Thermodynamics: Principles Characterizing Physical and Chemical Processes by J. M. Honig
• ISBN: 0123738776 • Publisher...
205 downloads
2476 Views
20MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Thermodynamics: Principles Characterizing Physical and Chemical Processes by J. M. Honig
• ISBN: 0123738776 • Publisher: Elsevier Science & Technology Books • Pub. Date: March 2007
Preface
The present volume involves several alterations in the presentation of thermodynamic topics covered in the previous editions. Obviously, it is not a trivial exercise to present in a novel fashion any material that covers a period of more than 160 years. However, as best as I can determine the treatment of irreversible phenomena in Sections 1.13, 1.14, and 1.20 appears not to be widely known. Following much indecision, and with encouragement by the editors, I have dropped the various exercises requiring numerical evaluation of formulae developed in the text. After much thought I have also relegated the Carathrodory formulation of the Second Law of Thermodynamics (and a derivation of the Debye-Htickel equation) as a separate chapter to the end of the book. This permitted me to concentrate on a simpler exposition that directly links entropy to the reversible transfer of heat. It also provides a neat parallelism with the First Law that directly connects energy to work performance in an adiabatic process. A more careful discussion of the basic mechanism that forces electrochemical phenomena has been provided. I have also added material on the effects of curved interfaces and self assembly, and presented a more systematic formulation of the basics of irreversible processes. A discussion of critical phenomena is now included as a separate chapter. Lastly, the treatment of binary solutions has been expanded to deal with asymmetric properties of such systems. The aim, as before, has been to avoid as much as possible a presentation that is simply a linear superposition of discussions found in many other textbooks. Again, great stress is placed on the benefits of a systematic development of every topic, starting with modest beginnings, and reaping a whole cornucopia of results through self-contained logical operations and mathematical manipulations. I am greatly indebted to many persons for providing help, advice, and criticism. Where appropriate I have acknowledged in footnotes the sources that I have closely followed in my expositions. In revising the earlier versions I am indebted to Professor Dor Ben-Amotz for many insightful discussions, especially those relating to irreversible phenomena. I also value the editorial help by personnel at Elsevier, Inc. The book is dedicated to my parents who helped instill a love of the arts and sciences, to my late wife Gertrude Claryce Dahlbom Honig, to my present, equally wonderful wife, Josephine Neely Vamos Honig, and to the many children, both grown and young, who constitute the immediate family. All of them have been
vi
PREFACE
very understanding in my complete absorption in the preparation of the current volume. I hope the present volume will be found useful to all who are interested in the fascinating field of classical thermodynamics.
July 2006
J.M. Honig Purdue University West Lafayette, Indiana
vii
Preface to the Second Edition
The present volume is an upgraded version of a reference text published by Elsevier under the same title in 1982. The goals of the presentation have remained unaltered: to provide a self-contained exposition of the main areas of thermodynamics and to demonstrate how from a few fundamental concepts one obtains a whole cornucopia of results through the consistent application of logic and mathematical operations. The book retains the same format. However, Section 1.16 has been completely rewritten, and several new sections have been added to clarify concepts or to add further insights. Principal among these are the full use of thermodynamic information for characterizing the Joule-Thomson effect, a reformulation of the basic principles underlying the operation of electrochemical cells, and a brief derivation of the Onsager reciprocity conditions. Several short sections containing sample calculations have also been inserted at locations deemed to be particularly instructive in illustrating the application of basic principles to actual problems. A special effort has also been made to eliminate the typographical errors of the earlier edition. The author would appreciate comments from readers that pertain to remaining errors or to obscure presentations. It remains to thank those whose diligence and hard work have made it possible to bring this work to fruition: Ms. Virginia Burbrink, who undertook much of the enormous task of converting the typography of the earlier edition to the present word processor format; Ms. Gail Shively, who completed this onerous task and patiently dealt with all of the unexpected formatting problems; and Ms. Sophia Onayo, who compiled the index and the table of contents. Purdue University has provided a very comfortable milieu in which both the writing and the later revision of the book were undertaken. It is a pleasure to express my appreciation to various individuals at Academic Press who encouraged me to prepare the revised text and who were most cooperative in getting the book to press. Last, this task could not have been completed without the support of my beloved wife, Josephine Vamos Honig, who gave me much moral support after the death of my first wife, as well as during the book revision process, and to whom I shall remain ever grateful. J.M. Honig Purdue University
ix
Preface to the First Edition The publication of yet another text on the well-explored topic of thermodynamics requires some commentary: such a venture may be justified on the grounds that as scientists our perceptions of any subject matter continually change; even as traditional and established an area as chemical thermodynamics is not exempt from such a subtle transmutation. Thus, there appears to be merit in a continuing series of expositions of the discipline of thermodynamics that differ perceptibly from linear combinations of discussions found in prior texts and monographs. In the present volume there occur several departures from conventional treatments, among them: (i) the presentation of the Second Law based on a simplified approach to Carath6odory's method; (ii) a reasonably comprehensive treatment of thermodynamics of systems subjected to externally applied fields-special emphasis has been placed on the systematics of electromagnetic fields and on gas adsorption processes, concerning which there has been much confusion; (iii) detailed investigations on the uniqueness of predictions of properties of solutions, in the face of a bewildering array of standard states, of methods for specifying composition, and of equilibrium constants; (iv) a rationalization scheme for the interpretation of phase diagrams; (v) a discussion of the thermodynamics of irreversible processes, centered on the macroscopic equations. Most of the above topics are not covered in detail in existing texts. Throughout, emphasis has been placed on the logical structure of the theory and on the need to correlate every analysis with experimental operating conditions and constraints. This is coupled with an attempt to remove the mystery that seems so often to surround the basic concepts in thermodynamics. Repeatedly, the attention of the reader is directed to the tremendous power inherent in the systematic development of the subject matter. Only the classical aspects of the problem are taken up; no attempt has been made to introduce the statistical approach, since the subject matter of classical thermodynamics is self-consistent and complete, and rests on an independent basis. The course of study is aimed at graduate students who have had prior exposure to the subject matter at a more elementary level. The author has had reasonable success in the presentation of these topics in a two-semester graduate class at Purdue University; in fact, the present book is an outgrowth of lecture notes for this course. No worked numerical examples have been provided, for there exist many excellent books in which different sets of problems have been worked out in detail. However, many problems are included as exercises at various levels of difficulty, which the student can use to become facile in numerical work.
x
PREFACE TO THE FIRST EDITION
The author's indebtedness to other sources should be readily apparent. He profited greatly from fundamental insights offered in two slim volumes: Classical Thermodynamics by H.A. Buchdahl and Methods of Thermodynamics by H. Reiss. Also, he found instructive the perusal of sources, texts, and monographs on classical thermodynamics authored by C.J. Adkins, I.V. Bazarov, H.B. Callen, S. Glasstone, E.A. Guggenheim, G.N. Hatsopoulos and J.H. Keenan, W. Kauzmann, J. Kestin, R. Kubo, P.J. Landsberg, EH. MacDougall, A. Mtinster, A.B. Pippard, I. Prigogine, P.A. Rock, and M.W. Zemansky. Specific sources that have been consulted are acknowledged in appropriate sections in the text. He is greatly indebted to Professor L.L. Van Zandt for assistance in formulating the thermodynamic characterization of electromagnetic fields. Most of all, he has enormously profited from the penetrating insight, unrelenting criticism, and incisive comments of his personal friend and colleague Professor J.W. Richardson. Obviously, the remaining errors are the author's responsibility, concerning which any correspondence from readers would be appreciated. It is a pleasant duty to acknowledge the efforts of several secretaries, Jane Biddie, Cheryl Zachman, Nancy Holder, Susan Baker, and especially Konie Young and Barbara Rosenberg~all of whom cheerfully cooperated in transforming illegible sets of paper scraps into a rough draft. Special thanks go to Hali Myers, who undertook the Herculean task of typing the final version; without her persistence the manuscript could not have been readied for publication. Dr. Madhuri Pai contributed greatly by assisting with the proofreading of the final manuscript. In a matter of personal experience, it is appropriate to acknowledge several meaningful discussions with my father, the late Richard M. Honig, who was an expert in jurisprudence and who readily saw the parallels between scientific methodology and the codification of law. He persisted with questions concerning the nature of thermodynamics that I could not readily answer and was thereby indirectly responsible for the tenor of the present volume. Last, it is important to thank my immediate family, particularly my beloved wife, Trudy, for much patient understanding and for many sacrifices, without which the work could have been neither undertaken nor completed.
Honig July 1981
J.M.
Table of Contents
• Preface, Pages v-vi • Preface to the Second Edition, Page vii • Preface to the First Edition, Pages ix-x • Chapter 1 - Fundamentals, Pages 1-110 • Chapter 2 - Equilibrium in Ideal Systems, Pages 111-158 • Chapter 3 - Characterization of Nonideal Solutions, Pages 159-247 • Chapter 4 - Thermodynamic Properties of Electrolytes, Pages 249-285 • Chapter 5 - Thermodynamic Properties of Materials in Externally Applied Fields, Pages 287-346 • Chapter 6 - Irreversible Thermodynamics, Pages 347-396 • Chapter 7 - Critical Phenomena, Pages 397-423 • Chapter 8 - A Final Speculation About Ultimate Temperatures—A Fourth Law of Thermodynamics?, Pages 425-426 • Chapter 9 - Mathematical Proof of the Carathéodory Theorem and Resulting Interpretations; derivation of the Debye-Hückel Equation, Pages 427-444 • Index, Pages 445-452
Chapter 1 Fundamentals
1.0
Introductory Remarks
Thermodynamics is an overarching discipline in the sense that all physical phenomena can be described and analyzed in terms of a general macroscopic framework that contains parameters which may be determined by experiment. It is truly remarkable that with the minimal input of only four postulates, and by the systematic application of mathematical logic, a whole cornucopia of results can be produced for use in the interpretation of experiments and for predictive purposes in a wide variety of physical disciplines. In this book an attempt will be made to stress both the systematics that provides the cornucopia as well as the need to establish a close link between theory and experiment. The exposition will encompass mostly the areas of physical chemistry and parts of physics, but the principles expounded below should enable the reader to apply the thermodynamic discipline and methodology to other areas of research. The fundamental concepts are introduced in the form of four basic laws. The procedure is reasonably axiomatic, so that one can deal with (i) the concept of temperature without initially having to refer to heat flow; (ii) the definition of energy as a function of state, and the definition of heat flow as a deficit function; (iii) the introduction of the entropy function that does not depend on a generalization of the performance characteristics of heat engines. A comparison of the entropy changes for a given process carried out reversibly and irreversibly is then used to obtain a variety of fundamental results. This in a natural manner leads to the introduction of several functions of state; considerable emphasis is placed on systematically exploiting their mathematical properties. The important concept of homogeneous functions of degree one is then introduced and is used to analyze the properties of open systems. This chapter ends with a study of stability problems. The reader should investigate not only the details of the derivations but also the internal structure of every presentation, and should note the benefits of a systematic approach to the study of thermodynamic principles.
2
1. FUNDAMENTALS
1.1
Introductory Definitions
Before launching into the concepts of thermodynamics it is important to agree on the meaning of several basic terms. These are discussed below:
System. A region in space that is identified as a useful object of study and set apart from the remainder of the cosmos for that purpose.
Surroundings. Regions immediately outside and contiguous to the system. Boundaries. Partitions separating a system from its surroundings. Comments. It is very important to set boundaries properly and to distinguish appropriately between system and surroundings. Failure to do so can lead to erroneous conclusions. Boundaries may be real, such as walls or partitions, or may be conceptual, such as geometric surfaces. Body. The content of a specific system. Comments. To be amenable to thermodynamic treatment an actual body must be of adequate size, such that normal fluctuations in its properties are minute compared to their average values, and such that physical measurements do not significantly perturb the properties of the body. The volume of such a body must generally be at least of the order of 10-15 cm-3. Homogeneous vs. heterogeneous systems. Homogeneous systems are uniform in properties over their entire volume. Otherwise such systems are heterogeneous. Subsystem. A portion of the region of a system singled out for special study. Isolated systems. Systems totally unresponsive to any changes that occur in the surroundings, or that have no surroundings. 1 Closed (open) systems. Systems in which transfer of matter to or from the surroundings cannot (can) occur. A closed system may nevertheless be subject to manipulation through external agents such as electric or magnetic fields. Permeable (semipermeable)boundaries. Boundaries that enclose an open system (that permit passage of certain chemical species while excluding other species). Adiabatic systems. Systems whose properties are unaffected when their surroundings are heated or cooled. Comment. A more appropriate definition for an adiabatic system will be provided in Section 1.7. Phase. A physically and chemically homogeneous macroscopic region in a system. Comment. In a system there may exist several sub-regions in distinct states of aggregation or composition. Diathermic boundaries. Boundaries that do not permit matter to be exchanged between systems and their surroundings but that permit changes to take place in properties of the system by heating or cooling of the surroundings. Thermodynamic properties. Physical or chemical attributes that specify the characteristic properties of a system.
INTRODUCTORY DEFINITIONS
3
Thermodynamic equilibrium. A state of a system where, as a necessary condition, none of the properties under study changes with time.
Comments. It is not a simple matter to determine whether a system is at equilibrium. One method described later involves subjecting the system to some process that takes the system away from its quiescent state under a set of prescribed conditions. If, on release of the constraint, the response is out of proportion to such a process and if the system does not then return to its original state it could not have been at equilibrium. If the system does return to its initial state without incurring any other changes in the universe then it is said to be in equilibrium with respect to the tests that have been conducted. It may be very difficult to decide whether equilibrium prevails in systems prone to very sluggish processes. In such situations one attempts to establish a relaxation time over which significant changes in properties are detectable when the system is externally perturbed. It is generally agreed that equilibrium prevails when no changes can be detected over intervals very large compared to the relaxation time. 2 Reservoir. A source or sink used to exchange matter with, or through appropriate interactions, to alter the properties of an attached system. A reservoir is assumed to be of such immense size that its properties remain essentially unaltered during any interactions with the system. Thermodynamic coordinates, variables, degrees of freedom. All three are used to designate linearly independent experimental macroscopic variables that are required to characterize the state of a system. Comments. A minimum number of such variables is required to describe systems at equilibrium; their values do not depend on the manner in which the equilibrium state is reached. Intensive (extensive)variables. Variables whose values are independent of (depend on) the size and/or quantity of matter contained in a system under study. State space, configuration space, phase space. An abstract space spanned by coordinate axes, one for each thermodynamic coordinate, on which a given point represents the numerical value of that coordinate. A hyperspace is then formed by a mutually orthogonal disposition of these axes about a common origin. Representative point. A point in phase space that corresponds to the state or characteristics of the system for which the state space was constructed. Path. A succession of states traversed by a system in passing from a given initial to a given final state. Quasistatic process. One that involves passage through a large succession of very closely spaced equilibrium states. In this process the surroundings may be altered such that on the return path to the original system configuration the universe ends up in a different state. Reversible process. One whose path may be exactly reversed though a succession of very closely spaced equilibrium states, such that on reversal of the path both the system and its surroundings are restored to their original state.
4
1. FUNDAMENTALS
Comments. The distinction between quasistatic and reversible processes may be illustrated by considering the magnetization of a paramagnetic and of a ferromagnetic material. In a paramagnet the gradual application of a magnetic field slowly magnetizes the sample, which can then be completely demagnetized by slowly eliminating the magnetic field--this process is reversible. A ferromagnet can be slowly magnetized by gradual application of a magnetic field, but on gradual elimination of the field the material remains partially magnetized. Here, a succession of equilibrium states, followed by the reverse, leaves the system in an altered configuration. This is an example of a quasistatic process. Reversible processes are necessarily quasistatic, but the reverse may not hold. Steady state processes. Processes which do not alter the state of a system but do change the surroundings. Comments. At equilibrium no changes in properties occur with time either in the system or in its surroundings. However, under steady state conditions inputs and outputs of the system remain in balance so that the properties of the system are not altered, but changes do occur in the surroundings as a result of such processes. 3 A more scientific characterization is provided in Chapter 6. Number of Independent Components. The least number of chemically distinct species whose mole numbers must be specified to prepare a particular phase. Comments. Due account must be taken of any prevailing chemical equilibria since in such cases the concentrations of the various participating species cannot all be independently altered. The number of independent components may then be determined from the number of distinct chemical compounds present in the system minus the number of chemical equations that specify their interactions. This matter is taken up in Section 2.1. Number of Degrees of Freedom. The number of state variables that can be altered independently and arbitrarily, within limits, without changing the number of phases within the system. Before proceeding it is taken for granted that the reader has an intuitive understanding of the concept of mass and volume. Much of the subsequent discussion will initially based on these concepts. REMARKS AND QUERIES 1.1.1. The universe is an excellent paradigm of an isolated and closed system. Ordinarily, events occurring at astronomical time scales may be ignored in the consideration of physical and chemical processes occurring in the laboratory. 1.1.2. As an example of problems involving long time scales consider the reaction of hydrogen and oxygen in a balloon at room temperature. The fact that there seems to be no detectable change in the concentration of either constituent over many months does not mean that the system is equilibrated: insertion of platinum black as a catalyst leads to a measurable rate of formation of water, and heating the balloon with a torch leads to a violent reaction.
THE ZEROTH LAW OF THERMODYNAMICS
5
1.1.3. As an example consider the passage of current from a battery through a conductor. At a steady state the average electron density in any section of the material remains invariant; also, the initial rise in temperature due to Joule heating stops when the rate of heat generation is exactly compensated for by the radiation of heat into the atmosphere. Thus, under steady state conditions the material properties of the conductor during this process do not change with time, but the surroundings are altered: the battery runs down and the air is heated up. 1.1.4. Is it appropriate to classify a definition as being correct or incorrect? Conventional or unconventional? Complete or incomplete? Consistent or inconsistent? 1.1.5. Cite conditions under which a proffered definition may be rejected.
1.2
The Zeroth Law of Thermodynamics
We are now ready to study of thermodynamic principles by enunciating general laws that govern the operation of all possible processes in the universe. Therein lies the power of Thermodynamics. The first of these principles involves the socalled Zeroth Law of Thermodynamics which asserts that
Two bodies in equilibrium with a third are in equilibrium with each other. The seemingly obvious statement of transitive properties of the Zeroth Law has important ramifications: at the outset consider only the case where the properties of a system can be specified in terms of a prevailing pressure P and volume V. We follow the procedure advocated by Buchdahl. 1 Consider then two systems 1 and 2 that are initially isolated; we use pressures P1 and P2 (forces per unit area) to deform their volumes 1/1 and V2. We may have to make thermal or other adjustments that will permit physically possible pairs of pressure-volume variables (P1, 1/1) and (P2, V2) to be independently established in the two systems. Let these two units now be joined and equilibrated; it is an experience of mankind that under these conditions only three of the four variables can be independently altered. This restriction is expressed by a mathematical relation r 1/1, P2, V2) = 0, where f13 is an appropriate mathematical function that provides the interrelation between the indicated variables; its detailed form is not of interest at this point. We now repeat the process for joining system 1 to a new system 3 characterized by the pressure-volume variables P3, V3. By the same line of argument, after setting up the compound system one encounters a second interrelation of the form flz(P1, V1, P3, V3) = 0. Lastly, on joining systems 2 and 3 one must set up a third mathematical restriction of the form/31 (P2, V2, P3, 1/3) = 0. If equilibrium prevails after each combination, we require for consistency with the Zeroth Law that system 3 remain unaltered in its union with either system 1 or 2; this allows us to solve for P3 in the functions f12 and fll to write: P3 = (Pl (P2, g2, V3) -q52 (P1, 1/1, ~ ) , from which we construct the following difference function:
~l(P2, V2, V3)- q52(P1, V1, V3)~ ~.(P1, V1, P2, V2, V3)=0.
(1.2.1)
6
1. FUNDAMENTALS
This unfortunately generates a glaring inconsistency: the functional dependence of )~ on V3 is absent from the function t3 - 0 ; also, it makes no sense to have to refer to system 3 when combining systems 1 and 2. To resolve this difficulty we introduce a new requirement: namely, we demand that V3 occur in the functions q~l and @2 in such a manner that V3 is eliminated when the difference between q~l and q~2 is constructed. This is achieved in most general terms by requiting that the functions q~ assume the forms q~l = f2(P2, V2)h(V3) + q(V3) and ~2 = fi (P1, Vi)h(V3) + q(V3), where h and q are arbitrary functions of V3. Substitution of the last two equations in Eq. (1.2.1) then leads to the relation fl (Pi, V1)= f2(P2, V2).
(1.2.2a)
Similarly, consistent with the Zeroth Law, we obtain
fl (P1, V1)= f3(P3, V3).
(1.2.2b)
These results are sensible: reference is now made only to variables appropriate to each distinct system. Eqs. (1.2.2a) and (1.2.2b) thus characterize the equilibration condition. Moreover, this process permits us to select system 1 as a reference standard to infer whether system 2 and 3 are in mutual equilibrium, according as system 1 is or is not changed when coming in contact with first with system 2 and then with system 3.
1.2.1
Empirical Temperatures and Equations of State
Clearly, the functional interrelation specified by fl (P1, V1) is of great significance; it therefore makes sense to provide for this function a special symbol, rl, as a short-hand notation: more generally, we write ri = f / ( P i, Vi), where ri is called the empirical temperature (function). The relationship ri = fi (P i, ~ ) is known as an equation of state for system i. We can thus specify the empirical temperature of system i by measuring its pressure and volume, and inserting these parameters into the chosen function j5 (P i, Vi) that obviously will have to be specified before ri can be quantified. Variables other than pressure and volume can be used equally well to construct different sets of empirical temperatures. The selection of such variables depends on the characteristics of the system that is being investigated. Clearly, for each different choice one can anticipate a distinct temperature scale; this then presents a problem of unifying all different possible temperature s c a l e s ~ a matter that we will resolve below. The labeling of ri as a 'temperature' is obviously meant to link the physical properties to human sensory perceptions of 'hotness levels'. Minimally one should ask that the temperature increase monotonically with increasing hotness levels. This requires a quantification scheme that utilizes a convenient equation of state of a suitable material as an indicator of hotness. An enormous multitude of
THE ZEROTH LAW OF THERMODYNAMICS
7
indicators have been used for this purpose, such as: measurements of volume of ideal gases, of resistivity of solids, of viscosity of liquids, of spectral emissivity of solids, of thermoelectric voltages, of sound velocity, and of magnetic susceptibility. The methods of measurement and the experimental precautions required to attain reproducible results are listed in special compendia. 2 Each type of measurement provides a different response to increases in hotness levels. To obtain a reasonable quantification scheme it is sensible to pick from all conceivable temperature measurements one that is of particular simplicity and utility, that is linear in the correlation with, and that can be used over a large range, of hotness levels. One system well suited for present purposes is the so-called ideal gas. It has been known for over three centuries that gases approaching this type of behavior closely obey the relation P V - - c o n s t a n t (Boyle's Law) when the gas is kept at a constant empirical temperature in a range well above the conditions where it can be liquefied. We therefore adopt the product P V as a direct measure of r. Over the years He gas has been chosen as the medium p a r excellence for such measurements; equipment used for this purpose is known as a gas thermometer. 1.2.2
A n A b s o l u t e T e m p e r a t u r e Scale
In many temperature determinations one maintains the gas thermometer at a fixed low pressure. A useful quantification scheme is the so-called Celsius scale that assigns the values r - 0 ~ (this was the original intent, but nowadays the standard value is r - 0 . 0 1 ~ and r - 100~ to the He gas thermometer which is at equilibrium respectively with water containing ice and with water equilibrated with steam maintained at 1 bar. 3 Let V, V0, and V]00 be the volume of He gas at a fixed, low pressure at temperatures r, 0 ~ and 100 ~ respectively; then r is to be specified by "r- 100
V - Vo
Vloo- Vo
= 100
v
V~oo- Vo
-
100
Vo
V~oo- Vo
= T + To.
(1.2.3)
The intercept of the straight line generated by the two fixed points (that is, the value of r at which V would vanish on that straight line if He could be maintained as an ideal gas down to extremely low temperatures 4) is found to be To -- -IOOVo/(V]oo - Vo) - -273.15 ~ This suggests a natural lower limit to temperature, namely, the point where V vanishes. It also suggests a shift of scale whereby the quantity T - 100 V/(V] 00 - Vo) is the fundamental entity of interest. Adoption of this method leads an absolute scale for quantifying hotness levels; we construct a thermodynamic temperature scale T(K) - r ( ~ + 273.15, where K stands for kelvins as the temperature unit. This still maintains the desired proportionality between absolute temperature and measured volumes of He at fixed, low pressures. Clearly, one could have used changes in pressure of an ideal gas as a measure of empirical temperature, so long as the pressure remained in a range where ideality
8
1. FUNDAMENTALS
can be maintained. In that case, at constant volume, one would set up the scale as (with an obvious subscript notation) r-
100
P-
Po
= 100
PlOO- Po
P PlOO- Po
- 100
Po
-- T + To. (1.2.4)
P l o o - Po
Here the intercept of the straight line generated occurs at the value where P would vanish if the ideal gas state could be maintained at all temperatures. Again, setting up a linear absolute temperature scales through pressure measurements at constant volume is an obvious next step. 1.2.3
Use of Triple Point
A difficulty with the above scheme is that measurements carried out with various actual gases that approach ideal behavior will lead to slightly different results. A better absolute standard is provided by the so-called triple point of water. As we shall see later, 3 the coexistence conditions of water in the solid, liquid, and vapor state can occur only under a set of precisely controlled, invariant conditions determined by the physical characteristics of H20. These conditions are completely reproducible all over the world. For consistency with the above absolute temperature scheme the triple point of water is assigned a temperature T (triple point of H20) = 273.16 K = Tt. Then any other absolute temperature is determined through the proportionality T = (P/Pt)" 273.16, where P is the pressure at T and Pt is the pressure measured for He in equilibrium with water at its triple point. The use of gas thermometers tends to be awkward. One can use more convenient methods by calibrating any other thermometer against the He gas thermometer in the range of hotness levels where these two overlap. The new system is so chosen that its range of operation extends over temperatures where use of the gas thermometer is awkward or impossible. Such a calibrated unit may be used in turn to calibrate yet another system over their common range of hotness levels; the third system is selected so as to extend the measurements over another range of hotness levels that remained inaccessible to the original equipment. The process can clearly be systematically extended. Details of the procedure are beyond the purview of the present discussion. Readers are urged to consult the many existing sources of information in the literature. 2 ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 1.2.1. H.A. Buchdahl, The Concepts of Classical Thermodynamics, Cambridge University Press, 1966, Chapter 2. 1.2.2. A very comprehensive account may be found in Temperature, its Measurement and Control in Science and Industry, American Institute of Physics, New York, which is a multiauthor, multivolume compendium.
MATHEMATICAL APPARATUS
9
1.2.3. In Section 2.2 it will be shown that when two phases of a pure material (e.g., water and steam) are maintained in equilibrium at a fixed pressure, the temperature of the system remains fixed. Similarly, three such phases (e.g., ice, water, and steam) can coexist only at one particular pressure and temperature, termed the triple point. 1.2.4. According to the Third Law of Thermodynamics, taken up later, the ideal gas concept fails at lowest achievable temperatures; no material remains in the gaseous state for all possible r. This fact, however, does not deter us from carrying out an extrapolation that indicates at what value of r the volume would vanish if an ideal gas could be maintained at all temperatures.
1.3
Mathematical
Apparatus
In subsequent sections we will continually apply various mathematical procedures that are listed below. These operations must be properly mastered before one can undertake the unified description of thermodynamic principles. 1.3.1
Transformation of Variables
The method of transformation of variables in three dimensions, described here, can readily be generalized to higher dimensions. Let F (x, y, z) be some function of three independent variables (in thermodynamics these usually are not spatial coordinates, but thermodynamic coordinates), each of which may be rewritten in terms of three different independent variables u, v, w that happen to be more convenient for the description of phenomena of interest. We write these interrelations as x - x(u, v, w), y - y(u, v, w), and z - z(u, v, w), so that the original function becomes F ( x , y, z ) -
F [ x ( u , v, w), y(u, v, w), z(u, v, w)]
(1.3.1)
= G(u, v, w) -- F(u, v, w).
In passing from (x, y, z) to (u, v, w), the function F assumes a different functional form, G. However, to avoid profusion of symbols and confusion in interpretation, it is customary to retain the same symbol for both functional dependences; for, the physical interpretation remains unaltered by any transformation in coordinate representation. On differentiation of Eq. (1.3.1) with respect to u one obtains through the chain rule of differentiation: --
+
v,w
y,z
v,w
77. x,z
+
,
v,w
x,y
v,w
(1.3.2) with similar expressions for (OF~Or) and (OF/Ow). We now determine the differential of F as dE--
OF ~x
dx + y,z
dy + x,z
~
de, x,y
(1.3.3)
10
1. FUNDAMENTALS
which we next abbreviate as
dF - X dx -t- Y dy + Z dz,
(1.3.4)
with X - (OF/Ox)y,z, Y - (OF/Oy)x,z, and Z - (OF/Oz)x,y. On replacing the partial F derivatives in Eq. (1.3.2) with X, Y, and Z one obtains OF
--X V,W
(0x)(0 t ~uu
+ Y
U,W
+Z I),W
(0zt ~uu
"
(1.3.5)
U,W
Thus, it appears as if on differentiating F in Eq. (1.3.4) with respect to u to obtain Eq. (1.3.5) we had left the coefficients X, Y, Z unaltered and 'differentiated' solely dx, dy, dz. However, Eq. (1.3.5) is equivalent to Eq. (1.3.2), which resolves the apparent puzzle. 1.3.2
Partial Derivatives with Different Constraints
A special case of the above arises when we set u - x and restrict ourselves to two independent variables, discarding z and w. Eq. (1.3.2) then reduces to
Oy
(~X )v-- (~X )y--[- (~y )x(-~X)v.
