THUTMOSE
III
THUTMOSE
III
A New Biography
E R I C H . C L I N E AND D A V I D
O'CONNOR
Editors
T H E U N I V E...
254 downloads
3953 Views
24MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
THUTMOSE
III
THUTMOSE
III
A New Biography
E R I C H . C L I N E AND D A V I D
O'CONNOR
Editors
T H E U N I V E R S I T Y OF M I C H I G A N P R E S S
Ann Arbor
Copyright © by the University of Michigan 2006 All rights reserved Published in the United States of America by The University of Michigan Press Manufactured in the United States of America ® Printed on acid-free paper 2009
2008
2007
2006
4
3
2
1
No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, or otherwise, without the written permission of the publisher. A CLP catalog recordfor this book is availablefrom the British Library.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Thutmose III : a new biography / Eric H. Cline and David O'Connor, editors, p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN-13: 978042114672 (cloth : alk. paper) ISBN-10 0-472-11467-0 (cloth : alk. paper) I. Thutmose III, King of Egypt. 2. Pharaohs—Biography. 3. Egypt—History— Eighteenth dynasty, ca. 1570—1320 B.C. I. Cline, Eric H. II. O'Connor, David DT87.2 .T48 2005 2005050653 932/.0I4/092 B 22
Preface
T
hutmose III—"Strong Bull Arising in Thebes" as one of his five names reads—was without question one of Egypts greatest pharaohs. His reign was packed with momentous events and was of unusual length—a total of fifty-four years in a time when the average for his dynasty—the Eighteenth—was about sixteen and one-half years. Thutmose came to the throne at an unusually young age. His stepmother (and aunt) Hatshepsut immediately became his regent, a position that she soon transformed into a corulership, with herself as the senior pharaoh—the most effective and powerful of the few women ever recognized as pharaoh in Egypt. This situation lasted some twenty years, with Thutmose being permitted considerable, if limited, independence. In particular, he may have led, on Hatshepsuts behalf, Egyptian campaigns against various foreign lands. Nevertheless, there was either an enduring resentment on his part or a dawning realization that Hatshepsuts reign had not been "politically correct." Late in Thutmose s reign, long after Hatshepsut s death, he ordered or permitted an attack on her memory at the beautifully decorated and enormously scaled funerary temple built for her at Deir el-Bahari, in western Thebes— her images were defaced, although the rest of the many figures represented in the temple were left intact. Once he was sole ruler, Thutmose initiated the most sustained policy of conquest and expansion known for ancient Egypt. In his twenty-second year, he led his armies into Canaan, defeating a vast coalition of enemies (coming from as far away as Syria) at Megiddo—the Armageddon of the Bible. As a result, the great rulers of the Near East (including Assyria, Babylonia, and the Hittites) who were not directly involved in the conflict sent Thutmose placatory gifts, recognizing his new status. Throughout the next twenty-two years, Thutmose and his forces developed Egypts first empire, a relatively stable system of Egyptian overseers and foreign vassals that extended through
vi
Preface
Canaan and Lebanon into southern Syria and up the Nile through northern and central Nubia. This empire, delivering annual tribute and services, greatly increased the wealth of Egypts kings and was the basis for an imperial system that persisted, to varying degrees, well into the Twentieth Dynasty. Thutmose s contacts beyond the empire included not only other parts of the Near East but Anatolia and the Aegean as well. Under Thutmose III, Egypts already well-developed culture achieved new heights. He himself was a prodigious builder of monuments, including a vast new "festival hall" east of the Karnak Temple proper, the Sixth and Seventh Pylons of Amun-Re s temple at Karnak, and the large sacred lake at Amun-Re s temple as well. In addition, he had a funerary temple and a richly decorated tomb at western Thebes and built temples at many other towns in Egypt. More generally, some of the most superbly decorated of the Theban elite tombs were produced for his officials, such as the great vizier or prime minister Rekhmire and others. Art and architecture, however, were only part of the story. In religion, important developments took place during Thutmose s corule with Hatshepsut. Later, during his sole rule, religious developments on the one hand reinforced and displayed the divine aspects of kingship even more ostentatiously than before, yet on the other hand they articulated the nature of Amun-Re, the imperial god, who came to be seen as a deity intervening directly in history and even in the lives of individual Egyptians. Thus, some scholars believe a tension began to set in between royal pretensions and Amun-Re s evolving personality and cult that was to lead to the innovative but destructive changes initiated by pharaoh Akhenaten, the monotheist ruler who was the great-great-grandson of Thutmose III. Literature and historical writing also flourished under Thutmose III. His Annals, set up within the sanctuary of Amun-Re at Karnak itself, are among the most extended of historical narratives to survive from ancient Egypt. They include a particularly elaborate description of the campaign that culminated in the Battle of Megiddo, a text that has fascinated both scholars and military men in recent times. Thutmose s reign was also characterized by complex religious hymns. This long, richly documented reign and the pharaoh who was central to it have never been the subject of an extensive monographic treatment in English. Moreover, recent studies of Thutmose III in German and French lack the depth and scope that is intended for the work presented here. Initiated by Dr. Benedict Davies, and then seen through development by coeditors Professors Eric Cline and David O'Connor, the book consists of essays on virtually every aspect of the reign of Thutmose III written by experts on each
Preface
vu
topic. This extensive treatment of a pivotal figure in the ancient Mediterranean world during the Late Bronze Age will provide a uniquely comprehensive view of one of Egypts greatest pharaohs and will be of interest to a wide audience—specialists in Egypt and the Near East, graduate and undergraduate students, and the wider public as a whole. We gratefully acknowledge the preparation of the index to this book by Dr. J. J. Shirley and Laurel Bestock.
Contents
List of Abbreviations xi List of Illustrations xv ONE
Thutmose III: An Enigmatic Pharaoh
i
David O^Connor TWO
T h e Early Reign of Thutmose III: An Unorthodox Mantle of Coregency 39 Peter F. Dorman THREE
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III
69
Betsy M. Bryan FOUR
Religion and Cult during the Time of Thutmose III
123
Lana Troy FIVE
Monumental Architecture and the Royal Building Program of Thutmose III 183 Piotr Laskowski SIX
T h e Building Activities of Thutmose III in the Valley of the Kings 238 Catharine H. Roehrip
x
Contents
SEVEN
Royal Portrait and Ideology: Evolution and Signification of the Statuary of Thutmose III 260 Dimitri Laboury EIGHT
T h e Artistic Production of the Reign of Thutmose III
292
Arielle P. Kozloff NINE
T h e Northern Wars of Thutmose III
325
Donald B. Redford TEN
Covetous Eyes South: T h e Background to Egypts Domination of Nubia by the Reign of Thutmose III 344 Anthony J. Spalinger ELEVEN
Foreigners in Egypt in the Time of Hatshepsut and Thutmose III 370 Diamantis Panagiotopoulos TWELVE
T h e End of the Reign and the Accession of Amenhotep II Peter Der Manuelian
Bibliography 431 Contributors 481 Title Index
485
Subject Index Plates 535
493
413
Abbreviations
AJA AJSL AnatSt ASM BA BASOR BCMA BdE BES BIFAO BiOr BMFA BMMA BMRAH BSA BSFE CdE CNRS EG FIFAO GM IEJ IJNA JAOS JARCE JCS
American Journal of Archaeology American Journal of Semitic Languages and Literatures Anatolian Studies Annales du Service des Antiquités de l'Egypte. Cairo Biblical Archaeologist Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research Bulletin of the Cleveland Museum of Art Bibliothèque d'Etude. Institut Français d'Archéologie Orientale du Caire, Cairo. Bulletin of the Egyptological Seminar Bulletin de l'Institut Français d'Archéologie Orientale du Caire. Cairo. Bibliotheca Orientalis Bulletin of the Museum of Fine Arts. Boston. Bulletin of the Metropolitan Museum of Art. N e w York. Bulletin des Musées Royaux d'Art et d'Histoire Annual of the British School at Athens Bulletin de la Société Française d'Egyptologie Chronique d'Egypte Centre Nationale de la Recherche Scientifique (France) Egyptian Grammar3, Oxford Fouilles de l'Institut Français d'Archéologie Orientale du Caire. Cairo. Göttinger Miszellen Israel Exploration Journal International Journal of Nautical Archaeology and Underwater Exploration Journal of the American Oriental Society Journal of the American Research Center in Egypt Journal of Cuneiform Studies
xii
JEA
Abbreviations
Journal of Egyptian Archaeology
JESHO JMA JMAA JNES JSSEA KRI
Journal of the Economic and Social History of the Orient Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology Journal of Mediterranean Anthropology and Archaeology Journal of Near Eastern Studies Journal of the Society for the Study of Egyptian Antiquities Kenneth A. Kitchen. Ramesside Inscriptions, Historical and Biographical. Vols. 1—8. Oxford: Blackwell, 1969—90. LA Lexikon der Ägyptologie. Wiesbaden: Otto Harrassowitz. LD Karl Richard Lepsius. Denkmäler aus Ägypten und Äthiopien. 6 vols. Berlin, 1849—56. Reprint, Geneva, 197z. LD Text I—V Karl Richard Lepsius. Denkmäler aus Ägypten und Äthiopien. Ed. MDAIK MDOG MIEAO MIO NARCE NAWG OJA OLZ PEQ PM
PM2
PPS RdE RHA RIDA RL S AK TT Urk. VA
E. Naville. Leipzig, 1897—1913. Mitteilungen des Deutschen Archäologischen Instituts, Abteilung Kairo. Cairo. Mitteilungen der Deutschen Orient- Gesellschaft zu Berlin Mémoires publiés par les Membres de l'Institut Français d'Archéologie Orientale du Caire. Cairo. Mitteilungen des Instituts für Orientforschung Newsletter of the American Research Center in Egypt Nachrichten der Akademie der Wissenschaften in Göttingen (I. Philologischhistoische Klasse). Oxford Journal of Archaeology Orientalistische Literaturzeitung Palestine Exploration Quarterly Porter, B., and Moss, R . Topographical Bibliography of Ancient Egyptian Hieroglyphic Texts) Reliefs) and Paintings. Vols. I—VII. Oxford: Clarendon. 1927—51. Porter, B., and Moss, R . Topographical Bibliography of Ancient Egyptian Hieroglyphic Texts, Reliefs, and Paintings, znd edition, (revised by J. Malek from 1974 onward) Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society Revue d'Egyptologie Revue hittite et asianique Revue Internationale des Droits de l'Antiquité La Revue du Louvre et des Musées de France Studien zur Altagyptischen Kultur Theban tomb Urkunden des Ägyptischen Altertums (IV-Sethe 19z7—30 and Helek 1955-58) Varia Aegyptiaca
Abbreviations Wb
xiii
ZA
Wörterbuch der Ägyptischen Sprache (A. Erman and HL Grapow, Bands I—V Berlin: Akademie-Verlag. 1955) Zeitschriftfür Assyriologie und vorderasiatische Archäologie
ZÄS ZDPV
Zeitschriftfür Ägyptische Sprache und Altertumskunde Zeitschrift des Deutschen Palästina-Vereins
Illustrations
Table I. Chronology Map I. Eighteenth Dynasty Egypt and its world Map 2. Egypt in the N e w Kingdom period Map 3. Thebes in the N e w Kingdom period Fig. Fig. Fig. Fig.
i.i. Karnak and contiguous temples 1.2. Karnak Temple before and after Thutmose III 1.3. Genealogy of the Eighteenth Dynasty 1.4. T h e Procession of the boat-shaped palanquin of Amun-Re during the corule of Hatshepsut and Thutmose III
Fig. Fig. Fig. Fig.
2.1. T h e graffito of Senenmut at Aswan 2.2. A stela of Hatshepsut at Serabit el-Khadim 2.3. Two blocks from a limestone chapel of Hatshepsut at Karnak 2.4. T h e lunette of the stela of Nakht, dated to year 20 of the coregency, at Serabit el-Khadim
Fig. 5.1. Texte de la Jeunesse Fig. 5.2. Karnak, Eastern sanctuary, alabaster naos and the northern wall of room II structurally connected with the enclosure wall Fig. 5.3. Karnak, Eastern sanctuary, remains of the southern wall of room III Fig. 5.4. Karnak, lake repository, southern row of external pillars adjoining the wall of the court Fig. 5.5. Deir el Bahari, temple of Thutmose III, plan Fig. 5.6. Deir el Bahari, temple of Thutmose III, rear wall of the niche Fig. 5.7. Elkab, architrave of the Thutmose I l l s construction
xvi
Illustrations
Fig. 5-8- Elkab, architrave of the Thutmose I l l s construction Fig. 5.9. Elkab, lintel of Thutmose III with the epithet "ruler of Heliopolis" inside the ring Fig. 6.1. The Valley of the Kings as it may have looked at the end of the reign of Thutmose III Fig. 6.2. K V 34 Fig. 6.3. Section of the south wall of chamber F, showing the list of deities from the fifth hour Fig. 6.4. Beginning of the list of deities in the first hour of the Amduat, north wall of chamber F Fig. 6.5. Section of the south wall of chamber F and the sixth hour in chamber J Fig. 6.6. Burial chamber (J) of K V 34, looking back at the entrance Fig. 6.7. Plan of chamber J in K V 34 with the approximate positions of the texts Fig. 6.8. Litany of Re on the south face of pillar I in chamber J Fig. 6.9. Third hour of the Amduat Fig. 6.10. Fourth hour of the Amduat, bordering the south jamb of the entrance Fig. 6.11. Fourth hour of the Amduat, bordering the north jamb of the entrance Fig. 6.12. South wall of chamber J in K V 34 Fig. 6.13. The doorway into storage room Jc framed by illustrations from the eighth hour Fig. 6.14. The end of the twelfth hour Fig. 6.15. Plan and elevation of K V 38 Fig. 6.16. K V 42 Fig. 6.17. K V 20 Fig. 6.18. Plan of the two burial chambers in K V 20 Fig. 6.19. Vignettes on the north face of pillar I in the burial chamber of K V 34 Figs. 7.1a and 7.1b. Thutmose III. Last twelve years of the reign. Figs. 7.2a and 7.2b. Thutmose III. Second half of the third decade of the reign. Figs. 7.3a and 7.3b. Thutmose III. Regency period, first seven years of the reign (?). Figs. 7.4a and 7.4b. Thutmose III. Beginning of the coregency with Hatshepsut, between year 7 and year 12 of the reign.
Illustrations
xvii
Figs. 7.5a and 7.5b. Thutmose III. Beginning of the coregency with Hatshepsut, between year 7 and year iz of the reign. Fig. Fig. Fig. Fig. Fig. Fig.
11.1. Nubian women and children from the tomb of Ineni ii.z. Syria-Palestinian procession 11.3. Left section of foreigners' scene in the tomb of Useramun 11.4. Aegean gift bearers from the tomb of Useramun 11.5. Syria-Palestinian gift bearers from the tomb of Useramun 11.6. Syria-Palestinian men, women, and children from the tomb of Useramun Fig. 11.7. T h e foreigners' scene from the tomb of Rekhmire Fig. 11.8. South end of the Puntite procession from the tomb of Rekhmire Fig. 11.9. Middle section of the Aegean procession from the tomb of Rekhmire Fig. 11.10. Middle section of the Nubian procession from the tomb of Rekhmire Fig. 11.11. Syria-Palestinians bringing gifts for the Egyptian king, tomb of Amenemheb Fig. 11.12. Presentation of gifts in Lebanon Fig. 11.13. Brickmaking by Syria-Palestinians and Nubians from the tomb of Rekhmire Fig. iz.i. T h e Gebel Barkal stela of Thutmose III Fig. iz.z. Five solutions for the reign of Thutmose III Fig. 1z.3. Leiden stela V, 11, of Henetnefret, representing Thutmose III and Amenhotep II facing each other Fig. 1z.4. T h e accession date of Amenhotep II Fig. 1z.5. T h e coregency of Thutmose III and Amenhotep II Fig. 1Z.6. T h e archery stela of Amenhotep II Fig. 1z.7. T h e Armant stela of Thutmose III
ONE
Thutmose III: An Enigmatic Pharaoh DAVID
O'CONNOR
ost ancient Egyptian kings, or pharaohs, as they may legitimately be called from the New Kingdom (ca. 1z39—1075 BC) onward, are shadowy, sometimes virtually nonexistent figures to us moderns. Some are simply names, preserved in a king list or on a fragment of architecture; others are associated with only a handful of largely uninformative inscriptions; and even some for whom there are a fair number of datable royal and elite monuments remain relatively poorly documented as rulers and, even more, as individuals. In literature we are provided glimpses of various kings' personalities: genial King Snefru is contrasted with his seemingly malignant son Khufu; 1 or King Amenemhet I laments his assassination from the grave, while his successor Senwosret I extends a regal benevolence to the mistakenly self-exiled Sinuhe. 2 Yet, despite their names, the kings in these stories are fictional characters, and the relationship of their depictions, as persons, to historical reality is problematic.3
M
With the New Kingdom, however, the number of texts relating to individual kings and the variety in their genres increase. For many scholars definitive individual personalities begin to emerge as a result. Among these, those pharaohs of whom this can be said include Thutmose III (ca. 1479—1425 BC), as well as his father s wife (but not his mother), queen, later king, Hatshepsut (ca. 1473—1458 BC). Gardiner felt able to judge the latter "a woman of most virile character;" 4 Redford imagined that when Thutmose III ordered the erasure of Hatshepsut s name and image from her monuments long after her death he spared the more obscurely placed: "Standing alone before the image of the queen, Thutmose relented. She was, after all, his own flesh";5 and Hayes describedThutmose III as vigorous, efficient, many-sided, "an ardent and discriminating patron of the arts," and a "Napoleonic little
4° ^
THUTMOSE
III
man" 6 Recent histories are more cautious and muted yet basically transmit similar messages. Undeniably, we are permitted glimpses into the life and character of Thutmose III (and some other New Kingdom pharaohs) that seem to convey an impression of his personality, motives, and ideas. He was, we know, very young when he ascended to the throne, and a text from Karnak Temple (in modern Luxor) depicts the event itself; Thutmose describes himself as a youthful acolyte in the god Amun-Res temple, standing modestly among others as the gods image was carried in procession through the hypostyle (columned) hall of the temple. The god forced the bearers carrying his image to circle the hall, "searching [for Thutmose] in every place": confronted by the awe-inspiring image, the future king prostrated himself, only to be raised and presented to the assembled elite as the acceding king. 7 Later, in his maturity, Thutmose is depicted as holding a council of war with his senior army officers in preparation for an advance on the city of Megiddo (in modern Israel), where a large coalition of enemy forces has assembled. Of three possible routes to Megiddo, the officers reject one because it is narrow; because the enemy is already prepared to resist the Egyptian army s passage along it; and because the narrowness of the route will dangerously extend the Egyptian line of march, with "horse behind horse, and man behind man," with the result that the Egyptian advance guard was likely to become involved in fighting without the support of the rear guard or of many of the intervening forces. The other two routes are safer and preferable. Thutmose swears, however, that he will proceed upon the dangerous road, probably for a good if unstated strategic reason: the advance, while dangerous, promises to take the enemy by surprise, while the others are likely to reveal the Egyptian movements well before the anticipated battle. However, he adds, his generals are free to take their forces along the safer route, while the king leads his share of the army along the dangerous route to surprise and victory. Unsurprisingly, all agree to follow him, and eventually a great victory is won. Even then, however, the human or individual dimension of the king becomes prominent again. The Egyptians defeat the enemy army, massed before the city of Megiddo, but fail to follow the momentum of their foes (who flee into the city) and enter and capture it. Thutmose berates the Egyptians for this failure: all the rebellious leaders are within Megiddo, its capture "is the capture of a thousand cities," and yet now it will require an arduous siege and, even more tellingly, a postponement of a celebratory offering to the god Re. 8 The army has offended not only king and state but kingly god and cosmos as well. This extraordinarily detailed and, compared to most Egyptian texts, personalized narrative resonates with one written about 184 years later, describ-
An Enigmatic Pharaoh
^
3
ing a similar situation for the pharaoh Ramesses II (ca. 1z79—1z13 B C ) of the Nineteenth Dynasty. Advancing on the enemy city of Kadesh (in modern Syria), Ramesses is misled by false information, pushes ahead of the bulk of his army, and sets up camp dangerously close to the enemy (much stronger than he supposes), with the rest of his army extended behind him in the form of three widely separated divisions. T h e enemy attacks the foremost of these, in effect the king s rear guard, and then attacks Ramesses and his demoralized forces; the sense of panic is well conveyed by an instruction to the royal children, Ramesses' sons being schooled in war, to flee behind the palisade of shields surrounding the royal camp. T h e king s military miscalculations are made clear (but not explicitly criticized) in the text, as is his personal moment of panic. Surrounded by 2,500 enemy chariots, Ramesses states: " N o officer was with me, no charioteer, no soldier of the army, no shield-bearer; my infantry, my chariotry yielded before them, not one of them stood firm to fight with them." Ramesses berates the god Amun for not helping him, after his many good actions on Amun's behalf, but a note of panic is also evident: "I am among a host of strangers, all countries are arrayed against me, I am alone, there's none with me!" Perhaps Thutmose III might have found himself in a similar situation had his military gamble failed. In the event, Amun responded to Ramesses: "I found Amun came when I called to him, he gave me his hand and I rejoiced. He called from behind as if near by: Torward, I am with you.'" 9 Here, too, we find a god directly intervening in a pharaohs life, as Amun did with Thutmose III when he identified him as the next king. These texts—about Thutmose III, Ramesses II, and others—make fascinating reading and enlarge our understanding of the kaleidoscopic perspectives the Egyptians displayed in reference to their kings, simultaneously gods on earth and risk-taking humans. Yet are they accurate representations of what Thutmose or Ramesses experienced, thought, and said? Doubt must be raised by the fact that the relevant texts, like the tales or narratives about Snefru and Khufu, and Amenemhet I and Senwosret I, are literature, not history in our sense of that term, with the striving for accuracy and objectivity that it implies. As Loprieno has pointed out, 1 0 every text I have cited belongs to a multifaceted literary genre, the Königsnovelle or "king's novel." These are narratives "in which the king fulfils at the same time all the roles of societal representation: He is the image, the trace, and the symbol of the country's cohesion.The Egyptian king is the metaphysical 'image' of Egyptian society in texts in which he stands for the country as a whole. . . . T h e king is also Egypt's metonymical 'trace,' a link of causality tying his existence to the country's well-being. . . . Finally, the king is Egypt's 'symbol' when he is theologically equated to entire spheres of the Egyptian conception of the world, such as divine constellations." 11
4°
^
THUTMOSE
III
Such narratives include palpably untrue elements. Amun did not literally force his bearers to identify the young Thutmose as the next king or literally manifest himself behind Ramesses II at the battle of Kadesh. They also, in some cases, do include events that are historically true. Amenemhet I may have been assassinated, but rich fictional use is made of this event, including his supposed, yet clearly invented, posthumous words and the emotions thus conveyed. I2 The battles of Megiddo and Kadesh surely took place, but these events, too, have been put to complex literary uses, involving the invention to at least some degree of the relevant king s actions, speech, and emotions. The likelihood that these circumstances render our glimpses into the royal personalities problematical is reinforced by more specific factors. For example, the description of Thutmose I l l s selection as king by the god was written some forty-two years after the event (though still within the king s lifetime) and was inspired by political and ideological factors rather than a desire to simply describe a historical event; it may have been modeled on a preexisting, and certainly fictional, text about Hatshepsut! 13 Even the lively description of the battle of Megiddo was set down upon the wall on which it was displayed over forty years after the battle occurred, 14 and it may, at least in part, have been composed at this late date. This situation has in part prompted my title for this introductory chapter: "Thutmose III: An Enigmatic Pharaoh." Despite their seeming immediacy and human interest, and their incorporation of actual historical events, the texts relevant to Thutmose III cannot be considered a true representation of his personality, or parts of it, or even necessarily of all the specific acts and speeches attributed to him. However, Thutmose III is also enigmatic in a different, but significant and exciting way. In fact, our documentation is rich enough to provide discussion of Thutmose s long reign with a relatively detailed historical structure not possible for most other pharaohs. Ramesses II also had a very long reign (sixtyseven years as compared to Thutmose s fifty-four), and an abundance of documents has survived from his time. However, when all is said and done, what can we say about Ramesses' own life and the personal experience of his kingship? 15 We know something of his wives and children: he was active in military affairs abroad, some very substantial, for about fourteen years, with no initiatives thereafter; and throughout much of his reign there was much building of temples and palaces. This is a fairly "classic" New Kingdom pattern for many, though not all, pharaohs. It is certainly significant that in one 237-page book on Ramesses' reign only about 82 pages, or 34.5 percent, deal with Ramesses personally, while the remainder cover the cultural and societal aspects of Egypt at that time or events after his death. 16
An Enigmatic Pharaoh
^
5
However, in several ways the reign of Thutmose III stands out from the norm and in particular displays a clearly defined structure, as noted earlier. Acceding to the throne on the death of his father, the pharaoh Thutmose II (ca. 1479 BC?), at a very young age (impossible to quantify exactly), Thutmose III appears in the earliest surviving documents of his reign as sole king of Egypt. Given his extreme youth, however, it is likely that his fathers wife, queen Hatshepsut (who was not Thutmose s mother) already exercised effective power, a supposition made all the more likely by her early assumption of king s titles, and the kingship they imply, in Thutmose s seventh regnal year or even before (see chapter z of this book).Thereafter, the two kings— one male, one female—ruled side by side for about fifteen years. The relationship, political and presumably personal, between the two was a complex one, and changed over time, but Hatshepsut seems to have remained the dominant power throughout. 17 Eventually, Hatshepsut disappears from the record, and presumably she died in or soon after Thutmose s twenty-second regnal year (she numbered her own regnal years to match his). Queens had been active politically, and perhaps even acted as regents, before this time. Queen Ahhotep, for example, is credited with decisively restoring order in Egypt when the king died and may have been coregent with her son Ahmose (fourth predecessor of Thutmose III but not his blood relative) when he became king. 1 8 However, no king of Egypt of any period is known to have undergone Thutmose s specific experience, in which a female regent actually became a king and dominated royal policy throughout much and maybe the entire corulership. Corulership between male kings (one sometimes senior, the other junior) was a less unusual experience, 19 although scholars often disagree about specific examples. This unique experience, then, serves to define most of the first twenty-two years of Thutmose s reign (ca. 1479-1457 BC). The next twenty years of Thutmose s (now sole) reign are also strongly defined and unusual for a New Kingdom pharaoh. Surviving evidence (a random, perhaps not very reliable source) indicates that some pharaohs were not much engaged in foreign campaigning; virtually none is attested, for example, for the eight successors of King Ramesses III, extending from ca. 1156 to 1075 BC, that is, over almost a century. More often than not, earlier New Kingdom rulers, of the Eighteenth and Nineteenth Dynasties, either led or at least initiated military campaigns or small-scale forays into the Levant or Nubia. However, there were few such per reign; for the 60 years (kings Ahmose to Thutmose II) preceding Thutmose III there was, on average, about one foreign campaign every 4.6 years, and for about 70 years after him (kings Amenhotep II to Amenhotep III) about one every 10.5 years. However, Thut-
4° ^
THUTMOSE
III
mose III recorded no less than seventeen foreign campaigns between his twenty-third and forty-second years—an average of one campaign every 1.2 years, all, or nearly all, in the Levant. 20 And even after this there were "minor skirmishes and one foray" in Nubia, where Thutmose III had likely campaigned earlier as well, during some or all of the four Nubian campaigns attributed to Hatshepsut during her corulership with Thutmose. 2 1 Thus, in all, Thutmose III may have been involved in as many as twenty-two foreign campaigns, some more substantial than others; extraordinary in itself, this circumstance is even more unusual for the concentration of so many campaigns in the third and fourth decades of Thutmose s reign, which are thus characterized structurally as a period of intense military and associated imperial administrative activity. Structure, in a historical sense, is provided in a different way in the last decade or so of Thutmose s reign (ca. 1437—14z5 BC). First, in or soon after his forty-second regnal year Thutmose ordered the erasure of the erstwhile co-king Hatshepsut s names and images from many (but not all) of the monuments upon which they were displayed at Karnak and at Hatshepsuts enormous and richly decorated temple at Deir el-Bahari on the west bank at Thebes. 2 2 In the latter case there was also systematic destruction of the many royal statues (some colossal in size) belonging to the temple; most of the vast number of surviving fragments were recovered from a huge pit lying south of the temple and a large quarry to its north by an expedition of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York. 2 3 The defacement ceased before all the relevant monuments were affected (if such was Thutmose s intention) after his son and successor, Amenhotep II, acceded to the throne. However, Hatshepsuts status continued to have negative connotations. She is omitted from the king lists inscribed during the Nineteenth Dynasty (ca. 1292—1190 BC), and some of her monuments—having evaded defacement during Thutmose I l l s time—were usurped by early Ramesside rulers. Thutmose s "proscription" of Hatshepsut is a much discussed issue, 24 and it is likely related to another major initiative of Thutmose s last decade, the construction and decoration of a substantial temple placed between Hatshepsut s temple at Deir el-Bahari and the much earlier, but still standing and venerated, temple of the Eleventh Dynasty king Nebhepetre Mentuhotep (ca. 2010—1960 BC) to the south of Hatshepsut s. In linking the two temples, as far as the formal organization of the resulting complex was concerned, Thutmose s new temple brought a visual comprehensiveness to a complex earlier comprised of two separate, if similarly structured, terrace temples. 25 But much more was involved than this perhaps unintended result. The defacement of Hatshepsut s temple, involving both a denial of her memory and the occupation of her temple by a host of artisans over an extended period,
An Enigmatic Pharaoh
^
7
suggests that it was no longer used for ritual purposes—at least insofar as they related to hen For other cultic purposes, Djeser Djeseru (its name) continued to function. A key event in the ritual life of the New Kingdom royal mortuary temples was the ritual visit made to each temple (or at least the reigning kings temple) by the bark-palanquin of Amun during its annual perambulation along the west bank during the Festival of the Valley. Typically, in the Eighteenth Dynasty the bark-palanquin was carried through the temple and deposited near its rear-lying, centrally positioned sanctuary until the bark-palanquin procession, and its exit from the temple, resumed. Thutmose III, like other Eighteenth Dynasty pharaohs, had a mortuary temple down by the edge of the western floodplain, constructed largely (but not entirely) during the corule with Hatshepsut. 26 Hatshepsuts selection of Deir el-Bahari for her mortuary temple was evidently for a special reason. 27 Already, for centuries, the annual visit by Amun to the west bank had the nearby temple of Nebhepetre as its ultimate destination—if the contemporary royal mortuary temple (in the Eighteenth Dynasty) was also visited en route, it was an important but, almost by definition, secondary event. By building her mortuary temple next to Nebhepetre Mentuhotep s (and imitating it in form), Hatshepsut was providing herself (and her father, Thutmose I, whose cult was also celebrated at Deir el-Bahari) unique status. Indeed, Haeny remarks: "Hatshepsut might have intended to oust Mentuhotep from his dominant position in the procession; perhaps for the duration of the reign she even succeeded." 28 Now, with Hatshepsuts mortuary temple at least partially closed down, as far as her cult was concernedThutmose s temple—called Djeser Akhet or "[Amun is] Holy of the Horizon"—became the ultimate destination of the Festival of the Valley, alongside or instead of Nebhepetre s. To reinforce the point, the relevant gateways were wider than those in Hatshepsuts temple to accommodate a new sacred bark-palanquin of Amun, which was wider than the old one: 29 Hatshepsut s temple, closed or not, would not even have permitted the new bark-palanquin ingress. To further accentuate the significance of the temple of Djeser Akhet as one of the phenomena characterizing the last decade of the reign, it should be noted that during this time no other building projects comparable in scale were undertaken inThebes, the royal center, though there was much new temple building elsewhere in Egypt and in Nubia. 3 0 Thutmose, earlier in his reign, had undertaken major building projects at Karnak, but in this last decade the only other significant initiative was the cutting and inscribing of a very large granite obelisk (33 meters or 108.2 feet) that was intended to stand, uniquely single, in front of the Eastern Sanctuary of the Karnak Temple. 3 1 In the event, the project was not completed, the obelisk being finally
4° ^
THUTMOSE
III
erected thirty-five years later by Thutmose s grandson, king Thutmose I V The fact that his son and successor, Amenhotep II, neglected to do so indicates that the obelisk project was of less significance than the building of Djeser Akhet, which involved—over a long period—a very substantial group of laborers, builders, and artisans. The actual building extended from year 43 to year 49, 3 2 although the decorating likely continued beyond this later date. A further indication that Thutmose s changed relationship with the long dead Hatshepsut is important in historically defining his last decade is a significant change in the representation of his image, both in relief and in statuary. Precisely from year 4z to year 54, the images of Thutmose III differ stylistically from the several successive phases identifiable in his earlier representations: more specifically, these late images seem "at least inspired by, if not copied from, the sculpted faces of Thutmose I andThutmose II," 3 3 and, more significantly in light of the preceding discussion, they eliminate or minimize those earlier aspects of his representation that were also characteristic of representations of Hatshepsut. 34 The reign of Thutmose III therefore seems to exhibit a historical structure, or clearly defined sequence, that is by no means evident in the reigns of most other New Kingdom pharaohs. Nevertheless, Thutmose himself still can be justifiably called "enigmatic" in that we do not know why the three phases took on their particular historical forms. It may not have been unusual for a queen to become regent for a juvenile king, but it was unusual for her to become fully a king herself, as Hatshepsut did. Why did she not retire from kingship when Thutmose was mature enough to reign alone? When she died in regnal year zz, he would have been perhaps twenty-five or twentynine years old and, as subsequent events showed, clearly able to function effectively as ruler. And why and how did this unusual situation come about in the first place? Another set of questions is raised by Thutmose s intensive campaigning during his next two decades as sole ruler. It represents an enormous investment of resources (human and other) and a sustained military and administrative effort otherwise unequaled in Egyptian history. Why did Thutmose embark on this venture? Did it develop in an ad hoc fashion, or was it from the outset a carefully thought out, long-term plan to secure the maximum possible domination for Egypt in the Levant in response to the expanding influence of Mitanni, an imperial state on the upper Euphrates? What were its fundamental dynamics: a personality-driven clash between the Egyptian and Mitannian rulers or an appreciation of the great strategic and economic benefits imperial expansion brought to Egypt? Finally, when we turn to the last decade or so, the "proscription" of Hatshepsut, and the replacement of her Deir el-Bahari temple (called Djeser
An Enigmatic Pharaoh
^
9
Djeseru, "the holiest of holy places") by Thutmose s new and adjacent temple (Djeser Akhet, "the holy horizon") loom large. Why was the proscription so long delayed and what prompted it; long suppressed resentment on Thutmose s part or a more objective policy decision related to then current politics or Hatshepsuts ambiguous status as a new king (inherently male in Egyptian thought) who was actually a woman? And why were the suppression and replacement of the mortuary cult at her Deir el-Bahari temple and the building of Djeser Akhet so important? N o New Kingdom king before Hatshepsut (except for, relatively modestly, Amenhotep I), and none after Thutmose III, attempted to build a temple at this site. As long as these and other questions cannot be definitively answered, Thutmose III will remain—perhaps forever—an enigma. In the following chapters, the evidence relevant to these issues is presented and a brilliant group of scholars provide illuminating commentaries on it. Answers to the questions I have posed are provided, admittedly hypothetical yet persuasive; so far, definitive ones elude us. Nevertheless, their exploration of this momentous period in Egyptian history is fascinating, above all in presenting the excitement that pervades so much Egyptological research, a process continually probing for truth and understanding among the remains of an extraordinary, but also extraordinarily complex and multifaceted, culture. In preparation for this journey of discovery, this chapter provides the reader with an overview of Thutmose s reign, following a simple chronological sequence, to provide a context for the discussions that follow.
CONTEXTUALIZING THE
REIGN
Ideologically, the accession of a new Egyptian king was equivalent to a recreation of the cosmos, a literal new beginning to the order that characterized that cosmos and was personified as the goddess Maat. 3 5 In reality, of course, Thutmose as king entered into a context shaped on the one hand by geography and government and on the other by the activities of the earlier Eighteenth Dynasty pharaohs and their subjects. To convey the full richness of that context, even as it is inadequately accessible to us moderns, is impossible here. Instead, I emphasize a few salient features that are essential for this overview and the chapters that follow. To start from the periphery and move inward, Egypt by Thutmose I l l s time had become engaged with a variety of foreign lands and peoples to a degree unanticipated in earlier periods of Egyptian history (map 1). These foreign lands had two levels of meaning for the Egyptians. They presented both challenge and opportunity in terms of military action, diplomatic relations, and trading and gift exchange opportunities, as well as of greatly in-
4° ^
THUTMOSE
III
creased revenue from an imperial system of governance that had been taking shape—especially in Nubia to the south—during the reigns of Thutmose s predecessors. At another level, however, these culturally alien peoples, with their non-Egyptian, hence imperfect environments (even the great Euphrates River, the nearest equivalent to the Nile, was called "the river that runs backward" because it flows from north to south, not south to north like the Nile), 3 6 had great symbolic significance. Their normative deviations placed them on the border between the perfect order of cosmos (Egypt) and the aggressively destructive force of Isfet, the limitless, formless entity that extended to infinity on every side of the cosmos. 37 Moreover, insofar as foreigners threatened or attacked Egypt, or resisted Egyptian initiatives or domination, they themselves became identified as the destructive force of Isfet, equivalent to the demons and monsters whose attacks on the sun gods regenerating cycle around the cosmos were ruthlessly suppressed by Egypts deities. The symbolic significance of foreigners and their lands deeply influenced the presentation of history in most surviving inscriptions of relevance and surely played an important part in the actual foreign policies of the pharaohs. However, equally or more important were the "real world" factors mentioned earlier. West of Egypt, in the time of Thutmose III and earlier, lay Libya (Egyptian Tjehenu and Tjemeh), a land of warlike nomads, centered probably on Cyrenaica, who seem not to have been of major concern to Egypt in the Eighteenth Dynasty. 38 Far to the southeast of Libya, over endless desert wastes, was the riverine land of Nubia (EgyptianTa Nehesy and often, in the New Kingdom, Kush), immediately upstream of Egypt itself. Nubia extended from the First to the Fifth Cataracts of the Nile; its resources in alluvial land and large numbers of domesticated animals supported a substantial population, which had a long history of state building. 39 With its access to gold (in the eastern desert) and highly desired trade goods such as ivory and ebony from southern Nubia and beyond, Nubia was economically attractive.40 In fact, in the Twelfth Dynasty Egypt had fortified and controlled northern Lower Nubia and competed for influence along the Middle Nile with the kingdom of Kerma, equivalent to central or Upper Nubia. During the Second Intermediate period (ca. 1630—1520 BC), however, Lower Nubia fell under Kermas control, and the king of the latter may have cooperated with the Levantine Hyksos, who controlled northern Egypt at this time (see the subsequent discussion). In these circumstances, it is not surprising that insofar as Thutmose I l l s Eighteenth Dynasty predecessors had a consistent foreign policy it was focused largely on the reconquest of Lower Nubia and the conquest of the Kerma kingdom. By Thutmose s time, Lower
An Enigmatic Pharaoh
^
29
Nubia was held by Egypt, and Upper Nubia (Kerma) also seems to have been under Egyptian control. 41 However, subsequent events during the corule of Thutmose III and Hatshepsut indicate that pacification was not yet complete or else hostilities were occurring with southern, independent Nubia. To the east lay the mysterious land of Punt. Its shoreline along the Red Sea perhaps included the modern town of Port Sudan, and it extended well inland. Punt has not yet been located, and the archaeology of its culture is unknown, but it had been visited by trading expeditions dispatched by Egyptian kings since the time of the Old Kingdom (ca. z575—z150 BC). From Punt the Egyptians valued most incense used in their temples and tomb chapels, but they also acquired exotica such as ivory and ebony. 42 In the New Kingdom, however, no expeditions thence are documented until the corule of Hatshepsut and Thutmose III. 4 3 Immediately northeast of Egypt lies Sinai (map 1), a mineral-rich wedge of land that also forms a land bridge between Egypt and the Levant. In historic times Sinai, or much of it, was under Egyptian control, but it was not during the Hyksos period (ca. 1330—1520 BC). During the latter period, rulers, probably from Canaan (roughly, modern Israel and western Jordan), gained dominion over northern Egypt, in part with the aid of their own followers, in part via Egyptian vassals. Increasingly, throughout the Seventeenth Dynasty, an indigenous Egyptian one that ruled southern Egypt from Thebes, conflicts between the latter and the Hyksos intensified. The last ruler of the dynasty, Kamose, launched a major attack on Avaris or Hat Weret, the Hyksos capital in the northeast delta, but it was left to his brother and successor Ahmose—later reckoned as the first king of the Eighteenth Dynasty—to capture Avaris, expel the Hyksos, and follow up his success by attacking and taking Sharuhen (a city south of Gaza, map 1) whence the last Hyksos ruler may have fled.44The road running across North Sinai (called later "the Ways of Horus") was surely occupied by Egypt at this time, but surprisingly there is at first little direct evidence for Egyptian activity in the mineral-rich southwest corner of Sinai (Serabit el Khadim and the Wadi Maghara). Votive objects in a temple there (founded in the Middle Kingdom) bear the name of king Ahmose s queen, 45 but formal inscriptions do not occur until the corule of Thutmose III and Hatshepsut (see subsequent discussion). What was the situation faced by Thutmose III, Hatshepsut, and their advisers in the Levant at the time of the kings accession ca. 1479 BC? Throughout the preceding reigns of the Eighteenth Dynasty, the geopolitical situation had been rapidly changing.46 Earlier, during Egypts Second Intermediate period (equivalent to the Hyksos Fifteenth Dynasty, 1630—1520 BC), the Levant (essentially the eastern Mediterranean lands) had been dom-
4° ^
THUTMOSE
III
inated by independent Amorite kingdoms extending through modern Syria (centered at Aleppo and Qatna, respectively) into modern Israel (Hazor). By Thutmose I l l s time, things were very different. The politics of Syria, Lebanon, and northern Palestine were now dominated by two great and competitive powers. In central Anatolia, the powerful kingdom of the Indo-European Hittites had been established and was expanding both to the southwest and southeast, into Syria. In northern Mesopotamia, another expansive state, Mitanni, had been founded by AyroHurrians. The Hurrians, a people that originated in northern Zagros in modern Iran, had become widespread throughout the Levant and were ruled by an Indo-European aristocracy of separate origins. Although the Hittites had been quite aggressive contemporaneously with the earlier Eighteenth Dynasty, bringing the Amorite kingdoms of Syria to an end and even raiding Babylon, far downstream on the Euphrates, by the time of Thutmose I (ca. 1493—?) Mitanni had become the dominant Levantine power. Aleppo was now part of Mitanni s empire, and Qatna had been eclipsed. Two new states of importance emerged; centered respectively atTunip and Kadesh, these two kingdoms were expansive but, if not actually subordinate to Mitanni, were susceptible to the strong political influence of the nearby "great power." Tunip extended its influence over nearby cities on the Mediterranean coast; Kadeshs power extended southward and "by the eve of Hatshepsuts death (ca. 1457 BC) had made itself the de facto master of Coele-Syria (Damascus and regions to the west) and north Palestine," with "its sprawling bailiwick at Megiddo" in northern Israel. 47 Prior to Thutmose III, the Egyptian reaction to these developments had been—on present evidence—remarkably restrained. Earlier, in the Middle Kingdom, the Egyptian king and elite had benefited from extensive diplomatic and trading contacts throughout the Levant interspersed with occasional hostilities, 48 and presumably such opportunities would still be appreciated but might have been inhibited by the changing geopolitical situation. Moreover, in the Second Intermediate period southern Palestine or Canaan at least (as the probable homeland of the Hyksos invaders of northern Egypt) had proved a great danger to Egypt, and similar threats might well have been anticipated in the Eighteenth Dynasty before Thutmose s time. In fact, there are indications that the Egyptians realized that the expansive kingdoms of Syria, and beyond them the great power of Mitanni, were potential sources of trouble. 49 Ahmose not only expelled the Hyksos and took the strategic center of Sharuhen, but he may also have campaigned inland from Byblos, while Amenhotep I may have campaigned against Tunip. More spectacularly, Thutmose I invaded Mitanni itself in his fifth or sixth regnal year (ca. 1434 or 1433 BC). Several of his soldiers left brief records of
An Enigmatic Pharaoh
^
13
this campaign. T h e army perhaps sailed first to Byblos and then marched overland up the Orontes Valley before striking east near Alalakh and eventually crossing the Euphrates near Carchemish, thus literally penetrating the "land of Naharin" (Mitanni) and "the foreign land of Mitanni" A battle with Mitannian troops ensued, and Thutmose I had a stela erected on the Euphrates to record his victory. This campaign has been described as a giant razzia, or raid, with little permanent effect; 5 0 yet it required careful planning and apparently a brilliant strategy. It seems clear that the Egyptians were already familiar with the complex geography and geopolitical structure of the entire Levant. Thereafter, however, we have no surviving evidence for substantial Egyptian activity for almost thirty years. Beyond the Levant lay yet other regions potentially open to Egyptian contact during the period covered here. To the east, along the TigrisEuphrates Valley, were the kingdoms of Assyria and Babylon. To the northwest, there was the Hittite empire of Anatolia. Prior to Thutmose III, no Egyptian contacts with any of these polities are recorded. Further west lay the Aegean and the polities and civilizations of the Minoan and Mycenaean worlds. Earlier, in the Middle Kingdom, Egypt may have been in direct contact with Crete at least, 51 and there were some Aegean contacts in Hyksos times. 52 Most spectacularly, Minoan-style frescoes were seemingly painted upon Hyksos palace walls at Tell el-Dab'a in the northeast delta but were later redated to Ahmose s reign; and they now may be redated yet again to the corule of Hatshepsut and Thutmose III! 5 3 In any event, there is otherwise little direct evidence for contact with the Aegean during the Eighteenth Dynasty before Thutmose III, yet such may be suspected. Rather abruptly, Aegean tributaries (Minoans and Mycenaeans) are depicted as presenting tribute to a pharaoh in several elite tombs during Thutmose I l l s reign, 54 and while this may indicate a sudden intensification of contacts it might equally well reflect earlier contacts as yet undocumented. In any event, despite the depictions, Aegean rulers and peoples were always essentially independent of Egypt, being diplomatic contacts and trading partners but not subjects. From the wide panorama of the actual or potential foreign contacts open to Thutmose III at his accession, we contract inward to Egypt itself (map 2), the fundamental basis of Egypts strength in his reign as in others. T h e internecine wars of the Hyksos period were long over, and throughout the sixty years preceding Thutmose I l l s accession Egypt experienced political consolidation and economic growth. At the same time, the power of the kingship, and of the elite supporting it, continually increased. 55 This is most evident from an important administrative document, called by Egyptologists the Duties of the Vizier. T h e official bearing, perhaps misleadingly, this chief title of the Ottoman administration was in fact the tjaty, best described in
4° ^
THUTMOSE
III
the N e w Kingdom as the chief executive officer of the pharaoh. In fact, usually there may have been two tjaty s, one for northern and the other for southern Egypt. 5 6 T h e document survives on the walls of four elite tomb chapels, extending from the reign of Thutmose III into the Nineteenth Dynasty, but the composition itself is considered to be earlier; most scholars date it to the beginning of the N e w Kingdom, while a minority still view it as possibly substantially Middle Kingdom in origin. 57 At this time, we can guess Egypts population numbered about three million, 5 8 distributed almost entirely along the relatively narrow floodplain (fanning out more broadly in the delta region) of the Egyptian Nile Valley. T h e great majority were primarily agriculturists (animal herding was substantial but economically secondary) of greatly varied status; they ranged from estate-owning elites through middle-level landholders (the nemehew\ independent of all but pharaoh, and others who were dependent on assigned landholdings) down to serfs, laborers, and slaves. 59 Much of the land belonged to the royal family and government institutions, including temples, but some was privately held. Generally, agricultural productivity was high, if requiring careful attention to the basin irrigation system; 60 the chief negative feature was the recurrence of relatively low Nile inundations over an extended period, a cyclical phenomenon that could place the population under considerable stress. 61 Most people lived in rural villages of variable sizes but others in what we would call towns and even (relatively small) cities. 62 T h e Duties of the Vizier reveals that the governance of this society was relatively strongly centralized, although we tend to overemphasize the power and pervasiveness of N e w Kingdom government because so much of our surviving source material concerns it and relatively little relates to perhaps more autonomous spheres of societal organization. What does emerge clearly, however, is the highly personalized nature of governance; ceremonial events highlighting the roles of the king, viziers, and senior officials were just as important as the more "utilitarian" machinery of government. Thus the Duties opens by describing how formal sessions by the tjaty are to be conducted, with strict attention to decorum: the assembled officials stand "rigid fixedly facing the one opposite to him amongst everyone (present at the session), one has to be heard after the other, without allowing the low (ranking official) to be heard before the high (ranking official)." 6 3 T h e tjaty s responsibilities vis-à-vis the royal palace are then described, 64 as is a formal consultation between the overseer of the treasury and the tjaty, followed by the latter s personal and daily report to the king himself. 65 As to the structure of the government, it can be schematically rendered in terms of its various departments, 66 which functioned both at a national or subnational level (some were divided into two, for the northern and southern
An Enigmatic Pharaoh
^
15
"halves" of Egypt, respectively) and at the level of the innumerable "town districts" into which Egypt was divided. 67 T h e dynamics of royal power are also evident in the Duties. T h e tjaty s authority comes from his highest-ranking office and close personal relationship (in governmental terms) with the king, whose revenues, security, and needs are directly overseen by the tjaty. Moreover, the tjaty, and hence his royal overlord, are linked to a subtle division of powers. T h e institutions of national government have considerable autonomy in carrying out their responsibilities, 68 but their heads cannot discipline their subordinates; this is reserved for the tjaty.69 The many local governments distributed throughout Egypt respond to the requirements of the central agencies but are appointed by, and regularly report to, the tjaty7° Moreover, it is the tjaty who issues the most crucial orders to local government, orders concerning the regular maintenance of the basic irrigation system and the initiation of the annual harvest. 71 Grain was not only the basic subsistence resource but also the chief form of state revenue. T h e degree to which this centralized system of governance was the creation of the early Eighteenth Dynasty or of Hatshepsut and Thutmose III themselves is debatable, but if it goes back to king Ahmose it was essentially inherited by the corulers. However, we should not confuse it with the highly bureaucratic national governments we are familiar with today; rather, it has been persuasively argued that all Near Eastern states of the second millennium BC, including Egypt, were "patrimonial" and as such "the antithesis of rationalized bureaucracy. In a patrimonial regime, the entire social order is viewed as an extension of the rulers household—and ultimately of the gods household... [and] governmental administration is effected through personal relationships on the household model rather than through an impersonal bureaucracy." 72 More specifically, New Kingdom Egypt can be fitted into this model, with an array of administrative titles that "defy rational analysis." 73 This situation highlights three important aspects of N e w Kingdom governance. First, its aims were likely limited. T h e collection of revenue, the maintenance insofar as necessary of social order, and the marshaling of services (labor, artisanal, military) were its chief concerns, not the imposition of a completely comprehensive and intrusive system of government. Second, the preceding circumstance suggests that Egyptian communities enjoyed considerable autonomy in major areas of societal life, although this remains to be proved. And, third, that motivation inextricably fused together what we would consider "rational" and "irrational." Government and imperial expansion served rational ends that were appreciated and valued—the wealth and power of the elite were enhanced, the productivity of the population maintained. But most relevant texts do not state these as aims; rather, they describe internal order and productivity as ultimately designed to service and
4° ^
THUTMOSE
III
placate Egypts deities—thus ensuring that they would permit Egypt to literally survive and thrive—and activities abroad as ordered by those deities as part of the cosmoswide battle against the annihilating threat offered by Isfet, or universal chaos and nonbeing. These were as powerful motivating factors as the more "rational" ones. For example, the continual building or renovation of temples, and the allotment to them of sometimes large economic resources, were time consuming and expensive, and even, some scholars think, a potential drain on the economic and hence political power of the kingship. Yet this process was successfully integrated into the general processes of governance and was a major perennial concern of Egyptian rulers, for whom it was a welcome as well as an inescapable obligation. Having moved from the outside world to Egypt, we now focus on the essential centers of power, the palaces of the kings and the temples of the chief gods, grouped together in the royal cities or capitals of New Kingdom Egypt (Thebes and Memphis, briefly el-Amarna, and later Pi-Ramesses). 74 Unfortunately, for the most part royal palaces and major temples are poorly known and often were largely destroyed or denuded. 75 The most important exception is Thebes, the southern royal city (map 3), which bulks disproportionately large in any discussion of the building and ritual activities of New Kingdom pharaohs. 76 For Hatshepsut and Thutmose III, the important temples on the east bank of the Nile in the city are those in the temple complex dedicated to the imperial god Amun-Re at Karnak and on the west bank the mortuary temples intended to service their decorated, rock cut tombs, located some distance away, like those of all New Kingdom pharaohs buried at Thebes (the majority) in the Valley of the Kings. 7 7 At the time of Thutmose I l l s accession, the west bank had experienced only relatively modest development. In fact, the most imposing monument was probably the still venerated terraced temple of king Nebhepetre Mentuhotep (ca. zoio—1960 BC, Eleventh Dynasty) at Deir el-Bahari, which was also one traditionally visited by the image of Amun-Re during the annual Festival of the Valley. 78 The tomb and separate mortuary temple of Ahmose, founder of the Eighteenth Dynasty, have never been found, but his successor Amenhotep Is tomb may have been identified at Dira abu el-Naga, while his mortuary temple is known inscriptionally if not archaeologically.79 The earliest tombs cut into the Valley of the Kings were those of Thutmose I and Thutmose II, grandfather and father of Thutmose III. The formers was up one side branch in the southwest quadrant of the valley ( K V 38); small (about 10 meters or 33 feet long), it had a curving access corridor and an oval burial chamber (equivalent to the end of the netherworld) and had been in part decorated with the Amduat, one of the Books of the Netherworld typically displayed on royal
An Enigmatic Pharaoh
^
17
tomb walls. In a nearby side valley was tomb K V 42, slightly larger but similar in overall plan and apparently undecorated: it is believed this was meant for Thutmose II, though some scholars disagree. 80 The mortuary temple of Thutmose I, attested inscriptionally, has not been found. That of Thutmose II has been excavated; compared to later ones, it was quite tiny at 212.1 square meters, more of a chapel than a temple. On the east bank, the ceremonial spine of Thebes the city was defined by the Amun-Re complex to the north (Karnak) and another Amun-Re temple to the south (Luxor). Thutmose III and Hatshepsut may have built a temple at Luxor, but if so it was later demolished to make way for a temple of Amenhotep III (ca. 1390—1353 BC). Karnak, however, was a different and more complicated story. At the opening of the Eighteenth Dynasty the temple of Amun at Karnak was essentially a Middle Kingdom structure, and this core, as far as we can tell, was maintained throughout the New Kingdom and even beyond. Unfortunately, the Middle Kingdom component of Amun-Res temple (Amun-Re being the more familiar New Kingdom term) has not survived as a standing monument (whereas much of the rest of Karnak has) or been adequately revealed by excavation. Its form and dimensions remain unknown and may not have any close relationship to the area known as the Middle Kingdom Court at Karnak. 81 Amun, a deity of Theban origin, had been of great significance to Middle Kingdom pharaohs (Twelfth and Thirteenth Dynasties) whose line derived from the same city, and in his cosmologically broader aspect as Amun-Re—divine king of Egypt, world, and cosmos—he was continually identified as the chief patron of the Eighteenth Dynasty, another royal line of Theban origin. From the outset, his relatively ancient temple at Karnak was the beneficiary of substantial royal building projects, just as the economic basis of his temple—in terms of landholdings and human resources especially—was continually increased by the successive members of this line of grateful pharaohs. One of the earliest Eighteenth Dynasty monuments to survive from Karnak is a "splendid stela," 82 of limestone, about 2.36 meters (7.5 feet) high, recording the valuable gifts and building activities proffered by king Ahmose, founder of the dynasty, to Amun-Re. "He is the king," states the stela s inscription, "whom Re has installed as king, and who Amun has made great, in that they [the two gods = Amun-Re] have given to him the banks [Egypt] and the foreign lands upon which Re shines," 83 ideas that were to echo and become even more luxuriant throughout the Eighteenth Dynasty and later. By the time of Thutmose I l l s accession, Karnak Temple (Fig. 1.3) had become a larger, more impressive structure than its Middle Kingdom core, al-
4° ^
THUTMOSE
III
though the details of its internal layout are largely unknown due to extensive rebuilding carried out by Hatshepsut and Thutmose III. However, the core building—laid out along an east-west axis—seems to have been renovated and enlarged by king Amenhotep I, and then the total area of the temple was substantially expanded by monumental features largely added by Thutmose I, Thutmose I l l s grandfather (fig. 1.4). Preceded by a large forecourt, the temple was fronted by an imposing limestone pylon (labeled Pylon I V by Egyptologists), before which—flanking the centrally placed gateway—were two tall obelisks of Thutmose I. A surprisingly short distance behind (east o f ) the pylon rose a second, imposing but smaller (Pylon V), marking the entrance to the temple proper. The space between the two pylons was a columned, roofed hall, a relatively modest predecessor to the great hypostyle hall that was eventually to rise west of Pylon III, the latter built by Amenhotep III (ca. 1390—1353 BC).The original Middle Kingdom sanctuary toward the rear of the temple apparently continued to serve as such, with somewhere before it a repository for the boat-shaped palanquin in which Amun-Re s image was carried during festival processions. The latter sometimes involved a progress by river as well, for which a special barge was provided, with each king often supplying a newer, presumably ever more splendid version. King Ahmose records that he had a great riverboat built: "Amun-Userhet is its name, from genuine cedar wood of the best from Lebanon." 84 Finally, Thutmose I provided the remaining three sides of the temple with a substantial enclosure wall, further expanding its area. In all, Karnak Temple prior to Thutmose I l l s reign occupied about 9,555 square meters (almost 1 hectare or 2.47 acres); butThutmose III was to leave it 1.6 times as large, at about 15,800 square meters or 1.58 hectares (including the eastern component called Menkheperre (Thutmose III) Akh Menu, a name that has been variously translated). Thutmose III was to add to the Karnak Temple in other ways as well. For example, it had a processional route running to the south, which he provided with its second pylon (VII), to the south of its earliest pylon (VIII), built during the corule; 85 later others extended it further to the south (fig. 1.4). Moreover, he replaced Karnaks (presumed) original Sacred Lake with a much larger one, 86 essentially that is still visible today. At all times, the area surrounding the temple of Amun-Re and related structures was enclosed by a high brick wall, separating it from the city of Thebes, which flanked or surrounded it. It is also possible that close to the northwest corner of Karnak Temple, and facing out onto the forecourt, there was a royal palace from the outset of the dynasty: one certainly existed in this location in Hatshepsuts day and later. 87 The palace may have been used for largely ceremonial purposes, when the king was involved in the rituals and festivals of the temple, or it also may
An Enigmatic Pharaoh
^
19
have been an "administrative palace" that played an important role in the process of governance.88 Royal palaces, however, were not restricted to Thebes. From at least the reign of Thutmose I, Memphis, a royal city of great antiquity (extending back to the Third Dynasty at least), had again become an important royal center, with a "palace of Thutmose I" that was administrative in function and was still in use as late as the reign of Tutankhamun (ca. 1332—13zz BC). 8 9 These, then—from periphery to center, from alien foreign lands emblematic of chaos to royal cities, palaces, and temples supremely evocative of cosmic order—were the circumstances and contexts within which the long reign of Thutmose III unfolded and in the process brought great change.
