THE WATER IS WIDE
PAT CONROY
Copyright The Water is Wide Copyright © 1972 by Pat Conroy Cover art and eForeword to the electronic edition copyright © 2000 by RosettaBooks, LLC All rights reserved. No part of this book may be used or reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical articles and reviews. For information address
[email protected] First electronic edition published 2000 by RosettaBooks LLC, New York. ISBN 0-7953-0072-7
The Water is Wide
2
Contents eForeword Chapter
1
Chapter
2
Chapter
3
Chapter
4
Chapter
5
Chapter
6
Chapter
7
Chapter
8
Chapter
9
Chapter
10
Chapter
11
Chapter
12
Acknowledgement
The Water is Wide
3
eForeword The South that is real to the novelist Pat Conroy is a lush and seductive place, but one that is haunted by violence, ignorance and oppression. The first of his books, The Water Is Wide (1972), is an account his personal experience as an idealistic young man trying to do the right thing in a forgotten corner of the South that is both beautiful and sad. Having failed to secure a place in the Peace Corps, Conroy is left having to accept an unlikely teaching job—on remote Yamacraw Island, just off the South Carolina coast, a place lost in time to all but the small, poor African-American community that lives and works there. The people’s livelihood is threatened by the pollution of the modern world, and their own poverty and illiteracy seems to doom them. “Conrack,” as the children come to call him, risks everything to change their lives. The Water Is Wide was the first success Pat Conroy (b. 1945) enjoyed, and the first of his books that would draw on his own life and experience. His desire to write about his unusual experience as a teacher launched a remarkable career that has since taken him into the realm of fiction, in search of the ultimate truth about the world that he knows. At the heart of all Conroy’s work, though, is the mesmerizing gift of a great storyteller, a quality that was immediately evident when The Water Is Wide was published. “A hell of a good story,” The New York Times called it, and Newsweek described it as “miraculous ... an experience of joy.” RosettaBooks is the leading publisher dedicated exclusively to electronic editions of great works of fiction and non-fiction that reflect our world. RosettaBooks is a committed e-publisher, maximizing the resources of the World Wide Web in opening a fresh dimension in the reading experience. In this electronic environment for reading, each RosettaBook will enhance the experience through The RosettaBooks Connection. This gateway instantly delivers to the reader the opportu-
The Water is Wide
4
nity to learn more about the title, the author, the content and the context of each work, using the full resources of the Web. To experience The RosettaBooks Connection for The Water Is Wide, go to:
Rosettabooks.com/TheWaterIsWide Other Conroy titles available from RosettaBooks include The Prince of Tides, The Great Santini and The Lords of Discipline.
This book is dedicated to my wife, Barbara Bolling Conroy
The water is wide, I cannot get o’er, Neither have I wings to fly. Get me a boat that can carry two, And both shall cross, My true love and I. -British folk song The river is deep, the river is wide, Milk and honey on the other side. -“Michael, Row the Boat Ashore”
The Water is Wide
7
Chapter 1 The southern school superintendent is a kind of remote deity who breathes the purer air of Mount Parnassus. The teachers see him only on those august occasions when they need to be reminded of the nobility of their calling. The powers of a superintendent are considerable. He hires and fires, manipulates the board of education, handles a staggering amount of money, and maintains the precarious existence of the status quo. Beaufort, South Carolina’s superintendent Dr. Henry Piedmont, had been in Beaufort for only a year when I went to see him. He had a reputation of being tough, capable, and honest. A friend told me that Piedmont took crap from no man. I walked into his office, introduced myself, chatted briefly, then told him I wanted to teach on Yamacraw Island. He gave me a hard stare and said, “Son, you are a godsend.” I sat in the chair rigidly analyzing my new status. “I have prayed at night,” he continued, “for an answer to the problems confronting Yamacraw Island. I have worried myself almost sick. And to think you would walk right into my office and offer to teach those poor colored children on that island. It just goes to show you that God works in mysterious ways.” “I don’t know if God had anything to do with it, Doctor. I applied for the Peace Corps and haven’t heard. Yamacraw seemed like a viable alternative.” “Son, you can do more good at Yamacraw than you could ever do in the Peace Corps. And you would be helping Americans, Pat. And I, for one, think it’s very important to help Americans.” “So do I, Doctor.” We chatted on about the problems of the island. Then he said, “You mentioned that God had nothing to do with your decision to go to Yamacraw, Pat. You remind me of myself when I was your age. Of
The Water is Wide
8
course, I came up the hard way. My folks worked in a mill. Good people, both of them. Simple people, but God-fearing. My mother was a saint. A saint on earth. I worked in the mill, too. Even after I graduated from college, I went back to the mill in a supervisory capacity. But I wasn’t happy, Pat. Something was missing. One night I was working late at the mill. I stepped outside the mill and looked up at the stars. I went toward the edge of the forest and fell to my knees. I prayed to Jesus and asked him what he wanted me to do in my life. And do you know what?” “No, sir, what?” Then Dr. Piedmont leaned forward in his seat, his eyes transformed with spiritual intensity. “He told me what to do that very night. He told me, ‘Henry, leave the mill. Go into education and help boys to go to college. Help them to be something. Go back to school, Henry, and get an advanced degree.’ So I went to Columbia University, one of the great universities of the world. I emerged with a doctorate. I was the first boy from my town who was ever called Doctor.” I added wittily, “That’s nice, Doctor.” “You remind me of that boy I was, Pat. Do you know why you came to me today?” “Yes, sir, I want to teach at Yamacraw.” “No, son. Do you know the real reason?’ “No, sir, I guess I don’t.” “Jesus,’ he said, as if he just found out the stone had been rolled back from the tomb. “You’re too young to realize it now, but Jesus made you come to me today.” I left his office soon afterward. He had been impressive. He was a powerful figure, very controlled, almost arrogantly confident in his abilities. He stared at me during our entire conversation. From experience I knew his breed. The mill-town kid who scratched his way to the top. Horatio Alger, who knew how to floor a man with a quick chop to the gonads. He was a product of the upcountry of South Carolina, the Bible Belt, sand-lot baseball, knife fights under the bleachers. His pride in his doctorate was almost religious. It was the badge that told the world that he was no longer a common man. Intellectually, he was a thoroughbred. Financially, he was secure. And
The Water is Wide
9
Jesus was his backer. Jesus, with the grits-and-gravy voice, the shortstop on the mill team, liked ol’ Henry Piedmont.
Yamacraw is an island off the South Carolina mainland not far from Savannah, Georgia. The island is fringed with the green, undulating marshes of the southern coast; shrimp boats ply the waters around her and fishermen cast their lines along her bountiful shores. Deer cut through her forests in small silent herds. The great southern oaks stand broodingly on her banks. The island and the waters around her teem with life. There is something eternal and indestructible about the tide-eroded shores and the dark, threatening silences of the swamps in the heart of the island. Yamacraw is beautiful because man has not yet had time to destroy this beauty. The twentieth century has basically ignored the presence of Yamacraw. The island is populated with black people who depend on the sea and their small farms for a living. Several white families live on the island in a paternalistic, but in many ways symbiotic, relationship with their neighbors. Only one white family actively participates in island life to any perceptible degree. The other three couples have come to the island to enjoy their retirement in the obscurity of the island’s remotest corners. Thus far, no bridge connects the island with the mainland, and anyone who sets foot on the island comes by water. The roads of the island are unpaved and rutted by the passage of ox carts, still a major form of transportation. The hand pump serves up questionable water to the black residents who live in their small familiar houses. Sears, Roebuck catalogues perform their classic function in the crudely built privies, which sit, half-hidden, in the tall grasses behind the shacks. Electricity came to the island several years ago. There is something unquestionably moving about the line of utility poles coming across the marsh, moving perhaps because electricity is a bringer of miracles and the journey of the faceless utility poles is such a long one—and such a humane one. But there are no telephones (electricity is enough of a miracle for one century). To call the island you must go to the Beaufort Sheriff’s Office and talk to the man who works the radio. Otherwise, Yamacraw remains aloof and apart from the world beyond the river. It is not a large island, nor an important one, but it represents an era and a segment of history that is rapidly dying in America. The people of the island have changed very little since the Emancipation Proclamation. Indeed, many of them have never heard of this
The Water is Wide
10
proclamation. They love their island with genuine affection but have watched the young people move to the city, to the lands far away and far removed from Yamacraw. The island is dying, and the people know it. In the parable of Yamacraw there was a time when the black people supported themselves well, worked hard, and lived up to the sacred tenets laid down in the Protestant ethic. Each morning the strong young men would take to their bateaux and search the shores and inlets for the large clusters of oysters, which the women and old men in the factory shucked into large jars. Yamacraw oysters were world famous. An island legend claims that a czar of Russia once ordered Yamacraw oysters for an imperial banquet. The white people propagate this rumor. The blacks, for the most part, would not know a czar from a fiddler crab, but the oysters were good, and the oyster factories operating on the island provided a substantial living for all the people. Everyone worked and everyone made money. Then a villain appeared. It was an industrial factory situated on a knoll above the Savannah River many miles away from Yamacraw. The villain spewed its excrement into the river, infected the creeks, and as silently as the pull of the tides, the filth crept to the shores of Yamacraw. As every good health inspector knows, the unfortunate consumer who lets an infected oyster slide down his throat is flirting with hepatitis. Someone took samples of the water around Yamacraw, analyzed them under a microscope, and reported the results to the proper officials. Soon after this, little white signs were placed by the oyster banks forbidding anyone to gather the oysters. Ten thousand oysters were now as worthless as grains of sand. No czar would order Yamacraw oysters again. The muddy creatures that had provided the people of the island with a way to keep their families alive were placed under permanent quarantine. Since a factory is soulless and faceless, it could not be moved to understand the destruction its coming had wrought. When the oysters became contaminated, the island’s only industry folded almost immediately. The great migration began. A steady flow of people faced with starvation moved toward the cities. They left in search of jobs. Few cities had any intemperate demand for professional oystershuckers, but the people were somehow assimilated. The population of the island diminished considerably. Houses surrendered their tenants to the city and signs of sudden departure were rife in the interiors of deserted homes. Over 300 people left the island. They left reluctantly, but left permanently and returned only on sporadic visits to
The Water is Wide
11
pay homage to the relatives too old or too stubborn to leave. As the oysters died, so did the people.
My neck has lightened several shades since former times, or at least I like to think it has. My early years, darkened by the shadows and regional superstitions of a bona fide cracker boy, act as a sobering agent during the execrable periods of self-righteousness that I inflict on those around me. Sometimes it is good for me to reflect on the Neanderthal period of my youth, when I rode in the backseat of a ‘57 Chevrolet along a night-blackened Carolina road hunting for blacks to hit with rotten watermelons tossed from the window of the speeding car, as they walked the shoulder of thin backroads. We called this intrepid form of entertainment “nigger-knocking,” and it was great fun during the carnival of blind hatred I participated joyfully in during my first couple of years in high school. Those were the years when the word nigger felt good to my tongue, for my mother raised her children to say colored and to bow our heads at the spoken name of Jesus. My mother taught that only white trash used the more explosive, more satisfying epithet to describe black people. Nigger possessed the mystery and lure of forbidden fruit and I overused it in the snickering clusters of white friends who helped my growing up. The early years were nomadic ones. Dad’s pursuit of greatness in the Marine Corps carried us into some of the more notable swamplands of the East Coast. I attended Catholic schools with mystical names like the Infant of Prague and the Annunciation, as Dad transferred from Marine base to desolate Marine base, or when we retired to my mother’s family home in Atlanta when the nation called my father to war. Mom’s people hailed originally from the northeast mountains of Alabama, while Dad’s greased the railroad cars in Chicago, but attitudinally they could have used the same sheet at a Klan rally. I loved the smooth-watered fifties, when I worried about the top-ten tunes and the homecoming queen, when I looked to Elvis for salvation, when the sharp dichotomy between black and white lay fallow and unchallenged, and when the World Series still was the most critical event of the year. The sixties brought this spindly-legged dream to its knees and the fall of the dream buried the joy of that blueeyed youth forever. Yet there were days that haunted the decade and presaged the tumultuous changes of the later sixties. By some miracle of chance, I
The Water is Wide
12
was playing a high school basketball game in Greensboro, North Carolina, on the day that black students entered a dime store for the first nationally significant sit-in demonstration. I was walking past the store on the way to my hotel when I heard the drone of the angry white crowd. Word spread along the street that the niggers were up to something, and a crowd started milling around the store. With rolledup sleeves and the Brylcreem look of the period, the mob soon became a ludicrous caricature of an entire society. The women had sharp, aquiline noses. I remember that. Everyone was surprised and enraged by the usurpation of this inalienable Caucasian right to park one’s ass on a leather stool and drink a Coke. I moved quickly out of the area, following a Conroy law of survival that says that restless mobs have a way of drawing trouble and cops—although the cops would not have bothered me on this day, I realized later. It would be nice to report that this event transformed me into a crusader for civil rights, but it did not. It did very little to me. I moved to Beaufort, South Carolina, in the early sixties, a town fed by warm salt tides and cooled by mild winds from the sea; a somnolent town built on a high bluff where a river snaked fortuitously. I was tired of moving every year, of changing home and environment with every new set of orders, of uprooting simply because my father was a nomad traveling under a different name and occupation. So we came to Beaufort, a town I grew to love with passion and without apology for its serenity, for its splendidly languid pace, and for its profound and infinite beauty. It was a place of hushed, fragrant gardens, silent streets, and large ante-bellum houses. My father flew jets in its skies and I went to the local segregated high school, courted the daughter of the Baptist minister, and tried to master the fast break and the quick jump shot. I lived in the security of a town founded in the sixteenth century, but in the world beyond it walked John F. Kennedy, the inexorable movement of black people coming up the road in search of the promised American grail, the television performances of Bull Connor, the snarling dogs, the fire hoses, the smoking names of Montgomery, Columbus, Monroe, and Birmingham. Having cast my lot with Beaufort, I migrated to college seventy miles up the road. I entered The Citadel, the military college of South Carolina, where for four years I marched to breakfast, saluted my superiors, was awakened by bugles, and continued my worship of the jock, the basketball, and the school fight song, “Dixie.” For four years I did not think about the world outside the gates. Myopic and color blind, I could not be a flashy, ascotted pilot like my father, so I opted for
The Water is Wide
13
teaching and Beaufort. At graduation I headed back down Highway 17 to begin my life teaching in the same high school that had spewed me forth several years before. But there was a difference this time: the purity of the student body was forever tainted. Thanks to the dastardly progression of law, black students now peppered the snow-white Elysium that once had harbored me. I loved teaching in high school. I dwelt amidst the fascists and the flagwavers in relative obscurity and I liked the students, who daily trooped into my class chewing gum and popping pimples. Painfully aware of my youth, I tried to belie my twenty-one years by acting mature and seasoned by experience. My act held up, until one horrid day when I asked a government class what was causing the peculiar smell that hovered in the room. A sharp-eyed pupil pointed out that I had stepped in a pile of dog crap and had tracked it around the room. Thus died maturity. I reveled in class discussion and the Socratic method of drawing substance out of calcified minds untrained to think. I would argue lamely for peace in Vietnam while my students clamored for the H-bombing of Hanoi and the subsequent obliteration of Moscow and Peking. They called me a Communist for not being pro-war; they called me a coward for my failure to rise to the defense of my country in its hour of greatest peril. When I protested that I saw very little threat posed by the government of North Vietnam to the United States, they mumbled ominously that I would eat several hundred pounds of crow when swarms of fanatical reds waded ashore at San Francisco Bay. These were children of the South just as I was. They were products of homes where the flag was cherished like Veronica’s veil, where the military was the pluperfect defender of honor, justice, and hymens, and where conservatism was a mandate of life, not merely a political philosophy. Each night I joined my best friends, George Garbade, Mike Jones, and Bernie Schein, in front of the television for the evening news. The war in Vietnam ate people on film. The seven o’clock news smoked with napalm and bodies. After the news, we held disorganized, vehement debates. George hailed from Ridgeland, South Carolina, a rural community so conservative that it made Beaufort look like a hotbed of liberalism. Mike was a divinity student who had dropped out for a year to reflect upon his impending life of spirituality among the hypocritical flocks that would be assigned to him. Bernie Schein was the twentythree-year-old principal of a tiny school in the next county. After the news the four of us argued until the late hours of night, exposing halfhidden prejudices. We mercilessly pounced on the member of the
The Water is Wide
14
group who dared utter a belief without foundation or without rational credibility. Those gatherings were group confessions of guilt, of cynicism, of rudderless idealism, and ultimately of hope. At the end of the year, the four of us went to Europe with our new-found credo. The world was good, we said, and it only needed minor adjustment. People were basically good, we asserted with disgusting smugness. In Germany I toured the concentration camp at Dachau and looked at the pictures of the piled bodies, starved and faceless, being shoved by bulldozers into mass burial pits. I stared at the furnace where Jews were reduced to piles of Jewish ash and felt that I stood on holy ground, a monument to the infinite inhumanity of man and society gone insane, a ground washed by thousands of gallons of human blood, a ground astir with ghosts and memories, of Jews and Germans trapped in a drama so horrible and unreal that the world could never have the same purity again. The imprint of Dachau branded me indelibly and caused me to suffer the miscarriage of my hopeful philosophy. If man was good, then Dachau could never have happened. Simple as that. In a hotel in Paris George, Bernie, and Mike argued anew for the basic goodness of man, but I felt that I had extracted the essential message of Dachau and that our philosophy was simply an exercise of innocence and nothing more. Nor could all the paint and clay of the Louvre dim the memory of one photograph: of a mother leading her small children to the gas chamber. I was getting tired of my own innocence. The year was 1968 and something had happened to me in April that also seemed to change my life. When the lone rifleman murdered Martin Luther King, Jr., in Memphis, the reaction among the students of Beaufort High School was explosive in its generation of raw, naked emotion. The white students, who composed the large majority of the student body, for the most part reacted passively to the event. Of course the village rednecks took vicious delight in calling Mrs. King a “black widow” and otherwise celebrating the death of this symbol of civil rights. A contingent of black students went to the principal in a futile attempt to get him to lower the flag to half-mast. Fearing community reaction, he predictably refused and closed his office to any further discussion of the matter. Since the faculty was all white, the black students walked the halls in silence, tears of frustration rolling down their cheeks and unspoken bitterness written on their faces in their inability to communicate their feelings to their white teachers. On the day King was buried the blacks assembled at recess in their accustomed place on the breezeway at the side of the school.
The Water is Wide
15
Apartheid was an unwritten law and there was very little crossing over. One of my duties as a teacher that year was to patrol that part of the campus where the black students congregated. It was in this capacity that I learned of the problems facing the blacks at the school. I talked and joked with them at recess, or at least I talked to most of them. One small, articulate group of girls eyed me with unconcealed hostility the entire year and I knew intuitively that in all their lives they would never approach a white man teacher without suspicion. I heard one of them say once that “only stupid nigger boys talk to Conroy.” On this momentous, hysteric day, however, these girls came for me. I was talking to some of the boys and did not immediately see the girls as they swarmed around me. The first to speak was Lily Smalls, a huge, imposing woman who the year before had beaten the hell out of a white girl who had made the mistake of calling her nigger. People still called her nigger but they made damn sure that Lily was not within earshot when they did. Lily shouted at me, “What are you doing here, white man? You sent here by the white man to make sure we don’t do anything de-structive?” Her friend Liz had inched closer to me and I felt the hot moisture of her breath on my neck. She sprayed me with spittle as she yelled, “Why don’t you get back with the rest of those honkies and let us cry in peace? We don’t need you to tell us how sorry you are or how much it disturbs you to see us upset. Just get your white ass back into that school and leave us alone.” “Wait!” another girl screamed. “I want to hear him say how sorry he is. I want to hear it. Say it. Say it.” I tried to say something, something redemptive or purgative, but no sound came from my throat. My vocal chords were not functioning well in this crisis. A sea of voices surrounded me, washed over me, and sucked me into a great whirlpool of sound and confusion. Bodies pressed up against me. A girl dug her nails into my arm until blood was drawn. Another girl screamed into my ear that the white bastards would kill all the black people in America. Lily’s voice shouted, “You white folks are happy to see Martin Luther King get shot, but you wait and see who takes his place. We gonna get mean, Conroy, and we ain’t gonna take shit from no whitey. You can tell all of your friends that the days of nonviolence and prayin’ for the white cat that beats you over the head is over. Man, they are gone, gone . . .” Then Lily wept. She stood there, almost nose to nose with me, and cried as though her soul was trying to wrench free of the prison of her body, as if all the tomorrows in the world were not worth the pain she felt right now.
The Water is Wide
16
But as she cried, other voices rose to fill the void of her silence. A boy pressed his mouth close to my left ear and rasped, “We are gonna burn this town down tonight. We gonna burn every white man with it.” A voice behind me wailed in rhythmic cadences a strangely moving lamentation, “Oh God, why can’t they leave us be? Why can’t they treat us right? Why can’t they love us like Jesus taught? Why do they hate us? Why do they hate black people?” More fingernails in my arm. Someone reached up and scratched my neck. I thought I felt strong fingers close about my throat, then release it suddenly. The entire mob was soon convulsed with raw, demonstrative sorrow. “Martin’s dead, Martin’s dead, Martin’s dead,” a voice cried. “The whites eat shit,” said a boy. “Fuck you, Conroy,” said a girl. And the bell, mercifully, rang. At a later date I heard the black kids laughing and snickering when Lurleen Wallace died of cancer. I questioned the appropriateness of their response as compared to the response of the crackers when King died. “She was a racist,” came the unanimous reply. So it was a little before Dachau that the mortar of cynicism was hardening. I was becoming convinced that the world was a colorful, variegated grab bag full of bastards. But the shadow that hovered over me, white guilt, still had to be reckoned with. So in the days after King’s assassination, greatly moved by the death of one I had admired so much, I lobbied for a course in black history in a school 90 per cent white. At that time, a black-history course was as common as a course in necrophilia. Now, with the times changing so rapidly, these courses have proliferated over the entire state. It seemed like big stuff then. I nursed the course through mild disapproval, coddled it through every pitfall encountered on the way up proper channels, argued with timorous authorities, wrote out a magnificent course outline, then realized I did not know a single thing about the history of black people in America. The course was mildly successful, but more as a symbol of the great flow of time than as a significant classroom experience. The year was fraught with embittering experiences for me with some of my fellow teachers. One lady with the delicate sweetness of a lemon told me that her father had required her to carry a gun when she was growing up to protect herself from lecherous attacks by black men. That, she told me, was the only nigger history she knew or needed to know. The same year the very coach that once had coached me in football relieved me of my job of junior-varsity basketball coach because he felt I favored the “coloreds.” As a senior I had surmised that this coach had a brain the size and density of a Ping-Pong ball, so it
The Water is Wide
17
came as no great surprise when he banished me forever from his gymnasium. But I was tired of fighting. Most of the teachers remained concerned and dedicated, and I respected them greatly for their efforts. Strange urges and a vague, restless energy made me look for something new and even adventurous. It was here that my good friend Bernie changed my life. Bernie Schein first told me about the job-opening on Yamacraw Island. He is one year older than I am and had been principal of an elementary school for three years. His first job, when he got out of Newberry College, was as principal of Yemassee Elementary School. Yemassee is a bunion of a town not far from Beaufort. Trains stop there. That is Yemassee’s singular mark of notoriety. Nothing else happens there. Bernie somehow talked the superintendent of Hampton County into letting him have the job. He had no qualifications, no experience, and no aptitude in administration, but since Bernie could talk a Baptist into burning a Bible, the superintendent had no other choice. Bernie took a room in a fly-bynight hotel, fought off an army of roaches, ate hamburgers for lunch and supper, watched the late movie every night, and became a great principal. He discovered an infallible formula: choose a town so dismal that the only thing left is study and hard work. When several of his friends started teaching in Beaufort, Bernie got a job as principal of Port Royal Elementary School, right outside the city limits. He felt that it was time for him to leave Yemassee. A rumor had it that Bernie was having an affair with a fifty-year-old teacher on his staff, and several Klansmen in the community were looking at this liberal Jewish principal with cross-burning eyes. We were inseparable from the beginning. We agreed with each other that Vietnam was intolerable, that the South had shit on the heads of the blacks, that the North was just as bad. Eugene McCarthy was an Arthurian figure elevated to knighthood in a moment of crisis; it was tough being a Jew in the South; it was tough being a Jew anywhere; we did not like Hitler, Strom Thurmond, Mendel Rivers, warm beer, or going to Atlanta for dates on the weekend. It was coming back from Atlanta that Bernie mentioned the job on Yamacraw Island. Since Bernie and I entertained delusions that we would somehow save the world, or at least a small portion of it, the idea of our own island, free from administrative supervision, appealed to us very much. Bernie told me what he knew about Yamacraw. “The school is all black. They’ve had two black teachers out there who evidently hate each other’s guts. The kids can’t read very well. Same
The Water is Wide
18
old story. Lack of materials, lack of motivation. Cut off from the outside world. I’ve never been over there, Pat, but we can borrow a boat and visit the island to see if we like it.” “Can you drive a boat, Bernie?” I asked. “Hell, no. Can you?” he answered. “Nope.” “Then I’ll ask someone about the job to see if we can both go over there for a year.” The next day Bernie talked to the official hiring man of the county. When he asked about chances for getting the job on the island, several members of the administrative staff hooted him out of the office. Bernie reported back that the stupid sons a bitches did not even listen to him make his sales pitch. Screw them, we both said, and sent in our applications to the Peace Corps. We had a tough time deciding whether we wanted to save Africa or Asia. We finally chose Africa. Within a month, the Peace Corps accepted Bernie for a project in Jamaica. I waited to hear. Months passed. No word from the Peace Corps. Toward the end of each school term, my draft board gets a restless desire to know of my intentions for the following year. I did not wish to return to the high school. I was through with teachers more concerned with the length of mini-skirts and hair than with education. But I certainly did not wish to join the Marine Corps, romp about the marshes of Parris Island, and emerge the product of a military system I had come to loathe. So I decided to go to the superintendent and ask about Yamacraw Island.
