Unfit Subjects Educational Policy and the Teen Mother
Unfit Subjects Educational Policy and the Teen Mother
Wanda S. P...
22 downloads
1177 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Unfit Subjects Educational Policy and the Teen Mother
Unfit Subjects Educational Policy and the Teen Mother
Wanda S. Pillow
ROUTLEDGEFALMER NEW YORK AND LONDON
Published in 2004 by RoutledgeFalmer 29 W 35th Street New York, NY 10001 www.routledge-ny.com Published in Great Britain by RoutledgeFalmer 11 New Fetter Lane London EC4P 4EE www.routledge.co.uk Copyright © 2004 by Taylor & Francis Books, Inc.
This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2004. RoutledgeFalmer is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilized in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission from the publishers. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Pillow, Wanda S. Unfit subjects: educational policy and the teen mother / Wanda S. Pillow. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references (p. ) and index. ISBN 0-415-94492-9 (alk. paper) -- ISBN 0-415-94493-7 (pbk. : alk. paper) 1. Pregnant schoolgirls--Education (Secondary)--United States. 2. Teenage mothers--Education (Secondary)--United States. 3. Sex discrimination in education--Law and legislation--United States. I. Title. LB3433.P55 2004 373.1826v947--dc22 2003066854
ISBN 0-203-46560-1 Master e-book ISBN
ISBN 0-203-47245-4 (Adobe eReader Format)
To Bonna Jean Seal Pillow
Contents
Dedication
v
Acknowledgments
xi
Preface
xiii
Introduction
1
Embodied Beginnings 1 Making Teen Pregnancy an Educational Policy Issue 4 Telling and Not Telling “Fit” Stories about Pregnant/Mothering Teens 5 Tracing Policy Talk—Performing New Policy Studies Methodology 8 Embodied Policy Analysis—Rethinking Educational Opportunity for Pregnant/Mothering Students 10 Overview of Chapters 12
1 Constructing Teen Pregnancy as a Problem
17
Social Historical Constructions of the Unwed Mother and Emergence of the Teen Mother 20 Emergence of the Teen Mother 26 Teen Mother as the “Girl Next Door” 28 The Teen Mother as the “Other” Girl 33 Governmental Legislation Regulating Teen Mothers 39 “Black Family” Discourse of the 1980s 41 Where Is Education? 45
2 Title IX and the Discursive Climate of Education for School-Age Mothers Laying a Foundation for Title IX—Tracing Key Arguments Supporting Education of Young Unwed Mothers 58
vii
55
viii • Contents Title IX and the Mandate to Provide Education for School-Age Mothers 61 Discourses of Contamination: Pregnancy as Dis(ease) 63 Early Decisions—Setting the Stage for “Separate but Equal” 64 National Honor Society Cases—Are Smart Girls Contaminated? 68 Discourses of Education as Responsibility 71 Concluding Thoughts on Contamination and Responsibility 73
3 Schooling Responses to Teen Mothers Absences, Colds, and Disabilities
79
Tracing Policy Absences at State and Local Levels: Evidence of Deliberate Ambivalence 85 Ambivalent Uses of Title IX 88 School Data Problems—Troubling Absences in Data Practices 92 Education Provision Models: Is Pregnancy like Having a Cold or Is Pregnancy a Disability? 97 Pregnancy as a Cold 98 Pregnancy as a Disability/Disease 101 Education as a Social Welfare Issue— The Impact of PRWORA & TANF on Implementation of Title IX 105
4 The Teen Mother as a Student Who Is She & What Do Schools Do with Her?
111
“Pregnancy Scares” and the White Girl on Family TV 114 The Teen Mother as Student: Who Is She? 115 Rethinking the Teen Mother as School Dropout: “Returning and Staying in School Due to My Baby” 117 Staying in School: School Engagement, Pregnancy, and Acculturation 120 Where Are Teen Mothers Served? Exposing Differential Service Patterns 122 Practices of Exclusion and Expulsion 123 Voluntary Practices? 129 What Does Comparable Look Like? 132
5 The “Dual-Role” Model of Schooling the Teen Mother This Is a Test. A Real Test 139 School-Based Programs and “Dual-Role” Training 141 The Florence Crittenton Homes Dual-Role Model 143 GRADS Dual-Roles Training 149 Defining Teen Mothers as in Need of Training in “Practical Reasoning Skills” 153 Schooling for Work 156 Training to Be a Responsible Mother 164 Paradoxes of “Practical Reasoning” and “Dual-Roles” 167
139
Contents • ix
6 Incitement to Discourse Talking about Sex in Abstinence-Only Education Movements
173
Lets Talk (about) Sex—Situating the Rise of Abstinence-Only Discourses 177 Discourses of Alarm 184 Sex Is Dirty 185 Sex Is Dangerous 191 Counter Testimony in Senate and Congressional Hearings— Mixed Messages Made Clear or Hidden 196 Discourses of Heteronormativity 200 Reassertion of Traditional Gender Roles: Women as Flowers, Men as the Necessary Tool 201 Marriage as the Solution 206 Discourses of Control—Norplant 209 Concluding Thoughts on Indictments to Discourse 211
7 Education for Teen Mothers
217
Interrupting Discourses of Contamination and Control 220 Making Teen Pregnancy a Fit Educational Equity Issue 221 Athletic Girls as Fit Subjects 223 Teen Pregnancy Spaces as Single Sex Spaces 224
Bibliography
229
Index
239
Acknowledgments
The research, conversations, and writing of Unfit Subjects took place over a series of years that have included moves, births, losses, growing pains, and many pleasures. Some things have remained constant—primarily the challenges of mothering while, to use Laurel Richardson’s phrase, “constructing an academic life.” I have watched two of my children grow up while doing the work for this book. Now as they are nearly adolescents I look at them with wonder, trepidation, and respect for their daily experiences. Watching Jeremy and Kimberlé, I also see and want to acknowledge the importance of other adults in their lives to listen, guide, and expose them to ideas and possibilities. I sincerely thank the extended family and “other mothers” in Columbus Ohio, Greensboro North Carolina, and currently Champaign/Urbana Illinois who have supported me, and now Larry and me, in our mothering and who have repeatedly been there for Jeremy and Kimberlé. Completing this project while pregnant has been a gift in disguise—my body growing and changing as the text grew and unfolded served as a fresh reminder of the physicality and emotions of pregnancy as well as the myriad of places I fit and no longer fit as a pregnant woman. Having given birth to this project, our family now anticipates the birth of our next new addition. Laurence Parker has been both partner and colleague. I could complete this work only by knowing there was another “mother” to take care of Jeremy and Kimberlé and all that that entails. He kept me nourished while working, read repeated drafts, and listened to my doubts and confidences. Muchas gracias Lorenzo. xi
xii • Acknowledgments
The research for this book began under and with the encouragement of Patti Lather who has continued to show support and interest in this “policy stuff.” This project would not have been possible without her support. My ongoing conversations and friendship with Elizabeth St. Pierre have also sustained this project. Her insightful feedback on many drafts of this text and her sense of humor have been integral to this book and my life. The impetus for a shift in my thinking and the historical focus of my work was brought about by many conversations with colleagues and students in the Department of Educational Policy Studies at UIUC. Thanks in particular to professor James Anderson for his interest in this project and allowance of timely leaves. Support by the Faculty Fellows program in the College of Education UIUC and funding by the Research Board, UIUC provided key time and funding that furthered this project. Obviously Unfit Subjects would not have been possible without the participation and openness of the school personnel and girls with whom I talked. Some of these “subjects” of my research became more than subjects and their lives and voices have been with me every step of this book. I hope Unfit Subjects helps create interest in and commitment to research that aids teen mothers’ full access to equal educational opportunities. Thank you also to Catherine Bernard who stepped in as editor and took on this project late in the process but guided it to completion. Once again, my gatita Pretinha, now twenty-one years old, kept me company during long writing days and nights, lying curled beside me when I ran out of lap space. Although slowing down, she has been hanging in there, I believe, to witness both births. Lastly, this book is dedicated to my mother, Bonna Jean Seal Pillow, who more than she realizes taught me about the status of mothering and women past and present.
Preface
If I’d never gotten pregnant, I would’ve never come back to school. I came back to school because of my baby. Title IX, passed in 1972, effective July 12, 1975, provides specific provision and language governing provision of education for school-age mothers. Title IX states: [A] recipient [of federal funding] shall not discriminate against any student, or exclude any student from its education program or activity, including any class or extracurricular activity, on the basis of such student’s pregnancy, childbirth, false pregnancy, termination of pregnancy or recovery therefrom, unless the student requests voluntarily to participate in a separate portion of the program. (106.40, b)
He called me into his office and he said, “I hear you are pregnant.” And I say “yeah, so what?” He says we don’t have pregnant girls in this school—how it was bad for the school’s reputation and would give other girls ideas. He told me I had to sign the slip and go to this other school—if you are pregnant and you wanna stay in school, this [the separate school] is the only choice. Furthermore, Title IX requires that admittance to any separate facility set up for teen mothers must be “completely voluntary on the part of the student (106.40, 3)” and the district must: “ensure that the instructional program is the separate program is comparable to that offered to nonpregnant students” (106.40, 3). xiii
xiv • Preface
Teen mothers don’t need academics they need to learn a skill . . . to get a job when they graduate so they won’t stay on welfare. I had to petition to return to my regular school to take the college prep classes because they don’t offer them here—they just have “slow track” classes here. So I go to my old school for my academic classes and then have to come back here for the other part of the day. Title IX also provides specific language on leave policy for school-age mothers: In the case of a recipient which does not maintain a leave policy for its students, or in the case of a student who does not otherwise qualify for leave under such a policy, a recipient shall treat pregnancy, childbirth, false pregnancy, termination of pregnancy, and recovery therefrom as a justification for a leave of absence for so long a period of time as is deemed medically necessary by the student’s physician, at the conclusion of which the student shall be reinstated to the status she held when the leave began. (106.40, 5)
After 3 absences you’re on probation—and they don’t let you count an absence for staying home with your sick kid, unless you have a doctor’s note. But if my kid has a fever he can’t go to daycare and I can’t take him to the doctor every time he has a fever; but the teachers don’t believe you they just think you’re being lazy.
Quotes from interviews with teen mothers attending school and a teen pregnancy teacher (author, 1997).
Introduction Bodies are maps of power and identity. —Donna Haraway, 1990 I watched one teen mother, who looked to be a good eight months, struggle to fit into her seat—it was one of those classic school seats where the desk is attached to the chair and unmovable. She tried sitting down by sliding in, that didn’t work. Then she tried backing into the seat but she had grown too wide to really fit. She stood by her desk—all the others girls were sitting down—and looked at the teacher; the teacher told her to sit down. She said she couldn’t fit into the chair. The teacher said as long as you are here you will fit into the chair and if you can’t fit you shouldn’t be here. The girl perched sideways on the seat, the desk pressing into her side for the next 45 minutes. I ached watching her . . . and found out later that she had 3 absences this month and if she had another she would be written-up; that’s why she stayed in the classroom. This was a classroom for teen mothers . . . and her body still didn’t fit. (Author’s field notes, 1994)
Embodied Beginnings The field notes from my qualitative research experiences in teen pregnancy classrooms in the mid-1990s are filled with stories similar to the one above. Looking over the worn and stain-ridden pages of my journal (memories of those veggie burritos I ate while writing my thoughts punctuated by notes made by my children), I reread incidences that describe how pregnant/mothering teens did not “fit” literally and figuratively into educational research, theories, policies, and practices.1 It seemed obvious to me at the time that teen mother’s bodies were key to how they fit and do not fit into schools.2 However, at that point, I was most interested in and attached to telling the educational stories of pregnant/mothering teens from their point of view, through their voices. I offered the girls’ stories to counter the prevalent stories about teen mothers constructed by “official” policy talk and policy discourse. I worked to show that many of the issues facing teen 1
2 • Unfit Subjects
mothers are the same ones faced by single parenting mothers and by lowincome single mothers, placing teen pregnancy within the larger constructs of motherhood and single parenting, and differentiating social expectations and definitions of such mothers based upon race. Paying close attention to bodies also opened many other questions and issues in my research: Why and how don’t pregnant/mothering bodies fit in school? Whose responsibility is it to “fit”? Whose responsibility is the pregnant/mothering teen—social welfare systems, community health clinics, vocational training programs, or schools? How are some pregnant/ mothering bodies constructed as more “fit,” more entitled to our help, concern, and treatment than other bodies? What type of education “fits” with the pregnant/mothering body? These questions repeatedly challenged and interrupted my research, most dramatically in terms of methodology and in terms of product. Succinctly, this is not the book I thought or expected I would write. As a qualitative researcher, with interests in questions of methodology and issues of representation, I had assumed I would write a book of data stories situated upon pregnant/mothering teens voices and experiences in schools. Although such a project is necessary and important, as such work on teen mothers is lacking,3 I remained dissatisfied with the continued attention in such a telling upon the teen mother as a unit of analysis. I think this is because working from the bodies and voices of teen mothers continually refocused my attention on the productions and gaps in existing research and knowledge: How is teen pregnancy constructed as a problem and for whom? Why is there so little focus in national policy debates and educational research on teen pregnancy as an educational policy issue? What impact has Title IX, which guarantees the rights of the pregnant/mothering student to an education equal to her peers, had on the education of teen mothers? What do we know about the educational experiences of pregnant/mothering students—where are they being served, in which schools, and how? What are the purposes of education for the pregnant/mothering teen? This book reflects the impetus of these questions, turning the lens of analysis from teen mothers as a site of investigation to a tracing and analysis of the discourses that construct who the teen mother is and what she then deserves and needs in terms of education. Such a tracing involves closely looking at what we think we know about pregnant/mothering teens and foregrounds what we believe the problem of teen pregnancy is, who teen mothers are, and thus deeply impacts how we define the educational needs of pregnant/mothering students. This book then is less about the stories of pregnant/mothering students than an analysis of the discourses surrounding pregnant/mothering teens and a specific look at how such discourses
Introduction • 3
impact and delimit educational policy and practice for the pregnant/mothering student. This emphasis foregrounds and acknowledges the effects of discourse upon policy, in this case educational policy. I use my qualitative research to provide a place from which to ask different questions about pregnant/ mothering teens and identify and complicate our understandings of teen mothers, specifically in relation to how we think about the provision of education to such girls. This is an analysis then that attempts to make explicit what is often implicit in social science and political discourse surrounding teen mothers. Such tracings involve looking at the stories constructed about teen mothers, identifying the metaphors and the highly racialized4 discourses used to define teen mothers, and through their exposure opening means for the “reconstruction of power.”5 Identifying the historical themes and discursive metaphors that define how teen pregnancy has been and is defined as a problem and examining what these definitions have meant for policy development and implementation are not simply causal analyses.6 Rather, tracing and identifying the metaphors teen pregnancy serves to “defamiliarize taken-for-granted beliefs in order to render them susceptible to critique and to illuminate present-day conflicts.”7 Further, this tracing shifts the lens of analysis from the teen mother, and a reliance upon her to explain herself in ways we can understand, to the arena of social and political discourses that construct and define the teen mother. For instance, such a tracing investigates how in social and educational policy some teen mothers are “good girls who made a mistake” while others are “Welfare Queens.” This tracing also identifies the historical and present-day racialized discourses embedded within such distinctions, without requiring teen mothers to explain and justify their lives to us. Thus while my qualitative research deeply influences the analysis in this book, I also examine public and political discourses on pregnant/mothering teens in the arenas of social science, legal policy, and popular culture. I use these data sources along with my qualitative research to provide the discursive tracing in Unfit Subjects.8 The time period on which the book focuses, 1972 to present day, is significant because it includes the passage of legislation that had a critical impact on the education of school-age mothers—Title IX. This period also saw an increase in public debate and media attention on social policy issues related to teen pregnancy: the moral challenges of female sexuality, including contraception availability, abortion, unwed motherhood; the decline of “family values” in the United States; the “Black family crisis”; and welfare reform. As writing is an act of inquiry in which constructing our work we come to know more than we knew before and learn to ask “better” questions, I
4 • Unfit Subjects
have also faced the gaps in my own research—wishing I had collected more discrete data on curriculum offerings and course schedules at separate schools for pregnant/mothering students, remembering stories about homebound schooling that at the time did not jump out at me, recalling practices of involuntary placement that were not my focus at the time.9 These gaps I hope are instructive for future research. My many years of living with teen pregnancy as a site of research have also uncovered several converging interests that have come about only due to my research experiences. These interests overlap in each chapter; some are more obvious, while others operate behind the scenes, yet each has helped shape Unfit Subjects. I introduce these interests here to provide a context for the chapters that follow. They include: • Situating teen pregnancy as an educational policy issue • Exploring the work of representation in qualitative research and policy analysis • Performing new policy studies methodology—feminist genealogy—a historical and present-day discourse analysis that foregrounds constructions and experiences of racialized bodies • Offering a foundation for further research to examine what equal educational opportunity looks like for pregnant/mothering students, opportunities that are not about making teen mothers fit, but about making schools fit for pregnant/mothering students.
Making Teen Pregnancy an Educational Policy Issue— Challenging Educational Silences While teen pregnancy has been understood as having implications for education, teen pregnancy has not been situated as an educational policy issue. Despite the amount of attention teen pregnancy receives, educational research is scarce, school data on teen mothers is often absent or out of date, teen pregnancy is repeatedly situated as a psychological, health, or social welfare issue not as an educational issue, and educational policy researchers have had little voice or impact on national and state level policies affecting teen mothers. Examining these lapses is key to this project. Although teen pregnancy would seem to be an educational policy issue, education has situated itself as a “low profile” service provider, implementing policy instead of taking a lead in developing educational policy for pregnant/mothering teens.10 This may be because schools and school personnel are themselves conflicted over whether teen pregnancy is really a school issue or a social issue, a moral issue, a family issue, a women’s issue, a local issue, a government issue, or a welfare issue. While public education
Introduction • 5
has been given the mandate to educate pregnant/mothering teens, there is much debate over how to do this, where to provide such an education, and what type of education pregnant/mothering teens need or deserve. When faced with the pregnant/mother student, the question: Do pregnant/mothering teens “fit” in regular public schools? remains in the fore of educator’s minds.11 Whether or not educators think teen mothers are fit educational subjects, Title IX, passed in 1972, guarantees the right of pregnant/mothering teens to an education equal to her peers and specifies that practices of separation and exclusion are illegal. Despite this explicit protection of access to an education under Title IX, there is evidence, as this book will reiterate, that discriminatory school practices continue. Yet, at present there is no case law challenging such practices or determining implementation guidelines for the education of pregnant/mothering students under Title IX. The lack of case law is linked with societal attitudes and educator’s ambivalence toward the education of teen mothers. For instance, the lack of data available from schools on the teen mother makes it difficult to determine the school experiences of pregnant/mothering teens and limits questions of school accountability under Title IX. Despite the lack of educational research and input on teen pregnancy, school personnel are involved in making daily decisions that impact the educational lives of pregnant/mothering teens. Understanding why education has been absent in national policy discussions, how schools track pregnant/mothering students, and how school personnel make decisions about the educational needs of pregnant/mothering students is integral to situating teen pregnancy as an educational policy issue.
Telling and Not Telling “Fit” Stories about Pregnant/Mothering Teens What is a representative story of a teen mother? One of the main challenges I have faced as a researcher of teen pregnancy is how to discuss and represent an already overrepresented, hypervisible subject like the teen mother? Paradoxically it is the hypervisibility of the teen mother in social welfare debates and diagnoses of sexual immorality in the United States that reproduces stereotypical knowledge about teen mothers and masks potential other knowings. Hypervisibility not only masks the gaps in our knowledge about teen mothers but also reproduces such gaps, structuring what is intelligible about the subject. How do we tell stories that do not easily fit into existing, hypervisible, narrative structures? Would telling “unfit” stories of teen mothers work? How are our stories as qualitative
6 • Unfit Subjects
researchers reproduced? What was the impact of my representations particularly in relation to educational policy and practice? Talking and thinking with others who were also questioning what it means to do qualitative research within the posts of our times (e.g. poststructuralism; post-feminism; critical race theory; queer theory), I was further challenged to rethink the role of qualitative research and ethnography in educational policy research. While working against structuring stories of teen mothers as feminist victim (teen mother as victim of her circumstances) or feminist victory (teen mother who overcame against all odds), I continued to meet the limits of my data stories. For instance, I had hoped that telling the educational stories of teen mothers through teen girls’ voices, from their experiences, would disrupt simplistic and hegemonic constructions and understandings of the teen mother. However, I also began to experience the effects of the sureness of existing discourses surrounding teen mothers. I found that whether I was speaking to an audience of academics or practitioners, my stories remained easily organized into one of several discursive ideological structures: teen mother as good girl who made a mistake; teen mother as bad girl who later overcame her deficient background to succeed; teen mother as resistant—girls who just know too much; and the teen mother to be pitied because she is beyond the realm of help from society and the school. These ideological narrative themes continue to ignore and silence the centrality of race, gender, sexuality, and class to the experiences of teen mothers, except when these “identities” fit into cultural explanations as causal factors for teen pregnancy. Further, these narrative themes continue to emphasize the pregnant/mothering teen as the problem, always keeping her as the target of analysis and ignoring social and structural inequities that construct teen pregnancy as problematic. Overexposure to information and images about pregnant/mothering teens, combined with the lack of information about pregnant/mothering teens, led listeners to want to hear overexposed stories, the tragic and epidemic stories, about teen mothers, and to rely upon such tellings in order to be comfortable. Perhaps this is because what is at stake in debates about who the teen mother is and what the problems of teen pregnancy are is a reinstitution of control over female sexuality and the reminder that women are ultimately responsible for not only their own sexual purity but societal sexual morality as well. A presentation about pregnant/mothering teens in school then can easily collapse into heated discussions and polarized debates about family structure and dysfunction, sex education versus abstinence education, birth control, abortion, social welfare, and national morality. These debates often then lead to questions such as: Do teen mothers even belong in school? Are schools responsible for teen mothers? If so, to what extent? Furthermore these debates
Introduction • 7
contain barely coded racialized constructions of the teen mother and the problems of teen pregnancy, with the teen mother variously but consistently described as “poor,”“urban,” from a “single-parent family,” who “grew up dependent upon welfare,” with “no moral guidance,” and “culturally deficit.” The racialized discourses constructing teen mothers make possible further representations of the unwed teen mother as deficient and allow the development of social and educational policy based on the racial formation of teen mothers in these discourses. I repeatedly faced situations where the girls I interviewed were constructed as outliers because their lives were not tragic enough or did not fit with existing assumptions about who teen mothers were. I attended meetings where the discussion of education for teen mothers collapsed into mourning the loss of “traditional family values.” I continually faced the limits and reproductions of my stories. These experiences forced me to broaden my scope; to turn my lens of analysis away from the teen mother herself and toward the discourses that construct and represent her. Exploring metaphors like “working the ruins,” I attempt to think about what it means to do our work in “troubling” times, to foreground power/knowledge relationships, and to acknowledge that questions of what to do when our representations “fail,” often lead to an unleashing of other forms of questions and knowledge.12 As Deborah Britzman asks and challenges: “[What] can our ethnographies not bear to know?” What is both intelligible and unintelligible to our constructed narratives? And specifically in the case of Unfit Subjects, what is intelligible and unintelligible in the policy arena? Such questioning is not a retreat from telling stories, but attention to qualitative research or ethnography as a “site of doubt.”13 This site of doubt need not operate as a form of poststructural paralysis or a retreat from action, from, for example Daphne Patai’s admonishment, “to get on with our work.”14 Rather it is an acknowledgment of the discursive workings of power present when attempting to discuss and represent the already overexposed and hypervisible subject, in this case the pregnant/mothering teen. In this way, ethnography is resituated as Britzman suggests to: Trace how power circulates and surprises, theorize how subjects spring from the discourses that incite them, and question the belief in representation even as one must practice representation as a way to intervene critically in the constitutive constraints of discourses.15
Here then the stories of teen girls are woven within analyses of the discourses, the power/knowledge discursive structures, surrounding and constructing teen pregnancy. The voices and narratives of the teen girls I have worked, as Ruth Linden notes of her subjects, with “permeate my life” and
8 • Unfit Subjects
while their narratives are not the only focus of this text they always inform its analysis.16
Tracing Policy Talk—Performing New Policy Studies Methodology Unfit Subjects seeks to identify where the discourses about teen pregnancy are being formed, how they work, and what educational opportunities these discourses open up or delimit for teen mothers. This line of questioning focuses attention on who gets to name and define political needs, how this process affects the types of policy developed, and how such definitions are localized in the interpretation and provision of services.17 These questions and emphases require a rethinking of policy studies methodology.18 In addition to my own research, I am fortunate that I can draw upon an important body of work providing social histories of the unwed mother and of social policy in the United States to establish a foundation for my analysis.19 These works foreground the gendered, racialized, and ideological constructs through which unwed mothering has been defined. They also help identify the ways in which policy discussions and outcomes are influenced by the varying discursive locations of the problems of unwed mothers and the pregnant teen, and how whose bodies in which the problem of teen pregnancy is located, lead to very different policy discussions and outcomes. This work provides the evidence and impetus to trace the development of policy at the macro- and micro-levels, from legislative policy and executive decisions, to specific program development and local implementation. Further, this focus identifies the interconnections between historical macro discourses surrounding, teen pregnancy, and policy development and implementation at the macro and micro level. It also examines the assumptive discourses present at all levels and questions what these discourses mean for the provision of education to teen mothers. In conjunction with the above feminist social welfare histories, I use Michel Foucault’s examples of historical, discursive tracings of state interests performed through power and bodies, and my own refiguration of his methods through what I term a feminist genealogy, to trace not only what is said about teen mothers, but how teen mothers are said and what this means for development and implementation of educational policy affecting school-age mothers.20 Genealogy as a form of analysis interrupts simple reversal strategies of displacement. As Kathy Ferguson states, “genealogical reversals do not restabilize cause/effect relations in the opposite direction so much as they unsettle any effort to conceptualize singular or linear relations between events and practices.”21 Instead of a search for
Introduction • 9
order, genealogy exposes how what is taken for order is characterized by “flux and discord.”22 Genealogy is useful to the policy analyst as it incessantly questions the conditions under which policy is produced. This is not to say that I understand policy as a one way arrangement or that somehow social and educational policies singly define for the teen mother who she is and how she should be. Rather, this study emphasizes that educational policy does not develop in a vacuum, but is affected by beliefs, values, and attitudes, situated in discourses, which in turn affect school policy by creating or limiting educational policy options. Genealogical tracings acknowledge “that there are serious political implications in many of the everyday decisions individuals make” and that such analyses offer “a framework for acting as intersectional agents within various institutional settings” providing “grounds for creative and unconventional forms of political organizing and struggle.”23 Feminist genealogy is immersed in the work of feminist and race theorists leading to a commitment to conduct analysis in such a way that the “agency” of teen parents, while troubled, is not silenced. Thus the analysis utilized in this research is not simply resistant but is meticulous in its search for the discursive strategies of power as they are camouflaged in the assumptive discourses and practices of policy theory, implementation, and evaluation. Furthermore genealogical analysis, including feminist genealogy, traces not only presences in policy discourse and practice, but also absences. This analysis acknowledges that “policy is as much constructed by denials of needs as by meeting them.”24 Identifying absences and gaps, however, is not to simply proclaim what has been silenced or unsaid as the right knowledge, the true discourse. It is not feminist victory stories of silences that are revealed in Unfit Subjects. Instead, tracing the constructions of absences reveals a proliferative relationship between what is produced and what is absent in discourses constructing teen mothers and teen pregnancy as a social problem. That is what is said and what is unsaid in debates about teen pregnancy produce each other in binary relationships and as Stephen Ball points out such dualisms are never neutral but are “always both oppositional and hierarchical.”25 Understanding the proliferative relationship between binary discourses is key to tracing racialized discourses locating teen pregnancy. For instance, the status of mothering, unwed mothering, and women’s sexuality has been and remains linked with racialized constructions of who is a good woman, who is a good mother, who is worthy of pity, or who is deserving of scorn. While these binary discourses may be recognizable—good mother versus bad mother—what has not been explored is how these binaries are dependent upon and proliferative of each other. In the case of
10 • Unfit Subjects
unwed teen mothers for example, constructions of black female sexuality as deviant and black unwed mothers as deficient are necessary to locate and allow punitive ideological constructions of and policy responses to such mothers as well as to affirm historical constructions of the problems of white teen mothers as recoverable errors in judgment or errors related to their social situation and thus treatable and fixable.26 Exposing the proliferative relationships between racialized discourses constructing teen pregnancy begins an unraveling of the power relationships embedded within teen pregnancy discourses. In this way, “genealogy as critique reveals the contingency, even arbitrariness, of what appears natural and necessary, and thereby it serves to open possibilities.”27
Embodied Policy Analysis—Rethinking Educational Opportunity for Pregnant/Mothering Students Feminist genealogy emphasizes that the formation of policies are about regulating, reproducing, and surveilling certain bodies, in this case pregnant/mothering teen bodies. The body of the teen girl, the sexually active, pregnant teen girl—and its constructions literally, metaphorically, and narratively—are key to the development of educational policy and practice for teen mothers. Bodies—how we talk about them, proliferate them, racialize, exoticize, and seek to control and contain them are key to the analysis in this text. Bodies cannot be ignored. Here an analysis of teen pregnancy is a story of the hypervisible gendered, sexualized, and racialized body, the body that does not fit, literally and figuratively, into social, legal, and educational policy. The pregnant teen body challenges ideologies and morals surrounding female sexuality, heightens fears and desires of and for the reproductive body, yields racial distinctions on the status of femininity and role of the female body, engenders a nostalgic yearning for the days of an innocent adolescence, and raises debates about the purpose of public schools. The pregnant teen body exposes both the fact of teen female sexuality and the fears we have of such bodies. The pregnant teen body is a site of debate, alarm, fear, scorn, and shame. This body is used as a symbol of all that is wrong in America and is thus also situated as a body in need of regulation, control, surveillance, and reformation. Unfit Subjects traces and identifies the discourses, ideologies, policies and practices that define unwed teen mothers as unfit, while seeking to expose who within these discursive arenas is deemed more or less unfit. Which teen mothers are worthy of an education and which are worthy only of regulation and training as low-income workers? Which teen mothers are fit education subjects and which are not? The analysis in this text reveals a historical and
Introduction • 11
present-day conflation of highly racialized ideological discourses that have at key moments resulted in legislative acts impacting educational policy and practice for teen mothers, from the passage of Title IX in 1972 to the passage of the Welfare Reform Act in 1996 and its recent reauthorization in 2002. As the following chapters indicate these legislative acts relate to one of the primary findings of this book—that the education of teen mothers has been and remains a racialized story. Teen mothers bodies and the location of the problem of teen pregnancy have historically been and continue to be differentially defined according to the race of the teen mother. These differential racial definitions of teen pregnancy have deeply influenced the development and implementation of a two-tiered system of education. Understanding the racialized discursive structures that construct teen pregnancy resituates it as an equal opportunity educational policy issue and further situates the educational treatment of teen mothers, prior to, during, and after pregnancy, as a gender and race educational equity issue. Unfit Subjects argues that the education of pregnant/mothering students cannot be separated from debates of equal education opportunity and questions of gender and race equity in schools. However, what equal opportunity means for pregnant/mothering students remains largely unexamined: Does it mean placement in regular school settings or removal to separate schools? Does it mean placement in regular curriculum tracks or vocational job training? To date, such questions have only been addressed in discourses that foreground what the public defines as the educational needs of the teen mother. Such discourses are most often based upon what we think the teen mother deserves rather than through questions of what equal educational opportunity could look like and should be for pregnant/mothering students. Questions of what equal opportunity looks like for pregnant/mothering teens are related to tensions and debates over what constitutes equal opportunity for any pregnant woman. As a society we have had difficulty determining what equal treatment means for pregnant women and mothers. At times equal treatment may include protection from work environments that are harmful, at other times equal treatment means access to work environments. Unfit Subjects traces and locates how schools reinstitute societal attitudes and confusion toward pregnancy and mothering, utilizing discourses of inclusion or contamination to determine whether pregnant/mothering students need such amenities as chairs they can fit into, bathroom breaks during the day, or excused absences during pregnancy, whether they should be placed in regular schools with no support or removed from the regular school setting. Certainly all teen mothers need help and support. They may need additional counseling and medical services to meet their specific needs, but they also need the support that any mother parenting as a single-parent with limited income needs—they need access to health care, childcare
12 • Unfit Subjects
options, flexible schedules, transportation, and a livable income. As Kristen Luker’s research reminds us it is not as simple as saying all teen mothers will be bad or incompetent mothers, rather it is the economic and social conditions that we parent in that impacts our abilities to mother.28 While debates will continue about what teen mothers need and do not need, what they deserve and do not deserve, there is one thing that all pregnant/mothering teens are legally entitled to—that is, an education equal to their peers. I hope that this book, through its analysis of how the shifting definitions of teen pregnancy have led to inequitable programmatic practices and outcomes, lends itself to further exploration of what education for pregnant/mothering students can be and to arguments and actions in support of the right of all pregnant/mothering teens to receive equal educational opportunities.