T H U T M O S E III A N D T H E A N C E S T R A L
SPIRITS
Although from one perspective New Kingdom pharaohs presented themselves as sui generis, each one a unique embodiment of Egyptian kingship as formed by the creator at the beginning of time and space, 90 they were also acutely conscious of the historical dimension of Egyptian kingship, of the long, almost endless line of human rulers who had preceded them. In particular, the earlier Eighteenth Dynasty had already evinced "a re-awakened consciousness of the past," 91 manifest, among other ways, in the display of king lists (stretching back over the centuries) in monumental contexts and the maintenance of cults dedicated to sometimes long deceased monarchs. Specifically, "theThutmosids of the 15th century fostered the worship of the royal ancestors, and re-awakened withal an interest in the king-list tradition"; they saw especially in the Twelfth Dynasty (ca. 1938—1755 BC and of Theban origin) a model for the administrative and cultic systems the Eighteenth Dynasty rulers were putting in place. 92 Thutmose I l l s interest in these ancestral figures seems stronger than most, although this impression may result from the higher chance of survival due to the multitude of inscriptions produced by such an unusually long reign. In any event, Thutmose III noted that during his renovation of the hypostyle hall of Thutmose I at Karnak (between Pylons I V and V ) , which had been damaged and structurally weakened by a cloudburst and excessive rain, he "removed [the statues o f ] the other kings of Upper and Lower Egypt" in this hall so that his renovations would not mask them, and reinstalled them so that "they might be on view for millions of years." 93 Later, in the vast Akh Menu complex Thutmose built east of Amun-Re s temple, there was a small chapel dedicated to the cult of the royal ancestors. They were shown as a series of no less than sixty-two seated statues, 94 perhaps the very group actually located in the hypostyle hall. In this chapel "great divine
4° ^
THUTMOSE
III
oblations" were offered to the kings ancestral spirits, 95 whose statues, in a more portable form than the larger ones of the hypostyle hall, visited the Akh Menu on festival occasions. The kings who, to judge from this chapel, had a special interest for Thutmose III and his immediate predecessors (Thutmose found the statues already present in Thutmose I s hypostyle hall) include some kings of the Fifth and Sixth Dynasties (Old Kingdom), many of the Eleventh and Twelfth Dynasties, some of the Thirteenth (Middle Kingdom), and some of the Sixteenth and Seventeenth (Second Intermediate period predecessors of the Eighteenth Dynasty at Thebes). The selectivity involved may have been due to reasons of space or the historical modesty of many preceding kings, but the omission of the Fourth Dynasty is striking, while the emphasis on the Eleventh and Twelfth was perhaps due to the Theban origin they shared with the Eighteenth and the models Middle Kingdom government and culture provided to the Eighteenth. As for Thutmose s immediate ancestors, special arrangements were made for their cults according to Redford. Images of all kings (and others?) from Ahmose onward were placed in "naos shrines of stone with doors of true cedar," which (figs, i.i and i.z) ran along the southern and northern lateral walls of the peristyle court behind Pylon V I 9 6 and were thus closely associated with the point at which the great festival processions of Amun-Re began. However, Hatshepsut and Thutmose III had an especially marked interest in their two closest predecessors, Thutmose I and Thutmose II. Close family ties may have been one reason for this, but it was given a special edge by what we can infer about concerns about the legitimacy, and hence the effectiveness, of the claims of the corulers to royal authority and power. During both their corule and the sole reign of Thutmose III thereafter, Hatshepsut and Thutmose III individually manipulated their relationships to the two earlier kings; "historical" events were invented, and the sculptural representations of both rulers drew upon, in changing ways, the physiognomic elements typical of representations of Thutmose I and Thutmose II. 9 7 The issue of legitimacy, of a proper relationship to the ancestral spirits and ultimately the creator from whom they emanated, was less likely related to systemic problems than to individual ones. To understand these points, the genealogy of Thutmose III must be briefly examined (fig. 1.3). A direct and indeed (to us moderns) incestuous line of descent linked the last rulers of the Seventeenth Dynasty with the earliest of the Eighteenth. This itself was an important legitimizing issue, for the Seventeenth Dynasty was famous for having initiated the wars against the Hyksos invaders, which were successfully completed (for unknown reasons) by Ahmose, reckoned later to be the first king of the Eighteenth Dynasty and recalled as much as fifty years
An Enigmatic Pharaoh
^
39
later by Hatshepsut, who spoke of restoring or completing temples left in ruins or unfinished "since the Asiatics were in the midst of Avaris of the Northlands (the Hyksos capital) and the barbarians were in the midst of them . . . while they ruled in ignorance of Re." 9 8 Like his father, Sekenenre Tao II, Ahmose married his full sister, also called Ahmose, but their son, king Amenhotep I, died without male heirs, and his sister (another Ahmose) married Thutmose I, who was not a direct descendant of the royal line and perhaps not even a royal relative. Thutmose I had at least two queens. Ahmose, the royal princess referred to above, bore him Hatshepsut, who was thus a direct descendant of the kings preceding her. Another queen, Mutnofret—not apparently of royal descent—was the mother of Thutmose II. Following earlier tradition, Thutmose II married his (half) sister, Hatshepsut, and they had a daughter, Neferura. However, Thutmose II had other wives, and one Isis (not apparently of royal descent) gave birth to Thutmose III. This made the latter the descendant of "commoners" (Thutmose I and II), not a member of the royal line; by the same token, he was also not a product of the brother-sister (or half sister) marriages that had been preferred, when possible, in the royal family up to this time. These systemic issues may not have lessened the legitimacy of Thutmose III in his own eyes or those of contemporaries. His grandfather, the commoner Thutmose I, had been a fully effective king, and later, when circumstances required, such commoners were again brought into the royal family (fig. 1.3). Akhenaten (or perhaps Tutankhamun) may have been the last of the direct line of kings in the Eighteenth Dynasty after Thutmose III, and kings Ay, Horemheb, and Ramesses I were all commoners brought in because no royal heir was available. As to brother-sister marriage in the royal family, it seems not to have been practiced again until the later Eighteenth Dynasty (by, perhaps, Smenkare and Tutankhamun), so whatever the reasons for the practice were they do not seem to have been compelling. However, as individuals, Hatshepsut and Thutmose III may well have been anxious that their legitimacy be specially emphasized, for different reasons in each case. So far as Thutmose was concerned, he acceded to the throne as a very young child, perhaps even "a nursling," 99 and the practical business of royal government seems to have been assumed immediately by Hatshepsut, a mature woman, formerly a princess of the royal house, and queen of Egypt for some years as wife of Thutmose II. There were precedents for such a regency, as we might call it; in particular, Ahhotep, the mother of king Ahmose, hero of the war against the Hyksos, seems to have had a similar role. 1 0 0 However, Hatshepsut did not or (perhaps for ideological reasons) could not relinquish power as Thutmose matured. Instead,
4° ^
THUTMOSE
III
by the seventh regnal year she had been declared formally a king, perhaps to reinforce her authority sinceThutmose would still be very young, and she remained such until her death in the twenty-second year, by which time Thutmose was at least twenty. During this period, Thutmose had also been a full king but essentially a junior cornier, whose effectiveness (we cannot be sure of this) might have been very limited. Thus, as sole ruler he might have followed practices designed to enhance legitimacy by reference to his father, Thutmose II, and especially his grandfather, Thutmose I, in order to "live down" his possible junior status during the corule. Late in his reign, the security of the accession of his young son, the future Amenhotep II, may have stimulated Thutmose III to a further manipulation of royal sculpture to reaffirm his and Amenhotep s links to the earlier Thutmosids. 1 0 1 As for Hatshepsut, her potential problem vis-à-vis legitimacy was basically one of gender; the archetypal Egyptian ruler was always male, and even the female kings who preceded (Nitiqret, Sixth Dynasty; Nefrusobek, Twelfth Dynasty) or followed her (Tausret, Nineteenth Dynas t y ) 1 0 2 do not seem to have claimed kingship to the same extent. One solution to this gender-based doubt about legitimacy was to increasingly represent Hatshepsut as not a female king but a fully male one; 1 0 3 but another was to invent a "divine birth," such as male kings enjoyed, and a fictitious recognition of her kingship by her royal father, Thutmose I . 1 0 4 Finally, of course, Hatshepsut—having died in regnal year 22—herself became one of Thutmose I l l s ancestral spirits. And he seems to have venerated her as such through the early years of his single rule. However, for reasons that are still debated, she was eventually removed from the august company of Thutmose s "fathers," the kings of Upper and Lower Egypt who preceded him. In the forty-second regnal year, twenty long years after her death, a "proscription" began, and Hatshepsuts representations and names were carefully chiseled out of her surviving monuments in Thebes and elsewhere. In Egyptian theology, this was tantamount to extinction, to the "second death" or complete annihilation experienced by Egyptians found unfit to enter the afterlife. With her images and names gone, Hatshepsut could no longer receive the cultic attention that other deceased kings, and even the deities themselves, depended on for their continuing existence. This proscription was honored by following generations. Hatshepsut survived historically in king lists used for dating and reference purposes (she seems to have been included as an Amessis or Amensis in the king list of Manetho, drawn up in the third century B C ) 1 0 5 but not in such lists placed in religious settings. 106 Moreover, her mortuary cult ceased at Deir el-Bahari, although in other ways Djeser Djeseru continued to function.
An Enigmatic Pharaoh
THE
^
23
CORULERSHIP
As noted earlier, the extreme youth of Thutmose III at the time of his accession required that a regent take responsibility for actual governance, and the arrangement made is succinctly described in a retrospective inscription in the tomb of the official Ineni: Thutmose II having gone "forth to heaven, having mingled with the gods," 1 0 7 his son (Thutmose III) "stood in his place as king of the Two Lands" while his "sister [actually his aunt by marriage] the Divine Consort Hatshepsut settled the affairs of the Two Lands by reason of her plans." 1 0 8 Despite the late date of the composition, the text likely describes what actually happened. A powerful and successful royal family, served by a coterie of loyal and efficient officials, had to solve the crisis engendered by Thutmose I l l s youth and perhaps thought a close female relative would be less likely to usurp the succession. Thutmose s age at accession is unknown, but it is guessed it lay between a year or two, on the one hand, or perhaps five or six on the other. 109 Such are the ambiguities of our evidence that Hatshepsut s age when Thutmose III acceded the throne is also doubtful, 1 1 0 an issue that could have had important political implications. Some suggest it was only fifteen or sixteen, which would make it likely that senior relatives actually governed Egypt for a period in the name of Thutmose III (king) and Hatshepsut (regent); but others think Hatshepsut was twenty or twenty-five at the time and capable of assuming direct responsibility from the outset. In any event, Hatshepsut was at least twice, and maybe three times, as old as Thutmose III when he acceded the throne. In these circumstances, "decrees" issued by Thutmose III in his early years must have been at Hatshepsut s (or another's) initiative. Indeed, in regnal year 2 the scenes and texts commemorating his endowment of the cult of king Senwosret III (Twelfth Dynasty, ca. 1836—1818 BC) at Semneh temple in Nubia 1 1 1 were originally complemented by others featuring queen (as she was then) Hatshepsut, subsequently erased. 1 1 2 Precious few such decrees actually survive (see the donation stela of Senenmut, year 4 and, more doubtfully, the year 5 appointment of the vizier Useramun). 1 1 3 After the death of Hatshepsut, Thutmose III sought to present a very different, and more purposive, picture of his life as a crown prince and then a young king. He had a long inscription set up in Karnak Temple recording his benefactions on behalf of Amun-Re but prefaced it with a "historical text" describing the uniqueness of his relationship to the god. In this, Thutmose describes how he was serving as a priest in Amun-Re s temple when, during a festival procession, the gods image forced its bearers to searchThut-
4° ^
THUTMOSE
III
mose out so Amun-Re could identify him publicly as the one chosen to be Egypts king. There followed an "ascent" to heaven (in reality, instruction in the arcane secrets of the rituals intended to ensure the orderly progression of the solar cycle) and a coronation by the god himself. 1 1 4 In reality, Thutmose s accession was likely much less dramatic and more routinized, and the description was probably recognized by his contemporaries in the elite as "fictitious."This did not, however, deprive it of power, for Egyptians had an understanding of the fictitious different from ours, if the context was appropriate. Since it was never certain which prince (or other person) would accede, a pharaoh, once enthroned, was able to promulgate revelations that were made known after the event and shown to be true by it. In particular, accession made it clear that the new king s mother had been impregnated by Amun-Re, not the king s actual father, and it was this "divine" birth that ensured the infant involved would in fact become the next k i n g . 1 1 5 Thutmose s claim about Amun-Re s selection of him is a variation on this theme, and legitimate in the eyes of contemporaries, even if, historically speaking, it did not actually occur. Thutmose s retrospective revelation was presumably stimulated by a drive to emphasize the fact that he had indeed been the legitimate heir, despite his extreme youth, at the time of his father s death. Hatshepsut herself, after the assumption of full kingship probably in or about the seventh regnal year, also publicized such revelations, though for a different reason; she wished to show that the transformation of her regency into kingship was also legitimate and guaranteed justificatory revelations. One, in fact, was a version of the same story just quoted about Thutmose I I I ! 1 1 6 This was subsequently transformed, by Thutmose III, into a text relating to Thutmose I, but other revelatory fabrications of Hatshepsut have survived better. These include a classic sequence of divine birth scenes and texts, 1 1 7 followed by an otherworldly coronation of the queen as king, 1 1 8 the terrestrial manifestation of Hatshepsut as k i n g , 1 1 9 and finally a "historical" section in which Thutmose I, Hatshepsuts father, is described as announcing to his court that Hatshepsut is his heir, that she will follow him as king, and what her full royal titulary will b e . 1 2 0 T h e merging of the celestial and terrestrial, of the other world and this world, and of past, present, and future throughout this entire extended series of scenes and texts is characteristic and was acceptable to Hatshepsuts contemporaries as a revelation of what actually happened, even if its transcendental qualities meant it was not recorded in contemporary descriptions or archives. In reality, the elaborate activities could not have occurred when Hatshepsut was made regent by the royal family: the king, as a child, needed a mature relative to actually manage the government. Only later, when Hatshepsut formally assumed kingship, did such revelations become
An Enigmatic Pharaoh
^
25
possible and indeed perhaps necessary to gloss over the stages whereby she actually reached this exalted position. At this point, she may actually have arranged for a coronation ceremony and so brought together the revelatory and the actual, the past and the present. 121 Hatshepsut s reign as pharaoh, running parallel in formal terms to Thutmose Ills, was a relatively long and successful one in Egyptian terms. 1 2 2 She kept the government running efficiently; she initiated and largely completed major building projects at Karnak Temple, probably Luxor temple, and Deir el-Bahari, as well as elsewhere; 123 and she organized some other important state projects, not least of which was a great trading expedition to Punt— on the African shore of the Red Sea—in the eighth and ninth regnal years. Such expeditions went far back in Egyptian history, but none survives as well recorded as this one in scene and text. 1 2 4 What was Thutmose I l l s role and status during this long span of royal activity? As Dorman shows, 1 2 5 Hatshepsut relatively rapidly underwent a process during which (according to the epigraphic and iconographie record) she moved from being (while regent) a queen to an assumption of royal titles (though still represented as female in form and dress) and then, finally, to a "purely masculine image," that is, seemingly a fully male ruler. However, in texts throughout her reign grammar continued to identify her as female, not so much as a concession to historical reality as a means of maintaining the essentials of her individual personality, which—at a transcendental level—was to benefit from the rituals of which her images, in relief or in the round, were the recipients. Throughout this period, as Dorman shows, Hatshepsut was careful to maintain an "etiquette" that recognized Thutmose s continuing status as a legitimate co-king but also showed that he was junior and subordinate to her. Thus, he is iconographically associated with her major building projects but is also shown in positions subordinate to hers and much less frequently. Laboury brings out well the complex roles royal portraiture played during the corule and the fact that it was likely manipulated by Hatshepsut so as to again indicate a productive relationship between herself and her co-king, but at the same time subtly communicate his subordination to her. 1 2 6 All this having been said, we should not see Thutmose III during the coreign as a complete cipher: rather, we should remember that even halfway through the corule, after, for example, the great Punt expedition had left and returned, Thutmose may have been only twelve years old, or at most sixteen. In these circumstances, it is what was done for him, or that which he was permitted to do, that is impressive and reflective of the relatively high status he enjoyed. We have seen his position acknowledged in the iconography of Hatshepsuts buildings (later he was to claim most of them as due to his initia-
4° ^
THUTMOSE
III
tive). 1 2 7 Moreover, as for all kings, his mortuary temple was begun early in the corule to ensure that in the event of an unexpectedly early death his mortuary cult, and his eternal well-being, would be well based. This temple, poorly preserved but well excavated and recorded (and reconstructed in plan) by Ricke, was large and originally quite impressive. The enclosed space originally occupied 9,450 square meters (almost 1 hectare or 2.47 acres); later, during his sole rule, Thutmose added a court, and a large pylon, in front. 1 2 8 Nevertheless, the characteristic imbalance of the corule was maintained. Hatshepsuts mortuary temple at Deir el-Bahari, even excluding its large but empty first court, covered an area of about 1 hectare, significantly not much larger than Thutmose s temple. However, its unusual terraced form, and unusual location, conferred upon it a unique status; it not only associated Hatshepsut with the similarly structured temple of king Nebhepetre Mentuhotep nearby (which Hatshepsuts temple was "squeezed in" by), 1 2 9 a ruler greatly venerated by the Eighteenth Dynasty, but it also linked Hatshepsut s cult strongly to Amun-Re s important annual Festival of the Valley. Roehrig believes that Thutmose s tomb, K V 34, with its elaborately decorated burial chamber, was not begun until the corule was over, 130 although this seems unusually late, given that his mortuary temple was apparently built while Hatshepsut still reigned. Her tomb ( K V 20) has a complex history, as Roehrig demonstrates, and it is not well preserved; however, it—like Thutmose Ills—was likely elaborately decorated with funerary scenes and texts. 1 3 1 Also important for Thutmose s status and activities during the corule are the military campaigns of Hatshepsut. The idea that corule represented the ascendancy of a "peace party," represented by her and dedicated to relatively peaceful contacts abroad, has been a long-lived one, 1 3 2 with Thutmose seen as the least putative leader of the "war party," kept under control by Hatshepsut while she was alive. In reality, Hatshepsut may have been a relatively traditional pharaoh insofar as making war was concerned. Redford long ago pointed out that accidents of preservation have probably created a misleading impression in this regard, and he plausibly suggests that four Nubian campaigns, and two Levantine, occurred during her reign. Moreover, contemporaries state that Hatshepsut appeared on the battlefield during one Nubian campaign, a statement worthy of credence and indicative of her determination to perform the role of king as fully as possible. 1 3 3 What is significant here is that Thutmose III may himself have led the two campaigns that occurred relatively late in the corule, 1 3 4 indicating that his status was high enough for him to be given access to significant military power without endangering Hatshepsut. As for Thutmose s personal life at this time, little is known. An appropriate consort was surely found for him, probably queen Satiah, who is first
An Enigmatic Pharaoh
^
27
documented as his wife early in his third decade, soon after Hatshepsuts death. A commoner, in the tradition that was to be followed for several reigns subsequently, she bore the king a "prince Amenemhet" (the Twelfth Dynasty royal name is significant), who did not, however, survive his long-lived father. Thus, the first two decades of Thutmose s reign close on a characteristically enigmatic note. Was the corule essentially a peaceful collaboration between two rulers, one mature, the other maturing under Hatshepsuts tutelage, dedicated to the survival and best interests of the royal family to which they belonged? Or was it a time of stress and competition, with the corulers —as Thutmose became older—jockeying for power and each developing a group of competitive supporters among the elite? To suggest that the answers lie somewhere between these extremes is plausible but not very helpful; hopefully, continuing research into this fascinating topic—well covered in several chapters in this book—will bring greater clarity.
T H U T M O S E III: W A R R I O R
KING
The next phase of Thutmose s career, extending over another twenty years or so, has its own special character as a result of the kings frequent and often very substantial campaigning abroad and the associated administrative activity that led to the development of an imperial system, albeit probably of a looser and more flexible kind than those familiar to us from more recent times. I have noted that Eighteenth Dynasty internal government, while effectively centralized, may have been structured as a "patrimonial" system that operated differently from the more "rational" systems of the first millennium BC. By the same token, the "empire" also would have been organized along patrimonial lines, and certainly such data as we have on it—fromThutmose s reign and later—suggest a loosely structured entity. This perhaps led the distinguished Egyptologist Alan Gardiner—who grew up in the latter years of the British Empire and its famously "impersonal" bureaucracy—to observe that "it may even be doubted whether the much vaunted Egyptian empire ever existed." 135 The military campaigning of Thutmose III has often been discussed, but its history is based on a complex set of sources and can be difficult for a reader to keep fully clear. As an introduction to subsequent chapters exploringThutmoses campaigns in the Levant and Nubia, 1 3 6 I outline here what is known about this campaigning and comment briefly on some of the issues raised. First, we must remember that under Hatshepsut there was some military campaigning in both Nubia and the Levant. Its seriousness is hard to evaluate on the basis of the small amount of evidence that survives, but it may
4° ^
THUTMOSE
III
have involved as many as six such initiatives, not a small number for a New Kingdom ruler. Moreover, there are indications that Thutmose III was involved in the later ones, and—if Hatshepsut was absent—he could have been, as a king, the leading figure. When his sole reign began, Thutmose was therefore not inexperienced in military affairs; on the contrary, his "first campaign of victory," as he called it, in year 23 reveals him as a full-fledged war leader and a superb tactician. Such qualities cannot be learned via training alone and reflect an already considerable military experience. Moreover, throughout the next twenty-two years Thutmose was often engaged in substantial campaigning (always, at least insofar as he personally was concerned, in the Levant, though campaigns may have been led by others on his behalf elsewhere), as is revealed by a unique source, the so-called Annals. By his forty-second regnal year, Thutmose had effected many changes in the cluster of stone-built rooms Hatshepsut had created around the bark shrine of Amun-Re s temple at Karnak. I 3 7 These rooms lay between the peristyle courts behind (east o f ) Pylon V I and the remainder of the temple, which has survived poorly.Thutmose I l l s bark shrine was a long, freestanding stone structure that stood partially within a large room and had a walled but open court in front of it. Along the walls of the room and courtThutmose s artisans had inscribed, in or after his forty-second regnal year, the Annals, a long, more or less continuous text. It began in the (approximate) northeast corner of the room and ran along its north wall; it then appears to have moved abruptly to the south wall, and continued along this for a space and then returned equally abruptly to the north wall face, extending out into the court, then turning along the west wall of the court, and finally terminating in its southeast corner. In a sense, then, the Annals virtually surrounded the bark shrine with a continuous text, most of it focused on military campaigning, booty, and "tribute" (in a variety of forms) but concluding (in the south half of the court) with a list of festivals and offerings created for Amun-Re. 1 3 8 The logic of this sequence (campaign and tribute descriptions, followed by a festival calendar) is the New Kingdom theory that the gods authorized warfare and guaranteed a pharaohs success; he undertook the task victoriously and in return lavished on the deities, especially Amun-Re, a rich array of buildings, gifts, estates, festivals, and offering cults intended to signal the pharaohs, and Egypts, gratitude and maintain—by pleasing the deities—the cyclical momentum of the process. Nevertheless, while the ideological reasons are clear, the placement of texts describing such warlike events in close proximity to a main internal component of a temple is virtually unique. Such material was more commonly displayed, often with pictorial embellishment, on temple pylons and exterior wall faces, along the
An Enigmatic Pharaoh
^
29
inner faces of courts, and on large stelae set up in front of, rather than within temples. The source drawn upon for the Annals, as Redford has demonstrated, is likely the daybook—a widely distributed genre of record—originating in the court of the king, of which actual examples (none relating to Thutmose III) have been found. 1 3 9 Such records were organized calendrically, a day by day record, and in the case of that underlying the Karnak Annals reported on the king s whereabouts, his movements from town to town and his (military) activity and, an important point, his reception of 'tribute' delivered in a specific regnal year (and probably, in the original, on specific days). 1 4 0 The Annals cover regnal years 22 to 42, and were deliberately terminated at that point, insofar as the inscriptions were concerned. That is, they were carved in their entirety in year 42 or later, 1 4 1 but they drew upon an existing daybook record that stretched back over twenty-two years and of course continued to be kept after year 42. Over those twenty-two years, the Annals record fourteen specific "campaigns of victory," and in fact fifteen, although the last (in year 42) is not specifically named as such. Thus, the eight other years were not marked by campaigns, or perhaps the presence of the king in the Levant, and may have recorded simply the delivery of tribute to Egypt. This, in fact, is specifically the case in years 38 and 39, but unfortunately, the records of some other years are damaged or concealed, including some that would have recounted some of the campaigns of victory. As Redford s analyses demonstrate, 142 Thutmose s campaigning was punctuated by key episodes of major activity separated by less intense periods that nevertheless would involve the development or maintenance of the infrastructure necessary to support those initiatives. In year 23, Thutmose fought his famous campaign against Megiddo (in northern Israel), whence had gathered a coalition of forces organized by Kadesh, a major city-state in what is now Syria, far to the north. The records for the next three years are not available, but in years 29 to 31 he was campaigning vigorously against cities in Lebanon and southern Syria, which represented the interests of Tunip, another major city-state, the capital of which was not far from modern Qatna. The region around Kadesh was also attacked. This second set of campaigns gave Thutmose control of the Levantine coast as far north as modern Tripoli, and the harbors of Lebanon were organized so as to provide material support for future Egyptian initiatives by sea. With this infrastructure assured, Thutmose s campaigning in years 33 to 35 involved direct clashes with Mitanni, the great state that had developed along the Upper Euphrates and was probably ultimately the source of much of the pressure Egypt was experiencing from Syrian and, further south, even
4° ^
THUTMOSE
III
Canaanite intermediaries for the Mitannians. Thutmose s army carried prefabricated boats overland and, after considerable fighting, reached the Euphrates near Carchemish (in year 33), crossed it in the boats, and campaigned deep into Mitannian territory. The next two years involved further fighting against Mitannian forces and allies, but the Euphrates was not crossed again. Finally, at the end of the Annals, in year 42, we find Thutmose active in the north again, with Kadesh and Tunip again aggressively promoting their own and Mitannian interests. Tunip was now captured (seemingly for the first time) and perhaps Kadesh as well. In the event, Egypt never secured control of the regions in which Thutmose had done so much campaigning. Perhaps the Egyptians never intended to or perhaps it was beyond their military and organizational resources. However, Thutmose had established Egypt as one of the "great powers" of the time. In year 33, after the foray into Mitanni, other great powers—Babylon, and the Hittites—sent gifts to Thutmose, the first we know of. His successor, Amenhotep II (ca. 1426—1400 BC) was also quite aggressive but ultimately found it appropriate to conclude a treaty with Mitanni, 1 4 3 which itself was justifiably concerned about the reexpanding kingdom of the Hittites. The other prominent feature of the Annals are the lists of tribute and tributaries that are distributed throughout it, delivering to Thutmose III a variety of valuable materials and artifacts but on a surprisingly random basis. Some, though described as tribute, were really diplomatic gifts from Babylon, the Hittites, and others, and such gifts were likely sporadic, the product of specific circumstances or diplomatic correspondence that might extend over several years. Other tribute, such as that received occasionally from Punt, was really trade goods. However, Retenu, a loose term that nonetheless seems to include Canaan, which must have been part of the "imperial" system Thutmose was organizing, is surprisingly sporadic in its tribute deliveries (though they occur randomly throughout virtually the entire twenty-two-year span covered by the Annals), suggesting that Egyptian control was relatively loose, despite the garrisons Thutmose installed and the rulers' sons he took as hostages to Egypt. In contrast, articles of tribute or other exactions from Wawat and Kush—like Retenu, in close proximity to Egypt but perhaps easier to control because of their dependence on the Nile Valley—were delivered with great regularity in years 32 and 34, respectively. As Redford and others have pointed out, 1 4 4 Thutmose I l l s aggression and the imperial system he set up were of great economic benefit to Egypt, but that benefit seems to have varied widely from one part of the empire to another. However, the Annals focus on the king, highlighting only deliveries involving him, and may ignore other systems of revenue collection that were more regular and frequent.
An Enigmatic Pharaoh
^
31
Finally, some brief observations on policy and strategy are in order. In his Levantine campaigning Thutmose III was building on earlier experience, especially his grandfather Thutmose Is great raid on Mitanni, which seems to indicate that Syria, and Mitanni beyond it, was long recognized as a substantial problem and even, judging from the coalition amassed at Megiddo, a threat to Egypt.Thutmose I l l s campaigning, therefore, was likely carefully thought out over the long term and not an ad hoc process of taking advantage of successes that led the Egyptians ever farther afield. Second, some scholars think the Egyptians were not well prepared militarily to deal with the sophisticated military organizations and strongly fortified cities of the Levant. 1 4 5 This, however, seems an unnecessarily pessimistic view. The Egyptians had been well experienced in siege warfare since the Middle Kingdom, itself a potent source of inspiration to the Eighteenth Dynasty, and under the late Seventeenth Dynasty Egyptian society had become quite militarized as a result of the long conflict with the Hyksos, in which Egyptians ultimately triumphed, capturing the heavily fortified Hyksos capital of Avaris (and then another major center in Canaan—Sharuhen) in the process. 146 Moreover, the sustained and skillful campaigning of Thutmose himself seems not to have been "learned on the spot," but rather drawn from long established Egyptian military traditions and resources. After year 4zThutmose, for the remaining twelve years of his reign, seems not to have become involved in further campaigning except for a foray into Nubia in year 50. 1 4 7 Impressively, during his campaigning years, Thutmose III was also undertaking major building projects in Egypt, which required a great deal of organization and a substantial investment in materials, labor, and time. In particular, the very large temple, east of Amun-Re s own temple at Karnak and called Akh Menu, was begun in year 24. Ultimately, it occupied about 3,060 square meters (.30 hectares) and displayed an elaborately developed plan focused on the cult of Amun-Re but in close relationship to that of the king. 1 4 8 The building of this temple not only was contemporary with much of the foreign campaigning but resonated with it more directly. One section of it, adjacent to the sanctuary of Amun-Re, depicts on its walls a collection of exotic plants. An accompanying inscription reads like an entry from the royal daybook, for it is dated to year 25 and states that the represented plants were those "which his majesty found in the land of Retenu" and in fact depict "all" the flowers of "Upper Retenu." 1 4 9 This unique episode, and its connection with Amun-Re, reminds us of the ideology that made such temple building (and other projects, e.g., along the southern axis of Karnak) 1 5 0 appropriate at the height of military campaigning. Victory came from the gods, especially Amun-Re, and acknowledgment of this in the form of splen-
4° ^
THUTMOSE
III
did buildings and endowments should be immediate. Moreover, there must have been a reflexive relationship between the governmental system that could repeatedly levy and supply the armies that moved into the Levant and the vast workforces that moved between the quarries and temple building sites of Egypt.
THE FINAL
YEARS
Thutmose III died in his fifty-fourth regnal year, some twelve years after his last significant campaign abroad, in year 42. By this time, he was in his late fifties, or perhaps about sixty years old, a long life for the ancient Near East. With the empire—such as it was—relatively stable, he felt no need for further campaigning, although surviving inscriptions show he often reminisced and boasted about the exciting events that had unfolded between years 22 and 42. Yet in terms of policy-making the king remained very active, particularly in the area of temple building. Laskowski demonstrates that during these latter years there was a significant rebuilding program at the core of Amun-Re s Karnak Temple, 1 5 1 affecting especially the suite of rooms flanking the bark shrine and built originally by Hatshepsut, and further work at temples on the west bank at Thebes, including the Amun temple at Medinet Habu and the enlargement of his own mortuary temple. Most impressively of all, Hatshepsuts mortuary cult at Djeser Djeseru was virtually closed down, while a new temple (Djeser Akhet) focused on the relationship between Amun-Re and Thutmose (like Akh Menu, built earlier at Karnak). Djeser Akhet was built between years 43 and 49 and lay between Hatshepsuts temple and the prototypical and still venerated one of Nebhepetre Mentuhotep. In this way, Thutmose III, like Nebhepetre, was given a special relationship to the allimportant Festival of the Valley not achievable through his more remotely located mortuary temple. Equally impressive was an extensive program of temple building and renovation throughout the provinces of Egypt and Nubia after a long period of about fifteen years (regnal years 27 to 42) when little activity of this kind took place. This period in fact coincides closely with the sustained military and administrative initiative in the Levant, suggesting that during this time Thutmose could still dedicate considerable resources to building at Thebes, and perhaps other royal cities such as Memphis and Heliopolis, but that a nationwide building program was beyond the available capabilities. Why turn to the provincial temples at all? In part, he did so because maintaining such temples was as much a part of a pharaoh s responsibilities as building and rebuilding at the royal centers. Egypts deities formed an in-
An Enigmatic Pharaoh
^
33
terlocking assemblage, and all of them were mutually responsible for Egypts well-being and success, so all had to be appropriately treated. Moreover, provincial temples and their cult establishments were important sources of pride and income to local elites and those of their relatives who rose to high positions at Thebes and Memphis. Much later, in the Eighteenth Dynasty, Horemheb, who had attained posts of the greatest power under kings Tutankhamun and Ay, was careful to celebrate the involvement of his ancestral, provincial deity, Horus of Hut-nesu, capital of the seventeenth province of Upper E g y p t , 1 5 2 which finally brought Horemheb himself to the kingship. 1 5 3 Attention to such temples may have been one way of further integrating the Egyptian system of governance. However, it is also likely that, given a lack of royal attention, provincial temples had become seriously dilapidated by this time. Earlier Hatshepsut had boasted of restoring dilapidated temples neglected—according to her— since Hyksos times. In particular, she singled out the temple of Hathor of Cusae, where the town, rising in elevation around the temple, had so engulfed it that children were able to play on the r o o f ! 1 5 4 Finally, given the propensity on Thutmose s part for long-term planning—evident in his campaigning in the Levant—the rebuilding of provincial temples may have formed part of an overall strategy relevant to the allimportant relationship between the pharaoh, the chief deity (Amun-Re), and all other deities. The Levantine initiative had been very much a collaborative effort between Amun-Re and Thutmose, and Karnak especially benefited as a result during those war-filled years. But ultimately all of Egypt's deities were responsible for Egypt's success, and for maintaining the stability and productivity that followed, so they, too, ultimately reaped the reward at an appropriate time in Thutmose's regime. Apart from the building program, the other significant feature of Thutmose Ill's last years was the proscription of Hatshepsuts memory and, indeed, from the Egyptian viewpoint, of her very existence in the afterworld. The systematic removal of her image and name on her monuments and the deliberate destruction and burial of her statuary began between regnal years 42 and 43, that is, just as the Levantine initiative was winding down. Was this, too, part of a long-term strategy, like the provincial temple building, and hence one long anticipated? Or was it dictated largely by contemporary circumstances? I noted earlier the possibility that ideology, rather than personal renown or the development of particular political needs, may have been the driving force in the proscription (which required, incidentally, a considerable organizational effort and investment of resources, a kind of temple decorating program in reverse). In other words, however necessary, productive, and
4° ^
THUTMOSE
III
even—for all we know—cordial the corule between Hatshepsut and Thutmose may have been, by some twenty years later it had become an embarrassment and even a shadow on the legitimacy and status of the royal house. A king who was actually a woman, and known to be, and who was eventually represented as male but normally referred to textually as female, may ultimately have seemed too great a contradiction, requiring her elimination from the historical record and cultic contexts. However, alternative scenarios to explain the proscription have been put forward, 1 5 5 and, given the ambiguity of our data, they provide serious alternatives to the preceding suggestions. In particular, the family history of Thutmose III may be relevant here. N o t much is known about Thutmose s family life. As we have seen, during the corule his wife (or at least chief queen) was Satiah, whose probable son, Amenenhet, was recognized at one point as the kings eldest son (i.e., the heir presumptive) but died between regnal years 24 and 35. 1 5 6 Later, probably during his fifth decade of rule, Thutmose had a new queen, MeryetreHatshepsut, who bore him several children, one of them the future Amenhotep II. The latter was still relatively young when he acceded the throne, at eighteen years of age, and some scholars suggest that Thutmose III was anxious to ensure that his young heir would actually succeed him. To that end, he may have initiated a brief coregency between himself and Amenhotep, 1 5 7 but Laboury goes further. 1 5 8 He suggests that Thutmose feared that another branch of the royal family, descended from Hatshepsut, would try to abort the succession. To reinforce the legitimacy of his line, and hence that of the future Amenhotep II as well, Thutmose on the one hand launched the proscription of Hatshepsut, reducing the legitimacy of her descendants by denying her any. On the other, he took the positive step of ordering a change in royal portraiture (there had been several such changes, for a variety of reasons, throughout the corule and later) in which his image no longer recalled Hatshepsuts, as had long been the case, and instead revived, in archaistic fashion, the attributes typical of the portraits of Thutmose I and Thutmose II, a kind of artistic fictionalization akin to that we have seen both Hatshepsut and Thutmose III applying to pseudo-historical events recorded in texts. Thus, in terms of representation, Thutmose I, II, and III, and hence the latter s son Amenhotep, formed a composite and ideal ruler, manifested over several generations in a sequence in which Hatshepsut no longer had any place. As with many issues relevant to the reign of Thutmose III, the issue cannot as yet be resolved, and the motives and actions of those involved remain enigmatic. Yet this is part of the extraordinary fascination of this long and complex reign, which is associated with one of the most brilliant cultural
An Enigmatic Pharaoh
^
35
phases known in Egypt, the many facets of which are revealingly explored in the following chapters.