(1.3.6)
The above is very useful if the experimental determination of (OF/Ox)v at constant v is complicated, but the specification of (OF/Ox)y can be carried through more conveniently, provided the partial derivatives (OF/Oy)x and (Oy/Ox)v can also be readily determined, as is frequently the case in thermodynamics. Often one deals with situations where a particular function of two variables is a constant, C, so that F(x, y) -- C. This immediately shows that x and y cannot be independent: we may solve for y = y(x) to write dy dx, so that
-- (Oy/Ox)F
d F--
-~x
dx+
y
~y
dy-
x
~x
dx+
-~y
y
x
-~x
dx-O.
F
(1.3.7)
This leads to another result of importance, namely
Oy)
-~X F
__(OF/Ox)Y
~
(OF/ay)x
(1.3 , 8)
Here a partial derivative that may be hard to evaluate with F fixed is rewritten in terms of partial derivatives involving F that may be much easier to determine. Many cases of this type will be encountered later. We next solve F (x, y) -- C for x = x (y); by the same steps this leads to the result
Ox ) _ _ (OF/Oy)x -~Y F (OF/Ox)y
(1.3.9) ~
MATHEMATICAL APPARATUS
11
Comparison of these two expressions yields the
(Ox/Oy)F --
Reciprocal Theorem:
(Oy/OX)F
,
(1.3.10)
which is extremely useful when it is difficult to deal with a function y expressed in terms of x, but when it is easy to handle x expressed in terms of y. Note the requirement that F be held fixed; otherwise the expression may not apply. Matters get more complicated when F is a function of three independent variables and when F(x, y, z) -- C, a constant; now only two of the variables are independent. Let us solve for x = x(y, z) or y = y(x, z), so that
dx -
()-~yOx z,Fdy +
() Oy d y - -~x
z,F
(Oy) dx + -~z
dz, y ,F
(1.3.11a)
dz.
(1.3.1 lb)
x,F
Substitute the second expression into the first and collect terms to find
Ox Ox -~Z Y,F] dz. [1-- (-O--fiy)z,F (~XX)z,F] dX -- [ (-O-fiy)z,F (~Z )x,F -~-(OX)
(1.3.12)
On account of (1.3.10) the left-hand side vanishes, and the right-hand side may be rewritten, such that one obtains the Reciprocity Theorem
(0;) (0;)(0z) z, F
-- - 1 ,
x ,F -~X y,F
(1.3.13)
which is useful in specialty applications encountered later. Yet another relation is found by requiring F (x, y) = C and expressing x and y in terms of two other independent variables, u and v. Set x = x(u, v) and y = y(u, v); by the chain rule of differentiation
v
y
v,F
x
v,F
(1.3.14)
which may be rearranged as
(Oy/OU)v,F (Ox/Ou)v,F
(OF/Ox)y (aF/Oy)x
(1.3.15)
On now introducing (1.3.8) one obtains finally
Oy ) _ (Oy/OU)v,F -~X F (OX/OU)v,F
~
(1.3 16) 9
12
1. FUNDAMENTALS
which is useful in cases where the derivative on the left is not readily evaluatedl but those on the fight are easily determined. The above operations are so frequently used that it is advisable to memorize them. 1.3.3
Euler's Theorem of Homogeneous Functions
A theorem of great importance in thermodynamics is based on a thought experiment: consider a system containing n l moles of species 1, n2 moles of species 2, . . . , n r moles of species r. On doubling all moles numbers at constant pressure and temperature the volume of this system also doubles. In thermodynamics we encounter many quantities with the property that a change in all variables (as opposed to the parameters; see below) by a given factor also changes the particular function by this same factor. We examine the consequences of imposing such a requirement. Given a function F ( x l , x 2 , . . . , Xr), we write ! ! ! d F -- F 1 dxl + F 2 dx2 + . . . + F r dnr, where the primes indicate partial derivatives. Now change all independent variables proportionally to their original values, using a common factor d)~, so that dxi -- xi d)~ for all i, and require a proportional change in F, such that d F -- F d)~. Then F d)~ -- ~--~i F{xi d)~, from which we obtain F
F(xl,x2 . . . . . Xr) -- i ~ l X i ( OF
(1.3.17) Xjr
This relationship is known as Euler's Theorem f o r Homogeneous Functions of Degree One. However, in addition to the dependence on the xi the function F may also display a dependence on parameters such as pressure P or temperature T that, of course, remains unaffected by the above manipulations. 1.3.4
Exact Differentials
For a system characterized by thermodynamic variables x l, have many occasions to examine differentials such as dL =_ Z
Xi(xl,x2,... ,xr)dxi,
X2, ...,
Xr, we will
(1.3.18)
i where the d symbol is used whenever the increment in L and hence, the integral f d L , depends on the specific path, described by the xi, by which the system proceeds from a given initial to a given final state. Functions of this type are awkward and ought, if possible, to be avoided: as the path is altered so is the differential and so is the related integral. In thermodynamics great emphasis is therefore placed on setting up and dealing with a special class of functions that depend solely on the initial and final states of the system and that are independent
MATHEMATICAL APPARATUS
13
of the particular path by which the system proceeds. The differential of such a function R (x l, x2 . . . . . Xr) then becomes
dR-i=1
dxi -= Z Xidxi. xJ~=i i
(1.3.19)
Note in particular that all the coefficients Xi a r e obtained by differentiation of the single function R (x l, x2 . . . . , Xr). Such a mathematical entity is known as a function of state of the system and its differential d R is known as an exact differential. Functions of state R that are useful in thermodynamics are subject to the following requirements: 1. R is a real, single-valued, analytic function of the thermodynamic variables that characterize the state of a system. 1 2. The difference in R for a system in two different states depends solely on these two states. 3. The change in R for a cyclic process is identically zero. 4. The quantity dR is an exact differential which has the form of Eq. (1.3.19).
1.3.5
Elements of Vector Analysis
We briefly review here several elements of vector analysis that are needed later; for a better and more complete description the reader is referred to textbooks of mathematics. Examples of vectors are the position vector r -- ix + j y + kz, where i, j , k are unit vectors that coincide with the mutually orthogonal x, y, z axes of the coordinate system, and x, y, z are the corresponding coordinates. A vector in this space is designated by A - i Ax § j a y § kAz, where the A)~ are the components of the A vector along the three axes. We will also need the gradient vector operator, defined by V ----iO/Ox + jO/Oy + kO/Oz. The following vector manipulations are of relevance. (i) The dot product of two vectors,
A. B-
IAIIB[ sinOAB,
(1.3.20)
where IA] is the magnitude of the vector A, and where OAB is the angle between the vectors in the plane defined by them. Clearly, by definition, the dot product results in the formation of a scalar. Since i, j , k are orthonormal it follows that i 9i - j - j - k . k - 1 and ex. e u - 0, with )~ 7~ # and ex - i, j , k. Thus the dot product of two vectors is given by A . B - (iAx + j A y + kAz) . (iBx + j B y + kBz)
= Ax Bx + AyBy + Az Bz.
(1.3.21)
14
1. FUNDAMENTALS
It is easily checked that the operation is commutative, A 9B = B 9A and distrib-
utive, A . (B + C) = A . B + A . C. Another operation of importance involves the gradient vector dot product:
v .A =
i- x + j- y +
9 (lAx + j A y + kAz)
OAx OAy OA z ~. Ox +--~-y + Oz
(1.3.22)
This operation is called the divergence; it measures the degree to which the vector A spreads out from any given point. For, along a given direction x a change in distance dx entails a change of the vector from lAx(x) to i Ax(x + dx) i[Ax(x) + (OAx/Ox)dx], in which the partial derivative in the last term specifies the rate of increase or decrease of the vector along the positive x direction. Eq. (1.3.22) is then clearly the three-dimensional counterpart. (ii) Another useful entity is the cross product of two vectors as defined by (1.3.23)
A x B - h l A I I B I sin0AS.
Here h is the unit vector perpendicular to the plane defined by A and B. It points in the direction specified by the fight-hand rule. In light of their definitions the orthonormal unit vectors satisfy the relations ex x ex - 0, and (i x j ) - k - ( j x i), ( j x k) - i - - ( k x j ) , (k x i) - j - - ( i x k). With these rules it is readily checked that A x B - (iAx + jAy + kAz) x (i Bx + j By nt- kBz) -- ( B x A) and that this cross product may be recast in determinantal form as
AxB=
i Ax Bx
j
Ay By
k Az Bz
(1.3.24)
The cross product obeys anticommutation rules. Similar rules apply to the gradient vector; we obtain
VxA=
i O/Ox
Ax
j k O / O y O/Oz
Ay
(1.3.25a)
Az
which may be expanded as
V x A-
i l/ OAz \ Oy
OAy) (OAx Oz + J Oz
OAz) (OAy Ox + k Ox
~Ax) Oy "
(1.3.25b)
The operation (1.3.25) is termed the curl; the name is appropriate because the curl of a vector that points in a fixed direction vanishes, whereas a vector that curves around a fixed axis has a large associated value of the curl.
MATHEMATICAL APPARATUS
15
Table 1.3.1 Selected vector operations A . (B x C) = B . (C x A ) = C . (A x B ) A x (B x C) = B ( A . C) - C ( A . B )
V(fg) = fVg + gV f V . ( f a ) = f ( V . A) + a . ( V / ) V x(fa)--f(VxA)-ax(Vf)
V.(AxB)=B.(VxA)-A.(V V • (V f ) = 0 V• xA)=VV.A-V.VA V.(V •
xB)
(a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) (g) (h) (i)
Selected integral operations if
V~
.
dr - O ( f ) - r
Gradient Theorem
f f f v v ' a d 3 r - - - ffsA~'d2r
Gauss'Theorem
f fs(V X A) . d2r = f A . dr Stokes'Theorem
O) (k)
(1)
Remarks. A, B, C are vector quantities, h is the outer unit normal to a surface element, g, f , r are scalar quantities. The integral in (j) is a line integral connecting an initial to a final state; the ones to the left and right of (k) extend over the volume and over the surface of a body; the ones to the left and right of (1) extend over the surface and form a closed loop on the surface of a body.
Lastly, we cite the relation for the volume of a parallelepiped which generally may be nonorthogonal. If A, B, C represent the vectors of length A, B, C along the tilted x, y, z axes of the parallelepiped, then the volume within this figure is given by
V=(AxB).C.
(1.3.25c)
We call attention to several more involved vector operations listed in Table 1.3.1. These may be verified by writing out both sides of each equation in component form. 1.3.6
First Order Differential Equations
We shall have occasion to deal with a first order differential equation of the form
dy(x) -F R(x)y(x)= X(x). dx
(1.3.26)
16
1. FUNDAMENTALS
Its solution, as may be checked by direct substitution, is given by
+el,
y(x)-•215
(1.3.27a)
where
exp[fdxR(x)],
•
(1.3.27b)
and where C is an arbitrary constant. 1.3.7
Integrals with Variable Limits
On occasion we will encounter cases where differentials or derivatives must be taken of integrals with variable limits. Three such situations are of importance: (i) The first of these is of the type (V is the volume of the system)
P-
-- - ~
OV
dx dy dz f (x, y, z; V, Y)
d d J-L~2
r
,
(1.3.28)
in which the x, y, z coordinates of physical length remain within the limits - L / 2 <~x, y, z <~L/2, where L is the length of a cube of volume V -- L 3, equivalent to the volume V of the actual system. 3 Y is a parameter in the problem, such as temperature, pressure, or magnetic field. Thus, the limits of the integral as well as the integrand itself are variable. 4 Therefore, one cannot simply interchange the integral and differential operators. We handle this case by introducing fractional coordinates ~ - x / L , r/-- y / L , ( -- z / L , such that - 1/2 ~< ~, r/, ( ~< 1/2 and d x dy dz - L3d~ do dr, whence 0
= (3V2/3)_ 1 0
00L
OV = OL OV
1
0
OL = 3L 2 OL"
(1.3.29)
Thus, we obtain
1 [ rrr,,2 P =
3L 2 OL a a ,!-1/2
d~ d~ d f L 3 f (~, rl, (; L, Y)
] y
.
(1.3.30)
Since the limits on the integral are now fixed we may carry out the differentiation under the integral sign to find
P -- -
fff
l/2
d~ d~Td( f ( ~ , JT, (; L, Y)
d d ,I-1/2
L ~f[1/2 "3 ] J] ,!-1/2
d~ drl d (
Of(~, rl, (; L Y) OL
(1.3.31) Y
MATHEMATICAL APPARATUS
17
Now transform back to the original variables:
P=
dx dy dz f (x y z" V, Y)
L3
'
l
fff
L/2
3L 2 a a a - L ~ 2
,,
dx dy dz ( O f ) -~
dV v dL'
(1.3 32) "
which may be put in the final form
l fv dx dy dz f (x, y, z; V, Y) -
P =
V
fv
dx dy dz-::-:_. o vOf Y"
. (1.333)
(ii) Another operation of interest is of the type 81
8
[ i.
=_ - ~ Z
dx dy dz g(x, y, z; Y, Z) (Y,Z)
J,
(1.3.34)
Z
in which the integration limits themselves depend on the variable of the differentiation. Again, this is handled by the method of fractional coordinates: we write
(,,) -~
,;;r l,.
--
z
d~ dr/d(L 3 g(~, r/, (; Y, Z)
O~Y a J a-l12 --
fff
z
l/2
O
d~ d q d (
J J ,I--1/2
--
fv
[Vg(~ ri (; Y, Z)] -~
'
'
Z
Og(x, y, z; Y, Z) OY z
dxdydz
+ fvdxdydz[g(x'Y'z;Y'Z)](OV(Y'Z)) V(Y,Z) OY
. (1.3.35) z
(iii) Lastly, in later discussion it will be necessary to consider the differential of the integral f v d3r(M" H), that is encountered in the study of magnetic effects. We treat this quantity as shown below:
d fvdxdydz(M 9 H) --
d f i r 1/2 d~
d~ d((M.
H) V
d d 3-1/2
fff
l/2
d~ dJTd( d [ V ( M . H)]
d d 3-1/2
-
dx dy dz -~ d[V (M. H)]
f M.n_ d3r
~/
dV+
+ f d3r M . d H. Jv
d3rH.dM (1.3.36)
18
1. FUNDAMENTALS
REMARKS 1.3.1. At isolated singular points such functions are allowed to be nonanalytic. 1.3.2. A physical rationalization of line (k) runs as follows. Consider the one dimensional flow along x and compare the mass m per unit volume of fluid at x and at x 4- dx. Then set m(x 4- dx) = m(x) 4- (Om/Ox)dx, where the second term indicates the net accumulation or depletion of m as the material traverses the distance dx. In three dimensions this generalizes to (Om/Ox)dx + (Om/Oy)dy + (Om/Oz)dz = V m 9d 3r. The integral on the left of line (k) thus represents the net accumulation of material within the volume, generated through the balance between influx and outflow. The right side represents the additive effect of summing the transfer of mass patchwise across the entire surface. The operation h 9dZr ensures that only the transfer of m in the direction orthogonal to each patch of size dZr is credited to the total accumulation. The minus sign is needed since ~ points in the direction away from the interior of the body. Stokes' theorem, line (1) is not as readily visualized: basically, the curl operation corresponds to a 'swirl' of material generated by rotating matter flows. In the interior of the body all the swirls cancel out, but the parts of the swirls on the surface can be added up to form any continuous closed path that one wishes to draw. 1.3.3. A simple method for checking the results shown below is to assume that f is independent of spatial coordinates. In that case the triple integral of Eq. (1.3.28) may be replaced by V f ( V , Y), so that we obtain P = - ( O ( V f ) / O V)r; the remaining equations simplify correspondingly. 1.3.4. Similar strategies are employed when the solid body is not a simple cube though the mathematical manipulations become more cumbersome. Alternatively, one approximates the actual shape through a juxtaposition of cubes of appropriate sizes that fit into the body, and one then sums the contributions. In any event, the final outcome is not affected by the shape of the body.
1.4
Thermodynamic Forces
Before discussing the concept of work we briefly take up the concept of thermodynamic force, as presented by Redlich. 1 Consider again two systems 1 and 2 that are initially isolated, whose deformation coordinates are represented respectively by the vectors X l and x2. In this state these coordinates can be varied independently and at will. We now allow the systems to interact, so that certain of the variables can no longer be altered independently; this defines the interaction. Suppose that coordinates Xr and Xs are changed simultaneously as a result of the interaction. This may be formally expressed by the function g (Xr, Xs) -- O. Nothing prevents us from replacing Xr and Xs by monotonically varying functions yr(Xr) and ys(Xs) respectively; this merely alters the mathematical description of the interaction. This freedom permits us to select coordinates Xr and Xs such that their changes obey the relation
dxr + dxs = O.
(1.4.1)
ELEMENTS OF WORK
19
When previously isolated systems interact in this manner there are three possible outcomes: Xr increases while Xs diminishes, Xs increases while Xr decreases, or xr and Xs remain unchanged; in the latter case the systems are at equilibrium with respect to the postulated interaction. We now consider a property fr (Xr) for system r and fs (Xs) for system s, for which three possible outcomes are anticipated: fs > fr
corresponds to
dxr > 0, dxs < 0,
(1.4.2a)
f~ < fr
corresponds to
dxr < 0, dxs > 0,
(1.4.2b)
fs = fr
corresponds to
dxr = dxs = 0.
(1.4.2c)
The functions f are arbitrary in the sense that all classes of functions that change monotonically with a particular deformation coordinate x are equally acceptable; we select those that are convenient in their application. These selected functions are known as generalized forces. In this terminology Xr and Xs are altered because the systems interact through the operation of forces that change the state of the systems. In general, body r may be regarded as the surroundings and body s, as the system. Quantitative measurements require the calibration of interactions against an accepted standard force appropriate to the measurement under study, in consonance with the physical laws that prescribe the interactions. When fr and f~ differ, processes take place in each system until the equilibrium state f~ -- fr is reached, at which point xr and Xs become stationary. The fact that processes come to a halt does not mean that all forces have ceased to exist; rather, they balance each other out. The interplay between forces and their effects will be explored in the next section. At this point we may introduce a better definition for quasi-static or reversible processes. These are changes in a system that result from an imbalance of only those forces that maintain a system at equilibrium. REFERENCE 1.4.1. O. Redlich, Rev. Mod. Phys. 40 (1968) 556.
1.5 1.5.1
Elements of Work General Statements
We now begin the mathematical description of performance of work by the surroundings on a system. As will be seen later, work performance can usually be measured or calculated, and represents a useful means for specifying (portions of) several functions of state. Work is performed by application of a thermodynamic force fi (see preceding section) of type i that results in an infinitesimal change dxi of the relevant thermodynamic coordinate in the system. In general, fi depends
20
1. FUNDAMENTALS
on Xi and is not necessarily collinear with it. Both these matters are handled by writing the element of work performance in vectorial form as d W = f ( x i ) 9 d x i , where the d symbol serves as a reminder that this increment in general is pathdependent, so that the summation of these increments generally changes as the path is altered. Where more than one type of work is performed the contributions must be summed. Matters are simplified by rendering the applied force small enough to incur reversible displacements in x i , so as to avoid the turbulent or dissipative conditions. Otherwise a whole host of extrathermodynamic variables are needed to describe the process. However, this is not a necessary requirement; we will occasionally consider cases where the applied force exceeds that needed for guaranteeing reversibility. The total work of type i performed on the system in taking it from state X l to x2 is specified by Wi --
fxx2f i " d x i ,
(1.5.1)
1
which quantity is path-dependent, unless, as explained below, a function q9 can be found such that one may set f = -Vqg. 1.5.2
Pressure-Volume Work
We now examine several different types of work performance under quasistatic conditions. We begin with the compression of gas in a cylinder of constant cross section A by a piston (cf. Fig. 1.5.1), for which the applied pressure at each stage is only incrementally larger than the opposing gas pressure within the cylinder. With a displacement - d x along the direction of the external force the element of
Pgas
Pa
Fig. 1.5.1. Compression of a gas in a cylinder of constant cross sectional area A. The volume of the gas is diminished by application of an external pressure.
ELEMENTS OF WORK
21
compressive work is then specified by f d W -- f ( - d x ) - - = A dx - - P d V. A
(1.5.2)
As a specific simple example let the contents of the cylinder be an ideal gas, so that we may write P - n R T / V . Then W - - f v V f ( n R T / V ) d V ; assuming infinitesimally slow compression, during which a constant temperature may be maintained, we find
W -- - ( n R T )
din V - n R T l n ( ~ / V f ) ,
(1.5.3a)
which is positive since Vi > VU. For an irregularly shaped, isotropic object we let P d a represent the force acting uniformly on cross section element d a of the boundary (see Fig. 1.5.2) which recedes inward by a distance - d x relative to the applied pressure. The element of work is given by
dW - - f
P d a dx - - P (
f
dcr) dx - - P dV,
(1.5.3b)
as before. However, if the mechanical characteristics of the body are anisotropic the procedure becomes more complicated, as demonstrated in a later section. One may generalize on the above by considering the sudden application of an externally applied constant pressure P0 in excess of the internal pressure P. The do
\; Fig. 1.5.2. Compression of an irregularly shaped object by application of an external pressure that diminishes the volume.
22
1. FUNDAMENTALS
rf
10
dl
Fig. 1.5.3. Stretching of a rod by an externally applied force. The length of the bar is increased in this process.
rapid contraction of the system is accompanied by all sorts of turbulent phenomena that cannot be described in terms of simple thermodynamic principles. However, this is immaterial: when equilibrium is established the internal and external pressures balance out, and the work that has been performed is given by the quantity - P o ( V f - Vi) that involves the difference in final vs initial volumes of the system. The point to be emphasized is that one must formulate W in terms of the externally applied pressure. This is a nice illustration of a case where problems arising from the occurrence of irreversible processes have been circumvented. Other situations will be taken up later. When a thin rod of cross section A and length l, initially at equilibrium, is stretched or compressed by application of a force f (Fig. 1.5.3) it is conventional to introduce a stress cr =_ f / A that induces a strain e =_ d l / l and to set cr > 0, d l > 0 when the rod is under tension and er < 0, d l < 0 under compresion. Note that in either case work is performed on the rod. In the elastic limit when the work element is carried out reversibly, d W -- Voo" d e ,
(1.5.4)
where V0 is the volume of the unstretched rod. Again, this result must be generalized, as is done later, for anisotropic materials. 1.5.3
Work in Gravitational Fields
Work done against gravity may be handled in two distinct ways. The first is to consider a material with n moles of gram atomic mass M being lifted through a height d z ; the element of work done on the system is dW - Mgn dz,
(1.5.5a)
where g is the gravitational constant. The nature of the material is not altered in this procedure; only its potential energy is changed. This should be contrasted with a process of incrementing the mass of the body by adding d n moles to it at height z (relative to a standard height, such as sea level). The work element is now given by dW - Mgz dn,
(1.5.5b)
ELEMENTS OF WORK
23
whereby both the constitution of the system, as well as its potential energy, have been changed. Which of these two descriptions is used depends on the process under consideration. 1.5.4
Work in Electrostatic Fields
A similar situation prevails for a charge q subjected to an electrostatic potential q~. If the latter is changed in the amount dq~ the work involved is dW = q d ~ ; no change is encountered in the thermodynamic deformation coordinates. However, if an element of charge dq is taken from infinity and placed in a location at the electrostatic potential q~, then dW = ~ dq. Here the thermodynamic coordinates as well as the potential energies are altered. This latter formulation requires generalization. We consider the potential to be a function of position: q~ = q~(r), at location r, where the charge density is given by p(r). We now increment the charge d3rp(r) in volume element d3r at that location by the amount dq - d3r dp(r). Then the element of work for bringing the charge increment from infinity to location r is given by d 3 r ~ ( r ) d p ( r ) . The work increment involving a body of volume V then reads dW - f v d3r ~ ( r ) d p ( r ) . Next, we introduce Maxwell's equation V 97~ = 47rp(r), where p(r) is now the free charge density at location r, i.e., a charge adjustable by external means and not intrinsic to the medium under study. Here ~9 is the electric displacement vector, which is related to the electric field vector E, by ~9 -- E + 47r79, in which 79 is the polarization density vector. Thus, dp -- (4zr)-IV 9dZ~. Introduce line (d) of Table 1.3.1, so that we may set
dW - f d3r (4zr)-' (V. diD)~(r) - (4yr)-'
f
d3r [ V . ~ d'V -- d ' V . V~b],
where the integration must be carried out over the entire region of space over which 7~ is present. Gauss' theorem, line (k) of Table 1.3.1, may now be applied to the first of these two integrals to obtain -(47r) -1 f dZr 9h ~ d~9, where h is the outer unit normal vector perpendicular to a given surface element, and where the integration extends over any arbitrary surface enveloping regions in which the electric displacement field exists. This boundary may therefore be extended to enormously remote regions where the surface flux vanishes. The first integral may thus be neglected. In the second we introduce the electric field vector in terms of the electrostatic potential as E = - V q~, so that finally the work element takes the form
dW - (4re)- 1 f d 3r E . d~9.
(1.5.6a)
While appropriate, this expression is not really useful because the integration must be extended over all space. In Section 1.6 we provide an alternative, more
24
1. FUNDAMENTALS
useful formulation, namely, d W - -(47r) -1 f v d3r 7:'. dEo,
(1.5.6b)
in which E0 is the applied electric field before introduction of the sample. The polarization vector 7:' vanishes outside the sample; hence, the integration may be restricted to the sample volume V. Conventionally one writes 7:' = oeg, where oe is the electric susceptibility; alternatively, we set 7:' --ot0g0. Here we have not taken into account the work required to energize the vacuum in setting up the field g0. This quantity, which enters the derivations of Section 1.6 is normally of no interest. 1.5.5
Work in Magnetic Fields
The work incurred in subjecting material to a magnetic field 7-r may be handled through the expression d W = .Ad . d7-r where .A4 is the magnetic moment vector per unit volume. In this formulation the thermodynamic coordinates remain unchanged; only the potential energy of the system is altered. This expression, analogous to the lifting of a given mass of material against a gravitational field, is normally not of interest. As an alternative formulation we introduce a local current density, J (r) that responds to a steady vector potential ,A(r). The associated work element is d W - ( l / c ) f v d3r J " d.A, where c is the velocity of light. We next introduce Maxwell's relation V x 7-r -- (47r/c)J, which applies when the electric displacement vector is independent of time and when J is the free current density. Thus, d W - (47r) -1 f d3r d . A . (V x 7-r On using line (g) of Table 1.3.1, the work increment reads d W -- (47c) -1
f
d3r [7-r (V x d.A) + V . (7-r x d.A)].
The integration extends over the entire region where 7-r is present. The second integral, involving a divergence, is rewritten by application of Gauss' theorem, wherein 7-r x d,A is evaluated over an arbitrary surface that may be drawn infinitely far away. This portion of the integral may be discarded, leaving us with the first part that involves V x d,A --- dB, where/3 is the magnetic induction vector. We thus obtain d W - (4rr) -1 f d 3r 7-[,. d113.
(1.5.7a)
Again, this formulation is awkward because the integral extends over all space and because the independent variable is 13, which includes the response of the material to the applied magnetic field 7-r which alone is subject to experimental control.
ELEMENTS OF WORK
25
For most practical applications it is more convenient to use the expression, derived in Section 1.6. (1.5.7b)
dW - f v d3r 7-Lo . d a d ,
where A,4 = (47r) -1 (B - 7-~), and 7"r is the applied magnetic field prior to the introduction of the sample. The integration involves only the volume of the specimen, since .A/I vanishes outside its confines. We have not included the work required to set up the magnetic field in vacuum prior to insertion of the sample. Also, one conventionally writes .AA --- X 7-r where X is the magnetic susceptibility; alternatively, .A4 = X07"r One should note the sign difference in comparing Eq. (1.5.6b) and (1.5.7b). 1.5.6
Two-Dimensional
Films
Consider a thin film that is mounted on a wire frame (Fig. 1.5.4) and that is stretched by length dx through the application of a force f ; the work element is given by dW = f dx. The area increase is d A = 21 dx, where 1 is the length of the frame perpendicular to the applied force; the factor 2 arises because there is a film on both sides of the wire frame. Thus, dW = ( f / 2 1 ) d A ; conventionally one defines the surface tension by Y =- f /21, whence
dW--ydA.
1.5.7
Elongation
(1.5.8)
of S p r i n g s
We furnish one example to illustrate further the concept of work. Consider a mass M attached to the end of a weightless spring, as shown in Fig. 1.5.5. Initially the system of (mass + spring) is at equilibrium when no net force acts of the
() O I I I I i I I I I
rf
() O dx
Fig. 1.5.4. Setup for expanding a film stretched over a wire frame.