Overview of Chapters In order to understand and situate teen pregnancy as a social and educational policy problem, I begin by tracing the shifting historical, social construction of teen pregnancy and link this construction with macro-level policy initiatives. This tracing provides a framework for the remaining chapters, layering discursive analyses that move from a macro-political analysis of teen pregnancy to a micro-analysis of how teen mothers experience school-based programs. This organization reveals the interconnections between historical macro discourses surrounding teen pregnancy and micro-level policy development and implementation, while exposing the assumptive discourses present at all levels. Each chapter progressively provides a more specific look at what we know about how pregnant/mothering students are receiving an education, which teen mothers are receiving an education, and how they are receiving it. Chapter 1 provides a foundation for the book by tracing the historical, social construction of teen pregnancy from early social and policy concerns about the unwed mother. This chapter also traces how varying definitions of the problem of teen pregnancy and shifting locations of the target of teen pregnancy from white female bodies to black female bodies influenced executive and legislative decisions and helped to reinforce and establish differential treatment of unwed and teen mothers by race. Finally this chapter provides an understanding of why the education of teen mothers has not been defined as an educational policy issue, but rather as a social welfare issue. Chapters 2 and 3 offer an in-depth look at what the passage of Title IX has meant for the education of pregnant/mothering teens. Although Title IX guarantees equal education to all teen mothers there is evidence that
Introduction • 13
schools treat teen mothers differentially by race, treating some young mothers as entitled to education and other teen mothers as responsible to society for their mistakes. However as these chapters also reveal, all pregnant/mothering teens are subject to barriers preventing them from accessing equal educational opportunities. Chapter 2 reviews the history of Title IX and identifies two discourses that impact the provision of education to teen mothers. These two discourses—a discourse of contamination and a discourse of education as responsibility—offer a lens through which to address the questions of the absence of case law under Title IX and the continuation of discriminatory practices toward pregnant/mothering students regardless of Title IX. Chapter 3, building from the analysis in chapter 2, explicitly traces education’s role in developing policies and programs for pregnant/mothering teens. Specifically what is notable in this analysis of state and local policy is the absence and ambivalence in the educational arena. Despite this lack of involvement, schools and educational personnel are the frontline service providers for teen mothers making daily decisions that impact the educational experiences of pregnant/mothering teens. Given the lack of data and policy guiding implementation decisions for teen mothers, how do school personnel decide how to provide pregnant/mothering teens with an education? I identify two prominent thematic discourses that school personnel use to determine how to provide education to pregnant/mothering teens, noting the problem and absences in both. Chapter 4 specifically looks at who the pregnant/mothering teen is as a student. The reader will find that the pregnant/mothering teen most likely to stay in school or to utilize school-based teen parent programs contrasts with the teen for whom Title IX was developed. This analysis sheds further light on why there has been no case law under Title IX to determine what educational opportunities for school-age mothers looks like and why schools continue to be ambivalent to providing education to school-age mothers. The second half of the chapter examines the barriers this ambivalence creates for pregnant/mothering students attempting to access an education. In chapter 5, I focus on the development of school-based programs that have emerged out of Title IX and other legislative mandates. I examine both the programs that place pregnant/mothering teens in separate schools and the programs that place them in a separate classroom at a regular school. I provide information on the development and implementation of a nationally disseminated school-based teen pregnancy program. Analyzing this program offers a way to identify how educator’s have addressed questions such as, what kind of an education should teen mothers get? and what do teen mothers need? The “dual-role” emphasis of this program focuses upon orienting and retraining the teen mother for her dual
14 • Unfit Subjects
role as mother and worker. Given that education for teen mothers has been situated as a social welfare policy issue, I suggest that these programs tell us more about what we think teen mothers deserve than what an equal education would look like for teen mothers. Chapter 6 may strike some as moving away from the above discussions about education for pregnant/mothering students, but I chose to include a chapter specifically on the sexuality of teenage girls because controlling or redeeming the sexual behaviors of teen girls (and certain teen girls in particular) has an important effect on teen pregnancy discourse and policy. Mindful of the questions Ken Plummer says we must ask about sexual stories: the nature of stories; the making of stories; the consuming of stories; the strategies of storytelling; and the work of stories in wider world,29 I ask these same questions of the stories told about teen sex in abstinence-only educational programs and in Congressional and Senate hearings on teen pregnancy and abstinence education. This chapter specifically traces the rise of abstinence-only education and identifies the narratives such programs tell about sex and the potential for extreme regulatory control, including enforced control of fertility and motherhood of certain girls, based upon an “incitement to discourse” and “epidemic logic” perpetuated in abstinence-only discourse. Chapter 7 returns to the impetus for the analysis in this book—What could education for teen mothers be? Building from the previous chapters discussion and analyses, and utilizing the language of equal educational opportunity found in Title IX, I raise questions concerning what “equal education” means for the school-age mother—does it simply mean access to regular public schooling or does it mean something else, some additional support or programs in order to receive an equal education. I argue that we cannot discuss this question without understanding and situating the education of pregnant/mothering students as an equal opportunity educational policy issue that is linked with issues of gender and race education equity issues. Consideration of separate teen pregnancy classrooms or separate schools as single-sex spaces yields further questions about the ability of such settings to provide equal educational opportunities to teen mothers. This chapter reaffirms the responsibility for equitable education for pregnant/mothering teens within the educational arena. Whether school personnel and the public like it or not, public schools are mandated to provide equal education to pregnant/mothering teens and educators have the responsibility to ensure that this occurs.
Notes 1.
In this book, I use the terms pregnant/mothering teen and teen mother to refer to schoolage girls from eleven to nineteen years old who are pregnant and/or parenting. I use the
Introduction • 15
2. 3. 4.
5. 6. 7. 8.
9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18.
phrase “pregnant/mothering teen” when specifically talking about provision of education and use the phrase “teen mother” as the phrase commonly used to represent the young unwed mother. However, the phrase “teen mother” is often used to describe pregnant teens. I counter this usage with the phrase “pregnant/mothering teen,” in order to differentiate between the pregnant teen and the teen mother and also to disallow a discourse that names the pregnant teen as a teen mother thereby slipping into language that supports an origin of life at conception. My use of the terms “mother” and “mothering” versus parent or parenting is to name the emphasis not upon unwed, teen parents, but upon teen mothers in policy and practice. Further, it should be noted that the needs, educational, psychological, and physical, of very young teen mothers (typically considered age thirteen or fourteen and under) are often differentiated from the needs of the older teen mothers (typically high school age, fourteen and above). Most of the research I cite including my own research is focused upon the older teen mother. Thus my discussion and analysis in this paper is most applicable to the older or high school teen mother. Pillow, Policy Discourse and Teenage Pregnancy. Pillow, “Decentering Silences/Troubling Irony,” 134–152; Pillow, “Exposed Methodology,” 349–363. Only a handful of such books exist and of these only a few focus explicitly on the education of teen mothers. See Kelly, Pregnant with Meaning; Lutrell, Pregnant Bodies, Fertile Minds. Throughout this text I use the term “racialize” to refer to the structural, discursive, and epistemological processes of race and racism. I rely upon David Theo Goldberg’s understanding of race, racism, and racialization with Michael Omi and Howard Winant’s development of “racial formation theory.” Goldberg points to the “fluidity” of race and the “masks of race” in order to trace figuratively how “race is a discursive object of racialized discourse that differs from racism. Race, nevertheless, creates the conceptual conditions of possibility, in some conjunctural conditions, for racist expression to be formulated.” See Goldberg, Racist Culture, 44. Correspondingly, Omi and Winant trace how political and social ideology structures racial formation. Racial formation theory suggests “a new conception of racial time, one which combines genealogical and contingent temporalities,” which acknowledges the discursive shiftings of racial formation in the form of racialized discourses to meet state needs. Omi and Winant. Racial Formation in the United States, 267. As quoted in Parsons, Power and Politics, xi. For discussion of the power of metaphor in policy analysis see Parsons, Power and Politics. For discussion of policy as discourse, see Allan, “Constructing Women’s Status,” 47–49. Fraser and Gordon, “A Genealogy of Dependency,” 310–11. Data sources for this book include: archival materials related to the social and historical construction of unwed and teen mothers from the Social Welfare History Archives at the University of Minnesota; policy documents—including legislation, executive orders, state and district policies; case law; program curricula; statements and publications by interest groups and research organizations; including new articles of media campaigns to prevent teen pregnancy; and data from my qualitative research, which included observing programs and conducting interviews with teen mothers, teachers, and school administrators across two states 1992–1994 and 1998–2000. One state I researched in had a statewide program implemented for teen mothers, the other state did not. I observed and interviewed pregnant/mothering students and school personnel at regular and separate school settings, spending one full year at a separate school setting. See Richardson, “Writing,” 516–529. Weatherly, et. al., Patchwork Programs. I use “regular” throughout this text to refer to traditional public school settings versus special alternative school settings developed for students requiring removal from the mainstream school setting. See St. Pierre and Pillow, eds. Working the Ruins. Britzman, “‘The Question of Belief,” 32. Patai, “Response,” 61–73. Britzman, “ ‘The question of Belief,’” 38. Linden, Making Stories, Making Selves, 8. Fraser, Unruly practices. For critiques of positivistic methods assuming political neutrality in educational policy studies see Ladson-Billings, and Tate. “Toward a Critical Race Theory of Education,” 47–63;
16 • Unfit Subjects
19. 20.
21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26.
27. 28. 29.
Marshall, ed. Feminist Critical Policy Analysis I. For explorations into recent critical social educational policy methodologies, see Ball, Politics and Policy Making in Education; Griffith, “Educational Policy as Text and Action,” 415–428; Hargreaves, “Transforming Knowledge,” 105–122; Scheurich, “Policy Archaeology,” 297–316. Abramovitz, Regulating the Lives of Women; Gordon, ed. Women, the State, and Welfare; Kunzel, Fallen Women, Problem Girls; Mink, The Wages of Motherhood; Lawson and Rhode, eds. The politics of pregnancy; Nathanson, Dangerous Passage; Solinger, Wake up little Susie. Michel Foucault’s use of genealogy is methodologically central to this project, as his work has reconceptualized history, power, subjects, and political discourse, see e.g., Foucault, The Foucault Reader. In earlier work, I describe what I term feminist genealogy, which builds upon Foucault’s work by focusing analysis upon historically and culturally situated decision-making with particular attention to how gender, race, sexuality, and class shape the policy process, see Pillow, “Exposed Methodology,” 349–363; Pillow, “Decentering Silences/Troubling Irony: 134–152; and Pillow, “ ‘Bodies Are Dangerous.’ “ Ferguson, The Man Question, 4. Ferguson, “Interpretation and Genealogy in Feminism,” 327. Mann, Micro-Politics, 32. Gordon, Women, the State, and Welfare, 11. Ball, “Some Reflections on Policy Theory,” 171. I use the terms “black” and “white” (lower and upper case) to denote the structural and institutionalized racism evident in the discursive climate surrounding unwed motherhood and teen pregnancy. By using the term black instead of African American, I am acknowledging an ongoing and persistent racial categorization of individuals as “black” based upon skin color (i.e., not white) regardless of an individual’s racial or ethnic background. In this way, “black” unwed mothers would historically have included “black” Puerto Ricans as well as other “black” Latinas and “black” American indians. Furthermore, incidence rates of teen pregnancy initially were based only on two racial categorizations “black” or “white” and only recently has data on additional racial and ethnic groups (including “Hispanic” and “Asian”) been gathered. When quoting from historical records and reports I use the terms of the author, which may include “Negro,” “Caucasian,” and “Hispanic.” When referring to present-day research I use the terms African American and Latina or the terms used by the author or report. For the young women I interviewed, I use the term they chose to identify themselves racially and ethnically. Mahon, Foucault’s Nietzschean Genealogy, 14. Luker, Dubious Conceptions. Plummer, Telling Sexual Stories, 29–30.
CHAPTER
1
Constructing Teen Pregnancy as a Problem She is assured that it does not matter what the past has been, the future may be all that she desires to make it, if only she is faithful in her resolves and is willing to be guided by the friends that she has now found. —Dr. Kate Waller Barrett, 1903 Unintended pregnancy . . . is happening to our young women, not only among the poor and minority groups, but in all socioeconomic groups . . . (It’s happening) . . . to ‘our daughters.’ —Alan Guttmacher Institute report, 1976 Out-of-wedlock teen birth is driving every single rotten outcome in our city. —Krista Ruth, social policy advisor, Indianapolis, 1996
Proclaimed a “national scandal” and cited as an indication of “a failure of American society,” teen pregnancy has been at the forefront of national debates and policy legislation about single motherhood, welfare, and the decline of morality and family values in the United States.1 The phrase “teen pregnancy” is so engrained into U.S. political discourse and public sentiment that it may be surprising to note that this commonly used phrase has a relatively short history. Prior to the mid-1970s, the phrase was not used and the attention of the public and of policy makers, albeit scant, was focused upon the issue of unwed mothers of all ages. While we have always had “teen mothers” in society, we have not always had focused research, policy, and media attention on teen mothers. Indeed, adolescent pregnancy was not seen as a specific problem to study until the 1960s but soon 17
18 • Unfit Subjects
caught popular media attention with the now oft used phrase “Children having Children.”2 The phrase “teen pregnancy” has further become symbolically linked with the economic and moral character of U.S. society and the problems associated with unwed teen pregnancy are assumed by policy makers and the lay citizen to be commonly known. However, as the quotes at the beginning of this chapter indicate, a close look at the construction of teen pregnancy as a social and educational problem reveals that the problem of teen pregnancy, even in its short history, has been defined differently at precise moments for varying political and social needs. What the problem of teen pregnancy is, who it is a problem for, and how government should intervene and on whose behalf (the teen mother, her child, or society) has always occured within a shifting social context—a social context that defines and at times redefines the problem of teen pregnancy.3 This chapter provides a tracing of how the problem of teen pregnancy is located and what this location means for policy development affecting teen mothers. This analysis pays close attention to shifts in how teen pregnancy is defined, how the pregnant girl is defined and symbolized, and what policy responses are seen as appropriate or necessary. A close analysis of the discursive shifts defining teen pregnancy makes apparent that how we think about teen pregnancy, how teen pregnancy is located, cannot be separated from the economic, political, racial, and moral climate. The problem of teen pregnancy is always constructed in a highly politicized context. Tracing the discursive climates surrounding teen pregnancy is key, for as Nancy Campbell notes in her insightful analysis of gender and drug policy in the United States, “definitions themselves do not determine the directions of policy, but political contestation over their meaning does.”4 Tracing contestations over meanings highlights the paradoxes and contestations in defining: What is the problem of teen pregnancy? When is one a teen mother? Who is teen pregnancy a problem for? And what should the roles of schools be in serving the school-age mother? In this analysis, I locate the emergence of the problem of teen pregnancy, and the contestations over the meaning of teen pregnancy, as occurring through what Linda Singer characterizes an “era of epidemic.” Singer argues that “epidemic logic” often prevails in political and policy discussions, particularly in regulatory practices that affect women, including contemporary discourses on bodies, pleasures, sexualities, reproductive rights, legal determinations of what a family is and the juridical construction of bodies in relation to the state.5 Singer extends an understanding of Foucault’s historical accounts of sex as a political issue and affirms and
Constructing Teen Pregnancy as a Problem • 19
furthers understandings of policy as discursive social, regulatory, and disciplinary actions. Modern regulatory power as Foucault demonstrated is “less likely to rely on force, but more likely to be comprised of disciplinary regimes, systems of surveillance, and normalizing tactics” that impact our ideologies and actions just as effectively, perhaps even more effectively.6 Foucault and others understand that power in this way is not simply located in positional power, but evident as “bio-power” in our everyday practices, and interpreted and reinforced in educational and legal institutions and discursive arenas such as the media.7 Policy enacts and reinforces modern regulatory power and is most regulatory when a social problem, like teen pregnancy, is defined as being of epidemic proportions. When a social problem is defined as epidemic it is “already a situation that is figured as out of control” and thus evokes a form of “panic logic” which “seeks immediate and dramatic responses to the situation at hand.”8 However, Singer also argues that “epidemic logic depends on certain structuring contradictions, proliferating what it seeks to contain, producing what it regulates.”9 In the defining and controlling of the problem, the problem is also (re)produced. As Singer states: Because epidemics justify and are in fact constructed in order to necessitate a complex system of surveillance and intervention, epidemic situations often provide occasions for the reinstitution of hegemonic lines of authority and control.10
In this way, epidemic logic provides “access to bodies and a series of codes for inscribing them, as well as providing a discourse of justification.” Singer’s conceptualization of epidemic logic allows an in-depth tracing of the work of “bio-power” in policy discourse and practice and a corresponding tracing of the use of language that marks, defines, and locates teen pregnancy as a target for intervention and how such discourses work to reproduce “the power that authorizes and justifies their deployment.”11 Here is it also vital to pay close attention to who is defining the discourses surrounding teen pregnancy, who, using Nancy Fraser’s term, is engaged in “needs talk” for teen mothers. Fraser points out that in welfare-state societies, talk about people’s needs is an important component of political discourse. Fraser views “needs talk” as “institutionalized as a major vocabulary of political discourse” through which “political conflict is played out and through which inequalities are symbolically elaborated and challenged.”12 Foucault also concisely stated this: “need is also a political instrument, meticulously prepared, calculated and used.”13 “Needs talk” takes on and produces many of the characteristics and dilemmas of crisis talk and epidemic logic by defining what the subject of the epidemic needs and what society needs in order to be protected from the epidemic. I utilize “needs talk”
20 • Unfit Subjects
not only to describe what has been defined as the needs of teen mothers, but also to focus attention upon the “politics of need interpretation.”14 Epidemic logic and needs talk is evident in teen pregnancy discourse and policy development and in educational policy development and implementation. However, I expand upon Singer’s and Fraser’s insights to expose the paradoxes of epidemic logic and needs talk when they are applied to differentially defined and racialized teen bodies. This exposure points out what is present as well as what is absent in policy discourses. While I certainly acknowledge a history where all women’s bodies and teen women’s bodies are discussed and regulated, I also trace differential discourses and outcomes based upon the race of the pregnant body. I present evidence that shows epidemic logic being used to argue for entitlement and access policies for certain teen mothers, while also being used to severely control, restrict, and regulate the bodies and lives of other teen mothers. These differential histories and discourses continue to impact how teen mothers are represented and what we think they need or deserve.
