am
m
mmm
m l
O
3 I
19L
m m
ml UI
aJ
INL ml
NnLo
9
~mLo
O
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
D e v e l...
114 downloads
2366 Views
23MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
am
m
mmm
m l
O
3 I
19L
m m
ml UI
aJ
INL ml
NnLo
9
~mLo
O
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
D e v e l o p m e n t s in P e t r o l e u m Science, 43
tracers in the oil field
BERNARD ZEMEL
The University of Texas at Austin, Center for Petroleum and Geosystems Engineering, Austin, TX 78712, USA
ELSEVIER
SCIENCE
Amsterdam - Lausanne - New York-
Oxford - Shannon - Tokyo
1995
ELSEVIER SCIENCE B.V. Sara B urgerhartstraat 25 P.O. Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands
ISBN: 0-444-88968-X
9 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher, Elsevier Science B.V., Copyright & Permissions Department, P.O. Box 521, 1000 AM Amsterdam, The Netherlands. Special regulations for readers in the USA - This publication has been registered with the Copyright Clearance Center Inc. (CCC), Salem, Massachusetts. Information can be obtained from the CCC about conditions under which photocopies of parts of this publication may be made in the USA. All other copyright questions, including photocopying outside of the USA, should be referred to the publisher. No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. This book is printed on acid-flee paper. Printed in The Netherlands
This work is dedicated to my wife, Jane, with gratitude for her understanding and patience during its preparation.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
TABLE Preface
OF
CONTENTS
............................................................................................................................... x v ~
Acknowledgments
...........................................................................................................
~dx
C r e d i t s .................................................................................................................................
xm
Chapter
One: Radioactivity
Basics
I N T R O D U C T I O N ............................................................................................................... I s o t o p e s a n d n u c l e a r s t r u c t u r e ...............................................................................
1 1
R A D I O A C T I V I T Y .............................................................................................................. Activity a n d half-life .................................................................................................. S t a t i s t i c s of c o u n t i n g ................................................................................................ S t a t i s t i c s of c o u n t i n g zero, s i g n a l vs. n o i s e ................................................. S e q u e n t i a l r a d i o a c t i v e d e c a y ................................................................................... R a d i o a c t i v e e q u i l i b r i u m ............................................................................................ N u c l e a r d e c a y p r o c e s s e s .......................................................................................... B e t a d e c a y ......................................................................................................... A l p h a d e c a y ....................................................................................................... G a m m a r a y e m i s s i o n ...................................................................................... N e u t r o n s o u r c e s ............................................................................................... C h a r a c t e r i s t i c e n e r g y ............................................................................................... D e c a y s c h e m e s .................................................................................................
3 3 5 5 6 7 9 10 11 12 12 14 15
I N T E R A C T I O N S O F R A D I A T I O N W I T H M A T T E R ................................................ A l p h a p a r t i c l e s a n d o t h e r p o s i t i v e l y c h a r g e d ions .............................................. B e t a p a r t i c l e s a n d p o s i t r o n s ................................................................................... G a m m a r a d i a t i o n ( a n d x-rays) ................................................................................ P h o t o e l e c t r i c a b s o r p t i o n (x) ............................................................................ C o m p t o n s c a t t e r i n g ((~) ................................................................................... P a i r p r o d u c t i o n (~) ............................................................................................ G a m m a r a y a t t e n u a t i o n .......................................................................................... C o l l i m a t e d b e a m s a n d s o u r c e g e o m e t r y ...................................................... D i s t r i b u t e d s o u r c e s a n d d e t e c t o r s ................................................................ N e u t r o n r e a c t i o n s w i t h m a t t e r ............................................................................... E l a s t i c collisions ( m o d e r a t i n g ) ....................................................................... N e u t r o n a b s o r p t i o n .......................................................................................... A t t e n u a t i o n of n e u t r o n s in m a t t e r ...............................................................
18 18 19 19 20 20 21 22 23 26 29 30 30 32
S O U R C E S O F R A D I O A C T I V E M A T E R I A L .............................................................. P r i m o r d i a l s o u r c e s ..................................................................................................... M a n m a d e m a t e r i a l s .................................................................................................. C o s m i c r a d i a t i o n ........................................................................................................
33 34 35 36
R E F E R E N C E S ................................................................................................................... 37
viii
Tracers in the Oil Field
Chapter Two: Measurements and Applications I N T R O D U C T I O N ............................................................................................................... 3 9 R A D I A T I O N D E T E C T I O N A N D M E A S U R E M E N T ................................................ I n t e r a c t i o n of r a d i a t i o n w i t h m a t t e r ...................................................................... Efficiency a n d g e o m e t r y of d e t e c t i o n ..................................................................... S i g n a l - t o - n o i s e r a t i o ..................................................................................................
39 39 40 40
C H A R G E C O L L E C T I O N I N G A S C O U N T E R S ........................................................ T h e effect of a n i m p r e s s e d v o l t a g e ......................................................................... P u l s e c o u n t i n g a n d c u r r e n t c o u n t i n g ..................................................................... I o n c h a m b e r ................................................................................................................ P r o p o r t i o n a l c o u n t e r ................................................................................................. G e i g e r - M u e l l e r c o u n t e r ............................................................................................. C o u n t e r p l a t e a u vs. p u l s e - h e i g h t p l a t e a u ............................................................
41 42 43 44 45 46 47
C O U N T I N G S Y S T E M S .................................................................................................... S i m p l e c o u n t e r s ......................................................................................................... C o u n t e r s m e a s u r i n g e n e r g y .................................................................................... B a c k ~ o u n d r e d u c t i o n ......................................................................................
48 48 49 50
S C I N T I L L A T I O N D E T E C T O R S ................................................................................... T h e p h o t o m u l t i p l i e r t u b e .......................................................................................... T h e NaI(T1) d e t e c t o r ................................................................................................. O p e r a t i o n of d e t e c t o r ....................................................................................... E n e r g y s p e c t r u m f r o m NaI(T1) c r y s t a l ....................................................... S p e c t r u m a n a l y s i s ........................................................................................... L i q u i d s c i n t i l l a t i o n c o u n t e r s ..................................................................................... A q u e o u s s o l u t i o n s of b e t a e m i t t e r s .............................................................. C o u n t e r o p e r a t i o n ............................................................................................
51 52 53 53 55 56 58 58 59
S O L I D S T A T E I O N I Z A T I O N D E T E C T O R S ............................................................... D i o d e d e t e c t o r s ........................................................................................................... G e r m a n i u m d e t e c t o r s ............................................................................................... T h e r m o l u m i n e s c e n t d o s i m e t e r s (TLD's) ...............................................................
63 63 64 64
N E U T R O N D E T E C T O R S ................................................................................................ 6 5 COUNT RATE METERS, MULTICHANNEL ANALYZERS, A N D S C A L E R S .................................................................................................................. A n a l o g c o u n t r a t e m e t e r s ........................................................................................ M u l t i c h a n n e l a n a l y z e r s ............................................................................................ P u l s e - h e i g h t a n a l y z e r m o d e ........................................................................... M u l t i c h a n n e l s c a l e r m o d e ............................................................................... M a r i n e l l i b e a k e r s .......................................................................................................
65 65 67 68 69 70
C O U N T I N G R A D I O A C T I V E A T O M S .......................................................................... 7 0 A c c e l e r a t o r m a s s s p e c t r o m e t r y ............................................................................. 71 R e s o n a n c e ion s p e c t r o m e t r y ................................................................................... 71 U S E F U L N U C L E A R P R O C E D U R E S ......................................................................... 71 I s o t o p e g e n e r a t o r s .................................................................................................... 71
T a b l e of C o n t e n t s
ix
A d v a n t a g e s ....................................................................................................... P r o c e d u r e s ........................................................................................................ B i o m e d i c a l b a s e ............................................................................................... I s o t o p e d i l u t i o n p r o c e d u r e s ..................................................................................... M a s s m e a s u r e m e n t s ...................................................................................... V o l u m e m e a s u r e m e n t s .................................................................................. F l o w - r a t e m e a s u r e m e n t s .............................................................................. A c t i v a t i o n a n a l y s i s ..................................................................................................
71 72 73 74 75 75 76 77
D O S I M E T R Y ...................................................................................................................... D o s i m e t r y u n i t s ........................................................................................................ D o s e c a l c u l a t i o n s ...................................................................................................... E s t i m a t e d e x t e r n a l d o s e f r o m a p o i n t g a m m a s o u r c e ............................. E s t i m a t e d i n t e r n a l d o s e f r o m i n g e s t e d b e t a s o u r c e .................................
78 78 79 79 79
L I C E N S I N G A N D C O N T R O L O F R A D I O A C T I V E M A T E R I A L .......................... 81 R a d i a t i o n p r o t e c t i o n : A L A R A a n d M P C .............................................................. 83 R E F E R E N C E S ..................................................................................................................
85
Chapter Three: I n t e r w e l l W a t e r Tracers I N T R O D U C T I O N .............................................................................................................. 8 9 F U N C T I O N S O F A W A T E R F L O O D I N G T R A C E R ................................................. H i s t o r y a n d d e v e l o p m e n t ........................................................................................ R e s e r v o i r c o n s t r a i n t s .............................................................................................. T r a c e r e x c h a n g e .............................................................................................. T r a c e r r e a c t i o n ................................................................................................ T r a c e r m a t e r i a l s for i n t e r w e l l u s e ................................................................ R a d i o a c t i v e a n d u n t a g g e d c h e m i c a l t r a c e r s .......................................................
89 90 90 91 91 92 92
R A D I O A C T I V E L Y T A G G E D T R A C E R S F O R W A T E R F L O O D S ......................... 9 3 R a d i o a c t i v e t r a c e r s a v a i l a b l e for field u s e ........................................................... 9 3 H e x a c y a n o c o b a l t a t e i o n s .............................................................................. 9 4 T r i t i a t e d w a t e r ................................................................................................. 9 4 O t h e r a n i o n i c c o m p l e x e s ................................................................................ 9 5 S p e c i a l t y t r a c e r s ............................................................................................. 9 5 T r a c e r q u a l i t y c o n t r o l .............................................................................................. 9 6 T r a c e r p r e p a r a t i o n ................................................................................................... 9 8 T r i t i a t e d w a t e r ................................................................................................. 9 8 H e x a c y a n o c o b a l t a t e s ..................................................................................... 9 8 T h i o c y a n a t e ion ............................................................................................... 9 9 F i e l d t r a c e r v e r i f i c a t i o n .................................................................................. 9 9 T r a c e r i n j e c t i o n p r o c e d u r e s ........................................................................... 1 0 0 F i e l d t r a c e r d e s i g n ..................................................................................................... 1 0 3 T o t a l d i l u t i o n field t r a c e r m o d e l .................................................................... 1 0 3 A b b a s z a d e h - B r i g h a m m o d e l ......................................................................... 1 0 5 T r a c e r a n a l y s e s : s e n s i t i v i t y , d y n a m i c r a n g e , a n d s e l e c t i v i t y ................ 1 0 5 A n a l y t i c a l s t r a t e g i e s ................................................................................................ 1 0 7
Tracers in the Oil Field
I o n e x c h a n g e c h r o m a t o g r a p h y ..................................................................... 1 0 8 C l a s s i c a l l i q u i d c h r o m a t o g r a p h y .................................................................. 1 0 9 N O N R A D I O A C T I V E L Y T A G G E D T R A C E R S F O R W A T E R F L O O D S ............... C h e m i c a l t r a c e r s a v a i l a b l e ..................................................................................... P o t e n t i a l t r a c e r s ....................................................................................................... A n a l y t i c a l m e t h o d s .................................................................................................. I o n c h r o m a t o g r a p h y ....................................................................................... M i n i m u m d e t e c t i o n l i m i t s ..............................................................................
114 115 116 117 118 124
T R A C E R S A M P L I N G A N D A N A L Y S I S I N T H E F I E L D ....................................... C o n v e n t i o n a l field s a m p l i n g .................................................................................... C o n t i n u o u s t r a c e r a n a l y s i s in t h e field ................................................................. A d d i t i v e p r o c e d u r e ........................................................................................... D i f f e r e n t i a l p r o c e d u r e s ...................................................................................
125 125 126 127 130
R E F E R E N C E S .................................................................................................................. 1 3 1
Chapter Four: Field Examples and Data Analysis I N T R O D U C T I O N .............................................................................................................. 13 7 W a t e r f l o o d l i t e r a t u r e ................................................................................................ 1 3 7 F I E L D T R A C E R R E P O R T S ........................................................................................... C o r r e l a t i o n o f t r a c e r d a t a w i t h field m e a s u r e m e n t s ......................................... N o r t h W e s t f a u l t block ................................................................................... F l o w m e c h a n i s m s ..................................................................................................... E k o f i s k field ...................................................................................................... G u l f a k s field ...................................................................................................... P h y s i c a l m o d e l of t r a c e r m o v e m e n t ..................................................................... A p p l i c a t i o n s of t h e B r i g h a m m o d e l .............................................................. S i m u l a t i o n of a t r a c e r p u l s e ................................................................................... Big M u d d y field t e s t s ....................................................................................... R a n g e r field t r a c e r t e s t s ................................................................................ N i i t s u oilfield t r a c e r s ....................................................................................... M a l j a m a r u n i t t r a c e r s .................................................................................... ......... C a t i o n i c r e s e r v o i r .....................................................................................................
138 138 139 141 141 142 145 146 148 150 153 159 163 164
V O L U M E T R I C A N A L Y S I S O F F I E L D T R A C E R D A T A ........................................ B a s i c a s s u m p t i o n s ................................................................................................... T r a c e r r e s p o n s e c u r v e s ........................................................................................... L a n d m a r k s ....................................................................................................... C u r v e n o i s e ....................................................................................................... T r a c e r r e s p o n s e a n a l y s e s u s i n g m o m e n t s .......................................................... M o m e n t a n a l y s e s ............................................................................................ F i r s t m o m e n t ................................................................................................... E x t r a p o l a t i o n of i n c o m p l e t e d a t a ................................................................. S e c o n d m o m e n t ............................................................................................... D i s t r i b u t i o n of i n j e c t e d w a t e r b e t w e e n p r o d u c e r s .............................................. M a s s b a l a n c e in w a t e r f l o o d t r a c e r s .............................................................
165 166 166 167 167 168 168 169 169 171 171 172
T a b l e of C o n t e n t s
xi
S w e p t p o r e v o l u m e f r o m f i r s t m o m e n t ....................................................... 1 7 2 F i e l d r e s u l t s , N o r t h W e s t f a u l t block .................................................................... 1 7 6 F i e l d d e s c r i p t i o n ............................................................................................... 1 7 6 C a l c u l a t i o n m e t h o d s ................................................................................................ 1 7 8 W a t e r p r o d u c t i o n a t w e l l M-10 f r o m M-03 ................................................ 1 7 9 W a t e r p r o d u c t i o n f r o m M - 0 3 to M - 2 3 ....................................................... . 1 8 1 S w e p t p o r e v o l u m e c a l c u l a t i o n s f r o m M - 0 3 to M - 2 3 ............................. . 1 8 1 S w e p t p o r e v o l u m e c a l c u l a t i o n s f r o m M - 0 3 to M - 1 0 ............................. 91 8 3 P r o d u c t i o n r e s p o n s e a n d s w e p t v o l u m e s f r o m M - 1 4 ............................. 91 8 4 R E F E R E N C E S .................................................................................................................
91 8 6
Chapter Five: Unconventional Waterflood Tracing I N T R O D U C T I O N .............................................................................................................. 1 9 1 R E S I D U A L O I L M E A S U R E M E N T S B Y T R A C E R S ............................................... 1 9 1 M e t h o d s i n u s e ........................................................................................................... 1 9 2 P a r t i t i o n i n g t r a c e r s .................................................................................................. 1 9 2 T r a c e r m e t h o d ........................................................................................................... 1 9 2 P r i n c i p l e s ........................................................................................................... 1 9 3 E q u a t i o n s .......................................................................................................... 1 9 3 D i s t r i b u t i o n coefficients ................................................................................. 1 9 5 E q u i l i b r i u m c o n d i t i o n s .................................................................................... 1 9 9 S i n g l e - w e l l t r a c e r t e s t for r e s i d u a l oil .................................................................... 2 0 1 S y m m e t r y p r o b l e m ......................................................................................... 2 0 1 A s y m m e t r y s o l u t i o n ....................................................................................... 2 0 2 F i e l d p r o c e d u r e s ............................................................................................... 2 0 4 T w o - w e l l t r a c e r t e s t ( T W T T ) for r e s i d u a l oil ....................................................... 2 0 7 R e s e r v o i r c o n d i t i o n s for t w o - w e l l t r a c e r t e s t ............................................. 2 0 8 T w o - w e l l t r a c e r t e s t s for r e s i d u a l oil: F i e l d r e s u l t s ................................... 2 0 9 O B S E R V A T I O N W E L L S ................................................................................................ 2 1 5 A d v a n t a g e s a n d d i s a d v a n t a g e s ............................................................................. 2 1 5 L o g g i n g o b s e r v a t i o n w e l l s ....................................................................................... 2 1 6 R e q u i r e m e n t s a n d l i m i t a t i o n s ....................................................................... 2 1 6 C o m p a r i s o n w i t h w a t e r f l o o d t r a c i n g ........................................................... 2 1 7 S u i t a b l e t r a c e r s ............................................................................................... 2 1 7 T r a c e r d e t e c t i o n ............................................................................................... 2 1 7 W e l l field e x p e r i e n c e ........................................................................................ 2 1 8 D e s i g n of a l o g g i n g o b s e r v a t i o n w e l l t r a c e r t e s t ................................................. 2 2 2 T e s t d e s i g n f a c t o r s .......................................................................................... 2 2 4 D i l u t i o n of t r a c e r p u l s e ................................................................................... 2 2 5 T r a c e r r e s p o n s e a t o b s e r v a t i o n w e l l ........................................................... 2 2 6 O t h e r field t r a c e r t e s t s ................................................................................... 2 2 7 S a m p l i n g o b s e r v a t i o n w e l l s .................................................................................... 2 3 0 M o n i t o r i n g t r a c e r s i n j e c t e d a t a n o b s e r v a t i o n w e l l ............................................ 2 3 2 INTERWELL
R E A C T I O N S ........................................................................................... 2 3 4
Tracers in the Oil Field
C o n v e r s i o n of i n j e c t e d s u l f a t e ion to h y d r o g e n sulfide ....................................... 2 3 4 FLOW THROUGH DOWNHOLE
F R A C T U R E S .................................................................................
INJECTION
237
A N D S A M P L I N G ........................................................... 2 3 8
R E F E R E N C E S ..................................................................................................................
239
Chapter Six: Interwell Gas Tracing I N T R O D U C T I O N ..............................................................................................................
243
G A S T R A C E R S F O R O I L F I E L D U S E ........................................................................ C h e m i c a l a n d p h y s i c a l r e s t r a i n t s ......................................................................... H i s t o r y a n d d e v e l o p m e n t ........................................................................................ G a s t r a c e r s u s e d for i n t e r w e l l t e s t s .............................................................
243 243 244 244
N O N I D E A L B E H A V I O R O F G A S T R A C E R S ........................................................... P a r t i t i o n of g a s t r a c e r s a n d i n j e c t e d g a s velocities ............................................ T r a c e d g a s p r o c e d u r e s ............................................................................................. P r e s s u r e m a i n t e n a n c e ................................................................................... S o l v e n t flooding ................................................................................................ R e s i d u a l oil ........................................................................................................
246 246 249 249 249 249
F I E L D P R O C E D U R E S .................................................................................................... T r a c e r p r o c e d u r e s a n d d e s i g n ................................................................................. D i l u t i o n v o l u m e s .............................................................................................. S a m p l i n g a n d a n a l y s i s ............................................................................................. T r a c e r s a m p l i n g ............................................................................................... N o n r a d i o a c t i v e t r a c e r a n a l y s i s .................................................................... A n a l y s i s of r a d i o a c t i v e t r a c e r s ..................................................................... O n - l i n e t r a c e r a n a l y s i s ................................................................................... V e r i f i c a t i o n of t r a c e r s .....................................................................................
250 250 250 251 251 252 253 254 255
F I E L D T R A C E R T E S T S ................................................................................................. G a s t r a c i n g a n d r e s e r v o i r d e s c r i p t i o n ................................................................... C o a l i n g a field .................................................................................................... D u a l c o m p l e t i o n well ....................................................................................... R e s i d u a l oil i n t h e g a s cap ....................................................................................... L a n d m a r k m e t h o d for r e s i d u a l oil ................................................................ S o l v e n t injection (MI) t r a c i n g ................................................................................. P h a s e b e h a v i o r ................................................................................................ F i e l d t e s t r e s u l t s ....................................................................................................... R a i n b o w K e g R i v e r B pool ............................................................................. S o u t h S w a n H i l l s M I flood ............................................................................. M i t s u e M I flood ................................................................................................ J u d y C r e e k M I flood ........................................................................................ F e n n - B i g V a l l e y M I flood ................................................................................
255 255 256 257 258 258 264 264 265 265 268 270 273 274
S T E A M T R A C I N G ............................................................................................................ 2 7 5 S t e a m b e h a v i o r ......................................................................................................... 2 7 6 G a s t r a c e r s for s t e a m ( v a p o r ) ...................................................................... 2 7 6
T a b l e of C o n t e n t s
xiii
W a t e r t r a c e r s for c o n d e n s a t e ....................................................................... 2 7 7 S t e a m t r a c e r i n j e c t i o n .................................................................................... 2 7 7 T r a c e r field r e s u l t s .................................................................................................... 2 7 7 T i a J u a n a & J O B O s t e a m d r i v e s ................................................................. 2 7 7 M i d w a y S u n s e t s t e a m pilot ........................................................................... 2 7 8 K e r n R i v e r s t e a m flood ................................................................................... 2 7 8 P e a c e R i v e r s t e a m p i l o t ................................................................................. 2 7 8 S a m p l e collection a n d a n a l y s i s ..................................................................... 2 8 2 GAS TRACING IN UNCONVENTIONAL
RESERVOIRS
.................................... 2 8 4
R E F E R E N C E S .................................................................................................................. 2 8 5
Chapter Seven: Downhole Tracers I N T R O D U C T I O N .............................................................................................................. 2 9 3 T r a c e r d e t e c t i o n i n t h e b o r e h o l e ............................................................................ 2 9 3 F A S T N E U T R O N A C T I V A T I O N O F T R A C E R S ...................................................... 2 9 5 L e a k s b e h i n d c a s i n g ................................................................................................. 2 9 5 O x y g e n a c t i v a t i o n log ............................................................................................... 2 9 5 C o n t i n u o u s n e u t r o n a c t i v a t i o n ..................................................................... 2 9 7 S h o r t p u l s e n e u t r o n a c t i v a t i o n ..................................................................... 2 9 8 O t h e r f a s t n e u t r o n a c t i v a t i o n s .............................................................................. 3 0 6 F a s t n e u t r o n a c t i v a t i o n of b a r i u m .............................................................. 3 0 6 D r i l l i n g m u d b e h i n d c a s i n g ............................................................................. 3 0 6 L O G - I N J E C T - L O G T R A C E R P R O C E D U R E S .......................................................... 3 0 7 R e s i d u a l oil b y n e u t r o n - a c t i v a t e d b r i n e t r a c e r ................................................... 3 0 8 W a t e r s a t u r a t i o n b y n e u t r o n - a c t i v a t e d b o r o n t r a c e r ....................................... 3 1 0 R a d i o a c t i v e t r a c e r s ......................................................................................... 3 1 0 R A D I O A C T I V E T R A C E R S F O R W E L L T R E A T M E N T D O W N H O L E ............... 3 1 1 S t i m u l a t i o n t r e a t m e n t ................................................................................... 3 1 2 C o n t r o l t r e a t m e n t ........................................................................................... 3 1 2 T r a c e r s u s e d for w e l l t r e a t i n g ....................................................................... 3 1 2 S p e c t r a l g a m m a r a y a n a l y s e s ............................................................................... 3 1 3 N a I s c i n t i l l a t i o n d e t e c t o r s ............................................................................. 3 1 3 D e c o n v o l u t i o n of g a m m a s p e c t r a ................................................................ 3 1 4 D e p t h of t r e a t m e n t p e n e t r a t i o n f r o m t r a c e r d a t a ............................................. 3 1 9 P r i n c i p l e s of m e a s u r e m e n t ............................................................................ 3 1 9 D o w n h o l e m e a s u r e m e n t s w i t h l o g g i n g tools .............................................. 3 2 0 D o w n h o l e t r a c e r p r o c e d u r e s ................................................................................... 3 2 2 D o w n h o l e t r a c e r t e s t d e s i g n .......................................................................... 3 2 2 F i e l d e x a m p l e s ........................................................................................................... 3 2 6 H y d r a u l i c f r a c t u r e t r a c i n g ............................................................................. 3 2 6 T a g g e d g r a v e l p a c k t r a c i n g ........................................................................... 3 2 7 T a g g e d d i v e r t e r s a n d m u l t i s t a g e acid t r e a t m e n t ...................................... 3 2 8 D i r e c t i o n a l o r i e n t a t i o n a t t h e b o r e h o l e ................................................................. 3 2 8 F o c u s i n g c o l l i m a t o r ......................................................................................... 3 3 1
xiv
Tracers in the Oil Field
A n o m a l o u s b a c k g r o u n d i n t e r f e r e n c e : R a d i o a c t i v e scale .................................. 3 3 2 O T H E R G A M M A - R A Y T R A C E R M E T H O D S ............................................................ 3 3 3 C e m e n t b e h i n d casing .............................................................................................. 3 3 3 W e l l t r a c e r m e t h o d ................................................................................................... 3 3 6 P R O D U C T I O N L O G G I N G .............................................................................................. W a t e r injection logging ............................................................................................. T r a c e r loss log .................................................................................................. Velocity shot log ............................................................................................... T r a c e r dilution logging P u l s e m e t h o d .................................................................................................... C o n t i n u o u s m e t h o d ......................................................................................... P r o d u c t i o n logging for gas: Field s t u d y ........................................................ P r o d u c t i o n logging w i t h isotope g e n e r a t o r s ......................................................... A v a i l a b l e isotope g e n e r a t o r s ......................................................................... I s o t o p e g e n e r a t o r s for d o w n h o l e logging ..................................................... C o n t i n u o u s t r a c e r p r o d u c t i o n f r o m a n isotope g e n e r a t o r ....................... Injection logging of s t e a m wells .............................................................................. Field injectivity profile m e a s u r e m e n t s ........................................................ S t e a m t r a c e r s u r v e y e v a l u a t i o n .................................................................. I n j e c t e d s t e a m q u a l i t y ....................................................................................
336 337 338 342 344 345 348 349 352 352 353 355 357 358 359 361
B O R E H O L E P R O C E S S E S ............................................................................................. M u d w a t e r i n v a s i o n .................................................................................................. H y d r a u l i c b e h a v i o r of m u d ............................................................................ Drill-bit w e a r ..............................................................................................................
362 362 364 364
R E F E R E N C E S .................................................................................................................. 3 6 5
Chapter Eight: Tracers in Facility Operations I N T R O D U C T I O N .............................................................................................................. 3 7 1 F L O W - R A T E M E A S U R E M E N T ................................................................................... I s o t o p e d i l u t i o n .......................................................................................................... C o n t i n u o u s injection m e t h o d ......................................................................... P u l s e injection m e t h o d s .................................................................................. P u l s e velocity .............................................................................................................
371 372 372 373 378
F L O W - R A T E A P P L I C A T I O N S ..................................................................................... Single- a n d m u l t i p h a s e flow .................................................................................... S l u d g e in pipes ........................................................................................................... L i n e m e t e r i n g by t r a c e r ........................................................................................... L i n e m e t e r i n g w i t h isotope g e n e r a t o r s ........................................................ O t h e r isotope g e n e r a t o r s for flow m o n i t o r i n g ............................................
379 379 382 382 384 386
F L O W R E G I M E I N P I P E A N D G A T H E R I N G L I N E S ............................................ S i n g l e - e n e r g y g a m m a - r a y t r a n s m i s s i o n .............................................................. S i n g l e - e n e r g y g a m m a for t h r e e - p h a s e flow ................................................ D u a l - e n e r g y g a m m a for t h r e e - p h a s e flow ...........................................................
387 387 388 389
T a b l e of C o n t e n t s
xv
T h r e e - p h a s e s a t u r a t i o n s ............................................................................... 3 8 9 D u a l - d e t e c t o r d u a l - e n e r g y s y s t e m s for t h r e e - p h a s e flow ................................. 3 9 2 G a m m a - r a y b a c k - s c a t t e r ....................................................................................... 3 9 4 T h r e e - p h a s e s a t u r a t i o n s ............................................................................... 3 9 4 P i p e l i n e w a l l s .................................................................................................... 3 9 4 N e u t r o n m e t h o d s ...................................................................................................... 3 9 5 C o m b i n e d m e t h o d s ................................................................................................... 3 9 6 UNDERGROUND G A S S T O R A G E .............................................................................. 3 9 6 T r a c e r s for u n d e r g r o u n d g a s s t o r a g e .................................................................... 3 9 6 P r o c e d u r e s i n c u r r e n t u s e .............................................................................. 3 9 7 K r - 8 5 for p r e t e s t of s t o r a g e i n t e g r i t y ................................................................... 3 9 7 H y d r o g e n t r a c e r for g a s m i x i n g in u n d e r g r o u n d s t o r a g e ................................... 3 9 8 T r o u b l e s h o o t i n g w i t h t r a c e r s ................................................................................. 3 9 9 O I L , W A T E R , A N D G A S S E P A R A T O R S .................................................................... 4 0 0 R e s i d e n c e t i m e d i s t r i b u t i o n (RTD) i n o i l / w a t e r s e p a r a t o r s .............................. 4 0 0 O i l / w a t e r s e p a r a t o r s ....................................................................................... 4 0 0 H y d r a u l i c b e h a v i o r of A P I s e p a r a t o r .......................................................... 4 0 1 H y d r a u l i c b e h a v i o r of oilfield s e p a r a t o r s .................................................... 4 0 2 E R O S I O N A N D C O R R O S I O N ....................................................................................... 4 ! 1 C o r r o s i o n a n d e r o s i o n m o n i t o r i n g .......................................................................... 4 1 1 C o r r o s i o n c o u p o n s ........................................................................................... 4 1 1 O t h e r c o r r o s i o n a n d e r o s i o n d e t e c t i o n p r o c e d u r e s .................................... 4 1 2 C o r r o s i o n t r e a t i n g ..................................................................................................... 4 1 3 S C A L E M O N I T O R I N G A N D T R E A T M E N T ............................................................. 4 1 4 T a g g e d s c a l e i n h i b i t o r s ............................................................................................ 4 1 5 PIPELINE
L E A K S ........................................................................................................... 4 1 6
ENVIRONMENTAL P R O B L E M S ................................................................................ 4 1 7 N a t u r a l l y O c c u r r i n g R a d i o a c t i v e M a t e r i a l ( N O R M ) ......................................... 4 1 7 O t h e r e n v i r o n m e n t a l c o n c e r n s .............................................................................. 4 1 8 Oil spills a n d oily w a t e r ................................................................................... 4 1 8 Drilling fluids ..................................................................................................... 4 1 9 O t h e r t r a c e r a p p l i c a t i o n s .............................................................................. 4 1 9 R E F E R E N C E S .................................................................................................................. 4 2 0
Appendix:
Analytical Flow Model for Design and Analysis of Tracer Pulse Tests
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
427
I N T R O D U C T I O N .............................................................................................................. 4 2 9 A n a l y t i c a l b a s e for t r a c e r m o v e m e n t .................................................................. 4 2 9 A R E A L D I L U T I O N F R O M P A T T E R N G E O M E T R Y ............................................... 4 3 1 P a t t e r n b r e a k t h r o u g h c u r v e for a f i v e - s p o t ........................................................ 4 3 1 D i s p l a c e m e n t of o n e fluid b y a n o t h e r .......................................................... 4 3 1 D i s p l a c e m e n t of a s m a l l s l u g ........................................................................ 4 3 2 G e n e r a l p a t t e r n b r e a k t h r o u g h c u r v e s ................................................................. 4 3 3
xvi
Tracers in the Oil F i e l d
C o r r e l a t i o n of p a t t e r n b r e a k t h r o u g h curves ....................................................... 4 3 4 A R E A L D I L U T I O N BY M I X I N G E F F E C T S .............................................................. Mixing in porous m e d i a ............................................................................................ F u n d a m e n t a l s .................................................................................................. Mixing in l i n e a r s y s t e m s ................................................................................ Mixing w i t h i n a s t r e a m t u b e ..........................................................................
