TREATISE ON ANALYSIS Volume I1
Enlarged and Corrected Printing
This is Volume 10-11 in PURE AND APPLIED MATHEMATICS A Series of Monographs and Textbooks
EILENBERG AND HYMAN BASS Editors: SAMUEL A list of recent titles in this series appears at the end of this volume.
Volume 10 TREATISE ON ANALYSIS 10-1. Chapters I-XI, Foundations of Modern Analysis, enlarged and corrected printing, 1969 10-11. Chapters XII-XV, enlarged and corrected printing, 1976 10-111. Chapters XVI-XVII, 1972 1 0-IV. Chapters XVIII-XX, 1974
TREATISE ON
ANALYSIS J. DI'EUDONN~ Membre de l'lnstitut
Volume I /
Enlarged and Corrected Printing
Translated by
1. G. Macdonald
University of Manchester Manchester, England
ACADEMIC PRESS
New York San Francisco London
A Subsidiary of Harcourt Brace lovanovich, Publishers
1976
COPYRIGHT 0 1976, BY ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. N O PART OF THIS PUBLICATION MAY BE REPRODUCED O R TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM OR BY ANY MEANS, ELECTRONIC OR MECHANICAL, INCLUDING PHOTOCOPY, RECORDING, OR ANY INFORMATION STORAGE AND RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, WITHOUT PERMISSION IN WRITING FROM THE PUBLISHER.
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC.
111 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10003
United Kingdom Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. (LONDON)LTD. 24/28 Oval Road. London N W l
LIBRARY O F CONGRESS CATALOG CARD
NUMBER:15 -313532
ISBN 0-12-215502-5 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES O F AMERICA
“Treatise on Analysis,” Volume I1 Enlarged and Corrected Printing First published in the French language under the title “Eldments d’Analyse,” tome 2, 2“ edition, revue et augment& and copyrighted in 1974 by Gauthier-Villars, Gditeur, Paris, France.
SCHEMATIC PLAN OF THE WORK
U I. E l e m e n t s of the theory of sets
X I Elementary spectral
C XXII.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CONTENTS
Notation
............................
Chapter XI1
TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
. . . . . . . . . .
1 . Topological spaces. 2. Topological concepts. 3. Hausdorff spaces. 4. Uniformizable spaces. 5 . Products of uniformizable spaces. 6. Locally finite coverings and partitions of unity. 7. Semicontinuous functions. 8. Topological groups. 9. Metrizable groups. 10. Spaces with operators. Orbit spaces. 1 1 . Homogeneous spaces. 12. Quotient groups. 13. Topological vector spaces. 14. Locally convex spaces. 15. Weak topologies. 16. Bake's theorem and its consequences.
Chapter Xlll
INTEGRATION
.......................
1. Definition of a measure. 2. Real measures. 3. Positive measures. The absolute value of a measure. 4. The vague topology. 5. Upper and lower integrals with respect to a positive measure. 6. Negligible functions and sets. 7. Integrable functions and sets. 8. Lebesgue's convergence theorems. 9. Measurable functions. 10. Integrals of vector-valued functions. 1 1 . The spaces L' and Lz. 12. The space L". 13. Measures with base p. 14. Integration with respect to a positive measure with basep. 15. TheLebesgue-Nikodym theorem and the order relation on MR(X). 16. Applications: I. Integration with respect to a complex measure. 17. Applications: 11. Dual of L'. 18. Canonical decompositions of a measure. 19. Support of a measure. Measureswith compact support. 20. Bounded measures. 21. Product of measures.
Chapter XIV
INTEGRATION IN LOCALLY COMPACT GROUPS
ix
1
98
. . . . . . . . 242
1. Existence and uniqueness of Haar measure. 2. Particular cases and examples. 3. The modulus function on a group. The modulus of an automorphism. 4. Haar measure on a quotient group. 5. Convolution of measures on a locally compact
vii
CONTENTS
viii
group. 6. Examples and partkular cases of convolution of measures. 7. Algebraic properties of convolution. 8. Convolution of a measure and a function. 9. Examples of convolutions of measures and functions. 10. Convolution of two functions. 11. Regularization. Chapter X V
NORMED ALGEBRAS A N D SPECTRAL THEORY
. . . . . . . . 304
1. Normed algebras. 2. Spectrum of an element of a normed algebra. 3. Characters and spectrum of a commutative Banach algebra. The Gelfand transformation. 4. Banach algebras with involution. Star algebras. 5. Representations of algebras with involution. 6. Positive linear forms, positive Hilbert forms, and representations. 7. Traces, bitraces, and Hilbert algebras. 8. Complete Hilbert algebras. 9. The Plancherel-Godement theorem. 10. Representations of algebras of continuous functions. I I. The spectral theory of Hilbert. 12. Unbounded normal operators. 13. Extensions of hermitian operators.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 444 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 447
References Index
NOTATION
In the following definitions, the first number is the number of the chapter and the second number is the number of the section within that chapter.
A-'
AB
support of a function: 12.6 characteristic function of a subset A of a set: 12.7 upper and lower envelopes of a family of real-valued functions: 12.7 upper and lower limit of a sequence of real-valued functions: 12.7 opposite of a group G: 12.8 group of automorphisms of a topological vector space E: 12.8 set of elements x-' where x E A (where A is a subset of a group in which the group law is written multiplicatively): 12.8 set of elements xy with x E A and y E B, where A and B are subsets of a group in which the group law is written multiplicatively: 12.8 normalizer and centralizer of a subset H of a group: 12.8 set of finite products xlxz . . . x, (with n arbitrary) of elements of a subset V of a group: 12.8 ix
x
NOTATION
ZL.
G*A
set of p-adic integers: 12.9, Problem 4 p-adic solenoid: 12.9, Problem 4 homogeneous space of left (right) cosets of a subgroup H in a group G : 12.10 and 12.11 union of the orbits of the points of a subset A of E, with respect to an action of G on E: 12.10 space of orbits with respect to G: 12.10 space of continuous complex-valued functions on X: 12.14 quotient normed space of a normed space E by a vector subspace F: 12.14 x'(x) for a vector x E E and a continuous linear form x' E E' (the dual of E): 12.15 transpose of a continuous linear mapping: 12.15 unitary group of a Hilbert space E: 12.15, Problem 8 space of continuous complex-valued functions with support contained in the compact subset K of X : 13.1 space of continuous complex-valued functions on X with compact support: 13.1 Dirac measure at the point x: 13.1 measure with density g with respect to p: 13.1 and 13.13 image of a measure p under a proper continuous mapping n: 13.1 and 13.1, Problem 8 measure induced on an open set U by a measure p (or restriction of p to U): 13.1 space of complex measures on X : 13.1 integral of f € X ( X ) with respect to p : 13.1 space of continuous real-valued functions with support contained in the compact subset K of X: 13.2
NOTATION
IPI
$59"
PY
xi
space of continuous real-valued functions on X with compact support: 13.2 conjugate of the measure D: 13.2 space of real measures on X: 13.2 real and imaginary parts of a complex measure: 13.2 set of positive measures on X: 13.3 positive and negative parts of a realvalued function J': 13.3 order relation between real measures : 13.3 absolute value of a complex measure: 13.3 set of lower semicontinuous functions on X which are bounded below by a function belonging to XR(X):13.5 upper integral off: 13.5 sum of a sequence (t,) of elements 20 of 8: 13.5 set of upper semicontinuous functions on X which are bounded above by a function belonging to X.(X): 13.5 lower integral off: 13.5 outer and inner measures of A c X: 13.5 equivalence class off (with respect to p): 13.6 order relation between equivalence classes: 13.6 sum and product of equivalence classes : 13.6 integral of a p-integrable function: 13.7 space of (finite) real-valued p-integrable functions: 13.7 measure of a p-integrable set: 13.7 integral of an equivalence class: 13.7 integral off over A: 13.9 upper integral off over A: 13.9 measure induced by p on a closed subspace Y: 13.9
xii
NOTATION
entropy of a finite partition a : 13.9, Problem 27 entropy of a finite partition a relative to a finite partition P : 13.9, Problem 27 least upper bound of a finite sequence of finite partitions: 13.9, Problem 27 entropy of a mapping u relative to a finite partition a : 13.9, Problem 28 entropy of a mapping u: 13.9, Problem 28 integral of a vector-valued function : 13.10 space of complex-valued p-integrable functions : 13.10 s* If I dp: 13.11 (Y If l2 dp)"': 13.1 1 space of (finite) real-valued squareintegrable functions : 13.11 space of p-negligible functions : 13.1 1 space of classes of pth power integrable functions: 13.11 and 13.11, Problem 12 N,U) for anyfin the classf: 13.11 space of complex-valued square-integrable functions: 13.11 space of classes of complex-valued square-integrable functions: 13.11 maximum and minimum in measure off: 13.12 space of real-valued p-measurable functions bounded in measure: 13.12 space of complex-valued p-measurable functions bounded in measure : 13.12 space of classes of real-valued p-measurable functions bounded in measure : 13.12 space of classes of complex-valued pmeasurable functions bounded in measure : 13.12 space of (finite) real-valued p-measurable functions: 13.12, Problem 2 space of classes of (finite) real-valued pmeasurable functions: 13.12, Problem 2
NOTATION
xiii
space of real-valued locally p-integrable functions : 13.13 space of complex-valued locally pintegrable functions : 13.13 space of classes of real (complex) valued locally p-integrable functions : 13.13 integral with respect to a complex measure : 13.16 support of a measure: 13.19 norm of a measure: 13-20 space of bounded real (complex) measures: 13.20 space of real (complex) valued continuous functions which ' tend to 0 at infinity: 13.20 integral with respect to the product measure A Q p : 13.21 product measure: 13.21 upper integral with respect to a product measure: 13.21 lower integral with respect to a product measure: 13.21 the function ( x , y ) H f ( x ) g ( y ) : 13.21 product of n measures: 13.21
m
0 n= 1
integral with respect to the product of the n measures: 13.21 product of an infinite sequence of measures: 13.21, Problem 9 translates of a function: 14.1 translates of a measure: 14.1 transforms of a function or measure under SHS-': 14.1
xiv
NOTATION
T AG(S),
mod,(u), mod(u)
one-dimensional torus: 14.2 modulus function on a group: 14.3 modulus of an automorphism of G: 14.3
field of p-adic numbers: 14.3, Problem 6 average off over a fibre: 14.4, Problem 2 convolution of n measures: 14.5 space of measures with compact support: 14.7
centralization of a measure: 14.7, Problem 6 convolution of a measure and a function: 14.8
convolution of two functions: 14.10 spectrum of an element x of an algebra A: 15.2 spectral radius of x : 15.2 spectrum of an algebra A: 15.3 Gelfand transformation: 15.3 Hardy spaces: 15.3, Problem 15 adjoint (in an algebra with involution): 15.4
Hilbert-Schmidt norm : 15.4 involution in MS(G): 15.4 algebra of Hilbert-Schmidt operators : 15.4
Problem 18 regular representation of a complete Hilbert algebra: 15.8 space of hermitian characters: 15.9 multiplication by the class of u : 15.10 space of bounded universally measurable complex-valued functions on K: 15.10 ( H e x J x )2 0 for all x : 15.11 function of a normal operator: 15.1 1 square root of a positive hermitian operator: 15.11 absolute value of an operator: 15.11, Problem 6 trace of a nuclear operator: 15.11, Problem 7 ( ~ ( X * X ) ) ” ~ : 15.4,
HZO
f (N) abs(T)
NOTATION
dom(T)
T*
xv
nuclear norm: 15.11, Problem 7 space of nuclear operators: 15.11, Problem 7 approximative point-spectrum of an operator: 15.1 1, Problem 9 domain of an unbounded operator: 15.12 adjoint of an unbounded operator with dense domain: 15.12 spectrum of an unbounded operator: 15.12 function of an unbounded normal operator: 15.12
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CHAPTER XI1
TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
As we said in the Introduction, we have sought to limit the material in this chapter to the minimum that the reader will require. We shall not stay to explore the refinements of general topology (filters, uniformities, separation axioms); instead, we shall pass as soon as possible to the category of uniformizable spaces, which are the only ones we shall meet in later chapters. Usually these spaces occur merely as “ ambient spaces ” in which it is convenient to operate, and we shall be mainly concerned-in conformity with the spirit of this book-with their separable metrizable subspaces. $or this reason we have included many criteria of metrizability and separability (12.3.6,12.4.6,12.4.7,12.5.8,12.9.1,12.10.10,12.11.3, 12.14.6.2,12.15.7,12.15.9, 12.15.10). These, together with Bake’s theorem and its consequences, are the only results in the chapter whose proofs are not straightforward. We have also included an account of various purely topological techniques which were not needed in the first volume (partitions of unity (12.6), semi-continuous functions (12,7)), and more than half the chapter is devoted to elementary concepts of topological algebra (topological groups, spaces with operators, topological vector spaces). All of this will be used constantly in the succeeding chapters.
1. TOPOLOGICAL SPACES
A topology on a set E is a set 0 of subsets of E (in other words, a subset of
p(E))satisfying the following two conditions :
(0,) The union of any family (AJA of sets belonging to D belongs to 0; (OJ The set E belongs to D,and the intersection of any two sets belonging to D belongs to D. 1
2
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
A topologicalspace is a set E endowed with a topology 0.The subsets of E which belong to 0 are called the open sets of the topological space E. Taking L = @ in (O,), it follows that the empty subset @ of E is always an open set, and from (0,Jwe see that E itself is an open set. Examples (12.1.1) The set D of open sets in a metric space E satisfies (0,)and (Oil) (3.5.2 and 3.5.3). This topology D is called the topology of the metric space E (or is said to be dejined by the distance given on E). Two topologically eguiualent distances (3.12) define the same topology. A topological space is said to be metrizable if its topology can be defined by a distance (and then this topology is also said to be metrizable). On any set E, the set 0 = E} is a topology, called the chaotic topology. It is not metrizable if E has at least two elements, because otherwise there would exist an open ball containing one of these elements and not the other, and this is impossible because E is the only nonempty open set. On a set E = {a, b } consisting of two elements, the set 0 = (0, { a } , E} is a nonmetrizable topology. If D,,0, are two topologies on the same set E, we say that 0, isfiner than O1 (or that 0, is coarser than D2)if 0, c D2. Two topologies on E are said to be comparable if one is finer than the other. The chaotic topology is coarser than all others. The discrete topology (i.e., the topology defined by the metric (3.2.51, for which D = V(E)) is finer than all others. Two topologies on E are not necessarily comparable; for example, let E = { a , b } be a set with two elements, and consider the two topologies 0, = (0, { a } , E} and 0, = {@, (61, El.
{a,
2. TOPOLOGICAL CONCEPTS
We have already remarked (3.12), in the context of metric spaces, that the notions of closed set, cluster point of a set, interior point of a set, frontier point of a set, neighborhood of apoinr (or of a set), dense set, continuous.function and homeomorphism are defined entirely in terms of the notion of an open sel in a metric space. Their definitions can therefore be transferred, without any change, to the context of arbitrary topological spaces. Moreover, all the properties involving these notions which were proved for metric spaces, and whose statements do not involve the distance (cf. (3.5) to (3.12)) remain valid for arbitrary topological spaces (and we shall therefore make use of them in the general case) with the following exceptions:
2 TOPOLOGICAL CONCEPTS
3
(1) The properties (3.8.11) and (3.8.12) are not true for arbitrary topological spaces, as is shown by the example of the space E = {a, b } with the topology (0, { a } ,E}. The existence of a distance is essential to the proof of these two propositions, although it does not feature in the enunciation. (2) We may define as in (3.9) the notion of a basis of open sets (or of the topology) of a topological space E. The criterion (3.9.3) is valid in general. We can also prove as in (3.9.4) that if there exists a denumerable basis for the topology of a topological space E, then there exists an at most denumerable set which is dense in E; but the converse is not valid for arbitrary topological spaces (Section 12.4, Problem 6).
By definition, a basis following property:
B of the topology of a topological space E has the
The intersection of any two sets of B is a union of sets of 8. Conversely, let B be a set of subsets of a set E. If B has the above property and if E E 8,then the set SJ of (arbitrary) unions of sets of B is a topology for which B is a basis. For it is immediately seen that 0 satisfies (0,)and (O,,). If E is a topological space and if F is any subset of E, then the set of intersections U n F, where U runs through the set of open subsets of E, satisfies the axioms (0,) and (0") and is therefore a topology on F. This topology on F is said to be induced by the topology on E. The set F, endowed with this topology, is called a subspace of E. With these definitions, all the propositions of (3.10) are valid for arbitrary topological spaces, with the exception of (3.10.9), which has to be stated in the following form: if the topology of E has a denumerable basis, then so does the topology induced on any subset of E. We have already remarked that the properties of compactness and local compactness for a metric space depend only on the topology, and not on the distance which defines the topology. We may therefore speak unambiguously of compact and locally compact rnetrizable spaces. We observe also that all the definitions and results of (3.19) relating to connectedness are valid for arbitrary topological spaces. (12.2.1) Let SJ1, SJ2 be two topologies on a set E. Then the followingproperties are equivalent:
(a) D2 is$ner than SJl; (b) if Ei denotes the topological space obtained by giving E the topology Di (i = 1, 2), then the identity mapping of E, onto E, is continuous; (c) for all x E E, every neighborhood of x in the topology Dlis a neighborhood of x in SJ2.
4
XI1 TOPOLOGY A N D TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
The equivalence of (a) and (b) follows from the criterion of continuity (3.11.4(b)), and the equivalence of (b) and (c) from the definition of a continuous function.
Remark (12.2.2) Let (UJaE I be an open covering (3.16) of a topological space E. For a set G c E to be open in E it is necessary and sufficient that each of the sets G n U, should be open in the subspace U, . This follows immediately from the and (O1Jand the relation G = (G n U,). Taking complements, axioms (0,)
u
as1
it follows that a set F c E is closed in E if and only if each of the sets F n U, is closed in the subspace U, . (12.2.3) Let L be a subset of a topological space E. Then the followingproperties are equivalent: (a) L nV (b) (c)
For each x E L there exists a neighborhood V of x in E such that is closed in V ; L is an open subset of the subspace L (the closure of L in E); L is the intersection of an open subset cind a closed subset of E.
It is clear that (b) implies (c), L being the intersection of L with an open subset of E. Equally clearly, (c) implies (a). Let us show that (a) implies (b). For each x E L, we have V n L = V n L, because V n L is closed in V; this shows that in the subspace L the point x is an interior point of L, and therefore L is open in L. When L satisfies the equivalent conditions of (12.2.3), it is said to be a locally closed subset of E. (12.2.4) A procedure for constructing topological spaces which is frequently used is that of “patching together” a family of topological spaces in such a way that, in the topological space E so obtained, the Ed are identified with open sets of E. Since pairs of these sets may very well intersect, this identification requires that, for each pair of indices (A, p), we are given a homeomorphism of an open subset of Ed onto an open subset of E, . To be precise, suppose that for each pair (A, p) E L x L we are given:
(I) an open subset A,, of E,; (2) a homeomorphism AMa: Alp-+ A,, , satisfying the following conditions :
2 TOPOLOGICAL CONCEPTS
5
(I) A,, = E,, and h,, is the identity mapping l E A ; (11) for each triple of indices (A, p, v) and each x E A,, n A,, , we have h,,W E A,, and (12.2.4.1 )
hv,(x) = hv,(h,,(X))
(patching condition). Let F be the sum of the E,, which are therefore pairwise disjoint subsets of F (1.8). In F, consider the relation
R(x, y ) : " there exist A, p such that x y = h,,(x)."
E
A,, , y E A,, , and
This is an equivalence relation. It is reflexive by virtue of condition (I); it is symmetric because h,, and h,, are inverses of each other (by applying (11) with v = A, and then (I)); finally, it is transitive, because if x
E A,,
Y
y
= h,,(x) E A,, n A,,
9
z = h,,Ot),
then we have x = h,,(y) and therefore x E A,, n A,, by (11), and it follows now from (12.2.4.1) that z = h,,(x). We remark also that, by condition (I), the intersection of an E, and an equivalence class of R consists of at most one point. If E = F/R is the set of equivalence classes of R and if
n : F -+F/R = E is the canonical mapping, then each of the restrictions n, = n I E, : E, -,E is injective. Moreover, the sets n,(E,) form a covering of E. Now consider the set 0 of subsets X of E with the following property: for each A E L, the set n;'(X n n,(E,)) is open in E, . It is clear that 0 satisfies axioms (0,) and (01,), and is therefore a topology on E. We shall show that in this topology the sets n,(E,) are open in E and that n, is a homeomorphism of E, onto the subspace n,(E,) of E, for each A E L. In view of the definition of D and of the fact that n, is a bijection of E, onto n,(E,), it is enough to establish the equivalence of the following two properties of a subset X , of E,: (a) X, is an open set in the topological space El; (b) for each p E L, the set n;'(n,(X,) n n,(E,)) is open in E,. Taking p = A, we see that (b) implies (a). Conversely, if (a) is satisfied, then n n,(E,)) = A,, by definition, the condition (b) since we have n;'(n,(E,) signifies that, for each p E L, the set h,,(X, n A,,) is open in E,. Now X, n A,, is open in A,, , and h,, is a homeomorphism of A,, onto an open subset of E, . Hence (a) implies (b). The topological space E so defined is said to be obtained by patching together the E, along the A,, by means of the h,, .
6
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
3. HAUSDORFF SPACES
The notion of a limit is defined as in (3.13) for arbitrary topological spaces, and the criterion (3.13.1)is merely another formulation of the definition. However, the conclusion of (3.13.3)is no longer necessarily true: for example, if E is a set endowed with the chaotic topology (12.1.1),every sequence o f points of E has every point of E as a limit. A topological space E is said to be Hausdorff, and its topology is said to be a Hausdorf topology, if it satisfies the following " Hausdorff axiom":
Given any two distinct points a, b in E, there exists a neighborhood U of a and a neighborhood V of b which do not intersect. Every metrizable space is Hausdorff
(12.3.1) Let E be a topological space, A a subset of E, and let a be a cluster point of A. Then a mapping f of A into a Hausdorff space E ' has at most one limit at the point a with respect to A. For if a', b' were two distinct limits off at the point a, there would exist neighborhoods U', V' of a', b', respectively, having no point in common. But by hypothesis there would be a neighborhood W of a in E such that f ( W n A) c U' and f (W n A) c V', and this is absurd because W nA # 0. Hence we may continue to use the notation
lim x E A ,x
f ( x ) to denote the +
a
unique limit o f f a t the point a. The propositions of (3.13) which do not refer to distances will remain valid for mappings (in particular for sequences) from an arbitrary topological space to a Hausdorf space, with the exception of (3.13.13)and (3.13.14).
(12.3.2) Every subspace of a Hausdorfspace is Hausdorf. (12.3.3) Every topology which isfiner than a Hausdor# topol5gy is Hausdorff. These are immediate consequences of the definitions.
(12.3.4) In a Hausdorff space E, every finite subset is closed. For if ( a i ) l s i s nis a finite sequence of points in E, a point b distinct from all the a, cannot be a cluster point of the set of the a i , because for each i there
3 HAUSDORFF SPACES
exists a neighborhood V i of b which does not contain a i , and V = then a neighborhood of b which does not contain any of the ai .
7
n Vi is n
i= 1
(12.3.5) LetS, g be two continuous mappings of a topological space E into a Hausdorffspace E’. Then the set A ofpoints x E E such that f ( x )= g(x) is closed in E.
The proof is similar to that of (3.15.1) (which is a special case of (12.3.5)). If a # A, then f ( a ) # g(a), and so there are disjoint neighborhoods U’ of f ( a ) and V’ of g(a). Since f -‘(U’) and f -‘(V’) are neighborhoods of a in E, the same is true of their intersection W , and it is clear that f ( x ) # g(x) for all x E W . Hence E - A is open. The principle of extension of identities (3.1 5.2) therefore remains true for continuous mappings of any topological space into a Hausdorfs space. Proposition (3.1 5.3) and its corollary (3.15.4) (the “principle of extension of inequalities ”) are also valid-the proofs are the same-for arbitrary topological spaces. (12.3.6) Let E be a compact metrizable space, F a Hausdorff space, and f a continuous mapping of E into F . Then f ( E ) is closed in F. I f f is injective, it is a homeomorphism of E onto the subspace f ( E ) of F.
Let y be a point of the complement off (E). For each z € f ( E ) ,there exist disjoint open neighborhoods V ( z ) of z and W ( z ) of y . The inverse images f - ’ ( V ( z ) ) form an open covering of E as z runs through f ( E ) (3.11.4). Hence by compactness there exists a finite number of points zi Ef ( E ) such that the V ( z i )form an open covering of f ( E ) in F. But then U = W ( z i )is an open i
neighborhood of y which does not intersect f ( E ) . This shows that f ( E ) is closed in F. It follows that if A is any closed subset of E, thenf(A) is closed in F (and therefore also in f ( E ) ) , because A is compact (3.17.3). Iff is injective, this establishes the continuity of the inverse mapping f (E) .+ E (3.11 -4). (12.3.7) I f a Hausdorff topology is coarser than the topology of a compact metrizable space, then the two topologies coincide. (12.3.8) Let E be a compact metrizable space, F a HausdorfSspace, f a continuous mapping of E into F . If b is any point o f f ( E ) and U is any open set in E containing f -‘(b), then there exists a neighborhood V of b in F such that f-yv) c
u.
8
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
For E - U is closed in E, hencef(E - U) is closed in F by (12.3.6). We have b #f(E - U) by definition, hence the complement V off(E - U) in F is an open neighborhood of b, and clearly U xf-'(V).
PROBLEMS
1. Find all possible topologies on a set of 2 or 3 elements. 2.
Let 5 be a set of subsets of a set E. Show that 5 is the set of closed sets for a topology on E if and only if 5 satisfies the following two conditions: (1) every intersection of a family of sets belonging to 8 belongs to 8 ; (2) the empty set belongs to 5, and the union of two sets belonging to 8 belongs to 8.
3. Let E be a set and for each x E E let B(x) be a set of subsets of E. Then there exists a topology F on E such that, for all x E E, B(x) is the set of neighborhoods of x with respect to Y, if and only if the sets B(x) satisfy the following conditions: (V,) Every subset of E which contains a set belonging to B(x) belongs to B(x). (V,,) The intersection of two sets belonging to %(x) belongs to B(x). (VIII) For all x E E and all V E B(x), we have x E V. (VIv) For all x B E and all V E B(x), there exists a set W E B(x) such that V E B(y) for all y E W. The topology Y is then unique. 4.
Let A be a commutative ring with an identity element 1 # 0. An ideal p of A is prime if A/@is an integral domain (and therefore #O). The set of prime ideals of A is called the spectrum of A and is denoted by Spec(A) (it can be shown to be nonempty). If a is an ideal in A, the set of prime ideals p 2 a is denoted by V(a). Show that V(a n b) = V(a) u V(b) for any two ideals a, b in A. Deduce that the subsets V(a) of Spec(A) are the closed sets in a topology, called the spectral topology, on Spec(A). If x , y are two distinct points of Spec(A), show that either there is a neighborhood of x which does not contain y, or else there is a neighborhood of y which does not contain x. Under what conditions is a set ( x } consisting of a single point closed in Spec(A)? Consider the case where A = Z, and the case where A is a discrete valuation ring. Let A' be another ring and let h: A+A' be a ring homomorphism such that h(1) = 1. Show that the mapping p'wh-'(@') of Spec(A') into Spec(A) is continuous with respect to the spectral topologies.
5. (a) The following conditions on a nonempty topological space E are equivalent: (1) the intersection of any two nonempty open sets in E is nonempty; (2) every nonempty open set is dense in E; (3) every open set in E is connected. The space E is then said to be irreducible. A nonempty subset F of a topological space E is said to be an irreducible set if the subspace F is irreducible. (b) Show that in a Hausdorff space every irreducible set consists of a single point.
3 HAUSDORFF SPACES
9
(c) In a topological space E, a subset F is irreducible if and only if its closure F is irreducible. In particular, for each x E E, the set is irreducible. If an irreducible then x is said to be a generic point of F. set F in E is of the form (d) Let A be an integral domain. Show that the topological space Spec(A) (Problem 4) is irreducible and that {0}is its unique generic point. In Spec(Z), show that the complement of the generic point is an irreducible set which has no generic point. (e) If E is an irreducible space, every nonempty open set in E is irreducible. (f) Let (Urn),A be an open covering of a topological space E, such that U. n UB# 0 for all pairs of indices (a,6). Show that if the sets U, are irreducible, then E is irreducible. (g) Let E, F be two topological spaces and letfbe a continuous mapping of E into F. If A is an irreducible subset of E, show thatf(A) is an irreducible subset of F. (h) Let E, F be two irreducible spaces, each of which has at least one generic point. Suppose also that F has a unique generic point b. Let f be a continuous mapping of E into F. Show thatf(E) is dense in F if and only iff(x) = b for each generic point x of E.
E,
a
6. A topological space E is said to be quasi-compact if it satisfies the Borel-Lebesgue axiom (3.16) and compact if it is quasi-compact and Hausdorff. A subset F of a topo-
logical space E is said to be a quasi-compact set (resp. a compact set) if the subspace F of E is quasi-compact (resp. compact). Every finite set is quasi-compact. (a) In a quasi-compact space, every closed set is quasicompact. (b) Let E be a Hausdorff space and let A, B be two disjoint compact sets in E. Show that there exist two disjoint open sets U, V, such that A c U and B c V. (Consider first the case where A consists of a single point.) Deduce that a compact set in a HauSdorff space is closed. (c) In a topological space E, any finite union of quasi-compact sets is quasi-compact. (d) If E is a quasi-compact space andf: E + F is a continuous mapping, then the set f(E) is quasi-compact. (e) A filter base on a set E is a set 8 c b(E) of nonempty subsets of E such that, whenever X and Y belong to 8, there exists 2 E 8 such that Z c X n Y. Show that if E is a quasi-compact space and all the sets of 8 are closed, then the intersection of the sets of B is nonempty (consider the complements of the sets of 8, and argue by contradiction). (f) If A is a commutative ring with an identity element 1 # 0, show that the topological space Spec(A) (Problem 4) is quasi-compact. (g) Let E be the union of the interval 10, I ] and two elements a, 6. Let 8 be the set of finite intersections of sets of the forms ]a, I], {a}u 10, a [ , @ } u 10, a [ , where 0 < a < 1 . Show that 8 is a basis of a non-Hausdorff topology on E, for which E is quasi-compact and every set consisting of a single point is closed in E. Every point of E has a compact metrizable neighborhood, but there are such neighborhoods of CL (or 8) which are not closed in E. Show that the intersection of a compact metrizable neighborhood of a and a compact metrizable neighborhood of is not quasi-compact. The topology of E has a denumerable basis consisting of separable metrizable subspaces. (h) Let E be the sum (1.8) of N and an infinite set A. For each x E N, write Q(x) = ( x } . For each x E A, let Sx+ denote the union of { X I and the set of integers z n , and let G(x) denote the set of sets Sx, as n runs through N. Show that there exists a non-Hausdorff topology on E such that G(x) is a fundamental system of neighborhoods of x , for each x E E. In this topology, every set consisting of a single point is closed, and E has a dense compact subspace, although E itself is not quasi-compact.
10
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
4. UNIFORMIZABLE SPACES
A pseudo-distance on a set E is a mapping d of E x E into R which is such that d(x, x ) = 0 for all x E E, and satisfies axioms (I), (HI), and (IV) of (3.1), but not necessarily axiom (11). It is clear that a pseudo-distance satisfies the inequalities 4 x 1 , xn) 5 4 x 1 ,
~
2
+) 4 x 2
3
~
14x9 2 ) - d(y, 41
3
+ )
* * *
+
s 4x9 Y )
4 X n - 1 , Xn),
for all x i and x , y , z in E. Examples (12.4.1)
Iffis any mapping of a set E into R,the mapping ( x , r)b IfW - f(Y>I
is a pseudo-distance. Let cp be a mapping of the interval [0, co[ into itself which satisfies the following three conditions : (1) cp(0) = 0 ; (2) cp is increasing; (3) cp(u v ) 5 cp(u) cp(u) for all u >= 0 and v 2 0. Then if d is a pseudo-distance on a set E, the same is true of the composite mapping cp d : ( x , y ) ~ c p ( d ( xy ,) ) . We have only to check the triangle inequality, and by conditions (2) and (3) we have
+
+
+
0
cp(d(x, 4) 5
cp(d(X,
Y ) + d(Y, 4) 5 cp(&
Y>)+ cp(d(x, 2)).
If (d,) is a sequence of pseudo-distances on a set E, such that the series E E x E, then its sum d(x, y ) is a pseudo-
1dn(x,y ) converges for all ( x , y ) n
distance on E (3.15.4). Now consider a family (da)aE , of pseudo-distances on a set E. For each a E E, each finite family ( a j ) l j j m of elements of I and each finite family (rj)l s j s m of real numbers >O, put
B(a; (aj), (r,)) = { x E E I daj(a,x ) < r j for 1 5 j 5 m}, B’(a; ( a j ) ,( r j ) ) = { x E E I da,(a, x) S r j for 1 S j 5 m}. Let r) denote the set of subsets U of E such that, for each x E U, there exists a finite family ( c t j ) , S j s m of elements of I and a finite family ( r i ) l s j S m of strictly positive real numbers such that B(x; (mj),( r j ) ) c U. It is immediately verified that D is a fopology on E. This topology is said to be defined by the
4 UNIFORMIZABLE SPACES
11
family of pseudo-distances (d,), I . A topology which can be defined by a family of pseudo-distances is said to be uniformizable, and a space equipped with such a topology is said to be uniformizable. It is obvious that a metrizable space is uniformizable, but the converse is false (for example, the family consisting only of the pseudo-distance d = 0 defines the chaotic topology). There exist Hausdorff topologies which are not uniformizable (Problems 3 and 4); but throughout this book (and in the majority of situations in analysis) uniformizable spaces are the only ones which we shall have to consider. (12.4.2) Let E be a uniJormizable space whose topology is defined by a family of pseudo-distances (d,), E,. Then the sets
B(a; ( a j ) , (rj))
(resp. B‘(a;( a j ) , (rj)))
are open (resp. closed) in E.
Let x E B(a; (aj), (rj)),and put sj = d,,(a, x ) . Then sj c r j for 1 s j 5 m, hence B(a; ( a j ) , ( r j ) ) contains the set B(x; ( a j ) , ( r j - s j ) ) by virtue of the triangle inequality for each of the d., . This shows that B(a; (aj), ( r j ) ) is an open set. If x 4 B‘(a;(aj), ( T i ) ) , then there exists an index k such that 1 k g m and d,,(a, x ) = s, > r, , and hence the triangle inequality for d,, shows that the set B(x; ak , s, - r,) does not meet B’(a; (aj), (rj)). This shows that B’(a;(aj),(rj)) is closed.
s
(1 2.4.3) In a uniformizable space, the closed neighborhoods of a point form a fundamental system of neighborhoods of the point.
This follows from (12.4.2) and the fact that
B’(a;
( a j ) , (rj/2))c
B(a; ( a j ) , (rj))*
(12.4.4) Let E be a uniformizable space and let (d,), I be a family of pseudodistances defining the topology of E. Then E is Hausdorfifand only $for each pair of distinct points x, y in E , there exists p E I such that d,(x, y ) # 0.
If E is Hausdorff, then by definition there exists a set B ( x ; (aj), ( r j ) ) not containing y , and therefore for at least one indexj we have d,,(x, y ) 2 rj > 0. Conversely, if d,(x, y ) = t > 0, then the open neighborhoods B(x; p, t / 2 ) and B(y; p, t/2) of x and y , respectively, are disjoint, by virtue of the triangle inequality for d, .
I f (d,) is a family of pseudo-distances defining a Hausdorff topology on a set E, then to say that a sequence (x,,)of points of E has a point a as limit with respect to this topology means that lim d,(a, x,,) = 0 for all LY. n-rm
12
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
Two families of pseudo-distances (dJ, (di)A on the same set E are said to be topologically equivalent if they define the same topology on E. (12.4.5) If ( d J U E I is any family of pseudo-distances on a set E , there exists a topologically equivalent family (d;), E , such that 0 5 dl 5 1 for all 01 E I .
+
Let cp(u) = inf(u, 1) for 0 5 u < co.Then cp(0) = 0, and cp is an increasing function on [0, + co[ and satisfies the inequality
+ cp(4.
cp(u + 0) 5
=+
+
(This last assertion is clear if u 1 or u > 1 or if u v 5 1 ; and if u 5 1 and v 5 1 and u v > 1 we have cp(u v ) = 1 < cp(u) + cp(v).) It follows rlow from (12.4.1) that di = cp d, is a pseudo-distance on E, for each 01 E 1. That the topologies defined by the families (d,) and (d;) are the same follows from (12.2.1) and the fact that, when 0 < r < 1, the relations d,(x, y ) < r and di(x, y ) < r are equivalent.
+
0
(1 2.4.6) A Hausdorfluniformizable space E , whose topology can be deJined by a sequence (d,,) of pseudo-distances, is metrizable.
Without loss of generality we may assume that the sequence (d,) is infinite, and by (12.4.5) that 0 5 d,, 5 1 for all n. Then the series (12.4.6.1)
1 d(x, y ) = 2 di(x, y )
1
1
+ 27 d,(x, y ) + + 2. d,,(x, y ) + * *
* * *
converges for all pairs (x, y ) of elements of E, and d is a pseudo-distance on E (12.4.1). Moreover, d is a distance, because d(x, y ) = 0 implies that d,,(x, y ) = 0 for all n, and therefore that x = y because E is Hausdorff (12.4.4). If Bo(x;r ) is the open ball with center x and radius r with respect to the distance d, then it follows immediately from (12.4.6.1) that B,(x; r ) c B(x;n,2"r) for all n. Conversely, if n is so large that 2"-' 2 l/r, then we have
C 2-"-k k= 1 W
d,,+k(x,y ) 5 2-" 5 +r
for all x , y in E , and therefore
B(x; (192, . .
9
4,( t r , . . ,h))= B o b , r). *
By (12.2.1), the proof is complete. (12.4.7) Let E be a topological space and (U,) aJinite or denumerable open covering of E such that the subspaces 0, are separable and metrizable. Then E is separable and metrizable.
4 UNIFORMIZABLE SPACES
13
We begin by showing that the topology of E is Hausdorf. Let x , y be two distinct points of E. If there exists an index n such that x E U, and y 4 On, then V = U, and W = E - 0, are open neighborhoods of x and y respectively which do not intersect. If on the other hand x E U, and y E 0, for some n, then in the metrizable subspace 0, there exists an open neighborhood V, of x and an open neighborhood W, of y which do not intersect. The set V = V, n U, is an open neighborhood of x in E, and there exists an open set W in E such that W n 0, = W, . Hence W is an open neighborhood of y in E, and VnW=@. For each n, let d, be a distance defining the topology of O n ,and let (Vrn,JmLbe a basis for the topology of U, , where V,, is an open ball with center a,, and radius r,, (3.9.4). Let A,,,, be the function which is equal to rmn- d,(a,,, x ) in V,, and is 0 in the complement of V,,,, in E. Then.f,, is continuous on E, since it vanishes at the frontier points of V,, . Now let &n(X,
Y ) = Ifmn(x) -fmn(Y)l
for all x, y in E. By virtue of (12.4.6), the proof will be complete if we show that the pseudo-distances d,,, define the topology of E. For each x , E E , every set defined by an inequality of the form d,,(xo, x ) < CI is open in E (3.11.4). Conversely, there exists an integer n such that x , E U, , and for each neighborhood W of x , in E there exists an integer m such that V,, is an open neighborhood of xo contained in W (3.9.3). Hence fmn(xo)= B > 0, and the set of all x E E such that d,,(xo, x ) < +B is therefore contained in W. By virtue of (12.2.1), this completes the proof. We remark that the conclusion of (12.4.7) is not valid without the hypothesis of denumerability on the open covering (U,) (Section 12.16, Problem 22); again, the hypotheses cannot be weakened by assuming merely that the open sets U, are separable and metrizable (section 12.3, Problem 6(f)).
PROBLEMS
1. Let E be a topological space such that, for each x E E, the neighborhoods of x which are both open and closed in E form a fundamental system of neighborhoods of x. Show that E is uniformizable.(Observe that the characteristicfunction of a set which is both open and closed in E is continuous on E.)
2. Let E be a denumerable Hausdorff uniformizable space. Show that, for each x E E, the open-and-closed neighborhoods of x form. a fundamental system of neighborhoods of x.
14
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
3. Let 6 be a positive irrational number. For each point (x, y ) E Q x Q+ (where Q+ = Q n R,) and each integer n > 0, let B.(x, y ) denote the set consisting of (x, y ) and the points (z, 0) E Q x Q + such that Iz - (x 6y)l < I/n or Iz - (x - 6y)l < I/n. As (x, y ) runs through Q x Q ,and n runs through the set of strictly positive integers, show that the sets B.(x, y ) form a (denumerable) basis of a topology .T on Q x Q + Show that .T is Hausdorff but that, if a and b are any two points of Q x Q + , every closed neighborhood of a meets every closed neighborhood of 6. Deduce that Q x Q ,, endowed with the topology .T, is connected and that every continuous mapping of Q x Q, into R is constant. This shows that the topology .T is not uniformizable.
+
.
4.
Let Q be the set of rational numbers endowed with the topology I .induced by that of R. Let !Dl be the set of subsets A of Q such that the closure A of A (in the topology .To)has only finitely many nonisolated points (3.10.10). Let B be the set consisting of all open intervals in Q, all complements of sets belonging to Fm and all intersections of these complements with open intervals in Q. Show that B is a basis for a topology F on Q, and that .T is finer than .To and therefore Hausdorff. Show that, with respect to this topology, a convergent sequence in Q has only finitely many distinct terms, although the topology I is not discrete. In the topology I , no point of Q has a denumerable fundamental system of neighborhoods, although Q is denumerable and every point of Q is the intersection of a denumerable family of neighborhoods of the point. By using (1 2.4.3), show that I is not uniformizable. although it is finer than a metrizable topology.
5. Let E be a topological space satisfying the following condition: for each x ‘EE and each neighborhood V of x in E, there exists a continuous mapping f: E -+ [O,11 such that f(x) = I and f(y) = 0 for all y E E - V. Show that E is uniformizable. Deduce that if E is a topological space such that every point of E has a closed neighborhood in E which is a uniformizable subspace, then E is uniformizable. Can the word “closed” be omitted from this proposition? (Cf. Section 12.3, Problem 6(f).) 6.
For each x E R and each integer n > 0, let U.(x) denote the union of the intervals [x, x l/n[ and ] - x - I/n, -XI.Show that there exists a topology 9on R such that the U.(x) form a fundamental system of neighborhoods of x, and that .T is not comparable with the usual topology of R. Show that I is uniformizable (use Problem 5). In this topology, every point has a denumerable fundamental system of neighborhoods, and there exists a denumerable dense subset. But there exists no denumerable basis of open sets for I and , consequently I is not metrizable. Show also that the topology induced by .T on the interval E = [ - I , 11 of R is not metrizable, although E is quasicompact and Hausdorff in this topology.
+
5. PRODUCTS O F U N I F O R M I Z A B L E SPACES
Let El, E, be two topological spaces. In the product set E = El x E, let 0 be the set of (arbitrary) unions of sets of the form Al x A , , where A, is open in El and A, is open in E, . The set 0 is a topology on E, because it clearly satisfies axiom (Of), and it satisfies (0,Jby reason of the relation
5
PRODUCTS OF UNIFORMIZABLE SPACES
15
where Ai and B, are open sets in E i ( i = 1,2). This topology 0 is called the product of the topologies on El and E,, and the set E endowed with this topology is called the product of the topological spaces El, E, . If x = ( x , , x,) is any point of E, the sets V, x V, (where V i runs through a fundamental system of neighborhoods of xi, f0r.i = 1, 2) form a fundamental system of neighborhoods of x in E (3.9.3). From this it follows that the continuity criterion (3.20.4)is valid for the product of two arbitrary topological spaces. The relation A, x A, = A, x A, (where A, c El and A, c E,) also remains true; for if (a,, a,) E E and if Vi is a neighborhood of a, in Ei (i = 1,2), the set (V, x V,) n (A, x A,) = (V, n A,) x (V, n A,) is empty if and only if one of the sets V in Ai is empty. For each a, E El, the set ((a,} x E2) n (A, x A2) is either empty or equal to {a,} x A , , and therefore the mapping x 2 ++(a,, x 2 ) is a homeomorphism of E, onto the subspace (a,} x E, of E. Likewise, if a2 E E,, the mapping x,H(x,, a2) is a homeomorphism of El onto the subspace El x { a 2 }of E. From this it follows immediately that the propositions (3.20.12)and (3.20.13), and the continuity criteria (3.20.14)and (3.20.15),are valid in general. If El and E, are Hausdorf then so is El x E, . For if x = (x,, x 2 ) and y = (yl, y 2 )are distinct, then either x, # y , or x, # y , . If the latter, there is a neighborhood U of x2 and a neighborhood V of y , in E, which do not intersect, and then El x U and El x V are disjoint neighborhoods of x and y , respectively, in E. IfE, = El, the canonicalsymmetry (x,, x , ) ~ (x, , xl) is a homeomorphism of El x El onto itself, and is equal to its inverse. The product of any finite number of topological spaces is defined in the same way. It follows immediately from the definition that the canonical “associativity” mappings such as (El x E,) x E, 4 El x (E, x E,) are homeomorphisms. We shall be concerned especially with the case in which El and E, are uniformizable. In this case the product space E is also uniformizable. To be precise, let (d$l))LL, ( d r ) ) r be families of pseudo-distances which define the topologies of’ El, E, respectively, and let
Then the el1) and )e: are pseudo-distances on E, and the definition of neighborhoods given above shows that the family of pseudo-distances ey) and ff), where I E L and p E M, defines the product topology on E. This leads to a generalization of the notion of a product to arbitrary (not necessarily finite) families of topological spaces. We shall restrict ourselves to uniformizable spaces.
16
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
Let (E,),
I
be any family of uniformizable spaces, and let E =
For each a E I, let (d,, topology of E, . If we put
fl E, .
,El
be a family of pseudo-distances defining the
eu, Ax, Y ) = d,, n(P'uX7 PlhY)
(12.5.1)
for each pair (x, y ) of elements of E =
nE,, then it is immediately checked
. E l
that the e,, are pseudo-distances on E. The product of the topologies of the E, is then the topology on E defined by the e,, as a runs through I and, for each a E I, Iz runs through L, . The set E endowed with this topology is called the product of the spaces E, . When I = { 1,2} this definition agrees with that given above for two spaces El, E, . of For every finite family ( a i , Ai), and every finite family (ri)l strictly positive real numbers, the set B(x; ( ( a i ,Ai)), (ri)) can be written in B, where, if a = ai, we have B, = B(pr,, x ; (Aj), (rj)),where j the form
n
UEI
runs through the indices for which aj = t l i , and B, = E, if a is not equal to any ai. From this and (3.6.4) we deduce immediately: (12.5.2) For each a E I, theprojection pr, is a continuous mappingof E onto E, , and the image under pr, of any open set in E is an open set in E, .
(,VH )
(12.5.3) For each finite subset H of I, and each family (UJUEH,where U, is U, x ( , B H E . ) is open in E. open in E, for each a E H, the set
For it is the intersection of the sets pr;'(U,), are open (12.5.2) and finite in number.
where a E H, and these sets
The sets described in (12.5.3) are called elementary sets in E. The description given above of the neighborhoods shows that (having regard to (3.9.3)) these sets form a basis for the topology of E. Incidentally, this shows also that the topology of E depends only on the topologies of the E, and not on the families of pseudo-distances (d,, Moreover, if b, is a basis for the topology of E,, the elementary sets such that U, E b, for all a form a basis for the U, with topology of E. It should be noted that, if I is infinite, a product
n
u61
U, open in E,, nonempty and # E, for a f fc1 E I, is not open in E. (12.5.4) Let A, be a subset of E,, for each a, and let A
A=
=
n A,.
Then
n A,. In particular, $each A, is closed in E, , then A is closed in E.
,El
QCI
5
PRODUCTS OF UNIFORMIZABLE SPACES
17
We have pr,(A) c pr,(A) = A, for all u E I ((12.5.2) and (3.11.4)), hence A,. Conversely, if a = (a,) E A,, and if we consider an ele-
Ac
n
n
as1
mentary set U =
n U, n E, containing a, its intersection with A is n n A,. as1
x
aeH
asl-H
aeH
(Aan U a ) x
asl-H
Since none of the A, is empty, no A, is empty and therefore U n A # which shows that a E A.
a,
(12.5.5) Let z~ f ( z ) = (f,(z)), I be a mapping of a topological space F into E. For f to be continuous at a point z, E F , it is necessary and sufficient that each f, should be continuous at zo .
For any elementary set U =
n f,-1(uU).
n U, n E,,
asH
x
asl-H
we have f-'(U) =
aeH
(12.5.6) Let (x("))be a sequence of points of E. For a = (a,) to be a limit of the sequence (x'")), it is necessary and suficient that a, should be a limit of the sequence (prax(n)),,tl, - for each CI E I .
This is an immediate consequence of (12.5.5) and the definition of a limit. In particular, if all the E, are equal to the same space F, then to say that a mapping u E F' of I into F is a limit of a sequence of mappings ( u , , ) , , of ~ ~I into F, with respect to the product topology, means that for each c1 E I the sequence (u,,(M))has u(a) as a limit in F. In this situation we say that the mapping u is a simple limit of the sequence (u,,), or that the latter converges simply to u. (12.5.7) v e a c h space E, is Hausdorfl, then so is the product space
E.
For if x # y , there exists an index u E I such that prax # p r a y ; hence, using (12.4.4), there exists A E La such that d,, I(pr,x, p r a y ) # 0, and therefore e,,,(x, y ) # 0. The result now follows from (12.4.4). (12.5.8) The product E of a denumerable family of metrizable (resp. separable metrizable) spaces is metrizable (resp. separable and metrizable).
First of all, E is Hausdorff by (12.5.7). To show that E is metrizable, apply (12.4.6) and the definition of pseudo-distances on a product. Now suppose that E =
fr En,where the Enare separable and metrizable. Then each
n= 1
18
XI1 TOPOLOGY A N D TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
Enhas a denumerable basis (Um,JmLO of open sets. For each n
n uf(j), n n
the set of elementary sets in E of the form
x
a
k=n+ 1
j= 1
1, let 23, be Ek, where f is
any mapping of { 1, 2, . . . , n} into N. Since N" is denumerable (1.9.3), the set 23, is at most denumerable (1.9.2). We have seen that the union 23 of the sets 23, is a basis for the topology of E (12.5.3); since $'3 is denumerable (1.9.4), it follows that E is separable (3.9.4). The product of a denumerablefamily of compact metrizable spaces is compact and metrizable. (1 2.5.9)
Let (En) be a sequence of compact metric spaces. Since we know already (12.5.8) that E =
m
fl E,
is metrizable, it is enough to show that every
,= 1
sequence (x,) of points of E has a cluster value (3.16.1). We define by induction on m 2 0 a family of sequences ( x ? ) ) , , ~ of ~ points of E, as follows: x:)' = x,; for m 2 1, the sequence ( x : ~ ) ) , ,is-a ~ ~ subsequence of the sequence (xp- I)),, (in other words, there exists a strictly increasing mapping q m : N + N such that xkm)= x$",;nf)) such that the sequence ( p r m x ~ ) ) n z l converges in Em to a point a,,,. This construction is possible because Em is compact. Now consider the sequence (y,) in E, where y, = xf) (Cantor's q l , we have y , = x,Jn); "diagonal trick"). If we put $,, = (P, q n - l 0 since $,(n) > $n-l(n - 1) by definition, it follows that (y,) is a subsequence of (x,). Furthermore, for each m, the sequence (y,Jn2, is a subsequence of the sequence ( x : ~ ) ) , , ~and ~ , therefore the sequence (prmy,JnLm converges to a,". Hence so does the sequence (prmy,),;L,, since it differs from the former by only a finite number of terms. Hence the sequence (y,) converges to the point a = (a,,,) (12.5.6). 0
0
PROBLEMS
1. Show that the product of two quasi-compact topological spaces (Section 12.3, Problem 6) is quasi-compact. 2. Show that a topological space E is Hausdorff if and only if the diagonal (1.4.2) of E X E is closed in E x E.
3. Let (Ea)as, be a family of arbitrary (not necessarily uniformizable) topological spaces, and let E = E.. Show that the elementary sets, defined as in (12.5.3), form a basis
n
OlEl
of a topology on E. This topology is called the producr of the topologies of the E, Generalize (12.5.2) to (12.5.7) to this situation.
.
5 PRODUCTS OF UNIFORMIZABLE SPACES 4.
Let E =
n E.
19
be a product of Hausdorff topological spaces, such that each E.
= E l
contains at least two distinct points a , , 6 , . For each (1: E I, let c. be the point of E such that pr.c. = b. and prac. = aa for all /3 # a. Show that every point of the set { c ~ } is~ an ~ , isolated point. Deduce that the topology of E has a denumerable basis if and only I is denumerable and each of the E. has a denumerable basis. Show that if I is not denumerable, the point a = (a,) has no denumerable fundamental system of neighborhoods. If E. = {arn, ba}for each a, and if F c E is the set of all x t E such that pr,x = b. for all but denumerably many indices a, show that F is dense in E and that a = (an)is not a limit of any sequence of elements of F.* 5. Let K be the discrete space {0, l}, let A be an infinite set, and let E be the product space KA. Let V be a nonempty elementary set in E. If h is the (finite) number of indices o! such that pr,V # K, let p(V) = 2 - h (cf. (13.21)). (a) Show that, if U,, . . . , U. are nonempty mutually disjoint elementary sets, then
"
&=1
p(Uk)5 1. (Write Urin the form Wx x KB,where B is the same for all k and is the
complement of a finite subset of A.) (b) Deduce from (a) that if (U,A6 is a family of nonempty pairwise disjoint open sets in E, then L is at most denumerable, although there exist sets C of arbitrary cardinal in E (for a suitable choice of A) all of whose points are isolated. Show also that if the cardinal of A is strictly greater than that of B(N), then E contains no denumerable dense subset.
6. With the notation of Problem 5, let 9 be the set of all subsets of KA of the form M a , where M. = K except for ar most denumerably many indices or. Show that 8
n
.EA
is a basis for a Hausdorff topology on KA which is finer than the product topology, and which is not discrete provided that A is infinite and non-denumerable.In this topology, every denumerable intersection of open sets is open; no point has a denumerable fundamental system of neighborhoods; and every quasi-compact subset is finite. The projections pr. are continuous with respect to this topology. Deduce that KA is uniformizable with respect to this topology (Section 12.4, Problem 5).
7. Let 1 be the interval [0, 11 in R,with the induced topology. Show that every separable metrizable space E is homeomorphic to a subspace of the product IN. (Reduce to the case where the distance d on E is 5 1, and consider a sequence (0.) which is dense in E, and the functions x H d ( a . , x).) 8. With the notation of Problem 7, show that in the uniformizable product space I', the subspace of continuous mappings of I into I is dense. Deduce that I' has a denumerable dense subset, although there is no denumerable basis of open sets (Problem 4). 9.
Show that if I is a nonempty open interval in R,there exists no nonconstant mapping f o f I into the product space NN with the following property: for each x E I and each
*This example shows that in general topological spaces (and even in Hausdorff uniformizable spaces) the convergent sequences do not determine the topology, as they do in metrizable spaces (cf. (3.1 3.3) and (3.1 3.4)). To get corresponding results in general, it is necessary to replace the notion of sequence by the more general notion of a filter (cf. [5]).
20
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
integer n > 0, there exists a neighborhood V of x in I such that, for all y E V, the first n terms of the sequence f(y) are the same as the first n terms of the sequence f ( x ) . (Show that this condition implies that f i s continuous, and use (3.19.7).) 10. (a) Let E be a topological space and A a nonempty closed subset of E. Let E’ be the sum of E - A and a set { w } consisting of a single element, and let 0’be the set of subsets of E’ which are either of the form U where U is an open set in E - A, or of the form (V - A) u { w } , where V is an open set in E which contains A. Show that 0’is a topology on E’, and denote by E/A the set E’ endowed with this topology. Let p(x) = x if x E E - A, and ~ ( x = ) w if x E A. Show that y is a continuous mapping of E onto E/A. Every continuous mapping f of E into a topological space F, which is constant on A, can be written uniquely in the form f = g 0 p, where g: E/A -+ F is continuous. (b) Suppose that E is metrizable and compact; let d be a distance defining the topology of E, and let (Wn)nblbe a basis for the topology of E - A. Let f o ( x )= d(x, A), f.(x) = d(x, E - W,) for n 2 1, and f ( x ) = ( f , ( ~ ) ) e. R~ N~ . Show that f(E) is a compact subspact: of RN, homeomorphic to E/A. This shows that E/A is compact and metrizable. (c) Show that if we take E = R and A = Z, then the space E/A defined in (a) is not metrizable (cf. Section 3.6, Problem).
6. LOCALLY FINITE COVERINGS A N D PARTITIONS O F U N I T Y
In a topological space E, a family (A,),., of subsets of E is said to be locallyfinite if for each point x E E there exists a neighborhood U of x in E such that U n A, = $3 for all but a finite number of indices c1 E I . If E is metrizable and K is a compact subset of E, it follows that there is a covering of K by afinite number of neighborhoods of points of K in E, each of which meets only afinite number of the sets A,. In particular, K meets only afinite number of the A,. If ( A J L E L ,(B,),EM are two coverings of a topological space E, the covering (B,) is said to be finer than (A,) if, for each p E M, there exists A E L such that B, c A,. (12.6.1) Let E be a separable, locally compact, metrizable space and let 23 be.a basis of open sets in E. If (A,),. is any open covering of E, there exists a denumerable locallyfinite open covering (B,) of E which isfiner than (A,), and such that the sets B, are relatively compact and belonq to 23. Consequently each B, meets only finitely many of the sets B, .
From (3.18.3) we know that there exists an increasing sequence (U,JnLO of relatively compact open sets such that 0, c U,,, for all n, and E = U,.
u n
6
LOCALLY FINITE COVERINGS AND PARTITIONS OF UNITY
21
Put K, = 0, - Un-l, which is a compact set for all n 2 0 (we put U,, = for all n < 0). For each n 2 0, the open set U,+, IS a neighborhood of K, . Hence, for each x E K,, there exists an open neighborhood W v ) E 23 of x, contained in Un+l- On-2and contained in one of the sets A,. There exists a finite number of points x i E K,, (I 5 i 5 p,) such that the sets WE) cover K, . Arrange the sets WLy) (m 2 0, 1 5 i 5 p m for each m) in a sequence in any way, and let (B,) denote this sequence. It is clear that (B,) is an open covering of E which is finer than (A,), L , and that the sets B, are relatively compact. Thus all that has to be checked is that the covering (B,) is locally finite. Let z be any point of E, and let n be the least integer ~ U hX that z E U, . Since z 4 U,-l, there exists a neighborhood T of z contained in U, and not meeting Consequently T can intersect only the sets W:) for which n - 2 m 5 n + 1, and the number of these sets is finite. (12.6.2) Let (A,,) be a denumerable locally$nite open covering of a metrizable space E. Then there exists an open covering (B,) of E such that B, c A, for all n.
B,
We shall define the family (B,) by induction on n, in such a way that
c A,, for each n, and such that for each n the family consisting of the B, with k 5 n and the A j with j > n is an open covering of E. Suppose that the
sets B, have been defined for n < m. Then the B, with n < m and the A j with
j 2 m cover E. Let C be the open set which is the union of the B, with n < m
and the Aj withj > m + I , so that we have E - A, c C. We shall show that there exists an open set V such that E - A,, c V c 0 c C. If E = A,, we may take V = 0. If C = E, we may take V = E. If neither E - A,, nor E - C is empty, there exists a continuous mapping f of E into the interval 10, 11of R,which is equal to 0 on E - A,, and to 1 on E - C (4.5.2).We then take V to be the open set of points y such that f ( y ) < f , and then 0 is contained in the closed set of points y such that f(y) 5 +, and hence ? c C. Put B, = E - 0. Then we have B,, c E - V c A,,, and B,, u C = E, so that the sets B,with n 5 m satisfy the required conditions, and the induction can proceed. For each x E E, there exists an integer n such that x 4 A,, for all m > n, and therefore x E B, for some k 5 n. Hence the sets B, cover E.
It is clear that the same argument will apply if the covering (A,) isfinite.
I f E is a topological space andf'is a mapping of E into a real vector space F or into R, the support off (denoted by Supp(f)) is defined to be the smallest closed set S in E such thatfvanishes on E - S. In other words, Supp(f) is the closure in E of the set of points x E E such that f(x) # 0 ; or again it is the set of points x E E with the property that every neighborhood of x in E contains a point y such that f ( y ) # 0.
XI1 TOPOLOGY A N D TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
22
Let (f,),. I be a family of mappings of E into F (resp. R) whose supports form a locally finite family. Then the sum C f a ( x ) is defined for all x E E, aa I
because it contains at most finitely many non-zero terms. We denote by f , the function x + + CfR(x).If F is B or a normed space (or more generally
c
as1
aE1
a topological vector space (12.13)), and if each f , is continuous on E, then so is f = f a :for given x E E there exists a neighborhood V of x which meets only
c
as1
finitely many of the Supp(f,), and hence there is a finite subset H of I such that f ( y ) = f a ( y ) for all y E V.
c
asH
A continuous partition of unity on E is by definition a family ( f a ) , ,I of continuous mappings of E into [0, I], such that the supports of the f a form a locally finite family, and such that f a ( x )= 1 for all x E E. If (Aa)aE I is an
1
aal
open covering of E indexed by the same set I, then the partition of unity (fa), I is said to be subordinate to the covering (AJa I if we have Supp(f,) c A, for all u E I. (12.6.3) Let (A,) be an at most denumerable 1ocally.finite open covering of a metrizable space E. Then there exists a continuous partition of unity (f,)on E subordinate to (A,,).