Social Historical Constructions of the Unwed Mother and Emergence of the Teen Mother Several excellent social histories detail the gendered and raced ideological framework of the U.S. welfare state, provide insight into the processes by which unwed motherhood in the United States has been socially constructed, and make linkages to resulting social policy responses.15 These works clearly link the problem of early parenting to the status of unwed motherhood and also begin to link differences in treatment options available to the unwed mother to the race of the unwed mother. For example, several works point to the construction of white unwed motherhood in the early 1900s as a psychological problem and thus treatable, while black women’s illegitimate pregnancies were viewed as a morality problem innate to their race, and thus untreatable.16 Key to analyzing the problem of unwed motherhood is to consider the role of homes for unwed mothers, the most influential and prevalent being the Florence Crittenton Homes for Unwed Mothers (F.C.). The F.C. homes and association, established in 1883, not only participated in defining and locating the problem of unwed motherhood, but also influenced public opinion and established treatment patterns for unwed mothers. From the late 1800s to the 1940s, unwed mothers were recharacterized from wanton vixen to “fallen women,” females who found themselve in dire circumstances, often for reasons beyond their control or due to their own mistaken judgment of a male. The F.C. Association was instrumental in
Constructing Teen Pregnancy as a Problem • 21
Fig. 1 Florence Crittenton Mission Papers, Social Welfare History Archives, University of Minnesota, 4:12.
shifting public perception about the unwed mother, from wanton prostitute to victim. As Otto Wilson, founder of F.C., wrote in 1933, It was startling indeed to have her [the unwed mother] presented as a victim—as an innocent girl of tender years, trapped, abducted, forcibly ravished, perhaps, or drugged, and then held prisoner through four of five years of utter degradation until excesses of disease wore her down into an ignominious grave.17
This characterization of the unwed mother as a girl, as a victim, was further fed by rumors and fear about “white slave traffic,” whereby a self-respecting white woman would be stolen from her home and forced into prostitution.18 Another characterization of unwed mothers as victims was based upon the young unwed mother’s limited life chances due to her economic and social living conditions. F.C. spokespersons and publications described such “girl’s” whose “misstep is not simply a deliberate sin, to be punished by God and man, but is in most cases the result of bad social conditions, of which she is more or less innocent victim.”19 F.C. homes were set up specifically to serve women who were victims, the unwed mother of little means, the “unfortunate” unwed mother, and offer her a safe place to stay during pregnancy and childbirth. This unfortunate unwed mother was repeatedly depicted in F.C. literature as a good girl, a respectable girl who just needed help, and was always Caucasian (see figure 1). She would be provided with
22 • Unfit Subjects
training and support until she was able to make her way on her own (with her child) in a respectable trade suitable to her class, typically as a housekeeper or washerwoman. While the F.C. Association strongly believed and only worked with unwed mothers who were planning to keep their children, their goal for these mothers (ranging in age from thirteen to late thirties) was ususally not marriage (because marriage to the men available to her would not be a suitable marriage) but self-sufficiency. It is important to recognize that despite being a proto-feminist foundation the F.C. Homes’ philosophy was based upon Christian ethics of caring for all, especially those beneath you. A basic ideology of the homes was one of rescue–rescue from one’s situation, which for the suitable unwed mother was one of hardship and squalor, and rescue from the unsuitable persons of one’s situation, in this case from males who were lazy and unscrupulous and took advantage of young women, and from females who had given into vice. Unwed mothers who were victims were a social responsibility and deserved the “full benefit of enlightened handling.”20 The unwed mothers accepted into F.C. Homes were seen as demonstrating the beginnings of recognition that they needed to change their life circumstances. From these beginnings, the F.C. Homes would instill a different set of values in the unwed mother that would in turn benefit society. The “new” values—including an emphasis upon Christian ethics, hard work, responsibility, wholesomeness, simple living, cleanliness, and economic independence by learning a vocation suitable to the unwed mother’s status—would ensure that the woman could redeem herself and make the best of her life situation for herself and her child. This retraining in values began with creating a world of cleanliness and order for the unwed pregnant female—household order, personal order, moral order, and spiritual order. This ideology viewed many unwed mothers as being victims of their circumstances, they were referred to as “inmates,”21 and assumed not to have had the benefits of exposure to moral and decent living. The homes ran according to a strict schedule and systemized routines for everything from the running of the home, to personal hygiene and health, to prayerful reflection.22 Thus F.C. Homes were not only a place to be while the woman was pregnant, but a place to be exposed to clean living. The matron of the home was to be a role model in all ways to the young “inmates,” providing counseling, guidance, and chastisement as necessary. Holding to the adage of “busy hands, pure heart,” women in the homes were expected to follow strict daily schedules and were assigned chores necessary to the running of a smooth household. Not only did such activities retrain the inmates mind, body, and soul but also provided the unwed mother with the experience she would need to be employable. Thus, the philosophy, organization and management of the F.C. Homes reinforced
Constructing Teen Pregnancy as a Problem • 23
that this unwed mother, the unwed mother in the F.C. Home, is a victim of her circumstances, a woman to be pitied, not reviled, a woman to be helped and retrained, not turned away. However, the homes were set up only for those whom F.C. found capable and worthy of rescue and reformation. Unwed mothers who were not suitable for the homes were turned away. As Dr. Kate Waller Barrett states, in her 1903 Some Practical Suggestions on the Conduct of a Rescue Home, “it is better to admit girls temporarily, and if, after the girl has been in the home for a few days, she is found to be an unworthy object, the only harm is that she has received a few days board that she is not entitled to.”23 Although Dr. Barrett reminded her matrons to “remember that Florence Crittenton Homes are for bad girls just as much as they are for good girls,” the F.C. Homes did help establish the beginnings of an ideological and pragmatic definition of which unwed mothers are treatable (and worthy of treatment) and which are not—providing a way to distinguish the “good” unwed mother from the “bad.”24 These discourses were deeply influenced by ideological and structural racism and established not only which unwed mothers were worthy of redemption, but also which infants were so worthy. For instance, Caucasian babies were repeatedly used in advertising campaigns to change societal attitudes toward and garnish support for the plight of unwed mothers and their children. A healthy, glowing, well-fed, smiling infant would be depicted with captions calling for sympathy and support for the white “illegitimate” child and his/her mother. A 1915 Detroit News article depicted such an infant with the caption, “Does His Smile Appeal to You?” and continued: It does to the nurses and doctors of the Florence Crittenton Home. It does to his grief-stricken, care-worn mother. He is only one of many who are cared for at the home. To see that smile grow on the face of a once wan, sick baby, to see a mother made comfortable, to see her saved from the anguish of desolation—that is the inspiration of those who are fighting to solve the problems of the institution.25
Such advertisements while a strategic attempt to play upon the generosity of a public sympathetic to an infant’s face also reinforced a commitment and social responsibility for the care and second-chance for white infants, children, and unwed mothers. F.C. ads also made an early linkage between the unwed mother and an economic drain upon the taxpayer using messages of sympathy and “pocket-books” to garnish support for the role of F.C. Homes. Consider the following plea made by a six-week-old infant: Won’t you please help . . . By helping me today, I will not be a burden to my community (and your pocket-book) later on, because your kindness and generosity now will help me be a good citizen when I grow up. You give my mother
24 • Unfit Subjects another chance to make good and your community and state is that much richer for her higher standard of living. (see figure 2)
While the philosophy of F.C. Homes claimed to provide care to all unwed mothers, and thus all their children, it is clear that the homes reflected prevalent racial segregation and racism of the time.26 Although the future for white unwed mothers was stated promisingly in 1933, black unwed mothers were described as problematic, as in this statement by Wilson: in the not too distant future it is easily possible that every white girl who need their [F.C homes] help can be received with the aura of their protecting care . . . the colored unmarrried mother is still a problem to be reckoned with.27
Thus, although there is evidence that some of the northeastern urban homes may have had integrated facilities at certain moments, most F.C. Homes routinely turned away black unwed mothers and homes in the southern states had policies to explicitly deny admittance to black unwed mothers. In the South, this led to the development of separate homes for the unwed “Negro” mother.28 In their respective works, Solinger and Kunzel each argue that separate facilities based upon race for the unwed mother fostered more than segregated settings. They link these separate services to differential definitions of the problem of unwed mothering dependent upon the race of the unwed mother. Further, these differential definitions of the origin of the problem of unwed mothering led to differential treatment of the unwed mother and her child. For example, Solinger points out how “social workers and other human service professionals claimed repeatedly that black single pregnancy was the product of family and community disorganization” and thus not treatable in the way white women’s unwed pregnancy was.29 This two-tiered system of treatment was further reinforced by a growing field of social science research. Research defined and situated white women’s unwed pregnancy as a “problem relocated from her body to her mind” and she was situated as a “treatable neurotic.”30 In contrast, black women were characterized and portrayed in research, practice, and policy as “unrestrained, wanton breeders, on the one hand, or as calculating breeders for profit on the other.”31 Thus while white unwed mothers were capable and worthy of rehabilitation, black women were rendered untreatable because their problems of unwed pregnancy were inherent and instilled in their culture and community.32 The immorality and incapacity for morality situated within the construction of black womanhood also continued and reinforced ideologies of idolization and protection of “white womanhood” which were particularly prevalent in the South. If black women were constructed as immoral, as
Constructing Teen Pregnancy as a Problem • 25
Fig. 2 Florence Crittenton Mission Papers, Social Welfare History Achives, University of Minnesota, 1:3.
26 • Unfit Subjects
untreatable, then contact between black women and white women could lead to the contamination and moral decline of white women. Recognition and acknowledgment of how racial segregation of services for unwed mothers continued to “protect” white women is necessary to understand the power of racialization in the diagnosis and provision of services to unwed mothers not only in the past, but how the vestiges of such ideologies impact present-day policies and practices. The differential definition of, characterization of, and location of the problem of unwed motherhood by race remained prevalent in social science research, treatment options, and political discourse. That the problem of unwed motherhood was different for white women than for black women was so ingrained it was never questioned. This differential definition affected the unwed mother’s access to treatment options, including counseling, placement in a home facility, health care, contraceptive information and availability, abortion, and adoption. Although the 1964 Civil Rights Act clearly called for an end to segregated service provision, F.C. Homes, still the most common option for unwed mothers at the time, continued separate provision of services for unwed mothers based upon race through the mid-1970s. At the same time, U.S. political and social culture experienced many changes. Women’s rights, sexual revolution, and access to the birth control pill contributed to major shifts in thinking about women’s sexuality. Yet the differential discursive climate surrounding the sexuality of white women and black women, as well as political and economic factors, meant that white women had access to and benefited from the changes during the late 1960s and 1970s. It was also during this time period that the focus shifted from unwed mothering to teenage pregnancy. As detailed below, the emergence of the teen mother and the problem of teenage pregnancy cannot be separated from this history of differentiated definitions and treatment of the unwed mother by race.
Emergence of the Teen Mother One of the most significant and surprising facts about the emergence of the problem of teen pregnancy, is that it occurred during a time period, from the late 1960s to the 1980s, when birthrates to teens were at their lowest.33 So what explains the emergence of the specific problems of the teen mother? One fact often overlooked is that while birthrates were stable or declining during this period, the teen population was at its highest, meaning there were just more teen girls than ever before, and adolescence emerged as a separate developmental stage of childhood.34 In 1959, the title of the F.C. Association’s annual conference was “Teaching School-age Unmarried Mothers in Maternity Homes” and the following year their an-
Constructing Teen Pregnancy as a Problem • 27
nual reports used the term “adolescent unmarried mother,” reflecting this change in thinking.35 In August 1962, the executive director of F.C. spoke specifically about the increase in young mothers in the homes. However, she was also clear that this increase was due not to a higher rate of teen births, but to the number of girls of this age: We are deeply concerned about this group since many of the girls we serve are very young. 71 percent last year were under 21, and 40 percent were in high school or college when they became pregnant. . . . We may expect an increase in the number of school-age girls needing services in this problem simply because there will be a tremendous increase of this age group in the next ten years. And I should like to emphasize here that this is not because the rate of out of wedlock pregnancies is increasing among teenagers. Actually it dropped in the last five years and the vast majority of our young people are not caught in this predicament—public opinion not withstanding.36
If birthrates to teen girls were declining, what was the problem and the public’s perception of the problem based upon? As Maris Vinovskis describes, by 1978, the political climate surrounding teen pregnancy was reaching a crisis level: Almost everyone in Washington believed that the problem of adolescent pregnancy constituted a very serious social and health crisis that necessitated an immediate response—whether from the federal, state, and local governments or from private citizens and organizations. Both the policymakers and the news media emphasized the “epidemic” nature of adolescent pregnancy. Many members of the Carter administration and the 95th Congress assumed that Americans faced a new and growing crisis and that drastic steps dealing with this threatening situation had to be initiated at once.37
Yet as Vinovskis demonstrates this “crisis” and “epidemic” occurred at the same time when teen birthrates were actually declining after reaching a high in 1957. Vinovskis argues that a series of events and situations led policymakers and the pubic to buy into the myth of an epidemic of teen pregnancy, including a lack of historical perspective on teen birthrates, the rising costs of early childbearing, the humanitarian approach of President Jimmy Carter and his administration, a more open attitude toward female use of contraceptives, a positioning of the discussion of teen pregnancy as an “alternative to abortion,” the role of interest groups like the Alan Guttmacher Institute (AGI), and a lack of social science research and policy-oriented studies on teen pregnancy.38 Annette Lawson and Deborah Rhodes argue that it was the socioeconomic context in which the births occured and the “cultural ideology they challenge[d]” that led to increased attention on teen pregnancy.39 While birthrates overall were at their lowest during the 1960s and 1970s, several other factors had changed:
28 • Unfit Subjects
• More teens, particularly white teens, were sexually active outside of marital or committed relationships • After 1972, there was an increase in pregnancies resulting in abortions, particularly among white women • There was a cited increase in unplanned pregnancies, particularly among white women • There were higher rates of birth to unmarried women and a significant rise in single parenting, again particularly by white women and teens.40 What is apparent from this information is that the beginnings of defining the problem of unwed teenage pregnancy initially rose out of concern about the increase in unwed sexual activity, pregnancies, unwed births, and unwed teen pregnancy among white women. While black women’s rates of unwed pregnancy were linked with inherent cultural weakness and thus yielded, at least initially, little attention, a rise in white unwed pregnancy was cause for concern and policy response. Contrary to current public opinion and policy focus, the initial symbol and focus of teen pregnancy was the white teen mother. This focus occurred within a highly racialized discourse of the problem of unwed mothers—a discourse that within a short time span defined the pregnant teen as the “girl next door” then redefined the pregnant teen as the “other girl.” While I discuss these discourses separately, they are not so distinct. Constructions of the “girl next door” are dependent upon contrary depictions of the “other girl,” and both discourses occur at the same time. However, each discourse yields its own possible policy options and the broad discursive and symbolic shift from “our girls” to the “other girl” has had a dramatic impact on the development of programs and services for teen mothers. Teen Mother as the “Girl Next Door” Although it is difficult to conceptualize in today’s political climate, the emergence of the problem of teen pregnancy was linked to the young white, middle-class, all-American, unwed mother. During the initial emergence of teen pregnancy, rates of sexual activity, pregnancy, abortion, and birthrates increased only among Caucasian teens.41 Although teen pregnancy and birthrates remained below mid-1950s rates, the number of teens particularly white female teens engaging in premarital sexual activity increased. The Allen Guttmacher Institute (AGI), a major research group influencing policy, published a 1976 pamphlet entitled 11 Million Teenagers: What Can Be Done About the Epidemic of Adolescent Pregnancies in the United States. This “epidemic” was situated as an one of white teens.42 The discursive shift involved in defining the teen mother as a poor unwed working-class white girl or as the irresponsible unwed black to
Constructing Teen Pregnancy as a Problem • 29
defining her as the girl next door is subtle but visible. As early as 1958, at the 8th annual F.C. conference, in Washington, D.C., Mary Louise Allen, director of F.C. Association stated: [W]e are seeing a different kind of unwed mother. They are not the little girl wronged by a heartless man as a rule or the trade woman of the red light district. They are any average American girl or woman, high school girls, college girls, professional women, secretaries, factory girls who simply got caught in a game where the majority of her contemporaries are engaged in the same game but without the dire consequences of illegitimate pregnancy.43
This “game” was the game of sexual activity before marriage and although associations like F.C. did not approve of such immoral conduct, the idea was circulated that such young women, the “average American girl,” who were “caught” were not to be reviled, but to be helped. For example, the F.C. Association became involved in developing films to influence public perceptions about unwed mothers and in 1960 developed and put on a play in New York City called “The Sweet Potato Vine.” The production notes for the play state: This play has a teen mother who is attractive, wholesome, and competent. Having grown up in a relatively large community in the Midwest as the daughter of respectable middle-class parents, she fits very well the description of “the girl next door.” Liked both at home and college, she is to all appearances well-adjusted to society and her group. She fabricates an excuse for coming to New York because of her humiliation brought on by her situation and her desire to shield her parents from disgrace. Despite her immense self-reliance she shows great intelligence by turning to a trained professional when the pressures brought on by her situation become too great. The actress playing Carol must be aware of the acting traps of self-pity and bitterness. While anxiety and fear are constantly at work in Carol, the audience must be aware at all times of her struggle to cope with and her effort to control these emotions. Only in specifically designated instances are these emotions allowed to break through unrestrained.44
Thus the unwed, white teen mother is a young wholesome girl, from a respectable family. She is caught in this situation, and does not wallow in self-pity or bitterness, but protects her family and herself by seeking professional help. This same year, 1960, a popular women’s magazine ran a “True Confessions” series depicting the lives of “normal, middle-class, respectable” women who were at one point in their lives unwed mothers. The magazine received an overwhelming response from readers in support of and with sympathy for this image of the unwed mother as the girl next door.45 F.C. Association sought to build upon the interest brought about by the “True Confessions” series and sent suggested radio scripts, newspaper ads, and publicity photos to its member homes.46
30 • Unfit Subjects
By the mid-1960s the idea that the unwed teen mother was “one of us” was making its way into political discourse and by the mid-1970s this discourse was established. Some note that it is not coincidental that this concern with and focus on white unwed motherhood occurred at the same time that public services for unwed mothers, like the F.C. Homes, could no longer legally operate as segregated institutions.47 Certainly there was much alarm and resistance within the F.C. Association membership about desegregation of the F.C. Homes. Fear of integration and comingling of black and white unwed mothers led to concerns that black mothers would be a bad influence upon white mothers. Although by the early 1960s some homes had officially changed their admission policies, many southern homes resisted such changes and continued to resist until Civil Rights laws found them in noncompliance. In 1963, F.C. Executive Director Mary Louise Allen noted, “There is a growing unrest in the southern Homes about integration of facilities but a new awareness of the needs of Negro girls for the services.”48 By August of the same year, Mrs. Allen sent a special memorandum to members of the F.C. board of directors: Lexington:–Following the Governor’s order regarding desegregation of all state licensed agencies, the Lexington FC Board is reviewing its intake policies. A word of encouragement to them from you would probably be welcomed. They are anxious that they will be deluged with applications. Experience does not bear this out—as a matter of fact, we have to reach out for Negro girls. Your experience will help them to move into a new service more comfortably.49
The idea that black unwed mothers would overrun public services available previously only to white mothers was a fear based upon historical conceptions of high rates of fertility and unwed mothering and intrinsic immorality of black women. Furthermore, black unwed motherhood at this point remained linked with what was characterized as an inherent immorality and irresponsibility in black culture, marking the problem of black unwed pregnancy virtually untreatable. The 1965 publication and debate over the Moynihan Report on “the Negro family,” and corresponding rise of a “culture of poverty” thesis provided support for those who believed that black individuals and families were inherently inferior.50 Further, it was strongly felt that white unwed mothers would be harmed by placement with black unwed mothers and that such inter-racial mixing even among women might increase the number of biracial births.51 These beliefs likely contributed to and reinforced a refocus of attention on the white unwed mother, while still relegating the black unwed mother as untreatable. A public and policy focus on white unwed mothering would work to differentiate the white unwed mother from the black unwed mother, even under forced desegregation of services.
Constructing Teen Pregnancy as a Problem • 31
For this to work the white unwed mother could not be just any white unwed mother, but one who would make a sympathetic subject. Media and policy makers found that sympathetic subject, proclaiming that “our girls” (white, middle-class girls) were at risk of becoming pregnant and that something must be done.52 1975 marked teen pregnancy’s “official” emergence as a social problem when Congress held its first hearing on teen pregnancy and Senator Edward Kennedy introduced his “National SchoolAge Mother and Child Health Act,” which did not pass but served to bring teens and their behavior to public attention.53 In 1976 the First Interhemispheric Conference on Adolescent Fertility was held in Virginia, attended by almost 160 people representing 39 nations. The conference report echoing AGI’s epidemic language, issued the following statement: Close to 13 million of the 60 million women who became mothers in 1975 became parents before they became adults . . . Early childbearing is increasing everywhere, is emerging as a serious problem in many countries, and has reached alarming levels in others.54
This report further not only drew attention to the number of U.S. teens becoming pregnant but focused attention upon who was getting pregnant. An AGI spokesperson put it succinctly in a 1978 hearing: “unintended pregnancy . . . is happening to our young women, not only among the poor and minority groups, but in all socioeconomic groups . . . (It’s happening) . . . to ‘our daughters.’”55 As Jennifer Mittelstadt notes by “the mid1970s, the previously socially ostracized pregnant teenager became the object of concern and compassion among policy makers.”56 Policy makers responded with legislation and funding for preventative measures including major legislation dealing with expanding access to birth control. The Supreme Court decision in Roe v. Wade established legal access to abortion counseling and procedures. With the recharacterization of the problem of teen pregnancy as a white, middle-class problem, pressure mounted not only to develop preventive programs but to also change existing conditions for unwed mothers. Similar to earlier constructions of white unwed mothers as women who had “fallen” but were worthy and capable of redemption through treatment, the white, middle-class teen mother of the 1970s was constructed as a young woman who had made a mistake—a mistake that should not be held against her or ruin her whole life. Not only should this teen mother be shown compassion, she was also entitled to certain rights. Up to this point, pregnant/parenting teens were excluded officially and unofficially from participation in school and social-based activities, associations, and organizations. One of the primary conditions that needed changing in the 1970s was the middle-class white pregnant girl’s access to a
32 • Unfit Subjects
public school education. Certainly such girls were not only deserving of an education, but were entitled to receive an equal and quality education and policy makers set out to protect this right, and did so in 1972 with the passage of Title IX. Prior to Title IX school-age mothers were routinely dismissed from school. Title IX clearly established the right of the school-age mother to receive an education and not just any education but an education equal to her peers. Title IX established specific provisions for governing schooling for teen mothers. It states: [A] recipient [of federal funding] shall not discriminate against any student, or exclude any student from its education program or activity . . . on the basis of such student’s pregnancy, childbirth, false pregnancy, termination of pregnancy or recovery therefrom, unless the student requests voluntarily to participate in a separate portion of the program.57
Furthermore, Title IX requires that any separate facility set up for teen mothers must be “comparable to that offered to nonpregnant teens.”58 Title IX is clearly the most significant legislation impacting and protecting the provision of education to school-age mothers. However, when tracing the impact of Title IX from 1972 to the present, it is vital to situate the passage of Title IX as occurring under and in response to a representation of teen mothers as “our girls.” After the passage of Title IX, immediate access to schooling for school-age mothers increased dramatically between 1975 and 1986 for white teen mothers, while decreasing for black teen mothers.59 In effect, Title IX increased access to schooling differentially by race of the teen mother enacting the prevalent political ideology of the time and providing evidence of Title IX’s initial conception as an entitlement policy focused upon the white teen mother. Further policy responses during the 1970s clearly focused on the white middle-class unwed mother, guaranteeing her access to health services and further establishing her entitlement to education. By 1978, the Office of Adolescent Pregnancy Programs had been established under the Adolescent Health, Services, and Pregnancy Prevention and Care Act, overseeing development and implementation of programs, both preventative and treatment, for teen mothers. Attention to “our girls” and girls who were victims focused policy discussion on comprehensive services for teen mothers, including education, health, and social services available from pregnancy until at least two years after delivery. This is not to discount that there still were prevalent ideas about the teen mother as a “bad girl,” but for the most part policy discussions in the 1970s focused upon helping the teen mother linked with constructions of teen mothers as “our girls.” While there was concern and debate over making teen pregnancy too “attractive” and specifically debate around issues like abortion counseling, the
Constructing Teen Pregnancy as a Problem • 33
majority discourse during this period was on providing comprehensive services to the teen mother, even though policy makers still knew little at this time about which comprehensive services really mattered or how to implement such services.60 An emphasis upon middle-income white teen age girls kept policy makers focused upon provision of equal access for the teen mother and a continuation of focus upon “our girls” was consistent across research reports and articles as evidence in a 1979 Phi Delta Kappan article which noted: “despite the traditional portrayal of increased early sexual activity among minorities and the poor, recent evidence points toward increasing sexual activity at earlier ages among middle- and upper-class white teenagers.”61 The focus upon white middle-income unwed, teen pregnancies has continued to be used specifically to draw attention to teen pregnancy as a policy issue in order to garnish funding and support for policies, specifically policy initiatives that provide services to teen mothers. For example, a 1986 Children’s Defense Fund brochure states in bold print “Teen Pregnancy is Epidemic” with smaller print explaining that this epidemic occurred “across all races and classes of American youth today.”62 Further the brochure admonishes the reader that, again in bold, “Teen Pregnancy Affects You” explaining “it could happen to your child, your niece, your grandchild, your friend’s child, or your school or Sunday school pupil unless you begin to think of ways to help children avoid tooearly sexual activity, pregnancy, and parenthood.”63 This construction of teen pregnancy as epidemic and of the potential teen mother as a “child” intimately connected with ourselves is a continued attempt to get the issue of teen pregnancy upon the policy agenda through an “our girl” discourse. However, while the use of the discursive image of “our girls” continued through the 1980s and is still sometimes present in teen pregnancy discourse, (see figure 3), this construction of the teen mother as a compassionate and entitled subject was short lived in the policy arena. By the mid-1980s, discourses of the “other” girl worked their way into, existing beside, and differentiated from discourses of the teen unwed mother as “our girl” opening a new wave of policy response to the problem of teen pregnancy. The Teen Mother as the “Other” Girl By the mid-1980s teen pregnancy had become linked with social welfare policy and reform (specifically Aid to Families with Dependent Children, AFDC) and the teen mother became synonymous with the welfare mother. Furthermore, a new discourse of welfare dependency linked with prevalent discourses about a cycle of poverty was closely linked with racialized assumptions about who was poor and who was most at risk to be dependent upon welfare.64 In this portrait of welfare dependency, the teen mother became the welfare dependent mother, the “welfare queen” as President
34 • Unfit Subjects
Fig. 3 “Multiply/Subtract: Adolescent pregnancy isn’t just a problem in America, it’s a crisis.” Copyright Children’s Defense Fund. Used by permission.
Ronald Reagan dubbed her, and was also assumed to be and symbolized by the black unwed mother.65 Teen pregnancy during the 1980s was again described as an epidemic, not, however, as a sympathetic epidemic but one redefined as a social ill, linked with poverty, immorality, and promiscuity. The most cited reasons for high rates of young, unwed pregnancy included, changing societal values that make sexual activity and out-of-wedlock childbearing more acceptable, changing family structure, the portrayal of sex in the
Constructing Teen Pregnancy as a Problem • 35 media, the earlier maturation of teenagers today, and the ready availability of methods of birth control.66
This focus on the societal and cultural causes of teen pregnancy led to an increase in moral discussions of teen pregnancy and female sexuality as well as the negative impact of feminism on gender roles in society and families. Backlashes to the feminist movement, which was characterized as turning women into men and making women feel guilty about being housewives, encouraged a return to married motherhood for white, middle-class women. Correspondingly, the image of the teen pregnant girl shifted in the political and public mind. She was no longer “our girl next door” but the “other girl.” Several discourses were present in making the teen pregnant girl the “other.” They included: • Teen pregnancy was again marked as an epidemic, but this time as a “brown” epidemic • Teen pregnancy was linked with a cycle of poverty and resituated as a social welfare issue • The teen mother was represented not as the “[white] girl next door” but as the “[black] welfare mother” and this phenomena was linked with “the decline of the black family” • Teen mothers were identified as “children having children,” as irresponsible and promiscuous, often the result of lenient social policy and a decline of the responsible family unit These discourses, which are still recirculated today, create a different discursive environment for policy development and implementation than the early 1970s emphasis on funding for program development and services to aid teen mothers. Creating policy for the “other” girl is very different for making policy for “our girls.” Further the policies and initiatives created under an ideology of “our girls,” were viewed by many as being too lenient, too approving of the sexually active unwed woman, and too accommodating of the unwed mother, allowing for a linkage of such policies with a decline of family values and disruption of gender roles. All of the discursive structures above depend upon constructing teen pregnancy as an epidemic. The marking of teen pregnancy as an epidemic during the 1980s is ironic given that teen birthrates were at their lowest level in twenty years and on the decline. For example, in 1985 the Children’s Defense Fund wrote that “birth rates for all but the very youngest teens, those younger than 15, have dropped significantly since 1970.”67 What did rise in the 1980s were the number of births to unmarried women.68 Further, close analysis of the so-called epidemic of the 1980s reveals that it occurred within a racialized context.
