Theory of Concentrated Vortices
S.V. Alekseenko · P.A. Kuibin · V.L. Okulov
Theory of Concentrated Vortices An Introd...
275 downloads
1783 Views
10MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Theory of Concentrated Vortices
S.V. Alekseenko · P.A. Kuibin · V.L. Okulov
Theory of Concentrated Vortices An Introduction
With 233 Figures and 12 Tables
Professor S.V. Alekseenko Professor P.A. Kuibin Professor V.L. Okulov Russian Academy of Sciences Siberian Branch Institute of Thermophysics Lavrentyev Avenue 1 630090 Novosibirsk Russia
Translated from the first Russian Edition “Bведенuе в meopuю кoнценmpupoвaнныx вuxpeй” (Hoвocuбupcк, Iнcmumym menлoфuзuкu CO PAH, 2003).
Library of Congress Control Number: 2007930219 ISBN 978-3-540-73375-1 Springer Berlin Heidelberg New York This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9, 1965, in its current version, and permission for use must always be obtained from Springer. Violations are liable for prosecution under the German Copyright Law. Springer is a part of Springer Science+Business Media springer.com c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2007 The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Typesetting: by the author Production: Integra Softwares Services Pvt. Ltd., India Cover design: Erich Kirchner, Heidelberg Printed on acid-free paper
SPIN: 11371441
543210
Preface
Vortex motion is one of the basic states of a flowing continuum. Interestingly, in many cases vorticity is space-localized, generating concentrated vortices. Vortex filaments having extremely diverse dynamics are the most characteristic examples of such vortices. Notable examples, in particular, include such phenomena as self-inducted motion, various instabilities, wave generation, and vortex breakdown. These effects are typically manifested as a spiral (or helical) configuration of a vortex axis. Many publications in the field of hydrodynamics are focused on vortex motion and vortex effects. Only a few books are devoted entirely to vortices, and even fewer to concentrated vortices. This work aims to highlight the key problems of vortex formation and behavior. The experimental observations of the authors, the impressive visualizations of concentrated vortices (including helical and spiral) and pictures of vortex breakdown primarily motivated the authors to begin this work. Later, the approach based on the helical symmetry of swirl flows was developed, allowing the authors to deduce simplified mathematical models and to describe many vortex phenomena. The major portion of this book consists of theoretical studies of vortex dynamics. The final chapter presents detailed results of experimentally observed concentrated vortices that provide the basis for analysis and stimulate development of vortex theory. The mathematical description of the dynamics of concentrated vortices is hindered by the requirement to consider three-dimensional and nonlinear effects, singularity, and various instabilities. For each particular problem, very different coordinate frames and equation systems must be used. Therefore the authors decided to open the work with a description of the basic laws of vortex motion and list in detail the flow equations of incompressible fluids1 in various reference systems (Chapter 1), even though this material may also be found in other books on fluid flow. Special attention is paid to flows with helical symmetry2, because the condition of helical symmetry makes it possible to simplify appreciably the formulation of problems and their solution, representing at the same time the properties of real flows, as shown in Chapter 7. When possible, all mathematical trans1
More detailed description of special models of compressible fluids flow can be found, for instance, in the work by Ovsyannikov (1981). 2 Additional information can be found in the book by Vasyliev (1958).
VI
Preface
formations and analytical calculations, both in the first and subsequent chapters, are fully presented for the reader’s information and convenience. Chapter 2 can be considered as the key section, since it describes an infinitely thin vortex filament - the fundamental object of the vortex motion theory. The Biot-Savart Law, that is the fundamental law of vortex filament dynamics, as well as the self-induction mechanism of the filament motion are also presented in the second Chapter. Chapter 3 deals with principle models of vortex structures, which are of interest in themselves but also serve as a basis for considering more complex problems in the following chapters. Chapter 4 is devoted to stability analyses and waves on columnar vortices. The analyses have been carried out mainly using linear approximations. This allowed the authors to obtain exact solutions for different types of basic vortices and various modes, such as axially symmetric and bending modes. Chapter 5, titled “Vortex Filament Dynamics”, presents approximate methods of description because strongly nonlinear perturbations of vortex filament are addressed and analyzed therein. The principal approximate approaches used are the cut-off method and force balance method. A number of examples are presented, including Hasimoto soliton. An introduction to vortex methods of flow calculation is presented in Chapter 6. Various mechanisms of vortex interactions are described and discussed. The possibilities of using vortex methods are shown for modeling the nonlinear stage of instability development in shear flow, such as a classical shear layer, a starting vortex and a wake behind a plane. A model for the initiation of vortex precession in a cylindrical tube is proposed. In Chapter 7, which is based predominantly on the works of the authors and their colleagues, experimental results on observations of concentrated vortices obtained using laboratory equipment are shown. The major aim of this section is to show the existence of helical symmetry in real swirl flows and to illustrate theoretical fundamentals by means of experimental examples of elongate concentrated vortices. The authors hope that this book will serve as an introduction to the theory of concentrated vortices and will be helpful for experts interested in vortex dynamics. Some of the authors results presented in this book were supported by The Russian Foundation for Basic Research (RFBR) under the grants 9402-05812, 96-01-01667, 97-05-65254, 00-05-65463, 01-01-00899; Grant of The President of The Russian Federation for the Support of Young Professors - 96-15-96815, grant 95-1149 by RFBR-INTAS, grant 00-00232 by INTAS, and grant 00-15-96810 by The Council for the Support of Leading Research Schools. All of these grants are gratefully acknowledged. The authors also would like to express their sincere gratitude to Mrs. E. Trifonova and Mrs. V. Bykovskaya, who kindly undertook the hard work of the manuscript preparation.
Contents
Introduction................................................................................................ 1 1 Equations and laws of vortex motion .................................................... 9 1.1 Vorticity. Circulation........................................................................ 9 1.2 Dynamics of vortical fluid .............................................................. 13 1.2.1 Equations of ideal fluid motion ............................................... 13 1.2.2 Theorems of motion for an ideal vortical fluid........................ 15 1.2.3 Bernoulli theorem .................................................................... 18 1.2.4 Equations of viscous fluid motion ........................................... 19 1.3 Equations of fluid motion in orthogonal coordinates ..................... 20 1.3.1 Arbitrary orthogonal system of curvilinear coordinates .......... 20 1.3.2 Cartesian coordinate system .................................................... 23 1.3.3 Cylindrical coordinate system ................................................. 24 1.3.4 Spherical coordinate system .................................................... 26 1.4 Special cases of vortex motion ....................................................... 28 1.4.1 Helical flows (Beltrami flows) ................................................ 28 1.4.2 Two-dimensional flows ........................................................... 30 1.4.3 One-dimensional flows............................................................ 37 1.5 Flows with helical symmetry.......................................................... 39 1.5.1 Derivation of equations ........................................................... 39 1.5.2 Flow with helical vorticity....................................................... 40 1.5.3 Helical flows with helical symmetry of the velocity field....... 43 1.6 Velocity field at specified distribution of sources and vortices...... 45 1.7 Vortex forces and invariants of vortex motion ............................... 49 1.7.1 Vortex forces ........................................................................... 49 1.7.2 Vortex momentum and vortex angular momentum................. 56 1.7.3 Kinetic energy ......................................................................... 61 1.7.4 Helicity .................................................................................... 62 1.7.5 Invariants of two-dimensional flows ....................................... 64 2 Vortex filaments.................................................................................... 69 2.1 Geometry of vortex filaments......................................................... 69 2.2 Biot – Savart law ............................................................................ 73 2.3 Rectilinear infinitely thin vortex filament ...................................... 76
VIII
Contents
2.3.1 Vortex filament in ideal fluid .................................................. 76 2.3.2 Vortex filament diffusion ........................................................ 80 2.4 Self-induced motion of a vortex filament ....................................... 82 2.5 Infinitely thin vortex ring ............................................................... 86 2.6 Infinitely thin helical vortex filament ............................................. 91 2.6.1 Helical vortex filament in infinite space.................................. 91 2.6.2 Helical vortex filament in a cylindrical tube ........................... 96 3 Models of vortex structures ............................................................... 111 3.1 Vortex sheet.................................................................................. 111 3.2 Spatially localized vortices ........................................................... 116 3.2.1 Vortex ring............................................................................. 116 3.2.2 Hill’s spherical vortex ........................................................... 124 3.2.3 Hicks spherical vortex ........................................................... 127 3.3 Columnar vortices in ideal fluid ................................................... 134 3.3.1 Rankine vortex....................................................................... 134 3.3.2 Gauss vortex .......................................................................... 136 3.3.3 One-dimensional helical flow................................................ 136 3.3.4 One-dimensional (columnar) helical vortices........................ 137 3.3.5 Q-vortex................................................................................. 145 3.3.6 Helical vortex with a finite-sized core................................... 146 3.4 Viscous models of vortices........................................................... 149 3.4.1 Burgers vortex ....................................................................... 149 3.4.2 Sullivan vortex....................................................................... 153 4 Stability and waves on columnar vortices ........................................ 155 4.1 Types of perturbations .................................................................. 155 4.2 Intsability of a vortex sheet........................................................... 157 4.3 Waves in fluids with solid-body rotation...................................... 160 4.3.1 Plane waves ........................................................................... 160 4.3.2 Axisymmetrical waves .......................................................... 165 4.3.3 Taylor column ....................................................................... 167 4.4 Linear instability of Rankine vortex with an axial flow ............... 170 4.4.1 Dispersion relationships ........................................................ 170 4.4.2 Linear analysis of temporal instability .................................. 176 4.4.3 Linear analysis of spatial instability ...................................... 185 4.5 Kelvin waves ................................................................................ 186 4.5.1 Dispersion equations ............................................................. 187 4.5.2 Axisymmetric mode, m = 0 ................................................... 188 4.5.3 Bending mode, m = 1 ............................................................ 190 4.5.4 Evolution of initially localized perturbations. Mechanisms of wave propagation .................................................. 194
Contents
IX
4.6 Instability of Q-vortex. Instability criteria ................................... 202 4.6.1 Instability criteria................................................................... 202 4.6.2 Instability of Q-vortex. Inviscid analysis .............................. 204 4.6.3 Instability of Q-vortex. Viscous analysis .............................. 211 4.7 Linear and nonlinear waves in columnar vortices (like Q-vortex).................................................................................... 214 4.7.1 Axisymmetrical nonlinear standing waves............................ 215 4.7.2 Axisymmetrical weakly-nonlinear traveling waves .............. 220 4.7.3 Bending waves....................................................................... 225 5 Dynamics of vortex filaments............................................................. 235 5.1 Cut-off method ............................................................................. 235 5.2 Self-induced motion of helical vortex filament with an arbitrary pitch .......................................................... 243 5.3 Hasimoto soliton........................................................................... 257 5.4 Application of momentum balance to description of vortex filament dynamics ............................................ 267 5.4.1 Forces acting on a vortex filament......................................... 267 5.4.2 Derivation of force-balance equations................................... 270 5.4.3 Hollow vortex ........................................................................ 279 5.4.4 Vortex filament with an inner structure................................. 282 5.4.5 Consideration of the inner core structure............................... 287 5.4.6 Modified equations of vortex filament motion ...................... 290 5.5 The method of matched asymptotic expansions ........................... 291 5.5.1 Derivation of the equation for vortex filament motion.......... 292 5.5.2 Local induction approximation.............................................. 297 5.5.3 N-soliton solution.................................................................. 300 5.5.4 Comments.............................................................................. 306 6 Dynamics of two-dimensional vortex structures .............................. 309 6.1 The method of discrete vortex particles........................................ 309 6.1.1 Motion equations of vortex particles in infinite liquid .......... 309 6.1.2 Motion equations of vortex particles in limited simply-connected domains............................................. 316 6.1.3 Motion equations of the system of co-axial vortex rings....... 324 6.2 Motion of the system of rectilinear vortices ................................. 328 6.2.1 Interaction of two identical vortices at various initial distances............................................................... 329 6.2.2 Interaction of two vortices of the same size but with different circulations......................................................... 332
X
Contents
6.2.3 Interaction of two vortices of the same circulation but with different sizes ................................................................... 332 6.2.4 Interaction of three vortices with circulations of the same sign .......................................................... 333 6.2.5 Interaction of two vortices with circulations of contrary signs.......................................................... 334 6.2.6 Interaction of three vortices with circulations of contrary signs. Vortex collapse .............................. 338 6.3 Modeling the dynamics of shear flows......................................... 341 6.3.1 Mechanisms of formation for the large vortices in the shear layer ................................................ 341 6.3.2 Instability of a starting vortex................................................ 347 6.3.3 Wake instability behind a thin plate ...................................... 357 6.4 Motion of vortices in cylindrical tubes......................................... 366 6.4.1 Motion equations for vortex particles in a circular domain... 367 6.4.2 Precession of a rectilinear vortex in a tube............................ 368 6.4.3 Motion of a helical vortex in a tube....................................... 374 7 Experimental observation of concentrated vortices in vortex apparatus ................................................................................................ 379 7.1 Experiment methods ..................................................................... 379 7.1.1 Experiment equipment........................................................... 379 7.1.2 Parameters of a swirling flow................................................ 383 7.2 Helical symmetry of vortex flows ................................................ 386 7.3 Concentrated vortex with a rectilinear axis .................................. 390 7.3.1 Generation of concentrated vortices ...................................... 390 7.3.2 Vortex composition ............................................................... 403 7.4 Precession of a vortex core ........................................................... 409 7.5 Stationary helical vortices ............................................................ 417 7.5.1 Single helical vortices............................................................ 417 7.5.2 Double helix .......................................................................... 422 7.6 Perturbations of a vortex core....................................................... 426 7.6.1 Waves on concentrated vortices ............................................ 426 7.6.2 Vortex breakdown in a channel ............................................. 431 7.6.3 Vortex breakdown in a container with a rotating lid ............. 445 References............................................................................................... 467 Index ....................................................................................................... 485
Nomenclature
A A a c cg d E er, eθ, ez
H I Im, Km i, j, k k L L1, L2, L3 l M m p Q R R r, θ, z Re
amplitude vector potential radius phase velocity group velocity diameter Euler constant triple of unit orthogonal vectors in a cylindrical coordinate system force frequency, function mass force helicity Bernoulli constant, Hamiltonian vortex momentum modified Bessel functions triple of unit orthogonal vectors wave number, parameter cut-off length Lame coefficients helix pitch vortex angular momentum azimuthal wave number pressure flow rate radius radius-vector cylindrical coordinate system Reynolds number ( = Wd/ν)
Ri
Richardson number ⎜ =
F f g
H
Ro
⎛
g dρ ⎛ dW ⎞ ⎜ ⎟ ρ dr ⎝ dr ⎠
⎜ ⎝ ⎛ Wk ⎞ Rossby number ⎜ = ⎟ ⎝ 2Ω ⎠
−2
⎞ ⎟ ⎟ ⎠
XII
Nomenclature
S s T t t, n, b
area, swirl parameter arc length, distance kinetic energy, tension force, parameter time triple of unit orthogonal vectors (tangent, normal and bi-normal) U, V, u, v velocity vectors u, v, w, U, V, W velocity vector components in Cartesian cylindrical coordinate systems V volume W complex potential x, y, z Cartesian coordinate systems z complex variable (= x + iy, = z1 + iz2) Greece symbols α, β Γ δ( ) ε θ κ ν ρ τ ϕ χ ψ, Ψ
angles, parameters circulation, vortex intensity Dirac's delta-function vortex core radius, small parameter complex variable (= ξ + iη, = ζ1+ iζ2) phase, angle curvature kinematic viscosity, parameter radius, density torsion, relative pitch potential, angle variable (= θ – z/l) vortex sheet intensity stream function vorticity, frequency vorticity vector frequency, solid angle angular velocity
Bold type signifies complex or vector character.
Introduction
The class of concentrated vortices is distinguished among a great diversity of vortex flows and attracts attention from the point of fundamental research and practical applications. There is no an accurate definition for a concentrated vortex (actually, there is no concept of vortex in general). A concentrated vortex can be rigorously defined for an ideal fluid: this is a space-localized zone with non-zero vorticity surrounded by potential flow. Certainly, this definition does not cover the observed multitude of vortex phenomena. In this book, we would rely more on intuitive comprehension, taking concentrated vortices to be the vortex motion for which the vorticity is bound to spatial zones with localization occurring for at least one dimension. The most illustrative examples of concentrated vortices are the following idealized objects: vortex sheet (localization in one dimension), infinitely thin vortex filament and its 2D analog – point vortex (localization in two dimensions), infinitely thin vortex ring of a finite diameter – closed vortex filament, vorton (localization in three dimensions). The more complex objects – a columnar vortex of Rankine vortex type (constant vorticity in a core of finite radius), fat vortex ring, Hill's vortex, and Hicks vortex – all of them have a non-zero volume with non-zero vorticity. In more complex cases vorticity is non-zero over the entire space; nonetheless a vortex core is easily distinguishable by much higher vorticity than in the rest of space. This is typical for viscous flow when vorticity diffusion takes place, and the Burgers vortex is a classic example. A great variety of vortex flows can be realized in nature and technology. Many of them can be interpreted as concentrated vortices depending on the extent of their similarity to the above mentioned idealized objects. Undoubtedly, one of the most common types of concentrated vortices is a columnar vortex, or filament-type vortex. This is supported by Table I.1, presenting a short list of similar phenomena, along with some illustrations (Figs. I.1–I.4, Color Fig. I.11). This book focuses mainly on the mentioned types of vortex motion. Alternatively, these vortices are also termed the elongate concentrated vortices. In addition, vortex rings are considered as well (Fig. I.5), since in many aspects they are similar to elongate vortices, 1
All figures in color are available in Color plates.
2
Introduction
as well as point vortices. The analysis of the dynamics of point vortices would help us to explain some features of elongate vortices, especially when they interact with each other or with a solid surface. In the literature there are no works devoted specifically to elongate concentrated vortices. These problems are highlighted most comprehensively in the book “Vortex Dynamics” (Saffman 1992). It is pertinent to also note the books by Villat (1930), Joukowski (1937a, b), Lamb (1932), Kochin et al. (1964), Milne-Thomson (1938), Sedov (1997), Batchelor (1967), Lavrentyev and Shabat (1973), Loitsyanskii (1966), Goldshtik (1981), Lugt (1983), Gupta et al. (1984), Ting and Klein (1991), Meleshko and Konstantinov (1993), Lugt (1996), Kozlov (1998), and reviews by Hall (1966), Widnall (1975), Saffman and Baker (1979), Leibovich (1984), Spalart (1998), Andersson and Alekseenko (2002). Table I.1. Examples of concentrated vortices Phenomenon Picture Description number in Fig. I.1 1 a Whirlpool in liquid flowing out a container through bottom orifice 2 b Tornado 3 c Vortices in flow over a delta wing under a high attack angle – Longitudinal vortices in a turbulent 4 boundary layer 5 d Longitudinal vortices in a boundary layer behind a body on a plane 6 e Set of vortex ropes formed behind the asymmetric jet injected into cross flow 7 f Set of vortex ropes in a rotating liquid layer heated from below 8 g Vortex ropes in the uprising vapor flow above a rotating liquid – Vortex filaments in the turbulence 9 model for superfluid helium 10 – Vortex filaments – bridges between vortex ropes in the wake behind a multi-blade propeller 11 – Vortex rings – closed vortex filaments 12 h Vortex filaments in flow over a dimple
References (Van Dyke 1982) (Snow 1984) (Payne et al. 1988) (Kim et al. 1971) (Tani et al. 1962) (Wu et al. 1988)
(Boubnov and Golitsyn 1986) (Vladimirov 1977b) (Donelly 1988) (Larin and Mavritskii 1971) (Widnall 1975) (Kiknadze et al. 1986)
Introduction
3
Fig. I.1. Examples of generation of concentrated vortices (see comments in Table I.1). f – vortex core
The description of concentrated vortices summarized in a single book is deemed by importance of concerned problem rather than by deficiency of certain books covering the subject. The concept of vortex filament is one of the fundamental concepts of fluid dynamics. The vortex filament (point vortex) is a simple and convenient model for describing real vortices. Moreover, this is a basis for developing mathematical models for more complex vortex flows (e.g., the Method of Point Vortices (Belotserkovsky and Nisht 1978) and the Model for a Flow with Helical Symmetry (Alekseenko et al. 1999)).
4
Introduction
In reality, the concentrated vortices of the vortex filament class almost never have a rectilinear axis due to arising from different instabilities and the capacity of the vortex cores to be a waveguide (i.e., to transfer disturbances). The disturbed states are characterized by a wide spectrum of different modes – axisymmetric, bending, etc. but the most typical forms of disturbances are those with a helical or spiral shape (Fig. I.2b). The key mechanism for the propagation of these disturbances is a selfinduced motion. This mechanism is also responsible for the motion of vortex rings and propagation of nonlinear wave packets known as a vortex soliton (or Hasimoto soliton) described (in first approximation) by the cubic Schrödinger equation. Existence of solid surfaces, other vortices, type of basic flow field – have a strong impact on the behavior of a concentrated vortex. It seems that the most striking and fascinating phenomenon is a vortex breakdown. This phenomenon is manifested in a sudden deviation of the concentrated vortex axis from the current direction or it manifests in a sudden expansion of the vortex core with formation of counter flow zones. The classic examples of vortex breakdown are presented in Fig I.4 for the case of flow over a delta wing and in Fig. I.6 - for a swirl flow in a slightly diverging pipe. There are many types of vortex breakdown, but the most frequent are the bubble type (Fig. I.6a, I.2d) and spiral type (Fig. I.6b, I.2c) breakdown. Vortex breakdown brings a radical restructuring of flow and it is significant for transfer processes and performance of industrial heat- and mass-transfer apparatuses of a vortex type (Alekseenko and Okulov 1996). The problem of vortex breakdown description has been one of main incentives for the study of concentrated vortex stability. In the book presented, the authors do not consider the theory of vortex breakdown because of its incompleteness. The main focus is on systematic description of experimental data in Section 7.6. The outline of this problem is available in several reviews: Hall (1972), Leibovich (1978, 1984), Escudier (1988), Althaus and Weimer (1997). Concentrated vortices are related to coherent structures, which may be identified as vortices and have a key role in the processes of laminarturbulent transition as well as in developed turbulent flow (Boiko et al. 2002; Kachanov 1994). Most important of those are the longitudinal vortices in a turbulent boundary layer (Kim et al. 1971), and horseshoe-shaped vortex structures (see review by Cantwell (1981)). The coherent structures in the form of vortex rings are clearly distinguishable in axisymmetric free shear flows. This kind of example for an impinging jet is shown in Color Fig. I.2, where experimental data obtained by Markovich (2003) is plotted in terms of velocity vector field as well as vorticity field. The concept of vortex rrggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggrrrggggggggrrrrrr
Introduction
b
40 mm
a
5
d
c
Fig. I.2. Undisturbed (a) and disturbed (b – d) vortex filaments. a, b – tangential hydraulic chamber (Alekseenko and Shtork 1992*)2; c – swirl air jet, Re = 1.4⋅104, nozzle diameter 152 mm (Panda and McLaughlin 1994*); d – chamber with rotating bottom of diameter 91.3 mm (Spohn et al. 1998*)
a
b
Fig. I.3. Formation of vortex filaments in a boundary layer ahead of an obstacle (cylinder) with slot suction (Seal and Smith 1997*): a – flow visualization with hydrogen bubbles; b – diagram, slot with sizes 64 × 2 mm is placed at 88.5 mm from the cylinder with diameter 89 mm 2
For references marked by the asterisk see the copyright and permission notices in the reference list.
6
Introduction
Fig. I.4. Bubble (above) and spiral (below) types of vortex breakdown in flow over a delta wing. Dye visualization in a water channel (Lambourne and Bryer 1961*). Flow velocity is 5.1 cm/s
a
b
c
Fig. I.5. Laminar (a) and turbulent (b, c) vortex rings. Smoke visualization (Akhmetov 2001)
a
b
Fig. I.6. Bubble ( ) and spiral (b) breakdown of a vortex. Dye visualization of flow in a slightly diverging pipe (Sarpkaya 1971*)
Introduction
7
filaments (quantum vortices) was especially fruitful in developing the Turbulence Theory for Superfliud Helium (Donelly 1988; Nemirovskii and Tsubota 2000). Concentrated vortices play an important (and often dominant) role in technical applications. For example, the design of the vortex flow meter involves measuring the liquid flow rate through the precession frequency of a concentrated vortex in swirl flow. The generation of precessing vortex ropes behind the hydroturbine wheel may induce high pressure pulsations and result in catastrophic consequences. The complex vortex structures were discovered in the Ranque-Hilsh vortex tube (see Fig. I.7) (Arbuzov et al. 1997; Piralishwili et al. 2000). Non-stationary vortex structures are significant for combustion processes in vortex furnaces and vortex burners (Gupta at al. 1984; Alekseenko and Okulov 1996). The formation of vortex ropes and their breakdown in flow over a delta wing can influence the lift force and wing control. The key mechanism of heat transfer enhancement on a surface with dimples concludes in the formation of elongate concentrated vortices often called “tornado-like structures”. Among the natural phenomena a tornado (see Color Fig. I.1) (Nalivkin 1969) and its small-scale analog – a whirlpool as well as a “dust devil” are the most revealing examples related to concentrated vortices. The largescale phenomena like oceanic vortices or atmospheric cyclones (anticyclones) also belong to the category of concentrated vortices. However, their scale is comparative (or larger) to the layer thickness of the atmosphere/ocean, so their description is a special subject. The concentrated vortices are revealed even at astrophysical level. The hydrodynamic mechanism of forming galactic spiral structures is related to the generation of nonlinear local disturbances similar to the Rossby vortices and they are the source of spiral waves in a galaxy disc (Nezlin and Snezhkin 1990; Alekseenko and Cherep 1994). All these features of real concentrated vortices demonstrate complexity and variety of their behavior; this creates great difficulties both in developing mathematical description and experimentation. That is why the theory of concentrated vortices is based mainly upon approximate mathematical models. The common approach to the description of dynamics of a deformed elongate vortex is based on the Biot-Savart Law in approximation of a thin vortex filament; although the low-disturbance states of a columnar vortex can be calculated with rather simple analytical or numerical methods on the basis of the exact equations of Euler or Navier-Stokes. As for experimental research, there is quite a limited number of works presenting tentative results on the stability and dynamics of concentrated vortices, acceptable for comprehensive validation of theoretical models.
8
Introduction
a b
Fig. I.7. Double spiral vortex in the Ranque-Hilsh vortex tube (Arbuzov et al. 1997*): a – flow diagram; b – Hilbert-visualization with exposition of 2.5⋅10-4 s (visualization of spatial gradient of optical density), chamber with rectangular cross-section of 34×34 mm
The above mentioned difficulties explain why so far there is no comprehensive knowledge of concentrated vortex dynamics. This book presents the authors’ collection and systemization of knowledge, which should enable the reader to understand the important features of concentrated vortices. At the same time we have not here considered the myriad of examples and applications, which could be suitable for another book (or even book series).
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
1.1 Vorticity. Circulation The term vorticity (or vorticity vector) is the important concept in fluid dynamics. It is a vector value, and in the Cartesian coordinate system (x, y, z) it is determined via projections (u, v, w) of the velocity vector u as
(r , t) ≡ ∇ × u = εijk
∂uk ⎛ ∂w ∂v ∂u ∂w ∂v ∂u ⎞ =⎜ − , − − ⎟, , ∂x j ⎝ ∂y ∂z ∂z ∂x ∂x ∂y ⎠
(1.1)
where εijk is a unit 3rd rank tensor of Levi – Civita. The motion of a continuous medium with zero vorticity (∇ × u = 0) is called irrotational. It follows from definition (1.1) and formulae of vector analysis that ∇
= ∇(∇ × u) = 0,
(1.2)
i.e., the vorticity vector is solenoidal. To understand the physical meaning of vorticity, let us analyze the relative motion of a medium in the vicinity of some point M(r) at a given instant of time. Let the fluid velocity at this point be u(r). Then, at some nearby point M'(r + δr) velocity alteration can be determined by series expansion to the values of the first infinitesimal order
δ ui =
∂ ui δ xj . ∂x j
Derivative ∂ui /∂xj is the 2nd rank tensor, which can be defined as the sum of the symmetric and antisymmetric tensors ∂ui ∂ui ( s ) ∂ui ( a ) = + . ∂x j ∂x j ∂x j Here, the symmetric part is written as ∂ui ( s ) 1 ⎛ ∂ui ∂u j = ⎜ + 2 ⎜⎝ ∂x j ∂xi ∂x j
⎞ ⎟ ≡ eij . ⎟ ⎠
(1.3)
10
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
Value eij is called the rate of strain tensor, and the corresponding part of velocity (eij δxj) describes the pure straining motion. The antisymmetric tensor takes the form ∂ui ( a ) 1 ⎛ ∂ui ∂u j = ⎜ − 2 ⎜⎝ ∂x j ∂xi ∂x j
⎞ ⎟, ⎟ ⎠
and it can be expressed via vorticity components (1.1) ∂ui ( a ) 1 = − εijk ωk . 2 ∂x j The corresponding component of velocity δu is written as 1 1 1 − εijk ωk δx j or εijk ω j δxk , or 2 2 2
× δr ,
and it describes the rotational motion of a small element as a solid body with angular velocity /2. Actually, in the case of rigid body rotation with angular velocity δu =
× δr.
Hence, =
1 2
.
(1.4)
Therefore, any motion of a continuous medium can be separated into pure straining, rotational and, naturally, translational motions. The physical meaning of vorticity lies in the fact, that it equals double the local angular velocity of a medium. Correspondingly, the relationship for velocity at a point M'(r + δr) will take the following form 1 ui (r + δr ) = ui (r ) + eij δx j + εijk ω j δxk , 2
(1.5)
where derivatives in eij and ωj are taken at point M(r). Together with vorticity , circulation Γ is another important concept in the dynamics of fluids with vorticity. This value is a scalar, and is defined as a curvilinear integral of fluid velocity u along closed circuit s
1.1 Vorticity. Circulation
Γ=
∫ u ds .
11
(1.6)
s
If the curve is reducible (i.e., it can be contracted to a point inside a continuos medium), Stokes theorem can be applied, and a linear integral can be transformed into a surface one (Fig. 1.1)
Γ=
∫ u ⋅ ds = ∫ rot u ⋅ ndS = ∫ s
⋅ ndS.
(1.7)
S
Here S is an arbitrary surface bounded by circuit s; n is a unit normal vector. Besides this, a relationship between velocity curl and vorticity (1.1) is considered. The path-tracing rule is shown in the figure. Relationship (1.7) means that a vorticity flux through an arbitrary open surface equals the velocity circulation along a closed curve. This statement is true for simply connected areas of the flow, where any closed circuit is reducible. It is convenient to describe the kinematics of vortex flows using the concepts of vortex filaments and vortex tubes. They are introduced similarly to the concept of a streamline (a line whose tangent coincides with the direction of the velocity vector at any point) and stream tube (a portion of fluid bounded by a surface consisting of streamlines). In accordance with this, a vortex line is a line in a fluid, whose tangent is parallel to a local vorticity vector at any point, and a vortex tube is a set of streamlines passing through each point of some closed surface in a fluid. Vortex lines passing through its boundary form the lateral surface of a vortex tube. It follows from the definition of a vortex tube that the vorticity vector is parallel to the lateral surface of the vortex tube, i.e. · n = 0.
Fig. 1.1. On the derivation of the integral relationship (1.7) between circulation and vorticity
Fig. 1.2. Vorticity flux through the vortex tube
12
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
Let us consider the part of a vortex tube bounded by two arbitrary open surfaces S1, S2 and a lateral surface St (Fig. 1.2). Thus, using the formula of Gauss – Ostrogradskii, the surface integral of the vorticity flux can be transformed into the volume integral in the following manner:
∫
∫
(1.8)
⋅ ndS = ∇ dV = 0 .
S
V
Here; the right side is reduced to zero due to the solenoidal character of the vorticity field (1.2). Expanding the left side of (1.8), we get
∫
⋅ ndS =
S
∫
⋅ ndS −
S1
∫
⋅ ndS +
S2
∫
⋅ ndS = 0 .
St
Since the vorticity flux through the lateral surface of the vortex tube is zero, the last relationship means that the vorticity flux through any transverse cross-section of the vortex tube is constant at a given instant of time. Thus, the vorticity flux can be considered as a characteristic of the vortex tube called the strength or the intensity of the vortex tube. Alternatively, if Eq. (1.7) is applied to the vortex tube, it can be concluded that the intensity of a vortex tube is equal to velocity circulation around any closed circuit on the tube surface, which encloses the tube once (Stokes theorem). It follows from the above consideration that vortex tubes cannot end in a continuous medium. Actually, if a vortex tube cross-section becomes equal to zero, according to the law condition, the angular velocity of fluid particles would increase to infinity. Obviously, to correspond to this conclusion, vortex tubes may be closed or end in infinity or end in solid or free surfaces. Let us introduce an additional important relationship between circulations of velocity and acceleration over a closed fluid circuit. With this purpose, at first, we notate a substantial derivative of velocity circulation over an open fluid circuit MP
d dt Considering that
P
∫
P
u ⋅ δr =
M
∫
M
du ⋅ δr + dt
P
d
∫ u ⋅ dt (δr ).
M
d (δr ) = δu , we get dt P
∫
M
⎛ u2 ⎞ 1 2 δ ⎜ ⎟ = uP2 − uM . ⎜ 2 ⎟ 2 ⎠ M ⎝ P
u ⋅ δu =
∫
(
)
1.2 Dynamics of vortical fluid
13
Then, reducing points M and P into a single point and obtaining closed circuit s, we get the following expression
d Γ(u) = Γ(u) , dt
(1.9)
where u = du dt , i.e., a substantial derivative of velocity circulation over a closed fluid circuit equals the circulation of acceleration over the same circuit. This is Kelvin’s circulation theorem. The above properties of vortical fluid motion represent merely kinematic theorems, not connected with specific features of fluids or peculiarities of their motion models. Proving of these theorems was only based on the general properties of medium continuity. Therefore, conclusions formulated in this section perfectly describe the reality. Other problems of vortical fluid motion concern dynamics and would significantly depend on the chosen flow model.
1.2 Dynamics of vortical fluid 1.2.1 Equations of ideal fluid motion
Hereafter, if not expressly stipulated, an ideal fluid will be considered. The theory of vortices in an ideal fluid due to its simplicity provides the solution to many specific problems with a practical value. First of all, this statement is related to the important problem of motions in ideal fluid caused by areas, whose vorticity differs from zero. The motion of ideal fluid is described by Euler equations ∇p du ∂u ≡ + (u ⋅ ∇)u = − +g dt ∂t ρ
(1.10)
and the equation of mass conservation dρ ∂ρ ∂ρ ≡ + u∇ρ = −ρ∇u or + div ( ρu ) = 0. dt ∂t ∂t
(1.11)
Equations are written for the general case of a compressible medium. Here g is the external force per a mass unit; p is the pressure; ρ is the density. Let us transform (1.10), taking into account vector identity (u∇)u = ∇(u 2/2) + curl u × u. As a result, we will get the Gromeka – Lamb equation
14
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
⎛ u2 ⎞ ∇p ∂u . + ∇ ⎜ ⎟ + curl u × u = g − ⎜ ⎟ 2 ∂t ρ ⎝ ⎠
(1.12)
Let us consider a case for practice, when the motion is barotropic, and forces are potential, i.e. g = −∇Π, where Π is a potential of mass force, and ρ = ρ(p) and corresponding function exists
P ( p) = ∫
dp . ρ( p)
Then, the Gromeka – Lamb equation will take the form
∂u + ∇Η + curl u × u = 0 , ∂t
(1.13)
where H u2/2 + P + Π. Finally, applying operation curl to (1.13) and introducing vorticity, we get Helmholtz equation
d = ( ⋅ ∇ )u − dt
⋅ ∇u ,
(1.14)
which in the case of incompressible fluid is written as d ∂ = ( ⋅ ∇)u or = curl(u × ) . dt ∂t
(1.15)
The main advantage of Helmholtz equation in comparison with Euler equation (1.10) is an absence of pressure in (1.14). It is useful to notate equations of motion in a non-inertial frame of reference. Let us consider the moving frame (x', y', z') with velocity of coordinate origin v0 and angular velocity of its rotation 0 together with the immobile coordinate system (x, y, z). Let us denote the vector of relative velocity of a fluid particle as v. Considering the value of translational velocity v0 + 0 × r, the vector of the absolute velocity is written in the form of u = v + v0 + 0 × r. According to Coriolis theorem (Kochin et al. 1964), the absolute acceleration of a fluid particle is composed of relative dv/dt and translational dv0 /dt + d 0 /dt × r + 0 × ( 0 × r) accelerations, and Coriolis acceleration 2( 0 × v). Taking into account that (1.12) includes the absolute acceleration; the Gromeka – Lamb equation for the relative motion takes the form
1.2 Dynamics of vortical fluid
∂′v v2 + ∇ − v × curl v + 2( ∂t 2 dv d 0 ∇p =− +g− 0 − ×r − ρ dt dt
0
× v) =
0
×(
0
15
× r ),
where a prime of time derivative means differentiation in the moving frame of reference. Sometimes it is convenient to consider the absolute motion of fluid using the moving frame of reference
⎛ u2 ∂′u + ∇⎜ − u ⋅ (v0 + ⎜ 2 ∂t ⎝
0
⎞ × r ) ⎟ − ( u ⋅ (v0 + ⎟ ⎠
0
× r ) ) × curl u = −
∇p +g ρ
1.2.2 Theorems of motion for an ideal vortical fluid
Using different forms of motion equations and considering the case of barotropic motion in the field of potential forces, several consequences important for vortex dynamics can be deduced. Originally, they were formulated by Helmholtz (Helmholtz 1858). Initially, let us turn to Kelvin theorem (1.9) and notate its right side with consideration of (1.10): ⎛ ∇p ⎞ dΓ du ds = ⎜ − = + g ⎟ ds = − ∇(P + Π ) ds ≡ 0 . dt dt ⎝ ρ ⎠ Here the integral of ∇(P + Π) over the closed circuit equals zero, if functions P and Π are single valued. This is obvious for P = P (p). Hence, for the barotropic motion in the field of conservative forces with a single valued potential, circulation around any closed circuit is constant, i.e.,
∫
∫
∫
dΓ = 0. dt
(1.16)
Applying Stokes theorem (1.7), it can be concluded that vorticity flux through a fluid surface rounded by a fluid closed curve also stays constant d dt
∫
⋅ n dS = 0 .
