ejm cover (i).qxd
3/9/05
11:24 AM
Page 1
ISBN 1-84544-098-6
ISSN 0309-0566
Volume 39 Number 3/4 2005
European Journal of Marketing The state of research in marketing Guest Editors: Nick Lee and John Saunders
www.emeraldinsight.com
European Journal of Marketing
ISSN 0309-0566 Volume 39 Number 3/4 2005
The state of research in marketing Guest Editors Nick Lee and John Saunders
Access this journal online _________________________
243
Editorial advisory board __________________________
244
GUEST EDITORIAL Whither research in marketing? John Saunders and Nick Lee _____________________________________
245
COMMENTARY Where are we and where are we going? The status and future of research in marketing Dale Littler and Caroline Tynan __________________________________
261
Beyond incommensurability? Empirical expansion on diversity in research Andrea Davies and James A. Fitchett ______________________________
272
Grounded theory, ethnography and phenomenology: a comparative analysis of three qualitative strategies for marketing research Christina Goulding _____________________________________________
294
Qualitative research in marketing: road-map for a wilderness of complexity and unpredictability Evert Gummesson______________________________________________
Access this journal electronically The current and past volumes of this journal are available at:
www.emeraldinsight.com/0309-0566.htm You can also search more than 100 additional Emerald journals in Emerald Fulltext (www.emeraldinsight.com/ft) and Emerald Management Xtra (www.emeraldinsight.com/emx) See page following contents for full details of what your access includes.
309
CONTENTS
CONTENTS
The rise and fall of the Latin Square in marketing: a cautionary tale
continued
Robert P. Hamlin ______________________________________________
328
Equivalence of survey data: relevance for international marketing Hester van Herk, Ype H. Poortinga and Theo M.M. Verhallen __________
351
The evolution of ‘‘classical mythology’’ within marketing measure development Nick Lee and Graham Hooley ____________________________________
365
Long life to marketing research: a postmodern view Michela Addis and Stefano Podesta`________________________________
386
About the authors ________________________________
413
Call for papers ___________________________________
416
www.emeraldinsight.com/ejm.htm As a subscriber to this journal, you can benefit from instant, electronic access to this title via Emerald Fulltext and Emerald Management Xtra. Your access includes a variety of features that increase the value of your journal subscription.
Additional complimentary services available
How to access this journal electronically
E-mail alert services These services allow you to be kept up to date with the latest additions to the journal via e-mail, as soon as new material enters the database. Further information about the services available can be found at www.emeraldinsight.com/alerts
To benefit from electronic access to this journal you first need to register via the internet. Registration is simple and full instructions are available online at www.emeraldinsight.com/admin Once registration is completed, your institution will have instant access to all articles through the journal’s Table of Contents page at www.emeraldinsight.com/0309-0566.htm More information about the journal is also available at www.emeraldinsight.com/ ejm.htm Our liberal institution-wide licence allows everyone within your institution to access your journal electronically, making your subscription more cost-effective. Our web site has been designed to provide you with a comprehensive, simple system that needs only minimum administration. Access is available via IP authentication or username and password.
Key features of Emerald electronic journals Automatic permission to make up to 25 copies of individual articles This facility can be used for training purposes, course notes, seminars etc. This only applies to articles of which Emerald owns copyright. For further details visit www.emeraldinsight.com/ copyright Online publishing and archiving As well as current volumes of the journal, you can also gain access to past volumes on the internet via Emerald Fulltext and Emerald Management Xtra. You can browse or search these databases for relevant articles. Key readings This feature provides abstracts of related articles chosen by the journal editor, selected to provide readers with current awareness of interesting articles from other publications in the field. Reference linking Direct links from the journal article references to abstracts of the most influential articles cited. Where possible, this link is to the full text of the article. E-mail an article Allows users to e-mail links to relevant and interesting articles to another computer for later use, reference or printing purposes. Emerald structured abstracts New for 2005, Emerald structured abstracts provide consistent, clear and informative summaries of the content of the articles, allowing faster evaluation of papers.
Your access includes a variety of features that add to the functionality and value of your journal subscription:
Research register A web-based research forum that provides insider information on research activity world-wide located at www.emeraldinsight.com/researchregister You can also register your research activity here. User services Comprehensive librarian and user toolkits have been created to help you get the most from your journal subscription. For further information about what is available visit www.emeraldinsight.com/usagetoolkit
Choice of access Electronic access to this journal is available via a number of channels. Our web site www.emeraldinsight.com is the recommended means of electronic access, as it provides fully searchable and value added access to the complete content of the journal. However, you can also access and search the article content of this journal through the following journal delivery services: EBSCOHost Electronic Journals Service ejournals.ebsco.com Huber E-Journals e-journals.hanshuber.com/english/index.htm Informatics J-Gate www.j-gate.informindia.co.in Ingenta www.ingenta.com Minerva Electronic Online Services www.minerva.at OCLC FirstSearch www.oclc.org/firstsearch SilverLinker www.ovid.com SwetsWise www.swetswise.com TDnet www.tdnet.com
Emerald Customer Support For customer support and technical help contact: E-mail
[email protected] Web www.emeraldinsight.com/customercharter Tel +44 (0) 1274 785278 Fax +44 (0) 1274 785204
EJM 39,3/4
EDITORIAL REVIEW BOARD
Professor Nicholas Alexander University of Ulster, Northern Ireland Dr Ali Bin Al-Khalifa University of Bahrain, State of Bahrain Professor George Avlonitis Athens University of Economics & Business, Greece Professor Michael Baker Westburn Publishers Ltd, UK Dr Susan Baker Cranfield University, UK Professor John Balmer Bradford Management Centre, UK Professor Jim Bell University of Ulster, Magee College, Northern Ireland Professor Bjo¨rn Bjerke Malmo¨ University, Sweden Professor Stephen Brown University of Ulster at Jordanstown, Northern Ireland Professor Francis Buttle Macquarie University, Australia Professor Tamar Cavusgil Michigan State University, USA Professor Bill Clarke University of Ulster, Northern Ireland Professor Brett Collins Auckland University of Technology, New Zealand Professor Nicole Coviello University of Auckland, New Zealand Professor David Cravens Texas Christian University, USA Professor Anthony Cunningham Co. Dublin, Ireland Professor Tevfik Dalgic University of Texas at Dallas, USA Dr Ken Deans University of Otago, New Zealand Professor Adamantios Diamantopoulos Loughborough University, UK Dr John Egan Middlesex University Business School, UK Professor John Fahy University of Limerick, Ireland Dr Kim Fam City University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong Professor Gordon R. Foxall Cardiff University, UK Professor Pervez Ghauri Manchester School of Management, UMIST, UK Professor Christina Goulding University of Wolverhampton, UK Ken Grant Monash University, Australia Professor Gordon Greenley Aston Business School, UK Professor Kjell Grønhaug Norges Handelshoyskole, Norway Professor Lloyd Harris Cardiff Business School, UK Dr Phil Harris Manchester Metropolitan University, UK Professor Roy Hayhurst University of Limerick, Ireland Professor Graham J. Hooley Aston Business School, UK European Journal of Marketing, Dr Gillian Hopkinson Vol. 39 No. 3/4, 2005 Lancaster University Management School, UK p. 244 Professor Ga´bor Hova´nyi # Emerald Group Publishing Limited Panno´nia UTCA, Hungary
244
0309-0566
Professor Claes Hultman ¨ rebro University, Sweden O Professor Mark Jenkins Nottingham University Business School, UK Professor David Jobber University of Bradford, UK Dr La´szlo´ Ka´rpa´ti University of Debrecen, Hungary Professor Hans Kasper University of Maastricht, The Netherlands Professor Erdener Kaynak Pennstate Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, USA Professor David Kirby University of Surrey, UK Professor Philip Kitchen The University of Hull, UK Professor Simon Knox Cranfield University, UK Professor Raymond LaForge University of Louisville, USA Professor Uolevi Lehtinen University of Tampere, Finland Professor Barbara Lewis Manchester School of Management, UMIST, UK Professor Veronica Liljander Swedish School of Economics and Business Administration, Finland Professor Andrew McAuley University of Stirling, UK Professor Jan Mattsson Roskilde University, Denmark Professor Bill Merrilees Griffith University, Australia Professor Morgan Miles Georgia Southern University, USA Professor dr Carla Millar TSM Business School, The Netherlands Professor Luiz Moutinho University of Glasgow Business School, UK Professor Patrick Murphy University of Notre Dame, USA Professor Aron O’Cass The University of Newcastle, Australia Professor Adrian Palmer University of Gloucestershire, UK Professor Paul Patterson University of New South Wales, Australia Professor Chad Perry The Gap, Queensland, Australia Professor Nigel Piercy University of Warwick, UK Professor David Shipley University of Dublin, Ireland Dr Wai-sum Siu Hong Kong Baptist University, Hong Kong Professor Richard Speed Melbourne Business School, Australia Professor Peter Turnbull University of Birmingham, UK Professor Caroline Tynan Nottingham University Business School, UK Professor Eduard Urban University of Economics, Czechoslovakia Dr Cleopatra Veloutsou University of Glasgow, Scotland, UK Professor Salvatore Vicari Bocconi University, Milan, Italy Professor Martin Wetzels Eindhoven University of Technology, The Netherlands Professor Len Tiu Wright De Montfort University, UK
GUEST EDITORIAL
Guest editorial
Whither research in marketing? John Saunders and Nick Lee Aston Business School, Aston University, Birmingham, UK
245
Abstract Purpose – To introduce the contents of this special issue on research in marketing and comment on the development of the discipline in UK universities. Design/methodology/approach – Relates each paper to a taxonomy of academic research and comments on their content. Examines major trends in higher education and relates them to the fortunes of marketing educators. Findings – There are reasons to be cheerful about academic marketing in the UK: there are clearly opportunities to publish in the world’s leading academic journals, increased funding for the discipline, the acceptability of a wide range of methodologies and the increasing influence of marketing. Less encouraging is the naı¨ve and destructive competition between universities and the consequent destruction of academic development. Research limitations/implications – This is a UK perspective that depends on limited knowledge of other than a few other countries. Practical implications – There are good reasons to be positive about an academic career in marketing, but also a desperate need to tackle the naı¨ve strategies of universities and to intervene to mend the gaps in the development of academic marketers. Originality/value – Gives an insight in to the range of research in marketing, and an insight into the opportunities and pitfalls of a career in academic marketing research. Keywords Market research, Universities, United Kingdom
About the Guest Editors John Saunders is Professor of Marketing, Head of Aston Business School and Pro-Vice Chancellor of Aston University. Besides being Dean of the Senate of the CIM, he has senior responsibilities within the EFMD and AACSB International. In addition, he has served on the research selectivity exercises of the UK, The Netherlands and New Zealand and on accreditation panels for EQUIS, AACSB International and the QAA. His research has covered market modelling and marketing strategy but focuses most recently on managerial incompetence. His articles have appeared in Journal of Marketing Research, Journal of Marketing, Marketing Science, International Journal of Research in Marketing, Journal of International Business Studies, Journal of Business Research, European Journal of Marketing, and many others. Nick Lee is a Lecturer in Marketing at Aston Business School. His research interests include sales management, electronic commerce, and marketing research philosophy and methodology. He has presented his work at international conferences around the world, and was the recipient of the 2002 EMAC Conference award for best paper based on doctoral work, as well as a 2002 UK Chartered Institute of Marketing Research Initiative Award. He lectures in marketing research at undergraduate and postgraduate level.
