Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics
FLUID MECHANICS AND ITS APPLICATIONS Volume 71 Series Editor: R. MOREAU MADYLAM Ecole Nationale Supérieure d'Hydraulique de Grenoble Boîte Postale 95 38402 Saint Martin d'Hères Cedex, France
Aims and Scope of the Series The purpose of this series is to focus on subjects in which fluid mechanics plays a fundamental role. As well as the more traditional applications of aeronautics, hydraulics, heat and mass transfer etc., books will be published dealing with topics which are currently in a state of rapid development, such as turbulence, suspensions and multiphase fluids, super and hypersonic flows and numerical modelling techniques. It is a widely held view that it is the interdisciplinary subjects that will receive intense scientific attention, bringing them to the forefront of technological advancement. Fluids have the ability to transport matter and its properties as well as transmit force, therefore fluid mechanics is a subject that is particulary open to cross fertilisation with other sciences and disciplines of engineering. The subject of fluid mechanics will be highly relevant in domains such as chemical, metallurgical, biological and ecological engineering. This series is particularly open to such new multidisciplinary domains. The median level of presentation is the first year graduate student. Some texts are monographs defining the current state of a field; others are accessible to final year undergraduates; but essentially the emphasis is on readability and clarity.
For a list of related mechanics titles, see final pages.
Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics Proceedings of the NATO ARW held in Zakopane, Poland, 2–7 September 2001, Sponsored as an IUTAM Symposium by the International Union of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics Edited by
K. BAJER Warsaw University, Institute of Geophysics, Warsaw, Poland and
H.K. MOFFATT University of Cambridge, Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics, Cambridge, United Kingdom
KLUWER ACADEMIC PUBLISHERS NEW YORK, BOSTON, DORDRECHT, LONDON, MOSCOW
eBook ISBN: Print ISBN:
0-306-48420-X 1-4020-0980-1
©2004 Kluwer Academic Publishers New York, Boston, Dordrecht, London, Moscow Print ©2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers Dordrecht All rights reserved No part of this eBook may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, recording, or otherwise, without written consent from the Publisher Created in the United States of America Visit Kluwer Online at: and Kluwer's eBookstore at:
http://kluweronline.com http://ebooks.kluweronline.com
International Scientific Committee K. BAJER M. FARGE J. JIMENEZ S. KIDA R. KRASNY H.K. MOFFATT A. NORDLUND A.E. PERRY D. PULLIN
(co-chairman)
(co-chairman)
Warsaw Paris Madrid Nagoya Ann Arbor Cambridge Copenhagen Melbourne Pasadena
Local Organising Committee K. BAJER M. BRANICKI S. DROBNIAK A. MROWIEC M. NUREK-MALINOWSKA A. PALCZEWSKI A. STYCZEK
(chairman)
Sponsors
NATO International Union of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics (IUTAM) Office of Naval Research International Field Office (ONRIFO)
Warsaw University Institute of Geophysics (IGF UW)
PROFESSOR ANTHONY E. PERRY - 19.2.1937 TO 3.1.2001 Tony Perry published extensively in the field of fluid mechanics and aerodynamics in both experimental and theoretical areas. He pioneered many aspects of turbulence studies, three-dimensional flow separation, flow pattern topology, and vortex shedding processes. Tony was also internationally renowned for his work in the study of turbulent boundary layers using hot-wire anemometry. Throughout his career as a member of the academic staff at the University of Melbourne, he spent extended periods at places such as Caltech, Stanford, Princeton, NASA Ames, Harvard, DFVLR Gottingen, and Cambridge. In 1992 he was a Sherman Fairchild Distinguished Scholar at GALCIT Caltech, Pasadena. In 1996 he held the Clark B. Millikan Chair of Aeronautics for distinguished visitors at Caltech, and in 1999 a Rothschild Visiting Professorship at the Isaac Newton Institute for Mathematical Sciences at Cambridge University. In 1985 Anthony Perry was elected Fellow of the Australian Academy of Sciences and in 1998 he was elected Fellow of the American Physical Society. Tony was a great engineer and scientist but he will mostly be remembered for his lectures at many international conferences around the world. In his flamboyant style he would entertain his audience with his simple explanations of the topology of complex three-dimensional flow patterns. He was an inspiration to all the graduate students at the University of Melbourne. When there were signs that he would not be able to make it to Zakopane he told Keith Higgins, who had just started his PhD with me, that he had to select a topic which would be not only of scientific interest but also “entertaining”. IUTAM was kind enough to invite us to Zakopane and to invite Keith Higgins to “entertain in the style of Tony Perry”.
Associate Professor M.S. Chong Department of Mechanical and Manufacturing Engineering University of Melbourne.
Postal and Internet addresses of all authors and colour versions of some figures in this volume are available on the conference website:
www.igf.fuw.edu.pl/IUTAM
Contents
Preface
xv
Part I Vortex structure, stability and evolution Simulation of vortex sheet roll-up: chaos, azimuthal waves, ring merger Robert KRASNY, Keith LINDSAY & Monika NITSCHE
3
Merging of non-symmetric Burgers vortices Keith HIGGINS, M. S. CHONG & Andrew OOI
13
Effect of stretching on vortices with axial flow Maurice ROSSI, Ivan DELBENDE & Stéphane LE DIZÈS
19
Optimal two-dimensional perturbations in a stretched shear layer Stéphane LE DIZÈS
25
Advection–diffusion of a passive scalar in the flow of a decaying vortex Konrad BAJER, Andrew P. BASSOM & Andrew D. GILBERT
31
Linear stability of a vortex ring revisited Yasuhide FUKUMOTO & Yuji HATTORI
37
The Vortex–in–cell method for the study of three–dimensional vortex structures Henryk KUDELA &
49
L-transition from right-to left-handed helical vortices Valery OKULOV, Jens N. SØRENSEN & Lars K. VOIGT
55
Dynamical behaviour of counter-current axisymmetric shear flows Xilin XIE, Weiwei MA & Huiliang ZHOU
61
Part II
Singular vortex filaments
Complexity measures of tangled vortex filaments Carlo F. BARENGHI, David C. SAMUELS & Renzo L. RICCA xi
69
xii
TUBES, SHEETS AND SINGULARITIES IN FLUID DYNAMICS
Corotating five point vortices in a plane Tatsuyuki NAKAKI
75
On motion of a double helical vortex in a cylindrical tube Pavel A. KUIBIN
81
Intensive and weak mixing in the chaotic region of a velocity field Alexandre GOURJII
87
Evolution of the anisotropy of the quantum vortex tangle Tomasz LIPNIACKI
93
Motion of vortex lines in quantum mechanics
99
Part III Magnetic structure, topology and reconnection Magnetic dissipation: spatial and temporal structure Åke NORDLUND
107
Current sheets in the Sun’s corona Eric PRIEST
115
A model for magnetic reconnection H.K. MOFFATT & R.E. HUNT
125
Reconnection in magnetic and vorticity fields Gunnar HORNIG
133
Energy, helicity and crossing number relations for complex flows Renzo L. RICCA
139
Helicity conservation laws
145
A third-order topological invariant for three magnetic fields Christoph MAYER & Gunnar HORNIG
151
Asymptotic structure of fast dynamo eigenfunctions B. J. BAYLY
157
Part IV Vortex structure in turbulent flow Vortex tubes, spirals, and large-eddy simulation of turbulence D.I. PULLIN
171
Low-pressure vortex analysis in turbulence: life, structure, and dynamical role of vortices 181 Shigeo KIDA, Susumu GOTO & Takafumi MAKIHARA
Contents
xiii
Vortex bi-layers and the emergence of vortex projectiles in compressible 191 accelerated inhomogeneous flows (AIFs) Norman J. ZABUSKY & Shuang ZHANG Interaction of localised packets of vorticity with turbulence A. LEONARD
201
Extraction of coherent vortex tubes in a 3D turbulent mixing layer using orthogonal wavelets Kai SCHNEIDER & Marie FARGE
211
Vortex tubes in shear-stratified turbulent flows 217 Marie FARGE, Alexandre AZZALINI, Alex MAHALOV, Basil NICOLAENKO, Frank TSE, Giulio PELLEGRINO & Kai SCHNEIDER Coherent dynamics in wall turbulence Javier JIMÉNEZ,
229
Some characteristics of the coherent structures in turbulent boundary layers Davide POGGI
241
A singularity-free model of the local velocity gradient and acceleration gradient structure of turbulent flow Brian CANTWELL
247
Spiral small–scale structures in compressible turbulent flows Thomas GOMEZ, Hélène POLITANO, Annick POUQUET & Michèle LARCHEVÊQUE
261
Part V Finite-time singularity problems Discrete groups, symmetric flows and hydrodynamic blowup Richard B. PELZ
269
Diffusion of Lagrangian invariants in the Navier-Stokes equations Peter CONSTANTIN
285
Evidence for singularity formation in a class of stretched solutions of the 295 equations for ideal MHD J. D. GIBBON & K. OHKITANI Numerical evidence of breaking of vortex lines in an ideal fluid Evgeniy A. KUZNETSOV, Olga M. PODVIGINA & Vladislav A. ZHELIGOVSKY
305
Sufficient condition for finite-time singularity and tendency towards selfsimilarity in a high-symmetry flow 317 C. S. NG & A. BHATTACHARJEE Finite time singularities in a class of hydrodynamic models Victor P. RUBAN, Dmitry I. PODOLSKY & Jens J. RASMUSSEN
329
xiv
TUBES, SHEETS AND SINGULARITIES IN FLUID DYNAMICS
On stabilisation of solutions of singular quasi-linear parabolic equations with singular potentials 335 Andrey MURAVNIK Part VI Stokes flow and singular behaviour near boundaries Interactions between two close spheres in Stokes flow Nicolas LECOQ, René ANTHORE, François BOSTEL & François FEUILLEBOIS
343
Effective boundary conditions for creeping flow along a periodic rough surface B. CICHOCKI, P. SZYMCZAK & F. FEUILLEBOIS
349
Steady Stokes flow in a trihedral corner Vladimir S. MALYUGA & Alexandre M. GOMILKO
355
After-dinner speeches
361
List of Participants
365
Author Index
367
Topic Index
373
Preface
Vortex tubes and vortex sheets can be thought of as the fundamental building blocks of fluid flow at high Reynolds number, whether laminar or turbulent. It is therefore important to understand their structure, stability and evolution, and the various non-linear interactions that can occur among them. Similar problems in relation to magnetic flux tubes arise in magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) at high magnetic Reynolds numbers; and the analogies between MHD and vortex dynamics can be exploited in the development of insight in both fields. The dynamics of vortex tubes, sheets and more complex structures plays a central rôle in the description of turbulent shear flows, whose ‘coherent structures’ can be most naturally interpreted as vortical structures subject to both self-induced evolution and the complex interactions with a random environment and with boundaries. The interaction of skewed vortex tubes is a problem of acute current interest, because the intense stretching associated with the mutual interaction when such tubes are close to each other leads to rapid growth of vorticity. Whether this growth is or is not bounded within any finite time-interval is one of the famous open problems of fluid dynamics, and is the subject of much current analytical and numerical work. The papers collected in this volume range over the above topics, and constitute the Proceedings of a NATO ARW and IUTAM Symposium held in Zakopane, Poland, 2-7 September 2001. They are grouped in six parts as follows: Part I Part II Part III Part IV Part V Part VI
Vortex structure, stability and evolution Singular vortex filaments Magnetic structure, topology and reconnection Vortex structures in turbulent flow Finite-time singularity problems Stokes flow and singular behaviour near boundaries xv
xvi
TUBES, SHEETS AND SINGULARITIES IN FLUID DYNAMICS
The volume also contains two papers which were prepared for the Symposium, but whose authors (D. Poggi and B. Cantwell) were unfortunately unable to be present. The fresh mountain air of Zakopane stimulated one of us [HKM] to compose a limerick as an ‘alternative abstract’ for each of the lectures that were presented. At the suggestion of many participants these are included (with the permission of the relevant authors!) on the title page of each paper. Two authors have written ‘response limericks’, also included; another has responded by composing his entire abstract in limerick format! We thank IUTAM for its initial approval and sponsorship of this Symposium, NATO for its generous financial support as an Advanced Research Workoshop (ARW), and the Office of Naval Research (International Field Office in London) for additional generous support. We thank also Warsaw University for administrative support in the arrangements of the meeting. Konrad Bajer Keith Moffatt
12 April 2002
Note added in proof At a late stage in the production of this volume, we have learnt with great sadness of the sudden death of Richard Pelz on 24th September 2002. Richard’s contribution to this volume is contained on pp 269–283. His contributions to the finite-time singularity problem, some of which are described in this paper, have been at the cutting edge of research on this topic of central importance to fluid dynamics. He will be greatly missed throughout the extended worldwide family of fluid dynamics.
I
VORTEX STRUCTURE, STABILITY AND EVOLUTION
This page intentionally left blank
Simulation of vortex sheet roll-up: chaos, azimuthal waves, ring merger Robert KRASNY1, Keith LINDSAY2 & Monika NITSCHE3 1
University of Michigan, Department of Mathematics, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109-1109 USA
[email protected]
2
National Center for Atmospheric Research, Climate and Global Dynamics Boulder, Colorado 80307-3000 USA
3
University of New Mexico, Department of Mathematics and Statistics Albuquerque, New Mexico 87131-1141 USA
Abstract This article reviews some recent simulations of vortex sheet roll-up using the vortex blob method. In planar and axisymmetric flow, the roll-up is initially smooth but irregular small-scale features develop later in time due to the onset of chaos. A numerically generated Poincaré section shows that the vortex sheet flow resembles a chaotic Hamiltonian system with resonance bands and a heteroclinic tangle. The chaos is induced by a self-sustained oscillation in the vortex core rather than external forcing. In three-dimensional flow, an adaptive treecode algorithm is applied to reduce the CPU time from to O(N log N), where N is the number of particles representing the sheet. Results are presented showing the growth of azimuthal waves on a vortex ring and the merger of two vortex rings. Vortex blob methods discrete, Applied to roll-up of a sheet, Will persuade any cynic That heteroclinic Tangles give insights quite neat.
1.
Introduction
Vortex sheets are commonly used in fluid dynamics to model thin shear layers in slightly viscous flow. This article reviews some recent simulations of vortex sheet roll-up in planar, axisymmetric, and threedimensional flow Krasny & Nitsche 2001; Lindsay & Krasny 2001. Vortex sheet simulations encounter difficulties due to Kelvin-Helmholtz in– stability and singularity formation Moore 1979 and the present work deals with these issues by applying the vortex blob method Chorin & Bernard 1973; Anderson 1985; Krasny 1987. This approach regularises
3 K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt (eds.), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 3–12. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
4
R. Krasny, K. Lindsay and M. Nitsche
the singular Biot-Savart kernel in the integral defining the sheet velocity. As a result, the instability is diminished and the computations can proceed past the singularity formation time into the roll–up regime. A comprehensive review of vortex blob methods is given by Cottet & Koumoutsakos (2000). The article is organised as follows. The onset of chaos in planar and axisymmetric flow is discussed in §2. A treecode algorithm for vortex sheet motion in three-dimensional flow is described in §3 and results are presented showing the growth of azimuthal waves on a vortex ring and the merger of two vortex rings. A summary is given in §4.
2.
The onset of chaos in vortex sheet flow
In planar flow, a vortex sheet is a material curve and it is represented on the discrete level by a set of particles with scalar weights for The particles are advected by the equations
where
is a regularised form of the 2-D Biot-Savart kernel. A similar approach is used for axisymmetric flow Nitsche & Krasny 1994. Figure 1 displays the roll-up of an initially flat vortex sheet in planar and axisymmetric flow, yielding respectively a vortex pair and a vortex ring Krasny & Nitsche 2001. At early times the roll–up is smooth, but at late times the sheet develops irregular small-scale features; a wake is shed behind the vortex ring arid gaps form between the spiral turns in the spiral core in both cases. Figure 2 shows a close-up at the final time. In the planar case, the irregular features are confined to a thin annular band around the core. In the axisymmetric case, the irregular features in the core are more dispersed and the sheet folds and stretches near the rear. It should be noted that the computations are well-resolved. As explained below, the irregular features are due to the onset of chaos. It is well-known that the motion of material points in planar incompressible flow is governed by a Hamiltonian system,
where the stream function plays the role of the Hamiltonian. A similar result holds for axisymmetric flow. Insights from dynamical
Simulation of vortex sheet roll-up
5
6
R. Krasny, K. Lindsay and M. Nitsche
systems theory can then be used to shed light on the fluid dynamics Aref 1984; Ottino 1989. One example especially relevant for the present work is the oscillating vortex pair Rom-Kedar, Leonard & Wiggins 1990. The stream function in this model has the form
where is the steady flow defined by a pair of counter-rotating point-vortices, is a time-periodic perturbation strain field, and is the perturbation amplitude. The system is integrable for and chaotic for Figure 3 describes the dynamics of the model. In particular, the perturbed system has chaotic orbits associated with heteroclinic tangles and resonance bands Guckenheimer & Holmes 1983; Wiggins 1992. Returning to the vortex sheet flow, the first observation is that past the initial transient the flow enters a quasisteady state. In this regime it was found that the vortex core undergoes a small-amplitude oscillation which is close to time-periodic. In other words, the stream function of the vortex sheet flow is close to the form given in (4). Using the oscillation frequency, a Poincaré section of the vortex sheet flow was constructed and the result, shown in figure 4, has the generic features of a chaotic Hamiltonian system. The resonance bands and heteroclinic tangle in the Poincaré section are well–correlated with the irregular features in the shape of the vortex sheet (compare figures 2 and 4). Hence the vortex sheet flow resembles a chaotic Hamiltonian system, although the chaos is induced here by a self-sustained oscillation in the vortex core rather than external forcing. The oscillation resembles the periodic motion of a strained elliptic vortex Kida 1981.
3.
Azimuthal waves, vortex ring merger
In three-dimensional flow, a vortex sheet is a material surface and it is represented on the discrete level by a set of particles with vectorvalued weights for The particles are advected by the equations
where
is a regularized form of the 3-D Biot-Savart kernel Rosenhead 1930; Moore 1972. Evaluating the sum (5) for is an example of
Simulation of vortex sheet roll-up
7
8
R. Krasny, K. Lindsay and M. Nitsche
an N-body problem. The simplest evaluation procedure is direct summation which computes particle-particle interactions per timestep. Since new particles are inserted to maintain resolution as the sheet rolls up, the CPU time quickly becomes prohibitive. The present simulations used a treecode algorithm to reduce the cost of evaluating the particle velocities Lindsay & Krasny 2001. The particles are divided into a nested set of clusters and the particleparticle interactions are replaced by a smaller number of particle-cluster interactions which can be efficiently computed using a multipole approx– imation. Treecode algorithms reduce the cost to O(N log N) Barnes & Hut 1986 or O(N) Greengard &; Rokhlin 1987. The algorithm used here follows an approach developed for two-dimensional vortex sheet motion and applies Taylor series in Cartesian coordinates to approximate the regularized Biot-Savart kernel Draghicescu & Draghicescu 1995. The algorithm implements several adaptive techniques including variable order approximation, nonuniform rectangular clusters, and a run-time choice between Taylor approximation and direct summation. The results presented below used up to particles. Figure 5 shows the growth of azimuthal waves on a vortex ring. The initial condition is a circular-disk vortex sheet with a transverse az– imuthal perturbation of wavenumber Such waves have been observed in experiments Lim & Nickels 1995; Shariff & Leonard 1992. Figure 6 presents a simulation of vortex ring merger. Experiments show that two vortex rings moving side by side in the same direction draw close to each other and merge into a single ring Schatzle 1987. This is a popular test case for numerical methods Cottet & Koumoutsakos 2000 and there is much interest in this flow as an example of vortex reconnection Kida & Takaoka 1994. In the present simulation, the rings are formed by the roll-up of two initially flat circular-disk vortex sheets. In figure 6, the material sheet surfaces are plotted in column and the associated vorticity isosurfaces are plotted in columns The vorticity was computed by differentiating the regularized Biot-Savart velocity integral. Two isosurfaces are plotted, (light gray) and (dark gray) of the initial maximum vorticity amplitude. The material surfaces representing the sheets approach closely but they do not actually touch. On the other hand, the vorticity isosurfaces apparently cancel and reconnect as the rings approach each other. Figure 7 shows a closeup of the material surfaces in the ring merger simulation at the final time. In the region where the two rings approach closely the core radius is small. The irregular small-scale features appear– ing in this region are artifacts of the graphics software; the simulation is well-resolved. The core radius becomes larger away from this region.
Simulation of vortex sheet roll-up
9
10
R. Krasny, K. Lindsay and M. Nitsche
Simulation of vortex sheet roll-up
4.
11
Summary
Simulations of vortex sheet roll-up using the vortex blob method were presented. In planar and axisymmetric flow, the sheet develops irregular small-scale features due to the onset of chaos. A Poincaré section of the vortex sheet flow displays resonance bands and a heteroclinic tangle, the generic features of a chaotic Hamiltonian system. The chaos is induced by a self-sustained oscillation in the vortex core rather than external forcing. In three-dimensional flow, a treecode algorithm is applied to simulate the growth of azimuthal waves on a vortex ring and the merger of two vortex rings. In the latter case, the vorticity isosurfaces cancel and reconnect even though the material sheet surfaces do not touch. The simulation is nominally inviscid and apparently it is the regularized Biot-Savart integration that allows the vorticity to cancel. There is evidence that vortex blob simulations provide a good approximation for true viscous flow in certain cases Nitsche &; Krasny 1994; Tryggvason, Dahm & Sbeih 1991, but it will be necessary to perform comparisons with experiments and Navier-Stokes simulations to determine the physical validity of the present findings.
Acknowledgments This work was supported by the U. S. National Science Foundation through grants DMS-9506452, DMS-9996254, and DMS-0107187.
12
R. Krasny, K. Lindsay and M. Nitsche
References ANDERSON, C. R. 1985 A vortex method for flows with slight density variations. Comput. Phys. 61, 417–444. AREF, H. 1984 Stirring by chaotic advection. J. Fluid Mech. 143, 1–21. BARNES, J. & HUT, P. 1986 A hierarchical O(N log N) force-calculation algorithm. Nature 324, 446–449. CHORIN, A. J. & BERNARD, P. S. 1973 Discretization of a vortex sheet, with an example of roll-up, J. Comput. Phys. 13, 423–429. COTTET, G.-H. & KOUMOUTSAKOS, P. D. 2000 Vortex Methods: Theory and Practice. Cambridge University Press. DRAGHICESCU, C. & DRAGHICESCU, M. 1995 A fast algorithm for vortex blob interactions, J. Comput. Phys. 116, 69–78. GREENGARD, L. & ROKHLIN, V. 1987 A fast algorithm for particle simulations, J. Comput. Phys. 73, 325–348. GUCKENHEIMER, J. & HOLMES, P. 1983 Nonlinear Oscillations, Dynamical Systems, and Bifurcations of Vector Fields. Springer-Verlag. KIDA, S. 1981 Motion of an elliptic vortex in a uniform shear flow. J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 50, 3517–3520. KIDA, S. & TAKAOKA, M. 1994 Vortex reconnection, Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 26, 169–189. KRASNY, R. 1987 Computation of vortex sheet roll-up in the Trefftz plane. J. Fluid Mech. 184, 123–155. KRASNY, R. & NITSCHE, M. 2001 The onset of chaos in vortex sheet flow. J. Fluid Mech. 454, 47–69. LIM, T. T. & NICKELS, T. B. 1995 Vortex rings. In Fluid Vortices (ed. S. I. Green), pp. 95–153. Kluwer. LINDSAY, K. & KRASNY, R. 2001 A particle method and adaptive treecode for vortex sheet motion in three-dimensional flow. J. Comput. Phys. 172, 879–907. MOORE, D. W. 1972 Finite amplitude waves on aircraft trailing vortices, Aero. Quart. 23, 307–314. MOORE, D. W. 1979 The spontaneous appearance of a singularity in the shape of an evolving vortex sheet. Proc. Roy. Soc. Land. A 365, 105–119. NITSCHE, M. & KRASNY, R. 1994 A numerical study of vortex ring formation at the edge of a circular tube, J. Fluid Mech. 276, 139–161. OTTINO, J. M. 1989 The Kinematics of Mixing: Stretching, Chaos, and Transport. Cambridge University Press. ROM-KEDAR, V., LEONARD, A. & WIGGINS, S. 1990 An analytical study of transport, mixing and chaos in an unsteady vortical flow. J. Fluid Mech. 314, 347–394. ROSENHEAD, L. 1930 The spread of vorticity in the wake behind a cylinder, Proc. Roy. Soc. Land. A127, 590–612. SCHATZLE, P. R. 1987 An experimental study of fusion of vortex rings, Ph.D. Thesis, California Institute of Technology. SHARIFF, K. & LEONARD, A. 1992 Vortex rings. Ann. Rev. Fluid Mech. 24, 235–297. TRYGGVASON, G., DAHM, W. J. A. & SBEIH, K. 1991 Fine structure of vortex sheet rollup by viscous and inviscid simulations, ASME J. Fluid Engin. 113, 31–36. WIGGINS, S. 1992 Chaotic Transport in Dynamical Systems. Springer-Verlag.
Merging of non-symmetric Burgers vortices Keith HIGGINS, M. S. CHONG & Andrew OOI Department of Mechanical Engineering, The University of Melbourne, Victoria 3010, Australia
[email protected]
Abstract The merging of two Burgers vortices in an irrotational background straining flow at high Reynolds number is studied. Both axisymmetric and biaxial strain fields are considered. The merging events produce fine scale spiral vortex structures. For biaxial strain, a cat’s-eye streamline pattern emerges and vorticity is transported away by the background strain. For intermediate strain ratios, the onset of vortex merging is delayed and the resulting vorticity contours are distorted compared to the axisymmetric case. The merging is suppressed for sufficiently large strain ratios. With a strain that’s non-axisymmetric, The dance of two whorls is quite hectic; They pulse and converge And eventually merge; The whole process is quite apoplectic!
1.
Introduction
The discovery of coherent vortical structures in numerical simulations of turbulence has renewed interest in the properties of the Burgers vortex, a well-known equilibrium solution of the Navier-Stokes equations. The Burgers vortex has been used in the development of many theories of turbulent fine scales, where these are modelled using spatial ensembles of stretched vortices (Pullin & Saffman 1998 and references therein). The Burgers vortex results when a unidirectional vorticity field is embedded in an axisymmetric irrotational background straining flow, where and are the strain rates and field can be characterised by a strain ratio,
This strain
13 K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt (eds.). Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 13–18. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
14
K. Higgins, M. S. Chong and A. Ooi
For the case of axisymmetric strain, and Burgers (1948) obtained the equilibrium vorticity distribution in cylindrical coordinates
Here the circulation is constant and is the kine– matic viscosity. This represents a balance between viscous diffusion and vorticity intensification due to the stretching strain field. A Reynolds number based on the circulation is defined as
The study of the dynamics of non-symmetric stretched vortices was initiated by Robinson & Saffman (1984). They calculated numerically steady solutions for a single vortex in a non-symmetric axial strain field for small , showing how and affected the ellipticity and orientation of the vortex. Moffatt, Kida & Ohkitani (1994) developed a large asymptotic theory of a single stretched vortex in a non-symmetric strain field. Prochazka & Pullin (1998) extended this work to develop quasi-steady non-symmetric numerical solutions for
Merging of non-symmetric Burgers vortices
15
large and large Buntine & Pullin (1989) computed the time dependent merging of two Burgers vortices in an axisymmetric strain field for They showed that the merging produced spiral vorticity structures and eventual relaxation to an axisymmetric Burgers vortex. The aim of the present work is to examine the merging of two Burgers vortices separated by a distance at Figure 1 shows the two background strain scenarios considered. For the streamlines are almost circular in the far-field. However, in the case of biaxial strain where stagnation points appear in the flow and a cat’s-eye type streamline pattern emerges.
2.
Governing equations and numerical method For uni-directional vorticity, the vorticity transport equation is
where Here the full velocity field is written as the sum of the velocities induced by the vortex and the background straining flow
Length and time scales are chosen to be and The governing equations are non-dimensionalised accordingly. The hybrid spectral finite-difference method developed by Buntine & Pullin (1989) is employed to solve (5) numerically on an infinite radial domain. The prescribed initial condition is a superposition of two Burgers vortices, which can be characterised by their total circulation, The boundary condition ensures that all quantities vanish at
3.
Results Moffatt et al. (1994) introduced the function
which represents the excess of vortex induced dissipation over the background values due to the strain field. Here is the second invariant of the characteristic equation of the dimensionless rate-of-strain tensor (Chong, Perry &; Cantwell 1990). Figure 2 shows radial profiles of and D for and the corresponding vorticity contours for strain ratios (a) and (b) at Re = 5000.