The Water is Wide
19
Chapter 2 After the administration became reasonably convinced that I was seriously thinking about the job, they promised to help me in every way possible. Ezra Bennington, the elderly deputy superintendent, showed special interest in my teaching on the island. Before the consolidation of Beaufort County school systems into one smoothly coordinated integer (at least in theory) Bennington had been in command of the Bluffton district, of which Yamacraw was a part. For over thirty years he had ruled his district like a Persian satrap. With consolidation he had had to accept the arrival of a more powerful presence in his midst and Dr. Piedmont had taken particular delight in letting his subordinates know that he was sitting with both buttocks solidly planted on the throne. Ezra had taken his fall from Eden gracefully, at least externally. But he still kept a vigilant eye on his old province of Bluffton, going over lists of new teachers, calling the principal who once worked under him to give unsolicited advice. When he learned that I was thinking about teaching on Yamacraw, he insisted that he be allowed to take me around the island. Ezra Bennington was the perfect name for him. He had a finely chiseled, fashionably wrinkled face that suggested integrity and character. His blue eyes were liquid and innocent. A gray mane covered his head. Ezra was Everyman’s grandfather. He would look good dressed in a white linen suit, rocking on a high verandah, shouting orders to Negroes working in the garden below him. Ezra looked, talked, and acted like a huge southern cliché, a parody who was unaware that his type had been catalogued and identified over and over again. Yet it is impossible to dislike men like Ezra. I have met a hundred of them in my life and, despite myself, have liked every one of them. Ezra agreed with the Piedmont formula that I sat on the right hand of the Father for going over to the island. He then said, “Lord knows how I
The Water is Wide
20
have tried to help these children, how I’ve fought to get them educated. As you know, Yamacraw is a problem, Mr. Conroy. I have tried to solve it for years and years. I tried to talk teachers into going over there to live. But no one would do it. Mrs. Brown was the first decent teacher I could get. You’ll meet her when we go out to the island.” I asked him, “Did you ever try to get anyone to commute to the island?” “Oh, no. You obviously don’t know about the waters around Yamacraw. They are very treacherous. During the winter it would be impossible for someone to commute. There are days when no one can get on or off the island.” “It just seemed like a good answer to me, Mr. Bennington. To have teachers commute to the island or to have a large boat to transport the children to the mainland. They have done this in other areas of the United States.” “It’s too far,” Ezra said, shaking his head remorsefully. “It’s just impossible. Just impossible.” Bennington spoke slowly. Each word rolled off his tongue like a drop of cold honey from the lip of a jar. He was straight and dignified and, jeepers creepers, he seemed like the most sincere human that ever came under the glance of the Lord. The county hired Andy Pappas to take Ezra and me over to Yamacraw. Andy was a short, fat Greek who ran a gas station in Bluffton. An avid fisherman, he knew the waters around the off-lying islands extremely well. He was the official boatman designated to take school personnel from the mainland to Yamacraw Island and he received twenty-five dollars every time he made the expedition. (The one thing I demanded in exchange for teaching on the island was that the school board buy me a boat for traveling to and from the island.) During the ride over, I concentrated on learning the water route from Bluffton to Yamacraw. Many sandbars and oyster banks scar the shallows of the saltwater creeks and rivers in lower South Carolina. In high school I had hit a sandbar while water skiing, flipped wildly in the air, and landed painfully on my back. I respected the presence of these latent hazards. I also listened to Bennington. Like many old people’s, his conversation constantly reverted to the past, and during the trip he reminisced about his boyhood and his career in education. He was reared, he said, on a prosperous farm in the upper part of the state. He was a southern agrarian, rooted in the rich, black soil of the Carolina midlands. He had farmed for a while, but ultimately decided
The Water is Wide
21
to exchange the plow for the blackboard. He came to Bluffton as an agricultural teacher, then shifted to administration. An accomplished raconteur, he made Andy giggle hysterically on the trip to Yamacraw by relating stories salted with a rural flavor. That first visit to the island told me very little about the children I would be teaching. It did serve to introduce me to the leading personalities with whom I would have to deal. A man named Ted Stone met us at the dock. Ted was a powerfully built man with steel gray hair and ice blue eyes. He greeted us matter of factly with a restraint and distance that made me a bit ill at ease. He was friendly enough and courteous enough, but he was aloof and suspicious. According to Bennington, he ruled Yamacraw Island. He had expropriated every job on Yamacraw Island for himself. He was the Game Warden, the Magistrate, the Director of Economic Opportunity, Warden of the Roads, Civil Defense Director, and held countless smaller titles, His wife, Lou, held every job not claimed by her husband. Lou was in her fifties but still had dark brown hair. She was the island postmaster and school-bus driver. Bennington described her as a “portrait of efficiency.” We borrowed the civil defense jeep from Mr. Stone. The island had few vehicles and the Stones kept all government transportation nestled under the large shed attached to their house. We drove down the dirt road leaving the Stones’ house. Trees, curtained with moss, dipped over the road. Only one car could traverse the road at a time. Andy spoke enthusiastically about hunting on the island. Deer populated the island in sizable herds. We took a left-hand turn at what could be described loosely as an intersection. Four weathered signs nailed to a pine log pointed toward the island’s four claims to notoriety: BEACH, SCHOOLHOUSE, LIBRARY, and COOPER RIVER LANDING. We drove past several small shacks. They were in seemingly good repair. One man stood in a field, hoeing his garden. He looked up, waved absently, then returned to his work. Bennington delivered a homily based on this scene. “These are good people,” he said, “but they are suspicious of strangers. I’ve worked with these people for Lord knows how many years. They respect me and trust me. They have never seen you, Mr. Conroy, so they will look upon this entire expedition with suspicion. For all they know you might be a revenuer coming to check on their stills.” Since I had never entered any community where strangers were greeted as affably as old friends, this information did not disturb me to any perceptible degree.
The Water is Wide
22
“Do they bootleg?” I asked. “They used to,” he replied. “In fact they used to make right good corn likker, isn’t that right, Andy?” “Damn right,” said Andy. “No likker ever tasted as good to me as Yamacraw likker. They made the stuff with copper tubing, too. You didn’t get your ass blinded if you drank the stuff. ‘Course, the revenuers have put most of them out of business.” “It sounds like a good industry,” I said. “Yeh, it was,” answered Andy. “Of course, they did a little drinking themselves. Ain’t nobody get drunk as a nigger. ‘Specially on Saturday night.” A pack of skeletal hounds intercepted us at the next house, snapped at the wheels of the jeep, then retreated to their shady refuge under the house. A woman appeared at the door. A small, dark woman. But only for a moment. She did not wave. Bennington then repeated the stranger formula verbatim. I am not certain what I expected the school to look like. It was a very attractive and simply constructed white frame building. It looked more like a house than a school. The trees around the purlieus of the schoolyard were massive, imposing guardians whose mass added security or mystery (depending on the looker’s point of view), to a scene rapidly becoming uncommon in the American South. Bennington gestured to a house on our right, across from the schoolhouse, and said conspiratorially, “Iris Glover lives there. She has been teaching for thirty-nine years on this island. The people are scared to death of her. She’s the island witch doctor. She’s liable to put a spell on you if you take the job.” “I thought she quit the job. I didn’t know I’d be taking anyone’s place,” I answered. “Oh, she’s retiring. At least the county is retiring her. She’s passed the mandatory age. Should have been fired forty years ago.” Miss Glover’s house was immaculately white with bright blue trim on her shutters and door. The blue paint was the universal symbol of recognition of the voodoo people. The paint discouraged demons and spirits from entering a house. Blue paint was to the voodoo people what garlic was to the villagers of Transylvania or what holy water was to the early Christians. The voodoo was a leftover from the African culture of the island blacks. Its modern form is much diluted and
The Water is Wide
23
infected by Christianity but still has sincere adherents among some blacks in the lowcountry. Without being aware of it, I subconsciously identified Miss Glover as being a prime enemy on the island. This proved to be a false impression. Bennington glowed like a Christmas bulb when he spoke of the other teacher. She was his personal discovery. He had championed her arrival on the island. Mrs. Brown appeared at the door of the schoolhouse and welcomed us to Yamacraw Elementary School. A large woman, she had great pendulous bosoms and huge sinewy arms and a handsome, expressive face. She was light-skinned and laughed a great deal. Everything about her seemed exaggerated and blown out of proportion. She treated Mr. Bennington like a nun would treat a visiting bishop. Mrs. Brown greeted me cordially and welcomed me “overseas.” She told me, “Things are tough overseas, Mr. Conroy. I’m a missionary over here helping these poor people. Only Jesus and I know how much they need help . . .” She spoke without a dialect and obviously was not from the island. When I asked her about this, she confided that she was from Georgia but was educated in a very fine private school where the cruder forms of black dialects were frowned upon by the Presbyterian educators who presided over the school. She was not from the island, she assured me. She had come to the island at the insistence of Mr. Bennington. “Mr. Bennington is the only one who understands the problems of Yamacraw Island. He knows what’s wrong,” she said, “and he knows what to do about them.” She spoke in rhythms. Her speech was exaggerated, going up and down like a piano scale. It almost scanned conversations in iambic pentameter; the words rolled off her tongue in poems. I tried to talk to some of the children, but they simply gazed at me with shy amusement, then buried their faces in their hands. The children were subdued, passive, and exceedingly polite. They had risen in unison when we walked into the room. They chanted “good morning” on cue from Mrs. Brown. They folded their hands and sat up straight at their desks. In an effort to achieve the common touch, Bennington walked among the children and cracked a few jokes. They looked at Mrs. Brown, saw that she was laughing, then laughed like hell themselves. Bennington then put his hand on one small boy’s head and whispered something in his ear. The boy smiled. Bennington was a fish in water. It was a yes-sir, no-sir world I had entered. Math and spelling papers hung from the bulletin boards. Everything was Mickey-Mouse neat and
The Water is Wide
24
virgin clean in the classroom. A map of the world, contributed by a Savannah bank, hung on one wall. Near it was a poster which read: EDUCATION IS THE KEY TO SUCCESS. A picture of a large key drove the point home. On Mrs. Brown’s desk was an item that caught and held my eye. It was a leather strap, smooth and very thick. It lay beneath a reading book. The relationship between Brown and Bennington intrigued me. Bennington represented a dying part of the South: the venerable, hoary-maned administrator who tended his district with the same care and paternalism the master once rendered to his plantation. As I watched him perform his classroom routine, I also observed Mrs. Brown’s reaction, a black teacher who nodded her head in agreement every time he opened his mouth to utter some memorable profundity. I could not tell if this was a role she was playing or if she actually believed that Bennington was the word made flesh. Anyway, they went well together. Both of them hated Miss Glover. For some undisclosed reason, Miss Glover was not at school on that day. Bennington and Brown cornered me and proceeded to blame the educational inadequacies of the children on Miss Glover. “She had been here forty years and the children didn’t even know how to use a fork,” said Mrs. Brown. “Well, Ruth,” Bennington intoned slowly, “that’s why I sent you out here. I knew you could lift these people up.” “I try, Mr. Bennington. You know I try. But these people don’t want to better themselves. Why, Mr. Conroy,” she said, turning to me, “the parents stay likkered up down there at the club and take the children with them when they do it. Satan smiles at all the sinnin’ going on at that club.” We soon departed. On the trip back I tried to gather my impressions together and come out with a final decision about teaching on the island. Andy handed out encomiums to several productive fishing holes we passed and indicated an osprey’s nest on top of a utility pole. Bennington talked about farming. I sat in the back of the boat and decided once and for all to take the job. Yamacraw was a universe of its own. The lushness of the island pleased me and the remarkable isolation of the school appealed to the do-gooder in me. Only a thoroughbred do-gooder can appreciate the feeling, the roseate, dawnlike, and nauseating glow that enveloped me on the return trip that day. I had found a place to absorb my wildest dogooding tendency. Unhappy do-gooders populate the world because
The Water is Wide
25
they have not found a Yamacraw all their own. All my apprehensive feelings disappeared. I had made a decision, The last statement I remember that day came from Mr. Bennington. “Did you notice how well I got along with those children?” he asked. “Yes,” I answered. “I’ve always been able to get along with colored people. They’ve always loved me.”
My first night on Yamacraw Island was spent in a sleeping bag on the schoolroom floor. The forest outside the perimeter of the schoolyard was insane with insect voices and the dark seemed darker than any place I had been before. No street-lamps, no traffic lights, no squeal of brakes, nor any other evidence of city life presented itself that night. Darkness in strange places is always fearful and, lying on the floor that night, sweating from the armpits to the metatarsals from the heat, I felt the fear that comes from being alone in a new environment. When I did get to sleep, I was later awakened by a thunderstorm. Lightning flashed around the island; thunder played its favorite game of scaring the crap out of all the shivering mortals on the earth below. Overall, the night seemed to augur strange things. But the morning was a time of renewal. The first morning was incredibly bright and tranquil. I awoke, shaved without a mirror, lost several pints of blood, and awaited the arrival of Mrs. Brown and the school bus. Mrs. Brown came first. “Welcome overseas,” she greeted me. “Thank you, ma’am. It is great to be here.” “Ho, ho, ho. Don’t speak too quick. You are in a snake pit, son. And them snakes are gonna start snappin’ at your toes. You’re overseas now.” She then delivered a rather ferocious homily about the handling of colored children by a teacher so obviously white. “You’ve got to treat them stern. Tough, you know. You got the older babies. Grades five through eight. Keep them busy with work all the time or they’ll run you right out of that there door,” she said. “I know colored people better than you do. That’s because I am one myself. You have to keep your foot on them all the time. Step on them. Step on them every day and keep steppin’ on them when they gets out of
The Water is Wide
26
line. If you have any trouble, Mama Brown will be right next door. We got lots of trees outside, and every tree gets lots of switches. I got some in that cabinet right over there.” “Thank you,” I said. The kids arrived at 8 A.M. and swarmed into the class, each of them pausing to murmur a dutiful good-morning. One small fry climbed into a seat only to be accosted by a larger girl who said that he was sitting in her seat. He said something unintelligible (to me). She cuffed his head, he swung a fist, then she drifted into another seat while I watched the whole scene. I think I said something profound like “now, now.” After this everyone sat erect in his seat appraising me with indirect glances, looking around at one another, then giggling and looking back at me. I felt ludicrously white. I gave them a little pep talk—one of the rah-rah varieties that is a universal choice of teachers all over the world on the first day of school. It was dull, rambling, and full of those go-go-get-’em-get-’em epigrams concerning the critical need for every human being to live up to his highest potential and to squeeze every possible morsel of knowledge from the textbook. They expected it and nodded their heads in solemn, collective assent. Not one of them knew my name, but all of them had prior knowledge that a white teacher would preside over them for the year. I printed my name PAT CONROY on the board. I then said my name aloud. When I said “Conroy” they laughed like hell. Since I saw nothing intrinsically humorous in my last name, I asked them what was so damn funny. This seemed to increase their laughter by several octaves. Several of the kids were trying to pronounce my name. One girl got “Mr. Corning” out of it, and this was the nearest approximation I heard. Mama Brown ended my ruminations over the last-name syndrome by trooping her first-through-fourth graders in for the first-day assembly. They marched in single file like a well-drilled squad of soldiers. When all were in their seats, Mama Brown delivered the memorable opening-day address. “Good morning, babies.” A few hesitant good-mornings answered her. “Well, now, babies, that isn’t much of an answer for the first day of school. Let’s try it again. Good morning, babies.” “Good morning” came the still timorous reply.
The Water is Wide
27
“Now, babies, I know your voices didn’t dry up like ole fruit over the summertime. Let’s use them vocal chords. Let me hear you say good morning like you mean it.” “Good morning!” they shouted loudly. The revival of the educational spirit buried in the inertia of summer had begun, at least for Mama Brown. She took a solid position behind the podium, which was placed somewhat pretentiously in the front of the room for the occasion. She then opened up with a fire-and-brimstone judgment-day sermon like an old circuit preacher who knew well the wrath of an angry God. She exhorted the kids to study hard and keep quiet or face the possibility of incurring the disfavor of the teacher who ruled them. “Most of you are slow,” she said. “All of us know that. But there are two of you, Frank and Mary, who could take a test right now and move up a grade or two. That’s because you got good brains and use them. The rest of you can’t think as good. We know that and you know that. Your brains are just slow. But you can learn if you work. You are just lazy, lazy, and lazy people just can’t get ahead in life. Of course some of you are even retarded, and that is even worse than being lazy. But we know you can’t help being retarded. That just means you have to work even harder than the lazy ones. Now those of you who are retarded know who you are. I don’t have to tell you. But retarded people need to be pushed and whipped harder than anyone. Here she paused and eyeballed the entire congregation. She then turned to me with an ingratiating smile. “I now have the privilege of introducing Mr. Patroy to the class. Mr. Patroy will be our new principal this year. He will teach the upper grades in the basics of language communication and the new math. Mr. Patroy is so good to come over here this year and we are thankful that the Lord brought Mr. Patroy to us. Now I am going to let Mr. Patroy speak to us. Now I am going to let Mr. Patroy get the floor and tell you babies what he has planned.” I walked up to the podium and gave a brief self-conscious talk about the joys of scholarship, then quickly relinquished the speaker’s platform back to Mrs. Brown. Mrs. Brown turned solemn. “We are now going to recite the Lord’s Prayer,” she said. “Now the Soo-preme Court said we couldn’t pray on Yamacraw, but I feel if the Lord ain’t on our side, then who is. If the Lord ain’t with us, then who’s gonna be for us. If the Lord decides to forget us, then there ain’t much use in livin’. Don’t you agree, Mr. Patroy?” Mr. Patroy nodded his head in solemn agreement.
The Water is Wide
28
We said the Lord’s Prayer, vilified the Soo-preme Court once more, then broke up the meeting. After the room had cleared of the underclasses, I put Plan Number 1 into immediate effect. I asked the kids to write a paper briefly describing themselves, telling me everything about themselves that they felt was important, what they liked about themselves and what they didn’t like. This seemed like a fairly reasonable request to me but most of the kids stared at me as if I had ordered them to translate hieroglyphs from a pyramid wall. I repeated the instructions and insisted that they make some attempt to follow them. So they began. As I walked around my new fiefdom, the kids earnestly applying themselves to the task at hand, I had my first moment of panic. Some of them could barely write. Half of them were incapable of expressiing even the simplest thought on paper. Three quarters of them could barely spell even the most elementary words. Three of them could not write their names. Sweet little Jesus, I thought, as I weaved between the desks, these kids don’t know crap. Most of them hid their papers as I came by, ashamed for me to see they had written nothing. By not being able to tell me anything about themselves, they were telling me everything. Next I read them a story, a very simple story, I thought, about a judge and a U.S. marshal in the Wild West. The story contained a murder, a treacherous friend, and a happy ending. I asked the eighth graders and the other kids who appeared the least bit literate to retell the story in their own words on paper. Frank, the eighth grader and the boy Mrs. Brown had introduced as the intellectual torch of the Yamacraw School, wrote the following: “Jim was a ranch. Jim had horse thef. Mike father was short in his back, Mike said Jim had shile his father.” A sixth grader wrote, “There was a cowboy name Jim and Mike had a ranch when Mike father got shoot in his barn. Mike did not no ho shoot him fadher one he fond out h.” This was Cindy Lou, who proudly produced this composition after fifteen minutes of laborious effort. Oh, I thought, we have no accomplished essayists in the class, so let us continue into other fields of endeavor. Perhaps some latent Demosthenes was sitting before me awaiting the coming of some twentieth-century Macedonia. I asked each child to tell me about his summer, what he did, what he enjoyed the most, or what he disliked about it. Since there was an obvious dearth of volunteers, I called on a diminutive boy named Saul, a seventh grader who looked no older than six.
The Water is Wide
29
“Tell me about the summer, Saul, me hearty lad,” I said, desperately trying to inject some life in the deadpan atmosphere of the room. Saul arose with paramount dignity, tugged on his belt, and spoke with a musical prepubic voice. “I slop de hog. I feed de cow. I feed two dog. I go to Savannah on the boat.” The next orator arose and said, “I slop de hog. I feed de cow. I feed three dog. I feed two cat. I go to Savannah in the boat.” The next brilliant innovator arose and said, quite surprisingly, “I feed the hog. I feed the cow. I feed the horse. I feed seven dogs. I go to Savannah in the boat.” Every other child in the class stood up and without a trace of expression or self-consciousness repeated Saul’s original speech verbatim. A boy named Prophet gave the only variation of the theme when he confided to the class with a grin that “I help poppa fick the poppa hog.” The class roared. After this failure to learn something about each of my new students, I pulled an old trick of the trade out of the hat, one of those tricks you find in a box in the middle of an elementary teacher’s magazine under the heading What to Do on That First Day. A girl I had been dating in Beaufort, herself an elementary teacher, suggested this to me. She promised that the kids would enjoy it and that I would find it extremely informative. I told the class to draw a portrait of me. They looked at me incredulously, jaws agape, as if I had asked them to draw a picture of horse genitals. “No lip, gang. No questions. Just draw a picture of this handsome devil you see before you.” “Humph, Conrack think he look good,” someone whispered. “Conrack don’t think he look good, honey,” I shouted. “Conrack know he look good. Now you just draw how good he looks.” “Conrack look bad,” one of the twins whispered. “Hey, twin. Conrack has big fist which says he looks good. Otherwise, fist crumples into little jaw of little twin and makes blood come out of face,” I said menacingly, as I put my clenched fist up against his face. “Conrack still look bad,” the other twin said, halfway across the room. “Good, then make me look bad.”