(1.17)
S
It follows from (1.16), (1.17) that vortex tubes and vortex lines move together with fluid and the intensity of a vortex tube does not change with time. Allow us to show this using the reasoning of Batchelor (1967). We
16
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
will consider a fluid tube (Fig. 1.3), which identically coincides with an arbitrary vortex tube at some instant of time t0. Let us mark out an arbitrary closed fluid circuit sc on the vortex tube surface, which encloses the tube once. In accordance with equation (1.16), circulation around this fluid circuit will stay constant in time. Now, let us again mark out an arbitrary small closed fluid circuit ss on the vortex tube surface, which does not enclose it. Apparently, the vorticity flux through the surface bounded by this circuit equals zero and according to (1.17) stays zero through time. Conversely, the intensity of the vortex tube will be maintained through time due to the invariance of circulation over the closed circuits enclosing the tube. This reasoning proves the above statement for the case of a vortex tube. Similar conclusions can be obtained for a vortex line, if a transverse cross-section of a vortex tube is reduced to a point and ultimately it is passed into a vortex line. The important relationship between the vorticity and the length of a fluid element follows from the conservation law of vortex tube intensity. Using t0, the length of a small fluid element (vortex tube element) is δr(t0), and the area of cross-section is δS(t0) (Fig. 1.4). Due to the small size of the element, directions of vectors δr and coincide. In the following instant of time t the tube will change its size and position as it is shown in the picture. Then, according to the law of vorticity flux conservation (1.17) we have | (t)|δS(t) = | (t0)|δS(t0), and according to the law of mass conservation ρ δS δs|t = ρ δS δs|t0 . Taking into account the direction of vectors, we get the following relationship:
Fig. 1.3. The scheme of an arbitrary vortex tube
Fig. 1.4. On the concept of vortex line stretching
1.2 Dynamics of vortical fluid
(
17
ρ)t δs(t ) = ρt δs(t0 )
(1.18)
(t ) δs(t ) . = (t0 ) δs(t0 )
(1.19)
0
or for incompressible fluid
Expression (1.19) has obvious physical meaning. At a change in the size of a small fluid element, the vector of local vorticity changes as does the length of a small element. Introducing the term stretching of vortex lines, as in the stretching of a small fluid element along the vortex line, we can assert that vortex line stretching leads to vorticity intensification. This effect is extremely important for the explanation of many phenomena connected with swirl flows and for the analysis of turbulence. However, in the last case, due to geometrically complex deformation of fluid elements, the integral value is introduced ∫1/2 ω2dV to estimate vorticity behavior. In the case of irrotational motion, Lagrange theorem is valid: if some volume of fluid moves irrotationally, it stays irrotational even after that. At that point, it is assumed that the fluid is ideal, the motion is barotropic, and body forces are conservative (Loitsyanskii 1966). The proof follows from Helmholtz equation (1.14) and analyticity condition of function (t) when using Lagrangian coordinates. Let at instant t0 (t0) = 0. Thus, according to (1.14), the substantial derivative d /dt at t = t0 is also equal to zero. It can be shown due to repeated differentiation of (1.14) that all following time derivatives also turn to zero at t = t0. This means that under the condition of analyticity of (t), vorticity remains zero at any instant of time t > t0. If it is required that the potential of body forces is single valued, Lagrange theorem can be easily proved using equation (1.17) without the condition of (t) analyticity. Ultimately, we can get from (1.17) that the vorticity flux through any open surface S is constant in time
∫
⋅ n dS = const .
S
If at some instant of time vorticity is equal to zero at any point of a control volume; const = 0. As the surface S and direction n are chosen arbitrarily, vorticity is also zero everywhere at any instant of time, which proves Lagrange theorem.
18
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
1.2.3 Bernoulli theorem
One of the most important laws of conservation in fluid dynamics is Bernoulli’s theorem (Loitsyanskii 1966), which reads: ‘At steady barotropic motion of an ideal fluid in the field of potential body forces, parameter H (Bernoulli’s trinomial, see (1.13)) keeps its constant value along a streamline.’ H = u2/2 + P + Π = const (along a streamline) This law is easily derived from the Gromeka – Lamb equation (1.13). Actually, from the condition of steadiness, the first term in (1.13) becomes zero. Then, we take the scalar product of (1.13) with u. Obviously, u · (curl u × u) 0. Then u · ∇H = 0 or u(u/u · ∇H) = 0, whence taking into account definition of directional derivative, it follows that dH/ds = 0, which proves Bernoulli theorem. Here d/ds indicates the derivative taken along the streamline or fluid trajectory, which is equivalent in the case of steady motion. Taking the scalar product of the Gromeka – Lamb equation with the vorticity vector , we similarly get: /ω · ∇H = dH/ds = 0. Now d/ds indicates the derivative along the vortex line. Therefore, Bernoulli theorem is true even for a vortex line H = u2/2 + P + Π = const (along a vortex line).
(1.20)
Generally, Bernoulli constant H has different values for different streamlines and vortex lines. However, if everywhere in the space × u = 0,
(1.21)
it follows from (1.13) that in the whole space occupied by a continuous medium Bernoulli constant retains its value. Condition (1.21) is satisfied in two cases: 1) = 0 – irrotational motion; 2) || u − so-called helical motion or helical flow (Vasiliev 1958), and according to other publications (Dritschel 1991) − Beltrami flow. In the last case, vortex lines coincide with streamlines. Numerous examples of these flows are presented, for instance, by Vasiliev (1958). In the simplest case of incompressible fluid in the field of gravitation forces, Bernoulli constant takes the form H = u2/2 + p/ρ + gz = const,
(1.22)
where coordinate z is taken along the upward vertical axis. Bernoulli equation can be written even for unsteady flow, if it is irrotational, i.e.,
1.2 Dynamics of vortical fluid
19
∇ × u = 0. Then there is the scalar function ϕ(r, t), called the velocity potential and determined from equation u = ∇ϕ.
(1.23)
The velocity potential is determined unambiguously only for the single connected area. Substituting (1.23) into the first term of the Gromeka – Lamb equation (1.13), we have
∂ϕ u 2 + + P + Π = F (t ). ∂t 2
(1.24)
Here F(t) is an arbitrary function of time, which is similar for the whole flow field and can be determined from the boundary conditions. Expression (1.24) is also called the Couchy – Lagrange Integral. 1.2.4 Equations of viscous fluid motion
As mentioned above, the model of incompressible density-uniform ideal fluid is mainly used for analysis of vortex motion. However, some cases cannot neglect consideration of viscosity effects. Viscous liquids are described by Navier – Stokes equations ∇p ∂u + (u ⋅ ∇) u = g − + ν∆u, ∂t ρ
(1.25)
where ν is the coefficient of kinematic viscosity. Equation of continuity (1.11) at ρ = const takes the simple form div u = 0.
(1.26)
Let us derive a generalization of the Gromeka – Lamb equations for the case of viscous fluid. It follows from equation (1.26), identity ∆ u = grad div u − curl curl u
(1.27)
and vorticity definition (1.1), that ∆ u = − curl . Then, for description of the motion of viscous incompressible fluid in the potential field of mass forces, the vector equation of Gromeka – Lamb is written ∂u + ∇H + ∂t
× u = −ν rot
,
(1.28)
20
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
an additional term ν∆ will appear on the right side of Helmholtz equation (1.15) due to the application of procedure curl to ν∆ u in Navier – Stokes equation (1.25). As a result, we have d = ( ⋅ ∇ ) u + ν∆ dt
or
∂ + (u ⋅ ∇) ∂t
= ( ⋅ ∇ ) u + ν∆ .
(1.29)
It follows from the last equation that at a given point of the flow of incompressible fluid, vorticity changes due to convection (the second term on the left side), deformation and rotation of a fluid element (the first term on the right) and diffusion caused by viscosity (the second term on the right).
1.3 Equations of fluid motion in orthogonal coordinates For convenience of application let us notate continuity equation (1.26), equations of motion (1.10) or (1.25), Gromeka – Lamb equations (1.12) or (1.28) and Helmholtz equations (1.14) or (1.29) in arbitrary orthogonal coordinates as well as in the most frequently used forms: Cartesian, cylindrical and spherical coordinate systems. Note that transition to equation for ideal fluid for any notation of equations might be accomplished by assuming ν = 0. 1.3.1 Arbitrary orthogonal system of curvilinear coordinates
Let us consider an arbitrary orthogonal system of curvilinear coordinates q1 , q2 , q3 , constrained with Cartesian coordinates by the following correlations qk = qk(x, y, z),
k = 1,2,3.
Equations qk(x, y, z) = const,
k = 1,2,3
determine the family of coordinate surfaces and three sets of curves, represented by the equations ⎧qk ( x, y, z) = const , k, n = 1, 2,3; k ≠ n, ⎨ ⎩qn ( x, y, z) = const are called coordinate lines. If unit vectors e1 , e2 , e3 , directed along the coordinate lines, are orthogonal at all spatial points, then the curvilinear co-
1.3 Equations of fluid motion in orthogonal coordinates
21
ordinates can be identified as orthogonal. In the case of non-zero Jacobian coordinate mapping, the latter can be solved using the Cartesian system, and then the position vector of an arbitrary point could be determined in the following form r = r(q1 , q2 , q3). Infinitesimal transition along the coordinate lines will be determined accordingly by increments drk =
∂r dqk , k = 1, 2, 3. ∂qk
Taking into account the orthogonality of a curvilinear system of coordinates, the second power of the length of a linear element can be written in the following form 2
3 ⎛ ∂r ⎞ = ds = dr ⋅ dr = ⎜ dq L2k dqk , ⎟ k ∂ q k ⎠ k =1 ⎝ k =1 3
∑
2
where Lk ( q1 , q2 , q3 ) =
( ∂x
∑
∂qk ) + ( ∂y ∂qk ) + ( ∂z ∂qk ) 2
2
2
are the Lame
coefficients. Let us illustrate the main processes of vector calculus in curvilinear orthogonal coordinates. Let ϕ be the scalar function, b the vector function, then
grad ϕ =
3
k =1
div b =
∆ϕ =
k
ek ,
k
1 ⎡ ∂ (L2 L3b1 ) ∂ (L1L3b2 ) ∂ ( L1L2b3 ) ⎤ + + ⎢ ⎥, ∂q2 ∂q3 ⎦ L1L2 L3 ⎣ ∂q1 rot b =
+
∂ϕ
∑ L ∂q
1 ⎡ ∂ (L3b3 ) ∂ (L2b2 ) ⎤ − ⎢ ⎥ e1 + ∂q3 ⎦ L2 L3 ⎣ ∂q2
1 ⎡ ∂L1b1 ∂L3b3 ⎤ 1 ⎡ ∂ (L2b2 ) ∂ (L1b1 ) ⎤ − − ⎢ ⎥ e2 + ⎢ ⎥ e3 , L3L1 ⎣ ∂q3 L1L2 ⎣ ∂q1 ∂q1 ⎦ ∂q2 ⎦
1 L1L2 L3
⎡ ∂ ⎛ L2 L3 ∂ϕ ⎞ ∂ ⎛ L1 L3 ∂ϕ ⎞ ∂ ⎛ L1 L2 ∂ϕ ⎞ ⎤ ⎢ ⎜ ⎟⎥ . ⎜ ⎟+ ⎜ ⎟+ ⎣⎢ ∂q1 ⎝ L1 ∂q1 ⎠ ∂q2 ⎝ L2 ∂q2 ⎠ ∂q3 ⎝ L3 ∂q3 ⎠ ⎦⎥
22
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
Applying the second formula to (1.26) we obtain the equation of continuity in the following form ∂ (L2 L3 u1 ) ∂ (L1L3 u2 ) ∂ (L1L2 u3 ) + + =0. ∂q1 ∂q2 ∂q3
(1.30)
To notate Euler equations in an arbitrary orthogonal coordinate system we have to apply representation of the gradient in the direction from vector a · ∇b, and to notate the Navier – Stokes equations we need in additional representation for a Laplace operator acting on vector function. The Laplace operator components can be calculated by replacing the scalar function in a given representation of the Laplace operator by b = b1e1 + b2e2 + b3e3 vector and calculating proper derivatives including those of e1 , e2 , e3. However, the obtained result is too complex and usually in order to obtain components of ∆u the form (1.27) may be used as well as the above cited formulae of vector analysis. Let us notate the equations of fluid motion for ideal fluid in the form of Gromeka – Lamb in the directions e1 , e2 , e3 of an orthogonal curvilinear system of coordinates
∂u1 1 ∂ ⎛ u12 + u22 + u32 ⎞ + ⎜ ⎟⎟ − ( u2 ω3 − u3 ω2 ) = ∂t L1 ∂q1 ⎜⎝ 2 ⎠ ⎤ 1 ∂p ν ⎡ ∂ ∂ ( L3 ω3 ) − (L2 ω2 ) ⎥ , = g1 − − ⎢ ρL1 ∂q1 L2 L3 ⎣ ∂q2 ∂q3 ⎦ 2 2 2 ∂u2 1 ∂ ⎛ u1 + u2 + u3 + ⎜ L2 ∂q2 ⎜⎝ ∂t 2
= g2 −
1 ∂p ν − ρL2 ∂q2 L3 L1
⎡ ∂ ⎤ ∂ (L1ω1 ) − (L3 ω3 ) ⎥ , ⎢ ∂q1 ⎣ ∂q3 ⎦
∂u3 1 ∂ ⎛ u12 + u22 + u32 + ⎜ 2 ∂t L3 ∂q3 ⎜⎝ = g3 −
ν 1 ∂p − ρL3 ∂q3 L1L2
⎞ ⎟⎟ − ( u3 ω1 − u1 ω3 ) = ⎠
⎞ ⎟⎟ − ( u1 ω2 − u2 ω1 ) = ⎠
⎡ ∂ ⎤ ∂ (L2 ω2 ) − (L1ω1 ) ⎥ . ⎢ ∂q2 ⎣ ∂q1 ⎦
Substituting components of the vorticity vector = curl u into the above equations and performing some algebra according to the above cited formulae of vector analysis we obtain the set of equations of fluid motion in an arbitrary orthogonal system of coordinates
1.3 Equations of fluid motion in orthogonal coordinates
∂un 1 + ∂t Ln
3
u ⎡ ∂
∂L ⎤
23
∂p
∑ Lkk ⎣⎢ ∂qk (Lnun ) − uk ∂qnk ⎦⎥ = gk − ρLk ∂qk + 1
k =1
(1.31) ⎤ ⎫⎪ Ln ∂ ⎧⎪ L1L2 L3 ⎡ ∂ ∂ +ν (Ln un ) − (Lkuk ) ⎥ ⎬, n = 1, 2,3. ⎨ 2 2 ⎢ ∂qn L1L2 L3 k=1 ∂qk ⎪⎩ Ln Lk ⎣ ∂qk ⎦ ⎪⎭ 3
∑
1.3.2 Cartesian coordinate system
The equations of motion for an incompressible fluid (1.30), (1.31) take the simplest form in the absence of mass forces (g = 0) in a Cartesian coordinate system (x, y, z), where Lame coefficients are L1 = L2 = L3 = 1 ⎛ ∂ 2u ∂ 2u ∂ 2u ⎞ 1 ∂p ∂u ∂u ∂u ∂u +u +v +w =− + ν⎜ 2 + 2 + 2 ⎟, ⎜ ∂t ∂x ∂y ∂z ρ ∂x ∂y ∂z ⎠⎟ ⎝ ∂x ⎛ ∂ 2v ∂ 2v ∂ 2v ⎞ 1 ∂p ∂v ∂v ∂v ∂v +u +v +w =− + ν ⎜ 2 + 2 + 2 ⎟, ⎜ ∂x ∂t ∂x ∂y ∂z ρ ∂y ∂y ∂z ⎟⎠ ⎝ ⎛ ∂ 2w ∂ 2w ∂ 2w ⎞ 1 ∂p ∂w ∂w ∂w ∂w +u +v +w =− + ν⎜ 2 + 2 + 2 ⎟, ⎜ ∂x ∂t ∂x ∂y ∂z ρ ∂z ∂y ∂z ⎟⎠ ⎝
(1.32)
∂u ∂v ∂w + + = 0. ∂x ∂y ∂z Let us notate the first three equations (1.32) in Gromeka – Lamb form ∂ωy ⎞ ⎛ ∂ω ∂u ∂ ⎛ u 2 + v2 + w2 p ⎞ + + ⎟ = v ωz − w ωy − ν ⎜ z − ⎜⎜ ⎟, ∂t ∂x ⎝ ρ ⎠⎟ ∂z ⎠ 2 ⎝ ∂y ∂ω ∂v ∂ ⎛ u 2 + v2 + w2 p ⎞ ⎛ ∂ω + + ⎟ = w ωx − u ωz − ν ⎜ x − z ⎜⎜ ⎟ 2 ∂t ∂y ⎝ ρ⎠ ∂x ⎝ ∂z
⎞ ⎟, ⎠
⎛ ∂ωy ∂ωx ∂w ∂ ⎛ u 2 + v2 + w2 p ⎞ + ⎜ + ⎟ = u ωy − v ωx − ν ⎜ − ∂t ∂z ⎝⎜ ρ ⎠⎟ ∂y 2 ⎝ ∂x
(1.33)
⎞ ⎟. ⎠
The generalized Helmholtz equation (1.29) for viscous fluids in Cartesian coordinates can be written as
24
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
∂ωx ∂ω ∂ω ∂ω ∂u ∂u + u x + v x + w x = ωx + ωy + ωz ∂t ∂x ∂y ∂z ∂x ∂y ∂ωy ∂ωy ∂ωy ∂ωy ∂v ∂v +u +v +w = ωx + ωy + ωz ∂t ∂x ∂y ∂z ∂x ∂y
∂u + ν∆ωx , ∂z ∂v + ν∆ωy , (1.34) ∂z
∂ωz ∂ω ∂ω ∂ω ∂w ∂w ∂w + u z + v z + w z = ωx + ωy + ωz + ν∆ωz , ∂t ∂x ∂y ∂z ∂x ∂y ∂z where vorticity vector components are determined by (1.1), while D = ∂ 2/∂x2 + ∂ 2/∂y2 + ∂ 2/∂z2. 1.3.3 Cylindrical coordinate system
In the cylindrical coordinate system (r, θ, z), the Lame coefficients have the following form: L1 = 1, L2 = r, L3 = 1. After substituting them into (1.30) and (1.31) for incompressible fluid we obtain
∂ur ∂u ∂u ∂u u 2 + ur r + uθ r + uz r − θ = r ∂θ r ∂t ∂r ∂z = gr −
u 1 ∂p 2 ∂u ⎞ ⎛ + ν ⎜ ∆ ur − 2r − 2 θ ⎟ , ρ ∂r r r ∂θ ⎠ ⎝
∂uθ ∂u ∂u ∂u uu + ur θ + uθ θ + uz θ + r θ = ∂t ∂r ∂z r ∂θ r = gθ −
1 ∂p 2 ∂u u ⎞ ⎛ + ν ⎜ ∆ uθ + 2 r − 2θ ⎟ , ρ r ∂θ r ∂θ r ⎠ ⎝
(1.35)
∂uz ∂u ∂u ∂u 1 ∂p + ur z + uθ z + uz z = gz − + ν∆uz , r ∂θ ∂t ∂r ∂z ρ ∂z ∂ (rur ) ∂uθ ∂ (ruz ) + + =0, ∂r ∂θ ∂z where ur, uθ, uz are respectively the radial, peripheral and axial components of the velocity vector, while operator ∆=
∂2 ∂r 2
+
1 ∂ 1 ∂2 ∂2 + 2 2 + 2 r ∂r r ∂θ ∂z
is equally defined for all equations of this Section.
1.3 Equations of fluid motion in orthogonal coordinates
25
Let us notate the Gromeka – Lamb equation in cylindrical coordinates only for fluid flowing in a potential field of mass forces ⎞ ∂ω ⎞ ∂ur ∂ ⎛ ur2 + uθ2 + uz2 p ⎛ ∂ω + ⎜ + + Π ⎟ = uθ ωz − uz ωθ − ν ⎜ r − 0 ⎟ , ⎟ 2 ∂t ∂r ⎜⎝ ρ ⎝ r ∂θ ∂z ⎠ ⎠ ⎞ ∂uθ ∂ω ∂ ⎛ ur2 + uθ2 + uz2 p ⎛ ∂ω + + + Π ⎟ = uz ωr − ur ωz − ν ⎜ r − z ⎜⎜ ⎟ 2 ∂t r ∂θ ⎝ ρ ∂r ⎝ ∂z ⎠
⎞ ⎟, ⎠
(1.36)
⎞ ∂uz ∂ ⎛ ur2 + uθ2 + uz2 p + ⎜ + +Π⎟ = ⎟ ∂t ∂z ⎜⎝ ρ 2 ⎠ ⎛ ∂ ( r ωθ ) ∂ωr ⎞ = ur ωθ − uθ ωr + ν ⎜ − ⎟. r ∂θ ⎠ ⎝ r ∂r Then generalized Helmholtz equation (1.29) accordingly takes the form ∂ωr ∂ω ∂ω ∂ω + ur r + uθ r + uz r = r ∂θ ∂t ∂r ∂z = ωr
∂ur ∂u ∂u ω 2 ∂ωθ ⎞ ⎛ + ωθ r + ωz r + ν ⎜ ∆ωr − 2r − 2 ⎟, ∂r ∂z r ∂θ r r ∂θ ⎠ ⎝ ∂ωθ ∂ω ∂ω ∂ω uω + ur θ + uθ θ + uz θ − r θ = ∂t ∂r ∂z r ∂θ r
∂u ∂u ∂u uω 2 ∂ωr ωθ ⎞ ⎛ = ωr θ + ωθ θ + ωz θ − θ r + ν ⎜ ∆ωθ + 2 − ⎟, ∂r ∂z r ∂θ r r ∂θ r 2 ⎠ ⎝
(1.37)
∂ωz ∂ωz ∂ωz ∂ωz + ur + uθ + uz = ∂t ∂r ∂z r ∂θ ∂u ∂u ∂u = ωr z + ωθ z + ωz z + ν∆ωz , ∂r ∂z r ∂θ where vorticity vector components are determined by the following formulae ωr =
∂ (ruθ ) ∂ur ∂uz ∂uθ ∂u ∂u − − , ωθ = r − z , ωz = . ∂z ∂r r ∂θ ∂z r ∂r r ∂θ
(1.38)
26
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
1.3.4 Spherical coordinate system
Let us consider another widespread notation for viscous fluid flow equation in a spherical coordinate system (r, θ – latitude, φ – longitude), in which the Lame coefficients are L1 = 1; L2 = r; L3 = r sin θ. After substituting them in (1.30) and (1.31) for spherical components of velocity vector ur, uθ and uφ we obtain the following set of equations uφ ∂ur uθ2 + uφ2 ∂ur ∂ur ∂ur + ur + uθ + − = r ∂θ r sin θ ∂φ r ∂t ∂r = gr −
⎛ 2u 1 ∂p 2 ∂ ( uθ sin θ ) 2 ∂uφ ⎞ + ν ⎜ ∆ ur − 2r − 2 − 2 ⎟, ρ ∂r ∂θ r r sin θ r sin θ ∂φ ⎠ ⎝
uφ ∂uθ ur uθ uφ2 cos θ ∂uθ ∂uθ ∂uθ + ur + uθ + + − = r ∂θ r sin θ ∂φ r r sin θ ∂t ∂r = gθ −
∂uφ ∂t = gφ −
+ ur
⎛ u 1 ∂p 2 ∂u 2cos θ ∂uφ ⎞ + ν ⎜ ∆uθ + 2 r − 2 θ 2 − 2 2 ⎟ , (1.39) ρ r ∂θ r ∂θ r sin θ r sin θ ∂φ ⎠ ⎝
∂uφ ∂r
+ uθ
∂uφ r ∂θ
+
uφ
∂uφ
r sin θ ∂φ
+
ur uφ
+
r
uθuφ cos θ r sin θ
=
uφ ⎞ ⎛ 1 1 ∂p 2 2cos θ ∂uθ + ν ⎜ ∆uφ + 2 + 2 2 − 2 2 ⎟, ρ r sin θ ∂φ r sin θ r sin θ ∂φ r sin θ ⎠ ⎝
(
∂ r 2 sin θ ur ∂r where ∆ =
) + ∂ (r sin θ u ) + ∂ru θ
∂θ
φ
∂φ
= 0,
1 ∂ ⎛ 2 ∂ ⎞ 1 1 ∂ ⎛ ∂ ⎞ ∂2 . r sin + θ + ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ∂θ ⎠ r 2 sin 2 θ ∂φ2 r 2 ∂r ⎝ ∂r ⎠ r 2 sin θ ∂θ ⎝
In a spherical coordinate system Gromeka – Lamb equations (1.28) for fluid flow in a potential field of mass forces can be written as
1.3 Equations of fluid motion in orthogonal coordinates 2 2 2 ⎞ ∂ur ∂ ⎛ ur + uθ + uφ p + ⎜ + + Π⎟ = ⎟ 2 ∂t ∂r ⎜ ρ ⎝ ⎠ ν ⎛ ∂ ωφ sin θ ∂ωθ ⎞ ⎜ ⎟, = uθ ωφ − uφ ωθ − − ∂θ ∂φ ⎟ r sin θ ⎜ ⎝ ⎠ 2 2 2 ⎞ ∂uθ ∂ ⎛ ur + uθ + uφ p ⎜ + + +Π⎟ = ⎟ 2 ∂t r∂θ ⎜ ρ ⎝ ⎠ ν ⎛ ∂ωr ∂ rωφ sin θ ⎞ ⎜ ⎟, = uφ ωr − ur ωφ − − ⎟ ∂r r sin θ ⎜ ∂φ ⎝ ⎠ 2 2 2 ⎞ ∂uφ 1 ∂ ⎛ ur + uθ + uφ p ⎜ + + + Π⎟ = ⎟ 2 ∂t r sin θ ∂θ ⎜ ρ ⎝ ⎠ ν ⎛ ∂ ( rωθ ) ∂ωr ⎞ = ur ωθ − uθ ωr − ⎜ − ⎟, ∂θ ⎠ r ⎝ ∂r
(
27
)
(
)
(1.40)
and generalized Helmholtz equation (1.29) becomes uφ ∂ωr ∂ωr ∂ωr ∂ω ∂u ∂u + ur + uθ r + = ωr r + ωθ r + ∂t ∂r ∂r r ∂θ r sin θ ∂φ r ∂θ +
⎡ ωφ ∂ ur 2ω 2 ⎛ ∂ ( ωθ sin θ ) ∂ωφ ⎞ ⎤ + ν ⎢ ∆ωr − 2r − 2 + ⎜ ⎟⎥ , ∂θ ∂φ ⎠ ⎥⎦ r sin θ ∂φ r r sin θ ⎝ ⎢⎣
uφ ∂ωθ ur ωθ − ωr uθ ∂ωθ ∂ω ∂ω ∂u + ur θ + uθ θ + − = ωr θ + ∂t ∂r ∂r r ∂θ r sin θ ∂φ r + ωθ
ωφ ∂uθ ⎛ ∂uθ ω 2 ∂ω 2cos θ ∂ωφ ⎞ + + ν ⎜ ∆ωθ + 2 r − 2 θ − 2 2 ⎟ , (1.41) r ∂θ r sin θ ∂φ r ∂θ r sin θ r sin θ ∂φ ⎠ ⎝
∂ωφ ∂t = ωr
+ ur ∂uφ ∂r
∂ωφ ∂r + ωθ
+ uθ ∂uφ r ∂θ
∂ωφ r ∂θ +
+
uφ
∂ωφ
r sin θ ∂φ
ωφ ∂uφ r sin θ ∂φ
−
−
ωr uφ r
ur ωφ r −
−
uθ ωφ cos θ r sin θ
ωθuφ cos θ r sin θ
ωφ ⎞ ⎛ 2 ∂ωr 2cos θ ∂ωθ +ν ⎜ ∆ωφ + 2 + 2 2 − 2 2 ⎟, r sin θ ∂φ r sin θ ∂φ r sin θ ⎠ ⎝
+
=
28
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
where vorticity is determined by the following correlations ωr =
ωθ =
(
)
∂u ⎞ 1 ⎜⎛ ∂ sin θ uφ − θ ⎟, ∂θ ∂φ ⎟ r sin θ ⎜ ⎝ ⎠
(
1 ⎜⎛ ∂ur ∂ r sin θ uφ − ∂r r sin θ ⎜ ∂φ ⎝ 1 ⎛ ∂ ( ruθ ) ∂ur ωφ = ⎜⎜ − r ⎝ ∂r ∂θ
) ⎟⎞ , ⎟ ⎠
(1.42)
⎞ ⎟⎟ . ⎠
1.4 Special cases of vortex motion 1.4.1 Helical flows (Beltrami flows)
The fundamentals of helical flows were first stated in 1881 by Gromeka in his obscure theses ‘Some Cases of Incompressible Fluid Flow’, and independently in the more known work of the Italian mathematician Beltrami in 1889 (due to this work, helical flows are also called as Beltrami flows). The most detailed description of this class of flows can be found in the book by Vasiliev (1958), which underpins the present Section. As already noted in Section 1.2.3, helical flow is a special case of the steady flow of an ideal fluid with vorticity when vortex lines coincide with streamlines (kinematic condition). The equivalent energetic condition concludes that mechanical energy is constant within the whole volume of flowing fluid, i.e. Bernoulli theorem is valid for the entire flow. For the general case of steady vortex flow of inviscid fluid, the particles moving along the different streamlines posses unequal amounts of energy, i.e. the Bernoulli constant assumes various magnitudes for the different streamlines. At the same time the amount of energy along each streamline remains the same, i.e. the Bernoulli constant remains equal. If all the streamlines originate from an area where the fluid is at rest or flows forward uniformly, then in all remaining areas, due to conservation of the Bernoulli constant along the streamlines, the energy of all particles will be identical, i.e. the flow will be either potential or helical. An example of such a flow may result in the formation of a helical flow in the discharge flowing from a vessel filled with liquid previously at rest. Another prime example is the formation of circulating flows in initially steady flows behind channel
1.4 Special cases of vortex motion
29
turns and tube bends. Yet when applying models of helical flow even in such evident examples we must remember that these results are valid only for steady flows of ideal fluid and stay in force only for those flows, where fluid viscosity and flow unsteadiness have a negligible role. The kinematic condition of helical motion can be expressed in the following way: u × curl u = 0
or curl u = λu,
(1.43)
at that, in general λ may be an arbitrary function of coordinates λ = λ (q1 , q2 , q3). If λ = const, then the helical flow is called uniform, while in the opposite case it is non-uniform. Taking the scalar product of (1.43) with u and accounting correlations curl
1 1 u 1 ⎛ ⎞ = curl u + grad × u and u ⋅ ⎜ grad × u ⎟ = 0, u u u u ⎝ ⎠
we find λ = e · curl e, where e = u / u is the unit vector, collinear to the velocity vector. An interesting property of the helical flow of compressible inviscid fluid results from the equation (1.43) if we apply div operation to both parts of the equation. Then we obtain λ div u + u grad λ = 0,
since
div curl u = 0.
Substituting the relationship for div u from the equation of continuity (1.11), we find u ⋅ grad
λ = 0. ρ
This means that along the streamline the ratio λ / ρ = const. For the special case of incompressible fluid, we obtain from the latter the following result: the streamlines are located on λ = const surfaces. Gromeka found that for a uniform helical flow with a solenoidal velocity field (div u = 0) velocity vector u should satisfy the vector equation ∆ u + λ2 u = 0. Indeed, this relationship follows from (1.43) after applying a rotor operation to the right and left sides of the equation. Moreover, from the fact that in this case div u = 0, it does not follow that the homogenous helical flow may exist only in incompressible fluid. From the equation of continuity
30
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
(1.11) it follows that for a compressible gas a steady homogenous helical flow is possible, if u · grad ρ = 0, i.e. where the velocity vector is orthogonal to the density gradient – the streamlines run on the surfaces of equal density. The equations of non-uniform helical flow (1.43) in curvilinear orthogonal coordinates (see representation for rotor in Section 1.3.1) may be written as: 1 ⎛ ∂L3 u3 ∂L2 u2 − ⎜ L2 L3 ⎝ ∂q2 ∂q3
⎞ ⎟ = λu1 , ⎠
1 ⎛ ∂L1u1 ∂L3 u3 ⎞ − ⎜ ⎟ = λu2 , ∂q1 ⎠ L3 L1 ⎝ ∂q3
(1.44)
1 ⎛ ∂L2 u2 ∂L1u1 ⎞ − ⎜ ⎟ = λu3 . ∂q2 ⎠ L1L2 ⎝ ∂q1
The equations (1.44) together with the equation of continuity (1.30) for the case of stabilized helical motion of compressible fluid provide us with a set of four equations to determine four variables u1, u2, u3 and λ. Thus, the velocity field for helical flows by analogy with potential flows is completely determined by kinematic equations, while dynamic laws in the form of the Bernoulli integral (1.20) are employed for restoring the pressure field. 1.4.2 Two-dimensional flows
In the general case for each instant of time, the fluid flow velocity field is determined by three functions – u1, u2, u3, which are components of the velocity vector in some curvilinear coordinate system q1, q2, q3 u1 = f1(q1, q2, q3); u2 = f2(q1, q2, q3); u3 = f3(q1, q2, q3). The flow, which may be referred to a coordinate system, where all three velocity components – u1, u2, u3 – for each instant of time are functions of just two coordinates q1, and q2, and do not depend upon the third – q3, i.e. u1 = f1(q1, q2),
u2 = f2(q1, q2),
u3 = f3(q1, q2)
1.4 Special cases of vortex motion
31
let us call two-dimensional1. Geometrically this means that on all coordinate surfaces q3 = const velocity field is identical. In other words, ∂u1 ∂u2 ∂u3 = = =0. ∂q3 ∂q3 ∂q3 This implies that the Jacobian of the velocity components over the coordinates also equals zero
∂ ( u1 , u2 , u3 ) ∂ ( q1 , q2 , q3 )
=
∂u1 ∂q1
∂u1 ∂q2
∂u1 ∂q3
∂u2 ∂q1
∂u2 ∂q2
∂u2 = 0. ∂q3
∂u3 ∂q1
∂u3 ∂q2
∂u3 ∂q3
Therefore the relationship, which exists between functions u1, u2, u3 should not depend on coordinates q1, q2, q3, i.e. for two-dimensional flow the following functional correlation takes place F(u1, u2, u3) = 0.
(1.45)
This correlation allows a reduction in the number of variables in the equations, reducing at the same time the number of equations in the set. Plane-parallel flow
The simplest example of two-dimensional flow is plane or plane-parallel fluid flow when in some inertial reference frame all the particles are located on the same normal in some immovable plane (xy, for instance), posses similar magnitudes of pressure and density and move equally in parallel to this plane (Fig. 1.5), i.e. correlation (1.45) is given by w u3 = 0. 1
In the literature such flows are sometimes called ‘two-parametric’. For instance, the classification of flows by Vasiliev (1958) is based both on a number of parameters required for the description of velocity field, and the number of nonzero velocity components. In contrast to ‘two-parametric’, the author calls ‘twodimensional flows’, those in which one of the velocity components in some curvilinear coordinate system is equal to zero. It is not difficult to envisage a threeparametric, two-dimensional system: the particles are moving in parallel on some plane, but their velocities on a parallel to this plane are not equal. Nevertheless the stated classification is not generally accepted and we will use the more traditional term of ‘two-dimensional flows’.
32
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
Fig. 1.5. The example of plane-parallel flow
In this case all the additives in equation set (1.32) containing z derivatives vanish. The third equation assumes its’ identity, while the fourth, the equation of continuity, takes the form div u ≡
∂u ∂v + =0, ∂x ∂y
(1.46)
where u and v are functions of coordinates x, y and time t, considered further as a parameter. Let us introduce function ψ(x, y) related to the velocity projections u=
∂ψ ∂ψ , v=− , ∂y ∂x
(1.47)
which identically follows the equation (1.46). Function ψ(x, y) has a simple hydrodynamic sense. Indeed, let us notate the streamline equation dx dy = u v
or udy − vdx ≡
∂ψ ∂ψ dx + dy = dψ = 0 . ∂x ∂y
It follows from the last equality that ψ function retains constant magnitudes along the streamlines; in other words the set of level lines ψ(x, y) = const represents the totality of the streamlines. In this context, function ψ(x, y) is called stream function. If we draw a curve between the points M and N in the xy plane, then fluid flow rate Q through this curve will be determined by the difference between the magnitudes of streamline function at points M and N. Indeed, if un is a normal curve velocity projection, then
1.4 Special cases of vortex motion N
N
∫
Q = ρ un ds = ρ M
∫
M
33
N
( −vdx + udy ) = ρ dψ = ρ ( ψ N − ψ M ) .
