i) f is almost periodic.
4.5. ALMOST PERIODIC FUNCTIONS
293
(ii) For every ε > 0 the set of all ε-periods is relatively dense in R. (iii) The orbit {S(t)f : t ∈ R} is relatively compact in BUC(R, X). This is an immediate consequence of Theorem 4.5.1. It follows in particular that for every f ∈ AP(R, X) there exist tn ∈ R such that limn→∞ tn = ∞ and
f (tn + s) − f (s) ≤
1 n
for all s ∈ R.
(4.23)
In particular, if f ∈ AP(R, X), then
f ∞ = sup f (t)
(4.24)
t≥τ
for all τ ∈ R. For f ∈ AP(R, X), η ∈ R, we define the mean Mη f
:= =
1 t −iηs lim e S(s)f ds t→∞ t 0 lim αR(α + iη, B)f. α↓0
These limits exist in BUC(R, X) (i.e., with respect to the uniform norm) by the remarks preceding Proposition 4.5.3 and by Proposition 4.3.1. Moreover, S(t)Mη f = eiηt Mη f for all t ∈ R. Evaluating at 0, we deduce that Mη f = eiη ⊗ (Mη f )(0).
(4.25)
As before in the abstract setting, we let Freq(f ) := {η ∈ R : Mη f = 0} be the set of all frequencies of f . By Proposition 4.3.11, this is a countable set. Moreover the following property of spectral synthesis holds. Proposition 4.5.8 (Spectral synthesis). Let f ∈ AP(R, X). Then f ∈ span{eiη ⊗ x : η ∈ Freq(f ), x ∈ f (R), } where the closure is taken in BUC(R, X). Proof. Let X0 := span{f (t) : t ∈ R} ⊂ X. Then by Theorem 4.5.7, f is also almost periodic when it is considered as a function with values in X0 . So we can assume that X0 = X. Now the claim follows from Proposition 4.5.3. From Corollary 4.5.4 we see the following.
294
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
Corollary 4.5.9. Let f ∈ AP(R, X). Then a) f ≡ 0 if and only if Freq(f ) = ∅. b) Freq(f ) ⊂ {η} if and only if f = eiη ⊗ f (0). c) f is a trigonometric polynomial if and only if Freq(f ) is finite. d) f is τ -periodic if and only if Freq(f ) ⊂
2π τ Z
(where τ > 0).
We call assertion a) the uniqueness theorem for almost periodic functions. We also obtain from Theorem 4.5.7 that almost periodic functions have relatively compact range. Corollary 4.5.10. Let f ∈ AP(R, X). Then the set {f (t) : t ∈ R}− is compact. Proof. By hypothesis, the set {S(t)f : t ∈ R} is relatively compact in BUC(R, X). Since evaluation at 0 is a continuous operator from BUC(R, X) into X, it follows that the set {f (t) : t ∈ R} = {(S(t)f )(0) : t ∈ R} is relatively compact in X. A function f ∈ BUC(R, X) is called weakly almost periodic if x∗ ◦ f is almost periodic for all x∗ ∈ X ∗ . Remark 4.5.11. There are various different definitions of weak almost periodicity in the literature. In particular, a function f ∈ BUC(R, X) is called weakly almost periodic in the sense of Eberlein if the set {S(t)f : t ∈ R} is relatively weakly compact in the Banach space BUC(R, X). This property is independent of weak almost periodicity, in general. We refer to the Notes. Proposition 4.5.12. Assume that f ∈ BUC(R, X) has relatively compact range. If f is weakly almost periodic, then f is almost periodic. Proof. Since f is separably valued, we can assume that X is separable. Then we can consider X as a closed subspace of C[0, 1] (see [Woj91, p.36]). Let (Pn )n∈N be a bounded sequence of finite rank operators on C[0, 1] such that limn→∞ Pn g = g for all g ∈ C[0, 1] (see [Woj91, pp.37,40]). Then Pn ◦ f is weakly almost periodic, hence almost periodic since it has values in a finite dimensional space. We have limn→∞ Pn (f (t)) = f (t) for all t ∈ R. Since f has relatively compact range, this convergence is uniform in t ∈ R (see Proposition B.15). Thus, Pn ◦ f converges to f in BUC(R, C[0, 1]). Consequently, f is almost periodic. Remark 4.5.13 (Almost periodic orbits). Let U be a bounded C0 -group on a Banach space Y and let x ∈ Y . Then the following are equivalent: (i) x ∈ Yap (i.e., {U (t)x : t ∈ R} is relatively compact in Y ). (ii) U (·)x ∈ AP(R, Y ).
4.6. COUNTABLE SPECTRUM AND ALMOST PERIODICITY
295
In fact, if U (·)x ∈ AP(R, Y ), then {U (t)x : t ∈ R} is relatively compact, by Corollary 4.5.10. Conversely, let x ∈ Yap . Let tn ∈ R. Then there exists a subsequence such that limk→∞ U (tnk )x := y exists. This implies that U (tnk + ·)x converges to U (·)y in BUC(R, Y ). Thus, {U (t + ·)y : t ∈ R} is relatively compact in BUC(R, Y ).
4.6
Countable Spectrum and Almost Periodicity
In this section we define the spectrum of a function f ∈ BUC(R, X) with the help of the Laplace transform (or more precisely, the Carleman transform). The main result of this section says that, under suitable conditions on the space X, a function f ∈ BUC(R, X) with countable spectrum is almost periodic. Let f ∈ BUC(R, X). The Carleman transform fˆ of f is defined by ∞ −λt e f (t) dt (Re λ > 0), 0 ˆ f (λ) := ∞ λt − 0 e f (−t) dt (Re λ < 0). Thus, fˆ is a holomorphic function defined on C\iR. Remark 4.6.1. Let f+ ∈ BUC(R+ , X) be the restriction of f to R+ and f− ∈ BUC(R+ , X) be given by f− (t) = f (−t) (t ∈ R+ ). Then fˆ+ (λ) (Re λ > 0), fˆ(λ) = −fˆ− (−λ) (Re λ < 0), where fˆ+ and fˆ− are the Laplace transforms of f+ and f− , respectively. We use the same symbol for the Carleman transform and the Laplace transform. This will not lead to confusion. A point iη ∈ iR is called regular for fˆ if fˆ has a holomorphic extension to a neighbourhood of iη (i.e., iη is regular if there exists an open neighbourhood V of iη and a holomorphic function h : V → X such that h(λ) = fˆ(λ) for all λ ∈ V \iR). The Carleman spectrum spC (f ) is defined by spC (f ) = {η ∈ R : iη is not regular for fˆ}.
(4.26)
The following remark explains why this notion of spectrum is well adapted to spectral theory of C0 -groups. Remark 4.6.2 (Carleman spectrum and C0 -groups). Let Y be a Banach space and U be a bounded C0 -group on Y with generator A. Then σ(A) ⊂ iR, since A and −A generate bounded C0 -semigroups. Let x ∈ Y and f (t) := U (t)x. Then the Carleman transform fˆ of f is given by fˆ(λ) = R(λ, A)x (λ ∈ C\iR).
(4.27)
296
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
In particular, i spC (f ) ⊂ σ(A).
(4.28)
Infact, (4.27) is clear for Re λ > 0. If Re λ < 0, then fˆ(λ) = −fˆ− (−λ) = ∞ − 0 eλt U (−t)x dt = −R(−λ, −A)x = R(λ, A)x. As in Section 4.5, we denote by S the shift group on BUC(R, X) and by B its generator. For f ∈ BUC(R, X) and s ∈ R, let fs := S(s)f . An easy calculation (see Remark 4.6.2) shows that s λs −λt ˆ (R(λ, B)f )(s) = fs (λ) = e f (λ) − e f (t) dt 0
for λ ∈ C \ iR. We shall see in Lemma 4.6.8 that the singularities of R(·, B) coincide with the singularities of fˆ; i.e., that the Carleman spectra of S(·)f and f (·) coincide. Let η ∈ R. A function f ∈ BUC(R, X) is called uniformly ergodic at η if it is ergodic at η with respect to S; i.e., if 1 t −iηs Mη f := lim e S(s)f ds (4.29) t→∞ t 0 exists in BUC(R, X). By Section 4.3, this is equivalent to saying that Mη f = lim αR(α + iη, B)f α↓0
(4.30)
exists in BUC(R, X). Since (R(α + iη, B)f )(s) = fs (α + iη), this can be reformulated by saying that αfs (α + iη) converges as α ↓ 0 uniformly in s ∈ R. We say that f is totally ergodic if f is uniformly ergodic at each η ∈ R; i.e., if f is totally ergodic with respect to S in the sense of Sections 4.3 and 4.5. Next, we introduce a geometric condition of Banach spaces. Let c0 be the Banach space of all complex sequences converging to 0 with the supremum norm (as in Example 1.1.5 b)). We say that X contains c0 , and write briefly c0 ⊂ X, if there exists a closed subspace of X which is isomorphic to c0 . Since closed subspaces of reflexive spaces are reflexive, no reflexive Banach space contains c0 . Also, any space of the form L1 (Ω, μ) does not contain c0 . See Appendix D for further information. Now we can formulate the main theorem of this section. Theorem 4.6.3. Let f ∈ BUC(R, X) have countable Carleman spectrum. Assume that one of the following conditions is satisfied: a) f is totally ergodic, or b) f has relatively compact range, or c) c0 ⊂ X.
4.6. COUNTABLE SPECTRUM AND ALMOST PERIODICITY
297
Then f is almost periodic. As a corollary, we note the important scalar case which is due to Loomis. Here, we let BUC(R) := BUC(R, C) and AP(R) := AP(R, C). Corollary 4.6.4 (Loomis’s Theorem). Let f ∈ BUC(R) have countable Carleman spectrum. Then f is almost periodic. We have seen in the preceding section that every almost periodic function is totally ergodic and has relatively compact range. Thus, conditions a) and b) in Theorem 4.6.3 are necessary for the conclusion to hold. If the Banach space X contains c0 , countability of the Carleman spectrum alone does not imply almost periodicity. This is shown by the following example. Example 4.6.5. Let X := c, the space of all convergent complex sequences x = (xn )n∈N with the supremum norm x = supn |xn |. Then X is isomorphic to c0 . Let f (t) := eit/n =: (fn (t))n∈N . n∈N
Since fn (t) = ni eit/n , the function f is Lipschitz continuous and thus f∈ BUC(R, c). The Carleman transform fˆ of f is given by 1 ˆ f (λ) = λ − i/n n∈N for all λ ∈ C \iR. Consequently, spC (f ) = {1/n : n ∈ N} ∪ {0}, which is countable. However, f ∈ AP(R, c). In fact, f does not have relatively compact range. To see this, consider φn ∈ c∗ given by x, φn := xn for x = (xk )k∈N ∈ c, and φ∞ ∈ c∗ given by x, φ∞ := limk→∞ xk . Then φn ≤ 1 (n ∈ N ∪ {∞}) and limn→∞ x, φn = x, φ∞ for all x ∈ c. Suppose that K := {f (t) : t ∈ R} is relatively compact in c. Then x, φn converges to x, φ∞ uniformly on K (see Proposition B.15). In particular, limn→∞ Imf (t), φn = limn→∞ sin nt = 0 uniformly in t ∈ R, which is absurd. We need several auxiliary results for the proof of Theorem 4.6.3. The following is a special kind of maximum principle for holomorphic functions. Lemma 4.6.6. Let V be an open neighbourhood of iη such that V contains the closed disc B(iη, 2r) = {z ∈ C : |z − iη| ≤ 2r}. Let h : V → X be holomorphic and c ≥ 0, k ∈ N0 such that
h(z) ≤
c | Re z|k
if |z − iη| = 2r, Re z = 0.
Then h(z) ≤ (4/3) cr−k for all z ∈ B(iη, r). k
298
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
Proof. We can assume that η = 0 (replacing h(z) by h(z + iη) otherwise). Define k z2 g : V → X by g(z) := 1 + h(z). Let |z| = 2r, z = 2reiθ . Then (2r)2
g(z) = |1 + ei2θ |k h(z) = |eiθ (e−iθ + eiθ )|k h(z)
c = 2k | cos θ|k h(z) ≤ k . r −k It follows from themaximum principle that g(z) ≤ cr if |z| ≤ 2r. Let |z| ≤ r. −1 2 2 2 z 4 (2r) ≤ 4r Then 1 + = . Hence, = (2r)2 (2r)2 + z 2 4r2 − r 2 3
−k z2
h(z) = 1 + g(z) ≤ (4/3)k cr−k (2r)2
(|z| ≤ r).
We now describe the local spectrum associated with a bounded C0 -group and an individual vector. Let U be an isometric C0 -group on a Banach space Y with generator A. For x ∈ Y we define the space Yx := span{U (t)x : t ∈ R}. It is invariant under the group U . We denote by Ax the generator of this restriction group. Then σ(Ax ) ⊂ σ(A) ⊂ iR, and R(λ, Ax ) = R(λ, A)|Yx (λ ∈ ρ(A)). As before, C+ := {z ∈ C : Re z > 0} denotes the right half plane. Lemma 4.6.7. Let x ∈ Y, η ∈ R. The following assertions are equivalent: (i) iη ∈ ρ(Ax ). (ii) There exists an open neighbourhood V of iη and a holomorphic function h : V → X such that h(λ) = R(λ, A)x for all λ ∈ C+ ∩ V . In that case, h(λ) = R(λ, A)x for all λ ∈ V \iR. Proof. (i) ⇒ (ii): Let V := ρ(Ax ), h(λ) := R(λ, Ax )x. (ii) ⇒ (i): Assume (ii) and assume that V is connected. We first show that h(λ) = R(λ, A)x for all λ ∈ V \iR. Let μ ∈ ρ(A). Then k(λ) := (λ − A)R(μ, A)h(λ) defines a holomorphic function on V such that k(λ) = R(μ, A)x for all λ ∈ C+ ∩ V . It follows from the uniqueness theorem that (λ − A)R(μ, A)h(λ) = k(λ) = R(μ, A)x for all λ ∈ V . This implies that R(μ, A)h(λ) = R(λ, A)R(μ, A)x = R(μ, A)R(λ, A)x for all λ ∈ V \iR. Since R(μ, A) is injective, the
∞claim follows. We now show that iη ∈ ρ(Ax ). We have R(λ, A) = 0 e−λt U (t) dt ≤ 1/(Re λ) (Re λ > 0), and similarly, R(λ, A) = R(−λ, −A) ≤ −1/(Re λ) for Re λ < 0. Thus R(λ, A) ≤ 1/| Re λ| for all λ ∈ V \iR. Choose r > 0 such that B(iη, 2r) ⊂ V . It follows from the assumption that R(·, A)z has a holomorphic extension to V for all z ∈ span{U (t)x : t ∈ R}. Now it follows from Lemma 4.6.6 that 4
R(λ, A)z ≤
z for all λ ∈ B(iη, r)\iR. 3r
4.6. COUNTABLE SPECTRUM AND ALMOST PERIODICITY Hence, R(λ, Ax ) ≤
4 3r
299
for all λ ∈ B(iη, r)\iR. This implies that iη ∈ ρ(Ax ).
We define the local spectrum of A at x by σ(A, x) := σ(Ax ) = C\ρ(Ax ). Thus, iη ∈ σ(A, x) if and only if the equivalent conditions (i) and (ii) of Lemma 4.6.7 are not satisfied. Now we consider the shift group S on BUC(R, X) with generator B, as before. We show that the Carleman spectrum coincides with the local spectrum with respect to B. Lemma 4.6.8. Let f ∈ BUC(R, X). Then i spC (f ) = σ(B, f ). Proof. a) Let iη ∈ iR \ σ(B, f ). There exists an open neighbourhood V of iη and a holomorphic function h : V → BUC(R, X) such that h(λ) = R(λ, B)f (λ ∈ V \iR). Let k(λ) := h(λ)(0). Then k : V → X is holomorphic, k(λ) = (R(λ, B)f )(0) = ∞ −λt e (S(t)f )(0) dt = fˆ(λ) for λ ∈ V ∩ C+ , and k(λ) = (R(λ, B)f )(0) = 0 ∞ ∞ −(R(−λ, −B)f )(0) = − 0 eλt (S(−t)f )(0) dt = − 0 eλt f (−t) dt for λ ∈ V , Re λ < 0. Thus, η ∈ spC (f ). b) Let η ∈ R\spC (f ). By assumption, there exists an open neighbourhood V of iη and a holomorphic function h : V → X such that ∞ −λt e f (t) dt (λ ∈ V ∩ C+ ) 0 h(λ) = ∞ λt − 0 e f (−t) dt (λ ∈ V, Re λ < 0). For λ ∈ V, s ∈ R, define
H(λ, s) := e Then for λ ∈ V, Re λ > 0,
(R(λ, B)f )(s) =
λs
∞
h(λ) −
s
e
−λt
f (t) dt .
0
e−λt f (t + s) dt = H(λ, s)
0
and for λ ∈ V, Re λ < 0, (R(λ, B)f )(s) = −(R(−λ, −B)f )(s) = −
0
∞
(s ∈ R)
eλt f (s − t) dt = H(λ, s).
Thus, H(λ, s) ≤ f ∞ /| Re λ| for λ ∈ V \ iR. By Lemma 4.6.6, this 6 implies that for r > 0 such that B(iη, 2r) ⊂ V , one has H(λ, s) ≤ 4 f ∞ 3r for all λ ∈ B(iη, r), s ∈ R. We know that H(λ, ·) = R(λ, B)f ∈ BUC(R, X) if Re λ > 0. Since H(·, s) is holomorphic on B(iη, r) and bounded uniformly in s, it follows
300
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
from Corollary A.4 that λ → H(λ, ·) is holomorphic on B(iη, r) with values in BUC(R, X). Here, we choose linear functionals on BUC(R, X) of the form g → g(s), x∗ for s ∈ R, x∗ ∈ X ∗ , x∗ ≤ 1. Now, iη ∈ σ(B, f ) by Lemma 4.6.7. We deduce from Lemma 4.6.8 the following interesting observation. Proposition 4.6.9. Let f ∈ BUC(R, X) and let η ∈ R \spC (f ). Then f is uniformly ergodic at η and Mη f = 0. Proof. It was shown in the proof of Lemma 4.6.8 that λ → R(λ, B)f has a holomorphic extension to a neighbourhood of iη. It follows in particular that limα↓0 αR(α + iη, B)f = 0 in BUC(R+ , X). Proposition 4.6.10. Let f ∈ AP(R, X). Then spC (f ) = Freq(f ). Proof. The inclusion Freq(f ) ⊂ spC (f ) is immediate from Proposition 4.6.9, although in this case the fact that f is uniformly ergodic at each point of R is already known (see Section 4.5). Since spC (f ) is closed, it follows that Freq(f ) ⊂ spC (f ). For the converse, let Y0 = span {eiη ⊗ x : η ∈ Freq(f ), x ∈ X} and Y := Y0 . By Proposition 4.5.8, f ∈ Y . For g ∈ Y0 , gˆ has a holomorphic extension g (λ) ≤ g ∞ /| Re λ|. By Lemma 4.6.6, ˆ g (iη) ≤ 6! to C \ i Freq(f ),"and ˆ 8 g ∞ 3 dist(η, Freq(f )) if η ∈ R \ Freq(f ). If (gn )n∈N is a sequence in Y0 such that gn − f ∞ → 0, it follows that limn→∞ g n (λ) exists for λ ∈ C \ i Freq(f ) and by Vitali’s Theorem A.5, this gives a holomorphic extension of fˆ to C \ i Freq(f ). Hence, spC (f ) ⊂ Freq(f ). The condition that c0 ⊂ X will enter the proof of Theorem 4.6.3 in form of the following theorem due to Kadets. Theorem 4.6.11 (Kadets). Assume that c0 ⊂ Xand let f ∈ BUC(R, X). If furthermore S(t)f − f ∈ AP(R, X) for all t ∈ R, then f ∈ AP(R, X). We will give the proof of Kadets’s theorem at the end of this section. For X = C, Theorem 4.6.11 is due to H. Bohr. We will give a separate direct proof for this easier case. For Theorem 4.6.3 we use the following spectral-theoretic reformulation of Kadets’s theorem. Denote by π : BUC(R, X) → BUC(R, X)/ AP(R, X) the quotient map. Recall that the quotient space is a Banach space for the norm
π(f ) := inf{ f + g : g ∈ AP(R, X)} and π is contractive for this norm. Since S(t) leaves the space AP(R, X) invariant, there exists a C0 -group S on the quotient BUC(R, X)/ AP(R, X) given by S(t)π(f ) := π(S(t)f ). Now Kadets’s theorem can be rephrased in the following We call its generator B. form.
