THIN-WALLED STRUCTURES ADVANCES AND DEVELOPMENTS
Elsevier Science Internet Homepage http://www.elsevier.nl (Europe) http://www.eisevier.com (America) http://www.elsevier.co.jp (Asia) Consult the Elsevier homepage for full catalogue information on all books, journals and electronic products and services. Elsevier Titles of Related Interest
BAI Pipelines & Risers. ISBN: 008-043 712-5
MAKELAINEN & HASSINEN Light-Weight Steel and Aluminium Structures. (ICSAS '99). ISBN: 008-043014-7
CHAN & CHUI Non-Linear Static and Cyclic Analysis of Steel frames with Semi-Rigid Connections. ISBN: 008-042998-X
OHTSUBO & SUMI Proceedings of the 14th International Ship and Offshore Structures Congress. (3 Volume Set) ISBN: 008-043602-1
CHAN & TENG ICASS '99, Advances in Steel Structures. (2 Volume Set). ISBN: 008-043015-5
OWENS Steel in Construction (CD-ROM Proceedings with Printed Abstracts Volume, 268 papers).
DUBINA SDSS '99 - Stability and Ductility of Steel Structures.
ISBN: 008-042997-1
ISBN: 008-043016-3
SHANMUGAM, LIEW & THEVENDRAN Thin-Walled Structures: Research and Development.
FRANGOPOL, COROTIS & RACKWlTZ Reliability and Optimization of Structural Systems.
ISBN: 008-043003-1
ISBN: 008-042826-6
USAMI & ITOH Stability and Ductility of Steel Structures.
FUKUMOTO Structural Stability Design.
ISBN: 008-043320-0
ISBN: 008-042263-2
GODOY Thin-Walled Structures with Structural Imperfections: Analysis and Behavior. ISBN: 008-042266-7
KELLY & ZWEBEN Comprehensive Composite Materials
VASSALOS Contemporary Ideas on Ship Stability. ISBN: 008-043652-8
WATSON Practical Ship Design. ISBN: 008-042999-8
YOUNG Wind Generated Ocean Waves.
ISBN: 008-042993-9
ISBN: 008-043317-0
KO&XU Advances in Structural Dynamics (2 Volume Set) (ASD 2000).
ZHAO & GRZEBIETA Structural Failure and Plasticity (IMPLAST2000)
ISBN: 008-043792-3
ISBN: 008-043875-X
Related Journals Free specimen copy gladly sent on request. Elsevier Science Ltd, The Boulevard, Lang]'ord Lane, Kidlington, Oxford, OX5 1GB, UK
Applied Ocean Research Advances in Engineering Software CAD Coastal Engineering Composite Structures Computers and Structures Construction and Building Materials Engineering Failure Analysis Engineering Fracture Mechanics
Engineering Structures Finite Elements in Analysis and Design International Journal of Solids and Structures Journal of Constructional Steel Research Marine Structures NDT & E International Ocean Engineering Structural Safety Thin-Walled Structures
To Contact the Publisher Elsevier Science welcomes enquiries concerning publishing proposals: books, journal special issues, conference proceedings, etc. All formats and media can be considered. Should you have a publishing proposal you wish to discuss, please contact, without obligation, the publisher responsible for Elsevier's civil and structural engineering publishing programme:
Ian Salusbury Phone: +44 1865 843425 Senior Publishing Editor Fax: +44 1865 843920 Elsevier Science Ltd E.mail:
[email protected] The Boulevard, Langford Lane Kidlington, Oxford OX5 IGB, UK General enquiries, including placing orders, should be directed to Elsevier's Regional Sales Offices - please access the Elsevier homepage for full contact details (homepage details at the top of this page).
THIN-WALLED STRUCTURES ADVANCES AND DEVELOPMENTS Third International Conference on Thin-Walled Structures
Edited by
J. Zara~ Technical University of L6d~ Poland
K. Kowal-Michalska Technical University of L6d~ Poland
J. Rhodes University of Strathclyde, UK
e
2001
ELSEVIER Amsterdam
- London
- New
York-
Oxford
- Paris - Shannon
- Tokyo
ELSEVIER SCIENCE Ltd The Boulevard, Langford Lane Kidlington, Oxford OX5 IGB, UK
9 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
This work and the individual contributions contained in it are protected under copyright by EL~'-vierScience Ltd, and the following terms and conditions apply to its use: Photocopying Single photocopies of single chapters may be made for personal use as allowed by national copyright laws. Permission of the publisher and payment of a fee is required for all other photocopying, including multiple or systematic copying, copying for advertising or promotional purposes, resale, and all forms of document delivery. Special rates are available for educational institutions that wish to make photocopies for non-profit educational classroom use. Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier Science Rights & Permissions Departm~t, PO Box 800, Oxford OX5 IDX, UK; phone: (+44) 1865 843830, fax: (+44) 1865 853333, e-mail:
[email protected]. You may also contact Rights & Permissions directly through Elsevier's home page (http-3/www.eisevier.nl), selecting fn~t 'Customer Support', then 'General Information', then 'Permissions Query Form'. In the USA, users may clear permissions and make payments through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA; phone: (978) 7508400, fax: (978) 7504744, and in the UK through the Copyright Licensing Agency Rapid Clearance Service (CLARCS), 90 Tottenham C..ounRoad, London WIP OLP, UK; phone: (+44) 171 436 5931; fax: (+44) 171 436 3986. Other countries may have a local reprographic rights agency for payments. Derivative Works Subscribers may reproduce tables of contents for internal circulation within their institutions. Permission of the publisher is required for resale or distribution of such material outside the institution. Permission of the publisher is required for all other derivative works, including compilations and translatiom. Electronic Stmage or Usage Permission of the publisher is required to stme or use electronically any material contained in this work, including any chapter or part of a chapter. Contact the publisher at the address indicated. Except as outlined above, no part of this work may be ~:r stored in a reirieval system or trammitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, reconting or otherwise, without prior written permission of the publisher. Address pmuissiom ~ to: Elsevier Science Rights & Pmnim'om Department, at the mail, fax and e-mail addresses noted above. Notice No responsibility is assmned by the i~blisher for any injury and/or damage to p e n o u or ~ as a maUe of pnxhlcts liability, neglil~ce or otherwise, or from any use or opmmion of any methods, pmducm, instmcfiem or ideas contained in the material herein. llecmme of rapid advances in the medical ~ , in particular, bJdePesldemvedficmion of diagnmes and drag dmages sh~ be made"
First edition 2001 Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data A catalog record from the Library of Congress has been applied for. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record from the British Library has been applied for.
ISBN:
0-08- 043955-1
Transferred to digital printing 2005 Printed and b o u n d by A n t o n y R o w e Ltd, E a s t b o u m e
ORGANISING COMMITTEE Chairman
M. Kr61ak,
Co-Chairmen
J. Rhodes, J. Loughlan, K.P. Chong,
Director Secretary
J. Zara~ M. Marciniak
Members
R. Gr~dzki M. Jaroniek, Z. Kotakowski M. Kote|ko K. Kowal-Michalska T. Kubiak M. Macdonald J. Swiniarski A. 2:eligowski
INTERNATIONAL SCIENTIFIC COMMITTEE Chairman N. E. Shanmugam, Singapore Members W. Abramowicz, Poland M. A. Bradford, Australia Y. K. Cheung, Hong Kong China C. K. Choi, Korea J. M. Davies, United Kingdom P. J. Dowling, United Kingdom D. Dubina, Romania M. Eisenberger, Israel R. Evans, United Kingdom Y. Fukumoto, Japan K. Ghavami, Brazil N. K. Gupta, India G. J. Hancock, Australia J. E. Harding, United Kingdom T. H6glund, Sweden N. Jones, United Kingdom S. Kitipornchai, Australia R. A. LaBoube, USA L. Librescu, USA M. Mahendran, Australia A. Manevich, Ukraine
J. Murzewski, Poland R. Narayanan, India T. Pekfz, USA W. Pietraszkiewicz, Poland K. J. R. Rasmussen, Australia J. Rondal, Belgium J. Spence, United Kingdom J. Stupnicki, Poland C. Szymczak, Poland A. S. Tooth, United Kingdom V. Tvergaard, Denmark S. Ujihashi, Japan T. Usami, Japan G. I. van den Berg, South Africa R. Vaziri, Canada A. C. Walker, United Kingdom F. Werner, Germany T. Wierzbicki, USA H. D. Wright, United Kingdom W. W. Yu, USA J. Zielnica, Poland
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
vii
PREFACE
There has been a substantial growth in knowledge in the field of Thin-Walled Structures over the past few decades. Lightweight structures are in widespread use in the Civil Engineering, Mechanical Engineering, Aeronautical, Automobile, Chemical and Offshore Engineering fields. The development of new processes, new methods of connections, new materials has gone hand-in-hand with the evolution of advanced analytical methods suitable for dealing with the increasing complexity of the design work involved in ensuring safety and confidence in the finished products. Of particular importance with regard to the analytical process is the growth in use of the finite element method. This method, about 40 years ago, was confined to rather specialist use, mainly in the aeronautical field, because of its requirements for substantial calculation capacity. The development over recent years of extremely powerful microcomputers has ensured that the application of the finite element method is now possible for problems in all fields of engineering, and a variety of finite element packages have been developed to enhance the ease of use and the availability of the method in the engineering design process. This volume contains the papers presented at the Third International Conference on Thin-Walled Structures, Cracow, Poland on June 5-7, 2001. This is the third conference in the "Thin-Walled Structures" series, and is a sequel to the first two, which were held in Glasgow in 1996 and in Singapore in 1998. There are 83 papers of which 5 are Keynote papers. They are arranged in 12 sections as follows: Keynote Papers Analysis, Design and Manufacture Bridge Structures Cold-Formed Sections Composites Dynamic Loading (Cyclic, Impact and Vibration)
Finite Element Analysis Laminate and Sandwich Structures Optimization and Sensitivity Analysis Plate Structures Shell Structures Ultimate Load Capacity
The Conference is organised by the Department of Strength of Materials and Structures of the Technical University of L6d~., Poland jointly with the Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Strathclyde and the College of Aeronautics, Cranfield University, UK and is supported by the State Committee for Scientific Research of Poland. The Editors should like to express their appreciation of the role played by the International Journal "Thin-Walled Structures" in the propagation of research in this field and in providing the impetus for this Conference.
Jan Zara~ Katarzyna Kowal-Michalska Jim Rhodes
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CONTENTS
Preface
vii
Section I: KEYNOTE PAPERS
Shear Strength of Empty and Infilled Cassettes J.M. Davies and A.S. Fragos Stability and Ductility of Thin High Strength G550 Steel Members and Connections C.A. Rogers, D. Yang and G.J. Hancock
19
Thin-Walled Structural Elements Containing Openings N.E. Shanmugam
37
Sensitivity Analysis of Thin-Walled Members, Problems and Applications C. Szymczak
53
Some Observations on the Post-Buckling Behaviour of Thin Plates and Thin-Walled Members 3. Rhodes
69
Section II" ANALYSIS, DESIGN AND MANUFACTURE
Residual Stresses in Unstiffened Plate Specimens M.R. Bambach and K.J.R. Rasmussen
87
Behaviour and Design of Valley-Fixed Steel Cladding Systems M. Mahendran and D. Mahaarachchi
95
Behaviour of Flexible Thin-Walled Steel Structures for Road and Railway Applications J. Vaslestad, B. Bednarek and L. Janusz
103
A Simplified Computation Model for Arch-Shaped Corrugated Shell Roof Fan Xuewei
109
Fabrication Accuracy and Cost of Thin-Walled Steel Plate Girders in Shop Assembling K. Yoshikawa and S. Shimizu
119
Section III: BRIDGE STRUCTURES
Web Breathing as a Fatigue Problem in Bridge Design U. Kuhlmann and H.-P. Giinther
129
Erosion of the Post-Buckled Reserve of Strength of Thin-Walled Structures due to Cumulative Damage M. ~kaloud and M. Z6rnerov6
137
Evaluation of Strength and Ductility Capacities for Steel Plates in Cyclic Shear T. Usami, P. Chusilp, A. Kasai and T. Watanabe
145
A Rational Model for the Elastic Restrained Distortional Buckling of Half-Through Girder Bridges Z. VrceO"and M.A. Bradford
153
Instability Testing of Steel Plate Girders with Folded Webs T. Yabuki, Y. Arizumi, J.M. Aribert and S. Guezouli
161
Section IV: COLD-FORMED SECTIONS
Modelling of the Behaviour of a Thin-Walled Channel Section Using Beam Finite Elements H. Deg~e
171
Codification of Imperfections for Advanced Finite Analysis of Cold-Formed Steel Members D. Dubina, V. Ungureanu and 1. Szabo
179
Innovative Cold-Formed Steel Structure for Restructuring of Existing RC or Masonry Buildings by Vertical Addition of Supplementary Storey D. Dubina, V. Ungureanu, M. Georgescu and L. Fiilb'p
187
EC.3-Annex Z Based Method for the Calibration of (a) Generalized Imperfection Factor in Case of Thin-Walled Cold-Formed Steel Members in Pure Bending M. Georgescu and D. Dubina
195
Design Aspects of Cold-Formed Portal Frames P. Frti and L. Dunai
203
Local Buckling and Effective Width of Thin-Walled Stainless Steel Members H. Kuwamura, Y. lnaba and A. lsozaki
209
Bifurcation Experiments on Locally Buckled Z-section Columns K.J.R. Rasmussen
217
Buckling Load Capacity of Stainless Steel Columns Subject to Concentric and Eccentric Loading J. Rhodes, M. Macdonald, M. Kotetko and W. McNiff
225
Experimental Behavior of Pallet Racks and Components K. S. (Siva) Sivakumaran
233
Structural Behaviour of Cold-Formed Steel Header Beams S.F. Stephens and R.A. LaBoube
241
Compression Tests of Thin-Walled Lipped Channels with Return Lips J. Yan and B. Young
249
Experimental Investigation of Stainless Steel Circular Hollow Section Columns B. Young and W. Hartono
257
Section V: COMPOSITES
A Model for Ferrocement Thin Walled Sructures D. Abruzzese
269
Effects of Manufacturing Variables on the Service Reliability of Composite Structures A.R.A. Arafath, R. Vaziri, H. Li, R.O. Foschi and A. Poursartip
277
Post-Failure Analysis of Thin-Walled Orthotropic Structural Members M. Kotetko
285
Modal Coupled Instabilities of Thin-Walled Composite Plate and Shell Structures M. Kr6lak, Z. Kotakowski and M. Kotetko
293
Induced Strain Actuation and its Application to Buckling Control in Smart Composite Structures J. Loughlan and S.P. Thompson
301
Failure Analysis of FRP Panels with a Cut-out Under Static and Cyclic Load A. Muc, P. Kcdziora, P. Krawczyk and M. Sikoh
313
Some New Applications of the Theory of Thin-Walled Bars J.B. Obrqbski
321
Buckling Behaviour of Thin-Walled Composite Columns Using Generalised Beam Theory N. Silvestre, D. Camotim, E. Batista and K. Nagahama
329
Shear Connection Between Concrete and Thin Steel Plates in Double Skin Composite Construction H.D. Wright, A. Elbadawy and R. Cairns
339
Section Vl: DYNAMIC LOADING (CYCLIC, IMPACT AND VIBRATION)
Regular and Chaotic Behaviour of Flexible Plates J. Awrejcewicz, V. A. Krysko and A. V. Krysko
349
Seismic Performance of Arc-Spot Weld Deck-to-Frame Connections W.F. Bond, C.A. Rogers and R. Tremblay
357
Dynamic Buckling and Collapse of Rectangular Plates Under Intermediate Velocity Impact S. Cui, H. Hao and H.K. Cheong
365
Structural Optimization of Thin Shells Under Dynamic Loads S.A. Falco, Luiz E. Vaz and S.M.B. Afonso
373
Vibrations of Compressed Sandwich Bars J. Hahkkowiak and F. Roman6w
381
Numerical Simulation of Damaged Steel Pier Using Hybrid Dynamic Response Analysis T. Ikeuchi and N. Nishimura
391
xii Cyclic Response of Metal-Clad Wood-Framed Shear Walls W. Pan and K.S. (Siva) Sivakumaran
399
Vibration of Imperfect Structures J. Ravinger and P. Kleiman
407
Section VII: FINITE ELEMENT ANALYSIS
The Finite Element Method for Thin-Walled Members - Basic Principles M.C.M. Bakker and T. Pek6z
417
Nonlinear Analysis of Locally Buckled I-Section Steel Beam-Columns A.S. Hasham and K.J.R. Rasmussen
427
The Finite Element Method for Thin-Walled Members - Applications A.T. Sarawit, Y. Kim, M.C.M. Bakker and T. PekOz
437
Finite Element Methods for the Analysis of Thin-Walled Tubular Sections Undergoing Plastic Rotation T. Wilkinson and G. Hancock
449
On Finite Element Mesh for Buckling Analysis of Steel Bridge Pier E. Yamaguchi, Y. Nanno, H. Nagamatsu and Y. Kubo
459
Section Vlll: LAMINATE AND SANDWICH STRUCTURES
The Elasto-Plastic Postbuckling Behaviour of Laminated Plates Subjected to Combined Loading R. Grqdzki and K. Kowal-Michalska
469
Axial Post-Buckling of Thin Orthotropic Cylindrical Shells with Foam Core X. Huang and G. Lu
477
Nonlinear Stability Problem of an Elastic-Plastic Sandwich Cylindrical Shell Under Combined Load L. Jaskuta and J. Zielnica
483
Buckling Analysis of Multilayered Angle-Ply Composite Plates H. Matsunaga
491
Optimum Design for Laminated Panel with Cutout: The Genetic Algorithm Approach Z Li and P. W. Khong
499
The Effect of Membrane-Flexural Coupling on the Compressive Stability of Anti-Synunetric Angle-Ply Laminated Plates J. Loughlan
507
Homogeneous and Sandwich Elastic and Viscoelastic Annular Plates Under Lateral Variable Loads D. Pawlus
515
xiii Local Buckling Behaviour of Sandwich Panels N. Pokharel and M. Ma;:endran
523
Section IX: OPTIMIZATION AND SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS
Optimal Design of Steel Telecommunication Towers by Interior Point Algorithms for Non-Linear Programming N.A. Cerqueira, G.S.A. Falcon, J.G.S. da Silva and F.J. da C.P. Soeiro
533
Design Optimisation of Shell Structures with Dimensional Analysis Resources M.P.R. C. Gomes
541
Vector Optimization of Stiffened Plates Subjected to Axial Compression Load Using the Canadian Norm S.A. Falco and K. Ghavami
549
Bicriteria Optimization of Sandwich Cylindrical Panels Aided by Expert System R. Kasperska and M. Ostwald
559
Shaping of Open Cross Section of the Thin-Walled Beam with Flat Web and Multiplate Flange E. Magnucka-Blandzi, R. Krupa and K. Magnucki
567
Two-Criteria Optimization of Thin-Walled Beams-Columns Under Compression and Bending A.1. Manevich and S. V. Raksha
575
Optimization of Volume for Composite Plated and Shell Structures A. Muc and W. Gurba
585
Sensitivity Analysis of Structures Made of Thin-Walled E-Profiles K. Rzeszut, W. Kqkol and A. Garstecki
593
Section X: PLATE STRUCTURES
Buckling Loads of Variable Thickness Plates A. Alexandrov and M. Eisenberger
603
Buckling and Post-Buckling Behavior of Plates on a Tensionless Elastic Foundation A.S. Holanda and P.B. Gonfalves
611
Degree of Wall Joint Work Together with Stiffening Rib in Steel Bunker M.1. Kazakevitch and D.O. Bannikov
619
Pure Distortional Buckling of Closed Cross-Section Columns K. Takahashi, H. Nakamura and K. lmamura
623
Elasto-Plastic Large Deflection of Uniformly Loaded Sector Plates G.J. Turvey and M. Salehi
631
xiv Section XI: SHELL S T R U C T U R E S
Validation of Analytical Lower Bounds for the Imperfection Sensitive Buckling of Axially Loaded Rotationally Symmetric Shells G.D. Gavrylenko and J.G.A. Croll
643
On the Analysis of Cylindrical Tubes Under Flexure F. Guarracino and M. Fraldi
653
Buckling of Aboveground Storage Tanks with Conical Roof L.A. Godoy and J. C. Mendez-Degr6
661
On the Collapse of a Reinforced Concrete Digester Tank L.A. Godoy and S. Lopez-Bobonis
669
Closed Cylindrical Shell Under Longitudinal Self-Balanced Loading V.L. Krasovsky and G. K Morozov
677
Coupled Instability of Cylindrical Shells Stiffened with Thin Ribs (Theoretical Models and Experimental Results) A.1. Manevich
683
Instability Modes of Stiffened Cylindrical Shells J. Murzewski
693
Refined Strain Energy of the Shell R.A. Walentyhski
701
Numerical and Experimental Studies on Generalised Elliptical Barrelled Shells Subjected to Hydrostatic Pressure P. Wang
709
Section XII: ULTIMATE LOAD CAPACITY
Experimental Techniques for Testing Unstiffened Plates in Compression and Bending M.R. Bambach and K.J.R. Rasmussen
719
Effects of Anchoring Tensile Stresses in Axially Loaded Plates and Sections M.R. Bambach and K. J.R. Rasmussen
729
A Probabilistic Approach to the Limit State of Centrally Loaded Thin-Walled Columns Z. Kala, J. Kala, B. Teplf4 M. ,qkaloud
739
Rotational Capacity of I-Shaped Aluminium Beams: A Numerical Study G. De Matteis , V. De Rosa and R. Landolfo
747
Author Index
757
Keyword Index
759
Section I KEYNOTE PAPERS
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Third International Conferenceon Thin-WalledStructures J. Zarag, K. Kowal-Michalskaand J. Rhodes 9 2001 ElsevierScience Ltd. All rights reserved
SHEAR STRENGTH OF EMPTY AND INFILLED CASSETTES J M Davies and A S Fragos Manchester School of Engineering, University of Manchester Manchester M13 9PL, UK
ABSTRACT This paper considers the shear buckling of light gauge steel cassette sections both with and without an infilling of relatively rigid thermal insulation. In cassette construction, In-plane shear stresses usually arise as a consequence of stressed skin (diaphragm) action and, in this context, it is local buckling of the wide flange that usually governs the design. Although there are some rudimentary equations for the shear strength of plain cassettes in Part 1.3 of Eurocode 3, this is a subject that is not fully understood and which raises some fundamental questions such as: What are the boundary conditions for plate buckling - is it sufficient to consider individual plate elements or is it necessary to consider the whole section? Is it sufficient to neglect the post-buckling strength or should this be incorporated in the design equations, as it is for plate elements in compression? How can the favourable interaction with a relatively rigid, thermally-insulating infill be incorporated in the design equations? Thus, this Keynote paper addresses some fundamental questions using the title topic to provide an illustration of the principles involved.
KEYWORDS Buckling, cassettes, finite element analysis, insulation, polystyrene, post-buckling, shear, steel, testing.
INTRODUCTION Typical cassette wall construction is illustrated in Figure 1. The first author has been interested in this form of construction for many years and has written a number of papers (eg Davies 1998a, Davies 1998b, Davies 2000a) advocating this method for houses and other low-rise commercial buildings. He has also been responsible for the structural design of a number of projects incorporating this form of load-bearing wall construction. This has led to a detailed study of the design of these structural elements. The design of light gauge steel cassettes (sometimes also known as structural liner trays) subject to axial load, bending or shear, is covered in Part 1.3 of Eurocode 3 (1996) (EC3). Figure 2 shows the most general form of a cassette section. The range of validity of the design procedures in EC3 is stated to be as follows:
0.75 mm 30 mm 60 mm 300 mm
< < < <
tnom bf
~ ~
1.5 mm 60 a n n
h bu I/b. h~ Sl
_< -< < _< <
200 mm 600 turn 10 rlq_/rl4/n'lnl h/8 1000 mm
where I, is the second moment of area of the wide flange about its own centroid as shown in the right hand insert on Figure 2.
L/~ C-shaped ~'~! ~ cassette
l lll
[Floor
. . . .
Figure 1" Cassette wall construction
A b!
Narrowflange
~_F- Lip
Wideflange
L
J Figure 2: Typical cassette section
However, the somewhat simplistic treatment in EC3 conceals a number of aspects of the design of these interesting elements which are only partly understood. In the case of cassettes subject to shear as a consequence of stressed skin (diaphragm) action, local buckling of the wide flange is usually critical. Here, the code offers the well-known "simplified Easley equation" which is safe but the subject is worthy of more detailed investigation bearing in mind that it fails to address the significance of such matters as boundary conditions and post-buckling behaviour. This paper approaches the subject in a more fundamental manner by considering the shear buckling of the basic plate element with different boundary conditions. The results of a number of tests with idealised boundary conditions are compared with alternative analytical approaches. This leads to a more fundamental understanding of the problem. The investigation is initially confmed to plane flanges. Flanges with rolled-in stiffeners will be the subject of a subsequent investigation. Cassettes may be advantageously infilled with rigid insulation (rigid plastic foam or mineral wool). This has the advantage of stabilising the wide flange against all modes of local buckling including shear. Both the test programme and the subsequent analysis included consideration of infilling with foams of different densities.
OVERVIEW OF THE BEHAVIOUR OF CASSETTE WALLS IN SHEAR A cassette wall assembly is a ready-made shear panel or 'diaphragm' for stressed skin construction (Davies and Bryan 1981). Stressed skin design is explicitly allowed in EC3 and appropriate enabling clauses are included in section 9. EC3 also includes somewhat rudimentary provisions for cassettes acting as shear panels. These make it clear that the behaviour of a cassette wall panel in shear is not significantly different from that of a conventional shear panel comprising trapezoidal steel sheeting framed by appropriate edge members so that the procedures described in any of the definitive publications (eg ECCS 1995) may be used. There are three main differences between cassette systems and the trapezoidally profiled roof sheeting and decking for which the calculation procedures were originally devised: 9
There is negligible flexibility due to shear distortion of the profile. This removes a design equation which tends to dominate the deflection calculation for trapezoidal profiles. Here it is possible to make a simplified estimate of deflections based on the assumption that the flexibility arises mainly in the fastenings.
9
The strength calculation tends to be dominated by the tendency of the wide flange to buckle locally in shear before any of the more usual diaphragm failure modes (fastener failure, profile end failure or global shear buckling) are mobilised.
9
There is often no separate longitudinal edge member. This means that there are no longitudinal edge fasteners to check and the web and narrow flange of the outermost cassette act as their own edge member which should be checked for the induced compressive force.
The first two of these considerations lead to the two equations given in EC3 for the ultimate and serviceability limit states respectively. These equations may be derived from the more familiar equations as follows: Baehre (1987) shows that the simplified Easley equation is valid for the determination of the shear flow Tv,sd to cause local buckling:-
_
Tv, Rd -
36 4~D x 3 ~ u2 Dy
where D x = bending stiffness across the wide flange
Dy = bending stiffness along the wide flange =
(1)
E Ix
bu Et 3
=
12(1 - v 2)
Et 3 10.96
I, = second moment of area of the wide flange about its own centroid.
Thus:
Tv, Rd =
4 ~10.963
lit
9 bu
= 6E
I,
(2)
This is the equation in clause 10.3.5 of EC3. It should be noted here that this equation is printed incorrectly in both Baehre's paper and in the original printing of EC3. It is corrected in the Corrigenda
to ENV 1993-1-3 dated 1997-02-25. For the calculation of deflection, Baehre (1987) considered the following four components of shear flexibility (Davies and Bryan 1981, ECCS 1995, etc): 9
c~.2
shear strain
9
c2.1
flexibility of the sheet end fasteners
9
C2.2
flexibility of the seam fasteners
9
C2.3
flexibility of the "shear connector" (longitudinal edge) fasteners
He showed that all are of similar magnitude and stated (without further explanation) that their resultant stiffness could be approximated by:
Sv =
2000 L b u E s(b - bu) (N/mm)
(3)
which is the equation to be found in clause 10.3.5 of the EC3. This rather crude approach to stiffness appears to be justified because, in the absence of the distortion term, the deflections tend to be small and because cassettes tend to be of fairly similar proportions and to have similar fastening systems, the individual fasteners of which have similar flexibilities. However, this simplification is not essential and, if the deflections are at all critical, the more fundamental approach to the calculation of deflections given in the definitive References is to be preferred. More importantly, the wording of the clauses in Eurocode 3, and the above equation for the shear flow to cause local buckling, may lead designers to overlook that fastener strength may also be critical. In addition to considering local buckling of the wide flange, it is essential also to consider the possibility of failure in each of the fastener failure modes considered in conventional stressed skin theory, namely: failure in the seam fasteners between adjacent cassettes failure in the fasteners connecting the ends of the cassettes to the foundation or the primary structure 9
failure in the shear connector (longitudinal edge fasteners)
It appears clear to the author that the excessive simplicity in the approach in EC3 to the design of cassettes subject to diaphragm action is likely to lead to a lack of fundamental understanding and overconfidence. The inevitable result will be serious design errors. However, this paper is primarily concerned with the local buckling phenomenon and the question of the design of fastening systems for cassette wall construction will not be pursued further.
METHODOLOGIES AVAILABLE FOR THE INVESTIGATION Davies (2000b) has reviewed the methodologies available for research into the stability of cold-formed steel structures. The following are available for this study:
Testing: Bearing in mind the influence of uncertain imperfections on buckling phenomena, the uncertainty of the boundary conditions for shear buckling and the interaction between unlike materials, testing will clearly have a major role to play in this research.
The finite element method: This is, of course, the obvious method for this type of research but care will be required when selecting the boundary conditions and dealing with the interface between unlike materials. Solutions of the governing differential equations: Early researchers into the shear buckling of thin plates used energy method solutions based on displacement functions in the form of a double sine series. This approach is clearly worthy of consideration for the more general situation considered here.
TEST P R O G R A M M E The apparatus and the initial test programme were described in Davies and Dewhurst (1997). Further testing using the same apparatus, modified where necessary, was carried out by Fragos (2000). This paper makes reference to the results of both test series, 50 tests in all. Figure 3 shows photographs of the test rig together with a typical buckled specimen and Figure 4 shows a cross-section through it.
Figure 3: View of the test rig showing specimen under test with short ends clamped
Shortage of space precludes a full description of the test procedure and results but the following points may be noted: The boundary conditions are evidently critical. It was considered to be appropriate to attempt to obtain a fully fixed condition along the longitudinal edges in order to allow easier comparison with available theories. The test results suggest that this was achieved, at least as far as initial buckling is concerned.
The short edge boundary condition is also significant. Both the free and restrained conditions were available and both were tested. The restrained condition was obtained by clamping the free edge of the cassette between two metal strips. Tests were carried out with the empty tray and 3 grades of expanded polystyrene foam infllling. The test specimens were produced in-house using a folding press. The width was constant at 400 mm and the length was varied. The majority of the tests were carried out with a length of 2400 mm but lengths of 1600 mm and 800 mm were also used. The metal thickness was varied in the range 0.73 to 1.27 mm.
Figure 4: Cross-section through the test rig
It was found to be rather difficult to identify the experimental buckling load. A number of different shapes of load-deflection curves were obtained and Figure 5 is fairly typical. The construction used to estimate the buckling load is also shown. There is evidently a significant amount of post-buckling strength. The general pattern of the results was the same while the boundary conditions and foam infllling were varied although there were some difficulties with the strongest 250f foam. This was significantly stronger than the alternative SDVB and HDN foams and breakdown of the Bostik D adhesive bond led to a greater scatter of the test results than was observed with the more usual foam insulants. The influence of the foam is considerable, particularly with thinner metal and/or the higher grades of foam. Figure 6 shows a typical family of test results for 2400 mm long cassettes with four edges clamped. The results for two edges clamped and for other lengths were broadly similar.