Let (B,) be an open covering of E, such that B, c A, for all ii (12.6.2). It is clear that the covering (B,) is locally finite. By (4.5.2), for each iz there exists a continuous mapping h,: E -+ [0, I] such that h, is equal to 1 on B, and equal to 0 on E - A,. If we put g , = (h, - +)+, then Supp(g,) is contained in the set of points x such that h,(x) 2 t,and hence is contained in A,. Let g = g, .
1 n
Since the sets B, cover E, we have g ( x ) > 0 for all x E E, and therefore the functionsf, = g,/g are defined and continuous on E, and form a partition of unity with the required properties. (12.6.4) Let E be a metrizable space, K a compact subset of E and afinite covering of K by open sets of E. Then there exist m continuous mappings f,: E --* [O, I] such that supp(fk) c A, for 1 5 k 5 m, and such that m
1
fk(x)
k= 1
5 1 for all x E E and
m
fk(x) = 1 for all x E K.
k= 1
Take a continuous partition of unity (fk)Odksn, subordinate to the open covering of E consisting of A,, = E - K and the A, (1 5 k 5 m).
7 SEMICONTINUOUS FUNCTIONS
23
Remark (12.6.5) Let F be a subset of the set of continuous mappings of E into R,with the following three properties :
(1) for each pair of disjoint nonempty subsets M, N of E, with M compact and N closed, there exists a function f 2 0 in F which is equal to 0 on N and 21 on M ; ( 2 ) if (f U ) E, , is a family of functions in 9 whose supports form a locally finite family, then f, belongs to 9; U E l
(3) i f f € 9 is such thatf(x) > 0 for all x E E, then g/fe 9for all g E 9.
Then the conclusions of (12.6.3) and (12.6.4) are still valid, when the A, are relatively compact, if we impose the extra condition that the functionsh should belong to 9. The proofs are unaltered.
7. SEMICONTI NUOUS FUNCTIONS
In this section, and above all in Chapter XIII, we shall need to consider mappings of a set A into the extended real line 8. Such mappings we shall call (by abuse of language) real-valuedfunctions on A. Such a function f is said to be finite if its value at each point a E A is finite, i.e., iff(A) c R.The functionf is said to be majorized or bounded above (resp. minorized or bounded below) if there exists a finite majorant (resp. a finite minorant) of f ( A ) . Iff is both majorized and minorized, it is said to be bounded (which clearly implies that f i s finite). We recall ((4.1.8), (4.1.9), and (3.15.5)) that in R x R the function (x, y ) x +~y (resp. (x,y ) H x y ) is defined and continuous except at the points (+ co, - co) and (- co, 00) (resp. (+ co, 0), (- co,O), (0, co), (0, - co)). The function X H I / X on R is defined and continuous except a t the point x = 0. In the interval [0, + co] of R, the function X H l/x (defined on 10, +a])can be extended by continuity by giving it the value f c o at the point 0. Let E be a topological space and letfbe a mapping of E into the extended real line R. The function f is said to be lower (resp. upper) semicontinuous at a point x o E E if, for each a E R such that a c f ( x o ) (resp. a > f ( x , ) ) , there exists a neighborhood V of xo in E such that, for all x E V, we have a < f ( x ) (resp. c( > f ( x ) ) . The functionfis said to be lower (resp. upper) semicontinuous on E if it is so at every point xo E E.
+
+
24
XI1 TOPOLOGY A N D TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
Clearly, iff is lower semicontinuous at xo , then -f is upper semicontinuous at this point. Hence we need consider only lower semicontinuous functions. If (P is a mapping of a topological space F into E which is continuous at a point yo E F, and iff is lower semicontinuous at the point xo = (~(y,,),then f (P is lower semicontinuous at y o . In particular, if F is a subspace of E, and iff is lower semicontinuous at a point yo E F, then so is the function f I F. 0
Examples
(12.7.1) A mapping f : E .+ a is said to have a relative minimum at a point xo E E if there exists a neighborhood V of xo such that f ( x ) 2 f ( x o ) for all x E V. If so, thenfis lower semicontinuous at the point xo . This is clearly the case whenever f ( x o ) = - 03. For each x E R, put f ( x ) = 0 if x is irrational, and f ( x ) = l/q if x is rational and equal to p / q (where p , q are coprime integers and q > 0). For each integer n 2 0, the subspace of rational numbers p / q with q S n is closed in R and discrete. Hence for each irrational x there exists a neighborhood V of x such that f ( y ) l / n for all y E V, and therefore f is continuous at the point x . On the other hand, f has a relative maximum at each rational point, and is therefore upper semicontinuous on R. (12.7.2) A mapping f : E + is lower semicontinuous on E if and only $ for each a E R, the set f - ' ( ] a , 031) of points x at which f ( x ) > a is open in E (or, equivalently, the set f -I([ - 03, a ] ) of points x such that f ( x ) 5 a is closed in E).
+
For to say that f is lower semicontinuous on E signifies that, for each a E W, the set f - ' ( ] a , +a])is a neighborhood of each of its points (3.6.4).
If A is any subset of a set E, the characteristic function of A (usually denoted by qA)is the mapping of E into R such that ( P ~ ( x= ) 1 for all x E A and pA(x) = 0 for all x E E - A. So we have q E = 1, ( P = ~ 0, and the formulas (PE-A=
I1 2.7.3)
(PA
-(PA,
+ (PB = (PA v B + (PA
nB
(PA(PB=(PAnB,
,
(PA n CB
= (PA
- (PA (PB,
where A, B are any two subsets of E, and (A,) is any family of subsets of E.
7 SEMICONTINUOUS FUNCTIONS
25
(12.7.4) A subset A of a topological space E is open (resp. closed) in E ifand only if qAis lower (resp. upper) semicontinuous on E.
This follows immediately from (12.7.2). (12.7.5) Let f, g be two mappings of a topological space E into R, each of which is lower semicontinuous at a point xo E E . Then the functions sup(f, g ) and inf(f, g ) are lower semicontinuous at xo . The same is true ,forf + g if the sum f ( x ) + g(x) is defined for all x E E (4.1.8), and for f g i f f and g are both 20 and the product f (x)g(x)is defined for all x E E (4.1.9).
We shall give the proof for f + g ; the other cases are analogous. The result is obvious if f ( x o ) or g(xo) is equal to -03. If not, then we have f ( x o ) + g ( x o ) >- co. Every number u E R such that u
+
+
+
I f f is lower semicontinuous at a point xo , and iff 2 0 on E, then the function l/f (where l / f ( x ) is taken to be 03 if f ( x ) = 0) is upper semicontinuous at xo . The proof is analogous.
+
Given a set E and any family ( f a ) , I of mappings of E into R, the upper (resp. lower) envelope of the family is defined to be the mapping X H sup f a ( x ) (resp. x w i n f f , ( x ) ) of E into aol
as 1
have sup (-A) = - inf f, U E l
ael
B. It is denoted by s u p f , (resp. inff,). We a€1
as1
(12.7.6) Let E be a topologicalspace and let (f,), I be a family of mappings of E into R. If e a c h f , is lower semicontinuous at a point xo E E, then the upper envelope f = supf, is lower semicontinuous at xo , a €I
Given any I
p E I such that I
there exists a neighborhood V of xo such that I
EV
, and
(12.7.7) The upper (resp. lower) envelope of a family of continuous mappings of E into R is lower (resp. upper) semicontinuous.
26
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
The Iower envelope of an infinite family of lower semicontinuous functions is not necessarily lower semicontinuous. As an example, for each rational number r let,fr denote the characteristic function of R - { r } , which is lower semicontinuous (12.7.4). The lower envelope f of the denumerable family (fr)rEQ takes the value 0 at each rational number and the value 1 at each irrational number (in other words, it is the " Dirichlet function" 1 - ' p Q , cf. (3.11.6)), and is not lower semicontinuous at irrational points. The following proposition is a partial converse of (12.7.7) (12.7.8) Let E be a separable, metrizable, locally compact space, and let f be a lower semicontinuous mapping of E into R. Suppose that there exists aJinite real valued function g , continuous on E and with compact support, such that f 2 g (which implies that f (x) 2 0 in the complement of some compact set). Then there exists an increasing sequence (f,)o f j n i f e real valued functions, continuous on E and with compact supports, such that f = supf, . n
Replacing f if necessary by .f - g (which is everywhere defined), we may assume that f 2 0. It is then enough to show that there exists a denumerable family of finite real-valued continuous functions with compact supports, with f as upper envelope. For it we arrange this family in a sequence (g,) and take ,P, = sup(g,, . . . ,g,), it is clear that the f , satisfy the required conditions. Let (U,) be an increasing sequence of relatively compact open sets in E, such that E = U, (3.18.3). If g, is the function which agrees with f on U,
u n
and is zero on E - U, , then clearly f
= supg,
, and g, is lower semicontin-
fl
uous. Hence if g, is the upper envelope of a denumerable set D, of finite realvalued continuous functions with compact supports, then f will be the upper envelope of D, (2.3.6). Hence we may restrict ourselves to the case where
u n
f has compact support. Suppose first of all that f = q A ,where A set. Putf,(x) = ri inf(d(x, E - A), l / n ) . This is valued function on E, with compact support f , ( x ) = f ( x ) whenever x E E - A or d(x, E - A) that f = sup,f, (3.8.9).
is a relatively compact open a finite, continuous, positive(3.11.8). Moreover, we have 2 l/n. It follows immediately
n
In the case where f 2 0 and has compact support, we can restrict ourselves to the case where 0 5i;fr 1, provided that the functions f,are chosen so that 0 5 f , ( x ) < 1 for all x E E. For in the general case the function h =fl(l +f) (taken to have the value 1 at points where f ( x ) = co) is lower semicontinuous (cf. (3.3.2)). If we have h = sup h,, with h, continuous and h,(x) < 1 for
+
n
7 SEMICONTINUOUS FUNCTIONS
27
all x E E, then f = supf, with f , = hJ(1 - h,), and f , is finite and continuous n
on E. So we are now in the situation where 0 6 f 5 1 and f has compact support. For each integer n 5 1, consider the. decreasing finite sequence of open sets A,, =f -‘(]k/n, + co]) (12.7.2), where 0 5 k 5 n - 1 . These sets A,, are relatively compact. The function g,
= (l/n)
n- 1
C qAknis
lower semicontinuous
k= 1
(12.7.5), and we have 0 5 f ( x ) - g,(x) 5 I / n for all x E E, hencefis the upper envelope of the sequence (9,).On the other hand, since each pAmis the upper envelope of a sequence ( h k , , ) , ~ of continuous functions, it follows that gn is
the upper envelope of the sequence (hm,)m21,where h,,
n- 1
1hkmn(2.3.11),
= (l/n>
k= I
and the h,, are continuous. Since g, 5 1 - (l/n), the functions h,, do not take the value 1, and it is clear that f is the upper envelope of the “ double” family (12.7.9) Let E be a nonempty metrizable compact space and let f be a lower semicontinuous mapping of E into R. Then there exists at least one point a E E such that f ( a ) = inf f ( x ) (in other words, f attains its lower bound on E). xeE
Let p
= inf
f ( x ) . Then there exists a decreasing sequence (A,) of elements
XEE
of R, belonging to f ( E ) and such that inf 1, = p. The setf -‘(p) is therefore the n
intersection of the nonempty closed sets F, =f -I([ - co,A,]) (12.7.2), which form a decreasing sequence. If their intersection were empty, the open sets U, = E - F, would cover E. But E is compact and the sequence (U,) is increasing; hence we should have one of the U, equal to E, which is absurd. In particular, i f f does not take the value - co on E, then f is minorized on E. Let (x,) be any sequence of elements of 8, and put y,
= inf x , + ~ , PtO
z,
= sup x , + ~ , P20
The sequence (y,) (resp. (z,)) is increasing (resp. decreasing), hence has a limit (4.2.1). We write
1
(12.7.10) lirn inf x, = lirn inf x , + ~ ,
(
n-+m p e o
n-+m
Clearly we have lim sup x, the limit inferior.
fl’O3
= -
1
lirn sup x, = lirn sup x , + ~ n+m
n-tm
(pzo
lirn inf( -x,), so that we need only consider n+ m
28
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
(12.7.11) For every sequence (x,) in R, lirn inf x, (resp. lirn sup x,) is the least n+
m
fl+
(resp. the greatest) of the cluster values of the sequence (x,).
a,
Let a = lirn inf x, ,and suppose first that a is finite. If c < a < c' and if m is It-+ m .. ~.
any integer, there exists n > m such that c < inf x , + ~< c', hence there exists P20
p 2 0 such that c < x,+, < c'. This shows that a is a cluster value of the sequence (x,) (3.13.11). 'If a = co (resp. a = -a),the argument is the same if we replace c' (resp. c) by a . Conversely, if b is a cluster value of (x,), then it is also a cluster value of every sequence ( x , + p ) p z o ,and therefore b 2 inf x , , + ~(3.13.7). Hence b 2 a.
+
P20
This result shows that the existence of a limit of the sequence (x,) is equivalent to the relation lirn inf x, = lim sup x, , and that the common value n+m
n+ m
of the two sides is then the limit of (x,) (3.16.4). It follows from the definition that if (x,,) is any subsequence of a sequence R, then we have
(x,) in
(12.7.12)
lirn inf x,, 2 lirn inf x, k+ m
n-rm
(12.7.13) Let E be a Hausdorf topological space and letf'be a mapping of E into R which is lower semicontinuous at a point a E E. Then for every sequence (x,) of points of E such that lirn x, = a, we have ,+ a,
(12.7.13.1)
lirn inf f ( x , ) 2 f(a). n+m
For every u < f ( a ) there exists a neighborhood V of a in E such that f ( y ) 2 u for all y E V ; but there exists no such that x, E V for all n 2 n o . Hence f (x,) >= u for all n 2 n o , which proves the result.
PROBLEMS
1. Let E be a topological space. For each closed subset A of the product space E x R, show that the mapping xHinf(A(x)) of prlA into R is lower semicontinuous. Conversely, iff: E -+R is lower semicontinuous, then the subset B of E x R consisting of all pairs ( x , y ) such thatf(x) 5 y is closed in E x R.
7 SEMICONTINUOUS FUNCTIONS 2.
29
(a) Let E, F be two metrizable locally compact spaces and let T :E -+ F be a continuous map. The mapping n is said to be proper if, for each compact subset K of F, the inverse image n--I(K) is compact. Show that, if T is proper and y E r(E), every neighborhood in E of the set r - ' ( y ) contains a neighborhood of the form T-'(U), where U is a neighborhood of y in F. (b) Let g be a lower semicontinuous real-valued function on E. For each y E F, let f ( y ) be the greatest lower bound of g on the set ~ - ' ( y (so ) that f ( y ) = 03 if n--'(y) = 0).Show thatfis lower semicontinuous on F. (c) Let g be the continuous function ( x ~ , x ~ ) H [ x ~ x11z on R x 10, +a[.For each x E R,letf(xl) = inf g(xl, xz). Show thatfis not lower semicontinuous on R.
+
XZ>0
+ +
+ +
3. For each point t = (tl, . . . , I,) E C", put P,(X) = X" tlX"-' . .. t.. Show that there exists a continuous mapping r + + x ( t )of C" into R and a lower semicontinuous mapping t t-+y(t) of C" into R, such that P,(x(r) iy(t)) = 0 for all r E C". (Take x ( t ) to be the largest of the real parts of the roots of P, , and use (9.17.4)). 4.
Let f be any mapping of a metric space E into a metric space F. For each x E E, let n ( x ) be the oscillation offat x with respect to E (3.14), so that n(x) is a positive real number or co. Show that the mapping XH n(x) of E into R is upper semicontinuous.
+
5.
Let E be a metric space and letf: E + R be lower semicontinuous. Let a E E be a point at which the oscillation n(a)o f f is finite. Show that for each E > 0, there exists a neighborhood V of a in E such that inf n ( x ) 5 E . (Show that otherwise there would X E V
exist points x arbitrarily close to a at which f ( x ) took arbitrarily large values.)
6. Let (an)n3lbe an infinite sequence of distinct points in the interval [0, I[. For each integer N > 1, let b l , . . . , bN denote the sequence obtained by arranging the set {u,, . . ., aN} in increasing order. The intervals [0, b,[, [ b ~b ,~ [... . , [ b -1, ~ b ~ [ , [ b1[~ , are said to form the Nrh subdivision of [0, I[ corresponding to the sequence (a"). Let uN (resp. uN)denote the minimum (resp. maximum) of the lengths of the intervals of the Nth subdivision. Let h = lim inf NUN, p = lim sup NUN. N- m
N-m
+
(a) For each E > 0, let no be such that uN 2 (A - E)/N and uN 2 ( p E)/N for all N 2 n o . Show that, for each N 2 no and each integer r such that 0 5 r 5 N, there exist 2r intervals of the (N r)th subdivision whose lengths are greater than or equal to the 2r numbers
+
h-E h-E h-E -h.- .E. N+l'
N+l'
N+2'
N+2'
h-E 'N+r'
h - E -
N+r
+
and such that the other intervals of the (N r)th subdivision are intervals of the Nth subdivision (use induction o n r). (b) Show that, if N 2 n o , the intervals of the Nth subdivision can be arranged in order in such a way that their lengths are less than or equal to the N 1 numbers
+
p +_ E _ pL-E -
N
' N+l'""
2N
'
(For each interval I of the Nth subdivision, let s(1) be the largest integer 5 2 N such that 1 is an interval of the s(1)th subdivision, and arrange the intervals I in order of
increasing s(I).)
30
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
(c) Deduce from (a) and (b) that
h 5 l/log 4, (use the fact that
N
1/(N
,= 1
p
2 I/log 2
+ r ) tends to log 2 as N -+ + co).
(d) Take a. = log2(2n - 1) - [log2(2n - I)]. Show that we have h = l/log 4 and p = l/log 2 for this sequence. (Observe that, if N = 2p, the set {al, , , . , a N }is the same as the set {CN , . . . , c ~ -N1) where c. = log, n - [log, n].) (Cf. Section 13.21, Problem 15.)
7. Let E be a metrizable space. Show that a nonempty closed subset S of E is the support of a lower semicontinuous (resp. continuous) real-valued function 2 0 on E if and only if S is the closure of its interior. 8.
Let E be a metrizable space and f a mapping of E into R. The lower semicontinuous regularization off is defined to be the upper envelope of the continuous functions g on E such that g f. (a) For each x E E we denote by lim inff(y) the greatest lower bound of the numbers Y-x
lirn inff(y.), for all sequences (y.) tending to x. Show that the function xwlim inff(y) Y-x
"-I m
is the lower semicontinuous regularization off. (b) Suppose that E is an open set in R. For each x greatest upper bound of the numbers lirn inff(y.) y , + x and y .
E
E, let lim inf f(y) denote the Y'X.
Y>X
for all sequences (y.) such that
n-m
2 x for all n. Show that the set of all x E E such that lirn inf f ( y ) > lirn inff(y) Y-x,
Y-IX
Y>X
is at most denumerable. (For each pair ( p , q) of rational numbers with p > q. show that the set of points x E E such that
lirn inf f(y) > p > q > lirn inff(y) Y-x.
Y>X
Y+X
is at most denumerable, by following the method of Section 3.9, Problem 3.) 9. A Dirichlet series is a series whose general term is of the form a.e-'"S, where (h.) is an increasing sequence of real numbers, tending to co, and (a")is any sequence of complex numbers, and s is complex. (a) Show that if the series is convergent for s = s o , then it is uniformly convergent in the angular sector consisting of the points s = so pele with p 2 0 and -a 2 6 a, where a is such that 0 < a < n/2. (Reduce to the case so = 0; show first that if 9 s = u, then
+
+
le-os-e-b*l
5
I~Io-'(e-O"--e-b")
whenever a and b are real and a < b, by considering the integral
+
s."
cXs dx. For each
integer m and each n l m , put S,,,= ~ , , + a , + ~* . . + a , and use the identity (Abel's partial summation formula)
7 SEMICONTINUOUS FUNCTIONS
31
(b) Deduce from (a) that there are the following three alternatives: either the series ( ~ " e - ~ does " ' ) not converge for any value of s, or it converges for all values of s, or else there exists a real number uo such that the series converges for 9 s > uo and does not converge when 9 s < uo. In the first (resp. second) case we put uo = m (resp. - 03). In all cases, the (extended real) number uo is called the abscissa of convergence of the series. The sum of the series is an analytic function of s in the region 92s > uo. (c) Show that if uo 2 0, then uo = lirn sup (log ISo. .I)/&. (Show first that if the
+
n-m
series with general term a.e-"' = b, is convergent (with s real and >O), then we have ISo, 5 KeAnswhere K is a constant, by writing a, = b.eAnS.Then show that if y = lim sup (log ISo, "\)/An,the series (ane-Afls) converges when s = y 6, where 6 is
+
n-m
real and >0, by arguing as in (a).) (d) Let u1 be the abscissa of convergence of the Dirichlet series with general term la.le-Ans.Then u1 2 uo. If uo < m , show that
+
log n u1 - uo 5 lim sup n-m
A.
I
(Remark that, given E > 0, we have lan\5 e'"o+e'Anfor all sufficientlylargen.)Consider the case where A,, = n (cf. Section 9.1, Problem 1). Show that, for the series with general term
wehaveuo=-mandal=+co. 10. Letfbe a real-valued function defined on the interval [0,
+
m[, satisfying the following conditions: (1) f ( s + t ) Z f ( s ) + f ( t ) ; (2) there exists a number M > 0 such that If(t)l 5 Mt for all t. Show that the limits
exist and are finite, and that at sf(r)5 /3r for all t 2 0. (To establish the existence of a it is enough to show that, if we take a = limsupf(r)/t (Problem 8), then 1-0
sf(r)/rfor
all t > 0. Take a decreasing sequence (1.) tending to 0, such that limf(rn)/tn = a, and let k, be the integral part of r/t.. Show that a
The proof of the existence of lim
f(r)/t
is similar; put
t-+m
/3 = lim inff(r)/t.) r-+m
11. Let f b e a continuous mapping of an open set U in a Banach space E into a Banach space F. For each x E U, let Ilf(Y) -f(x)ll
D+f(x) = lim sup y-x.y+x
D - f ( x ) = lim inf Y-x.Y#x
We have 0 2 D-f(x)
5 D+f(x)
+ m.
IlY-XI1
'
/I f(Y)- f ( x )II IlY-XI1
.
32
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
(a) If the function f is differentiable at a point x E U, then D+f(x) = Ilf’(x)ll. If f:(x) is not a linear homeomorphism of E onto a subspace of F,we have D-f(x) = 0 . In the contrary case, we have D-f(x)= ~ ~ ( J ’ ( x ) ) - ~where ~ ~ - ~(,f ’ ( ~ ) ) - ~denotes the inverse homeomorphism. (b) Suppose that the segment with endpoints a, b is contained in U, and that D+f(x) M for all points x in this segment. Prove that llf(b) -f(a)ll 5 Mllb - all (see the proof of 8.5.1).) (c) Take U = E =R3 and F =R3,and letfbe defined as follows:
if (fl, &) # (0,O); and f(0,O) = 0. Show that the greatest lower bound of D-fon U is strictly positive, but that there is no neighborhood of 0 in U on whichfis injective. (d) For the remainder of this problem, suppose that there exist two numbers m, M with 0 < m < M < co, such that m 5 D-f(x) 5 M for all x E U. Suppose also that for each x E U there exists an open neighborhood V of x*in U such that f l V is a homeomorphism of V onto an open set in F ; thenf(U) is open in F. Let a be a point of U, and for each line D c F containing f ( a ) let ID be the connected component of the point f(a) in the open set D n f ( U ) in D. The union S, of the sets I D is the largest star-shaped open set with respect to f ( a ) contained in f(U). For each line D in F passing through f ( u ) , tnere exists a unique continuous mapping go : ID--f U such that g o ( f ( a ) )= a and f ( g D ( y ) )= y for all y E ID (the proof is the same as in Section 10.2, Problem 6(c).) If y, y’ are points of ID, we have I ~ ~ D ( Y ‘ ) - S D ( Y ) ~S~ m--’Ily’ - Y I I . Deduce that as y tends to an endpoint of ID (when there is one), g&) has a limit belonging to Fr(U). (e) Let y : J + U be a path in U with origin a and extremity b. Show that, if f(y(J)) C S., then we have b =gD(j(b)), where D is the line throughf(a) and f(b), and II f ( b )-f(a)ll 2 mll b - all. (f) Deduce from (d) and (e) that if U = E then S, = F, and f is a homeomorphism of E onto F. (9) Let k = M/m. Let a, b be two points of U such that the set Ek7a,b of points z E E such that I/z- all llz - bl/ 5 k/l b - all is contained in U. If L is the closed segment with endpoints a, b, show that f(L) c S,, and hence that
+
+
IlfW -f(a)ll 2 mll b - all.
+
(Proof by contradiction: consider the least I E [0, I ] such that y = f ( u t(b - a)) $ S., If D is the line throughf(u) and y, there is an endpoint u of ID belonging to the open segment with endpoints !(a) and y . When f ‘ < t tends to t, there is a point u‘ of the open segment with endpoints f(a) and y‘ = f ( a r’(b - a)) which tends to u. Let D’ be the line through f ( a ) and y’, and let z’ = go&’). Using (e), show that z’ E Ek,(I,b , and obtain a contradiction by making r’ tend to I and using (d).) (h) Suppose that E and F are Hilbert spaces and that U is the ball llxll < 1. Deduce (kZ- 1)’l2), the restriction off to B is a from (g) that if B is the ball llxll < 1/(1 homeomorphism onto f(B),and that Ilf(x’) -f(x)il 2 m ljx’ - XI( for any two points x, x’ in B. ( 9 With the hypotheses of (h), suppose also th at 4 < ((1 +2/5)/2)1/2. Show that f is then injective on U and, more precisely, that for any two points x, x’ in U we have Ilf(x’) -f(x)II 2 p Ilx’- x/I, where - M(M2 - m2)1/2 p = m + (Mz - m2)1/2 ‘
+
+
8 TOPOLOGICAL GROUPS
33
8. TOPOLOGICAL GROUPS
If G is a group, in which the law of composition is written (for example) multiplicatively, a topology on G is said to be compatible with the group structure if the two mappings ( x , y ) H x y of G x G (endowed with the product topology) into G, and X H X - ' of G into G, are continuous. A group endowed with a topology compatible with its group structure is called a topological group. We leave it to the reader to transcribe this definition (and all the results which follow) into additive notation. An isomorphism of a topological group G onto a topological group G' is by definition an isomorphism of the group G onto the group G' which is bicontinuous. If G' = G, we say automorphism instead of isomorphism. If G is any group, the law of composition ( x , y ) ~ y defines x a group structure on the set G (and this structure is different from the given one unless G is commutative). The group so defined is denoted by Go and is called the opposite of G. Any topology which is compatible with the group structure of G is also compatible with that of Go, and hence makes G o into a topological group. The mapping XHX-' is then an isomorphism of G onto Go.
Examples (12.8.1) The discrete topology and the chaotic topology (12.1.1) are compatible with the structure of any group. The topology of a normed space (in particular R or C) is compatible with its additive group structure. On the additive group Q of rational numbers, the topology defined by the p-adic distance d (3.2.6) is compatible with the group structure, because by virtue of the definition of this distance and (3.2.6.4) we have
4x0
+ yo x + Y ) s MaxMxo 4, dcvo ,v)) 5
Y
and
d(-xo, -x)
= d ( x o ,x ) .
If E is a (real or complex) Banach space and GL(E) the set of linear homeomorphisms of E onto E, then the topology induced on GL(E) by that of Y(E; E) is compatible with the group structure ((5.7.5) and (8.3.2)).
34
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
In particular, the topology induced on the multiplicative group R* (resp. C*)of real (resp. complex) numbers # O by the topology of R (resp. C) makes R* (resp. C*)into a topological group. If G is a topological group (in multiplicative notation), the mappings (x, y ) H xy-' and ( x , y ) H x - ' y are continuous mappings of G x G into G (3.11.5). For each a E G , the left and right translations x H ax and x H xa
are homeomorphisms of G onto G, because they are bijective and continuous ((3.20.14) and (12.5))and so are the inverse mappings x H a - ' x a n d x H x a - ' .
For any a, b in G, the mapping x H a x b (and in particular the inner automorphism x ~ a x a - ' is ) therefore a homeomorphism of G onto G (3.11.5). Since the mapping X H X - ' is bijective and equal to its inverse, it also is a homeomorphism of G onto G. (12.8.2) Let G be a topological group.
(i) For each open (resp. cloJed) subset A of' G, and each x E G, the sets x A , Ax and A - ' (the set of ally-', where y E A) are open (resp. closed) in G. (ii) For each open set A in G and each subset B of G , the sets AB (the set of all products yz, where y E A and z E B) and BA are open in G. The assertions in (i) follow immediately from the preceding remarks, and (ii) follows from (i), since AB = A z is a union of open sets.
u
ZEB
(12.8.2.1) On the other hand, if A and B are closed in G, it does not necessarily follow that AB is closed (cf. (12.10.5)). For example, if 9 is an irrational number, consider the subgroups Z and OZ of R . Then the subgroup Z 8Z is not closed in R. To see why, observe that this subgroup is denumerable, and therefore is not the whole of R (2.2.17). Hence it is enough to prove the following result:
+
The only closed subgroups of R are R itseyand the subgroups of the form crZ, where cr E R. (12.8.2.2)
Granted this, we cannot have both 1 = nz and 9 = ma with m and n integers, because 8 is irrational, and the assertion of (12.8.2.1) then follows. To prove (12.8.2.2), we shall first show that a subgroup H of R is either discrete or dense in R. If H is not discrete, then for each E > 0 there exists x # 0 in the set H n [ - E , S E ] .Since the integer multiples n x ( n E Z) belong to H, every interval of length greater than E in R contains one of these points and therefore H is dense in R.
8 TOPOLOGICAL GROUPS
35
To complete the proof of (12.8.2.2), it remains to be shown that if H is discrete it is of the form a Z . We may assume that H # ( 0 ) . Since H = -H, the intersection H n 10, +a[is not empty. If b > 0 belongs to H, the intersection H n [O, b ] is compact and discrete and therefore$nire (3.16.3). Let a be the smallest element > O in this set, and for any X E H let m = [ x / a ] be the integral part of x / a . Then x - ma E H, and 0 5 x - ma < a. This implies that x - ma = 0 and so we have H = a Z . (12.8.3) Let G be a topological group. (i) Let a E G . r f V runs through a fundamental system of neighborhoods of the neutral element e of G , the sets a V (resp. V a )form a fundamental system of neighborhoods of a. (ii) For each neighborhood U of e, there exists a neighborhood V of e such that VV-' c U. (iii) For each neighborhood U of e and each a E G , there exists a neighborhood W of e such that aWa-' c U. (iv) G is Hausdorflifand only if the set { e } is closed in G . The assertion (i) follows from the fact that translations are homeomorphisms; (ii) expresses that the mapping (x, y ) ~ x y - 'is continuous at ( e , e ) , having regard to the definition of open sets in G x G (12.5); (iii) expresses the continuity of the mapping X H axa- at the point e . As to (iv), it is clear that if G is Hausdorff the set { e } is closed (12.3.4). Conversely, if { e } is closed and if x , y are distinct points of G, then there exists a neighborhood V of e such that e # x-'yV, i.e., such that x # y V . If W is a neighborhood of e such that WW-' c V (which is possible by (ii)), then we have XW n yW = 0, because the relation xw' = yw" with w' and W" in W would imply x = yW"W'-1
Eyww-'
cyv
Hence G is Hausdorff. A neighborhood V of e is said to be symmetric if V-' = V. The symmetric neighborhoods of e form a fundamental system of neighborhoods of e in G, because if U is any neighborhood of e, then so is U-' (12.8.2) and therefore U n U-' is a symmetric neighborhood of e contained in U. For each integer n > 0 and each subset V of G we define V" inductively by the rule V" = V"-' V = V V"-'. (The set V" is not the set of X" with x E V.) If V is a neighborhood of e , then so is V" 3 V for all n 2 I , and it follows from (12.8.3(ii)) that if U is any neighborhood of e and n is an integer > 1, there exists a symmetric neighborhood V of e such that V" c U.
36
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
(12.8.4) For a homomorphism f of a topological group G into a topological group G' to be continuous, it is necessary and suficient that f should be continuous at one point.
For iff is continuous at a E G and if V' is a neighborhood of f ( a ) , then f -'(V') = V is a neighborhood of a. For each x E G, we have
f(xa-'v) = f ( x > ( f ( a ) > - ' f ( Vc)f ( x > ( f ( a ) > - ' v ' , which establishes the continuity off at the point x , by virtue of (12.8.3(i)). If H is a subgroup of a topological group G, the induced topology on H is clearly compatible with the group structure of H. Whenever we consider H as a topological group, it is to be understood in this sense unless the contrary is explicitly stated. (12.8.5) The closure R of a subgroup (resp. normal subgroup) H qfa topological group G is a subgroup (resp. normal subgroup) of G. If G is Hausdorff and H is commutative, then R is commututive.
'
The image of R x R = H x H under the continuous mapping (x,y ) Hxy of G x G into G is contained in R, because the image of H x H under this mapping is contained in H (3.11.4). Hence R is a subgroup. Likewise, if H is normal and a E G, the image of H under the mapping x H a x a - ' is contained in H, hence the image of R is contained in R, and therefore R is normal. Finally, if G is Hausdorff and H is commutative, the continuous functions x y and y x are equal on H x H and therefore also on R x R by virtue of the principle of extension of identities ((3.15.2), 12.3, and 12.5). (12.8.6) ( i ) In a topological group G, the normalizer N ( H ) of a closed subgroup H (i.e., the set of all x E G such that xHx-' c H) is a closed subgroup. (ii) In a Hausdorff topological group G , the centralizer d ( M ) of any subset M ofG (i.e., the set of all x E G which commute with every element of M ) is a closed subgroup of G. In particular, the center of G i s closed.
For each z E H, the set of elements x E G such that xzx-' E H is the inverse image of H under the continuous mapping X H X Z X - I , hence is a closed set (3.11.4). Since N ( H ) is the intersection of these sets as z runs through H , it follows that N(H)is closed (3.8.2). Again, if G is Hausdorff then for each z E M the set of x E G such that zx = xz is closed (12.3.5) and hence so is S ( M ) since it is the intersection of these sets. (12.8.7) (i) In a topological group G, every Iocally closed subgroup is closed. Every subgroup which has an interior point is both open and closed. (ii) In a HausdorfSgroup, every discrete subgroup is closed.
8
TOPOLOGICAL GROUPS
37
(i) Let H be a locally closed subgroup of G. Then R is a subgroup of G, and H is an open subgroup of R (12.2.3). Hence it is enough to prove the second assertion. Now if H has an interior point, then by translation it follows that every point of H is interior, and therefore H is open. Hence the left cosets x H are also open sets, and therefore CH is open in G (because it is a union of cosets xH). Consequently H is closed in G. (ii) If G is Hausdorff and H is a discrete subgroup of G, then there exists a symmetric open neighborhood V of e such that V n H = { e } . If X E R ,we have xV n H # fa. Now if y ~ x V n H, then x ~ y V and the set { y } is closed in the open set yV, because G is Hausdorff. Since yV n H = { y } (because y E H), we must have x = y , and therefore R = H. (12.8.8) If G is a connected group and V is a symmetric neighborhood of e, then G is equal to the union V" of the sets V"for n > 0.
The set V" is clearly symmetric, and since V"V" = Vm+"it follows that V"V" c V". Hence V" is a subgroup of G. Since e is an interior point of V", this subgroup is both open and closed (12.8.7) and therefore is the whole of G . (12.8.9) In a topological group G , the connected component K of the neutral element (3.19) is a closed normal subgroup (called the neutral component or identity component of G). For each x E G , the connected component of x in G is XK = Kx.
If a E K, the set a - ' K is connected and contains e, hence K-'K c K. This shows that K is a subgroup of G. It is invariant under all automorphisms of the topological group G, in particular under all inner automorphisms, hence K is normal in G. Also K is closed in G (3.19). Finally, the last assertion follows from the fact that left and right translations are homeomorphisms of G onto G. (12.8.10) If G,, G, are two topological groups, then the product topology on the product group G = G, x G, is compatible with the group structure of G. For, identifying canonically the product spaces G x G and (GI x G,) x (G, x G,) (12.5), the mapping
((x19 x2)9 ( Y l , Y 2 ) ) +-+(XlY13 x2 Y2) is continuous ((3.20.15) and (12.5)), and the mapping (xl, x,)H(x;~, x;') is continuous for the same reason. The group G, x G , , endowed with the product topology, is called the product of the topological groups G , and G , . If G is a commutative topological group, the mapping (x, y ) ~ x is y a continuous homomorphism of G x G into G.
38
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
PROBLEMS
1. Let G be a group and let 'x1 be a set of subsets of G , satisfying conditions (V,) and (V,,) of Section 12.3, Problem 3, together with the following:
(GV,) For all U E % there exists V E 3 such that V . V c U. (GV,,) For all U E ti we have U - ' E %, (GV,,,) For all U E % and a E G, we have aUa-I E ti. Show that there exists a unique topology on G , compatible with the group structure of G, for which % is the set of neighborhoods of the neutral element e . 2.
Every topology compatible with the group structure of a finite group G is obtained by taking as neighborhoods of the neutral element the sets containing a normal subgroup H of G. Give an example of a non-Hausdorff topological group in which the center is not closed and has as its closure a noncommutative subgroup.
3.
Let G be a connected topological group. Show that every totally disconnected normal subgroup D of G is contained in the center of G. (If a E D, consider the mapping XHXUX-' of G into D.)
4.
Show that the commutator subgroup of a connected topological group is connected (use (3.19.3)and (3.19.7)).
5.
Let G be a topological group and let H , K be subgroups of G such that H 3 K 2 H', where H' is the commutator subgroup of H. Show that R contains the commutator subgroup of R . Deduce that if G is Hausdorff, the closure in G of a solvable subgroup is solvable (induction on the length of the derived series).
6. Let G be a topological group and let H be a closed normal subgroup of G , containing the commutator subgroup of G. If the identity component K of H is solvable, show that the identity component L of G is solvable. (Show by using Problem 4 that K contains the commutator subgroup of L.)
T be the canonical homomorphism and let 6 be an irrational number. O n the topological space G = RZ x T2,a group law is defined by
I. Let cp : R
--f
In this way G becomes a locally compact group (even a Lie group). Show that the commutator subgroup of G is not closed in G. 8.
Let (G&cl be any family of topological groups. Show that the product topology on G = G , is compatible with the product group structure (Section 12.5, Problem 4).
n
.El
The topological group so defined is called the product of the topological groups G, . Let H be the normal subgroup of G cocsisting of all x = (x,) such that for all but a finite number of indices x. is the identity element of C , . Show that H is dense in G .
9
METRIZABLE GROUPS
39
9. METRIZABLE G R O U P S
If G is a group, a function f on G x G is said to be left (resp. right) invariant if f ( x y , x z ) =f ( y , z ) (resp. f ( y x , zx) =f ( y , z ) ) for all x, y , z in G. When G is commutative, these two conditions coincide, andfis then said to be translation-invariant. A distance d o n G is left (resp. right) invariant if and only if the left (resp. right) translations are isometries with respect to d. Iff is a left-invariant function on G x G, then the function (x,y ) ~ f ( x - ly,- ' ) is right-invariant, and vice versa. For example, if E is a normed space, the distance / / x- y/1 on E is translation-invariant. (12.9.1 ) In order that the topology of a topological group G should be metrizable (in which case G is said to be a metrizable group) it is necessary and suficient that there should exist a denumerable fundamental system of neighborhoods of the neutral element e, whose intersection consists of e alone. When this condition is satisfied, the topology of G can be defined by a leftinvariant distance, or by a right-invariant distance.
It is enough to show that if there exists a denumerable fundamental system of neighborhoods (U,) of e in G such that U, = { e } ,then the topology of G n
can be defined by a left-invariant distance. We define inductively a sequence (V,) of symmetric neighborhoods of e in G such that V, c U, and
VL, v,
n
u,
for all n 2 1 (12.8.3), so that (V,) is also a fundamental system of neighborhoods of e. Now define a real-valued function g on G x G as follows: g(x, x ) = 0 ; if x # y , then either x - ' y 4 V,, in which case we takeg(x, y ) = 1; or else there exists a greatest integer k such that x - ' y E Vk (because x - ' y # e cannot belong to all the V,), in which case we define g(x, y> = 2-k. It is clear from this definition that g ( x , y ) = g(y, x), that g(x, y ) 2 0, and that g(zx, z y ) = g(x, y ) for all x , y , z in G. Now let (12.9.1 . I )
where the infimum is taken over the set of all finite sequences (zo , z l , . . . , z,,) (with p arbitrary) such that z,, = x and z p = y . We shall show that d is a leftinvariant distance on G and satisfies the inequalities (1 2.9.1.2)
M X ?Y)
5 4x9 Y ) I g(x, Y).
40
XI1 TOPOLOGY A N D TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
From the definition of d, it follows immediately that d is left-invariant (because g is), satisfies the triangle inequaiity, is symmetric and positive. Moreover, the right-hand inequality in (12.9.1.2) is obvious, and shows that d(x, x ) = 0 for all x E G. Hence d is a pseudo-distance on G. T o prove the lefthand inequality of (12.9.1.2) we shall show by induction on p that, for each finite sequence ( z i ) o s i s po f p 1 points in G such that zo = x and z p = y , we have
+
P- 1
(12.9.1.3)
1 g(zi
i=O
7
This inequality is obvious if p
zi+1) 2 +g(x, Y ) .
1g(zi, ziti). The
P- 1
1. Let us write a =
=
i=O
inequality (12.9.1.3) is true if a 2 +, because g(x, y ) 1, If a = 0, then zi = zi+l for 0 5 i S p - 1, hence x = y and so (12.9.1.3) is trivially satisfied. So suppose that 0 < a < and let h be the greatest index such that g ( z i , zi+l>5 +a. Then we have g ( z i , z ~ +>~+a, ) so that
1
+,
i
1
i
1 g(zi
i>h
9
zi+1)
5 3.
By the inductive hypothesis, we have g(x, zh) S a and g(z,+,, y ) 5 a ; on the other hand, it is clear that g(zh, z ~ +5~a.) Let k be the smallest integer > O such that 2 - k 5 a. Then k 2 2, and the elements X-'zh, Z ; ' Z ~ + ~ ,Z;>~Y are all in Vk, by virtue of the definition ofg. Hence x - ' y E V l t Vk-l, which implies that g(x, y ) 5 2l - k 5 2a, and proves (12.9.1.3). Hence (12.9.1.2) is established, and shows first of all that d is a distance on G. Also, if r > 0, the ball B'(e; r ) (with respect to d ) contains vk for all indices such that 2 - k < r, and conversely each v k contains the ball B'(e; 2-k-1). Since d is left-invariant, it now follows from (12.8.3(i)) and (12.2.1) that d defines the topology of G. In general it is not possible to define the topology of G by means of a distance which is both left- and right-invariant (Problem 1 and Section 14.3, Problem 11). (12.9.2) Let G be a metrizable group. A necessary and su8cient condition for a sequence (x,) in G to be a Cauchy sequence with respect to a left-invariant distance defining the topology of G is that, for each neighborhood V of e, there exists an integer no such that x i ' x , E V for all m 2 no and n 2 n o .
For if d is a left-invariant distance, we have d(x,, x,) = d(e, X ,
'Xrn),
and the proposition follows from the fact that d defines the topology of G.
9 METRIZABLE GROUPS
41
Hence the property of being a Cauchy sequence with respect to some leftinvariant distance is independent of the choice of distance, and depends only on the topology of G. We shall say simply that such a sequence is a left Cauchy sequence in G. A right Cauchy sequence in G is defined analogously by replacing x; ' x , in (12.9.2) by x, x i It can happen that a left Cauchy sequence is not a right Cauchy sequence (Problem 8); but if (x,) is a left Cauchy sequence, then (x,-') is a right Cauchy sequence. Since the mapping X I - + X - ~ is continuous it follows that, if every left Cauchy sequence in G converges, then so does every right Cauchy sequence. In this case G is said to be a complete metrizable group: it is complete with respect to every leftinvariant distance and every right-invariant distance defining the topology of G. (12.9.3) Let G, G' be two metrizable groups. Then every continuous homom0rphism.f of G into G' is unformly continuous with respect to left- (resp. right-) invariant distances on G and G'. Let d, d' be two such distances on G, G , respectively. By hypothesis, for each E > 0 there exists 6 > 0 such that the relation d(e, z ) 5 6 implies d'(e', f ( z ) ) S E . Hence if d(x, y ) = d(e, x - ' y ) 5 6 , then d'(f(x), f ( y ) ) S E , because d ' ( f ( X ) , f ( Y ) ) = d'(e'9 ( f ( x ) ) - ' f ( y ) )= d'(e',f(x-'y))
since f is a homomorphism. (12.9.4) Let G,, G, be two metrizable groups such that G, is complete, and let H, (resp. H,) be a dense subgroup of G , (resp. G,). Then every continuous homomorphism u : H1 -+ H, can be extended uniquely to a continuous homomorphism ii : G , -+ G, . If G, is also complete and if u is an isomorphism (of topological groups) of H, onto H, , then ii is an isomorphism (of topological groups) q f G , onto G, . There exist left-invariant distances on G, and G, , and the existence of the continuous extension ii then follows from (12.9.3) and (3.15.6).The fact that ii is a group homomorphism follows from the principle of extension of identities applied to the two functions ( x , y ) ii(xy) ~ and (x,y)wE(x)U(y)on G, x G, (having regard to (3.20.3)). Finally, if G, is complete and if v : H, -+ H, is the inverse of the isomorphism u, then v can be extended to a continuous homomorphism fi of G, into G,. Since V 0 U and E fi agree with the identity mappings on HI and H, respectively, they are the identity mappings on G , and G, respectively, by virtue of the principle of extension of identitiesand (3.11.5). This completes the proof. 0
42
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
It should be carefully noted that, if we suppose only that u is injective (resp. surjective), then 6 is not necessarily injective (resp. surjective) (Problem 9). (12.9.5) Let G be a metrizable group in which there exists a neighborhood V of e which is complete (with respect to some left- or right-invariant distance). Then G is complete. In particular, a locally compact metrizable group is complete.
Let d be a left-invariant distance on G and let (x,,) be a left Cauchy sequence in G. Let E > 0 be such that theclosed ball B’(e; E ) is contained inV. By hypothesis there exists an integer no such that d(x,,, x,) 5 E for all m 2 no and n 2 n o , hence the sequence (x,,),~,,,, is contained in the closed ball B’(x,,,; E ) . But this closed ball is a complete subspace, because it is obtained by left translation from B’(e; E ) which is closed in V (3.14.5). Hence the seconverges in G. The last assertion follows from (3.16.1). quence (x,,),,~~ (12.9.6) In a Hausdorff topological group G , every locally compact metrizable subgroup H is closed.
Let x E R, let V be a neighborhood of e in G such that V n H is compact, and let W be a symmetric neighborhood of e in G such that W2 c V. Then XW n H is nonempty and relatively compact in H, because if yo E XW n H then for each y E xW n H we have y o ‘ y E Wz n H c V n H and therefore y E yo(V n H), which is a compact set. It follows (12.3.6) that the closure of XW n H in G is contained in H. and therefore x E H. Let G be a Hausdorff commutative topological group, written additively. All the material on series in Section 5.2 which involves only the topology of C remains valid without any change. The same is true of Cauchy’s criterion (5.2.1) if C is metrizable, by replacing the norm llxll by d(0, x), where d is an invariant distance on G. (12.9.7)
PROBLEMS
1. Let G = GL(2, R) be the multiplicative group of all real 2 x 2 nonsingular square
matrices. For each integer
n
> 0, let V. be the set of matrices X =
(z
t )
E
G such
that jx - I I 6 l/n, ly] 5 l / n , IzI 5 l/n, and jt - 11 5 I/n. Show that the family of sets V, is a fundamental system of neighborhoods of the neutral element I of G for a topology .Y compatible with the group structure of G (cf. Section 12.8, Problem I). The group G is locally compact in the topology .T, but 9-cannot be defined by a
9
METRIZABLE GROUPS
43
distance which is both left and right-invariant (cf. Section 14.3, Problem ll).) (Use the fact that if the topology of a metrizable group G can be defined by a distance which is both left and right-invariant, then for every neighborhood V of the neutral element e of G there exists a neighborhood W c V of e such that xWx-' c V for all X E G.) 2.
Let S be a compact subset of a metrizable group G, such that xy E S whenever x E S and y E S . Show that for each x E S we have xS = S. (Consider a cluster value y of the sequence (x")., in S, and show that yS is the intersection of the sets Y S; deduce that yxS = y S . ) Deduce that S is a subgroup of G.
3
Let G be a locally compact and totally disconnected metrizable group. (a) Show that every neighborhood of e in G contains an open compact subgroup of G. (Every neighborhood V of e contains a neighborhood U of e which is both open and closed (Section 3.19, Problem 9). If B = CU, show that there exists a symmetric open neighborhood W of e in G such that W c U and UW n BW = 125, and deduce that the subgroup generated by W is contained in U.) (b) Suppose that the topology of G can be defined by a left- and right-invariant distance. Show that every neighborhood of e in G contains a compact open normal subgroup of G (remark that every neighborhood V of e contains a symmetric open neighborhood W such that XWX-'c V for all x E G).
4.
Let p be a prime number. Consider the family of finite groups Z/p"Z (n 2 I), each with the discrete topology, and their product G (Section 12.8, Problem 8) which is compact and totally disconnected. For each n, let y.: Z/p"Z+Z/p"-'Z be the canonical homomorphism. = z. for all n is a closed (a) Show that the set of all z = (z.) E G such that q&.) (hence compact) subgroup Z, of G. If a+bnis the restriction to Z, of the projection pr, : G + Z/p"Z, then is a surjective homomorphism. (b) Foreachz=(z.)EZ,,put lz(,=Oifz=O,and ~ ~ ~ , = p ' - ~ i f m i s t h e s m a l l e s t integer such that z, # 0. Show that 1z - 2'1, is a translation-invariant distance which defines the topology of Z, . (c) For each n 2 1, let f n : Z + Z/pnZ be the canonical homomorphism. Show that the homomorphismf: ZH( ~ , ( Z) ) , , ~of Z into Z, is injective and that its imagef(Z) is a dense subgroup of Z,. If we put d(z, z') = I f ( z ) -f(z')l,, show that d is the p-adic distance on Z (3.2.6).The elements of Z, are called p-adic integers.
5.
Let p be a prime number, and let G be the compact group which is the product of an infinite sequence (G,),,, of groups G. all equal to T =R/Z. For each n, let vnbe the homomorphism XHPX of G . into G.-'. The compact subgroup of G consisting of all z = (2.) such that y,(z.) = zn-' for all n is called the p-adic solenoid and is denoted by Tp. (a) For each n , let fn:T, -+ G , = T be the restriction of pr. to T, . Show that f. is a surjective homomorphism with kernel isomorphic to the group Z, (Problem 4). (b) Let y : R -+T be the canonical homomorphism. For each x E R, show that the point 8(x) = (cp(x/pn)).,, belongs to T,. Prove that 6 is an injective continuous homomorphism of R into T,, and that 8(R) is a dense subgroup of T, . Deduce that T, is connected. (c) Let I be an open interval in R, with centre 0 and length < 1. Show that the subspace f<'(rp(I)) of T, is homeomorphic to the product I x Z,. Deduce that T, is not locally connected.
44
XI1 TOPOLOGY A N D TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
(d) Show that every closed subgroup H of T, , other than T, and {O}, is totally disconnected and isomorphic to a group of the form Z/nZ or ( Z / n Z ) x Z,, where n is an integer prime to p. (Consider the groups f.(H).) (e) Show that T, is an indecomposable compact connected space, i.e., that it cannot be covered by two compact connected sets P, Q, each distinct from Tp. (Observe that there exists an integer n such that f.(P) # G. and f.(Q) # G , , and examine the sets fn+,(P) andf,+,(Q) to obtain a contradiction.) 6 . A topological group G is said to have no small subgroups if there exists a neighborhood V of e such that {e} is the only subgroup of G contained in V . Let G be a locally compact metrizable group with no small subgroups. (a) Show that there exists a compact neighborhood V of e such that, for all x , y in V, the relation x 2 = y 2 implies x = y . (We may assume that G is not commutative. If the result were false, there would exist two sequences (x"), (y,) of points of G, both tending to e, such that x.' = y.' and x.y; = a. # e. Let U be a compact symmetric neighborhood of e not containing any subgroup of G other than {el, and let p n be the smallest integer p > 0 such that a{+ 4 U. Show, by passing to a subsequence, that we may assume that a = lim a? exists, is # e and belongs to U. Show that n-rm
-a
and so obtain a contradiction.) (b) Let U be a compact symmetric neighborhood of e, containing no subgroup other than {el, and let V be a neighborhood of e. Show that there exists a number c(V) > 0 such that, whenever p and q are strictly positive integers such that p 5 c(V)q and x E G is such that x, x2, . . ,x' are in U, then xp E V. (Argue by contradiction: suppose that there exist two sequences of integers ( p J , (qn)such that lim pn/q,,= 0, and for .-I
.
n-m
each n an element a, E G such that a: E U for 1 5 h 2 qn, but n? $ V. We may also assume that the sequence (a?) has a limit a # e such that a E U. Show that amE U for all rn > 0, and hence get a contradiction.) 7.
Let G be a locally compact metrizable group with no small subgroups, and let V be a compact symmetric neighborhood of e containing no subgroup of G other than {el, and such that for all x , y E V the relation x 2 = y2 implies x = y (Problem 6(a)). (a) Show that if (an)is any sequence of points of V with e as limit, there exists a subsequence (b.) of (a,) and a sequence (k.) of integers > O such that the sequence (b:")converges to a point #e. (Consider the smallest of the integers k such that .:+I 6 V.) (b) Show that if r, s are two real numbers such that the sequences ( b p ' ) , (b:'"') converge to x, y, respectively, in G, then the sequence (b!,(""""') converges to xy. (Here [t] denotes the integral part of the real number t . ) (c) Using (a), (b), and the uniqueness of the square root, show that for every dyadic number r E [0, I ] the sequence (by'"') converges in G. (d) Let W c V be a neighborhood of e in G. Show that, for every real number r E [0, I], there exists a dyadic number s such that b[,'+s)knlE W for all n (use Problem 6(b)). Deduce that, for each r E [0, 11, the sequence (by'"') has a limit X(r). (e) If -1 2 r $0,put X ( r ) = ( X ( - r ) ) - I . Show that, if r, s and r s are all in the interval [- 1, 11, we have X ( r ) X ( s ) = X(r s) and that the mapping r t+X(r) of [-1, 11 into G is continuous. Deduce that this mapping can be extended to a nonconstant continuous homomorphism of R into G.
+
8.
+
Let I be the compact interval [0,1] in R,and let G be thegroup of all homeomorphisms of I onto I, which is contained in the Banach space '#,(I) (7.2.1). Show that the
10 SPACES WITH OPERATORS. ORBIT SPACES
45
(metrizable) topology induced on G by that of VR(I) is compatible with the group structure of G, and that right Cauchy sequences in G are the same as Cauchy sequences (7.1). &Give an example of a right Cauchy (in G) with respect to the norm on ‘if sequence in G which is not a left Cauchy sequence. 9.
(a) Let G’ be a complete metrizable group and let G o # G‘ be a dense subgroup of G’. Let G be the topplogical group obtained by giving Go the discrete topology. The identity mapping G + G o is a continuous bijective homomorphism, but its extension by continuity to a homomorphism G --t G’ (12.9.4) is not surjective. (b) Let G be the dense subgroup QZ of RZ,let 0 be an irrational number, and let u be the continuous homomorphism ( x , ~ ) H X 0y of G into R. Let G’ = u(G).The mapping u, considered as a homomorphism of G into G’, is bijective, but its continuous extension to a homomorphism of RZ into R is not injective. (c) Use (a) and (b) to construct an example of two complete groups G I , G2 and a continuous bijective homomorphism u of a dense subgroup HI of G I onto a dense subgroup Hz of Gz , such that the continuous extension of u to a homomorphism of G I into GZis neither injective nor surjective.
+
10. Let f be a continuous homomorphism of a subgroup H # {O} of R into a locally compact metrizable group G. Show that i f f is not an isomorphism of H onto the
subgroup f(H) of G, then f(H) is relatively compact in G. (Reduce to the case where H is closed in R andf(H) is dense in G . Begin by showing that, for each neighborhood W of the neutral element e in G, the set f-’(W) is unbounded, and deduce that f(H n R,) is dense in G. If V is a compact symmetric neighborhood of e in G, show that there exist a finite number of elements ti > 0 in H such that the neighborhoods f ( f l ) Vcover V. For each x E G, let A, be the set of all t E H such that f ( t ) E xV. Show that, if t E A,, there exists a ti such that t - ti E A,, and deduce that, if I is the largest compact interval with origin 0 in R containing all the t l , then I n A, is not empty. Deduce that G Cf(1) . V is compact.) 11. Let G be a commutative metrizable topological group, and let d be an invariant
distance defining the topology of G. Let h be the Hausdorff distance on %(G)corresponding to d (Section 3.16, Problem 3). Show that if M, N, P, Q are four bounded closed subsets of G, then h(MP, NQ) h ( M , N) h(P, Q).
+
10. SPACES WITH OPERATORS. ORBIT SPACES
Let G be a group and E a set. An action (or left action) of G on E is a mapping (s, x ) H S . x of G x E into E satisfying the following conditions:
-
(1) If e is the neutral element of G, then e x = x for all x E E. (2) For all s, t in G we have s ( t * x ) = ( s t ) x for all x E E.
-
- -
These conditions imply that s-’ (s x ) = x for all s E G and all x E E; hence for each s E G the mapping x ~ x sis a bijection of E onto E, and the inverse bijection is XHS-’ . x. For each x E E, the set G x of elements s . x where s E G is called the orbit of x (for the given action of G on E). The set S , of elements s E G such
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
46
that s * x = x is a subgroup of G called the stabilizer of x. The relation s * x = t * x is equivalent to t - ' s E S,. The mapping SHS x of G onto G x factorizes as follows: (12.10.1)
G A G/S,
3G
x
where G/S, is the set of left cosets sS, of S, in G ; p is the canonical mapping SHSS,; and cp is the bijection s S , w s x. The group G is said to act faithfitlly on E if the intersection of the stabilizers S,, as x runs through E, consists only of e. The group G is said to act freely on E if the stabilizer of every x e E consists only of e, or equivalently if for every x E E the relation s * x = t ' x implies s = t . The relation " y belongs to the orbit of x" is an equivalence relation on E, for which the equivalence classes are the orbits of the elements of E. The set of orbits is denoted by E/G (it is a subset of Cp(E)). If this set consists of a single element (in other words if, given any two elements x , y of E, there exists s E G such that y = s . x), then G is said to act transitively on E. The union G * A of the orbits of the elements of a subset A of E is called the saturation of A with respect to G ; the restriction to G x (G. A) of the mapping (s, X)HS * x is an action of G on G A. If : E -+ E/G is the canonical mapping (so that n(x) = G * x for all x E E), then G * A is equal to x-'(x(A)). The relation G A = A is equivalent to G ' A c A.
-
Now suppose that G is a topological group and E a topological space. Then G is said to act continuously on E if the mapping (s, X)HS * x of the product space G x E into E is continuous.
Examples (12.10.2) Let H be a subgroup of a topological group G . Then each of the actions (s, x)++sx and (s, X)HSXS-' of H on G is continuous. For the former action, the stabilizer of each x E G is the identity subgroup { e } , and the orbit of x is the right coset Hx; for the latter action, the stabilizer of x is the intersection H A b(x), where b(x) is the centralizer of x in G (12.8.6), and the orbit of x is the set of its conjugates hxh-' by elements h E H. If H, K are subgroups of G, the product group H x K acts continuously on G by ((s, t ) , x)Hsx~-'. The orbit of x is the double coset H x K of x with respect to H and K . If E is a real (resp. complex) topological vector space (12.13), the group R* (resp. C*) acts continuously on E by (A, x ) ~ A . xThe . orbits are {0} and the sets D - {0}, where D is a line (i.e. a one-dimensional subspace) in E.
10 SPACES WITH OPERATORS. ORBIT SPACES
47
If E is a Banach space, the group GL(E) of linear homeomorphisms of E onto E (12.8.1) acts continuously on E by (u, X ) H u(x) (5.7.4). Let G be a topological group and E a topological space. The mapping (s, X)HX of G x E into E is a continuous action of G on E, called the triuial action. Let G be a topological group acting continuously on a topological space E. If p is a continuous homomorphism of a topological group G' into G, then G' acts continuously on E by (s', x ) ~ p ( s '* )x. (12.10.3) r f G is a topological group acting continuously on a topological space E, then for each s E G the mapping x H s * x is a homeomorphism of E onto E.
For it is a continuous bijection, and the inverse bijection XHS-' also continuous.
x is
(12.10.4) If G is a topological group acting continuously on a Hausdorf topological space E, the stabilizer of each point of E is a closed subgroup of G . This follows immediately from (12.3.5). (12.10.5) Let G be a metrizable group acting continuously on a metrizable space E. Let A be a compact subset of G, and B a closed (resp. compact) subset of E. Then A * B is closed (resp. compact) in E.