436 436 436 437 438
TRACER RESPONSE FROM DEVELOPED HOMOGENEOUS P A T T E R N S ........................................................................................................................ F o r m u l a t i o n ............................................................................................................... C o r r e l a t i o n of t r a c e r p r o d u c t i o n curves ............................................................... Adsorption a n d decay ...............................................................................................
440 440 441 443
T R A C E R F L O W I N I R R E G U L A R A N D O P E N P A T T E R N S ................................ 4 4 6 T R A C E R R E S P O N S E I N L A Y E R E D R E S E R V O I R S ............................................. L a y e r i n g ...................................................................................................................... C o m p u t a t i o n of t r a c e r r e s p o n s e from a l a y e r e d r e s e r v o i r ...................... N u m e r i c a l e x a m p l e of l a y e r e d r e s p o n s e c o m p u t a t i o n ............................. H e t e r o g e n e i t y definition by layers ........................................................................ S t a t i s t i c a l b a c k g r o u n d ................................................................................... D y k s t r a - P a r s o n s coefficient to c h a r a c t e r i z e l a y e r i n g h e t e r o g e n e i t y .......................................................................... C o n s t r u c t i o n of l a y e r s u s i n g D y k s t r a - P a r s o n s coefficient, VDP ...................................................................................... N u m e r i c a l e x a m p l e of l a y e r construction from VDP ................................
448 448 448 449 450 450
D E C O N V O L U T I O N O F T R A C E R B R E A K T H R O U G H DATA .............................. N o n l i n e a r regression ................................................................................................ I n t e r p r e t a t i o n of Loco field t r a c e r test ................................................................. A d j u s t m e n t s for o p e n p a t t e r n ...................................................................... L a y e r a n a l y s i s by n o n l i n e a r r e g r e s s i o n ...................................................... A r e a l h e t e r o g e n e i t i e s ...............................................................................................
454 454 456 457 458 461
D E S I G N O F T R A C E R T E S T S ....................................................................................... Design b a s e d on a single layer ................................................................................ D e s i g n b a s e d u p o n l a y e r i n g .................................................................................... D e s i g n b a s e d on t h e D y k s t r a - P a r s o n s VDP coefficient ....................................
462 462 463 466
451 452 453
D E R I V A T I O N O F P A T T E R N B R E A K T H R O U G H C U R V E S ............................... 4 6 6 N O M E N C L A T U R E .......................................................................................................... 4 6 8 S Y M B O L S .......................................................................................................................... 4 7 0 E R R O R F U N C T I O N S ...................................................................................................... 4 7 1 R E F E R E N C E S .................................................................................................................. 4 7 2 I n d e x ................................................................................................................................... 4 7 5
PREFACE Most of the applications of tracers to oilfield operations have occurred within the past forty years. Throughout most of this period, I have been an active participant in these applications and have observed the development of m a n y innovative and useful techniques. Unfortunately, perhaps due to the n a t u r e of this competitive industry, a good deal of the work is poorly documented, if at all, in the open literature. In addition, available literature is widely dispersed and the small service companies t h a t have supported much of this effort are disappearing from the scene. As a result, much of this knowledge passes only by word of mouth among an ever-decreasing set of providers. This book is an attempt to fill the void and make the technology more available to current users in the oil field. The initial expansion of tracer applications in the oil field was based on radioactive tracers, much of it a consequence of the Atoms-for-Peace programs following the nuclear developments of World War II, and depended on a multitude of small service companies for support. In the intervening years, developments in analytical chemistry have expanded the use of nonradioactive tracers in biomedicine and other fields, but very little of this has made its way to the oil field. Because there is so little knowledge among oilfield personnel about either of these, I have included enough background material for both kinds of tracers to enable a field engineer to evaluate their application to field problems. The computer revolution of recent years has added a dimension to tracer technology and has placed new emphasis on mathematical modeling and computer simulation of tracer-response curves. Unfortunately, there is little communication between those who design and perform the tracer tests in the oil field and those who model them. This often results in a poorly designed test, in modelers who do not u n d e r s t a n d the significance of the field data they model, and in practitioners concerned only with a qualitative aspect of the test. This book is primarily concerned with field and laboratory test procedures; however examples of computer modeling of oilfield tracer tests described in the literature are included. I have emphasized quantitative aspects of tracer tests, with regard both to field practice and to data analysis, and I anticipate a future in which most tracer design and analysis will also involve computer simulation. Tracers have been used to study a very broad range of topics in the oil field. It is not possible in a book of this kind to touch on all of them or to dwell equally on all the topics chosen. Some topics are a m a t t e r of personal choice, but most were chosen for their applicability to modern field usage, and because they provide the most quantitative information. This book is about field applications, and where possible, the tracer applications discussed here are illustrated by data from field tests t h a t have been reported in the open literature, or for which permission to publish has been received from the sponsoring company. I have freely taken tracer applications from other disciplines wherever they provide a useful procedure for oilfield use. While this book is not concerned with
ooo
XVI]I
Tracers in the Oil Field
oilwell logging as such, those areas of oilfield logging that use tracer techniques have been included and placed in context with other oilfield tracer methods. The use of radiation from radioactive sources for monitoring flowrates and measuring fluid saturations in pipes and tubulars is also included here because it is so intimately tied up with tracer measurements. Two tracer applications used in the biomedical field offer an advantage over current techniques used in the oilfield, and are therefore included here: 1) the use of short-lived radioactive tracers from isotope generators down hole to monitor tracers in the neighborhood of the borehole; and 2) the use of a focusing collimator for imaging radioactively tagged treatments inside the borehole. J u s t as oilfield tracer applications have roots in hydrology, g r o u n d w a t e r studies, chemical reactor engineering, civil engineering, sanitation, environmental studies, and many other, disciplines, many of the procedures developed in the oil field are applicable to equivalent studies in these disciplines. An example is the use of partitioning tracers in locating and removing nonaqueous toxic substances from the ground by Dr. Gary Pope and his co-workers. This technique was designed to measure residual oil in the reservoir. Laboratory tests and computer simulations at The University of Texas at Austin have demonstrated the suitability of the technique for monitoring the amount and location of these toxic nonaqueous fluids in the near subsurface. The efficacy of such tertiary oilfield recovery methods as surfactant flooding for removing these materials has also been demonstrated. The design of a tracer test is often an educated guess based upon empirical factors, and the produced data are frequently used only for qualitative observation. An analytical method for designing a waterflood tracer test and analyzing the tracer response data from the field was introduced by Brigham and Smith in 1964 and has since been modified by Abbaszadeh and Brigham. The method has been described in the literature, but the mathematical language has kept its applications from being widely used. An appendix written by Dr. Abbaszadeh has been added to this text to clarify this method for designing a field tracer test and analyzing the tracer response curves from the test.
Bernard Zemel Austin, Texas September 12, 1994
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I wish to t h a n k both the Center for Petroleum and Geosystems Engineering and the Department of Petroleum and Geosystems Engineering at The University of Texas at Austin for granting me the privilege of a Visiting Scholar position during the preparation of this book. The preparation of a camera-ready manuscript would have been far more difficult without the aid of departmental facilities and my many discussions with faculty and staff members. I am particularly beholden to Dr. Gary Pope for his encouragement during the writing of this work and for our many discussions about tracers in the oil field. I must also express my appreciation for the computer simulations of tracer movement in the reservoir performed by Dr. Pope and his student Vichai Maroongroge, which have clarified my understanding of the functions of a tracer test. I wish to thank the following people who have taken the time to read and return critical reviews of various sections of this book: Dr. Harry Deans of the University of Wyoming, and Krishan Malik, Dr. Dan Hill, Dr. Henry Dunlap, Dr. Larry Lake, Dr. Augusto Podio, and Dr. John C. Reis of The University of Texas at Austin. Thank are due both to Shell Development Co. and to BP Exploration for permission to share the results of unpublished work with which I was involved. This has enabled me to illustrate some useful unconventional tracer procedures. I also wish to thank those oilfield people, too numerous to mention here, who have shared information on field tracer applications over the years. I would like to extend special thanks to Larry Taylor of True Tag, Larry Gadeken of Haliburton, Wally Loder of Tracer Tech International, Roy Dobson and Dave Ferguson of Tracerco, Andy Carmichael of Teledyne Isotopes, and Gordon Tinker. Equally important are Mike Prats and Philip Clossman, who are responsible for my starting this book. Finally, I wish to t ha nk my editor and book designer, Jane Chamberlain of Pangloss Publishing, for her careful pruning of the language and the many hours she spent laying out the pages in a Macintosh program never intended for this purpose.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CREDITS Since this is a book on field tracer applications, it contains illustrations and tables describing these applications. Many of these have been taken from copyrighted material published in the oilfield literature, in subsidiary texts, in the commercial literature, and from unpublished company reports. The cooperation of the publishers in granting permission to use this material is appreciated and acknowledged below, as is that of the sponsoring companies allowing the use of unpublished company reports. Illustrations from government documents and other public sources are not listed here but are noted and referenced in the text. The illustrations and tables used from these sources are noted where they appear in the text, and sources are listed with the references at the end of each chapter. Credits for these sources are given below in the following order: 1) the oilfield literature as described in journals and society presentations or taken from unpublished company reports by permission of the sponsoring company; 2) texts on basics of tracer properties or applications; and 3) commercial suppliers of services or materials used in tracer tests. The following copyrighted 9 material is reproduced by permission from the Society of Petroleum Engineers (SPE). It includes preprints of presentations at meetings and papers from SPE journals. Figures are cited in order of appearance: 3.2, 4.1, 4.2, 4.3, 4.6, 4.7, 4.11, 4.12, 4.13, 4.15, 4.16, 4.17, 4.18, 5.2, 5.11, 5.14, 5.15, 5.16, 5.18, 5.19, 5.20, 5.21, 6.1, 6.7, 6.8, 6.12, 6.13, 6.14, 7.1, 7.2, 7.3, 7.5, 7.6, 7.7, 7.14, 7.15, 7.16, 7.19, 7.20, 7.21, 7.23, 7.25, 7.26, 7.30, 7.31, 7.33, 8.6, 8.7, 8.8, 8.16, 8.17, 8.18, 8.19, 8.20, 8.21, and 8.22. The following copyrighted 9 material is reproduced by permission of the Petroleum Society of CIM: Table 5.2, Figs. 5.10, 6.2, 6.3, 6.4, 6.5, 6.9, 6.10, and 6.11. The following figures are reproduced from journals and other compendia with permission from the copyright owner: Fig. 1.14 from Geophysics, 9 the Society of Exploration Geophysicists Fig. 1.15 from Nucleonics, 9 McGraw Hill Publishing Co. Fig. 3.5 from Journal of Chromatography, 9 Elsevier Science Ltd., Kidlington, UK, Pergamon Press Fig. 3.6 from Journal of Chromatography, 9 Elsevier Science Ltd., Kidlington, UK, Pergamon Press Figs. 4.4 and 4.5 from the International Energy Agency for permission to use material 9 from the Symposium on Reservoir Engineering, Paris (1990) Figs. 4.8, 4.9, 4.10, 4.14, and 5.12 from The Journal of Petroleum Engineering Science, 9 Elsevier Science Publishers Figs. 7.4 and 7.17 from The Analyst and SPWLA Symposia, 9 Society of Professional Well Logging Analysts
x~
Tracers in the Oil Field
Fig. 7.11 from the International Symposium on Exploration of Energy and Natural Resources, Vienna, 9 International Atomic Energy Agency Fig. 7.27 from Formation Evaluation Symposium, 9 Canadian Well Logging Society Fig. 8.9 from Nucleonics, 9 McGraw Hill Publishing Co. Figs. 8.12, 8.13, 8.14 from Nuclear Geophysics, 9 Elsevier Science Ltd., Kidlington, UK, Pergamon Press Fig. 8.25 from the Proceedings of the Twenty Fourth Annual Meeting (1977) 9 Southwest Petroleum Short Course Assoc. The following figures, tables and other stated material from previously unpublished works are reproduced with permission as follows: Figs. 4.22, 4.23, 4.24, 4.25, 4.26, 4.27, 5.4, Table 5.1 and associated text, BP Exploration Co. Figs. 3.10, 5.23 and associated text, Shell Development Co. The following figures are reproduced with permission from the copyright owner from the specified texts: Fig. 1.1, R.D. Evans, The Atomic Nucleus, 9 Krieger Publishing Co., Malabar, Florida Figs. 1.1, 1.2, and 1.16, Treatise on Analytical Chemistry, Elving and Kolthoff (eds.), Part 1, 14, sect. K, chap. 1, 9 John Wiley & Sons, New York Figs. 1.17 and 2.22, Ehmann, W.D., and Vance, D.E., Radiochemistry and Nuclear Methods of Analysis, 9 John Wiley & Sons, New York Fig. 2.3, Knoll, G.F., Radiation Detection and Measurement, 9 John Wiley & Sons, New York Fig. 2.20, Tsoulfanidis, N., Measurement and Detection of Radiation, 9 Hemisphere Publishing Corp., Washington, D.C. Fig. 7.18, Hine, G.J., and Sorensen, J.A., eds., Instrumentation in Nuclear Medicine, vol.2, chap. 1., 9 Academic Press, New York Fig. 8.24, Levenspiel, O., Chemical Reaction Engineering, 9 John Wiley & Sons, New York The following figures are reproduced from the specified texts with permission from the commercial supplier holding the copyright: Fig. 2.10, The RCA Photomultiplier Manual, 9 1970 Burle Industries, Tube Products Division Figs. 2.14, 2.15, 2.16, Workshop Manuals, 9 Packard Instrument Co, Meriden, Connecticut
Credits
xxifi
Fig. 2.17, Instrument Manual, 9 Beckman Instruments, San Diego, California Figs. 5.6, 5.7, and 5.8, Determination of Residual Oil Saturation, 9 Interstate Oil Compact Commission, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma Figs. 7.10, 7.12, 7.24, 9 Schlumberger Logging Co., Houston, Texas Fig. 7.13, 9 Haliburton Logging Co.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Tracers in the Oil Field
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CHAPTER 1
RADIOACTIVITY BASICS
INTRODUCTION Modern applications of radioactivity and radioactive tracers to industrial and commercial problems stem largely from the nuclear developments associated with the atomic bomb and subsequent "Atoms for Peace" programs in the United States and elsewhere after World War II. Successful applications of nuclear technology were noted especially in the fields of medicine and oil exploration. During this time the use and development of nuclear logging tools expanded greatly. Radioactive tracers were also applied to virtually every phase of oil production both in the laboratory and in the field, and small companies offering m a n y types of radioactive services proliferated. To a lesser extent, these tracer studies are still going on, most of them in the medical area. While radioactivity is certainly not a requirement for a tracer, most of the open forums devoted to tracer applications at this time are those sponsored by nuclear societies such as the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) and the American Nuclear Society. This chapter is concerned with the basic principles and definitions required to apply radioactivity and the use of radioactive tracers to oilfield problems. This work will not cover considerations of nuclear structure or aspects of nuclear physics and chemistry that have no significant bearing on the use of radioactivity in the oil field. For readers in search of further information on these topics, m a n y excellent references are available, a few of which are listed at the end of this chapter. We will emphasize aspects of radioactivity relevant to current oilfield practice, including some t h a t may not be in current use but have a demonstrated utility in this area.
Isotopes a n d n u c l e a r s t r u c t u r e All m a t t e r is composed of elements, which are composed of atoms. An atom consists of a small, positively charged nucleus balanced by a distribution of surrounding orbital electrons of negative charge. The atoms of each element differ in their nuclear properties. While avoiding discussion of nuclear structure, we can t r e a t the nucleus as being composed of neutrons and protons. The neutron is a heavy particle t h a t carries no charge, whereas the proton is a heavy particle with a single positive charge. Any given species of atom or nuclide has a nucleus composed of a certain n u m b e r of neutrons (N) and protons (P). The number of protons in the nuclide is the atomic n u m b e r (Z), which determines the extra nuclear electrons of the atom and its chemical nature. The sum of the neutrons and protons in the nucleus (N+P) is the atomic mass (M).
2
Chapter I
The elements are arranged in periodic tables according to their atomic n u m bers. For each nuclide of a given atomic n u m b e r there can, however, be different n u m b e r s of neutrons. Atoms with the same atomic n u m b e r but different n u m b e r of n e u t r o n s in the nucleus are called isotopes. Isotopes of an element all have the same chemical properties and occupy the same place in the periodic table but differ in their atomic weight. The fractional atomic weights listed in the periodic table are the weighted average of the atomic masses of the n a t u r a l l y occurring isotopes. Conventional s h o r t h a n d for expressing the atomic weight of an isotope is mz I, where I is the common n a m e of the element and m is the mass. Since z is the atomic number, which defines the common name given to I, it is r e d u n d a n t and normally omitted. Thus hydrogen of mass 3 is written as 3H. In this text we will also use the designation H-3 or hydrogen-3 as an equivalent form. H-3 also carries the common name of tritium and is abbreviated as (T). A consequence of Einstein's special theory of relativity is the r e l a t i o n s h i p between mass (M) and energy (E) given by the expression: E=MC 2
(1.1)
where C is the velocity of light. The atomic mass unit (amu) is based upon the mass assigned to the carbon isotope 12C, which is given a value of exactly 12. The SI unit for energy is the joule (j); however the unit traditionally and most widely used for energy in nuclear studies is the electron volt (eV). This is defined as the energy gained by an electron when it is accelerated through a potential difference of one volt. A multiple frequently used is the mega electron volt (MeV), which is equal to 106 eV. Based upon these units: TABLE 1.1 Mass conversion units Unit
Abbreviation
joules
MeV
electron volt
eV
1.602 x 10 -19
10~
atomic mass unit
amu
1.492 x 10 -10
931.5
8.170 x 10 -14
0.51
electron rest mass
It should be noted t h a t the m e a s u r e d mass of a nucleus is always smaller t h a n the combined mass of its component neutrons and protons. This difference is called the mass defect. Its energy equivalent is called the binding energy, and is a m e a s u r e of the stability of the nucleus. Nuclear reactions always result in the emission or absorption of energy, calculated from the difference between the masses of the products and those of the reactants.
Radioactivity Basics RADIOACTIVITY Some combinations of protons and neutrons result in unstable nuclei. Such nuclides undergo spontaneous disintegration with time. This decay, accompanied by the emission of nuclear particles and/or electromagnetic radiation, is termed radioactivity. Emission of particles from the nucleus also results in the formation of a new nuclide if there is a net change in the n u m b e r of protons in the new nucleus as a result of the decay. Statistically, decay of a given radioactive nucleus is a random, unpredictable event; however if a sufficient number of radioactive nuclides is present, the rate of decay, dN/dT, becomes proportional to the number of nuclides (N) present. The greater the number of radioactive nuclides, the more closely this rule is followed. The rate of decay per unit time, dN/dt, is a m e a s u r e of the a m o u n t of radioactivity (A) present and has the dimensions of events per second. This is shown below, where k is a proportionality constant, known as the decay constant, which is specific to each isotope.
dN
A = -d-~-= LN
(1.2)
Activity and half-life In modern (SI) nomenclature, the basic unit for the amount of radioactivity present, A, is the becquerel (Bq), which is equal to a decay rate of one disintegration per second (dps). An older unit still widely used in the industry is the curie (Ci), which is equal to 3.7 x 1010 dps. The Bq and the Ci are normally used in multiples and submultiples, respectively, of these units as can be seen in Table 1.2. TABLE 1.2 Unit multipliers Prefix
Symbol
Multiple
femto pico nano micro milli kilo mega giga tera
f p n ~t m k M G T
10-15 10 -12 10-9 10-6 10-3 10 3 10 6 109 1012
Example fj = femtojoule pCi = picocurie nCi = nanocurie ~tSv = microsievert mGy = milligray kr = kilorad MBq = megabecquerel GeV = gigaelectron volt TBq = terabecquerels
4
Chapter i
These multiples are important in a wide variety of nuclear units, such as electron volts (eV), sieverts, grays, etc., as well as non-nuclear units such as joules, seconds, and grams. All of these units will be discussed as they arise in appropriate sections of chapters I and 2. Integration of Eq. (1.2) above yields the standard equation for the exponential decay of radioactivity. Here N O is the n u m b e r of radioactive atoms p r e s e n t at zero time, )~ is the decay constant, and N is the n u m b e r r e m a i n i n g at a subsequent time: N = N o r ~t
(1.3)
The average life expectancy (x) of any radioactive species can be calculated from the first m o m e n t of the probability, e -xt, t h a t the nucleus will survive the time, t, and is given by: 1 t =-
(1.4)
Radioactive decay r a t e s are normally t a b u l a t e d in t e r m s of half-life, t 1/2 r a t h e r t h a n decay constant, where t l/2 is the time required for the activity of a given nuclear species or nuclide to decrease to h a l f of its original value. By substituting the half-life t 152 for t in Eq. (1.3), =
In 2 tm
(1.5)
Hence, if the n u m b e r of half-lives, h = t/t 1/2, N = N02 -h
(1.6)
This is a convenient method to calculate decay in terms of powers of 2. The half-life is specific to each radionuclide. Thus, a curie (37 GBq) of tritium w i t h a half-life of 12.6 years would decay to h a l f t h a t value in 12.6 years, w h e r e a s a curie of carbon-14 (14C) would require 5700 years to decrease to onehalf its value. TABLE 1.3 Confidence level as a function of standard deviation Deviation (units of s ) 0
Confidence level (%) 0 68
2a 3a
95 99
Radioactivity Basics
Statistics of counting The equation of radioactive decay can be derived from simple probability theory since the time of decay for any single atom is unpredictable. For a given nuclide, the chance of a decay occurring in a given time is described by the binomial distribution. This is a distribution t h a t for most nuclear counting can be approximated by the simpler Poisson distribution, an approximation of the binomial distribution characterized by a low probability of success. It assumes a relatively large n u m b e r of active atoms, which are counted for a time which is short compared to their half-life. This is the usual situation for most counting experiments. If p(m) is the probability of collecting m events, when M is the m e a n n u m b e r expected, then the Poisson distribution is given by: Mm p(m) = ~ e -M
(1.7)
It can be shown t h a t this is a single p a r a m e t e r distribution: i.e., a single value, m, provides both an estimate of the mean, M, and of the predicted variance, ~2. Thus M is equal to m, with a standard deviation given by ~ = ~]m. If, for example, we record 100 disintegrations, this is a good estimate of the "true" (expected) value, with a standard deviation of ~] 100 = 10. For more t h a n about 20 events, the Poisson distribution can be replaced by the normal (Gaussian) distribution. This is the standard, symmetrical, bell-shaped curve. For this distribution there is a 68 percent confidence level t h a t the m e a s u r e d count will not differ from the "true count" by more t h a n one s t a n d a r d deviation, ~. The confidence level for other values of ~ is given in Table 1.3 above. It is important to remember t h a t the single p a r a m e t e r of the Poisson distribution still holds here although it is not generally true for Gaussian distributions. Most oilfield tracer data are reported in terms of a confidence level. STATISTICS OF COUNTING ZERO, SIGNAL VS. NOISE We do not live in a radiation-free environment. As will be discussed later in this chapter, there are m a n y naturally occurring and m a n m a d e sources of radiation. As a result, when radioactive material is m e a s u r e d by a counter, the total n u m b e r , Nt, of radioactive atoms counted includes a b a c k g r o u n d component, Nb, due to radiation from the environment. This b a c k g r o u n d radioactivity must be subtracted from the measured activity in order to arrive at a true value. Since radioactivity is a statistical, fluctuating phenomenon, it is important in most applications to have a criterion for knowing when there is a significant a m o u n t of radioactivity present in a sample in the presence of a radioactive background. If Nt r e p r e s e n t s the total n u m b e r of radioactive events counted and Nb represents the background count, then the net count, Nn, is given by:
6
Nn = N t - Nb
Chapter I
(1.8)
The variance of either the sum or the difference of two statistically random quantities is equal to the sum of the variances. Since the variance, ~2(N) = N, the standard deviation ~(Nn), of Nn is given by: ~(Nt + Nb) = ~] ~2(Nt ) + ~2(Nb)= ~]Nt + Nb
(1.9)
As the number of radioactive atoms being counted approaches zero, Nt approaches Nb, and in the limit, the error in determining zero is proportional to the square root of the background. For a 95 percent confidence level, this is given by 2g: 2(~N(0) = 2~]2NB
(1.10)
Since radioactivity is measured as a counting rate, R = N/t, where N is the number of events per unit time t, the error of determining zero count rate is given by: 2~R(0) = ~]2RB
(1.11)
where R B is the background counting rate. This is an important number since, all other things being equal, it is a measure of the lowest detectable activity in a given counter and is the noise level that the counting signal must overcome. Other factors affecting this number will be discussed as they arise in chapters 1 and 2.
Sequential radioactive decay In any mixture of unrelated radioactive materials, the total activity is the sum of the individual activities. This total activity decreases as each of the separate activities decays exponentially according to its own half-life, and there are no special relationships between them. In a sequential decay, however, decay of a radioactive isotope results in the formation of a second radioactive isotope rather than a stable isotope. Thus, if N 1 is the (original) parent isotope, then N2 is the number of atoms of the daughter isotope produced by decay of the parent N 1. The rate of formation of N2 by decay of its parent is equal to NI~I. The rate of loss of N2 by its own decay rate is N2~2; hence the net rate of growth of N2 is given by the difference, as shown in Eq. (1.12). dN2 = ~,IN1- ~2N2 dt
(1.12)
Radioactivity Basics
This is a linear, first-order differential equation. The solution is demonstrated in many textbooks on radioactivity and is given below, where N(0)2 refers to the amount (if any) of N2 present initially: ~ NI[e-A1 t _ e-;t2 t ]+ N(0)2 e-;t2t N2 = ~2_~ 1
(1.13)
This can also be expressed in terms of half-lives, letting Ti represent the halflife of species i and h = t ~ i , the number of half-lives elapsed, as follows: T1 N112 -hi - 2 -h2 ]+ N(0)2 -h2 N2 = T 2 - T'-------~
(1.14)
Radioactive equilibrium When the parent half-life is shorter than that of the daughter, there can be no equilibrium. The parent simply decays away, leaving only the daughter activity. If the parent half-life is longer than the daughter half-life, the two will ultimately reach an equilibrium wherein the exponential portion becomes negligible. At radioactive equilibrium, then, Eq. (1.13) reduces to: N2 = ~ N 1 ~2 -~,1
(1.15)
This is called transient equilibrium. Here both parent and daughter decay with the half-life of the parent. The growth and decay of the daughter as the parent decays is shown in Fig. 1.1 (Lieser, 1986). It should be noted that the total activity is always the sum of both activities. If the daughter activity is separated from the parent, it will decay at its own decay rate as shown. The rate at which new daughter activity grows in and reaches equilibrium with the parent is given by the exponential factor [ 2-hl - 2 - h 2 ] of Eq. (1.14). The total activity is sum of the two activities. When the parent half-life is so much longer than its daughter's that it does not show decay through many daughter half-lives, the decay of the parent can be ignored. This is a limiting case of the transient equilibrium described above, known as secular equilibrium, shown in Fig. 1.2 (Lieser, 1986). Since k 1 is negligible compared to k2, Eq. (1.13) simplifies to: ~'IN (1- e "~'2t N2= ~22 1 )
(1.16/
For a time, t, that is long compared to daughter half-life ~2, this reduces to: N2 = ~; N1 ~2
hence A1 = A2
(1.17)
8
Chapter i
The growth of the daughter activity is derived from Eq. (1.12) and given by the expression: N2=~22~1N I ( I _ e-k2t ) (1.18)
Total activity = A + A 1 2 io + .....
/
"~ <
3
Decay of separated daughter
i
10,
,021[ 0
Daughter A 2 growing in
parent A 1
Time in half-lives
Figure 1.1. Transient equilibrium The rate of growth of the activity is given by (1 - e-~2t). This factor plays an important role in many nuclear reactions of interest in the oil field. It is also known as the saturation factor. In these equilibria, if the daughter is separated from the parent, it immediately begins to decay at its own half-life, T2, as shown in the figures. A new daughter then begins to grow in from the parent activity and continues until equilibrium is reestablished. The formation of daughter activities is not limited to a single generation but may go on for many generations of radioactivity (Bateman, 1910). Principal examples of a long sequence of radioactive generations are the uranium and thorium series. The uranium series is illustrated in Fig. 1.17. The gamma emission from these naturally occurring radioactive series (plus potassium) is the major source of gamma radiation in the wellbore. The two kinds of radioactive equilibria described above are important in accounting for the naturally occurring radioactive chains. They have an additional importance in the development of isotope generators described in a later chapter.