16
K. Higgins, M. S. Chong and A. Ooi
The vorticity contours of figure 2 (a) show the emergence of spiral arm structures. These tighten under the action of differential rotation due to wind-up by the merging vortex cores and radial contraction due to the background straining flow. Portions of the arms are eventually wound into the resulting axisymmetric core, or are dissipated by viscosity. Turning now to the radial D profiles, we see that the initial local minimum in D is at the same radial position as the local maximum in The time sequence shows that the positions of the local minima in the D profile follow the positions of the spiral arms. At large times, a single axisymmetric Burgers vortex emerges. Here the local maximum in the D profile occurs at finite radius and in agreement with the asymptotic results of Moffatt et al. (1994). Figure 2(b) shows that the merging event is modified in a biaxial strain field. The vorticity contours and radial vorticity profile at show the vortex cores connected by a thin vortex sheet, produced from an earlier interaction of the cores. The cores are subsequently pulled apart by the positive axis strain. They reach an almost stationary position where the background strain field balances the convective ten– dency to merge. However, at time convective effects dominate and merging proceeds. Vorticity in the emerging spiral arms is transported away by the background strain. Fine spiral structure develops by although the tendency of the core to wind-up the arms is somewhat balanced by unwinding due to the positive strain. Hence the spiral structure is less persistent than in the case. At the vortices have merged and the resulting vorticity distribution begins to relax to a non-symmetric shape. Since the simulation was stopped at this time, it is not known if a steady solution would be obtained in this case. At large times the radial D profile has a local maximum at finite radius, although This is again in agreement with the asymptotic results of Moffatt et al. (1994) for Figure 3 shows the evolution of the vortex core separation, as defined in the inset. All curves intercept the axis at For initially decreases, and then oscillates as the cores begin to merge. For the and axes are aligned with the axes of maximum stretching and contracting strain rates respectively. Here the cores are initially pushed together, as they are aligned with the axis. As the cores orbit each other and become aligned with the axis, increases. Convective effects eventually dominate and decreases. Oscillations in ensue and the merging is completed at a later time compared to the axisymmetric case. However, for (these vorticity contours were not shown in figure 2), the background strain dominates and the core separation increases indefinitely.
Merging of non-symmetric Burgers vortices
17
K. Higgins, M. S. Chong and A. Ooi
18
4.
Conclusion
The merging of Burgers vortices in both axisymmetric and biaxial strain fields parametrised by a strain ratio has been studied at Fine vortex spiral arm structure is produced in both cases, provided that merging proceeds. For sufficiently large merging is suppressed. Qualitative comparisons of the function D with the asymptotic results of Moffatt et al. (1994) show good agreement. Support from NATO, IUTAM and The Australian Research Council is gratefully acknowledged.
References BUNTINE, J. D. & PULLIN, D. I. 1989 Merger and cancellation of strained vortices. J. Fluid Mech. 205, 263–295. BURGERS, J. M. 1948 A mathematical model illustrating the theory of turbulence. Adv. Appl. Mech. 1, 171–199. CHONG, M. S., PERRY, A. E. & CANTWELL, B. J. 1990 A general classification of three-dimensional flow fields. Phys. Fluids A 2, 765–777. MOFFATT, H. K., KIDA, S. & OHKITANI, K. 1994 Stretched vortices - the sinews of turbulence; large-Reynolds-number asymptotics. J. Fluid Mech. 259, 241–264. PROCHAZKA, A. & PULLIN, D. I. 1998 Structure and stability of non-symmetric burgers vortices. J. Fluid Mech. 363, 199–228. PULLIN, D. I. & SAFFMAN, P. G. 1998 Vortex dynamics in turbulence Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 30 31–51. ROBINSON, A. C. & SAFFMAN, P. G. 1984 Stability and structure of stretched vortices Stud. Appl. Maths 163–181.
Effect of stretching on vortices with axial flow Maurice ROSSI1, Ivan DELBENDE 2 & Stéphane LE DIZÈS3 1
LMM, Université Paris VI, 4 place Jussieu, F-75252 Paris Cedex 05, France
[email protected]
2
LIMSI, CNRS–UPR 3251, BP 133, F-91403 Orsay Cedex,France
[email protected]
3
IRPHE, CNRS–UMR 6594, 49 rue F. Joliot-Curie, B.P. 146, F-13384 Marseille Cedex 13, France
[email protected]
Abstract It is shown that a weak time-dependent stretching might rapidly destabilise a vortex, thus providing a mechanism for vortex bursts observed in turbulent flows. This study addresses the three-dimensional stability of a stretched viscous Batchelor vortex. In a fashion quite similar to Lundgren’s transformation, the strain field is almost eliminated from the linear equations that govern three-dimensional perturbations. Such transformed equations, which are reminiscent of those for the swirling jet instability, are then numerically solved in the simple case of a compression phase followed by a stretching phase. Simulations qualitatively demonstrate how strain and azimuthal vorticity cooperate to destabilise the vortex. When the strain on a tube is unsteady, For excitable modes please be ready! By scaling we claim: In a suitable frame, A vortex bursts into an eddy.
1.
Introduction
In turbulent flows, vorticity filaments have been individuated in real experiments (Cadot, Douady & Couder 1995) or numerical simulations (Vincent & Meneguzzi 1991). Their evolution clearly depends on the varying background stretching field generated by surrounding vortices. In this context, numerical studies have been performed where the stretching field acting on a straight vortex is non-uniform, time-periodic or generated by an array of vortex rings (see for instance Verzicco, Jiménez & 19 K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt (eds.), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 19–24. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
20
M. Rossi, I. Delbende and S. Le Dizès
Orlandi 1995; Verzicco & Jiménez 1999; Abid et al. 2002). Moreover new stretched vortex solutions have recently been found by Gibbon, Fokas & Doering (1999). These basic flows, which satisfy the Navier–Stokes equations, describe a vortex possessing both azimuthal and axial velocities, subjected to a time-dependent strain field oriented along with its axis. Such solutions are different from the previously studied cases and more pertinent to the description of real turbulent flows since both basic axial and azimuthal vorticity are present and the vorticity field is no longer aligned with a principal direction of strain. In this work, which addresses the dynamics of infinitesimal three-dimensional perturbations superimposed on such an unsteady stretched vortex, it is shown that another main consequence follows: the interaction between axial and azimuthal basic vorticity components gives rise, as in an unstretched swirling jet (see Lessen, Singh & Paillet 1974; Mayer & Powell 1992). to a powerful instability mechanism. Indeed, the cooperation between the classical swirling jet instability and stretching might destabilise the stretched basic vortex flow.
2.
The basic vortex flow.
A new set of exact Navier–Stokes solutions which include a global stretching effect, has recently been obtained by Gibbon et al. (1999). These solutions differ from the earlier solutions by Lundgren (1982) by two main features: stretching may be non-uniform and axial velocities are present. Here we put the emphasis on the second feature and we select an axisymmetric velocity field which reads, in polar coordinates as:
This flow is a combination of an unsteady linear strain field, an axisymmetric vortex (2) of constant circulation and an unsteady axial jet (3) of initial centerline velocity The core size which is identical for axial and azimuthal velocities, depends on kinematic viscosity and strain rate via
Effect of stretching on vortices with axial flow
where the modified time
21
is defined through the dimensionless quantity
and clearly coincides with real time for zero rate of strain At each time these expressions characterise an instantaneous Batchelor vortex of radius and swirl number (the typical ratio between characteristic azimuthal and axial velocities) Other flow profiles can be used but the present choice is natural since the stability properties of the unstretched Batchelor vortex are rather well-documented. Solutions (2)–(3) are clearly more general than the classical Burgers vortex as vorticity is not necessarily aligned along with the vortex axis or with a principal direction of strain. More importantly, it is easily checked that axial vorticity is enhanced (resp. reduced ) by stretching (resp. compression) while azimuthal vorticity is reduced (resp. enhanced). This dynamical exchange between vorticity components makes these solutions better candidates for vortex filament models. Note that quantity might a priori follow any time dependence. In a turbulent environment, this variation models the action of large structures on the vortex, i.e. it is linked to the dynamics of distant vortices. Such an explicit relation is not considered here. However, we expect quantity to fluctuate with a characteristic time larger than the vortex turnover time.
3.
Three-dimensional stability equations.
Using time and space rescalings, Gibbon et al. (1999) have shown that the stretched solution and the classical unstretched selfsimilar Batchelor vortex are connected. In the present section, we extend this property to the three-dimensional stability of this basic flow, i.e. we provide a connection between equations governing infinitesimal threedimensional perturbations of the stretched solution to those governing infinitesimal disturbances of its unstretched diffusing Batchelor vortex. Infinitesimal fluctuations of pressure and velocity (here written in polar coordinates) superimposed upon velocity field are governed by a linear system inhomogeneous with respect to time and spatial coordinates and Because of these explicit dependences, such a stability problem cannot be simplified by standard Fourier transform techniques. In order to handle this difficulty, three transformations
22
M. Rossi, I. Delbende and S. Le Dizès
are now applied on the stability equations. The first two were previously used by Lundgren to relate the stretched and unstretched basic vortex solution. The change of variable for when written in terms of a time-dependent wavenumber, is commonly used in the context of inertial waves or rapid distortion theory. Both changes do neither modify the partial derivatives with respect to nor affect the elementary volume but they do eliminate terms relative to stretching or the explicit Finally, the additional transformations
are introduced to preserve the ratio between perturbation and basic state or else to remove the amplification factor affecting perturbation amplitudes due to external strain. After completion, the transformed linear system is quite close to the classical 3D stability of the vinstretched basic flow state: it differs only through the presence of terms associated with For details, the reader may consult a forthcoming article which will appear in JFM. The 2D stability of a stretched vortex (2)–(3) is directly related to the 2D stability problem for its unstretched and diffusing companion via these various transformations. For the general 3D stability problem, a quasi-static approximation may be assumed in which the linear stability characteristics are directly connected to those of an unstretched Batchelor vortex as follows. Near a time viscous diffusion may be neglected in the basic state: a char– acteristic length scale for radial variable is then given by the core size and a characteristic time scale by In turbu– lence studies, stretching due to large scales is small with respect to the velocity inside the vortex: we may hence assume As a result, although it might be of order one, is slowly evolving in time since in dimensionless form and can thus be considered frozen to its value Let us now employ as scale for velocity components and as a scale for veloc– ity component as a scale for pressure and as a scale for The dimensionless quasi-static equations become identical to equations governing the linear perturbations of an unstretched Batchelor vortex with swirl number and Reynolds num– ber Within this approximation, we infer that the strain however small may destabilise the vortex by bringing the unsteady swirl number in a region in which the companion unstretched Batchelor vortex is affected by a swirling jet instability. This results in a strong and rapid evolution of perturbations which may disrupt the previously coherent stretched vortex structure.
Effect of stretching on vortices with axial flow
4.
23
Numerical simulations.
Instead of the above mentioned quasi-static approximation, stabilisation of the stretched vortex is considered anew using numerical simulations of the three-dimensional equations. The simplest fluctuation containing a single stretching and compression phase is simulated: for the vortex is compressed with a constant negative strain rate and, for the vortex is stretched with the opposite strain rate Due to lack of space, only the main results are given here (for details, see the forthcoming article to appear in JFM) and only the case is shown. In that instance, the instantaneous swirl number, initially set to decreases during the compression down to the value and thereafter increases back towards its initial value: it thus lies initially outside the classical swirling jet instability bandwith, then penetrates it and finally leaves it. Moreover, the Reynolds number is fixed to Re = 667 and all simulations are initiated with perturbations in the form of a random field obtained by projecting a spatial white noise on divergence-free fields. The numerical simulations confirm the predicted stabilising effect of stretching and they agree with the theoretical framework presented within the quasi-static approximation: indeed, parameter is a good indicator to understand the observed time evolution. In particular, the fluctuation growth phase lies within the instability domain. The transverse flow structure is represented for different times in figure 1 where
24
M. Rossi, I. Delbende and S. Le Dizès
isocontours of the axial component of the perturbation vorticity are plotted at a fixed streamwise location. The physical domain shown is a transverse cut of the vortex centred around its core. One observes first a filtering of small scales and the gradual appearance of a vortical structure. The observed symmetries indicate the presence of azimuthal wavenumbers and which are reminiscent of the most unstable azimuthal modes of the viscous unstretched Batchelor vortex at During the subsequent stretching phase, this structure is finally rolled-up. Compression and stretching effects appear on the average vortex core size. Moreover it can be shown that the growth rate achieves a maximum for axial wavenumbers around 2. In the nonlinear régime, this evolution might lead to the formation of several interwoven filaments. In turbulent flows, vortex filaments are subjected to fluctuating strain caused by large scale structures. The above simulations emulate such fluctuations and provide the following scenario: an initially stable vortex is brought inside the swirling jet instability domain by a long enough compression. If it remains in that region, perturbations may reach high amplitudes, causing the vortex to disrupt into filaments. This two-step mechanism tentatively explains the abrupt vortex destruction as observed in turbulent flows.
References ABID, M., ANDREOTTI, B., DOUADY, S. & NORE, C. 2002 Oscillating structures in a stretched–compressed vortex. J. Fluid Mech. 450, 207–233. CADOT, O., DOUADY, S. & COUDER, Y. 1995 Characterization of the low pressure filaments in three-dimensional turbulent shear flow. Phys. Fluids 7 (3), 630–646. DELBENDE, I., ROSSI. M. & LE DIZÈS, S. 2002 Stretching effects on the threedimensional stability of vortices with axial flow J. Fluid Mech. 454, 419–442. GIBBON, J.D., FOKAS, A.S. & DOERING, C.R. 1999 Dynamically stretched vortices as solution of the 3D Navier–Stokes equations. Physica D 132, 497–510. LESSEN, M., SINGH, P.J. & PAILLET, P. 1974 The stability of a trailing line vortex. Part 1. Inviscid theory. J. Fluid Mech. 63, 753–763. LUNDGREN, T.S. 1982 Strained spiral vortex model for turbulent fine structure. Phys. Fluids , 25(12), 2193–2203. MAYER, E.W. & POWELL, K.G. 1992 Viscous and inviscid instabilities of a trailing line vortex, J. Fluid Mech. 245, 91–114. VERZICCO, R. & JIMÉNEZ, J. 1999 On the survival of strong vortex filaments in ‘model’ turbulence. J. Fluid Mech. 394, 261–279. VERZICCO, R., JIMÉNEZ, J. & ORLANDI, P. 1995 On steady columnar vortices under local compression. J. Fluid Mech. 299, 367–388. VINCENT, A. & MENEGUZZI, M. 1991 The spatial structure and statistical properties of homogeneous turbulence. J. Fluid Mech. 225, 1–20.
Optimal two-dimensional perturbations in a stretched shear layer Stéphane LE DIZÈS Intitut de Recherche sur les Phénomènes Hors Équilibre, 49, rue F. Joliot Curie, BP 146, F-13384 Marseille cedex 13, FRANCE
[email protected]
Abstract The evolution of 2D linear perturbations in a uniform shear layer stretched along the streamwise direction is considered in this work. The shear layer is assumed to have an error function profile. The width and strength of the shear layer evolve in time due to the combined effect of viscous diffusion and stretching. The timedependent basic flow is therefore characterised by two parameters: the stretching rate and the Reynolds number . Using a direct-adjoint technique, perturbations which maximise the energy gain during a time interval are computed for various and . The results are compared with those obtained using a normal mode decomposition of the perturbations (WKBJ approach). Transient growths are shown to be weak in a stretched shear layer by opposition to what is observed in boundary layer flows. A sheet that is stretched, in collusion With limited viscous diffusion, Upon a flat table, Is grossly unstable; But frankly, it’s all a delusion.
1.
Introduction
A vortex sheet during its roll-up or the braid region between two adjacent vortices in a shear flow are typical examples of shear layers stretched along the streamwise direction. The goal of this article is to determine under which conditions these stretched layers are unstable with respect to the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability. Shear layers in a non-viscous flow have been known to be unstable with respect to two-dimensional perturbations since the works of Kelvin, Helmholtz and Rayleigh. Betchov & Szewczyk (1963) analysed the effect of viscosity and demonstrated that the instability extended down to zero Reynolds number. Using a WKBJ ansatz, they also took into account the weakly diffusing character of the shear layer and computed
25 K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt (eds.), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 25–30. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
26
S. Le Dizès
the maximum energy gain that a plane wave perturbation could reach during a time interval As viscosity, stretching is expected to also affect the stability properties of the shear layer. It is known to induce time-dependency by elongating scales along the stretching direction, and contracting the other ones (see for instance Delbende et al., this volume). My goal is here to understand the combined effect of stretching and viscosity by analysing the stability properties of a uniformly stretched viscous shear layer. As the flow is time-dependent, the stability analysis is performed by searching the optimal perturbations, that is those which maximise the energy gain on a prescribed time interval (see Trefethen et al. 1993) . This method allows to consider strongly time-dependent flows associated with slow Reynolds number and large stretching rate. It also captures transient growths associated with the non-normal nature of the perturbation equations. Here, the optimisation procedure is implemented using the direct-adjoint technique of Andersson, Berggren & Henningson (1999). For weakly time-dependent flows, the results are compared with the WKBJ approach of Betchov & Szewczyk in order to quantify the transient growth contribution in the maximum energy gain.
2.
Perturbations on a stretched shear layer
We consider a shear layer which is uniformly stretched along the streamwise direction and which possesses a velocity field of the form :
where erf is the error function. The stretching rate positive constant such that the velocity magnitude of the shear layer vary according to
is assumed to be a and the width
with Here, both initial width and initial velocity magnitude are normalised. Thus the basic flow evolution only depends on two parameters: the strain rate and the (initial) Reynolds number . This Navier-Stokes solution is different from the so-called Burgers layer which is stretched along the vorticity direction (see Beronov, 1997).
Optimal two-dimensional perturbations in a stretched shear layer
27
Here, the width of the shear layer goes to a non-zero constant for large time but the vorticity magnitude decreases exponentially to zero. The goal of the paper is to analyse the dynamics of linear perturbations on this time-dependent flow. The equations satisfied by 2D linear disturbances are obtained by linearising the Navier-Stokes equations around the basic flow (1). The stretching terms can be eliminated by transforming the spatial variables according to with given by (3). This leads to equations homogeneous with respect to the modified streamwise variable This permits to do a modeby-mode analysis where perturbation vorticity and streamfunction are given, for each wavenumber by
Using these expressions, the governing equations for to reduce to:
3.
and
are found
Optimal perturbations
As the perturbation equations (5a,b) contain explicit time-dependency in both S and the behaviour of the perturbations is expected to vary in time. The relevant quantity to characterise a perturbation is thus no longer its growth rate but instead its energy gain during a given time interval. Here, we shall consider an energy density defined for each wavenumber by
such that the energy gain on is given by When and the time-dependency is weak: the perturbation can be searched under the form of a local normal mode (WKBJ approach). Thus, at each instant, the WKBJ perturbation has a local growth rate Using equations (5a,b), one can show that is given by
where is the dispersion relation of a normalised shear layer with an error function profile. From (7), a WKBJ estimate for the
28
energy gain
S. Le Dizès
is provided by
The optimal gain is obtained by maximising the gain over all the perturbations without any assumption on the form of the perturbation. It can be computed by a optimisation procedure based on direct integrations of equation (5a) and of its adjoint as shown in Andersson et al. (1999). The optimisation procedure is not restricted to configurations where and Moreover, it captures transient growths associated with interactions of non-orthogonal modes.
Optimal two-dimensional perturbations in a stretched shear layer
29
In order to identify these effects, it is useful first to consider the case and for which the shear layer is stationary. Indeed, in that case, the WKBJ approach is exact and equivalent to a classical normal mode analysis. Differences between WKBJ gain and optimal gain can therefore only be due to algebraic growth generated by mode interactions. The results are displayed on figure 1(a) where the mean growth rate of the optimal perturbation is compared to the normal mode growth rate for various As expected, it is for the smallest that the departure from the normal mode analysis is the strongest. Note in particular that for the largest mean growth rate is obtained for a stable wavenumber. Nevertheless, the gain difference between WKBJ and optimal approaches remains small for all as seen on figure 1(b). In this figure are also analysed viscous effects. It shows that viscosity does not modify the difference between maximum WKBJ gain and maximum optimal gain. This difference is approximately constant and limited to a factor 5. The first conclusion of this work is therefore that transient growth associated with mode inter-
30
S. Le Dizès
actions remains limited in a shear layer. This flow is therefore different from boundary layer flows where the energy gain induced by transient growths can reach several thousands (Trefethen et al. 1993). Transient growths are also weak in presence of stretching (not shown here). This implies that the effect of stretching can be understood from the WKB J approach, and more precisely from the variation with respect to and of the local growth rate defined in (7). Characteristics of the most dangerous optimal perturbations are displayed on figures 2(a,b) for various Reynolds numbers and stretching rate. Figure 2(a) shows that the maximum gain diminishes with both viscosity and stretching for a fixed The stabilising effect of viscosity on the gain is directly related to the damping character of viscosity on the local growth rate. The same argument applies for stretching as the local Reynolds num[see expression (7)], decreases as ber, which is defined by stretching increases. With the same argument, the variation of the optimal wavenumber with respect to and shown on figure 2(b) can be understood. Indeed, as the local wavenumber decreases when or increases, the initial wavenumber must also increase with and in order to have the local wavenumber close to the most unstable wavenumber during a longer period of time. The spatial structures of the most dangerous optimal perturbation at and are displayed on figures 3 for a case dominated by viscosity (shown on the left) and and a case dominated by stretching (shown on the right). On these plots, both spatial variables are nondimensionalised by the initial width of the shear layer. This permits to compare the wavelengths of each case, and to see the spreading or contraction of the shear layer. It is interesting to note that the most apparent difference between both cases is the initial wavelengths.
Acknowledgments O. N. E. R. A. is gratefully acknowledged for its financial support.
References ANDERSSON, P., BERGGREN, M. & HENNINGSON, D. S. 1999 Optimal disturbances and bypass transition in boundary layers. Phys. Fluids 11 (1), 134–150. BERONOV, K. N. 1997 Vorticity layers in unbounded viscous flow with uniform rates of strain. Fluid Dynamics Research 21, 285–302. BETCHOV, R. & SZEWCZYK, A. 1963 Stability of a shear layer between parallel streams. Phys. Fluids 6 (10), 1391–1396. ROSSI, M., DELBENDE, I. & LE DIZÈS, S. 2001 Effect of stretching on vortices with axial flow. This volume. TREFETHEN, L. N., TREFETHEN, A. E., REDDY, S. C. & DRISCOLL, T. A. 1993 Hydrodynamic stability without eigenvalues. Science 261, 578–584.
Advection–diffusion of a passive scalar in the flow of a decaying vortex Konrad BAJER1, Andrew P. BASSOM2 & Andrew D. GILBERT2 1
Warsaw University, Institute of Geophysics ul. Pasteura 7, 02-093 Warszawa, Poland
[email protected]
2
University of Exeter, School of Mathematical Sciences Exeter, EX4 4QE, U.K. Here’s a blob that’s subjected to swirl; It’s a problem for somebody virile! But right at the core Where it turns more and more, That’s where I get in a whirl.
1.
Introduction
The shear due to the presence of a vortex is known to have strong effects on the advection–diffusion of a passive scalar. If there is an initial gradient of the scalar concentration with the spatial scale large compared with the size of the vortex, then this gradient will decay on a timescale much faster than normal diffusion, making the scalar concentration almost uniform in the vicinity of the vortex (Rhines & Young 1983). The process is governed by the advection–diffusion equation,
which is a linear equation for the scalar field The application of the linear advection–diffusion equation extends beyond the description of tracers carried by the fluid. In flows with a symmetry the same equation governs other important physical quantities. In the evolution of a weak magnetic field in two-dimensional MHD, for which both the velocity and the field vectors lie in the same plane, the evolution of the field is equivalent to the advection–diffusion of a flux function (Bajer 1998). The annihilation of the gradient of the flux function near a vortex implies the cancellation of the field — the phenomenon known in MHD as ‘flux expulsion’ (see Bajer, Bassom & Gilbert 2001 and the references therein). Similarly, the streamwise ve31 K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt (eds.), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 31–36. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
32
K. Bajer, A.P. Bassom and A.D. Gilbert
locity component in a boundary layer is carried by streamwise vortices, the streamwise momentum playing the role of a passive scalar (Pearson & Abernathy 1984, Moore 1985).
2.
Similarity solution
We consider the concentration of a passive scalar under the process of advection–diffusiori in the flow due to single axisymmetric Gaussian vortex where, in polar co-ordinates,
and the corresponding azimuthal velocity is equal to
We solve the advection–diffusion equation (1). The equation is linear and the flow is axisymmetric, so the Fourier modes of
evolve independently, satisfying
There is no natural length scale in this problem so we try for a similarity solution,
and with
given by (2) we obtain
Here is the Péclet number and is the Schmidt number. Therefore, the problem admits a similarity solution valid for all values of Pe and Sc. We will now analyse the regime when and but the vortex Reynolds number is fixed. We focus on the situation when the gradient of is uniform at the initial instant i.e., the mode but the following analysis can be easily adapted to other values of
Advection–diffusion of a passive scalar in the flow of a decaying vortex
Rescaling the similarity variable
33
we obtain
where is the Fourier mode with This equation has a regular singular point at and an irregular singular point at infinity, and is in the form suitable for the WKB analysis with as the perturbation parameter. We take
The regular solution takes the form,
where is now a similarity variable associated with the vortex rather than the scalar and At the second order we obtain
We plot with taken up to the second order in the WKB expansion, with Sc = 100 (fig. 1) and Sc = 10 (fig. 2), for different values of Re. The solution (9) is the ‘outer’ solution valid, in principle, in the region satisfying the correct boundary condition,
Obtaining the details of the solution at the centre of the vortex requires delicate matching of two regions, and the details of which will be given elsewhere. However when it transpires that the true value of the solution at is exponentially small (Moore 1985), so the WKB solution (9) vanishing at is then a good approximation almost everywhere.
3.
Conclusions
We have shown the existence of a similarity solution of the advection– diffusion equation representing the evolution of the initially uniform gradient of a passive scalar in the flow field of a diffusing Gaussian vortex.
34
K. Bajer, A.P. Bassom and A.D. Gilbert
Advection–diffusion of a passive scalar in the flow of a decaying vortex
35
36
K. Bajer, A.P. Bassom and A.D. Gilbert
As a special case, Sc=1 gives the solution of the Navier-Stokes equation obtained by Abernathy & Pearson (1984) and Moore (1985) where the diffusing quantity is the background vorticity perpendicular to the axis of the central vortex. The solution yields a quantitative description of the process of spiral wind-up (Bassom & Gilbert 1998, 1999), giving accelerated diffusion due to the reduction of radial scale and the enhancement of the concentration gradients. Such a situation occurs when a name sheet or another chemical reaction front is wrapped around a diffusing vortex. Marble (1985) studied the case when the initial fuel concentration is given by a step function. The similarity solution (9) and the analogous solutions for higher Fourier modes can be added to approximate the evolution of any initial concentration profile. Both small and large Sc regimes are of practical interest.
Acknowledgments We thank Andrew Soward and Dale Pullin for helpful comments and discussions. This work was supported by the British/Polish Joint Research Collaboration Programme of the British Council and and the State Committee for Scientific Research (KBN). K.B. also acknowledges the support from the KBN under the grant number 2 P03B 13517.
References BAJER, K. 1998 Flux expulsion by a point vortex. Eur. J. Mech. B/Fluids 17, 653–664. BAJER, K., BASSOM, A. P. & GILBERT, A. D. 2001 Accelerated diffusion in the centre of a vortex. J. Fluid Mech. 437, 395–411. BASSOM, A. P. & GILBERT A. D. 1998 The spiral wind-up and dissipation of vorticity in an inviscid planar vortex. J. Fluid Mech. abf 371, 109–140. BASSOM, A. P. & GILBERT A. D. 1999 The spiral wind-up and dissipation of vorticity and a passive scalar in a strained planar vortex. J. Fluid Mech. 398, 245–270. KAWAHARA, G., KIDA, S., TANAKA, M. & YANASE, S. 1997 Wrap, tilt and stretch of vorticity lines around a strong thin straight vortex tube in a simple shear flow. J. Fluid Mech. 353, 115–162. MARBLE, F. E. 1985 Growth of a diffusion flame in the field of a vortex. In Recent Advances in the Aerospace Sciences. Ed. C. Casci. Plenum 1985. MOORE, D. W. 1985 The interaction of a diffusing vortex and an aligned shear flow. Proc. R. Soc. Land. A 399, 367–375. PEARSON, C. F. & ABERNATHY, F. H. 1984 Evolution of the flow field associated with a streamwise diffusing vortex. J. Fluid Mech. 146, 271–283. RHINES, P. B. & YOUNG, W. R. 1983 How rapidly is a passive scalar mixed within closed streamlines? J. Fluid Mech. 133, 133–145.