The Water is Wide
30
Everyone then became serious about art. Oscar, a seventh grader and the biggest boy in the class, gazed at my face with the intensity of a Parisian artist studying the contours of a nude. They all scratched and erased, hooted and squealed, and imprinted my image on their lined pieces of notebook paper. My pug nose caught hell. So did my sideburns. One girl, Ethel, was really very good. As I pinned them up on the bulletin board, I couldn’t help but notice there was some correlation between those who could not draw and those who could not write. They then drew a picture of themselves. I had no particular reason for doing this. The thought impulsively struck me that it might be interesting to compare the drawings they made of themselves with the ones they made of me. I was very glad I did this when I saw the results. Most of the boys drew themselves to look exactly as they had drawn me. Several boys had made what looked like duplicate copies. The girls saved themselves from exact reproduction by the fact they had included long hair and dresses in their self-portraits. No one had darkened his face or gave any indication that he or she might be black. Just before the arrival of the bus, we had an impromptu geography lesson. A map of the world hung near the door. I asked for a volunteer to come up and pinpoint the location of Yamacraw Island on the map. Eight hands immediately shot up. This surprised me somewhat and for a moment I thought I had expected too little from these kids, that they were more advanced than I had given them credit for. I called on Mary, the eldest, tallest, and supposedly the brightest girl in class. She strode confidently to the map and without hesitation and without faltering an instant, she placed her finger on a spot in the northeast corner of Outer Mongolia. When I told her this wasn’t quite right, the rest of the class cackled and taunted Mary all the way back to her seat. Fred prodded Mary’s arm with his finger and laughed like hell, until Mary swung a thin, long, graceful hand against the side of Fred’s face. A kid who identified himself as Big C walked up to the map and immediately chose a place near Bombay, India; nor did Top Cat neglect the portion of Russia that borders the Bering Sea. Then the bus arrived. The kids filed out. “Good-bye, Mr. Conrack,” they said. “Good-bye, gang, see you tomorrow. Then Mrs. Brown poked her head in the door and asked me how it went. “Crappy,” I answered, and she chuckled. “You’re overseas now.
The Water is Wide
31
She then gave me about five hundred tons of paper, which I would need as principal of Yamacraw Elementary. “No one told me I was supposed to be principal, Mrs. Brown. I thought you were the principal. In fact, I was told that you were the principal.” “Oh no, Mr. Patroy. You are the principal. Of course you’re the principal.” A month and a half later Dr. Piedmont sent word over to the island that Mrs. Brown was indeed the principal. She laid the papers on my desk, then went back to her room. It suddenly struck me that she took it for granted I was principal simply because I was white. Just as the first day of school was spent getting to know the individual children in the class, the second day was spent in an honest effort to find out what they knew. No one on the mainland could tell me exactly what problems I would encounter. Everyone seemed to agree it was bad, yet no one knew what diagnostic techniques to recommend. Several administrators intimated that whatever I taught the Yamacraw children, it would be infinitely superior to what they had learned before, regardless of what methods I employed. Yamacraw was an enigma to the minions who gathered under Piedmont’s protective wing. Bennington knew more than anyone, but his major preoccupation was to erase his own trail of incompetence and his contribution toward actually shoving the true portrait of the Yamacraw School before my eyes was negligible. After the second day of school, however, Bennington, Piedmont, and all the other king’s horses could come to me for information about the quality and condition of education on the island. It stunk. It is important to realize that I had never taught in an elementary school, that my experience had only been with high school students. I had not the vaguest notion what body of knowledge a sixth or seventh grader possessed. Nor did I really know what I was expected to teach them. So the night after the first day of school, I prepared a list of questions, questions that seemed to be the most basic units of information I could devise. I also pulled eighteen books out of the two bookshelves that passed for the library. These books ranged from the simplest I could find to one with a relatively complex vocabulary. In the morning the yellow school bus came into the yard at promptly eight o’clock. The kids filed in, each one of them giving me an obsequious good-morning as he passed through the front door. I swatted each one of the boys on the shoulder as he entered, called
The Water is Wide
32
him “chicken,” and dared any of them to summon up the courage to fight back. Big C crept up behind me and booted me in the rump. The class squealed and laughed approvingly. I chased Big C into a corner and commenced to wrestle him to the schoolroom floor. By this time the noise level had risen to an insect pitch. I was about to put Big C into a full Nelson, when a funereal silence descended on the room; I saw Mama Brown’s huge head staring disapprovingly into the window. She beckoned me to the door with her finger. Her finger was the size of a small blackjack. I went. “Mr. Patroy,” she said, “you have already lost the respect of these children. You have lowered yourself in their eyes. They need discipline, not fun time. This school isn’t any fun time, you know.” “Yes, ma’am,” I mumbled, embarrassed as hell. “Remember what I told you about colored children. They need the whip. They understand the whip. O.K. Do you understand me?” “Yes, ma’am. “O.K., that’s good. Now, this is the day we hand out books. In exactly one hour, I want you to send a child you trust to my room. The state requires us to hand out these textbooks as soon as possible.” “Can the kids read these books?” I asked. “They are supposed to read them. The state department requires them to read them.” “What if they can’t?” “Then we must make them read them. Of course, some of them are retarded and can’t read anything. You got to remember that we are overseas, Mr. Patroy, and things are tough overseas. “I’ll remember.” I returned to the classroom a chastened man. No more half-Nelsons on that particular day. I winked at Big C. Then I began the interrogation. “O.K., gang, loosen up. Shake those hands and feet. We are going to dust the cobwebs off those sweet little brains of ours. Prophet, you are going to have the opportunity to prove that you are a genius before all the world today. Carolina, you are going to shine like the sun. Everybody is going to look good.” One of the questionable themes developed in two years of teaching was the necessity to put students at complete ease. It worked well in
The Water is Wide
33
Beaufort, but the Yamacraw kids looked at me as though I were a mentally deficient clown. “What country do we live in, gang? Everybody tell me at once,” I exhorted. No one said a word. Several of the kids looked at one another and shrugged their shoulders. “Gang,” I continued, “what is the name of this grand old, red, white, and blue country of ours? The place where we live. The land of the free and the home of the brave.” Still there was silence. I was struggling for the right words to simplify the question even further. “Does anyone know what country we live in?” I asked again. No one answered. Each child sat before me with a pained and embarrassed look. “Have you ever heard of the United States of America?” I asked. “Oh, yeh,” Mary, one of the eighth-grade girls said. “I heared it. I heared it in I pledge a legent to the flag of United States of America.” “The Pledge of Allegiance. Good, Mary. Then you knew what country you live in.” “No, just know pledge a legent.” “All right, gang. Now the first golden nugget of information we are going to learn this year is that all of us live in the United States of America. Now the next thing I want someone to tell me is this: who is President of the United States in this year of 1969?” Again there was silence. “Does anyone know?” I asked. Everyone shook his head. Frank raised his hand. “John F. Kennedy,” he said. “Yeh,” the whole class answered, looking to me for approval. “Yeh,” I responded. “That’s great, Frank. Why did you say Kennedy?” “He good to colored man,” answered Frank. “Yeh,” the class answered. “Yeh,” I agreed.
The Water is Wide
34
“Can anyone tell me who the first President of the United States was?” Silence again. “Ever hear of George Washington?” I asked. Only a couple of students nodded their heads affirmatively. The rest had not. “Who can tell me who Willie Mays is?” No one could. “All right, gang, relax. We are going to get off these goofy people for a while. I am sick and tired of talking about people. Let’s talk about water. Who can name me an ocean?” Fred looked at Top Cat and Top Cat looked at Fred, who was staring intently at me. None of them had ever heard of any ocean. “I’m going to give you a hint,” I said, “one of the oceans washes up against the shore of Yamacraw Island.” Cindy Lou lit up and shouted, “Oh, he mean the beach.” “That’s right, Cindy. Now what is the name of the beach?” “The beach, man,” she answered indignantly. “No, I mean the name given to that whole ocean.” “I tole you it was the beach,” she said angrily. “O.K. It’s the beach,” I agreed. “But it also is called the Atlantic Ocean. Have any of you ever heard it called that?” All heads shook sadly and mournfully. “Well, don’t worry about it,” I continued. “That kind of stuff is easy to learn. Just by talking about it, without even thinking real hard, you have learned what ocean is by Yamacraw. Mary, if I were a stranger on this island and I met you on the beach and asked you what body of water this was I was walking next to, what would you tell me?” “Body?” she asked in a tone intimating that she had incriminating evidence against my sanity. “Yeh, body of water.” “I don’t know about no bodies,” she insisted. “Forget about body. What ocean would you tell me I was walking by?”
The Water is Wide
35
“Lantic Ocean.” “Atlantic.” “Atlantic,” she repeated. “What ocean, everybody?” “Atlantic Ocean,” they shouted in unison. “Are you sure it’s the Atlantic Ocean?” “Yeh,” they answered. “Well, it’s not.” They looked at me again like they had been placed under the jurisdiction of a functioning cretin. “The real name of the ocean is the Conroy Ocean.” “No,” they said. “Yeh,” I said. “No,” they said. “Yeh, it’s the truth. My great-great grandfather was Ferdinand Conroy, a Spanish soldier of fortune, who swam from Europe to North America, a distance of fifteen million miles. Because of this singular and extraordinary feat, they named this huge expanse of water after him.” “What you say?” one of the twins asked me. “He didn’t say nothen,” Cindy Lou said. “Anyway,” I continued undaunted, “from that day forward, it has been called Conroy Ocean.” “No,” George said. “How do you know?” I challenged. “Just ain’t. You said it is Atlantic.” “I’m a liar.” “You’s a teacher.” “Teachers lie all the time.” “Oh Gawd,” Lincoln said. I had been noticing whenever Lincoln was surprised or ecstatic he would use the phrase Oh Gawd.
The Water is Wide
36
So the day continued and with each question I got closer and closer to the children. With each question I asked I got madder and madder at the people responsible for the condition of these kids. At the end of the day I had compiled an impressive ledger of achievement. Seven of my students could not recite the alphabet. Three children could not spell their names. Eighteen children thought Savannah, Georgia, was the largest city in the world. Savannah was the only city any of the kids could name. Eighteen children had never seen a hill—eighteen children had never heard the words integration and segregation. Four children could not add two plus two. Eighteen children did not know we were fighting a war in Southeast Asia. Of course, eighteen children never had heard of Asia. One child was positive that John Kennedy was the first President of the United States. Seventeen children agreed with that child. Eighteen children concurred with the preCopernican Theory that the earth was the center of the universe. Two children did not know how old they were. Five children did not know their birth dates. Four children could not count to ten. The four oldest thought the Civil War was fought between the Germans and the Japs. Each question I asked opened up a new lesion of ignorance or misinformation. A stunned embarrassment gripped the class, as if I had broken some unwritten law by prying into areas where I had no business, or exposing linen of a very personal nature. No one would look me in the eye. Nor would anyone talk to me. I had stumbled into another century. The job I had taken to assuage the demon of dogooderism was a bit more titanic than anticipated. All around the room sat human beings of various sizes and hues who were not aware that a world surrounded them, a world they would be forced to enter, and enter soon. I now knew the score of the ball game. Or at least thought I did. The kids did not know crap. I walked up to Prophet. I put up six fingers and asked him how many fingers I had raised. “Eight,” he answered. “You only missed it by two, Prophet. Try it again,” I said. “Two,” he whispered. “No, Prophet. Now start at this first finger and count to the last one.” “Five,” he whispered again. By this time his eyes were begging me to cease the interrogation. His classmates laughed at him each time
The Water is Wide
37
he gave a wrong answer. I had humiliated him and his eyes carried the message. “Don’t worry about it, Prophet, we are going to bust the hell out of those old numbers before this is over. O.K.?” He nodded. Prophet gave the general appearance that a thought never entered his head, that his brain had never suffered from the painful malady of an idea. Samuel and Sidney, the twins, by their appearance alone made Prophet look like a candidate for the “College Bowl.” They were pitifully skinny, unanimated, dull-eyed, and seemingly retarded. Whenever I got the other children laughing by performing some insane act or saying some outrageous thing, Sam and Sidney would laugh several seconds after the other kids, as if they depended on the reaction of their peers for the proper responses. The twins seemed hopeless. Prophet smiled often enough, with his bell-ringer grin, to give me some faith that he was not completely oblivious to the world about him. This second day proved a hypothesis formulated quickly and haphazardly on the first day. A huge, almost unbridgeable communication gap existed in the room. When the kids were conversing normally, there was not a tinker’s chance in hell that I could understand them. The island blacks of South Carolina are famous among linguists for their Gullah dialect. Experts have studied this patois for years and they have written several books on the subject. It is a combination of an African dialect and English; some even claim that remnants of Elizabethan English survive among the Gullah people. Whatever the origin of the speech, I could not decipher the ordinary conversation of any of the children in the class. They spoke like machine guns, rapidly or in short, explosive spurts. Whenever I would stand off and listen to a group of them conversing, it became impossible for me to follow what they said. I could not grasp the syntax, nor could I follow any logical sentence pattern, nor could I participate in their discussions by piecing together words I did catch accidentally when one of them was sprinting through his version of a story. To make matters even more serious, none of them could understand me. Among the peoples of the world I am not universally admired for the bell-like clarity of my diction. Words slide out of my mouth like fat fish. Having lived my life in various parts of Georgia, Virginia, and the Carolinas and having been sired by a gruff-talking Marine from Chicago and a grits-and-gravy honey from Rome, Georgia, what has
The Water is Wide
38
remained is an indefinable nonspeech, flavored subtly with a nonaccent, and decipherable to no one, black or white, on the American continent. I am embarrassed to talk on telephones for the simple reason that operators cannot understand me. So the situation in the classroom was desperate in more ways than one. I knew the kids didn’t know very much and I knew that I could teach them a hell of a lot, but I could not understand a word they were saying, nor could they understand a word I was saying. With the help of Mary a compromise was reached. Mary seemed to understand almost everything I said, and on occasion I could understand some of what she said. I designated her as grand interpreter with illimitable powers of life and death over all. When Prophet said something known only to God, Mary would tell me what he said. Sometimes the whole class would help Mary out, and seventeen voices would rise slowly in an unintelligible gibberish, grow louder as each voice tried to be heard, and finally reach a deafening crescendo à la Babel. “Enough of this,” I’d yell. Then Mary would proudly explain to me that Prophet wanted to take a piss. That night I fired off a rather angry, self-righteous letter to Dr. Piedmont telling him that his cute little schoolhouse on Yamacraw was not worth a pound of cow dung. Looking back, I scoff at the bugeyed believer in the system I was then. There I sat in a small schoolroom, with a sleeping bag unrolled on the floor beside me, a dinner of beef stew and Gatorade digesting in my stomach, the smell of chalk dust and old textbooks in my nostrils, the wild insect sounds of night rampant in the forest around me, writing a brimstone letter to a man I had met only once, but whom I trusted implicitly to understand, to sympathize, and to act. Because the situation was so much worse than I anticipated, I was less diplomatic than I might have been. I wanted to shock Piedmont as I had been shocked and wanted to shake the plodding bureaucrats who plowed around the heavily carpeted county office building into awareness of the disastrous education they were giving kids. Yeh, I was a tough bastard in those early days. Piedmont learned that he had not sent me to Yamacraw to preside over an intellectual wasteland with all due acknowledgments to T. S. Eliot. The letter was written in a fit of Conroy passion, the tiny bellicose Irishman residing in my genes and collective unconscious urging me on and whispering to me that a great injustice was being perpetrated and that it was up to me to expose this condition to the person with the ability and training to do something about it.
The Water is Wide
39
The letter was written the second day of the school year. From that day forward, no one in the educational hierarchy of the county could plead ignorance concerning the school on the island. I had told them. On the third day I despaired. Each time I broached a new subject, it revealed some astonishing gap in the kids’ knowledge. The realm of their experience was not only limited, it often seemed nonexistent. Some of them vaguely remembered having heard of Vietnam but were not aware that the United States was at war in that country. When I asked whom we were fighting there, Oscar’s hand shot up and he quickly said, “The Germans and the Japs.” The whole class solemnly agreed that we had to beat those Germans and Japs. Yamacraw Island was the largest of the nine planets. When I asked who was the greatest man that ever lived, Mary answered, “Jesus.” Everyone, of course, fervently agreed. When I asked who was the second greatest man who ever lived, her brother Lincoln answered, “Jesus Christ.” Once again the entire class unanimously consented to this second choice. I could understand the class not knowing Richard Nixon, Napoleon, Julius Caesar, or Alexander the Great, but I could not see how black children living in the latter half of the twentieth century could fail to know Sidney Poitier, Wilt Chamberlain, or Willie Mays. They had never heard of Shakespeare or Aesop. They never heard of England or India. They had never been to a movie theater or to a ball game. They had never heard of democracy, governors or senators, capitals of states, or any oceans, or famous actors, or artists, or newspapers, or kinds of automobiles. They had never been to a museum, never looked at a work of art, never read a piece of good literature, never ridden a city bus, never taken a trip, never seen a hill, never seen a swift stream, never seen a superhighway, never learned to swim, and never done a thousand things that children of a similar age took for granted. I learned all this on the third day. I had pulled up a chair in the middle of the class and all the kids had drawn up their desks in a semicircle around me. And we just talked. We spent the whole day talking. I told them about myself, about my mother and father, about my four brothers and two sisters, about teaching in Beaufort, about going to Europe, and about my coming to Yamacraw. They were thrilled to learn that my father flew jet planes. I also told them I drove a small yellow car called a Volkswagen when I was on the mainland. The car was manufactured in a country called Germany on a continent called Europe. I showed them the country and the continent on the map.
The Water is Wide
40
They asked me about places I had been, and what New York looked like, and had I ever been on an airplane. They then told me about hunting on the island, and the boys became extremely animated describing the number of squirrels to be found deep in the woods and how you had to be a great shot to pick out the gray tuft of fur high in the black oaks and bring it down with one shot of the .22. The further you went in the woods, they told me, the more tame the squirrels became, the closer they would come, and the easier they were to kill. The girls then told me in elaborate detail how to clean the squirrels. They called the process “scrinching.” You slit open the belly with a sharp knife, peeled the squirrel’s pelt off like the skin of a grape, then scraped the squirrel’s skin until it was white and smooth. Ethel said, “A lady in Savannah won’t eat squirrel ‘cause she say after a squirrel been scrinched it look like little white baby.” “How many in here like to eat squirrel?” I asked. Everyone loved squirrel, although there was one purist faction in the class that liked squirrel meat without any other embellishments and another who preferred their squirrel with a thick gravy and a heavy stew. “I would have to be starving to death before I ate a squirrel,” I told the class. “A squirrel looks like a big hairy rat to me and since I would not eat a rat, I most probably would not eat a squirrel either.” Lincoln asked incredulously, “You ain’t never eaten squirrel?” I answered negatively. “Gawd, that man never eaten squirrel,” said Cindy Lou. “Squirrel ain’t no rat,” Saul said. “You eat rat,” Lincoln said to Saul. “No, I don’t eat rat. You eat crow.” The whole class roared when the puny Saul accused Lincoln of eating crow. Evidently, crow-eating had connotations on the island which were literal as well as metaphorical. “You know what you eat, Saul. You eat buzzard.” The class laughed wildly again. “Fat man, you know what you eat.” “What I eat, little man?” “You know what you eat,” Saul answered menacingly, his tiny frame rigid with anger.
The Water is Wide
41
“Little man, better tell me what I eat.” “Fat man eats shee-it.” “Oh Gawd,” half the class exclaimed simultaneously. Someone shouted, “Little man told big man he eat shee-it. He curse. He curse. Lawd, Mr. Conrack gonna do some beating now.” Saul had slumped into his seat after he had uttered the forbidden word and hidden his face in his hands, awaiting whatever punishment I would impose upon him. Why I had let the situation totally escape me, I did not know. I had been so interested in the downward progression of gourmet foods according to the island connoisseurs that I was totally unprepared for the final plunge to unpackaged feces. Lincoln, enraged at being called a shee-it eater, huffed and puffed triumphantly and waited impatiently for me to yank Saul from his seat and beat hell out of him. Meanwhile Saul had started to cry. “Saul,” I intoned, trying to sound like a miniature Yahweh. “Oh Gawd,” said Lincoln. Saul looked up still sobbing. “Saul, do you know how I used to punish students who were bad when I taught high school?” “No,” he answered. “I used to scrinch ‘em, son. I used to take a knife and cut open their bellies. Then I’d scrape their skin until they were ready for the pot.” “No,” the whole class said. “Yeah,” I, the wild-eyed scrincher, answered. Then I’d try to sell them for people to eat, but no one would eat them because them scrinched students looked too much like baby squirrels.” “White man crazy,” someone whispered. “Now everyone shut up. ‘Cause I am about to scrinch Saul.” “No,” the class shouted. “Yeah,” I shouted back. “But I am going to give him a chance. Now if I was Saul I would say, ‘Teacher, I said that stinking word and I made a mistake. If you give me another chance, I promise I won’t do it again.’” “Teacher,” Saul said rather quickly, “give me a chance and I won’t do nothin’ again.” “O.K. Fair enough. Now, Lincoln, is it true the stuff I hear about you?”
The Water is Wide
42
“What, man?” “Is it true that you eat skunk?” “Yeah, he eat skunk,” the rest of the class shouted. It was strange how I marveled about their lack of knowledge concerning history and geography. On the third day, though despairing, I wondered if they felt any pity for me for not having feasted on squirrel stew or enjoyed the simple pleasures of scrinching. The boys were hunters; the girls were expert in the preparation of the spoils of the hunt. Oscar, the tallest and the blackest kid in class, told me he had shot a deer the year before. Lincoln then told me that Frank had shot Oscar the year before. With this statement the class lapsed into a profound, but uncertain silence. Frank looked at Lincoln with eyes that danced with rage and fury. Oscar looked as if he was sucking on a lemon. Finally Saul spoke up. “Frank shot Oscar through the arm.” “Where was this?” I asked. “Down on Bloody Point on other side of island. They hunt bird.” Lincoln said, “Frank no have any guard on his trigger. Walking along, Frank trip over root. Trigger catch in his sleeve and put hole in Oscar’s arm.” “Oscar bleed like hog,” Sidney, one of the twins, said. It was obvious that Frank and Oscar still carried scars from that particular day in the woods—Oscar impulsively holding his left arm, Frank staring at his pencil, both of them thinking about the blood and pain. “That boy nearly bleed to death, Mr. Conrack,” Ethel said. “They walk to Mr. Stone’s house and a man take him to the doctor in Savannah. Say he almost die on the way.” “Shut up, girl,” Oscar said. “Yeah, man. Let’s everyone be quiet.” The bus was pulling up into the yard. “Tomorrow return and we will continue to derive great pleasure from the joy of learning.” “Oh Gawd, Conrack.” When Friday afternoon came and the bus sucked the kids out the school door and they bade farewell to Mr. Conrack for the weekend, it was a matter of minutes before I was untying the boat at Stone’s dock
The Water is Wide
43
and heading for Bluffton, where Bernie was meeting me. We drove to his apartment in Beaufort, where I took my first shower in a week. I luxuriated in the flow of hot water. All the crud of the island fell off me like a skin. Then I turned my attention to the mosquito bites, which were legion over the length and breadth of my body. Pouring alcohol into cotton balls, I dabbed the red swellings until they stung and glowed. One particular bite merited more detailed attention. Under careful scrutiny, I saw that it was a tick. It was just sitting there beneath my armpit, growing fat by sucking my lifeblood. He was in there deep; his snout drilled far into my flesh enjoying the refreshment of the plasma coursing through my veins. I grabbed him by his tiny behind and yanked. He split in half. His straw still remained in me, sucking away. Bernie got a match and after applying four first-degree burns to my arm, the tick shriveled and came out easily. A spot check revealed that I was covered with the ravenous fellows. They preferred the warmth and obscurity of the pubic region, where they could hide and suck without detection. They were forest creatures and to the forests they retreated, hiding like guerrillas in the dense foliage of arse and scrotum. Taking a pair of tweezers, I extracted nine ticks from my body. “An occupational hazard, son,” Bernie sang.
The Water is Wide
44
Chapter 3 The school library would have been funny if it had not been such a tragic commentary on administrative inefficiency and stupidity. Each day we had a half-hour reading period during which the kids could read anything they liked. Since a lot of them couldn’t read at all, the period had become a time when I simply tried to get them interested in books. Cindy Lou chose a book called Tommy the Telephone as her personal favorite. Each time Cindy read to me about Tommy, the irony struck me: a girl reading about telephones who has never used a telephone. Other books with negligible relationship to life on the island populated the shelves. There were books on Eskimos, Scandinavians, dairy farms in Wisconsin, and the Japanese pearl divers, but I could find no books or information on rural blacks in the Yamacraw school library. I brought a Sears, Roebuck catalogue to school and it proved to be one of the most popular books. The girls perused the fashions, while the boys lusted after the hunting and sports equipment. My group of rock-hard nonreaders flipped through the encyclopedias, looking at the pictures and asking me innumerable questions. “What this here, Conrack?” Sidney would ask. “That’s a pyramid, Sid. They used to bury kings in those things thousands of years ago in a country called Egypt.” “No.” “Yeah,” I answered. “Who this?” Prophet would ask then, thumbing through another encyclopedia. “That’s Babe Ruth. One of the greatest baseball players that ever lived. He used to play for the New York Yankees. He hit 714 home runs in his career, more than anyone else in the history of baseball.”