16
~
i::l ~ i i : : J - ] ~ ~
'~ -.' S
-
iii~ii 6
I
',
',
t.dr",
i-~1
...!. i - - i i ' i " l i
"
0
9
0,~5
'liiiii
i
I ', ', i
',
I ',
} I i. . .i . i i
! ! ! I
i i I
i
[ !
! I : : : : ~
',
',
4] ri'iiii"iii'!",i 2 -it
illiiil
9
"
1,5
!i!!i!i
i
|
2
2,S
"'|
1
i
,
o
'
''
i
3
Deformation z-axis (ram)
Figure 5" Typical test result: Load versus longitudinal shear deflection
Figure 6: Critical buckling loads of cassettes with four edges clamped Figure 6 needs to be interpreted in the light of the properties of the foams used in the tests. These were standard products obtained from a major manufacturer, Vencil Resil Ltd, UK, and the properties, as delivered, were determined using the procedures described in the European Recommendations (CIB 1995). The results are summarised in Table 1 and it is these values that were used in the finite element analyses which are described later in this paper.
Material
Density kg/m3
Compressive modulus N/ram 2
15 21.3 44.4
2.73 3.87 14.8
Tensile modulus N/ram 2
Shear modulus N/mm 2
11.0 8.04 10.3
8.11 4.58 13.6
.....
SDVB
HDN 250f
~,,
Table 1" Material properties of the foams - as used in the numerical modelling
10 The properties of the steel were also measure in both the longitudinal and transverse directions using the standard tensile test. The average measured values were: Transverse
Longitudinal
Yield stress
Thickness
(ram)
Tensile modulus
Yield stress
Tensile modulus
(N/mm2)
(N/ram 2)
fN/mm 2)
0.73 0.80 1.27
188 202 183
144 220 253
189 210 187
155 216 253
(Nlmm 2)
For the theoretical analysis described later, a bi-linear stress-strain curve was assumed with the average values of modulus and yield stress from the longitudinal and transverse directions.
SHEAR BUCKLING OF THIN METAL PLATES Southwell and Skan (1924) obtained the first exact solution for the shear buckling of an infinitely long plate. They showed that the buckling stress is given by: 1:cr =
where
D K b t E v
Et 3
=
~2D
K-b2t
= flexural stiffness of the plate
12(1 - v 2) is is is is is
a non-dimensional buckling stress coefficient the width of the plate the thickness of the plate the elastic modulus of the metal of the plate Poisson's ratio
Figure 7: Local shear buckling of infinitely long thin plates
(4)
It was found that the buckled plate developed a series of inclined waves, as shown in Figure 7, whose wavelength Lcr varied as the boundary condition along the lOngitudinal edge varied from simply supported (Lcr = 1.33b) to fixed (Lc~ = 0.80b). The value of the buckling coefficient K was found to be 5.35 for a simple support and 8.98 for a clamped support. Various authors have continued this work, considering plates of finite length 'a' and alternative boundary conditions. For all situations, including those where the buckled plate element is stiffened by rigid insulation, the basic pattern of inclined waves remains the same. The results are invariably expressed in terms of the buckling coefficient 'K'. Fragos (2000) has reviewed this work and compared it with the results of his own extensive finite element analyses. He has shown that an accurate value for 'K' is given by expressions of the form: K
= tt+e
where ct and 13 depend on the boundary conditions: Boundary condition 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
All edges simply supported All edges rigidly clamped Two long edges clamped, two short edges simply supported Two long edges simply supported, two short edges clamped One long edge rigidly clamped, other edges simply supported One short edge rigidly clamped, other edges simply supported
tx 4.188 7.868 7.980 4.089 6.209 4.262
1.64 1.92 1.53 2.14 1.56 1.90
The test results for boundary conditions 2 and 3 are in accordance with the above formulae. The finite element analysis referred to above also serves as a partial validation for the more general finite element analysis which follows.
FINITE ELEMENT ANALYSIS FOR INFILLED CASSETTES WITH IDEALISED BOUNDARY CONDITIONS After various trials, the finite element analysis reported in this paper was carried out using the ANSYS 5.4 package using the "SHELL93" 8-node shell element for the metal skin of the cassettes and the "SOLID95" 20-node solid element for the foam infill. Some numerical experiments were carried out using the "CONTA174" 8-node surface-to-surface contact element to represent the surface contact between the foam core and the skin of the cassettes. However, it was found that this was not particularly useful except for some cases with the strong 250f foam where loss of adhesive bond contributed to the failure. A convergence study was carried out in order to determine the minimum number of elements that could be used to obtain an accurate and stable result with a reasonable computation time. It was found that elements measuring 5 cm x 5 cm were adequate, giving 48 x 8 = 384 elements in the wide flange and a further 192 elements in the webs, where these are relevant. Two types of analysis were used in this study. The critical buckling load can be obtained from an eigenvalue bifurcation buckling analysis but it is also interesting to carry out a full non-linear analysis with large deflection effects using Newton-Raphson iteration. This, of course, allows the post-buckling behaviour to be considered. Whenever the full non-linear analysis was used, an initial bifurcation
12 analysis was carried out first. This determined the critical buckling mode and allowed an arbitrary imperfection to be introduced which mobilised the critical mode at the outset of the calculation. The buckled shapes found in this way were invariably similar to those observed in the tests. However, it has to be conceded that the correlation between the experimental and theoretical load deflection curves was not good and that there was much more post-buckling strength in theory than was observed in the tests. The only explanation that can be offered for this is that the longitudinal edge fixity, which certainly approximated to the fully clamped case at initial buckling, broke down as the buckling increased thus leading to a "premature" failure.
Foam None
SDVB m
HDN
250f
Thickness
P o, (test)
Per (FE)
(mm)
(kN)
(kN)
(%)
0.73 0.82 0.95 1.02 1.20 1.27
12.15 16.35
11.96 16.95 26.36 32.62 53.10 62.94
-1.56 +3.67
t
t
+1.46 +4.32 +5.61
38.0 52.0 62.8
28.54 33.80 43.31 49.50 69.40 78.87
+5.70
29.0
t t
t t
-1.89
63.0
0.73 0.82 0.95 1.02 1.20 1.27
t 32.15 50.9 59.6 27.0
t t 50.5
t 81.15
0.82 0.95 1.20 1.27
38.4 49.7
0.82 0.95 1.20 1.27
78.8 107.2
t t
t t
Difference
Pult (test)
P~t (FE)
(kN)
(kN)
12.5 18.0
32.9 44.6 71.6 82.7 126 163
t
t
-2.81
130
40.73 50.31 76.89 86.47
+6.07 +1.23
42.4 57.5
t t
t t
96.03 110.0 142.0 152.9
+21.9 +2.62
81.5 118
t t
t t
78.5 90.0 111 126 191 236 102 128 198 218 244 270 331 387
Note: t indicates that no test was carded out for this arrangement Table 2: Test results: Two long edges clamped, two short edges free It is well-known that the development of post-buckling shear strength in the webs of plate girders requires a fully anchored tension field. It appears evident that, here, the arrangement shown in Figure 4 was not sufficiently strong for this tension field to be fully activated. However, this injects a certain realism into the study and it may be concluded that the full theoretical post-bucking strength cannot be relied upon, even under the "idealised" fully fixed conditions of the tests. However, some postbuckling strength may still be available under more realistic boundary conditions approximating to practice. This, of course, requires further investigation. For the above reasons, although the ultimate load conditions are included for completeness in Tables
13 2 and 3, which summarise the test results and the theoretical comparisons for panels of length 2400 mm and width 400 mm, no detailed consideration is given tO the theoretical ultimate loads and discussion is confined to the buckling values.
Foam
Per (test) (kN)
Per (FE) (kN)
Difference
(%)
Pu~t(test) (kN)
Puk (FE) (kN)
0.73 0.82 0.95 1.02 1.20 1.27
13.20 19.67
13.54 19.19 29.84 36.94 60.14 71.28
+2.58 -2.44
16.0 22.9
-0.43
41.0
37.2 50.3 78.1 89.6 155 176
0.73 0.82 0.95 1.02 1.20 1.27
34.4
Thickness
(mm) None
SDVB
HDN
250f
t 37.1
t 69.8
t t 60.2 84.1
t
0.82 0.95 1.20 1.27
49.6
0.82 0.95 1.20 1.27
92.4
t 90.1
t t 156.9
t
33.47 39.67 50.94 58.30 82.04 93.35 47.44 59.06 90.64 102.1 113.5 129.3 166.6 179.3
t t
t
+2.12
100
-2.70
37.0
t t
t t
-3.16 -2.45
71.2 107
t
t
-4.35
56.0
t
t
+0.60
112
t
t
+22.8
100
t
t
+6.16
161
t
t
92.0 109 140 160 226 256 130 162 249 280 302 336 448 483
Table 3" Test results: All four edges clamped Evidently, the finite element predictions of the buckling load are adequate for all practical purposes. This method, based on the critical buckling load, therefore provides the basis for an accurate design procedure when more realistic boundary conditions are introduced in the next section of this paper.
FINITE ELEMENT ANALYSIS FOR REALISTIC BOUNDARY CONDITIONS Having effectively calibrated the finite element analysis for idealised, clamped longitudinal boundary conditions, the next step is to apply this analysis to more realistic boundary conditions approximating to those likely to arise in practice in a cassette wall or liner tray roof. A number of different boundary conditions were investigated before the one shown in Figure 8 was adopted for a detailed parametric study. This attempts to model the interaction between adjacent trays together with the usual seam fasteners placed somewhere between the middle of the web and the wide upper flange. Thus, at the middle of the web, complete positional and rotational restraint was applied. At the top of the web, only restraint in the transverse x-direction was applied while, at the bottom of the web, the corner had complete positional restraint though no rotational restraint. From the point of view of
14 initial buckling, it is the rotational restraint to the wide flange that is the most critical and, here, this is provided by the remainder of the section. The assumption of x-direction restraint only at the junction between the web and the wide flange may be less conservative when post-buckling is considered.
Figure 8: Boundary conditions used in the parametric study For the purposes of parametric study, the material properties were assumed to be identical to those used previously. The study covered empty cassettes and all three foam insulation materials together with the range of geometries defined in Figure 9. This represents a huge number of analyses and it is not appropriate to provide the detailed results here.
Figure 9: Range of geometries used in the parametric study Figure 10 shows a typical load deflection curve obtained from the full Newton-Raphson non-linear analysis of an HDN-filled cassette of length 1600 mm, width 600 mm and 1.0 mm metal thickness. The vertical axis labelled "time" is in effect the load axis as the value shown multiplied by the load in each sub-step gives the applied load. Evidently the buckling load is clearly defined and, because there was a small but significant difference between the critical buckling loads obtained from the full analysis and those obtained using an eigenvalue bifurcation analysis, the critical buckling loads deduced from the full non-linear analysis were used for the detailed study which follows. The results of many such analyses were processed and it was found that the following equation gave an accurate account of all of the buckling loads obtained: ~=
=
n2D 10 b2t
Ec Ec + 2.9-- - - t at
where
D
=
Et 3 12(I - v 2)
(6)
In Equation 6, the stiffening effect of the foam is described in terms of the compressive modulus Er of the insulant material. Various other core parameters were investigated and this was found to give the most consistent results. A typical comparison between the results given by the above equation and
15 those given by finite element analysis is shown in Figure 11 for 400 mm wide cassettes of different length stiffened by SDVB foam. The cases of empty cassettes and other foams are equally accurate over the range of widths considered. 00
h
700-~.
300 200
-
q~
O, 0,00
!
"|
0,20
I
0,40
9
0,60
'
0,80
1,00
~s~acemom (mm)
Figure 10: Typical load-deflection curve from non-linear analysis
150
r
11o
9
I
~0
-"
1200ram
Finite element
I-- . . . . . .
,38 43 ..... ~
C -2400mm ~
.-. 100 ~
2400ram./
- - I I - - 1600ram
C
-:~,
80
1600ram ~ - 1200ram ~
Equation 6 68,95 ~ ' ~
-
~" 60 40
20 0 0,5
0,7
0,9
11
13
15
1L7
T h i c k n e s s (It-m)
Figure 11" Critical buckling loads from finite element analysis and Equation 6
Equation 6 is clearly suitable for the practical design of infilled cassettes.
ENERGY METHOD OF ANALYSIS The fundamental differential equations for the shear buckling of thin metal plates have been given by Timoshenko and Gere (1961) and these equations have been used by other researchers. The general procedure for plates with simply supported edges is to use a double sine series displacement function:
16
w
= m~| m=ln=l
a
n~tYsm~ " b
(7)
where the x-coordinate is valid between 0 and a and the y-coordinate is valid between 0 and b. Using these equations, it is possible to determine expressions for the strain energy of bending of the buckled metal skin of the plate and the potential energy lost by the load. These equations contain a potentially infinite number of terms in which the unknowns are the constants am and, in order to obtain a satisfactory approximate solution, it is necessary to choose how many of these to use. Thus, for only two terms with constants al~ and a22, the error is approximately 15% and increases as the aspect ratio a/b increases. Increasing the number of terms increases the accuracy but the general characteristic that more terms are needed for higher aspect ratios persists. Fragos (2000) has shown that it is possible to add into the above procedure additional terms which represent the stiffening effect of the core. This is at the cost of considerable complexity in the equations so that the full analysis cannot be presented here. However, the results are encouraging. For a square panel of side 1 metre and metal thickness 8 mm stiffened by 100 mm of foam of shear modulus Ge = 5 N/mm 2 and compression modulus E e = 2.5 N/mm 2, the following results were obtained: Equation 6: Energy method with 2 terms: Energy method with 5 terms:
Per = 6.60 kN Per = 6.46 kN Per = 6.62 kN
However, as the aspect ratio a/b is increased, the accuracy drops quite quickly and it is necessary to use more terms. This has yet to be attempted.
CONCLUSIONS The study reported in this paper is of practical interest. Cassette wall construction has been used for more than 20 actual projects and some of these have used rigid foam infilling, albeit to improve the thermal performance, "feel" and resistance to damage rather than to improve the structural performance. However, as far as the authors are aware, it is also a relatively new research topic and no other investigations of the infilled case in particular are known. This has led to a number of fundamental considerations which have had to be addressed in order to allow the research to proceed and these are addressed in this paper. The authors consider that these have wider implications than to the specific and relatively narrow topic of the paper: The first author has believed for a long time that thin-walled metal members and structures act at their best when they are used in conjunction with other materials. The sandwich panel and the composite floor deck provide good examples of this principle. The rapid expansion in the usage of these components in recent years provides excellent proof that this principle is sound. The significant increase in the shear buckling strength occasioned by infilling cassettes with rigid foam insulant offers a further illustration of this principle. Although not part of this paper, it is clear that this foam infilling is also beneficial with respect to axial and bending loads. The use of testing as a research and development tool has declined dramatically in recent years. The reason for this is clear - testing is expensive and you can solve most problems more
17 cheaply using finite element analysis. You also obtain more quality information. However, there are still some problems which require the use of testing and the problem addressed in this paper is one of these. Although the initial shear buckling load of a cassette is not particularly sensitive to the boundary conditions, the post-buckling behaviour clearly is. Indeed, further testing and analysis is required before any practical appeal can be made to the post-buckling strength that is clearly present in cassette wall and roof construction. As expected, finite element analysis is directly relevant to the problem in question and an extensive parametric study provided the only practical way to obtain useful design equations. However, it is the authors' experience that, when addressing a new situation, most researchers find it difficult to get the boundary conditions right first time. In some cases, the appropriate boundary conditions can only be chosen with certainty after comparison with test results. Here, further research is required before the results given by the non-linear, large deflection analysis can be used with confidence. Direct solution of the governing differential equations is rarely useful in the design of thinwalled structural elements. The main exceptions to this general rule are in global (lateral and lateral-torsional) buckling problems and some simple cases of local buckling. Here, a series solution for local shear buckling in the presence of rigid foam stiffening appears to be possible though the complexity is such as to render it of questionable value in comparison to the results of parametric studies using the finite element method. From the practical point of view, the main outcome of the study reported in this paper is Equation 6 which is offered as a suitable design equation for the shear buckling of empty and infilled cassettes.
REFERENCES
Baehre R. (1987) "Zur Shubfeldwirkung und-bemessung von Kassettenkonstructionen" (On the behaviour and design of cassette assemblies in shear), Stahlbau 7, pp 197-202. CIB (1995) "Preliminary European Recommendations for sandwich panels with additional recommendations for panels with mineral wool core material: Part 1: Design", International Council for Building Research, Studies and Documentation, Publication No 148, Reprinted November 1995. Davies J. M. and Bryan E. R. (1981) "Manual of stressed skin diaphragm design", Granada. Davies J. M. and Dewhurst D. W. (1997) "The shear behaviour of thin-walled cassette sections infilled by rigid insulation", Proc. lnt. Conf. on Experimental Model Research and Testing of Thin-Walled Structures, Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, Prague, Sept., pp 209-216. Davies J. M. (1998a) "Light gauge steel cassette wall construction", Nordic Steel Construction Conference 98, Bergen, Sept. 14-16, pp 427-440. Davies J. M. (1998b) "Light gauge steel framing for house construction", 2nd Int. conf. on ThinWalled Structures, Singapore, pp 17-28. Davies J. M. (2000a) "Steel framed house construction", The Structural Engineer, Vol. 78, No. 6, 21 March, pp 17-24.
18 Davies J. M. (2000b) "Recent research advances in cold-formed steel structures", J Constructional Steel Research, Vol. 55, Nos 1-3, July-September, pp 267-288. ECCS (1995) "European recommendations for the application of metal sheeting acting as a diaphragm", European Convention for Constructional Steelwork Publication No. 88. Eurocode 3 (1996): Design of Steel Structures- Part 1.3 : General rules- Supplementary rules for cold formed thin gauge members and sheeting, CEN ENV 1993-1-3, February 1996. Fragos A.S. (2000) "The shear buckling of metal plates and empty and filled C-shaped sections", PhD Thesis, University of Manchester, November 2000. Southwell and Skan (1924) "On the stability under shearing forces of a flat elastic strip", Proc. Royal Society, A, Vol. 105, No. 733. Timoshenko S. P. and Gere J. M. (1961) "Theory of elastic stability", McGraw Hill, New York.
Third InternationalConferenceon Thin-WaUedStructures J. Zara~,K. Kowal-Michalskaand J. Rhodes 9 2001 ElsevierScienceLtd. All rightsreserved
19
STABILITY AND DUCTILITY OF THIN HIGH STRENGTH G550 STEEL MEMBERS AND CONNECTIONS C.A. Rogers2, D.Yang I and G.J. Hancock 1 IDepartment of Civil Engineering, University of Sydney NSW, Australia, 2006 2Department of Civil Engineering and Applied Mechanics, McGill University Montreal, Quebec, Canada,H3A 2K6
ABSTRACT High strength cold-reduced steel is typically of stress grade G550 (550 MPa nominal yield and tensile strength) and less than 1 mm thick. The steel has been used for many years for sheeting and decking but is now being used for structural members such as roof trusses and stud walls of steel framed houses. The paper summarises a major research program on the stability and ductility of this steel which has been proceeding for several years at the University of Sydney. The paper relates the Sydney research to the work of others being undertaken around the world. KEYWORDS High strength steel, stability, ductility, structural members, structural connections INTRODUCTION
G550 sheet steels (SA, 1993) are manufactured by cold reducing mild sheet steels 0or = 300 MPa) to a thickness which ranges from 0.42 mm to 1.0 mm. Cold reduction produces large deformations of the grain structure which cause an increase in yield stress and ultimate strength and a decrease in ductility. G550 sheet steels (0.48 mm _< t _< 0.75 mm) have recently been introduced for use as structural members in the Australian residential construction industry (Hancock and Murray, 1996), as well as for panel and deck sections in other types of building construction. The use of G550 sheet steels has been restricted to non-structural applications in most countries due to concerns regarding the ductility of members and connections, and possible problems with stability due to low strain hardening. Cold formed structural members are fabricated from sheet steels consisting of various material properties which must meet requirements prescribed in applicable design standards. The Australian/New Zealand Design Standard (SA/NZS, 1996) allows for the use of thin (t < 0.9 mm), high strength (fy = 550 MPa) sheet steels in all structural sections. However, due to the lack of ductility exhibited by sheet steels that are cold reduced in thickness, the engineer must use a yield stress and ultimate strength reduced to 75% of the minimum specified values. The American Iron and Steel Institute (AISI) Design Specification (1997) further limits the use of thin, high strength steels to roofing, siding and floor decking panels. Sheet steels are required to have minimum elongation
20 capability to ensure that members and connections can undergo small displacements without a loss in structural performance, and to reduce the harmful effects of stress concentrations. The ductility criterion specified in the Australian/New Zealand and North American (CSA, 1994; AISI, 1997) Design Standards is based on an investigation of sheet steels by Dhalla and Winter (1974a, b), which did not include the thin high strength G550 steels available today. However, Dhalla and Winter did test commercially available low ductility steel (A446 Grade E (1968) in 0.965 mm thickness- Type Z) which did not satisfy their elongation requirements, but was able to fully plastify for perforated longitudinal test specimens and reach 94% of the net cross-section tensile strength for transverse specimens. Early research by McAdam et al. (1988) on steels with a low fu/fy ratio led to the use of full strength design in Clause A3.3.1 of the AISI Specification for purlins and girts which are principally flexural members. The design of high strength steel compression members was not permitted. However, Daudet and Klippstein (1994) at Dietrich Industries Indiana included work on the stub column strength of sections used for stud walls in residential construction. The material studied had a tensile to yield stress ratio close to 1.0 rather than 1.08 as required by Section A3.3.1 of the AISI Specification. The study showed that steels having an fu/fy as low as 1.01 and elongations as low as 3 percent can be conservatively designed in compression using a reduced yield stress of 0.7fy. A series of research projects on profiled steel roof claddings constructed from G550 steel has been performed by Mahendran at Queensland University of Technology over a period of more than 10 years. These studies have included static behaviour of corrugated roofing under simulated wind uplift (Mahendran 1990), behaviour and design of crest-fixed profiled steel roof claddings under.wind forces (Mahendran, 1994) and pull-over strength of trapezoidal steel roof and wall claddings (Tang and Mahendran, 1999). Design formulae for the pull-over strength of crest fixed cladding have been developed which are directly applicable to G550 steel design. Recent research by Rogers and Hancock at the University of Sydney has included ductility of thin G550 sheet steels in tension including perforations (Rogers and Hancock, 1997), bolted connections in G550 sheet steels (Rogers and Hancock, 1998a), screwed connections in G550 sheet steels (Rogers and Hancock, 1999) and fracture in G550 sheet steel (Rogers and Hancock, 2001). This paper summarises the more important findings and proposed design rules from these studies. Research at the University of Missouri-Rolla by Wu, Yu and LaBoube (1996a, 1996b) on decking sections in flexure composed of ASTM A653 (1997) Structural Grade 80 steel has resulted in an exception clause being added to the latest update of the AISI Specification (AISI, 2000). This exception clause permits a reduced yield point (Rbfy) for computing the nominal flexural strength of multiple web configurations. The reduced yield point depends on the plate slenderness but is generally greater than the 75% discussed previously. Investigations by (Wu, Yu and LaBoube,1997, 1998) of these steels revealed that the full specified minimum yield point can be used to determine web crippling strength and shear strength. However, the latest update to the AISI Specification (AISI, 2000) still requires the reduction in the yield stress to 0.75fy. The compression stability of G550/Grade E steels with low strain hardening has only been investigated in the context of decking sections in bending. However, a research program at the University of Sydney on G550 steel in compression has recently commenced. Test specimens include square box type sections with glued and screwed comer connections. The results of these tests are being compared in the first instance with the RbFyapproach recently adopted in the AISI Specification. The preliminary results of this project are included in this paper.
21 MANUFACTURING PROCESS OF G550 SHEET STEEL G550 Sheet Steels
The usual process for the production of these steels is cold reduction. This process can be used to increase the strength and hardness, as well as to form an accurate thickness for sheet steels and other steel products. Initially the sheet steels are rolled to size in a hot strip mill with finishing and coiling temperatures of approximately 940~ and 670~ respectively. The hot worked coil of steel, typically 2.5 mm in thickness with a minimum specified 300 MPa yield stress, is uncoiled and cleaned in an acid solution to remove surface oxides and scale. The uncoiled strip is then trimmed to size and fed into a cold reduction mill, which may contain any number of stands. High compressive force in the stands and strip tension systematically reduce the thickness of the steel sheet until the desired dimension is reached, e.g. by approximately 85% for the 0.42 mm sheet steels. The milling process causes the grain structure of cold reduced steels to elongate in the rolling direction, which produces a directional increase in the material strength and a decrease in the material ductility. The effects of cold working are cumulative, i.e. grain distortion increases with further cold working as a result of an increase in total dislocation density, however, it is possible to change the distorted grain structure and to control the steel properties through subsequent heat treatment. Various types of heat treatment exist and are used for different steel products. G550 sheet steels are stress relief annealed, although recrystallisation does not occur. Stress relief annealing involves heating the steel to below the recrystallisation temperature, holding the steel until the temperature is constant throughout its thickness, then cooling slowly. Mild sheet steels of similar thicknesses are annealed to a greater extent in comparison with G550 sheet steels, and hence recover their ductile behaviour. Annealing is carried out in a hot dip coating line prior to application of either a zinc or aluminum/zinc coating. Upon final cooling the sheet steel is further processed through a tension levelling mill, e.g. 0.35% extension, to improve the finish quality and the flatness of the coil. The cold-reduced G550 sheet must be differentiated from other sheet steels whose high yield stress and ultimate strength values are obtained by means of an alloying process, i.e. high strength low alloy (HSLA) steels. The material property requirements for G550 or Grade E sheet steels are specified in Australia by AS 1397 (1993) and in North America by the following ASTM Standards; A611, A653, A792 and A875. Material property specifications for HSLA sheet steels can also be found in ASTM Standard A653. G550 DUCTILITY STUDIES
A recent study of G550 steel to AS 1397 in 0.42 mm and 0.60 mm thicknesses was performed by Rogers and Hancock (1997) to ascertain the ductility of G550 steel, and to investigate the validity of Clause 1.5.1.5(b) of AS/NZS 4600 and Section A3.3.2 of the AISI Specification. Three representative elongation distributions are shown in Fig. 1 for unperforated tensile coupons taken from 0.42 mm G550 steel in (a) the longitudinal rolling direction of the steel strip, (b) the transverse direction and (c) the diagonal direction. The coupons were each taken to fracture. In general, G550 coated longitudinal specimens have constant uniform elongation for each 2.5 mm gauge with an increase in percent elongation at the gauge in which fracture occurs as shown in Fig. 1(a). Transverse G550 specimens show almost no uniform elongation, but do have limited elongation at the fracture as shown in Fig. l(b). The diagonal test specimen results in Fig. 1(c) indicate that uniform elongation is limited outside of a 12.5 mm zone around the fracture while local elongation occurs in the fracture gauge as well as in the adjoining gauges. These results show that the G550 steel ductility is dependent upon the
22
direction from which the tensile coupons are obtained. The steel does not meet the Dhalla and Winter requirements described above except for uniform elongation in the longitudinal direction. Rogers and Hancock (1997) also investigated the tensile capacity of perforated coupons to determine whether the full fracture capacity could be developed at the net section. Coupons were taken in the longitudinal, transverse and diagonal directions as described in the preceding paragraph. Circular, square and diamond shaped perforations of varying sizes were placed in the coupons. It was found that despite the low values of elongation measured for this steel, the load carrying capacity of G550 steel as measured in concentrically loaded perforated tensile coupons can be adequately predicted using existing limit states design procedures based on net section fracture without the need to limit the tensile strength to 75% of 550 MPa as specified in Clause 1.5.1.5(b) of AS/NZS 4600 or Section A3.3.2 of the AISI Specification. 40.0 35.0
30.0 1
25.0 .~ 20.0 !
~i, ,5.o! ,o.o!
I
0.0 il.=l,l,ll,l,l,l,li.=,ll,ll,n,l,,,,,.,,,,,,,n,.,., 5.o
-50Jl'
' 3 '5' '7' '9' '11' 'i3 i5' '17' G u g e Number
'19
21' '23" '25 27.=
0.42 mm G550 Longitudinal 40.0 35,0 30.0 1
25.0 .=.=2ooi
I0.0 5.0 -5.0 Jl
3
5
7
9
il
I
13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27
Gauge Number
0.42 mm G550 Transverse 40.0 i 35.0
30.0 I
I
25.0 .-. 20.0
I
i,o ,In
0.0 v.... I,
-5.0 j I
3
5
7
9
I ! 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 Gauge Number
0.42 mm G550 Diagonal
Fig. 1 Elongation of 0.42 mm G550 Steel
23 BOLTED CONNECTION STUDIES
Background Recent research has been performed at the University of Sydney by Rogers and Hancock (1998a) on bolted connections of thin G550 and G300 sheet steels in 0.42 mm and 0.60 mm base metal thickness. This is the same steel as was used for the ductility studies described above. The test results indicate that the connection provisions in AS/NZS 4600 and the AISI Specification cannot be used to accurately predict the failure modes of bolted connections from thin G550 and G300 steels. Furthermore, the design rules cannot be used to accurately determine the bearing resistance of bolted test specimens based on a failure criterion for predicted loads.
Proposed Design Provisionsfor Bolted Connections Significantly unconservative predictions of the load resistance obtained for certain bolted connection test specimens have demonstrated a need for a gradated bearing coefficient which is dependent on the stability of the edge of the bolt hole. Unconservative predictions of connection bearing capacity have been recorded for bolted test specimens where thin sheet steels are connected and loaded in shear, as shown for the failure based criterion test-to-predicted results calculated using the AS/NZS 4600, AISI and Eurocode design standards for the 0.42 mm G550, 0.60ram G550, 0.60 mm (3300 test specimens, as well as the 0.80 mm G550 and 1.0 mm G550 test specimens (which all failed in bearing) (Rogers and Hancock, 1998a). A proposed method to accommodate for the change in bearing behaviour, that relies on the ratio of bolt diameter to sheet thickness, d/t, summarised here. This proposed method includes the gross yielding, Eq. 1, and the net section fracture, Eq. 2, failure provisions that are contained in the CAN/CSA-S136 design standard (1994), i.e. no stress reduction factor is used. Calculation of the end pull-out resistance follows the procedure given in the Eurocode design standard, Eq. 3. The recommended equations for gross yielding failure, net section fracture and end pull-out failure are as follows: Nt = Agfy
(I)
where Ag is the area of the gross cross-section andfy is the yield or 0.2% proof stress. Nt = Anfu
(2)
where An is the area of the net cross-section andfu is the ultimate strength. Vf= t ef. / 1.2
(3)
where t is the thickness of the thinnest connected part and e is the distance measured parallel to the direction of applied force from the centre of a standard hole to the nearest edge of an adjacent hole or to the end of the connected part. Modification of the existing bolted connection design provisions was made to the beating formulation. Beating stress ratios, fbu /fu, for some of the bolted connection test specimens that failed by bearing are illustrated in Figure 2. The bearing stress ratios for these specimem decrease as the thickness decreases, hence, a formulation to calculate a bearing coefficient, which is similar to that recommended in the CAN/CSA-S136 design standard, has been proposed and is shown in Fig. 3.
24 4.0 t
4.0 r
3.5 +
3.5 +
~
I
,)//
3.0
O End Pull-Out r'! Bearing I End Pull-Out
4600 l
~
" 2.0 1.5 !.0
1.0
0.5 0.0
0.0
0
!