36 • Unfit Subjects
The policies and programs of the 1970s provided access for women to health care, contraceptive choices, and abortions. However, due to the effects of societal and institutional racism, women’s access to the benefits of such policies and programs varied according to their race. During the 1970s white women experienced and benefited from shifting attitudes toward women’s sexuality and had increased access to information about female sexuality, birth control options, and abortions, while black women did not experience this increased access. Such access to information, products, and services alongside white women’s increased access to higher education and careers, led to a decrease and delay in marriage and childbearing to white women overall, with the result that by the 1980s early childbearing began to be concentrated among poor and black women.69 Teen pregnancy birthrates tend to follow national trends for birthrates to women overall. By the mid-1980s, birthrates to white women, including white teens, were declining, while birthrates to black women, including black teens, remained the same.70 At the same time Latinos were gaining attention as one the largest immigrant populations in the United States and Latina teen pregnancy began to be monitored. So, although birthrates to black women had not dramatically increased during the 1980s the birthrates of white women, particularly middle-income white women, declined. What these trends in birthrates meant for the “changing face of America” was made clear by a cover story in Time magazine in 1990 depicting a “browning of America.” As young women embody the “problem” of teen pregnancy literally and figuratively, Nancy Lesko observes of the Time article: Girls of different colors, shapes, ages with babies in their arms or on their laps stare out from the pages of Time. . . . Young women with extended bellies or small children both represent and are the problem of sexual irresponsibility and failure to delay motherhood.71
Yet the Time story went further noting that given present trends in lower birthrates to white middle-class mothers and higher birthrates to black mothers, U.S. society would move from white to brown to black. As black mothers and the black community were assumed to be impoverished, culturally and economically, a “browning” of America raised fears about creation of a predominant lower-class in the United States. In 1986 a special issue of Education Week projecting the school-age population for the next twenty years proclaimed, “A country without a middle-class majority will simply not be the America we have known.”72 These symbolic demographic representations provide a context for situating (minority) teen pregnancy as a “crisis” specifically when the number of births to white middle-class Americans is slowing and many
Constructing Teen Pregnancy as a Problem • 37
middle- and higher-income Americans regard “their own position vis-ávis increasing numbers of immigrants and minorities in a shrinking economy, as well as concern for the U.S. economic viability.”73 Could it be that white women’s birthrates would continue to decline as white women gained access to education and career paths previously not open to them? Is it possible that the white middle-class could shrink, while a Black and Latino middle- and lower-class grows? Is it possible that “minorities” will outnumber white Americans? And is it further possible, that specifically black and brown Americans will become a majority in the United States? These questions and the pictorial display of a “brown to black” America caused fear and alarm and situated the issue of teen pregnancy as primarily a concern over who was having children as a national social concern. The sense of crisis surrounding the above questions led to a shift in how the problem of teen pregnancy was popularly thought. Although the beginning of the 1980s focused upon “children having children” and upon teens becoming sexually active at “too young” an age emphasizing the belief that teens should not be engaged in such behavior, attention soon shifted to asking who was fit to have a child.74 This shift should be viewed not as naturally occurring, but used strategically and purposefully to support and limit certain political and public discourse.75 Such a shift also allows for highly racialized and recognized discourses to predominate without the speaker or listener having to acknowledge the presence of racism. A sense of crisis and a discourse of epidemics brings out highly coded language and phrases that stand in for race, yet the exact sense of crisis limits questions of such usages. These discursive shifts around a social problem, like teen pregnancy, have a dramatic impact upon the development of social and educational policy.76 For instance, Linda McClain identifies three rhetorical models of irresponsibility that defined unfit mothering during this time—”the single mother, the welfare mother, and the teen mother.” She also identified three corresponding aspects of irresponsibility “immorality, unaccountability, and incapacity.”77 Embedded in the discursive debate over teen pregnancy were questions such as, what age is too young to have a child? and who is to poor, and thus too irresponsible to have a child? Teen pregnancy became the link and explanation for a whole host of other social problems, including poverty, premature birth, low birth rate, an increase in dropout rates for high school, skyrocketing Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC) costs, and a high rate of fertility among African Americans. Cultural poverty arguments returned to the forefront of public and political discourse locating the epidemic of teen pregnancy within a range of social problems, all of which were specifically attributable to black communities and families.
38 • Unfit Subjects
Constance Nathanson links the construction of teen pregnancy as a “black single mother problem” to its “dazzling” rise to crisis level.78 Fear and alarm over the construction of teen pregnancy as a problem based upon a manipulation of birthrates yielded a “statistical formulation of the teenage pregnancy ‘problem’ and its commonsense ‘solution’” as “neutral and objective,” while as Bonnie Trudell argues, “it actually embodies particular economic and social interests as well as normative assumptions about cultural meaning and what constitutes legitimate sexual expression.”79 Understanding teen pregnancy as a problem of cultural deficiency within the black family remains a prevalent and assumed discourse today and continues to evoke epidemic logic supporting increased surveillance of all female sexuality and regulation of specifically black female sexuality. The epidemic and crisis of teen pregnancy in the 1980s, was grounded in concerns about declining white birthrates and steady or rising black birthrates and resulted in two overarching discourses that impacted policy development. The first, as mentioned above, established a linkage of teen pregnancy as a major cause of poverty. Thus teen pregnancy became a social welfare issue and the problem of teen pregnancy was resituated from an entitlement policy concern, prevalent in the 1970s, to a concern of the taxpayer. The second prevalent discourse situated within a discursive climate of institionalized racism located the black family as culturally deficit, incapable of passing on (white) American values of responsibility and morality. Additionally, due to higher rates of abortion and adoption among white teens, the increase in sexual activity in this group yielded lower rates of birth than those of black teens and became a focus of the new Moral Majority in the United States. Increasing rates of sexual activity among white teens, whether such activity resulted in a pregnancy or not, was a point of concern and attributed to what broadly became referred to as a “decline of family values.” This discourse barely masked a racial concern—that black girls seemingly inherent sexually active nature and their irresponsibility and immorality not “rub off ” on white teen girls and that births to white women occur in stable, married, economically viable relationships. Consider the following quote attributed to a family life teacher in the Washington Post, “the sexual mores that used to be attributed to lower-class kids from public housing are now rampant among affluent whites.”80 Note that while the race of the “lower-class kids from public housing” is not specified, it is not necessary for the author to identify these kids as black. The reader knows who the teacher is referring to through code words like “public housing” and the demarcation of the “affluent white” kids. Such commentaries insidiously reproduce discourses that place the blame for a decline of family values within the understood deviancy of the black family and the black fe-
Constructing Teen Pregnancy as a Problem • 39
male. Further embedded within this discourse is a renewed interest and concern about unwed mothers. Single parents (meaning single mothers) were situated as inadequate family units and single parenting was associated with a range of social and educational problems for the child. Single-parent families and poor families became constructed as unsatisfactory environments for creating self-sufficient, rational, life-planning, optimistic, upwardly mobile children. Lesko argues that “the problem of teenage pregnancy is part of a social logic and politics that discredits single mothers (who are overwhelmingly poor) by blaming their economic and family traits on bad values.”81 “Single-parent,” “one-parent” and “low-income” households represent discourses that define the teen mother and signal rampant negative social ramifications not only for the individual experiencing these categories but for society. These categories also locate blame. The assumed problems linked with teen pregnancy and the containment and control of teen girls’ sexuality are justifiable because pregnant girls are deemed irresponsible, and place a burden upon taxpayers, social services, and the U.S. economy.
Governmental Legislation Regulating Teen Mothers The overarching discourses surrounding teen pregnancy yielded a twopronged policy focus that began in the late 1970s and has continued to the present day. The two-tiered approach is about controlling and regulating who has children and under what circumstances. Since it seemed white women in particular had responded to health and reproductive policies and legal decisions of the 1960s and 1970s by increasing their unwed sexual activity, it was deemed necessary by the early 1980s to repeal easy access to services that may promote sexual activity. In particular, teen girls were seen as easy targets to restrict access to information, availability, and services. After all, by this point, the teen mother was situated as irresponsible and incapable. The Hyde Amendment of 1976 began an initial repeal in public funding for abortion counseling clinics and placed restrictions on what adult health care workers, teachers, and counselors could say to teens about sexual contraception and abortion availability. The 1978 Adolescent Health, Services, and Pregnancy Prevention and Care Act focused upon teen pregnancy prevention and community and citizenship responsibility.82 With a Republican president and Republican control of the senate a platform was created to reduce federal domestic programs, while endorsing funding to promote sexual abstinence in teen programs.83 In 1981 Orrin Hatch sponsored the Adolescent Family Life Act, commonly known as the “chastity bill,” which superseded the 1978 Act, spurred
40 • Unfit Subjects
“Just say no,” campaigns, and put chastity into policy as a primary means of preventing teen pregnancy. During the Reagan era, the Office of Adolescent Pregnancy promoted sexual abstinence and one program to come out of this was the idea of school-based “Chastity Centers.” Chastity Center programs firmly established sexual abstinence as an official policy response to problems of teen sexuality and childbearing.84 Chastity Centers focused upon single teens and firmly defined the problem as unmarried teen sex. As Connaught Marshner, a leading New Right spokeswoman stated “they [liberals] begin with the premise that teenagers should not have babies. We begin with the premise that single teenagers should not have sex.”85 Liberals who attempted to counter such policies often appeared to be promoting teen sexual activity. Although in 1981 representative Toby Moffet, Democrat, predicted to the New York Times that implementing the chastity centers would mean, “we’ll be laughed out of every junior high school in America,”86 the political climate was such that anything other than abstinence was situated as promoting teen sex. At the same time that legislators were active in decreasing teen’s access to reproductive services and information while increasingly pushing for abstinence, social welfare legislation increasingly targeted the pregnant teen, specifically the black female teen. Social welfare policy has historically been focused upon controlling and regulating female sexuality, particularly black female sexuality.87 In tracing policy regulation it is important to understand how earlier constructions of white women’s bodies and sexuality as differed from constructions of black women’s bodies and sexuality, and how these differences impact present-day policy discourse and policy decisions.88 Three welfare polices passed in the mid-1980s that restricted income support, choice of living arrangements, and options for education and employment, specifically for low-income teen mothers reflected a perspective of irresponsible parenting. In 1984, changes in federal law affecting AFDC instituted a “grandparent deeming” clause which mandated that all of a household’s resources be counted as available to support the child for whom AFDC eligibility is being sought. Thus responsible parenting was not only aimed at the teen mother but at her family in an effort to fix and place responsibility on families that were seen as being irresponsible, in this case low-income families. The second policy change, the development of the Family Support Act of 1988 (FSA) allowed states to require that the minor teen parent live with her parent(s) in order to receive AFDC. While most minor parents do live with their parents or guardians, this policy meant that if teen mother wished to live on her own, she must demonstrate why she should not live with her parent(s) or guardian. This act focused upon the issue of “welfare
Constructing Teen Pregnancy as a Problem • 41
dependency.” If the teen mother is allowed to set up her own separate household on welfare, she is more likely to develop a long term dependency upon welfare, a dependency facilitated by social policy. The combination of these two provisions makes it difficult for the teen mother to take on responsibilities and establish herself at the head of a household. A third policy change embedded within the FSA, focused upon education and employment training for welfare recipients. Teen mothers under this provision are treated separately and differentially more harshly than other unwed mothers receiving welfare assistance. In a form of “tough love” programming for teen mothers, FSA deemed that each state require welfare recipients who are teen mothers and have not completed high school to return to school full time immediately after the birth of their child (previous to the passage of this policy most mothers were exempt from a forced return to school or workforce if their youngest child was under age 3 or in some state under 1 year of age). Additionally, FSA determined that if the teen mother at age eighteen or nineteen was failing to make appropriate progress in school, than the state could require her to participate in whatever work/training programs the state deemed appropriate. These policy changes clearly situate society’s interest in ensuring that the low-income teen mother will become economically self-sufficient. At the same time these policies work to take decision making away from the teen mother, and as the following section emphasizes, were particularly aimed at fixing the black family in the United States.
“Black Family” Discourse of the 1980s Key to policy debates and initiatives of the 1980s was a national focus on “the decline of the black family.” As noted previously crisis discourses and a culture of poverty ideology focused government attention—in the form of regulation and surveillance—upon the black family. The discursive construction of “the decline” and the “crisis of the Black family” yielded public and political discussions, and similar to epidemic talk surrounding teen pregnancy, called for government intervention in the black family. Prior to and during Reagan’s executive terms, he was highly influential in focusing public and policy attention upon the black, unwed mother through his construction of the “welfare queen.”89 Reagan’s depiction of the black, unwed mother who abuses the tax payer by cheating on and abusing the social welfare system became iconical. It did not matter that Reagan grossly overstated the case he initially based this image on, there did not need to be any specific proof of abuse, Reagan’s metaphor captured and reinforced public belief and sentiment. Although factually a myth, the image of the black welfare queen drove social welfare policy
42 • Unfit Subjects
discourse and further situated the black family in the United States as deficit.90 Amid heated social welfare policy debates of the mid-1980s and the airing of a Bill Moyer television show on the “vanishing” Black family, Ebony published a 1986 issue devoted to “the crisis of the Black family” calling it “perhaps the biggest crisis blacks have faced since slavery time.”91 The editors of Ebony noted that attention to the black family, dominated the Black and the Black/White dialogue in 1986, pushing all other issues to the side . . . day after night after day, the controversy raged, making 1986 the year of the Black family or, to be precise, the year of public discussion of the Black family.92
While the editors of Ebony clearly argued that the controversy “reflected the fears and misconceptions that have always surrounded discussions of Black sexuality”93 and linked a mourning of the “death of the Black family” to endemic and historical racism, they also stayed within national discourse about the problem of teen pregnancies and unwed mothering asking, “What can be done about children having children? How do we stop the alarming increase in the number of female-headed households?”94 Articles by Maya Angelou, Marian Wright Edelman, Alvin F. Poussaint, M.D., and Alex Haley attempted to rewrite a racialized and sexualized history for black Americans, but the articles and editorial comments remain focused upon mainstream sentiment noting the problems of unwed mothering and finding solutions in strengthening the presence of the two-parent heterosexual family unit in the black community. However, it is important to note that while the discourses around the problems of teen pregnancy and unwed mothering in this issue of Ebony are similar to popular ideology (e.g., that unwed mothering is bad and marriage is the solution), the authors in Ebony do propose different methods to achieve the solution of decreasing teen sexual activity and increasing marriage. While political social welfare policy discourse and public sentiment during the mid-1980s was focused upon the lack of responsibility of the (black) unwed welfare mother and the need for stringent controls and a reduction in support services that yield co-dependence, Ebony editors and authors call for means, such as improved access to quality education, mentoring, job training, livable wages, adequate housing, and health care. Yet, proposing different means to achieve the same goals was lost in the predominant crisis mode of political and public discourse. Further, a focus within Ebony upon the problems of the black family in language similar to that in mainstream media and political discourse continues to keep “The Black Family” as continually the focus of analysis, the lens through which to analyze and name the problems of unwed pregnancy
Constructing Teen Pregnancy as a Problem • 43
and social welfare abuse. The black family, and specifically the black woman, remains the visual image and discursive portrait of what is wrong in America. Although several researchers continued to point out that “teenage sexual activity, pregnancy and childbearing are not confined to poor, innercity populations” and that “rates of sexual activity among white teens have increased faster than rates among black teens, and the increase in births to unmarried teens is entirely attributable to whites,”95 public perceptions and policy discourse remained focused upon black unwed pregnancies. The strength of the discursive structure of the “crisis of the black family” is evidenced in how it has been attributed not only to low-income unwed black mothers but also to the now increasing rise of black female professionals, who similar to white middle-income women of the 1970s, often delayed marriage and childbearing. Consider the attention and debate created around Liz Walker, a prominent Black female anchorwoman in Boston, and her decision in 1987 to continue her pregnancy as an unwed woman and become a single mother. Ms. Walker, surprised at the amount of negative attention her decision caused, found herself located within and representative of a “new” crisis in the black family. Regardless of the fact that Liz Walker, who at that time was thirty-six and made over $500,000 annually, was not the unwed mother targeted by social policy, she was upheld as a symbol of the effects of shifting gender roles and lenient morals and policies that were leading to a decline of family values in the United States. The fact that she is black only added to the visibility of her downfall. Liz Walker was placed alongside the fictional Murphy Brown, the difference being she is black and thus accountable to and responsible for a crisis in the black family. 96 As a pastor from a church in east Boston summarized, “She is very attractive, very articulate and she is black.”97 Walker’s case also led to divided feminist responses, leaving feminist spokespeople talking about class and means as an indicator of responsible childbearing, noting that Liz Walker “knows she has enough to have a child” and citing the differences between “a mature, financially capable woman making a decision and an immature, financially incapable woman making a decision.”98 Thus while media coverage sought a black response that focused upon the problem of Walker’s (black) unwed mothering status, feminist responses ignored Liz Walker’s race, focusing solely upon her class status. This feminist construction of unwed mothering not only allowed a continued focus upon defining and naming “bad,” “incapable,” “irresponsible” unwed mothers as simply low-income mothers, but reinforced existing conservative political discourses that opened the way for sanctioned control of certain women’s sexuality and mothering.
44 • Unfit Subjects
Such polemical and emotional debates situate the discourses surrounding teen pregnancy as always occurring within debates around the role of women and the problems of unwed mothering. The linkages of the problems of unwed mothering with teen pregnancy continue today, allowing for assumptive discourses to prevail in descriptions and definitions of the teen mother as in the following statement: “given that the attributes ‘poor’ and ‘single-parent’ do a good job of describing the typical teenage family arrangement.”99 We, the public and policy makers, understand without having to be convinced that teen mothers are more likely to be abusive parents, neglectful, irresponsible, and less competent. The 1996 congressional hearings on teen pregnancy continued to situate the problems of teen pregnancy upon a “decline of the American family” with one witness noting “our current teen pregnancy crisis evolved over several generations when the social fabric became worn and tattered and began to unravel.”100 The teen mother in the hearings is described as “more likely to be uneducated, unskilled, unmarried, and caught in a cycle of poverty.”101 In these hearings, the linkage of this decline of family values remains firmly situated within the problems of the black community with several witnesses calling for bringing morality through “abstinence” into “public housing developments.”102 Dr. Foster, advisor to former President Clinton stated.“I tried to look at what might be considered middle-class values that were good” and he describes how he has taken kids to airports, Disney World, Washington D.C., and the “office of a multimillionaire in Atlanta.” When describing the impact of his programs he recalls the effect of a visit to an airport, But for those kids to see these marvelous machines glistening in the sun that can weigh 400,000 pounds at takeoff, to hear them, to see them, to see black pilots, to see women pilots, to see all these people going and coming, that creates a sense of excitement.103
The ideological construction of the black family and community as dysfunctional drove social policy talk in the 1980s and continues today. In this way, the black unwed mother continues to be linked with a host of social problems. However, attention to the black mother and the black family is not occurring out of some primary (white) national concern for the well-being of the black family, but rather has everything to do with the linkage of unwed mothering with economic costs to the United States.104 Citing the extensive economic costs of unwed teen mothers, a 1994 article makes a connection between teen parenting and “a weaker less-competitive economy,” noting that “given that our chief economic rivals, Japan and Western Europe, have much lowered teenage birthrates . . . teenage childbearing could also be viewed as a liability to America’s global economic competitiveness.”105
Constructing Teen Pregnancy as a Problem • 45
Thus while discourses of “declining family values” and “cultural breakdown” in the United States have been and are situated as a crisis for white America, debates about the causal factors of this crisis are located within the assumed dysfunction of the black family and community. Epidemic logic in response to this crisis yields interventions or regulation and control of the black family not simply because, as Dinesh D’Souza pointedly notes the “effects of cultural breakdown are particularly harsh and bitter when it comes to African Americans in general, and poor blacks in particular,”106 but to protect white families and communities from the unhealthiness of black families and communities. Epidemic logic reinforces strategic and regulatory interventions aimed at keeping the problems of black families from seeping into white culture. D’Souza further feeds epidemic logic when he situates the problems of the black family as attributable to all African Americans themselves citing their “very heavy and perhaps excessive reliance on government” and “a sometimes virtual paranoia that racism is to blame for all problems.”107 Such comments work to continually support an ideology of black families as dysfunctional and black individuals, particularly unwed black mothers, as lazy and irresponsible. The black community is not the only “minority” group presumed to be culturally inferior as evidenced in repeated remarks about Hispanics in the United States. In example, Dr. William Archer III, the health commissioner in Texas who has worked with President George W. Bush, and served under the President Bush Sr. as deputy assistant secretary of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, said in 2000 that “Hispanics lack that cultural belief that getting pregnant is a bad thing.”108 In this way, Latino/a communities, particularly immigrant and Mexican-American families, are situated as over-reproductive, producing large families, over-crowding and overwhelming schools with their specialized language “problems.” As the U.S. Latina/o population continues to grow and Latina teen pregnancy rates gain more public and policy scrutiny it is likely that further constructions of the Latina teen mother will be featured in public and political discourse. The implications in terms of policy and practice of the persistent racialization of teen pregnancy are explored throughout the remaining chapters. In the last section of this chapter I provide an overview of what the discourses structuring teen pregnancy have meant for education.
Where Is Education? The 1980s discursive focus upon a culture of poverty and a lack of morality and corresponding emphasis upon the black woman and black family, saw a clear shift away from a focus on educating the school-age mother, a shift that allowed other political initiatives to flourish. Indeed, funding for
46 • Unfit Subjects
agencies serving the educational needs of pregnant teens was cut in half during Ronald Reagan’s administration and the Office of Adolescent Pregnancy was refigured to provide information on and support to the promotion of sexual abstinence as official policy.109 The Reagan and Bush eras saw heightened attention to who should or should not be having sex, affirmed that such attention was our rightly moral concern, and increased focus and funding on preventing teen pregnancy through abstinence education, further portraying the pregnant teen girl as immoral, irresponsible, and a drain on society.110 Before assuming however that this shift in teen pregnancy as a social welfare problem was a partisan issue, we need only to look at what was said about teen pregnancy during the Clinton administration (1992–2000). Indeed, President Clinton named teen pregnancy as one of the “seven great challenges” facing the United States in his 1996 State of Union Address and that same year initiated a National Campaign to Reduce Teen Pregnancy.111 In a weekly radio address in 1996, President Clinton emphasized, “We have to make it clear that a baby doesn’t give you a right and won’t give you the money to leave home and drop out of school.”112 Clinton clearly linked “illegitimate births” with poverty, and situated the problem of teen pregnancy with welfare reform and the economic stability of the United States: “we want to talk about teen pregnancy, because it is a moral problem and a personal problem and a challenge that individual young people should face and because it has reached such proportions that it is a very significant economic and social problem for the United States.”113 Although in his speech announcing the National Campaign to Reduce Teen Pregnancy Clinton did mention education, it was linked to making “the most of their [teen parents] own lives in the work force or to succeed themselves as parents.”114 It is notable that of the twelve “leaders in the field of helping our young people” who would first run the campaign, only one came from the field of education, and this person was a university president.115 It is interesting and important to note that at the same time teen pregnancy was in the political and media limelight, education had become a noteworthy political and executive issue. Similar to the issue of teen pregnancy, the “failure” of U.S. public education was situated as a crisis in need of immediate and drastic response by four consecutive presidents. However, even amidst this heightened discussion of education for all, schoolage mothers did not become education subjects. Despite massive political and executive level attention to the status of education in the United States with publications such as A Nation at Risk, Goals 2000, and No Child Left Behind, discussions of educational policy affecting teen mothers had been effectively removed from the educational arena. Although the metaphor of
Constructing Teen Pregnancy as a Problem • 47
“crisis” referred to both the failure of education in the United States and the “epidemic of children having children,” the discourses defining teen pregnancy firmly situated teen pregnancy as a social welfare policy issue and thus outside of the education crisis. The emphasis and linkage of teen pregnancy with welfare reform led to dramatically decreased funding and attention to educational policy and educational programs for school-age mothers and further supported the practice of legislators, policy makers, and policy analysts outside the field of education to be the ones developing policy determining the purpose of education for school-age mothers, a trend that continues today.116 In this way, when education of teen mothers is discussed it is linked with training teen mothers to be economically self-sufficient. The teen mother’s sexual activity and pregnancy, particularly the low-income teen mother’s, make her first and always a welfare subject and an unfit subject for education. No where is this discourse more prevalent than in the Republican-sponsored “Contract with America” and the ensuing welfare reform act of 1996, the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act (PRWORA). The discursive emphasis in the Contract for America is clearly on protecting the tax-paying American citizen who is tired of paying for the irresponsibility and immorality shown by unwed mothers: Have an illegitimate baby and taxpayers will guarantee you cash, food stamps, and medical care, plus a host of other benefits. As long as you are single and don’t work, we’ll continue giving you benefits worth a minimum of $12000 a year. It’s time to change the incentives and make responsible parenthood the norm and not the exception. So we commit to under the THE PERSONAL RESPONSIBILITY ACT: Discourage illegitimacy and teen pregnancy by prohibiting welfare to minor mothers and denying increased AFDC for additional children while on welfare, cut spending for welfare programs, and enact a tough two-years-andout provision with work requirements to promote individual responsibility.117
The regulation of unwed teen pregnancy was by this time firmly situated as a legitimate social concern and more emphatically as a societal right. As a citizen I have the right to have my interests, fiscal and moral, protected by decreasing irresponsible unwed teen pregnancies. An Emmett, Idaho, prosecutor, concerned over high rates of teen pregnancy in his district, sought to bring charges against teen mothers (note that only women were the target of his prosecution) in 1996 using a 1921 Idaho law banning sex by unmarried persons, stated: “It is absolutely inarguable that the state has a compelling interest in preventing the transmission and spread of sexually transmitted diseases as well as preventing teen pregnancies”118 This “inarguable” interest became key to the passage of the most restrictive welfare reform package to date, the PRWORA of 1996, fostered under the tutelage of a Democratic president and a Republican congress.