The Water is Wide
45
“He play now?” asked Richard. “He’s dead,” I said. “Yeah, stupid, he daid.” Sid grinned as he punched Richard. “That man dead?” Prophet asked again. “Richard think that man ‘live,” Sid continued. Richard slugged Sid and the discussion of the Sultan of Swat ended. One day as the guys pored over the musty tomes, which they came to consider their personal property during the reading period, Jasper stumbled on the section dealing with snakes. The whole class ran over to look at the snakes. “Snake bad,” Oscar said sagaciously. “Yeah, bad,” everyone agreed. “Snake good,” I interjected. “Gang, snakes eat rats and other rodents which are pests around the yard.” “Snake eat you, too,” Lincoln said. The class howled. “Just poisonous snakes will hurt you,” I said defensively. Since Yamacraw contained some of the largest diamondback rattlesnakes to be found anywhere, I could understand their fear of snakes, but as an amateur herpetologist, I felt that I had to make an impassioned defense of snakedom. “And snakes will not bother you unless you bother them.” “Lord, Mr. C’roy, you just don’t know snakes,” Ethel said. “We got a snake here on this island that wrap himself around you and whip you to death.” “Yeah,” everyone agreed. “Bullcrap,” I said. “He cuss,” Sam whispered. “That is nonsense. That is what we call a myth. Something that is not true. How many in here have ever seen a snake whipping a man to death?” Naturally, every hand in the room flew up. “Who was the man you actually saw getting the hell beat out of him by a snake?” “He cuss one more time.” Old Sam was keeping tabs.
The Water is Wide
46
“His name was Jacob Hudson, used to live here on the island,” Ethel said. “Did the snake kill him?” I asked. “No. He run away. Have marks on his body, though,” continued Ethel. “Yeah. Have marks on his body.” The others agreed. “Did you actually see this man being whipped?” “No.” “Then you do not know if the snake really whipped the man.” “Yeah. He have marks,” said Mary. “Ever see a snake milk a cow, Mr. C’roy?” Big C asked. “Oh, crap.” “Yeah, he milk cow dry.” “That is simply not true. These are all snake myths,” I pleaded to an unconvinced audience. By the expressions on their faces, I could tell they thought I was nuts. “I seen plenty of snakes milk cows,” Big C said. “Do they put the milk in bottles?” I now resorted to my last weapon, ridicule. “No, they suck it up.” Mr. Conroy, ever see how snake eat egg?” Lincoln asked. “No, Lincoln, but I’m afraid to ask.” “He swallow the egg whole. Then he climb up tree, jump off branch, land on ground, and pop egg in belly.” “That’s how I eat eggs, too, Lincoln.” I returned to the serpent mythology on numerous occasions during the year, exhorting the students to look truth in the eye and to understand that the things we learn in our youth are not always literally correct. With brilliant logic they argued that what I had learned in the city about snakes was not any better than what they learned while living on the island. They had lived with snakes all their lives; I had merely read about them. In one remote corner of the room, the dustiest and most spidercontrolled corner, sat several boxes full of books. A church had
The Water is Wide
47
donated the books in order to rid the island of illiteracy. Give them books and they shall read. Earnest ladies and pious men had scurried around attics and unused libraries in search of books for the unread natives of Yamacraw Island. Their minister sometimes came to Yamacraw on Sundays to preach to the blacks on the island, to exhort them to quit their evil likker-drinking ways. He was enormously proud of the fact that he could summon up enough Christianity to preach to the niggers, since he made it no secret on the mainland that he did not think much of niggers. If a black had entered his church, the church would have closed down automatically. That was the plan of the hallowed vestrymen should a black foot cross the threshold. Christ must do a lot of puking when he reflects upon the good works done in his name. Anyway, the church gathered books in cardboard boxes and shipped them to the island for use in the school. Looking at the books, I saw little possibility of handing my students The Power of Positive Thinking by Norman Vincent Peale. Nor did I think they could relish Gone with the Wind. Several books on Christian doctrine seemed equally inappropriate. A nice gesture and a good idea, but none of the books were on a level the kids could handle. By far the greatest travesty was the public library established on the island by a concerned group of citizens who thought it deplorable that the island did not have a library of its own. It was deplorable and unthinkable that an island had no place to which a man could retire to mull over his thoughts, to write great novels, to generate lofty ideas, or to lose himself in scholarly pursuits. To solve this problem, the county decided to establish a library to serve the intellectual needs of the islanders, most of whom could neither read nor write. So the county transported 2000 books out to the island, put them in the community center, and hired a part-time librarian as custodian of the books. The books, of course, reflected the great trends of literature; the selection was vast and represented all the eminent authors. Here an old oyster-shucker could find Look Homeward, Angel by Thomas Wolfe, The Sound and the Fury by William Faulkner, For Whom the Bell Tolls by Ernest Hemingway. Or, if he preferred the nineteenth century, this same ox-cart driver could select Moby Dick by Herman Melville or The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne. All of these books were available. When no one checked out a book in three years, officials were noticeably chagrined. “Stupid niggers. You bust your ass to help them, and they don’t even check out a book.” Good intentions flourish on Yamacraw Island. The projects of concerned
The Water is Wide
48
white folks are evident everywhere. Supply books and by a miraculous process of osmosis, the oyster-pickers will become Shakespearean scholars. All dem nigras need is books and a little tad of education. James Brown is the Yahweh substitute on the island. The kids tingle every time his name is mentioned; they have memorized his songs as though they were the Gospel according to Luke. Top Cat, numero uno dispenser of good poop on Mr. Dynamite and his Famous Flames, shook and gyrated his way around the room when he thought I was not looking. The contorting moves he put his body through defy description and he is acknowledged by his peers as being the finest dancer on the island. “That Top Cat, crazy. Watch Top Cat shake that thing,” they say with profound respect. Once in a while he felt the fire within him rage and, at that exact moment, strutted and jerked up to my desk and asked to sing James Brown’s latest song. We turned on the tape recorder (discovered in a corner in Mrs. Brown’s room) and Top Cat lost himself in his art. The kids loved it. Of course, Mrs. Brown hated it and delivered an impassioned lecture against wasting valuable school time and ignoring the sacred laws of the state government. One day in late September Top Cat was studying the covers of some long-playing albums beside my record player. Since I had not yet moved into my house, all my earthly possessions stood in one corner of the schoolroom. The record album that came under the most careful study by Top Cat was a gift from my mother back in those ancient days when Mom thought her family should develop some familiarity with the arts. She invested a considerable sum of money in the Readers Digest series of records and books designed to give cultural dimwits at least a surface knowledge of the world’s finer things. Somehow I had confiscated the “Fifty Favorites,” a collection that included brief but famous fragments of the great composers. Top Cat asked me if James Brown, Mr. Dynamite and his Famous Flames, sang any “tough” songs on this here record. “Top Cat, James Brown and his Famous Flames were not good enough to make this record. They tried but they just couldn’t make it. The Reader’s Digest put this thing out. Ever heard of the Reader’s Digest?” “Nope.” “Anybody ever heard of the Reader’s Digest?” Nobody had ever heard of it. Being an American and not knowing the Reader’s Digest is like being English and not knowing the queen.
The Water is Wide
49
“This little magazine put out this little record you see here in my hands. This record is a treasure, an absolute delight. A collection of greatness. Now the first great tune I am going to play for you was written by a long-haired cat named Beethoven. Who was that?” “Bay Cloven.” “Close enough. Now old Bay Cloven loved music, and he could write some pretty mean songs. He was the James Brown of Germany. What continent is Germany in [pointing to the map]?” “Europe.” “Good. Now one of Beethoven’s most famous songs was written about death. Death knocking at the door. Death, that grim, grim reaper coming to the house and rapping at the door. Does death come to everybody’s door sometime?” “Yeah, death come knocking at Dooney’s door last year,” Big C said. “Well, Beethoven thought a little bit about death, then decided that if death were really knocking at the door, he would sound something like this: da-da-da-da. Now I am going to place this little needle on this valuable record and we are going to hear death knocking at Bay Cloven’s door.” The first notes ripped out. 0l’ death, that son of a bitch. “Do you hear that rotten death?” I yelled. “Don’t hear nuttin’,” said Prophet. “Sound like music,” said Lincoln. “Shut up and listen for that bloodsucker death,” I yelled again. “Yeah, I hear ‘im,” Mary said. “Me, too,” a couple of the others agreed. Finally, everyone was hearing old death rapping at the door. Once we labeled death and identified him for all time, I switched to the Triumphal March from Aida. Rhapsodically explaining the glorious entry into Rome, swelling with pride over the victories in the Egypt-Ethiopian campaigns, I described Verdi’s panoramic vision of the coming home from the wars. I impressed no one with the performance and discovered to my unconcealed chagrin that I had played the Emperor Waltz instead. “We want to hear Bay Cloven.”
The Water is Wide
50
“Shut up. You will listen to Verdi.” “We want death,” Fred said. “Then death you get.” Bay Cloven was definitely the top tune of the day. When I played Brahms’s Lullaby, I whisked Sam out of his seat, cuddled him like an infant, and rocked him asleep. He reacted brilliantly, as only a natural performer could, throwing his head back in a ludicrous imitation of sleep, his mouth open, his eyes closed. The class also reacted well to “The Flight of the Bumblebee” by Rimsky-Korsakov. “You hear them bees?” I asked. “Just like a honey tree,” Frank answered. “Any honey trees on Yamacraw?” “Yeah, they honey trees. Honey bees too.” “Bee sting,” Prophet added. “Bee sting bad,” someone else said. “Who wrote this song?” “Rinkey horsecup,” Jimmie Sue said authoritatively. “Gang, we are going to learn all the songs on this record,” I said. “And I just thought of a good reason for doing it. Because you are going to look like geniuses when you know these songs. People are going to come to this island to revel in stupidity and poverty. I am going to switch on the record player and you are going to look at these people and exclaim with British accents, ‘Pahdon me, suh. Are you perchance familiar with Rimsky-Korsakov?’ We can knock their behinds off. Now, an important question: do you guys and gals think you can learn these songs and who wrote them? You already know three of them. You know Beethoven’s Fifth, ‘The Flight of the Bumblebee’ by RimskyKorsakov, and Brahms’s Lullaby. You learned three of them without even trying. Can you learn a whole mess of them?” “Yeah,” everyone shouted. “I believe you.” So we did it. That night I chose twenty of the most impressive titles written by the most impressive composers. For the next two months a portion of each day was set aside for the consumption, memorization, and enjoyment of this top twenty. On a weekend I purchased a huge
The Water is Wide
51
poster of Beethoven, and hung his shaggy-maned visage on the bulletin board. It tickled me to think of Big B’s reaction to his celebration on an island as remote as Yamacraw. In a short time he became “BayToven the Fifth” and no matter how earnestly I tried to explain that the fifth was not an addendum to his name, so it remained. It gave an incredible feeling to put the needle down, to hear Tchaikovsky swell into the room, then watch the hands shoot up, or to hear voices excitedly identify the piece without bothering with the raised-hand crap. Soon we derived a game out of it. I would skip all over the record, trying to fool them into guessing wrong. When it was apparent that most of them had developed an almost infallible expertise in the big twenty, I told them that they were the most advanced scholars in classical music functioning in the elementary schools of Beaufort County. Bay Cloven would be proud, I told them, and so would James Brown. I then told them that they had to look upon themselves in a different light, that they had to be convinced of their basic worth, and that they could learn just as fast as anybody else. If they didn’t believe it, they could get the hell out of my class. The music eventually proved a great ego-inflater. When I started bringing an influx of visitors in the spring, curious people who heard about the island and who came basically to pity, to commiserate, and to poke around, it gave me and the kids almost Satanic pleasure to flip on the record player, challenge an unsuspecting guest to a contest in classical music, then let the well-drilled students maul them. Oh, the joy. To see the misty-eyed whites who had flagellated themselves with visions of worm-eaten cretins and deprived idiots trounced in a headon collision of wits was a banquet to be savored again and again. On the way home, riding through the green marshes, I would explain to the shell-shocked visitor that the children felt that Strauss was overrated, you know, old chap, a little too mawkish and sugary. On the other hand, they felt Brahms was not getting his due with the general public. He had written some fine stuff that had remained unknown to the common run of listeners. Those were such good and satisfying days. And the kids seemed genuinely to like the stuff. One morning Top Cat leapt off the bus, ran into the classroom, and informed me that “The Flight of the Bumblebee” was played on the “Andy Williams Show.” Later, in the year Lincoln and Mary reported that they heard “The Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy.” When I brought Leonard Bernstein’s Children’s Concert to the school, Leonard was a mild, if not overwhelming, success. His orchestra
The Water is Wide
52
played several of the movements we had memorized and when they played these pieces, the kids would hoot and slap each other, then say. “That’s old Shy-Koski.” Every single film on music I could find in the county film library and every one I could order from the state department made its way into the classroom. We learned the instruments in the orchestra, then promptly forgot them. We were cocky about our music. Me, the gang, Bay Cloven, Shy-Koski, and the boys. Each morning, as my students filed into the class, flipping me a dutiful, lachrymose good-morning, I would turn on the radio to catch the latest news. They showed great interest in the morning news. “Oh Gawd,” Lincoln would lament, “here come de mornin’ news again.” “That man talk every mornin’ about nothin’,” Oscar would add. “Ah, the joys of learning,” I would pipe in, “the tremendous interest you show in the happenings around the world is gratifying to see. The world is out there.” I gesticulated rather dramatically. “Wars are being fought, people are being killed, famines are wiping out nations, and rulers are being assassinated. We can hear it all, right here on the morning news.” My pre-Yamacraw theory of teaching held several sacred tenets, among these being that the teacher must always maintain an air of insanity, or of eccentricity out of control, if he is to catch and hold the attention of his students. The teacher must always be on the attack, looking for new ideas, changing worn-out tactics, and never, ever falling into patterns that lead to student ennui. Bernie and I both believed in teacher dramatics, gross posturings and frenzied excesses to get a rise out of dead-head, thought-killed students, who daily sat before us like shoed mushrooms. The master of clowns, Bernie could twist his face into a thousand contortions to get kids to laugh with or at him. Bernie would tell me, “Boy, keep them laughing. Make them laugh so damn hard and so damn loud that they don’t realize they are learning.” My tactics were different. I concentrated on variety as the primary method. Sweet talk, Shakespearean monologues, Marine Corps brutality, prayers—anything that could possibly inflame the imagination, even momentarily, of someone imprisoned in my classroom all day. “We don’t like the news,” one child whispered.
The Water is Wide
53
“Tough crap, we are going to listen to the news whether you like it or not. Let’s take a vote. Who does not want to listen to the news?” Every hand in the room shot up. “I am going to break every arm that is raised in the air after we take the next vote. Who does not want to listen to the news?” No one raised a single hand. “Ah, excellent. Then it is unanimous, and I must say it is extremely gratifying that my students are sharing such a great concern for the rest of mankind.” I put the news on, as I would for the next four months. As the announcer listed the deliriously happy events which occurred on the preceding day, I would stand by the map of the world and pinpoint the countries mentioned. Every time he named a country, a new dimension or a new frame of reference was added to my class’s growing repertoire. They were geographically illiterate. The world map, pinned on the same spot probably for several years, could have been an anatomical chart of an earthworm for all they knew. When the announcer told the world that terrorists had abducted the American ambassador to Brazil, I put my finger on a big yellow blotch on the map and whispered, “This hunk of yellow on the map is the country of Brazil.” Tracing Brazil with my finger as the announcer gave the details, I told them that Brazil produced most of the world’s coffee. Then we learned of the latest border skirmishes between Egypt and Israel; Everett Dirksen dying in Illinois; Korean students rioting in Seoul. After the news, I showed them each country, gave them some juicy little fact about some of that country, and informed them that they would know something about that country from that time forward under pain of death. “Now what bright young scholar can tell me what product we drink from Brazil?” No one answered, naturally. “Some people drink it black. Some people drink it with cream. Some people drink it with sugar. And some people don’t drink it at all.” “Coke,” Richard yelled. “No,” I answered. “Coffee!” some of them shouted. “What is it?” I shouted back.
The Water is Wide
54
“Coffee,” all of them shouted. “Where do they produce coffee?” “Brazil,” some of them answered. “Where is it?” I asked again. “Brazil,” they shouted together. And it was in this way that the pep-rally method of education began on Yamacraw Island. For the next several weeks a certain part of the morning was set aside for a daily chant or incantation to the gods of basic knowledge. Eleven of the students displayed an interest in learning little morsels or fragments of information for no other reason than just to know them. I talked about rivers, the one that flowed by Yamacraw, rivers I had seen in Europe, and then told them of the three great rivers of the world, the Nile, the Amazon, and the Mississippi. I listed the continents, the planets, and the oceans. I also gave them a brief outline of American history: Columbus stumbling upon America, Magellan’s trip around the world, Balboa seeing the great Pacific, George Washington and the boys giving the British hell. Strange terms like the Constitution, the Declaration of Independence (which one of the kids kept calling the Decoration of Indianapolis), the Revolutionary War, the Civil War, and the Emancipation Proclamation. None of these subjects did I touch in depth; I only gave a very general explanation of each one and tried to get the kids to look at history as a flow of events that somehow affects every person on earth. We used no books. It was oral history and oral geography. Nothing was written down. We talked and learned by talking and, soon enough for me, our pep rallies had evolved into wild chaotic exchanges of rote memory. I teased and cajoled them and expected them to fire back, to take no crap from me, just as I took no crap from them. “All right, young cats. We are about to embark on a journey of knowledge. Now, I am convinced I am going to ask certain questions today so hard that you will not be able to answer any of them right.” “No,” everyone murmured. They still thought I was a madman. “What is the longest stinking river in the whole wide world?” “The Nile,” all of them shouted, poking each other with their fingers and exulting in the breadth of their education. “What continent is it on?”
The Water is Wide
55
“Africa.” “Who comes from Africa?” “Black people.” “I came from Africa.” “No!” “Yeh! I came from Africa because I am white with blue eyes. Ireland is a country in Africa.” “No. You lie. That ain’t right. He crazy,” they retorted. “James Brown came from Ireland.” “No.” “What’s the largest planet in the universe?” “Jupiter.” “Second largest?” “Saturn.” “Nearest star?” “The sun.” “Largest country in the world?” “Russia.” “Country with the most people?” “China.” “James Brown comes from China.” “No.” “Who was the first President?” “George Washington.” “Second President was D. P. Conroy.” “He crazy,” Sherman said. “What country do we live in?” “The United States of America.” “What state do we live in?”
The Water is Wide
56
“South Carolina.” “Are you sure?” “Yeh, we sure.” “What ocean washes up against this island?” “Atlantic.” “Where are we fighting a war?” “Vietnam.” “Who is the President of North Vietnam?” “Ho Chi Minh.” “What is James Brown’s greatest song?” “‘Say It Loud, “I’m Black and I’m Proud.”’” “No, it’s not,” I would say on cue. “His greatest song is ‘Say It Loud, “I’m White and I’m Proud.”’” “No, man. He’s colored,” Big C answered. “No. White man crazy,” Prophet added. “What state is below South Carolina?” “Georgia.” And on it went. Whenever we learned something new, it became part of the pep rally. I would often go to the map and point to a country, or a continent, or a river or ocean, and ask them to identify it. The map itself became a center of class activity—the map, a symbol of the world, where Yamacraw was not even a pinprick, not even represented by a molecular dot when compared to the incomprehensible vastness of the world. “Here is Asia and here is Yamacraw,” I would chant, moving my finger along the map. “Here is California and here is Yamacraw. Here is China and here is Yamacraw. Gang, do you realize the neat things that are happening out there? The millions and millions of people swarming all over the earth? We are going to learn great stuff this year. We are going to stuff our brains with facts and ideas, and we are going to become sharp as razors.” It should be noted that seven of the students got very little out of the pep rallies. But they shouted when everybody else was shouting, and
The Water is Wide
57
even though they were not saying anything, they loved being a part of the successful whole. When I asked a question, they shouted a grunted reply. Flushed by success, their whoops grew louder and louder. Our pep rallies invariably ended when Mrs. Brown’s large head would peer into the window and flash disapproving, desultory glances at me and the kids. The kids reacted as if a death’s-head was in the window. After school Mrs. Brown would lecture me about the “proper way to conduct yourself around colored children.” She repeated her offer to buy me a leather strap. I thanked her and told her that I was looking at a bullwhip in Savannah. Complete illiteracy was an animal I had never encountered before. While teaching at the high school I came across some students who were not the brightest flames on the academic horizon, but none of them could compare with the seven students who formed a kind of know-nothing fraternity at the Yamacraw School. Of these seven, five were unbelievable. Richard, Prophet, Jasper and the twins not only were untouched by the twenty-six letters of the alphabet, they were appallingly lacking in other skills too. “How many fingers on one hand, Prophet?” I asked one day. “Two,” he answered. “Try it, Samuel.” “Three.” I put out the five fingers of my hand. “Count the fingers, Sidney.” “One,” said Sidney. “How many fingers, Richard?” “Four.” “Sweet Jesus,” I said, regretting it instantly when I saw the four very embarrassed faces. The other students, supposedly working on their own projects, were giggling. “Shut up, punks. We are in the process of education and so do not have time to be disturbed.” Then I carefully explained the five-fingered hand. They could not count to ten. They could not add one and one, two and two, or anything else. Mrs. Brown told me they were retarded and not to waste my time on them. Someone obviously had not wasted a great deal of time trying to educate them. If I held up basic-word cards for them, they stared at
The Water is Wide
58
the cards with blank, vacuous faces. The sum total of their education seemed to be nothing. The word the was as foreign to them as the word elephant. I found no area where they were remotely proficient. Jasper tried like hell. He was nominally a sixth grader. His lips moved subconsciously, fighting hard to piece the proper sounds together. No sound emerged. Richard, his brother, reigned as master of the nonsense guess. I held up the word rat and Richard said, “Tree.” The other four nodded their heads seriously to show their commitment and faith in Richard’s judgment. I held up the word cat and Richard said, “Bread.” “Yep,” the others agreed, “it bread, O.K.” The twins, Samuel and Sidney, sat there unruffled by my efforts to get them to respond. They seemed to like me, probably because I did not beat them. Whenever Mrs. Brown was beating one of her students and the screams and the sound of leather on flesh drifted into the room, the twins lifted their heads, their mouths slightly open, and listened until the screams turned to sobs and the song of the belt was ended. I would bet my ass they had known Mrs. Brown’s calling card. Prophet, one of the five, could look like a clown and a tragic character at the same time. His speech was absolutely unintelligible. He did not have a speech impediment; he had five impediments. If he said anything to me, one of the other kids had to translate it. He could neither talk, read, nor write, yet he was as likable and affable as anyone in the class. His smile was infectious, crafted by some supernatural mischief-maker. He played and frolicked as a profession, not a hobby, and I was important in his life only because I was constantly interfering in his fun-filled, puckish life. Every time I asked Prophet a question, he answered me with an approximation of “yes, ma’am.” No one ever told Prophet that teachers could be male and that the phrase yes, ma’am is applied only to women. To Prophet yes, ma’am was what you said to teachers. Perhaps it was just as well, for many of the other children hit me constantly with the odious yassuh. And no matter how diligently I tried to eradicate the phrase from their vocabulary, they continued to use it. After one month of anguish and labor all of them could present a reasonable facsimile of the alphabet upon request, depending on their mood and level of inspiration. They had also mastered the first ten numbers. They also recognized with varying degrees of success approximately thirty words. Sometimes we would have spelling tests to see how well the words had actually found permanent soil. I liked to give spelling tests to this group for no other reason than to watch the magnificent cheating which invariably took place. Samuel and Sidney,
The Water is Wide
59
whose tiny heads scanned the horizon constantly for real or imagined enemies, cheated with real passion. They were inured to failure and to school. And though they were cheaters of the first magnitude, neither of them had developed any technique to avoid detection. In the middle of the spelling test Samuel’s head would be practically lying on Richard’s paper, while Sidney would simply move Jasper’s arm aside to get an unencumbered view of his paper. The challenge of suppressing cheaters who performed their dastardly deeds so openly and disingenuously and with so much intellectual relish was immense. In fact I enjoyed the performances greatly. A game I begged from an administrator in the county office proved very helpful with the five. It helped rescue them from total boredom in the classroom. It’s called Play and Talk. It resembles a poor man’s Parcheesi board, has a spinner, and the usual collection of rules. The game forces the player to spell a word using the letter of the alphabet on which he lands. When I first introduced the game, Sidney started first. He landed on the letter D. “What sound does that letter make, Sid,” I asked. “Duh,” he answered correctly. “Very good. Now spell a word that starts with the letter D.” “Dog,” he said hesitantly. “D-O-D.” Hands shot up all around him. Samuel, his twin, giggled like hell. Sidney leaned over and socked Samuel. Samuel leaned over and socked Sidney. I leaped between them and demanded that they halt this nonsense immediately. Sid leaned around my left and yanked Samuel’s ear. Samuel screamed and told me that if Sid touched him one more time he was going to kick his butt. Eventually I restored a semblance of peace and the game continued. As I watched them play on that day and on succeeding days, it was apparent that this group played for blood and not for fun. If someone missed a word the others screamed and fought to answer it correctly. So intense was the competition that I could rarely drift too far away in another part of the room without a pitched battle arising. One occasion, I looked over to find Jasper and Richard sitting nose to nose, glaring virulently at each other, saying nothing, pinching each other’s arms. Their faces were twisted in anger. Jasper pinched Richard. Then Richard pinched Jasper. And so on. When the great two-hundred-pound mediator stumbled over to intervene, I was told, “Richard cheats,” by Jasper and then, “Jasper cheats,” by Richard.