Radioactivity Basics
Total activity = A 1+ A 2 @ _
.
.
.
.
4
/
nt activity, A 1
'~ 103t ~, ~
Decay of
Daughter activity, A 2 growth 2 10-
,
~
,
~separated ~ daughter '~
,
,
,
,
,
Time in half-lives
Figure 1.2. Secular equilibrium
N u c l e a r decay processes We described the nucleus in terms of neutrons and protons. The proton has a mass of about one atomic unit and carries a positive charge. Outside the nuclear environment, the proton exists as a stable e n t i t y - the hydrogen ion. The neutron also has a mass of one unit but carries no charge. It can also exist outside of the nucleus but it is u n s t a b l e with respect to decay and m a y react w i t h other nuclei in the neighborhood. In a v a c u u m it decays w i t h a half-life of about 11 m i n u t e s to a proton plus an electron. An electron emitted from a nucleus is called a beta particle. It carries a negative charge and has no significant mass. By i n t e r n a t i o n a l convention, nuclear reactions are always w r i t t e n w i t h the mass (N + P) of each species at the top left and the charge carried at the bottom left of the e l e m e n t symbol. In writing the equation for a n u c l e a r reaction, the total charge on each side of the equation m u s t balance, as m u s t the total mass on each side of the equation. This is shown in the equation for n e u t r o n decay below, w h e r e a n e u t r o n with zero charge and mass of 1 decays to a proton h a v i n g a mass of 1 and a charge of +1, plus a ~ particle whose mass is zero and charge is
10
Chapter i
-1. In nuclear reactions the neutron is written as n to avoid confusion with N, the symbol for nitrogen:
1 On - - >
o p+_113
The decay of radioactive nuclei can take place by several mechanisms t h a t m a y not be m u t u a l l y exclusive. In the oil industry we are normally concerned with only two of these, beta decay and alpha decay. An additional decay path of interest is spontaneous fission, which is the only practical decay path resulting in neutron emission. BETA DECAY The three processes classified under beta decay are beta particle emission, positron emission, and electron capture. Beta particle emission This is the conventional emission of a negative beta particle. Negative beta particle (-~) decay of the radioactive nucleus results in a new nucleus with essentially the same mass but with an increase of one in atomic number. For example, carbon-14 decays by beta emission with a half-life of 5700 years. In the process the atomic number is increased by one, hence carbon-14 is t r a n s m u t e d to nitrogen-14. As shown below, the masses on both sides of the equation add up to 14 and the charges add up to 6 on each side.
14o .14
+
Positron emission This is the emission of an anti-electron (+~). An antiparticle is associated with most of the subnuclear particles. The antiparticles have most of the same properties as their coparticles but have an opposite charge or other opposite nuclear property. While antiparticles include both antiprotons and antineutrons, the only one of significance to oilfield tracer work is the antielectron, which has a positive charge and is called a positron. Positron emission is a common form of beta decay. Particles and antiparticles cannot coexist. They annihilate each other when they come in contact and are converted to a penetrating form of radiation called annihilation radiation. The annihilation of a positron with an electron results in the formation of two g a m m a rays, emitted 180 ~ apart. Each g a m m a ray has the mass-equivalent energy of an electron or 0.51 MeV, as shown in Table 1.1, and illustrated in Fig. 1.3. The elimination of a positron from a nucleus because of radioactive decay requires the same kind of charge balance as electron decay, except t h a t it is
11
Radioactivity Basics
opposite in sign. This results in the formation of a new element having the same mass but with a decrease of one in atomic number. Thus 22Na decays by positron emission with a half-life of 2.26 years. The 22Na being t r a n s m u t e d to 22Ne: 22 22 0 11Na --> lONe ++1
Electron capture (ec) The third form of beta decay is an alternative to positron emission and has the same effect on the charge balance. In electron capture, an inner orbital electron from the atom, usually a K or L electron, is captured by the nucleus. A proton is then converted to a neutron, resulting in a new nucleus having the same mass with a decrease of one unit in atomic number. It differs from positron emission in t h a t there is no annihilation radiation associated with it. Instead, monoenergetic X-rays characteristic of the captured orbital electron are generated from the extra nuclear part of the atom. 22Na decays principally by positron emission, but 10 percent of the nuclei decay instead to an excited state of 22Ne by electron capture: 22 0 22 11Na + -le --> 10Ne
T= 0.51 MeV o=
180
T= 0.51 MeV
Figure 1.3. Positron annihilation
ALPHA DECAY An alpha particle is identically a helium nucleus emitted from a radioactive nucleus. It has a mass of 4 atomic units and a charge of plus 2. It is the principal mode of decay for elements of atomic number greater than 82 and is involved in the natural occurrence of uranium and thorium chains in the ground. Alpha decay results in t r a n s m u t a t i o n of the radionuclide to a n e w e l e m e n t whose atomic n u m b e r is lower by 2 units and whose mass is lower by 4 mass units t h a n the original nucleus, as shown below.
12
Chapter I
234 4 238V --'Y Wh + 2He 92 90 This is the predominant decay path for all the naturally occurring radioactive series. The series of isotopes in secular equilibrium with the p a r e n t U-238 is illustrated in Fig. 1.17, shown later in this chapter. In this figure of atomic number vs. atomic mass, alpha decay moves the atomic number down 2 units and decreases the atomic mass by 4 units as shown by the arrow. G A M M A RAY EMISSION
G a m m a radiation (and internal transition) normally occurs as a m e a n s of deexcitation of an activated nuclear state induced by beta or alpha decay. It is not a primary m o d e of decay and usually shares the half-life of the particle decay mode, although in some case the activated state m a y have an extended half-life.
De-excitation by gamma emission In the course of the alpha and beta decay processes indicated above, new elements are formed, most of which are left in an excited (nuclear) state. Usually these excited states decay to the ground state almost instantly (with less t h a n a picosecond's delay) with the emission of penetrating electromagnetic radiation called g a m m a rays. There may even be several excited states, each resulting in its own g a m m a ray emission. Occasionally there is a significant half-life of decay from the excited state due to a forbidden transition. Such excited states are called isomers and are designated by the symbol (m) following the mass number, e.g., 137mBa. They have the same mass and atomic n u m b e r but a different half-life from the associated beta or alpha decay.
De-excitation by internal transition (it) In this alternative to de-excitation by g a m m a emission for some excited states, the excess nuclear energy is transferred directly to an orbital electron, which is emitted from the atom as a free electron. This results in a monoenergetic electron with the characteristic energy of the transition less the binding energy of the electron. It is accompanied by x-radiation emitted by the atom as these electron shells are filled up. G a m m a radiation differs from X-radiation only in that it is emitted from the nucleus r a t h e r t h a n from interactions with the extranuclear electrons. G a m m a radiation is more energetic as well, although there is a small region of energy where the rays overlap. X-rays usually range from 100 eV to about 100 keV, whereas gamma radiation ranges from about 10 keV to 100 MeV. NEUTRON
SOURCES
Neutrons are not emitted as a means of de-excitation byany of the radioisotopes having a practical half-life. They are generated as a byproduct in
Radioactivity Basics
13
nuclear fission reactions, by nuclear interactions with charged particles, and by nuclear interactions with gamma rays.
Fission Fission is a procedure whereby the nucleus breaks up into two large fragments, which break down further into smaller nuclides by various decay processes (mostly beta decay) and the emission of neutrons. Associated with fission and the subsequent processes is the release of a large amount of energy. M a n y of the t r a n s u r a n i c elements are subject to spontaneous fission as a means of de-excitation. 252Cf is the only practical neutron source of this type. It is a transuranic element t h a t decays primarily by alpha decay with a half-life of 2.65 years. Approximately 3.1 percent of the 252Cf decays by spontaneous fission accompanied by the emission of neutrons. This very compact portable source of neutrons produces about 2.3 x 106 neutrons/second/~gm of californium. Fission of u r a n i u m and plutonium isotopes in nuclear reactors is the largest source of available neutrons. In these reactions a controlled chain reaction maintains an excess of neutrons in the reactor. Most available reactors are small research reactors, m a n y of the swimming pool type. These are not portable in any sense of the word but do constitute a commercial source for m a n y radioactive isotopes and are used for activation analyses. They offer neutron fluxes in the order of 1012 to 1015 neutrons/second/cm 2.
Beryllium alpha reactions Most a particles lose energy by reaction with the atomic electrons, however a small fraction of the alphas overcome the nuclear barriers to react with a target nucleus, providing one of the means of making portable neutron generators. Such sources are generally referred to as chemical neutron sources. In particular, the reaction of alpha particles with beryllium is a useful method for g e n e r a t i n g neutrons by the following reaction: 9 12 1 He + 4Be --~ 6 C + oN + 5.71MeV The interaction of particles with a nucleus is normally written in an abbreviated form. For example, the above reaction can be expressed as 9Be(a,n)12C. The first symbol, 9Be, represents the target material; the photon or particle reaction is indicated by the parenthesis, (a,n), where an alpha particle enters the t a r g e t nucleus and a neutron leaves it; the last symbol shows the conversion product of the t a r g e t material 12C. The energy of the reaction is 5.71 MeV. A n u m b e r of such sources are in use in the petroleum industry for downhole neutron generation. Several t r a n s u r a n i c alpha sources are used for this purpose. 239Pu, 238Pu, and 241Am are widely used, under the acronyms PUBE and AMBE. The probability of alpha interaction with the Be is maximized by using an alloy of the transuranic element with beryllium.
14
Chapter i
Particle accelerators A second nuclear interaction for generating neutrons is the 3H(2H,n)4He reaction. This is often written as T(D,n)a, where D stands for deuterium and T for tritium, and represents the reaction: 2 H + 3 H --~ 4He + n For the reaction to take place, the deuterium need only be accelerated to an energy of 100 to 300 keV. This can be done using a relatively simple static generator, which can be small enough to go down hole in an oil well. The reaction, which produces 14 MeV neutrons, has a great advantage over chemical neutron sources in t h a t it can be pulsed and turned on and off at will. It has become a major tool for use in borehole logging.
Other neutron-forming reactions In addition to the reactions indicated above, a variety of other (a,n) and (7,n) "chemical" neutron sources have been developed; however the ones discussed earlier are most common. These are portable sources that may be used in the laboratory, taken to the field or even in many cases used down hole. Neutrons are i m p o r t a n t in direct and indirect tracer applications because of their ability to undergo reactions with m a n y materials of interest in the oil field. C h a r a c t e r i s t i c energy The emission of radiation from the nucleus is always associated with a discrete energy, Q, which is characteristic of the nuclear transition. The alpha particles emitted from the nucleus, as well as the g a m m a rays emitted from the subsequent excited nuclei, are emitted with a characteristic energy, Q. Beta particles (both negative and positive) appear to be exceptions, showing instead a continuous spectrum of energies. A plot of beta energy versus the n u m b e r of beta particles having t h a t energy for a given nuclide extends from zero energy to a maximum energy Emax. A typical beta spectrum is shown in Fig. 1.4. This continuous energy spectrum is due to the simultaneous emission of a neutrino with each beta. The characteristic energy is shared between the two. Neutrinos, having no charge and virtually n o mass, are measurable only with great difficulty. As a result we obtain only the beta part of the spectrum. The characteristic energy of the emitted beta particle is, however, given by the maxim u m energy, Emax, of the spectrum. This energy is tabulated as the beta energy for a given isotope. The average energy of the beta emission is about 1/3 of the m a x i m u m energy. As illustrated for tritium in the figure above, the m a x i m u m energy is 18 keV and the mean energy, Eave, is 6 keV. The only radioactive sources of monoenergetic electrons are those emitted by isotopes undergoing internal transition. Positrons have a similar type of spectrum, except t h a t after m a n y collisions they undergo annihilation.
15
Radioactivity Basics
m
0.8 0.6
N(E)
Emax
0.4 0.2 0
0
3
6
9
12
15
18
Energy, keV
Figure 1.4. Tritium beta energy spectrum DECAY SCHEMES The decay schemes for all of the normally available isotopes are published in m a n y compendia, which present the information in different ways. References to some of these compilations are given at the end of this chapter. One kind is a tabular listing of each isotope, giving pertinent properties such as half-life, mode of decay and all the emitted radiation. Another shows detailed two-dimensional decay schemes. A collection of such (simplified) beta decay schemes for some common tracer materials is shown in Fig. 1.5. Beta decay is often accompanied by g a m m a radiation from the produced isotope, each g a m m a ray having a characteristic energy. Thus, from Fig. 1.5, cobalt60 undergoes negative beta decay to an excited state of (stable) Ni-60. The cobalt60 emits two g a m m a rays in cascade; one g a m m a ray of 1.173 MeV in going to a lower excited state, and a second g a m m a ray of 1.332 MeV in going from this excited state to the ground state. A total of two gamma rays are emitted with each beta particle. The decay schemes in the figure illustrate m a n y of the reactions discussed earlier. Nuclear structures can be quite complex, and different decay processes may go on simultaneously. Naturally occurring K-40 shown in this figure undergoes two such decay processes, each with its own decay probability, leading to different decay products. In addition, there are periodic charts t h a t show all of the isotopes in a twodimensional a r r a y where the number of protons, Z, per nuclide is plotted against the n u m b e r of neutrons, N = A-Z. A roughly 45-degree line drawn through the such charts passes t h r o u g h the stable isotopes. Nuclides with an excess of neutrons with respect to this line decay by beta (-) decay; those with an excess of protons decay by electron capture or positron decay, as shown in Fig. 1.6. These
16
Chapter I
are large wall charts t h a t are not easy to reproduce in this space. The nuclear properties of each isotope are shown within its designated square in the chart. This includes the decay modes, half-lives, and radiation emitted for the radionuclides, and other nuclear properties for the stable isotopes. A small section of such a chart is shown in Fig. 1.7. The chart makes it easy to see the effect of a variety of nuclear interactions with a given isotope. The probability of any given reaction is a function of the energy of the incident particle or ray. Most nuclear interactions of positively charged particles, fast neutrons, and g a m m a rays have energy thresholds below which no reaction takes place. A typical view for the products from nuclear reactions with a given isotope is shown in Fig. 1.8. The likelihood of each reaction depends upon its specific probability at the energy of the incident particle.
6000 T = 5.26 years
5700 T = 270 days 27
27
.
~
0.136 MeV
2.505 MeV !
= 1.173 MeV ~,1.332 MeV y1 l 60Ni ~ 0 MeV y2
y2 = 1.332 MeV
(11%) 59Fe
137
C T = 5730 years
Cs T=27years
(6.5%)~ ~ ( 9 3 " 5 % )
~~
37mga T= 2.7 minutes 137ga ~ 0.662 MeV
0 MeV
1.406 MeV
4~
J~Y
$3 (9%)
4~
T = 1.26 x 109years
~'~' (11%)
40CaN-(89%)
Figure 1.5. Nuclear energy levels
Radioactivity Basics
17
100 8O
e.c, 13+
~ 60: 40 20 J
J
/
/.~_
J
J
~
J
20 4b 6b 8b 16o 12o 14o Neutrons
Figure 1.6. Nuclear chart showing nuclear stability line
C9 127 m s
C10
B8
B9
B10
Be8
Be9
-19 174 m s 10 s e c
4 3 He3
Be 6
Be 7
Cll
19.4 s 20.4 m
-21
-16 10 sec 53.3 d 10 s e c
Li 5
-21
Li 6
Li 7
He5
He6
840ms
10 sec
He 4
Li 8
-21
He7
lO see 805 ms short Z
H1
H2
H3
3
4
12.3 Y
1 N
2 v
Figure 1.7. Nuclear chart, partial display
5
18
Chapter I
a, 3n
2n
0~, n
P,T n, 2n He 3 n
a, np
T,R n, 2n
original nucleus
d,p n, T
t, np
T,np
T,P
n,p
p, n
n, cz
t, n
Hea, p
n, He 3
Figure 1.8. Nuclear reactions from chart
I N T E R A C T I O N S OF R A D I A T I O N WITH M A T T E R
The particles and radiation emitted during radioactive decay interact with the surrounding matter in many ways before they are absorbed. The reactions they undergo in the course of these interactions, including those leading to detection, are at the heart of the applications of such tracer materials to any problem.
Alpha particles and other positively charged ions Alpha particles are helium nuclei, ~He, which are emitted by radioactive decay with energies mostly in the range of 4 to 6 MeV. As they move through matter, they lose most of their energy by coulombic interaction with the intervening electrons. The travel path is very short and straight. A 6 MeV alpha particle has a range in air of about 4.5 centimeters. For most alpha emitters, particles not at the surface are absorbed in the emitter. A small fraction of the alpha particles can react with the nucleus in the (a,n) reaction described earlier. At a high enough energy, many positive ions become capable of reacting with nuclei directly. The ions are raised to high energy by accelerators designed for this purpose. Protons, in particular, are accelerated to high energies in cyclotrons
Radioactivity Basics
19
and other machines, where they are a source of radioactive species not otherwise available.
Beta particles and positrons Negative and positive (positron) beta particles from any source are emitted with a range of energies from zero to the characteristic (maximum) energy for the transition. They are absorbed in matter by two processes. Most of the beta energy is lost in collisions with atomic electrons proportionally to the atomic number of the intervening matter. The path is tortuous: only a small part of the energy is lost at each collision, leaving ion pairs in its wake. A significant part of the beta emission is reflected back to the origin. The transmission of beta particles in passing through matter shows an exponential decline: N = Noe-~x
(1.19)
where N and No refer to the transmitted and original numbers of beta particles, ~t is a constant and x is the thickness of the material. Positrons, in addition, undergo the annihilation reaction near the end of their paths with the emission of two 0.51 MeV g a m m a rays. The annihilation of positrons is a major source of g a m m a radiation from positron emitters. The gammas, which are emitted 180 degrees apart, are also coincident in time. This property can be used either to differentiate such emitters from other gamma emitters or as a means of collimating unscattered radiation. A small fraction of the emitted beta energy loses energy by radiation. When a beta particle comes close to the nucleus of an atom, it is accelerated by the electric field and emits a type of X-radiation known as brehmsstralung. The ratio of energy loss by radiation (Lr) to energy loss by ionization (Li) is given by:
Lr ZE L i - 750
(1.20)
where Z is the atomic number of the intervening m a t t e r and E is the characteristic (maximum) beta energy. B r e h m s s t r a l u n g is a significant factor only for high energy betas in high atomic n u m b e r absorbers, but it is always present when betas are absorbed. It has been used as a means of monitoring the activity of very large sources of low energy beta emitters such as tritium and carbon-14. The energy of brehmsstralung from carbon-14 is sufficient to allow field monitoring for the large sources used for interwell tracers if the container walls are not too thick.
Gamma radiation (and x-rays) G a m m a and x-radiation are absorbed through a number of interactions with a b s o r b e r atoms, only three of which are normally i m p o r t a n t . These are photoelectric absorption, Compton scattering, and pair production. Photoelectric
20
Chapter 1
absorption is a reaction of the g a m m a ray with the atoms of the absorber; Compton scattering is a reaction with the individual electrons; and pair production is an interaction with the electric field of the nucleus. Most tracer work in the oil field can also neglect pair production. G a m m a ray interactions with the nucleus are also possible and have been used for m a k i n g n e u t r o n sources but are not important to this discussion The different kinds of interactions described below affect the way gamma radiation is used, monitored and shielded.
t'E~--I~- E'O~ Compton Scattering
1' ~---~ 0 E~
e"
Photoelectric Absorption
Figure 1.9. Gamma ray interactions PHOTOELECTRIC ABSORPTION (1;) Here all the captured g a m m a energy is transferred to an orbital electron of the absorber atom, which is then ejected with the characteristic energy of the g a m m a photon, less the electron binding energy, BE, as shown in Fig. 1.9. For most g a m m a radiation, the electron binding energy is negligible. Photoelectric absorption is most important for low gamma energies and in high atomic number absorbers. The probability, ~, of this interaction's occurring is roughly proportional to the fifth power of the atomic number and inversely proportional to 3.5 power of the energy, as shown in Eq. (1.21), where k is a constant, Z is the atomic number, and E is the energy. kZ5 I;= E3.5
(1.21)
This reaction leads to the complete absorption of the g a m m a ray and is used in g a m m a ray spectroscopy to identify its energy level. The sensitivity of the photoelectric effect to atomic number makes it a useful analytical tool for qualitative analysis in the field and in the laboratory. It is most effective at low g a m m a ray energies and is useful for monitoring fluid density in the borehole and in pipes. COMPTON SCATTERING (~) In this process (Fig. 1.9), the g a m m a photons interact with the individual electrons of the absorber. Here, part of the energy of the photon is transferred to an electron, and the photon is deflected from its original path minus the energy
Radioactivity Basics
21
lost to the electron. In this process, Eo is the energy of the incident g a m m a ray, E' the energy of the deflected gamma ray, and ~ the scattering angle. The energy lost per impact depends upon the angle of incidence and leads to a continuous energy spectrum. The direction and energy of the deflected gamma photon is given by the Klein-Nishima equation, which relates the energy of the incident g a m m a ray to the scattering angle and the energy of the scattered g a m m a ray. The m a x i m u m energy loss occurs in a 180-degree collision, whereas the m i n i m u m energy loss is at a grazing collision where ~ approaches zero. Fig. 1.10 shows a distribution of scattered electrons from the interaction with gamma rays of energy E ~ The sharp line at the beginning of the Compton distribution is known as the Compton edge. This distribution is important in monitoring g a m m a radiation and will be discussed further in chapter 2. The probability (g) of Compton scattering changes slowly with energy and is effective over most of the energies of interest for oilfield work. Absorption is the ultimate fate of Compton-scattered photons. The attenuation of gamma radiation by Compton scattering is proportional to the density of the intervening material, and Compton scattering is frequently used for measuring the density of materials. Compton backscatter is used to monitor formation density in downhole logging with gamma sources.
f
io
Photo peak
~
dN
!
Energy (MeV)
Figure 1.10. Distribution of Compton-scattered electrons PAIR PRODUCTION (~) This process is important only for high-energy g a m m a radiation. In oilfield tracer work, this occurs mostly with g a m m a radiation resulting from neutron interactions near the wellbore Here, a g a m m a photon is converted into an electron-positron pair in the electric field of the nucleus. This cannot occur unless the energy exceeds 1.02 MeV, the energy equivalent to the two masses of the
22
Chapter I
electron pair (0.51 MeV). It is accompanied by the annihilation of the positron. This interaction probability is given by K: Gamma ray attenuation
The overall probability of attenuation of gamma or x-radiation is equal to the total attenuation coefficient, ~, which is the sum of the three processes discussed under g a m m a radiation above. ~t = I: + (~ + K:
(1.22)
The attenuation coefficient, ~, of a molecule is the sum of its atomic absorption coefficients. A mixture of compounds has the attenuation coefficient of the sum of the fractions each contributes. The attenuation of radiation in m a t t e r is a function both of the material and of the energy of the incident radiation. This is illustrated in Fig. 1.11 (White, 1952), which shows the a t t e n u a t i o n of g a m m a radiation in lead. In particular, because of the high atomic n u m b e r of lead, the photoelectric effect is dominant over a wide range of energies. Since this leads to the complete absorption of the g a m m a ray, the importance of high atomic n u m b e r materials as a shield for low energy radiation becomes obvious from this figure. The sharp breaks in the photoelectric attenuation curve are due to energy resonances associated with the K and L electron orbits. The loss of radiation is expressed here in terms of the m a s s a t t e n u a t i o n coefficient, the usual way in which g a m m a ray absorption is tabulated and a subject for further discussion later in this chapter. The relative importance of the three coefficients as a function of energy and atomic n u m b e r is shown more broadly in Fig. 1.12 (Evans, 1986). The three regions are separated by lines of equal coefficients: on the left is the line of ~ = ~, where the photoelectric and Compton coefficients are equal, and on the right, the line of ~ = ~, where the probability of a Compton effect equals t h a t for pair production. The average atomic number of formation materials is about 20. From this figure it is obvious t h a t for borehole work, Compton scattering is the predominant interaction between energies lying between 100 keV and 10 MeV. Most g a m m a rays will therefore undergo many Compton interactions in passing through matter. The ratio of Compton to photoelectric interactions can be used as an indicator of the thickness of material intersected by the g a m m a ray. For borehole fluids where atomic numbers are below 20, the photoelectric effect becomes more important. The g a m m a energies of most tracers in oilfield use lie below 4.0 MeV, hence for tracer experiments where m e a s u r e m e n t s are made in a field environment, such as near the borehole or a separation facility, Compton scattering is a major mechanism of gamma-ray attenuation.
23
Radioactivity Basics
200 100
E
10
I[
"
I " I
i I rilll'
i
i
I'! i I if|
"l
~
i i 1 ~'i!
-
L
-
E L~ .m 0
1.0
:$::
o 0 C 0
0.1
E (D
-Compton ",____\ ~,~___Total Attenuation scattering . \\.,, coefficient
-
:
:
~" "~-'.-....... -.7.--'...... . photoelectric
{D
,..:'"'
.01 P
.001 .01
\\.\
-x,,..... .......
_
_ ~.-~
Pair produc I
! I ILIlI|
0.1
i
1 Illltll
1.0
[
I
l
I I|NI~II
10
1
L
I
lllLt
100
Energy (MeV)
Figure 1.11. Gamma ray absorption in lead COLLIMATED BEAMS AND SOURCE GEOMETRY If a narrow beam of g a m m a rays of intensity Io passes through an absorber, a g a m m a detector in the path will observe only those g a m m a photons that have not been absorbed or scattered from the path, much as in the optical equivalent in Beer's law. Since the probability of reacting with a g a m m a photon is given by p, the attenuation of the beam follows an exponential decline in intensity with distance through an absorber and is given by: I = Ioe-~x
(1.23)
24
Chapter I
where I and Io refer to the final and original gamma ray intensities, respectively, x is the absorber thickness, and ~ is the linear attenuation coefficient. The mean free path of a gamma ray in any absorbing medium is obtained by analogy with the mean residence time from the first moment and is given by: = 1
(1.24)
_
I
I I IIIIII
I
I
I Iii1|1
I
t
I IIIIII
I
I
t III1:1
120 L.
0
~ 0 N
11111
-
8o 6o 40
-
_
~ Pair ~ production
j /
-
_-
J
Photoelectric . effect / ('~) / 1,
.
~
6~ /
/ ~1 -I "
C~176 ~II~7, effect ~ k
-
20
o O.Ol
,,,,,,,,
0.05 0.1
0.5
1
Energy in MeV
5
10
50
100
Figure 1.12. Relative importance of the three different gamma ray interactions For most materials and gamma-ray energies of interest, the primary mechanism of g a m m a ray attenuation is Compton scattering. The Compton-scattering coefficient is a function only of the material density, p, for those elements whose ratio of atomic number to atomic weight is about 1/2, true for most elements, and is usually tabulated in terms of the mass attenuation coefficient, expressed as ~/p, in units of cm 2 per gram. This has the advantage that the coefficient becomes independent of the kind of material in the absorber and is dependent only upon material density. I = Ioe-(WP)(P)t
(1.25)
The relationship between the linear and mass coefficients, ~] and I&n, respectively, is given by: ~m (m2/kg) = ~l ( m ' l ) p (kg/m 3 )
(1.26)
25
Radioactivity Basics
It should be noted t h a t the attenuation described above is true only for the narrow beam case, where the path is linear and in which scattered radiation does not r e t u r n to the path. This is shown in Fig. 1.13, part A. In most of our dealings with g a m m a radiation, this is not the case. Radiation is not totally absorbed, but as shown in part B of Fig 1.13, much of it is scattered back into the path. An exception is the response of a detector that can differentiate scattered radiation by energy discrimination.
Broad Beam Geometry
Narrow Beam Geometry
Source
~I
1
II ~
I I~
Collimators
Detector
Source
Detector
"
Absorber A
Absorber B
Figure 1.13. Narrow and broad beam geometry A detector looking at an uncollimated point source of radiation will see more g a m m a radiation t h a n in the narrow beam case shown above due to scattering from the intervening matter, as shown in part B of Fig. 1.13. To correct for the additional radiation scattered back into the path, a correction factor called the dose build-up factor, B, is added. It is a function of incident energy, composition and thickness of absorber, and geometry, and is t a b u l a t e d in handbooks for simple geometries. The radiation from a point source is emitted isotropically and moves out in all directions in spherical geometry. As a result, it decreases in intensity by the inverse square of the distance, d, from source to detector. The radiation from a point source at a distance, d, from it is as given by Eq. (1.27)" I=
IoBe -~t d2
(1.27)
26
Chapter I
This is m o s t i m p o r t a n t for shielding calculations where it is necessary to reduce all t r a n s m i t t e d radiation. Since the scattered r a d i a t i o n m u s t be lower in energy t h a n the original beam, a detector t h a t can discriminate against the lower energy r a d i a t i o n has a build-up factor of one. For radiation sources t h a t are dist r i b u t e d over a volume of space and are not point sources, the situation is more complicated, since the r a d i a t i o n e m i t t e d at each point in the source volume is isotropic a n d acts independently. In general, the radiation received from such sources does not follow the inverse square law unless the distance from source to detector is large compared to the dimensions of the source. In most cases, the r a d i a t i o n will follow the exponential decline given by Eq. (1.19) if an experim e n t a l l y or numerically derived coefficient (Reis, 1992) is used to replace ~. DISTRIBUTED SOURCES AND DETECTORS In m a n y common situations we do not deal with point sources or narrow b e a m geometry. These are usually dealt with by complex tables of functions and buildup factors. The w i d e s p r e a d development of computers has, however, m a d e it possible to calculate the g a m m a - r a y response specific to the situation w i t h o u t the need for elaborate tables of build-up factors. The principal method used for doing this is the Monte Carlo procedure.