26
1. FUNDAMENTALS
Fig. 1.5.5. Schematic diagram depicting a massless spring with an attached mass point.
system: the spring is extended to its normal length x0 and the mass point is stationary. Now apply a force F that elastically extends the spring to length x > x0; assuming that H o o k e ' s L a w holds, the applied force is specified by F -- k ( x - xo), where k represents the force constant of the spring. Under contraction F points in the direction opposite to that shown, so that x < x0. Let the force F -- Fs be applied quasistatically, so that it barely exceeds the internal force of the spring at each stage of the process; then the velocity v of the mass point is essentially zero. The work carried out on the system in this process is given by W --
fxxl Fs d x
- k
ixxl(x -
0
xo) d x ,
(1.5.9a)
0
where x l is the extension of the spring at the conclusion of the process. The work performed on the system is thus specified by
w-5l k ( x l
- x0) 2
(1.5.9b)
if k is independent of x. The energy increment is stored as potential energy within the spring. Fs thus represents the minimum force needed to extend the spring. Now apply a force F in excess of the force Fs needed to extend the spring quasistatically. Then W -
fxxl Fs d x + ixxl( F 0
Fs) d x ,
(1.5.10a)
0
in which we treat the first term as before. The second contribution describes an acceleration of the mass point M arising from use of the excess applied force. The velocity of the mass point is v = v0 - 0 initially and reaches Vl when the spring is extended to length Xl. According to Newton's First Law, F - Fs -- M d Z x / d t 2 ; with v - d x / d t , ( d Z x / d t 2) d x - ( d v / d t ) v d t - v d r . Hence, the second term in Eq. (1.5.10a) becomes 89(v 2 - 0) and Eq. (1.5.10a) may be written as 1
w - - ~ l k ( x l - x0) 2 + ~ M v 2,
(1 ..5 10b)
ELEMENTS OF WORK
27
where the energy change now involves not just the potential energy contribution but a kinetic energy term as well. This example clearly illustrates that only in the case of quasistatic processes can one replace the applied external force by the opposing internal force of the system. In closing, one notes that in all cases the element of work is specified by the (dot) product of an intensive variable with the differential of an extensive variable. Where forces are superposed one must sum over distinct elements of work. This important conclusion is summarized by the mathematical formulation dW - Z
(1.5.11 a)
Yi d yi , i
in which the Yi represent appropriate generalized forces, and the Yi represent the corresponding displacements. Where appropriate, these quantities must be present in vectorial form.
1.5.8
Path-independent Line Integrals
We have noted that work, as expressed in the form Wi --
ix x2 f
(1.5.lib)
i "dxi,
1
depends on the manner in which the force varies with displacement, when x is changed from X l to x2; thus, generally, W is path-dependent. For obvious reasons it is not easy to develop general statements governing the properties of such quantities. One is thus led to seek out integrals that are actually independent of the path taken between the end points, quantities that were described in Section 1.3 as functions o f state. In the present context we now consider integrals (1.5.1 l b) which can be shown to depend solely on the end points. Such integrals vanish identically when x l = x2. For this purpose choose as a reference state the quantity x 1 -- 0 that is arbitrary but, once selected, not changeable. We may then introduce a function q~(x2) defined by
q5(X2) -- -- f0 x2 f(x)
(1.5.12)
.dx,
called a potentialfunction. It depends solely on the variable X2; the minus sign is introduced as a convention. Then, we can determine the potential difference as qO(x2) - qo ( x l ) -
-
fx X2f ( x ) 1
.dx -
fx X2[ V . 1
~(x)]dx.
(1.5.13)
28
1. FUNDAMENTALS
The fight hand is obtained through line (j) of Table 1.3.1; it involves the definition of the divergence symbol. Since the integrands must match we find that f -- - V ~ .
(1.5.14)
That is to say, the vector f and its three spatial components may actually be specified in terms of the gradient of a single scalar potential function 45. It is therefore simplest to determine the potential function first and then take the gradient to find the components of the force vector. This extraordinary property invites further exploration that illuminates the properties of functions of state. For this purpose we invoke Stokes' Theorem, line (1) of Table 1.3.1 in the form
f F . dx - f fs(V X F) . d2x,
(1.5.15)
where the left-hand side involves any closed boundary path that is located on a surface region. Any function of state F taken around a closed loop must vanish; the left-hand side is then equal to zero, so that the integrand on the fight vanishes as well; we then find that V
x F
-
0.
(1.5.16)
Thus, the three components of the function of state F are not independent: when Eq. (1.5.16) is expanded as shown in Eq. (1.3.25) one finds
OFx 3y
=
3 Fy 3x
,
OFz 3y
=
3 Fy 0z
,
3 Fz 0x
=
OFx 0z
,
(1.5.17)
showing that under the assumed conditions the function F is subject to stringent requirements. On finally setting F - - V q O taking F x - - O ~ / O x , F y - - O ~ / O y , Fz -- O ~ / 3 z , and invoking Eq. (1.5.17) we find that 02~/OxOy - 02~/3yOx - O , and similarly for the other components. Thus, the second order cross derivatives of the potential function taken in either order are the s a m e ~ a comforting result. One should note that the potential function specified by Eq. (1.5.12) is actually a mathematical construct reminiscent of the concept of potential energy, commonly encountered in elementary treatments. However, the two ideas should not be confused; the potential energy is often invoked because, as shown below, the integrand does arise in the development of the concept of energy. The potential qo, however, can be invoked only for line integrals that are independent of the path, i.e., that vanish when taken around a loop. QUERIES 1.5.1. It is stated that the element of work always involves an intensive and the differential of an extensive variable. Yet, in Eqs. (1.5.6) and (1.5.7) only intensive quantities seem to be present. How is this apparent contradiction resolved? 1.5.2. What changes in the analysis of the spring performance must be introduced when the spring itself has a nonzero mass?
THE ELEMENT OF WORK FOR A SYSTEM SUBJECTED TO ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS
1.6
29
The Element of Work for a System Subjected to Electromagnetic Fields
We now provide the derivation leading to Eqs. (1.5.6b) and (1.5.7b), beginning with the Maxwell equations 10B
V • E +
= 0,
c Ot 1 01)
V • 7"r
c Ot
=
(1.6.1a)
47rJf
.
c
(1.6.1b)
Here E, "/9, 7"r J f represent respectively the electric field, electric displacement, magnetic field, magnetic induction, and current density; c is the speed of light. Form the scalar product of Eq. (1.6. l a) with 7-r and of Eq. (1.6.1b) with E and subtract, to obtain 7-r
1 x E) - E . (V x H ) + -7-r
OB
c
~
019
1 -4- - g c
~t
4re = ---E. c
Jf.
(1.6.2)
Next, introduce the vector identity 7-r (V x E) - g . (V • 7"r - V 9 (g • 7-s line (f), Table 1.3.1, to obtain V . (E x 7-r
47r c
s
1 Jf +-"~ c
0/3
1 +-g.
"-~
0/)
c
~t
= 0.
(1.6.3)
f
Now integrate over all space. By Gauss' theorem, d3r V . (E • 7-s may be transformed into a surface integral enveloping the fields; the surface integration can be extended to infinitely remote boundaries where the fields ultimately vanish. This term therefore drops out, leaving -
f
l fd3r(E.dg+7-t.dt3).
d3r E,. J f dt - 4re
(1.6.4)
We rewrite the left-hand integrand in the form E . ] s - E . p i ~ s - [ p I E + ~ - ~ p I ~ I • t3] 9 ~ i - f L . ~ I ,
(1.6.5)
in which pf and v f are the free charge carrier density and velocity, respectively. On the fight we inserted the vector identity v f 9 (v f • 1~) - B . (v f • v f ) = O, which holds because the cross product v f • v f vanishes identically. Physically, this corresponds to the fact that a charged particle moving in a magnetic field does no work. The quantity in square brackets represents the Lorentz force density, designated by f L . We finally obtain ctw--fd3rE
9J f d t - - f d 3 r f L
.vfdt
I
1
i
_
_
[ d3r (E, d~D + 7-s dl3) 47r J 9
o
(1.6.6)
30
1. FUNDAMENTALS
as the increment of work. 1 We now follow Heine (1956) in taking note of the mathematical identity
E, . dZ) + 7-L . d13 - E,o . dl~o + 7"r d13o + (8,. d~Do - 1). dE, o) + ('k-Co. d B - 13o. dT-~) + (1)o. ds +
(13o. d7"r
- 8o" d ~ o )
- 7-~o. d B o ) + E . ( d l ) -
+ ('D - / ) o ) " dCo + B o . (dT'L - d7"r
dl)o) + (7-r - 7"r
d13. (1.6.7)
The subscripted vectors represent field variables arising from fixed charge and current distributions existing prior to insertion of the sample, and the remaining vectors represent corresponding quantities when the sample is inserted into the field. We then integrate over all space. In the absence of the sample we can also set B0 = 7-s and Z~0 = E0. The third term then becomes (E - ~9) 9dE0 = - 4 7 r 7 9 . dE0, and the integration may be restricted to the volume of the sample, since 79 vanishes elsewhere. The fourth term reads 7-r ( d B - d7-r = 47r(7-r 9d.A,4); here, the integration may be restricted to the sample volume, since elsewhere ,A,4 = 0. The fifth and sixth terms vanish automatically. When the integration is carried out each of the last four terms vanishes as well, on account of a vector theorem derived by Stratton. 2 This leaves
1 f d3r(E,o.dE, o + B o . d B o ) dW - 4re
f v d 3 r 7 9 . d E , o + fvd3rT-Co.d.AA.
(1.6.8) Here the first two integrals extend over all space and specify the work increment required to set up the electromagnetic field in free space; these quantities normally are of no interest. We thus concentrate on the remainder, which relate to the additional work involved in immersing the sample into the preexisting field. One should note the difference in sign between the third and fourth terms, and the nonsymmetric disposition of the field and response variables in these two integrals. REMARK AND REFERENCE 1.6.1. The sign convention requires a comment. Positive current proceeds in the direction of the electric field; hence, the dot product of the integrand is positive. On the other hand, the charges, flowing from a region of higher to lower potential, have lost energy, which is transferred (as work under isothermal conditions) to the surroundings. This process thus necessitates the minus sign in specifying the work performance. If the carriers are negatively charged then the sign of pf and that of v f are both reversed, so that the conclusion is still the same. 1.6.2. J.A. Stratton, Electromagnetic Theory, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1941, p. 111.
THE FIRST LAW OF THERMODYNAMICS
1.7 1.7.1
31
The First Law of Thermodynamics The First Law of Thermodynamics
We had noted earlier the advantage of adopting functions of state in describing thermodynamic processes, so as to avoid having to deal with path-dependent properties. For present purposes we achieve this aim by invoking an experience of mankind: the performance of work under adiabatic conditions, Wa, in taking a given system from a particular initial state {xi} = (Xl, x2 . . . . . X n ) i to a particular final state {x f } = (X 1, X2, . . . , X n ) f is independent of the type of work performed and is independent of the path taken in proceeding from {x i} to {x f }. We therefore assign this function of state a special name, the (internal) energy E, whose difference, A E = E f -- Ei = Wa, is specified by the amount of work of any kind performed while taking the system from state x i to state x f under adiabatic conditions. If now such a process is carried out under nonadiabatic conditions this situation no longer holds, which seems to impair the usefulness of the energy concept. However, other changes now also take place that were absent in the adiabatic process, so as to maintain the viability of the concept of energy. This experience of mankind gives rise to a new assertion, namely, the First Law of Thermodynamics:
For any process whatsoever there exists a function of state, called the internal energy, E, which depends solely on the initial and final thermodynamic coordinates of the system. Differences in this quantity may be determined by calculating or measuring the work performed adiabatically on the system for the process under study. In other words, corresponding to a given transformation of the system from state {xi } t o {Xf} there exists a unique energy difference A E = EU - - Ei that characterizes this change. Obviously, this assertion is not very useful until one knows how to determine the energy difference for all conceivable processes. To clarify the above concept a reader interested in a more mathematical introduction to the First Law is referred to Section 9.4. There the existence of such a function is derived as a necessary consequence from the existence of the linear representation of work performance as dW - Z i Yi dyi, Eq. (1.5.11 a). The above Law has important ramifications. In any nonadiabatic process the work performed, W, differs from Wa. Since now A E - W 7~ 0 it is expedient introduce a deficit function Q that restores the equality: we write Q - ( A E W) = 0, where Q is called the heat transfer. One must recognize that changes in energy of a system can only be brought about through interactions of the system with its surroundings; internal reconfigurations without changes in surroundings leave the energy function unaltered. Also, for all processes that connect the same initial and final states of the system
32
1. FUNDAMENTALS
A E remains unchanged, but it is the interactions between the system and its surroundings, specified by W and by Q, that depend on the process under consideration. Clearly, for an adiabatic process Q = 0; we henceforth take this to be a sufficient criterion for characterizing adiabatic conditions. Methods for determining Q experimentally will be described in later sections. Here we adopt the measurements of Wa as a method of preference to determine A E. If no adiabatic path exists to proceed from state i to state f one can generally find an intermediate state r such that by performance of work Wa~ and Wa" one can execute the adiabatic transformations i --+ r and r --+ f respectively. Let AEir, AErf, and AEif be the corresponding energy changes; then clearly A E i f = A E i r nt- A E r f -- Wta -+- W~a~ allows the desired energy change to be determined via separate measurements of Wa~ and Wa". We now write the First Law in the following mathematical form: A E = Q + W.
(1.7.1)
As noted earlier, Q and W represent two different manifestations of energy in transit across the boundaries of the system. They incur changes in the energy of the system but do not represent energies per se. Clearly, the energy of the system is increased by rendering Q > 0 and W > 0, in which case one states, by convention, that heat flows into the system and that work is performed on the system. Conversely, the energy is diminished by having Q < 0 and W < 0, in which case heat flows out of the system and work is done by the system. 1 Thus, though Q and W generally are not functions of state, their algebraic sum is. Also, it makes no sense to ask how much heat or work a given system contains, since only the internal energy properly characterizes the state of a given system (a nice analogy that clarifies this idea will be presented in the next section). Moreover, only a difference in energy can be uniquely determined; there is no such thing as 'the energy' of a system. This reflects the well-known fact that energies can be specified only to within an arbitrary constant that has no fundamental significance. 1.7.2
The First Law of Thermodynamics in Analytic Form
We now present the differential form of Eq. (1.7.1) as
dE = dQ + dW,
(1.7.2)
wherein the d symbol is used to emphasize that these infinitesimals are path dependent, whereas the infinitesimal d E is not. We can then broaden the concept of adiabatic processes; in these dQ = 0 for every infinitesimal stage of the process. Lastly, since energy is a function of state involving the thermodynamic coordinates x l, x2, . . . , Xn we can write its differential in the analytic form
n OE d E - - j ~ 1 OXj dxj. 9
(1.7.3)
THE FIRST LAW OF THERMODYNAMICS
33
A similar expression for Q and W is clearly inappropriate. Since these latter quantities represent energies in transit any process taking place totally within a given system does not change its energy. This immediately leads to the Law of Conservation of Energy as a corollary to the First Law. In an isolated system the energy is constant, no matter what processes occur within it. Such processes change the internal configuration of the isolated system but not its energy. It is of interest to note that the First Law may be set up on a more mathematical basis by adapting the so-called Carath6odory theorem to the differential Pfaffian form for work: dW = Z i Yidyi, Eq. (1.5.1 l a). As explicitly developed in Chapter 9, when adiabatic conditions are imposed the theorem, under the constraint dW -- O, necessitates the existence of an associated function of state that is constant under these conditions. 1.7.3
Examples Illustrating Problems in Defining Surroundings During Performance of Work
The foregoing calls for a more protracted discussion of the interchange of work and energy between a system and its surroundings. It is extraordinarily important in all changes of state brought about through the execution of work (i) to distinguish clearly between what constitutes the system, the surroundings, and the connecting link between them; (ii) to note that for the determination of work it is not necessary to be informed about the internal changes in the system when work is performed on it or by it; and (iii) to recognize that work performed on or by the system can be determined only after setting up a "work reservoir", completely external to the system under study, and operating in such a manner that the performance of work can be either readily measured or calculated. We illustrate the problems which arise by reference to Fig. 1.7.1, which depicts an enclosure S equipped with a movable piston P of mass Mp. The latter rests on release pins rl and r2; the container is also furnished with stops s l and s2 that arrest the downward motion of the piston under the action of the earth's gravitational field. Let the space in the enclosure be totally evacuated and let the release pins then be retracted; the piston is then accelerated through a vertical distance h, until arrested by the lower stops, s l and s2. The volume of the enclosure is thereby reduced from Vi to VU. Consider first the case where the system comprises the empty space and piston but excludes the walls. The work performed by the descent of the piston P through the height h is - M p g h , where g is the gravitational constant. The minus sign arises because on completion of the process the compound system has a lower potential energy than at the start. If, on the other hand, the system is restricted to the empty space no work has been done because the internal configuration of the space has remained unchanged. However, as regards the compound system, heat in the form of radiation crosses the boundaries of the system; for, the surrounding walls are heated through the friction of the moving cylinder and the stops are
34
1. FUNDAMENTALS
P ~r~
r2~
h
S
~]s1
.
.
$2C
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Fig. 1.7.1. Schematic diagram depicting a system S in an adiabatic enclosure that contains a movable piston P; r 1 a n d r 2 are retractable release pins, and Sl and s2 are stops that arrest the motion of the piston under the influence of a gravitational field.
deformed by its sudden arrest. Thus, the work performance shows up in the form of a heat transfer into the surrounding space. Next, let the container be filled with a gas at a pressure Pi sufficiently low that the released piston compresses the gas to pressure Pf when ultimately arrested by the stops; i.e., the pressure of the gas satisfies the relations Pi <~ P <~ Pf < Mpg/A, A being the cross-section of the piston. Let the system again exclude the walls. Contrary to popular misconceptions, the work performed on the compound system is still Mpgh, even though there now exists an opposing gas pressure P in the range Pi <~ P <~ PU. However, in the present situation the acceleration of piston P is lower than that prevailing in vacuum; at the same time the gas is now subject to convection, turbulence, and heating in the compression stage; also, the walls are heated, though to a lesser extent than before, by the friction of the moving piston and by its ultimate sudden deceleration. Clearly, even if the system is restricted to the gas alone, its internal coordinates are altered, and the energy of the gas is therefore altered. In this more restricted case the piston is part of the surroundings. Without detailed information it is impossible to ascertain how much of the work, during the descent of R is converted into an increase in energy of the gas, and how much appears as increased energy of the walls. For nonequilibrium situations this type of analysis would require the specification of a host of nonthermodynamic variables. However, as far as the ultimate equilibrium state is concerned, none of this matters; after the system has come to equilibrium,
THE FIRST LAW OF THERMODYNAMICS
35
the work performed by the compound system (P + G) is again A E = -Mpgh, regardless of how A E is partitioned between gas and walls. It is only in adiabatic processes that all of the work shows up as an increase in energy of the system that is comprised solely of the gas space. The potential energy change has been partially or fully converted as a higher energy state of the compressed gas. As the next experiment, let enough gas be admitted to the system to support the piston by virtue of the balancing relation Pg = Mpg/A. Now, add one grain of sand at a time to the top of the piston, thereby forcing P to move downward very slightly at each step against the increasing opposing gas pressure. In this case all frictional effects are negligible. Continue this process until the piston is gently nudged against the lower arrests. Here it is appropriate to consider the piston as part of the surroundings in equilibrium with the system that is comprised solely of the gas phase. Work in the amount g fo d(mz) has been performed on the system that does not include the cylinder; re(z) represents the mass of the piston-plus-sand which is present at the height z above the arrests. A new feature appears in this series of quasistatic steps: the applied external and resistive internal pressures essentially balance, and at each stage the gas is only infinitesimally removed from equilibrium. One may therefore introduce the equation of state of the gas P(T, V) and thereby evaluate both the work f P(T, V)dV and the energy increase of the system arising from this work performance; appropriate equations of state for this process are provided in later sections. On the other hand, if one takes the compound system to comprise both piston and gas the internal coordinates have been altered: energy in one form (as potential energy) has been transformed into energy of another type (described by the greater mass of the piston and by changed properties of the gas, as will be explained in Section 1.13). Further discussion of this matter will be deferred until the effects of external fields are explored in Chapter 5. Another instructive exercise consists in examining the free expansion of a gas, depicted in Fig. 1.7.2. The gas is initially confined to a space of volume VA, volume VB being totally evacuated. A hole of macroscopic dimensions is now opened in the diaphragm separating the two volumes; the gas ultimately occupies the total volume VA + VB. What is the work involved in this process? The answer is not absolutely straightforward: If the system is taken with boundaries encompassing only the volume VA, complications arise because in the expansion process the internal coordinates of the system so defined are altered by the motion of gas through the hole. With respect to volume VA one now deals with an open system, with new ground rules that will be taken up in Section 1.20. If, on the other hand, the system encompasses the total volume VA + VB plus the inside portion of the walls, no work is executed by the process. To understand this point it is important to restrict considerations to the system in its original equilibrium state and in the final equilibrium state of the adiabatic enclosure. There has been no change in surroundings, nor has any work reservoir been needed
36
1. FUNDAMENTALS
Fig. 1.7.2. Schematic diagram illustrating the free expansion of a gas initially confined to compartment A. On opening the partition the gas then expands into compartment B.
to run the process. Put differently, the process of expansion has taken place totally within the completely isolated compound system A + B; no heat or work crosses the boundaries. Once again, there is no need to worry about the complex interactions as the jets of expanding gases exert forces on the container walls first in one direction as they emerge from chamber A and then in other directions as they strike the various walls of chamber B. The final state of the adiabatic system is that in which it has reached a totally quiescent state; note that A E for the process of reaching this final state from the initial state, vanishes. Nevertheless, clearly 'something has happened' that calls for a description which the energy function is unable to provide. The requisite analysis is furnished by the entropy state function that will be introduced below in due course. The adiabatic enclosures mentioned above are ideal partitions which separate regions of thermodynamic interest from the remainder of the universe; in particular, no heat transfer of any type can occur across such boundaries. The walls of the container are in intimate contact with the gas which is being compressed but changes in its internal coordinates cannot be communicated to the remainder of the universe. Thus, quite generally, in calculating work performance, one must start with the initial equilibration state and end with the final equilibration state. The fact that the system passes through intermediate nonequilibrium stages, wherein not all of the alterations in potential energy of the piston are communicated to the gas, does not matter: in determining functions of state of a system the details of the intervening processes are irrelevant in thermodynamic analyses based on equilibrium states.
THE FIRST LAW OF THERMODYNAMICS AS A PARABLE
37
The above examples illustrate the necessity of dealing appropriately with the concept of work and with the placement of boundaries of a system. Concerning the former, one must distinguish carefully between work and other perturbations that affect the system or the state of the surroundings, one must deal with a system at equilibrium before a process is started and after it is completed, and the work involved must be calculable or measurable by standard methods. The placement of boundaries must be such that no frictional or other dissipative effects occur in its immediate vicinity or across the boundary; regions in which such phenomena take place must be clearly included either in the system or else in the surroundings. One should note again that changes in the specification of the boundaries may totally alter the specification of work that accompanies a given process. REMARKS AND QUERIES 1.7.1. In many texts and papers, following historic precedent, the First Law has been written in the form A E -- Q - W. Readers are cautioned to note carefully which formulation is used by any given author. Obviously, the convention for W employed in this text must everywhere be replaced by - W if the above convention is employed, wherein W < 0 and W > 0 represent work done on or by the system respectively. In modern presentations the usage in the present text is the preferred one. 1.7.2. Discuss the relevance of the Law of Conservation of Energy to the operation of perpetual motion machines. 1.7.3. Consider the explosive reaction when a mixture of hydrogen and oxygen is ignited by a spark, developed by equipment located internally in the system. If the system is totally isolated there is supposedly no change in its energy in such a violent process. Yet 'something' clearly has happened. Aside from the spark, what is the source for this process (i.e., where did the explosive 'energy' come from?), and what are the results of this process (i.e., what has happened to the explosive 'energy' liberated in this process)? What can you conclude from the fact that there seems to be a problem in the thermodynamic description of some processes: whereas a remarkable change in constitution of the system has taken place, the energy function of state of the system presumably has remained invariant.
1.8
The First Law of Thermodynamics as a Parable
Callen 1 has provided an interpretation of the First Law of Thermodynamics in terms of a parable that bears repeating. A certain person owns a rectangular swimming pool; he allows water to enter or leave through an inlet and outlet and daily compares the height of the water level with the amount of water that has flowed through the water meters attached to the inlet and outlet. In general the owner notes no detailed correlation between the water meter readings and the change in water level in the pool, but he notes that on rainy days
38
1. FUNDAMENTALS
the pool contains more than the expected amount, and on very dry days less water is present than anticipated. So the owner is led to cover the pool with a tarpaulin. At that point the owner finds that indeed the change in water level can be balanced precisely with the rates of water passage through the inlet and outlet. The analogy with the energy of a system should be clear. The covered pool is the analogue of an adiabatic system; changes in water levels correspond to energy changes. Water flowing through the inlet and outlet corresponds to positive and negative work, respectively. When the tarpaulin is removed the water added through rainfall or diminished by evaporation corresponds to heat influx and outflow. In these circumstances the bookkeeping requires that water gained through rainfall or lost through evaporation be taken into consideration when tracking changes in water level. Notice finally, that the liquid in the pool is just water; one cannot differentiate between liquid that entered or left through the faucets, as compared to water that was accumulated or lost through rainfall or evaporation. This should render more understandable earlier statements that heat and work transfers represent energy in transit across boundaries, and that they cannot be identified as pieces of energy within the system. All parables, being analogies, are to some extent misleading. Chief among the problems is the fact that, unlike water, heat is not a conserved quantity. However, this should not deter readers from pondering the lessons of this very nice tale. REFERENCE
1.8.1. H.B. Callen, Thermodynamics, Wiley, New York, 1960. 1.9
The Second Law of Thermodynamics
We begin here the discussion of the Second Law of Thermodynamics. This law has been enunciated in many different forms, the most prominent being the formulations by Kelvin and by Planck. These will be presented later as consequences of the approach derived below. 1 Undoubtedly, the most elegant statement of this Law was provided by Carathdodory in the following form:
In every neighborhood of a representative point of system in phase space there exist neighboring points that cannot be reached through any adiabatic process. The linking of this statement to consequences involving physical, chemical, cosmological, biological, or related processes requires a certain degree of mathematical sophistication and skill. Interested readers are encouraged to refer to a variety of sources, where these matters are discussed in detail. 2 This approach is important in the mathematically rigorous development of the subject matter. However, its presentation at this stage unnecessarily complicates the fundamental issues that should be emphasized. Hence, the material has been relegated to a
THE SECOND LAW OF THERMODYNAMICS
39
separate chapter at the end of the book. Those interested in the formal approach should examine the derivations after reading through the end of the current section. We develop instead a shortcut for the Second Law along the following lines: Just as we were able to link the performance of work under adiabatic conditions to the existence of a function of state, the energy, so we will postulate that the transfer of heat under reversible conditions is related to another functions of state, termed the empirical entropy, symbolized by s (or, later, the metrical entropy, S), which will then found to be useful to characterize various processes. In short, it is claimed as part of the Second Law of Thermodynamics that
A reversible incremental transfer of heat, dr Q, between a given system and its surroundings is related to a new incremental function of state, termed the empirical entropy, ds, through an integrating denominator, )~, whose physical significance is to be established later The above statement permits the Second Law to be expressed mathematically as
dr Q /)~ = ds.
(1.9.1)
The important point here is that under the above conditions one can dispense with path-dependent quantities. The identification of )~ is among the very compelling logical presentations of abstract reasoning. Namely, we examine the process of combining two different systems A and B into a composite system C. Let the heats transferred reversibly from the surroundings to the system in an infinitesimal process be designated by dr Q a and dr Qb for the component parts, and dr Qc for the isolated and internally equilibrated compound system; dr Q a -k- dr Qb = dr Qc. According to the Second Law, then d s c _ )~a dsa +
-s
dsb.
(1.9.2)
To proceed with the identification of )~ let the deformation coordinates of A and B be given by x l, x2 . . . . . Xn-1, t and Yl, Y2, . . . , Ym-1, t respectively, where t is the common empirical temperature of the compound system. Mathematically, we can then 'solve' for Xn-1 in terms of Xl, x2, . . . , Xn-2, t, Sa and for Ym-1 in terms of Yl, Y2 . . . . , Ym-2, t, Sb. We now assert the following: [1] Sc must be independent of X l , X 2 . . . . . X n - 2 , Yl, Y 2 , . . . , Ym-2, t. If this were not so Eq. (1.9.2) would then necessarily contain terms involving dxl, d x 2 , . . . , dym-2, dt, analogous to Eq. (1.3.9) or (1.7.3) for the differential forms of the energy E expressed as an analytic function of the coordinates {xi }. [2] The ratios )~a/)~c and )~b/)~c cannot depend on these variables; otherwise statement [ 1] would be contradicted.
40
1. FUNDAMENTALS
[3] )~c cannot depend on Y l , Y2 . . . . , Ym-2; for, if it did, then )~a in Eq. (1.9.2) would have to depend on these same coordinates in such a manner as to cancel out from the ratio ~.a/)~c, for consistency with statement [2] and [1]. However, )~a cannot possibly depend on the y coordinates appropriate to system B. By the same reasoning ~.c must be independent of x l, x2, . . . , Xn-2. [4] Furthermore, )~a cannot depend on x l, X2,..., X n - 2 , and )~b cannot depend on yl, y2, . . . , Ym-2. For, according to [3] these variables are missing from ~.c whence the ratios )~a/)~c and )~b/)~c must also be free of these variables, to remain consistent with [1 ], [2], [3]. However, this argument does not apply to t, which is common to A, B, and C. [5] As a consequence of [1]-[4] the functions )~a, ~+, and )~c can involve at most the variables (Sa, t), (sb, t), and (Sa, sb, t), respectively. [6] The functional dependences mentioned in [5] must have the form ~ - a - qga(sa)T(t), )~b -- qgb(sb)T(t), )~c -- gOc(Sa, s b ) T ( t ) , in which T ( t ) is a common though perfectly arbitrary function of the empirical temperature t; this function cancels from the ratios )~a/)~c and ~+/)~c in Eq. (1.9.2), in consonance with requirement [2]. [7] In summary, we find that dr Qa - T(t)qga(Sa) dsa - T ( t ) dSa,
dr Qb - T (t)qgb(sb) dsb -- T (t) dSb, dr Qc - T (t)qgc(Sa, Sb) dsc -- T (t) dSc,
(1.9.3)
where S in the differential form d S = go(s)ds is termed the metrical entropy. As described earlier, one can select any arbitrary function for T(t); we thus take T to be identical with the thermodynamic temperature scale introduced in Section 1.2. We show in Section 1.13 that it is this particular choice that corresponds to all possible empirical temperature scales that are monotonic in hotness levels. Moreover, equilibrium conditions have been assumed throughout, witness the fact that a limited number of well defined, equilibrium thermodynamic variables xi or Yi were introduced to characterize the properties of each subsystem. To preserve these all processes must be executed reversibly, as indicated by the subscript r. We are thus led to the fundamental result d S - dr Q / T.