The Water is Wide
60
Both of them proved their cases conclusively. Indeed, both of them undeniably had cheated. When Prophet said that he had seen it all and that both were wrong, I nodded my head sagaciously, delivered an impromptu sermon on the need for honesty, and left them to continue the game in peace. When I looked around again, Richard and Jasper were pinching Prophet. Yet nothing bothered Prophet. He was the clown at war with a frowning world. When he found out that corporal punishment was not my trump card, he spent his whole life improvising irritations to test my self-control. He would walk up to me and make these ludicrous faces. Sticking out his tongue or rolling his eyes, he followed me around making faces or stealing my wallet from my back pocket. He loved games and this was why he adapted so well to the Play and Talk game. It was during a session of this game that Prophet electrified the class and held it unwittingly in the palm of his hand for several staggering moments. He spun the dial and landed on the letter F. He properly identified the letter and its sound. But naming a word that started with F proved a considerable challenge. Finally, after long and tortured deliberation, he came out with a word. “Fuck,” he said rather smugly. The class and the teacher of the class were stunned. Prophet grinned. “What did you say, Prophet?” I asked inanely. “Fuck,” he repeated, with bell-like clarity for Prophet. “Would you please spell that word, Prophet?” I asked, praying for deliverance. “F-U-X,” he spelled. “Do you mean ‘fox,’ Prophet?” “Yas’m. Look like dawg.” The class erupted. Prophet smiled broadly, amazed and pleased by his ability to evoke laughter from the elder section of Yamacraw scholars.
The Water is Wide
61
Chapter 4 Each day when school was over, it became my habit to set off in a new direction on the island, exploring, walking, singing to myself, and generally enjoying the isolation and silences of Yamacraw’s forests. These daily expeditions took me all over the island. And though I enjoyed these walks, several characteristics of the island made them uncomfortable and even painful. The island swarmed with mosquitoes. Whenever a human being left the front door of his house, legions of mosquitoes with their hypodermic snouts would cover the wretch from head to foot. It is difficult to know whether I am exaggerating or not, but I do know for certain that they made life on the island extremely uncomfortable and that no matter how extensive one’s precautions against them were, no matter how much repellent one applied to his body, the mosquitoes still managed to get in their licks. They buzzed around my head in squadrons during all my walks. One day Frank showed me an island trick to keep them at their distance. He tore a leafy branch from a small tree and waved it back and forth across his back. “You hear ‘em, you swat ‘em,” he told me. So armed with this surrogate cow’s tail and covered with enough insect repellent to kill a dinosaur, I would troop out toward the beach road, glistening like a Polynesian fresh from a coconut bath. The beach road began about a quarter of a mile from the school. It cut through a black-water swamp where the deer and the moccasins played. It was a dark and brooding part of the island, very wild and uninhabited. Purple and yellow wildflowers grew in profusion. The first time I walked the road I was shocked to find two odd-looking brick structures on a curve in the road. There was a sign on one of the buildings that read SILVER DEW WINERY 1953. A little further down the road was a magnificent old house with wagon wheels in the yard and the forlorn appearance assumed by all houses that have lost
The Water is Wide
62
their people. I went up to the house and peered into the windows. The furniture was good and functional, yet cobwebs and brown spiders had claimed the walls for themselves. At the back of the house, above the back door, was a very large and tattered Confederate flag. What the flag was doing there I never found out, but it was odd how the house and the flag seemed to fit together in this silent tribute to a lost people and a forgotten cause. I have known a great many Confederate flag nuts in my life, rabid dreamers who dwell on the glory of Fort Sumter and Bull Run and repress the reality of Appomattox. The Confederate flag summons primitive emotions in these people. Recently it only disgusts me, although there was a time I revered it as religiously as Christians revere the cross. Here on Yamacraw, fastened over the door of a peeling house, mute in its testimony to a defeated cause and an expiring way of life, the flag had more dignity than I had ever noticed before. Perhaps the dignity was, in fact, that the flag was dead and the house was dead, and I was only passing by. I passed by the house each day in the month of September on the way to the beach, for the beach was the best single place on the island. Ten miles of beach front and not a damn person on it except me. I would come out of the swamp and race full speed past the sand and sea oats. I would hit the beach sprinting as hard as I could go. The beach breeze kept the five million mosquitoes hovering in the forest behind me. I would run until I got tired, then strip naked and swim in the surf. The water was shallow and very warm, but the salt felt good on my mosquito bites, and there is something undeniably salubrious for the soul about floating naked in the surf without another human being in sight or sound, free from the encumbrances or worries of the classroom. After the swim, I would walk far down the beach, often to Bloody Point, where the British once drove a tribe of Indians to the end of the island and slaughtered them, men, women, and children, at the edge of the sea. I used to walk and look at the dead horseshoe crabs, strange prehistoric creatures who simply could not cope with the pollution of the Savannah River and had washed ashore at Yamacraw by the hundred. The whole beach stunk of death and decaying marine life. At the end of the island I could see the factories belching and puking into the sky. The same factories that had killed the Yamacraw oysters and the economy of the island had not spared the defenseless, clumsy, and harmless horseshoe crabs. The legacy of the factories was here on the beach.
The Water is Wide
63
After one week on the island, I knew that Ted Stone was king. The reason I knew it is that Ted Stone told me so. I would go down and pick up my mail every day at five o’clock. Invariably Ted would come out to talk about the school, about the people of the island, and about his position among them. He and his wife not only cornered every job available on the island, but their home also contained the short-wave radio that was the sole means of communication with the mainland. Piss off Ted Stone and the possibility for a delay on the radio was certainly there. Ted was also the quintessential outdoorsman. He hunted religiously, fished expertly, and shrimped the waters off Yamacraw to supplement his already sizable income. I would often come in his yard to find the carcass of a deer strung from a tree, the carnage of the hunt in evidence all around, guts littering the ground, and Ted sitting proudly on a lawn chair. He could do things with his hands very well. He could plow a field, milk a cow, gut a hog, cook a trout, clean a rifle—all the things that made us such complete opposites. His eyes were ice blue and suspicious. He was thickly built with powerful arms and a great barrel of a chest. He was short with a remarkable mane of gray hair and a handsome, weather-beaten face. Ted was a fine-looking man. And not a few black residents of the island had stated in no uncertain terms that Ted Stone was a son of a bitch. Yet, in the early days, Ted went out of his way to be kind to me. His wife, Lou, was an extremely proficient woman. A lover of flowers and solitude, she seemed perfectly adapted to the Spartan existence on Yamacraw. She drove the school bus as proudly and as competently as Junior Johnson drives his stock cars. She delivered mail daily, depending upon the weather and her mood. The post office was located in the back of their house. It was a small clean room, which she kept securely padlocked because of the “nigras.” She claimed to be extremely interested in the education of the poor children I was teaching. All the educational deficiencies of the children she blamed on Miss Glover, whom she—like everyone else—believed to be the voodoo woman of the island. Mrs. Brown, on the other hand, ranked in the major leagues as a savior of epic proportions; she was teaching the children manners and one thing these children needed was manners. Both Stones worried about the morality of the nigras. “They’re savages,” Ted exclaimed over and over. “They sleep with one another’s wives and husbands. They sleep with anyone that comes
The Water is Wide
64
along. They are filthy savages who shouldn’t be allowed to have children. They drink all night long while their children are starving. They all ought to be shot.” Ted’s eyes would sparkle maniacally whenever he got upset. Lou would add, “There are a couple of good ones. Aunt Ruth is just as sweet as she could be. And Mrs. Brown is part Indian, you know. It’s the ones who are pure black who are really worthless.” These were my kiss-ass days. I needed Ted and Lou. I kept my boat at their dock; I would be renting a house through them as soon as certain legal entanglements were straightened out; they brought my mail; they sold me fresh eggs and milk; and they provided my transportation. According to my early philosophy of survival on the island, I had to have Ted and Lou on my side. They wielded enormous power—even the power of life and death. One day during the second week Lou told me a very illuminating story. Her youngest son had gone to school on the island. When I asked if Mrs. Brown or Miss Glover had taught him, she quickly explained that he did not go to school with the nigras but had gone to the white school. “I didn’t know they had a white school,” I said. “They built one just for my son so he wouldn’t have to go to school with the coloreds.” “You’re kidding?” I asked incredulously. “They built a one-room schoolhouse, hired a teacher to come over here and live in the school, and she taught my son.” “No one else went to the school? No other white kids?” I questioned. “No other white kids on the island,” she replied. “Of course we wouldn’t send our child with the coloreds. George deserved as good an education as any other white child. That’s what we demanded and that’s what we got.” “One teacher for one child! That’s not bad,” I said. “Mrs. Brown lives in the white schoolhouse now,” Lou said. “My George got a good education there. A real fine education.” Despite my objections to Ted Stone’s theories of apartheid, his paranoia about my long hair, and the new morality, I enjoyed jogging down to his house, picking up my mail, and then swimming off his dock. I also found Ted to be a fascinating raconteur. The stories he told had the flavor of earth, blood, and the hunt. He had been a
The Water is Wide
65
trapper, a professional fisherman, a hunter of some repute, and a plasterer in Fort Lauderdale, Florida. He killed deer for pleasure and for food, shot rattlesnakes as a public service, and fished the waters off Yamacraw with religious regularity. He had once run a restaurant on Yamacraw. His wife had cooked and served the food; he had plied the customers with beer. The customers were fishermen from Savannah and Bluffton. According to Mr. Stone, his restaurant did a thriving business on weekends. When I asked why he didn’t still run the place, he answered rather succinctly, “Niggers wanted to get served, just like whites. Had to close it.” Of course if it hadn’t been the niggers, then the hippies would probably have wanted to buy a beer under his roof, and he would not have had any of that. Yet his life was fascinating to me, in that it was so different from my own. My father taught me how to shoot a hook shot, lead a fast break, and feed off to the open man; he also instructed me how to throw a cross-body block and how to field a ground ball skimming across a short-grassed infield. To my father life offered no finer pleasures or more consummate skills. Mr. Stone, in contrast, could skin and clean a deer in an hour, take apart a boat motor and assemble it again, milk a cow, plant a garden, fix a muffler, and drag a seine across a shallow inlet in preparation for a shrimp dinner. My life was centered around academics and sports; Stone’s was concerned with the arts of survival. I depended on supermarkets and theaters; Stone frequented feed stores and garden-supply shops when he journeyed to Savannah. So I listened to Stone and was glad to be learning. He loved to talk about himself and nothing could have been more instructive to me. On a whim, he had once traveled to Florida with a group of friends, bought the boat which Humphrey Bogart captained in the film The African Queen, and brought it back to Yamacraw Island, where it survived a year then rotted slowly into oblivion. It gave me an immense thrill to think that my boat docked in the same spot which once harbored the African Queen. It fired the Irish romanticism within me, as did Mr. Stone’s accounts of the hurricane of ‘59 that crushed boats and docks like playthings, that uprooted oak trees as tall as towers, that incapacitated a town thirty miles from the island and made it a national disaster area. As his house creaked ominously, Ted and Lou sipped coffee and watched the gods of storm seize the wind and river for several violent hours. Stone’s powers of description were excellent. He spent two hours one day relating his war experiences. He had landed on the third wave
The Water is Wide
66
during D-Day, fought his way across France, teamed up with a sharpshooting Texan, who together with Stone formed a murderously competent sniping team, and eventually crossed into Germany when the armistice was signed. With eyes blue and shimmering, yet serious and fatalistic, he described a German soldier’s head rising above a roof-top ledge, how he waited until he could see the German’s whole head, until he could see the face was young and unlined. He aimed carefully and put a bullet between the eyes of his enemy. It was a strange story, strangely told, and Ted Stone grew uncharacteristically reflective and philosophical as he thought of the life he snuffed out somewhere in France twenty-five years before. “Killing a man is different from killing a deer.” Yet he was intensely proud that he had killed other men in the defense of his country. A faded American flag flew from a wooden pole in the backyard of the Stone house. This was the symbol of the post office, yet also seemed to symbolize Stone’s allegiance to his country which was blind, uncompromising, unconditional, and though he would have fought me had he heard me express the thought, almost Third Reich in its fervor and rigidity. One night at the Stones’ is memorable. It was October 15, Moratorium Day, when the United States reverberated with the chants and pleadings of those discontented with the war. I wanted desperately to watch the news that night, to see how the Washington march went, and to see the reaction of people around the country to the moratorium itself. I had a pretty good idea about what Ted thought about the moratorium, but I did not realize that I would be watching the greatest show on earth in Ted’s living room. As soon as the news came on, Ted began a long monologue which continued unabated till I excused myself an hour later. “Look at those long-haired bastards. Can’t tell if they’re boys or girls. Worse than Germans or Japs. Look at that hippie with the flag sewed to his butt. I’d cut it off his ass with a butcher knife if I was there. Take half of his ass with it. Lice. All they are is lice. Huntley and Brinkley are lice, too. They aren’t supporting our boys in Vietnam. Naw. They’re lice. Just like that nigger Martin Luther King. He was a goddam Communist sure as hell. Ask J. Edgar Hoover. Now there’s a man. Finest man in America. He calls a spade a spade. Look at them lice there now. Cute, ain’t they? I wouldn’t give them a drink of piss if they were dyin’ of thirst. There are some niggers. Every time you turn on TV you see the niggers. They even got them brushin’ their teeth on TV. Hippies. Goddam Communist hippies. Dirty, don’t take baths. We got some hippies coming
The Water is Wide
67
to this island now. Those California boys are just hippies that get their hair cut before they come here. All of ‘em’s lice. Niggerlovin’ lice. There’s the White House. Where the President of the United States lives. Where the President of the United States of America leads his people. Wallace wouldn’t have had it. There would have been bodies lyin’ all over the streets if he had gotten in. He’d of used flame throwers and tanks.” Stone talked and I listened. It was insane, ludicrous, and frightening. His face curled in hatred. He forgot I was in the room. He smelled blood and his whole personality was transfixed to the thought that the marchers should die en masse on Constitution Avenue. He wanted them dead, he said, “to give America a good name in the free world.” D. P. Conroy said nothing. Stricken with fright, I saw the awesome display of weapons mounted in Stone’s front room and did not wish to give Stone even the slightest reason to identify me with the Washington marchers. When I left, Stone told me to come watch the news with him anytime. The next day I was swimming off Stone’s dock after school. The water was growing colder, but its bracing chill seemed to clean out the frustrations for a little while. Stone came down to the dock and started talking. This time he talked of fishing. “Good fishing off this dock here,” he said. “Catch a whole string of winter trout, right now. Might even catch a sea trout or two. My son caught a ten-foot shark off this dock a year ago.” In three strokes I covered about twenty yards of water. In a flash of spray and spume and chilled blood, I stood upon the dock a scant four seconds after Stone delivered the news about the shark. “Are there lots of sharks out there?” I asked, my voice squeaking and my knees filled with jelly. “Oh, lots of them. They hang around the dock a lot.” “That’s great, Mr. Stone. That is really great. You mean I have been swimming in shark-infested waters all this time and you never told me!” “You knew sharks lived in salt water.” “I did not know they had a clubhouse under your dock, or my young ass would never have hit water. Sharks eat people, Mr. Stone.” “Not around here. I’ve never heard of anyone getting eaten around here.” “Well, I sure don’t want to become a precedent.” My afternoon swims ended for all time on that day.
The Water is Wide
68
Several friends of mine in Beaufort warned me about forming any kind of relationship with Zeke Skimberry. Skimberry was the maintenance man of the Bluffton district and because of a decree emanating from the high echelons of the educational hierarchy, Zeke was designated as the official guardian of my boat. Skimberry aroused suspicion in many quarters because of his sycophantic allegiance to Ezra Bennington. Zeke had survived many purges of personnel and many tumultuous years in the Bluffton school system by affixing his fate to the more luminous and permanent star of Bennington. He mowed Bennington’s grass, moved cumbersome early American furniture around Mrs. Bennington’s plush antique shop, and acted as Bennington’s chauffeur, valet, and servant when the occasion demanded it. Behind his back, people hissed that Zeke was “Bennington’s nigger” and nothing more. I found a lot more. He was, on first meeting, one of the warmest, most genuinely friendly people I had ever met. His large blue eyes danced and flashed expressively, puckishly; a grin constantly played about his mouth. He was lean but muscled by constant exposure to physical labor and his face revealed an intelligence, an alertness, that both surprised and delighted me. Zeke was a California transplant, a divorcé who drifted out of an unhappy marriage in the West, wandered from job to job, drank good whiskey under the skies of many states, until he met and fell in love with Ida McKee, a striking young blonde hitting a cash register in a general store near Bluffton, South Carolina. Zeke drove her to Georgia after a madcap courtship, married her with the benediction of an itchy-palmed justice of the peace, and returned to Bluffton to begin the second act of his life in completely new surroundings. In fourteen years in Bluffton he had sired two sons and managed to worm his way so completely into Bennington’s life and make himself so indispensable that he sometimes seemed like Bennington’s third leg. When Bennington was in power, Zeke’s position was enviable, but now that Bennington’s career was in its eclipse, Zeke was beginning to feel the pressure of insecurity again. My relationship with Zeke Skimberry and his family started slowly and inauspiciously but gathered momentum and intimacy as the year passed. He was impossible to dislike. He loved to tease, to banter lightly with all who crossed his path, and to mimic the supervisors who ruled him. At our first meeting he told me, “People over here think you are crazy for teachin’ at that school.” “People over here are exactly right,” I answered.