Reasons to be cheerful: part 1 Dale Littler and Caroline Tynan’s powerful commentary in this special issue suggests that we have reason to despair, but we also have reasons to cheerful about the state of
European Journal of Marketing Vol. 39 No. 3/4, 2005 pp. 245-260 q Emerald Group Publishing Limited 0309-0566 DOI 10.1108/03090560510581755
EJM 39,3/4
246
research in marketing. Our subject is blossoming. The long established marketing academies, including AM, AMA, EMAC and MSI, are thriving to such an extent that EMAC is forever concerned about its annual conference getting too large and inclusive. As our discipline globalises new associations, such as ANZMAC, are flourishing and spawning new journals. Much of this energy comes from demand for our subject from undergraduate and graduate students who pay most of our wages and justify our existence. MBA and other graduate programmes, that have always been associated with the strongest research tradition, account for most of the increased demand. So strong is the growth in this market that Britain is producing more MBAs per head of population than the USA[1]. This burgeoning market contrasts with other parts of higher education where demand is slipping. Across the world, students are spurning science and technology for the green fields and blue skies of marketing, psychology and other social sciences disciplines. Marketers should have some concern about this trend because someone still has to design and make what they sell. Even though academic salaries are notionally standardised across disciplines and across institutions in state universities, markets are at work and demand is pushing up salaries and promotion prospects for marketing academics. Americans invented academic marketing and they still dominate the subject. Some have bemoaned the dominance of “American journals” which are biased against non-American research. Many still hold this view though the evidence is otherwise. The Benelux countries have a string of academics that are top of the food chain in the very journals that are supposedly “biased”, and their data sets and first language are certainly not American. Among these are colleagues at Tilburg, Groningen and Louven[2]. Within the UK, the successes of Stephen Brown (Brown et al., 2003), and Adamantios Diamantopoulos (Diamantopoulos and Winklhofer, 2001) show a diversity of European research that has overcome this supposed prejudice. The circumvention of once impregnable journals is not restricted to the odd individual, the majority of current output of at least three marketing groups in the UK is within “fortress USA”. The point here is not to elevate US journals over those published elsewhere in the world, but to celebrate their lack of geographical exclusivity. Reasons to be cheerful: part 2 Taking a more parochial view, the picture in Britain is particularly rosy. British business schools take up solid share of the world’s leading MBA programmes, although the top slots are still held by America’s hugely endowed private schools (The Economist, 2003). British business schools also have a much more embedded research culture than in the majority of European counties, particularly the larger ones. This often becomes apparent in EQUIS accreditations that uncover research outputs and research cultures that are undeveloped compared with those in English-speaking countries. Realistically European business schools will never compete with their US competitors until university vice-chancellors and business school deans focus on raising money rather than spending it. The Oxford Centre for Higher Education Funding (Palfreyman, 2002) squeals that expenditure per undergraduate at relatively wealthy Oxford is one-third of the levels of Harvard and Princeton, the teaching load per academic is twice as high and salaries are a third to a half lower. Notwithstanding
their academic source, their figures are misleading. The OxCHEPS calculations add all of the university’s endowment income to undergraduates then forgets that Oxford also receive £80 million from the Higher Education Funding Council for England (HEFCE) for research and staff development. When calculating funding it is as reasonable to add this to the income per student as it is to allocate the whole of endowment income. Although HEFCE research income is not for teaching it does pay more than half of some academic salary bills, increases the number of staff a university can employ to teach the same number of students and therefore brings down teaching loads. When the fee income per students rises from £1,050 to £3,000, Oxford’s total fee and state funding per undergraduate will be higher than Harvard. However, the fees increase will do little to overcome Oxford’s complaints. The gap in income is the huge endowment income of the US school that, based on OxCHEPS’ figures, account for 82 per cent of the cost of educating Harvard’s undergraduates. Adding Birmingham, a Russell group university, and UCE, a new university shows the funding gap per students between Oxford and Birmingham is as wide as that between Oxford and Harvard. The reason why Oxford students are so well funded compared with Birmingham’s students is Oxford’s superior endowments and the government’s extra funding of £2,000 per year given to the colleges. Even though Birmingham’s endowments and research income are hugely greater than UCE’s, their overall funding per student is surprisingly close. Whatever the figures, for the moment many British business school deans are off the hook. The HEFCE has just increased the “band D” funds for most marketing students by over 20 per cent starting 2004/2005. In addition, marketing can also access some higher level “band C” funding that is available for cost centre 7 (psychology and behavioural sciences) and 25 (IT and system sciences) (HEFCE, 2003a). The money is there, but anticipate that many heads of business school and heads of marketing will have to spend the next few years getting their hands on it. Then Tony Blair risked his Government over increased student fees. The Higher Education Bill is still in the committee stage at the time of writing but it is likely that fees will rise from £1,050 to £3,000 for most business students within a few years (Grice, 2004). The impact of England’s proposed increase in student fees also shows why the super-e´lite colleges are shouting about wanting to set fees higher than £3,000 (see Table I). Because Oxford has so much other income, the increased fee only increases their income by 9 per cent. In contrast, Birmingham University can hope to receive 27 per cent more per student and UCE 38 per cent. That is, if UCE have the pulling power to charge the maximum fee allowed. Few academic marketers across the world have as rosy funding prospects as the British. In the USA many state colleges are cutting their student intakes to keep within ever-declining state budgets. In most of Europe and many other developed economies, academics suffer in regimes where funds are low and where universities have to accept all students who matriculate. The result is huge first year classes with little student support and where most students drop out or take many years to graduate (The Economist, 2004). The opening address of one of Sorbonne’s professors to his class of 80 students gives an insight: Too many. Half of you will have to leave. When we are down to 40 I’ll start teaching. Foreigners will go first.
Guest editorial
247
EJM 39,3/4
Oxford
Harvard
2,000 80
9,000 360
1,000 40
57 2
1 0
59 80 139
0 0 0
0 0 0
67 34 101
41 1
10,500 5,500 16,000
6,680 10,820 17,500
6,000 5,750 11,750
16,765 7,923 24,688
12,873 2,290 15,163
State research funding Per student Per graduate
5,000 7,619
0 0
0 0
1,377 2,028
66 78
Endowment income Per student Per graduate Undergraduate fee
5,000 7,619 1,050
20,571 53,892 15,940
3,404 6,667 15,620
92 136 1,050
3 3 1,050
State funding Per undergraduate Undergraduate financial aid
6,000 0
0 23,990
0 22,190
4,000 0
4,000 0
Income per undergraduate Teaching plus endowment Teaching, endowment and other state funding Expressed as percentage of Oxford
14,669 22,288 100
65,842 65,842 295
20,097 20,097 90
5186 7214 32
5,053 5,131 23
Impact of increased fees Income per student Increased income
24,238 9
9,164 27
7,081 38
Endowment capital: £ millions Endowment yield: £ millions (4 per cent)
248
State funding (2002) Teaching: £ millions Research: £ millions Total: £ millions Students Undergraduate Postgraduate Total
Table I. Poor little rich colleges
Duke
Birmingham
UCE
No wonder that wealthy French students study at the fiercely selective grande e´coles. It is also clear why the OECD sees the university funding model that caused Tony Blair such difficulties as a “role model for Europe” (Green, 2004). Reasons to be cheerful: part 3 Part of the joy of being a researcher in marketing is its sheer variety and eclecticism. Figure 1 tries to capture some of the range, but is a dendrogram that will always grow, and whose choice of dendrites will always be personal. The papers in this special issue show this profusion of approaches and cover many parts of the framework. In the first paper[3], Davies and Fitchett study a divide that often occurs across between the qualitative, quantitative and modelling traditions in our dendogram, provoking a rethink of what appears to have become a key issue within marketing research – both in an academic and social sense (as attendance at many conferences will demonstrate!). Specifically, while it often seems to many of us that there is an unbridgeable divide between the epistemological “camps” of positivism and interpretivism which have developed in marketing over the last few decades, Davies
Guest editorial
249
Figure 1. Dendrogram of research in marketing
EJM 39,3/4
250
and Fitchett argue that this divisive approach is unnecessary and potentially harmful. Beginning with a discussion of how Kuhn’s (1970) paradigmatic incommensurability thesis has been misunderstood within marketing research, they go on to show that one should consider the difference between how we think about research, and how we actually go about doing research, leading to a re-examination of the very concept of a “paradigm”. They illustrate their argument with a discussion of two studies on the same topic, each conducted independently under different epistemological assumptions. Ultimately, adherence to ideas of paradigm incommensurability is shown to be an unhelpful and artificial barrier to greater understanding, leading to marginalisation of potentially useful findings and the irrelevance of marketing research to all but those inside their narrow paradigmatic bunkers. The second paper, by Goulding, fits rather more neatly into the qualitative branch in Figure 1, as a comparison and review of three different qualitative strategies. Here, Goulding provides an interesting counterpoint to Davies and Fitchett, by touching on the paradigmatic debate described above, but considering it to be slowing down rather than still raging. Goulding discusses the methodologies of Grounded Theory, ethnography, and phenomenology, giving an overview of the philosophical underpinnings of each, as well as an appreciation of the key authors and topics relevant to each approach within marketing research. Furthermore, the paper provides an excellent introduction to the process of conducting research using each of the three approaches. One of the key contributions of this paper is its clear exposition of exactly what these three methodologies actually entail. The need for such an appreciation is clear since, as Goulding argues, for too long have marketing researchers rather carelessly used terms such as “grounded theory”, “ethnography”, and “phenomenology”, often to indicate simply the use of a qualitative approach. Goulding provides a valuable overview of the key differences between such methods, and their characteristics. She also argues that these methods deserve wider application within marketing research, rather than their current marginalisation within consumer-related research, which will hopefully inspire readers who may have previously ignored these methodologies to investigate them further. Gummesson’s paper is also squarely located within the “qualitative” branch of our dendogram. While his paper is a very personal view, it is clear that it also touches on many of the themes that run throughout the content of this special issue. In particular, Gummesson appears to concur with Davies and Fitchett’s argument that qualitative and quantitative approaches should not be seen as fundamentally opposed, but instead as complementary. Gummesson’s paper is also relevant to Goulding’s work, with its focus on the actual process of doing research. In particular, Gummesson argues that we are doing our students, and the readers of our research, a disservice by focussing on the data collection methodology of our studies rather than the analysis and interpretation of the qualitative data themselves. He makes a large contribution by integrating a huge amount of existing theoretical knowledge with his own considerable experience to create a set of useful guidelines for researchers. Following this, Gummesson concentrates on the generation of theory itself – and again Kuhn (1970) makes an appearance. In this section Gummesson discusses a number of viewpoints which should stimulate considerable debate amongst marketing academia – such as that we should not solely consider theory generation as a cumulative process, nor accept unquestioningly everything we read simply because it is in a certain journal or by a
certain author. Finally, similar to Addis and Podesta below, Gummesson recommends that each of us follows his/her own path to generate knowledge within a pluralistic framework, rather than blindly participating in what he calls the “power games” of the mainstream. As an example he then discusses his own method of choice – interactive research. Whether or not you agree with his thesis, Gummesson in this paper does what all good research should do, makes us think. The next three papers provide something of a break from the qualitative or integrative approaches presented so far, being as they are each about a key quantitative concept that has had a long history within marketing research. First, directly referencing branch 2.2.4 of our tree diagram, Hamlin provides a very interesting historical analysis of the Latin Square experimental design in marketing research – often using a metaphor of the “Titanic” to illustrate his points, although unfortunately without visual reference to Kate Winslet. The narrow focus of Hamlin’s paper provides two key contributions. First, he is able to provide an excellent introduction to the Latin Square (and other experimental designs in general), which should be of particular interest to our younger readers raised on the hegemony of survey research. Second, and perfectly in keeping with the aims of this special issue, Hamlin is able to draw implications for academic research in marketing with his cautionary tale of how the Latin Square design was “done to death” by errors in its application and interpretation. This case study has important implications for marketing researchers – some of which are also touched on by Lee and Hooley in their paper. Specifically, poor application of analysis techniques does not mean that the techniques are poor, merely that the researcher is poor. Furthermore, we as researchers, teachers and reviewers have a duty to understand fully the techniques we use, rather than simply quoting precedence, which can allow serious errors to compound one another – eventually leading to invalid results and the death of rigorous research. All of us would do well to take note of Hamlin’s work here, and its relevance to our own. The next paper is by van Herk, Poortinga and Verhallen, and it deals with a topic that has generated considerable interest among marketing researchers recently – that of the cross-cultural equivalence of survey data – thus relating to branch 2.1 of the dendogram. Van Herk, Poortinga and Verhallen contribute to this area by integrating what may have become two rather disparate approaches – that of the statistical assessment of measurement invariance, and the more general assessment of the research design itself. Ignorance of the latter is likely to introduce bias into research designs, which is compounded by ignorance of the former, meaning one does not realise the biases inherent in one’s data. Ultimately, not taking into account either of these approaches may lead to erroneous conclusions – and worse, one may never be aware of the errors. Van Herk, Poortinga and Verhallen’s paper demystifies and synthesises the cross-cultural equivalence issues, which can appear rather arcane to the uninitiated researcher, and they also provide some extremely useful guidelines on how to interpret the results of equivalence tests. The paper, like Hamlin’s, also has considerable relevance to commercial market researchers (and users of commercial research) with its integration of an interesting commercial study as an example and specific reference to areas where commercial research needs to improve its methods. Lee and Hooley’s paper is squarely located in section 2.1.4 of our dendogram, that of psychometrics. However in a similar, although less overt, way to Hamlin they also attempt to draw some wider implications for marketing research from their discussion
Guest editorial
251
EJM 39,3/4
252
of one specific technique. Psychometrics has become one of the driving forces of marketing research in the last 25 years, and Lee and Hooley attempt to elucidate some of the key issues regarding the evolution of these techniques in marketing research. Specifically, they discuss what have become unquestioned assumptions in psychometric measure development in marketing – which they term “classical mythology”. In particular, Lee and Hooley deal with the statistical techniques of measure purification, such as exploratory factor analysis and internal consistency, which have been the mainstays of measure development within marketing for over 20 years, and are still widely used today. Lee and Hooley link the underlying theory of psychometrics to our accepted assumptions, such as the widely quoted cut-off point of 0.7 for coefficient alpha, to show that – rather than being absolute rules – these assumptions are often somewhat groundless and should be viewed as such. As a result they recommend that researchers should learn to interpret their results rather than merely report them. In fact, they suggest that the dogmatic adherence to psychometric “rules” could have actually detracted from the validity of our findings rather than enhanced it, a situation which may be seen in other branches of marketing research as well. Thus, within this paper are some valuable conceptual and technical tools for interpreting existing work, as well as to guide research in the future. Our final paper is by Addis and Podesta`, and deals with an issue which has been the source of much debate within marketing research over the past decade – both within the hallowed halls and journals of marketing academia, and the smoky bars many of us also frequent – namely the postmodern “turn”. We might consider this piece of research as slotting into branch 1.1.3 of our tree, although doubtless others would argue it cannot be so atomistically classified. In their paper Addis and Podesta` consider that while the establishment of postmodern thought within marketing would necessitate a serious rethink of the discipline, this “revolution” could have major benefits. Essentially, the rejection of the scientific metanarrative and the removal of objectivity from our frames of reference means we would operate without the “safety net” of scientific rationality – which they contend could also constitute a cage. Thus, similar to Gummesson’s work, they advocate freedom for marketing researchers – and in this case freedom even from the concepts of true and false. Research is judged herein on a single criterion, does the knowledge it creates enrich the individual and/or the community? To illuminate some of these concepts, Addis and Podesta` trace the history of thought in marketing research, beginning from the 1950s, arguing that it has become stagnant and trapped inside the boundaries of narrow specialisms and methodologies. They then move to a discussion of relationship and experiential marketing, two approaches that challenged the existing direction of marketing research. Addis and Podesta` argue that, although both approaches criticised the application of marketing knowledge, neither actually attacked the knowledge generation process itself. By contrast, Addis and Podesta` provide a fascinating deconstruction of the scientific process, leading to some thoughts on the possible postmodern future of marketing research. Ultimately, Addis and Podesta` strongly deny the charge of nihilism which has sometimes been levelled against postmodernism, and point to a future familiar to all of us who watched the “Matrix” trilogy – where we are freed from “the machine”, and are responsible for our own knowledge generation. Free to conduct research, as Neo might say “because we choose to”.