2
4
3
5
6
0
I
'
:
,
,
2
3
4
5
e/d
eld
0.42 mm
0.80 mm
Figure 2 Bearing Stress Ratios for Various Sheet Steel (Full fu used)
:- Proposed :'
4.0
r~ 3.5
/
/
d / t ~: 10 : C = 3.0 10 < d/t < 22 9C = 4 - O. I d/t d/t :~ 22 : C = 1.8
!9 3.0
- A S / N Z S 4600, A I S I
' C=3.0
2.5 ~2.0 C = 2.5 o~ ~
CSA-S136-
1.5 1.0
d/t_< 1 0 : C = 3 . 0 10 < d / t < 15 : C = 30t/d d/t_> 15 : C = 2 . 0
0.5
0.0 0
5
!
i
10
15
,
t
I
20
25
30
dlt Figure 3 Existing and Proposed Bearing Coefficients for Bolted Connections SCREWED CONNECTION STUDIES
Background Investigations of single overlap connections in G550 steel concentrically loaded in shear have been reported by Rogers and Hancock (1999). The steel ranged in thickness from 0.42 mm to 1.00 mm, and the type, number and placement of screws were varied.
Proposed Design Provisionsfor Screwed Connections A proposed method to accommodate for the change in bearing behaviour with sheet steel thickness, which relies on the ratio of screw diameter to sheet thickness, d/t, was presented in Rogers and Hancock (1999). Unconservative predictions of connection bearing capacity have demonstrated a need for a gradated bearing coefficient which is dependent on the stability of the edge of the screw hole in a similar manner to the bolted connections described above. These unsatisfactory results have been recorded for test specimens where two different thickness sheet steels are connected and loaded in shear. The screwed connection test specimens that have two elements of the same thickness all failed in a combined bearing/tilting mode and have acceptable test-to-predicted ratios. Macindoe and Pham (1996) tested a number of screwed connections where bearing failure was forced to occur because of a large differential in the thickness of the connected sheets. This behaviour differs from that exhibited for the majority of the connections that were tested for by Rogers and Hancock, and by Macindoe and Pham, where failure was caused by a combination of beating and tilting. The connection resistance that was calculated for the screwed connection tests where bearing/tilting failure occurred is
25 reasonably accurate. Hence, the proposed method includes the tilting formulation that is specified in both the AS/NZS 4600 (1996) and AISI (1997) design standards. It also includes the gross yielding (1) and net section fracture (2) failure provisions described for bolts in the preceding sections i.e. no stress reduction factor is used. The material properties for thin G550 sheet steels are not reduced by the 0.75 factor. At present, the bearing coefficient that is contained in the AS/NZS-4600 (1996) and AISI (1997a) design standards is a constant 2.7 for screw connections as shown in Fig. 4. The CAN/CSA-S136 design standard (1994) requires that the bearing coefficient vary depending on the ratio of d/t, as shown in Fig. 4. The proposed method contains a gradated bearing coefficient which is also dependent on d/t, however, the maximum allowed value is lowered to 2.7 and the rate of change of the bearing coefficient is modified accordingly.
,~- C S A - S 1 3 6 //
4.0
ro 3.5 .~ 3.0 ~
2.5
~
2.0
//
d/t~: 1 0 : C - 3 . 0 10 < d/t < 1 5 : C = 3 0 t / d d/t 2 15 : C = 2.0
C=2.7
f
=P r o p o s e d d/t < 6 : C = 2.7 6 < d/t < 13 : C = 3.3 - O. l d/t d/t ~ 1 3 : C = 2.0
o~ 1.5 1.0 ~
- A S / N Z S 4600, A I S I
(1.5 0.0 0
3
6
9
12
15
18
d/t Figure 4 Proposed bearing coefficient for screwed connections
FRACTURE STUDIES
Background Test results from Rogers and Hancock (1997) reveal that the ability of G550 sheet steels to undergo deformation is dependent on the direction of load within the plane of the sheet, where transverse specimens exhibit the least amount of overall, local and uniform elongation. Typically, transverse specimens fail immediately after exiting the linear elastic phase of deformation with minimal plastification of the net section or the gauge length. The fracture resistance of the material, which in reality contains microscopic cracks, may have influenced this behaviour. The G550 sheet steels that were tested do not meet the Dhalla and Winter (1974b) elongation and ultimate strength to yield stress ratio requirements regardless of direction, except for the uniform elongation of longitudinal coupon specimens. The paper on fracture toughness of G550 sheet steels subject to tension by Rogers and Hancock (2001) reports on the fracture resistance properties of G550 sheet steels that were tested in tension. The fracture resistance of the G550 sheet steels was measured for a range of temperatures, and a numerical study of the effect of cracks on structural performance in the elastic deformation range was completed using the FRANC2D 1995) finite element computer program. A summary of the results from this paper are included here.
26
Measurement of Critical Stress Intensity Factors Stress distribution in a loaded member is greatly affected by the presence of cracks or discontinuities. The classical structural mechanics approach deals with these matters by a numerical multiplier referred to as a stress concentration factor, which can be thought of as the increase in stress caused by a change in geometry such as a notch. Fracture mechanics, however, recognises that the stress intensity at the tip of the crack can be expressed as a stress intensity factor, K, as follows, K = o',pp~
(4)
where travp is the nominal stress applied to the member and a is the size of the crack. Thus K can grow as crsop or a or simply the product of these grows. However, K cannot grow to a value larger than the fracture toughness of the material, Kc, which is the critical stress intensity factor at the tip of a crack and is def'med as follows,
IL = 4Eao
(5)
where E is the elastic constant of the material (Young's Modulus) and Gc is the toughness of the material. As the stress intensity factor at the tip of the crack, K, increases with increased loading, it may reach the value of Kc, when the balance of elastic energy release from the loaded body exceeds the energy requirement for crack extension. At this point a running crack that is known as unstable fracture takes place. The stress intensity factor, K, at the tip of the crack should be kept at a value less than the characteristic Kc of the material under investigation if unstable fracture of the structure is to be avoided. This is analogous to the requirement that the cross-sectional stress, f, must lie below fy if one does not want yielding to occur. A total of 30 notch specimens were tested using the same steels as for the ductility, bolted connection and screwed connection tests described above. The main objective of this experimental testing phase was to determine the critical Mode I, i.e. crack opening as opposed to crack sliding (Mode II) or crack tearing (Mode III), stress intensity factors, Ke, for 0.42 and 0.60 mm G550 sheet steels. Tests were completed to measure the magnitude of the crack tip stress field where ultimate failure was caused by unstable fracture of the notch specimens. All of the test pieces within a material and thickness type were cut from the same sheet, although similar specimens were cut from various locations to avoid localised material properties. The material properties of cold reduced sheet steels have been shown to be anisotropic, hence, specimens were cut from three directions within the sheet; longitudinal, transverse and diagonal with respect to the rolling direction. Critical stress intensity factors were calculated for all of the notch test specimens. Of the 30 notch tests, 18 were completed at a temperature of 21.5~ (room temperature) and the remaining at temperatures which varied from I~ to -21~ The room temperature mean value test results are provided in Table 1, and detailed information for each individual notch specimen can be found in Rogers and Hancock (1998b). All of the sheet steel types that were tested have critical stress intensity factors that exceed 3000 MNm "3r2. A significant decrease in the fracture toughness of the G550 sheet steels is not evident for the transverse direction in comparison to the longitudinal and diagonal directions. However, the transverse Kc values do fall below the longitudinal and diagonal values for both the 0.42 mm and 0.60 mm G550 sheet steels. The measured Kr values are atypically high partially because of the thinness of the G550 sheet steels, which did not allow for plane strain conditions to occur during testing. This does not mean that the measured Kc values are incorrect, but that these values are only valid for the thicknesses tested. Ashby (1981) associates the failure of materials that are found to have Ke values in the range measured with the plastic rupture ductile fracture failure mode.
27 No significant variation in the measured critical stress intensity factors of the G550 sheet steels was observed for the range of temperatures used in testing, i.e. 21.5~ to -21 ~ (see Rogers and Hancock (1998b)). This is an indication that the transition temperature from ductile to brittle fracture behaviour of the G550 sheet steels that were tested lies below the range of temperatures used. Table 1: Mean Measured Kc Values at Room Temperature (21.5~
Material Type & Direction
K~ 3/2
(MNm")
0.42ram G550 Long. 0.42ram G550 Tran. 0.42mm G550 Diag. 0.60ram G550 Long. 0.60mm G550 Tran. 0.60ram G550 Diag. IIIII
3767 3182 3748 3551 3260 3743 I
Evaluation of the Critical Stress Intensity Factorsfor Perforated Coupon Specimens An analytical study of cracked specimens fabricated from G550 sheet steels was completed to determine the design implications of possible failure by unstable fracture in the elastic deformation range. Critical stress intensity factors were computed using a finite element model, and then were compared with the measured critical stress intensity factors obtained from tests. The FRANC2D (1995) finite element computer program, distributed and written by the Comell University Fracture Group, was used because it had been specifically developed for the analysis of crack behaviour. The FRANC2D program allows the user to easily define element meshes at crack tips, extend cracks in any direction and remesh the crack area, as well as calculate stress intensity factors at the crack tip. In this analytical study, it was assumed that for the modelled test specimens rapid unstable fracture resulting in ultimate failure would occur when the stress intensity at the prescribed crack tip reached the critical measured I~ value. This is a conservative assumption that is dependent on the following; 1) once the specimen has reached its ultimate load carrying capacity the maximum load does not decrease as the crack size increases, hence rapid fracture of the specimen is not abated, and 2) that loading occurs over a short period of time so that stable crack growth does not occur prior to ultimate failure, i.e. the length of the fatigue crack is not extended by any further crack growth except at ultimate failure. All of the elements used in the finite element models had elastic-isotropic material properties that were defined using the results obtained from the coupon tests of G550 sheet steels (Rogers and Hancock, 1997). Numerical analyses of representative coupon models, with 1, 2, 5 and 7 mm circular, as well as 5 mm diamond and square perforations, for the two G550 sheet steel types were completed using the FRANC2D (1995) computer program. The nominal size of the previously tested perforated coupons was used (see Rogers and Hancock (1997)). Additional 0.25 mm long non-cohesive cracks were placed on either side of the perforation at the position of the highest stress concentration, perpendicular to the direction of load. The applied ultimate edge stress was calculated based on the assumption that the average stress over the net section, which was calculated using only the perforation dimension and not the crack length, would equal the yield stress of the material (see Rogers and Hancock' 1997). The loaded and boundary edges of the coupon models were defined as found for the notch specimen finite element model.
28 Numerical analysis, using the FRANC2D computer program, of the perforated coupons with additional edge cracks revealed that the applied stress intensity factors, Kapp, did not reach a critical level, Kc, as defined by the tested notch specimens (see Figures 5 and 6 for 0.42 mm G550 steel). These results indicate that failure of the real perforated G550 sheet steel coupon specimens (Rogers and Hancock, 1997) can be attributed to yielding and ultimate rupture of the material at the net section, and not unstable fracture in the elastic deformation range. The results also show that the sharp geometry of a diamond perforation and the presence of a small crack will cause the largest applied stress intensity factors.
Figure 5 Perforated Coupons Kapp versus K~ (0.42 mm G550 Longitudinal)
Figure 6 Perforated Coupons Kapp versus I~ (0.42 mm G550 Transverse)
Evaluation of the Critical Stress Intensity Factorsfor Triple Bolted Specimens
The longitudinal and transverse triple bolt G550 sheet steel connections that are documented in Rogers and Hancock (1998), and which failed through rupture of the net section, were also analysed using the FRANC2D (1995) computer program. For each bolted connection, additional 0.5 mm long noncohesive cracks were placed on either side of the perforation of the innermost bolt hole at the position of the highest stress concentration, perpendicular to the direction of load. Distributed loads were
29 applied to all of the bolt holes along the edge where the bolt and sheet steel were in contact. The boundary edge was defined as previously noted for the notch Specimen finite element model. Analysis of the bolted connection specimens using the FRANC2D computer program revealed that the applied stress intensity factors, Kapp, did not reach a critical level, Kr as defined by the notch specimens that were tested (see Figure 7). These results indicate that failure of the triple bolt connection G550 sheet steel specimens can be attributed to yielding and ultimate rupture of the material at the net section and not unstable fracture in the elastic deformation range. However, the applied stress intensity factors have increased in comparison with the values obtained in the analysis of the perforated coupons. This increase can be attributed to the greater width of the test piece, greater crack length and more localised load distribution. It is most noticeable for the transverse 0.42 mm G550 test specimens where the applied stress intensity factors fall just short of reaching the critical level. Further increases in the crack length would result in elevated applied stress intensity factors and ultimately, unstable fracture of the test specimens in the elastic deformation range.
Figure 7 Triple Bolt Connections Kapp versus Kr
Conclusions on Fracture o f G550 Sheet Steels The Mode I critical stress intensity factor, Kc, for the 0.42 mm G550 and 0.60 mm G550 sheet steels was determined for three directions in the plane of the sheet. Single notch test specimens with fatigue cracks were loaded in tension to determine the resistance of G550 sheet steels to failure by unstable fracture in the elastic deformation range. The critical stress intensity factors obtained by testing were then used in a finite element study to determine the risk of unstable fracture in the elastic deformation zone for a range of different G550 sheet steel structural models. It was determined that the perforated coupon and bolted connection specimens that were previously tested for this research project were not at risk of failure by unstable fracture in the elastic zone. Notch specimens that were tested at different temperatures (1 to -21~ did not provide crack resistance values that significantly varied from those tested at room temperature (21.5~ These results are an indication that the ductile-brittle transition temperature lies below the range of temperatures used in testing.
30 COMPRESSION STUDIES
Background and Geometry of Sections Tested The tests by Wu, Yu and LaBoube (1996a, 1996b) discussed in the introduction to this paper were performed on decking sections in bending and so the stiffened flange elements in compression were supported by 2 webs in bending. In order to produce a section with all elements in compression, box sections were formed from 0.6 mm G550 sheet steel at the University of Sydney. The same steel as used for the earlier ductility tests was used. It was not possible to form a complete box without some type of connection at at least one of the comers. Consequently, boxes were formed from two pieces brake-pressed then connected at two of the comers as shown in Fig. 8. Epoxy was used between the sheet steel sections at the comers. These sections were designed to be as close to a true square hollow section as possible without any welding which would have produced considerable distortion of the very thin sections. The sections ranged from 20 mm to 100 mm fiat widths. The b/t ratios therefore varied from 33.3 to 167. The unstiffened lip elements were kept at 7.5 mm long for all section sizes. The local buckling stresses varied from approximately 30 MPa for the 100 mm section to 710 MPa for the 20 mrn section. The effect of the double thickness comer (lip) elements was to increase the theoretical local buckling coefficients to approximately 4.5 due to slight torsional restraint at 2 of the comers.
Figure 8 G550 Box Column Section- Type 1
Test Results and Comparisons with Design Standards The sections were tested in an MTS Sintech 300 kN testing machine with machined end plates. Pattemstone was used between the end plate located against the top of the specimen and the testing machine top platen to ensure even bearing on the specimens. The first few specimens were found to fracture in the epoxy at loads very close to the ultimate load. It was therefore decided to drill 3 mm holes in the comer lips and to place small diameter bolts and nuts to ensure that the comers did not come apart. Initially, these bolts were only located at the ends, but subsequent testing resulted in increased numbers of bolts with the bolt spacing at approximately 20 mm then 10 ram. A photograph of a box section with the small bolts after test and showing the local buckles is shown in Fig. 9. The measured yield stress of the steel was 711 MPa.
Figure 9 G550 Box Section after Test
The test results have been plotted in Fig. 10 versus the theoretical stub column test strengths computed using AS/NZS 4600 (his) and the AISI Specification (Pn). In Fig. 10, the areas of the holes have not been allowed for. The test results with a square are those for the holes at approximately 20 mm spacing, and those with the crosses are for the tests with the 10 mm hole spacing. It is clear that decreasing the hole spacing decreases the load. Obviously the holes are having an effect. All results lie below the theoretical strength based on R~fy as included in Section A3.3.2 of the latest addendum to the AISI Specification (2000). The results of the test have been plotted in Fig. 11 with the areas of the holes removed from the effective area on the assumption that the lips are fully effective and the holes can simply be removed. In this case, the majority of the test results lie above the revised AISI Section A3.3.2 curve. It is also interesting to note that for more slender sections, the test results are closer to the theoretical strengths assuming no reductions in the yield stress. This is to be expected since the effect of no strain hardening is likely to have a lesser effect for sections which are slender and fail principally by post-local instability and then yielding rather than inelastic local buckling. For the more stocky sections, the results are closer to the revised AISI strengths. At the time of writing this paper, further tests were underway for sections without holes and bolts.
32
1.20
I
1.15
-
1.10
-
1.05
-
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
'1
+ Holes at 10mm spacing o Holes at 20mm spacing
_
1.00
Ntes---! 0 . 9 5 Ns 0.90
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .~,,, AISI supplement No. 1, 1999 -oo
O.ooo. . . . . .[] .
0.85
9 9 ~::~o. o. o
[] 0.80 -
~:
+
m
~
~176o o o . ~
t:]
[]
+
.p
0.75 0.70
,
0
I
,,,
20
],
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
40
60
80
100 b/t
120
140
160
180
200
Figure 10 Comparison of G550 Stub Box Compression Tests with Design Standards (holes excluded from calculations) 1.20
I
II
Ill
I
III I
I
I'
I
1.15
+ Holes at 10mm spacing D Holes at 20mm spacing
1.10
_
1.05 1.00
Ntest Ns 0.95
[] '''~176176176
....
9
0.90
B O
[]
....
~176
o
0.85
i ....... .ยง ..... .~
AISI supplement No. 1, 1999
0.80 0.75 0.70
0
I
I=
20
40
I ....
60
I
80
I
I
~
i
100 b/t
120
140
160
180
200
Figure 11 Comparison of G550 Stub Box Compression Tests with Design Standards (holes included in calculations)
33 CONCLUSIONS The use of cold reduced G550 coated sheet steel is becoming more common in the construction industry for structural members, particularly in residential construction. A wide range of research projects has been performed mainly at the University of Sydney and the University of Missouri-Rolla to ascertain the strength of these steels when used in load beating applications. The areas of members in compression, bending and tension, and screwed and bolted connections have been investigated. Fracture toughness has been investigated where it has been shown that all specimens and connections tested to date have failed by ductile failure rather than sudden fracture. Further research is required in the area of compression members to ascertain whether sections composed of G550 sheet steels can carry their design capacity without significant reductions in the yield stress being required in the design equations. Ongoing work is being performed in this area at the University of Sydney.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors would like to thank the Australian Research Council and BHP Coated Steel Division for their financial support for these projects performed at the University of Sydney. The advise of Associate Professor Kim Rasmussen on the compression tests is gratefully acknowledged. REFERENCES
American Iron and Steel Institute. (1997). "1996 Edition of the Specification for the Design of ColdFormed Steel Structural Members", Washington, DC, USA. American Iron and Steel Institute. (2000). "1996 Edition of the Specification for the Design of ColdFormed Steel Structural Members, Supplement 1, July 1999", Washington, DC, USA.
American Society for Testing and Materials A 611. (1997). "Standard Specification for Steel, Sheet, Carbon, Cold-Rolled, Structural Quality", Philadelphia, PA, USA American Society for Testing and Materials A 653. (1997). "Standard Specification for Steel Sheet, ZincCoated (Galvanized) or Zinc-iron Alloy-Coated (Galvannealed) by the Hot-Dip Process", Philadelphia, PA, USA. American Society for Testing and Materials A 792. (1997). "Standard Specification for Steel Sheet, 55% Aluminum-Zinc Alloy-Coated by the Hot-Dip Process", Philadelphia, PA, USA. American Society for Testing and Materials A 875. (1997). "Standard Specification for Steel Sheet, Zinc5% Aluminium Alloy-Coated by the Hot-Dip Process", Philadelphia, PA, USA. Ashby, M.F.. (1981). Prog. Mat. Sci., Chalmers Anniversary Volume, pp. 1-25. Canadian Standards Association, S 136. (1994). "Cold Formed Steel Structural Members", Etobicoke, Ont, Canada.
34 Dhalla, A.K., Winter, G.. (1974a). "Steel Ductility Measurements", Journal of the Structural Division, ASCE, Vol. 100, No. ST2, pp. 427-444. DhaUa, A.K., Winter, G.. (1974b). "Suggested Steel Ductility Requirements", Journal of the Structural Division, ASCE, Vol. 100, No. ST2, pp. 445-462. Daudet,R., and Klippstein,K.H. (1994), "Stub Column Study using Welded, Cold-Reduced Steel", 12th International Specialty Conference on Cold-Formed Steel Structures, St Louis, Missouri, Oct 1994, pp 285 - 302. FRANC2D. (1995). "Tutorial and User's Guide", Version 2.7, ComeU University Fracture Group, Ithaca NY, USA. Hancock, G.J. and Murray, T.M (1996), "Residential Applications of Cold-Formed Stmcaaal Members in Australia, 13th International Specialty Conference on Cold-Formed Steel Structures, St Louis, Missouri, Oct 1996, pp 505 - 511. Macindoe, L. and Pham, L., (1995), Test Data from Screwed and Blind Rivetted Connections", CSIRO Division of Building, Construction and Engineering, Document 96/22(M), Higher Victoria, Australia Mahendran, M, (1990), "Static Behaviour of Corrugated Roofing under Simulated Wind Loading",Civil Engg Transactions, Inst. Engrs. Aust., Vo132, No. 4, pp 211-218. Mahendran, M, (1994), "Behaviour and Design of Crest Fixed Profiled Steel Roof Claddings under High Wind Forces",Engg. Struct., Vol. 16 No. 5. McAdam, J.N, Brockenbrough, R.A., LaBoube, R.A., Pekoz, T, and Schneider, E.J., "Low Strain Hardening Ductile Steel Cold-Formed Members", 9~ International Specialty Conference on Cold-Formed Steel Structures, St Louis, Missouri, Nov 1988. Rogers, C.A., Hancock, G.J.. (1997). "Ductility of G550 Sheet Steels in Tension", Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE, Vol. 123, No. 12, 1586-1594. Rogers, C.A., Hancock, G.J.. (1998a). "Bolted Connection Tests of Thin G550 and G300 Sheet Steels", Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE, Vol. 124, No. 7, pp. 798-808. Rogers, C.A., Hancock, G.J.. (1998b). "Tensile Fracture Behaviour of Thin G550 Sheet Steels", Research Report No. R773, Centre for Advanced Structural Engineering, University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia Rogers, C.A., Hancock, G.J. (1999). "Screwed Connection Tests of Thin G550 and G300 Sheet Steels", Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE, Vol. 125, No. 2, pp. 128-136. Rogers, C.A. and Hancock, G.J. (2001). "Fracture Toughness of G550 Sheet Steels subjected to Tension", Journal of Constructional Steel Research, Vo157, pp 71-89. Standards Australia. ( 1 9 9 3 ) . "Steel sheet and strip - Hot-dipped zinc-coated or aluminium/zinc coated - AS 1397", Sydney,NSW, AusUalia Standards Australia / Standards New Zealand. (1996). "Cold-formed steel structures - AS/NZS 4600", Sydney, NSW, Australia
35 Tang, and Mahendmn, M. (1998),"Local Failures in Trapezoidal Steel Claddings", Thin-Walled Stractures Research and Developments, Eds Shanmugam, Liew and Thevendran, Elsevier
-
Wu, S., Yu, W.W, and LaBoube, R.A. (1996a), "Strength of Flexural Members using Structural Grade 80 of A653 Steel (Deck Panel Tests)", Second Progress Report, Department of Civil Engineering, University of Missouri-Rolla, November. Wu, S., Yu, W.W, and LaBoube, R.A. (1996b), "Flexural Members using Structural Grade 80 of A653 Steel (Deck Panel Tests)", 13th International Specialty Conference on Cold-Formed Steel Structures, St Louis, Missouri, Oct 1996, pp 255-274. Wu, S., Yu, W.W, and LaBoube, R.A. (1997a), "Strength of Flexural Members using Structural Grade 80 of A653 Steel (Web Crippling Tests)", Third Progress Report, Depamnent of Civil Engineering, University of Missouri-Rolla, November. Wu, S., Yu, W.W, and LaBoube, tLA. (1997b), "Web Crippling Strength of Members using High Strength Steels", 14th International Specialty Conference on Cold-Formed Steel Structures, St Louis, Missouri, Oct 1998, pp 193-208.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Third International Conferenceon Thin-WalledStructures J. Zarag, K. Kowal-Michaiskaand J. Rhodes 9 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved
37
THIN-WALLED STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS CONTAINING OPENINGS N.E.Shanmugam Department of Civil Engineering The National University of Singapore 10, Kent Ridge Crescent, Singapore-119260
ABSTRACT This paper is concerned with thin-walled structural elements that contain openings provided to allow for locating services, to facilitate fabrication process and to reduce the self-weight of the structures. Extensive analytical and experimental investigations have been carried out in the past to examine the behavior of thin-walled structures containing openings. However, due to lack of an organized database the results have not been fully utilized by other researchers. As part of this review an endeavor is made to cluster the experimental and analytical results with particular importance on plates, beams and plate girders and compression members and cellular structures containing perforations as an elucidative database using a handy spreadsheet program written in Visual Basic. KEYWORDS Thin-walled, structural elements, local buckling, in-plane loading, shear loading, review, experiments, analyses INTRODUCTION Openings are often introduced in thin-walled structures such as automobiles, aircrafts, bridges, ships and storage racking structures to facilitate access for services and inspection. Presence of these openings also help to lighten the structure and to enhance the constructability of thin-walled sections by allowing easy consolidation of building services, piping, electric-wiring, plumbing etc., within the section depth. Access for repair and maintenance works are provided through openings in webs of plate girders, box girders and ship grillage. In aircraft industry openings are often provided for air passage to the interior. Thin-walled members for some specific tasks are generally manufactured with a regular pattern of multiple holes in order to meet the requisites. Typical openings in thin-walled structure are shown in Figure 1. Presence of openings results in redistribution of the membrane stresses, change in buckling and strength characteristics leading to drop in load-carrying capacity. Geometry of the thin-walled structural element (e.g. angle, channel - plain or lipped, etc.), type of applied stress (e.g. compressive, tensile, shear etc) and shape, size, location and number of the openings have greater influence on the
38
Figure: 1 Some examples of Thin-Walled Structures Containing Openings behaviour of structural members containing openings. Thus, the precise analysis and design of structural steel members with perforated elements are imperative. A considerable amount of research has been directed towards this problem during the last three or four decades and approximate design methods for evaluating the ultimate capacity of thin plate elements containing openings and subjected to in-plane axial or shear loading have been proposed by researchers. A review on the research work to account for the effects of openings on the behaviour of thin-walled elements in steel structures has been presented by Shanmugam (1997). Attention is directed, in the review, to the analytical and experimental work carried out on centrally or eccentrically placed, reinforced or unreinforced circular or rectangular openings in perforated plate elements, stiffened flanges, shear webs and cold-formed steel structural elements. Also, design methods of thin-walled steel structural elements that account for the presence of openings are highlighted. However, detailed information from each of the works is not presented in this paper and, one has to dig out the references listed for such information. The object of this paper is, therefore, to summarize the works and present a data bank in a systematic manner so that future researchers could have one source from which they would be able to get any details of the past work done for their reference. An effort has been made in this paper to provide a comprehensive review and to compile the experimental and analytical results on perforated thin-walled structures in a user-friendly format. The review is presented, for convenience of the readers, under four major topics viz. plates, thin-plated beams, thin-walled columns and cellular structures.
PLATES A number of researchers studied initially perforated flange and web plates subjected to different types of loadings such as uniaxial compression, biaxial compression and shear and investigated the stress concentration around openings. Finite element method was applied to determine the elastic buckling of plate elements with cutouts. The method was extended further to include inelastic and largedeflection behaviour of such plate elements.
Uniaxiai and Biaxial Loadings Pennington Vann (1971) employed finite element method for elastic buckling analysis of uniaxially loaded plates. The theoretical and experimental results presented indicate that unless a central nonflange,d hole is rather large, it will have a small effect on the elastic buckling load of a plate, and that a flanged hole can be expected to make the elastic buckling load greater than that of the corresponding non-perforated plate. Tentative results concerning the ultimate strength of pierced plates indicate that a small non-flanged hole has essentially no effect on the ultimate strength, and a stiffened hole may or may not affect the ultimate strength. The finite element method was extended later (Shanmugam and
39 Narayanan, 1982; Sabir and Chow, 1983)to encompass other forms of loading and support conditions for both square and circular openings. The knowledge of post-buckling behaviour is necessary to determine the ultimate load-carrying capacity. Yu and Davies (1971) and Ritchie and Rhodes (1975) proposed that the effective width concept with slight modification could be extended to the postbuckling analysis of axially compressed perforated plates, taking size and shape of openings into consideration. The proposed method was validated with the experimental results on the buckling and post-buckling behaviour of thin-walled structural elements containing centrally located hole. The finite element formulation, which incorporated the material and geometric non-linearity and the initial plate imperfections, based on variational principles (Azizian and Roberts, 1983 and 1984) could predict the non-linear behaviour of perforated plates, right up to failure. Narayanan and Chan (1985) proposed an approximate method based on energy approach to predict the ultimate load capacity of uniaxially compressed plates under linearly varying load across the width. Plate elements subjected to biaxial loading commonly occur in ship double bottoms, dock gates and multi-cell girders. Only limited information is available on the behaviour of such members in the literature. Elastic buckling of such plate elements containing openings was investigated by employing finite element method (Shanmugam and Narayanan, 1982; Sabir and Chow, 1983). A simplified procedure was proposed to estimate the peak load of biaxially loaded plates containing openings was proposed by Narayanan and Chow (1984a). The proposed procedure has been found to give reasonable predictions compared to the corresponding experimental values. Taking into account of the time and cost factor involved in such methods, Narayanan and Chow (1984b, 1984c, 1987)suggested an approximate design method for evaluating the ultimate capacity of plates containing openings and subjected to uni-axial or biaxial compression. All these methods require a proper understanding of the plate behaviour and the effective width concept. Shanmugam et al. (1999) proposed a design formula using finite element method that does not require any rigorous mathematical computations. The designers need to compute different sets of coefficients and substitute into the general equation to predict the ultimate capacity of the circular and square perforated plates for different shapes of openings, different types of axial loading and different combinations of boundary conditions. Shear Loading
Finite element method was employed by Rockey et al. (1967) to study the buckling of a square plate having a centrally located circular hole when subjected to edge shear load. The introduction of openings was found to result in drop of critical shear stress for square plate panel. Studies by other researchers (Shanmugam and Narayanan, 1982; Sabir and Chow, 1983; Narayanan and Chow, 1984c; Naryanan and Der Avenesian, 1984) of the elastic buckling behaviour of perforated plates under shear loading include different shapes of openings and boundary conditions. It may be necessary to place openings eccentrically in the plate. The effects of such eccentricity on elastic buckling behaviour under shear loading of plates were extensively analysed by Narayanan and Der Avenesian (1984). Reinforcements around rectangular and circular openings were also considered in these studies. For plates with central circular and rectangular cutout, an approximate relationship for the shear-buckling coefficient was suggested based on the finite element results. Narayanan and Chow (1984), based on experimental investigations, concluded that the effect of opening size on buckling is more significant than that of location. Stiffened Plates
It becomes essential for flange plates employed in ship double bottoms, dock gates and box girder bridges to be stiffened longitudinally in order to enhance the efficiency of the structure to resist loads. Such stiffened plates often contain openings in bed-plates in which case the failure load may be determined using a method proposed by Mahendran et al. (1994, 1996). This method has been found
40 to predict the failure load to an acceptable degree of accuracy compared with a number of experimental failure loads (Shanmugam et al. 1985, 1986).