(1.9.4)
The Second Law contains one other fundamental assertion: The entropy o f the final state f o r a process occurring in an isolated system is never less than that o f the initial state.
Implied in the above statement is the concept that processes in isolated systems are not subject to experimental control and therefore are spontaneous. Such
THE SECOND LAW OF THERMODYNAMICS
41
processes continue until equilibrium is established, at which point the entropy of the system is at a maximum, consistent with the properties of the system in its final state. The above statement also applies to adiabatically isolated systems, in which case one deals with processes for which the entropy of the system increases in the absence of any heat transfer to or from the surroundings. One should carefully note that it is possible to decrease the entropy of a system through appropriate interactions with the surroundings, but in that event there must occur elsewhere in the universe a compensating process such that the total entropy of the system plus the surroundings does increase. An important feature, already implicit in earlier discussions, is the fact that in an irreversible change one need to demand only that the system remain equilibrated at the beginning and end of the process. As far as functions of state are concerned it is immaterial that the changes of the system during an irreversible process cannot be described by a limited number of thermodynamic variables. As long as one deals with functions of state their change in an irreversible process may always be calculated by setting up a reversible process that brings the system from the same initial to the same final state. 1.9.1
Final Comments
We call attention to the mathematical construction in Chapter 9: when the transfer of heat assumes the linear form d Q = ~-~i Xi dxi Carath6odory's theorem necessitates the existence of a function of state that is fixed under adiabatic conditions, and whose change is tied to the transfer of heat under reversible conditions. We can now combine the First and Second Laws as follows: when only mechanical work is incurred a n d all p r o c e s s e s are c a r r i e d out reversibly we may write d E = dr Q + dr W - T d S - P d V .
(1.9.5)
This is the fundamental starting point for many subsequent thermodynamic operations. We will later deal with cases where processes are executed irreversibly. The concept of increasing entropy of a system may be linked to increasing disorder within the system. This important topic is beyond the purview of classical thermodynamics; readers are urged to consult an extensive literature dealing with this subject. NOTES AND QUERIES 1.9.1 The Kelvin and Planck statements (see Section 1.10) deal with the impossibility of operating thermal engines under certain prescribed conditions; from these assumptions the Second Law may then be deduced. There is no logical objection to this procedure, but it does seem somewhat unsatisfactory to base a universally applicable Law on principles pertaining to the operation of heat engines. The reverse
42
1. FUNDAMENTALS
procedure, outlined in Section 1.10 does provide what appears to be a better alternative; here the cyclic operation of heat engines is derived as a consequence of the Second Law. 1.9.2. We follow here the presentation provided by H.A. Buchdahl, The Concepts of Classical Thermodynamics, Cambridge University Press, 1966, Chapters 5, 6. Readers interested in a somewhat more detailed exposition of Carathrodory's approach and in the introduction of the thermodynamic temperature concept may also consult Chapter 9, where it was placed so as not to interrupt the current derivation. In retrospect it seems to be more direct to start with the formulation of the Second Law adopted here rather than working with the more elegant theory developed by Carathrodory. 1.9.3. An adiabatic enclosure is filled with supercooled water and then allowed to stand; in due time ice is observed to form. Obviously, the process is spontaneous, yet there is a decrease in overall order, hence, a reduction in entropy. How can this be reconciled with the statement that the entropy of an isolated system can only increase? 1.9.4. Is a process for which dS = 0 necessarily adiabatic? Explain your reasoning.
1.10
1.10.1
Cyclic Processes in Relation to Reversibility and Irreversibility. C a r n o t Efficiency Cyclic Processes
Considerations of cyclic processes constitute a very powerful tool in final deductions based on the Second Law. Consider two points in configuration space that are infinitesimally close to one another, as represented by 1 and 2 in Fig. 1.10.1. Choose a particular quasistatic process that takes a given system from state 1 2 I
r
Xl
o
\ i
~'
~..~
u
....
1
X2
Fig. 1.10.1. Illustration of a reversible path (solid curve) connecting states 1 and 2 and of an irreversible path (dashed curve) connecting states 2 and 1. The dashed path involves coordinates that fall outside the domain of the indicated configuration space.
CYCLIC PROCESSES IN RELATION TO REVERSIBILITY AND IRREVERSIBILITY
43
to state 2; let the heat exchange between system and surroundings be given as dr Q 1~ 2 (in Exercise 1.10.2 we ask whether it matters if this quantity is negative or positive). Select a second, irreversible path that effects the same 1 --+ 2 change and that involves a heat exchange di Q l~2. This latter path is dashed on the diagram: being an irreversible process, the path lies outside the phase space appropriate to quasistatic processes. By the First Law, dr Q 1--+2 _ d E 1-->2 _ dr W 1--->2, and di Q l ~ 2 _ dE1-->2 _ di W 1-->2, so that di Q 1--->2 - d r Q 1--->2 - d r W 1--->2 - di W 1--->2.
(1.10.1)
Note that the energy differentials have canceled out; being functions of state, they are the same for both processes. The differences in Eq. (1.10.1) cannot vanish. If they did the reversible and irreversible paths would have to coincide, because d Q and d W depend on the chosen paths. This, however, would lead to a contradiction of terms. Thus, the algebraic sums in (1.10.1) must be either positive or negative. Suppose first that di Q 1-->2 _ dr Q 1-->2 ~ di Q 1~ 2 + dr Q2--->1 > 0; then, by Eq. (1.10.1), the work involved in completing the cycle by going from 1 to 2 and back to 1 is given by dr W 1-+2 - di W 1--+2 - - - ( d i W 1--+2 + dr W 2--> 1) > 0. That is to say: in executing a cycle we have expended (i.e., put into the system) an amount of heat di Q1--->2 -Jr-dr Q2--+ 1 > 0 and have obtained from the system (i.e., the system has performed) an exactly equal amount of work di W 1~2 -Jr- dr W 2--+ 1 < O. No other changes have occurred in the universe. Suppose next that di Ql-+2 _ dr Q1--->2 ~ di Q1--->2 _+_dr Q2-+ 1 < o, so that by Eq. (1.10.1), dr W 1-+2 - di W 1~2 = - ( d i W ~-->2 + dr W 2-> 1) < 0. A similar line of reasoning now shows that in going around the cycle once we have expended (i.e., put into the system) an amount of work di W 1~ 2 _jr_dr W 2--> 1 > 0 and we have obtained from the system (i.e., the system has transferred to its surroundings) an exactly equal amount of heat di Q1--->2 -k- dr Q2---> 1 < 0. No other changes have occurred in the universe. Which of these alternatives do we choose? Let us simplify the notation by setting di Q 1~ 2 ~ di Q and dr Q 1-->2 _~ T d S 1~2 =_ T dS. One must now consider the possibilities (a) di Q - T d S > O, i.e., T d S < di Q, or (b) di Q - T d S < 0, i.e., T d S > di Q. The present discussion must apply to all situations, including the special case where the irreversible process is carried out adiabatically. Under alternative (b) one finds that T dS > 0 for the adiabatically isolated system, and no contradictions are uncovered. Under alternative (a) one would require T d S < 0 for an irreversible, adiabatic process, and by the corollary to the Second Law, discussed in Section 1.9, this possibility must be ruled out. We thus claim that diQ < TdS-drQ.
(1.10.2a)
This result is eminently sensible: if we take the system from state 1 to state 2 by a reversible sequence of steps the entropy change must be matched by a heat
44
1. FUNDAMENTALS
transfer of magnitude dr Q~ T. If the same change is achieved by an irreversible operation, part of the overall entropy change is generated by processes that cannot be controlled experimentally through manipulation of the surroundings. The amount of heat required to match the remaining entropy change will be correspondingly smaller. Also, from alternative (b) we find that dr
W 1---~2<
di W 1--+2,
(1 .10.2b)
di Q~ T.
(1.10.3)
and for any finite changes 82 -- S1 >
fl
We shall discuss these inequalities in much greater detail in Section 1.12. Equation (1.10.3) must be used with care, for it leaves open the question as to what temperature is to be employed in conjunction with any irreversible process that takes the system from state 1 to state 2. In the present case, as in most treatments, Eq. (1.10.3) is used solely in situations where the system under study is intimately thermally anchored to a reservoir under conditions where T is maintained at the fixed temperature To of the surroundings. Where this is not the case one must resort to the approach taken in Section 1.12, or adopt the procedures outlined in Chapter 6. 1.10.2
The Clausius Inequality
Consider next a different process wherein a system is taken reversibly from some state through a macroscopic cycle back to the same initial state. Denoting such a path by the integral sign fo, we find that the state function S is specified by
fodS-fo dFQ-~
(1.10.4)
On the other hand, Eq. (1.10.3) shows that in this cyclic process, for which
S1 --$2,
fo di Q T
< 0.
(1.10.5)
0,
(1.10.6)
Both statements may be combined to read
fo -T
which is known as the Clausius inequality. Note again the very nature of an irreversible process: one can never reverse the process and return to the starting point without incurring other changes in
CYCLIC PROCESSES IN RELATION TO REVERSIBILITY AND IRREVERSIBILITY
45
the universe; also, one cannot influence any event in an isolated system. If an irreversible process proceeds at all, it must go in the spontaneous direction that increases the entropy; when quiescence sets in the entropy will be at a maximum consistent with the imposed constraints. Note once more that the state function S serves as a means of monitoring whether a given process in an (adiabatically) isolated system is indeed possible. No process for which S decreases can occur in an (adiabatically) isolated system; conversely, any process for which S increases in such a system will be spontaneous. For a system A which exchanges heat with surroundings B we consider an enlarged system in which the original system and all of its surroundings form a composite isolated system for which d Stot = d SA -Jr- d SB ~> O. 1.10.3
Operation of a Heat Engine
Consider now the operation of a heat engine. To be useful as a continuous source of power it must be capable of being operated in cycles, so that at the end of every cycle the engine gets back to the same state from which it started. All net changes accompanying the operation of the engine thus occur in the universe. We operate the engine between a hot and a cold reservoir kept at temperatures Th and Tc. The reservoirs are assumed so large that heat transfers do not appreciably alter the temperatures of each. Let Qh be the heat transfer per cycle across the boundary between the reservoir at temperature Th and the engine (Qh > 0 or Qh < 0 according as heat flows into or is rejected by the engine at the hot junction), and let Qc be the heat transfer per cycle across the boundary separating the engine and the reservoir at temperature Tc(Qc > 0 or Qc < 0 according as heat is caused to flow into or is rejected by the engine at the cold junction). If n o w Qh > Qc, o r Qh -- Qc > 0, then in the course of one cycle we must have W < 0 in order that the First Law, as applied to the cyclic process, ( Q h -Qc) + W --0, may hold. That is, by arranging matters so that heat is transferred into the engine from the hot reservoir and heat is rejected from the engine to the cold reservoir, the difference Qh -- Qc is transformed into work W < 0 performed by the engine. We now ask how efficiently this energy conversion process can be carried out in a heat engine operating in cycles. The efficiency is measured by a quantity r/ defined as ~
Work out Heat in
.
(1.10.7)
To determine this quantity recall the Clausius inequality (1.10.6). In the present case the integration in (1.10.6) reduces to the two processes occurring during heat transfers Qh from the hot reservoir into the engine and - Q c from the engine into
46
1. FUNDAMENTALS
the cold reservoir. 2 Thus, according to (1.10.6),
y ~ Oi _ Oh Th i
Qc <
(1.10.8)
or
(1.10.9)
Qh <~ Q_.f_c Th Tc '
where Qh, Qc are both positive quantities, since a negative sign precedes Qc whenever we consider the heat removed from the engine. Hence, (1.10.9) may be rewritten a s Oc/Oh >/Tc/Th, o r
Qc <~ Tc Qh Th'
(1.10.10)
thus, we rewrite Eq. (1.10.7) (the right side is the Carnot efficiency)
W Q h - Qc Qc = 1<~ 1 ~7- Qh -Qh Qh
Tc T h - Tc = Th Th
=
r/Carno t.
(1.10.11)
Note the following points: (i) The generality of our approach. We have not restricted ourselves as to types of engines, reversibility, or types of processes, other than the restriction to cyclic events and to engines operating with two reservoirs. (ii) The efficiency relates to the isothermal heat transfer across the hot junction. (iii) The equality sign holds only for reversible processes, so that for any irreversible process the efficiency is inevitably less than that for a reversible one. (iv) Even a reversible process is never 100 % efficient, except in the inaccessible limits Tc = 0 o r Th ~ ~ ; it becomes the more efficient the larger Th/Tc is. (v) q depends only on the temperatures of the 'boiler' and 'condenser'. Statements (v) and (iii) are sometimes called the First and Second Theorems of Carnot. We can now recast the Second Law in a variety of ways. Statement (iv) above provides the basis for Kelvin's Formulation of the Second Law:
It is impossible to devise an engine which, working in cycles, shall produce no effect other than to extract heat from a reservoir and to perform an equal amount
of work. By working the derivations given here in reverse we can see that this statement implies the validity of the Second Law.
AN ENTROPY ANALOGY
47
Related to the above is Planck's Statement of the Second Law:
It is impossible to devise a machine which, operating in cycles, transfers heat from a colder to a hotter body without producing any other effects in the universe. This may be demonstrated by noting what would happen if the Planck statement were incorrect. If no other changes occurred in the universe then the heat extracted from the cold reservoir must be transferred without loss to the heat reservoir. Equation (1.10.8) would then have to be altered to read - Q h / T h + Qc/Tc <, 0, with the requirement that Qc be the heat flow into the engine and that Oh = Qc. In these circumstances one finds that Th/Tc ~< 1, which contradicts the definition, Th > Tc.
QUERIES AND COMMENTS 1.10.1. Examine whether the arguments relating to cyclic processes depend on the direction of the heat transfer between the system and its surroundings. 1.10.2. Here again the question arises as to what temperature is involved if the hot and cold reservoirs differ significantly in temperature from those of the engine at the respective junctions. Such a difference must exist to sustain the heat transfers. As shown later, the temperatures are those of the reservoirs. 1.10.3. Does the Kelvin statement apply to rocket performance? Or to engines operating on a single stroke?
1.11 An Entropy Analogy Just as for the First Law, one may provide a parable that illuminates the Second Law of Thermodynamics and its consequences; we follow the presentation by Spalding and Cole. 1 Entropy change may be likened to a difference ASAB in elevation between two points A and B in rough, mountainous terrain. A mountaineer elects to measure ASAB in terms of the number of steps, n =_ nr, each one-foot in height, he must take to get from level A to level B. On a firm path the difference in height is then given by ASAB = nr. But if he chooses a slippery path through the underbrush filled with dirt and gravel, slippage occurs at every step. Now, given a particular height difference, he fails to surmount this difference with the number of one-foot incremental steps, n =_ n i, that would have sufficed had he stayed on the firm path: here ASAB > n i . Considerable effort has been wasted in the form of heat supplied to the countryside when the climber, dirt, and gravel resettle at every step. Furthermore, rather than by counting n r, the value of A SAB may be ascertained by consulting geodetic maps on which altitude contours are entered. It should be clear that A SAB corresponds to an entropy change and that n r and n i simulate f dr Q~ T and f di Q~ T respectively, while contour lines on a map correspond to tabulations of entropy values.
48
1. FUNDAMENTALS
COMMENTS AND QUERIES
1.11.1. D.B. Spalding and E.H. Cole, Engineering Thermodynamics, Arnold, London, and McGraw-Hill, New York, 1959. 1.11.2. Explore the shortcomings of this parable.
1.12
Constraints, Equilibrium, Functions of State I
In this section we study among other topics the processes that involve a difference in temperature between a system and the surroundings with which it interacts. This matter seems not to have received sufficient attention in the literature, even though such a difference is needed in any process that involves a transfer of heat. The discussion is much facilitated by the introduction of a deficit function at various stages of the derivation. These deliberations then lead quite naturally to the generation of a variety of useful functions of state and to a study of their extremal properties.
1.12.1
Entropy Deficit Function
We introduce several concepts that are directly linked to the following properties of energy and entropy:
d E + dEo = O,
(1.12.1a)
dS + dSo >~O,
(1.12.1b)
where the subscript zero represents the surroundings to the system of interest. We also introduce a generally accepted assumption: we take the reservoirs to be so huge and inert that all processes within them occur reversibly at a constant temperature To. Without use of this assumption further progress is difficult. Surroundings of this type are referred to as baths. Consider first a reversible process that changes the entropy of a system through interactions with its surrounding bath but that can produce no net change of entropy in the universe: during an infinitesimal step
dSu =-drS + dlSo = O,
(1.12.2a)
where an obvious subscript notation was used. Let the same process now be executed irreversibly (1.12.2), so that the entropy of the universe increases:
d Su - di S + d2 So > O.
(1.12.2b)
Since S is a function of state of the system, di S = drS - dS; the entropy change is identical for both infinitesimal steps. Comparison of (1.12.2a) and (1.12.2b) shows that d2 So > dl So.
CONSTRAINTS, EQUILIBRIUM, FUNCTIONS OF STATE
49
The use of inequalities is very awkward in any subsequent mathematical manipulations. As a remedy it is apposite to introduce a positive entropy deficit function dO > 0 that converts Eq. (1.12.2b) into an equality: d~ S + d2So - dO = O.
(1.12.3a)
dSu ==_di S + d2So = dO.
(1.12.3b)
It follows that
Thus, dO may be interpreted as representing the infinitesimal differential entropy increase in the universe arising from irreversible interactions between the system and its surroundings. Alternative interpretations are furnished below. Moreover, on subtracting (1.12.2a) from (1.12.3b) one obtains d2 So - dl So =dO,
(1.12.4)
which shows clearly that any excess entropy generated in the irreversible process must end up in the bath, as is entirely consistent with the requirement that S be a function of state of the system. The entropy exchanged between the system and its surrounding bath is greater by the amount dO for an irreversible process than for the same process executed reversibly. Next, we note that in the closed compound unit of (system + bath) any heat that leaves the surroundings (system) must show up in the system (bath). Hence, 2 in an irreversible process, dzQo = - d i Q, so that dzSo = dzQo/ To = - d i Q~ To. Also, for the reversible case dl So = - d S, whence (1.12.4) becomes 3 dS=
~Q
+dO.
(1.12.5)
To
This equation shows that in an infinitesimal irreversible process the entropy change of the system is related but not equal to the heat transfer, that involves the inverse of the temperature of the reservoir, To, which is a well characterized quantity. Eq. (1.12.5) replaces the standard inequality d S > di Q~ T and provides a second interpretation of the deficit function: dO specifies the difference between the entropy change dS and the experimentally determined value of di Q~ To in an infinitesimal step. It is only for a reversible process that these quantities match and that dO drops out; in the irreversible case the heat transfer is numerically smaller. 1.12.2
Two Examples
It may not be out of place to illustrate the above discussion by citing two examples. Consider the magnetization of a paramagnetic sample by an external magnetic field. During a very slow, essentially reversible, process at constant temperature the gradual resulting alignment of electronic spins reduces the entropy of
50
1. FUNDAMENTALS
the sample (see also Section 5.7). Hence, at every infinitesimal step d S < 0; entropy is expelled into the surroundings, and, in accordance with Eq. (1.12.2a), we find that dl So = - d S > 0. If instead the same magnetic field is imposed in one large pulse at constant temperature, the same entropy change takes place in the system for the same degree of spin alignment. However, now, in conformity with Eq. (1.12.3a), dzSo = - d S + dO > 0 incurs a larger entropy flow into the surroundings than before. Thus, dzSo > dl So, as claimed earlier. To maintain constant temperature in both cases we set d S = dr Q~ To in Eq. (1.12.5) to find that di Q = dr Q - TodO < 0 and di Q < dr Q. Thus, with d S < 0, more heat flows out of the system in an infinitesimal step carried out irreversibly than in the reversible execution; di Q is more negative than dr Q. As a second example consider the slow expansion of a gas through a very tiny pinhole from an initial volume to a larger volume at constant temperature. As is intuitively obvious, and will be demonstrated in Section 2.4, its entropy is increased at the expense of a diminution of the entropy of the surroundings. Hence, consistent with Eq. (1.12.2a), dl So = - d S < 0. If the opening is increased to macroscopic dimensions the process runs irreversibly, such that, by Eq. (1.12.3a) d2 So -- - d S -+- dO > dl So still holds, but here in the sense that d2 So is less negative than dl So. Thus, in the irreversible process less entropy is shifted from the surroundings into the system than during the reversible operation. Note that dr Q / T matches the positive dS but di Q / T is less than dS, so that in this example again di Q < dr Q, but in the sense that both differentials are positive. 1.12.3
Characterization of Systems whose Surroundings are at Different Temperatures
We now return to Eq. (1.12.4) and replace - d l S o by d r S - dr Q / T ; it is at this point that the temperature of the system enters. 4 We next again set d2 So - d i Q~ To and thereby obtain a fundamental relation (that appears not to be widely known) for the difference in infinitesimal heat transfers under reversible and irreversible conditions drQ
T
diQ = ~ + dO.
(1.12.6a)
To
One should note how the temperatures of the system and surroundings occur in the above expression. Eq. (1.12.6a) can then be trivially rearranged to solve for the heat transfer for any given infinitesimal process under irreversible conditions" di Q - --~- dr Q - To dO - dr Q + = dr Q + ( To - T ) d S - To dO .
- 1 dr Q - To dO
(1.12.6b)
Obviously, the above relation becomes useful only after a recipe is provided to show how the quantity dO may be determined; this matter is addressed below.
CONSTRAINTS, EQUILIBRIUM, FUNCTIONS OF STATE
51
Under the more restrictive conditions where the temperatures of the system and reservoir are essentially identical, that is, when the system is thermally firmly anchored to the reservoir, one obtains the simpler form 5 di Q - dr Q - To dO - dr Q - de,
(1.12.6c)
where we have introduced a new deficit quantity with units of energy, de =- To dO. As shown in Eq. (1.12.6c), it specifies the difference in heat transfer in a given infinitesimal step between the system and its surroundings at almost the same temperature, when carried out reversibly as opposed to irreversibly. We rearrange (1.12.6a) as diQ
drQ
To
T
(1.12.6d)
=dO,
and observe an important consequence" this relation allows for the possibility that the heat transfer during the irreversible process may be the same as for the reversible process. This can happen when T ~ To and when the deficit function satisfies the relation T-To dO - dr Q ~ TTo
T-To -- ~ To
dS.
(1.12.6e)
In other words, the equality di Q - dr Q obtains not only when d O - 0 (as in Eq. (1.12.6c)), but also when matters are so arranged that dO satisfies Eq. (1.12.6e). 1.12.4
Performance of Work
At this point we invoke the First Law to write d E -- di Q + di W - dr Q + dr W; by substituting for di Q in Eq. (1.12.6b) we find that di W -- dr W - ( To - 1 ) T
dr Q + de -- dr W - ( To - T ) d S + To dO
(1.12.7a)
We now recognize that in comparing a given reversible and irreversible process with the same dQ, any work performance may be mapped onto the equivalent process of raising a weight against the force of gravity, regardless of how the other type of work is performed (i.e., whether it is electric, mechanical, magnetic, etc., in origin). It is intuitively evident that the least amount of work required to raise a weight is expended in a reversible process. Under irreversible conditions extra work is needed to overcome friction, turbulence, etc., that is then lost to the surroundings. Hence, we impose the condition that in comparing a particular process that is performed on the system reversibly as opposed to irreversibly we set di W > dr W. Conversely, the greatest amount of work is available to the
52
1. FUNDAMENTALS
surroundings when a system is operated in a reversible manner; i.e., dr W is more negative than di W. Thus, the last two terms in (1.12.7a) must be positive. By far the most interesting feature of Eq. (1.12.7a) is the fact that it permits a direct determination of dO as
dO - --~ol [di W - dr W -t (To - T) d S ] .
(1.12.7b)
This specifies the infinitesimal entropy increase of the universe for any irreversible practical process in terms of the measurable or calculable quantities di W, dr W, and d S ~ a n apparently unappreciated result. Note that for cyclic processes the dS term drops out, and the difference di W - dr W can grow without bounds if the cycle is endlessly repeated. By contrast, the above arguments impose a lower bound on the sum of the last two terms in (1.12.7a), namely,
TodO=de>
~-1
drQ--(To-T)dS>O.
(1.12.7c)
This inequality should be compared with the equality (1.12.6e). The righthand side reflects the fact that for To > T, heat flows into the system, so that ( T o / T - 1)dr Q is positive. When To < T both factors are negative. Hence, the lower bound, being positive, is more restrictive than the original inequality dO>O. If the system remains thermally well anchored to the reservoir such that T = To throughout any given process, Eq. (1.12.7a) reduces to d~ W = d~ W + d~,
(1.12.7d)
so that de then relates to the work performed in executing at essentially constant T an infinitesimal irreversible, as compared to a reversible, step. We finally return to Eq. (1.12.6b) via (1.12.7c) and note that when we set (To~ T - 1) dr Q - de < 0 we obtain di Q < dr Q, which is a reformulation of the basic thermodynamic inequality that rests on the Second Law. The present analysis could, of course, be run backwards: starting with the basic inequality di Q < dr Q one may use the above derivation to show that di W > dr W.
1.12.5
Basic Formulation of Equilibrium Thermodynamics
At this point we can begin a study of the very basic relations that underlie the remaining thermodynamic developments, namely the construction of appropriate functions of state. For this purpose we now rewrite Eq. (1.12.1 a) as di Q + di W + dEo = 0; then, using Eq. (1.12.5), we obtain the fundamental expression
TodS - de + di W - d E = O,
(1.12.8)
CONSTRAINTS, EQUILIBRIUM, FUNCTIONS OF STATE
53
which makes no explicit reference to heat transfers but involves only the performance of work and irreversibility effects. Note that it is the well-established temperature of the surroundings that enters the equation. 4 1.12.6
Construction of Functions of State and their Extremal Properties
In what follows we apply Eq. (1.12.8) to several special situations and examine the consequences. In some situations we imagine the system at temperature T to be enveloped by surroundings at a temperature To, and to be subjected to a variety of virtual displacements away from the equilibrium state, while maintaining the initially specified constraints. To emphasize this point we introduce the symbol 6 whenever constrained variations are considered. We then examine the response to such a displacement. 1.12.7
Isolated or Isoenergetic Systems
As a first example, consider the isolated system; here ~i Q = ~i W = ~ E -- 0; also note that in the absence of surroundings we simply introduce the temperature of the system, T. Then Eq. (1.12.8) reduces to
T ~ S = 6 e = _ T~O ~ 0 .
(1.12.9a)
Here, 3S = 60 >~ 0 is the entropy change arising from irreversible processes occurring within a completely closed system. As Eq. (1.12.9a) shows, S can then only increase. As soon as these processes have ceased, 30 = 6 S = 0, so that S has assumed an extremal value which is a maximum under the present constraints. For example, the entropy change in the free expansion of a gas can be determined by finding AS under quasistatic conditions, as specified later in Section 2.3. Since S is a function of state the same entropy change takes place in a free expansion under the same conditions. All this, of course, merely repeats what has been well established in earlier sections. Consider next an isoenergetic process for which 6 E -- 0, but for which interactions between system and surroundings are permitted, as long as one requires that the work exchange at each infinitesimal step be precisely balanced by the heat exchange. This can only be done under quasi-equilibrium conditions that exclude any irreversible processes over which the experimenter has no control. As a necessary condition the temperatures of the system and surroundings must converge to the same limiting value. We therefore set 3r W = --6r Q and 6e = 0. Then Eq. (1.12.8) reduces to
T6S=6rQ,
(1.12.9b)
which merely repeats the well-established fact that the entropy change is tracked by the reversible heat transfer.
54
1. FUNDAMENTALS
Alternatively, we write T 3S -- - ( ~ r W ,
(1.12.9C)
which signals the fact that the entropy of a system can be reduced, namely by doing work on the system, ~r W > 0, while maintaining constant energy. This should dispel the idea that in any process whatever the entropy of a system always remains either constant or can only increase. Obviously, the entropy diminution in the system must be compensated for elsewhere in the universe by processes that increase the total entropy of the system plus surroundings. 1.12.8
State Functions for Isothermal Processes
New concepts are established by considering processes that occur isothermally, that is, in the limit: 3T - - 0 and To -- T. We may now rewrite Eq. (1.12.8) as 3 ( E - T S ) -- 3A -- 3 i W -(~B -- (~rW.
(1.12.10a)
In the above we have invented a new function of state, A = E - T S, involving state functions that had been previously introduced. A is called the Helmholtz (free) energy function. The fight-hand side follows from Eq. (1.12.7d). As is seen, changes in A are tracked by the reversible performance of work at constant T. If no work is involved, but irreversible (and therefore, uncontrollable) processes are allowed to occur at constant temperature, we find from the above that 3A = - 3 e
~< 0.