Monte Carlo procedure In this procedure, all of the interactions a specific g a m m a ray can undergo are calculated from the known probability coefficient for each interaction, the initial e n e r g y of the g a m m a ray, and the properties of the m e d i u m . E n o u g h r a y s are t r a c k e d until the geometry of the source is defined and the detector response is constant. This m a y t a k e several million rays, but for r e a s o n a b l y simple geometries, it can be accomplished on a modern personal computer (Reis and Idrees, 1992). A r a n d o m n u m b e r g e n e r a t o r is used to initiate a g a m m a r a y from a point inside the source in any direction. If the nuclide emits more t h a n one g a m m a photon, t h e n o r m a l i z e d probability for each emission is used to choose the g a m m a ray. Until it collides with an atom, the g a m m a ray continues along a p a t h whose l e n g t h is calculated from the g a m m a r a y energy, the k n o w n collision probability, the density, and the atomic n u m b e r of the medium. If the collision r e s u l t s in a photoelectric absorption, the r a y is t e r m i n a t e d a n d a new r a y is s t a r t e d . If it r e s u l t s in a Compton scatter, the energy a n d direction of the s c a t t e r e d g a m m a r a y is c a l c u l a t e d from t h e K l e i n - N i s h i m a e q u a t i o n . The s c a t t e r e d r a y is tracked until it reaches the detector or is absorbed a n d can no longer reach the detector. A d i s t r i b u t e d source in cylindrical g e o m e t r y is the rule in m a n y borehole applications. The m o s t common case is the m e a s u r e m e n t of n a t u r a l g a m m a r a d i a t i o n from the s u r r o u n d i n g formation by a detector suspended in the bore-
Radioactivity Basics
27
hole. Another occurs w h e n g a m m a radiation induced in the s u r r o u n d i n g formation by a downhole neutron source is monitored by a g a m m a detector in the s a m e tool. A similar situation also occurs in an observation well w h e n a g a m m a - t a g g e d w a t e r t r a c e r is logged by a tool suspended in the borehole as it passes the well. Cylindrical geometry also applies when the radioactive source is in the borehole and a detector on the s a m e tool monitors the effect of the s u r r o u n d i n g formation on the e m i t t e d radiation. The l a t t e r is used to m e a s u r e f o r m a t i o n properties, such as density by monitoring g a m m a - r a y backscatter. Here the source and detector are shielded from direct interaction, so t h a t the detector only sees r a d i a tion scattered into it from the formation.
1.0
•
~
v ....}
y .........,,oo,o,0oo keY
0.5
I/
Calculated for Unscattered 1.46 MeV gamma rays
]/ '
0--=
0
2'~
r(cm)
~'o
7's
Figure 1.14. Depth of g a m m a penetration in boreholes
External cylinder, distributed source by Monte Carlo calculations Monte Carlo calculations have been reported for the 1.46 MeV g a m m a r a y from 4~ for a detector in an 8-in. d i a m e t e r borehole s u r r o u n d e d by an infinite medium. This is illustrated in Fig. 1.14 (Wahl, 1983), which shows the i n t e g r a t e d signal (normalized) produced from coaxial cylinders of p o t a s s i u m - b e a r i n g rock around the borehole, plotted as a function of formation thickness in centimeters. For a bulk density of 2.5 gms/cc, 90 percent of the u n s c a t t e r e d g a m m a radiation comes from a 15-cm thick a n n u l u s around the wellbore. For m u l t i p l y s c a t t e r e d r a d i a t i o n , t h e t h i c k n e s s is i n c r e a s e d only a few c e n t i m e t e r s . The d e p t h of investigation of all neutron- and gamma-logging tools is limited by the m e a n free p a t h of the emitted radiation in the surrounding formation. Most of the response at the detector comes from a 20-cm, or smaller, radius about the wellbore.
28
Chapter I
External cylinder, distributed source, spherical approximation Cylindrical geometry is a common oilfield source distribution. Borehole geometry can be substituted adequately for m a n y approximations by spherical geometry. One such procedure is described here (Ellis, 1987). The equation for g a m m a ray attenuation is given as" N = No e-pc~
(1.28)
where co is the mass absorption coefficient, p is the bulk density, and x is thickness t r a v e r s e d by the g a m m a rays. The m e a n free path, ~, for the g a m m a radiation is given by Eq. (1.24) above. _
x-
1
cop
(1.29)
For the 1.46 MeV g a m m a ray of 4~ co = .05 cm2/gm. If the bulk density is t a k e n as 2.5 gms/cm 3, t h e n the m e a n free path, ~, is 8 cm. For u n s c a t t e r e d radiation, the total flux, ~, from a spherical shell to a point detector at radius R can be expressed in terms of: n
9 = ~ (1- e -1~)
(1.30)
For this equation, 90 percent of the total flux comes from a spherical shell surrounding the detector at a radius equal to 2.3 ~. For these conditions, this is about 18 centimeters, which is in reasonable agreement with the Monte Carlo calculation of 15 cm.
Internal cylinder, distributed source, external detector A common geometrical distribution of tracers in the field is for the tracers to be in an internal cylinder with the detector on the outside. This distribution occurs in monitoring tracer solutions in pipes and in the borehole and also in g a m m a density measurements In these m e a s u r e m e n t s , it is important to know how much of the emitted radiation is absorbed by the intervening liquid. This can be estimated from the simple exponential absorption equation adequately for most purposes. A common way to do this is by charts of the type shown in Fig. 1.15. Here, ~ is the linear absorption coefficient in cm -1, D is the diameter of the pipe in cm, and f is the fractional loss of radiation, i.e., t h a t fraction t h a t does not arrive at the inner wall of the pipe. If ~D < 0.14, there is no loss. If ~tD > 5, the source behaves like an infinitely thick slab, where f = 1/~D, as the response decreases linearly with distance. The region between these is important for estimating how much tracer is required to monitor g a m m a radiation when the source is uniformly distributed in pipes, gathering lines, and borehole fluid.
Radioactivity Basics
29
Infinite slab, f = 1/I~D
-\ 0.1
Q2
0.3
0.4 Q5 0 6
0.8 "
~D
2
3
4
5
Figure 1.15. Gamma radiation from pipes
Neutron reactions with matter
Neutrons carry no charge and therefore have no coulombic interactions with matter. They are subject to scattering but may travel a considerable distance through m a t t e r (centimeters) without collisions. Most neutron reactions are with the nucleus. The neutron may either be scattered from its p a t h or it m a y be absorbed by the target nucleus. Neutron reactions with m a t t e r can be energy dependent so t h a t neutrons are usually divided into fast and slow neutron reactions, depending upon how they are classified. A common division in well logging is to classify as fast neutrons those having energies from about 10 eV to 14 MeV; whereas those with energies between about 0.1 and 10 eV are classified as epithermal neutrons, and the distribution of neutrons about the mode (0.025 eV at room temperature) as thermal neutrons. All of these energy divisions are, however, arbitrary. Neutrons lose energy and are slowed, in passing through matter, by scattering collisions, both elastic and inelastic, and by reaction with a target nucleus. Elastic collisions involve only a transfer of kinetic energy between particles. Fast neutrons can also lose energy by inelastic collisions of the (n,n') type for incident n e u t r o n s above some threshold energy. Here, the n e u t r o n loses some of its energy by forming an excited state with the target nucleus, which immediately decays to a ground state(s) emitting lower-energy n e u t r o n s and g a m m a radiation. Both reactions result in neutrons of lower energy. Neutrons react with m a t t e r by forming an activated complex with the target nucleus. The most likely reaction is radiative capture (n,7), where the compound
30
Chapter 1
nucleus de-excites by e m i t t i n g g a m m a radiation. An alternative de-excitation is by emission of a charged particle such as a beta, alpha, proton, or other particle. The probability of a n y given interaction's t a k i n g place is expressed by its cross section (~) in units of barns. One b a r n is 10 -24 cm 2. Each kind of n e u t r o n interaction has a cross section t h a t m a y be a function of the n e u t r o n energy. The total cross section for energy loss is the sum of all the interaction cross sections. ELASTIC COLLISIONS (MODERATING) Most n e u t r o n s are first slowed by elastic collisions of the billiard ball type. The n e u t r o n s lose kinetic energy by transfer to a t a r g e t nucleus at each collision as t h e y slow down. The actual a m o u n t of energy lost per collision depends upon t h e m a s s of the t a r g e t nuclei and the angle of incidence of the neutron. The m a x i m u m energy t r a n s f e r for a direct hit (180 ~ collision) is given by:
E2:E1{1(I:A)4A}2
(1.31)
w h e r e Ei is the initial neutron energy, Ef is the final neutron energy and A is the m a s s of the t a r g e t nucleus. It can be seen t h a t the m a x i m u m energy t r a n s f e r occurs w i t h a proton (hydrogen) t a r g e t w h e r e A = 1. The energy t r a n s f e r per collision decreases with increasing atomic weight. As a consequence of the s c a t t e r i n g reactions, a collection of n e u t r o n s in m a t t e r h a s a distribution of velocities m u c h like t h a t of a gas w i t h a MaxwellB o l t z m a n distribution of energies. The n e u t r o n s diffuse in all directions, ultim a t e l y forming a cloud of t h e r m a l neutrons. In this case the n e u t r o n flux becomes a function of position and energy. The principles of n e u t r o n diffusion have been well worked out in reactor theory and are detailed in a n u m b e r of texts. NEUTRON ABSORPTION The u l t i m a t e fate of the slowed n e u t r o n is capture by a nucleus to form an activated compound nucleus t h a t usually deactivates by the emission of g a m m a rays by m e a n s of the (n,7) reaction. Other reactions can lead to charged particles which are accompanied by g a m m a emission.
Thermal capture The cross section for a nuclear reaction as a function of the energy of the incident r a d i a t i o n is known as its excitation function. The cross section for the (n,7) reaction with a t a r g e t nucleus is inversely proportional to the n e u t r o n energy, v. The increase in cross section, ~, with decreasing n e u t r o n energy, v, is roughly proportional to l/v, and is known as the one-over-v rule. This relationship holds for n e u t r o n energies from a few h u n d r e d to less t h a n 0.01 eV, and is i l l u s t r a t e d for a silver t a r g e t in Fig. 1.16 (Lieser, 1986). Eventually all t h e r m a l neutrons are
Radioactivity Basics
31
captured by t a r g e t nuclei; however, as shown in the figure, resonance peaks of high cross section are found at higher energies, especially in the region above one electron volt. These resonances correspond to energy states in the nucleus; they differ for different target isotopes and can be used for analytical purposes. Cross sections for t h e r m a l neutron capture can exceed t h a t predicted from the 1/v rule, and for some nuclides can exceed 104 barns.
4
10
lo3. c~
0
c3 ~o .01
0.1
1
10
100
Energy, eV
Figure 1.16. Neutron cross section vs. energy for silver The process of slowing down or moderating neutron energies continues until the n e u t r o n s are at t h e r m a l energies. At room t e m p e r a t u r e , the most probable value is 0.025 eV. The energy in electron volts can be expressed in t e r m s of a velocity using the equation for kinetic energy, and the n e u t r o n velocity, v, at a known energy. 1
E = ~ Mv2
(1.32)
The velocity of n e u t r o n s at t h e r m a l energy (E is 0.025 eV) is 2200 m/sec, hence for any neutron energy in eV, the neutron velocity is given by: v=
= 2200 0.025
(1.33)
32
Chapter 1
The lifetime of neutrons under borehole conditions is in the order of milliseconds. The usual product of the reaction is a compound nucleus, which de-excites immediately with the emission of characteristic g a m m a radiation. The g a m m a radiation emitted in the capture reaction is called capture g a m m a emission. Some of the compound nuclei de-excite by emission of a beta (or other) particle, leading to beta decay, which is often associated with delayed g a m m a emission. The reaction probabilities are governed by the surrounding isotopic species, their cross sections, and the neutron energy. The interaction of neutrons with m a t t e r by emitting "capture gammas" as well as by delayed g a m m a emission is at the h e a r t of m a n y of the downhole neutron logging techniques. One of the log-injectlog methods for residual oil uses neutrons in a tracer tagging technique in which activation is used to monitor the presence of an injected material downhole. Neutron absorption is the principal method used for production of radioactive tracers. It is also used for activation analysis in the neighborhood of the borehole and as a general analytical technique. The n a t u r e and intensity of the g a m m a emission can be used to identify and analyze the material exposed to the neutron flux. Most radioactive materials produced for sale by neutron b o m b a r d m e n t of stable isotopes undergo beta decay. Fast neutron capture F a s t (high-energy) neutrons also have a chance of capture in which an activated state is formed and then undergoes a variety of de-excitation reactions such as (n,p), (n,a), and (n,2n) reactions in which a new nuclide is formed. Many of the fast neutron reactions have a threshold of neutron energy below which they cannot take place. These cross sections are usually far smaller t h a n those for thermal neutrons. This has, however, become important for special analytical techniques for the light elements and is also being used in such downhole logging procedures as oxygen activation for water tracing. ATTENUATION OF NEUTRONS IN MATTER The entire set of interactions of neutrons with matter, including those of scattering and absorption, can be expressed as the sum of these cross sections. The t r a n s m i s s i o n of a narrow neutron beam through a thickness, x, of m a t t e r is expressed in the same m a n n e r as for gamma ray transmission, by: N = NOe-~x
(1.34)
In the usual interactions where an uncollimated, broad beam of neutrons passes through matter, either a build-up factor or a Monte Carlo type procedure is required to calculate the attenuation, as for g a m m a radiation. The m e a n free path of the neutron is equal to 1/~t, calculated in the same m a n n e r as for g a m m a radiation. Interactions of neutrons with bulk m a t t e r are expressed in terms of macroscopic cross sections, Z, rather t h a n microscopic cross sections, ~.
Radioactivity Basics
NAP $:i = Ni(~i = ~ ( ~ i
33
(1.35)
where Ni is the n u m b e r of atoms of isotope i per cm 3, p is the density of the medium, and N A is Avogadro's number. This value, calculated for ~ at thermal energies, is widely used in logging measurements and expressed as capture units (cu). One cu = 1000Z. Given a neutron beam with a density of n neutrons/cm 3 and a neutron velocity of v cndsec, we define the neutron flux ~ = nv neutrons/cm2/sec., and the rate of reaction, R, as: R = CZ
(1.36)
A major application of neutron reactions in the oil field is in nuclear logging. The high hydrogen content of oil and water makes moderation of neutrons an important tool for monitoring porosity by the slowing down of neutrons in the fluidfilled pore space. This has become a relatively sophisticated m e a s u r e m e n t with corrections for the effect of borehole fluids as well as other environmental interferences. The downhole pulsed neutron generator is used to measure water saturation, by monitoring the decay of gamma radiation from the (n,7) reaction, following the injection of a 14 MeV neutron pulse. This tool is also used for chemical analysis of formation materials by identification of g a m m a radiation from inelastic and radiative capture reactions, as well as those resulting in particle formation. In this procedure, gamma radiation from inelastic scattering can be separated from capture g a m m a radiation by timing the data collection. This tool can also used to generate gamma-emitting tracers down hole. The logging applications are thoroughly described in texts (Tittman, 1986; Ellis, 1987) and in the literature; therefore they will not be discussed here. Their use for tracer applications, however, will be covered in later chapters.
SOURCES OF RADIOACTIVE MATERIAL The three sources of radioactive materials are: 1) primordial sources and their decay products t h a t have been in the earth since its origin; 2) radioactive materials generated naturally by reactions with cosmic radiation; and 3) radioactive materials t h a t are man made. Together these sources account for all the radioactivity on earth. These include the source of radioactive tracers for oilfield use as well as the source of the background count rate in nuclear counters.
34
Chapter 1
Primordial
sources
Primordial sources include nuclides whose half-life is long enough to have survived since the formation of the earth. The principal primordial sources are the 238U series, the 232Th series, and 40K. Others in this group are shown in Table 1.4 (Friedlander et al., 1981). TABLE 1.4 Other radioactive materials with half-lives long enough to survive on earth Radionuclide
Half-life, years
Isotopic abundance (%)
19~ 186Os 187Re
6.1 x I0 II 2.0 x I01 5 x 109
0.0127 1.6 62.6
174Hf 176Lu 152Gd 147 Sm 148Sm 144Nd 138La 123Te ll5In
2 x 1015 3.6 x 1010 1.1 x 1014 1.05 x 1011 7 x 1015 2.1 x 1015 1.35 x 1011 1.24 x 1013 5.1 x 1015
0.18 2.6 0.20 15.0 11.2 23.9 0.09 0.87 95.7
ll3Cd 87Rb 4~
9 x 1015 4.7 x I0 I0 1.28 x 10 9
12.3 27.83 0.012
The u r a n i u m and thorium series are so called because they are composed of a series of radioactive descendants (daughters) in secular equilibrium with the (original) parent activity. The decay of each member of the series results in a new radioactive isotope, each series finally terminating in a different lead isotope. The decay path for the uranium-238 series is shown in Fig. 1.17 (Ehmann and Vance, 1991). This series undergoes a series of transformation by alpha decay, indicated by the downward diagonal lines, and beta decay, indicated by a vertical rise. It begins with uranium-238 of atomic n u m b e r 92 and ends at lead-206, atomic n u m b e r 82. The radioisotopes in between are identified by their atomic n u m b e r and mass. Many of these alpha and beta transformations are associated with the emission of g a m m a radiation. When undisturbed by chemical separations, this entire group is in secular equilibrium with the parent isotope, and the total activity is the sum of the activities of all the members.
Radioactivity Basics
N
92
~ 90
Alpha decay
: ", !.,,,,
i "\
"~ 88 0~=86
35
]
%\
I
\x
t
~x 9
I
i 238
230 222 214 Mass number, A
206
Beta decay Pb-206
Figure 1.17. Uranium-238 decay series Potassium, which makes up about 2.4 percent of the crust of the earth, has three naturally occurring isotopes. One of these, 4~ is radioactive with a halflife of 1.25 x 10 9 years and an abundance of 0.0117 percent. It decays principally (89 percent) by beta decay to 4~ but about 11 percent of the decay is by positron emission to an activated state of 4~ associated with a 1.46 MeV g a m m a ray. The decay scheme is shown in Fig. 1.5. Manmade materials Nuclear reactors are the principal source of radioactive tracers. Some are separated from fission products formed in the reactors. Most are made by (n,y) reaction with thermal neutrons in a nuclear reactor and undergo beta decay; however (n,a), (n,p) and other neutron reactions are also used. Cobalt-60 is produced by activation of normal cobalt by 59Co(n,y)60Co. Carbon-14, on the other hand, is produced by the 14N(n,p)14C reaction, and tritium (3H) by means of the 6Li(n,a)3H reaction. The probability of a neutron reaction is given by the absorption cross section ~. These values are well known for most isotopes and for the neutron energy distribution found in the reactor. In order to prepare a radioactive nuclide by the (n,T) reaction, a suitable nuclide is exposed to a known neutron flux such as may exist in a nuclear reactor or defined neutron source. The reaction can be quantified. If r is the slow neutron flux in a given reactor position, h is the abundance of the isotope being irradiated, ~ is the absorption cross section for the nuclear reaction, and t is the time of irradiation, then R, the number of atoms of the isotope produced by neutron irradiation, is given by:
36
R = Oa ht
Chapter I
(1.37)
The rate of production of the radioactive product is controlled by its decay constant, k2. This situation is identical to that described in Eq. (1.2) for secular equilibrium except that R replaces N l k 1 as the source of radioisotope N 2. Hence the net production of N 2 is given by: N2 = R (l-e- L2t) ~2
(1.38)
If N 2 also has a significant cross section for neutron reaction, this m u s t be taken a step further to account for the additional loss of N2 by neutron reaction. In quantitative work, additional factors such as the geometry of the neutron flux and the self-absorption of the source m u s t also be considered. In all of these reactions the rate of growth of the nuclide is governed by the saturation factor, 1 - e -~2t. For material of long half-life, such as 14C, very long irradiation times are needed to obtain significant amounts of material. The a m o u n t of material produced is calculated in accordance with Eq. (1.38) above. The same kind of analysis and the same equation is used for materials produced by charged particle accelerators such as cyclotrons. These reactions generally lead to products that decay by positron emission or electron capture. Such isotopes as 57Co and 22Na are made by this method. Because of the limited path length of charged particles in matter, thin targets are used. Since the product nuclide will have a different atomic number from that of the target, it is usually available carrier-free. As a rule, neutron irradiation is far cheaper than charged particle irradiation. The proliferation of m a n m a d e isotopes and the increase in separated natural radioactivity have resulted in an increase in the background for nuclear counters. The release of fission-produced isotopes into the atmosphere from nuclear reactors and from nuclear bomb tests has also added a widespread background level of radioactive nuclides. On the average, however, naturally occurring radiation accounts for most background radiation. Cosmic radiation
The third source of radioactive materials is that arising from the reactions of cosmic rays with atmospheric and terrestrial components. This results in an increased counter background, both because of the radiation entering the counter space and because of the formation of radioactive nuclides. Spallation reactions are those in which the target nucleus is fragmented by reaction with the incoming high-energy particle to yield a number of nuclear products. Nuclear charts such as the one shown in Fig. 1.8 can be used to help anticipate the products of spallation.
Radioactivity Basics
37
Such isotopes as 14C and 3H are formed continuously in the atmosphere by direct interaction with high-energy particles in spallation reactions, as well as interaction with secondary radiation of lower energy. Tritium is formed at a rate of about 0.4 atom/cm2/sec, and carbon-14 at a rate of about 2.4 atoms/cm2/sec. Other nuclides formed in this manner include: 7Be 10Be 36C1 81Kr
half-life half-life half-life half-life
= 53.6 days = 2.5 x 106 years = 2.9 x 105 years = 2.1 x 105 years
Many of the cosmic ray-produced isotopes, particularly carbon-14, are used for age dating. They also provide a "natural" background limit of sensitivity for many tracer isotopes such as tritium and carbon-14.
REFERENCES
Bateman, H., "The Solution of a System of Differential Equations Occurring in the Theory of Radioactive Transformations," Proc. Cambridge Phil. Soc. (1910) 15,423. Browne, E., and Firestone, R.B., Tables of Radioactive Isotopes, Shirley, V.S., ed., John Wiley, New York (1986). Ehmann, W.D., and Vance, D.E., Radiochemistry and Nuclear Methods of Analysis, John Wiley, New York (1991). Ellis, D.W., Well Logging for Earth Scientists, Elsevier Sci. Pub., London (1987). Evans, R.D., The Atomic Nucleus, Krieger, New York (1982). Friedlander, G., Kenedy, J.W., Macias, E.S., and Miller, J.M., Nuclear and Radiochemistry, 3d ed., John Wiley, New York (1981). GE Nuclear Energy, Nuclides and Isotopes, 14th ed. (Chart of the nuclides prepared by Walker, F.W., Parrington, J.R., and Feiner, F.), General Electric Co. (Nuclear Energy Operations), San Jose, CA (1989). Heath, R.L., Scintillation Spectrometry Gamma Ray Spectrum Catalogue, (2 vols.) IDO-16880 (1964). Heath, R.L., Tables of Isotopes: CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics, 69th ed., CRC Press (1989). Kocher, D.C., Radioactive Decay Tables, DOEfrIC-11206 (1981).
38
Chapter 1
Lieser, K.H., "Fundamentals of Nuclear Activation and Radioisotopic Methods of Analysis," in Treatise on Analytical Chemistry, Elving and Kolthoff (eds.), Part 1, 14, 1, John Wiley, New York (1986). Radiological Health Handbook, Bureau of Radiological Health, U.S. Dept. of HE&W, Superintendent of Documents, Washington, DC (1970). Tittman, J., Geophysical Well Logging, Academic Press, Orlando, FL (1986). Tuli, J.K., Nuclear Wallet Cards (available on-line through Telnet), National Nuclear Data Center, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, NY (1990). Wahl, J.S., "Gamma Ray Logging," Geophysics (1983) 48, No. 11, 1536. White, G.E., National Bureau of Standards Report 1003 (1952).
CHAPTER 2
MEASUREMENTS AND APPLICATIONS
INTRODUCTION In the previous chapter we laid the groundwork of nomenclature and principles required for the application of radioactivity to tracer problems. This chapter is concerned with the application of these principles to the measurement of radioactivity in the laboratory and in the field. Some of the counting procedures often used in tracer analysis are presented here in some detail for those who may be unfamiliar with them. The decrease in companies offering tracer services has left a void in the availability of much of this technology. The details offered here may help fill in the gap, and provide background for the specific applications to be discussed in the remaining chapters. Several texts on the detection and measurement of radiation are included in the list of references at the end of this chapter. Topics covered include 1) the major classes of detectors used for measuring radiation and the support systems required by these detectors to obtain count rate and energy data; 2) counting procedures used to monitor beta- and gammaemitting tracers in the field and in the laboratory; 3) radiotracer application to field problems using isotope generators, isotope dilution, and activation analysis; and 4) radiation dosimetry, licensing, and the control of radioactive materials.
RADIATION D E T E C T I O N AND MEASUREMENT
I n t e r a c t i o n o f r a d i a t i o n with m a t t e r Radioactive material can only be measured and identified by the radiation it emits. The detection of radiation is closely tied to its interaction with matter. If the radiation does not react in a recognizable way, it cannot be detected. The medium for this reaction is the detector. For radiation to be measurable, its energy must be transferred to the detector and the transferred energy must be measured. At the current state of the art, two major detection methods are recognized: one based on ionization and the other on conversion to light. Ionization is a primary method of interaction between radiation and matter for all charged particles and for gamma and x-radiation. Charge collection is therefore one of the principal methods used for detection of ionizing radiation. A second important detection method is conversion of radiation to light by scintillation counting. Alternative methods of monitoring radiation include conversion to light by photographic methods and conversion to heat (calorimetry). Neutrons are not charged and do not form ions directly. They are detected by nuclear reactions with materials that lead to ionizing reactions or light emission, which are then detected.
40
Chapter 2
Efficiency and geometry of detection In order to determine the quantity of radioactivity present in a given source, we must detect the radiation emitted and relate it quantitatively to the amount of radioactivity in the source. This requires a knowledge of the fraction of emitted radiation intercepted by the detector, and of how much of the incident radiation is converted to a measurable signal by the detector. The effectiveness of the transfer and its measurement is called the efficiency, E, of the detector and is expressed as the percent of incident radiation detected. Radiation is emitted isotropically from all points in a radioactive source. The fraction of radiation emitted by the source, which is intercepted by the detector, is called the geometry, G, of the detector with respect to the source. It is also expressed in percent. Because of these effects we normally measure a count rate, C, which is lower than the true disintegration rate, N, of the source. The measured activity of a source in counts, C, per unit time is related to the true activity in disintegrations, N, per unit time by the efficiency of counting, E, and the geometry of capture, G: C =NxExG
(2.1)
Here, E and G are expressed as fractions, and both factors are functions of the counting system used.
Signal-to-noise ratio In Eq. (1.10) of the previous chapter, we showed that at a 95 percent confidence level, the lowest detection limit for radioactivity is limited by background radiation (noise) to: 2 ~R(0) = 2~/2RB
(2.2)
t
Here, RB is the counter background and t is the time of counting. Radioactivity measured by the counter is also affected by the efficiency of counting and by the source-detector geometry, hence the detection limit must also be corrected to include both of these effects: 2(~R(0) =E2G~ 2RBt
(2.3)
Most laboratory counting systems for monitoring tracer concentration operate at 100 percent geometry. The factor ~ B / E is a figure of merit for comparing counting systems in terms of the signal-to-noise ratio. Sometimes presented in the inverse form, E2/RB, it is a common standard for judging counters and for altering counter operations to improve sensitivity. The sensitivity of the counter
Measurements and Applications
41
as defined here is the m i n i m u m signal-to-noise ratio at a confidence level of 95 percent.
Gas Counting Tube.
Voltage Source
Ionization path
-r-
Meter
Figure 2.1. Generalized gas counter C H A R G E C O L L E C T I O N I N GAS C O U N T E R S Ion collection in gas counters is a widely used m e t h o d for m o n i t o r i n g radiation. Fig. 2.1. shows a generalized gas counter consisting of a gas chamber with a central anode (positive electrode) and a negatively charged wall. The cylindrical geometry shown here is not required, although it is the most common. P l a n a r and spherical geometries m a y also be used. A source of voltage is i m p r e s s e d across the electrodes and a m e t e r is used to m e a s u r e the collected charge. D e p e n d i n g upon the gas and counter properties, a c o u n t e r can be operated within three different voltage regions. The counter can behave as an ion chamber, a proportional counter, or a Geiger counter, depending on the voltage region chosen. The three conditions are shown schematically in Fig 2.2 and described below.
The effect of an impressed voltage W h e n a radioactive event such as a particle or photon of g a m m a radiation passes through the gas in a counter, it loses energy in a m a t t e r of nanoseconds by collision with the molecules in the gas until all its energy is absorbed. Each of these collisions results in the formation of an ion pair. Depending upon the gas composition, it takes about 30 eV to form one ion pair in a gas (including air). A 300 keV ~ particle will thus form about 104 ion pairs if its entire p a t h lies within the gas. These ion pairs, composed of an electron and a positive ion, will normally recombine. If, however, an electric field is impressed upon the gas, there will be a m i n i m u m voltage at which some of the ions s e p a r a t e and move t o w a r d s the
42
Chapter 2
oppositely charged electrode. This results in the collection of a charge pulse with a height proportional to the number of ions collected. This is the region of recombination. As the voltage increases, the pulse height will increase until all the ions formed by collision of the passing particle or photon are collected. F u r t h e r increases in voltage cause no increase in current until secondary reactions of the ions in the field cause additional ions to be formed. This is called the saturation current. The voltage region in which it occurs is marked as region I in Fig. 2.2. Detectors operating in this region of voltage are called ion chambers. The size of the pulse collected is independent of the applied voltage and is a function only of the energy of the event. For each radioactive event occurring in the counter, a current will be generated that is proportional to the energy of the individual event.
/
f
01
J
III
Voltage
Figure 2.2. Voltage operation regions in gas-filled counters As the voltage is increased beyond the saturation value, the charge collected for each particle or radiation quantum begins to increase because the original ions are accelerated in the electric field until their velocity is so high that they initiate secondary ions, generating avalanches of new ions. This results in pulses containing a much greater charge than the original pulses. The size of each pulse is still proportional to the energy of the initial ionizing event but is simply amplified in the counter by ion multiplication. As the voltage is raised, amplification continues until the multiplication loses its proportionality. This voltage region is identified as region II in Fig. 2.2, and detectors operating within this region are known as proportional counters. If the impressed voltage is increased beyond the proportional region, the induced ion avalanches increase until the pulses are no longer proportional to the
Measurements and Applications
43
particle energy. This continues until a single event triggers n u m e r o u s avalanches, producing a large, single pulse of charge across the system regardless of its original source or energy. This voltage region is known as the Geiger region and is m a r k e d as region III in Fig. 2.2. Detectors operating here are known as Geiger-Mueller or GM counters. If the voltage is increased beyond this region, the counter goes into continuous discharge. In these discussions we have assumed that all of the radiation is absorbed by the counting gas in the detector, but the efficiency of detection is frequently much lower t h a n 100 percent. Gases have good stopping power for beta particles, alpha particles, and soft X-radiation; however they have very poor stopping power for g a m m a radiation. Here, most of the reaction of gamma radiation is with the walls of the counter, and only the inner layer of wall releases secondary electrons into the sensitive volume of the counter for counting.