Linear stability of a vortex ring revisited Yasuhide FUKUMOTO1 & Yuji HATTORI2 1
Graduate School of Mathematics, Kyushu University 33, Fukuoka 812–8581, Japan
[email protected]
2
Faculty of Engineering, Kyushu Institute of Technology, Kitakyushu 804-8550, Japan
Abstract We revisit the stability of an elliptically strained vortex and a thin axisymmetric vortex ring, embedded in an inviscid incompressible fluid, to three-dimensional disturbances of infinitesimal amplitude. The results of Tsai & Widnall (1976) for an elliptically strained vortex are simplified by providing an explicit expression for the disturbance flow field. A direct relation is established with the elliptical instability. For Kelvin’s vortex ring, the primary perturbation to the Rankine vortex is a dipole field. We show that the dipole field causes a parametric resonance instability between axisymmetric and bending waves at intersection points of the dispersion curves. It is found that the dipole effect predominates over the straining effect for a very thin core. The mechanism is attributable to stretching of the disturbance vortex lines in the toroidal direction. When water is pushed through a hole, The ring vortex plays a key role; When the core is quite thin, Res’nant waves are packed in; To grasp them, why, that is the goal!
1.
Introduction
Vortex rings are invariably susceptible to wavy distortions, leading sometimes to violent wiggles and eventually to disruption. We revisit the linear stability problem of a thin vortex ring. It is widely accepted that the Moore-Saffman-Tsai- Widnall instability is responsible for genesis of unstable waves. Remember that this is an instability for a straight vortex tube subjected to a straining field in a plane perpendicular to the tube axis (Moore & Saffman 1975, Tsai & Widnall 1976). When viewed locally, a thin vortex ring looks like a straight tube. For simplicity, we restrict our attention to the Rankine vortex, a circular core of uniform vorticity. The Rankine vortex supports a family of neutrally stable three-dimensional waves of infinitesimal amplitude, being
37 K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt (eds.), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 37–48. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
38
Y. Fukumoto and Y. Hattori
well known as the Kelvin waves. The vortex ring induces, on itself, not only a local uniform flow but also a local straining field akin to a pure shear with principal axes oriented at 45° from the symmetric axis in the meridional plane (Widnall, Bliss & Tsai 1974, Widnall & Tsai 1977). A pure shear with the principal axes perpendicular to the vorticity deforms the core into an ellipse. This is a quadrupole field proportional to and in terms of polar coordinates in the meridional plane. The mechanism for the Moore-Saffman-Tsai-Widnall instability is a parametric resonance between the left- and right-handed bending waves via this quadrupole field. As shown by Bayly (1986) and Waleffe (1990), this instability has much in common with the elliptical instability, implying the ubiquity of the former; the influence of neighbouring vortices is, in the leading-order approximation, incorporated as a linear shear flow. The asymptotic solution of the Navier-Stokes equations for a thin vortex ring in powers of a small parameter the ratio of the core to the ring radii, starts with a circular-cylindrical vortex tube, at Then a dipole field proportional to follows at The quadrupole field comes as a correction at (Fukumoto & Moffatt 2000). Despite its dominance, the dipole field has not attracted as much attention as it deserves. This paper addresses a possible instability that the dipole field can trigger. According to Krein’s theory of parametric resonance in Hamiltonian systems (MacKay 1986), a single Kelvin wave cannot be fed by perturbations breaking the circular symmetry. An instability becomes permissible only for a superposition of at least two modes with the same wavenumber and the same frequency. Subjected to the dipole field, two Kelvin waves with angular dependence and can cooperatively be amplified at the intersection points of dispersion curves if the condition is met. As a first step, we investigate a parametric resonance that may occur between axisymmetric and bending waves. In §2, we give a concise description of the problem setting for linear stability analysis. In §3, the Kelvin waves are recalled. Before proceeding to a vortex ring, in §4, we have a look at the paper by Tsai & Widnall (1976), hereafter being referred to as TW76, for the stability of a strained vortex. A simplification is achieved by implementing the indefinite integrals left in TW76. In §5, we revisit the linear stability of a vortex ring. The growth rate of the dipole instability is compared with that of the Moore-Saffman-Tsai-Widnall instability. An interpretation is given of the mechanism for the new instability.
Linear stability of a vortex ring revisited
2.
39
Setting of linear stability problem
We write down the steady asymptotic solutions of the Euler equations for the circular vortex with uniform vorticity subject to some perturbations as the basic flow fields. We begin with an elliptic vortex. The perturbation is a plane pure shear. We expand the MooreSaffman elliptic vortex (Moore & Saffman 1971) in powers of strength of the shear. The notation follows that of TW76. Let us introduce cylindrical coordinates with the along the centreline of the circular core. The radial coordinate is normalised by the core radius and the velocity by the maximum azimuthal velocity Here is the circulation of the vortex. Let the and of velocity field be U and V, and the pressure be P inside the core The flow field in the exterior domain is assumed to be irrotational and we denote its velocity potential by The first-order truncation of the Moore-Saffman vortex is written as follows:
The leading-order flow is the Rankine vortex which is written, in dimensionless form, as
The first-order perturbation is a pure shear flow given by
a quadrupole field. The boundary shape of the core cross-section is an ellipse with the major axis along Next we turn to Kelvin’s vortex ring, a thin axisymmetric vortex ring with vorticity proportional to the distance from the axis of symmetry, which propagates steadily in an inviscid incompressible fluid. It is assumed that the ratio of the core radius to the ring radius R is very small: Introduce local cylindrical coordinates in the meridional plane, fixed to the ring, with the origin maintained at the centre of the circular core and with the angle measured from the direction parallel to the axis of symmetry. The detail of the asymptotic solution is found, for instance, in Widnall & Tsai (1977), hereafter being referred to as WT77. The leading-order
40
Y. Fukumoto and Y. Hattori
flow is the Rankine vortex (2). At the effect of curvature is called into play, and the perturbation flow field takes the following form:
The streamline pattern in the exterior region resembles that of the flow past a circular cylinder, being characteristic of the dipole field. It is noteworthy that a straining field appears at Roughly speaking, We inquire into evolution of three-dimensional disturbances of infinitesimal amplitude superposed on these steady flows. Following the prescription of Moore & Saffman (1975) and TW76, we seek the solution for disturbance velocity in a power series of a small parameter to first order: The wavenumber
and the frequency
are also expanded as
In the case of a vortex ring, is used in place of along the ring centreline is used in place of
3.
and the arclength
Kelvin waves
To leading order, the stability problem is reduced to oscillations of the circular core of constant vorticity. The dispersion relation for the Kelvin waves is described, for example, in Saffman’s textbook (1992). Suppose that an infinitesimal-amplitude wave of the form is imposed on the Rankine vortex. For later use, we write down the dispersion relation and the eigenfurictions only for the axisymmetric and the bending modes. We denote the or the toroidal component in the case of the vortex ring, of disturbance velocity by Define The dispersion relation for
reads
Linear stability of a vortex ring revisited
where we have simply written
where tions at For
and
where
and
4.
41
The corresponding flow field is
are constants constrained by the connecting condibut otherwise arbitrary. the dispersion relation and the eigenfunctions are
are constants related by the boundary conditions.
Linear instability of an elliptic vortex
The pure shear (3) at deforms the circular core into an elliptical shape and thus breaks the This quadrupole field excites a parametric resonance between two Kelvin waves with azimuthal wavenumber difference 2. Among them, the resonance between two bending modes is of particular significance. We shall make an attempt at simplifying the formulae of TW76. We recall that, in the core the Euler equations are reduced to a second-order ordinary differential equations for the disturbance pressure We find that this is explicitly solvable as
where are constants associated with the homogeneous part. The above expression simplifies TW76 by performing the indefinite integrals that were left in (3.15a, b). In accordance, the radial velocity in the
42
Y. Fukumoto and Y. Hattori
core is simplified. The velocity potential for the disturbance outside the core is the same as obtained by TW76:
where are constants for the homogeneous solution. Notice that the factor in front of diverges at Hence (13) is invalidated in this case and a separate treatment is necessary. Upon substitution from this solution, the kinematical and dynamical boundary conditions at are converted into a system of linear algebraic equations for and in the form:
where the matrix and
is, with use of the simplified notation
As is common, the matrices at are identical with those at In order for (15) to have non-trivial solutions for must belong to the spaces of the images of the corresponding matrices. This condition postulates that
Combining (17) for and – 1, we are left with a coupled system of homogeneous linear algebraic equations for and The flow is unstable when The non-real is possible only when (17) for simultaneously possess a nontrivial solution as demonstrated by Moore & Saffman (1975) and TW76. This requirement gives rise to the desired relation that holds between and For a collision of eigenvalues leading to instability, the maximum of growth rate occurs at The width in the wavenumber range of instability is determined by non-reality condition of The numerical computation of and is feasible with a high accuracy. All of the collisions of eigenvalues lead to instability, which does not agree with the result of TW76. We show in Table 1 the numerical results for a few crossing points of two dispersion curves (9) that
Linear stability of a vortex ring revisited
43
occur close to the axis of The bottom row is the values for a crossing point on this axis to be explained subsequently. Including other crossing points, at the crossing points with is of the same order with each other and is significantly, say a hundred times, smaller than the case of We thus confirm that the non-rotating waves are far more dominant than the rotating ones.
The case of The collision at calls for an individual treatment. The velocitypotential (14) for the exterior disturbance flow remains intact. The disturbance pressure in the core gives way to, to
and accordingly the expression of undergoes alteration. Repeating the same procedure, we arrive at compact formulae for the maximum growth rate and the unstable band width as
These formulae are valid only at values of satisfying (9) restricted to The most unstable mode is attained at the smallest root and the numerical result is shown in Table 1. The asymptotic behaviour of (19) and (20) at large values of is manipulated with ease as
44
Y. Fukumoto and Y. Hattori
The leading-order term of coincides with the growth rate of the elliptical instability as deduced by Bayly (1986) and Waleffe (1990). This term was reached by Eloy & Le Dizès (2001) by elaborating the limiting behaviour of the terms arising in Moore-Saffman’s approach.
5.
Linear instability of a vortex ring
For Kelvin’s vortex ring, it is the the dipole field (5) that breaks, to the of the Rankine vortex. The governing equations for the disturbance velocity and the disturbance pressure at inside the core and for the potential for the disturbance flow outside the core are written out in WT77. To have an idea, we give the of the Euler equations:
The boundary conditions require that, at
In view of (22) and (23), along with (5), a resonance instability is possible between the disturbance fields of the modes and satisfying at intersection points of the dispersion curves. Incidentally, this type of resonance is driven also by the Coriolis force (Mahalov 1993). It is illustrative to carry through a calculation for the case of and The leading-order disturbance velocity and the disturbance-velocity potential as well consist of a superposition of the axisymmetric and right-handed bending waves:
Substituting (5) and (24) into (22) and the remaining components of the Euler equations, we obtain equations for the axisymmetric and bending waves at Remarkably, these equations are again solvable. For the disturbance pressure and the velocity-potential disturbance are
Linear stability of a vortex ring revisited
For
the disturbance pressure
45
is
and the velocity-potential disturbance takes the same form as (26). Imposition of the boundary conditions (23) yields systems of inhomogeneous linear algebraic equations for and in the case of and for and in the case of The matrices at are identical with those at The solvability condition brings in a system of homogeneous linear algebraic equations for and The requirement that they possess a nontrivial solution for constitutes an eigenvalue problem for given Figure 1 displays curves of the dispersion relations, of the Kelvin waves, (11) for the axisymmetric wave and (9) for the bending wave Curves for are drawn with solid lines, whereas those for are drawn with dashed lines. The axisymmetric wave has two types of infinite branches symmetrically with respect to the horizontal axis either increasing or decreasing with Among the curves of the bending wave, the primary mode, being drawn with a thick solid line, is isolated. An infinite number of the remaining curves are called the Bessel modes. The branches increasing with correspond to waves rotating faster than the basic circulatory flow, while the opposite is true for the decreasing branches. The maximum of growth rate, if the instability occurs, is attained at We compute the value of with at many of the
46
Y. Fukumoto and Y. Hattori
intersection points. The primary branch, of has turned out to be totally irrelevant to the instability, and hence is ignored. The correction of the frequency takes non-real values only at the intersection points between the increasing branches of and the decreasing branches of Among all the intersection points looked at so far, the maximum growth rate is obtained at the intersection point with the smallest
between the first branches of and the Bessel mode maximum growth rate and the band width in
The are
Relatively large growth rate is attained at the intersections of the same branches of and the The longer waves may have some relevance to the oscillatory deformations of elliptical and triangular shapes touched upon by Shariff, Verzicco & Orlandi (1994). We need to be cautious about the smallness of the value of In the higher-order asymptotic solution for the vortex ring, the secondorder correction is a straining field (WT77, Fukumoto & Moffatt 2000). The growth rate of the resonance between and modes and the growth rate of the Moore-Saffman-TsaiWidnall instability (§4) are highly competitive. Comparison with the result of WT77 concludes that the present mechanism predominates over the other when the vortex ring is very thin:
Linear stability of a vortex ring revisited
47
Eloy & Le Dizès (2001) showed that the instability of the Rankine vortex subject to shear flow can be explained by parallelisation of the direction of stretching due to the shear and the disturbance vorticity. For the present case of a vortex ring, the strain tensor due to the first-order flow (5) is
Its eigenvalues and corresponding eigenvectors read
The direction of maximum stretching is the unit vector along the ring centreline, for and otherwise. Thus it would be interesting to investigate correlation between these eigenvectors and the unstable modes. Figure 2a shows the pdf’s of angles between vorticity and eigenvectors for the unstable case Here the pdf’s are weighted by the magnitude of vorticity. Note that uniform distribution corresponds to in three dimensions. It is seen that the vorticity is almost parallel to
48
Y. Fukumoto and Y. Hattori
Since the eigenvalue which corresponds to is positive for and negative for the corresponding pdf is decomposed into positive part and negative part in figure 2b. It shows that the positive part exceeds the negative part which implies that the alignment with gives positive stretching on average. The present instability is possibly due to the stretching in the toroidal direction. The solvability of problem rests on the assumption of uniform vorticity to leading order. This is not the case of a general vorticity distribution. To be worse, a critical layer would make its appearance in a thin region encircling the core as surmised by Kop’ev & Chernyshev (2000). These and other factors bearing with a practical situation wait for a further investigation.
References BAYLY, B. J. 1986 Three-dimensional instability of elliptical flow. Phys. Rev. Lett. 57, 2160–2163. ELOY, C. & LE DIZÈS, S. 2001 Stability of the Rankine vortex in a multipolar strain field Phys. Fluids 13, 660–676. FUKUMOTO, Y. & MOFFATT, H. K. 2000 Motion and expansion of a viscous vortex ring. Part 1. A higher-order asymptotic formula for the velocity. J. Fluid Mech. 417, 1–45. KOP’EV, V. F. & CHERNYSHEV, S. A. 2000 Vortex ring oscillations, the development of turbulence in vortex rings and generation of sound. Phys. Uspekhi 43, 663–690. MACKAY, R. S. 1986 Stability of equilibria of Hamiltonian system. In Nonlinear Phenomena and Chaos (ed. S. Sarkar), pp. 254–270. Adam Hilger, Bristol. MAHALOV, A. 1993 The instability of rotating fluid columns subjected to a weak external Coriolis force. Phys. Fluids A 5, 891–900. MOORE, D. W. & SAFFMAN, P. G. 1971 Structure of a line vortex in an imposed strain. In Aircraft Wake Turbulence and its Detection (ed. J. H. Olsen, A. Goldburg & M. Rogers), pp. 339–354. Plenum. MOORE, D. W. & SAFFMAN, P. G. 1975 The instability of a straight vortex filament in a strain field. Proc. Roy. Soc. Land. A 346, 413–425. SAFFMAN, P. G. 1992 Vortex Dynamics, Chaps. 3, 10. Cambridge University Press. SHARIFF, K., VERZICCO, R. & ORLANDI, P. 1994 A numerical study of threedimensional vortex ring instabilities: viscous corrections and early nonlinear stage. J. Fluid Mech. 279, 351–375. TSAI, C.-Y. & WIDNALL, S. E. 1976 The stability of short waves on a straight vortex filament in a weak externally imposed strain field. J. Fluid Mech. 73, 721–733. WALEFFE, F. 1990 On the three-dimensional instability of strained vortices. Phys. Fluids A 2, 776–780. WIDNALL, S. E., BLISS, D. B. & TSAI, C.-Y. 1974 The instability of short waves on a vortex ring. J. Fluid Mech. 66, 35–47. WIDNALL, S. E. & TSAI, C.-Y. 1977 The instability of the thin vortex ring of constant vorticity. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Land. A 287, 273–305.
The vortex-in-cell method for the study of three-dimensional vortex structures Henryk KUDELA, Pawel REGUCKI Wroclaw University of Technology, 27, 50-370 Poland
[email protected],
[email protected] Abstract The vortex particle method for numerical simulation of the 3D vortex structure evolution was used. Validation of the method was tested for the study of a single vortex ring by comparing the computed translation velocity with the theoretical formula and for the leap-frogging phenomenon for two rings with the same circulation. Our paper is clear as a bell On the method of vortex-in-cell; For vortical strings And leap-frogging rings The method works plausibly well.
1.
Introduction
Vorticity plays a fundamental role in all real fluid dynamic phenomena and for this reason the vortex method in the study of the fluid dynamics cannot be overestimated. In computation the “vortex particle” permits direct tracing for the evolution of the vorticity. Now it seems that the 2D vortex particle method is well grounded in that many numerical and theoretical results have been obtained (Ould Salihi & at al 2000, Kudela 1999). On the other hand, the 3D vortex method must still be developed. Generally the vortex method can be divided on the direct, free grid method based on the Biot-Savart law (Leonard 1985, Knio & Ghoniem 1990, Winckelmans & Leonard 1993) and vortex-in-cell methods where a grid is used for the velocity calculation but particles are used to track the vorticity (Christiansen 1973, Zawadzki & Aref 1991, Cottet 2000). The vortex-in-cell method is much faster then the free grid vortex method. Despite the fact that vorticity is divergence free, we introduced to the computation a vector particle that carries the “mass” of the vorticity. We are going to build a 3D program for the simulation of the viscous fluid flow using the vortex-in-cell method. Components that must be
49 K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt (eds.), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 49–54. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
50
H. Kudela and P. Regucki
included in such a program should be: a Euler inviscid solution of the flow by the vortex particles and a numerical procedure that takes into account the viscosity of the fluid (Cottet 2000). Here we present our primary results that relate to the inviscid Euler equations.
2.
Equation of motion and description of the computational algorithm
The equations that described the evolution of the vorticity in the inviscid and incompressible three-dimensional space are:
where is the vorticity vector and is the velocity. Now in agreement with the spirit of the vortex-in-cell method, the distribution of the vorticity is replaced by a discrete distribution of Dirac delta measures:
where
means vector particle at position When the domain of the flow is covered by the numerical mesh with equidistant spacing then the of the vector particle is:
Equation (2) assures the existence of vector potential the vorticity distribution to the velocity field:
which relates
where the components of vector potential are obtained by the solution of the Poisson equations (it was assumed that
The numerical calculation goes as follows:
The vortex-in-cell method for the study of 3D vortex structures
51
1) To solve equations (6) on the numerical mesh the strength of particles must be redistributed on the mesh nodes
where for we used the B-spline of the first order (it is equivalent to the volume-weighted scheme and influenced only 8 nodes). After the redistribution, equations (6) were solved by the fast Poisson solver. We used the periodic boundary conditions. 2) Using (5), the velocities at the grid nodes were computed by the central difference. The particles were advanced in time employing the Runge-Kutta scheme:
The velocity was computed from the grid nodes velocities by interpolation. We used the second order interpolator from the Fortran IMSL library. 3) Due to the vorticity stretching effect, in the new position the strength of the particles was updated:
The derivatives of the velocity were interpolated from the grid nodes on the position of the particles. For the solution of (9) we used the 4order Adams-Bashforth scheme. This completes one time step and the calculation returns to step 1.
3.
Examples of the numerical results
At first we used our program to test the motion of a single ring with uniform vorticity inside the core. The translation velocity is given by the the formula (Lim & Nickels 1995, Saffman 1993):
where of the core, - radius of the ring, For our calculation we took domain 10 × 10 × 10 and grid step The time step was used as The ring was divided into 100 slices, and in each slice the vorticity was redistributed between 100 particles where the summation is made for the particles that are in volume
52
H. Kudela and P. Regucki
a unit vector normal to the slice). For these parameters the velocity obtained from formula (10) is ~ 0.187 and it is nearly the same as the translation velocity for the ring in Figure 2. In Figure 3 we tried to simulate the motion of two rings with the same circulation that created the “vortex leap-frogging” phenomenon (Lim & Nickels 1995). We found that the evolution of two vortex rings strongly depends on their initial positions and parameters. In Figure 4 the initial position of the first ring was closer to the larger one and its diameter was smaller than in Figure 3. Qualitative changes in evolution between Figures 3 and 4 are clearly visible. The smaller ring passes through the larger one and starts to roll-up around the larger one producing the “tail”. Qualitatively the pictures resemble the experimental one published in Shariff & Leonard (1992).
4.
Closing remarks
It seems that the particle vortex method for 3D flow gives reasonable results and may be very useful for the simulation of the viscous 3D flow.
The vortex-in-cell method for the study of 3D vortex structures
53
54
H. Kudela and P. Regucki
During our calculations we monitored the kinetic energy helicity For the single ring For the case of “vortex game” (Figure 3) H changed from 0 to for the case from Figure 4 final helicity was Energy for the single ring (Figure 2) changed less then 1% but for the case from Figure 4 energy changed nearly about 40 %. We suspect that using a smoother redistribution of the “mass vorticity” (Cottet 2000) on the grid nodes will improve the results.
References CHRISTIANSEN, J. P. 1973 Vortex method for flow simulation. J. Comput. Phys. 13, 363–379. COTTET, G. -H. 2000 3D vortex methods: achievements and challenges. In Vortex Method, Selected Papers of the First International Conference on Vortex Methods, Kobe Japan 1999 (ed. K. Kamemoto & M. Tsutahara, Word Scientific (2000)), pp. 123–134. GHARAKHANI, A. & GHONIEM, A. F. 1997 Three–dimensional vortex simulation of time dependent incompressible internal viscous flows. J. Comput. Phys. 134, 75– 95. KNIO, O. M. & GHONIEM, A. F. 1990 Numerical study of a three–dimensional vortex method. J. Comput. Phys. 86, 75–106. KUDELA, H. 1999 Application of the vortex–in–cell method for the simulation of two–dimensional viscous flow. Task Quarterly 3, 343–360. LEONARD, A. 1985 Computing three–dimensional incompressible flows with vortex elements. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 17, 523–559. LIM, T. I. & NICKELS, T. B. 1995 Vortex rings. In Fluid Vortices (ed. S. I. Green, Kluwer Academic Publishers), pp. 95–153. MEIBURG, E. 1995 Three–dimensional vortex dynamics simulations. In Fluid Vortices (ed. S. I. Green, Kluwer Academic Publishers), pp. 651–685. OULD SALIHI, M. L. & COTTET, G. -H. & HAMRAOUI, M. EL. 2000 Blending finite–difference and vortex methods for incompressible flow computations. SIAM J. Comput. 22 (5), 1655–1674. SAFFMAN, P. G. 1981 Vortex interactions and coherent structures in turbulence. In Transition and Turbulence (ed. R. E. Meyer, Academic Press), pp. 149–166. SAFFMAN, P. G. 1992 Vortex dynamics, (ed. Cambridge University Press) SHARIFF, K. & LEONARD, A. 1992 Vortex rings. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mechanics 24, 235–279. WINCKELMANS, G. S. & LEONARD, A. 1993 Contributions to vortex particle methods for computation of three–dimensional incompressible unsteady flows. J. Comput. Phys. 109, 247–273. ZAWADZKI, I. & AREF, H. 1991 Mixing during vortex ring collision. Phys. Fluids A 3 (5), 1405–1410.
L-transition from right- to left-handed helical vortices Valery OKULOV1’2, Jens N. SØRENSEN1 & Lars K. VOIGT1 1
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Technical University of Denmark Nils Koppels Allé, Bldg. 403, DK-2800 Lyngby, Denmark
[email protected]
2
Institute of Thermophysics, SB RAS, Novosibirsk, Russia
[email protected]
Abstract This study is devoted to analysing changes in the helical symmetry of axial vortex structures. The aim is to provide an improved understanding of the appearance of recirculating bubbles in swirl flows. The bubble generation is usually referred to as vortex breakdown, see e.g. Leibovich 1978 or Escudier 1988. The study concerns a viscous, incompressible, axisymmetric flow in a closed cylinder with co-rotation of the end-covers in the regime where the appearance of the first bubble takes place, see Brøns et al. 1999. For the investigated flow regime only one type of change in helical symmetry, denoted L-transition, was observed. The change of helical symmetry provides a possible explanation for the appearance of bubble structures in the vortex breakdown problem.
1.
Introduction
Recent progress in the understanding of vortex breakdown (Okulov 1996) shows that the phenomenon may be considered as a spontaneous transition from right- to left-handed helical vortices that both may exist under the same integral flow parameters. The difference between vortex structures with right- and left-handed helical symmetry (Alekseenko et al. 1999) is governed by the sign of the helical pitch of the vortex lines (a positive pitch denotes a right-handed helical vortex and a negative pitch a left-handed one). Although the theory (Okulov 1996) connects the flow before and after breakdown, it does not explain how the helical symmetry of the flow changes. As shown in figure 1, a continuous transition from a right-handed helical vortex to a left-handed one may take place in two different ways. Either the pitch goes through infinity or it goes through zero. The first (regular) case we refer to as L (linear)-transition (figure 1a) and the second (singular) one we refer to as R (ring)-transition (figure 16). If the vortex ring appearing in the R-transition was added to the swirl flow, without changing input and output conditions, it would 55 K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt (eds.), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 55–60. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
56
V. L. Okulov, J. N. Sørensen and L. K. Voigt
give a simple description of the appearance of a bubble as an induced axial reversal flow (see Saffman 1992). Unfortunately, only L-transition have up to now been observed experimentally (see e.g. Alekseenko et al. 1999). Employing a numerical code, as in the present study, allows one to obtain more detailed information about the bubble structures. Thus, the main objective of this study is to analyse locally the change in helical symmetry of the axial structures in the zone where vortex breakdown occurs and to define the type of transition correctly.
2.
Formulation of the problem and results
The fluid motion in a cylinder generated by rotating both end-covers (figure 1c) has proved to be useful for the study of the secondary reverse flow. Topological classification by Brøns et al. 1999 have demonstrated the richness of the flow patterns. Thus, sixteen different topologies have been detected as a function of the governing flow parameters. On the other hand, the basic topology change, from a flow without bubbles to a flow with one axial bubble, is still not fully understood. Thus, in the present work, we restrict our consideration to this basic case only. We consider a viscous, incompressible, axisymmetric flow in a cylinder of height 2H and radius R (figure 1c). The bottom and top covers rotate with constant angular velocities, and respectively. The three dimensionless numbers characterising the problem are and where is the kinematic viscosity of the fluid. The flow is described using cylindrical coordinates with corresponding velocity and vorticity depending only on In the we introduce an analogue to
L-transition from right- to left-handed helical vortices
the stream function
57
and a local circulation
Hence, the velocity and vorticity fields can be described by the scalar function and the tangential components of velocity and vorticity Formulated in these variables, the flow is governed by two transport equations arid a Poisson equation. Boundary conditions are established from the no-slip assumption of the velocity. For the numerical simulation we use the finite difference code developed at LIMSI/CNRS (see e.g. Daube 1991 or Sørensen & Loc 1989). The transport equations are discretised by a second-order central difference scheme and the Poisson equation is discretised to fourth-order accuracy using three-point expressions for the derivatives. Previous comparisons of results from the solver with experiments for the configuration with a fixed cover showed that the simulations with a grid size of 100 × 100h for and for predict correctly the onset of the reverse flow within experimental accuracy. In the present study we have investigated the particular case where the end covers either co- or counter-rotate with identical and constant angular velocity At counter-rotation, the axial and tangential velocities are equal to zero at the middle plane. The pumping in this case leads to the formation of a purely progressive motion along the cylindrical axis towards the disks (figure 2a). In this case, contours of the stream-surfaces are in the meridional intersection picture shown as two mirror images, consisting of closed and deformed tori. In figures 2 and 3, the intensity levels of stream surfaces and vortex tubes in the meridional intersection are nonuniformly spaced, with different numbers n of the levels determined by where B is or Profiles of the vortex-surfaces are two mirrored sets from deformed semitori, which encloses each other and break into disks (figure 2b). Such a semi-torus of the vortex tube is similar to a vortex semi-ring resting on a disk surfaces. Please note that the vortex rings only can induce a purely progressive motion along the axis toward the disks, and are not capable of generating recirculating bubbles. In the opposite case of co-rotation of the disks, another picture of the flow is obtained. Here the tangential velocities are non-zero in the middle cross-section, and the fluid corotates in the upper and lower half parts of the cylinder. Contours of the stream-surfaces in meridional intersection (figure 2c) shows the appearance of symmetrical bubbles, i.e. recirculation zones with weak reverse flow along the cylindrical axis. In this case the vorticity distribution is easy to describe (see figure 2d). Vortex tubes akin to enclosed cylin-
58
V. L. Okulov, J. N. Sørensen and L. K. Voigt
ders pass through the whole flow domain in the central part of the flow, whereas the structures of semi-torus shape are located near the cylindrical wall. In the following we neglect the influence of the induction of the torus vortices, and analyse only the influence from the vortex tubes on the bubble generation. The iso-curves of and from formula (1), are the intersection of the physical axisymmetric stream-surfaces and vortex-surfaces with any meridional plane. As the tangential velocity is non-zero, the real physical streamlines are three-dimensional spirals, as e.g. demonstrated in the computations by Sotiropoulos & Ventikos 2001. For the same reason, even though the flow is axisymmetric, the vortex lines are three-dimensional, with the near-axial vortex tubes consisting of helical-like vortex lines. To give a measure of their helical properties, we introduce the helical pitch defined as a the pitch of a helix filament touched by a vortex line in a given point. Thus, the dimensionless twist of a helix-like vortex lines is given as or in a more unified, form where is the angle of the inclination of the vorticity vector from vertical. The distinction between real vortex tubes and pure cylindrical forms are neglected, and the thin Ekman-type boundary layer zones on the rotating disks are not considered. In figure 3, two specific flow regimes are depicted. The first is a flow at a Reynolds number of 150, where no bubbles are present, and the other one is at a Reynolds number of 500, where one recirculating bubble appears in the middle of the flow domain. At the lower Reynolds number (figure 3a-c) the flow contains a right-helical vortex (l or K are positive) in the upper half part of the cylinder and a left-handed vortex (l or K are negative) in the lower part (see figure 3b). Thus, pure jet-like profiles of the axial velocity to both rotating disks are formed as a superposition of the flow
L-transition from right- to left-handed helical vortices
59
induced the central vortex structure and the peripheral deformed vortex semi-rings. By increasing Re the helical pitch changes sign (figure 3e). This change in helical symmetry induces an axial dent in the initial jetlike profile of the axial velocity. At increasing Re, the dent continuously enlarges together with a growth of the vortex-line screw is increasing) , corresponding to a reduction of the distance between the turns of the screw is decreasing). At a certain Reynolds number the influence of the dent makes the axial flow component to become zero and reversal flow appears on the cylindrical axis (figure 3f.) It should be mentioned that this behaviour was observed for all analysed aspect ratios. Furthermore, flow reversal took place approximately under the same value of the twist parameter or On this basis, as a generalisation, we conclude that a necessary (but not sufficient) criterion for the creation of a recirculating bubble in swirl flows are that a mirror change of the central vortex structure takes place. Furthermore, the cre-
60
V. L. Okulov, J. N. Sørensen and L. K. Voigt
ation of a recirculating bubble will first take place when the maximum pitch assumes a value
3.