(1.12.10b)
Thus, irreversible processes within the system at constant temperature lead to a decrease in its Helmholtz free energy. When quiescence sets in, 6A -- 0, and A is minimized; this characterizes the equilibrium constraint for a system at constant temperature. In what follows we distinguish again between mechanical and nonmechanical work by setting di W - di Wm + d W n and de - d6m + d6:n. In the Exercises 6 the reader is asked to show that dSm and d6n must separately be nonnegative. If, in addition to T, the volume V is held fixed (isothermal-isochoric conditions, for which no mechanical work is possible) then the above expressions reduce to A = ~i Wn - ~6n "-- ~r Wn.
(1.12.11)
Parenthetically, Eq. (1.12.11) is a restricted version of (1.12.10); contrary to some assertions in the literature, there is no need to require constant volume conditions to prove the assertion that A is a minimum at equilibrium. Suppose, instead, that the system is subjected to processes at constant pressure (isothermal-isobaric conditions). It is then expedient to rewrite Eq. (1.12.8) as d E - d ( T S ) + d ( P V) - di Wn + den = O, or, 3(E - TS + PV) -3G
-- 3iWn - 3en = ~ r W n .
(1.12.12a)
CONSTRAINTS, EQUILIBRIUM, FUNCTIONS OF STATE
55
By arguments now familiar we have introduced a new function of state, G -= E - T S + P V, the Gibbs (free) energy, involving the indicated combination of other functions of state. As is evident, changes in this quantity are tracked by the reversible performance of work at constant T and P other than mechanical. Moreover, if irreversible phenomena occur under isothermal-isobaric conditions in the absence of any work performance then 3G = - 3 e n <. O,
(1.12.12b)
showing that in such circumstances the Gibbs free energy of the system diminishes and reaches a minimum at equilibrium. 1.12.9
Isentropic Processes
We next consider isentropic processes that do not explicitly involve temperature as a variable. Here S is held fixed, and all processes involving Eq. (1.12.8) are subject to the restriction d E + de - di W -- 0. Thus, 7 E = - 3 e + ~i W -- ~r W,
(1.12.13a)
showing that the energy change under such conditions is tracked by reversible performance of work under adiabatic conditions. This, of course, simply repeats what was originally stated while setting up the First Law. The right-hand side follows from the use of Eq. (1.12.7a), with the central term missing. However, if irreversible conditions prevail within the system in the absence of any work, we find 6E = - 6 s
~< 0,
(1.12.13b)
so that under the stipulated conditions the energy of the system diminishes while the process lasts, and E is minimized at equilibrium. A special case arises if the volume is also held fixed; under such isentropicisochoric conditions E = - 6 e n + ~i Wn -- ~r W n ,
(1.12.14a)
E = -3Sn <. O.
(1.12.14b)
and
On the other hand, if pressure is kept fixed at constant entropy, we find for isentropic-isobaric conditions that d E + d (P V) + dgn - di Wn - O, SO that 6(E + P V) =_ 6H = ~i Wn - ~gn = ~r W n .
(1.12.15a)
We thus encounter yet another function of state, the enthalpy, H =_ E + P V, whose change under adiabatic conditions is tracked by reversible performance of
56
1. FUNDAMENTALS
nonmechanical work. When irreversible effects enter and no work is performed we find that (1.12.15b)
6 H = - 3 S n <~ O,
showing that this function too diminishes when the system is subjected to isentropic irreversible processes in the absence of work performance. At equilibrium the enthalpy is a minimum. 1.12.10
Summary
The full utility of the functions of state listed above can become apparent only later. For now we note that changes in A and G may be specified by reversible performance of work under isothermal conditions, while changes in E and H are linked to performance of work under conditions of constant entropy. Variations in S may be similarly monitored under conditions of no energy change. As emphasized earlier, the characterization of processes is greatly simplified by t~tilizing such path-independent functions. Moreover, since work can always be measured empirically or calculated, these functions of state can be directly evaluated or determined experimentally. Except for S the above functions of state are all at a minimum when equilibrium prevails under the postulated constraints, while S is at a maximum. The above results are summarized in Table 1.12.1. The table shows that different functions of state are useful in characterizing equilibrium conditions under a variety of conditions. The table should also put at rest a common misconception that the performance of work is invariably linked to energy changes. Obviously, the relevant function of state depends on the conditions of the experiment. Also, we can illustrate the meaning of 'virtual processes'. These refer to slight displacements of the system from equilibrium while maintaining the indicated constraints. If the function of state does not change in such a displacement the system is at equilibrium; if not, changes take place until a new equilibrium point is reached. Table 1.12.1 Characterization of equilibrium
Fixed parameters (constraints)
Equilibrium
Relation to reversible work
E S S, V
~S = 0, S maximum ~E -- 0, E minimum 6E = 0, E minimum ~ H -- 0, H minimum ~A = 0, A minimum 6A = 0, A minimum SG = 0, G minimum
~S " ~E =
S, P
T T, V T, P
--Sr W/T Sr
W
6 E = ~r Wn ~H = (~r Wn
~F
- - ~r
W
S F = 8r Wn ~G -- Sr Wn
CONSTRAINTS, EQUILIBRIUM, FUNCTIONS OF STATE
57
REMARKS AND QUERIES 1.12.1. The author is greatly indebted to Professor Dor Ben Amotz of Purdue University for his insightful participation that greatly clarified the fundamental concepts on which the present section is based. See also: Dor Ben Amotz and J.M. Honig, J. Chem. Phys. B 118 (2003) 5932. 1.12.2. The notation is a bit awkward at this point: di Q really refers to the heat released by the system to the surroundings or absorbed from it in an irreversible manner. The negative of this quantity is absorbed by or furnished from processes taking place reversibly in the reservoir. Since no heat escapes the compound system, we may set di Q = -d2 Qo. 1.12.3. Strictly speaking, the differential d (in dX) should only be used to indicate an infinitesimal variation of X along a thermodynamically describable path, and should not be applied to extrathermodynamic, irreversible phenomena. In our case, however, we demand only that the initial and final points of the process be representable as equilibrium states. The use of yet another symbol for a nonequilibrium differential process seems excessive. 1.12.4. The question of how to deal with the concept of temperature in a system undergoing irreversible processes will be discussed below and is taken up in Chapter 6. 1.12.5. Of course, this statement should be more carefully formulated. Since no heat transfer can occur without a temperature difference between the system and the surroundings Eq. (1.12.6c) is to be interpreted as a limiting law wherein dQ signifies the heat flow for the case where T closely approaches To. 1.12.6. To show that the individual de are nonnegative consider some spontaneous process for which d8m < 0; and examine the consequences by comparing work performance in reversible and irreversible processes. 1.12.7. At this point it is vital to distinguish between adiabatic and isenthalpic processes. In the former dQ = 0, so that by the First Law di W = dr W; for any given infinitesimal process all types of work performance lead to the same energy differential, dE. In the isenthalpic case (or if T = To) the central term in Eq. (1.12.7a) drops out and Eq. (1.12.7d) is applicable; now the energy change does depend on how the work is executed in the process. If done irreversibly the entropy dO thereby generated must be transferred out of the system by removal of heat to the surroundings. Incidentally, one way of maintaining the T -- To requirement is through the contrived step of ramping the reservoir temperature up or down in step with the temperature of the system at each infinitesimal change of conditions, but it is best to focus attention on the requirement that dS -- 0. 1.12.8. The so-called Grand Potential function J = A - G has occasionally been used to characterize thermodynamic states. Show under what conditions this quantity can be related to reversible performance of work and characterize the properties of this function when irreversible processes occur. 1.12.9. As another example that relates to comparisons between processes executed reversibly or irreversibly, consider at constant volume the conversion of hydrogen and oxygen into steam over a platinum catalyst, and compare this with the explosive conversion by an electric spark. Are any changes needed in the derivations?
58
1.13 1.13.1
1. FUNDAMENTALS
Systematics of Thermodynamic Functions of State Thermodynamic Functions of State
We begin here a study of the properties of functions of state that are useful in characterizing physical processes. One should note the amount of information that becomes available through a systematic approach. We begin with the general formulation for the energy change of a system by noting the corresponding expression for the surroundings, as indicated by the subscript zero. Here we replace the heat transferred into the bath by dr Qo = To dS0, and the mechanical work performed, by dr W = - P d VO, so that d E o = To dSo - Po dVo,
(1.13.1a)
which we adopt because it is assumed at the outset that all processes in the surroundings always take place reversibly. In a closed unit comprised of system + surroundings maintained at constant volume 1 we then set d E o - - d E and d V0 = - d V. We also adopt Eq. (1.12.4), in which we set dl So = - d S; it will be recalled that dl So was defined to be the entropy change in the surroundings when the process in the system was carried out reversibly. Then (1.13.1b)
d2 So = - d S + dO.
When the above substitution is applied to (1.13.1a) one obtains the fundamental result for the differential energy of the system d E -- To d S - Po d V - To dO.
(1.13.1c)
This expression shows that volume and entropy serve as thermodynamic variables, or as control variables, for the internal energy function of the system: E = E ( S , V). Nevertheless, the intensive variables are those of the surroundings, and are therefore well defined, even when the processes in the system proper are far removed from equilibrium. For the present we exclude other types of work that are treated in Chapter 5. We defer the generalization of the present treatment to the case of open systems to Section 1.20. It is now expedient to introduce explicitly the difference in intensive variables between the system and surroundings, by rewriting the above in the form d E = (To - T ) d S -
(Po - P ) d V
if- T d S -
P d V - TodO.
(1.13.1d)
This, however, again raises the problem of defining intensive variables such as temperature for a system that undergoes irreversible processes. One way to approach this difficulty is presented in Chapter 6, where T is allowed to depend on the position within the sample. An alternative is shown in Fig. 1.13.1 which
SYSTEMATICS OF THERMODYNAMIC FUNCTIONS OF STATE SYSTEM
59
SURROUNDINGS
1
T0
Fig. 1.13.1. Temperature profile near the junction between a system (left) at temperature T and a reservoir (right) at temperature T O under QSI operating conditions. The change in temperature occurs over a narrow boundary region.
shows a partition between the system and its surroundings that permits the transfer of heat. If this barrier is a poor thermal conductor the rate of heat transfer will be sufficiently small, such that most of the volume of the surroundings (the sample) will be at temperature To (T). The changeover from T to To is then confined to the immediate vicinity of the thin barrier. Thermal processes carried out under such conditions will be termed quasi-static irreversible (QSI). More generally, we define the QSI processes as those in which the characteristics of the system and, separately, of the surroundings do not deviate seriously from internal equilibrium. However, the QSI state of the system and surroundings may differ to any arbitrary extent. The reader may construct other scenarios in which T represents some suitably averaged value over the volume of the system; this represents no major difficulty when the variation in T over the sample volume is small relative to its average. However, for severe departures from equilibrium the concept of temperature may no longer be viable. Similar considerations apply to all other intensive variables, such as pressure. As a special case consider removing the system from its equilibrium state by external intervention and then allowing the system to respond, all the while maintaining conditions of constant entropy and volume. In that event one finds that d E -- - T o d O .
(1.13.1e)
This shows that in the absence of external driving forces To d S and Po d V any ongoing process will take place intemally, and will not be subject to experimental control. Thus, with dO > 0, the energy of the system spontaneously diminishes until these irreversible phenomena have run their course, at which point E assumes a minimum value consistent with the imposed constraints. Eq. (1.13.1e) coincides with Eq. (1.12.13b) that holds when no work is performed. By contrast, if the conditions of the surroundings and of the system are in near balance, so that T ~ To and P ~ P0, then any process becomes essentially reversible, and the differential energy function (1.13.1 d) assumes the standard form dE = T dS - P dV.
(1.13.If)
60
1. FUNDAMENTALS
Thus, entropy and volume represent the appropriate control variables. Since E is a function of state Eq. (1.13.If) may be subtracted from Eq. (1.13.1d), thus allowing us to solve for (1.13.1g)
TodO -- (To - T) dS - (Po - P) dV.
This relation is of considerable interest: for, it allows us to determine the infinitesimal contribution to the entropy that is attributable to irreversibility effects. Note that this determination is based on changes in volume or entropy that can be measured. Before Eq. (1.13.1g) can be integrated one must specify how the intensive variables To - T and P0 - P are altered in a given irreversible process. If this is done one obtains 0 in terms of S and V. This matter will be taken up below in a slightly different context. We next examine the other functions of state that had been introduced in the preceding section. The first of these is the enthalpy, defined by H = E + P V,
(1.13.2a)
which, sensibly, invokes the pressure P that characterizes the system, rather than P0. The corresponding differential d H = d E + P d V + V d P has the generalized form, obtained from Eq. (1.13.1 d) d H - - ( T o - T) d S -
(1.13.2b)
( P o - P) d V + T d S + V d P - TodO.
The difficulty here is that H = H (S, P) should be written out in terms of S and P as control variables. To address this problem we adopt a transcription based on the relations V -- V (T, P) and S -- S (T, P). We then invert the latter in the form T = T (S, P) and substitute in the former to set V = V ((S, P), P) = V (S, P), from which we derive the relation dV-
( ) -~
dS+
-~
sdP'
(1.13.2c)
which is then substituted in (1.13.2b) to yield d H -- (To - T ) d S -
(Po - P)
+ T dS + V d P -
[()
TodO.
ov --~
P
as+
S
de
] (1.13.2d)
If desired, the partial derivatives may be reexpressed as shown in Section 1.3. As an example, one might decide to write (OV/OP)s = (OV/OP)T + (OV/OT)p(OT/OP)s. The quantities (OV/OP)T or (OV/OT)p are specified by - f l V or ot V respectively, where fl and o~ are the isothermal compressibility coefficient and the isobaric thermal expansion coefficient. Also, in a reversible process (OT/O P ) s represents the change in temperature of the system during an adiabatic
SYSTEMATICS OF THERMODYNAMIC FUNCTIONS OF STATE
61
change in pressure. In any event, we have now expressed d H in terms of independent experimental variables that specify enthalpy changes. In the special case dS = d P =- 0 there is no external driving force for generating changes in enthalpy. Any remaining processes are spontaneous, thus, not subject to experimental control, and are therefore expressed by the relation (1.13.2e)
d H = - To dO,
so that the enthalpy diminishes until quiescence sets in, at which point H is at a minimum consistent with the indicated constraints. This relation is identical with Eq. (1.12.15b) which holds when no work is performed. If, instead, conditions prevail in which the system and surroundings are in near-equilibrium, so that processes occur nearly reversibly with P = P0 and T = To, one obtains the standard formulation (1.13.2f)
dH = T dS + V dP,
where entropy and pressure again serve as the control variables. On subtraction from (1.13.2d) one obtains TodO - ( T o - T) d S -
(Po - P)
-~
dS +
-ff--fi
P
dP .
(1.13.2g)
s
Here 0 involves S and P as control variables. To carry out an integration To - T and P0 - P must be specified for a particular process. Proceeding along very similar lines we introduce the Helmholtz (free) energy through the relation A = E-
TS,
(1.13.3a)
with the differential form dA -- d E - T d S - S d T, so that d A = (To - T) d S -
(Po - P) d V - P d V - S d T - TodO.
(1.~3.3b)
The problem here is that A = A ( T , V) should be written out in terms of T and V as control variables. We address this situation by setting S = S ( T , V), so that dS_
( ) _~
dT +
(~
-ff--ff T d V "
(1.13.3c)
At this stage we anticipate the derivations provided below that result in the formulation of Eqs. (1.13.12) and (1.13.15), according to which we may set (0 S/O T) v = C v / T, where C v is the heat capacity at constant volume, and we may introduce the relation (OS/OV)T = ( O P / O T ) v . These results are derived by independent methods, so that circular arguments are avoided. We next introduce the mathematical identity (1.3.9) to write ( O P / O T ) v = - ( O V / O T ) p / ( O V / O P ) T
62
1. FUNDAMENTALS
and then replace the numerator and denominator by ot V and by - f l V, where ot and fl are the isobaric thermal expansion and the isothermal compressibility respectively. On introducing these substitutions we finally obtain
[
]
Ol
d a -- ( To - T ) CV T d T + -fl d V
- ( P o - P ) d V - P d V - S d T - TodO
(1.13.3d) which expresses the Helmholtz differential in the appropriate independent variables and in terms of measurable quantities. Using familiar arguments we next set d T = d V = 0, and find that in spontaneous processes under these conditions d A = - To dO,
(1.13.3e)
showing that the Helmholtz free energy assumes a minimum value under the indicated constraints. This relation agrees with Eq. (1.12.10b), obtained in the absence of any type of work. When system and surroundings are in near equilibrium a reversible process is characterized by the standard relation d A -- - S d T - P d V .
(1.13.30
When subtracted from (1.13.3b) we find TodO--(To-r) --(To-T)
[( ) [ ~ -OS ~
V
dr+
-~
CV d T + dV T -fl
T
dV
-(Po-
]
-(Po-
P)dV
P)dV,
(1 13.3g)
where we have expressed dO in terms of T and V and quantities that may be measured experimentally. Once again (To - T) and (Po - P) must be specified for a particular process before the integration can be performed. Finally, we introduce the Gibbs (flee) energy function via (1.13.4a)
G=E+PV-TS, whose differential form is given by d G = (To - T ) d S -
(Po - P ) d V + V d P - S d T - TodO.
(1.13.4b)
This must be rewritten so as to involve T and P as control variables. Proceeding in the manner shown above we set S = S(T, P) and V = V (T, P) to write d G - ( T o - T)
OS -~
P
dT +
-ff--fi
dT+
r
(OV)
dR
-if-fiT d P ]
+ VdP-
SdT-
TodO
SYSTEMATICS OF THERMODYNAMIC FUNCTIONS OF STATE
--(To-T)
Cp T d T - o~V d P
+ V dP - SdT-
63
J
- (Po - P)[o~V d T - ~6V d P ]
(1.13.4c)
TodO.
In the second part we again used Eqs. (1.13.10) and (1.13.15) that will be derived below on an independent basis: C p is the heat capacity at constant pressure and ( O V / O T ) p and ( O V / O P ) T were replaced by c~V and by - f l V , respectively. When we require that d P = d T = 0 no controllable changes can take place. Any residual processes are spontaneous, and thus, subject to the relation (1.13.4d)
d G = - To dO,
so that the Gibbs free energy assumes a minimum value under the indicated constraints. Once more, this relation coincides with Eq. (1.12.12b) when no work is incurred. When near equilibrium prevails Eq. (1.13.4b) reduces to the standard form dG = -S dT § V dP.
(1.13.4e)
By methods now familiar we subtract Eq. (1.13.4e) from (1.13.4b) to write -
d T - oeV d P J
_
-
(Po -
P)[o~V dT
-
~V dP],
(1.13.4f)
where we are specifying 0 in terms of T and P. 1.13.2
Discussion
This completes the construction of the elementary functions of state for a closed system; their generalization to open system is deferred to Section 1.20. In the formulations (1.13.1g), (1.13.2g), (1.13.3g), (1.13.4f) the deficit function was written out in terms of differentials of functions of state and in terms of (T0 - T) and (P0 - P). As a first approximation one may expand these differences in a Taylor's series up to second powers. The same applies to the generalized functions of state (1.13.1 d), (1.13.2d), (1.13.3d), (1.13.4c). The ramifications of such steps have not been explored, but a version equivalent to the first power expansion is provided in Chapter 6. To integrate Eq. (1.13.4f) is not a trivial matter. At the outset let us assume that the surroundings are essentially infinite, so that whatever the process, the quantities To and P0 remain unaltered. The remaining variables change continuously during the irreversible process, so that the trajectory of each must be specified as
64
1. FUNDAMENTALS
a function of time t. Thus, the integrated form stretches over limits between the initial time ti and the final time t f . We obtain
-
[/,o-,<,> To
~V(T(t))
-57
dt -
To
~V(P(t))
-3T
dt
]
"
(1.13.4g) Clearly, the above expression is very unwieldy. Some simplification is achieved by ignoring the dependence of Cp, ~ V, and/5 V on the indicated variables, so that the first integral reads Cp f ( 1/ T - 1/ To) d T -- Cp [In (Tf / Ti ) - (1 / To) (Tf /~) ]. The last integral may be rewritten in the form - (~ V~ To) [Po ( P f - Pi) ( p 2 _ p2)/2] Thus, these two integrals are path-independent in this approxif 9 . mation. On the other hand, the two central integrals cannot be simplified in this fashion. One possible approach is to assume that in (1 - T~ To), T may sensibly be replaced by its average value 7~ ~ (Tf - / ~ ) / 2 , and similarly, for P(t) in the third integral. If T does not deviate significantly from To, and similarly for P the two central contributions are small and the approximations are tenable. In this particular simplification the two integrals reduce to -or V (1 - T~ To)(Pf - Pi) and (~ V Po/To) (1 - P / Po) (Tf - Ti), respectively. The extent to which such steps may be justified can only be decided by experiment. In any case, an explicit result has been provided for one particular set of approximations. 1.13.3
Summary
In summarizing the above we should note that the First and Second Laws have now been placed on an equal footing: for any irreversible process we write d E = dQ + d W
(1.13.4h)
d S = d Q / To + dO,
(1.13.4i)
and
in which dO is specified by any of the appropriate variations cited above. Since these relations involve measurable quantities and functions of state the differential for the entropy is now properly specified for any process. The resulting reformulation parallels the First Law, in the sense that it facilitates the determination of entropy changes involved in heat and work exchanges of any kind, just as the First Law quantifies energy changes arising from any kind of interchange of heat and work. In this connection it is also important to recall Eq. (1.12.7b) that expressed dO solely in terms of work and entropy increments. This provides an alternative procedure for use in Eq. (1.13.4i).
SYSTEMATICS OF THERMODYNAMIC FUNCTIONS OF STATE
1.13.4
65
Systematization of Results Based on Functions of State
Henceforth we concentrate on the use of Eqs. (1.13.10, (1.13.20, (1.13.3f), (1.13.4e) as the fundamental building blocks (as applied to equilibrium processes) for all subsequent thermodynamic operations. The enormous advantage accruing to their use is that by the First Law all of these functions depend solely on the difference between the initial and the final equilibrium state. We no longer rely on the use of quantities such as heat and work that are individually path dependent. As will be shown shortly and in much of what is to follow, these functions of state may be manipulated to obtain useful information for characterizing experimental observations. One should note that the choice of the functions E, H, A, or G depends on the experimental conditions. For example, in processes where temperature and pressure are under experimental control one would select the Gibbs free energy as the appropriate function of state. Processes carried out under adiabatic and constant pressure conditions are best characterized by the enthalpy state function. When changing these control variables in going from (If) <-+ (2f) <-+ (3f) (4e) by successively adopting (2a), (3a), (4a) one progresses from one function of state to the next. This process is known as executing a set of Legendre Transformations. Thus, no one function is in any sense more fundamental than any other; the choice is dictated solely by what quantity is the most convenient for use in any experimental situation. 1.13.5
Thermodynamic Interrelations; Maxwell Equations, and Equations of State
At this point the systematics kicks in. It will be evident that an enormous amount of information may be generated by a systematic application of elementary steps, thereby illustrating the power of thermodynamic methodology. Consider first the process of taking first partial derivatives of the functions (1.13.If), (1.13.2d), (1.13.3d), (1.13.4e) with respect to the appropriate independent variables. We obtain T = (3E/3S)v
= (OH/OS)p,
(1.13.5)
V = (3H/3P)s
= (3G/3P)T,
(1.13.6)
S = -(3A/3T)v P = -(3E/3
= -(3G/3T)p,
V)s = -(3A/3
V)T.
(1.13.7) (1.13.8)
Eq. (1.13.7) for the entropy is particularly useful if A or G are known as functions of T, V or T, P, respectively. These can be determined, for example, through the use of partition functions in statistical mechanics, which is usually relatively straightforward, at least in commonly used approximation procedures. Alternative
66
1. FUNDAMENTALS
methods for finding A or G via equations of state or other methods are furnished later. Similarly, determining the pressure via Eq. (1.13.8) is useful when direct measurements (e.g., the pressure exerted by electrons in a metal) are difficult. The remaining relations are likely to be less useful. The next step consists in carrying out a cross differentiation in either order; for example, by applying the relation (02E/OSOV) -- (02E/OVOS) to Eq. (1.13.If) one obtains Eq. (1.13.9) below. The other expressions are similarly derived.
(OT/O V)s = - ( 0 P/aS)v,
(1.13.9)
(aSIa P)T = --(O V/aT) p,
(1.13.10)
(OT/OP)s = (OV/OS)p,
(1.13.11)
(OS/OV)T = (OP/OT)v.
(1.13.12)
The above relations are known as Maxwell Equations. Eqs. (1.13.10) and (1.13.12) are particularly useful: if the equations of state is known in the form P = P (V, T) or V = V (P, T) for any given material; then its entropy may be determined by integration of the partial differential equation with respect to P or V. 2 More generally, these expressions are used to eliminate partial derivatives of the entropy in favor of temperature derivatives of pressure or volume, quantities that are directly accessible by experiment.
1.13.6
Caloric Equations of State
Other deductions are found by substituting S = S (T, V) or S = S (T, P) into E = E (S, V) or into H = H (S, P) to obtain E = E (S (V, T), V) = E (T, V) and H = H(S(P, T), P) -- H(T, p),3 so that one may write
aS -~
dE--T
v
OE --
-~
dH-T-~
dT+
dT + V
OS
-~
-~
T
-P
dV
OV,
(1.13.13)
T
P
OH
T -~
[()]
dT + T - ~
aT +
T
+ V dP
dP.
e
(1.13.14)
V
Comparing the coefficients leads to the results
--
OT
-~ Cv,
~
V
-
P
~ Cp,
T
P
(1.13.15)
SYSTEMATICS OF THERMODYNAMIC FUNCTIONS OF STATE
() OE -~
-- T T
-~
T
(0,) -~
- P - T
-~
T -- T
-~-fi
67
- P ( V , T),
(1.13.16)
p + V(P, T),
(1.13.17)
V + V-- - T
-~
T
where the appropriate Maxwell relations were used to obtain the right-hand side of the last two equations. The quantities C v and Cp are defined as shown in (1.13.15), and are known as heat capacities at constant volume or at constant pressure. These can be experimentally determined as a function of T over wide temperature ranges, normally by standard calorimetric methods (see also Section 1.16). Integration of the experimental heat capacities with respect to temperature then yields E, H, or S as a function of T (see Section 1.17), with either V or P as parameters. Alternatively, by inserting the equation of state into (1.13.16) or (1.13.17), followed by integration, one can find the dependence of E on V or H on P, with T as a parameter. Eqs. (1.13.16) and (1.13.17) are known as caloric equations o f state. As an aside, Eqs. (1.13.13) and (1.13.14) illustrate the difference between what is often referred to as natural and unnatural coordinates. It is seen that E, considered as a function of S and V, has a very simple differential form, Eq. (1.13.If); this is obviously the natural coordinate representation. By contrast, E, considered as a function of T and V has a more complicated 'unnatural' differential form, in which the coefficients of d T and of d V are specified by the relation (1.13.13). Similar remarks pertain to the enthalpy, H. Lastly, insertion of Eq. (1.13.7) into A = E - T S leads to
A--E+T
~
v
or
~
v
-~
P
or
-~-
P
~
T
(1 13.18)
T
(1 13 19)
~
Similarly, one finds G--H+T
-----
~
o
o
o
The above relations are known as G i b b s - H e l m h o l t z equations. The solution of these partial differential equations, after insertion for E or H from (1.13.13)(1.13.17), yields A or G. We have thus achieved a complete specification of the various thermodynamic functions of interest in terms of experimental information. We shall later discuss simpler experimental techniques for determining these quantities. 1.13.7
The Equilibrium State Reviewed
We have seen above that after processes have run their course the various functions of state E, H, A, G, and - S have assumed minimal values consistent with
68
1. FUNDAMENTALS
the constraints imposed on the system. To undo the minimization process work must be executed, or, as seen later, material must be transferred across the boundaries of the system. On this basis we may identify the equilibrium state as that for which the appropriate thermodynamic function of state (depending on the various applicable constraints) is at a minimum. Again, any displacement from this state requires a relaxation of the constraints and/or performance of work and/or transfer of matter across boundaries.
1.13.8
The Absolute Temperature Scale; Reprise
We are also now in a position to introduce a very elegant proof set forth by Landsberg, 4 which shows that all classes of different physically sensible temperature scales do in fact correspond uniquely to the absolute temperature scale introduced in Section 1.2. We thereby complete the discussion which was briefly alluded to in Sections 1.2 and 1.9. We attempt to correlate an empirical temperature scale t to the thermodynamic temperature scale T. For this purpose we rewrite Eq. (1.13.16) in the form
OP
-1
1 (1.13.20)
Multiply both sides by ( d T / d t ) d t and integrate from to (corresponding to To) to ti (corresponding to 7~)
Ct fT~ i d T T
1
I i
(0P / O T ) v
Jto P + ( O E / O V ) t
dt =-- Ki
1
ln(Ti/To)
(i
1, 2 . . . . ).
1
(1.13.21) Here to is a standard temperature that has been arbitrarily chosen and the set ti represents a set of other temperature values on the chosen empirical t scale. Note the definition for Ki. From (l. 13.21) one immediately deduces that T2 -- eK2 To ~ e K2
TO e K2 T1 - To (T1 - T o ) - ~ K1 ( T l-e 1
- To).
(1.13.22)
Let T1 be deliberately chosen such that tl - to corresponds to the difference between the boiling and freezing points of water maintained at one bar. Then we may set T1 - To = 100 K. Suppose now another empirical temperature scale is selected in which t il corresponds to tj correspondingly, K~ must match Ki. Thus,
' ftj;P +(OP/Ot')v (0 E/O V)t' dt'- f6
Ki =~
dt = Ki
(i = 1, 2 . . . . ). (1.13.23)
SYSTEMATICS OF THERMODYNAMIC FUNCTIONS OF STATE
69
!