NOTES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
—
Parkinson (1997) 109—20, Ibid., 21—53, 203—11. Parkinson (2002) 149—68, 182—92, 241—48. Gardiner (1961) 184. Redford (1967) 87. Hayes (1973) 319. For recent overviews of Thutmose III, see Fevre (1993); andTulhoff
(1984). 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40.
Breasted (2001) 2:59—61. Ibid., 184-85. Lichtheim (1976) 62—66. Loprieno (1996). Ibid., 277—78. Parkinson (2002) 8—10, 241—48. Redford (1967) 74—76. Breasted (2001) 217. Kitchen (1982). Ibid. See chapter 2 of this book. James (1973) 306—4. Murnane (1977a). See chapter 9 of this book. See chapter 10 of this book. See chapters 2 and 7 of this book. O'Connor (1996) 95, n. 13; Winlock (2001) 76—78, 91, 141—42, 154—63, 168—73, î^7—89* 209—17. See chapters 2, 7, and 12 of this book. For the reconstruction, see Weeks (2001) 70—71. See chapter 5 of this book. Haeny (1997) 93—95; Bryan (2001). Haeny (1997) 95. See chapter 5 of this book. Ibid. Ibid. Ibid. See chapter 7 of this book. Ibid. Assmann (1995a). Gardiner (1947) 159^—162^. Assmann (2001) 3—4. Osing(1981). O'Connor (1993a) 10—57; idem (1991). For a different view, see Adams (1977) 118—94. Zibelius-Chen (1988); Smith (1995); Morkot (1987).
4° ^ 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50. 51. 52. 53. 54. 55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60. 61. 62. 63. 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69. 70. 71. 72. 73. 74. 75. 76. 77. 78. 79. 80. 81. 82. 83. 84. 85. 86.
T H U T M O S E III
See chapter 10 of this book; Morkot (1991); O'Connor (1987). Kitchen (1999). Säve-Soderberg (1946) 13; Kitchen (1993) 591—602. Redford (1997); O'Connor (1997); Bietak (1997); Oren (1997). James (1973) 311. Redford (1992) 129—56. Ibid., 155—56. See, especially, Callender (2001) 163—64, 166—67, 178—79; and, in more detail, Kemp (1983) 137-47. Redford (1992) 148—56; Drawer (1973) 431—33, 444Redford (1992) 154—55. Kemp (1992) 147-49. Betancourt (1997). Bietak (1997) 115—24; Cline (1998b); Bietak (2000). Wachsmann (1987). Hayes (1973); O'Connor (1983). Van den Boorn (1988) 18—22. See, for example, Spalinger (1992). Butzer (1976) 83; see also Hassan (1993). For a revealing cross section from later in the New Kingdom, see Katary (1989). Butzer (1976), chapter 5. Hassan (1993) 554—55. Ibid., 558—68; O'Connor (1993a) 576—82. Van den Boorn (1988) 13, 14—41. Ibid. 42ff. Ibid. 55ff. Imperfectly, O'Connor (1983) 208, 204—18. Van den Boorn (1988) 98—108. For a detailed overview, see chapter 3 of this book. Van den Boorn (1988) 77ff. Ibid., 208—15. Ibid., 234—49. Schloen (2001) 51. Ibid. 313—16. O'Connor (1993a). On palaces, see O'Connor (1995). On temples, see Arnold (1992), and Wilkinson (2000). Nims (1965). Hornung (1990); Weeks (2001). Arnold (1997) 74—76. Haeny (1997) 92. See chapter 6 of this book. Lauffray (1979) 47. Breasted (2001) 2:13. Klug (2002) 28, translation by the author. Ibid., 31, translation by the author. Barguet (1962) 258—64, 268—72. Nims (1965) 102.
An Enigmatic Pharaoh 87. 88. 89. 90. 91. 92. 93. 94. 95. 96. 97. 98. 99. 100. 101. 102. 103. 104. 105. 106. 107. 108. 109. no. hi. 112. 113. 114. 115. 116. 117. 118. 119. 120. 121. 122. 123. 124. 125. 126. 127. 128. 129. 130. 131. 132.
^
37
O'Connor (1995) 271—72. Ibid., 270—79. Van Dijk (1988) 37. Silverman (1995) 67—68; idem (1991) 67—72. Redford (1986b) 165ff. Ibid., 170. Ibid., 175—76. Ibid., 29—31. Ibid., 32. Ibid., 34. See chapters 2 and 7 in this book. Breasted (2001) 2:125—26. See chapter 2 in this book. James (1973) 306—7. See chapters 7 and 12 of this book. On all three, see Robins (1993) 50. See chapter 2 in this book. Breasted (2001) 2:75—86, 87—100. Waddell (1948) 101—19. Redford (1986a) 35, 242. Breasted (2001) 2:48. Ibid., 142. See chapter 2 of this book. Ibid. Breasted (2001) 2:69—72; chapter 2 of this book. See chapter 2 of this book. Ibid. Breasted (2001) 2:59—68. Brunner (1964); Silverman (1995) 69—72. For an early example, see O'Connor (1999) 218. Redford (1967) 74—76. At Deir el-Bahari; see Breasted (2001) 2:78—87. Ibid., 88-89. Ibid., 89—94. Ibid., 94—99. Redford (1967) 74—7&> 9Z~97For good overviews, seeTyldesly (1998); and Desroches-Noblecourt (2002). See also Hayes (1973); and Redford (1967), chapter 4. See chapter 5 of this book. Kitchen (1993); Smith (1965) 137—39. See chapter 2 of this book. See chapter 7 of this book. See chapter 5 of this book for the so-called Texte de la Jeunesse. Badawy (1968) 336, fig. 179, 337—38; Haeny (1997) 95—96. Haeny (1997) 94. See chapter 6 of this book. Ibid. Gundlach (1992).
4° ^ 133. 134. 135. 136. 137. 138. 139. 140. 141. 142. 143. 144. 145. 146. 147. 148. 149. 150. 151. 152. 153. 154. 155. 156. 157. 158.
T H U T M O S E III
Redford (1967) 57—62; chapter 10 of this book. Redford (1967) 62. Gardiner (1961) 230. See chapters 9 and 10 of this book. See chapter 5 of this book. For the entire text, see Breasted (2001) 2:163—227. Redford (1986a) 124, 107—10, 112—15. Ibid., 124—25. Breasted (2001) 2:217. See chapter 9 of this book; and Redford (1992) 156—62. Redford (1992) 163—65. See chapter 9 of this book. See, for example, ibid. O'Connor (1997). See chapter 10 of this book. See chapter 5 of this book. Breasted (2001) 2:193. See chapter 5 of this book. Ibid. Gardiner (1947) 2:107—8. Breasted (2001) 3:16—17. Ibid., 2:124. See especially chapter 7 of this book. See chapter 12 of this book. Ibid. See chapter 7 of this book.
TWO
The Early Reign of Thutmose III: An Unorthodox Mantle of Coregency P E T E R F. D O R M A N
T
he reign of Thutmose III, destined to be the longest and one of the most glorious of the Eighteenth Dynasty, opened under what contemporaries must have considered to be inauspicious circumstances. The recent past had been a time distinguished by the stunning triumphs of Thutmose I, whose exploits beyond the borders of Egypt had in turn built on the military achievements of his immediate predecessors. To the north Egyptian armies had reached the Euphrates River, a feat commemorated by a stela set up on its eastern bank; and if this military action was only a farflung raid rather than a concerted policy of territorial domination, it nonetheless eliminated the threat of foreign invasion from Asia for four hundred years.1 Closer to home, southern Palestine, the cultural homeland of the Hyksos kings, who had until recently ruled the Nile Valley from their capital at Avaris, had been overrun and was to remain within the Egyptian sphere of influence until the end of the Bronze Age in the Levant. 2 The southern reach of Egyptian conquest had been extended into Nubia well beyond the rocky barrier of the Fourth Caratact, far surpassing the territory controlled by the monarchs of the Middle Kingdom and setting the stage for the gradual Egyptianization of the indigenous population. 3 Foreign successes were commemorated at home by a significant expansion of the temple of Amun at Karnak, and a royal tomb was prepared in the western hills of Thebes, an initiative that may already have led to the establishment of a new necropolis in the Valley of the Kings. 4 In the course of his reign of perhaps thirteen or fourteen years,5 Thutmose I had already lost two elder sons, who may have been designated successively as heirs to the throne: Amenmose and Wadjmose, both of whom
4°
^
THUTMOSE
III
were revered by later generations and accorded a place in ancestor cults of the Theban necropolis.6 When Thutmose I died, he was succeeded by a third son, who like his father was born of a woman who could claim no descent from the royal family. Mutnofret was a commoner and secondary royal wife, and her son, Thutmose II, was probably relatively young when he acceded to the throne. 7 He married his half sister, a daughter of Thutmose I and Ahmose named Hatshepsut, who may also have been of rather tender years.8 An inscription at Aswan attests to a rebellion put down in the first regnal year of Thutmose II, 9 and the Karnak Temple was further embellished with a lavish open-air festival court erected in front of Pylon I V 1 0 A brief characterization of the reign is found in the tomb biography of the architect Ineni, who had been engaged in the expansion of the Karnak Temple and excavation of the royal tomb during the floruit of Thutmose I and had survived into old age. The section of the text reserved for Thutmose II is somewhat superficial, and Ineni recounts no personal achievements of his own other than the vague role of senior adviser. The falcon in the nest . . . the king of Upper and Lower Egypt, ( 3~hpr~n~r] he being king of the black land and ruling the red land, having seized the two banks in justification. I was a confidant of the king in every place of his, and what he did for me was greater than (for) those who had gone before. Revered, I attained old age, being in the favor of his majesty in the course of (every) day, with the result that I was provisioned even from the offering table of the king, consisting of bread from the royal repast, and beer as well, rich meats, vegetables, various (sorts o f ) fruit, honey, cakes, wine, and moringa oil, while my health and life were asked after, being what the king himself said, through love of me. 1 1 There is nothing to indicate from contemporary records—scarce as they are—that the dynasty was not on the verge of another long reign full of conquest overseas, but Thutmose II was apparently fated to rule Egypt for only a few years. 12 His demise seems to have left a vacuum of power on the throne of Egypt, for Thutmose II and his chief queen Hatshepsut had left no adult male heir: the only known child of the royal union was princess Neferura. 1 3 The eldest surviving prince was yet another son named Thutmose, born of a secondary queen by the name of Isis, and once again the new king himself seems to have been very young. 14 The death of Thutmose II heralded not only the beginning of a new reign but an astonishing experiment by the queen regent, Hatshepsut, in the exercise of the Egyptian kingship itself. The process by which she eventually claimed the throne in her own right is trace-
The Early Reign of Thutmose III
^
41
able in contemporary monuments, even if the purpose of this unprecedented event remains imperfectly understood. 1 5
T H U T M O S E III A N D Q U E E N THE
HATSHEPSUT:
REGENCY
T h e fateful transition to the new reign is noted somewhat laconically by the architect Ineni. [Thutmose II] ascended to heaven and united with the gods, while his son stood in his place as king of the two lands, having assumed rulership upon the throne of the one who begat him, and while his sister, the gods wife Hatshepsut, was conducting the affairs of the country, the two lands being in her care. With Egypt in obeisance she is served, the beneficent divine seed who has come forth before him, the prowrope of Upper Egypt and mooring post of the southerners. She is the excellent sternrope of Lower Egypt, mistress of command, whose counsels are splendid, with whose words the two banks are pleased. 16 T h e import of this passage is less a celebration over the advent of a new ruler than the observance of an unexpected but ineluctable succession, with its emphasis on a queen regent who is clearly acting in unusual circumstances. 17 More remarkably, the name of the new pharaoh is not mentioned. Rarely in Egyptian monumental texts is there such a sense of the specific historical moment, doubtless reflecting the immediate circumstances under which Ineni had his biography drafted, just after the death of Thutmose II and before his successor had a chance to place his official stamp on governmental affairs. 1 8 There is no other contemporary account of the accession of Thutmose III, which occurred on 1 smvo 4. T h e date is mentioned in the king s coronation inscription at Karnak, but this text is retrospective by more than forty years; 19 moreover, its recounting of the oracular selection of princeThutmose by Amun must be evaluated in light of intervening events, including the perfection by Hatshepsut of a particular genre of propagandistic treatises advocating her own kingship and descent. How old Thutmose III was on his accession day can be approximated only between certain limits, but in view of his eventual fifty-three regnal years on the throne it is likely that he was very young. 20 It is this circumstance, together with the highly visible role of Hatshepsut in state affairs—a role already unremarkable for queens at this date in the Eighteenth Dynasty 2 1 —that may best explain the unprece-
4° ^
THUTMOSE
III
dented coregency that was to emerge by progressive stages during the early years of Thutmose s rule. In terms of seniority, it is quite possible that Hatshepsut was as much as twenty or twenty-five years older than Thutmose III, 2 2 and if Ineni s description of the situation may be taken at face value she was clearly in charge of state affairs from the death of her husband. 23 Indeed, if Thutmose was only a nursling he may never have remembered a day when Hatshepsut was not in control. In light of the age difference between them, as well as Hatshepsuts presumed firm hand on the reins of government, it is especially striking that the earliest dated records of the reign of Thutmose III refer exclusively to the king. These dates provide a chronological framework for the difficult problem of establishing the date of Hatshepsut s assumption of pharaonic titulary, a problem that has not yet yielded a satisfactory solution. T h e earliest document of the reign is a visitor s graffito from the Step Pyramid complex at Saqqara, left by one Ptahhotep, which begins "regnal year i, fourth month of 3ht, day 5, under the majesty of the King of Upper and Lower Egypt, Mn~hpr~rc (Thutmose III)." 2 4 It then describes the kings benefactions in Thebes and concludes with Thutmose I l l s titulary, without mention of Hatshepsut. T h e graffito was inscribed only seven months into the new reign. In his second regnal year, just thirteen months after his accession, Thutmose III issued an order to his chief representative in Nubia, the viceroy of Kush, to have the temple of Semneh refurbished and rededicated in honor of the god Dedwen and the deified Senwosret III. 2 5 T h e wording of the royal command is reproduced on the eastern exterior wall of the temple. Year 2, second month of smw} day 7, under the majesty o f . . . the king of Upper and Lower Egypt Mn~hpr~r, son of Re Thutmose, given life. What was said in the majesty of the palace (life, prosperity, and health) to the seal-bearer of the king of Upper and Lower Egypt, the sole friend, royal son and overseer of southern foreign lands Ne[hy]: 2 6 "Have the divine food offerings, which the king of Upper and Lower Egypt, lord of ritual H^k3.w-r (Sesostris III), the Horus divine of forms, made for all the gods [ . . . ] (re)inscribed in the temple of his father, Dedwen, foremost of Nubia." 2 7 T h e inscription also mentions various amounts of cattle and grain to be offered on certain festival days for the cults of Senwosret III and his queen, Meretseger. Despite the claim that "it was his majesty who instituted the divine food offerings anew," 28 in view of his young age it must be wondered whether it was Thutmose III who personally devised a plan for a temple so
The Early Reign of Thutmose III
^
43
far distant from Thebes or whether it was merely an order issued in his name. In any case, there is no mention or portrayal of Hatshepsut on this wall. T h e exterior western wall of the Semneh temple bears a series of scenes, the central tableau of which depicts the king kneeling before Dedwen, who affixes the white crown on his head in an act affirming his coronation. 29 T h e text behind the attendant goddess, Wadjit, reads: T h e good god Mn~hpr~f made as his memorial for his father, Dedwen, foremost of Nubia, and for the king of Upper and Lower Egypt H'-kj.w-r the making for them of a temple of fine white Nubian sandstone, after my majesty found it of brick, and very ruined. 30 But there is a second royal presence in these reliefs, detectable now only as trace lines in areas that have been thoroughly smoothed over. In a continuation of the text just cited, two lines of erased inscription echo the words of Thutmose I I I . 3 1 [The hereditary heire]ss, great of favor and charm, gre[at of love . . . ] the god s wife and great king s wife, Hatshepsut, made (it) as her memorial for her father Dedwen, foremost of Nubia, that she might make life [. . .] forever. 32 More significantly, at the far right of the same wall, where the later intrusion of a doorway caused several later revisions to the scene, the deified Senwosret III was originally shown enthroned before Satet, who introduced Hatshepsut (later carefully erased) with the following words, reconstructed by Caminos from the trace lines of the inscription. Words spoken: "Your beloved [daughter, Hatshepsut], your beneficent heir, the gods wi[fe] and great kings wife—she is the daughter who has come forth from your [limbs]. With a loving heart you have raised her, for she is your bodily daughter, with the result that she makes a mem[ori]a1 for you. All health and stability on your part are her reward." 33 T h e titles of Hatshepsut are purely those of a chief royal wife, but her presence, her role, and her reception by the gods is consonant with a temple donor—who would normally be the king. T h e few original traces on the wall do not permit any observations as to the nature of her costume or insignia. In whatever manner Hatshepsut may have been portrayed at Semneh, the construction and decoration of the temple walls must postdate the royal
4° ^
THUTMOSE
III
command dated to the beginning of year 2. Unfortunately, as Caminos notes, "with the records at our disposal we cannot determine just how long the execution of this command required, that is, the time lapse between the issue of the royal order and the carving of the text and accompanying figures upon the eastern wall of the then newly finished Semna temple" 3 4 Whatever the time lag may have been, Hatshepsuts official protocol at Semneh is merely that of a queen. T h e next dated document of the reign is a donation stela, 35 discovered in situ at North Karnak, 3 6 inscribed by the steward of Amun, Senenmut, an official with close ties to the household of queen Hatshepsut and her daughter, Neferura. T h e date of the stela has been read as year 4, 1 smw 16, but the first lines have been damaged by salt effluorescence and other regnal years have been suggested as well. 3 7 T h e inscription opens as follows. Year 4, 1 smw 16, under the majesty of the king of Upper and Lower Egypt Mn~hpr~r, the son of Re Thutmose rifr-hpr.w, given life forever: a command promulgated in regard to the temple of Amun on this day in praise and in love. (His) majesty decreed that the petition of the steward of Amun, Senenmut, be granted at the (very) time of petitioning the king himself: 38 "Grant that a transfer of property be ordered drawn up for this humble servant in regard to my property, inasmuch as (it) should be done in the royal records hall on behalf of the life, prosperity, and health of Mn-hpr-r, (life, prosperity, and health) my lord, (thereby) granting that (it) endure forever. Let there be donated three auroras of land in the region of Hw.t-shm and five auroras of land in the region of S3k3, being that award which your majesty gave to me when he was only an inpw. I shall moreover make offerings of this bread and beer therefrom, which are to be presented before this god, since if the festivals of Amun are put in order in the course of every day, I shall be doing what is loved in the hall of offerings on behalf of the life, prosperity, and health of your majesty." 39 A list of the types of loaves, beer, and grain involved in these divine offerings follows; in addition, a male and a female servant of Senenmut s household are contributed "as a levy for the corvee labor which the king of Upper and Lower Egypt, Mn~hpr~r\ given life, has established for his father Amun [ . . .]." 4 0 For historical purposes, the early date and the unambiguous mention of Thutmose III would suggest that three full years after his accession official deeds were being transacted in his name alone. Unfortunately, in addition to the uncertainty surrounding the date of the stela, the first thirteen lines were entirely recarved during the restoration of monuments dam-
The Early Reign of Thutmose III
^
45
aged during the Amarna period, 41 so that a large portion of the inscription is only a Ramesside copy of the Tuthmoside text. Since the original surface of the stone is gone, it is no longer possible to form an independent judgment as to whether the prenomen of Thutmose III is original wherever it appears or whether it was surcharged over that of Hatshepsut. The question remains: had Hatshepsut assumed royal titles as early as regnal year 4? The legal provisions of the donation are followed by a separate section, now much damaged, recounting Senenmuts good character in fairly banal phrases: "I am straightforward, free from blame. Having been provided with burial as a royal favor, I attained old age [...]; no fault of mine has occurred, no blame to me can be found." 4 2 After this stereotypical account, the final section of the stela begins in the last line of the front side, which refers to "[doing what is prai]sed in the hall of offerings in Dsr~dsr.w" the mortuary temple of Hatshepsut, and continues onto the left and right sides of the stela, in a resumption of donation phraseology identical to that used for Thutmose III: "[a male and a female servant o f ] the estate of this humble servant, concluded as a levy for the corvee labor which the king of Upper and Lower Egypt, Mf.t-kj-R', given life, has established for her father Amun in
Dsr~dsr.w."43
A number of indicators in the text—the reference to Senenmuts funerary complex, on which construction seems not to have been started much before year 7; 4 4 the use of Senenmuts title "steward of Amun," which was accorded him only after the queens assumption of royal titles; 45 the occurrence of Hatshepsut s prenomen; and the mention of her temple at Deir el-Bahari— have all tended to support the claim that by internal evidence the stela must date to a time after Hatshepsut was crowned king. 46 But the organization of the text, with the appearance of cliche biographical phrases between two donation passages, suggests rather that the provisions for the Hatshepsut corvee were appended as a codicil to a preexisting composition and were intentionally not integrated with the opening phraseology. 47 It cannot be assumed, then, that the year date—whatever it may have been—of Senenmuts petition to Thutmose III pertains to the codicil of the stela, nor that the stela was set up on the date mentioned.48 Indeed, the juxtaposition of two apparently separate endowment texts points to the inscription of the stela as retrospectively recorded.49 In any case, in light of the manifold uncertainties surrounding the recarving of the donation stela and the date of its erection, it cannot be used as a reliable document to prove the early accession of Hatshepsut as king. The fifth year of Thutmose III was distinguished by the appointment of a new vizier, when the Theban official Useramun replaced his elderly father, Aamethu, in that office. The date appears in P. Turin 1878, which contains only the beginning of what was surely a laudatory literary account of the ap-
4° ^
64^T H U T M O S E
III
pointment, detailing how Thutmose III personally came to select Useramun because of his sterling qualities; 50 another version of this event, not dated, was inscribed on the walls of Useramun s tomb in Thebes. 5 1 On the face of it one might suppose that this appointment would offer a positive indication that the king was exercising his independent royal prerogative to appoint his chief deputy, but neither of the recorded accounts is contemporary with the event itself The tomb inscription was recorded when Useramun was completing his own funerary preparations toward the middle or end of the reign of Thutmose III, after the death of Hatshepsut. His royal audience was therefore the king rather than his deceased coregent, and by that date there may well have been no compunction to mention her at all. The papyrus is of an even later date, surely after the Eighteenth Dynasty, 52 and is subject to the usual context of retrospective documents, tinged with a large measure of politic hindsight. 53 Thutmose III is depicted alone on two stelae from the temple of Hathor at Serabit el-Khadim that are both dated to year 5, 54 while Hatshepsut is first mentioned as king in the Sinai inscriptions only in year 13, 55 well after her kingship is attested elsewhere. But the absence of Hatshepsut as king on the stelae of year 5 is an argument ex silentio, and in any case it was not deemed necessary during the course of the coregency to portray both current rulers in reliefs and stelae set up at Sinai. 56 A number of other monuments can be assigned to the time before Hatshepsuts assumption of royal titles. These are undated, but they shed light on the role of Hatshepsut in initiating construction projects during the early years of Thutmose III. A red granite statue of Thutmose II, showing the ruler seated wearing a Sed Festival robe and a white crown, was discovered on the island of Elephantine, where it had once been dedicated in the temple of Khnum. 5 7 The two text panels on the front of the throne have both been recarved to varying degrees: the right proper panel contains a clumsy Ramesside restoration of the name and title of Amun; and the left one now reads "for her brother, the king of Upper and Lower Egypt, c3~hpr~n~Rc (Thutmose II), beloved of Khnum, lord of the cataract region, forever." The reference to Khnum seems itself to be a later alteration of the original text, but the introduction, "for her brother," is original and must have been a continuation of the text on the opposite side of the throne. Moreover, the likeliest restoration for the inscription is the dedicatory phrase, "[(title) Hatshepsut made it as a monument] for her brother, the king of Upper and Lower Egypt, used for dedications to gods and deceased kings. Since Thutmose II is portrayed in garb suitable for the celebration of a jubilee, which he seems never to have observed, the statue must have been
The Early Reign of Thutmose III
^
47
donated at Elephantine by his widow, queen Hatshepsut, as a memorial after his death. 59 Another clue to the delicate balance of royal power at this time is a block statue of Senenmut in the British Museum, datable to the regency by the queenly titles of Hatshepsut that it bears. 60 The main inscription, carved on the front side of the enveloping gown, contains several references to the reigning pharaoh without actually naming him, a situation reminiscent of the Ineni biography. [Senenmut, . . .] one who has guided the footsteps of the king since his childhood . . . who adorns the Horus who is present on earth, one pure of limbs whom his lord has purified, who has access to the marvelous nature of the lord of the two lands . . . 6 I And, as with Ineni, Senenmuts advancement, described in a text placed on the base of the statue, seems to be largely due to Hatshepsuts personal initiative, implying that the king was of too young an age to be making decisions of appointment on his own. [M]y mistress repeated favors for me, the gods wife, Hatshepsut, may she live; she made me great and enriched me; I was promoted to the front of the officials, she having recognized my excellence in her opinion . . . 6 2 Perhaps during the same period an undated graffito was engraved at Aswan, commemorating an expedition led by Senenmut to extract a pair of obelisks from the granite quarries at the command of Hatshepsut (fig. z.i). 63 The obelisks were very likely quarried during the reign of Thutmose II but never brought to completion before his death; they are to be identified with a pair erected at Karnak in the festival court of Thutmose II on bases that now lie beneath the foundations of Pylon III. 6 4 In the Aswan graffito the queen and Senenmut appear face to face, the former wearing a long dress and the double-plumed crown of a gods wife and referred to by her queenly titles: "the heiress, great as to favor and charm, great of love, to whom Re has given the actual kingship of the two lands, who is in the midst of the ennead, the king s daughter and king s sister, the gods wife and great king s wife." By reason of Hatshepsut s garb and titles, a date in the regency period is assured for this inscription. Despite the rather blatant reminder, reminiscent of Ineni, that the kingship was, for all practical purposes, in the hands of Hatshepsut—and with explicit divine approval—she is nonetheless portrayed as a woman.
4
8
^
THUTMOSE
III
An interesting shift in ideological emphasis is observable in Senenmuts chapel at the sandstone quarries of Gebel el-Silsila, which is one of many such shrines erected by New Kingdom officials commissioned to obtain building stone for their kings. 65 On the entrance lintel of Senenmut s chapel, Hatshepsuts name and protocol, though now damaged, can still be read: "Live, the kings first-born daughter, Hatshepsut, may she live, beloved of Amun, lord of the thrones of the two lands, king of the gods ." 6 6 In the much abraded scenes of the shrine both inside and out, nothing else can be discerned of her formal protocol, but the queenly titles that associate her as sister and wife with Thutmose II seem to have vanished. Even her most important religious title, "gods wife," used ubiquitously on her queenly monuments, seems to have been purposely avoided in relation to Hatshepsut herself, although it occurs in one of Senenmuts titles on the entrance jamb. 67 Even more surprising are two scenes on the interior western wall of the cenotaph facing toward the central niche, in which the queen is portrayed in the embrace of two gods of the region: Seth of Ombos and Nekhbet. Although Hatshepsuts figures have virtually vanished due to intentional damage and natural abrasion, the extant traces are sufficient to establish that not only was she wearing a long kilt typical of male royal attire,68 but she was portrayed with her feet set wide apart, in a striding stance exclusively used for men. 69 These scenes seem to have been altered, however, following her adoption of the male form, possibly years after the unusual titles were carved on the door jamb. 70 Yet the lintel of Senenmuts cenotaph at Gebel el-Silsila may capture the penultimate step in Hatshepsuts gradual progression toward the throne of Egypt as a full coregent with Thutmose III. The disappearance of the title of gods wife in favor of "the kings firstborn daughter" represents an ideological shift, abandoning a queens prerogatives in favor of an heirs hereditary claim. Royal titles had certainly been acquired by regnal year 7. The burial chamber of Senenmuts parents, Ramose and Hatnofer, was discovered in excavations undertaken on the hillside of Sheikh Abd el-Qurna in 1935—36 by the Metropolitan Museum of Art. 7 1 Located just below the tomb chapel of their son (Theban tomb 71), the chamber had been buried below the artificial terrace of the chapel, a construction formed by three retaining walls and an enormous mass of limestone chips pouring directly from the excavation of tomb 71—and therefore dated to the beginning of tomb construction. The chamber contained several amphoras bearing dates and seals that the excavators, Lansing and Hayes, immediately recognized had a bearing on the date of Hatshepsuts accession. One amphora bore a hieratic docket on its shoulder: "year 7, second month of pr.t) day 8," a date that must have pre-
The Early Reign of Thutmose III
^
49
ceded the sealing of the tomb; a second amphora, also bearing a hieratic docket of simply "year 7," was sealed with a jar stopper bearing the stamp of "the god s wife Hatshepsut " Two others bore seals with the royal prenomen: "the good goddess Mf.t-k^R'." The amphora date of year 7, 2 pr.t 8, provides only a terminus post quem for the sealing of the tomb; the terminus ante quem is apparently indicated by an ostracon found by Norman de Garis Davies in the forecourt of tomb 71, referring to the beginning of construction "in this tomb" in year 7, fourth month of pr.t, day 2, after which limestone chips from the tomb would have begun covering the hillside just below. 72 Lansing and Hayes deduced that Hatshepsuts accession therefore took place in year 7 between 2 pr.t 8 and 4 pr.t 2; and, while this date range (less than two full months) may be too narrow for most scholars, year 7 is universally accepted as the latest possible limit for Hatshepsut s assumption of royal titles. 73 At this point the regency of queen Hatshepsut may be regarded as having ended and the coregency of the two monarchs begun.
T H U T M O S E III A N D K I N G T H E I N C E P T I O N OF T H E
HATSHEPSUT: COREGENCY
Whether or not Hateshepsuts assumption of the royal titulary occurred in year 7 or earlier, the monuments of the early reign of Thutmose III show that her unprecedented elevation to male kingship was achieved in terms of both royal protocol and visual representation but that each aspect was achieved at a different time. The first step, the date of which has been considered, was the assumption of royal titles and insignia, while Hatshepsut retained her outward female form and dress. Several documents display an intriguing mixture of kingly and queenly attributes, and they offer a basis for differing interpretations. An occurrence of the queens prenomen is to be found in the tomb of Ahmose-Pennekhbet at Elkab, a long-lived individual whose biographical text reveals that he was already a soldier in the time of Ahmose. Recounting active participation in military campaigns from Ahmose down through the reign of Thutmose II, he claims: I followed the n5w.f-[kings and the bí].ty-kings . . . to the southern and northern foreign lands and to any place in which they were: the king of Upper and Lower Egypt Nb~ph.ty~Rc (Ahmose), justified; the king of Upper and Lower Egypt Dsr-kj-R' (Amenhotep I), justified; the king of Upper and Lower Egypt f-hpr-kj-R' (Thutmose I), justified; and the king of Upper and Lower Egypt f~hpr~n~Rc (Thutmose II),
68
^
THUTMOSE
III
justified; down to the good god, the king of Upper and Lower Egypt Mn~hpr~Rc (Thutmose III), given life forever. I attained a good old age while I was a kings man, being in the favor of their majesties, my love being in the palace (life, prosperity, and health). For me the god s wife repeated favors, the kings great wife Mj c .t^k^R c (Hatshepsut), justified; I brought up her eldest (daughter), the princess Neferura, justified, while she was (still) a child at the breast. 74 The appearance of Hatshepsuts prenomen dates this text to the period of the coregency, but she is still referred to by her queenly titles, including the hm.t-nsw.t wr.t title that links her to Thutmose II. While Hatshepsut and Neferura are both mentioned, they are deliberately excluded from the chronological sequence of male kings. Moreover, the occurrence of the epithet "justified" after the names of Hatshepsut and Neferura would seem to place them in the category of deceased rulers, in contrast to the "living" Thutmose III, thus suggesting that the text was carved after the death of Hatshepsut and her daughter. 75 But such a late date would add another two decades to the life span of Ahmose-Pennekhbet, who must already have been over sixty years old when Thutmose II died. 76 Moreover, the titles used for the two women would have been obsolete at the time Thutmose I l l s sole reign began in his third decade. Neferura was elevated to the office of gods wife of Amun on Hatshepsut s accession, 77 so the particular distribution of the women's titles as they appear in this biography reflects a reality that existed only for a brief period, perhaps at the very beginning of the coregency period. 78 On an undated stela at Sinai, Hatshepsut is shown in a long dress and wearing the double-plumed headdress of the god s wife of Amun, but before her face are two cartouches, one containing her birth name and the other the prenomen that she bore as king: Mf.t-kj-R' (fig. z.z). 79 Oddly, they are carved in reverse order, the prenomen following the nomen, and each cartouche is followed by the same epithet, "may she live." Is this an indication that the prenomen was added at a later time, to a relief already in existence, or is the stela an early witness to her new royal titles?80 The evolved stage of female kingship is most clearly demonstrated by a limestone door lintel from Karnak, in which Hatshepsut stands before Amun, "offering wine that she might achieve living.'" 8 1 Her titles are "King of Upper and Lower Egypt, mistress of rit[ua]1, Mf.t-kj-R', may she live," and Amun responds by asserting "I have given to you (fem.) mi11[ions of years . . . ] like Re forever." The inscriptions, with their feminine endings and pronouns, are typical of her royal monuments, but her garb is a mixture of queenly costume and kingly headgear. Dressed in a tight-fitting robe that
The Early Reign of Thutmose III
^
51
reaches her ankles, Hatshepsut wears a short curled wig and a crown consisting of tall plumes and rams horns, with a small horned sun disk placed at the center; a uraeus rears from her brow. 82 A similar display of royal titulary—one that still falls short of male rulership—is to be found in a limestone chapel built by Hatshepsut at Karnak. Only a relatively small number of blocks from this structure, later reused in the foundations of Amenhotep I l l s Montu temple at Karnak North, have been recovered, but they are sufficient to have prompted a reconstruction by Gabolde and Rondot. 83 Only one block bears a representation of Hatshepsut herself, in which she offers in masculine guise to Amun (fig. 2.3). While the scene shows evidence of later erasure at the hands of Thutmose III, the authors are doubtless correct in recognizing that an initial alteration took place at Hatshepsut s own hands: a queenly figure with tall plumes was revised as a male king wearing an 3íf crown. 84 The titles above her head are original to the scene, however, and prove that her royal protocol was fully developed and employed during the period of her feminine portrayals. Hatshepsuts own conversion of these early female figures to male seems to be rare, and the need for it remains uncertain. 85 This modest limestone chapel apparently excludes Thutmose III altogether; it was, however, surrounded by an enclosure wall, the portal of which was decorated jointly by the two coregents.86 It must have been at approximately this time that the southern temple of Buhen was erected in the names of both Thutmose III and Hatshepsut, whose cartouches originally appeared on the doorjambs in complementary balance. While the temple has suffered the usual suppression of the queens name and figures, extant traces still reveal that in a number of scenes Hatshepsut presented offerings to individual gods—clearly as a reigning sovereign, although only the bottoms of the scenes are preserved—and that she was originally portrayed in the long robe of a queen. In one instance in the bark room of the temple, her feet are placed close together, 87 as suitable for the traditional female pose and as on the limestone door lintel from Karnak. In several other scenes in the inner sanctuary, however, an iconographie shift has occurred: although Hatshepsut is garbed in a long dress, her feet are spaced further apart, as if actively striding toward the deity, approaching the broader stance of a male king. 88 It is difficult to say how long this intermediate stage lasted, in which king Hatshepsut was represented as a woman, but certainly enough time must have elapsed for the construction of at least three monuments: her limestone chapel at Karnak, the structure to which the limestone door lintel belonged, and the southern temple of Buhen. It is significant that Thutmose II was still honored in the innermost sanctuary at Buhen during the decoration of the temple. 89 Evidently at this stage Hatshepsut had not yet committed herself
52
^
THUTMOSE
III
to relinquishing all association with her husband; that is, she had not yet taken the final step of emphasizing her descent from her father, Thutmose I, an ideological shift that was to play a prominent role in advertising her royal legitimization on her later monuments, to say nothing of her mortuary arrangements. Ultimately, kingly titles and crowns combined with a feminine costume were deemed insufficient to Hatshepsuts intended purpose. The impetus that compelled the final iconographie shift to a purely masculine image can only be surmised. Chappaz has suggested that a series of political exigencies may have arisen during the early reign of Thutmose III that, in his words, "ont pu atteindre un seuil particulièrement critique qui rendait nécessaire la présence physique (et médiatrice?) d'un souverain veritable, rôle que Thoutmosis III n'aurait pu assumer en raison de son jeune âge." 90 It is also possible that once Hatshepsut had taken the decision to assume the fivefold titulary of Egypt's pharaohs—for whatever reasons prompted it in the first place—her preference to be represented as a man may have been dictated by the unprecedented situation that there was already a legitimate ruler on the throne and he was male. Ruling in female guise as a senior coregent to a crowned king was perhaps not a permanent option for iconographie or practical reasons. 91 The gradual increments in which Hatshepsut assumed her kingship must reflect an accommodation to contemporary exigencies: either political or iconographie or perhaps a combination of the two. Nor could anyone have had foreknowledge of the many years that she would yet share on the throne with her young nephew. In the course of several years, a number of avenues for asserting her authority had been explored and discarded: the traditional and understated presence—apparent already under Thutmose II—with the queenly god's wife shown as a peripheral participant in royal scenes (as at Semneh); 92 the adoption of a prenomen, used with queenly titles or costume (as at Sinai and Elkab); and then a fuller protocol, occasionally combined with kingly crowns, laying full claim to royal status but with Hatshepsut still in female form (as in the Karnak chapel and at Buhen). It was only after these expedients had been exhausted that the queen was portrayed as a male, garbed entirely in kingly regalia, with all the ritual power and status such a transformation entailed. Nonetheless, her femininity continued to be resolutely proclaimed in the inscriptions attached to her portrayals. 93 Surely never had there existed such an odd disjunction between text and representation, the two aspects of Egyptian monumental art that are intimately related in both spatial and syntactic terms. The date at which the change to masculine form occurred remains uncertain, for the evidence of the year 7 regnal date applies only to the ap-
The Early Reign of Thutmose III
^
53
pearance of royal names for Hatshepsut. There is only one dated relief in which a male Hatshepsut is represented—the throne scene of year 9 at Deir el Bahri marking the return of the Punt expedition—but the carving of the scene was accomplished at an even later time, when the mortuary temple was being decorated. The final change to male form cannot have been long delayed, since the ambitious building programs undertaken by Hatshepsut at Karnak and Luxor, Deir el-Bahari and the Valley of the Kings, the Speos Artemidos, and Medinet Habu would have taken considerable time to complete, and by the time they were being decorated the epiphany of the male pharaoh Hatshepsut had been fully achieved. As the Karnak chapel shows, an effort was made to masculinize certain of her female figures, but in other instances the effort was not made at all. 94 Throughout the first several years of Thutmose I l l s reign there are constant indications that it was his stepmother and aunt who effectively governed or at least made important decisions that were promulgated in the name of the king. 95 It is impossible to guess precisely what part Thutmose III played in such affairs as the construction of temples, the dedication of statues, land grants to worthy officials, the appointment of viziers, the commissioning of mining expeditions, and the quarrying of obelisks, or whether he was simply far too young to claim a role. But it is clear from contemporary records that effective control rested in Hatshepsut s hands from the moment of her husbands death. Accordingly, the early monuments of the early reign of Thutmose III reflect not a sudden seizure of power by the queen but rather a deliberate and purposeful search for an appropriate iconography with which to exercise that power. 96
T H E F R A G I L E E T I Q U E T T E OF
COREGENCY
Because Hatshepsut wielded real power from the beginning of her nephew s reign and acquired regal titles and kingly iconography only in a gradual process, the question of her precise accession or coronation date is to some extent moot. Her accession date is best described as the day on which her de jure iconography caught up with her de facto authority. In purely functional terms, it changed nothing—certainly not the dating system by which all events in the kingdom were recorded. Chappaz has already pointed out that for the entire period in which she exercised power there are no documents directly dated to Hatshepsut. 97 Completely lacking from the record are inscriptions that begin with a regnal year followed immediately by the standard phrase "under the majesty of (king) Hatshepsut," one of the undoubted prerogatives of kingship. 98 By contrast, several are dated jointly to both coregents and even more to Thut-
54 ^
THUTMOSE
III
mose III alone. Joint dates appear more frequently in rock graffiti and on a single stela from Sinai (fig. 2.4); those in the sole name of Thutmose III include five regnal years that span the duration of the coregency: 13, 16, 18, 20, and 2 1 . " Clearly there was no hesitancy in ascribing dates to both of the ruling monarchs together or solely to the younger coregent. 100 The curious lack of regnal years attributed solely to Hatshepsut may be due to the vagaries of preservation; alternatively, dating to the older coregent was perhaps intentionally avoided. In any case, the known dates that can be associated with Hatshepsut alone are contained in just three texts: regnal year 9 occurs in the Punt reliefs at Deir el-Bahari, announcing the return of the expedition, in a narrative placed in front of the royal dais; 1 0 1 years 15 and 16 are mentioned in a passage that describes the length of time required to quarry a pair of obelisks for Hatshepsut at Aswan; 1 0 2 and year 17 appears in a fragmentary inscription at Karnak placed after the titulary of Hatshepsut. 1 0 3 A fourth occurrence of a regnal date is an anomaly: a stela at Sinai bears the figures of princess Neferura and Senenmut, as well as the year date 11, which is placed in the lunette above the scene, without any royal name attached. 104 Although this document has in the past been put forward as providing a unique regnal date with political significance for Neferura, 1 0 5 it is merely a reference to the eleventh year of the coregency with a discreet omission of the royal names. The general avoidance of attaching a specific regnal date to Hatshepsut alone, noticeable even on the monuments for which she took primary responsibility, is part and parcel of the etiquette of coregency that Hatshepsut devised in order to bring historical reality into concord with her ideological claims. It has been argued that Hatshepsut selected a particular dating scheme to reflect the new emphasis on her hereditary legitimacy; for example, that she "dated her reign" from the death of Thutmose II, so as to "define the nature of her claim to the royal dignity as something she had been entitled to by rightful succession;" 106 or that she "theoretically" dated her reign from the death of her father, portraying herself as the legitimate heir of both Thutmose I and queen Ahmose. 1 0 7 But none of the dates from the entire period of the coregency reflects a deliberate strategy on the part of Hatshepsut. Her regnal years simply conformed to those of Thutmose III, an expedient that had less to do with an ideological program of her own than with the necessity of maintaining the current system of dating. 108 To be sure, an ideological program was critical to the position in which she found herself.The basis for Hatshepsuts regency vis-à-visThutmose III had been her marriage with Thutmose II and her status as chief queen. But now portrayed as a masculine king—even if still referred to in the feminine gender—Hatshepsut could no longer claim royal authority through her de-
The Early Reign of Thutmose III
^
55
ceased husband, and she shed her last associations with Thutmose IL Her new claim to legitimacy was the most conservative imaginable and derived from hereditary circumstances that governed all normal successions to the Egyptian throne: she was the eldest surviving heir of Thutmose L Couched in mythological terms, it is this filial relationship that is emphasized on all the great monuments completed during her last years. The divine birth reliefs at her temple at Deir el-Bahari recount the story of the divine impregnation of queen Ahmose by Amun, disguised as Thutmose I ; 1 0 9 the "Légende de la Jeunesse" text at Deir el-Bahari describes her formal designation by Thutmose I as future monarch of E g y p t ; 1 1 0 her obelisks at Karnak extol her filial piety; 1 1 1 her mortuary temple incorporated an offering chapel for Thutmose I; and her tomb in the Valley of the Kings was furnished with a quartzite sarcophagus altered to receive his mummy. 1 1 2 Hatshepsuts mother, Ahmose, was honored as well, not only as the human focus of the divine birth reliefs but on smaller stelae, where she occasionally appears on a seemingly equal footing with Hatshepsut. 1 1 3 Thus, ideology was deliberately employed to support the fragile etiquette of coregency and to obscure the fundamental contradiction of her kingship: although she presented herself as the heir of Thutmose I, her joint rule with Thutmose III began only with the death of Thutmose II. The "Légende de la Jeunesse" belongs to the same mythico-religious topos as the divine impregnation of queen Ahmose, and there is little to be gained in suggesting a factual basis for either event, although the former text has been mined for nuggets of historical truth. The crux of the "Légende" is the coronation of Hatshepsut and the formulation of the five parts of her titulary, which are specifically decreed in the presence of her father. Even without the mythological setting of the ennead in attendance, the event is patently nonhistorical and was understood as such by Hatshepsuts contemp o r a r i e s . ^ T h e date on which the supposed coronation took place is given as I 3h.t I, corresponding to civil New Years Day, the day on which all new regnal years commenced during the Middle Kingdom; it is, however, both symbolic and archaic in nature and therefore suspect as a true date. 1 1 5 An historical accession on 1 3h.t i, even if placed during the reign of Thutmose III, is contradicted by Hatshepsuts own obelisk text at Karnak, describing the quarrying of a pair of obelisks in years 15 and 16, in which the year date changes between z pr.t 1 and 4 šmw 30, a gap that accommodates Thutmose I l l s own accession but not New Years D a y . 1 1 6 Hatshepsut evidently recorded several occasions on which she was proclaimed, when still a princess or queen, as the future monarch in ceremonies that sound very much like formal installations and presage the tenor of the coronation inscription of Thutmose III. One such proclamation is found on
56 ^
THUTMOSE
III
a block from the chapelle rouge at Karnak, which recounts a festival procession at the temple of Luxor. Year 2, pr.t 29, the third day of the festival of Amun, being the ordination of the Two Lands for me in the broad hall of Southern Opet, while his majesty (Amun) delivered an oracle in the presence of this good god. M y father appeared in his beautiful festival: Amun, chief of the gods. Then he seized my majesty [at the sta]tions of the beneficent king, multiplying the oracles for me in the face of the entire land. 1 1 7 The date, once argued by Schott to represent Hatshepsut s actual accession in the second year of Tuthmois I I I , 1 1 8 is now generally recognized as an account of an oracle purported to have taken place in the reign of one of her predecessors. 119 But whether such accounts reflect a strict or slightly altered historical reality is beside the point: in light of the oracles that Hatshepsut later broadcast, foretelling her accession to the throne and the declaration of the five portions of her titulary, it is not impossible that she staged a coronation for herself that signaled the beginning of her (male) kingship. For, while accession days (and thus regnal years) during the New Kingdom invariably coincided with the day after the death of the previous king, kingly regalia was not immediately bestowed. 120 Coronations were held at a later date and could be arranged to coincide with significant festal events, as with Horemheb and his installation during the festival of Opet. 1 2 1 There may have been some initial uncertainty regarding the effectiveness of this fragile etiquette of coregency; there is evidence that Hatshepsut inserted her name on buildings that had already been initiated in the name of Thutmose III. The peripteral temple dedicated to Amun-Re-Kamutef just outside the precinct of Mut at Karnak yielded foundation deposits in the name of Thutmose III alone, but the walls had been adorned with friezes containing the distinctive rebus of Mf.t-kj-r;122 her name was also carved on a door lintel, and on an upper door socket as well. The excavator, Ricke, concluded that the shrine had been begun by Thutmose III but finished during the coregency. 123 Some usurpation of cartouches has been noted at Karnak, 1 2 4 but a general surcharging of cartouches is not widespread, nor was Thutmose III systematically excluded from royal reliefs in general. Over the next ten to twelve years all major construction was initiated and largely completed by Hatshepsut, who always appears as the central figure in the decorated reliefs. Particular monuments, such as the Karnak obelisks between Pylons I V and V and her small limestone Karnak chapel, were dedicated in her name alone, but the great construction projects generally in-
The Early Reign of Thutmose III
^
57
eluded representations of her younger coregent as well, to be sure in a subsidiary position and less frequently than she, but nonetheless partaking in public processions and religious ceremonies. It is impossible to assess Thutmose I l l s own attitude at the time regarding his relegation to a subsidiary role in these reliefs. In the case of the chapelle rouge, which contained Hatshepsuts own propagandizing version of her divine selection as future king of Egypt, Thutmose simply claimed it as his own in later years, omitting any mention of his former coregent. 125 As with the first years of his reign, it is difficult to assess what role Thutmose III played during the declared kingship of Hatshepsut. If assessments of his age are realistic, he could have been as young as two or three at his fathers death and only nine or ten in his seventh regnal year—certainly not an age when he would be taking a predominant role in state affairs in any case. Seen in this light, the major projects initiated by Hatshepsut, such as expanding the temple of Amun and providing for her own (and her fathers) burial on the west bank, were indeed primarily hers. His inclusion in ritual scenes may be seen as a mere courtesy, even by the time these buildings were being decorated, when Thutmose could have been nineteen or twenty. Hatshepsut s temples were in fact to alter the religious topography on both banks of the Nile at Thebes: a suite of rooms built inside the pylons of her father, expanding the core of the Middle Kingdom temple at Karnak (the so-called palais de maat); 1 2 6 the chapelle rouge; 1 2 7 the Eighth Pylon, which provides a monumental facade for the southern processional route to the temple of Luxor; 1 2 8 a series of bark shrines lining the road to Luxor; 1 2 9 the expansion of the small temple of Amun at Medinet H a b u ; 1 3 0 a magnificent mortuary temple that crowned the rocky bay of Deir el-Bahari; and a royal tomb in the Valley of the Kings. 1 3 1 Except for the tomb itself, Thutmose III was excluded from none of these religious monuments. But aside from his occasional presence in temple reliefs and the occurrence of his name in graffiti in Nubia, which may signify his presence on military campaigns (for which see chapter 9 in this volume), little may be deduced concerning his active role in governance during the years of Hatshepsuts kingship.