48 • Unfit Subjects
PRWORA established a welfare block grant program, Temporary Assistance to Need Families (TANF), which specifically requires pregnant/parenting teens to live with a parent/guardian/approved adult and enroll and attend school. If teen parents do not meet these requirements they are not eligible for welfare assistance. Until TANF, under the 1988 FSA, states could individually decide whether to require and enforce educational activities for the school-age mother. Under TANF, states no longer have this choice; they must require school or training for the unmarried school-age mother (up to age eighteen or nineteen, although states may include older mothers in this requirement) who receives welfare assistance. TANF does allow for states to decide how to implement this requirement, including provision for the use of sanctions, typically in the form of reducing the family grant for school-age mothers who do not meet the school/training requirement. TANF also includes provision for states to further implement sanctions against out of wedlock births and set “family caps” that would deny assistance for additional births to an unwed teen mother already receiving TANF. PRWORA is also the first welfare reform policy to combine the twotiered approach to the problem of teen pregnancy in one policy. On the one hand, PRWORA through TANF regulates the low-income teen mother, while on the other hand PRWORA also includes policy and funding (nearly 500 million in federal and state funds) for an Abstinence Education Program, under the Maternal Child Health Block Grant, targeting all teens. Prior to 1996, abstinence education was handled under the Adolescent Family Life Program, as described above. The new 1996 program links social welfare funding with abstinence and legislates a set of themes for funded abstinence programs. States are not required to participate, but only one state did not participate in 1998.119 It is important to note that the funding for abstinence education available under PRWORA is for a specific type of abstinence education, that is abstinence-only meaning abstinence from unmarrried sex throughout life, and cannot be used in conjunction with other programs in a school that provide any information about contraceptives to unmarried teens. This law was passed even though there was and remains no research “providing clear evidence that abstinence-unless-married education helps reduce sexual activity or birth rates.”120 More dramatic to note is that 1996 legislation and funding came at a time when teen pregnancy rates were continuing to decline.121 What all of the welfare reform packages fail to acknowledge is that the burden of parenting with little resources—whether economic, health, or education—remains whether the low-income single mother is a teen mother or mother of twenty-four years. Some researchers have recently begun to question easily held assumptions between the causal effect of
Constructing Teen Pregnancy as a Problem • 49
teen pregnancy and poverty, arguing instead that more than 80 percent of teen mothers are living in poverty or near poverty long before they became pregnant.122 If these women just waited a few more years before having children, then they and society would be better off is an unfounded assumption. What if teen pregnancy does not cause poverty in single mothers but the social and structural inequities of single mothering overburdens all mothers? How do recent policies open access to opportunity for young women and low-income mothers? Caught up in epidemic discourses and logic, such questions have not been popular or even viable. The present administration’s “compassionate conservatism” does not look different from the previous two decades in its characterization of the unwed teen mother as irresponsible, culturally deficit, and in need of regulation and surveillance. At the same time it seems that access to and funding for contraceptive and abortion counseling will continue to be cut. President George W. Bush’s budget plan proposed ending a requirement that national health care programs provide reimbursement for multiple forms of contraceptives, including the birth control pill, the IUD, and the diaphragm.123 Further, President George W. Bush’s recent executive order to provide health care to all low-income women who are pregnant sets a tone for continued policy changes affecting the teen mother. Close examination reveals that President Bush’s plan, administered under the Children’s Health Insurance Program and seemingly compassionate in its attention to the lowincome woman, is not focused upon care of the unwed mother, but is focused upon the “unborn child.” Under Bush’s plan, in order for low-income mothers to receive health care during pregnancy, the definition of “child” would have to be expanded to include the unborn fetus, thus marking the beginning of “childhood” at conception, not birth. Such a move obviously opens the door for challenges to access and provision of abortion in the United States and this policy ignores the dearth of health benefits for low-income Americans. Further this move once again situates the unwed mother as not worthy of treatment herself—the state’s interest is not in her but in her innocent unborn child. Deborah Brake refers such polices as “fetuscentric” noting an increased focus on “fetuscentric” policy and case law.124 As Lynn Paltrow, director of National Advocates for Pregnant Women told a New York Times reporter, this maneuver to create insurance for unborn children both personifies the fetus and accentuates the fact that women themselves are neither full persons under the law, nor valued enough to be funded themselves.125
Thus, it seems the construction of the problem of unwed and teen mothers as unfit subjects and as a social welfare and taxpayer issue will continue. While the late 1990s saw a plethora of articles announcing a “steady drop
50 • Unfit Subjects
in teen birth rates” with Planned Parenthood, social welfare reform advocates, and abstinence-only groups each claiming victory for the results of their public messages and policy interventions, the “drop” is not so convincing when examined closely.126 While African-American teen girls’ birth rates did decline in the early 1990s, Caucasian birthrates decreased little, and Latina teen birthrates rose significantly. Further, part of the decrease in rates can be attributed to a smaller group of adolescent girls than in earlier decades meaning the myriad of social and welfare policies implemented in the early to mid-1990s cannot be effectively linked to any decrease in teen pregnancy birthrates. Given the current political climate, with a focus upon “homeland security” and the looming specter of war and “reconstruction,” and the Bush administration’s previous regulatory and limiting policies concerning women’s health and access to birth control, it seems unlikely that attention, time, and funding will be provided to analyze the decrease of teen pregnancy rates in the late 1990s. What seems more likely is that in a time of caution and fear, facing a stagnant economy and budget deficits, which in the past have led to increased rates of teen births, the public and policy makers will continue to rely upon epidemic ideology to determine what teen mothers need and deserve and which teen mothers are deserving and which are worthy only of control. The ramifications of thirty years of developing policy for unwed and teen mothers differentially by the race of the mother as a social welfare issue and a morality issue will be evident in the following chapters tracing what these shifting and highly racialized characterizations of teen pregnancy have meant for the education of pregnant/mothering teens.
Notes 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15.
See National Center for Health Statistics (1992). Vital statistics of the United States. Time. “Children having Children.” December 9, 1985. Lawson and Rhode, eds. The Politics of Pregnancy; Nathanson, Dangerous Passage. Campbell, Using Women, 42. Singer, Erotic Welfare. Rushing, “Sin, Sex, and Segregation,” 168. See Foucault, The Foucault Reader; Foucault, Discipline and Punish; Lugg, For God and Country; Rushing, “Sin, Sex, and Segregation,” 167–179. Singer, Erotic Welfare, 28. Singer, Erotic Welfare, 29. Singer, Erotic Welfare, 31. Singer, Erotic Welfare, 117, 118. Fraser, Unruly Practices, 159. Foucault, The Foucault Reader, 26. Fraser, Unruly Practices, 160. See Abramovitz, Regulating the lives of women; Gordon, Women, the State, and Welfare; Kunzel, Fallen Women, Problem Girls; Lawson and Rhode, The Politics of Pregnancy; Mink, The Wages of Motherhood; Nathanson, Dangerous Passage; and Solinger, Wake up Little Susie.
Constructing Teen Pregnancy as a Problem • 51 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23.
24. 25. 26. 27. 28.
29. 30. 31. 32.
33. 34.
35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41.
See specifically Kunzel, Fallen Women, Problem Girls; and Solinger, Wake up Little Susie. Wilson, Fifty Years’ Work with Girls, 22. By 1906 an American National Vigilance Committee was formed to investigate and prohibit white slave traffic. See Wilson, Fifty Years’ Work with Girls for full discussion. Wilson, Fifty Years’ Work with Girls, 71. Wilson, Fifty Years’ Work with Girls, 70. The “girls” at F.C. Homes were referred to as “inmates” by Barrett, Some Practical Suggestions on the Conduct of a Rescue Home, 13; and Wilson, Fifty Years’ Work with Girls, 508. For details on philosophy of F.C. Homes and details on how F.C. Homes should be managed see Barrett, Some Practical Suggestions. Barrett, Some Practical Suggestions, 19. Girls may also be dismissed from the home for revealing during pregnancy their intention to give their child up, “to put her child away and go back into sin” (Barrett, 49), then she is “not sincere in her heart” and “it would be purgatory to her to have to stay and hear the girls planning for their future with their children” (Barrett, 49). Barrett suggests that in such cases the girl herself “will come to you and say that she has decided to go somewhere else (Barrett, 49). Barrett, Some Practical Suggestions, 100. Florence Crittenton Mission Records (hereafter cited as NFCM papers), Social Welfare History Archives, University of Minnesota (hereafter cited as SWHA), Detroit News, February 16, 1915, “Does His Smile Appeal to You?” Box 20, Folder 5. See Kunzel, Fallen Women, Problem Girls; and Solinger, Wake up Little Susie. Wilson, Fifty Years’ Work with Girls, 89. It is important to note however that similar to the history of black education in the south (see Anderson, Education of Black in the South), many of the “negro” homes were controlled by local white boards. A July 1954 F.C. Field Reporter, noted: “the now independent organization of Little Rock’s Negro Florence Crittenton Home is in the process of developing an organization separate from that of the White Home. Previous to this time, it has been an Extension of the Little Rock Home [the white F.C. home]. This is being done with the assistance and cooperation of the “White Board,” who hold title to the property which will continue to be used for expanded services to Negro girls.” Florence Crittenton Association of American Records (hereafter cited as FCAA), SWHA, Field Reporter, July, 1954, Box 48, Folder 5. Solinger, Wake up Little Susie, 7. Solinger, Wake up Little Susie, 8–9. Solinger, Wake up Little Susie, 9. This situation also led to the prevalent belief that the black community is more accepting of unwed pregnancies. Because black unwed mothers could not avail themselves of programs for unwed mothers available to the white unwed mother, they were necessarily more visible and reliant upon family and community members. Although Solinger Notes in Wake up Little Susie that “it is striking how the black community organized itself to accommodate mother and child while the white community was totally unwilling and unable to do so,” (7) this “accommodation” was/is due to a history of institutionalized racism in the U.S., and should not be read as proof that the black community is more accepting, less concerned about, unwed pregnancies. Vinovskis, An “Epidemic” of Adolescent Pregnancy? The developmental stage, termed adolescent, and later known as “the teen years” also gained in study and popular perception. Now it would be hard to imagine educating, parenting, or providing consumer products and advertising without the teen in mind. For critical analysis of the construction of adolescence and our society’s dependency upon it see Lesko, Act Your Age. FCAA, SWHA Ninth Annual National Conference, 1959, Box 41, Folder 3 and by 1960 the F.C. Association was using the term “adolescent unmarried mother” in their annual reports, see Executive Director Reports, 1959–63, Box 35, Folder 6. FCAA, SWHA, Executive Director speech, 1959, Box 35, Folder 4. Vinovskis, An “Epidemic” of Adolescent Pregnancy?, 24. Vinovskis, An “Epidemic” of Adolescent Pregnancy? Lawson and Rhode, The Politics of Pregnancy, 3. Lawson and Rhode, The Politics of Pregnancy, 3–7; 244–48. Lawson and Rhode, The Politics of Pregnancy, 3–7; and Nathanson, Dangerous passage, 145–166; and Vinovskis, An “Epidemic” of Adolescent Pregnancy?, 29–37.
52 • Unfit Subjects 42. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48.
49. 50. 51.
52. 53. 54.
55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60. 61. 62. 63. 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69.
Alan Guttmacher Institute, 11 Million Teenagers. FCAA, SWHA, Eighth Annual National Conference Report, 1958, Box 40, Folder 8, p. 14. FCAA, SWHA, Public Relations, “The Sweet Potato Vine,” 1961, Box 52, Folder 5, p. ix of the productions notes. Kunzel, “Pulp Fictions and Problem Girls,” 1465–1487. FCAA, SWHA, see for example Public Relations Box 51 Folders 1–12 and Box 52, Folders 1–7. Mittelstadt, “Educating ‘our girls’ and ‘welfare mothers,’ “ 326–353; and Solinger, Wake up Little Susie, 65–76. FCAA, SWHA, Executive Director Report, 1963, p. 10, Box 35, Folder 6. The F.C. Association while focused upon the white mother also began to attempt to focus F.C. member homes on the “Negro” unwed mother. This may have been due to the ethic that underlied the program of serving all teen mothers, but this emphasis also foreshadowed a later need for F.C. to seek black mothers to serve when rates of white unwed mothers seeking home placement declined. An October 1954 Field Reporter ran a feature titled “Where are Negro unmarried mothers?” noting that several F.C. Homes provided service to all races, the article read, “There are three special services for Negro girls. We know the incidence of unmarried motherhood is reported to be higher among Negro girls. We know further that many of these girls are of a very high type and surely would benefit by a high type of service. Kansas City, Little Rock, and Topeka could well serve a larger number of girls who need positive assistance.” FCAA, SWHA, Field Reporter, October, 1954, Box 48, Folder 5. FCAA, SWHA, Executive Director Report, 1963, p. 3, Box 35, Folder 6. For report see Moynihan, The Negro Family. For ensuing debates about the report see Ryan, Blaming the Victim; Valentine, Culture and Poverty. While biracial births to black women were not tracked in F.C. Homes, biracial births were noted with alarm. The few cases where white mothers were not forthright about “the nature” of their child’s origin before birth, resulting in the “surprise” of a brown/black baby born in a white home, the mother was moved out of the home as soon as she was physically able. For history of fear of interracial sexual activity see Hodes, White Women, Black Men; Hodes, Sex, Love, Race. I am relying upon Mittelstadt’s insightful characterization of “our girls” in this analysis. See Mittelstadt, “Educating ‘our girls’ and ‘welfare mothers,’ “ Vinovskis, An “Epidemic” of Adolescent Pregnancy?, 22–46. For a thorough overview of this bill and others leading to the development of the 1978 Adolescent Health, Services, Pregnancy Prevention and Care Act, see Vinovskis An “Epidemic” of Adolescent Pregnancy? As cited in Hendrixson, “Pregnant Children,” 663. In 1976, the U.S. ranked fourth in rates of teen pregnancy among women aged 15–19, resulting in one million teen girls getting pregnant “59% carried to term (38% legitimate, 21% illegitimate), 27% had abortions, and 14% had miscarriages.” At that time East Germany, New Zealand, and Romania were ranked one thru three in number of teen births. Mittelstadt, “Educating ‘our girls’ and ‘welfare mothers,’ .” Mittelstadt, “Educating ‘our girls’ and ‘welfare mothers,’ “ 326. Stamm, “A skeleton in the closet,” 1203–1237. Stamm, “A Skeleton in the Closet.” Upchurch and McCarthy, “Adolescent Childbearing and High School Completion in the 1980s,” 199–202. Vinovskis, An “Epidemic” of Adolescent Pregnancy? Hendrixson, “Pregnant children,” 663. Children’s Defense Fund, “Preventing Children Having Children,” 1. Children’s Defense Fund, “Preventing Children Having Children,” 1. For overview of race and class and social policy in the U.S. see Conley Being Black, Living in the Red. “ ‘Welfare Queen’ becomes Issue in Reagan Campaign,” New York Times Feb. 15, 1976. Kenney and Orr, “Sex education,” 491. Children’s Defense Fund, “Preventing Children having Children,” 3. The Center for Population Options,“Adolescent Sexual Behavior, pregnancy, and Parenthood.” Furstenberg, Jr., Brooks-Gunn, and Morgan, Adolescent Mothers in Later Life; and Luker, Dubious Conceptions.
Constructing Teen Pregnancy as a Problem • 53 70. 71. 72. 73. 74. 75. 76. 77. 78. 79. 80. 81. 82. 83. 84. 85. 86. 87. 88. 89. 90. 91. 92. 93. 94. 95. 96.
97. 98. 99. 100. 101. 102. 103. 104.
105. 106. 107. 108. 109. 110.
Furstenberg, Jr. et. al, Adolescent Mothers in Later Life. Lesko, “Curriculum Differentiation as Social Redemption,” 121. Education Week, “Here They Come, Ready or Not,” 3. Lesko, “Curriculum Differentiation as Social Redemption,” 122. For further detail see Luker, Dubious Conceptions; and Lawson and Rhode, The Politics of Pregnancy. Lugg, For God and Country. For analysis of racial and racist discourses and impact upon social policy see: Omni and Winnant, Racial Formation in the United States from the 1960s to the 1990s; and Schram, Words of Welfare. McClain “Irresponsible’ Reproduction,” 339–372, 342. Nathanson, Dangerous Passage. Trudell, Doing Sex Education, 15. Welsh, “High School Confidential ‘91,” C1; C4. Lesko, “The ‘Leaky Needs’ of School-Age Mothers,” 183. Luker, Dubious Conceptions. Vinovskis, An “Epidemic” of Adolescent Pregnancy? Vinovskis, An “Epidemic” of Adolescent Pregnancy? Marshner, The New Traditional Woman, 9. In Vinovskis, An “Epidemic” of Adolescent Pregnancy?, 83. See e.g., McClain, “Irresponsible’ Reproduction,” and Mink The Wages of Motherhood. See Thomas, “Race, Gender, and Welfare Reform,” 419–446. “ ‘Welfare Queen’ becomes Issue in Reagan campaign,” New York Times, 1976. For discussion of the myth of the “welfare queen,” see Zucchino, Myth of the Welfare Queen. For discussion of linkage of black female with welfare, see Schram, Words of Welfare. Ebony publisher’s statement, “The Crisis of the Black Family,” 33. Ebony publisher’s statement, “The Crisis of the Black Family,” 33–34. Ebony, special issue, “The Crisis of the Black Family,” 30–78. Ebony publisher’s statement, “The Crisis of the Black Family,” 33. Kenney, “Teen Pregnancy,” 730. For articles on Liz Walker, see Cohen, “Significant Mothers,” W3; and Longcope, “Liz Walker is Expecting,” 9–10; Newsmakers, “Black Boston TV Anchor Goes Public on Pregnancy,” 32; and Trescott, “The War over motherhood,” C1, C10, C11; and For those who are not familiar with or do not recall Vice President Dan Quayle’s remarks about the unwed mothering status of fictional television character Murphy Brown, see “Dan Quayle vs. Murphy Brown,” Time, 20. Trescott, “The War over Motherhood,” C10. Trescott, “The War over Motherhood,” C11. Caldas, “Teen Pregnancy,” 403. U.S. Congress. Subcommittee on Human Resources and Intergovernmetnal relations. Preventing Teen Pregnancy, 20, 42. U.S. Congress. Subcommittee. Preventing Teen Pregnancy, 7, 14, 16, 45, 58. U.S. Congress. Subcommittee. Preventing Teen Pregnancy, 26. U.S. Congress. Subcommittee. Preventing Teen Pregnancy, 57. This would be a case of what Derrick Bell describes as “interest conversion”—when white America pays attention to issues affecting African Americans only when these issues impact upon white, dominant interests. Bell, “Brown v. Board of Education and the interest-convergence dilemma,” 518–33. Caldas, “Teen Pregnancy,” 404. D’Souza, “Improving Culture to End Racism,” 789. D’Souza, “Improving Culture to End Racism,” 789. As quoted in Herbert, “GOP ‘Big Tent’ Is Shrinking.” See e.g., Joffe, “Sexual Politics and the Teenage Pregnancy Prevention Worker in the United States,” 284–300; and Mittelstadt, “Educating ‘Our Girls’ and ‘Welfare Mothers.’ “ At the same time abstinence became official policy, funding for programs providing birth control information or availability were not only limited but cut out entirely, antiabortion activity, including often violent means, was at its height, and several initiatives were passed limiting adolescent’s access to birth control and abortion information through a so-called
54 • Unfit Subjects
111.
112. 113. 114. 115.
116. 117. 118. 119. 120. 121. 122. 123. 124. 125. 126.
“gag-rule” forbidding adults at, for example, Planned Parenthood to discuss such options with teens even if the teen requested such information. For analysis of discourses of abstinence education, see chapter 6. For text of the state of the union address, see New York Times, “Prepared Text for the President’s State of the Union Message,” A9; A14. The National Campaign to Prevent Teen Pregnancy is made up of a unique bipartisan mix of politicians, researchers, medical personnel, celebrities, and organizations typically on opposite sides of debates about teen pregnancy. The campaign sought to lessen the debates between groups and create a coalition that could agree on one issue: the goal of decreasing teen pregnancy in the U.S. The campaign has been active in producing media targeted toward teens and in promoting a “pregnancyfree adolescence.” As quoted in, Vobejda, “President Limits Teens on Welfare,” A1. Clinton, “Remarks Announcing the National Campaign to Reduce Teen Pregnancy.” Clinton, “Remarks Announcing the National Campaign to Reduce Teen Pregnancy.” The members included: a former Surgeon General; a Carnegie Corporation representative; a former governor, two former senators, and a mayor; a representative from a pharmaceuticals company with a major interest in birth control products; a medical doctor active in teen pregnancy prevention; a representative from the Urban Institute; two members from the entertainment sector including the then president of MTV and Whoopi Goldberg; and as mentioned the president of Drew University. See Burdell, “Teen Mothers in High School,” 163–207; Weatherly, Perlman, Levine, and Klerman, Patchwork Programs; and Vinovskis, An “Apidemic” of Adolescent Pregnancy? For overview of PRWORA see Weinstein, “The Teenage Pregnancy ‘Problem’,” 117–152. July 6, 1996, www.aclu.org. State Policy Documentation Project, Summary of Policy Issues, 12. Levin-Epstein, Teen Parent Provisions in the New Law; see also, Weinstein, “The Teenage Pregnancy ‘Problem’,”117–152. Between 1991 and 1995 teen birth rates decreased 8 percent; birth rates to all women decreased 6 percent, Levin-Epstein, Teen Parent Provisions in the New Law. See e.g., Luker, Dubious Conceptions. Farmer, “NOW Challenges President Bush to Abide by Federal Court Ruling on Contraceptive Coverage.” Brake, “Legal Challenges to the Educational Barriers Facing Pregnant and Parenting Adolescents,” 141–155. As quoted in Herbert, “Sneak Attack,” A27. For a sampling of such articles and suppositions, see “Steady Drop in Teen Birth Rate Has Many ‘Proud Parents’,” A12:1; Lewin, “Birth Rates for Teen-Agers Declined Sharply in the 90s,” A27:4; Terry, “Fewer Teen-Age Mothers? Maybe,” A18:4; Stolberg, “Birth Rate at New Low as Teen-Age Pregnancy Declines,” A26:3.
CHAPTER
2
Title IX and the Discursive Climate of Education for School-Age Mothers On this important day, President Bush and I join in celebrating the success and the spirit of Title IX that says, “Open to all.” —U.S. Secretary Rod Paige You show, you go. —Principal Stevens, Boston Public
In July 2002, U.S. Secretary Rod Paige announced the thirtieth anniversary of Title IX noting that “Title IX has opened many doors of opportunity to generations of women and girls to achieve, to compete, and to pursue their American Dream.” Secretary Paige’s comments lacked a celebratory tone for women’s rights groups as his statement was followed by an announcement of a committee of experts to look at the “explosive growth” in women’s sports and evaluate what is currently “fair” under Title IX for those “facing the difficult issues in athletics every day.”1 Couching a review of Title IX under a discourse of “fairness” and “open to all” justifiably makes many civil rights advocates nervous given President Bush and his administration’s interpretations of fairness and equal opportunity. However, of equal importance in Paige’s announcement was the absence of any attention to the educational gender equity components of Title IX, including the protection of pregnant/mothering students. While press statements noted that Title IX prohibits discrimination on the basis of sex, no media coverage in press, television, or radio ever mentioned the 55
56 • Unfit Subjects
protection of the right of the teen mother to equal educational opportunity. It seems that even on the anniversary of Title IX teen mothers remain the unmentionables and unknowns of Title IX. Does “open to all” include pregnant/mothering students? Compare the politicized introduction to Title IX with the above statement made by principal Stevens, a character on the television show Boston Public (which depicts the daily lives of students and adults in an urban public high school) to a white honor-student, who after fainting during an interview with representatives of Yale University, found out she was pregnant. The student who was applying to Yale seemingly was forced to have to choose between an education and a future or having her child and dropping out of school. In this episode, the student under the stress of this polemical decision had an abortion. Principal Stevens, although grieved by her decision, sticks to his belief that teen mothers do not belong in regular public school settings. Principal Stevens’ sentiment of “you show, you go” is reminiscent of a long-standing practice of dismissing pregnant girls from their regular school regardless of Title IX.2 This episode of Boston Public not only captures this sentiment but also reinforces beliefs that teen mothers do not have a right to an education and that such decisions are left up to a local school administrator. Compare this modern story of the unwed, pregnant teen to an actual case of a pregnant teen in 1971. In 1971, Fay Ordway, an honor student and yearbook editor, was expelled from her high school because she was unmarried and pregnant. The basis for the schools decision was that she would “contaminate” other students. Ordway challenged her school’s decision and at the district court level won the right to attend school but was banned from the National Honor Society and lost a college scholarship she had been promised.3 The legacy of the Ordway decision continues as many school-age mothers find that while public schools cannot deny them access to an education per se, they can and do limit their educational opportunities, by restricting or barring their ability to participate in a range of educational activities. These practices continue, and are dramatized in our media as standard behavior, despite being thirty years into Title IX mandates of equal educational opportunity for all female students, including pregnant/mothering teens. How does this occur? Why have schools not been more compelled under Title IX to provide an equal education to teen mothers? Addressing these questions includes once again understanding teen pregnancy as a historical, social, economic, and moral issue in the United States and situating the education of teen mothers within the discourses surrounding teen pregnancy. Although Title IX clearly requires that pregnant/mothering students have access to equal education, what this entails has not been
Title IX and the Discursive Climate of Education for School-Age Mothers • 57
determined under case law, leaving the interpretation up to individual schools. Presently, beyond forbidding expulsion, there is no case law to enforce or guide the provision of educational services for teen mothers at the local or state level.4 Schools and school communities, working in the discursive climate surrounding schooling for teen mothers, continue to question and challenge whether teen mothers fit in public schools and which teen mothers are fit for an education. Analyzing the impact of Title IX on the education of pregnant/mothering teens cannot be separated from societal and politicized views on the problem of teen pregnancy. This chapter addresses the broader questions and issues of what has influenced the implementation of Title IX’s call for the education of school-age mothers. Here I am interested not only with the impact of Title IX as it might be measured in terms of numbers of pregnant teens attending and graduating school. I am also interested in the discursive impact of Title IX—that is how the implementation of Title IX is impacted by what is said and what is presumed about pregnant/mothering teens as students and how the language of Title IX affects how we think about and characterize equal education opportunity for pregnant/mothering teens. This focus builds from the discussion in chapter 1 and foregrounds how the provision of education to school-age mothers occurs within a social, political, economic, and moral climate. This climate not only discursively constructs the pregnant/mothering teen, but also shapes the development, interpretation, and implementation of educational policy for the pregnant/mothering teen. A discursive analysis of the climate surrounding the education of pregnant/mothering teens reveals two prominent themes in the provision of education to school-age mothers. These themes are prevalent in the language of existing court decisions that affect the provision of education to pregnant/mothering students and contribute to a discursive policy climate surrounding teen mothers and schooling. Presences and absences within these themes are equally important to identify as policy is impacted by both what we think we know and what we do not even acknowledge, what “we cannot bear to know.” The first theme I call “discourses of contamination,” discourses that justify removal of the school-age mother from the school setting based upon the fear that her sexual immorality will spread to other students. The second theme, “differentiated subjects,” involves a division and shift between discourses and policies that view education for the pregnant/mothering teen as a right and those that view it as a responsibility. Together these themes organize a discursive climate affecting interpretation and implementation of case law and educational policy under Title IX. Common to both themes is a shifting construction of the problem of teen pregnancy
58 • Unfit Subjects
based upon the race of the teen mother that has yielded a two-tiered system of educational policy and practice. However, this chapter also demonstrates that even the most entitled pregnant teen—the white, high-achieving mother—has had severe limitations placed upon her educational opportunity. In later chapters, I take up what this means for the “other” teen mother, the African Americans and Latinas, who utilize school-based teen pregnancy programs at a higher rate than white teen mothers. Yet it is important to note that in this chapter low-income and racialized teen mothers are also clearly marked by their absence as subjects in case law, an absence that defines who the racialized teen mother is and thus what education she deserves and is capable of.