The second assertion follows from the fact that A B is the image of the compact set A x B (3.20.16(v)) by the continuous mapping (8, X)HS * x (3.17.9). As to the first assertion, consider a sequence (s, * x,) of points of A * B (where s, E A and x, E B) with a limit z E E. By hypothesis, the sequence (s,,) has a subsequence (s,,,) converging to some point a E A . Since x,, = s";' (s,, * x,,,), the sequence (x,,,)converges to a-' * z. But B is closed in E and therefore a-' * z E B, hence z = a * (a-' * z ) E A * B. By (3.13.13), the proof is complete. Let G be a topological group acting continuously on a topological space E. Let E/G be the set of orbits and let TC : E + E/G be the canonical mapping, so that n(x) is the orbit G * x for each x E E. Let D be the set of subsets U of E/G such that n-'(U) is open in E. It follows immediately from the formulas (1.8.5) and (1.8.6) that r) is a topology on E/G. The set E/G, endowed with
48
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
this topology, is called the orbit space of the action of G on E. The mapping UH x-'(U) is a bijection of the set of open sets of E/G onto the set of saturated open sets of E. A subset F of E/G is closed in E/G if and only if n-'(F) is closed in E, because n-'((E/G) - F) = E - n-'(F).
(12.10.6) (i) The canonical mapping x : E -+ E/G is continuous. (ii) The image under n of every open set in E is open in E/G. (iii) A mapping f of E/G inzo a topological space E' is continuous if and only i f f n : E -,E' is continuous. 0
The first assertion follows from the definition of the topology of E/G and from (3.11.4(b)).To prove the second, it is enough to show that if V is open in E then its saturation G * V = n-'(n(V)) is open in E; and this is clear because G V = s * V, and each s V is open in E by virtue of (12.10.3). Finally, if
u
SEG
f:E/G + E' is continuous, then so is f
0 x by (i); conversely, i f f 0 x is continuous, then for every open set U' in E' the set n-'(f -'(U')) is open in E, hence f -'(U') is open in E/G. This proves (iii).
If x is any point of E and if V runs through a fundamental system of neighborhoods of x in E, the sets x(V) form a fundamental system of neighborhoods of the point x(x) in E/G.
(12.10.7) Let A be a subset of E and let A' = G A = n-'(n(A)) be its saturation with respect to G. Then the canonical bijecfion cp of the subspace n(A) of E/G onto the orbit space A'/G is a homeomorphism. The mapping cp is defined as follows: if x E A, the image under cp of the orbit G x is the same orbit considered as an element of A'/G. As U runs through the set of open subsets of E/G, the mapping cp takes U n n(A) to the canonical image of n-'(U) n A' in A'/G. Now U n n(A) runs through the set of open subsets of the subspace x(A) of E/G, and cp(n-'(U) n A') runs through the set of open subsets of A'/G. For if V' is a saturated open subset of .the subspace A' of E, then V' is of the form V n A', where V is open in E; but also V' = (G V) n A' = x-'(n(V)) n A', and x(V) is open in E/G by (12.10.6).
(12.10.8) Let G be a topological group acting continuously on a topological space E. In order that E/G should be Hausdorff it is necessary and suflcient that, in the product space E x E , the set R of pairs (x, y ) belonging to the same orbit be closed. When this is the case, every orbit is closed in E.
10 SPACES WITH OPERATORS. ORBIT SPACES
49
Let n(x) and n(y) be distinct points of E/G. If E/G is Hausdorff, there exist saturated open sets V, W in E such that V n W = fa and x E V and y E W. It is clear that the open set V x W in E x E contains ( x , y ) and does not meet R. Hence R is closed in E x E. Conversely, if R is closed in E x E, there exists an open neighborhood S of x and an open neighborhood T of y in E such that (S x T) n R = @. By (12.10.6), n(S) and n(T) are neighborhoods of n(x) and n(y), respectively. I f they intersected, there would exist s E S and t E T belonging to the same orbit, which means that (s, t ) E R ; and this is absurd. Hence E/G is Hausdorff. The last assertion follows from (12.3.4) and the continuity of n. (12.10.9) Let E be a metrizable space, G a topological group acting continuously on E, and n : E + E/G the canonical mapping. Suppose that E/G is metrizable. Then :
(i) ifE is separable, E/G is separable. (ii) ifE is locally compact (resp.' compact), E/G is locally compact (resp. compact); (iii) ifE is locally compact and K is any compact subset of E/G, there exists a compact subset L of E such that K = n(L).
If D is a denumerable dense subset of E, then n(D) is dense in E/G (3.11.4(d)). This proves (i). If V is a compact neighborhood of x E E, then n(V) is a compact neighborhood of n(x) in E/G ((3.17.9) and (12.10.6)); hence (ii). Finally, for each z E K , let V(z) be a compact neighborhood of a point of n-'(z) in E, so that n(V(z))is a compact neighborhood of z. There exist a finite number of points zi E K such that the n(V(z,)) cover K. Let L, be the compact set V(zi) in E. We have K c n(L,), hence the set L = L, n n-'(K)
u i
is compact (because it is closed in L, : (3.11.4) and (3.17.3)) and we have x(L) = K. (12.10.10) Let E be a locally compact, separable metrizable space and G a topological group acting continuously on E. Let n : E --+ E/G be the canonical mapping. Suppose that (1) E/G is Hausdorff, (2)for each x E E there exists a compact subset K ( x ) of E , containing x and such that the restriction of n to K ( x ) is injective and n ( K ( x ) )is a neighborhood o f n ( x ) . Then E/G is metrizable (and therefore, by (12.10.9), locally compact and separable).
We shall first show that there exists a sequence (K,) of compact subsets of E such that the restriction of n to K, is injective and the interiors of the sets n(K,,) cover E/G. By (3.18.3)there exists an increasing sequence (A,,) of compact subsets of E, whose union is E. For each z E n(A,), let x be a point of
50
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
n-’(z), and let K(x) be a set with the properties enunciated above. Then V(z) = (n(K(x)))O is an open neighborhood of z, and therefore n-’(V(z)) is an open neighborhood of n-‘(z) n A, . Since A,, is compact, there are a finite number of points zi E n(A,,) such that the sets n-’(V(z,)) (1 g i 6 p,,, say) cover A,. Let Ki,, be the set K(x) corresponding to V(zi), so that the interiors of the sets n(K,,,) form an open covering of n(A,,)in E/G. Then it is clear that the K i n( n 2 1 , 1 5 i 5 p , for each n ) satisfy the required conditions. This being so, the restriction of n to K, is a homeomorphism of K, onto the subspace n(K,,) of E/G, because E/G is Hausdorff (12.3.6), and this subspace is therefore compact and metrizable. The result therefore follows from (12.4.7). (12.10.11) Let G (resp. G‘) be a topological group acting continuously on a topological space E (resp. E’). Then G x G’ acts continuously on E x E‘ by (s,s‘) (x, x’) = (s x, s’. K‘), and the mapping w defined by
-
-
(G x G’) (x, x’) H ((G . x), (G’ . x’)) is a homeomorphism of(E x E’)/(G x G’) onto (E/G) x (E’/G’).
It is immediately checked that o is bijective, and it is continuous by virtue of (12.10.5). Moreover, every open set in (E x E’)/(G x G’) is the image, under the canonical mapping p : E x E’ + (E x E’)/(G x G’),of an open set U in E x E‘, and we have o ( p ( U ) ) = n(prl U) x n’(pr, U ) , where n : E -+E/G and 71‘ : E’ -+ E’/G’ are the canonical mappings. The set w ( p ( U ) ) is therefore open in (E/G) x (E’/G’), and the proof is complete. (12.10.12) Let G be a connected topologicalgroup acting continuously on a topological space E. If the orbit space E/G is connected, then E is connected.
Since the mapping s w s x of G onto G x is continuous, it follows
(3.19.7) that every orbit is connected. Suppose that there exist two non-empty open sets U, V in E such that U n V = @ and U u V = E. For each x E E, the sets U n (G * x) and V n (G * x) are open in G * x; their union is G * x
and their intersection is empty. Hence one of them is empty; in other words, U and V are saturated. But this implies that n(U) and n(V) are nonempty open sets in E/G whose intersection is empty and whose union is E/G, and this contradicts the hypothesis that E/G is connected. Remark (12.10.13) A right action of a group G on a set E is a mapping (s, x) Hx * s of G x Einto E such that x . e = xfor all x E E, and(x * t ) s = x . (ts)for all
10 SPACES WITH OPERATORS. ORBIT SPACES
51
x E E and all, s, t in G. Everything we have said can be immediately transposed to this situation; the set of orbits is sometimes denoted by G\E. For example, a subgroup H of a topological group G acts continuously on the right on G by the action (s,x) Hxs.
PROBLEMS
1. Let G be a locally compact metrizable group and E a locally compact metrizable space on which G acts continuously. For each pair of subsets K, L in E let P(K, L) denote the set of all s E G such that (s . K) n L # 0. (a) Show that if K is compact and L is closed in G, then the set P(K, L) is closed in G. The group G is said to act properly on E if P(K, L) IS a compact subset of G whenever K and L are compact subsets of E. (This will always be the case if G is compact.) (b) Show that, if G acts properly on E, then F . K is closed in E whenever F is closed in G and K is a compact subset of E. In particular, for each x E E, the orbit G * x is closed in E. (c) Under the same hypotheses, for each x E E the stabilizer S, of x is a compact subgroup of G, and the canonical map G/S, + G . x is a homeomorphism. (d) Under the same hypotheses, the orbit space E/G is Hausdorff. 2.
For each pair (a,t) of real numbers such that a 2 1, the pointf.(r) follows : if
t
<
-
E RZ is
defined as
L
a + 1’
Let C , denote the set of pointsf.(?) ( r E R) and let E be the union of the sets C . (a2 1) and the lines D’, D”, where D’ (resp. D”) is the set of points (f, - 1) (resp. (f, 1)) with tER. The additive group R acts on the locally compact space E as follows: (1) s . ( t , - 1) = (s t , - 1); (2) s . f ( r ) = f ( s + t ) for a 2 1 ; (3) s . ( t , 1) = ( t - s, 1). Show that R acts continuously and freely on E, that the orbits R * z are closed sets and that the canonical mapping R + R . z is a homeomorphism, but that the orbit space E/R is not Hausdorff.
+
3. The group 2 acts continuously and properly on R2 as follows:
n ‘( x , Y ) = ((- 1Yx, y
+ 2n).
The orbit space M (the Mubius strip) is metrizable and locally compact. If r :R2 -+ M is the canonical mapping, the restriction of r to E - D” (notation of Problem 2) is injective, and r ( E - D”) = n(E) is locally compact. The group R acts on r(E - D”) by the law s . r ( z ) = n ( s z) for all z E E - D”. Show that R acts continuously and
52
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
freely on w(E), that for each z E E the orbit R . ~ ( zis)closed in w(E), that the canonical mapping R + R . n(z)is a homeomorphism, and that the orbit space a(E)/R is separable, metrizable and locally compact; but that R does not act properly on n(E). 4.
In R 3 , let E be the union of the sets C, x {z}for a 2 1 and z 2 0 (notation of Problem 2) and the line Db and the lines D: for z > 0, where Db is the set of points (t, -1.0) with t E R , and D:(is the set of points ( t , 1, z) with t E R . The additive group R acts continuously on E as follows: (1) s . ( t , - 1,O) = (s f , - 1,O); (2) s . (f.(t), z)= (f.(s -tt ) , z ) ; (3) s . ( t , 1, z ) = ( t - s, 1, z). Show that the orbits of this action have the same properties as in Problems 2 and 3, and that the orbit space E/R is Hausdorff but not metrizable.
+
5.
Let E be a locally compact metrizable space and let G be a topological group acting continuously on E. Let w : E + E / G be the canonical map. Suppose that E/G is Hausdorff. (a) Let K be a compact subset of E and let U be an open neighborhood of K. Show that there exists a continuous mapping of E into [0,1] which takes the value 1 on w - ’ ( r ( K ) ) and the value 0 on the complement of a-‘(a(U)). (b) Deduce from (a) that there exists a continuous mapping of E/G into [0, 11, taking the value 1 on T ( K ) and the value 0 on the complement of w(U). (Show first that there exists a relatively compact open neighborhood U, of K in E such that 0, c U. Deduce that there exist two continuous mappings fi,fi of E into [0, t ] such that f i takes the value 4 on T-’(T(K)) and the value 0 on E - w-’(T(U,)),and fi takes the value 4 on T - ~ ( T ( ~ ~and ) ) the value 0 on E - T-~(T(U)). Consider the functionf, f2 Iterate this “interpolation” indefinitely and pass to the limit.) (c) If E is separable, show that there exists a sequence (U,) of relatively compact open sets in E such that the n(UJ form a basis for the topology of E/G. (d) Suppose that E is separable. Show that E/G is metrizable. (For each pair of indices m, n such that 0, c U., consider a continuous mappingf,. of E/G into [0, 11 which takes the value 1 on T(U,) and the value 0 on the complement of n(U,). Consider the continuous mapping x ~ ( f , . ( x ) ) of E/G into the product space RN N).
+ .
6. If M is a monoid with neutral element e , we define an action of M on a set E as at the beginning of (12.10). Suppose that E is a compact metric space and that, for each s E M, the mapping XHS . x is continuous. The closed orbit of x with respect to M is defined to be the set M * x ; it is stable under the action of M. Show that for each x E E there exists in M . x a minimal closed orbit Z (i.e., such that M . z = Z for all z E Z). (For each y E M . x let h(y) be the least upper bound, as t runs through M . y, of the distances from t to a closed orbit contained in M . t . Show that the greatest lower bound of the numbers h(y) with y E M . xis 0, by showing that otherwise E would not be precompact. -Deduce that there exists a sequence (y.) of points of M * x such that y , , , E M * y . and the
-
sequence (h(y.)) tends to 0. Now use the compactness of E to complete the proof.)
11. HOMOGENEOUS SPACES
Let G be a group, H a subgroup of G.Recall that the set of left cosets xH (resp. right cosets Hx)of H in G is denoted by G/H(resp. H\G). For each
11 HOMOGENEOUS SPACES
53
coset J = xH (resp. J = Hx) in G/H (resp. H\G) and each s E G, write s 3 = (sx)H (resp. 1 s = H(xs)). Then it is clear that G acts on the left (resp. on the right) on G/H (resp. H\G), and that this action is transitive. The set G/H (resp. H\G) together with this action of G is called the homogeneous space of left (resp. right) cosets of H in G. We shall work throughout with G/H. Everything we shall do can be transposed in an obvious way to apply to H\G. Let n denote the canonical mapping XHXH of G onto G/H. Clearly G/H is the set of orbits of elements of G for the right action (h, x ) w x h (12.10.13) of H on G. If G is a topological group, we can therefore topologize G/H with the topology defined in (12.10), which is called the quotient by H of the topology of G. If x, E G and if 3, = x,H is its image in G/H, we obtain a fundamental system of neighborhoods of 3 , in G/H by considering the canonical images in G/H of the neighborhoods V of x, in G (i.e., for each V, the set of cosets x H of the elements x E V, or equivalently the image of V (or of VH) under the canonical mapping n : G + G/H). Whenever we consider G/H as a topological space, it will always be this topology that is meant, unless the contrary is expressly stated. (12.11.1)
The group G acts continuously on G/H.
Let (so, a,) be a point of G x (G/H) and let xo be an element of the coset 3,, . Every neighborhood of so 3 , is of the form n(V), where V is a neighborhood of soxo in G . There exists a neighborhood U of so and a neighborhood W of xo such that the relations s E U and x E W imply sx E V; hence the relations s E U and 3 E n(W) imply s J E n(V).
-
-
(12.11.2) Let G be a topological group, H a subgroup of G. (i) G/H is Hausdorfl if and only if H is closed. (ii) G/H is discrete ifand only i f H is open. (iii) If H is discrete, then every x E G has a neighborhood V such that the restriction of n to V is a homeomorphism of V onto the neighborhood n(V) of n(x) = 3 in G/H.
(i) If G/H is Hausdorff, then { n ( e ) }is closed in G/H (12.3.4) and hence H = n-'(n(e)) is closed in G. Conversely, if H is closed in G, the set of pairs (x, y ) E G x G belonging to the same orbit under the action of H on the right is the set of (x, y ) such that x - ' y E H, and is therefore closed, being the inverse image of H under the continuous mapping (x, y ) w x - ' y . Hence G/H is Hausdorff (12.10.8). (ii) If G/H is discrete, the set (n(e)) is open in G/H and therefore H = n-'(n(e)) is open in G. Conversely, if H is open in G, then so is each
54
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
coset x H , and therefore { n ( x ) }= 7c(xH)is open in G/H (12.10.6). Hence G/H is discrete. (iii) Let U, be a neighborhood of e in G such that U, n H = { e } , and let V , be a symmetric open neighborhood of e such that V$ c.Uo (12.8.3). Then, for each x E G, the restriction of 7c to V = x V , is injective, because if h, h’ in H are such that xzh = xz’h’ with z , z’ in V,, we have h’h-’ = z ’ - l z E Vg c U, , so that h’ = h and z’ = z. Since the image under 71 of any open set in V is open in n(V) (12.10.6), and 7c is continuous, it follows that the restriction of I[ to V is a homeomorphism onto n(V). (12.11.3) Let G be a metrizable group, H a closed subgroup of G, and let d be a right-invariant distance dejning the topology of G (12.9.1). For any two points 1, j in G/H, put do(i,j ) = d(xH, y H ) (3.4). Then do is a distance
defining the topology of G/H. If G is complete (12.9.2), then G/H is complete with respect ro d o .
We remark first that if x E f and y
Ej
, we have do(f,j ) = d(x, yH). For
d(x,y H ) = inf d(x, yh) and therefore, for every h’ E H, we have d(xh’, yH)
=
hEH
d(x,y H ) by virtue of the right-invariance of d. Hence, for each z E G, we have ldo(f, i) - dO(3,ill
=
14%zH) - dcv, zH)I 6 4x9 Y )
by (3.4.2). Since this is true for all x , y in the respective cosets f, j , it follows that Id,(& 2 ) - do(j, i)l6 do(& j ) , which shows that do is a pseudo-distance on G/H. The relation do(f, 3 ) < r is equivalent to the existence of a point y E 3 such that d ( x , y ) c r . Since H is closed in G, this proves that do is a distance, and that if B(x; r ) is the open ball with center x and radius r (with respect to d ) , then its image under the canonical mapping n : G + G/H is the open ball with center n(x) and radius r with respect to do. Hence do defines the topology of G/H. Now suppose that G is complete. Let (1,)be a Cauchy sequence with respect to do. We shall show that, by passing to a subsequence of (1,)if necessary, we can reduce to the case where there exists a right Cauchy sequence (x,) in G such that n(x,) = 1,. Since by hypothesis the sequence (x,) converges, this will show that ( i nhas ) a cluster value and therefore converges (3.14.2), and hence that G/H is complete. There exists in G a denumerable fundamental system (V,) of neighborhoods of e such that V;,, c V, for all n (12.9.1 and 12.8.3). Let (&), be a sequence of real numbers > O such that the relation d(e, z ) < E, implies that z E V, . The hypothesis implies that we can define inductively a subsequence (Ank) of (a,) such that d o ( i n pin4) , < E~ for all p 2 k and q 2 k. Replacing the original sequence (1,)by (ink), we can therefore assume that d O ( i pkq) , < E, for
12 QUOTIENT GROUPS
55
all p 2 n and q >= n. Since d is right-invariant, this means that for all y E Rp the intersection of R, and the neighborhood V ,y is not empty. We can then define, by induction on n, a sequence (x,) in G such that x , E R , and x,, E V ,x, for all n. Hence it follows, by induction on p , that for all p > 0 we n ~ V n - V,2+1 1 ~ n c V , for have x,+*EV,+ p - 1 V n + p - 2 . . . V n t l V n ~ (because all n). Hence the sequence (x,) is a right Cauchy sequence in G. Q.E.D. Let G be a topological group, and let E be a topological space on which G acts continuously and transitively. Let x E E and let S, be the stabilizer of x in G; then (12.10.1) the continuous mapping h, : SHS * x of G into E, which by hypothesis is surjective, factorizes canonically as (12.1 1.4)
h, : G 2 G/S, 2 E,
where n, is the canonical mapping of G onto the homogeneous space G/S,, and f, is the bijection SS,H s x . It follows from (12.10.6) that f, is a continuous bijection, but it is not necessarily a homeomorphism (Section 12.12, Problem 2). (12.1 1.5) With the notation above, the bijection f, : G/S, -,E is a homeomorphism for each x E E if and only if there exists a point xo E E such that the mapping h,, : SHS * xo transforms each neighborhood of e in G into a neighborhood of xo in E.
In view of (12.10.6) we need only prove that the condition is sufficient. Notice first that each x E E can by hypothesis be written in the form x = t xo for some t E G. I f V is a neighborhood of e, it follows from the hypothesis that V . x = ( V t ) xo is a neighborhood of x, because we can write ( V t ) x o = t ( ( t - l v t ) . xo), and t -'Vt is a neighborhood of e in G (12.8.3), and ~ H Sy is a homeomorphism of E onto E, for each s E G (12.10.3). Since each open set in G/S, is the image under n, of some open set in G, it is enough to show that for each open set U in G, and each x E E, the set h,(U) =f,(n,(U)) = U * x is open in E. Now, for each t E U, the set t -'U is a neighborhood of e, and therefore ( t -'U) x is a neighborhood of x in E, from the first part of the proof. Hence U * x = t . ( ( t- ' U ) x ) is a neighborhood of t * x ; by (3.6.4), the proof is complete.
-
-
12. QUOTIENT GROUPS
If H is a normal subgroup of a group G, then xH = H x for each x E G and therefore the sets G/H and H\G are identical; and G/H has a group structure
56
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
(the quotient of G by H) for which the canonical mapping n : G -+ G/H is a homomorphism. (12.12.1) Let G be a topologicalgroup and H a normalsubgroup of G. Then the quotient by H of the topology of G is compatible with the group structure of G/H.
Let (,to,j o ) be a point of (G/H) x (G/H), and let xo (resp. yo) be an element of the coset f, (resp. jo).Every neighborhood of i o j 0is of the form n(U), where U is a neighborhood of xo y o . There exists a neighborhood V of xo and a neighborhood W of yo in G such that the relations X E V and y e W imply x y U. ~ Hence the relations , t ~ n ( V )and j ~ n ( W imply ) i j E n(U), and therefore the mapping ( i j,) ~ + , t jis continuous at the point (a,, yo). The proof of continuity of the map 2 w i - l is similar. Whenever we speak of the quotient G/H o f a topological group G by a subgroup H, it is to be understood that G/H carries the quotient topology. (12.12.2) Let G be a topologicalgroup and let H , K be two normal subgroups of G such that H 3 K. Then the canonical bijection cp : G/K -+ (G/H)/(K/H) is an isomorphism of topological groups.
We know that cp is the unique mapping which makes the following diagram commutative : G
A G/K
where n, d ,and n" are the canonical homomorphisms. The definition of a quotient topology (12.10) shows that a subset U of (G/H)/(K/H) is open if and only if n'-'(n''--'(U>)is open in G, that is, if and only if n-'(cp-'(U)) is open in G ; but this last condition signifies that cp-'(U) is open in G/K. Since cp is bijective, the result follows. (12.12.3) Let G be a topologicalgroup, H a normal subgroup of G , 71: G + G / H the canonical mapping, and A a subgroup of G. Then the canonical bijection of n(A) onto the quotient group AH/H is an isomorphism of topological groups.
This is a particular case of (12.10.7), applied to the right action (h, x ) ~ x of h H on G.
12 QUOTIENT GROUPS
57
There is also a canonical bijection II/ of the quotient group A/(A n H) onto the subgroup n(A) of G/H ;this bijection II/ is the unique mapping which makes the following diagram commutative: A
(1 2.12.4)
/n
b n o j
A/(A n H)+
n(A)
where n' is the canonical mapping and j : A + G the canonical injection. It follows from (12.10.6) that is continuous, but it is not necessarily bicontinuous (Problem 2). However:
(12.12.5) Let G be a metrizable group and H a compact subgroup of G . For each closed subgroup A of G , the canonical bijection II/ : A/(A n H) -+ n(A) is an isomorphism of topological groups. It is enough to show that the image under II/ of an arbitrary closed subset F of A/(A n H) is closed in n(A). Now n'-'(F) = B is a closed subset of A, hence closed in G , and $(F) = n(j(B)) = n(BH). But since H is compact, the set BH is closed in G (12.10.5) and saturated, hence n(BH) is closed in G/H (12.10) and therefore also closed in n(A).
(12.12.6) Let G,, G2 be two topological groups and HI (resp. H,) a normal subgroup of GI (resp. G 2 ) .Then the canonical bijection 0 : (GI
x G2)/(H, x H2)
-+
(G,/H,) x (G2/H2)
is an isomorphism of topological groups. This is an immediate consequence of (12.10.11 ) .
(12.12.7) Let G, G' be two topological groups and u : G -+ G' a continuous homorphism. Then u factorizes canonically as G 5 G/N 1;u ( ~2) G! where N is the kernel of u, p is the canonical homomorphism, and j the canonical injection. The mapping u is a continuous bijection (12.10.6(iii)), but is not necessarily bicontinuous. When u is bicontinuous, the homomorphism u is said to be a strict morphism of G into G ' ; for this to be the case, it is necessary and sufficient that for each neighborhood V of e in G, the set u(V) should be a neighborhood of e' = u(e) in u(G) (12.11.5).
58
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
PROBLEMS
1. (a) Let G be a topological group, K its identity component, H a subgroup of G contained i n K. Show that the connected components of the space G/H are the images of the connected components of G under the canonical mapping T : G + G / H . Show that K is the smallest of the subgroups L of G such that G/L is totally disconnected. (b) Let G be the additive subgroup of the Banach space d , ( N ) (7.1.3) consisting of the mappings nt-+f(n) such that f(n) E Q for all n E N and lim f ( n ) exists in R. The
"- uo
distance induced on G by that on d R ( N ) defines a topology compatible with the group structure of G , and with respect to this topology G is totally disconnected. Let H be the subgroup of G consisting of all f~G such that lim f(n) = 0. Show that H is closed n- m
in G and that G / H is isomorphic to R,and therefore connected. (c) Let G be a locally compact metrizable group, H a closed subgroup of G, and rr : G + G/H the canonical mapping. Show that the connected components of G/H are the closures of the images under T of the connected components of G. (Reduce to the case where G is totally disconnected, and use Problem 3 of Section 12.9.) 2.
In the additive group R,let H be the subgroup Z and let A be the subgroup 0Z, where 0 is an irrational number. Show that the canonical bijection A/(A n H) +(A H)/H is not an isomorphism of topological groups.
+
3. Let p be a prime number and let (GJ be an infinite sequence of topological groups all equal to the discrete group Z / p 2 Z .Let H. be the subgroup p Z / p 2 Z of G, . Let G be the subgroup of the product g r o u p n G. consisting of all x = (x.) such that xn E H. for all n
but a finite set of values of n. Let 23 be the set of neighborhoods of 0 in the product group H, = H c G. Show that W is a fundamental system of neighborhoods of 0
n
for a topology on G compatible with the group structure, and that in this topology G is metrizable and locally compact and G/H is discrete. Show that the homomorphism u : X H ~ Xof G into G is not a strict morphism of G into G, and that u(G)is not closed in G. 4.
Let G be a metrizable group, K a closed normal subgroup of G. If K and G/K are complete, show that G is complete.
5. (a) Let G be a topological group, K a normal subgroup of G. Show that if K and G/K have no small subgroups (Section 12.9, Problem 6), then G has no small subgroups. (b) Deduce from (a) that if H I , H 1are two normal subgrouos of a topological group G, such that G/H1 and G/H, have no small subgroups, then G/(H, n H,) has no small subgroups. 6. Let G be a connected, locally compact, metrizable group, K a compact normal subgroup of G , and N a closed normal subgroup of K, such that K/N has no small subgroups (Section 12.9, Problem 6). Show that N is a normal subgroup of G. (Observe that the hypothesis on K / N implies the existence of a neighborhood U of e in G such that xNx-' c N for all x E U.)
7. Let G be a connected metrizable group and H a compact normal commutative subgroup of G, with no small subgroups. Show that H is contained in the center of G .
13 TOPOLOGICAL VECTOR SPACES
59
(Observe that, if s is close to e in G, then the image of H under the mapping is close to e.)
xt-+sxs-'x-'
8. Let G be a locally compact metrizable group and H a closed normal subgroup of G , such that G/H is not discrete and has no small subgroups. Show that there exists a f continuous homomorphism f:R + G such that the composition R + G +G/H is nontrivial (see Section 12.9, Problem 7).
13. T O P O L O G I C A L V E C T O R SPACES
We shall adhere to the conventions of (5.1), so that all vector spaces under consideration have as field of scalars either the real field R or the complex field C. If E is a vector space over R (resp. C),a topology on E is said to be compatible with the vector space structure if the mappings ( x ,y ) - x + y of E x E into E, and (A, X ) H A X of R x E (resp. C x E) into E are continuous. A vector space endowed with a topology compatible with its vector space structure is called a topological vector space. Since -x = (- l)x, the conditions above imply that the topology is afortiori compatible with the additive group structure of E, and all the notions and properties established for topological groups in the preceding sections will apply in particular to topological vector spaces (provided of course that these properties are transcribed into additive notation). An isomorphism of a topological vector space E onto a topological vector space F is a linear bijection of E onto F which is a homeomorphism. If llxll is a norm on a vector space E, the topology on E defined by the distance IIx - yll is compatible with the vector space structure of E (5.1.5) and therefore makes E a topological vector space. Two equivalent norms (5.6) define the same topology. In a topological vector space E, the translations XHX a and the homotheties XH Ax ( A # 0 ) are homeomorphisms of E onto E, the inverse mappings being, respectively, the translation X H x - a and the homothety xwa-lx. In a vector space E over R (resp. C) a set M is said to be balanced if, for each x E M and each scalar A such that 1A1 =< I , we have Ax E M (in other words, if AM c M whenever 111 5 1). The set M is said to be absorbing if, for each X E E , there exists a real number a > 0 such that A X E M whenever (A16 a. Every absorbing subset of E generates the vector space E. For a balanced subset M of E to be absorbing, it is enough that for each x E E there should exist a scalar A # 0 such that Ax E M.
+
60
XI1 TOPOLOGY A N D TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
(1 2.13.1 ) In a topological vector space E, the absorbing balanced neighborhoods of 0 form a fundamental system of neighborhoods of 0.
For each xo E E, the mapping AH AxO of the scalar field into E is continuous at the point 0; hence, for each neighborhood V of 0 in E, there exists ct > 0 such that the relation 1 11 S CI implies Ax, E V. This shows that every neighborhood of 0 is absorbing. On the other hand, the continuity of the mapping (A, x) I--, Ax at the point (0,O) implies that, for each neighborhood V of 0 in E, there exists ct > 0 and a neighborhood W of 0 in E such that the relations 111 6 ct and x E W imply Ax E V. The union U of the sets 1W, where 1A1 6 CI, is clearly a balanced neighborhood of 0 in E, and is contained in V. Hence the result. Let F be a vector subspace of a topological vector space E. Then the topology induced on F by the topology on E is compatible with the vector space structure of F. Whenever we consider a vector subspace F as a topological vector space, it is always the induced topology that is meant, unless the contrary is expressly stated. The proof of (5.4.1) applies without any change and shows that F is a vector subspace of E. The definition of a total subset of E is the same as in (5.4). On the quotient vector space E/F, the quotient topology (12.11) is compatible with the vector space structure. For if n : E + E/F is the canonical mapping, let ( A o , 2,) be any point of R x (E/F) (resp. C x (E/F)) and let xo be any point of 2,. Then every neighborhood of 1, i o contains a neighborhood of the form n(V),where V is a neighborhood of 1, *yo.There exists a neighborhood U of A, in R (resp. C ) and a neighborhood W of x, in E such that the relations 1 E U and x E W imply Ax E V; consequently the relations 1 E U and R E n(W) imply 1i E n(V), and the assertion is proved. Whenever we consider E/F as a topological vector space, it is always with the quotient topology, unless the contrary is expressly stated. The criteria for continuity in a product ((3.20.15) and (12.5)) show immediately that if El, E, are two topological vector spaces, the product topology on El x E2 is compatible with the vector space structure of El x E, . The vector space El x E 2 , endowed with this topology, is called the product of the topological vector spaces El and E 2 . Proposition (5.4.2) and the definition of the topological direct sum of two subspaces are valid without modification for arbitrary topological vector spaces. If E is the direct sum of two subspaces F,, F, , and if p 1 : E + F, is the corresponding projection, then the kernel of p 1 is F, , and p1 therefore has a
13 TOPOLOGICAL VECTOR SPACES
61
canonical factorization E + E/F2% F,, where jl is a bijection. To say that E is the topological direct sum of F1 and F2 signifies that .jl is continuous (12.10.6), or equivalently that the inverse bijection, which is the restriction to F, of the canonical mapping n2 : E -+ E/F2 (and which is always continuous) is bicontinuous. (12.1 3.2) (i) Let E be a topological vector space and let H be a hyperp1ane.h E , with equation f ( x ) = 0. Then H is closed in E ifand only if the linear form f is continuous on E. (ii) Let E be a HausdorJf topological vector space over R (resp. C ) of finite dimension n. I f ( a i ) 1 6 i s nis a basis of E, the mapping
of R" (resp. C") onto E is an isomorphism of topological vector spaces. (iii) Let E be a topological vector space, M a closed vector subspace of E , and F a finite-dimensional vector subspace of E. Then M F is closed in E. In particular, if E is Hausdorf, every finite-dimensional vector subspace of E is closed in E. (iv) Let E be a topological vector space and let M be a closed vector subspace of finite codimension in E. Then every algebraic supplement N of M in E is a topological supplement.
+
We shall prove (ii) first. Since u is continuous and bijective, we have to show that u is bicontinuous, or equivalently (considering the inverse images under u of open sets in E) that if D is a Hausdorf topology compatible with the vector space structure of R" (resp. C"), and coarser than the product topology Do, then 0 = Do. Put JIxIJ= ~ u p l
62 XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
E/M is also Hausdorff (12.11.2), the canonical mapping of N onto E/M, which is linear and bijective, is bicontinuous by (ii) because both N and E/M are finite-dimensional. Next, consider (i). Iff is continuous it is clear that H = f - ' ( O ) is closed. The converse follows from (iv): if f ( a ) = 1, then the line D = Ra (resp. D = Ca) is supplementary to H and therefore a topological supplement; hence the mapping x - f ( x ) a is continuous, and by (ii) this implies the continuity off. Finally, to prove (iii), assume first that K = { O } . Then F is a locally compact metrizable subgroup by (ii), and we can apply (12.9.6). In thegeneral case, consider E/M and apply the characterization of closed sets in E/M (12.10). The result (ii) above may also be expressed as follows: on a finite-dimensional vector space (over R or C), there is a unique Hausdorfl topology compatible with the vector space structure (every endomorphism of the vector space R" (resp. C") being necessarily continuous with respect to the product topology). This topology is said to be canonical. (12.13.3) Let El, E, be two metrizable topological vector spaces, and assume that E, is complete. Let F, (resp. F,) be a dense vector subspace of El (resp. E,). Then every continuous linear mapping u : F, 4 F, has a unique extension to a continuous linear mapping U : El E, . If in addition E, is complete and u is an isomorphism (of topological vector spaces) of F, onto F, , then U is an isomorphism (of topological vector spaces) of E, onto E, . --f
In view of (12.9.4), we have only to show that U is linear, i.e., that U(Ax)= AU(x) for all x E El and all scalars A; but this is a consequence of the principle of extension of identities (3.15.2).
14. LOCALLY C O N V E X SPACES
Let E be a vector space over R or C. A seminorm on E is a mappingp of E into R which satisfies conditions (I), (III), and (IV) of (5.1). A norm is therefore a seminorm p such that p(x) # 0 for all x # 0 in E. If p is a seminorm on E, then d(x, y ) = p ( x - y ) is a pseudo-distance on E which is translationinvariant and such that d(Ax, Ay) = IAI d(x, y ) for all scalars A. (12.14.1) Let ( P ~ I) be ~ a family ofseminorms on a vector space E. u t h e upper envelope p = sup p m is finite on E, then it is a seminorm. a
14 LOCALLY CONVEX SPACES
63
For it is clear that p(Ax) = IAIp(x); also we have Pa(x for all
(Y
E
I , hence p(x
+ Y ) 5 P,(x>+ Pa(Y) 2 P ( X ) + P(Y) + y ) I_ p(x) + p(y).
(12.14.2) Let p be a seminorm on a topological vector space E. Then the following conditions are equivalent: (a) p is continuous; (b) ihere exists a neighborhood V of 0 on which p is bounded.
Clearly (a) implies (b). Conversely, if p ( x ) 5 a for all x E V, then for all xo E E and all x E xo + EV we have Ip(x) - p(xo)l 5 p ( x - xo) 5 a&,and therefore p is continuous on E. (12.14.3) Let ( p J a be any family of seminorms on a vector space E . Then the topology dejned by the pseudo-distances da(x,y ) = p,(x - y ) (12.4) is compatible with the vector space structure of E . In view of the definitions, the proofs are the same as in (4.1.l) and (5.1.5). The topology defined by the pseudo-distances d, is said to be defined by the family of seminorms ( p a ) a E Two I . families of seminorms on E are said to be equivalent if they define the same topology (cf. (12.14.12)). A topological vector space whose topology can be defined by a family of seminorms is said to be locally conuex. If (pa),, I is a family of seminorms defining the topology of a locally convex space E, we obtain a fundamental system of neighborhoods of 0 in E by considering the sets (12.14.3.1)
W((ui);r ) = { x E E (pa,(x)< r for
1 I_ i
5 n}
where runs through the set offinite families of indices belonging to I , and r is any real number > O . (12.14.4) Let E be a vector space and let (pa)a I be a family of seminorms on E. For the topology defined by the family (pa)to be Hausdorff, it is necessary and suficient that for each x # 0 in E there should exist an index CI E I such that Pa(x> 0.
+
This follows from (12.4.4). Hence a seminorm p on a vector space E is a norm if and only if the topology defined by this single seminorm is Hausdorff.
64 XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
(12.14.5) A locally convex Hausdorfspace whose topology can be defined by a denumerable family of seminorms is metrizable.
This follows from (12.4.6). A locally convex Hausdorff space E whose topology can be defined by a denumerable family of seminorms, and which is complete with respect to every translation-invariant distance on E (12.9.2) is called a FrPchet space. A Banach space (5.1) is therefore a Frtchet space.
Example (12.14.6) Let X be a separable, locally compact, metrizable space and let gC(X)denote the set of continuous mappings of X into C. Clearly qC(X) is a vector space over C. Let (U,) be a sequence of relatively compact open sets in X satisfying the conditions of (3.18.3). For each continuous function f E %,(X) and each integer n , let (12.1 4.6.1 )
It is immediately seen that thep, are seminorms on gc(X) (but they are not norms if X is not compact). Furthermore, for each f # 0 in Vc(X), there exists a point x E X such that f ( x ) # 0 and an integer n such that x E U,, hence p , ( f ) # 0. The locally convex space %,(X) so defined is therefore metrizable. Moreover, to say that a sequence (f,) in Vc(X) is a Cauchy sequence signifies(by virtue of (12.9.2)) that, for each integer n, the sequence of restrictionsf, I 0, is a Cauchy sequence in the Banach space %?,(on) (7.2.1), hence converges ungormZy in 0, to a continuous mapping g, of fr, into C. Since it is clear that gn+l10, = g,, there exists a continuous function fEV,(X) whose restriction to each U, agrees with the restriction of g n . Evidently lim p,(j”--fm) = 0 for all n, hence f is the limit of the Cauchy in+ m
sequence (f,).Thus we have proved that U,(X) is a FrPchet space. When X is compact, it is just the Banach space %?,(X)defined in (7.2). Moreover, (7.4.4) generalizes as follows: (12.14.6.2) The FrPchet space U,(X) is separable. More precisely, there exists a denumerable dense set in Uc(X) consisting of continuous functions with compact supports.
With the notation used above, for each integer n there exists a dense sequence (hmn)m21in the Banach space %,(On), by (7.4.4). By the TietzeUrysohn theorem (4.5.1) applied to the closed set 0, n in X, there
14 LOCALLY CONVEX SPACES
65
exists a continuous mapping gm, of X into C, with support containedin (and therefore compact) and agreeing with h,, on 0,. Consequently, for each E > 0, eachfE Wc(X) and each integer n, there exists an integer m such that p , ( f - g,) 5 E. Since the sequence of seminorms (p,,) is increasing, this proves the result, having regard to (12.14.3.1) and the definition of the topology on Wc(X). Remark (12.14.6.3) The proof shows also that if Supp(f) c U,, then f is the limit of a sequence of functions g, with supports contained in Un+l. (12.14.7) Let (pa)=E , be a family of seminorms on a vector space E. For each finite subset H of I, the function p H= sup pa is a seminorm on E (12.14.1). U€H
Since the set W((cc,); r ) defined in (12.14.3.1) is the set of all x E E such that pH(x)< r (where H is the set of the ai),it follows that the family of seminorms p H ,where H runs through all finite subsets of I, is equivalent to the family (pa).A set I' of seminorms on E is said to be directed if for each pair of seminorms p', p" belonging to r, there exists p E r such that p 2 sup(p', p"). It follows that the topology of a locally convex space can always be defined by a directed set of seminorms. Let E be a locally convex space whose topology is defined by a set r of seminorms. If F is a vector subspace of E, it is clear that the induced topology on F is defined by the restrictions to F of the seminorms belonging to r. The corresponding result for quotient spaces is the following: (12.14.8) Let E be a vector space, F a vector subspace of E, and n : E -,E/F
the canonical homomorphism. (i) Let p be a seminorm on E. For each 2 E E/F let
b(f)
(12.14.8.1)
= inf p ( z ) . ff(2)=*
Then p is a semi-norm on E/F. (ii) Ifr is a directed set of seminorms and ifE is endowed with the topology defined by r, then the quotient topology on E/F (12.11) is defined by the set of seminorms p , where p E r. (i)
We have
j ( A i ) = inf p(Az) = 1111 inf p ( z ) = 1A1 j ( i ) , ff(2)=*
ff(Z)=*
so that it remains to prove the triangle inequality. If i, 1; are elements of E/F
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
66
+
and u E i, u E 3, then p(u + u) 5 p ( u ) p(u) and therefore (as u + u E i+ j ) p ( i + 3) 5 p(u) p(v). Since (2.3.11)
+
inf
(P(U>
U € X . V E j
+ P ( U > > = rjw + l j ( J j ) ,
the proof of (i) is complete. (ii) Let r be a real number > O and let U be the set of all x E E such that p ( x ) < r. Then it follows immediately from the definition (12.14.8.1) that n(U) is the set of all iE E/F such that @ < r. Since ( ri is ) directed, the sets U, a s p runs through r and r runs through the set of real numbers > O , form a fundamental system of neighborhoods of 0 in E. Hence (ii) follows from the definition of neighborhoods in E/F (12.1 1). Whenever we consider E/F as a locally convex space, it is always the quotient topology that is meant, unless the contrary is expressly stated. (12.14.9) Every closed vector subspace of a Fre‘chet space is a Fre‘chet space. Every quotient of a FrPchet space by a closed vector subspace is a Fre‘chet space.
The first assertion follows from above and from (3.14.5), the second from (12.14.8) and (12.11.3).
Remark (12.14.10) Let E be a normed space and F a closed vector subspace of E.
Then (12.14.10.1)
((f(l = inf llzll
= d(0, f)
ZEX
(in the last expression, f is considered as a linear variety parallel to F in the vector space E) is a norm on E/F which defines the quotient topology, by virtue of (12.14.4), (12.14.8), and (12.11.2). Whenever we consider E/F as a normed space, it is always this norm that is meant, unless the contrary is expressly stated. More particularly, suppose that E is a Hilbert space. Then if F is a closed subspace of E, and if F’ = Pi ‘(0) is the orthogonal supplement of F (6.3.1), the bijective linear mapping F’ -+ E/F, the restriction to F’ of the canonical mapping TI : E + E/F, is an isometry. For by Pythagoras’ theorem we have /Jx’+- z)I2 = / ) X ’ ) )+~ ) ) z ) )for ~ all z E F and all x’E F’; hence llx’I) is the infimum of the norms of elements of x’ + F. We may therefore identify E/F with the Hilbert space F’.
14 LOCALLY CONVEX SPACES
67
(12.14.11) Let E , E’ be two locally conuex spaces. Let r be a directed set of seminorms defining the topology of E , and r’ a set of seminorms dejining the topology of E‘. Let u : E -+ E‘ be a linear mapping. Then thefollowing conditions are equivalent: (a) u is continuous; (b) for each seminorm p‘ E l-”, there exists a neighborhood of 0 in E on which the function x w p ’ ( u ( x ) )is bounded (or, equivalently (12.14.2), the seminorm p‘ u on E is continuous); (c) for each seminorm p’ E r‘,there exists a seminorm p E r and a real c p ( x )for all x E E. number c > 0 such that p‘(u(x))I 0
From the definition of the neighborhoods of 0 in E and E’, condition (c) implies that u is continuous at the point 0, hence everywhere (12.8.4). So (c) implies (a). The condition (a) implies that the function p’ u is continuous on E (because p’ is continuous on E’), hence (b). Finally, suppose that (b) is satisfied. Then by hypothesis there exist two numbers r > 0 and a > 0 and a seminorm p E r such that the relation p(z) 5 r implies p’(u(z)) 5 a. Let x be any point of E and Iet A be a scalar strictly greater than 0 such that p(Ax) = Ap(x) 5 r. Then p’(u(Ax))5 a, so that p’(u(x)) 5 a / L If p(x) = 0, we can take 1to be arbitrarily large, and therefore p’(u(x)) = 0; if p ( x ) > 0, we take 1= r/p(x), and then we have p’(u(x)) 5 (a/r) . p(x). So in either case the Q.E.D. condition (c) is satisfied, with c = a/r. 0
(12.14.11 . I ) Likewise, if u is a multilinear mapping of a product
El x E, x . * . x E, of locally convex spaces into a locally convex space E , the continuity of u implies that for each seminorm p‘ E r’ there exist neighborhoods V j of 0 in Ej (I S j S n) such that the function ( x l ,. . . , X , ) H P ’ ( U ( X ~ , . . . , x,)) is bounded in Vi x . * .x V,. If rj is a directed set of seminorms defining the topology of Ej (1 s j 5 n), this latter condition implies that there exist numbers a > 0, rj > 0 ( I 5 j 5 n) and seminorms p j E rj(1 5 j 5 n) such that the relations p j ( z j )5 r j (1 s j 5 n) imply p’(u(z,, . . . , z,,)) 5 a. Now let ( x l , . . . , x,) be any point of E, x . . . x En, and for each j let ,Ij > 0 be such that p j ( A j x j )= Ajpj(xj)5 r j ; then it follows that p’(u(xl, . . . , x,)) I a/A,A,.
. . A,
We deduce as above that ifpj(xj) = 0 for some indexj, then Aj may be chosen arbitrarily large, and hencep’(u(x,, . . . ,x,)) = 0. If on the other handpj(xj) # 0 for all j , we may take Aj = rj/pj(xj)for 1 S,j 5 n ; putting c = airl , . . r,,,
68
XI1 TOPOLOGY A N D TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
it follows that for each point ( x l , . . . , x,) in E l x
* * *
x
En,we have
Conversely, it is clear that if for each seminorm p' E r' there exist seminorms p j E rj and a real number c > 0 such that (12.14.11.2) is satisfied throughout E, x . * * x E n , then u is continuous at the point (0, . . . ,0). Now let (bl,. . . , b,) be an arbitrary point of El x * . . x E n , and write
u(x1, * .
*
9
xn) - ~ ( b 1.,. ., bn) = C
~
(
~
. . ., y n ) , 1
3
H
where H runs through the 2" - 1 proper subsets of { 1, 2, . . . , n}, and for each such H put y j = bj if j E H, and y j = x j - bj if j 4 H. Then it follows immediately that u is continuous at the point (bl, . . . , b,), i.e., u is continuous on El x x En. (12.14.12) On a vector space E , let and r' be two families of seminorms. Then the topology defined by r isfiner than the topology defined by r' if and of semionly $,for each seminormp' E r', there exists afinite,family(pi)15i6n norms belonging to r and a real number c > 0 such that p'(x) _I c . sup pi(x) i for aN x E E.
Apply (12.14.11) to the identity map u
=
l E (12.2.1).
(12.14.13) Finally, we remark that the notions of series and convergent series are defined in a topological vector space E just as in a normed space (5.2); propositions (5.2.2), (5.2.3), (5.2.4) and the fact that the general term of a convergent series tends to 0 remain valid without change. If E is locally convex and its topology is defined by a family ( p J of seminorms, then for a series with general term x, to converge in E it is necessary that, for each E > 0 and each scalar I , there should exist an integer no such that
for all n 2 no and q > 0. If E is a FrCchet space, this condition is also sufficient, as follows from Cauchy's criterion (12.9).
PROBLEMS
1. Let E be a vector space over R (resp. C) and let 8 be a set of subsets of E satisfying conditions (V,) and (V,,) of Section 12.3, Problem 3, together with the following: (EV,) Every set V E 8 is balanced and absorbing.
14 LOCALLY CONVEX SPACES
69
(EV,,) For all V E 23 and all h # 0 in R (resp. C), we have XV E B. (EVIII) For each V E B, there exists W E B such that W W c V. Show that there exists a unique topology on E, compatible with the vector space structure, for which 8 is a fundamental system of neighborhoods of 0.
+
2.
Let E be a vector space over R with a denumerable infinite basis (en), and let 5 be the set of aN balanced absorbing sets in E. Show that 5 does not satisfy axiom (EVIII) of Problem 1. (For each n > 0, let A. be the set of points
n 1=1
he, such that [tIl6 l/n for
1 5 i 5 n, and let A be the union of the sets A,, . Show that there exists no set M € 5such that M M C A.)
+
3. Let E be the vector space VR(R) of continuous mappings of R into R. For each continuous function m such that m(f) > 0 for all r E R,let V, denote the set offunctions YE E such that If(r)l 5 m(f) for all t E R. (a) Show that the V, form a fundamental system of neighborhoods of 0 in a topology .Toon E which is compatible with the additive group structure of E, but not with the vector space structure. (b) Let D be the vector subspace of E consisting of functions with compact support (12.6). Show that the topology Y induced by T oon D is compatible with the vector space structure of D, and is not metrizable. 4.
Let (EJaG1be any family of topological vector spaces, and E =
n E. the product a.1
vector space. Show that the product of the topologies of the Em(12.5) is compatible with the vector space structure of E. If each E. is locally convex and its topology is defined by a family of seminorms (p& Lm, then the topology of E is locally convex and is defined by the family of seminorms par pr. (for all a E I and all A E Le).In particular, every (finite or) denumerable product of Frkhet spaces is a Frkchet space. 0
5. Let p be a seminorm on a (real or complex) vector space E. Show that the set N of x E E such that p(x) = 0 is a vector subspace of E. The seminorm defined by (12.14.8.1) on E/N is a norm. Let E be a Hausdorff locally convex space whose topology is defined by a family (pa) of seminorms, and for each a let N. be the subspace of E consisting of those x E E for which p.(x) = 0. Show that E is isomorphic to a subspace of the product of the normed spaces E/N, (the norm on E/N. being i.). In particular. every Frkchet space is isomorphic to a closed subspace of a denumerable product of normed spaces. 6. A subset A of a vector space E over R is said to absorb a subset B of E if there exists a > 0 such that hB c A whenever 5 a. If E is a topological vector space, a subset
1x1
B of E is said to be bounded(with respect to the topological vector space structure of E) if every neighborhood of 0 absorbs B. (a) The closure of a bounded set is bounded. Every finite set is bounded. If A, B are bounded, then so are A u B and A B. If E is metrizable, every precompact set in E is bounded. (b) Suppose that E is Hausdorff. Then a subset B of E is bounded if and only if, for every sequence (x,,) in B and every sequence (A,) of real numbers tending to zero, the sequence (h.~.) tends to 0 in E. (c) Let (E.) be a family of topological vector spaces and E E. their product
+
=n 8
(Problem 4). Show that a subset B of E is bounded if and only if pra(B) is bounded in E. for each a.
70
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA (d) Let E, F be two topological vector spaces and f:E + F a continuous linear mapping. Then for each bounded subset B of E, the image set f(B) is bounded in F.
7. (a) Let E be a (real or complex) Hausdorff topological vector space. Show that, if there exists a bounded neighborhood V of 0 in E (Problem 6), the sets n-'V (n an integer > 0 ) form a fundamental system of neighborhoods of 0 in E, and consequently E is metrizable. If furthermore E is locally convex, then its topology can be defined by a single norm. (b) Let E be a metrizable locally convex space whose topology is defined by an increasing sequence ( p , ) of seminorms. Show that the topology of E can be defined by a single norm if and only if there exists an integer N such that, for all n 2 N, there exists a real number k. 2 0 for which pn 2 k n p N . (c) Let E be the real vector space of indefinitely differentiable real-valued functions on the interval I = [0, I ] in R.For each n 2 0 and eachfe E, put
(where Dof=f). Show that each p . is a norm on E and that the topology defined by the sequence of norms (p,) cannot be defined by a single norm (cf. (17.1)). (d) Let E be a Hausdorff locally convex space whose topology is defined by a sequence of seminorms but cannot be defined by a single norm. If d is a translationinvariant distance defining the topology of E (1 2.9.2) show that every set in E which is bounded in the sense of the topological vector space structure of E is bounded with respect to the distance d , but there exist subsets of E which are bounded with respect to d but are unbounded with respect to the topological vector space structure of E. 8. Let E be a metrizable topological vector space. (a) Show that every balanced subset of E which absorbs all sequences in E which converge to 0 is a neighborhood of 0 in E. Deduce that, if u is a linear mappingof E into a topological vector space F, and u transforms every sequence converging to 0 in E into a bounded sequence in F, then u is continuous. (b) Let (B,) be any sequence of bounded subsets of E. Show that there exists a sequence (A,) of nonzero scalars such that the union of the sets A,B. is bounded. 9. Let E be a topological vector space. A set b of bounded subsets of E is called a fundamental system of bounded subsets if every bounded set in E is contained in a set belonging to b. Show that, if E is a metrizable locally convex space whose topology
cannot be defined by a single norm, no fundamental system of bounded subsets of E is denumerable (use Problem 8).
10. Let (En)nslbe a sequence of normed spaces such that Elis not separable. Let F be a E,, such that pr.(F) = E, for each n. Show that there exists vector subspace of E
=n n
a real number 6 > 0 and a bounded sequence (x,,Jmal in F such that llprlxl- pr1xAl
28
whenever i # j . (Remark that, for each index n and each nondenumerable subset A of F, there exists a nondenumerable subset B of A such that pr.(B) is bounded in En.) Deduce that a Frkchet space is separable if every bounded subset is relariuely compact. 11. A subset A of a real or complex vector space E is convex if, whenever x and y belong to A and 0 5 A 6 1, we have kr + (1 - A)y E A (Section 8.5, Problem 9). It follows
71
14 LOCALLY CONVEX SPACES
that, if A is convex and ( x , ) ~ , < ,is,
n
1=1
I=1
is any sequence of n real numbers 2 0 such that chi= 1, we have
h l x , E A.
(a) Let E, F be vector spaces over R and letfbe an affire linear mapping of E into F. Then the image under f of any convex subset of E is convex, and the inverse image underf'of any convex subset of F is convex. In particular, if g # 0 is a linear form on E, then the half-spaces defined by one or other of the relations g ( x ) > a , g ( x ) 2 a (where a is any real number) are convex sets. (b) In a vector space E over R,the intersection of any family of convex sets is convex. If A, B are convex subsets of E and a , fl are any real numbers, then the set a A flB is convex. (c) Let (Ea)aE,be a family of vector spaces over R and let E E. be their product.
+
=n For each a, let A. be a nonempty subset of E.. Show that A =nA. is convex if and 01
a
only if each A. is convex. (d) In a topological vector space E, the closure A and the interior A of a convex set A are convex. If, moreover, A is not empty, then A is the closure of A, and A the interior of A. (e) In a topological vector space E, for a half-space { x : g ( x ) 2 a } (where g is a nonzero linear form on E) to be either closed or to have an interior point, it is necessary and sufficient that g should be continuous; in which case the hyperplane g ( x ) = a is the frontier of the half-space. 12. (a) Let E be a vector space over R and p a seminorm on E. Show that the set of x E E such that p ( x ) < 1 (resp. p ( x ) 2 1) is an absorbing symmetric convex set. Conversely, let A be an absorbing symmetric convex set in E, and for each x E E let p(x)= inf p. Show that p is a seminorm on E and that A contains the set of P>O
XEPA
points such that p ( x ) < 1 and is contained in the set of points such that p(x) 6 1. (b) Let E be a topological vector space over R, and p a seminorm on E. Then the set A = {x E E : p ( x ) 5 1 ) is closed if and only if p is lower semicontinuous on E. Also A has an interior point if and only i f p is continuous at the point 0, a n d p is then continuous throughout E. (c) Deduce from (b) that a topological vector space E is locally convex if and only if there exists a fundamental system of convex neighborhoods of 0 in E. The topology of a metrizable locally convex space can be defined by an at most denumerable family of seminorms. 13. Let E be a real vector space. If A is any subset of E, the convex hull of A is defined to be the smallest convex set containing A. If E is a topological vector space, the closed convex hull of A is defined to be the smallest closed convex set containing A ; it is also the closure of the convex hull of A. (a) Show that the convex hull of A is the set of all points h, x., where (x.) is any a
finite family of points of A, and the h, are real numbers 2 0 such that
h, = I .
(b) Suppose that E is a metrizable locally convex space. Show that the convex hull in E of a precompact set is precompact. If E is a Frechet space, the closed convex hull of a compact set is compact (cf. Section 13.4, Problem 13). 14. Let E be the real vector space of regulated functions f on I = [0, 11, continuous on the right at all f < 1 and such thatf(1) = 0. For each integer n > 0, let V, be the
72
XI1 TOPOLOGY A N D TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
set of all functions f~ E such that jt If(t)l'/* dt 5 l/n. Show that the sets V,, form a fundamental system of neighborhoods of 0 for a metrizable topology on E compatible with the vector space structure, that the sets V. are bounded with respect to this topology, but that the convex hull of each V, is the whole space E. (Observe that every function YE E can be written as f= )(g h) with g , h E E and
+
Deduce that every continuous seminorm on E is identically zero. In particular, if a linear form on E is continuous, it is zero. 15.
(a) Let E be a topological real vector space, H a nonempty convex open subset of E, and f a convex function (Section 8.5, Problem 8) defined on H. Show that f i s continuous on H if and only if there exists a nonempty open set U c H on which f is bounded above. In particular, every upper semicontinuous convex function on H is continuous on H. (b) Give an example of a convex function p, which is defined on a compact convex set K C RZ,lower semicontinuous and bounded in K, but not continuous at a frontier point of K. (Take K to be a closed disk with 0 as a frontier point, and apply the definition of Problem 12(a).) Hence give an example of a compact convex set A 3 K such that p can be extended to a convex function which is lower semicontinuous on A, but not bounded on A.
16. Let E be a Hausdorff locally convex space, X a locally compact separable metric space, d the distance on X , A a closed subset of X. and f a continuous mapping of A into E. (a) Show that there exists a denumerable covering (U.) of X - A, consisting of open sets U. c X - A, which is locally finite and such that, for every frontier point a of A and every neighborhood V of a in X, there exists a neighborhood V' c V of a with the property that each U,, which meets V' is contained in V. (For each x E X - A, consider the open ball with center x and radius #d(x, A), and use (1 2.6.1 ).) (b) Let (h,) be a continuous partition of unity on X - A subordinate to the covering (U,) (12.6.3). For each n let b. E U, and a, E A be such that d(b., am)5 2d(b,, A). Let g(x) = f ( x ) if x E A, and
d x )=
c h.(x)f(a.) I
if x E X - A. Show that g is a continuous mapping of X into E which extends f and is such that g ( X ) is contained in the convex hull (Problem 13) off(A).
17. Let E, F be two locally convex spaces, f a continuous linear mapping of E into F, and L a locally compact separable metrizable subspace of F such that f(E) n L is dense in L. For each continuous seminorm p on E and each E > 0, show that there exists a continuous mapping s : L -+ E such that p ( z - f ( s ( z ) ) ) E for all z E L. (Consider a locally finite denumerable open covering (U,) of L such that p(x' - x) 2 &e whenever x and x' lie in the same U,, a continuous partition of unity (h,) subordinate to (U"),and for each n a point a,,E U, nf(E). If b, ~ f - ' ( a . )show , that the function s defined by s(z)
=Cb,,h,(z) satisfies the required conditions.) I
15 WEAK TOPOLOGIES
73
15. WEAK TOPOLOGIES
(12.15.1) Let (E,),e I be a family of locally convex spaces, and f o r each a let Lm be a family of seminorms dejining the topology of E, . Let E = E,
n
be the product vector space, and for each a E I and each I (12.1 5.1 . l )
&(x)
= pal(prorx)
E L,
, put
UEE
for all x E E.