4.6. COUNTABLE SPECTRUM AND ALMOST PERIODICITY
301
Corollary 4.6.12. The following assertions are equivalent: (i) c0 ⊂ X. has empty point spectrum. (ii) B So it suffices to show Proof. (i) ⇒ (ii): Theorem 4.6.11 says that 0 ∈ σp (B). iηr that σp (B) = σp (B) + iR. Let η ∈ R, eiη (r) := e . Then Qη f := eiη · f defines an isomorphism Qη on BUC(R, X) which leaves AP(R, X) invariant. Moreη on BUC(R, X)/ AP(R, X) by Q η (π(f )) := over, Q−η S(t)Qη = eiηt S(t). Define Q iηt π(Qη f ). Then Q−η S(t)Qη = e S(t). This implies the claim. (ii) ⇒ (i): We have to show that if c0 ⊂ X then there exists f ∈ BUC(R, X) such that f ∈ AP(R, X) but S(t)f − f ∈ AP(R, X) for all t ≥ 0. Since the space c0 is isomorphic to the space c, it suffices to" consider X = c. Consider ! the function f ∈ BUC(R, c) given by f (t) := eit/n n∈N . Then f ∈ AP(R, c) by ! " Example 4.6.5. Let t ∈ R, g := S(t)f − f . Then g(s) = (eit/n − 1)eis/n n∈N =: (gn (s))n∈N . Let hn (s) := (g1 (s), . . . , gn (s), 0, 0, . . .). Since limn→∞ (eit/n − 1) = 0, we have limn→∞ hn = g in BUC(R, c). But hn ∈ AP(R, c) for all n ∈ N. Thus, g ∈ AP(R, c). Proof of Theorem 4.6.3. Let f ∈ BUC(R, X) such that spC (f ) is countable. Case c): We assume that c0 ⊂ X. Let Y := BUC(R, X)/ AP(R, X) and on Y . Assume that f ∈ AP(R, X); consider the shift group S with generator B f : t ∈ R} and the i.e., f := π(f ) = 0. We consider the space Yf := span{S(t) (see the discussion before Lemma 4.6.7). Let η ∈ R\spC (f ). induced operator B f
Then by Lemma 4.6.8, the function λ → R(λ, B)f has a holomorphic extension h : V → BUC(R, X) where V is an open neighbourhood of iη. Then π ◦ h is a f = π(R(λ, B)f ). It follows from Lemma holomorphic extension of λ → R(λ, B) ). We have proved that σ(B ) ⊂ spC (f ). Thus, σ(B ) is 4.6.7 that iη ∈ σ(B f f f countable, closed and non-empty (by Corollary 4.4.12), so it contains an isolated has non-empty point spectrum. point. It follows from Corollary 4.4.13 that B f also has non-empty point spectrum. This contradicts Corollary 4.6.12. Hence, B The proof is finished in this case. Case a): Now assume that f is totally ergodic. Consider the space E := {g ∈ BUC(R, X) : g is totally ergodic} which is closed and invariant under the shift group. We denote the shift group on E also by S and its generator by B. Consider the quotient space E := E/ AP(R, X), the quotient map π : E → E and the induced It suffices to show group S on E given by S(t)π(g) := π(S(t)g) with generator B. has empty point spectrum. Then the proof given in Case a) carries over. that B Assume that g ∈ E, η ∈ R such that S(t)π(g) = eiηt π(g) (t ∈ R). Then −iηt e S(t)g − g ∈ AP(R, X) (t ∈ R). It follows that " 1 t ! −iηs Mη g − g = lim e S(s)g − g ds ∈ AP(R, X). t→∞ t 0
302
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
But Mη g = eiη ⊗ (Mη g)(0) ∈ AP(R, X). Thus g ∈ AP(R, X). Case b): Assume that f has relatively compact range. It follows from Case c) applied in the scalar case that f is weakly almost periodic. Hence, f ∈ AP(R, X) by Proposition 4.5.12. Now Theorem 4.6.3 is completely proved in the case a) where f is assumed to be uniformly ergodic at each η ∈ spC (f ). The proof in the other cases is complete admitting Kadets’s theorem. Note however that for the case b), where f is assumed to have relatively compact range, we merely need Kadets’s theorem in the scalar case. The scalar case is much easier to prove and will be particularly important for the general complex Tauberian theorem presented in Section 4.9. For this reason, we first give a direct proof of Kadets’s theorem in the scalar case. The following reformulation will be useful. Lemma 4.6.13. Let X be a Banach space. The following assertions are equivalent: t (i) If f ∈ AP(R, X) such that F (t) := 0 f (s) ds (t ∈ R) is bounded, then F ∈ AP(R, X). (ii) If f ∈ BUC(R, X) such that S(t)f − f ∈ AP(R, X) for all t ∈ R, then f ∈ AP(R, X). t Proof. (ii) ⇒ (i): Let f ∈ AP(R, X) such that F (t) = 0 f (s) ds is bounded. Then t F ∈ BUC(R, X) and S(t)F − F = 0 S(s)f ds ∈ AP(R, X) for all t ∈ R. Hence, F ∈ AP(R, X) by (ii). (i) ⇒ (ii): Let f ∈ BUC(R, X) such that S(t)f − f ∈ AP(R, X) for all t ∈ R. Let λ > 0 and g = R(λ, B)f . Then S(t)g − g ∈ AP(R, X) and g ∈ D(B). It follows that g = lim 1/t (S(t)g − g) ∈ AP(R, X). t↓0
t
Thus by (i), g(t) − g(0) = 0 g (s) ds defines an almost periodic function. We have shown that R(λ, B)f ∈ AP(R, X) for all λ > 0. Since f = limλ→∞ λR(λ, B)f in BUC(R, X) (see Proposition 3.1.9 a)), it follows that f ∈ AP(R, X). Proof of Theorem 4.6.11 in the scalar case. Let f ∈ AP(R) such that F (t) := t f (s) ds is bounded. We show that F ∈ AP(R). Then the result follows from 0 Lemma 4.6.13. It follows easily from Definition 4.5.6 that we can assume that f is real-valued. It is clear that F ∈ BUC(R). Let sk ∈ R (k ∈ N). There exists a subsequence tm := skm such that g := limm→∞ S(tm )f exists in BUC(R). We have to show that S(tm )F has a convergent subsequence. Then F ∈ AP(R) by Theorem 4.5.7. t +t t a) Since (S(tm )F ) (t) = 0 m f (s) ds = 0 S(tm )f (s) ds + F (tm ), and (F (tm ))m∈N is bounded, it follows that S(tm )F has a limit point G for compact convergence (by which we mean the topology of uniform convergence on bounded t intervals), where G(t) = 0 g(s) ds + d for some d ∈ R. Clearly, G ∈ BUC(R) and sup G := supt∈R G(t) ≤ sup F, inf G ≥ inf F . Since S(−tm )g → f as m → ∞,
4.6. COUNTABLE SPECTRUM AND ALMOST PERIODICITY
303
for the same reason S(−tm )G has a limit point H for compact convergence, H is differentiable, H = f, sup H ≤ sup G, inf H ≥ inf G. Hence, H(t) = F (t) + c for some c ∈ R and c + sup F ≤ sup G ≤ sup F and inf F + c ≥ inf G ≥ inf F . Hence, c = 0. Thus, sup G = sup F and inf G = inf F . This determines d uniquely. So the limit point G is unique. Hence, S(tm )F converges to G ∈ BUC(R) uniformly on bounded intervals. b) Now it remains to show that S(tm )F converges uniformly to G. If not, passing to a subsequence we can assume that there exist ε > 0 and sm ∈ R such that |F (tm + sm ) − G(sm )| ≥ ε > 0 (m ∈ N). Taking subsequences, we can assume that h := limm→∞ S(tm + sm )f and h1 := limm→∞ S(sm )g = h1 exist in BUC(R). Then h = h1 , since |h(t) − h1 (t)|
Let H(t) :=
t 0
≤
|h(t) − f (t + tm + sm )| + |f (t + tm + sm ) − g(sm + t)|
+ |g(sm + t) − h1 (t)| → 0 as m → ∞. h(s) ds. By a), there exist constants c1 , c2 such that
lim (S(tm + sm )F ) (t) = H(t) + c1 and
m→∞
lim (S(sm )G) (t) = H(t) + c2
m→∞
uniformly on bounded intervals, and inf F = inf H + c1 , and inf G = inf H + c2 . Since inf F = inf G, it follows that c1 = c2 . Thus ε ≤ limm→∞ |F (tm + sm ) − G(sm )| = |c1 − c2 | = 0, a contradiction. Now we have proved Kadets’s theorem in the scalar case, and hence also the proof of Theorem 4.6.3 in the case b), and in particular of Loomis’s theorem, is complete. Before proving Kadets’s theorem in full generality, we consider another special case which can be deduced from the scalar case by a short but clever argument. Recall that a Banach space X is called uniformly convex if for all ε > 0 there exists δ > 0 such that for x ≤ 1, y ≤ 1,
x + y
x − y ≥ ε ⇒ (4.31)
2 ≤ 1 − δ. Every uniformly convex space is reflexive, and Lp -spaces are uniformly convex for 1 < p < ∞. Proof of Theorem 4.6.11 for uniformly convex spaces. t Let f ∈ AP(R, X) such that F (t) = 0 f (s) ds is bounded. We claim that F is almost periodic. We can assume that
F ∞ := sup F (t) = 1. t∈R
Since by the scalar case, F is weakly almost periodic, in view of Proposition 4.5.12 it suffices to show that F has precompact range.
304
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS Assume that this is false. Then there exist ε > 0, tn ∈ R such that
F (tn ) − F (tm ) ≥ ε (n = m).
Choose δ > 0 according to (4.31). Let x∗ ∈ X ∗ such that x∗ = 1 and x∗ ◦F ∞ > 1 − 4δ . Replacing (tn )n∈N by a subsequence if necessary, we can assume that S(tn )f S(tn )(x∗ ◦ F )
→ f in BUC(R, X) → g in BUC(R).
Then g ∞ ≥ 1 − 4δ , since S(−tn )g → x∗ ◦ F in BUC(R). Let t ∈ R such that |g(t)| ≥ 1 − δ2 . Then lim sup F (tn + t) − F (tm + t)
n,m→∞ n=m
t
= lim sup F (tn ) − F (tm ) + (f (tn + s) − f (tm + s)) ds
n,m→∞ 0
n=m
= lim sup F (tn ) − F (tm ) ≥ ε. n,m→∞ n=m
Hence by (4.31), 1−
δ ≤ |g(t)| = 2
lim n,m→∞ n=m
≤ lim sup n,m→∞ n=m
|F (t + tn ) + F (t + tm ), x∗ | 2
F (t + tn ) + F (t + tm )
2
≤ 1 − δ. This is a contradiction. For the proof of Kadets’s theorem in the general case we use the following characterization which is proved in Appendix D. Theorem 4.6.14. Let X be a Banach space. The following are equivalent: (i) c0 ⊂ X.
∞ (ii) there is a divergent series n=1 xn in X which is unconditionally bounded; i.e., there exists M ≥ 0 such that
m
x nj ≤ M
j=1
whenever nj ∈ N (j = 1, 2, . . . , m) such that n1 < n2 < . . . < nm .
4.6. COUNTABLE SPECTRUM AND ALMOST PERIODICITY
305
Proof of Kadets’s Theorem 4.6.11. t Assume that there exists f ∈ AP(R, X) such that F (t) = 0 f (s) ds is bounded, but F ∈ AP(R, X). We show that this implies that c0 ⊂ X. In view of Lemma 4.6.13, this proves Kadets’s theorem. By the scalar case already proved, F is weakly almost periodic. a) We show that there exists ε > 0 such that the set U (ε) := {t ∈ R : F (t) < ε} is not relatively dense. Assume that, on the contrary, U (ε) is relatively dense for all ε > 0. n Let ε > 0. We show that R = j=0 (U (ε) + sj ) for suitable s0 , . . . , sn ∈ R. In fact, there exists l > 0 such that U (ε/2) ∩ [a − l, a] = ∅ for all a ∈ R. Since F is Lipschitz continuous, there exists δ > 0 such that F (z) ≤ ε/2 implies F (r) ≤ ε for all r ∈ [z, z + δ]. Let s0 := 0, s1 := δ, s2 := 2δ, . . . , sn := nδ, where nδ > l. Let t ∈ R. Take s ∈ [t − l, t] ∩ U (ε/2). Then [s, s + δ] ⊂ U (ε) = U (ε) + s0 , [s + δ, s + 2δ] = [s, s + δ] + δ ⊂ U (ε) + s1 , .. . [s + (n − 1)δ, s + nδ] ⊂ U (ε) + sn . n Thus, t ∈ [s, s + l] ⊂ j=0 (U (ε) + sj ). t Since f ∈ AP(R, X), the function S(t)F − F = 0 S(r)f dr ∈ AP(R, X) for all t ∈ R. In particular, S(sj )F − F has precompact range Kj . Now let t ∈ R. Then t = s + sj for some s ∈ U (ε), j ∈ {0, 1, 2, . . . , n}. Thus, F (t) = F (s + sj ) = (S(s n j )F − F ) (s) + F (s) ∈ Kj + B(0, ε). Thus, the range of F is contained in j=0 Kj + B(0, ε). Since ε > 0 is arbitrary, this implies that F has precompact range. This is impossible by Proposition 4.5.12. b) For γ ∈ R, δ > 0, let ' ( Vγ (δ) := t ∈ R : F (t + γ) − F (t) − F (γ) < δ . n We show that j=1 Vγj (δ) is relatively dense in R for all δ > 0, γ1 , γ2 , . . . , γn ∈ R. In fact, let γ := maxj=1,...,n |γj |. Then
γj
F (t + γj ) − F (t) − F (γj ) = (f (t + s) − f (s)) ds
0
≤ γ. sup f (t + s) − f (s) . 0≤s≤γ
Thus, n
j=1
Vγj (δ) ⊃
δ t ∈ R : f (t + s) − f (s) ≤ for all s ∈ [0, γ] . γ
306
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
The last set is relatively dense since f ∈ AP(R, X). c) By a) and b), there exists ε > 0 such that the following holds: If δ > 0, γ1 , γ2 , . . . , γr ∈ R, then U (ε) ⊃ ∩rj=1 Vγj (δ).
(4.32)
We construct tn ∈ R such that F (tn ) ≥ ε (n ∈ N) and
F (tn + tj1 + . . . + tjr ) − F (tn ) − F (tj1 + . . . + tjr ) ≤ 2−n
(4.33)
whenever j1 , j2 , . . . , jr ∈ N, 1 ≤ j1 < j2 < . . . < jr ≤ n − 1. Choose t1 ∈ R \ U (ε). Assume that t1 , . . . , tn−1 are constructed. By (4.32), there exists tn ∈ R\U (ε) such that tn ∈ Vγ (2−n ) whenever γ = tj1 + . . . + tjr with 1 ≤ j1 < j2 < . . . < jr ≤ n − 1. This means that (4.33) holds. ∞ d) Let xn := F (tn ). Then the series n=1 xn diverges. We show that
m
xik ≤ F ∞ + 1 (4.34)
k=1
whenever i1 < i2 < . . . < im . In fact,
m−1 m m m
tik − F (tik ) ≤ F tik − F (tim ) − F tik
F
k=1 k=1 k=1 k=1
m−1 m−2
+ F tik − F (tim−1 ) − F tik
k=1 k=1
+ . . . + F (ti2 + ti1 ) − F (ti2 ) − F (ti1 ) ≤ 2−im + . . . + 2−i2 ≤ 1. Thus,
m
m
xik = F (tik ) ≤ 1 + F ∞ .
k=1
k=1
Now it follows from Theorem 4.6.14 that c0 ⊂ X.
4.7
Asymptotically Almost Periodic Functions
In this section we study bounded uniformly continuous functions on the half-line. The main result is a Tauberian theorem (Theorem 4.7.7) which says that, under additional assumptions, such a function with countable spectrum is asymptotically almost periodic. Here we again use a quotient method similar to the preceding section. A similar result, in the case when the spectrum has at most one point, was given in Theorem 4.4.8 with a proof by elementary contour integrals.
4.7. ASYMPTOTICALLY ALMOST PERIODIC FUNCTIONS
307
Let X be a Banach space and denote by BUC(R+ , X) the space of all bounded uniformly continuous functions defined on R+ with values in X. It is a Banach space for the uniform norm
f ∞ = sup f (t) (f ∈ BUC(R+ , X)). t≥0
By C0 (R+ , X) we denote the closed subspace consisting of all f ∈ BUC(R+ , X) such that limt→∞ f (t) = 0. For x ∈ X, η ∈ R, we now consider the function eiη ⊗ x : t → eiηt x on R+ and denote by AP(R+ , X) := span{eiη ⊗ x : η ∈ R, x ∈ X} the space of all almost periodic functions on the half-line (the closure being taken in BUC(R+ , X)). Proposition 4.7.1. Every f ∈ AP(R+ , X) has a unique extension f ∈ AP(R, X) and f ∞ = f ∞ . Moreover,
f ∞ = sup f (t)
for all τ ≥ 0.
(4.35)
t≥τ
Proof. Let f ∈ AP(R+ , X). There exist trigonometric polynomials fn ∈ span{eiη ⊗ x : η ∈ R, x ∈ X} such that fn → f in BUC(R+ , X) as n → ∞. It follows from (4.24) that (fn )n∈N is a Cauchy sequence in BUC(R, X). Let f be the limit of (fn )n∈N in BUC(R, X). Then f ∈ AP(R, X) and (4.35) follows from (4.24). It follows from (4.35) that AP(R+ , X) ∩ C0 (R+ , X) = {0}.
(4.36)
By AAP(R+ , X) := C0 (R+ , X) ⊕ AP(R+ , X), we denote the space of all asymptotically almost periodic functions on the half-line. It follows from (4.35) that for f = f0 + f1 with f0 ∈ C0 (R+ , X), f1 ∈ AP(R+ , X), one has f1 ∞ ≤ f ∞ . Thus, AAP(R+ , X) is a closed subspace of BUC(R+ , X). The following observation is useful for later purposes. By (4.23), there exist tn ∈ R+ such that limn→∞ tn = ∞ and
f (tn + s) − f1 (s) ≤
1 n
for all s ∈ R+ .
(4.37)
In the following, we consider the shift semigroup S on BUC(R+ , X) given by (S(t)f ) (s) = f (t + s)
(s, t ≥ 0, f ∈ BUC(R+ , X)).
It is a C0 -semigroup of contractions, and its generator will be denoted by B.
308
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS Similarly to Section 4.6, for f ∈ BUC(R+ , X), Re λ > 0 and s ≥ 0, s λs −λt ˆ (R(λ, B)f )(s) = fs (λ) = e f (λ) − e f (t) dt , 0
where fs := S(s)f . We shall see in Lemma 4.7.9 that the singularities of R(·, B)f and fˆ(·) in iR coincide, and we shall exploit this to prove an analogue of part of Theorem 4.6.3 (Theorem 4.7.7). Let f ∈ BUC(R+ , X). Let η ∈ R. We say that f is uniformly ergodic at η if f is ergodic at η with respect to S; i.e., if 1 t −iηs Mη f := lim e S(s)f ds t→∞ t 0 converges in BUC(R+ , X). This is equivalent to the convergence of Mη f = lim αR(α + iη, B)f. α↓0
In that case, Mη f = eiη ⊗ (Mη f )(0).
(4.38)
A function f ∈ BUC(R+ , X) is called totally ergodic if f is ergodic at all η ∈ R. From now on, we denote by E(R+ , X) the set of all totally ergodic functions in BUC(R+ , X). This is a closed subspace of BUC(R+ , X) containing AAP(R+ , X). In the following we will consider the quotient space E := E(R+ , X)/ AAP(R+ , X) Then E is a Banach space for the norm with quotient map π : E(R+ , X) → E.
π(f ) := inf{ f − g ∞ : g ∈ AAP(R+ , X)}
(f ∈ E(R+ , X)).
Since E(R+ , X) and AAP(R+ , X) are invariant under the shift semigroup, we can define a C0 -semigroup S on E by S(t)π(f ) := π (S(t)f )
(t ≥ 0, f ∈ E(R+ , X)).
the generator of S. We denote by B The interesting fact about this construction is the following. Proposition 4.7.2. Each S(t) is isometric and surjective. Thus, S extends to an ˜ ˜ has empty point spectrum. isometric C0 -group on E. Moreover, B Proof. It is immediate that S(t)
≤ S(t) = 1 for all t ≥ 0. We show that S(t) is isometric. Let f ∈ E(R+ , X), t ≥ 0 and g ∈ AAP(R+ , X). Define h : R+ → X by g(s − t) (s ≥ t) h(s) := g(0) + f (s) − f (t) (s < t).