Conclusion
In this study, numerical solutions of the axisymmetric Navier-Stokes equations were used to examine changes in the helical symmetry of vortex lines. As a specific case, we considered axial vortex structures in a steady swirl flow in a cylinder with co-rotating end-covers. The hypothesis that the phenomenon of vortex breakdown is associated with a transition from one helical vortex structure to a mirror-symmetrical structure has been confirmed. Only L-type transition was observed for the considered flow regime. Finally, the computations demonstrate that the creation of a recirculating bubble first takes place when the maximum pitch assumes a value
Acknowledgments This research has been supported in part by the INTAS (grant no. 0000232), RFBR (grant no. 01-01-00899), and the Otto Mønsteds Foundation.
References ALEKSEENKO, S.V., KUIBIN, P.A., OKULOV, V.L., & SHTORK, S.I. 1999 Helical vortices in swirl flow. J. Fluid Mech. 382, 195–243. BRØNS, M., VOIGT, L. K. & SØRENSEN, J. N. 1999 Streamline topology of steady axisymmetric vortex breakdown in a cylinder with co- and counter-rotating endcovers. J. Fluid Mech. 401, 275–292. DAUBE, O. 1991 Numerical simulation of axisymmetric vortex breakdown in a closed cylinder. Lectures in Applied Mathematics 28, 131–152. ESCUDIER, M. 1988 Vortex breakdown: observations and explanations. Prog. Aerosp. Sci., 25, 189–229. LEIBOVICH, S. 1978 The structure of vortex breakdown. Ann. Rev. of Fluid Mech., 10, 221–246. OKULOV, V.L. 1996 Transition from the right spiral symmetry to the left spiral symmetry during vortex destruction. Tech. Phys. Lett., 22(19), 47–54. SAFFMAN, P.G. 1992 Vortex dynamics. Cambridge Univ. Press. SOTIROPOULOS, F. & VENTIKOS, Y. 2001 The three-dimensional structure of confined swirling flows with vortex breakdown. J. Fluid Mech., 426, 155–175. SØRENSEN J.N. & LOC, T.P. 1989 High-order axisymmetric Navier-Stokes code: Description and evaluation of boundary conditions. Int. J. Numer. Math. in Fluids., vol. 9, 1517–1537.
Dynamical behaviour of counter-current axisymmetric shear flows Xilin XIE 1 , Weiwei MA 2 & Huiliang ZHOU 1 1
Department of Mechanics & Engineering Science, 220 Handan Road, Shanghai 200433, P.R.China
[email protected] 2
Donghua University, College of Basic Science 1882 Yanan Xi Road, Shanghai 200051, P.R. China
Abstract The dynamical behaviour of coherent structures in counter-current ax– isymmetric shear flow has been experimentally studied. Two kinds of vortices, i.e., axisymmetric and helical structures, were discovered with respect to different regimes in the forward velocity versus velocity ratio diagram. On axisymmetric structures, two global self-excited oscillation modes referred to as the shear layer and jet column modes could be set in the flow system and the effect of the velocity ratio on the dynamical behaviour of this kind of structures could be concluded as the principle of relative movement. On helical structures, it is a kind of streamwise vortex structures resulting from the jet column bifurcations whose temporal asymptotic behaviour could be described as a 2-torus. We measured the helical flow In a tube at some speeds high and low; We readily reckoned Two meters per second As a critical speed you should know.
1.
Introduction
The study of the dynamical behaviour of coherent structures in the free shear flow play an essential important role in the modern research of the generation mechanism of turbulence. The coherent structures in shear flow could be classified into two groups: spanwise (including axisymmetric) and helical structures. The dynamical behaviour of the wakes of a 2D circular cylinder have been experimentally studied in detail (Williamson 1996), a kind of amplitude modulation type of velocity fluctuations were widely discovered, e.g. near the borders between cells of different frequencies and oblique resonance regions, all of these cases corresponding to the interaction of
61 K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt (eds.), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 61–66 © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
62
X. L. Xie, W. W. Ma and H. L. Zhou
different spanwise vortices. On round (or called axisymmetric) jets, two kinds of global self-excited oscillation modes termed as the shear layer and jet column modes could occur in actual flow systems. The former mode corresponds to the energetic vortices being quite regularly spaced in the streamwise direction and suppressing the vortex pairing resulting in the lengthening of the potential core (Strykowski & Niccum 1991). Oppositely; the latter peculiar to the jet column strengthens the vortex pairing in the shear layer resulting in the shortening of the jet potential core (Strykowski & Wilcoxon 1993). Danalia, Dusek & Anselmet (1997) discovered a kind of streamwise vortices, termed as the helical structure in our paper, in the case of the Reynolds number below a critical value
Dynamical behaviour of counter-current axisymmetric shear flows
63
in their numerical study of coherent structures in a round, unforced, spatially evolving, homogeneous jet.
64
X. L. Xie, W. W. Ma and H. L. Zhou
Nowadays, the standard approach of dynamical system is being more and more widely used to study the dynamical behaviour of coherent structures. This study comprises two aspects: first in physical space and secondly in phase space. The former study includes not only topological structures of coherent structures and their spatial evolution, but also parametric evolution, that is the evolution of the form of coherent structures due to the varying of control parameters. The latter study puts emphasis on the statistic character of attractors.
2.
Experimental Results
The dynamical behaviour of counter-current axisymmetric shear flow have been studied in the forward velocity versus the velocity ratio R
Dynamical behaviour of counter-current axisymmetric shear flows
65
diagram as shown in Fig.l. The detailed description of the experimental facilities and instruments can be found in the paper (Ma, Xie & Zhou, 2001). The well-known axisymmetric structure (vortex ring) plays an important role in the case of in the range from to and a kind of unfamiliar vortex termed as helical structure is prevailing in the case about The main results are separated into two parts corresponding to axisymmetric and helical structures. (I) Dynamical behaviour of Axisymmetric Structures Based on the dynamical behaviour of axisymmetric structures as shown in Fig.2 and 3, the critical forward velocity is defined, subsequently the subcritical velocity regime and the supercritical regime In the subcritical velocity regime, the shear layer exhibits a self-excited oscillation in a certain range of the velocity ratio with a fixed forward velocity as shown in Fig.1 and Fig.4(a). In the supercritical regime, the effect of the velocity ratio could be described as the principle of relative movement, that is making measurements at a fixed spatial position when increasing the velocity ratio from an initial value is equivalent to moving the probe downstream to detect the spatial evolution of the flow system as the velocity ratio is fixed onto this initial value. The scenario of the spatial evolution of axisymmetric structures, based on this principle, could be deduced as follows: vortex rolling up, pairing and agglomeration gaining in intensity with structures unchanged (jet column self-excited oscillation) arranging in an ordered pattern (shear layer self-excited oscillation) after its intensity saturated ’ordered’ tearing ’weak’ turbulence when the forward velocity is less than as shown in Fig.4(b); the flow system evolves directly into ’weak’ turbulence rather than undergoing the ’ordered’ tearing process when the forward velocity is greater than or equal to Correspondingly, the spatial evolution of the temporal asymptotic behaviour of the dynamical system related to the axisymmetric vortices in the supercritical regime, as shown by Fig.5, could be described as follows: limit cycle (Hopf Bifurcation corresponding to vortex rolling up) limit cycle (subharmonic bifurcation corresponding to the vortex agglomeration) limit cycle (inverse superharmonic bifurcation corresponding to self-excited oscillations) limit cycle (superharmonic bifurcation or frequency-doubling bifurcation corresponding to ’ordered’ tearing) chaos (’weak’ turbulence) when the forward velocity is less than the ’ordered tearing’ does not exist when the forward velocity is greater than or equal to (II) Dynamical behaviour of Helical Structures The helical structure is a kind of streamwise vortex. The time trace of the velocity fluctuation is characteristic of amplitude modulation, and
66
X. L. Xie, W. W. Ma and H. L. Zhou
two base frequencies are contained in the flow system that coexist simultaneously. The spatial evolution of the helical structure could be described as follows: the jet column is separated into two parts at a certain spatial location and those entangle each other to form the helical structure, then the two parts reconnect further downstream resulting in the flow system evolving into turbulence in a catastrophic form. The spatial evolution of the mean streamwise velocity and streamwise turbulence intensity on the jet centre line corresponding to different velocity ratio are shown in Fig.6 and are quite different than those corresponds to axisymmetric structures. Correspondingly, the evolution of the temporal asymptotic behaviour of the dynamical system is as follows: the dynamical system directly evolves into a 2-torus through supercritical Hopf bifurcation corresponding to the jet column separation and undergoes transition from quasi-periodic attractor to strange attractor in a catastrophic form corresponding to the reconnection of the two separated jet columns. On parameter evolution, the evolution of the temporal asymptotic behaviour of the dynamical system as the velocity ratio increases from 1 to 3 could be described as follows: 2-torus limit cycle (inverse Hopf bifurcation) strange attractor (subharmonic bifurcation), as shown in Fig.7. The 3D phase trajectory corresponding to helical structure is revealed as a 2-torus as shown in Fig.8, and the correlation dimension is about 2.
Acknowledgments The work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China under the Grant Number 10072018.
References DANALIA, I., DUSEK J. & ANSELMET, F. 1997 Coherent Structures in a Round, Spatially Evolving, Unforced, Homogeneous Jet at Low Reynolds Numbers. Phys. Fluids. 9(11), 3323–3342. MA, W.W. , XIE, X.L. & ZHOU, H.L. 2001 An experimental study on the coherent structures and chaotic phenomena in the axisymmetric counter shear flows. ACTA MECHANICA SINICA. 17(3), 214–224. STRYKOWSKI, P.J. & NICCUM, D.L. 1991 The stability of countercurrent mixing layers in circular jets. J. Fluid Mech. 227, 309–343. STRYKOWSKI, P.J. & WILCOXON, R.K. 1991 Mixing enhancement due to global oscillations in jets with annular counterfkrw. AIAA Journal 31(3), 564–570. WILLIAMSON, C.H.K. 1996 Vortex Dynamics in the Cylinder Wake. Annu. Rev. Fluid. Much. 28, 345–407.
II
SINGULAR VORTEX FILAMENTS
This page intentionally left blank
Complexity measures of tangled vortex filaments Carlo F. BARENGHI1, David C. SAMUELS1 & Renzo L. RICCA2 1
Mathematics Department, University of Newcastle, Newcastle NE1 7RU, United Kingdom.
[email protected]
2
Mathematics Department, University College London, London, WC1 6BT, United Kingdom.
Abstract We introduce and test measures of geometric and topological complexity to quantify morphological aspects of a tangle of vortex filaments. The tangle is produced by standard numerical simulation of superfluid turbulence in Helium II. Complexity measures such as linking number, writhing number, average crossing number and helicity are computed, and their relation to the energy of the fluid is investigated. We found a complexity measure – It really is quite a treasure. – For a vortex entangled, By methods new-fangled; I'll explain if you have enough leisure.
1.
Introduction
Complex systems of filaments occur frequently in nature. Examples range from vortex structures to magnetic flux tubes to polymers, proteins arid DNA. We would like to relate the morphological complexity of such systems with physical properties, such as energy. The aim of this paper is twofold. First we introduce candidate measures of geometric and topological complexity; secondly, we choose superfluid turbulence as a convenient benchmark, compute these measures and compare them to energy.
2.
Vortex dynamics and superfluid turbulence
Superfluid turbulence (Barenghi 2001) consists of a disordered, apparently random tangle of vortex filaments. This state of turbulence is particularly simple if compared to traditional hydrodynamics turbulence. Firstly, the superfluid is inviscid. Secondly, all vortex filaments
69 K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt (eds.), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 69–74. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
70
C.F. Barenghi, D.C. Samuels and R.L. Ricca
have the same circulation (the quantum of circulation). Thirdly, the vortex core radius is so small and the filaments are so long that the classical theory of thin-core vortex filaments applies well. Unlike what happens in classical turbulence, in which eddies can be of any size and strength, superfluid vorticity is always geometrically well defined (it is the location where both the real and the imaginary parts of the quantum mechanical wave function vanish). All these features make superfluid turbulence a convenient benchmark to study issues of complexity.
A superfluid vortex line can be described as a closed curve (Schwarz 1988) where is arc length and is time. The line interacts with the thermal excitations present in Helium II, which can be modelled as a viscous fluid of velocity field the interaction depends on a temperature dependent friction coefficient The instantaneous velocity of a point of the superfluid vortex line is given by
where is the tangent unit vector and the self-induced velocity is given by the classical Biot-Savart integral
where varies along the line and the integral extends to the collection of vortex lines which form the turbulent tangle Equations (1) and (2) are used to determine numerically the time evolution of an initial system of vortex lines in the presence of a given The computer code also performs vortex reconnections when two vortex lines become very close to each other. In superfluid turbulence
Complexity measures of tangled vortex filaments
71
reconnections do not involve dissipation and arise from the underlying quantum mechanics in a way which is well described by the Gross Pitaevskii equation for a Bose - Einstein condensate (Koplik and Levine 1993, Leadbeater et al 2001). In most experiments (Maurer and Tabeling 1998, Stalp et al 1999) the normal fluid is turbulent. To represent we perform calculations using two different models. The first is a steady ABC flow (Barenghi et al 1997) given by where and and A, B, C and are parameters. The second is a more realistic kinematic simulation of turbulence (Kivotides, Barenghi and Samuels 2001) for which
where J is the number of modes used, is a random unit vector, and the directions and orientations of and are chosen randomly but so that the energy of the mode has the dependence of Kolmogorov turbulence. A typical calculation starts with few seeding vortex rings as initial condition (our results do not depend on the initial condition). The initial vortex lines interact with each other and with the background normal fluid, which feeds energy into them. Soon the initial lines become distorted, grow, reconnect, and a vortex tangle is created (see Figure 1).
3.
Complexity measures
To analyse the tangle’s complexity we project it othogonally onto a given plane. The vortex loops are naturally oriented by the direction of the vorticity, so, using standard convention, we assign an algebraic value to each apparent point of self-intersection of the projected tangle. An algebraic measure of the complexity of two loops and is the average crossing number (Freedman and He 1991, Moffatt and Ricca 1992)
where and ing over all directions
and the angular brackets denote averagof projection. The generalisation to the entire
72
C.F. Barenghi, D.C. Samuels and R.L. Ricca
collection of filaments is
For computational simplicity we take only the projections onto the three principal planes and obtain the estimated average crossing number
where indicates that the solid angle average is replaced by the algebraic mean over the three principal planes of projection. Another interesting quantity is the writhing number which measures the average total coiling of a loop. For a single filament one can show that (Moffatt and Ricca 1992)
where the average is extended to the number of apparent, signed self-intersections of The generalisation to the tangle is Again, it is computationally convenient to approximate by the estimated writhing number given by
The linking number between two closed loops and a measure of the topological linking and can be denned as
provides
Unlike previous measures, the linking number is a topological invariant because it does not change under continuous deformations of the vortex strands performed by a sequence of Reidemeister moves (Adams 1994), so it is independent of the projection used. The total linking of a system of vortex lines can be defined by
where we deliberately exclude contributions from self-linking (due to writhe and twist of each vortex filament).
Complexity measures of tangled vortex filaments
73
The final measure of complexity which we consider is the kinetic helicity (Moffatt 1969) defined by
where
is the vorticity and the integral is taken over the tangle volume . Since vorticity is confined only to vortex lines, is a delta function of strength in the direction along each filament of and we have
4.
Results
We compute complexity measures as function of time as the vortex tangle grows, and compare one another and against the tangle’s total length L and kinetic energy E. Typical results are shown in Figure 2
74
C.F. Barenghi, D.C. Samuels and R.L. Ricca
in the case of an ABC flow (Barenghi, Ricca and Samuels 2001) but essentially similar results are obtained when the Kolmogorov turbulence model is used. The initial rate of growth of L is in agreement with linear stability calculations. As the vortex structure unfolds, the dynamics develops structural complexity and entanglement. It is apparent that the length is a good measure of the energy of the system, as in the trivial case of a single straight vortex line. It is also apparent that, after the initial transient, the growth rate of all complexity measures is essentially the same, and is approximately twice the rate of growth of the length. This means that vortex tangle grows by curling up and folding upon itself more than by spreading and diffusing in space.
Acknowledgments R. L. R. acknowledges support from EPSRC (grant GR/K99015) and PPARC (GR/L63143).
References ADAMS, C. C. 1994 The knot book, W. H. Freeman and Co., New York, p. 14. BARENGHI, C. F., BAUER, G., SAMUELS, D. C. AND DONNELLY, R. J. 1997 Superfluid vortex lines in a model of turbulent flow. Phys. Fluids 9 2631–2643. BARENGHI, C. F. 2001 Introduction to superfluid vortices and turbulence. In Quantized vortex dynamics and superfluid turbulence (ed. C. F. Barenghi, R. J. Donnelly and W. F. Vinen), pp. 3–13. Springer Verlag. BARENGHI, C. F., RICCA, R. L. AND SAMUELS, D. C. 2001 How tangled is a tangle ? Physica D 157 197–206. FREEDMAN, M. H. AND HE, Z. -X. 1991 Divergence-free field. Energy and asymptotic crossing number. Ann. Math. 134 189–229. KIVOTIDES, D., BARENGHI, C. F. AND SAMUELS, D. C. 2001 Fractal nature of superfluid turbulence. Phys. Rev. Letters 87 155301. KOPLIK, J. AND LEVINE, H. 1993 Vortex reconnections in superfluid helium. 1375– 1378 (1993). LEADBEATER, M., WINIECKI, T., SAMUELS, D. C., BARENGHI, C. F. AND ADAMS, C. S. 2001 Sound emission due to superfluid vortex reconnections. Phys. Rev. Letters 86, 1410–1413. MAURER, J. AND TABELING, P. 1998 Local investigation of superfluid turbulence. Europhysics Letters 43 29–34. MOFFATT, H. K. 1969 The degree of knottedness of tangles vortex lines. J. Fluid Mechanics, 35 117–129. MOFFATT, H. K. AND RICCA, R. L. 1992 Helicity and the Calugareanu invariant. Proc. Roy. Soc. London A 439 411–429. 4 SCHWARZ, K. W. 1988 Three dimensional vortex dynamics in superfluid He. Phys. Rev. B 38, 2398–2417. STALP, S. R., SKRBEK, L. AND DONNELLY, R. J. 1999 Decay of grid turbulence in a finite channel. Phys. Rev. Letters 82, 4831–4834.
Corotating five point vortices in a plane Tatsuyuki NAKAKI Faculty of Mathematics, Kyushu University 6–10–1 Hakozaki, Fukuoka 812–8581 JAPAN
[email protected]
Abstract Let us consider the motion of assembly of point vortices in the twodimensional incompressible ideal fluid. The motion is described by an ordinary differential equation, and we focus our attention on the relative equilibria which imply the corotation of vortices. In this paper, we analyse the stability of the equilibria when five point vortices satisfy some condition on the strength and initial configuration. When parameters, which appear in the above condition, belong to some range, we show that the equilibria are unstable and that the solution, which locates near the equilibria at the initial time, exhibits the relaxation oscillation. The stable equilibria appear in a narrow parameter range. For some equilibria, the stability is shown by a computer-assisted proof. On the problem of vortices five, For long I’ve continued to strive; Sometimes they’re stable, And then I am able To show how they jiggle and jive.
1.
Introduction
We consider the motion of assembly of point vortices in the twodimensional Euler fluid. When several vortices are in the fluid, every vortex drifts away with the flow due to the other vortices. Such a phenomenon is described by the following ordinary differential equation when the fluid occupies the whole plane:
where and are the complex position at time and the strength of vortex, respectively. The complex conjugate of is denoted by and The equation (1) is analysed for long times and many results are already known. We briefly summarise some of them. When two point vortices are in the fluid, the motion of vortices is easily analysed as is 75 K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt (eds.), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 75–80. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
76
T. Nakaki
shown in textbooks on fluid mechanics. A qualitative analysis of three point vortices are done by Aref 1979. When the number of vortices is greater than three, (1) is not solved yet in general cases, however, some special cases are treated. For example, Morikawa & Swerison 1971 and Cabrel & Schmidt 1999 deal with the problem of vortices at the vertices and centre of a regular polygon. They show the stability of corotation of the vortices. Other results are seen in O’neil 1987, Aref 1995, Castilla et al. 1993, Nakaki 2001, for examples. In this paper, we treat the case where vortices are at the vertices and centre of a diamond: Let and be real parameters. At the initial time we impose
which means that vortices are at the vertices and is at the centre of a diamond. The shape of the diamond is described by the parameter We also assume that
where is determined so that the five point vortices corotate around the origin, that is, there exists a real constant such that is constant in Here the constant shows the angular velocity of the corotation. In this case we call that five point vortices are in a relative equilibrium. The purpose of the paper is to discuss the stability of the relative equilibria. In the following section, the simple case where and is considered. The equilibria are unstable and we show that vortices, which locate near the equilibrium at the initial time, exhibit the relaxation oscillation. In Section 3, we shall focus our attention to the case where Our numerical simulation suggests that the corotation is stable only on a narrow parameter range.
2.
Square-shaped configuration
In this section, we treat the simple case where and the vortices with unit strength are at the vertices of a square and the fifth vortex is at the centre of the square. In this case it is easily found that five vortices are in the relative equilibria for all Nakaki 1999 already show the following theorem: Theorem 1.
which satisfies
Then there is a solution
of (1)
Corotating five point vortices in a plane
77
where
In the above theorem, the assumption implies that the angular velocity is zero, and that and are equilibria of (1). Theorem 1 implies the existence of a heteroclinic orbit. By applying Theorem 1 repeatedly, we find that there exist heteroclinic connections, which induce the oscillation of the five vortices as follows: When the initial configuration of five vortices are closed to an equilibrium (without loss of generality, we can assume that the equilibrium is , the solution of (1) travels near the heteroclinic orbit and approaches to the equilibrium . After approaching the solution goes away from due to the other heteroclinic orbit. In this way an oscillation of vortices occurs. Moreover the motion of the solution is slow when the solution is near equilibria and is fast when it is far from equilibria. As a result, we observe that the vortices do not move for a while, however, they begin to move suddenly and approach to the another equilibrium. After staying near the equilibrium, the vortices also resume moving (see Figure 1). Let us call this motion the relaxation oscillation.
Remark 1. When we can similarly show the existence of the heteroclinic orbit, and the relaxation oscillation also occurs. We omit the details here. If the relative equilibrium is stable against perturbations which satisfy the symmetric condition
According to our numerical simulations, the relaxation oscillation does not occur anymore.
78
3.
T. Nakaki
Diamond-shaped configuration
In this section we treat the case where 0 < b < 1. At first let the vortices at the vertices have same strength. By the standard lingered analysis we can easy find Theorem 2. There exist constants satisfy 1 If lingered sense;
and
which
the relative equilibrium is unstable in the
the relative equilibrium is neutrally stable; that is, 2 If all lingered eigenvalues are purely imaginary numbers. Numerically we find that · · · and · · · . In the latter case of Theorem 2, the stability of the equilibria is not become clear by checking the linear terms. To verify the stability the numerical simulations are done as shown in Figure 2, where we show the snapshots
of numerical simulations with b = 0. 57 (upper-left in the each window), b = 0. 585 (upper-right) and b = 0. 6 (lower-right). In view of Theorem 2, the configurations of vortices with b = 0. 57 and b = 0. 6 are unstable. We also observe that the configuration with b = 0. 585 seems to be stable from numerical points of view. So we can say that, when the configuration can be stable only in the narrow parameter range.
Corotating five point vortices in a plane
79
Next we consider the general case where The parameter range where the relative equilibrium is neutrally stable is shown in Figure 3. To prove the stability we examine the energy of
vortex system, that is, the Hamiltonian of (1) defined by
Let ,..., be the relative equilibrium. If attains the strictly local minimum of H, we can conclude that the relative equilibrium is stable in the Lyapunov sense. Here we remark that the Hamiltonian H is also the first integral of the vortex system in the rotating coordinate because We analyse the stability when the perturbation given to the equilibrium does not change the value of the angular velocity Without loss of generality, we remove the rotation of the configuration. To this end, after Cabrel & Schmidt 1999, we assume that the angular velocity is fixed to the initial value and is purely imaginary:
Here we use the fact that the angular velocity is determined by the moment of inertia and the circulations Under the condition (8), we try to show that the energy attains the strictly local minimum at the equilibrium by the following steps: 1. Compute the Hessian of H, namely
80
T. Nakaki
2. Show that P is positive definite, that is, P > 0. To show P > 0, it suffices to prove that det > 0 for where and is the size of P. The elements of P is too complex to analyse by the standard methods. Hence we use the interval computations on workstations to estimate the value of det if the lower limit of the interval value of det is positive, we can rigorously conclude that det In other words, we apply a computer-assisted proof. The profil/bias library (see Knüppel 1994) is used to make interval computations. From now we show our results on the stability of equilibria. Let 4/3. The equilibria are neutrally stable if The interval computations to verify P > 0 are made for b = 0. 7, 0. 7 1 , . . . , 0. 94. Then we find that P > 0 when b = 0. 88, 0. 8 9 , . . . , 0. 93, which yields Theorem 3. When and b = 0. 88, 0. 8 9 , . . . , 0. 93, the relative equilibria are stable against the perturbations which satisfy (8). For b = 0. 7, 0. 7 1 , . . . , 0. 87 and b = 0. 94 we fail to show P > 0. For general values of our results are summarised in Figure 3. The parameters, for which we can prove P > 0, are in region B of Figure 3. For a lot of parameters in region B (almost any parameters in B), the relative equilibria are stable. Until now we do not succeed in proving the stability for all parameters in B because we use the computer-assisted proof for given discrete parameters We expect that the neutrally stable relative equilibria are stable when the circulations have the same sign, which is one of our future works.