PERFORATED BEAMS Bending Hoglund (1971) concluded that the reduction in bending strength of a thin web I-girder having web openings located at the centre is small since the flanges carry most of the bending moment. Experimental and analytical studies were carried out by Shan (1994) to determine the local buckling characteristics of a flexural member containing web opening and proposed an equation to determine the flexural capacity of such sections. Yu and Davis (1973) studied the behaviour of thin-walled steel members with perforated web elements and concluded that the presence of a circular hole results in reduction of shear capacity; they have proposed an empirical reduction factor to quantify the reduction. An approximate method was proposed by Narayanan and Rockey (1981) for the analysis of perforated plate girders. The method was based on experimental observations on plate girders containing web openings. Equilibrium solutions by Narayanan and Der Avanesian (1983 a-d, 1984 a, b, 1985, 1986) based on further assumptions on tension field action has covered shapes and locations of openings in plate girder webs. Though there is no theoretical basis to confirm the hypothetical tension band around openings, the observed experimental pattern of failure substantiated the concept. The predictions obtained by the equilibrium solutions, compared with test results, have invariably been conservative, however, there has been no systematic study to verify if this would generally be the case. Shan (1994) developed both linear and non-linear reduction factors to determine the nominal shear strength, based on the findings from experimental and analytical studies of the behaviour of web elements of cross sections with web openings subjected to uniform shear force. Schuster (1999)carried out experiments to establish an analytical method for calculating the shear resistance of perforated cold-formed steel Csections subjected to constant shear at the University of Waterloo. Combined effect of bending moment and shear force was investigated at the University of MissouriRolla (Shan, 1994; Shan et al., 1996) on standard C- shaped members containing web openings. The current interaction equation in the AISI Specifications, which adequately predicts the web capacity of the nominal shear and bending strengths, are appropriately modified to account for the presence of web openings based on the test results. In the case of beams and columns subjected to concentrated loads in the steel framing structures provision must be made for the load transfer into the web from the flange. Web crippling occurs when web flange intersection subjected to a large compressive force and, this problem becomes more critical in the presence of openings. This problem of web crippling in coldformed steel members has been addressed in the recent research findings (Sivakumaran, 1988; Sivakumaran et al., 1989; Shan et al., 1993 and 1994). Yu and Davies (1973) have also reported on the reduction in web crippling strength due to presence of web openings. This is based on the experimental results on cold-formed steel members. Recent experimental and theoretical studies by Chung (1995) have shown that for perforated sections with practical shapes and significant sizes, the resistance of the sections to web crippling load resistances is often not significant.
Lateral Buckling The problem of lateral buckling in deep slender beams is an important issue that needs adequate consideration in the design of such beams. However, only limited information could be traced in the published literature on the effect of openings on the buckling capacity of beams (Bower, 1968; ASCE Task Committee Report, 1971; Redwood and Uenoya, 1979). Redwood and Uenoya (1979) have treated the problem of webs as a stability problem of a perforated plate with simplified edge loadings and support conditions. The finite element method has been used to solve the resulting problem. Coull and Alvarez (1980) based on their experimental studies have proposed an empirical method for
41 determining the lateral buckling capacity of beams with a number of openings, either circular or rectangular. Their formulae do not seem to allow for openings Other than those considered by them. Thevendran and Shanmugam (1991, 1992a,b) proposed using the principle of minimum total potential energy a numerical method to predict the elastic lateral buckling load of narrow rectangular and I beams containing web openings and subjected to single concentrated load applied at the centroid of the cross section. The accuracy of the method has been verified with results obtained from experiments similar to those shown in Figure 2. Simply supported and cantilever beams were considered and the method is capable of predicting the effects of size, location and shape of openings on the elastic critical load.
Figure 2 : Experiments on Lateral Buckling of Beams with Openings
Reinforced Web Openings It is an expensive operation to provide reinforcements around openings in order to minimize the strength reduction. However, if the loss of strength implicit in cutting a web hole is unacceptable, the web opening will need to be reinforced around its periphery so that the opening can still be introduced. The method of designing an appropriate circular ring reinforcement to restore the strength lost due to the cutout serves as a useful tool in the design office. Based on their investigation, Narayanan and Der Avenesian (1984 a, b) proposed an equilibrium solution for prediction of the ultimate capacity of girders containing a reinforced circular or rectangular hole. Since the tension field in a non-perforated web is developed predominantly along a diagonal band, it is wise to locate openings away from this band, so that the girder does not suffer any significant drop in strength. The effect of eccentrically placed openings on the behaviour of plate girder webs was investigated by Narayanan et al. (1984,1985). THIN-WALLED COLUMNS Local buckling and post-buckling strength for stiffened and unstiffened doubly symmetric perforated cold-formed steel compression members were first considered by Davis and Yu (1972) and their findings based on experimental investigations formed the basis for further developments in the evaluation of the effective design width of perforated plate elements. Yu and Davis proposed an effective design width equation for plates with either central or square perforation. Because of the intricacy involved in the computation of various constants, this equation is not popular with designers. The effective width equation, in the same form as that of Winter's formula (1947), recommended by Ortiz-Colberg (1981) is now currently practiced in the AISI Specifications (1996). But this equation is only applicable for stiffened plates under uniform compression with certain limitation on slenderness ratio and circular perforation to width ratio. Sivakumaran and Banwait (1987 a, b, c) recommended reassessment of effective design width equations in the design codes CAN3-S 136-M84 and AISI-1986,
42 in which the strength of sections is overestimated. They emphasized on the need for experimental data on the sections with manufacturer's hole. Miller and Pekoz (1994) attempted to modify the unified effective width approach to local buckling in the Specification for Design of Cold-Formed Steel Structural Members (AISI 1986) to model the perforated section. It was concluded that the effect of perforations is negligible unless the perforation is extended to the effective portion of the compressed element. An effective design width equations to determine the ultimate strength of non-perforated and perforated cold-formed steel compression members was proposed (Rahman, 1997; Rahman and Sivakumaran, 1998) based on a proven finite element model (Sivakumaran, Rahman, 1998). It has been found that this equation could predict well for manufacturer's hole.
Multiple Openings In the field of storage racking, an ample proportion of cold-formed steel construction, the upright is generally having many perforations, otten in the form of a repeating pattern to a significant extent as shown in Figure 3. The strut capacity of such member is generally assessed on the basis of tests. A more general, but relatively conservative design approach for perforated wall stud assemblies is given in the Canadian standard S136-94 (CSA 1994), which is not applicable for single members in compression. The CSA $136-1974 equations for non-stiffened plates are not suitable for analyzing perforated studs with short holes similar to those tested. Loov (1984)developed an equation to
Figure 3 : Typical Examples of Multiple Openings determine the effective width of non-stiffened portion of the web beside the holes based on the experiments. The test results support the present equation for the average yield stress in Canadian Standards Association Standard S136-1974 but the present code equations for non-stiffened plates are unduly conservative when applied to the design of the web adjacent to openings of the size considered. Rhodes and Schneider (1996)studied experimentally the effects of multiple circular perforations on the ultimate compressive strength of cold-formed steel channel sections. The application of existing coldformed steel design codes to perforated members is examined on the basis of comparison with the tests, and various modifications to the design codes are considered to take perforations into account. Rhodes and Macdonald (1996) extended the investigation to study the effects of perforation length on the stub column capacity. The study concluded that consideration should be given to the perforation geometry along the member as well as the perforation geometry across the member. Wall structures, especially used in the Nordic Countries, include web-perforated C- or sigma-sections as studs and U-sections as tracks and, e.g. gypsum wallboards attached to the stud flanges to provide
43 quality thermal performance. Jyrki Kesti and Pentti Makelainen (1999)proposed design curves to determine the distortional buckling strength of the section based on the experimental study. The comparison showed that the method used gives reasonable results for C-sections but overestimates the compression capacity of sigma sections. CELLULAR STRUCTURES Multi-cell structures, otten used in bridges, storage tanks, dock gates and ship double bottoms, usually contain large openings in webs (Figure 4). The influence on shear deflection component of web openings resulted in large deflection of this form of structures. Studies (Shanmugam and Evans, 1979 a,b) have also shown that openings have influence on longitudinal stresses too. Empirical curves, based on suitable reduction coefficients for shear and torsional stiffness of the structure, can be used adequately to represent the effect of the web openings in grillage analyses of multi-cellular structures. The analysis was also applied to investigate the elastic behaviour and vibrational characteristics of thin-walled multi-cell structures containing web openings (Shanmugam and Balendra, 1985). Evans and Shanmugam (1981,1985) observed tension field action in the webs of cellular structures also.
Figure 4 : Celluar Structure Models with Web Perforations COMPILATION Extensive research materials on the behavior of perforated thin-walled structures have been reported in the published literature. However, there is no collection of data organized especially for rapid search and retrieval. Review is mandatory to prevent consuming valuable time in replicating the previous work. Compilation is essential to avoid unnecessary time in extracting important information from the other researchers work. An effort is, therefore, made to cluster the experimental and analytical results with particular emphasis on plates, beams, compression members and cellular structures containing perforations as an elucidative database using a handy spreadsheet program. The database in visual basic programming contains main record and sub records preceded by the user-friendly instruction sheet. Main record is carefully organized in such a way that a user can easily view through the sheet and select the research work he needed to retrieve from the sub records. The main record is presented in a table format in Appendix I. The sub records include research group, material properties, experimental and analytical results, design equations critical comments and final results for 59 different sets, categorized under different structures, Plate, Beam and Column. An attempt is made to provide all the necessary data needed in a comprehensible format. So the future researcher can refer this database to get all the information needed about perforated thin-walled members. Sample set is given for each category of plate, beam and column in Appendix II.
44 CONCLUSIONS Significant progress has been made in the investigation of thin walled structures containing openings. Several analytical models have been proposed to predict the effects of cutouts on the behaviour of thinwalled members, particularly on singly and doubly symmetric sections with single and multiple perforations subjected to different types of loadings. A number of experiments have been carried out to verify the proposed models. The investigations have resulted in simplified design methods of thinwalled elements containing openings. An attempt has been made in this paper to consolidate all the research works carried out on perforated thin-walled structural elements and to give a comprehensive review and a data base which could be of use to the future researchers in this field. REFERENCES
Abdel - Rahman, N. (1997). Cold-Formed Steel Compression Members with Perforations, PhD Thesis, Mc Master University, Hamilton, Ont. Azizian, Z. G. and Roberts, T. M. (1983). Buckling and Elasto-Plastic Collapse of Structures,
Proceedings of the International Conference on Instability and Plastic Collapse of Structures, Manchester, 322-328. Balendra, T. and Shanmugam, N.E. (1985). Vibrational Characteristics of Multi-Cellular Structures, Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE, 111:7, 1449-1459. Banwait, A. S. (1987). Axial Load Behaviour of Thin-Walled Steel Sections with Openings, M.Eng Thesis, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada. Bower, J.E., (1968). Design of Beams with Web Openings, 3'. Struct. Div., ASCE 94, 783-807. Sub-committee on Beams with Web Openings of the Task Committee on Flexural Members of the Structural Division. (1971). Suggested Design Guides for Beams with Web Holes, J. Struct. Div., ASCE 97, 2707-2727. Chung, K. F. (1995). Structural Performance of Cold-Formed Sections with Single and Multiple Web Openings- Part 1" Experimental Investigation, The Structural Engineer, 73:9, 141-149. Chung, K. F. (1995). Structural Performance of Cold-Formed Sections with Single and Multiple Web Openings- Part 2: Design Rules, The Structural Engineer, 73:9, 141-149. Coull, A. and Alvarez, M.C. (1980). Effect of Openings on Lateral Buckling of Beams, J. Struct. Div., ASCE 106, 2553-2560. Davis, C. S. and Yu. W. (1972). The structural Behaviour of Cold-Formed Steel Members with Perforated Elements, Department of Civil Engineering, University of Missouri Rolla, Rolla, Mo. Evans, H. R. and Shanmugam, N. E. (1979). The Elastic Analysis of Cellular Structures containing Web Openings, Proceedings, The Institution of Civil Engineers, 67:2, 035-1063. Evans, H. R. and Shanmugam, N. E. (1981). An Experimental study of the Ultimate Load Behaviour of Small-scale Box Girder Models with Web Openings, Journal of Strain Analysis, 16:4, 251-259. Hoglund, T. (1971). Strength of Thin Plate Girders with Circular or Rectangular Web Holes without Web Stiffeners, Proceedings, Colloquium of the International Association of Bridge and Structural Engineering, London. Jyrki Kesti and Penti Makelainen. (1999). Compression Behaviour of Perforated Steel Wall Studs, Lightweight Steel and Aluminum Structures. Loov, R. (1984). Local Buckling Capacity of C-Shaped Cold-Formed Steel Sections with Punched Webs, Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, 11, 1-7. Mahendran, M., Shanmugam, N. E. and Richard Liew, J. Y. (1994). Strength of Stiffened Plates with Openings, Proceedings, Twelfth International Specialty Conference on Cold-Formed Steel Structures, St. Louis, 29-40. Mahendran, M., Shanmugam, N. E. and Liew, J. Y. (1996). Design of Stiffened Plates with Openings, Journal of Institution of Engineers, Singapore, 36:2, 15-21.
45 Miller, T. H. and Pekoz, T. (1994). Unstiffened Strip approach for Perforated Wall Studs, ASCE Journal of Structural Engineering, 120:2, 410-421. Nabil Abdel-Rahman and Sivakumaran, K. S. (1998). Effective Design Width for Perforated Cold-Formed Steel Compression Members, Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, 25, 319-330. Narayanan, R. and Rockey, K. C. (1981). Ultimate Load Capacity of Plate Girders with Webs containing Circular Cut-outs, Proceedings, Institution of Civil Engineers, 71:2, 845-862. Narayanan, R. and Der Avenesian, N. G. V. (1983a). Strength of Webs Containing Circular Cutouts, IABSE Proceedings P-64/83, 141-152. Narayanan, R. and Der Avenesian, N. G. V. (1983b). Equilibrium Solution for Predicting the Strength of Webs with Rectangular Holes, Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers, 75:2, 265-282. Narayanan, R. and Der Avenesian, N. G. V. and Ghannam, M. M. (1983). Small-scale Model Tests on Perforated Webs, The Structural Engineer, 61 (3), 47-53. Narayanan, R. (1983). Ultimate Shear Capacity of Pate Girders with Openings in Webs, Plated Structures-Stability and Strength, ed. R. Narayanan, Applied Science Publishers, London, pp. 3976. Narayanan, R. and Der Avenesian, N. G. V. (1984a). Design of Slender Webs Containing Circular Holes, IABSE Proceedings P-72/84, pp. 25-32. Narayanan, R. and Der Avenesian, N. G. V. (1984b). An Equilibrium Method for assessing the Strength of Plate Girders with Reinforced Web Openings, Proceedings, Institution of Civil Engineers, 77:2, pp. 107-137. Narayanan, R. and Der Avenesian, N. G. V. (1984c). Elastic Buckling of Perforated Plates under Shear, Thin-Walled Structures, 2, 51-73. Narayanan, R. and Der Avenesian, N. G. V. (1984d). Strength of Webs with Comer Openings, The Structural Engineer, 62B, 6-11. Narayanan, R. and Chow, F. Y. (1984a). Strength of Biaxially Compressed Perforated Plates, Proceedings, Seventh International Specialty Conference on Cold-Formed Steel Structures, University of Missouri-Rolla, 55-73. Narayanan, R and Chow, F.Y. (1984b). Ultimate Capacity of Uniaxially Compressed Perforated Plates, Thin-Walled Structures, 2, 241-264,. Narayanan, R and Chow, F.Y. (1984c). Buckling of Plates Containing Openings, Proceedings, Seventh International Specialty Conference on Cold-Formed Steel Structures, University of Missouri Rolla, 39-53. Narayanan, R. and Chow, F. Y. (1984d). Experiments on Perforated Plates Subjected to Shear, Thin-Walled Structures, 2, 51-73. Narayanan, R. and Der Avenesian, N. G. V. (1985). Design of Slender Webs having Rectangular Holes, dournal of Structural Engineering, ASCE, 111:4, 777-787. Narayanan, R. and Darwish, I. Y. S. (1985). Strength of Slender Webs having Non-Central Holes, The Structural Engineer, 63B, 57-62,. Narayanan, R. and Chan, S.L. (1985). Ultimate Capacity of Plates Containing Holes under Linearly Varying Edge Displacements, Computers and Structures, 21:4, 841-849. Narayanan, R. and Der Avenesian, N. G. V. (1986). Analysis of Plate Girders with Perforated Webs, Thin-Walled Structures, 4, 363-380. Narayanan, R. (1987). Simplified Procedures for the Strength Assessment of Axially Compressed Plates with or without Openings, Proceedings, International Conference on Steel and Aluminum Structures, Cardiff, 592-606. Ortiz-Colberg, R. (1981). The Load Carrying Capacity of Perforated Cold-Formed Steel Columns, M.Sc. Thesis, Cornell University, Ithaca, N.Y. Pennington Vann, W. (1971 ) Compressive Buckling of Perforated Plate Elements, Proceedings of the first Specialty Conference on Cold-Formed Structures, University of Missouri Rolla, 52-57. Redwood, R.G. and Uenoya, M. (1979). Critical Loads for Webs with Holes, d. Struct. Div., ASCE 105, 2053-2067.
46 Ritchie, D. and Rhodes, J. (1975). Buckling and Post-Buckling Behaviour of Plates with Holes, Aeronautical Quarterly, 281-296. Roberts, T. M. and Azizian, Z. G. (1984). Strength of Perforated Plates subjected to in-plane Loading, Thin-Walled Structures, 2:2, 153-164. Rockey, K. C., Anderson, R. G. and Cheung, Y. K. (1967). The behaviour of square Shear Webs having Circular Hole, Proceedings of the Swansea Conference on Thin-Walled Structures, Crosby Lockwood and Sons, London, 148-169. Rhodes, J., and Macdonald, M. (1996). The effects of Perforation Length on the behaviour of Perforated Elements in Compression, Proceedings, 13th International Specialty Conference on Cold-Formed Steel Structures, St. Louis, Mo., 91-101. Rhodes, J. and Schneider, F. D. (1996). The Compressional behaviour of Perforated Elements, Proceedings, 12th International Specialty Conference on Cold-Formed Steel Structures, St. Louis, Mo., 11-28. Sabir, A.B. and Chow, F.Y. (1983). Elastic Buckling of Flat Panels Containing Circular and Square Holes, Proceedings, International Conference on Instability and Plastic Collapse of Structures, Manchester, pp. 311-321. Said, A. N. (1995). The behaviour of Thin-Walled Perforated Elements under Compression, Final Year Project Thesis, University of Strathclyde, Glascow. Schuster, R. M. (1999). Perforated Cold-Formed Steel C-Sections subjected to shear (Experimental Results), Light-Weight Steel and Alumnium Structures, 779-788. Shan, M.Y., LaBoube, R.A. and Yu W.W. (1993). Shear behaviour of web elements with openings, Proceedings, Structural Stability Research Council Annual Technical Session. 103-113. Shan, M. Y., Batson, K. D., LaBoube, R. A. and Yu, W. W. (1994). Local Buckling flexural Strength of Webs with Openings, Engineering Structures, 16:5, 317-323. Shan, M. Y. (1994). Behaviour of Web Elements with Openings subjected to Bending, Shear and the combination of Bending and Shear, PhD dissertation, Dept. of Civil Engg., University of Missouri Rolla, Roila, Mo.. Shan, M. Y., LaBoube, R. A. and Yu. W. W. (1966). Bending and Shear Behaviour of Web Elements with Openings, Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE. Shanmugam, N. E. and Evans, H. R. (1979). An Experimental and Theoretical Study of the effects of Web Openings on the Elastic Behaviour of Cellular Structures, Proceedings, The Institution of Civil Engineers, 67:2, 653-676. Shanmugam, N.E and Narayanan, R. (1982). Elastic Buckling of Perforated Square Plates for Various Loading and Edge Conditions, Proc., Proceedings, International Conference on finite element methods, Shanghai, China, 241-245. Shanmugam, N. E. and Evans, H. R. (1985). Structural Response and Ultimate Strength of Cellular Structures with Perforated Webs, Thin-Walled Structures, 3,255-271. Shanmugam, N.E. and Balendra, T. (1985). Model Studies on Multi-Cell Structures, Proceedings, Institution of Civil Engineers, Part 2: Research and Theory, 79, 55-71. Shanmugam, N. E. and Paramasivam and Lee, S. L. (1985). Ultimate Strength of Axially Compressed Stiffened Plates Containing Openings, Proceedings of the International Conference on Metal Structures, Melbourne, Australia, 48-52. Shanmugam, N. E. and Paramasivam and Lee, S. L. (1986). Stiffened Flanges Containing Openings, Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE, 112:10, 2234-2246. Shanmugam, N. E. and Thevendran, V. (1992). Critical Loads of Thin-Walled Beams Containing Web Openings, Thin-Walled Structures, 14, 291-305. Shanmugam, N.E. (1997). Openings in Thin-Walled Structures. Thin-Walled Structures, 28:3-4, 355-372. Shanmugam, N. E., Thevendran. V. and Y. H. Tan. (1999). Design Formula for Axially Compressed Perforated Plates, Thin-Walled Structures, 34, 1-20.
47 Sivakumaran, K. S., Banwait, A. S. (1987). Effect of Perforation on the Strength of Axially Loaded Cold-Formed Steel Section, Proceedings, International conference on Steel and Aluminum Structures, Cardiff, UK, 8-10 July 1987, pp. 428-437. Sivakumaran, K. S. (1987). Load Capacity of Uniformly Compressed Cold-Formed Steel Section with Punched Web, Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, 14, 550-558. Sivakumaran, K. S. and Nabil Abdel-Rahman. (1998). A Finite Element Analysis Model for the Behaviour of Cold-Formed Steel Members, Thin-Walled Structures, 31,305-324. Sivakumaran, K.S. (1988). Some Studies on Cold-Formed Steel Sections with Web Openings, Proceedings, Ninth International Specially Conference on Cold-Formed Steel Structures, St. Louis, 513-527. Sivakumaran, K.S. and Zielonka, K. M. (1989). Web Crippling Strength of Thin-Walled Steel Members with Web Openings, Thin-Walled Structures, 8, 295-319. Thevendran, V and Shanmugam, N. E. (1991). Lateral Buckling of Doubly Symmetric Beams Containing Openings, Jr. Eng. Mech., ASCE, 117:7, 1427-41. Thevendran, V and Shanmugam, N. E. (1992). Lateral Buckling of Narrow Rectangular Beams Containing Openings, Computers and Structures, 43(2), 247-254. Winter, G. (1947). Strength of Thin Steel Compression Flanges, Transactions of the American Society of Civil Engineers, 112, 527-554. Yu, W.W. and Davies, C.S. (1971). Bucking Behaviour and Post-Buckling Strength of Perforated Stiffened Compression Elements, Proceedings, The first Specially Conference on Cold-Formed Structures, University of Missouri Rolla, 58-64. Yu, W. W. and Davies, C. S. (1973). Cold-Formed Steel Members with Perforated Elements, ASCE Journal of Structural Engineering Division, 99(ST 10), 2061-2077. APPENDIX I: SAMPLE OF THE MAIN R E C O R D OF THE DATA B A S E STRUCTURE : WORKSHEET:
No
Year
PLATE PLATE
Title
Source
Author
Status
1971
CompressiveBuckling of Perforated Plate Elements
The first SpecialityConference PenningtonVann, on Cold-FormedStructures W
Platel
1971
BuckingBehaviourand PostBuckling Strength of Perforated Stiffened CompressionElements
The first SpecialityConference Yu, W.W., on Cold-FormedStructures Davies, C.S
Plate2
1975
Bucklingand Post-Buckling Behaviour of Plates with Holes
Aeronautical Quarterly
1982
ElasticBuckling of Perforated Square Plates for Various Loading and Edge Conditions
Proc., International Conference Shanmugam,N.E, on finite element methods Narayanan,R
Plate4
1983
Elastic Buckling of Flat Panels Containing Circular and Square Holes
Proc., International Conference Sabir,A.B., on Instability and Plastic Chow, F.Y Collapse of Structures
Plate5
1983
Buckling and Elasto-Plastic Collapse of Perforated Plates
Proc., International Conference Azizian,Z.G, on Instability and Plastic Roberts, T.M Collapse of Structures
Plate6
1984
Ultimate Capacity of Uniaxially Compressed Perforated Plates
Thin-Walled Structures, (Vol.2) Narayanan,R, Chow, F.Y
Plate7
Ritchie, D., Rhodes, Plate3 J
48
STRUCTURE : BEAM WORKSHEET:
BEAM
1
1967
The Behaviour of Square Shear Webs having Circular Hole
Proc., The Swansea Conference on Thin-Walled Structures
Rockey,K.C., Anderson, R.G., Cheung, Y.K
Beaml
2
1971
Bucking Behaviour and PostBuckling Strength of Perforated Stiffened Compression Elements
The first Speciality Conference on Cold-Formed Structures
Yu, W.W., Davies, C.S
Beam2
3
1971
Strength of Thin Plate Girders with Circular or Rectangular Web Holes without Web Stiffeners
Proc., Coloquium, International Association of Bridge and Structural Engineering, London
Hoglund, T.
Beam3
4
1981
Ultimate Load Capacity of Plate Girders with Webs Containing Circular Cut-Outs
Proc., Institution of Civil Engineers, Part2, Vol.71, pp 845-862
Narayanan, R., Rockey, K.C.
Beam4
5
1983
Design of I beams with Web Perforations
Beams and Beam ColumnsStability Strength
Redwood, R.G.
Beam5
6
1983
Equilibrium Solution for Predicting the Strength of webs with Rectangular Holes
Proc., Institution of Civil Engineers, Part2, Vol.75, pp 265-282
Narayanan, R., Der Avenessian, N.G.V.
Beam6
7
1983
Strength of Webs Containing Circular Cut-Outs
IABSE Proceedings P-64/83, pp 141-152
Narayanan, R., Der Avenessian, N.G.V
Beam7
8
1983
Small-Scale Model Tests on Perforated Webs
The Structural Engineer, Vol. 61B, No.3, pp. 47-53
Narayanan, R., Der Avenessian, N.G.V Ghannam, M.M.
Beam8
STRUCTURE
:
WORKSHEET :
COLUMN COLUMN
1
1971
Compressive Buckling of Perforated Plate Elements
The first Speciality Conference on Cold-Formed Structures
Pennington Vann, W
Columnl
2
1971
Bucking Behaviour and PostBuckling Strength of Perforated Stiffened Compression Elements
The first Speciality Conference on Cold-Formed Structures
Yu, W.W., Davies, C.S.
Column2
3
1973
Cold-Formed Steel Members with Perforated Elements
ASCE Journal of Structural Engineering Division, Vol.99(STI 0), pp. 2061-2077
Yu, W.W., Davies, C.S.
Column3
4
1984
Local Buckling Capacity of CShaped Cold-Formed Steel Sections with Punched Webs
Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, Vol. 11, pp. 1-7
Loov, R.
Column4
5
1984
Effect of Perforation on the Strength of Axially Loaded ColdFormed Steel Section
Proc. Int. natl. Conf. On Steel Aluminum Structures, Cardiff, UK, 1987, pp. 428-437
Sivakumaran, K.S., Banwait, A.S.
Column5
6
1987
Load Capacity of Uniformly Compressed Cold-Formed Steel Section with Punched Web
Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, Vol. 14, pp. 550558
Sivakumaran, K.S.
Column6
49
APPENDIX
II: SAMPLE
SET OF DATA BASE
PLATE 7 Year Subject Title Author Structure Boundary Condition
: : : : :
1956 Ultimate Capacity of Uniaxially Compressed Perforated Plates Thin-Walled Structures, (Vol.2) Narayanan, R and Chow, F.Y Plate
:
Simply Supported
An approximate method of evaluating the ultimate capacity has been suggested using simple elastic-plastic concepts. Design Curves for centrally perforated plates have been suggested for designers. The analysis is based on small deflection theory, hence the method is not valid for wide plates with slenderness values in excess of 80 or so
Table I : DETAILS OF TEST SPECIMENS CONTAINING CENTRAL CUTOUTS Group Circular
a (mm)
t (mm)
a/t = b/t
d or a' (mm)
d/a or a'/a
Imper (mm)
lmper/t
YldStress N/mm2
CIR2a CIR2b CIR3a CIR4a CIR4b CIR5a CIR6 CIR7 CIR8 CIR9 CIRI 0 CIR11 CIR12
125.0 125.0 125.0 125.0 125.0 125.0 86.0 86.0 86.0 86.0 86.0 86.0 86.0
1.615 1.615 1.615 1.615 1.615 1.615 2.032 1.615 0.972 0.693 2.032 1.615 0.972
77.40 77.40 77.40 77.40 77.40 77.40 42.30 53.23 88.48 124.10 42.30 53.25 88.48
25.0 25.0 37.5 50.0 50.0 62.5 25.0 25.0 25.0 25.0 40.0 40.0 40.0
0.2 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.4 0.5 0.291 0.291 0.291 0.291 0.465 0.465 0.465
0.229 0.097 0.136 0.304 0.127 0.279 0.254 0.229 0.102 0.051 0.102 0.279 0.152
0.142 0.060 0.084 0.188 0.079 0.173 0.143 0.142 0.105 0.074 0.050 0.173 0.156
323.3 323.3 323.3 323.3 323.3 323.3 334.7 323.3 317.6 322.8 334.7 323.3 317.6
Square SQ2 SQ3 SQ4 SQ5
125.0 125.0 125.0 125.0
1.615 1.615 1.615 1.615
77.40 77.40 77.40 77.40
25.0 37.5 50.0 62.5
0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5
0.097 0.141 0.113 0.209
0.060 0.087 0.070 0.129
323.3 323.3 323.3 323.3
Table 2 : DETAILS OF TEST SPECIMENS CONTAINING ECCENTRICAL CUTOUTS Yield Stress = 317.6 N/mm2 Specimen Circular
a t (mm) (mm)
aJt = b/t
d or a' (mm)
d/a or a'/a
e (mm)
e/a
lmper (mm)
Imper/t
UEC 1 UEC 2
125.0 0.972 125.0 0.972
128.60 128.60
37.5 62.5
0.3 0.5
12.5 12.5
0.1 0.1
0.254 0.102
0.261 0.105
Square UES 1 UES 2 UES 3 UES4
125.0 125.0 125.0 125.0
128.60 128.60 128.60 128.60
37.5 62.5 37.5 62.5
0.3 0.5 0.3 0.5
12.5 12.5 25.0 25.0
0.1 0.1 0.2 0.2
0.127 0.229 0.078 0.132
0.131 0.236 0.080 0.136
0.972 0.972 0.972 0.972
50
Table 3: E X P E R I M E N T A L RESULTS FOR UNIAXIALLY LOADED PLATES HAVING CENTRAL HOLES Specimen
a/t
d/a or a'/a
Observed Values Ku Avg. Failure Load (Pf) (kN)
Circulzr
(mm)
(mm)
Pcr Avg. (kN)
PL CIR2a CIR2b CIIL3a CIR4a CIR4b CIR5a CIR6 CIR7 CIR8 CIR9 CIRI 0 CIR11 CIR12 Square Hole SQ2 SQ3 SQ4 SQ5
77.40 77.40 77.40 77.40 77.40 77.40 77.40 42.30 53.23 88.48 124.10 42.30 53.25 88.48
0.0 0.2 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.4 0.5 0.291 0.291 0.291 0.291 0.465 0.465 0.465
25.064 22.504 23.228 21.311 19.706 18.358 19.482 6.341 2.320 5.926
4.013 3.604 3.720 3.413 3.156 2.940 3.120 3.205 3.235 2.995
77.40 77.40 77.40 77.40
0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5
22.600 20.290 18.230 19.170
3.620 3.250 2.920 3.070
Pf/Psq
Pxh/Psq
Pxh/Pf
39.32 37.46 38.70 33.94 29.57 28.39 27.35 42.17 26.18 12.35 7.33 33.64 22.14 10.89
0.603 0.574 0.593 0.520 0.453 0.435 0.419 0.721 0.583 0.465 0.381 0.575 0.493 0.410
0.610 0.560 0.560 0.510 0.470 0.470 0.420 0.700 0.615 0.480 0.410 0.560 0.510 0.410
1.012 0.976 0.944 0.981 1.038 1.080 1.002 0.971 1.055 1.032 1.076 0.974 1.034 1.000
33.48 28.85 25.52 21.86
0.525 0.460 0.400 0.340
0.525 0.460 0.400 0.340
1.024 1.041 1.023 1.015
BEAM 12
Year : 1984 Subject : Strength of Webs x~ith Con~er Openings Title : The Structural Engineer, Vol. 62B, pp. 6-11 Author : Narayanan, R and Der-Avanessian, N.G Structure: Plate Girder Material: Steel An equilibrium method of predicting the ultiamte capacity of plate girder webs containing comer web openings and loaded in shear is presented and based on the post-critical behaviour of such webs. Ultimate load = elastic critical load on the web + load carried by the tensile membrane stresses developed in the post=critical stages + load carried by the flanges. TABLE 2: E X P E R I M E N T A L VALUES OF U L I T M A T E LOADS C O M P A R E D WITH PREDICTED VALUES Girder
NCP13 NCPI3 NCPl4 NCPI4 NCP 15 NCP15 NCPl 6 NCPl6
Diameter of Cutout (mm) 125 175 250 325 180 270 360 480
h/t (nominal)
b/h (nominal)
d/h (nominal)
250 250 250 250 360 360 360 360
1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1 l l l
0.25 0.35 0.5 0.65 0.25 0.375 0.5 0.67
Observed Ultimate load (kN) 176.4 168.6 125.4 85 234.4 218.8 170.2 112
Equilibrium Solution Predicted load Pre/obs (kN) (kN) 162.9 0.923 157.2 0.932 121.7 0.97 79.7 0.937 221.5 0.945 202.1 0.924 158.8 0.933 87.4 0.78
The theory and experiments confirm that it is advantageous to locate the holes in the comers of the web panels in the compression diagonal i.e far away from the tension field.