4.7. ASYMPTOTICALLY ALMOST PERIODIC FUNCTIONS
309
Then h ∈ AAP(R+ , X) and
f − h ∞
=
sup f (s) − g(s − t) = sup f (s + t) − g(s)
s≥t
s≥0
= S(t)f − g ∞ . Hence, π(f ) ≤ π(S(t)f ) = S(t)π(f ) . ˜ Since S(t) maps E(R+ , X) onto E(R+ , X), it follows that S(t) is surjective. By Proposition 3.1.23, S extends to a C0 -group on E. is empty. Let f ∈ E(R+ , X) It remains to show that the point spectrum of B t iηt and η ∈ R such that S(t)π(f ) = e π(f ) (t ≥ 0). Then 1t 0 e−iηs S(s)π(f ) ds = 1 t −iηs π(f ) (t ≥ 0). On the other hand, limt→∞ t 0 e S(s)f ds = Mη f ∈ AP(R+ , X). t Applying π on both sides, we conclude that limt→∞ 1t 0 e−iηs S(s)π(f ) ds = π(Mη f ) = 0. Hence, π(f ) = 0. The following simple result is essentially a reformulation of part of Proposition 4.7.2 (see Lemma 4.6.13). t Proposition 4.7.3. Let f ∈ AAP(R+ , X) and F (t) := 0 f (s) ds. Suppose that F is bounded and uniformly ergodic at 0. Then F ∈ AAP(R+ , X). Proof. Note first that S(s)F − F = Hence, 1 t→∞ t
M0 F − F = lim
s
0
0
t
S(r)f dr ∈ AAP(R+ , X).
(S(s)F − F ) ds ∈ AAP(R+ , X).
Since M0 F is a constant function, it follows that F ∈ AAP(R+ , X). Next, we characterize asymptotically almost periodic functions by relative compactness of the orbits under S. This is analogous to the characterization of almost periodic functions on the line proved in Section 4.5 (see Theorem 4.5.7). Theorem 4.7.4. Let f ∈ BUC(R+ , X). The following are equivalent: (i) f ∈ AAP(R+ , X). (ii) The orbit {S(t)f : t ≥ 0} is relatively compact in BUC(R+ , X). Proof. (i) ⇒ (ii): If h ∈ C0 (R+ , X), then limt→∞ S(t)h = 0. Thus, {S(t)h : t ≥ 0} is precompact. If f = eiη ⊗x, then S(t)f = eiηt f , so f has precompact orbit. It follows that every f ∈ span ({eiη ⊗ x : η ∈ R, x ∈ X} ∪ C0 (R+ , X)) = AAP(R+ , X) has precompact orbit. (ii) ⇒ (i): Assume that Of := {S(t)f : t ≥ 0} is relatively compact in BUC(R+ , X). Then f ∈ E(R+ , X) by Proposition 4.3.12, and Oπ(f ) := π(Of ) =
310
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
It follows from Theorem 4.5.1 that {S(t)π(f ) : t ≥ 0} is relatively compact in E. ' ( iηt π(f ) ∈ span g ∈ E : S(t) g = e g (t ∈ R) for some η ∈ R . By Proposition 4.7.2, this set is reduced to {0}. Thus, π(f ) = 0; i.e., f ∈ AAP(R+ , X). Similarly to the results on the line in Section 4.5, one can also characterize asymptotically almost periodic functions by “the relative density of asymptotic ε-periods”, but the definition on the half-line is slightly different. Let f ∈ BUC(R+ , X). For ε > 0, λ > 0, we let ' ( Qε,λ (f ) := τ ∈ R+ : f (t + τ ) − f (t) ≤ ε whenever t ≥ λ . We say that a subset Q of R+ is relatively dense in R+ if there exists a length l > 0 such that [a, a + l] ∩ Q = ∅ for all a ∈ R+ . Theorem 4.7.5. Let f ∈ BUC(R+ , X). The following assertions are equivalent: (i) f ∈ AAP(R+ , X). (ii) For all ε > 0 there exists a λ > 0 such that Qε,λ (f ) is relatively dense in R+ . Proof. (ii) ⇒ (i): By Theorem 4.7.4, we have to show that the set {S(t)f : t ≥ 0} is precompact in BUC(R+ , X). Let ε > 0. By assumption, there exists λ > 0 such that Qε,λ (f ) is relatively dense in R+ . Choose a length l such that [a, a + l] ∩ Qε,λ (f ) = ∅ for all a ≥ 0. Since {S(t)f : 0 ≤ t ≤ 2λ + l} is precompact, it suffices to cover {S(t)f : t ≥ 2λ + l} by finitely many balls of radius 2ε. There exist t1 , . . . , tm ∈ [λ, λ + l] such that for all t ∈ [λ, λ + l] there exists j ∈ {1, . . . , m} such that
S(t)f − S(tj )f ∞ ≤ ε. Now let t ≥ 2λ+l. There exists τ ∈ Qε,λ (f )∩[t−λ−l, t−λ]. Then t−τ ∈ [λ, λ+l]. There exists j ∈ {1, . . . , m} such that
S(t − τ )f − S(tj )f ∞ ≤ ε. Hence,
S(t)f − S(tj )f ∞ ≤ S(t)f − S(t − τ )f ∞ + S(t − τ )f − S(tj )f ∞ ≤ 2ε since τ ∈ Qε,λ (f ) and t − τ ≥ λ. (i) ⇒ (ii): Let f ∈ AAP(R+ , X). Let ε > 0. There exist λ ≥ 0 and h ∈ AP(R, X) such that f (t) − h(t) ≤ ε/3 for all t ≥ λ. Let τ > 0 be an ε/3-period for h. Then τ ∈ Qε,λ (f ). Since ε/3-periods for h are relatively dense in R, Qε, λ (f ) is relatively dense in R+ . Recall from Section 4.4 that the half-line spectrum sp(f ) of a function f ∈ BUC(R+ , X) is defined in the following way: call iη ∈ iR regular for fˆ if fˆ has a holomorphic extension to a neighbourhood of iη. Then we set ' ( sp(f ) = η ∈ R : iη is not regular for fˆ (4.39)
4.7. ASYMPTOTICALLY ALMOST PERIODIC FUNCTIONS
311
The half-line spectrum should not be confused with the Carleman spectrum introduced in the preceding section. Indeed, if f is the restriction of a function g ∈ BUC(R, X), then the half-line spectrum of f is much smaller than the Carleman spectrum of g in general. We make this more precise in the following remark. Remark 4.7.6 (Comparison of half-line spectrum and Carleman spectrum). a) Let f ∈ BUC(R+ , X). Assume that there exists η ∈ R \ sp(f ). Then f has at most one extension g ∈ BUC(R, X) such that η ∈ spC (g). In fact, assume that there are two extensions g, h ∈ BUC(R, X) such that η ∈ spC (g) ∪ spC (h). Consider k := g − h. Then k|R+ = 0. It follows that the Carleman transform kˆ of k is 0 on the right half-plane. Since kˆ is a holomorphic function on C \ iR with a holomorphic extension to a neighbourhood of iη, it ˆ follows from the uniqueness theorem for holomorphic functions that k(λ) = 0 also on the left half-plane. This implies that g − h = 0 by the uniqueness theorem for Laplace transforms. b) Let f ∈ BUC(R+ , X) be exponentially decreasing, but f = 0. Then spC (g) = R for all extensions g ∈ BUC(R, X) of f , but sp(f ) = ∅. In fact, there exist M ≥ 0, ε > 0 such that f (t) ≤ M e−εt . Thus the Laplace transform fˆ(λ) of f has a holomorphic extension to the region {Re λ > −ε} and fˆ(λ) is bounded for Re λ ≥ −ε/2. Now assume that g ∈ BUC(R, X) is an extension of f such that spC (g) = R. Then the Carleman transform gˆ(λ) of g agrees with fˆ(λ) for Re λ > 0, and hence for Re λ > −ε by the uniqueness theorem for holomorphic functions. Since gˆ(λ) is bounded for Re λ ≤ −ε/2, it follows that gˆ extends to a bounded entire function. So gˆ is constant by Liouville’s theorem. Since limλ→∞ fˆ(λ) = 0, it follows that fˆ = 0. Hence, f = 0. It is clear from the preceding remark that the assumption that the half-line spectrum be countable is much less restrictive than countability of the Carleman spectrum. In addition, we have the following observation about countability of a part of the spectrum. Let f ∈ E(R+ , X). As in Section 4.3, we define the set of all frequencies of f by Freq(f ) := {η ∈ R : Mη f = 0} . Since (Mη f )(0) = limα↓0 αfˆ(α + iη), it follows from (4.38) that Freq(f ) ⊂ sp(f ). It follows from Proposition 4.3.11 that Freq(f ) is countable. Now we can formulate the main result of this section which is a complex Tauberian theorem. With the help of Proposition 4.7.2, we are able to reduce the proof to an application of Gelfand’s theorem (Corollary 4.4.12). Theorem 4.7.7. Let f be a totally ergodic function in BUC(R+ , X) with countable half-line spectrum sp(f ). Then f is asymptotically almost periodic. The following corollary illustrates particularly well the Tauberian character of this theorem.
312
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
Corollary 4.7.8. Let f ∈ E(R+ , X) with countable half-line spectrum. a) If Freq(f ) = ∅, then f ∈ C0 (R+ , X). b) If Freq(f ) = {0}, then limt→∞ f (t) exists. c) If Freq(f ) ⊂ 2π Z, where τ > 0, then there exists a τ -periodic, continuous τ function g : R+ → X such that limt→∞ f (t) − g(t) = 0. Proof. By Theorem 4.7.7, one has f = g + h ∈ AP(R+ , X) + C0 (R+ , X). Since Freq(g) = Freq(f ), the claim follows from Corollary 4.5.9. For the proof of Theorem 4.7.7 we need the following lemma which is analogous to Lemma 4.6.8. Lemma 4.7.9. Let f ∈ BUC(R+ , X). Assume that the Laplace transform fˆ of f has a holomorphic extension to a neighbourhood of iη, where η ∈ R. Then the function R(·, B)f : C+ → BUC(R+ , X) has a holomorphic extension to a neighbourhood of iη. Proof. We can assume that η = 0. Let V be a connected neighbourhood of 0 and g : V → X be holomorphic such that g(λ) = fˆ(λ) for λ ∈ V ∩ C+ . For λ ∈ V let s λs −λt g(λ) − e f (t) dt (s ∈ R+ ). G(λ, s) := e 0
Then for Re λ > 0,
∞
G(λ, s) =
e−λt f (t + s) dt = (R(λ, B)f )(s).
0
It is clear that G(·, s) : V → X is holomorphic for all s ∈ R+ . Choose r > 0 such that B(0, 2r) ⊂ V . We show that sup s∈R+ , |λ|≤r
G(λ, s) < ∞.
In fact, let M := sup|λ|≤2r g(λ) . If Re λ > 0, then
G(λ, s) = (R(λ, B)f )(s) ≤ R(λ, B)f ∞ ≤
f ∞ . Re λ
If Re λ < 0, |λ| = 2r, then |eλs | ≤ 1 and so s
f ∞
G(λ, s) ≤ M + e− Re λ (t−s) dt f ∞ ≤ M + | Re λ| 0 2rM + f ∞ ≤ . | Re λ|
4.7. ASYMPTOTICALLY ALMOST PERIODIC FUNCTIONS It follows from Lemma 4.6.6 that G(λ, s) ≤
4 3
2rM + f ∞ r
313
=: c for all λ ∈
B(0, r), s ∈ R+ . Now the claim follows from Corollary A.4 if we choose linear functionals ψ on BUC(R+ , X) which are of the form f, ψ := f (s), x∗ where s ∈ R+ , x∗ ∈ X ∗ , x∗ ≤ 1. Proof of Theorem 4.7.7. We keep the notation introduced before Proposition 4.7.2. Let f ∈ E(R+ , X) have countable spectrum. Assume that f := π(f ) = 0. Then f : t ∈ R} = {0}. Ef := span{S(t) the generator of the group S restricted to E. Let η ∈ R \ sp(f ). Denote by B f f By Lemma 4.7.9, there exists an open neighbourhood V of iη and a holomorphic function H : V → BUC(R+ , X) such that H(λ) = R(λ, B)f for λ ∈ V, Re λ > 0. Since H(λ) ∈ E(R+ , X) for Re λ > 0, it follows from the identity theorem (Proposition A.2) that H(λ) ∈ E(R+ , X) for all λ ∈ V . The function π ◦H : V → E is holomorphic and for λ ∈ V ∩ C+ , (π ◦ H)(λ) = R(λ, B)π(f ). It follows from ) contains Lemma 4.6.7 that iη ∈ σ(Bf). Thus, σ(Bf) is countable. But then σ(B f by Corollary 4.4.13. This contradicts an isolated point which is an eigenvalue of B f
Proposition 4.7.2. Thus, π(f ) = 0; i.e., f ∈ AAP(R+ , X).
An even more general version of Theorem 4.7.7 will be given in Section 4.9. However, before that some further preparation concerning harmonic analysis is given in the following section. We note an immediate corollary of Lemma 4.7.9. Corollary 4.7.10. Let f ∈ BUC(R+ , X). If η ∈ R \ sp(f ), then f is uniformly ergodic at η and Mη f = 0. We now give an example which shows that the condition of total ergodicity is crucial in Theorem 4.7.7, even in the scalar case. This contrasts dramatically with the situation of the entire line where total ergodicity is a consequence of countability of the Carleman spectrum if c0 ⊂ X (Theorem 4.6.3. The example also shows that ergodicity has to be uniform with respect to translates of the function. Recall that total ergodicity means by definition that the function is uniformly ergodic at each η ∈ R. √ Example 4.7.11. The function f (t) := sin t has half-line spectrum sp(f ) = {0} and 0 ∈ Freq(f ). Since f (t) does not converge to 0 as t → ∞, it follows from Thet orem 4.7.7 that f is not uniformly ergodic at 0. However, limt→∞ 1t 0 f (s) ds = 0. Proof. a) We show that √ fˆ(λ) =
πe−1/4λ 2λ3/2
(Re λ > 0).
314
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
In fact, f (t) = sin term, we obtain
√
t=
∞
fˆ(λ)
(−1)n tn+1/2 (2n+1)! .
n=0 ∞
=
Thus, for λ > 0, integrating term by
√ sin t e−λt dt
0
∞ ∞ (−1)n = tn+1/2 e−λt dt (2n + 1)! 0 n=0 ∞ ∞ (−1)n 1 = un+1/2 e−u du n+3/2 (2n + 1)! λ 0 n=0 ∞ (−1)n −n−3/2 λ Γ(n + 3/2). (2n + 1)! n=0
=
Standard formulas for the Gamma function give 1 Γ(n + 3/2) = (n + 1/2)(n − 1/2) . . . Γ(1/2) 2 (2n + 1)(2n − 1) . . . 1 √ (2n + 1)! √ = π= π. 2n+1 n!22n+1 Thus, fˆ(λ)
=
∞
λ−n−3/2
n=0
(−1)n √ π n!22n+1
√
=
√ ∞ π 1 (−1)n π = 3/2 e−1/4λ . n 3/2 n! (4λ) 2λ 2λ n=0
By uniqueness of holomorphic extensions, this formula is true for Re λ > 0. It follows that sp(f ) = {0}. b) For t > 0, 1 t
t
f (s) ds = 0
1 t
√
t
2u sin u du 0
√t √ 1 2 t = [−2u cos u]0 + cos u du t t 0 √ √ 2 cos t 2 = − √ + sin t → 0 t t
as t → ∞. c) One can directly see that f is not uniformly ergodic at 0. In fact, given t > 0 we may choose s such that √ √ (2n + 1/4)π < s < s + t < (2n + 3/4)π
4.7. ASYMPTOTICALLY ALMOST PERIODIC FUNCTIONS
315
√ √ for some integer n (since s + t − s → 0 as s → ∞). Then f (u) > √12 whenever s+t s ≤ u ≤ s + t, so 1t s f (u) du > √12 . Thus, f is not uniformly ergodic at 0. We want to extend Theorem 4.7.7 to bounded measurable functions. Then we can only obtain assertions for the means of f , for example B-convergence, but this is sufficient for interesting applications to power series. Let f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X). We define the half-line spectrum sp(f ) as in Section 4.4; viz., sp(f ) := η ∈ R : fˆ(λ) does not have a holomorphic extension to a neighbourhood of iη . Moreover, we say that f is totally ergodic if for each η ∈ R, ∞ (Mη f )(t) := lim α e−(α+iη)s f (t + s) ds α↓0
0
converges uniformly in t ∈ R+ . In that case, it follows as in (4.25) that Mη f = eiη ⊗ x, where eiη (t) = eiηt , x = (Mη f )(0) ∈ X. We set Freq(f ) := {η ∈ R : Mη f = 0}. The following is a Tauberian theorem where B-convergence is deduced. Theorem 4.7.12. Let f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X) be totally ergodic. Assume that sp(f ) is countable and Freq(f ) ⊂ {0}. Then B-limt→∞ f (t) = (M0 f )(0). t+δ Proof. Let δ > 0, g(t) := 1δ t f (s) ds. Then g ∈ BUC(R+ , X). Integrating by parts we obtain for Re λ > 0, ∞ 1 d ! −λt " t+δ gˆ(λ) = − e f (s) ds dt δλ 0 dt t ∞ δ 1 −λt = f (s) ds + e (f (t + δ) − f (t)) dt δλ 0 0 ∞ δ 1 λδ −λt = f (s) ds + e e f (t) dt − fˆ(λ) δλ 0 δ δ δ 1 λδ 1 λδ −λs ˆ = (e − 1)f (λ) + f (s) ds − e e f (s) ds δλ δλ 0 0 δ λδ δ −λs 1 λδ 1 − e 1 − e λδ = (e − 1)fˆ(λ) + f (s) ds + e f (s) ds . δλ λδ λδ 0 0
316
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
1 The right-hand summand defines an entire function of λ. Since δλ (eλδ −1) is entire, it follows that sp(g) ⊂ sp(f ). Next, we show that g is totally ergodic. Let r ∈ R, gr (s) := g(s + r), fr (s) := t+δ f (s + r). Then gr (t) = 1δ t fr (s) ds. By the computation above, we have for Re λ > 0, δ 1 λδ 1 − eλδ δ 1 − e−λδ gr (λ) = (e − 1)fr (λ) + fr (s) ds + eλδ fr (s) ds. δλ λδ λδ 0 0
Let λ = α + iη (α > 0). Then αfr (α + iη) converges uniformly in r ∈ R+ as α ↓ 0. Consequently, so does αgr (α + iη). We have shown that g is totally ergodic. Moreover, (M0 g)(0) = limα↓0 αˆ g (α) = limα↓0 αfˆ(α) = (M0 f )(0), whereas for η = 0, (Mη g)(0) = 0. It follows from Corollary 4.7.8 that g(t) converges as t → ∞; i.e., f (t) is B-convergent as t → ∞. It follows from Theorem 4.1.2 that B- lim f (t) = lim g(t) = (M0 g)(0) = (M0 f )(0). t→∞
t→∞
Lemma 4.7.13. Let f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X). Let η ∈ R such that
t
−iηs
sup e f (s) ds
< ∞. 0
t≥0
Then f is uniformly ergodic at η and Mη f = 0.
t
Proof. Let M be such that 0 e−iηs f (s) ds ≤ M (t ≥ 0). Let r ≥ 0. Then
t
iηr t+r −iηs
−iηs
e f (s + r) ds = e e f (s) ds
≤ 2M. 0
t
As an application of Theorem 4.7.12 we obtain the following result on power series. We let T := {z ∈ C : |z| = 1}. m Proposition 4.7.14. Let an ∈ X such that M := supm∈N n=0 an < ∞. Consider the power series ∞ an z n (|z| < 1). p(z) := n=0
Assume that for each z ∈ T \ {1} the function p has a holomorphic extension to a neighbourhood of z. Then limn→∞ an = 0. Proof. Let f (t) := an for t ∈ [n, n + 1), n ∈ N0 . Then f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X) and
f ∞ ≤ 2M . For Re λ > 0, one has m+1 1 ∞ ∞ fˆ(λ) = am e−λt dt = am e−λm e−λt dt m=0
=
1−e λ
m ∞ −λ m=0
m=0
am e−λm .