Laying a Foundation for Title IX—Tracing Key Arguments Supporting Education of Young Unwed Mothers As early as 1929, a decision was made in the Kansas Supreme Court ordering a school district to allow a married school-age mother to continue her education at the public school.5 By 1969, the fourteenth amendment guarantee of equal protection had been used to defend the right of the unwed school-age mother to attend school.6 Key to these decisions and a key issue of debate was the status of the teen mother as single, as unwed, and a protection of the right of the school-age mother to receive an education regardless of her marital status. However, not until Title IX was the teen mother’s right to an education, regardless of her marital status guaranteed. Prior to the passage of Title IX, the F.C. Association was actively involved in supporting the necessity of the unwed teen mother to receive an education during her pregnancy, either at an F.C. Home or day school, and to return to her regular school after the birth of her child. By the late 1950s, F.C. Homes were noting an increase in the number of “young unwed mothers,” thus focusing the attention of the association upon the educational needs of these women.7 However, as early as 1929, one F.C. Home superintendent reported sending her young girls to public school to “finish their eighth grade at least.”8 At the 1960 Annual Meeting of the F.C. Homes Association several papers focused upon the debates surrounding whether to offer young unwed mothers continuing education and if so, how to offer it. These papers noted the benefits of providing education to the unmarried teen mother, including “profound health, mental health, and educational influences upon her mother, her family, and future family” and a lessening of “community problems when unmarried mothers are encouraged to continue in school.” Speakers also commented upon the observance that “many unmarried mothers are exceedingly receptive to educational needs” and that
Title IX and the Discursive Climate of Education for School-Age Mothers • 59
“unmarried mothers rarely create special school problems by returning to regular classes in public schools while relatives or others take care of their babies during the day.”9 This shift from separating the unwed mother from society to promoting her integration into public schools (at least after the birth of her child), was partly influenced by “rapid changes in attitudes toward morals.” As the Executive Director of F.C. noted in 1968: The old concept of a maternity home, which essentially through its insistence on confidentiality denied the pregnancy, is disappearing, and while confidentiality is still needed for a comparatively small number of unmarried mothers, the need for secrecy is decreasing. The winds of change are bringing new concepts and the necessity of agencies to rethink their programs, so they can use their resources most effectively to meet the needs of local communities.10
During the late 1960s other advocacy groups such as the National Council on Illegitimacy (NCI) had become involved in changing societal attitudes toward the unwed mother and in supporting the right of education for the young unwed mother. NCI personnel offered nationwide inservice training for public school teachers and administrators on how to retain and offer continuing education to the pregnant/mothering teen.11 By 1968, NCI adopted a “Policy Statement on Continued Schooling for Pregnant Girls and Young Mothers” that advocated “the right to continued public education for all pregnant girls and young mothers.” NCI’s policy contains language that is similar to what is introduced in Title IX four years later and is thus worth quoting at length: Recognizing that educational opportunities are part of the value system of a free society, and recognizing further that education in our increasingly complex and technological society is a prerequisite for the opportunity to lead a full and productive life, NCI advocates the right to continued public education for all pregnant girls and young mothers. The pregnant girl and young mother has or should have the legal right to continued schooling in regular school classes. In the event that an individual pregnant student wishes to withdraw from her home school during pregnancy, the public school system alone, or in conjunction with other community institutions, has an obligation to furnish her with separate facilities, educationally centered, and enriched through health and welfare services.12
What is unique in NCI’s statement is the focus upon the right of the unwed pregnant girl to remain in a public school during her pregnancy and the right to continued provision of educational services should she decide to withdraw. NCI’s policy required substantive changes to the public school system. NCI outlined eight substantive changes needed in school policy in order for the unwed pregnant/mothering student to gain access
60 • Unfit Subjects
to education. These changes included a dramatic shift in school responsibility for the teen mother: School systems will accept responsibility for pregnant girls and young mothers beyond the statutory limit of school attendance. They will seek these girls out and attempt to motivate them to complete schooling.13
NCI’s policy notes the growing difference in the practices at the F.C. Homes and at the public schools. The pregnant teen mother was removed from the public school while she was pregnant, had her child, and then returned to her home and regular school “ready to return to her uninterrupted life.”14 This model of service provision to the unmarried young mother continued to separate the pregnant girl from the school environment while she was at the height of her pregnancy, and only returned her to school when she was “regular” and “fit” again. However, the barriers to public school attendance for the unwed teen mother, who has already given birth and either kept or put her baby up for adoption, cannot be underestimated. The F.C. Association worked to challenge such barriers. Although F.C. notes provide evidence that the association supported education for the pregnant young mother, education that took place either at an F.C. home or in day school, the association’s emphasis was initially upon gaining access to education for the unmarried young mother. The roadblocks encountered by a young unwed mother trying to access education were identified in a paper presented at the 1960 F.C. Annual Meeting are similar to many present-day attitudes toward pregnant/mothering teens. Consider the following comments identified as prevalent in 1960 even by “generally substantial and intelligent persons”: “Why award them for the problems they have brought upon themselves and society?” “I would not want them to attend school with my daughter.” “Let them spend their time taking care of their babies.” “They’ve had an opportunity to go to school and will have plenty of opportunity for future education through correspondence courses, and adult night school classes.” “Very few of these girls have placed any real value on school work.”“Some of these girls have become mothers deliberately for the purpose of escaping school.” “The school budget does not allow for special education services for them.” “A mother can no longer be considered a school child.”15
Such comments and the ideology behind them can be heard throughout this book identifying the discourses that continue to affect and impact pregnant/mothering students’ access to education. Despite such roadblocks, organizations such as the F.C. Association and NCI continued to stress the benefits education provided for the young unwed mother and for society. Speaking of the problems and challenges
Title IX and the Discursive Climate of Education for School-Age Mothers • 61
facing unwed young mothers and acknowledging the threat and disruption society feels, as well as public schools history of “a continuing barrage of criticism” leading to a “schoolman who is harried and beset,” the presenter of a 1963 speech to NCI still argues for the “uninterrupted education of unwed mothers” as a way to reduce “the amount of fumbling and to suggest ways of working together more effectively.”16 Education for teen mothers was situated as a cure for the young unwed mother herself, for her child, and for society: This problem [young unwed mothers] grows out of social disorganization and individual maladjustment. If we neglect it, it will continue to fester and spread contamination. The healing process will call for better social organization and the development of more adequate individuals. And, fortunately the process of healing is also the process of prevention.17
Were the hopes and expectations of associations such as F.C. and NCI realized? A review of what Title IX says about the education of pregnant/mothering students reveals the influence of such associations on the development of policy affecting the education of teen mothers. However, a closer look at the implementation of Title IX policy also makes apparent the limits placed on the access to equal educational opportunity for teen mothers and continues to raise questions about whether schools have enacted the substantive changes necessary for pregnant/mothering students to access equal education opportunity or, whether it is the teen mother herself who remains the target of change, requiring the teen mother to make herself fit for an education.
Title IX and the Mandate to Provide Education for School-Age Mothers Title IX specifically addresses the right of the school-age mother to equal access to an education equivalent to her peers. Although few are aware, Title IX, passed in 1972 and effective July 12, 1975, provides specific provision and language governing schooling for school-age mothers. Title IX states: [A] recipient [of federal funding] shall not discriminate against any student, or exclude any student from its education program or activity, including any class or extracurricular activity, on the basis of such student’s pregnancy, childbirth, false pregnancy, termination of pregnancy or recovery therefrom, unless the student requests voluntarily to participate in a separate portion of the program.18
Furthermore, Title IX requires that any separate facility set up for teen mothers in addition to being voluntary must be “comparable to that offered to nonpregnant teens.”19 Additionally Title IX provides specific language regarding the handling of absences for the pregnant teen, noting
62 • Unfit Subjects
that the pregnant teen must be treated the same as any student with a medical condition or disability.20 If a school does not have a policy in place for such students they must abide by the doctor’s orders for the student. This means the teen mother should have excused absences, access to make-up work or tests, or in the case of long-term absences, be given a grade based on what she did complete of the school semester instead of failing the student and requiring her to repeat the class. Similarly, accommodations must be made for the pregnant student to participate in the school day without discrimination based upon her condition. For example, such accommodations may include extra time to get to classes, the provision of appropriate seating, and access to bathroom breaks as needed.21 It seems given the explicitness of Title IX that case law determining the intricacies of what it means to have access to equal education opportunity, what constitutes “voluntary,” what “comparable” or “equivalent” education is, and which daily practices of schools are discriminatory, would be prevalent. However, at present there is no case law addressing implementation issues under Title IX. While there have been several recent cases on the access school-age mothers have to extracurricular activities and National Honor Society membership, no cases concerning their access to an equal education during the school day have been heard in federal or district court. Anecdotal evidence suggests that challenges by students may be settled at the school district level, however, complaints to the Office of Civil Rights remain low.22 Legal challenges are lengthy, time consuming, and costly, and many teen mothers may not be aware of their educational rights or have the support to challenge local district practices. Monica Stamm also notes that the “temporary nature of pregnancy” may be a reason for the lack of legal decisions around teen pregnancy. As she states, “by the time a suit could be brought and won, not only is the case moot because the student can return to the regular school program, but the student is more likely to lose interest in pursuing a law suit when she is dealing with pregnancy and motherhood.”23 Stamm assumes in this statement that all teen mothers do gain access to their regular school program upon birth of their child, an assumption that does not hold for all teen mothers. Regardless, the absence of case law on the education of school-age mothers speaks loudly about the status of education for teen mothers and means that decisions on what to do with pregnant/mothering students continue to be left up to individual school districts. A lack of case law under Title IX should not be taken as an assumption that schools are adhering to Title IX.24 As with other school equity issues, it is often difficult to gather evidence to pursue a suit and as Stamm notes the temporary nature of pregnancy makes pursuing a case even more difficult.
Title IX and the Discursive Climate of Education for School-Age Mothers • 63
Public rights groups such as the ACLU and the Women’s Rights Project have been gathering and tracking anecdotal facts concerning discrimination toward school-age mothers. Sources at these groups note that their involvement has caused some policies to change without going to trial.25 However, for all of the situations they do hear of, it is likely there are many more cases that are not pursued or are settled “quietly” within the school district.26 Why have pregnant/mothering students remained so silenced as legal and educational subjects? Two themes have shaped the discursive legal climate surrounding education for teen mothers and have impacted the development and implementation of educational programs for them. These discourses work to define responses to the question of what education for teen mothers should look like under Title IX. Although I discuss the two themes separately below, it will become apparent that they work together to shape discourses about the problem of teen pregnancy and the role of education plays in addressing it.
Discourses of Contamination: Pregnancy as Dis(ease) Historical and present-day debates on the education of school-age mothers contain a common theme of contamination. This theme circulates the idea that the presence of a sexually active female student (as a pregnant student or as a mother) will contaminate the student body leading to an epidemic of immoral and promiscuous behavior. Contamination discourse inscribes pregnancy as an illness and females as the contaminators. Fear and control of women’s sexuality has a long history. Women’s sexuality and reproductivity have been described as pathological, as mystical, but in either case women’s sexuality and sexual activity is to be regulated and controlled.27 While arguably sexual mores have changed in the United States, female sexuality remains paradoxically both apparent and hidden. Apparent because female sexuality remains at the forefront of marketing and consumption and hidden because knowledge of much of women’s lives and sexuality in terms of physical functioning and pleasure remains underresearched, and taboo. While talk of male functioning and pleasure is prevalent in popular culture and sex education curricula, marking this knowledge as important for both females and males, there is no corresponding discussion of female sexuality, particularly in U.S. sex education curricula—female sexuality remains hidden, mysterious, missing.28 Teen girls are caught in this mire of confusing and conflicting images and messages about female sexuality and women’s roles and a “good girl/bad girl” discourse still pervades teen talk.29 Adolescent sexuality is confusing not only for adolescents but also for adults. Teen sex raises fear
64 • Unfit Subjects
in parents, school personnel, and policy makers. Teen pregnancy in its embodiment is evidence that adolescent sexuality has not been contained and the pregnant teen body causes discomfort, morally and viscerally.30 The very term “teen pregnancy” indicates a pregnancy that is marked as wrong and teen pregnancy carries a heightened sense of surveillance with it. To state the obvious, the pregnant body of the teen girl is visual evidence of what we fear and her changing, swelling, leaking body becomes the target and repository of these fears and beliefs. Thus it is this body, the pregnant teen body, which we seek to control and contain, because the evidence of this body is literally in front of us. Discourses of contamination are one form of containment of the pregnant teen body. As noted in chapter 1, one key discourse of contamination, an epidemic discourse created out of a climate of crisis, has surrounded teen pregnancy from the passage of Title IX. Title IX and other federally funded education initiatives for teen mothers occurred under a climate of crisis—an epidemic of “children having children.” Although at the height of this climate of crisis births to teen mothers were at their lowest since the 1950s the discursive image of an epidemic of teen pregnancy was accepted and recirculated by policymakers, media, and the public. As noted in chapter 1, what had shifted during the 1970s and 1980s was the increasing rate of unwed teen mothers—specifically white unwed mothers, a growing sense of a lack of family values, fear of societal changes affected by Civil Rights, and conservative responses to the crisis of education.31 However, regardless of the lack of an “epidemic” in the rate of teen births, epidemic logic prevailed in the public mind and social welfare policy. Here I trace how epidemic logic, fed by contamination discourses, which support practices of separation and containment, made necessary practices of “separate but equal” in educational policy and practice for pregnant/mothering teens.
Early Decisions—Setting the Stage for “Separate but Equal” Epidemic logic and the fear of contamination have been effectively used in case law and school practice. Despite the language of Title IX, discourses and practices of contamination pervade development and implementation of educational policy for school-age mothers. Contamination was a prevalent theme in cases prior to Title IX, thus laying a foundation for this discourse and its ensuing practices to continue. The cases and issues traced below point out how insidious contamination discourse is; one cannot shake off contamination, it pervades and often overrides policies like Title IX. A 1969 decision, Perry v. Grenada Municipal Separate School District, upheld the school board’s “fear that the presence of unwed mothers in the
Title IX and the Discursive Climate of Education for School-Age Mothers • 65
schools will be a bad influence on the other students” and granted the board’s discretion to determine “whether an unwed mother has requisite moral character to be readmitted to school.”32 While in 1971, Faye Ordway won her case, affirming her right to attend her own public school, with the court stating “it would seem beyond argument that the right to receive a public school education is a basic personal right or liberty,” a year later, a Decatur, Georgia student was expelled from attending day classes in her public school.33 The school district successfully argued that the student’s presence in school during the day would “contaminate the other students” and that the pregnant student could receive an equal education by attending nighttime GED classes.34 Key to the Court’s decision was an acknowledgment of the school board’s compelling interest in maintaining a “safe environment” for other students. The Court decided based upon an ideology of “contamination” that the pregnant student presented such a threat to the student body as a whole that the school district was justified in removing the student from attending school.35 Furthermore the Court concluded that “there is no dispute that some students who marry or who become parents are normally more precocious than other students. . . . Because of their precociousness, it is conceivable that their presence in a regular daytime school could result in the disruption thereof.”36 An article by Donald Warren in the October 1972 issue of Phi Delta Kappan provides details of a case in Indiana of a student “poor, white, and eighteen years old,” who attempted to challenge local school policy which stated, “an unwed expectant mother shall report her condition to the girls’ counselor and withdraw from school when the fact is known and before it becomes obvious.”37 The policy further detailed that although the teen mother “may reenter school following the birth of the child” and that school staff would work to “rehabilitate her toward a successful life,” her attendance at school would be allowed only as “her conduct is acceptable and her presence is compatible with the welfare of the group.”38 This Indiana policy existed to protect the student body at large from contamination by the unwed pregnant teen and night school was considered a suitable and reasonable alternative for girls who were pregnant. However, in the case of this student, Donna, the night school was located far away, and she could not afford transportation costs, the night school also did not offer the courses she needed for graduation. Donna and her mother fought for her right to continue to attend her regular school during the day, beginning with hearings with the local school superintendent. Warren succinctly described the 1972 meeting: a young woman and her mother, not as nervous as one might expect, trying with limited vocabularies and poise to convince the officials, all male, educated
66 • Unfit Subjects and articulate, that they did not wish to undermine the values, order, and majority needs of the school but only to protect the young woman’s right to an education. That objective, commonplace and patently acceptable when stated abstractly, challenged long-accepted definitions of American public school roles and functions because the student involved was pregnant and unmarried.39
Warren identifies the key question to be asked in these hearings: “Does pregnancy constitute a valid reason for excluding a student from school?” and notes that instead the discussion centered around Donna’s capabilities as a student (“mediocre . . . with a poor attendance record”), her affect on other students, and concerns for her own safety. This last concern came in spite of testimony by a doctor that she was in “good health” and that “the regular activity involved in attending classes would be beneficial to her and the fetus.”40 Looking at such cases provides a glimpse of the narrative reasoning used to justify practices of dismissal for pregnant/mothering teens. These cases are also important because they lay a foundation for and lend support to practices of separate but equal in the provision of education for school-age mothers. Further these cases support an ideology of contamination that requires separation of the school-age mother for the protection of the student body as a whole. The most common provision of education to teen mothers is through placement into separate classrooms or separate schools.41 I explore the question of how voluntary such placements are in chapter 4 and address what these separate settings may offer the teen mother in terms of pedagogy and curriculum in chapter 5, but it is important here to understand that placing pregnant teens in separate schools has reflected the public school’s desire to keep them out of sight rather than sound pedagogical reasoning. Discourses of contamination continue to be prevalent in present-day discourse surrounding teen pregnancy. Barbara Whitehead in a 1994 article in The Atlantic Monthly called for a “return” to policies that would “‘uglify’ unwed teenage motherhood and reestablish some of the disincentives that worked in the past; including separation of the girl from her peer group.”42 The argument, although misinformed, is popular. That somehow there were “disincentives” in “the past” that worked, is not supportable— what is different is that school-age teen mothers are more visible now and have a right under Title IX to continue in their regular school. Ignoring the presence of Title IX, Whitehead elaborates what she means by “separation of the girl from her peer group”: [P]erhaps teen mothers should attend special high schools, as they do in some cities, rather than mixing with the general high school population. This contemporary version of being “sent away”—although it would not interrupt education—would segregate teenage mothers from nonpregnant teenagers.43
Title IX and the Discursive Climate of Education for School-Age Mothers • 67
Whitehead’s recommendation, reinforcing contamination logic, is made without reference to either the legalities of Title IX or the lack of any evidence that the presence of teen mothers spreads the problem of teen pregnancy. What is important here is that a discourse of contamination is more powerful than what we know or what we think we know. I found that discourses of contamination to be most prevalent in schools that have programs for teen mothers, despite that the data from these very schools does not indicate an increasing number of teen girls getting pregnant.44 Rather, what did change in such schools were the increased number of teen girls who stay or return to school when they are pregnant, thus making teen pregnancy more visible. Discourses of contamination are a response to a conflicting desire within education—we want teen mothers to be responsible and get an education but we do not want them to do it where we can see them. However, while discourses of contamination certainly create the justification and necessity of separate schools and classrooms for teen mothers I have argued that while teachers and students at separate school settings are more able to set their own climate, teachers and students within the regular school feel that they are under constant surveillance. For instance, it is not only adults who identify and participate in discourses of contamination, but teen mothers also identify discourses of contamination.45 Contamination discourse yields practices of control, separation, and surveillance within the regular school. The regulatory control of surveillance perpetuates the idea that teen mothers do not belong in this school and that teen mothers are “dangerous.” For example, one teen mother who served in a teen pregnancy classroom in a regular public school notes: they treat us like we’re different and you get watched twice as closely. Mrs. (her teacher) says we have to set a good example, that some people think we should not even be in school.
A teacher for a school–based teen pregnancy class in a similar school supports the above student’s characterization, stating: we have to keep it very quiet that we are here. I am not allowed to hang a banner or flier up saying this is a teen pregnancy classroom. Some of the teachers (in this school) do not even know I am here. I cannot go into other classes and talk about the program to the kids—so the girls really have to find me.
Such comments by pregnant/mothering students and teachers who work with them acknowledge that contamination discourses impact local practices when pregnant girls are “allowed” to remain in regular school settings. Schools often attempt to handle the visibility and contamination of teen girl’s pregnancies by encouraging removal of pregnant girls from the school setting. Some entitled students will return to the regular school setting as mothers, however, as discussed below, such girls have recently been
68 • Unfit Subjects
found to be continually infectious due to their pregnancy and mothering status.
National Honor Society Cases—Are Smart Girls Contaminated? Present-day discourses of contamination are also found in the recent attention to cases of teen mothers’ access to extracurricular and club activities. For instance, some school districts have been challenged on policies prohibiting pregnant/mothering students from membership and participation in cheerleading squads, National Honor Societies, student councils, and debate teams. What is interesting about these cases is that they focus upon “high-achieving” white teen mothers—teen mothers who are “good” students and active in school organizations. Yet, a discourse of contamination is also found in these cases. While a 1984 seventh circuit court decision held that a student’s dismissal from the National Honor Society (NHS) on account of her pregnancy violated Title IX, recent decisions have found otherwise.46 Consider for instance a 1990 decision by the third circuit court, that upheld a local NHS chapter’s discretion to terminate a pregnant/mothering student’s membership, while teen fathers are thus far exempt from such limitations.47 The court’s decision was based on the finding that the local NHS chapter had dismissed the female student not due to her pregnancy (and was thus not pregnancy/sex discrimination), but due to her engagement in premarital sexual activity, behavior regarded as not upholding the high standards required by NHS.48 The court found it within NHS “discretion to determine that a student’s premarital sexual activity was ‘contrary to the qualities of leadership and character essential for membership’ which includes upholding ‘high standards of moral conduct.’”49 Although this NHS chapter was able to determine this student had been sexually active due to her pregnancy, it could not determine if other students (male and female) had also been sexually active. Still the court decided that such factors did not matter in this decision.50 Although her pregnancy had made her sexual activity apparent, the school district and the court continued to state that the student was dismissed for her premarital sexual activity not her pregnancy. This decision paved the way for other school districts to exclude pregnant/mothering students due to their sexual activity, and thus avoid charges of discrimination. After this case made the news, the ACLU had numerous reports of other such dismissals.51 A 1998 case brought in Williamston, Kentucky, also involved the dismissal of two white students from the NHS due to their premarital sexual activity, not their pregnancies, which would be discrimination under the law.52 Thus in the 1990s, the pregnant/mothering teen, even the high-achieving (white) student, is still seen as immoral, and morally infectious. The
Title IX and the Discursive Climate of Education for School-Age Mothers • 69
above court decisions point to a continuing discrepancy between how sexually active girls are treated versus sexually active boys. While a boy’s sexual activity is not apparent, a pregnancy makes apparent and visible a teen girl’s sexual activity, thus exposing her to regulatory consequences. These cases suggest the legal decisions surrounding teen pregnancy are influenced more by societal morality and beliefs surrounding female sexuality than by case law.53 In response to these cases, the ACLU ran an advertisement campaign to draw attention to such inconsistencies affecting these “high-achieving” teen mothers (see figure 4). The full-page advertisement ran in the New York Times and The New Republic in 1998 with the headline, “Should the Government be allowed to investigate your teenager’s sex life?” The ad detailed the case of Somer Chipman and Chasity Glass both from Williamstown, Kentucky, who were excluded from National Honor Society membership due to the schools charge that they had had premarital sex. The ad stated, “How did Grant County School officials know that these young women were guilty of forbidden sex acts? Easy—they became pregnant and had their babies.” The ad further questions “What about girls who don’t get pregnant, or have abortions? And what about boys?” The ad concluded by asking “Who is more immoral, two young women who took responsibility for their conduct and still managed to earn top honors, or government officials who want to probe into students’ private behavior and deny them the honors they earned through hard work? Think about it.” This ad clearly attempted what had been successful in the early 1970s—to link the plight of these girls who were pregnant to “your teenager,” your daughter, “our girls.” The ad also situated these teen mothers as responsible teen mothers, hard working and moral, and worthy of full educational opportunity. The ads garnished little response, created no public outcry about the lack of rights for teen mothers. The attention the ads did receive was mainly negative.54 So entrenched is the ideology of the teen pregnant mother as a drain on society, as immoral, that by this time the public could not view her differently even when she was a white, honor student. In the public mind, these girls were the exception, and to afford any pregnant girl more rights would send a message that teen pregnancy is okay; or worse that law and policy were condoning teen pregnancy by going “soft” on teen mothers. Although Title IX guarantees teen mothers access to school activities, the courts and the public continue to view such activities as a privilege—a privilege that teen mothers do not deserve because they embody what we most fear, female teen sexuality and sexual activity.55 The white, high-achieving teen mother is still contaminated and contaminating, daring to make visible what we cannot bear to see or know. Thus, while under different circumstances these girls are described as responsible, treatable,
Fig. 4 American Civil Liberties Union
Title IX and the Discursive Climate of Education for School-Age Mothers • 71
and entitled teen mothers, the public still does not accept them or want them to be “our girls” or “my daughter.”56
Discourses of Education as Responsibility While discourses of contamination do affect all pregnant students it does not represent all pregnant students similarly—some students are seen as more dangerously infectious than others. Evident in the above review of cases is an absence of African-American or Latina teen mothers as legal subjects. Is this because African-American and Latina teen mothers are receiving equal education with no problems? Research indicates otherwise, so why aren’t the educational concerns, issues, and needs of African-American and Latina teen mothers represented in case law? Key to addressing this question is a return to the historical tracing of the different definitions of the problem of teen pregnancy presented in chapter 1. As I argued in that chapter, differential definitions and corresponding differential treatment patterns of the unwed mother linked to race were established by the 1950s. By the 1980s black teen mothers were effectively defined as the “other” teen mother. This “other” teen mother is one who is inherently deficit, morally and culturally. Lisa Ikemoto describes these “other” mothers as “unwed adult women, teens, welfare recipients, and/or women of color” who are “too fertile.”57 These “too fertile” women are identifiable as a group, “because there were already stories and images attached to these identities;” as a group they are constructed and identifiable and their fertility is situated as a social problem.58 Linda McClain identifies three additional rhetorical models of irresponsibility assigned to the “the single mother, the welfare mother, and the teen mother” those being, “immorality, unaccountability, and incapacity.”59 While all teen unwed mothers are subject to these constructs, as evidenced in the NHS cases, race and class further inscribe some teen mothers as inherently deficit. These teen mothers, the “other” teen mothers, cannot even be imagined as legal subjects, as subjects entitled to education. What rights does a teen mother who is “too fertile,” immoral, unaccountable, and irresponsible have? While the language of Title IX includes this pregnant female, she has to this point not been included in policy or case law that grants any sense of entitlement to teen mothers. Consider for example, that the teen mothers in the NHS cases were not filing suit for access to equal education opportunity in terms of access to their schools, or access to a certain curricula. They already had access to their regular public school and to the school curriculum they studied before becoming teen mothers. These teen mothers, white, mainly middleclass, high-achieving students were exactly whom Title IX was developed for and in these cases the teen mothers benefited at least initially from Title IX by being able to continue their education at the same level they worked
72 • Unfit Subjects
at before becoming pregnant. A study by Dawn M. Upchurch and James L. McCarthy supports this claim, noting that white teen mothers made their greatest gain in graduation rates between 1975 and 1986. In contrast, black mothers made their greatest gains in graduation rates between 1958 and 1975, before the implementation of Title IX.60 This startling finding reinforces the ideology of Title IX as developed out of a sense of entitlement for “our girls” traced in chapter 1 and white teen mothers certainly benefited from this ideology. At the same time, recall that black teen mothers, by the late 1970s, were being further constructed not only as immoral and irresponsible, but also as welfare mothers, welfare subjects. For these mothers education was certainly not viewed as a right but came to be constructed as the responsibility of the teen mother. The benefit of an education is not for this teen mother, but pursuing education is what she owes to society for the benefit of her child and relief of the taxpayer. The NHS cases work to further differentiate between good and bad teen mothers, white and black teen mothers, and what they are entitled to. One of the girls bringing suit herself states: “not all teen mothers are bad.” However, such a discourse even in its attempts to interrupt stereotypes, recirculates and accepts the idea that there indeed are some “bad” teen mothers. Further, if the “good” teen mothers can be excluded from the NHS based on their “immoral” behavior; if the “good” teen mother does not garnish public support or sympathy, what chance does the “bad” teen mother have to make her case for equal education opportunity? Although schools may not like serving the “good” teen mother, they do know more about what to do with her—leave her alone, return her to her normal classes, and let her graduate. In fact there is evidence that schools place teen mothers into different programs by race, with white girls most often being served in the regular public school or offered tutoring at home until the birth of their child at which point they return to school, while African-American and Latina teens are overrepresented in separate school placements, an issue explored further in later chapters.61 However, what does education in these separate settings mean for the “bad” teen mother? What is the purpose of education for the “bad” teen mother? While these questions have seldom been asked or researched thoroughly, linking education for these girls to welfare reform acts, including the PRWORA, does firmly situate education as a responsibility for these girls. Here then linking teen pregnancy to a social welfare issue shifts the major question from “What is the purpose of education for the school-age mother?” to “What is the purpose of education for the teen mother on welfare?” The latter question lends itself to the development of programs for teen mothers not based on entitlement to education but on education as a
Title IX and the Discursive Climate of Education for School-Age Mothers • 73
responsibility to society. Education in this way for racialized teen mothers, who are assumed to be irresponsible, is a responsibility that the girls must meet for society. Further, it is assumed that teen mothers in need of education would not seek it on their own, as they are irresponsible, and must be forced (through social welfare legislation) to get this education. This attitude became prevalent in welfare reform measures requiring school attendance and a high school degree in order to qualify for social welfare support. As Mittelstadt notes, “the very purpose of education was reconfigured from a guaranteed entitlement to an enforced requirement.”62 A discourse of education as a responsibility has helped to determine what the goals of such an education should include: economic self-sufficiency through high school completion with an emphasis on job training; prevention of a repeat pregnancy; and retraining in values and responsibility. Thus, schools under this discourse find themselves in the business of much more than providing access to academics or graduation. They necessarily are involved with tracking the teen mother on welfare, linking her with local community health and social service agencies, and often involving her in programs to prevent a repeat pregnancy which will emphasize values retraining.63 Curricula and programs developed for schools have proliferated, including one popular welfare/school/job training program “Learnfare,” which comes with a corresponding “how-to” guide, “How to implement a mandatory stay-in-school program for Teenage Parents on Welfare.”64 Research on these separate programs further suggests that a key role of the teen pregnancy program is for teen girls to redeem themselves and learn to make responsible, “morally defensible actions.”65 These special programs, developed under a discourse of education as responsibility, are not developed with the white, middle-class girl in mind. These programs are focused upon the low-income, unwed, and assumed “minority” teen mother. Such girls are not deserving or capable of a regular education; instead such a girl has a responsibility not to become a burden on the taxpayer.