Then the pad are seminorms on E and dejine the product topology (12.5) on E. It is straightforward to check that the pLl are seminorms, and then the second assertion follows from the definition (12.5) of a product of uniformizable spaces. In particular, when all the E, are equal to the same locally convex space F, then the product topology on the vector space F' of all mappings of I into F is defined by the seminorms
f
HP ( f
(4)
where a E I and p belongs to a set r of seminorms defining the topology of F. This topology is called the topology of simple (or pointwise) convergence on the vector space F', or on any of its vector subspaces (cf. (12.5)). With respect to this topoiogy, each mapping f w f (a) (a E I) is a continuous linear mapping on F', and maps each open set in F' to an open set in F (12.5.2). The topology of simple convergence is Hausdorf if F is Hausdorff (12.5.7). A mapping t wft of a topological space T into F' is continuous with respect to the topology of simple convergence if and only if the mapping t w f , ( a ) of T into F is continuous, for each a E I (12.5.5). When F is a Banach space over K (= R or C) and T is an open subset of K", a mapping t wft of T into F' is said to be p times diferentiable (resp. indefinitely diferentiable, resp. analytic) with respect to the topology of simple convergence if, for each index a E I, the mapping t w f t ( a ) of T into F has the corresponding property. We shall be particularly concerned with the case in which F is the field of scalars K, and I is a vector space E over K. Let V be a subspace of KEwhose elements are linear forms on E. The topology of simple convergence on such a subspace V is called the weak topology; it is defined by seminorms (12.1 5.2)
f-
If(X>l,
where x runs through E. For each x E E, the mapping f ~ f l x is) a continuous linearform on V with respect to the weak topology. A sequence (f.)of elements
74
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
of V which converges to f E V with respect to the weak topology (i.e., is such that lim f,(x) =f ( x ) for all x E E) is also said to be weakly conuergent. On n-) m
the same principle, we shall speak of subsets of V being weakly closed (in V), weakly compact, etc. A subset B of KE is said to be weakly bounded if all the seminorms (12.15.2) are bounded on B, that is if sup I f ( x ) l < 00 for
+
JEB
all x E E. We shall also use the phrases weakly continuous (resp. weakly differentiable, weakly analytic) or scalarly continuous (resp. scalarly differentiable, scalarly analytic) in place of “continuous (resp. differentiable, analytic) with respect to the weak topology.”
If E is a locally conuex space (over K = R or C), the vector space of continuous linear forms on E is called the dual of E, and is often denoted by E’. If x’ E E is a continuous linear form on E, its value at a point x E E is often denoted by the expression (x, x’) or (x’, x) instead of x’(x). Since E‘ is a vector subspace of KE, it is endowed with the weak topology defined by the seminorms X ’ H I(x, x’)l. For each x E E, the function X ’ H ( x ,x‘) is a weakly continuous linear form on E’. If E is a FrCchet space and E, a dense vector subspace of E, then it follows from (12.9.4) and the principle of extension of identities (3.15.2) that the mapping X ’ H X ’ I E, is an (algebraic) isomorphism of the dual E‘ of E onto the dual Eb of E, . (12.15.3) Let E, F be two locally convex spaces, E‘ and F’ their respective duals, and u : E -+ F a continuous linear mapping. Then Y ‘ H Y ‘ u is a linear mapping of F’ into E’ which is continuous with respect to the weak topologies. 0
If y’ is a continuous linear form on F, then y’ u is a continuous linear form on E. Given x, E E, there exists yo E F such that (x,, , y’ u ) = ( y o , y’) for all y’ E F’, namely yo = u(x,); the continuity of the mapping y ’ y’ ~ u is therefore an immediate consequence of (12.14.11) and the definition (12.15.2) of the seminorms which define the weak topology. 0
0
0
, the linear mapping ‘u : F’ -+ E’ is called the We write y’ u = ‘ ~ ( y ’ )and transpose of the continuous linear mapping u. Thus we have 0
(u(x), Y‘> = (x, ‘4Y’))
(12.15.4)
for all x E E and y’ (12.15.5)
E
F’. Clearly
yu1
+ u2) = +
tU2,
‘(Au)= A . ‘u
for any scalar 1,and for any continuous linear mappings u l , u2 of E into F. If
15 WEAK TOPOLOGIES
75
v is a continuous linear mapping of F into a locally convex space G, then (12.15.6)
‘(0
0
u ) = 5.4 0 %.
The weak topology on the dual of a locally convex space is not metrizable in general (Problem 2). However, there is the following result: (12.15.7) Let E be a separable metrizable locally convex space. If H is any equicontinuous (7.5) subset of the dual E’ of E, then the weak closure of H in E‘ is a compact metrizable space in the weak topology.
We shall first prove the following lemma: (12.15.7.1 ) Let E be a metrizable vector space and F a normed space. In order that a set H of linear mappings of E into F should be eguicontinuous, it is necessary and suficient that there should exist a neighborhood V of 0 in E and a real number c > 0 such that IIu(x)I/I c for all x E V and all u E H.
(If E is normed, this condition is also equivalent to sup llull < +a UEH
by (5.7.1).)
The condition expresses that H is equicontinuous at the point 0. If this is the case, then for each xo E E and each x E xo EV,we have
+
IIU(4
for all u
E
- u(xo>ll= l l 4 X
- X0)Il
I EC
H, and therefore H is equicontinuous at xo .
In proving (12.15.7), we may first of all restrict ourselves to the case where H is weakly closed in E’. For if R is the weak closure of H in E’, the continuity of the mapping X’H ( x , x’) on E’ implies that if I(x, x ’ ) ] 5 c for all x E V and all x’ E H, then also I(x, x’)l 5 c for all x E V and all x’E R (3.15.4), whence the result by (12.15.7.1). Now let (a,,) be a sequence which is dense in E. We shall show that the weak topology on H is defined by the pseudo-distances
d,,(x’, y’) = I & , ,
x’ - Y Y .
Clearly the topology defined by these pseudo-distances is coarser than the weak topology; hence it is enough to show that it is alsofiner. By hypothesis, every neighborhood of a point xb E H in the weak topology contains a subset W of H consisting of elements x’ E H satisfying ajinite number of inequalities (12.15.7.2)
[ ( x i ,x’- xb)l < r
(1
5 i 5 m)
76
XI1 TOPOLOGY A N D TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
where the x i are points of E, and r > 0. Suppose that H satisfies the condition (12.15.7.1). Choose E > 0 such that ~ E < C +r. For each index i, there exists an a,,(i)such that x i - a,,(i)E EV. By virtue of (12.15.7.1), it follows that for each xf E H we have [ ( x i - a,,(i),xf - xb)l
5~
< +r,
E C
and the relations x’ - xb)l < f r therefore imply the inequalities (12.15.7.2). Since the weak topology is Hausdorff, we have shown that H is metrizable (12.4.6). More precisely, the above argument shows that the map~ H into the product space KN (where K = R or C) ping x’t-+((a,, x ’ ) ) , , ~of is a homeomorphism of H onto a subspace L of KN.So it remains to be shown that L is compact. In the first place, the projections of L are boundedsubsets of K (and therefore relatively compact ((3.17.6) and (3.20.16))): for each index n there exists A,, > 0 such that AnanE V and therefore [(a,,, x’)l 5 c/A,, for all x’ E H. By virtue of (12.5.9), (12.5.4), and (3.17.3), it remains to be shown that L is closed in KN.Now if (xh) is a sequence of points in H such that for each n the sequence ((a,,, ~ k ) ) , , , > converges ~ in K, then it follows from (7.5.5) that the sequence (xk) converges simply in V. Since for each Z E E there exists a scalar y such that yz E V (so that (z, x i ) = y-l(yz, xh)), the sequence (xh) converges simply in E: its limit y’ is a linear mapping, by the principle of extension of identities, and is continuous by (7.5.5), and is therefore a point Q.E.D. of H. We recall that if E is a normed space, its dual E’ = 2 ( E ; K) is a Banach space with respect to the norm IIx’II = sup I(x, x’)l (5.7.3); since IIXII 5
1
I ( x , x’)I 5 ((x(( I(xf((, the topology defined by this norm (sometimes called the strong topology on E‘) isjner than the weak topology on E’.
(12.15.8) Let E be a normed space. The mapping X’H I(x’I( of E’ into R is lower semicontinuous with respect to the weak topology.
For it is the upper envelope of the weakly continuous mappings
x’H((x, x’)], where x runs through the ball (1x115 1 in E. Hence the result follows from (12.7.7).
If (x;) is a sequence in E’ which converges weakly to a’, then by (12.7.13) we have (12.15.8.1)
lim inf (lxLll 2 Ila’ll. n-tm
15 WEAK TOPOLOGIES
77
(12.15.9) Let E be a separable normed space. Then every closed ball B': IIx'II
5 r in E' is metrizable and compact with respect to the weak topology.
By (12.15.7) and (12.15.7.1) it is enough to show that B' is weakly closed, and this follows from the fact that the function x ' w llx'II is lower semicontinuous on E' (12.7.2). Now let E be a Hilbert space (6.2). For each x E E, let j ( x ) denote the continuous linear form y ~ ( I x) y on E. It follows from (6.3.2) that X H ~ ( X ) is a semilinear isometry (i.e., we have Axl
+ x2) = j(xl> +Ax2),
j(Ax) = JAx)
for all scalars A) of E onto its dual E'. We can therefore " transport" to E the weak topology on E': the weak topology on E is therefore the topology defined by the seminorms x ~ l ( a l x ) as l a runs through E. This topology is coarser than the topology defined by the norm on E (which is called the strong topology of the Hilbert space E). From (12.15.9) we have: (12.15.10) In a separable Hilbert space, every closed ball is metrizable and compact with respect to the weak topology.
If u is a continuous endomorphism (with respect to the strong topology) of a Hilbert space E, then by virtue of (12.15.4) and (11.5.1) MX)
I Y ) = (u(x), iW> = ( x , ' 4 A Y ) ) ) = (x l~-1(r4AY)N) = (x I U*(Y))
for all x, y in E , and therefore (6.3.2) (12.15.11)
u*
=j-1
o'uoj.
This relation shows immediately that 'u is strongly continuous and that = IIu*II = (lull.Replacing u by u* in (12.15.11), we see that every strongly continuous endomorphism of E is also weakly continuous (cf. (12.16.7)).
II'uII
(12.1 5.12) In a Hilbert space E , a sequence (x,) converges strongly to apoint a
if and o n b if it converges weakly to a and lim llxnll = Ilall. n+ w
The conditions are clearly necessary. To see that they are sufficient, consider the formula IIX,
- allZ = IIXnII' - 29W, I a) + IIaI12.
Since by hypothesis the sequence ((x, 1 a))converges to (a I a ) = 11a1I2,it follows that IIx, - all tends to 0.
78
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
PROBLEMS 1. Let E be a vector space over K (= R or C) and let F be a vector subspace of KEwhose elements are linear forms on E. We write ( x , x ’ ) in place of x’(x) for x E E and x’ E F. Given a finite sequence ( x i ) l 6 l a n of elements of F, show that for this sequence to be free (A. 4.l)it is necessary and sufficient that there should exist n vectors x1 (1 i 5 n) in E such that ( x , , x ; ) = (Kronecker delta). The vector space E is then the direct sum of the subspace V of dimension n generated by the X I , and the subspace W of all x E E such that ( x , x i ) = 0 for 1 5 n. A linear form x’ E F is such that ( x , x’> = 0 for all x E W if and only if x’ is a linear combination of the x { . (Prove these assertions simultaneously by induction on n.)
s
sr,
is
2.
The notation and hypotheses are the same as in Problem 1. Suppose also that there exists no vector x # 0 in E such that ( x , x ‘ ) = 0 for all x’ E F. (a) Show that the weak topology on F is metrizable if and only if E has an at most and ( z , ) ~ ~are , ~ two ~ finite denumerable basis (A. 4.1). (Observe that if (yf)161sm sequences of vectors in E such that the relation sup I ( y l , x’)l 5 1 implies the relation
sup I (z,,
x’)l
51
ISl6rn
in F, then the z, are linear combinations of the y , .
16J6n
Show that if we have ( y , , x’) = 0 for 1 5 i 5 m,then we must also have (z,, x ’ ) = 0 for 1 6j 5 n, and apply the result of Problem 1 by identifying E with the set of linear forms X‘H ( x , x’) on F.) (b) Deduce from (a) that, in an infinite-dimensional separable Hilbert space, the weak topology is not metrizable (cf. Section 5.9, Problem 2). (c) Show that every linear form on F which is continuous with respect to the weak topology can be written x ’ w ( x , x ’ ) for a uniquely determined x E E (argue as in (a)).
3. (a) In a Hilbert space E, let A be a closed convex set (Section 12.14, Problem 11) and a a point of E. Show that there exists a unique point b E A such that d(a, A) = d(a, b) (the projection of a on A). For each z E A show that (z - b I b - a) 20 (argue as in (6.3.1)). (b) Deduce from (a) that every closed convex set A in E is the intersection of closed half-spaces whose frontiers are hyperplanes of support of A (Section 5.8, Problem 3). Deduce that A is weakly closed, and that if C is any convex subset of E, the strong and weak closures of C are the same. Every bounded closed convex subset of E is weakly compact. (c) Show that the weak closure in E of the sphere S : ((xi(= 1 is the ball ( / X I / <= 1. A subset of S is compact in the weak topology if and only if it is compact in the strong topology (use (1 2.1 5.12)). (d) Let U be a nonempty convex open set in E. Show that, if a is any frontier point of U, there exists a closed hyperplane of support of U passing through a (Hahn-Banach theorem for a Hilbert space). (Consider a sequence (a”) of points exterior to U, converging to a, and for each n let b. be the projection of a. on U defined in (a). Put u, = (b. - an)/llbn-- a,/l, and show that the sequence (u.) has a subsequence which converges weakly to a point u # 0, by using the fact that U has a n interior point c , and that this implies a relation of the form (c - bn I u,) 2 r > 0 for all n.) (e) Suppose that E is separable, and let (en)nblbe basis (6.5.2) of E. Let A be the closed convex hull (Section 12.14, Problem 13) of the set of points e./n. Show that A is compact and that the interior of A is empty, and that A has no closed hyperplane of support containing the (frontier) point 0, although there exist lines D passing through 0 and such that D n A = {O}.
15 WEAK TOPOLOGIES
4.
79
Let E be a separable real Frechet space a n d p a continuous seminorm on E. (a) Let (an)n2O be a total (12.13) free sequence in E, and let E. be the subspace of dimension n 1 generated by a o , a ] , . . . , a,. Show by induction on n that for each n there exists a linear formf, on E, such that f. is the restriction of fn+] to En, fo(ao)= p ( a o ) and fn(x) s p ( x ) for all x E E.. (Consider the hyperplane H in given by the equation f n - l ( x )=fn -l(ao), and use Problem 3(d) in the plane which is the quotient of E, by the hyperplane Ho : j m - I ( x= ) 0 in En-l.) (b) Deduce from (a) that there exists a continuous linear form f o n E such that f ( a 0 ) =p(ao) and If(x)i s . p ( x ) for all x E E (Hahn-Banach theorem for a separable Frechet space). In particular, if E is a separable Banach space, then for each x E E we have
+
IIX II = S U P I <x, Y’> I IlY’ll s I (the norm on the dual E being that defined in (5.7.3)). Deduce that if E and F are separable Banach spaces, E and F’ their duals, and u : E -+ F a continuous linear mapping, then llfu/1= IIu/l. (c) Deduce from (b) the geometrical form of the Hahn-Banach theorem: given any nonempty convex open set A in E, and a point x o $ A, there exists a closed hyperplane with equation g ( x ) - a = 0 such that g(x) > a for all x E A, and g ( x o ) 5 a. (Reduce to the case where 0 E A and x o is a frontier point of A. We can then assume that A is symmetrical about 0 and therefore is the set of all x such that p ( x ) < 1 , where p is a continuous seminorm on E.) (d) Let A, B be two disjoint closed convex sets in E, one of which (say, A) is compact. Show that there exists a closed hyperplane H, with equation g(x) - a = 0, which strictly separates A and B: that is to say, such that g ( x ) > a for all x f A and g ( x ) < a for all x E B. (e) Deduce from (d) that every closed convex set in E is an intersection of closed half-spaces, and that every closed linear variety in E is an intersection of closed hyperplanes. (f) Deduce that for a vector subspace F not to be dense in E it is necessary and sufficient that there should exist a continuous linear formff 0 on E such that f ( x ) = 0 for all x E F.
5. Let A be a convex set in a real vector space. A point a E A is said to be an extremal point of A if there exists no line-segment containing more than one point, which is contained in A and has a as an interior point: in other words, if the relations b E A, ~ E Aa ,= X b $ ( l - & c , O < h < l imply b = c = a .
(a) Let E be a Hilbert space, A a bounded closed convex set in E, 6 > 0 the diameter of A, and a, b two points of A such that Ilb - all 2 &dE. 6 . Show that there exists a supporting hyperplane H of A orthogonal to the vector b - a and such that the set H n A has diameter 548. (b) Deduce from (a) that A has at least one extremal point (proof by induction). (c) Show that A is the closed convex hull of the set of its extremal points (KreinMilman fheorem for Hilbert space). (First deduce from (b) that every closed hyperplane of support of A contains at least one extremal point. Then argue by contradiction, assuming that the closed convex hull B of the set of extremal points of A is distinct from A; by using Problem 4(e), show that there would then exist a hyperplane of support of A which did not meet B.) (Cf. Section 13.10, Problem 8.)
80
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
(d) If C is a convex set in E, the intersection of C with a closed (resp. open) halfspace is called a closed (resp. open) cap in C . If a E A is an extremal point, show that the open caps in A which contain a form a fundamental system of neighborhoods of a in A. (Remark that the convex hull of the union of two closed caps in A is weakly compact and does not contain a if neither of the two closed caps contains a ; then use Problem 4(e), and Section 12.3, Problem 6(e).) (e) Suppose that there exists a weakly compact set K c A such that the closed convex hull of K is A. Show that every extremal point of A belongs to K (use (d)). (f) In the Banach space (co) (Section 5.3, Problem 5) show that the closed ball llxll 1 has no extremal points. 6. Let E, F be two locally convex spaces. Let (p.) be a family of seminorms defining the topology of F, and let 6 be a set of bounded subsets of E (Section 12.14, Problem 6). For each continuous linear mapping u of E into F, and each B E (5, put p., .(u) = supp.(u(x)). Show that p., is a seminorm on the vector space P ( E ; F) of conZ€B
tinuous linear mappings of E into F. If the set of homothetic images of the sets of 6 covers E, then the topology defined by the seminorms p a , on 9 ( E ; F)is Hausdorff. If E and F are normed spaces and if 6 consists only of the closed unit ball /\XI\ 5 1 in E, then the corresponding topology on 9 ( E ; F) is that defined by the norm (5.7.1).
7. Let E be an infinite-dimensional separable Hilbert space. Show that, with respect to the topology defined by the norm (5.7.1) on P ( E ; E) (this topology is called the norm topology), the unit ball V consisting of the operators U with norm l\Ul\ 1 (the "contractions" of E) is not separable. (Let (en),>,, be an orthonormal basis of E. For each point z = ({.).20 of the Banach space 1" (Section 5.7, Problem l), let U,E 9 ( E ; E) be the mapping defined by U,. en= [.en for all n 2 0. Show that zt-+ Uzis an isometric linear mapping of I" onto a subspace of 9 ( E ; E), and use the Problem of Section 5.10.) 8. Let E be a separable Hilbert space of infinite dimension. The strong topology on P(E; E) is that obtained by the procedure of Problem 6 by taking (5 to be the set of all finite subsets of E, so that this topology is defined by the seminorms p,(U> = llU. x(I for all x E E. The strong topology is coarser than the norm topology.
(a) Show that the strong topology is not metrizable. (Observe that 9 ( E ; E) contains vector subspaces which, when given the topology induced by the strong topology, are isomorphic to E endowed with the weak topology.) (b) The unit ball V of 9 ( E ; E), endowed with the strong topology, is separable and metrizable. (Proceed as in (12.5.7), by embedding V in EN.) (c) Show that the mapping (U,V ) w UV is continuous in the strong topology on Q x 9;p(E;E) and not continuous on 9(E: F,)X Q. (d) Show that the mapping UHU' of V into V is not continuous with respect to the strong topology. (Let (en)nzObe an orthonormal basis of E, and consider the sequence of operators uk such that uk * e, = 0 if n < k and U k. e . = en-k if n 2 k . ) (e) Let U(E) c V be the unirury group of E, consisting of all linear isometries of E onto E. Show that the topology induced on U(E) by the strong topology is compatible with the group structure. Give an example in this group of a right Cauchy sequence which is not a left Cauchy sequence. Show that U(E) is closed in V. 9.
Let E be a separable Hilbert space of infinite dimension. The weak ropology on Y(E; E) is that obtained by the procedure of Problem 6 by takingG to be the set of
16 BAIRE'S THEOREM A N D ITS CONSEQUENCES
81
finite subsets of E, but taking E with the weak topology, so that this topology is defined by the seminorms p x ,,(U)= I (U . x I y ) 1 for all x , y in E. This topology is coarser than the strong topology. (a) Show that the weak topology is not metrizable (same methodas in Problem 8fa)). Ib) The unit ball Q in Y(E; E) is metrizable and compact in the weak topology (method of (12.5.7)). (c) The bounded sets in 9 ( E ; E) are the same for the weak topology as for the strong topology. (d) The mapping U H U * of Y(E; E) into itself is continuous with respect to the weak topology. (e) Show that the mapping (U, V ) 4 U V of V x V into V is not continuous for the weak topology. (IF is a Hilbert basis of E indexed by Z, consider the "shift operator" U defined by U .en = en+l for all n E Z, and its powers U" and U+.) The topology induced on the unitary group U(E) by the weak topology is identical with that induced by the strong topology, and hence is compatible with the group structure. Also U(E) is not closed in G9 for the weak topology. (f) Show that, for each Uo f Y(E; E), the linear mappings VH Uo V and V++ VUO are continuous on Y(E; E) for the weak topology. (9) Let uly be a submonoid of V (i.e., uly is stable under multiplication). Show that the closure of uly with respect to the weak topology on 9 ( E ; E) is a compact monoid, which is commutative if uly is commutative. 10. The notation is the same as in Problem 9.
(a) Let U E Q. Show that the relations U * x = x , (x [ (I.x ) = (x [ x), and U* . x = x are equivalent. (b) Deduce that the idempotent operators in are the orthogonal projections (Sections 6.3 and 11.5.)
11. Let E be a separable Hilbert space, A a submonoid containing the identity l E which is weakly closed (and therefore weakly compact) in V (notation of Problem 8). For each x E E, the orbit of x under A is the set .I. n of vectors U * x where U E 4; it is weakly compact in E. We say that x is a flight vector with respect to uly if 0 E uly * x, and that x is a reversibfe vector with respect to &if for each U EX there exists V E X such that VU . x = x . Let F(uly) (resp. R(uly)) denote the set of flight (resp. reversible) vectors with respect to uly. If x is reversible, then IIU .xII = llxll
for all U E A. (a) Every orbit uly * x contains a minimal orbit N (Section 12.10, Problem 6), and every y E N is reversible with respect to uly. Let U E uly be such that U . x = y E N, and let d be the weakly closed submonoid generated by l E and U : this submonoid d is Commutative. Let P C d . y c N be a minimal orbit with respect to d , and let V E d be such that V .y = z E P. Show that there exists W E d such that VU W . z = I;deduce that the vector x - W . z is a flight vector, and hence that every x E E is the sum of a flight vector and a reversible vector belonging to A * x . (b) Show that if x E E is reversible with respect to X then x is also reversible with respect to every weakly closed submonoid M . (Split up x into the sum of a vector y E R( N)belonging to N . x and a vector z E F(N);use the fact that if a , b are two b)ll <: llall = llbll, and deduce distinct vectors in E with the same norm, then II& that y = x . ) Deduce that if x E R ( 4 , then given any U E uly there exists an element V in the weakly closed submonoid of A generated by l E and U, such that
+
vu.x=x.
82
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
(c) Let X * be the monoid consisting of the adjoints U* of the operators U E X ; then A* is weakly compact (Problem 9(d)). Show that R(.X) and F(X*) are orthogonal supplementary vector subspaces of E. (Use (b) to reduce to the case where -4 is commutative.) Ileduce that F(X) is stable under X . (d) Let ( x , ) ~ be~ a, finite ~ ~ sequence of vectors in E. For each i, let x , = y , z i , where y , E R ( A ) and z, E F(X). Use (c) to show that there exists U E X such that U zi = 0 (1 6 i 5 n), and then prove that there exists U EX such that VU . y , = y , for 1 2 i 2 n. (Consider the space En and the image A’ of X in Y(E”; E“) consisting of the operators (tl, . . , t.)++(T. t , , . . , T.1.) where T EA, and use the fact that R ( X ) is a vector subspace.) Deduce that the set P(xl, . . ., x.) of operators W EX such that W * x, = W .y , = y , for 1 5 i 5 n is not empty, and then that the intersection of all these sets (where (xi) varies over all finite sequences of vectors in E) is nonempty (Section 12.3, Problem 6(e)). Finally, deduce that the projection P : E -+R(X) corresponding to the direct sum decomposition E = R(M) @ F(X) belongs to X and hence to V, and use Problem 10 to conclude that R(A) and F(XrU’) are orthogonal supplementary vector subspaces (“ Jacobs’ theorem ”). (e) Show that for each U E X there exists V E X such that VU . y = y for all y E R ( X ) (same method as in (d)). In other words, the image 59 of X under the mapping UH U I R ( X ) is a subgroup o f t h e unitary group U(R(-kl)). Show that the orbits of this subgroup are strongly compact in R ( X ) (cf. Problem 3(c)) and deduce that B is strongly compact in Y ( R ( X ) ;R(-4)). (f) Let be an orthonormal basis of E, and let X be the weakly compact submonoid of V generated by the unitary operator U defined by U .en= e n + , for all n E Z. Show that F ( 4 = E and R ( 4 = {O}.
+
.
.
12. In the notation of Problem 9, let X be any submonoid of V, containing l E . For each x E E, let I’(X . x ) be the closed convex hull of the orbit of x under 4.
(a) Show that r ( X .x) contains a X-invariant point (cf. Problem 3(a)). Deduce that, if @ ( X )denotes the set of .A-invariant vectors and Q ( X )the set of x E E such that 0 E I ’ ( X . x), then every vector in E can be written as the sum of a vector belonging to @(A) and a vector belonging to n(X). (b) Show that @(A) and Cl(X*)are orthogonal supplementary vector subspaces and n ( X )are orthogonal supplementary of E. Use Problem 10 to deduce that @,(A) vector subspaces of E. Deduce that l?(X. x) contains only one 4-invariant point. (c) Deduce from (b) that, for each contraction U E V and each vector x E E, the limit
exists and is invariant under U (“von Neumann’s ergodic theorem”). 13.
(a) Let E be a vector space over R or C , and let V be a vector space of linear forms on E, endowed with the weak topology. Let A be a weakly closed convex set in E, such that 0 4 A. Show that there exists a weakly closed hyperplane H in V passing through 0, such that H is the set of a l l f e V for whichf(xo) = 0 for some xa # 0 in E, and such that g(xo) 2 0 for all g E A. (Use Problem 1 to reduce to the case where V is finite-dimensional, by observing that there exists a neighborhood of 0 containing a closed subspace W of finite codimension in V, and such that the projection of A on a supplement L of W in V does not meet a neighborhood of 0 in L. Then apply the result of Problem 3(a).)
16 BAIRE’S THEOREM A N D ITS CONSEQUENCES
83
(b) Deduce that, if A is a weakly closed convex set in E, and B is a weakly compact convex set disjoint from A, then there exists a weakly closed hyperplane H = { f V~: f ( x o ) = a}where xo # 0, such that g(xo) 2 a for all g E A, and h(xo)2 a for all h E B. (Consider the convex set A (-B).) (c) Deduce from (b) that for a vector subspace F not to be dense in V for the weak topology, it is necessary and sufficient that there should exist xo # 0 in E such that f(xo) = 0 for all f~ F.
+
14. In a Hilbert space E, let (xn) be a sequence which converges weakly to a point a.
Show that, for each point b f a ,
liminfIlx.-bll n-m
>lim infl/x.-all.
”-.
0)
16. BAIRE’S THEOREM A N D ITS CONSEQUENCES
(Baire’s theorem) Let E be a topological space in which eoery (12.16.1) point has a neighborhood homeomorphic to a complete metric space. If(U,) is a sequence of dense open sets in E, then the intersection of the U, is dense in E. It is enough to prove that, for each x E E and each neighborhood V of x, the intersection of V and the U, is not empty. Hence we may assume that E itself is a complete metric space and (bearing in mind (3.14.5)) prove that the intersection G of the U,, is nonempty. Let d be a distance defining the topology of E, with respect to which E is complete. We shall define by induction on n a sequence (x,) of points of E and a sequence (r,) of real numbers > O , as follows: x1 E U1; I , < l / n for each n >= 1 ; the closed ball B’(x,,; r,) is contained in U, n B’(xnWl;r,,-l). This is possible because U, n B(xn-l; r,,-l) is a nonempty open set in E, since U, is dense in E. Clearly we have d(x,, x,+,,) r, < l / n for each n 2 1 and each p > 0, and therefore (x,) is a Cauchy sequence in E. By hypothesis it converges to a point a E E, and since x,+,, E B’(x,; r,) for each p > 0, we have a E B’(x,; I,,) c U, for each n since B‘(x,; r,) is closed in E. The point a therefore belongs to G . Q.E.D. We shall apply Baire’s theorem mainly when E is an open subspace of a complete metric space or a locally compact rnetrizable space (by virtue of (3.16.1)). In a topological space E, a subset A is said to be nowhere dense if the open set E - i% is dense (or, equivalently, if A contains no nonempty open set, or if has empty interior). For example, in a Hausdorff space E, a set { a } consisting
84
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
of a single point is nowhere dense unless it is open, i.e., unless a is isolaied in E (3.10.10). In a topological group G, every closed subgroup H which is not open is nowhere dense (12.8.7). In a topological space E, a subset B is said to be meager if it is the union of at most denumerably many nowhere-dense sets. Since the closure of a nowheredense set is nowhere dense by definition, Baire's theorem can be restated in the form that, in a space E satisfying the conditions of (12.16.1), the complement of a meager set is dense in E. For example, in a Frtchet space E, a denumerable union of closed linear varieties, each distinct from E, i.e., sets of the form a, + V,, where V, # E is a closed vector subspace of E, has a dense complement in E. For it follows from (12.13.1) that a vector subspace V of a topological vector space E cannot be open in E unless V = E. In particular, a denumerable set in a Frtchet space is meager, but it should be noted that such a set may also be dense (if the space is separable). (12.16.2) Let E be a topological space in which every point has a neighborhood homeomorphic to a complete metric space, and let u be a lower semicontinuous function on E. Ifu(x) < + 00 for each x E E , then given any nonempty open set U in E there exists a nonempty open set V c U such that sup u(x) < 00. xov
+
It is enough to prove the result when U = E. For each integer n > 0, let F, be the set of all x E E such that u(x) 5 n. By hypothesis, F, is a closed set (12.7.2), and E is the union of the F,; hence at least one of the F, is not nowhere dense (12.16.1), and therefore contains a nonempty open set. Q.E.D. Notice that under the hypotheses of (12.16.2) it can happen that sup u(x) = xsE
+ 00.
Consider for example the real-valued function on R which is equal to 0 at x = 0, and equal to 1/x2when x # 0. In particular: (12.1 6.3) In a Fre'chet space E , every lower semicontinuous seminorm is continuous.
By definition, a seminorm p on E is finite at all points of E. If p is lower semicontinuous, it follows from (12.16.2) that there exists a point x,, E E, a
16 BAIRE’S THEOREM AND ITS CONSEQUENCES
85
neighborhood V of 0 in E, and a real number c > 0 such that p(x) 5 c for all
x E xo + V. Hence
P(Z)
for all z
E V,
5P b O )
+ P(X0 + z ) 2 c + P ( X 0 )
which proves the result (12.14.2).
(Banach-Steinhaus theorem) Let E be a Frkchet space, F a (12.16.4) normed space. Let H be a set of continuous linear mappings of E into F. Suppose that sup IIu(x)II < + co for all x E E . Then H is equicontinuous. ueH
The function p(x) = sup IIu(x)II, being finite for all x E E, is a seminorm usH
on E (12.14.1). Since each of the functions X H IIu(x)I[ is continuous, p is lower semicontinuous (12.7.7). The result therefore follows from (12.1 6.3) and (12.15.7.1).
As a consequence, we have: (12.16.5) (i) Under the hypotheses of (12.16.4), let (u,) be a sequence of continuous linear mappings of E into F which converges simply in E to a mapping u of E into F. Then u is a continuous linear mapping of E into F. (ii) More generally, let Z be a metric space, A a subset of Z , and z w u, a mappie3 of A into the space of continuous linear mappings of E into F. Let zo E Z be a point in the closure of A, and suppose that the limit
lim u,(x) = v(x)
z-+zo,zeA
exists in F, for each x E E. Then v is a continuous linear mapping of E into F .
(i) From the hypotheses we have sup IIu,(x)II < +co for all x
E
E, hence
n
the Banach-Steinhaus theorem shows that the sequence (u,) is equicontinuous, and the continuity of u follows from (7.5.5). The fact that u is linear is an immediate consequence of the principle of extension of identities. (ii) The point zo is the limit of a sequence of points (z,) in A (3.13.13), hence u(x) = lim U J X ) for all x E E. Now apply (i). n-tm
(12.16.6) Let E be a Frkchet space, F a Banach space, I an open interval in R. Let Y ( E ; F ) denote the space of continuous linear mappings of E into F , endowed with the topology of simple convergence (12.15). I f a mapping t t - f , of I into Y(E; F ) is diferentiable with respect to the topology of simple convergence (12.15), then there exists a mapping t H f j of I into 2 ( E ; F ) such that f ; ( x ) = D(f,(x))for all x E E.
86
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
For D(f,(x)) is the limit, as h # 0 tends to 0, of the mapping
h + + ( f r + h -fr)lh, and the result therefore follows from (12.16.5). The mapping f iois said to be the derivative at the point to of the mapping t w f , (with respect to the topology of simple convergence), or the weak derivative when F is the field of scalars (and therefore Y(E; F) = E’). Remark
(12.16.6.1) Let A be an open set in C and let Z H ~ , be a weakly analytic mapping (12.15) of A into the dual E’ of a complex FrCchet space F. Then the same argument as in (12.16.6) shows that there exists a weak derivative 2-f: of Z H ~ ,, with fL(x) = D(f,(x)) for all x E E, and this weak derivative is weakly analytic. Moreover, for each a E A and each circuit y contained in A - { a } , we have the Cauchy formula (12.16.6.2) Conversely, let y be a road in C defined in an interval I = [b, c ] in R,and let z H g , be a weakly continuous mapping of y(1) into E’. Then, for z # y(I), the mapping
(12.16.6.3) is a linear formf, on E, belonging to E’. Indeed, for each x E E the right-hand side of (12.16.6.3) is the limit of a sequence
where
((3.16.5) and (8.7.8)),hence our assertion is a consequence of the BanachSteinhaus theorem. By virtue of (9.9.2),f, is weakly analytic in C - y(I), and for a 4 y(1) we can write (12.16.6.4)
m
f Z ( 4
=
1 cn(x)(z - a)”,
n=O
the series being convergent in any disk with center a not meeting y(1). The
16 BAIRE’S THEOREM AND ITS CONSEQUENCES
87
coefficients c,, E E’ are given by
Applying this result to the situation where y is a circuit t H a + reit (0 5 t 5 2n) in A - { a } we obtain, for any weakly analytic function ZI+L on A, the Taylor expansion (12.16.6.5)
convergent in the disk ) z - a1 < r (independent of z E E), and the derivatives are given by (12.16.6.6)
More generally, suppose that in A - { a } we have (12.16.6.7)
where the x: are linear forms on E (a priori, not necessarily continuous), and zHg, is a weakly analytic function on A - { a } which is weakly bounded in a neighborhood of a. Then, by (9.15), for each x E E, the function zt-tg,(x) can be extended by continuity to the point a, and the extended function is analytic in A. Hence there exists a weakly analytic function z H h, in A whose restriction to A - ( a } is zI+g,. Furthermore, the x: are continuous linear forms on E (i.e., they are elements of E’). Indeed, for each x E E we have ( Z - u ) ~ - ’ ~ = ( dz x)
where y is a circuit tt+a + rei‘ (0 5 t 2n) with r sufficiently small and independent of x (9.14); our assertion therefore follows from the considerations above (12.16.6.3). Finally, we remark that the principle of analytic continuation (9.4.2) remains valid for weakly analytic functions. This is an immediate consequence of the definitions. (12.16.7) Let E be a Hilbert space and u an endomorphism of the (nontopological) vector space E. Then the following three conditions are equivalent: (a) u is continuous; (b) u is weakly continuous; (c) u has an adjoint (11S).
88
XI1 TOPOLOGY A N D TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
We have already seen (12.15.11) that (a) implies (b). If u is weakly continuous, then for all y E E the linear form X H (u(x) I y ) is weakly continuous, and therefore a fortiori continuous with respect to the strong topology, which is finer than the weak topology. Consequently (6.3.2), for each y E E there exists a unique point u*(y) such that (u(x) I y) = (x I u*(y)) for all x E E: in other words (11.5), u has an adjoint, and therefore (b) implies (c). Finally, if u has an adjoint, then we have IIU*(Y)ll = SUP
llxll 5 1
IbIU*(Y))l
= SUP
llxll 6 1
I(u(x)lv)l,
and each of the linear forms y ~ ( I u(x)) y = (u(x) l y ) is continuous, hence
YH IIu*(y)(l is a lower semicontinuous seminorm on E, and is therefore continuous in the strong topology (12.1 6.3). But this is equivalent to saying that
u* is (strongly) continuous, and therefore so is u = u** (11.5.2).
We remark that it is essential for the truth of (1 2.16.4), (12.16.5), (12.1 6.6), and (12.16.7) that the space E should be complete (cf. Problems 21 and 22). (12.1 6.8) (Banach's theorem) Let E, F be two Fre'chet spaces and let u be a continuous linear mapping of E into F. Then either u(E) is meager in F, or else u(E) = F. In the latter case, if N is the kernel of u and E --+ E/N & F the canonical factorization of u, the mapping v is an isomorphism of the Frtchet space E/N (12.14.9) onto F (in other words (12.12.7), u is a strict morphism of E onto F).
Suppose that u(E) is not meager in F. By virtue of (12.13.1) and (12.12.7), the theorem will be proved if we can show that, for each neighborhood V of 0 in E, u(V) is a neighborhood of 0 in F. There are two steps to the proof. (12.16.8.1) Let E, F be two topological vector spaces, and u a linear mapping of E into F such that u(E) is not meager in F. Thenfor each neighborhood V of 0 in E, the closure u(V) of the image of V is a neighborhood of 0 in F.
Let W be a balanced neighborhood of 0 in E such that W + W c V ((12.13.1) and (12.8.3)). Then for each x E E there exists an integer n 2 1 such that x E nW. Consequently u(E) is the union of the sets u(nW) = n u(W). Since u(E) is not meager, at least one of the sets n * u(W) has an interior point, and therefore so does u(W). But since __ -u(W) = u(W), we have -~ - u(W) = u(W). So if yo is an interior point of u(W), so is - y o , and -then therefore 0 = yo ( y o ) is an interior point of u(W) u(W) (12.8.2). But _ _ u(W) u(W) is contained in theclosure of u(W) + u(W) = u(W W ) c u(V), and so (12.16.8.1) is proved.
+
+
+
+
16
BAIRE'S THEOREM A N D ITS CONSEQUENCES
89
Now suppose that E, F are equipped with translation-invariant distances d, d , respectively, compatible with their topologies (12.9.1). By (12.16.8.1), the hypothesis that u(E) is not meager in F implies that, for each r > 0, there exists p = p(r) > 0 such that B'(0; p) c u(B'(0; r)). By translation it follows that for each x E E we have B'(u(x); p ) c u(B'(x; r)). Hence it is enough to prove the following lemma: (12.16.8.2) Let E be a complete metric space, F a metric space, and u a continuous mapping of E into F with the following property: for each r > 0 there exists p = p(r) > 0 such that B'(u(x);p ) c u(B'(x;r ) ) for all x E E. Then B'(u(x);p ) c u(B'(x; 2r))for all x E E.
For each integer n 2 1, there exists by hypothesis a number p, > 0 such that B'(u(x); p,) c u(B'(x; 2-"+'r)) for all x E E. We may take p1 = p and (replacing p, if necessary by inf(p, , 2 - 7 ) assume that lirn p, = 0. Let xo be n+m
any point of E, and let y E B'(u(x,); p). We shall prove that y E u(B'(x,; 2r)). For this we define inductively a sequence (x,),,, of points of E such that, for each n 2 1, we have x, E B'(x,,-,; 2 - " + l r ) and u(x,) E B'(y; pn+,). Suppose that xl, . . . , x,-, have been chosen to satisfy these conditions. Then we have y E B'(u(x,,-,);p,), and since B'(u(x,,-,); p,) c u(B'(x,-,; 2-"+'r)), there exists a point x, E B ' ( X , , - ~2; - " + ' r ) such that u(x,,) E B'(y; p,+J. So the inductive construction can continue. Now the sequence (x,) is a Cauchy sequence in E, because for each n 2 0 we have + 2-"-p+' r 5- 2-"+'r d(x,, x,,~) 2-"r 2 - " - l r +
s
+
-
for all p > 0. Since E is complete, the sequence converges in E to a point
x such that d(x,, x ) 5 2r. Since u is continuous, we have u(x) = lirn u(x,,);
and since d'(u(x,), y )
s pnil,
it follows that lim u(x,) = y . n+m
n-+m
Q.E.D.
This theorem has the following corollaries : (12.1 6.9) Let E, F be two Frkchet spaces. Then every continuous bijective linear mapping of E onto F is an isomorphism.
In this proposition it is essential to assume that both E and F are complete. For example, if we take E = I; (6.5) and F to be the canonical image of E under the identity mapping E-tBR(N) (7.1), endowed with the topology induced by that of gR(N), then this mapping is continuous because
90
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
C 4; 2 sup (,2 n
n
(5.5.1),but the inverse bijection of F onto E is not continuous:
otherwise F would be complete, and therefore closed in g,(N) (3.14.4),which is absurd, because its closure in gIR(N)is the set of all sequences (5,) such that lim 4, = 0. n-, m
(1 2.16.10) Let E, F be two Banach spaces, and u a continuous surjective linear mapping of E to F. Then there exists a number m > 0 such that for each x E E there exists x' E E,for which u(x) = u(x') and IIu(x)II 2 m * IIx'II. Bearing in mind (12.14.8)and (5.5.1),this expresses that the bijection F .+ E/u-'(O), the inverse of the bijection E/u-'(O) F induced by u, is continuous on F. -+
(12.16.11) (Closed graph theorem) Let E, F be two Frtchet spaces. For a linear mapping u of E into F to be continuous, it is necessary and sufficient that the graph (1.4)of u should be closed in the product space E x F. In general, iff is a continuous mapping of a topological space X into a Hausdorff topological space Y, the graph offis closed in X x Y, because it is the set of all z E X x Y satisfying the relation pr, z =f(prlz), and theassertion follows from (12.3.5).To show that the condition stated in (12.16.11)is sufficient, remark that it implies that the graph G of u, being a closed vector subspace of the FrCchet space E x F (3.20.16(iv)),is a FrCchet space (3.14.5). The projection z w p r l z of G onto E is therefore a continuous bijective linear mapping, hence an isomorphism (12.16.9). Since the inverse mapping is u : X H ( X , u(x)), it follows that xt-,u(x) = pr,(u(x)) is continuous on E. The condition of (12.16.11)may also be expressed by saying that if a sequence (x,, u(x,)) in E x F tends to a point (x, y ) , then y = u(x). Replacing x, by x, - x, and using the linearity of u, an equivalent formulation is that i f a sequence (x,) in E tends to 0 and is such that the sequence ( ~ ( x , )tends ) to a limit y , then y = 0. It is this criterion that we shall apply in practice to verify the continuity of u. Finally, the following consequence of Baire's theorem allows us to use the criterion (12.11.5):
(12.16.12) Let G be a separable, metrizable, locally compact group, acting continuously and transitively on a Hausdorff topological space E in which every point has a neighborhood homeomorphic to a complete metric space. For each x E E, let S, be the stabilizer of x. Then the canonical bijection f, : G/S, -+ E is a homeomorphism.
16 BAIRE’S THEOREM A N D ITS CONSEQUENCES
91
Let xo E E. We have to show that, for each neighborhood V of e in G, the set V xo is a neighborhood of x, in E (12.11.5). Let W be a compact symmetric neighborhood of e in G such that W2 c V, and let (s,) be a sequence which is dense in G, such that (s,,W) is a covering of G. Each of the sets s,,W . x, is closed in E, because st+s x, is continuous (12.3.61, and E is the union of the denumerable sequence of closed sets s, W xo . By Baire’s theorem (12.16.1), there exists an index n such that s,,W * xo has an interior point s,s xo, with s E W. It follows (12.10.3) that x, is an interior point of the set a
s-’s,’(s,W.
xo) = s-’w* xo
in other words, V * x, is a neighborhood of xo .
c
v . x,; Q.E.D.
(12.16.13) Let G be a separable, metrizable, locally compact group, let G’ be a metrizable group, and let f : G -+ G’ be a continuous surjective homomorphism. Then f is a sfrict morphism (12.12.7) (in other words, if H is the kernel off; then the canonical bijection g : G/H G’ is an isomorphism of topological groups). --f
For we may consider G’ as a space on which G acts continuously and transitively by the rule (s, t ’ )f (~s ) f ’ ,and the stabilizer of the neutral element e‘ of G’ is H. The result therefore follows from (12.16.12).
PROBLEMS 1. Let E, F be two metric spaces, A a dense subspace of E, and f a continuous mapping of A into F. If F is complete, show that the set of points in E at whichfhas no limit relative to A (3.1 3 ) is meager in E. (For each n , consider the set of points x E E at which the oscillation offwith respect to A (3.14) is > l/n.) 2.
Let E, F be two complete metric spaces, and f a homeomorphism of a dense subspace A of E onto a dense subspace B of F. Show that there exists a subspace C 3 A in E (resp. D 3 B in F) which is a denumerable intersection of open sets, and an extension offto a homeomorphism g of C onto D. (Apply Problem 1 to f and its inverse.)
3. Let E be a complete metric space, F a metric space, and (fn) a sequence of continuous mappings of E into F which converges simply (pointwise) in E to a mapping f. Show that the set of points x E E at which f is not continuous is meager in E. (Let G p ,,, be the set of x E E for which the distance between f,(x) and &(x) is 5 1/2n for all q z p . Show that the union of the interiors of the sets G,, for p 2 1 is a dense open set, by using Baire’s theorem. Deduce that the set of points at which the oscillation of f’is
92
XI1
TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
4. Let E be a separable metrizable space. For each subset A of E, let D(A) denote the set of points x E E such that, for each neighborhood V of x, the set V n A is not meager. We have D(A) C A. Show that D(A) = 0 if and only if A is meager. Show that D(A) is closed and that A n (E - D(A)) is meager. Show that D(A) is the closure of its interior. (If D'(A) is the closure of the interior of D(A), show that A n (E - D'(A)) is meager.) 5.
Let G be a separable metrizable group. Show that if H is a nonmeager subgroup of G, then R is an open subgroup of G. (With the notation of Problem 4, show that the interior of D(H) is not empty.)
6.
If a complete metrizable group is denumerable, then it is discrete.
7.
Let G be a separable, metrizable, locally compact group, and let H be a closed normal subgroup of G. Show that the canonical bijection A/(A n H)+AH/H is an isomorphism of topological groups.
8.
Let E, F, G be three metric spaces and d, d', d" the distances on E, F, G, respectively. Letfbe a mapping of E x F into G such that for each x o E E the mappingyt+f(xo, y ) is continuous on F, and for each yo E F the mapping X H f(x, y o ) is continuous on E. (a) For each E > 0, each b E F and each x E E, let g(x; b, E ) be the least upper bound of the set of numbers 0: > 0 such that d'(b, y ) 5 a implies d"cf(x, b), f(x, y ) ) 5 E . Show that the mapping x w g ( x ; b, E ) is upper semicontinuous. (b) If E is complete, deduce from (a) that for each b E F there exists a meager set Ma c E such thatfis continuous at (a, 6) for all a 6 Mb. If F also is complete, deduce that there exists a meager set N in E x F such that the restriction offto (E x F) - N is conrinuous. (For each k , consider the set of points at which the oscillation offis < I/k, and use Problem 4 of Section (12.7). (c) If E, F, G are FrCchet spaces and f' is a bilinear mapping of E x F into G , such that the linear mappings f(xo, .) and f(.,yo) are continuous for all xo E E and all yo E F, show that f is continuous on E x F.
9. Let G be a group and d a distance on G defining a topology for which G is a complete, separable, locally compact, metric space. Suppose that for each xo E G the mappings
y t r x o y and yt+yx0 are continuous on G. Show that the topology defined by d is compatible with the group structure of G . (First prove that the mapping (x, y)++xy is continuous, by using Problem 8. Then consider the set F in G x G consisting of all ( x , x-l) with x E: G. Show that F, with the law of composition (x, x-')(y, y-l) = (xy, y-'x-') and the topology induced by the product topology on G x G , is a topological group and is closed in G x G . Finally show that the restriction of prl to F is bicontinuous, by using (12.16.12), and deduce that the mapping x w x - l is continuous on G.)
10.
Let T be a metric space, E a FrCchet space, and M a set of mappings of E x T into a metrizable topological vector space F, satisfying the following conditions: (1) for each to E T, the set of mappings f(.,to), where f E M, is an equicontinuous set of linear mappings of E into F; (2) for each xo E E, the set of mappingsf(xo, *),where YE M, is equicontinuous. Show that M is equicontinuous. (Given to E T and a balanced closed neighborhood V of 0 in F, for each x E E let d, be the least upper bound of radii of open balls with centre to in T, such that for every point f of such a ball we have f ( x , 1 ) - f ( x , l o ) E V for all f~ M. Show that the mapping x k d , is upper semicontinuous on E (argue by contradiction); then use (12.16.2).)
16 BAIRE'S THEOREM A N D ITS CONSEQUENCES
93
11. Let E, F be two Frkchet spaces, G a Banach space, and (f.) a sequence of continuous bilinear mappings of E x F into G. Suppose that, for each ( x , y ) E E x F, the sequence (f.(x, y)) is bounded in G. If D is a dense subset of E x F and the sequence (f.(x, y)) converges for all (x, y ) E D, show that the sequence (A) converges simply in E x F and that the limit function is continuous. (Use Problem 10 and (7.5.5).) 12.
Let E be the set of all sequences x general term
& is convergent, and
=(fJnbO
of real numbers such that the series with
put Ilxll = sup
"
C & I. KO
(a) Show that llxll is a norm on E and that E is complete with respect to this norm. (b) The Banach space 1' (Section (5.7), Problem 1) is dense in E with respect to the m
norm IIxIl. If 1' is endowed with its norm (/xII1= C 16.1, then the canonical injection n=0
I' --+ E is continuous. (c) Let (P,) be an increasing sequence of finite subsets of N x N, forming a covering of N x N. For each x = (&) E E and each y = (7") E I', let f.(x, y) = t17,. (1. I ) E P n
Show that the sequence (f.) converges simply in E x I' if and only if, for each (x, y ) E E x f ' , the sequence (ACx, y)) is bounded, and that the limit of (fn(x, y)) for all ( x , y )
E
E x 1'. (Use Problem 11 with
D = 1' x l'.) (d) For each j E N, let pjn be the smallest number of closed intervals in N whose union is the section P;'(j) (the projection of P, n (N x {j))). Let pD= sup pJn. Show that the condition in (c) is equivalent to sup p. < n
+ co. (If qPnis JEN
the
characteristic function of P., show that the norm of the bilinear form f. (5.7.7) is equal to
(" Theorem of Mertens-Alexiewicz ").
13. The Banach space I' (Section 5.7, Problem 1 ) is algebraically a vector subspace of the space f 2 (6.5). If l(xlll and IIx(12are the norms on I' and l2 respectively, we have /JxI12 5 JIx/J1 for all x E 1'. Show that in the space 12, the unit ball B : llxlll 5 1 of 1' is not closed with respect to the norm ( I x ( / ~ although , the intersection of B with every finite-dimensional linear variety is closed (use (1 2.1 6.3)). 14. Let E be a FrQhet space and F a normed space. If H is a set of continuous linear mappings of E into F which is not equicontinuous, show that the set of x E E such
that H(x) (the set of all u(x) with u E H ) is not bounded in F is the complement of a meager set. Deduce that if (F,) is a sequence of Banach spaces and if,for each n, H. is a subset of O(E; F.) which is not equicontinuous, then there exists xo E E such that none of the sets H.(xo) is bounded ("principle of condensation of singularities ").
15. Let (ail)lsibe a family of points of the interval I = [0,1] in R. For each integer n 2 0 ,
let w.(x)
I1( x - q.), and suppose that the roots of this polynomial are all distinct. n
=
1=0
Let
-
qtn(X) = ~ n t x ) / ( 4 ( a 3 ( x 01.))
94
XI1 TOPOLOGY A N D TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
for 0 2 i 6 n. For each real-valued function f defined on I, the Lagrange interpolation polynomial off corresponding t o ( a l J )is the polynomial
(a) The mapping f ~ P . ( f ) is a continuous linear mapping of the Banach space %?(I) into itself. The sequence of polynomials P.(f) converges uniformly to f on I for all f E V(I) if and only if the sequence of norms IIP./I of these linear mappings is bounded (use (12.16.5) and (7.5.5)). Show that
(b) Take al.= i/n for O s i j n . Show that the sequence (IIPnll) tends to +a. Deduce that, for this choice of the a,. , there exists a function fo E V(1) such that the sequence of polynomials P,(fo) is not uniformly bounded on I (use Problem 14).
16. Let f be a continuous real-valued function on an open interval 1 in R, having a righthand derivative f: (8.4) at every point of I. (a) Show that the set of points x E I such that f: is bounded in some neighborhood of x is a dense open set in I (use (12.16.2)). (b) Show that the set of points x E I at whichf; is continuous is the complement of a meager set in I (cf. Problem 3). Deduce that f has a derivative a t all points of the complement of a meager set in I (cf. Section 8.6, Problem 2).
17. (a) In the Banach space V(I), where I = [0, I], let A. be the set of functions fsuch
that for some x E 0, 1 - l / n , depending on f, we have If(x') - f ( x ) l =< n lx' - XI for all x' E ]x, x -t l/n[. Show that A, is nowhere dense in V(1). (Notice first that in V(I) every ball contains a function which has a bounded right-hand derivative at all points of I. Secondly, observe that for each E > 0 and each integer m, there exists a function g E @(I) with a right-hand derivative at every point of [0, 1 [ and such that 1g(x)1 5 E and Jg:(x)l >= m at all x E [O, l[.) (b) Deduce from (a) that the set A of functions f~ %(I) such that, for at least one point x E [0, 1[ (depending onf), f h a s a right-hand derivative at x, is meager in V(1). Consequently, the complement of this set, that is to say the set of all ft V(I) having no right-hand derivative at any point of [0, I[, is dense in V(1) (cf. Section 8.4, Problem I).
18. Letfbe a real-valued function defined on an open set A c R2,such that for each point (xo , y o ) E A the function f(.,y o ) is continuous at xo and the function f ( x o , .) is continuous and differentiable at the point y o . Show that there exists a meager Eet M in A such that the derivative D2f is continuous on A - M (use Problem 8(b) and Problem 3). 19. Let E be a complex Banach space and E' its dual, which is a Banach space with respect to the norm (5.7.1). Show that a weakly analytic mapping Z H ~ , of an open set A c C into E' is in fact analyric in the sense of (9.3) (with respect to the norm under consideration). (Use the formula (1 2.1 6.6.6) and the Banach-Steinhaus theorem.)
16
BAIRE'S THEOREM AND ITS CONSEQUENCES
95
20.
Let Z be a complete metric space and f a weakly continuous mapping of Z into a separable Hilbert space E. (a) If A is any closed convex set in E, show that f-'(A) is closed in Z (Cf. Section 12.1 5, Problem 3(b)). (b) For each integer n > 1, let D. be the set of points z E Z such that the oscillation of the function f (considered as a mapping of a metric space into a metric space) is z l / n . The set D. is closed (Section 12.7, Problem 4). Show that D. is meager in Z. (Cover E by a sequence ( S , ) of closed balls of diameter 5 1/2n, and use (a) and Baire's theorem to show that D, n f - ' ( S k ) is a nowhere dense closed set in 2,for each k.) (c) Deduce from (a) that there exists a meager set M in Z such that f i s strongly continuous at every point of Z - M.
21.
Let E = X(R) be the subspace consisting of continuous functions with compact support, in the Banach space g ( R ) of real-valued bounded functions on R. Let u. n
be the continuous linear f o r r n f H x f ( k ) on E. Show that the sequence (u.) converges k= 1
simply on E but is not bounded in the dual E', and that its limit u is not continuous on E. 22.
Let E be the subspace consisting of sequences (6") with finite support, in the Hilbert space P , so that E is the set of all (finite) linear combinations of the vectors en in l 2 (6.5). Let u be the endomorphism of E for which u(e.) = ne. for all n. Show that, for every y E E, the linear form x ~ ( u ( x ) I y is ) continuous on E, but that u is not a continuous endomorphism of E.
23. Let E be the subset of R2 consisting of the line D = {0}X R and the points ( l / n ,k/n2), where n and k belong to Z and n > 0. (a) For every point (0,y ) E E and every integer n > 0, let T&) be the set of points (u, u ) E E such that u 5 l / n and Iu - yl 5 u. Show that if we take the sets T.(y) (n 2 1) as a fundamental system of neighborhoods of (0, y), for each y E R, and if for each other point z of E we take the set consisting of that point alone as a fundamental system of neighborhoods of z, then we have a Hausdorff topology 9on E, for which each subspace T.(y) is metrizable and compact. The topology induced by 9 on D is the discrete topology. (b) Let A be the set (0)x Q, which is closed in D and whose complement B in D is also closed. If a set U which is open with respect to 7 contains B, show that there exists an interval {0}x [a, b] in D (with a < 6) and an integer n such that U contains the union of the sets T,(y) for y E [a, 61 and (0, y ) E B. (Use the fact that Q is a meager subset of R in the usual topology.) Deduce that every neighborhood of A in E meets U, and hence that the space E is not metrizable, although it contains a discrete denumerable dense subset (use (4.5.2)). 24.
Let (an)be a sequence of real numbers. Suppose that, for each sequence (6.) of real numbers belonging to the space I' (Section 5.7, Problem 1) (resp. to the space l 2 (6.5)), the series with general term antnis convergent. Prove that the sequence (a") belongs to I" (Section 5.6, Problem 1) (resp. belongs to 1'). (For each integer N, N
consider the continuous linear form x HC a. f,,on I' (resp. I'), and apply the BanachSteinhaus theorem .)
"= 1
96
XI1 TOPOLOGY AND TOPOLOGICAL ALGEBRA
25. (a) Give an example of a sequence (f.)of continuous real-valued functions on an interval I c R which converges simply at each point of I but is such that there exists
no nonempty open interval contained in I on which the sequence converges uniformly (cf. (I2.7.1 )). (b) Let (f.)be a sequence of complex analytic functions on an open set D c C which converges simply at each point of D. Show that there exists a dense open set U in D such that, for each zo E U, there exists a neighborhood of zo on which the sequence (f.) is uniformly convergent. (Consider the sequence of functions ZH If.(z)l and use (9.13.2).)
26.
+
Let t H A ( t ) be a continuous mapping of the interval R + = [0, m[ of R into the space of real n x n matrices, and let t H C ( f ) be the solution of the homogeneous linear differential equation U' = A(t)U which is equal to the unit matrix when t = 0 (10.8.4). Let El denote the vector subspace of R" consisting of vectors y such that the and let E2 be a supplement of El in function t H C ( t ) . y is bounded on [0, a[, R".Let P1 : R"+ E l and P z : R" + E2 be the projections associated with the directsum decomposition R" = El @ E2 (5.4). (a) Suppose that, for each function f~ WZ"(R,), the differential equation x' = A ( t ) . x + f ( t ) has at least one solution which is bounded on R + . Show that, for each function f E qpn(R+), there exists a unique vector y ( f ) E E, such that the unique solution uf of the equation x' = A ( t ) . x + f ( t ) which takes the value y ( f ) at the point 0 is bounded in R, ,and that there exists a constant c > 0 such that
+
(Consider the space F of continuously differentiable functions x on R, with values in R" such that x and x' - A . x are bounded on R, and x(0) E E2.Show that the function
N(x) = llxll
+ Ilx' - A . xII
is a norm on F, with respect to which F is a Banach space. Then apply Banach's theorem to the linear mapping XHX' - A . x of F into 9;"(R+), bearing in mind the definition of E2.) (b) Deduce from (a) that a necessary and sufficient condition for the equation x' = A(t) . x + f ( t ) to have a solution which is bounded on R + , for all functions f~ @gn(R,). is that
(cf. (10.8.6) and (13.14.4)). 27.
Let f:[a, b[ + R be an increasing function, continuous on the right. Suppose that the countable set of points of discontinuity o f f is dense in [a, b[ (Section 3.15, Problem). Show that the set of points x E [a, b[ at whichfhas a finite derivative on the right is meager. (For each integer n > 0, let A. be the set of points x E [a, b[ such that thereexist pointsy, z E [a, h[ satisfyingx < y < z < x l / n and
+
Show that A. is a dense open subset of [a, b[.)