0
4.7. ASYMPTOTICALLY ALMOST PERIODIC FUNCTIONS
317
t
Thus, sp(f ) ⊂ 2πZ. We will show that supt≥0 0 e−iηs f (s) ds < ∞ for all η ∈ 2πZ. Then Lemma 4.7.13 and Corollary 4.7.10 imply that f is totally ergodic and Mη f = 0 for all η ∈ R. Finally, Theorem 4.7.12 implies that
n+1
lim an = lim
n→∞
n→∞
f (s) ds = B- lim f (t) = 0. n→∞
n
Let η = 0. For t ≥ 0, let n ∈ N such that t ∈ [n, n + 1). Then
t
f (s) ds = 0
n−1
am + an (t − n).
m=0
t
Thus, 0 f (s) ds ≤ 3M . Let η = 2πk, k ∈ Z \ {0}. Let t ≥ 0, t ∈ [n, n + 1). Then
t
e−iηs f (s) ds
0
=
n−1
t
= an
t
Hence, 0 e−iηs f (s) ds ≤ 2M .
e−i2πkt dt + an
m
m=0
m+1
am
t
e−i2πks ds
n
e−i2πks ds.
n
Corollary 4.7.15 (Katznelson-Tzafriri). Let T ∈ L(X) be an operator such that M := supn∈N T n < ∞. Then σ(T ) ∩ T ⊂ {1} if and only if limn→∞ T n (I − T ) = 0. Proof. a) Assume that σ(T ) ∩ T ⊂ {1}. Let p(z) :=
∞
(T − I)T n z n = (T − I)(I − zT )−1
for |z| < 1.
n=0
Then
m
(T − I)T n = T m+1 − I ≤ M + 1.
n=0
Thus the claim follows from Proposition 4.7.14. b) Suppose that limn→∞ T n (I − T ) = 0 and μ ∈ σ(T ) ∩ T. By the spectral mapping theorem, μn (1 − μ) ∈ σ(T n (I − T )). Then |1 − μ| = |μn (1 − μ)| ≤ T n (I − T ) → 0. Hence, μ = 1.
318
4.8
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
Carleman Spectrum and Fourier Transform
For functions on the line, the Carleman spectrum is the natural notion if we are interested in the properties of the Laplace transform (or more precisely, the Carleman transform). However, the Fourier transform is also a powerful tool. In order to make it available we show in this section that the Carleman spectrum coincides with the support of the Fourier transform of the given function and also with the Beurling spectrum. As applications we give several results which allow us to deduce asymptotic properties of a function from the nature of its spectrum. For example, we show that a function f ∈ BUC(R, X) is almost periodic whenever it has discrete spectrum. A function f ∈ L∞ (R, X) is τ -periodic if and only if its spectrum is contained in 2π Z. τ Let f ∈ L1 (R). As in Section 1.8 and Appendix E, we denote by Ff ∈ C0 (R) the Fourier transform given by Ff (t) := e−ist f (s) ds (t ∈ R) (4.40) R
and we let Ff (t) :=
R
eits f (s) ds (t ∈ R).
(4.41)
By S(R) we denote the Schwartz space; i.e., the space of all infinitely differentiable functions f : R → C such that supt∈R |f (m) (t)|(1 + |t|)k < ∞ for all m, k ∈ N0 . Then F is a bijective mapping from S(R) into S(R) with inverse (2π)−1 F . See Appendix E for further information. −k Let X be a Banach space. By L1 (R, we denote the space of (1 + |t|) dt; X) 1 all functions f ∈ Lloc (R, X) such that R f (t) (1 + |t|)−k dt < ∞, where k ∈ N0 . Note that L1 (R, X) ⊂ L1 (R, (1 + |t|)−k dt; X) for all k ∈ N0 . Let f ∈ L1 (R, (1 + |t|)−k dt; X), where k ∈ N0 . Then we define Ff as a linear mapping from S(R) into X by ϕ, Ff = f (t)(Fϕ)(t) dt (ϕ ∈ S(R)). R
The support of F f is defined by supp F f := η ∈ R : for all ε > 0 there exists ϕ ∈ S(R) such that
supp ϕ ⊂ (η − ε, η + ε) and ϕ, F f , = 0 .
(4.42)
In the particular when k = 0, i.e. f ∈ L1 (R, X), Fubini’s theorem shows that case −ist ϕ, Ff = R R f (t)e dt ϕ(s) ds. Hence, supp Ff = {s ∈ R : (Ff )(s) = 0}− ,
(4.43)
4.8. CARLEMAN SPECTRUM AND FOURIER TRANSFORM
319
and our notation is consistent with (4.40) and the identification of absolutely regular functions with distributions when X = C (see Theorem 1.8.1 b) and Appendix E). If f ∈ L1 (R, (1 + |t|)−k dt; X), then one can define the Carleman transform ˆ f : C \ (iR) → X and the Carleman spectrum spC (f ) exactly as in Section 4.6. We are going to show that supp Ff and spC (f ) coincide. We recall the notion of mollifier (ρn )n∈N from Section 1.3, but here we shall assume that ρ1 ∈ S(R). The function ρ1 ∈ S(R) satisfies R ρ1 (t) dt = 1. Then ρn ∈ S(R) is given by ρn (t) = nρ1 (nt) (t ∈ R, n ∈ N). Thus, F ρn ∈ S(R)
(n ∈ N),
(4.44)
and F ρn (t) = Fρ1 ( nt ), so lim (Fρn )(t) = 1 (t ∈ R); |(Fρn )(t)| ≤ |ρ1 (s)| ds (t ∈ R, n ∈ N). n→∞
(4.45) (4.46)
R
Moreover, if supp ρ1 ⊂ (−1, 1), then
! " supp ρn ⊂ − n1 , n1
(n ∈ N);
(4.47)
(n ∈ N).
(4.48)
and if supp Fρ1 ⊂ (−1, 1), then supp Fρn ⊂ (−n, n)
Theorem 4.8.1. Let k ∈ N0 , f ∈ L1 (R, (1 + |t|)−k dt; X). Then spC (f ) = supp F f . Proof. Let η ∈ R. Then by the definition of the Carleman transform, for α > 0, one has ∞ ˆ f (α + iη) = e−αt e−iηt f (t) dt and 0
fˆ(−α + iη)
=
−
0
eαt e−iηt f (t) dt.
−∞
Hence,
fˆ(α + iη) − fˆ(−α + iη) =
∞
e−α|t| e−iηt f (t) dt.
−∞
Let ϕ ∈ S(R). Then by Fubini’s theorem, ϕ, F f = f (t)(Fϕ)(t) dt R = lim e−α|t| f (t)(F ϕ)(t) dt α↓0 R = lim e−α|t| f (t) e−ist ϕ(s) ds dt α↓0 R R −α|t| −ist = lim e e f (t) dt ϕ(s) ds. α↓0
R
R
(4.49)
320
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
Thus by (4.49), we obtain ϕ, F f = lim
α↓0
R
fˆ(α + is) − fˆ(−α + is) ϕ(s) ds
(4.50)
for all ϕ ∈ S(R). From this, the inclusion supp F f ⊂ spC (f ) follows immediately: Assume that η ∈ spC (f ). Then there exists ε > 0 such !that fˆ has a bounded holomorphic " extension to B(iη, ε). This implies that limα↓0 fˆ(α + is) − fˆ(−α + is) = 0 whenever s ∈ (η − ε, η + ε). Thus, by (4.50) and the dominated convergence theorem, ϕ, Ff = 0 whenever ϕ ∈ S(R) and supp ϕ ⊂ (η − ε, η + ε). Next, we prove the other inclusion: spC (f ) ⊂ supp Ff . a) We first deal with the special case where k = 0; i.e., f ∈ L1 (R). Then F f is a continuous function. Let η ∈ R \ supp Ff . Then there exists ε > 0 such that Ff vanishes on (η − ε, η + ε). Putting fˆ(iβ) :=
∞
−iβt
e 0
f (t) dt = −
0
e−iβt f (t) dt
−∞
for β ∈ (η − ε, η + ε), fˆ has a continuous extension to a neighbourhood of iη. It follows from Morera’s theorem that this extension is holomorphic. Thus, η ∈ spC (f ). b) Now let k ∈ N0 be arbitrary. We first give an estimate of fˆ. Let M := (1 + |t|)−k f (t) dt. Then R
fˆ(λ) ≤ M kk e1−k | Re λ|−k
(4.51)
whenever 0 < | Re λ| < 1. In fact, if 0 < Re λ < 1, then ∞
fˆ(λ) ≤ e− Re λt f (t) dt 0 ! " ≤ M sup (1 + t)k e− Re λt t>0
≤ M kk e1−k (Re λ)−k . The estimation is similar for −1 < Re λ < 0. Now let η ∈ R \ supp F f . Then there exists ε > 0 such that ϕ, F f = 0 for all ϕ ∈ S(R) with supp ϕ ⊂ (η − 2ε, η + 2ε). Let (ρn )n∈N be a mollifier in S(R), such that supp ρn ⊂ (− n1 , n1 ). Let fn := (Fρn ) · f . Since F ρn ∈ S(R), we have fn ∈ L1 (R, X). For n > 1/ε, we have supp Ffn ∩ (η − ε, η + ε) = ∅. In fact, let ϕ ∈ S(R) such that supp ϕ ⊂ (η − ε, η + ε). Then F f , ϕ = f F ϕ = f F ρn · F ϕ = n R n R f F (ρn ∗ ϕ) = 0 since ρn ∗ ϕ ∈ S(R) and supp ρn ∗ ϕ ⊂ supp ρn + supp ϕ ⊂ (− n1 , n1 ) + (η − ε, η + ε) ⊂ (η − 2ε, η + 2ε).
4.8. CARLEMAN SPECTRUM AND FOURIER TRANSFORM
321
From part a) of the proof we conclude that fˆn has a holomorphic extension to B(iη, ε). Since fn (t) ≤ f (t) ρ1 1 , we obtain from (4.51) (replacing f by fn ) that fˆn (λ) ≤ M ρ 1 k k e1−k | Re λ|−k whenever 0 < | Re λ| < 1. Now it follows from Lemma 4.6.6 that
fˆn (λ) ≤ c
(λ ∈ B(iη, ε/2))
(4.52)
for all n ∈ N, where c is a constant independent of n ∈ N. Since fn (t) → f (t) as n → ∞ for all t ∈ R (see Lemma 1.3.3), it follows from the dominated convergence theorem that limn→∞ fˆn (λ) = fˆ(λ) if Re λ > 0. It follows from Vitali’s theorem (Theorem A.5) that fˆ has a holomorphic extension to B(iη, ε/2). Thus, η ∈ spC (f ). The following are consequences of Theorem 4.8.1, and extensions of parts of Corollary 4.5.9 (see Proposition 4.6.10). Theorem 4.8.2. Let f ∈ L1 (R, (1 + |t|)−k dt; X) for some k ∈ N0 . a) spC (f ) = ∅ if and only if f (t) = 0 a.e. b) spC (f ) = {0} if and only if f is a polynomial. c) spC (f ) ⊂ {η 1 . . . ηm } if and only if there exist polynomials p1 , . . . , pm such m that f (t) = j=1 pj (t)eiηj t (t ∈ R). Proof. a) Assume that spC (f ) = ∅. Then it follows from the proof of Theorem 4.8.1 that R f (t)Fϕ(t) dt = 0 for all ϕ ∈ Cc∞ (R). Since Cc∞ (R) is dense in S(R) for the canonical topology of S(R) and since F is continuous(see Appendix E), it follows that R f (t)(Fϕ)(t) dt = 0 for all ϕ ∈ S(R). Hence, R f (t)ψ(t) dt = 0 for all ψ ∈ S(R). This implies that f (t) = 0 a.e. b) Assume that spC (f ) = {0}. Then the Laurent series fˆ(λ) =
∞
an λn
n=−∞
converges for λ ∈ C \ {0}, where 1 an := f (z)z −n−1 dz 2πi |z|=r
(n ∈ Z)
independently of r > 0. From (4.51) we obtain a constant c > 0 such that
fˆ(λ) ≤ c| Re λ|−k for 0 < | Re λ| < 1. This implies that
1
z2 k ˆ
n+k−1 z (1 + 2 ) f (z) dz ≤ c 2k r n
2πi |z|=r
r
(4.53)
(n ∈ Z, r ∈ (0, 1))
322
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS 2
(observe that for z = reiθ , (1 + zr2 )k fˆ(z) ≤ |1 + ei2θ |k c |r cos θ|−k = 2k cr−k ). Hence,
k
k
1 −2j n+k−1+2j ˆ
c 2k r n ≥ r · z f (z) dz
2πi |z|=r
j=0 j
k k −2j
= r a −n−k−2j
j=0 j
for all r ∈ (0, 1). Multiplying by r 2k , we obtain
k
k
k n+2k 2k−2j
c2 r ≥ r a−n−k−2j
. j
j=0
Now let n ≥ 1−2k. Then the left-hand term, as well as all terms on the right except for j = k, converge to 0 as r ↓ 0. Consequently, a−n−3k = 0 whenever n ≥ 1 − 2k, ∞ k i.e., am = 0 if m < −k, so fˆ(λ) = n=−k an λn . Let f0 (t) := j=0 a−j−1 tj /j!. −1 Then fˆ0 (λ) = n=−k an λn . Thus fˆ− fˆ0 is entire and so spC (f −f0 ) = ∅. It follows from a) that f (t) = f0 (t) a.e. c) We prove the assertion by induction. Let m = 1. Then spC (f ) = {η1 }. Let g(t) := e−iη1 t f (t). Then spC (g) = 0. It follows from b) that g is a polynomial. Now assume that the assertion holds for m and that spC (f ) = {η1 , . . . , ηm+1 }, where ηj = ηl if j = l. Replacing f (t) by e−iηm+1 t f (t) if necessary, we can assume that ηm+1 = 0. It follows from the proof of b) that 0 is a pole of fˆ. Moreover, there exists a polynomial pm+1 such that (f − pm+1 ) has a holomorphic extension to a neighbourhood of 0. Thus, spC (f − pm+1 ) ⊂ {η 1m, . . . , ηm }. Now it follows from the inductive assumption that (f − pm+1 )(t) = n=1 pn (t)eiηn t (t ∈ R). Corollary 4.8.3. Let f ∈ L∞ (R, X). a) If spC (f ) = {0}, then f is constant. b) If spC (f ) is finite, then f is a trigonometric polynomial. If f ∈ L∞ (R, X), there is an alternative way to describe the spectrum of f . We define the Beurling spectrum by spB (f ) := η ∈ R : for all ε > 0 there exists g ∈ L1 (R) such that supp Fg ⊂ (η − ε, η + ε) and f ∗ g = 0 . Proposition 4.8.4. Let f ∈ L∞ (R, X). Then spC (f ) = spB (f ).
4.8. CARLEMAN SPECTRUM AND FOURIER TRANSFORM
323
Proof. By Theorem 4.8.1, we have spC (f ) = supp F f = η ∈ R : for all ε > 0 there exists ϕ ∈ S(R) such that supp ϕ ⊂ (η − ε, η + ε) and =
η ∈ R : for all ε > 0 there exists h ∈ S(R) such that supp F h ⊂ (η − ε, η + ε) and
=
=
R
f (t)h(t) dt = 0
η ∈ R : for all ε > 0 there exists h ∈ S(R) such that supp F h ⊂ (η − ε, η + ε) and
R
f (t)(F ϕ)(t) dt = 0
R
f (t)h(−t) dt = 0
η ∈ R : for all ε > 0 there exists h ∈ S(R) such that supp F h ⊂ (η − ε, η + ε) and (f ∗ h)(0) = 0 .
This shows that spC (f ) ⊂ spB (f ). In order to show the converse, let η ∈ spB (f ). Let ε > 0. Then there exists g ∈ L1 (R) such that supp F g ⊂ (η − ε, η + ε) and f ∗ g = 0. Replacing g by g(· − t) if necessary, we can assume that (f ∗ g)(0) = 0. Take a mollifier (ρn )n∈N in S(R) such that supp ρn ⊂ (− n1 , n1 ), and define gn := F ρn · g. By (4.45), (4.46) and the dominated convergence theorem, limn→∞ gn = g in L1 (R). It follows from Proposition 1.3.2 that limn→∞ (gn ∗ f )(0) = (g ∗ f )(0) = 0. We have ρn ∗ Fg ∈ C ∞ (R) (see Proposition 1.3.6) and supp(ρn ∗ Fg) ⊂ 1 1 (− n , n ) + (η − ε, η + ε) ⊂ (η − 2ε, η + 2ε) if n > 1/ε. Moreover, (ρn ∗ Fg)(s) = ρn (s − r)Fg(r) dr = ρn (s − r) g(t)e−irt dt dr = ρn (r) g(t)e−i(s−r)t dt dr = F((Fρn )·g)(s). Hence, Fgn = F((Fρn )·g) ∈ Cc∞ (R) ⊂ S(R). Since F is a bijection from S(R) onto S(R), it follows that gn ∈ S(R). We have shown that there exists n > 1/ε such that gn ∈ S(R), supp F gn ⊂ (η − 2ε, η + 2ε) and (f ∗ gn )(0) = 0. Since ε > 0 is arbitrary, it follows that η ∈ supp F f = spC (f ). So far, we have established the identity of three different notions of spectrum of a function f ∈ L∞ (R, X): the Carleman spectrum, the support of its Fourier transform, and the Beurling spectrum. Next, we consider two situations in which a special form of the spectrum of a function tells us a lot about the nature of the function itself (Theorems 4.8.7 and 4.8.8). We need the following auxiliary result. Lemma 4.8.5. Let f ∈ L∞ (R, X) and g ∈ L1 (R). Then spC (f ∗ g) ⊂ spC (f ) ∩ supp Fg. Proof. a) Let η ∈ R \ spC (f ). By Proposition 4.8.4, there exists ε > 0 such that
324
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
f ∗ h = 0 whenever h ∈ L1 (R), supp Fh ⊂ (η − ε, η + ε). Hence, (f ∗ g) ∗ h = (f ∗ h) ∗ g = 0. Thus, η ∈ spB (f ∗ g) = spC (f ∗ g). b) Let η ∈ supp F g. We show that η ∈ spB (f ∗ g). There exists ε > 0 such that (Fg)(r) = 0 for all r ∈ (η − ε, η + ε). Let h ∈ L1 (R) such that supp Fh ⊂ (η − ε, η + ε). Then F(g ∗ h) = F g · Fh = 0. Thus, g ∗ h = 0. Hence, (f ∗ g) ∗ h = 0. This proves the claim. Remark 4.8.6. The same property is true if f ∈ L1 (R, (1 + |t|)−k dt; X) for some k ∈ N0 and g ∈ S(R). Now we can prove that a function f ∈ BUC(R, X) is almost periodic whenever it has discrete Carleman spectrum. Thus, the geometric condition “c0 ⊂ X”, which appeared in Theorem 4.6.3, is not needed if the spectrum does not have any accumulation point. Theorem 4.8.7. Let f ∈ BUC(R, X). If the spectrum spC (f ) of f is discrete, then f is almost periodic. Proof. Let (ρn )n∈N be a mollifier in S(R) such that supp F ρ1 ⊂ (−1, 1). By Proposition 1.3.2 and Lemma 4.8.5, f ∗ ρn ∈ BUC(R, X) and spC (f ∗ ρn ) ⊂ spC (f ) ∩ supp F ρn ⊂ spC (f ) ∩ (−n, n). Thus, f ∗ ρn has finite spectrum, and it follows from Corollary 4.8.3 that f ∗ ρn ∈ AP(R, X). By Lemma 1.3.3, it follows that f = limn→∞ f ∗ ρn ∈ AP(R, X). Next, we give a spectral characterization of periodic functions extending part of Corollary 4.5.9. If g is a function defined on R we let gˇ(t) = g(−t) (t ∈ R). Theorem 4.8.8. Let f ∈ L∞ (R, X) and let τ > 0. Then f is τ -periodic (i.e., f (t + τ ) = f (t) t-a.e.) if and only if spC (f ) ⊂ 2π τ Z. Proof. a) Let f be τ -periodic. Then fˆ(λ) = (1 − e−λτ )−1
τ
e−λt f (t) dt
0
for λ ∈ C \ iR. Thus, fˆ extends to a meromorphic function with at most simple poles at λn := 2πin/τ (n ∈ Z). The residue at λn is given by 1 τ −2πint/τ cn := e f (t) dt (n ∈ Z). τ 0 Therefore we have spC (f ) = {2πn/τ : n ∈ Z, cn = 0} . b) Assume that spC (f ) ⊂ 2π τ Z. Let (ρn )n∈N be a mollifier in S(R) such that supp Fρn ⊂ (−n, n) and ρˇn = ρn (n ∈ N). Then ρn ∗ f ∈ BUC(R, X) and spC (ρn ∗ f ) ⊂ supp Fρn ∩ spC (f ) ⊂ (−n, n) ∩ spC (f ) ⊂ (−n, n) ∩ 2π τ Z. It follows
4.9. COMPLEX TAUBERIAN THEOREMS: THE FOURIER METHOD 325 from Corollary 4.8.3 and Proposition 4.6.10 that ρn ∗f is a τ -periodic trigonometric polynomial. Letϕ ∈ Cc (R). Then limn→∞ ρn ∗ ϕ = ϕ in L1 (R). Thus, f (t + τ ) ϕ(t)dt = limn→∞ f (t + τ ) (ρn ∗ ϕ)(t) dt = limn→∞ (f ∗ρn )(t + τ ) ϕ(t) dt = limn→∞ (f ∗ ρn )(t) ϕ(t) dt = limn→∞ f (t) (ρn ∗ ϕ)(t) dt = f (t) ϕ(t) dt. Since ϕ ∈ Cc (R) is arbitrary, it follows that f (t + τ ) = f (t) t-a.e.