Reasons to be doleful: part 4 But enough of optimism! There is plenty of reason to be doleful about research in marketing. Success is damaging the discipline. Marketers would suggest that in a crowded market, like that for university education, competitors should specialise. Unfortunately university vice-chancellors or principles have not read the book, so are careering towards lemming-like mutual destruction and pain (Saunders et al., 2000). Rather than focussing on their strengths, vice-chancellors are responding to student demand and making universities more alike. Marketing aside, university after university is closing down languages, science and engineering departments while diving into anything that is likely to increase scale. Media studies was the “joke” of the 1990s that teaching quality and research assessments have shown to be not so funny. The explosion in student numbers means psychology is rapidly becoming “the joke” of the new millennium, although it will also be fun watching how troubled Boots absorbs the huge supply of pharmacists that new programmes will soon be tipping onto an oversubscribed market. As part of business studies, marketing is nearing the tail end of a headlong dash into a mature and crowded market. For the last two decades, every so often, a lethargic university wakes up and says: “business school, we’ll have one of those too”, Depending how weak the analysis, the next move is either to slam together bits of the university that could have something to do with business (a bad idea), or confuse a business school with having a big building and then slam bits together (an even worse idea). The discipline of marketing, along with a few others, crops up when it is realised that the slammed together bits leave core subjects missing. The consequence is a vortex of decline (see Figure 2) that leaves the disciplines severely damaged. A traditional academic in a research-oriented school would follow track “I” from a taught research-oriented degree, through a doctorate and post-doctoral research to an academic position, and finally to a full professorship. That is the track in strong academic disciplines that are close to marketing, such as economics and psychology. Comparing the ideal track I with that occurring in many leading business schools, track ‘II’, shows many gaps: . Taught degrees. The taught degrees are often aggressively practical and career oriented. A successful business degree has graduates who are highly employable by blue chip companies, but have rarely studied a subject in depth and have little inkling of what social science research involves. The USA has the same problem and is the reason why leading schools recruit their research students from engineering, science, economics or psychology rather than their own business degrees. . Doctoral degrees. The orientation of business graduates or research students coming in from other disciplines means that doctoral programmes have to cover the basics of research, not the advanced research topics studied in US programmes. The frequent lack of methodological skills means many graduating doctors of philosophy cannot even understand articles in the leading journals in our discipline, never mind publish in those journals. . Post-doc. Such is the demand for marketing faculty that the traditional “post doc” research post has disappeared. Instead, students are recruited off doctoral programmes before their research is finished or complete their degrees while
Guest editorial
253
EJM 39,3/4
254
Figure 2. Vortex of decline
.
occupying teaching posts. Another reason for this gap is the lack of large funded research projects on which post-docs traditionally work. Lecturers. There is so much demand for lecturers that Europe has no tradition of the great recruiting conference typified by the summer AMA. At this, US schools vie for the best PhD students supervised by the top researchers. European schools often recruit practitioners, graduates, or people part of the way through their PhD. In some disciplines the academic life and that of practitioners are so
.
.
similar that people can switch between one and the other. This is not so in marketing where practice is completely unlike the life of a research academic. Young academics from aspiring schools (track III) are a rich source of young recruits for the leading schools. Just as soon as they as they show signs of research productivity, the leading schools pounce and steal the talent. Career progression. Budding researchers should have a chance to learn their craft as lecturers. In an ideal school, they would be part of a community of fellow academics at various stages of their career development. Such breeding grounds of excellence are becoming increasingly hard to maintain. Now the aspiring schools retaliate for their earlier losses by offering senior posts to still-developing young researchers. Leaps from lecturer to professor are common. These transfers plug gaps in developing schools but damage the culture in the donating school. Worryingly, these young academics lose the research infrastructure that could allow them to grow and are prematurely plunged into research leadership, or even more onerous administrative responsibilities. Aspiring schools have two strategies for managing their new appointments. The first alternative is to obtain immediate payback from their expensive acquisition by allocating them a major administrative role. That is likely to kill the goose that is supposed to continue laying golden eggs. The second alternative is to privilege the acquisition with low teaching and research support. This keeps the bird laying although, without the research infrastructure, less prolifically than before. The full cost to the aspiring school comes in paying for the cuckoo, which is fed by taking resources from their young colleagues. Professors. The vortex of decline leaves professors in all organisations isolated. Those in the leading schools have lost their lieutenants while those in the aspiring schools never had them. From on high, the answer to this problem is clear. Hire some more professors. Enthusiastic deans no longer talk of an additional professor of marketing, but two or three. Sadly the vortex of decline has ensured that such clutches of research leaders do not exist. The result – another round of head hunting and culture-destroying promotions.
The very success of marketing is destroying it. It takes years to train and allow an excellent marketing academic to develop, but the environment where they can grow and develop is very hard to maintain. Only when universities realise that business and marketing are not a quick fix will our discipline have time to grow organically and gain strength. By increasingly focusing research income, Britain’s HEFCs are trying to transmit the message that mediocrity does not pay. But while universities continue to confuse big and broad with best, they will cultivate the bland. Oh for the focus of London’s LBS, LSE and Imperial; Boston’s Harvard and MIT; or Europe’s HEC, IMD and INSEAD! Another strategic whim that has previously had Aston, Bradford, Birmingham, Cardiff, Huddersfield, Imperial, Leicester, Loughborough, MBS, UCE and UMIST in the headlines is the dream of mergers – another manifestation of big, broad and bland. Part of the rationalisation for this is an endearing faith in scale economies. It was even proposed that Imperial (11,495 students according to HESA (2004)) and UCL (17,805 students) should merge to achieve the scale of Harvard (17,500 students)! It is interesting to note that one of HEFCE’s own studies shows that scale does not reduce
Guest editorial
255
EJM 39,3/4
256
costs significantly since multi-site operations, that are the usual outcome from mergers, drive up central costs (Brignall and Pierce-Brown, 2004). Mergers cover whole universities, not just business schools, but since many highly marketable people work in business schools, it is they that are likely to suffer the mass efflux of staff that mergers precipitate. Some lessons from mergers are true for businesses as well as universities. Mergers are exciting for senior managers but distract attention from the core business, in our case conducting excellent teaching and research. They also have a devastating effect on morale and invariably degenerate into cost cutting to recover the original investment. Another reason to be doleful is the unfortunate scale of Britain’s marketing community. In strategic management “b*****d size” refers to a business unit that is too small to reap economies of scale yet too large to niche. Maybe academic marketing communities have the same problem. The mighty USA has the greatest academic power, but beyond that scale is not the thing. The next group of developed countries by size includes the European quartet France, Germany, Italy and Spain. Although they are economic middleweights, on the world academic scene they are featherweights. This is not because they lack marketing academics but is because they are large enough to have their own self-contained academic marketing communities. German academics become invisible to the rest of the world because they are expected to publish in German journals. Most of the French output goes into French journals and some in the community refer to “A” journals (meaning top international) and “AN” (national journals that are rated “A” in their home country only). In these cases the local publishing opportunities are great enough to absorb most output. This has two effects. First, never mind how good the local research and journals are, the output is invisible elsewhere in the world. Second, local traditions and research conventions emerge that do not necessarily make the local scene a stepping stone to the wider academic community. For a long time in the UK, that meant researching only a few of Figure 1’s dendrites. Until recently much research was managerial (dendrite 1.1.2), case oriented (1.2.2) or surveys of managers (2.1.2). Recently these have been supplemented by an enthusiasm for scale development (2.1.3), critical theory (1.1.1) and postmodern work (1.1.3). So intense is the focus on researching managers that some companies have managers filling out questionnaires for most of their working week, and questionnaire fatigue is growing (Maitland, 2004). Meanwhile the focus elsewhere in the world has been on consumer research (2.1.1 and 2.1.4), observation (2.2), model building (3.1), and analysis (3.2). The national tradition increases the parochialism of national research as the traditions and methodology of the local community grow out of synch with the rest of the world. The countries with large academic communities are the academic “b******d size”. Below them in size are a string of countries that are too small to be independent, so play the international game. Chief among these are the Benelux, Scandinavian and Australasian countries. Still, there is reason to be cheerful. While most people are trapped in their comfortable national community, a few brave souls are venturing forth to cross swords outside their national boundaries. This itself can cause a split. A venturesome academic either frequents both national and international conferences or becomes invisible at home. That is why British marketing
academics see little of people from LBS, and some of the leading Dutch marketing academics ignore EMAC. Reasons to be cheerful: part 5 So why are we cheerful? Publishers who travel to conferences across all disciplines and time zones recognise that there is something odd about marketing academics. They are generally happy. Why? There are a number of possible reasons. First, enough of us are close enough to business to recognise the joys of academic life. We can look in practitioner journals and see that even marketing directors are not paid all that much. We know the demands, uncertainty and risk of practice. We also know the joy of being able to take a long-term view; to take time over trying to do things properly rather than chasing short-term deadlines; the joys of research; indulging one’s inquisitiveness at other people’s expense. The joy of going into a bookshop and reading and realising that it is work! Joys in a marketing academic’s life also come from not having to fight over a fixed domain. Marketing practice is forever changing, always at the frontier of new developments, be they e-business or E coli. Being an eclectic discipline, it borrows, adapts or develops ideas from other fields. Marketing, like engineering, is about results so any means will do. Marketing also glorifies in its relevance. Sometimes for good, sometimes not; marketing is everywhere. With manufactured designs being transient and making “things” getting cheaper, value is in the mind and it is marketing that adds that value. Relevance also means that we are graced with students whose degree gives them a career, a chance in life. Certainly academic life has its difficulties but we are free spirits in an expanding and developing discipline. The vortex of decline makes life difficult but we can intervene. We can develop programmes as academic as our research. Where students learn how to create as well as use knowledge. There is certainly room for e´lite programmes that train marketing scientists with tools and skills that will make them invaluable to market research, consulting and the City in addition to academic life. We are also free to collaborate, so there is no reason why such programmes could not be shared across institutions. The Bologna Accord’s expectation of a 3 þ 2 (three-year undergraduate and two-year postgraduate degree) means that we will have to create a second year of postgraduate study to be able to award “European Masters” degrees. How great it would be if the second year concentrates on advanced research methods and an extended project. In Britain we also have reason to be cheered about the HEFCE’s decisions not to back an e´lite club of universities. The Russell Group tried numerous tricks to concentrate research in the middle-aged universities. The campaign was damaged by their own super-e´lite trying to grasp all the goodies for themselves (Oxbridge, plus the London trio of Imperial, UCL and LSE). Instead, funds will flow to excellent 3* or 4* research, wherever it is located (HEFCE, 2003a). However, the HEFCE research funding model is applying an inexorable pressure for centres of excellence. As research funding is focussed, a few institutions will have a concentration of internationally recognised researchers. One day, even vice-chancellors will recognise what strategists have understood for generations: it pays to concentrate, not dissipate. Figure 3 shows why. Where resources increase with effort, the return is
Guest editorial
257
EJM 39,3/4
258
Figure 3. Returns to scale
higher (3r) if resources are concentrated on one “Unit of Assessment” 2 (UoA) rather than the same effort being dissipated across UoA 1 and UoA 2. The increasing return on effort of research selectivity (HEFCE, 2003b) emphasises a return on scale that is general to academic activities (Figure 4). That explains the focus of the USA’s top universities, the clear focus of two of the self-selected e´lite UK institutions (Imperial and LSE) and the size distinction between 4, 5, and 5* rated business schools. The final reason to be cheerful is the pliability of marketing that allows it to fulfil anyone’s desires:
Figure 4. HEFCE’s increased funding concentration
.
Believe in capitalism? Well, that is what marketing is all about.
.
Anti-global? Then marketing is a way of presenting ideas and marshalling support.
.
Want to win an election? Political marketing will tell you how and will probably be discussed as much as policies.
.
.
Want to help the underprivileged? Marketing will help you raise money, increase awareness of people’s plight, and educate people about how to help themselves. Want to succeed as a marketing academic? Try marketing: find out what your target market is and respond accordingly.