Pulse counting and current counting These counters can be used either in pulse form, where each event is individually counted, or in current form, where the total charge is integrated and presented as a charge rate or activity. The pulse method is a much more sensitive counter for the number of events (count rate) t h a n the current method. In practice, however, the pulses generated in the ion chamber are very small, and the ion chamber is almost always used in the current form. The proportional and the GM counters are almost always used as pulse counters. In an energy sensitive counter such as the proportional type, it is possible both to count the separate pulses and to measure their energy. In this procedure, the number of events captured per unit time is the count rate, C. Their energies can be obtained by measuring pulse heights. The alternative method is to measure the average current generated by these events - - a function of the n u m b e r of events per unit time and the total energy absorbed. If the radiation event has an average energy, E (eV), the energy required to form an ion pair (eV) is W; J = 1.602 x 10 -19 ampere-seconds is the number of coulombs per esu of charge; and N events per second enter the chamber per unit time; the current, I, generated is given by: I =
JNE W
(2.4)
Most detectors in the ion chamber region measure current response. For such counters the average current collected in the saturation region is proportional to the energy absorbed by the counter, i.e., to the number of events collected in the counter and to the energy of each event. Thus, if the 1 MBq of a beta emitter with an average energy of 300 keV were counted in an ion chamber where W is
44
Chapter 2
30 eV per ion pair, 1.6 nanoamperes of current would be generated according to Eq. (2.4).
Outer electrode Guard ring Center electrode
> r-~ , r~.
Outer insulator ~ inner
I
,I,I ]
|
Figure 2.3. Cross section showing guard-ring construction Ion c h a m b e r
This is a simple and very stable counter with a long voltage plateau; however an electrometer or equivalent is required to monitor the very small currents it generates. The major problem in constructing an ion chamber is the current loss due to leakage paths along the insulator separating the electrodes. To reduce this loss, particularly at low current levels, a guard ring is installed, illustrated in Fig. 2.3 (Knoll, 1989). The ion chamber is relatively insensitive to t e m p e r a t u r e , and can be operated at several hundred degrees if the materials of construction can w i t h s t a n d the temperature. It can also be operated at high gas pressures to increase the g a m m a ray stopping power in the gas. The counter is easily constructed in the laboratory in virtually any configuration with commonly available materials. I n s u l a t i n g m a t e r i a l s should be as smooth as possible. Teflon is a useful insulating material for most normal uses. Synthetic sapphire is an excellent insulating material for high temperatures. The ion chamber is widely used for personnel dosimetry since it m e a s u r e s absorbed energy directly. A hand-held survey meter is calibrated to monitor the charge collected in air in coulombs/kg (roentgens) and can be set up as a "tissue equivalent" chamber for monitoring radiation exposure. A special form of the ion chamber about the size and shape of a pen is also used for personnel monitoring. It uses the discharge of a quartz fiber electrometer to monitor total radiation. The quartz fiber is attached to a pointer t h a t moves across a scale visible through a magnifying glass. Since the ion chamber is very tolerant of the composition of the counting gas, it can function using air as a counting gas. As a result, the chamber
Measurements and Applications
45
can be used to monitor ambient air for the presence of soft beta emitters such as t r i t i u m and carbon-14. It can also be used as a r a d i a t i o n detector for gas c h r o m a t o g r a p h y of C-14 and tritium tagged gases at the millicurie level, an important application in gas-tracer preparation. Because of its great stability, the ion chamber is still used in m a n y industries, including the oil industry, for level gauging. It is the method of choice for calibrating radioactive sources by comparison with primary standards because of its long-time stability. Calibration standards of better t h a n 0.1 percent accuracy can be maintained for years.
Proportional counter This counter differs from the ion chamber in t h a t a very high electric field is m a i n t a i n e d in the neighborhood of the anode. The only way to do this at a reasonable voltage is to use an anode made of small-diameter wire. For cylindrical geometry, the strength of the electric field, E, at a radius, r, from the anode is given by: V E(r) = r In(b/a)
(2.5)
where b is the radius of the cathode (the inner diameter of the counter), a is the radius of the anode wire, and V is the applied voltage. Smooth tungsten wires are available with radii in the order of 1 mil (.001 in., .025mm). End effects from the electric field can be avoided by the use of field t u b e s - - larger d i a m e t e r tubes (hypodermic syringe tubing) t h a t fit over the anode near the ends of the counter. The larger diameter reduces the electric field so t h a t no gas multiplication takes place at the ends. The active counter volume is the region between field tubes. An example of a flow-through counter is shown in Fig. 2.4 (Bennett and Yule, 1973). Most of the gases produced from an oil field can be used as proportional counter gases. This includes the usual hydrocarbons, carbon dioxide, and nitrogen. As a consequence, such counters can be used to monitor produced gas at the wellhead or separator, as well as to count collected field samples in the laboratory, providing w a t e r vapor and other condensables are first removed. In either case, the counter can be used for single samples by evacuation before filing. This and m a n y other geometries (Emery, 1966) have been used with success for both flowing and nonflowing counters. Electrons, attracted to the anode, are accelerated by this electric field until they gain enough energy to form new ion pairs in collision with gas molecules. These, in turn, strike molecules enroute, forming new ion pairs and ultimately creating an electron avalanche of far higher charge t h a n t h a t of the original pulse. Pulse amplification in this region can easily reach 104 times the original value. Pulse collection is more rapid t h a n in the ion chamber mode, and the counter is much more sensitive to gas composition t h a n the ion chamber. It requires special
46
Chapter 2
counting gases that do not form electronegative ions, thus oxygen must be excluded. Since the number of pulses collected is not changed by the multiplication, it has a good working plateau of count rate versus voltage, though it is not as stable as the ionization chamber. The proportional counter is used in the oil industry for neutron logging with a neutron-reactive fill gas. It is also used in the laboratory for monitoring tracer gases containing beta emitters such as tritium, carbon-14, sulfur-35, and krypton-85. In this procedure, the tracer is introduced into the counter with the counting gas, resulting in 100 percent geometry and efficiencies varying from 70 to 100 percent, depending on the beta energy and the counter size. Because the amplitude (height) of each pulse is directly proportional to its energy, pulse-height analysis can be used to identify a beta emitter by its energy. It can be used to analyze mixtures of isotopes having different energies without having to separate them. A plot of pulse height versus energy is linear and easily calibrated using sources of known energy and activity.
Gas inlet
insulator
field tube catlode
I Gas out
Figure 2.4. Proportional counter schematic
Geiger-Mueller counter Probably the most widely used of the gas counters, the GM counter produces very large pulses and can be operated with relatively unsophisticated components, although a special gas mixture is required for operation. Although it is used for personnel monitoring as well as for field and laboratory measurements, there is no obvious correlation with absorbed dose rate as there is for the ion chamber or proportional counter. A major problem with the use of this counter is the long dead time of the counter (ca. 0.1 seconds) due to slow anion collection. During this collection time, the counter is unable to respond to radiation. This is adequate for count rates below 104/minute, but not for high count rates where count losses can become excessive. The GM counter is frequently used as a sealed de-
Measurements and Applications
47
tector for monitoring external radiation. Gases have very little stopping power for g a m m a radiation, since most of the gamma interactions are with the walls of the counter. To increase the sensitivity for monitoring g a m m a radiation, the inner side of the counter wall is lined with a high z material such as bismuth. The lining is just thick enough to allow secondary radiation from any g a m m a interaction in it to escape into the sensitive volume. Because of the limited absorption of gamma radiation by the wall and in the counter gas, g a m m a counting efficiencies are low.
rr 0
f
j Voltage
Figure 2.5. Counter plateau as function of voltage A counting system is much simpler to construct for the Geiger counter t h a n for the proportional counter. Pulses are large enough to be counted with little if any amplification. The only additional equipment needed is the power supply and a counter or meter to display the collected counts. Geiger counters are also used as radiation survey meters, but their response is a function of the energy of the radiation. Such meters usually come supplied with calibration graphs correcting the recorded readings for the incident gamma energy.
Counter plateau vs. pulse-height plateau When a counter is used in any of the voltage modes described above, it should be operated in a stable voltage region. The stability of the region is described by the counting plateau. With increase in voltage, the variation of count rate should show a long region with little change in count rate. Unlike the data shown in Fig. 2.2, this is a plot of count rate, not of pulse height vs. impressed voltage, which describes the desired operating condition for any of these counting modes
48
Chapter 2
(Fig. 2.5). The plateau for all operating counters should be monitored periodically using a s t a n d a r d radiation source. The counter is usually operated at the voltage of the center of the plateau. The ion chamber usually shows the flattest and longest plateau of the three counters, and the GM tube the steepest.
Highvoltage i? supply i I Amplifier I Detector I" - - t - -
I I
ITimerll A
t I i I_ . . IScalerl . .
I I
I I
-- --I
i IRatemeterlBi
Figure 2.6. Simple counter system
C O U N T I N G SYSTEMS In most applications, radiation is monitored by counting individual electrical pulses initiated in some m a n n e r by the detector. This is true for the scintillation and semiconductor detectors to be discussed later as well as for the gas detectors described above. The systems used to support and collect the produced pulses are called counters or counting systems. With minor variations, depending upon the detectors used, these counting systems share the same kind of components. Those needed for counter systems are available as standard modules. An extraordinary range of pulse handling and logic circuits is commercially available. These modules are made to fit in the Nuclear I n s t r u m e n t S t a n d a r d (NIM) bin, where a single power supply provides power for all modules. These are the components referred to in the following discussion of counting systems.
Simple counters The output from a detector of radiation is a collection of events called counts, which are collected by tabulating devices called scalers. The n u m b e r of counts tabulated by a scaler has no intrinsic correlation with either time or energy. To m e a s u r e radioactivity, we need a count rate, hence we must also know the time interval during which the counts were collected. If the counter also produces
Measurements and Applications
49
pulses whose height is proportional to the energy of the event, the pulses may be analyzed further and sorted by pulse height to obtain the energy information. The simplest system only counts pulses. Geiger counter survey meters use such a system, often without an external amplifier. It is composed of the detector; a high-voltage bias supply, which all detectors require; an amplifier, if needed to increase the pulse size; and a readout giving a count rate. In most cases where radioactive tracers are counted in the field, only the counting rate is required, and a simple system will suffice. The count rate is obtained from the number of pulses collected during a fixed time interval. An automatic timer can record the n u m b e r of counts for a preset interval of time, automatically r e s e t t i n g the counter at the end of each interval, as shown in A, Fig. 2.6. This has obvious limitations for following radiation t h a t changes rapidly in intensity, as in following a moving pulse of tracer in a pipe or rapid decay in a short-lived isotope. A solution for this kind of monitoring is to use a count-rate meter t h a t directly converts the collected pulses to a pulse rate, marked as B in the figure. Count rate meters are commonly used in hand-held radiation monitors. Such monitors go directly from the amplifier (if any) to the rate meter with no other electronics. Both analog meters and digital methods are available and will be discussed later in this chapter.
Counters measuring energy When multiple tracers of different energy are used, it is often necessary to monitor the radiation energy in addition to the number of radioactive events. In t h a t event, assuming t h a t pulse heights are proportional to energy, the pulseheight distribution is also measured. If the detector produces pulses containing energy information, a preamplifier is usually required to transfer the signal to the amplifier without loss, and to reduce noise. The amplifier used m u s t be linear; i.e., it must amplify pulses of all amplitudes equally to avoid loss of energy information. The simplest way to sort the pulses by energy is through a singlechannel analyzer (SCA) composed of two discriminators. A lower level pulse discriminator (LLD) is used to eliminate all pulses below a preset level and to reduce noise by eliminating spurious low-level signals. An upper level discriminator (ULD) is used to discriminate against all pulses above a preset level. The two discriminators can be coupled together to define a region of pulse heights or energies, AP for any given pulse height. The count rate measured in t h a t region is AC. To obtain the spectrum, AC/AP is measured as a function of P. Since the pulse h e i g h t s are usually linear in energy, the pulse-height s p e c t r u m is equivalent to the energy spectrum of AC/AE versus E. A typical system used for all energy-sensitive counting systems is shown schematically in Fig. 2.7. These components are available commercially as modules or as an integrated system.
50
Chapter 2
BACKGROUND REDUCTION In operation, most detectors are surrounded by shielding, usually lead, to reduce background from external sources of radiation. F u r t h e r reduction is possible if counter m a t e r i a l s are carefully chosen to be free of m a n m a d e or n a t u r a l l y occurring radioactivity. Very low-level counting is often required, or at least desirable, in monitoring interwell tracers. This can be achieved by surrounding the counting detector with an external detector and using anticoincidence to cancel events t h a t occur simultaneously in both detectors. The outer detector is often referred to as a guard counter, with the assumption t h a t events external to the counting system represent background radiation and will be removed relative to those being counted. In this procedure, the signal from the outer detector activates a gate in an anticoincidence circuit. This module allows signals from the inner detector to be counted only if they are not coincident with signals from the outer detector. An example of this is low-level counting of radioactive gas tracers by proportional counting. In this system, the gases are counted in a proportional counter, mixed with the counting gas. This counter is surrounded by a GM counter, as shown in Fig. 2.8. Radioactive events such as cosmic rays originating outside the counters have enough energy to pass through both counters. The radioactive tracers in the proportional counter are beta emitters, entirely absorbed within the detector volume. If the two detectors are connected in anticoincidence, only the i n t e r n a l l y g e n e r a t e d signals will be counted. A l-liter proportional counter inside a 3-inch lead shield with an anticoincident guard counter can reduce the background to less t h a n 6 counts per minute. There may be some loss of counts due to accidental coincidences; however at the low counting levels normally found in gas tracer counting, this is negligible.
Proportional Counter
I
Preamp.
i rT-l
Linear Amplifier ~ !~ Timer
I I Upper& Lower High Voltage Discriminators Power Supply
Figure 2.7. Energy-sensitive counting system
Scaler
Measurements and Applications
51
Anticoincidence
/ Lead shield
fl
L i
/
':':-:-:-::':':':':':'::-'.-';
,':':':-:': ........... :':':'::': ............... :':':': ........... :':':'::':i-;-; ...... "
Inner counter iiiii::iiiiiiii:iiii:
I
guard amplifier
"t
/"
I "..
Inner amplifier
--'I !
!
Guard counter I
Figure 2.8. Background reduction by anticoincidence with guard counter
SCINTILLATION DETECTORS Ionizing r a d i a t i o n can interact with a n u m b e r of phosphors to produce scintillations of light. This includes some of our oldest known m e a s u r i n g techniques. Organic m a t e r i a l s such as anthracene, as well as solutions of some organic phosphors in suitable solvents and in plastics, are used for beta-particle and a variety of low-energy radiation detection. The interaction of organic materials with radiation is a property of the molecule. Most organic phosphors are composed of planar aromatic rings having a ~ electronic structure (Birks, 1964). Absorption of radiation raises the molecule to an excited state t h a t can de-excite by emission of light. Since this is a molecular property, the phosphor can fluoresce in vapor form, as a crystal, or in solution. It is also available dissolved in plastics obtainable in virtually any shape or size. Several inorganic materials are also capable of converting radiation to light. These include crystals such as NaI, CsI, LiI, Bi4Ge3012, (bismuth germinate, BGO), BaF2, CsF, ZnS, etc. The interaction of these materials with radiation is a p r o p e r t y of the crystal structure. Electrons in nonconducting crystals are restricted to discrete energy bands. In the pure crystal, electrons normally occupy the valence band t h a t is the level where they are bound to the lattice sites. To leave this level they must be excited to the conduction band, leaving a hole in the valence band. De-excitation from this level by production of a photon is an inefficient process, often occurring at too high an energy level to produce visible light. The region between these bands is forbidden. If a small amount of a suitable impurity is added as an activator, an intermediate energy band between these
52
Chapter 2
two bands becomes available. Electrons can de-excite back from these states to the valence band with the emission of a photon of visible light, as illustrated in Fig. 2.9. The sodium iodide NaI(T1) (thallium activated crystals) is the inorganic material most widely used for gamma counting because its high density gives it good stopping power, the high atomic number of iodine has a good photoelectric cross section, and it is transparent to the light it generates. These detectors require the use of a photomultiplier tube to amplify the scintillation pulses produced and convert them to an electrical pulse. Requirements for a useful scintillation detector are discussed in monographs (Birks, 1964) and texts (Tsoulfanidis, 1983; Knoll, 1989). In this section we will cover only the detectors most commonly used for monitoring gamma and beta radiation.
I Conduction Band I
I
Forbidde
I Valence Band
levels I
Figure 2.9. Mechanism of crystal scintillation
The p h o t o m u l t i p l i e r tube The photomultiplier tube (PMT) is basic to the use of all scintillation detectors. A diagram of a photomultiplier is shown in Fig. 2.10 (RCA, 1970). The PMT consists of an evacuated glass or quartz tube with a flat end for optical coupling to a crystal. The inside of the flat end contains the photocathode, which converts the light pulse to an electron pulse. Between the photocathode and the collection anode is a string of dynodes. Electrons from the photocathode strike the first dynode, where each is multiplied in number. Each succeeding dynode multiplies the electrons arriving from the preceding dynode. The final pulse produced can have a multiplication factor of about 1010 to 1012, depending on the number of dynodes. An electric field is used to focus and direct the electron pulses from the photo cathode and intervening dynodes to the anode. The amplified pulse will be proportional in height to the original light pulse and will have similar timing characteristics. A stable high-voltage source is required to bias the PMT electrodes, using a resistor string to provide the focusing and amplifying voltages
Measurements and Applications
53
needed at each dynode. These resistors are usually mounted inside the base of the PMT. Photomultiplier tubes are available commercially with a large range of photocathode diameters. Output from the PMT is usually fed to a preamplifier and then to a linear amplifier as illustrated in Fig. 2.7.
The Nal(T1) d e t e c t o r OPERATION OF DETECTOR The t h a l l i u m - a c t i v a t e d sodium iodide detector is the most common solid scintillator in use. It is composed of a single crystal, which is hygroscopic and must be hermetically sealed in aluminum to protect it from water vapor. One face is left covered with glass or quartz for optical coupling to the face of a photomultiplier tube (PMT). The coupling medium is a transparent, viscous fluid with a suitable refractive index, usually one of the silicones. The NaI(T1)-PMT combination is wrapped with black plastic tape to make it opaque, and the entire assembly shielded to reduce background. The crystal and PMT are available commercially as separate units or as a sealed package. The electronics needed for counting and measuring the pulses from the detector can be provided by a handheld survey meter, by laboratory survey meters, or by the electronic modules packaged in an NIM bin. In dealing with g a m m a radiation of different energies, it is convenient to be able to deal with a large n u m b e r of channels. For this purpose the single-channel analyzer described earlier is often too time-consuming and is replaced by the multichannel analyzer (MCA). The MCA is an electronic device t h a t can be used to sort rapidly all incoming pulses by amplitude into separate energy channels. For the NaI(T1) crystal, a 250-channel analyzer is commonly used. The use of the MCA is discussed in a later section. The light pulse generated in the crystal is transformed to a charge pulse by the PMT. The height of each pulse produced is proportional to the energy of the radiation q u a n t u m absorbed in the detector. The NaI(T1) is one of the most efficient detectors for g a m m a radiation up to several MeV in energy. Efficiency increases with detector volume, and crystals are available in large sizes up to several feet in diameter. For commonly available sizes, such as 2- to 3-in. diameter, it approaches an efficiency of 100 percent for energies below 0.5 MeV and about 50 percent for 1.7 MeV gammas. The radiation background also rises with increased crystal size. The tradeoff between efficiency and background is best evaluated in terms of the figure of merit discussed earlier, E2/B, and the permissible limitations on background. For most purposes, crystal sizes below 5-in. by 5-in. are the most useful. A variety of NaI crystal-PMT combinations are available commercially, including well crystals, which are commonly used in laboratory work for counting gamma-emitting tracers from interwell waterfloods. Such a detector is illustrated in Fig. 2.11. It allows a sample vial to be placed inside the crystal so t h a t it may be counted with virtually 100 percent geometry.
54
Chapter 2
Photons Photocathode \\ Focusing section
I i
i
/
\,1II
:j 7,,;
~--m
Photoelectron trajectories
Electron multiplier section
1 to 12 = Dynodes 13 = Anode
Figure 2.10. Photomultiplier tube
Aluminum enca ~sulation
We,, fk~, ) /-- '0~~ Figure 2.11. Crystal well counter
~,noo.
Measurements and Applications
55
ENERGY SPECTRUM FROM NaI(T1) CRYSTAL The pulses produced by the PMT are amplified and sorted according to pulse height to display a spectrum of energy versus intensity. The absorption of g a m m a radiation in a crystal follows the same processes as those described earlier for all matter. The three major processes are Compton scattering, photoelectric absorption, and pair production. In all of these, the gamma ray reacts with the material to produce energetic electrons, which will react in the crystal to produce excited states, resulting in the emission of photons. If the g a m m a radiation were released inside a crystal large enough to absorb all the emitted radiation, the energy spectrum would display a single peak for each g a m m a ray emitted. This total energy peak has a G a u s s i a n distribution instead of a single line, because the energy transfer from incident g a m m a ray to the produced light pulse is composed of several inefficient processes. The energy required to produce one information carrier (a photoelectron) is about 100 eV or more. The statistical fluctuations in the relatively small n u m b e r of carriers formed limit the resolution of the detector (Knoll, 1989). In real scintillation crystals, all the energy of the g a m m a ray is not captured. The radiation all comes from outside the crystal: some of the radiation m a y graze the crystal; some will scatter off the surroundings before entering the crystal; depending upon the crystal size, some of the incident radiation may pass through the crystal and not be captured at all; and all the processes by which g a m m a rays lose energy will be displayed. As a result, the spectrum will be far more complicated t h a n indicated above. Such a spectrum is illustrated in Fig. 2.12 for an isotope emitting two g a m m a rays. The photopeaks representing the characteristic energy of the two g a m m a rays are m a r k e d as ~1 and ~2. A backscatter peak due to escape of scattered radiation from the shielding usually shows up at about 0.25 MeV. Each g a m m a ray has a Compton continuum associated with it, with the Compton edge displaced about 0.2 MeV from the g a m m a ray photopeak. This was discussed earlier in chapter 1 and the process illustrated in Fig. 1.4. Resolution loss and other effects in the real crystal t u r n the sharp Compton edge shown in Fig. 1.4 to a bump in the curve. Pair production occurs at g a m m a energies above 1.02 MeV, resulting in the formation of two 0.51 MeV annihilation photons. One or both of these m a y escape the crystal, resulting in a single escape peak (esc 1) and a double escape peak (esc 2). Sum peaks can occur whenever two events take place within the resolving time of the detector and associated circuitry, shown in Fig. 2.12 as sum. (Cascaded g a m m a rays such as the 1.17 and 1.31 MeV gammas emitted by cobalt-60 usually result in an additional peak at the sum of these energies.) The response curve can be further degraded by secondary radiation, such as X-radiation and b r e m s s t r a h l u n g generated in or n e a r the crystal. The result of all this is a complex continuum of radiation with several peaks or humps. Each g a m m a energy is still identified by its photopeak; but with m a n y g a m m a
56
Chapter 2
rays and the associated Compton scatter arising either from one or from multiple sources, the spectrum can become difficult to resolve. The ability of the NaI(T1) detector to resolve a single emitted gamma energy is the figure of merit of the detector, R. This is quoted as "full width at half maximum" (FWHM) at the energy of the photo peak, usually expressed in percent:
FVCrIM
R=~
x 100
(2.6)
-ray ~2
Comp.~ edge
8
sum
i sca'er esc2 esc 1
____A.
Energy, MeV
Figure 2.12. Complex gamma spectrum The photoelectric peak produced by the 0.66 MeV gamma ray from 137Cs is a common resolution monitor, shown in Fig. 2.13 (Friedlander et al., 1981). A good sodium iodide crystal will have a resolution of about 7.0 percent. Also illustrated in the figure are additional peaks generated by the single gamma ray from 137 Cs. SPECTRUM ANALYSIS Simple spectra that contain only a few g a m m a sources yielding a few welldefined photopeaks are easy to resolve into the isotopic components. The peak energies associated with each known isotope are available from libraries (Heath, 1964) of data collected by NaI detectors under a variety of conditions. Such spectra can, however, become difficult to analyze with increasing n u m b e r of radioactive sources. This is due to the statistical noise associated with radioactivity,
Measurements and Applications
57
the relatively poor resolution of each photopeak, the Compton continuum associated with each g a m m a energy, and the secondary reactions t h a t can take place in the crystal. As a result the spectrum often shows relatively little character, particularly at low counting rates. These spectra are usually stored in computer memories. Modern advances in computational speed have made it possible to resolve m a n y such spectra using a variety of search and evaluation programs. The methods developed for analyzing such spectra are briefly described below.
'
I
'
1
'
I
~
I
FWHM Resolution- - - ~ XlO0 t-
Compton ~ edge [ J/! k ~ ~ " / R . e.~.~e..ff~,r ~ ,i
...... [
'
FWHM. l j l
x-ray
0
9
fl~ Photopeak /i/~/ -
I
i
I
i
I
Energy
! I ! Midp~ I ~ energy /i/ E 9
I
,,I
\
I
,
_
E
Figure 2.13. NaI(T1) detector resolution Two things are required from a g a m m a ray spectrum: identification of the component g a m m a sources and a measure of the activity of each source. The first of these requires peak energy identification (Carpenter et al., 1979). Search programs look for an increase in count rate associated with a m a x i m u m and compare this with a library of g a m m a ray energies. Poorly resolved peaks can sometimes be separated from the noise by programs t h a t differentiate the peak data and look for roots in the first and higher order differentials, or programs t h a t look for Gaussian or other specific shapes to fit the peak. In the use of multiple tracers in oilfield work, it is sometimes sufficient to identify the presence of a specific tracer, as described above. The amount of each component present is obtained from the areas under the peaks assigned to t h a t component. This can be done by graphical integration with suitable corrections for interference. It can also be done by curve fitting to preassigned shapes. For evaluation of complex spectra, two additional procedures
58
Chapter 2
have been used. The most common is spectrum stripping. In this procedure one isotope w i t h p r o m i n e n t photopeaks is identified. A spectrum of the pure component is made under the same conditions and used to fit the photopeaks in complex spectrum. This is then subtracted from the entire spectrum. The process continues, using the next prominent peak until all are analyzed. This procedure suffers from the propagation of errors, the last components having the greatest errors. The best programs for resolving and analyzing small peaks in a composite spectrum with little character are the least squares procedures (Schonfeld 1967; Yule, 1973). A set of spectra for each of the radiotracers present is divided into a set of energy channels. Intensities are calculated so that their sums best fit the composite spectrum, and the sum of the squares of the residuals in all the channels is a minimum. This is superior to the spectrum stripping method, since all components receive equal weight. It is the method commonly used in the oilfield for deconvolving g a m m a ray spectra emitted by n a t u r a l and m a n m a d e sources downhole.
L i q u i d scintillation counters AQUEOUS SOLUTIONS OF BETA EMITTERS The liquid scintillation counter (LSC) is the only method t h a t can be used for directly counting aqueous solutions of beta emitting tracers such as tritium and carbon-14 with 100 percent geometry and high efficiency. Until the development of this method, such materials could not be counted directly but first had to be separated from solution and then converted to a (tritium and carbon-14) form suitable for counting in a gas counter. The LSC is the most widely used detector for monitoring tracer solutions that emit radiation of low penetrating power, including solutions or suspensions of tracers that decay by alpha emission, beta emission, electron capture, or internal transition. It is the principal method used for counting the tritiated and carbon-14 tagged tracers used in waterflood tracing (Horrocks, 1974). A variety of solids can also be counted in the LSC by suspending them as a fine powder in a suitable "cocktail." In this counter, the solution is incorporated into a liquid scintillation "cocktail" within the sensitive volume of the detector. This avoids the need to penetrate the walls of an external detector and provides essentially 100 percent geometry. The principal problem in counting low-energy beta particles in the LSC is the reduction of light output due to the presence of interfering impurities, particularly the presence of water. Commercial cocktails capable of counting tritium efficiently in mixtures containing up to 50 percent water are now available. In such cocktails the water is usually in a colloidal suspension r a t h e r t h a n in solution.
Measurements and Applications
59
Beta particles are produced in a continuous energy spectrum, as shown in Fig. 1.4, r a t h e r t h a n as a single discrete energy. Spreading the energy spectrum out in this m a n n e r reduces the sensitivity of detection for an event. It is further reduced by inefficient conversion, since only about 10 percent of the beta energy is converted to light photons. There is also a lower limit of sensitivity imposed by noise discrimination and by the need for coincidence monitoring. As a consequence, particles below about 1 keV cannot be monitored. This is very important for tritium, less so for carbon-14 - - the two isotopes most widely used in the oil industry. The average energy of a tritium beta is only about 6 keV; t h a t of a C-14 beta is about 50 keV. COUNTER OPERATION The liquid scintillation cocktail consists of a solvent, a primary scintillator, an emulsifier and the radioactive sample. The solvent has the dual function of keeping this mixture in solution and of energy transfer. Most of the energy of the beta particle is dissipated in the solvent, which must provide a radiationless transfer of this energy to the primary scintillator. The scintillator then converts the radiation to a light pulse of which the height is proportional to the energy of the emitted radiation. The emulsifier serves to keep materials t h a t are not soluble, or would separate by gravity, suspended in the cocktail. Sample preparation consists of mixing a suitable scintillation cocktail with a known volume of sample in a scintillation vial. Aqueous solutions are commonly counted for most applications such as interwell tracing by incorporation into the cocktail as a colloidal suspension. It is important to m a i n t a i n a single colloidal phase in these cocktails since multiple phases can cause unreliable count rates. The formation of multiple phases depends on the fraction of w a t e r present, the ionic strength of the solution, and the temperature. To keep background levels down, the vials are made of low-potassium glass or plastic. The continuous energy spectrum produced by beta particles combined with the low energy of tritium and carbon-14 betas makes noise reduction vital in these m e a s u r e m e n t s . All i n s t r u m e n t s produced commercially reduce random noise by using two photomultipliers (PMT's) in coincidence to view the sample vial. This separates the random t h e r m a l effects, which are not coincident, from the true counts in the scintillation vial, which are coincident. The output of the two tubes is then summed to average out readings at different positions and to increase the sensitivity of measurement. This output goes into a multichannel analyzer, or a set of single-channel analyzers. At least three channels of data are needed if multiple tracers, e.g., C-14 and tritium, are to be counted. A schematic diagram of such a liquid scintillation counter is shown in Fig. 2.14 (Packard Inst., 1982). Most commercial instruments are automatic in operation. The samples are placed in a motor driven belt, which lowers each sample in t u r n to a shielded counting chamber for a preset period of time. Driven by microprocessors, these instruments can count up to several hundred samples sequentially for variable counting times.