∫
M
Let us find the vorticity vector for plane fluid flow. Since in this case w = 0, yet u and v depend only upon x, y and time t, the vorticity vector will be determined only by its’ z projection, i.e. ωz = where ∆ =
∂2
+
∂v ∂u ∂2ψ ∂2ψ − = − 2 − 2 = −∆ψ , ∂x ∂y ∂x ∂y
(1.48)
∂2
is the Laplace operator. ∂x 2 ∂y 2 In the case of steady-state flow, using (1.46), we may notate the Gromeka – Lamb equation (1.13) in the form of two scalar equalities −ωz
∂ψ ∂H ∂ψ ∂H , − ωz = = . ∂x ∂x ∂y ∂y
Equating mixed derivatives of H function, we derive the form ∂ ( ωz , ψ ) ∂ωz ∂ψ ∂ωz ∂ψ − = 0 or Jacobian =0, ∂x ∂y ∂y ∂x ∂ ( x, y ) i.e. ωz should be dependant on ψ only. In applications the form of the above correlation is often used as given in this function ωz (x, y) = ωz {ψ(x, y)} which should satisfy Helmholtz equation (1.34), for which a flat case takes the form ∂ωz ∂ω ∂ω + u z + v z = ν∆ωz . ∂t ∂x ∂y
(1.49)
If relationship ωz = ωz (ψ) is known, then the investigation reduces to the solution of a boundary problem for ψ, which obeys the equation (1.48). Substituting (1.48) into (1.49) Landau and Lifshitz (1987) derived a full equation for ideal fluid, for which the stream function of a plane flow should satisfy ∂∆ψ ∂ψ ∂∆ψ ∂ψ ∂∆ψ − + =0. ∂t ∂x ∂y ∂y ∂x
34
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
Nonswirling (longitudinal) axisymmetric flow
Another simple example of two-dimensional fluid flow is nonswirling (longitudinal) axisymmetric flow, when all the particles move equally along each of the planes, intersecting over the given line (axis), and have equal magnitudes of pressure and density (Fig 1.6). In a cylindrical coordinate system, for instance, those planes are rz, and the axis is Oz, while function (1.45) takes form of uθ u2 = 0. Equations (1.35) in this case lose all terms with θ-derivatives, the second equation reduces, while the fourth, the equation of continuity, takes the form ∂ (rur ) ∂ (ruz ) + =0. ∂r ∂z
(1.50)
The differential equation of streamlines for axisymmetric flow can be written as dr dz = ur uz
or
ur dz − uz dr = 0 .
(1.51)
Equation (1.50) shows, that r serves as an integrating factor for equation (1.51). After multiplying by r, the left side of this equation takes the form of the full differential of some function ψ dψ = rur dz − ruz dr , thus ur = −
1 ∂ψ 1 ∂ψ . ; uz = r ∂z r ∂r
(1.52)
Function ψ is called Stokes Stream Function. This function remains equal for each streamline and hence will stay constant on a surface (stream tube), which is obtained by rotating the given streamline around the axis of vvvvv
Fig. 1.6. The example of axisymmetric flow
1.4 Special cases of vortex motion
35
symmetry. If we draw an arbitrary surface between two concentric circles located on different stream tubes passing through the points M and N, then fluid flow rate Q, flowing through this surface, will be equal to the difference between the magnitudes of stream function on the stream tubes multiplied by 2πρ. Indeed, 2π
N
0
M
Q = ρ u ⋅ ndS = ρ ( ur nr + uz nz ) dS = ρ dθ
∫
S
∫ ∫ ( ur rdz − uzrdr ) =
∫
S N
= 2πρ dψ = 2πρ ( ψ N − ψ M ) .
∫
M
Let us calculate the vorticity components in the considered axisymmetric flow using stream function. Accounting that the velocity components do not depend on z and uθ = 0, and substituting their representation through the stream function (1.52) in (1.38), we get axial and radial vorticity components equal to zero. Then the equation to determine stream function by given distribution of circumference vorticity component ωθ takes the form 1 ∂ 2 ψ ∂ ⎛ 1 ∂ψ ⎞ + ⎜ ⎟ = −ωθ , r ∂z 2 ∂r ⎝ r ∂r ⎠
(1.53)
where ωθ being a function of coordinates and time should satisfy Helmholtz equation (1.37) ∂ωθ ∂ω ∂ω u ω + ur θ + uz θ − r θ = 0 or ∂t ∂r ∂z r
d ⎛ ωθ ⎞ ⎜ ⎟=0, dt ⎝ r ⎠
wherefrom it follows that in a steady-state case value ωθ /r is an arbitrary function of stream function ψ. Swirl axisymmetric flow
Another important example of two-dimensional flow is swirl axisymmetric flow of ideal fluid (Batchelor 1967). This flow is considered in many research works and referred to differently. For instance, it is described in the works by Vasiliev (1958) and Goldshtik (1981) as the circulating and vortex-type flow. The essential difference of such a flow as compared to the above considered nonswirling axisymmetric flow is the rotation occurrence, i.e. all velocity components may take non-zero magnitudes, including uθ u2. Though in this case the assumption concerning flow axisymmetry is still valid (all flow characteristics depend only on two cylindrical
36
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
coordinates [r, z] and do not depend on θ; stream tubes represent surfaces of revolution), nevertheless the trajectories of the particles are no longer flat, but spatial curves (Fig. 1.7). For swirl axisymmetric flows, the equation of continuity retains the same form as (1.50). This allows us to introduce, according to Eqs. (1.52) the analog of stream function ψ, otherwise – stream function of the meridian section (Goldshtik 1981), which converts the equation of continuity to identity. For a steady flow taking the scalar product of equation (1.13) by the velocity vector and taking into account that u⋅( × u) = 0, and flow characteristics do not depend on θ, we obtain ur
∂H ∂H + uz = 0 or ∂r ∂z
∂ψ ∂H ∂ψ ∂H − = 0. ∂z ∂r ∂r ∂z
(1.54)
Equation (1.54) means, that there exists a relationship between functions H and ψ, which does not depend on coordinates r and z, i.e. H=
ur2 + uθ2 + uz2 p + + Π = H (ψ ) . 2 ρ
(1.55)
To derive an equation, describing steady axisymmetric flow of ideal fluid in a potential field of mass forces, let us introduce the function Γ = ruθ. In this case the second equation of the system (1.35) can be rewritten as ur
∂ (ruθ ) ∂ (ruθ ) 1 ∂ψ ∂Γ 1 ∂ψ ∂Γ + uz = − =0. r ∂z ∂r r ∂r ∂z ∂r ∂z
(1.56)
From the obtained relationship it also follows, that function Γ is only a ψ-dependant function, i.e. Γ = Γ(ψ). Let us further consider the first equation of the system (1.36). With regard to all the assumptions concerning flow and after substituting components of the vorticity vector (1.38), the equation takes the form
Fig. 1.7. Schematic diagram of axisymmetric swirl flow in a channel
1.4 Special cases of vortex motion
37
∂u ⎞ ∂H uθ ∂ (ruθ ) ⎛ ∂u = − uz ⎜ r − z ⎟ r ∂r ∂r ∂r ⎠ ⎝ ∂z or, taking into account (1.52), we obtain dH ∂ψ Γ ⎛ dΓ ∂ψ ⎞ 1 ∂ψ ⎛ 1 ∂ 2 ψ ∂ ⎛ 1 ∂ψ ⎞ ⎞ = ⎜ + ⎜ ⎜ ⎟+ ⎟⎟ . dψ ∂r r 2 ⎝ dψ ∂r ⎠ r ∂r ⎜⎝ r ∂z 2 ∂r ⎝ r ∂r ⎠ ⎟⎠ Hence r
∂ ⎛ 1 ∂ψ ⎞ ∂ 2 ψ dΓ 2 dH −Γ = −r ωθ . ⎜ ⎟+ 2 =r ∂r ⎝ r ∂r ⎠ ∂z dψ dψ
(1.57)
Functions H and Γ, appearing in equation (1.57), should be given. Sometimes it is possible to determine them by employing boundary conditions (see, for example, Goldshtik (1981)). Thus, the problem of vortex axisymmetric flow description is reduced to the investigation of an equation for meridian stream function, where the right-hand side of the equation needs additional consideration, similar to the equations for determination of stream function in plane (1.48) and longitudinal axisymmetric (1.53) flows. Note that Helmholtz equations (1.37) for components ωr and ωz in the concerned case apply identically. For ωθ we have d ⎛ ωθ dt ⎜⎝ r
⎞ 1 ∂ 2 ⎟ = 2 ∂z uθ . ⎠ r
The latter equation can be integrated (see Saffman (1992)) and we can obtain (1.57). Components ωr and ωz are linked with the respective velocity components by simple relationships ωr = ur dΓ dψ,
ωz = uz dΓ dψ .
Hence, we see that the projections of velocity and vorticity vectors to the meridian plane are parallel (antiparallel) to each other. 1.4.3 One-dimensional flows
Similarly, as for two-dimensional flows let us call one-dimensional flows those which can be related to such a reference frame where velocity components are functions of just one coordinate q1 u1 = f1 (q1 ); u2 = f2 (q1 ); u3 = f3 (q1 ).
(1.58)
38
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
It is obvious that all considered examples of two-dimensional flow under the assumption of (1.58) could be simplified. Among the possibilities of transition from two-dimensional flow to one-dimensional let us consider just two important examples with uniform distribution of vorticity. 1. Let the velocity of a plane-parallel steady-state flow in an inertial reference frame have just one u component along the axis x (v = 0) and let this component be a function of just one y coordinate. Then, in view of Eq. (1.48), we obtain −
∂u ∂2ψ = − 2 = ωz ≡ ω = const . ∂y ∂y
Hence u = – ωy + u0, where u0 is velocity at the x axis. Consequently, the considered flow has its velocity, which changes linearly along the y axis. Stream function of such flow is given by ψ=−
ω 2 y + u0 y + ψ 0 . 2
This flow is shown in Fig. 1.8 and is called shear flow. In the particular case (ω = 0) all liquid particles move with equal constant velocities u0. Such flow is called uniform. 2. Let us consider steady-state flow with constant vorticity, which in a cylindrical coordinate system has only one circumferential component uθ, dependent on radial coordinate r. After notating (1.48) in cylindrical coordinates and taking into account the accepted assumptions we obtain −
1 ∂ (ruθ ) 1 ∂ ⎛ ∂ψ ⎞ = ⎜r ⎟ = −ωz ≡ −ω = const . r ∂r r ∂r ⎝ ∂r ⎠
Integrating this equation we find ruθ =
ω 2 ω r + C; ψ = − r 2 − C log r + ψ 0 . 2 4
Fig. 1.8. Scheme of shear flow
Fig. 1.9. Scheme of quasi-rigid-body fluid rotation
1.5 Flows with helical symmetry
39
For flows with restricted velocities constant C should be equal to zero. Streamlines of such flows are of concentric circumferences (Fig. 1.9), and the circumferential velocity varies linearly along the radius. Such a flow is usually called quasi-rigid-body rotation.
1.5 Flows with helical symmetry 1.5.1 Derivation of equations
Let us consider ideal incompressible fluid flow in the cylindrical reference system (r, θ, z) with the axis Oz, directed along the flow axis. Suppose that the flow has helical symmetry. This means that in the planes orthogonal to the z axis the flow pattern will remain the same at the translational motion along the z axis, accompanied by a simultaneous rotation on some angle θ. A possible scheme of such flow is presented in Fig 1.10. That is to say that the flow characteristics will maintain their magnitudes along the helical lines, which are described by equations r = const
z − θ ⋅ l = const .
(1.59)
Value h = 2πl corresponds to the pitch of helical symmetry, moreover the magnitude of l assumes positive values in the case of right-handed helical symmetry, and negative values in the case of left-handed symmetry. The vector tangent of the helical lines (1.59) will be as follows B = B 2 ⎡⎣ ez + ( r l ) eθ ⎤⎦ , where B 2 = (1 + r 2 / l 2 ) −1.
(1.60)
For such normalizing, the vector is called the Beltrami vector (Dritschel 1991). By means of vector B the condition of helical symmetry can be presented as B ⋅ ∇f = 0 ,
(1.61)
where f is an arbitrary scalar function characterizing the flow (velocity component, density and pressure). Vector B is orthogonal to unit radial vector er of the cylindrical coordinate system. Their vector product determines the third orthogonal vector = B × er = B2 ⎡⎣eθ − ( r l ) ez ⎤⎦ .
(1.62)
Let us introduce the values combined with the velocity projection onto the orthogonal directions er , B, ,
40
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
Fig. 1.10. Scheme of a flow with helical symmetry
ur , uB =
B ⋅u B
2
⋅u r r = uz + uθ , uχ = 2 = uθ − uz . l l B
(1.63)
Further, following Alekseenko et al. (1999) for flows with helical symmetry, satisfying (1.61), let us rewrite the equation of continuity and Euler equations, expressed with the new variables (r, χ = θ – z/l) ∂ (rur ) ∂uχ + = 0, ∂r ∂χ 2
∂ur ∂u ∂u 1 ∂p B4 ⎛ r ⎞ + ur r + uχ r − , ⎜ uχ + uB ⎟ = − r ∂χ r ⎝ l ∂t ∂r ρ ∂r ⎠ B2 ⎛ r B−2 ∂p ⎞ ur ⎜ 2 uB + 2 − B−2 uχ ⎟ = − + ur + uχ − , r ∂χ r ∂t ∂r ρ r ∂χ ⎝ l ⎠
∂uχ
∂uχ
∂uχ
(
(1.64)
)
∂uB ∂u ∂u + ur B + uχ B = 0 . r ∂χ ∂t ∂r Below we consider two possible cases of vortex flows, which are described by the equations (1.64). 1.5.2 Flow with helical vorticity
Allow the ideal incompressible fluid flow to possess helical symmetry, i.e. all flow characteristics depend only on two spatial variables – r, χ and satisfy the equation set (1.64). Suppose that in the whole flow area the velocity projections of tangential direction to the lines (1.59) are proportional to the cosines of the inclination angle of the helical lines relative to the Oz axis. In this case functional relation (1.45) takes the simple form
1.5 Flows with helical symmetry
41
uB = const. This results in identical completion of the latter equation of the system (1.64). Besides, for the considered class of equations according to the first equation (1.64) we may introduce the analog of stream function ψ, which is determined by the relationships ur =
1 ∂ψ , r ∂χ
uχ = −
∂ψ . ∂r
(1.65)
Similar to previously considered uniform flow, where velocity remained constant across the whole area, this class of flows can be conventionally called ‘flows with helical symmetry’, which is characterized by “uniform” motion along the helical lines. According to (1.63) for circumferential and axial components in a cylindrical reference frame the condition of constant velocity uB takes the form r r u − u0 r uB = uz + uθ = u0 ≡ const, or uz = u0 − uθ , or z = − , (1.66) l l uθ l where constant u0 determines the value of the axial component of velocity on a flow axis. Solving (1.63) relatively uθ and uz, and taking into account (1.65) and (1.66) we obtain uθ =
∂ψ ⎞ ⎛r ⎞ 2⎛r ⎜ uB + uχ ⎟ = B ⎜ u0 − ⎟, ∂r ⎠ r +l ⎝ l ⎠ ⎝l l2
2
2
r ⎞ r ∂ψ ⎞ ⎛ ⎛ uz = 2 2 ⎜ uB − uχ ⎟ = B2 ⎜ u0 + ⎟. l ⎠ l ∂r ⎠ r +l ⎝ ⎝ l2
(1.67)
Analyzing (1.66) and (1.67) we may conclude that the considered class of flows conditionally could be referred to as a uniform type. Indeed, the flow velocity components ur, uθ, uz may take arbitrary values, under the stipulation that Eq. (1.66), associated only with axial and circumferential velocity components, holds true. Only in extreme cases, when l ∞, and helical lines (1.59) become straight, the axial velocity component will be constant in the whole area of the flow, i.e uz = u0 and the flow actually becomes uniform in z direction. A pioneer to introduce the class of flows satisfying condition (1.66), was Okulov (1993, 1995). However partial solution within the considered class was employed for combustion analysis (Borissov et al. 1993) and energy separation (Borissov et al. 1994) in swirl flows inside tubes. The most comprehensive analysis showing the effectiveness of use of the considered type of flows, describing real swirl flows, is given by Alekseenko et al. (1999).
42
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
Let us consider the peculiarities of vorticity distribution in such flows. Then the vorticity vector components in cylindrical coordinates can be written as ωr = ωθ = − ωz = −
1 ∂uB ≡ 0, r ∂χ
r ⎡ 1 ∂ 2 ψ 1 ∂ ⎛ 2 ∂ψ ⎞ B4 ⎤ 1 ∂ur ∂uz 2 rB u − =− ⎢ 2 2 + − ⎥, 0 ⎜ ⎟ ∂r ∂r ⎠ l ∂χ l ⎢⎣ r ∂χ r ∂r ⎝ l ⎦⎥
(1.68)
⎡ 1 ∂ 2 ψ 1 ∂ ⎛ 2 ∂ψ ⎞ B4 ⎤ 1 ∂ur 1 ∂ (ruθ ) + =− ⎢ 2 + − rB u 2 ⎥. 0 ⎜ ⎟ 2 ∂r ⎠ r ∂χ r ∂r r ∂r ⎝ l ⎥⎦ ⎣⎢ r ∂χ 2
4 2
It is justified here, that ∂B /∂r = −2rB /l . It follows from (1.68), that the radial component of the vorticity field is equal to zero. In addition based on (1.68) we may obtain the relationship between the axial and circumferential components of the vorticity vector ωr = 0;
ωθ / ωz = r / l
or
ωθ = r ωz / l.
(1.69)
Condition (1.69) means, that for the given class of flows the vorticity vector is always directed along the tangent in helical lines. The converse proposition is also true (Okulov, 1993, 1995): if the vorticity field is collinear to the helical lines, then the condition (1.66) holds true. Indeed, if the flows with helical symmetry are conditioned by requirements (1.69), then after integrating the first equation of (1.69) and in view of definition of ωr we obtain uB = f(r). According to the second condition (1.69) let us consider the difference ωθ – r ωz / l = 0 and take into account (1.67) and (1.68). As a result we obtain f ' (r) = 0, i.e. uB = const. Thus, for the given class, the fulfillment of condition (1.66) imposed on a velocity field is equivalent to the requirement of collinearity of the vorticity field with tangents in helical lines (1.69). In that case the considered class of flows can be called flows with vorticity fields featuring vectors directed along helical lines, or simply flows with helical vorticity. The third equation in (1.68) can be presented as an equation determining stream function ψ according to the given distribution of the axial vorticity component ωz
∆ψ = 2u0
B2 ωz − 2, l B
(1.70)
1.5 Flows with helical symmetry
43
⎛ 2r 2 ⎞ 1 ∂ l 2 + r 2 ∂ 2 + − + 22 1 . ⎜ ⎟ r l ∂χ 2 ∂r 2 ⎝⎜ r 2 + l 2 ⎠⎟ r ∂r The vorticity vector for this class of flows can be directed according to the Eqs. (1.68) and (1.69) only along the tangent of the helical lines (1.59), and it can be completely determined by assigning just one component, ωz, for instance. At that, the value ωz, as a function of coordinates and time, should satisfy Helmholtz equation (1.37), which in helical variables r and χ reduces to one scalar equation where ∆ =
∂2
∂ωz ∂ωz ∂ωz ∂u r ⎛ ⎞ ∂u + ur + uχ = ωr z + ⎜ ωθ − ωz ⎟ z . ∂t ∂r r ∂χ ∂r ⎝ l ⎠ r ∂χ
(1.71)
Starting from (1.69) we deduce, that the right-hand part of the equation (1.71) equals zero. This means that the axial vorticity component does not vary along the trajectory of the fluid particle, and in steady state conditions ωz is an arbitrary function depending only on stream function ψ and not depending explicitly on spatial coordinates. Moreover, because of Eq. (1.69) the latter claim is valid also for the ratio ωθ /r. Note another interesting property of flows with helical symmetry with “uniform” motion along helical lines (1.66), which can be obtained, if considering flow in the coordinate system, uniformly moving with u0 velocity along the z axis. In this case, based on (1.66) – (1.68) the velocity and vorticity fields will take the form ⎛ 1 ∂ψ ∂ψ r ∂ψ ⎞ u=⎜ , − B2 , B2 ⎟ ∂r l ∂r ⎠ ⎝ r ∂χ r ⎛ ⎞ and = ⎜ 0, − B2 ∆ψ, B2 ∆ψ ⎟ . l ⎝ ⎠
(1.72)
It is easy to check that their scalar product is equal to zero, i.e. in some inertial reference frame the velocity and vorticity fields are orthogonal in contrast to the helical flows considered below. 1.5.3 Helical flows with helical symmetry of the velocity field
In the framework of the ideal fluid flow model with helical symmetry, let us consider a swirl flow in which velocity and vorticity fields are colinear. The velocity and vorticity fields of such flows in view of their solenoidal character may be represented by means of Beltrami vector B in the form of decompositions (Landman 1990; Dritschel 1991)
44
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
u = φB + ∇ψ × B ,
= ζB + ∇ξ × B ,
(1.73)
where φ, ψ, ζ and ξ are some scalar functions of r and χ. Indeed, if taking into account relationships for div B = 0 and curl B = – 2 B2 B / l, then it is easy to prove that in view of the decompositions (1.73) the equation of continuity div u = 0 and equation div = 0 automatically hold true. Using definitions of vorticity = curl u and gradient, expressed in variables r and χ ∇ = er
∂ 1 ∂ , + eχ rB ∂χ ∂r
(1.74)
and based on the decompositions (1.73), we obtain ξ = – φ and ∆* ψ = 2
where
∆* ≡
B4 φ − B2 ξ, l
(1.75)
1 ∂ ⎛ 2 ∂ ⎞ 1 ∂ . ⎜ rB ⎟+ ∂ r ⎠ r 2 ∂χ 2 r ∂r ⎝
After introducing of the decompositions (1.73) into kinematic determination of uniform helical flows (1.43), we obtain φ = λψ,
ζ = − λφ = − λ2 ψ.
(1.76)
Therefore uniform helical flows with helical symmetry of flow field are completely determined by means of just one scalar function ψ, which satisfies the uniform equation ⎛ B4 ∆* ψ − ⎜ λ 2 B2 + 2λ ⎜ l ⎝
⎞ ⎟⎟ ψ = 0 . ⎠
(1.77)
Based on the first decompositions of (1.73) and (1.76), the velocity components in a cylindrical coordinate system in terms of ψ function, may be determined by means of the following formulae ur =
1 ∂ψ r ∂ψ ⎞ ∂ψ ⎞ ⎛r 2⎛ , uθ = B2 ⎜ λψ − ⎟ , uz = B ⎜ λψ + ⎟. l r l ∂r ⎠ ∂ r ∂χ ⎝ ⎠ ⎝
(1.78)
Thus, for uniform helical flows with helical symmetry, the problem of determination of velocity field can be fully reduced to the solution of a boundary problem for one scalar uniform linear equation (1.77). Then, based on the determined velocity field, the pressure may be recalculated by means of the Bernoulli integral.
1.6 Velocity field at specified distribution of sources and vortices
45
1.6 Velocity field at specified distribution of sources and vortices If vorticity field is known, for instance, from the solution of the Helmholtz equation, then the reverse problem; concerned with the construction of corresponding velocity field u, arises. The additional condition, imposed on u, would be the mass conservation equation (1.11). Nevertheless (1.11) includes another function as well, which is the density function ρ. In order to exclude this function, let us consider incompressible fluid satisfying ∇u = 0. Also, to demonstrate the generality of the mathematical operations for the two initial equations, let us introduce the density of volume sources ε(r, t), which will be included in the right-hand side of the equation of continuity for incompressible fluid. Then we obtain ∇u = ε,
∇×u = ,
(1.79)
where ε and are known functions of coordinates and time. Thus, the mathematical problem concludes in the determination of the vector field based on given distributions of divergence and the rotor of the sought vector. This problem is solvable, though the solution would be unique only under certain conditions. Let us consider the case of infinite space first, and then let us demonstrate the methods of accounting for solid boundaries following Sedov (1997) and Batchelor (1967). Let ε = ε(r) and = (r) be given within the whole infinite space and at the infinity (|r| → ∞) let ε → 0, → 0, u → 0. Then we can prove that the formulated problem has a unique solution, which can be expressed in the following form u(r, t) = uI(r, t) + uV(r, t).
(1.80)
Here uI is the solution of the problem (1.79) for the case ε ≠ 0, = 0 (irrotational or potential flow), while uV is the solution for ε = 0, ≠ 0, i.e. the initial problem splits into two new problems. Let us start with the first, when the density of the sources ε is known, and the flow is irrotational ∇u = ε,
∇ × u = 0.
(1.81)
Due to the second condition we may assume that u = ∇ϕ. Consequently we obtain the Poisson equation from the first condition ∇2ϕ = ε.
(1.82)
46
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
Here the potential ϕ is a scalar function of coordinates. The solution of the Poisson equation is well known and takes the form ϕ(r ) = −
1 4π
ε(r ′)
∫ r − r ′ dV(r ′) .
(1.83)
The integral should be taken over the whole volume occupied by the fluid, and can exist only if ε is imposed by some limitations. The proper relationship for velocity uI takes the form uI (r ) = ∇ϕ =
1 (r − r ′) ε (r ′) dV (r ′) . 4π r − r ′ 3
∫
(1.84)
Now let us consider the second problem, when the vorticity field is given but the sources are absent ∇u = 0,
∇×u = .
(1.85)
Based on the first equation we may assign u = ∇ × A,
(1.86)
where A is the vector potential. Obviously the velocity field will not change if we substitute A ⇒ A + ∇f, where f is an arbitrary scalar function, i.e. potential A is not uniquely determined. Selecting f in such a way that ∇A = 0, and using (1.86) and the second expression in (1.85), we have ∇ × (∇ × A) = ∇(∇A) – ∇2A = ,
wherefrom for A we obtain the Poisson vector equation ∇2A = – .
(1.87)
Similarly to the first problem we may notate the expression for vector potential and respective velocity uV
A(r ) =
1 4π
(r ′)
∫ r − r′ dV(r′) ,
uV (r ) =
1 4π
∫
(r ′) × (r − r ′) r − r′
3
dV (r ′) .
(1.88)
Just as in the first problem for ε, certain restrictions are imposed on vorticity distribution . In particular, the existence of discontinuity surfaces of vector are permitted, but normal components ωn should be continuous on these surfaces. Another requirement is that the vorticity should be nonzero only in the finite part of the space limited by surface S, where ωn = 0.
1.6 Velocity field at specified distribution of sources and vortices
47
The resulting expression for the velocity vector in an infinite space including sources and vortices takes the form u = ∇ϕ + ∇ × A =
1 ε ⋅ ∆r 1 dV + 3 4 π ∆r 4π
∫
∫
× ∆r ∆r
3
dV ,
(1.89)
where ∆r = r – r'. Now let the space filled with fluid posses solid boundaries Σ. Then for the solution of problem (1.79) one should specify the boundary conditions on Σ. Due to the linearity of the equation, this means that the sought solution (1.80) should be rewritten in the following form u = uI + uV + u0 ,
(1.90)
where the additional velocity field u0 satisfies equations (1.79) with a zero-equal right side ∇u0 = 0,
∇ × u0 = 0.
(1.91)
Here uI, uV as before are determined by the Eqs. (1.84) and (1.88), which account for the distribution of ε and in a mass of fluid, while the boundary conditions at the solid boundary Σ are included by means of solution u0. As is obvious from (1.91), the vector field u0 is both solenoidal and irrotational. Condition = 0 gives the existence of velocity potential ϕ, so that u0 = ∇ϕ. As was already noted, the velocity potential is uniquely determined only for a simply connected domain. Substituting the expression for velocity into the first equation (1.91), we obtain the Laplace equation for the scalar function ϕ ∇2ϕ = 0.
(1.92)
Thus it is necessary to also solve the boundary problem to determine the harmonic function ϕ(r). The boundary conditions at Σ may be very different, usually however the normal velocity component un is given. Finally, to use Eqs. (1.84) and (1.88) it is required to extend functions ε and , given in a space filled with fluid, through Σ boundary into the whole space. Again, there may be various possibilities of such extension. This is concerned with the specific character of a particular problem as well as a certain degree of arbitrariness (see (Batchelor 1967, Sedov 1997,
48
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
Saffman 1992)). Though we must take into account that the normal vorticity component ωn should be continuous on Σ 2. Note in conclusion that if the space is infinite and there are no sources, then the Poisson equation (1.82) transforms into the Laplace equation with solution ϕ = 0 for the case of infinite space. Then the resulting formula (1.89) will take the form u=
1 4π
∫
× ∆r ∆r
3
dV .
(1.93)
Based on analogy with the formulae of electromagnetic field theory, it can be said that vorticity induces velocity field. In the specific case of plain parallel flow the vector potential is A = (0, 0, ψ) and the vorticity vector is (r′) = (0, 0, ω). Stream function may be presented as a solution of the Poisson equation (1.87)
ψ (r ) = −
1 ω ( r ′ ) log r − r ′ dS′ . 2π
∫
(1.94)
After differentiating (1.94) we obtain the velocity field u=−
1 y − y′ 1 x − x′ ω(r ′) dS′ . dS′ and v = ω(r ′) 2 2 2π 2π r − r′ r − r′
∫
∫
(1.95)
For non-swirling axisymmetric flow with cylindrical variables (r, θ, z) the vector potential is A = (0, ψ/r, 0), while the vorticity vector is (r′) = (0, ω, 0). Introducing 12
2 s = ⎡( z − z′) + r 2 + r ′2 − 2rr ′ cos ( θ − θ′)⎤ ⎣ ⎦
and dV (r') = r'dz'dr'dθ, from (1.88) we obtain r ψ= 4π
∫∫
r ′ω ( r ′, z′ ) dr ′dz′
2π
∫ 0
cos θ dθ . s
The integral with respect to θ can be rewritten in the following form (Batchelor 1967) The latter condition can be removed, because we can always construct the Σ' surface, where · n = 0, beyond Σ boundary (concerning the extension of see Section 1.7.1.) 2
1.7 Vortex forces and invariants of vortex motion 2π
∫ 0
49
π⎡ 1 2⎤ −1 2 cos θdθ 1 2⎛ ⎛2 ⎞⎛ 2 2 θ⎞ 2 2 θ⎞ = − ⎜ 1 − k cos ⎟ ⎥ dθ = ⎢⎜ − k ⎟⎜1 − k cos ⎟ s k⎝ 2⎠ 2 ⎠ ⎥⎦ rr ′ 0 ⎢⎣⎝ k ⎠⎝ ⎤ 2 ⎡⎛ 2 2 ⎞ = ⎜ − k ⎟ K ( k ) − E ( k )⎥ , ⎢ k rr ′ ⎣⎝ k ⎠ ⎦
∫
12
2 2 where k2 = 4rr ′ ⎡( z − z′ ) + ( r + r ′ ) ⎤ ⎣ ⎦
K (k) =
π2
∫(
1 − k2 cos 2 θ
)
−1 2
, while
dθ and E ( k ) =
0
π2
∫ (1 − k
2
cos 2 θ
)
12
dθ
0
are complete elliptic integrals of the first and second kinds. Denoting ⎡⎛ 2 ⎤ 2 ⎞ f ( k ) = ⎢⎜ − k ⎟ K ( k ) − E ( k ) ⎥ , k ⎠ ⎣⎝ k ⎦
we get ψ=
1 2π
∫∫ f ( k )( rr ′)
12
ω ( r ′, z ′ ) dr ′dz ′ .
(1.96)
Accordingly, velocity components take the form ∂k 1 12 f ′ ( k ) ( rr ′ ) ω ( r ′, z′ ) dr ′dz′ , 2πr ∂z ⎡ f (k) ∂k ⎤ 1 12 uz = + f ′ ( k ) ⎥ ( rr ′ ) ω ( r ′, z′ ) dr ′dz′ . ⎢ 2πr ⎣ 2r ∂r ⎦ ur = −
∫∫
∫∫
(1.97)
1.7 Vortex forces and invariants of vortex motion 1.7.1 Vortex forces
The method of force balance is one of the most important approaches to the description of the dynamics of vortex structures. To understand and interpret correctly the forces in ideal fluid with vortices, firstly, we consider the forces acting on a solid body in uniform motion in ideal fluid with velocity U. Let us establish a coordinate system moving together with a body, and the coordinate origin is inside this body (see Fig. 1.11). In this system, the flow over a body has velocity at infinity U∞ = – U.
50
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
Fig. 1.11. On the definition of forces in the ideal fluid
Let us apply the theorem of momentum to a fluid volume between the body boundary A and circumference s of a large radius R (in 2-D statement). Normal vectors n are directed outward from the body surface A and inward from the circumference s. Let us introduce the velocity vector V in the moving frame of reference V = u – U,
(1.98)
where u is the velocity of fluid in the absolute coordinate system. In fact, u is the perturbation of fluid velocity caused by a solid body. In this connection, we should note that in the case of 2-D circulation flow around the body, velocity perturbation at large distances, R decreases ∞ Actually, let us use for example the soas 1/R, i.e., |u| = O(1/R) at R lution to the problem on circulation flow around a cylinder (circle) with the radius of a (see Loitsyanskii (1966)): u =
U a2 Γ − ∞2 → at 2πiz z
R → ∞,
where z = x + iy. It is obvious that for large distances, the cylinder radius is not included in the solution, and, it can be assumed that the asymptotic solution does not depend on the body shape and is determined only by the value of the circulation. Considering the absence of tangential stresses in the ideal fluid, the momentum balance is written as
1.7 Vortex forces and invariants of vortex motion
51
∫ pn ds + ∫ pn ds + ∫ ρV (V ⋅ n ) ds = 0. A
s
s
Here the first integral is the pressure force from the body on the fluid. Correspondingly, from the fluid the body experiences the force
∫
F = − pn ds . A
The second integral is the force of pressure from the ambient fluid on a control volume, and the third integral is a momentum flux through the surface s. Therefore, it follows from the momentum balance that the force of fluid impact on a solid body is completely determined by distribution of pressure and velocity on cylindrical surface s distanced from the body F = ρ V (V ⋅ n ) ds + pn ds .
∫
∫
s
s
We should remember that here ds is the element of length, therefore, the force is determined per a length unit of the cylinder generatrix by Bernoulli’s equation p = const – ρV2/2,
where the constant is the same for the whole space because the flow is irrotational. Then, taking into account (1.98) and neglecting the small terms, which are quadratic by u, we have F = −ρU (V ⋅ n ) ds − u (U ⋅ n ) ds +
∫
∫
s
s
⎛ U + ⎜ const − ρ ⎜ 2 ⎝
2
⎞ ⎟⎟ n ds + ρ ( u ⋅ U ) n ds . ⎠s s
∫
∫
∫
Here the first term on the right side vanishes because (V ⋅ n ) ds is the fluid flow rate through the control surface s, which equals zero in the absence of sources and sinks. The third term also vanishes because for the circumference s one has the identity:
∫ n ds = 0. s
Two other terms can be combined and expressed via the double vector product
52
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
∫ ⎡⎣u (U ⋅ n ) − ( u ⋅ U ) n ⎤⎦ ds = ∫ U × ( u × n ) ds. The substitution u u – U = V can be made in the last integral and since the additional integral is equal to zero, i.e.
∫ U × (U × n ) ds = U × (U × ∫ n ds) = 0 , s
s
we get
∫
F = −ρU × V × n ds .
(1.99)
s
The value U is taken outside the integral because this is the constant. Then, we introduce a unit vector t tangent to the circumference s, and a unit vector b, orthogonal to n and t, directed normally to the sketch plane in the reader’s direction as well as the z axis (see Fig. 1.11). Then, n = b × t. By this expression, we notate the integral in (1.99), again using the formulae of vector algebra
∫ V × n ds = ∫ V × (b × t) ds = ∫ (V ⋅ t ) b ds − t ∫ (V ⋅ b) ds = b Γ . This considers that V·b = 0 for a plane flow and, according to definition, ∫V·t ds = Γ is circulation. Sometimes the circulation vector is introduced = Γ b.
(1.100)
Finally, we have the following formula for the force F, acting on a solid body at its translational motion with velocity U in ideal fluid: F = – ρ U × b Γ.
(1.101)
In the case of uniform flow around an immobile body we get F = ρ U∞ × b Γ.
(1.102)
where U∞ = – U is the flow velocity at infinity. These relationships are the Kutta – Joukowski formula. According to Eqs. (1.101), (1.102), force F does not depend on the body shape. It is oriented normally to direction of the body or flow motion as it is shown in Fig. 1.11, and determined only by circulation around the body. Correspondingly, the module of this force is F = ρ U∞ |Γ|.