References MORIKAWA, G. K. & SWENSON, E. V. 1971 Interacting motion of rectilinear geostrophic vortices. Phys. Fluids 14, 1058–1073. AREF, H. 1979 Motion of three vortices. Phys. Fluids 22, 393–400. O’NEIL, K. A. 1987 Stationary configurations of point vortices. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 302, 383–425. CASTILLA, M. S. A. C, MOAURO, V., NEGRINI, N. & OLIA, W. M. 1993 The four positive vortices problem: regions of chaotic behavior and the nonintegrability. Ann. Inst. H. Poincaré Phys. Théor. 59, 99–115. KNÜPPEL, O. 1994 PROFIL/BIAS — a fast interval library. Computing 53, 277–287. AREF, H. 1995 On the equilibrium and stability of a row of point vortices. J. Fluid Mech. 290, 167–181. CABRAL, H. E. & SCHMIDT, D. S. 1999 Stability of relative equilibria in the problem of N + 1 vortices. SIAM J. Math. Anal. 31, 231–250. NAKAKI, T. 1999 Behavior of point vortices in a plane and existence of heteroclinic orbits. Dynam. Contin. Discrete Impuls. Systems 5, 159–169. NAKAKI, T. 2001 The analysis to some point vortex problems using computers. Nonlinear Analysis 47, 3849–3857.
On motion of a double helical vortex in a cylindrical tube Pavel A. KUIBIN Institute of Thermophysics Lavrentiev ave., 1, 630090 Novosibirsk, Russia
[email protected]
Abstract New approach is developed for the velocity estimation of a double helical vortex motion in boundless space as well as in a cylindrical tube. The system under consideration is two thin helical vortices winding around common axis and propagating in surrounding irrotational fluid. The problem on the determination of the velocity of the vortices motion is solved with help of formulae describing the velocity field induced by infinitely thin helical vortex inside a cylindrical tube (Okulov 1995) and using the technique of the singularities separation from this solution (Kuibin & Okulov 1998). As a result an analytical formula for the vortices propagation velocity is found with account for the self and mutual induced velocities, influence of the solid boundary and translational motion. The formula contains infinite series from the modified Bessel functions. Nonetheless it is shown that impact of these series is small enough and can be neglected to give a more simple formula. Vortices coiled up in doubles Bring great analytical troubles; But with series of Kapteyn We’re able to obtain Their speed, in the absence of bubbles!
1.
Introduction
The phenomenon of double helical vortex is known for a long time. First of all such vortex is being generated in the wake of two-blade propeller or turbine. Double helix represents one of the possible vortex states after vortex breakdown (Faler & Leibovich 1977). A perfect double helix rotates and moves translationary without change of its form. The problem on determination of the vortex velocity and frequency of velocity pulsations induced remains actual one. In a bounded space double helix can be immobile. Such vortex system was observed in a vortex chamber of square cross-section with two-slopes bottom (Alekseenko et al. 1999).
81 K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt (eds.), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 81–86. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
82
Pavel A. Kuibin
There are known few approaches to the determination of a double helix velocity. Takaki & Hussain (1984) gave a dispersion equation using the cut-off technique where is the wavenumber and is the phase velocity of the helical form propagation. The parameter A depends on the helix radius, and radius of its core, Here L and are the cut-off lengths which are in common case unknown functions of the helix parameters. Wood (1998) had analysed the case of small pitch, and showed that velocity has an asymptote for pair of vortices shifted circumferentially by radians and with equal circulations The problem solution becomes possible due to the progress in solution of an analogous problem on determination of the propagation velocity for a single helical vortex. Ricca (1994) had analysed different approaches of a helical vortex description. During numerical calculations of the velocity field induced by the helical vortex filament (with help of Hardin’s (1982) approach) in its vicinity, the author separated from the total velocity the part responsible for the drift velocity of the helix. Comparison of this result with the quadrature formula of the helix self-induced velocity based on the approach by Moore & Saffman (1972) showed that these quantities behave similarly in a wide range of the helix pitch variation and differ approximately by 0. 25. The solution for the velocity field given by Hardin (1982) represents infinite series which contain singularities of the polar and logarithmic type. Consequently difficulties arise at numerical calculations of the velocity field in the neighbourhood of the filament. Moreover the less is the helix pitch the slower is the series convergence. To avoid these difficulties a technique of the explicit separation of the singularities from the series was developed by Kuibin & Okulov (1998). They found in limit cases of small and large pitch that regular remainder of the velocity expansion in vicinity of a vortex filament differs exactly by 1/4 from the remainder presenting in the formula for the self-induced rotation of a vortex with finite circular core over which the vorticity is distributed uniformly. Recently Boersma & Wood (1999) proved that this difference equals exactly 1/4 for arbitrary vortex pitch. Now it is possible to find the self-induced velocity of a helical vortex through the constant appearing in the expansion of the binomial velocity in vicinity of an infinitely thin helical vortex filament. For the last constant depending of cause on the helix geometry an analytical formula was derived (Kuibin & Okulov 1998) and some simplification was proposed. The present work develops the method of singularities separation on the case of a double helix, both when the vortex propagates in boundless space and inside a cylindrical tube.
On motion of a double helical vortex in a cylindrical tube
2.
83
Statement of the problem
Let’s consider a symmetric system of two identical helical vortices with radius pitch ) and circulation propagating in surrounding potential flow inside a cylindrical tube of radius R. The centrelines of the helices in cylindrical variables correspond to the equations and The vorticity is proposed to have a uniform distribution over vortex cores of small radius One additional parameter we will need is the value of velocity at the symmetry axis, The geometry of the vorticity distribution determines the helical symmetry of the velocity field which in turn yields the following relations (Alekseenko et al. 1999)
Thus analysis of a single velocity component, say will be enough for the problem solution. In accordance with the technique of the singularities separation (Kuibin & Okulov 1998) the circumferential velocity induced by a single helical vortex can be written as a sum of singular, and regular, parts
The members marked by asterisk relate to the velocity induced by the interaction of helical vortex filament with the cylindrical wall. For the singular parts we have
The quantities with a tilde may be interpreted as distorted radial distances with Coefficients before the logarithmic terms contain the functions The variables with indices a or R are constructed by the same rule. The quantity corresponds in some sense to a reflected or imaginary helical vortex outside the cylinder. The parameter combines the angular and axial coordinates,
84
Pavel A. Kuibin
The regular parts read
where and are the modified Bessel functions (the prime denotes the derivative). Here and further, the upper and lower lines in the brackets correspond to the vortex interior and its exterior respectively. When we have a double helical vortex the velocity induced by the second vortex is being evaluated by the formulae (2)-(6) with the replacement by For the case of a single helical vortex with a finite uniform core the binormal velocity of its motion was found earlier (Kuibin & Okulov 1998). As the binormal velocity relates to the axial and circumferential components by the relation then in view of condition (1) we can write the rotational component of the helix motion
New parameter
introduced here means the dimensionless torsion i. e. ratio of the torsion to the curvature; in the same time equals the dimensionless helix pitch The term H appears from the regular part and - from the parts responsible for the interaction with the tube wall: The evaluation has showed that contribution of into does not exceed 1. 5% and may be neglected. In view of these notes H and read
On motion of a double helical vortex in a cylindrical tube
85
Now the problem on determination of the double helical vortex motion is reduced to the evaluation of the mutual influence of the helices and in the case of vortices inside a cylinder - to additional evaluation of the velocity induced by the interaction of the second helix with the wall.
3.
Solution and analysis
We again consider a presentation for the motion velocity of (2) type. From the singular member taken at we find the contribution [– ln 2] entering into the square brackets and { –1/2} entering into the figure brackets in (7). The term arising from the regular part is similar to (8) and represents series with the members of altering sign (multiplied by and in combination with (8) it gives the series for the double helix
In the terms responsible for the interaction with the wall the singular part plays again the dominant role to give together with (9)
The impact from the regular part is negligible. Thus for the rotational motion of the double helical vortex we have
The analysis of the series yields asymptotes at large and at small is the Riemann zeta function). Numerical estimation of at moderate showed that it is two orders less then the first member in the figure brackets and also can be neglected. The axial component of the double helix motion in accordance with condition (1) can be found from a simple relation The dependencies of the velocity components are presented in figure 1. At the small the dimensionless rotational velocity tends to 1 and the axial velocity (at behaves as In At the large pitch the rotational velocity tends to asymptote + 1/2 and the axial velocity decreases as Naturally, at limit we obtain the motion of two thin straight vortices placed symmetrically relative the cylinder axis. Thus, a simple analytical formula is derived for the description of motion of a couple of thin helical vortices inside cylindrical tube.
86
Pavel A. Kuibin
Acknowledgments This research has been supported in part by the RFBR Grant 00-0565463, Council for Scientific Schools Support, Grant 00-15-96810 and INTAS Grant 00-00232.
References ALEKSEENKO, S. V., KUIBIN, P. A., OKULOV, V. L. & SHTORK, S. I. 1999 Helical vortices in swirl flow. J. Fluid Mech. 382, 195–243. BOERSMA, J. & WOOD, D.H. 1999 On the self-induced motion of a helical vortex. J. Fluid Mech. 384, 263–280. FALER, J.H. & LEIBOVICH, S. 1977 Disrupted states of vortex flow and vortex breakdown. Phys. Fluids 20, 1385–1400. HARDIN, J. C. 1982 The velocity field induced by a helical vortex filament. Phys. Fluids 25, 1949–1952. KUIBIN, P.A. & OKULOV, V.L. 1998 Self-induced motion and asymptotic expansion of the velocity field in the vicinity of a helical vortex filament. Phys. Fluids 10, 607–614. MOORE, D.W. & SAFFMAN, P.G. 1972 The motion of a vortex filament with axial flow. Trans. R. Soc. London Ser. A 272, 403–429. OKULOV, V.L. 1995 The velocity field induced by vortex filaments with cylindric and conic supporting surface. Russian J. Eng. Thermophys. 5, 63–75. RICCA, R.L. 1994 The effect of torsion on the motion of a helical vortex filament. J. Fluid Mech. 273, 241–259. TAKAKI, R. & HUSSAIN, A.K.M.F. 1984 Dynamics of entangled vortex filaments. Phys. Fluids 27, 761–763. WOOD, D. H. 1998 The velocity of the tip vortex of a horizontal-axis wind turbine at high tip speed ratio. Renewable Energy 13, 51–54.
Intensive and weak mixing in the chaotic region of a velocity field Alexandre GOURJII Institute of Hydromechanics, National Academy of Science of Ukraine 8/4 Zhelyabov str., Kiev 03680, Ukraine
[email protected]
Abstract The local stirring properties of a passive fluid domain with arbitrary borders in known velocity field are discussed. Construction of maps for local stretching values in fixed moments allows to analyse informatively an evolution of regions, in which an intensive stirring takes place. The stirring process is explored in a sample of an advection problem of a passive impurity in the velocity field induced by a system of three point vortices moved periodically. It is shown that the regions of a chaotic motion of fluid particles and of an intensive stirring do not coincide. Chaotic region has a zone of weak stirring, in which contours are transported from one intensive stretching zone to another without any deformation. As three vortices follow their paths There’s a chance for some elegant maths; There’s absolute chaos From Kiev to Laos, You may see this in rivers and baths.
1.
Introduction
Mixing is a complex natural phenomenon that includes various mechanisms, the two most important being stretching due to velocity field and diffusion due to Brownian motion [Ottino, 1989]. In some cases diffusive effects can be neglected because of physical characteristics of fluid or time scale of the phenomenon, and the problem can be reduced to the analysis of deformation process of fluid domain in the velocity field. The velocity field is assumed to be given a priori. The problem on deformation of appointed regions, usually called the advection problem in literature [Ottino, 1989; Aref, 1990], is limited to the analysis of the trajectories of Lagrangian fluid particles, which form borders of the region under investigation, in Eulerian velocity field. Every fluid particle can be treated as a passive fluid particle, and governing equations of the problem are the system of differential equations of the 87 K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt (eds.), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 87–92. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
88
A. A. Gourjii
first order (Cauchy problem) with corresponding initial conditions. Every such particle moves along its own trajectory, and one can predict particle positions at any moment. Their ordered connection results to forming domain borders for a given moment. It is commonly accepted [Ottino, 1989; Aref, 1990; Meleshko & van Heijst, 1994, and references]: if the length of contours is increased exponentially in time, we have a chaotic system. If the length of contours is increased linearly, then the considered process is regular. Even for simple laminar flows, some hydrodynamical systems can be non-integrable and display a chaotic behaviour. Aref, 1990 proposed the terms chaotic advection or Lagrangian turbulence for this phenomenon, and it is the subject of intensive studying of many investigators.
2.
Formulation
Our objective directs to an investigation of the local properties of stretching for various segments and contours. Consider an arbitrary fluid particle in a two-dimensional unsteady velocity field U and another particle placed nearby for We determine in such way to introduce the velocity field U in the linearised form. Then the evolutionary equation can be presented in the form
where
Here our primary interest is the change of length of the vector in time, > 0. The components and define a temporal scale during which the particle A remains in the neighbourhood of O. The solution of equations (1) depends on the solution of the characteristic equation of the system, complex values and
where is a value, which has the largest real part; functions A, B, C, D, E and F are determined by gradients of the velocity field evaluated They depend on the sign of the function = at the point + (ad – cb).
Intensive and weak mixing in the chaotic region of a velocity field
89
A smooth contour can be presented by a set of passive particles (markers). Their local coordinates at the initial moment can be given as where
is the parameter of the contour. The relative length of the contour is determined by the integral
=
Here the dot denotes differentiation of the functions with respect to It is important to note that the exponential part in eq. (4) depends on the velocity field. It is not controlled by the type of contour, which surrounds the point O. The other part of the equation is determined by an integral, which describes local stretching properties of given contours for An analysis above can be carried out for another base point of the velocity field for the same fixed moment The stretching peculiarities can be presented using topological maps (local stretching maps), where it is convenient to plot the value for chaotic advection regimes. The set of maps for various moments permits to analyse an evolution of regions, which have an intensive or weak stretching, in time.
3.
Advection problem analysis
Let us apply the method based on local stretching maps to the flow generated by a system of point vortices. The motion of N point vortices of intensity at position is described [Aref, 1983] by
Here the dot denoted the derivative with respect to time, the asterisk means the complex conjugate and the prime denotes omission of the singular term The motion of the system of point vortices is defined by a Hamiltonian dynamical system
90
A. A. Gourjii
The integrability of the system depends on the number of vortices and, for the case of three and more vortices, the generated velocity field leads to a chaotic advection and, as a result, to an intensive stirring. The equation of motion of a passive Lagrangian fluid particle in the velocity field induced by the system of point vortices may be obtained by considering a marker at as a point vortex of zero intensity [ Meleshko et al., 1992]. The equation of passive fluid particle motion can be also transformed into Hamiltonian form. Therefore, the dynamical problem of a time-dependent Hamiltonian system with one degree of freedom is equivalent to the kinematic problem of passive fluid particle. Consider the periodic motion of three point vortices with the following non-dimensional initial conditions: The additional information about details of this interaction of such system of point vortices have been presented in Meleshko & Gourjii, 1994. The evolution of the vortex system is shown in fig. 1. During an interaction, vortices 1 and 2 form a vortex pair moving periodically with local period At the same time three vortices rotate around centre of vorticity with global period here First we can identify global chaotic regions of motion of fluid particle [Ottino, 1989]. Figure 2 shows the Poincaré section for fluid particles moved in the velocity field under the vortex interaction. There are both regular and chaotic regions of motion: the fuzzy collection of points corresponds to a chaotic motion, while the ordered set of points detects the regions of regular motion.
Intensive and weak mixing in the chaotic region of a velocity field
91
The map of exponential coefficient is plotted in fig. 3 using topological level method. The value of stretching of contours due to exponential multiplier has a dominant role in the region, where point vortices place. Chaotic region has also zones with weak stirring. These zones are located on the sides and on the top of the chaotic domain plotted in Poincaré section (fig. 2). To analyse an advection problem, one needs also to simulate this process for passive fluid particles in given velocity field induced by three point vortices. Calculations were performed for passive domain initially distributed in a circle of radius 0. 5, whose centre is placed in the chaotic domain of motion with coordinates (fig. 4). We apply the piece-spline interpolation method [Gourjii et al., 1996], which lets us to form the borders of a closed domain using an ordered set of markers. The moment is shown in fig. 5a. The system has a mutual position that is similar to the initial moment. The shape of the passive domain is practically unchanged. The passive domain remains in the region of the chaotic advection shown by dashed lines. The intensive regime begins only in this moment. Significant deformation takes place. Now the studied region has strong stretching, and is deformed almost into a line during the next half period of the interaction. Fig. 5b shows borders of the domain at The contour is subjected to a significant deformation: its length is increased exponentially. It confirms that a chaotic advection regime had risen. The construction of local stretching maps for various contours for the fixed moment gives a considerable utility in a preliminary analysis of the advection process of passive fluid contours in velocity field to be given.
92
A. A. Gourjii
These maps, like snapshots of stretching values (or normalised stretching values) for various contours, helps not only to find the existence of regions of intensive stirring, but also, using the set of maps, to detect their drift in time.
Acknowledgments The author gratefully acknowledges financial support from the Organising Committee of the Symposium.
References AREF H. 1983 Integrable, chaotic and turbulent vortex motion in two-dimensional flows. Ann. Rev. Fluid Mech. 15, 345–390. OTTINO J. M. 1989 The Kinematics of Mixing: Stretching, Chaos and Transport. Cambridge. Cambridge University Press. 683. AREF H. 1990 Chaotic advection of fluid particle. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. London 333, 273–288. MELESHKO V. V., KONSTANTINOV M. YU., GURZHI A. A. AND KONOVALYUK T. P. 1992 Advection of a vortex pair atmosphere in a velocity field of point vortices. Phys. Fluids A4, 2779–2797. MELESHKO V. V. & VAN HEIJST G. J. F. 1994 Interacting two-dimensional vortex structures: point vortices, contour kinematics and stirring properties. Chaos, Solitons & Fractals 4, 977–1010. MELESHKO V. V. & GOURJII A. A. 1994 Stirring of an inviscid fluid by interacting point vortices. In Modelling of Oceanic Vortices (ed. G. J. F. van Heijst), Proceeding Colloquium Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Science, Amsterdam, North-Holland. 271-281. GOURJII A. A., MELESHKO V. V., VAN HEIJST G. J. F. 1996 Method of piece spline interpolation in an advection problem of passive impurity in a given velocity field, Dop. AN Ukrainy, N. 8. 48–54.
Evolution of the anisotropy of the quantum vortex tangle Tomasz LIPNIACKI Institute of Fundamental Technological Research, 21 Swietokrzyska St., 00-049 Warsaw, Poland
[email protected]
Abstract The evolution of a quantised vortex tangle in superfluid depends on its line-length density, but it is also related to various geometrical measures of the vortex lines forming the tangle. In this paper microscopic dynamics of the vortex tangle is studied analytically to derive an evolution equation for an average binormal to the vortex lines, which is an important measure controlling the growth of the vortex tangle. This equation supplements the Vinen equation for the line-length density. The resulting system (in the contrary to the both Vinen equation alone and alternative Vinen equation) is applicable to an analysis of transients in which the counter-flow changes its direction as well as to the processes with counter-flow changing periodically with various frequencies. Research on fields anisotropic Is surely an interesting topic; The unit binormal Shows features abnormal, As seen if you’re not too myopic!
1.
Introduction
The variety of the dynamic phenomena exhibited by the superfluid He (He II) involves the appearance and motion of quantised vortices. We recall that at low velocities He II flows in a frictionless, presumably laminar manner and can be described within the ideal fluid model. When the characteristic velocities becomes sufficiently large, the superfluid laminar flow develops into a superfluid turbulent flow in which quantum vortices form a chaotic tangle. The quantum tangle is a complex system which behaviour can be analysed via various geometrical and topological measures. The topological complexity measures like linking number, writhing number etc. are on the current investigation, see Barenghi, Samuels & Ricca in this volume. Here we focus on geo4
93 K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt (eds.), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 93–98. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
94
T. Lipniacki
metrical properties of a tangle which is generated by counter-flow (the relative velocity of the two components) In such a case only the superfluid flow is turbulent while the normal flow may remain laminar, what significantly simplifies the analysis. Our description of dynamics of quantum vortices will base on the Localised Induction Approximation (LIA), supplemented by the assumption that vortex lines reconnect when they get close enough. Let us recall: If a curve traced out by a vortex filament is specified in a parametric form, an instantaneous velocity of a given point of the filament (in the superfluid reference frame) reads:
where the over-dot and the prime denote instantaneous derivatives with respect to time and arc length respectively, while non-dimensional friction coefficients, arid is a parameter of order of quantum circulation. If the motion of a vortex filament fulfils Eq. (l) its line-length satisfies the following equation (Schwarz 1988):
The main parameter characterising the vortex tangle is its line-length density L, i. e. the total length of vortices per unit volume The evolution equation for L follows from Eq. (2). Define (after Schwarz 1988) the following characteristic measures of a vortex tangle
Note, that vector I measures the anisotropy of the binorrnal to the vortex lines. For example, I = 0 for an isotropic tangle and if all binomials to the vortex lines forming the tangle are parallel. The parameter introduced by Schwarz is defined as Using the above measures one can rewrite Eq. (2) in the following form:
Evolution of the anisotropy…
95
The equation above corresponds to the Vinen equation
In Eq. (7) the phenomenological coefficients and has been interpreted as functions of the microscopic measures of the tangle. Moreover let us note that in Eq. (7) the generation term is proportional, not absolute value of counter-flow velocity like in Eq(8), but to its scalar product with anisotropy vector I. The anisotropy of the binomial is induced by the counter-flow, and for steady state turbulence the anisotropy vector I is parallel to However, when the counter-flow changes its direction abruptly to the opposite, then, before the polarisation of the vortex tangle will adjust to the new direction of counter-flow, the generation term in Eq. (7) will be negative. As a result, the line-length density must drop below its equilibrium value before the new equilibrium is reached. Note, that according to the classical Vinen equation (8) such transients are invisible since the generation term, which is proportional to the absolute value of counter-flow, remains constant. This example suggests that the Vinen equation should be supplemented by additional equation for time dependence of the anisotropy vector I, but, possibly, also by equations for other geometrical measures of the tangle like and
2.
Time evolution of anisotropy of the binormal to vortex lines in a tangle
In this section we propose an evolution equation for the anisotropy vector I. We assume that the time derivative dI/dt is composed of two terms:
Here, the generation term corresponds to the growth of the anisotropy due to the action of the counter-flow via mutual friction while the decay term describes the relaxation of the tangle due to reconnections. In order to devise the generation term let us recall the dynamics of a single vortex ring under the LIA (1) (eg. Lipniacki 2000 ). Let b be the unit binormal to a given vortex ring (normal to the plane containing the ring). Then
96
T. Lipniacki
Now, let us represent the tangle as a sum of vortex rings (or parts of the rings) having the same value of curvature: Such a representation is equivalent to neglecting the influence of higher derivatives (like ... ) on vortex dynamics, in the calculation of the generation term. Let f(b) denote the angular distribution of the binormal to the rings. Then we have
where denotes integration over unit sphere. To calculate the left hand side of Eq. (11) let us assume that f(b) is the most probable distribution of binomials to vortex rings which results in a given I i. e.
After standard calculations (see Lipniacki 2001a for details) one gets
where
is given by the implicit formula below:
Inserting Eq. (13) into Eq. (ll) one gets
The above expression can be easily calculate only in two limits; when the anisotropy is zero, or on the other extreme, when the i. e. when all rings have parallel binomials. The results obtained in these two cases suggest the following approximation of Eq. (15)
Evolution of the anisotropy…
97
We expect that the main contribution to the decay of the anisotropy of the binormal is due to the relaxation of the tangle caused by reconnections of vortices. Thus, to deduce this term we cannot anymore treat the tangle as a composition of vortex rings. Reconnections produce kinks and add the curvature to the vortex tangle. However, since any two kinks produced by a reconnection have opposite orientation, the reconnections do not alter the average binormal in the tangle. In the result the tangle anisotropy decreases at any reconnection event. Let denote time in which the reconnections produce the total curvature C, equal to that of lines forming the vortex tangle,
Time determine the characteristic time in which the tangle ”forgets” about is initial anisotropy. It may be calculated as follows. The reconnection frequency per unit volume, can be estimated, neglecting the influence of the counter-flow on vortex velocities, as (see Lipniacki 2001b)
Each reconnection introduces a curvature of the order of can be expressed as
Hence, time
Assuming an exponential decay of the anisotropy vector (in the case when the counter-flow is ”switched off”) we postulate the decay term in the following form:
where, according to Eq. (19), Finally, we get the evolution equation for the anisotropy vector I
which supplements the equation for line-length density, L.
98
T. Lipniacki
The above system is analysed in Lipniacki 2001a. Here we note only that the evolution of line-length density L predicted by Eqs. (21, 22) significantly differs from that predicted by Vinen equation alone or alternative Vinen equation, especially when the counter-flow velocity changed its direction during the transient. The above system is applicable for analysis of processes with counter-flow changing periodically. When counter-flow changes its direction periodically then there exists the critical frequency above which the line-length density L drops to zero. The prediction of that critical frequency (which is dependent to the amplitude of counter-flow signal) can be use to validate evolution system (21, 22) and so the proposed approach experimentally.
Acknowledgments The author is grateful to Carlo Barenghi, David Samuels for a stimulating discussion. This work was supported by the KBN Grant No 7T07A 01817.
References BARENGHI, C.F., SAMUELS D.C. & D.C. RICCA, R.L. Complexity measures of tangled vortex filaments This volume. LIPNIACKI, T. 2000 Evolution of quantum vortices following reconnection, Eur. J. Mech., B/Fluids 19, 361–378. LIPNIACKI, T. 2001 Evolution of the line-length density and anisotropy of quantum tangle Phys. Rev. B, 64, 214516-1-9. LIPNIACKI, T. 2001 From vortex reconnection to quantum turbulence. In Quantized Vortex Dynamics and Superfluid Turbulence (ed. C. Barenghi et al), Lecture Notes in Physics V. 571, Springer-Verlag. SCHWARZ, K.W.1988, Three-dimensional vortex dynamics in superfluid Homogenous superfluid turbulence, Phys. Rev. B, 38, 2398–2417.
Motion of vortex lines in quantum mechanics 1, 1
2
1,
&
3
Center for Theoretical Physics, Al. Lotników 32/46, 02-668 Warsaw, Poland
[email protected]
2
Institute of Physics, Al. Lotników 32/46, 02–668 Warsaw, Poland
3
S. I. Witkiewicz High School, ul. 51, 01-737 Warsaw, Poland
Abstract In quantum theory, vortex lines arise in the hydrodynamic interpretation of the wave equation. In this interpretation, which is originally due to Madelung, the flow of the probability density for a single particle is described in terms of the hydrodynamic variables. For the sake of simplicity, the standard time-dependent Schrödinger equation, and the related vortex lines embedded in the probability fluid of the quantum particle, are considered here. A vortex line in this case is simply the curve defined by equating the wave function to zero. The linearity of the Schrödinger equation enables us to obtain a large family of exact time-dependent analytic solutions for the wave functions with vortex lines. Moreover, the method is general enough to allow for various initial configurations of the vortex lines. Although the equation of motion of the quantum mechanical probability fluid is different in its literal form from the equations describing the real physical fluid, we believe that the evolution of the vorticity in the quantum and in the real fluid share the same qualitative features that can be described in terms of the topology of the vortex lines configurations. The general phenomena such as the switch-over, creation and annihilation of vortices can be observed in the quantum mechanical fluid.
I’ll talk about quantum switch-over As felt going from Calais to Dover; The vortex lines shift Reconnect and then lift . . . I’m sorry my lecture’s now over!
1.
Introduction
The principle of probability conservation in non-relativistic quantum mechanics gives rise to a hydrodynamic interpretation of the quantum
99 K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt (eds.), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 99–104. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
100
wave equations. If we consider the Schrodinger equation for a quantum particle as an example, the probability density is and there is a simple formula for the probability flow current. Therefore, it is valid to interpret the probability density as the density of some “quantum fluid¨, and the corresponding conserved current as the flow of this “quantum fluid”. In et. al. (2000) it was argued that the zeros of a generic solution of the linear Schrödinger equation correspond to vortex line singularities in the quantum flow. In section 2 the objects of the study arc defined. In section 3 it is shown that the property of vorticity quantisation follows directly from the definition of the hydrodynamic variables. A very simple example of a straight vortex is given in section 4. A general method of generating more complex vortex solutions of linear wave equations is presented in section 5.
2.
Basic definitions and current conservation in quantum mechanics
The probability density the conserved current velocity field are connected with the wave function the formulae
and the through
where is the mass of the particle and is the electromagnetic vector potential. The continuity equation reads
Since the denominator in equation (4) may have zeros, the velocity field may have singularities like in case of a vortex line in a real fluid. In general, the zeros of a complex function of three real variables are one-dimensional varieties, i. e. lines. In the present context
Motion of vortex lines in quantum mechanics
they are vortex lines embedded in the solution equation
3.
101
of the Schrödinger
Quantisation of vortex strength
Since in the standard quantum mechanics the wave function is always a single valued function of the coordinates, the strength of a vortex line as measured by the circulation along any closed contour C encircling the vortex line and not intersecting other vortex lines,
must be quantised:
Indeed, the phase is well denned (up to a constant and modulo though), and the circulation is the total change of the phase along the contour C. If the velocity must tend to infinity as one approaches the vortex line, so as to satisfy the quantisation condition (8). Hence, nonzero vortex strength implies a singularity of the velocity field: quantum vortices are line singularities.