16 BAIRE'S THEOREM AND ITS CONSEQUENCES
97
28. Let f b e an indefinitely differentiable real-valued function defined on an open interval ]u,b[ of R.Suppose that for each point x E Ju,b[ there exists an integer N(x) such that DN("'f(x)= 0. Show that f i s a polynomial. (One may proceed as follows: (a) Let G be the open set of points x E ]a, b[ such that in some neighborhood of x the function fcoincides with a polynomial, and let F be the complement of G in ]u,b[. Show that F has no isolated points (3.10.10). (b) For each integer n, let En be the closed subset of F consisting of the points x E F such that D"f(x)= 0. If F is not empty, show that there exists a nonempty open interval 1 C ]a, b[ and an integer N such that F n I is nonempty and is contained in EN (use Baire's theorem). Then deduce from (a) that F n I c E, for all n > N. (c) Deduce from (b) that F n I is nowhere dense in I, and then that DNf(x)= 0 on every component interval of G n I. Hence derive a contradiction of the hypothesis F f 121.) 29. Let E, F be two separable Banach spaces, F' the dual of F. Suppose that F is contained
in a Hausdorff locally convex space G , and that the topology on F induced by that of G is coarser than the weak topology of F . Let u : E -+ G be a continuous linear mapping. (a) Show that, for every ball B in the Banach space F', the inverse image u-'(B) is a closed subset of E. (Use (12.15.9) and (12.15.8.1).) (b) Suppose that there exists a nonmeager subset A of E such that u(x) E F' for all x E A. Show that u(E) c F' and that u is continuous for the topology defined by the norm on F'.
30. Let E be a Frechet space, and let (u.) be a family of continuous linear mappings of E into a normed space F. Suppose that there exists a nonmeager subset A of E such that for each x E A the set of points tl.(x) is bounded in F. Show that the family (u,) is equicontinuous. (For each integer n 1, consider the set of points x E E such that l/u,(x)lI5 n for each index a,)
CHAPTER XI11
INTEGRATION
The theory of integration which we shall develop in this chapter is restricted to separable metrizable locally compact spaces, this being sufficient for our purposes in later chapters. We have followed fairly closely the exposition of N. Bourbaki [22], with the simplifications afforded by our more restricted hypotheses. The key results of the theory of integration are Lebesgue’s convergence theorems (1 3.8), the Fischer-Riesz theorem (13.11.4), the Lebesgue-Nikodym theorem (13.1 5.5) and the Lebesgue-Fubini theorem (1 3.21.7). Unfortunately it is necessary to include rather a lot of material on upper integrals, measurable functions and negligible functions, which are indispensable technical tools. The important properties of certain particular measures on locally compact groups or on differential manifolds will be examined in Chapters XIV and XVI. We have also included, amongst the problems, applications of integration which are not dealt with in the text, especially to ergodic theory and orthogonal systems. The reader who wishes to go further in these directions should consult [21], [26a], [28], [30], and [31]. Nowadays the purposes of a theory of integration are very different from what they were at the beginning of this century. If the aim was only to be able to integrate “ very discontinuous ” functions, integration would hardly have gone beyond the rather narrow confines of the “ fine ” theory of functions of one or more real variables. The reasons for the importance that Lebesgue’s concept of integral has acquired in modern analysis are of quite a different nature. One is that it leads naturally to the consideration of various new complete function spaces, which can be conveniently handled precisely because they are spaces offunctions (or of classes of “equivalent ” functions) and not just abstract objects, as is usually the case when one constructs the completion of a space. Another is that the theorem of Lebesgue-Nikodym 98
1 DEFINITION OF A MEASURE
99
and the properties of measures defined by densities (13.15) give us a method for dealing with denumerable families of measures on a locally compact space, by fixing a basic measure and working with the densities relative to this basic measure (hence again withfunctions); this again proves to be extremely convenient. Here the modern point of view emerges: given a p-integrable function5 what is important is not the values taken byfso much as the way in whichf operates on the space of bounded continuous functions by means of the linear mapping g w fg dp (this mapping depends only on the equivalence class off and therefore does not change when we modifyfat the points of a set of measure zero). The development of this point of view will lead in Chapter XVII to the theory of distributions, which is a natural generalization of the notion of measure on differential manifolds. Throughout this chapter, the phrase “ locally compact space ” will always mean ‘‘ separable metrizable locally compact space.” 1. DEFINITION OF A MEASURE
To begin with, let X be a compact (metrizable) space. A measure (or complex measure) on X is by definition an element of the dual of the Banach space gc(X) of complex-vaiued continuous functions on X (7.2),that is to say ((12.1 5) and (5.5.1 )) it is a linear form f tt p(f) on VC(X)which satisfies an inequality of the form Icl(f)l 2 a I l f
(13.1.1)
for a l l y €%,(X) (recall that
llfll
= sup
II
1f ( x ) l ) .
XEX
Now let X be a locally compact space (metrizable and separable, in accordance with our conventions). For every compact subset K of X, let X ( X ; K) (or X,(X; K)) denote the vector subspace of g,-(X) consisting of the functions whose support (12.6) is contained in K (and is thereforecompact). We shall denote by X,(X) (or X ( X ) )the union of the X c ( X ;K ) as K runs through all compact subsets of X. In other words, X,(X) is the vector space of (complex-valued) continuous functions with compact support. Clearly .X,(X) = V:cm(X). A measure (or complex measure) on X is by definition a linear form p on X,(X) with the following property: for each compact subset K of X, there exists a real number aK >= 0 (in general depending on K) such that (13.1.2)
for allfE X ( X ;K).
Ip(f)I
5 OK l l f l l
XI11 INTEGRATION
100
This definition agrees with the preceding one when X is compact. It expresses that the restriction of p to X ( X ;K) is continuous with respect to the topology induced by that of %?,?(X).We remark that X ( X ; K) is closed in %?F(X),and therefore a Banach space (3.14.5). I n general, a measure is not necessarily continuous on X,(X) with respect to the topology induced by that of %?F(X)(i.e., the topology defined by the norm 11 f 11). We shall examine this question later (13.20). Examples of Measures (13.1.3) Let X be a locally compact space, and let X E X .The mapping f t +f ( x ) of X ( X )into C is a measure, for it is linear and we have If(x)l 5 i l f l l for each compact subset K of X such that f E X ( X ; K). This measure is called the Dirac measure at the point x , or the measure defined by the unit mass at thepoint x , and is denoted by E,. More generally, let (a,) be a sequence of distinct points in X , and (t,,) a sequence of complex numbers, such that for each compact K c X the subsequence formed by the t,, f o r which a, E K is absolutely summable (5.3). Let cK = ItJ. Then, for each function f E X ( X ;K), the series t,,f(a,) is a,
E
1
K
n
absolutely convergent, because the only nonzero terms are those for which a, E K, and we have
C ItnSta,JI S IfII C = CK . IISIIThis also shows that f H C t,,f (a,) is a measure on X . This measure is said to *
U"EK
a,eK
tn
n
be defined by the masses t, at the points a,, for all n (cf. (13.18.8)). (13.1.4) Let f~ X c ( R ) . For each interval [a, b ] containing the support off, the value of the integral Jabf(t)dt (8.7) is the same, and we denote it by
s'^
f ( t ) dt. The mappingfwJ+OOf(t) -00 dt is a linear form on XX,(R),and it is a measure because, for each compact interval K = [a, b ] in R and each functionfE X ( R ; K) we have -m
by the mean value theorem (8.7.7). This measure is called Lebesgue measure on the real line R. (1 3.1.5) Let p be a measure on X and let g E %',(X). Then for each function f E X ( X ) it is clear that g f E , X ( X ) , and the mapping f w p ( g f ) is therefore
1 DEFINITION OF A MEASURE
101
a h e a r form on X(X). It is a measure, for if K is any compact subset of X and i f f E X ( X ;K), then IIgfII g 11 f 11 sup Ig(x)l, and consequently
-
XEK
Ip(gf)l 5 bK (1 f 11, where bK = aK sup Ig(x)l. This measure is denoted by g * p, X€K
and it is called the measure with density g relative to p (cf. (1 3.13)). (13.1.6) Let n : X + X' be a homeomorphism of X onto a locally compact space X'. For each functionfE X(X'),the function f 0 n belongs to X(X), and we have Supp(f0 n) = n-'(Supp f). It follows immediately that, if p is any measure on X, then f Hp( f 0 n) is a measure on X', called the image of p under n and denoted by n(p). (13.1.7) Let Y be a closed subset of X (and therefore a locally compact subspace of X (3.18.4)) and v a measure on Y. For each f E X ( X ; K), the restriction f I Y belongs to X ( Y ; K n Y), and hence there exists a constant CK such that If(y)l 5 c K l l f l l Iv(flY>I5 cK ' YE
Y
for all f E X ( X ;K). The mapping f Hv( f I Y) is therefore a measure on X, called the image of v under the canonical injection Y + X, or the canonical extension of v to X. (1 3.1.8) Let U be an open subset of X (and therefore again a locally compact subspace (3.18.4)). For each compact subset K of U, it is clear that the mappingft+ f I U is an isometry of X ( X ;K) onto X ( U ; K). The image under the inverse isometry of a function g E X ( U ; K) is the function g' which agrees with g on U and is zero on X - U. (By abuse of notation, we shall often write f in place off/ U when Supp(f) c U, and g in place of g'). The mapping g w g U of Xc(U) into X,(X) is therefore injective. If p is any measure on X , the mapping g H p(g') is a measure on U, said to be induced by p on U, or the restriction of p to U, and denoted by pu or p I U. It should be noted that a measure v on U is not necessarily the restriction of a measure on X (Section (13.4), Problem l), and that an " extension " of v to X, if it exists, is not in general unique. However, there is the following result: (13.1.9) Let (U,),€, be an open covering of X. For each a E I let pa be a measure on U, such that, for each pair of indices a, p, the restrictions of pa and p, to U, n U, (1 3.1.8) are equal. 'Then there exists a unique measure p on X whose restriction to U, is p a , for each a E 1.
We shall first show that each function , f X,(X) ~ can be written in the n
form f = cfiwhere, for each index i, there exists ai E I such that f i E Xc(X) i= 1
102
Xlll INTEGRATION
and Supp(fi)c U,, . For this purpose we observe that if K is the support of f, then there exist finitely many indices cli E I (1 5 i 5 n ) such that the U,, cover K. Hence ((3.18.2) and (12.6.4)) there exist n continuous mappings hi : X -+ [0, I] such that Supp(hi) is compact and is contained in U,, for 1 5 i 5 n, and such that
n
h,(x) = 1 for all x E K. Then the functions f i =f hi
i=1
satisfy the required conditions. This already proves the uniqueness of p: for by definition we must have
~ ( f=)i= C1pU(fhi)= i2= 1pa,Uhi). n
To prove the existence of a linear form p on X,(X) whose restriction to X,.(U,) is p, for each a E I, it is enough to establish the following assertion: given two finite sequences (gJl s i j m and j g n of functions belonging to X,(X), such that Supp(g,) c U,, for 1 5 i 5 m and Supp(hj) c U,, for 1 S j S n, and such that
for all x E Supp(f),then we have
Now, we have
and therefore
Similarly,
But since Supp(fgihj) is contained in U,, n U,,, it follows from the hypotheses that pu,(f g i hi) = ppj(fgihj),and our assertion follows. It remains to be shown that the linear form p so defined is a measure. Let K be a compact subset of X, and define the U,, and the hi as at the beginning of the proof. If H i = Supp(hi), then by hypothesis there exists a
2 REAL MEASURES
number a, 2 0 such that lpai(g)l 5 a i llgll for all g Hence, for each function f E X ( X ;K), we have Ipai(.fhi>l5 aiiifhiil
so that
I ~ W5I
E
.X(X; Hi) (13.1.2).
5 aiilfil,
(,faijli/ii* I=
103
Q.E.D.
1
(13.1.10) If I and p are two measures on X, then so are A + p and a l for any scalar a E C. The set of all measures on X is therefore a uecior subspace of CXC('), which we denote by M,(X) or M(X). By analogy with the example (13.1.4), if p is a measure on a locally com-
s
s
pact space X, we write f dp or f ( x ) dp(x) (or also (f, p ) or ( p , f ) ) in place of p[f), for any f E X ( X ) , and we call this number the integral o f f with respect to p. 2. REAL MEASURES
Let X be a locally compact space. Let X , ( X ) denote the set of all realualued continuous functions on X with compact support, and X,(X; K) the set of those whose support is contained in K. Clearly XR(X)is a real vector subspace of X,(X), and we can write YC(x)=
x,(x) @ iXR(x)
(direct sum). For every (complex) measure p , the restriction of p to XR(X) is an R-linear mapping p o of X R ( X ) into C; moreover p,, determines p uniquely, for i f f = f l ifz with f i t f z in .X,(X),then p ( f ) = p o ( f i ) ipo(fz). Conversely, if an R-linear mapping p o : X,(X) + C is such that, for each compact subset K of X, there exists aK > 0 with the property that Ipo(f)l 5 uK llfll for allfE X , ( X ; K), then it is immediately obvious that the mapping
+
+
fi + $2
HP O ( f 1 )
+ iPO(f2)
is a (complex) measure on X. Hence we may identify each measure on X with its restriction to .X,(X).
Let p be a (complex) measure on X . It follows immediately from (13.1.2) that the m a p p i n g f t + X ) is also a measure on X, called the conjugate of p and denoted by ji. We have p = / i , and if I , .iiare measures o n X and a, b are any two complex numbers, then aI = bp = ZX hii. More generally, if g is any function belonging to %,(X) and p is any measure on X, then we have F p = S ji (13.1.5).
+
-
104
Xlll INTEGRATION
A measure p on X is said to be real if ji = p, or equivalently if p ( f ) is real for everyfe X,(X). We may therefore identify the set of real measures on X with a vector space of linear forms on the real vector space X,(X). This vector space is denoted by MR(X). Lebesgue measure and all Dirac measures are real. If p is any complex measure, then the measures p1 = ( p + ji)/2 and p 2 = ( p - F)/2i are real. They are called respectively the real and imaginary parts of p, and are denoted by 92p and Yp respectively. For each function f E X,(X), we have
and by definition (13.2.2)
p
= 92p
+ iYp,
ji
= 9?p - iYp.
3. POSITIVE MEASURES: T H E ABSOLUTE V A L U E O F A MEASURE
A measure p on a locally compact space X is said to be positive if, for each function f~ ,X,(X) such that f 2 0, we have p(f) 2 0. Consequently, i f f and g are two functions belonging to X,(X) such that f 5 g, we have p ( f ) 5 p(g). Since each f E X,(X) can be written in the form f = f + -f (where f + ( x ) = ( f (x))' and f - ( x ) = ( f ( x ) ) - (2.2)), it follows that a positive measure is a real measure. We denote by M+(X) the set of all positive measures on X. Surprisingly, the property of positivity alone implies the defining property (13.1.2) of a measure: (13.3.1) p(f)
Let p be a linear form on the real vector space X,(X) such that is a (positioe) measlire on X.
2 0 whenever f 2 0 . Then p
We have to show that (13.1.2) is satisfied. There exists a function g E X,(X) with values in [0, I ] and equal to I throughout K ((3.18.2) and (4.5.2)). Hence for all f E X,(X; K), we have
0 S . f + 5 ll.fll* g ,
0 5 . r 5 llfll . g
and therefore 0
s A f + )5 llf'll . A g > ,
so that finally
Icc(f'>I S 2 llfll . A g ) .
05 K
- )s I l f II .
3 POSITIVE MEASURES: THE ABSOLUTE VALUE OF A MEASURE
105
The notion of a positive measure enables us to define an order relation on the vector space MR(X) of real measures on X. We write p S v if the measure v - p is positive. Since the relations p 2 0 and p S 0 imply that p ( f ) = p ( f + ) - p ( f - ) = 0 for allfc X,(X), and therefore that p = 0, it follows that p v is indeed an order relation on MR(X)(not, in general, a total ordering). It is clear that p 5 v implies that I + p 5 I + v for all real measures I , and ap =< av for all real scalars a 2 0. (For a study of this order relation, see (13.15).) (13.3.2) Let p be a (complex) measure on X . Then there exists a smallest positive measure p on X such that Ip(f)l 5 p(1fl)for a l l f c X,(X).
For every positive measure v such that Ip(f)l S v(lfl) for all f~ .X,(X), the relations g 2 0 and Ihl 2 g (9,h E ,X,(X)) imply Ip(h)l Iv(lhl) 5 v(g). We shall show that there exists a positive measure p on X such that, for each functionfz 0 in .X,(X), we have (13.3.2.1)
This p will then clearly satisfy the conditions of (13.3.2). To begin with, we remark that the right-hand side of (13.3.2.1) isJinite; for if K = Supp(f), then Supp(g) c K, and Il*(g)l 5 a K ' llgll
5 aK llfll
whenever 1g(s A by virtue of (13.1.2). Also it is clear that, for any real scalar a 2 0, we have p(af) = ap(f). We shall show next that, if f , and f 2 are two functions 2 0 belonging to ,XR(X),then
For each E > 0, there exists g i E X,(X) such that lgil 5 fi and
IAgi>lZ p ( f i ) - E (i = 192).
Multiplying gi by a complex number with absolute value 1, we may assume that p ( g i ) = Ip(gi)l, and then we have P(91
+ g2) = IP(Sl>l + 1AS;)l 2 P(f1) + p(f2)
- 2%
+
and since lgl + g215 f l + f 2 we have p(f, + f 2 ) 2 p(f,) p(f2) - 2 ~ Since . is arbitrary, it follows that p(f,) + p ( f 2 ) 2 p ( f i + f 2 ) . On the other hand, let h E .X,(X) be such that Ihl 5fl + f 2 . Let hi be the function which is equal to hf,/(fi + f 2 ) at the points x where f i ( x ) + f 2 ( x ) # 0 and is zero E
106
Xlll INTEGRATION
elsewhere (i = 1, 2). Then hi is continuous on X, because fi/(fl + f 2 ) is continuous at the points x wheref,(x) +fz(x) > 0, and also Ihi(x)l 2 Ih(x)l for all x E X, which proves that hi is continuous at the points x where f i ( x ) +fz(x)= 0, because h(x) also vanishes at these points. It is clear that / h i /Sfi (i = 1, 2) and that h = h, + h,; hence lP(h>l I lP(M
+ lP(h2)l I P ( f , ) + P(.fz)*
Since Ip(h)l may be taken to be arbitrarily close to p ( f , +f2),it follows that p(fl +fz) I p ( , f l ) p(f,). Hence (13.3.2.2)is proved. We shall now extend the definition of p ( f ) to all functionsf€ X,(X). To do this we write p ( f ) = p(f’) - p ( f ” ) , wheref=f’ -f ” is any decomposition off as the difference of two functions f ’ , f “ 2 0 belonging to X,(X). The value of p ( f ) so obtained is independent of the decomposition, because if f = f ; - f ; = f ; - f i , then f ; +f;’ =f;’ + f ; and therefore p(f;) p(f;) = p(f;’) + p(f;) by virtue of (1 3.3.2.2). With this definition, the formula (13.3.2.2) is valid for allfl,fz in X,(X). For we can writef, =f ; -f ; , f 2 =f ; - f i wherefi’,fi” (i = 1,2) are 20 and belong to X,(X); sincef, + f z = ( f ; + f ; ) - ( f : +f;’), our assertion follows from the definition above and from (13.3.2.2)for functions 2 0 . Finally, the above definition shows that, for each scalar a 2 0, we have p(uf) = up(f ) ; and if a < 0, then we have
+
+
P ( d > = p(af’
- a ! ” )= d - a f ” )
+ p(af’>
- p(-af‘) = ( - M f ” )- (- 4 P C f ’ ) = (-a)p(f”)
= ap(f).
Hence the relation p(uf) = ap(f) is valid for all real scalars a, and therefore we have proved that p is a (real) linear form on X,(X). Hence by (13.3.1)it is a positive measure. Q.E.D. The measure p defined by (13.3.2)is called the absolute value of the complex measure p, and is denoted by IpI. Hence by definition we have
It is immediately seen that if a E C and p is a measure on X, we have
(13.3.4)
laPl = I4 - IPl.
If p is a positive measure on X, then
(1 3.3.5)
IPI = P.
3
POSITIVE MEASURES: THE ABSOLUTE VALUE OF A MEASURE
107
By virtue of (13.3.2.1) it is enough to show that Iy(f)l S y(lf1) for all = 1 and Iy(f)l = [y(f) = p ( ( f ) ; since p is real, we have y(Tf) = y(9(cf)); and since y 2 0 and 9(Cf)5 Ifl, it follows that y(B([f)) 5 y(lfl), which establishes the assertion.
f~ X,-(X).Givenf, there exists [ E C such that l[l
If y is any real measure on X, it follows from (13.3.3) that y 5 lyl, and therefore :
(13.3.6) Every real measure on X is the diference of two positive measures (for a more precise result, see (13.15)). If y is any (complex) measure on X, it follows from (13.3.3) and (13.3.2) that we have
Also if y, v are any two measures on X we have
(13.3.8)
IP +
4 5 IPI + I4
by virtue of (1 3.3.2). Finally, it follows immediately from the definitions that, if n : X -+ X’ is a homeomorphism and y is any measure on X, then
PROBLEMS
1. Let X be a locally compact space, E a vector subspace of eR(X)and P a conuex cone in U,(X) (i.e., a subset of this space such that the relations f~ P and g E P imply f+ g E P and a f P~ for all scalars a > 0). Suppose that for each function h E S R ( X ) there exists f~ E such that f- h E P. Let u be a real linear form on E such that the relation f~ E n P implies u ( f ) 2 0. Let h E XR(X)and let PA be the set of all f~ E such that h - f P, ~ and Pi the set of a l l f s E such thatf- h E P. Show that these two sets PA, Pi are nonempty, and that if a’ is the least upper bound of the u ( f ) with f~ P A and a“ the greatest lower bound of the u ( f ) with f s Pl , then a’ and a” are finite and a’ 5 a”. Deduce that there exists a linear form u1 on the subspace El = E + Rh of VR(X) which extends u, such that the relationf, E El n P implies ul(fi)2 0. Show that a’ 2 u,(h) 6 a# for any such extension u1 of u, and that the extension is unique if and only if a’ = a”.
108 2.
XI11 INTEGRATION
Let X be a compact space and let p be a real-valued function on VR(X) satisfying the following two conditions: (i) p ( f + g ) g p ( f ) + p ( g ) ; (ii) p(uf) = u p ( f ) for all u > 0. Then the set P of functions f~ VR(X) such that p ( f ) 5 0 is a convex cone. Suppose furthermore that (iii) inff(x) s p ( f ) 5 supf(x) for all f~ V,(X), so that we have X E X
X E X
p(l) = 1. Show that there exists a positive measure p of mass 1 on X such that p ( f ) sp ( f ) for allfc VR(X).If moreover we are given a linear form u on a vector subspace E of VR(X) such that u ( f ) ( p ( f ) for all f~ E, then there exists a measure (L of the above type which extends the form u. (Consider a denumerable total set ( g n ) n ) Oin WR(X), with go = 1 ; use the result of Problem 1 inductively to obtain, on the subspace G of 'e,(X) generated by E and thegn, a linear form u such that -p( -f) 2 u (f)5 p c f )
for allfg G, and deduce that u extends by continuity to a measure on X.) Show that the measure p i s unique if and only ifp(f) p ( - f ) = 0 for allfe E.
+
4. T H E V A G U E T O P O L O G Y
Since the space M,(X) is a subspace of CXC('), we can define the weak topology, i.e., the topology of simple convergence in X c ( X ) (12.15). This topology on M,(X) is called the vague topology. To say that a sequence (p,) of measures on X converges cyaguely to a measure p therefore means that, for each function f E X,(X), the sequence ( p , ( f ) ) converges to p ( f ) in C. (13.4.1 ) Let (p,,)be a sequence of measures on X such that,for each f E X,(X), the sequence (pn(f )) tends to a limit p( f ) in C . Thenf Hp ( f ) is a measure on X and is the vague limit of the sequence (p,). If the pn are all positive, then so is p.
We have already remarked (13.1) that, for each compact subset K of X, X ( X ;K) is a Banach space and the restrictions of the p, to X ( X ;K) are continuous linear forms. Hence it follows from the Banach-Steinhaus theorem (12.16.5) that the restriction of p to X ( X ;K) is continuous, and therefore that p is a measure on X (and clearly a positive measure if the ,u, are positive). We recall (12.15) that a subset H of M,(X) is said to be vaguely bounded (or just bounded, if there is no risk of ambiguity) if, for each f E X,(X), we have sup I p ( f ) l < +a.Every vaguely convergent sequence is vaguely bounded.
PEH
(13.4.2) Let H be a bounded subset of M,(X). (i) For each conipact subset K of X, there exists a real number cK > 0 such that, for each p E H and each,f E .X,(X), we have Ip(.f>I 5
cK
(and therefore (13.3.2.1), 1p1(1 f I) 5 cK 11 f 11).
llfil
4 THE VAGUE TOPOLOGY
109
(ii) The vague closure of H in M,(X) is a compact metrizable space with respect to the vague topology. (i) This is an immediate consequence of the Banach-Steinhaus theorem (12.1 6.4). (ii) Let (U,) be a sequence of relatively compact open sets in X which cover X and are such that 0, c U,,+l (3.18.3). Since every compact subset K of X is contained in some U, (3.16), each space X ( X ;K) can be identified hence with a closed with a closed subspace of one of the Banach spaces W(u,,), subspace of X ( X ;0,).Now we know (7.4.4) that %(On)is separable, hence the same is true of X ( X ;0,) (3.10.9). Let (fmn)mL1 be a dense sequence in X ( X ;On).To show that H is metrizable it is enough to show that the vague topology on H can be defined by the pseudo-distances I(f, p - v ) l (12.4.6). This means that if g i (1 5 i 5 p ) is a finite sequence of functions belonging to X,(X), if p o is an element of H and r a real number >O, there exists a finite number of functions f,,,, (1 =< k =< q ) such that the relations p E H and I(fmknk P - ~ o > 5 l ! ~ r(1 5 k _I 4 ) imply I(gi P - PO)I 5 r (1 5 i 5 P ) . But the g i all belong to X ( X ;0,)for some fixed n, and the set of restrictions is equicontinuous, by (i) above and (12.15.7.1). of the p E H to X ( X ;D,,) Hence the assertion follows from (12.15.7). It remains to show (by the same reasoning as in (12.15.7)) that, when we identify H with its image L in the product space C N x Nby means of the mapping PI--+(( f,, , p)), L is closed in CNx .' If ( p k ) is a sequence of points of H such that each of the sequences ((fmn, p k ) ) k L 1 is convergent, then it follows from (12.15.7) that, in each X ( X ;On),the restrictions of the pk converge to a continuous linear form. Hence the sequence (pk) converges vaguely to a measure on X. Q.E.D. 3
9
We shall see later (13.20) that condition (i) in (13.4.2) can also be written in the form IpI(K) 5 cK for each measure p E H. Notice also that (13.4.2(ii)) implies (13.4.1) as a particular case. In particular: (1 3.4.3) Let v be a positive measure on X . Then the set of complex measures p such that lpl 5 v is metrizable and compact with respect to the vague topology.
For this set is evidently bounded and closed in M,.(X) in the vague topology. It should be noted that a bounded set of measures does not necessarily satisfy the hypothesis of (13.4.3).
110
Xlll INTEGRATION
(13.4.4) Let (pn) be an increasing sequence of real measures on X such that, for each function f 2 0 belonging to XR(X), the sequence ( p n ( f ) )is bounded above in R. Then the sequence ( p n ) has a vague limit in MR(X) which is also its least upper bound f o r the order-relation on MR(X).
For each function f 2 0 in XR(X), the sequence (pn(f)) is increasing and bounded above in R, hence (4.2.1) has a limit p ( f ) in R which is equal to sup p n ( f ) .Since every function belonging to X,(X) is a linear combination n
of four functions 2 0 belonging to X,(X), it follows that the sequence (p") is vaguely convergent (13.4.1), and it is clear that p is its least upper bound, by the definition of the order-relation on MR(X). (13.4.5) I f a series of positive measures on X , with general term p n , is such that, for each f 2 0 in X,(X), the series with general term p,,(f) 2 0 is convergent in R, then the series with general term p n is vaguely convergent in MR(X), and its sum p = p,,is such that p( f)= 2 p n ( f ) f o rall f E X,(X).
1 n
n
Apply (13.4.4) to the partial sums of the series.
PROBLEMS
+
1. Let be Lebesgue measure on R, let ,u be its restriction to R t =lo, m [, and let g be the function X H l/x on Rf Show that the measure g . ,u cannot be extended to a measure on R (cf. (17.9)).
.
2. On the real line R,show that the sequence of Dirac measures E. (unit mass at the point +n) converges vaguely to 0. Give an example of a sequence (f.) in Xc(R) which converges to 0 in the Frkchet space Qc(R) (12.14.6) but is such that the sequence (<&",fn>) tends to 1.
3. Let X be. a compact space. (a) Show that if (f.)is a sequence of functions in the Banach space Vc(X) which tends to 0 and if (p.) is a sequence of measures on X which tends vaguely to 0, then the sequence ((p&)) tends to 0 (use (13.4.2)). (b) Suppose that X is infinite. Let V be a neighborhood of 0 in M(X) for the vague topology, defined by a finite number of inequalities I +,&)I 5 1 (1 5 j 5 m), and let f be any function belonging to Uc(X) which is not a linear combination of the fJ . Show that there exists ,u E V such that I<,u,f>i is arbitrarily large (cf. Section 12.15, Problem 1). Deduce that the mapping ( , u , f )H ( p ,f) of Uc(X) x M(X) into C is not continuous, and hence (using (a)) that the space M(X) is not metrizable with respect to the vague topology.
4 THE VAGUE TOPOLOGY
111
4. Let X be a compact space. Show that the topology induced on M+(X) by the vague topology is separable, metrizable and locally compact. (Observe that for each po E M+(X) there exists a neighborhood V of po in M(X) such that V n M+(X) is , of Uc(X) x M+(X) into C is bounded.) Deduce that the mapping ( p , f ) ~ ( pf) continuous. Deduce that if X is locally compact but not compact, then M+(X) is still metrizable with respect to the topology induced by the vague topology, but is not separable. 5. (a) Let X be a locally compact space. Show that if (9") is a sequence of functions in the FrCchet space U,(X) tending to 0 and (pn)is a sequence of measures on X tending vaguely to 0, then the sequence of measures (gn . pn)tends vaguely to 0. (b) Show that if M +(X) is endowed with the topology induced by the vague topology, the mapping (p,g ) HQ ' p of M +(X)x Vc(X) into M(X) is continuous. (c) Suppose that X is compact and infinite. Show that the mapping ( p ,g ) ~g . p of M(X) x U,(X) into M(X) is not continuous when M(X) is endowed with the vague topology (argue as in Problem 3(b)).
6. Let X be the unit interval [0, I ] in R. Show that the sequence (p.) tends vaguely to 0 (a) Let p n be the measure eo but that the sequence (Ip,I) tends vaguely to 2e0. (b) Let h be Lebesgue measure on X , and let g n ( x )= sin nx. Show that the sequence of positive measures p n = (I - gn). h converges vaguely to h as n a,but does not converge to h with respect to the topology defined by the norm (5.7.1) on M(X). --f
+
7. Let X be a compact space and p a positive measure of mass 1 on X. A sequence (x,) of points of X is said to be equirepartitioned with respect to p if the sequence of measures ( n - l ( e x L . . . ex")) converges vaguely to p. Show that a necessary and sufficient condition for this to be the case is that, if ( X ) is any total sequence (5.4) in U,-(X), then for each k the sequence ( n - ' ( f x ( x , ) . .. +fx(x.))) converges to jfx d p . Consider in particular the case where X = [0, I ] and xn = no - [no] (where [ t ] is the integral part of a real number t ) . Show that if 6 is irrational, then the sequence (x.) is equirepartitioned with respect to Lebesgue measure (" Bohl's theorem "). (Use the sequence of functions X ( x ) = e Z n i k1x .
+ +
+
8. Let X , Y be two locally compact spaces and n : X + Y a proper continuous mapping (Section 12.7, Problem 2). For each function g E X ( Y ) , we have g n E X ( X ) . If p is any measure on X, then the image of p under n is defined to be the measure g ~ p ( 0gn) on Y, and is denoted by n(p). The mapping p ~ n ( pof) M(X) into M(Y) is linear and vaguely continuous. Suppose that X is compact. Let r be a set of continuous mappings of X into X, each pair of which commute. Let I?' be the set of linear mappings of the form p ~ n - ' ( p+ u(p) + ... + u " - ' ( p ) ) of M(X) into M(X), where u E I? and n is any positive integer, and let I?" be the set of all compositions of any finite number of elements of I". If K is the convex and vaguely compact set of positive measures of total mass 1 on X, then u(K) c K for all u E I?". Show that the sets u(K), where u E P', form a filter base in K consisting of vaguely compact sets, and deduce that the intersection I of these sets is nonempty. Show finally that each measure p E I is invariant under I?, i.e., that u(p) = p for all u E I? ("Markoff-Kakutani theorem"). (Observe that, by definition, there exists for each n a measure V E K such that p = n-'(v u(v) ... u"-'(v)), and evaluate iiu(p) - pil.) Consider the case of a compact commutative group operating on itself by translation (cf. (14.1)). 0
+
+ +
112
9.
XI11 INTEGRATION
I f f is any real-valued function on I = [0, 11, the nth Bernsrein polynomiul off is defined to be
(a) I f f 2 0 on I, then Bn,, 2 0 on I, and B,. is equal to the constant 1. Deduce that 5 Ilfll in 30). IlB~.~lI (b) Show by induction on k that, if&@) = f k , we have
+
B d r ) = %. n t k p k , "(0, (*I> where ak, ,, = (1 - (k - l ) / n ) ~ ~ -and ~ , uo, = 1, and Px. is a polynomial of degree s k - 1 whose coefficients are less than Ck/n in absolute value, where ck is a constant independent of n. (Differentiate the equation ( * k ) with respect to t , then multiply through by t . ) (c) Deduce from (b) and Weierstrass' theorem that, for every continuous function f c %'(I), the sequence (B".,) converges uniformly t o f o n 1. 10.
Let X be a metrizable compact space, let (f.).,,, be a sequence of complex-valued continuous functions on X, and let ( c . ) . , ~ be a sequence of complex numbers. (a) In order that there should exist a complex measure p on X such that p(f.) = c, for all n , it is necessary and sufficient that there should exist a number A > 0 with the following property: for every finite sequence of complex numbers, we have
(Use the Hahn-Banach theorem.) (b) Suppose that the fk are real-valued, the numbers ck real, and fo = I . Then there exists a positiue measure p on X such that p(fn)= c. for all n if and only if, for each sequence (A,),,,
2
I=O
11.
/\k
ck
of real numbers such that
"
1X,fk(x) 2 0 for all x E X, we have
k=O
2 o (cf. Section I3.3, Problem 2).
In Problem 10, take X = [0, I ] and For each sequence (c,) of scalars, put
f.(r)
= 1"
("Hausdorff's moment problem").
(a) Show that there exists a complex measure p on X such that p(fn)= c, for all n if and only if there exists a number A > 0 such that
(Observe that Akc. must be the value of p for the polynomial t"(1 - t ) k , and use Problem 9(b) by remarking that, for each real polynomial P, there exists a constant Cp such that I 1 Bn,P - - CPS P 5 B",P - CP
+
for all n.) (b) There exists a posiriue measure p on X such that p(f,)= c. for all n if and only if Akc. 2 0 for all k 2 0 and all n >= 0 (same method).
5 UPPER A N D LOWER INTEGRALS
113
12. Let X be a compact space. Show that in M(X) the set of positive measures with finite support and total mass 1 is dense (with respect to the vague topology) in the set P of all positive measures with total mass 1. (Let U be a neighborhood of p E P with respect to the vague topology, consisting of measures v E P such that Ip(fi)- v(fi)l 5 6, with fi E %‘,(X).Consider a continuous partition (g,) of unity and points U, E X such that Ifi(x) -Cfi(u,)g,(x)l 5 6 for all i . ) J
13. Let X be the unit interval [0, 11 in R.Show that the set K of Dirac measures E , (x E X) is vaguely compact, and that in M(X) the Lebesgue measure lies in the vague closure of the convex hull of K, but does not lie in the convex hull of K.
5. UPPER A N D LOWER INTEGRALS WITH RESPECT TO A POSITIVE MEASURE
In Sections (13.5) to (13.14)(including the problems), p denotes a positive measure on a locally compact space X. We shall show (13.7.3)that p can be extended from .XR(X) to a vector subspace YA(X, p) of RX,depending on p and containing (and in general distinct from) .XR(X),in such a way that this extension (also denoted by p) is apositive linear form on 2’A(X, p) (i.e., p takes values 2 0 on functions 20 belonging to Y ; ( X , p)) and possesses the fundamental property of passage to the limit for increasing sequences: that is to say, if (f,) is an increasing sequence of functions in 9A(X, p) whose upper envelopef (12.7.5)also belongs to Y A ( X , p), then we have lim p(fn) = &-). n+m
Let 9 (or 4(X)) be the set of all functions f : X + which are lower semicontinuous on X and bounded below by a function belonging to X,(X) (this implies that f ( x ) > - cx) for all x E X ; but we can have f ( x ) = + 00 at some points x E X : indeed, the constant function equal to + 00 belongs to 9). Every function f 2 0 which is lower semicontinuous on X belongs to 4 . For every f E 9,we put
this is a real number, or +a. Clearly iff E .X,(X) we have p * ( f ) = p ( f ) ; iff, g E 9 a n d f s g , we have p * ( f ) 5 p*(g); and for any real number a > 0, we have p*(af) = a p * ( f ) for all f E 4 .
(13.5.2) Let (f,) be an increasing sequence of functions belonging to 4 , and = supf, (so that f E 4 (12.7.6)).Then
let f
n
Xlll INTEGRATION
114
Suppose first of all that f E .X,(X) and that f,E X,(X) for all n. It is clear that the supports of all thef, are contained in the same compact set K = Supp(f) u Supp(f,). By Dini's theorem (7.2.2), the sequence (f.)converges uniformly t o f o n X. The formula (13.5.2.1) then follows from the fact that the restriction of p to X ( X ;K) is a continuous linear form on this Banach space. Now pass to the general case. Clearly we have p*(f,) 5 p * ( f ) for all n. Hence it is enough to show that, for each function u E X,(X) such that u 55 we have p*(u) S sup p*(f,). Now by (12.7.8) we know that, for each function,f, , there exists an increasir.5 sequence (gm,JnlZlof functions belonging to X,(X) such that f, = sup gmn. We have f = sup gmn, hence also m
m, n
f = sup h, , where h, = sup g p q. The functions h, clearly belong to X,(X) n
p l n , qsn
and form an increasing sequence. Since u SJ, we have u = sup(inf(u, h,,)); the n
sequence of functions inf(u, h,) is increasing and belongs to X,(X);since also u E X,(X), the first part of the proof shows that p*(u) = sup p*(inf(u, h,,)); n
but since h, S.d, we have p*(inf(rr, h,)) 5 p*(f,), and therefore finally P*@) 5 SUP P*(f,). Q.E.D. n
We remark that because the functions in 9 never take the value -03, the sumfl +fi of two such functions is defined at every point of X, and belongs to 9 (12.7.5).
We may write . f l
=
lim g, and f2 = lim h,, where (g,) and (h,) are two
n-. w
n+ a,
increasing sequences of functions belonging to X,(X) (12.7.8). Hence we have fl +f2= lim (g, h,) (4.1.8). Since p ( g , h,) = p(g.) + p(h,), the ti+
m
+
+
result follows from (13.5.2) and (4.1.8). Let (t,) be any sequence whose terms are real numbers 20, or +a. Since the partial sums s, = t , + -.-+ r, are defined (4.1.8) and form an increasing sequence, this sequence has a limit in R (4.2.1), denoted by
m
C t,
n= 1
and called the sum of the series with general term t,. For every sequence
(f,)of positiue functions belonging to I, the function
m
XH
c f , ( x ) is therefore n= 1
5 UPPER A N D LOWER INTEGRALS m
defined, and is denoted by
115
f n ; also it belongs to 9 (12.7.6). If we apply
n= 1
(13.5.2) to the sequence of partial sums
cfn,and (13.5.3) to each of the N
n= 1
terms in this partial sum, we obtain the following corollary: (13.5.4)
Zf(fn)ntl is a sequence of functions 20 belonging to 9,then
Now consider an arbitrary mapping f of X into R. There always exist functions h E 9 such that h 2 J for example the constant function equal to +co. Put p*(f) =
(13.5.5)
inf
htj,he/
p*(h);
this number p * ( f ) is called the upper integral o f f with respect to the measure p. Iff E 9 it is clear that this definition agrees with the preceding one. Here the value of p * ( f ) can be any element of R. The relation f 6 g implies p * ( f ) 5 p*(g). For any scalar a > 0 we have p*(af) = ap*(f).
+
(13.5.6) Ifthe sum f l f , of two mappings of X into R is definedat allpoints of X , and if p*( f l ) > - 00 and p*( f,) > - 03, then
+ f J 5 P*(fl) + P*(f,).
P*(fl
This is obvious if one of the numbers p * ( f i ) , p * ( f 2 ) is +a.If not, given any a > p * ( f i ) and b > p*(f2), there exist h,, h, in 9 such that h,, f , 5 h, and p*(hl) 5 a, p*(h,) b. It follows that h, + h, 2 f l +f , fi and p*(h, + h,) 5 a + b by (13.5.3). Hence the result. (I3.5.7) Zf (f.) is any increasing sequence of mappings of X into p*( f n ) > - 03 for all suficiently large n, then
1
P* SUPfn (
n
The inequality p* supf ( n
W
such that
= SUP P*(fn) = lim p*(fn)* n+
n
m
2 sup p*(fn) is clear. Let us prove the reverse n)
n
inequality. We may assume that sup p*(fn) < n
+
03,
otherwise there is
nothing to prove. By hypothesis, we may therefore assume that sup p * ( f . ) n
and all the p * ( f . ) arefinite. For each E > 0, we shall show that there exists an
116
Xlll INTEGRATION
increasing sequence (g,) of functions belonging to 9 such that for each n we have f , 5 gn and p*(gn) 5 p*(f,) + E . Then, if we put f = supf, and g = sup g, , we shall have g E 9,f 5 g, p*(g) = sup p*(gn) 5 sup p*(f,)
+E
by virtue of (13.5.2),and finally p * ( f ) 5 p * ( g ) 5 sup p * ( f , ) + E . Since
was
n
n
n
E
n
arbitrary, this will complete the proof. By definition, for each n there exists h, E Y such that f n 5 h, and p*( f , ) 5 p*(hn)5 p*(f,) 2 - k Put g, = sup(h,, . . . , I?,,), so that gnE 9 (12.7.5).Clearly the sequence (g,) is increasing, and f,5 gn. We shall show by induction on n that
+
This is evident from the definitions when n = 1. Suppose that (13.5.7.1)is true, and remark that gn+l= sup(hn+lrg,) and f , 5 inf(h,+,, gn). Since the functions h,+l and g, do not take the value -co,we have SUp(hn+ 1,
gn>
+ inf(hn+
13
Sn) = h n +
1
+ gn
and therefore, by virtue of (13.5.3)and the fact that p*(g,,) and p*(h,+l) are finite,
by the inductive hypothesis (1 3.5.7.1).
Q.E.D.
It should be noted that for a decreasing sequence (fn), it is no.t necessarily true that p* infS, = inf p*(f,), even if all the numbers p*(fn) are $finite
L1
(Section 13.8,Problem 13). (13.5.8) Z f ( f n ) is any sequence of functions 20,then
5
UPPER AND LOWER INTEGRALS
117
For each integer N 2 1 it follows from (13.5.7) that
now apply (12.5.7) to the increasing sequence of partial sums
N
Cfn.
n= 1
R, the mapping
If (f n )is any sequence of mappings of X into
x H l i m inff,(x)
(resp. x H l i m supfn(x))
n+w
n-t m
is defined for all x E X. It is denoted by lirn inff, (resp. lirn supf,). n+m
(13.5.9)
n- m
(Fatou’s lemma) r f ( f n )is any sequence ofjiunctions 2 0 , then p* lirn inff,,
(
n-tm
1 s lirn inf p * ( f , ) . n+m
For each n 2 1 , let gn = inf (f,+,). Clearly we have p*(gn) 5 inf p * ( f , + & , P20
and gn 2 0; since the sequence (gn) is increasing and lirn inf f ,
p* lirn inff, n+m
= sup g n , it
n+ m
foIlows from (13.5.7)that
(
P20
= sup p*(g,) 1
5 sup (inf p*(fn+,))
n
pZ0
n
= lirn inf p*(f,). n+ w
Iff: X + R is any mapping, we define p * ( f ) = - p * ( - f ) ; this number is called the lower integral off with respect to the measure p. All the properties above which were proved for the upper integral can be immediately translated into properties of the lower integral. In particular, if we put -9 = 9 (or Y ( X ) ) , then Y is the set of all upper semicontinuous functions on X which are bounded above by a function belonging to X,(X) (which implies that they do not take the value + 00). For all functions f E 9, we have
CL*U)=
inf
9 b f 9 9 E XR(X)
P(S>
and for all f:X + R we have P*(f) =
(13.5.10)
SUP P*(h).
hsf,heY
I f f is any mapping of X into R, then p * ( f ) 5 p * ( f ) .
118
Xlll INTEGRATION
By virtue of the definitions, it is enough to show that if u E 9, u E 9 and u 6 u, then p*(u) p*(u). Since - u E 9 it follows that u - u = u ( - u ) is defined throughout X,belongs to Y and is 20;hence
+
0 5 p*(u - u) = p*(u
+ (- u)) = p*(u) + p*( =p*(d
- u)
- P*b)
by virtue of (13.5.3). We shall oftenwrite j * f d p or s * f ( x ) dp(x) (resp. S*fdpor f t f ( x ) dp(x)) instead of p * ( f ) (resp. p*(f)). For any subset A of X, we put p*(A) = p*(qA) and p,(A) = p*(qA), where qA is the characteristic function of A (12.7). These numbers p*(A) and p,(A) are 20 (possibly +a);they are called, respectively, the outer measure and inner measure of A. Example (13.5.11) Let I be Lebesgue measure on R and let I = ] a , b[ be an open interval in R. We shall show that I*(I) = b - a (which is equal to + 03 if b = + 03 or a = - a).If a < a' < b' < b, then there exists a continuous mappingfof R into the unit interval [0, 11, with support contained in [a, b ] , and equal to 1 throughout [a', b'] (4.5.2). We have J -00 + m f ( t )dt 2 b' - a'. Conversely, for each function g E XX,(R) such that 0 5 g 5 q r ,we have / +- mm g ( t )dt 5 b - a. Hence it follows that I*(I) = b - a. Now let U be any open set in R. Then its connected components (3.19) are open intervals ((3.19.1) and (3.19.5)), and the set of connected components is at most denumerable, because each component contains a point of the denumerable set Q, and the components are pairwise disjoint. Hence if they are r k = ] & , bk[, then q u = C qlk,and therefore ((12.7.4) and (13.5.4)) k
n*(u)= 1 ( b k - ak). k
(13.5.11.1)
6. NEGLIGIBLE F U N C T I O N S A N D SETS
A mapping f : X --t R is said to be negligible (with respect to the measure
p), or p-negligible, if p * ( l f l ) = 0. Then ufis also negligible for all a # 0 in
and if 191 5
If[,
then g is negligible.
R;
6 NEGLIGIBLE FUNCTIONS AND SETS
(13.6.1) I f ( f . ) is a sequence of negligible functions 20, then
m
119
fn is negligible.
n=l
This follows immediately from (13.5.8).
A subset N of X is said to be negligible (with respect to p) or p-negligible if its characteristic function cp, (12.7) is p-negligible. Clearly any subset of a negligible set is negligible. (1 3.6.2)
A denumerable union of negligible sets is negligible.
For if ( N k )is a sequence of negligible sets and N (P,
= sup cpNk k
=
5 1 q N kand , the result follows from (13.6.1).
u
N k , we have
k
k
For example, with respect to Lebesgue measure A, every set { t } consisting of a single real number is negligible. For if E > 0 there exists a function f E XX,(R)with values in [0, I] which is equal to 1 at the point t and vanishes on the complement of the interval [t - E , t + E ] , and therefore L*((P{f,)
I 4f1 I 28.
Hence, by (13.6.2), it follows that every denumerable subset of R (for example, the set Q of rational numbers) is negligible with respect to Lebesgue measure. One can also give examples of nondenumerable sets in R which are negligible with respect to Lebesgue measure (Section 13.8, Problem 4).
A property P(x) of the points of X is said to be true almost everywhere (with respect to p) if the complement of the set of points for which P(x) is true is pnegligibie. (13.6.3) A mapping f :X -+ everywhere.
(P,
is negligible if and only
if it is zero almost
Let N be the set of all x E X such that If(x)l > 0. Then we have 5 sup nl f 1, and If1 5 sup ncp,, hence the result follows from (13.5.7). n
n
(1 3.6.4) I f a mapping f : X -+ R issuch that p*( f)< + cx) (resp. p * ( f ) > - a), then f ( x ) < co (resp. f ( x ) > - a)almost everywhere.
+
It is enough to prove the assertion relating to the upper integral. By hypothesis, there exists a function h E 9 such that f 5 h and p*(h) < + 00. We may therefore limit ourselves to the case where f E 9,and since there is
120
Xlll
INTEGRATION
then a function u E .X,(X) such thatf - u >= 0, we may also assume t h a t f z 0. Now let N be the set of points x E X such thatf(x) = + 03 ; we have ncp, 5 f for all integers n > 0, hence np*(cp,) 5 p*(f), and the hypothesis therefore implies that p*((pN) = 0. The relation “f(x) = g(x) almost everywhere in X ” is an equivalence relation between mappings of X into a set E, because the union of two negligible sets is negligible. We say then that f and g are equivalent (with respect to p) or p-equivalent, and we shall denote by f the equivalence class of a mapping f :X --+ E. A mapping f :A -,E, where A is a subset of X, is said (by abuse of language) to be defined almost everywhere in X if X - A is negligible. The equivalence class of such a mapping f is then defined to be the equivalence class of any mapping of X into E which extendsf; as before, we denote the equivalence class by f. Two functions f, g defined almost everywhere are said to be equivalent i f f = 8; this means that the set of points x E X at which f and g are both defined andf(x) = g(x) has a negligible set for its complement. (1 3.6.5)
Let f,g be two equivalent mappings of X into 8. Then p*( f) = p*(g).
Let N be the negligible set of points x E X such that f (x) # g(x). Since the functions f, g and sup(f, g ) are equal on X - N, we may assume that f 5 g. Let h be the negligible function which is equal to co at the points of N, and to 0 elsewhere. If v E 9 is such t h a t f s v, the function v h is defined at all points of X, and we have g 5 v + h, so that
+
+
by virtue of (13.5.6), because p*(v) > - co. From the definition of p * ( f ) , it follows that p*(g) 5 p * ( f ) and hence that p*(g) = p*(f). Iffis a mapping into 8 which is defined and finite almost everywhere in X, then f is equivalent to afinite function defined on the whole of X. Iff, g are functions defined almost everywhere in X, with values in R, and finite almost everywhere, then the same is true o f f + g andfg, and the equivalence classes of these functions depend only on f and 8. They are denoted by f + and fg, respectively. Iff(x) 5 g(x) almost everywhere, thenfl(x) 5 gl(x) almost everywhere for any functions fl, g1 equivalent to f, g, respectively. In this case we write f ij , and this defines an order relation on the set of equivalence classes (with respect to p ) of mappings of X into W.
7 INTEGRABLE FUNCTIONS A N D SETS
121
7. INTEGRABLE F U N C T I O N S A N D SETS
Wehaveseen (13.5.10) that every function f:X + R satisfies p * ( f ) S p * ( f ) . The function f is said to be integrable (with respect to p) or p-integrable if p * ( f ) and p * ( f ) are finite and equal. Their common value is then called the integral off with respect to p, and is written p ( f ) , or (S, p), or j f dp, or
1f ( x ) dp(x). Clearly every function f
.X,(X) is integrable and its integral is the value of p atf, so that our notation is consistent. An integrable function is therefore finite almost everywhere (13.6.4), but a bounded function is not necessarily integrable. For example, a constant nonIxl), is not integrable zero function on R, or the continuous function 1/(1 (with respect to Lebesgue measure) (cf. (13.20)). In view of the definitions in (13.5), we have the following criterion for integrability : E
+
(13.7.1) (i) For a function f :X -+ R to be integrable, it is necessary and sufficient that, given any E > 0, there should exist g E 9’and h E J such that g S f h and p*(h) - p*(g) 5 E (or, equivalently (13.5.3), p*(h - g ) 6 e). (ii) I f f is integrable, there exists a decreasing sequence (h,) of functions belonging to 9 and an increasing sequence (g,) of functions belonging to Y such that g, 5 f 5 h, for all n and lim p*(hn) = lim p*(gn) = Af).
n+ w
n+
m
(i) The condition implies that p*(h) and p J g ) are necessarily finite (and therefore so are p*( f ) and p*( f ) ) , and that p*( f ) = p*( f ) . (ii) For each n there exists h; E J and g; E 9’ such that g; S f S hi and p ( f ) - n-l S p*(gA) 5 p ( f ) 5 p*(h:) 5 p ( f ) + n-’. The required conditions are then satisfied by taking h, = inf(h;, . . . , h@ and g, = sup(g;, .. ., g;). Iff is integrable, then clearly so is any function f l equivalent to f (13.6), and we have f i dp = f dp (which we denote also by p ( f ) ) . It is now clear how integrability should be defined for functions defined almost everywhere in X: such a function f is integrable if the functions equivalent to f and defined on the whole of X are integrable. The number p(f) is also denoted by f dp,
s
s
f
or j f W dP(X), or A f ) ,or (S, P>. (13.7.2) For a mapping f : X + to be integrable it is necessary and suficient that, given any E > 0, there exists a function u E .X,(X) such that cc*(lf - 4) S E.
Xlll INTEGRATION
122
Necessity. Suppose that f is integrable, then there exist functions g E 9’and h E 9 such that g 5 f 5 h and p*(h - g ) 5 +E. Also ((13.5,l) and (13.5.3)) there exists u E X,(X) such that u 5 h and p*(h - u) +&. Since If - uI 5 Ih - uI + Ih - 91, it follows by (13.5.3) that
s
s
p*(lf - 4) p*(lh - 4)+ p*(lh - g l ) S
6.
Suficiency. If u E .X,(X) is such that p * ( l f - ul) 5 E , then by definition (13.5.5) there exists a function v E 9 such that If - uj v and p*(v) 5 2 ~ . But the relation - u 5 f - u 5 v can be written in the form
s
+ u5f5 v + u have - u + u E 9’and v + u E .f (12.7.5), -v
(u being finite); also we p*(v u - (- u u ) ) = 2p*(v)
+
+
5 4 ~ hence ; f is integrable.
and
s
The set L?i(X, p) (also denoted by L?A(p) or 2’:) offinite p-integrable functions on X is a vector space over R,and the mapping f H f dp is a positive ( I 3.7.3)
s
linear form on 9; (i.e.) the relation f 2 0 implies f dp 2 0).
Iff is finite and integrable, then clearly so is af for every scalar a E R, and we have af dp = a f dp. Iff and g are finite and integrable, it follows from (13.5.6) applied to f and g and to -f and -9 that
I
s
s s s* f&+ B 4 - I
(f+B)dPS
which completes the proof.
s*
(f+B)dPS
s s f4+
94.4
It follows that iff and g are integrable functions (finite or not) on X with values in R, then f + g (which is defined almost everywhere) is integrable, and that
J ( f -k 9 ) dP = / f
+ 1 9 4.
(13.7.4) I f f is integrable, then so are If I, f
+
and f -, and we haue
(13.7.4.1)
I f f and g are integrable, then so are sup(f, g ) and inf(A 9).
If
uE
X,(X) is such that p * ( l f - ul) 5 E , then since
I If1 - I4 I S I f - 4,
7 INTEGRABLE FUNCTIONS AND SETS
)I
it follows that p*(I If1 - ( u J 5 E , which by (13.7.2) shows that rable. Moreover, we have -If[ 5 f 5 If1 and hence
If1
123
is integ-
Ifl) = -PL(ISI) 5 P*(f) = C lm 5 P*(lfl> = A l f I)? which establishes (13.7.4.1). Since f = f ( f + If[) and f - = +(If1 -f), it /A*(-
+
follows thatf' and f - are integrable (13.7.3). Iff and g are integrable, then f - g is defined almost everywhere and integrable, and the functions (everywhere defined) sup(f, g ) and inf(f, g ) are equivalent respectively to the functions (defined almost everywhere) + ( f g Ifgl) and +(f g - I f - 91). Hence they are integrable.
+ +
+
(13.7.5) For a function h E 9 (resp. g E 9) to be integrable, it is necessary and suflcient that p*(h) < + 00 (resp. p*(g) > - 00).
For if p*(h) <
+
00,
then for any
u S h and p*(h - u ) = p*(h) - p(u)
S
E
> 0 there exists u E XR(X)such that
by (13.5.1) and (13.5.3). The result now follows from the definition of integrable functions. E,
A subset A of X is said to be integrable if its characteristic function cpA is integrable, or equivalently if p*(A) and p*(A) are jinite and equal. Their common value cp d is then denoted by p(A) and is called the measure of A. We have p ( 0 ) = 0. The negligible sets are the same as the integrable sets with measure zero. If A is integrable, then so is every set B for which A n eB and B n EA are negligible, and p(B) = p(A).
1.p
(1 3.7.6) I f A and B are integrable sets, then A v B, A n B and A n CB are integrable.
This follows from the formulas (12.7.3). (13.7.7) Every compact set is integrable. For an open set U to be integrable it is necessary and suficient that p*(U) < + 00. In particular, every relatively compact open set is integrable.
This follows immediately from (1 3.7.5) and (12.7.4).
Example (13.7.8) With respect to Lebesgue measure on R, every bounded interval with endpoints a, b is integrable and its measure is Ib - a / , by virtue of
124
Xlll
INTEGRATION
(13.5.11) and the fact that all finite sets are negligible (for Lebesgue measure) (13.6). If I = [a, b] is a bounded interval, the “Dirichlet function” (3.11) (P, - ( P , ( P ~ (which is 0 at the rational points of I and on the complement of I, and 1 at the irrational points of I) is integrable, and its integral is b - a, since the set Q is negligible (13.6). (13.7.9) A subset A of X is integrable i f and only i f , given any E > 0, there exists a compact set K and an open set G such that K c A c G and p*(G - K) E.
The condition is sufficient by virtue of the definition of integrable functions and (12.7.4). Suppose conversely that A is integrable, and let E be such that 0 < E < 1. By hypothesis, there exists h E 9 such that ( P 5 ~ h and
s
- (PA) dp 5
Let G be the set of points x E X such that h(x) > 1 - E ; then G is open (12.7.2) and contains A. Clearly h 2 (1 - E ) ( P ~ ,hence
I
Also there exists g E Y such that g 5 ( P and ~ ( q A- g ) dp 5 E , and by the definition of Y the set of points x E X such that g ( x ) > 0 is relativelycompact. Choose 6 > 0 so that Sp(A) 5 E , and let K be the set of all x E X such that g ( x ) 2 S; then K is closed in X (12.7.2) and therefcre compact (3.17.3), since it is contained in a relatively compact set. Clearly we have K c A and g 5 ( P ~ Sq,, where B = A - K ; hence
+
j g dp
S p(K) + M B ) S p(K) + M A ) S
and finally p(A) 5 j g dp
p(K)
+ E,
+ I p(K) + 2 ~ .
Q.E.D.
E
There exist bounded subsets of R which are not integrable with respect to Lebesgue measure (Section 13.21, Problem 6). (13.7.10) Let n : X -+X‘ be a homeomorphism. It follows directly from the definitions that iff’ is any function on X with values in R, we have
j*Yd(nW) = J>ft
.
O
dP.
125
8 LEBESGUE’S CONVERGENCE THEOREMS
The function f ’ is n(p)-integrable if and only if ,f’ that case we have J f ‘ d(n(p))= f ’ o 71) dp.
I(
0
71
is p-integrable, and in
8. LEBESGUE’S C O N V E R G E N C E T H E O R E M S
(13.8.1) Let (f,) be an increasing sequence of integrable functions. For supf, to be integrable, it is necessary and sufficient that n
and if this condition is satisfied we have
(13.8.1.1) Since J*f,dp > - co for all n, we have
j*(sup f.) n
dp
= sup
/fndp
n
(13.5.7).This already shows that the condition is necessary. Conversely, if the condition is satisfied, let f = supf , . Then, given any E > 0, there exists n n
such that the functi0n.f -f, (which is defined almost everywhere because f and f n are finite almost everywhere (13.6.4))satisfies
(13.5.6). But there exists a function (13.7.2),hence by (13.5.6)we have
uE
X,(X) such that J Ifn - uI dp 5 E
and the result follows by (13.7.2). There is of course a corresponding theorem for decreasing sequences of integrable functions, obtained by replacing f , by -A in (13.8.1). (13.8.2) Let (f,) be any sequence of integrablefunctions. In order thatf = sup fn
should be integrable, it is necessary and suficient that there should exist a g dp < + 00 and f n 5 g almost everywhere. function g 2 0 such that
I*
The condition is obviously necessary (take g =f+).Conversely, if it is satisfied, let gn = sup fk . Then g, is integrable (13.7.4) and f = sup gn . 1S k S n
n
Xlll INTEGRATION
126
<s*
Since the sequence (gn) is increasing and s g n dp = follows from (1 3.8.1).
gn dp <
+ 03,
the result
(13.8.3) Let (f,)be a sequence of integrable functions, and suppose that there
s*
+
exists a function h 2 0 such that h dp < 00 and - h S f , S h almost everywhere, for all n. Then the functions lirn inf f,and lirn supfn are integrable, n-t w
and we have (13.8.3.1) j ( l i z F f f n ) dp
s
5 lirn inf f , n-m
dp
1
s l i m s u p f,dp n+ m
n+ m
<=
ji
limsupf,
dp.
n-tm
It is enough to prove that lim inff, is integrable and that the left-hand n+ m
inequality in (13.8.3.1) is valid; the other assertions then follow by replacing f , by - f n . Let gn = inff,,,. It follows from (13.8.2) applied to the sequence PZO
(-fn+,),20 and from the hypothesis f,,, 2 -h, that gn is integrable, and clearly d p 5 Ifn+. dp for all p 2 0, so that sg,, dp 5 inf Ifn+. dp. The
19,
P20
sequence (9,) is increasing; we have gn5 h for all n, and by definition (12.7.10), lim inf f, = sup g,,. Hence it follows from (13.8.1) that lim inf f,is integrable n--* m
and that
n-+ w
n
ji
lim inf f, dp = sup n-+m
n
j
g, d p
5 sup n
= lirn inf n+ m
J
f, dp.