T H E E N D OF T H E
COREGENCY
The congruence of several dated texts apparently indicates the end of the coregency in regnal year zz, although there is no certain indication of Hatshepsuts demise at any specific time. A stela at Serabit el-Khadim, dedicated by the scribe Nakht and dated to year zo, depicts Hatshepsut making an offering together with her coregent; her cartouche is followed by the epithet di
58 ^
THUTMOSE
III
c
nh d.t (fig. 2.4). 1 3 2 The campaign annals of Thutmose III begin toward the end of regnal year 22 and attest to a burst of foreign military activity, corresponding rather well to the twenty-one years and nine months ascribed by Manetho to king Amessis, described as the sister of one "Amenôphis." 133 The stela of Thutmose III from Armant refers to itself as a "collection of deeds of valor and victory" and commences with a date of regnal year 22, second month of pr.t, day 10, remarkably close to Manetho s calculation. 134 The presumed death of Hatshepsut in year 22 is therefore generally accepted by historians. Because her name was expunged from the king lists that have been preserved to the present day, Manetho s apparently accurate recognition of her reign must derive from some source other than the king list traditions available to modern historians. While attempts have been made to explain the derivation of the name Amessis from those monuments of hers that may have been accessible in the Late Period, 1 3 5 the source of the precise regnal span—measured in years and months—provided by Manetho remains a mystery. It has also been hypothesized that Hatshepsut did not actually die in year 22 but may have simply handed over the reins of power to her now fully mature nephew and stepson and continued to live on for years, retired from governmental responsibilities. 136 Evidence either for or against such an idea is lacking; its strongest appeal is purely an interpretive one. That is, if Hatshepsut survived another two decades after her supposed abdication in year 22, the commencement of her official proscription beginning in or after year 42 would coincide with her demise, and the timing for her posthumous persecution would be neatly explained. 137 But there is simply no compelling reason to assume that Hatshepsuts disappearance from the throne in regnal year 22 does not coincide with her death or that her proscription two decades later could not have been initiated for reasons other than her immediate demise. A different assessment is perhaps in order. Although Hatshepsut has been regarded as a usurper of the Egyptian throne, seizing power with the connivance of a partisan faction of officials and suffering a posthumous oblivion for her temerity, the evidence of contemporary monuments suggests that she played a rather different role, as one who spread an unorthodox mantle of coregency over the kingship to ensure the succession of a young pharaoh. Her greatest contribution may indeed have been to guarantee the stability of the first decades of the reign of Thutmose III, opening the way to an additional thirty-two years of sole rule for her nephew and stepson, distinguished by the military campaigns and domestic prosperity for which later generations would justly honor him.
The Early Reign of Thutmose III
NOTES
^
59
—
1. For the operations of Thutmose I and his predecessors in Asia, see Redford (1992) 148—54. For the nature of the Egyptian empire in Asia, see Kemp (1978a) 43—57; Frandsen (1979) 174-90. 2. For a convenient summary of the cultural basis of the Hyksos settlement at Tell elDab'a, with further references, see Bietak (1991) 27—72; and idem (1996). 3. The Kurguz inscription of Thutmose I, dated to year 2, marks the southernmost penetration of Egyptian armies; see Vandersleyen (1995a) 255—56. For recent epigraphic work on the inscription, see Davies 2001; idem 2003a; and idem 2003b; the author is grateful to Dr. Davies for drawing his attention to the last two references. The Egptianization of the Nilotic Nubian peoples is outlined in Kemp (1978a) 34—43. Kurguz perhaps marks the terminus of a land route from Korosko rather than the extent of riverine domination; see Morkot (1987) 31; and idem 1991.The northern and southern limits of conquest under Thutmose I were to acquire cosmic reference, for which see Liverani (1990) 59—62. 4. The architect Ineni s description of the construction of the royal tomb ( Urk. IV57.3—5) implies a site removed from public notice, typical of locations in the valley favored by early kings of the Eighteenth Dynasty. For the suggestion that Hatshepsut s tomb ( K V 20) was originally the one excavated by Ineni and later expanded, see Romer (1974) 119—33. For a rejoinder based on tomb typology, see Altenmüller (1983) 25—38. 5. For the possible length of the reign, see the discussion in von Beckerath (1994) no—12. 6. Amenmose s name appears in a cartouche on a naos dated to the fourth regnal year of Thutmose I (Zivie [1976] 52—55, pi. 4). For the Theban mortuary chapel of Wadjmose, see P M 2 , 444—46; Lecuyot and Loyrette (1995) 85—93; anc ^ idem (1996) in—22. The reverence accorded to the princes in later reigns is evident on the stela of Senimose, C G 34016, in Lacau (1909) 32—36, pi. 10, and in their inclusion on such ancestor lists as that of Khabekhnet, owner of Theban tomb 2, for which see Berlin Museum (1924) 190—92; and KRI 3:806—7. 7. The age of Thutmose II has been debated in recent years, but the general consensus supports a youthful one. Gabolde (1987: 61—62) suggests that the king was twelve or thirteen years old on his accession, based on the length of the reign of Thutmose I, the biography of Ineni (for which see the subsequent discussion) and the Nubian campaign stela of Thutmose Us first regnal year, which makes clear that the king did not accompany his army into the field. Chappaz (1993: 88—91) is essentially in agreement but points out that Thutmose Us mother, Mutnofret, though only a secondary wife, may have been married to Thutmose I prior to his marriage with Ahmose and could therefore have borne Thutmose II before his fathers accession. For the view that Thutmose I did not marry Ahmose before his accession, see Schmitz (1978) 216—20; Robins (1990) 216; and Bierbrier (1995) 15—19. As a possible reflection on the youth of Thutmose II, the great king s wife Ahmose is a prominent presence on royal monuments of his reign, though she was not the kings mother; see her portrayal on Berlin stela 15699 in Wildung (1974) 255—68. The authenticity of the stela, however, has recently been called into question by Krauss and Goedicke (1998: 203—20), a reference brought to the author s notice by Luc Gabolde. The author would like to thank Dr. Gabolde profusely for a most attentive reading of a final draft of this chapter and for his numerous thoughtful suggestions and comments, not all of which could be incorporated here. 8. The question of the age of Hatshepsut turns largely on her mothers titles, for queen Ahmose is known only as sn.t-nsw.t, hm.t-nsw.t (yor.t)} and mw.t-nsw.t, the last title acquired only after Hatshepsuts own accession. If Ahmose had been the sister or daughter of Amenhotep
78
^
THUTMOSE
III
I—providing a dynastic link to the first two kings of the Eighteenth Dynasty—she should also have carried the title s3.t~nsw.t} but this seems not to have been the case; see Robins (1990) 216. If Ahmose derived the sn.t~nsw.t title by marrying her brother, Thutmose I, only after his accession, mimicking the contemporary royal custom of brother-sister unions, Bierbrier (1995: 15—16) points out that Hatshepsut, as an offspring of this marriage, could have been no older than twelve or thirteen when her father died. A longer reign for Thutmose I would permit a greater age for Hatshepsut, as would a different assessment of queen Ahmose s titles, allowing Hatshepsut to be born prior to her fathers accession, a possibility suggested by Schmitz (1978: 217, n. 6). 9. See the Nubian campaign stela referred to in n. 7 in this chapter; and Urk. IY137—41. For the suggestion that the rebellion was an opportune response to the death of Thutmose I, see Morkot (1987) 32. 10. Gabolde (1993) 1—82. For the posthumous placement of the obelisks of Thutmose II in the center of the court, see idem (1982—85) 143—58. 11. Urk. IV53—62. F ° r th e biographical text as it is preserved now, see Dziobek (1992) 44—54, pis. 34c and 42. For the archaic use of the phrase "royal repast" and its ritual implications, see Dorman (1994) 463—66. 12. Recent proposals for the length of the reign of Thutmose II suggest either three years, based primarily on contemporary evidence, or thirteen years, by incorporating other historical traditions such as Manetho, as well as the periodicity of jubilees during the New Kingdom. The arguments rest largely on the projected ages of the kings involved, the age at which they were able to conceive children, and the biographies of their private officials, criteria that may be assessed in different ways. Solely for the purposes of this chapter, a short reign is assumed. For recent treatments, see von Beckerath (1994) in, with the references listed in n. 709; and Chappaz (1993) 90. For the problems regarding the identity of the royal mummy labeled in antiquity as that of Thutmose II, see Wente and Harris (1992) 9—10. 13. If one or both members of the royal couple had just reached sexual maturity at the time of Thutmose Us accession (see nn. 7 and 8 in this chapter), Neferura could not have been much older than two at her father s death, assuming a short reign of three years; her age could be increased by accepting a longer reign for Thutmose II (see n. 12 in this chapter). 14. The probable youth of Thutmose II at his accession and the brevity of his rule—if the short reign is accepted—would together rule out an age for Thutmose III of more than a year or two. The age at death of Thutmose III has been estimated at thirty-five to forty years from the royal mummy identified as his; see Harris and Wente (1980) 210—11. The king, however, is known to have ruled into his fifty-fourth regnal year, and his eldest son, Amenemhat, is mentioned no earlier than year 23 (247), facts that also speak for his accession to the throne at an early age, estimated by Harris and Wente at between two and thirteen years (247; see also Wente and Harris [1992] 11 and passim). Even arguing for a thirteen-year reign for Thutmose II, von Beckerath (1994:112) proposes that Thutmose III was only five or six years old at his accession. 15. Hatshepsuts rise to royal power has been variously imputed to a lust for power, a disregard for her nephews legitimate rights, an inordinately strong character, and the support of a powerful coterie of male partisans. The historiographie basis for this imputation derives from the Thronwirren theories originated by Sethe in 1896 (and defended one last time in Sethe [1932], no. 4). While the methodological rebuttal to Sethe s reconstruction of history was conclusively made by Edgerton (1933) sixty-five years ago, the objective reassessment of Hatshepsut s role during the reign of Thutmose III has lagged far behind. For a consideration of modern historical interpretations of the period, see Dorman (1988) 2—16. 16. Urk. IV58.12—60.11; cf. Dziobek (1992), pi. 34c. The inscription terminates with a se-
The Early Reign of Thutmose III
^
61
ries of Hatshepsuts benefactions to Ineni, and while these are phrased as a series of sâm.n.f forms they are as likely to be placed chronologically prior to the death of Thutmose IL 17. One may well wonder how old Hatshepsut was at this juncture. If Hatshepsut were only twelve or thirteen at her father s death (perhaps barely able to bear children), she would have been only fifteen or sixteen at her husbands demise (assuming a short reign of three years)—hardly capable of the decisive acts of governance implied by Ineni. But a long reign of thirteen years for Thutmose II would add another decade to her age, alleviating this difficulty to some degree; see also the arguments presented at the end of n. 8 in this chapter. 18. Thutmose II (and doubtless his father, had this portion been preserved) is referred to in this biography only by his prenomen. It might be suggested that the lack of a definite mention by Ineni of the new king s name was due neither to intentional disrespect nor to the nascent power of Hatshepsut but to the fact that the text was carved in Inenis tomb before Thutmose III had acquired a prenomen of his own, that is, before his formal coronation. 19. Urk. IV180—91. Located on Pylon V I I at Karnak, the inscription makes reference to the eighth campaign of year 33 as well as the doorways of the hall of Annals, a structure that itself contains records of the campaigns down to year 42. For the suggestion that the use of the verb sr} "to proclaim, ordain, foretell," in this text hints at a "corégence plus ou moins fictive" between Thutmose III and his father, see Cannuyer (1990) 105—9. F ° r a broader interpretation of sr and its uses in this text and on the chapelle rouge, see Dorman (1988) 27—28. 20. For the probable youth of Thutmose III at his accession, see n. 14 in this chapter; and, in particular, Gabolde (1987) 72—73; von Beckerath (1990) 70—71; and Chappaz (1993) 88—91. 21. The first queens of the New Kingdom—Tetisheri, Ahhotep (I), Ahmose-Nefertari, and Ahmose—seem to have been especially prominent during the reigns of their sons or honored after their deaths; see, conveniently, Troy (1986) 140—43. 22. This would be the case if she were born before the accession of her father or if Thutmose II is accorded a long reign of thirteen years; see n. 17 in this chapter. 23. Murnane (1977a: 33) states that "from the beginning, then, Hatshepsut ruled Egypt in all but name."The contrast in roles is even expressed syntactically in Inenis biography: the stative form is used for Thutmose III, while the progressive hr + infinitive is employed for Hatshepsut. 24. Firth and Quibell (1935) 80 (D). 25. P M 7:145—50. See Caminos (1998). I am most grateful to Mr. T.G.H. James for his kindness in allowing me to peruse portions of the work when it was still in manuscript form. 26. Although the name has virtually disappeared, a bit of the crest on the nh bird of "Nehy" was confirmed by both Caminos and Säve-Söderbergh (Caminos [1998] 44, n. 2; cf. pl. 25, col. 2). The suggestion of Gauthier (1921:187—88) that the name of the earlier viceroy Seni in this location should be restored must therefore be rejected. This does, however, raise questions of succession among the viceroys of Kush, since Nehy is otherwise known only after year 23 of Thutmose III and another office holder, Amen-em-nekhu, appears in year 18; for the latter, see Hintze and Reinecke (1989) 1:90, 2: pl. 122. For a recent summary of the viceroys under Thutmose III, see Dziobek (1993) 29—32. 27. Urk. IV193—96; cf. Caminos (1998), pi. 25. 28. Urk. IV194.15. 29. This scene is reproduced in LD 3, pis. 52b and 53, but these early drawings do not indicate the trace lines documented by Caminos. 30. Caminos (1998), pi. 38. 31. These two obscured lines are not recorded in LD 3, pi. 52b; they are located immediately to the left of the scene as recorded by Lepsius.
62 ^
T H U T M O S E III
32. Caminos (1998), pl. 38. 33. Urk. IV201—2, where several words have been omitted; cf. Caminos (1998), pi. 42. In LD 3, pi. 53, a male royal figure is restored in the erased area, but no trace of such a figure was substantiated during Caminos s epigraphic work. 34. Caminos (1998) 44. 35. Another year date that has in the past been claimed for the early reign of Thutmose III appears on one of the blocks of the chapelle rouge, erected by Hatshepsut in year 2, 2 pr.t 29, which would fall just nineteen months after his accession. This document is discussed in the subsequent text. 36. P M II 2 , 17; Christophe (1951) 86—89, pi* x5* F ° r commentary on the stela, see Helck (i960) 23—34; Murnane (1977a) 35—36; Meyer (1982a) 150—56; Dorman (1988) 29—31; and von Beckerath (1990) 72—73. 37. For year 4, see Christophe (1951) 87; and Helck (i960) 24.Tefnin (1973: 236) reads the regnal year as 12; Brovarksi (1976: 67, n. 12) suggests a reading of year 3. 38. The import of this phrase is that the king did not hesitate for a moment in granting the wish. The following speech is a literal rendition of the petition, placed in the mouth of Senenmut. 39. Helck (1983c) 122. 40. Ibid., 123. 41. The recutting was noted by Christophe (1951: 86), but it was ascribed incorrectly to the Kushite period. 42. For this and the following quotes, see Helck (1983c) 125—26. 43. Perhaps because of its obscure location, the prenomen of Hatshepsut on the side of the stela was overlooked during the general erasure of her name after her death, whether or not the prenomina on the face of the stela were altered. 44. Dorman (1991) 161. 45. See Helck (1958) 362; and Meyer (1982a) 154 and 277. For the possibility that the title predates Hatshepsuts acquisition of royal titles, see Dorman (1988) 119—20. 46. This is true regardless of the accepted reading of the regnal year date. Those who understand the year date as 4, of course, suppose that Hatshepsut was already king by this time; see Meyer (1982a) 150ff; and Vandersleyen (1995a) 274. Wysocki s suggestion (1986: 213—28) that Thutmose II was the founder of Dsr-dsr. %v must be treated as tentative until more definitive evidence is found. 47. This is not to say that the stela was reinscribed at a later date, with Hatshepsuts donation tacked on as an afterthought—there is no reason to suppose that the entire composition of the stela, as it now stands, was determined from the first. The use of the edges of stelae to continue long texts is uncommon but not unattested; for examples, see Murnane (1977a) 35, n. 12. 48. On this and other considerations, see ibid., 35—36. The gateway next to which the stela still lies is ascribed in P M II 2 , 16, to Thutmose I and was then reused by Amenhotep II, but the structure seems to have been built by Hatshepsut during her kingship, with her name replaced by that of her father after her death; see Van Sielen (1984b) 83. 49. Another fascinating fact is the mention of several aurouras of land given to Senenmut as a reward when Thutmose III was an hipw, a term generally understood to refer to a young person who has not yet reached maturity. Von Beckerath (1990: 72) asserts that "so liegt bei dem Wort jnpw 'königliches (göttliches) Kind* der Nachdruck mehr auf 'königlich' als auf 'Kind'" and that at the time of the grant Thutmose was on the throne but officially still a minor. For the suggestion that the term has no intrinsic age implication at all but refers,
The Early Reign of Thutmose III
^
63
retrospectively, to royal heirs before they acceded to the throne, see Vandersleyen (1992) 563—66. Such an interpretation does not easily square with the youthful age estimates for Thutmose III, for which see n. 14 in this chapter. In the case of the Senenmut donation stela, one wonders whether Thutmose III, during his father s lifetime, would have had the power to reward officials with land grants or could even have been old enough to do so. 50. Helck (1955b) in—15. 51. Dziobek (1994) 73—77, pis. 17—19, 42—43, 81—82. 52. Dorman (1988) 33—34. 53. A perverse uncertainty surrounds the installation accounts of Useramun, like so much else from these early years. Surely in year 5 Hatshepsut would in any case have been very much involved in the decision regarding a new vizier, whether in her role as queen regent or as newly crowned king. Her name may have been intentionally omitted in the tomb inscription (or replaced by that of Thutmose III) simply because she was deceased. But if Useramuns appointment was proclaimed after Hatshepsut took on royal titles and in the name of both coregents why should so much fulsome praise be heaped, in both the monumental and literary versions, on the unique role of Thutmose III long after the fact? Or was Useramuns installation worthy of such remarkable notice precisely because the appointment had been made in Thutmose s sole name, so that the viziers many years of excellent service would have been seen, after Hatshepsuts death, as validating the young ruler s prescient choice? Such reasoning would favor a kingship for Hatshepsut beginning after year 5. Vandersleyen, who leans toward an early kingship for Hatshepsut beginning around year 3 (1995a: 275), asserts that "le fait qu en Tan 5 Touthmosis III ait présidé à l'intronisation du vizir Amenouser ne prouve rien puisque, pendant toute la coregence, Touthmosis III agira souvent tout à fait indépendamment de la reine" (274). In fact, very little is known about Thutmose Ills ability or freedom to make unilateral decisions during the coregency, particularly during the earliest years, when he was likely very young. 54. Gardiner, Peet, and Í erny (1952—55), nos. 175 and 176, pis. 56 and 57. For these stelae, see the discussions in Murnane (1977a) 36; and Dorman (1988) 32. 55. Gardiner, Peet, and Cerny (1952—55), no. 180, pi. 61. The regnal year is given in terms of Thutmose III, but is mentioned on one side. 56. Uniquely, on one stela Neferura appears with Senenmut in the absence of any king (see the subsequent discussion of dated documents of the coregency and for another stela in which Hatshepsut appears alone dressed in the costume of gods wife). 57. Dreyer (1984) 489—99; Dorman (1988) 42—43; Vandersleyen (1995a) 272. The statue is Aswan Museum no. 1086. For a dating of this statue to king Ahmose based on stylistic criteria, see Lindblad (1988) 197—201. 58. This follows the suggestion of Dreyer (1984: 491—92). 59. Ibid., 492. Although it is generally assumed that Thutmose II was not posthumously honored by Hatshepsut after her assumption of the throne, Gabolde has pointed out to the author that he is in fact memorialized by king Hatshepsut at least once in the Deir el-Bahari sanctuary (Naville [1906], pi. 144), as well as in his own memorial temple, the walls of which are adorned with the familiar Hatshepsut rebus frieze; see Laboury (1998a) 495, n. 1361. For the traditional observation of the jubilee during the New Kingdom, see Hornung and Staehelin (1974) 30—40, 51—65; and Wente and Van Sielen (1976) 219—23. 60. The statue is British Museum 1513; for the text, see British Museum (1914) 9, pL 29; and Dorman (1988) 116—18, 189. Of Senenmuts numerous monuments, not a single one can be dated with any certainty to the reign of Thutmose II (see Meyer [1982a: 275]), and the strong presumption is that his earliest statues belong to the regency period during the first years of Thutmose III.
64 ^
T H U T M O S E III
61. British Museum (1914), pL 29. 62. Ibid. For the orthography of the third-person feminine pronouns in this text, see Meyer (1982a) 113, n. 1. 63. Habachi (1957) 92—96; Meyer (1982a) 129—31; Dorman (1988) 115—16,198—99 (where it is referred to inaccurately as the "Sehel graffito"). 64. This thesis has been persuasively proposed by Gabolde (1987: 143—58), especially in n. 9 on 149. The time lapse involved in their erection was long enough that Hatshepsut must have assumed the throne before they were inscribed. The two granite shafts were dedicated by her to her father, and her cartouches were later surcharged by Thutmose III during her proscription. The obelisks were taken down by Amenhotep III during the demolition of the festival court, and several fragments were reused in the granite bark shrine of Phillip Arrhidaeus. 65. Caminos and James (1963) 1—2. 66. Ibid., pl. 40. 67. Presumably [itny-rpr n~] hm.t~ntr} "[steward o f ] the gods wife"; whether or not Hatshepsut had ceased using the title, Senenmut was still in charge of the administration of the estate of the religious office. It is generally accepted that Hatshepsut transferred the title hm.t-ntr to her daughter, Neferura, at her accession. See Meyer (1982a) 116, with n. 7; and idem (1982b), cols. 382—83. 68. This was already noted by Caminos and James (1963: 56; cf. pl. 44). 69. Although only one foot is preserved in each scene, it is obvious from the angle of the shins and the space available in each scene that Hatshepsut was shown in a striding stance; compare in particular the close-set feet of Nekhbet. For this stance, see my subsequent discussion of the temple of Buhen. 70. This was noted by Gabolde (1990: col. 640); and Vandersleyen (1995a: 290, n. 3). 71. Lansing and Hayes (1937) sec. 2, 3—39. 72. Hayes (1942) 21, no. 62, pi. 13; idem (1957) 78—81. 73. For earlier accession dates, see Meyer (1982a) 14—27, in favor of year 2; and Vandersleyen (1995a) 275: "L'apparition d'Hatshepsout en roi aurait eu lieu à une date indéterminée, après Tan 2 de Semna et avant Tan 7, probablement dés Tan 3." 74. Urk. IV34.5—17. 75. This view is espoused by Gabolde (1987: 70). It is by no means certain, however, that the epithet m3^hrw is conclusively an indication of deceased status; see also n. 78 in this chapter. 76. For discussions on the estimated age of Ahmose-Pennekhbet at the accession of Thutmose III, see ibid.; and von Beckerath (1990) 68. 77. The peculiar combination of queens titles and the royal prenomen Mj c .i-%-r c in the text of Ahmose-Pennekhbet is unique. 78. It is difficult to believe that had Ahmose-Pennekhbet recorded his biography after the death of Hatshepsut and Neferura he would have gone to such pains to re-create titles that had pertinence for the two royal women only during a remote crux in their lifetimes. The "repetition of favors" phrase is strikingly reminiscent of the phrases used by Ineni to describe the kindnesses, couched in general terms, shown him by the gods wife Hatshepsut while she was still very much alive. 79. Gardiner, Peet, and Í erny (1952—55), pi. 56, no. 177. See also Dorman (1988) 32, n. 76; and Gabolde and Rondot (1996) 214, n. 90. 80. The signs of Hatshepsuts titulary are more cramped than the other texts of the stela, and it is uncertain what appeared above the nsw.t-bity title, which should have preceded the prenomen. While such orthographic oddities may suggest recutting or a later addition of ti-
The Early Reign of Thutmose III
^
65
ties, it is also possible that the figures on this provincial stela received priority in carving, while the inscriptions were added around them as space was available. 81. Chevrier (1934) 172, pi. 4. 82. Although the scene to the left is no longer extant, the probability of an identical pendant scene of Hatshepsut is strong; the end of a shoulder and upper tip of a rear plume are visible at the edge of the break. To this phase of female kingship belongs the Metropolitan Museum of Art statue 30.3.3 (Tefnin 1979, 2—6, pi. Ia), which depicts Hatshepsut as a woman wearing a khat headdress and proclaims her full kingly titulary. 83. Gabolde and Rondot (1996). 84. Ibid., 182. The evidence consists of a crudely recarved fan behind Hatshepsut and the adjustment of the plural strokes in the word cnh.w. The fragmentary nature of the limestone chapel and the thoroughness of the later Tuthmoside erasures make it difficult to ascertain whether the same revision was made to other scenes as well, but presumably all the female figures on the monument would have been altered to male at the same time. 85. See n. 93 in this chapter. Senenmuts Gebel el-Silsila cenotaph is one example of such a transformation, for which see n. 70 in this chapter. 86. Ibid., 206-9. 87. Caminos (1974) 77, with n. 1 and pi. 65. 88. Ibid., 85, 98—99, pis. 82 and 85; see also the important comments of Karkowski (1978: 76-81). 89. See Caminos (1974), pi. 76. The dedication by Hatshepsut of the granite statue of Thutmose II at Aswan may conceivably be as late as the date of the decoration of Buhen; see n. 57 in this chapter. 90. Chappaz (1993) 109—10, remarking on the Speos Artemidos inscription, which he suggests may refer not to the Hyksos kings, already some time distant, but perhaps to more recent events following on the death of Thutmose II, commented on only elliptically. 91. This is eloquently stated by Gabolde and Rondot (1996) 215: "La dernière phase n est qu'un ultime ajustement pour que le pharaon ait dans ses représentations l'apparence masculine depuis toujours liée à cette charge. Il se confirme ainsi, par le fait même que les pronoms sont restés féminins, que c'est la fonction royale d'Hatchepsout qui est figurée sur les reliefs (et dans la statuaire) et qu'il n'y a jamais eu la moindre intention de masquer le fait que le roi d'Egypte était une femme." By contrast, kingly crowns combined with female costume had proved sufficient for Nefrusobek of the Twelfth Dynasty, who had previously assumed pharaonic titles; see, for example, Habachi (1954) 459—60, pis, 7B and 8. The representational and textual evidence is slight for the ephemeral Nitiqret of the Sixth Dynasty; see Zivie (1982), cols. 513—14. 92. A limestone structure of Thutmose II, preserved in fragments at Karnak, depicts queen Hatshepsut in a number of scenes, even in direct contact with gods. See n. 123 in this chapter. 93. Especially noteworthy is the consistently feminine form of her five-fold kingly titulary; see Robins 1999. 94. Gabolde and Rondot (1996: 214, n. 89) suggest that at Buhen "Hatchepsout fit, à l'occasion, modifier ses représentations féminines en images masculines," but it is more likely that these changes were not initiated during her lifetime but only as part of her later proscription by Thutmose III. For example, Hatshepsuts figure in the bark sanctuary was erased, leaving nothing in its place but a recarved scepter in the hand of the deity (Caminos [1974], pi. 65, scene 74; for a similar erasure, see pi. 68, scene 77). In the inner sanctuary, another feminine figure of Hatshepsut was recarved as male, but the accompanying text was changed in toto
66 ^
T H U T M O S E III
(pl. 69, scene 79). The same may be deduced for a third scene, where the king s kilt intrudes into the column of inscription (pi. 77, scene 88; cf. Karkowski [1978] 79, fig. 10; and Caminos [1974], pi. 79, by inference). Such changes are more in keeping with the revisions made during Hatshepsuts proscription, incorporating not just the transformation of a female figure into a masculine one but the readjustment of the entire offering program in certain rooms, doubtless due to the methodical deletion of one of the royal participants. Gabolde and Rondot also refer to a number of blocks in storage at Karnak that provide evidence of female forms changed to masculine ones: the question remains whether the alterations were made by Hatshepsut after she assumed male form (as in her Karnak chapel) or by Thutmose III during his more extensive revision of temple scenes in the final decade of his reign (as at Buhen). 95. Vandersleyen (1995a: 272) has suggested that "elle avait dès le temps de son père la conviction que le pouvoir lui revenait de droit," but there is no evidence that she or her father made contingencies or provisions of this sort. The view that Hatshepsut "pouvait se considérer comme tel (roi) dès le moment oùTouthmosis I e r lui avait accordé cette dignité" (291) rests solely on an uncritical acceptance of Hatshepsuts own claims in the "Légende de la Jeunesse" and a literal interpretation of an event that is both retrospective and mythologized. As von Beckerath (1994: 43) notes, "daß die angebliche Krönung der Hatshepsut zur Mitregentin ihres Vaters Thutmose I. eine Fiktion war, ist heute allgemein anerkannt. Es handlelt es sich teilweise um die Abschrift des Thronbesteigungstextes eines Königs der X I I Dynastie (Krönung am Neujahrs tag)." 96. There has been a welcome reassessment of the nature of Hatshepsuts actions and motives in assuming royal titles. For example, see Teeter (1990) 4—13, 56—57; Vandersleyen (1995a) 276—77; and Chappaz (1993) 88 and 108—10. 97. Chappaz (1993) 95—96. 98. For a convenient list of all dated documents of the first twenty-two years of Thutmose I l l s reign, see ibid., 94—95. 99. These dates are contemporary with their recording; a number of others are retrospective (e.g., the year 15 renewal by Thutmose III of offerings for Amun, mentioned in his coronation inscription). 100. For possible precedent for the practice of dating to the junior coregent, see the Middle Kingdom evidence in Simpson (1956) 214—19; and the remarks of Wegner (1996) 266—70, 274—77. The application to the Hatshepsut—Thutmose III coregency is uncertain. Although Hatshepsut was the older of the pair and clearly more dominant during her lifetime, her kingship was declared later than Thutmose Ills. 101. See Naville (1898), pi. 86; and Urk. IV349-54. 102. Urk. IV364—69. 103. PM 2 :93, chapel 5; Urk. IV376; Nims (1966) 97; Dorman (1988) 47. 104. Gardiner, Peet, and Íerny (1952—55) no. 179, pi. 58. 105. See, for example, Redford (1967) 55—56; Murnane (1977a) 37—38; and Meyer (1982b), col. 382. 106. Murnane (1977a) 34. Despite indications that Hatshepsut did not entirely ignore the memory of the deceased Thutmose II (see n. 59 in this chapter), the deliberate and more widespread emphasis she placed on her direct descent from Thutmose I demonstrates that Hatshepsut was not claiming rightful succession from her husband but from her father— despite the overriding need to number regnal years from the demise of the former. 107. Wente and Van Sielen (1976) 220—21. Their assignment of a long reign of fourteen years for Thutmose II would thus lend credence to Hatshepsuts claim to a jubilee beginning in the sixteenth year of the reign of Thutmose III.
The Early Reign of Thutmose III
^
67
108. The "choice" of a dating system was not one that Hatshepsut was free to make, and there is no indication that she ever varied from the system already in existence under Thutmose III. The coregency has not yielded a single double-dated inscription—a text that contains the year date of one coregent corresponding to a different regnal year for the second partner—to prove that Hatshepsut s royal authority was calculated in a manner different than that of Thutmose III. Nor is such a date to be expected. Unlike the dating system of the Old and Middle Kingdoms, in which the regnal years of the king changed invariably on civil New Years Day, 1 3h.t i (regardless of whether there was one ruler or two coregents on the throne), regnal years of the New Kingdom were computed from the exact accession day of the king and changed only on the anniversary of that accession. Unless a junior coregent acceded to the throne on the anniversary of the senior partner, there could be no uniformity in the change of regnal years, and concordant double dating would be impossible. In any case the known accession days of New Kingdom pharaohs are all different; for a convenient list, see von Beckerath (1994) 201. 109. Urk. IV216—34; Naville (1896), pis. 46—55. no. Urk. IV242—65. in. For those between Pylons I V and V see ibid., 357—71. For those erected in the festival court of Thutmose II, see Gabolde (1982—85) 143—48 (for the pair at eastern Karnak, see the references in 149, n. 6). 112. Manuelian and Loeben (1993) 121—55. On the importance of such reburial as an integral act of legitimation, see Gabolde (1989) 176—77; and M. Gabolde (1998) 267—70 and 275-76. 113. She appears this way on Berlin stela 3/71, for which see Wildung (1974) 257—59. Here Ahmose presents offerings to Hathor, "who resides in Bhd.tand behind her king r is embraced by Horus of Bhd.t, Wildung has also shown that on Berlin stela 15699 (see n. 7 in this chapter) Ahmose s titles were updated—from sn.t-nsw.t to mw.t-nsw.t—to reflect her status as a kings mother, even while the figure of Hatshepsut was allowed to remain, now anachronistically, a mere queen. 114. In view of the circumstances of her cautious accrual of royal status, it is difficult to credit the possibility that Hatshepsut, even prior to her assuming queenly titles under Thutmose II, would have been designated by Thutmose I as his sole heir during his lifetime, as Murnane (1977a: 242) seems to suggest: "[T]he nature of Hatshepsuts claim is obscure, for her 'enthronement* by Thutmose I is probably fictional and the text does not rule out that her 'Great Names' were proclaimed in anticipation of her successful takeover two decades later." Similarly, Vandersleyen (1995a: 250) writes that "ce n est pas trop rêver que d'admettre comme possible que, dans sa fragile progéniture, Thoutmosis I e r ait trouvé en Hatshepsout le seul rejeton assez solide et assez âgé pour le sortir, lui le pharaon, dans son royal isolement." This would seem to endow Thutmose I with the supernatural foresight to have envisioned the early death of his successor as well as the extreme youth of the next eligible male heir—and to have taken steps to mitigate those eventualities. 115. Urk. IV262.7—8. The format of the date is consciously archaizing, imitating the wording of annals dating back to the Old Kingdom. It would have been possible, of course, to "stage" a coronation ceremony any time after Hatshepsut assumed a full titulary, even on New Year s Day, without tampering with the current regnal dating system. 116. This was already noted by Redford (1967: 55). 117. Lacau and Chevrier (1977—79) 96, fig. 15, and 133—35, pis. 1—6. 118. Schott (1955) 212—13. His thesis has been recently reiterated by Cannuyer (1990: 109-15).
68
^
THUTMOSE
III
119. For discussions of this date, see the references in Dorman (1988) 22—28. Contra Vandersleyen (1995a) 250—51, the date is very probably to be ascribed to Thutmose II rather than his father, since the regnal date of year 2 would place it extremely early in the reign of Thutmose I, which brings into question once again the age of princess Hatshepsut (see n. 8 in this chapter). See also the remarks of Redford (1986b: 169, with n. 32), who points out that Thutmose I was in Nubia in 2 pr.t of his reign. Luc Gabolde has indicated to the author that the same suggestion is made in the Berkeley Ph.D. dissertation of Fattah M . Sabbahy (1986: 247, n. 46). 120. Barta (1980) 33—49. For the possibility of a lag between the accession and coronation of Thutmose III, see n. 18 of this chapter. 121. Gardiner (1953a) 13—31. There is no direct evidence that Hatshepsut arranged a coronation for herself, on N e w Year s Day or any other, but at least one of Senenmut s statues bears titles that suggest he assumed certain ritual roles associated with either a coronation or a jubilee; see Berlandini-Grenier (1976) in—32; and Dorman (1988) 129—33. 122. For the reading of the rebus as the prenomen of Hatshepsut, see Drioton (1938) 231-46. 123. Ricke (1954) 21, pl. 9e. 124. For example, such usurpation is found on the structure containing the limestone door lintel mentioned earlier. For other fragments from this monument, which are treated by Gabolde in his dissertation, see Vandersleyen (1995a) 265, n. 3. 125. Urk. IV167.1—9. By internal evidence this inscription dates to a time after year 42, when the proscription of Hatshepsut was probably under way and the chapelle rouge had already been dismantled. 126. Barguet (1962) 141—53. These rooms are now under study by the Centre franco-égyptien d'étude des temples de Karnak. 127. T h e chapelle rouge has been reconstructed at the Musée en plein air at Karnak. For its decoration, see Lacau and Chevrier (1977—79); for one suggestion regarding its original location and revised dimensions, see Carlotti (1995) 141—66. 128. Barguet (1962) 258—64. 129. T h e shrines are depicted in the third register on the southern exterior wall of the chapelle rouge; see Lacau and Chevrier (1977—79) 154—69. For reused elements of one such shrine at Luxor, see Habachi (1965) 93—97; and Bell (1997) 161—62, 159, fig. 58. 130. For the respective representations of Hatshepsut and Thutmose III in the inner chapels, see Hölscher (1939) 10—19, 46—50. 131. Hatshepsuts tomb ( K V 20) remains the earliest positively identified royal tomb in the valley; see the references in n. 4 in this chapter. For the latest commentary on the attribution of K V 20, see Vandersleyen (1995b) 22—24. 132. Gardiner, Peet, and Í e r n y (1952—55), no. 181, pi. 57. 133. Waddell (1948) 100—101. Variations on the length of the reign of Amessis (Amensis, Amersis) include twenty-two years (Africanus) and twenty-one years, one month (Theophilus). 134. M o n d and Myers (1940) 182—84, pi. 103; Urk. IV1243—47. 135. See, for example, Redford (1986b) 246—47. 136. Vandersleyen (1995a) 277—78. 137. For the date of Hatshepsut s proscription, beginning no earlier than year 42, see Dorman (1988) 46—65; and Van Sielen (1989) 85—86.
THREE
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III B E T S Y M. B R Y A N
gyptian bureaucracy was labyrinthine, and the center of the maze was the institution of kingship. The king theoretically owned the entirety of the country, and the bureaucracy grew up as a means of collecting and redistributing the produce of Egypt on behalf of the ruler. The vizier, for example, acted in loco regis with regard to judicial, administrative, and economic matters, just as the high priests of temple cults did with regard to ritual requirements. It is often difficult, if not impossible, to distinguish between the holdings of the king and those of the state, and it may be that we should not insist on doing so too enthusiastically. Attempts to map an orderly division of state functions, those of the king personally, and those of the temples lead frequently to blind alleys. Following Martin-Pardey, in the framework given in this chapter the operations of the royal household (per nesu) will be understood as those of the state, but the reader should understand that this structure was fluid.1 It was not uncommon for the functions associated with specific titles to appear to move from one office to another, occasionally even within a single reign. The antiquity of the bureaucracy, however, and its ideological connection to the mission of the kingship—the maintenance of Maat, or divine order—helped to maintain the primary activities of the state, despite a frequent turnover in personnel.
E
There are several important themes that one may identify in examining Thutmose I l l s administration. First, we are fortunate to have the lengthy texts relating to the Installation and Duties of the Vizier from two tombs of the period—TT 131 of Useramun and T T 100 of Rekhmire—with two additional texts from T T 131 alone, representing an instruction of Aamethu for his son Useramun, as well as a text of Useramuns appointment, known also
88
^
THUTMOSE
III
from a papyrus version. These inscriptions provide a framework for at least some of the country s governance and underline the powerful role of the vizier at this period. Nonetheless, these texts largely concern the vizierate and not the organization of other bureaus. Other sources must complete the picture. Second, as Dziobek has pointed out, the ruler probably needed the support of the nobility to effect the transition from the regency of Thutmose III to the coregency of Hatshepsut and Thutmose III. 2 The changeover to Thutmose s sole rule could only have necessitated a similar show of solidarity from court elites. A number of major officials, such as Minnakht, overseer of the granaries of Upper and Lower Egypt; Sennefri, overseer of the seal; Aamethu and Useramun, both viziers; as well as Nehesy, Ty, Senemiah, Pahery, Ahmose-Pennekhbet, Hapuseneb, Puyemre, and Wadjetrenput, served under Hatshepsut and suffered no damage to their memories in the sole reign of Thutmose III. 3 On the contrary, powerful men such as Useramun and Minnakht bolstered their own positions as they offered their devotion to Thutmose III. Third, the more stable offices of vizier, overseer of the seal, overseer of the granaries, and high priest of Amun were supplemented and to some extent surrounded by a new class of officials who were given positions in the royal house. These were the veterans of Thutmose I l l s many military campaigns, and the officeholders ranged from a brave warrior who was made royal barber upon his return to Egypt to the great overseer of works for all the temples of Egypt, who had served with the king in Syria. These men earned their place in the administration through their personal value to the king—as friends and loyal warriors.The impact of this group of officials on the administration generally will be examined in this chapter. The structure to be followed first examines the major offices of the state, including those of the vizier, the overseer of the seal, and the overseer of the granaries. Overseers of the gold and silver houses, royal heralds, and royal messengers represent men who connected the kings domain to that of the state. They are treated here as part of the bureaucracy. The chief royal stewards, royal butler, and other palace functionaries in various positions will be treated next, followed by members of the priesthoods and large temple institutions and finally the military, including the king s son of Nubia.