51
COLUMN 6 Year : Subject: Title : Author : Structure: Material: Internal Radius: Loading : Section : Opening :
1984 Local Buckling Capacity of C-Shaped Cold-Formed Steel Sections with Punched Webs Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, Vol. 11, pp. 1-7 Loov, R Column Steel 3.2 Stub-column test Lipped Channel Section Each of the studs had a 38.1 x 44.5 mm rectangular hole centrally punched in the web. Additionally, a 22.2mm diameter hole was centered 41.3ram from one edge of the rectangular opening & a 27.7mm diameter hole was centered in 41.3mm on the opposite side along the centerline of the web.
Specimen
Web
Flange
Lip
Hole Width
Fy
Test
1 2 3 4 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36
(mm) 63.8 63.8 63.8 63.7 63.7 63.5 63.5 63.5 92.3 92.3 92.3 92.1 92.1 92.1 92.4 92.4 92.4 152.8 152.8 152.8 152.5 152.5 152.5 152.6 152.6 152.6 203.7 203.7 203.7 203.0 203.0 203.0 204.0 204.0 204.0
(mm) 42.6 42.6 42.6 42.2 42.2 42.4 42.4 42.4 42.2 42.2 42.2 42.2 42.2 42.2 42.4 42.4 42.4 42.1 42.1 42.1 41.9 41.9 41.9 42.2 42.2 42.2 42.1 42.1 42.1 41.9 41.9 41.9 42.7 42.7 42.7
(mm) 12.5 12.5 12.5 13.0 13.0 12.1 12.1 12.1 12.5 12.5 12.5 13.0 13.0 13.0 12.8 12.8 12.8 12.7 12.7 12.7 12.8 12.8 12.8 12.9 12.9 12.9 12.5 12.5 12.5 12.9 12.9 12.9 12.9 12.9 12.9
(mm) 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38. I 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1 38.1
MPa 384.0 384.0 384.0 382.9 382.9 268.5 268.5 268.5 268.5 268.5 268.5 382.9 382.9 382.9 384.0 384.0 384.0 268.5 268.5 268.5 382.9 382.9 382.9 384.0 384.0 384.0 268.5 268.5 268.5 382.9 382.9 382.9 384.0 384.0 384.0
(kN) 103.62 103.92 102.40 78.65 76.00 44.76 43.87 42.80 46.92 48.11 48.22 72.00 76.40 78.90 119.20 118.00 118.20 51.52 52.32 52.46 84.10 83.40 86.70 128.30 130.00 125.20 51.33 48.70 46.02 87.20 81.70 86.70 133.00 133.50 135.40
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Third International Conference on Thin-Walled Structures J. Zara~, K. Kowal-Michalskaand J. Rhodes 9 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved
53
SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS OF THIN-WALLED MEMBERS, PROBLEMS AND APPLICATIONS C. Szymczak Department of Civil Engineering, Technical University of Gdafisk, U1. G. Narutowicza 11, 80-340 Gdafisk, Poland
ABSTRACT A review of problems related to sensitivity analysis of thin walled members with open monosymmetric or bisymmetric cross-section is presented. Three different kinds of restraint imposed on angle of crosssection rotation, transverse displacement and cross-section warping are taken into account. The consideration is based upon the classical theory of thin-walled beams with nondeformable cross-section for linear elastic range of the member material. Attention is focused on the members undergoing torsion, because this topic is not so popular as bending and/or compression. The first variations of state variables due to a change of the design variable are investigated. Arbitrary displacement, internal force or reaction of the member subject to static load, critical buckling load, frequency and mode of torsional vibration are assumed to be the state variables. The dimensions of the cross-section, the material constants, the restraints stiffness, and their locations, position of the member ends are taken as the design variables. All problems under consideration are illustrated by numerical examples. Accuracy of the approximation changes of the state variables achieved by sensitivity analysis is also discussed. Finally some problems dealing with generalization of the sensitivity analysis elaborated upon the space frames and grids assembled with thin-walled members are described.
KEYWORDS Thin-walled structures, statics, stability, vibrations, restraints, sensitivity analysis.
INTRODUCTION Behavior of the thin-walled members is described by means of so-called state variable s such as: displacements, internal forces, reactions, critical buckling loads and frequencies and modes of free vibrations. The values of these state variables depend on many parameters of the members, known as design variables d. In many problems of engineering practice it is very useful to know a direct relation between the state variable variation 6s and the design variable variation of 5d. Sensitivity analysis (Haug, Choi & Komkov (1986)) enables to derive such relations. Since the sensitivity analysis of structures undergoing bending and compression or tension is well developed, the present paper deals with the sensitivity analysis of members subjected to torsion. From the mathematical point of view, one can distinguish two kinds of design variables:
54 Continuous variables, for example, the cross-section dimensions and the member material constants, Discrete variables, for instance, the restraints stiffness and their location and the support position. In case of the variation of the continuous design variable the first order variation of the state variable sought can be expressed as follows -
-
1
~Ss= IFsa(z)Sd dz
(1)
0
where the underintegral function Fsd(z)can be considered as the influence line of the state variable variation due to the unit point variation of the design variable. If the discrete design variables are taken into account, then a similar relation between the state variable variation and the vector of the design variable variation 5d is 5s = WsT &l
(2)
where vector Wsd consists of the first order sensitivity coefficient corresponding to the design variable and (...)T denotes transposition of the vector. The usual assumptions of the classical theory of thin-walled members with nondeformable crosssection (Vlasov (1959)) adopted in this paper are: (1) The thin-walled member is prismatic, (2) The static loads are conservative, (3) The member cross-section is not deformed in its plane but it is subject to warping in the longitudinal direction, (4) The shear deformation in the middle surface vanishes, (5) The deformations and the strains are small, (6) The member material is homogeneous, isotropic and obeys Hooke's law. Because a lack of a general theory of thin-walled members with arbitrary variable cross-section, the sensitivity analysis is restricted to the member cross-section with one or double axis of symmetry. It is well known that for the bisymmetric cross-section, torsion of the member can be considered independently of bending, as in case of monosymmetric cross-section bending with respect of the symmetry axis independently of torsion and bending with respect to the second axis. Three types of elastic restraints are considered in this paper: the flexural restraint against the lateral displacement of the member axis, the torsional restraint against the member cross-section rotation, and the warping restraint against the cross-section warping. The behavior of the restraints is modelled by suitable linear elastic supports. The sensitivity analysis problems are investigated only for linearly elastic range of the member material behavior.
SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS OF MEMBERS SUBJECT TO STATIC LOADS
Continuous design variable Consider a thin-walled beam with bisymmetric open cross-section shown in Figure 1. The rectangular coordinate system x,y,z is so chosen that x and y coincide with the principal axis of the cross-section and z coincide with the longitudinal axis of the beam. The beam of length I is subjected to a distributed torque m, and axial end loads P. Moreover, two types of restraint, torsional and warping, are imposed on the member. Following Szewczak, Smith & DeWolf (1983) continuously distributed restraints under consideration are modelled by linear elastic foundation with corresponding stiffness k0, kw. In this case the torsion of the member can be considered independently of bending. A detailed treatment of the member behavior is presented by Trahair and Bild (1990). The first variation of the state variable 5s determining the behavior of the member due to some variations of the design variable 5d is sought.
55
m
P._l'.z/r
kw, k0
:-i
'
k0
\
kw
Figure 1" Thin-walled member with bisymmetric cross-section The angle of cross-section rotation and its first derivative, the internal force at a specified cross-section or reactions at the supports and restraints are assumed to be the state variable. Our attention in this section is concentrated on the continuous design variables, for example,: the cross-section dimensions, the material moduli, and the stiffness of the continuously distributed restraints. Taking advantage of the concept of adjoint structure (Dems & Mr6z (1983)), the first variation of the design variable can be written as (compare Budkowska & Szymczak (1992a)) 1
5s=
),d
+
+kw,d
+k0,d
0 0 where E and G are Young's and shear modulus, respectively; Iw stands for the warping constant, Id denotes the St. Venant torsion constant, r represents the radius of gyration of the cross-section, 0 m
and 0 are the angle of the cross-section rotation for the external loads and adjoint member, respectively. The derivative with respect to z is denoted by prime and ("'),d is the partial derivative with respect to the design variable d. The underintegral function Fsd(Z) is considered to be the influence line of the state variable variation due to point unit variation of the design variable. The static analysis of the member necessary to determine the influence line can be carried out by the FEM. The first numerical example deals with continuous thin-walled I beam presented in Figure 2. The computer program elaborated on the basis of the sensitivity analysis presented enables to obtain the influence line of the torsional moment on the right side of support B due to point torsional restraint with unit stiffness K0 = 1. m = 2 kNm/m for 0< z <7.2
!z
J ...... .......
A
.L
.a_
~
-
9
4x0.8
Kw = 50 kNm 3
S .....
,,~-
..,
3x0.4
3.2m
~
M=2kN
1.2
~.
K0 = 50 kNm
0.8
4x0.4 4m
1.2m 2m
t,b,j ~ , t
h-0.2 ,
t - 0.01 m b = 0.15 m (B-C) v 0.2 m (A-B, C-D)
Figure 2: Thin-walled I-beam
Discrete design variable Now consider the effect of variations of discrete design variable on the behavior of the member. Of course the effect of such discrete variable as the restraint dimensions or the spring support stiffness can be determined using the above presented influence line. If, for example, one dimension di of the torsional restraint at a specified cross-section z = z0 is taken into account, then the variation of the
56
restraint stiffness 5K0 can be expressed by the design variable variation 6di 5K0 = (K0),(t (Sdi,
(4)
and the state variable variation 5s can be calculated by multiplication of the value of the influence line at z = zo by relation (4). 0.0 0E+0 '-": .
.
.
.
1.0 '
.
.
.
.
2.0 |
.
.
.
.
3.0 |
.
.
.
4.0
.
|
.
.
.
5.0
.
,
.
.
.
.
6.0 |
9
i
,
,
7.0 I
,
,
.
-
8.0 |
.
.
.
.
9.0 ,,
9
z[m] -2E-3 -4E-3 -6E-3" -8E-3 Figure 3: Influence line of torsional moment on the right side of support B due to point torsional restraint with unit stiffness K0 = 1 Therefore only the discrete variable related to location of the member support and the restraints is investigated in this section. The member should be divided into some sections from one restraint to another and in order to find the variation of the state variable, at first some shifts of the section ends 5zo and 5zl (see Figure 1) are analysed. Using the rules of calculus of variations for variable boundary (Gelfand & Fomin(1970)) for the total potential energy of the member and taking into account above mentioned concept of the adjoint system one can derive the variation of state variable 5s due to assumed shifts of the member ends (see Iwicki (1997))
(-
+
(-
+
Ms0,- 0. zo
where B is the bimoment, Ms denotes the torsional moment and by overbar the values of the state variable at the adjoint member are represented .Having used relation (5) for each section of the member and after utilising the continuity conditions, some suitable formulae for the state variation for shift of arbitrary support or restraint can be derived. To illustrate the theoretical considerations a clamped beam subject to uniformly distributed torque is given in Figure 4. The relative variation of the bimoment at the beam middle cross-section 5B/B due to the relative shift of the fight support 5zr/1 is determined and shown in Figure 5. The accuracy of the approximation of the bimoment change given by sensitivity analysis is compared with the exact results. in
z
f:
t.:_i
~...r .....-J - " ....~ ' ...... - - .....,,+- ....- - .....
2 in
~
~1 - 4 in
i.\ ,
.] - 5z~
1 0.2
t-0.01 in, E=210GPa, G-80.77 GPa
Figure 4: Clamped thin-walled I-beam with shift of right support
57 0.4
0,2
-
-
!
Sens Exar
itivity analysi~ t results
0 -
8B/B
J
f -0.2
-f
J
f
I
-0.4
-
-0.1
0 0.1 ~Szl/1 Figure 5: Relative variation of bimoment at the middle cross-section vs. relative shift of beam end
SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS OF CRITICAL BUCKLING LOADS
Continuous design variable Consider the flexural-torsional buckling of a thin-walled member of length 1 with open monosymmetric cross-section shown in Figure 6. Three kinds of restraints are imposed on it. Besides the two above mentioned torsional and warping restraints, an additional one namely a flexural restraint of stiffness ku against horizontal displacement u of the member axis is imposed. The member is subjected to axial end loads P, a distributed load q and two end bending moments Ml and M2. It is also assumed that the moments depend on one parameter m. Thus a three-parameter-stability problem is formulated.
m-Ml~-'~--~ g P ~
"z"Z
ko,kx,kw
m.M2 _~0
. . . .
"/ 1
//"
~
y
Figure 6: Thin-walled beam with monosymmetric open cross-section The total potential energy V of the beam in a buckled position may be written as (Trahair & Bild(1990)) V=0.5 S{ElyU.2 +El w0.2 +Gld 0,2 _ p [u,2 + ~ 2 + yo 2 )~,2 + 2you,0,]}dz 0
+0.5 ~[M (20u" + 13x0'2 )+ kuu2+ k002+ ks0'2 + q(yq_ Yo)02 ]dz, (6) 0 where Iy is the moment of inertia of the cross-section about axis y, Y0 stands for the distance of the distributed load to the member axis, yq denotes the place of acting of the distributed load q and 13x represents the coefficient of the cross-section. Using the first variation the functional (6) with respect to the design variable and taking into account that in critical state the potential energy vanishes we arrive
58 at the following relation between variations of the critical values of the applied loads and the design variable variation (Szymczak & Mikulski (2000)) 1{(EIy),d u"2 + (EIc0),d 0"2 + (GId),d 0'2 +ku,d u2 +k0, d 02 + k s , d 0,2}5ddz 0 + f{M(~x ,d 0'2)- P [~2,d +yO2,d)O'2 + 2YO,d u'O']+ q(yq,d-YO,d)02 }Sd dz
(7)
0
+~{~Mcr ~0u,+ ~x0,2 )._ ~SPcr[u,2 + ~2+ y02 )0,2+ 2Y0U,0,]+ &:lcr(yq_ Yo)02 }dz =0 0 Eqn.7 enables to determine variations of the critical loads in all possible interactions between them. The buckling mode described by displacements 0, u and their derivatives can be determined using the analytical method or the FEM in more complex cases. As a numerical example a simply supported beam subject to axial end loads P and two equal bending moments M at the ends is considered (Figure 7). bg= 0.I
pz~ ~Mi c r
~~.~Mcr
t?
I0 .2
k
l=8m
p
~~
Ijl\
..1
"ba = 0.2 " m E = 210GPa, G = 80.769 GPa, t = 0.01 m
Figure 7: Simply supported thin-walled beam with monosymmetric cross-section 250 200 P
150 gr
[kN]
100
/.
. i
~,B
B
.~.
B
M
/
-
50_
-100
-50
0
50
100
M cr
[kNm]
Figure 8: Interaction curves of critical load Per vs. critical moment Mcr for beam with monosymmetric cross-section (M) and bisymmetric cross-section 03) Figure 8 shows the interaction curves of axial load P and bending moments M for beams with monosymmetric cross-section and comparable bisymmetric cross-section. The width of flanges of the bisymmetric cross-section is equal to an average width of monosymmetric beam. The influence lines of the relative variation of the critical buckling moments for positive (M > 0) and negative (M < 0) values due to a point restraints with unit stiffness are established and shown in Figures 9, 10 and 11. The axial end loads are not taken into account (P = 0). The variations of the critical moments are presented with reference to the critical moments of beam without any restraints. Moreover, similar influence lines
59 corresponding to I beam with bisymmetric cross-section are also added, for comparative purposes. More details for the case of members with a bisymmetric cross-section can be found in Szymczak (1999a). 10p
,,_
D M>0 M<0
8Mer/Mer [10 3]
B
5
.1
\
0
2
4
6
8
z[m] Figure 9: Influence lines of relative variations of critical moment 15M~r/ Mcr for monosymmetric and bisymmetric cross-section (B) due to point flexural restraint unit stiffness Kx = 1 _
f
.~
//
P= 0 M>0 M<0
5Mcr/Mcr
[10 -3 ]
-
2.5
B
\
oi 0
2
4
6
8
z[m] Figure 10: Influence lines of relative variations of critical moment ~Mcr / Mer for monosymmetric and bisymmetric cross-section (B) due to point torsional restraint unit stiffness Ko = 1 Moreover, for thin-walled beams with bisymmetric cross-section the effect of residual normal stresses t~oon torsional buckling and post-buckling behavior of axially loaded columns is also investigated (see Szymczak (1998)). The variation of the critical buckling due to the design variable variation with allowance for arbitrary distributed residual stresses can be written as
~JPcr = ~ 0
w ,d
+ GId,d
- R0a,d
+ kw ,d
+ k|
r2
(8)
where the term including the effect of the residual stresses is R0a = Its0(x 2 + y2)dz
(9)
A The results obtained by Szymczak (1998) indicate that the residual stresses can cause an increase or decrease of the critical buckling load depending on the stress distribution over the cross-section. It is also evident that the point of bifurcation of torsional buckling is symmetric and stable independently of the residual stresses, that means insensitivity of the buckling load to inevitable geometrical imperfection of the column axis.
60
12
-'
=0 ---- M > 0 ]kA lVl
JN ~ u
8Mcr/Mcr
[10 -3]
0
2
4
6
8
z [m]
Figure 11" Influence lines of relative variations of critical moment ~Mcr [ Mcr for monosymmetric and bisymmetric cross-section (B) due to point warping restraint unit stiffness Kw = 1 Discrete design variable
Consider the variation of the flexural-buckling load due to the discrete variable variation. As explained above some changes of location of restraints, supports or the member ends are taken into consideration. The derivation of the first variation of the critical load due to the member end shifts 5z0, 5z~ proceeds in a similar manner to that of previous chapter but the final results are very complex to write them in a general way. If a special case of one parameter load M~ = M2 = M for fixed axial and transverse load (P, q- constants) is investigated, then the variation of the critical moment can be written as 5Mcr
= a-l(Wlz=16Zl- Wlz:05Zo)
(10)
where a=
u" + 0.5J3 x 0
W = 0.5{EIy (u " 2 - 2 u ' u ' ) + EI w {0" 2 - 20'0")+ GIde '2 - kx u2 - ko02 + kwe '2 } _ 0.5{P[u,2 + ~2 + yo2)9,2 + 2you,0,]+ Mcr (2u,0,_ 13x0,2)+ q(yq _ yo)02 }
(11)
and by ("')lz=k the expression calculated for z = k is denoted.
I-----
1.5 -
Sensitivity (M>0) Exact (M >0) Sensi!ivity (M <0) F.~tact (u ~n) J
1.3 i
5Mcr/Mcr
1.1
-
0.9
-
0.7 ....
0.8
0) 0.9
1
1.1
1.2
1+ 8zl/1 Figure 12: Comparison of exact relative variation of the critical moment ~Mcr / Mcr vs. relative shift of beam 8Zl / I to its approximation obtained by sensitivity analysis
61 A numerical example illustrating a theoretical consideration deals with the beam presented in Figure 7 The axial loads P are neglected. The critical moment variation ~Mcr due to the beam end shift 5zl is sought. A comparison of the relative variation of the critical moment 5 M J Mcr obtained by means of sensitivity analysis with the exact results is presented in Figure 12 for a positive and negative value of the critical moment. A good agreement of approximation of the exact results by the sensitivity analysis should be noted. It is also very important, from the engineering point of view, to give a more detailed specification of the point of bifurcation. It is well known (Szymczak (1980)) that the point of bifurcation of torsional buckling of thin-walled column with bisymmetric cross-section is symmetric and stable. It means that the critical load is insensitive to geometrical imperfections of the column axis. Szymczak (1999b) gives a contribution to the effect of restraint on the post-buckling behavior and the bifurcation point. It is worthwhile to point out that, for some stiffness of the restraint, the bifurcation point may be symmetric but unstable. In this case a drastic decrease of the critical buckling load can occur.
SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS OF F R E E TORSIONAL VIBRATION
Continuous design variable Consider free torsional vibration of a thin-walled member with bisymmetric open cross-section shown in Figure 1. The member is subject to axial end loads P but only torsional restraints against the crosssection rotation are taken into consideration. The first variation of the eigenvalue, i.e. the square of natural frequency 5~ = 50a2 due to variation of the distributed parameter ~Sd is sought. Making use of equivalence of the extremum values of the kinetic and potential energy and calculus of variations one can derive the variation under consideration (Budkowska & Szymczak (1992c)) 1
5~. = ~{(EIw),d 0"2 + [(GId),d-(pr2),d ]0 '2 + k0, d 0 2 - ~ o
(12)
[(Plo), d 02 +(PIw), d 0'2]}5d d z / ! p(Io0 2 + I w 0,2 )dz where p is the mass density of the member material and I0 stands for the polar moment of inertia of the cross-section. In Eqn.12 0 represents the mode of vibration corresponding to the frequency of free vibration sought. The dynamic analysis of free vibration to determine the frequencies and modes can be camed out analytically in simple cases or in numerical way by the FEM. The latter manner enables to obtain values of the influence line only in nodes of discretization of the member. Moreover, in this way the analysis in the case of discrete distribution of the restraints is more accurate. A simply supported I beam with constant cross-section subject to axial end loads P given in Figure 13 is acknowledged to be a numerical example. The relative variation of the first three eigenvalues 5~i]~,i for i = 1,2,3 due to the relative variation of the beam flanges 5b/b are under investigation. The influence lines obtained from the sensitivity analysis are presented in Figure 14. Flange width variation zone 5b 1/2=2.00 m ~I ~-I P---1' -.ยง ...... ' ...... ~
I__~
Y
1=4.00 m
b=0.20
p
0.01 ~
~
Figure 13: Simply supported thin-walled I beam
x--T~,1 0.01m
y
62
1-st
0.8
2-nd 3-rd
~",-~
eigenvalue eigenvalue eigenvalue
/\
ra
0.6
0.4
0.2
0 .0
i
!
'"
0 2 z Im| 4 Figure 14: Influence line of relative variation of three eigenvalues of torsional vibration 8~,i/~,i vs. relative variation of the I beam flange width 5b/b 0.25 exact solution
zl
sensitivity solution
f
I
f
0.00
-0.25
i
-0.50
i
i
i
I
i
0.00
I
I
I
5b/b
I
]
0.50
Figure 15" Approximation accuracy of relative change of the first natural frequency square to the I-beam flange width change in half of the span 0.6
....
0.4
P= 1 M N P=-I MN P-0 ~,,. ~" ~--/ / / / /
~5~L1/~l due
\ \ \
0.2
0.0
J
-0.2 0
2
z [m]
4
Figure 16: Effect of axial loads on the influence line of relative first eigenvalue due to relative variation of the I-beam flange width 5b/b
63 Figure 15 shows accuracy of the approximation of change of the first eigenvalue ~ i / ~ i due to the Ibeam flange width change in half of the span as seen in Figure 13. A good agreement of the sensitivity analysis result with the exact calculation is observed. Moreover, a distinct change of distribution of the influence lines of the first eigenvalue for three values of the axial loads is presented in Figure 16. The torsional vibration analysis is performed by the FEM, using a typical cubic shape function (Szymczak (1978)) Now, the variation of the vibration mode due to the design variable variation is investigated. It is assumed that the member is divided into some elements and Di denotes the eigenvector under consideration. Because the eigenvectors establish a complete set of vectors in the R k space, then the variation of the eigenvector Di can be represented by their linear combination m=k
8D i = 5". aijmDmSd j m=l where coefficients a0k can be written as
(13)
[OK
DIT ~ j - ~ ' i ~ j j aijl =
i fori41
(14)
(~i-~1)
and for i = 1 aiji = - 2 D T ar M D 19
(15)
where K and M are the stiffness and the mass matrices, respectively. Obviously, Eqn. (14) is valid only when ~i ~ Z.1 i.e. for simple (non-repeated) eigenvalues. To illustrate the results of this section, let us consider the same simply supported I-beam with a constant cross-section shown in Figure 13 but stiffened by three nodal torsional restraints of equal stiffness K0~ = 1(02 = 14,o3= K0 = 1000 kNm as shown in Figure 17. Some modifications of the stiffness of the restraints are assumed 814,01= 0.2K0, 81(02= 0.1K0, 8K03 = -0.214,o. The exact change of the first mode of the torsional vibration is determined by means of the FEM analysis and it is compared to the mode established by the sensitivity analysis in Figure 18. A very good approximation of the mode change obtained by means of the sensitivity analysis is worth noticing. b=0.20 m
z
0"01AA~/~ X~'20
' r
L am
~
lm
,.1., lm
J., lm
m
I K0= 1000 kNm
Y Figure 17: Simply supported I beam stiffened by three torsional restraints
Discrete design variable Now consider the variation of the free torsional vibration eigenvalue of the beam due to change of location of its end, the supports and the restraints imposed on the beam. At first, some shifts of the beam end 8z0. 8z~ are taken into account. As in problems discussed above, by use of the calculus of variations the frequency square variation 8X is derived.
64 60 sensitivity analysis exact solution
I
40
20 8Kol--0.2 Kol
0
\
~Ko2=0.1 Ko2 ~5K03=-0.2 K03 .... !
-20
i
0
1
i
!
2
3
z[m]
4
Figure 18: Comparison of exact first mode of torsional vibration with sensitivity analysis result for modified beam restraints 8~, = {[-EI w 0 ~2 + 2(EI w0")'0' - (GI d - [ - E I w 0"2 +2(EIw0")'0'-(GId
-
+ k~ pr2)0 '2 +ko 02
I
- P~'(I~
- Iw 0'2)] z=l
-
-
p~,(Io 02
Iw0'2)]z_ I ~ 6Zo}/
(16)
1
JP(Io 02 + Iw 0'2)dz 0 Having this variation derived, one can divide the member into some sections from one restraint to another and apply Eqn. (16) to each section. Also taking advantage of the continuity conditions in all points, where the sections are connected, it is possible to obtain an appropriate variation of the eigenvalue for any restraint under consideration. A simple example dealing with the simply supported I beam subject to axial end loads (Figure 19) allows to illustrate effectiveness of the sensitivity analysis presented. The variation of the beam length 81 is assumed. The exact first eigenvalue changes are found analytically and compared with the sensitivity analysis results. In order to investigate the effect of the axial loads on accuracy of the approximation a relative eigenvalue change for P = 0 and P = 1.5 MN is provided (Figure 20). In this case the torsional restraints are neglected. Moreover, the effect of continuously distributed torsional restraints is also studied. Figure 21 shows the accuracy of the sensitivity analysis approximation of the relative egenvalue change for the beam with and without restraints of stiffness k0 = 2 kNm. It is observed that in all cases a fairly good approximation is obtained even for twenty per cent change of the beam length. L ~ rPkr P==I
I ._L
_.L_
9
z
--
-K0
~//~
I
I ==:I Pkr I .L_.N_
~ 1-/~rl
.
.
a F I
b
"y
1+61
I"
j fl
E=210GPa, E/G=-2.6 Figure 19: Simply supported I beam
.
.
O.
"I
O01 9 2
65
4.00
. . . . .
k0=0 ~~--
-
3.00 ~l(1+61) -
P=0 P = 1.5MN
~
......
~',,
1.00 ~ ' ~ ~ ' ~ L ~ , ~
.
-0.3
-0.'2 -61i-
0
0.1
61 / 1
().3-
Figure 20: Comparison of exact change of first eigenvalue of torsional vibration with the results of sensitivity analysis (straight lines) for P = 0 and P = 1.5 MN 3.00 -t ~(1+61)
k0=0
~(1)
k0= 2 kNm
2.00
1.00
0
!
-0.3
-0.2
-O.1
0
0.1
!
61 / 1
0.3
Figure 21" Comparison of exact change of first eigenvalue of torsional vibration with the results of sensitivity analysis (straight lines) for k0 = 0 and k0 = 2 kNm
FRAMES AND GRIDS Frames and grids assembled from thin-walled members are very often used in the industry and civil engineering structures. The sensitivity analysis of these structures is possible provided the members are not undergoing torsion. If the members are subject to torques an additional internal force, referred to as bimoment arises. Unfortunately one can not establish an equilibrium condition for the bimoments in the structural joints similar to the well known conditions for other internal forces, therefore up till now in many papers dealing with these structures it has been assumed that the members are pinned or fixed connected in nodes. Obviously one can observe some discrepancies, in many cases, significant, between the results corresponding to these extreme assumptions. An interesting theoretical and experimental investigation of the problem of frame analysis made of I members has been presented by Szmidt (1975). In order to find a better solution to the problem of the bimoment distribution in nodes Yang & McGuire (1984) introduced the warping indicator concept. According to this idea each member is connected to the node by means of warping springs of appropriate stiffness but no rules for
66 the stiffness are given. Krenk & Damklide (1991) point out that in order to fulfill the continuity conditions in the node in which some thin-walled members are connected, deformations of their crosssection is necessary. Of course, the effect of the cross-section deformation on the frame behavior depends on the geometrical and material parameters of the structure. Finally one can state that the problem of static analysis of frames and grids made of thin-walled members, in compliance with onedimensional theory, is not generally solved in successfully way. Thus a direct application of the sensitivity analysis to the frames and grids is possible only by making allowance for above mentioned, simplification of the bimoment distribution.