60
Chapter 2
P"TI I 1 vial 0 PMT2!~
oo,nFI,o,_ dence
sum
ADCII !I~
Figure 2.14. Liquid scintillation counter Generally, provisions are made for one or more sets of calibration standards, for background counting and subtraction, and for efficiency corrections. Multiple tracers are identified, and the data are presented in terms of ~Ci/ml (MBq/cm 3) or equivalent units.
Quenching and efficiency measurements The addition of aqueous materials to the scintillation cocktail has two effects. It reduces the number of photons produced from each event, and it shifts the curves of energy distribution to lower energies. These combined effects are known as quenching (Fig. 2.15; Packard, 1982) and are important in m e a s u r i n g the efficiency of counting and in deconvolving mixed spectra. Quenching is a function of a great m a n y variables, including the amount of water, the n a t u r e of the solute, its concentration in solution, and the temperature. It may be different in each sample but must be corrected for in order to calculate counting efficiency. The two principal ways to obtain counting efficiencies from quenched samples are the channels ratio method and the external standard method. Both methods require a set of standards containing the same amount of activity, but different amounts of quenching. In the first method, the standards are counted in both a quenched region and in an unquenched region and the ratio of counts in the two regions plotted against the calculated efficiency, usually resulting in a smooth monotonic curve (Fig. 2.16; Packard, 1982). The efficiency of an unknown sample is obtained from its measured channels ratio using the s t a n d a r d curve. The external standard method uses a gamma source such as radium or cesium-137 to generate Compton-scattered electrons in the scintillator. These behave as beta particles and can be used to obtain a s t a n d a r d quench curve. The external standard method is the most widely used and can also be corrected for quench by applying various correction algorithms, including channels ratio. It usually has a very high activity and is dropped into position next to the unknown samples for only a few seconds after the sample has been counted for the required time.
61
Measurements and Applications
dN
pulse height
Figure 2.15. Effect of quenching
BO
o>,
60
40 ,-- - I
20
.00
.20
.40
.60
.80
1.00
Channel ratio
Figure 2.16. Channel ratio method for efficiency monitoring
Chapter 2
62
I
I
I
ched
I
I I I I I
8 ,
200
41)0
6~'5
I Channels I
I I
I I
I
I Unquenched I
I
1C.14
I
8
I
200
40O
III
675
Channels
Figure 2.17. Tritium and carbon-14 spectra in LSC A consequence of the spread in the beta spectrum and the effect of quenching is that only a limited amount of energy deconvolution is possible. If their energies are far enough apart, up to three different beta-emitting isotopes can be analyzed simultaneously. In most cases isotope separation must deal with overlapping spectra for each isotope. Energy (pulse-height) channels are chosen to minimize the overlap, and the isotopes are separated by solving simultaneous equations for the fractional concentration in each of the spectral regions. Two of the most frequently used isotopes are tritium and 14C. The beta spectrum for each of these, quenched and unquenched, is shown in Fig. 2.17 (Beckman, 1985). The effect of the spectral shift is made clearer here by showing the two spectra on the same
Measurements and Applications
63
energy (pulse-height channel) scale. The counting data are deconvolved with the help of data from a set of quench standards counted for each isotope. The presence of quenching agents such as water, salt, oxygen, or colored m a t t e r reduces the total light output from each isotope and changes the shape of each spectrum. Many modern i n s t r u m e n t s are equipped with microprocessors t h a t use the data from a set of quench standards counted for each isotope to calculate the amount of each isotope and the efficiency of measurement.
SOLID STATE IONIZATION DETECTORS Many semiconductor crystals have the ability to interact with radiation by producing ions. Such counters behave as parallel plate ionization chambers if an electric field is applied across the parallel faces. The radiation is absorbed in the crystal by forming electron-hole pairs equivalent to the ion pairs in a gas. Elecrons are raised into the conduction band of the crystal and migrate to the positive electrode. Positive charges (holes) are collected at the other electrode. The most successful semiconductors for monitoring radiation have been elemental germanium and silicon. The high density of these materials, particularly germanium, makes them very efficient g a m m a absorbers compared to gas. In addition, since only 3 or 4 eV is required to form an electron-hole pair, their energy resolution is much better t h a n that of any other detector. Diode detectors These materials lie within group IV of the periodic table and are quadrivalent. They can be made conducting by doping them with small amounts of group III or group V elements. If a group III material (e.g., boron) is used, it will be p type material m electron deficient, generating positive holes in the crystal. If a group V m a t e r i a l (e.g., phosphorus) is used as a dopant, it will be known as n type material and will have an excess of electrons. These holes and electrons formed in the p and n types, respectively, are charge carriers that are free to move under an electrical field. If n and p type materials are joined together to form a diode, and an electrical potential is applied, current will flow in only one direction. If the potential is reversed, the charge carriers will each flow away from the diode junction, leaving this region depleted. No current will flow except for t h a t generated thermally. If, however, an ionizing particle or q u a n t u m of energy passes through this depleted region, electron-hole pairs are formed and a current pulse will flow. The diode will thus act as a counter for ionizing radiation, yielding pulses whose height is proportional to the energy of the ionizing event. For penetrating radiation such as g a m m a and x-radiation, the depleted region near the diode junction is too thin to allow for efficient interaction with radiation.
64
Chapter 2
For both silicon and germanium diodes, lithium can be used to compensate for extra charge carriers as well as to greatly expand the depleted layer. The lithium "drifted" silicon detector is used as a detector for x-ray fluorescence analyses. Both must be kept at liquid nitrogen temperature to maintain the lithium-drifted layer. G e r m a n i u m detectors Because of germanium's high atomic number and density, germanium diodes are used for gamma counting. Lithium-drifted germanium diodes (Ge(Li)) are being phased out by ultrapure (intrinsic) germanium. The ultrapure germanium detector compares favorably with the Ge(Li) detector in that, although it has an equally thick depletion layer, it need not be stored at liquid nitrogen temperature when not in use. When in use, however, the germanium diode detectors must be operated at liquid nitrogen temperature to keep thermally induced noise from overwhelming the detector. Germanium detectors are less efficient than NaI(T1) detectors because of the much smaller useful volume. The efficiency of a Ge detector is usually quoted in terms of percent of NaI efficiency at a specific energy. Large Ge crystals can approach NaI efficiency but are quite expensive. The great advantage to using the Ge detector is the tremendous increase in spectral resolution; energy resolution obtained from a Ge detector is about 100x higher than that from NaI. Since the height and location of the photopeaks are used to quantify the gamma response, the narrowly defined photopeaks stand out from the Compton scatter far better in the Ge detector than in broad peaks generated in NaI. This also improves gamma analysis from the Ge detector. The background radiation level can be reduced by shielding and by use of a guard counter in anticoincidence with a detector, as described earlier and shown in Fig. 2.8. In this case, the result is a significant reduction in the Compton scattering relative to the photopeaks. This is because the Compton component of the spectrum includes many photons that were partially scattered and then escaped; whereas the photopeaks used to monitor the full energy have no escape. A NaI(T1) crystal is the usual guard counter. The shielded and cooled Ge detector produces small pulses of charge that are amplified in the manner illustrated in Fig. 2.6. Because of the high resolution of the energy pulses, a larger number of channels is useful for spectral display. Most energy resolution is done using 4000 channels. T h e r m o l u m i n e s c e n t dosimeters (TLD's) TLD's are semiconductors that respond to radiation by raising electrons to excited levels where they are trapped without the immediate emission of light. These excited electrons can be stored for long periods of time without loss of energy, so that the TLD acts as an integrating dosimeter. When the TLD is
Measurements and Applications
65
h e a t e d u n d e r controlled conditions, it emits light proportional to the energy originally absorbed, which can be monitored by a photomultiplier tube. The curve of light intensity as a function of temperature is called a glow curve. TLD's have in m a n y cases replaced the film badge in personnel monitoring for g a m m a and x-ray exposure. A n u m b e r of materials have been developed for this purpose including LiF, CaF2(Mn), CaSO 4, and others.
NEUTRON DETECTORS
Neutrons do not cause ionization in reacting with matter. They are detected only by means of secondary reactions t h a t produce a measurable signal. This is a two-step process: the neutron must react with the nucleus of a material having a high reaction cross section and this reaction must result in the emission of a particle of high ionization ability. The three most common neutron counters for oilfield work use the (n,p) and the (n,a) reactions. The boron trifluoride (BF3) detector uses boron trifluoride (BF3), enriched in 10B, as both the neutron target and the proportional counting gas. The lOB(n,a) reaction produces energetic alpha particles with high ionizing power and easy detectability. The high specific energy of the alpha particle makes it easy to detect even in the presence of high gamma radiation levels. The same holds true for the lithium iodide scintillation detector using the 6Li(n,(~) reaction. The energy of the emitted alpha particle is so much greater t h a n t h a t of the g a m m a radiation normally encountered t h a t it can be separated from interfering g a m m a background by energy discrimination. The most common detector used in the oil field is the helium-3 detector, which undergoes the 3He(n,p) reaction with neutrons. Helium-3 acts as the neutron target as well as the proportional counting gas. The neutron capture cross section here is considerably higher t h a n for the other two counters; in addition, the gas density can be increased by high-pressure operation without h a r m i n g the counter operation. All three of these counters are sensitive to t h e r m a l n e u t r o n s and give a response t h a t is independent of the neutron energy. To monitor higher energy neutrons by these detectors, the neutrons must be slowed down in a known way by interaction with an intervening moderator.
C O U N T R A T E M E T E R S , M U L T I C H A N N E L ANALYZERS, AND M U L T I C H A N N E L S C A L E R S Analog count rate meters
The analog count r a t e m e t e r (CRM) is the only m e t h o d for obtaining a continuous reading of the average activity in counts per unit time. It is also one
66
Chapter 2
of the oldest, cheapest, and most widely used methods for presenting counting data. The circuit for a typical meter is shown in Fig. 2.18. Here, the entering pulses from the counter deposit their charge in the capacitor, C, which is discharged through the resistor, R. This combination of resistor and capacitor is called a tank circuit. Equilibrium is reached after a few values of the time constant, RC, and the rate of discharge will equal the rate of charge. If N is the count rate in counts per second and q is the charge deposited by each pulse, then the average voltage produced is directly proportional to the count rate and is given
by: V = NqR
(2.7)
The produced voltage fluctuates about the average count rate as it charges (and discharges) with the random count rate. If necessary, the input pulses are shaped to remove any difference in count caused by pulse shape. If there is a change in count rate, the CRM will respond by approaching the new equilibrium value at a rate given by (1-e-t/RC), where t is the time and RC is the time constant.
I Tank circuit i "
_J-L Input pulses
I
I I
>
(r ~
I I
I
I
C
I
FI
Output voltage
I -
I I
-
Figure 2.18. Typical count rate meter circuit Short time constants provide more rapid equilibrium but larger deviations from the average. Long time constants show less deviation but a much slower response to changing signals. The counting error for the meter is usually expressed as the percent standard deviation. If ~ is the standard deviation and v is the average voltage, this is given by: ~_ = 1 v ~]2NRC
(2.8)
This kind of circuitry is normally found in pulse-counting survey meters, generally those using a GM tube or a NaI scintillator as a detector. Such meters
67
Measurements and Applications
usually have a choice of scales for counting ranges t h a t are adjusted by changing the value of the resistor, R, with a switch on the front panel. They also have adjustments for changing "percent standard deviation" by a switch on the panel t h a t alters the capacitance, C. Survey meters t h a t measure pulses r a t h e r t h a n current may be calibrated in terms of counts per unit time or as a "dose rate" in mR/hour or ~Sv/hr. These terms will be discussed in a later section of this chapter. The output is a measure of the average count rate and is displayed on a panel-mounted ammeter. The output can also be made to bypass the ammeter by means of a suitable set of pin jacks displaying the results on a strip chart recorder.
Tracer pulse -~
-__-_-_-_----------:_-_-.==_~ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Flow
..._ v
Hv
(Survey meter)
Figure 2.19. Analog count rate meter and recorder The ability to record the activity as a function of time with a strip chart recorder provides a cheap and useful method for monitoring the m o v e m e n t of tracers through pipelines and other media in facilities, as illustrated in Fig. 2.19. Portable NaI survey meters draw relatively little current and can operate on dry cells for extended periods of time, as can some battery-operated strip chart recorders, allowing complete independence from other power sources. If the count rate varies significantly with time in the passage of a pulse of activity, the ratemeter will lag the data because of its response time. For precise work, the ratemeter output can be corrected for the lag (Pilgrim, 1965) with simple computational methods.
Multichannel analyzers Energy information is obtained from the amplitude (height) of the pulse. To extract this information in a useful way, the pulses must first be sorted according to pulse heights. This can be done in simple systems using a pair of pulse-height
68
Chapter 2
discriminators in a single-channel analyzer. For complex spectra, a multichannel analyzer t h a t displays the entire energy spectrum is a better solution. The multichannel analyzer (MCA) is the i n s t r u m e n t of choice for complex energy spectra. The price and size of MCA's has decreased significantly in the past few years, and such i n s t r u m e n t s are now available in portable units weighing only a few pounds, able to display at least a thousand channels, and not significantly more expensive t h a n a s t a n d a r d counting unit. Many MCA's can also support a sodium iodide/photomultiplier detector providing both signal amplification and high-voltage bias. In addition, MCA cards are available for insertion into personal computers t h a t allow all the functions of a stand-alone MCA. Most MCA's are capable of operating as a pulse-height analyzer (PHA) or a multichannel scaler (MCS). The pulse-height analyzing function of the MCA is its most widely recognized application; however the multichannel scaling function is also useful in a great m a n y field applications. The two modes of operation are illustrated in Fig. 2.20 (Tsoulfanidas, 1983) and discussed below. PULSE-HEIGHT ANALYZER MODE In the pulse-height analyzer mode (PHA), the MCA acts as though the incoming signal were received by a large n u m b e r of single-channel analyzers, each accepting a pulse of a different (energy) height Ei -+ AE. It achieves this by digitizing the incoming pulse height in an analog-to-digital converter (ADC). It t h e n stores a n u m b e r proportional to each pulse height, El, in a channel containing all pulses whose height is Ei -+ AE. Channels are sorted according to height, and each channel is given a separate address in the memory. The resolution of the system is AE, and the m a x i m u m content of a memory channel is about 16 million counts. The number of channels available is expressed in powers of 2 and varies from 28 (256 channels) to 213 (8192 channels) and above. (These are normally referred to as 250 channels and 8000 channels). The n u m b e r of channels, N, required to cover the signal from a given detector efficiently depends upon the resolution of the detector, G, and the range of g a m m a energies to be covered. A commonly used rule of thumb is given by: N =5
range (keV) G (keV)
(2.9)
Thus, a sodium iodide crystal with resolution of 50 keV and a range of 2000 keV would require 10,000/50, or about 200 channels. A germanium detector with a resolution of about 2 keV would require about 5000 channels. Hence, for work with the sodium iodide crystal, a 250-channel ADC would be adequate; whereas at least 4000 channels would be needed for the germanium detector. Modern MCA's are equipped with a cathode ray tube display t h a t shows the energy spectrum as it is collected. It can also display multiple (energy) regions of interest (ROI's) and the total count collected in each energy range. These can also be printed out on an X Y recorder.
69
Measurements and Applications MULTICHANNEL SCALER MODE
In the m u l t i c h a n n e l scaler (MCS) mode, the m u l t i c h a n n e l a n a l y z e r records each count as a function of a preset counting interval, At. Each channel is assigned a time interval during which it collects counts. At the end of each time interval, the signal is automatically transferred to a second channel where counts are collected for the same time interval. This continues until all the channels are full. The result is a continuous sequence of counts per unit time (At) as a function of time. This allows the collection and display of data from changing radiation intensity due to changes in tracer activity with changes in position or time. About 6 preset intervals are usually available from the front panel of the i n s t r u m e n t , r a n g i n g from 1 ~tsecond to 1 second, from 1 second to 106 seconds, or from any other desirable base. Since there are usually at least 1000 channels to fill, the actual time interval spent in monitoring can cover virtually any counting situation.
/"~_PHA
-"
ADC
-"-
address register
I
I memory I I cRT I t
~~,
MCS -"
data reg.
___J
Output
Figure 2.20. Multichannel analyzer diagram
The purpose of this mode is to monitor radioactive signals, which change with time. The MSC mode acts in m a n y ways as a count-rate meter, except t h a t the signal is digital, there is no lag, and the counting intervals are preset. Unlike the case of an analog meter, there is no need to pick a counting range, since each channel in the MCA will hold several million counts if need be. It also has the a d v a n t a g e t h a t the d a t a are visible on the cathode r a y display as t h e y are collected and can usually be stored in a battery-supported memory and off-loaded into a computer for further analysis or printed out on a strip recorder.
70
Chapter 2
Marinelli beakers
These are re-entrant beakers in which a gamma detector is surrounded by the sample in cylindrical geometry, as shown in Fig. 2.21. They are widely used for directly counting high-volume, low-level environmental samples. For multiple gamma energies, high resolution of the germanium diode is needed; for widely separated energies, however, the NaI detector can be used. Several computational methods have been described to calculate multiple tracer activities corrected for geometry, efficiency, and position (Verheijke, 1970; Suzuki et al., 1987; Dryak et al., 1989). Their principal application in the oil industry is for counting samples directly without the use of any intervening chemical or physical separation. In the event that a single gamma-emitting isotope is used, e.g., cobalt-60 from an interwell tracer experiment, a large sample could be counted directly in a well-shielded container by dipping a sodium iodide detector into the container. Simple calibration with a known amount of cobalt-60 activity is sufficient for conversion of counts to activity. Such counters are also useful for counting samples of sediment or water in the event of a spill. The more complex gamma-ray analyses required for the tracers used in following downhole acidization and fracturing are better analyzed using a Ge detector and a suitable computational technique.
[3
Marinellibeaker
i I NaI(TI)detector LFI~I~PMT > signal out
Figure 2.21. Marinelli beaker COUNTING RADIOACTIVE ATOMS In recent years, two new methods have been developed to measure the number of radioactive atoms present before they decay. This is a much more sensitive procedure than counting their rate of decay. These methods have a sensitivity about three orders of magnitude below counting methods with greatest sensitivity for long-lived nuclides. Available at several university and National Laboratory locations, these methods are important as a means of
Measurements and Applications
71
extending the dynamic range of interwell tracers. They are not cheap, but for some applications there is no reasonable substitute. These and newer methods may hold the future for tracer applications in environmentally sensitive areas.
A c c e l e r a t o r mass spectrometry This method (Bennet et al., 1978; Muller et al., 1979) accelerates negative ions using two 10 MeV Van de Graaff accelerators in tandem. Atoms are stripped of electrons and focused by electric and magnetic fields on the detector. Capable of rare to stable isotope ratios down to 1:1016, the method has been used for counting chlorine-36. This is a long-lived (T 1/2 = 3 x 106 yrs isotope generated by cosmic rays and available commercially. It has also been reported for counting other long-lived nuclides such as carbon-14 and beryllium-10.
Resonance ion spectrometry This method (Hurst et al., 1980) is based upon the use of lasers of appropriate frequencies to selectively bring the desired species to an excited state and then raise it into the ionization band. From that point, the ions are accelerated to a detector by electrostatic forces. The method has been used to measure krypton-81 trapped in glaciers with a sensitivity of 1000 atoms (Thonnard et al., 1988) and krypton-85 with a sensitivity of 3000 atoms. It has also been used for separating uranium-235.
USEFUL NUCLEAR PROCEDURES There are several nuclear procedures t h a t have reached a high stage of development in other fields but have been largely ignored by the oil industry. Many have applications that could be useful in a number of oilfield tracer problems. A few of these are introduced below and described in somewhat greater detail for suitable applications as they arise in later sections.
Isotope g e n e r a t o r s ADVANTAGES An isotope generator consists of a pair of isotopes in radioactive equilibrium, arranged so t h a t the short-lived daughter can be selectively removed from the generator as needed. It addresses a major problem in the use of radioactive tracers in boreholes, facilities and gathering lines: the danger of contamination of produced fluids and surface materials. It does this by providing a tracer, at the m e a s u r e m e n t site, of such short half-life that the radioactivity disappears by
72
Chapter 2
decay before contamination becomes a problem. This still provides sufficient activity at the test site to permit good measurements, normally a difficult thing to do. The time t h a t would be required to transport a tracer to the test site and place it down hole or in a gathering line would consume most short-lived tracers before they could be used. The isotope generator takes advantage of the long halflife of the parent isotope to transport the short-lived daughter tracer to the site as needed. Most downhole and facility m e a s u r e m e n t s are completed in a relatively short time. A very short-lived tracer could easily do most jobs if it were available at the downhole location in the test site on demand. PROCEDURES
In an earlier section we described secular and transient equilibrium of two radioactive species t h a t are related by the sequential decay of one radioactive species to form the other. This kind of equilibrium is used in isotope generators, sometimes called radioactive "cows," which are used to make short-lived isotopes available for experiments and tests by generating them in situ as needed from a longer-lived parent, as shown in Fig. 2.22 (Ehmann and Vance, 1991).
~).0 "',~
Mo-99 decay
regrowth 1.0
0
!
!
Decay time, days
Figure 2.22. Isotope generator In these systems, a long-lived parent is fixed upon a substrate in such a m a n n e r that the daughter activity can be "milked" off without removing the parent from the substrate. The d a u g h t e r activity is usually eluted from the generator by passing a small volume of solution through it, making a short-lived
Measurements and Applications
73
activity available where it never could have been transported otherwise. Other procedures are also used, but a simple method of stripping the daughter activity is required for use down hole. The short-lived daughter activity can be regenerated m a n y times by simply "milking" the generator in place. Although these cows are widely used in medicine, for some reason they have attracted little attention in the oil field. A partial list of commercially available cows is given in Table 2.1. (The Cs-137/Ba-137m generator is included because it has been available in the past and is particularly useful for oilfield applications.) Cows have great oilfield potential for tracer work in the borehole, in facilities, and in gathering lines. Such generators remove the hazard of surface contamination from produced tracers while permitting the use of high levels of downhole activity. BIOMEDICAL BASE Most of the current work in generator development is driven by the medical goals of reducing patient exposure and increasing the activity available for measurement. In addition to a vast collection of biochemical procedures, isotope generators are also used with such applications as gamma-ray cameras and positron imaging. Although many medical uses are not applicable to the oil field, several commercially available isotope generators can be adapted to satisfy oilfield needs. Table 2.1 lists some of these. For downhole use, they would have to be adapted to high pressure and remote operations, but for gathering lines and facility work they can be used virtually as purchased. Many isotope generators proposed and developed during the past 30 years have been described in reviews (Spytsin and Mikheev, 1971; Henry, 1971).
The technetium generator The most commonly used generator in medicine is the 99mTc generator. In this generator, the p a r e n t isotope, 99Mo (half-life = 66 hr) is prepared by the 98Mo(n,~) reaction. The parent isotope is fixed upon an ion-exchange material so that only technetium is eluted. As the parent decays, the technetium-99m (halflife = 6 hr) grows into transient equilibrium with it. It can be milked off (eluted) periodically, allowing new 99mTc to grow in, as shown in Fig. 2.22. The rate of growth of the Tc is given by the saturation factor 1 - e -~t. The amount of daughter available at any time can be calculated from the equations for transient equilibrium. Thus, four hours after a 10 mCi generator is milked, another 6.3 mCi of Tc becomes available. This generator is used in millions of medical and biochemical procedures worldwide. As a result, it is relatively cheap, available on short notice virtually anywhere in the world, with the generator activity g u a r a n t e e d for delivery date on site. The 99mTc isotope produces a 140 keV x-ray, which would require a detector capable of passing this energy through the pressure housing for downhole use or inserted through the wall for pipeline use.
74
Chapter 2
TABLE 2.1 Commercially available isotope generators
Daughter
Daughter half-life
Daughter gamma energy (MeV)
118 days
ll3mIn
103 min
0.39
132Te
77.7 hr
132I
2.3 hr
99 Mo
66 hr
99mWc
6 hr
0.14
137 Cs
27 yr
137mBa
2.6 min
0.67
280 days
68Ga
1.13 hr
0.511
Parent
Parent half-life
ll3Sn
68Ge
<0.77
Cs-137 has a 27-yr half-life and decays by ~ decay to the 2.6-min d a u g h t e r 137tuBa. Barium-137 is in secular equilibrium with the parent, hence it can be milked as frequently as desired. Cesium-137 is a commonly used downhole isotope but is always in equilibrium with its barium-137m daughter. When cesium-137 is used as a barium-137m generator, it can be milked to provide a continuous source of the 2.6-min activity for flow m e a s u r e m e n t s inside the borehole. The Ba-137m activity is reduced by a thousand in 26 min and by a million in 52 min; hence, no contamination occurs at the surface while more t h a n enough activity remains available for m e a s u r i n g flows in the borehole. The 137Cs: 137mBa generator has been reported several times (Newacheck et al., 1957; Gwyn, 1961; Turtiainen, 1986), for measuring flow rates in pipes, avoiding contamination problems downstream. These are discussed in greater detail in chapter 8 on tracer use in facilities. Measuring flow rates in the borehole should require only a pressure-shielded, remotely operated generator. Applications of isotope generators to specific oilfield problems will be pointed out in other sections as they become relevant.
Isotope dilution procedures Isotope dilution originated as a chemical technique for analyzing a specific m a t e r i a l in a mixture without having to isolate it quantitatively from the mixture. It is still used for t h a t purpose; however it is a powerful technique t h a t has m a n y other applications. It can be used to measure volumes and flow rates in both open and closed systems. It has been used to determine flow rates in pipes, streams, and estuaries, and for measuring the volume of cavities and storage vessels of unknown dimensions. The basic assumptions in isotope dilution are that the tracer is 1) conserved, 2) well mixed with the medium before measurement, and 3) ideal. Conservation
Measurements and Applications
75
of tracer is the basis for all isotope dilution methods. It can be used with either continuous or pulse injection of tracer to monitor mass, volume, or flow rate in a variety of situations, but its most important application to the oil industry is in measuring flow rates. MASS MEASUREMENTS In its original form for measuring the amount (mass) of a given material in a mixture, a radioactive isotope of known specific activity is added as a tracer for the desired component, x. The added tracer is well mixed with the material, a small amount of the mixture containing the added isotope is separated out, and its specific activity remeasured. The specific activity, am, of the tracer by itself is given by am = A/m, where A is the amount of activity in any consistent units and m is the weight in mg. The mixed material will have a specific activity of a'= A/(m + mx), where mx is the weight of x separated out with m after the tracer was added. Since the total amount of tracer, A, is unchanged, amx = a' (m + mx); hence: mx=m
(am -amx) amx
(2.10)
As an example, suppose we wish to analyze a hydrocarbon mixture for the amount of a specific hydrocarbon, HX. We can add a tritium tagged analog HX* having a specific activity, a, to the mixture. The tracer is first placed on a gas chromatographic column, the peak area noted using a suitable detector, and material from t h a t peak counted. The same thing is done with the mixed tracer material at the same position. If the initial activity, a, equals 104 cpm/mg, and if after mixing the new activity is 300 cpm in the same counting system, and the peak area represents 0.04 mg, then from Eq. (2.10), the amount of material in the gas is 0.3 rag. If the original volume of gas analyzed were 10 liters, the concentration of HX in the gas would be 0.3 ppm. This procedure is also used for monitoring trace amounts, where separation losses can be large. Although this procedure was first proposed and developed for use with radioactive isotopes, it is not restricted to radioactivity. It is a common analytical tool in mass spectroscopy using stable isotopes for isotope dilution. A n u m b e r of v a r i a n t s of this procedure have been described (Stary, 1986) for special situations. VOLUME MEASUREMENTS The specific activity of the tracer in terms of volume is given by a = A/v. If this is added to an u n k n o w n volume, after mixing the new material will have a specific activity, a ' = A/(v + v'), where v' is the amount of additional material in the mixture. Since the total amount of activity, A, does not change, the added volume, v', can be calculated in the same m a n n e r as above by:
76
v'= v
Chapter 2
(a-a') a'
(2.11)
In the case of large storage vessels a' is very much less t h a n a, therefore Eq. (2.11) reduces to v/v'= eda', so that the volume can be obtained from the ratio of specific activity before and after mixing. This method does not require a radioactive tracer but will work as well with any chemical tracer. FLOW-RATE MEASUREMENTS Flow r a t e s can be m e a s u r e d by isotope dilution using two different procedures: 1) injection of a solution containing a known concentration of tracer at a constant rate or 2) injection of a pulse containing a known total amount of tracer. The principles of the methods are given here, and details of m e a s u r e m e n t are described in chapter 8 on facilities. Its application to similar m e a s u r e m e n t s in the borehole is discussed in the section on borehole measurements in chapter 7. The volume measurements described above can be used to measure flow rates by the first method. Since tracer is conserved, then by analogy with Eq. (2.11) above, if a tracer with a known specific activity, a (in activity/unit volume), is injected into a pipeline at a constant flow rate, Q, the unknown (constant) flow rate of the pipeline, Q', is then given by Eq. (2.12), where a' is the specific activity after mixing and transport by the moving fluid, as: O ' = O (a-a') a'
(2.12)
This principle has been described (Clayton, 1966; Ljunggren, 1966) and used in a n u m b e r of procedures for accurately measuring flow rate in pipelines, rivers, and other regions of moving fluids. Flow-rate m e a s u r e m e n t s can be made using the second method by injecting a pulse of tracer containing a known amount of activity, A, and m e a s u r i n g the tracer concentration downstream after it is mixed with the flowing stream. Here, the conservation of activity is expressed as: A = J c(v) dv
(2.13)
w h e r e c(v) is the m e a s u r e d tracer concentration d o w n s t r e a m as a function of volume. The volume integral can be transformed to a time integral using J c(v) dv = Q ~ c(t)dt, where Q is the flow rate to be m e a s u r e d and c(t) is the measured concentration as a function of time. Hence: A Q = Jc(t) dt The response is measured at a point downstream where mixing is sufficient.