Our job as academic marketers is to find out those things that help ourselves, and help others, achieve what they want. Our mission is to find ever better ways of “finding out what people want” and “responding accordingly”. The quest will never end because people and the technology will always change. That is why we have reason to be cheerful. Notes 1. Calculation based on MBA programme sizes reported in The Economist (2003). 2. The 2003 output of just three authors (with their colleagues) in what the leading US business schools class as tenure track journals includes Dekempe: Deleersnyder et al. (2002), Gielens and Dekimpe (2001), Nijs et al. (2001); Steamcamp: Baumgartner and Steenkamp (2001), Nijs et al. (2001); Widel: Brangule-Vlagsma et al. (2002), Elpers et al. (2003), Brangule-Vlagsma et al. (2002), Haaijer and Wedel (2001), Hofstede et al. (2002a, b), Kamakura et al. (2003), Pieters et al. (2002), Sandor and Wedel (2001). Unfortunately for Europe, Widel has just left for a chair at Wharton. 3. The order of the papers was determined strictly on alphabetical lines (as originally submitted), excepting the commentaries herein and by Littler and Tynan. References Baumgartner, H. and Steenkamp, J.-B.E.M. (2001), “Response styles in marketing research: a cross-national investigation”, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol. 38 No. 2, p. 143. Brangule-Vlagsma, K., Pieters, R.G.M. and Wedel, M. (2002), “The dynamics of value segments: modeling framework and empirical illustration”, International Journal of Research in Marketing, Vol. 19 No. 3, p. 267. Brignall, S. and Pierce-Brown, R. (2004), “Administrative efficiency in UK universities”, paper presented at the EAA Annual Congress, Prague, 1-3 April. Brown, S., Kozinets, R.V. and Sherry, J.F. Jr (2003), “Teaching old brands new tricks: retro branding and the revival of brand meaning”, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 67 No. 3, p. 19. Deleersnyder, B., Geyskens, I., Gielens, K. and Dekimpe, M.G. (2002), “How cannibalistic is the internet channel? A study of the newspaper industry in the United Kingdom and The Netherlands”, International Journal of Research in Marketing, Vol. 19 No. 4, p. 337. Diamantopoulos, A. and Winklhofer, H. (2001), “Index construction with formative indicators: an alternative to scale development”, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol. 38 No. 2, p. 269. (The) Economist (2003), Which MBA?, 15th ed., Economist Intelligence Unit, London. (The) Economist (2004), “Who pays to study?”, 22 January. Elpers, J., Woltman, L.C.M., Wedel, M. and Pieters, R.G.M. (2003), “Why do consumers stop viewing television commercials? Two experiments on the influence of moment-to-moment entertainment and information value”, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol. 40 No. 4, p. 437. Gielens, K. and Dekimpe, M.G. (2001), “Do international entry decisions of retail chains matter in the long run?”, International Journal of Research in Marketing, Vol. 18 No. 3, p. 235. Green, M. (2004), “Tuition fee proposal hailed as ‘role model for Europe’”, Financial Times, 21 January.
Guest editorial
259
EJM 39,3/4
260
Grice, A. (2004), “Chancellor appeals to MPs for unity in vote on top-up fees”, The Independent, 25 March. Haaijer, R. and Wedel, M. (2001), “Habit persistence in time series models of discrete choice”, Marketing Letters, Vol. 12 No. 1, p. 25. HEFCE (2003a), Developing the Funding Method for Teaching for 2003/4, HEFCE 2003/42, HEFCE, London, August. HEFCE (2003b), Recurrent Grant for 2003/4, HEFCE 2003/10, HEFCE, London, March. HESA (2004), available at: www.hesa.ac.uk/holisdocs/pubinfo/student/institution0102.htm Hofstede, F.T., Kim, Y. and Wedel, M. (2002a), “Bayesian prediction in hybrid conjoint analysis”, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol. 39 No. 2, p. 253. Hofstede, F.T., Wedel, M. and Steenkamp, J.-B.E.M. (2002b), “Identifying spatial segments in international markets”, Marketing Science, Vol. 21 No. 2, p. 160. Kamakura, W.A., Wedel, M., de Rosa, F. and Mazzon, J.A. (2003), “Cross-selling through database marketing: a mixed data factor analyzer for data augmentation and prediction”, International Journal of Research in Marketing, Vol. 20 No. 1, p. 45. Kuhn, T.S. (1970), The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL. Maitland, A. (2004), “Companies face an avalanche of questionnaires”, Financial Times, 26 March, p. 10. Nijs, V.R., Dekimpe, M.G., Steenkamp, J.-B.E.M. and Hanssens, D.H. (2001), “The category-demand effects of price promotions”, Marketing Science, Vol. 20 No. 1, p. 1. Parlfreyman, D. (2002), “Higher education in the United Kingdom: a viable e´lite-mass ‘third way’?”, Occasional Paper, No. 4, OxCHEPS, Oxford. Pieters, R., Warlop, L. and Wedel, M. (2002), “Breaking through the clutter: benefits of advertisement originality and familiarity for brand attention and memory”, Management Science, Vol. 48 No. 6, p. 765. Sandor, Z. and Wedel, M. (2001), “Designing conjoint choice experiments using managers’ prior beliefs”, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol. 38 No. 4, p. 430. Saunders, J., Stern, P., Wensley, R. and Forrester, R. (2000), “In search of lemmus lemmus: an investigation into convergent competition”, British Journal of Management, Vol. 11 No. 1, pp. S81-S95. Further reading Geyskens, I., Gielens, K. and Dekimpe, M.G. (2002), “The market valuation of internet channel additions”, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 66 No. 2, p. 102. Sandor, Z. and Wedel, M. (2002), “Profile construction in experimental choice designs for mixed logit models”, Marketing Science, Vol. 21 No. 4, p. 455. Scheer, L.K., Kumar, N. and Steenkamp, J.-B.E.M. (2003), “Reactions to perceived inequity in US and Dutch interorganizational relationships”, Academy of Management Journal, Vol. 46 No. 3, p. 303. Srinivasan, S., Pauwels, K., Hanssens, D. and Dekimpe, M. (2002), “Who benefits from price promotions?”, Harvard Business Review, Vol. 80 No. 9, p. 22.
The Emerald Research Register for this journal is available at www.emeraldinsight.com/researchregister
The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available at www.emeraldinsight.com/0309-0566.htm
COMMENTARY
Where are we and where are we going? The status and future of research in marketing
The status and future of research 261
Dale Littler Manchester School of Management, UMIST, Manchester, UK, and
Caroline Tynan Nottingham University Business School, Nottingham University, Nottingham, UK Abstract Purpose – The paper strives to assess the current status of research in marketing. Design/methodology/approach – The paper examines statistics showing the current position of market area studies. The paper also looks at the range of supply and demand factors affecting the quality and volume of research in marketing. Findings – The paper argues that there is a range of extrinsic factors that affect in some way how research in marketing is undertaken, how it is perceived more widely and the form of its output. Research in marketing also has its own internal drivers that reflect in particular the current position of its knowledge base, and the manner in which those engaged in research perceive research potential. Finally, on the basis of the analysis the paper suggests some practical means of enhancing research in marketing. Originality/value – This is important in identifying areas of concern that can be addressed in order to enhance the status of marketing. Keywords Market research, Education, Educational development Paper type Viewpoint
Introduction Many marketing academics when asked will generally register their dissatisfaction about the lack of recognition given to research in marketing. They may employ as evidence the low levels of research council support for research in marketing; they may even note the low regard often given to marketing by social scientists, including some of those in other areas of business and management. Even practitioners are voicing their concerns about business’s failure to give marketing the regard they consider it merits. Recent campaigns run by, inter alia, the Chartered Institute of Marketing suggest that marketing does not often have top executive representation, while the contribution they allege marketing makes to overall corporate performance is not acknowledged. Practitioners may not universally accept that academic marketing research is either relevant or makes a significant contribution to practice; and this in turn reinforces the low esteem that academic marketers feel that others in general hold of marketing per se and more specifically of the research that there is pressure on them to undertake.
European Journal of Marketing Vol. 39 No. 3/4, 2005 pp. 261-271 q Emerald Group Publishing Limited 0309-0566 DOI 10.1108/03090560510581764
EJM 39,3/4
262
The resources to engage in in-depth scholarship and extensive programmes of research are scarce while the considerable external pressures stemming from uncertainties in Government policies, the rapid expansion in business and management and the lack of availability of appropriately trained academic staff all add to the difficulties of marketing. In addition, there is still a dilemma concerning the legitimate domain of marketing (Wensley, 2000) and as recently as 1995, Wensley (1995) noted the lack of cumulative research on issues in marketing including such central topics as market structure and segmentation, market networks and inter-firm relationships, marketing orientation and the implementation of the marketing concept. The paper strives to assess the current status of research in marketing. We argue that there are a range of extrinsic factors that affect in some way how research is marketing is undertaken, how it is perceived more widely and the form of its output. Research in marketing also has its own internal drivers that reflect in particular the current position of its knowledge base, and the manner in which those engaged in research perceive research potential. Finally, on the basis of our analysis we suggest some practical means of enhancing research in marketing. The current position It is widely accepted, certainly by those in the business and management academic community, that Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) support for research in their area is in general unsatisfactory. Of the 16 disciplines for which the ESRC is responsible, both in 2000/2001 and 2001/2002 Management and Business Studies had the lowest success rate (21 per cent and 16 per cent respectively) of ESRC research grant applications. For comparison, “area studies” had success rates of 67 per cent and 50 per cent, while the figures for economics were 48 per cent and 40 per cent (Dobson, 2003). The success rates for applications to the defined research programmes in 2002-2003 was 33 per cent (ESRC, 2003, p. 75) with a total of 17 out of the 109 proposals supported being in “management and business” of which ten were in the area of “evolution of business knowledge’. For all the research programmes for which full statistics are available, for 2002/2003 only around 1.87 per cent of the total number of original applications was awarded in the area of management and business (ESRC, 2003, p. 77). The ESRC-supported Commission on Management Research established in 1993 identified some possible ways forward. Unfortunately this does not appear to have resulted in any long lasting significant positive results. More recently the AIM (ESRC, 2004) initiative sought to support business and management research although in very specific areas and it is too early to assess the possible effects, although the limited number of fellowships awarded, with only one in marketing, suggests that the effects will be limited. Business and management research often seeks support from elsewhere such as charitable trusts, but these have limited resources for which there are many competing demands. The majority of other funding sources often require solutions to relatively short-term policy and other questions. This scarcity of and major sources of available funding may have a negative effect on the development of basic knowledge in business and management. There is also much current dissatisfaction with the research output, with questions about the “relevance” and contribution of business and management research (see, for example, the comment by Varadarajan, 2003, p. 368) For example, the
Commission on the Social Sciences singled out research in business and management as the “greatest concern” because it was of a standard well below that of other research (Utley, 2003). If the position facing business and management researchers in general is difficult, it is even more so for those in marketing. Given its share of business and management it could justifiably be argued that marketing is significantly under-funded, a point reinforced by Bessant et al. (2003, p. 56), who noted that for some time academic marketing has had to survive without significant funding from the ESRC. The accusation that the ESRC review process is biased against marketing per se can be countered by the fact that the ESRC is only responsible for putting in place the evaluation of proposals that it receives and these are then subject to peer review. Possible explanations for the low success rate may reside in the inadequate “quality” of many of the proposals received or intrinsic inefficiencies in the peer review process. Many proposals may fail to secure support because they are deficient in themselves with poor definition of objectives, an inadequate literature review, insufficient attention to the development of a detailed, robust methodology, or a lack of attention to how the data will be analysed. There may also be difficulties in securing the support of a sufficient body of referees, both in terms of the number of academic marketers who are prepared to act in this role and, of those who do review, the time and effort they can afford or are willing to devote to reviewing. Moreover the lack of agreed paradigms unlike in other social sciences may lead to a higher level of disagreement by reviewers that may not enhance the ability of proposals to secure approval when considered by ESRC committees. The final decisions on acceptance or rejection are made by groups that are generally not exclusively “business and management” oriented; in fact in 2002/2003 only 8 per cent of the academics on the various ESRC boards were from management and business studies (ESRC, 2003). Few of these are likely to be familiar with the challenges of research in marketing. Here another influence may come into play: a possible perception that somehow or other marketing is not of the same calibre as other business and management subjects let alone other social sciences. Whether or not there are intrinsic biases either in perception or in process certainly demands greater analysis. However, the belief that there is such a bias can discourage marketing academics from investing in the development of proposals for this important academic funding body, leading to a reinforcement of the perception, supported by the statistics, that few research in marketing proposals are funded! There is also the question about the international status of marketing: in fact, the analysis of the last research assessment exercise (RAE) returns points to a concentration in UK-based journals, with a significant proportion of these not being seen as particularly prestigious. Some involve limited refereeing. There were few publications in what are regarded as “international journals” which is usually synonymous with top league US publications. It is the US journals that dominate the top rankings of academic marketing journals. Here British authors “cannot compete on an equal basis because they face implicit and explicit barriers when attempting to publish in the US” (Easton and Easton, 2003, p. 16). Apart from a possible prejudice against UK academics publishing there, it is evident that given the intense competition with US academics there are limited opportunities for the several hundred UK academics to publish in these prestigious “international” journals.