4.9
Complex Tauberian Theorems: the Fourier Method
In this section we present an approach via Fourier transforms to complex Tauberian theorems for Laplace transforms. This method was already used in a restricted form by Ingham in 1935 (see [Ing35]). It will eventually lead to the most general complex Tauberian theorem presented in this book (Theorem 4.9.7). It is not such a great difference to consider bounded measurable functions which are slowly oscillating, instead of uniformly continuous functions as we did before, but the point is that the notion of spectrum is changed. Instead of considering a point iη as regular if the Laplace transform has a holomorphic extension in a neighbourhood of iη, we merely assume that a locally integrable extension to the imaginary axis exists. This leads to a smaller spectrum which we call the weak half-line spectrum. Thus, asking that this small spectrum be countable is a weaker hypothesis. It turns out that this weaker hypothesis is more natural or easier to verify in some applications (see the Notes of this section). In the case where the weak half-line spectrum is empty, the proof is completely elementary and leads to a slight generalization of Ingham’s Tauberian theorem. We consider this case first (Theorem 4.9.5). The general case will be proved by a Hahn-Banach argument which allows us to apply Loomis’s theorem in a quite tricky way. Let f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X). We define the weak half-line spectrum spw (f ) of f as follows. Definition 4.9.1. Let η ∈ R. We say that iη is a weakly regular point for fˆ if there exist ε > 0 and h ∈ L1 ((η − ε, η + ε), X) such that fˆ(α + i·) → h in the distributional sense on (η − ε, η + ε) as α ↓ 0.
(4.54)
Then the weak half-line spectrum spw (f ) of f is defined as the set of all real numbers which are not weakly regular for fˆ. Of course, (4.54) means by definition that lim α↓0
fˆ(α + is)ϕ(s) ds =
R
η+ε
h(s)ϕ(s) ds η−ε
for all test functions ϕ ∈ D(η − ε, η − ε) = Cc∞ (η − ε, η − ε).
(4.55)
326
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
It is clear that spw (f ) is a closed subset of R. Moreover, if fˆ(λ) has a continuous extension to C+ ∪ (i(η − ε), i(η + ε)), where η ∈ R, ε > 0, then clearly η ∈ spw (f ). In particular, we have spw (f ) ⊂ sp(f ). The inclusion is strict in general as the following example shows. Example 4.9.2. Let X := l2 , f (t) := n−1 e−t/n
. n∈N
Then fˆ has a continuous extension to C+ ∪ iR, but not a holomorphic extension to a neighbourhood of 0. Lemma 4.9.3. Let f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X). Then there exists h ∈ L1loc (R \ spw (f ), X) such that fˆ(α + i·) → h in the distributional sense on R \ spw (f ) as α ↓ 0.
(4.56)
We set fˆ(is) := h(s) (s ∈ R \ spw (f )). Proof. For all x ∈ R \ spw (f ), we find an open neighbourhood Ux of x and hx ∈ L1 (Ux , X) such that fˆ(α + i·) → hx in the distributional sense on Ux as α ↓ 0. Clearly, hx (t) = hy (t) almost everywhere on Ux ∩ Uy whenever x, y ∈ R \ spw (f ). Hence, there exists a function h ∈ L1loc (R \ spw (f ), X) such that h|Ux = hx
(x ∈ R \ spw (f )).
It remains to show (4.56). Let ϕ ∈ D(R \ spw (f )). Let K := supp ϕ. There exist x1 , x2 , . . . , xn such that the sets Uj := Uxj (j = 1, 2, . . . , n) cover K. Let ϕj ∈ D(R \ spw (f )) (j = 1, 2, . . . , n) be a partition of unity nsubordinate to this covering; i.e., 0 ≤ ϕj ≤ 1, supp ϕj ⊂ Uj (j = 1, 2, . . . , n), j=1 ϕj (x) = 1 for all x ∈ K. n Then ϕ = j=1 ψj , where ψj := ϕϕj . Since supp ψj ⊂ Uj , lim fˆ(α + is)ψj (s) ds = h(s)ψj (s) ds α↓0
R
Uj
for all j = 1, 2, . . . , n. Hence, lim fˆ(α + is)ϕ(s) ds = α↓0
R
h(s)ϕ(s) ds.
(4.57)
R\spw (f )
Since ϕ ∈ D(R \ spw (f )) is arbitrary, this is precisely the meaning of (4.56). Lemma 4.9.4. Let f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X). Then ϕ ∗ f ∈ C0 (R+ , X) for all ϕ ∈ S(R) such that Fϕ ∈ Cc∞ (R) and supp F ϕ ∩ spw (f ) = ∅.
4.9. COMPLEX TAUBERIAN THEOREMS: THE FOURIER METHOD 327 Here as elsewhere, we identify a function defined on R+ with its extension by 0 on R. In particular, ∞ (ϕ ∗ f )(t) = f (s)ϕ(t − s) ds (t ∈ R). 0
Proof of Lemma 4.9.4. Let ϕ ∈ S(R) such that F ϕ ∈ Cc∞ (R) and supp Fϕ ∩ spw (f ) = ∅. Then Fϕ · fˆ(i·) ∈ L1 (R, X), where fˆ(i·) was defined in Lemma 4.9.3. Let t ≥ 0. Then the inverse Fourier transform of the function s → ϕ(t − s) is the function η → (2π)−1 eiηt Fϕ(η). Thus by Theorem 1.8.1 b), ∞ (ϕ ∗ f )(t) = f (s)ϕ(t − s) ds 0 ∞ = lim e−αs f (s)ϕ(t − s) ds α↓0 0 −1 = lim (2π) fˆ(α + iη)eiηt Fϕ(η) dη α↓0 R −1 = (2π) fˆ(iη)Fϕ(η)eiηt dη. R
It follows from the Riemann-Lebesgue lemma (Theorem 1.8.1) that limt→∞ (ϕ ∗ f )(t) = 0. Now we prove the complex Tauberian theorem in the case where the weak half-line spectrum is empty. Theorem 4.9.5 (Ingham). Let f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X) be slowly oscillating. If spw (f ) = ∅, then lim f (t) = 0. t→∞
Proof. a) We show that g ∗ f ∈ C0 (R+ , X) for all g ∈ L1 (R). By Proposition 1.3.2, T g := (g ∗ f )|R+ defines a bounded linear operator from L1 (R) into BUC(R+ , X). Let φ be a continuous linear functional on BUC(R+ , X) vanishing on C0 (R+ , X). By the Hahn-Banach theorem, it suffices to show that T g, φ = 0 for all g ∈ L1 (R). Let h := T ∗ φ ∈ L∞ (R). Then g ∗ f, φ = hg dt R
for all g ∈ L1 (R). It follows from Lemma 4.9.4 that R hϕ dt = 0 if ϕ ∈ S(R) and Fϕ ∈ Cc∞ (R). Hence, supp F h = ∅ (see (4.42)). Thus, spC (h) = ∅ by Theorem 4.8.1 which implies that h = 0 by Theorem 4.8.2. This proves the claim. We have shown that g ∗ f ∈ C0 (R+ , X) for all g ∈ L1 (R). b) Taking in particular g := 1δ χ[0,δ] , it follows from a) that B-limt→∞ f (t) = 0. Now it follows from Theorem 4.2.3 that limt→∞ f (t) = 0.
328
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
We will see in Example 5.5.7 that in general the hypothesis that g be slowly oscillating cannot be omitted. Next, we consider the case of countable weak spectrum and we extend Theorem 4.7.12. We need the notion of uniform ergodicity on a subset of R, for bounded measurable functions, similar to the total ergodicity of Section 4.7. Definition 4.9.6. Let f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X) and let E be a subset of R. We say that f is uniformly ergodic on E if for all η ∈ E the limit ∞ (Mη f ) (t) = lim α e−(α+iη)s f (t + s) ds α↓0
0
exists uniformly in t ∈ R+ . As in (4.25) it follows that Mη f = eiη ⊗ x where eiη (t) = e
iηt
, x = (Mη f ) (0) ∈ X.
The following complex Tauberian theorem is the main result of this section. Its proof is based on the same idea as the one of Theorem 4.9.5, but it is less elementary since Loomis’s theorem is used. Theorem 4.9.7. Let f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X) be slowly oscillating. Assume that spw (f ) is countable and that f is uniformly ergodic on spw (f ). Then f = f0 + f1 , where f1 ∈ AP(R+ , X) and limt→∞ f0 (t) = 0. In particular, if f ∈ BUC(R+ , X) then f ∈ AAP(R+ , X). Proof. a) We show that g ∗ f ∈ AAP(R+ , X) for all g ∈ L1 (R) (and for this we do not need the assumption that f is slowly oscillating). As in the proof of Theorem 4.9.5, we consider the operator T : L1 (R) → BUC(R+ , X) given by T g := (g ∗ f )|R+ . Let φ ∈ BUC(R+ , X)∗ be a continuous linear functional on BUC(R+ , X) which vanishes on AAP(R+ , X). We have to show that g ∗ f, φ = 0 for all g ∈ L1 (R). Then the claim follows from the Hahn-Banach theorem. Let h := T ∗ φ. As in the proof of Theorem 4.9.5 it follows from Lemma 4.9.4 that spC (h) ⊂ spw (f ). Hence, spC (h) is countable. Let ϕ ∈ L1 (R). Since spC (ϕ ∗ h) ⊂ spC (h) (by Lemma 4.8.5), spC (ϕ ∗ h) is also countable. Moreover, ϕ ∗ h ∈ BUC(R) by Proposition 1.3.2. It follows from Loomis’s theorem (Corollary 4.6.4) that ϕ ∗ h ∈ AP(R) for all ϕ ∈ L1 (R). Next, let ϕ ∈ Cc∞ (0, ∞). We show that Mη (ϕ ∗ h) = 0 for all η ∈ R in order to conclude that ϕ ∗ h = 0 by Corollary 4.5.9. First, since Freq(ϕ ∗ h) ⊂ spC (ϕ ∗ h) ⊂ spw (f ), it is clear that Mη (ϕ ∗ h) = 0 for all η ∈ R \ spw (f ). Now, let η ∈ spw (f ). Let cη := Mη (ϕ ∗ h)(0). Then Mη (ϕ ∗ h)(t) = cη eiηt
(see (4.25)).
4.10. NOTES
329
We have to show that cη = 0. For λ ∈ R, we define eλ (t) := eλt (t ∈ R). Note that ∞ cη = lim α e−(α+iη)t (ϕ ∗ h) (t) dt α↓0
0
= lim αχR+ e−(α+iη) , ϕ ∗ h α↓0
= lim αh, χR− eα+iη ∗ ϕ α↓0
= lim α(f ∗ χR− eα+iη ∗ ϕ)|R+ , φ . α↓0
However, kα (t) := α
0
−∞
f (t − s)ei(α+iη)s ds = α
∞
f (t + s)e−i(α+iη)s ds
0
converges to the function eiη ⊗ x as α ↓ 0 uniformly in t ≥ 0. Since ϕ ∈ Cc∞ (0, ∞), this implies that (kα ∗ ϕ)(t) converges to ∞ eiηt e−iηs ϕ(s) ds x =: k(t) 0
uniformly in t ≥ 0 as α ↓ 0. Thus, cη = k, φ . Since k ∈ AP(R+ , X), it follows that cη = 0. We have shown that h ∗ ϕ = 0 for all ϕ ∈ Cc∞ (0, ∞). Choosing a mollifier (ρn )n∈N ⊂ Cc∞ (−∞, 0), we deduce that for all k ∈ L1 (R), k, h = lim k ∗ ρn , h = lim k, ρˇn ∗ h = 0. n→∞
n→∞
Thus, T ∗ φ = h = 0. Here, for v : R → X we let vˇ(t) = v(−t). It follows that g ∗ f, φ = 0 for all φ ∈ BUC(R+ , X)∗ vanishing on AAP(R+ , X). Hence, g ∗ f ∈ AAP(R+ , X). b) Since f is slowly oscillating, f = g0 + g1 where g1 ∈ BUC(R+ , X) and limt→∞ g0 (t) = 0, by Proposition 4.2.2. Let (ρn )n∈N ⊂ Cc∞ (0, ∞) be a mollifier with supp ρn ⊂ (0, 1/n). Then ρn ∗ g0 ∈ C0 (R+ , X), and ρn ∗ f ∈ AAP(R+ , X) by a). Hence, ρn ∗ g1 = ρn ∗ f − ρn ∗ g0 ∈ AAP(R+ , X). Since g1 ∈ BUC(R+ , X), limn→∞ ρn ∗ g1 = g1 in BUC(R+ , X). Thus, g1 ∈ AAP(R+ , X). Now, g1 = f1 + f2 with f1 ∈ AP(R+ , X), f2 ∈ C0 (R+ , X). Thus, f = f1 + (f2 + g0 ).
4.10 Notes Sections 4.1 and 4.2 The prototype for Abelian theorems was Abel’s classical continuity theorem (Theorem 4.1.6) which was proved by N. Abel [Abe26] in 1826. Tauberian theorems form their counterpart and the first result of this type is Tauber’s classical theorem from 1897
330
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
[Tau97] which is mentioned in connection with Hardy’s Theorem 4.2.17. There is an enormous amount of literature on Tauberian theorems. We refer to the monographs by Widder [Wid71] and by Doetsch [Doe50, Volume I] for the classical results. The monographs of Pitt [Pit58] and van de Lune [Lun86], and Chatterji’s historical account [Cha84], cover some of the subsequent developments, and Korevaar’s book [Kor04] is a wide-ranging account which provides much historical information up to recent times. The notion of B-limit was introduced by Arendt and Pr¨ uss [AP92] following ideas of Batty [Bat90] showing how to pass from theorem of type D to results of type E. Theorem 4.2.15 illustrates in a surprising way how this strategy can be used. The presentation given here is close to [AP92]. With the help of Wiener’s Tauberian theorem the following clarification of Bconvergence was given by Arendt and Batty [AB00]. Theorem 4.10.1. Let u ∈ L∞ (R, X), u∞ ∈ X, and suppose that 1 t→∞ δ
lim
t
t+δ
u(s) ds = u∞
holds for δ = δ1 and δ = δ2 , where δ1 and δ2 are rationally independent. Then
lim (ρ ∗ u)(t) = ρ u∞ t→∞
R
for all ρ ∈ L1 (R). In particular, B-limt→∞ u(t) = u∞ . Karamata’s theorem has important applications to the study of eigenvalue distributions (see e.g. [Sim79, Theorem 10.6]). An elegant short proof of Karamata’s theorem in the scalar case has been given by K¨ onig [K¨ on60]. Further Abelian and Tauberian theorems for positive vector-valued functions were given by El-Mennaoui [Elm94]. Another direction of Tauberian theorems for Laplace transforms occurs in the framework of limitation theory. A final result in this direction has been obtained by Stadtm¨ uller and Trautner [ST81] and by Kratz and Stadtm¨ uller [KS90] in the discrete case. Section 4.3 The results at the beginning of the section are quite standard. A systematic study of mean convergence of integrated semigroups was carried out by El-Mennaoui [Elm92]. In particular, Theorem 4.3.7, saying that for positive C0 semigroups Ces` aro-ergodicity and Abel-ergodicity are equivalent, can be extended to integrated semigroups. We state a special case explicitly as follows: Let E be a Banach lattice with order continuous norm. Let A be a resolvent positive operator, so A generates a once integrated semigroup S (by Theorem 3.11.7). Then X = Ker A ⊕ Ran A if and only if P x = lim
t→∞
1 S(t)x t
exists for all x ∈ E. In that case, P is the projection onto Ker A along Ran A. See [Elm92, Theorem 4.1].
4.10. NOTES
331
Theorem 4.3.7 and Theorem 4.3.8 are explicitly proved in Arendt and Pr¨ uss [AP92]. More generally, El-Mennaoui [Elm92] studied strong convergence of t1k S(t) (as t → ∞), where S is a k-times integrated semigroup and k ∈ N. This is a very natural problem. In fact, if A is the generator of S, then for x ∈ D(Ak+1 ), S(·)x ∈ C k+1 ((0, ∞), X) and u(t) := S (k) (t)x defines a classical solution of the Cauchy problem u (t) = Au(t) (t ≥ 0), u(0) = x. t k−1 Thus, t1k S(t)x = t1k 0 (t−s) u(s) ds is the kth Ces` aro mean of the solution u and (k−1)! describes its asymptotic behaviour for t → ∞. Proposition 4.3.13 is due to Arendt and Batty [AB92a] who also showed that the result does not hold on every Banach lattice. In fact, an example is given in [AB92a] which shows that a positive C0 -semigroup on a space C(K), where K is compact, may well be Ces` aro-ergodic without being totally ergodic. However, in Proposition 4.3.13 the L1 -space may be replaced by any Banach lattice with order continuous norm. The striking properties concerning C0 -semigroups on L∞ -spaces are due to Lotz [Lot85]. In fact, it had been proved before by Kishimoto and Robinson [KR81] that every generator of a positive C0 -semigroup on an L∞ -space is bounded, and independently of Lotz, Coulhon [Cou84] had proved Corollary 4.3.19 for contraction semigroups. However, it was Lotz who discovered the interesting interplay of the geometric properties (G) and (DP). He proved in particular Lemma 4.3.16 and also proved ergodic theorems in the discrete case (i.e., for power bounded operators). Other examples of Banach spaces having both properties (DP) and (G) are the following: a) C(K), where K is an F -space (cf. the Notes of Section 2.7). b) H ∞ (D), the space of all bounded holomorphic functions on the unit disc D := {z ∈ C : |z| < 1} with the supremum norm. We refer to [Nag86, Section A-II.3] and the references given there. Section 4.4. A version of the complex Tauberian Theorem 4.4.1 was proved by Ingham [Ing35]. The ingenious contour argument proof of a case of Ingham’s theorem was given in Korevaar’s beautiful article [Kor82] which also gives an elementary proof of the prime number theorem based on Ingham’s Tauberian theorem. Korevaar was inspired by Newman [New80] who proved the corresponding result for Dirichlet series; see also the book by Newman [New98]. The quantified version presented in Theorem 4.4.6 is due to Batty and Duyckaerts [BD08]. Remark 4.4.7 shows that the estimate (4.15) is quite sharp when M is bounded or grows very slowly, and Borichev and Tomilov [BT10] have shown that it is optimal for polynomial growth. Theorem 4.4.8, as stated here, is due to Arendt and Batty [AB88], who also gave other versions allowing a countable number or even a null set of singularities. Here, merely the case of one singularity is presented which allows several interesting applications including those given in this section and later in the chapter. A quantified version is given in [BD08]. Further versions are contained in the work of Arendt and Pr¨ uss [AP92]. Ces` aro convergence is investigated in [AB95] with the help of contour arguments similar to those of Theorem 4.4.8. For example, it is shown that a function f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X) is Ces´ aro
332
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
convergent if f (t) = O(t) as t → ∞ and every point of iR is either regular for fˆ or a pole of order 1. Corollary 4.4.12 is contained in Arveson’s work on spectral subspaces [Arv82], but it is usually associated with Gelfand’s name. More precisely, it is the corresponding result on bounded operators which is due to Gelfand (saying that an isometry whose spectrum is {1} is necessarily the identity). Since the weak spectral mapping theorem holds for bounded C0 -groups [Nag86, A-III, Theorem 7.4], Corollary 4.4.12 follows immediately from Gelfand’s classical theorem on isometries. Another elegant proof of Gelfand’s theorem is due to Allan and Ransford [AR89], see also the survey article of Zemanek [Zem94]. Extensions of Gelfand’s theorem have been obtained by Zarrabi [Zar93]. He proved in particular that an invertible contraction T on a Banach space X with countable spectrum is already an isometry if it satisfies the growth condition log T −n
√ = 0. n→∞ n lim
Theorem 4.4.14 is taken from [BD08]. Remarkably the implication (ii) ⇒ (i) does not seem to have been in the earlier literature of operator semigroups. The implication (i) ⇒ (ii) was already implicit in [AB88] (see [Bat94, p.41]). Quantified versions were obtained for polynomial growth of M on arbitrary Banach spaces [BEPS06], and for polynomial or exponential growth of M [Bur98], [Leb96], [LR05], using methods which generally give slightly slower rates of decay than (4.19). For M (s) = β(1 + s)α , it is −1 shown in [BT10] that the rate in (4.19) is optimal on general Banach spaces, but Mlog can be replaced by M −1 in the case of Hilbert spaces. A version of Theorem 4.4.14 when σ(A) ∩ iR is finite is given in [Mar11]. These results have applications to energy decay of damped wave equations of the form ⎧ 2 ∂ u ∂u ⎪ ⎪ (t > 0, x ∈ Ω), ⎪ ⎨ ∂t2 = Δu − 2a(x) ∂t (4.58) u(x, t) = 0 (t > 0, x ∈ ∂Ω), ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ∂u 1 2 ⎩ u(·, 0) = u0 ∈ H0 (Ω), (·, 0) = u1 ∈ L (Ω). ∂t Here, Ω is a smooth or convex open subset of Rn with boundary ∂Ω, and a : Ω → [0, ∞) is a bounded continuous function representing the damping at each point. Let X be the Hilbert space H01 (Ω) × L2 (Ω), and let A be the operator on X defined by 2 D(A) := H (Ω) ∩ H01 (Ω) × H01 (Ω),
0 I A := . Δ −2a(x) Then A generates a C0 -semigroup of contractions on X, and the energy of the solution u of (4.58) is given by E(u, t) := 12 T (t)(u0 , u1 ) 2X . The following result was proved by Lebeau [Leb96] with a slightly slower rate of decay in b), and the optimal rate given here was established in [Bur98]. Once a) is proved, b) follows directly from Theorem 4.4.14 a) with M (s) = βeαs . Theorem 4.10.2. Consider the damped wave equation (4.58), where Ω is a bounded open set and a is not identically zero. We assume that Ω is smooth or convex. Let A and E(u, t) be as above. Then the following hold.