F I R S T T I E R O F F I C E S OF T H E
STATE
T h e Vizierate The middle of the Eighteenth Dynasty was a period of great power for viziers, known most familiarly to us as the highest judicial authorities of the
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III ^
71
land.The position of chief judge was, however, only one of the viziers many duties, as we learn from the texts and scenes left to us in the two great viziers' tombs—those of Useramun ( T T 61 and 131) and Rekhmire ( T T 100). At this time there were two viziers, one for the north and one for the south. 4 The southern vizier, about whose role we are well informed, controlled the area between Assiut and Aswan, 5 while the northern vizier administered the area to the north. The vizier served as the king s representative in his house, and as such the functioning of all the departments of the royal household, the per nesu, was under his direct charge. Every official in the country could be subject to the judgment of the vizier, while he was kept informed of matters at local levels throughout his area of control. From the Duties of the Vizier we learn numerous functions of the vizier—although the interpretation of these roles remains an area of debate.6 For example, the "Duties" stated that "as for everything which enters or departs the grounds of the royal residence, it is the vizier s messenger who allows entering and departing." From the larger context we learn that the vizier was kept informed of deliveries and withdrawals at the royal house, but the exact role of the messenger remains obscure.7 The majority of the vizier s functions were judicial in some way or other. All the officials of the per nesu were subject to justice by the vizier, and bureau officials were also brought before him. Disputes regarding the high offices of mayor and estate ruler came before him, while most legal matters outside the royal house were only reported to him. Generally civil petitions (e.g., contractual disputes), were submitted to local councils, but petitions concerning land automatically found their way to the vizier. Likewise he was responsible for sealing every imyt~per; or transfer deed, himself. 8 With regard to the functioning of the land generally, the vizier appointed a magistracy that reported to him three times a year with written documents. Combined with the position of judge was the vizier s supervision of the police. He appointed the chief of police for the per nesu, while the police reported to him regularly on the security of the country. The vizier also interacted with the Great Prison, such that archives of hearings by the vizier were registered there in the event of a second offense by a convicted official. The vizier acted as a chief executive officer for the royal house, guaranteeing its secure functioning every day. In a highly ritualized ceremony, the vizier and the overseer of the seal first assured each other that the palace was in order and that all sealed facilities opened and closed on time. The vizier then informed the king of the sound condition of the country and proceeded to authorize the opening of the royal households gates so that goods might be brought in or supplies might be distributed for use elsewhere. The entrance area to the kings house (whether figurative or literal remains a ques-
72
^
THUTMOSE
III
tion for us) 9 was called the "aryt, a reference to a gateway. This gate region functioned as a liminal area between the king s domain and the rest of Egypt. Here the vizier was in charge, as royal deputy. He hired and fired all the personnel of the yaryt, and he could summon mayors and local rulers there to answer inquiries. Anything offered at the yaryt was reported to him as well, and this may refer to the bringing of revenue to the royal household. The functions of the per nesu that reached outside the residence were also largely under his control. He sent messengers to mayors, sent officials on circuits, and dispatched all the royal expeditions (and works projects).The reason for this is that the vizier was truly the kings agent and, as the Duties of the Vizier states: "It is he who hears every decree [of the king]." 1 0 The royal commands were carried out through the vizier, such that he could order wood to be cut and canals to be dug and he sent local rulers to take charge of cultivation and later harvest taxation. While the vizier directly collected the revenues of the ges-per workshops (according to the herald Duawynehhe, this institution processed the grain assigned as the yearly tax for the temple of Amun by Hatshepsut), 11 the general deliveries brought back from the mayors and other local leaders were reported to him. It might be noted that in the tomb scenes of Useramun and Rekhmire the taxes of Upper Egypt are paid at the vizier s office with the official looking on. When the king traveled outside the residence, the vizier was responsible for his military escort and the security of the palace in the rulers absence. Turning now first to the southern viziers known from this era, we primarily have the witness of four tombs, those of Aamethu (83), Useramun (61 and 131), and Rekhmire (100). Although Aamethu served during the first few years of the regency, less is known of his tenure than of those of his successors. 12 Useramun received the viziership, according to one version of the "Appointment of the Vizier" text in year 5. 1 3 He replaced his father Aamethu at that time, succeeding from the office of scribe of the divine seal for the temple of Amun. Useramun successfully held the viziership well into the sole rule of Thutmose III, and although it is certain that he was still in office in year 28 there is indirect evidence that he may still have functioned in year 33, although Rekhmire is known to have been in office in year 34. 1 4 There is much to indicate that Useramun was a more powerful vizier than even his father had been—the building of two tombs with complementary decoration being one such hint. One immediately thinks in this regard of Senenmut, whose lower tomb was placed within the grounds of the queens own temple of millions of years and whose unfinished decoration included an astronomical ceiling akin to those otherwise known only from royal monuments. The upper tomb of that great steward bore elaborate painted scenes showing Senenmuts importance to the ruler. Useramun used tomb 131, with its
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III ^
73
pyramid superstructure, to provide a great transverse hall in which the formalities of his office and the related texts were displayed. There was no shaft. Tomb 61, on the other hand, had a long narrow corridor, where the funerary scenes were depicted, and the burial shaft descended from the court of this tomb. That burial shaft contained the only nonroyal example known in the New Kingdom of the Amduat—the funerary book composed about this time that narrates the sun god s journey through the twelve hours of the night in the underworld. Useramun placed himself, like the king, as part of the gods boat crew and partook of many divine associations as a result. In the new composition created for him, "The Teaching of Aamethu," Useramun is called "he who causes the commoner to breathe," 15 an epithet that Dziobek felt might have been somewhat expansive. Since much of the term of office for Useramun was during Hatshepsut s reign, her close compatriots, such as Senenmut and Hapuseneb, tend to overshadow our view of Useramuns role during his first years. However, by the time his tombs were built, the vizier showed himself actively receiving the imposts of all of Upper Egypt. He also appears as recipient of the revenues of the northern lands as far as the Aegean, and scenes show Minoans and Syrians in registers with their goods. Likewise the produce of the vineyards of the delta and the oases are brought before Useramun in his official capacity. 16 He also is shown inspecting the Karnak Temple storehouses and treasuries and is said to be responsible for sealing up all the precious commodities of every land. 1 7 His specific enterprises are better preserved to us from the tombs of his administrators—a demonstration in itself of his power. The scribe of the vizier Amenemhet of T T 82 detailed the works in Thebes that Useramun had accomplished up to year 28. Just as we know from the Duties of the Vizier, Amenemhet states that "the vizier Useramun made a large withdrawal from the royal house (per nesu), consisting of silver and lapis lazuli, turquoise, and every precious stone, silver and bronze vessels,... ebony and sesnedjem w o o d . . . . Vizier Useramun made numerous statues for the royal house consisting of silver, bronze, ebony . . . every excellent and hard granite . . " I 8 Amenemhet as the controller of the work continued to describe other statues, a large lake (?) west of Thebes surrounded by trees, and the royal tomb: "This noble made for him a great and very excellent tomb at the mountain (hekhen) of the sacred land, making large the writings of its walls... " I 9 Useramuns responsibility for the royal tomb explains how the distribution of texts from the Litany of Re were split between Thutmose I l l s burial chamber and Useramuns own and is likely related to his claim to the Amduat for himself as well. Useramun also appeared in his father Aamethu s tomb, in his nephew and successor Rekhmire s tomb, and in his active functioning on the stela of Senimose.
74
^
THUTMOSE
III
The majority of his role, however, is conveyed in the four lengthy texts from the tomb, and we should not doubt that his duties were those already described from those texts. It may well be that, as the Speos Artemidos inscription of Hatshepsut suggests for temple restorations, the reorganization of the administration was also not complete until this time. The Duties of the Vizier suggests to us that the land had been apportioned (perhaps following Ahmose s wars of unification) and that the vizierate helped to assure that boundaries and ownership would be respected in this "New Kingdom." The mayors and rulers of estates were solidly bound to the ruler by the viziers direct control over them. N o t only did this deter corruption by regional rulers, but it may also have encouraged a connection between the palace and the provinces. Indeed, it may not be coincidence that local mayors, such as Satepihu of Thinis, Montuherkhepeshef of Qau el Kebir (Antaeopolis), Min of Thinis, and Iamnefer of Nefrusy, were active participants in the royal households of Hatshepsut and Thutmose III. Min and Montuherkhepeshef were also buried in Thebes. Useramuns family consisted of his father, the vizier Aamethu; his mother, Ta-aamethu; his wife, the mistress of the house Tjuiu; and men carrying the title "son," including the scribe of the seal of the god (Useramuns earlier title) Sa-menkhet, the priest and scribe of Amun Merimaat, a priest of Amun in Djeser Djeseru Mery, a simple wab (pure) priest of Amun Amenemhet, and an untitled Userhet. Daughters, or women bearing that title, include two Ahmoses, Amenemweskhet, Amenemheb, Baket (wife of Amenemhet of T T 82), Henut, and Seniseneb. All of these are known from Gebel el-Silsila shrine 17 and most from more than one tomb. 20 The vizier Rekhmire is known to have been in office in year 34 because he is named as being responsible for grain deliveries in the account papyrus Louvre 3226 at that date. Rekhmire was apparently the nephew of Useramun and grandson of Aamethu by a certain wab priest of Amun Neferweben, such that the vizierate remained in the same family for a third generation. 21 Useramun had several sons who might have received the office, but for reasons unknown to us Rekhmire succeeded to the position. It must be said that Neferweben, as a son of Aamethu, is known only from Rekhmire s own tomb. A connection of this man with the vizier Neferweben in the north cannot be established at present, 22 and in his tomb Rekhmire took pains to represent the families of both Aamethu and Useramun as well as that of Neferweben. Rekhmire married the mistress of the house and royal ornament (a court honorific title), Meryt, and his tomb named five sons and four daughters, with six other children shown but not named. All the offspring bore titles associated with the temple of Amun at Karnak.
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III ^
75
The tomb of Rekhmire ( T T ioo) is a veritable treasure trove of representations regarding his office. N o t only does it contain the Duties of the Vizier and the Installation of the Vizier texts, but it preserves scenes showing the vizier supervising the payment of taxes for all of Upper Egypt, as well as the deliveries of goods from the oases and, of course, numerous foreign countries. Careful to preserve the formality of his decoration scheme, which is similar to that of Useramun, Rekhmire nonetheless showed the representatives of recently defeated city states in the Levant among the many visitors to Egypt with their gifts. By the time of Rekhmire s succession to the vizierate, Thutmose III had already had eight major campaigns in Palestine and Syria. The largest part of his Palestine campaigning was complete, while the Syrian expedition against the Mitanni vassals and ruler had begun in earnest and with results. Nonetheless, in his tomb Rekhmire used the archaizing processional scene types seen in Useramuns and Senenmut s tombs, combining the deliveries of Nubia, Punt, Retenu, and Crete, as if they had all arrived by similar means. The omission of Naharin, home to the Mitanni whom Thutmose III met in combat between years 33 and 42, is hardly coincidental, for it occurs in tombs of other contemporaries of the king. Either the tomb was decorated soon after Rekhmires appointment to the office, and the Syrian wars were still going on, or the vizier chose to depict a deliberately archaistic group of foreigners to underscore the universality of his function as recipient of revenues, foreign and domestic. That there is a mention of Amenhotep II in one corridor scene cannot date the tomb, since this was quite possibly a late addition to the completed monument. Although we know of the judicial functions of Rekhmire as Vizier, we rarely find documents that depict the exercise of those functions explicitly. Nor do we have his name on papyri or inscriptions that refer to disputes over sealed documents, as we do for Useramun from the case of Senimose (discussed later). Nonetheless, this must have been the largest part of his job. We do have him included in an account papyrus that lists grain and date deliveries over a number of years, and the cities mentioned as providing these goods are indeed among those named as paying taxes to the office of Rekhmire in his tomb. 23 The grain deliveries are noted as being made in shemu, the harvest season when taxes were paid. This papyrus thus likely does provide us a glimpse at the accounting of the Upper Egyptian imposts. Rekhmire himself was said to have "given from the great granary" large deliveries of grain (a total of 606 khar or 46,540 liters) to the two granary officials. The overseal of the seal is seen doing similarly with grain from Coptos, where he held the position of overseer of priests. What is unclear is
7
6
^
THUTMOSE
III
whether these two high officials were providing their own personal taxes or those deriving from the offices they held. Although Useramun had been promoted from within the Karnak administration, his chief works projects did not concern that temple. Other men, about whom we will hear, were responsible for the many monuments that Hatshepsut and Thutmose III built in Ipet-Sut. Rekhmire, however, did receive the appointment as overseer of all works in the temple of Amun. In an inscription from the tomb, he is said to have "supervised all works which please the god in Karnak in his office of overseer of works." 24 On the walls of his tomb he depicted the numerous projects, large and small, that he undertook there and even showed workers speaking with one another about the tasks ahead of them. Onlookers say to the workers: "May your arms build according to the commands (hw), that we might do what this official praises, embellishing the monuments of his lord in the temple of father Amun, his name being upon it enduring and lasting for future years." The work leader replies: "The overseer of works says to the one who brings him stone: your arms are made strong according to the commands, that we might build Karnak out of stone as works which are eternal." 25 Since we know that Thutmose I l l s efforts did in many ways "build Karnak out of stone," the record of Rekhmire s tomb is all the more important to us. We must see him involved in the carving of the Annals of the king, for example, as well as the construction of Pylon VII, both of which left records of the ruler s numerous northern military expeditions. The role of overseer of works in Karnak was not one automatically associated with the vizier. However, his position as vizier would have given him access to all the royal treasuries and storehouses of the royal house, and this might have facilitated the movement of war plunder from the kings hands to the temple s. We also hear from inscriptions in tomb 100 of his "receiving carob beans and honey from the treasury of the temple in his office of chief of secrets, and sealing every precious thing in [the temple of Amun]," while he is referred to as "vizier" when "receiving the deliveries of the southern oasis and of Lower Egypt," apparently also for the temple. 26 The various titles invoked in connection with particular functions are difficult to assess. It may be suggested tentatively that Rekhmire s position as vizier did not entitle him to open and close the sealed magazines of Karnak but that he did so using the seal of the chief of secrets (hery seshta). For the movement of materials that came from the per nesu he could be responsible as vizier, but for the actual work oversight he required the overseer of works title. This last was still a royal appointment to construct monuments in the king s name and so bore more connection to Rekhmire s role as vizier. While we cannot as-
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III
^
77
sert a clear distinction of functions, there does appear to be a difference between the royal and temple hierarchies. Two viziers of the north are known from the reign of Thutmose III. Neferweben left a statue in the temple of Ptah as well as another that is dated by cartouche to the reign. 27 Two canopic jars of his are also identified. The provenance of the Ptah temple monument is the only evidence that Neferweben served as northern vizier. At present no tomb is known for him, nor is any further information about his length of service. The vizier Ptahmose is known from a statue from the funerary temple of Thutmose III, 2 8 a false door in Leiden, a palette, and a cubit rod. 29 The false door, part of the Anastasi collection, was collected from Saqqara, where the official must have been buried. Although the activities of these two northern viziers are unknown to us, the existence of their monuments, particularly the great false door of Ptahmose, suggests that their burials rivaled those of the southern viziers. The great residence city of Memphis may have been destroyed, but its cemeteries continue to provide us with clues as to the administrative dominance of the north. 30 This may have already been the case in the reign of Thutmose III. We note that in the reign of Hatshepsut the great Punt expedition was directed by the overseer of the seal, Nehesy, 31 whose tomb was found in Saqqara. It is thus possible that Nehesy was carrying out the mission under direct orders from a northern vizier, perhaps even Neferweben. T h e Overseer of the Seal It appears that this office, 3 2 like that of the vizier, was divided between the north and the south in the reign of Thutmose III. Although there are five men known to have held the title during the rules of Hatshepsut and Thutmose III, it is not altogether clear for all of them whether they served in the north or the south. The office itself is somewhat poorly understood as a result of the preserved documentation. The overseer of the seal has traditionally been referred to as the chief treasurer, although another office entitled overseer of the gold and silver houses existed. In fact, at least through the reign of Thutmose I V the overseer of the seal, who, according to the Duties of the Vizier, opened the gold house together with the vizier every day, was very likely the direct superior of the overseer of the gold and silver houses, and he was, as his title implies, responsible for all sealed materials of the state—grain, food, produce, stone, metal, and so on. 3 3 Despite views to the contrary, 34 the overseer of the seal did possess functions that extended beyond the royal household—in parallel with those of the vizier. For example, Overseer of the Seal Sennefri informs us that in that office he was made over-
78
^
THUTMOSE
III
seer of the granaries and received the grain taxes of every year.35 Further, royal expeditions were commanded by the ruler, responsible to the vizier, and directed most frequently by the overseer of the seal. The expeditions often brought back precious commodities used in building royal monuments, most frequently temples. The overseer of the seal Nehesy was ordered to send the army to Punt as a result of an oracle from Amun to Hatshepsut, and it would be difficult to see this duty as one confined to the royal household.36 Likewise, the overseer of the seal might hold judicial functions as we learn from the Mook Papyrus, dated to the reign of Thutmose I V 3 7 In that instance the overseer of the seal Sobekhotep reported before a vizier s court impaneled at the royal court. A soldier argued against the temple of Hathor at Gebelein. The challenge was to revenues due the temple and probably came to the viziers court because it concerned a land dispute (the soldier had claimed that in the reign of Thutmose III a case had disputed taxes due the temple, and he used this as a precedent). The overseer of the seal announced that the taxes due the temple had been unchanged since the time of Ahmose, and this view was upheld by the court. Although Helck argued that Sobekhotep was there on behalf of the temple, outside the purview of his office, this is not addressed by the text. The vizier s duties included the judgment of disputes such as this, and it may have been that members of his administration were consequently responsible for researching the claims brought for consideration. In any case, overseers of the seal certainly had roles outside the immediate oversight of the royal household magazines and treasuries. Within the royal household overseers of the seal were often entrusted with the tutelage of princes, and at least two of the five known had that responsibility. Ahmose, called Pennekhbet, the king s son of Elkab, buried in the reign of Thutmose III, held the title of overseer of the seal apparently into the regency of Hatshepsut.38 His tomb inscriptions focus on military exploits reaching back to the reign of Ahmose and the consequent riches he was given by several rulers. He noted, in addition, that he nursed Hatshepsuts daughter Neferura "when she was a child at the breast."39 Although he cannot be eliminated from the list, Pennekhbet s activity under Thutmose III may have been brief. Whether the office was divided between north and south at this point remains uncertain. Senenmut also held the title of overseer of the seal according to a monument dated to the regency.40 On that statue he was also identified as overseer of the audience chamber and steward for princess Neferura, a post perhaps complementary to that of Ahmose-Pennekhbet. He was also here overseer of the gold and silver houses. As Dorman has pointed out, these are largely palace appointments, and since the title of overseer of the seal only
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III
^
79
recurs in two verses from Senenmut s Book of the Dead texts inTheban tomb 353, his length of service in the office is unknown. It is probable that he was appointed to the position by Thutmose II or Hatshepsut as regent and stepped aside to take up his more important service as steward of Amun. The man Nehesy was overseer of the seal in the reign of Hatshepsut, specifically in year 9, when the Punt expedition took place. Here we see one of the most common roles for the official, that of expedition organizer.41 Nehesy was certainly an overseer of the seal based in the north, for his tomb was found there by Alain Zivie. 42 Nehesy probably oversaw works projects for Hatshepsut, for he left a cenotaph at the Silsila West sandstone quarries, as did many of the officials of the period. 43 Although he may have lived to the end of Hatshepsut s reign, he was perhaps replaced as overseer of the seal before that time. A man called Ty was overseer of the seal during the coregency of Hatshepsut and Thutmose III and continued into the sole rule. He is known from a graffito at Sehel, another from Serabit el-Khadim, and a letter of the overseer of works Ahmose. The graffito at Sehel refers to a Nubian rebellion during Hatshepsuts reign, and Ty reportedly witnessed the expedition.44 There are other inscriptions attesting to Nubian campaigns of the queen, and they are dated between years 12 and 18, the year zo inscription of Tombos being perhaps the latest.45 The Sehel graffito is thus likely to have come from the second decade of the reign rather than earlier. The letter preserved on a papyrus in the Louvre is written by Ahmose to the overseer of the seal Ty during the reign of Hatshepsut.46 Its content concerns a female servant whom Ahmose wished to be returned to him. Since Ahmose complained that the girl had been given to someone else and he appealed to the overseer of the seal, it may be that the servant had been conscripted as part of a works project. However, we see here only a sideways glance into the activities of the officials in question, although Ty s presence in Thebes during this period is confirmed. In year z5 Ty left a lengthy inscription in the Sinai in praise of Thutmose III, and he was shown standing behind the king, who offered to Hathor. 47 Accompanying this text was one by the royal messenger Si-Montu, who claimed that the king had sent him at the head of the expedition to bring back large amounts of turquoise. He had indeed done so. Whether the overseer of the seal Ty was actually part of this expedition or, as is more likely, directly responsible for it is uncertain. Nonetheless, we can confirm that he was in office at least until year 25, perhaps following Nehesy in the northern position. The best-documented overseer of the seal for this period is Sennefri, owner of Theban tomb 99. Sennefri held office in the south and began his
98
^
THUTMOSE
III
tenure in the coregency period, for Hatsepsut s name was on his cenotaph at SilsilaWest but was later changed to that of Thutmose III. 4 8 His father was overseer of the station in Watet-Hor, a source of wine and produce mentioned in the tomb of Puyemre. It may have been located near the northeastern border of Egypt, not far from the similarly named "Horus way" road. 49 His mother was the royal ornament Sit-Djehuty. Sennefri may have grown up in the north and even functioned there, since he had titles associated with Heliopolis and made a point in his autobiography of noting that he was later brought to southern Heliopolis. 5 0 Sennefri held office until at least year 33 of Thutmose I l l s sole reign. His tomb, located directly above that of Rekhmire in Skeikh Abd el-Qurna, may have been planned at about the same time as the vizier s. Sennefris career path is outlined in an autobiographical inscription from the tomb. He noted three main areas of functioning, although he did not provide a chronology for the offices. T h e first office was that of a superior, who had authority over the overseers of the storehouses. In the New Kingdom, the storehouse, or šn, designated production centers for the processing of basic foodstuffs. They formed an important element in the country s redistributive economy and are to be distinguished from storage centers. 51 His second office was that of overseer of the seal, and he noted that at this point he was brought to Thebes and made overseer of the granaries. His third office was mayor and overseer of priests for several deities, including Sobek and Anubis. He also claimed to be the chief of the mayors (hry h3tyw^) and overseer of the fields of Amun. 5 2 From a statue in the British Museum we learn that Sennefri was also mayor of Akhmim and overseer of priests for Min of Coptos. 5 3 T h e connection with mayoralties could be related to Sennefri s role as overseer of the seal and second-ranked official in the royal administration, as outlined in the Duties of the Vizier. T h e mayors were accountable to the vizier for cultivation of land and the consequent harvest taxes, and the vizier could both summon them to the gate of the palace and send officials to them to receive reports (sees. 5, Iz, 16). 5 4 Sennefris role may have concerned this interaction between the royal house and the city rulers. If some of the duties of the overseer of the seal are unclear, not all are. T h e involvement with expeditions to procure materials of all kinds is well known for the office. Nehesy s role in the Punt expedition has already been cited, as well as Ty s in the Sinai. Sennefri, too, was active in the region of Serabit el-Khadim and is known from more than one inscription there, including one with a year 33 date. In another inscription at the entrance to the temple Thutmose III stands before Hathor, mistress of turquoise. Sennefri stands behind him, and the great royal steward Kenna is shown last. 55 In this case it is impossible to conclude with certainty that Sennefri made the trip
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III
^
himself, but in at least one instance he did make a long journey to acquire products. In his tomb Sennefri shows two representations of himself being sent to and returning from Byblos in Lebanon to bring back cedar trees for the flagstaffs of the temple of Amun at Karnak: 5 6 "Byblos gave them for her favorite god, giving . . . of the choicest thereof. I brought back 60 cubits in [their] length." 57 T h e importance given this expedition in Sennefris tomb certainly underscores his pride in bringing back the cedar and other products of the Levant. In another scene in the tomb Sennefri is shown receiving precious metals and stones, which are designated as "determined duties" (š3yt). In this text he is referred to as "overseer of the gold lands of [Amun], overseer of horns and overseer of the seal, overseer of thousands of all things and overseer of the seal, festival leader for Atum and overseer of the seal, and mayor and overseer of priests of all the gods and [overseer of the seal]." 58 T h e title of overseer of the gold lands of Amun appears several times in the tomb, 5 9 and in this instance it may concern the metal brought from the eastern deserts reached from Coptos. Sennefris attachment to that region has been registered in other offices he held, but there is nothing to suggest a connection to Nubia, where other gold lands were located. It might be added that he also carried the title of royal herald in the tomb and elsewhere. This position, to be discussed further, was likely related to his role as recipient of goods for the royal household. 60 T h e last overseer of the seal known for the reign of Thutmose III is Min, whose son, Sobekhotep, held the position under Thutmose I V 6 1 Min is known from a cenotaph at SilsilaWest dated to Thutmose III and with honorific epithets suggesting his close connection to the sovereign. There he also was called "great chief in Upper Egypt and judge in Lower Egypt," perhaps suggesting actual functions on behalf of the king and vizier. 62 Min also left funerary cones from an unlocated tomb in Thebes, as well as a statue found at the site of Tell Muqdam in the delta. T h e kings cartouche was on the statues shoulder, and the dedication was to Horus foremost of Tjerer. Min was also named in the tomb of his son. Unfortunately, other than his activity at the sandstone quarries of Silsila, we know nothing of Mins activities.
Overseer of the Granary T h e collection and redistribution of grain was one of the most fundamental organizational activities of the state. T h e overseer of the granary was responsible for supervising this activity, for seeing that it was properly recorded, and for reporting the results to the king. As we learn from papyrus Louvre 3226, there were two overseers of the dual granaries, each of whom
99
82
^
THUTMOSE
III
had his own scribal staff and accounted for half of all grain and produce. Although the papyrus accounts are all registered in Thebes, these same overseers of the granary may have operated in Memphis as well, since the full title of the office was overseer of the granaries of Upper and Lower Egypt. In addition to the main residence cities, the chief granary officials also took responsibility for grain storage facilities in more out of the way places, including the watery portions of the delta (see below). Minnakht was overseer of the granaries from the reign of Hatshepsut to at least year 36. He appears to have had two cenotaphs at Silsila West, numbers 23 and 12, and according to those monuments his office governed granaries in all of Egypt already during the coregency.63 Minnakht was the son of one Sen-Djehuty, named in his burial chamber, and in shrine 23 at Silsila, as the sab (judge). 64 The father may be the same man mentioned in an ostracon, but if so he was still functioning as overseer of the granaries of Amun in year 43 of Thutmose III, when his grandson Menkheperreseneb may already have been in office. 65 A Sen-Djehuty appeared in Theban tomb 294 as recipient of offerings and apparently had the title of overseer of the granaries of Amun and steward of Amun and may be the same man as this last. The identification of Minnakht s father Sen-Djehuty with this other officeholder remains unclear, both because Minnakht did not ascribe a granary title to his father and because the chronology appears somewhat dubious. In the publication dealing with Minnakht s tomb (Theban tomb 87), the rather formal decoration scheme was reconstructed.66 The tomb of Minnakht and that of his son Menkheperreseneb, also overseer of the granaries, were given as favors of the ruler, and they are architecturally connected, since Minnakhts shaft begins from the court of Menkheperreseneb s tomb. Despite the importance of their occupations for the efficient running of the state, neither tomb shows the tomb owner performing his duties before the ruler, nor, indeed, do the most common activities of the overseers of the granaries appear to be represented at all. Rather, both men seem to have emphasized their own wealth and their gifts from the king. Minnakht s position clearly took him to all parts of the country, and it is perhaps this travel that partially explains his monuments being known from several cities, including Thebes, Coptos, and Memphis. 67 On two of his statues (both from Thebes), Minnakht carried the title "overseer of the granaries of the watery areas of the two lands" (hjwt), a designation used to describe parts of the delta. 68 Specific details regarding his role derive from the account in papyrus Louvre 3226, already referred to several times. 69 There it is not Minnakht himself who is functioning, but the scribes in charge of his administration. They (the first was Hepu and the second, appearing in years 33—34, was Wesy) are accounting for the furnishing of dates with an ex-
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III
^
83
change account in grain alongside it. These scribes are strictly said to be "of the overseer of the granaries Minnakht" or "of • • • Tjenuna," and the men furnishing the dates are under their authority. These accounts, representing years 28—35 in Thutmose I l l s reign, suggest the role played by the administration in balancing the collection and distribution of commodities through a value exchange system. Referring to his career, Sennefri stated: " [ M y second office] was overseer of the seal. I was brought to Thebes, the Southern Heliopolis, and I was placed as overseer of the dual granaries. I received... their taxes (h^kwt), consisting of the determined duties of their cities as the tax (tr) of every year." 70 T h e question here is the extent of Sennefris role as overseer of the granaries. It is useful to point out that the position of overseer of the seal was heavily concerned with the accounting of grain in the storehouses in any case, and we see this activity in the tomb of Sobekhotep (Theban tomb 63), overseer of the seal for Thutmose I V where the inscription reads: "overseeing (m33) the granaries of the royal house, l.p.h., they being richly filled. Counting the grain in wheat and barley, by . . . the overseer of the seal Sobekhotep." 7 1 However, Sobekhotep did not have the title of overseer of granaries, so we cannot be sure that Sennefri s position, as with Sobekhotep, concerned only the grain of the royal household. Although it is frequently stated that the overseer of the seal (and the vizier to an extent) only operated for the per nesu} it is also stated that the overseers of the granary administered a national institution. 72 However, in the inscriptions of the overseer of the granaries Khaemhet it is clear that the grain (whether all or part of it is unclear) is considered to be the king s. Khaemhet is called: "the great one in his office in the royal house (per nesu) . . . the overseer of the granaries of the lord of the two lands."The officials presenting the grain taxes for the year in the presence of the king represent both the royal household—the "stewards of the great houses, (life, prosperity, and health!)" (pryt 3 c.w.s.)—and an apparently separate administration—the "directors of Upper and Lower Egypt." 7 3 Likewise Minnakht is titled "overseer of the great granaries [i.e., the so-called central administration] of the king in Upper and Lower Egypt." 7 4 In other words, the operations of the per nesu are frequently impossible to differentiate from those of other administrative entities. At least part of Sennefri s tenure as overseer of the seal overlapped that of Minnakht and Tjenuna as overseers of the granaries. All three of these officials appear in Louvre 3226, Sennefri in year 32, named as overseer of the seal, and the two granary officers for the entire period covered by the accounts, years 28—35.75 We are ignorant of when Minnakht and Tjenuna were appointed, but because Minnakht was already the owner of a Silsila West chapel in the reign of Hatshepsut perhaps he was in office before Tjenuna.
84
^
THUTMOSE
III
Indeed, Tjenuna seems to have held a position in the divine adoratrice s administration at an earlier time. 76 In this case Sennefri could have been both overseer of the seal and overseer of the granary until ceding the latter office to Tjenuna before year 28. This remains uncertain, however. Tjenuna is known to have been overseer of the granaries (of Upper and Lower Egypt) because of the papyrus Louvre 3226 but not from contemporary monuments of his own. He may be identical to a man called "Tjenuna of the house of the divine adoratorice" known from an ostracon and probably a funerary papyrus (Louvre 3074). He was very likely not the same man who served as chief steward and steward of Amun for Thutmose I V (Theban tomb 76). 7 7 T h e royal herald Duawynehhe is given the title of overseer of the granaries in his tomb (Theban tomb 125), along with the overseer of the ges-per or workrooms. It is highly likely that this title related to the temple of Amun, based on the remainder of his tomb inscriptions. Rather, the next overseer of granaries after Tjenuna may have been Iamnedjeh, who possessed tomb 84 in Thebes. That tomb was reused a few years later by the high priest of Amun Mery in the reign of Amenhotep II. 7 8 Iamnedjeh held several important positions in Thutmose I l l s administration, and he began his career early, serving as an overseer of works in year 15 while Hatshepsut was still in power. In his tomb Iamnedjeh appears overseeing the produce of Lower Egypt in his role as overseer of the ruyt (discussed subsequently) and royal scribe.The legends further state that the men carrying in the produce are doing this for "the overseer of the ruyt, royal scribe, counter of cattle and fowl, overseer of granaries who counts the taxes (hrpwt) of Upper and Lower Egypt, Iamn[edjeh]." Elsewhere in the tomb he is at least twice given the title overseer of the granaries of Upper and Lower Egypt as the primary title (i.e., it is listed last before his name). This is clearly not his main title, however, which would be first royal herald and overseer of the ruyt. However, it appears that he did function as one of the two granary officials for Thutmose III. At what point in the reign this might have occurred is impossible on current evidence to clarify, but it should be noted that Iamnedjeh accompaniedThutmose III to Syria on the kings eighth campaign in year 33, a point at which both Minnakht and Tjenuna were still functioning. More probably Iamnedjeh held the granary position toward the end of the reign, perhaps at the same time that Minnakhts son Menkheperreseneb held the twin office. Menkheperreseneb became overseer of the granary after his father left office. He apparently continued to serve in the reign of Amenhotep II, though how late is unknown. Stylistically the tomb of Menkheperreseneb (Theban tomb 79) should be placed early in the reign of Amenhotep II, but
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III ^
85
this need not give us the date of his latest functioning. We cannot be more precise at this time. 79 Menkheperreseneb may have carried out many of his duties in the north of Egypt, for he carried several titles associated with Heliopolis, both for the granary and for the temple administration. His link to Thebes is equally notable, for he was a wab priest of Amun in Henketankh, the funerary temple of Thutmose III. As Guksch has pointed out, he was already overseer of granaries for all of Egypt when his tomb was decorated (contra Helck s view), for it is clear that it was common to abbreviate the title as simply "overseer of granaries." 80 In addition to the men named here, several more are known with the overseer of the granary/granaries title but with insufficient documentation to place them correctly. 81 As we learned from the account papyrus, scribes carried out much of the essential work of the granaries. Other functionaries of the institution included corn measurers, and a man Hatit is known to have been the corn measurer of Minnakht. 8 2 Two men, Senemiah of Theban tomb 127 and Amenemhet, owner of Theban tomb 123, held the title scribe of counting bread for Upper and Lower Egypt. Amenemhet was also overseer of the granaries of bread, while Senemiah, primarily an overseer of the gold and silver houses, also held the title of counter of grain for Upper and Lower Egypt. It seems likely, though not entirely certain, that these men would have been part of the same administration. 83 Since Minnakht also acted as overseer of the granaries of Amun, the owner of Theban tomb 82, Amenemhet, may well have worked with him. Amenemhet was scribe of counting the grain of Amun and steward of the vizier (Useramun). Here we see the close interaction of the royal and temple economies.
S E C O N D - T I E R O F F I C E S OF T H E
STATE
Overseer of the Silver and G o l d Houses T h e overseer of the seal is designated in the Duties of the Vizier as responsible for opening the gold house with the vizier. 84 T h e hierarchy appears to have been such that the vizier was ultimately in charge of all wealth in the per nesu} the overseer of the seal operated as the official with the actual seal for the institution, and the overseer of the silver and gold houses was the direct supervisor for materials used from these treasuries. There are variant titles for men such as Djehuty (Theban tomb 11), designating them alternately overseer of the silver houses and overseer of the gold houses. T h e overseers of the gold and silver houses were subordinate to the overseer of the seal in the reign of Thutmose III, but due to the treasury locations within the royal household, the royal stewards would have had a close con-
86
^
THUTMOSE
III
nection to this position as welL There are indications that the overseer of the seal s office was diminished before the reign of Amenhotep III and that the overseer of the silver and gold houses served together with the royal stewards in similar capacities.85 The most famous holder of this title was Senenmut who was already installed in the regency of Hatshepsut. On a statue now in the British Museum he was overseer of the silver and gold houses, as well as overseer of the seal.86 He also bore the title in texts from his tomb and on name stones. Unfortunately, we can only imagine his use of this office when examining the testimony of one of his contemporaries with the same function. A stela left by Djehuty, who served both Hatshepsut and Thutmose III, detailed his role as an overseer of works overseeing the production of monuments for Amun in Thebes. "The hereditary prince and noble, overseer of the double silver and gold houses," Djehuty says, "I led the artisans to act regarding the works on the great bark of the head of the river, Amunuserhet, worked in gold of the best of the deserts."87 He continued in this way to mention monuments of electrum at Hatshepsut s funerary temple, a shrine of ebony with an alabaster stairway, as well as doors in Karnak and chests with vessels, all of precious metals: "Then every exotic thing was directed, every revenue of every foreign country, and the choicest of the exotic things of Punt . . " 8 8 On a second stela Djehuty continued, saying that the king placed him over the magazines: "I sealed the exotic materials, consisting of the revenues of the heryiu sha, (those on the sand) of the north: gold of Aamu [the Levant], silver and bronze. . . . I counted with regard to the mayors; I accepted all their taxes (b3kw)"89 Clearly Djehuty s career as overseer of the gold and silver houses for Hatshepsut and Thutmose III endowed him with the rulers trust, as well as access to the most valuable commodities in the land. However, lest we take Djehuty s testimony too literally, we should also point out that several men who served under Hatshepsut claimed to have overseen the same monuments Djehuty refers to, including Hapuseneb, high priest of Amun, and Puyemre, second priest of Amun. Senenmut likewise had responsibility for the materials that entered the storehouses, at the same time that men such as Useramun, Sennefri, and Djehuty functioned in their offices. Senenmut says: The taxes (hrpwt) of south and north were on my seal."90 Senemiah, mentioned earlier as a granary officer, was also overseer of the silver and gold houses for Hatshepsut, with broad duties concerning a variety of products. Unlike Djehuty, Senemiah does not mention duties as an overseer of works, who would withdraw precious materials from the treasuries to use in making monuments. His responsibility appears to have been that of accountant.91
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III ^
87
Much later, in the sole reign of Thutmose III, Benermerut is attested as overseer of the gold houses and overseer of the silver house. Like Djehuty, Benermerut was involved in monument building for the ruler, and he claimed to have been overseer of all works of the king. A stela donating land on behalf of the Heliopolitan bull Mnevis and his cattle is dated year 45 and records that Benermerut gave 60 auroura for the herd. A statue of him from Karnak shows him with the king s daughter, Meryetamun, a princess known also from Thutmose I l l s Deir el-Bahari Hathor shrine. Benermerut also left a stela at the great sphinx in Giza and may have been buried in the north, for his tomb is not known in Thebes. 92
Overseer o f the Ruyt
Several men are known to have held this title in the reign of Thutmose III. The best known of them was Iamnedjeh, cited earlier as an overseer of the granaries. One of Iamnedjeh s two principal titles in his Theban tomb, number 84, was overseer of the ruyt; the other was first royal herald (discussed subsequently), a position he had held from early in the king s sole rule, if we are to believe his autobiography. 93 Iamnedjeh had an unusual career path for this period, having begun his career during the coregency period as one who oversaw the building of monuments, including obelisks in Thebes and Heliopolis, and then moved into the military. He was promoted to the position of royal herald and accompanied the king on his northern expeditions, having participated with him in the crossing of the Euphrates in year 33. When he was given the title overseer of the ruyt is uncertain; however, it is likely to have been after his campaigns with the ruler. As van den Boorn has shown, 94 the ruyt was part of the entrance to the per nesu and constituted transitional areas between Egypt generally and the domain of the king. Activities in the ruyt and the related 'aryt (both words deriving from terms for gates and porticos) were both judicial and nonjudicial. As stated above, the vizier was the supreme power over the 'aryt, and he appointed its personnel, which would have included the overseer of the ruyt. Because the ruyt was an area to which deliveries were made for the per nesu, and it was the only main entrance to the palace, the overseer of the ruyt was an influential man. In the "Instruction for Ptahhotep," the vizier tells his son, "If you are in the ruyt, stand up and sit down according to your rank which was assigned to you on the first day. Do not trespass, for you will be turned back. Keen is the face to him who enters announced, and spacious the seat of him who has been called. The ruyt has rules, all behavior is by measure." 95 The overseer of the ruyt might thus have influenced access to the interior of the palace or viziral offices, having
88
^
THUTMOSE
III
oversight authority in this entry environment. Iamnedjeh once claimed to have been "overseer of the ruyt hearing alone."96 Rather than a reference to the official as a judge, this may suggest that Iamnedjeh could assess petitioners' applications for entrance to the state offices by himself Both Senenmut and Sennefri claimed this same epithet, Senenmut having added "in privacy » to vit/9 7 In addition, as the vizier s employee in the ruyt Iamnedjeh s duties may be reflected in the Duties of the Vizier. In his tomb he was shown viewing herds of cattle and confronting the rulers of estates (hkj hwtt). The Duties tells us that the vizier s message "takes the mayors and the rulers of estates to the y aryt"98 where Iamnedjeh would have received them. The yaryt was also the place through which all deliveries entered the per nesu.99 In the rear passage of his tomb Iamnedjeh was shown inspecting the revenues of Lower Egypt together with his wife. Here he was called royal scribe and overseer of the ruyt, as well as royal scribe of counting cattle and birds and overseer of the granaries who counts the taxes of Upper and Lower Egypt. He was not called first royal herald here. Other men known to have held the title overseer of the ruyt include the viceroy of Nubia Nehy, but whether he held it with regard to the antechambers of the royal houses in Egypt proper (Thebes or Memphis) or in Nubia itself is uncertain. He bears the title on several monuments from Aniba and Qasr Ibrim. I 0 0 The royal butler Wah (Theban tomb zz) also held the title in his tomb. 1 0 1 Functions different from those identified for Iamnedjeh are known from several other texts of the period. From year zy of Thutmose III is an inscription reproducing the text of a document made on behalf of the royal barber Si-Bastet.The document itself will be considered later, but it was witnessed in the presence of the king by "the guard Amenemheb, the royal scribe Ahmose, the royal scribe and inspector Baki, the royal scribe Amenmose, and the overseer of the ruyt Amen-pa-?" 102 On the kneeling statue of Neferperet from Karnak is a juridical text outlining this royal butlers plans for seven bulls from the Levant that he brought back as booty with the kings permission. The document set out his intent that they would be placed under the care of his brother and nephew after his death. At this point in the text there followed: "Entering because of it: the overseer of the ruyt Nebseny. Coming because of it: the royal scribe Amenmose [the same man as in Si-Bastet s inscription?] What was said in the majesty of the palace, l.p.h. (stp-sj) 'They [his relatives] shall be in your accompaniment on your day of life. As to after you possess old age, they shall be as son to son, heir to heir. Do not give them [the cattle] to the residence of the overseer of cattle. As to anyone who
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III ^
89
shall come regarding the matter, do not allow that one judge for them in any office of the king. Do not allow that one transgress to do anything.;'" 103 Here are a number of allusions to situations detailed in the Duties of the Vizier. The overseer of the ruyt Nebseny is said to "enter," while the royal scribe "comes." Since the following sentence tells us the decision within the palace, it is likely that Nebseny "entered" the palace from the yaryt to witness this document and to be the one to report back concerning it. The royal scribe would have already been within the palace offices. In addition, we hear a prohibition of someone bringing suit in any office (h3) of the king to prevent the bringing of claims that would normally come to the vizier. It is uncertain when Nebseny functioned, but the statue of Neferperet may date to the last part of the reign. 104 Last, an unnamed overseer of the ruyt is mentioned in the testament of Senimose, inscribed on a stelophorous statue from the chapel of prince Wadjmose in Thebes. It was dated in year zi and was adjudicated and finalized by the vizier Useramun, apparently because the imyt-fer; or property transfer, had been challenged. An overseer of the ruyt and a guard of the palace seem to have entered to present the documents before Useramun, but the text is quite fragmentary. 105 We must conclude that the role of the overseer of the ruyt, like the area of the yaryt itself, combined judicial and nonjudicial functions. In Iamnedjeh s case we appear to see the nonjudicial functions, while with Nebseny, Amun-pa-?, and the unnamed man in Senimose s text, the involvement with matters requiring legal attention is certain. Royal Herald 1 0 6 There were heralds at all levels of the Egyptian bureaucracy, for these men had the authority to speak for the leader, just as the scribe had the authority to record for him. The royal herald was thus the king s reporter and operated over a broad geographic range. The two best-known royal heralds of the reign are Iamnedjeh, already referred to as both overseer of the granaries and overseer of the ruyt, and Intef, who was also mayor of Thinis and chief of the oases. As noted, Iamnedjeh was promoted to be first royal herald after serving as a controller of works during the coregency. He says of his office: "I was sent on [every mission]. . . . I followed the good god to every northern foreign country, I not straying from him on the battlefield." He also claimed to be "the confidant on every mission, the houses of gold and silver being enclosed in his hand as a single thing, the excellent royal herald.. " I 0 7 T h e tomb of Iamnedjeh was usurped by the high priest Amun Mery, for himself and his mother, and the final title and name of Iamnedjeh are therefore often removed
108
^
THUTMOSE
III
in the funerary chapeL 1 0 8 However, it was presumably as first royal herald that he appeared announcing the chiefs of the north and the south before Thutmose III. T h e king was seated on his throne in the palace Q in southern Heliopolis, where the deliveries of defeated Retenu were offered for Amun of Karnak. As Pardey has argued in her discussion of the heralds, Iamnedjeh was seen acting as the kings personal representative before the rulers of foreign countries. Although his position as royal herald could properly be said to be part of a palace administration, rather than a state one, both Iamnedjeh and Intef held responsibilities in the 'aryt and the per nesu. Based on the autobiography, Iamnedjehs role as royal herald was primarily one of observation and reporting that extended from the ruyt (where he was entrusted to receive for the gold and silver houses) to the whole of Egypt and beyond. As seen from the tomb texts and paintings, as royal herald Iamnedjeh displayed to the ruler the riches brought from foreign deliveries; for Lower Egypt he supervised the deposit of revenues. The connection of the office to the military should not be neglected, however, and Pardey sees it as deliberately connective between the army and the administration. This is more evident in the case of Intef, but Iamnedjehs involvement in the first Syrian campaign is well known. 1 0 9 Intef, owner of Theban tomb 155, 1 1 0 served under Hatshepsut and Thutmose III and very likely completed his burial site before Iamnedjeh did. His title as herald was listed with several variants that may suggest the range of his position. In the scene on his stela, now in the Louvre (Cz6), he was called the great herald of the king and also first herald of the king. In the body of the inscription he was termed first herald of the yaryt twice and great herald of the yaryt once, as well as great steward, overseer of the granaries, and controller of all works of the royal house (l.p.h.). Several times he was called "excellent scribe" and once "excellent scribe, the best of counting." He was not called royal scribe and should not be understood as having arisen out of the state bureaucracy but perhaps out of the regional administrations. His role as herald was emphasized, as with Iamnedjeh, for two areas: the royal house and its access area, the yaryt; and regions outside Egypt where the ruler campaigned. Summarizing his role at court, Intef said: " M y office (j3t) was in the per nesu, (l.p.h.), my duty (wnwt) was in the palace (stps3), my completion (km) was in the ruyt" Here Intef appears to inform us first that his rank placed him within the elite realm of the royal house and state offices, that his service obligation was to the king himself in the palace, and that his activity was most apparent in the waiting rooms of the per nesu. While the overseer of the ruyt principally received goods or decided the order of access for petitions or legal matters, the royal herald in the yaryt organized and announced the people entering the per nesu and made sure they knew exactly where they should stand—even accompanying them to their places, as he
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III
^
91
notes in saying that he "performed the marches of the ruyt." In his tomb, however, Intef did appear inspecting gold, as well as the revenues of the Keftiu, the Syrians, and the oasis dwellers. This likely had to do with his reporting role also. With regard to internal state functioning, Intef claimed to have been "the tongue which speaks for the one who in the palace." 111 His autobiography was particularly full of descriptions of him as someone who imposed order at court and throughout the land. He even boasted that he was "one who caused that the one who is disaffected make rule, law, and precision out of the hatred of his heart." 1 1 2 He apparently did the same for everyone at court and described himself as "the confidant of the king in directing (hrp) his army, who caused the councils (knbt) and the army (mnfyt) to come, who counted the officials, who introduced the nobles, who caused the august ones of the king to approach their stations . . . who performed the marches (nmtwt) of the ruyt, who caused that the regulations took place in the royal house (l.p.h.)." 113 Far from meaning that Intef ran parts of the military, he boasted here of organizing the proper admittance of various groups into audiences before the king. Here is a reference to the elaborate rituals that dominated the royal household, as described so well in the Duties of the Vizier. 1 1 4 It is important to bear in mind that among the many duties assigned to the vizier giving orders to the army was one of them, and the officers therefore approached and entered through the "aryt for that purpose. 115 Intef s role as great herald of the king outside Egypt proper may have been similar to his role at court. He appears to have organized the king s living quarters in the field, but he also accompanied the king directly and compared himself to the brave warriors of the army. At the front, perhaps in the western desert, he set up palaces and prepared them to be proper for the king, "they being embellished more than the palace of Egypt—purified, cleansed, hidden, sacred of their temples I counted the deliveries of the rulers who are in every foreign country, consisting of silver, gold, moringa oil, incense, and wine." 1 1 6 These are perhaps the products of the western oases, where Intef himself held sway. In two places Intef referred to the mayors and rulers of estates, claiming once to have overseen them and their scribal functionaries and once to have counted all their taxes (b3wt). In the latter case Intef is called "excellent scribe" in the next line. As Pardey has underlined in her discussion, Intef s role as royal herald would not have given him authority over the collection of agricultural taxes. Since he also claimed to have been a chief steward and overseer of the granary, he may have recorded revenues in relation to those offices. Other men from the reign are known as royal heralds, without first or great before their titles. These men included Ahmose-Pennekhbet (although