The status and future of research 263
EJM 39,3/4
264
There is at least one other dimension to the current position of marketing that merits mention at this stage and that is the increasing concern about its possible future given the difficulties in recruiting marketing academics that are disciplined researchers and effective educators across a range of levels. There are fears that there will insufficient numbers entering the profession to replace those who retire, with possible consequential deleterious impact on research in marketing. There are a range of supply and demand factors that in some way affect the quality and volume of research in marketing. These include the: . availability and source of resources to support research in marketing; . perceptions of research in marketing; . institutional process for assessing research in marketing; . “teaching” demands of marketing academics; . supply of marketing academics; and . internal dynamics of marketing. Resources We have already noted that there is severe competition for resources for what might be termed scholarly, long term, more basic research in the social sciences in general, and more especially in marketing. The ESRC allocates only 9 per cent of funds to management and business that in terms of student numbers represents 50 per cent of the social science community (Learning and Teaching Support Network, 2001). The policy of increasing selectivity with the concentration of funding in those departments that achieved a 5 or 5* suggests that many marketing academics cannot rely for any meaningful support from their own institutions which themselves have seen their research grant curtailed. Even where this policy is not being strictly followed, as in Scotland, the lack of growth in the availability of funds for research per se means the opportunities for universities to allow significant research time will undoubtedly be limited. Marketers then like their cousins from other business and management areas, seek research funding from organisations, such as regional development agencies, with a clear policy agenda; knowledge partnerships schemes (formerly teaching companies); businesses; and from consultancies. The majority of the research pursued in this way is likely to be oriented towards developing analyses and even solutions desired by the funder. The paymaster dictates, and the outcome is more likely to be concerned with assisting relative short-term practice rather than providing theoretical and conceptual insights. It can be specific rather than general knowledge, although this is not inevitable if those participants in practice-based research have the ability to extend the understanding beyond the specific context in which it was gained in order to develop new perspectives and question extant theories and concepts. However, it tends not to be the case that such funders favour supporting such extensions of the research while the researchers often do not have the luxury to undertake the requisite long-term reflection and development because of the pressures of managing relationships with the funders, seeking out new funders and the heavy burdens of teaching and administration. Unfortunately, the articulated policy of generally concentrating more research resources within a top research tier of universities, the increasing allocation of
funds by the Higher Education Funding Council to targeted socio-economic ends and the inadequate supply of both funds and students for doctoral research suggests that the lot of many researchers in marketing may not improve, and indeed may even worsen.
The status and future of research
Research evaluation The UK has been a pioneer in the national evaluation of research quality by discipline and institution through its periodic RAE. This is in essence a peer review evaluation of, in the case of business and management, the research outputs of individual business and management departments, although in arriving at an overall evaluation a significant number of factors are taken into account. Whether or not the quality of the four publications required for each submitted academic in the last RAE is the deciding factor is debatable; however, the view, widely held, is that they do have a significant influence on the grading given the emphasis by the Panel on reading and reviewing a substantial proportion of them. The RAE undoubtedly places pressure on academics to publish, and in particular to ensure that they have at least four “worthy” publications. It could reasonably be argued that this results in “quick fix” research: research that is likely to lead to publishable results in the short term. It may then shape the type of research is marketing that is undertaken. There may, for example, be a tendency for academics not to engage in long-term “blue skies” research, longitudinal studies that demand considerable preparation and extensive fieldwork, and in-depth conceptualisation or theory construction. Instead, one can see the advantages of collecting cross-sectional data generally by questionnaire, and subjecting this to often sophisticated statistical analysis; undertaking a series of mini case studies; or capitalising on student dissertation projects. Undoubtedly academics are now aware that to satisfy institutions’ ambitions to have a significantly financeable research rating (one that is currently 5 or above) it is important to have the requisite number of publications in what might be seen as at least reasonable journals with some form of independent refereeing process. The pressure to publish per se then can have implications for the type of research in marketing that is favoured. There is, however, the question of the frequency with which it is possible to report weighty research. Research, empirically based or not, that is substantial and which is likely to have a significant impact will tend to require considerable “space”: time for scholarship, for reflection, for analysis for dialogue with other scholars: space that is not often available. The time and effort involved in preparing papers for many of the top flight journals is probably beyond the means of the average UK marketing academic. This is reflected in the conclusions of the RAE panel for Business and Management: “The mass of research in marketing . . . does not exhibit the methodological rigour or theory-building that would come close to . . . international academic standards” (Bessant et al., 2003, p. 56). It is also evident that there are increasing pressures on the Higher Education Funding Councils to concentrate funding in those departments where there is a track record of what has been judged to be “quality” research, as reflected in the RAE grading. This policy is founded on the assumptions that institutions will continue to maintain their record, despite changes in structures and personnel, that the criteria which were applied at the time the assessment was made were valid and pertinent and
265
EJM 39,3/4
266
will continue to be so, and that only “good” research can be undertaken. This may result in the concentration of knowledge production in just a few centres, thereby discouraging diversity and stifling innovative and creative thinking. The focusing of Government funding means that many academics will have little if any opportunity to engage in certainly fundamental knowledge creation. As the Higher Education Minister noted in September 2003: . . . we are acutely aware of the vulnerability of our nation’s world class research base. Ensuring that our very best departments receive the funding they need to compete internationally means that we must be selective in spending these new funds. The hard truth is we can no longer fund departments rated 4, 3a and 3b as before, but we are not saying that public funding will stop altogether (Johnson, cited in Research Fortnight, 2003, p. 1).
There has also been renewed questioning of the dual support system for university research. This system relies on two mechanisms for distributing research funding: the RAE to allocate resources for research infrastructure; and the research councils open review system to support specific research projects. In an independent study commissioned by the Royal Society (compiled by the independent research and policy analysts, Evidence) it was concluded that the cost of maintaining the current dual support funding streams amounted to £230 million (Fazackerley and Goddard, 2003). An alternative approach would be to simplify the procedure by using a system of competitive tendering based on full economic costs for the allocation of research funding, an approach, however, that is likely to deprive even more academics of the opportunities to participate in research which in turn could adversely affect teaching. Even if it is accepted that there is only a tenuous link between research and teaching, a link that many marketing academics see as both concrete and symbiotic, such a policy change could have profound deleterious implications for the standard of the education available to a significant proportion of university students. Teaching The massive, under-funded growth in university education since the 1970s has resulted in conditions and teaching loads which are far less than ideal. The whole university system produces three times as many students as it did 30 years ago (Elias and Purcell, 2003), but the resources to do so have not kept pace with the growth. The experience of undergraduates in 2004 with huge class sizes, limited tutorials and inaccessible faculty is unrecognisable to those who graduated 30 or even 20 years ago. The policy of continued expansion of higher education to embrace those from less privileged backgrounds can in some cases place an additional onus on academics who may be faced with groups of more than usual mixed ability with the need to undertake necessary remedial work. The pain associated with this growth in student numbers is not evenly spread throughout the university and disproportionately affects business and management departments because of the high levels of student demand, from both the UK and overseas. Indeed, the demand for business and management degree programmes remains buoyant with in 2001/2002 almost 12 per cent of all degree level students opting to read for degrees in this area, an increase of 11 per cent on the previous year (HESA, 2003 cited in ABS, 2003, pp. 28-9). Moreover, in 2001-2002 business and management degree programmes were the most popular for non-UK students studying in the UK at both undergraduate (16.5 per cent of the total) and postgraduate (22.6 per cent) levels
(HESA, 2003 cited in ABS, 2003, p. 3). Within business and management marketing remains highly popular, particularly at second year and final year levels, with student cohorts for some courses totalling hundreds. The direct contact time may be limited, but the servicing of such courses can be both time consuming and exhausting. This leaves marketing academics with comparatively high contact hours and poor conditions even when compared to academics in other subject areas. The notorious two-tier university system makes this systematic under-resourcing, even more of a problem for those in the post-1992 universities. Students sometimes encouraged by their parents may often regard themselves as “consumers” because they are now both directly and indirectly paying for a service in terms of fees, maintenance, and opportunity costs. Understandably students demand a high level of educational experience and many are increasingly likely to take appropriate action, either through a formal complaints procedure or even litigation, if they perceive that this is not being provided. At both institutional and individual levels processes have been introduced to ensure there is available clear information about programmes and courses, there are transparent procedures for evaluation and complaints, and there are records of inter alia meetings and other contacts with students. The Quality Assurance Agency itself has developed a range of policies the implementation of which are periodically reviewed in time consuming assessments. All of this has made the academic’s job even more onerous. Supply of marketing academics It is widely recognised that there is shortage of research-trained staff to teach business and management at all levels in the universities (Learning and Teaching Support Network, 2001) and most academic managers of marketing departments are familiar with the problems of recruiting high quality marketing academics. Moreover, a recent survey by Baker and Erdogan (2000), reported that 60 per cent of marketing academics were over 40 years old. This confirms the ageing population, which is going to exacerbate recruiting difficulties. In addition there is a lack of good young academics and research students in marketing to replace the retirees. Even now, we are recruiting too few good, young marketing academics. This might be because the current low pay, excessive workloads (more than one-quarter of Baker and Erdogan’s sample reported working over 51 hours per week on academic activities) heavy teaching loads and relatively poor conditions are not attractive. It might also be that for our best graduating students consulting and management offer a lucrative alternative to academe. The increase in indebtedness caused by the introduction of higher fees for a university degree will inevitably exacerbate this trend. For those research students we do manage to recruit, the RAE panel have questioned whether most doctoral training programmes equip them to do research to the necessary standard, be that in a critical or positivist paradigm (Bessant et al., 2003, p. 56). Whether this is related to the lack of a relevant academic background the lack of a doctorate among the faculty is a matter of conjecture but Diamatopoulos et al. (1992, p. 16) raised both issues in their 1992 survey of UK marketing academics. They concluded “Marketing academia at UK universities is male-dominated, rapidly ageing, with little industrial/commercial full-time work experience, under-qualified at the doctoral level, largely inappropriately qualified with regard to subjects read prior to entering the profession and badly equipped to keep up with new developments through
The status and future of research 267
EJM 39,3/4
268
membership of professional organisations”. Burton (2003) recommends that it is an appropriate time for the UK’s marketing academics to rethink research training provision in the light of the ESRC initiatives on reconfiguring the PhD programme to include formalised research training in year one, followed by three years focusing on a thesis. Marketing knowledge At least part of the explanation of the low apparent funding of research in marketing and its perceived low status may be that marketing per se is an embryonic social sciences’ discipline that has yet to develop its own coherent paradigm. Its core concepts are, for the most part, derived from more established disciplines, in particular economics, sociology, and psychology. Many of its methodologies are those that have been initially developed and applied elsewhere, while their application without adequate training can itself result in poor quality research. For instance, the contemporary discovery of ethnography by marketing academics may lead to its adoption without the detailed in depth training that the valid use of this complex methodology demands. In fact it may also be as Pringle (2001, quoting Claycamp, 1971) argues that we spend too much time creating new and sophisticated techniques and too little to operationalising them. Marketing per se may be viewed as an applied discipline driven by the demands of practitioners. Indeed there is a widespread acceptance that marketing should aim to solve business problems by developing “best practice”, a tendency that is reinforced by the availability of resources to undertake practitioner-oriented research, either through some form of consultancy, knowledge transfer partnerships and postgraduate student funding. The obstacles, perceived or otherwise, to securing funding for more conceptual research also support this practice-based orientation. Knowledge about practice should not be undervalued: it has its own validity and is the essence of many technology subjects, as well as medicine where the emphasis is increasingly on evidence-based practice. Whatever the form of knowledge, the methodology by which it is developed must be transparent, together with clear evidence, so that the status of “the knowledge” can be clearly evaluated. Moreover, it should be recognised that the creation and development of knowledge is not restricted to universities or indeed individual institutions, but is often the product of a complex of influences within a diverse range of structures. Indeed the formation of marketing knowledge may necessarily involve intimate dialogue with practitioners. Research therefore can be viewed as not “being institutionalised primarily within university structures . . . [it] involves the close interaction of many actors throughout the process of knowledge production . . . [it] makes use of a wider range of criteria in judging quality control” (Gibbons et al., 1994). There are, however, worries about what is regarded as the lack of “relevance” both of business and management research in general and of marketing in particular. For example, the editor of Marketing Science suggested: “There is concern that our work is becoming less relevant to practitioners and that we are less successful than we could be an impacting practice” (Ratchford, 2001, pp. iii-iv). The focus on “relevance”, however, begs the question of what this means and who defines it? The significance of research output can be time dependent, reliant on developments extraneous to the research and specific to particular users. The
worthiness of much basic science for example was often not realised at the time of its discovery, but only emerged later as opportunities for its exploitation were realised through social, economic, political and technological developments. To take one example: the implications of identifying the structure of DNA were not fully recognised at the time of the “discovery”. The scientists were driven by the challenge of being the first to unravel this scientific mystery; not by its relevance to resolving paternity suits; engineering plants and crops; or predicting and curing inherited diseases. These “relevancies” emerged later. Often the “best” science is driven internally by the curiosity of scientists who have an appreciation of the potential returns from the development of particular knowledge trajectories and who invest their intellectual energy in striving to realise these. This is not to argue that they undertake research free from any extraneous influences; but rather to state the case for a more balanced view of the production of knowledge that recognises that it embraces a range of actors from a variety of institutional contexts, and that relevance itself is a shifting and context specific notion that may in itself not be the initial, primary driver. Nevertheless, it is likely that in any future research evaluation process there will increase emphasis on “relevance” to users. Indeed, even in the 2001 RAE the definition of research adopted for all panels and units of assessment in RAE 2001 embraced the specific inclusion of “work of direct relevance to the needs of commerce and industry” (Baker and Gabbott, 2002, p. 6). The assessment of the value-added to professional practice by research is an issue that was identified as not being properly address in RAE 2001 and is therefore being taken into account in the next RAE (Higher Education and Research Opportunities in the United Kingdom, 2003, p. 23). This suggests that in the future we will be faced with the spectre of the “double hurdle” of academic rigor and practical relevance for research in marketing, as identified by Pettigrew (cited in Wensley, 2002, p. 394).
Conclusions So where does all that leave us? It is evident that there may be some practical steps that marketers can take in order to enhance the status of marketing. First, more effort should be directed towards securing funding to support both basic and practice-oriented knowledge production. Inevitably this demands that we make efforts to improve research support from bodies such as the ESRC and Leverhulme, in addition to obtaining financial support from more applied funding. This demands increasing the volume of applications and ensuring that they meet the criteria applied to assessing the “quality” of any research proposal: clear objectives, familiarity with the appropriate literature, the specification of the methodology and the means of analysis, some of which often lacks the attention to detail that encourages confidence in the proposers. In all cases there is a need for more experienced referees who will invest in providing detailed and productive feedback. Second, more attention should be given to the development of capabilities in research in marketing. There is a need to develop robust methodology training programmes both as an integral component of doctoral training and also for the marketing academy in general to ensure that all of use have the opportunity to familiarise ourselves with a range of methodologies.