APPLICATIONS The presented sensitivity analysis of thin-walled members enables us to obtain an approximation of the state variable variations due to some changes of the member parameters without repetition of the analysis of modified structures. This feature can be useful for designing structure, whereas some of its modifications are necessary in order to fulfill constraints related to displacements, critical loads or frequency of vibration. Moreover, it is possible to apply the sensitivity analysis developed in following problems: Analysis of thin-walled members of variable cross-section especially in a situation when a one state variable is of primary significance, for example the critical buckling load or the displacement in a specified cross-section. Consider, for instance, an I beam of variable width of flanges as shown in Figure 22. Then instead of using the FEM for the member of stepped cross-section one can take advantage of the sensitivity analysis. It is necessary to find the influence line for the variation of the state variable specified vs. the width variation for the beam with constant, for example, average width of flanges and next to calculate the change of the state variable from Eqn. 1. -
!
Figure 22: Variable flange widths of I beam An optimal design of thin-walled members by means of the gradient method. The state variable variation established with aid of the sensitivity analysis can be used directly for the optimization algorithm. - Identification of some parameters of the thin-walled members. Many assumptions of the theory of thin-walled beam mentioned in the introduction cause some discrepancies between the results and experiments carried out on real structures or the analysis by means of more general theory, for example, the theory of shells. In order to improve the mathematical model of the structure, the identification of its parameters on the basis of experiments or the theory of shells is advisable. The least square method is most useful for this purpose. Application of the sensitivity analysis to the identification process is very effective. Some variations of the model parameter di for i = 1,2...n in order to improve the mathematical model are sought. The state variable vector s is determined using the theory of thin-walled members but its variation can be obtained by sensitivity analysis as a linear function of the parameter variation 5di. The objective function to be minimized with respect to the variation of the parameter vector variation f~! is
-
minF(g~) = ~
i~lai si + ~ s i - s i
(17)
where s i is the state variable established experimentally or as a result of a more general theory, and ~i denotes the weight coefficient. The method of identification is successfully applied to the settlement of the tranverse stiffener stiffness in I beams (Szymczak & Mikulski (2000b)). The results indicate that
67 the stiffness of the transverse stiffeners recommended by many researchers, for example, Szewczak, Smith & DeWolf (1983)) should be lowered in order to achieve better compatibility with the shell theory. - Analysis of structures with probabilistic parameters, for example, some imperfections with a given distribution of probabilistic density. The method of linearisation, very popular in analysis of this kind, requires knowledge of the linear relation between the state variable and the parameter variations. It is possible to apply the sensitivity analysis for this purpose. Choice of the best sites for the measurements in order to investigate the material properties of the structure, or to check its dimensions. These measurements should be carried out in the cross-section where the sensitivity coefficient is very large because this means a very big influence on the state variable under consideration. It is a very important problem in engineering expert researches, but very often the choice of the measurements is determined by chance. -
CONCLUSIONS A review of problems and applications of the sensitivity analysis of thin-walled members is presented. The members subject to static loads involving torsion, stability, and free torsional vibration analysis are taken into consideration. Many carefully selected numerical examples illustrate effectiveness, efficiency and broad spectrum of applications of the theoretical investigation. Accuracy of approximation of the state variable changes due to some design variable variations is also studied. The results obtained show in the prevailing cases a sufficiently good accuracy of the approximation even for a large twenty per cent change of the design variable. Numerous interesting detailed conclusions regarding the effects of some parameters on the influence lines determined by the sensitivity analysis can be formulated. Further expansion of the application of the sensitivity analysis to frame and grid structures requires an effective solution of the problem of bimoment distribution in nodal connections of the structural members.
AKNOWLEDGEMENTS The author would like to thank Piotr Iwicki and Tomasz Mikulski, Assisant Professors, Faculty of Civil Engineering, Technical University of Gdafisk for assisting in the numerical calculation of some examples. The financial support of the Polish Committee of Scientific Research (KBN) under Grant No. 7 T07E 01519 is gratefully acknowledged.
References Budkowska B.B., Szymczak C. (1992a). Sensitivity Analysis of Thin-Walled I-Beams Resting on Elastic Foundation. J. Engng. Mech. ASCE 118:6, 1239-1248. Budkowska B.B., Szymczak C. (1992b). Sensitivity Analysis of Critical Torsional Buckling Load of Thin-Walled I-Columns Resting on Elastic Foundation. Thin-Walled Struct. 14:1, 37-44. Budkowska B.B., Szymczak C. (1992). Sensitivity Analysis of Free Torsional Vibration Frequencies of Thin-Walled I-Beam Resting on Elastic Foundation, Thin-Walled Struct. 13:3, 399408. Dems K. and Mr6z Z. (1983). Variational Approach by Means of Adjoint Systems to Structural Optimization and Sensitivity Analysis - I, Variation of Material Parameter within Fixed Domain. Int. J. Solids Struct. 19"8, 677-692.
68 Haug E.J., Choi K.K. & Komkov V. (1986). Design Sensitivity Analysis of Structural System. Academic Press, Orlando. Gelfand I.M. and Fomin S.W. (1970). Calculus of Variations. PWN, Warszawa (in Polish). Iwicki P. (1997). Problems of Sensitivity Analysis of Thin-Walled Bars with Bisymmetric Open Cross-Section Subject to Static Loads. Ph.D. Thesis, Faculty of Civil Engineering, Technical University of Gdafisk, Poland, 1-114 (in Polish). Krenk S. and Damklide L. (1991). Warping of Joints in I-Beam Assemblages. J. Engng. Mech. ASCE 117:11, 2457-2474. Rogers L. C. "Derivatives of Eigenx;alues and Eigenvectors, A/AA J., 8, 943-944, 1970. Svensson S.E. and Plum C.M.(1983). Stiffener Effects on Torsional Buckling of Columns. J. Struct. Engng. ASCE 109:3, 758-772. Szewczak R.M., Smith E.A. & DeWolf J.T. (1983). Beams with Torsional Stiffeners. J. Struct. Engng. ASCE 109:7, 1635-1647. Szmidt J.K. (1975). Analysis of Frames made up of Thin-Walled Members. Engrg. Trans., 23:3, 447-472 (in Polish). Szymczak C. (1978). Torsional Vibration of Thin-Walled Bars with Bisymmetric Cross-Section. Engng. Trans., 26:2, 267-274 (in Polish). Szymczak C. (1980). Buckling and Initial Post-Buckling Behavior of Thin-Walled I Columns. Comput. Struct., 11, 481-487. Szymczak C. (1998). Effect of Residual Stresses on Buckling and Initial Post-Buckling Behaviour of Thin-Walled Columns. Arch. Civil Engng., 44:4, 287-297. Szymczak C. (1999a). Sensitivity Analysis of Critical Loads of Flexural-Torsional Buckling of Thin-Walled I Beam. Arch. Civil Engng., 45"3, 401-412. Szymczak C. (1999b). Effect of Elastic Restraints on Buckling and Initial Post-Buckling Behaviour of Thin-Walled Column. Arch. Civil Engng., 45-4, 601-615. Szymczak C. and Mikulski T. (2000a). Selected Problems of Sensitivity Analysis of Thin-Walled Members with Open Cross-Section. Proc. IX Symposium on Stability of Structures, Zakopane, 269276 (in Polish). Trahair N.S. and Bild S. (1990). Elastic Biaxial Bending and Torsion of Thin-Walled Members. Thin-Walled Struct., 9:2, 269-307. Szymczak C. and Mikulski T. (2000b). Identification of Model of Stiffeners of Thin-Walled Bars with Open Cross-Section. Proc. XLVI Scientific Conf. KILiW PAN and KN PZITB Krynica 2000, Wroctaw-Krynica, 1, 169-174 (in Polish). Vlasov V.Z. (1959). Thin-Walled Elastic Beams [in Russian]. Fizmatgiz, Moscow. Yang Y.-B. and McGuire W. (1984). A Procedure for Analysing Space Frames with Partial Warping Restraints. Int. J. Numer. Meth. Engng., 21}:8, 1377-1398.
Third InternationalConferenceon Thin-WalledStructures J. Zara~,K. Kowal-Michalskaand J. Rhodes 9 2001 ElsevierScienceLtd. All rightsreserved
69
SOME OBSERVATIONS ON THE POST-BUCKLING BEHAVIOUR OF THIN PLATES AND THIN-WALLED MEMBERS. J Rhodes Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, Scotland, UK.
ABSTRACT A brief examination of some of the research on the post-buckling analysis of plates and plate structures is outlined. Only a very superficial examination has been carried out. The behaviour of plates and sections under eccentric load or eccentric compression is considered, and the application of plate analysis to strut, beam and column design is discussed.
KEYWORDS Plates, thin-walled members, struts, beams, columns, buckling, post-buckling, compression, bending
INTRODUCTION
Analysis of thin plates in compression probably began with von Karman et. al.(1) in 1932, in which the concept of "effective width" was developed and explained. Cox (2), two years later, produced an analysis of compressed plate behaviour in which the effects of buckling deflections on the plate membrane strains and stresses were developed on the basis of geometrical analysis. Cox considered "averaged" membrane strains, and neglected some in-plane effects, so that his approach tended to underestimate the plate post-buckling strength and stiffness. Indeed this approach was later sometimes termed the "lower bound method", although it was not in fact a lower bound approach. Cox also developed more rigorous plate analysis methods, e.g in (3), but his original method has been used by many authors as a simple and expedient method of plate analysis. Probably the first researcher to produce a rigorous elastic plate post-buckling analysis was Marguerre (4). Using Marguerre's analysis the in-plane strains and stresses are determined from the exact satisfaction of compatibility conditions with the out-of plane deflections and the Principle of Minimum Potential Energy is used to furnish the final relationships between loading and displacements. Since Marguerre's paper there has been a proliferation of publications on plate buckling behaviour and its effects on the behaviour of beams, struts and columns. From the 1940s through the 1960s many papers on rigorous analysis using the von Karman large deflection equations, and on extensions of Marguerre's
70 approach were published, and it is outwith the scope of this article to examine these publications in depth. In this paper we shall briefly consider some theoretical plate analyses.
POST-BUCKLING BEHAVIOUR OF PLATES AND SECTIONS. Plate b e h a v i o u r at and after buckling.
Plate buckling, and post-buckling behaviour, is illustrated in Figure 1 for a thin-walled section in which local buckling is present in all the plate elements.
1
i
I Figure 1. Thin-walled locally buckled member In the elastic range the buckled portions of the plate shed load, and become ineffective in resisting further loading, while in the portions of plate close to supports the out of plane buckling is diminished, and these parts have post-buckling reserves of strength and stiffness. The plate as a whole sustains increases in load after buckling, but the axial stiffness reduces. This effect is demonstrated in Figure 2, where point A is the
Perfect plate " LoadP
S
S
S
I
~Imperfect _ plate
End displacement u Figure 2. Load - end displacement characteristics of locally buckled section
buckling point. For a plate without imperfections the post-buckling axial stiffness drops immediately upon buckling, and thereafter reduces still further as loading increases. Also because of the highly
71 redistributed stress system the maximum stress grows at an increased rate after buckling, ensuring earlier failure than if the plate remained unbuckled. As the load increases the stresses also increase, and for metallic plates failure generally occurs at a load close to that at which the maximum membrane stresses within a plate become equal to the yield stress. The plastic behaviour of plates and sections is in itself a very large and important field of study, but this will not be considered in this paper.
"Lower
bound"
plate
analysis
method.
Consider a plate of width 'b' and length 'a' as shown in Figure 3. If the plate is initially compressed axially by an amount 'u' and then buckles into a sinusoidal wave along its length with value 'w' in any strip, the average axial strain in an elementary strip of plate as shown due to the interaction of in-plane and out-of plane deflections is:-
fi/
/ ~r
/--..
~X
..--/
Figure 3. Deflected elementary strip of plate -- -
6X=a
-
w2
(1)
4
If we assume that membrane stresses act in the x-direction only, and the variation of deflections w is given by the expression w = A.Y(y) the strain energy of membrane actions can be written as follows:-
VD=I
E 6 2 dV = E t a I ( u ) 2 l(X]4A4~y4dy x . + 2 2 16k, a J 0
_
. ~ . ( u ] ( ~ ) l 2A2by2., dy ] 0
(2)
The total potential energy is the sum of the membrane energy, the strain energy of bending, and that of any external restraints. The strain energy of bending can be written as:
v. =---4-
JolL~
r 12+ 2 ( l - v )
LtayJ +w ay JJ
: OaA2 ......... 4
(3)
Adding the membrane energy to the bending energy to obtain the total potential energy, V, minimising this by differentiating V with respect to A, and rearranging leads to the following expression for the deflection magnitudes A:-
72
! y2.
A2= 4
a2O b ,: 2
--
o~Y4dy
7
(4)
U - x E E t !yEdyJ
When the term inside the second bracket is zero we have the critical value of u to cause local buckling. We can thus replace the second term inside these brackets by u....cR.Substituting Eqn.(4) into (1) gives:a b
f y2dy x y2
e~ =
b
a
-
(5)
~y4 dy 0
The total load on the plate can be obtained by integrating E t ex across the plate, to get
P=Etb{ u-
K, IU - -~-l} where K, =
(!y2. (6)
b
b ~y4dy 0
Prior to buckling the load - strain relationship is simply
dP du
Ebt a
could be written as ---- = ~ .
P = E b t u_. The a
pre-buckling axial stiffness
dP du
The post-buckling axial stiffness can be written as ~
Et b a
=~
(1 - K~).
The ratio of post-buckling to pre-buckling axial stiffness is otten described by the quantity E*/E, where E* is a fictitious elasticity modulus. Using the lower bound method the ratio E*/E is given by:E'/E=
1-K~
(7)
Equation (7) provides a simple approximate evaluation of post-buckling stiffness for different boundary conditions by direct substitution of suitable functions describing the deflection across the plate. For example the deflections for a plate with simply supported unloaded edges can be taken as Y = sin :r__~y. b Substitution into Equation (3) gives E*/E = 1/3. For some other standard boundary conditions suitable functions and resulting E*/E ratios are as follows:Unloaded Edges fixed-fixed:-
y = sin2 :r_.~y b
:- E*/E=18/35
Unloaded Edges simply supported-free:-
Y =--Y b
:- E*/E=4/9
Unloaded Edges free-flee:-
Y = constant :- E*/E=0
Thus for plates supported on both edges the effects of local buckling are to reduce the axial stiffness to around half of its pre-buckling value. It is interesting to observe that the plate theory used shows agreement with simple column theory in predicting zero post-buckling stiffness for plates with no
73 restraint on the unloaded edges. It is also worthy of notice that this simplified approach gives no variation of post-buckling stiffness ratio with variation in buckle half wavelength. It should also be mentioned that perhaps the most widely known approach to dealing with plate post buckling behaviour is the "effective width" approach. In this approach it is assumed that an "effective width" of plating carrying the maximum applied stress takes the load on the complete plate. In the plate examined, under nominal strain u/a the load carried is
P-Etbeu-Etb{u-K'[u-ucR]}a
whence b---~ 1 - =b
KI[ 1 - -~'R-I
(8,
The lower bound method is easily applied and can give quick results and approximations. This method can also be easily computerised, and used in conjunction with numerical or semi-numerical approaches such as the Finite Strip method to tackle a wide range of problems. The presence of imperfections can be easily taken into account, but these can be dealt with using more rigorous analysis without undue difficulty in any case.
More rigorous post-buckling analysis. The elastic post-buckling behaviour of thin plates is governed by two simultaneous non-linear differential equations originally set up by von Karman (5) and modified some time later by Marguerre (6) to take account of the presence of initial imperfections. These equations may be written as follows, in terms of deflections w and stress function F:-
d4F ~ +
ax4
c~w ~X 4
2
d4F ~ +
ax aY d4w
~
d4F
aY4
=E
I(
d2W / 2- d2w d2w
F,axaY)
ax
_
d2Wo
dxdy
/ 2 d2 9 ] q_
Wo d - W o
dx 2 Oy 2
(9)
d4w
+ 2 O x 2 0 y 2 + Oy 4 =
_- -qd + t [ g f l F d 2 ( w + w o )
-2
F d 2(w+wo) d 2 F d 2(w+wo)] OxOy 2 dxcTy + dx 2 3yZ
(10)
J
The first of these equations, sometimes called the "Compatibility Equation", ensures that in an elastic plate the in-plane and out-of-plane displacements are compatible. The second equation is based on equilibrium principles, and is sometimes termed the "Equilibrium Equation". Exact solution of these equations is only possible for the simplest loading and support conditions, but solutions which are within reasonable accuracy are obtainable for a wide range of problems. Perhaps the most widely used approach to rigorous analysis of elastic plate postbuckling behaviour is to postulate a form for the deflections w, to then evaluate the corresponding stress function for the particular boundary and loading conditions using the exact solution of Equation (9), which is amenable to solution for a wide range of conditions. Atter this the required solution can be attained either by approximate solution of the Equilibrium equation (10) or by disregarding this equation and expressing the total potential energy in terms of F and w and applying the Principal of minimum Potential Energy to obtain the solution. If it is assumed that the deflected form in the axial direction is sinusoidal, generally a most reasonable assumption for plate elements of prismatic structural members, then the corresponding stress function
74 obtained on the basis of Equation (9) has two parts, one constant with respect to x and the other varying with twice the frequency of the deflections, i.e. 2~x F = F~ + F 2 c o s ~
(1 I)
/2
The firstterm, F~,, essentiallydescribes the average membrane stressesalong the plate, i.e.those which could be determined on the basis of Equation (1), and the second term describes a secondary membrane stresssystem which arisesto fullysatisfycompatibilityconditions.
The stress system described by the function F2 indicates mainly periodically varying stresses in the axial direction for plate elements of prismatic thin-walled structural members in which loading is carried in the axial direction only. For plate elements of bridge, ship or similar structures which can have a multiplicity of plates arranged together the unloaded edges remain relatively straight, and this straightness is maintained by periodically varying stresses in the direction perpendicular to loading. The stress variations along simply supported plates of both types is illustrated in Figure 4. In the more rigorous analysis the quantity K~, originally defined in Equation (6) can be re-defined as follows
I! 12 y2dy
(12)
It is obvious from the above equation that if all else is equal, K1 calculated from the above equation will be smaller than that calculated from Equation (6). Thus E*/E and be calculated on the basis of the more rigorous approach will always be greater than those obtained from the lower bound approach, provided the same deflected form is assumed.
Unloaded edges held straight
Unloaded edges free to wave in-plane
Figure 4. Stress systems on simply supported plates with different unloaded edge conditions This hypothesis is almost correct, but not completely so. As may be observed from Figure 4Co), for plates with unloaded edges free to wave in-plane, the axial stress on the edge of the plate varies along the plate, and has a maximum value at the crest of a buckle. This induces the requirement to specify closely what is the function of the effective width. In many design specifications a dual function is assumed, simplification of analysis with regard to plate stiffness and simplification with regard to plate strength, although the Eurocode for cold-formed steel does recognise to some extent that there are differences
75 between these two functions. Among researchers in plate analysis it has long been recognised that two different effective widths should be specified, one based on the largest membrane stress being the effective width for strength and the other, based on the average membrane edge stress being the effective width for stiffness calculations.
BEHAVIOUR FAR BEYOND BUCKLING
As loading progresses beyond the buckling load the deflections change in magnitude, and also change in form. Changes in the form, or shape, of the deformations bring corresponding changes in the axial stiffness of a plate. In general for plates supported on both edges the deflected form across the plate flattens, and the axial stiffness reduces as loading progresses. This can be taken into account in analysis by providing the freedom for the buckled form to change. Many authors have examined such behaviour successfully. An investigation by Stein (7), however, in 1951 is worthy of special mention. Stein used the perturbation approach in which the solution is obtained in terms of the power series expansion of a "perturbation parameter". The parameter used by Stein was :fl= P -1+ P~
where
Wo
(12)
w
wo is the initial deflection of the plate.
A complete picture of the plate behaviour could be derived in terms of a power series of this parameter. The first two terms of this power series could effectively detail the plate post buckling behaviour well into the far post buckling range. Essentially this meant that by obtaining analytical solutions at two specific points, one of which could be the buckling point, and utilising the pertubation approach a picture of the complete post-buckling range of behaviour of identical plates with any magnitude of imperfection could be produced. Walker used this approach in 1975 (8) to obtain explicit solutions for square simply supported plates. The results were used in the 1975 edition of the UK specification for the design of cold-formed steel specimens. Williams and Walker (9) extended this study to deal with a wide variety of plate geometries and boundary conditions, and tables of coefficients obtained from a finite difference analysis were given from which the reader could analyse the plate of his choice. It is only a short step to go from this position to fitting expressions to the coefficients so that by solving simple equations the coefficients governing rectangular plates of arbitrary buckle half wavelength and arbitrary boundary restraint conditions can be determined. In Ref (10) slightly modified forms of explicit expression, obtained on the basis of a Marguerre type analysis allied to the perturbation technique, are presented. The explicit expressions are in the following forms:-
/
PcR = ( q -
8cR
1) fl + c 2 r2
! cy'~ PcRP)=(c3-1)fl+c4fl2 --
= C5 ~
+ C6
(13) (14) (15)
76 In the above 13 is as defined in Eqn. (12). The terms CrcR, 6cR and
PcR are the critical values of axial
stress, axial strain and load respectively, i.e. the values of these quantities at the point of local buckling. Expressions for the coefficients Cl to C6 for plates with varying buckle half wavelengths and rotational restraints on the unloaded edges have been tabulated in Ref (10). The explicit expressions shown here have slight modifications built in to eliminate the possibility of ill conditioning affecting the postulated behaviour in the far post-buckling range, and these equations give results in close agreement with existing theory in comparable cases. At very large strains it can be shown that the load/strain and load/maximum stress relationships given by Equations (13) and (14) tend towards P
= 1,1
S
P
c- r n1.1 tax-
(16)
These relationships have similarities with plate relationships derived in much different manners. It is of interest that yon Karman's effective width equation produces these results with C2 = C3 =1 To illustrate the effects of initial imperfections on plate behaviour, load-out of plane deflection curves and load compression curves for simply supported square plates are shown in Figures 5 and 6. Figure 5 shows that for imperfect plates the out of plane deflections grow from the start of loading. As the load increases the deflections tend towards those of a perfect plate. Figure 6 shows the reduction in load at a given strain which results from imperfections. The maximum reductions occur at around a strain equal to the strain at which local buckling occurs. A plate with initial deflection of magnitude equal to the plate thickness sustains less than half the load of a perfect plate at an applied strain of around the critical strain although the same plate will carry something of the order of 90% of the perfect pate load when the strain is about 7 times the critical strain. Also in Figure 6 the reduction in stiffness of the plate as loading increases is evident. Note that this is due to variation in deflected form across the plate.
wo
/ T =o
/_.~0.2
.
P
1 1
,
2
1
I
3
w/t
Figure 5. Load -out of plane deflection curves for simply supported square plates
77
- โข Q0-20.4n - ,~ ==0
/ ~...~~O. 8 ~1.0
.
.,
P
ecR I
e---I
Simply supported unloaded edges 0
1
L,
2
4 ~/eCR
/
,,
I
6
8
Figure 6. Load end displacement curves for square simply supported plates. Figure 7 shows the variation in load with end compression (displacement) and with maximum stress for simply-supported plates with unloaded edges either free to wave in plane or restrained from waving. Curves are also shown for plates with fixed tmloaded edges. In this figure the buckle half wavelength is that at which the plate initially buckles - i.e. equal to the plate width for the simply supported plates and about two thirds of the plate width for the fixed edge plates. The effects of allowing the buckle half wavelength to vary are illustrated in Figure 8 in which the same plates as previously examined are considered. As may be observed allowing the buckle half-wavelength to vary to produce the most flexible case leads to somewhat less stiffness in all cases, and tends to bring the results for different cases closer together. Note that the loads were only minimised with regard to end compression, so that the results in Figure 8 for stresses are for half-wavelengths at which the end displacement is maximised with regard to load, not the maximum stress S S - C o m p - Free to w a v e - e = l S S - S t r e s s - F r e e to w a v e - e = l SS - Comp/stress - restrained e=l FF - C o m p - e = 0 . 6 7 ---,--FF - Stress e=0.67 - - Von Karman's Equation ....
9
12 9
P/PcR
6 3
0
!
i
i
!
20
40
60
80
e / CcR or
100
Crn~x/CrcR
Figure 7. Load v Compression. and Load v maximum stress for plates with fixed buckle half wavelength
78 SS- C o m p - Free to w a v e - e varies SS - Stress- Free to wave - e varies -- F~FF- Cornp/stress- restrained e varies L;orr~ - e varies - - - . - - F F - Stress e varies - - - Von Karrnan's Equation
,21 9-1
P/PcR
r
I
I
I
I
I
0
20
40
60
80
100
616cR or trm~xl trcR Figure 8 Load v Compression and Load v maximum stress for plates with varying buckle half wavelength
ECCENTRICITIES IN LOAD OR END DISPLACEMENT APPLICATION So far it has been considered that the plates examined have been subject to uniform compression. This is not always the case. Plate elements of thin-walled members, and indeed thin-walled members, may be subjected to combinations of bending, compression and tension. Indeed the type of loading undergone by a member may be affected by the member's resistance to load. Consider two plates as shown in Figure 9:-
Load
Load
ili~
i
f Fulcra
(a)
(b)
Figure 9. Constant compression eccentricity and constant load eccentricity on plates Both plates are loaded through rigid loading bars. In case (a) the loading bar rotates about a fulcrum which may be at any specified position (For enforced uniform compression the fulcrum is positioned at a point infinitely distant from the plate). In this case the plate is subjected to a specified eccentricity of
79 compression (or end displacement) which is independent of its reaction to the loading. In case (b) the load is applied at a specific location, giving specified load eccentricity. In such a case the plate reaction to the loading must be such that the internal actions within the plate must be in equilibrium with the load acting. In practice it would be expected that the actual loading conditions in a plate element of a structure would be somewhere between these two conditions. Secondary members or secondary elements are often subjected to external actions which are dependant mainly on the reactions of primary members to the applied loading, so that secondary members are generally subjected to constant compression eccentricity while primary members are generally subjected to constant load eccentricity. In order to deal with either of these cases the possibility of eccentricity of compression must be considered. If the applied end displacement on a plate was to vary linearly from u at y=0 to u ( 1 - a ) at y=b then Equation (1) could be rewritten to take the variation in strain into account as follows:-
u uoy
zx =
a
a b
), w2
4
(17)
The membrane strain energy expression becomes:
ta[Iu
~=--F
b
2
b
b
a UaYab]2 + 1-"-(rt~4A4of 4dy - "21( u ] ( ~ ] A2 fYo 2dy +l(u~aa A2 o~Y2Y"~dy
7
]
(18)
Adding the bending energy and applying the Principle of Minimum Potential Energy gives, for A 2
y2@
y2
@ UCR
=
b
--
fly4@
b
a
(19)
~y2@ 0
Note that in Equation (19) the term under uniform compression.
UcR specifies the critical end displacement corresponding to buckling
Substitution for A in Eqn (17) and performing the appropriate steps give expressions for the end load on the plate and the moment about the x-axis caused by the in-plane forces, as follows:-
=
a
...... u- ~
- Kl
UcR) + K 2 ua]
(20)
(21) where K1 is given by Eqn. (6) or (12) and Note that K2 and I<3 are given above for the lower bound case. For more rigorous analysis the denominator in both functions should be replaced by that of Eqn. (12).
80 Equations (20) and (21) permit the examination of plates under combinations of axial forces and moments. Extension of these equations to deal with any number of plates combined to form structural sections is a simple matter. '
[i L"i~~ I UonifpLio n
~
-
~
~
Central loading
u/ucR Figure 10. Load v compression for simply supported -free plates Examination of uniformly compressed plates, or plates with any fixed compression eccentricity using Eqns. (20) and (21) is simply accomplished by setting the quantity ua to the relevant value (0 for uniform compression). The examination of constant load eccentricity can be carried out by setting M=kP, with k defining the load position, using Eqn. (21). It is found that the cases of constant load eccentricity and constant compression eccentricity are not significantly different for plates with both edges supported. For plates with only one edge supported the cases of constant load eccentricity and constant compression eccentricity give very different results (11). This is illustrated in Figure (10) for a plate with one unloaded edge simply supported and the other free. Uniform compression produces a post-buckling axial stiffness of about 4/9 of that before buckling. Loading applied along a specified line of action - halfway across the plate, produces very small post-buckling axial stiffness, although the pre-buckling axial stiffness is the same as that for the uniform compression case. The main reason for this is that under uniform compression the plate resistance is concentrated near the supported edge, while under central loading the plate has to bend in-plane to resist the applied loading concentrated at the plate centre. The variation of membrane strains across the plates are indicated in the small plate sketches in Figure 10. Some post-local buckling properties of a plate can be determined on the basis of Eqns. (20) and (21) by evaluating u in terms of ucx, UCR and P from Eqn. (20) and substituting into Eqn (21) to obtain the following expression:2
M
-
g 2
(1- K,)
The corresponding equation prior to local buckling can be obtained by setting K~, 1(2 and K3 equal to zero to get
M= Eb2t~xuaa x (-1) + Pb2
(23)
81 Now the term u a / a describes the variation of strain across the plate width "b", and it is a simple matter to show that the in-plane curvature in the plate is given by:C .
1
. . R~
.
02v
. . ax2
ua ab
(24)
On this basis we can see that Eqn. (24) simply states that E I
~ = d2v dx 2
-M
Pb +~ 2
(25)
In the above M is the moment about the plate edge, y=0. We have not as yet made any specification regarding M, i.e. we have not stated how or where the axial load is to be applied. If, for example we wish to examine the case of a plate under a central loading we could specify M=Pb/2, in which case Equation (25) would read :- E 1-----= d2v 0 Thus in this case the plate (in the pre-buckling range) would behave as if dx 2
there was no curvature, as would indeed be the case. In a more general situation we could say that M=Pd, where d is the distance from the y axis at which P is applied. In such a case Equation (25) reads:-
-
(26)
Taking the same approach to equation (24) under the same loading, we can write this as:-
(y. _ y)+,(y" In the above I* and y ' , which may be obtained by inspection from Equation (22), are modified values of the second moment of area I and the distance from the y axis to the neutral axis taking the effects of local buckling into account. The ratio of I* to I indicates the effect of local buckling on the in-plane flexural stiffness of a plate or section. The effects of local buckling on flexural stiffness are somewhat more complicated than on axial stiffness, when evaluated on the basis of the method discussed, as the tensile effects introduced by local buckling can stiffen the tension side of a plate or member undergoing bending, leading in some cases to large discrepancies. For example, in the case of a single plate element, simply supported on both unloaded edges, under pure in-plane bending, rigorous analysis (12) suggests that the initial ratio of postbuckling flexural stiffness to pre-buckling flexural stiffness is about 70%. If, however, it is assumed that the buckled form due to in-plane bending is sinusoidal across the plate (exact for pure compression) a value of 100% is determined for this ratio, i.e. local buckling is calculated to have no effect on subsequent flexural stiffness. This erroneous result arises from the symmetrical deflected form, in which stiffening effects on the tensile side counteracted rigifying effects on the compression side. In general this method requires account to be taken of changes buckled form after initial buckling to be taken into account.
APPLICATIONS TO COLUMNS In the derivation of Equations (26) and (27) we assumed M=Pd. This ignores any effects of deflections of the plate or section on the moment. If we consider that the reference axis of the plate or section has
82 displaced from its initial position by a measurable amount "v" then this should be taken into account in the calculations. If we say that M = P(d+v) then Equations (26) and (27) become:-
dx 2
+
d)
(28)
where for a single plate y = b/2 d x2
+,v-
(29)
The first of these is the very well known equation for buckling of a pin-ended column loaded with eccentricity d - y . The second is the post-buckling equivalent. These equations can be derived for structural sections in much the same way as they have been derived here for plates. Solutions for the case of pin-ended columns under eccentric loading are as follows:v=
v=
d-
see ~
- 1
(30)
I(d-y')+-~y-y*)l[sec/2
p~E./-
(31)
11
In the above P~r = zc2 E I / L 2 a n d Pe" = rc 2 E f / L 2 are the Euler load and reduced Euler load for the locally buckled sections respectively. Equation (30) governs while the column has not buckled locally, while Equation (31) governs after local buckling has occurred. This approach, or very similar approaches, has been used to examine a number of column problems in the past (e.g) bridge plating (13), (14), plane channels (15), lipped channels (16), (17), I sections (18). The reduction in Euler load caused by local buckling varies substantially for these sections. For example a plane channel suffering local buckling such that the flange free edges are further compressed by the overall displacements can lose about 85% of its stiffness, while if the dimensions or loading are such that buckling in the opposite direction occurs only about 20% of the stiffness is lost.