1.7 Vortex forces and invariants of vortex motion
53
To determine the direction of the equivalent force action, the following rule may be used: the direction of the resultant force affecting the body is obtained by rotation of the body velocity vector by the angle of 90° relative to the fluid towards the velocity circulation. Since the force component towards the body motion is zero, Eq. (1.101) also illustrates the known D’Alembert paradox on friction absence upon the motion of a body in ideal fluid. Now we consider the problem of the force balance in the flow with areas of concentrated vorticity. We rewrite Gromeka – Lamb equation (1.12), rearranging the convective terms to the right side ρ
⎛ u2 ⎞ ∂u = ρg − ∇p − ρ∇ ⎜ ⎟ + ρu × . ⎜ 2 ⎟ ∂t ⎝ ⎠
(1.103)
The value ρ u × is called the vortex force (Prandtl 1919, Saffman 1992). Integrating the equation (1.103) at ρ = const over the fixed volume V, we have ∂ ρu dV = − pT n dS + (ρg + ρu × ) dV. ∂t
∫
∫
∫
(1.104)
1 2 ρu is the total pressure. 2 The left side is the rate of fluid momentum alteration inside the volume V. At steady motion, this value vanishes. In this case, equation (1.104) provides the condition of the balance between pressure forces affecting the surface bounded by the volume V, external forces and vortex force. We should note that if there are no external forces beyond V and the Bernoulli constant at the volume surface is the same (this occurs when the surface is the streamline surface), the first integral on the right side of (1.104) vanishes, and hence, the external force becomes balanced by the vortex force. In other words, the value ρ u × in a steady flow can not be expressed by the gradient of some function, and hence, it cannot be compensated by the pressure forces because some external non-conservative mass force should be applied to the fluid for balance maintenance. The idea of kinematic substitution of the body moving relative to the fluid by vorticity distribution providing the required streamlining conditions on the body surface is directly connected with the concept of the vortex force. Joukowski called these systems bound vortices. This imaginary distribution of vorticity can be considered as a continuation of the free vorticity field into the body. Simultaneously, an imaginary velocity field appears inside the body. It is necessary to note that the field of bound vorticity does not satisfy Helm-
Here pT = p +
54
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
holtz equation. Despite the infinitely many distributions of bound vorticity, the velocity field induced by this vorticity beyond the body should be the same. We should also note that the distribution of bound vorticity depends on the presence of other bodies and free vorticity. Among the many methods of vorticity field continuation into a body, we wish to mention the following: a) it is assumed that within the continuation area curl = 0 (Batchelor 1967); in this case = grad f, ∆f = 0; b) the properties of symmetry are used (for the area limited by a plane, sphere or cylindrical surface); c) the technique of conformal mapping of the flow area to the area with symmetrical properties is applied for the 2-D problems (see Chapter 6); d) if on the surface · n = 0, inside the body it is assumed to be = 0; the surface is thereby substituted by the vortex sheet (Saffman 1992). If the distribution of bound vorticity is determined and the total pressure on the body surface is constant, the force FB, affecting the body, is FB = ρ
∫ u×
dV .
VB
(1.105)
Using the vector identity and converting the volumetric integral to the surface one, we get for incompressible fluid
∫ u×
VB
dV =
⎡ 1
∫ ⎢⎣∇ 2 u
VB
2
⎤ ⎛1 ⎞ − (u∇)u ⎥ dV = ⎜ u 2 ⋅ n − u(u ⋅ n) ⎟ dS .(1.106) ⎦ ⎝2 ⎠ S
∫
B
The right side of equation (1.106) is determined by the velocity on the body boundary, and it does not depend on the method of imaginary system determination. Hence, the total force does not depend on the partial distribution of bound vorticity. As an example, we again consider the irrotational flow around the cylinder of radius a with circulation Γ > 0. The cylinder axis is directed along axis z, and its motion is 2-D and occurs in plane xy (Fig. 1.12). The flow potential in polar coordinates r, θ takes the form (e.g., see Loitsyansky (1966)) ϕ = − U∞ (r + a 2 r ) cos θ + Γ θ 2π .
Now we remove the cylinder and substitute it for the distribution of bound vorticity. Vortex lines are parallel to axis z, i.e., = (0,0, ω). One of the infinite possible distributions of vorticity is:
1.7 Vortex forces and invariants of vortex motion
55
Fig. 1.12. On the description of the irrotational flow of ideal fluid around the cylinder with circulation Γ
ω=
Γ πa
2
+
8 U∞ a2
r sin θ, r < a .
(1.107)
The corresponding velocity field inside the cylinder is solenoidal. It is described by the formulae u = − U∞ (1 + 2sin 2 θ)
r2 a
v = 2 U∞ sin θ cos θ
2
+ U∞ −
r2 a
2
+
Γ
2πa 2
Γ 2πa 2
r sin θ ,
r cos θ .
(1.108)
(1.109)
Expanding (1.105) FB = ρ
∫
u×
r ≤R
∫
∫
dV = ρ ⎡ − j uω dV + i vω dV ⎤ ⎣ ⎦
and substituting Eqs. (1.107) – (1.109), we find FB = ρ U∞ Γ j = ρU∞ × k Γ .
By doing so, we again come to the Kutta – Joukowski formula (1.102), where b k. The idea of the vortex force can also be applied to the determination of velocity of the straight vortex filament subject to the external force F. In-
56
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
deed, in the coordinate system moving together with the vortex, the vortex force is ρ (u – uV) × , where u is the flow velocity, uV is the vortex velocity. The equilibrium condition requires that F + (u – uV) × = 0. If the vortex filament is oriented along basis vector k, we obtain uV = u + k × F/Γ.
1.7.2 Vortex momentum and vortex angular momentum
One of the advantages of the fluid motion description via vorticity distribution is in the existence of invariants of vortex motion, which are determined by the initial vorticity distribution and do not change with time. Therefore, some properties of the flow can be predicted without studying the flow details. The first two invariants include the so-called vortex momentum and the vortex angular momentum. We consider the flow of unbounded fluid resting at infinity without inner boundaries and in the presence of a confined area of vorticity3. The fluid density is assumed to be constant. The real momentum of the fluid ρ∫udV is determined conditionally because the value of the integral may depend on the shape of the surface, where the volume of integration tends to infinity. Thus, we proceed as follows: we calculate the resultant momentum, which should be applied to a limited fluid volume to provide the given motion from resting. This quantity is called the fluid impulse of the flow field (Batchelor 1967, p. 518). For the subsequent analysis we introduce a certain necessary integral identity. On the basis of vector identity ∇(b · a) = a × curl b + b × curl a + (a∇)b + (b∇)a
and assuming that b
r, we get
r × curl a = − a + ∇(r · a) − (r∇)a.
We notate the last term on the right side for each component of vector a (r∇)ai = ∇(r ai) − ai ∇r = ∇(r ai) − 3ai . Then, we integrate the vector identity over the volume, considering the last relationship, and convert two volumetric integrals containing gradients into the surface ones. Finally, using the formula of double vector product, we will obtain the integral identity 3
Results will not change if vorticity decreases exponentially at infinity.
1.7 Vortex forces and invariants of vortex motion
∫ r × curl a dV = 2∫ a dV + ∫ r × (n × a) dS.
57
(1.110)
This identity is true only for the 3-D space because at transformations it is taken into account that ∇r = 3. In the plane case, this value is 2 and, correspondingly, in (1.110) coefficient 1 will be used instead of 2 on the right side. Applying identity (1.110) to the velocity vector, we have 1 ρ u dV = ρ r × 2
∫
1 dV − ρ r × (n × u) dS. 2
∫
∫
(1.111)
A part of momentum, namely the value
1 I = ρ r× 2
∫
dV ,
(1.112)
which was introduced by Lamb (1932), is called the vortex impulse (or vortex momentum). The second term is finite, if surface S tends to infinity, but the value of the integral depends upon the surface shape. To verify this, we take into account that at infinity the flow field is potential, and without sources and sinks the main term of asymptotic expansion of potential is the dipole ϕ = – D·r/r3. The intensity of the dipole is proportional to the vortex momentum D = I/4π (Saffman 1992). Now we find velocity is asymptotic at infinity u ≡ ∇ϕ ∼
⎡3 ⎤ ( I ⋅ r )r − I ⎥ . ⎢ 2 4π r ⎣ r ⎦ 1
3 3
Substituting the result obtained into the surface integral in (1.111), we find that in spherical geometry, the integral equals – I/3, i.e., if the surface is a sphere, the “real” momentum is
∫
ρ u dV = (2 3) I. V
The same result will be obtained if V is a cube. If the volume has anisotropy, the result will differ. For instance, for the body in the form of a cylinder, whose height equals its’ diameter and the axis is directed along the axis of Ox, the integral is equal to ⎛ 4−2 2 2 2 ⎞ Ix , − Iy , − Iz . ⎜⎜ − 4 4 4 ⎝ ⎠
58
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
We will show that the amount of vortex momentum, required to generate motion from resting, does not depend on time, even in the case of unsteady flow. Indeed, with consideration of Helmholtz equation (1.15) we have from (1.112): dI 1 ⎛ = ρ ⎜u× dt 2 ⎝
∫
+r×
d dt
1 ⎞ ⎟ dV = ρ 2 ⎠
∫ (u ×
+ r × ( ∇)u ) dV .
Let us use one of conclusions from Gauss – Ostrogradskii theorem (divergence theorem)
∫ ⎡⎣b(∇a) + (a∇)b⎤⎦dV = ∫ b(a ⋅ n) dS,
(1.113)
which at substitution of r × b instead of b takes the form
∫ ⎡⎣r × (a∇)b + a × b + (r × b)∇a⎤⎦dV = ∫ (r × b) ⋅ (a ⋅ n) dS. Assuming a =
(1.114)
, b = u, for the derivative of the momentum we get
dI = ρ u× dt
∫
1 dV + ρ (r × u) ⋅ ( ⋅ n) dS. 2
∫
The surface integral becomes zero, since disappears at infinity. The first item is the integral of force and it can be reduced to the surface integral of velocity (see (1.106)). Owing to the fact that the velocity at infinity decreases as r –3, we see that this integral also becomes zero. Therefore, dI/dt = 0, which was to be proved. Another quantity required for the description of rotational motion of fluid from rest is the resultant angular momentum. Lamb (1932, § 152) has defined the momentum related to vorticity (or vortex angular momentum) as:
1 M = − ρ r 2 dV . 2
∫
(1.115)
Let us compare the quantity M with the “real” angular momentum of fluid ρ ∫ r × u dV. From the theorem about the curl (G. Korn and T. Korn 1968) we get
1 1 ρ r × u dV = − ρ r 2 dV − ρ r 2 (u × n) dS. 2 2
∫
∫
∫
1.7 Vortex forces and invariants of vortex motion
59
The surface integral in general diverges, nevertheless, if S is a sphere containing all the vorticity, then r 2 = const and if ( ·n) = 0 on the surface, the integral becomes zero, as it follows from the chain of transformations
∫ n × u dS = ∫
dV =
∫ [ r∇
+ ( ∇)r ] dV = r ( ⋅ n) dS = 0 .
∫
It is considered here that ∇ = 0. The definition of angular momentum provided by Batchelor (1967) is somewhat different
1 M = ρ r × (r × ) dV . 3
∫
From identity (1.113), assuming a =
(1.116)
, b = r 2·r, we find
1 1 2 1 2 r × (r × ) dV + r dV = r r ( ⋅ n) dS . 3 2 6
∫
∫
∫
Thus, it follows that definitions (1.115) and (1.116) are equivalent, if ( ·n) = 0 at the boundary. This is also true for the unbounded fluid because disappears at infinity. We will show that the angular momentum M is invariant. Let us notate the time derivative of Eq. (1.115) with consideration of (1.15) ⎡ ⎡ ⎤ dM r2 d ⎤ r2 = −ρ ⎢ (r ⋅ u) + ⎥ dV = − ρ ⎢(r ⋅ u) + ( ∇)u ⎥ dV. dt 2 dt ⎥⎦ 2 ⎢⎣ ⎣⎢ ⎦⎥
∫
∫
Applying Eq. (1.113) at a =
∫ ⎡⎣r
2
, b = r 2 u, we discover
∫
( ∇) u + 2u(r ⋅ ) ⎤ dV = r 2 u( ⋅ n) dS. ⎦
As a result, for the derivative of M we have
1 dM = ρ r × (u × ) dV − ρ r 2 u( ⋅ n) dS . 2 dt
∫
∫
It is obvious that the first term here is the integral of the vortex force moment; the surface integral tends to zero due to the disappearance of at infinity. Applying relationships u × = ∇(u 2/2) − (u∇)u, ∇ × (u 2 r) = ∇u 2 × r and Eq. (1.114) at a = b = u, we get
⎡ ⎤ ⎛ u2 ⎞ ⎡ u2 ⎤ dM = −ρ ⎢∇ × ⎜ r + r × (u∇)u ⎥ dV = ρ r × ⎢n − u(u ⋅ n) ⎥ dS . ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ dt ⎝ 2 ⎠ ⎣⎢ 2 ⎦⎥ ⎣⎢ ⎦⎥
∫
∫
60
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
The integrand has asymptotic O(r –5) at infinity, and this provides zero value of the surface integral, i.e., dM/dt = 0. When examining the momentum of vortex motion of fluid in a bounded region, Vladimirov (1977 ) interprets the surface integral in relationship (1.111) as the bound impulse caused by vorticity distribution over a bounding surface with density u × n, i.e., the vortex momentum is the sum of the momentum intrinsic to a given fluid volume and attached momentum. The bound angular momentum is interpreted in the same way. The surface integral in the expression for angular momentum of the vortex fluid motion in a bounded region is
1 M= ρ 3
{∫ r × (r ×
}
∫
) dV + r × (r × [n × u]) dS .
The generalization of definition of vortex momentum for the flow of non-uniform density incompressible fluid is also presented in cited work
I=
1 r × curl(ρu) dV . 2
∫
Deficiency of absolute convergence of integral ∫ ρ udV can be eliminated, if we consider the motion of a slightly compressible medium (Saffman 1992). The motion generated by concentrated pulse force was considered as the example. It was demonstrated that the momentum of fluid confined in a sphere of radius ct, expanding with the sound velocity c, is equal to 2I0/3. Here index 0 means that a density of undisturbed flow is taken for ρ. The remainder, I0/3, is concentrated at a spherical front. It is interesting to note that invariants I and M stay valid even for a viscous unbounded fluid. Indeed, the action of viscosity is equivalent to supplementary mass force ν∇2u, added to the right side of equation (1.103). Correspondingly, the balance of total forces is supplemented with integral
∫
∫
ν ∇ 2 u dV = −ν ∇ ×
∫
dV = −ν n ×
dS,
and the integral
∫
∫
∫
∫
ν r × ∇ 2 u dV = −ν r × (∇ × ) dV = −ν r × (n × ) dS − 2ν n × u dS.
is added to the balance of force moments. Identity r × (∇ × ) = ∇(r · ) − (r ∇)
−
and Eq. (1.113) were applied at a = r, b = , to reduce the last integral to the surface one. The surface integrals vanish, since u = O(r –3), and dis-
1.7 Vortex forces and invariants of vortex motion
61
appears at infinity. Hence, viscous forces do not influence the rate of impulse and angular impulse change. Saffman (1992) presents the development laws for impulse
IV =
1 r× 2
∫
dVV
(1.117)
and angular momentum MV = −
1 2 r dVV 2
∫
(1.118)
of isolated vortices in the presence of external forces g and external velocity ue, which can be induced by other vortices or imaginary vorticity. The above relationships take the form dIV = gdVV + ue × dt
∫
∫
dVV ,
dMV = r × gdVV + r × (ue × ) dVV , dt
∫
∫
where integration is performed over volume VV, occupied by the vortex. Note that even in the bounded flows, the laws of momentum and momentum conservation can be partially satisfied. For instance, in a vortex flow in a region limited by a plane wall or two parallel walls, without mass forces the momentum component parallel to the wall is the invariant (Betz 1932). It is obvious that the flow in a sphere under conditions u · n = 0, · n = 0 at the surface has invariant M. Considered invariants I and M correspond to invariants of Euler equations relative to a spatial translation and rotation. Two additional invariants – kinetic energy and helicity, are connected with the invariance properties of Euler equations relative to time and plane reflection invariance. 1.7.3 Kinetic energy
The kinetic energy of fluid bounded by the volume V, is T=
1
∫ 2 ρu dV. 2
Introducing the vector potential A, at a constant fluid density, we have
62
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
1 1 T = ρ u(∇ × A) dV = ρ A ⋅ 2 2
∫
∫
1 dV + ρ n ⋅ ( A × u) dS . 2
∫
In the infinite fluid the surface integral disappears, and considering (1.88), we have 1 T = ρ A⋅ 2
∫
dV =
1 ρ 8π
∫∫
(r ) ⋅ (r ′) dVdV ′. r − r′
(1.119)
Another expression for kinetic energy is presented by Lamb (1932)
∫
T = ρ u(r × ) dV . Equivalence of definitions can be checked by integration of identity 1 2 ⎡1 ⎤ u − u ⋅ (r × ) = div ⎢ u 2r − u ⋅ (r ⋅ u) ⎥ . 2 ⎣2 ⎦
The integral of the right side vanishes since it is reduced to the surface integral with the asymptotic of integrand O(r –5). Kinetic energy is invariant, if the incompressible fluid is unbounded or bounded by resting walls, external forces are conservative with the singlevalued potential Π and viscosity equals zero. Indeed, it follows from Euler equation (1.10) that
1 d du ρ u 2 dV = ρ u dV = dt 2 dt
∫
∫
∫ [ −u∇p + u ⋅ g] dV = −∫ (Π + p)(u ⋅ n) dS .
The surface integral vanishes, if u · n = 0 at the surface or the surface tends to infinity. 1.7.4 Helicity
The fourth invariant is helicity. It was defined by Moffatt (1969)
H = ∫ u ⋅ dV .
(1.120)
Helicity characterizes the linkage degree of vortex lines in a flow. We examine two wound vortex filaments C1 and C2 (Fig. 1.13) with intensities 1 and 2 as the simplest example. Assume that both lines are not knotted, i.e., they are continuously shrunk into a point. According to Stokes theorem, the circulation around the first contour is
1.7 Vortex forces and invariants of vortex motion
a
63
b
Fig. 1.13. The right ( ) and left (b) single winding of vortex filaments
K1 =
∫ u ds = ∫
C1
⋅ n dS .
S1
Since the vorticity flux through S1 is induced only by the second filament C2, then if the filaments are not linked ⎧0, K1 = ⎨ ⎩ ±Γ 2 , if the filaments are single-linked Sign “+” here corresponds to “right” winding, i.e., the circulation direction of the induced velocity around contour C1 coincides with the direction of the vorticity vector on the filament C1; sign “–” corresponds to “left” winding. In general, filament C2 may wind around C1 any whole number of times. In this case K1 = α12 · Γ2 where α12 (= α21) is an integer, which can be either positive or negative (‘the parameter of mutual winding of curves’ C1 and C2). Now we consider the value Γ1 K1, written as the integral over the volume V1, occupied by the vortex filament C1. Since ds is parallel to vector on the filament, Γ1 ds can be substituted by dV, i.e., Γ1K1 =
∫ Γ1u ds = ∫ u ⋅
C2
dV .
V1
While calculating the sum, we obtain
H = ∑ αij ΓiΓ j = 2α12Γ1Γ 2 = ∫ u ⋅ dV , i, j
V
64
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
where V is the volume occupied by both filaments, or alternatively, the whole volume occupied by the fluid (since vorticity concentrates only on filaments). The value H = ±2n Γ1 Γ2, where n is the number of windings of one filament around another, and the sign indicates a right or left winding direction. The simplest description of helicity density h = u · is peculiar to the flow with helical symmetry (see section 1.5.1). In this case h = u0 · ωz. In real swirl flows, the value ωz changes slightly, whereas, u0 varies across a wide range and can change its sign, i.e., in these flows the helicity density is determined by the velocity at the flow axis. Helicity does not change with time at the motion of inviscid incompressible fluid under the action of a conservative force. The rate of helicity change is dH ⎛ du = ⎜ dt ⎝ dt
∫
+u
d dt
⎡1 ⎤ ⎞ ⎟ dV = ⎢ ( −∇p − ∇Π ) + u( ∇ )u ⎥ dV = ⎠ ⎣ρ ⎦
∫
⎛ − p − Π u2 ⎞ = ⎜ + ⎟( ⋅ n) dS . ⎜ ρ 2 ⎟⎠ ⎝
∫
Due to this, it is clear that in the infinite fluid with a bounded region of vorticity dH /dt = 0. In the bounded region helicity is the invariant, if the condition · n = 0 is satisfied at the region boundary. Conservation of helicity means that the “knottedness” structure of the vortex field is maintained (Moffatt 1969). The helicity invariant is related to the more common topological characteristic: the Hopf invariant (see Moffatt (1984)). Helicity is of special importance in magnetic hydrodynamics, particularly, in the dynamo theory (Moffatt and Tsinober 1992). 1.7.5 Invariants of two-dimensional flows
When studying the invariants of a two-dimensional fluid flow, it is necessary to consider some important differences. Firstly, the velocity at infinity may have the order of r –1. Secondly, vorticity is the maintained scalar value = (0, 0, ω) (there is no effect of vorticity amplification due to the stretching of vortex tubes). Finally, the velocity field u, v in variables x, y is determined by one scalar function namely the stream function (the third velocity component in the direction of axis z is usually neglected because it affects neither the velocity components in the flow plane, nor the pressure distribution).
1.7 Vortex forces and invariants of vortex motion
65
Due to a slow decrease in the velocity at infinity, it is impossible to apply directly the total momentum, angular momentum and kinetic energy of fluid4. However, there are some related quantities, which are invariant. Moreover, the additional invariant appears
∫
Γ = ω dS .
It is equal to the velocity circulation over a closed contour covering the whole region of the vortical fluid. The evidence of invariance Γ follows from the conservation of vorticity and the area of a fluid element (see also Section 1.2). For the following analysis we need the asymptotic of the stream function at infinity. Substituting expansion log |r − r′| = log r − r ⋅ r′/r2 + O(1/r2) into (1.94), we find ψ∼−
1 ⎡ Γ log r + 2π 2π ⎣⎢
( ∫ ωr × k dS ) × r ⎤⎦⎥ ⋅ rk + O ⎛⎜⎝ r1 ⎞⎟⎠. 2
2
(1.121)
Here k is a unit vector, normal to the flow plane. We should note that the second term has the order of O(1/r). To eliminate the problem of integral divergence, Batchelor (1967) suggests considering the characteristics of auxiliary flow with the stream function
ψ′ = ψ +
Γ log r . 2π
This flow is the difference between the given motion and the steady motion with the same total vorticity concentrated at the coordinate origin. Alternatively, this transformation can be called the reduction to zero total vorticity. The velocity of auxiliary flow decreases as r –2 at r ∞. Nevertheless, the integrals in determination of total momentum and angular momentum of fluid are still not completely converging. The magnitudes of corresponding values of the vortex momentum and the vortex angular momentum in the flow with a bounded region of the vortical fluid are determined correctly (the quantities are reduced to a unit length in zdirection) 4
The fourth invariant – helicity, has no sense for the plain and axisymmetrical flows without swirling because · u = 0.
66
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
(∫
∫
)
∫
I = ρ ωr × k dS = ρ yωdS, −ρ xωdS, 0 ,
(1.122)
1 1 ⎛ ⎞ M = − ρ r 2 ωk dS = ⎜ 0, 0, − ρ ( x 2 + y 2 )ω dS ⎟ . 2 2 ⎝ ⎠
(1.123)
∫
∫
There is no multiplier 1/2 in determination of momentum because the vortex lines are not closed. If the vortex lines are closed through the end planes of a unit thickness layer, and this vorticity is taken into account, the expression will coincide with (1.112) (Saffman 1992). To establish a connection of I with the ‘genuine’ momentum, we will use a plane analog of identity (1.110)
∫ r × rot a dS = ∫ a dS − ∫ r × (n × a) ds , wherefrom at a = u we get
∫ u dS = ∫ r ×
dS +
∫ r × (n × u) ds .
Let us estimate the contour integral for a circle of large radius R. Asymptotics of the velocity field of an auxiliary flow (or the flow at Γ = 0) will be determined by the stream function (1.121) taking into account (1.122) u∼
1
⎡ − Ir 2 + 2( I ⋅ r )r ⎤ . ⎦ 2πρr 4 ⎣
Substitution into the contour integral at the limit provides lim ρ
R→∞
∫
u dS =
r
1 I. 2
Therefore, in a 2-D flow a half of the applied momentum converts into the momentum of unbounded fluid, and the second half goes to infinity. The vortex angular momentum of the auxiliary flow (or the flow at Γ = 0) coincides with the real angular momentum. Indeed, 1 1 M = − ρ r 2 ∇ × u dS = ρ r × u dS − ρ ∇ × (r 2 u) dS. 2 2
∫
∫
∫
The first integral on the right side is the real angular momentum, and the second integral is reduced to the contour one, which provides 1/2 ρR2Γ = 0 at integration over the circle of large radius R.
1.7 Vortex forces and invariants of vortex motion
67
Now we consider kinetic energy of the plane motion of fluid. According to Batchelor (1967), we notate ∂ψ ⎞ 1 1 ⎛ ∂ψ −v T = ρ (u 2 + v2 ) dS = ρ ⎜ u ⎟ dS = ∂x ⎠ 2 2 ⎝ ∂y ⎡ ∂ (uψ ) ∂ (vψ) ⎤ 1 1 1 = ρ ⎢ψω + − dS = ρ ψω dS − ρ ψu ds. ⎥ 2 2 2 ∂y ∂x ⎦ ⎣
∫
∫
∫
∫
∫
The first of these two integrals converges at the tending of S to infinity. Behavior of the second integral at high values of r will be estimated using asymptotics of the stream function (1.121). Choosing a circumference of radius R as a boundary of the integration domain, we find
∫ i.e., at R
ψu ds ~ −
1 log R 2π
(∫
ω dS
)
2
=−
Γ2 log R , 2π
∞ Γ2 1 T − ρ ψω dS − ρ log R → 0. 2 4π
∫
The value 1 ρ T0 = ρ ψω dS = − ρ 2 8π
∫
∫∫ ω( r ) ω ( r ′) ln r − r ′ dSdS′
(1.124)
equals the part of fluid kinetic energy, which depends on the distribution of total fluid vorticity. To notate the double integral, we use the presentation of the stream function (1.94). Since ψ is a component of the vector potential, it seems natural to use definition (1.119). Really, at Γ = 0 definition (1.124) can be obtained from (1.119). For the finite value of total circulation in the unbounded fluid, kinetic energy is infinite, and instead of T the value T0 should be used. To ensure that T0 is invariant we consider the rate of the stream function change with the help of (1.94). Since in the plane flow dω/dt = 0, ⎡ ⎤ 2( x − x ′) 2( y − y′) 1 dψ =− ω( x ′, y ′) ⎢u +v ⎥ dS 2 2 2 2 4π dt ( x − x ′) + ( y − y ′) ⎦⎥ ⎣⎢ ( x − x ′) + ( y − y′)
∫
and taking into account the formula of velocity determination (1.95), we obtain dψ/dt = 0, and hence, dT0 /dt = 0.
68
1 Equations and laws of vortex motion
Thus, in the plane flow of fluid with vorticity, quantities Γ, Ix, Iy, M and T0 are constant. When Γ ≠ 0, we can introduce other invariants related to I and M, and namely, the coordinates of vorticity centroid Xc =
∫ xω dS , Y = ∫ yω dS c ∫ ω dS ∫ ω dS
and the dispersion of vorticity distribution relative to the vorticity centroid
∫ [(x − Xc ) + (y − Yc )] ω dS = ∫ (x + y ) dS − X 2 − Y 2 , = c c ∫ ω dS ∫ ω dS 2
D
2
2
(1.125)
1 i.e., I = ρΓ(Yc, −Xc, 0) = ρΓRc × k, M = − ρ Γ( D2 + Xc2 + Yc2 ) k . 2 For the axisymmetrical flow with circular vortex lines in cylindrical coordinates (r, θ, z) = (0, ω, 0), A = (0, ψ/r, 0). In this case, the vortex momentum I = πρ
∫∫ ω r drdz 2
(1.126)
is directed along the axis of symmetry; and the kinetic energy is written as T = πρ
∫∫ ψω drdz.
(1.127)
It will be shown in Section 3.2.1 that knowing values I and T for the vortex ring, we can determine the velocity of its motion. Helicity and angular momentum in the considered flow are identically equal to zero. The spherical Hicks vortex (see Section 3.2) can be presented as the example of a vortex with non-zero helicity. The flow in the Hicks vortex is axisymmetrical with swirl, and it can be described by the stream function satisfying equation (1.57). The streamlines and vortex lines are situated on the stream surfaces, forming a family of nested tori. The flow possesses non-zero helicity, momentum, angular momentum and kinetic energy, which are constant in time.
2 Vortex filaments
2.1 Geometry of vortex filaments The key object in the vortical flow theory is the vortex filament; its widest definition is a vortex tube surrounded by fluid with zero vorticity. It is clear that this strict definition is applicable to the ideal fluid only. In real fluids the diffusion of vorticity occurs, however, the concept of the vortex filament is useful and contansive for a medium with a low viscosity. If we tend the filament cross-section to zero and maintain a constant value for circulation Γ, we obtain the vorticity distribution, different from zero only along a certain spatial curve. This vorticity distribution is called an infinitely thin vortex filament, or a line vortex (do not confuse this with a vortex line). In some literature, the term ‘vortex filament’ just means an infinitely thin vortex filament. We will use the term “vortex filament” also for interpretation of experimental results on swirl flow study, where vortex structures have elongated spatial shapes with vorticity concentrating along the axis. The examples are: tornado, waterspout, vortex behind the turbine runner, etc. The peculiarity of the listed structures is their three-dimensional geometry. Therefore we should consider the main methods of description and the basic (canonic) types of spatial curves with special emphasis on a helical line. Generally, the spatial curve might be given in parametric form (Bronshtein and Semendyaev 1985) r = r(α)
or
x = x(α), y = y(α), z = z(α).
(2.1)
Here α is a real parameter. The positive direction on this curve corresponds to the growth of α. The arc length s along the curve between points M0 and M, which are given by values of parameters α0 and α, is determined by formulae α
s=
∫
α0
2
ds,
⎛ dr ⎞ 2 2 2 ds = ⎜ ⎟ dα = x + y + z dα, d α ⎝ ⎠
70
2 Vortex filaments
where the dot represents a derivative with respect to α. If we fix point M0, the length s along the curve can be considered as a new parameter, i.e.
r = r(s)
or
x = x(s), y = y(s), z = z(s).
(2.2)
Besides Eqs. (2.1) and (2.2), other methods for description of a spatial curve are possible: 1 – by the introduction of a right-hand triple of orthogonal unit vectors (t, n, b), called a moving trihedron for point M of a spatial curve and representing three vectors directed along tangent, principal normal, and bi-normal; 2 – via two shape parameters – curvature and torsion – for this spatial curve at each point. Let us consider those parameters in detail. The unit vector of the tangent is t = dr(s)/ds. This vector coincides with the tangent at point M and is directed to the same side as the curve (Fig. 2.1). The unit vector n, co-directional to vector d2r (s)/ds2 is called a principal normal vector at point M (hereafter: normal vector). The binormal vector b is defined as b = t × n. One can prove that with the accuracy of the second infinitesimal order terms, the spatial curve element lies in the plane formed by vectors t, n. This plane is called the osculating plane. Note that the vector n is directed inside the arc on this plane. The curvature κ at point M is defined by relationships
d2 r ( s)
or κ = [ x ′′2 + y ′′2 + z ′′2 ]1/ 2 ≥ 0, ds 2 where the prime represents the derivative with respect to length s along the curve. The reciprocal value is a curvature radius R = 1/ κ. Note that for the plain case the curvature is a sign-alternated quantity. Torsion τ of a spatial curve is defined by the formula
κn =
τ=
(t × t′) ⋅ t ′′ t′
2
x ′ y′ z′ 1 = 2 x′′ y′′ z′′ . x′′ + y′′2 + z′′2 x′′′ y′′′ z′′′
(2.3)
Fig. 2.1. Right-hand triple of orthogonal unit vectors (t, n, b), used for the description of a spatial curve
2.1 Geometry of vortex filaments
71
The value τ = 0 implies that the curve is flat. Unlike the curvature parameter, the torsion has a sign that defines the direction of the curve twist. If τ > 0, the curve resembles a right-handed screw, while τ < 0 corresponds to a left-handed screw. If the curve is given in the form (2.1), then
κ2 =
1 R2
=
( x 2 + y 2 + z 2 )( x 2 + y 2 + z 2 ) − ( x x + y y + z z) 2 ( x 2 + y 2 + z 2 )3
τ=
x y z x y z . ( x 2 + y 2 + z 2 )3 x y z R2
,
(2.4)
(2.5)
The curvature and torsion are related to the triple of unit vectors (t, n, b) through Frenet – Serret equations
dt = κn , ds
dn = τb − κt , ds
db = −τn . ds
(2.6)
One can see from the above formula that the curve torsion may be interpreted as the angular velocity of the bi-normal rotation around the instant position of the tangent. Let us take a helical curve as an example; it is described in a parametric way
x = a cos α, y = a sin α, z = l α, a > 0.
(2.7)
Here a is the cylinder radius with the helical curve wound on, parameter α has the meaning of angle, counted from a certain point M0 (Fig. 2.2). The value 2πl is the helix pitch, and l > 0 corresponds to the right-handed screw depicted in the figure, and l < 0 - to the left-handed one. Taking the expression for the arc length s, we obtain α
∫
s = ( x 2 + y 2 + z 2 )1/ 2 dα = α a 2 + l 2 .
(2.8)
0
Correspondingly,
(
)
(
)
x = a cos s / a 2 + l 2 , y = a sin s / a 2 + l 2 , z = ls / a 2 + l 2 . Then the curvature and torsion are
κ = 1 R = x ′′2 + y ′′2 + z ′′2 = a (a 2 + l 2 ) = const ,
(2.9)
72
2 Vortex filaments
Fig. 2.2. Helical curve
−a sin α a cos α l l τ= −a cos α −a sin α 0 = 2 2 = const. (2.10) 3 ⎡(−a sin α)2 + (a cos α)2 + l2 ⎤ a sin α −a cos α 0 a + l ⎣ ⎦ R2
It is also easy to calculate the triple of unit vectors
l⎤ ⎡ − sin α, cos α, ⎥ , ⎢ a⎦ a2 + l2 ⎣ r ′′ = [ − cos α, − sin α, 0] , n= r ′′
t = r′ =
b =t×n =
a
(2.11)
a⎤ ⎡ sin α, − cos α, ⎥ . ⎢ l⎦ a2 + l2 ⎣ l
And the formula for the slope angle of the helical curve β is the following: tan β =
l τ = . a κ
(2.12)
Note that a circle is an example of a curve with zero torsion (τ = 0) and curvature is inversely proportional to the circle radius a
κ = 1/a,
(2.13)
while a straight line is an example of a curve with zero torsion and zero curvature.
2.2 Biot – Savart law
73
2.2 Biot – Savart law Let us derive a velocity distribution induced by an infinitely thin closed vortex filament with intensity Γ in infinite space with zero vorticity. We consider a closed vortex filament with a small, but finite cross-section δS (Fig. 2.3). Then vector is parallel to the filament element ds. Here we use Eq. (1.93), transformed into the following form, assuming dV = δS ds: 1 1 × ∆r × ∆r δSds = lim δSds . u= 3 3 0 S δ → 4π 4π ∆r ∆r
∫
∫
V
s
Here V is the vortex filament volume. According to the Stokes theorem ω · δS = Γ. With the limits δS 0, ω ∞ and condition Γ = const, we obtain the formula
u(r ) = −
Γ 4π
∫ s
∆r × ds (r ′) ∆r
3
.
(2.14)
This formula for velocity induced by an infinitely thin vortex filament is called the Biot – Savart law, since it coincides (formally) with the formula for magnetic field created by a closed conductor with a constant current. Formula (2.14) can be rewritten in the differential form
du = −
Γ ∆r × ds . 4π ∆r 3
(2.15)
Then du is an infinitely small velocity induced by element ds of the vortex filament at point M(r). There exists another, more simple method for the derivation of the Biot – Savart formula (2.14). We consider an infinitely thin vortex filament (also closed). Let n, b, t be the unit vectors of normal, bi-normal, and tangent, correspondingly, and xn, xb, xt are the coordinates along these directions. Obviously, in this case the vorticity can be presented in the form = Γδ(xn) δ(xb)t,
(2.16)
where δ is Dirac's delta-function. Substituting (2.16) in (1.93) and integrating over xn, xb, we obtain the desired formula Γ Γ ∆r × ds t × ∆r δ( xn )δ( xb ) dxn dxb dxt = − u= . 3 3 4π 4π ∆r ∆r
∫
Here we take dV = dxn dxb dxt and t dxt
∫
ds.
74
2 Vortex filaments
Fig. 2.3. On the formulation of the Biot – Savart law
The vorticity in the form (2.16) is written for the coordinate system bound to a curve. In the absolute coordinate system the following definition is more convenient (Leonard, 1985): ∂r = Γ δ ⎡⎣r − r ( s′ ) ⎤⎦ ds′. ∂s′ The Biot – Savart formula may take another form, if we transform the contour integral in (2.14) into the integral over arbitrary surface S bound to the contour s (looped infinitely thin vortex filament). Using one of the corollaries of Stokes theorem (G. Korn and T. Korn 1968) to the vector Γ r − r′ B≡ , 4π r − r ′ 3
∫
we obtain
∫ (dS × ∇) × B = ∫ ds × B ≡ u .
(2.17)
S
Here dS = ndS, dS is the surface element, n is the unit normal vector to this element. According to the Biot – Savart law, the right-hand side is the expression for induced velocity that has equivalent definition through the surface integral. We rewrite the vector product using the following vector identity: (dS × ∇) × B = ∇(B · dS) − (∇B)dS.
(2.18)
For convenience we perform the following transformations in the coordinate form. Let us expand ∇B, using the denotation
2.2 Biot – Savart law
75
a ≡ ∆r = ( x − x ′) 2 + ( y − y ′) 2 + ( z − z ′) 2 ,
∇B ≡
=
∂ ⎛ r − r ′ ⎞ ∂ ⎛ x − x′ ⎞ ∂ ⎛ y − y′ ⎞ ∂ ⎛ z − z′ ⎞ = + + = ∂r ′ ⎜⎝ a3 ⎟⎠ ∂x ′ ⎜⎝ a3 ⎟⎠ ∂y ′ ⎜⎝ a3 ⎟⎠ ∂z ′ ⎜⎝ a3 ⎟⎠
−a3 + 3( x − x ′) 2 a5
+
−a3 + 3( y − y ′) 2 a5
+
−a3 + 3( z − z ′) 2 a5
= 0,
i.e., the second right-hand term in (2.18) vanishes. Obviously, ∂/∂r' (B · dS) = − ∂/∂r (B · dS), because B = B(r − r'), and operator ∂/∂r may be taken outside the integral in (2.17), retaining the symbol ∇. At last, we obtain from (2.17)
u=−
Γ ∇Ω , 4π
(2.19)
where we bring in the notation
Ω(r ) =
r − r′
∫ r − r ′ 3 dS .