92 ^
THUTMOSE
III
when he held this title is unknown from his autobiography); Djehuty (Theban tomb no); Sennefri, the overseer of the seal; Thutmose, owner of Theban tomb 342; and Nehy, the viceroy of Nubia. All of these men would have had numerous occasions to represent the ruler outside the palace, as well as within i t . 1 1 7 Duawynehhe (Theban tomb 125) was a "first herald," but his role may have concerned the organization of foodstuffs, animals, and linens of the Karnak ges-per. Nothing suggests that he was part of the per nesu administration. 1 1 8
Royal Messengers T h e royal messengers were part of the hierarchy described by the Duties of the V i z i e r . 1 1 9 T h e vizier determined every royal messengers mission as the kings representative. From the contemporary collaborative texts it is clear that the overseer of the seal, as deputy to the vizier, was directly responsible for the royal messengers' expeditions.The person of the messenger was sacrosanct while on a mission and could not be made to bow while delivering his message. 1 2 0 This "diplomatic immunity" no doubt extended to messengers operating outside Egypt as well, although for Thutmose I l l s reign we cannot demonstrate this. Later in the N e w Kingdom royal messengers were employed in the cyclical inspection of the pharaoh s holdings in the north and the south. Their military capabilities were romanticized in a famous literary work that poked fun at a functionary too ignorant of the geography of the Levant to carry a message. 1 2 1 Despite the long period of Thutmose I l l s reign, the careers of royal messengers from this period are poorly attested. Only one man with a known tomb has been recognized, and he was certainly part of the kings Levantine campaigns. 1 2 2 One is known from the Punt inscriptions of Hatshepsut and two from inscription in the Sinai. 1 2 3 A legend to the arrival scene in Punt states, "arrival of the royal messenger at the gods land together with the army which accompanied him." He then was shown receiving the products of Punt, again at the head of the army. 1 2 4 Clearly he was the head of the expedition sent by the overseer of the seal Nehesy, but his name is unknown. T h e scribe Nakht, known from a year 20 text in the Sinai, boasts that he was promoted to be a royal messenger. A second inscription referred to him as "royal messenger at the front of the army, the scribe Nakht of T j e n t i . " 1 2 5 A year 25 inscription from the Sinai was apparently left by a royal messenger whose name may have been SiMontu. T h e text is appended to the inscription of the overseer of the seal Ty and its accompanying praise of the ruler. T h e likelihood is that the royal messenger actually carried out the expedition on behalf of the overseer of the seal, just as was the case in the mission to Punt. He claimed to have been
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III
^
93
a close confidant of the ruler and boasted of finding more turquoise than was required. The inscription states that the work was done "under the agency of the royal messenger, overseer in front of every channel of the Wadjwer [?], . . . of the Lower Egyptian king, sole companion, Si-Montu." 126 Dedi, owner of Theban tomb zoo, was termed a royal messenger in every foreign country in his funerary chapel. The inscriptions also inform us that he received the "gold of honor" because of his valiance on numerous occasions, and on the wall he was shown wearing the combination of a gold fly with striding lions—the award given in the Syrian campaign, according to the Annals of Thutmose III. The owner of Theban tomb 9z, the royal butler Suemniwet, also received this award. 127 Both men fought along with and accompanied the king on marches, but Dedi s titles were more explicitly military than those of Suemniwet (see ensuing discussion). In his later years Dedi was put in charge of the deserts of western Thebes—meaning the cemetery areas. He also had responsibility for the police, presumably in that same region. We do not know how long Dedi functioned as royal messenger, but the title he held implied that the service took place abroad. From the Duties of the Vizier it is clear that the messenger of the royal house (a variant of the royal messenger) functioned within the country on many missions, but it is impossible to confirm whether Dedi did likewise. 128
PALACE
ADMINISTRATION
Chief Steward of the King (mr pr wr n nsw) The royal household was administered by a chief steward, who kept the accounts of the rulers personal holdings. 129 Some chief stewards became extremely influential through their close personal connections to the rulers, and this was never more true than in the reign of Hatshepsut. Senenmut, the queens steward in the reign of Thutmose II, continued to function in that role after the coregency began. In his tomb Senenmut held the title of chief steward of the king, as well as the following steward titles: steward, chief steward, steward of Amun, chief steward of Amun, steward of the king, steward of the gods wife Hatshepsut, and steward of the princess Neferura. 130 As chief steward to Hatshepsut and Neferura before the coregency, Senenmut directed work on a pair of obelisks for Karnak and apparently was already involved in other monument building to judge from his early cenotaph at Silsila West. According to that chapel he was chief steward of the gods wife and chief steward of the royal wife, overseer of the granaries of [Amun], and "overseer of the residence (hnw) who directs every divine office." 1 3 1 Senenmut was highly visible on behalf of the queen as she
94
^
THUTMOSE
III
built her temples at Deir el-Bahari and her additions to the temple of Karnak. As a controller of work and an overseer of overseers of work, Senenmut even carried the designations "overseer of the work of Amun in Djeseru," referring to the funerary temple, and "controller of work in Ipet-sut," or K a r n a k . 1 3 2 Although Senenmuts many statues and two tomb sections demonstrate that his principal functioning title was (chief ) steward of Amun, it is clear that at court under Hatshepsut he held sway. On a statue now in Berlin he stated: "I am a dignitary beloved of his lord, who entered concerning marvels for the mistress of the two lands. He promoted me before the two lands, he having placed me as chief mouth for his house, judge of the gate in the entire land." 1 3 3 This last title suggests that Senenmut could usurp the authority of the vizier s office, if Van den Boorns interpretation of the term is correct, and other claims by the chief steward might support this view. On a statue from the Mut temple Senenmut is called "the one relating to Nekhen (Hierakonpolis), the priest of M a a t , " 1 3 4 both of which are titles of the vizier. On the same statue the steward further boasted: "I am indeed one to whom the conditions of the two lands are reported, the taxes of Upper and Lower are upon my seal, the dues of every country are under my authority. I am one who knows his paths (nmtwt) in the royal house." 1 3 5 These are all functions of the vizier, but Senenmut felt that he could at least claim them. Since we know that Useramun was vizier during this period, but we know little of his position at court under Hatshepsut s reign, we cannot judge the claims of the chief steward. They are nonetheless intriguing. Amenhotep, owner of Theban tomb 7 3 , 1 3 6 was also chief steward under Hatshepsut. In his tomb he presents costly N e w Year s gifts to Hatshepsut as the product of his work on her behalf. A number of his epithets parallel those of Senenmut but without the allusions to the vizierate. Clearly Amenhotep s major accomplishments were as overseer of works, and he particularly noted that he was "overseer of works for the great obelisks in the house of Amun." He also introduced the cattle for the Festival of Opet. Exactly when Amenhotep served as chief steward of the king is unknown, but he does not appear to have lived into the sole rule of Thutmose III. At the quarries of Gebel Hammam in southern Egypt an inscription dated in the names of both Hatshepsut and Thutmose III records new work beginning for the chief steward of the king Wadjetrenput. 1 3 7 Two letters from western Thebes name this chief steward, and one of them concerns the overseer of the sealTy. Helck concluded that Wadjetrenput served at the end of the reign of Hatshepsut. A fourth chief steward appeared on the temple pylon at Serabit el-Khadim behind Thutmose III and the overseer of the seal Sennefri. T h e chief steward of the king Kenna could belong to the sole rule of the king, since we know Sennefri was active as late as year 32. N o later
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III
^
95
chief stewards are known from the reign. 138 It would be tempting to conclude that the emphasis on the vizierate during the sole rule of Thutmose III and the apparent diminution of the chief steward s role were reactions to the dominance of Hatshepsuts close associates, particularly Senenmut. However, there is insufficient evidence to do more than wonder. Royal Butler Royal butlers were clearly highly trusted members of the royal circle, and they did provide provisions for the palace, as one might expect from the title. 139 These men, however, were also functionaries whom the ruler trusted to accompany him on the battlefield and in some cases to represent him in foreign countries. 140 As early as the Amarna period, royal butlers were recognized as a separate category, neither civil nor military in nature but combining features of both. They were listed in the tomb of Neferhotep, at a royal audience, after the viziers and overseer of the seal and before the followers of the king, with whom they may have had much in common. 141 A number of men with this title are known from the reign of Thutmose III, and one often identified with the position did not hold it—the royal scribe and overseer of works Minmose. One Kenamun, also a mayor of Memphis, held the title and was buried in an unknown tomb in Thebes. 1 4 2 Neferperet, who donated a statue of himself in Karnak, was a child of the kap (within the palace) and a royal butler, pure of hands. His statue provides the text of a legal declaration concerning booty he brought from the Levant: "What the royal butler Neferperet brought away while he was in the following of his majesty in the foreign country of Retenu: bulls of Djahy [a Levantine region]; female 4; female Egyptian 2; male 1. Total, 7. Bronze: milk jar in order to provide it to the temple of millions of years of Henketankh [Thutmose Ills funerary temple]." As noted earlier with respect to the overseer of the ruyt Nebseny, Neferperets wishes regarding the cattle were granted by the palace. We may conclude that his familiarity with the royal family (he showed both the king and his wife Meryetre on his stelophorous statue) and his attendance on the king during the northern campaigns contributed to his securing a sinecure for his brother and son. Unfortunately we learn nothing about Neferperets role as royal butler. The royal butler, clean of hands, Montu-iywy, left an autobiography in his tomb (Theban tomb 172) where he described his service under Thutmose III and Amenhotep II. 1 4 3 Although he made clear that he accompanied the former king to the Levant and crossed the Euphrates, never straying on the battlefield, he did not provide his title during that time. He did state that he had started as a servant of the royal apartments fipt nsw), and this would im-
9
6
^
THUTMOSE
III
ply a close personal relationship with the ruler. Under Amenhotep II he claimed to have been promoted in the per nesu, but he could already have been appointed royal butler by Thutmose. We can only note that his roles appear to parallel those of Neferperet and Suemniwet, who served with Thutmose III and then became royal butlers by the time his tomb was decorated early in the reign of Amenhotep I I . 1 4 4
Child of the
Kap145
This position is poorly understood, largely because there are no certain regular functions associated with it. T h e children of the kap were part of the palace, and they have been referred to as "pages," but this cannot be corroborated. In two cases children of the kap associated themselves with a specific royal person—once king Ahmose and once princess Merytamun. T h e word kap indicates an enclosure and suggests a protected area of the palace. For this reason it has been thought that these were people who were raised at court, often from youth. They do not, however, appear to have been people who later held the highest bureaucratic positions. Rather, as might be expected, some of these men, as trusted friends of the king, held palace positions, such as royal nurse or royal butler, while others accompanied the king on military expeditions. Some did not maintain positions directly connected to court, however, for reasons of which we are ignorant. T h e titleholders for this reign included Senimen, tutor of princess Neferura; Maiherperi, fan bearer on the right of the king (in the time of Hatshepsut); one Amenemhet, with no other known title; Ahmose, owner of Theban tomb 241 and chief of secrets in the house of the morning; Neferperet, royal butler; Nebenkemet, chief of the stables and fan bearer; Pahekamen, called Benia, overseer of works; Inpehuwysen, with no other known title; Amenemheb, called Mahu, owner of Theban tomb 85, adjutant of the army and troop commander; his son Iamu; and Montu-iywy, royal butler. T h e most interesting text from this reign that mentions the children of the kap is the inscription of the royal barber Si-Bastet. 1 4 6 Si-Bastet left a mummiform statuette as a dedicatory object and on it had the text of a royal petition inscribed on it. T h e petition begins as follows: "Year 27 under the majesty of the King of Upper and Lower Egypt, Menkheperre, given life and stability, the son of Re Thutmose, Ruler of Maat, like Re forever. A petition which the royal barber Si-Bastet made in the presence of the children of the kap of the royal house (per nesu)" T h e text continues, stating that Si-Bastet had brought a slave back from his campaigning with the ruler. That slave, named Amen-iywy, was to be given the position of Si-Bastet s father (barber of the temple of Bubastis) and was given in marriage to Si-Bastet s niece. T h e
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III ^
97
petition was to prevent the slave s being denied access to the royal house and to assure his status in the future. 147 This was not, contrary to earlier views, a slave manumission. The slave was never freed. 148 The significant point here is that the petition was made before the children of the kap and then recorded in writing by a royal scribe and witnessed by officials associated with the royal palace, including a guardian, royal scribes, and an overseer of the ruyt. Although very analogous to the Neferperet inscription mentioned earlier, which guaranteed the royal butlers brother a sinecure with respect to cows and a bull for the funerary temple of Thutmose III, that inscription was not described as a petition, and Neferperets statement was confirmed by "the majesty of the palace, l.p.h." in the presence of the overseer of the ruyt and the royal scribe Amenmose. Here the children of the kap, by hearing a petition, acted as a judicial body within the palace, although there is nothing to suggest that they made any decision. Rather they were hearing a matter, which was then recorded in writing. Since Si-Bastets petition contained the provisions of an imyt-per, or property transfer, on behalf of his sister, niece, and the slave, the vizier s office may have sealed the formal document. This text suggests that Si-Bastet wished its contents to be known at court— perhaps specifically by the children of the kap—where he desired his slave to be accepted and "not to be turned away at any royal portal."The barbers audience before this group may also indicate that his access to the royal house was great but not complete. Otherwise we might have expected his audience to have been before the king himself—or, as with Neferperet, set elliptically before "the majesty of the palace." The Royal Nurse The position of royal nurse became highly visible through a stream of monuments dedicated throughout the Eighteenth Dynasty. 149 Perhaps due to the importance of rearing and protecting the future rulers of Egypt, and following the unfortunate loss of more than once prince at the beginning of the dynasty (e.g., Ahmose-ankh and Ahmose sa-pair), the institution of the royal nurses developed. The nurses were both male and female and were sometimes appointed for a group of royal children and other times selected to tutor one prince or princess. In general it is thought that the female titleholders were wet nurses to these young royals, while the men called royal nurse were tutors. At least one man, however, Ahmose-Pennekhbet, claimed to have functioned as nurse for a child still at the breast. In the reign of Thutmose III there were several men known to have been royal nurses or tutors. Pahery, governor of Elkab, was also royal nurse to prince Wadjmose, son of Thutmose I. The family of Thutmose I and II
9
8
^
THUTMOSE
III
(seemingly through Mutnofret) and collateral to Hatshepsuts line through Thutmose I and queen Ahmose, was memorialized in a chapel associated with Wadjmose. 1 5 0 Senimose, also the royal tutor of Wadjmose left a year zi inscription on a stela there, recounting the legal battles he encountered with regard to his testamentary intentions. 151 The family of Hatshepsut also had royal nurses. Ahmose-Pennekhbet claimed in his tomb at Elkab to have "nursed [literally, "suckled"] her eldest son [sic] the kings daughter Neferura when she was a child who was at the breast." 1 5 2 The nurse best known to us is Senenmut, who carried the title of nurse of the royal daughter Neferura in the period prior to Hatshepsuts accession. Following the queens assumption of pharaonic rule, she appointed Senenmut to be father and great nurse for the royal daughter, mistress of the two lands, gods wife Neferura. At that point Senimen, who had been nurse for Hatshepsut as gods wife, took over as royal nurse for Neferura, with Senenmut retaining a close but more supervisory role. 1 5 3 A royal tutor for the kings son Amenhotep is also known. In the tomb of Min, the mayor of This and the oases, Theban tomb 109, the tomb owner appears demonstrating the pulling of the bow to the young prince Amenhotep. It is likely that this is the youth who became Amenhotep II and Min s title was apparently "[father] and nurse for the royal son Amenhotep." 1 5 4 Ahmose Humay, owner of Theban tomb 224, and father of the vizier Amenemipet, was also a royal nurse who may have served the palace as early as the reign of Amenhotep I . 1 5 5 Other men from the reign of Thutmose III were known to have been associated with royal children but did not carry the title of nurse. For example, Minmose, the retired soldier who acted as an overseer of works for the king, appeared with two princes, Nedjem and Weben[senu] on a statue, but the children could have been either Thutmose I l l s or Amenhotep U s . 1 5 6 Benermerut, the overseer of the gold and silver houses, also left a statue of himself with the princess Meryetamun. 1 5 7 We can only presume that men such as these had close ties to the king and participated directly in the education of royal children, though perhaps in their more advanced years. Royal nurses appeared to have undertaken duties even as younger men. Women who were designated as royal nurses included one Sitre, who had been a nurse for Hatshepsut as a child. Upon her charge s accession, Sitre was granted a life-sized statue of herself holding the ruler. An ostracon with a draft of the statues text is in Vienna. 1 5 8 Also during the reign of Hatshepsut, the wife of the mayor of Thinis, Satepihu, was a royal nurse. That lady, Tinet-iunet is known from a stela. 1 5 9 The lady Nebetkabeny was the great nurse of the royal daughter and greatest of entertainers of Amun, Sitamun. Nebetkabeny was also called royal ornament who suckles the god and favored one of the good god. On a stela of which she was the focus, this lady
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III
^
99
was identified as the mother of the scribe of the temple of Osiris, Hekanefer. Two of her other sons were the wab priest of Menkheperre, Kenamun, and the wab priest of the first phyle in Henketankh, Nesy-su. Princess Sitamun was a daughter of king Ahmose and is known from the reign of Amenhotep L The stela of Nebetkabeny was dedicated in the reign of Thutmose III, but this lady may have been long past her years of nursing—if not already deceased. 160 The wife of the army adjutant Amenemheb, called Mahu, was named Baky. In their tomb, number 85 at Thebes, she was referred to as "the favored one of the good god, great nurse of the lord of the two lands, Horus having united to her breast, the possessor of a burial on the west of Thebes as a favor of the good god, the [royal ornament and mistress of the house Baky] I 1 1 6 1 Baky s favored position certainly suggests that she had been nurse for Amenhotep II himself, although another lady claimed that role as well. Amenemipet, mother of the great steward of Amun for Amenhotep II, Kenamun, was shown as a royal nurse holding the young king on her lap in her sons tomb (Theban tomb 93). 1 6 2 Indeed, Kenamun held the coveted title of foster brother of the king, apparently due to his mothers role vis-avis the ruler. The wife of Pehsuker, Neith, was called royal nurse and great nurse who suckles the [god] in Theban tomb 88, where they were buried. Although the tomb may have been decorated in the early years of Amenhotep II, the military adjutant Pehsuker certainly functioned alongside Amenemheb Mahu during the reign of Thutmose III. In a scene that replicates one from tomb 85 of Mahu and Baky, Neith appeared with him offering the bouquet of Amun to the king and was called there "the singer of Amun, great nurse of the lord of the two lands, favored one of the good god, who nursed the god, perfect of suckling the one who is united to the breast." 163
THE REGIONAL
ADMINISTRATION164
Returning once more to the Duties of the Vizier, we recall the sections that refer to mayors, or h^tyw-—the men responsible for the economies of Egypts forty-two nomes, or regions, and particularly its primary urban areas. The four sections (11, 21, 25, and 32) that refer to mayors make it clear that the vizier could direct them to carry out both cultivation and harvest, as well as receive reports from them about their tax deliveries. He could also order them to the residence and hear any legal matters brought against them. Van den Boorn described the mayors' duties as follows: "They were responsible for the collection and transportation of taxes and deliveries of grain and other commodities. In addition they were charged in many instances with the support of local temples or state institutions. We find them entrusted with
118
^
THUTMOSE
III
the management and control of granaries. In the N e w Kingdom they often combined their office of mayor with agricultural functions such as 'overseer of fields.' Apart from that, they could be charged as mayors with the management of particular types of fields, e.g., khato-fields. Especially from N e w Kingdom sources, one often gains the impression that their work to a large extent consisted of agricultural tasks." 1 6 5 From the monuments of men known to have been mayors in the reign of Thutmose III, agriculture would appear to have been a significant but perhaps not a primary occupation for them. In addition to commodity supervision, we find them involved in monument building, tutelage of royal children, and other court-related functions. However, the tomb of Pahery at Elkab shows the production and transportation of grain as the main function of that mayor, whose governance included both Nekheb (Elkab) and Iunyt (Esna). He was also a scribe of accounting, a position that was no doubt associated with grain deliveries as well. 1 6 6 Pahery may have been in the mayoral office for a long time, since he was also the royal nurse for prince Wadjmose, son of Thutmose I. T h e region of Esna was important for grain production in the early N e w Kingdom, and it had a high population density as well. In the tomb of Rekhmire, the delivery of grain to the vizier was effected by the mayor of Elkab and a ruler of the estate from Esna. This may well have been Pahery, accompanied by the estate administrator for this rich agricultural region. Three men are known to have been mayors of Thinis during this period: Satepihu was in office during the coregency of Hatshepsut and Thutmose III, and, as already noted, he participated in the obelisk construction for the queen as recorded at the temple of Deir el-Bahari. T h e herald Intef who was so indispensable in the per nesu, was also mayor of Thinis and "chief of all the oases." Although it has been assumed that Intef campaigned in Palestine and Syria with Thutmose III, it may be that his travels with the ruler took place in the Egyptian desert regions that then delivered their revenues to Egypt, as shown in the tomb of Intef and also with emphasis in the tomb of Rekhmire. A third mayor of Thinis was the man named Min, who was also royal tutor to prince Amenhotep (II). In his tomb at Thebes ( T T 109) Min underscored his connections to both the Thinite and Abydene regions and his association with the western oases. On his funerary cone he was mayor of the oasis, and he was also overseer of priests of Osiris. In the tomb he was overseer of priests of Onuris. One Montuherkhepeshef, owner of Theban tomb zo, was the mayor of the tenth Upper Egyptian nome, with its center at ancient Tjebu, perhaps Qaw el Kebir. This man was also a fan bearer, but we know little else of h i m . 1 6 7 Also in Middle Egypt was the town of Nefrusy, led at this time by
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III^119
Iamnefer, son of one Pa-ahawty, also a mayor of that city. Iamnefer had earlier been a wab priest and scribe of divine offerings for Thoth, but later, to judge from his titles, he participated in at least one of Thutmose Ills Sed Festivals and eventually became high priest of Thoth as well as mayor. He also claimed the title of "great chief of the Hare nome," even before assuming his father s office. On a statue of his, apparently dedicated in Karnak Temple, he held the prince Aakheperenreseneb on his lap, a clear indication of his distinction at court. 168 Iamnefer s son, Suemniwet, became royal butler under Amenhotep II, having also accompanied Thutmose III on his travels in Syria and Palestine. Near the still unidentified site of Nefrusy was the Fayum Oasis, where a mayoral family flourished at this time. Two men, Kapu and his son Sobekhotep, held office in Fayum during the reigns of Thutmose III and Amenhotep II. The exact time of their functioning cannot be stated. The agricultural capabilities of Fayum were great and being reexploited in this period. The mayors there were known to have been involved with the distribution of local commodities, and they were also involved with provisioning the royal palace established at Gurob by Thutmose III. 1 6 9 A final mayoralty about which we have some information is that of Memphis. One Hemy was mayor of Mennefer in the reign of Thutmose III and is known from a statue in the Louvre. Another man, Kenamun, also held this title, as well as those of royal butler and overseer of the granary and several priestly ranks. Gessler-Löhr considered that the combination of Kenamuns mayoral position with the overseer of the granary rank suggests his involvement in the transportation of commodities from north to south. As stated earlier, this would agree with other indicators, such as the Duties of the Vizier. Van Sielen has pointed out that, despite his position in Memphis, this Kenamun was buried in Thebes, as a funerary cone demonstrates.170 Which man held office first during the fifty-year period is unknown. T H E K I N G ' S S O N A N D O V E R S E E R OF
SOUTHERN
C O U N T R I E S ( V I C E R O Y OF N U B I A )
The king s sons who headed the administration of Nubia during the New Kingdom derived their roles from Egypts military domination of the region, which began as early as the reign of Kamose. Important soldiers such as Ahmose, son of Ebana, and Ahmose-Pennekhbet from Elkab related some of the story of Egypt's conquest over the kings of Kush centered at Kerma. The military campaigns of the kings of the Eighteenth Dynasty who preceded Thutmose III secured this area for Egypt, and the civil administration that oversaw the peace in the region and carried out economic exploitation of the gold-bearing wadis, as well as the building of royal cities in the area, was well
120
^
THUTMOSE
III
developed by the reign of Thutmose I . 1 7 1 T h e kings son and overseer of southern countries traveled back and forth between Egypt and Nubia on a circuit that characterized Egyptian foreign administration. He was assisted in his work by deputies (idnw) for Lower Nubia (Wawat) and Upper Nubia (Kush) and also by military commanders. In addition, local Nubian rulers were Egyptianized, no doubt by taking them to Egypt (shown in the tomb of Ineni, Theban tomb 81, reign of Thutmose II) and then returning them to rule as part of the royal administration. Their local power may well have been bolstered by their association with Egypt, and their willingness to participate was therefore probably real. These chiefs, two of whom (Djehutyhotep and his son Amenemhet) are known from the reign of Thutmose III at the site of Tehkhet (Debeira), were buried in a N e w Kingdom style tomb with Egyptian paintings on the wall. Djehutyhotep was the son of the last chief of Tehkhet, Ruiu, and thus this area had been brought under Egyptian influence early in the dynasty. 1 7 2 Concerning the kings sons and overseers of southern country for the reign there has been long discussion by scholars because the order and length of service of most of the officeholders are uncertain. Although Habachi believed that the first viceroy of the reign was Inebny (or Ini(anti), followed by Amen-em-nekhu, then Nehy, the most recent work has shown that only a few facts are certain. An unknown viceroy, whose name has been entirely erased, was in office in year 2; Amen-em-nekhu is known from year 18; a man whose named begins In[. . .] was overseer of southern countries in year 20; and Nehy is solidly dated in years 23 and 2 5 . 1 7 3 As Dziobek concluded, there are several viceroys from the coregency period, and it is obvious that the erasure of names suggests intense competition, exacerbated by the distance of the activity from Thebes or Memphis. O f the men named, only Nehy, who was in office in the sole rule of Thutmose III, was known to have left a tomb in Thebes. This same man left numerous monuments in Nubia and was responsible for building the city of Aniba, or Miam, which became the administrative center of Lower Egypt. His name and titles dedicated the storage magazine at that site, and he was known to have been active at major Nubian temple sites, including Buhen and Semneh and even as far south as Sai Island near the Third Cataract. At Qasr Ibrim he inscribed a grotto as a dedication from Thutmose III and himself to Horus of Miam. Despite the dearth of certain evidence about the various viceroys and the length of their service, the inscriptions from Nubia (with erasures) and the private tombs in Thebes attest to the regular arrival of Nubian deliveries at the royal house—during the coregency as well as the sole reign. T h e Annals of Thutmose III likewise show that yearly revenues were brought to Egypt from N u bia from years 31 to 42 (excepting 32).
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III
THE MILITARY
^
103
ADMINISTRATION
With the onset of the New Kingdom, Egypt entered a phase that is often termed imperial. A veritable ancient form of "Manifest Destiny" emerged in the ideology of royal inscriptions, where the pharaohs campaigns to overtake city-states in Palestine or to quell the forces of the Kushite ruler of Nubia were explained as "extending the borders of Egypt" As a recent work has noted, this expansion was always legitimized by reference to the foreigners as rebels against the king (and therefore the gods). 1 7 4 Nonetheless, this new approach to the external world necessitated a large standing army, and such quickly sprang into existence out of the forms already current at the end of the Second Intermediate period and influenced considerably by the forms of warfare current in the Near East. For example, the highest officers were called overseers of the army, a title of some antiquity. Commanders of troops were in charge of simple units of bowmen. The introduction of the chariot into the ancient world was changing the technology of war at this time, and one impact on Egypt was the rise of an equestrian elite that could keep and train horses for the chariotry.Thutmose I l l s own son, Amenhotep II, was such an athlete before succeeding his father, and his skills with horses and on the chariot are legendary. The appearance of an office, overseer of horses, is one index of this new development, and there are titleholders known from the reign of Thutmose III. Another feature of the military in the New Kingdom was bureaucratization—something characteristic of ancient Egypt in all periods. Scribes accompanied the army on its marches, keeping records of the skirmishes and, more importantly, keeping count of the soldiers. Other scribes registered the conscription of men into the military, and still others kept detailed accounts of the provisions allotted and distributed, as pictured in the tomb of Userhet in the reign of Amenhotep II (Theban tomb 56). 1 7 5
O V E R S E E R OF T H E
ARMY
The men known to have been overseers of the army in the reign of Thutmose III are few, and it is difficult, if not irrelevant, to suggest a chronological ordering of them. Indeed, all three holders of this office have different collateral functions and may have served in different capacities.The most famous overseer of the army is Djehuty, whose military exploits were celebrated in later times by the creation of stories about his craftiness. The New Kingdom tale about the "Taking of Joppa" includes an episode similar to that of Ali Baba (and the Trojan horse), wherein Djehuty hides two hundred soldiers in baskets, which are carried into the town as peace offerings. The taking of the city was thus accomplished through Djehuty s cleverness. 176
122^T H U T M O S E
III
Although Djehuty s tomb has been lost, objects in his name have provided a list of his titles, including overseer of northern countries and overseer of a garrison (zw Y), as well as overseer of foreign countries and royal scribe. 1 7 7 The likelihood is that Djehutys tomb is in Saqqara, from which his canopic jars were said to derive. 178 Djehutys ranks indicate his military and administrative roles outside Egypt. In addition to leading some of the king s armies, Djehuty oversaw the delivery of revenues from Syria and Palestine back to Egypt in his role as overseer of northern countries, 179 and he also led a garrison placed in a city or cities in the same region. One title from an alabaster jar calls him "confidant of the king in the gods land," suggesting that he operated in the Lebanon on behalf of the ruler. 1 8 0 In view of the later tradition about Djehutys fame, the story of his burial related by Bonomi, that he was found encased in gold on his fingers, toes, and elsewhere, with gold bracelets and a heart scarab on a chain, may be true. Bonomi noted that the heart scarab had gone to Leiden, and indeed that is where Djehutys scarab i s . 1 8 1 T h e mayor of Thinis and the western oasis, Min, was also termed "overseer of the army of the western river and chief and overseer of the south." There does not appear to be another instance of this first rank, and the "western river" cannot be certainly identified. It has been equated with the Canopic branch of the Nile and also with the region of Lake Mariotis, which was fed by that branch in ancient times. 1 8 2 This would have been far from the area of Mins major oversight—Thinis and the oases—but there is little evidence to improve upon the suggestion. Given Mins other rank as chief and overseer in the south, it may be that his military activity was directed toward the western oases. Perhaps the research of John Darnell in the western desert areas north of Luxor will shed light on the military activity there after the beginning of the New Kingdom, as well as before. 1 8 3 A third man who held the title of overseer of the army was Tjanuny, owner of Theban tomb 74, who died in the reign of Thutmose I V In the reign of Thutmose III, he was already very active in the army. According to Tjanuny s autobiography he recorded the kings actions in the field: "I it is who established the victories which he performed in every foreign country, having made in writing according to what was done." In this instance he referred to his primary office of "scribe of the army." In front of Thutmose I V he was shown presenting dignitaries from the northern countries, and in that instance he was termed "overseer of the army, scribe of recruits (nfrw)" He was called overseer of the army of the king in an offering formula, but more often he was termed "overseer of the scribes of the army." We remain uncertain whether Tjanuny ever led soldiers, as we suppose Djehuty did; indeed, if we are to conclude anything from his autobiography, he did not.
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III
^
105
However, he was highly valued during the reigns of three rulers. Schulman has concluded that this title did not have specific functions associated with it but indicated a "military officer" generally. More recently Gnirs has suggested that this office and that of "chief overseer of the army" both indicated the army commander and that, in addition, the position "overseer of the menfyt" was a variant of it. Given the scarcity of our evidence, it would be prudent not to suggest more than that the rank here was indeed a high one, as indicated by the other protocols of these three men. 1 8 4 Amenmose, owner of Theban tomb 42, held the lofty position of chief of bowmen, as well as "the one relating to the king in the two lands of Retenu" and "overseer of northern countries," the last a rank also held by Djehuty. Whether Djehuty preceded Amenmose in this last office is unknown. The taking of a fortress in Syria is depicted on the walls of his tomb, as is the presentation of northern tribute that includes Amenmose offering to Thutmose III. 1 8 5 This last scene may well be a function of his position as overseer of northern countries, which, like that of overseer of southern countries, included the supervision of revenue deliveries to Egypt. Amenmose names Amenhotep II in his tomb, although the ruler appearing there was probably Thutmose III. Like Djehuty, Amenmose appears to have been a regular army officer on whom the burden of administration was placed. A chief of bowmen, Nebamun, ownedTheban tomb 145, which was only recently published posthumously by Helck. 1 8 6 The tomb was photographed in the 1940s and visited in 1956, but it was found to be entirely destroyed in 1990. According to Helck the tomb dated to the end of the reign of Thutmose III. Thutmose Ills campaigns in Palestine and Syria were of great significance in his time and later, and the men who participated in those expeditions were aware of the historical moment of which they were a part. Several, for example, were with the king when he crossed the Euphrates River in Syria—referred to as the "great bend." Amenemheb (called Mahu), Iamnedjeh, Montu-iywy, and Minmose all reported the event on their monuments, and all returned to Egypt to be given significant roles at home. Amenemheb, perhaps more the pure warrior than the others, remained as adjutant of the army until his death, but he also served as a crew member of the divine boat of Karnak "Amun-Userhet." 187 His tomb bears a detailed text about the movements of the royal army in Syria during the eighth campaign, and it is clear that Amenemheb was a soldier who fought alongside the ruler, hand to hand, and captured the elite mariannu chariot warriors in more than one instance. As one who was "related to the legs" of the king (common to the men who fought with Thutmose III and Amenhotep II), Amenemheb
124
^
THUTMOSE
III
stressed his loyalty to the sovereign and probably also his privileged position near the king. Amenemheb lived into the reign of Amenhotep II but probably only just. Pehsuker, owner of Theban tomb 88, held similar titles (although he was also a chief of bowmen) and died in the reign of Amenhotep II, who appears in his tomb. He was, like Amenemheb, an adjutant of the army, but he was also a fan bearer for the lord of the two lands. Intentional structural and decorative similarities between Amenemheb s and Pehsuker s tombs have recently been discussed. 188 T h e soldier Dedi, owner of Theban tomb zoo, fought in the Syrian wars with Thutmose III as well. He received the gold lion award with flies, as did his colleague Suemniwet, chief of stables and later royal butler and owner of Theban tomb 9z. Dedi had the title of chief of the companies (sjw) of the Great House (or pharaoh) and was also termed "valiant one of the menfyt "1S9 Men with military titles of a slightly lower level included Nebenkemet, chief of the stables. He was also a fan bearer and died in the reign of Amenhotep I I . 1 9 0 One Maienhekaw left several stelae that record his role as a weapon bearer for Menkheperre, a chief of the warship, fan bearer of the imu warship, and fan bearer for "Amehotep, the antelope," apparently the name of a ship. 1 9 1 One Intef, owner of Theban tomb 164, was a scribe of recruits in this period, probably operating at the same time as Tjanuny, who, however, rose in the ranks. 1 9 2 One Neferkhat was the owner of a stela showing Thutmose III offering before Amun-Re. On the stela Neferkhat is termed chief (W) of the Medjay, but he also claimed to have followed his lord on his marches in the northern and southern countries. Neferkhat, like Djehuty and Amenmose, claimed the title overseer of foreign countries, and he also had a son who assumed his fathers position of chief of police—or Medjay. Menkheperreseneb left a statue of himself on which he is termed overseer of foreign countries and chief of the Medjay, as well as a chief of stables of the lord of the two lands and overseer of hunters. Since he also claimed to have been "chief of the followers of his majesty when he was an inpu" Menkheperreseneb may well have served both Thutmose III and his son Amenhotep II. That he served the older king is suggested by his claim to be "one whose youth happened at the place where the god is, one whom the lord of the cult act instructed because he was effective to the heart." 1 9 3 T h e role of chief of the Medjay was assigned to Dedi, who had fought with Thutmose III in Syria and received the gold lion award. It is likely that Dedi s achievements in warfare earned him both the position of chief of the military phyles of the Great House, a function discussed earlier, and that of overseer of the desert on the west of Thebes. As chief of the Medjay, Dedi was responsible for policing the cemeteries of western Thebes
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III
^
107
and probably the accesses to them from the west. An unnamed chief (hry) of the Medjay of Coptos, overseer of the gold lands of Coptos, and overseer of hunters appears in the tomb of the high priest Menkheperreseneb, owner of Theban tomb 86. 1 9 4 It remains unclear whether the territory policed by Neferkhat and Menkheperreseneb was greater than that secured by Dedi and this anonymous functionary for the Coptite region. Both the cemetery areas of Thebes and the Wadi Hammammat access to the eastern gold lands would have demanded particular attention.
RELIGIOUS
ADMINISTRATION
Without a doubt the temple administration for the estate of Amun showed enormous growth through the coregency period and the sole reign of Thutmose I I I . 1 9 5 Monuments in the name of temple functionaries, as well as tombs in Thebes, attest to this burgeoning priesthood, and it is both men and women whose titles are more heavily attested in the period. From an absence of certainly identified high priests of Amun for the reigns of Thutmose I and II, the reign of Hatshepsut begins with the activity of Hapuseneb as first hem priest already evident. 196 Thutmose II is mentioned on one of his statues, and he claimed to have overseen the temple built at Karnak for Hatshepsut and Thutmose II together, although this may have been after the kings death. 1 9 7 Hapuseneb came from a well-connected family, his father having been a third lector priest of Amun and his mother a khekret nesu, or court lady. Hapuseneb left a tomb in Thebes (Theban tomb 67) in which he represented the felling of trees in Punt, alluding to his involvement in the great diplomatic mission sent to that southern locale. Hapuseneb participated in the construction of Hatshepsut s Valley of the Kings tomb and also directed a variety of works in Karnak. T h e overseer of the gold and silver houses (Djehuty) and Hapuseneb were involved with the production of a number of the same monuments. In this case Hapuseneb should be understood to have been principally responsible for the construction, while Djehuty was responsible for the valuable materials used. 1 9 8 He was the first high priest of Amun to also hold the title of overseer of hem priests of Upper and Lower Egypt, a title that remained with the high priests through the Twentieth Dynasty. In his complete involvement in the Amun cult, Hapuseneb administered both the staff and the property of the temple, including the cattle of Amun. On one statue, which contains the longest list of titles he held, Hapuseneb claimed the position of overseer of the city and vizier. It has already been noted that this may well have coincided with Useramuns tenure as vizier and could have been more of an honorific title than a true one. It was coupled in the inscription with overseer of the temples. 1 9 9 Hapuseneb
126
^
thutmose
iii
mentioned only Hatshepsut in his tomb and probably predeceased the queen. 200 His immediate successor may not be known to us, but the next identified high priest was named Menkheperreseneb, owner of either Theban tomb 86 or 112. It was long assumed that a high priest of Amun named Menkheperreseneb had two tombs in Thebes, numbers 86 and 112, and that the latter was constructed first. Peter Dorman has argued, however, on the basis of the genealogies from these tombs, that there were two men with the same name and that the earlier high priest, Menkheperreseneb, owner of tomb 86, held office until a point late in the reign of Thutmose III (having begun at an unknown time) and that he was succeeded by his nephew, also named Menkheperreseneb. 201 While Dorman has persuasively demonstrated the existence of two men named Menkheperreseneb, which man served first remains somewhat uncertain. The genealogy's crux is the identification of the mother of Menkheperreseneb from tomb 86, the "sister of nursing of the king," Nebetta with the grandmother of Menkheperreseneb from tomb 112, called once simply Nebetta and once, apparently, mistress of the house. 202 Since the name Nebetta is not uncommon in this period, (Thutmose III himself was married to a woman of that name) perhaps caution should be given, since the style of tomb 112 does indeed, as Davies thought, appear to be earlier than that of tomb 86. Tomb 112 is a limestone relief one, typical of tombs of the earlier part of the dynasty, and it should be noted that the only monuments named in the tomb include both Djeser Djeseru, the temple of Hatshepsut, and Henketankh, the temple of Thutmose III. The later Djeser Akhet does not appear. The Menkheperreseneb of tomb 86 participated in the building of monuments in Karnak, particularly carrying the designation of overseer of works in "Amun who lifts up the crowns of Menkheperre," perhaps the king s granite naos in the heart of the temple, 203 and he held the title of overseer of the silver and gold houses, one presumes for the temple. He was also a chief of secrets for the two ladies, as well as overseer of the granaries for Amun and overseer of hem priests of Upper and Lower Egypt. These are largely titles well known for the later high priests of Amun, but it should be noted that the estates and buildings associated with the Amun temple were then expanding, so these titles may have been held first by Hapuseneb and one of the Menkheperresenebs. As Dorman has pointed out, the name of the temple of Djeser Akhet appeared in tomb 86, and he concluded that this suggests a date late in the reign of Thutmose III for the end of this Menkheperreseneb s tenure. 204 Os-
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III
^
109
traça referring to work there bear dates in years 43 and 44, but, as Dorman himself points out in another work, the temple of Djeser Akhet was a rebuilt form of an earlier Hatshepsut temple called Kha Akhet, and it was dedicated with the new name in the period of sole rule. It must remain open whether the temple of Djeser Akhet was entirely reconstructed by Thutmose III only in his late years or whether work had begun there earlier and then resumed. This would make the reference to Djeser Akhet in the first Menkheperresenebs tomb less diagnostic of a date for the high priests tenure. 205 Nonetheless, the mention of Syrian city-states, as well as the "great bend," or Euphrates River, implies that tomb 86 was decorated after the king s eighth campaign in year 33 and that Menkheperreseneb was in office at least that late in the reign. One might also point out that the high priest s name alone places his birth in the period of Thutmose I l l s rule. The second Menkheperreseneb, owner of Theban tomb 112, may have been the nephew of the high priest and owner of tomb 86 or he may have preceded him in office. His mother, Taiunet, the royal nurse, was married to the charioteer (snn) of his majesty Hepu. His titles included that of the high priest and also overseer of all hem priests of Upper and Lower Egypt. The second priest of Amun was the owner of Theban tomb 39, Puyemre, son of a dignitary named Puya. 2 0 6 Like others, Puyemre served both Hatshepsut and Thutmose III and successfully made the transition into the sole reign of the latter. On a statue from the temple of Mut, Puyemre spoke of overseeing construction of the ebony shrine of the queen, as well as [doors] of Tura limestone for that precinct. 207 The remains of Hatshepsut s limestone chapels in the Mut temple are still visible. At that early time in his career Puyemre was also overseer of the cattle and fields of Amun. In his tomb Puyemre showed his responsibilities with regard to receiving goods from the oases as well as booty from Nubia, including captives. The second priest of Amun frequently was involved in the royal constructions at Karnak, and Puyemre claimed that duty as well. In his tomb he appeared overseeing objects made for the temple and is addressed by the overseers of craftsmen of Karnak, as well as the overseers of works of the temple. The construction of two of the kings obelisks was also shown in the tomb— probably those erected soon after Hatshepsuts disappearance. Puyemre may have received the office of second priest by means of his marriage to a daughter of the high priest of Amun Hapuseneb, Seniseneb. That lady was the divine adoratrice of Amun and a temple singer as well, and she appears in the Gebel el-Silsila shrine of the high priest as well as in Theban tomb 39- 208 Seniseneb may have been the nonroyal woman whose job it was to enact the daily duties of the gods wife of Amun, a position held by
126 ^
thutmose
iii
several royal women during the reign. It is noteworthy that Puyemre had two wives, Seniseneb andTanefert, both of whom are shown with equal frequency through the tomb, normally one shown on either side of Puyemre. Puyemre may have been succeeded in his office by the owner of Theban tomb 86, Menkheperreseneb, later the high priest. T h e statue that would so identify him does not, however, bear a cartouche; nor are the mans parents named. T h e next certainly identified second priest of Amun in Karnak was Amenhotep Si-Se, whose tomb was built in the reign of Thutmose IV, although he may have served in the rank earlier. 209 A number of the duties associated with the second priest, namely, the oversight of temple constructions and related functions, were perhaps carried out by Menkheperreseneb as high priest of Amun. Several other men are known from the reign of Thutmose III with the title second priest of Amun. One was a son of Rekhmire named Neferhotep. That man appears in Theban tomb 100 offering perfume to his parents. T h e name is in an atenist mutilation and was originally reconstructed as Amenhotep by Sethe and later as Neferhotep by Davies. T h e title "second priest [of Amun]" is clear, however. 2 1 0 Kees expressed doubt that both this Neferhotep and a son of the vizier Useramun, Merimaat, were second priests of Amun in Karnak and felt that they may have rather functioned at Deir el-Bahari. 2 1 1 T h e same suggestion was applied to the second priest of Amun Mahu, who appeared in the tomb of Pehsuker, Theban tomb 88, as well as the second priest of Amun Ahmose, known from a statue in Copenhagen. 2 1 2 One Kaemheryibsen, owner of Theban tomb 98, was the third priest of A m u n . 2 1 3 He was the son of a royal nurse, Amenemipet, and was married to the royal ornament and singer of Amun Henuttawy. Van Sielen has argued that he was a brother, by one Nebiry and Amenemipet, to the great royal steward and steward of Amun under Amenhotep II, Kenamun. A fourth priest of Amun, Kaemamun, is known from a statue in the Louvre but cannot conclusively be associated with Karnak rather than the mortuary temple. 2 1 4 His son, Aakheperkareseneb, was the second priest of Thutmose III, but Puyemre also had sons who officiated in the mortuary temple of Henketankh.The same was true of Hapuseneb s son, who served in the mortuary temple of Thutmose I. Indeed, Kees made the point that the mortuary temple cults provided support for many family members of the elites in the Eighteenth Dynasty. 2 1 5 Other offices in the temple of Amun included the position of first king s son of Amun, held at this period by one Ahmose. This man left a statue, now in Brooklyn, 2 1 6 that records the fact that Hatshepsut (name replaced with that of Thutmose I) and Thutmose III awarded him with a gold-handled
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III
^
129
staff of electrum "[against] old age in the temple of Amun-Re" Ahmose also held the priestly title of pure priest and overseer of hem priests of Min of Coptos. In his role as first royal son of Amun, Ahmose may have substituted for the king during festivals at K a r n a k . 2 1 7 T h e grandson of a first royal son of Amun, one Amenhotep, also held positions in the temple of Amun as overseer of the lands of Amun, of the guardians (or tenants, khenty-she) of Amun, and of the granaries and serfs of Amun. He also acted as mortuary priest to Amenhotep I, Thutmose I, and Thutmose I I I . 2 1 8 Important administrative roles in the temple of Amun included the stewardship, well known to have been held by Senenmut, discussed earlier as royal steward.The stewardship of Amun was Senenmuts primary title through the coregency period, and he also held the positions of overseer of the granary of Amun and overseer of the fields and cattle, along with a number of other designations relating to the people and property of the temple. Senenmut was succeeded by one Roau, whose tomb in Thebes was a gift of the king founded at the same time as Djeser Akhet, apparently some years into the sole reign of Thutmose III, if not later. 2 1 9 One Sen-Djehuty, known from a statue found in the Karnak Temple of Ptah, included the titles of both steward of the temple of Amun and overseer of the granary of A m u n . 2 2 0 It is likely that Sen-Djehuty followed Roau in the office, since the latter was known to have been a contemporary of Senenmut. T h e high priest Amenemhet, owner of Theban tomb 97 and successor to one of the Menkheperresenebs, also listed the title steward of the temple of Amun as his function. Whether this was during the reign of Thutmose III or Amenhotep II, in concert with his pontificate, is unknown. 2 2 1 On a statue the overseer of the seal Sennefri was given the title of steward of Amun, but the title does not occur in his tomb, Theban tomb 99: 2 2 2 A contemporary of Senenmut, Duawynehhe, owner of Theban tomb 125, was the overseer of the workshops of Amun, while the royal steward Amenhotep, owner of Theban tomb 73, was an overseer of cattle of Amun and an overseer of the erection of obelisks in Karnak. 2 2 3 Minnakht, the overseer of granaries for Upper and Lower Egypt, also bore the title overseer of granaries of Amun in the northern region, as well as chief of serfs of Amun and overseer of the storehouse of A m u n . 2 2 4 T h e shared nature of the royal house, the central offices, and the temple of Amun regularly confronts us as we attempt to understand the workings of the administration. It appears that the men who operated across these borders attempted to relate their functions to the appropriate economic source, under whose seal work would have been done. It nonetheless remains obscure to us today. Another man who operated in the Karnak Temple was Amenemhet, owner of Theban tomb 53. He was a temple functionary (imy st~cf a gods father, and a pure priest. As a
126
^
thutmose
iii
career member of the temple personnel, Amenemhet left a tomb that mentions not the ruler but the god as his source of support. 2 2 5 The evidence for the temple of Amun so overwhelms the preserved documentation from ancient Egypt that it does not allow us a clear idea of how powerful vis-à-vis other cults Amun was in the mid—Eighteenth Dynasty. We do, however, know of a few men who served in other priesthoods. For example, one Sennefer, whose family was buried in Sedment, the cemetery to Heracleopolis, held both the title of "greatest of seers in Heliopolis," that is, the high priesthood of Re, and the position of "sem priest and greatest controller of craftsmen," that is, the high priesthood of Ptah in Memphis. The combination of both positions in the hand of a single man is exceptional, but we are ignorant of his means of access to the functions. The stela derived from Sennefer s son-in-law s family tomb at Sedment, where the high priests daughter, Sherit-Re, and her husband, the hem priest of Heryshef Nebnakht, as well as their son, the priest of Heryshef Amenmose, were buried. 226 A man named Ken was the high priest of Mut, mistress of Isheru, and mistress of the sky during the reign of Thutmose III. His tomb, Theban number 59, also showed his brothers, both of whom held titles that may have been related to the Mut temple. One Kenamun was the overseer of gold workers and sculptors, while Wesy was the overseer of the granary. 227 Nebwawy was high priest of Osiris during this period and into the reign of Amenhotep II. He was also the steward of the temple of Osiris and a hem priest of Heket. 2 2 8 On a stela that Nebwawy set up in Abydos, the priest begins by stating that Thutmose III had given him the monument as a royal gift, although he did not have it carved until after the death of the ruler. Among the things he claimed was the direction of works in the temple, using precious metals and stones, all of which were under his seal. He was promoted among the nobles of the king, and upon the death of Thutmose III Amenhotep II gave him a statue of the deceased king, as "an image of millions of years in the temple of the father Osiris, along with divine offerings, fields, and tenants." 229 It is interesting to see that the enrichment of Nebwawy within his own temple of employment was enhanced by the statue donation. This may have been the equivalent of providing priestly offices in the mortuary temples of Thebes—in both cases the appointee receives a designated share. Also known from the Osiris temple during the reign was the mayor Min, who was overseer of hem priests of Osiris, as well as the festival leader of Osiris. In nearby Thinis, he was overseer of hem priests for Onuris and steward of Onuris. 2 3 0 One Hekanefer, son of a royal nurse, was a scribe of the temple of Osiris. His sons, like many courtiers, were given a role in the mortuary temple, as pure priest of Thutmose III and of the first phyle in Henketankh. 231
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III
^
113
Iamnefer, mayor of Nefrusy in Middle Egypt, was also high priest of Thoth, as well as greatest of the five in the temple of Thoth and scribe of divine offerings of Thoth, lord of Khemenu (Eight-town). His wife, Meryt, was greatest of the entertainers of T h o t h . 2 3 2 Although the men and women listed here as temple personnel represent only a small fraction of those known to have functioned during the long reign of Thutmose III, they are nonetheless representative, particularly of what is known of the highest priestly offices. Like the civil administrators these officeholders came from both established and new families, Hapuseneb being an example of the former and Menkheperreseneb, owner of Theban tomb 112, of the latter. We may add to their number the men, such as the overseer of works Minmose, whose postmilitary role was to oversee Thutmose I l l s temple constructions throughout Egypt.