(13.8.4) (Dominated convergence theorem) Let (f,) be a sequence of integrable functions I. suppose that lirnf,(x) =f( x ) exists almost everywhere n-t m
s*
g dp < and that there exists a function g 2 0 such that almost everywhere. for all n. Then f is integrable and
+ 03
and If,l 6 g
This follows from (13.8.3). In this situation the two extreme terms of (13.8.3.1) are equal, whence the result.
8 LEBESGUE’S CONVERGENCE THEOREMS
127
The usefulness of this theorem is that it does not require the convergence to be unifarm (not even on compact subsets). In particular: (1 3.8.5) Let (f,) be a sequence of integrablefunctions, such that the series with general term If,l dp is convergent. Then the series with general term f,(x) is
i
almost everywhere absolutely convergent in R, and
if we put f ( x )=
c fn(x), m
n=
the function f (defined almost everywhere) is integrable and we have
1
(13.8.5.1 ) (“ term-by-term integration of a series of integrable functions ”).
For each integer N 2 0, let gN
N
2 If,l. The sequence (gN)is an increasing n=
=
1
sequence of integrable functions, and
((13.7.4) and (13.7.3)). By (13.8.1), the function g = lim gN= N-tm
m n= 1
IfnI is
integrable. This implies first of all that g is finite almost everywhere (1 3.6.4), in other words that the series with general term [ f,(x)[ is convergent almost everywhere, which proves the first assertion ((5.3.1) and (5.3.2)). Moreover, for all N we have
c If,l 5 9,from which by (13.8.4) follow the integrability N
n= 1
off and the relation (13.8.5.1). (13.8.6) (i) Let E be a metric space, ( x , Z ) H f (x, z ) a mapping ofX x E into
R, and zo a point of E. Suppose that
for each z E E, the function X H f (x, z ) is integrable ; for almost all x E X, the function Z H f ( x , z ) is continuous at z,, ; there exists an integrable function g 2 0 such that, for all z E E, we have If (x, z)l 5 g(x) almost everywhere in X. Then h(z) = f (x, z ) dp(x) is continuous at zo .
1
(ii) Suppose furthermore that E is an open interval in R and that f satisfies the following conditions : (4) for almost all x derioative D, f ( x , 2);
E
X, the function
ZH
f ( x , z ) is finite and admits a
128
Xlll
INTEGRATION
( 5 ) there exists an integrable function g1 2 0 such that, for all z E E , we have ID2f ( x , z)l 5 g,(x) almost everywhere in X .
Then h is diferentiable at every point of E, and we have
s
h’(d = D 2 f k z ) dP(X)
(13.8.6.1)
(“ differentiation under the integral sign ”).
(iii) Now suppose that E is an open set in C and that f is a mapping of X x E into C,satisfying the following conditions :
(6) for almost all x E X , the function z Hf(x, z ) is analytic in E ; (7) for all z E E , the function x H f ( x , z ) is integrable ; (8) there exists an integrable function g 2 0 such that for all z E E we have If ( x , z)l S g(x) almost euerywhere in X. Then h is analytic in E , and for each integer k > 0 and each point z the function X H Dif ( x , z ) is integrable, and we have
E
E,
J
/.
Dkh(z)= D;f(x, z ) d p ( x ) . (i) By (3.13.14) it is enough to show that, for every sequence (z,) tending to zo in E, we have lim h(z,) = h(zo); and this follows from the hypotheses n-m
and from (13.8.4). (ii) Again by virtue of (3.13.14), it is enough to show that, for each sequence (t,) of real numbers #O and tending to 0, the sequence
has as limit the right-hand side of (13.8.6.1). But it follows from the hypotheses and from (8.5.4) that
for all n, so that the result again follows from (13.8.4). (iii) Let y : t H a + reit (0 5 t 5 2n) be a circuit contained in E. For each z in the interior of the disc Iz - a1 6 r, we have (13.8.6.2)
8 LEBESGUE'S CONVERGENCE THEOREMS
129
from which it follows ((3.16.5) and (8.7.8)) that, for almost all x , the function m
(
f ( x , z ) is the limit of the sequence n-' x h n ( x ) ) where , fkn(X)
k=-1
f(x, a + re2kni/n)re2kni/n = a + re2kniln - z
Applying (13.8.4), it follows that h(z) is the limit of the sequence
and therefore that
which shows that h is analytic in E (9.9.4). By replacing the term I/(( - z) in the right-hand side of (13.8.6.2) by k ! / ( ( - z ) ~ " , we obtain the formula stated for Dkh(z). (13.8.7) (i)
I f (A,) is a sequence of integrable sets, then A =
integrable. If also the sequence (A,) is decreasing, we have
n An is n
p(A) = inf p(An).
(13.8.7.1)
n
u
(ii) I f ( A n is ) a sequence of integrable sets contained in an integrable set B , then A = An is integrable. n
(iii) I f (A,,) is a sequence of integrable sets such that
then the union A
= n
An is integrable, and we have
(1 3.8.7.2)
I f moreover the sets A, are pairwise disjoint, then
("complete additivity of measure ").
130
Xlll
INTEGRATION
Assertion (i) is a consequence of (13.8.1) and (13.8.2), applied to the sequence (- cpAn). Assertion (ii) follows from (13.8.2). The first part of (iii) m
and the formula (13.8.7.2) follow from (13.8.2), the inequality cpA
cpAn
n= 1
and (13.5.8). Finally, if the sets A, are pairwise disjoint, then we have m
cpA =
n= 1
cpA,
, and (13.8.7.3) follows from (1 3.8.5), applied to thefunctionscpAn.
Example
(13.8.8) Let f be a regulated function on R with compact support (and therefore bounded, by (7.6.1)). Then f is integrable with respect to Lebesgue measure A. If J = [a, b] is an interval containing Supp(f), we have
s
lab
fdA=
(13.8.8.1)
f(t)dt
in the sense of (8.7). For we have If/ 5 llfll cp,, and by (7.6.1), (8.7.8) and (13.8.4) it is enough to prove (13.8.8.1) for a step function with compact support (7.6). Such a function is a linear combination of characteristic functions of intervals, so that finally we are reduced to the case where f = cpr , with I an interval; and in this case our assertion follows from (13.7.8).
PROBLEMS 1. On the discrete space N, letp be the measure for which p({n})= 1 for all n. Show that
the functions IIHU. which arep-integrable are those for which the series with general term u, is absolutely convergent. They are also those for which the upper (or the lower) integral is finite. We have
I
m
u.
dp(n)=
u., and the space SPA(N,p) is the Banach
"=O
space 1' (Section 5.7, Problem 1). 2.
(a) Show that i f f and g are two real-valued functions 2 0 defined on X, then SUP ( f , d+p+(inf(f,g)) 5 p * ( f ) p * ( d (b) Let f be a real-valued function on X such that p * ( f ) is finite. Show that there exists an integrable functionfl Lfsuch that p(fl) = p * ( f ) . Iffz is another integrable function such thatfi z f a n d p(f2)= p * ( f ) , thenfi andfz are equivalent. (c) Let f be a real-valued function on X such that both p * ( f ) and p * ( f )are finite. Let g, h be integrable functions such that g zf6 h and p(g) = p * ( f ) , p(h) = p * ( f ) . Show that p * ( f - g) = p+(h - f) = 0 and that
+
p * ( f - 9)= p*(h -f) = p*W - p*W.
8 LEBESGUE'S CONVERGENCE THEOREMS
131
(d) Let f i , f z be real-valued functions on X such that p * ( f i ) , p * ( f z ) ,p*(f i ), p + ( f 2 ) are all finite. Show that
p*(f1
+f;) 5 P*(fl) + p * ( f d 2 p*(f1+fi).
(If gZ is an integrable function such that J2 gz and p*(Jz)= p ( g 2 ) , observe that we have h - g2 5fi for every integrable function h such that h +fz .) Deduce that, iffl is integrable, then
sfl
and
+ p*(fz), + p*(fz),
p*(f1+fz)
= p(f1)
/L*(fi
+f2)
= pU1)
p*(fl
+
f2)=
p*(sup(fI1f d + p*(inf(fl, fd)
(use (a)). (e) Let f be a finite integrable function, and let g be a function such that p * ( g ) is finite. Show that g is integrable if and only if p ( f ) = p * ( y ) + p * ( f - g ) . (If g1 is an integrable function such that g < g l and p*(gl) = p(gl), remark that
f-
91
sf- 9.)
3. (a) For each pair of subsets A, B of X, show that p*(A u B)+ p*(A n B ) S p*(A)+ p*(B).
(b) For each subset A of X, show that p*(A) is the least upper bound of measures of compact sets contained in A. (c) For each subset A of X with finite outer measure, show that there exist two integrable sets Al, A, such that Al c A c Az and p*(A) = p(A,) and p*(A) = p(A,). Show that p*(A - A,) = p*(AZ - A) = 0 and that p * ( A - Al) = p*(AZ - A) = p*(A) (d) Let A be an integrable set. Show that if B c A then P(A)
= p*(B)
+ p*(A
- B).
(e) Let A, B, be disjoint sets of finite outer measure. If C = A u B, show that p*(A)
+ p*(B) 2 p*(C) 5 p * ( N + p*(B) 5 p*(C) 5 p*(A) + p*@)
and that
p*(C)- p*(A)
-
p*(B) 5 p*(A)
+ p*(B)-
p*(C).
(To prove the latter inequality, reduce to the case where p*(A) = p*(B) =- 0 with the help of (c): if Az, Bz are integrable sets such that A c A, , B c Bz and p*(A) p(AZ), t*.*(B) = p(B2),show that p*(C)S p(A2 n BZL) :
4.
Let h be Lebesgue measure on the unit interval I = [0, I]. (a) Let a be a real number such that 0 5 GI < 1. Construct a nowhere-dense (12.16) compact set in I whose Lebesgue measure is a. (Adapt the method of construction of the Cantor set (Section 4.2, Problem 2), for which GI = 0.) (b) Construct a sequence (A,) of mutually disjoint, nowhere-dense compact sets, such that h(A,) =2-" and such that every interval which is a connected component of I - At contains a subset of A,,, of measure >O. If A = A n , show that A is
u
16"
u n
a meager set of measure 1, and consequently that I -A, which is the complement of a meager set, is h-negligible.
132
Xlll INTEGRATION
5. Let h be Lebesgue measure on R, and let E be the topological vector space obtained by endowing the space -%"(A) with the topology of simple convergence (12.15). Show that the linear f o r m f w j f d h on E is not continuous.
6 . Let (A,) be a sequence of p-integrable subsets of X, such that
p(AJ
< +a.For
n
each integer k , let G , be the set of all x E X such that x E A,, for at least k values of n. Show that Gk is integrable and that k . p(Gk)5 p(A,).
"
7. Let X be a compact space, p a positive measure on X, and (An)a sequence of integrable subsets of X such that inf p(AJ = m > 0. Show that the set B of points of X which n
belong to infinitely many of the sets A. is integrable, and that p(B) 2 rn. 8.
Let A be Lebesgue measure on the interval 1 = [0, 11 and let A. be a sequence of integrable sets in I such that inf h(A.) = rn > 0. For each integer k , let %k denote the
"
+
set of 2k intervals of the form [ j . 2-,, ( j 1) .2-,] in I(0 5 j < 2'9, and CSk the set of all the unions of sets of a,. Show that there exists a decreasing sequence ( I k ) k r O of subsets of I such that 1, = I , I, E Ek for all k , and a subsequence (Ank) of the sequence (A,) with the following properties: (i) &A,, n (I - I k ) ) 5 &rn;\(l - I t ) for all r >= k ) ; (ii) &Anvn J) 2 trnA(J) for all r 2 k and all J E Dk contained in I,. (Proceed by induction on k , using the diagonal trick.) Deduce that there exists a subsequence (B.) of (A,) such that, for all k and all J E ' D k contained in I, , the intersection of J with the sequence (B,) is not empty. (Use Problem 7 and the diagonal trick.) Deduce that B, contains a non-empty compact set with no isolated points (and therefore n
nondenumerable (Section 4.2, Problem 3(c))).
9. Letfbe a real-valued function 2 0 on X. Show that the mapping p ~ p * ( f 'of) M+(X) into R is continuous with respect to the vague topology (13.4) if and only iff is continuous and compactly supported. The mapping p ~ p * ( fis) lower semicontinuous with respect to the vague topology if and only iffis lower semicontinuous. 10. Let (pn)be an increasing sequence of positive measures on X. Suppose that the sequence is bounded above in M+(X), and let t~ be its least upper bound (13.4.4). Show that, for every functionfz 0 on X, we have p * ( f ) = lim pcL:(/). = "-1
Let (pn)be a decreasing sequence of positive measures on X, and let p be the greatest lower bound of the sequence in M+(X) (13.4.4). Iff is a function 2 0 on X such that pz(f)< +to for all sufficiently large n, show that p*(f)= limp,*(f).
11. (a)
+
"+ m
(If g 2 0 is lower semicontinuous and p*(g) < a,observe that there exists a sequence (h,) of continuous functions 2 0 with compact supports, such that h,, s g and p.*(g)
=?p.*(h,)
x m
for all n.)
(b) On the discrete space N, let p n be the measure such that p n ( { m }= ) 0 for rn < n and 1 for rn 2 n. Show that the greatest lower bound of the decreasing sequence (p.) in M+(N) is 0, but that p,*(N)= to for all n.
+
8 LEBESGUE'S CONVERGENCE THEOREMS
133
12. Let X, Y be two locally compact spaces and T : X -+Y a proper continuous mapping (Section 12.7, Problem 2). Let p be a positive measure on X, and let v = ~ ( p(Section ) 13.4, Problem 8). Show that v * ( g ) = p*(g T)for all functions g 2 0 on Y. (Consider first the case in which g has compact support, and then use Section 12.7, Problem 0
2(b).) Show that N c Y is v-negligible if and only if n-l(N) is p-negligible.
13. Assume that there exists in I = [0, I ] an increasing sequence (H.) of nonmeasurable H. = I and h,(H,) = 0 for all n. sets (with respect to Lebesgue measure h) such that
u"
Show that h* inf (1 - yHn)) = 0, but that h*(l - vHn) = 1 for all n.
("
Let F be a convex function defined on a convex open set A c R" (Section 8.5, Problem 8) and let fk (1 6 k 6 n) be n integrable functions on X, such that the mapping x ~ ( f * ( x ) takes ) ~ ~its~ values ~ ~ in A, and such that the composite function x ~ F ( f i ( x .).,. , f . ( x ) )is integrable. Show that if u , is bounded (13.9.16) and p(X) = 1, then
14. (a)
(Use the Hahn-Banach theorem applied to the convex set of points (ti, ..., ~ , , , u ) E A X R
such that u 2 F(r,, . . . , t,,).) Consider in particular the case n = 1, F ( t ) = e', and deduce the inequality of the means uyu;2
. . . u:m
s
U1Ul
where the uk are >O, the uIiare 2 0 and
1-u2 u2
+ ..+ '
umum,
m k= t
uk= 1.
(b) Suppose that p is bounded and p ( X ) = l . Show that if two functions .f2_0, g 2 0 are integrable and such thatfg 2 1, then ( l f d p ) ( s g d p ) 2 1 (use (a)). 15. For each finite sequence (A,)
,5 , d m of p-integrable sets, put
if none of the A, is pnegligible. (Remark that a point of D(AI, . . . , An) belongs to a t least n - 1 of the sets D(A,, A,) (i <j).)
h is Lebesgue measure on the unit interval I = [0,1] and if S(1) is the set of nonempty closed subsets of I (Section 3.16, Problem 3), show that the function A H ~ ( A ) is not continuous with respect to the Hausdorff distance on S(1).
16. If
134
Xlll
INTEGRATION
9. MEASURABLE FUNCTIONS
(1 3.9.1) Let A be an integrable subset of X . Then there exists a partition of A consisting of a sequence (K,) of compact sets and a negligible set N . We define the sets K, inductively as follows, using (13.7.9), (13.7.7), and
u
n-1
(13.7.6):K, c A and p(A - K,) 5 1 ; K, c A -
i= 1
K i and
if n > 1. Then the intersection N of the sets A -
(13.8.7).
u Ki n
i= 1
is negligible, by
A subset of A is said to be measurable (with respect to p) or p-measurable if there exists a partition of A consisting of a sequence of compact sets and a negligible set. Jf K' and K are compact sets such that K' c K, then K - K' is integrable ((13.7.6) and (13.7.7)), and therefore, by virtue of (13.9.1), an equivalent statement is that A is the union of a sequence of compact sets and a negligible set. The same reasoning shows also that another equivalent statement is that A is the union of a sequence of integrable sets. A set A c X is said to be universally measurable if it is measurable with respect to every positive measure on X.
(13.9.2) For a subset A of X to be measurable it is necessary and suficient that A n K should be integrable,for each compact set K in X . The condition is necessary, by virtue of (13.8.7(ii)). It is sufficient, because X is the union of an increasing sequence (K,) of compact sets (3.18.3), and therefore A I S the union of the sequence (A n K,) of integrable sets. In particular, we see that the space X itself is measurable.
(13.9.3) (i) The complement of a measurable set is measurable. (ii) Denumerable unions and denumerable intersections of measurable sets are measurable. (iii) All open set,r and all closed sets are universally measurable. Assertion (i) follows from (1 3.9.2) and (1 3.7.6); assertion (ii) from (13.9.2) and (13.8.7); assertion (iii) from (13.9.2) and (13.7.7) for closed sets, and then by (i) for open sets.
9
MEASURABLE FUNCTIONS
135
The sets obtained from the open (or closed) sets of X by iterated application of the operations (i) and (ii) above are therefore also universally measurable. The definition of a p-measurable set A also shows that there exists a universally measurable set B contained in A such that A - B is p-negligible. By applying this result to X - A, we see that there also exists a universully measurable set C containing A such that C - A is p-negligible. A mapping u of X into a topological space Y is said to be measurable (with respect to p) or p-measurable if there exists a partition of X into a sequence of compact sets K, and a p-negligible set N such that each of the restrictions u I Kn is continuous. The mapping u is said to be universally measurable if it is measurable for all measures on X. A continuous function is universally measurable. For a subset A of X to be measurable (resp. universally measurable) it is necessary and sufficient that its characteristic function q A should be measurable (resp. universally measurable). For if we have a partition of X consisting of a sequence of compact sets K, and a negligible set N, such that qAI K, is continuous for all n, then K, is the union of two disjoint compact subsets, namely A n K, and K, - (A n K,)((3.11.4) and (3.17.3)), and A is the union of the sets A n K, and A n N, and is therefore measurable. Conversely, if A is measurable, then so is X - A (13.9.3), hence there exists a partition of X consisting of a sequence of compact sets K, and a negligible set N, such that either K, c A or K, c X - A for all n. Consequently qAI K, is continuous for all n. (13.9.4) Let u be a mapping of X into a topological space Y . Then the following three properties are equivalent: (a) u is p-measurable. (b) For each compact subset K of X and each E > 0, there exists u compact subset K' of K such that p(K - K') 5 E and such that the restriction of u to K' is continuous. (c) For each compact subset K of X, there exists apartition of K consisting of a sequence (L,) of compact sets and a p-negligible set M, such that each of the restrictions u I L, is continuous. To show that (a) implies (c), we remark that the hypothesis (a) implies the existence of a partition of X consisting of a sequence (K,) of compact sets and a negligible set N, such that u I K, is continuous for all n ; hence (c) is satisfied by taking L, = K n K, and M = K n N. To show that (c) implies (b), we remark that it follows from (c) that p(K)
a,
=
1 p(L,) fl=
1
(13.8.7), and hence that there is an integer n such that
p(K - K') 5 E , where K' =
u Li .
icn
Clearly K' satisfies the conditions of (b).
136
Xlll
INTEGRATION
Finally, we have to show that (b) implies (a). The space X is the union of an increasing sequence (H,) of compact sets (3.18.3). For each n we use the hypothesis (b) together with (13.7.9)to define a sequence (Km,),21 of compact sets such that K,, c H, - H,-,, K,, c (H, K i n , and
u
i<m
and such that the restrictions u I K,, are continuous. The complement of the union of the sets K,,, for n 2 1 and m 2 I is then negligible, and consequently u is measurable. It follows that, for a mapping f : X -+ B to be measurable, it is necessary and sufficient that, for each compact subset K of X, the function f q K (which by convention is taken to be zero at all points of X - K, even iff is infinite at such points (cf. (13.11)) should be measurable. For this condition is sufficient by virtue of (13.9.4),and it is necessary by (13.9.4)and the fact that X - K is measurable (13.9.3). The same reasoning shows that iff is a mapping of X into R and K is a compact subset of X such that f I K is continuous, then f q K is measurable.
(13.9.5) Let (Y,)be a sequence of topological spaces, and f o r each n let u,, be a measurable mapping of X into Y, . Then, given any compact subset K of X andany E > 0, there exists a compact subset K' of K such that p(K - K') 5 E and such that u, I K' is continuous for all n. Using (13.9.4)we define inductively a decreasing sequence (K,) of compact subsets of K such that p(K - K,) 5 f~ and p(K, - K,+l) 5 e/2"+', and such that u, 1 K, is continuous. Then by (13.8.7)it is clear that K' = K, satisfies
0 n
the required conditions.
(1 3.9.6) Let (Yi)l be afinite sequence of topological spaces, Z a topological space, and v a continuous mapping of Y i into Z. Let :ii : X -+ Y i (1 2 i 5 n)
n
be measurable. Then the mapping
i
XF-+ v(u,(x),
... , u,,(x)) is measurable.
This follows immediately from (1 3.9.5) and (1 3.9.4).
(13.9.7) V J g are two measurable functions with values in 8, then sup(f, g ) and inf(f, g ) are measurable. r f u, v are measurable mappings of X into a (real or complex) vector space, then u + v and au (where a is any scalar) are measurable.
9 MEASURABLE FUNCTIONS
137
(13.9.8) A function equivalent to a measurable function is measurable.
This follows from (13.9.4)and the fact that if K is compact and N c K is negligible, then there exists a compact set K' c K - N with measure arbitrarily close to the measure of K (1 3.7.9). A mapping f defined almost everywhere in X , with values in a topological space Y, is said to be measurable if every mapping of X into Y which is equivalent to f (13.6)is measurable. Clearly (13.9.8)it is enough for one such mapping to be measurable.
(13.9.8.1) In particular, it follows from (13.9.6)and (13.9.8)that iff and g (with values in R) are defined andjinite almost everywherein X and measurable, then f g and f g (which are defined almost everywhere) are measurable.
+
(13.9.9) Let u be a measurable mapping of X into a topologicalspace Y . I f M is any open or closed subset of Y , then u-'(M) is measurable. Consider a partition of X consisting of a sequence of compact sets Kn and a negligible set N, such that the restrictions u I K, are continuous. If M c Y is closed, then u-'(M) n K, is compact (3.11.4),hence u-'(M) is measurable. If M is open, then X - u-'(M) = u-'(Y - M) is measurable, and therefore so is u-'(M) (13.9.3).
(13.9.10) (Egoroffs theorem) Let Y be a metric space and let (f,)be a sequence of measurable mappings of X into Y such that, for almost all x E X , the sequence (f,(x)) converges to a limit f (x). Then ( 1 ) f is measurable; ( 2 ) f o r each compact subset K of X and each E > 0, there exists a compact subset K' of K such that p(K - K ' ) S E and such that the restrictions f,I K' are continuous and converge uniformly in K' to f I K'. Clearly it is sufficient to prove the second assertion ((1 3.9.4)and (7.2.1)). Let KObe a compact subset of K such that p(K - KO)5 +E and such that the restrictionsf, I KO are continuous for all n (13.9.5). If d denotes the distance fmction on Y, let B,,, be the set of all x E KO such that d(fp(x),fq(x))2 l / r for ar least one pair of integers ( p , q ) such that p 2 n and q 2 n. If A p,q,r is the set of points x E KOsuch that d(f,(x),f,(x)) 2 l/r, then we have Bn,r
=
U
phn. s t n
Ap.q,r*
138
Xlll INTEGRATION
Now the sets A p , q ,are r closed (3.11.4),hence B,,,r is integrable (13.8.7). Moreover, by hypothesis, for each integer r 2 l we have p( B,,, = 0, and the
() .)
sequence (B,,,,),,? is decreasing, so that by (13.8.7) we have lim p(BnPr)= 0. n-m
Hence there exists an integer n, such that P ( B , , , ~ 2 ) 142"'~.Let B the set B is integrable, and we have p(B) 5
m
C142'''
=&
=
u r
B,,,.,,;
by (13.8.7). The
I=
set C = KO- B is also integrable, and by definition the sequence ( f , I C ) converges uniformly to f l C . Hence we may take K' to be any compact subset of C such that p(C - K') 5 4 6 (13.7.9). (1 3.9.1 1) Let (f,)be any sequence of measurable functions on X with values in R. Then the functions inff, , sup f,, , lim sup f, and lim inff, are measurable. n
n
n-+ w
n-m
For supf, is the limit of the increasing sequence of functions g,
=
sup f;.,
l
which are measurable (1 3.9.7); and lim supf , is the limit of the decreasing fl+
w
sequence of functions supf,+, , which are measurable, by what has just been P?O
proved.
(13.9.11.1) The propositions (13.9.6), (13.9.7), (13.9.9), and (13.9.11) remain valid when the word " measurable " is replaced throughout by " universally measurable." On the other hand, a function cannot be universally measurable unless it is everywhere dejined, because any nonempty subset N of X has measure p(N) # 0 if for example p is the Dirac measure at a point of N. In particular (12.7.8), every function belonging to 4 (resp. 9) is universally measurable. I f f is any lower semicontinuous function on X, then by writing
f = inf (sup ( f , - n ) )
and
n
sup ( f , - n ) = - n + sup ( f
+ n, 0)
and using (13.9.6), it follows that (13.9.11.2) Every (upper or lower) semicontinuous function on X with values in R is universally measurable. The same will be true of all functions obtained from semi-continuous functions by repeated applications of the operations in (13.9.6), (13.9.7), and (1 3.9.1 1).
9 MEASURABLE FUNCTIONS
A function f : X -+
139
8 is a step .function if it takes only a finite number of
values ak(1 5 k 5 n). In that case we have f =
n
akq A kwhere , Ak =f -'(ak),
k= 1
with the convention that if ak is k 00, the value of akqAkis ak in Ak and 0 in X - Ak (13.11). It follows immediately from this and from (13.9.9) that f is measurable if and only if each of the Ak is measurable. (13.9.12) Let f : X -+ 8 be measurable. Then there exists a sequence (9,) of universally measurable step functions with compact support, such that 1g,(x)1 5 1f(x)lfor all x E X and such that the sequence (g,(x)) converges almost everywhere to f ( x ) (which implies that f is equivalent to a universally measurable function).
Consider a partition of X consisting of a sequence (K,) of compact sets and a negligible set N. For each integer i n, there exists a finite covering (U$)), j s q , n of K i by sets which are open in Ki , such that the oscillation of f i n each Ul;)is 5 l / n (with respect to a distance on 8,cf. (3.16.5)). Now we have the following lemma: (13.9.12.1) Let (F,,),shsp be a finite family of integrable sets. Then there exists a finite family (Gk)ls k s r of pairwise disjoint integrable sets, such that each F,, is the union of some-of the Gk.
Consider the 2 p - 1 sets of the form
n z,, , where each P
z h
h= 1
is either F, or
X - Fh ,and z h = F, for at least one index h. Then the family of distinct nonempty sets of this form satisfies the conditions of the lemma, because these sets are integrable by (13.7.6) and each Fhis the union of the sets
P
0Z , for which
1=1
Z h = F h .
By applying this lemma to each of the finite families (U$))lsjsq,n, we sksrrln of Ki into universally measurable, integrable obtain a partition sets. Let if f changes sign in A!:), a!:) = inff(A{,"))
[supOf(Aic))
if f 2 0 on A$'), if f i0 on A$:),
and define g, as follows: g,(x) = a{;)if x E A!;) (1 5 i 5 n, 1 S k S T i n ) , arid g,(x) = 0 otherwise. Then it is clear that the functions g. have the required properties.
Xlll INTEGRATION
140
(13.9.13) In order that a mapping f : X -+ K should be integrable, it isnecessary and sufficient that f should be measurable and that the upper integral p*(l f I) be jinite.
Necessity. Since I f 1 is integrable (13.7.4), clearly p * ( l f l ) is finite. Next we remark that, for each integer n, there exists by hypothesis a functionf, E 9 such t h a t f s f , and p(f, - f ) 5 l / n (13.7.1). Replacingf, by inf f i (12.7.5), 14isn
we may assume that the sequence (A) is decreasing. If g is the limit of this sequence (equal to its lower envelope), we have f S g and p ( g -f) = lim p(.h - . f ) = 0 (13.8.1). In other words, f is almost everywhere equal to
n-tm
the limit of the sequence (f,).Now all functions belonging to 9 are measurable (13.9.11), and another application of Egoroffs theorem (13.9.10) then proves that f i s measurable. Suficiency. We may assume thatfis finite, by replacing f by an equivalent function (13.6.4). By (13.9.12) there exists a sequence (g,,)of measurable step functions with compact supports such that ( g n (5 I fI and the sequence (9,) converges to f almost everywhere. Now gn is a linear combination of characteristic functions of relatively compact measurable sets ; since such sets are integrable (13.9.2), it follows that gn is integrable. Hence, applying (13.8.4) again, f is integrable. (13.9.14) (i) Zf f is an integrable function and A is a measurable set, then the function . f V A is integrable. (ii) Zf(A,) is an increasing sequence of integrable sets, whose union is the complement of a negligible set N, then
J f d~ = ilz J
fqA,
d ~ ,
We may assume without loss of generality that f is everywhere finite
(13.6.4). Then f q A is measurable (13.9.6), and we have p*(lfVAl)
5 p*(lfl) 5 + 03,
from which (i) follows by (13.9.13). The assertion (ii) follows from the dominated convergence theorem (1 3.8.4).
1
=lA
1*
In the situation of (13.9.14), we put f p A dp f dp, or f ( x ) dp(x); this number is called the integral o f f over A. Also (if A is measurable) we write f du in place of I * f i A dp.
1:
9
MEASURABLE FUNCTIONS
141
(13.9.15) I f f is integrable and if A, B are two measurable sets such that A n B is negligible, then
For qAU and q A+ qB are then equivalent functions (12.7.3).
Remark If I is a compact interval [a, b ] in R, then for any regulated function f with compact support we have f dA = f ( x ) dx, where A is Lebesgue measure (13.8.8). If now f is an arbitrary regulated function defined on R, then f is measurable because it is the limit of the integrable functions fqln, where I,, = [ - n , n] (1 3.9.1 1). For f to be integrable, it is necessary and sufficient that lim S'"I f(x)l dx < + 00, and in that case we have (13.9.16)
/ f dA
=
I+"
,,S:
lim
n-tm
f ( x ) dx ((13.8.2) and (13.8.4)); this integral is also denoted
n+m
by
-n
1;
6
f ( x ) dx. It can happen that the limit lim n+m
lim l + m lf ( x ) l dx
n+m
=
S'" f ( x ) dx exists although -n
+ co (this is the case, for example, if f ( x ) = (sin x ) / x for
x # 0). The interpretation of most of these "improper integrals" belongs to
the theory of distributions (Section 17.5, Problem 4, and Chapter XXIII). For the reasons given above, if I c R is any interval with endpoints a, b (with a 5 b), we write f ( x ) dx in place of f dA, for any function f such S I that f q , is integrable.
C
The (positive) measure p is said to be bounded if the constant function 1 is integrable, or in other words (13.9.13), if p*(X) = p*(l) isfinite: the number p(X) = p(I) = dp is then called the total mass of p (cf. (13.20)).
Sx
(1 3.9.17) I f p is bounded, then every bounded measurable function f : X + R is integrable (in particular, every bounded semicontinuous function is integrable) and (13.9.17.1)
This follows directly from (13.9.13).
142
Xlll
INTEGRATION
(13.9.18) Let p be a boundedpositive measure on X. Thenfor each E > 0 there exists a compact subset K of X such that p ( X - K) 5 E.
This is a particular case of (13.7.9). (13.9.19) Suppose that p is bounded. Let (f,)be a uniformly boundedsequence of measurable functions (i.e., sup Ilf,ll < co) such that lim fn(x) =f ( x ) exists
+
n
for almost all x E X. Thenf is integrable, and we have r
(13.9.19.1)
J
f d p = lim n+w
r
J fn
n+ w
dp.
This is a particular case of (1 3.8.4).
Exaniple (13.9.20) Let p be a positive measure on X and let Y be a closed subspace of X. It follows from the Tietze-Urysohn theorem (4.5.1) that every function f E X,(Y) is the restriction to Y of a function g E Y;(X) such that 11g11 = 11 f 11. The function f = gqY,which is equal to f in Y and zero outside Y, is therefore p-integrable (13.9.1 3), and [p(f ‘)I S [If 11 p(Supp(f)). Write py( f ) = p( f ’) (which clearly depends only on f ); then the discussion above shows that f Hpy(f ) is a positive measure on Y, which is said to be the measure induced by p on Y. From (12.7.8), the remarks above and (13.5.7), it follows immediately that iff belongs to J ( Y ) and if as above we denote by f the function which is equal tof in Y and is zero in X - Y, then we have p:( f ) = p*( f Hence we conclude (13.5.5) that this formula is valid for any mapping f : Y + (with f y defined as before). Hence, finally, a function f : Y + R is p,-integrable if and only iffy is p-integrable, and that in this case we have
-
(1 3.9.20.1)
Likewise, a mapping u of Y into a topological space Z is py-measurable if and only if the mapping u’ : X -+ Z which extends u to X by giving u’(x) an (arbitrary) constant value for x c X- Y, is p-measurable. Conversely, consider a closed subset Y of X and a positive measure v on Y, and let p be the canonical extension of v to X (13.1.7). Clearly we have v = p y . Also, iff E .f(Y), then the functio? g which is equal to f on Y and to + co on X - Y belongs to Y(X), and we have v*(f) = p*(g). It follows
9
MEASURABLE FUNCTIONS
143
directly (13.5.5)that, for any mapping g : X R, we have p*(g) = v*(g I Y), and hence that such a mapping g is p-integrable if and only if g I Y is Yintegrable, in which case we have --.f
(1 3.9.20.2) Likewise, a mapping u of X into a topological space Z is p-measurable if and only if u I Y is v-measurable.
(13.9.21) If 71 : X -+X' is a homeomorphism, then a mapping u' of X' into a topological space Y is n(,u)-measurable if and only if u' 0 ?I is p-measurable.
PROBLEMS (fmn) be a double sequence of pmeasurable mappings of X into a metric space Y. Suppose that for each rn the sequence (fn,n)n>l converges almost everywhere to a function g m , and that the sequence (gnJconverges almost everywhere to a function h. Show that there exist two strictly increasing sequences of integers (mk),(nk) such that the sequence (fmk n k ) X S converges almost everywhere to h. (First prove the result when X is compact by observing that, for each E > 0, there exists a compact subset K C X such that p ( X - K) 5 E and such that the sequence (gm)and each of the sequences (fmn)nbl are uniformly convergent on K. Then pass to the general case by using the diagonal trick.)
1. Let
2.
(a) Let f,g be two real-valued functions 2 0 , and suppose that g is p-measurable. Show that p*(fg) = inf p*(ug), where u runs through the set of all p-measurable functions Lf. (b) Let g, h be three functions 2 0 on X, finite or not, and suppose that g and h are p-measurable. Show that p * ( / ( g h)) = p*(fg) p * ( f h ) (using the convention of (13.11) for the product of 0 and to).
+
+
+
3. Let f:X -+ R be p-measurable. For each n E Z, let A, be the set of all x 2"-' < If(x)l 5 2". Show thatfis integrable if and only if 2"p(A,) < " € 2
4.
EX
such that
+ to.
Let (fn) be a sequence of integrable functions on X, converging simply to a functionf. (a) Iff is integrable and
s
fdp
=
lim
n-m
s
fn dp, show that for each E > 0 there exists
an integrable set A, an integrable function g 2 0 and an integer no such that, for all
n 2 no, we have lsx-Afndpl 5 c and Ifn(x)I 5 Ig(x)l for all X E A . (Consider a n integrable set B such that Egoroff's theorem.)
If1
dp 5 +E and such thatfis bounded on B, and apply
144
XI11 INTEGRATION
(b) Suppose that, for each E > 0, there exists a measurable set A, an integrable function g 2 0, and an integer no such that, for all n 2 n o , we have If.(x)l
s
5 Ig(x)l for all x E A. Show that f i s integrable and that lim If-f.1 n-m
dp= 0.
Consider the converse. (c) Show by examples that the conditions of (a) are not sufficient and that the con-
I
I
ditions of (b) are not necessary for f to be integrable and f d p = lim f. dp. n-m
If A is measurable and B is any subset of X, show that
p*(B) = p*(B n A)
+
+ p*(B n (X -A)).
(If p*(B)< m, consider an integrable set B1 3 B such that p*(B) = p(BI).) Conversely, show that if A satisfies this condition (for all B c X), then A is measurable (cf. Section 13.8, Problem 3). Suppose that X is compact. A bounded real-valued function f on X is said to be continuous almost everywhere (with respect to p) on X if the set of points of discontinuity off is negligible. (a) Give an example of a functionfwhich is continuous almost everywhere and such that there exists no continuous function g which is equal to falmost everywhere. (b) Suppose that the support of p is equal to X. Show that a bounded real-valued function fdefined on X is equal almost everywhere to an almost everywhere continuous function on X if and only if there exists a subset A of X such that X - A is negligible and f l A is continuous. (To show that the condition is sufficient, observe that A is dense in X and that the lower semicontinuous extension of f JA to X is continuous at every point of A.) Deduce that f is measurable. Show that there exists a sequence (A) of continuous functions on X which converges at every point of X and whose limit is almost everywhere equal tof(cf. Section 13.11, Problem 3). (c) Show that a real-valued function f on R which is continuous on the right (i.e., such thatf(x+) = f ( x ) for all x E R) is continuous except at the points of an at most denumerable. set, and is therefore continuous almost everywhere with respect to Lebesgue measure. (Apply Section 3.9, Problem 3 to the set A, of points x E R at which the oscillation offis > l/n.) A partition w = (A.) of a set E is said to be finer than a partition m’ = (A;) of E if, for each index a , there exists B such that A, c A;. The partitions of E form an ordered set with respect to this relation. (a) Let X be a compact metric space. For each finite partition zu = (Ak)of X consisting of integrable sets and each bounded real-valued function f on X, put
(“Riemann sums” relative tofand the partition
and that if
w
w ) . Show that
is finer than m’, then s , # ( f ) s , ( f ) and S , ( f )
6 S,,(f).
9
MEASURABLE FUNCTIONS
145
(b) A sequence (m,)of finite partitions of X is said to be fundamental if ZU,,+~ is finer than w, for all n and if the maximum of the diameters of the sets of w, tends to 0 as n tends to m. Show that iffis a bounded integrable function on X, then there exists at least one fundamental sequence (m,) of finite partitions of X, consisting of
+
integrable sets, and such that the sequences ( s W n ( f and ) ) [S,"(f)) both tend to
s
f dp.
(c) Letfbe bounded and continuous almost everywhere on X (Problem 6). Show that, for all fundamental sequences (m,) of finite partitions of X consisting of integrable
f dp. (Observe that if A. is the J X at which the oscillation off (Section is Ll/n, then
sets, the sequences (s,Jf)) and ( S m n ( f ) ) both tend to
closed set of points x E 3.14) p(A,,) tends to 0 as n tends to m ; each A,, has an open neighborhood V. such that the points of V,,have a distance < l/n from A,, and such that p(V,) tends to 0. For a partition m k whose sets all have diameter < l/n, consider separately the sets of the partition which meet V. and those which do not.) Iffis bounded and lower semi-
+
s
continuous on X, show that s,,(f) tends to f d p for every fundamental sequence (m,) of finite partitions of X consisting of integrable sets. (d) A subset A of X is said to be quadrable (with respect to p) if its characteristic function va is continuous almost everywhere, or equivalently if the frontier of A is p-negligible. Show that every point xo in X has a fundamental system of quadrable open neighborhoods. (For each neighborhood V of xo , let f :X + [0, I ] be a continuous mapping such that f ( x o ) = 1 and f ( x ) = 0 for all x E X - V. For each a E 30, 1 [, consider the set of points x E X such that f ( x ) > E . ) Deduce that there exists a fundamental sequence of finite partitions of X consisting of sets which are either open or negligible. Give an example of a nonquadrable closed set (Section 13.8, Problem 4(a); cf. Section 13.21, Problem 2). (e) Let (w,) be a fundamental sequence of finite partitions of X consisting of sets which are either open or negligible. Iffis a bounded function on X, let g be the largest lower semicontinuous function sfi show that s&) = s,(g). Deduce that the sequences ( s m n ( f ) and ) (S,"(f)) tend to the same limit if and only iff is continuous almost everywhere. (f) Use (e) to give an example of a negligible functionfand a fundamental sequence (w") of finite partitions of X consisting of integrable sets, such that the sequences (s,Jf)) and ( S m n ( f ) )do not tend to the same limit. 8.
Let f be a measurable mapping of X into a complete metric space E, and let K be a compact subset of X. Show that f l K can be approximated uniformly by measurable step-functions if and only iff(K) is relatively compact in E.
9. Suppose that X is compact. Let (f.) be a sequence of p-measurable finite real-valued functions on X. Show that the following properties are equivalent: (1) There exists a subsequence of (A) which tends to 0 almost everywhere in X. (2) There exists a sequence (I,) of finite real numbers, such that lim sup 1t.l > 0 n-m
and such that the series with general term f,f.(x) converges almost everywhere in X. (3) There exists a sequence (t.) of finite real numbers such that C 1r.l = m n
+
and such that the series with general term t.f.(x) converges absolutely almost everywhere in X.
146
Xlll
INTEGRATION
(To show that (I) implies (2) and (3), use Egoroff's theorem. To show that (3) implies (1). show that (3) implies that there exists a n increasing sequence of integrable subsets A, of X and a subsequence ( f n k ) of the sequence (fn), such that p(Ak)tends to
p ( X ) and
s*, Ifn,.[
d p tends to 0, as k tends to
+
03.)
10. Let X, Y be two locally compact spaces and 7r : X + Y a proper continuous mapping. ) 13.4, Problem 8). Let p be a positive measure on X, and let v = ~ ( p(Section (a) A mapping g of Y into a topological space is v-measurable if and only if g 0 T
is p-measurable. (b) A mapping g : Y -+ R is v-integrable if and only if g we have s g dv = / ( g
0
7r)
0
7r
is p-integrable, and then
dp. (Use Problem 12 of Section 13.8.)
(c) Show that the support of v is the closure of
7r
(Supp(p)).
11. Let X be a locally compact space, u : X + X a continuous mapping, and p a positive
measure on X. Suppose that for each p-negligible set N, the inverse image u - ' ( N ) is p-negligible (cf. Problem 17). We shall write u-"(A)for (u")-'(A),for each integer n 1 and each subset A of X, and uo = lx. If A is any p-measurable subset of X, let A,,,
u u-"(A) be the set of points m
=
"=O
which "enter A at least once," and let A,,, = A n u-'(A,,,) be the set of points of A which "return at least once to A". Also put A,,,
inf =
An
n u-"(A,,,), the set of m
"=O
points of A which "return to A infinitely often;' The set A is said to be wandering (relative to u) if the sets rc-"(A)( n 2 0) are pairwise disjoint. The mapping u is said to be incompressible if, for each p-measurable subset A of X such that A c u.-'(A),the set u-'(A) - A is negligible; or equivalently if, for each p-measurable subset B of X such that u-'(B) c B, the set B - u-'(B) is negligible. If u is not incompressible it is said to be compressible. (a) Show that the following four properties are equivalent: ( a ) u is incompressible. (p) The wandering sets (relative to u) are negligible. ( y ) For each measurable set A, the set A - A,,, is negligible. is negligible. (6) For each measurable set A, the set A - A,,, (Observe that u-'(Ae0,) c A,,, and that A - Are, is wandering.) (b) Show that u is compressible if and only if there exists a measurable real-valued function f on X such that f ( u ( x ) )>f(x) for all x E X and such that the set of points x E X at whichf(u(x)) > f ( x ) has measure >O. (To show that the condition is sufficient, argue by contradiction to show that it implies that there exists a rational number r for which the set of points x E X such thatf(x) < r < f ( u ( x ) ) is not negligible.) Deduce that if u" is incompressible for some integer n > 1, then u is incompressible. (c) Suppose that X is compact and that the measure p is inoariant with respect t o u (cf. Section 13.4, Problem 8). Show that u is incompressible (" Poincarb's recurrence theorem "). (d) Show that if u is incompressible, then there exists a negligible set N in X such that, for every x $ N and every neighborhood V of x in X, there are infinitely many integers n such that u"(x) E V. (Consider the sets U - U,,, i n f , as U runs through a denumerable basis of open sets of X.)
9
MEASURABLE FUNCTIONS
147
Let (t,)oarsnbe a sequence of real numbers, and let m be an integer ( n . Let L, be the set of indices i with the following property: there exists an integer p such t12_0.(Observethat t h a t O _ I p s m a n d t f + t i + l + ~ ~ ~ + t i + 2p 0- .- Show l that
12. (a)
lELm
if i E L,, and if p is the smallest of the integers with the above property, then i + 1, ..., i + p - 1 belong to L,,,.) (b) Let X be a locally compact space and p a positive measure on X. Let u : X + X be a proper continuous mapping such that u ( p ) = p. Iff’is any p-integrable function on X, putf, = f a n d f x = f o up ( k 2 1). For each integer m , let A, be the measurable set of points x E X such that one of the sumsfo(x) +fi(x) ...+f,(x), wherep 5 m,
+
is
2 0. Show that
JAM
f(x) dp(x) 2 0. (For each integer n > 0 and each x E X, consider
the sequence ( f r ( ~ ) ), and ~ ~apply ~ ~ (a) ~ to+ this ~ sequence, denoting the corresponding set of indices by L,(x). For each k 5 n m, let Bkbe the set of x E X such that
+
k
E
Lm(x), and deduce from (a) that
n+m
C
k=O
B!,
fx(x) dp(x) 2 0. Now use the fact that
Bk= Kk(Am)for 0 5 k 5 n to deduce that
for all n.) If A is the union of the Am, conclude that
f ( x ) dp(x) 2 0 (“maximal /A
ergodic theorem ”). (c) Let a be a real number and C a n integrable set such that
x
1”-1 a < Iim sup fx(x) n-+m
for all x E C . Show that ap(C) 6
nk=o
1
If(x)l dp(x). (Apply (b) to the function f- avc .)
(d) Let a , b be two real numbers such that a < b. If E is the set of points x E X such that 1”-1
Iim infn-m
1”-1
1fk(x) < a < b < Iimn + msup -n kC= o /i(x),
k=O
show that E is p-negligible. (Deduce first from (c) that E is integrable, and then apply (b) to each of the functions (f- b)vEand (a -f)yE, using the fact that u(E) C E.) Hence show that,for almost aNx E X, the sequence
converges to a limit f*(x), that f* is integrable and that f*(u(x)) = f * ( x ) almost everywhere (G. D. Birkhoff’s ergodic theorem). (Take a , b to be all pairs of rational numbers such that a < b.)
s
s
f* dp = f dp. (Reduce to the case f 2_ 0, and consider first the case wherefis bounded; then pass to the general case by observing
(e) If X is compact, show that that
/ If’l
dp 5
If1 dp.1
148
Xlll INTEGRATION (f) Suppose that X i s compact and p(X) = 1. Consider a sequence (gn)of pintegrable functions such that lim g,(x) = f ( x ) almost everywhere. Suppose moreover that there nr'"
exists a p-integrable function G 2 0 such that /gnI 5 G almost everywhere, for each integer n. Show that under these conditions the sequence
converges almost everywhere to f * ( x ) . (Reduce to the case f = 0. For each e E 10, 1 [, there exists 6 > 0 such that, for each p-integrable subset B of X satisfying p(B) 5 6, we have of points x
G d p e2 (13.15.5). Next, there exists an integer m such that the set A, X satisfying
E
SUP Ig,(x)l
nbm
Ie2
has measure p(A,) 2 1 - 6. Let G , be the function which is equal to G on X - A,; then for n 2 m and all x E X, we may write
Deduce from (c) that the set of points x
1:
lim sup "'rn
has measure 13.
E
6'
on A, and to
X such that g,,(uk(x))
2e
5 26.)
Let X be a locally compact space, p a positive measure on X, and u : X +X a continuous mapping such that, for each p-negligible set N, the set u-'(N) is p-negligible. A measurable real-valued function f on X is said to be pinvariant with respect to u if f a u and J' are equal almost everywhere (relative to p). A p-measurable subset A of X is said to be p-inuarianr with respect to u if its characteristic function is pinvariant with respect to u. (a) For a measurable function f to be pinvariant with respect t o u, it is necessary and sufficient that, for each rational number r , the set of points X E X such that f ( x ) 2 r should bc p-invariant with respect to u. (To show that the condition is sufficient, consider the set of points x E X such thatf(u(x)) # f ( x ) . ) (b) From now on, suppose that u is proper and the measure p-invariant with respect to u (i.e., u ( p ) = p). The mapping u is said to be ergodic with respect to p (or p is ergodic with respect to u) if the only p-measurable functions which are pinvariant with respect to u are constant almost everywhere. Then, for every p-integrable function f on X, the function
(sf(.)
is constant almost everywhere. If X is compact, the value of the constant is
dp(x))/p(X). Conversely, if X is compact and i f f * is constant almost every-
where, for every p-integrable function A then u is ergodic.
9
MEASURABLE FUNCTIONS
149
(c) Take X to be the circle U : IzJ= 1 in C , and p to be the image of Lebesgue measure under the mapping t w e Z n i rof [0, 11 onto U. If 6 is irrational, show that the mapping u : z w e Z n i e zleaves p invariant and is ergodic with respect to p. (Use Bohl's theorem, Section 13.4, Problem 7.) (d) Suppose that X is compact and u ergodic with respect to p. If A and B are p-measurable subsets of X, show that
Conversely, if this formula is satisfied for all pairs of measurable subsets A, B in X, then u is ergodic with respect to p. (e) Suppose that X is compact and u ergodic with respect to p. If a measurable 0 is such that function
fz
exists almost everywhere, thenfis integrable. (Consider f a s the limit of an increasing sequence of bounded functions.) (f) Suppose that X is compact, that u is ergodic with respect to p, and that Supp(p) = X. Show that, for almost all x E X, the set of points u"(x) (n 2 0) is dense in X. 14.
Let X be a compact space, u : X + X a ccntinuous mapping, and p a positive measure on X, invariant with respect to u and of total mass 1. Let A be a p-measurable subset of X. For each x E A, let n(x) denote the smallest integer n 2 1 such that u"(x) E A, If we put A, = u - " ( A ) and B. = u-"(X - A), then the set of points x E A for which n(x) = rn is A,, n B, n Bz n ... n B,-, n A,,,, and hence the function x ~ n ( x is) measurable. (a) Put a0 = 1 and a,
= p(Bo
n B1 n . . . n B",-,) (rn 2 1). Show that
p(Ao n B1 n B, n ... n B,,-l n B, n A,,,,)
=
+
a,,, - 2a,,,+, a m f 2
for all m 2 0. (b) Show that the series whose general term is a,,, - a,+1 is convergent and that its terms form a decreasing sequence (interpret a,,, - urn+,as the measure of a set). Deduce that lim rn(tL, = 0.
n B..
m-m
(c) Let B,
=
Show that IAnLL(x)dp(x) = 1 - pCL(Bm)
("Kac's theorem": use (a) and (b)). Consider the case where u is ergodic with respect to p, and p(A) > 0. (d) Suppose that u is bijective and ergodic with respect to p, and that p(A) > 0. Let En, be the set of points x t A such that n(x) = rn. Show that the complement in
A of
u Emis negligible (cf. Problem Il(a)). Show that the sets up(E,) for rn 2 1 m
m=l
and 0 ' p < rn are mutually disjoint, and that the complement of their union in X is negligible (" Kakutani's skyscraper "1.
150
Xlll
INTEGRATION
15.
Let f be a lower (or upper) semicontinuous real-valued function on R". Let X be a locallycompact space and ul, . . . , universally measurablefinite real-valued functions. Show thatf(ul, . . . , u,) is universally measurable (cf. Problem 17).
16.
With the notation of Section 12.7, Problem 3, show that there exist n universally measurable mappings f w z k ( t )of C" into C (1 5 k 5 n) such that P,(X)=X"+ r,X"-'+
...+ t . - n ( x - z & ) ) . k=O
(By induction on the degree n , using Problem 15.) 17. Let f be the continuous function on I = [0, I ] which was defined in Section 4.2, Problem 2(d), such that the restriction o f f t o the Cantor set K is a bijection of K onto 1. Let g be the function defined by g (x ) = x -tf(x); then g is a homeomorphism of 1 onto 21= [0,2], such that g(K) is a compact set of measure 1 (with respect to Lebesgue measure), although K is negligible. If h(x) = 3-'(2x), then h is a homeomorphism of I onto I such that h-'(K) is not negligible with respect to Lebesgue measure. Moreover, if A is a nonmeasurable set (with respect to Lebesgue measure) contained in g(K), then the set B = h(&A)is negligible and therefore measurable. The function F~ h is not measurable, although h is continuous and pB is measurable (cf. (16.23)). 0
R. Show that there exists a real-valued function g on R which is universally measurable and such thatf(g(x)) = x for all x E ~ ( R(cf. ) Section 12.7, Problem 1). (b) Assume that there exists a partition of I = [0, 11 into a family (HJnSz of nonmeasurable sets (with respect to Lebesgue measure) such that Card (H.) = Card(R) for all n E 2. Let K be the Cantor set (Section 4.2, Problem 2) and F = (K t n),
18. (a) Let f be a finite continuous real-valued function on
u
n s z
so that F is a negligible closed set. Show that there exists a bijection f:R .+R such thatffF n In, n 1[) = H, for all n, and such that f is linear in each of the component intervals of IF. Then f is measurable with respect to Lebesgue measure, but f - I is not.
+
19.
Let X be a locally compact space and p a positive measure on X. Let D be a denumerable dense subset of R.Show that a mappingf: X R is p-measurable if and only if, for each r E D, the set of points x E X such thatf(x) 2 r is p-measurable.
20.
Suppose p bounded and p ( X ) = I . If f
20
s
is an integrable function, show that
(1 -tf2)''2is integrable and that, if A = fdp, then
(Use Problem 14(a) of Section 13.8.) 21.
-
Let X, Y, Z be three locally compact spaces. iff: X + Y and g :Y Z are universally measurable, show that g of is universally measurable. (To show thatg o f is p-measurable where p is any positive measure on X, reduce to the case where X is compact and consider the measure f(p) on Y (Section 13.4, Problem 8).) In particular, if B c Y is universally measurable, then f -'(B) is universally measurable.
9 MEASURABLE FUNCTIONS 22.
151
Let X be a locally compact space, Y a compact space, p a positive measure on X, and (fn)">, a sequence of p-measurable mappings from X to Y . Show that there exists a mapping ( p , X)HU~(X) of N x X into N with the following properties: (1) for each integer p 2 0 and each integer n 2 0, the set upl(n) is p-measurable; (2) for each x E X, the sequence (f~,cx,(x)),soconverges in Y . (One method is as follows. Taking a distance function on Y , define universally measurable subsets A, of Y satisfying conditions (i) and (ii) of Section 4.2, Problem 3(a) and such that (in the same notation) A,, n A , - = a . Then define subsets B, of X inductively as follows: if B, has been defined in such a way that, for each x E B,, infinitely many terms of the sequence ( f , ( x ) ) belong to A,, we define B,. as the set of all points x E B, such that infinitely many terms of the sequence (fn(x)) belong to A,, , and we define B,. to be the complement of B,, in B,. Now let x E X and let (&,JP>, be the sequence of 0's and 1's such that, if s, = then x E B,, for all p . Define up(x) by induction as follows: uo(x) is the smallest integer n such that fn(x) E A,, , and up(x)is the smallest integer n > O,-~(X) such that f.(x) E A,, . Use Problem 21 to verify that this definition of u,(x) satisfies the conditions of the problem.)
23. Let p be a bounded positive measure on X and let f > 0 be a pintegrable function.
Show that there exists a lower semicontinuous function g such that g 2 l/f (with the convention that l / O = to) and such that gf is integrable (with the convention that the product of 0 and cc is 0). (Reduce to the case wherefis bounded; consider the sets A. of points x E X such that f ( x ) 5 Ijn, and apply (13.7.9) to these sets to construct 9 . )
+ +
24. Let X, Y be locally compact spaces, p a positive bounded measure on X, and 7r a p-measurable mapping from X to Y . For each f c Xw,(u>, show that f o n is p-integ-
rable and that the mapping f~
s
( f 0 n)dp is a posiriue measure v on Y (called the
image of p under T , and denoted by ~ ( p ) )Generalize . the results of Section 13.8, Problem 12, and Section 13.9, Problems 10 to 14.
25.
Let X be a compact space and let (m,)be a sequence of finite partitions of X consisting of integral sets, such that m ,is finer then w. whenever m > n (Problem 7). An elementary martingale relative to the sequence (m,)is by definition a sequence (f.) of integrable functions 2 0 such that: (i) fn is constant on each set of the partition m,; (ii) If m > n, for each set A em. we have
(in other words, on each set A E wnthe value offn is equal to the average offm over A). (a) Let a , b be real numbers such that 0 5 a < b, and let Eabbe the integrable set of points x E X such that
lim inffn(x) < a < b < lim supfn(x). n-m
n-m
Show that E,, is negligible. (Suppose if possible that p(E.J > 0. For each integer p > 0, let F, be the union of the sets A E m. (n > p ) such that A n Eubi 0; if F = F,, then p(F) 2 p(Enb)> 0. Show that for each integer p and each A E m, (n 2 p )
n P
such that A n Eabf
a,we have b . p(A n F,)
a . p(A) for all q
2 n, by using the
152
XI11 INTEGRATION
+
+
definition of a martingale; now let q+ co, then p - + co, and so obtain a contradiction.) (b) Deduce from (a) that the sequence (f.) converges almost everywhere to a n integrable functionf: (Give a , b rational values, and use Fatou’s lemma.)
J^
(c) Give an example where f dp is not equal to the (constant) value of the integrals
J^hdp. (Take X
~7
[0, 11 and take p to be Lebesgue measure; take wnto consist of the
intervals [0, 2-”[, [2-”, 2-”+’[, ..., [B, 11.1 (d) Let F(x) = supf.(x). Show that there exists a constant C > 0 such that, for all n
a > 0, if B“ is the set of points x such that F(x) > a, we have p(B.) that B, is the union of the sets Ba, = { x E X : f.(x) > a}.)
5 Cia. (Remark
26.
With the hypotheses of Problem 25, let (T be another finite partition of X into pintegrable sets. For each x E X and each integer n, let B E u and A E w. be the sets of the partitions u and m, which contain x ; put f.(x) 0 if p(A) = 0, and f&) = p(B n A)/p(A) if p(A) > 0. Show that the sequence ( f . ( x ) ) converges almost everywhere to a limit f ( x ) 5 I , and that the sequence (f.)converges in mean tof: (For each set B t u, observe that the functions ysfA form an elementary martingale for the measure yB. p, and use Problem 25.)
27.
Let X be a compact space with measure p(X) = 1 , and let a = (Ai)1E16nbe a finite partition of X into integrable subsets. For each x t X, if Ai E a is the set containing x, the number i(a;x ) =
- log
p(Ad
is called the information at the point x corresponding to the partition a . The number
(with the convention that f log t = 0 when t = 0) is called the entropy of the partition a (relative to the measure p). It is the “average” of the information corresponding to a. I f / = (BJ, Eks,,, is another finite partition of X into integrable subsets, the number H(a//)
=
- C p(AI n Bk) log(p(A, n Bk)/p(BxN2 0 i, k
(in which the terms for which p(BJ = 0 are replaced by 0) is called the entropy ofa relative ro p. If (0is the partition consisting of the single set X, then H ( a / w )= H(a). (a) If ( C L , ) ~ ~is,
$’ CL, or a ,
V a2 V . . . V a n the coarsest of the partitions which are finer
J=I
than all the a J , that is to say the partition consisting of all nonempty intersections A , n Az n . . .n A,, where A, E a, for each j . If a, /3, y are three finite partitions of X into integrable sets, show that
+ H(P/(a V y))
H((a V P)/y)- H(a/y) and in particular
9 MEASURABLE FUNCTIONS
153
Deduce that if a is coarser than p, then H ( a / y ) S H ( B / y ) ,and in particular H(a) 5 H@). (b) With the same notation, show that if p is coarser than y then H(a/B)2 H(a/y) (use the fact that the function 1 - f log r is convex in [0, 11). In particular, we have H(a) 2 H(a/y). For arbitrary a, p, y, we have
28.