The status and future of research 269
EJM 39,3/4
270
Third, effort needs to be invested in ensuring that the scholarship and research robustness of academic papers in marketing is developed through for instance, more careful attention to both then training of academic referees and the investment of time by referees in providing the positive feedback that is a hallmark of effective refereeing. The preparation of papers of substance often demands significant time and there is a need to campaign for more emphasis on quality as against quantity: more can indeed mean less! Fourth, we need to ensure that the issue of “users” is addressed by demonstrating how the results of the results will be disseminated. The “user community” embraces more than practitioners in business, commerce and the public sector; it also includes users of knowledge per se. Research may not be solely concerned or even involve the generation of solutions that have immediate application. It is unquestionably the case that “relevance” in some guise will be a pertinent criterion in the next RAE, but as we have argued there is no definitive interpretation of what this means. Overall, what is important is the “ quality” as reflected in the conceptual development and analysis; where appropriate, the robustness of the methodology employed; and the impact of the research on understanding. Good research is undertaken by enquiring minds: it is the curiosity of the researcher that produces the surprising result that has a considerable impact on our understanding. That rather than pointing to the “blindingly” obvious should be our goal. Here, however, we do offer some “blindingly obvious” practical steps that could have a positive impact on our discipline: . Improve our PhD programmes, seeking external recognition and verification of professional standards. . Publish more and better papers, (increased commitment to research). . Publish accessible versions of good papers with emphasis on managerial implications in practitioner journals. . Develop epistemology and research methodology workshops to facilitate the improvement of research standards in marketing. . Improve the methodological rigor of our work (Bessant et al., 2003). . Apply for more research funding. . Review each others’ work critically, helpfully and strategically. . Make nominations of marketing academics to the research council panels. . Network and mentor to the benefit of the discipline. References (The) Association of Business Schools (ABS) (2003), Pillars of the Economy: How UK Business Schools Are Meeting the Global Competitive Challenge, ABS, London. Baker, M.J. and Erdogan, B.Z. (2000), “Who we are and what we do – 2000”, Journal of Marketing Management, Vol. 16 No. 7, pp. 679-96. Baker, M.J. and Gabbott, M. (2002), “The assessment of research”, The International Journal of Management Education, Vol. 2 No. 3, pp. 3-15. Bessant, J., Birley, S., Cooper, C., Dawson, S., Gennard, J., Gardiner, M., Gray, A., Jones, P., Mayer, C., McGee, J., Pidd, M., Rowley, G., Saunders, J. and Stark, A. (2003), “The state of
the field in UK management research: reflections of the Research Assessment Exercises (RAE) Panel”, British Journal of Management, Vol. 14 No. 1, pp. 51-68. Burton, D. (2003), “Rethinking the UK system of doctoral training in marketing”, Journal of Marketing Management, Vol. 19 No. 7-8, pp. 883-904. Diamantopoulos, A., Schlegelmilch, B.B. and Neate-Stidson, S. (1992), “Who we are and what we do: a profile of marketing academics in UK universities”, Journal of Marketing Management, Vol. 8 No. 1, pp. 5-20. Dobson, M. (2003), “Investing in the future – ESRC funding opportunities”, paper presented at the Academy of Marketing Conference, Business School, Aston, Birmingham, July. Easton, G. and Easton, D.M. (2003), “Marketing journals and the research assessment exercise”, Journal of Marketing Management, Vol. 19 No. 1/2, pp. 5-24. Elias, P. and Purcell, K. (2003), “Too many graduates? The market disagrees”, THES, 20 June. ESRC (2003), The Economic and Social Research Council Annual Report and Accounts 2002-03, The Stationery Office, London. ESRC (2004), available at: www.esrc.ac.uk?esrccontent/researchfundinmg/aim_fellowship.asp (accessed 26 January). Fazackerley, A. and Goddard, A. (2003), “Price of policy put at £230 m”, THES, 28 November, p. 7. Gibbons, M., Limoges, C., Nowotony, H., Schwartzman, S., Scott, P. and Trow, M. (1994), The New Production of Knowledge: The Dynamics of Science and Research in Contemporary Societies, Sage Publications, London. Higher Education and Research Opportunities in the United Kingdom (2003), available at: www.hero.ac.uk/rae/ Learning and Teaching Support Network (2001), Learning and Teaching in Business, Management and Accounting: The UK Landscape, December, Business Education Support Team, York. Pringle, L.G. (2001), “The academy and the practice: in principle they are different but in practice, they never are”, Marketing Science, Vol. 20 No. 4, pp. 373-81. Ratchford, B.T. (2001), “Editorial”, Marketing Science, Vol. 20 No. 4, Fall, pp. iii-iv. Research Fortnight (2003), “Johnson moves top calm VC fears over research”, Vol. 9 No. 198, 17 September. Utley, A. (2003), “Social science failing its users”, THES, 28 March. Varadarajan, P.R. (2003), “Musings on relevance and rigor of scholarly research in marketing”, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, Vol. 31 No. 4, pp. 368-76. Wensley, R. (1995), “A critical review of research in marketing”, British Journal of Management, Vol. 6, December, pp. S63-S82. Wensley, R. (2000), “The MSI priorities: a critical view on researching firm performance, customer experience and marketing”, Journal of Marketing Management, Vol. 16 No. 1, pp. 11-27. Wensley, R. (2002), “Bridge over troubled water?”, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 36 No. 3, pp. 391-400.
The status and future of research 271
The Emerald Research Register for this journal is available at www.emeraldinsight.com/researchregister
The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available at www.emeraldinsight.com/0309-0566.htm
EJM 39,3/4
Beyond incommensurability? Empirical expansion on diversity in research
272
Andrea Davies
Received January 2003 Revised September 2003 Accepted January 2004
Management Centre, University of Leicester, Leicester, UK, and
James A. Fitchett Nottingham University Business School, Nottingham, UK Abstract Purpose – This paper is a practical attempt to contribute to the ongoing reappraisal of the dichotomies and categories that have become prevalent throughout marketing research. Design/methodology/approach – The paper reviews current literature on incommensurability and undertakes a comparative re-examination of two studies. Findings – How the authors view their research is constituted in retrospective terms through a marketing and consumption logic based on the principles of division, distinction and difference. Re-examination of some empirical case material suggests that in practice the perceived duality separating research traditions is unsound. A misplaced reading of paradigm incommensurability has resulted in research practices appearing oppositional and static when they are essentially undifferentiated and dynamic. An over-socialised research epistemology has raised the tangible outcomes of research activities to be dominant in directing research practice. Research limitations/implications – The comparative analysis is illustrative rather than representative. Originality/value – The paper offers an applied exposition of theoretical debates in marketing research concerning paradigm incommensurability. Keywords Market research methods, History Paper type Conceptual paper
European Journal of Marketing Vol. 39 No. 3/4, 2005 pp. 272-293 q Emerald Group Publishing Limited 0309-0566 DOI 10.1108/03090560510581773
Introduction Marketing and consumer research is once again experiencing a period of reappraisal, looking internally to question the direction and speed of its theoretical development and the jurisdiction of its theoretical boundaries (Levy, 2002; Brown, 2002; Zaltman, 2000; Lowenstein, 2001; Rossiter, 2001; Wells, 2001; Bettany, 2002). Marketing has been defined by its multi-disciplinary status for some time now and the processes of generating knowledge have been characterised by considerable methodological diversity (Wilk, 2001; Murray et al., 2002; Piercy, 2002). As with any field of academic enquiry the activities associated with theory making underpin disciplinary content and progress in marketing science (Gummesson, 2001; O’Shaughnessy and O’Shaughnessy, 2002; Thompson, 2002). However, the extent to which research communities in business research have a complete understanding of what constitutes and drives research practice is less clear and it may be either too much or too little disciplinary self-confidence that accounts for an unwillingness to examine the practices of knowledge production (Remenyi, 2002).
Paradigmatic debates were afforded a high profile in the marketing and consumer research literatures throughout the 1980s and 1990s. During this period questions were frequently asked regarding the authority of different research traditions with several ways to move forward and guide the research community being proposed (e.g. Anderson, 1983, 1986; Deshpande, 1983; Hirschman, 1985; Hirschman and Holbrook, 1992; Hudson and Ozanne, 1988; Ozanne and Hudson, 1989; Hunt, 1990, 1991, 1992, 1994; Sherry, 1991; Kavanagh, 1994). Critical pluralists (Hunt, 1991, 1994; Kavanagh, 1994) claiming openness and tolerance called for the status of qualitative methods to be repositioned in an effort to challenge what they perceived to be increasingly pervasive nihilistic and relativistic tendencies. These conciliatory efforts can perhaps be thought of as an attempt by influential groups within the academy at resolving, ending or offering a “last word” in debates over epistemology or so-called “epistobabble” warfare. Whether one agrees or disagrees with resolution couched solely in an objectivist and realist philosophy (Wilk, 2001), contemporary evidence would suggest that the concerns raised during this era of paradigm debate have not been “resolved” in the everyday practice and experience of researchers. Current debates concerning the legitimacy of different research approaches may be less likely to adopt the oppositional tone that characterised much of this earlier discussion but acknowledgement of divisions and boundaries between research programmes nevertheless continues to feature regularly in respected journals (Thompson, 2002; Wells, 2001; Shankar and Patterson, 2001; Szmigim and Foxhall, 2000; Hackley, 1999). The difficulties of “investigating”, “solving” or “resolving” issues of research diversity has the potential to deter researchers from undertaking empirical research, as well as deterring much needed discussion about the status of theory and knowledge generation and the relationship to research practice. As Wilk (2001) reminds us, pluralism demands that we accept the possibility that two studies or methods cannot be brought to bear on one another and that a single explanation is insufficient. The absence of agreed criteria that could be applied to adjudicate on the merits of different approaches to research investigation calls into question whether discussions about research practice or debates concerning the value of multi-method research constitute valid topics of enquiry. Evaluative criteria are bound up in the same social world in which the operative knowledge they are sought to bear on is generated (Schmidt, 2001) and this produces a situation of underdetermination (Anderson, 1986). In marketing and consumer research (Wilk, 2001) other social sciences (Sayers, 1987; Guba and Lincoln, 1998; Weick, 1989; Lewis and Grimes, 1999) and beyond (Nagel and Newman, 1971) the inability to step outside our own theoretical and epistemological languages is recognised as an impasse, or at the very least a stumbling block, that makes the study of diversity in research traditions fraught with anxiety. Since it may be impossible to “adequately ‘solve’ the problems of being, truth and subjectivity” (Flax, 1990, p. 193) we must perhaps be content to live in “the middle of things” (Wilk, 2001) and to accept the “messiness of this condition” (St Pierre, 1997). Our intention here is to offer another view on the diversity observed in our research traditions. From the outset it is necessary to draw a distinction between the appreciative and instrumental systems in research (Vickers, 1995), what we might summarise as the differences between the way the research process is viewed and theorised on the one hand and the way it is conducted or enacted on the other. The paper focuses on the manner in which marketing and consumer research knowledge is
Expansion on diversity in research 273
EJM 39,3/4
274
produced and represented through research practice to critique and challenge some misunderstandings that have now become entrenched. Marketing research remains constituted primarily in static and retrospective terms through a logic based on the principles of division, distinction and difference. Oppositional terms such as inside/outside, mind/matter, part/whole, self/other, academic/practitioner, qualitative/quantitative and positivist/interpretivist, are the direct products of such logic and have become the key conceptual categories that we rely on to express research experiences and research practices. Kuhn’s (1970a) incommensurability thesis is often drawn on to maintain and justify the integrity of such oppositional dualisms. In the following section we suggest that this thesis has been misunderstood in marketing. Building on this discussion we go on to consider two studies both of which examine a similar subject but are conducted in what would be widely defined as alternative paradigms. Our analysis offers a practical attempt to confront incommensurability by drawing on empirical case material. By critically contrasting the two studies we are able to examine the practice of interpretivism and the practice of positivism in the context of ongoing philosophy of science dualisms. The main outcome of this analysis is to contribute to the growing body of work in the management sciences that seeks to reappraise prevailing dichotomies and categories (e.g. Gioia and Pitre´, 1990; Schultz and Hatch, 1996; Lewis and Grimes, 1999). Incommensurability and beyond There is a widespread rejection of a unified meta-theoretical paradigm in marketing and consumer research (Anderson, 1983; Arndt, 1985; Mick, 1999; Zaltman, 2000). While the Kuhnian cycle of scientific revolution together with the thesis on incommensurability was described some time ago as a ”colourful exaggeration” (Venkatesh, 1985) and marketing was “not considered to have experienced robust alternative schools of marketing thought” (Savitt, 1990, p. 299), it remains a core concept in debates over paradigm credibility. At the workbench as it were, it seems that researchers are now being required to make an “either/or” choice between two seemingly polar paradigmatic opposites of research practice (Howe, 1988, 1992; Rose, 2001). In consumer research, for example, researchers choose between “positivist” and “interpretivist” (or “humanist”) approaches (Hudson and Ozanne, 1988; Wilk, 2001; Wells, 2001; Shankar and Patterson, 2001; Sherry, 2000; Brown, 2002; Thompson, 2002). Although strict conceptual justification for paradigmatic choice might be appealing in theory, inconsistencies begin to emerge when these principles are translated and applied to specific research practices and to the general social context of the academy in which research is undertaken. For example, differences in researchers’ personalities (Brown, 1999; Hirschman, 1985; Leong et al., 1994) and socialisation and cultural environments (Anderson, 1986; Hirschman and Holbrook, 1992; Trocchia and Berkowitz, 1999) have been shown to guide paradigmatic choices. Yet the spectre of incommensurability continues to restrict and restrain advances despite calls for multi-paradigm enquiry in the marketing discipline (Mick, 1999; Zaltman, 2000), social sciences (Schultz and Hatch, 1996; Lewis and Grimes, 1999) and by leading figures beyond the empiricist paradigm (Howe, 1992). This is all the more confounding when one considers the multi-disciplinary agenda of the subject, its focus on diversity (Ferber, 1977; Frank, 1974; Kavanagh, 1994; Kernan, 1995; Wilk, 2001) and history of