CONCLUSION
While some of Thutmose I l l s military cronies, such as Iamnedjeh, were suited to the inner workings of the palace itself, others were better placed at the peripheries. Men such as Minmose, the overseer of works, and Neferperet, whom the king made a royal tutor and royal butler, were certainly welcome at court, but they did not serve in the royal house (per nesu) directly. Others, such as Amenemheb Mahu and Pehsuker, never left the military sector, but their court connections were secure and cemented through their wives, who were royal nurses. Over the course of the sole reign of Thutmose III, the various spheres of administration appear to have been regularly supplemented by the former war companions of the king. There is little to suggest yet, however, that that group of veterans filled many of the traditional ranks of the country, including the vizier, the overseer of the seal, overseer of the granary, or high priest of Amun. Indeed, Thutmose III was able to utilize the expertise of a professional bureaucracy to enable a smooth transition to sole rule and—even more extraordinary—was capable of leaving the country each year without fear of instability. Thanks to the obvious promotion of the vizierate at this time—regardless of when its rules as expressed in the Duties of the Vizier were composed—Useramun and Rekhmire provided a continuity and atmosphere of just order that was echoed in the aims of all the magnates of the time. T h e charge was to do things correctly, and men such as Intef, Iamnedjeh, Sennefri, and Djehuty vied with each other to do so. Thanks to the revenues coming into Egypt from Thutmose s campaigns, support was possible for the many who were available. Although we do not know the size of the several administrations during the period immediately before Thutmose I l l s accession, the documentation increases so
thutmose
iii
greatly that it must be due to a new affluence and consequent burgeoning of the bureaucracy. Although they are only the most visible proof of the governments activity, monuments in stunning numbers echo the many men who directed their construction for the king. Likewise the individual monuments of officeholders throughout the country bespeak a healthy traditional government vitalized by an influx of new men from the former military ranks.
NOTES
—
1. Martin-Pardey (1995) 269—85. J. J. Shirley has completed a dissertation on the administration of Thutmose III and Amenhotep II, focusing on the means by which offices moved through time. I wish to thank her for pointing out several errors in my first draft. Any remaining mistakes are solely my own. 2. Dziobek (1995) 135. 3. In a few instances the name of Hatshepsut was erased in the tombs. In fact, it is quite possible that in the case of Hapuseneb and Senemiah the cartouche erasures could have dated to the end of the reign, when the general proscription went on; see ibid., 134. 4. Helck (1958) 17—44; v a n den B o o r n (1988); Gessler-Löhr (1995) 133—57. 5. Dziobek (1994) 86. 6. Urk. IV1105.7—9. The Duties are summarized here, often with a literal rendering of the text which is unclear in meaning. The section numbers follow van den Boorn. The conclusions made here about the functions of the vizier do not entirely agree with van den Boorns assessment (1988). 7. Sec. 2. The punctual sealing and opening of the locked enclosures (khetmu) were reported to him; the condition of the southern and northern fortresses was reported to him. Everything that left or entered the per nesu was reported to him. The overseer of police, policemen, and overseers of the district reported conditions to him. Sec. 3. The vizier comes before the king daily to report the condition of the two lands. The overseer of the seal informs the vizier that all affairs of the palace are sound, and the vizier tells the overseer of the seal that the locked enclosures have all been closed and opened on time. Then the vizier has the doors of the per nesu opened to allowed things to enter and leave. Sec. 4. The vizier punishes all officials of the bureaus (khaw). They cannot be judged within their offices. Sec. 5. His message is the priority of any official to whom it is sent. It takes the mayors and estate leaders to the 'aryt. The messenger cannot be forced to prostrate himself. Sec. 6. The vizier questions officials and finds them culpable such that their names are placed on a register in the Great Prison, where they can be found if they commit additional offenses. Sec. 8. Petitioners whose requests involve land are summoned directly to the vizier, who also consults the overseer of fields and the council of the mat. Otherwise messengers go to the petitioners as agents of the vizier. Sec. 9. The vizier brings the councillors of the district (kenbetyu w) to report their condition. Every imyt-per (transfer deed or will) is brought to him, and he seals it. Sec. 10. He allots shed fields for state service and inspects the documents assigning them when challenges are made. Sec. 11. Petitions of officials sent on mining expeditions must be reported to him in writing only, not by oral testimony.
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III
^
115
Sec. 12. The vizier sends the messengers of the per nesu to the mayors and estate leaders (hekau hut). He sends every circuit officer and every expedition of the per nesu. Sec. 13. He appoints members of the magistracy (nety em serut) in Upper and Lower Egypt and Thinis. They report to him every four months and bring their documents and those of their councils. Sec. 14. The vizier assembles a traveling army unit to escort the king north and south. He directs the remainder (of the army) to stay in Thebes in the residence according to what the king has ordered. He instructs the captain of the king s vessel, and likewise a council of the army to provide them with the protocols (tep red) of the army. Sec. 16. He sends [a contingent] to cut down sycamore trees on the king s command. He sends the councillors of the district to open canals throughout the whole land. He sends the mayors and estate leaders for cultivation and for the harvest (tax). Sec. 17. The vizier appoints the overseer of police in the office of the per nesu. He conducts a hearing of the mayors and estate leaders who represent him in Upper and Lower Egypt. Every legal matter is reported to him, as well as the condition of the fortress of the south [Elephantine?] and any arrest that concerns stealing. He redistributes the plunder of warfare in every town district (sepat). He judges the thief. Sec. 18. He sends the scribes of the mat to carry out the king s instructions, with written documents required for the hearings. He creates the boundaries of all domains, vegetable plots, divine offerings, and everything sealed. He enforces royal pronouncements (shed-ra). Sec. 19. He hears any complaint (?) when a man goes to court against a colleague. He selects anyone appointed to the "aryt. Anyone investigated in the per nesu comes to him. He hears every command. Col. R28.The vizier hears about the discontinuation of any divine offering. He provides food for anyone to whom it is given. Col. R29. He collects the deliveries of the gesu-per workshops. The great council reports to him its provisions of food in his presence. He hears the workshop (shena). Col. R30. He hears about the "arryt and everything offered to the "arryt. He opens the gold house together with the overseer of the seal. He inspects the revenue of the land. Col. 31. The vizier makes an inventory of all cattle to be counted. He oversees the drink supply(?) (Swrt) for every ten-day period. Col. 32. The deliveries (inu) of the mayors, estate leaders, and everyone are reported to him. The overseer of the district and every policeman report conflicts to him. Col. 33. [. . .] report to him by the month concerning the accuracy of deliveries . . . the rising of Sothis, the beginning of the inundation . . . Col. 34. He assigns ships to everyone to whomever they should be assigned. He sends [meaning uncertain] every messenger of the per nesu concerning . . . when the lord is on an expedition. He . . . Col. 35. Every council of the front and the rear of the fleet reports to him. He seals every decree of . . . Col. 36. . . . a doorkeeper of the "arryt reports to him. 8. Van den Boorn (1988: 182) believes the vizier only dealt with imyt pers of a "public" nature; however, the text does not support this view. 9. Van den Boorn, who argues for the physical existence of the "royal house" (ibid.: 67), has a hypothetical drawing of the complex, while Martin-Pardey (1995: 269—85) argues that it should not be understood as a royal household or palace but rather as the abstracted "administrative apparatus." 10. Van den Boorn (1988) 276; ntf sdm %vd nb. 11. Urk. IV379.15—21.
126 ^
thutmose
iii
12. Ibid., 489—94. 13. Ibid., 1384, from the papyrus Turin i.The appointment text from the tomb is undated and is lengthier (1380—83). 14. For the year 28 date in tomb T T 82 of Amenemhet, scribe of the vizier, see Urk. IV1043. For suggestive evidence, see Dziobek (1994) 100. For the year 34 date for Rekhmire, see Megally (1977) 245, 278—79. 15. Dziobek (1995) 137 (line 31 of the text). This text bears much in common with the "Installation of the Vizier," being more concerned with the morality of the office and its association with righting wrong. It uses the same formula, "Behold you are one who . . " that appears in the installation text in the tomb of Rekhmire. Cf. Dziobek (1994), pi. 82; and Urk. IV1090—91.13. 16. Giddy (1980) 119—25. 17. Dziobek (1994) 80—83. 18. Urk. IV1046. 19. Ibid., 1048. This is an apparent reference to the version of the Amduat written on the walls of Thutmose I l l s burial chamber. 20. The family is named in Whale (1989) 55—58. See also Helck (1958) 436—37 and plates. 21. Helck (1958) 131—35, 437—38 and plates. 22. Ibid., 131—32 and 287, n. 112. 23. Megally (1977) 220—25. 24. Urk. IV1151. 25. Ibid., 1154. 26. Ibid., 1140, 1145. 27* Gessler-Löhr (1995) X33—57Î Brussels Royal Museum E7333, P M III 2 , 865; Museum of Fine Arts Boston 29.728, P M VIII part 2, 517. 28. Urk. IV1376, Cairo J E 38336. 29. Gessler-Löhr (1995) 133—57, Leiden A M 1; a palette in Louvre N 3026, P M III 2 , 773; a cubit rod in Leiden, A D 54, P M III 2 , 774. 30. Likewise, see Murnane (1998) 201—2; and Zivie (1988) 27—28. 31. Urk. IV354, from Deir el-Bahari. 32. Van den Boorn (1988) 61—62. See also Helck (1958) 77—88 for the office; and 345—52 for the officeholders. 33. Van den Boorn (1988) 62 and n. 42. 34. Murnane (1998:182—83) rejects the view that the overseer of the seal was the treasurer and sees him as only an official of the royal household. 35. Urk. IV530. 36. See also van den Boorn (1988) 361. 37. Bryan (1991) 245—46; Spiegelberg (1928) 105—15; Helck (1958) 82. 38. Urk. IV32-39; Helck (1958) 466. 39. Urk. IV34. 40. From British Museum, EA 174. Dorman (1988) 171, 207, 212. 41. See notes 31—32 in this chapter. 42. Zivie (1984) 245—52. 43. Urk. IV419. 44. Habachi (1957) 88—104. 45. Ibid., 99—100; Vandersleyen (1995a) 281—82. 46. Louvre 3230b; Wente (1990) 92; Peet (1926) 70—72. 47. Urk. IV886-89.
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III
^
48. Ibid., 528. The date of the functioning of Sennefri here follows Megally (1977) 274—75, and Dziobek (1994) 100, contra Helck (1981b) 39—41. 49. Bietak (1980) 63. 50. Urk. IY536 (festival leader for Atum), 541 (festival leader for all gods of Heliopolis), 530 (festival leader for southern Heliopolis). 51. Polz (1990) 43—60. 52. Urk. IV530—31. 53. Ibid., 546. 54. Van den Boorn (1988: 99—106) discusses the mayors and documents of the period in which they are attested. 55. Urk. IV587 (year 33 text); 548. 56. P M I 2 ,1:205 (3) (5). 57. Urk. IV535. For the entire journey, see 532—36. 58. Ibid., 536-37. 59. Ibid., 536, 540, 541, 542. 60. Ibid., 540, 546, 547. 61. Ibid., 1027—29. 62. Bryan (1990) 82, with the discussion of the monuments of Min. 63. Following Megally (1977) 274—75. Cf. Caminos and James (1963) 35, 74. 64. Literature cited in Guksch (1995) 15 and n. 5—12. 65. Urk. IV1179.The suggestion that this is the same man known from the statue in Cairo, C G 42123, followed by Guksch, is unconvincing. That statue s inscription appears to name only a man named Djehuty, and the style of that statue makes it comfortable only in the early part of the reign, probably the beginning of the sole reign. See P M II 2 , 202. 66. See Guksch (1995), an excellent volume that tackles many of the difficulties of these tombs. 67. For the titles of Minnakht, see ibid., 17—19. 68. Urk. IV1184, 1190. See Wb III.360 for watery regions in the delta. 69. Megally (1977), esp. 113—32. 70. Urk. IV530.11—16. 71. Ibid., 1582. 72. Helck (1958) 81; Murnane (1998) 182-83. 73. Urk. IV1845,1841—42. In addition, the scribes accompanying Khaemhet represent both the royal household and the granary: the "scribe of counting grain for the lord of the two lands in Upper and Lower Egypt" and "the scribe of the granary of the Great House" are shown together. (1844). 74. The "great granary" is mentioned in Louvre 3026 as the delivery point for Rekhmire s grain. See n. 11 in this chapter; and Urk. IV1189. 75. Megally (1977) 274-78. 76. A statue in Leipzig, number 13; and a funerary papyrus, Louvre E 3074 (ibid., 276). 77. Megally (1977) 276—77; Bryan (1991) 255—57, citing also (in note 112) British Museum E A 35400, a glazed steatite statuette of one Tjununa, overseer of the cattle of Amun and of the temple of Menkheperre—possibly one of these two men named Tjenuna. 78. Texts at Urk. IV937—62,1370; Gnirs, Grothe, and Guksch (1997) 57—83; and Polz (1991) 281-91 (fig.). 79. Guksch (1995) 122—23. 80. Ibid., 123. 81. Helck (1958) 505—7.
135
126
^
thutmose
iii
82. Urk. IV1206. 83. Ibid., 513, 1026. On Amenemhet, see P M I 2 , 1:236—37. This man was also "one who inscribes all people without exempting one." 84. Section R30 of the "Duties" Van den Boorn (1988) 62. See also 361—62 for the opinion that the "treasury" was the pr~} "house of silver," despite citations of the title overseer of the gold and silver houses. 85. Bryan (1991) 247—48, followed by Murnane (1998) 187 and n. 54. 86. Dorman (1988) 212, 206. 87. Urk. IV421. 88. Ibid., 429. 89. Ibid., 436. 90. Ibid., 412. 91. Ibid., 512—15. 92. Ibid., 1372—73. See also Shore (1969—70) 151—53. 93. Urk. IV937—62, esp. 953—55. 94. Van den Boorn (1985) 1—25. 95. After Lichtheim (1975) 67, slightly amending the translation. 96. Mr rwyt sdmt wV Urk. IV961. 97* Ibid., 410> 54^98. Van den Boorn (1988) 102, sec. 11. 99. Ibid., 82. 100. Urk. IV984, from Ibrim; P M VII, 81 (Aniba on jambs from a storage magazine), 93. 101. According to Helck (1958) 67. 102. Urk. IV1369. 103. Ibid., 1021. 104. Photographs of the statue, front and rear, are reproduced in Hornung and Bryan (2002) no. 11, 91—92. 105. Urk. IV1069; Spalinger (1984) 631—51. 106. Pardey (1997) 377—97. The viewpoint expressed here about the officeholders for the reign of Thutmose III does not always agree with that of Pardey. She considers this to be a more powerful position than I do. 107. Urk. IV940—41, 942. 108. Polz (1991) 281—91. 109. Pardey (1997) 377—97, esp. the statue mentioning the crossing of the Euphrates ( Urk. IV1370). no. P M I 2 , 1:263-65; Urk. IV963-75; Helck (1958) 67-68. in. Urk. IV968. 112. Ibid., 969. 113. Ibid., 966—67. 114. Van den Boorn (1988) 12—41 (for a session before the vizier), 55—76 (for the viziers reporting before the king each day); Helck (1958) 66. Cf. Schulman (1964) 38, 90. 115. Van den Boorn (1988) 218, 220, 226, sec. 14, R23—24. 116. Ibid., 974—75. 117. Helck (1958) 68-70; Urk. IV35, 528, 548, 452; P M I 2 , 1:227—28, 409—10. 118. Ibid., 1379—80. 119. On royal messengers in general, see Valloggia (1976). 120. Van den Boorn (1988: 89—96) discusses sections 9—13 of the Duties regarding the messenger. He concludes that this refers only to a viziers messenger, but the text states, "as
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III
^
119
for any messenger whom the vizier sends with a message to an official" In any case the immunity of the royal messenger would hardly have been less than that of the vizier. 121. Fischer-Elfert (1983); Redford (1992) 201—2. 122. This was Dedi, owner of Theban tomb 200. See P M I 2 , 1:303—4. 123. Otto (1975d) 846-47; Urk. IV323, 889. 124. Urk. IV325—26. 125. Ibid., 1378—79. 126. Ibid., 889. 127. Ibid., 995—96; Bryan (2000a) 74—75 [71—84]. 128. Van den Boorn (1988: 203—4) equates the "messenger of the royal house" of sections 21 and 34 with the "royal messenger." 129. On chief stewards, see the prosopographies in Helck (1958) 356—65. 130. Dorman (1991) 179; idem. (1988). 131. Urk. IV396-98. 132. Dorman (1991) 179. 133. Urk. IV404—5. For the "judge of the gate," see van den Boorn (1988) 80. 134. Urk. IV411. 135. Ibid., 412. 136. P M I 2 , 1:143-44. 137. Urk. IV394—95; Helck (1958) 364—65, with n. 1 on 365. 138. Urk. IV548. 139. On royal butlers, see Helck (1958) 269—76; and Schmitz (1986) 771—72. See also the important remarks on the varying ranks of butlers in Schulman (1976) 123—24. 140. Schmitz (1986) 771—72. 141. Urk. IV2177—78. 142. Van Sielen (1991) 156—60. 143. Urk. IV1466-68. 144. Ibid., 1449—52. The tomb has been prepared for publication by this author. 145. On the children of the kap} see Feucht (1995) 272—308. Pages 272—76 list the officeholders under Thutmose III. Although some references were missed with regard to the periods of Thutmose I V and Amenhotep III, in general this is a useful overview of the literature. See also Feucht (1985) 38—47. 146. De Linage (1939) 217—34, pis. X X I V — X X V 147. See Bryan (forthcoming) for a discussion of the petitions context; and the remarks in Spalinger (1984). 148. See, most recently, Feucht (1995) 268. There is no room in the text s gaps to provide for granting freedom to the slave. See Bakir (1953) 48—52 (on the formula for emancipation, including New Kingdom examples), 82—87 (on slave marriage and ownership of property). 149. On royal nurses, see Roehrig (1990a). 150. Loyrette (1992) 131—40. 151. Cairo J E 27815, in Urk. IV1065—70. See also Spalinger (1984) 631—51. 152. Urk. IV34. 153. Dorman (1988) 124—26, 170—71; Helck (1958) 478. On Theban tomb 252 for Senimen, see P M I 2 , 1:337. 154. Urk. IV976-81. 155. P M I 2 i, 325. 156. Ibid., 1447. See Bryan (1991) 46—49 for a discussion of the dating of these princes. 157. Urk. IV1373—74.
126 ^
thutmose
iii
158. Cairo JE 56264, P M II 2 , 371, from Deir el-Bahari. 159. CG 34080, Lacau (1909), pl. xl, 127—29. 160. CG 34117, ibid. For Sitamun, see P M II 2 261, pl. liii, 169. 161. Urk. IV913 (list of titles, including those shown here bracketed), 920—22. 162. P M I 2 I, 192; Urk. IV1395—96. Pehsuker appears in the same scene. 163. Urk. IV1460. 164. Generally, see Helck (1958) 220—25. 165. Van den Boorn (1988) 243. 166. Urk. IV124—25. Van den Boorn (1988: 106—7) discusses the administration of Esna and Elkab under Pahery, although he followed von Beckerath in dating that tomb to Thutmose I. This view would hardly be followed today, for stylistically the tomb is entirely of the time of Thutmose III. 167. PM I2,1:34—35. Theban tomb 20 is afinelimestone relief tomb in Dira Abu en-Naga. 168. Iamnefer s family is being studied by J. J. Shirley as part of a doctoral dissertation, completed in 2005. Preliminary results were reported at the ARCE annual meeting in Chicago in April 1999. See also Urk. IV1453—55. See Dorman (1988) 217 re the participation in the Sed Festival. 169. Bryan (1991) 103—5, with literature cited. 170. Gessler-Löhr (1997) 34—37; Van Sielen (1991) 156—60. 171. Generally, see Habachi (1981) 630—40. W.V Davies, Keeper of Egyptian Antiquities at the British Museum, will publish new inscriptions of this early period that he recently discovered in the Kawa region. 172. Säve-Söderbergh (1991) 186—94. See also Morkot (1991) 199. Cf. the view of Vandersleyen (1995a: 311). 173. Dziobek (1993) 29—32; El-Sabbahy (1992) 99—102; Pamminger (1992) 97—100; Weinstein (1978) 39—42; I, Müller (1982) 465—70; Dewachter (1976) 151—53; Habachi (1961) 210—25. 174. Galan (1995). 175. Beinlich-Seeber and Shedid (1987). 176. Wente (1972) 81—84. 177. Urk. IV999—1002. See the objects in the excellent catalog edited by Eggebrecht and Eggebrecht (1987: 120 [dagger], 338—44). 178. Eggebrecht and Eggebrecht (1987) 344; Reeves (1993) 259—61. British Museum EA 71492 suggests an association with the burial of Djehuty, which was brought to light by local inhabitants at Saqqara in 1824. 179. Murnane (1997a) 251—58. 180. Urk. IV1000; Eggebrecht and Eggebrecht (1987) 340. 181. Reeves (1993) 260; Eggebrecht and Eggebrecht (1987) 344. 182. Hannig (1995) 1315; Helck (1958) 231. 183. See, for example, Darnell and Darnell (1997) 241—58. 184. Schulman (1964) 41—44; Gnirs (1996). 185. Davies (1933). For titles, see pi. 39. 186. Helck (1996) 73-85. 187. Urk. IV895-905. 188. Ibid., 1459—63; Manuelian (1987) 122; Gnirs, Grothe, and Guksch (1997) 57—83. 189. Urk. IV995—96. 190. P M I 2 , 1:340—41, Theban tomb 256. 191. A recent article that discusses all the monuments is Chevereau (1997) 9—28: Louvre C 59, Turin 1459, and a funerary cone in the Cairo Museum, as well as another stela known
Administration in the Reign of Thutmose III
^
from the antiquities trade in Paris. Chevereau concluded that the name Amenhotep-behes referred to the future king Amenhotep IL This may be the case, but it does not seem certain. 192. P M I 2 , 1:276-77. 193. Urk. IV993—94. 194. Ibid., 931; Davies (1933), pl. IX. 195. On religious administration in general, see Kees (1953). Most recently, Eichler (2000). 196. Bierbrier (1977) 1241—49; Kees (1953) 10—13; Helck (1977) 955—56, Eichler (2000), no. 433, p. 306. 197. Urk. IV474—76; Vandersleyen (1995a) 265—67, citing works by L. Gabolde on the monuments of Thutmose II. 198. Close reading of the texts of the two men makes this clear. See, for Hapuseneb, Urk. IV474—77; and for Djehuty 421—41. For Djehuty, Eichler (2000), no. 564, 327. 199. Helck (1958) 434; Urk. IV471—87, esp. 471—78. 200. Dziobek (1995) 133. 201. Dorman (1995:148—54) also discusses earlier proposals by Lefebvre and Davies. Eichler (2000), no. 260 ( T T 112); no. 261 ( T T 86), 279. 202. Davies (1933), pl. X I V (tomb 86), pis. X X I V X X V I (tomb 112). In plate X X V I , what appears as nbtpr may have been incorrectly copied for nbt but there is no sign of the snt n mn Y n nsw title. 203. Dorman (1995) 154, citing Barguet (1962) 316—17. See also Urk. IV932.14—933, 4: . . [called] Amun who raises the crowns of Menkheperre out of strong granite, from a single stone on each of its ways [?] w3t.[f nb], . . . worked with electrum, . . . with sandstone, worked with the best gold of the deserts . . . worked with gold." 204. Dorman (1995) 154. 205. Dorman (1988) 135—37. 206. See Urk. IV520—27, for his monuments. Eichler (2000), no. 225, 273. 207. Urk. IV520—21. 208. Caminos and James (1963), pi. 38; Davies (1922) pis. IX, LXII, L X I V 209. Dorman (1995) 151—52; Bryan (1991) 269 for Amenhotep Si-Se. 210. Urk. IV1168. Eichler (2000), no. 370, 296. 211. Kees (1953) 20, 23. 212. Urk. IV1460; Manuelian (1987) 107. The statue is Copenhagen A E I N 74. 213. Manuelian (1987) 108, citing literature; Van Sielen (1985—86) 87—91. Eichler (2000), no. 529, 321—22. 214. Louvre 10443, a family statue of limestone. See Kees (1953) 24. Eichler (2000), no. 527, 321. 215. Ibid., 13. For example, the son of the overseer of the granaries, Minnakht Menkheperreseneb, was himself overseer of the granaries and also pure priest of Amun in Henketankh; his son, Nebenmaat, was scribe of the temple in Henketankh. See Urk. IV1198—1201.The forthcoming publication of T T 72 by Peter Piccioni will deal with these priestly families. 216. Brooklyn 61.196. See James (1974) 77—78, pi. 47; and Sauneron (1968) 45—50. Eichler (2000), no. 014, 239. 217. Kees (1953) 21; Dewachter (1984) 83—94. 218. Habachi (1968) 51—56. Eichler (2000), no. 134, 259. 219. Dorman (1988) 178—79. Eichler (2000), no. 505, 317—18; no. 398, 301. 220. P M II 2 , 202, Cairo, C G 42123. Eichler (2000), no. 507, 318. 221. Urk. IV1412. 222. Helck (1958) 467.
139
126 ^
thutmose
iii
223. Urk. IV453—54, 460. Eichler (2000), no. 560, 326; no. 098, 253. 224. Urk. IV1177—90. The Amun titles are in the burial chamber. Eichler, no. 389, 299. 225. Urk. IV1217—25. Eichler, no. 045, 244. 226. The stela is J E 46993. See Hornung and Bryan (2002) 92—93 (entry by Elaine Sullivan, "Stela of Nebnakht and Family"). The J E number omits last digit. 227. P M I 2 , 1:120—21; unpublished personal notes from the tomb. 228. Urk. IV1494—96; Manuelian (1987) 107. 229. Urk. IV, 1495. 230. Ibid., 976—82. 231. Lacau (1909) C G 34117, of the royal nurse Nebetkabeny. 232. Urk. IV1454—55.
FOUR
Religion and Cult during the Time of Thutmose III LANA TROY
T
he wealth of empire that characterized the reign of Thutmose III generated an extensive range of material expressions of religiosity. This documentation, as it has survived, reveals some of the concerns of this period, providing an initial view of the development of New Kingdom religious thought. The comparatively sparse remains of earlier Eighteenth Dynasty reigns invites an interpretation of this period as innovative. While this may be true, a note of caution is in place, as new material may reveal unexpected, earlier contributions.1 This survey deals with the core elements of religious expression, as conveyed by the material dated to the reign of Thutmose III. A small number of monuments have been selected as representative of the period. The Festival Hall of Thutmose III and the Deir el-Bahari temple of Hatshepsut are obvious choices. Another important source is the bark chapel of Hatshepsut, while present work on the Deir el-Bahari temple of Thutmose III promises to contribute to our knowledge of the cult practices of the period. 2 Theoretical issues in the study of Egyptian religion have been set aside. The discussion regarding the emergence of the sun cult, and its possible implications, is well known through the work of Assmann. 3 The emphasis placed on this aspect of the period has to some extent overshadowed the interest it shows in traditional forms. The review that follows is somewhat simplistic in its emphasis on primary sources and the basic components of religious activities. It provides, however, in my view, a representative view of this period. The innovative forms of religious expression that emerge at this time are imaginative formulations of traditional concepts, indicating that above all the theologians
126 ^
thutmose
iii
of the middle Eighteenth Dynasty were firmly grounded in the accumulated corpus of ancient Egyptian religious expression.
T H E GODS AND GODDESSES
Amun-Re was the natural focus for royal cult activity during this period. 4 The name combination, as well as Amuns characteristic ithyphallic form, are documented as early as the Eleventh Dynasty. 5 By the Eighteenth Dynasty, "Amun-Min," is joined by the image of the striding or enthroned divine king. These two forms conveyed the god s double nature. The Min aspect comprised the concept of self-generating male fertility. The inclusion of a solar reference added cyclical renewal to this gods character. Amuns explicit dual nature is exemplified in the material of this period in, for example, the two forms found at Thutmose I l l s mortuary temple, Amun-Min, who resides in Henketankh, and Amun-Re-Kamutef. 6 Amun-Min was also connected to Horus. The god Horus-Min, the Victorious, is documented during the Middle Kingdom. In Coptos, Thutmose III is given the form of this god. 7 The solar aspect of Amun entailed a special connection to the theology of Heliopolis and to its gods, including Atum. 8 Amun became, within the context of the divine kingship, a Theban manifestation of Re. The conceptual unity of these two regional expressions of the kingship is illustrated by a hymn dated to the Second Intermediate period. 9 It is dedicated to Re, King of Upper and Lower Egypt, and to Min-Amun, Lord of Eternity, Maker of Forever. The god is "the one who made humankind and created animals, lord of that which is, creator of the tree of life, from whose eye all vegetation went forth. . . . He is the one who made that which is beneath and that which is above, . . . who crosses the heaven in peace . . . the maker of the gods who lifts up heaven and holds back the earth." To this is added Atum, "who made the common people, distinguished their characters . . . separated their colors, one from the other." The elevated creator described in these lines can, however, be reached through supplication, as he "listens to plea of the one who is in distress" and is "gracious when one calls to him." This imagery of the merciful creator is linked to that of the kingship, as the god receives royal insignia such as the Two Feathers, and the White Crown. He is the "Lord of Rays who makes light," who gives assistance to the one whom he loves, while consuming his enemy with fire. This hymn describes the deity as consisting of attributes found in the core identities of Amun and Min, Re and Atum. He is a primeval creator and cyclically self-renewing solar deity, active earthly progenitor, and divine ruler of the combined divine and mortal worlds.
Religion and Cult during the Time of Thutmose III
^
125
Hathor had a special status on the Theban west bank during this period. The connection between this goddess and the royal cult is found at Thebes from the Eleventh Dynasty, when she is depicted in the temple of Nebhepetre Mentuhotep as "Mistress of Dendera," a title often applied to this goddess in Thebes. 1 0 A cult of Hathor may have existed at Karnak during the Twelfth Dynasty, as suggested by a double statue of Senwosret I and Hathor, Chieftainess of Thebes. 1 1 The Hathor chapel of the Deir el-Bahari temple of Hatshepsut is the earliest known structure dedicated to that goddess on the west bank. 1 2 Depicted in the form of a cow, she is titled Hathor of Dendera, Chieftainness of Thebes. As the protective and nourishing mother, she is shown licking the queen, as the cow does her calf. 1 3 Cattle references are prominent in the accompanying texts, where Hathor is referred to as theTjenenet cow and Apis is theTjenen bull, "who engendered the heifers." 14 Anubis is also cited here as the "Lord of the Horned Ones, who resides in the land of the heifers." 15 The birth of Horus in the marshes is the underlying theme of these scenes. The goddess kisses the queen, "as I did for Horus in the nest at Chemmis." Hatshepsut, the child of the divine cow, is "my Horus of Gold." 1 6 Suckled by the divine cow, Hatshepsut receives the gifts of life and strength as well as the power of the transfigured Akhu. I 7 This theme is used to bring other goddesses into the role of protective and nourishing mother. Tefnut, Nut, Nephtys, Hathor, Satis, Anubis, Nekhbet, Wadjit, andTjenenet are among those goddesses cited as providing milk for the king. 1 8 This theme is also extended into the tomb decoration of Thutmose III, where the king is depicted suckling the tree goddess identified as Isis, which was also the name of his earthly mother. 19 The monuments of the west bank reflect the close relationship between Hathor and Amun. 2 0 The organization of the two cults confirms that they were perceived as a couple.The mortuary temple of Thutmose III maintained three cults, those of Amun, Hathor, and the king. As in the sun temples of the Fifth Dynasty, where priests of Re served in the cult of Hathor, 21 priests attached to the cult of Amun also attended to the cult of the goddess. 22 This appears to have been the case at Hatshepsuts Deir el-Bahari temple as well, as Senenu was high priest of Hathor s, as well as Amuns, cult in this temple. 23 Hathor was also a "diadem goddess." This term is used to cover those female deities that are identified with the royal crowns and their authority. The image of the uraeus as daughter of Re is associated with numerous goddesses, Hathor, Sakhmet, and Maat among them. In her twin manifestations as Hathor, "Chieftainess of Thebes," and Hathor, Mistress of Dendera, this goddess participated in the coronation, providing the queen with the crowns that symbolized her authority. 24
126 ^
thutmose
iii
Mut, Mistress of Isheru, gradually became the most important of the Theban diadem goddesses. There are indications that Mut was a solar variation of the vulture goddess Nekhbet. 25 The Double Crown characterizes the iconography of the goddess and signifies, as it does for Nekhbet, the hegemony of the south over the north. Mut is repeatedly treated as a variation of the uraeus, also manifested in the lioness form of Sakhmet. The inscription on a statue of Hapuseneb, the high priest of Amun under Hatshepsut, 26 addresses Mut, Mistress of Isheru, together with Sakhmet the Great, Mistress of the Two Lands, and Bastet, Mistress of Ankhtawy, a Memphite district. The text paraphrases the Middle Kingdom diadem hymn 2 7 and echoes a segment of the daily ritual used to appease the uraeus guarding the naos of the god. 28 The text ends as the goddess is asked to direct her wrath against enemies of the queen. Amaunet, depicted, like Mut, as the consort of Amun, displays characteristics suggesting that she was Muts northern counterpart. Amaunet is found in a number of ritual scenes from this time and with greater frequency than Mut. 2 9 This goddess is nominally the female counterpart of Amun, found in the Hermopolitan Ogdoad. 3 0 Her iconography, however, adds another dimension to the discussion of Muts role as a version of Nekhbet. Wearing the Red Crown, in contrast to the Double Crown of Mut, Amaunet forms a pair with Mut, creating a Theban variation of the Two Ladies. 31 The emergence of the cult of Mut is documented by statue inscriptions dated to this period. A statue of Senenmut refers to his supervision of the construction of Mut s Isheru temple and notes that he "lifted Hathor, Chieftainess of Thebes and Mut of Isheru, that he might make her appear, and he might raise her beauty." 32 This is taken as a reference to a bark procession in which Senenmut presumably carried the bark of either both goddesses or, considering the feminine singular of the text, one goddess comprising both Hathor and Mut. A parallel with the combined service of Amun and Hathor in the funerary temples of Hatshepsut and Thutmose III may have existed in the early years of Muts Karnak cult. A stela fragment from this period records that Mes was wab priest of the first phyle of the cult of Amun and of the first phyle of the cult of Mut. 3 3 Another example of the interest in the diadem goddess is the role given the lion-headed goddess Weret-Hekau, "Great of Magic." 3 4 Like Hathor, she participates in the coronation of Hatshepsut. 35 This goddess is highlighted in other contexts as well. In a text from the Pakhet sanctuary known as Speos Artemidos, 36 Weret-Hekau is the fire-breathing uraeus placed on the brow of the queen. Diadem goddesses were given special attention during this period with their characteristic attributes integrated into the presentation of female divin-
Religion and Cult during the Time of Thutmose III
^
127
ity. Hathor, Mut, Amaunet, and Weret-Hekau, as well as Wadjit, Sakhmet, and Maat all reflect a prototype that is recognized by the epithet "Daughter of Re ." The interest displayed in those female deities that conferred the authority of kingship was apt at a time when a Daughter of Re occupied the throne. The documentation from this period confirms an inclusive attitude toward the gods and cults of Egypt. Although the emphasis was on Amun-Re, as King of the Gods, the totality of the divine community of gods was brought into the sphere of royal patronage. Thoth, as record keeper, plays a distinctive role in relation to the kingship. He and his female counterpart, Seshat, documented the future success of the king at the coronation and subsequent Sed Festivals. Thoth s administrative authority extended to the royal treasury, as he took charge of the products brought from foreign lands. 37 Thoth joins with Horus in the purification of the king on the occasion of his coronation 38 and is well placed to participate in the coronation ceremony, accompanying Weret-Hekau. 39 Although Thoth is given a prominent part in the narrative of the kingship, his cult at Hermopolis is poorly documented for this period. At Deir el Bersha, a stela from Thutmose I l l s year 33 depicts the king before this god. It was dedicated by the high priest of Thoth, Sennefer. 40 The title "Great One of the Five," the title of Thoth s high priest, is also attested for the Theban official Djehuty, who was overseer of the priests in Hermopolis. 41 Montu, once the most prominent of Theban gods, 42 plays a secondary but influential role during this period.The inclusion of his bark in sequences at Deir el-Bahari may reflect this gods earlier more prominent status. 43 Montus iconographie characteristics as the falcon-headed warrior overlap with those of Re-Harakhty. This adds another dimension to the combination of Montu and Atum often found leading the king, 44 with both gods displaying Heliopolitan imagery as representatives of Thebes and Heliopolis. Montu was also an important reference point for the royal persona of Thutmose III, who placed the display of his skill as an archer within the context of that god s Armant temple. 45 This period sees a further development of Montus role as "the good genius" of the king on the battlefield. 46 Specific groups of deities conveyed well-defined themes. Horus and Seth appear in the Theban temples of this period as the male version of Nekhbet and Wadjit, conferring the double kingship of Egypt and alluding to the union of the two lands. 47 Osiris and Anubis are combined with a personification of the Goddess of the West to provide a holistic framework for the progression from mummification to transfiguration in the private funerary cult. 48 The triad of Elephantine, consisting of Khnum, Satis, and Anukis, with its connection to the cataract area, gives overtones of the creation in Nun, amplified by Khnums role as potter-creator.49
126
^
thutmose
iii
The deities brought together in the Holy Wedding sequence from Hatshepsuts Deir el-Bahari temple define the coeval realms of birth and rebirth. 50 The canopic goddesses Neith and Selket are guardians of the marriage bed. Khnum creates the double being of the king as ka and newborn child, assisted by the birth goddess Heket, called the White One, suggesting a correlation with Nekhbet and that goddesss status as divine midwife. The birth brick Meskhenet appears as yet another divine mother, with the deities Bes andTaueris, as well as the "Souls" of Pe and Nekhen, providing protection for the divine birth. The suckling motif, discussed earlier, is also reiterated with the presence of the numerous Hesat cows. A Nile god and an obscure milk god, Iat, stand by representing yet another level of emphasis on the provisioning of the king. The text also refers to the purification of the birth house by Horus and Seth, providing parallels to coronation. The world of the gods, as described at Thebes, centered on enhancing the position of Amun-Re as king of a divine community. Beyond this perspective, the other cult centers of Egypt also shared, to differing degrees, in the prosperity of the emerging empire. This took the form of traditional restoration projects and the construction of new temples. For many cults, it was the royal endowment of cult maintenance that was the primary contribution of this reign. Although the theologies of Thebes and Heliopolis were well integrated by the reign of Thutmose III, the ancient northern center continued to maintain a cult activity distinct from that of Thebes. Thutmose III participated in this by contributing to the growing number of obelisks located in the temple complex, as well as by strengthening its enclosure wall. A donation to the Mnevis bull is also recorded. 51 Heliopolis also continued to maintain the hierarchy of its priesthood. It is uncertain, however, where the real authority was located. The title Great of Seerers, which was used to designate the Heliopolitan high priest, has a distribution that suggests that it was used for both the Heliopolitan and the Theban versions of the solar priesthood. This period sees a number of candidates for the post, including two sons of the king. 52 Senemiah and Rekhmire, important Theban officials of this period, are also cited with a variation of this title as Great of Seerers in the Per-Wer. 53 At Memphis, as at Heliopolis, the highest level of the priesthood continued to function. Ptahmose, Great of Crafts, the title of the Memphite high priest, is depicted on a naos, 54 with the distinctive youth braid of this priesthood. It was dedicated at Abydos on behalf of Thutmose III. Although the Memphite temple was the center of the worship of Ptah, "south of his wall" this god also had a temple within the precinct of the Karnak, which he shared with his consort Hathor. 55 The dedication stela from
Religion and Cult during the Time of Thutmose III
^
129
that temple relates that it was rebuilt by Thutmose III after he found it "built of brick, with wooden columns, its doors of wood, having fallen to ruin " 5 6 T h e king not only restored the temple but also renewed the provisions for its cult. T h e wealth of the reign of Thutmose III contributed to numerous building projects. Many were within well-known temple complexes such as Elephantine, Dendera, and Abydos. 5 7 Others, however, are more obscure, such as the temple built by Thutmose III within the harem community of Gurob, possibly dedicated to Sobek. 5 8 Objects, such as stelae, document the widespread "presence" of the king in the cults of Egypt. A small stela depicts Thutmose III offering wine to the ram-headed Heryshef, Lord of Herakleopolis. 59 A recently discovered festival calendar dated to Thutmose III from the site of Buto, 60 dedicated to the lion-headed Wadjit, adds to the extensive catalog that documents royal support of Egypts gods. Many gods were gathered together in the Theban temples to participate in various aspects of the divine rule of Amun-Re. One illustration of this has been provided with reference to the Holy Wedding. There it is seen that the term ennead was expanded to include deities of interest in a Theban environment. 61 Beyond the general use of ennead\ there was a tendency to include as broad an array of deities as possible in the temples of Thebes. This was facilitated by the diversity of cultic activities. This interest in including the gods of all of Egypt in ritual is not limited to their presence in the temples. It is also found in the private funerary literature.The gods are called up "en masse" in Djehutys htp~di~nsw text, with a group comprised of: Amun-Re-Harakhty; Nun; Geb; Shu; Anubis; Sokar; Wepwaut; Osiris; Hathor, Chieftainess of the Desert, Foremost of Deir elBahari; Isis the Great, Divine Mother W h o m her Horus Loves; Ptah the Great, South of his Wall; Khonsu, Lord of Joy; Hathor, Mistress of Cusae; and Bastet of Bubastis; as well as other names too fragmentary to read. 62 T h e collective organization of deities also occurs on a more practical level. T h e administration of the "middle-sized" cults appears to have been centralized as part of the responsibility of the clergy of Karnak. Delegation of this responsibility is also documented. Minmose, as overseer of the priests of Montu, Lord of Thebes, was also put in charge of the work done in temples beyond Karnak. 6 3 He lists these as the Medamud temple of Montu and the temples of Wepwaut in Assiut; Hathor in Atfih; Bastet in the Memphite region known as Ankhtawy; Sopdu; Horus of Letopolis; Khnum (Foremost of the Road); Sakhmet (Foremost of the Desert); Re-Horus of Sakhbu; Hathor, Mistress of Kom el-Hisn; Wadjit, Mistress of Pe and Dep; Osiris, Lord of Busiris; Horus Khentykhety; and the Bull of the Black Bull Nome. After a break in the text the list continues with Amun, Lord of the Thrones
126
^
thutmose
iii
of the Two Lands on the Island of Amun, Hathor of Byblos, and yet another Amun whose identifying epithet is lost. Minmose continues his narrative by adding that he stretched the cord in these temples and supervised the erection of their monuments. He was also given high positions in some of them, being appointed priest and "opener of the mouth" in Letopolis and Great One of the Papyrus Scepter in the House of Bastet, Mistress of Ankhtawy. In the other temples he was given control over the distribution of the offices of priest and wab priest. This brief review of some of the gods found in the documentation of the reign of Thutmose III only touches on some of the more accessible material. It illustrates the expansive nature of theological thought during this period, indicating an interest in presenting a differentiated imagery for the divine world.