#~ 0.8 0.6
-----Initial Postbuckling Far postbuckling
Before local buckling After local buckling
0.4 0.3
b2
O4
.o 0.2 t-
0.4 0.1
0.2 |
0
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
1
b2/bl
Figure 11. Post-buckling Flexural stiffness of Channels
0
0.2
i
f
0.4 0.6 b2/bl
J
0.8
1
Figure 12. Neutral axis positions for channels
83 Figure 11 illustrates this behaviour for a plane channel section with flange width b2 and web width b]. In the figure the flexural stiffness, denoted by I*, calculated immediately after buckling and that calculated well into the post-local buckling range are used to illustrate the variation in behaviour observed. In Figure 12 the assymptotic variation in neutral axis position evaluated in the post-buckling range is shown for the channel section. This demonstrates the well known "wandering neutral axis" concept. The applicablity or inapplicability of this concept in the general scheme of things is a matter of some discussion, but there are at least some instances in which it requires to be taken into account. Figure 13 shows the variation in Euler load due to local buckling for several of different cross sections with variation in slenderness ratio 9 For simplicity it is assumed that local buckling has occurred at one fifth of the squash load for all sections, indicating highly ineffective cross sections. It is obvious from these figures that, all else being equal the effects of local buckling are such that a failure curve based directly on the Euler curve for the gross cross section is very likely to overestimate the capacities of columns which undergo substantial local buckling before failure, and this is evident for slender columns, not just for those in which the squash load governs. This does not seem to be taken due account of in the Eurocode for cold-formed steel (19). In this, although the reductions due to local buckling's effect on the squash load are included, the shape of the transition curve from Euler to squash governed failure does not make any allowance for local buckling effects, as is evidenced in Figure 14, which uses Column curves (b) It is of interest to observe that in the European Recommendations for the design Light gauge steel members (20), the weakening effects of local buckling on column behaviour were taken into account using a biased imperfection formula. The effects of this formula are shown in Figure 14, in which the larger the reduction in section effectiveness the larger the difference between European Recommendations and Eurocode predictions.
12
Faler load
12
~ R a i ~
1
....
08
(1)
B ~ .__,Je~__'en
08
I~on
n 06 n 04
~
.
,
Rain ~
Column curve (b) Solid lines-Eurocode Dashed lines- Euro-Recs
1
(2)
06 04
02
.
0
|
0
50
|
100 L/r
.
.
.
!
150
It
0.2
.
Q "
"
" . ,
,.
=
= .
1
i
I
I
i
i
200
0
50
100 L/r
150
200
Figure 13. Buckling interaction curves
Figure 14. Column design curves
[t is obvious that there is dubiety here as to the effects of local buckling on column behaviour, and to the importance of these effects. It is perhaps a good thing that very light gauge members tend to have been used as beams rather than as columns in the past. If it is intended that light gauge members be widely used as columns there are problems which must be tackled with some urgency.
84 SUMMARY This paper has made a somewhat brief and superficial study of plate elements and members subject to local buckling, and has mentioned a few of the interesting problems faced in this field of study. It is obvious that although there has been a great deal of work carded out on plate bcckling and post-buckling behaviour, there is still a substantial amount to be learnt.
REFERENCES von Karman, E. E. Sechler and L. H. Donnel., Strength of thin plates in compression, Trans. ASME, 54, 1932. 2. Cox, H. L., Buckling ofthin plates in compression, ARC R & MNo.1554, 1934. 3. Cox, H. L., The theory of fiat panels buckled in compression, ARC R & A No.2178, 1945. 4. K. Marguerre, The apparent width of the plate in compression, NACA TA No.833, 1937. 5. T. von Karman. Festigheitsprobleme im Maschinenbau. Encyclopaedie der Mathematischen Wissenschafien, 4, p349, 1910 6. K. Marguerre Zur theorie der gekreummter platte grosser formaendenmg. Procfifth lnt. Congress for Applied Mechanics. Cambridge, 1938 7. M. Stein, Loads and deformations in buckled rectangular plates, NASA Teci Rep. R-40, 1959. 8. A.C. Walker. The post-buckling behaviour of simply supported square plates. Aero Quarterly, XX,, 1969 9. D.G. Williams and A. C. Walker. Explicit solutions for the design of initially deformed plates subject to compression. Proc 1. C. E, 59, 1975 10. J Rhodes. Microcomputer design analysis of plate post-buckling behaviour. Jnl of Strain Analysis, 21, 1986 11. J. Rhodes and J. M. Harvey. Effects of eccentricity of load or compression on the buckling and postbuckling behaviour of fiat plates. Int. Jnl of Mech Sci. Vo113. P867, 1971 12. J Rhodes. The post buckling behaviour of bending elements. Proc 6th lnt Specialty Conf. On ColdFormed Steel Structures, St. Louis, 1982 13. W. C. Fok, J. Rhodes and A. C. Walker. Local buckling of outstands in stiffened plates. Aero Quarterly, XXVll, 1976 14. W. C. Fok, A. C. Walker and J. Rhodes. Buckling of locally imperfect stiffeners in plates. Jnl of the Eng. Mech Div. ASCE. Vo1103 No. EM5, 1977 15. J. Rhodes and J. M Harvey. Interaction behaviour of plain channel columns under concentric or eccentric loading. Prelim Report. 2nd lnt. Colloquiumon the Stability of Steel Structures, Liege, 1977 16. J. Loughlan. Mode interaction in lipped channel columns under concentric or eccentric loading. PhD thesis, University of Strathclyde, 1979. 17. J. Rhodes and J. Loughlan. Simple design analysis of lipped channel column. Proc. 5th Int Specialty Conf on Cold Formed Steel Structures, St Louis, 1980. 18. J. Loug~tlhan and M. Navabian. The behaviour of thin-walled I section cohmms a_fter local buckling. Proc. 8t lnt Specialty Conf on Cold Formed Steel Structures, St Louis, 1986. 19. CEN ENV 1993-1-3:1996. Euroeode3:Design of Steel Structures- Part 1.3:General Rulessupplementary rules for cold-formed thin gauge members and sheeting 20. ECCS TC-7. European recommendations for the design of light gauge steel members, 1987. 1.
Section II ANALYSIS, DESIGN AND MANUFACTURE
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Third International Conference on Thin-Walled Structures J. Zarag, K. Kowal-Michalska and J. Rhodes 9 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved
87
RESIDUAL STRESSES IN UNSTIFFENED PLATE SPECIMENS M. R. Bambach 1 and K. J. R. Rasmussen ~ 1Department of Civil Engineering, Sydney University, Australia
ABSTRACT Rectangular plate specimens have been prepared for testing in a rig that provides simple support to three sides, leaving the remaining (longitudinal) edge free. In many applications such plate elements exist as flange outstands in thin-walled sections whose fabrication process involves welding and possibly flame cutting. In order to accurately predict the behavior of unstiffened elements in this condition, equivalent residual stress profiles must be induced in the plate specimens prior to testing. Details of the processes involved in inducing and measuring residual stresses in the plate specimens are presented. Previously developed models relating voltage, current and arc speed to the stress induced, as a function of plate width are extended, such that residual stress magnitudes and gradients can be predicted that approximate those in the flange outstand of fabricated sections. KEYWORDS
Weld shrinkage, residual stresses, tendon force, fabricated thin-walled sections, plate elements INTRODUCTION It is well known that residual stresses are induced in members as a result of welding and flame cutting processes, and that these stresses may influence the load carrying capacity of thin-walled members, particularly those that contain slender component plates. In the 1970s an extensive program was undertaken at Cambridge University to investigate the nature and magnitude of residual stress profiles induced by a large variety of welding processes common to the fabrication of thin-walled steel members. Reports by Kamtekar (1974) and White (1977a,b,c) give details of welding experiments performed on single plates and sections, and propose equations that predict the profiles and magnitudes of residual stresses. Reports by Moxham (1971), Dwight and Moxham (1971) and Bradfield (1979) detail welding processes on single plates, for the purpose of inducing residual stresses in plate specimens that were subsequently tested in plate testing rigs. The results of these tests provided valuable data on the effect of residual stresses on the load carrying capacity of stiffened plate elements (plates simply supported on all sides).
88 Most research on plates of that period and since then has concentrated on the testing of stiffened plates, giving little attention to inducing residual stress profiles in plates that are to be tested as unstiffened elements, that is simply supported on three sides, with the remaining (longitudinal) edge free. This paper outlines the applicability of the residual stress theory to unstiffened plates.
TENDON FORCE CONCEPT Centre Welded Plate. The research at Cambridge led to the 'tendon force' concept for beadon-thin-plate weld shrinkage, whereby a weld may be considered as a tendon exerting a force F, which is resisted by the full cross-section. If a continuous weld is laid longitudinally on a thin plate along its centreline, a longitudinal stress pattern is induced that consists of a region of tensile yield stress in the immediate vicinity of the weld, and compressive stress elsewhere, the resultant of which resists the tendon force. For all practical welding and plate parameters, the magnitude of the tendon force is given by (White 1977a): where p is the process efficiency and (Q/v) is the heat input per unit length of weld. The process efficiency for a centre weld was found to be 0.8, and the tendon force was shown to be insensitive to plate width and yield stress. This condition is applicable to the weld shrinkage induced in a flange plate when it is welded into an I-section or T-section. The distribution of longitudinal residual stress is shown in Figure la. A small gradient may exist in the compressive zone due to 'wrap up', where small angular distortions may occur about the line of the weld, as shown in Figure la. It is noted that transverse residual stresses were found to be negligible. Tensile Stress 9
(a) Centreline weld
0 - "
(b) One edge welded
|
~
(c) Both edges welded simultaneously
l,
!
Compressive Stress
Figure 1: Residual Stress Profiles for Bead-on-Thin-Plate Welds
Edge Welded Plate. If the weld is laid eccentrically to the centroid of a plate, a bending stress is induced due to the offset of the tendon force. This causes a stress gradient and increases the magnitude of the tendon force (White 1977b), such that for edge welds it is
given by:
[:;edge--" 0.32p{~v / \--/
The process efficiency (p) was found to be less than that for a centre weld, due heat loss from the weld. White (1977b) suggested a value of 0.42. This applicable to the web in a welded T-section or the flange of a welded channel residual stress gradient generally causes the unwelded edge to be in tension, Figure lb.
(2) to increased condition is section. The as shown in
89 Both Edges Welded Simultaneously. If welds are laid symmetrically and simultaneously, the eccentricities of the tendon forces effectively cancel each other out, and constant compressive stress is induced in the central region of the plate as shown in Figure lc. The magnitude of the tendon force is the same as that given for the centre welded plate in Eqn. 1. This condition is applicable to the web in a welded I-section, when the edges are welded simultaneously, such as in an automatic welding process.
Consecutive Edge Welds. If one edge of the plate is welded and the specimen allowed to cool, the residual stress pattem for a single edge weld is induced (Figure l b). If the other edge is then welded, this weld is laid in a region of existing tensile stress. Weld theory (White 1977a) shows that the material around the weld yields in compression during the heating cycle before tensile stresses develop at the weld during the cooling process. Laying a weld in a tensile zone results in a reduced width of material yielding in compression during the heating cycle, and the tendon force produced is less than that for a similar weld laid in stress free material. The converse is true for welds laid in regions of compressive stress. Experiments by White (1977b) showed the magnitude of the tendon force to be the same as that for edge welds (Eqn. 2), but scaled up or down by a factor (m) according to the magnitude of the existing compressive or tensile stresses respectively: If edge welds are laid consecutively then, with the same heat input per unit length, and weld 1 inducing tension at the opposite edge, weld 2 will produce a smaller tendon force than weld 1. The residual compressive stress resisting the tendon force will thus be less, as shown in Figure 2a. The addition of the residual stresses from each weld produces the final stress profile shown in Figure 2b. Tensile Stress ~y
(a) Addition of residual stresses from consecutive edge welds
-,
i-i
I-1 ,I , I
I
I I I
! ! I
j
..I
I I I
i I 0 = =
Weld1 ~E ~.---...=,
Compressive Stress
(b) Final residual stress pattem
,"""
I
I
I I I
I Weld2
,...--
Figure 2: Addition of Residual Stresses from Consecutive Edge Welds
RESIDUAL STRESS PROFILES IN FLANGE OUTSTANDS Two conditions common to the fabrication of I-sections are detailed here, for the purpose of determining the residual stress profiles exisiting in flange outstands of fabricated sections. Firstly an I-section fabricated from as-rolled or cold-cut plates, and secondly one fabricated from flame cut plates. In the first case, it may be assumed that the plates are stress free when they are welded to form the section, such that the two flange plates develop a residual stress pattern similar to Figure la, and the web similar to Figure lc. It is assumed that the welding process is automated, such that the welds are laid simultaneously. An I-section fabricated in this way by Chick and Rasmussen (1999) produced the profile shown in Figure 3a, having a nearly uniform compressive stress with an average of 109MPa in the web, and a small gradient in the flanges, where the average compressive stress is also 109MPa.
90
J 9
=.
Flame cut plate -200
+200
Plate welded into I-section
1
i
J
j
Addition of residual stresses on flange plate
~: i " L..}::::::::::--;~.....':....~2;:::..::--; .....
(a) I-section fabricated from stress free plates
(b) I-sectionfabricated from flame cut plates
Figure 3: Residual Stress Profiles in Fabricated I-Sections I-sections that are fabricated from flame cut plates develop residual stresses from each heating process. Flame cutting the edges (simultaneously) induces residual stresses in the flange plate similar to those in Figure lc, and when the plate is welded into the I-section residual stresses similar to a centre weld are added, as shown in Figure 3b. The resulting residual stress pattems in the flange outstands are shown for each case in Figure 4. Tensile Stress fy
Compressive Stress
o
(a) I-sectionfabricated from stress free plates
~ (b) I-section fabricated from flame cut plates
Figure 4: Residual Stress Profiles in Flange Outstands of Fabricated I-Sections
INDUCING EQUIVALENT RESIDUAL STRESS PROFILES IN PLATE SPECIMENS Plate specimens have been prepared for testing in a plate rig where the plate will be simply supported on three sides, modelling a flange outstand of a fabricated section. Residual stress profiles are thus required that are equivalent to those in Figures 4a,b. A single edge weld produces yield in tension at the welded edge and less than yield in tension at the unwelded edge, as shown in Figure lb. This pattem does not resemble the one shown in Figure 4a for cold-cut plates in regard to the stress at the edge opposite the weld, which is also the unsupported edge of the flange outstand. It is important to induce compressive residual stresses at this edge and at the centre of the plate since they affect the buckling
9] behaviour. It has been considered to shift the weld closer to the centre so as to reduce the residual stress gradient and obtain a residual stress pattern in agreement with that shown in Figure 4a. However, the shift required to produce reasonable agreement exceeds a quarter of the plate width, which is deemed unacceptable. It is concluded that it is not possible to induce a residual stress pattem similar to that shown in Figure 4a by placing a weld on a single plate. The investigation therefore focuses on flame-cut plates, for which the residual stress pattem is similar to that shown in Figure 4b. Two consecutive edge welds are required to produce this pattem, as shown in Figure 2. Since the second weld is laid in a tensile zone, the tendon force is reduced and a stress gradient will arise. Aiming for a constant value of compressive residual stress, more heat is applied in laying the second weld compared to the first. This requires an estimation of the reduction factor 'm' in Eqn. 3, for which the curves given by White (1977b) were used. The target value of compressive residual stress is taken to be 110 MPa, which is a suitable mean of measured values on flanges of I-sections (Hasham and Rasmussen 1998, Chick and Rasmussen 1999). WELDING EXPERIMENTAL PROCESS As the plate specimens are to be used in a plate testing rig, weld deposit along the edges is not desirable. To avoid this an electric-arc welder was used without the addition of weld metal, such that it was operating as a heat source only. The torch was mounted on a motorised, rail-guided trolley that travelled the length of the plates at a constant speed, such that the heat input was constant along the length of the specimen. The magnitude of the heat input per unit length (Q/v) is controlled by the closed circuit voltage (V) and current (!), and the speed (v) of the trolley. The heat input to arc (Q) is given by Q = V x I. The parameters required to induce a compressive stress of 110MPa were determined by substitution into Eqn. 2 and 3. An estimate of the process efficiency of p=0.45, and reduction factor m=0.7 were used. The test setup is shown in Figure 5.
Figure 5: Welding Table Setup
Figure 6: Extensometer
The residual strains from the welding process were measured with the purpose built extensometer (Denston and White 1977), shown in Figure 6. Small indents are made in the central region of the plates by striking lmm ball bearings with a hammer. The extensometer is seated in the indentations before and after the welds are laid, and the distance between the two holes is measured. From these readings the weld shrinkage strain may be deduced, and the stress is calculated by multiplying the strain by the material Young's modulus.
92
Readings are taken on each surface of the plate and averaged to obtain the membrane stresses. An example of the indentation layout is given in Figure 7. The width of plates varies from 60 to 355mm, with all thicknesses nominally 5mm and lengths five times the width. 100mm
5mm
I i I Plate: 80x400xsmm " I I I
Indentations for J strain m e a s u r e m e n t -
s T 9
15mm 50ram
E
oE T-
I cL
15mm
Figure 7" Typical Indentation Layout RESULTS OF WELDING EXPERIMENTS Forty plate specimens were welded along both longitudinal edges consecutively. Table 1 shows a sample of the results for the plates of width 120mm. It is noted that the required current is set on the welder, and the machine runs at a voltage that is affected by the distance of the arc from the plate. The measured voltage was generally in the range of 9-12 Volts, varying slightly along the length of the plate. The voltage values in Table 1 are average values for the weld runs.
Weld1 Weld2 Weld1 Weld2 Weld1 Weld2
Width (mm) 120 120 120 120 120 120
I
Thickness Voltage (V) (mm) 10 5 11 5 10 5 11 5 10 5 10 5
Experiment Parameters Current Speed Q/v (Amps) (mm/sec) kJ/m 208.25 105 5.04 314.75 148 5.17 203.00 105 5.17 317.46 148 5.13 192.50 105 5.45 286.13 148 5.17
Results Pt I (iPa)
i
Pt 5 ( i P a ) ....
m
p
0.717
0.530
-120
-129
0.694
0.499
-111
-117
0.729
0.478
-107
-111
Table 1" Sample of Welding Results for Plate Width 120mm The centreline of the weld from the edge was 5mm for plate widths less than 100mm, and 10mm for those exceeding 100mm. The average process efficiency of the former was found to be 0.416, and the latter 0.507. This is a result of increased heat loss when the weld is placed closer to the edge of the plate. The process efficiency is calculated from Eqn's 2 and 3, where the reduction factor (m) is deduced from the measured stress gradient and the tendon force (F) from the measured stress magnitude. Figure 8 shows the process efficiency to increase slightly with plate width. All the plates were positioned on heat resistant bricks then clamped with steel clamps to minimise bending near the line of the weld, as shown in Figure 5. As the plate width increases, comparitively less of the specimen is seated on the bricks, and therefore less heat is lost through the bricks and clamps. The process efficiency therefore increases. The process efficiency is largely dependant on the experimental setup. As the process efficiency increases, so does the tendon force in Eqn. 2 for the first weld, and consequently the value of tensile stress produced at the other edge by the first weld increases also. The second weld is thus being laid in a more highly stressed material than
93 was expected from the assumption that the process efficiency would remain constant, and consequently as the plate width increases the calculated reduction factor 'm' decreases. This is shown in Figure 9. The average value of m was found to be 0.701, which is very close to the assumed constant value of 0.7. Where the assumed value of m is different from the actual value, a gradient exists in the residual stress profile. The average difference in stress between the two edges of the compressive regions for all specimens is 15%. The average compressive stress is 104MPa, with a standard deviation of 16MPa. The specimens of width greater than 200mm were excluded from the results, due to inconsistencies resulting from the high heat input required in these wide specimens in order to achieve a compressive stress of 110MPa. a. >, 0 " :.~ =:: uJ
0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 U) 0.2 o 0.1 2 a. 0 50
E 1 |
9
,=
9
~ 0L L. 6
~' ~, o.4 13 J
i
100 150 PlateWidth (rnm)
rr"
200
Figure 8: Process Efficiency vs Plate Width
0.2 0
~
50
i
!
100 150 Rate Width(mm)
200
Figure 9: Reduction Factor vs Plate Width
CONCLUSIONS The tendon force concept for determining residual stress profiles resulting from welding processes is reviewed, as are the models developed for inducing profiles in plates that approximate those in the stiffened elements of fabricated sections. The applicability of these methods to the unstiffened elements of fabricated sections is presented. It is shown how the models may be applied to unstiffened plate specimens, in order to create residual stress profiles that approximate those existing in the flange outstands of fabricated sections. The paper shows good correlation between the models and residual stress measurements on forty plate specimens of varying widths.
REFERENCES
Bradfield C.D. (1979). Tests on Single Plates under In-Plane Compression with Controlled Residual Stresses and Out-of-Flatness.University of Cambridge,ReportCUED/C-Struct/TR.78 Chick C.G. and Rasmussen K.J.R. (1999). Thin-Walled Beam-Columns. 1:Sequential Loading and Moment Gradient Tests. Journal of Structural Engineering. ASCE, 125:11, pp 1257-1266 Denston R.J and White J.D. (1977). An Electric Demountable Extensometer. University of Cambridge, Report CUED/C-Struct/TR.61 Dwight J.B. and Moxham K.E. (1971). Further tests on Welded Box Columns. University of Cambridge, Report CUED/C-Struct/TR.15 Hasham A.S. and Rasmussen K.J.R., (1998), Section Capacityof Thin-walled I-section Beam-columns, Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE, 124:4, 351-359. Kamtekar A.G. (1974). An Experimental Study of Welding Residual Stresses. University of Cambridge, Report CUED/C-Struct/TR.39 Moxham K.E. (1971). Buckling Tests on Individual Welded Steel Plates in Compression. Universityof Cambridge, Report CUED/C-Struct/TR.3 White J.D. (1977a). Longitudinal Shrinkage of a Single Pass Weld. Universityof Cambridge, Report CUED/CStruct/TR.57 White J.D. (1977b). Longitudinal Stresses in a Member Containing Non-Interacting Welds. Universityof Cambridge, Report CUED/C-Struct/TR.58 White J.D. (1977c). Longitudinal Stresses in Welded T-Sections. Universityof Cambridge, Report CUED/CStruct/TR.60
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Third International Conferenceon Thin-WalledStructures J. Zarag, K. Kowal-Michalskaand J. Rhodes 9 2001 ElsevierScience Ltd. All rights reserved
95
BEHAVIOUR AND DESIGN OF VALLEY-FIXED STEEL CLADDING SYSTEMS Mahen Mahendran ! and Dhammika Mahaarachchi 2 1Associate Professor, 2phD Research Scholar, Physical Infrastructure Centre, School of Civil Engineering, Queensland University of Technology, Brisbane, QLD 4000 Australia
ABSTRACT When thin steel cladding systems are subjected to wind uplift/suction loading, local pull-through failures occur prematurely at their screwed connections whether they are crest- or valley-fixed. During high wind events, these local failures then lead to severe damage to the buildings and their contents. In recent times, the use of valley-fixing has increased in Australia. Although valley-fixing has been used for many years in other countries, and relevant design formulae and test methods are available, the applicability of these formulae and test methods to Australian steel claddings is unknown. Therefore a series of small- and large-scale experiments of valley-fixed high strength steel cladding systems was conducted. This paper presents the details of this experimental investigation, and the results.
KEYWORDS Steel cladding systems, Valley-fixed, Wind uplift, Pull-through failures, Experiments
1. INTRODUCTION The profiled steel roof and wall cladding systems in Australia (Figures l a, b) are commonly made of very thin high strength steels, and are crest-fixed with screw fasteners (Figure l c). The thin high strength steels (0.42 mm base metal thickness) have a very high yield stress (G550 - minimum yield strength of 550 MPa) at the expense of reduced ductility (strain at failure < 2 %). During high wind events, these claddings have suffered severely because of local failures of their screwed connections under wind uplift/suction loading. The two common local failures are pull-out and pull-through failures and have been the subject of many research projects in the past (Mahendran, 1994, Mahendran and Tang, 1998, Mahaarachchi and Mahendmn, 2000). The pull-out failure occurs when the screw fastener pulls out of the batten or purlin whereas the pull-through failure occurs when the screw head pulls through by splitting the steel sheeting due to the presence of large stress concentrations around the fastener holes under wind uplift loading (Mahendran, 1994). In some cases, a localised dimpling failure occurs instead of splitting. Figure 2a shows the pull-through failures (splitting and dimpling) in crest-fixed steel cladding systems.
96
Figure 2: Local Pull-through Failures In recent times, the use of valley-fixing has increased in Australia. The steel claddings often suffer from local pull-through failures at their screw connections whether they are crest- or valley-fixed. Figure 2b shows the local pull-through failure that occurs in valley-fixed steel claddings. In the USA and Europe, valley-fixing has been used for many years, and relevant design formulae and test methods are available. However, the applicability of these formulae and test methods to Australian steel cladding systems is unknown. Since the local pull-through failures in the less ductile G550 steel claddings are initiated by transverse splitting at the fastener holes, analytical studies have not been able to determine the pullthrough failure loads. An appropriate splitting criterion is required for valley-fixed claddings. Therefore a series of experiments of valley-fixed high strength steel cladding systems has been conducted using small scale and large scale experiments. This paper presents the details of the experiments of valleyfixed steel claddings, the splitting criterion, and the accuracy of current design formulae and test methods in predicting the local pull-through failure loads.
2. CURRENT DESIGN AND TEST METHODS Currently the American (AISI, 1996) and European (Eurocode, 1996) design provisions recommend detailed design formulae for a range of mechanically fastened connections such as bolts and screws in tension in cold-formed thin-walled steel sheeting and members. The pull-through capacity of screwed connections in tension is calculated as follows: AISI (1996) Fov = 1.5 t dw fa (1 a) Eurocode 3 (1996) For = t dw fa (1 b) where dw = larger value of the screw head or the washer diameter, but limited to 12.7 mm in Eq.la t = steel thickness fu = ultimate tensile strength of steel In contrast, previous Australian design codes do not recommend any design formula, and the design for the local failures of screwed connections in tension has been entirely based on laboratory experiments. However, Equation l a has now been included in the new cold-formed steel structures code AS4600 (SA, 1996). This design formula was developed for conventional fasteners and thicker mild steel and specifically for valley-fixed steel cladding systems used in the USA and Europe. Mahendran and Tang (1998) and Mahaarachchi and Mahendran (2000) have found that the above design formulae were inadequate to predict the pull-through capacity of crest-fixed steel claddings. It is unknown whether these formulae will predict the pull-through strength of Australian valley-fixed steel cladding systems. Therefore there is a need to verify the applicability of these formulae.
97 As an alternative to the design method, the American and European specifications (AISI, 1992, Eurocode, 1996) and the new code AS4600 (SA, 1996) recommend standard test methods using small scale models. They were mainly developed for valley-fixed claddings and cold-formed connections in general. Hence these test methods were not able to predict the pull-through strength of crest-fixed steel cladding systems (Mahendran, 1995). In the absence of suitable simple design and test methods, Australian manufacturers and designers have been using a two-span steel cladding assembly with simply supported ends (Mahendran, 1994). In this investigation on valley-fixed claddings, it is not known whether the standard test methods recommended by AISI (1992) will predict accurate results. Although the two-span cladding test methods using air bags or bricks were the preferred methods, Mahendran (1994) developed a small scale test method to simulate the pull-through failures in crestfixed claddings as these failures are highly localized around the screw holes (Figure 2). He recommended a small scale cladding specimen of approximately 240 mm x 240 mm bolted to a small wooden frame. It is known whether this method will give accurate results for valley-fixed steel claddings. Therefore in this investigation all the above-mentioned methods, that is, the two-span test method, small scale test methods recommended by AISI (1992) and Mahendran (1994) were used. The following section describes the details of this experimental investigation.
3.
EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION
3.1 Two-span cladding Tests Since the pull-through loads of valley-fixed claddings were considerably larger than those of the crestfixed claddings, the required wind uplift pressure to be applied was very high (>7 kPa). When an airbox facility was used, most of the valley-fixed cladding systems failed due to other modes of failure such as section failures at midspan. The use of reduced cladding spans improved this situation, but then it required very high wind uplift pressures (15 kPa). Therefore the use of an airbox facility or an airbag/brick loading method was not possible. Instead a two-span cladding test method with midspan line loading was used to determine the pull-through load of valley-fixed screw fasteners at the critical central support. Figure 3 shows the test set-up using Tinius Olsen Testing Machine. TABLE 1. Test Results using the Two-span Cladding Method Cladding Profile and Span in mm Trapez. Trapez. Trapez. Trapez. Trapez. Trapez.
Type B / 600 Type B / 400 Type B / 400 Type B / 400 Type B / 400 Type B / 400
Steel Thickness in mm and Grade 0.42 - G550 0.42 - G550 0.42 - G550 0.42- G550 0.42- G550 0.42 - G550
dw Imm)
Failure mode
Average Measurd load per Fastener fastener (N)* Load .....2 3 (N) 3560 2373 2410 372012480 3120 4560 i3040 3490 5170 3447 3310 4510 3007 4140 1880 1253 1840 .
Test to Predict. AISI
I4.5 Splitting 0.73 14:5. Splitting 0.95 19 Punching 1.06 22 Splitting 1.00 19'" Splitting 1.25 10 Splitting0.71 longitudinl _Trapez. Type B / 400 0AS - G550 14..5 Splitting 5860 3907 4160 1.10 Corrugated / 600 0.42 - G550 14.5 Splitting 2010 1340 1690 0.51 Corrugated / 400 0.42 - G550 14.5 Splitting 3100 2067 2760 0.84 Corrugated / 400 0.42 - G550 10 Splitting 2850 1900 2380 0.92 Corrugated / 400 0.48 - G550 14.5 Splitting 3750 2500 3030 0.80 Corrugated / 400 0.60 - G300 14.5 Deformed 4060 2707 2550 0.55 Note: dw (mm) - Larger value of screw iaead or washer diameter ** 10 mm screw hole * 2 = Central support reaction/2 3 = Central support reaction/3 ,..
.
.
.
.
.
.
...
Test to Predict. Euro code 0.96 1.24 1.06 0.87 1.26 1.06 .
.
.
.
.
....
1.45 0.67 1.10 1.37 1.06 0.73 .
....
.....
.
.
.
.
.
98
Figure 3: Test Set-up
Figure 4: Typical Load-deflection Curves
The commonly available trapezoidal and corrugated claddings (Figure 1) were used, but with reduced width so that they can be accommodated in the testing machine. Past research has shown that both single-sheet and two-sheet wide specimens gave identical results for crest-fixed steel cladding systems (Mahaarachchi and Mahendran, 2000). Despite the reduced width, the test specimens had 3 screw fasteners at each support. The following parameters were varied: type of sheeting, span, screw shaft diameter, and screw head/washer diameter. The midspan loading was increased until one or more of the central support fasteners pulled through the sheeting. During the tests, the following measurements were taken: deflections of sheeting at critical locations, central support reaction using two load cells placed at the central support ends, and the load on one of the central support fasteners using a special load cell (Figure 3). Table 1 presents the details of the tests and the results. Figures 4 and 5a show the typical load-deflection curves and pull-through failure modes observed when this test method was used.