4.10. NOTES
333
a) σ(A) ⊂ {λ ∈ C : −2 a ∞ ≤ Re λ < 0}, and there exist α, β > 0 such that
R(is, A) ≤ βeα|s| for all s ∈ R. b) There is a constant C such that E(u, t) ≤ H01 (Ω), u1 ∈ H01 (Ω), and t ≥ 0.
C (u0 , u1 ) 2H 2 ×H 1 for all u0 ∈ H 2 (Ω) ∩ (log(2 + t))2
When the data is sufficiently smooth that (u0, u1 ) ∈ D(Ak ), the rate of energy decay in b) can readily be improved to O (log t)−k . In many cases, the rate is much faster than logarithmic. When the domain of damping {x ∈ Ω : a(x) > 0} satisfies the “geometric optics condition”, the energy decay is exponential (and uniform with respect to (u0 , u1 ) X ), i.e., ω(T ) < 0 and R(is, A) is bounded [BLR89]. When Ω is a rectangle in R2 and the domain of damping is a strip across Ω, the geometric optics condition is not satisfied but R(is, A) = O(s2 ) as |s| → ∞ [LR05, Example 3]. In this case, the optimal rate of decay E(u, t) = O(t−1 ) follows from [BT10, Theorem 2.4]. Laplace transform methods can also be applied to local energy decay of wave equations on exterior domains, a subject which already featured prominently in the 1967 monograph by Lax and Phillips [LP67]. In this context, Ω = Rn \ K where K is a compact obstacle, and a = 0 in (4.58). The quantity of study is now the local energy of the solutions, and one restricts attention to initial data supported in a fixed compact set. Thus one is interested in the asymptotic behaviour of P1 T (t)R(μ, A)P2 where P1 and P2 are multiplications by characteristic functions of balls. The semigroup property does not hold for P1 T (t)P2 , but Laplace transform results are still applicable. However P1 R(λ, A)P2 has a singularity at the origin when n is even, so a quantified version of Theorem 4.4.8 is used (see [BD08]). The general result, originally obtained in [Bur98], is that the local energy decays at least logarithmically. For the case when the obstacle is “not trapping”, earlier results had shown that the decay occurs at an exponential rate if n is odd and at a polynomial rate if n is even (see [MRS77], [MS78]). Theorem 4.4.16 is due to Arendt and Pr¨ uss [AP92]; it is a continuous analogue of the Katznelson-Tzafriri theorem [KT86] (see Corollary 4.7.15). Most of these results were originally proved by means of harmonic analysis; the link with Korevaar’s contour methods for complex Tauberian theorems was first established by Allan, Ransford and O’Farrell [AOR87] whose work inspired [AB88]. Theorem 4.4.18 and Theorem 4.4.19 were discovered by Blake [Bla99] (see also [BB00]) who developed a method used by van Neerven [Nee96b] in the case of orbits of C0 -semigroups (see the Notes on Section 5.1). These results are valid not only when f is exponentially bounded, but even when e−ωt f (t) ∈ Lp (R+ , X) for some ω and some p > 1. However, they are not valid in the case p = 1. Bloch [Blo49] gave an example where e−ωt f (t) ∈ L1 (R+ ) whenever ω > 0, abs(f ) = 0 and hol0 (fˆ) = −∞. His example can be adapted to show that the estimate c(1 + t) in the conclusion of Theorem 4.4.18 is sharp for the class of exponentially bounded functions f [Bat03]. Section 4.5 The material presented here is standard. Almost periodic functions were introduced by Harald Bohr [Boh25] in 1925, and the first edition of his book [Boh47] was published in 1934. Further textbooks are those of Levitan and Zhikov [LZ82], Fink [Fin74] and Amerio and Prouse [AP71]. Concerning the role of almost periodic functions for dynamical systems governed by partial differential equations, we refer to Haraux [Har91].
334
4. ASYMPTOTICS OF LAPLACE TRANSFORMS
Some authors use the terminology “scalarly almost periodic” functions instead of weakly almost periodic functions in order to distinguish from the notion of “weakly almost periodic in the sense of Eberlein”. We refer to Milnes [Mil80] and to the Notes of Section 4.7 for more information and comparison of these different notions. Section 4.6 It was Loomis [Loo60] who proved that bounded uniformly continuous functions with countable spectrum are almost periodic in the scalar case. The extension to the vectorvalued case when c0 ⊂ X was included in the book of Levitan and Zhikov [LZ82] after Kadets had proved his striking result (Theorem 4.6.11) in [Kad69]. For the proof of Kadets’s theorem we follow [LZ82]. The condition of total ergodicity was used by Levitan [Lev66] in the context of antiderivatives of almost periodic functions. Theorem 4.6.3 in case a) is due to Ruess and V˜ u [RV95], but with a different proof. The condition of total ergodicity turned out to be crucial in later developments on the half-line (see Sections 4.7, 4.9). The proof of Theorem 4.6.3 which we give here, is due to Arendt and Batty [AB97], but Lemma 4.6.6 and Lemma 4.6.7 are taken from Batty, van Neerven and R¨ abiger [BNR98a]. Several results presented here can be extended to measurable functions. In particular, a version of Theorem 4.6.3 remains true if f ∈ L∞ (R, X) is slowly oscillating at infinity and a priori not continuous. Then the result says that f is equal almost everywhere to an almost periodic function (see the paper of Arendt and Batty [AB00, Corollary 3.3]). A harmonic analytic approach to countable spectrum on the line and almost periodicity was taken by Baskakov [Bas78], [Bas85] and Basit [Bas95], [Bas97], using the Beurling spectrum instead of the Carleman spectrum (c.f. Section 4.8). Section 4.7 The main result of this section, Theorem 4.7.7 is due to Batty, van Neerven and R¨ abiger [BNR98a], [BNR98b] who also proved Lemma 4.7.9. However, their proof is more complicated and based on the countable spectrum theorem (Theorem 5.5.4). The direct proof via the quotient method given here is due to Arendt and Batty [AB99] who proved Proposition 4.7.2 in particular. Example 4.7.11 was considered by Staffans [Sta81, p.608], Ruess and V˜ u [RV95, Example 3.12] and Batty, van Neerven and R¨ abiger [BNR98b]. The proof of the Katznelson-Tzafriri theorem (Corollary 4.7.15) presented here is similar to the one given by Arendt and Pr¨ uss [AP92]. Here our emphasis is on (strong) asymptotic almost periodicity, but there are many interesting results on weak versions of these notions. A function f ∈ BUC(R+ , X) is called weakly asymptotically almost periodic in the sense of Eberlein (in short, Eberleinw.a.a.p.) if the set {S(t)f : t ≥ 0} is relatively weakly compact in BUC(R+ , X). Ruess and Summers have investigated this notion in a series of articles [RS86], [RS87], [RS88a], [RS88b], [RS89], [RS90a], [RS90b], [RS92a], [RS92b]; see also papers of Ruess [Rue91], [Rue95] and Rosenblatt, Ruess and Sentilles [RRS91]. They show in a convincing way that this is the right notion for evolution equations. It is different from weak asymptotic almost periodicity (w.a.a.p.) in the sense that x∗ ◦ f is asymptotically almost periodic for all x∗ ∈ X ∗ . An example of an Eberlein-w.a.a.p. orbit of a bounded C0 -semigroup, which is not w.a.a.p. is given in [RS90b, p.180]. The notion of Eberlein-w.a.a.p. functions is particularly useful in the context of the mean ergodic theorem for non-linear semigroups; see [RS87], [RS88a], [RS90a] and [RS92a]. An Eberlein-w.a.a.p. function f splits, f = f0 + f1 , where f1 is almost periodic and f0 is such that 0 is in the weak closure of {S(t)f0 : t ≥ 0} in BUC(R+ , X) (see
4.10. NOTES
335
Theorem 5.4.11). This implies that Mη f0 = 0 for all η ∈ R, but otherwise the asymptotic behaviour as t → ∞ of the function f0 is very weak. It can still happen that for some sequence tn → ∞, S(tn )f0 − f0 ∞ → 0 (see [RRS91, Section 3]). Section 4.8 In this section we closely follow the book of Pr¨ uss [Pr¨ u93] where in particular Proposition 4.8.4 is proved with the help of our favourite fudge factor. A different proof is given in Davies’s book [Dav80, Chapter 8]. Theorem 4.8.7 on discrete spectrum is contained in a paper of Arendt and Schweiker [AS99] with a slightly different proof. In more abstract contexts the result appeared already in work of Baskakov [Bas85], Beurling [Beu47] and Reiter [Rei52]. Section 4.9 In this section we follow closely Chill’s thesis [Chi98a] (see also [Chi98b]). In particular, Theorem 4.9.7 is due to Chill with the proof which we give here. This theorem seems to be a definitive complex Tauberian theorem involving countable spectrum. It is worth mentioning that uniform ergodicity is automatic outside the weak half-line spectrum. More precisely, Chill [Chi98a, Lemma 1.16] proved the following. Lemma 4.10.3. Let f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X) and let η ∈ R \ spw (f ). Then f is uniformly ergodic at η. The more general weak half-line spectrum seems to be more natural in the context of Volterra equations. A first investigation of asymptotic behaviour of the corresponding solution operators (which are called resolvents in the theory of Volterra equations) has been carried out by Arendt and Pr¨ uss [AP92] (see also [Pr¨ u93]). Theorem 4.9.7 can now be more directly applied, as shown by Chill and Pr¨ uss [CP01] and Fasangova and Pr¨ uss [FP01].
Chapter 5
Asymptotics of Solutions of Cauchy Problems In this chapter, we give various results concerning the long-time asymptotic behaviour of mild solutions of homogeneous and inhomogeneous Cauchy problems on R+ (see Section 3.1 for the definitions and basic properties). For the most part, we shall assume that the homogeneous problem is well-posed, so that the operator A generates a C0 -semigroup T , mild solutions of the homogeneous problem (ACP0 ) are given by u(t) = T (t)x =: ux (t) (Theorem 3.1.12), and mild solutions of the inhomogeneous problem (ACPf ) are given by u(t) = T (t)x + (T ∗ f )(t), where T ∗ f is the convolution of T and f (Proposition 3.1.16). In typical applications, the operator A and its spectral properties will be known, but solutions u will not be known explicitly, so the objective is to obtain information about the behaviour of u from the spectral properties of A. To achieve this, we shall apply the results of earlier chapters, making use of the fact that the Laplace transform of u can easily be described in terms of the resolvent of A. In Section 5.1, we obtain general relations between spectral bounds of A, abscissas associated with the Laplace transform of T , growth bounds of T and its associated integrated semigroup, and the behaviour of convolutions T ∗ f for general f . In Sections 5.2 and 5.3, we give more precise relations between spectral and growth bounds in the cases of semigroups on Hilbert spaces and positive semigroups on Banach lattices. In Section 5.4, we use the general theory of ergodicity and asymptotic almost periodicity (Sections 4.3 and 4.7) to obtain splitting theorems (Glicksberg-deLeeuw theorems) for C0 -semigroups with relatively (weakly) compact orbits. In Section 5.5, we apply the complex Tauberian theorem (Theorem 4.7.7 or Theorem 4.9.7) to the case when the imaginary part of the spectrum of A is countable.
W. Arendt et al., Vector-valued Laplace Transforms and Cauchy Problems: Second Edition, Monographs in Mathematics 96, DOI 10.1007/978-3-0348-0087-7_5, © Springer Basel AG 2011
337
338
5. ASYMPTOTICS OF SOLUTIONS OF CAUCHY PROBLEMS
In Section 5.6, we consider the asymptotic behaviour of T ∗ f , showing in particular that T ∗ f is bounded when T is a bounded holomorphic C0 -semigroup, f is bounded, and T and f are out of phase in a sense described by their Laplace transforms.
5.1
Growth Bounds and Spectral Bounds
Let T be a C0 -semigroup on X with generator A. Recall from Section 3.1 that T is exponentially bounded, and the exponential growth bound ω(T ) is defined by: ωt ω(T ) = inf ω ∈ R : there exists Mω such that T (t) ≤ Mω e for all t ≥ 0 . By the uniform boundedness principle applied to {e−ωt T (t) : t ≥ 0}, ω(T ) = inf ω ∈ R : for each x ∈ X, there exists Mω,x such that T (t)x ≤ Mω,x e
ωt
=
sup ω(ux ),
for all t ≥ 0 (5.1)
x∈X
where ux (t) := T (t)x. This suggests several possible ways of defining other bounds, for example by replacing ω(ux ) by hol( ux ) or abs(ux ), and/or taking the supremum in (5.1) not over all x ∈ X, but only over x ∈ D(A) (i.e., considering classical solutions ux of the homogeneous Cauchy problem rather than mild solutions). Later in this section, we shall consider such bounds, and also bounds associated with the spectrum and resolvent of the generator A, but first we establish some properties of ω(T ). The first elementary result exploits the semigroup property of T to obtain some simple properties of the growth bound. Proposition 5.1.1. Let T be a C0 -semigroup on X. Then a) ω(T ) = lim t−1 log T (t) = inf t−1 log T (t) . t→∞
t>0
b) The spectral radius r(T (t)) of T (t) is etω(T ) . ∞ c) Let x ∈ X and ω ∈ R, and suppose that 0 e−ωt T (t)x dt < ∞. Then ω(ux ) ≤ ω. Proof. a) For ω > ω(T ), log T (t)
log Mω ≤ + ω, t t so
lim sup t−1 log T (t) ≤ ω. t→∞
5.1. GROWTH BOUNDS AND SPECTRAL BOUNDS Hence,
339
lim sup t−1 log T (t) ≤ ω(T ). t→∞
For the reverse inequality we may assume that T (t) > 0 for all t ≥ 0. For τ > 0 and nτ ≤ t < (n + 1)τ ,
T (t)
= T (τ )n T (t − nτ ) ≤ Cτ T (τ ) n ! " ≤ Cτ T (τ ) t/τ = Cτ exp (τ −1 log T (τ ) )t ,
where Cτ =
Cτ = sup T (s) , 0≤s≤τ
Thus,
Cτ
if T (τ ) ≥ 1, if T (τ ) < 1.
Cτ T (τ )
ω(T ) ≤ τ −1 log T (τ )
for all τ > 0. This proves a). b) By the spectral radius formula and a), n 1/n
r(T (t)) = lim T (t)
n→∞
1/n
= lim T (nt)
n→∞
=
lim exp
n→∞
t log T (nt)
nt
= etω(T ) . c) Take τ ≥ 1. For τ − 1 ≤ t ≤ τ ,
ux (τ ) = T (τ )x = T (τ − t)T (t)x ≤ C1 T (t)x = C1 ux (t) . Hence, e−ωτ ux (τ ) ≤ C1
τ
τ −1
This shows that τ → e ω(ux ) ≤ ω.
−ωτ
e−ωτ ux (t) dt ≤ C1 e|ω|
∞ 0
e−ωt ux (t) dt < ∞.
ux (τ ) is bounded on [1, ∞) and hence on R+ , so
It follows from Proposition 5.1.1 c) that ∞ −ωt ω(T ) = inf ω ∈ R : e
T (t)x dt < ∞ for all x ∈ X
(5.2)
0
=
sup {abs( ux ) : x ∈ X}
=
abs( T ).
The following result (which we call Datko’s theorem, although there were other contributions; see the Notes) shows that the infimum in (5.2) is never attained. Indeed, applied to e−ωt T (t) with p = 1, condition b) shows that ∞ when −ωt ω(T ) < ω if 0 e
T (t)x dt < ∞ for all x ∈ X.
340
5. ASYMPTOTICS OF SOLUTIONS OF CAUCHY PROBLEMS Recall from Section 1.3 that T ∗ f denotes the convolution of T with f , so (T ∗ f )(t) :=
t 0
T (t − s)f (s) ds =
t 0
T (s)f (t − s) ds
when f ∈ L1loc (R+ , X). Theorem 5.1.2 (Datko’s Theorem). Let T be a C0 -semigroup on X, and let 1 ≤ p < ∞. The following are equivalent: (i) ω(T ) < 0. (ii) For all x ∈ X, ux ∈ Lp (R+ , X). (iii) For all f ∈ Lp (R+ , X), T ∗ f ∈ Lp (R+ , X). (iv) For all f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X), T ∗ f ∈ L∞ (R+ , X). (v) For all f ∈ C0 (R+ , X), T ∗ f ∈ C0 (R+ , X). (vi) For all f ∈ C0 (R+ , X),
t
< ∞. sup T (s)f (s) ds
t≥0
0
(vii) For all f ∈ AP(R+ , X),
t
< ∞. sup T (s)f (s) ds
t≥0
0
(viii) There is a constant C such that
t
≤ C sup f (s)
T (s)f (s) ds
0≤s≤t
(5.3)
0
for all f ∈ C([0, t], X) and all t ≥ 0. Proof. First, assume that (i) holds. Then there exist M and α > 0 such that
T (t) ≤ M e−αt for all t ≥ 0. Since ux (t) ≤ M e−αt x , ux ∈ Lp (R+ , X), so (ii) holds. Proposition 1.3.5 shows that (iii), (iv) and (v) hold. The proofs of (vi), (vii) and (viii) all follow from the estimate
t
t
M
T (s)f (s) ds M e−αs sup f (r) ds ≤ sup f (s) .
≤ α 0≤s≤t 0≤r≤t 0 0
5.1. GROWTH BOUNDS AND SPECTRAL BOUNDS
341
(ii) ⇒ (i): By hypothesis, x → ux maps X into Lp (R+ , X), and it is easy to check that this map has closed graph. Hence, there is a constant C such that ∞
T (t)x p dt ≤ C x p (5.4) 0
for all x ∈ X. Suppose that ω(T ) ≥ 0. By Proposition 5.1.1 b), there exists λ ∈ σ(T (1)) with |λ| = eω(T ) ≥ 1, and λ is in the topological boundary of σ(T (1)). Now λ is an approximate eigenvalue of T (1) (Proposition B.2), so there is a sequence (xk ) in X such that xk = 1 and limk→∞ T (1)xk − λxk = 0. Then limk→∞ T (1)n xk − λn xk = 0 for n ∈ N. Passing to a subsequence of (xk ), we may assume that
xk = 1, Hence, T (n)xk ≥
1 2
T (1)n xk − λn xk ≤
1 2
(n = 1, 2, . . . , k).
(n = 1, 2, . . . , k). If n − 1 ≤ t ≤ n ≤ k, then
1 ≤ T (n)xk = T (n − t)T (t)xk ≤ C1 T (t)xk , 2 where C1 = sup0≤s≤1 T (s) . Thus, T (t)xk ≥ 1/(2C1 ) whenever 0 ≤ t ≤ k, so p ∞ 1 p
T (t)xk dt ≥ k xk p (k = 1, 2, . . .). 2C1 0 This contradicts (5.4). It follows that ω(T ) < 0. (iii) ⇒ (ii): Choose ω > max(0, ω(T )). Take x ∈ X, and let f (t) := e−ωt T (t)x. Then f ∈ Lp (R+ , X), so (iii) implies that T ∗ f ∈ Lp (R+ , X). But t 1 − e−ωt (T ∗ f )(t) = T (s) e−ω(t−s) T (t − s)x ds = ux (t). ω 0 ω Thus, ux (t) ≤
(T ∗ f )(t) for t ≥ 1, and ux is bounded on [0, 1], so 1 − e−ω p ux ∈ L (R+ , X). (iv) or (v) ⇒ (viii): Define Vt : C0 (R+ , X) → X by Vt g := (T ∗ g)(t). Either (iv) or (v) implies that supt≥0 Vt g < ∞ for each g ∈ C0 (R+ , X). By the uniform boundedness principle, there is a constant C such that
t
≤ C g ∞ T (s)g(t − s) ds
0
for all g ∈ C0 (R+ , X). Given t ≥ 0 and f ∈ C([0, t], X), choose g ∈ C0 (R+ , X) such that g(s) = f (t − s) whenever 0 ≤ s ≤ t and g ∞ = sup0≤s≤t f (s) . Then
t
t
T (s)f (s) ds = T (s)g(t − s) ds
≤ C g ∞ = C sup f (s) . 0
0
0≤s≤t
342
5. ASYMPTOTICS OF SOLUTIONS OF CAUCHY PROBLEMS
(vi) or (vii) ⇒ (viii): As in the proof of (iv) or (v) ⇒ (viii), (vi) (respectively, (vii)) implies that there is a constant C such that
t
T (s)g(s) ds
≤ C g ∞ 0
for all g ∈ C0 (R+ , X) (respectively, g ∈ AP(R+ , X)). Given t ≥ 0 and f ∈ C([0, t], X) there exists an extension g ∈ C0 (R+ , X) (respectively, a periodic extension g) such that g ∞ = sup0≤s≤t f (s) . It follows that
t
T (s)f (s) ds sup f (s) .