4.
An example: a straight vortex line
To give a simple example of a vortex line let us consider the wave function
The vortex line equation defines a straight vortex line along the (intersection of the planes and In this case the vortex strength
5.
A general method of generating vortex solutions
Let us choose as the initial condition for the Schrödinger equation an element of the continuous family of wave functions
102
Motion of vortex lines in quantum mechanics
103
104
parameterised be the components of the wave vector k. It is assumed that a solution of the time-dependent Schrodinger equation is known that corresponds to the initial condition By differentiating with respect to the components of k (any number of times), we obtain new wave functions. Each differentiation brings down a component of the position vector and in this manner we may generate an arbitrary complex polynomial that multiplies the initial wave function. Carrying out the differentiations, adding the results with appropriate complex coefficients, and setting k = 0 at the end, we arrive at the expression for the initial wave function of the form where and are real polynomials in the three variables and Conversely, given a function and two real polynomials arid we define two differential operators and by substituting in place of the variables in the polynomials and The two operators, acting on the family at yield the polynomial factors and again, providing a solution of the Schrödinger equation for the given initial wave function It is an obvious observation that is the polynomial part of the initial wave function, while the remaining part, denoted enters the solution via the initial condition
6.
Examples and conclusions
In section 5, a general method was presented to generate vortex solutions of the wave equations. Using this general method, example solutions were obtained for the free particle case, i. e. A(r, t) = 0, V(r) = 0. The pictures show the particularly peculiar phases of motion of two (fig. 1) and three (fig. 2–5) vortex lines, see the references for details. Our conclusion is that interesting phenomena occurring in the quantum mechanical probability fluid — in contrast with the “physical” fluids — can be easily described and visualised.
References MADELUNG, O. 1926, Z. Phys 40, 342. &
C. 2000, Motion of vortex
lines in quantum mechanics. Phys. Rev. A 61, 032110. &
Vortex lines in motion. Ada Phys. Pol. 100 — Supplement, 29.
C. 2001,
III
MAGNETIC STRUCTURE, TOPOLOGY AND RECONNECTION
This page intentionally left blank
Magnetic dissipation: spatial and temporal structure Åke NORDLUND Niels Bohr Institute and Theoretical Astrophysics Center, Juliane Maries Vej 30, DK-2100 Copenhagen Denmark
[email protected]
Abstract A magnetically dominated plasma driven by motions on boundaries at which magnetic field lines are anchored is forced to dissipate the work being done upon it, no matter how small the electrical resistivity. Numerical experiments have clarified the mechanisms through which balance between the boundary work and the dissipation in the interior is obtained. Dissipation is achieved through the formation of a hierarchy of electrical current sheets, which appear as a result of the topological interlocking of individual strands of magnetic field. The probability distribution function of the local winding of magnetic field lines is nearly Gaussian, with a width of the order unity. The dissipation is highly irregular in space as well as in time, but the average level of dissipation is well described by a scaling law that is independent of the electrical resistivity. If the boundary driving is suspended for a period of time the magnetic dissipation rapidly drops to insignificant levels, leaving the magnetic field in a nearly force-free, yet spatially complex state, with significant amounts of free magnetic energy but no dissipating current sheets. Renewed boundary driving leads to a quick return to dissipation levels compatible with the rate of boundary work, with dissipation starting much more rapidly than when starting from idealised initial conditions with a uniform magnetic field. Application of these concepts to modelling of the solar corona leads to scaling predictions in agreement with scaling laws obtained empirically; the dissipation scales with the inverse square of the loop length, and is proportional to the surface magnetic flux. The ultimate source of the coronal heating is the photospheric velocity field, which causes braiding and reconnection of magnetic field lines in the corona. Realistic, three-dimensional numerical models predict emission measures, coronal structures, and heating rates compatible with observations. When driv’n by extreme agitation, I am subject to fierce dissipation; In each current sheet There’s created much heat, And my field thus achieves saturation.
107 K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt (eds.), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 107–114. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
108
1.
Å. Nordlund
Introduction
Magnetic fields are ubiquitous in astrophysical objects; circumstances where there is no magnetic field present are exceptions. Indeed, much of the non-thermal activity that is observed in astrophysical systems is probably related to the presence of magnetic fields. Gravity is, indirectly, a major reason for the ubiquitous magnetic activity, because it tends to separate matter into dense and tenuous regions. Magnetic fields that connect such regions are subjected to stress in the dense regions, and are forced to dissipate in the tenuous regions. There, the magnetic field energy density can be many times higher than the thermal and kinetic energy density of the gas, and minor readjustments of the magnetic field may correspond to significant heating and acceleration of the gas. Understanding the principles that control the dissipation of magnetic energy when the plasma beta where is gas pressure and is magnetic pressure) is low and the magnetic Reynolds number where U is velocity, L size, arid magnetic diffusivity) is very high is a major challenge, and numerous research papers, review articles and books have been published on this subject over the years (e. g., Parker 1972, 1983, 1988, 1994; Sturrock & Uchida 1981; van Ballegooijen 1986; et al. 1989; Heyvaerts & Priest 1992; Longcope & Sudan 1994; Galsgaard and Nordlund 1996ab; Nordlund & Galsgaard 1997; Gomez, Dmitruk &; Milano 2000; to mention just a few). The solar corona is an ideal ‘test site’ for theories and models of magnetic dissipation, since it provides rich opportunities for observing both the spatial and temporal structure of a dissipating low beta plasma. The Sun is indeed a ‘Rosetta stone’ in the context of magnetic dissipation— once we understand how magnetic dissipation occurs under such well observed conditions we may be much more confident when extrapolating to more distant and less well observed circumstances. Numerical experiments have emerged as a complementary and rich source of inspiration in the quest to understand magnetic dissipation. Below I briefly summarise conclusions from two types of experiments; generic experiments where a low beta plasma is driven from two opposing boundaries, and realistic experiments that attempt to model solar coronal conditions as closely as possible.
2.
Boundary driven magnetic dissipation
Generic experiments demonstrate that magnetic dissipation does not occur in simple, monolithic current sheets, even if the boundary motions are large scale and slow (cf. Galsgaard and Nordlund 1996a for details
Magnetic dissipation: spatial and temporal structure
109
about such experiments). Rather, a hierarchy of current sheets form, with smaller scale current sheets protruding from larger scale ones (cf. Fig. 1). On the average, the collective dissipation in the hierarchy of current sheets balances the boundary work, as it must, to satisfy energy conservation. The average level of work and dissipation at which the equilibrium is obtained does not depend noticeably on the resistivity (or, equivalently, the numerical resolution), as long as the magnetic Reynolds number is not too small. The work W, and hence the dissipation times the distance L between the boundaries, is proportional to the energy density of the magnetic field at the boundary, the average angle of inclination of the magnetic field at the boundary, and the boundary velocity
The crucial angle factor tan scales as tan where is the autocorrelation time of the boundary motions, is the “stroke length” of the boundary motions, and L is the distance between the driving boundaries. The average dissipation thus scales as
(Fig. 2a). Incidentally, it turns out that the scaling of the photospheric motions that drive the solar corona is such that which implies that similar contributions to the driving are obtained from an extended range of scales.
110
Å. Nordlund
A sequence of uncorrelated strokes at the two opposing boundaries would, if the connectivity between the boundaries was conserved, lead to further increase of the tilt angles. The magnetic field lines would become increasingly tangled, as each new stroke would cause the end points of field lines connected to neighbouring points at one boundary to move further apart at the other boundary. But the development of current sheets prevents connectivity from being conserved, and prevents the build-up of angles much larger than In the hierarchy of current sheets the smaller current sheets provide a dissipation path for the larger ones, down to the smallest current sheets at a few times the resistive scale. An increase of resolution (magnetic Reynolds number) allows even smaller current sheets to form, but does not change the large scale angles noticeably, and hence does not influence the average level of dissipation. In terms of the winding of one field line around another, the statistical steady state is one where the number of windings from one boundary to the other has an approximately Gaussian distribution, with a Gaussian width of order unity (Fig. 2b). It is indeed a well known result that a twist much larger than unity leads to violent instability (see Galsgaard & Nordlund 1996b and references cited therein).
3.
Suspended / resumed boundary driving
If the external work is suspended dissipation quickly drops, as the current sheets die out. Distributed (smooth) currents remain, but these dissipate much more slowly. The system is in an approximately forcefree state, similar to the one just before current sheets first turned on.
Magnetic dissipation: spatial and temporal structure
111
When the external work is resumed current sheets return promptly, and dissipation quickly returns to the previous average level (Fig. 3). Note that, even though exactly the same velocity field is applied for exactly the same time, there are much sharper current concentrations (current sheets) in the right-most inset of Fig. 3, illustrating that the quiescent but spatially complex magnetic field in the suspended state is ”ripe” for quickly producing current sheets. The system thus reaches balance between driving and dissipation much more quickly from the suspended driving (~ force free) state than from the initial (potential) state.
4.
Coronal heating experiments
Realistic numerical models of coronal heating and activity are now within reach (Gudiksen & Nordlund 2002), even though the resolution
112
Å. Nordlund
constraints are quite severe. In order to apply realistic and well calibrated boundary conditions it is necessary to bridge the distance from the base of the corona to the photospheric surface, where both the magnetic field and the velocity field are known sufficiently well to specify the boundary driving. This limits the vertical resolution to better than, or of the order of, photospheric and chromospheric pressure and density scale heights. The horizontal resolution needs to be similar, to resolve the granular scales where the horizontal velocity amplitudes are largest. The size of a model, on the other hand, needs to be of the order of the size of an active region, or larger. The very high Alfvén velocity in the corona above active regions limits (via the Courant condition) the time step to of the order of 10–30 ms, at the given spatial resolution. Time intervals of at least several granulation turn over times (~ 5 min) need to be covered. The resulting overall constraints are demanding, but not excessively so, given the power of current, massively parallel supercomputers. With a relevant cooling function approximation (Kahn 1976) and Spitzer conductivity, and by computing synthetic emission measures that correspond closely to those observed from, e. g., the TRACE satellite (Aschwanden, Schrijver & Alexander 2001), one may compare the results directly with solar conditions. With initial conditions taken from a high resolution MDI magnetogram (Fig. 4a), and a random velocity field with scaling properties consistent with a 5 km/s rms solar photospheric velocity field, one obtains average heating rates over an active region and emission measure images that are similar to observed ones (cf. Fig. 4b).
Magnetic dissipation: spatial and temporal structure
5.
113
Discussion and concluding remarks
The results of the numerical experiments, and the properties of the scaling law derived from them, provide evidence that we are finally approaching a basic understanding of magnetic dissipation. First of all, the basic form of the scaling law (2) follows from first principles, and agrees with previously proposed scaling laws (Parker 1983, van Ballegooijen 1986). In addition, it adds a prediction for the crucial inclination factor, for which Parker (1983) and van Ballegooijen (1986) had to make arbitrary assumptions. Secondly, the scaling law is robust in that the crucial inclination factor is bracketed from above and below. It is bracketed from below because in general current sheets do not develop until the local winding number is of the order of unity. It is bracketed from above, because a local winding number much larger than unity inevitably leads to instabilities that rapidly dissipate the surplus magnetic energy. Because of the spontaneous formation of a hierarchy of current sheets the scaling law is also robust against changes of the magnetic Reynolds number. If anything, an increased Reynolds number could in principle lead to an increase of the magnetic dissipation because, as pointed out by Parker (1988), if one assumes that a reduction of the magnetic diffusivity initially leads to a reduction of the magnetic dissipation the consequence is only that the boundary work for a while exceeds the dissipation, which leads to an increase of the average inclination and hence to a further increase of the boundary work. When the magnetic dissipation eventually comes into balance with the boundary work again it happens at a higher level than before. But in practice, an increase of the magnetic Reynolds number just leads to an extension of the hierarchy of electrical current sheets to smaller scales, which makes it possible to dissipate at the same rate even without increasing the average angle of inclination at the boundaries. Any claim to the contrary must be accompanied by a demonstration that it is possible to sustain a distribution of winding number that is substantially wider than unity at high The scaling law (2) is furthermore consistent with scaling laws derived from observations, in that it predicts magnetic dissipation to scale as in agreement with Porter & Klimchuk (1995). Also, since the solar photosphere has a very intermittent distribution of magnetic field strength B, where B is either very weak or of the order of 1 kG, the average heating is predicted to scale roughly as the magnetic surface filling factor. This again agrees with the observed scaling of coronal heating (Fisher et al. 1998).
114
Å. Nordlund
Acknowledgments This work was supported in part by the Danish National Research Foundation through its establishment of the Theoretical Astrophysics Center.
References ASCHWANDEN, M. J., SCHRIJVER, C. J. & ALEXANDER, D. 2001 Modeling of Coronal EUV Loops Observed with TRACE. I. Hydrostatic Solutions with Nonuniform Heating. Astrophysical Journal 550, 1036–1050. FISHER, G. H., LONGCOPE, D. W., METCALF, T. R. & PEVTSOV, A. A. 1998 Coronal Heating in Active Regions as a Function of Global Magnetic Variables. Astrophysical Journal 508, 885–898. GALSGAARD, K. & NORDLUND, Å. 1996a The Heating and Activity of the Solar Corona: I. Boundary Shearing of an Initially Homogeneous Magnetic Field. Journal of Geophysical Research 101, 13445–13460. GALSGAARD, K. & NORDLUND, Å. 1996b The Heating and Activity of the Solar Corona: II. Kink Instability in a Flux Tube. Journal of Geophysical Research 102, 219–230. GOMEZ, D. O., DMITRUK, P. A. & MILANO, L. J. 2000 Recent theoretical results on coronal heating. Solar Physics 195, 299–318. GUDIKSEN, B. & NORDLUND, Å. 2002 Bulk heating and slender magnetic loops in the solar corona. Astrophys. J. Letters, 572, L113–L116. HEYVAERTS, J. & PRIEST, E. R. 1992 A self-consistent turbulent model for solar coronal heating ApJ 390, 297–308. LONGCOPE, D. W. & SUDAN, R. N. 1994 Evolution and statistics of current sheets in coronal magnetic loops ApJ 437, 491–504. Z., SCHNACK, D. D., & VAN HOVEN, G. 1989 Creation of current filaments in the solar corona ApJ 338, 1148–1157. NORDLUND, Å. & GALSGAARD, K. 1997 Topologically Forced Reconnection. Lecture Notes in Physicsh 489, 179–200. PARKER, E. N. 1972 Topological Dissipation and the Small-Scale Fields in Turbulent Gases. Astrophysical Journal 174, 499–510. PARKER, E. N. 1983 Magnetic Neutral Sheets in Evolving Fields. II - Formation of the solar corona. Astrophysical Journal 264, 642–647. PARKER, E. N. 1988 Nanoflares and the solar X-ray corona. Astrophysical Journal 330, 474–479. PARKER, E. N. 1994 Spontaneous current sheets in magnetic fields: with applications to stellar x-rays. New York : Oxford University Press, 1994. PORTER, L. J. & KLIMCHUK, J. A. 1995 Soft X-Ray Loops and Coronal Heating. Astrophysical Journal 454, 499–511. STURROCK, P. A. & UCHIDA, Y. 1981 Coronal heating by stochastic magnetic pumping ApJ 246, 331 VAN BALLEGOOIJEN, A. A. 1986 Cascade of magnetic energy as a mechanism of coronal heating ApJ 311, 1001–1014.
Current sheets in the Sun’s corona Eric PRIEST School of Mathematics and Statistics, University of St Andrews, St Andrews, Fife KY16 9SS, Scotland
[email protected]
Abstract Current sheets play an important role in the Sun’s atmosphere, especially in coronal heating events and solar flares. They may form in response to motions of the magnetic footpoints in the solar surface or following a loss of equilibrium. In two dimensions, X-type null points may collapse to current sheets, as described by nonlinear self-similar solutions and by complex-variable theory. Magnetic diffusion resolves the sheets and allows fast reconnection to take place. There are many ways in which such reconnection can occur, depending on the boundary conditions, including one family of almost-uniform regimes and another family of non-uniform regimes. In three dimensions, nulls may also collapse to give a growing current along the spine or the fan of the null. (These are, respectively, isolated field lines or surfaces of field lines that approach or recede from the null point. ) Dissipation can then occur by either spine reconnection or fan reconnection, or also by separator reconnection when the current concentrates along, respectively, the spine, the fan or a separator (which is a field line that links one null point to another). Coronal heating may be produced by reconnection in the following ways: by converging photospheric motions at X-ray bright points; by binary reconnection when pairs of magnetic sources interact; by separator reconnection in complex fields due to tertiary flux interactions; by braiding of field lines; and by coronal tectonics heating at separatrix surfaces between intense flux tubes. Solar flares may occur when a magnetic catastrophe causes the slow eruption of a flux tube, which in turn drives the formation of a current sheet under the flux tube. As the sheet dissipates and reconnects, the overlying field lines holding down the flux tube are released so that rapid eruption and energy release can take place. The magnetic field of the Sun Engenders a whole lot of fun; There’s nothing to beat Collapse to a sheet, And that’s how the heating’s begun.
1.
Introduction
The Sun’s atmosphere has three layers. The surface, called the photosphere, is only 6000K in temperature and it possesses sunspots, dark areas of very strong magnetic field. Images of the line-of-site compo-
115 K. Bajer and H. K. Moffatt (eds. ), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 115–124. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
116
E.R. Priest
nent of the magnetic field reveal bipolar flux at sunspot pairs and also the presence of concentrated magnetic flux over the whole solar surface at the boundaries of convection cells (supergranules). Above the photosphere lies the warmer and rarer chromosphere and above that the temperature rises dramatically to over a million degrees in the corona. A key problem in astrophysics is then to understand how the corona is heated to such high temperatures. The energy that is required to heat the corona is about 5000 in an active region (a region lying above a group of sunspots where the magnetic field is stronger than normal). The energy flux through the surface of the Sun is plentiful. Since the Poynting flux is of order which is typically W for observed velocities (v) of 0. 1 km and field strengths (B) of 100G. But the key question is: how is this energy flux converted to heat? The induction equation
describes how the magnetic field changes in time. In the corona the ratio of the first to the second term on the right is of order 108 and so the diffusion term is completely negligible and the magnetic field is frozen to the plasma. The exception is in singularities where the electric current and therefore the gradient of the magnetic field is very large. So, how does the Sun create such singularities? In the following sections we describe: the formation and dissipation of 2D current sheets (Sections 2 and 3); the corresponding formation and dissipation in three dimensions (Section 4); and their importance for coronal heating (Section 5) and solar flares (Section 6). For more details of these subjects and for an extensive set of references, see Priest & Forbes 2000.
2.
2.1
Formation of current sheets in two dimensions X-points tend to collapse (locally)
If the field lines are free or there is an inflow of energy, an X-point tends to collapse (Figure 2). Physically, if you perturb a flux function from to then the force tends to continue the collapse. There are linear solutions with magnetic diffusion, which exhibit a decaying oscillation. Also, nonlinear self-similar solutions to
Current sheets in the Sun’s corona
117
the ideal equations have been studied of the form
which produce a collapse in a finite time, but these are only local.
2.2
Sheet formation modelled with a complex variable
The formation of a sheet has been modelled using complex-variable theory For example, consider a potential field X-point (Figure la) having a field Move the footpoints of a finite region or add a finite energy to this minimum-energy configuration. Then, if the topology is preserved, to what configuration does this field evolve? Green suggested an evolution to a field of the form (Figure 1b) having a current sheet stretching from to Later, however, Somov & Syrovatsky 1976 suggested an alternative evolution to which contains singularities at the ends of the sheet (Figure 1c).
2.3
Self-consistent formation
More recently, self-consistent solutions satisfying the ideal MHD equations were discovered. Bajer 1990 gave numerical examples using the method of Moffatt 1985 to solve the ideal induction equation (which preserves the topology) and an equation of motion with an artificial damping term that ensures that the motions decay away in time. Furthermore, an analytical example of time-dependent sheet formation (Priest et al 1995) was obtained by expanding the MHD equations in powers of the Alfvén Mach number
118
E.R. Priest
so that, to lowest order, the field evolves through a series of quasi-potential states with outside current sheets, in such a way that the velocity satisfies the ideal induction equation together with the condition that the acceleration be perpendicular to the field One example has singular end-points to the sheet.
2.4 Extensions to the basic theory The basic theory has been extended in many ways. First of all, the form of has been written down for other configurations. Also, a general method has been proposed for finding f(z) when the topology is preserved (Titov 1992), and techniques have been developed for modelling three-dimensional sheets. The formation of sheets in forcefree and magnetostatic fields have been treated (Bajer 1990; Bungey & Priest 1995). Finally, it has been realised that shearing motions of photospheric footpoints can form current sheets along separatrices.
3.
Dissipation of current sheets in two dimensions
When an X-point collapses to a sheet, dissipation allows the field lines to break and reconnect (Figure 1). The magnetic energy is converted to heat, kinetic energy and fast particle energy. This process is the source of heating and of many dynamic processes on the Sun, so how does it occur in both 2D and 3D? In 2D reconnection takes place at an X-type null point, where a localised breakdown of the frozen-field condition produces a change of field-line connectivity. The theory in two dimensions is well developed and includes: slow Sweet-Parker reconnection, fast Petschek reconnection and many other fast regimes that depend on the boundary conditions, such as Almost-Uniform and Nonuniform reconnection.
3.1
Classical reconnection Sweet and Parker suggested a model consisting of a simple current sheet with a uniform inflow (Figure 2a). The sheet has length 2L and width 21, while the inflow velocity and field are and and the outflow values are and Mass conservation into and out of the sheet implies while a steady balance between inwards advection of flux and its diffusion implies Furthermore, acceleration along the sheet by the force accelerates the plasma to an outflow speed equal to the Alfvén speed Eliminating L and between these three relations gives an expression for the reconnection rate which may be written in dimensionless form as
Current sheets in the Sun’s corona
119
where the magnetic Reynolds number is With say, the rate is only too slow to explain a solar flare. Later, Petschek proposed a much more rapid mechanism, in which the sheet bifurcates into two pairs of slow-mode shocks at which most of the energy conversion takes place (Figure 2b). The reconnection speed may be at any rate up to a maximum of which is typically 0. 01 - 0. 1. Here the subscript e refers to “external” values in the inflow region far from the current sheet. More recently, a family of regimes of Almost-Uniform reconnection was discovered in which the magnetic field lines are weakly curved in the inflow region (Figure 4b-e). The different regimes are produced by different boundary conditions on the inflow, producing either converging or diverging flows. Petschek’s mechanism is just one special case. These models were then generalised even further by allowing the inflowing field lines to be strongly curved (Figure 2f). The resulting NonUniform Reconnection regimes again depend on the boundary conditions and agree with numerical experiments provided the same boundary conditions are adopted (and the magnetic diffusivity is nonuniform).
120
4. 4.1
E.R. Priest
Three-dimensional reconnection Null-points - structure and collapse
In three dimensions the simplest null point has a field which possesses two families of field lines that pass through the null (Figure 3). An isolated “spine” field line approaches (or recedes from the null), here along the while a “fan” surface of field lines emanates from it (or approaches it), here in the (Priest & Titov 1996). Most generally, in the linear vicinity of a null the field can be written as
in terms of four parameters, namely (p, q) and the components of the current along the spine and normal to it (Parnell et al 1996). As in two dimensions, nulls can collapse to give a growing current along the spine or in the fan (Bulanov & Sakai 1997; Parnell et al 1996). There are linear and nonlinear treatments, which show the development of a singularity in a finite time, but the analysis is only local. When the fan current grows, the angle between the fan and spine decreases, whereas when the spine current grows the field lines in the fan rotate and close up (Figure 4).
4.2
Reconnection at a 3D null
At 3D null points there are three types of reconnection (Figures 5 and 6), namely spine reconnection (when the current focuses along the spine), fan reconnection (when it is concentrated in the fan) and separator reconnection, when the current grows along the separator joining one null to another (Priest & Titov 1996; Longcope 1996; Hornig &
Current sheets in the Sun’s corona
121
Schindler 1996). Figure 5 shows the result of a kinematic analysis, while Figure 6 gives an image from a 3D resistive MHD experiment of Galsgaard & Nordlund 1997a in which they explored the effect of imposing a shear on two boundaries of a box initially containing eight null points in equilibrium.
5.
Can reconnect ion heat the solar corona?
The solar corona is highly complex. It consists of three types of structure, which may well be heated differently. Coronal holes are magnetically open into interplanetary space, so the fast solar wind escapes from them, whereas coronal loops have both ends attached to the solar surface. There are also tiny points of emission called X-ray bright points, several hundred of which are present at any time. Reconnection may be heating in different ways. Simple reconnection may be driven at null points by photospheric motions to create an X-ray bright point according to the Converging Flux model. In this model new flux emerges in a supergranulation cell and migrates to the cell boundary, where it reconnects with pre-existfing flux on the boundary. A second way is by “binary reconnection” (Priest & Schrijver 1999) when pairs of oppositely directed flux sources in the solar surface move relative to one another and drive reconnection in the corona. Interactions between three or more sources in complex fields may instead involve separator reconnection (Priest & Titov 1996; Longcope 1996). Finally, braiding of field lines may also produce current sheets and heating. The relative motion of two photospheric sources in an overlying field has been studied numerically by Galsgaard et al 2000. Initially, the sources are unconnected, but as they move past one another reconnection takes place at a separator (Figure 7) and creates a twisted flux tube joining the two sources. Braiding was first proposed by Parker 1979 as
122
E.R. Priest
a heating model and has been extensively studied (see Nordlund and Bhattacharjee). In particular, an experiment by Galsgaard & Nordlund 1997b shows the growth of current sheets and an impulsive heating.
6.
How do solar flares and coronal mass ejections occur?
The overall picture for a solar flare is that during the pre-flare phase a large flux tube with an overlying arcade of field lines becomes sheared
Current sheets in the Sun’s corona
123
and rises slowly. At some critical point, reconnection of the overlying arcade occurs at points below the rising flux tube. This disconnects some of the overlying field lines from the solar surface and so allows a rapid eruption to take place. As the eruption and reconnection continue, an arcade of rising hot loops is created with bright ribbons at its feet. A model in two dimensions for the cause of the eruption has been developed (Priest & Forbes 2000), consisting of a flux tube with an overlying arcade having sources that are a distance apart. As decreases and the sources slowly approach one another, the height of the flux tube slowly decreases and the configuration passes through a series of equilibria - until, that is, a critical point is reached beyond which there is no neighbouring equilibrium. If there is no reconnection, the flux tube rises towards a new equilibrium that contains a current sheet linking the tube to the solar surface. However, in numerical experiments, reconnection is driven at the current sheet and allows a rapid eruption of the tube. More recently, a three-dimensional version of this model has been developed.
E.R. Priest
124
7.
Conclusion
On the Sun it is likely that the occurrence of current sheets is responsible both for coronal heating and for solar flares. In two dimensions, the formation and dissipation of current sheets is well understood, but in three dimensions the theory is only just beginning to be developed. However, there are many fascinating observations and numerical experiments to guide and inspire us in the future.
Acknowledgments I am most grateful to Konrad Bajer for organising an excellent meeting with such care and attention.
References BAJER, K. 1990 PhD Thesis, Cambridge University. BULANOV, S.V. AND SAKAI, J. 1997 Magnetic collapse in incompressible plasma flows. J. Phys. Soc. Jap. 66, 3477–3483. BUNGEY, T.N. AND PRIEST, E.R. 1995 Current sheet configurations in potential and force-free fields. Astron. Astrophys. 293, 215–224. GALSGAARD, K. AND NORDLUND, A. 1997a Heating and activity of the solar corona III. J. Geophys. Res. 102, 231–248. GALSGAARD, K. AND NORDLUND, A. 1997b Heating and activity of the solar corona I. J. Geophys. Res. 101, 13445–13460. GALSGAARD, K., PARNELL, C.E. AND BLAIZOT, J. 2000 Elementary heating events - magnetic interactions between two sources. Astron. Astrophys. 362, 383–394. HORNIG, G. AND SCHINDLER, K. 1996 Magnetic topology and the problem of its invariant definition. Phys. Plasmas 3, 781–791. LONGCOPE, D.W. 1996 Topology and current ribbons. Solar Phys. 169, 91–121. MOFFATT, H.K. 1985 Magnetostatic equilibria and Euler flows of complex topology. J. Fluid Mech. 159, 359–378. PARKER, E.N. 1979 Cosmical Magnetic Fields, Clarendon Press, Oxford. PARNELL, C.P., SMITH, J., NEUKIRCH, T. AND PRIEST, E.R. 1996 Structure of 3D magnetic neutral points. Phys. Plasmas 3, 759–770. PRIEST, E.R. AND FORBES, T.G. 2000 Magnetic Reconnection Camb. Univ. Press. PRIEST, E.R. AND SCHRIJVER, C.J. 1999 Aspects of 3D reconnection. Solar Phys. 190, 1–24. PRIEST, E.R. AND TITOV, V.S. 1996 Magnetic reconnection at 3D null points. Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. Lond. 354, 2951–2992. PRIEST, E.R., TITOV, V.S. AND RICKARD, G.J. 1995 The formation of magnetic singularities by nonlinear time-dependent collapse of an X-type magnetic field. Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. Lond. A. 351, 1–37. SOMOV, B.V. AND SYROVATSKY, S.I. 1976 Hydrodynamic plasma flow in a strong magnetic field. Proc. Lebedev Phys. Inst. 74, 13–72. TITOV, V.S. 1992 Calculating 2D potential fields with current sheets. Solar Phys. 139, 401–404.