(2.20)
Since the flow beyond the vortex filament is potential, then by definition u = ∇ϕ we see that the potential ϕ is ϕ=−
Γ Ω. 4π
(2.21)
Note that the velocity potential is ambiguously determined, because the area beyond the vortex filament is not a simply connected domain. Quantity Ω is a solid angle subtended by area S viewed from point M(r); and the area is bound by the looped vortex filament (Fig. 2.4). Indeed, we have from (2.20) that dΩ = dSa/a2, where a = |r − r'| is the distance from point M to element dS, and dSa is the projection of the surdsssis
Fig. 2.4. Illustration of Biot – Savart law interpretation
76
2 Vortex filaments
face element on the plane normal to the vector (r − r'). The relationship obtained is a definition for the elementary solid angle. Finally, the velocity induced by a vortex filament can be determined through a vector potential: u = curl A. The vector potential of a vortex filament can be deduced from Eq. (1.88) by substitution of Eq. (2.16) for vorticity
A=
Γ 4π
∫
ds . ∆r
(2.22)
2.3 Rectilinear infinitely thin vortex filament 2.3.1 Vortex filament in ideal fluid A rectilinear infinitely thin vortex filament is a simple object, which can be easily described by the Biot – Savart law. It can be interpreted as a circle with an infinitely large curvature radius. Let axis z in a cylindrical coordinate system be directed along the vortex filament, as shown in Fig. 2.5. Obviously, we have only the tangential component of induced velocity u = u(r), the formula for this component can be obtained from (2.14)
u= u =
Γ 4π
∞
sin α
∫ r2 + z
−∞
π
dz = 2
Γ Γ . sin α dα = 4πr 2πr
∫
(2.23)
0
Hence, the circulation over a circle with radius r equals Γ. For r 0 the velocity u ∞, which is a consequence of the ideal fluid approach.
Fig. 2.5. Rectilinear vortex filament
2.3 Rectilinear infinitely thin vortex filament
77
Let us notate the formulae for stream function ψ and potential ϕ, which can be defined with the accuracy of a constant. In polar coordinates (r, θ) the definition gives us
uθ ≡ u = −
∂ψ 1 ∂ϕ = , ∂r r ∂θ
and accounting for (2.23)
ϕ=
Γ θ + const, 2π
ψ=−
Γ log r + const. 2π
(2.24)
Since these relationships are independent of coordinate z, it is enough to consider motion in a 2-D plane. Therefore, instead of a vortex filament, we refer to a point vortex. Then we can introduce a complex potential W(z)
W (z) = ϕ + iψ =
Γ Γ (log r + iθ) + const = log z + const . 2πi 2πi
Here the complex coordinate z = x + iy = reiθ, x, y are the Cartesian coordinates. If the vortex filament does not coincide with the z axis, but passes through a point on plane xy with a complex coordinate z0 = x0 + iy0, the complex potential is written as
W=
Γ log(z − z0 ) + const . 2πi
The benefits of using a complex potential is that due to additivity one can easily find the potential for a system of isolated or continuously distributed vortex filaments; after that the velocity field is simply recovered by formula
ux − iuy =
dW . dz
Here ux, uy are the components of velocity in a Cartesian coordinate system. We take as an example N rectilinear vortex filaments oriented in parallel to the z axis with complex coordinates z0k on plane xy. Then
W=
N
⎡Γ
⎤
∑ ⎢⎣ 2πki log(z − z0k ) + Ck ⎥⎦ , k =1
Γk dW N = , ux − iuy = dz 2πi( z − z0k ) k=1
∑
(2.25)
78
2 Vortex filaments
where Ck are the arbitrary constants that must be selected for better convergence at N ∞. The fluid velocity at the point coinciding with the vortex position z0p is determined by the following rule: in sum (2.25) we eliminate the term including z0p which is responsible for singularity. Consider the particular case of the last problem: there are two identical linear vortices with opposite signs and the distance between the vortices tends to zero. Then, taking the coordinates z0 + δz/2 and z0 − δz/2 for positive and negative vortices correspondingly, we obtain the formula W=
⎡ ⎛ Γ δz ⎞ δz ⎞ ⎤ Γ ⎛ δz ⎞ ⎛ lim ⎢log ⎜ z − z0 − ⎟ − log ⎜ z − z0 + ⎟ ⎥ = lim ⎜− ⎟. 2πi δz →0 ⎣ ⎝ 2 ⎠ 2 ⎠ ⎦ δz →0 2πi ⎝ z − z0 ⎠ ⎝
Assuming that lim Γ δz = m , we have δz →0
W=
iM . 2 π( z − z0 )
Here M = meiθm, where θm is derived from the initial vector orientation δz = | δz0|eiθm. To simplify the analysis we take z0 = 0, θm = 0, i.e., both vortices pass through the x axis on plane xy at both sides of the origin. Then
W=
im . 2 πz
(2.26)
This formula describes the so-called linear vortex dipole, or simply the vortex dipole with moment m. It is easy to demonstrate that the streamlines and equipotential curves are the circles passing the coordinate origins. Besides, the circle centers lie on the x and y axes, correspondingly. Note that for a usual dipole consisting of a source and a sink, the complex potential takes the form: W = m/2πz. One can see from comparison with (2.26) that the distinction between the vortical and usual dipoles is that streamlines replace equipotential curves and vice versa. We have described a rectilinear vortex filament in infinite space (or a point vortex on an infinite plane). In some particular cases, the analytical solution for space with rigid boundaries can be deduced using the image vortex method. In particular, for a point vortex in an area restricted with a real axis, the image vortex has a circulation equal in magnitude and opposite by the sign (Fig. 2.6). The complex potential of the system and induced velocity field are
2.3 Rectilinear infinitely thin vortex filament
W=
z − z0 Γ Γ ⎛ 1 1 ⎞ , ux − iuy = − log ⎜ ⎟, 2πi ⎝ z − z0 z − z0 ⎠ z − z0 2πi
79
(2.27)
where z0 is a complex coordinate of vortex, and the bar represents a complex conjugation. Here the vortex moves parallel to the wall with a speed equal to that induced by the image vortex at point z0, U = Γ/4πy0. Here y0 is the distance from the vortex to the wall. Another example is the motion of a point vortex inside or outside a rounded region with the radius a (Fig. 2.7). In this case the image vortex circulation is also equal in magnitude and opposite by sign to the actual one. The image vortex is placed on a radial half-line passing through the basic vortex at the distance of a2/r0 from the circle center. The complex potential and velocity for this system are described in the following way: W=
⎞ z − z0 Γ ⎛ 1 1 Γ − , ux − iuy = log ⎜⎜ ⎟⎟ . 2 2 2 πi ⎝ z − z0 z − a z0 ⎠ 2πi z − a z0
(2.28)
The vortex moves along a circular trajectory concentric to the area boundary with the velocity U=
r0 Γ , 2 2π a − r02
i.e., it rotates with the frequency f=
Fig. 2.6. Point vortex near a rigid plane
1 Γ . 2 2 4 π a − r02
Fig. 2.7. Point vortex inside a circular area
(2.29)
80
2 Vortex filaments
Here r0 = |z0| is the distance from the circle center to the vortex. The analytical solution for a vortex in a bounded area can be written for a more general case when the conformal image of the flow zone into a circle (or its outside) or to a half-plane is known. Introducing a complex variable in the flow zone and prescribing the conformity z( ) into a halfplane Im(z) > 0, we obtain
W=
z( ) − z( 0 ) Γ log . 2πi z( ) − z ( 0 )
Note that any external potential flow can be superimposed on the flow induced by the vortex and its image. 2.3.2 Vortex filament diffusion Now we analyze the contribution of viscosity. One of the consequences of the viscosity effect is that vortex lines do not coincide with the trajectories of liquid particles. This is clear from the conditions underlying the Eqs. (1.16), (1.17). Let us consider in detail the viscosity effect with the example of rectilinear vortex filament diffusion. At time instant t = 0 we have an infinitely thin vortex filament (of circulation Γ) coinciding with the z axis. Obviously, the solution with time remains axisymmetric, so the set of equations (1.37) simplifies to a single equation
⎛ ∂ 2 ω 1 ∂ω ⎞ ∂ω = ν⎜ 2 + ⎟, ⎜ ∂r r ∂r ⎟⎠ ∂t ⎝ where ω ωz is the axial component of vorticity. This equation coincides with the heat transfer equation for a problem of heat spreading from a linear source in a uniform medium. This solution is well known
ω=
c −r 2 e 4πνt
4 νt
.
(2.30)
Constant c follows from the initial condition, which is given through the Stokes theorem
Γ = Γ (r, t )
r
t =0
∫
= 2π ωrdr 0
Using the solution (2.30), we obtain
. t =0
2.3 Rectilinear infinitely thin vortex filament r
2 2π e −r Γ=c 4πνt
∫
4 νt
ξ
(
∫
rdr t =0 = c e −ξ d ξ t =0 = c 1 − e −r
0
0
2
4 νt
)
t =0
81
= c.
Thus
ω (r , t) =
Γ −r 2 e 4πνt
4 νt
.
(2.31)
Then the tangential velocity u is as follows: r
u(r , t) =
(
2 Γ 1 ωr dr = 1 − e −r 2πr r
∫ 0
4 νt
).
(2.32)
Distributions of velocity u are plotted in Fig. 2.8 for different instants of time. At t = 0 we have the velocity distribution induced by the infinitely thin vortex filament: u = Γ/2πl. For t > 0, a local maximum appears on these profiles and it drifts with time to infinity, with simultaneous decrease in the amplitude of the maximum. For r << 4νt the velocity u = Γr/8πνt, i.e., the liquid in the vortex core rotates as a solid body with the angular velocity Γ/8πνt. Thus the vorticity diffuses into the entire space filled with the fluid. This flow example was named the Lamb – Oseen vortex (Lamb, 1932). All the above analysis proves that taking into account the viscosity in the bulk of a fluid leads to vorticity diffusion, but in no way it is responsible for its generation.
Fig. 2.8. Radial distributions of tangential velocity at different time instants for the Lamb – Oseen vortex
82
2 Vortex filaments
2.4 Self-induced motion of a vortex filament Any bending of the vortex filament creates a situation where the given piece of filament is in the field of velocity induced by other sections of this filament. The resulting motion is known as self-induced vortex filament motion. According to Batchelor (1967) we can estimate the behavior of a curved thin vortex filament using the Biot – Savart law (2.14)
u (r ) = −
Γ 4π
∫
( r − r ′) × ds ( r ′ ). r − r′
3
Obviously, the integral diverges at r r', i.e., at the points of the vortex filament. Therefore, we estimate the induced velocity in the immediate vicinity of the given point on the vortex filament. Let this point be the origin of the coordinate system, and a small piece of filament is approximated by an arc with radius R = 1/κ, where κ is the curvature (Fig. 2.9). Let us introduce a triple of orthogonal unit vectors (t, n, b) allowing for b = t × n. Here n and b are the unit vectors of normal and bi-normal, and t is a tangent unit vector. Vector r' corresponds to the point on the filament, while r gives us the point where the induced velocity is calculated. We assume that the calculation region for velocity estimation is limited by conditions |r| = r
R and
s
R (or θ
1),
(2.33)
where s is the distance along the vortex filament from the origin O. The length scale is the curvature radius R. Thus
Fig. 2.9. Illustration on the calculation of self-induced motion of a vortex filament
2.4 Self-induced motion of a vortex filament
r = yn + zb,
83
s = Rθ,
r' = x' t + y' n = tR sin θ + nR(1 − cos θ) ≈ tRθ + n(R θ2/2) = st + (s2κ/2)n, dr' = δs ≈ (t + sκn)ds. Then we specify the numerator and denominator in the Biot – Savart integral
(
)
(r − r ′) × δs ≈ yn + zb − st − ( s 2 κ 2)n × ( t + sκn ) ds = = ⎡ zn − zsκt + ( y + s 2 κ 2) b ⎤ ds, ⎣ ⎦ 2
r − r ′ = yn + zb − st − ( s 2 κ 2)n = r 2 + s 2 (1 − yκ) + κ 2 s 4 4 . 2
Let us divide the Biot – Savart integral into two parts. After substitution of ready expressions into the first part of Biot – Savart integral, we integrate it at the limits – L ≤ s ≤ L, where L satisfies condition (2.33). The results is
Γ − 4π
∫
(r − r ′) × ds r − r′
3
Γ =− 4π
L
∫
−L
− zsκt + zn − ( y + κs 2 2)b ds + In , (2.34) ⎡r 2 + s 2 (1 − yκ) + κ2 s 4 4⎤ 3 2 ⎣ ⎦
where In is the remaining part of the Biot – Savart integral. So far we have used only this condition: s, L R. We can calculate the asymptotic expression for this integral, for the limit
r
0, L
∞.
0, L/r
To accomplish this, we have to use a new variable m = s/r
⎛ y κm 2 ⎞ z z − κ + − t n m ⎜⎜ 2 + ⎟b M 2 ⎟⎠ r r2 r Γ ⎝ − dm ≈ 32 4π 2 2 4 − M ⎡1 + m (1 − y κ + κ s 4) ⎤ ⎣ ⎦
∫
≈
r →0
Γ 4π
M
∫
(by − nz)(1 + 1.5m 2 yκ (1 + m 2 )) r 2 + bκ m 2 2 (1 + m 2 )3 2
−M
dm =
M M ⎞ 3κy dm m2 Γ (by − nz) ⎛ ⎜ ⎟+ = + dm 2 32 ⎜ ⎟ 4π 2 (1 + m 2 )5 / 2 r2 −M ⎝ − M (1 + m ) ⎠
∫
∫
84
2 Vortex filaments
+
κΓ b 8π
M
m 2 dm
∫
(1 + m 2 )3 2 −M
,
where M = L/r. We have neglected the first term in the numerator of the initial integral and have discarded the extra terms in round brackets in the denominator, except for yκ, which is taken into account as a correction for the numerator. This gives us M
dm
∫
−M M
∫
−M
m 2 dm (1 + m 2 )3 2
M
∫
=
1 + m2
≈ 2, −M
(
)
M
⎡ ⎤ 2L m , = ⎢− + ln m + 1 + m 2 ⎥ ≈ −2 + 2log 2 r ⎥⎦ − M ⎣⎢ 1 + m
m 2 dm
−M
(1 + m 2 )3 2
M
m
(1 + m 2 )5 2
⎡ ⎤ 1 1 4 2 dm ≈ 2 − = . − ⎢ ⎥ 2 3/ 2 2 5/ 2 3 3 (1 + m ) ⎦⎥ ⎢ (1 + m ) −M ⎣ M
=
∫
The result is the asymptotic formula for induced velocity in the vicinity of a curved vortex filament u≈
Γ 2πr
where
2
( y b − zn ) +
In0 = In
Γy 4πr
2
L→0 r →0
( y b − zn ) κ +
Γ L→0 4π
= lim
∫
s >L
2L ⎞ 0 Γκb ⎛ − 1⎟ + In , ⎜ log 4π ⎝ r ⎠
r ′ × ds (r ′) r′
3
(2.35)
.
Here the first term represents rotational fluid motion around the considered element of a filament and it does not produce any shift. The module of this term equals Γ/2πr and it coincides with Eq. (2.23) for the velocity induced by a rectilinear vortex filament. The second term is a correction to circulatory motion due to the filament curvature. The third term is responsible for motion by the bi-normal vector and it becomes infinite on the vortex filament. This means that the curved filament moves along the bi-normal vector with infinite velocity and may undergo deformations. Integral In0 , taken over the rest of the filament represents the non-local contribution to selfinduced motion of the filament. For finite values of L, this integral is limited. For L 0 the contribution from In0 in the origin vicinity is
2.4 Self-induced motion of a vortex filament
85
⎡ Γ ( st + ns 2 κ 2) × ds ⎤ Γ ⎡ ds ⎤ Γκ ⎥ −2 ⎢ =− ⎢ = −b log L. ⎥ 3 4π ⎢⎣ s ⎥⎦ 4π ⎢⎣ 4π ⎥⎦ s = s L s=L
∫
∫
Here coefficient 2 appears because the contributions from the vicinity of points s = ±L are the same, and the minus sign is because (+L) and (−L) are the lower and upper limits of integration, correspondingly. Returning to (2.35), we see that integral In0 liquidates the logarithmic singularity in the second term, occurring at L 0. Thus, in the asymptotic expression 0, i.e., at the point of for induced velocity (2.35), only ln r diverges at r the vortex filament. The general meaning of this is that the self-induced motion of a curved vortex filament at asymptotic limit is caused exclusively by local effect, and more specifically – by local curvature of filament axis κ. The divergence is related to the idealized concept of the vortex filament as an object with an infinitely thin core. Nevertheless, these formulae can be used for deducing stable forms of curved vortex filament (this is demonstrated below). With additional suppositions about the vortex core, these formulae are suitable for description of vortex filament dynamics. We rewrite (2.35) retaining only the term that makes a local contribution to self-induced motion, u=
2L ⎞ Γ ⎛ κb ⎜ log −1 . r 4π ⎝ ⎠
(2.36)
Note that in this approximate formula, the limit of integration L remains uncertain. This problem is discussed in the following sections. Now let us use Eq. (2.36) for the derivation of the equation for self-induced motion of a vortex filament. To avoid the divergence problem in (2.36), we make the assumption that the vortex filament is thin, but still has a finite radius ε (or its effective value – for a complex core structure) and that self-induced velocity is derived from (2.36) at r = ε. We denote the radius-vector of a point on the vortex filament as X(s, t), where s is the distance along the filament. By definition, the velocity of this point is
u = ∂X/∂t.
(2.37)
We introduce a new time coordinate t
Γ ⎛ 2L ⎞ − 1⎟ → t , ⎜ log ε 4π ⎝ ⎠
(2.38)
assuming L/ε = const. By making equal (2.37) and (2.36) at r = ε and taking into account (2.38), we obtain the equation for filament motion
86
2 Vortex filaments
∂X (t, s) = κb . ∂t
(2.39)
This approach is known as the local induction approximation and is usually attributed to Hama (1962) and Arms and Hama (1965), although it had been used previously in the work by Da Rios (1906) (as acknowledged by Ricca (1996)). We transform equation (2.39), accounting for these relationships:
b = t × n,
∂X ≡ X ′ = t, ∂s
X" = κn.
Thus κn = κ(t × n) = X' × X". The result is the so-called local induction equation (or LIE):
∂X (t, s) = X ′ × X ′′ . ∂t
(2.40)
The local induction approximation is one of the main simplified approaches to the dynamics of a vortex filament. We emphasize that within this approximation the induced velocity is directed by the bi-normal to the filament, but the effects of filament stretching or contracting remain beyond this approach, even though these effects can be significant in vortex filament dynamics (Klein and Majda 1991). Several important conclusions and LIE solutions, as well as other approaches will be described and discussed in the successive chapters.
2.5 Infinitely thin vortex ring Considering a vortex filament of circular shape (Fig. 2.10), we can determine the vorticity component normal to the plane (r, z), through Dirac's delta-function (see (2.16)) ω = Γδ(r − r0∗ )δ( z − z0∗ ).
(2.41)
Here (r0, z0) is the point where the filament passes through the plane (r, z) and Γ is its circulation. Substituting ω into (1.96), we deduce the stream function
ψ=
Γ (rr0 )1/ 2 2π
2 ⎡⎛ 2 ⎤ ⎞ ⎢⎜ k − k ⎟ K (k) − k E(k) ⎥ , ⎠ ⎣⎝ ⎦
(2.42)
2.5 Infinitely thin vortex ring
87
where k2 = 4rr0/[(z – z0)2 + (r + r0)2], K and E are full elliptic integrals of the first and second kind. Lamb (1932, §161), offered another form for stream function; he introduced the minimum and maximum distance from point (r, z) to the ring s12 = ( z − z0 ) 2 + (r − r0 ) 2 ; s22 = ( z − z0 ) 2 + (r + r0 ) 2 and used the new variable λ = (s2 – s1)/(s2 + s1). The result is the following
ψ=
Γ ( s1 + s2 ) [ K(λ) − E(λ)]. 2π
(2.43)
This expression can be derived through Landen's transformation (G. Korn and T. Korn 1968). Since a vortex filament with circulation Γ is equivalent to a distribution of dipoles over the circle area with uniform intensity Γ, it is possible to find the potential and stream function as the integral of the Bessel function (Lamb 1932, §161). ∞
ϕ=
Γ r0 e −λ ( z − z0 ) J0 (λr ) J1 (λr0 )dλ 2
∫ 0
∞
Γ ψ = rr0 e −λ ( z − z0 ) J1 (λr ) J1 (λr0 )dλ 2
z − z0 > 0 .
(2.44)
∫ 0
This form of stream function does not possess any special advantages in comparison with (2.42) and (2.43).
Fig. 2.10. Infinitely thin vortex ring
88
2 Vortex filaments
A round vortex filament is a simple object with non-zero curvature. As discussed above, this filament shifts by the binormal, i.e., in direction of the z axis, with infinite velocity. Due to its symmetry, the circular filament is not liable to deformation. The kinetic energy of the liquid motion, which is induced by the infinitely thin closed vortex filament, equals infinity. Note that the vortex impulse (despite a singularity in the velocity field) is a finite quantity. Indeed, substituting r = (x – r0 cos ϕ, y – r0 sin ϕ, z – z0), = ω · i0 = ω(−sin ϕ, cos ϕ, 0), dV = dSr0dϕ in (1.112) and taking into account (2.41), we find the non-zero component of the impulse
Iz = πρΓr02 = const .
(2.45)
The asymptotic expansion of a velocity field in the vicinity of a vortex filament with arbitrary geometry was considered in Section 2.4. For the specific case of a circular vortex filament, the stream function and velocity asymptotic can be found through the asymptotic properties of elliptic integrals (Abramowitz and Stegun 1964). Assuming s = s1 r0, we obtain from (2.42):
ψ=
uz =
Γr0 2π
⎧⎪ 8r ⎛ s2 8r0 s cos θ ⎛ s ⎞ ⎫⎪ ⎞ 0 O − + − + log 2 log 1 ⎜⎜ 2 log ⎟⎟ ⎬ , ⎨ ⎜ ⎟ s s r0 ⎠ ⎪⎭ 2r0 ⎝ ⎠ ⎪⎩ ⎝ r0
(2.46)
⎛ Γs 8r Γ Γ ⎛ 1 ∂ψ s⎞ ⎞ cos θ + log 0 − sin 2 θ ⎟ + O ⎜ 2 log ⎟ , =− ⎜ ⎜ r ∂r s r0 ⎠⎟ 2πs 4πr0 ⎝ ⎠ ⎝ r0
(2.47)
⎛ Γs 1 ∂ψ s⎞ Γ Γ sin θ − sin θ cos θ + O ⎜ 2 log ⎟ . = ⎜r 4πr0 r ∂z 2πs r0 ⎟⎠ ⎝ 0
(2.48)
ur =
Here s cos θ = r – r0, s sin θ = z – z0 (Fig. 2.11). As in the general case (see (2.35)), the first terms in the formulae for velocity correspond to a circulatory flow around a filament. In the formula for axial velocity (2.47), the second term has a logarithmic singularity that is responsible for translational motion of the vortex ring. Comparing Eqs. (2.47), (2.48) with (2.35), we obtain the formula for quantity L:
4πr0 0 ⎞ ⎛ L = 4r0 exp ⎜ 1 − In ⎟ . Γ ⎝ ⎠ Taking into account viscosity, the diffusion of a circular vortex filament within short time periods is described by Eq. (2.31) (Tung and Ting 1967).
2.5 Infinitely thin vortex ring
89
Fig. 2.11. Cylindrical and local polar co-ordinate systems in the vicinity of a circular vortex filament
With the growth of effective size (4νt)1/2, the influence of curvature should be taken into consideration. Assuming that the fluid convection relative to the moving vortex has no significant effect on vorticity distribution, Kaltaev (1982) derived the approximate Helmholtz equation
⎛ ∂ 2ω ∂ ω ∂ 2ω ⎞ ∂ω dz0 ∂ω + = ν⎜ 2 + − ⎟ ⎜ ∂r ∂t dt ∂r ∂r r ∂z 2 ⎟⎠ ⎝ with the exact solution
ω =
⎛ 4ν t ⎞ 2π−1/ 2 ⎜ 2 ⎟ ⎜ r ⎟ ⎝ 0 ⎠
−3 / 2
⎛ r 2 + r02 + ( z − z0 )2 ⎞ ⎛ rr ⎞ I1 ⎜ 0 ⎟ exp ⎜ − ⎟⎟ . ⎜ 4νt ⎝ 2ν t ⎠ ⎝ ⎠
(2.49)
Here z0(t) is the motion law for the vortex ring. A similar solution was deduced in the paper by Berezovskii and Kaplanskii (1988), where the problem was solved using the “quasi-self-similar” approach at the limit of small Reynolds numbers. For high Re numbers, the same authors (Berezovskii and Kaplanskii 1992) obtained the first approximation of the solution applying the technique of two-scale expansion (Van Dyke 1964) and using the small parameter ε = (2νt)1/2/r0 1. In this case ⎛ ρ2 + 2νt0 ⎞ ⎛ t0 ⎞ ρ ω ≅ ω0 (t ) exp ⎜ − I0 ⎜ ⎟ ⎟, ⎜ 4νt ⎟⎠ ⎜⎝ (2νt0 )1/ 2 t ⎟⎠ ⎝
(2.50)
90
2 Vortex filaments
where ρ2 = (r – r0)2 + (z – z0)2, t0 is a certain fixed point in time. A power function ω0(t) ~ tk is taken for the time dependence of the vorticity scale. The power law was applied also for the length scale – the vortex radius r0(t) ~ tp. The exponent value can be determined from the condition of the existence for a self-similar solution t d r0 (t ) + k + 1 = 0 r0 (t) dt
and the momentum conservation law (2.45). The circulation is obtained through the direct integration of vorticity (2.50) ∞ ∞
Γ=
∫ ∫ ω drdz = πω0 r0
2
.
(2.51)
−∞ 0
For p and k we obtain the equation system
p + k + 1 = 0,
k + 4p = 0,
from whence p = 1/3, k = −4/3. Thus, the vortex radius increases by the law r0(t) = R0(t/t0)1/3, where R0 is the vortex radius at t = t0. The law for the vorticity scale change is found from equation (2.51)
ω0 =
And the circulation is Γ =
p π2 r04
=
p ⎛ t0 ⎞ ⎜ ⎟ πR02 ⎝ t ⎠
⎛ t0 ⎞ ⎜ ⎟ π2 R04 ⎝ t ⎠ p
4/3
.
2/3
.
A similar model is elaborated in a paper by Lugovtsov (1970) for the turbulent diffusion of vorticity. In contrast to the laminar mode, when the viscous scale of the length is LL ~ t1/2, here the law for the length scale is LT ~ t1/4, and this gives us the scale for vorticity ωT ~ t−3/4. In conclusion of this Section, we give the examples of particular cases of bounded flows when an analytical formula can be found for stream function of a circular vortex filament. Consider a circular filament, which is placed parallel to a plane. Obviously, the condition of zero flux through the plane is fulfilled if we introduce another vortex filament, which is a mirror image of the first, relative to the plane. If we denote the expression in square brackets in (2.42) as f(k), we obtain
2.6 Infinitely thin helical vortex filament
ψ=
Γ(rr0 )1/ 2 ( f (k) − f (k1 )), 2π
91
(2.52)
where k12 = 4rr0 /[( z + z0 ) 2 + (r + r0 ) 2 ]. If the axis of the circular vortex filament passes through the center of a sphere of radius a (coordinate origin), the “image” vortex has the circulation −Γ (r02 + z02 )1/ 2 a , radius r1 = r0 a 2 (r02 + z02 ) , and axial coordinate
z1 = z0 a 2 (r02 + z02 ) . Therefore, the stream function is described by Eq. (2.52) with module k1, satisfying the condition 2 2 k12 = 4rr1 ⎡( z − z1 ) + ( r + r1 ) ⎤ . ⎣ ⎦
Finally, Brasseur (1986) found the additional stream function for the circular vortex filament, which is co-axial to a cylinder with radius a ∞
K1 (λa) Γ ψ1 = − rr0 I1 (λr0 ) I1 (λr )cos λ( z − z0 ) dλ . π I1 (λa)
∫ 0
To deduce the complete stream function, it is enough to add to ψ1 one of the forms for stream function (2.42) – (2.44).
2.6 Infinitely thin helical vortex filament 2.6.1 Helical vortex filament in infinite space Consider a flow of incompressible ideal fluid in infinite space induced by an infinitely thin helical vortex filament with pitch 2πl, radius a, and circulation Γ (Fig. 2.2). This elementary vortex structure is a fundamental object in the vortex flow theory (equally with the rectilinear filament and the vortex ring described in previous sections). The formula for the velocity induced by a helical filament can be deduced from the Biot – Savart law in the form of vector potential (2.22). Following Hardin (1982) and taking the geometry of a helical filament in the form x' = a cos φ, y' = a sin φ, z' = l φ, we notate the integral
I ( α, r ) =
∞
∫
−∞
exp ( iαφ ) dφ
r
.
(2.53)
92
2 Vortex filaments
Here r = (x – x', y – y', z – z'). Then the vector potential takes the form
A=
Γ {−a Im [ I(1, r)], aRe [ I(1, r)], lI(0, r )} , 4π
(2.54)
and the components of the velocity vector induced by the vortex filament are written, according to Eq. (1.86), as u=
∂Az ∂Ay , − ∂y ∂z
v=
∂Ax ∂Az , − ∂z ∂x
w=
∂Ay ∂x
−
∂Ax . ∂y
Let us rewrite the integral (2.53) for the cylindrical coordinate system (x = r cos θ, y = r sin θ)
I (α) =
∞
∫
−∞
(
exp ( iαφ) dφ r02 + ( z − lφ )
)
2 1/ 2
,
(2.55)
where r02 = r 2 + a 2 − 2ar cos ( θ − φ ) . Then we use the relationships known from the theory of cylindrical functions (Watson 1944): ∞
1 = exp ( − s σ ) J0 ( σr ) dσ , R
∫ 0
where R = r + s , and J0(⋅) is the zero-order Bessel function of the first kind that can be given in the form of series 2
2
J0 ( σr0 ) =
2
∑ δm Jm ( σr ) Jm ( σa ) cos m ( θ − φ) ,
⎧1, m = 0 where δm = ⎨ , ⎩2 , m ≠ 0
and the integral (2.55) is transformed into
I ( α) =
∞
∞
∞
0
0
−∞
∑ δm ∫ dσJm ( σr ) Jm ( σa ) ∫ dφ exp ( iαφ − z − lφ σ ) cos m ( θ − φ).
The direct integration of the inner integral over θ gives us ∞
∫ dφ exp ( iαφ − z − lφ σ ) cos m ( θ − φ) =
−∞
=
σ exp ( iα z l ) ⎛ exp ⎡⎣im ( θ − z l ) ⎤⎦ exp ⎡⎣ −im ( θ − z l )⎤⎦ ⎞ ⎜ ⎟. + ⎜ σ2 + ⎡ ( m − α ) l ⎤ 2 σ 2 + ⎡ ( m + α ) l ⎤ 2 ⎟ l ⎣ ⎦ ⎣ ⎦ ⎠ ⎝
2.6 Infinitely thin helical vortex filament
93
Besides, values for those integrals can be found in Watson (1944): for m±α≠0
σJm ( σr ) Jm ( σa )
∞
∫
dσ
0
σ2 + ⎡⎣( m ± α ) l ⎤⎦
2
⎧ ⎛ m±α ⎞ ⎛ m±α ⎞ a ⎟ Km ⎜ r⎟ ,a
and for m ± α = 0 ∞
∫ dσ
J1 ( σr ) J1 ( σa )
0
σ
⎧1 a ⎪⎪ 2 r , a < r =⎨ , ⎪1 r , r < a ⎪⎩ 2 a
where Im(⋅) and Km(⋅) are modified Bessel functions of m order. The final presentation of integral (2.55) for α = 0 and α = 1 is as follows:
I ( 0) =
∞
J ( σa ) J0 ( σr ) 4 ∞ ⎧ Im ( mr l ) Km ( ma l ) ⎫ 2 z⎞ ⎛ + dσ 0 ⎨ ⎬ cos m ⎜ θ − ⎟ ; σ l l m=1 ⎩ Im ( ma l ) Km ( mr l ) ⎭ l⎠ ⎝ 0
I (1) = +
∑
∫
2 ∞ mz ⎤ ⎞ ⎧⎪ Im−1 ( mr l ) Km−1 ( ma l ) ⎫⎪ ⎛ ⎡ exp ⎜ −i ⎢( m − 1) θ − ⎬+ ⎟⎨ l m=1 l ⎥⎦ ⎠ ⎪⎩ Im−1 ( ma l ) Km−1 ( mr l ) ⎭⎪ ⎝ ⎣
∑
⎧r a ⎫ ⎛ ⎡ mz ⎤ ⎞ ⎧⎪Im+1 ( mr l ) Km+1 ( ma l ) ⎫⎪ 1 2 ∞ exp ⎜ i ⎢( m + 1) θ − ⎬ + exp ( iθ ) ⎨ ⎬ . ⎟ ⎨I ⎥ l m=1 l ⎦ ⎠ ⎪⎩ m+1 ( ma l ) Km+1 ( mr l ) ⎪⎭ l ⎝ ⎣ ⎩a r ⎭
∑
Hereafter, the upper line in braces corresponds to the case r < a, and the lower line is for r > a. Substituting values I(0) and I(1) into the definition for vector potential (2.54) and performing several algebraic transformations using the recurrence equations for cylindrical functions of order m, m – 1, m + 1, and taking into account that
∂ ∂r
∞
∫ 0
J0 ( σa ) J0 ( σr ) σ
⎧ −1 ∞ ⎪ ,a
∫
the final formulae for velocity components induced by a helical filament take the form
94
2 Vortex filaments
ur =
Γa πl
2
∞
⎪⎧ I ′ ( mr l ) K ′ ( ma l ) ⎪⎫
⎛
z⎞
∑ m ⎨⎩⎪Imm′ ( ma l ) Kmm′ ( mr l )⎬⎭⎪ sin m ⎜⎝ θ − l ⎟⎠ ;
m =1
uθ =
Γ ⎧0 ⎫ Γa ∞ ⎪⎧ Im ( mr l ) Km′ ( ma l ) ⎪⎫ z⎞ ⎛ m⎨ ⎨ ⎬+ ⎬ cos m ⎜ θ − ⎟ ; 2πr ⎩1 ⎭ πrl m=1 ⎩⎪ Im′ ( ma l ) Km ( mr l ) ⎭⎪ l⎠ ⎝
uz =
Γ ⎧1 ⎫ Γa ⎨ ⎬− 2πl ⎩0 ⎭ πl 2
∑ ∞
⎪⎧ I
( mr l ) K ′ ( ma l )⎪⎫
⎛
(2.56)
z⎞
∑ m ⎨⎩⎪Imm′ ( ma l ) Kmm ( mr l )⎬⎭⎪ cos m ⎜⎝ θ − l ⎟⎠.
m =1
If we introduce
S ( a, b ) =
∞
∑ Im ( mb ) Km ( ma ),
m =1
then ∂S(a, b)/∂b is the well studied (Watson 1944) Kapteyn series and it converges if a > b ≥ 0. The series describing velocity field (2.56) is quite similar in format to this series, and for r < a and θ – z/l = 0 the series for uθ and uz coincides with the Kapteyn series; this means that it converges for all values = θ – z/l and r < a. The recent results on the analytical study of the Kapteyn series are available in Boersma and Yakubovich (1998). Hardin (1982) established through numerical techniques the convergence of a series incorporating the definition of ur, and also for uθ and uz at r > a. Note that if a 0, i.e., the helical filament transforms into a rectilinear one, the extreme values for solution (2.56) ur = uz = 0, uθ = Γ/2πr are in complete agreement with the known solution for a rectilinear filament (2.23). Formulae (2.56) give the velocity field induced by a right-handed vortex filament. To describe the effect of a left-handed filament, we should substitute the argument in trigonometric functions for θ + z/l and to change the signs for both components in the formula for uz. Note that solution (2.56) depends only on two helical variables r and = θ – z/l. This means that it belongs to the class of flows with helical symmetry described in 1.5.1, and a direct check proves that uB ≡ uz + ruθ /l = Γ/2πl ≡ const. The velocity component uχ = uθ – ruz /l orthogonal to it and to ur is as follows
⎧ ⎛ mr ⎞ ⎛ ma ⎞ ⎫ Im ⎜ Km′ ⎜ ⎟ ⎟⎪ ⎪ Γ ⎧⎪−r l ⎪ Γa ⎛ l r ⎞ ⎪ ⎝ l ⎠ ⎝ l ⎠⎪ uχ = ⎨ ⎬+ ⎬ cos mχ. ⎜ + ⎟ m⎨ 2π ⎪⎩ 1 r ⎪⎭ πl 2 ⎝ r l ⎠ m =1 ⎪ ⎛ ma ⎞ mr ⎞ ⎪ ⎛ I′ K ⎪⎩ m ⎜⎝ l ⎟⎠ m ⎜⎝ l ⎟⎠ ⎪⎭ 2⎫
∞
∑
2.6 Infinitely thin helical vortex filament
95
The velocity components ur and uχ obey the discontinuity equation in the form of the first equation in (1.64); this makes possible the introduction of the stream function (1.65), i.e., uχ = – ∂ψ/∂r and
⎧ ⎛ mr ⎞ ⎛ ma ⎞ ⎫ ⎪ Im′ ⎜ l ⎟ Km′ ⎜ l ⎟ ⎪ 1 ∂ψ Γa ⎪ ⎝ ⎠ ⎝ ⎠⎪ ur = m⎨ = 2 ⎬ sin mχ . r ∂χ πl m =1 ⎪ ⎛ ma ⎞ mr ⎞ ⎪ ⎛ I′ K′ ⎪⎩ m ⎜⎝ l ⎟⎠ m ⎜⎝ l ⎟⎠ ⎪⎭ ∞
∑
After integrating this we obtain
⎧ ⎛ mr ⎞ ⎛ ma ⎞ ⎫ ⎧ f1 ( r ) ⎫ ⎪ Im′ ⎜ l ⎟ Km′ ⎜ l ⎟ ⎪ Γar ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎝ ⎠ ⎝ ⎠⎪ ψ=− 2 ⎨ ⎬ cos mχ + ⎨ ⎬, πl m=1 ⎪ ′ ⎛ ma ⎞ ′ ⎛ mr ⎞ ⎪ ⎪f ( r )⎪ I K ⎩2 ⎭ ⎪⎩ m ⎝⎜ l ⎠⎟ m ⎝⎜ l ⎠⎟ ⎪⎭ ∞
∑
where f1(r) and f2(r) are the arbitrary functions of r, defined, correspondingly, in areas r < a and r > a. Finding of f1(r) and f2(r) requires differentiation of ψ with respect to r. The use of recurrent ratios for derivatives of modified Bessel functions of m-th order and comparison with uχ yields
⎧ ⎡ ⎛ mr ⎞ mr ⎛ mr ⎞ ⎤ ⎛ ma ⎞ ⎫ Im′′ ⎜ ⎪ ⎢ Im′ ⎜ ⎟+ ⎟ ⎥ Km′ ⎜ ⎟⎪ ⎝ l ⎠⎦ ⎝ l ⎠⎪ ∂ψ Γa ⎪⎣ ⎝ l ⎠ l ⎪⎧ f1′( r ) ⎪⎫ = 2 ⎨ ⎬ cos mχ + ⎨ ⎬= ∂r πl m =1 ⎪ ⎛ ma ⎞ ⎡ mr ⎞ mr mr ⎞ ⎤ ⎪ ⎪⎩ f2′ ( r ) ⎭⎪ ⎛ ⎛ + I′ K′ K′′ ⎪ m ⎜⎝ l ⎟⎠ ⎢⎣ m ⎜⎝ l ⎟⎠ l m ⎜⎝ l ⎟⎠ ⎥⎦ ⎪ ⎩ ⎭ 2 Γ ⎧⎪−r l ⎫⎪ ⎪⎧ f1′( r ) ⎪⎫ = −uχ + ⎨ ⎬+⎨ ⎬ ≡ −uχ . 2π ⎩⎪ 1 r ⎭⎪ ⎩⎪ f2′ ( r ) ⎭⎪ ∞
∑
Integration gives f1(r) and f2(r), so the final form for stream function is as follows:
⎧ ⎛ mr ⎞ ⎛ ma ⎞ ⎫ Im′ ⎜ Km′ ⎜ ⎟ ⎟⎪ ⎪ Γ ⎪⎧ (r − a ) l ⎪⎫ Γar ⎪ ⎝ l ⎠ ⎝ l ⎠⎪ ψ= − ⎨ ⎬ ⎨ ⎬ cos mχ , 4π ⎩⎪− log(r 2 a 2 ) ⎭⎪ πl 2 m =1 ⎪ ⎛ ma ⎞ mr ⎞ ⎪ ⎛ I′ K′ ⎪⎩ m ⎜⎝ l ⎟⎠ m ⎜⎝ l ⎟⎠ ⎪⎭ 2
2
2
∞
∑
(2.57)
which is determined with a constant accuracy. One can see that the stream 0 reduces to a simple formula ψ = − Γ/2π log r and this function at a coincides with the solution for a rectilinear filament (2.24).