(2.14)
Measurements and Applications
77
Activation analysis A second nuclear technique used for analysis is activation analysis. This a method for determining the elemental composition of an unknown mixture by measuring the gamma rays emitted in response to an activation procedure, usually neutron activation. It is a rapid, nondestructive analytical procedure. The development of high-resolution gamma-ray spectroscopy has given the method an additional boost and has made multi-element analysis possible At this time, neutron activation analysis (NAA) is available to the public from a number of research reactors operated by universities, and by public and private research groups. Associated with these reactors is availability of hot laboratories, many equipped with remote handling and counting equipment. This analytical technique has not played a major role in the downstream part of the oil industry; however it has provided the base for the use of neutrons in downhole logging and for the analysis of complex gamma spectra. Most of the applications of neutrons in downhole logging are described elsewhere in the logging literature. This material is presented here as an overview of the basic process; greater detail on the use of neutrons for tracer applications will be provided in other sections. First demonstrated by Hevesy and co-workers in the late 1930's, activation analysis did not become important until large neutron fluxes became available from nuclear reactors. The procedure used is to expose the materials to a thermal neutron flux, with the concentration of each constituent obtained from the analysis of the emitted gamma radiation following the irradiation. The principles of NAA are the same as those used for producing radioactive tracers by neutron activation as given in Eq. (1.38); however the major difference lies in the need for reproducibility of conditions in order to assess accuracy of measurement. A great deal of work has gone into clarifying and eliminating sources of error (Erdtmann and Petri, 1986; Alfassi, 1990), and the method is capable of a high degree of precision and accuracy, with sensitivity in the micrograms-per-gram region. NAA is a nondestructive method widely used for multi-element trace analysis in biological and geological samples. Much of the analysis of extraterrestrial mineral specimens was done by NAA. It has been proposed for detecting nonradioactive tracers from interwell tracer tests, but it does not have the sensitivity required to be competitive with radioactive tracers. NAA is also being done by prompt gamma emission, combined chemical separation, delayed gamma emission, epithermal neutron analysis, cyclic activation analysis, pulsed neutron reactor analysis, and a host of other variants (Alfassi, 1990). In addition to NAA, many other nuclear reactions have been developed and have become routine analytical methods. Light elements such as 02, N2, F, Si, A1, etc., are quickly analyzed using 14 MeV neutrons from small generators. The availability of high-energy accelerators has added a large number of special
78
Chapter 2
analytical procedures, particularly useful in analyzing light elements such as nitrogen, oxygen, and fluorine, which are difficult to analyze by other means. The high-energy accelerators are also used to produce isotopes for special purposes, such as isotope generators.
DOSIMETRY Until now the m e a s u r e m e n t of radiation has been discussed only as a m e a n s of m e a s u r i n g the amount of radioactive material present in a source. The topic of dosimetry is concerned with the properties of the radiation field generated by the source and, in this context, with the effect of this radiation on humans. The units used to describe the radiation field and its effects are discussed below.
Dosimetry units Radioactive nuclides generate a radiation field. For g a m m a and X radiation the unit of field intensity used historically is the roentgen (R), the a m o u n t of radiation required to induce 1 electrostatic unit (esu) of charge in 1 cm 3 (.001293 grams) of dry air at s t a n d a r d t e m p e r a t u r e and pressure. The SI unit for this is the a m o u n t of radiation required to induce 1 coulomb in 1 kg. It has no name, hence by default the roentgen is still used, but it is equivalent to 2.58 x 10 -4 coulombs per kilogram (C/kg). Since m a n y old meters for monitoring exposure rate, calibrated in R/hr, are still in service, this unit may be expected to remain in use for a long time. The old unit for the a m o u n t of radiation or dose (H) absorbed by an object exposed to a radiation field is the rad, defined as the absorption of 100 ergs/gm or 0.01 joules per kilogram (J/kg) in the given material. The new SI unit is the gray (Gy), which is the absorption of 1J/kg. One Gy = 100 rad. Since 1.602 x 10 -13 J = 1 MeV, then one Gy = 6.24 x 1012 MeV/kg. The relationship between these units is given in Table 2.2. Since safety is an important consideration in the use of radiation, the effect of different kinds of radiation upon tissue must also be considered in the absorbed dose. The SI unit for the dose equivalent to correct the gray for the quality (Q), of absorbed radiation in tissue is called the sievert (Sv). It replaces the historic unit called the rem (roentgen equivalent man) (R). Because of the large i n s t r u m e n t and literature base using the old unit, both units will probably coexist for some time. New meters are also calibrated in ~tSv/hr. The units are defined as follows: Sv= GyxQ rem (R) = rad (R) x Q For X-ray, beta, and g a m m a radiation, Q is equal to 1, but for neutrons, alpha particles and other positive ions, Q>I and is a significant correction for the specific effects of radiation of different energy on tissue.
Measurements and Applications
79
TABLE 2.2 U n i t s of absorbed dose joules/kg
Gy R
1 .01
MeV/kg
ergs/gm
6.24 x 1012
104
6.24 x 1010
100
Gy 1
R 100
.01
1
Dose calculations ESTIMATED EXTERNAL DOSE FROM A POINT GAMMASOURCE The e s t i m a t i o n of dose r a t e from a source of radiation can be a complex m a t ter; however some simple procedures have evolved for e s t i m a t i n g dose in common situations. G a m m a dose r a t e s from a point source can be e s t i m a t e d from semiempirical equations and from tabulations. An isotopic point source of r a d i a t i o n in curies is r e l a t e d to the exposure rate in R/hr at 1 meter, by: CF R / h r = d2
(2.15)
w h e r e d is t h e distance from the point source in m e t e r s , a nd F is t h e exposure r a t e constant, t a b u l a t e d in Table 2.3 for some common g a m m a e m i t t e r s w h e r e C is in curies. For an exposure rate in mR]hr, C can be expressed in mCi's. As a rule of t h u m b , the exposure rate at one m e t e r can also be e s t i m a t e d from the equation: Exposure r a t e ( m R / h r ) =
6CEn d2
(2.16)
where: E = the g a m m a energy of the g a m m a ray in MeV; n = the n u m b e r of g a m m a q u a n t a per disintegration; C = the activity in mCi; d = distance from source in feet. The value for the constant changes to fit the units used for the p a r a m e t e r s of the equation. ESTIMATED INTERNAL DOSE FROM INGESTED BETA SOURCE It is commonly said t h a t pure beta e m i t t e r s such as t r i t i u m a n d carbon-14 p r e s e n t no r a d i a t i o n h a z a r d and are "safe" to use. This is not t r u e for m a t e r i a l t h a t h a s been ingested, in which case all of the beta energy is absorbed into the body. The dose received from an i n t e r n a l source of beta r a d i a t i o n such as t r i t i u m should be a n o t h e r source of concern.
80
Chapter 2
The l a r g e s t use of t r i t i u m in the oil field is in the form of t r i t i a t e d water. It would be instructive to calculate the dose r a t e in m R / h r (~Sv/hr) and the total dose received from the ingestion of 10 mCi (37 MBq) of t r i t i a t e d water. This is an i m p o r t a n t n u m b e r since 50 percent of the w a t e r enters the body t h r o u g h t h e skin. The following base is used for the calculation:
TABLE 2.3 Specific g a m m a ray constants
Nuclide Ba-133 Cs-137 / Ba-137 Cr-51 Co-57 Co-60 Ga-67 Au-192 1-131 1-132 Ir-192 Ra-226 Sc-46 Sn-ll3 Xe-133 Sb-124
F, g a m m a ray constants 2.4 3.3 0.16 0.9 13.2 1.1 2.3 2.2 11.8 4.8 8.25 10.9 1.7 0.1 9.8
1. The biological half-life of w a t e r in the body is about seven days. 2. The " s t a n d a r d " m a n weighs 75 kg (165 lb) and contains 43,000 gm of water. 3. The average energy of a t r i t i u m beta is 0.006 MeV. 4. One rad = 62.4 x 106 MeV/gm. 5. All the beta radiation is absorbed in the water. As a first step: 10 mCi 3.7 x 107dps 0.006 MeV 43000 gm x mCi x dis. = 51.6 MeV/gm sec hence: 3600 103mR 51.6 x 6 2 . 4 x 106 x rad = 3.0 mR/hr (30 ~tSv/hr)
(2.17)
Measurements and Applications
81
The retention of tritiated water in the body is controlled by its biological halflife. Compared to the short retention half-life of 7 days, the physical half-life of tritium (12.6 yr) is not significant. The average life, x, of tritium in the body is derived from the biological half-life by: 1 n ~ =~
tl/2 .693 - 10 days
The total dose within the range sources per year. The procedure say. A 2-ml urine of: 2x
(2.18)
received = 0.3 mR]hr x 24 hr/day x 10 days = 720 mR. This is of the average a m o u n t of radiation received from n a t u r a l used to monitor for ingestion of tritiated water is urine bioassample within 24 hours of ingestion should have a count rate
3.7 x 108 43000 = 1.7 x 104 counts per minute
(2.19)
Service companies are required by law to provide urine bioassays for oil company employees who may be exposed to large sources of tritiated water. The estimate of dose rate as calculated above can be generalized for any beta emitter assuming the conditions above for a standard man: Beta dose rate (mR/hr) = 50. C. E. n
(2.20)
where C is the radioactivity in mCi, E is the average beta energy in MeV, and n is the fraction of decays having that energy.
L I C E N S I N G AND C O N T R O L OF R A D I O A C T I V E M A T E R I A L The limits authorized by regulatory agencies for the safe handling of radioactive materials are based upon recommendations from two organizations: the National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements (NCRP) in the U.S., and the International Commission on Radiological Protection (ICRP). The NCRP is an independent organization chartered by Congress, whereas the ICRP was set up by a technical society, the International Congress of Radiology. The two organizations are composed of representatives of m a n y technical societies and work closely together. Regulations setting the standards for control of exposure from the use of radioactive materials are governed by an appropriate national regulatory agency in each country. In the U.S. the situation is rather complicated. The Nuclear Regulatory Agency (NRC) and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) formulate the regulations. The NRC enforces the regulations together with agreement states states t h a t have taken over the regulatory function of the NRC by setting up
82
Chapter 2
an equivalent regulatory agency within their borders. Regulations covering naturally occurring radioactive material (NORM) and other nonbyproduct materials are controlled by the states, and these are quite variable. The regulations are given in Title 10 of the Code of Federal Regulations (10 CFR). Strictly speaking, these pertain only to reactor-produced isotopes. Naturally occurring isotopes and those produced by particle accelerators are controlled by the states. In practice, the NRC is concerned with any use of refined nuclides. Except for certain exemptions, all users of radioactive material must be licensed by the NRC or by an agreement state. A general license is given for the use of exempt quantities and concentrations of certain isotopes (10 CFR 30.18, 30.71 Schedule B) that excuses the user from applying for a specific license for these materials, but not from the regulations for safe use of radioactivity. The standards for safe use of radioactive materials are given in Title 10, Part 20 of the Code of Federal Regulations (10 CFR 20), and in the separate regulations derived from this code by agreement states. The pertinent regulations covering the licensing of radioactive materials for various uses are given in 10 CFR, parts 30 - 40. A license to use radionuclides is obtained from the appropriate state or federal agency upon request. It is initiated by filling out a special material license form in which the requester names the nuclides requested, their intended use, and the maximum quantities in possession at any time. The requester answers a number of questions on the ability of the users and the safe handling of the materials, including equipment handling, emergency procedures, and waste disposal. Requesters must show that they are equipped with the proper instruments for monitoring radiation dose and that they can maintain the required records. The records are important and subject to periodic review by inspectors. Recordkeeping by the users is at the heart of the radiation control system set up by the regulating authorities. This includes personnel exposure, radiation surveys, bioassay records, tracer receipts, waste disposal, history of all radioactive materials possessed by the user, and any other records required to show compliance with the regulations according to 10 CFR 20 or equivalent state regulations. Noncompliance with these requirements can result in fines and loss of license privileges. A complicated set of rules and regulations governs the transportation of radioactive materials. The transport of most of these materials falls under the Department of Transportation (DOT). The body of regulations is given under 49 CFR, parts 172 and 173. Shipment by air is covered in 49 CFR, 176 parts A-D and M, shipment by rail in 49 CFR 174, parts A-D and K. Shipment by public highway is covered in 49 CFR 177; and the pertinent DOT regulations to cover packaging, marking and labeling, placarding, monitoring, and shipping papers are found in 10 CFR 71.5. Materials classified as "limited quantities" have much simpler regulations. The amount and concentration allowed for each isotope is given in
Measurements and Applications
83
the above references. They require special marking and m u s t contain the statement "This package conforms to the conditions and limitations of 49 CFR 173.421 for excepted radioactive materials, limited quantities, N.O.S., UN4910." A level above "limited quantities" is t h a t of "low specific activity," which still is exempt from some of the packaging and shipping paper regulations.
R a d i a t i o n protection: ALARA a n d MPC At the time of writing, the U.S. is revising m a n y of its regulations for the control of radiation. The principles and the background behind the proposed regulations for radiation protection are given in the revised S t a n d a r d s for Protection Against Radiation, 10 CFR, part 20, published in the federal register for May 21, 1991. The old units for radiation and radioactivity are still used in these proposals, but the equivalent SI units are also shown in parentheses. They are worth reading for insight into the regulatory process in radiation control. These standards are essentially the same worldwide. The s t a n d a r d for radiation exposure places a limit on the m a x i m u m a n n u a l radiation dose t h a t an individual may receive. For occupationally exposed peronnel, this limit is 5 rem (50 mSv) per year. For the general public, it is reduced to 100 mR (1 mSv) per year. It is to be understood, however, t h a t the dose will be kept "as low as reasonably achievable," expressed by the acronym ALARA. The old m a x i m u m permissible concentrations (MPC) are to be replaced with a new set of numbers given in appendix B of the proposed regulations as Table 1 for occupationally exposed workers, Table 2 for unrestricted areas, and Table 3 for disposal into the sewer. The values for occupational exposure to some common waterflood tracers were abstracted from Table 1 above and appear in Table 2.4 in this chapter. For the first time, these regulations also go into detail on how the numbers were derived. The maximum permissible concentration (MPC) for unrestricted areas is widely used in calculating the a m o u n t of radioactivity to be injected in oilfield tracer tests. It is useful to u n d e r s t a n d how these n u m b e r s were arrived at and what they mean. The effluent concentrations listed in Table 2 of the appendix in the proposed regulations are equivalent to the radionuclide concentrations that, if ingested or inhaled continuously over the course of a year, would produce a total effective dose equivalent of 50 m r e m (0.5 mSv). The effluent concentration is divided into two parts, one for the limit in water and one for the limit in air. The "Annual Limit of Intake" (ALI) chosen is a factor of the chemical composition. The water limit is calculated from the ALI required to arrive at this dose. This is done by dividing the volume of water consumed in one year by the s t a n d a r d m a n by a factor of 50 to reduce the dose to 100 mR, and by an additional factor of 2 to remove age considerations.
84
Chapter 2
TABLE 2.4 M a x i m u m occupational concentrations (10 CFR 20, Appendix B, Table 1) Isotope
Class
H-3 C-14 C-14 C-14 Co-57 Co-57 Co-60 Co-60
water* CO CO2 compounds **W **Y **W **Y
Oral ingestion ALI, ~tCi 8 x 104
2 8 4 5 2
x x x x x
103 103 103 102 102
Inhalation ALI, ~tCi/ml DAC, ~Ci/ml 8 2 2 2 2 7 2 3
x x x x x x x x
104 106 105 103 103 102 102 10
2x 7x 9x 1x 4x 3x 7x I x
10 -5 10-4 10 -5 10 -6 10 -9 10 -7 10 -8 10 -8
* DAC includes skin absorption. ** ALI's a n d DAC's for aerosol with average d i a m e t e r of l~m. W = r a n g e of clearance half-times between 10 and 100 days. Y = g r e a t e r t h a n 100 days.
Table 3 of the above appendix gives the m a x i m u m permissible concentrations for disposal in sewers. It is derived from the ALI by dividing it by the a n n u a l w a t e r i n t a k e and reducing the concentration by a factor of 10. If sewage were the only source of w a t e r for th e reference m a n over one year, he would receive a c o m m i t t e d dose of 500 mR. U n d e r these conditions, presumably, ra dia tion would be a m o n g the least of his problems. T a b l e s 2 a n d 3 in th e proposed federal r e g u l a t i o n s d i s c u s s e d above a re a b s t r a c t e d in Table 2.5 using some of the t r a c e r elements t h a t are i m p o r t a n t for waterflood tracing as examples. TABLE 2.5 M a x i m u m concentrations, unrestricted areas
Isotope
Class
Table 2 Effluent concentrations Air, ~Ci/ml Water, ~Ci/ml
H-3 water* I x 10 -7 C-14 CO 2 x 10 -6 C-14 CO2 3 x 10 -7 C-14 Compounds 3 x 10 -9 Co-57 **W 4 x 10 -9 Co-57 **Y 9 x 10 -9 Co-60 **W 2 x 10 -10 Co-60 **Y 5 x i0 -11 # = average mo n th ly concentration
Table 3 Sewer release #, ~tCi/ml
I x 10 -3
1 x 10 -2
3 x 10 -5 6 x 10 -5
3 x 10 -4 6 x 104
3 x 10 -6
3 x 10 -5
Measurements and Applications
85
REFERENCES
Alfassi, Z.B. (ed.), Activation Analysis (2 vols.), CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL (1989). Beckman Instruments Nuclear Systems, "LS 6800, 7800, 9800 Series Liquid Scintillation Systems," Operating Manual (1985). Bennet, C.L., Beukins, R.P., Clover, M.R., Elsmore, H.E., Gove, H.E., Kilius, L., Litherland, A.E., and Purser, K.H., "Radiocarbon Dating with Electrostatic Accelerators: Dating of Milligram Samples," Science (1978) 201, 346. Bennett, E.F., and Yule, T.J., Argonne Natl. Lab. Rept. ANL7763 (1973). Birks, J.B., The Theory and Practice of Scintillation Counting, Pergamon Press, Oxford (1964). Carpenter, B.S., D'Agostino, M.D., and Yule, H.D. (eds.), "Computers in Activation Analysis and Gamma Ray Spectroscopy," Proc. Amer. Nuc. Soc. Conf., Mayaguez, PR, April 30 - May 4, 1978, DOE (1979). Clayton, C.G., and Smith, D.R., "A Comparison of Radioisotope Methods for River Flow Measurement," Proc., Symp. Radioisotopes in Hydrology, IAEA, Vienna (1963) 563. Dryak, P., Kover, P., Plechova, L., and Suran, J., "Correction for the Marinelli Geometry," J. Radioanal. Chem. (1989) 135, 4, 281. Ehmann, W.D., and Vance, D.E., Radiochemistry and Nuclear Methods of Analysis, John Wiley, New York (1991). Emery E.W., "Geiger-Mueller and Proportional Counters," in Radiation Dosimetry, Vol. II, Attix, F.E., and Roesch, W.C. (eds.), Academic Press, New York (1966). Erdtmann, G., and Petri, H., "Nuclear Activation Analysis: Fundamentals and Techniques," in Treatise on Analytical Chemistry, Elving and Kolthoff (eds.), Part 1, 14, 419, John Wiley, New York (1986). Evans, R.D., The Atomic Nucleus, Krieger, New York (1982). Friedlander, G., Kenedy, J.W., Macias, E.S., and Miller, J.M., Nuclear and Radiochemistry, 3d ed., John Wiley, New York (1981). Gwyn, J.E., "Fast Response Pulse Tests Use of Gamma Milking," Ind. Eng. Chem. (1961) 53, 908. Heath, R.L., Scintillation Spectrometry Gamma Ray Spectrum Catalogue, (2 vols.) IDO-16880 (1964). Henry, R., "Isotope Generators, Present and Future," J. Nucl. Bio. Med. (1971) 15, 105. Horrocks, D.L., Applications of Liquid Scintillation Counting, Academic Press, New York (1974).
86
Chapter 2
Hurst, G.S., Payne, M.G., Kramer, S.C., and Young, J.P., "Resonance Ion Spectroscopy and One Atom Detection," Rev. Mod. Phys. (1979) 51, 767. Knoll, G.F., Radiation Detection and Measurement, John Wiley, New York (1989). Korff, S.A., Electron and Nuclear Counters, D. Van Nostrand, New York (1955). Ljunggren, K., "Review of the Use of Radioactive Tracers for Evaluating Parameters Pertaining to the Flow of Material in Plant and Natural Systems," Proc., Symp. Radioisotopes in Hydrology, IAEA, Vienna (1963) 303. Muller, R.A., "Radioisotope Dating with Accelerators," Physics Today (1979) 32, No. 2, 23. Newacheck, R.L., Beaufait, L.J. Jr., and Anderson, E.E., "Isotope Milker Supplies 137Ba from Parent 137Cs," Nucleonics (May 1957) 15, No. 5, 122. Packard Instrument Co., "How to get the Best Results from Your Scintillation Counter," LSC Workshop Manual, 3d ed. (1982). Pilgrim, D.H., "Correction of Ratemeter Readings with Varying Count Rates for Response Time Lag," Int. J. Appl. Radiation and Isotopes (1965) 16, 461. Radiological Health Handbook, Bureau of Radiological Health, U.S. Dept. of HE&W, Superintendent of Documents, Washington, DC (1970).
RCA Photomultiplier Manual, Tech. Series PT-61, RCA Solid State Division, Electro-Optics and Devices, Lancaster, PA (1970). Schonfeld, E., Nucl. Instrum. Methods (1967) 52, 177. Spytsin, V.I., and Mikheev, N.B., "Generators for the Production of Short-lived Radioisotopes," At. Energy Rev. (1971) 9, No. 4, 787. Stary, J., "Determination Techniques Based on Radiotracers," in Treatise on Analytical Chemistry, Elving and Kolthoff (eds.), Part 1, 14, 241, John Wiley, New York (1986). Suzuki, T., Inokoshi, Y., Chisaka, H., Nakamura, T., "Optimum Geometry of Large Marinelli-type Vessels for In-situ Environmental Sample Measurements with Germanium (Lithium) Detectors," Appl. Radiat. Isot. (1987) 39, No. 3, 253-56' Thonnard, N., Willis R.D., Wright, M.C., and Davis, W.A., "Resonance Ion Spectroscopy and the Detection of 81Kr," Nuc. Instruments and Methods in Phys. Res. B (1987) 29,398. Tsoulfanidis, N., Measurement and Detection of Radiation, Hemisphere Publishing Corp., Washington, DC (1983). Turtiainen, H., "Flow Measurements with Radioactive Tracers Using the Transit Time Method," Valt. Tek. Tutkimuskeskus Tutimuksia (Aug. 1986) 421.
Measurements and Applications
87
Verheijke, M.L., "Calculated Efficiencies of Na(T1) Scintillation Crystals for Marinelli Beakers with Aqueous Sources," Int. J. Appl. Radiat. Isotop. (1970) 21, No. 3, 119. Wahl, J.S., "Gamma Ray Logging," Geophysics (1983) 48, No. 11, 1536. Wilkinson, D.H., Ionization Chambers and Counters, Cambridge University Press, London (1950). Yule, H.P., J. Radioanal. Chem. (1973) 15, 695.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CHAPTER 3
INTERWELL
WATER TRACERS
INTRODUCTION The usefulness of waterflood tracers is based upon the assumption t h a t the movement of the tracer reflects the movement of the injected water. How closely this holds true depends upon how closely the tracer follows the injected water through a formation without significant loss or delay. This in turn depends upon how well the chemical composition of the tracer meets the constraints set by the properties of the formation. Radioactive isotopes are used to tag chemical tracers to provide analytical tools of high selectivity and sensitivity. The tracer properties, however, are defined only by their chemical composition. This chapter is concerned with designing and carrying out a waterflood tracer test using both radioactive and nonradioactive tracers. Information is presented on the choice and preparation of tracer materials, field injection procedures, and methods for collecting and analyzing samples of produced water for tracers. Ionexchange procedures are emphasized because of their importance in both chemical and radioactive tracers.
FUNCTIONS OF A WATERFLOODING TRACER Waterflooding and water-based floods are the most widely used secondary and tertiary oil recovery methods. The principles of waterflooding are described in most standard reservoir engineering texts and in special waterflood monographs (Craig, 1971; Wilhite, 1986). Application of the theory to field operations is hampered by a lack of detailed knowledge about the reservoir and how the fluids move through it. In cases where the water entering the field comes from m a n y different sources, managing the waterflood operation can become difficult. The addition of a tracer to the injected water is the only means of distinguishing between injection water and formation water, or between waters from different injection wells in the same field. Tracers are added to waterfloods for many reasons and in a variety of circumstances. They can be a powerful tool for describing the reservoir, investigating unexpected anomalies in flow, or verifying suspected geological barriers or flow channels. They can also be used in a test section of the field before expanding the flood. Flow in most reservoirs is anisotropic. The reservoir structures are usually layered and frequently contain significant heterogeneities leading to directional variations in the extent of flow. As a result, the m a n n e r in which water moves in the reservoir can be difficult to predict. Tracers are used in enhanced oil recovery pilot tests to monitor the actual water-flow pattern during the test.
90
Chapter 3
The ability to identify the water source is basic to the use of tracers for all the purposes described above. The tracer response as a function of position and time provides a qualitative description of fluid movement that can play a useful part in managing the flood; however it is also possible to obtain quantitative measure of water movement in the reservoir from the tracer data.
History and development An ideal water tracer must meet two requirements: it must faithfully follow the path and velocity of the water with which it is injected, and it must be easy to identify and measure quantitatively. Differences in test and operating conditions can lead to large differences in apparent tracer suitability. These differences have led to contradictory conclusions about tracer use. Tracers have a long history of use for tagging water. Suitable materials for this purpose have included everything from sticks, dyes, and mushroom spores to chemical and radioactive tracers. Early work on tracers for use in following water in streams, underground caverns, sanitary systems, ground water, and oil fields reported tests on the use of a variety of materials as water tracers. (Slichter, 1905; Fox, 1952; Kaufman and Orlob, 1956; Halevy et al., 1958; Barker et al., 1959; Skibitzke et al., 1961; Halevy et al., 1962; Weibenga et al., 1967). Tracer suitability has varied with the constraints and conditions of the tests. Tracers for streams, both open and underground, have few constraints except for environmental conditions. Tracers for following water through aquifers and for following groundwater flow are much more constrained. Various organic materials, including such compounds as dextrose, picric acid, glycine, salicylic acid, fluorescene, and a variety of alcohols, have been tested with generally poor results; tracers either did not survive or showed long delays in appearance (Greenkorn, 1961; Lansdown, 1961). Inorganic compounds such as tritiated w a t e r and simple anions such as nitrate, halides, and thiocyanate fared much better. Highly oxidized anions such as dichromate, permanganate, and borate did poorly, as did a number of cations, including radioactive isotopes. The search for water tracers for use in waterflooding oil fields followed the same p a t t e r n as the tests above. Many organic and inorganic compounds were tested (Watkins, 1957; Heemstra et al., 1961; Greenkorn, 1961). Because of differences in conditions, some of the data are contradictory, but over the years a small group of tracers has come to be regarded as generally useful for oilfield waterfloods.
Reservoir constraints The survival of tracers depends upon the nature of the oilfield reservoirs in which they are used. These reservoirs (and the materials used for standard test
Interwell Water Tracers
91
cores) have certain properties t h a t act as constraints on the permissible properties of the tracers. These materials generally have negatively charged surfaces and contain varying amounts of clays with high cation-exchange capacities. The reservoir environment is a reducing one and the surface-to-volume ratio of the porous medium is large. Oil, water, and gas can coexist in the reservoir, and there can be a significant population of bacteria. Successful tracers are those that are not delayed or lost by interacting with these reservoir properties. By definition, these are ideal tracers (Lake, 1990) and should be carried at the velocity of the injected water. The reservoir constraints can show up in different ways TRACER EXCHANGE Ions adsorbed on the reservoir surfaces are free to exchange with ions in solution and tend to be in equilibrium with them. This is a reversible process known as ion exchange. The negatively charged surfaces of the reservoir absorb positively charged ions by electrostatic forces. If the tracer ions are positively charged, they can exchange with the cations adsorbed on the reservoir surfaces. The small diameters of pores in the reservoir and the low velocity of most waterfloods ensure t h a t there will be a local equilibrium between the ions on the surfaces and those in the water. Tracer ions are immobile when on the surface and only move at water velocity when in the water. Depending upon the nature of the cation, there is a fixed probability that it will spend a certain fraction of time on the surface; hence, the tracer ions will be delayed relative to w a t e r passage by the fraction of time they spend on the immobile surface. The velocity of the tracer pulse containing positively charged ions will thus be lower t h a n the w a t e r velocity. If the cation is very strongly absorbed by the surface, it may become essentially immobile and entirely lose its ability to trace the water. A similar effect can occur if some of the tracer is soluble in the oil phase. The fraction of tracer in the oil will move at the velocity of the oil phase; if the oil is immobile, the tracer will be delayed relative to the water phase by the fraction of time it spends in the oil, as in the case above. If the oil phase is mobile, the situation is more complicated; however the tracer velocity will not truly reflect the velocity of the water. In either event the tracer is no longer an ideal tracer, even though ultimately it may all be produced. TRACER REACTION In the case of tracer delay, as described above for reversible ion exchange, the tracer will arrive later t h a n the water; but all of it will ultimately arrive since the tracer is conserved. In cases where exchange is irreversible, or where there is a change in chemical form as by bacterial attack or chemical reaction, some or all of the tracer may never be produced with the water. In this case, the tracer is not conserved and is no longer ideal, even though a reduced tracer pulse may arrive without apparent delay.
92
Chapter 3
Tracer materials t h a t lose solubility or react chemically with the ions in solution are also undesirable for the above reasons. Thus, carbonate and sulfate ions, which can react to form insoluble precipitates with m a n y common reservoir ions, are undesirable tracers unless the latter are absent from the reservoir. The use of radioactive cobalt and cesium as cations for w a t e r tracing was recently reported (Wood, 1989). Cesium-134 and -137 and cobalt-57 and -60 used as cations, with and without ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid (EDTA) as a complexing agent, were injected into a small waterflood pilot in a carbonate reservoir. In the case of carbonate reservoirs, however, the charge on the surfaces depends upon the pH of the formation water. If the surfaces were negatively charged they would become anion exchangers, and cations r a t h e r t h a n anionic tracers would be required. If the clay content is low, such cationic tracers would be suitable. The only other report of injections of cationic tracers in the literature (Asga~pour, 1987, 1988) showed no tracer response (except for tritiated water) aider two years. TRACER MATERIALSFOR INTERWELLUSE While ideal tracers are desirable, there are many situations in which nonideal tracers are adequate for flow description. In the case of fracture paths, where surface-to-volume ratios are relatively low and velocities are r a t h e r large, dyes may be satisfactory indicators even if some of the dye is lost by absorption on the reservoir. If the only purpose of the tracer is to indicate the source and direction of flow through the reservoir, as to identify sealing or conducting faults, a small delay in tracer arrival may not be important and can be ignored. A long delay, however, may result in undue dilution of tracer, making detection difficult. The delay may also imply a nonexistent flow behavior and should be avoided. In general, tracers for waterfloods should be ideal. They should be anionic or neutral materials t h a t are totally water soluble and do not react chemically or physically with other materials in the reservoir. This precludes the use of cations, large, polarizable molecules such as dyes, or easily reduced or reactive materials. Materials that are extractable into the oil, have a high vapor pressure, or are subject to bacterial attack should also be avoided.