Concluding Thoughts on Contamination and Responsibility Certainly vestiges of both contamination and responsibility discourse remain prevalent in the provision of education to teen mothers today. While these discourses affect all teen mothers they affect teen mothers differentially by race. Although all teen mothers are situated as morally infectious, white teen mothers have been historically situated as entitled to an education and the gain in graduation rates for white teen mothers after Title IX supports the impact of this ideology. In this way, white teen mothers have
74 • Unfit Subjects
been good legal subjects under Title IX, even if they were unsuccessful in the cases they brought against it. At the same time, racialized teen mothers have been situated as infectious, and linked so strongly with inherent immorality, irresponsibility, and social welfare dependency that education for them has been redefined, not as an entitlement, but as a social responsibility. Here education operates under an ideology of “equal to what they deserve” and further situates these girls’ education as not for their benefit, but a responsibility to society. Under discourses of contamination black and Latina pregnant/mothering teens are contaminated and by their invisibility in case law regarded as unfit legal subjects. Through discourses of education as a responsibility, such girls are further situated as unfit and unentitled educational subjects in need of separation, enforcement, and control. This analysis demonstrates how pregnant teens are differentially treated although all school-age mothers are guaranteed equal education opportunity under Title IX. The logic of the discourses of contamination and responsibility override concerns about meeting the intent of Title IX and allow public and political ideology to continue to impact the education provided to teen mothers. What these discourses specifically mean in terms of how teen mothers are educated and which mothers are provided what kind of education is discussed in detail in the chapters that follow.
Notes 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10.
All quotes taken directly from the Statement of the Honorable Roderick Paige before the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions, June 27, 2002. See e.g. Brake, “Legal Challenges to the Educational Barriers Facing Pregnant and Parenting Adolescents.” Upchurch and McCarthy, “Adolescent Childbearing and High School Completion in the 1980s”; and, Weatherly, et.al., “Patchwork Programs.” Ordway v. Hargraves, 323 F. Supp, 1155 (D. Mass. 1971). For a discussion of Ordway, see Brake, “Legal Challenges to the Educational Barriers Facing Pregnant and Parenting Adolescents”; and, Luker, Dubious Conceptions. Brake, “Legal Challenges to the Educational Barriers Facing Pregnant and Parenting Adolescents”; and, Stamm, “A Skeleton in the Closet: Single-sex Schools for Pregnant Girls,” 1203–1237. Nutt v. Goodland, 128 Kan. 507, 278 P. 1065 (1929). Perry v. Grenada Municipal School District as discussed in Grace Belsches-Simmons, “Teenage Pregnancy and Schooling,” 3. See e.g., FCAA, SWHA, Publications-Field Reporter, 1959, Box 48, Folder 13, p. 3. NFCM, SWHA, Publications-Annual Report, 1929, Box 2, Folder 9, p. 31. FCAA, SWHA, Publications-Conference Papers, Boyd Nelson “Elimination of Roadblocks in Educating School-Age Unmarried Mothers,” 1960, Box 50, Folder 1, pp. 2–3. FCAA, SWHA, Executive Committee Minutes, 1968, Box 36, Folder 6, p. 3. Changes in F.C. Home philosophy and service were also related to changing policies in many homes allowing for the unwed mother to give her child up for adoption. Such an option became increasingly common for the unwed young mother meaning that F.C. Homes, as one head teacher noted, “took on an aspect of a boarding school” with the girls staying at a hospital while pregnant, having their child, who was put up for adoption and then returning to their homes, “ready to return to her uninterrupted life.” FCAA, SWHA, Publications-June Peterson, “Public School Services in a Maternity Home,”1970, Box 49, Folder 10, p. 3.
Title IX and the Discursive Climate of Education for School-Age Mothers • 75 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21.
22.
23. 24.
25.
26. 27. 28. 29. 30.
Children’s Welfare League of America papers (hereafter cited as CWLA) SWHA, NCI Meeting Report, Box 48, Folder 5, pp. 3–6. CWLA, SWHA, NCI Policy Statement, Box 48, Folder 2. CWLA, SWHA, NCI Supplementary Statement to Project Application Training School Personnel to Accept Unmarried Mothers, Box 48, Folder 5, p. 2. FCAA, SWHA, Publications-June Peterson, “Public School Services in a Maternity Home,”1970, Box 49, Folder 10, p. 3. FCAA, SWHA, Publications-Conference Papers, Boyd Nelson “Elimination of Roadblocks in Educating School-Age Unmarried Mothers,” 1960, Box 50, Folder 1, pp. 1–2. CWLA, SWHA, Ovid Parody, “The Uninterrupted Education of Unwed Mothers,” Box 47, Folder 10, pp. 1–2. CWLA, SWHA, Ovid Parody, “The Uninterrupted Education of Unwed Mothers,” Box 47, Folder 10, p. 7. Educational Amendments of 1972, Section 901–902; 20 U.S.C. Section 1681 (1972); 34 C.F.R. Section 106.40 (b) (1) Id. Section 106.40(b)(3). Id. Section 106.40(b)(4–5). I recognize that these may sound like basic issues to the reader, however, my research and the research of others show that teen mothers do not have access even to these “basics.” Such issues often become mired in issues of power, control, and ideology about what the teen mother deserves. I explicate how this happens in the next chapter. When attempting to find the number of complaints about teen mothers’ access to schools that OCR had received nationwide, I was informed there was “no available code for ‘teen pregnancy.’”“Maternity discrimination” at elementary and secondary schools was suggested as the best search parameter, however, the number of reported cases under this search may also include adult women filing complaints (e.g., work-related complaints). OCR presently has no way of distinguishing teen mothers’ complaints under Title IX from adult women’s complaints. Complaints would have to be looked at individually to determine whether any were brought by a pregnant/mothering student, however, the complaints are not public documents unless they have been investigated or settled. The limits of using OCR data to determine whether pregnant/mothering students are receiving fair access to schools are apparent. Under the available search parameters, OCR reported that it found twenty-five complaints under “maternity discrimination” nationwide from 1993 to 2002. Personal Communication, September 18, 2002. Office of Civil Rights, Philadelphia, FOIA # 73. Stamm, “A Skeleton in the Closet,” FN 182. Schools are not alone in setting policy that violates Title IX. Take for example, Indianapolis mayor Steve Goldsmith’s plan to turn to religious groups and organizations to reduce unwed pregnancy. He developed a “twenty-seven strategy” plan to “stigmatize out-of-wedlock births”—a “culture war” led by religious groups against illegitimacy. The plan placed pressure on schools “to ban pregnant teens and boys who had fathered children from extracurricular activities” and to send “pregnant girls to separate schools altogether.” Both of these strategies are blatantly illegal under Title IX. Loconte, “A City’s Assault on Teen Pregnancy,” 12. Two examples of this include a decision made in 1998 by the school district in Xenia, Ohio to review its National Honor Society membership policy after rescinding a student’s membership when they found she was a teen, unwed mother, and a change in policy by the school board in Texas in 1993 after three cheerleaders who were pregnant were kicked off the cheerleading squad, while a fourth who had an abortion was allowed to remain on the squad. I describe such a situation in Pillow “The Making of Mothers,” and Pillow, “Exposed Methodology.” See e.g., Fine, “Sexuality, Schooling, and Adolescent Females,” 29–53; Gordon, ed. Women, the State, and Welfare; Lesko, “The ‘Leaky Needs’ of School-Age Mothers,” 177–205; and, Rushing, “Sin, Sex, and Segregation.” See e.g., Fine, “Sexuality, Schooling, and Adolescent Females.” Kelly, “Warning Labels,” 165–186; Lesko, “Curriculum Differentiation as Social Redemption”; Lesko, “Implausible Endings”; Pillow, The Making of Mothers; Tolman, “Doing Desire,” 324–342. I have written about how teen mothers are often aware of the fear and discomfort their pregnant bodies engender in adult teachers and may even use this discomfort to their advantage
76 • Unfit Subjects
31. 32. 33. 34. 35.
36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41.
42.
43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48.
49. 50. 51. 52. 53. 54. 55.
to get what they want, exaggerating their pregnant bodies by standing with their full bodies thrust forward. Whether these young women were using the knowledge of the discomfort they caused adults to their educational advantage is debatable, but young pregnant women themselves are certainly aware of the discomfort their bodies cause for adults in school settings, see, e.g., Pillow “The Making of Mothers,” and Pillow, “Exposed Methodology.” See e.g., Lugg, For God and Country. Stamm, “A Skeleton in the Closet,” 149. Houston v. Prosser, 1972; also see Warren, “Pregnant Students/Public Schools,” 112. Initially, the student was paying for the GED courses. The court decision did include the mandate that the school district pay for the student to complete the GED courses. Schools have also attempted to dismiss students for other behaviors seen as immoral. A 1981 seventh circuit court decision ruled that the Cobb County School District in Georgia had violated a student’s constitutional rights when it barred her from attending her regular school and required her to attend night school after she began living with her boyfriend (Street v. Cobb County School District, Georgia, 1981). Teachers also have been targets of contamination logic. As late as 1986 a teacher was dismissed for being an unwed mother. A district court affirmed the jury finding that the school board had violated the rights of the teachers’ constitution (Eckmann v. Board of Education of Hawthorn School District, Illinois, 1986). As reported in Grace Belsches-Simmons, “Teenage Pregnancy and Schooling, 4, FN 10. Warren, “Pregnant Students,” 111. Warren, “Pregnant Students,” 111. Warren, “Pregnant Students,” 112. Warren, “Pregnant Students,” 112. One comprehensive study detailing service provisions for teen mothers found that teen mothers predominantly served at separate school sites or off-campus programs, see Barrett, “An Assessment of Educational Services for Pregnant Students and Teenage Mothers”; see also Ling, “Lifting Voices,” 2387–2412. Barbara Whitehead, “The Failure of Sex Education,” 77. Note Whitehead’s focus upon “unwed” teen mothers—does this mean that teen mothers who are married would be treated differentially? Existing research does not support that married teen mothers fare better than unmarried teen mothers, an issue discussed in chapter 6. Whitehead, “The Failure of Sex Education.” Pillow, The Making of Mothers. See e.g., Pillow, The Making of Mothers; and Pillow, “Exposed Methodologies.” Wort v. Vierling, No. 82-3169 (C.D. Ill. Sept. 4, 1984). Pfeiffer v. Marion Ctr. Area School District, Civ. Act. 84–648 (W.D. Pa Jan. 10, 1990), aff ’d in part, vacated and remanded in part, 917 F.2d 779 (3d Cir. 1990), reh’g denied, 1990 U.S. app. LEXIS 23289 (3d Cir. Dec. 20, 1990), at 10–11. How do such decisions occur? How can courts separate premarital sexual activity from pregnancy? In a 1974 Supreme Court decision, Geduldig v. Aiello, that still stands, the court established a distinction between pregnant and nonpregnant persons that separates “pregnancy-related classifications from gender-based classifications” (Stamm, “A Skeleton in the Closet,” 1215). This decision thus allows for exclusionary policies based on pregnancy because such policies are not viewed as gender exclusions but the same as any other physical condition. Given public dissatisfaction with this decision, the legislature passed the Pregnancy Discrimination Act in 1975, specifically protecting pregnant women from discrimination in the workplace. However, for NHS cases, courts have relied upon the Geduldig decision to guide their decision making. Stamm, “A Skeleton in the Closet,” 1228. Brake, “Legal Challenges.” www.aclu.org.news. Chipman v. Grant County School District, 1998. See e.g., Brake, “Legal Challenges”; and Stamm, “A Skeleton in the Closet.” See e.g., responses on ACLU website, www.aclu.org. It is obvious that the focus and attention and control in these cases are only on female students. While male students may engage in premarital sexual activity or may even be an unwed parent, such facts have not been deemed necessary or admissible to the court or even pertinent in the public mind. See Brake, “Legal Challenges.”
Title IX and the Discursive Climate of Education for School-Age Mothers • 77 56.
57. 58. 59. 60. 61. 62. 63. 64. 65.
On the other hand, the American public loves stories of people who overcome hardship. Thus the story of Nora Cadena made national news in June 1999, because although she was mother to a ten-month-old girl, having become a teen mother at age sixteen, she was heading to college at Massachusetts Institute of Technology with a scholarship based on her high grades and scholastic achievement. The story of this “southern California” teen mother was news because Ms. Cadena defies several stereotypes—she is attending a prestigious university based on her grades not on affirmative action, a feat in and of itself assumed to be notable for a Latina, and she is doing so as a young Latina unwed mother. In this story Ms. Cadena is treated sympathetically, because she is meeting a societal need to know that a Latina teen mother is going to be self-sufficient, hard-working, responsible, and not welfare dependent. This is the story the public wants to hear and wants reproduced—the teen mother who is taking responsibility and overcoming her hardships on her own, not asking for privileges. Ikemoto, “The In/Fertile, the Too Fertile, and the Dysfertile,” 1008. Ikemoto, “The In/Fertile, the Too Fertile, and the Dysfertile,” 1042. McClain, “‘Irresponsible’ Reproduction,” 342. Upchurch and McCarthy, “Adolescent Childbearing.” See e.g., Pillow, The Making of Mothers; and, Upchurch and McCarthy, “Adolescent Childbearing.” Mittelstadt, “Educating ‘Our Girls’ and ‘Welfare Mothers,’” 33. See e.g., Card, et. al. Family Planning Perspectives, 210–220; Lesko, “Curriculum Differentiation as Social Redemption”; Lesko, “The “Leaky Needs” of School-Age Mothers” and Pillow, The Making of Mothers. Long and Bos, Learnfare. See e.g., Lesko, “Curriculum Differentiation as Social Redemption”; Lesko, “Implausible Endings”; and, Pillow, The Making of Mothers.
CHAPTER
3
Schooling Responses to Teen Mothers Absences, Colds, and Disabilities This [teenage pregnancy] is a national emergency . . . I propose that teenage girls be encouraged to use long-term, maintenance-free contraceptives such as Norplant, IUDs, or Depo-Provera and they be paid regularly to continue doing so up to age 20 or so. —Quote from past AERA president, Educational Researcher, 1998 Schools are getting into being social workers rather than educators —School Board Member, Chicago Public Schools, 1998 We don’t want to make it too easy for teen mothers; otherwise we’ll reinforce the problems of teen pregnancy. —High School Principal, 2000
The National Campaign to Reduce Teen Pregnancy initiated by President Clinton in 1996 included representatives from the medical community, sports figures, a university president, and comedian Whoopi Goldberg.1 It did not include an educator or administrator from a grade school or a high school, or an educational researcher or policy analyst that studied teen pregnancy. The composition of this committee reflects the lack of involvement and visibility of educators and educational researchers in policy arenas at a national level. This absence is curious given that it is schools that have the most contact with adolescents and are the acknowledged frontline service providers for teen mothers. It seems obvious that educators and educational policy researchers have much to contribute to national 79
80 • Unfit Subjects
discussions and policy deliberations about teen pregnancy or should at least be involved in establishing policies that schools will be required to implement. So where have the educational policy researchers been? Why are education personnel noticeably missing from discussions, debates, and policy development? Why is their absence not questioned? Ellen Lagemann offers one explanation for educationists’ (her term for those who conduct education research) absence in social and educational policy development. Lagemann begins by asking why and how the educational “domain of scholarly work always has been regarded as something of a stepchild, reluctantly tolerated at the margins of academe and rarely trusted by policy makers, practitioners, or members of the public at large?”2 Lagemann suggests that while the arena of educational research attempts to be taken serious as a discipline, the field over-disciplined itself, mimicking other established disciplines in the social sciences and replicating existing research practices and methods. This process Lagemann argues has limited education’s usefulness to policy and has delegated the field of education to the realm of “poor cousin” of the social sciences. Lagemann’s history of educationists “low status and isolation” offers an understanding of the “current weak demand for education research” and the absence of educationists on a national policy level.3 However, an absence of attention to research on teen mothers is also present within educational policy and research. The arena of educational policy and research is also surprisingly devoid of discussion or analysis of teen pregnancy. While there are numerous articles in social science journals that focus upon the social-psychological attributes of teen mothers such articles remain focused upon identifying which girls are most “atrisk” and perpetuate cultural deficit theories to explain teen pregnancy. A review of the articles and books that do focus upon the education of pregnant/mothering students shows little to no mention of Title IX.4 This is a glaring absence given the direct impact court decisions and Title IX hold for the provision of education for school-age mothers. There are only a handful of education scholars in the United States who have researched and published on the educational experiences of teen mothers and most mention that their research is confounded by the lack of basic data on teen mothers at the school level, data such as school attendance and dropout rates.5 While teen pregnancy has remained at the forefront of policy debates over the past thirty years, information on how and where pregnant teens and teen mothers are being educated remains largely unavailable and schools have been primary participants in continuing this absence. For instance, over 90 percent of the schools and school districts I contacted could not respond to routine questions like, “How many pregnant teens or teen mothers are attending school?” “What schools are they attending?” “How
Schooling Responses to Teen Mothers • 81
many teen mothers leave school?” “How many teen mothers return to school?”“What kinds of support services or programs are pregnant/mothering teens getting?”“How many teen mothers complete school?”6 The education of teen mothers has not been a topic of consideration by larger research and policy groups either. While there is a wealth of research on prevention programs, there continues to be an absence of discussion and research on how to educate the teen girl when she is pregnant/mothering. Policy reports that discuss the problems of teen pregnancy often do not provide recommendations for how schools can respond to them or consider the role of Title IX in educating teen mothers. Many educational research groups do not include information on teen pregnancy or when information is provided it is focused upon prevention. A 1985 National Conference on State Legislatures report on initiatives that address teen pregnancy noted that: The major roadblock is denial. Even though we live in a highly sexually oriented culture, no one wants to admit that teenagers are sexually active. When you start introducing teenage pregnancy bills, the argument you’ll get from some of your constituents is ‘these kids should not be having sex,’ rather than ‘how can we prevent these 10,000 pregnancies a year?’ It’s like watching a house burn down . . .7
This denial and the fears of public policymakers and educationists to engage in a dialogue on such an emotionally charged topic have meant sparse attention has been given to the education of teen mothers. By comparison, great attention has been given to approaching teen pregnancy as a social welfare issue while there is no existing funding for longitudinal evaluation research to begin to determine what type of education is best for teen mothers.8 However, while there is an absence of knowledge and research about the educational needs and experiences of teen mothers, there is not a lack of opinion by educators about who the teen mother is, what she needs, and what she deserves. Regardless of the lack of basic information, data, and comprehensive research, school personnel have felt free to speak authoritatively about the problems of teen pregnancy in their school, district, or state and to offer prescriptive policy recommendations. It is difficult to identify the impact or influence of Title IX within statements by school personnel—often the fact of Title IX is not even mentioned, leaving the role schools should or could play in educating teen mothers seemingly open to local decision making. In this way the education of teen mothers can be recognized as both debated and ignored within the education arena. The debates that do occur reflect the sentiments of the quotes at the beginning of this chapter—that teen pregnancy is the fault of individual immorality, that schools getting involved with teen mothers overstep the
82 • Unfit Subjects
boundaries of education, and that providing programs for teen mothers to increase their access to schooling will give the perception that a school is “soft” on teen pregnancy. Notably absent in educational research and debate, is what schools can or should do under Title IX, to support the right of a teen mother’s access to an education equal to her peers. This absence is notable in education journals, where there are few articles focusing upon the education of the school-age teen mother. While articles on preventing teen pregnancy are relatively numerous, especially in social science journals, articles that focus on educating teen mothers are few. For example, between 1972 and 2002 Phi Delta Kappan published the most articles on education and the school-age mother, yet only one of these articles mentions Title IX.9 The remaining articles discuss the education of teen mothers without ever referring to the fact that it is illegal to dismiss teen mothers from school, that alternative placements must be voluntary, and that the teen mother has the right to an education comparable to her peers. Such absences within educational research support the discursive workings of crisis talk allowing it to dominate existing educational talk about teen pregnancy. The lack of data and information on educating teen mothers allows education personnel to replicate societal and social policy crisis and epidemic talk on unwed teen pregnancy. The quotes at the front of this chapter, which reflect the sense of crisis and epidemic surrounding teen pregnancy, are often difficult to argue against as they capture prevailing sentiment and there is not existing research to refute such statements as ideological. As noted previously, a climate of crisis engenders epidemic logic, which reinforces quick, poorly thought out, limited, and regulatory policy recommendations and decisions. For instance, Julian Stanley, the former president of the American Education Research Association (AERA), makes the extreme recommendation, cited at the beginning of this chapter, without any consideration of what effects it may have. Instead, he notes that “researchers could determine whether the strategy that I have proposed increases educational levels, reduces delinquency and crime, and promotes vocationally self-sufficiency.”10 Despite that some of the contraceptive methods he lists have not been studied or approved for use by women under the age of seventeen, he also fails to acknowledge that the long-term effects such contraceptives may have on teenagers are not known. Ethical considerations such as these are overridden by the sense of “emergency” surrounding teen pregnancy. Additionally, Stanley does not address how decisions about which teens to put on contraceptives will be made—presumably we will just know which girls are at risk. There are obvious problems with such policy recommendation, but before we dismiss Stanley’s views as far fetched, consider that several judges
Schooling Responses to Teen Mothers • 83
in the early 1990s prescribed mandatory birth control, through the insertion of Norplant, as part of women’s sentences for child abuse, drug use, or welfare fraud. Additionally many states have linked incentives to use Norplant with the welfare system along with family caps.11 I explore the ramifications of such policy decisions further in chapter 6, but here note that Stanley’s recommendations are alarming exactly because such practices have already begun. This example is highlighted to point out that while I do present a picture of education personnel as absent from national and state-level debate and decision making regarding the education of teen mothers, schools are the frontline service providers for teen mothers and education personnel are making decisions daily that affect the lives of teen mothers. However, many frontline decisions are not based upon research or experience, but rather on epidemic logic, fear, and heightened morality discourses, all of which focus upon control, regulation, and surveillance of the pregnant/ mothering teen. Note the rendering of a pregnant girl from a 1987 Phi Delta Kappan article that called for “schools to tackle the problem” of teen pregnancy (see figure 5). Her eyes downcast redemptively, swollen belly prominent, she is dwarfed by the adults around her, clearly distinguishing her as a child versus the adults surrounding her. This white pregnant girl, though depicted as an object of attention by school personnel, is silent and silenced, without agency or voice, while the adults with large, claw-like hands hold her from the front and behind and control her future.12 Figure 5 illustrates the complexities of analyzing school responses, both absent and active, to the pregnant/mothering teen. Here I situate the complexities of reading school responses within practices and discourses of absence and ambivalence surrounding the provision of education to the pregnant/mothering student. Discourses and practices of absence and ambivalence are evident first in the lack of state and local policy for pregnant/mothering teens and within restricted interpretations of Title IX by school administrators. Correspondingly, a lack of research and data on the educational experiences and needs of pregnant/mothering students impacts and delimits how pregnant/mothering teens receive an education. Lastly, I consider in light of these absences how school personnel are making decisions about how to provide education to the pregnant/mothering student. By analyzing documents and conducting interviews with school personnel, including administrators and educators at regular public schools and administrators at the district and state level, I identify two metaphors that describe educational approaches to school-age mothers at local school levels: pregnancy as a cold and pregnancy as a disability/disease. These discursive models impact policy development and service provision and address the lack of data collection that allows binary understandings of teen
84 • Unfit Subjects
Fig. 5 Phi Delta Kappan, June 1987.