96
2 Vortex filaments
The isolines of stream function (2.57) at different values of helical pitch h = 2πl a are depicted in Fig. 2.12. For a higher pitch (Fig. 2.12 ), the isolines of ψ in the horizontal cross-section z = const are almost concentric circles; this corresponds to a flow induced by a rectilinear vortex filament (see Section 2.3.1). At the same time the isolines plotted in a vertical plane θ = const testify that the flow is spatial. Some isolines in the vicinity of the vortex filament crossing the plane are closed isolines. As the pitch decreases, the flow structure changes. For example, for h = 4 (Fig. 2.12c) we see the second family of loops in the horizontal section; this corresponds1 to the development of a "through" channel inside the helix. For a denser helix (Fig. 2.12d), we have a resting flow outside the helix and an almost uniform axial flow in the center (the dashed curves in Fig. 2.12 mark the cylindrical surface with radius 2a). At the limit h → 0 the coils of helical vortex merge and create a cylindrical vortex sheet (see Section 3.1). Solution (2.56), (2.57) for a helical filament in infinite space was obtained by Hardin (1982). Previous analysis has demonstrated that although the solution was obtained without additional suppositions (only by direct transformation of the Biot – Savart integral), it still belongs to the class of flows with helical symmetry with “uniform” motion along the helical lines described in Section 1.5.1. This conclusion is drawn also from the vorticity distribution along the helix. It is worth noting that for the case of a helical filament we cannot obtain a solution in the space limited by a tube using a simple image method (see Section 2.3.1) because for the helical vortex filament (unlike for rectilinear filaments) the image principle does not work. That is why in the next section we offer another approach for deducing the velocity field induced by a helical vortex filament in a tube. 2.6.2 Helical vortex filament in a cylindrical tube In this Section we follow Okulov's approach (Okulov 1993, 1995) and try to determine the velocity field for ideal fluid that is induced by a helical vortex filament inside an infinite cylindrical tube of radius R (the helix axis coincides with the cylinder axis) (Fig. 2.13). Since the vorticity is concentrated in the vortex filament (described by Eqs. (2.7)) and the vorticity vector is directed along the filament, the problem solution belongs to the class of flows (see Section 1.5.1) with helical symmetry and “uniform” motion along the helical lines or with a helical distribution of vorticity. In this case the stream function (1.65) inside the tube must satisfy the equation (1.70), and zero-flux condition has to be fulfilled at the tube wall 1
The correspondence is not strict because the lines ψ = const are not streamlines.
a
b
c
d
e
A
Fig. 2.12. Isolines of stream function for a flow induced by a helical vortex filament for horizontal (A, z = const) and meridian (B, θ = 0, π) cross-sections for different relative pitches of helix h = 2πl/a. a – 16; b – 8; c – 4; d – 2; e – 1
2.6 Infinitely thin helical vortex filament
B
97
98
2 Vortex filaments
Fig. 2.13. Helical vortex filament in a cylindrical tube
ur
r =R
= r −1 ∂ψ ∂χ r = R = 0.
(2.58)
Let us make more specific the right side of equation (1.70), i.e., determine the ωz. The vorticity is concentrated along the helical line L wound with pitch 2πl on the cylinder with radius a. The intensity of an infinitely thin vortex filament is described by circulation Γ, which is constant for the problem under consideration and related to vorticity through the Stokes formula
∫
⋅ ndS = Γ = const .
∆S
(2.59)
Here ∆S is the surface element where the filament passes, and n is the unit vector normal to this surface. Since in (1.70) we have only the zcomponent of vorticity, it is reasonable to take as ∆S a surface element with its normal parallel to the z-axis (Fig. 2.13). Then we have
∫
⋅ ndS =
∆S
∫ ωzdF = ∫ ωzrdϕdr.
∆S
∆S
After transition to variables (r, χ), we obtain the equation
∫ ωzr drdχ = Γ .
∆S
(2.60)
2.6 Infinitely thin helical vortex filament
99
Since the vorticity is different from zero only on the filament axis with coordinates (r = a, χ = χ0), the sub-integral function can be expressed through Dirac's delta-function
ωz = Γδ(r − a)δ(χ − χ0)/r,
(2.61)
and equation (1.70) takes the form
∂ 2ψ ∂r 2 =
+
l 2 − r 2 1 ∂ψ l 2 + r 2 ∂ 2 ψ + 2 2 = l 2 + r 2 r ∂r l r ∂χ 2
2lu0 r 2 + l2
− Γδ(r − a)δ(χ − χ0 )
r 2 + l2 r l2
(2.62)
.
To simplify calculations, we will search for a complex-valued function (ψ = Re ), that satisfies equation (2.62) and boundary conditions (2.58). Due to periodicity on χ, function can be written as
(r, χ) = r
∞
∑
m =−∞
exp ⎣⎡im ( χ − χ0 ) ⎦⎤ pm ( r , a ) .
(2.63)
We substitute the form (2.63) into (2.62) and multiply both sides by exp(−inχ), (n = 0, ±1, …) and integrate with respect to χ from 0 up to 2π. Taking into account the orthogonal property of functions {exp(imχ)}, we obtain for m ≠ 0
⎛ 2l 2 pm′′ + ⎜ 1 + 2 2 ⎜ ⎝ l +r
(
⎛ m2 l 2 + r 2 ⎞1 l2 − r 2 ⎜ − ⎟⎟ pm′ + ⎜ 2 l2r 2 ⎜ l + r2 r2 ⎠r ⎝ Γ l2 + r 2 = δ(r − a) 2 2 , 2π l r
(
)
) ⎟⎞ p ⎟⎟ ⎠
m
= (2.64)
and for m = 0 ⎛ 2l 2 p0′′ + ⎜ 1 + 2 ⎜ l + r2 ⎝
−
(l
2lu0 2
+ r2
⎞ 1 l2 − r 2 ′ + p p0 = ⎟⎟ 0 2 2 2 r + l r r ⎠
(
)
l + r2 Γ + δ (r − a ) . r2 r 2π 2
)
Firstly, we find the solution for equation (2.65)
(2.65)
100
2 Vortex filaments
(
c2l 2 + lu0 c1 c2r p0 ( r , a ) = + + r r 2
)
log r −
2 2 2 Γ ⎧⎪a / l + log a , ⎨ 4πr ⎪⎩ r 2 / l 2 + log r 2
where c1, c2 are the integration constants. The solution of equation (2.64) takes the form r
pm =
1 pm
∫
(
1
)
2
W pm , pm
0 1
R
2
Hpm dr
2 pm
+
∫W r
1
Hpm dσ
(p
1 m
2
, pm
)
,
(2.66)
2
here pm , pm are linear independent solutions for the corresponding (2.64) uniform equation, H is the right side of (2.64) and W is a Wronskian. To find the solutions of a homogeneous equation derived from (2.64), let us consider the Bessel equation l 2r 2 l +r 2
2
′′ + qm
l 2r 2 l +r 2
2
1 ′ − m 2 qm = 0, qm r
with linear-independent solutions in the form of modified Bessel functions Im(mr/l) and Km(mr/l). Let us differentiate this Bessel equation and divide the result by l2r2/(l2 + r2). The result is the homogeneous equation on derivative from the function q. This means that the solutions of equation (2.64) are the derivatives of modified Bessel functions or their linear combinations. To satisfy the boundary conditions (2.58), and meet the requirement of a regular solution at r = 0, we choose the following functions as the solutions of the homogenous equations: pm = Im′ ( mr l ) , pm = Km′ ( mr l ) − αm Im′ ( mr l ). 1
2
Then after calculations using Eq. (2.66) we find
pm = −
Γ ⎪⎧ Im′ ( mr l ) ( Km′ ( ma l ) − αm Im′ ( ma l ) ) , r ≤ a ⎫⎪ ⎨ ⎬. 2πl 2 ⎩⎪ Im′ ( ma l ) ( Km′ ( mr l ) − αm Im′ ( mr l ) ) , r > a ⎪⎭
By substituting pm into (2.63), taking the real part of the result, and considering that the relationship Z−m = − Zm is true for cylindrical functions, we obtain the formula for stream functions
ψ = c1 −
(
)
c2r 2 Γ + l 2 c2 + lu0 log r − 2 4πl 2
⎧⎪a 2 + l 2 log a 2 ⎫⎪ ⎨ 2 2 ⎬− 2 ⎩⎪r + l log r ⎭⎪
(2.67)
2.6 Infinitely thin helical vortex filament
−
Γar
101
⎪⎧Im′ ( mr l ) ( Km′ ( ma l ) − αm Im′ ( ma l ) ) ⎪⎫ ⎬ cos ⎡⎣m ( χ − χ0 ) ⎤⎦ . ′ ( mr l ) ) ⎭⎪ m m Im ⎪ m m=1 ⎩ ∞
∑ ⎨I′ ( ma l ) ( K′ ( mr l ) − α πl 2
Hereafter, the upper line in braces corresponds to the situation r < a, and the lower line to r ≥ a. In the solution (2.67) we have to specify the integration constants. The requirement for regularity of the solution at r 0 (a ≠ 0) yields the connection between constants u0 and c2: lc2 + u0 = 0. The constant c1 may be taken as zero, because the stream function is determined to within a constant. Thus, the solution is written in the form
ψ=
2 2 2 u0 r 2 Γ ⎪⎧a l + log a ⎪⎫ − ⎨ 2 2 ⎬− 2l 4π ⎪⎩ r l + log r 2 ⎭⎪ ⎧ ⎛ mr ⎞ ⎛ ma ⎞ ⎫ I′ ⎟ Zm′ ⎜ ⎟⎪ ∞ ⎪ m⎜ Γar ⎪ ⎝ l ⎠ ⎝ l ⎠⎪ − 2 ⎨ ⎬ cos m ( χ − χ0 ) , πl m=1 ⎪ ⎛ ma ⎞ ⎛ mr ⎞ ⎪ I′ Z′ ⎪⎩ m ⎜⎝ l ⎟⎠ m ⎜⎝ l ⎟⎠ ⎪⎭
(2.68)
∑
where Zm(x) = Km(x) − αmIm(x); αm = Km′ ( mR l ) Im′ ( mR l ) are taken to satisfy the zero-flux condition (2.58). Substituting (2.68) into (1.65) and using (1.67), we notate the components of the velocity vector
⎧ ⎛ mr ⎞ ⎛ ma ⎞ ⎫ ⎪ Im′ ⎜ l ⎟ Zm′ ⎜ l ⎟ ⎪ Γa ⎪ ⎝ ⎠ ⎝ ⎠⎪ ur = 2 m⎨ ⎬ sin m(χ − χ0 ), πl m=1 ⎪ ′ ⎛ ma ⎞ ′ ⎛ mr ⎞ ⎪ I Z ⎪⎩ m ⎜⎝ l ⎟⎠ m ⎜⎝ l ⎟⎠ ⎪⎭ ⎧ ⎛ mr ⎞ ⎛ ma ⎞ ⎫ Im ⎜ Zm′ ⎜ ⎟ ⎟⎪ ⎪ ∞ Γ ⎧ 0 ⎫ Γa ⎪ ⎝ l ⎠ ⎝ l ⎠⎪ uϕ = m + ⎨ ⎬ ⎨ ⎬ cos m(χ − χ0 ), 2πr ⎩1 ⎭ πrl m=1 ⎪ ⎛ ma ⎞ mr ⎞ ⎪ ⎛ I′ Z ⎪⎩ m ⎜⎝ l ⎟⎠ m ⎜⎝ l ⎟⎠ ⎪⎭ ∞
∑
∑
⎧ ⎛ mr ⎞ ⎛ ma ⎞ ⎫ Im ⎜ Zm′ ⎜ ⎟ ⎟⎪ ⎪ Γ ⎧ 0 ⎫ Γa ⎪ ⎝ l ⎠ ⎝ l ⎠⎪ uz = u0 − m⎨ ⎨ ⎬− ⎬ cos m(χ − χ0 ). 2πl ⎩1 ⎭ πl 2 m=1 ⎪ ⎛ ma ⎞ mr ⎞ ⎪ ⎛ I′ Z ⎪⎩ m ⎜⎝ l ⎟⎠ m ⎜⎝ l ⎟⎠ ⎪⎭ ∞
∑
(2.69)
102
2 Vortex filaments
Note that at R ∞ we have a helical filament in infinite space. Then αm 0 and solution (2.69) for the velocity components ur and uϕ coincides with the results of Hardin (1982). The value uz is different only by a constant u0, which corresponds to a uniform flow along the z axis. Both Hardin's solution (2.56), (2.57), and Eqs. (2.68), (2.69) are too complicated. Besides, the series diverges at the points of the vortex filament. The correct computation of the velocity field and stream functions requires isolation of singularities in the explicit form. Following Okulov (1993, 1995) and Kuibin and Okulov (1998), we can use the uniform decompositions of the modified Bessel functions at high values of argument (Abramowitz and Stegun 1964)
ξ t ⎡ ξ ⎤ emη ⎢1 + 1 + 22 + ...⎥ , 2πm ⎣ m m ⎦ πt −mη ⎡ ξ1 ξ 2 ⎤ 1 − + 2 − ...⎥ , Km (mx ) = e ⎢ 2m ⎣ m m ⎦ mη e ⎡ ζ1 ζ 2 1 ⎤ + 2 + ...⎥ , Im′ (mx ) = 1+ ⎢ 2πmt x ⎣ m m ⎦ Im (mx ) =
π e −mη ⎡ ζ1 ζ 2 ⎤ Km′ (mx ) = − 1− + − ...⎥ , 2mt x ⎢⎣ m m 2 ⎦ 1 1 1−t , t = (1 + x 2 ) −1/ 2 , η = + log 1+ t t 2 ξ1 = (3t − 5t 3 ) / 24, ξ2 = (81t 2 − 462t 4 + 385t 6 ) /1152,
(2.70)
ζ1 = (−9t + 7t3 ) / 24, ζ 2 = (−135t 2 + 594t 4 − 455t 6 ) /1152. If we substitute into the expressions for stream functions (2.68) the Bessel functions with their asymptotics (2.70), we find that the contribution into the singularity (of the logarithmic kind) is made only by the first terms of the series. Indeed, the replacement m m Car l 2 ⎡⎛ x ⎞ mx ⎞ my ⎞ ⎛ xy ⎞ ⎤ ⎛ ⎛ ′ ⎢ → − − Im′ ⎜ Z ⎜ ⎟ ⎟ m⎜ ⎟ ⎜ 2⎟ ⎥ 2mra ⎢⎝ y ⎠ ⎝ l ⎠ ⎝ l ⎠ ⎝ R ⎠ ⎥⎦ ⎣
makes possible the summation of the series produced from (2.68), and the presentation of the stream function in the form of a sum of singular and regular components
2.6 Infinitely thin helical vortex filament
ψ=
Sψ = −Car log
Γ Sψ + Rψ , 4π
(
)
103
(2.71)
a 2 + r 2 − 2ra cos ( χ − χ0 )
a*2 + r 2 − 2ra* cos ( χ − χ0 )
,
(2.72)
⎧⎪a 2 l 2 + log a 2 − Car log a 2 a∗2 ⎫⎪ Rψ = β 2 − ⎨ ⎬− 2 2 2 2 ∗2 l ⎩⎪ r l + log r − Car log r a ⎪⎭ 4ra ∞ ⎧⎪ Bm ( r , a ) ⎫⎪ − 2 ⎨ ⎬ cos m ( χ − χ0 ), l m =1 ⎩⎪ Bm ( a, r ) ⎭⎪ r2
(2.73)
∑
2 ⎛ xy ⎞ ⎛ mx ⎞ ′ ⎛ my ⎞ Car l ⎡⎢⎛ x ⎞ + Bm ( x, y ) = Im′ ⎜ Z ⎜ ⎟ −⎜ 2 ⎟ ⎟ m⎜ ⎟ l l mra y 2 ⎢⎣⎝ ⎠ ⎝ ⎠ ⎝ ⎠ ⎝R ⎠ m
m⎤
⎥ , β = 2πlu0 Γ . ⎥⎦
Here tilde stands for transformation
x = x 2 exp [Cx − 1] (Cx + 1) , Cx = 1 + x 2 l 2 (at l → ∞ x → x ; symbol x corresponds to a, r or R). The multiplier
Car = CaCr . The asterisk marks the “radius” of the “image vortex”
a* = R2 a . The singular component Sψ contains basic information about the flow pattern and dependency on the vortex parameters; it is useful for qualitative analysis of the flow. Nevertheless, the existence of a singularity in the primary presentation of stream functions via the series (2.68) forbids the operation of differentiation to Eq. (2.71) that would give us the formula for the velocity field. Therefore we have to separate the velocity field singularity directly in the series (2.69). Unlike in the case of stream functions, now we have to consider the second terms in series (2.70) of modified Bessel functions. Since the formula contains only functions ξ1(x) and ζ1(x), we can skip the subscript “1”, but we introduce the subscripts a, r, and R in Eqs. (2.70) when substituting a/l, r/l or R/l instead of x, correspondingly. The formulae for velocity (2.69) now takes the form:
104
2 Vortex filaments
ur =
Γa πl
2
( Sr + Rr ) ,
uϕ =
Γ ⎧ 0 ⎫ Γa Sχ + Rχ , ⎨ ⎬+ 2πr ⎩1 ⎭ πrl
(
)
Γ ⎧ 0 ⎫ Γa uz = u0 − Sχ + Rχ . ⎨ ⎬− 2πl ⎩1 ⎭ πl 2
(
)
(2.74)
The singular components Sr and Sχ are also written through elementary functions of distorted radial distances
⎡ ar sin(χ − χ0 ) a*r sin(χ − χ0 ) − + ⎢ 2 2 *2 2 * ⎢⎣ a + r − 2ar cos(χ − χ0 ) a + r − 2a r cos(χ − χ0 ) ⎧⎪ ( ζ r − ζ a ) atan ( r sin(χ − χ0 ) ( a − r cos(χ − χ 0 ) ) ) ⎫⎪ +⎨ ⎬− ⎪⎩( ζ a − ζ r ) atan ( a sin(χ − χ0 ) ( r − a cos(χ − χ 0 ) ) ) ⎪⎭ ⎛ r sin(χ − χ0 ) ⎞ ⎤ − ( ζ r + ζ a − 2ζ R ) atan ⎜ * , ⎜ a − r cos(χ − χ ) ⎟⎟ ⎥⎥ 0 ⎠⎦ ⎝ (2.75) Ca r l ⎡⎧ 0 ⎫ r 2 − ar cos(χ − χ0 ) r 2 − a*r cos(χ − χ0 ) − Sχ = + ⎢⎨ ⎬ + 2a ⎣⎢⎩−1⎭ a2 + r 2 − 2ar cos(χ − χ0 ) a*2 + r 2 − 2a*r cos(χ − χ0 )
Sr = −
Car l 2 2ar
⎛ ⎧⎪log a 2 ⎫⎪ ⎞ 1 2 2 ⎜ + ( ξr − ζ a ) log a + r − 2ar cos(χ − χ0 ) − ⎨ ⎬⎟ − 2 ⎟ ⎜ 2 r log ⎪⎩ ⎭⎪ ⎠ ⎝
(
)
a*2 + r 2 − 2a*r cos(χ − χ0 ) ⎤ 1 − ( ξr + ζ a − 2ζ R ) log ⎥. 2 a*2 ⎥⎦ Here Ca / r = Ca Cr , and the series residues are
Rr =
∞ ⎧⎪ Bmr ( r , a ) ⎫⎪ ⎧⎪ BmI ⎫⎪ m⎨ r m sin χ − χ = R m ( ) , ⎬ ⎨ Z ⎬ cos m ( χ − χ0 ) , (2.76) 0 χ B a r , ( ) ⎪⎩ Bm ⎪⎭ ⎪ 1 = m =1 ⎪ m m ⎩ ⎭
∞
∑
∑
where
⎛ mx ⎞ ⎛ my ⎞ Bmr ( x , y ) = Im′ ⎜ ⎟ Zm′ ⎜ ⎟+ ⎝ l ⎠ ⎝ l ⎠ m m Car l 2 ⎡⎛ x ⎞ ⎛ ζ x − ζ y ⎞ ⎛ xy ⎞ ⎛ ζ x + ζ y − 2ζ R ⎞ ⎤ ⎢⎜ ⎟ ⎜ 1 + + ⎟ − ⎜ 2 ⎟ ⎜1 + ⎟⎥ , m ⎠ ⎝R ⎠ ⎝ m 2mra ⎢⎝ y ⎠ ⎝ ⎠ ⎦⎥ ⎣
2.6 Infinitely thin helical vortex filament
105
⎛ mr ⎞ ⎛ ma ⎞ BmI = Im ⎜ ⎟ Zm′ ⎜ ⎟+ ⎝ l ⎠ ⎝ l ⎠ m m Ca / r l ⎡⎛ r ⎞ ⎛ ξr − ζ a ⎞ ⎛ ra ⎞ ⎛ ξr + ζ a − 2ζ R ⎞ ⎤ + + 1⎟ − ⎜ 2 ⎟ ⎜ 1 + ⎢⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟⎥ , m 2ma ⎢⎣⎝ a ⎠ ⎝ m ⎠ ⎝R ⎠ ⎝ ⎠ ⎥⎦
⎛ ma ⎞ ⎛ mr ⎞ BmZ = Im′ ⎜ ⎟ Zm ⎜ ⎟+ ⎝ l ⎠ ⎝ l ⎠ +
m m Ca / r l ⎡⎛ a ⎞ ⎛ ξr − ζ a ⎞ ⎛ ra ⎞ ⎛ ξ + ζ a − 2ζ R ⎞ ⎤ − 1⎟ − ⎜ 2 ⎟ ⎜ 1 + r ⎢⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟⎥ . m 2ma ⎢⎣⎝ r ⎠ ⎝ m ⎠ ⎝R ⎠ ⎝ ⎠ ⎥⎦
∞ the soluAnalysis of the forms (2.71) – (2.76) demonstrates that for l tion coincides with solution (2.28) for a rectilinear vortex in a cylinder (or for a point vortex in a circle). Numerical tests confirm that for a wide range of filament parameters, the series residues (2.73) and (2.76) are rather small in comparison with the main singular parts (2.72) and (2.75) presenting the stream functions (2.71) and the velocity field (2.74). Thus, we can neglect the residues (see quantitative estimates in (Okulov and Fukumoto 2004, Fukumoto and Okulov 2005)) in calculations during qualitative analysis. Since the key parts of (2.72) and (2.75) are expressed in simple form (through elementary functions), this gives us an opportunity to find illustrations for flow patterns in a wide range of vortex parameters. Plotting of stream function isolines helps in the understanding of several features of the flow. In particular (like in the case of a plain flow), a higher density of lines corresponds to a higher velocity (see. (1.47)). But the direction of the velocity vector does not coincide with the tangent to the isolines ψ = const. Therefore, the “stream lines” are plotted for the transverse (z = const) and longitudinal ([θ = 0] + [θ = π]) cross-sections of a tube for better understanding. This requires the integration of equation dr/ur = rdθ/uθ , in the plane z = const, and integration of dr/ur = dz/uz in the plane θ = const. Thus, the projections of velocity vector on these planes are directed by tangents to the constructed “stream lines”. Actually, these lines are the cross-sections of the stream tubes. Hereafter, we take the quantities normalized by the cylinder radius R. The variable parameters are the vortex pitch h = 2πl, the radius of helical filament a, and dimensionless velocity at the axis u0 = 2πlu0 / Γ (starting from this place, we skip the symbol of tilde for dimensionless velocity).
106
2 Vortex filaments a
b
c
A
B
Fig. 2.14. Isolines of stream functions in the horizontal cross-section z = const for a helical vortex filament in a cylindrical tube (A) and in infinite space (B). (a) h = 1, a = 0.5; (b) h = 8, a = 0.5; (c) h = 2, a = 0.9
Firstly, we have to consider the influence of the cylinder walls on the flow. For a small pitch h = 1 and moderate radius a = 0.5 (Fig. 2.14a) the isolines for stream functions in a tube are almost the same as the isolines in an unbounded flow. This is because the introduced transformation decreases the relative radius of the vortex. Indeed, for h = 1, a = 0.5, R = 1 we obtain a = 2.314 , R = 57.92 , so that a / R = 0.04 . Obviously, the influence of the walls in this situation is small. For a large pitch h = 8 (Fig. 2.14b), the flow patterns for a channel and infinite space are very different. In this case a = 0.519 , R = 1.155 , a / R = 0.45. Certainly, with the increase in the vortex radius, the wall effect becomes greater (Fig. 2.14, h = 2, a = 0.9), although the transformation has its effect also: a / R = 0.718 . Obviously, for a smaller helical pitch, the wall effect will be smaller. If at a = 0.9 we take h = 0.195, then a / R = 0.04 . The laws of flow pattern change, due to variation of the vortex parameters, are more obvious through the viewing of “stream lines”. Note that the value of u0 has no impact on the flow pattern in the tube crosssection. As it is obvious from Eqs. (2.69) for uz, the contribution u0 can be interpreted as a transition to the coordinate system moving with velocity –u0 along the z axis. It is clear that the quantity u0 is connected to the liquid flow rate through the tube and is important in the description of a swirling flow in a bounded zone. For example, at u0 = 0, h = 1 (Fig. 2.15)
2.6 Infinitely thin helical vortex filament
107
the axial motion in the vicinity of the tube axis is very weak because the axial motion mostly occurs through liquid flow at the periphery (near the channel walls). For u0 = 1, h = 1 and vice versa, the flow almost stops near the tube walls and the liquid flows through the central part of the channel. In the intermediate variant (Fig. 2.15, u0 = 0.5, h = 1) the fluids inside and outside the helical filament move in opposite directions. The same figure demonstrates the influence of vortex pitch on flow structure. For the case of a dense vortex (Fig. 2.15, h = 1) the near-axis flow is almost separated from the wall flow. The helical vortex filament and its vicinity play the role of a cylindrical shear layer. With a higher pitch (h = 2), the vortex becomes less dense and some portion of fluid in helical motion flows from the periphery towards the central part and vice versa, flow towards the periphery takes place. The higher the pitch, the larger the proportion of liquid which passes through both parts of the flow (periphery and near-axis). The flow patterns at different values of helical filament radius with a fixed pitch (h = 2) are plotted in Fig. 2.16. When the axial velocity is zero (u0 = 0) and the radius of the helix is small (a = 0.1), the flow is similar to the case of a rectilinear vortex filament and an almost uniform axial flow occupies most of tube cross-section. With an increase in radius (a = 0.5), a part of the axial flow concentrates in the vicinity of the vortex filament. The last variant: when the vortex is closer to the wall, and the axial velocity is zero (a = 0.9, u0 = 0), almost all motion is concentrated in a thin vortex helical tube near the filament. But when the axial velocity is non-zero (u0 = 0.5), the flow pattern changes: at moderate radius (a = 0.5; 0.7) the greater part of the flow passes through a helical stream tube of large crosssection, and for a large radius (a = 0.9) the fluid moves in the axial direction in the tube center except for the peripheral area, where we have a flow in a helical stream tube of moderate cross-section. The qualitative change in the flow structure at low radius of the helix occurs if the axial velocity corresponds to the case of a steady unbounded stream away from the vortex. As one can see from Fig. 2.16 (u0 = 1), even at the smallest radii considered (a = 0.1), a helical vortex stream tube develops and it spans from the wall to the significant part of the pipe cross-section and even overlaps the center. At a = 0.3 the efficient diameter of the stream tube is about half the channel diameter and it decreases drastically with the increase of a. More complete information about the flow structure is available by plotting the actual streamlines. This requires integration of the system of equations dr/ur = rdθ/uθ = dz/uz. Examples of streamlines are illustrated in the Color Fig. 1. For a curved vortex with zero velocity at the axis (Color Fig. 1a), streamlines near the vortex filament are slightly deformed spirals.
0.5
1
2
4
8
108
u0 h
2 Vortex filaments
A
0
B 0.5
1.0
Fig. 2.15. Dependence of flow structure induced by a helical vortex in a cylindrical channel on helical pitch at different values of parameter u0 and fixed radius of the helical filament a = 0.5. (A) is the horizontal and (B) is the vertical cross-section
u0 a
0.1
0.3
0.5
0.7
0.9
A
0
0.5
1.0
109
Fig. 2.16. Dependence of flow structure induced by a helical vortex in a cylindrical channel on helix radius at different values of parameter u0 and a fixed helical pitch h = 2. (A) is the horizontal and (B) is the vertical cross-section
2.6 Infinitely thin helical vortex filament
B
110
2 Vortex filaments
As for the periphery, the streamlines are hardly curved, i.e., the axial component of velocity is much higher than the circumferential and radial components. For the case u0 = 1 and a small radius of the vortex filament (Color Fig.1 b,c), the streamlines are dense spirals either near or away from the filament, and the axial velocity at the periphery is much smaller than the circumferential one. For a vortex of large radius (a = 0.7) with zero axial velocity (Color Fig. 1c), the streamlines (except those closest to the filament) have complex structures. Otherwise, at u0 = 1 (Color Fig. 1d) the streamlines in the channel center are curved slightly. But the most drastic difference in the flow pattern is visible at low pitch of the helix (h = 0.5). At a = 0.5 and u0 = 0 (Color Fig. 1e), the wall flow is directed downwards and slightly swirling. Inside the helix, the flow is slow. An interesting streamline is observed: it passes near the tube axis and is directed by the diameter, then it winds around the vortex filament and again passes by the diameter (shifted by a half-period). For the opposite case, at u0 = 1, a vertical uprising flow occurs in the tube center, and the periphery is described by a spiral flow (Color Fig. 1f).
3 Models of vortex structures
3.1 Vortex sheet The infinitely thin vortex filament described in Sections 2.3 – 2.6 reflects the simplest marginal vorticity distribution when the whole vorticity is concentrated along some spatial curve coinciding with the vortex line. In another important extreme case, the vorticity is concentrated within an infinitely thin layer along some three-dimensional surface, which is called a vortex sheet. A vortex sheet can be conceived as being a thin layer with the thickness ε and vorticity ω, for which there exists a finite limit χ = lim εω ε→0 ω→∞
when ε 0, ω ∞. According to Stokes theorem, circulation Γ along the small rectangular contour with the thickness ε and length s is Γ = ωεs. Here the orientation of the contour is selected in such a way that vector is orthogonal to the plane of the contour. At the upper limit Γ = lim ωε s = χ s , ε→0 ω→∞
(3.1)
i.e. the quantity χ is the circulation per unit of vortex sheet length, and it can be considered as a measure of sheet intensity. Since there is a given direction connected with the vorticity vector, let us also introduce vector = χt, where t is the unit vector tangentional to the vortex line. Let us represent the vortex sheet element, as shown in Fig. 3.1. Here the vorticity vector (and t, accordingly) is orthogonal to the drawing plane and is directed towards the reader, while n is the unit vector to the sheet element. Then, if outside the vortex sheet the flow is irrotational, the vorticity can be expressed nominally by delta-function as follows
112
3 Models of vortex structures
Fig. 3.1. The vortex sheet element
= δ(xn),
(3.2)
where xn is the coordinate along the normal n. To determine the velocity induced by the vortex sheet let us substitute expression (3.2) into the Eq. (1.93)
u(r ) = −
1 ∆r × 1 ∆r × δ( xn ) dV = − dSdxn = 3 3 4π 4π r r ∆ ∆ V V
∫
∫
1 ∆r × dS(r ′) . =− 4π ∆r 3 S
∫
(3.3)
Here dS is the vortex surface element, r' is the coordinate of the point on the vortex sheet (Fig. 3.1; generally, vectors r, r', ∆r do not lie in the drawing plane). In the particular case of a single plane vortex sheet with the constant intensity χ, the integral in (3.3) can be easily solved. First of all let us expand the vector ∆r along the basis vectors (t, n, b)
∆r = (∆r · t)t + (∆r · n)n + (∆r · b)b. Then the first term on the right-hand side gives zero contribution to (3.3), because t || . The same applies to the second term, because ∆r · b is an odd function. As a result we obtain u(r ) =
4π
×
∫
(∆r ⋅ n)n ∆r
3
dS =
× n dS⊥ = 2 4π ∆r
∫
×n . 2
(3.4)
Here dS⊥ is the projection of the elementary area to the plane, orthogonal to ∆r. Therefore the last integral is the solid angle, at which the plane could be observed from point M(r), and equal to 2π. It follows from (3.4),
3.1 Vortex sheet
113
that the velocity vector in area 1 is parallel to the plane of the sheet and orthogonal to the vector (Fig. 3.1) and its scalar is the same everywhere
u1 = χ/2. In area 2 the velocity is directed to the opposite side and its scalar equals u1
u2 = −χ/2. Hence, on the vortex sheet with intensity nent undergoes discontinuity equal to [u] =
the tangential velocity compo-
× n.
(3.5)
And on the contrary, the existence of tangential discontinuity means the subsistence of the vortex sheet with the intensity, which can be found by = n × [u].