Let X be a compact space with measure p ( X ) = 1, and let u : X -+X be a p-measurable mapping such that u(p) = p (Problem 24). Let a be a finite partition of X into integrable subsets; if a = (Ak)lQ k Q m , we denote by u-"(cI) the partition formed by the sets u-"(Ak),l 5 k 5 rn. (a) With the notation of Problem 27, show that the limit
(1V:
1 h(u, a ) = lim - H n-rio n
exists and is finite. (If a, = H
(::: V
u-'(a)
),
)
u-~(o~)
show by the use of Problem 27(b) that
urn+" 5 a , + a , , and then copy the proof of (15.2.7(i)). The number h(u, a) is called the entropy ofu relative fo a. Show that h(u, a ) 5 H(a) (use Problem 27). (b) If a, B are two finite partitions of X into integrable subsets, show that Nu, a
v p, 5 h(u, a ) + h ( 4 a ) 5 h(u,
If also a is coarser than (c) Show that
B) +
p, then h(u, a ) 5 h(u, p). (Use Problem 27.)
(Prove by induction on n that
by using Problem 27.) (d) Show that, for each integer rn 2 1,
(
h(u, a>= h u,
v
J I O
)
u-J(a)
(Observe that the right-hand side is equal to
and use Problem 27.) If in addition u is bijective and u - l is p-measurable, then for
154
Xlll
INTEGRATION
each integer m 2 1 we have h(N, a ) = a( u,
:d(4)
J= -m
(same method). (e) Put h(u) = sup h(u, a), where the supremum is taken over all finite partitions of
X into /r-integrable subsets. The number h(u) is called the entropy of u (relative to the measure p). Show that, for each integer m >- 1, we have h(u") = mh(u). (Remark that
( :1
h(um,a ) $ h urn, V
u-j(a)
)
= mh(u, a).)
If moreover u is bijective and u-l is p-measurable, then h(u-') = h(u). (f) Show that h(1,) = 0, where l x is the identity mapping of X. Deduce that if u p = lx for some integer p > 0, then h(u) = 0.
10. INTEGRALS O F VECTOR-VALUED F U N C T I O N S
Consider first a mapping f of X into ajnite-dimensional real vector space
E. Let (ei)l5is,n be a basis of E, and put f(x) =
cfi(x)ei for each x m
i= 1
E X.
Then f is said to be integrable (with respect to p ) or p-integrable if each of the real-valued functions fi is integrable, and we define (1 3.10.1) It is immediately checked that this definition is independent of the basis chosen. If llzll is a norm defining the topology of E, then we have the following criterion: (13.10.2) A mapping f : X -+E is integrable ifand only iff is measurable and XH Ilf(x)JIis then integrable.
j*llf(x)ll dp(x) < + co. Thefunction
For f is measurable if and only if the f;: (1 S i 5 n) are measurable, by (13.9.6); also there exist two constants a, b such that a
Ci Ifi(x) I IIIf(x>IIS b 1 I fi(x>I i *
by (5.9.1). The result now follows from (13.9.13) and (13.9.6). In particular, a complex function f on X is integrable if and only if Bf
10 INTEGRALS OF VECTOR-VALUED FUNCTIONS
155
and 9 f are integrable, and we have
from which it follows immediately that S f d p = J Z
The set Y,!.(X, p) of p-integrable functions on X with values in C is a vector space over C , and f~ I f d p is a linear form on this vector space. Furthermore, iff is any complex-valued integrable function, then I f [ is integrable and
(13.10.3)
+
For since 1.f I = ( ( W f ) 2 ( Y f ) 2 ) ” 2it, follows that If I is measurable (13.9.6),and we have p * ( l f l ) 5 p*(lWfl) p*(lXfl). Hence the first assertion, by (13.9.13).Also there exists a complex number c of absolute value 1 such that Mf)= Mf)L and hence IP(f’)l = W ( P ( c f ) ) = P ( W ( i f ) ) 5 Alfl), which establishes (13.1 0.3).
+
If E‘ is the dual of the finite-dimensional vector space E, then to say that thef, are integrable is equivalent to saying that, for each z’ E E’, the mapping x w ( f ( x ) , z ’ ) is integrable (because it is a linear combination of the A). We generalize this as follows: if I is any set, then a mapping X H ~ ,of X into the vector space K’ (where K = R or C) is scalarly p-integrable if for each c1 E I the function x ~ f , ( a )is integrable.
(1 3.1 0.4) Let E be a Frkchet space, E‘ its dual (1 2.15). Let X H f , be a scalarly integrable mapping of X into E’ such that, for each convergent sequence (a,,) in E , there exists a ,function g 2 0 defined on X such that p*(g) < + 03 and Ifx(a,)l 5 g(x)for all n, almost everywhere in X . Then there exists a continuous linear form z’ E E’ on E such that (Z , z’) = / f x ( z )dp(x)f o r all z E E.
sf,(.)
By (3.13.4)it is enough to show that if (a,,) is a sequence in E with limit z then dp(x)= lim sfx(a,) dp(x);and this follows from (13.8.4). n+m
The linear form z’ so defined is called the integral (or weak integral) of the function x-f, with respect to p , and is denoted by dp(x). Hence, for
sf,
Xlll INTEGRATION
1%
all x E E, we have (13.10.5)
If in particular E is a Hilbert space, then since there is a semilinear isometry z w j ( z ) of E onto its dual E’ (12.15), we can define the notion of a scalarly integrable mapping xl-*f(x) of X into E: this means that, for each z E E, the complex-valued function x.-,(f(x) Iz) is integrable. If the function XH(I f(x)ll is integrable, then by (13.10.4) there exists a unique element of E, denoted by jf(x) &(x) and called the integral (or weak integral) of f, with the property that (1 3.1 0.6)
for all z E E. PROBLEMS 1. If a mapping x H f , of X into R’is scalarly p-integrable, then the element
j
H fx(a) dp(x)
of R’ is called the integral of the mapping and is denoted by f,
J
f,
dp(x). If, for all x
E
X,
belongs to a weakly closed convex set A in R’ and if X is integrable and p(X) = 1,
then the integral jf,dp(x) also belongs to A. (Use Problem 13 of Section 12.15.) 2.
Let E be a separable real Frkhet space and E’ its dual (12.15). It follows from the Hahn-Banach theorem (Section 12.15, Problem 4) that the linear mapping cE which maps each z E E to the linear form Z’H (I,z’) on E’, is an injective mapping of E into RE’and is continuous with respect to the product topology on RE’.If K is any compact subset of E, the restriction CE I K is a homeomorphism of K onto the subspace ce(K) of Re’(12.3.6). (a) Suppose that K is a compact conuex subset of E. A mapping f of X into K is said to be scalarly p-integrable if, for each z’ E E’, the real-valued function XH (f(x), z’) is p-integrable. Using the remarks above and Problem 1, show that there then exists a unique vector z E K such that (z, z is denoted by
s s
2’) =
I
for all z’ c E’. This vector
f dp or f(x) dp(x), and is called the integral off. In particular, if X = K and f is the identity mapping l K, for any positive measure
p on K with fofalmass equal to 1, the element b
-I -
z dp of K is called the burycenter
of p. (b) Let H be a compact subset of E. Show that the closed convex hull K of H is
10 INTEGRALS OF VECTOR-VALUED FUNCTIONS
157
compact (by proving that it is precompact) and coincides with the set of barycenters b, of positive measures with total mass 1 and support contarnedin H. (Remark that as p runs through the set P C M+(H) of positive measures with total mass 1 , the mapping PH b, is continuous with respect to the vague topology on P and the topology induced on K by the product topology on Re', and use Section 13.4, Problem 12.) 3.
Let E be a separable real Frkhet space and A a closed convex subset of E. Show that every convex function f(Section 13.9, Problem 14) which is lower semicontinuous on A is the upper envelope (12.7) of a family of functions which are the restrictions to A of continuous ufine linear functions on E (i.e., functions of the form Z H U u(z), where u is a continuous linear form on E, and u E R). (Apply the Hahn-Banach theorem to the closed convex set of points (z,() E E x R such that z E A and 5 Z f ( z ) . )
+
4.
Let E be a separable real FrCchet space, K a compact convex subset of E, p a positive measure of total mass 1 on K, and b, the barycenter of p (Problem 2). Show that iff is a convex real-valued function 2 0 which is lower semicontinuous on K, then f(b,)
5
1'
f d p (use Problem 3).
5. (a) Let E be a separable Frkhet space, K a compact convex subset of E, and z a point of K. Show that every positive measure p on K, with total mass 1, which has z as barycenter, lies in the vague closure of the set of positive measures of total mass 1 and finire support which have z as barycenter. (Let U be a neighborhood of p with respect to the vague topology, consisting of measures VonKsuchthat Ip(fi) - v(fi)l 5 8 for some functions 1;E qC(K). Show that there exists a finite number of points aJE K , and for each j a compact convex neighborhood WJ of aJ in K, such that the W,, cover K and Ifi(y) -fi(aJ)I 38 for each i and each y E W,. Show (by using a continuous partition of unity) that we can write p in the f o r m z aJp,, where each pJ is a positive J
measure of total mass 1 and support contained in W, , and each a,
=c
10 and
c
aJ= 1.
J
If zJ is the barycenter of p J ,show that the barycenter of v E., is Z, and that J v E U.) (b) Let K' be a compact subset of K, such that K is the closed convex hull of K'. For a point z E K to be an extrenial point of K (Section 12.15, Problem 5) it is necessary and sufficient that E. should be the only positive measure on K' with total mass 1 and z as barycenter. (Use (a) to prove that the condition is necessary.)
6 . Let E be a separable real Frechet space and K a compact convex subset of E. Show that there exists a strictly conuex continuous real-valued function on K. (The set d of restrictions to K of continuous affine linear functions on E is a subspace of the separable metrizable space VR(K), hence contains a dense sequence (An). Show that, for suitable scalars GC,> 0, the function C a,hi satisfies the required conditions, by using the Hahn-Banach theorem.)
"
7. Let E be a separable real Frechet space, K a compact convex subset of E; let u be a convex continuous real-valued function on K, let G c E x R be the graph of u, and let S be the closed convex hull of G in E x R. (a) Let u be the lower envelope of the continuous affine linear functions w on E such that w(z) 2 u(z) for all z E K. Show that S is the set of points (2, 5) E E x R such that
158
Xlll
INTEGRATION
5 ;g u(z). (By the Hahn-Banach theorem, the points (z,[) belonging to S are those with the following property: if h is any continuous affine linear function on E x R such that h ( y , rr(y)) 2 0 for all y E K, then h ( z , 5) 2 0. (Use Problem 5 . ) (b) Show that if u is strictly convex in K, then u(z) < u(z) for all nonextremal points z in K. (c) Show that, for each point z E K, there exists a positive measure p on K having z z E K and u(z) _I
as barycenter and such that u(z)=
J^
u(y)dp(y). (Apply Problem 2(b) to the closed
convex hull S of the compact set G in E x R.)Deduce from Problem 4 that u(z) = u(z) almost everywhere in K, with respect to p. 8. Let E be a separable real FrCchet space and K a compact convex subset of E. (a) Show that the set M of extremal points of K is the intersection of a sequence of open sets of K, and therefore universally measurable. (In the space K x K x [0, I], consider the set of triples (z’, z”, h) such that z’ # z” and 0 < h < 1 , and its image K - M under the mapping (z’, z”, h)whz’ (1 - h)z”.) (b) Prove that every point of K is the barycenter of a positive measure p on K, with total mass 1, such that p(K - M) = 0 (“Choquet’s theorem”). (Use Problems 6 and 7.)
+
9. Extend the results of Problems 2 to 8 to the case of a convex and vaguely compact subset K of M+(X). where X is a compact space (cf. Section 12.15, Problem 13).
11. T H E SPACES L’ A N D
Lz
Throughout the remainder of this chapter we shall make the following convention: the function (x,y ) ~ x ywill be extended to R x R by putting xy = 0 whenever one of the factors is 0 and the other is fco (of course, this extension to R of the multiplication on R is not continuous). With this convention, we have x(yz) = (xy)z for all x, y , z E 8, and the relations x 5 y and z 2 0 imply xz 5 yz. Iff is any mapping of X into R, we put
(13.1 1.2) (13.11.2.1)
For all mappings f 2 0 and g N,(f
2 0 of X into R, we have
+ 9) 5 N,(S) + N,(d
(P = 1,2)*
This has already been proved for p = 1 (13.5.6). For p = 2 we shall first prove (with the above convention for products in R) the generalized CutrchySchwarz inequality (13.1 1.2.2)
N,(fg) 2 N,(f)N,(g).
This inequality is true if one of the factors on the right-hand side is zero. If for example N,(g) =0, then g 2 is negligible and therefore so is g (13.6.3)
11 THE SPACES
L’ AND Lz
159
hence also fg (with the above convention) (13.6.3), and so both sides of (13.11.2.2) are zero. Next, the inequality is true when one of the factors on the right-hand side is 00 (for the same reason). Hence we may assume that both factors on the right-hand side of (13.11.2.2) are Jinite and nonzero, which implies (13.6.4) that j’ and g are Jinite almost everywhere. Now if a, b are any two real numbers 2 0, we have
+
2ab 5 ta’
+ t-’b2
for all scalars t 2 0. Bearing in mind (13.6.5) and (13.5.6), it follows that
2 Putting t
s’
f g dp
s*
s (tf’ +
= N,(g)/N,(f),
t-lg’)
dp
5t
*
f’ dp + t - 1 j * g ’
dp,
we have the inequality (13.1 1.2.2).
To prove (13.11.2.1) when p = 2, we may again restrict ourselves t o the case where N2(f) and N,(g) are finite, and f and g are 20. Since (f+g)’ S 2(f2 g’), it follows that Nz(f + g) is finite. We may assume that N,( f g ) # 0. Moreover, we have
+
+
(f+s)’ = f ( f + s ) + s ( f + 9 ) with the convention at the beginning of this section; hence ((13.5.6) and (13.11.2.2)) (N2(f + s))’ = Nl((f+ 9)’)
s N l ( f ( f + 9))+ N,(g(f + 9 ) ) 5 N,(f)N‘(f + 9 ) + N2(9)N’(f + 9 )
from which (13.11.2.1) follows, by dividing through by N2(f (13.11.3) r f
(f,)is any sequence of functions on X with values in 8, then
This also has already been proved for p
= 1
for p = 2 : the sequence of functions gn =
(iA)’ as its upper envelope. Since n= 1
+ g ) # 0.
(1 3.5.8). The proof is similar
C fk )’
(kll
(N1(gn))’/’ 5
is increasing and has
f NZ(fk),by (13.11.2.1)
k= 1
and induction on n, we can apply (13.5.7) to the sequence (gn)to obtain the result. We have already (13.7.3) defined the set 5?:(X, p) of (finite) real-valued p-integrable functions, and we have seen that it is a vector space. Likewise,
160
Xlll INTEGRATION
the set of all real-valued p-measurable functions f such that . f 2 is integrable For . if f and g is a vector space 9’ipZ(X, p) (also denoted by Y ; ( p ) or 9’;) are measurable and f and g2 are integrable, then f + g is measurable by virtue of (13.11.2.1), and it follows from (13.9.13) that ( f g)’ is integrable. There exist functions f which are non-measurable, such that f 2 is integrable (Problem 2). By abuse of language, the space Y i ( X , p) is called the space of squareintegrable functions. Since N,(af) = laJN,(f ) for p = 1, 2 and any scalar a # 0, it follows from (13.11.2.1) that N, is a seminorm on the space 9’i(X, p). The set A” of functions f such that N,(J) = 0 is in both cases the vector subspace of negligible (finite) real-valued functions (13.6.3). Hence the space Y i ( X , p) is not in general Hausdorff with respect to the topology defined by the seminorm N,. The quotient space Lg(X, p) = Y ; ( X , p)/N (also denoted by Lk(p) or G)is the space of equivalence classesjof integrable functions when p = 1, square-integrable functions when p = 2 (13.6). A function which is defined and finite almost everywhere in X is said to be square-integrable if its class belongs to L; . The number N , ( f ) is the same for all functions f belonging to a class ? E L ; , and is denoted by N,(3). From (12.14.8) it follows that f - N p ( f ) isanormonLL(p=1,2).
+
(13.11.4) (Fischer-Riesz Theorem) The normed space Lg(X, p) is complete ( p = 1, 2) (in other words, it is a Banach space). More precisely:
(i) r f (g,) is a sequence of functions on X whose classes belong to Lg , m and if N,(gn) < + 00, then the series whose general term is g,(x) converges
1
n= 1
absolutely in R almost everywhere. I f g ( x ) = 2 g,(x), the class j of the funcm
n= 1
tion g (defined almost everywhere) belongs to Lg, and we have j =
1j, m
n= 1
in the normed space Lg . (ii) If (f,) is a sequence of functions such that the sequence (3,) of their equivalence classes is a Cauchy sequence in L i , then there exists a subsequence (fnJ such that (f n k ( x ) )converges to a limit f ( x ) in R almost everywhere. For each such subsequence (f,,), the class f of f belongs to Lg and is the limit of the sequence (f,)in the normed space Lg . (iii) Let (f,)be a sequence of functions belonging to 9’f;(X, p) such that the sequence ( f , ( x ) )converges almost everywhere to a limit f ( x ) , and suppose that there exists afunction h E U g ( X , p) such that If,(x)I 5 h(x) almost everywhere, for all n. Then the class f o f f belongs to Lp and is the limit of the sequence (?,) in the normed space Lg .
11 THE SPACES L’ AND
L2
161
To show that Lg is complete, it is clearly enough to prove (i) and (ii). We have already proved (i) in the casep = 1 (13.8.5). Whenp = 2, it follows from m
1 lgnlis finite almost every-
the hypotheses and (13.11.3.1) that the function where (13.6.4), and hence the series x E X. Hence the same is true for
m
n= 1
m
n= 1
Ig,(x)l converges in R for almost all
1g,(x),
and since Ig(x)l 5
n= 1
m
1 lgn(x)lalmost
everywhere, we have N,(g) < + co by (1 3.1 1.3.1). Moreover, g is measurable (13.9.11), hence its class belongs to L:. Since n= 1
for all n and almost all x E X, it follows from (13.11.3.1) that
which is arbitrarily small for large n. Hence 8
m
=
1J , .
n= 1
(ii) To prove the first assertion, it is enough to show that, for a suitably m
+ C (f,,+l(x)-f,,(x)) I
chosen subsequence
(f,,),the seriesf,,
(x)
converges
k= 1
almost everywhere, and that if f ( x ) is its sum (defined almost everywhere) then f = lim fn . We define the sequence (nk) inductively to satisfy n-+m
for all k 2 1 (and n, = 1); then it follows from (i) that the series
fn,(’>
CD
+ k = 1(fnk+I(’)
-fnk(’))
converges almost everywhere and that, if f ( x ) is its sum, then f = limTnk in Lg . Since (f,)is a Cauchy sequence, it follows that
f = limf,
k+ m
in L:,
n+m
by (3.14.2). To prove the second assertion, the preceding argument may be applied by replacing the sequence (f,) by any subsequence (Ak) which has a limit almost everywhere. (iii) For each n let g, = sup I&+,, - f , + k l . Then gnis 2 0 and meashzO, k z O
urable (1 3.9.1 I),and belongs to 2 ‘ : (1 3.9.1 3) because lgnl 5 2h. The sequence (gn) is decreasing and by hypothesis tends to 0 almost everywhere, hence
162
Xlll
lim N,(g,)
INTEGRATION = 0 (13.8.1).
n+m
This shows that the sequence (f,,) is a Cauchy
sequence in Lp, and converges to j* by virtue of (ii) and the hypotheses. A sequence (f,)in 9;which converges to f E 9 ; with respect to the topology defined by the seminorm N , is said to converge in themean to .f when p = 1, and to converge in square mean to f when p = 2. It can happen that .f, tends to f in this sense but that the sequence (f,(x)) does not converge in R for any x E X (Problem 1). (13.11.5) Let 6 c 9; be a dense set of functions (with respect to the topology
, there exists a defined by the seminorm N,). Then, f o r every function f E 9; sequence of functions g, E & such that the sequence (g,(x)) converges almost everywhere to f ( x)and such that gn tends to f i n 9;.
This follows immediately from (13.11.4) and the fact that in the metric space Lg there exists a sequence (8,) of classes of functions belonging to b, with f as limit (3.13.13). This result applies in particular when 8 = X,(X): The subspace X,(X) is dense in LFg(X, p) ( p = 1, 2). (ii) For each compact subset K of X, the topology induced on X,(X; K) by the topology of LF;(X, p ) is coarser than the topology defined by the norm l l f II. (iii) The spaces YiPg(X, p ) are separable ( p = 1, 2). (13.11.6) (i)
Assertion (i) has already been proved for p = 1 (13.7.2). To prove it for p = 2, it is enough to show that every function f 2 0 in 9;lies in the closure of X,(X). Now by (13.7.2), given any E > 0, there exists a function u E X,(X) such that N l ( f ’ - u ) S E , and since If’ - u+I 5 If’ - uI we may assume that u 2 0, hence that u = v’ with u E X,(X) and u 2 0 . But then If- ul’ 6 If’ - u’l, and consequently (N2(f-
UN2 =
N l ( l f - V1’) 5 Wlf’ - u’1) 2
&.
To prove (ii) it is enough to observe that for any g E X,(X; K) we have N , ( d 5 llsll * (P(K))l’p. Finally, let (K,) be an increasing sequence of compact sets which cover X and are such that X,(X) is the union of the X,(X; K,) (3.18.3). By (7.4.4) and (3.10.9), for each n there exists a dense sequence (gmn)m21 in the Banach space X,(X; K,,). From (i) and (ii) above, the double sequence (grnn)rntl.n~lis dense in WP(X, PI*
11 THE SPACES L’ AND
Lz
163
We remark that, given f E Y : ( X , p), it is not always possible to find a function f’ equivalent to f and a sequence of functions f, E XR(X)such that the sequence (S,(x)) converges tof’(x) for all x E X (Problem 3). We have already defined (13.10) the vector space Y h ( X , p) of complexvalued integrable functions. Likewise, we denote by Y i ( X , p) (or 9&), or 9;) the set of complex-valued p-measurable functions such that is p-integrable, and we define N,(f) and N,(f) by the formula (13.11.1) for any complex-valued function$ Since a complex-valued function is measurable if and only if 9f and 9fare measurable, and since SUP (IBf
I,
1.m)
If1
5
IBfl + I 9fl,
it follows that
Y i ( X , p ) = %%X,P) 0 i 9 i W L p )
All the properties of Y i ( X , p) proved above extend immediately to 9 E ( X , p) ( p = 1,2), and the Banach space LF;(X, p) (also denoted by 9 S ( p ) or Yf) is defined exactly as in the real case. Furthermore, we have (13.11.7) I f f t g belong to 9 i ( X , p) (resp. 9 i ( X , p)) then their product f g belongs to 9 A ( X , p) (resp. Y h ( X , p ) ) . The space Li(X, p) (resp. Li(X, p)) is a separable Hilbert space with respect to the Hermitian form (13.11.7.1)
(J 4) H(f14) =
s
f ( x )g o 444,
and the corresponding norm is N,(f). The product f g is measurable (I 3.9.8.1), hence the first assertion follows from (13.9.13) and (13.11.2.2). The second follows from the first together with the Fischer-Riesz theorem (13.11.4) and (13.11.6).
PROBLEMS
+
be Lebesgue measure on I = [O,1 [. For each integer n = 2h k (05 k < 2h), let f, be the function which is equal to 1 on the interval [k . 2 - h , (k 1) . 2 - h [ , and zero elsewhere. Show that the sequence (f,)converges to 0 in mean and in square mean, but that the sequence (f;(x)) does not converge for any x E I.
1. Let
+
164 2.
Xlll INTEGRATION
Let A be a subset of I = [0,1] which is not Lebesgue-measurable, and let f be the function which is equal to 1 on A and to - 1 on I - A. Then f 2 is integrable but f is not measurable.
3. Consider the sequence (A") defined in Problem 4(b) of Section 13.8, and let H be the union of the sets Az.+l (n > 0). Show that, if J is any nonempty open interval contained in I, then the sets J n H and J n (I - H) both have strictly positive measure. Now let f be a function equal to vH almost everywhere. Show that there does not exist any sequence (f,)of continuous functions on I which converges at every point of I to the functionf: (Remark thatfmust be discontinuous at every point of I, and use Problem 3 of Section 12.16.) 4.
Let p be a bounded measure of total mass 1 on a locally compact space X. Let (Ak)'Q r d n be a finite sequence of integrable subsets of X, such that p(Ak) = c > 0 for all k . If nc > 1 and E > c(1 - c)/(n - l), show that there exist two distinct indices i, j such that p(Afn A,) cz - E . (Argue by contradiction, using the CauchySchwarz inequality.)
5.
Let (fn)be a sequence of functions belonging to -Yk(X, p) ( p = 1 or 2) which converges almost everywhere to a functionf. (a) Show that, if N,(f.) 5 a for all n, then f~ U k ( X , p) and N,(f) 5 a. (Use Fatou's lemma.) Give an example (with p = 1) where N,(f,) does not tend to N,(f). (b) Now suppose in addition that N,(f.)+N,(f) as n-, S m . Show that N,(f-f,) + 0. (Show that for each E > 0 there exists a compact subset K of X and an
If. 1
dp 5
E
for all n 2 no .)
6 . In the space -Yi(I,A), where I = 10, 11 and h is Lebesgue measure, consider the functions t' ( a real), which belong to this space provided that a > - 3. Show that a sequence of distinct exponents a, > -3 is such that the functions tanform a total sequence in Yi(1, A) if and only if the sequence (an) satisfies one of the
following three conditions: there exists a subsequence of the sequence (an) tending to a finite limit > - 4; 1 (2) lima,=- - - and n-m 2 lim a. = m a n d z a;' = + co. (3) (1)
n-r m
+
"
(Using Weierstrass' theorem (7.4.1), calculate for each integer m > 0 the minimum of Nz(t"'- f ( r ) ) asfruns through the set of all linear combinations of the first n functions tuk. For this purpose, use Problem 3(b) of Section 6.6, and the formula (Cauchy's determinant) (or - aj)(bi - 6,) det - = (at 6,) '<' (a, 6,)
n
0
+
in which (ai),(b,) are any two sequences of n distinct numbers > O . ) Deduce that the
11 THE SPACES
sequence of functions consisting of 1 and sequence in the space WR(i), if and only if
t u n(n
c a;' n
L' AND Lz
2 l), where lirn a. n-m
=
= +to,
165
is a total
+ cci (" Muntz's theorem ").
In U : ( X , p) or U & ( X ,p) a sequence (fn) of functions is said to be orrhonormal if the sequence of classes A of these functions is an orthonormal system in the corresponding Hilbert space. (a) Let (fn) be an infinite orthonormal sequence, uniformly bounded on X. If IJ. is bounded, show that there exists a set A with measure >O such t h a t c Ifn(x)l = + OD
"
for all x E A. (Argue by contradiction, observing that the sequence (fn)cannot tend to 0 almost everywhere.) (b) Suppose that p is bounded. Let (f,)be a uniformly bounded infinite orthonormal sequence. If a sequence (a,) of scalars is such that the series with general term a.fn(x) converges almost everywhere, show that lim a. = 0 (use Egoroff's theorem applied to n- m
the sequence (1a.f. 1 ')). Show that there exists a sequence of scalars (6.) such that 1 b. 1 '/fn(x)1 = a,on a set of measure >O. (Choose the sequence lim 6. = 0 and
"
n-m
(b.) so that
"
Ib,( ' =
+
+ a ,and
argue by contradiction, by applying Egoroff's
theorem to the partial sums of the seriesz Ib,/
"
if. 1 2 . )
(c) Let (fa) be a sequence in 9'.Show that the following three conditions are equivalent: a) If a sequence (a") is such that the series with general term o.f,(x) converges on a set of measure >0, then lim a. = 0. n-m
fl)
If a sequence (a,) is such that the series with general term a.fn(x) converges absolutely on a set of measure >0, then lim a. = 0. n- m
y ) For every measurable set A of measure >0, we have
Iim inf n-m
(To prove that y ) implies a) and
J If.1
d p > 0.
A
fl), use Egoroffs theorem. To prove the converse,
argue by contradiction, by considering a subsequence (fnu)such that and taking an, = k and a.
=0
if n # nk .)
dp > l / k 3 , JA
(d) Suppose that p is bounded and (f.) is a sequence in PEPz. Prove that the following three conditions are equivalent: a) For each sequence (an)such that the series with general term a.f.(x) converges almost everywhere, we have lim a. = 0. n-m
p)
For each sequence (an>such that the series with general term a,f,(x) converges absolutely almost everywhere, we have lim a. = 0. n- m
y ) There exists 6 > 0 such that, for eveiry measurable set A whose complement
has measure 56, we have lirn inf n-m
Ilfnl
d p > 0. (Same method as (c).) Deduce that,
if the sequence (A) is orthonormal and uniformly bounded, it satisfies these three conditions, and therefore the series with general term a.f.(x) converges absolutely almost everywhere if and only if la.\ < co (use (b)).
"
+
XIII INTEGRATION
166
8. (a) Let ( f k ) l q , & be a finite orthonormal sequence in U&(X, p). Show that there exists a constant c independent of n such that, for every finite sequence S k Q n of complex numbers, we have
(Suppose first that n = 2‘. For each j 5 n, let
c J
s, =
h= I
a&.
Split up this sum into a t
most r + 1 partial sums corresponding to the dyadic expansion of the number j, so
that sJ = C pq where, for each q, either pq = 0 or else pq is of the form I
q=o
c
arb,
h.Z4
5r .
with 0 5 h < 2‘-q. Using Cauchy’s inequality ls,l’
Ipq12,show that
q=o
Finally, if 2’ 5 rr< 2’”, take the ak to be 0 for k > n.) (b) Let (w(n)),,31 be an increasing sequence of integers >0, and tending to + w . Let ( f n ) . 3 1 be an orthonormal sequence in U&(X,p). If the sequence is such that w(n)la,\’ < 03, and if ( n k ) is a sequence of integers such that
+
”
k
5 w(nk) < k 4-1,
nk
then the sequence of partial sums snk = C ajfi converges almost J= 1
everywhere in X. (Iff E U&(X, p) has the a, as coefficients (6.5.2) with respect to the system (h),evaluate Nz(f- snk)= rnk say, and remark that the series with general term r:, converges, using Abel’s partial summation technique by writing r i k = (k + 1 - k)r;, (Section 13.21, Problem 61.) (c) Suppose that the sequence (a,) is such that 2 In,l’(log n)’ < series
2 a.f, n
n
(First deduce from (b) that the sequence use (a) to show that, if 6, converges.)
+ w . Show that the
converges almost everywhere (“ Rademacher-Menchoff =
sup
Is,
(Szk)
theorem ”).
converges almost everywhere. Then
- s z k I , the series with general term j S : d p
Zkg“
9. Suppose that the measure p is bounded, so that Lz(X, p) c L1(X, p). Suppose also
that p(X) = 1. Let U be a continuous endomorphism of L’ with norm $1 (a “contraction”) whose restriction t o L2 is also a contraction (i.e., N,(U .?) 5 N2(f) in L2). 1”-1
Let P be the endomorphism of L2 which is the strong limit of n
U k(Section 12.15,
k=O
Problem 12), so that P = PU = UP = P’. Show that P can be extended by continuity to:an endomorphism of LLsatisfying the same relations and that
for all/€ L’ (use the fact that L2 is dense in L’ and that Nl(f)
5 N2(f ) . )
11
THE SPACES L’ AND Lz
167
10. Suppose that the measure p is bounded and that p(X) = 1. Let u be a p-measurable mapping of X into itself which leaves invariant the measure p (Section 13.9, Problem 24). Then for every functionfe P ( X , p) the class U . / = f o u depends only
on the class o f f , hence defines an endomorphism of L’, also denoted by fw(I.f, such that N,(U .f) = N,(f). The restriction of U to L2is a unitary operator on L2. (a) If P is the orthogonal projection of Lz on the subspace of vectors which are invariant under U,defined in Problem 9, show that N,(f)’ 5 (fl P .f)for allfc L2. (b) Show that for each 3 . L’ and each E > 0 there exists an integer n such that, for all integers m > 0,
(c) Deduce that, for each measurable subset A of X and each E > 0, there exists an integer n > 0 with the property that for each integer m > 0, there exists an integer k such that m 5 k =< m t n - 1 and p(A n u - ~ ( A )>=) (p(A))’ - E (“Khintchine’s statistical recurrence theorem ”). (d) For each f E and each integer n , put
Show that the limit F A X ) = lim
m-rm
1
m-1
- hC ( ( U h.f,>(x) - (P . f ) ( x ) Y , =o
m
s
(where P .fdenotes a function in the class P . f ) exists almost everywhere and that lim F, dp = 0. (Use Birkhoff’s ergodic theorem.)
n-r m
(e) LetfeY’(X, p) be such thatf(x)z 0 almost everywhere. Show that, for almost all x E X , either f ( x ) = 0 or ( P . f ) ( x ) > 0 . (Consider the set N of points x E X at which ( P . f ) ( x )is either undefined or equal to zero.) 11. Let X be a metrizable compact space and let u : X + X be a homeomorphism. The set I of measures 2 0 on X of total mass 1 and invariant under u is then a nonempty vaguely compact subset of M(X) (Section 13.4, Problem 8). A point x E X is said to be quasi-regular (relative to u) if the sequence of measures
+
converges vaguely as n + 03 (necessarily to a measure px E I). Let Q denote the set of quasi-regular points of X. A point x E Q is said to be ergodic (relative to u ) if the measure pxis ergodic (Section 13.9, Problem 13). Let E be the set of ergodic points x E Q. A point x E Q is said to be dense if x belongs to the support of px. Let D be the set of dense points x E Q. The points belonging to R = E n D are said to be regular (relative to p). (a) Show that the complement of R (and hence also the complement of Q, E and D) is negligible with respect to any invariant measure v E I. (To show that Q has measure 1 for any measure v E I, apply Birkhoff’s ergodic theorem to the functions belonging to a dense sequence in V?(X). To show that D has measure 1, consider a denumerable basis (U,) for the topology of X, and for each pair (m.n ) such that 0, c U,, a continuous
168
Xlll INTEGRATION
mapping gmn: X + [0, 11 such that gmn(x)= 1 for all x E U, and gmn(x)= 0 for all x E X - U.; apply Problem 10(e) to each of the functions gmn. Finally, to show that E has measure 1, show (with the notation of Problem 10) that, for any measure v E I,
j((P . f ) ( Y ) - (P. f ) ( x V W Y ) = 0 for almost all x E X and allfE U ( X ) ,by applying Problem 10(d); now letfrun through a dense sequence of functions in U( X) .) (b) With respect to the vague topology on M(X) show that, for every measure v E I,
in the sense of (13.10), and that the external points of I are the measures which are ergodic with respect to u (cf. Section 13.10, Problem 9). (c) For every ergodic measure v E I, let QV (resp. R,) be the set of points x E Q (resp. x E R) such that px = v . The measure v is concentrated on R, (13.18). The sets QYand R, are called the quasi-ergodic set and the ergodic set corresponding to v . The Qv(resp. R,) form a partition of Q (resp. R), and we have u(Q,)= Q. and u(RJ = R,. Show that, for each closed set F such that u(F) = F, we have either F n R,= R, or F n Ri= 0. (d) For every nonempty closed set F such that u(F) = F, show that R n F # @ (consider the points which are regular with respect to u [ F). (e) Let A be the monoid generated by l x and u. Show that if 2 is any minimal closed orbit with respect to A (Section 12.10, Problem 6) we have u(2) = 2 and hence R n 2 # @. Deduce that, for each x E X, the closed orbit O(x) of x with respect to A intersects R, and that O ( x ) n R is a union of ergodic sets R, . (f) For each x E X,let p be a measure which is a cluster point of the sequence (pn,x) in M(X). Show that p(O(x))= 1. (g) Show that for a measure p E I to be ergodic it is necessary and sufficient that there should exist an ergodic set R, such that p(RJ = 1, and that then we have p = v . (Use (b) to prove that the condition is sufficient.) (h) If x E X is such that O(x) contains only one ergodic set, show that x is an ergodic point (use (f) and (g)). (i) Suppose that I consists of a single measure y o . Then Q = X, and R = D is the support of vo (use (h)) and is the only minimal closed orbit with respect to M. More1”-l
over, for each function f~ %‘(X),the sequence of numbers f(uk(x)) converges to n k=O f / d v , uniformZy in x
E
X. (Observe that, for each n , the mapping x ~ p . ,of X into
M(X) is continuous with respect to the vague topology, and use (7.5.6))
(s’
12. For every real number p such that 0 < p <
NU)=
Ifl,
+ co, and every mapping f:X +R, put
dp)’”’
(a) If p > 1, put q = p / ( p - I). I f f , g are any two mappings of X into R,show that N l ( f g ) 5 N ,(f)N,( g) (“Holder’s inequality”). (Show that the set of points (rl, tz) E R2 such that t 1 2 0 and t 2 2 0 and t : l P t Y 2 1 is convex, and argue as in Section 13.8, Problem 14(c), making use of (13.5.6). Notice that the proof of (13.11.2.2) is a particular case.) (b) I f f 2 0,g 2 0 and p > 1, then N,( f ’+ g ) I N , ( f ) N,(g) (“ Minkowski’s inequality”). (Same method as (a): consider the set of points (II, t z ) such that t l L 0 and t 2 2 0 and ti’’ I:/’ 2 I . )
+
+
11 THE SPACES L’ AND
L2
169
(c) Extend the results of Section 13.11 to the case where p is any number such that 1 < p < +a. (d) Suppose that p > 1. Let f~ U i , g E -3’2 be two functions 2 0. Show that we have Nl(fg) = N,(f)N,(g) if and only if there exist two constants a > 0, p > 0 such that a(f(x))” = p(g(x))‘I almost everywhere. (e) Suppose that the measure p is bounded and that p(X) = 1. For each r > 0 and each measurable function 0 such that f‘ is integrable, show that the mapping p - N p ( f ) is an increasing function on the interval 10, r ] (use HGlder’s inequality).
fz
As p - 0 , its limit isexp(J* log
If1
d p ) , or 0 if
I’
log
If1
dp = - co. If the limit is
# 0, it follows that f ( x ) # 0 almost everywhere. If exp(l* log
the function (f) Let
If1
if1
dp)
=
/If1
dp,
is constant almost everywhere.
fz0 be a p-measurable function, and for each a > 0 let A, be the set of all
2 a. I f f e &;, then app(A,) 6/fp dp. Conversely, if the measure p is bounded and if there exist constants C > 0, E > 0 such that p(A.) C . a - p - c for all a > 0, then f~ 9: (cf. Section 13.9, Problem 3).
x E X such thatf(x)
+
f be a real valued function 2 0 defined on R*, = ] 0, to [, which is Lebesguemeasurable and such that I f l p is Lebesgue-integrable (1 < p < co). (a) The functionfis integrable on every compact subset of LO, co [,and in particular
13. Let
c +
F(x) =
f ( f ) dr
+ +
is defined for all x > 0 (use Holder’s inequality). As x tends to 0
or t o co, the quotient F ( X ) / X ( ~ tends -~)’~ to 0 (same method). (b) Show that the function F(x)/x is pth-power-integrable on 10,
+ co [ and that
(“Hardy’s inequality”). (Consider first the case where f~ X(R+,).For each compact interval [a, b] c R*, , majorize the integral using Holder’s inequality.)
Jab
(F(r)/fy df, by integrating by parts and
f be a complex p-measurable function such that ( I ) I f l p is p-integrable and ( 2 ) e r f is p-integrable for 0 < f < f o . Show that N p ( r - ’ ( e r f - 1) -f) -0 as r +O. (Let f = u iv where u and v are real; observe that if we put wI= erY- 1 - ru, we have w,/s 2 wI/f for 0 6 s 5 t. If 0 c p < 1, use the elementary inequality (a b)’ 5 u p bP when n , b are 2 0 . Finally, apply (13.8.1) and (1 3.8.4).)
14. Let p be a real number > O and let
+
+
15.
+
Let (An)”s1be a strictly increasing sequence of integers >0, and let h be a rational integer. For each integer N 2 I , put
Show that the series
170
Xlll
INTEGRATION
converges. Note that if mz 6 N < (rn
+ l)',
we have
~ to 0 for almost all x E [0, I ] (with and deduce that the sequence ( & ( x ) ) ~ >tends respect to Lebesgue measure). Hence show that, for almost all x E [0, I], the sequence (x.x - [x,x]) is equirepartitioned with respect to Lebesgue measure (Section 13.4, Problem 7).
16. Let U be a continuous endomorphism of the space LA(X, p) with norm 5 1 (in other words, such that NI(U . f ) 5 N,(f)) and such that the relationfz 0 implies U .f& 0 (13.6). l f f i s any function in the class we denote by U . f a n y function in the class V .J: (a) Let (f,) be a sequence of functions in 2 L p :which converges almost everywhere to a function f and is such that there exists a function h E Y i satisfying 1f n l 5 h for all n. Show that under these conditions the sequence ( U .f,) converges almost everywhere to U -f (Reduce to the case f = 0, and consider the sequence of functions
r:
9. = SUP
lf"+Pl.)
P
(b) For each finite sequence (rk)l
k
of real numbers, put
s,(tl, . . . , t,) = If s,(tl,
SUP lQkdn
(r,
+ . . . + tr)+
(fl
+ .. . + t k ) .
. . . ,t.) :0, then . . . ,t.)
S,(t,,
.
=
sup
1Sk8n
Show that if s n ( t l , .. , t,) > 0, then for all (11
tl
r,,,
E
R we have
+ s,(tz, . . . , t n + d1s.(tl, ..., td.
(c) For each functionfE U:, show that
...
S"(U.f,
)
un+1.f)z U.S"(f,
. . ' ) U..f)
almost everywhere. (Use (I) and the fact that for any n functions f , , we have sup
IqkQn
u'fksu'
sup
...,f , E 14:
fk
I&k
almost everywhere.) (6) Let E(f) be the measurable set of points x
E
X such that
(Un-1' f ) ( x )> 0
f(x)+(U'"(x)+.''i
for some integer n > 0. Show that
(E. Hopf's maximal ergodic theorem). (For each integer n 2 1, let E,(f) denote the set of x E X such that f ( x ) -1 ( U .f)(x)
+ . t- (Uk f ) ( x ) > 0 ' '
-
'
11
for some integer ic between 0 and n-I ; show that
THE SPACES
J
En(,)
L' AND Lz
171
f dp 2 0 by using (c) above.)
Hence deduce the maximal ergodic theorem of Section 13.9, Problem 12. 17. Suppose that U satisfies the conditions of Problem 16 and also that for each t > 0 the relation i f ( x ) I t almost everywhere in X implies that I(U .f)(x)I t almost everywhere. (This will be the case whenever p is bounded and U . c = c for each constant c.) (a) Show that, for each function f~ 9; and each t > 0,
<
almost everywhere. (Consider the function which is equal to fwhen lf(x)l 5 f , to 1 whenf(x) > t, and to - / when f ( x ) < -/.) (b) Show that, for each function f E 9; n 9,," the function U .f belongs to 2'; for 1 < p 5 co and that
+
(Deduce from (1 3.21.9) that for eachfE 9; n9 2 ,the function (x, t ) - F 2 ( f ( x ) - 1)' is integrable relative to the measure on X x 10, +a)[ which is the product of p and Lebesgue measure, and then integrate the inequality tP-2
5 t.-'(f-
( U . f - t)'
t)+.)
Deduce that U can be extended to an endomorphism of norm 5 1 of each of the spaces 9 g . Denote this extension also by U. (c) Let f e 9 p h for some p E [ l , +a)[. For each t > 0 and each integer n 2 0, let E , , , t ( f )denote the set of points x E X such that
t ...+ (u"-' .f)(x)>nt,
f(x)+(U.f)(x)
and let E,(f) denote the union of the En,,(f). Show that each of the sets E,,,(f) is integrable and that
(Observe that E.,,(f) is contained in the set of points x E X satisfying one or other of then relations ( U k . f ) ( x ) > t, where 0 5 k n - 1; then continue as in Problem 16, by remarking that
<
(U
.f+ U 2 .f+ ". + Uk-' .f- (k + 1)t)' 5 U '(f+ u .f + ". + U' .f- (k + l)f)+.)
(d) I f f € Y ; , deduce from (c) that
for all t > 0. 18. Suppose that U satisfies the conditions of Problem 16. Let k g E 9: be such that f Z 0 and g 2 0. (a) Let E be a real number > 0, and let A, be the set of x E X which satisfy the inequality (U" .f)(x) >
+ (ug ) ( x ) -t . + (U" '
' '
'
g)(x)).
172
Xlll INTEGRATION
Show that the series Y A l g (Observe that
+ g)AZg + ... + 9A.g + . . . converges almost everywhere.
almost everywhere; integrate both sides, and use (1 3.8.5)) (b) Let B be the measurable set of points x E X such that ( U " . g ) ( x ) > O for at least one integer n 2 0. Show that in B the sequence of functions un.fl(g+ U . g + . . . + U " . g )
converges to 0 almost everywhere. (Deduce from (a) above that the intersection of A, with the set { x E X :g ( x ) > 01 is negligible. Now replace g and f successively by
0"
U " . g and U" .J where m 2 1.) (c) Let Bo be the measurable set of points x let
such that g ( x ) > 0. For each x
EX
and let R*(f, 9)= sup [ R,(f, g ) I. Show that R*(J g ) ( x ) <
"
(For each t > 0, let A, be the set of points x t j A c9 d p
E
5 NI(f) by applying Problem 16(d) to I f 1
+ ( U . @)(x) + . + (U" . ' '
00
for almost all x
E Bo
.
B, such that R*(J g ) ( x ) > t . Show that
(d) Let @ E 0,be :such that Q(x) > 0 for all x X, of points x :6 X such that @(x)
+
E Bo
-t
EX
.9.)
(cf. (1 3.1 5.7)). Show that the set
@)(XI
+ ... = +
cc1
does not depend on the choice of @, but only on U. For each x E X, let
+ ( U . @ ) ( x )+ . . . + (w-1 . (so that G ( x ) + for x EX,).
G.(x) = @ ( x )
and let G ( x ) = limG.(x) n- m
Q(X)
=
00
Show that for each
integrable set A c X, and each t > 0 we have t . ( U .vA) 6 G , and hence, that the function U . q A is zero almost everywhere in X, = CX, . (Observe that, if A. is the set of x E A such that G , ( x ) > f , then tqAn 2 G , .)
12. THE SPACE
L"'
Iff is a mapping of X into R, the maximum in measure (resp. minimum in measure) offon X (with respect to the measure p) is defined to be the greatest lower bound (resp. least upper bound) of the real numbers a such that f ( x ) 5 a (resp. f ( x ) 2 a) almost everywhere with respect to p, and is denoted by M,(f), or ess supf, or ess supf(x) (resp. m,(f), or ess inff, or ess inff(x)). Clearly we have m , ( f )
XEX
=
-Ma(-f).
X E X
12 THE SPACE L"
173
Suppose that M,(f) < +a.Then for each a > M,(f) the set of points x E X such that f ( x ) > a is negligible. Now the set of points x E X such that f ( x ) > M,(f) is the union of the sets of x E X such that f ( x ) > r n , where (rn)is a decreasing sequence with M , ( f ) as limit. Hence (13.6.2) we have m,(f) 5 f ( x ) 5 M,(f) almost everywhere in X . It follows that m , ( f ) S M , ( f ) if p # 0. (If p = 0, then m,(f) = + co and M,(f) = - m.) The relation m,(f) = M,(f) is equivalent to saying that f is equivalent to a constant if p # 0. Also (still assuming that p # 0) we have inff(x) XEX
5 ess inff(x) 5 ess supf(x) 5 supf(x). xsx
xex
XEX
If two functions ft g are equivalent, then
Hence we can define m,( f ) and M a ( f)for a function f which is defined only almost everywhere in X : we choose any function g ~ f s u c hthat g is defined everywhere in X, and put m,(f) = m,(g) and M,(f) = M,(g). Iff and g are such thatf+ g is defined almost everywhere, then (13.12.1)
M,(f
+ s) 5 M A f ) + M,(g)
wherever the right-hand side is defined. Likewise, iff and g are both 2 0, then
Mm(fg) 5 Mm(.f)Mm(g) with the product convention of (13.11). A function,f, defined almost everywhere on X, with values in R or C, is said to be bounded in measure or essentially bounded (with respect to p) if M,(1 f 1) < + ca ; it follows that f is thenfinite almost everywhere. A bounded function is bounded in measure. (Mean value theorem) Let f : X + R be measurable and (13.12.2) bounded in measure. For every integrable function g 2 0, the function f g (which is defined and finite almost everywhere) is integrable, and (13.12.2.1)
s s
s
mm(f) g d P S f g d P S M m ( f ) gdP*
Furthermore, two of the three terms in (13.12.2.1) are equal only is, in the (measurable) set S of points x E X such that g(x) # 0, we have either f ( x ) = M,(f) almost everywhere, or f ( x ) = m,(f) almost everywhere.
174
Xlll
INTEGRATION
The function f g is measurable (13.9.8.1) and we have m ,(f )g(x) 5 f ( x ) g ( x ) I M ,(f ) g ( 4 almost everywhere. Hence fg is integrable (1 3.9.1 3), and the inequalities (13.12.2.1) follow. On the other hand, the function M,(f)g - f g is defined almost everywhere and equal to ( M , ( f ) - f ) g , hence is almost everywhere 2 0 in X. Hence the relation / ( M , ( f ) - f ) g dp = 0 implies that (M,( f ) - f ) g is negligible, which completes the proof. In particular, if A is any integrable set, we have (13.12.2.2)
For any functionfon X with values in R or C, we put N , ( f ) = M,(I f I) if p # 0, and N , ( f ) = 0 if p = 0. By virtue of (13.12.1), the set Y;(X, p) (resp. Y , " ( X , p)) of real-valued (resp. complex-valued) measurable functions on X such that N , ( f ) < +a is a real (resp. complex) vector space, and N, is a seminorm on this space. The set of functions f such that N , ( f ) = 0 is once again the vector subspace N of negligible functions. The quotient of Yg(X, p) (resp. Y , " ( X , p)) by this subspace is therefore the space of equivalence classesf of measurable functions bounded in measure. It is denoted by L,"(X, p ) , or simply by L;(p) or Lg (resp. L,"(X, p), or L?(p) or L,"). The number N , ( f ) is the same for all functionsfbelonging to the same class f~ L; (resp. f~ L,"); it is denoted also by N,(f), and the function ?I--+ N , ( f ) is a norm on Lg (resp. L,"). Clearly we have L," = Lg 0 iLg . (1 3.12.3) For a sequence (f,)in 9 2 (resp. 9,") to converge to a function S, it is necessary and sujicient that f , ( x ) should tend uniformly to f ( x ) in the complement of a negligible set.
The condition is clearly sufficient. Conversely, if lim N,( f -f,)
= 0, then
n- m
for each integer m there exists a negligible set H, and an integer no such that, for all n >= n o , we have I f ( x ) -f,(x)I 5 l / m for all X E CH,. The union H of the sets H, is negligible, and f , ( x ) tends to f ( x ) uniformly in GH. (13.12.4) The normed space L,"(X, p) (resp. L,"(X, p)) is complete (Lea, a Banach space).
Let (,f,) be a sequence such that (f,)is a Cauchy sequence in L; (resp. L,"). For each integer n >= 1, there exists an integer k , such that N,(L
-f)5 1/n
12
THE SPACE L"
175
for r 2 k, and s 2 k , . For each pair (r, s) such that r 2 k , and s 2 k,, let A,,, be the negligible set of points x E X such that If,(x) -f,(x)I > I/n, and let A be the union of the sets A,,, (n 2 1, r 2 k , , s 2 k,), so that A is a negligible set. It is clear that in X - A the sequence ( f , ( x ) ) converges uniformly to a limitf(x). The functionf, which is defined almost everywhere, is measurable (13.9.10) and bounded in X - A. Hence f~ Lg (resp. f~ L,"). Clearly N , ( f - f , ) 5 I/n for all r 2 k , , and therefore 7 is the limit of the sequence (f,).
(13.12.5) r f f E S[(X, p ) (where p = 1 or 2) and g E =.YF(X,p), then PI, and N,(fg) 5 N p ( f ) N m ( 9 ) .
fgE
ym
For fg is measurable (13.9.8.1), and If(x)g(x)l everywhere; hence the result.
If(x)IN,(g)
almost
Remark
(13.12.6) Evidently we have %;(X) c S g ( X , p); but in general the canonical image of %?;(X) in L,"(X, p ) is not dense in the latter space, and L,"(X, p ) is not separable in general (Problem 1). PROBLEMS
1. If h is Lebesgue measure, show that the space Lg(R, h) is not separable. (If (A,) is an infinite sequence of nonnegligible measurable sets, no two of which intersect, consider the functions which are constant on each A, and take only the values 1.) 2.
(a) For every p-integrable subset A of X ahd every 6 > 0, let V(A, 6) denote the set of p-measurable real-valued functions f such that the set M of points x E A for which If(x)l > 6 has measure p(M) 2 6. Let Y ( X , p) denote the vector space of (finite) real-valued p-measurable functions on X. Show that the sets V(A, 6) form a fundamental system of neighborhoods of 0 for a topology on Y(X, p) compatible with its vector space structure (Section 12.14, Problem 1). This topology is called the topology of convergence in measure (with respect to p). A sequence (fn)which tends to a limitf in this topology is said to converge in measure to f. (b) Show that the intersection of all the neighborhoods V(A, 6) is the subspace .N of negligible functions, and that the quotient space S(X, p) = 9 ( X , p ) / N is metrizable. (c) If (fn) is any sequence in Y ( X , p) (12.9) such that (h)is a Cauchy sequence in S(X, p), show that there exists a subsequence (jJ of (f,)such that the sequence (fnk(x)) converges for almost all x E X. Deduce that the metrizable vector space S(X, p) is complete. (d) Every sequence (1;)of measurable real-valued functions which converges almost everywhere to a functionf, converges in measure tof. (e) For every finitep 2 1, show that the space U g ( X , p) is dense in Y ( X , p),and that the topology induced on 3g(X,p) by the topology of convergence in measure is coarser than that defined by the seminorm N, .
Xlll INTEGRATION
176
(f) Suppose that X is compact and that the measure p is diffuse (13.18). Show that, for every neighborhood V of 0 in .V(X, p) and every function f E Y(X, p), there exists an integer n such that all the functions af(where a is any real number) belong to V ... V ( n summands). Deduce that every continuous linear form on .V(X, p) is identically zero, and hence that every vector subspace of finite codimension in .V(X,p) is dense in Y ( X , p).
+ +
3. Suppose that X is compact and the measure p diffuse (13.18). (a) Let be a Hilbert basis of Lk(X, p). Show that, for each real number 6 > 0, there exists a compact subset Y of X such that p(X - Y) 5 6 and the sequence is total in L;(Y, py).(By using Problems 2(e) and 2(f), show that there exists a sequence of linear combinations of the f. ( n >= 2) which converges in measure to fl ; then use Problem 2(c) and Egoroffs theorem.) (b) Show that there exists a bounded measurable function h such that the sequence (&),,2 is total in L&(X,p). (Choose h > 0 such that f J h $ U&(X,p),and then show that no nonnegligible function can be orthogonal to hf. for all n >= 2.) 4.
Let p be a finite real number if, for each
E
>= 1. A subset H of
.PJLpg(X, p) is said to be equi-integrable
sA1fIp
> 0, there exists a compact subset K of X such that
for all f~ H, and a real number 6 > 0 such that
6.
integrable sets A of measure p(A)
sx-,lf1P
d p =( E
dp 5 E for all f~ H and all
(a) On an equi-integrable set H, show that the topology of convergence in measure is the same as that defined by the seminorm N, . Is the conclusion true if H is merely bounded in Y p ? (b) A sequence (f.) in .P&(X,p) is convergent if and only if it is equi-integrable and convergent in measure. (c) Suppose that the measure p is bounded and that p(X) = 1. Let (f,)be a sequence of functions belonging to Y & ,and suppose that lim lim Nl(I -If.[)
= 0.
"+a
s s
Show that lim
n-r m
n-r m
I Yfnldp = 0. (Use (b).)
(d) With p as in (c), let (f.) be a sequence of functions belonging to 9 ';such that
If.1
d p = lim n-r m
s
lfnll'z
dp = 1.
Show that lirn N1(l -f,)= 0. (Reduce to the situation of (c) above by using the n-r m
Cauchy-Schwarz inequality; write 11 - L l S 11 - ILII
and
+ 1If.I -f,l
11 - I L I ~= 11 - I f n I 1 / z I 5.
11
+ I.Lnt1'21.)
Let F be a real-valued function with period 1 on R which is integrable on the unit interval I = [0, 11 (with respect to Lebesgue measure). (a) Iff is any bounded measurable function on [0,1], then
12 THE SPACE L"
177
If also F is bounded on [O, 11, then this equality is valid for every integrable functionfon [0,1]. (Start with the case where F is bounded a n d f i s continuous on [0, 11, then (forfE 2")approximatefby continuous functions. When F is unbounded, reduce to the case F 2 0 and approximate F by an increasing sequence of bounded functions.) (b) Deduce from (a) that, for every function f which is integrable on an interval [a, b ] in R , we have lim j a b f ( t )sin nt dt = lim
I-m
j a b f ( t )cos nt
dt = 0.
"-4"
(c) Let q~ be the canonical mapping of R onto T = R/Z, and let p be the measure on T which is the image under q~ I I of Lebesgue measure on I; then p is invariant under translations in the compact group T (cf. (1 4.4)). Let k be an integer > 1, and let u : T + T be the continuous mapping such that u(v(t))= u ( k t ) for t E 1. The mapping u is not injective, but p is invariant with respect to u. Deduce from (a) that u is ergodic with respect to p (use Problem 13(b) of Section 13.9). Deduce that lim sup F(k"t) n-tm
is almost everywhere equal to the constant ess sup F(t), and that the same is true of
sup F(nr).
n21
6. Let
(cI
f~ 9 ; ( p ) . Show that
Isf I =!if] dp
161
d p if and only if there exists c E C with
= 1 such thatf(x) = clf(x)[almost everywhere.
S
7. Suppose that p is bounded and that p ( X ) = 1. LetfE 9;.If we have (1 for every complex number [, show that
s
+ [fl
dp >= 1
f d p = O . (For a fixed [ E C , consider
8. (a) If l s p < r < + m , then L:n L, "cLg n L: and L ; n L , " c L L n L , " . On the space L;: n L," , the function N,,, = N, + N, is a norm with respect to which the space is complete. Give an example in which the norm induced on L&n L," by n Lg we always have N,,,(f) 5 2Np,,(f).) NP., is not equivalent to N,,, . (In The space L;: n L," is a Banach algebra relative to the product 38 defined in Section 13.6; it posesses an identity element only if p is bounded (in which case it is identical with L,"). (b) The set I(X, p) (or I(p)) of idempotents in the algebra L> n L2 is independent of r , and consists of the classes @ A , where A runs through the set of integrable subsets of X. If A, B are integrable subsets of X, the relation @A = qB signifies that the set D(A, B) = A u B -A n B (Section 13.8, Problem 15) is negligible; the relation p(D(A, B)) = 0 is an equivalence relation on the set of integrable subsets of X, and the quotient set may be identified with I(X, p). We shall write A in place of qA. All the norms N,," induce the same topology on I(X, p), and this topology is therefore defined by the distance d(& 8) = NI(vA - yB)= p(D(A, B)), with respect to which I(X, p) is a complete space. The mappings (A, 8)Hsup(& 8) = (A u B)" and (A, 8)Hinf(A, 8 )= (A n B)" are continuous for this topology. (c) Let Y be another locally compact space, v a positive measure on Y. If there exists an isometry U of I(X, p) onto I(Y, v) such that U ( 4 ) = the measures p and v are said to be isometric. For each number p E [l, m [, there then exists a unique
+
4,
178
Xlll INTEGRATION linear isometry U,,of LE(X, p) onto L((Y, v) which extends U. (Show that U has a unique extension to a linear bijection of the space E(X, p) of classes of p-integrable step functions on X, onto the space E(Y, v) of_classes of v-integrable step functions on Y . Begin by proving that if inf(A, 8 ) = $, then also inf(U(A), U(8))= C$ and U(sup(A, 8))= sup(U(A), U ( B ) ) ; then deduce that U ( A ) 5 U(B)whenever A 5 8 ; finally, show that for arbitrary A,B we have U(inf(A, B)) = inf(U(A), U(@) and U(sup(A,B)) = sup(U(A), U(8)).Observe then that N,(U(f)) = N,(f) forfE E(X, p).) Show that the image of L[(X, p) n LF(X, p) under U p is L:(Y, v) n L,"(Y, v), and that the restriction of U p to Lg(X, p) n L,"(X, p) is an isomorphism of Banach algebras.
+
(d) Conversely, for a p such that 1 s p < m , let V be a linear isometry of Lg(X, p) onto Lg(Y, v) such that the restriction of V to Lg(X, p ) n L,"(X, p) is an algebra isomorphism onto L;(Y, v) n L,"(Y, v). Then the restriction of V to 1(X, p) is an isometry onto 1(Y, v) which maps I$ to
4.
9. Let X be a compact space such that p(X) = I . Let 2 be a set of integrable subsets of X, such that the relations A E 5 and B E 5 imply that X - A E 2 and A n B E 5 . Suppose also that the set {A:A E Z} is dense in the metric space I(X, p) (Problem 8). (a) Let (Cj)lsjCn be a finite partition of X into p-integrable subsets. Show that for each E > 0 there exists a partition (Aj)1Qj4,,consisting of sets in 5 such that p(D(Cj, A,)) : E for 1 5j 5 n. (Observe that if p(D(Cj, Bj)) 5 6 for 1 5 j 5 n - I , then p ( B j n B,) 5 26 for I 51j < k 5 n - 1 ; if N is the union of the Bj n B,, consider
the sets Aj =: B,
-N
(1
5 j 5 n - 1) and A,, = X
u Aj).