≤ C 0≤s≤t 0
(viii) ⇒ (i): Take ω > max(0, ω(T )), so there exists M such that T (s) ≤ M eωs for all s ≥ 0. For t ≥ 0 and x ∈ X, let f (s) := eωs T (t − s)x (0 ≤ s ≤ t). Then (5.3) gives ωt e −1
T (t)x ≤ CM eωt x . ω Thus,
T (t)x ≤
CM ω x
1 − e−ω
for all t ≥ 1. It follows that M0 := supt≥0 T (t) < ∞. Putting f (s) := T (t − s)x in (5.3) gives t T (t)x ≤ CM0 x
for all t ≥ 0 and all x ∈ X. Thus, T (t) ≤ CM0 /t < 1 for sufficiently large t, so ω(T ) = inf t>0 t−1 log T (t) < 0. The following corollary of Datko’s theorem can also be proved by a variation of the method of Lemma 3.2.14, without assuming that T is a semigroup. Corollary 5.1.3. Let T be a C0 -semigroup on X. Then there exists x ∈ X such that ω(ux ) = ω(T ). In particular, if for each x ∈ X there exist Mx and αx > 0 such that T (t)x ≤ Mx e−αx t for all t ≥ 0, then there exist M and α > 0 such that T (t) ≤ M e−αt for all t ≥ 0. Proof. The result is trivial if ω(T ) = −∞, so we assume that ω(T ) > −∞. Replacing T (t) by e−ω(T )t T (t), we may assume that ω(T ) = 0. Then the result follows immediately from Theorem 5.1.2, (ii) ⇒ (i). Recall from Sections 1.4 and 1.5 that abs(T )
:= =
sup {abs(ux ) : x ∈ X} inf ω ∈ R : for all x ∈ X, lim τ →∞
τ 0
e−ωt T (t)x dt exists ,
5.1. GROWTH BOUNDS AND SPECTRAL BOUNDS
343
t lim e−λs T (s)x ds = u x (λ) (λ > abs(T ), x ∈ X), t→∞ 0 := inf ω ∈ R : Tˆ extends to a holomorphic
Tˆ(λ)x := hol(Tˆ )
function from {Re λ > ω} to L(X) = =
sup {hol(ux ) : x ∈ X} inf ω ∈ R : for all x ∈ X, ux has a holomorphic extension to {λ ∈ C : Re λ > ω} .
We now define ω1 (T )
:= = =
=
sup {ω(ux ) : x ∈ D(A)} ∞ inf ω ∈ R : e−ωt T (t)x dt < ∞ for all x ∈ D(A) 0 inf ω ∈ R : for all x ∈ D(A), there exists Mω,x such that T (t)x ≤ Mω,x eωt for all t ≥ 0 inf ω ∈ R : there exists Mω such that
T (t)R(λ, A) ≤ Mω eωt for all t ≥ 0 .
Here, λ is any point in ρ(A). The equalities follow from the definition of ω(ux ), Proposition 5.1.1 c) and the uniform boundedness principle. It is clear from (1.10), (1.14) and the definitions that hol(T ) ≤ abs(T ) ≤ ω(T ) and ω1 (T ) ≤ ω(T ). The spectral bound s(A) of the generator A of T is defined by s(A) := sup {Re λ : λ ∈ σ(A)} , with the convention that s(A) = −∞ if σ(A) is empty. The following results make precise the relation between the spectrum and resolvent of A and abscissas associated with the Laplace transform of T . In particular, Proposition 5.1.4 shows that s(A) < ∞. Proposition 5.1.4. Let T be a C0 -semigroup on X with generator A. Then Moreover, for x ∈ X,
s(A) = hol(Tˆ ).
(5.5)
u x (λ) = R(λ, A)x
(5.6)
whenever Re λ > s(A),
R(λ, A)x = lim
τ →∞
0
τ
e−λt T (t)x dt
(5.7)
344
5. ASYMPTOTICS OF SOLUTIONS OF CAUCHY PROBLEMS
whenever Re λ > abs(T ), and sup { R(λ, A) : Re λ > ω} < ∞
(5.8)
whenever ω > ω(T ). Proof. The functions Tˆ (λ) and R(λ, A) are holomorphic for Re λ > hol(Tˆ) and for λ ∈ ρ(A), respectively, and they coincide for λ > ω(T ). Thus Tˆ has a holomorphic extension for Re λ > min(s(A), hol(Tˆ)) and this implies that hol(Tˆ) ≤ s(A) and (5.6) and (5.7) hold. The equality (5.5) now follows from Theorem 3.1.7. For ω > ω > ω(T ), there exists M such that T (t) ≤ M eω t for all t. For Re λ > ω, ∞ M x
R(λ, A)x ≤ e− Re λt T (t)x dt ≤ , Re λ − ω 0 so M sup { R(λ, A) : Re λ > ω} ≤ < ∞. ω − ω When Re λ = abs(T ), the existence of the limit in (5.7) for all x ∈ X does not correspond exactly to the existence of R(λ, A) (consider, for example, T (t) = I with λ ∈ iR, λ = 0). The following result describes the relation between these two properties and stability of classical solutions of the homogeneous problem. Proposition 5.1.5. Let T be a C0 -semigroup on X, and let λ ∈ C. The following are equivalent: t (i) lim e−λs T (s)x ds exists for all x ∈ X. t→∞
0
(ii) λ ∈ ρ(A) and lim e−λt T (t)x = 0 for all x ∈ D(A). t→∞
In that case,
t
R(λ, A)x = lim
t→∞
e−λs T (s)x ds
0
for all x ∈ X. Proof. Replacing T (t) by e−λt T (t), we may assume that λ = 0. t (i) ⇒ (ii): Suppose that Bx := limt→∞ 0 T (s)x ds exists for all x ∈ X. Then 1 1 (T (h)Bx − Bx) = − h h
0
h
T (s)x ds → −x
as h ↓ 0. Thus, Bx ∈ D(A) and ABx = −x for all x ∈ X. Now suppose that x ∈ D(A). Then t BAx = lim T (s)Ax ds = lim T (t)x − x, t→∞
0
t→∞
5.1. GROWTH BOUNDS AND SPECTRAL BOUNDS
345
t by Proposition 3.1.9. Thus, y := limt→∞ T (t)x exists. Since limt→∞ 0 T (s)x ds also exists, it follows that y = 0 and BAx = −x (for all x ∈ D(A)). Thus A has an algebraic inverse −B. By Proposition B.1, 0 ∈ ρ(A) and B = −A−1 = R(0, A). (ii) ⇒ (i): Suppose that 0 ∈ ρ(A) and limt→∞ T (t)y = 0 for all y ∈ D(A). Then, for x ∈ X, t t T (s)x ds = − T (s)AR(0, A)x ds 0
0
R(0, A)x − T (t)R(0, A)x
=
→ R(0, A)x as t → ∞. The following result is the analogue of Theorem 1.4.3 for semigroups. Proposition 5.1.6. Let T be a C0 -semigroup on X with generator A, let S be the associated integrated semigroup: t S(t)x := T (s)x ds (x ∈ X), 0
and let := S(t) Then
S(t) − R(0, A) S(t)
if 0 ∈ ρ(A), if 0 ∈ σ(A).
abs(T ) = ω1 (T ) = ω(S).
follows from Proposition 1.4.5, Remark 1.4.6 Proof. The fact that abs(T ) = ω(S) and Proposition 5.1.5. To prove that abs(T ) = ω1 (T ), we may assume that ω(T ) < 0 (replacing T (t) by e−ωt T (t)). Then 0 ∈ ρ(A). By Proposition 3.1.9, S(t)x ∈ D(A) and AS(t)x = T (t)x − x for all x ∈ X. Hence, S(t)x = S(t)x − R(0, A)x = T (t)A−1 x. Thus,
= sup {ω(uA−1 x ) : x ∈ X} = ω1 (T ). abs(T ) = ω(S)
It turns out that the spectral bound s(A) is of limited use in the study of asymptotic behaviour—the spectrum of an operator may be unstable under small perturbations. However, such instability can only occur when the norm of the resolvent is large, so it is more useful to consider the pseudo-spectral bound defined by s0 (A) := inf ω > s(A) : there exists Cω such that
R(λ, A) ≤ Cω whenever Re λ > ω .
346
5. ASYMPTOTICS OF SOLUTIONS OF CAUCHY PROBLEMS
It is clear from (5.8) that s(A) ≤ s0 (A) ≤ ω(T ). It follows from (5.5) and the uniform boundedness principle that s0 (A) = sup {hol0 ( ux ) : x ∈ X} , where hol0 (fˆ) is the abscissa of boundedness of fˆ defined in Sections 1.5 and 4.4. Theorem 4.4.19 provides the following result. Theorem 5.1.7. Let T be a C0 -semigroup on X with generator A. Then abs(T ) ≤ s0 (A). Proof. By Theorem 4.4.19, abs(ux ) ≤ hol0 ( ux ) for each x ∈ X. Hence, abs(T ) = supx abs(ux ) ≤ supx hol0 ( ux ) = s0 (A). Proceeding as in the proof of Theorem 4.4.14 a), we can deduce from Theorem 4.4.18 the following more precise information about asymptotic behaviour for individual vectors. Theorem 5.1.8. Let T be a C0 -semigroup on X with generator A, and let S be the associated integrated semigroup. Let x ∈ X, and suppose that hol( ux ) ≤ 0 and u x is bounded on C+ . Then there is a constant c (depending on x) such that
S(t)x ≤ c(1 + t) for all t ≥ 0. Moreover, for each μ ∈ ρ(A), there is a constant cμ (depending on x and μ) such that
T (t)R(μ, A)x ≤ cμ (1 + t) for all t ≥ 0. Proof. The first statement is immediate from Theorem 4.4.18. By Proposition 3.1.9, t T (t)R(μ, A)x = R(μ, A)x + T (s)AR(μ, A)x ds 0
= R(μ, A)x + (μR(μ, A) − I)S(t)x, and the second statement follows. We now summarise the general relations between spectral bounds, abscissas and growth bounds associated with semigroups, obtained in Proposition 5.1.4, Proposition 5.1.6 and Theorem 5.1.7. Theorem 5.1.9. Let T be a C0 -semigroup on X with generator A. Then s(A) = hol(Tˆ ) ≤ ω1 (T ) = abs(T ) ≤ s0 (A) ≤ ω(T ).
5.1. GROWTH BOUNDS AND SPECTRAL BOUNDS
347
Now, we give two examples which show that none of the inequalities in Theorem 5.1.9 can be replaced by an equality, and we shall give a further example in Section 5.3. In Theorem 5.1.12 and the next two sections of this chapter, we shall see that further equalities are valid under various additional assumptions on X and/or T . Example 5.1.10. There is a C0 -semigroup T on a Hilbert space X such that s(A) < ω1 (T ) < s0 (A) = ω(T ). Let X be the Hilbert space X
x = (xn )n∈N : xn ∈ C , n
:=
x :=
∞
2
xn < ∞ ,
n=1
1/2
xn 2
∞
,
n=1 (n)
where the norm on Cn is the Euclidean norm. Let Bn := (βi,j )1≤i,j≤n be the (n)
(n)
n × n complex matrix with βi,i+1 = 1 for 1 ≤ i < n, βi,j = 0 otherwise, and let An := i2n In + Bn . Let A be the operator on X defined by D(A)
:=
x∈X :
∞
22n xn 2 < ∞ ,
n=1
Ax
:= (An xn )n∈N .
Since Bn = 1 and Bnn = 0, tj
tA tB n−1
e n = e n ≤ ≤ et . j! j=0
On the other hand, if xn := n−1/2 (1, 1, 1, . . . , 1)T ∈ Cn , then xn = 1 and ⎛ ⎞2 n−1 m j
tB
t
e n xn − et xn 2 = 1 ⎝ − et ⎠ → 0 n m=0 j=0 j!
as n → ∞. Thus, supn etAn = et . We may define T (t) : X → X by ! " T (t)x := etAn xn n∈N . Then T (t) = et , and T is a C0 -semigroup with generator A and ω(T ) = 1.
348
5. ASYMPTOTICS OF SOLUTIONS OF CAUCHY PROBLEMS For x ∈ D(A),
∞
tA
e n xn 2
T (t)x 2 =
≤
n=1
∞ n=1
≤
∞
⎛
⎞2 t ⎠
xn 2 j!
n−1 j
⎝ ⎛
j=0
n−1
⎝
n=1
j=0
⎞2 ∞ tj ⎠ 2n 2 t 2
x
≤ e 22n xn 2 . n 2j j! n=1
Thus, ω1 (T ) ≤ 12 . On the other hand, if 0 < α < 1/2 and xn = αn (1, 1, . . . , 1)T ∈ Cn , then x = (xn ) ∈ D(A) and
T (t)x 2
⎛ ⎞2 m j t ⎝ ⎠ α2n = j! n=1 m=0 j=0 ⎛ ⎞ ∞ 2n−2 ⎜ r! ⎟ tr 2n ≥ ⎝ ⎠ α j!k! r! j+k=r n=1 r=0 ∞ n−1
0≤j,k≤n−1
∞ 2n−2 2 r tr ≥ α2n r + 1 r! n=1 r=0
=
∞
r=0 n≥ r2 +1
≥
α2n
2 r tr (r + 1)!
∞ αr+3 2r tr α2 e2αt − 1 = . 1 − α2 (r + 1)! 1 − α2 2t r=0
Thus, ω(ux ) ≥ α. It follows that ω1 (T ) = 12 . To calculate the spectral bounds, note that σ(An ) = {i2n } and
R(λ, An ) = R(λ − i2n , Bn ) ≤
1 |λ − i2n | − 1
(5.9)
if |λ − i2n | > 1. It follows that supn R(λ, An ) < ∞ whenever λ ∈ / {i2n : n ∈ N}. n Hence, σ(A) = {i2 : n = 1, 2, . . .}, so s(A) = 0. It also follows from (5.9) that s0 (A) ≤ 1. On the other hand,
n−1
j 1/2
R(1 + i2 , A) ≥ R(1, Bn ) = Bn
≥n . n
j=0
Hence, s0 (A) = 1.
5.1. GROWTH BOUNDS AND SPECTRAL BOUNDS
349
We shall see in Section 5.2 that the equality s0 (A) = ω(T ) holds for all C0 -semigroups on Hilbert space. Example 5.1.11. There is a positive C0 -semigroup on a (reflexive) Banach lattice X such that s(A) = ω1 (T ) = s0 (A) < ω(T ). Let X := Lp (1, ∞) ∩ Lq (1, ∞), where 1 ≤ p ≤ q < ∞. Then X is a Banach lattice with the natural ordering and norm:
f := max( f p , f q ). Let Tp be the C0 -semigroup on Lp (1, ∞) defined by (Tp (t)g) (s) := g(set ), and let T be the positive C0 -semigroup on X obtained by restricting Tp to X. Let A and Ap be the generators of T and Tp , respectively. For f ∈ X, 1/p ∞ 1/q ∞ t p t q
T (t)f = max |f (se )| ds , |f (se )| ds 1
=
max e−t/p
1
∞
et
1/p |f (r)|p dr
, e−t/q
≤ max e−t/p f p , e−t/q f q
∞
et
1/q |f (r)|q dr
≤ e−t/q f . On the other hand, if 1 (et ≤ s ≤ et + 1), f (s) := 0 otherwise, then f = 1 and T (t)f = e−t/q . Thus, T (t) = e−t/q and ω(T ) = −1/q. For Re λ < −1/p, let fλ (s) := sλ . Then fλ ∈ X and T (t)fλ = eλt fλ , so fλ ∈ D(A) and Afλ = λfλ . Hence, σ(A) ⊇ λ ∈ C : Re λ ≤ − p1 , and s(A) ≥ −1/p. In the case p = q, we now know that s(Ap ) = ω(Tp ) = −1/p, and for Re λ := α > −1/p and f ∈ Lp (1, ∞), ∞ ∞ f (r) (R(λ, Ap )f ) (s) = e−λt f (set ) dt = sλ dr. rλ+1 0 s
350
5. ASYMPTOTICS OF SOLUTIONS OF CAUCHY PROBLEMS
For 1 < p < q < ∞ and p such that 1
∞
1 p
+
≤ = =
= 1, we have
q f (r) dr ds r λ+1 1 s ∞ q/p ∞ dr αq q s f p ds r (α+1)p 1 s ∞
f qp s−q/p ds ((α + 1)p − 1)q/p 1
f qp p . ((α + 1)p − 1)q/p (q − p)
q
|(R(λ, Ap )f )(s)| ds =
1 p
∞
sαq
∞
If 1 = p < q < ∞, then
∞ 1
q
|(R(λ, Ap )f )(s)| ds ≤
f q1 . q−1
In each case, R(λ, Ap ) maps Lp (1, ∞) into X, so D(Ap ) ⊂ X. Since p (λ)|X = R(λ, Ap )|X R(λ, A) = Tˆ (λ) = T for λ > −1/q, it follows that A is the part of Ap in X, σ(A) ⊂ σ(Ap ) ⊂ {Re λ ≤ −1/p}, and R(λ, A) = R(λ, Ap )|X for Re λ > −1/p (see Proposition B.8). For f ∈ X and Re λ = α > −1/p,
f p p1/q
R(λ, A)f ≤ max R(λ, A)f p , ((α + 1)p − 1)1/p (q − p)1/q p p1/q ≤ max ,
f
αp + 1 ((α + 1)p − 1)1/p (q − p)1/q if 1 < p < q < ∞;
R(λ, A)f ≤ max
1 1 , α + 1 (q − 1)1/q
f
if 1 = p < q < ∞. Thus, s0 (A) = −1/p. It follows from Theorem 5.1.9 that ω1 (T ) = −1/p. We shall see in Section 5.3 that the equality s(A) = s0 (A) holds for all positive semigroups on Banach lattices, while the equality s(A) = ω(T ) holds for all positive semigroups on Lp -spaces. We conclude this section by showing that s(A) = ω(T ) for all holomorphic semigroups. Theorem 5.1.12. Let T be a holomorphic C0 -semigroup on X with generator A. Then ω(T ) = s(A). Moreover, there exists λ ∈ σ(A) such that Re λ = ω(T ).
5.2. SEMIGROUPS ON HILBERT SPACES
351
Proof. For each x ∈ X, ux has a holomorphic extension to a sector Σθ , given by ux (z) = T (z)x. By Theorem 2.6.2, ω(ux ) = inf ω ∈ R : λ → R(λ, A)x has a holomorphic extension to {λ : Re λ > ω} ≤ s(A). Hence, ω(T ) = sup ω(ux ) ≤ s(A). x∈X
The final statement follows from the fact that {λ ∈ σ(A) : Re λ ≥ s(A) − 1} is nonempty and compact (see Theorem 3.7.11 and Corollary 3.7.17).