(3.6)
Relationships (3.5) and (3.6) are valid for any vortex sheet if considered locally. Another important case concerns the cylindrical sheet, when vector is orthogonal to the cylinder generating line. Let the cylinder have a circumferential cross-section (Fig. 3.2a, b). Taking into account that the element of length along the vortex line written in vector form is ds = tds, = tχ and dz(r') is the element of the generating line, we obtain from (3.3) the following
u=−
∞
∞
1 ∆r × χ ∆r × ds(r′) χ = − dS dz ( r′) = − 3 4π ∆r 3 4π 4 π ∆r −∞ −∞
∫
∫∫
⎡∞ χ ⎢ dz =− ⎢ 4π 2 2 ⎢⎣−∞ R + z
∫ ∫
(
∫∫
R× ds(r′)
(R
2
)
2 3/ 2
+z
dz =
⎤ χ R× ds(r′) ⎥ ′) = − × ( . d R s r ⎥ 3/ 2 2 2π R ⎥⎦
)
∫
Here it is taken into account, that ∆r = z + R, where R and z are projections of vector ∆r to the cross-sectional plane and the cylinder generating line accordingly, and that z component being odd does not contribute to the integral. The integral in brackets equals 2/R2. Let b be the unit vector parallel to the cylinder generating line and satisfying the b = t × n condition (Fig. 3.2a, b). Then, rewriting the expression under the integral via angles α and ϕ, we obtain for the point inside the cylinder
114
3 Models of vortex structures b
c
d
Fig. 3.2. Cylindrical vortex sheet of circular cross-section. Vortex lines: a, b – directed along the circumference, c – directed along the generating line, d – helical and I – selected vortex line
χb u= 2π
∫
ds sin α χb = R 2π
2π
∫ dϕ = χb = χ × n . 0
For the point outside the cylinder the integral apparently equals zero, i.e. u = 0. Thus, we have obtained a similar expression for the velocity jump as in (3.5) valid for a plane sheet, but now with different values of absolute velocities on both sides of the vortex sheet. This result has complete analogy with the magnetic field inside the infinitely long direct current solenoid. Note that similar conclusions are valid for a cylindrical vortex sheet with an arbitrary configuration of cross-section. Let us consider again the cylindrical sheet of circumferential crosssection with the radius a and intensity χ. But now the vortex lines are directed along the generating line (Fig. 3.2c). For this problem, velocity field can be obtained in a more simple way, using axial symmetry. This means that the induced velocity should only have the tangential component u, which is constant on the circumference of radius r. Then, according to the Stokes theorem, velocity circulation along the circumference L outside the cylindrical sheet, determined as Γ = 2πru, equals vorticity flux, which according to (3.1) is χ 2πa, wherefrom
u =
χa r
or
u =
Γ . 2π r
(3.7)
3.1 Vortex sheet
115
Apparently, the latter relationship exactly coincides with the velocity distribution (2.23) for an infinitely thin vortex line with the intensity Γ. Inside the cylindrical sheet the circulation along any concentric circumference in the cross-section of the cylinder obviously equals zero. Therefore, in the internal part u = 0. Note that the considered vortex sheet may be obtained by infinite compression of a helical vortex filament. Indeed, in the limit l ∞ in Eqs. (2.56), we find, that ur = uz = 0, while uθ agrees with (3.7) in an external area, whereas it equals zero in the internal area. In the third case of a cylindrical sheet (Fig. 3.2d), when vortex lines are helical, both axial and circumferential velocity components are induced. Such a sheet of circumferential cross-section with radius a, intensity χ and pitch of the helical vortex lines 2πl may be imagined as a superposition of the above considered vortex sheets: the first, generated by rectilinear vortex lines with intensity χ l
a 2 + l 2 , and the second, generated by vortex
lines in the form of circumferences with the intensity χ a
a 2 + l 2 . Thus,
χal Γ ⎧ = , uz = 0 ; r > a, ⎪uθ = r a 2 + l 2 2πr ⎪ ⎨ χa Γ ⎪u = 0, u = = ; r < a. z 2 2 ⎪ θ π l 2 a +l ⎩
(3.8)
Here Γ = 2π χ l a 2 + l 2 . We observe that the velocity field (3.8) obeys the general law of flows with helical symmetry (see Section 1.5) uz = u0 – r/l uθ, if we select for u0 the velocity inside the cylinder Γ/2πl. In conclusion of this Section, let us return to the solitary plane vortex sheet and calculate the velocity field based on the concept; that the vortex sheet is a continuous distribution of rectilinear vortex lines. As this occurs it is helpful to use complex variables. Let N be filaments (or point vortices) of an equal intensity n which are uniformly located along the x axis (Fig. 3.3). Passing to continuous distribution, let us rewrite the formula (2.25) in the integral form
∂w χ 1 dΓ = = ux − iuy = ∂z 2πi z − z0 2πi
∫
∞
∫
−∞
∞
dz0 χ =− log ( z0 − z ) . 2πi z − z0 −∞
Here dΓ = χdz0, z0 ≡ x, z = x + iy. Let us represent an argument of the logarithm in polar coordinates: z0 − z = reiϕ. If z0 ± ∞, then ϕ = 0, −π at
116
3 Models of vortex structures
Fig. 3.3. Modeling of the vortex sheet by continuous distribution of vortex filaments
y > 0 and ϕ = 0, +π at y < 0. Therefore, ux − iuy = ux = ∓ χ 2 at y
> <
0,
which agrees with the above obtained result (see Eq. 3.5). Formation of the vortex sheet occurs in many actual cases, such as flow over supporting areas, delta-shaped wings, and high-drag bodies. Due to self-induction impact, the vortex sheet is usually unstable and rolls into a spiral. This is how large-scale vortices appear, for instance, two tip vortices behind a plane, or a Karman vortex street behind a cylinder. The importance of representing the vortex sheet as a distribution of vortex filaments is that using a finite set of discrete vortices we may sufficiently simulate various flows, including the rolling-up process of the vortex sheet (see Section 6).
3.2 Spatially localized vortices 3.2.1 Vortex ring
The vortex ring is one of the few vortex objects in nature, which is commonly observed (see Fig. I.5). We can form a vortex ring, if we breathe out a puff of smoke through rounded lips. Often, we can see vortex rings coming from a car or tractor tailpipe. Dropping one fluid (colored) onto another illustrates another example of vortex ring formation. The first attempts of vortex ring mathematical description were undertaken at the end of 19th Century. Since the velocity field induced by a thin vortex almost coincides with the velocity field of an infinitely thin vortex, determination of the self-induced motion velocity of a vortex ring was the main problem. For a ring with circulation , having radius r0 , and core radius ε r0 (with uniform vorticity distribution), Kelvin (1867) suggested the formula for the velocity of translation motion
3.2 Spatially localized vortices
U=
8r 1 ⎞ Γ ⎛ log 0 − ⎟ . ⎜ ε 4⎠ 4πr0 ⎝
117
(3.9)
Hicks (1885) determined the velocity of a hollow (or filled with immobile fluid) vortex ring U=
8r 1 ⎞ Γ ⎛ log 0 − ⎟ . ⎜ ε 2⎠ 4πr0 ⎝
(3.10)
Proof of the validity of formula (3.9) for the round cross-section of a small area can be found in Lamb (1932, §§ 161-163). On the basis of Lamb’s ideas, Saffman (1970) developed the approach, which allows consideration of viscosity effect, swirling, unsteadiness and compressibility. Following the paper of Saffman, we will consider a thin vortex ring moving in a fluid at rest. The velocity field is shown in the form of the sum
u = U + u,
(3.11)
where U is the velocity of the vortex ring, which should be determined. Substituting expression (3.11) into the formula for kinetic energy T by Lamb’s definition (see Section 1.7.3) and taking into account the definition of impulse I (1.112), we obtain
∫
T = 2U ⋅ I + u ⋅ (r × ) dV .
(3.12)
We will use the local polar coordinates (s, θ) with the origin in the center of the cross-section (Fig. 3.4), which in the first approximation is assumed to be round. Fraenkel (1970) proved that vorticity in this case can be expressed as
ω(r, z) = ω0(s)[1 + O(ε/r0)].
(3.13)
The vortex ring impulse can be calculated using Eq. (1.126). It is directed parallel to the ring axis and amounts to (at a unit density) (3.14) ∫∫ ω (r , z)r drdz = πr0 Γ [1 + O(ε r0 )], ε Γ = ∫∫ ω (r , z)drdz = 2π ∫ sω0 ( s)ds . To determine the kinetic en0
I=π
where
2
2
ergy of the vortex ring using Eq. (1.127), we require the expression for the stream function, which can be obtained via the integration of Green function G over the vortex core
118
3 Models of vortex structures
Fig. 3.4. The coordinate system for a vortex ring
Ψ=
∫∫ ω (r , z)Gdrdz.
(3.15)
Function G coincides with the stream function of an infinitely thin vortex ring (2.42) with the unit circulation. Neglecting the small terms in expansion (2.46) and substituting it into (3.15) together with (3.13), we find
Ψ=
r0 2π
ε 2π
∫ ∫ s′ω0 (s′) ⎢⎣log (8r0 ) − 2 − 2 log ( s ⎡
1
0 0
2
)
⎤ + s′2 − 2ss′ cos ( θ − θ′ ) ⎥ ds′dθ′ . ⎦
For integration over θ' we will use the formula (Gradshtein and Ryzhik 1965) 2π
∫ 0
⎧4π log s′, s′ > s, log ⎡ s 2 + s′2 − 2 ss′ cos θ ⎤ dθ = ⎨ ⎣ ⎦ ⎩4π log s, s > s′.
From this formula we have for the points within the vortex cross-section ε
s
∫
∫
0
0
ε
∫
Ψ = r0 (log8r0 − 2) ω0 ( s′) s′ds′ − r0 log s ω0 ( s′) s′ds′ − r0 ω0 ( s′) log s′s′ds′ . s
Introducing function s
∫
Γ0 ( s) = 2π ω0 ( s ′) s ′ds ′
(3.16)
0
(where Γ = Γ0(ε)) and integrating by parts, reduces the expression for the stream function to the following:
3.2 Spatially localized vortices
119
ε
Ψ=
r0 Γ ⎛ 8r ⎞ r Γ0 ( s′) ds′. log 0 − 2 ⎟ + 0 ⎜ 2π ⎝ ε ⎠ 2π s s′
∫
Now substituting Ψ into Eq. (1.127), we deduce the main terms of kinetic energy expansion in the small parameter ε/r0
T=π
∫∫
ε
ωϕ Ψ drdz ≈
2 8r0 r0 Γ 2 ⎛ ⎞ r0 Γ0 ( s) log 2 ds . − + ⎟ 2 2 ⎜⎝ s ε ⎠ 0
∫
(3.17)
For a vortex ring with swirling, i.e., if the velocity component uϕ is nonzero, the following term will be added to the kinetic energy π
∫∫ ruϕ drdz, 2
and the last item in equation (3.12) will take the form
∫ u ⋅ (r ×
∫∫ rωϕ (ruz − zur )drdz + + 2π ∫∫ ruϕ ( zωr − r ωz )drdz.
) dV = 2π
(3.18)
Taking into consideration that
ωr = − ∂uϕ ∂z , ωz =
1 ∂ (ruϕ ) , r ∂r
we find that the second term on the right side of (3.18)
(
)
(
)
∂ 2 2 ⎫ ⎧∂ 2π ruϕ ( zωr − rωz ) drdz = π ruϕ2drdz − π ⎨ rzuϕ2 + r uϕ ⎬ drdz. ∂r ⎩ ∂z ⎭
∫∫
∫∫
∫∫
The last integral disappears here, if uϕ vanishes at infinity. As a result, equation (3.12) is written in the same manner both for a vortex with and without swirling
π
∫∫ ωϕ Ψdrdz = 2UI +2π∫∫ r ωϕ (ruz − zur )drdz.
(3.19)
The left side of Eq. (3.19) and the impulse are determined by the main terms with accuracy O(ε/r0) according to the Eqs. (3.14) and (3.17). They depend on ω0(s), vortex radius r0 and intensity Γ. We should note that these two terms have the order of O(r0Γ2). A problem is caused by the last term. Since ωϕ ∼ Γ/ε2, uz ∼ Γ/ε, r ∼ r0, drdz ∼ ε2, the order of this term is r02 Γ2/ε, and the left side of (3.19) is not considered in the estimation of U.
120
3 Models of vortex structures
However, due to more accurate estimation of ωϕ and uz, we see that this is not correct. To prove this, let us use Lamb’s transformation (1932, § 162). We assume that the motion is steady. Components of velocity uz, ur and vorticity ωϕ satisfy the steady motion equations in the coordinate frame moving together with the vortex ∂u 1 ∂ (rur ) + z = 0, r ∂r ∂z
ur
∂ωϕ ∂r
+ uz
∂ωϕ ∂z
=
ur ωϕ
1 ∂uϕ + . r ∂z 2
r
Hence,
r 2 uz ωϕ − rzur ωϕ = ruϕ2 − 3rzur ωϕ −
(
)
(
)
∂ 2 ∂ 2 uϕ rz − r 2 zuz ωϕ + r zur ωϕ . ∂z ∂r
Integrating this relationship over the vortex cross-section, we get
2π
∫∫ r ωϕ (ruz − zur )drdz = −6π∫∫ rzur ωϕ drdz + 2π∫∫ ruϕ drdz . 2
This formula is accurate for the steady flow. Now the terms on the right side have the order O(r0Γ2) and can be estimated using the approximation (3.13), i.e., ωϕ = ω0(s), ur = Γ0(s) cos θ/2πs, uϕ = uϕ0(s), drdz = s ds dθ. This gives
2π
∫∫
ε
3 r ωϕ (ruz − zur )drdz ≈ − r0 Γ 2 + 4π2 r0 suϕ20 ds . 4
∫ 0
Substituting the calculated integral into (3.19), we have ε
ε
2 8r 1 2 ⎛ 3 ⎞ r Γ0 ( s) Γ r0 ⎜ log 0 − 2 ⎟ + 0 ds = 2Uπr02 Γ − r0 Γ 2 + 4π2r0 suϕ20 ds . ε 2 4 ⎝ ⎠ 20 s 0
∫
∫
Finally, the expression for the velocity of the vortex ring motion can be written as:
U=
⎛ π2 ε 2 uϕ20 ⎞ π2 ε 2 uθ2 8r 1 Γ ⎜ ⎟. log 0 − + 2 4 − 4πr0 ⎜ ε 2 Γ2 Γ2 ⎟ ⎠ ⎝
(3.20)
Here uθ = Γ0(s)/2πs, and the lines above the quantities represent an averaging over the vortex cross-section. The estimate of the kinetic energy with the same accuracy gives
3.2 Spatially localized vortices
⎛ π2 ε 2 uϕ20 ⎞ 8r π2 ε 2 uθ2 1 ⎜. 2 T = r0 Γ 2 ⎜ log 0 − 2 + 2 + ⎜ ⎜ 2 ε Γ2 Γ2 ⎝ ⎠
121
(3.21)
The effect of swirling, i.e., the motion along the vortex axis, on the velocity of the vortex ring has also been studied by Widnall et al. (1971) with the help of the matched asymptotic expansions method. We should note that swirling, ultimately decreases the vortex velocity to zero and even causes motion in the opposite direction. When there is no swirling, formula (3.12) can be written through the integral characteristics
T = 2UI −
3 I2 , 4 π2 r03
i.e., the velocity of the vortex ring is expressed through energy, impulse and a typical length scale U=
T 3 I . + 2 I 8 π2 r03
Without swirling, formulae similar to (3.20) and (3.21) were derived by Fraenkel (1970) with the help of expansion in the small parameter ε/r0 1 in the solution of integral equation on the stream function
1 Ψ (r , z) = − Ur 2 + 2
∫∫ r ′F(Ψ(r ′, z′))G(r , r ′, z − z′) dr ′dz′.
(3.22)
Here rF(Ψ) = ωϕ; G is the Green function of the Laplace operator for infinite space under the condition of axial symmetry; it coincides with the stream function (2.42) at = 1. Using an expansion of type (2.46), Fraenkel proved the existence of a solution for equation (3.22) and determined the motion velocity of the thin vortex ring
U=
1 ⎤ ⎪⎧ ⎛ ε2 Γ ⎡ 8r0 1 ε ⎞ ⎪⎫ ⎢log − + 4 V 2 ( s) sds ⎥ ⎨1 + O ⎜ 2 log 2 ⎟ ⎬ , ⎜ 4πr0 ⎢ r0 ⎟⎠ ⎭⎪ ε 2 ⎝ r0 0 ⎣ ⎦⎥ ⎩⎪
∫
s
where
1 Ω( s ′) s ′ds ′, V ( s) = − s
∫ 0
πε 2 ω0 ( s) . Ω( s ) = Γ
122
3 Models of vortex structures
It is clear that this result coincides with the formula (3.20). For the vortex without any swirling and with uniform vorticity distribution we have from (3.16) that Γ(s) = Γ s2/ε2, and correspondingly uθ = Γ s/2π ε2 and uθ2 = Γ 2 8π2 ε 2 , and relationship (3.9) follows from there. For a hollow vortex,
there is no inner motion in the core, and hence, u θ2 = 0 , uϕ20 = 0 and (3.20) provides the Hicks formula (3.10). If in the core there is no clear boundary of vorticity at s = ε, Eqs. (3.20) and (3.21) become insufficiently definite. For the case of smooth vorticity distribution rapidly decreasing with distance from the axis, Saffman (1992) suggests combining the items
− log ε +
1 Γ2
ε
∫ 0
Γ 02 ( s ) ds . s
This sum does not depend on ε, if ε is sufficiently high, therefore, Γ0(ε) = Γ. Particularly, for the viscous vortex ring for short periods t << r02 4ν , the core structure can be considered as the local 2-D, then from (2.31) we have
(
Γ0 ( s) = Γ 1 − e− s
2
4 νt
).
As a result, U=
Γ 4πr0
8r0 1 ⎧ ⎫ − (1 − γ + log 2) ⎬. ⎨log 4ν t 2 ⎩ ⎭
(3.23)
The motion of a viscous vortex was studied by Tung and Ting (1967) using the method of the matched asymptotic expansions, but due to an arithmetical mistake the constant equals 0.688 instead of (1 − γ + log 2)/2 ≈ 0.588. Strictly speaking, under the condition of viscosity the motion is not steady. Nevertheless, according to Saffman (1970), if the velocity of the vorticity centroid transportation X=
1 (r × ) ⋅ I rdV , 2 I2
∫
U=
dX , dt
is considered as the vortex ring velocity, the Lamb transformation is true and Eq. (3.23) represents the velocity of the vortex centroid motion. Applying the solution for vorticity diffusion in the vortex ring of the type (2.49), valid in a wider time range, Kaplanski and Rudi (1999) derived the formula for the vortex ring velocity in the form of integral
3.2 Spatially localized vortices
U=
Γ0 4π
∞
{π [1 − erf(µ)] (1 − 6µ 2ν t ∫ 0
2
123
⎛ µr ⎞ ) + 6 π µ exp(−µ 2 ) J12 ⎜ 0 ⎟ dµ, ⎝ 2ν t ⎠
}
coinciding with (3.23) at low values of t and providing the right asymptotic for the decaying vortex ring (Rott and Cantwell 1993 , b)
U AS =
7 πr02 Γ 0 . 15 (8πνt )3 / 2
On the basis of the approach by Saffman (1970), Moore (1985) examined the motion of a uniform vortex ring in a compressed medium and derived a correction for the velocity formula
U=
8r0 1 5M2 ⎞ Γ ⎛ − − ⎜⎜ log ⎟. 4πr0 ⎝ ε 4 12 ⎟⎠
Here M = Γ/2πac∞ is the Mach number, c∞ is the sound velocity at infinity. This formula considers only the lowest degree of expansion in M. As for “fat” vortex rings, their geometry and motion velocity are determined by numerical calculations only. When solving equation (3.22) with function F(Ψ) = const, Norbury (1973) obtained a one-parametric family of steady vortex rings. The dimensionless average core radius α = S πr02 was chosen as the parameter, where S is the area of the vortex crosssection, and r0 = (rmin + rmax)/2. The range of parameter α is from α 1 (corresponding to a thin vortex ring) to α = 2 (corresponding to a Hill spherical vortex ring with the known accurate analytical solution) were studied. The shape of the vortex ring cross-section for different values of α is shown in Fig. 3.5. With an increase in α, the motion velocity and the kinetic energy of the vortex both decrease (Fig. 3.6), and the impulse increases. Dependencies for the thin vortex core, obtaining from (3.18), (3.19) and (3.14) by means of normalizing with the same length and velocity scales, as in the paper by Norbury (1973) 1⎛ 8 1⎞ 8 7⎞ π2 ⎛ U = ⎜ log − ⎟ , T = ⎜ log − , 4⎝ α 4⎠ α 4⎠ 2 ⎝
I = π2 .
are presented in Fig. 3.6 for comparison. Expansions of U, T and I with consideration of small values of the second order by α are given in the paper by Fraenkel (1972).
124
3 Models of vortex structures
Fig. 3.5. The shape of the vortex ring cross-section vs. the dimensionless average core radius α (Norbury 1973*)
Fig. 3.6. Dependency of velocity U, kinetic energy T and impulse I of the vortex ring on dimensionless core radius α. Dashed lines correspond to the “thin” vortex core (Norbury 1973*)
3.2.2 Hill’s spherical vortex Now we consider the extreme case α = 2 (Hill 1894). The area of vortical fluid is assumed to be confined to the interior of a sphere of radius a, translating with the constant velocity U. The vortex lines are circles with a common axis passing through the center of the sphere, and the streamlines lie in meridian planes. Outside the sphere the motion is potential. We use the cylindrical variables (r, ϕ, z) with the coordinate origin in the center of the sphere and consider the distribution of vorticity ω = (0, ωϕ, 0)
3.2 Spatially localized vortices
⎧⎪ Ar , r 2 + z 2 < a 2 , ωϕ = ⎨ 2 2 2 ⎪⎩0, r + z > a ,
125
(3.24)
satisfying Helmholtz equation (1.15). The velocity field relative to a moving vortex satisfies the continuity equation and we can introduce the stream function ur = −
1 ∂Ψ , r ∂z
uz =
1 ∂Ψ . r ∂r
We should note that the vector potential is A = (0, Ψ r , 0) . The equation for the stream function can be obtained from the kinematic relationship = curl u
r
∂ ⎛ 1 ∂Ψ ⎞ ∂ 2 Ψ = −r ωθ . ⎜ ⎟+ ∂r ⎝ r ∂r ⎠ ∂z 2
(3.25)
The boundary conditions on the sphere surface follow from the velocity continuity. In the same time ωϕ r = F ( Ψ ) , whence it follows that
Ψ = const on the surface, bounding the region of non-zero vorticity. Far from the sphere, the velocity uz relative to the sphere is –U. It is more convenient to solve the equation (3.25) using spherical variables (ρ, ϕ, χ) [ρ sin χ = r, ρ cos χ = z] ∂2Ψ ∂ρ2
+
1 ⎛ ∂ 2 Ψ cos χ ∂Ψ ⎞ ⎪⎧− Aρ2 sin 2 χ, ρ < a, − ⎜ ⎟=⎨ ρ2 ⎝⎜ ∂χ 2 sin χ ∂χ ⎠⎟ ⎪⎩ 0, ρ > a
(3.26)
and employing the variable separation method. The general solution to the uniform equation is ⎛ d⎞ Ψ c = ⎜ cρ2 + ⎟ sin 2 χ . ρ⎠ ⎝
Obviously, inside the sphere we have d = 0, and outside it c = 0. The particular solution to the non-uniform equation is
Ψp = −
A 4 2 ρ sin χ . 10
Satisfying the conditions on the sphere surface, we determine
126
3 Models of vortex structures
⎧1 2 2 2 2 ⎪⎪10 Aρ sin χ(a − ρ ), ρ < a , Ψ=⎨ ⎪− 1 Aa 2ρ2 sin 2 χ(1 − a3 ρ3 ), ρ > a , ⎪⎩ 15
(3.27)
or, returning to cylindrical variables,
⎧1 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 ⎪⎪10 Ar (a − r − z ), r + z < a , Ψ=⎨ ⎪− 1 Aa 2r 2 ⎡1 − a3 (r 2 + z 2 )3 / 2 ⎤ , r 2 + z 2 > a 2 . ⎣ ⎦ ⎪⎩ 15
(3.28)
The constant A is derived from the condition of flow uniformity far from the sphere 2 − a 2 A = −U . 15 The streamline pattern in the Hill vortex is shown in Fig. 3.7. When differentiating the stream functions (3.28), we get the velocity components
3 rz ur = U 2 , 2 a
3 ⎛ 2r 2 + z 2 ⎞ 2 2 2 uz = U ⎜1 − ⎟⎟ , r + z < a , 2 2 ⎜⎝ a ⎠
⎡⎛ a2 uz = U ⎢⎜ 2 ⎢⎜⎝ r + z 2 ⎣
⎞ ⎟⎟ ⎠
5/ 2
⎛ a2 ⎜⎜ 2 2 ⎝r + z
5/ 2
⎞ ⎟⎟ , ⎠ ⎤ 2z 2 − r 2 ⎥ , r 2 + z2 > a 2 . 1 − ⎥ 2a 2 ⎦
3 rz ur = U 2 2 a
(3.29)
(3.30)
In the frame of reference related to the vortex, the motion is steady, and this provides easy determination of the pressure distribution. Indeed, it is found from (1.57) and (3.24) that inside the sphere the Bernoulli constant is H = –AΨ, and from the Bernoulli equation without mass forces and at the unit density we find that
P = P∞ − AΨ − (ur2 + uz2 ) 2 with velocity components (3.29). Outside the sphere, the Bernoulli constant is a global constant and correspondingly
3.2 Spatially localized vortices
127
1
0 -1
0
1
Fig. 3.7. Streamlines in the Hill vortex
1
0 -1
0
1
Fig. 3.8. Pressure isolines in the Hill vortex
P = P∞ − (ur2 + uz2 ) 2 with values ur and uz, determined by functions (3.31). The distribution of pressure in the vortex is shown in Fig. 3.8. The following invariants can be easily calculated for the spherical Hill vortex: circulation Γ = 5aU, impulse I = Iz = 2πa3U, angular momentum M = Mϕ = –5π/16a4U, and kinetic energy T = 10/7 π a3U2. We should note that at the calculation of invariants it is necessary to use the absolute reference frame
1 ur = ur , uz = uz + U , Ψ = Ψ + Ur 2 . 2
(3.31)
3.2.3 Hicks spherical vortex The Hicks spherical vortex (Hicks 1899) is a more spatially complex vortex structure with three non-zero components of velocity and vorticity. For the general case of axisymmetrical swirling flow, the fields of velocity and vorticity in cylindrical coordinates (r, ϕ, z) are determined by two functions (see section 1.4.2)
128
3 Models of vortex structures
1 ∂Ψ ⎞ ⎛ 1 ∂Ψ , uϕ , u = ⎜− ⎟, r ∂r ⎠ ⎝ r ∂z ⎛ ∂uϕ ⎞ 1 1 ∂ = ⎜− , − D2 Ψ , ruϕ ⎟ , r r ∂r ⎝ ∂z ⎠
(3.32)
(3.33)
∂ 1 ∂Ψ ∂ 2 Ψ + 2 . ∂r r ∂r ∂z Let us assume that a region of swirling fluid propagates without a shape change, i.e., for some moving reference frame, where ∂Ψ/∂t ≡ 0, the motion is stationary. Then, in accordance with (1.57)
where D2 Ψ = r
ωϕ r
=−
dH (Ψ ) Γ dΓ(Ψ ) . + 2 dΨ dΨ r
(3.34)
Here Γ = ruϕ and H = 1 2 (ur2 + uϕ2 + uz2 ) + P ρ + Π (Bernoulli function) are the arbitrary functions of Ψ . We again use the variables with tilde, i.e., the values of velocity and stream function in the reference frame translating with some constant velocity U along the axis Oz. As this occurs, relationships (3.31) and uϕ = uϕ remain true. We will skip tilde above ur, uϕ. Thus, for the stream function, we have the following differential equation
D2 Ψ = r 2
dH dΓ −Γ . dΨ dΨ
(3.35)
For the Hill spherical vortex considered above H = AΨ , Γ = 0 inside the sphere, and H = const, Γ = 0 beyond the sphere. Moffatt (1969) (see also Hicks (1899)) showed that equation (3.35) can be solved, if it is assumed that 2 2 2 ⎪⎧ H = H0 − AΨ , Γ = αΨ , r + z < a , ⎨ 2 2 2 ⎪⎩ H = H0 , Γ = 0, r + z > a .
(3.36)
Here H0 , A, α are constants. In addition, equation (3.35) becomes linear 2 2 2 2 2 ⎪⎧− Ar − α Ψ , r + z < a , D2 Ψ = ⎨ 2 2 2 ⎪⎩0, r + z < a ,
(3.37)
3.2 Spatially localized vortices
129
and the simple relationship between the velocity and vorticity fields is implemented
ωr = αur,
ωϕ = αuϕ + Ar,
ωz = αuz.
(3.38)
The boundary conditions for Ψ coincide with the conditions in the problem of the Hill vortex. The external solution at r2 + z2 > a2 will coincide with that described above. We introduce the quantity
Ψ1 = Ψ + Ar 2 α 2
(3.39)
and reduce equation (3.37) to a uniform one
D2Ψ1 = – α2Ψ1. As in the case of deducing a solution to the Hill vortex, it is reasonable to employ the spherical variables (ρ, ϕ, χ) [ρ sin χ = r, ρ cos χ = z] and solve the problem using the variable separation method
∂ 2 Ψ1 ∂ρ2
+
1 ⎛ ∂ 2 Ψ1 cos χ ∂Ψ1 ⎞ 2 − ⎜ ⎟⎟ + α Ψ1 = 0 . 2 ⎜ 2 χ ∂χ sin ρ ⎝ ∂χ ⎠
To provide matching with the external flow, it is necessary to choose the following dependency on χ: Ψ1 ∼ sin2 χ, i.e., Ψ1 = R(ρ) sin2 χ. For R(ρ) we have the equation ⎛ 2 ⎞ R′′ + ⎜ α 2 − 2 ⎟ R = 0 , ⎜ ρ ⎟⎠ ⎝ whose solution can be expressed via the spherical Bessel function of the first order1 (Abramowitz and Stegun 1964)
R = bαρ j1 (αρ),
j1 ( x ) =
sin x x
2
−
cos x , b = const . x
Therefore, considering Eq. (3.39), we get
Ψ = ⎡bαρ j1 (αρ) − A ρ2 α 2 ⎤ sin 2 χ , ρ < a . ⎣ ⎦
(3.40)
Constants b and A are determined from the condition of matching the stream function (3.40) with function (see (3.27), (3.28))
1
Moffatt (1969) uses the Bessel function of the fractional order
J3/ 2 ( x) = 2 x / π j1 ( x) instead of j1.
130
3 Models of vortex structures
Ψ=−
U 2 2 ⎛ a3 ρ sin χ ⎜1 − 3 ⎜ ρ 2 ⎝
⎞ ⎟⎟ , ρ > a , ⎠
and their derivatives with respect to ρ at ρ = a. As a result, A=
α3 j1 (αa ) b, a
2 U = α 2 j2 (αa) b . 3
(3.41)
Assuming that parameters α and b are given, and varying them, we discover the family of vortices. The velocity of the vortex motion is determined by Eqs. (3.41). Two subfamilies of the determined solutions should be noted specially. The first of them is given by the values of α, when j1(αa) = 0. In this case A = 0 and according to (3.38), ω = αu, i.e., the Beltrami flow is obtained. The first root of function j1(x) gives the value α = 4.493/a. Another distinguished subfamily appears at j2(αa) = 0, and this corresponds to the value of U = 0, i.e., to immobile vortices. The minimum value of parameter α for such vortices equals 5.763/a. Finally, passing to the limit α → 0 from Eqs. (3.40), (3.41), we get the stream function for the Hill vortex (3.27). When the stream function (3.40) is known, the velocity components are determined by differentiation uz, uz
ur = bα2 sin χ cos χ j2(αρ),
(3.42)
uz = 2bα [ j1 (αρ) ρ − j1 (αa) a ] − bα 2 α 2 (αρ) sin 2 χ .
(3.43)
The velocity component uϕ inside the vortex is obtained from definition Γ (Γ = ruϕ) and Eq. (3.36)
uϕ = bα2 ρ [j1(αρ)/ρ – j1(αa)/a] sin χ.
(3.44)
A simple connection between the velocity curl and the velocity itself (3.38) allows easy determination of the flow vector potential. Indeed, since rot u = αu + Ar iϕ , it is natural to seek the vector potential in the following form 1 A= u+F, α and for the determination of vector F we get the equation curl F = −
Ar iϕ . α
(3.45)
3.2 Spatially localized vortices
a
Fig. 3.9. Hicks vortex. surfaces (αa = 3)
131
b
– behavior of the vortex line and streamline; b – stream
The second equation arises from the condition that vector A must be solenoidal div F = 0.
(3.46)
Obviously, the problem of (3.45), (3.46) is similar to that of the inner flow in the Hill spherical vortex (3.26), and in correspondence with (3.29) this gives
Ar =
1 A 2 1 A 2 ur − ρ (1 + sin 2 χ) . ρ sin χ cos χ , Az = uz + α α 5α 5α
Finally, the component Aϕ is proportional to uϕ:
Aϕ = uϕ α . Beyond the sphere ρ = a, the vector potential has a single non-zero component Aϕ = Ψ / r . Now, we consider the structure of the vortex field inside the sphere. It is clear from Eqs. (3.38) that the vortex lines, like the streamlines lie on the surfaces Ψ = const (Fig. 3.9 ). In turn, the latter are torus-like nested surfaces (Fig. 3.9b). At αa < 5.763, the stream function has one extreme at the point with coordinates χ = π/2, ρ = ρ0, satisfying the condition uz = 0 . At αa > 5.763, the second extreme appears at point χ = π/2, ρ = ρ1. The picture of isoline Ψ = const becomes two-celled (Fig. 3.10). An increase in the number of cells occurs after the transition of the value αa through the hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
132
3 Models of vortex structures
Fig. 3.10. The two-cell structure of the stream surfaces in the Hill vortex at α = 7
Fig. 3.11. Radial positions of stream function extreme points ρ0 and ρ1 in the Hill vortex vs. parameter α
next root of function j2(x). Dependencies ρ0(α) and ρ1(α) are shown in Fig. 3.11. At α → 0 ρ0 → a/ 2 , and this corresponds to the extreme of the stream function in the Hill vortex. In another extreme case α → ∞ ρ0 → s0/α, where s0 = 2.744 is the first root of equation (s2 – 1) sin s + s cos s = 0.
(3.47)
Respectively, ρ1 → s1/α, etc. According to Moffatt (1969), the period of a vortex line increases from zero at Ψ = 0 (at the boundary of a sphere ρ = a) to infinity at Ψ = Ψ max at the vortex “axis” (χ = π/2, ρ = ρ0). However, according to the detailed analysis (Kuibin 2003), the vortex line period increases logarithmically at Ψ → 0 , and at Ψ → Ψ max, the period becomes finite and equals
(
2 παr0
2 α2r02 − 2 + Ar04 Ψ max
)
⎛ A r02 ⎞ . ⎜⎜ 1 + 2⎟ ⎟ ⎝ Ψ max α ⎠
Considering the simple dependencies of velocity components on coordinates, we can express all invariants via the elementary functions. The impulse (see (1.126)) of the Hicks vortex is directed along axis z, and equals
Iz = π
∫∫ r
2
ωϕ drdz = 2πa3U =
4π abf0 (αa), 3
f0 ( x) = x 2 j2 ( x) ,
and coincides with the impulse of the Hill vortex at the same velocity U. The angular momentum (see (1.115)) has two non-zero components
Mϕ = −π
∫∫ r (r
2
+ z 2 )ωϕ drdz = −2π2 ba 2 f1 (αa),
3.2 Spatially localized vortices
133
b
Fig. 3.12. Diagrams of functions f0(x), f1(x), f2(x) ( ) and f3(x), f4(x) (b), included in relationships for invariants of the Hicks vortex
f1 ( x ) = ⎡(8 + 4x 2 − x 4 ) j0 ( x ) − (8x − 4 x3 ) j1 ( x ) − 8⎤ x 2 , ⎣ ⎦ Mz = −π
∫∫ r (r
2
+ z 2 )ωz drdz = −
8π 2 ba f2 (αa), 15
f2 ( x) = x 2 j1 ( x) − 5xj2 ( x). Kinetic energy can be calculated using the formula (1.119)
T = 16π
b2 f3 (αa), a
⎡ j 2 ( x) j1 ( x ) j2 ( x) j12 ( x) ⎤ − + f3 ( x ) = x 4 ⎢ 2 ⎥. 2x 10 ⎥⎦ ⎣⎢ 9
The last invariant of the Hicks vortex is helicity
H = 2π ∫∫ ru ⋅ drdz =
8π b 2 f4 (αa), 3 a2
f4 ( x) = x 4 ⎡ xj12 ( x) − xj0 ( x) j2 ( x) − 2 j1 ( x) j2 ( x) ⎤ . ⎣ ⎦ Diagrams of functions f0, f1, f2 are shown in Fig. 3.12 , while f3, f4 are presented in Fig. 3.12b. If we know two invariants, for instance; impulse and energy, we can determine (at a given radius a) the velocity of the vortex motion and the value of parameter α. Applying the third invariant, Mz or helicity H, we can determine all three values, which assign the vortex parameters: a, b, α (velocity U is connected with parameter b by Eqs. (3.41)).
134
3 Models of vortex structures
3.3 Columnar vortices in ideal fluid 3.3.1 Rankine vortex The model of a cylinder vortex with a finite round core of radius a, and a constant vorticity ω inside it (Fig. 3.13), is more realistic than the model of an infinitely thin vortex filament. Outside the core, the flow is assumed to be irrotational. As in the case of a vortex sheet, this vortex can be approximated by the continuous distribution of rectilinear vortex filaments in the core. Then, according to Stokes theorem, the contribution of the core cross-section element dS to circulation dΓ, equals
dΓ = ω dS. The circulation around any circuit once and enclosing the whole vortex core is Γ = ωπa2 = const.