Note that the equality K i - - K i arises because the evaluation of an integral is independent of the selection of a dummy integration variable. It now follows from Eqs. (1.13.22) and (1.13.23) that eK2 T 2 - eK 1 __ l ( r ; !
7'( -- Td Z ; ) - Z2 T1----2--~o.
(1 13.24)
!
Hence, if tl - to - t 1 - to are both so chosen as to correspond to 7'( - Td -- T1 To -- 100 K, then T ~ - T2, which proves the assertion. The absolute temperature is thus independent of the choice of an empirical temperature scale. 1.13.9
Equations
of State
In the foregoing we have emphasized the useful role that an equation of state plays in the determination of the various functions of state displayed above. Hence, we briefly comment on some mathematical relations that have been found useful for this purpose. The simplest of these is the perfect gas law which may be written in the form PV
Z -
RT
= 1.
(1.13.25)
The use of this relation is obviously very restrictive. One may attempt to improve on its usefulness by introducing an expansion of the form B(T) C(T) V~ + 9 2 + " "
Z(T, 9)--I+
(1.13.26)
where the coefficients B, C . . . . can generally be determined from theories of intermolecular forces; they have been tabulated for various materials. Eq. (1.13.26) is known as a virial equation of state. A more ubiquitous relation was first proposed by Johannes van der Waals in 1873 that is applicable to fluids; it has the form RT
a
P :- 9 - b
92"
(1.13.27)
This formulation has been found so useful that compilations of the parameters a and b are widely available. Eq. (1.13.27) leads to the relation 1
a
Z =
~
1 -b/V
~.
(1.13.28)
RTV
In many cases b / V << 1, in which case one may expand the denominator of the first term to obtain a )1 Z-l+
b-
b2 +
+..-
"
(1 13.29)
70
1. FUNDAMENTALS
A comparison of (1.13.29) and (1.13.26) establishes a relation between the virial coefficients B, C . . . . , and the van der Waals coefficients. Other equations of state for fluids have been proposed in the literature, among them the Berthelot relation
(
P + T 9 2 ( 9 - B b ) - RT,
(1.13.30)
P ( V -- b')e a'/RTf' = RT,
(1.13.31)
the Dieterici relation
and the Redlich-Kwong relation P =
RT V-b
a T1/2V(V+b)
.
(1.13.32)
When solids rather than fluids are considered one invokes the so-called Griineisen Law. In differential form (at constant volume) it reads
dP--yG(T)Cv(T)dT,
(1.13.33)
where yG(T) is a temperature dependent parameter that has been specified in the literature for a variety of solids. If the solid is metallic yG(T)Cv(T) must be replaced by yG(T)Cv(T) + 2Cv,el/3. where the correction term involves the electronic contribution to the heat capacity of the solid. This latter term is generally swamped by the first term except at lowest temperatures. Frequently one simply employs an empirical relation of the form Z =
RT
(1 + at - tiP),
(1.13.34)
where Vo, or, fl are parameters that are found in appropriate tables; t is the temperature in ~
1.13.10
Thermodynamics of Anisotropic Media
At this point we take up the thermodynamic principles governing mechanical work in anisotropic media. Here the changes in physical extension depend on the direction of application of nonhydrostatic pressure. Consider a deformation in which s(r) and s(r + dr) are displacement vectors that move element A, originally at r, to r + s(r), and a neighboring element B, originally at r + dr to an adjacent location. For small displacements, s(r + dr) ~ s(r) + d r . Vs(r). Here V s ( r ) is a matrix (a tensor) with columns Osx(r)/Ox, Osx(r)/Oy, Osx(r)/Oz, and similarly with sy(r), Sz(r ). As is evident, any matrix with entries Mij may be rewritten in the form Mij = (1/2)(Mij + Mji) + (1/2)(Mij - Mji), involving
SYSTEMATICS OF THERMODYNAMIC FUNCTIONS OF STATE
71
Table 1.13.1 Matrix entries for deformation of anisotropic materials A. Entries to the symmetric strain tensor
es=
exxexyexz eyxeyyeyz ezxezyezz
exx : (OSx/OX) eyy=(OSy/Oy) ezz : (OSz/OZ)
exy : (1/2)[(OSx/Oy) + (OSy/OX)] : e y x exz=(1/2)[(OSx/OZ)+(OSz/OX)]=ezx ey z : (1/2)[(OSz/Oy) + (OSy/OZ)] = ezy
B. Conventional notation for strain components
el =- exx e4 =- 2exy = 2eyx
e 2 =- eyy e5 =- 2exz = 2ezx
e 3 =_ ezz e6 =- 2eyz =- 2ezy
C. Conventional notation for stress components
o.1 -= o.xx pressure along x o.2 =- o.yy pressure along y o.3 = o.zz pressure along z
~ =- o.xy -- o.yx pressure 2_ x along y or vice versa ~ --o.xz = o.zx pressure _1_x along z or vice versa o6 = o.yz -- o.zy pressure 2- y along z or vice versa
respectively a symmetric (es) and an antisymmetric component (ea). The matrix for es ~ in the overall matrix Vs(r) - es + ea is shown in Table 1.13.1 which involves the entries eij - - ( 1 / 2 ) [ O s i / O r j + O s j / O r i ] . For the ea entries the ' + ' sign is replaced by ' - ' , so that the diagonal elements of ea vanish. ,,.,
,,.,
Consider again a dilatation of a solid in which element A at r is displaced by s(r) to A ~, and a neighboring element B at r + d r is displaced to B ~ by the operation s(r + d r ) . The A ~- B' separation distance is then d r ~ - d r + [s(r + d r ) - s ( r ) ] - d r + d r . Vs(r) - d r + d r . ( e s + e a ) . Note that e a represents a pure rotation; on rotating the coordinate system by - e a , we obtain d r ' - d r + d r 9 es in the rotated system. Here d r is the row vector [dx, dy, dz] while the es matrix is shown in Table 1.13.1. A linear dilatation along x is then specified by d x ' - (1 + e x x ) d x + eyx dy + ezx dz, with similar expressions for dy' and dz ~. Thus, the diagonal element exx of Table 1.13.1 indicates the fractional lengthening of the solid along the x-axis, and similarly, for y and z. Angular dilatations, on the other hand, involve a displacement dl whereby idl originally perpendicular to ) dl (i and ) are orthogonal unit vectors along x and y) now change into Ax - i dl + i dl . es - i(1 + exx) dl + ~
) e x y d l -q- ~:exz d l , a n d Z y =_ ) d l
q-)dl.es-
i e y x d l nt- ) ( 1 -+- e y y ) d l + ~:eyz d l .
The angle between Ax and A y in the x - y plane is specified by
COSq~xy =
('i dl + "idl . e s ) . () dl + ) dl . e s) ~ ^ ~ . li dl + i dl . es I x Ij dl + ) dl . es [
(1.13.35)
When the appropriate entries for es are introduced and an expansion is carried out to first order in eij o n e obtains (after a large number of elementary steps)
72
1. FUNDAMENTALS
Table 1.13.2 Maxwell relations for anisotropic solids; constant V
1 (0eS/) (Off/) W T -- - ~ ei
I(OS) V
~i
ei = -
(Oei) OTis
(T1.13.2.1)
V
(T1.13.2.3)
l ( O~ie)i O"i = - ( -oai ) S (T1.13.2.4) W ~
T
\ a T , ] ei
COS ~xy
"~ 2exy. Now introduce the deviation from the right angle by ~'2xy dPxy, so that c o s dl)xy,~ ff2xy ~ 2exy. Similarly F2xz ~ 2exz, F2yz ,~ 2ey z.
--
re~2-
It is conventional to introduce a more compact notation for the strain components, as shown in Part B of Table 1.13.1; also, one sets up six components of a stress tensor ff that induces the strain. Here ~Yi - - [ O ( U / V ) / O e i ] S , e j # i ; these are listed in Part C of Table 1.13.1. The element of work is then given by V Z i r dei. With these definitions the above concepts are embedded in thermodynamics by writing the differential of the energy (of the strained relative to the unstrained body) as 6
dU -- TdS + V ~ criei.
(1.13.36a)
i=1
One should note the positive sign ahead of the second term: work is done by the system as the strain is diminished. We next introduce the enthalpy by H U - ~ 6 = 1 o"i ( V e i ) . The enthalpy differential is then given by 6
6
dH - dU - V Z
ei dai - V ~
i=1
6
cri dei - Z
i=1 6
= T dS - V Z
aiei d V
i=1
6
ei doi - Z
i=1
oiei dV.
(1.13.36b)
i=1
From (1.13.36a) and (1.13.36b) Maxwell relations may be constructed in the usual manner; these are listed in Table 1.13.2. Integration of those involving the entropy differentials then specify the entropy of the solid in its dependence or ai or on ei under different conditions. Moreover, from the definition of the stress tensor it follows that
(O0"i/Oej)S,ejr i ~Cijls--(Ocrj/Oei)S,ej#i ~ c j i l s , (Ocri/Oej)T,ej#i ~
cijlT -
(Ocrj/Oei)T,ej_r ~
cjilw,
(1.13.37a)
(1.13.37b)
which are know as isentropic and isothermal elastic stiffness coefficients. The inverses (Oai/Oej)s,aj#i or (Ooi /Oej)T,aj#i represent isentropic and isothermal compliance coefficients. There also exist six thermal strain coefficients Oti
INTERRELATIONS INVOLVING HEAT CAPACITIES
73
(Oei/OT)aj and six thermal stress coefficients (~i ~ (Oai/OT)ej that deal with the temperature variations of the respective coefficients. This completes the brief survey of commonly used coefficients that characterize the deformation of anisotropic elastic solids. QUERIES AND COMMENTS 1.13.1. The imposition of a constant volume condition is actually too restrictive. It is only necessary to demand that the change of volume in the system be exactly compensated for by a corresponding change in the surroundings. This does not rule out other volume changes in the surroundings that do not affect the properties of the system. 1.13.2. Can you think of reasons why Eq. (1.13.10) is generally more readily applicable to experimental measurements than Eq. (1.13.12)? 1.13.3. Strictly speaking, one should employ different symbols to distinguish between energy as a function of S, V and as a function of T, V, but such proliferation of symbols is undesirable. What is meant should be clear from the indication of the relevant independent variables. 1.13.4. ET. Landsberg, Thermodynamics and Statistical Mechanics, Oxford University Press, 1978, Chapter 5. 1.13.5. Determine the dependence of E on V and of H on P for isentropic processes using an ideal gas. Note the resulting expressions. 1.13.6. Repeat Exercise 1.13.5, using the van der Waals gas as a working substance. In carrying out the mathematical manipulations do not attempt to solve the van der Waals equation for V(T, P), but use appropriate mathematical 'tricks' of Section 1.3, so that you can always employ the van der Waals equation in the form P = P ( T , V).
1.14
Interrelations Involving Heat Capacities
We turn to relations characterizing heat capacities. Experimentally, it is much easier to measure heat capacities at constant pressure than at constant volume; the latter inevitably changes with temperature. However, the quantity relevant to theoretical interpretation is Cv rather than C p. A relation between these may be established, beginning with the definition H = E § P V, so that
Cp = ( O H / O T ) p = (OE/OT)p + P ( O V / O T ) p .
(1.14.1)
Next, we write E = E ( T , V), so that
dE-
()
- ~E
dT +
-ff-ff T d V - Cv T §
-ff-ff T
We now differentiate with respect to T at constant P; by Eq. (1.3.5) the coefficients remain unaffected. Thus,
( ) OE 0-T
P
-- Cv +
~ T
. P
(1.14.3)
74
1. FUNDAMENTALS
Insert Eq. (1.14.3) into ( 1.14.1 ) to obtain Cp-Cvn
t-
[
P+
(1.14.4) T
P
On substitution, using Eq. (1.13.16), we find
(1.14.5) V
P
It is very difficult to measure (OP/OT)v because of the problem of keeping V fixed while varying T. Accordingly, we use Eq. (1.3.8) to write
OP)_ v
(OV/OT)p -(av/aP)v
(1.14.6)
Insertion into Eq. (1.14.5) leads to
ce - Cv - - T (aV/aT)~ (OV/OP)T
_- o t 2 V T . [3
(1.14.7)
Here ot -- V -1 (0 V/OT)p is the isobaric expansion coefficient of the material, and - - V -1 (0 V/OP)T is its isothermal compressibility. These two parameters are usually available in tabulations, so that the difference Cp - Cv can be determined. It is readily checked that for an ideal gas,
Cp - C v =nR,
(1.14.8)
where n is the number of moles of gas and R is the gas constant. Heat capacities are also useful in determining the variation of temperature with pressure or volume in isentropic processes. For this purpose introduce Eq. (1.3.8) to write
( O T ) _----(OS/OP)T--T_ ( 0 V ) , -ff-fi s (a S / a T ) p C p - ~ p
(1.14.9)
where we had invoked Eqs. (1.13.15) and (1.13.10) to obtain the final result. Once again, knowledge of the equation of state of the material and of the heat capacity at constant pressure suffice to determine the quantity of interest. It is not hard to prove in the same manner that
(OT)
_
s
(OS/OV)T_
T (OP)
-(as/ar)v-----~
(1 14.10)
-~ v"
Eq. (1.14.6) may then be introduced to substitute for the troublesome partial derivative on the right. These matters are left as exercises for the reader.
THE JOULE-THOMSON EXPERIMENT
75
The variation of heat capacity with pressure or volume is readily found by inserting Eqs. (1.13.15) or (1.13.10) into the expression o Z S / O T O P = (1/T)(OCp/OP)T --(02V/OT2)p, whence OCp OP
- -T~oT2
,
T
(1.14.11)
P
and similarly OCv OV
- T ~
-f~
.
(1.14.12)
v
Once more, the equation of state may be used to explore the indicated partial derivatives. EXERCISES
1.14.1. Determine the variation of Cp with P and of Cv with V for an ideal gas and for a van der Waals gas. Comment on your findings. 1.14.2. Determine the dependence of T on P and on V for isentropic processes using an ideal gas. Note the resulting expressions. 1.14.3. Repeat Exercise 1.14.2, using the van der Waals gas as a working substance. In carrying out the mathematical manipulations do not attempt to solve the van der Waals equation for V(T, P) but use appropriate mathematical 'tricks' of Section 1.3, so that you can always employ the van der Waals equation in the form P=P(T,V).
1.14.4. Is it not a contradiction to differentiate Cp, the heat capacity at constant pressure, with respect to pressure? How do you resolve this apparent problem?
1.15 1.15.1
The Joule-Thomson Experiment Analysis of the Joule-Thomson Effect
One of the good illustrations of thermodynamic methodology is based on the Joule-Thomson porous plug experiment; the results were also of considerable practical interest in the latter half of the 19th century, at a time when the liquefaction of gases was of great importance. Consider the passage of a gas through a porous plug in an adiabatically insulated enclosure, as shown schematically in Fig. 1.15.1. Let the gas initially be in volume V1 and at pressure P1 on the left and let it be completely transported quasistatically at constant pressure through the porous plug. Let it emerge on the right where the pressure is maintained at the constant value P2 and where the final volume is V2. This process is isenthalpic: for, the work involved in removing the gas entirely from the left is given by W1 - - f o P1 d V1 - P1 V1, while the work involved on the right is specified
76
1. FUNDAMENTALS
Fig. 1.15.1. Porous plug experiment of Joule and Thomson. (a) Initial state: the gas is on the left in volume V1 and at pressure P 1. A pressure P slightly greater than P 1 is applied to the piston to drive the gas through the porous plug. (b) Final state: the gas has been reversibly and under isenthalpic conditions forced through the plug and appears on the right-hand side in volume V2 and at pressure P2 < P 1.
by W2 - - j o ~ P2 d V2 - - P2 V2. The net work is then W - W1 -q- W2 - P1 V1 P2 V2 - - A E -
E2 - E l , since Q -
0. T h u s , E 2 + P2 V2 -
H2 -
E1 + P l V1 -
H1.
Therefore, the process, known as the Joule-Thomson porous plug experiment is isenthalpic, as claimed. It is characterized by the Joule-Thomson coefficient
rij =-- (OT/OP)H,
(1.15.1)
which correlates the change in temperature of the gas as it passes through a pressure difference across the porous plug. Depending on whether 0J > 0, r/j - - 0 , or r/j < 0, a gas will either cool, remain at constant temperature, or heat up as it passes through the plug (N.B. d P is negative). We examine the magnitude and sign of 0J using the van der Waals gas as an illustrative example. We first adopt Eq. (1.3.8) to rewrite (1.15.1) in the form rlj - - --
(OH/OP)T (OH/OT)p
= --
(OH/OP)T Cp
.
(1.15.2)
Introduce Eq. (1.13.17) into the expression (OH/OP)T -- - r I j C p to obtain (on a molar basis; V =- V/n; C =- C / n ) T
(0~)) --],)--17jCP. ~-~ p
(1.15.3)
We now adopt the van der Waals equation of state: P =
RT
a
V- b
V 2"
(1.15.4)
THE JOULE-THOMSON EXPERIMENT
77
Unfortunately, its inversion to obtain V(T, P) for insertion in (1.15.3) is algebraically very cumbersome. We thus resort to approximations. Multiply both sides of (1.15.4) by (V - b ) / P to obtain
RT P
V=
a ab Fbq-~ PV P V 2"
(1.15.5)
We regard the last three terms as 'corrections' to the perfect gas law, and in this spirit replace V on the right-hand side by R T / P to find
RT P
V-
a +b+ RT
abP (RT) 2"
(1.15.6)
Then
OV )
R
a
2abP RZT3.
P -- --~ -4 R T 2
--~
(1.15.7)
Now solve Eq. (1.15.6) for R~ P and substitute the result in (1.15.7) to obtain
OV) -~
_ V - b p
T
2a
3abP
-1 R T 2
R2T3.
(1.15.8)
When (1.15.6) and (1.15.8) are inserted in (1.15.3) one finds, on neglect of the term involving 1/T 3"
1 ~ J -- -~p
2a RT
b
3abP ) R ZT 2 "
(1 15.9) "
Under conditions where the third term does not dominate/TJ is rendered positive for 'large' a and for 'small' b, i.e., for large interatomic forces and for small effective volumes. In addition, the heat capacity should be as small as possible. These requirements must be optimized to achieve the liquefaction of gases by cooling. However, as the pressure is raised the third term in (1.15.9) becomes increasingly important, and ultimately causes rlj to pass through zero and then turn negative. Hence, the operating pressure drop across the porous plug must be chosen carefully to ensure conditions of gas liquefaction.
1.15.2
Inversion Temperature
A practical problem of interest is to determine the inversion temperature, Ti, at which r/j - 0 . According to Eq. (1.15.9) this happens when Ti satisfies the quadratic equation Ti2
2a 3a P Rb Ti -I- R---T- = 0.
(1.15.10)
78
1. FUNDAMENTALS
500 ~
400 ~
300 ~ "1 t.,.
-
~ ~ ~ ' X
E 200~ 0
9~ loo ~ 0~ -
t
" ~" I S
j
j
l
~
-100
.... _:! ......
20
._ t
60
_
I ................
100
1..= .
200 Pressure
I
..........
300 Atm.
Fig. 1 . 1 5 . 2 . J o u l e - T h o m s o n inversion curve for N2 gas; actual data as compared to predictions based on the van der Waals equation of state.
A plot of T/ vs. P, as applied to N2 gas, is shown in Fig. 1.15.2. The calculated curve is in fair agreement with experiment. Better agreement is achieved by use of more realistic approximations to the equation of state. Somewhere below 350 bar there exist two inversion temperatures that are specified by Eq. (1.15.10). For all temperatures within the curve r/j remains positive; this maps out the conditions that must be satisfied for effective cooling of a gas via adiabatic expansion through a porous plug.
1.15.3 IsenthalpsI Isenthalps can be used to establish the enthalpy of a van der Waals gas at any point in its adiabatic expansion through the porous plug. We begin with the expression (for the remainder of this section all extensive quantities will be specified as being molar variables) dH = (OH/OT)p dT + (OH/OP)T dP, whence
dH
-- Cp(T,
P)dT
-
Cprlj
dP
3abP ] =Cp(T,P)dT+ -~--~ + b + R2T2 dP.
(1.15.11)
THE JOULE-THOMSON EXPERIMENT
79
Since d H is an exact differential the cross derivatives taken in either order must match:
OCp ) _ 2a OP T RT2
6abP R2T3"
(1 15.12)
Next, carry out an indefinite integration over pressure at constant temperature"
2a Cp - R T 2 P
3ab R2T 3 p2 + L(T),
(1.15.13)
where L ( T ) is an arbitrary, unspecified function of the temperature. Then, by combining (1.15.2), (1.15.11), and (1.15.13) the Joule-Thomson coefficient may be written as
2a/RT - 3abP/R2T 2 - b
qj - -
L(T) + (2a/RT2)p - (3ab/R2T3)p 2
CP-~T--
2a/RT - b L(T) + (2a/RT2)p '
(1.15.14)
where the higher order terms have been dropped. Let the van der Waals gas be taken from an initial state T1, P1 to a final state T2, P2 in two steps: (i) Cool the gas reversibly from T1 to T2 at constant pressure P1. (ii) Expand the gas reversibly from P1 to P2 at fixed temperature T1. In executing these steps under these conditions we find. on use of (1.15.11) and (1.15.13): 0 -- AH
-
-
fT T2 Cp d T
--
1
+ f t P2 d H 1
P1
1
-R-T--2
T2
R 2 T 3 .ql_ L ( T )
d T 21-
,
- - - ~ 2 -~ N 2 T 2
Ji- b
dr.
(1.15.15) On dropping out higher order terms and taking a, b, L to be sensibly independent of temperature we can carry out the integration to obtain 0--AH=
R
T2
T1
+ L(T2 - T1) +
b
RT2 (P2 - P1).
(1.15.16)
This may be rearranged to read
LT1 + bP1
2a P1
R T~
= LT2 + bP2
2a P2
R T2
= H(T1, P1) -- H(T2, P2) = H
(a constant). (1.15.17)
80
1. FUNDAMENTALS
Thus, the quantity H ( T , P) =
2a P RT
+ L T + bP
(1.15.18)
is a constant under the assumed conditions and approximations and represents the desired isenthalp. Eq. (1.15.17) can be used to determine the variation of temperature with pressure, given a, b, H, and L. Eq. (1.15.13) may be used to fix L experimentally, and to check whether the assumption that this quantity is independent of T actually holds. If this is not the case the L ( T ) dependence must be introduced in Eq. (1.15.15) before the integration is performed. In the present case H is found by insertion of one pair of P and T values. Having thus fixed H, Eq. (1.15.17) is then employed again to trace out the general dependence of T on P. Note that, on account of Eq. (1.15.1), the slope of this curve furnishes a value of 17j for each specified set of (P, T) values. The maximum of the slope for each H curve thus determines the largest accessible value of the Joule-Thomson coefficient for a given set of conditions. In numerical work one should recall the approximations that have been introduced. More accurate results are obtained by use of fewer restrictive assumptions and of more realistic equations of state. Aside from its intrinsic interest the above discussion furnishes a nice illustration of how the methodology of thermodynamics can be used to obtain results of practical value. ACKNOWLEDGMENT
1.15.1. The author is greatly indebted to Professor James W. Richardson at Purdue University for useful discussion that formed the basis for formulating the present section.
1.16
Heat Measurements and Calorimetry
Up to now heat has been treated as a somewhat aetherial quantity, having been introduced as a deficit function that restores the balance between energy changes and work performance in a system. We complement this earlier presentation with a more meaningful description by introducing a set of units and a method for measuring heat transfers. The heat transfer was originally measured in units of calories, where one calorie was defined as the quantity of energy required to raise one gram of pure water from 14.5 to 15.5 ~ at one atmosphere. This definition has been supplanted by the introduction of the joule, which represents the energy specified by the conversion factor: 1 cal - 4.184 joules. One joule is also equivalent to the energy developed in a circuit by an electric current of one ampere flowing through a resistance of one ohm (driven by a potential difference of one volt) in one second.
HEAT MEASUREMENTS AND CALORIMETRY
81
Heat transfers are conveniently measured by calorimetric techniques. Citing Eq. (1.13.13), we write
dE-- -~
dT-+- -~ TdV"
(1.16.1)
At constant volume the second term drops out and the partial derivative in the first term may be replaced by the heat capacity at constant volume, Cv (see Eq. (1.13.15)). Then, in the absence of any other work for an infinitesimal step we may write
dE--ctQlv -CvdT,
(1.16.2a)
and in a finite step,
AE-- Q[V-- fT72CvdT= (Cv)(T2- T1),
(1.16.2b)
where the quantity in angular brackets represents an averaged value. This equation shows that the heat generated by a given process in an adiabatically insulated calorimeter may be determined by the temperature rise, once the heat capacity of the apparatus is known. This may be found by supplying a known amount of electrical energy to the system and recording the temperature increase of the calorimeter. Naturally, the actual procedures of calibration and operation are much more involved than indicated here. In fact, one cannot easily measure temperature increases at constant volume. Hence, we now consider processes at constant pressure. For this purpose one invokes Eqs. (1.13.15) and (1.13.17) to establish that (for fixed P and in the absence of any work)
dn--dale --fedT
(1.16.3a)
and
zXn- Qlp- fv : CpdT= (Cp)(T2- T1).
(1.16.3b)
The earlier remarks apply here as well, except that temperature changes are monitored at constant pressure, so that temperature changes cause no difficulties in experimental measurements. There exist many other techniques for determining heat generation and transfer, which readers are invited to explore by reference to appropriate texts and monographs. The principal purpose of the present discussion is only to outline one method by which Q or changes in energy and enthalpy may be measured.
82
1.17 1.17.1
1. FUNDAMENTALS
Determination of Enthalpies and Entropies of Materials Entropy Determinations
One of the important problems in thermodynamics involves the determination of the entropy of any material. Before considering this matter we must examine the characteristics of phase transitions. 1.17.2
Heat Transfer in Phase Transformations
Consider a material that undergoes a first order phase transition such as fusion, vaporization, allotropic transformation, and the like. In each case two phases remain in equilibrium at a fixed temperature while heat flows in or out of the system during the transition. The theoretical background for characterizing this process will be provided in Chapter 2. The energy change of the system on completion of the transition is specified by (in the absence of any work other than mechanical)
AEt-
Qt + wt - Qt - f P dV.
(1.17.1)
Transitions are generally carried out at constant pressure; we thus replace the integral by P A Vt and then obtain
AH lp - Q, Ip
(1.17.2)
The corresponding entropy change on completion of the transition is found by invoking A H -- T AS at equilibrium, 1 so that for the change in phase
Ast Ip - AHI Ip/ Tt
(1.17.3)
Henceforth we drop the P subscript. We also reintroduce Eq. (1.13.15), (OS/OT)p = C p / T , to write
$2 - S1 - fTy 2CP T dT 1.17.3
CpdlnT.
(1.17.4)
Determination of Entropies
For purposes of illustration consider a material whose entropy is to be determined as a function of increasing temperature. Let the sample undergo an otfl transition at temperature Tc~t~, melt at a temperature Tm > T,~, and boil at a temperature Tb > Tm. We wish to determine the entropy at a temperature T > Tm. For convenience we divide the temperature interval into segments 0 --+ Ta --+ Tot~ --+ Tm --+ Tb ~ T; here Ta is a temperature somewhere in the range 0-10 K, below which
DETERMINATION OF ENTHALPIES AND ENTROPIES OF MATERIALS
83
it is difficult to determine Cp accurately. We proceed by considering the various ranges separately. Between 0 and Ta one frequently resorts to the Debye theory for the heat capacity of a nonconducting solids, and extended to metals by Sommerfeld. As a first approximation one uses the relation
Cp - a T 3 + FT,
(1.17.5)
where a and Y are parameters that in principle can be specified by microscopic theories. In practice their values are usually determined empirically by plotting Cp vs. T2; the straight line has a slope a and intercept F. Fig. 1.17.1 shows three
1.6
1.2 0
E 0.8 E
Copper
~ o.4
o
1
,
2
I
,
i
4
,
6
[
l
8
1
,,,a
10
I
l ...... J~ . . . . l
!
12
14
16
L ....... I . . . .
18
4.0 93"}
f
"O
3.0 O
E E b
2.0 1.0 !
0
i
I,
2
i
[,,
4
I
6
I
..
8
1...,.~.
t
10
.
12
J.....
14
,
I..
~.
16
!
18
10 ~,
8
S
"o m O
6
E E O
4 2 I J
2
,
!
4
i
i
6
. L
l
8
.
l
10
,
!
12
,
I
14
-~ . . . . |
16
i
J,
18
T 2, deg 2
Fig. 1.17.1. Heat capacity measurements on elemental metals at low temperature. After W.C. Corak, M.P. Garfunkel, C.B. Satterthwaite, and A. Wexler, Phys. Rev. B 98 (1955) 1699.
84
1. FUNDAMENTALS
such plots for the indicated elemental metals; these show the degree to which the present analysis is applicable, and the extent of extrapolation required to determine the intercept. Inserting Eq. (1.17.5) into (1.17.4) we write
S(Ta)- S(O)- fo Ta (aT 2 + y ) d T - aT3 3 + yTa.
(1 17.6a)
As an aside, S(0) vanishes only under the conditions prescribed in Section 1.18. In the range Ta to Ta~ we obtain
S(Ta~)- S(Ta)- f r~ C~pdr, d Ta T
(1.17.6b)
that requires an empirical determination of C~ as a function of T for phase or, so that the integration may be performed. At the or/3 phase transition we write Q~t~ (Sfl -- Sot)T~# =
T~
AH~ -
-
-
Ta~
~
(1 17.6c) ~
The entropy change in the range T~ to Tm is given by
S(Tm)- s ( r ~ ) - fTf m C~P T dT "
(1.17.6d)
It is evident that the remaining contributions are as follows:
Qm (Sl -- SS)Vm =
Tm
=
A Hm
(at the melting point),
Tm
S(Tb)- S(Tm)-- f~~b Cl T dT Qb ( S v - Sl)Tb - -
Tb
S ( T ) - S(Tb)-
A Hb
Tb
T dr
(for the liquid phase),
(1.17.6e) (1.17.6f)
(at the boiling point),
(1.17.6g)
(for the gas phase).