"- 1
-
j=1
of X into integrable (b) Deduce from (a) that for each finite partition y = (C,), subsets, and each E 1 0 , there exists a finite partition a = (Aj)lajsn consisting of sets in Z and such that (in the notation of Section 13.9, Problem 27)
H(a/y) -i-H(y/a) 5 E . (Reduce to the case where none of the C j is negligible, and use the fact that the function t ~ +t log t is zero and continuous at f = I . ) 10. Let X be a compact space such that p ( X ) = 1, and let u : X --z X be a p-measurable mapping such that u ( p ) = p . (a) Let a be a finite partition of X into integrable subsets, and let Z be the set of all finite unions of subsets of X belonging to one or other of the partitions
n-
1
V [)-'(a).
j = O
Suppose that the set of classes {A: A E 2) is dense in 1(X, p) (Problem 8). Show that we then have h(u) : h(u, a). (It is enough to show that h(u, /3) 5 h(u, a ) for every finite partition /3 of X into integrable subsets; observe that we have
and use Problem 28(d) of Section 13.9, and Problem 9 above.) is (b) Under the hypotheses of (a), show that if in addition u is bijective and p-measurable, then h(u)= 0. (Observe that the set of classes { ( u - * ( A ) ) - :A E Z} is again densc in I(X, p), and use Problem 28(c) of Section 13.9.) (c) S~tpposethat u is bijective and N - I is p-measurable. Let 5' be the set of finite
" V uj(a),and suppose J = -n
unions of subsets of X belonging to one or other of the partitions
13 MEASURES WITH BASE p
179
that the set of classes A, as A runs through 5', is dense in 1(X, p). Show that h(u) = h(u, a ) (Kolmogoroff-Sinai theorem). (Same method as in (a).) (d) Take X to be the unitcircle U : 1 z 1 = 1, let p be the image of Lebesgue measure under the mapping t H e Z Z iof t [0, I ] onto U, and let N be the mapping z H e Z n L a z . Show that h(u) = 0. (Distinguish two cases according as 8 is rational or irrational. In the latter case use (b), by taking a to be a partition into two half-open semicircles.) 11. Let X, Y be two compact spaces and let p (resp.v) be a positive measure on X (resp. Y ) such that p(X) = v(Y) = 1. A p-measurable (resp. v-measurable) mapping u : X HX (resp. u : Y t,Y) such that u ( p )= p(resp. u(v) = v) defines an endomorphism U : ~ H(f0 u) - of L&(X,p) (resp. an endomorphism V :B H (g 0 v)- of Li(Y, v)) (Section 13.1 1, Problem 10). The mappings u, u are said to be conjugate if there exists an isometry T of I(X, p) onto I(Y, v) (Problem 8) such that V o T = T o U. Show that if this is the case then h(u) = h ( v ) .
12. Suppose that the measure p is bounded, and let p E [ l , +a[. Let (Un) be a sequence of continuous linear mappings of L&(X)into the space S(X, p) (Problem 2). For any function of f e -Yk we denote by U, .f any function belonging to the class U, .f and pu$
For each a > 0 let E.,N(f) denote the set of all x E X such that (U,*. f ) ( x ) > a, and let E,(f) denote the set of all x f X such that (U* . f ) ( x )> a. (a) Show that the set of f~ Lg such that p(E.,N(f)) 5 E is closed, for each E > 0. (b) Assume that for aN f E 2 k the function U* . f i s finite almost everywhere. Show that under these conditions the number
+
tends t o 0 as a+ co (Banach's principle). (Use Bake's theorem in the complete space Lg .) (c) Under the hypotheses of (b), show that the set H of classes f such that the sequence ((U, . f ) ( x ) )converges everywhere in X is closed in Lk. (Write
RVXX) = lim .-a
remark that R(f)(x)
=
(
SUP
m,n3,
I (u,,,. f ) ( x ) - (u,. f ) ( x ) lj,
R(f- g ) ( x ) almost everywhere for @ E H, and use (b).)
13. MEASURES WITH BASE p
n.
Then the following con(13.13.1) Let g be a mapping of X into C or into ditions are equivalent: (a) For each x E X,there exists a neighborhood V of x in X such that gqv is integrable.
180
Xlll INTEGRATION
(b) The function g is measurable, and f o r each compact set K c X we have J*lc?l(P.
dP < + a *
(c) For each function h E X,(X), the function gh is integrable.
+
Since we may write g = g1 ig, , where g 1 and 9 , are 8-valued, and then g1 = g : - g ; , g 2 = g t - g ; , we reduce straightaway ((13.9.6) and (13.10)) to the case where g is a mapping 2 0 of X into To show that (a) implies (b), cover K by a finite number of open sets V j such that g q is integrable for VJ each j . Then sup(gcp,,) is integrable (13.7.4) and hence so I S
w.
j
g(PK = (PK * sup(g'PVj) i
(13.9.14). Hence (b) follows from (13.9.13). To show that (b) implies (c), observe first that g is almost everywhere finite (X being a denumerable union of compact sets), hence gh is measurable (13.9.8.1). Moreover, if L = Supp(h), we have 1gh( 5 lgpLl * Ilhll, hence it follows from (b) and (13.9.1 3) that gh is integrable. Finally, to show that (c) implies (a), consider a compact neighborhood V of x e X and a continuous mapping h : X -+ [O, 1) which is equal to 1 on V and has compact support ((3.18.2) and (4.5.2)). By hypothesis gh is integrable, hence so is g p , = (gh)pv (13.9.14).
When the equivalent conditions of (13.13.1) are satisfied, the function g is said to be locally integrable (with respect to p) or locally p-integrable. Clearly every integrable function is locally integrable. Every measurable function whose restriction to every compact subset of X is bounded almost everywhere (in particular, every function belonging to 9 2 or 2'2) is locally integrable. Every function belonging to 9;or 9 6 is locally integrable, by (13.11.7). Every function equivalent to a locally integrable function is locally integrable. We have remarked in the course of the proof of (13.13.1) that every locally integrable function is finite almost everywhere. The function on R which is equal to l/lxl when x # 0 and is 0 when x = 0 is lower semicontinuous but not locally integrable with respect to Lebesgue measure. For a complex-valued function g to be locally integrable,,it is necessary and sufficient that Seg and 9 g should be locally integrable. For a real-valued function g to be locally integrable, it is necessary and sufficient that g+ and g- should be locally integrable.
i
Let g be a locally p-integrable function. Sincef H fg dp is defined on the whole of .X,(X), it is a linear form on this complex vector space. Moreover
13 MEASURES WITH BASE p
181
this linear form is a (complex) measure on X, because if K is any compact subset of X,we have
for allfE X,(X; K), by virtue of (13.10.3). The measure so defined is called the measure with density g relative to p, and is denoted by g * p ; when g is continuous, this agrees with the definition (13.1.5). Measures of the form g p are also called measures with base p. It follows immediately from this definition that if g takes values in R (resp. 20 almost everywhere), then the measure g * p is real (resp. positive). Furthermore, g p does not change if we replace g by an equivalent function (with respect to p), and therefore we may restrict ourselves to the case where g is everywhere finite and universally measurable (1 3.9.12). If g 1 and g2 are two locally integrable functions, then g 1 + g2 and ag, are locally integrable (a being any complex scalar), and we have
-
-
For every complex-valued locally integrable function g, we have
(13.13.4) The set 9;oc, R(X,p) (resp. 9’;oc, c(X, p)) of real-valued (resp. complex-valued) locally p-integrable functions is a real (resp. complex) vector space, often denoted by 910c(X,p ) or 2’loe(p) or U,,,(X) or Y p l O c . For every compact subset K of x, the mapping p K :g w )g(pKI dp is a semi-norm on this space. We shall always suppose YlOc to be endowed with the topology defined by these seminorms. If (K,) is an increasing sequence of K, = X and K, c K,,, (3.18.3), then it is compact subsets of X, such that
i
u n
immediately seen that the topology of 9,0c is defined by the seminorms pK,. In particular, if, X is compact, then 9’;oc, R(X,p) (resp. $Plot, c(X, p)) is identical with 9 k ( X , p) (resp. 9’A(X, p)). The set of locally integrable realvalued functions g such that p&) = 0 for all compact subsets K of X is the space Jfr of p-negligible functions. We define Lioc,
p) = 9’lloc,
p)/ Jfr
and L;oc,c(X, p ) analogously. The seminorms pK(g) depend only on the class of g: if we put pK(g”)= p K ( g ) ,then we obtzin seminorms defining the topologies of these spaces, which are therefore metrizable and locally convex.
Xlll INTEGRATION
182
(13.13.5) Zfg is locallyp-integrable, then so is 191, and wehave 1g pi
=
-
19) p.
The first assertion follows immediately from (1 3.1 3.1) and (1 3.7.4).To prove the second, note first that i f f 2 0 is a function belonging to X,(X) and if u E X,(X) is such that ( u (SJ then we have
(13.10.3), and therefore (13.3.2.1)1g . pl S 19) . p. To prove the reverse inequality, let L denote the (compact) support 0f.f. Let A be the set of all x E L such that g ( x ) # 0; the set A is integrable ((13.9.9)and (13.9.2))and therefore (1 3.9.1) there exists an increasing sequence of compact subsets K, of A such that A - K, is p-negligible. Hence, by (13.8.4),for any E > 0
u n
there exists an integer n such that /A-Kn f1g1 dp S E . The same reasoning, using the measurability of g and (13.8.4),shows that there exists a compact subset KA of K, such that g I KA is continuous and JA-K,, f l g l d p 5 2 ~Now . consider on KA the continuous function x t t Ig(x)l/g(x);by applying (3.18.2) and the Tietze-Urysohn theorem (4.5.1)to the real and imaginary parts of this function, we see that there exists a function w E X,(X) such that w(x) = ( g ( x ) j / g ( x for ) all x E KA. The function u = w . inf(1, l / J w J )(with the convention 1/0 = + 03) is then continuous on X, hence belongs to X,(X), and is such that v(x) =: Ig(x)l/g(x) in KA and [u(x)l 5 I throughout X. Hence If4 S f a n d
but
and
so that finally
Since E > 0 was arbitrary, this completes the proof.
13
MEASURES WITH BASE p
183
PROBLEMS
1. Show that the locally convex metrizable space L;oc,R(X, p) (resp. Lloc,&X, p)) is complete (in other words, is a Frkhet space). 2.
Let A“ be a vector subspace of .2’:oc,Rcontaining the subspace Jy of pnegligible Jy is endowed with the structure functions. Suppose that the quotient space H = P/ of a real Hilbert space, in which the scalar product is denoted by (318) and the norm 131.Suppose moreover that, for every compact subset K ofX, there exists a constant uK 2 0 such that
for all II E 2 (cf. Section 15.11, Problem 26). (We shall also use the notation (u I u) andlulfor (ci I d) andltilwhen N and u belong to 2.)Let 2; denotethe set of bounded measurable functions on X with compact support. (a) Given any function f~ 9 2 , show that there exists a function U’ E 2 such that
s
(Uf / u) = u f d p for all u E 2 ;and that the class of U’ in H is uniquely determined by the class off. The function Uf is called the potential of f. Show that the set of classes of potentials Uf is dense in the Hilbert space H (use (6.3.2)). If J g are two elements of
s
9 2 ,then (U’ I Us) = guydp =
i
f U g dp.
(b) As f runs through the functions 2 0 belonging to YE, the set of potentials U’ is a convex cone in 2. We denote by B the closure of this cone (with respect to the topology defined by the seminorm 161 on X ) . The elements of 9’ are called pure potentials. Let P denote the image of 9’ in H. For each element ri E H let d be the projection of ti on P (Section 12.15, Problem 3(a)). Show that we have lal’ = (61li), that u(x) 2 u ( x ) almost everywhere, and that d is the only element of P satisfying these conditions. Also we have 161 5 151. Deduce that, for each L? E H , the projection of 0 on the closed convex set of points 4 E H such that u(x) 2 u ( x ) almost everywhere belongs to P. (c) Deduce from (b) that an element u E P belongs to B if and only if ( u l w ) 2 0 for all w E 2 such that w ( x ) 2 0 almost everywhere (consider the difference between d and its projection on 9). Equivalently, Id i-3 I 2 151 for all w E X such that w ( x ) 2 0 almost everywhere. (d) Suppose that for all u E 2 we have IuI E 2 and I(lu1)- I5 Iril. Show that every pure potential u is 2 0 almost everywhere (use (c)). If u, u are two pure potentials, show that inf(u, u ) is a pure potential. (Among the elements of A“ which majorize inf(u, u), consider an element w such that 1 6 1 is a minimum; then w is a pure potential, by (b), and we have ( u w 1 u - w) 5 ( u w 1 Iu - w l ) . By calculating I(inf(u, w))” 12, deduce that I(inf(u, w ) ) - I $ 131; likewise that I(inf(u, w))- 15 161;and hence that w = inf(u, w) = inf(u, w ) almost everywhere.) (e) With the same hypotheses as in (d), show that i f f € 9 2 is 20 almost everywhere, and if u E B is such that Uf(x) 5 u ( x ) almost everywhere in the set of points x E X such rhat f ( x ) > 0 , then Uf(x) 5 u ( x ) almost everywhere in X (“principle of domination”). (Observe that u = inf(Uf, u ) is a pure potential, that (Uf 1 Uf - u ) = 0 and (u I U’ - u) 2 0, and deduce that u = Uf almost everywhere.) (f) Suppose that the hypotheses in (d) are satisfied and also that for all u E 2‘we have inf(u, 1) E 2 and I(inf(u, 1))- 15 I t i l . Show then that if u is a pure potential,
+
+
184
Xlll INTEGRATION
then so is inf ( u , 1) (same method as in (d)). Deduce that, if u and u are pure potentials, then inf(u, ti 1) is a pure potential, by remarking that u inf(u, I ) is a pure potential 2 2 is 20 almost everywhere and if u E B is and using (d). Finally show that, if such that U f ( x )5 u(x) 1 almost everywhere in the set of points x E X such that f ( x ) > 0, then U f ( x )5 u(x) 1 almost everywhere in X ("complete maximum principle": same method as in (e)).
+
+
+
+
14. I N T E G R A T I O N WITH RESPECT TO A POSITIVE MEASURE WITH BASE p
(13.14.1) Let g be a locally p-integrable function which is 2 0 on X, and let v = g p. Then iff 2 0 is any 8-valued function on X, we have (13.14.1 . I )
s'f
dv
= s"fg
4
where, on the right-hand side, the value of f g is by dejinition taken to be 0 at every point x E X at which one of f ( x ) , g ( x ) vanishes (even if the other factor is +a (13.11)).
The proof consists of several steps. (13.14.1.2) Suppose first of all that f E 3. Then (12.7.8) there exists an increasing sequence ( f , ) of functions belonging to X,(X) such that f = sup f , . n
In view of the convention about products, this implies that the sequence (f,g) is increasing and that f g is equivalent to sup(f,g), because g is almost n
everywhere finite (with respect to p ) . Moreover, the functions f . g are p integrable (13.13.1), and 1f.g dp = . j f n dv. Hence it follows from (13.5.7) that
(1 3.1 4.1.3)
Every p-negligible set N is also v-negligible.
Suppose first of all that N is relatively compact. Then ((3.18.2) and (1 3.7.9)) there exists a decreasing sequence of relatively compact open sets U, containing N, such that inf p(U,) = 0. Since g q u , is p-integrable n
by virtue of (13.1 3.1), we have Sgq", dp = v ( ~ , ) by (13.14.1.2)
and
14 INTEGRATION WITH RESPECT TO A POSITIVE MEASURE
185
(13.7.7). But, by (13.8.4), if N ' x N is the intersection of the U,, then inf lg(pun dp = /g(pN.dp = 0; and since v(N) S v(U,) for all n, we have n
v(N) = 0. Now let N be any p-negligible set, and (K,) a denumerahle covering of X by compact sets. Then the sets N n K, are v-negligible, by what has just been proved, and hence so is their union N. (13.14.1.4) Suppose now that K = Supp(f) is compact and that f l K is continuous, with values in R (and therefore bounded (3.17.10)). Then there exists a decreasing sequence (U,) of relatively compact neighborhoods of K such that K = U, (3.18.2); also, by virtue of the Tietze-Urysohn theorem
n n
(4.5.1), there exists for each n a function f, E .X,(X), with support contained in U,, which extendsf and is such that [If,[] = Ilfll. Hence we have If,dv = / f , g dp for all n. Bearing in mind (1 3.13 4 , it follows from (1 3.8.4)
that f is v-integrable and fg is p-integrable, and that Ifdv = /fg dp. (13.14.1.5) The set A of points x E X such that g(x) = 6 is v-negligible.
Since g is p-measurable (13.13.1), A is p-measurable (13.9.9), and hence is the union of a sequence (K,) of compact sets and a p-negligible set N. By virtue of (13.14.1.4) applied t o f = qK,, we have v(K,) = sg(pKn dp = 0, and v(N) = 0 by (1 3.14.1.3) ; hence v(A) = 0. (13.14.1.6) Consider now the case where Supp(f) = K is compact andfl K is lower semicontinuous on K. Then it follows from (12.7.8) that there exists an increasing sequence of finite real-valued functions u, which are continuous and >, 0 on K and such that f l K = sup u, . Let f, be the function which is n
equal to u, on K and zero on X - K, so thatf= supf,. By virtue of (13.5.7) n
and (13.14.1.4), we have
j*
f dv = s u p n
j*
f, dv = sup n
j* *! f,g d p =
fg dp
sincefg is equivalent (with respect to p) to supf,g, by virtue of the convention n
about products and the fact that g is finite almost everywhere with respect to p.
186
Xlll
INTEGRATION
End of the Proof (13.14.1.7)
For every function u E 9 such that f 5 u, we have f g 5 vg, and
J’* v dv = J’* vg dp
J’*f g dp 5 J‘*vg dp = J’* v dv.
by (13.14.1.2), so that
Hence, by definition of the upper integral, we have it remains to establish the opposite inequality
I*
f g dp S
s*
f dv. Hence
(13.14.1.8)
Let h E 9 be such that h 2 f g . Then it is enough to show that
s* s* f dv
(13.14.1.9)
5
h dp.
The set X - A is the union of a denumerable increasing sequence of compact sets H, and a p-negligible set N, such that g I H, is continuous, finite and > O for all n. We define a mapping u of X into R as follows: u = h/g in the union of the sets H,, and u(x) = 00 in N and in A. In each of the sets H, we have ug = h, and by virtue of (13.14.1.6)
+
;:j
dv = 1:;g
dp =
f/I d p .
But v(N) = 0 by virtue of (13.14.1.3), and v(A) hence, as h 2 0 , (13.5.7) j * u dv = sp :
:1;
dv = s:p
/:/I
=0
by virtue of (13.14.1.5),
dp 5 j * h dp.
Since f 5 u, we obtain the required inequaliLy (13.14.1.9).
Q.E.D.
(13.14.2) Let g be a locally p-integrable function which is 2 0 on X, let S be the p-measurable set of points x E X such that g(x) > 0, and let v = g p . Let f be a mapping of X into E.Then the following conditions (with the conventions of (1 3.11) for products) are equivalent : (a) f is v-measurable ; (b) f q s is pi-measurable : (c) f g is p-measurable.
We may suppose g to be finite. With the conventions we have made, we have f g = ( f cps)(gcps),and since the two factors on the right-hand side never
14 INTEGRATION WITH RESPECT TO A POSITIVE MEASURE
187
take the values 0 and kc0 simulta~ieously,it follows from (13.9.8.1) tnat (b) implies (c). Conversely, it is immediately seen that the function g’ which is equal to g-l on S and vanishes on X - S is p-measurable: for there exists a partition of S (resp. X - S) into compact sets L, (resp. M,) and a p-negligible set P (resp. Q) such that the restriction o f g to each L, is continuous, and it follows that the restrictions of g’ t o L, and M, are continuous. Furthermore, we have (fg)g’ =f q s , hence by the same argument it follows that (c) implies (b). Hence it is enough to prove that (a) and (b) are equivalent. Suppose first that f q s is p-measurable. The set GS is v-negligible, by virtue of (13.14.1.5); also the hypothesis implies the existence of a partition of S into a sequence of compact sets L, and a p-negligible set N, such that f l L , is continuous for each n. Also N is v-negligible, by (13.14.1.3); hence f is v-measurable. Conversely, suppose thatfis v-measurable. Then there exists a partition of X consisting of a sequence of compact sets H, and a v-negligible set N, such thatfl H, is continuous for all n. Also there exists a partition of S consisting of a p-negligible set L and a sequence of compact sets K, such that g I K, is continuous (and >O) for all n. For all n, we have inf g(x) = a, > 0. Finally, XEK,
there exists also a partition of X - S into a p-negligible set L’ and a sequence of compact sets KI,. It is clear that the restriction of f i s to each of the sets H, n K, and KL is continuous, and it is therefore enough to prove that N n S is p-negligible. Now if p*(N n K,) > 0, then we should have g dp 2 a,p*(N n K,) > 0, which is absurd because
S”K,
0 = v(N n S)
=lNnSg dp
by virtue of (13.14.1). Hence each set N n K, is p-negligible, therefore so is N n S, and hence finally f qs is p-measurable. (13.14.3) Let g be a locally p-integrable function uhich is 2 0 on X, and let v = g . p. Then a mapping f : X -+ R is v-integrable f a n d only f ( w i t h the concentions of (13.11)) f g is p-integrable; and in that case we hare
J
P
(1 3.14.3.1)
fdv=
J
P
fgdp.
For f to be v-iniegrable it is necessary and sufficient thatf’ and f - should be (1 3.7.4) ; and since we have (fg)’ =f ‘ g , ( f g ) - =f -9, with the conventions of 13.11 about products, it is enough to prove (13.14.3) when f 2 0. The first assertion is now a consequence of (1 3.1 4.1 ), (13.1 4.2), and (1 3.9.13); and the relation (13.14.3.1) is just (13.14.1 .I).
188
Xlll INTEGRATION
(13.14.4) With the hypotheses of (1 3.14.3), the measure v is bounded ifand only i f g i s p-integrable; and v = 0 i f and only i f g is p-negligible. (13.14.5) Let g,, g 2 be two mappings of X into R, such that g1 is 2 0 and locally p-integrable. Then g2 is locally ( g l * p)-integrable Sf and only f ( w i t h the product convention of (13.11)) g 2 g 1 is locally p-integrable, and in that case we have
By considering g: and g;, we reduce immediately to the case where g 2 2 0. To say that g 2 is locally ( g l * p)-integrable signifies (13.13.1) that, for every f E XR(X), the function g 2f is ( g , p)-integrable, or equivalently (13.14.3), that g 2 g l f is p-integrable; which in turn means that g 2 g 1 is locally p-integrable. Also, if we put v = g1 . p and 1 = g 2 - ( g l * p ) , we have f dA = s f g 2 dv f g 2 g 1dp by (13.14.3); hence the relation (13.14.5.1). a
s
=s
PROBLEMS
1. Let X be a locally compact space, p a positive measure on X, and (/") a sequence of
= f. I
functions belonging to U k ( X ,p). Write p n =fn . p and pn(A)
dp for any
p-measurable set A. (a) Show that if X is not compact it can happen that the sequence (A) is unbounded in L', but that the sequence (p,) is vaguely bounded. (b) Suppose that, for every subset A of X consisting of a single point, and for every open subset A of X such that the measure induced by p on the frontier of A has finite support, the sequence &(A)) is bounded. Show that the sequence (A) is bounded in L'. (Show first that every point xo E X has an open neighborhood U such that the sequence of numbers Ip,l(U) is bounded. To do this, argue by contradiction, by showing that otherwise it would be possible to define a strictly increasing sequence of integers (nk), a decreasing sequence (uk) of open neighborhoods of xo , and a sequence (wk) of p-quadrable (Section 13.9, Problem 7) open sets, with the following properties: o k c u k - i , ~cL(ukC{Ixo})~1/k, l p n ~ l ( u k - { X o } ) ~ 1for i < k , \kkcUk--k+,, and finally
Consider the union W of the Wk, and obtain a contradiction. Then show by a similar argument that there exists a compact subset K of X such that the sequence (Ip.l(X - K)) is bounded.) (c) Deduce from (b) that if the sequence (p.(A)) is bounded for every open set A in X, then the sequence (A) is bounded in L'. (d) On the interval [0,1], take p. to be the measure defined by a mass n at the point
189
14 INTEGRATION WITH RESPECT TO A POSITIVE MEASURE
0 and a mass -n at the point I/n. Then the sequence &(A)) is bounded for every open set A which is 1p.I-quadrable for all n , but the sequence of norms Ilp.jl is unbounded. Again, if we take pnto be the measure defined by a mass n at the point l / n and a mass --n at the point l / ( n l), then the sequence (p.(A)) is bounded for every interval A c [0,1] (and therefore also for every finite subset A of [0, l]), but the sequence of norms IIpL.llis not bounded.
+
2.
For each integer n 2 1, let E. be an at most denumerable closed subset of I = 10, 1 [, and let I, be the family of component intervals of I - En. Suppose that the maximum length d. of the intervals J E 9"tends to 0 as! n + m. Let h be Lebesgue measure on I and let A be a A-measurable subset of I. Suppose that there exists a number k E 10, 1[ such that, for all n and all J E I,,we have h(A n J) < kh(J). Show that h ( A ) = 0. (By using (13.7.9), show that h(A) 5 E k ( h ( A ) E ) for all E > 0.)
+
+
+
3. For each integer n > 0, the Farey series of order n is the set F. of all rational numbers which, when expressed in their lowest terms p/q, are such that 0 $ p 5 q 5 n, and arranged in increasing order. The distance between two consecutive terms of F. is therefore 5 l/n. (a) Show that if two rational numbers r = p / q and r'=p'/q' are such that qp' - pq' = & 1, then for every pair of integers (p", q") there exist integers x, y such that p" = px p'y and q" = qx 4'y. The fraction p"/q" belongs to the closed interval with endpoints r, r' if and only if x, y are of the same sign. (b) Deduce from (a) that if r = p/q and r' = p'/q' are two rational numbers belonging to the interval [0, 11, such that q > 0, q' > 0 and qp' - pq' = f1, then r and r' are consecutive elements of the Farey series FsUpc,, ,,). Moreover the smallest of theintegers m such that the open interval with endpoints r, r' contains a point of F, is the integer q q', and this open interval contains only one point of F,,,., namely(p +p')/(q 4'). (c) Conversely, if r and r' are consecutive terms of F., show that qp' - p4' = f1 (induction on n).
+
+
4.
+
+
For each x E I = 10, I ] , put p(x) = (I/x) - [I/x], where [t] denotes the integral part of the real number t. Ifp"(x) = p(p"-'(x)) is defined and nonzero, putqn+I(x)= [l/p.(x)] (with 41(x) = [l/xl). (a) For every n such that p"(x) is defined, show that
where A.(x) and B.(x) are integers k n - 1. The fractions An-l(x)/Bn-l(x) and A,(x)/B.(x) are two consecutive terms of a Farey series (Problem 3) and x belongs to the closed interval with these as endpoints. Deduce that p"(x) is defined for all n 2 1 if and only if x is irrational. The (finite or infinite) sequence 01 numbers q.(x) is called the continued fraction expansion of x, and the fractions A.(x)/B.(x) are the convergents to x . The A.(x) and B.(x) are constant on the complement of the denumerable closed set En of points x such that P.+~(X) is not defined, and on each of the component intervals of I - E, the function p. is monotone and varies from 0 to 1 . (b) Let h be Lebesgue measure on I and let A be a h-measurable subset of I consisting entirely of irrational numbers. Suppose that is h-invariant with respect to p (Section
190
Xlll INTEGRATION 13.9, Problems 13 and 24). Show that &A) is either 0 or 1 . (Suppose that d = &A) t 10, 1 [. Show that, for each component interval J of I - En,we have &A n
J) 5 (2d/(l + d))h(J).
For this purpose use (a) above and Problem l(c) of Section 13.21 to show that
+
for suitably chosen integers p , q, r , s with p s - qr = 1. Use Problem 2 to complete the proof.) x), is invariant with respecf (c) Show that the measure p = g A, where g(x) = l/(l fo p. Deduce from (b) and the ergodic theorem (Section 13.9, Problems 13 and 24) that, for every &integrable function f on I and almost all irrational x E I, we have
+
(Gauss-Kuzmin formula). (d) Deduce from (c) that, for each integer p k n such that qx(x)= p (x irrational), then
2 1,
if v,(x, p ) is the number cf indices
for almost all irrational x E I. (e) Deduce from ( c ) that
for almost all irrational x .
15. T H E L E B E S G U E - N I K O D Y M T H E O R E M A N D T H E ORDER R E L A T I O N O N MR(X)
(13.15.1) Let p and v he two positire measures on a focally compact space X, such that v 5 p. Then there exists a focally pintegrable function g such tl~at v=g-/&.
We distinguish two cases. (1) Suppose first that v is bounded. Since the function 1 is then v-integrable, it follows from (13.11.2.2) that for everyfE X,(X)
(13.15.1.1)
Iv(.f)12
5 V(l)V(f2)
s V(l)Pc(f*).
191
15 THE LEBESGUE-NIKODYM THEOREM
This shows first of all that iff is p-negligible then v ( f ) = 0. Passing to the quotient by the subspace Jlr of p-negligible functions, the linear form v on X,(X) therefore defines a linear form ?++v(?) on the subspace g R ( X ) of Li(X, p ) which is the canonical image of X,(X) in Li(X, p). The inequality (13.5.1.1) shows that this linear form is conrinuous (5.5.1) on the subspace g R ( X ) ;since the latter is dense in Li(X, p) (13.11.6), the linear f o r m f w v ( f ) extends by continuity to a linear form on the Hilbert space L:(X, p ) (5.5.4). Hence there exists a function g E Yi(X, p) such that v ( f ) = p(gf) for all f E X,(X) (6.3.2). Sincegislocallyp-integrable (13.13),it follows that v = g . p . (11) General case. There exists a partition of X into a sequence of compact sets K, and a p-negligible set N (13.9.2). If we put M = X - N = K,,
u n
then q M is locally p-integrable and 1 - qM is p-negligible, hence (13.14.4) q M . p = p . Put p, = qK, p and v, = qK,. v. Since qKnis the lower envelope of a decreasing sequence of functions 2 0 belonging to X,(X), the relation v 5 p implies v, p, for all n ; furthermore, v, is bounded (13.14.4). Hence, by (I) above, there exists a locally p,-integrable function g, such that v,, =g, - p , = (g,qK,) . p = )gnqK,I p ((13.13.5) and (13.14.5)), and thefunction g,qK, is locally p-integrable. Let g denote the function which is equal to Jg,qK,I on each Kn and is zero on N. Then g is the sum of the series
-
m
C
lg,(PK,(.I f f is any function 2 0 in X,(X), and m is any integer, then
and therefore ((13.8.4) and (13.13.1)) the function g is locally p-integrable.
__
m
Also, since f = zfqKn ilmost everywhere (with respect to
sfs
,= 1
/I),
we have
(13.8.4) d p = j f q n dv. To show that v = g * p , it remains to be proved that N is also v-negligible. But by definition (13.5.5), for each E > 0 there exists a function h E 9 such that q N 5 h and p(h) 5 E . Since h is the upper envelope of an increasing sequence of functions 2 0 belonging to X,(X), the inequality v 5 p implies that v*(h) S p(h) 5 E , and the proof is complete.
The following lemma will be generalized later (1 3.1 5.8) : (13.15.2) r f ( p j ) ,j j j r is any$nite sequence of complex measures on X , there exists a positiile meamre A such that each p j is a measure with base 2.
192
Xlll INTEGRATION
By writing each p j as a linear combination of four positive measures (13.3.6), we may assume that the measures p j are all positive. Then we take r
1 = 1p j , and apply the result of (13.15.1) to each p j
A.
j= 1
(13.15.3) (i) With respect to the order relation on MR(X), m y two real measures p, v have a least upper bound sup(p, v) and a greatest lower bound inf(p, v). For each real measure p put p' = sup@, 0) and p- = sup( - p , 0); then we have (13.15.3.1)
inf(p+,p - ) = 0,
lpl = p + + p - = sup(p,-p)
p = p+-p-,
and, for any two real m e a w e s p, v,
(13.15.3.2)
(ii) Let 1 be a positive measure and let g l , g2 be real-valued locally I-integrable functions on X.r f p , = g1 1 and p2 = g2 * A, then (1 3.15.3.3)
and in particular, for any real-valued locally A-integrable function g , (1 3.1 5.3.4)
W e have g1 * 1 respect to 1.
( g . A ) += g +
*A,
g 2 1 if and only
( g ' A ) - = g - -1.
if gl(x) 5 g2(x) almost everywhere with
(iii) Let (gn) be an increasing sequence of locally A-integrable real-valued functions. Then the increasing sequence of measures gn ' A is bounded above in MR(X)$and only if the function sup gn is locally A-integrable, and in that case n we have (13.15.3.5)
SUP n
( g n * 1)=
(SUP n
*
A.
To prove (i), we remark that the measures p, v can be written in the form p = p1 - 1 2 , v = v1 - v 2 , where pl, p 2 , v1 and v 2 are positive (13.3.6). Applying (13.15.2) to the four measures p l , p 2 , vl, v 2 we see (by using (13.13.2)) that p =: u , Iand v = u . A, where A is a positive measure and u, u 1
15 THE LEBESGUE-NIKODYM THEOREM
193
are locally A-integrable real-valued functions. Hence the assertions of (i) are consequences of those of (ii). To prove (13.15.3.3), we reduce to the case where pz = 0; for if sup(pl - p 2 ,0) exists and is equal to (gl - gz)+ 1, it follows immediately (13.3) that we shall have
This reduces us to proving (13.15.3.4). For this, we shall begin by proving the last assertion of (ii), or equivalently that the relation g A 2 0 implies g(x) 2 0 almost everywhere with respect to A. Let N be the set of points x E X such that g(x) < 0. If we put v = 9-1,it follows from (1 3.14.1.5) that v(X - N) = 0; so if we can show that v(N) = 0, it will follow that v = 0, and this will establish our assertion (13.14.4). Clearly it is enough to prove that v(N n K) = 0 for each compact subset K of X. If U is any relatively compact open set g - dA g + dA. For by hypothesis containing N n K, then we have /(g' - g - ) f dA 2 0 for every function f 2 0 belonging to X,(X), and it is therefore sufficient to remark that g - dA = sup g - f dA, g f dA =
1"
ju
i
ju
s sf5
lu
sup g'lf dA, the supremum being taken over all functions f E X,(X) such that 0 qrl(13.5.1). Since g'(x) = 0 for x E N n K, we have g + dA = inf U
consequently, J N (13.14.3).
g - dA = inf U
I
ju
g f dA = 0;
g - dA = 0,which shows that v(N n K) = 0
+
Now let p be a measure such that p 2 0 and p 2 g A. Putting A p = 0 , we have (13.15.1) p = u * a and A = u 8 , where u and u are locally a-integrable and u 2 0 and u 2 0 almost everywhere with respect to 8. I t follows that u 2 gu almost everywhere with respect to a, hence that u 2 (gv)' = g'v almost everywhere with respect to a ; but this implies that p =u .a
>= (g+v) - a = g + - A
by virtue of (13.14.5). Finally, we have to prove (iii). If the sequence (9,. A) is bounded above in MR(X), then for each function f 2 0 belonging to .X,(X) we have
.s
sup fgn dA <
+
00
;
194
Xlll INTEGRATION
consequently (1 3.8.1) the functionfg
= sup,fg,
is A-integrable, and
n
J
.J
f g dA = SUP fg, dA.
Hence g is locally /?-integrable (13.13.1) and g . A
= sup&
. A) (13.4.4).
n
Scholium (13.15.3.6) We may therefore say that, for a positive measure p , the mapping g”Hg p is a linear bijection of the vector space L:oc, R(X, p ) of equivalence classes (relative to p) of locally p-integrable real-valued functions onto the vector space of real measures with base p , and moreover that this bijection is order-preserving. This is the fundamental fact that we shall use repeatedly from now on until the end of Section 13.19.
We remark also that the mapping g” t+g * p , considered as a mapping into M(X), is continuous when L,tc,R(X,p ) is endowed with the topology defined in (13.13.4) and M(X) is endowed with the vague topology. (13.15.4) In the space MR(X), every subset H which is bounded above has a least upper bound v , and there exists an increasing sequence (p,) of elemenis of H such that v = sup (pn). n
l f , f z 0 belongs to X,(X), then the set of numbers ,u(f),where p E H, has a finite least upper bound by hypothesis, and we shall show that sup p ( f ) is llEH
equal to v ( f ) . For this purpose consider an increasing sequence (K,) of compact subsets of X which cover X and are such that X,(X) is the union of the X R ( X ;K,) (3.18.3), and let (gmn)mtl be a dense sequence in the Banach space X,(X; K,) ((7.4.4) and (3.10.9)). For each pair ( m , n), there exists a of elements of H such that sup(p,,,,&;,,)) = sup p(g;,,). sequence (,D,,,,,~)~~, Now let
P
A, denote
N E H
SUP (Pmnp) mSr,nSr, p s r
(which exists by (13.15.3)). The sequence (Ar) is increasing and bounded above in MR(X), hence has a least upper bound vo which is also its limit in the vague topology (13.4.4). If p E H, we have p(g;,) 5 v,,(g;,,) for each pair ( m , n ) ; hence, by continuity and because If’ - g;,I =< 1f- gmnl,it follows that p(f) 5 vo(f) for a l l f z 0 belonging to X R ( X ; K,) and for all n ; hence p 5 v o .
15 THE LEBESGUE-NIKODYM THEOREM
195
On the other hand, if p 2 p for all p E H, then in particular p 2 v,, by the definition of v,; hence v, is the least upper bound v, and we have v(f 1 = SUP P ( f ) PEH
for all f 2 0 belonging to X,(X).
(13.15.5) (Lebesgue-Nikodym Theorem) Let p , v be two positive measures on X. Then the following conditions are equivalent: (a) Y is a measure with base p. (b) Every p-negligible set is v-negligible. (b’) Every compact p-negligible set is v-negligible. (c) For every function f 2 0 which is both p-integrable and v-integrable, and for every real number E > 0, there exists 6 > 0 such that the relations 0 2 h 5 f and l * h dp 5 6 imply / * h dv 5 E . (c’) For every compact subset K of X and every real number E > 0, there exists 6 > 0 such that the relations A c K and p*(A) 5 6 imply v*(A) 5 E (“absolute continuity” of v with respect to p ) . (d) v = sup (inf(v, np)). n
The fact that (a) implies (b) follows immediately from (13.14.1) and
(13.6.3). Clearly (b) implies (b’). Conversely, suppose that (b’) is satisfied, and let N be a p-negligible set. Since X is a denumerable union of compact sets K,, it is enough to show that each of the sets N n K, is v-negligible, and we may therefore assume that N is relatioely conzpact. Since N then has a compact neighborhood (3.18.2),it follows from (13.7.9)and (13.8.7,(i)) that we may restrict ourselves to the case where N is a denumerable intersection of relatively compact open sets; but in this case N is v-integrable ((13.7.7)and (13.8.7,(i)), hence is the union of a sequence (H,) of compact sets and a v-negligible set P. Since by hypothesis v(H,) = 0 for all n, it follows that N is v-negligi ble. To prove that (b) implies (d) and that (d) implies (a), we remark that we may express p and v in the form p = u * A and v = v 1, where 1 is a positive measure and u, v are finite, 2 0 and locally A-integrable ((13.15.2) and (13.15.3)).If we put v’ = sup(inf(v, nu)) and o” = u - ZI’, then we have n
21’
2 0, v“ 2 0 and sup(inf(v, np)) = u‘ . A (13.15.3).Hence to show that (b) n
implies (d) it is enough to show that (b) implies that v” . A = 0. Now the set A of points x E X at which v”(x) > 0 is contained in the set of points x at which
196
XI11 INTEGRATION
u(x) = 0,and therefore is p-negligible (13.14.1), hence v-negligible by hypothesis. On the other hand, U” = u q , , hence ((13.14.1) and (13.6.3)) the relation v(A) = 0 is equivalent to u“ being hegligible, and therefore implies that u” A = 0 (13.14.4). To show that (d) implies (a), it is enough to remark that the condition (d) signifies that u” * 1 = 0, and hence (13.14.4) the set A is &negligible. Hence if we put g(x) = u(x)/u(x) at points where u(x) > 0, and g(x) = 0 elsewhere, we shall have u(x) = g(x)u(x) at all x 4 A, hence almost everywhere with respect to 1.Consequently (1 3.14.5), g is locally p-integrable, and we have v = g * p. It remains to establish the equivalence of (b), (c), and (c’). Clearly (c’) is a consequence of (c), applied to f = q K .Also (c‘) implies that v*(A) = 0 for every relatively compact p-negligible set A; since every p-negligible set is the union of relatively compact p-negligible sets, this proves that (c’) implies (b). To prove that (b) implies (c) we shall argue by contradiction. Suppose therefore that there exists a function fo 2 0 which is p-integrable and v-integrable, and a real number a > 0 such that, for each integer n > 0, there exists a function 9, for which 0 5 g, S fo, j * g , dp S 2-” and / * g n dv > a . By virtue of (13.5.5), we may replace g , by inf(fo, 9:) for a suitably chosen function g: E 9,without disturbing the above properties, hence (13.9.13) we may assume that 9, is p-integrable and v-integrable. Now let
-
h = lim sup g, = inf h , , n-tm
n
where m
Since g, sfofor all n, it follows that h, is p-integrable and v-integrable for all n (13.8.2), apd we have
(13.5.8). Hence J h d p
=0
(13.8.1), and the hypothesis (b) therefore implies
that h is v-negligible (13.6.3). But we have
s
h, dv
>= a
(13.8.1),
which gives the required contradiction. Hence (b) implies (c), and the proof is complete. (13.15.6) Let p and v be two positive measures on X. Then the,followii?g conditions are equivalent: (a) The negligible sets are the same f o r p and f o r v .
15 THE LEBESGUE-NIKODYM THEOREM
197
(b) v = g . p7 where g is locally p-integrable and g(x) > 0 almost everywhere with respect to p. If (a) is satisfied, it follows from (13.15.5) that v = g * p and p = h * v, where g (resp. h) is positive and locally integrable with respect to p (resp v), Hence (13.4.5) the function hg is locally p-integrable, and we have p = (hg) * p, which implies (13.15.3) that hg is equivalent (relative to p) to the function 1, so that g(x) > 0 and h(x) = l/g(x) almost everywhere with respect to p. Conversely, suppose that v = g . p, with g(x) 0 almost everywhere with respect to p. Since (l/g(x))g(x)is equal to 1 almost everywhere with respect to p7 the function I/g(x) is locally v-integrable, and we have p = ( l / g ) v (13.14.5), so that the condition (a) is satisfied. If p and v satisfy the equivalent conditions of (13.15.6) they are said to be equivalent positive measures on X. Clearly we have here an equivalence relation on the set of positive measures on X. The notion of a measurable function is the same for two equivalent measures (1 3.9.4). (1 3.15.7) If p is any positive measure on X , there exists a continuousfunction h such that h(x) > 0 for all x E X and such that the measure v = h * p (which is equivalent to p by virtue of (13.15.6)) is bounded.
Let (U,,) be an increasing sequence of relatively compact open sets in X with the properties of (3.18.3), and for each n let f,, be a continuous function on X with values in [0, 11, such that f,,(x) = 1 for all x E U,, andf,(x) = 0 for all x E X - Un+l(4.5.2). Let (a,,) be a sequence of real numbers > O such that m
1a,, < +
03.
Then the series h =
n= 1
m
1a,f,
is normally convergent in X (7.1),
n= 1
hence h is continuous on X (7.2.1), and h(x) > 0 for all x E X . If v = h * p, then v*(l) = l * h dp 5 Ca,,J'/;. dp ((13.14.1) and (13.5.8)). If for example we take n
a,, =
2-" a,, <
then we have
+ 03
otherwise,
and v*(l) <
+ 00.
This completes the proof.
n
(13.15.8) Let (p,,)be any sequence of positive measures on X . Then there existf a bounded positive measure v on X such that the relation v(N) = 0 is equivalent to p,,(N) = 0 for all n (which implies (13.15.5) that each p,, is a measure with base v). Furthermore, if v' is another positive measure on X having this property, then v and v' are equivalent.
Xlll INTEGRATION
198
The last assertion follows from the definition of equivalent measures. To prove the first assertion, we may, by virtue of (13.15.7),assume that the measures pn are bounded. By multiplying each p,, by a suitable positive real number, we may also assume that pJ1) 5 2-". If v, = sup(pI, p 2 , . .., p,), then by virtue of (13.15.3.2) we have v,(f) 5
pk(f) k= 1
5 1 for every f
E
X,(X) such that 0 5 f 5 1, and every n.
Hence (1 3.4.4)the increasing sequence (v,) converges vaguely to its least upper bound v in MR(X), and we have v(f) 5 1 for every f~ .X,(X) such that 0 S f S 1. Hence v*(l) 5 1 and so v is bounded. We may therefore write p,, = g, v, where g. is locally v-integrable and 2 0 ; hence v, = sup gk * v (I
(13.15.3.3) and consequently v =
)
v (13.15.3.5). It is now clear
(1 3.15.5)that the relation v(N) = 0 implies that p,(N) = 0 for all n ; conversely, if p,,(N) = 0 for all n, then each of the functions g, q N is v-negligible (13.14.1), hence so is sup g q N by (13.6.2),and so N is v-negligible. ( n
n)
(13.15.9) Let (p,) be an increasing sequence of positive measures having a least upper bound v in MR(X).For a function f to be v-integrable it is necessary and Sufficient that f should be p,-integrable for all n, and that
In that case we have P
J f d v = ,l\;
-
J
P
f dp,,.
We may write p,, = g, v, where g, is 2 0 and locally v-integrable, and the sequence (9,) is increasing. Moreover, we have v = sup g v by (1 3.1 5.3), hence sup g,
(
=
n
1 almost everywhere with respect to v. Iffis v-integrable, then
n
so isfg, for all n, by virtue of (13.9.6),the inequality Ifg,l 1f I (which is true almost everywhere with respect to v), and (13.9.13).Hence by (13.14.3)f is p,-integrable for all n. Conversely, if,fis p,-integrable for all n, then the functions f g , are v-integrable (13.14.3)and we have f = limfg, almost everya
,-+
where with respect to v, so that f is v-measurable (13.9.11). Also we have If1 = sup Ifg,l almost everywhere with respect to v. Hence the result follows n
from (13.9.13)and (13.8.1),and the last assertion of the proposition follows from the dominated convergence theorem (13.8.4).
16 APPLICATIONS: I. INTEGRATION
199
16. APPLICATIONS: 1. I N T E G R A T I O N WITH RESPECT TO A C O M P L E X MEASURE
(13.16.1) Let p, v be two positive measures on X. (i) We have ( p v)* = p* + v*. (ii) For afunctionfto be ( p \*)-integrable(resp. ( p v)-measurable) it is necessary and suficient that f should be p-integrable and v-integrable (resp. p-measurable and v-measurable), and in that case we have
+
s
(13.16.1 .I)
+
+
fd(p
+ v) =
s s fdp
+
fdv.
+
We may write p = g ( p v) and v = h ( p + v), where g and h are 2 0 and locally ( p v)-integrable ((13.15.1) and (13.15.3)). Since p + v = ( g h) ( p + v), it follows that g ( x ) + h(x) = 1 almost everywhere with respect to p v. Put l = p v. To prove (i), we have to show that
+ -
+
+
+
S* J' s fdl=
fgdl+
s'
fhdl
for all :unctionsf2 0. Clearly j*fd,l 5 / * f g d l
+ / * f h dA. Also there is no
loss of generality in assuming that *f d l < + co, in which case there exists a decreasing sequence (u,) of A-integrable functions belonging to 9,such that f 5 u, for all n and I * f dA = inf J^u, dA. Since u,, d l = ung dA u,h dA,
+s 1 . r we obtain the desired inequality by passing to the limit. Assertion (ii) then n
follows from (13.14.2) and (13.14.3). Now let 1be a complex measure on X . A complex-valued functionfon X is said to be A-integrable if it is Ill-integrable. If we put l1 = &?A and l z= 91, it follows from (13.3.7) and (13.16.1) that f is kintegrable if and only iff is &-integrable and &-integrable. Since by (13.15.3.1) we have lA1l = AT + A; and = A; + A;, it follows thatfis A-integrable if and only iffis integrable with respect to each of the four positive measures A:, A;, A:, A;. The integral off with respect to l is then defined to be the complex number (13.16.2)
Sf
d l =I f l dl;
-j
f dl;
+i s f dli -is
f d&.
200
Xlll INTEGRATION
The mapping f w J f dA so defined is clearly a C-linear form on the complex vector space 9’i(X, In() which extends the given C-linear form R on X,(X).
-
(13.16.3) IfA is any complex measure on X, we have I = h 111,where h is a locally IA(-integrable .function such that Ih(x)l = 1 almost everywhere with respect to (II.
Let A1, I , denote the real measures 921,$1, respectively. Then [A1[5 and 1A21 IlIl (13.3.7), so that I , and A, are measures with base 121, and therefore the same is true of I . If A = h * 111, it follows that IAI = lh[ IAl (13.13.5), which implies that Ih(x)I = 1 almost everywhere with respect to IAl (13.15.3).
-
It follows now from the definition (13.16.2) and from (13.14.3) that, for any A-integrable function f, we have (1 3.1 6.4)
and hence, by virtue of (1 3.1 6.3) and (1 3.10.3), (1 3.16.5)
A function is said to be A-negligible (resp. A-measurable) if it is 121-negligible (resp. 121-measurable). Likewise for sets. If A and p are two complex measures and iff is both I-integrable and p-integrable, then f is (A + p)-integrable, by virtue of (13.16.1) and the inequality II + p ) 5 121 + Ip()(13.3.8). If A is a complex measure, a function g is said to be locally I-integrable if it is locally IAl-integrable. In that case, for every function f E .X,(X), the function gf is A-integrable, and as in (1 3.13) we see that f - 1 g f dd is a meas-
s
s
ure, denoted by y * A. If A = h . 11)(13.16.3), we have fg dA = fgh dlAl, or equivalently g A = (gh) * 111,so that the study of measures of the form g A is immediately reduced to the case where I. is a positive measure. In particular, it follows from (13.13.4) that
-
(1 3.1 6.6)
19.4 = 191 . 1 1 1 .
17 APPLICATIONS: II DUAL OF
L’
201
17. APPLICATIONS: II. D U A L OF L’
(13.17.1) Let p be a positive measure on X. For each ,function g E 2’ipRm(X, p) (resp. g E Y F ( X , p)), the mapping$, :f - J f g dji is a continuous linear form on the space 2’:(X, p) (resp. Y;(X, p)) with respect to the topology dejned by the norm N,. The corresponding continuous linear form gg:f~ p(&) on the Banach space L:(X, p) (resp. Li(X, p)) has norm (5.7.1) equa/ to N,(g). Conversely, every continuous linear form on 2’;(X, p) (resp. 2’;(X, p)) is of the form f fg dp, where g is a function belonging to 2’g(X, p) (resp. Y F ( X , p)), and the equioalence class of g is uniquely determined.
WS
We shall give the proof for 2’;.The fact that fIg is a continuous linear form on Y;, and the inequality l l ~ g l l N,(g), are consequences of (13.12.5). To prove that llggll = N,(g), we may assume that g is not p-negligible (in other words, that N,(g) > 0), since the assertion is trivial otherwise. Let a be any real number such that 0 < a < N,(g). Then there exists a compact subset K of X, with measure p(K) > 0, such that g1 K is continuous and Ig(x)l > a for all x E K ((13.9.9) and (13.9.4)). For each E > 0 there exists a finite covering (Ui) of K by open sets in K, such that the oscillation o f g in each Ui is S &(3.16.5). Hence there exists a partition of K into a finite number of integrable sets A, such that the oscillation of g in each A, is S E(13.9.12.1). At least one of these sets, which we shall denote by A, has measure p ( A ) > 0. Let b be one of the values taken by g in A. We have 161 > a and J g ( x )- b( 5 E for all x E A. Now put
f clearlyfE 9;and N,(f)
1s
=
= (b/(lblp(A)))YA;
1. Also we have
L (lbl - & M A )2 ( a - E)P(A),
fgdpl 2 a - c. This proves our assertion, because E > 0 and a < N,(g) were arbitrary. Conversely, let u be a continuous linear form on 9;. Then there exists a real number c > 0 such that lu(f)I c * N , ( f ) for all f E 2’;(12.14.1). If K is any compact subset of X, it is known (13.11.6) that the topology induced on X c ( X ;K) by that of 2’;(X, p) is coarser than the topology defined by the norm Ilfll. Hence the linear form u is continuous on each of the Banach so that
202
Xlll
INTEGRATION
spaces X c ( X ;K) (with respect to the norm lifli) ; in other words, the restriction of p to .X,.(X) is a (complex) nieasiire v. Furthermore, it follows from the inequality lu(,f)l 5 c . ?4,(./), where f~ . X c ( X ) ,and from (13.3.2.1) that ~ v ~ ( ~5 ~c f. N,(f) ~ ) = c . p(If1). Hence we deduce from (13.15.1) and (13.15.3) that there exists a locally p-integrable function go such that lgo(x)l 5 c almost everywhere with respect to p, and such that 1v1 = g o . p. If v = h * I v ( (13.16.3) we have therefore v = g . p, where g = g o h (13.14.5), and it is clear that g E 9; ( p ) . This being so, the linear forms u and 0, agree on the subspace X,-(X), which is dense in 2’; (13.11.6); since they are both continuous on Uh, it follows that they are equal (3.15.2). Finally, the fact that O,, = O,, implies dl = g2 follows from (1 3.15.3). Q.E.D.
Lg
H0, is a linear isometry of the Banach space onto the Lfuaf of the Banach space LA (12.15).
I t follows that the mapping
We remark also that it follows from (13.12.5) that, for each function f~ .YC(X,p), the linear form gt+ fg dp on 2’pc“(X, p) is continuous with respect to the topology defined by the seminorm N,. But in general there exist linear forms on 2’:(X, p) which are continuous with respect to this topology but are not of the above type.
s
PROBLEMS
1. (a) Let X be a locally compact space, p a positive measure on X. Letf’be a p-measurable mapping of X into R and p a real number such that 1 s p 5 -t00. Show that N,(f)
= sup
1’
lfyl dp, where g runs through the set of functions belonging to XB(X)
+
such that N,(y) :1, where y = p / ( p - 1) (and y = Q if p = I). State and prove an analogous result for a p-measurable mapping of X into C. (b) Suppose that I < p < Q. For each function g E Y&(X,p) (resp. g E YpE(X, p)), let 03 denote the linear form f ~ p ( & ) on LgfX, p) (resp. L&(X, p)). Show that g H 06 is an isometry of L&(X,p) (resp. LE(X, p)) onto the Banach space (5.7.3) dual to the Banach space Lp(X, p ) (resp. LE(X, p)). (Imitate the proof of (13.17.1), using (a).)
+
2. Let X be a c o r w ~ space, r p a positive measure on X, and (f’“)an oi-thoiiornial sequence in -Y’&(X, p). Write
(the “nth Lebesgue function” of the system (JJ,cf. Section 11.6, Problem 2). For a n y g E Yy%X,p), let s,(y) denote the function
17 APPLICATIONS: II DUAL OF L’
203
(a) Let x, E X. Show that, for every complex-valued continuous function g on X the partial sums s,(y) are bounded (by a number depending on g and on x o ) if and only if the set of numbers H.(xo) is bounded (use Problem l(a) and the Banach-Steinhaus theorem). (This result generalizes Problem 2(a) of Section 11.6.) (b) For every complex-valued continuous function g on X the partial sums s.(g) converge uniformly to g if and only if the following two conditions are satisfied: (I)every complex-valued continuous function on X can be approximated uniformly on X by linear combinations of thef,; (2) there exists a constant a such that IH.(x)l 5 a for all x E X and all n. (To prove that (2) is necessary, observe that if s.(g) converges uniformly to g, then for any increasing sequence of integers (nk) and any sequence ( x k ) of points of X, the sequence of numbers
1
K n k ( x ky)g(y) , dp(y) is bounded (by a number depend-
ing on y); now use the Banach-Steinhaus theorem.) In particular, for the Haar orthonormal system (Section 8.7, Problem 7), the Lebesgue functions are uniformly bounded.
3. Let X be a locally compact space, p a positive measure on X, and p a real number satisfying 1 s p < 4-co; let q = p / ( p - I). Let g be a complex-valued measurable function such that fg is integrable for all f ’ U~ E ( X ,p). Show that g E 2’L(X, p). (Show that the rnappingf~+fg of Lp into L1 is continuous, by using the closed graph theorem (12.16.11).) (Cf. Section 12.16, Problem 248.) 4.
Let U be a continuous endomorphism of Li(X, p) which satisfies the conditions of Section 13.11, Problem 16. Its transpose ‘U is therefore a continuous endomorphism of the Banach L,“(X, p) with norm i 1 (Section 12.15, Problem 4) and such that the relation & 0 implies ‘ U .& 0. For any f t UF(X, p), we denote by ‘ U .f any function in the class ‘ U . J (a) Let (fn) be a sequence of functions in 2’; which converges almost everywhere tofand is such that the sequence of norms N,(f,) is bounded. Show that the sequence (‘U.J,) converges almost everywhere to ‘U .f. (Consider the sequence of functions gn= suplf,,,
-fnl,
and use the relation J;’U. g.)h dp = Jy.(U. h ) dp, which is
P
valid for any function h E 9; .) (b) Let Y 2 0 be a function in 9;. With the notation of Section 13.11, Problem 16, show that if ‘ U .Y 5 Y almost everywhere, then for each functionft PA, we have
lE,,lfYdp 2 0. (Consider the measure Y . p and apply Section 13.11, Problem 16(d).) (c) With the notation of Section 13.11, Problem 18, show that ‘U.px, spx, almost everywhere. Deduce that, for each function f t 9: which vanishes almost everwhere in X , , the function U ‘fvanishes almost everywhere in X , . 5. With the notation of Section 13.11, Problem 18, suppose that the set X, is negligible. (This will always be the case if p is bounded and U . 1 1 .) (a) Show that i f f . 9;is such that ‘ U .f‘f almost everywhere, then ‘ U .f:f almost everywhere. (Majorize the integral of the function 2
(f-‘U.f)(@ 1 U.cD-t...-+U - ”.@).) (b) Let 9 be the set of all functions h E 2’; such that ‘ U .h = h almost everywhere (i.e., the set of functions whose classes h are fixed by ‘ U ) .Show that the constant functions belong to f and that if (h,) is any sequence in f such that the sequence (NK(h,J)is bounded, then sup h, t 8.(Use (a) above, and Problem 4(a).) Deduce n
204 Xlll INTEGRATION
that for h to belong to f , it is necessary and sufficient that for each a E R the characteristic function of the set h - ' ( ] a , a,[) should belong to f . (c) Show that if h E f and f s U:, then U . ( h f ) = h(U .f)almost everywhere. (Reduce to the case where h = rpA, and show that the integral of (1 - V A ) ( U(.r p A f ) ) is 0.) (d) Show that the set Y of functions of the form h@ g - U . g, where h E 9 and g E 2';,is dense in 2:. (Use Section 12.1 5, Problem 4(f); show that if u E -Y;pR"
+
is such that
1
+
u(g - U . g) d p = 0
and deduce that
s
for all g
E
-YA, then
u necessarily belongs to f ,
uz@dp = 0.)
(e) I f f = h@ t g - U . g E V , then the sequence (R,(f, @)) converges to h almost everywhere, and we have Nl(h@) 5 N,(f). (For the latter assertion, consider the uf dp, bearing in mind that 3.)Deduce that j there exists a continuous endomorphism Rs of LA, of norm 5 1 , whose image is the
function u = sgn h and evaluate
u
E
closure in LA of the vector subspace formed by the classes hG where h E f , and such that Rs .fis equal to h 6 iff= h@ g - U g E Y . (f) For each function f e -YA, we denote by Ro .f any function in the class Rs .f: Deduce from (e) that the sequence (Rn(fr a)) converges to @-'(Re .f)almost everywhere. Furthermore, for each ~ E Rtheset , of points X E Xsuch that (Ra . f ) ( x ) l a@(x)is such that its characteristic function belongs to 3,and for each function h E f
+
s
we have h ( R , . f ) dp = [ h f d p . (Iffl
E
V is such that Nl(f-fi)
E,
show that the
set of x E X such that R*(f-fl, @)(x) 2 or Rm(f-fi)(x) 2 E ' / ~ @ ( X ) , has / ~ to @ . p, by using Section 13.11, Problem 18(c).) measure 5 2 ~with~ respect (g) Deduce that for any two functions f, g E 9 : such that g 2 0, the sequence (Rn(frg)) converges almost everywhere to a finite limit in the set B of points x E X such that (U" . g)(x) > 0 for a t least one value of the integer n 2 0 (Chacbn-Ornstein theorem). 6. (a) Let a1< oz be two real numbers, let B be the vertical strip u1 5 W s 5 uz in C, and let f be a function holomorphic in b and continuous in B. Suppose also that (i) If(s) I ;; M for s = a, it and s = o2 it, where t E R is arbitrary; (ii) there exist two constants a > 0, A > 0 such that if(u i t ) ] 5 A . e'lrl for all
+
+
utifEB.
+
Show that under these assumptions we have If(.s)l 5 M throughout B. (Use the PhragmCn-Lindelof principle as in Section 9.5, Problem 17, by taking g(s) = e".) (b) Iffis continu