(3.48)
Applying formula (2.25) for the velocity field induced by N vortices and turning to the continuous distribution, we have
ux − iuy =
dΓ
∫ 2πi(z − z0 ) =
ω dS(z0 ) . 2πi z − z0
∫
S
This integral is convenient for calculation, but it is simpler to get the result by considering the axial symmetry of the problem, i.e., the presence of only the circumferential velocity component u = u(r). From Stokes theorem, for a circle with radius r > 0, we have 2πru = ω, and further taking into account (3.48) we find the expression for velocity in the region of irrotational (potential) flow b
Fig. 3.13. Profiles of velocity ( ) and pressure (b) in the Rankine vortex
3.3 Columnar vortices in ideal fluid
u=
Γ a2 ω = , r > a. 2r 2πr
135
(3.49)
As in the case of a cylindrical sheet, this distribution coincides with the velocity field induced by an infinitely thin vortex filament with intensity Γ at distance r > a. Inside the core, in the same way we obtain
u=
2πru = πr2ω or
Γr 2πa 2
, r < a.
(3.50)
Linearity of the profile indicates the solid-body rotation of fluid in the vortex core with angular velocity Ω equal to
Ω = Γ/2πa2.
(3.51)
The resultant velocity distribution is shown in Fig. 3.13 . Apparently, there is a break in the velocity profile at the boundary of the core r = a, caused by a vorticity jump. Nevertheless, this model called the Rankine vortex is the most popular. It reflects the main features of concentrated vortices. The radial distribution of static pressure is characterized by a drastic decrease in the vortex core. To calculate the pressure profile, we use the Euler equation, which in polar coordinates and accounting for axial symmetry takes the form
ρ
u 2 dp = , r dr
(3.52)
then r
p = p∞ + ρ
∫
∞
u2 dr , r
(3.53)
where ρ is the fluid density, p∞ is the pressure at infinity. Substituting velocity profiles (3.49), (3.50) into (3.53), we find the distribution of pressure p = p∞ − ρ
p = p∞ − ρ
ω2 a 4 8r 2
, r > a,
ω2 a 2 ω2 2 r , r < a, +ρ 4 8
(3.54)
(3.55)
136
3 Models of vortex structures
the diagram of which is shown in Fig. 3.13b. The minimum pressure is obtained at the vortex axis
pmin = p∞ − ρω2 a 2 / 4 = p∞ − ρ
Γ2 4π 2 a 2
.
(3.56)
At the core boundary, p – p∞ = (pmin – p∞)/2. For an infinitely thin vortex filament of intensity Γ, the pressure at the axis tends to (– ∞), as it is obvious from (3.56) at a → 0. Such a drastic decrease in pressure explains the formation of funnels on the free surface of the fluid upon intensive rotation and objects being drawing into the near-axial zone of tornadoes. 3.3.2 Gauss vortex
The smooth profiles of vorticity and azimuthal velocity were obtained by Hopfinger and van Heijst (1993) upon numerical examination of monopolar vortex instability. In the dimensionless form they are written as q ⎡ ⎛ r ⎞q ⎤ ⎡ ⎛ r q ⎞⎤ ωR ⎡ 1 ⎛ r ⎞ ⎤ u 1 r exp ⎢ − ⎜ ω≡ = ⎢1 − q ⎜ ⎟ ⎥ exp ⎢ − ⎜ ⎟ ⎥ , u ≡ = ⎟⎥ . U ⎣⎢ 2 ⎝ R ⎠ ⎦⎥ U 2R ⎢⎣ ⎝ R ⎠ ⎦⎥ ⎢⎣ ⎝⎜ R ⎠⎟ ⎦⎥ Here R, U are the scales of length and velocity, q is a shape factor. In particular, assuming that q = 2 and introducing the dimensionless coordinate r = 2r / R, we obtain ⎛ r2 ⎞ ⎛ 1 ⎞ ω = ⎜1 − r 2 ⎟ exp ⎜ − ⎟ . ⎜ 2 ⎟ ⎝ 2 ⎠ ⎝ ⎠
(3.57)
This vortex is called the Gauss vortex because the dimensionless stream function Ψ is described by the Gaussian distribution
Ψ=
1 r2 exp(− ). 2 2
(3.58)
Due to their simplicity, formulae (3.57), (3.58) are often used for the generalization of experimental data. 3.3.3 One-dimensional helical flow Let us consider an example of a steady one-dimensional helical flow, where the streamlines coincide with the vortex lines (Section 1.4.1), in the framework of the model of swirling axisymmetrical flow. With this pur-
3.3 Columnar vortices in ideal fluid
137
pose we notate (1.44) in cylindrical coordinates. We assume that the velocity components depend on the radial coordinate only and λ ≡ const ≠ 0. Then, it follows from the first equation (1.44) that ur ≡ 0, i.e., we obtain the flow with the streamlines located on the co-axial cylinders. Due to the combination of the second and third equations in (1.44), we get
uθ ∂ (r uθ ) ∂u 1 ∂ uz + uz z = 0, at that =λ. uθ ∂r ∂r ∂r r
(3.59)
We should note that the first equation in (3.59) can be also obtained from (1.36) after substitution of (1.38) and considering the above assumptions and the fact that for steady helical flows the Bernoulli constant is the same within the whole flow area. Equations (3.59) determine nothing but the sustained helical flow of inviscid fluid in a round tube at uniform energy distribution. Equations (3.59) can be integrated at various initial assumptions. However, according to Vasiliev (1958), we restrict oneself to a case of simple distribution for the circumferential velocity component uθ = αr,
α = const,
which is equivalent to the velocity distribution inside the Rankine vortex core (3.50). Then, after integration of (3.59) we get for the axial velocity component uz = u02 − 2αr 2 , where u0 is the velocity at the flow axis. Therefore, in contrast to the Rankine vortex, where the axial velocity may only be constant, this class of flows allows non-uniform radial distribution of the axial velocity component. 3.3.4 One-dimensional (columnar) helical vortices Elementary helical vortex structures (an infinitely thin vortex filament and a vortex sheet consisting of helical vortex filaments) were described formerly. However, real vortices have a finite sized core. We commence the consideration of this class of helical vortices with the simplest case of axisymmetrical or columnar vortices. In contrast to the Rankine vortex, consisting of uniformly distributed rectilinear vortex filaments (or point vortices in a circle), we consider the axisymmetrical helical vortex made by superposition of helical vortex filaments (Fig. 3.14) (Kuibin and Okulov 1996). If the distribution of filament intensities within a cylindrical hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
138
3 Models of vortex structures
Fig. 3.14. Schemes of the axisymmetrical helical vortex
region is known, the problem of the velocity field is reduced to the integration of statement (2.56) or (2.69). However, the problem can be solved without the application of results from Section 2.6. Analysis of equations (Section 1.5) determining the flow demonstrates that the condition of axial symmetry allows rigorous development of the general model of axisymmetrical helical vortices, since ∂/∂χ ≡ 0, ur ≡ 0. Hence, the Helmholtz equation (1.71) is true for any distribution of a vertical vorticity component by r. From (1.68) we have
∂ ( ruθ ) = rωz . ∂r
(3.60)
Integrating (3.60) with respect to r, we get r
1 ωz (r ′)r ′dr ′. uθ = r
∫
(3.61)
0
Since the axial velocity component stays connected with uθ by relationship (1.66), we have, correspondingly r
uz = u0 −
1 ωz ( r ′ ) r ′dr ′. l
∫
(3.62)
0
The condition of axial symmetry, significantly simplifies the problem of pressure calculation from the Euler equation. Actually, one of two equations of system (1.64), which includes the pressure, is satisfied identically, and the second equation is reduced to
3.3 Columnar vortices in ideal fluid
139
1 2 1 ∂p uθ = , r ρ ∂r then, r
∫
p = p0 + ρ uθ2 0
dr ′ , r′
(3.63)
where p0 is the pressure at the tube axis. It is obvious from (3.63) that the axial velocity component does not affect the pressure in the swirling axisymmetrical flow, induced by the distribution of helical vortex filaments. Later, this important feature will be used for evaluation of vortex parameters through distribution of the bottom pressure (see Chapter 7). For more convenient description, we introduce the dimensionless function r
2π Φ (r ) = ωz (r ′)r ′dr ′. Γ
∫
(3.64)
0
At that, in accordance with (3.61) and (3.62), the velocity components are expressed via function Φ(r)
uθ =
Γ Γ Φ ( r ) , uz = u0 − Φ (r ). 2πr 2πl
(3.65)
We also introduce a dimensionless vorticity and pressure drop ωz =
8π2 ε 2 p − p0 πε 2 , ωz , ∆p = Γ ρ Γ2
(3.66)
where ε is the typical size of the vortex. Let us consider three important examples of the simplest vorticity distributions (Table 3.1): uniform distribution within the core of radius ε (model I); fractional-power distribution (model II) and Gaussian distribution (model III). Like the distributions of pressure in the above examples, the profiles of circumferential velocity coincide with those for the vortices of Rankine (model I), Scully (1975) (model II) and Lamb (see (Hopfinger and van Heijst 1993), model III), correspondingly. Simultaneously, the vorticity vector has a non-zero circumferential component and, thus, we get the axial velocity profile, which is non-uniform over the radius. We should note that the difference uz – u0 is inversely proportional to the pitch of helical symmetry.
140
3 Models of vortex structures
Table 3.1. Models of axisymmetrical vortices Model
ωz
I
∆p
ε
ε
⎧1, r < ε ⎨ ⎩0, r ≥ ε Φ (r )
II
⎧⎪r 2 ε 2 , r < ε ⎨ r≥ε ⎪⎩ 1,
⎧⎪ r 2 ε 2 , r<ε ⎨ 2 2 ⎪⎩2 − ε r , r ≥ ε
ε
⎛ r2 ⎜⎜1 + 2 ⎝ ε r2 r +ε 2
III
2
r2 r 2 + ε2
⎞ ⎟⎟ ⎠
−2
⎛ r2 exp ⎜⎜ − 2 ⎝ ε
⎞ ⎟⎟ ⎠
⎛ r2 1 − exp ⎜⎜ − 2 ⎝ ε
⎞ ⎟⎟ ⎠
⎛ r2 ε2 ⎡ 2 log 2 − 2 ⎢1 − exp ⎜⎜ − 2 r ⎢⎣ ⎝ ε
2
⎞⎤ ⎟⎟ ⎥ + ⎠ ⎥⎦ 2 2 ⎛ r ⎞ ⎛ r ⎞ +2 Ei ⎜⎜ − 2 ⎟⎟ − 2 Ei ⎜⎜ −2 2 ⎟⎟ ⎝ ε ⎠ ⎝ ε ⎠
We consider the uniform vorticity distribution over the annular crosssection b1 ≤ r ≤ b2 as a generalization of model I
r < b, ⎧ 0, ⎪ 2 2 ⎧0, r < b1 , r > b2 Γ ⎪ r − b1 , Φ = r , b1 ≤ r ≤ b2 , (3.67) ωz = ( ) ⎨ ⎨ 2 2 π(b22 − b12 ) ⎩1, b1 ≤ r ≤ b2 ⎪ b2 − b1 ⎪ 1, r > b2 . ⎩ Such “hollow” vortices may be formed by near-wall swirling of the flow, and they will be used for construction of more complex models of vortices (see Section 7.3.2). The pressure field for the helical vortex with ringshaped vorticity distribution takes the form
3.3 Columnar vortices in ideal fluid
0, r < b1 , ⎧ ⎪ 4 4 ⎛ r − b1 1 r ⎞ 2 ⎪ 4 log b − ⎜ ⎟⎟ , b1 ≤ r ≤ b2 , 1 2 ⎪ 2 2 2 ⎜ ρΓ ⎪ b r b b − 1 ⎠ 2 1 ⎝ p = p0 − 2 ⎨ 8π ⎪ 4b12 b ⎪ − 1 + 2 − log 2 , r > b2 . 2 2 2 2 ⎪ b1 2 2 r b2 − b1 − b b 2 1 ⎪⎩
(
)
(
141
(3.68)
)
At b1 = 0 and b2 ≡ ε, the model described by Eqs. (3.67), (3.68), coincides with model I. Profile families of tangential and axial velocity components calculated by Eqs. (3.65) are shown in Fig. 3.15 together with function Φ(r) from (3.67). In contrast to the Rankine vortex, this model admits a great variety of axial velocity distributions depending on the values and signs of the helical pitch l and the velocity at axis u0. In the extreme case, l → 0, Γ → 0, Γ/l = const, (b2 − b1) → 0 the ring vortex degenerates into the vortex sheet localized on the cylindrical surface r = b2 = b1, with a uniform axial flow inside (see Section 3.1). In contrast to models (3.67), (3.68) and model I, in real flows the distributions of vorticity and velocity demonstrate a smooth behavior. The profile of tangential velocity in model II corresponds to a special case of generalized empirical profile used by Shtym (1985) for the vortex chambers. The pressure in this model does not depend on l and it is linearly connected with the axial velocity
p = p0 + ρ
Γ 4πε 2
( u0 − uz ) .
Apparently, model II is more convenient for the description of turbulent vortices (Murakhtina and Okulov 2000). At the same time, it is more natural to assume a Gaussian vorticity distribution for the laminar vortices. It is known that in a viscous fluid the vorticity concentrated in a rectilinear vortex filament (see Section 2.3.2) diffuses in time as follows ω (r, t ) =
⎛ r2 ⎞ Γ exp ⎜ − ⎟⎟ . ⎜ 4πνt ⎝ 4ν t ⎠
(3.69)
For a steady axisymmetrical swirling flow in a cylindrical channel, the vortex size will increase the downward flow, and it can be assumed for some region of the channel that this vortex has a core of a constant size ε (see Table 3.1, model III). The velocity field corresponding to this model is written as
142
3 Models of vortex structures
Fig. 3.15. The family of profiles of tangential uθ and axial uz velocity components of the columnar vortex. Helical pitch l and velocity at axis u0 are the parameters of the flow
3.3 Columnar vortices in ideal fluid
uθ =
(
)
Γ ⎡ 1 − exp −r 2 / ε 2 ⎤ , ⎦ 2πr ⎣
uz = u0 −
(
)
Γ ⎡ 1 − exp −r 2 / ε 2 ⎤ ⎦ 2πl ⎣
143
(3.70)
or uθ =
⎛ ⎛ Γ ⎡ Γ ⎡ r 2 ⎞⎤ r 2 ⎞⎤ ⎢1 − exp ⎜⎜ −1.256 2 ⎟⎟ ⎥ . ⎢1 − exp ⎜⎜ −1.256 2 ⎟⎟ ⎥ , uz = u0 − 2πl ⎢⎣ 2πr ⎢⎣ rm ⎠ ⎥⎦ rm ⎠ ⎥⎦ ⎝ ⎝
Here, the radius of the maximum tangential velocity is introduced instead of scale ε rm = 1.256 ε . The pressure distribution in model III is expressed via the integral exponent
Ei ( − x ) =
−x
∫ exp ( −x )
x dx.
−∞
At a large argument (small ε), function Ei(− x) decreases as exp(− x)/x. As a result, the relationship for the pressure at a distance r > ε simplifies significantly. In the paper by Bühler (1988) the formula for pressure was derived in a different form (Ei was expanded into a series). Models I, II, and III are compared in Fig. 3.16 by two different methods. In all cases, the parameters are as follows: u0 = 0 and l = –1. The values of ε were chosen due to the demand, that radius rm – maximum of tangential velocity profile is the same for all three models (ε = 1 – for models I, II and ε = 1/1.12 – for model III). The first comparison in Fig. 3.16 is made for the vortices with the same circulation Γ = 2π. As a result, we can conclude that the solutions corresponding to models I and III are the closest. However, model I is simpler and more illustrative because the size of the vortex core can be easily determined by the break in the velocity profile. Therefore, model I will be used for the following analysis. A significant distinction (especially for the pressures) of models I and III from model II is explained by the fact that the vorticity in the last vortex is less concentrated. In our opinion, if it is assigned that for all vortices pressure differences ∆p at the vortex axis and its periphery (r → ∞) are the same, the comparison will be more correct. But vortex circulations will differ:
Γ1 = 2π, Γ 2 = 2π 2, Γ3 = 2π
1.256 log2 .
In this case, profiles of vorticity and velocity for all three solutions become more agreeable with each other, especially the profiles of pressure (Fig. 3.16b). Comparison of all calculated pressure profiles at the maximumpoint of tangential velocity rm provides the important information. For vortices I and II, this maximum point coincides with point r0.5, where the pres-
144
3 Models of vortex structures b
ωz
ωz
2
2
1
1
0 uθ
0 uθ
0.5
0.5
0.0 uz
0.0 uz
1.0
1.0
0.5
0.5
0.0 ∆ p/ρ
0.0 ∆ p/ρ
0.5
0.5
0.0
0
1
2
3
r
0.0
0
1
2
3
r
Fig. . Comparison of radial distributions of the axial vorticity component ωz, tangential uθ and axial uz velocity components and pressure ∆p/ρ for different models ( – I, – II, – III) of a columnar vortex (see Table 3.1). Comparison conditions: – equal circulations ; b – the difference between the values of static pressure in the vortex center and at its periphery are the same
sure is half of the total pressure difference at the vortex axis and the periphery (half of the total drop). This fact follows directly from the analysis of corresponding formulae for the pressure. While analyzing the pressure distribution, we should note that even here points rm and r0.5 almost coincide. This means that the vortex radius can be determined using the point, where the pressure equals half of the total pressure drop.
3.3 Columnar vortices in ideal fluid
145
3.3.5 Q-vortex To describe a flow before and after vortex breakdown, empirical formulae are usually used (Leibovich 1978, 1984)
uθ =
(
(
))
(
K 1 − exp −αr 2 , r
uz = W1 + W2 exp −αr
2
) =W +W 1
2
(
(
− W2 1 − exp −αr
2
)),
(3.71)
where K, W1, W2, α are constants determined empirically. Distribution of tangential velocity in (3.71) exactly corresponds to the Burgers vortex (Burgers 1940), the velocity field of which satisfies the Navier-Stokes equations (see Section 3.4.1). However, for the axial velocity component in (3.71) and, respectively, in the experiment, there are significant differences from Burgers solution. In Burgers vortex, the axial velocity is the function of coordinate z only, whereas in (3.71) uz does not depend on z, but changes considerably along the radial coordinate. The velocity field in the form of (3.71) was first studied against instability in the paper by Lessen et al. (1974), and it was derived from the self-similar solution of Batchelor (1964) for a swirling wake with neglect for some small terms. We should note that profiles (3.71) describe the experiment with great accuracy, and they are widely used for the processing of data on swirling flows (Faler and Leibovich 1977; Escudier 1988; Alekseenko and Shtork 1992). Considering this fact, the above formulae are widely applied for theoretical analysis of swirling flow stability. Indeed, for these purposes a simpler one-parametric model is used
uθ =
(
( ))
( )
q 1 − exp −r 2 , uz = exp −r 2 , r
(3.72)
which is called the Q-vortex. However, it is important that in the structure, the solution (3.70) obtained previously exactly coincides with the empirical formulae (3.71). The direct comparison of the exact solution of (3.70) and the empirical formulae (3.71) gives
Γ = 2πK,
l = K/W2 ,
u0 = W1 + W2
and ε = 1
α,
and this both specifies the physical sense of empirical constants and identifies a large class of swirling flows, described by (3.71), as flows induced by the columnar helical vortices with Gaussian distribution of vorticity in the core. Correspondingly, for Q - vortex
146
3 Models of vortex structures
Γ = 2πq,
l = q,
u0 = 1,
which significantly constricts the considered class of flows. Therefore, profiles (3.71), (3.72) are the solution to the equations of ideal fluid motion, which satisfactorily describe the experimental data. 3.3.6 Helical vortex with a finite-sized core For theoretical description of rotating helical vortices, the solution derived in Section 2.6 is of little use because the self-induced velocity of the infinitely thin filament equals infinity. In a real fluid, the vortex core always has a finite size. According to this, we elaborate the model of the vortex with a core in the shape of a helical rope of a round cross-section ε in the plane normal to the vortex axis (Fig. 3.17). Let us consider the simplest distribution of vorticity, satisfying Helmholtz equation (1.71): ωz = const inside the core. The velocity field induced by this vortex can be easily presented via solution of (2.56) or (2.69), if the core is considered a superposition of infinitely thin vortex filaments, spread uniformly over the core. Note that the module of vorticity ω is not a constant, since vortex filaments in such a vortex are twisted, and the angle of the vorticity vector inclination changes over the vortex cross-section. Indeed, according to geometrical plotting
ωz = ω cos α = ωl / l 2 + r ′2 . Here r′ is the radial coordinate of the vortex filament; α is the angle between ω and axis z (Fig. 3.17). It is clear that at ωz = const and l = const the value of ω increases with distance r′.
Fig. 3.17. The model of a helical vortex with a finite-sized core. The local coordinate system (σ, ϕ) is shown on the right
3.3 Columnar vortices in ideal fluid
147
Now we consider the solution to (2.69) for an infinitely thin helical vortex filament with circulation in the form of u = F, where F is the function of filament geometry only. Turning to continuous distribution of vortex filaments, for a thin vortex tube we can write the following differential relationship
duε = Fd , where F is the same function as for an infinitely thin vortex filament, d is the circulation of a distinguished vortex tube with a cross-section dSn, index ε represents the solution for a vortex with the core radius ε. It is more convenient to calculate the solution using the horizontal cross-section (z = 0) of the vortex tube with the area Sz. From the Stokes equation we have
d
= ω · n dS = ωz dSz.
Thus, it follows that: = ωz Sz. We should stress that here is the circulation for a helical vortex with a finite-sized core. In the same time ωz dSz = ω dSn , and taking into account the connection between ωz and ω, we obtain
dSz = dSn l 2 + r ′2 l
or
Sz =
∫
Sn
l 2 + r ′2 dSn . l
Using the last formula, we can determine the area of the helical vortex cross-section in the plane z = 0. Considering all these relationships, we obtain the equation for the velocity induced by the helical vortex with a core of finite-sized radius
∫
∫
uε (r , θ, z) = FdΓ = ωz FdSz =
=
1 lSz
Γ FdSz = Sz
∫
(3.73)
ε 2π
∫∫
l 2 + r ′2 F (r , θ, z; r ′, θ′, z′)σ dσ dϕ .
0 0
It is also considered here that dSn = σ dσ dϕ. Integration is performed over a circumference of radius ε with the center at point r′ = a, θ′ = θ0, z′ = 0. The local polar coordinates σ, ϕ with the center at point (a, θ0, 0) are connected with coordinates of the basic cylindrical system r′, θ′, z′ by relationships
148
3 Models of vortex structures
⎧r ′ cos(θ′ − θ0 ) = a + σ cos ϕ , ⎪ ⎨r ′ sin(θ′ − θ0 ) = σ sin ϕ cos α , ⎪ z′ = −σ sin ϕ sin α , ⎩ where α is the angle between the vortex axis and axis Oz (tan α = a/l). This model differs from the conventional one described in the literature, which deals with the theoretical description of helical vortices, where uniform distribution of the vorticity module over the core cross-section is assumed (Widnall et al. 1971; Moore and Saffman 1972). However, this distribution of vorticity does not satisfy Helmholtz equation. Actually, if we substitute the following relationship ωz = ωl
r 2 + l2 ,
into the left side of (1.71), where ω = const, we obtain
dωz l l ∂ω ∂ ⎛ = + ur ω ⎜ ⎜ 2 2 2 dt ∂r ⎝ r + l 2 r + l ∂t
⎞ ⎟⎟ , ⎠
r − a ≤ ε.
(3.74)
In general, the right side of (3.74) is not zero. Helmholtz equation is accurately satisfied only in some particular cases, for instance, for the considered axisymmetrical helical vortex, when ur = 0 and ω does not depend on time. For an arbitrary helical vortex, the model (3.73) is the approximate one. The smallness of the right side of (3.74) is the required condition for application of this model. Particularly, this is possible for weakly curved vortices (a l). In approximation of thin vortex filaments, component ωz changes insignificantly over the core cross-section, and it can be considered almost constant, then the right side of (3.74) is also small.
Fig. 3.18. On the determination of function F(r) in (3.76). The tube and core cross-sections in a horizontal plane ( ) and the plane normal to the vortex axis (b)
3.4 Viscous models of vortices
149
The simpler form of the approximate model (3.73) is obtained for characteristics, averaged over the angular coordinate θ, uε =
1 2π
2π
∫ uε dθ.
(3.75)
0
Let us substitute (3.75) into (3.73) and change the order of integration. Considering that the integrals from series entering into solution (2.69) for u, are equal to zero, we can reduce the problem of average velocity determination to the calculation of a single function F(r)
urε ≡ 0,
Γ Γ F (r ), uzε = u0 − F (r ) , 2πr 2πl 1 ⎧0, r < r ′⎫ F (r ) = ⎨ ⎬ dS . Sz ⎩1, r ≥ r ′ ⎭ uϕε =
∫
(3.76)
Sz
The integral in (3.76) equals the intersection area of the circle of radius r with cross-section Sz. The ratio of areas in (3.76) does not change, if both figures are projected on the plane normal to the helical axis of the vortex (Fig. 3.18). Therefore, we find that F(r) = S(0)/πε2, where S(0) is the intersection area of the circle σ = ε with the ellipse prescribed by the formula .
(a + σ cos θ)2/l2 + (σ sin θ)2/(a2 + l2) = r2/l2. Equation (3.73) represents a formal notation of the velocity induced by the helical vortex with a core of round cross-section. Fukumoto and Okulov (2005) elaborated a more rigorous approach for searching the solution for the velocity field induced by a helical vortex with an arbitrary vorticity distribution in a core of finite but small size.
3.4 Viscous models of vortices 3.4.1 Burgers vortex Taking into account viscosity enables us to smooth out peculiarities which appear in the vicinity of the vortex core in the models of both an infinitely thin vortex filament and a Rankine vortex. Such a solution for steady-state conditions was considered in Section 2.3.2 as an example of the viscous diffusion of vorticity. To compare time dependent profiles of vorticity (2.31) and velocity (2.32) with the experimental data we must introduce a
150
3 Models of vortex structures
certain scale a = 2 νt , which is a linear measure of the vortex at a point in time t. Then we obtain the following correlations Γ exp ( − r 2 a 2 ) , π a2
(3.77)
Γ ⎡1 − exp ( − r 2 a 2 )⎤ , ⎦ 2πr ⎣
(3.78)
ω=
v=
describing the so called Lamb vortex (see Saffman and Baker (1979); Hopfinger and van Heijst (1993)). By their structure the formulae (3.77) and (3.78) coincide with the vorticity distribution and azimuthal velocity for a three-dimensional steady-state Burgers vortex, which was pioneered by Burgers (1940, 1948) and Rott (1958) for the description of turbulent swirl flows. Burgers vortex pertains to the class of axisymmetric exact solutions of the Navier-Stokes equations expressed in form
ur = u(r), uθ = v(r), uz = w(r) = zf(r),
(3.79)
where u, v, w are the radial, azimuthal and axial velocity components, respectively. Donaldson and Sullivan (1960) described a family of solutions similar to (3.79). It was assumed that the flow was formed within an infinitely long rotating porous tube with the proper boundary conditions at the wall. A solution to the Navier-Stokes equations in form of (3.79) was also found by Sullivan (1959), but within boundless space. Assigning velocity circulation and an additional constant at the infinity, he obtained the solution in the form of a two-cell vortex (see Section 3.4.2). In particular, Burgers vortex follows on from this solution. To find the solution for Burgers vortex let us consider the special case of (3.79)
u = u(r), v = v(r), w = αz, α = const,
(3.80)
and rewrite the Navier-Stokes equations and the equation of continuity (1.35) in cylindrical coordinates taking into account (3.80)
u
∂u v2 ∂ ⎛1 ∂ 1 ∂p ⎞ − =− +ν ⎜ (ru) ⎟ , ∂r r ρ ∂r ∂r ⎝ r ∂r ⎠
(3.81)
∂v ∂ ⎛1 ∂ ⎞ uv =ν (rv) ⎟ − , ⎜ ∂r ∂r ⎝ r ∂r ⎠ r
(3.82)
u
3.4 Viscous models of vortices
w
∂w 1 ∂p , =− ∂z ρ ∂z
151
(3.83)
∂w 1 ∂ (ru) + = 0. r ∂r ∂z
(3.84)
The relationship for radial velocity can be obtained simply from the equation of continuity (3.84)
u = − αr/2.
(3.85)
Then (3.82) yields the equation for the azimuthal component
−
α ⎡1 ⎤′ (vr )′ = ν ⎢ (rv)′⎥ , 2 ⎣r ⎦
where prime means r derivative. Integration under the boundary condition v = 0 at r → ∞ gives v = c1[1 − exp(−αr2/4ν)]/r. Integration constant c1 can be found by assigning circulation Γ at the infinity:
Γ = 2πrv|r → ∞ = c1 2π. As a result we derive the following expression for v:
v=
⎛ αr 2 ⎞ ⎤ Γ ⎡ ⎢1 − exp ⎜ − ⎟⎥, 2πr ⎣ ⎝ 4ν ⎠ ⎦
Γ = Γ r =∞ .
(3.86)
The velocity profile has just one local maximum vm, determined by the condition v′ = 0 or 1 + 2ϕ = eϕ, where ϕ = αr2/4ν. The solution of this transcendental equation is ϕ = 1.2565… , from which
rm = 2.242
vm = 0.16
ν . α
Γ α 0.36 Γ . = π ν π rm
(3.87)
(3.88)
Quantity rm is usually interpreted as the effective vortex radius. Using extreme values, the profile of azimuthal velocity can be expressed in the convenient dimensionless form
152
3 Models of vortex structures
Fig. 3.19. Azimuthal velocity profiles in Rankine and Burgers vortex models
⎛ 1.39 ⎡ v r 2 ⎞⎤ = ⎢1 − exp ⎜ −1.26 2 ⎟ ⎥ . vm (r / rm ) ⎣ rm ⎠ ⎦ ⎝
(3.89)
Let us consider asymptotic expressions (3.86). At r → 0
v=
Γ αr 2 Γα Γ r (1 − 1 + , r = 1.26 + ...) ≈ 2πr 4ν 8πν 2π rm2
i.e., near the axis we have rigid-body rotation. In addition, if we assign α2 = rm2 /1.26, the velocity profile will concur with distribution (3.50) for a Rankine vortex. At r → ∞ we have asymptote v = Γ/2πr which conforms both to a Rankine vortex and a singular vortex of the same intensity Γ. Comparison of azimuthal velocity for Burgers and Rankine models under the conditions Γ = Γ|r = ∞ = idem and a = rm is presented in Fig. 3.19. Now let us determine the pressure from the remaining two equations. Equation (3.83) takes the form of α2z = −(1/ρ)∂p/∂z, from which p = −ρα2z2/2 + ρc(r). Substituting this expression in (3.81) we obtain the desired equation for c(r): c′( r) = −α2r/4 +v2/r. Integrating and substituting c(r) into the expression for p, we derive the calculation formula r 2 ⎛ r2 ⎞ v 1 p = p0 − ρα 2 ⎜ z 2 + ⎟ + ρ ∫ dr , r 2 4⎠ ⎝ 0
(3.90)
involving an integral which can be computed using numerical methods. The existence of a steady solution for viscous fluid is accounted for by the circumstance that viscous vorticity diffusion is compensated by the radial transfer of vorticity due to axial straining of the vortex (because w = αz).
3.4 Viscous models of vortices
153
3.4.2 Sullivan vortex Sullivan (1959) obtained an exact solution to the Navier-Stokes equation in the form of a steady two-cell vortex. This solution was discovered in the form of (3.79) and written as
⎛ αr 2 ⎞ ⎤ α r 6ν ⎡ + ⎢1 − exp ⎜ − ⎟⎥ , 2 r ⎣ ⎝ 4ν ⎠ ⎦ ⎤ Γ ⎡ ⎛ αr 2 ⎞ v= ⎢H ⎜ ⎟ H (∞ ) ⎥ , 2πr ⎣ ⎝ 4ν ⎠ ⎦ 2 ⎡ ⎛ αr ⎞ ⎤ w = αz ⎢1 − 3exp ⎜ − ⎟⎥ , ⎝ 4ν ⎠ ⎦ ⎣
u=−
α 2r 2 ν2 1 ⎧⎪ + 36 2 p = p0 − ρ ⎨α 2 z 2 + 2 ⎪ 4 r ⎩
⎡ ⎛ αr 2 ⎞ ⎤ − 1 exp ⎢ ⎜− ⎟⎥ ⎝ 4ν ⎠ ⎦ ⎣
(3.91) 2
r 2 ⎫⎪ v + ρ ⎬ ∫ dr , r 0 ⎪⎭
x t ⎪⎧ ⎪⎫ H ( x ) = ∫ exp ⎨−t + 3∫ [1 − exp(− s )]s −1ds ⎬ dt. 0 0 ⎩⎪ ⎭⎪
Here Γ is the circulation at the infinity; α is the constant; p0 is the pressure at point r = 0; z = 0; ν is the kinematic viscosity. As an example, various velocity profiles are illustrated in Fig. 3.20. When r → ∞ the Sullivan vortex exactly coincides with the Burgers vortex. Bellamy-Knights (1970) generalized the Sullivan solution for a timedependent situation. As a result he obtained a solution, describing the timedependent breakdown of a two-cell vortex. Earlier, Rott (1958) studied an unsteady one-cell vortex solution.
Fig. 3.20. Velocity distribution in the Sullivan vortex. α = 0.001, ν = 0.01, z = 1
4 Stability and waves on columnar vortices
4.1 Types of perturbations Numerous observations confirm that many kinds of swirling flows (either bounded or free) exhibit instability. This instability leads to the formation of secondary vortical motions, linear or nonlinear waves, and may cause the vortex breakdown. However, different kinds of perturbations (for example, neutral (inertial) waves) can be observed even for stable flows. This Chapter focuses on columnar vortices only. The key aim is to identify the criteria for vortex instability and describe the waves on vortices. The characteristic feature of these disturbances is a 3-D structure, which usually exhibit as spiral or helical forms (Fig. 4.1). Before we begin the theoretical analysis of the instability problem, let us consider the main types of axisymmetrical and non-axisymmetrical perturbations of a columnar vortex (for other types of disturbances, like those on vortex rings, see the review by Kop’ev and Chernyshev (2000)). For clarity, we will consider a vortex with a distinguished core of radius r = R that has a discontinuity in the velocity profile (or velocity derivative) on its boundary. For the most general presentation, the core boundary affected by a linear monochromatic disturbance is described by the formula r = R + aRe ei(kz + mϕ − ωt), where amplitude a
R;
(4.1)
Re is the real part; k is the axial wave number;
m is an integer (the azimuthal wave number); ϕ is the azimuthal angle (Fig. 4.2); ω is the frequency. For analysis of disturbed core shape, we may consider the case when k is real and t = 0. Then we obtain r = R + a cos (kz + mϕ).
(4.2)
The main types of perturbations given by Eq. (4.2) are shown in Fig. 4.2. The case of m = 0 corresponds to the axisymmetrical mode. The wavelength is 2π/k. The cross-sections z = const are concentric circles with a radius from (R − a) to (R + a).
156
4 Stability and waves on columnar vortices a
b
Fig. 4.1. Spiral perturbations in a swirling flow: a – spiral breakdown of a vortex after a diaphragm in a vortex chamber (Alekseenko and Shtork 1992*); b – spiral disturbance of a flow axis in a container with a rotating bottom (Hourigan et al. 1995*)
Fig. 4.2. Types of perturbations for a core of columnar vortex: 1 – core boundary; 2 – lines of fixed phase kz + mϕ = const
4.2 Intsability of a vortex sheet
157
For m ≠ 0 we obtain non-axisymmetrical modes. The modes with m = ±1 are usually called bending modes. The core cross-section z = const is a circle of radius R, shifted by distance a along the radius r at the angle ϕ = −kz/m. The mode m = +1 takes the form of a left-handed helix, and m = −1 of a right-handed one. The helix pitch equals 2π/k, the same as the wavelength for an axisymmetrical disturbance with m = 0. Fig. 4.2 shows the isolines {r = const, kz + mϕ = const} in the form of helical lines with the pitch of 2π/k|m|. We also plotted the isolines of constant velocity – isotaches with a more complex shape. For |m| = 2 the circular shape of the core cross-section transforms into an ellipse. For all the cases with |m| ≥ 2, the vortex axis (due to symmetry in disturbance) remains undisturbed. If the amplitude of disturbance is not small, we cannot use the simple canonic form. For the limiting case of an infinitely thin vortex filament, the disturbed state can be described by one of the canonic curves – a helical line r = const,
kz + mϕ = const,
as described in detail in Section 2.1.
4.2 Intsability of a vortex sheet It follows from Eq. (3.6) that a tangential discontinuity produces a vortex sheet. Several basic vortex models have a tangential discontinuity. Before we begin to study the problem of columnar vortex stability, we have to pay attention to a vortex sheet; the stability of this object can be of special interest (Batchelor 1967; Saffman 1992). Helmholtz was the first to demonstrate vortex sheet instability in response to small disturbances (Helmholtz 1868). We will consider the simplest case of a plain vortex layer formed by two uniform fluid flows of the same density moving in opposite directions with the velocity of 0.5U (Fig. 4.3). In the general case of 3-D disturbances, the deviation of this vortex layer from its undisturbed state is y = η(x, z, t). Since vorticity is concentrated only in a vortex sheet, the flow in the rest of the space remains potential and it is described by the Laplace equation with potentials
158
4 Stability and waves on columnar vortices
Fig. 4.3. Diagram for vortex sheet disturbance. The vorticity vector is directed normally towards the reader