A model for magnetic reconnection H.K. MOFFATT & R.E. HUNT Isaac Newton Institute for Mathematical Sciences, 20 Clarkson Road, Cambridge CB3 90E, UK
[email protected]
If you’re not too dreadfully weary, You may ask: what’s the point of this theory? Just please recollect That B-lines reconnect; I hope that will answer your query!
1.
Introduction
Magnetic reconnection is a diffusive process whereby the topology of a magnetic field imbedded in a highly conducting fluid may change with time. The process is frequently represented by the simple diagram shown in figure 1 in which the oppositely directed lines of force AB, CD reconnect to the configuration AC, BD. A huge literature emanating from the early papers of Sweet (1958), Parker (1957) and Petschek (1964) has evolved; for a recent thorough exposition including discussion of the important application of the theory in solar, magnetospheric and other contexts, see Priest & Forbes (2000). Despite the prolonged research on this topic, there seems to be as yet no simple model which demonstrates unambiguously the necessarily time-dependent process indicated in figure 1 which takes account of the curvature of the field lines before and after reconnection. It is the purpose of this short paper to provide such a model. We restrict attention here to two-dimensional evolution in an incompressible fluid; generalisation to the more challenging problem of three-dimensional skewed flux tubes may however also be possible.
2.
The initial configuration
It is natural to represent the curves AB, CD in figure 1 by the hyperbola where k and Y are constants. We first construct a magnetic field 125 K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt (eds.), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 125–138. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
126
H.K. Moffatt and R.E. Hunt
which is confined to two oppositely directed flux sheets centred on this hyperbola. With this is achieved by the choice where is the transverse scale of the flux sheet. We shall adopt nondimensional variables using as the unit of length; so from here on we may take We shall assume further that Y > 1 (so that the two flux sheets are ‘separated’ at t = 0, well separated if and we shall assume that the curvature parameter is < 1. The field components associated with (2) are
With sheet is
the flux (per unit distance in the
in the upper
and the flux in the lower sheet is similarly In order to induce rapid reconnection, we subject this field to the irrotational straining flow with (Figure 2). We may adopt as the unit of time, so that henceforth The Lorentz force with will obviously perturb this flow; but we may adopt (6) as an initial condition for the velocity field, and as an outer boundary condition as for all The initial streamfunction associated with (6) (with now is
Magnetic Reconnection
3.
127
The evolution equations Consider first the magnetic induction equation
where is the (dimensionless) magnetic diffusivity parameter. For the two-dimensional situation, we take with
Note that is in the applied electric field in the be ‘uncurled’ to give.
Equivalently, with
and There is no In these circumstances, (8) may
and
The Navier-Stokes equation including the Lorentz force is, in standard
With vorticity
the vorticity equation is
H.K. Moffatt and R.E. Hunt
128
or equivalently
Equations (11) and (14), coupled with the initial conditions A = at and the outer boundary conditions
provide a complete specification of the problem. Note the symmetries, A even in and odd in and which are respected by the evolution equations.
4.
Boundary-layer approximation
As the straining flow sweeps the two sheets towards each other, it is obvious that the field gradient in the will increase, while that in the will diminish. In these circumstances, a boundarylayer approach is legitimate. We expand A and in the form
where
is odd in
and g and
are even in
Note that then,
In each case, the leading-order term will be dominated by the part involving the i.e.
With this boundary-layer approximation, we have
Magnetic Reconnection
129
and so, to leading order, (11) yields
and (14) yields
where a measure of the strength of the initial field. This equation integrates with respect to (as expected within the boundarylayer approximation) to give
where the constant of integration (+1) is fixed by the boundary conditions We have thus reduced the problem to three nonlinear coupled evolution equations (24), (25), (27). Clearly the initial condition on is just To obtain initial conditions on
and h, we expand (2) in the form
so that, from (4. 2), these initial conditions are
5.
Weak field limit
If then the field behaves, at least in the initial stages, as a passive vector field. We then have and (24), (25) become
If diffusion is negligible
then the field is ‘frozen in’,
130
H.K. Moffatt and R.E. Hunt
and so
We then have
Thus, although the magnetic field strength increases exponentially (like the relevant part of the Lorentz force in (27) (that part not compensated by the pressure field) remains this is because the curvature of the field lines near decreases in proportion to There may be a weak cumulative effect of the Lorentz force over a long time; but the perturbation velocity field driven by this Lorentz force certainly does not increase exponentially, and remains relative to the imposed strain field. When this frozen field development lasts only for so long as the diffusion terms in (33), (34) remain negligible. From (36), becomes comparable with when
at which stage the (dimensionless) field strength is of order From this point on, diffusive reconnection proceeds in a layer whose thickness is and presumably does not decrease much below this.
6.
Saddle point reconnection Being even in
the functions
admit expansions
where, from (31), (32),
Of course, for
we have
Near the origin, the B-lines A = cst. are hyperbolic and given by
Magnetic Reconnection
131
The separatrices through O are the lines
Note that at , although the field is exponentially weak near O, these separatrices are well-defined as Under the frozen-field evolution (36), (37), they move with the fluid to position
i. e. the angle between the separatrices decreases exponentially. At time , the flux crossing the positive is at time , it is
The difference, is the flux that has reconnected and is associated with the field in the region (see figure 3). Clearly, this reconnection process occurs in an -neighbour-
hood of the saddle point of the field B where and cannot occur in the absence of such a saddle point. Figure 4 shows the computed evolution of based on equations (24), (25), (27), for the following parameter values:
132
H.K. Moffatt and R.E. Hunt
As expected, remains constant at near -1 for small t, while diffusion is still negligible; it then rises quite rapidly and tends to +1, the reconnection process being 99% complete by Contrary to received opinion, there is no indication here that the Lorentz force has a dominating effect on this process. The time-scale of the process is O(1), i.e. when we return to dimensional variables; this is because, however small the value of the transverse scale decreases to before the onset of diffusion, and on dimensional grounds the reconnection time-scale is necessarily Of course this conclusion may need modification if the magnetic field parameter M is greatly increased. Numerical experiments over the space of the parameters and are in progress.
References PARKER, E.N. 1957 Sweet’s mechanism for merging magnetic fields in conducting fluids. J. Geophys. Res. 62, 509–520. PETSCHEK, H.E. 1964 Magnetic field annihilation. In Physics of Solar Flares (Ed. W. N. Hess), NASA SP-50, Washington, DC, 425–439. PRIEST, E.R. & FORBES, T. 2000 Magnetic Reconnection Camb. Univ. Press. SWEET, P.A. 1958 The neutral point theory of solar flares. In Electromagnetic Phenomena in Cosmical Physics, IAU Symp. 6, (Ed. B. Lehnert) Camb. Univ. Press, 123–134.
Reconnection in magnetic and vorticity fields Gunnar HORNIG Theoretische Physik IV, Fakultät für Physik und Astronomie, Ruhr-Universität Bochum, 44780 Bochum, Germany
[email protected]
Abstract Reconnection is an important process of structure formation in fluid dynamics. It occurs in form of vortex reconnection in hydrodynamics as well as in form of magnetic reconnection in plasmas. Two basic types of reconnection are known.
The planar two-dimensional reconnection and the more generic, but more complicated three-dimensional case. These two types differ for example with respect to their production of helicity in reconnection. Simple analytic examples of vortex reconnection are given and compared with corresponding solutions of magnetic reconnection. It is shown that, while for magnetic reconnection two-dimensional stationary solutions exist, vortex reconnection always requires a time-dependent velocity field. This explains why vortex reconnection in spite of all similarities often has a more complicated geometry than magnetic reconnection . The process of line reconnection Results from diffusion-advection; With a flick of the wrist I can generate twist, And this for your greater detection!
1.
Introduction
Reconnection is an important process both in magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) and hydrodynamics (HD). It describes a change in the topology of field lines of a divergence-free field, i. e. the vorticity field in HD or the magnetic field in MHD. The equation which determines the evolution of the divergence-free field is in the case of vorticity the curl of the NavierStokes equation and for the magnetic field the curl of Ohm’s law. We can summarize both in
133 K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt (eds.), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 133–138. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
134
G. Hornig
where is either the vorticity field or the magnetic field and denotes the resistive term in Ohm’s law or the right hand side of the NavierStokes equation, i. e. The process of reconnection is most pronounced in fluids or plasmas which have respectively a high Reynolds number or magnetic Reynolds number. Here the effect of is negligible almost everywhere in the fluid so that is frozen-in with respect to the flow v. For a vanishing the flux of and the topology of field lines are conserved due to Kelvin’s theorem (Alfvén’s theorem in MHD). However, the approximation of small compared to can break down easily near null points of Figure 1 shows an example of a planar two-dimensional reconnection process, that is a process where can be written as The images show the evolution of a set of G-field lines which initially form a single flux tube. The field lines are integrated from two crosssections (black) which are moving with the fluid. The non-ideal term dominates the evolution only near the X-point of the field (z-axis) and thereby enables reconnection.
For the planar case eqn. (1) can be rewritten as an ideal evolution,
where the velocity u is to be considered as the transport velocity of the lines. For the case of a non-vanishing at an X-point of we get a stagnation flow with a singularity at the X-point. In the generic case, i. e. if does not vanish in higher order at the null, the singularity scales as where is the distance from the null point. This results in a transport of the field lines onto the x-point in a finite time (Hornig 2001b). Correspondingly the newly connected field lines are transported in a finite time downstream away from the null. The result is in accordance with numerical calculations by De Waele (1994), which show a quadratic dependence of the reconnection time on the distance between the flux tubes. The particular structure of the singularity
Reconnection in magnetic and vorticity fields
135
is the mathematical reason for the ‘cut and reconnect’ process. It can be used for a definition of reconnection in planar configurations (Hornig 2001b). Simple examples of this type of reconnection for both MHD and HD were given in Hornig (2001a).
2.
Three-dimensional reconnection
In the investigation of magnetic reconnection it was soon realized that the planar, two-dimensional concept of reconnection is not easily transferred to three-dimensional systems. Already adding a small constant component to parallel to the former invariant direction does not significantly change the dynamics of the process but inhibits the determination of a transport velocity The latter exists if and only if which is no longer satisfied if there is a parallel component of It was shown in Hornig (2001b) that both the planar and the three-dimensional reconnection can be described in a general framework of covariant flux conservation. Within this description there exist corresponding transport 4-velocities, which in the case of three-dimensional reconnection cannot be mapped to 3-vector flows The dynamics of flux tubes in the three-dimensional reconnection is different form the planar case in that there does not exist a well-defined place where the field lines are cut, instead the flux tubes undergoing reconnection split as soon as they enter the region where is relevant for the dynamics (see Figure 2). Thereupon they flip around each other before they merge to two newly connected flux tubes. In MHD this is sometimes called magnetic flipping. The splitting of the flux tubes reflects the fact that no transporting flow neither smooth nor singular for this process exists. This process differs from the planar case in another aspect. It does not conserve the total helicity. The total helicity measures an averaged linkage of field lines in a certain volume
136
G. Hornig
V and is defined as
where is the vector potential for This quantity is well defined if the volume V is bounded by a surface which is tangential to lines. The dynamics of this quantity can be derived from the identity where is the electric potential in MHD and in HD we can use for all non-relativistic flows. Integrating over a volume with a boundary on which the helicity current vanishes (e. g. where and yields
The term on the right hand side is to be considered as the source term of helicity. For MHD the source term vanishes for the planar reconnection since For HD it vanishes only if we assume divergencefree, isentropic flows since in this case not only has to vanish, but also Note that this holds also for threedimensional fields or which show a planar type of reconnection. It is not required that the field is planar outside the reconnection region. For the three-dimensional case the helicity production will be in general non-vanishing. This effect causes a twist of the two flux tubes in the final state of Figure 2, provided the initial flux tube was untwisted.
3.
Reconnection solutions in HD
In the following it is shown how two- and three-dimensional reconnection solutions are constructed for the Navier-Stokes equation. We assume a constant viscosity , a constant density and a divergencefree velocity so that the continuity equation is trivially satisfied and it remains to solve First we consider two-dimensional solutions of the form and refer to the direction of the z-axis). This implies that both components, and are divergence-free and eqn. (6) splits into two equations:
Reconnection in magnetic and vorticity fields
137
A solution of the system can be found by first solving eqn. (7) and substituting this into eqn. (8). The latter is the same type of equation that we have to solve for two-dimensional resistive MHD. There we express the magnetic field with the help of a flux function so that the resistive Ohm’s law reads
For a prescribed velocity that is for the so called kinematic problem, the solution of this equation are well studied both analytically and numerically, see for example Moffatt 1978. In particular we know that for reconnection to occur the velocity field has to have a stagnation flow, that is it has to have a hyperbolic null point. In addition the electric field has to be non-vanishing at the stagnation point. The rate of reconnected flux is given by an integral along the reconnection line, which is the line obtained by extending the X-point of in the invariant direction,
This implies that in vortex reconnection even if the vorticity field is planar the velocity field has to have a non-vanishing component in the third direction since Although the non-vanishing reconnection rate requires a time-dependent and three-dimensional velocity field for vortex reconnection, we can solve the system (7, 8) by starting with a time-independent solution of (7) with parameters
For this solution is a simple linear stagnation flow. Inserting it into Eq. (8) and using corresponding initial conditions we get a time-dependent solution which resembles the planar reconnection process shown in Figure 1. Note however, that the vorticity field is still invariant in one direction. The figure shows only a set of vorticity field lines forming a flux tube. This is different from the case where the vorticity is concentrated in tubes, as for instance in the numerical simulations by Kida (1991). By using in (11) we superimpose the stagnation flow with a field of constant vorticity in z-direction. This yields a simple extension from a planar two-dimensional vorticity field to a field which now has a component in the third direction. Reconnection in such a field evolves like in the example shown in Figure 2. To be more precise the figure shows a situation where i. e. the component, is comparatively small. For
138
G. Hornig
higher values of the process becomes increasingly asymmetric. Finally for the hyperbolic structure of turns into an elliptic structure and inhibits reconnection. This feature is not present in magnetic reconnection, it is due to the coupling of and by In MHD a similar relation between and does not exist. This restriction also limits the helicity production per reconnected flux in HD.
4.
Summary
A selection of fundamental features of reconnection in magnetic fields and vorticity fields were given and the differences for planar and threedimensional reconnection were discussed. It turns out that while for magnetic reconnection stationary two-dimensional reconnection solutions exist, vortex reconnection requires always a three-dimensional and timedependent velocity field. There exist, however, solutions where the vorticity field is planar and depends only on two coordinates. This shows that the complicated three-dimensional dynamics shown in many numerical simulations of vortex reconnection is mainly due to the global interaction of vortex structures and not a requirement of the local reconnection process.
Acknowledgments The author gratefully acknowledges financial support from the Volkswagen Foundation.
References DE WAELE, A.T.A.M. & AARTS, R.G.K.M. 1994 Route to vortex reconnection, Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 482-485. HORNIG, G. 2001a The Geometry of Magnetic and Vortex Reconnection. In Quantized Vortex Dynamics and Superfluid Turbulence (ed. C. F. Barenghi, R. J. Donnelly & W. F. Vinen), Lecture Notes in Physics 571, Springer. HORNIG, G. 2001b The geometry of reconnection. In Geometry and Topology of Fluid Flows (ed. R. Ricca) Kluwer. KIDA, S., TAKAOKA, M. & HUSSAIN, F. 1991 Collision of two vortex rings, J. Fluid Mech. 230, 583-646. MOFFATT, H.K. 1978 Magnetic field generation in electric conducting fluids, Cambridge University Press.
Energy, helicity and crossing number relations for complex flows Renzo L. RICCA Department of Mathematics, University College London, Gower Street, London WC1E 6BT, United Kingdom
[email protected]
Abstract Algebraic and topological measures based on crossing number relations provide bounds on energy and helicity of ideal fluid flows and can be used to quantify morphological complexity of tangles of magnetic and vortex tubes. In the case of volume-preserving flows we discuss new results useful to determine lower bounds on magnetic energy in terms of topological crossing number and average spacing of the physical system. New relationships between average crossing number, energy and helicity are derived also for homogeneous vortex tangles. These results find interesting applications in the study of possible connections between energy and complexity of structured flows. Topological arguments show That the energy’s bounded below; But what’s so engrossing’s The number of crossings, From which my new insights will flow.
1.
Magnetic and vortex knots as standard embeddings
Consider an incompressible and perfectly conducting fluid in an unbounded domain of that is simply connected, with fluid velocity smooth function of the position vector and time and such that in and at infinity. Consider the class of magnetic fields {B} that are solenoidal and frozen in that is
Under ideal conditions these fields have their prescribed topology conserved during time evolution. We restrict our attention to fields that are localised in space and that are indeed confined to tubular neighbourhoods of knots and links. By construction the field is standardly embedded into nested tori centred on smooth loops that are knot139 K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt (eds.), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 139–144. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
140
R. L. Ricca
ted and linked in (Ricca 1998). For simplicity we take field lines that are closed on themselves within each tube and that have same flux We therefore identify an magnetic link with the standard embedding of a disjoint union of magnetic solitori in
Similarly, by replacing the magnetic field B with the vorticity field chosen so as to satisfy (1) and (2), we obtain vortex knots and links Let us denote by the total volume of the magnetic link and consider the evolution of under the action of the group of volumeand flux–preserving diffeomorphisms
The magnetic energy and the helicity of
are defined by
where A is the vector potential associated with An important issue in topological fluid mechanics is to relate geometric and topological properties to the energy and helicity of the fluid system (for an introductory review see Ricca & Berger 1996).
2.
Helicity, linking and average crossing numbers
It is well known that helicity admits topological interpretation in terms of linking numbers. We have: Theorem (Moffatt 1969; Berger & Field 1984; Moffatt & Ricca 1992): Let be a collection of magnetic links (knots). Then
where denotes the linking number of respect to the framing induced by the embedding of the in denotes the (Gauss) linking number of with
with and
The Gauss linking number between and is a fundamental topological invariant of link types and it is obviously conserved under frozen field evolution. The linking number admits interpretation in terms of minimal number of crossings of the link type: by
Energy, helicity and crossing number relations
141
assigning to each crossing present in a given projected diagram of the oriented link (omitting self-crossings and following a standard sign convention), it can be expressed as sum over signed crossings, according to the formula
where is the classical Gauss integrand form and denotes over- and under–crossings in plane projections (omitting self–crossings; see Figure 1). The White linking number is also a topological invariant associated with the field embedded in and it can be decomposed in two geometric quantities the writhing number (which measures the average space coiling of in ) and the total twist present in Linking numbers are closely related to the average crossing number which is an algebraic measure of the link complexity in space (Freedman & He 1991). For any pair and of components this quantity is simply given by the average total number of apparent crossings present in the link and is defined by
where # denotes all possible crossings (including self-crossings) of the curves and < • > average over all possible planes. Now, since
142
R. L. Ricca
and holds true for any given pair of components and the inequality can be extended to the whole system, hence by using (6) and (8), we have
3.
Topological bounds on magnetic energy
We consider the magnetic relaxation of the magnetic link subject to a volume- and flux-preserving diffeomorphism, as discussed by Moffatt (1992). For simplicity we assume that all link components have same flux and that are all zero–framed, that means for each An interesting result that relates magnetic energy and complexity of the physical system is given by the following: Theorem (Freedman & He 1991): Let link (or knot), then we have
Note that
where
be an essential magnetic
denotes the topological crossing
number of the knot or link type. Moreover Moffatt has shown (1992) that the energy is bounded from below, according to the inequality
where depends on the geometry of supp(B), with a spectrum of ground states given (1990) by
where is related to the topology of the system. The problem whether these infima can actually reach their minimum value remains open. Both and were left undetermined. By using the result of Freedman & He, combined with the inequality (10), we can show (for a detailed discussion, see Ricca 2002) that
Equation (14–i) and (12) state that for given linking complexity (with notable exceptions: see Figure 2b), the smaller the volume, the higher the energy level. This is in agreement with the intuitive idea that for a
Energy, helicity and crossing number relations
143
knotted rope the tighter the knot, i. e. the smaller the physical space it occupies, the higher is its potential energy. Equation (14–ii) identifies with the topological crossing number of the knot/link type. This result, combined with eq. (13), provides an interesting and powerful relationship between ground state energy and topology and shows the intimate relationship between the two. By direct inspection of the link tabulation, it is however immediately evident that there may be countably many topologically distinct links with equal number of components and same topological crossing number leaving partially open the fundamental question of identifying uniquely ground state energies with topology. An example is given by Figure 2, where three distinct link types with and are shown: assuming for these links same volume and flux, then all three links have same
4.
Vortex tangles and complexity
Finally, let us consider a tangle of (zero-framed) vortex filaments in a steady state. As above, all filaments are assumed to have same strength Kinetic energy T and helicity are defined as usual by
Since
by applying Hölder inequality to the second term, we have
144
R. L. Ricca
where is the total enstrophy of the tangle. Work on possible new relationships between complexity, topology and energy of vortex tangles is currently under way and new results on complexity measures can be found in the paper by Barenghi, Ricca & Samuels (2001) (see also the paper in this volume).
Acknowledgments The present author wishes to acknowledge financial support from EPSRC (grant GR/K99015) and PPARC (GR/L63143).
References BARENGHI C.F., RICCA, R.L. & SAMUELS D.C. 2001 How tangled is a tangle? Physica D 157, 197–206. BERGER, M.. & FIELD, G.B. 1984 The topological properties of magnetic helicity. J. Fluid Mech. 147, 133–148. FREEDMAN, M.H. & HE, Z.-X. 1991 Divergence-free fields: energy and asymptotic, crossing number. Ann. Math. 134, 189–229. MOFFATT, H.K. 1969 The degree of knottedness of tangled vortex lines. J. Fluid Mech. 35, 117–129. MOFFATT, H.K. 1990 The energy spectrum of knots and links. Nature 347, 367–369. MOFFATT, H.K. 1992 Relaxation under topological constraints. In Topological Aspects of the Dynamics of Fluids and Plasmas (ed. H. K. Moffatt et al.), pp. 3–28. Kluwer, Dordrecht, The Netherlands. MOFFATT, H.K. & RICCA, R.L. 1992 Helicity and the invariant. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 439, 411–429. RICCA, R.L. 1998 Applications of knot theory in fluid mechanics. In Knot Theory (ed. V. F. R. Jones et al.), pp. 321–346. Banach Center Publ. 42, Polish Academy of Sciences, Warsaw. RICCA, R.L. 2002 Energy, helicity and topological bounds. In preparation. RICCA, R.L. & BERGER, M.A. 1996 Topological ideas and fluid mechanics. Phys. Today 49 (12), 24–30.
Helicity conservation laws
Institute of Applied Mathematics and Mechanics, Warsaw University, ul. Banacha 2, 02-097 Warsaw, and Institute of Fundamental Technological Research, ul. 21, 00-049 Warsaw, Poland
[email protected]
Abstract Using the language of differential forms on a space-time, one can write the equation of an ideal fluid in a form similar to the Maxwell equations. Vorticity current plays then the role of the source term and the Euler equations can be interpreted as the generalisation, to the whole space-time, of the well-known fact that the number of vortex lines passing through any two-dimensional surface spanned on a closed contour can be expressed by a circulation associated with this contour. A similar procedure can be used for the ideal MHD. It appears that by using this formulation various helicity conservation theorems may be derived in the natural and straightforward manner . My passion for diff’rential forms Defies all traditional norms; It may make you queasy, But it’s really quite easy; It ought to be taught in the dorms.
1.
Introduction
It appears that many equations of mathematical physics when formulated in the language of differential forms take especially simple and elegant form (Flanders 1963, Arnold, Khesin 1998). This, as we will see, concerns also equations of fluid dynamics 1990, 1991), including MHD. The simplest example of a differential form (apart from 0-forms which are just functions) is a 1-form i. e. a field of covectors. Such a form can be evaluated on a vector-field X to obtain (with Einstein summation convention observed). Having such forms one defines their exterior product – a simple which when evaluated on vector-fields gives
145 K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt (eds.), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 145–150. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
146
So, this is always zero when ( is the dimension of the space) or when 1-forms are linearly dependent. Any is a linear combination (with coefficients depending on ) of such simple forms. For being respectively and we have
so
if is an odd number (or Forms can be also differentiated
).
The operation takes into derivative. We have the useful relation
it is called the exterior
For any given vector-field V we can define also, what is sometimes called the interior derivative of the by
Thus the interior derivative takes into purely algebraic operation. Assuming that is a
and it is a we have
In principle we will be working here with differential forms defined on the four-dimensional space-time. However, for clarity and better exposition of the correspondence with the commonly used vector notation we will often decompose any 1-form into temporal and spatial part, where the spatial part is For convenience we assume that Greek indices take values 0, 1, 2, 3 whereas the Latin ones – values 1, 2, 3. Similarly, we can decompose the exterior derivative where This decomposition makes sense as long as we use the Galilean system of coordinates. In the description that we propose the vortices (vortex lines) are treated as a sort of particles responsible for the induced fields. So, in this language both ”fields” and ”particles” are treated as equally real. This corresponds to the situation which one encounters in superfluids, where vortices are even better visible than the fluid velocity.
Helicity conservation laws
2.
147
The Euler equations
To begin with, we define the action 1-form
where are the covariant components of fluid velocity and specific enthalpy, which in the case of incompressible fluid is and in the more general case of a barotropic fluid
is the
Here denotes the pressure. The ”density” of vortex lines can be measured by a vorticity current 2form J, which in a system of coordinates co-moving with vortex lines is given by a purely spatial 2-form
The dot above the equality sign reminds here that the equality takes place in a specific system of coordinates. Using Galilean transformation
with being the vortex line velocity we may pass to the laboratory system to obtain The contravariant velocity of vortex lines in general can be different from the fluid velocity, as it occurs, for example, in the case of superfluid helium In the case of the ordinary fluid Let S be a 2-dimensional surface in the space-time, spanned on a contour The equality
by the Stokes law leads to which appears to be equivalent in the vector notation to
where in the last two equations is a vorticity vector-field which corresponds to the vorticity 2-form in 3-dimensional space by Obviously, the continuity equation can be also written by
148
using the fluid current 3-form where again in the system of coordinates moving locally with the fluid
and where
is the fluid density. In the laboratory system again
where is contravariant fluid velocity. The continuity equation div reads then as Thus finally the full set of flow equations is given by Let us note that in the four-dimensional space-time a vortex line is represented by a two-dimensional surface (the history of a vortex line). In general, two two-dimensional surfaces (e. g. planes) in a four-dimensional space have just one point in common. Therefore it makes sense to speak of vortex lines passing through a two-dimensional surface in the spacetime. As so taking the exterior derivative of Eq. (10), one obtains
which in the vector notation is equivalent to the equations for vorticity
Here the dot denotes the time derivative.
3.
MHD equations
In addition to the previously introduced forms 2-form of the magnetic field.
and J we define the
Let be a contravariant vector-field of the electric current divided by the fluid density then the equation
is equivalent in the vector notation to the following system
Helicity conservation laws
149
Similarly, let us define the 1-form of the electromagnetic potential
and the ”magnetic current”
Then the equation is equivalent to the following system of vectorial equations
Taking the exterior derivative of (18) we have
which again is equivalent to
Summarising the equations of the ideal MHD can be written as
and
4.
is their consequence.
Helicity conservation laws
Theorem 1 The following 3-forms in the space-time define conserved currents
where in
we assume
(the case of ordinary fluid dynamics).
To prove it, we have to demonstrate that
150
Indeed, in the appropriate co-moving system of coordinates this is equivalent respectively to 1. 2. 3. & 4. Again and are vanishing since these are 4-forms living in 3-space (there is no dt). Since we have also
which proves that indeed For example, in the vector notation the equation expressed as
where defines helicity and the flux of helicity. In particular, if
can be
is is vanishing at infinity, we have
As noticed by Moffatt (1969) helicity expresses some topological properties of vortex (respectively magnetic) lines. This work was supported by KBN grant 7T07A01817.
References ARNOLD, V.I., KHESIN, B.A. 1998 Topological Methods in Hydrodynamics. SpringerVerlag, New York–Berlin–Heidelberg. FLANDERS, H. 1963 Differential Forms with applications to physical sciences. Academic Press, New York–London. MOFFATT, H.K. 1969 The degree of knottedness of tangled vortex lines. J. Fluid Mech. 35, part 1, 117-129. 1988 Properly posed boundary condition and the existence theorem in superfluid In Trends in Applications of Mathematics to Mechanics, Proc. 7th Symposium (ed. J. F. Besseling & W. Eckhaus), pp. 224-237. Springer Verlag. 1990 Helicity theorem and vortex lines in superfluid Int. J. Theoret. Physics 29, 1277-1284. 1991 Differential forms and fluid dynamics. Arch. Mech. 43, 653661.