R a d i o a c t i v e a n d u n t a g g e d c h e m i c a l tracers There is a widespread misconception that "chemical" and radioactive tracers are different kinds of tracers. In fact, all waterflood tracers are compounds having specific chemical properties. Radioactive isotopes can be used to tag some of the compounds that have proven to be suitable for this purpose. This provides these compounds with a highly selective and sensitive analytical method. While we refer to them as radioactive tracers, it is important to remember t h a t they are radioactively tagged chemical tracers. The same materials without a radioactive tag are also useful tracers.
Interwell Water Tracers
93
Except for the nitrate and bromide ions all waterflood tracers in current use can be tagged with radioactive isotopes. There is no radioactive isotope of suitable half-life for either the nitrate or bromide tracers. The use of radioactivity provides a very sensitive analytical method for detecting and m e a s u r i n g waterflood tracers. In addition, it almost doubles the tracers available for use, because the detection limit for radioactive tracers is sufficiently lower t h a n t h a t for the chemical itself that tracers rarely interfere with chemical analysis. The discussion of waterflood tracers in this section will begin with radioactively tagged tracers, taking into consideration their chemical nature. It will be followed by a discussion of the analytical problems and procedures specific to nonradioactive tracers.
RADIOACTIVELY TAGGED TRACERS FOR WATERFLOODS R a d i o a c t i v e t r a c e r s a v a i l a b l e for field use
The n u m b e r of radioactive tracers suitable for use as waterflood tracers is severely limited by two factors: the tracer must have the chemical properties required to survive the environment, and it m u s t have nuclear properties t h a t m a k e it suitable for monitoring. As a result, only a m a x i m u m of four nuclides combined in only three different chemical forms are currently used for waterflood tracing. In m a n y cases the number of tracers listed below is adequate; however m u l t i p l e - p a t t e r n floods can place a severe strain on the n u m b e r of applicable tracers. The current list of radioactive waterflood tracers with a good history of success in the field is limited to the materials in Table 3.1. Comments appear in the literature from time to time suggesting t h a t various tracers are not "ideal" because of properties that alter their path from t h a t of the injected water. Such comments argue t h a t tritiated water, for example, can lose tritium to the reservoir by exchange with hydrogen ions in connate w a t e r or with other fixed sources of hydrogen ions. Similar arguments are made t h a t anionic tracers move "faster" t h a n neutral tracers because they are excluded from the connate w a t e r layer by their negative charge. Many other such comments are passed on by word of mouth. At present there is no quantitative evidence of any significant differences in field behavior among the common tracers. Virtually all easily available radioactive nuclides of practical half-life are either cationic or otherwise unsuitable for tracing water. Many field and lab tests have, however, established such ions as thiocyanate and hexacyanocobaltate as stable anionic carriers for the normally cationic cobalt isotopes and for 14C. Many tests using these tracers have been carried out in oilfield waterfloods throughout the world.
94
Chapter 3
TABLE 3.1 Radioactive interwell water tracers Compound (ion)
Formula
Radioactive Isotope
Hexacyanocobaltate
Co(CN) 6-
60Co, 58Co, 57Co, 14C
Tritiated Water
HTO
3H
Thiocyanate
SCN-
14C, 35S
Halides
Cl-, I-
36C1' 125I
Alcohols
CnH2nOH
3H, 14C
HEXACYANOCOBALTATEIONS The hexacyanocobaltate ion is a very stable ion with a formation constant of about 1038. It was first introduced as a groundwater tracer (Halevy et al., 1958) and is now widely used as a cobalt isotope carrier throughout the world. It is, however, currently prohibited in the British sector of the North Sea because of some accidents in which the tracer (Co-60) remained in the well tubing following injection in a well on a North Sea platform. Although the reasons for this are not known, errors in the preparation of the compound are suspected. This author has been involved in more than thirty waterfloods in the continental United States and Alaska in which Co-60 was injected as the hexacyano complex. In all of these, the surface tubing was monitored until the count rate returned to background, and no evidence of tubing contamination was found. Similar results were noted in a recent paper, where no cobalt-60 contamination was reported after logging the wells (Lichtenberger, 1989). This material should, however, always be tested before injection to ensure that it is an anionic complex. Hexacyanocobaltate can be used as a carrier for the two cobalt nuclides as well as for carbon-14. Cobalt-60 undergoes beta decay with a 5.3-yr half-life and the emission of two high-energy gamma rays (1.17, 1.13 MeV) per beta. It can be monitored in a 3-in. diameter Nal well counter with an efficiency of about 60 percent. Cobalt-57 decays by electron capture with a 9-mo half-life, and can be counted with good efficiency (>90 percent) in a Nal well counter. Both nuclides undergo beta decay and can also be counted in a liquid scintillation counter with more than 90 percent efficiency. TRITIATED WATER Tritiated water has the longest history of use as an oilfield tracer. It differs from conventional water in that it contains hydrogen of mass 3 instead of mass 1. Its chemical properties are otherwise identical; however a kinetic effect is noted due to the relatively large mass difference between the two hydrogen isotopes.
Interwell Water Tracers
95
Although this is not sufficient to affect the use of tritiated w a t e r as a w a t e r tracer, the difference in rate constants is sufficient to allow enrichment of tritium in w a t e r by electrolysis. Tritium undergoes beta decay with a half-life of about 12.7 years. It emits beta particles of very low energy and no g a m m a radiation, hence it presents virtually no external radiation hazard. Tritiated w a t e r has a biological half-life of about a week in the body. The low energy of the beta requires internal counting by liquid scintillation. It can be counted directly in a 50 percent mixture of produced brines with about 25 percent efficiency. The figure of m e r i t can be significantly increased by distilling off the w a t e r sample before counting it. OTHER ANIONIC COMPLEXES Despite the success of the complex cobalt cyanide as a waterflood tracer, the only other complex anions proposed in the literature are the chelating complexes of e t h y l e n e d i a m i n e tetraacetic acid (EDTA) and its analogs (Watkins et al., 1962), using radioactive cations. They have not had a high success rate in oilfield practice because of exchange with other cations in solutions t h a t form stronger complexes and/or are far more numerous. The areas of use would depend on the presence and concentration of competing divalent ions such as Ca++ t h a t form strong complexes in solution. Iridium-192 has been proposed as the (IrC16) -3 ion, a complex t h a t has not been successful with use in normal brine solution. A n u m b e r of complex cyanides are potential candidates for tracing waterfloods: the dicyanoaurate (Au(CN)2)-2, the dicyanomercuric, and the t e t r a c y a n o n i c k e l a t e complexes have formation constants on the order of 10 40 and merit investigation. The dicyanoaurate has been tested successfully (Thatcher and Ramsey, 1977) as a g r o u n d w a t e r tracer; however no reports on the use of these or other complex cyanides for waterflood tracing have been found in the literature. The 186-day half-life gold-195 and 100-yr half-life nickel-63 isotopes would be suitable for tagging these complexes. The hexacyanocobaltates seem to have been successful cobalt tracers; however in view of the aforementioned problems reported in the North Sea, an effort should be made to find additional gamma-emitting tracers. SPECIALTY TRACERS A n u m b e r of specialty radioactive tracers have been reported and used for waterfloods, including short-lived anions such as the 8-day half-life 1-131. Shortlived isotopes are useful where injection response is relatively fast, as in a suspected fracture or thief zone. As a rough rule of thumb, they can be used for periods up to six times the half-life before handling and analytical problems become too great. Chlorine-36 is a m a n m a d e isotope having a half-life of 3.5x105 years. It is quite expensive to make because of its long half-life; however it can be detected in very small quantities by atom counting as described in chapter 2, using accelerator mass spectrometry.
96
Chapter 3
Several reports have been published on the use of tagged alcohols as water tracers. All the simple alcohols partition into oil and are subject to bacterial attack, the partition coefficients increasing with carbon number. For methanol the effect is negligible (Wood et al., 1990), and for ethanol the partition is quite small; however for propyl alcohol and the higher-carbon n u m b e r alcohols the effect of partition is quite noticeable. For tracer tests in which identification of the source of the water is the only objective, this may not be significant; otherwise alcohol will lag the waterfront. In general the odd carbon number alcohols are more resistant to bacterial attack than the even-numbered ones. Some of the alcohols, such as isopropyl and tertiary butyl, are particularly resistant and can serve as biocides. If there is a high concentration of a naturally occurring isotope in the formation water, it can serve as a carrier, allowing otherwise unusable ions to serve as tracer, e.g., naturally occurring strontium ions in solution for 90Sr. The tracer will be carried by the mass effect of the naturally occurring strontium isotopes in solution, reducing the lag. In the case of strontium, the exchange of 90Sr with the natural strontium isotopes on the reservoir surface in the formation still causes a significant lag. Tests performed in the North Slope of Alaska showed a significant delay in the arrival of Sr-90 over that of tritiated water, despite the presence of strontium ion in the produced water (Loder, 1992). The use of 22Na has been proposed (Bjornsted et al., 1990) on a similar basis using a sensitive analytical method for 22Na. In very saline brines it may, however, be possible to eliminate much of the lag by a sufficiently high concentration of the naturally occurring sodium isotope. The water volumes involved in most waterfloods are large, so that dilution of the injected tracers is extensive and sensitive methods of analysis are required. The high cost of labor precludes the use of m a n y chemical manipulations for analyzing samples. Therefore, the tracers chosen should be easily analyzed using automatic or semiautomatic methods of high sensitivity and selectivity. Radioactive materials are uniquely suited to this purpose, since the combination of suitable chemical form and specific radiation properties provides both high sensitivity and selectivity. In addition, radiation monitoring lends itself to automatic counting operations. Generally, analysis of these compounds should use a separation scheme t h a t accomplishes as much of the analysis as possible by direct counting. Many p a t t e r n floods can be followed using only four different tracers, although occasionally more are needed to avoid ambiguity. In some patterns, two or three tracers may be sufficient to provide unambiguous answers.
Tracer quality control Remarkably little quality control is exerted in the sale of waterflood tracers. The stated quality and quantity of the tracers provided are usually accepted at
Interwell Water Tracers
97
face value. Few people seek evidence of either radiochemical purity or amount. There have been many cases of error in these factors, and failed tracer projects have been attributed to such errors (Omoregie et al., 1987). At the current state of waterflood tracing, two kinds of companies are usually involved in a field tracer injection, each licensed separately: the supplier who provides the material in the correct chemical form and activity to the service company; and the service company that injects the material in the field and deals with the client. Quality control is minimal; often the service company supplies the tracer design, injects the tracers, and provides the tracer response data to the client. In other cases, the client may design the test and analyze the water for produced tracer, while the service company acquires the tracer and does the field injection. Testing to verify how much of each tracer was injected or whether the right tracer was supplied is rarely done. In the preparation of specialty organic compounds labeled with radioactivity, it is conventional for the supplier to provide data such as radiochromatograms showing that the compound is properly labeled and contains the correct amount of radioactivity. Such evidence should also be requested for waterflood tracers The best way to verify the actual quality and q u a n t i t y of a tracer is by analysis of an aliquot of the batch of tracer material to be injected. In this context, an aliquot is a small, measured volume of the actual tracer solution shipped for field injection. This aliquot can be analyzed by the supplier, the service company, the user, or an independent laboratory. The principal source for an independent laboratory is either a university with a nuclear engineering d e p a r t m e n t or a government laboratory. In the United States, a n u m b e r of universities with nuclear engineering d e p a r t m e n t s (Shirley, 1988) m a i n t a i n research reactors and laboratories t h a t are available for such purposes. The National Laboratories, most of which were originally nuclear laboratories, may also be suitable sources for tracer analyses. Proper verification should establish the isotopic purity and a m o u n t of activity provided, and t h a t the isotope is attached to the desired chemical form. This is particularly i m p o r t a n t for the hexacyanocobaltates. It is quite possible, for example, to have cobalt-60 in a solution of the hexacyanocobaltate w i t h o u t the hexacyano complex being radioactive or the cobalt-60 being in the desired complex form. The chemical form of the cobalt can only be monitored in the laboratory. A simple test for the radioactive hexacyanocobaltate is to pass a small a m o u n t t h r o u g h a cation exchanger in series with an anion exchanger. The material should pass through the cation exchanger but be counted on the anion exchanger, and the g a m m a spectrum should show only Co-60 present. Even if nothing is done to verify the isotopic composition in advance of the injection, it is still possible to verify it after the fact on samples of wash water t a k e n from the injector. Very little tracer is required to make such a test; the service company doing the injection can easily save a few milliliters of the
98
Chapter 3
washings for this purpose. In view of the North Sea problems with Co-60 tagged hexacyanocobaltate, it would be a wise thing to do for this tracer. Any laboratory capable of handling even small amounts of radioactivity can do the ion exchange test indicated in the previous paragraph.
Tracer preparation The p r e p a r a t i o n of field quantities of tracer for waterflood tracing is a specialized area. Most service companies or users of these tracers will never be involved in the preparation. It is nevertheless of some importance to be aware of the preparation procedures in current use. Preparation of any of the tracers used for waterflood tracing must be done in a suitably licensed laboratory by personnel trained in the safe use of radiochemical procedures. Both the preparation and the transport of these materials require governmental approval. In the United States this may involve several agencies. TRITIATED WATER Tritiated water is available as a byproduct of nuclear reactor operation from m a n y sources in the USA and abroad. It can also be made from the oxidation of t r i t i u m gas (HT) over certain hot metal oxides, supported platinum, or other catalysts. Copper oxide pellets at about 850~ are commonly used. Hightemperature alloys are required for containing the hot copper oxide pellets. HEXACYANOCOBALTATES The hexacyanocobaltates are prepared by oxidation of the cobaltous ion to the cobaltic form in the presence of excess cyanide solution (Fernelius, 1946). Some heat is required; the synthesis can start with metallic (elemental) cobalt wires or pellets. The isotope is normally produced by irradiation of cobalt-59 in a nuclear reactor by the (n,T) reaction. The elemental cobalt is first dissolved in aqua regia to form cobaltous chloride and the excess acid removed. The Co-60 tagged cobaltous chloride is also available commercially. Cobalt-57 is made in an accelerator by the (p,a) reaction on nickel-60, as discussed in chapter 2. It is generally more costly than neutron-produced isotopes because of the high cost of accelerator operation. The reaction of cobalt-60 or cobalt-57 (*Co) tagged cobaltous chloride with cyanide to form the complex ion is a two-step process. In the first step, the cobalt reacts with the cyanide to form insoluble cobaltous cyanide: *Co ++ + 2 C N ' = *Co(CN)2
(3.1)
In the second step, the precipitated cobaltous cyanide is further treated with an excess of cyanide and the solution is then heated to form the complex cyanide. In this process, the cobalt is oxidized to the plus three state (cobaltic), with the
Interwell Water Tracers
99
appearance of a yellow color typical of the complex, and water is reduced with the elimination of hydrogen as a gas. The complete reaction is given by: 2*Co(CN)2 + 2 H 2 0 + 8KCN = 2K3*Co(CN)6 + H2 + 2KOH
(3.2)
The reaction can be performed in a single step combining steps one and two, usually in the presence of ammonia. THIOCYANATE ION The thiocyanate ion is formed by the direct reaction of elemental sulfur with a cyanide salt in the presence of heat. The reaction is given as: KCN + S = KSCN
(3.3)
The carbon-14 tagged thiocyanate is prepared with carbon-14 tagged cyanide. The sulfur-35 tagged compound is prepared using tagged sulfur. Both tagged cyanide and tagged elemental sulfur are commonly available. FIELD TRACER VERIFICATION Some verification procedures can be performed in the field or at the service company laboratory. Tritium or carbon-14 sources, for example, should never be associated with penetrating g a m m a radiation, however some x-radiation may be present from large sources in thin-walled vessels. For multi-curie tritiated water sources, the b r e m s s t r a h l u n g g e n e r a t e d by the t r i t i u m betas is sufficient to permit m e a s u r e m e n t of the x-rays through a glass or a l u m i n u m ampoule. This can be m e a s u r e d by the vendor or service company through a glass ampoule or before it is transferred to a steel transport vessel for shipment and injection at the field. Carbon-14 tagged compounds of field strength can usually be monitored in the field by m e a n s of the b r e m s s t r a h l u n g generated through the steel tubing. A detector calibrated for the tubing used is needed for quantitative measurements. The supplier should provide radiochemical evidence t h a t the tagged compound has the correct chemical and radioactive composition. The hexacyanocobaltate ion can be purchased from several suppliers and the a m o u n t of tracer present can be monitored externally, depending on the cobalt isotope used. Cobalt-57 is a low energy e m i t t e r and can only be monitored t h r o u g h t h i n shielding. Cobalt-60 emits high-energy r a d i a t i o n b u t can be monitored through relatively thick shielding using a survey m e t e r calibrated in suitable units. A reasonable estimate of any g a m m a - e m i t t e r activity can be obtained from the equation for a point source of activity using the g a m m a factor to estimate the amount of radioactivity required to emit m e a s u r e d radiation for the thickness of lead shielding and distance of m e a s u r e m e n t . This is shown in Eq. (3.4) for a survey meter calibrated in mR/hr. In this equation, F is the g a m m a factor, h is the thickness of lead shielding expressed in the n u m b e r of half-value thicknesses, and d is the distance in meters from the survey m e t e r to the source.
100
Chapter 3
Values for F and h for some common tracers were given in Table 2.3; more extensive tables are available from s t a n d a r d handbooks (CRC). For Co-60 the half value thickness (h) is 0.5 in. and the g a m m a factor, F, is 1.32 mR/hr per meter per millicurie. F(2) h R (mR]hr) = d2 (3.4) Unshielded cobalt-60 sources can emit dangerous levels of radioactivity and should only be handled in a properly equipped laboratory t h a t meets government regulations. The chemical form of the cobalt can only be monitored in the laboratory from an aliquot as discussed earlier. TRACER INJECTION PROCEDURES Radioactive tracers generally come in small packages. Even for giant fields, the required tracer volume rarely exceeds a few milliliters. This makes shielding and shipping easier for g a m m a emitters; it also makes pulse injection of tracers easy to accomplish. Mixing with injection w a t e r in the borehole and in the formation near the wellbore ensures that the tracer is mixed in much more t h a n a small pulse. When a continuous tracer injection is desired, the mechanics of injection and of travel through the formation smoothes the pulses out enough t h a t periodic small pulses cannot be distinguished from a single continuous pulse at the production wells. The output from a pulse injection of tracer gives the same information as t h a t from the tracer front produced by a continuous injection of tracer, since the former is the differential of the latter. The pulse injection is, however, much easier and cheaper to perform, and the data are easier to analyze. Because of the very high specific activity of tracers used for waterfloods, it is important to avoid spills of concentrated tracer. Except for emergencies, concent r a t e d radioactive tracers in open containers should be handled only in laboratories designed for this purpose under controlled conditions. The i m p o r t a n t safety and handling procedures for field injection have been covered in chapter 2, including some factors specific to tritiated water tracing. In the early days of waterflood tracing, it was common to transfer the concentrated tracer from a container to the injection well by hand. Hypodermic syringes were a common means of transfer, but direct pouring or pumping of the tracer from an open container was also used. As the activity of the injected tracer quantities increased, these procedures were largely replaced by methods t h a t eliminated the handling of open sources at the field. These can be divided into two types. In one, the tracer is transported to the field in a suitably shielded, sealed glass vial. The glass vial is then transferred by hand to a breaking tool at the injection well. The tool assembly is pressure tested at the desired pressure, the vial is broken, and the contents are flushed into the injection stream. The advantage of this method is t h a t the small size of the vial allows reduced shielding volumes
Interwell Water Tracers
101
to be used. The disadvantage lies in the exposure of personnel to radiation during the transfer of the vial from the shielded container to the breaker tool, as well as the danger of breakage by dropping the vial during transfer, thus releasing concentrated tracer solutions at the field site. The second method used to transfer water tracers into an injection well uses the shipping container as a transfer cylinder, which avoids tracer handling by personnel at the field. The shipping container is designed and tested as a transfer cylinder under oilfield pressure and temperature conditions. It is fitted with inlet and outlet valves, and usually with suitable check valves to prevent backflow. A typical setup is shown schematically in Fig. 3.1. The container (shielded as necessary) is connected to the injection stream at its downstream end, while the u p s t r e a m end is connected to a pressurized water source. The water source may be obtained from the injection stream by suitable valving (as shown here) or from an external source such as a clean water supply or a pump truck. The system is tested under pressure for leaks and the tracer injected by opening proper valves. Many combinations of valves and gauges are possible. Simple strain gauges are often used for pressure measuring since they are easy to decontaminate. The advantage to this method is t h a t it avoids h a n d l i n g concentrated tracer solutions in the field, reducing the possibility of radiation exposure and the chance of releasing dangerous quantities of radioactivity in the field. This is probably the safer method and for beta emitters and low-energy g a m m a emitters such as 57Co or 125I, it is often the method of choice. The disadvantage is t h a t the larger size container requires much more shielding when used with high-energy gamma emitters such as 60Co.
{~
ressuretes
Pressuregauge
0o
s
~Tracer InjectionValve or Orifice 'rl' out ~ 0 Injectionline ~'~X
Figure 3.1. Waterflood tracer injector
~ water ~ ,n Water flow 0
102
Chapter 3
Sinker bar
Shear pin
Crushing rod Tracer vial Temporary seal Flow ports
S
~-'~, I
Collar stop
Figure 3.2. Wireline tracer injector Service companies vary in their systems for delivering and injecting tracers. One fixes the tracers in a gel and uses a piston drive to inject the gelled tracer through high-pressure grease fittings. One oil company (Wood et al., 1989) t r a n s fers the tracer vial to a piston-driven breaker on a wireline. The vial and the piston assembly are placed down hole, flow is started, and the vial mechanically s m a s h e d opposite a desired interval. Packers are used to divert flow from unwanted zones. This process is illustrated in Fig. 3.2. O t h e r special procedures have been devised for special circumstances. A special procedure was devised for injecting a curie (37 GBq) of 24Na (half-life = 15 hours) in a special steam pilot test. In this case 24Na was produced in a swimming pool reactor at a university by an (n,~) reaction on 23NaOH. The irradiated vial, which was fitted with a septum, was transferred to a shielded container at the reactor and t r a n s p o r t e d to the field location by truck. A hydraulic piston containing two hypodermic needles was driven through the septum at the well location and the tracer injected into the well by passing injection w a t e r through the vial by way of the needles. The injection was performed at slightly higher t h a n atmospheric pressure. Tritiated w a t e r is considered to be one of the safest tracers to handle because of its very low radiation energy and its short residence time in the body. While t h e r e is no radiation danger associated with tritium, open sources pose an
Interwell Water Tracers
103
ingestion hazard, particularly in enclosed areas, t h a t is not shared with nonvolatile water tracers. Tritiated water vapor enters the body through the skin as well as by mouth and nose, and large amounts of tritiated water in the body can provide an instant internal dose of radiation that can do damage. Such undiluted sources should never be opened in an enclosed space except in a properly designed laboratory.
Field t r a c e r design The design of a field tracer test has two components: a tracer part and an analytical part. The tracer component includes choosing the tracers for each well, 'estimating the required amount of each activity, dealing with the regulations and the plan for acquisition and injection of the tracers into the ground. The analytical part includes selecting an analytical strategy, setting up a sampling schedule, and determining the detection limits of the tracer materials. The amount of radioactive tracer required for a field test is governed by two limits: 1) sensitivity of detection at the lower limit and 2) m a x i m u m permissible concentration (MPC: defined in chapter 2) at the upper limit. In order to exceed the lower limit but not the upper, one must therefore estimate by how much the injected tracer will be diluted when it is produced. In fields with large reservoir volumes the cost of tracer materials can impose an upper limit well below the MPC. There are two methods in current use for determining how much tracer m u s t be added to meet these limits. The most widely used method is the total dilution model, which is discussed below. An alternate method is based upon a model originally proposed by Brigham and Smith (1964) and since modified by Abbaszadeh and Brigham (Abbaszadeh-Dehgani, 1982). A detailed discussion of this method, written by Dr. Abbaszadeh, is given in the appendix of this volume. TOTAL DILUTION FIELD TRACER This method estimates an average concentration of produced tracer on the a s s u m p t i o n t h a t the injected tracer is uniformly diluted by the entire swept water volume when it is produced. This is the most widely used method and is discussed below. The rule of t h u m b most commonly used in the field is to assume t h a t the injected tracer will be diluted by the total volume of water displaced in the flow pattern. Sufficient tracer is added to ensure detection at this concentration. The peak tracer concentration is presumed to lie well above the average. The first part of the calculation is to estimate an anticipated dilution volume. This volume is obtained by calculating the water-filled pore volume between the injector and the s u r r o u n d i n g producing wells. Radial geometry is generally assumed for regular patterns, but it is usually modified by any known reservoir
104
Chapter 3
conditions, such as large permeability differences between strata, known flow channels or barriers, odd pattern geometry, etc. This dilution volume is an estimate that, when used intelligently, has given consistent results in a wide variety of field situations. The smallest injection pulse required is usually the amount of tracer needed to produce an average concentration of 10 times the minimum detection limit in this dilution volume. Since in most cases produced water is reinjected into brine- and oil-filled formations in the ground, no legal problem arises with exceeding the m a x i m u m permissible concentration (MPC); however the convenience of being able to handle freely and ship the produced water samples makes this a practical requirement. Therefore, the maximum concentration in the produced water should be less than the MPC. To ensure that the produced tracer concentration will not exceed this number, the smallest dilution volume required to meet the MPC is calculated. This is considered a worst-case scenario and should not exceed a few percent of the estimated dilution volume for the entire pattern. The anticipated dilution volume, Vd, can be calculated from pertinent reservoir data as above, using a radial approximation to the pattern geometry. Line floods and odd p a t t e r n floods may require different geometries, as do special geologic features. If r is the distance from injector to producers, ~ is the porosity of the formation, h is its thickness, and Sw is the water saturation, then the swept volume for a radial approximation to the area is given by: Vd = nr2hSw@
(3.5)
The sensitivity of detection for a radioactive isotope is calculated from the instrumental background with no tracer present, as given by Eq. (2.3), for a geometry factor of one. It is a measure of the signal-to-noise ratio arrived at from purely statistical considerations. The m i n i m u m detection l i m i t (MDL) is the calculated value at two s t a n d a r d deviations and is usually quoted as the 95 percent confidence level (see chapter 2). The m i n i m u m tracer activity, A, required to exceed 10 x the MDL is given by: A > 10 x M D L x V d = 2 0 ~ EtV s
xV d
(3.6)
where Cb is the background count for counting time, t, E is the counting efficiency of the detector for this isotope, Vs is the sample volume, and Vd is the dilution volume of the reservoir. The proposed MPC for some of the common waterflood tracers is discussed in chapter 2 and given in tables 2.4 and 2.5. There is usually at least an additional order of magnitude between the m a x i m u m produced tracer concentration and the MPC.
Interwell Water Tracers
105
ABBASZADEH-BRIGHAM MODEL This model, which is discussed in the appendix, is introduced here only for purposes of comparison. It assumes a mechanism of tracer transport in which the injected tracer pulse moves through the formation by convective and dispersive forces, arriving at the s u r r o u n d i n g producers according to the s t r e a m l i n e s generated by the geometry of the flow pattern. The tracer arriving at the producers is diluted by untagged water arriving under other streamlines. This model treats heterogeneity by dividing the reservoir into a set of homogeneous layers. The injected tracer is distributed among these layers according to their respective conductivities (kh). These tracer pulses, moving independently through each of these layers, mix at the borehole to generate the tracer-response curve. A computer program uses the thickness and permeability of each layer and the pattern geometry to estimate the amount of injected tracer required to produce a desired maximum tracer concentration. Equivalently, a heterogeneity index such as the Dykstra-Parsons coefficient can be used to generate pseudolayers for design of a tracer test. TRACER ANALYSES:SENSITIVITY, DYNAMICRANGE, AND SELECTIVITY
Sensitivity The m i n i m u m detection limit (MDL) is a measure of the sensitivity of the counting system. It is a m e a s u r e of the signal-to-noise (s/n) ratio, fixed by constraints in the counter and by the background radiation level (noise). As shown in Eq. (3.6), the factors controlling the MDL are ~]Cb / (EtVs). The background count, C b, the counting efficiency, E, and the counting time, t, are generally fixed to minimize the MDL at normal operating conditions. The easiest constraint to change is the volume of sample counted, V s . This volume cannot exceed the sensitive volume of the counter, but the tracer it contains can be increased by concentrating the tracer. Enriching the tracer in the counting sample has the same effect as increasing the sample volume, Vs. If the tracer in a liter of collected sample can be concentrated into a one-ml counting volume, this is an enhancement factor of 1000 in the term Vs, since it is equivalent to counting a sample 1000 times its size. As environmental concerns have increased and costs of m a n y tracer materials have risen in recent years, pressure has mounted to decrease the a m o u n t of radioactivity used. Tracer enrichment, which reduces the a m o u n t of tracer prepared, is the most influential factor in this decrease, but decreasing the noise level in the counter (low level counting), and increasing the counting efficiency can also help. The sensitive volume of the liquid scintillation counters used for counting most waterflood tracers is determined by the volume of the counting vial used. Most common is the 20-ml scintillation vial. Commercial scintillation cocktails will accept up to 50 percent produced brine, depending upon salinity; however,
106
Chapter 3
the counting efficiency, E, decreases (particularly for tritium) as the percentage of water in the vial increases. The volume of water accepted is the sample volume, Vs. If smaller vials are used, the detection limit is lowered because a lower counting volume results in a lower background. If larger vials are used, the counting efficiency can be increased by lowering the percentage of water in the cocktail while increasing the sample volume. A number of choices are involved in maximizing the sensitivity for any given set of tracers. No strong advantage is gained by reducing the sample volumes below the