The Water is Wide
69
“Of course, all these people are crazy themselves, so there’s no tellin’,” he said with his eyes dancing, mischievous, and very blue. Then he said with great seriousness, “Course, the niggers on Yamacraw have needed something for a damn long time. I sure hope you can help those little nigger kids.” The most fascinating thing about Zeke Skimberry, however, was his irrepressible wife, Ida. She was a poetess of profanity, an oracle of epithets who could outcuss a bathroom wall. Unlike most women I have known, she placed no value on shallow pretensions or hypocritical displays of gentility. Her first words to me as I drove into her yard on a Sunday afternoon the first week in September marked her as a person to be handled gently and with caution. From the screened-in porch of her tiny house, she yelled, “What in the hell are you looking for?” “Ma’am, I’m looking for Zeke Skimberry, the janitor.” “He’s not a goddam janitor. He’s the maintenance man. Everybody’s always calling him a janitor. Well, who in the hell are you?” she asked with eyes ablazing. “I’m Pat Conroy, ma’am. I teach over on Yamacraw Island, and I was supposed to get in touch with your husband, Mrs. Skimberry.” “He ain’t here now. Come on inside and git yourself a cup of coffee.” As I got out of the car, she startled me again by saying, “Hot as a bitch, ain’t it?” “Yes, ma’am, it certainly is.” In no way had my mother with her air of gentility and fine breeding prepared me for the Ida Skimberrys of the world. The coffeepot, positioned in honorable perpetuity on the stove, was the center of the tiny Skimberry universe, and over the year we consumed gallons of the steaming, hot brew as Zeke rambled on about the idiosyncracies of his work or the insecurity of his position. Or Ida would curse fluently at the lack of money, at her husband’s lack of status, or at her inability to find a decent job. During the week I parked my car in the Skimberrys’ yard under Ida’s vigilant eye. After my second week on the island, after Zeke had picked me up at Alljoy Landing, and after consuming three cups of coffee while describing the events of the week, I walked out to my car to discover that Ida had washed the car and cleaned out the inside during the week. She had also found a sack of dirty clothes in the backseat. She had washed and ironed all the clothes and neatly
The Water is Wide
70
folded them in a cardboard box. I was overwhelmed by this kindness. I thanked her with genuine emotion, but all she said was, “Shit, the goddam car needed washin’ and the goddam clothes needed a good cleanin’.” Then her face, which could be hard as a callus, softened into a magnificently warm smile and she said, “I enjoy doin’ things for people.” It did not take me long to warm to this kind of people. And just as I had entered a new realm of experience on Yamacraw, I also walked on fresh territory each time I entered the door to Zeke and Ida’s house. My background did not expose me to white people who subsisted on $4000 a year, who did not have a set of china for special meals, who did not select a pattern of silver, and who had not graduated from high school. I had never dealt directly with people who felt their lives enriched by weekly odysseys to wrestling matches. The Skimberrys were of a different social class than I and one of the year’s miracles was my introduction to their way of life, to their complete and ingenuous acceptance of me as a friend, and to the perspective they gave me of society and the men on top as viewed from the bottom. I came to love the Skimberrys devotedly, for without reason, they took me into their home, told me their dreams and disappointments, shared with me the intimate secrets and compromises of their lives. They bared their souls before me because of an elementary honesty that did not understand guile or pretense. I was part of their life and it became important to the Yamacraw story as events took place and circumstances shifted. And how many mornings or afternoons do I remember Ida’s voice rasping, as I came through the door, “Pat, you ol’ son of a bitch, git you some coffee.” I saw the town of Bluffton through the eyes of Zeke Skimberry. In the early morning, before the insect noise had died in the woods near his house, Zeke would sit in his favorite chair, sip hot coffee from a thick, cream-colored mug, and talk about the town. He was one of those men who were gifted storytellers, who could capture the spirit of a place by recounting forgotten incidents, or by digging up skeletons the town might have preferred to leave buried and untouched. Zeke knew the merchants, the cheaters, the lonely, the schizophrenic, the lusty, the insane, the religious, the hypocritical, the blacks, the rednecks, the generous. He knew them all and could sketch an accurate biography of everyone who lived in town, He knew who slept with whom, who wanted to sleep with whom, and who would sleep with whom. He could list every murder that had occurred in the past ten years, how much blood was lost, where the bullet or knife struck, and how stiff the body
The Water is Wide
71
was when discovered by authorities. He knew the authorities, too, with all their frailties and flaws, with all their weaknesses and pretensions. It was over coffee that I learned about Zeke and Ida and grew to love them. Their house was alive with joy, laughter, and worry over money, derision of professionals and hacks; their house was warm, good, and filled with coffee smells. And both of them loved to talk of their town. Bluffton perched above the winding, tide-ruled May River, egrets fished its shores, and fleets of long bateaux explored the blind inlets and creeks in search of productive oyster beds. Bluffton is a town of matchless serenity, a town thick with glinting, towering magnolias, impressive oaks, sloughs glutted with wildflowers, peeling but remarkably attractive houses. A church built from cypress stands beside the river; a structure of elegant simplicity and fine lines built by slaves, and presided over by the omnipresent town pillar, the deacon of deacons, Ezra Bennington. Bluffton is sleepy, magisterially silent, and enjoys a benediction of flowers every brilliant spring. Yet it is a town that retains many of the wrinkles and arthritic cramps of the Old South. There was the story of Thomas, a massive black man whom Zeke and I often passed in the morning on our way to gas up. Thomas would sit in the middle of a large group of animated black men on the steps of a crumbling tenement. He was incredibly large, a redwood among the smaller pines. “That’s a damn big nigger, ain’t he,” Zeke would say. “Yep,” I would reply rurally. “He’s had a tough life, ol’ Thomas. When he was just a young boy, not more’n about fifteen or sixteen, he used to help deliver ice door to door. Now those were the days when there wasn’t such things as refrigerators. When you said icebox, you meant a damn box with a big hunk of ice in it. So ol’ Thomas, being a big son of a bitch, could lift them hunks of ice pretty easy and carry them door to door. One day he went up to a house at Alljoy Beach and knocked on the door. A young white girl answered his knock. Well, Thomas didn’t talk real good, anyway, so he got real nervous and asked this white girl if she wanted a piece, meaning a piece of ice for the icebox. Well, the girl misunderstood what Thomas was tryin’ to say, you know, thought he was trying to give her a piece of his pecker. She screamed and raised hell till every white man in town was running down to her. Now you know how this town is, now. Can you imagine what those people were thinkin’ then? This big ol’ Thomas trying to get into a little white
The Water is Wide
72
girl’s britches. He was lucky they didn’t lynch him and cut his balls off. As it was, they tried him and sent him up for twenty-somethin’ years. All the time, Thomas just stood there looking kind of dumb and muttering that all he wanted was to sell her some ice. The bad thing about it, Pat, was that this girl was crazy as hell, anyway. A month after the trial she went completely nuts and spent the rest of her life in a mental hospital.” “What a horrible, goddam story, Zeke.” “Just goes to show you that people will shit on a nigger and never think a thing about it. People around here are just prejudiced against niggers. Want to see them all dead. Want to see them all shipped back to Africa. All these good Christian people.” “Good Christian people” was the most cynical epithet in Zeke’s repertoire. He and Ida had been very active members of the local Baptist church until the congregation voted to close the church if a nigger ever tried to attend a service. Zeke and Ida simply never went back after that. “Can you imagine, Pat. A bunch of Christians keeping another bunch of Christians from praying. Can you see Jesus sitting at the front door of the church saying, ‘Hey, you shit-eatin’ niggers, you can’t come in this here church. Go to your own nigger church.’ Yeh, I can just see Jesus doing that.” Zeke and Ida mouthed the regional prejudices against blacks constantly, and believed implicitly in almost every stereotype ever concocted against blacks in the South. Yet every black man or woman I brought to their house was invited inside, offered coffee, and treated with dignity and warmth. Later, Ida would tell me, “That was sure a nice nigger man you brought here this morning. I hope you bring him back again real soon.” I could never place this dichotomy of attitude, could never understand it, could never be comfortable around such a casual, unself-conscious use of the word nigger, but ultimately came to accept it as the way Zeke and Ida were, no more and no less. They instinctively liked all people but had been conditioned to dislike and depreciate blacks. Several conversations with Ida were enough to convince me that all the sermonizing in the world could not shake the foundation of her thirty-three years in Bluffton. I came from the river one day in the spring, and Ida said, “Pat, I just done a terrible thing today. Little Eddie has been havin’ trouble with
The Water is Wide
73
his glands again, so I decided to call a specialist in Savannah to have a look.” “It’s best to go to a specialist when you think somethin’s really the matter, Ida.” “Yeh, that’s why I called. Well, this doctor gets on the phone and tells me to bring Eddie in on Thursday morning, ten o’clock sharp.” “Nothin’ wrong with that, Ida.” Then she lowered her voice and said, “Pat, I do believe I called me a nigger doctor.” “No,” I said, shrinking back in mock horror. “It ain’t funny. Wouldn’t make no difference to a stupid bastard like yourself, anyhow. But goddam it, I ain’t sending my young ‘un to no nigger doctor.” “Why do you think this doctor is black, Ida?” “He talked like a nigger,” she answered. “You know that funny way niggers talk. You can tell a nigger a mile away when he opens his mouth. And I looked at his street in the phone book, and Pat, I ain’t never heard of no street by this name. Have you?” I looked at the address and professed ignorance. “Only a nigger doctor would have an address on a street no one’s ever heard of,” she continued. “I think the phone company should tell you who is and who isn’t a nigger doctor.” “He’s probably as good as any of the white doctors, Ida.” “Goddam it, Pat, if I don’t think you’re part nigger yourself sometimes. Now tell me quick what I kin do. Kin I call him down there, very polite and all, and say, ‘Hello, I made an appointment with you the other day, but I didn’t know you were a nigger doctor. I meant no harm and I thank you for your kindness. I just feel that a person should go to his own kind.’ You think that’d do it?” “That’d do it O.K., Ida. He’d probably tell you to get laid.” “And I’d kick him in the goddam ass if he did,” she bristled. Yet within her own family circle, Ida was considered an unregenerated liberal. Sometimes her mother, sisters, and in-laws would stop by her house to exchange gossip while I was still there. These exchanges always amazed me. The subject of race was a violent and recurrent theme.
The Water is Wide
74
“If one of them nigger teachers even lays a hand on my child, I’ll kill her deader than hell. I’ll kill her, I swear on a Bible, I’ll kill her,” one of Ida’s sisters would say. “Shore you’d kill her,” someone would say. “If one of them niggers even looks cross-eyed at my girl, she’s gonna have me sittin’ on her ass,” another voice of reason rang out. “Shore you would, honey.” In the midst of all this, Ida’s youngest sister would turn to her little girl and ask softly, “What are you, sugar?” And the little girl would reply dramatically, “I’m a sweet little Christian girl who loves the baby Jesus.” And everybody would answer chorally, “Sure you love Jesus, honey. We all love Jesus.” Except Ida. She would mouth the word bullshit and wink at me. Then the harangue would continue on the other side of the kitchen table. “I mean if these niggers want to teach in white schools, they can’t go around knockin’ white children. Otherwise, I’m gonna have to knock their goddam heads off.” “Shore you will, honey.” Then Ida would shock the gathering by declaring, “Hell, I told Eddie’s teacher to beat the shit out of him if he gave her any sass. She’s a damn good teacher and a nice lady besides. I want her to hit my young ‘un if he acts up. How else is she gonna teach ‘im?” “Why, Ida, sometimes you talk just plain trash.” “You shore do, honey.” “You’d let a nigger hit pore little Eddie?” “Damn right, I would,” Ida answered. Then, to heal the wounds opened by the argument, the youngest sister again would gaze worshipfully into the eyes of her child and say, “What are you, sugar?” And the fat, saccharine, little cherub would reply, “I’m a sweet little Christian girl who loves the baby Jesus.” And Ida would mouth the word bullshit again and wink.
At the end of September, a month which had assumed the dimensions of an eternity, I left my corner of the schoolroom for the more spacious quarters of the Buckner house. Taking all things in
The Water is Wide
75
consideration, I had hated living in the school, shaving without a mirror with cold water, cooking in pots big enough to hold small cows, and sleeping on a cot sprinkled lightly with chalk dust. Chalk dust has a way of conquering a room, and I was faintly weary of waking up feeling like a butterfly wing or a powdered underarm. And I was tired of dwelling in the same place I worked. The whole situation was becoming unbearable. A lot of frustration had to do with me. When I first envisioned myself on the island, a noble creature enshrined among the illiterate masses working in the primitive conditions that would have warmed the cockles of Henry Thoreau’s heart, I did not consider my compulsive need for friends and good conversation. I love people and collect friends like some people collect coins or exotic pipes. So far, the people of the island had “yassuhed” me to death. I was the white principal, a figure of authority, which in itself could not be trusted. The white people, without exception, were back-to-Africa advocates, believers in the small-brain theory, and as suspicious a bunch as I had ever met. To everybody I met, I flashed the toothy grin, the hearty salutation, and the slap-happy demeanor of someone desperately in need of friendship. But in the space of a month I had failed to establish any allegiances. I had often fantasized myself as being the world’s greatest undiscovered poet, living in obscurity and biding my time until the seeds of greatness germinated and I would cast poems to the world. In the first month I tried to write these poems. In fact, I tried to write many things, but my mind was so boggled by the circumstances of my students and my own life was so uncertain and without direction that I found myself writing mawkish doggerel and prose of an extraordinary purplish tinge. The month of September was a ludicrous month and I was a ludicrous person. There was another reason I wished to leave the schoolhouse. One night, as a storm gathered over the island, and the thunder rumbled menacingly above, I was lying in bed reading. The night was coal black except for brief intervals when lightning illuminated the sky. As I was reading, my head against the pillow, my bed underneath a window that afforded me a view of the playground, I felt a sudden strange and frightening sensation. I looked up and saw the face of a grinning black man wearing a beret, staring at me through the window. His face was less than two feet away from me. I was momentarily stunned with fright and shock. My face evidently reflected my emotions, for the man turned suddenly and raced off in a sprint toward
The Water is Wide
76
the forest. As he ran, a maniacal, animalistic howl split the darkness. The howl grew fainter the farther away he ran. Massaging my heart, trying to get it beating again, I tried to make some move appropriate to the situation. The face had startled me; the noise had terrified me. The face, framed in the window, against the backdrop of night and storm, was a metaphor of lunacy, a blank and uncomprehending face with a smile devoid of feeling. I was completely unnerved. I turned out the lights and tried to see if the creature still lurked around the school. I grabbed a baseball bat and went from window to window trying to catch a glimpse of my unnamed visitor. Since no shades hung from the windows, I had no way of preventing eyes from peering into my room, no way to shut myself off from the outside. Had I seen this stranger again, peeking in at me with those possessed eyes and demonic smile, I am certain I would have died of fright. The baseball bat slept with me that night, an uncomfortable but comforting bed partner. I slept miserably, fearing that whoever the guy was, there was always the chance he could break into the kitchen and gain access to my room. If he did, I promised myself, he would be facing an antagonist crazed with fear, a desire to live, and carrying a baseball bat that would remove heads if the occasion required. When the dawn finally arrived—oh blessed dawn, oh holy light, oh lovely sun—and I explained to Mrs. Brown what had happened, she told me that I had met face to face with Mad Billie. I got to know Mad Billie well after the incident. He was the resident crazy person on the island, the genuine Quasimodo who earned his living and insured his survival by being considered crazy. Everyone called him Mad Billie to his face and behind his back. He chopped wood, carried packages, and delivered messages for people on the island, white and black alike. The Stones told me authoritatively that Billie was crazy, but harmless and would not hurt a fly. Mrs. Brown ran him off the school grounds every time he came around, saying that he was “retarded” and liable to molest the girls. Billie’s guise of craziness dropped whenever he spoke to me about Mrs. Brown. He hated her guts and his most common epithet directed toward her was “shitass.” Billie talked as if he were living a dream sequence, which perhaps he was. He cursed with gusto, smiled constantly and vacuously, talked strangely and vaguely and mostly to himself, and lived rather contentedly while playing his role of island lunatic. Billie always seemed to know what was going on. One would find him all over the island—coming out of the woods carrying an ax, or running full speed up one of the island roads. He was rabbit fast and
The Water is Wide
77
ran almost everywhere he went, often making the preternatural noise I heard on that stormy night. The noise was his personal trademark, a kind of calling card he carried with him. I walked with Billie to the beach one afternoon in October. He suddenly broke into a run, emitted his patented hellish whine, and disappeared into the forest. By now accustomed to Billie’s personal flamboyancies, I continued toward the beach. As I walked along, Billie froze me once more by making his noise from the branch of a tree I was walking under. When he saw me jump, he threw back his head and laughed his registered crazy laugh. Ol’ Billie was a weird guy. Because of Billie I was glad to be moving out of the school, but tragedy brought me to the house I was renting. Viola Buckner, an island matriarch and an important bridge in the tenuous relationship between blacks and whites on the island, left home during the summer for an operation. She never returned to the island. When the doctors opened her stomach, they found that cancer had established complete dominion. She died several days later. Her house was a neat, clapboard structure with a wilderness of vines and plants running over the yard and field around the house. Inside, the house was a patchwork of various woods, a gingerbread house of conflicting colors and patterns, pasteboard and tile thrown together ar random. One attribute made this house a palace on Yamacraw. It possessed a shiny, glistening white commode, a treasure of inestimable value and an invention that overshadows the wheel as necessary for man’s comfort and convenience. Since I had sampled several of the Yamacraw privies, the presence of the toilet delighted me. The smell of feces and urine-stained wood has never struck me as a gratifying sensual experience and my middle-class background had not prepared me for life without scented toilet paper. This particular commode was a monument of sorts. Viola, like the other black residents of the island, used the outhouse her entire life. But Viola had had dreams. She had the toilet installed several months before she died. She had told people that if she sat on her commode only one time, it would have been worth the price to her. As I stared at Viola’s toilet, I saluted her and her dream. Some unknown hand had painted the bathroom walls a passionate pink. A calendar hung on one wall advertising Black Draught Laxative and Cardui Pills for women “who really want help on ‘those certain days.’” The living room was small and cramped with dark brown, squatty furniture. A picture of the risen Christ with the attendant angels
The Water is Wide
78
swarming like pigeons around him held the place of honor above the oil heater. A great many framed photographs lined the walls. Photographs have always made me very sad. Here in Viola’s house, it seemed sacrilegious to stare at old photographs of nameless blacks, many of whom had died years before. The scrubbed faces of smiling people were beautifully captured by a lens that froze a brief, escaping moment, froze it into a single, essential study; the moment having passed, those lives continued and finally snuffed out. Age had faded the photographs. One picture particularly caught and held my eye, not only for its inappropriateness to the other memorabilia in the room but also because of its haunting relationship to my own life. It was the picture of a Corsair, a stubby black fighter plane whose vintage years were in the early 1950s. My father, a career Marine, had often flown over our house when I was a first grader, dipping his wings and otherwise making his presence known to the tiny world assembled on the front yard below him. In my youth, when I looked to planes as sources of illimitable power and freedom and looked to my father as the tamer of the great black birds he controlled, the Corsair became a symbol of the past. As a boy I worshiped the Marine Corps, her planes, and her pilots. I built model airplanes and dreamed of the day when I would pilot a black plane through the blue skies. But the 1960s and the turbulence of social change and the ominous presence of the unholy Asian war killed my dreams of flight and soldierdom. From the ashes of the Corsair rose the passionate do-gooder. Here, on Viola’s wall, in odd juxtaposition with the other artifacts of Viola’s house, flew a Corsair, the dark shadow of my childhood. Why the Corsair? I would never find out. My bedroom resembled a small cave. With the shutters closed and the lights out, I could not see my five fingers in front of my face. I was in. I was home. My depression had nothing to do with my house. It was me. All of the people were fishermen. Good fishermen. They were good because it was necessary to be good. The river was their supermarket, their corner store, and their largest garden. In my afternoon walks I would often come upon a silent group of men and women sitting on the edge of the dock, studying the long and jointed cane poles that rested on the weathered railings. A couple of men would always be crabbing, using the skinned corpse of a possum for bait. In a tree near the river was the skeleton of an osprey who had come too near the fishermen the previous summer. It must have
The Water is Wide
79
been a large, beautiful bird with magnificent plumage, but its skeleton, hung like a warning to other fowl, was a portentous reminder that the fishermen were also hunters who killed for pleasure as well as for food. They fished in conjunction with the tides. They read the message of the tides as easily as commuters read newspapers. I learned this after a very short time on the island. I would sometimes go down and watch them fish, although many times I would find no one on the dock. “The tides ain’t right,” it was explained. If the tides were not right, then there would be no fish, and if there were no fish, then there would be no people. And I would sit on the dock alone with the osprey’s skeleton behind me. I tried to decipher the tides and what certain part of the cycle marked the coming of the fish. One thing I knew for certain, the people and the fish arrived together as though it had been arranged by a higher power for a long time. After watching several times it seemed that the people fished when the tide slowed somewhat and was beginning to consider a rest before the great reversal and the heavy flow of salt water in the opposite direction. When the water grew sluggish, relinquished its swiftness, rested against the marshes, and waited for the moon to assert its power again, then the people would appear with their shrimp and poles. They fished at the beginning and end of the tides, never in the middle. The fish abided by these rules. I met many of the black islanders in this manner. They threw a thousand yassuhs in my direction, which made me uncomfortable, but I met some of the island’s most colorful figures when I went down to talk with the fishermen. Aunt Ruth was one. She was eighty years old, in marvelous physical condition, and possessed the face of a lost cherub. She loved conversation and enjoyed talking about her life on the island. “I be on this island plenty long time. I the midwife over here. All these chillun on this island my chillun. I take them out of their mothers. I see ‘em when they first be born. I deliver so many chillun. Over one hunnert. All those chillun you teach yonder schoolhouse. They all my chillun. My husband be the undertaker befo’ he die. I bring the people into the eart’. He put ‘em back in.” She would talk about her memories of the island in the past before modern civilization had ruined it. She remembered the first car that had driven on the island and the first plane that had flown overhead.
The Water is Wide
80
She was a kind of repository of history and island lore. She also made potent batches of plum and blackberry wines at her house. She kept me supplied with both types during the entire year. Quick Fella was another. I saw him pass the school one day on the way to the island church. The kids saw him at the same time and one of them shouted, “Oh Gawd, that Quick Fella move so fast.” He moved fast indeed. His gait was a modified sprint. He walked as though possessed by demons, a jerky, mechanical walk with his head bobbing and his arms pumping to keep time with his legs. He was lanky and thin and his stride was awesome. He disappeared into the trees swiftly, an apparition, a passing thought. “Quick Fella never slow up. He jes’ keep on movin’ down the road so fast,” Lincoln said. I met Quick Fella while he was fishing one day. I introduced myself and started a conversation. I learned two things about Quick Fella during that first talk: that he spoke in a rich language that seemed almost Elizabethan and that he gave an exceptionally detailed weather report. “So very nice. So very nice. So pleased to make your acquaintance. I am so pleased to tell you that the chillun seemed to think you are a fine gentleman. Yes, a fine gentleman. So very nice. So very pleased to make your acquaintance,” he said—very quickly, I should add. We talked a bit about the school, then I mentioned something about the thunderclouds that had rolled in from the east. “Oh yes. I believe there will be a storm. Yes, yes. The temperature is about ninety-three degrees and slightly falling. The rel’tive humid-aty is eighty-seven per cent and rising. Scattered thundershowers late in the afternoon. Winds out of the east at fifteen miles an hour. Small boat warnings out for small boat. Big boats O.K. and don’t have to worry about nothin’.” I was listening to a Quick Fella special, his interpretation of the weather given over the Savannah radio. He often disagreed with this report and would alter the forecast according to his own studies of existing weather conditions. He was an astute observer of cloud formations and wind shifts. The people of the island generally believed in his reports and ignored those coming from Savannah. Of course, all people who live on islands become skillful at predicting the weather, but Quick Fella had transformed his skill into an art. The other resident who provided a glimpse into island life was a powerfully muscled man called Sam. He did not tell me his name. I
The Water is Wide
81
heard him called that by the other fishermen. He was a scowling, taciturn man who made no pretense of wishing to engage in small talk with me. He looked at me with a malevolent glance that could have melted a fishhook. Amicability was not Sam’s greatest virtue. His foot was crippled. He dragged it behind him like an old anchor. It was bent, gnarled, and stuffed into a correction shoe. He liked to sit on the dock with his fishing pole and swing his feet underneath the dock, so his deformity would not show. I would make attempts to talk to him. “How’s it going today? You caught any big ones?” I would say. He would answer me with one of his fishhook stares. “Fish not biting today, eh? Well, some days are good. Some days are bad,” I would whine with infinite wisdom. “You just gotta stick with it when you’re fishing. Yes, sir, patience really pays off.” Throughout this monologue, Sam has continued to stare at me. There is nothing human in his face. He is not amused or entertained by my intrusion. His crippled foot is swung out of sight under the dock. His stare is hollow, uncomprehending but hostile. “Well, it’s been great talkin’ to you. I really enjoyed the conversation,” I say, as I walk away from him. I learned about Sam from the kids at school. When he was an infant, his mother left him untended in a crib while she went to the nightclub to drink. While she was out, Sam slipped out of the crib but caught his left foot somehow in between two of the slats. The foot broke. He hung suspended from the crib for a long time screaming in agony. His mother came home finally and freed him. She never took her son to the doctor to have his foot set, and the bone healed itself at a grotesque, crooked angle that grew worse as Sam grew older. The kids said Sam didn’t smile much. But I saw him smiling once. He owned the finest horse on the island, a graceful mare with a handsome head and a sleek, somewhat spare body. I saw Sam riding this horse down the main road at full gallop, the horse straining for acceleration, the man bent over the horse’s back shouting encouragement and smiling a full, evocative smile. The horse was swift and the man was intoxicated with the speed of his animal and the feel of the wind along his spine. Sam waved to me as he passed.I watched as the man and the horse grew smaller down the road and it made me glad there were horses in the world for people like Sam. When Sam was on his horse, then Sam, the cripple,
The Water is Wide
82
sprouted wings and flew. Sam’s horse was a good foot and his horse made him smile. Even though I was on Yamacraw, I was not of Yamacraw. My first overtures of friendship with the people on the island, although not rebuffed, failed to win me any friends with whom I felt completely comfortable. I thought constantly of my friends in Beaufort. Consciously I began to wish for a way to extricate myself from a job and a situation I felt incapable of handling. The loneliness was beginning to shred my nerves. I became distracted with myself and my vainglorious attempt to act as a symbolic bridge between the children of the Yamacraw and the outside world. I was impatient because I had failed to turn illiterates into lovers of the great classics in the span of a single month. I had tired of measuring victories in terms of whether Prophet had learned the alphabet or Sidney could spell his name. Nor could I shake the feeling that everything I taught or achieved was a worthless, needless effort that ultimately would not affect the quality of my students’ lives. What could I teach them or give them that would substantially alter the course of their lives? Nothing. Not a goddam thing. Each had come into the world imprisoned by a river and by a system which insured his destruction the moment he uttered his first cry by his mother’s side. Many of my friends drew me aside in those early days, before I had defined myself in relation to the island, and told me they envied my opportunity for solitude, for reflection, and for time to assemble my thoughts and generate ideas. Almost every man dreams of a place where he can withdraw into himself, away from the roar of engines and squeal of tires, away from the push of crowds. Yet, by placing myself on Yamacraw, I was denying my natural gregariousness and my compulsive need for good friends. As a lover of conversation, I found myself strangely restless in the mute house, or the mute forest, or walking beside the mute ocean. I was an island within an island. And something far more profound and debilitating was occupying my mind in the month of September, long before I had conditioned myself to the isolation of the island and the frustration of the task at hand. In the midst of resolving the most traumatic adjustment I had ever made, I found myself struck with a new and foreign emotion that had not appeared in the prescribed blueprint of the year. On September 18, 1969, beknownst only to God, me, and one other person, I fell in love. On October 10, 1969, the unlikely triumvirate cooperated once again and I married Barbara Bolling Jones. Barbara and I had been neighbors the previous year when I resided in a comfortably picturesque apartment in Beaufort. The house rested on
The Water is Wide
83
the edge of a slough formed by the Beaufort River. It was behind one of the oldest houses in Beaufort and its many-windowed view of the river traffic of boat and fowl made the fifty dollars’ rent I paid seem like the most incredible bargain in Christendom. The neighborhood went by the name of The Point, a collection of splendid old houses with fine white columns and dreams sundered by a great war and changing times. It was a genuine remnant of the Old South, with rocking chairs on high verandahs and venerable octogenarians and their aristocratic progeny carrying on the myth and legend which ended reluctantly at Appomattox Courthouse. I liked The Point for many reasons: for the quietude of its shaded, narrow streets, the courtesy and refinement of its residents, the imposing presence of its history, and for its essential apartness from the pace and hustle of the earth—its eccentric removal from all things plastic, electric, neoned, cheap, contrived, or asphalted. A visitor from the North once told me that The Point was evil because its people were prejudiced against blacks. “Then leave,” I answered. I did not stop to explain my feelings for the place. I should have. It was in a great yellow house on The Point, a house of exquisite proportions, that I can remember first feeling some compassion and insight into the condition of black people. I was sixteen, and in the prime of my nigger-baiting days, when I visited Gene Norris’ apartment on the second story of this yellow house. Gene dwelt in Beaufort as the prophet before the storm, an intense bespectacled man who preached love for all humanity at a time when it was physically dangerous to do so. He perpetuated the great blasphemy of having his students read the New York Times instead of the Charleston News and Courier. An inveterate radical, he assigned Catcher in the Rye to his students before the town could mobilize its committees of repression. He reigned as the village eight-ball, the left arm, the joker in the pile, the odd number in our even-numbered world. Like many students in Beaufort, I owe a great deal to Gene Norris. At any rate, one night in my junior year, he invited me and several other students to his house for dinner. The assembled group started teasing Gene about being a nigger-lover. Gene spat out a devastating reply, then asked us to listen to a record he had bought that day. He played “We Shall Overcome” by Pete Seeger. I remember that moment with crystal clarity and I comprehend it as a turning point in my life: a moment terrible in its illumination of a toad in my soul, an ugliness so pervasive that it seemed my insides were vomit. Of course, I remained a nigger-hater for many years afterward, but the journey at least had a beginning, a point of embarkation. And the beginning had happened in an ante-bellum house on The Point.