A third-order topological invariant for three magnetic fields Christoph MAYER & Gunnar HORNIG* Theoretische Physik IV, Fakultät für Physik und Astronomie, Ruhr-Universität Bochum, 44780 Bochum, Germany
[email protected],
[email protected]
If you notice a third-order link You can colour it green, brown and pink; Invariants follow, As hills follow hollow; So a field triply-linked cannot shrink.
Abstract The topology of divergence-free fields is important in many parts of physics, e. g. in magnetohydrodynamics, plasma physics, hydrodynamics, superfluids etc. With the focus on applications in magnetohydrodynamics, our principal aim is the characterisation of magnetic fields by the means of invariants. In this report an introduction to the problem of finding higher order invariants is given. Then a third-order link integral of three magnetic fields is presented, which can be shown to be a topological invariant and therefore an invariant in ideal magnetohydrodynamics. This integral generalises the known third-order link invariant derived from the Massey triple product, which could only be applied to isolated flux tubes. As an example three magnetic fields not confined to flux tubes are given that possess a third-order linkage.
1.
Introduction
In recent years topological considerations have become increasingly important in the study of physical problems. In plasma physics for example the topology of magnetic fields plays an important role when dealing with problems such as the stability and time evolution of a plasma or when estimating its energy content. The structure of magnetic fields is studied with the aid of topological measures of complexity, i. e. measures which are invariant under diffeo-
*The
authors gratefully acknowledge financial support from the Volkswagen Foundation.
151 K. Bajer and H.K. Moffatt (eds.), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 151–156. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
152
Christoph Mayer and Gunnar Hornig
morphic isotopies of the magnetic field. The simplest of such measures is magnetic helicity. For a magnetic field B with vector potential A it is defined as the volume integral
which is gauge invariant if Magnetic helicity measures the total mutual linkage of magnetic flux (see Moffatt 1969). In ideal magnetohydrodynamics, i. e. in the regime of large magnetic Reynolds numbers, the magnetic field is frozen into the plasma flow and magnetic helicity is a conserved quantity. Since it is quadratic in magnetic flux it is often referred to as a second-order topological invariant. As examples the Hopf link and the double twisted torus are shown in the following figure, which both have the same magnetic helicity of
It has been known for a long time that magnetic field configurations exist which are non-trivially linked, but for which the magnetic helicity vanishes. Helicity e. g. fails to detect the interlocking of three flux tubes in the form of the Borromean rings (Figure 1c). This raises the question whether higher order invariants exist which detect these linkages.
2.
Higher order invariants
In knot theory different invariants are known which distinguish for example the Borromean rings from unlinked rings. To use these invariants e. g. to measure the complexity of magnetic fields, they have to be expressed in terms of physical quantities, i. e. in terms of the magnetic field B. For most knot invariants a translation into a physical setting is unknown and still no higher order invariant with > 2 has been found which is applicable to an arbitrary magnetic field We will see that matters simplify, if the field splits into isolated flux tubes each with magnetic field In this case is to be considered as an invariant which measures the -th order cross-linkage of distinct magnetic flux tubes.
A third-order topological invariant for three magnetic fields
153
It was recognised by Monastyrsky & Retakh (1986) and independently by Berger (1990) and Evans & Berger (1992) that the link invariants based on so-called Massey higher products (see Massey 1958, 1969) can be written as invariants applicable to magnetic flux tubes. Massey higher products in fact yield a hierarchy of higher order invariants, which are expressible as cross-linkage integrals of the above mentioned type. Unfortunately, their usage is restricted to magnetic fields confined to flux tubes which must not possess a linkage lower than the linkage which is measured. The situation is summarised in the following table Total-linkage
Cross-linkage
cross-helicity for arbitrary fields fields restricted to flux tubes with no 2nd order linkage fields restricted to flux tubes with no 2nd or 3rd order linkage where and are constructed respectively from the Massey triple and quadruple product.
3.
Generalisation of the third-order invariant
In this section we generalise the third-order invariant known from the Massey triple product to an invariant of three magnetic fields not confined to flux tubes. Theorem: Let and be three magnetic fields with potentials and let In an ideal dynamics, i.e. with in all three components, the integral
is a gauge invariant, conserved quantity, if the three potentials obey for all and the boundary condition for n being the normal vector to the boundary of the integration volume V.
154
Christoph Mayer and Gunnar Hornig
A complete proof of this theorem is given in Hornig & Mayer (2001) and only the main ideas shall be presented here: For an arbitrary gauge field we have the following general identity
where the term on the left is known as the second Chern class and the three-form on the right as the Chern-Simons three-form. For the gauge group U(1), which yields electrodynamics on identity (2), together with an ideal dynamics, i. e. with leads to the continuity equation for helicity density
This proves the well known result that the integral over helicity density, for the boundary condition is a conserved quantity. Using instead of the group U(1) the gauge group SU(2), the potential A naturally has three components A summation over repeated indices is understood. Here the Pauli matrices were chosen as a basis for the Lie algebra su(2). Interpreted as three independent potentials of electromagnetic fields identity (2) together with leads (i) to the helicity conservation of and (ii) to a new continuity equation, which with and cyclic permutations of it, reads
Analogous to the case of helicity this continuity equation yields a conservation law for the density Together with the gauge invariance (see Hornig & Mayer 2001) this proves the above theorem. Let us note that the presented derivation reveals a close relationship between magnetic helicity and the generalised third-order invariant. In fact, both conservation laws result from the same identity (2). In the special case of three fields confined to flux tubes, condition (i) of the theorem implies that the tubes must be mutually unlinked. It can easily be confirmed that in this case integral (1) coincides with expressions derived from the Massey triple product given by Monastyrsky & Retakh (1986), Berger (1990) and Ruzmaikin & Akhmetiev (1994). Finally we want to remark, that the third-order invariant can be interpreted as the cross-helicity
of the pair of divergence-free fields
and
for each
A third-order topological invariant for three magnetic fields
4.
155
Example magnetic field
We know that the requirement of the above theorem can always be satisfied for fields confined to mutually unlinked flux tubes. However, it is not easily satisfied for three arbitrary fields. In the following Yang-Mills theory is used to construct a natural example of three magnetic fields not confined to flux tubes, to which the invariant can be applied. In an SU(2) gauge symmetry the field strength has components for Taking the exterior derivative we observe that is sufficient for all to vanish. These potential components meet the above requirement and therefore shall be interpreted as three potentials of independent electromagnetic fields. Since is trivially fulfilled for i. e. for a pure gauge Yang-Mills field, we are now going to construct such a field on a time slice of Using the mapping
we perform a gauge transformation from the classical vacuum
This yields the potential of a vacuum Yang-Mills field (see Hornig & Mayer 2001) with a winding number of the vacuum of 1 (see ItzyksonZuber 1980). The three independent magnetic fields, calculated from are well defined and decay sufficiently with
156
Christoph Mayer and Gunnar Hornig
for large radii. As is shown in Hornig & Mayer (2001) the non-vanishing winding number of the Yang-Mills vacuum directly implies a non-trivial third-order linkage. Explicitly calculating integral (1) we find
The constructed magnetic fields are in fact highly symmetric. Each field is invariant with respect to rotations about the and all three fields are similar in that they can be obtained from one field by rotations which map the axis of symmetry on one another. As seen in Figure (2) all field lines are closed and have an elliptical shape. Even though all cross-helicities vanish, individual field lines among different fields are in general linked. To be more precise, every pair of such field lines is either linked exactly once or intersects twice.
5.
Conclusions
An integral expression is given which generalises the third-order invariant known from the Massey triple product. It is interesting that in the presented derivation helicity and are the result of the same identity. An example shows that the new invariant is a real generalisation. Still an open question is whether a third-order invariant for the “total-linkage” of a single arbitrary magnetic field exists and whether it can be constructed from the “cross-linkage” similar to the case of helicity. There might e. g. exist a subdivision of a single magnetic field into three components, such that Unfortunately, the antisymmetry of the “cross-linkage” seems to be one of the key problems for a further generalisation analogous to helicity.
References BERGER, M.A. 1990 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 23, 2787. EVANS, N.W., BERGER, M.A. 1992 in Moffatt et al: Topological aspects of fluids and plasmas, Nato ASI Series E, Vol 218 (Dordrecht, Kluwer Academic Publ. ), p 237. HORNIG, G., MAYER, C. 2001 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. (accepted), arXiv: physics/0203048. ITZYKSON, C. & ZUBER, J.-B. 1980 Quantum Field Theory. McGraw-Hill, New York. MASSEY, W.S. 1958 Some higher order cohomology operations. Symp. Intern. Topologia Algebraica, Mexico, UNESCO. MASSEY, W.S. 1969 “Higher order linking numbers”. In Conf. on Algebraic Topology, Univ. Illinois at Chicago Circle, Chicago, Ill., June 1968, ed. Victor Gugenheim. Reprinted in: J. of Knot Theory and Its Ram., 7, No. 3, (1998), 393-414. MOFFATT, H.K. 1969 Journal of Fluid Mechanics 35, 117. MONASTYRSKY, M.I. & RETAKH, V.S. 1986 Commun. Math. Phys. 103, 445. RUZMAIKIN, A. & AKHMETIEV P. 1994 Phys. Plasmas 1, 331-336.
Asymptotic structure of fast dynamo eigenfunctions B. J. BAYLY Mathematics Dept., University of Arizona Tucson AZ 85721, USA
[email protected]
Abstract The eigenfunctions of the kinematic dynamo problem exhibit complicated spatial structure when the magnetic diffusivity is small. When the base flow is spatially periodic, we may study this structure by examining the Fourier components of the eigenfunction at large wavevectors. In this regime we may seek a WKB form in terms of slowly-varying functions of wavevector. The resulting hierarchy of equations may be systematically analysed for both zero and small nonzero diffusivities. Eigenfunctions of dynamos fast Have fine structure of gradient vast; I ask you to gaze At equations of phase, And singular things that don’t last. —HKM 2001
1.
A Professor in old Zakopane Wrote limericks clever and fane, Then read them aloud To an exuberant crowd Whose response was to throw lots of mane. –BJB 2001
Introduction
This symposium is devoted to understanding the origin and role of the near-singular events and structures observed in real flows and numerical simulations. The direct approach, pursued by most participants at this meeting, is to start from nonlinear evolution equations (exact or approximated or modelled) and ask under what circumstances the solutions become infinite at some points in space and time. An alternative, less direct, approach is to start from the linearised equations for perturbations to known solutions, and formulate hydrodynamic or hydromagnetic stability problems. The resulting eigenproblems are again nonlinear, because the unknown eigenvalue multiplies the unknown eigenfunction, but in a different way from the original evolution equations. These eigenproblems may also have singular solutions, but the singularities will be different from the singularities of the evolution equations. Despite the indirectness of this formulation, it is likely that
157 K. Bajer and H. K. Moffatt (eds.), Tubes, Sheets and Singularities in Fluid Dynamics, 157–168. © 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
158
B. J. Bayly
some of the near-singular structures observed in real and simulated flows are closely related to the singular eigenfunctions of stability problems. The techniques of this paper are applicable to a wide variety of hydromagnetic stability problems. For simplicity, however, we will focus on the kinematic dynamo problem, in which a flow of electrically-conducting fluid is specified and the behaviour of a weak magnetic perturbation is analysed in the linear regime. For positive values of the magnetic diffusivity this problem is relatively well-understood as an elliptic eigenvalue problem. But in the limit of zero magnetic diffusivity the eigenfunctions develop more and more complex spatial structure, and there are open questions about what (if anything) they converge to. Understanding the behaviour of the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions in the non-diffusive limit is the fast dynamo problem. The fast dynamo problem was identified almost thirty years ago ( Vainshtein & Zeldovich 1972) and has been considerably studied since. We draw the reader’s attention to the monograph of Childress & Gilbert (1995) for a comprehensible introduction and comprehensive discussion of what is now a sizable body of scientific literature. The bibliography of the present note will of necessity only mention a small selection of the work on this subject.
2.
Kinematic dynamo basics
The usual formulation of the kinematic dynamo problem is as follows. The velocity field of an electrically-conducting fluid is prescribed. It is typically smooth, with “Jacobian” strain-rate derivative matrix
and solenoidal: Then the induction equation for the magnetic field can be written in advection-stretching form:
where represents the magnetic diffusivity. We will suppose that all physical quantities are non-dimensionalised with respect to sensible scales, so that is the inverse of the magnetic Reynolds number. The velocity field is typically bounded in space, and steady in time. This allows the possibility that solutions to (2) might grow exponentially in time with a well-defined spatial form:
Asymptotic structure of fast dynamo eigenfunctions
159
with Indeed, the classical kinematic dynamo problem is to determine for what flows there are such growing solutions, and what the growing solutions look like. The fast dynamo problem further asks whether the growth rate remains bounded above zero as the diffusivity and to what (if anything) do the eigenfunctions converge. In virtually all studies appears to approach a well-defined limit as even though develops extremely complicated structure on ever-smaller scales. In this work I shall assume that the eigenvalue converges, and examine the detailed structure of the magnetic field eigenfunctions.
3.
Steady spatially-periodic velocity field
We shall assume that the given velocity field is steady and spatially periodic, and write it explicitly as
where is a subset of In many examples is actually finite, as with ABC flows (Arnold & Korkina 1983, Galloway & Frisch 1986, Lau & Finn 1993). Otherwise it is reasonable to assume rapidly as so that is smooth. Eigensolutions of the induction equation (2) then may be sought in the form (choosing the Bloch wavevector equal to zero)
This form is not necessarily localised in wavevector space. We anticipate that if the diffusivity is positive then at some point will decay as increases, but if is small then this decay may only begin at large values of Furthermore the limit of as with m held fixed might not decay with increasing at all. The noninterchangeability of these limits is a subtle but important aspect of the fast dynamo problem. The induction equation can then be separated into its own Fourier components:
This form is frequently computationally convenient, especially when is a small finite set). Unfortunately it is conceptually rather opaque, as most of us have little experience with multivariable difference equations with non-constant coefficients.
160
4.
B. J. Bayly
Slowly varying Fourier amplitudes
The existence of structure on many length scales in indicates that the significant Fourier amplitudes are ”spread” over a wide region of wavevector space. More precisely, the size of the region occupied by significant Fourier amplitudes is large compared with the typical size of the wavevectors in Over most of this region the separation between and is relatively small and seems relatively unimportant, just as the differences between Cambridge and Oxford appear small and unimportant when viewed from outside Britain. In the fast dynamo problem this impression is correct. We may incorporate it in a WKB (or GLJWKB, as enthusiasts for historical accuracy at the workshop suggested) ansatz
where and are slowly varying functions of This ansatz also assumes that m may be treated as a continuous variable, and that Taylor series may be used to approximate the slowly varying functions when evaluated at The vector field is given unit magnitude everywhere, and merely plays the role of indicating the direction of There are orientability issues concerned with the choice of sign for but these will not be pursued in this paper. The important information lies in which has both real and imaginary parts to reflect both the phase and amplitude of respectively. The exponential ansatz (7) will also allow us to seek S as the sum of a leading-order part plus corrections. Important aspects of such as power laws or diffusive regularisation will emerge transparently from additive corrections to It should be noted that itself is not slowly- varying by the above definition. Our ansatz does not prevent from varying by an O(1) amount from one lattice point in to its neighbours. It is subtle, even fortuitous, that we are able to assume slowly-varying and to draw inferences regarding the values of the non-slowly-varying function at discrete wavevectors. Substituting (7) into the induction equation, and multiplying through by yields
Asymptotic structure of fast dynamo eigenfunctions
161
Now we use the assumption of slow variation to write
where indicates higher-order, i.e. asymptotically smaller, terms. We can use (9) to approximate the exponentials in (8) by
bearing in mind that we can use the linear approximation to the exponential for o(1) but not O(1) arguments. Before we attempt to substitute the approximations (9), (10) into the induction equation (8), note that many of the terms will have similar structures. Using F, G as dummy symbols, these common structures are of the form
Anything like that does not depend on factors out of the sum, and the remaining summations simply amount to reconstituting the original physical-space function and its second derivative, respectively:
These derivatives are of course matrix-valued, but we are omitting indices in the hope that the reduced clutter enhances clarity. Returning to the quantities appearing in the induction equation, we observe that the original physical-space forms of the velocity and velocitygradient fields reappear when the slowly-varying ansatz (7) for the Fourier amplitudes of the magnetic field eigensolution is substituted into the induction equation (6) in wavevector space. This algebraic felicity reflects a general geometric principle: that the main contributions to the Fourier amplitude at a wavevector of large magnitude tend to come from a localised region of physical space in which the gradients are aligned with
B. J. Bayly
162
the direction of (the principle of stationary phase). These formulae also tell us the location of the spatial region giving the dominant contribution to it is the argument of the reconstituted physical-space formulae in (12). Because it is so important we give it its own symbol: At this stage it might be objected that we seem to have inconsistent interpretations of S. When S was first introduced we said it should have both real and imaginary parts to accommodate phase and amplitude variations of But if we identify with a physical point in space, this would seem to prohibit any non-constant imaginary part of S. The resolution is that the principle of stationary phase is intentionally an approximate statement that describes only the leading order of a short-wave asymptotic theory. We will find typically that at leading order and are real, and imaginary components enter only as corrections. To be sure, there are circumstances in which even the leading order parts of S and X are complex, but we shall not pursue them in this paper. As mentioned before, the unit vector field indicates the direction of but does not play a major role in determining the asymptotic behaviour. For simplicity we shall modify the whole problem to a scalar form (Bayly 1993). We drop and replace the stretching matrix by the scalar “stretching function” The result is an eikonal equation for the phase function alone:
For those concerned about throwing the baby out with the bathwater, the scalar dynamo model allows complex-valued fields, so that vector processes such as cancellation of oppositely-directed fields may still be faithfully represented. Numerical investigations of complex-valued scalar dynamo models show behaviour completely analogous to the original vector problem.
5.
Diffusionless asymptotics
The situation of diffusivity exactly zero is of course not the same as the limit as diffusivity goes to zero. This can be seen directly in (6), in which the diffusivity multiplies while all other terms involve lower
Asymptotic structure of fast dynamo eigenfunctions
163
powers of m. No matter how small is, as long as it is positive the diffusive term dominates for sufficiently large On the other hand, if is very small then there will be a sizable finite range of m for which the non-diffusive terms dominate. For the high-wavenumber part of this range we may still use the slowly-varying ansatz and focus on the nondiffusive terms only. What we are doing, of course, is working out an intermediate asymptotics for m in an “overlap” region between the very high at which diffusivity dominates and the low at which is O(1). In a global theory we would work out asymptotics for these other regimes also and fix undetermined quantities by matching. In this work, however, we shall restrict attention to this intermediate regime. Even apart from the diffusive term, some terms in the equation will dominate others. The solution will then consist of a big part that approximately satisfies the dominant balance, plus a little part that collectively accounts for all the corrections. Our ansatz suggests that will be with gradient of size O(1). The correction is expected to be O(l), or perhaps with gradient Without the diffusive term, the leading order in (14) is and at this order we have Recalling the stationary-phase interpretation that is a physical point at which the spatial structures are aligned perpendicular to m, equation (15) indicates that to leading order the spatial structures at are aligned parallel to the velocity field. This is not at all surprising; indeed it a check on the sensibility of the asymptotics. Equation (15) is an Eulerian statement about the alignment of structures at a fixed point in space. There is a natural Lagrangian version of this statement that is perhaps slightly stronger: if the spatial structures are aligned parallel to the velocity field at a certain point at a certain time, and then allowed to follow the material trajectories of the flow, they will continue to remain so aligned. More precisely, if we introduce a time-like parameter along a Lagrangian trajectory, then the position and wavevector evolve along the trajectory according to
Then, if (15) is true at any point of the trajectory, it will be true at every point. As mentioned in a previous section, the leading order functions and are purely real, consistent with the stationary phase interpretation.
164
B. J. Bayly
The next order appearing in the diffusionless (14) is O(1):
This can be interpreted in the Lagrangian representation (16) as
Recalling the definition (7) of S, we recognise this as simply the logarithm of the magnitude of Again, this bears out our previous remark that the corrections to the purely real leading-order behaviour may be complex, with the imaginary part containing amplitude information. The exact nature of solutions to (18) depends of course on the Lagrangian trajectories, i. e. fluid particle paths, of the flow. It is a common situation for a substantial portion of the flow to exhibit “Lagrangian chaos”, in which details of individual trajectories are chaotic and unpredictable but long-time averages along trajectories take well-defined values. We would therefore expect the right-hand side of (18) to have a well-defined trajectory average The logarithmic amplitude would then be expected to go roughly like as a function of the Lagrangian parameter The amplitude itself goes roughly like
At the same time, if the trajectory is in the chaotic region, we expect the magnitude of the wavevector to increase exponentially at a rate given by the Lyapunov exponent along the trajectory,
Putting (19) and (20) together implies a power law type of behaviour:
The exponent in this law depends in an intricate way on several quantities. Some of them have simple geometric significance, such as the Lyapunov exponent or the trajectory average of the stretching function But the eigenvalue is not so simple; it appears to be determined by the interaction of large-scale structures, i. e. at wavevectors of size O(1). And the third term on the right-hand side of (18) seems to defy simple interpretation, let alone its trajectory average. Whatever the power is, the fact that it is a power law at all indicates that the zero-diffusivity limit of the eigenfunction is not smooth.
Asymptotic structure of fast dynamo eigenfunctions
165
If the power is negative the spatial eigenfunction may be continuous or even differentiable a certain number of times. It appears in most situations that the power is actually positive. This implies that no pointwise convergence is to be expected, or even convergence to a distribution like a The most likely candidate so far advanced for zerodiffusivity limit of the eigenfunction is a sign-singular measure (Du, Tel, &Ott 1994).
6.
Diffusive asymptotics
Because the diffusivity multiplies the highest power of in the induction equation (whichever form we consider) the point at which it enters the asymptotics depends on the regime. For example, when or greater, diffusion is as strong as advection, and both are stronger than stretching. At the opposite extreme, when diffusion is smaller than advection and stretching, both of which are O(1). As mentioned before, we are interested in small scales, but for which diffusive effects are still relatively small. More precisely, we will assume so that the leading order remains non-diffusive and diffusive effects enter as corrections. There still remains the question of the relative magnitudes of and the formally O(1) terms in the diffusionless expansion. In practice there can be a variety of subtle balances and fractional powers (e. g. or in the results, depending on details of the velocity and stretching fields. The reality is that now we have a problem with two small quantities in which we want to expand the solution, one of which is a constant and the other a variable. The complete theory must involve consideration of all the possible balances and appropriate matches amongst them, and is beyond the scope of this note. We will therefore proceed informally from here on. Algebraically, the crucial difference between the diffusive and diffusionless eikonal equations is that the diffusive equation is quadratic in albeit with the small prefactor Therefore the correction to the phase function must also contain a term quadratic in and we expect its magnitude to go to zero as although as yet its precise limiting behaviour is not specified. We use the same notation as in the diffusionless expansion, with diffusive corrections
The eikonal equation uses the derivatives of the phase functions
166
and similar expressions for equation yields an order
B. J. Bayly
Substituting into the eikonal component
where is the same quantity that appeared at the leading order of the diffusionless expansion. Details of the solution to (24) depend of course on the flow-field and the stretching function But we can observe that is now a mere inhomogeneous term. i. e. a regular perturbation, no longer a singular perturbation. Whatever the details bring, we can anticipate that solutions at small finite will connect continuously with the solutions when exactly. For example, suppose we are in the situation described at the end of the diffusionless asymptotics: that we are in a region of chaotic flow. Then, following the Lagrangian trajectory with time-like parameter we have upon which (24) becomes
therefore
In other words, the overall behaviour of the diffusive correction to the phase function is a negative imaginary (hence regularising) part quadratic in Keith Moffatt remarked that, according to this formula, diffusive effects become important when i. e. at physical lengthscales on the order of in agreement with an estimate obtained by quite different methods(Moffatt & Proctor 1985). We may pursue higher-order terms in the diffusive asymptotics, though the terms rapidly increase in number and decrease in usable information. As is typical of many such expansions, successive corrections satisfy linear equations with inhomogeneities defined in terms of lower-order terms already found. Provided resonance does not occur, successive diffusive corrections are expected to have the same dependence on as with decreasing powers of
Asymptotic structure of fast dynamo eigenfunctions
167
Resonance does not appear to occur at but it does at O(1). Indeed, it would be surprising if it did not, because at O(1) will appear any modification of the eigenvalue due to the presence of small finite diffusivity. Now, the complete determination of the diffusive correction must involve “boundary conditions” on the diffusive corrections to which can only be defined by matching to other asymptotic regimes. Nonetheless, the order-of-magnitude dependence on is governed by the structure of the asymptotic expansion, and we therefore expect the diffusive correction to the eigenvalue to be of the same magnitude in as The claim of the foregoing paragraph may appear to be a detail of high-order asymptotics, of marginal interest at best. But the last paragraph argues that whatever determines the eigenvalue, the difference between the diffusive and non-diffusive eigenvalues should vanish at a well-defined rate as the diffusivity goes to zero. This result is almost, but not quite, an affirmative answer to the fast dynamo problem. In order to establish a positive fast dynamo result, very little more has to be done. What is needed is an accurate numerical calculation at a sufficiently small but finite diffusivity, yielding an eigenvalue with real part greater than zero by an O(1) amount. What “sufficiently” means is that the real part of the calculated eigenvalue should be greater than the magnitude of the diffusive correction to the eigenvalue. This would establish that for any smaller diffusivity, the real part of the corresponding eigenvalue would also be positive, and that the limit of the eigenvalue as diffusivity goes to zero would also exist and have positive real part. Of course, such a conclusion would still lack mathematical rigour by the nature of both the numerics and the asymptotics. But it would be a substantial step in our understanding of the fast dynamo problem. It has been almost 30 years since Vainshtein and Zel’dovich first formulated it; we really ought to be asymptotically approaching a solution by now.
7.
Summary
Many important fluid mechanical phenomena involve structures developing on the smallest spatial scales available. These smallest scales are usually determined by a diffusivity of some kind, and in the limit of zero diffusivity the small scale structures often appear to approach some kind of singularity. The kinematic dynamo is a well-studied problem of this type, and this paper has presented a general approach to investigating its small-scale structure. Since we only specified classes of problems rather than specific examples we were not able to provide explicit results,
168
B. J. Bayly
but we have identified the nature of the asymptotic limit and described some features we expect to be generic or at least common. We only considered the kinematic dynamo problem in this paper, and indeed obtained most of our conclusions from a scalar modification. However it does not appear that the overall results depend crucially on the special structure of either the scalar model or the kinematic dynamo problem. In particular, we expect this kind of behaviour to manifest itself in a wide variety of hydrodynamic and hydromagnetic stability problems. The technique of using a WKB-type analysis in wavevector space instead of physical space was the key to making progress in this problem, and it will be of interest to see in what other problems this technique proves to be useful.
Acknowledgments I first worked on fast dynamos with Steve Childress over fifteen years ago. I would like to acknowledge his continuing influence and inspiration as I have pursued this ever-more intriguing problem.
References ARNOLD, V. I. & KORKINA, E. I. 1983 The growth of a magnetic field in a threedimensional steady incompressible flow. Vest. Mask. Un. Ta. Ser. 1, Matem. Mekh. no. 3, 43-46. BAYLY, B. J. 1993 Scalar dynamo models. Geo. Astro. Fluid Dyn. 73, 61-74. CHILDRESS, S. & GILBERT, A. D. 1995 Stretch, Twist, Fold: The Fast Dynamo, Springer. DU, Y., TEL, T., & OTT, E. 1994 Characterization of sign-singular measures. Physica D 76, 168-180. GALLOWAY, D. J. & FRISCH, U. 1986 Dynamo action in a family of flows with chaotic streamlines. Geo. Astro. Fluid Dyn. 36, 53-83. LAU, Y. -T. & FINN, J. M. 1993 Fast dynamos with finite resistivity in steady flows with stagnation points. Phys. Fluids B 5, 365-375. MOFFATT, H. K. & PROCTOR, M. R. E. 1985 Topological constraints associated with fast dynamo action. J. Fluid Mech. 154, 493-507. VAINSHTEIN, S. I. & ZELDOVICH, YA. B. 1972 Origin of magnetic fields in astrophysics. Usp. Fiz. Nauk 106, 431-457. [English translation: Sov. Phys. Usp. 15, 159-172. ]
IV
VORTEX STRUCTURE IN TURBULENT FLOW
This page intentionally left blank
Vortex tubes, spirals, and large-eddy simulation of turbulence D.I. PULLIN Graduate Aeronautical Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena CA 91125
Abstract Progress in the quantitative modelling of turbulence using vortex-based models of the fine scales is reviewed. Recent work on the calculation of the spectrum of a passive scalar convecting and diffusing with