(1.17.6h)
We then find S ( T ) - S(O) by addition of Eqs. (1.17.6a)-(1.17.6h). While this is straightforward the difference S(T) - S(O) depends on the pressure to the same extent that Cp, Q, and the various temperature ranges do. It is therefore conventional to measure, or at least report, all results under standard conditions of one bar and to let users of such information introduce corrections such as Eq. (1.13.10) to determine S(T) at other pressures. Conventionally, entropies cited for standard conditions are denoted by S O(T).
DETERMINATION OF ENTHALPIES AND ENTROPIES OF MATERIALS
85
It should be evident that a similar approach is used to find the enthalpy. Beginning with Eq. (1.17.2) and (1.13.15), we obtain under standard conditions
H~
o +. frf~ Cp,o dT 4F yT2a . + [ r . e. C~0 dT . + Qu#
H ~ 4 a T .a 4
.
J Ta
(1.17.7) We may combine the above to determine the standard Gibbs free energy according to
G~
(H~
H~
H~
- T(S~
S~
(1.17.8)
Tabulations of [G~ - H~ [H~ - H~ and of S~ - S~ are available in numerous reference works in the literature and play a large role in industrial applications. By way of illustrations we display in Fig. 1.17.2 a plot of the molar heat capacity of oxygen under standard conditions. The plot of Cp vs. In T is then used to determine the entropy of oxygen from the area under the curves. Note that the element in the solid state exists in three distinct allotropic modifications, with transition temperatures close to 23.6 and 43.8 K; the melting point occurs at 54.4 K, and the boiling point is at 90.1 K. All the enthalpies of transition at the various phase transformations are accurately known. An extrapolation procedure was employed below 14 K, which in 1929 was about the lower limit that could conveniently be reached in calorimetric measurements. 14 ~ 12
T
Liquid
t
02
10 0
E
6, 8 "13 n t~
o
&
Gas_____........
6
0
__.i17t II 1 1
2 Log T
Fig. 1.17.2. The molar heat capacity of oxygen. After W.F. Giauque and H.L. Johnston, J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 51 (1929) 2300.
86
1. FUNDAMENTALS
REMARK
1.17.1. Here we are getting slightly ahead of the logical presentation. In Chapter 2 we learn that two phases, 1 and 2, at equilibrium are characterized by the same Gibbs free energy: G1 = H1 - Tt S1 = G 2 = H 2 - Tt $2. These findings are not based on arguments developed in the present section; hence, the reasoning is not circular. 1.18
The Third Law of Thermodynamics
The Third Law deals with processes taking place close to T - - 0 ; clearly, problems arise since the integrating factor 1/ T begins to diverge at that point. We first inquire whether the state corresponding to T -- 0 can be reached. Consider a system characterized by a deformation coordinate z with a conjugate variable Z such that the element of work is given by dW = - Z d z . Then the energy of the system is expressed functionally by E = E(S, z) -- E ( S ( T , z), z); thus,
dS-
T-I(dE + Zdz)-
T - l { OEoTd T +
Z + ~
dz .
(1.18.1)
On taking second derivatives of S with respect to z and T in either order one obtains the expression
O---z
OT
-- ~
Z+ ~
.
(1.18.2)
After carrying out the indicated differentiations one obtains
OE
Z + ~
Oz
OZ
= T~.
(1.18.3)
OT
We now consider an adiabatically reversible process, since it is only under conditions of such isolation that one can hope to attain ultralow temperatures. On setting d S = 0, Eq. (1.18.1) becomes
dT = -
Z+OE/Oz
dz,
(1.18.4)
whence, by (1.18.3),
dT =-T
(OZ/OT)z dz (OE/OT)z
T(OZ/OT)z dz. Cz
(1.18.5)
The above expression carries an important general message: any adiabatic reversible process resulting in a change of thermodynamic coordinates z necessarily alters the temperature of the system. If now the heat capacity at constant z, Cz, were to remain constant at low T and if (OZ/OT)z were to be positive in this range, then it would indeed be
THE THIRD LAW OF THERMODYNAMICS
87
possible to attain the absolute zero of temperature. However, it is an experience of mankind that for all materials Cz varies with temperature a s T -a, a >7 1, as T --+ 0. Everything thus hinges on the question whether (OZ/OT)z > 0 approaches zero faster than does the quantity T 1-a which diverges at the limit T -- 0. As an experience of mankind the answer is found to be in the affirmative. It is therefore impossible to reach the limit T - - 0 . To examine the implications we note that the differential of the Helmholtz free energy A - E - TS is given by d A - - Z d z S dT. On cross differentiation with respect to z and T we obtain a Maxwell relation of the form (OZ/OT)z = (OS/Oz)~, so that Eq. (1.18.5) may be rewritten as
d T --
T(OS) dz. C z -~z T
(1.18.6)
In other words, since one cannot attain the limit T - - 0 one must require that in every conceivable situation (OS/Oz)TT/Cz --+ 0 as T ~ 0. Thus, (OS/Oz)T not only approaches zero but with Cz ~ T -a does so faster than 1 / T a - 1 . This gives rise to the principle of unattainability of the absolute zero of temperature. The statement (OS/Oz)T --+ 0 as T --+ 0 is incorporated in another Law: The Third Law of Thermodynamics asserts:
As the temperature of any system approaches the lowest possible temperature of O K the entropy of the system assumes a particular, least value when the system is in its lowest energy state. The entropy reaches this value with zero slope taken with respect to all thermodynamic deformation coordinates. One should carefully note that we do not claim that S itself vanishes at T = 0. The statement about lowest energy attends to the fact that in the cooling process to lowest temperatures excited energy states may accidentally be frozen in. This then keeps the system from attaining equilibrium, so that it cannot be properly characterized in terms of deformation coordinates. Also, any equilibrium state that remains intrinsically disordered as T ~ 0 will have a nonzero entropy; examples are furnished in the Remarks section. 1 Thus, at equilibrium in its lowest energy state the system is in its most stable configuration, for which the entropy at absolute zero, So, has the lowest possible value, whatever the coordinate z under consideration. Moreover, the lowest possible entropy is attained in the limit of vanishing slope: (OS/Oz)~ --+ 0 as T --+ 0. Despite the above disclaimer one often does set So = 0, namely when So is not altered during a given process, in which case the actual entropy change does not depend on the value assigned to So. As a simple example one may consider processes that do not involve nuclear transformations. Here the entropy at T - - 0 associated with the mixture of different isotopic species does not change. Hence, for practical purposes, we may ignore this contribution, thus allowing us to set the effective entropy at the absolute zero to zero. However, one must obviously
88
1. FUNDAMENTALS
be very careful in determining whether setting So - - 0 is justified; some counterexamples are offered in the Remarks section. 1 An important consequence of the Third Law is that it denies the existence of an ideal gas. For, as we establish in Chapter 2, its entropy is given by
S =CvlnT + RlnV,
(1.18.7)
whose derivative, (OS/OV)r = R / V does not vanish at T = 0. This fact, of course, does not prevent us from using the ideal gas law at elevated temperatures as an approximation to characterize properties of actual gases. However, it is clear that the approximation fails at low T. 2 REMARKS AND QUERIES 1.18.1. Exceptions to setting So = 0 arise whenever configurational disorder must be taken into account, as in cases where a material may be disordered or be in several states of equal energy that are frozen in at T = 0. Several instances come to mind: (a) Helium, which remains a liquid at T -- 0, unless subjected to external pressure. (b) Solid CO, H20, N20 and the like: neighboring pairs may be encountered in configurations such as CO-CO or CO-OC of nearly equal energy. At ultralow temperatures even that small energy difference may become important, and a disordered state is frozen in. On heating the disorder is annihilated. (c) Glasses or solid mixtures such as AgC1 + AgBr that may be regarded as frozen liquids or solutions, with a residual entropy of mixing. (d) Paramagnetic materials whose electronic spins remain disordered down to lowest attainable temperatures. (e) Materials in which it is important to take account of isotopic distributions or nuclear spin degeneracies, if these quantities change in a given process. 1.18.2. There is also a logical problem in the elementary derivations of the Second Law that are quoted in many textbooks. These depend on the use of an ideal gas as a working substance in Carnot cycles, that are then used in setting up the Second Law. Clearly, it is awkward to have to acknowledge at a later stage that the very existence of such a working substance is denied by the Third Law. 1.18.3. Does the van der Waals or Berthelot equation of state satisfy the requirements of the Third Law? Discuss the implications of your answer.
1.19
The Gibbs-Duhem Relation and Its Analogs
So far we have not taken into account the chemical constitution of m a t t e r ~ a subject of central importance in chemical thermodynamics. We now discuss several fundamental issues, and in subsequent sections provide a systematic thermodynamic analysis of compositional changes.
1.19.1
Partial Molal Volumes
We begin by showing how the volume of a system depends on its chemical composition in a mixture for which the mole numbers of the constituent components
THE GIBBS-DUHEM RELATION AND ITS ANALOGS
89
are specified. Consider as an example an aqueous solution containing sulfuric acid and sodium chloride at constant temperature and pressure. If we double the mole numbers of each of H 2 S O 4 , NaC1, and H20 we double the volume of the system. Thus, more generally, at fixed T and P the volume of a system should be a homogeneous function of the mole numbers n i of all species in the system, independent of the state of aggregation of each constituent. Then according to Euler's Theorem, Section 1.3,
r
(0nV/) (1.19.1)
V (T, P, n l , n2 . . . . . nr) -- i~l ni 9
T,P,nj#i
We now introduce the short-hand notation Vi =- (0 V / O n i ) T , P , n j # i to write F
V(T, P, nl, n2, ..., t / r ) - Z
ni Vi(T, P).
(1.19.2)
i=1 n
Here V/ is known as the partial molal volume of component i. It is the effective volume of one mole of that component in an infinite copy of the solution. Alternatively, this quantity may be regarded as the incremental change in volume of the solution in which temperature, pressure, and all other components are held at fixed values. In general, the volume of the mixture is not equal to the sum of volumes of the individual components. Thus, for Eq. (1.19.2) to be useful we need to find out how the individual Vi are to be determined experimentally. We shall address that problem below. A distinction must be made between the functional dependence of Vi on the mole numbers n i, and the parametric dependence of Vi on T and P; for, doubling T and P obviously does not double the volume of any mixture. These two quantities are held fixed in specifying the partial derivatives in Eq. (1.19.1). However, as T and P are assigned different sets of values (P1, T1), (P2, T2), and so forth, Vi and V change in a manner prescribed by experiment. Thus, the fact that these parameters are held fixed in a given set of partial differentiations does not preclude the partial molal volumes from changing as one passes from one set of experimental conditions to a different set. 1.19.2
A Variant on the G i b b s - D u h e m Relation
We examine a consequence of setting V -- V(T, P, n l, lows that
dV -
(I
OV dT + - ~ P,ni
~
n2, . . . ,
dP + ~r f'i dni, T,ni
i--1
n r). It then fol-
(1.19.3)
90
1. FUNDAMENTALS
which is to be compared with the differential form derived from Eq. (1.19.2): r
r
(1.19.4)
d V - Z ~" drti -F y'~rti dVl'. i=1 i=1
Consistency then demands that we set r
.idf i=1
dP,
-
(1.19.5a)
T,ni
P,ni
which for fixed T and P reduces to r
(1.19.5b)
Znid(-'z i --0. i=1
The above relations represent variants on the Gibbs-Duhem relation. Note the important point that Eqs. (1.19.5) represent constraints. One cannot arbitrarily change T, P, and the summation y~r=l n id Vi independently. Rather, the formulation (1.19.3) has consequences that are not obvious, and that must be individually examined; see below. 1.19.3
Determination of Partial Molal Volumes
We begin with the definition of the molar volume of a mixture by writing I7' = V~ ~ i ni. On introducing mole fractions we then convert (1.19.2) to the form -- ~
Xi Vi.
(1.19.6)
i
It is evident that for a one-component system 17'1- 17'k. For a binary system we differentiate V - (1 - x2)1/1 + x2 V2: -- - V 1 -~- (1 - x2) ~,~x2
(o 2)
T,P
q- f2 q- X2 ~ ~ X 2
T,P
m
-
(OV2~
-- - g l + X l -~x 2 ,] T, p --]- V2 --k-x 2 --~X2 ,] T, p
- V 2 - ~71,
(1.19.7)
where we noted that xI(OV1/OX2)T,p -Jr-x2(OV2/OX2)T,p - - 0 on account of Eq. (1.19.5b). Next, set V - xl I7'1 + x2132 and eliminate V2 from Eq. (1.19.7). This yields (1.19.8a)
gl -- V - x 2 T,P
THE GIBBS-DUHEM RELATION AND ITS ANALOGS
91
V2
i
J J J
/ ~ //......- O i
,z
O
~'''~
i I I i ! b
1 x2
Fig. 1.19.1. Plot illustrating how the partial molal volumes of components in a binary mixture may be determined by extrapolation.
Similarly, it may be shown that
(1.19.8b) This provides a means of finding the partial molal volumes: as illustrated in Fig. 1.19.1, one measures the molar volume of the solution at a set of x2 values. At the particular value x2 = b a tangent to the curve is drawn. The points of intersection of this tangent at x2 - - 0 , 1 yields the desired quantities V1 and V2 respectively. 1.19.4
A l t e r n a t i v e M e t h o d for D e t e r m i n i n g Partial M o l a l V o l u m e s
An alternative procedure draws on the definition of an apparent molal volume in a binary mixture, based on the relation V - nl ~"~ + n2d#,
(1.19.9)
where f,o is the molar volume of pure component 1. This is converted to the mass of the solution by switching to molalities m2 as the concentration unit for the solute, in terms of 1000 g of pure solvent. The total mass of the solution of density p is specified by Vp - 1000 + m zM2, where M2 is the gram molecular mass of solute. Correspondingly, for the pure solvent V~ 1P0 - 1000. Now solve
92
1. FUNDAMENTALS
(1.19.9) for ~b and substitute for V and for IP~ in the resultant expression. This yields ~b -
m2
[
n2p(m2)
M2
lO00 p(m2) - Po 1 . m2 Po
(1.19.10)
Measurements of the various quantities on the right of (1.19.10) then specifies ~. This, in turn, allows one to find V2 via Eq. (1.19.9) as
V2--
~
= ~b -+- n 2
r,P,nl
= ~b -+- m 2
T,P,nl
.
(1.19.11)
T,P
The relation V -- n 1I7'1 + n2 V2 - n117,0 + n2~b may be rewritten as gl -
g 0 nt- - - ( , -
f/r2)- g 0 -m2--
171 ~
tll
m2M1
T,P
(1.19.12)
Eqs. (1.19.11) and (1.19.12), along with (1.19.10), are now available to determine the desired partial molal volumes. 1.19.5
The Gibbs-Duhem Relation
The above treatment with respect to volume may be carried over to other thermodynamic functions in which T and P appear as parameters. Anticipating the next section, we introduce the Gibbs free energy in the form G = G (T, P, n 1, n2, . . . , nr). As in the case of the volume we assert that the Gibbs function is to be homogeneous in the mole numbers n i. We proceed by strict analogy to the above treatment of effective volumes. For a one component system we write the Gibbs free energy in the form G - n lG1. For a set of components this generalizes to G - Y~.i G i n i , where Gi represents the effective Gibbs free energy of component i in the mixture. The fact that G is to depend on the n i in the indicated form means that we must satisfy the Euler criterion by writing r
G ( T , P, n l , n2, . . . , nr) -- E
nilzi(T, P),
(1.19.13a)
i=1
where
#i=--(O~ni)r,P,ny#i is known as the
(1.19.13b)
chemical potential; the nomenclature is explained in Section 2.2.
THERMODYNAMICS OF OPEN SYSTEMS
93
The differential of (1.19.13a) may be written out as
dG - Z
ni dlzi @ Z i
lzi dni
(1.19.14a)
i
and is to be compared to the differential of G ( T , P, n l, n2, . . . , nr), namely,
dG -
dT +
lg~idni.
d P -at-
P,ni
T,ni
(1.19.14b)
i--1
We thus establish that
Z
nid~i i
dP = -S dT + V dP,
-~
(1.19.15a)
P,ni
which at constant T and P specializes to Z
ni d # i - O.
(1.19.15b)
i Both expressions are known as the G i b b s - D u h e m relation. Again, these relations impose important constraints, this time on the chemical potentials encountered in a mixture of different components. An example of such a restriction will be furnished in Section 3.14. Since G is not as readily measured as V, methods other than those discussed above for specifying partial molal volumes must be introduced to determine the chemical potentials. These procedures will be taken up at a later stage. QUERY 1.19.1. Cite an example of a system for which the following statement is incorrect: consider two systems at the same temperature and pressure containing the same chemical materials in identical amounts. When these are combined the total energy is twice that of each subsystem. What does this teach you? Explain in detail what conditions must be met so that the statement is corrected.
1.20
Thermodynamics of Open Systems
1.20.1 Thermodynamic Functions of State At this point we extend the earlier discussions to open systems, in which the mole numbers n i of the different components of a systems are allowed to change through the exchange of material with the surroundings. Thus, the various thermodynamic functions of state, V, E, H, S, A, G are now functions of these mole numbers in the manner already displayed for V and G in the preceding section.
94
1. FUNDAMENTALS
An alternative, more systematic formulation will be provided at the end of the present section. We begin by adopting Eq. (1.19.14b):
dG--SdT
+ V dP + E lZi dni.
(1.20.1a)
i
On applying the usual Legendre transformations which are designed to hold for both closed and open systems we set up the remaining functions of state
dA--S
d T - P dV + ~_~ lZi dni,
(1.20.1b)
1
i
dH -- T dS + V dP + ~
dni,
(1.20.1c)
lZi dni.
(1.20.1d)
~i
I
i
d E - T dS - P dV 4- ~ i Here we have set
T,P,njr
S, V,njr (1.20.2) In Exercise 1.20.1 it is to be shown that all four definitions for the chemical potential are identical; hence, one symbol suffices. Experimentally it is simplest to realize the process of adding dni moles of material to a system, at constant pressure, temperature and remaining mole numbers; for that reason the definition ~i = (OG/Oni)T,P,nj#i is ordinarily used. However, under different constraints another of the above definitions will need to be employed. 1.20.2
T, V,njr
S,P,njr
~
First Derivatives and Maxwell Relations
We now initiate the ordinary procedure: we carry out a single differentiation to obtain n - -
s--
Uv
() OA
-~
s,x j
v,~
-
-~
__()_ OG -~
v,x j '
, P,xj
T
-~
S,xj
--~
V,xj
-~
_(o,) -~
T,xj' n,xj
The above are obvious generalizations of Eqs. (1.13.5)-(1.13.8), which, incidentally, justifies the adoption of Eq. (1.20. l a). As before, the most useful formulations are the ones that specify S and P. Also, E and H are the appropriate functions of state under adiabatic constraints, whereas A and G are appropriate for characterizing isothermal processes. The next step involves the set of double differentiations in either order: we set (02X/OxiOxj) -- (02X/OxjOxi), with X -- E, H, A, G; x - P, V, S, T, n. This
9
9
~~
~
g
~
~~,,~oa g ~
=r
~
::r
=
~.=r"
~
~.
~"
~'~ - ~
~
~'~
9
~
~
.
~,.
9 9
< ~
b~
~"
~
0
~-~.
.~.
~
,.<
9
9
0
t~
o
',<
9
t~
t~
::r
~.~~
cr
::r
9
t~
c~
I
II
II
~1 ~
I
II
c~
c~
c~
II
II
II
~
I
II
II
,.,.
I
I
II
II
~
I
~
II
II
~..~ I ~ D
k,N.
r~
r~
r~
@
r~
@
BI
~
~
m
m
-<
m
0
o
Z
0
I m :D
96
1. FUNDAMENTALS
1.20.3
Further Generalizations
Several additional points should be noted: from G -- H - T S we deduce that /Zi
--
/-ti
--
T Si,
(1.20.5)
where Hi =--- (OH/Oni)T,P,nj#i and Si =-- ( O S / O n i ) r , P , n j # i . We also generalize the definition of heat Q as the deficit function needed so that dQ - ( d E - d W - Z i [zi dni) vanishes identically, in order that E remains a function of state. We then view the entropy change as being given by
drQ
dS = ~, T
(1.20.6)
as before; also, when only mechanical work is involved, the element of work may be generalized to read dr W - - P d V + Z
(1.20.7)
lzi dni. i
We may also rewrite the First Law in the form dE
T
OS "'-
dT +
-~
V,xi
-- P d V + Z
dV + T,xi
i
T, V,nj#i
dni] (1.20.8)
~ i dni, i
which should be compared with
dE--
OE -~
dT+ V,xi
dni. T,xi
i
(1.20.9)
T,V,nj#i
On matching coefficients we generalize Section 1.13 as -- T
=---Cv,xi,
V,xi
V,xi
T,xi
V,xi
(1.20.10a)
(1.20.10c) T,V,nj#I
Here we had introduced the appropriate Maxwell relation to arrive at (1.20.10b). Thus, we can also write d E - Cv,xi d T +
T
-~
Y,xi -- P
J
d V qL ~
Eidni. i
(1.20.11)
THERMODYNAMICS OF OPEN SYSTEMS
97
Eq. (1.20.10c) involves a short-hand symbol for the differential energy. The reader should be able to construct corresponding arguments for the enthalpy, and to derive the expressions
-- T
-~
(1.20.12a) P,xj
and dH
= Cp,xi
dT +
- T
-~
P ,x i
"Jf-V
d P 4- Zi
tSli d n i ,
(1.20.12b)
wherein fli = (OH/Oni)T,P,ni#j. We may replace (OV/OT)p,xi with otV, where ot is the isobaric coefficient of expansion. 1.20.4
Two Important Relations
We note two relations that will be extensively used in later derivations: According to Table 1.20.1, term [3], we write
( O#i ~
OP ]T,xi
-- Vi.
(1.20.13)
Also, staging with G~ T = H~ T - S we obtain H
dH
d(G/ T) - ---T~ NT ~- ~1
H
-dS-
VdP
T2 dT --1-------~.
(1.20.14)
Thus, at constant P, O(G/T)) OT
_ P,xi
H T2 "
(1.20.15a)
If we now allow G and H to depend on the {Xi } and take partial derivatives of (1.20.15a) with respect to xi at constant T and P, we obtain (on interchanging the order of the partial differentiations on the left-hand side),
( O(lzi / T ) ) OT
ISli P,xi
T 2'
a relation that will be cited frequently in our further development.
(1.20.15b)
98
1.20.5
1. FUNDAMENTALS
Extension to Nonequilibrium Processes
A more systematic presentation may be developed, which is an extension of the procedures developed in Section 1.13. We consider a very general process that couples events in the open system to those of the surroundings; the latter are designated with the subscript zero. By convention, all events in the reservoirs occur reversibly, so that the energy change in an infinitesimal step of any process in the surroundings may be written as d Eo - To d So - Pod Vo + Z
lzOi dnoi ,
(1.20.16)
i
where To and P0 are the prevailing temperature and pressure, So and V0 the entropy and volume,/x0i is the chemical potential of species i and noi, the corresponding mole number. We now invoke Eqs. (1.12.1a) and (1.12.4), so as to refer to properties of the system: for the closed unit (system + surroundings) maintained at a constant volume we find that 2 d Eo = - d E , d So =- d2 So = dl So + dO = - d S + dO, d Vo -- - d V, dnoi = - d n i . After the substitutions we obtain dE-
To d S -
PodV + Z
(1.20.17a)
lzOi dni - To dO,
i
which we rewrite in the equivalent form d E -- (To - T ) d S -
+ TdS-
(Po - P ) d V + Z(ll~oi i
PdV + Zlzidni i
- TodO.
- ll~i) dni
(1.20.17b)
This expression holds for any irreversibly executed step in which the intensive variables for the system differ from those of the surroundings. One of the limitations is the need to specify the intensive variables of the system executing processes that depart substantially from equilibrium. One possible way of addressing this problem is sketched in Fig. 1.20.1, which pertains to the temperature of a system exchanging heat with its surroundings. At sufficiently slow exchange rates most of the reservoir and most of the system are at well defined, different temperatures, while the temperature change occurs in a poor conductor of heat over a distance that is small compared to the extension of system and reservoir. Other schemes may be conceived, such as replacing the slowly varying temperature within the system by a suitably averaged value. Alternatively, T, P, and/z i may be regarded as functions of position within the system, as is done in Chapter 6. Eq. (1.20.17) then becomes a local function in which contiguous regions form the surroundings. However, as always, when the system departs
THERMODYNAMICS OF OPEN SYSTEMS
99
System
> / <
Reservoir
To
Fig. 1.20.1. Sketch of a temperature profile for the combined system and reservoir at different temperatures T and T 0. The temperature in each phase remains essentially constant over almost the entire region; the gradient in temperature develops over only a small region 1 at the interface.
extensively from its equilibrium configuration the problem of assigning a temperature becomes acute. Similar considerations apply to the other intensive variables. Lastly, if work other than mechanical is carried out, the appropriate conjugate intensive-extensive variable pairs must be included in the above formulation. This problem is taken up in Chapters 5 and 6. Clearly, under quasi-equilibrium conditions T -- To, P -- P0, /Zi = / Z 0 i , and dO = 0, so that the standard form dE-
T dS-
P dV + ~
lZi dni
(1.20.17c)
i
is recovered. The fact that this relation applies only under limiting conditions is frequently not sufficiently emphasized. Moreover, since E is a function of state we may subtract this relation from Eq. (1.20.17b) to obtain TodO - (To - T) d S -
(Po - P) d V + ~ ( ~ o i
- lzi) dni,
(1.20.17d)
i
which shows how the deficit function may be specified when entropy, volume and composition represent the relevant control variables. We next introduce the Helmholtz free energy by the relation A - E - T S, which leads to the differential form dA
-
(To -
T)dS-
(Po -
P)dV
+ ~--~(lzoi - ~i) dni i
- S dT-
P dV + ~
ll~i dni - To dO.
(1.20.18a)
i
However, the appropriate control variables for the function A - A ( T , V, {ni }) are temperature, volume, and composition. Accordingly, it is necessary to introduce these quantities as independent variables for the entropy" S - S ( T , V, {ni}). We
100
1. FUNDAMENTALS
thus write
dS -
( ) OS -~
dT +
-~
V,ni
dV +
T,ni
z(01) i
dni.
(1.20.18b)
T, V,nicj
In the above we next introduce the same substitutions that led to setting up Eq. (1.13.3d), and we also set Si ~ (OS/Orti)T,V,nj:/:i to write dA -
(To - T )
[ Cv'ni
dT +
T - (Po - P ) d V
-Jr-E
~
dV
-[- E
fl
Si d n i
]
i
+ E ( l ~ o i - l~i)dni - S d T - P d V i (1.20.18c)
~ i d n i - To dO ,
which is the desired expression for an infinitesimal change in Helmholtz free energy under nonequilibrium conditions. Here ot and fl are the isobaric thermal expansion and the isothermal compressibility coefficients respectively. The above correctly reduces to the standard form when the infinitesimal step is executed reversibly, namely, (1.20.18d)
l~i d n i .
dA - -S dT - P dV + ~
i When this is subtracted from (1.20.18c) one obtains
T - (Po - P ) d V
i
+ E(~o i
(1.20.18e)
i - lzi)dni,
which specifies the deficit function when temperature, volume, and composition are the appropriate control variables; their coefficients are experimentally accessible. Similarly, the Gibbs free energy is introduced by G - E + P V - T S, whose differential form is dG -
(To - T ) d S -
- SdT
+ VdP
(Po - P ) d V
+ ~#idni i
+ E(~o i
- TodO.
i - tzi) dni (1.20.19a)
THERMODYNAMICS OF OPEN SYSTEMS
101
Since temperature, pressure, and composition are the appropriate independent variables for the Gibbs free energy we must now write out the entropy and volume in the form S = S(T, P, {ni}) and V = V(T, P, {ni}), take their differential forms, and substitute these in Eq. (1.20.19a). Following the method used in setting up Eq. (1.13.4c), we next introduce the heat capacity at constant pressure, the appropriate Maxwell relation, as well as o~ and/3. We also introduce the partial molal entropy Si and volume Vi to obtain
dG-(To-T)ICp'n~dT-etVdP+ESidni] T i
i
i
- SdT + V dP + ~--~,#i dni - TodO,
(1.20.19b)
i
which applies to any process with the indicated control variables, and which properly reduces to the standard form when the infinitesimal step is executed reversibly, namely,
dG--SdT
+ V dP + E ll.i dni.
(1.20.19c)
Subtraction from (1.20.19b) yields
TodO--(To-T) ICp'ni d T - o t V d P + E S i d n i ] T i -(Po- P)I~VdT-flVdP
+ K ~'dni] + E ( # o i - # i ) d n i , i
i
(1.20.19d) which specifies the deficit function in terms of T, P, and ni and variables that can be measured. Lastly, we turn to the enthalpy H - E + P V. By methods now familiar we obtain
dH - (To- T ) d S - (Po - P)dV + E ( # o i - #i) dni i
+
T d S + VdP + E t z i d n i -
TdO.