The Water is Wide
84
So, The Point, bedizened with moss and the memory of slavery, symbolized to me a place, not of evil and of minds anchored to a corrupt past, but a place where change was possible, even imminent. As soon as I graduated from The Citadel, I house-hunted in The Point area and there only. Here I was to live and here I planned to die. At twenty-two I had decided that it was best to live and grow old in a small town. The call of the city failed to capture me. Barbara lived next door to me, but the currents of our lives did not cross. I once started her car on an unseasonably chilly October morning when her profanity streamed into my bedroom window as I was shaving. I walked out and started her car. She apologized profusely when I commended her for the salt of her tongue. That was all. The first thing I noticed about her was the wedding ring on her left hand. Bachelors reflexively study a strange girl’s left hand. Without the formality of introducing ourselves, we parted. I heard of her again a month later. Her husband, a Marine pilot, had been shot down and killed in Vietnam. A week later I heard through Beaufort’s well-developed grapevine that Barbara was pregnant with her second child. We had few occasions to talk after that. I would often see her in her yard as I drove to and from school. I watched the child grow within her and measured time by the changes in her condition. Her second child, Melissa, was born in April. In May I met Barbara at a party. We talked. I went to her house for a drink after the party. Initially, I felt uncomfortable around her. Her husband had died in a war I considered immoral and unjustified. I could sympathize with her loss but could not condone or defend the cause for which he died. Teaching had preserved me from the draft and from facing the decision of fighting in an ignoble war because my country decreed it. So I steered away from talk about the war or the military. A week later she left to visit her parents-in-law in Norway for the summer. My falling in love was simply a gradual awareness that I wanted to live with Barbara. When she returned to Beaufort in August, I was there. The idea of assuming the role of father for two young children terrified me, and the additional burden of entering a house where the shadow of a man I never knew was imprinted in every corner seemed a legitimate reason for hesitating on the brink of matrimony. And we were so different. Barbara cared not one bit for the social issues of the day that were so important to me. Her main interest in life was the
The Water is Wide
85
ineluctable pursuit of the contented home and happy family. Hers was a life of order, of cocktails served promptly before dinner, of napkins and candlesticks, of military protocol, and attention to form. Mine was chaotic, plebian, and disjointed. She voted for Nixon, while I prayed for the elevation of McCarthy. Whatever the differences between us, none of it made much difference on October 10. Before a small crowd of friends, we were married in St. Helena’s Church in Beaufort. Bernie was there poking me in the ribs and grinning like hell. Big George Garbade towered above the guests, who were whispering occasionally that now I’d have to get off that goddam island. Gene Norris was there, a classic portrait of the tweedy English professor. Yamacraw, far away and oblivious in the October sunshine, seemed mysteriously remote and inaccessible, like a dream that lingered just beneath the surface of memory, and not a part of me at all. I had invited everyone I knew on the island to my wedding: the kids, the parents, Mrs. Brown, the Stones. All said they would try to attend, and predictably, because of distance, inconvenience, and the fact that none of them knew me very well, none of them showed. We honeymooned on Yamacraw Island. For some reason, Niagara Falls, the Virgin Islands, or any of the other meccas for the hordes of lusty young couples checking into motels did not arouse any enthusiasm in me. Since Barbara had not seen Yamacraw and since it was important she understand the problems of the island and its isolation from the rest of the world, we decided to spend our honeymoon on the island. Zeke put the boat into the water, taunted me with the ancient jokes directed at newly anointed husbands, and watched as we headed toward Bull Creek. I drove the boat and pointed out the high spots of the trip: the osprey’s nest atop the utility pole on Savage Island, the huge crescent sandbar that blocked one whole section of navigable creek at low tide on Bull Island, the thousands of brown oysters encrusted in the mud flats along the shore. A porpoise fin broke like a green shaft in the water beside us, the sun flashing off his body in brilliant knives of light. A great blue heron, disturbed by the boat, flew patiently and majestically to another spot. The boat was an intrusion. It always was. We stayed for two days. My living quarters did not impress Barbara to a great extent, but the weather cooperated and even the mosquitoes seemed to diminish the fury of their attacks. We wandered about the island exulting in the aloneness. Barbara picked ticks from her body
The Water is Wide
86
and took cold-water baths with Spartan determination. We had never considered her living on the island. She did not want to bring her young children to a place without doctors or telephones. I would live on the island, come home on the weekend, and during the week when I was able. Thus, our marriage was planned for the first year. Barbara would remain in Beaufort; I would live on the island. How different my life would be had we followed this original plan. I was young and surpassingly naïve at this juncture and I saw no undue hardship resulting from this arrangement. Barbara had lived a year without a husband and an absentee husband seemed infinitely better than no husband at all. I was not about to quit my job on Yamacraw, nor was she going to bring her children to live on the island. As I look back, it is surprising we both did not tell each other to go to hell and forget the whole thing. Anyway, it was a good honeymoon. I took my bride back to Beaufort and deposited her in our Beaufort home. The house we had rented had all the character of a hamburger stand: cyclone fence, picture window, carport, and all the other accouterments of suburbia. I hated the house and the neighborhood. The Point had nothing for rent or sale, so we were forced to join the ranks of the red-brick people who drive station wagons and play bridge. I lived on a remote island during the week and next to George Babbitt on the weekend. After October 10 I was not happy on the island. Separating myself from Barbara only seemed to heighten my loneliness on the island. I became rather irritable and impatient in dealing with the kids in class. Mrs. Brown and her tirades seemed less amusing to me. Ted Stone began to fray my nerves. I missed Barbara and wanted to be with her. I could not quit, yet I wanted to quit. I was also starting to feel guilty about the two-year-old girl, Jessica, who was now my responsibility. She thought of me simply as “that man, Mommy” and had not realized that I was her father. Jessica needed a father, not a weekend visitor. These things preyed on my mind in the middle of October. I was a father and a teacher, yet I could not throw myself completely into either project. It was not until December that I became a daily commuter.
The Water is Wide
87
Chapter 5 On a reconnaissance foray into the bowels of the great closet that harbored the jetsam and flotsam washed into the schoolroom over the years, I unearthed a brand-new automatic movie projector. When I queried Mrs. Brown, she told me that films were difficult to get to and from the island; in fact, they were more trouble than they were worth. Therefore the projector sat in permanent exile. I also found an SRA Reading Kit and a fairly new record player gathering dust on one of the closet shelves. I was ecstatic. I am a firm and uncompromising believer in the audiovisual age. The projector was gold bullion. It became my habit from that day forward to make damn sure that the room was filled with films on all subjects. I raided the film library at the county office each month. Since the difficulty of transporting films was so obvious, I was allowed to take as many films as I wanted and to keep them for as long as I wanted. Though this entailed a broken rule, the woman in charge of the films was very flexible. The films were divided into three groups: boring films that imparted a body of knowledge I felt the gang should have partial exposure to, interesting films that I accidentally picked up with the boring films, and fun films whose sole purpose was to provide entertainment. The class generally liked films better than any other part of the day and voted to have at least one film daily. They also insisted that when a film especially appealed to them, they would be allowed to view it a second time. I acquiesced to the will of the majority. A film on the Calgary Rodeo received three curtain calls. At the third showine, the Gorgonian head of Mrs. Brown peered in through the glass window, called me out into the hall, and gave me a splendid lecture. “Every second of school time is important, Mr. Conroy,” she intoned, “and we cannot afford to waste any time with movin’ pictures. These
The Water is Wide
88
children need the basics. The basics. If they get the basics that’s all they need.” “Yes, ma’am,” I answered. Several times during the year Mrs. Brown attempted to sabotage the film program. She constantly derided the fact that I was wasting valuable time, when I could be drilling the class on those good ole, French-fried, batter-whipped basics. A couple of the kids watched movies as if they were partaking of a sacrament, completely enthralled and religiously attentive. Fred fidgeted through movies, but Fred would wiggle through his own interment. Lincoln chattered throughout the movie, but much of his conversation was directed toward characters on the screen. So, no matter how much the film series offended Mrs. Brown, I was determined to keep it part of my program. On one occasion, a film was the fuse for an explosion of enthusiasm for the whole class in which eighteen children momentarily forgot the prison of the classroom, forgot about the iron-clad rules of propriety, forgot about the frowning Mrs. Brown in the next room, and danced maniacally in the pure joy of group sharing and identification. It started with Walter Cronkite. Walter, with his voice of doomsday sincerity, came on a brief visit to Yamacraw via film. In the film library I came across The Salem Witch Trials, part of the old “You Are There” programs, which Cronkite narrated. The film launched me back into a bucket of tears’ worth of nostalgia and reminiscing. I cannot estimate how many times I watched the program as a child, but seeing young Walter with his unlined face and dignified thinness was like welcoming an old friend back into my life. I tried to tell the kids about the part Walter Cronkite played in my childhood, when I sat transfixed before the television set as my favorite shows flickered on and off. They seemed to understand. The kids loved the resonant, stirring quality of the phrase You are there. In the film, the alleged witches swear their innocence before a noncompassionate judge. Their accusers moan and squeal in delightful overacting. Soldiers drag people off to the gallows. The kids were going wild. “Hang the judge,” they chanted. The supernatural held a macabre fascination for the children; they discussed it frequently, and believed implicitly in the existence of witches, warlocks, ghosts, and devils. After the film, I extracted several hokey morals to discuss the nature of justice and other such manure. The kids would have none of it. They
The Water is Wide
89
hadn’t had a good bull session about witches for a damn long time— too long, they decided; let’s discuss them now. Ethel Lee spoke first, “I know two witches in Savannah—they mean.” “Damn right, they mean,” Fred said to Big C, not knowing I had heard. “They ain’t as mean as the one in Bluffton,” Cindy Lou added. “Meanest witch in the world right here on Yamacraw,” Frank concluded. “How many of you ever seen a witch?” I asked. Every hand flew up. Damn right they’d seen witches. Big C screwed his face up into his question-mark look. “It true if you throw water on a witch, she disappear?” Suddenly every eye in the room was riveted on me. Only the pigs grunting and rooting on the schoolyard disturbed the silence created by this single question. And there was something about the question itself, something ancient and primordial, something that disturbed the hidden and oft lost mythology of my own youth; I felt something stir as I thought about the wet witch, and knew that a feeling in my subconscious was rising like an air bubble to the surface. Then I had it. “Big C, you’ve seen the Wizard of Oz.” Eighteen voices shouted hosannas to the trembling faker of Oz. Cindy Lou broke off into an impromptu rendition of “Over the Rainbow.” Others pretended they were cowardly lions. Richard stood up and walked like a scarecrow suspended from his stake. Each member of the class had memorized the movie classic, had watched it religiously each time it appeared on television and had added personal interpretations to the bizarre forces rampant in the spirit-haunted land over the rainbow. And if the Yamacraw children knew about Oz, then I was convinced a hell of a lot of other children in America knew about it, too. My jeremiads against television since my first days on the island had continued undiminished, fed with the plentiful food of my students’ ignorance about people, events, and the world. Now, in a single moment, I had to retract my sweeping indictment of TV: it had not failed completely, only partially. Every child in the room knew the legend of Oz by heart, the importance of the yellow-brick road, the incarnate evil of the wicked Witch of the West, and the ultimate hypocrisy of the great wizard himself. Oz, it seemed, had entered into the consciousness of American children, and not just a selected few, but almost every child in every situation. I considered Yamacraw a touchstone: if the Yamacraw
The Water is Wide
90
children knew about it, then the chances were excellent that the vast majority of American children had been reached. The Wizard of Oz, through the medium of television, had become part of American mythology as important and relevant to the children of America as the Homeric legends were to the children of Athens. So Big C’s question was the catalyst for a great and memorable afternoon, one of those rare moments generated by chance, planned by no one, spontaneous and joyful, transcending the need for a teacher or a classroom, and making me once more think of education as something alive and helpful, instead of as a withered dream in need of formaldehyde. Oz took over the rest of the day. For a couple of minutes it was utter pandemonium. Fred introduced a moving argument in incomprehensible Fredese in favor of the proposition that water could evaporate witches. Prophet thought this was crap. He told Fred so. Fred told Prophet he would kick his butt if he continued to think it was crap. Mary mumbled something into her left hand about fire being better than water. Saul said that there ain’t no sure way to kill a witch. Cindy Lou’s voice finally broke through the general upheaval of noise and offered to recite her King James Version of the story. “O.K.,” said I. “There was this little girl who got blown away in a rainstorm,” she started. “That ain’t the way it was,” said Jimmy Sue. “How was it then, you old ugly self?” Cindy Lou shot back. “Ain’t no rainstorm, sister.” “Damn right it was a rainstorm.” “No, girl, it was a tor-nay-do.” “Yeah,” the class agreed, “it was a tornado.” “Same thing,” claimed Cindy Lou. “No, girl. Tor-nay-do take your head clean off,” offered Mary. “You tellin’ the story, girl?” Cindy inquired menacingly of Jimmy Sue. “No.” “Then you keep your mout’ out of it.” “This girl got blown away by a wind and the house she was in hit a bad witch on the head and kill her dead. Then the girl and her little dog
The Water is Wide
91
go marchin’ down this yellow-brick road ‘til they meet this chicken lion who try to act tough.” “No,” a chorus of voices shouted. “No, what?” Cindy Lou asked. “That girl don’t meet no lion,” said Samuel, in one of his first vocal contributions of the year. “Sure she meets a lion.” “No, girl, first she sees the scarecrow. Ain’t got no brains.” “Yeah, scarecrow first,” the class agreed, acting out the chorus in this impromptu drama. “You tell the story, cockeye.” “Call me cockeye and I bust your head,” Samuel shouts, clenching his fists. “Don’t call Samuel cockeye, Cindy Lou.” “He is cockeye.” “Yeah, he cockeye,” the chorus agrees. “No,” I say. “I bust your head,” Samuel warns the whole class. “You cockeye,” the class chants. “The scarecrow first,” says Richard. “Let me tell the story.” “Oh boy, Richard, give it to us.” So Richard rendered his version of Oz. Then Oscar, then Frank, then Mary, then Sidney, each adding their own peculiar interpretations, each emphasizing a different part of the story, and each feeling perfectly free to combine incidents from the Wizard of Oz with incidents that occurred in other television programs. Sidney got Oz confused with an episode from “Bonanza.” Hoss Cartwright battling the witches of the Purple Sage. According to Oscar, Oz and Disneyland were somehow related. Richard somehow got Captain Kangaroo confused with the wizard, and Mr. Greenjeans confused with the scarecrow. Ethel, a purist in the group, strutted to the microphone and began a long, precise, but monotonous epic, which was technically unflawed
The Water is Wide
92
and accurate except that everyone in the class believed she was making the stuff up. In the middle of her story, Top Cat got up and started singing a new song just released by swing-man James Brown. He hopped and swayed what he called a “new jive” while the kids clapped their hands and tapped their feet until the great head of Mrs. Brown appeared in the window, flashing a look the Romans must have worn on their faces when turning thumbs down on some prostrate Christian. But even though the kids quit responding and reverted back to their classical pose of scholars erect in their desks and lusting for knowledge, Top Cat gyrated on, a grin like a jack-o’-lantern carved on his face and eyes raised in adoration of some muse deep within him. When Top Cat finally subsided and sank back into his desk, Prophet of the unknown tongue continued the interrupted marathon of Oz, an untranslatable potpourri of grunts and monosyllables, punctuated only by Prophet’s beautifully effusive smiles. When the afternoon was over and the bus ambled into the schoolyard, and the kids had filed out of the room, I had on tape the story of Oz as it had never been told before—a new Oz, a land that Judy Garland had never entered, but one especially created on a December afternoon by children of an island ruled by a river, and possibly another wizard, with perhaps a greater claim to credibility.
The first two California boys arrived on the island in early October. They were part of an unusual college program emanating from Cowell College, a part of the University of California at Santa Cruz. The program had survived for a solid year. Herman Blake, a black professor at the college who had been born on a sea island further up the coast, was the mercurial, driving force behind the program; he devised it, implemented it, and was the strong shaft that supported the experiment in the early days and nurtured it past the stormy and vehement disapproval of the island troll, Ted Stone. Mr. Stone told me about Blake, about the California boys, and about the program. “All of them are Communists trained in Havana. If they keep comin’ to the island there is bound to be trouble. One of them has already gone back to California and married a nigger girl. Another one named Zach Sklar was a Russian Jew.” Stone considered the program an insidious, corrosive threat to his domination of the island’s people and politics. “What exactly do they do, Mr. Stone?” I asked. “You can tell me.”
The Water is Wide
93
He answered, “It don’t appear like they do nothing.” It seemed improbable that two Californians would travel 3000 miles for the experience of dwelling among black people on an unbridged island solely for credit in a sociology class. Whatever the probability, I met Jim Ford and Joe Sanfort the first week in October. With all six of the California boys I worked with during the year there was a period of aloofness, of deintoxification, before we could communicate on a serious level with each other. The prime reason was my background. I was a white southerner, a graduate of an all white male military college, a nine-year resident of Beaufort, and the first white teacher encountered in the Cowell College program. During the training sessions for their journey to Yamacraw, Blake concentrated on prepping his missionaries well in the psyche of the rural blacks, but he did not prepare them well at all for dealing with the southern whites. In their simplistic assessment, all southern whites were incorrigible racists who loved to eat grits, smell magnolias, and lynch blacks. Blake told them to handle the Stones with oily diplomacy. In fact the major command passed to them before they left the protected enclosure of their campus was not to piss anybody off, white or black. Remember the program, it must go on at all costs. So Jim and Joe approached me with extreme caution, said nothing that would ruffle the white supremacist feathers that lay directly beneath my bright red neck, and generally said nothing at all. They were the first people I had met from an infamous California college. I am positive I was the first person they had met who had worn a uniform to the latrine in his college days. From the beginning it was a merger of opposites and a meeting of two extraordinarily different worlds. After we thawed our suspicions, we became good friends and they introduced me for the first time to that land gilded with Sierras, pocked with surfers, and as strange and multifaceted as Yamacraw itself—California. Jim and Joe explained the program one night soon after my marriage, as we drank beer and killed mosquitoes in the gloom of early evening in my house. Each quarter Blake selected two people for the Yamacraw Island Project. The twosome spent an entire quarter living among the people of the island, talking to them, helping them in whatever service that they could provide, and absorbing the atmosphere and culture of the island in the process. One of the ultimate aims of the program was to get into the school and help the teachers with the children. Thus far, Mrs. Brown had proved to be the major obstacle. Jim and Joe ran a recreation program every day after
The Water is Wide
94
school. More aptly, they stood in the middle of a great surge of children racing wildly about them, engaged in some unidentifiable game that had been brought to the island as football and corrupted over the years. Jim’s personality was such that he desired to see order emerge from the chaos, form to somehow overpower the void, rules to tame and dignify the surface appearance of his program. In fact, beneath his long hair and mustache, Jim Ford was the quintessential organization man who was not happy unless a football game spread across the playground with Lombardian precision. To Jim a recreation program, or at least his recreation program, was something sacred and if he had any say in the matter, his program on Yamacraw would be a model for sea islands everywhere. So when Jim would clap his hands and ask for order and the dust cloud of children kicking a ball and each other would swirl past him oblivious to his command, and when he would clap his hands again, this time louder and more peremptory, and the great cloud would nearly trample him as it passed his spot again, I could only smile and thank God that I had taught awhile and knew where I stood in the great chain of being among the children of Yamacraw School. I knew Jim wanted to have a program he could be proud of when he returned to California. Therefore, my heart saluted him when I saw him standing alone, a sentinel waving frantically beneath the stand of oaks beside the school, asking for quiet, for attention, for anything that would let him assume command and control of a situation that he could not control. Joe, on the other hand, cared little for organization, for achievements to boast upon, or anything else. Joe’s cynicism appealed to me greatly; he would sit alone on the seesaw, deprecating the fact that a black man would send two blue-eyed white boys bursting with bullshit and idealism to an island that needed them like it needed two escalators. Every once in a while guilt would cause Joe to make an attempt to organize a softball game or a kickball game, but after his efforts had melted into mere remembrances of things past, he returned to his seesaw and ruminated upon the folly of the recreation program. Of course, Mrs. Brown would watch the entire spectacle shaking her head disgustedly, screaming at every child who raced past her that this was no way to run a recreation program, that whoever was running this recreation program sure didn’t know what in the hell they were doing, and if she were running the program it would certainly be organized better. Jim would hustle over to her side, they
The Water is Wide
95
would huddle together in great seriousness, Jim would then break from the huddle like a center from the Green Bay Packers, trot to the middle of the playground, clap his hands, shout hopelessly to the mass of kids racing in every conceivable direction, and the entire cycle would begin anew. God, did I sympathize with both Jim and Joe. About the third recess at Yamacraw, I became momentarily inspired to teach the boys the finer nuances of football. They knew nothing. They could not pass; they could not block or kick the ball or line up in a semblance of a formation. Their version of the game was pure, unsullied madness. Whoever held the ball at any time was simply murdered by every other player on the field. Sometimes Top Cat and Oscar, the two largest, would team up together while the frail youngsters tried vainly to drag them to the ground. I had never seen such ferocity on the field. Sam and Sidney, emaciated and puny, would fly into the churning legs of Top Cat without losing a bit of momentum. Top Cat would shake them off as if they were made from butterfly wings, then face Richard’s seventy-pound charge into his stomach. Everyone growled, foamed, and grunted appropriately. When someone hit the ground, all participants felt duty bound to leap on the fallen prey; fists would pound heads, feet would kick any and every exposed leg, thigh, or head. Curses flew from the pile in dangling, disjointed clusters. I’d never seen anything so brutal, so dangerous, so insane in my whole life. So I decided to teach them rules, fair play, and sportsmanship: the essence of the noble game, the proper manner in which gentlemen and athletes conduct themselves on a field of honor. I taught them huddles, the stance for blocking, the way to pass a spiral, the science of plays, the beauty of the stiff arm. This took two whole recesses. After I was convinced that I had given them enough theory, that they were well grounded in the basics of the game, I flipped the ball to Lincoln and told him to kick off. He was immediately buried under an avalanche of bodies kicking, gouging, biting, and hitting at the unfortunate Lincoln, who howled at the bottom of the pile. This was one of my last attempts to organize the time-honored version of football on the island. Jim and Joe were in a strange position on the island. They were there conceivably to serve the people. If there was a fence to be mended, a privy to be built, an errand to be run, or an itch to be scratched, the islanders knew that all they had to do was ask the California boys. It did not take long for the more savvy islanders to take more than full
The Water is Wide
96
advantage of this miraculous labor force from across the continent. Nor did it become unusual for someone to see healthy black men sitting in the shade sipping Scotch and watching Joe and Jim sweating in the broiling sun over a collection of nails and boards that would soon be a new privy. I identified with Joe and Jim and saw that they were merely putting their burning liberalism to the test of the sword. Joe and Jim, archetypes of white, middle-class America, could come to the thickets and backwaters of the Carolinas and master the art of shit-house building. Dear Mom, Sallie May Toomer now craps in elegance and style, so my life has not been in vain. I once asked Mrs. Brown if the California boys could come into the schoolhouse and work with some of the kids on remedial reading. It seemed natural that two juniors in college would be moderately qualified to help out in the scholarly environs of Yamacraw School. Not that I disparaged their field work, for they were becoming so proficient in shit-house building that they completed these structures with remarkable speed. But both of them felt that they could accomplish far more if they could help the children in school. I agreed. It was funny how we thought education to be the great gilded key which would solve all problems, eliminate all poverty and disease, eradicate differences between social classes, and bring the children of okra-planters up to par with the children of emperors. A trinity of whitetoothed white boys, Joe, Jim, and I, entered into the stream of Yamacraw life-style and felt all that was needed was a meteoric reading level, a couple of shots of new math, and a high score on the college entrance exams. So the guys wanted me to approach the unapproachable Mrs. Brown to see if she would put her approval on their apprenticeship within the schoolhouse walls. “Mr. Conroy, do you realize that these boys have no credentials? The state requires all of its teachers to have the proper credentials. What if the man from the state department comes walkin’ into this here school, carrying his badge, and askin’ to see everybody’s credentials? Now what we gonna do with these California boys? Hide ‘em in the ladies’ room? No, Mr. Conroy, we must abide by the rules of the state.” “Mrs. Brown, all these guys want to do is come in during the day and help us out. Nothing else. It cannot hurt a single thing.” “It will hurt the reputation and cree-dentials of this school.” “This ain’t Harvard, Mrs. Brown.” “Rules are rules, Mr. Conroy. The state makes the rules.”