Schooling Responses to Teen Mothers • 85
pregnancy to continue. Like the work of contamination discourse in chapter 2, either a cold or a disease/disability approach may contaminate the student body, however, the severity of the contamination determines how to treat and manage the pregnant female body. These discursive constructions of pregnancy structure schools’ responses to the teen mother—what and how much can schools be expected to deal with and handle. For instance, perhaps schools can handle a student’s cold, but not their disease. The cold or disability discursive model also guides how much empathy to feel for the pregnant student—having a cold is a pain and inconvenience, but you get over it, versus a disease or disability that is likely beyond your control and has long-term consequences. Obviously, the problem with these discursive models is that at times pregnancy is neither completely like a cold or a disability—it is sometimes neither, sometimes both. The limits of these models point to our continuing inability to deal with women’s fluctuating bodies, discursively and in practice.
Tracing Policy Absences at State and Local Levels: Evidence of Deliberate Ambivalence Certainly, Title IX has had a dramatic impact on teen mothers’ initial access to education, particularly white teen mothers.13 Prior to Title IX less than 10 percent of schools offered educational services to teen mothers.14 During the 1970s, schools routinely dismissed pregnant teens from attending school on the grounds of “gross personal misconduct.”15 In fact, in the 1970s married pregnant teachers were also asked to leave school and it was not until the early 1980s that all female teachers gained the right to remain at school throughout the term of their pregnancy.16 Similarly, prior to Title IX, the marital status of the pregnant teen did not protect her from school expulsion. However, while the most common practice prior to Title IX was outright dismissal of the pregnant teen, some communities and schools did have programs to accommodate the needs of the pregnant student. A 1972 Phi Delta Kappan article estimated that there were “nearly 200” programs in public schools for pregnant unwed mothers. These included providing home tutoring during the teen’s pregnancy, placing the teen in a separate setting, allowing the teen to remain in school until the fifth or sixth month of her pregnancy, offering the teen special classes at the regular school, or schools that continued to “dismiss pregnant students outright.”17 Donald Warren noted that in 1972 the type of service available to a teen mother was highly dependent upon where she lived, concluding: In short, there is little uniformity in the treatment of pregnant students by public schools, even within a given county or state; and, of course the quality of the programs where they exist varies from school district to school district and often from school to school.18
86 • Unfit Subjects
Although one might expect the passage of Title IX to have served as an impetus for schools to coordinate their policies and programs for teen mothers, this was not the case. Although by the mid-1970s schools were situated as the primary service providers for programs to deal with teen pregnancy, state and local school districts did not develop specific programs and policies to guide the education of teen mothers. A lack of federal funding initiatives to implement Title IX partially explains the lack of program development. Without authorization of funds to support the development of school-based teen pregnancy programs for pregnant/mothering students, school districts had little incentive to proactively develop programs for such students.19 After the passage of Title IX, states continued to leave the education of school-age mothers open to local definition and control. The effects of local interpretation and control are evidenced in a 1979 New Jersey plan that promoted a policy which allowed each school district to “voluntarily plan a program for its pregnant students.”20 Given the voluntary nature of this policy only a handful of school districts developed school plans for pregnant teens, meaning that the remaining school districts handled cases individually.21 With policies this unstructured, the schools’ responses to the teen mother have been sporadic, idiosyncratic, and limited. At issue is the evidence that even after Title IX schools have demonstrated ambivalence toward educating pregnant teens, unsure whether they are really the school’s responsibility or the responsibility of social welfare agencies and community organizations. Title IX made schools face the fact that they could no longer routinely dismiss pregnant/mothering students. Yet a RAND study indicated that by 1981 “most of the school districts studied had established separate facilities” for teen mothers and that these separate facilities had “low academic standards.”22 This use of alternative school placements for teen mothers should not be understood as a new age of school policy providing guidelines for the education of teen mothers. The same RAND study revealed that public schools were most likely to do no more than forbid expulsion of school-age pregnant teens.23 Schools typically developed programming for pregnant teens only under external pressure and in the Rand study, school administrators were never the first to initiate such programming, creating programs and policies only in response to external pressures.24 In this light, trends of placement of school-age mothers in existing alternative school settings are more accurately viewed as a response to schools no longer being able to dismiss pregnant teens outright, not a as response to the educational needs of teen mothers. Many such alternative schools were originally established for learning- and behavior-disordered youth, and teen mothers were often placed in such schools without any additional support.25 A 1981 “Information Update” on “The response of the schools to teenage pregnancy and parenting” put out by the Children’s Welfare
Schooling Responses to Teen Mothers • 87
League of America noted several trends and problems in school response.26 Three types of programs for teen mothers were identified: “inclusive curriculum programs; supplementary curriculum programs . . . ; and noncurriculuar programs.” However, contrary to NCI’s expressed hope that schools become actively involved in the education of pregnant/mothering teens (see chapter 2), this study found that “schools neither seek nor want an active role in student pregnancy or parenthood” and further that the initiation of special programs for teen mothers “depends for the most part upon the dedication of a single individual.” Perhaps due to the lack of school personnel support, the update also noted that “pregnant students make most decisions concerning pregnancy and school continuation without school staff input.” Further, the quality of the three program models was found to be “uneven, both within and across programs” and while each program model was noted to offer something to the teen mother, none was able to meet all the needs of the pregnant/mothering student. A comprehensive 1985 study reported similar findings and no progress in coordination and development of school-based programs for teen mothers.27 The Children’s Defense Fund noting this trend saw fit to publish in 1986 a report titled “Preventing Adolescent Pregnancy: What Schools Can Do” linking the importance of educational opportunity for female students with the prevention of teen pregnancy as well as the vital role of public schools and educators in the life of pregnant/mothering teens. However, Larry Cuban argues that by 1986 school based programs and policies were more focused on preventing pregnancy than on educating pregnant teens, noting that “for prevention efforts, . . . schools have become the preferred provider,” however, “the prevention of teen pregnancy has been divorced from helping teenagers who are already pregnant.”28 Although a 1987 article reported that “65 percent of school administrators view teen pregnancy as one of the top ten problems facing their school systems,”29 another article in the same journal noted that there had been little progress in educating teen mothers, finding that a “vast majority” of school districts “have not begun to develop comprehensive plans to deal with the problems of teen pregnancy or teen parenting.”30 The author, James Buie, perhaps attempting to build from the mid-1980s attention to teen pregnancy as an epidemic of “children having children,” admonished educators, “The topic is hot. The time is ripe” further stating: school administrators need to act—carefully but courageously—to establish innovative programs to deal with [problems of teen pregnancy] in their own communities. 31
However the author of the article does not discuss the role of Title IX in establishing programs for teen mothers and emphasizes “employment skills” as the goal for teen mothers. Buie further cites the need for teen
88 • Unfit Subjects
pregnancy programs and programs for teen parents to take the “the romanticism out of having a baby” and further argues that although “mainstreaming is favored by 80% of school administrators . . . mainstreaming may be crueler than isolating teen parents in special programs,” due to the “toughness” it takes to survive in the “regular” school as a pregnant or parenting teen.32 Buie’s comments and recommendations remain focused upon changing the teen mother instead of considering how schools themselves could, and under Title IX should, change to accommodate the pregnant/parenting student. Although Buie suggests that the majority of school administrators favor “mainstreaming” of the pregnant student, a 1987 study found the more common practice was that of placing pregnant/mothering teens in alternative school settings, with 76 out of 90 cities providing services to teen mothers in “alternative schools.”33 This study further reported that the “education strands of the programs themselves most frequently provided counseling, special education, and nutrition, as well as family life and sex education.”34 Based upon articles and policy reports of the 1970s and 1980s, a disparate pattern of education provided to pregnant/mothering teens emerges, reflecting little program development that addresses their education, an emphasis upon vocational education as an appropriate goal for school-aged mothers and little to no attention to Title IX in educational policy research and development.
Ambivalent Uses of Title IX Wendy Wolf of the Center for Analysis and Policy Development argues that Title IX is still not being well utilized for pregnant teens and that the area of education to teen mothers is overlooked.35 At present most states continue to have no comprehensive policy for educating the pregnant or parenting teen. When state educational policies do exist “they can be divided into two general categories: rules excluding or segregating pregnant girls and mothers and rules restricting their participation in extracurricular activities.”36 Further, while school personnel often name teen pregnancy as one of the worst problems they face, at the same time, they have little knowledge about the legal rights of teen mothers or about effective educational models.37 This means that the education of school-age mothers remains open to local interpretation and implementation and thus programs for teen mothers vary widely in availability, size, services, admission policies, and goals. Certainly schools face many challenges in attempting to design policy to guide the education of pregnant/mothering teens. Basic questions such as, When is a teen mother a problem for the school—when she is pregnant, when she is a mother, or both? What kind of support and educational services are schools required to provide for the school-age girl who is pregnant
Schooling Responses to Teen Mothers • 89
or parenting? How and what type of accommodations should schools make to ensure access for the teen mother? and, should our school have a teen pregnancy/parents program?, can quickly collapse into heated debates about the role of schools and charges of a declining morality in U.S. society. Discussions of what to do with teen mothers is compounded by the myriad of program options (despite little data about their effectiveness) and needs of the pregnant/mothering teen to consider. For example, do we need family life courses to prevent teen pregnancy, or family planning services, or prenatal health care programs, or alternative education programs, including vocational training and parent education, for the teen mother? Should the school play a role in coordinating social services for the teen mother? Who is a teen mother’s primary case manager—the teacher or the social worker? And should schools offer on-site childcare for teen mothers? None of these program options are easily discussed or easily placed within the regular school setting without intensive discussion and planning and many of them are “hot-topic” issues for local communities.38 Thus, it is often easier for school personnel to avoid making program decisions and focus instead upon the need for “character education” or programs like “dollars for deeds” which pay female students to stay in school, receive passing grades, and not get pregnant.39 As discussed, policy and research have been more focused on pregnancy prevention than on what to do with the teen girl once she is pregnant. I have observed that it is much easier to discuss pregnancy (and thus sexual relations) prevention and control, even if it is still difficult to agree upon how to prevent teen pregnancy. When discussing teen pregnancy however, adults are faced with the failure of “prevention” and their own fears and concerns about teen sexuality cannot be ignored. This means that policies affecting the education of teen mothers are left undeveloped or are established at a minimal level, such as a policy that states “teen mothers may not be routinely dismissed from school.” A 1991 publication by the U.S. Department of Education Office for Civil Rights titled, “Teenage Pregnancy and Parenthood Issues under Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972,” was developed in response to the fact that fifteen years after the passage of Title IX many school administrators remained unclear about the legal obligations of public schools to provide an education to school-age mothers.40 Although legal cases of complaint had not officially occurred, anecdotal evidence pointed out that local school districts were widely varying in their treatment of the teen mother and that many were likely infringing upon the rights of teen mothers. This pamphlet was developed to counter such practices and prevent future litigation. The pamphlet reviews the language of Title IX noting, “schools may not bar pregnant students from any part of their education program, including
90 • Unfit Subjects
specific classes such as an honors class or program, or from any of the extracurricular programs, such as interscholastic sports or the debate team.” The pamphlet also emphasizes that alternative or “special” programs for teen mothers must be voluntary, “If special programs or special schools exist for students who are pregnant or who have children, schools may not require these students to enroll in or transfer to these programs. Such coercion is illegal.”41 (emphasis in original) However, the next section of the pamphlet seems to offer the school administrator a loophole in providing educational services to the teen mother, or at least confuse the school official about what a legally appropriate education for the school-age mother would be. For example, the section entitled, “Approaches for Addressing the Educational Problem of Teenage Pregnancy and Parenting,” states that “administrators, teachers, and school counselors are seeking ways of providing the best opportunity for these students to continue their education and maintain their academic progress” and lists “approaches used by some elementary and secondary schools to deal with the educational issues associated with teen pregnancy, marriage, and parenting while complying with Title IX.” However, prior to the listing the pamphlet states: “These approaches are not legally mandated by Title IX or the ED regulation” and further notes these approaches are ones performed by school districts who have “gone beyond preventing discrimination.”42 Thus, in this publication, Title IX is interpreted as simply preventing basic discrimination without specifying how to do this.43 The assumption continues that if a school simply does not expel the pregnant teen then it is meeting Title IX, regardless of the kind of educational programs and opportunities provided. School personnel are left to their own ideological and political determination and to that of their community, in deciding what education for school-age mothers will entail in their school system. Interviews with school personnel reveal this to be true; school administrators feel justified in making “decisions for their school” about how to handle teen mothers and in my research I found that knowledge about Title IX was sporadic. For instance, while most of the school administrators I spoke with knew they could not “kick” a pregnant teen out of school, many did not know that alternative school placements for the teens that is any placement outside of the regular school classroom, should be voluntary, and most typically had a diminished view of the kind of education the teen mother needed or deserved. As one school principal explained: What they (teen mothers) need now is not an education, but skills training. Training on how to be a mother. Training on how to learn a skill to get a job. And we (the mainstream school) are not equipped to provide these needs—they are better served in a vocational school setting or GED program.
Schooling Responses to Teen Mothers • 91
Although Title IX requires that such placements be voluntary, this administrator does not acknowledge this nor did this school practice “voluntary” placements. Such practices and sentiments are echoed in a review of educational policy guiding placement of pregnant/mothering teens by states. As of 1999, only fifteen states have criteria for alternative education placements for pregnant/mothering teens.44 This lack of criteria allows school personnel to indiscriminately place pregnant/mothering teens within alternative placements instead of considering how the regular, mainstream, school could continue to meet the students’ educational needs. However, the presence of criteria does not seem to decrease placement of teen mothers in alternative education programs. States that do have placement criteria also report the most alternative placement options with “employment training” and “other” being the most cited type of alternative programs available.45 Even in a state with a statewide policy and program for teen mothers, I found wide variations in the interpretation and application of this policy between school districts and between schools in the same district. Consider the following statements from three regular high school administrators in the same school district: This school is not a place where pregnant girls should be—it takes away the focus on academics and is a bad role model for our younger students. They usually leave this school for good or come back after their baby is born. I send all pregnant teens to [the alternative school site]. We can’t accommodate their needs here. We just keep the girls going in their current schedule.
At present, the continuing lack of statewide policies or district policies providing guidelines on educating the school-age mother in the regular or alternative school setting means that although the passage of Title IX protects the right of the teen mother to an education, where she will receive it, how, and what it will entail are open to local interpretation and implementation. This means that there is a wide range of disparity in teen mothers’ educational experiences. There are several basic provision models schools use to provide education to school-age mothers. These include, 1. Attend home school with no special provisions 2. Attend home school with separate teen pregnancy classes during the school day or after the school day 3. Attend separate school for full day for duration of pregnancy or in some cases until graduation 4. Home schooling during pregnancy and for several months after the birth of the child, then mother returns to home school
92 • Unfit Subjects
5. Attend Night GED classes—no involvement with the home school. The range of services provided by schools such as, counseling, childcare, transportation, tutoring, and parenting classes, also widely vary increasing the amount of disparity between programs for teen mothers. This means that depending on where a pregnant or mothering student lives, educational opportunities for her may be severely limited. Currently, there are many services to pregnant teens that are often uncoordinated, sporadically offered, overlapping, unaware of each other, and at times working at cross purposes.46 At present there is no case law under Title IX determining which of the above types of provisions meets the “equal education,” “voluntary,” and “comparable” components of Title IX, or any determining where schoolage mothers would be best served (in terms of equal education opportunity). Certainly, however, Title IX clearly situates the responsibility of providing access to an equal, comparable education for the school-age mother with public schools. So how have schools responded to this mandate—which provision models are schools using and for which teen mothers? Before specifically turning to this question, I first address the role a lack of data has on the provision of education to pregnant/mothering students.
School Data Problems—Troubling Absences in Data Practices Overriding any discussion of teen pregnancy as an educational policy issue is the lack of data and information on the teen mother as a student. I cannot overemphasize the problem caused by the lack of basic data collected on the educational experiences of teen mothers. Questions of how, where, and what type of an education schools are providing to school-age mothers is confounded by a lack of informative data. Data on how many teen mothers graduate, from where, and with what type of an education, are often not available or embedded in data sets on other “at-risk” school factors. Programs for teen mothers are often provided under the guise of “atrisk” programs or within other programs such as vocational education and home economics and once the pregnant teen has given birth she is often no longer tracked as a teen mother.47 While there are annual counts of the rate of teen pregnancy and full scale reports on prevention policy and programs, there is no corresponding study and analysis on the education of teen mothers.48 States do not routinely gather data on or track teen mothers in school and many local school districts do not keep track of teen mothers in their schools. A 1986 Select Committee House of Representatives report, Teen Pregnancy: What Is Being Done? A State-by-state Look,” notes:
Schooling Responses to Teen Mothers • 93 [I]t is clear from this report that there is no focused approach to solving the complex problems of teen pregnancy at any level of government. The efforts that do exist are too few, uncoordinated, and lack significant support. In short, the system is broken.49
While the relationship between educational attainment and economic well-being is noted, the report found that “states lack the ability, using current data, to fully assess the problem and design appropriate services”50 For example, the report found that “no states were able to report the number of pregnant or parenting adolescents finishing high school with their class, or within one year of their intended graduation date.”51 Similarly, states could not provide the number of teen mothers who complete G.E.D. or vocational education programs. At the time of the study, “fifty percent of the States reported schoolbased educational programs which aim at preventing teen pregnancies.”52 These programs emphasized “family life, sex education, and/or health education,” but again the focus remains here on preventing teen pregnancy. Similarly, the National Research Council in a 1986 report, “Risking the Future: Adolescent Sexuality, Pregnancy, and Childbearing,” placed emphasis upon pregnancy prevention, making prevention the highest priority. This report did not address how schools could or should play a role in addressing the problems of teen pregnancy and childbearing, a glaring omission, given that the report was published twelve years after Title IX.53 In the 1986 report there is little information on what type of service pattern models schools use for pregnant/mothering teens, although twenty states described offering “parenting and other skills and child development to soon-to-be, and new adolescent parents” and twelve states specifically noted the use of “alternative schools which only enroll pregnant or parenting teens” and a “few states mentioned homebound programs,” while “eleven states reported providing school-based child care services at regular and/or alternative school sites.”54 Further, the report states that: [N]one of the states provided information for the following questions on the survey: the number and percent of pregnant and parenting adolescents completing the General Equivalency Degree (G.E.D.) within two years of their intended graduation date; the number and percent of pregnant and parenting adolescents completing vocational education programs within two years of their intended graduation date; the number and percent of pregnant and parenting adolescents obtaining employment; the unemployment rate among adolescent mothers and fathers; and the percent of adolescent fathers providing child support to their infants.55
While there was no discussion of Title IX and its role in regulating the education of pregnant/mothering teens in the questionnaire, the report supported the development of vocational education programs for school-age mothers.
94 • Unfit Subjects
Research on teen pregnancy is made further problematic because the National Center for Health Statistics, the Bureau of Census, and the Alan Guttmacher Institute, which provide the majority of data on teen pregnancy, use different systems of age and racial classification and have differing definitions of what constitutes a teen pregnancy.56 While the Department of Public Health in each state tracks the number of teen births, these statistics do not tell us how many of these girls continue in, return to, and/or complete high school. Wendy Wolf suggests a formula for determining the number of girls a state or district could expect to be serving in schools based upon aggregated birthrates to teen mothers over several years. Wolf explains that “a typical mid-size city with about 500 births to girls 18 and under on an annual basis will have about 800 to 900 adolescent parents who are eligible for services.”57 A city and school district then can estimate how many teen mothers are being or not being served by subtracting the number of pregnant/mothering teens receiving services from the estimated birth rate. However, the use of such a formula quickly becomes complicated in practice. In each of the states I studied, data on the number of teen mothers in school was not available or varied by availability at the state or district school level, replicating the “broken system” findings of the 1986 House report. In my research, State Departments of Education did not have or could not provide data on the number of pregnant/mothering students in school. At the district level, only 25 percent could provide me with up-to-date information (within the past three years) on the number of pregnant/mothering teens in school. Districts with some type of teen pregnancy program in place did have data, but again this data was confounded by unclear definitions and grouping of data on teen mothers with other categorical areas. Compounding the problem of tracking the educational experiences of pregnant/mothering students is that when schools do attempt to track the teen mother many problems of definition arise. For example, when is the pregnant/mothering student considered a teen mother? When she is age seventeen or under, or also when she is eighteen and older? If the student is married is she still considered a teen mother? If the pregnant teen leaves school or does home tutoring while she is pregnant and returns to school without support after birth, should she be counted as a teen mother? When a female student drops out of school how does the school know whether she left school due to a pregnancy or not? If the pregnant/mothering teen is receiving support services is she tracked as a teen mother or as a special education student? Given that the majority of schools have not developed policies to deal with the pregnant/mothering student, many questions also arise about how to count the teen mother as a student and how to treat her
Schooling Responses to Teen Mothers • 95
absences due to illness during pregnancy or absences immediately after childbirth. When should the pregnant/mothering teen’s absences be excused and when should they not? Certainly much of the confusion around defining who the teen mother is and the resulting confusing data practices is related to funding for services for the teen mother. Programs that allow (or in some cases require) schools to facilitate services for pregnant/mothering teens decide how teen mothers are defined and tracked. For instance, I found practices that included, girls leaving their regular school, enrolling in an alternative school, but still appearing on the attendance roles in their regular school; girls who attended after-school mothering classes labeled as “behavioral disorder”; and girls who had left school due to pregnancy and were prevented from returning to school because they could drop back into school only at certain times during the school year due to strict attendance regulations. I also found differing data practices in schools within the same school district. As one school administrator stated, showing me the triplicates of forms she had to file on the teen mothers we were discussing, “It could not be more confusing.” While it may be surprising to those outside of education that schools have not achieved better data management and collection on the problem of teen pregnancy, for the school personnel attempting to keep track of the experiences of teen mothers the paperwork is already “burdensome” and as another district administrator explained to me: “teachers [the teen pregnancy teachers] are all coding differently no matter how we try to systemize the forms. The state requires data from us that we sometimes cannot answer, but we have to fill in the blanks for funding.” Further, when directly and persistently questioned, school personnel I interviewed in school districts or states that do offer school-based programs for teen mothers acknowledge that they likely serve a small percentage of the teen mothers in the community. Similarly, a review of the 1994 Children’s Defense Fund (CDF) publication on Teenage Pregnancy in Ohio, reveals that the gap between eligible and enrolled teen parents in a teen parent program, “Graduation, Reality, and Dual-Role Skills” (GRADS), offered throughout the state varied dramatically from county to county, ranging from approximately 10 percent to 65 percent.58 Thus, at best GRADS reached approximately 65 percent of eligible students, while some counties served only 10 percent of eligible students. GRADS summary and evaluation reports do not make such facts known. So, for example, while a GRADS 1992 annual report asserted that it graduated 85 percent of its students, this is 85 percent of the teen parents the program reaches, which in some districts may be a small number of eligible students.59 A more representative figure of the number of teen mothers graduating was reported by the CDF noting that “less than 56 percent of 18- and 19-year-old teen mothers are high school graduates.”60
96 • Unfit Subjects
Combining data absences at state and local levels with conflicting practices of reporting at local school levels yields a portrait of data confusion and misinformation. The data we do have on pregnant/mothering students is, even within the same school district, often based upon conflicting interpretations of how to track and code the teen mother and is likely inaccurate. The result is that at present we simply do not know how many teen mothers receive an education, how and where, they receive it, and what percentage of pregnant/mothering teens are in and not in school. Yet, it would seem obvious that knowing how many school-age mothers are in which schools and which programs, and how they do in the school or program is basic to evaluating services to teen mothers. The author of a 1972 article in Phi Delta Kappan recognized this need and despairing of the lack of data on teen mothers called for schools and educational researchers to begin to address the following questions: • “What effect does the presence of unwed pregnant students have on the values and life-styles of their peers?”. . . “is the student’s sexual activity any of the school’s business?” • “What is the effect of pregnant students on the school climate and the pace of student life?” “Do students relate to each other differently when pregnant students are among them?” “Are studentteacher relationships altered?” • “Does pregnancy affect positively a student’s cognitive development and motivation for learning? And, if it does, what learning environments would most effectively make use of this deepening interest in education?” • “What are the strengths and weaknesses of the various programs for pregnant students found among the nation’s public schools? For example, is a program offering home tutors a meaningful alternative to outright dismissal? What is the effect of isolating pregnant students from regular programs, both on the student involved and her peers?” • “What is the range of community attitudes toward a school’s exclusion or inclusion of pregnant students?”61 Thirty years later these questions remain pertinent and could still be pointed to as primary research questions. Yet we still lack informative research that begins to address such questions and begins to understand school-age mothers’ educational experiences and needs. This lack of data is not only due to educational researchers positions as the “poor cousin” of social science research as Lagemann argues, but also due to the lack of internal discussion, debate, and research within education. In summary, educational policy, local decision making, and discourses are impacted by the many problems encountered when attempting to re-
Schooling Responses to Teen Mothers • 97
search and develop policy and programs for the school-age mother. These problems include, • Lack of research and discussion in education journals on teen mother’s educational experiences and specific lack of discussion of Title IX • Lack of state educational policy to coordinate schools’ responses to and treatment of teen mothers • Lack of data on teen mothers at the state and district level, and when data is collected, a lack of coordination of what data is to be collected and how • Lack of coordination between schools and many community programs for teen mothers • Fear of discussion of teen pregnancy The lack of research—evaluative, descriptive, interpretive—contributes to the sense of confusion and debate over what role schools should or could play in the lives of pregnant/mothering teens. Despite the passage of Title IX, community and education personnel remain ambivalent to providing services and programs for the pregnant/mothering teen within public schools. Local solutions often involve moving services for the pregnant/mothering teen to a community center, away from the visible site of