(1.20.20a)
i
Since H - H(S, P, {ni}), S, P, and ni are regarded as control variables. We therefore consider the volume first in the form V - V(P, T, {ni}), then introduce the entropy as a function of the same variables" S - S(P, T, {ni }), which function
102
1. FUNDAMENTALS
we invert to read T - T ( S , P, {ni}). Lastly, we insert this expression into the equation of state: V -- V ( P , T ( S , P, {ni}), {ni}) = V ( S , P, {ni}). On taking the differential of this latter relation and substituting for d V we obtain d H -- (To - T) d S
- (Po - P)
3V -~
dS +
-ff--fi
P,ni
dP +
S,ni
dni
i
S,P,ni#j
+ y~(ld, Oi -- lzi)dni + T d S + V d e + Z[dl, i dni - TodO. i i
(1.20.20b)
This specifies the enthalpy change in an infinitesimal step under nonequilibrium conditions. When the above infinitesimal step is executed reversibly the above reduces to the standard form (1.20.20c)
lZi dni.
d H - T dS + V d P + ~
i When this is subtracted from (1.20.20b) one obtains To dO - ( To - T ) d S
- (Po-- e ) [ ( ~ S ) p , n + Z ( l d , Oi -- lzi)dni, i
idS +
( ) OV
-~
dP+~-~ S,ni
~ i
dni S,P,ni#j
]
(1.20.20d)
which completes the specification of the deficit function in terms of S, P, and n i. The integration of the various differential forms dO is not a simple matter. The subject was extensively discussed in Section 1.13 for a closed system by means of a specific example; the procedure may readily be extended to open systems, though the final formulation is then much more complicated. As in Sections 1.12, 1.13 we recognize that the state functions E, H, A, G allow us to analyze any process in terms of quantities that depend only on the initial and final configuration of the system, thus dispensing with such path-dependent quantities as heat and work. Which of the four functions are found to be useful depends on the conditions of the experiment: as an example, if a process is carried out under conditions where temperature and pressure are the relevant experimental variables then the Gibbs free energy is the quantity on which all deductions are based. EXERCISES
1.20.1. Verify that the various definitions for chemical potential cited in Eq. (1.20.2) are equivalent. Is it appropriate to define a chemical potential by the relations (OE/Oni)T,V,ni or (OH/Oni)T,V,ni .9 Document your answer fully.
EFFECT OF CHEMICAL CHANGES ON COMPOSITION
103
1.20.2. The above conditions are somewhat restrictive. We need demand only that the change in volume of the system be attributed to a compensating change in volume of the surroundings, which does not preclude other volume changes in the reservoirs from occurring. Also, for the time being, we deal solely with changes in composition that arise from a transfer of material across the boundaries of the system. Internal compositional changes are treated in the next section and in Chapter 2. 1.20.3. Could you have adopted the view that the term - Z i # i dni should have been grouped with the deficit function dQ rather than with dW ? What would be the consequences of adopting such a stance? 1.20.4. Expand on the analysis of the present section by considering types of work other than mechanical to be performed. 1.20.5. The quantity Z i ~ i dni is sometimes referred to as 'chemical work'. Do you consider this designation to be appropriate? Or should such a quantity be considered as part of the heat transfer, as suggested in Exercise 2? 1.20.6. Would it be feasible to replace the commonly used expression for the differential of the Gibbs free energy by dG -- - T dS + V dP + Z i # i dxi, where X i designates a mole fraction, and where the summation now runs over the c - 1 components? 1.20.7. Derive the following relation that is commonly used in statistical mechanics for a one-component system: (d#/dn)T,V = - ( V / n Z ) ( d P / d V ) T , n . You will need to consult several of the theorems developed in Section 1.3 and recognize that an equation of state interrelates T, P, V, n, whereas # involves T, P, and n. 1.20.8. The grand potential is defined by the relation Y2 = E - T S - Z i Izi dni, Derive expression for S, P, and n i in terms of partial derivatives involving ~ . Then discuss the utility of this function. 1.20.9. Establish the Gibbs-Duhem relation in the following form: E d ( 1 / T ) + V d ( P / T) ~ i ni d(lzi / T) -- O. 1.20.10. Would it be appropriate to introduce a Legendre transform that interchanges # and n, so that the various functions of state would involve terms of the type Y~i ni d#i ? -
1.21 1.21.1
-
Effect of C h e m i c a l C h a n g e s on C o m p o s i t i o n The Isolated System as a Black Box I
So far we have made no distinction between changes in mole numbers of constituent i that are brought about by transport of i across the system boundaries (ni) and those arising from occurrence of chemical reactions within the system ( N i). We now attend to this by writing the First Law in the form
dE-
T dS-
P dV + ~
~i
i
d(ni + Ni).
(1.21.1)
104
1. FUNDAMENTALS
Consider the special case of a closed system for which dni = 0 for all i. The resulting expression
d E - T d S - P dV
+
~-~l~i dNi
(1.21.2)
i
must be handled with care. Consider first the case of a set of reagents in the isolated system whose mole numbers Ni are kept fixed by constraints. Now let the constraints be lifted so that interactions may take place reversibly, adiabatically, and at fixed volume, without transfer of material across the boundaries. Under these conditions we must require that d S = 0 and that d E = 0, which in turn requires that
Z l ~ i dNi - 0 .
(1.21.3)
i
This result appears to be counterintuitive, especially since we normally allow the energy to depend on mole numbers, as specified by the relation E = E(S, V, {Ni }). However, this problem is apparent rather than real 2" from the viewpoint of chemistry the fundamental species in any chemical reaction are the participating atoms whose numbers are strictly conserved~witness the process of balancing any chemical equation. Thus, while the arrangement or configuration of the atoms changes in a chemical process their numbers are not altered in this process. Under conditions of strict isolation the system behaves as a 'black box'; no indication of the internal processes is communicated to the outside. 3 One should not attempt to describe processes to which one has no direct access. However, under conditions illustrated in Remark 1.21.2, even an isochoric reaction carried out very slowly in strict isolation, produces an entropy change dS - dO = Z i ~i dNi > 0. See also Eq. (2.9.3) which proves Eq. (1.21.3) under equilibrium conditions. 1.21.2
Counteracting the Isolation Problem
There is nothing to prevent us from setting up schemes that allow us to investigate the internal equilibrium state of the black box, but only by at least temporarily destroying its isolation. For example, we could lift the initial constraints to allow for an infinitesimal advancement of the reaction at constant volume, and transfer the concomitant energy in the form of heat, by an amount equivalent to the change in entropy - T d S , to the outside world. We could then reintroduce this amount of heat back into the system, corresponding to the transfer +TdS. The net process is adiabatic, but gives rise to a temperature change specified by Cv d T, where the heat capacity is that of the system. As an alternative, we could slowly and reversibly introduce an infinitesimal jet containing chemical species of appropriate composition, whose constituents are poised to interact. We then allow the reactions to proceed during the transfer stage.
EFFECT OF CHEMICAL CHANGES ON COMPOSITION
105
At the conclusion of this process the mole numbers dni of all species inside the system are now altered; also, the 'heat of reaction' has been transported across the boundaries. These events lead to a change in the energy coordinates of the system that is specified by Eq. (1.20.8). Let us specialize to the case where the volume is held fixed. That relation then reduces to
dE - T[dtS + dnS] + E
ll~i dni
i
=7"
[()OS
dT + v, i
l z
dni Jrr,v, j i
,.
= CvdT + T E Si dni + E # i dni (V fixed), i
l~i
dni
i
(1.21.4)
i
which shows the general response of the system (i.e., the energy change) in terms of an entropy change dt S triggered by the energetics of the reaction, and an entropy change dnS associated with the change in the amounts of material in the system. The former effect produces a change in temperature measured by the heat capacity at constant volume. If we now demand that the energy of the system remain constant during the above process we impose the restriction E
(lzi + r g i ) d n i
-- - E
i
Ei d n i -
-Cvdr
-
-r
diS;
(1.21.5)
i
that is, heat must be transferred across the boundaries as required to satisfy Eq. (1.21.5). This latest derivation is an illustration of the fact, previously mentioned, that there do exist processes during which the energy of a system can be held fixed, but only if the work performance (in this case, in the form of mass transfers) is compensated for by a heat exchange. As an alternative, we may contemplate the reversible jet transfer under the adiabatic conditions mentioned above. In such a situation the energy of the system is altered but in a reversible process we now demand that the entropy remain fixed. This imposes the restriction
dS-
(as) -~
dT+ E (O~ni) V,xi
i
dni - CVdT-F E S i d n i -O. T,V,nj=/:i T i
(1.21.6) Thus, the temperature of the system rises as prescribed by Eq. (1.21.6), which should be carefully contrasted with Eq. (1.21.5) and with the earlier discussion. REMARKS 1.21.1. The author thanks Professor Dor Ben Amotz of Purdue University for very insightful discussions concerning this topic.
106
1. FUNDAMENTALS
1.21.2. The problem that arises is illustrated by the following example: Two moles of hydrogen gas and one mole of oxygen gas are placed in a totally isolated container and then exposed to a platinum catalyst. The reaction to form water as a condensed phase is allowed to proceed exceedingly slowly. After a very long time interval one encounters all three species. It is difficult to argue that, as might perhaps be expected, the entropy change in this totally isolated reaction should be zero. The resolution of this paradox hinges on the definition of what is meant by a reversible reaction. Even though the reaction itself proceeds very gradually, no provision has been made to bring the system back to its original state, let alone without incurring any other changes in the universe. Thus, the process must be regarded as being spontaneous, with d S = dO > 0. This indicates that the execution of a very slow reaction is a necessary but by no means sufficient condition to guarantee reversibility. To achieve the latter one may, for example, include in the isolated system an interactive electrochemical cell (see Chapter 4) that is very slowly charged by the reaction. When the process is terminated the initial conditions may be restored by slowly running the cell backwards. In this enlarged system the entropy changes are represented by dSr + dSb = 0, where the two symbols stand for the entropy change in an infinitesimal step of the reaction and of the battery operation. More generally, to ensure reversibility of a chemical reaction one must include in the isolated system some type of storage unit to which the entropy changes may be transferred reversibly and from which they may be recovered in the reverse process. It is in this sense that the quantity d S (=- d Sr + d Sb) used in the text must be understood when dealing with isolated systems, since the ordinary differential relations for functions of state only apply under reversibility conditions. In the absence of an internal entropy reservoir the reaction within an isolated system always proceeds spontaneously. 1.21.3. In other words, the quantity d S in Eq. (1.21.2) is determined by heat transfers across the boundaries, and, as indicated in the previous footnote, is not an entropy change brought about by a purely reversible, internal rearrangement of atoms in the absence of external influences. One must recall that Eq. (1.21.2) only applies to reversible processes, for which dSr + dSb (see Remark 1.21.2) must vanish.
1.22 1.22.1
Legendre Transforms and Stability of a System Generalized Legendre Transforms
For later use we investigate some characteristics of Legendre transforms. Consider a function of state that depends solely on a set of t 4- 1 extensive variables: Y -- Y({xi}). Then t
d Y -- Z i=0
Pi dxi,
(1.22.1a)
LEGENDRE TRANSFORMS AND STABILITY OF A SYSTEM
107
with (1.22.1b)
Pi ~ (O~iXi)xjr
Now introduce a partial Legendre transform as follows: n Z(p0,
9 9 9
Pn, Xn+l .....
Xt) -- d Y ( x o , . . . , xt) - ~
n
Pi dxi - Z
i =0
t --
Xi
dpi
i =0
n
Z pi d x i - Z x i i=n+ l i=0
dpi,
(1.22.2)
(k ~< n)
(1.22.3)
(k > n).
(1.22.4)
where Eq. (1.22.1 a) had been introduced. Then, OZ(po, . . . , pn,Xn+l . . . . , x t ) ) OPs
= -x~ pj~k
and O Z ( p o , . . . , Pn, Xn+l , . . . , Xt) ) -O-Xk
-- p~ x j T~k
It follows from Eq. (1.22.1 b) that
( Op~~
02 Y
(1.22.5) x j s~k
On carrying out a second partial differentiation of Z with respect to p~ in Eq. (1.22.3) we find that
p-7) 02Z
1
(k ~< n).
(1.22.6)
In cumbersome language: the second partial derivative of the function of state Y with respect to the extensive variable x~ has a sign opposite to the second partial derivative of the partially inverted Legendre transform Z taken with respect to its conjugate variable p~. 1.22.2
Stability Conditions Based on Fluctuations
We now apply the above results to the energy function E ( S , V, n l . . . . . n t ) . To explore the effect of entropy fluctuations giving rise to slight departures from
108
1. FUNDAMENTALS
equilibration while keeping all other variables fixed we may expand E about its equilibrium value E0:
E - Eo--
-~ V,x~dS + -~( O2E ) V,x~d 2S + . . . .
(1.22.7)
The first derivative vanishes and the second must be positive to guarantee that at equilibrium E be at a minimum value consistent with the fixed constraints; we exclude here and below the trivial case d S --d2S - - 0 . Thus, on account of (1.13.1c), (1.13.15),
> O.
v,x
(I .22.8a)
Cv, i
This shows that the entropy at constant volume and composition rises with temperature, as is intuitively evident; also, it shows that the heat capacity at constant volume and composition cannot be negative. In similar fashion one may show that 02E
- -
> 0,
(1.22.8b)
S,xk
which indicates that (0 P/O V)s,x~ < 0; under adiabatic and constant composition conditions any pressure rise produces a shrinkage of v o l u m e ~ a common sense experience. In addition, > 0.
(1.22.8c)
S, V,nj:/:k
In other words, the chemical potential of species i rises as more i is added to the system at constant S, V, and constant nj~i. This, of course, is a common feature of all potential functions. The above results also show that, whatever the extensive variable, E remains convex. We now apply the same procedure to the enthalpy H = H(T, P, {ni ]): first we write [cf. (1.13.2d), (1.13.15)] > 0. OS 2
P,xk
-~
P,xk
(1.22.9a)
C P,xi
Thus, as above, a rise in temperature raises the entropy of the system during a process at constant pressure and composition. Also, the heat capacity at constant pressure and composition cannot be negative.
LEGENDRE TRANSFORMS AND STABILITY OF A SYSTEM
109
When we consider changes of H with P we must invoke Eq. (1.22.6) which addresses the change from the extensive variable V to its intensive conjugate, P. Thus, we write --
~
] S,xi
0P 2
S,xi
< O,
(1.22.9b)
> 0,
(1.22.9c)
S,xi
which is identical with Eq. (1.22.8b). We finally cite the relation
02H
an2i ) s,p,~j~
Ort i ,,l S , P , n j:/:k
with the same message as Eq. (1.22.8c), except that constant pressure conditions prevail. In a similar vein we derive the relations .
.
showing that
.
(+,)
.
v,x,
~,5-~]v,x,
Cv,xi >
U
v,x,
=
T
< 0
'
"
0, in conformity with (1.22.8a). Furthermore,
( 2A) 0V2
(1.22 10a)
/22.0b. T,xi
--
-~
r,xi
showing that the isothermal compressibility fi is positive. This relation is the analogue of Eq. (1.22.8b). Finally,
(02A~
--
~-~2i]t,V,xj~i
(Ol.ti) ~ Ol'li
> 0,
(1.22.10c)
T,V,xj~i
which is the analogue of (1.22.8c); again, the chemical potential increases with mole number of species i under the indicated constraints. Lastly, we consider the Gibbs free energy . showing
.
.
.
=
0S2 P,xi ~ P,xi - ~ P,xi that Cp,x~ is positive, as already established -
-
\5~
r,x,
T
< 0,
~
'
(1.22.11a)
in (1.22.9a). Also,
-
ap2 ~,x,
< 0
(1.22.11
b)
(1.22.11
c)
~,xi
as already established in (1.22.10b). Also, --
T,P,nj#i
> 0,
Oni ] T,P,nj#i
which is the pressure analogue of (1.22.10c).
110
1. FUNDAMENTALS
1.22.3
Virtual P r o c e s s e s in C l o s e d S y s t e m s
We next consider virtual energy changes in a closed system. Here the second order term in the expansion of E -- E(S, V) must be positive to guarantee stability and to avoid the trivial case d S - d E - O. We now introduce the symbols E ss = (02 E/O S2)v and similarly for the other partial derivatives. The stability condition then reads 1
f!
a2E -- '~[E~s(aS) 2 -Jr-2E~vaSaV -+- E v v ( a V ) 2] > O.
(1.22.12)
It will be shown in Section 2.2 that the following conditions must apply to satisfy the requirement 32E > 0" " > 0, ESS
" > 0, EVV
" " EssEvv
-
" 2> (Esv)
0.
(1.22.13)
The first two conditions duplicate Eqs. (1.22.8a) and (1.22.8b). The third condition assumes the form
(Esv)2 " < - T(OP/OV)s .
(1.22.14)
Cv
The positive fight-hand side furnishes both an upper and a negative lower bound ff for the cross derivative Esv. If desired the quantity (OP/O V)s may be rewritten via Eq. (1.3.8) in terms of partial derivatives that involve the entropy. Similar arguments may be advanced for virtual changes involving the other thermodynamic functions of state. However, one must be careful: for example, virtual changes in the Helmholtz function assume the form ,, aT aV + Avv ,, a 2 A - ~1 [ - A T,,T ( a T ) 2 + 2ATv
(aV)2] > 0 '
(1.22.15)
where we recognized that the Legendre transform interchange of S with T requires a sign change in the indicated second partial derivative. In fact, we write
--ART --
v
= ~ >0 T
Avv - - '
- f l V > 0,
(1.22.16)
T
in conformity with (1.22.8a) and (1.22.10b). Also,
(A}v)2
<
,,
(aS)
3P) P --~ r
_
Cp
flVT'
(1.22.17)
which establishes an upper and negative lower bound for the cross derivative. The reader should take the time and trouble to use the above arguments to find the second derivatives of the enthalpy and of the Gibbs free energy functions so as to establish analogues of Eqs. (1.22.13), (1.22.14) and (1.22.16), (1.22.17).
111
Chapter 2 Equilibrium in Ideal Systems
2.0
Thermodynamics of Ideal Systems with Several Components and Phases
In the preceding chapter we have considered in general terms the fundamental principles of thermodynamics that govern any physical process. We now specialize to ideal systems in which several components coexist in one or more phases. We proceed gradually from the simple equilibrium conditions to more complex cases, noting the underlying thread that if equilibrium is to prevail the system must be subject to constraints, all of which are ultimately based on Gibb's criterion: at equilibrium the chemical potential of a given species must be the same in all phases.
2.1
Coexistence of Phases: The Gibbs Phase Rule
We examine here the very stringent constraints which arise when two or more distinct phases are to be maintained in equilibrium. We note that equilibrium between two or more phases, considered as coexisting open systems with no rigid partitions, requires minimally the uniformity of temperature and of pressure throughout the entire system. This makes it apposite to deal with the Gibbs free energy as the appropriate function of state. We also restrict ourselves to mechanical work; the generalization to other types of work is taken up later. We finally assume that each of the c components is encountered in every one of the p phases; removal of this constraint is considered in Exercise 2.1.1. Thus, let the total Gibbs free energy be written as G - G ~+ G tl + . . . + G (p),
(2.1.1)
in which G ~ G ~ G (p) a r e the corresponding quantities in phase 1 2, ,p As discussed in Section 1.13, the condition for equilibrium is specified by setting ~
9
9
9
~
~
.
.
.
.
112
2. EQUILIBRIUM IN IDEAL SYSTEMS
the Gibbs free energy at a minimum, with 6G -- 0; hence,
6G - 3G I + 3G" + . . . + 3G (p) --O,
(2.1.2)
which is, however, is minimally subject to the following restrictions: T -- 0,
8 P -- 0.
(2.1.3a,b)
Consider initially the various phases in isolation; in particular, for phase 1, identified here by the prime symbol, C
8G O' -- _so'STO' + vO'spO' + Z l Z ~
0'.
(2.1.4)
i=1
The superscript 0 serves as a reminder that we deal with isolated phases, each at its own temperature T ~ pressure p0, and with mole numbers n o that generally differ in each of the phases. Observe that 2 + c - 1 - c + 1 independent variables are present in Eq. (2.1.4), namely T, P, and the c - 1 mole fractions constructed from the c mole numbers. The total number of variables associated with the p isolated phases, involved in the sum 3G ~ + . . . § 3 G O(p)t, is thus p(c + 1). We now combine all phases and allow thermal, mechanical, and chemical equilibrium to take place throughout the composite system. The temperatures T, pressures P, and mole numbers n i now differ from the values that obtained when the phases were isolated. From Eqs. (2.1.2) and (2.1.4) we find for the new set of variables:
3G--(SI3T
I + S ' 3 T " + . . . + S(P)3T (p))
+ (V'3P'+ V"3P"+... +
+
+ V(P)6P (p))
+... +
+
+""
+""
+ (lZ'cgn'c + lz~gn~ + . . . + lz~P)3n~p)) --O.
(2.1.5)
One must now consider the constraints. On account of the uniformity of temperature and pressure we set
T t- T'=...=
T (p) =-- T
or
3T ~ - 3T" . . . .
- - 6 T (p) - - a T -
O, (2.1.6a)
P~-- P ' = - . . =
P(P) =~ P
or
8pI _ 8 p , = ... = 3p(p ) =~ 3P -- O. (2.1.6b)
and
COEXISTENCE OF PHASES: THE GIBBS PHASE RULE
113
This set of requirements guarantees constancy of T and P for every phase. On applying this constraint the first two bracketed terms in the first two lines in Eq. (2.1.5) are found to vanish. A second set of constraints arises by imposing the conservation of mole numbers for every component in the overall closed system: n l - - n tl + n tlt + - - . + n
(lp) or
3n t1 + 6 n ttl + . . . + 6 n
or
nc - n c + n c + . . . + n
(~nc + 6n c + . . . +
(lp) = - - 6 n 1 - - 0 ,
=- (~nc - O. (2.1.6c)
From (2.1.6c) it is seen that if we wish to set 6G - 0 , with 8T -- 6 P --0, then in Eq. (2.1.5) we must also require that /zlt -- #1tt = " " = / z (lp) = / z l , /z I
2~
/z II
2~'"~
/z~p)
~ k 62,
9
~
~
o
#c
I
-- #c
,
--'"--
/z~p)
=
#c.
(2.1.7)
For, in these circumstances Eq. (2.1.6c) applies, so that the conditions 3nl 6n2 . . . . . 6nc - 0 hold. Thus, when Eq. (2.1.7) is imposed as a requirement, Eq. (2.1.5) is identically satisfied: 6 G - 0 for the entire system at equilibrium. We have thus arrived at a very important necessary and sufficient condition which characterizes the equilibrium conditions among phases: A s i d e f r o m uniform i t y o f t e m p e r a t u r e a n d pressure, one requires that the c h e m i c a l p o t e n t i a l lzi f o r e a c h one o f the c c o m p o n e n t s be the s a m e t h r o u g h o u t all p p h a s e s .
We can also calculate the number of degrees of freedom f for the assembly of phases. As stated earlier, if the phases were all separate systems, p ( c + 1) independent variables of state would have to be specified. However, after establishing equilibrium among the phases one must take account of the 2(p - 1) constraints of Eq. (2.1.6a) and (2.1.6b) to ensure uniformity in T and P, and one must note the c ( p - 1) interrelations in Eq. (2.1.7). The totality of constraints therefore is (c + 2)(p - 1). The number of degrees of freedom remaining is then f - p ( c + 1) - (c + 2)(p - 1) - 2 4- c - p.
(2.1.8)
Equation (2.1.8) specifies the famous p h a s e rule o f G i b b s (1875-1878). Knowing the number of components and phases in a given system, and assuming that T and P for the system as a whole are uniformly variable, Eq. (2.1.8) indicates how many state variables may be independently adjusted over limited ranges without altering the number of phases of the system. The ramifications of the phase rule will be discussed in Section 2.3.
114
2. EQUILIBRIUM IN IDEAL SYSTEMS
Further insight regarding the concept of the chemical potential may be obtained by considering a two-phase, one-component system at fixed temperature and prest t tt t/ t tt sure, for which G - n 1# 1 + n2/z2" Suppose now that at some instant # 1 > # 1" The system can then not be at equilibrium; instead, spontaneous processes will occur that move the system closer to equilibrium, which ultimately results in the equalization of #1t and/z t1/ . At constant T and P this can occur only by a transfer of matter from one phase to the other, Let there be a transfer of - d n ' l - +dnl" > 0 moles from phase ~ to phase "; then d G - (#~( - / Z l )t d n l , where we have set tt dn 1 =- dnt[. Since we assumed #1t > #1, the preceding relation shows that d G < 0 in this case; i.e., matter is transferred spontaneously from the phase of higher chemical potential to the phase of lower chemical potential. Thus, a difference in chemical potential represents a 'driving force' for transfer of chemical species, rather analogous to the difference of electrical potential that is a 'driving force' for electrically charged species. As for an electrical potential, equilibrium is achieved only by an equality of the chemical potential for the species in question throughout the entire system. Just as the relative magnitudes of electrical potentials determine the direction of current flow between the two conductors, so the relative magnitudes of chemical potentials of a given component in two phases in contact determine the direction of transfer of the component between the phases. These considerations will be put on a firmer footing in later discussions. EXERCISES
2.1.1. How must the Gibbs phase rule be modified to take account of the following cases: (a) A multiphase system is placed between two charged parallel condenser plates? (b) One or more of the components are absent from one or more of the phases present? (c) Several distinct regions of the system are maintained at different pressures by means of semipermeable membranes? Document your answers fully. 2.1.2. How must the derivation of the Gibbs phase rule be modified if work other than mechanical P - V work is performed on or by the system? (Hint: classify these degrees of freedom with P and V and proceed with an expanded derivation.) 2.1.3. What tacit assumption has been made in proceeding from Eq. (2.1.1) to Eq. (2.1.2)?
2.2
Achievement of Equilibrium
A basic problem in thermodynamics consists in determining the final equilibrium state that an isolated system reaches after starting out from a given set of initial conditions and constraints. In this matter we are guided by two corollaries of the First and Second Laws; namely, that in an isolated system subjected to any change the entropy cannot decrease, and that its energy must remain constant. These requirements may not be sufficient to determine the final equilibrium state, in which case other experimental data or additional constraints must be inserted to provide a unique solution to the problem.
ACHIEVEMENT OF EQUILIBRIUM
2.2.1
115
C h a r a c t e r i z a t i o n of H e a t F l o w
We now examine several equilibration processes in detail. The first relates to thermal conditions which prevail when two adjacent isolated systems, designated as ' and ", initially at temperature T' and T ' , are equilibrated, after allowing their rigid adiabatic partition to become slightly diathermic (see Fig. 2.2.1). The restriction that the compound system remain isolated and that the energies and entropies be additive yields the relations (ignoring interfacial contributions) or
E'+E"=Et
dE '+dE'=0,
(2.2.1)
and
S--S'(E',V')+S"(E",V")
(2.2.2)
If the walls are rigid we also require d V ' = d V " = O. In an infinitesimal exchange of heat between the two subsystems,
)
( OS~ dE' + d S -- \ OE, v'
(0,,,) OE"
v"
d E " >~O.
(2.2.3)
On account of Eq. (2.2.1) and the relation (OE/OS)v = T, Eq. (2.2.3) now reads dS--
(1 l) T'
T"
d E ' >~0,
(2.2.4)
which immediately establishes the requirement T' -- T" as a necessary condition for thermal equilibrium; this confirms what is already known. Also as the system approaches its equilibrium value the entropy will increase towards its final maximum. In now differentiating with respect to time t we find )-
T'
T"
~
~>0.
(2.2.5a)
> /<
Fig. 2.2.1. Temperature profile for the flow of heat between a region at temperature T p and a second region at temperature T", separated by a narrow transition region of cross section A and length 1.
116
2. EQUILIBRIUM IN IDEAL SYSTEMS
Here S = dS/dt represents the rate of entropy production during the energy transfer; this quantity cannot be negative and it vanishes at equilibrium. In the present case no work has been performed; therefore, all energy changes involve solely heat transfers. It is therefore reasonable to equate dE~/dt with the rate of heat flow, .Q, across the internal boundary. We thus rewrite Eq. (2.2.5a) as ~d-- A(1/T)Q. Next, we define a heatflux by the relation Jo - Q/A, where A is the cross-sectional area of the diathermic partition. Note that by Eq. (2.2.5a) and Fig. 2.2.1, when d E~/dt is positive, Ja involves a heat flow into system ~. We also suppose that the temperatures T ~ and T ~ are very nearly constant in both compartments and that the changeover from T t to T" takes place only over a small distance 1 perpendicular to the partition (see Fig. 2.2.1). Then the product A1 roughly defines a volume V over which the temperature changes occur; thus, we may write S - A (1 / T) V JQ / 1. In the limit of small 1 the ratio A (1 / T) / 1 becomes the gradient V ( 1 / T ) ; also, S / V = 0 is the rate of entropy production per unit volume, which turns out, as seen later, to be a quantity of great theoretical interest. Eq. (2.2.5a) has thereby been rewritten in the more fundamental form
0 -- V(1/T)JQ >~O.
(2.2.5b)
The preceding chain of reasoning is obviously very crude; for a proper derivation of Eq. (2.2.5b) the reader is referred to Chapter 6. We can nevertheless proceed with several interesting deductions involving irreversible thermodynamics without having to cope with the full machinery of Chapter 6. An important aspect of Eq. (2.2.5b) is the fact that JQ and V ( 1 / T ) = F r are conjugate variables, in that they occur as the product of a flux JQ and a generalized (thermal)force, or affinity Fr, in the expression 0 -- F r Jo. Note that 0 > 0 means either that F r > 0, JQ > 0 (i.e. T ~ < T") or that F r < 0, JQ < 0 (i.e. T ~ > T ' ) ; in either case heat flows spontaneously from the region of higher to the region of lower temperature. This is not exactly news, but a