The Water is Wide
97
“There are no rules which say these guys cannot come and help us every day.” “I am the principal.” “Yes, ma’am.” So Joe and Jim remained the grand officiators of the recreation program. I explained to them that I was relatively powerless to cope with Mrs. Brown when she so adamantly refused to listen to reason. White guilt, that nasty little creature who rested on my left shoulder, prevented me from challenging Mrs. Brown on this or any other point. At this time of my life a black man could probably have handed me a bucket of cow piss, commanded me to drink it in order that I might rid my soul of the stench of racism, and I would have only asked for a straw. Blacks who have gone through the civil rights struggle have met a hundred white boys and girls who would dive head first in a septic tank to prove their liberation from the sins of their fathers. I thought Mrs. Brown was wrong, but did not have the moral courage to tell her so. In the fantasy of the races conceived in my mind, all blacks were noble people who had struggled against a repressive social order for years and who were finally reaping the tangible rewards of this struggle. All whites, especially myself, were guilty of heinous, extraordinarily brutal crimes against humanity. It dawned on me that I came to Yamacraw for a fallacious reason: I needed to be cleansed, born again, resurrected by good works and suffering, purified of the dark cankers that grew like toadstools in my past. I was on the island for expiation, and I think I liked to watch Joe and Jim struggle so patiently because I saw in them a reflection of myself. The word had passed. The California boys were banned from the classroom. I thought credentials constituted the primary reason why they were not allowed to enter the school. Then one day Mrs. Brown told me conspiratorially, “We can’t let white boys and colored girls rub elbows too much. Them boys are young bulls with no cows on this island ‘cept them colored cows. We can’t afford to have no half-breed cows on this island.”
I had borrowed a tape recorder from Mrs. Brown that I had noticed sitting in a corner of her room, virginal and unused. She let me have it reluctantly, telling me some crap that it was too valuable a piece of equipment to use with my “babies” around. I swore by the whiskers of Jehovah that I would treat the priceless machine as I would a tiara
The Water is Wide
98
from Tiffany’s. Then I carried it into my room. Tape recorders are great instruments, I knew this intuitively, though I had never used one in a classroom environment and had no idea, at that particular moment, how exactly I would utilize one in this class. Since I am a virtual idiot when it comes to machines of any kind, it took a good fifteen minutes to figure out how to operate this box full of hidden levers and submerged screws. Finally, after incredible fumbling on my part, the tape recorder whirred proudly and efficiently into action. Mary told me the machine had sat idle the year before and that Mrs. Brown had not played it at all. “Fine,” I said, “we are going to play the hell out of it.” I told everyone to come up to the tape recorder and give name, address, and grade. Big C was first. He rolled his eyes, lowered his head, then mumbled, “My name Charles Graves. I am in the seventh grade. I live on Yamacraw.” Then I replayed his performance. When Big C’s voice came back into the room, I think I gained some insight into a magician’s feeling of power when he pulls a rabbit from his hat before a roomful of children. Lincoln yelled “God Almighty. Good gracious.” Whoops and giggles spread around the room as each succeeding voice came stuttering magically from the tape. Poor Prophet caught hell from the rest of the class when his own version of the language rolled incomprehensibly forth, and his brother Fred was so self-conscious about his inability to articulate that he merely grunted into the microphone. Oscar, however, the completion of the Simmons trinity, was so proud of the sound of his voice that he volunteered to tell the story of the book he had just finished reading. So he launched into a lengthy monologue about Moolak, an Eskimo salmon fisherman. Since Oscar was not a proponent of brevity, he described in intricate detail how Moolak caught what seemed to be a few million salmon. But while Oscar was droning on, a burst of noise arose spontaneously around Top Cat. “Top Cat gonna sing,” Mary trilled. “That right. He sound better than Brother James Brown,” Saul added. Top Cat strutted and shimmied to the center of the room as if possessed by an orchestra of demons. His whole body danced and shook, and the class deferred to his assumption of an inalienable right to the microphone. Something had moved Top Cat. “Do you need any music. Top Cat?” I asked.
The Water is Wide
99
“All I need is that there mike,” he said, his eyes closed and his lips already moving. I gave him that there mike and sat down to enjoy the show. Top Cat was a great showman. He threw his head back, threw out his arms, wrinkled his face like an old raisin, and burst into a classic Otis Redding number, “Sittin’ on the Dock of the Bay.” The kid I had thought nearly illiterate had memorized the words of a fairly complicated song and developed a diction and sense of timing that was almost perfect. The class sat respectfully silent while Top Cat performed. When he finished, they applauded vigorously. Then came the flood. Richard, who I knew damn well was illiterate, who could not string the twenty-six letters of the alphabet together, who could not add two and two, and who could not write his name, came striding manfully to the microphone. Richard was terribly bashful in class and would hide his face in his hands if I even looked in his direction. He also had developed an infallible escape mechanism; if it looked as though I was going to involve him in some class activity, Richard would raise his hand and ask to go to the bathroom. On one day he had gone to the land of pee eleven times. I followed him into the bathroom the last time and watched as Richard looked out the window at the forest surrounding the school. He almost hemorrhaged when he saw me looking at him. So Richard, striding to the microphone, smiling shyly and mumbling incoherently to himself, was kind of a big thing. And old Richard could sing like hell. His voice was high and clear, almost belllike. He sang a spiritual with style and emotion. “Will the circle Be unbroken? By and by, Lord, By and by.” His brother Jasper grabbed the microphone from Richard as soon as possible and launched into a song notable primarily for its epic length. It was called “Alabama Moonshine.” The song went on and on, an endless song not enhanced or flattered by Jasper’s flat, monotonic voice or his uninspired delivery. He sang it like a Trappist chant without life or humor, just a long, long ballad with piles and piles of verses—like Moolak with piles and piles of salmon. Lincoln quit crapping around long enough to sing “The Birds and the Bees.” He was awful, but he enjoyed singing so much I remained
The Water is Wide
100
silent and appreciative. The class unanimously declared him to be a lousy singer. “Lincoln, you so bad,” shouted Big C. “He sound like shee-t,” Saul said in a whisper, but of course, every time Saul whispered, everyone within three miles heard it. “Saul cuss,” said Ethel. “Shut up, girl,” Saul said murderously. “I pinch your head, little man,” Ethel said back. “Don’t you call me little man,” Saul warned. “I call you little man, little man,” she answered. Saul started to cry. He was extremely sensitive about his height and any mention of it would make him cry. Naturally, his classmates taunted him unmercifully and with unrestrained cruelty. “Little man crying.” “Cry, little man.” “Shut up, punks,” I yelled. “You a punk, big man,” Samuel told me. “Sam, I am going to pinch your head like a pimple.” Sam talking was such a rare event that I would almost have let him tell me to lunch on manure. “Sam call Conrack a punk,” someone yelled. “Sam die now.” “Sam no die. Sam live,” said Sam, for some reason. Meanwhile, Lincoln had not skipped a note and was finishing up his mauled rendition of “The Birds and the Bees.” “Want me sing ‘nother one, Conrack?” “No, Lincoln, I can take only so much pure pleasure in one day.” “Pretty good, huh?” “Great stuff, kid.” Top Cat then gyrated to the center of the room again and belted out another one called “Cloud Nine.” When he sat down, Ethel and Anna teamed up for what was probably the worst duet in history. It was so
The Water is Wide
101
bad, and they knew it was so bad, that I did not even replay it when they were finished. Then back to Richard, who sang eight brief words, then forgot the rest of the song he was singing. “You sing, Conrack?” Lincoln said. “Doggone right, I sing. I’m a great singer. I once worked my way through college dancing in a go-go cage and singing rock and roll.” “No,” the class yelled. “Yeh,” I yelled back. “I’m such a good singer, in fact, that I only sing for money.” “How much?” Oscar asked. “How much you got?” I answered. “Three nickels,” he said. “That ain’t enough, son. I’m used to singing for hundreds of dollars.” “You lie.” “Darn right I lie.” I have a voice that sounds like a flushing commode, and it is only under optimum circumstances that I allow myself to be pilloried by the world for my lousy voice. After school, Mrs. Brown rushed to my room and delivered a long sermon. “Singing is a waste of time, Mr. Conroy. Just a waste of good school time. Those children love to sing. Lord, they’d sing all day if you’d let them. They need readin’, writin’, and arithmetic. The state requires it. If some big man from the state department comes over here and finds your class singing, they gonna run you clean off this island. They got textbooks. Otherwise, nobody in your room can be promoted. Lord knows. Singing! Next thing, they’ll be dancin’ and cuttin’ up and drinking wine in school just like their parents. They gonna be just like their parents if you don’t watch out. Drinkin’ and singin’ and sinnin’ on Saturday night. Not going to visit the Lord on Sunday morning. We run this school here for education’s sake. Give them seat work. Keep them busy. We not here to have fun. We’re here to educate. We got rules to follow.”
A major theme of mine during the year resulted from observing the manner in which my students treated their pets and animals in general. I was labeled squeamish when I found a toad minus his two
The Water is Wide
102
back legs crawling painfully along the front steps. One of the twins had removed his back legs with two quick strokes of a knife before he entered the school after recess. The portrait of the toad, trailing blood behind him on the gritty steps, crawling off to die under the schoolhouse, made me mad as hell. “What d’you do that for, Sam?” I yelled. “Kill ‘im dead. Hee, hee, hee,” Sam replied. “How’d you feel if I ripped your legs off?” “I shoot you dead. Hee, hee, hee.” “Man, you guys treat animals like crap. I have never seen a bunch of people treat animals any worse in my whole life. I swear I wouldn’t give you kids a dead flounder for a pet. You kick your dogs around, you starve your cats, you torture squirrels, shoot songbirds, and maim turtles. You treat animals with kindness or leave them the hell alone. If you kill them to eat them that is fine. Killing an animal for fun is not right and if I see it again there’s gonna be a fist fight.” “Jes’ an ol’ frog,” someone mumbled. “You are jes’ an ol’ person,” I shouted back. “Frog ain’t good for nuttin’.” “They’re good for eating insects,” I said. “All animals are good for something.” “Oscar shoot my pet dog daid,” Saul whispered suddenly. “No, boy. You lie.” “No, you shoot ‘im.” “You shaddup, boy.” “Oscar get his gun and put hole in that ol’ dog’s haid.” ‘That one nasty ol’ dog.” “Dog daid now.” “That my dog,” cried Saul. “That dog daid now. Ain’t nobody’s dog,” Lincoln cackled. “Oscar, that is a rotten, lousy thing to do. Shoot someone’s dog.” “Dog bad. He try to bite me.”
The Water is Wide
103
“I wish he’d bitten you on the throat.” “Someone shoot all Oscar’s dogs too,” Ethel said. “Yeh. Two man dogs. One woman dog,” Prophet piped up. “One dog, red dog. That my dog.” “Who shot them, Prophet?” “Someone shot’im daid in the head. Dog rot up in the woods when Poppa find ‘im. Ain’t got no dogs now.” “And you shot Saul’s dog after someone shot your dog, Oscar. That’s terrible.” Oscar was feeling persecuted, refused to discuss the subject further, and lowered his head as a sign that he had ended his participation in the discussion. But this was not the only conversation I had with the kids about their treatment of animals. Their overall treatment of animals was deplorable or worse. Big C once picked up a large, bloated toad and smashed it against the schoolhouse wall. One day some of the smaller kids in Mrs. Brown’s class scoured the entire playground for insects. Whenever they found a beetle or captured a dragonfly or grasshopper, they tore its wings off and watched it buzz convulsively and helplessly on the ground. I would launch into long-winded diatribes condemning senseless violence perpetrated against helpless creatures while the class nodded in solemn agreement. Then they would go home, chastened by the sharp barbs of my logic, and kick the hell out of their dogs. The dogs of Yamacraw were a special breed. Without question, they were the gauntest, mangiest, slinkiest and most oppressed group I had ever laid eyes on. They had bred and interbred time and again and the net result was an animal so lacking in character or nobility that a possum looked like a racehorse in comparison. At some houses the dogs were so drained of energy that they would bark at strangers without lifting their heads. They were emaciated, undernourished, and listless refuse who were alternately loved and abused by their masters. Only Edna Graves’ dogs showed signs of enthusiasm and that was when the pack decided to rend an unsuspecting visitor to shreds. “You have to take better care of your dogs, gang. Most of your dogs look like walking skeletons. You gotta fatten them up. Make them happy. Make these miserable, wretched dogs proud and healthy.”
The Water is Wide
104
“My dog look a lot better than your dog, that ol’ ugly Beau,” Cindy Lou said indignantly. “Gawd, that a funny-lookin’ dog.” She was referring to my pet dachshund I had brought to school for a visit. “Beau is a beautiful beast of great nobility, Cindy,” I retorted. “Gawd, Mr. Conrack, that dawg so skinny and long. That dawg make me sick.” “Beau is supposed to be skinny and long. Beau is a dachshund.” “I don’t know what that dawg is but he shore is ugly.” “You look like a dawg, Jasper yelled at Cindy Lou. “Watch what you say, boy.” “She look like dawg.” Sidney giggled. “Watch yo’ mout’, boy.” “Who you tell to watch yo’ mout’, girl.” “I tell you, that’s who, boy. You ain’t deef.” “Children, children, children. We must show love, compassion, and understanding for each other,” I intoned. “What that man say,” said Big C. My be-kind-to-mongrel addresses usually degenerated into these backbiting arguments with Cindy Lou making deprecating remarks about the much-maligned Beau. I never could quite convince her that Beau was supposed to look the way he did and was not a victim of abuse or starvation. It was Zeke Skimberry who finally provided the means for me to carry out an experiment in the proper treatment of pets. Two of his dogs gave birth almost simultaneously and Zeke suddenly found himself the proud owner of not four, but sixteen dogs. He asked me if any of my students would be interested in acquiring a new pet. I told him I would check the following day. “All right, gang. Very important news to give you. Zeke Skimberry’s beloved dog Lady has sired ten lovely little puppies who are whimpering for a good home. Now I told Zeke that none of you like dogs or knew how to take care of them.” “No. That not right. No, Conrack,” the cry rose. “I’ve seen the way you take care of dogs. Man, I’d never give you a dog of mine.”
The Water is Wide
105
“No, I take good care of dawg,” shouted Lincoln. “Me too,” shouted Oscar. “Since Saul’s dog was shot,” I said, “I’m going to bring him the best dog in the litter to make up for the one he lost. Now how many in here would take real good care of a dog if I brought him one?” The air was full of uplifted, frantic arms. I spent another twenty minutes defining what I meant by the proper care of dogs. Then Mary made a list of who wanted dogs and what sex they preferred. Oscar said, “Bring me a man dog.” “Me too,” said Lincoln, “I want a little man dog.” “Don’t bring me no woman dog,” Jasper said, “I need me a good man dawg to take huntin’.” “What if I bring you a woman dog, Jasper?” I asked. “Den I shoot ‘im,” he replied. “That’s the wrong damn attitude, Jasper. That’s exactly what I don’t want you to say.” The next day I loaded seven man dogs and one woman dog into a large cardboard box and delivered them to their new owners. All the recipients seemed to take proper care of their animals and love them passionately, and gave me progress reports from time to time. I felt that by introducing these hardy, durable Skimberry hounds into the island strain, some healthy, Darwinic principle would be served. Many months later I went by a house and stopped to admire one of the dogs I had transported to the island. He had acquired all the negative characteristics of his peers and his listlessness and general appearance caused me to regret my condemning these dogs to such a life. But, before my melancholy could reach epic proportions, the dog, in a flash of former glory, shot out of his resting place under the house and bit me on the boot.
The Water is Wide
106
Chapter 6 On a Friday afternoon just before three o’clock and the arrival of the bus, I stood in the middle of the room having a bull session with the class. Top Cat was telling me about Saturday night on Yamacraw, when all the black people gathered in the boxlike building on the West River, danced to the music of James Brown and his Famous Flames, jumping a new type of jive until early in the morning. “It’s so much fun, Mr. Conrack.” I promised to make it one Saturday night, but that my new wife would not approve of my absence on a weekend just yet. Anna, the small, delicately featured sister of Saul who rarely spoke but who possessed one of the brightest, most inquisitive minds in the class, was copying a witch out of a book. The witch, of course, instantly summoned up visions of Halloween and those lost nights from my childhood when I would leave my house sporting the casual work clothes of a ghost or Frankenstein monster. I was curious about the traditions of Halloween on the island, and especially what modifications or exaggerations had evolved over the years. Since the kids believed as fervently in ghosts or witches as I believed in Chrysler motors, I imagined that Halloween was a much more macabre and meaningful night to them than it was to me. Imagine wandering out into the Yamacraw night, with the spirits and graveyards astir with disinterred fury, and the witches congregating in wicked clusters around the funeral sites of souls long dead and resurrected for a single night. God, I was fired up to hear about Halloween on Yamacraw. “What are you cats gonna be doin’ on October thirty-first?” I asked satanically. “Nuttin’,” Prophet answered without flinching. “C’mon, man. There is something going on October thirty-first. A holiday where we go from door to door with bags in our grubby little hands. Well. What holiday am I talking about?”
The Water is Wide
107
They all simply stared at me with their inscrutable expressions that collectively said that they were in the hands of a madman who asked impossible questions. I became more animated. Every time they did not respond to some obvious question I handed them, I always thought that it was simply because I was not explaining it adequately or that I was not elaborating properly on the given theme. Articulation was not a personal forte, and I often had to backtrack, slow down, or repeat something again and again before they caught the gist of what I said. Since it was inconceivable to me that Halloween was not as much a part of their vocabulary as it was of mine, I felt that I had obfuscated the high festival of witchcraft with a combination of too much talk and too much bull. Finally I said, “What are you going to do on Halloween?” “Nuttin’,” said Prophet. “Nuttin’,” said everyone else. “What do you usually do on Halloween?” “Nuttin’,” came the answer again. “Wait a minute. You mean to tell me you have never dressed up as a ghost and gone out trick-or-treating?” “Man crazy,” Frank said. “Triggertricking?” someone asked. “I ain’t dress up no ghost clothes,” said Cindy Lou, “You have never gone out with a bag, dressed up in a costume, knocked at people’s doors, said ‘trick or treat,’ and had them give you candy?” “Naw,” Top Cat replied. “That is ridiculous.” I was amazed. “That is un-American and is completely ridiculous. Halloween is one of the truly great parts of being a kid. Running around a neighborhood, soaping up people’s windows, collecting big bags of candy. Those are great memories.” “What he say?” Ethel questioned Cindy Lou. “He didn’t say nuttin’,” Cindy Lou answered. “Well, I’ll have to check into this stuff. No life is complete without a little trick-or-treating in it.”
The Water is Wide
108
When I arrived home that evening, Bernie was sitting in the living room talking with Barbara. Three teachers together, by definition, means that the talk centers around events in the classroom and at school. I told them that I had just learned that none of my students had participated in that great celebration of life and after-life, Halloween. “Why don’t you bring them over to Beaufort for Halloween?” Barbara asked. “Bring them over and they can come to the Halloween party we’re having at my school. Hell, bring them over early and they can go to the carnival, then ride on a float in the parade.” Bernie’s voice grew louder. “Where will they stay?” I asked. “I’ll get them places to stay. My PTA is coming along fine this year. They are ready to go. To do something. The kids can stay in the houses of the parents.” “Bernie, you are not living in Harlem. You are living in Port Royal, South Carolina, an area where white people historically have, shall we say, looked down upon black people.” “You forget one thing, my boy. They love me. They think that Bernie Schein is a genius. And do you know what, Conroy?” Here he whispered low, intimately: “They are absolutely correct. I am a genius.” “You are an asshole,” I whispered back, “but you have a great idea, my lad.” On Monday, I unveiled the master plan to the kids. I told them we would dress up in costumes, get bags with pictures of pumpkins on them, and hit every house in Beaufort for candy. I related my own personal Halloween history for them: two years as Casper, the friendly ghost, two years as a hobo, one year as Frankenstein. I did not tell them that one year my best friend and I put soot on our faces and went disguised as black minstrels. Then I recounted the houses of the truly generous people of the world who prepared for Halloween with a joyful spirit and vastness of heart. When I lived in Florida, when Dad was shipped to the Mediterranean, there were two elderly women with tiny hands and wrinkled faces who inhabited a great white house with a shrubchoked garden. On Halloween, they made candy apples and gave them out to children who came to their door. A man in Virginia, who lived alone, gave out all-day suckers every Halloween—round, multiflavored suckers. Halloween was a time of candy corn, jack-o’-
The Water is Wide
109
lanterns, candy kisses, peanut-butter cups, bubble gum, Fig Newtons, soapy windows. I tried to tell about Halloween and what it represented to me—a great ritual of childhood when the world for a single night opened its doors and its coffers of candy and fun and happiness. “Can you go to Beaufort for Halloween? It is this Friday, and we are going to have to work fast.” “Yeah.” everyone could go. There was no problem. “O.K. Everybody is going to have to get a note from his parents that says, ‘I give my permission for so and so to go to Beaufort for Halloween.’ The big shots demand that I get this note in case any of you die at the shock of being under the Big Lights in Beaufort. Bring your notes in tomorrow so we will be ready to go.” “What boat you take us out?” Frank asked. “I don’t have a boat yet. I am leaving the island this afternoon to find a boat.” “How big?” “Look, gang, it ain’t going to be no aircraft carrier or battleship.” Later I went in and told Mrs. Brown about this superb brainstorm. I expected her to praise me profusely, tell me what an outstanding job I was doing, and offer to help me in any way possible. I would blush modestly, shuffle my right foot back and forth over an imaginary mark on the floor, lower my head, and say, “Aw, shucks,” or something as appropriate. “No, you cannot go,” she said simply. “Why the hell not?” I asked incredulously. “These children don’t need trips. They need fundamentals. They need drill and more drill.” “Mrs. Brown, that is what you think they need. It is not what I think they need. It is not what I think they need and since those eighteen children are my responsibility and since it is up to me to decide how best to educate them, I am going to take them to Beaufort for Halloween.” “I am the principal.” “I was