THE KING
The presentation of the king, in his role as mediator of divine authority, was one of the primary tasks of the theologians responsible for the texts and representations found on the walls of temples. A coronation opened the opportunity for a new understanding of the kingship as it was manifested in a new individual. The situation presented by the ascent of Hatshepsut as coruler with the young Thutmose III was complex. Both were legitimate kings, and together they formed a dual kingship that differed from previous father-son coregencies. The resources of the multifaceted worldview of the ancient Egyptians were mustered to formulate a suitable theological context for this unusual situation. The most evident quality of the divine kingship was its dependence on the concept of the king as the divine child. 64 The Holy Wedding sequence from Hatshepsuts temple draws on this tradition, 65 conveying a narrative similar to that surmised from the story of the three kings in papyrus Westcar. 66 Hatshepsuts version was in all likelihood the first reworking of this ancient theme for temple use. It does not, however, appear to have had an immediate association with the particular circumstances of her reign, as it remained in the corpus of material reused in other temples for other rulers. 67 Taking the long perspective, the Holy Wedding narrative can be seen as the beginning of a development that produces the child cults that begin to be documented during this dynasty.68 The story of Hatshepsuts birth is, however, only part of the effort put into emphasizing the divinity of the queen. Another Deir el-Bahari text describes a journey taken by the queen with her father, Thutmose I, to all the
Religion and Cult during the Time of Thutmose III
^
131
sanctuaries of Egypt. 6 9 This text was apparently adapted from an earlier model that was part of the royal "coronation corpus ." 7 0 Rewritten to suit Hatshepsut, the journey narrative is employed to create a fictional coregency with Thutmose I and to emphasize the divinity of Hatshepsut as "king," as it is said of her: "Her form was that of a god, her character was that of a god, she did everything like god, she was beneficial like a god. Her majesty had become a beautiful young maiden, Wadjit in her moment." 71 This sequence, followed by the formal presentation of the titulary of the queen, signaled her transformation into a king. As sovereign, Hatshepsut was empowered by the attributes of the divine kingship. The obelisk provided an appropriate setting for underlining her identification with the ascendant aspect of the sun god. She is "the one who came into being in the forms of Khepri, the one who appears like [Hor]akhty,... the one whom Amun himself made appear on the throne of Southern Heliopolis." 72 Yet another example of the merging of the identity of Hatshepsut with that of the divine kingship is found in restoration texts of Speos Artemidos. Hatshepsut describes the restoration as an act of devotion to her father Amun: "I have [elevated] Maat, whom he loves, for I know that he lives on her. She is my bread. I wash down her savor. I am indeed one body with him." 73 The bodily identity between the sovereign and the divine father could hardly be more clearly expressed. The narrative of the accession of Thutmose III, recorded in year 42 of his reign, is no less dramatic. Here the focus is on the gods recognition of his heir in the sacral environment of the temple. The text describes the transformation of the child from mortal to god, using familiar imagery. Appearing in the temple, most likely in the form of a cult statue on the shoulders of priests, the god stops before the child, indicating his recognition: "There was no one [standing] in front who knew what he was doing, as his majesty searched everywhere. Then, knowing me, he stopped." 74 Thutmose pays homage to his divine father and his transformation into the Golden Horus, king of Egypt begins: "[He opened] the doors of heaven [for] me. He opened the gates of the horizon for me, and I flew up to heaven as a divine falcon, and saw his secret form that is in heaven. I adored his majesty. . . . I saw the manifestations of the horizon god on his secret roads in heaven." 75 Assuming the identity of Horus, the young king receives the insignia of his office and is transformed: "I was equipped with all his Akhu power I was 76 made wise with the wisdom of the gods like Horus." His titulary established, the status of the new king is summarized: "I am his son, who came forth from him, a likeness that was formed like the one foremost of Hesert.
126 ^
thutmose
iii
He has united all of my manifestations in this name of Son of Re Thutmose, beautiful of being, who lives forever and for eternity" 7 7 T h e legitimacy of each of the two sovereigns is expressed as unequivocal. In the more than twenty years of coregency the dual kingship was consistently presented as the harmonious combination of two complementary parts of a single equation, with symmetry often employed to emphasize this point. 7 8 There is, however, also a distinctive individuality in the choice of which aspects of the kingship should be highlighted. A perceptible, and individualized, focus is found in the documentation of the two kings. T h e masculine guise eventually adopted by Hatshepsut did not prevent a feminine emphasis in her textual presentation. Her most convincing claim to the throne was based on her status as royal daughter, underlined in her relationship to her father Amun. This opened the way to imagery of the fiercely protective and aggressive uraeus, the prototype of the diadem goddess, also a divine daughter. T h e association between Hatshepsut and the different forms of her divine correlate, the daughter of Re, comes through in her choice of titulary. Her throne name, Maatkare, "Maat is the ka of Re," suggests that Hatshepsut, as an embodiment of Maat, was the ka, or life-generating energy, of Re. This is one interpretation among many. 79 Other allusions to goddesses may be found in the names of the queen. Useret is named in her Horus name, wsrt kjw, Strong of Kas, and Wadjit in her Two Ladies name, wjdt rnpwt, Green of Years. In examining the question, Robins has suggested that the combination of Useret, a possiblyTheban epithet for Hathor, and Wadjit, the cobra goddess of Lower Egypt, may correspond to that of the Two Ladies, Nekhbet and Wadjit as representatives of Upper and Lower Egypt. 8 0 T h e material from the reign of Hatshepsut suggests an exploitation of the daughter role on two levels. T h e repetitive references to Thutmose I indicate a reliance on her tie to her father as the source for her claim to the throne. On another level, her status as daughter of the king incorporated that of Wife of the God, and was used as a natural point of transition to the kingship. T h e description of the ascent of Thutmose III to the throne emphasizes a different kind of transition. T h e god recognizes his son, and, in the knowledge of that recognition, the child is transformed into the divine royal falcon. T h e historical circumstances of the reign of Thutmose III favored a presentation of this king as successful hunter and warrior.This vision is overwhelming in almost everything related to this king. Amun-Re was the agent of Thutmose I l l s success, and as such he became the recipient of the goods gained from that success. 81 Among the gifts to the god are the battle narra-
Religion and Cult during the Time of Thutmose III
^
133
tives, 82 inscribed as a protective field around the bark sanctuary. This use of battle inscriptions, first found here, later becomes a well-defined element in the decoration program of royal mortuary temples. 83 The warrior king as type is developed in the narratives of the king s military successes. The reference point for this persona is provided by the Theban Montu, depicted as falcon headed, thus carrying allusions to Horus, both as defender of his father and as the ascendant form of the sun god. The connection between the king as military leader and this god is illustrated by the so-called Armant stela, on which the physical prowess of this king as an archer is described. 84 The newly discovered Buto stela elaborates on this image of Thutmose III as warrior and manifestation of the skills of Montu and the attributes of Min, calling his protection that of Min of the uplifted arm and identifying the king as the archer of Montu. 8 5 The difference between the royal personae of the two sovereigns was not only a matter of theological formulation but was also incorporated in the presentation of the interaction (projected or real) between the two rulers and their subjects.Two, more personal descriptions illustrate this point.The overseer of the treasury Senemiah describes the participation of his mistress in a ritual: "The blending of myrrh and sand was ordained for her, the best thereof piercing heaven, blending the crown with the stars. I saw these things with my two eyes . . . the king himself carrying hekat measures with his two hands, circling around that he might carry (them), the dust of servants after him, the unguent that he took being in his hands." 86 This description of Hatshepsut making the preparations "himself," to the amazement of the onlookers, provides a minor insight into what had become a proper presentation of the role of the queen. A corresponding description of Thutmose III is found in the text of the Minmose: "Regarding these foreign lands of which I have spoken, my lord conquered them with his strength, with his bow, with his arrow, with his battle axe. I have seen the strength of his majesty when fighting occurs, plundering 30 cities in the region of Thsy) bringing their chiefs, their families, their cattle." 87 The image of this king is above all that of a warrior, an image that permeated the kingship during this period and soon after. Hatshepsut and Thutmose III projected varied aspects of the kingship, chosen to amplify their individual suitability for the role. They were both, however, subject to the main requirement of the office, the maintenance of the harmony of the state and the cosmos on behalf of their divine father, Amun-Re. This was achieved by adhering to that which Amun had commanded. A simplified description of Amuns expectations is found on Hatshepsuts bark chapel.88
126 ^
thutmose
iii
Fill the estate, supply the altar Instruct the wab priest regarding their tasks Advance the laws Perpetuate the regulations Enrich the property Increase that which existed previously Expand the space of my treasuries Build without neglecting sandstone or granite Renew for my temple the statues in good quality limestone Advance this work for me in the future Control the monuments of the temples Install every god according to his (own) regulations Each one there exactly according to his means Advance his primeval time for him Advancing his laws is the joy of a god The obligations of the kingship included the construction and renewal of monuments. The restoration theme is thus very important in affirming that the king has met his obligations. Thutmose III, as mentioned earlier, renewed the temple of Ptah at Karnak, 89 while Hatshepsut renewed that of Pakhet in Middle Egypt. The "temple in ruins" rhetoric becomes a standard part of the royal corpus. It is difficult, however, to surpass that from Speos Artemidos. 90 The temple of the Mistress of Cusae was fallen to ruin and the earth had swallowed her noble chapel. Children danced on its roof for the serpent guardian did not frighten (them). Paupers did the accounting, . . . and her offerings did not occur. . . . (Even) he who entered, face to face (with) the leader of the Ennead Atum, is ignorant, there being no wisdom in his temple, the Fathers of the God were destitute.. . . Hatshepsut reestablished the procedure for festivals, which had been lost in the disruption of temple activity, 91 illustrating the direct responsibility of the king for the details of ritual and festival. The responsibilities of the kingship were to a large extent expressed in terms of the obligations to the cults of the gods. Hatshepsut moved from Wife of the God to King as she relinquished the insignia of the one for the other. 92 Thutmose III was recognized by his father Amun while performing the duties of the Iunmutef, 93 a priestly role patterned on that of the child Horus and reserved, at least theoretically, for the heir. The character of the
Religion and Cult during the Time of Thutmose III
^
135
kingship as a manifestation of both divinity and ritual responsibility made mediation between the two realms of heaven and earth possible.
T H E C U L T S OF T H E
GODS
The king, as priest, had the responsibility for maintenance of the interdependent exchange between the mortal and divine worlds. His participation in the cults of the gods ensured their provisioning and thus the harmony of the life of the living. In return the king was blessed with life, strength, stability, and joy, as well as countless Sed Festivals, guaranteeing the eternal endurance of the kingship. Ritual offerings, the pivotal function of the temple, are represented repeatedly, affirming that the king has fulfilled his obligation in the maintenance of the temple cults. Each temple served as the residence of a primary deity, as well as several "visiting" deities. Each god was, as least theoretically, the object of a daily ritual that renewed the life of the god inhabiting the cult statue. The god was gently awakened in his naos with greetings, purification, anointing, and fresh clothing.The statue was imbued with new life through an embrace. The ritual culminated as the god was returned to the naos, which was then resealed and all signs of human presence removed, as the priests brushed away the footprints left in the clean sand of the sanctuary. Purification ended the ceremony. The codification of the daily ritual has survived in the Abydos temple of Seti I. 9 4 Although an equivalent record is lacking for the reign of Thutmose III, several rooms for this purpose have been identified. 95 Abbreviated versions are also recorded in the various temple locations. The bark chapel of Hatshepsut documents a sequence that depicts the core of the daily ritual, including a scene in which the queen sweeps the ground with a broomlike stalk. 96 The sequence ends with the embrace of the queen and Amun-Re, which may relate to the act of conferring life on the cult statue. Additional examples of this ritual are found in the Deir el-Bahari temple. In the chapel of Anubis the queen opens the naos containing the statue of Ptah. 97 On a block from the sanctuary of Amun-Re-Kamutef, 98 Hatshepsut removes the robe from Amun. Offering, central to the daily ritual, is also found in other contexts. Often lacking specificity, the various offering scenes may not have been intended to represent individual occasions.The offering of Maat is one type that tends to occur without a specified context. Found as chapter 43 in the Karnak "Liturgy of Amun," 99 the offering of Maat was integrated into the ritual activities of the king during the New Kingdom. The depiction of this ritual, in which Maat is offered in the personified form of the goddess, is first doc-
126 ^
thutmose
iii
umented during the reign of Thutmose I I L 1 0 0 It belongs to what had been described as one of many "new" depictions of cultic activities. 101 Although the pictorial representations of the rite are dated to the "middle years" of the Thutmose I l l s reign, it is attested in the texts dated to the coregency as well. 1 0 2 In an inscription from the Pakhet shrine, Hatshepsut says: "I have [elevated] Maat, whom he loves. I know that he lives on her. She is my bread. I wash ("her") down with her sweet savor." 1 0 3 Here the connection between Maat and the more concrete offering of bread and beer is made clear and integrates the abstraction of "truth" or "justice" into the basic needs of the gods. Another example of a textual description of this ritual is found in a description of Thutmose I l l s elevation to the kingship. A list of three gates is given, with the note reading "Maat enters through them for him." 1 0 4 Comparing the two quotes, it would appear that the act of entering between the gates and of swallowing the offering as a cake could be equated as ways in which Maat was integrated into the kingship. T h e king was included among those deities for whom offering, also in the context of the daily ritual, was performed. Theoretically, the ruling king was present in each of the temples in the form of a cult statue. Two areas have been identified as dedicated to the worship of Thutmose III at Karn a k . 1 0 5 In the Festival H a l l , 1 0 6 a scene depicting the king seated before an offering table together with his ka identifies the function of one r o o m . 1 0 7 Additionally, a separate part of this complex, known as the Eastern Temple, contained an alabaster naos with a figure of Amun-Re and one that was later sculpted into Amaunet. 1 0 8 It has been suggested that Thutmose III was originally represented with Amun and that he was also worshiped there since reference is made to offering to the royal ka.109 Textual evidence also indicates an active royal statue cult at Karnak, as upon his return from victory in the Levant Thutmose III laid down a "divine offering" to his own statues. 1 1 0 Although many royal temple statues were placed in areas connected to the daily cult, there were others that were the focus of cult activity. T h e Osiride statues of the king, found at Deir el-Bahari and elsewhere, were essentially architectural elements. They were, however, also treated as individual manifestations of the king and appear to have been the object of worship. 1 1 1 The worship of past kings was expressed both in terms of a select collective and in individual cult contexts, where particularly esteemed historical kings were worshiped. 1 1 2 According to Fairman, 1 1 3 the offerings laid down for the daily cult were transferred to the royal ancestors, as recipients of the first "reversion of offerings" immediately following the conclusion of the ritual. T h e collective worship of the "fathers" is perhaps best exemplified by the annals chamber erected by Thutmose III in the Festival H a l l , 1 1 4 where sixtyone kings were listed as recipients of a htp~dî~nsw offering. T h e inscription
Religion and Cult during the Time of Thutmose III
^
13 7
speaks of the construction of the chamber that is called, like the mortuary temple of the king, a Great House of Millions of Years. It is said to preserve the names of his fathers, to strengthen their offerings, and to fashion their cult images in all their f o r m s . 1 1 5 Another example of the cult of the ancestors is associated with offerings to Mut.Temple scenes showThutmose III censing and libating before the goddess's statue, while a procession of royal statues leaves and returns to the temple. 1 1 6 T h e text accompanying the scene reads: "The statues go forth after performing the ritual of praising, going around the palace outside it. Recitation by the Lector-priest. Praises and rejoicing for Menkheperre, performing the ritual according to the ritual book, presenting life to the statues." 117 The elevation of former kings to the status of gods could go beyond that of offerings to individual statues. Thutmose III had a special relationship with Senwosret III, who was worshiped at several Nubian sites. Among the signs of this devotion was the establishment of the temple dedicated to Senwosret III and Hathor at Gebel Dosha. 1 1 8 An inscription of year 21 of the reign of Thutmose dedicates the renewal of the oldest part of the temple of Semneh to Senwosret III "in the temple of his father Dedwen," where his father Khnum, Opposer of Bows, was also worshiped. 1 1 9 This temple also included a bark belonging to Senwosret I I I . 1 2 0 Amenhotep I was given special attention at Karnak and possibly Medinet Habu. A cult room at Karnak, 1 2 1 as well as a relief fragment said to come from Medinet H a b u , 1 2 2 point to an interest in creating a parallel between Thutmose III and Amenhotep I, using a symmetric composition. The gods, including the kings past and present, were given renewed strength with the daily presentation of offerings.The daily ritual marked the beginning and end of the day, with an implied period of rest for each god in his naos, a period equivalent to sleep. The day thus consisted of a cyclical period of renewal and transformation. The inclusion of a journey through the night, a prominent element in the solar cult, as part of the conceptualization of the period of dormancy, adds another aspect to the interaction between the divine and mortal worlds expressed in the solar cult. Amun-Re served as the ultimate model for the divine king and creator, combining primeval origin with regenerating solar creation. This association extended beyond the individual deities, identifyingThebes as the "Southern Heliopolis." 1 2 3 By the time of Thutmose III, this identification had become mythologized, as we read: "The Southern Heliopolis is his (Amuns) eye, the horizon on this earth." 1 2 4 The obelisk, as an architectural form, when erected in Thebes signified the bond between Heliopolis and Thebes while affirming the association between Amun and Re. The ways in which these monuments were described
126
^
thutmose
iii
make it clear that their form was placed within a solar framework, as the obelisk could be said to "fill the land with its r a y s " 1 2 5 The sun god, Re, was both part of Amun-Re and an independent deity, with a separate cult in the name of Re-Harakhty. His sanctuary was called the Shade of Re and was found at Karnak during this period. 1 2 6 A roof sanctuary, common in later periods for that gods cult, may have existed at Thutmose I l l s Festival H a l l . 1 2 7 Although the site of the primary cult of ReHarakhty at Karnak is uncertain, its existence as a part of the temple s daily activities is well attested. Among the donations made by Thutmose III on his return from his first expedition is a divine offering "to make praises for my father Re-Harakhty when he rises." 128 The moon festivals were the occasions for these offerings, which were to be performed "like that which is done in Heliopolis" The sun sanctuary that provides the best evidence for this cult is found at Hatshepsuts Deir el-Bahari temple. 1 2 9 The significance of the texts found there was recognized by Assmann, 1 3 0 who interpreted their contents as identifying the king as a priest of the god Re-Harakhty. Three different liturgical texts have been identified in the sanctuary of Re-Harakhty. Taken as a whole, they provide the earliest documentation of a conceptual complex that continued to develop throughout the pharaonic period. Two of these texts functioned as hymns to the setting and rising sun. The second hour of the Book of the N i g h t , 1 3 1 first attested here, was recited as the sun set. Reconstructed with the help of parallels, it describes the entry of the sun disk into the darkness of the night and initiates the theme of the presence of light in the darkness.The incorporation of the nightly journey of the sun in the royal cult coincides with the imagery of the text corpus that decorates the royal tombs from this period. Another text titled "The Baboons that Foretell R e , " 1 3 2 welcomed the sun in the morning. It speaks of the birth of the solar deity at the sixth hour in the underworld and how the baboons, known for their noisy celebration of the morning, jump, dance, and sing for the god when he appears from between his mother Nuts thighs. 1 3 3 These two texts describe the journey of the sun as one that begins with trepidation and danger and ends with triumph and jubilation. It is, however, the third text that provides a key to understanding the role of the king as priest. It clarifies the role of knowledge, accessible to the king alone, as the prerequisite weapon against the dangers faced by the sun god on his journey. Assmann sees this text as a theological treatise. 134 It describes the birth of Re at dawn in the form of the scarab Khepri and continues with a validation of the king as "the one who knows" the specifics of the solar journey and
Religion and Cult during the Time of Thutmose III
^
139
the mystery of the daily birth of Re. The conclusion is a declaration that the king has been put on earth by Re to provide a link between heaven and earth. Re has installed the King on the earth of the living for eternity and forever, to administer justice to human beings and satisfy the gods, to fulfill Maat and annihilate falsehood. These texts differ from those usually associated with depictions of rituals in that they do not specify offering but worship. The god is not provisioned, but rather it is the knowledge of the king that reinforces the powers of the god in meeting the dangers of the night. The rising and setting sun provided the key to understanding the kingship as an extension of the solar cycle, representing the same powers that entered the darkness of the night and reappeared each morning victorious, having destroyed falsehood and upheld truth. Knowledge of the particulars of this journey guaranteed the kings participation in its successful completion, on a daily basis in this world, and in the transition between this life and the next when applied to a funerary context.
T H E F E S T I V A L S OF T H E G O D S
The celebration of temple festivals was regulated by a calendar, established under the authority of the king. The festival, like the daily ritual, was dependent on donations from the king. One aspect, in particular, accounts for the importance of the festival. As he left the isolation of the temple, the god, in the form of a cult statue, came in contact with his worshipers. This was an occasion for the celebration that is often the theme of the pictorial presentation of these festivals. The use of the portable bark for transporting the god from one place to another characterizedTheban festivals during the New Kingdom. A bark was used as determinative for words referring to several festivals recorded on the Palermo Stone, 1 3 5 indicating that it was thematically central to festival activity from the earliest times. The inclusion of the bark in ritual context reaches a high point during the New Kingdom. 1 3 6 In Thebes, the bark, as an image for the god, dates back to at least the Thirteenth Dynasty, when a wab priest records his participation in a procession, carrying the bark of M o n t u . 1 3 7 The bark shrine of the New Kingdom functioned as a sanctuary and a focus of ritual activity when the god was at home. 1 3 8 The shrine, together with the chapels used as rest stops for bark
126 ^
thutmose
iii
processions, verify the importance of the procession as part of the festival activity of the temple. By the reign of Thutmose III, the bark shrine appears to have become an obligatory part of major temple architecture since two temples, the mortuary temple of Thutmose II and the Eighteenth Dynasty temple at Medinet Habu, were altered to accommodate a bark shrine. 1 3 9 T h e Opet Festival was one occasion on which the bark was used for transporting the divine image. 1 4 0 Amun, in his Min-Kamutef form, was taken from Karnak to the temple of Luxor, "the southern harem," for what has been surmised was a form of holy wedding. Nothing, however, is recorded regarding the events that took place inside the temple once the god had arrived. T h e earliest evidence for the celebration of the Opet comes from the dismantled bark chapel of Hatshepsut. 1 4 1 Fifteen scenes were used to summarize the journey. T h e first section concerns the procession to Luxor, by land, with the portable bark being carried on the shoulders of priests, accompanied by fan bearers and sem priests. Both Hatshepsut and Thutmose III are shown leading the procession and taking part in the rituals performed along the way. T h e procession to Luxor took place in stages, measured out by six stations. One of these was found before the House of the Chest, 1 4 2 the name of the sanctuary of Amun-Re-Kamutef, built by Hatshepsut at the entrance to the Mut sanctuary. 143 T h e journey to Luxor was by land, utilizing the six monumental rest stops erected for the purpose. One of these would have been the construction credited to Hatshepsut at the entrance to Luxor temple. 1 4 4 T h e presentation of the return journey by water is minimal and summarized using the images of the barks involved. I 4 5 The first bark carries the naos in the form of the PerWer sanctuary. T h e queen stands, her hands on her kilt, in a gesture of adoration while Thutmose III paddles. He is said to be "sailing, four times," indicating a ritual involving the departure by water, performed the obligatory four times. T h e heading reads: "Going down to the Great Bark, the Userhet of Amun, navigating downstream." This sequence also includes a scene in which two barks follow each other, making it clear the Userhet bark is being towed. T h e lead bark carries the king and queen seated in a chapel, with both sovereigns wearing the short Sed Festival tunics, Hatshepsut bearing the White Crown and Thutmose III the Red. Both hold towing ropes: "Taking the prow rope of the divine boat." T h e "taking of the prow rope" is also a specific ritual act, documented as early as the Sixth Dynasty. 1 4 6 T h e safe return of the god to Karnak occasioned the performance of a number of ritual acts confirming the unity of Egypt, such as the Striking of the Meret-Chests, and the Running the Course. T h e celebration included a Hathoric choir of women with sistra, as well as acrobatic dances. T h e texts
Religion and Cult during the Time of Thutmose III
^
141
indicate that this was one of the occasions on which the god renewed his promises of sovereignty, as Hatshepsut received the blessings of the sistrum and menât of Hathor. T h e Opet Festival was one of national significance. Offerings for this occasion were among those established on the occasion of Thutmose I l l s return from his first victory. 1 4 7 It is also included as a time for the celebration of Amun in the festival calendar established by Thutmose III at Elephantine. 1 4 8 Another, more fragmentary depiction of this festival is found at Hatshepsuts Deir el-Bahari temple, 1 4 9 although from the viewpoint of the west bank there was another festival of greater interest. Amun-Re also visited his cult center at Deir el-Bahari. At some time during the Eighteenth Dynasty this visit was routed to the temple of the reigning sovereign, becoming part of the Festival of the Beautiful Valley. 1 5 0 T h e earliest example of Amuns journey to the west is associated with the temple of Nebhepetre Mentuhotep. A Twelfth Dynasty graffito scrawled in the cliff above that temple records that the priest Neferibed kissed the earth when he sailed over to the valley of Nebhepetre for the first t i m e . 1 5 1 T h e construction of the temple of Hatshepsut redirected Amuns journey to the bark shrine that had been built to receive the g o d . 1 5 2 Like the Opet Festival, the events of the Deir el-Bahari festival were described in a series of scenes on the queens bark chapel at Karnak. T h e placement of the depictions of the two festivals on corresponding positions on the north (Deir el-Bahari) and south (Luxor) walls implies that they were seen as parallel celebrations of the god. Unfortunately only two blocks have survived of the scenes showing the departure of Amun to Deir el-Bahari.The destination of the journey is made clear with the heading "Crossing in peace to the Head of the Canal for the sailing of Djeser D j e s e r u . " I 5 3 T h e last scene in this sequence shows the bark resting on its podium in the sanctuary, as the queen consecrates an offering to Amun. Another version of the conclusion of the journey is found in the bark sanctuary of Deir el-Bahari, where depictions of torch processions and milk basins are f o u n d . 1 5 4 This suggests that the bark arrived at night and that the torches were ritually extinguished in m i l k . 1 5 5 From the little that remains representing the return journey, it would appear that the representations on the bark chapel schematized the two return journeys so that they would resemble one another. Both processions, from Luxor and Deir el-Bahari, stopped at the alabaster chapel of Amenhotep I . 1 5 6 Like Hatshepsuts bark chapel, this monument was reused as foundation material and now exists in a modern reconstruction. As in the return from Luxor, the arrival of the god from Deir el-Bahari was an occasion for festivity, with musical entertainment: "I have come to you, O male god,
126
^
thutmose
iii
O primordial one of the Two Lands. O consecrated Amun, Lord of the Two Feathers. May you protect the King of Upper and Lower Egypt, like Re." Other musicians of the House of Amun sing "the scent of food, the scent of food, how sweet the scent." Royal offerings affirmed the reestablishment of the god in his shrine. 1 5 7 Another version of this festival is found at Deir el Bahari itself. 1 5 8 There a bark carrying a statue of the queen is included in the group arriving at the temple. A procession of royal statues is also part of this record, as well as barks identified as belonging to Thutmose II, Thutmose III, and the queen. Inscribed above the bark of the queen, a text identifies the occasion as the festival of Amun of Djeser Djeseru at the monument of Maatkare. 1 5 9 The purpose of Amuns visit to Deir el Bahari is not stated in the texts. It has been deduced that Amun of Karnak would meet and unite with Amun of Deir el Bahari. This is the same pattern suggested for the Opet Festival, indicating that the hegemony of Amun of Karnak was reinforced by affirming that he was one with the other Amuns worshipped at other temples. Here, as at Luxor, there were undertones of a holy wedding. 160 There is ample evidence of Hathor s inclusion in the celebration of Amuns presence at Deir el Bahari. It has been suggested that originally Hathor may have, like Amun, only visited the site on the occasion of a festival. 161 The references to a festival procession of Hathor, found in her chapel at Deir el Bahari, 1 6 2 while not resolving the issue, do indicate that the goddess was more than marginally involved in this or a similar celebration.The cult image of the cow goddess is seen towed in a bark. Another bark contains young army recruits. The accompanying text provides the connection between this procession, featuring Hathor, and the presence of Amun in Deir el Bahari. 1 6 3 "Acclamation by the crew of the royal bark, recruits from Thebes, beautiful youths of the army of the entire land, rejoicing when meeting this god, Amun, Lord of the Throne of the Two Lands in his sailing at the beginning of the year, on behalf of the Life, Prosperity and Health of Maatkare and on behalf of the Life, Prosperity and Life of Menkheperre given life forever, when the majesty of this great goddess is made to go forth to rest in her temple in the Djeser Djeseru of Amun, so that they might live forever." This procession concludes in the Deir el Bahari sequence, with song and dance and various royal rituals. 164 Thutmose III is seen presenting an oar to Hathor, reminiscent of the scene from the Opet Festival where the king paddles the boat on the return journey. With the sole reign of Thutmose III, Hatshepsuts temple was superseded as that of the reigning king, and Amuns journey to the west bank came to include the Qurna mortuary temple of Thutmose I I I . 1 6 5 This complex,
Religion and Cult during the Time of Thutmose III
^
143
together with the Deir el-Bahari structures of this king, effectively replaced Hatshepsuts temple as the destination for festival celebrations. 166 The procession that carried the cult statue out of the temple was in itself an occasion for jubilation. "Going Forth" is the technical term and was used in reference to various local, as well as national, festivals, of which the Going Forth of Min is the best known. 1 6 7 Although the Palermo Stone reference to "fashioning (the statue of) Min" from the reign of Djer is often cited as the first mention of the festival, 168 the earliest detailed description of the Festival of the Going Forth of Min is found in the Ramesseum. 169 The Min Festival was associated with the harvest and featured the procession of the cult statue, carried on a plank covered by an embroidered cloth and accompanied by a white bull. This festival is documented during the reign of Thutmose III as one of the occasions supported by donations made after his first expedition. 170 Although specific references to the procession of Min are few from this period, there is one ceremony that reoccurs in this material and has a close connection with the cult of that god. Called Raising the Tent Poles, 1 7 1 it is first documented in the white chapel of Senwosret I at Karnak. 1 7 2 Three examples of this scene are dated to the reign of Thutmose I I I . 1 7 3 The king inaugurates the "tent poles," as men climb them, apparently in order to attach protective symbols at the top of the construction. 174 The earliest versions of this scene are directly connected with the ithyphallic form of Amun, called Lord of the Tent. Lacau has argued that the ceremony introduced the foundation ritual, with the poles representing the earliest type of Egyptian building. 175 The association with Min is found in his role as Lord of the Eastern Desert and thus the proper patron of a nomadic population, the most frequent users of tents. This interpretation was developed by Helck, who went on to place the origin of the ceremony in Wadi Hammammat. 1 7 6 Another festival documented for this period is the Sokar Festival, 177 distinctive in this material for its Memphite context. It is attested on the Palermo Stone in connection with both the coronation and the foundation ritual and may also have had an originally agrarian reference. 178 The main event of the Sokar Festival was the procession of the Henu bark around the temple walls. Prior to that, the ritual of "hacking the earth," also found in the foundation ritual, 179 was carried out. The festival was given an abbreviated presentation in the Festival Hall. 1 8 0 The bark of Sokar is depicted carried by eight priests, with another priest, possibly the lector priest, walking alongside it. Four additional priests, all wearing headbands and carrying symbolic towing ropes, lead the procession. A portion of the shrine of the mummified falcon Sokar has been preserved
126
^
thutmose
iii
in the depiction, along with texts possibly referring to "entering into the place of purification" 1 8 1 T h e king is shown turning nmst vases upside down, as a priest of Sokar and possibly a priestess stand by. References to the Sokar Festival during this period coincide with the first examples of the funerary text, the Amduat. 1 8 2 This text describes the journey of the sun god in his bark through the well-defined geography of the underworld. T h e land of Sokar, comprising the regions of the fourth and fifth hours, is a transitional desert zone between the fertile fields of the living, still found in the second and third regions, and N u n and the body of Re-Osiris in the sixth hour. These hours are "necropolis zones," where the inhabitants can hear, but not see, the sun god as he passes. Interpreted as a region of latent but not actualized powers of renewal, it is suitably expressed in the figure of the mummified falcon and his companions, the canopic gods. T h e funerary character of this god makes his occurrence apt in a mortuary setting such as the Deir el-Bahari temple. T h e depiction of this festival in the Karnak Temple area of Thutmose III suggests, however, that its agrarian character still made it suitable for royal cultic activities. T h e record of another, little-known, festival has survived in the Festival Hall. This is the Festival of the White Hippopotamus. T h e problematic character of this scene is indicated by the notation "spearing the hippopotamus." 1 8 3 Associated with the offering of milk and the erection of the tent poles, the scene depicts the king, carrying a scepter and a longer staff, possibly a spear. Before him, in two registers, are a hippopotamus standing on a float or sled and beneath it two dancing men, face to face, identified as archaic and unknown Egyptian towns. T h e iconographie nature of this scene is verified by Old Kingdom examples, 1 8 4 with an almost exact parallel surviving from Memphis. 1 8 5 T h e inclusion of numerous priests in the Memphite example confirms the scene s ritual character. This version also specifies that it is the Festival of the White Hippopotamus of Upper Egypt. Kees has interpreted these scenes as a variation on the theme of hunting the hippopotamus, which is current in the private tombs of the N e w Kingd o m . 1 8 6 Countering this, Säve-Söderbergh has pointed out the dichotomy between the red male hippopotamus and the white female. 1 8 7 T h e red male is a fierce symbol for the enemy, hunted and killed by the king. In contrast, the white female is connected to the pacified forms of a female deity, whose presence evokes joy. Numerous well-known festivals occurred on a daily, monthly (moon festivals), or yearly basis. Festival calendars, established at each temple, 1 8 8 regulated when each festival occurred, as well as the provisions allowed for their celebration. T h e majority of the known festival calendars of the N e w King-
Religion and Cult during the Time of Thutmose III
^
145
dom date to the reign of Thutmose III. Three come from Karnak, 1 8 9 with additional calendars documented from Abydos, Elephantine, and Buto. 1 9 0 T h e proclamation of festivals was the prerogative of the king. Thutmose III, celebrating his triumphant return from his first expedition, endowed several festivals as well as "foundations" created for the support of the cults. Primary in this list are victory festivals that appear to largely coincide with celebrations of the cult of Amun at his mortuary temple at Qurna. T h e offerings consisted of the redistribution of wealth from his military success in the Levant. T h e relative rare occurrence of milk offerings 1 9 1 may be related to the care with which the provision of cows for the temple was treated. An endowment of four milk cows, from Upper and Lower Egypt, Syria, and Kush, "to be milked for milk for the milk jars of fine gold, every day," is recorded in one of the Karnak calendars. 192 Another example of the donation of milk cows from this reign is found in the narrative of Neferperet, 1 9 3 who says that while accompanying the king in Retenu he acquired seven head of cattle intended for the mortuary temple of Thutmose III. He notes that his brother Amenmehib guarded them and his son Djeserkare carried the milk jars. Additional donations included a wide spectrum of gifts such as prisoners of war as laborers, fields, Syrian towns, and provisions for the harem. This donation list also includes an admonition to the priesthood to attend to their duties. 1 9 4 This list provides a useful reminder of the dependency of religious activity in Egypt on the prosperity of the national treasury. T h e Buto calendar provides a unique glimpse of the festival year in its entirety, as well as its needs. 1 9 5 It records the daily ritual, four monthly moon festivals, and fifteen additional festivals spread through the year. Wadjit, the "owner" of the temple, was celebrated four times in three festivals (hh) and one "Going Forth" (prt). Another example of the celebration of the Going Forth of Wadjit is found with the same date, day zo of the first month of winter, on a stela from the temple of M u t . 1 9 6 Other related festival occasions suggest that the Going Forth of Wadjit was part of a general celebration of the return of the lion goddess from remote regions. 1 9 7 T h e other example of a "Going Forth" from the Buto calendar refers to the celebration of the rising of Sothis, called the "Going Forth of Sothis." Lacking a specific date, it is found between the "Coronation Festival of the King of Upper and Lower Egypt, Menkheperre, who lives forever" on the fourth day of the first month of summer and the "Festival of the Upper and Lower Egyptian Meret," celebrated on the last day of the first month of summer. T h e same festival was placed on the calendar of Elephantine on day 28 of the third month of summer. 1 9 8
126 ^
thutmose
iii
The standard measures of offering gifts for each festival, given in the Buto calendar, 199 also gives some sense of priorities for each of the occasions. Although this issue is too complex to treat in detail here, it is worth noting, for example, that twenty-five honey cakes were provided for the celebration of the New Year while the ordinary ration was five or exceptionally ten. Twenty is- jars of beer were provided for the New Year compared to the common ten or occasionally fifteen. Twenty-five bundles of vegetables was a common offering even for the New Year, but the Festival of Nehebkau, another form of New Year s celebration, 200 was allotted fifty. The well-being of Egypts gods ensured the well-being of the land and its people. The king mediated in this connection through his cultic responsibilities. He was also part of that divine world. His status required divine sanction and blessing so that his actions would be effective in influencing the prosperity of the gods and of Egypt.
ROYAL FESTIVALS AND CULTIC ACTIVITIES
The king officiated at the rituals and festivals of the gods. There were also a number of occasions during which the king, as actor, was the focus of the celebration. Three major events were celebrated as royal festivals: the coronation, the foundation of consecrated buildings, and the jubilee or Sed Festival. There were also a number of cultic acts that are not easily connected to one specific occasion but could indeed occur (or be depicted) as part of a broad spectrum of festival occasions. These acts reinforced the unity of Egypt and the endurance of the kingship, as they related to different symbolic contexts. The coronation as an event was expressed by the verb hci, "to appear (in glory)." It has a useful ambivalence, referring both to the "appearance" of the king on the Horus throne of the living and to the crowns (hcw) that affirmed his legitimacy as ruler. The Appearance as King included two standard events during the early years of Egypt's political unity. The Palermo Stone refers to the coronation as "appearing as king," "circling outside the wall," and "uniting Upper and Lower Egypt." 2 0 1 The New Kingdom is more ambivalent with regard to the exact rituals that were included in the confirmation of the kingship. The textual descriptions of the coronation, found in the royal narratives, are highly individualized, as was discussed earlier. A small number of representations identify some key elements, such as the purification before entering the shrine where the coronation takes place. This is performed by Horus and Thoth and initiated the process that legitimized the king. 2 0 2
Religion and Cult during the Time of Thutmose III
^
147
Coronation was associated with an "entry" or "induction," using the term hs found in connection with priestly initiation. T h e building into which the king entered to assume the royal identity was identified as the royal sanctuaries of Upper and Lower Egypt, the Upper Egyptian Per-Wer, and the Lower Egyptian Per-Neser or Per-Nu. A scene from the bark chapel of Hatshepsut shows the queen "entering and leaving, the royal induction in the PerWer and the Per-Neser, in the two shrines of the south and the north." 2 0 4 203
Another version of this episode is found in the Festival Hall of Thutmose I I L 2 0 5 T h e text indicates that the sequence begins with the purification in the Per-Wer. Horus and Seth are then seen bearing first an empty carrying chair, with the following scene showing the king in the carrying chair, acclaimed by the souls of Pe as he is carried toward the shrines of Upper and Lower Egypt. A textual version of the same type of event is found in a simplified version in a text from the Pylon V I I : 2 0 6 " [ M y father] Amun-Re-Harakhty [has given to me] the appearance [on the Horus throne of the living], I having been inducted before him in the interior of the [temple], the authority over the Two Lands, the thrones of Geb and the offices of Khepri having been predicted for me at the side of my father the good god, King of Upper and Lower Egypt Aakheperenre, given life forever." T h e coronation culminated with the establishment of the royal titulary, as described by both Hatshepsut and Thutmose I I I . 2 0 7 In the Hatshepsut narrative, it is possible to discern another element of the coronation sequence as motif. There are several references to receiving the "portion" belonging to Horus and/or Seth, 2 0 8 with the two deities reverting to their archaic roles as the Two Lords. T h e "mixing" of the two crowns of Upper and Lower Egypt also carries the message of the union of the two lands. 2 0 9 T h e meeting of the two crowns and the assumption of the role of the Two Lords function as another form of the "union of the two lands" motif, used in the earliest coronation rituals. T h e themes of receiving the crown and the union of the two lands are brought together in the festival temple, 2 1 0 as the king and his ka are depicted on a "union" (sm3) sign while in an adjoining scene he is crowned by two gods. Another important element in the assumption of the kingship is the creation of the annals of the king. Thoth and his female partner, Seshat, document the kings millions of future Sed Festivals. 2 1 1 T h e king is seen inscribing his annals on, in one scene, the year staff given to him by Thoth and in another scene on a block of stone. T h e surviving texts clarify the tasks of the two gods, as Seshat, "foremost of the library," is said to either fill or provide the nostrils of the king, implying that the creation of the Annals is another formulation for providing the king with l i f e . 2 1 2
126 ^
thutmose
iii
A Heliopolitan version of this scene is introduced during the early part of the dynasty. 213 In this form it is the Ished tree that provides the writing material for the king s fate. The king receives his fate, as inscribed on the leaves of a persea tree. By the reign of Thutmose I I I , 2 1 4 the Ished tree motif has established itself as a variation of the Annals theme. When transposed to the Karnak obelisks of Hatshepsut, it is Amun who steps into the role of Atum and becomes the one who establishes the future of the queen. 2 1 5 One of the most important themes in the royal record is the construction and renewal of the monuments of the gods. The ritual that initiated these projects highlighted the role of the king as builder, as he laid out the floor plan together with the goddess Seshat and then reenacted key moments in the construction process. This ceremony ensured the tie between the king and his creation. This ceremony, known as the foundation ritual, is also well represented during this period. Like the coronation, the foundation ritual appears as early as the First Dynasty in the inscriptions of the Palermo Stone. As recorded there, it consisted of "planning," "stretching the cord" (performed by a priest of Seshat), the "opening of a lake," and the "spearing of the hippopotamus." 216 The basic elements of the ceremony had increased in number by the time of Thutmose I I I . 2 1 7 At Medinet Habu, 2 1 8 six scenes are associated with the foundation ritual. The king stretches the cord, dedicates the temple, hacks the earth, molds the bricks, and offers wine, and the ceremony is completed when a cattle offering is consecrated. In a text from Karnak, Thutmose III describes the ceremony: "His majesty himself performed with his (own) two hands, the Stretching of the Cord and the Releasing of the Cord that was placed on the ground." 2 1 9 The Sed Festival, often called a jubilee, is interpreted as a formal reinstatement of the king, with cultic reenactments that affirm his ability to rule. 2 2 0 It has a history extending back beyond the creation of the Egyptian state, with the Palermo Stone once again providing the earliest textual references. 221 A certain standardization of sequences belonging to this celebration can be discerned in the periodic presentation of this celebration. The earliest of these is found in the sun temple of Neuserre. 2 2 2 In his discussion of these sequences, Kaiser has delineated a number of elements distinctive to the Sed Festival, including the foundation ceremony and cattle inspection scenes. 223 Sequences (discussed earlier as part of the coronation) are, in the Fifth Dynasty context, regarded as part of the Sed Festival. The "bringing and ascending of the carrying chair" is a distinctive element that certainly corresponds with scenes from the Festival Hall. 2 2 4 There are others as well, such as the localization of the event to the Per-Wer and the presence of the
Religion and Cult during the Time of Thutmose III
^
149
gods and goddesses representing Upper and Lower Egypt, Horus of Edfu, Seth of Ombos, Nekhbet, and Wadjit. 2 2 5 Although some sequences are eloquent in their descriptions of this ceremony, the reality of these celebrations is difficult to pin down. Hornung and Stahelin have cataloged the documentation for the Sed celebration for both Hatshepsut and Thutmose III. 2 2 6 Pillar inscriptions from Deir elBahari, as well as the queens northern obelisk, mention the "first occasion of the Sed Festival." 227 There are numerous references to the Sed Festival in the documentation of the reign of Thutmose III, including representations of the king in the short tunic typical of the occasion. 228 Reference to the first occasion of the Sed Festival is found in the Festival Hall, 2 2 9 while his third is named on the Heliopolitan obelisk now in London. 2 3 0 A partial depiction of what is likely to be a Sed Festival celebration for Thutmose III is found in the Festival Hall. 2 3 1 It begins as the king is led into the presence of the ennead by the Iunmutef priest. The make-up of this ennead is typically Theban, with a total of eighteen gods represented. 232 The next preserved sequence is a version of "running the course," consisting of three scenes. Thutmose III is first seen standing in front of the palace. The text reads: "He stands at the northern area." In the next scene the king is running, with half-sized figures of Thoth and the Southern Merit facing him. In discussing this sequence Kees notes that the initial scene is lacking. 233 It is, however, preserved in the Sed Festival sequence from Bubastis and shows the king entering the chapel of Wepwaut to be anointed before the ceremony. In the register directly beneath this, the king, wearing the Red Crown, moves toward the palace. In the following scene he is dressed in the Sed tunic. On the next wall he wears the White Crown, a short mantel wrapped around him so that only his hands are visible, holding the w35 scepter. This is followed by the king shooting an arrow to the west, assisted by Seth the Ombite. Two crossed arrows are seen lying on a shield-shaped target, with Horus of Edfu standing by. 2 3 4 The king then leaves as he came, with the next sequence showing him on the throne. As noted earlier, there were also individual ceremonies of a cultic nature that could be included as part of the Sed Festival or other occasions. They vary considerably in date of origin and frame of reference. All of these, however, were supportive of the theme of the endurance and triumph of the kingship. Among those acts performed by the king as part of the continual interchange of offerings and blessings is the "running the course." In these scenes the king is depicted, legs wide apart, running with objects in one or both hands. Included among these objects are one or more hes vases, a bird (often
126
^
thutmose
iii
identifiable as an Akh ibis), an oar, a hepet rudder, 2 3 5 a mekes document case, a bundle of four staves, and a flail. One scene, preserved from the bark chapel, shows Hatshepsut running with the Apis bull 2 3 6 and may document the earliest version of the ritual, as the Palermo Stone refers to the "running of the Apis," sometimes in association with the coronation. 2 3 7 Although the ceremony has an ancient connection to the coronation and Sed Festival, it is not restricted to that context, nor is Amun-Re the only beneficiary during this period. Hathor is among those deities for whom the king "runs the course." 2 3 8 In the area of the Sixth Pylon, the goddess greets the running king with a menât in her hand as two Ihys play the sistra. This act could also be placed within the context of the union of the two lands, as in one example where the king runs to Amun before Horus of E d f u on one wall and before Seth the Ombite on another. 239 Another version of this ceremony begins with the king approaching the bark of Amun. 2 4 0 Next he is seen "running the course to Bastet, that he may perform the giving of life." T h e remains of the text provide some clue as to the theme of the scenes, as it reads "their chiefs are bound under your sandals." 241 T h e inclusion of the bark suggests that the scene refers to a procession of the god. This ceremony is frequent in the material from this period. Its significance is, however, far from clear. Kees uses the more verbal Ptolemaic material to make a connection between the Akh ibis and the ka242 citing an E d f u text: "Take your divine image. I have brought to you your ka, that you might open the way for all the gods." 2 4 3 Two of the cultic acts most richly documented for this period have been discussed by Egberts, 2 4 4 where he, like Kees, relies on Ptolemaic sources to provide a referential frame for their meaning. T h e Meret chest ceremony and the ceremony of driving the calves are represented repeatedly in the material for both Thutmose III and Hatshepsut. 2 4 5 T h e ritual of the Meret chest is first found at Coptos, dated to Antef V Driving the calves dates back, however, to the Old Kingdom or before. 2 4 6 T h e heading for both rituals begins with the verb hwl, "to strike" or "to drive," in the case of the calves. Egberts suggests that the Meret chests had their origin in those chests shown carrying the grave gifts in burial procession scenes dated to the Old Kingdom. 2 4 7 Containing strips of red, white, and green cloth, representing mummy wrappings, the chests were important items in the preparation for burial. T h e chests are bound together by cloth or cord, referring perhaps to one pun on their name as "the bound one." There is also wordplay with t^mrt, "beloved land," one of the names of Egypt. Egberts points out that the chests, four in number, corresponding to the four cardinal points, had two intertwined interpretations. On the one hand they were the mummified,
Religion and Cult during the Time of Thutmose III
^
151
bound body of Osiris, and on the other they represented Egypt, made up of many regions. 248 Following this reasoning, the purpose of the ceremony was to assure the unity of Egypt as it was paralleled to the resurrection of Osiris. Egberts sees a number of interrelated themes in the ritual of driving the calves. 249 The king is depicted as a herdsman driving the four calves before him, threshing the grain. Egberts argues, however, that the treading of the calves crushes the worms that threaten the crops and, by extension, kills the "enemies" of the integrity of the state. Another theme links this ceremony to that of the Meret chest, with which it is often associated. Both, it is argued, refer to the mysteries of Osiris.The treading of the calves takes place over the tomb of the god, with the intention of hiding it from his enemies. Spread throughout the material are four a