(b) Standard Test Method Recommended by AISI (1992) Figure 5: Typical Local Failures
99
Figure 5: Typical Local Failures
3.2 Standard Test Method Recommended by AISI (1992) The standard test method recommended by AISI (1992) and Eurocode (1996) was used in this series of tests (see Figure 6). This method uses a very small scale trapezoidal-shaped specimen fastened at the trough/valley. As it uses the same geometry specimen, it does not allow for the variation in the geometry of cladding profile. Therefore only the following parameters were varied in these tests: steel thickness and screw head/washer diameter. The test set-up recommended by AISI (1992) was used as shown in Figure 6, in which the tension load in the screw fastener was increased using the Tinius Olsen Testing Machine until a failure occurred. Table 2 presents the details of the tests and the results. Figure 5b shows the pull-through failure modes observed when this test method was used.
Figure 6: Test Set-up Recommended by AISI (1992) TABLE 2. Test Results using the Standard Test Method Recommended by AISI (1992) Steel thickness in mm and Grade " 0 . 4 0 - G250 0.40 - G250 0.42 - G550 0.42 - G550 0.42 - G550 0.42 - G550 t,,,
.,
....
Screw head/washer diameter dw (ram)
Failure Mode
Failure Load (N)
10 14.5 10 14.5 19 22
Splitting Splitting Punching Punching Punching Punching
2700 3240 2590 2605 1790 1575
Test to Predicted Value for AISI 1.80 1.70 1.00 0.80 0.54 0.47
Test to Predicted Value for Euroeode 2.70 2.23 1.50 1.03 0.57 0.40
100 3.3 Small Scale Test Method Recommended by Mahendran (1994)
The small scale test method developed by Mahendran (1994) was used in this series of tests. Small scale cladding specimens of approximately 240 mm x 240 mm were bolted to a small wooden frame. The width of the specimen between the bolts in transverse direction was the pitch of the cladding profile including the rib. A long screw fastener with a load cell attached to it was located at the centre of the specimen. The specimen was then loaded with a tension force by using a simple hand-tightening procedure. Unlike the AISI standard test method used in the last series of tests, this method models both the longitudinal and transverse membrane and bending deformations around the fastener hole and the tension force in the screw fastener. The tension force in the screw fastener was increased by handtightening until a failure occurred. This simple method enabled a large number of tests to be completed with limited resources in a short period of time. Figure 7 shows the test set-up whereas Table 3 presents the details of the tests and the results. The failure modes observed are shown in Figure 5c.
TABLE 3: Test Results using the Small Scale Test Method Recommended by Mahendran (1994)
Cladding Profile
Steel thickness in mm and Grade
Screw head/washer diameter dw
Cmm) Trapez Type B 0.42 - G550 Trapez Type B 0.42 - G550 Trapez Type B 0.42 - G550 Trapez Type B 0.42 - G550 Trapez Type B 0.42 - G550 . 0.60 - G550 Trapez Type B Trapez Type B 0.60 - G550 0.60 - G550 Trapez Type B 0.40 - G250 Trapez Type B Trapez Type B 0.40 - G250 0.40 - G250 Trapez Type B 0.40-G250 , Trapez Type B Trapez Type B 0.60 - G250 0.60-G250 i Trapez Type B 0.60 - G250 Trapez Type B 0.60 - G250 Trapez Type B 0.80 - G250 Trapez Type B 0.80 - G250 Trapez Type B 0.80 - G250 Trapez Type B 0.42 - G550 Trapez Type A 0.42 - G550 9Trapez Type A 0.42 - G550 Trapez Type A 0.42 - G550 Corrugated 0.42 - G550 Corrugated ' 0.42-G550 i 9 ' 0.42- G550 Corrugated Note: * - For both AISI and Eurocode thickness<0.9 mm i
i
i
14.5 19 22 19 (1Gramhole) 19 (14mmhole) 14.5 19 22 10 14.5 19 22 10 14.5 19 22 14.5 19 22 14.5 19 22 14.5 19
Failure Test to Load i Predict. (N) AISI*
Failure mode
Test to Predict. Euro code*
Splitt!ng 3755 1.14 1.49 Punching. 3715 1.13 .... 1.13 Splitting 4090 1.24 1.07 1.19 Splitting 3915 1 19 i j Splitting 3775 1.14 1.15 Splitting 6445 1.37 1.80 1.71 Punching 7615 1.62 1.11 Punching 6035 1.28 1.18 Splitting 1890 0.79 1.32 Splitting 3055 1.00 1.19 Splitting 3610 1.18 1.25 Splitting 4390 1.44 1.32 Splitting ~ 3160 0.88 1.55 Splitting i 5390 1.18 1.32 Punching ! 6005 1.31 1.17 1.35 Punching, i 6175 1.79 Punching j 8325 1.37 1.31 Punching I 7955 1.30 >1.04 Didn't fail >7330 >1.20 1.69 i Splitting 4250 1.29 1.21 L Punching , 3995 , 1.21 1.39 , Splitting , 5280 , 1.60 1.70 , Splitting, 4265 1.29 1.29 , Splitting 4230 i 1.28 1.05 , Splitting ' 3990 I 1.21 22 1.19 19 tl0mmhole). S p l i t t i n g 3915 I 1.19 predictions, 75% of fu was used for G550 steel with i
m
101
Figure 7: Small Scale Test Set-up Recommended by Mahendran (1994) 4. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
4.1 Comparison of Results from Different Test Methods In the two-span cladding tests, the fastener load was measured directly and also calculated based on the measured central support reaction. The measured fastener load appears to be between the two calculated values (see Table 1) and was used in the comparions. The test failure loads shown in Tables 1 to 3 are the average of 2 test results. The standard test method recommended by AISI (1992) and Eurocode (1996) was unable to simulate the longitudinal and transverse bending actions including the localised deformations at the fastener hole. The failure mode of punching at the edges of screw head was due to the pure transverse bending action as seen Figure 5b, and was not the pull-through failures observed in the two-span cladding tests (Figure 5a). Therefore this standard test method cannot be used to determine the pull-through load of valley-fixed cladding, particularly for thin high strength steels (G550). On the other hand, the small scale test method (Mahendran, 1994) simulated the pull-through failures observed in the two-span tests (Figures 5a and 5c). The pull-through failure loads compared reasonably well in many cases, but there were considerable, unexpected differences in some cases. Further tests using varying specimen lengths are required to validate the accuracy of this test method.
4.2 Comparison of Test Failure Loads and Current Design Loads In general, current design formulae appear to be conservative (Tables 1 and 3). This may be due to the fact that they were developed to allow for both pull-through failures, namely the transverse splitting and the punching type failures (see Figure 5). The latter occurred when the screw fastener/washer head size (dw) was increased. Most of the test results indicated that the failure load increased with increasing dw, but the AISI formula predicted the same load for dw>12.5 mm. The Eurocode formula does not have this shortcoming, but it is more conservative than the AISI formula for dw
102 TABLE 4: Comparison of Failure Strains Two-span Test Details Trapez Type B 014243550 span = 400 dw'- 14.5 Trapez Type B 0.42-G550_span -"400 dw= 19 Trapez Type B 0.4243550 span = 400 dw- 22 Corrugate d 0.4243550 span = 400 dw= 14.5 Corrugated 0.42-G550 span = 600 dw= lzi.5 Corrugated 0.4843550 sp.an= 400 dw= 14.5 Corrugated 0.60-G300 span = 400 dw= 14.5
Membrane strain Strain
% Strain
3.19 2.57 3.40
83 81 87 74 79 73 58
1.70
2.39 2.59 1.41
, ,
Fiexurai strain Strain % strain 0.64 17 0.60 19 0.50 13 0.56 26 0.66 21 0.95 27 1.03 42 ,
Total Strain 3.83
3.17 3.90 2.28 3.O5 3.54 2.44 no split
Membrane strains at failure indicate that they have to be greater than about 60% for splitting to occur. This observation is similar to that determined by Mahaarachchi and Mahendran (2000) for crest-fixed claddings. However, the total strain at failure was greater than the tensile strain at failure (2% for 0.42 mm G550 steel). This contradicts the criterion for crest-fixed claddings for which the total strain at failure was found to be equal to the strain at failure from tensile coupon tests. Therefore further tests are required to develop an appropriate criterion for valley-fixed claddings. This will allow advanced numerical modelling to be undertaken and thus improve the design methods.
5. CONCLUSIONS This paper has described the behaviour of valley-fixed profiled steel claddings under wind uplift forces using three different test methods. The standard test method recommended by American and European codes was found to be inadequate in predicting the pull-through failure loads of full scale steel cladding systems made of high strength steel. The current design formula appears to be conservative in predicting the pull-through capacity of valley-fixed steel cladding systems. Further research is continuing to improve the design and test methods of high strength valley-fixed steel cladding systems.
6. REFERENCES 1. 2. 3.
4.
5. 6. 7. 8.
American Iron and Steel Institute (AISI) (1996), Specification for the Design of Cold-formed Steel Structural Members, AISI, Washington, DC. American Iron and Steel Institute (AISI) (1992), Test methods for Mechanically Fastened Coldformed Steel Connections, Report CF92-1, AISI, Washington, DC. Eurocode 3 (1996), Design of Steel Structures, Part 1.3 -General Rules-Supplementary Rules for Cold-formed Thin-gauge Members and Sheeting, European Committee for Standardisation, Brussels. Mahaarachchi, D. and Mahendran, M. (2000), Pull-through Failures of Crest-fixed Steel Claddings Initiated by Transverse Splitting, Proc.15 th International Conference on Cold-formed Steel Structures, St. Louise, MO, October, pp.635-646. Mahendran, M. (1994), Behaviour and Design of Crest-fixed Profiled Steel Roof Claddings under High Wind Forces, Engng. Struct., Vo1.16, No.5. pp.368-376. Mahendran, M. (1995), Test Methods for Determination of Pull-through Strength of Screwed Connections in Profiled Steel Claddings, Civil Eng Trans., IEAust., Vol.CE37, No.3, pp.219-227. Mahendran, M. and Tang, R.B. (1998), Pull-out Strength of Steel Roof and Wall Cladding Systems, Journal of Structural. Engineering, ASCE., Vol. 124 No.10, pp. 1192-1201. Standards Australia (SAA) (1996), AS4600 Steel Structures Code.
Third International Conferenceon Thin-Walled Structures J. Zarag, K. Kowal-Michalskaand J. Rhodes 9 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved
103
BEHAVIOUR OF FLEXIBLE THIN-WALLED STEEL STRUCTURES FOR ROAD AND RAILWAY APPLICATIONS J. Vaslestad 1, B. Bednarek 2 and L. Janusz 2 1 ViaCon Norway, Strandveien 3B, 2005 Raelingen 2 ViaCon Poland, 64-130 Rydzyna k/Leszna, ul. Przemysiowa 6
ABSTRACT Corrugated steel culverts are increasingly being used in road and railway projects as alternative solutions to concrete bridges and culverts. The construction period is short, and the structures have both technical and economical advantages. Several full scale tests have been performed in the field to validate the long-term performance and great load bearing capacity of these structures, but not very many structures have been tested in controlled conditions in a test facility like the test in Zmigrod, Wysokowski (1997). The testing consists of static testing and dynamic testing. The dynamic and fatigue part consists of 600.000 cycles, Vaslestad and Wysokowski (1999). The full scale testing and finite element analyses of structures will help us to optimize and design more economic structures. It is of importance to have high quality test results when designing the flexible structures with minimum cover for live loads (railway and road). This paper describes three flexible thin-walled steel culverts, two from Poland and one from Norway. The first structure, built in 1997, is a 9,92 m span steel arch railroad tunnel with low cover and main road crossing over. The structure was instrumented with earth pressure cells and strain gages. The second structure, built in 1998, is a 8,9 m span pipe arch with railroad crossing over. The structure was instrumented with nd strain gages and deformation gages. The third structure, built in 1999, is a 11,58 rn span steel arch with road crossing over. The structure was instrumented with deformation gages for long-term monitoring.
KE~ORDS
Corrugated steel structure, pipe arch, soil-structure interaction, bearing capacity
INTRODUCTION Several approaches have been suggested for the design of thin-walled flexible steel structures, Kloppel and Glock (1970), Vaslestad (1990). Many of the design methods are reviewed by Bednarek (2000).
104 It is also recognized that buries flexible culverts undergo changes in deformation and structural response as time progresses after installation. Long-term behaviour of two instrumented corrugated steel culverts in Norway built in 1983 and 1985 are reported by Vaslestad (1990). The full scale testing and finite element analyses of structures will help us to optimize and design more economic structures. It is of importance to have high quality test results when designing the flexible structures with minimum cover for live loads (railway and road). Several full scale tests have been performed in the field to validate the long-term performance and great load beating capacity of these structures, but not very many structures have been tested in controlled conditions in a test facility like the test in Zmigrod, Wysokowski (1997). The testing consisted of static testing and dynamic testing. The dynamic and fatigue part consists of 600.000 cycles. Vaslestad and Wysokowski (1999). Earth pressure, steel stress and deformations were recorded during the static and dynamic testing. The testing were performed with height of cover ranging from 1,0 m and down to 0,3 m. The results show that there are small deformations and stresses. Full scale testing in the field in Poland on instrumented structures with railway loading have confirmed this. The results shows that the corrugated steel stuctures are safe with height of cover down to 0,30 m for both railways and roads, Vaslestad and Wysokowski (1999).
STEEL ARCH AS RAILROAD TUNNELWITH LOW COVER In 1997 a 55 m long corrugated steel tunnel was built as a railroad culvert with a road crossing over. Corrugated steel plates with 150x50 mm corrugation and steel thickness 7 mm were used. The tunnel is constructed as a steel arch on cast-in-place concrete foundations with 2,0 m width and thickness 0,5 m. The width of the tunnel is 9,92 m. The steel arch was erected in 10 working days. The minimum cover above the culvert was 0,45 m below the road and a concrete relieving slab were used to distribute the traffic loads from the road. The steel culvert were instrumented with strain gages and earth pressure cells, because this was a non-standard solution with low cover and reinforced steep slopes. The instrumentation were financed by the owner Public Roads Administration. Long-term behaviour of two instrumented corrugated steel culverts in Norway built in 1983 and 1985 are reported by Vaslestad (1989). Geotextile reinforced steep slopes were used around the opening ends of the steel culvert. The slope angle is 60 degrees and the maximum height is 10 m. A woven multifilament polyester geotextile with a characteristic short time tensile strength of 150 kN/m were used as reinforcement. The wall facing consisted of steel mesh and vegetation mat. The reinforced slope is reported by Vaslestad and Clausen (1998). A concrete relieving slab with thickness 260 mm and width 12 m were used below the road due to the low cover. An alternative with geotextile instead of the concrete slab were considered, but only used outside the road. Model tests at University of Oxford with geotextile above flexible steel culverts, Pearson and Milligan (1990), were shown to give a reduction with 25 % on the bending moment and 50 % on deformations of the culvert. Similar results were shown with model tests from Canada, Kennedy et.al. (1988). The minimum cover above flexible steel culverts can be reduced by using a layer of high strength geotextile or geogrid. In the summer 1999 Public Roads Administration performed a full scale load test on the road above the relieving slab, Braaten et.al. (2000). A vehicle with total weight 246 kN, and axle load 181 kN were placed on the road, and deformations and earth pressure were measured. The maximum measured vertical deformation on top of the steel culvert were less than 0,5 ram. The maximum increase in earth pressure below the relieving slab were 3 kPa..
105 STEEL PIPE-ARCH REPLACING OLD RAILWAY BRIDGE Poznafi structure
Phot. 1" Poznafi Rubiez: structure view
Fig. 1" Poznah Rubiez: vertical deflection- symmetrical load
106 STEEL ARCH AS ROAD TUNNEL
Lublin structure
Phot.2: Lublin: structure view
REFERENCES
Kennedy J.B., Laba J.T. and Shaheen H. (1988). Reinforced soil-metal structures. Journal of Structural Engineering, VoI. 114, No. 6, ASCE, pp. 1372-1389. Kl6ppel K. and Glock D. (1970). Theoretische und experimentelle Untersuchungen zu den Traglastproblemen biegeweicher, in die Erde eingebetteter Rohre. Heft 10, Institut fiar Statik und Stahlbau der Technischen Hochschule Darmstadt. Madaj A., Vaslestad J. and Janusz L. (1999). Full-scale testing of a long-span corrugated steel culvert used to rehabilitate a concrete frame railway viaduct. (in Polish) Proceedings of the IX Polish Bridge Conference, Poznan, 8-9 June 1999, pp. 106-117. Pearson A.E. and Milligan G.W. (1990). Model tests of reinforced soil in conjunction with flexible culverts. Performance of reinforced soil structures, Thomas Telford, pp. 365-372. Vaslestad J. (1989). Long-term behaviour of flexible large-span culverts. Transportation Research Record 1231, pp 14-24, Transportation Research Board, Washington D'C, 1989. Vaslestad J. (1990). Soil structure interaction of buried culverts. Dr.ing thesis, Norwegian Institute of Technology, Trondheim.
107 Vaslestad J. and Clausen B. (1998). Case histories with long span corrugated steel culverts from Norway. 8th seminar: Contemporaries methods of bridges reinforcing and reconstruction. Poznan 910.06.1998. Vaslestad J. and Janusz L. (2000). Application of flexible structures of corrugated steel plates in military engineering. Examples from Poland and abroad. (in Polish). III Technical and Scientific Conference: Military engineering- problems and prospects. Szklarska Poreba, Poland, 22-24 November 2000. Vaslestad J. and Janusz L. (2000). Flexible corrugated steel road tunnel, the biggest in Poland. (in Polish) Proceedings of the VI International Conference: Durable and safe road pavements, Kielce, Poland, 9-10 May 2000, pp. 95-103. Vaslestad J., Janusz L. and Bednarek B. (2000). Corrugated steel structures used for construction of bridges (in Polish). Materiaty Budowlane, 11/2000, pp. 48-49. Vaslestad J. and Wysokowski A. (1999). Full scale testing of MultiPlate corrugated steel culverts including fatigue problems. Archives of Civil Engineering, XLV, 2, 1999, pp. 375-383. Wysokowski A. (1997). Stand for testing of bridges at natural scale - research possibilities. Report from Polish Road and Bridge Research Institute, Zmigrod 1997. Wysokowski A., Vaslestad J. and Pryga A. (2000). Full scale fatigue testing of corrugated steel culverts. (in Polish) Konstrukcje Stalowe 5 (42), August 2000, pp. 45-47. Bednarek B. (2000) Steel corrugated MultiPlate type bridges and overpasses alongside A-2 motorway (on the distance between Swiecko and Poznan). (in Polish), M.A.Thesis, Poznan University of Technology, Poland.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
109
Third InternationalConferenceon Thin-WalledStructures J. Zara~,K. Kowal-Michalskaand J. Rhodes 9 2001 ElsevierScienceLtd. All rights reserved
A SIMPLIFIED COMPUTATION MODEL FOR ARCH-SHAPED CORRUGATED SHELL ROOF Fan Xuewei School of Civil Engineering and Architecture, Northem Jiaotong University, Beijing, 100044, P. R. China
ABSTRACT Arch-shaped corrugated shell roof is a new type of steel light structure in China. It is widely used in China now for its short construction period, cheap cost and so on. The construction area covers over 2,000,000 m 2 per year at present. Many arch-shaped corrugated shell roofs have been collapsed in recent years nearly every area in China for heavy snow or typhoon. Xu studied the structure carefully and pointed out that the corrugation on the roof is the key factors for the accidents and the corrugation decreases the beating capacity of the roof. Based on this fact, the author put forward a type of FEM model to design the structure, which is nonlinear thin-walled beam consisted of orthotropic plates. The computation example of the article indicates this model has good precision and is easy to converge. The model is competent for the design of the structure. KEYWORDS arch-shaped corrugated shell roof, finite element method, corrugation effect, steel light structure, thin-walled structure, spatial structure
INTRODUCTION Arch-shaped corrugated shell roof (ACSR) is a new type of steel light structure in China. It is widely used in China for its very short construction period, cheap cost and so on. Its construction process is shown in Figl, Fig2 and Fig 3. In 1997 there were six ACSR collapsed for heavy snow in An' Shah city
,,,
Fig 1. Channel section forming
Fig 2. Corrugated channel forming
110 in northeast China. From then on there were many accidents of ACSR collapsed for heavy snow or typhoon in nearly every area in China. So the accidents attracted the industry's great attention. Xu (1998) pointed out that the corrugation on the roof decreases the bearing capacity of the structure while the designers did not consider the corrugation effect. On one hand as is well known, the difference of the stiffness for the corrugated sheet along the two perpendicular principal axis directions is very large. Generally the strong stiffness of the corrugation sheet is used to bear the load in architecture structure. However the weak stiffness direction of the corrugation sheet is the same as the arch axis direction along which there exists very large axis forces and partial moments. This is to say, the bearing load way of ACSR is to use the weak stiffness to bear the load and it is unreasonable. On the other hand from the computation manual it can be seen that the designers do not consider the corrugation effect. Further more Xu (1998) pointed out that the design of ACSR must consider corrugation influence on the bearing capacity of the structure. Based on this view, the author of the article put forward a FEM model --nonlinear thin-walled beam consisted of orthotropic plates. The element stiffness matrix is derived in the article. Finally an example is provided and the computation results indicate the method has the good precision and good convergence character. Seam together Seam
4
Seam
4
Fig 4. Sketch map of the section
Fig 3. Seam the edges together
G
r
E, 1
:xo Ely,
Fig 5. Coordinates of the cross section
Fig 6. Section property
MECHANICS MODEL AND ASSUMPTIONS Designers always assume that the loads on the roof along the longitudinal direction are the same. So the structure is a typical 2D structure. This is to say unit width roof can be separated from the structure and can be treated as the study object. There are generally two kind of method to design the roof. The first
111 one is to use shell element to compute the structure, but it is very complicated. The second one is to use thin-walled beam element. For the beam, the corrugation shows the orthotropic character. So the designers must consider this character. In this article, a thin-walled beam consisted of orthotropic plates is introduced here. Fig 5 shows the section coordinates of the beam. G, P, A is a general point on the cross section, a pole and an arbitrary point on the contour of the bar, respectively. There are three kinds of coordinates in the cross section, which are X - Y - Z coordinates system, r - q - z coordinates system and n - s - z coordinates system. Define the displacement components of the bar in the x and y directions and the rotation about the positive z direction to be U, V, ~ . Let the displacement of point A to be u, v, w in the n , s, z direction. To distinguish between the two displacement schemes, U, V and 9 are referred as bar displacements and u, v, w as the shell displacements. Wang (1999) tested the orthotropic material properties, and the one of the principle axis of the corrugation slab is parallel to the z-axis of the coordinates system. The elastic moduli of the corrugation slab are E1x, E2x and Ely , E2y. The Poisson ratio are ~l.lx, ~2x andlxly, ~t2y. (See Fig 6.)
The assumptions employed in this article are given below. 1. The cross section is assumed to be perfectly rigid in its plane while free to warp out of its plane. 2. The shear strain in the middle surface is very small and can be neglected. 3. Each segment of the cross section behaves as a thin shell, which means Kirchhoff-Love assumptions are valid. 4. The normal stress in the contour direction ( os ) is very small compared to the axial stress. So it could be neglected.
FEM
F O R M U L A S
The Displacement Strain Relationship u, v and ~v can be expressed in the form below: (Gjelsvik, 1981)
u(z,s) =U(z)sinO(s)-V(z)cosO(s)-~(z)q(s) ] v(s,z):U(z),cosO(s)+V(z)sinO(s)+.(z)r(s) ~ w = W ( z ) - U (z)X~(s)-r" (z)r~(s)-a~'(s)fl~(s)j
(1)
where ~"~a = ~(s)r($) dS is the sectoral area. The displacements u, ~, ~ for a point on the contour in the (n, s, z) directions are related to the displacements u, v, w for a general point on the cross section in the same directions, by the following relations (Fluggle, 1966) -
u=u
-
0u
v=v--as
-
0u
w=w-n-~z
The nonlinear relationship between displacements and strains are
(2)
112 Ow ' ( O u ~ 2 l ( O v ) 2 l ( a w ~ 2" ez=&-+2k,&-zJ +-2 ~zz + 2 \ O z J
Ov l ( O u ) 2 l ( O v ) 2
I(o~'] 2
e==N+Tkos) +2t,Os) +2 ~s o%, o% Ou Ou
ezs
Os
Ov Ov
Ow Ow
Oz Oz Os Oz Os
Oz Os
(3)
Thus the linear and nonlinear strains can be written in terms of the beam displacements ez = W ' - XU"- YV"- [)~" ~,2 nz= (U '2 + V ' 2 ) + - ~ [ ( X - X p ) 2 + ( y - y p ) 2 I - U ' O ( Y - yp)+ V ~ ' ( X - X p )
(5)
ezs = 2nO'
(6)
(4)
Constitutive Relations The constitutive relations for the orthotropic plates are
{} L0 Ns = Nzs
(7)
21 A22 0 A33J[ezsJ
(8) Mu
0
D33Jlk~J
Where N , , 2% and N=s are the membrane forces of the corrugated sheet, Mz, Ms and Mm are the bending and twisting moments of the corrugated sheet. A0 is the stiffness coefficient of the membrane. Dv is the stiffness coefficient of the bending and twisting. After the integration over the contour, the relationship between the beams and displacements in the principle axes of the cross section can be gained. N=A*W'
-Mx=I~V "
M r = I ~ U"
(9) (10)
Mco = I~co~" Ts = I* G~' The expressions of A" , I~x, * I ~ , Ioo, " J*G are listed in the appendix.
The Deriviation of The Element Stiffness Matrix For an arbitrary bar, two nodes can be defined 1 and 2. Then the beam displacements are expressed in terms of nodal displacements as
W=(nl){Wi}
U=(n3){Uz}
V =(n3){V~}
~P=(n3){Oi}
(11)
113 where { ~ } = ( W I
{r}=(Vl
V'I v2
(nl)=(1-f3,f3)
{Ut}=(UI
W2) r
v'2) r
U'I U2 U'2)r t
[o1=(ol
col *2 ~"2)r
(n3)=(1-3~ 2 + 2f3s,f3-2~ 2+f33,3f32-2~3,~3-~ 2)
(12) (13)
(14)
(nl) ,(ns) is the interpolation functions. The virtual work principle can be written t
I tSo'Stg.O"tdV + ~ t(~o~)tl"lij'dV= tV tV
t+At
R-I
t(3ij~)te~jtdV
(15)
tV
For the thin-walled beam, the virtual work done by the internal forces is
8W = ~(N81u + MxSg" + MrSU" + McoS~" + TsSO')dz = I(A*WBW' + I'xxV'BV" + I~u*ru" + I*~,oO'SO" + +j*GO'~O')dz + tr
,_tN
X
A
I~
E l--7;-
Y
tMr + - ~ - t M x - - w - t M o ]
{1(U'2, + V '2) + ~
Ixx
(16)
Inn
[ ( X - X p)2 + ( y _ y p)2] _ U'O(Y - y , ) + V~'(X - X p)}dV
After complicate computation, the element stiffness matrix is derived.
[KE] = [KL] + [ K m ]
(17)
The expression of [KL] is the same as in the book by Bao(1991). [KlvL] is listed in the appendix.
The Solution Of The Nonlinear Equations Increment iterative method is the usual method to solve the nonlinear equations. It assumes that the solution is known at the initial discrete moment t, solution at the presumed moment t + At is derived. At is the increment. The fundamental equation in the nonlinear analysis is t+~t{R}-t+ta{F} =0, in which
t+at{R}is exterior load vector on the nodes, t+at{F} is node force vector equivalent to stress of the element. Iterative method is needed because the node force vector t+at{F} depends on the nodes displacement nonlinearly. For i=1,2,3.., the iterative equations are given below.
{A~R}(i-l)=t+At {R} t+~{F}O-l)
(18)
tf KI{AU}(O = {AR}O -1)
(19)
t+~t{U}CO=t+~{u}O-o + {AU} co
(20)
'+~{uiCO)=,iu},
(21)
'ยง
Compute the no equilibrium load vector in Eq.(18) in each of iteration, and the displacement increment is derived in Eq. (20). Terminate the iteration until {z~} 0-1) or {AU} O) converges.
114 EXAMPLES To verify this FEM model, an example is given below. The principle mechanical properties of the corrugated sheet are measured to be: Elx =0.24e5MPa; Ely = 0.48e5MPa; ~tlx =0.006; ~tly =0.045;
E2x = 0.09e5MPa; E2y = 0.7e5MPa; ~t2x = 0.02; P2y =0.07. Two computational models are provided in this article. The first one is an orthotropic shell model, and the second model is the thin-walled beam model. Fig 8 shows the load-deflection curves of the two models. The maximum percentage error between two models is less than 5%. The comparison results indicate that the thin-walled beam consisted of orthotropic plates is capable of the design work.
0.4 ,[
I
1,
1,
,I,
* o. 3
]-----model I
I= ~o.2
---0.1
0 0
Fig7. Computation model
30
,
,
60
90
120
Fig 8. Di~lac=~ ent,load curves
CONCLUSIONS In this article, a nonlinear FEM model for ACSR was established. The method has the advantages such as good precision, good convergence character, easy to master for designers and so on. The computation software for the ACSR design has adapted this method recently.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: The authors gratefully acknowledge the support for this study provided by the Ministry of Construction of P. R. China.
References Asokendu Samanta, Madhujit Mukhopadhyay, (1999), Finite Element Static and Dynamic Analyses of Folded Plates. Engineering Structures. 21:3, 277-287 B. Omidvar, A. Ghorbanpoor, (1996), Nonlinear FE Solution for Thin-Walled Open-section Composites Beams, J. Structure Engineering, 122:11, 1369-1378 Bao Shihua, Zhou Jian, (1991), Thin-WalledBars Mechanics, China Architecture Industry Press, Beijing, China Fan Xuewei, Xu Guobin, Cui Ling, (2000), The Static Work Character Analysis of Arch-Shaped Metal
115
Corrugated Shell Roof Considering Corrugated Effect. The 6th Asian Pacific Conference on Shell and Spatial Structures, Seoul, Korea Flugge, W. (1966), Stresses In The Shells, Springer-Verlag, N. Y. Gjelsvik, A. (1981), The Theory of Thin Walled Bars, John Wiley & Sons, N. Y. Nelson R. ,Bauld Jr., Lih-shyng Tzeg, (1984), A Vlasov Theory for The Fiber-Reinforced Beams With Thin-Walled Open Cross Section, Int. d. Solids and Structures, 20:3, 277-297 Wang Xiaoping, Jiang Cangru, Li Guiqing, (1999), Simplifying of Calculating Model on Metal Corrugated Arch Roof, Steel Construction, 14:4, 8-10 Xu Guobin, Cui Ling, Pan Yi, (1998), Collapse Analysis of Wrinkled Steel Thin Walled Arch-Shell Roof. Spatial structures. 4:4, 49-55
Appendix Notation: A* 9axial stiffness of beam. E , : modulus of elasticity of corrugated slab in the direction along the arch axis.
E22 : modulus of elasticity of corrugated slab perpendicular to the direction of El,. I ~ , I ~ 9moment of inertia of the thin-walled beam about principal axes X and Y. Ioo 9warping moment of inertia.
J*G " torsion constant. M x , M r 9bending moments about principal axes X and Y. Mo : bimoment
Ts : Saint Venant torsion.
All=
El~l t, .422= E2~2 t, A12=`421= ~t21El~l t= ~t12E22 t, 1-btl2~t21 1-btl2kt21 1-ktl2b