mixing, matching and importing ideas and techniques from many different areas (Tellis et al., 1999; Bettencourt and Houston, 2001). Authors in both “positivist” and “interpretivist” camps have focused on the value added to research designed with some form of triangulation (e.g. Arnould and Price, 1993; Deshpande, 1983; McQuarrie and Mick, 1992; Gummesson, 2001; McAlexander et al., 2002; Thompson and Troester, 2002). A problem common to such integrationist stances is that different research traditions are rarely given equal authority in the agenda, findings or conclusions drawn from empirical work (Hirschman, 1985). Indeed, examples of studies that have used a mixture of qualitative and quantitative methods, or cases where attention has been given to the triangulation of different kinds of data, have been criticised for relying on only one or a very narrowly defined set of philosophical and ontological beliefs (Wilk, 2001). Assigning equal value and weight to different traditions and methods of research is often considered problematic due to arguments regarding the apparent lack of common criteria to judge their quality (e.g. Szmigim and Foxhall, 2000; Thompson, 1990, 1993). The potential of realising a workable and acceptable context for multi-paradigm and inter-paradigm research remains uncertain. Theoretical frameworks for multiple paradigm research have been explored in some detail in management studies (Gioia and Pitre´, 1990; Schultz and Hatch, 1996; Lewis and Grimes, 1999). In contrast to the integrationist view common in marketing and consumer research, these frameworks contend that paradigm interplay produces new forms of understanding by stressing the interdependencies between constitutive oppositions. Their approach seeks to embrace disparity to build an enlarged and enlightened understanding of phenomena thus offering another perspective on paradigm reconciliation (Hirschman, 1985; Hirschman and Holbrook, 1992; Hunt, 1994; Hudson and Ozanne, 1988; Ozanne and Hudson, 1989; Szmigim and Foxhall, 2000). Although Schultz and Hatch (1996) offer a meta-paradigmatic position that denies incommensurability, their theoretical framework of meta-triangulation maintains rather than smoothes over notions of differences and boundaries that uphold divisions between different research traditions. This is exemplified by their use of “bridging” and “interplay” and does not seem adequately to attain a meta-paradigmatic level where different research traditions can co-exist (de Cock et al., 1995). Instead these frameworks operate in a grey area between paradigms where the potential to privilege one side of a dualism remains. Eisenhart (2000) views this middle ground as a way to avoid the blandness of synthesis and celebrates the co-existence of dualities. She calls for the need to uphold and accept paradox in practice and questions whether incommensurability is a state of nature. The importance of representing the interdependencies and commonalities among and between diverse research traditions does however remain unattended in theories that adhere to incommensurability as well as those based on meta-paradigmatic explanations. One of the problems researchers face when trying to resolve paradigm debates is the contradiction between the philosophy of research on the one hand, and the practice of research on the other (Kaplan, 1964; Lauden, 1984; Marsden, 2001; Wilk, 2001; Bouchikhi and Kimberley, 2001). The majority of researchers involved in the marketing and consumer research community would probably be able to locate their own and colleagues’ work within either a positivist or interpretivist tradition. The type and style of data collected and analysis employed, as well the type and range of
Expansion on diversity in research 275
EJM 39,3/4
276
research issues attended to, are most likely to be assumed to provide surrogate indicators that locate researchers in one tradition rather than another. However, while current debates about philosophy of science would seem to imply that positivists and interpretivists should be odds, in everyday practice this is not necessarily the case (Heath, 1992; Venkatesh, 1985). Researchers from different research traditions work alongside one another, discuss and argue common ideas and topics, attend similar conferences and publish in the same pool of journals. Furthermore, research conducted in one tradition often draws on work conducted in other traditions (Tellis et al., 1999; Bettencourt and Houston, 2001). There are of course disagreements and conflicts between researchers that should not be overlooked. However, these disagreements are arguably equally prevalent within the interpretivist and positivist traditions as they are between them. Research philosophy and research practice Accounts of the “muddling of method” (Baker et al., 1992; Goulding, 1999), the “stand between” metaphor as a description of research practice (Charmaz, 1995), and Heath’s (1992) boundary blurring description of consumer researchers as “liberal naturalists” or “conservative humanists” highlight the difficulty of linking paradigm theories to research practices. Examples of studies that have applied qualitative methods in a positivist tradition (Iacobucci, 2001) and quantitative methods in an interpretivist tradition (Potter and Wetherell, 1994) emphasise the widely accepted observation that there is a lack of correspondence between qualitative and quantitative methods of research (instruments) and the theoretical paradigms of positivism and humanism in which they are used (Lauden, 1984; Howe, 1988; Silverman, 1997; Riley and Love, 2000). Despite this it has become common to define paradigm debates using surrogate measures of methodology choice, research community conventions, power locales, data collection and analysis procedures, and accepted presentation protocols (e.g. Hunt, 1994; Shankar and Patterson, 2001; Brown et al., 2001). There is a real difficulty, even impossibility, of isolating one theoretical research tradition from another without drawing on more procedural aspects of research conduct. Research papers with recognised and accepted methods, procedures, and reporting conventions, are the tangible representations of theory generating research activity. Reward systems are based on journal publications and citation frequency, and the maturity of the discipline is analysed by the degree of diversity and exchange of reference citations (Zinkan et al., 1992; Bettencourt and Houston, 2001). We are the consumers of new ideas presented in our journal papers and their review and editorial practices guide what is right and good in the discipline. Studies of reference diversity in top journals show a negative relationship between subsequent article citation and the conceptual distance or disciplinary variety of citations contained within them (Bettencourt and Houston, 2001). As consumers of new research we favour theories that are readily understandable and easy to put into operation (Peter and Olson, 1983; Lynch, 1998). There is comfort in the certain and the familiar. As researchers we look for marketable findings, replicating the methodological and rhetorical strategies necessary to conform to the accepted practice of various sub-disciplines as they are constructed (Bouchikhi and Kimberley, 2001; Wells, 2001; Thompson, 2002). We persuade our audiences primarily through the utilisation of specific narrative forms (Van Mannen, 1995; de Cock and Chia, 2001), staging credible truth effects in a
progression of popularity contests (Sutton and Shaw, 1995; O’Shaughnessy, 1997; Shankar and Patterson, 2001). Schmidt (2001) recognises the cultural location of norms and standards held by our research traditions. He accounts for this “oversocialised epistemology” in terms of the “various parochialisms to which most academics (including himself) lean due to processes of deformation professionelle” (Schmidt, 2001, p. 148). It would seem research communities use Kuhn’s incommensurability thesis as an ontological act of differentiation to authenticate the credibility and status of sub-groups and sub-disciplinary areas, and research traditions become “traps invented by researchers to snare and dismember them” (Zaltman, 2000). Researchers focus on dissimilarities rather than similarities and reject the applicability of conceptually distant theories (Bettencourt and Houston, 2001). There is a drive to reduce epistemological uncertainty so as to establish credible research traditions. This has raised methodological and representational concerns to the status of first principle where the means through which marketing knowledge or science has become normalised have become ends in themselves (Haslam and McGarty, 2001). Research papers have become prized and valued over and above the research activities they describe. When valued only as research papers our research activities reified, becoming “thing-like”. One problem is that when viewed retrospectively, what is accepted in our journals becomes viewed as a universal way or theoretical map of what is right and good. This is at best a “counterfeit” account of research practice and disciplinary progression. As Rescher (1996, p. 35) explains “‘things’ [research papers] are no more than stability waves in a sea of process”. Journal papers cannot represent the full extent of research activity. They fail to capture the dialogue and exchange that is part of research practice. Paradigms revisited Kuhn’s (1968) original incommensurability thesis positions all research and knowledge within specific contexts of institutions, expectations, languages, instruments, and modes of understanding. These boundaries define and locate research paradigms. Hassard (1988) emphasises that paradigm change has been misinterpreted as a gradual transition where existing paradigms are seen as nurturing, growing, sitting alongside, and finally being subsumed to new paradigms. For Kuhn (1970a, p. 85), however, paradigm shifts are points of fracture and transformation from one form of “normal” science to another. Such a reading does not adequately reflect the current status of different research communities nor the relationship between interpretivists and positivists for disciplines that see themselves as pluri-paradigmatic and hold constant two (Hudson and Ozanne, 1988; Szmigim and Foxhall, 2000), or more “paradigms” (Hirschman and Holbrook, 1992; Sherry, 1991). Other recent re-examinations of Kuhn’s understanding of paradigms and paradigm revolutions highlight the logical and discursive inconsistency between the idea of scientific progress on the one hand, and paradigmatic conflict or rivalry leading to incommensurability on the other. Conflict and rivalry require at least some level of translation, common location and reference or meaning, whereas theories expressed in alternative incommensurable paradigmatic languages can have no common meaning and comparable content. Davidson (1984) and Putman (1981) show that it is incoherent to suggest theoretical languages are untranslatable, unless the content of theories in
Expansion on diversity in research 277
EJM 39,3/4
278
one paradigm are received as “farm yard noises” with no meaningful expression in other paradigms. Indeed, both Kuhn and Feyerabend did not adhere to an indeterminable notion of semantic incommensurability, but rather to one of “local incommensurability” (Kuhn, 1983). Sankey (1994) also rejects a reading of “paradigm” based on discontinuous transition between theories which have no common reference or which refer to distinct worlds of their own making. Instead he considers there to be a referential continuity where supposedly divergent paradigmatic theories can be compared on content because they only have “divergent referential relations to a common theory-dependent reality” (Sankey, 1994, p. 219). Drawing on Feyerabend (1965) he suggests that translation, at least at the level of non-instantial theory or common descriptive concepts can occur due to the presence of background theories that are in some way generically common and therefore applicable in more than one paradigm. Evidence of semantic understanding and exchange between seemingly alternative paradigmatic traditions would suggest that current paradigmatic boundaries are at least permeable or, perhaps more dramatically, that boundaries and divisions have been drawn pre-maturely and do not reflect substantially different content. O’Shaughnessy (1997) suggests that there may be little substance in the differences identified in marketing and consumer research traditions and that we are subject to the “granfalloon effect”. We believe and act as though we have something in common because we can be, and need to be, identified with a legitimate research tradition. In a similar vein, Wilk (2001) argues that knowledge of any sort is fundamentally built on comparison. He suggests all research papers are in fact re-studies of what has gone before. It would seem that we have created difference as a disciplinary legitimising tactic and this limits our ability to foster discontinuous innovation (Zaltman, 2000; Feyerabend, 1965). The absence of a unified or authoritative paradigmatic position and the subsequent lack of a commonly agreed consensus to define mechanisms of evaluation, has tended to over-emphasise and inflate differences in terms of conflict, and in some cases as “paradigm warfare” (Anderson, 1983, 1986; Hunt, 1990, 1991, 1992; Kavanagh, 1994). As a consequence, evidence of common language (Putman, 1981) or shared cognitive goals (Howe, 1992) is under represented. Methodological approach The incommensurability thesis is a difficult one to examine if paradigmatic boundaries are considered to be fixed or partial incommensurable. Debates surrounding incommensurability question the very assumptions of scientific examination. To seek and “verify” the thesis would from a certain paradigmatic position seem acceptable and necessary, whereas from others such efforts are inappropriate, even irrelevant. In terms of a method we adopt a critically-reflexive re-inquiry (Thompson, 2002). The primary methodological motivation is to address the issue of incommensurability in two research traditions by employing a data-driven agenda. The lack of broadly comparable case studies undertaken in similar research contexts, but from alternate paradigmatic traditions, has hindered the exploration of paradigm commensurability as practised, as opposed to how the debate is conceptualised. The aim of the analysis is to illustrate the contrasts evident between studies with different so called paradigmatic bases, to compare respective assumptions and justifications, and to identify agreement and disagreement in the main findings. Here we shift our attention from the “reality”
being presented in studies from different research to the representation of those realities in each tradition. This enquiry draws on two empirical studies that examine consumption experience and consumer behaviour in the leisure industry, and in particular the museum “sector”. The two studies were conducted independently of each other, with neither research programme or research team involved with the other. Only following the completion and peer review of both studies did the researchers become aware of the other piece of research. Study A was undertaken in accordance with what would be identified as a positivist approach, whereas Study B was undertaken in the interpretivist tradition. Study A takes the traditional psychological/ behaviourist paradigm in consumer research as its basis, applying the Theory of Planned Behaviour to compare several predictive models of museum visiting behaviour, based on a stratified spatial random sample of 400 individuals, and using a two-stage structural equation modelling analysis technique. The intangible experience-outcomes shared by museum visitors, and disliked or undervalued by museum non-visitors, are offered as the basis for enlarging the explanation of museum visiting and non-visiting intentions by improved descriptive depth and predictive validity. Study B draws heavily on Marxist and Post-Marxist critical theory to examine whether the museum experience is organised in terms of a commodity code, and visiting a museum as an act of consumption. Study B offers a cultural/macro explanation of museum visiting, identifying the cultural processes that have enabled aspects of history and culture (museum exhibitions) to become represented and consumed as commodities. Based on a naturalistic/ethnographic methodology where 40 qualitative interviews are supplemented with photography to ensure sensitivity to the natural setting, the design of the study aims to maximise thickness and depth and stresses the authority of the author in developing/presenting the description and interpretation the museum experience. Both studies justify their chosen research philosophies, and conduct, analyse and report the research process and their findings in accordance with the principles ascribed by their respective methodologies. Study A presents and verifies data by drawing on conventions of quantitative modelling. Study B relies on textual data and description. Study A maintains a focus on individual cognitive processes to explain museum visiting, whereas Study B focuses exclusively on the explication of socio-structural codes to describe and understand the experience. A summary of the main conceptual, methodological and analytical components of both studies is given in Table I.