5.2
Semigroups on Hilbert Spaces
Example 5.1.10 shows that there are C0 -semigroups on Hilbert spaces such that s(A) < ω1 (T ) < s0 (A). In that example, s0 (A) = ω(T ), and we now show that this equality always holds on Hilbert spaces. Theorem 5.2.1. Let T be a C0 -semigroup on a Hilbert space X with generator A. Then s0 (A) = ω(T ). Proof. Let x ∈ X. For ω > ω(T ), the function s → R(ω + is, A)x on R is the Fourier transform of the function t → e−ωt T (t)x on R+ . By Plancherel’s Theorem 1.8.2, ∞ ∞ 1 e−2ωt T (t)x 2 dt =
R(ω + is, A)x 2 ds. (5.10) 2π −∞ 0 Suppose that s0 (A) < ω(T ) and let C := supRe λ>ω(T ) R(λ, A) < ∞. For ω(T ) < ω1 < ω2 , R(ω1 + is, A)x = R(ω2 + is, A)x + (ω2 − ω1 )R(ω1 + is, A)R(ω2 + is, A)x, so
R(ω1 + is, A)x ≤ (1 + C(ω2 − ω1 )) R(ω2 + is, A)x . By (5.10), ∞ 0
2
e−2ω1 t T (t)x 2 dt ≤ (1 + C(ω2 − ω1 ))
Letting ω1 ↓ ω(T ) gives ∞ 2 e−2ω(T )t T (t)x 2 dt ≤ (1 + C(ω2 − ω(T ))) 0
∞
0
∞ 0
e−2ω2 t T (t)x 2 dt.
e−2ω2 t T (t)x 2 dt < ∞
352
5. ASYMPTOTICS OF SOLUTIONS OF CAUCHY PROBLEMS
for all x ∈ X. The implication (ii) ⇒ (i) of Theorem 5.1.2, with p = 2 and T (t) replaced by e−ω(T )t T (t), gives a contradiction. Theorem 5.2.1 is not valid for X = Lp (0, 1) (1 < p < ∞, p = 2). Example 5.2.2. Let 2 < q < ∞. Example 5.1.11 shows that there is a C0 -semigroup Tq on L2 (1, ∞) ∩ Lq (1, ∞) whose generator Aq satisfies s0 (Aq ) = − 12 < − 1q = ω(Tq ). There is a linear homeomorphism Jq of Lq (0, 1) onto L2 (1, ∞) ∩ Lq (1, ∞) [LT77, Corollary II.2.e.8]. Let Sq (t) := Jq−1 Tq (t)Jq . Then Sq is a C0 -semigroup on Lq (0, 1) whose generator Bq satisfies s0 (Bq ) = − 12 < − 1q = ω(Sq ). Let 1 < p < 2, and let q be the conjugate index, so that p1 + 1q = 1 and Lp (0, 1) = Lq (0, 1)∗ . Let Sp (t) := Sq (t)∗ . By Corollary 3.3.9, Sp is a C0 -semigroup on Lp (0, 1), whose generator Bp = Bq∗ satisfies s0 (Bp ) = − 12 < − 1q = ω(Sp ). We shall see in the next section that ω(T ) = s0 (A) = s(A) for all positive semigroups on Lp -spaces. The analogue of Theorem 5.2.1 for individual orbits is not true. Example 5.2.3. There is a C0 -semigroup T on a Hilbert space X with a vector x ∈ X and a real number a < ω(ux ) such that u x = R(·, A)x has a bounded holomorphic extension to the half-plane {λ ∈ C : Re λ > a}. Let X := L2 (1, ∞) and (T (t)f )(s) := f (set ). By Example 5.1.11, s(A) = ω(T ) = ω(A) = −1/2. Let A1 be the generator of the C0 -semigroup on L1 (1, ∞) ∩ L2 (1, ∞) obtained by restricting T , so s0 (A1 ) = −1, again by Example 5.1.11. For f ∈ L1 (1, ∞) ∩ L2 (1, ∞), R(·, A1 )f has an extension to a bounded holomorphic map of {λ ∈ C : Re λ > a} into L1 (1, ∞) ∩ L2 (1, ∞) whenever a > −1. But R(λ, A)f = R(λ, A1 )f when Re λ is large, so R(·, A)f has an extension to a bounded holomorphic map of {λ ∈ C : Re λ > a} into L2 (1, ∞). However, it is possible to choose f ∈ L1 (1, ∞) ∩ L2 (1, ∞) such that ω(uf ) = −1/2 (where ω(uf ) is calculated in L2 (1, ∞)). For example, let 1 (en ≤ s ≤ en + n−2 ; n ∈ N), f (s) = 0 otherwise. Then (T (n)f )(s) = 1 for 1 ≤ s ≤ 1 + n−2 e−n , so T (n)f 2 > n−1 e−n/2 . Hence, ω(uf ) ≥ −1/2. On the other hand, ω(uf ) ≤ ω(T ) = −1/2.
5.3
Positive Semigroups
Let T be a C0 -semigroup on an ordered Banach space X, with generator A. We recall from Section 3.11 that T is positive if and only if A is resolvent positive. Example 5.1.11 shows that there are positive C0 -semigroups T on spaces of the form Lp (Ω, μ)∩Lq (Ω, μ) (1 ≤ p < q < ∞) such that s(A) < ω(T ). On the other hand, we shall show in this section that s(A) = abs(T ) = s0 (A) for all positive
5.3. POSITIVE SEMIGROUPS
353
semigroups on any ordered Banach space with normal cone, and that s(A) = ω(T ) for all positive semigroups on Lp (Ω, μ). Note that Proposition 3.11.2 shows that s(A) ∈ σ(A) if A generates a positive semigroup and σ(A) is non-empty. The following result makes this more precise. We give a proof that abs(T ) ∈ σ(A) based on Theorem 1.5.3, whereas Proposition 3.11.2 was proved by means of Bernstein’s Theorem 2.7.7. Theorem 5.3.1. Let X be an ordered Banach space with normal cone and let T be a positive C0 -semigroup on X with generator A. Then s(A) = ω1 (T ) = abs(T ) = s0 (A). Moreover, s(A) ∈ σ(A) if s(A) > −∞. Proof. By Theorem 5.1.9, s(A) ≤ ω1 (T ) = abs(T ) ≤ s0 (A). It suffices to prove that abs(T ) ∈ σ(A) if abs(T ) > −∞, and that supRe λ>ω R(λ, A) < ∞ whenever ω > abs(T ), so abs(T ) = s0 (A). Suppose that abs(T ) > −∞ and abs(T ) ∈ ρ(A). Let ε > 0 such that the ball B(abs(T ), ε) ⊂ ρ(A). For x ∈ X+ , the function ux is positive with Laplace transform R(λ, A)x (Re λ > ω1 (T )), which has a holomorphic extension to B(abs(T ), ε). By Theorem 1.5.3, abs(ux ) ≤ abs(T ) − ε. By linearity, abs(ux ) ≤ abs(T ) − ε for all x ∈ X. But this contradicts the definition of abs(T ). This proves that abs(T ) ∈ σ(A) if abs(T ) > −∞, and hence s(A) = abs(T ). By Corollary 3.11.3, supRe λ>ω R(λ, A) < ∞. Example 5.3.2. There exist a Hilbert space X which is a vector lattice with continuous lattice operations, and a positive C0 -semigroup T on X such that s(A) = ω1 (T ) < s0 (A) = ω(T ). Let X be the Sobolev space H 1 (1, ∞) := {f ∈ L2 (1, ∞) : f ∈ L2 (1, ∞)}, (see Appendix E) with ! "1/2
f H 1 (1,∞) := f 22 + f 22 . Then
X is a Hilbert space, and it is a vector lattice with the properties that
|f | = f [DL90, Chapter IV, Section 7, Proposition 6] and lattice operations are continuous (see [BY84, p.219]), but it is not a Banach lattice and the positive cone is not normal. Let T be the C0 -semigroup on H 1 (1, ∞) given by (T (t)f )(s) := f (set ). The generator A of T is given by ' ( D(A) = f ∈ H 1 (1, ∞) : s → sf (s) ∈ H 1 (1, ∞) , (Af )(s) = sf (s).
354
5. ASYMPTOTICS OF SOLUTIONS OF CAUCHY PROBLEMS
The semigroup governs the following very natural partial differential equation: ∂u ∂u = s , ∂t ∂s u(0, s) = u0 (s),
(t > 0, s > 1), (s > 1),
where u(t, s) := (T (t)u0 )(s). For α < −1/2, the function fα (s) := sα lies in X and T (t)fα = eαt fα . Hence, s(A) ≥ −1/2. For f ∈ H 1 (1, ∞), ∞ ∞ 2 2 t 2
T (t)f H 1 (1,∞) = f (se ) ds + e2t f (set ) ds 1 1 ∞ ∞ 2 −t 2 = e |f (r)| dr + et |f (r)| dr ≤ e
t
et
f 2H 1 (1,∞) .
et
Thus, ω(T ) ≤ 1/2. Choose non-zero g ∈ Cc∞ (R) with support in R+" . Given ∞! t ≥ 0, let f (s) := g(s − et ). Then f 2H 1 (1,∞) = 0 |g(s)|2 + |g (s)|2 ds and ∞ 2
T (t)f 2H 1 (1,∞) ≥ et 1 |g (r)| dr. It follows that ω(T ) ≥ 1/2, so s0 (A) = 1/2 by Theorem 5.2.1. We shall show that abs(T ) ≤ −1/2. It then follows from Theorem 5.1.9 that s(A) = ω1 (T ) = −1/2. Let S be the corresponding C0 -semigroup on L2 (1, ∞) with generator B, so abs(S) = ω1 (S) = ω(S) = −1/2 (Example 5.1.11). Let ω > −1/2 and f ∈ H 1 (1, ∞). For t > 0, let t gt := e−ωr T (r)f dr ∈ H 1 (1, ∞), 0
g
:=
R(ω, B)f ∈ L2 (1, ∞).
Then limt→∞ ||gt − g 2 = 0, since ω > abs(S). We have to show that limt→∞ ||gt − g H 1 (1,∞) = 0. By Proposition 3.1.9, gt ∈ D(A − ω) = D(A) ⊂ D(B), and (A − ω)gt = (B − ω)gt = e−ωt S(t)f − f. But (Agt )(s) = sgt (s), so
! " gt = h · ωgt − f + e−ωt S(t)f ,
where h(s) := s−1 . Since |h(s)| ≤ 1 for all s ∈ (1, ∞), it is clear that lim gt − h(ωg − f ) 2 = 0,
t→∞
so limt→∞ gt exists in H 1 (1, ∞). Thus, abs(uf ) ≤ −1/2 for all f ∈ H 1 (1, ∞), so abs(T ) ≤ −1/2.
5.3. POSITIVE SEMIGROUPS
355
Now we consider positive semigroups on Lp (Ω, μ), where we aim to show that s(A) = ω(T ). For p = 2, this result is immediate from Theorems 5.3.1 and 5.2.1. There is also an easy proof for p = 1, which we present in Proposition 5.3.7. The general case needs some preliminaries. We work with the product space R × Ω, and we use a vector-valued norm on Lp (R × Ω). We begin by defining this norm, and establishing its properties. Let (Ω, μ) be a σ-finite measure space, and consider R×Ω to be equipped with the product of Lebesgue measure m on R and the given measure μ on Ω. Let 1 ≤ p < ∞. We write Lp (Ω) for Lp (Ω, μ) and we identify Lp (R×Ω) with Lp (R, Lp (Ω)), so that the notations g(t, y) and g(t)(y) (t ∈ R, y ∈ Ω) are interchangeable. We consider the non-linear map Φ : Lp (R, Lp (Ω)) → Lp (Ω) given by
∞
Φ(g) := −∞
1/p |g(t)| dt p
.
This is the composition of three maps: Φ1 : Lp (R × Ω) → L1 (R × Ω), Φ2 : L1 (R × Ω) → L1 (Ω), 1
Φ1 (g) := |g|p , ∞ Φ2 (h)(y) := h(t, y) dt, −∞ 1/p
Φ3 : L (Ω) → L (Ω),
Φ3 (k) := |k|
p
.
This makes it clear that Φ is well defined. Lemma 5.3.3. Let g, h ∈ Lp (R, Lp (Ω)), f ∈ L∞ (Ω), s ∈ R. Then a) Φ(g) Lp (Ω) = g Lp (R×Ω) . b) Φ(gs ) = Φ(g), where gs (t) = g(t + s). c) Φ(f · g) = |f |Φ(g), where (f · g)(t, y) = f (y)g(t, y). d) Φ(g + h) ≤ Φ(g) + Φ(h) in Lp (Ω). e) Φ is continuous. Proof. a), b) and c) are all trivial. To prove d), let Gy (t) := g(t, y), Hy (t) := h(t, y) (t ∈ R, y ∈ Ω). For μ-almost all y, Gy ∈ Lp (R) and Hy ∈ Lp (R), so Minkowski’s inequality gives
Gy + Hy Lp (R) ≤ Gy Lp (R) + Hy Lp (R) . But
Gy Lp (R) =
∞
−∞
1/p |g(t, y)|p dt
= Φ(g)(y),
etc., so (5.11) gives Φ(g + h)(y) ≤ Φ(g)(y) + Φ(h)(y).
(5.11)
356
5. ASYMPTOTICS OF SOLUTIONS OF CAUCHY PROBLEMS
This holds μ-a.e., so Φ(g + h) ≤ Φ(g) + Φ(h) in Lp (Ω). Now, e) follows from a) and d). By d), Φ(g) ≤ Φ(g − h) + Φ(h), so Φ(g) − Φ(h) ≤ Φ(g − h). Similarly, Φ(h) − Φ(g) ≤ Φ(h − g) = Φ(g − h). Since Φ(g) etc. are real-valued, this shows that |Φ(g) − Φ(h)| ≤ Φ(g − h). Hence,
Φ(g) − Φ(h) Lp (Ω) ≤ Φ(g − h) Lp (Ω) = g − h Lp (R,Lp (Ω)) . Lemma 5.3.3 shows that Φ is a convex, vector-valued function. The next lemma is a vector-valued instance of Jensen’s inequality. Lemma 5.3.4. Let G : [a, b] → Lp (R, Lp (Ω)) be continuous. Then b
Φ
G(t) dt a
b
≤
Φ(G(t)) dt
in Lp (Ω).
a
Proof. By Lemma 5.3.3, c) and d), Φ
2n −1 2n −1 b−a rb + (2n − r)a b−a rb + (2n − 1)a G ≤ n Φ G . 2n r=0 2n 2 2n r=0
Letting n → ∞ and using the continuity of Φ (Lemma 5.3.3 e)) gives the result. For g ∈ Lp (R, Lp (Ω)) and a bounded operator T on Lp (Ω), we may define T ◦ g ∈ Lp (R, Lp (Ω)) by (T ◦ g)(t) = T (g(t)). Proposition 5.3.5. Let T be a positive bounded linear operator on Lp (Ω), and g ∈ Lp (R, Lp (Ω)). Then Φ(T ◦ g) ≤ T (Φ(g)). (5.12) Proof. Both sides of (5.12) depend continuously on g, so it suffices to assume that g is a simple function n g(t)(y) = χAk (t)gk (y), k=1
5.3. POSITIVE SEMIGROUPS
357
where A1 , . . . , An are disjoint Borel subsets of R, and g1 , . . . , gn ∈ Lp (Ω). Let hk := m(Ak )1/p gk (k = 1, . . . , n). Then Φ(T ◦ g) =
n
1/p m(Ak )|T gk |
p
k=1
T (Φ(g)) = T
n
=
m(Ak )|gk |
1/p |T hk |
p
k=1
1/p p
n
=T
k=1
n
, 1/p
|hk |
p
.
k=1
n Take αk ∈ Q + iQ with k=1 |αk |p ≤ 1, where p is the conjugate index of p (maxk |αk | ≤ 1 if p = 1). By H¨ older’s inequality, Re
n
≤
αk hk
k=1
n
1/p |hk |
p
= Φ(g).
k=1
Applying T gives Re
n
αk T hk
=T
Re
k=1
n
αk h k
≤ T (Φ(g)).
k=1
Now
n k=1
=
1/p |(T hk )(y)| sup Re
p
n
αk (T hk )(y)
: αk ∈ Q + iQ,
k=1
n
|αk |p ≤ 1
k=1
≤ T (Φ(g))(y) μ-a.e. Thus, Φ(T ◦ g) ≤ T (Φ(g)). Theorem 5.3.6. Let (Ω, μ) be a σ-finite measure space, 1 ≤ p < ∞, and T be a positive C0 -semigroup on Lp (Ω), with generator A. Then s(A) = ω(T ). Proof. First, assume that s(A) < 0. Fix α > max(0, ω(T )). Take f ∈ Lp (Ω) and define g ∈ Lp (R, Lp (Ω)) by e−αt T (t)f (t ≥ 0), g(t) := 0 (t < 0). Define G : R+ → Lp (R, Lp (Ω)) by G(s) := T (s) ◦ g−s ,
358
5. ASYMPTOTICS OF SOLUTIONS OF CAUCHY PROBLEMS
where g−s (t) := g(t − s). Thus, G(s)(t) =
e−α(t−s) T (t)f 0
Then Φ
m
G(s) ds
∞
=
0
0
1 α
=
(0 ≤ s ≤ t), (−∞ < t < s).
p 1/p min(m,t) −α(t−s) e T (t)f ds dt 0 ∞
−α max(0,t−m)
e 0
−αt
−e
p
1/p
|T (t)f | dt p
.
Thus, 1 α
0 ≤ =
−α max(0,t−m)
e 0m
Φ m
≤
∞
−e
−αt
p
1/p |T (t)f | dt p
G(s) ds
0
Φ(G(s)) ds 0 m
=
0
0
≤
Φ (T (s) ◦ g−s ) ds
m
T (s) (Φ(g−s )) ds m
=
T (s)(Φ(g)) ds, 0
where we have used Lemma 5.3.4, Proposition 5.3.5 and Lemma 5.3.3 b) in the third, fifth and sixth lines respectively. Since abs(T ) = s(A) < 0 (Theorem 5.3.1), m T (s)(Φ(g)) ds → R(0, A)(Φ(g)) in Lp (Ω), 0
as m → ∞ (Proposition 5.1.4). By the monotone convergence theorem, ∞ 1/p ! "p 1 0≤ 1 − e−αt |T (t)f |p dt ≤ R(0, A)(Φ(g)). α 0 Hence,
1 − e−α α
1
∞
1/p |T (t)f |p dt
Taking norms in Lp (Ω) gives ∞ p |(T (t)f )(y)| dt dμ(y) ≤ Ω
1
α 1 − e−α
≤ R(0, A)(Φ(g)). p
R(0, A) p Φ(g) pLp (Ω) ,
5.3. POSITIVE SEMIGROUPS
so
∞
1
359
T (t)f pLp (Ω) dt < ∞.
It follows from Theorem 5.1.2 (ii) ⇒ (i), that ω(T ) < 0. In the general case, we may apply the case above to the semigroup e−ωt T (t) for ω > s(A), and we deduce that ω(T ) < ω whenever ω > s(A). Thus ω(T ) ≤ s(A). For p = 1, there is a much simpler proof of Theorem 5.3.6. A Banach lattice X is said to be an L-space if
x + y = x + y
for all x, y ∈ X+ .
(5.13)
If (Ω, μ) is any measure space, then L1 (Ω, μ) is an L-space. If Ω is a locally compact, Hausdorff space, then C0 (Ω)∗ (which can be identified with the space of all regular Borel measures on Ω) is an L-space. On the other hand, any L-space is isomorphic as a Banach lattice to a space of the form L1 (Ω, μ) [Sch74, Theorem II.8.5]. Proposition 5.3.7. Let T be a positive C0 -semigroup on an L-space X, with generator A. Then s(A) = ω(T ). ∗ Proof. By (5.13), there exists x∗ ∈ X+ such that x, x∗ = x for all x ∈ X+ . Let ω > abs(T ) = s(A) (Theorem 5.3.1). For x ∈ X+ and τ ≥ 0, τ 1 τ 2 e−ωt T (t)x dt = e−ωt T (t)x dt, x∗ ≤ R(ω, A)x, x∗ . 0
Hence,
0
∞ 0
e−ωt T (t)x dt < ∞
for all x ∈ X+ , and so for all x ∈ X. It follows from Datko’s theorem (Theorem 5.1.2) that ω(T ) < ω whenever ω > s(A), and therefore ω(T ) = s(A). Theorem 5.3.6 is also true in the case p = ∞ (even without the assumption that the semigroup is positive), but for the trivial reason that the semigroup is norm-continuous (Corollary 4.3.19). A more interesting case is that of spaces of the form C0 (Ω), and this can be deduced from Proposition 5.3.7 by duality. Theorem 5.3.8. Let Ω be a locally compact, Hausdorff space, and T be a positive C0 -semigroup on C0 (Ω), with generator A. Then s(A) = ω(T ). Proof. Let X := C0 (Ω)∗ , which is an L-space and therefore has order-continuous norm. Let Y := D(A∗ ). By Theorem 3.11.8, Y is a closed ideal in X, so Y is also an L-space. Let T (t) := T (t)∗ |Y . By Proposition 3.3.14, T is a C0 -semigroup on Y whose generator A is the part of A∗ in Y . Moreover, σ(A ) = σ(A) (see
360
5. ASYMPTOTICS OF SOLUTIONS OF CAUCHY PROBLEMS
Propositions B.8 and B.11). Let ω > s(A) = s(A ). By Proposition 5.3.7, there exists M such that T (t) ≤ M eωt for all t ≥ 0. For x ∈ X and y ∗ ∈ Y , |T (t)x, y ∗ | ≤ M eωt x y ∗ . For x∗ ∈ X ∗ and λ > ω(T ), R(λ, A)∗ x∗ ∈ D(A∗ )