Qualitative and descriptive contrasts To examine the two pieces of research we considered the textual structure and constituency of both studies using a literary critical, or discourse analytical approach. This level of analysis calls for the two studies to be examined as texts written in accordance with certain protocols, languages and traditions. Paradigms have been seen as differentiated by conventions of discourse and modes of representation making communication between paradigms appear unfeasible. While we focus part of this analysis on the findings and data generated by the two pieces of research, we also take the research texts themselves as units for analysis. This analysis considers the
Expansion on diversity in research 279
EJM 39,3/4 Principal literature
280
Conceptual framework
Methodological argument Research design
Structure of main findings
Table I. Composition of Study A and Study B
Study A: marketing goes to the museum
Study B: consumption and cultural commodification
Experiential consumption and museum visitor research Review of motivation theory in social psychology, leisure and tourism studies Review theoretical and methodological concerns for Theory of Planned Behaviour Explain visitor and non-visitor intentions by anticipated experiences moderated by value and museum interpretive style (service environment), skills and resources and social norms Methodological and conceptual modification to the Theory of Planned Behaviour Justification of a modelling approach Qualitative variable definition Quantitative data collection Two-stage structural modelling In-depth interviewing Structured survey questionnaire Random-spatial sample Scenario method with two contrasting pictorial stimuli Patterns of museum behaviour Identification and description of structural model Testing predictive and descriptive utility of alternative models of Theory of Planned Behavior Identification of principal determinants of visiting behaviour
Anthropology and material culture theory of gift/commodity exchange Review of Marxist critical theory and sociological research on commodity culture Review of post-Marxist critique, postmodernism and theories of consumer culture The museum/collection in pre-industrial, industrial and post-industrial society The consumer “experience” Typology of consumer value
Justification of an interpretivist approach Qualitative data collection and analysis methods In-depth interviewing Ethnographic approaches to consumer research Description of the research locations The value of museum visiting Examination of sign value in the museum Commodification of museum exhibits Experiences of authenticity and proximity Narrative construction
discursive framing, modes of justification and argument, styles and language of representation and the underlying assumptions and rationales for each text. In accordance with discourse analysis a close reading of the two texts was used to identify common “codes” or tropes (Elliott, 1996). The approach involved each author preparing a close reading of the other text, that is, the author of Study A began analysing Study B, and vice versa. A series of panel sessions were organised whereby these initial analyses were discussed, with both differences and similarities being confronted and further examined. The first theme discussed below refers to the presence of a “marketing zeitgeist”. It can be read as a “common world view” or shared set of underlying assumptions. The second theme explores the basis of the research assumptions and the manner in which they are constructed, justified and represented in the texts. The third theme goes on to examine the some of the principle research findings developed in both studies.
A marketing zeitgeist When analysed as a socially and historically located phenomenon, consumer research like all modes of enquiry has common traits or dominant themes (Kernan, 1995). Knowledge is emergent and organic rather than explicitly planned or chosen by any one group or institution (Kuhn, 1970b). That two researchers decided to consider the identical subject of museum visiting consumption reveals a great deal about the zeitgeist or underlying state of ideas and theories in marketing at the time. The following excerpts illustrate the extent to which both studies represent and respond to these prevailing: Study A: In an over-supplied heritage attractions market . . . and against a background of increasingly demanding and discerning consumers bent on avid “experience” seeking of the past, present and future . . . it has now become a matter of urgency for museum professionals to understand the determinants of museum visiting intentions, customer satisfaction and the potentials for market development . . . Studies from diverse literatures beyond heritage research have been relatively more substantial in their concern with consumption experiences . . . An examination of studies from [consumer research] offer[s] potential classifications of experience useful to understand the possible “nature” of the museum experience, and to forward the conceptual development of a research agenda focused on consumer and non-consumer experiences of heritage consumption . . . The overall aim of this paper is to contribute to the understanding and knowledge of museum consumption behaviour framed within an experiential management approach. Study B: The museum profession, like many other “culture industries”, has had to respond to a changing environment. The structure of public funding together with the limitations placed on national and regional government expenditure has meant that many museums have been forced to reconsider their priorities and strategies for continued survival . . . As a consequence, the role of the visitor has undergone somewhat of a metamorphosis. As museums become organised like businesses, visitors become increasingly redefined as consumers. The problem however, which is central to this investigation, is what exactly constitutes the museum commodity? If museum visitors are consumers, then what do they consume? The museum, as a site of consumption, presents several problems in terms of existing theories of consumer behaviour, namely the lack of any economic exchange, material acquisition or functional utility relating to “needs”. The primary objective of this empirical investigation is to examine whether a semiotic, cultural theory of consumption can be applied to understand museum consumption.
These excerpts illustrate that there was a motivation to question traditional boundaries around the discipline that have tended to locate consumer research firmly in the sphere of commercial product-based contexts (e.g. Kotler, 1979; Hirschman and Holbrook, 1982; Holbrook and Schindler, 1989). A number of opportunities were emerging in which empirically to examine further increasingly popular conceptual ideas concerning the consumption experience, and tourism and leisure activities as marketing-related processes (Arnould and Price, 1993; Celsi et al., 1993; Hirschman and Holbrook, 1992; McCracken, 1988). During this period, popular ideas relating to postmodernism, consumer culture, and consumption symbolism (Belk, 1988; Brown, 1995; Firat and Venkatesh, 1995) were also being given empirical attention. These trends in the subject demonstrate the importance of disciplinary socialisation. Despite seemingly incommensurable methodologies, both studies share and build on a
Expansion on diversity in research 281
EJM 39,3/4
282
common legacy within the field of consumer research. Issues and topics popular in the discipline do not only determine these underlying areas of similarity, but also the location where the research was conducted, the resources available to support the research, and the specific social and cultural community where the research was undertaken. The broader social and cultural location of the researchers should not be ignored. Both studies were completed in marketing faculties of business schools in Scotland (UK) in the late 1990s. The prevailing cultural conditions in Scotland at the time focussed heavily on questions of Scottish identity, Scottish (as opposed to English) culture, and Scottish institutions, with museums playing a highly visible role in debates surrounding the celebration and representation of Scottish culture. When looked at in relational terms, the salience of Scottish identity issues and the role of museums in representing these issues have influenced project and issue formulation. The role of marketing in promoting and encouraging public support for these institutions of culture, as well as the generic trend towards recreating museums as visitor (consumer) attractions for the increasingly significant tourism and leisure industry in Scotland provides some explanation for why both studies selected a common context in which to conduct the empirical aspects of their research programmes. While both studies can be seen to address a shared basic question or “problem”, the form that this question takes in the studies differs. Study A presents no theoretical justification for the observed shift in consumer research. That other non-commercial settings have been peer reviewed as credible sites for consumer enquiry is a sufficient justification for the museum as a location of research. Unlike Study A, Study B is not concerned with issues that demand explanative, or definitive styles of investigation but rather with the reasons why this set of conditions emerged is a given cultural-historical context. This reveals that debates about commensurability become complex and somewhat open to negotiation when applied empirically. Both studies can be seen to share underlying themes and motivations despite clear paradigmatic differences in terms of their respective theoretical expressions and cognitive aims (Howe, 1992; Sankey, 1994). The prevailing zeitgeist in both the discipline and the social environment provides some kind of meta-paradigmatic context that simultaneously enables alternative paradigmatically bound explanations to be pursued. Research assumptions The two studies have distinct research assumptions that conform to their respective methodological positions and this provides an opportunity to apply a conventional incommensurability thesis. Study A explains consumption at the individual level of behaviour that is influenced by various environmental stimuli. Study B is not concerned with the individual level but rather with the macro, or cultural conditions that have enabled contemporary consumption (represented by the proliferation of commodities) to emerge. The experience, behaviour and beliefs of consumers are taken only as illustrative of this general condition. While Study A is concerned with consumers and their behaviour, Study B is concerned with consumption and consumer society. Claims that the two studies should be considered commensurable because they both investigate the general topic of “consumption” in a museum setting could be questioned since both take a different view on what constitutes consumption and
consumption-related behaviour. However, it is not that Study B rejects or disagrees with the assumption that consumption can be understood as a behavioural condition, or that Study A attempts to refute a cultural critique of consumer society. Rather that the discourses used to develop Study B do not require behavioural readings, and the discourses used to develop Study A provide no space to account for cultural critiques other than as marginal behavioural determinants. However, collective insights can be gained from reading both studies together despite the lack of commonly informed research assumptions, as our comparative assessment of findings in the next section illustrates. Both studies apply a schema or theory to put into operation their respective approaches to the study of museum consumption, although this is achieved in subtly different ways. In common with the hypothetic-deductive approach, Study A is largely predetermined by the Theory of Planned Behaviour (Ajzen, 1991). Moderation of the theoretical model is justified in the literature review and then tested in the study. Study A rejects the conventional method of measuring antecedent attitudinal, subjective norm and control beliefs to suggest a revision based on disaggregation (Bagozzi, 1985) and a modelling procedure previously unused with this schema. The schematic classification used in Study B is not represented as a model, but rather as a simplified, and logical reduction of theories of commodity value. Whereas Study A uses behavioural antecedents as principal conditions for its model (classification), Study B draws on linguistic, or structuralist antecedents for its categorical description. While these schematic structures are not directly commensurable both seek to confirm a schematic premise that can be comprehended from each paradigmatic position. Both studies develop their arguments in a way that is appropriate to their respective root paradigms. For Study B, which locates itself in an interpretivist perspective, theory evaluation is implicit and not stressed. Study A, which associates itself with a positivist perspective, explicitly recognises model testing as an important part of the research design. Comparative assessment of findings Study A reports its findings with little concern for the cultural, historical or social conditions of consumer behaviour, and Study B offers little behavioural explanation for respondents’ actions. The coherence and rigour demanded of all research, whether interpretivist or positivist, by necessity leads to specialised modes of enquiry. The findings evident in both studies, whilst leading to somewhat disparate ends can, however, be seen to share some common traits. The main areas of commonality relate to visitors’ perceptions of authenticity, the issue of active participation and construction of the museum experience, and visitors’ desire to maintain a degree of personal control in the museum experience. Both studies identify consumer research as having traditionally viewed consumption as a passive activity, with the main focus being on the object of consumption and the manner in which it is provided or supplied. The two studies use empirical evidence to argue that consumption in a museum context is a mutually constructive process involving active interpretation. They both further ideas of the consumer as producer (or co-producer) of the consumption experience (Firat and Dholakia, 1998). The excerpts given below illustrate differences in discourse (or syntax) but commonality in terms of meaning (semantics):
Expansion on diversity in research 283
EJM 39,3/4
284
Study A: “Imagineering” or the professional dreaming-up of three dimensional fantasies which are planned and reconstructed for the total experience has become common place in our developing urban landscape . . . [and] characteristic of postmodern society as hyperreality. In terms of perceived positive reactions to the museum exhibitions, the idea and object based museums were found to significantly diverge in terms of hedonic cognitions and wakeful daydreaming, . . . personal and non-personal imagery (Hirschman and Holbrook, 1982). In particular, strong differences were noted for “feeling the past is brought to life” (p , 0:000, Cramer’s V ¼ 0:38) and “creating images in your mind of how and who used the objects” (p , 0:000, Cramer’s V ¼ 0:36). For instance, 80.0 per cent of idea-based museum respondents said it was extremely or quite likely that the “past would be brought to life” (p , 0:000, Cramer’s V ¼ 0:38), compared to only 46.5 per cent of object-based museum respondents. Similarly more respondents in the idea-based museum thought it was extremely or quite likely (77.0 per cent) that this would “create images in their minds of how and who used the objects’, compared to 46.0 per cent respondents in the object-based museum sample (p , 0:000, Cramer’s V ¼ 0:36) . . . These findings confirm that the idea-based museum is far more effective at facilitating respondents’ imaginations. “Imagineering”, has been shown as a positive and enabling change agent rather than an inability to come to terms with the past with its associated experiences of nostalgia and escapism . . . The fourth dimension extracted from principal component analysis (to describe the structure of museum experience) represents the experiential cognitions described by Hirschman (1985). Variables which loaded significantly on this dimension included “feeling a connection with the past”, “imagining what your life would have been like living in the past”, “imagining who used and how the objects were used” and “feeling admiration for the skill and craftsmanship of people in the past”. Study B: When visitors come into contact with museum artefacts, they use this experience to make stories about the past. In some cases this narrative construction was highly personal, relating to aspects of the visitor’s own past. This was particularly evident in the Museum of Transport with visitors who could remember the exhibits when they functioned as vehicles of public transport. In producing these stories about the past, visitors used the artefacts to structure their narratives, as if by being close to objects, the memories and stories about the past were more visual and more real and therefore more useful for visitors when constructing their own narratives . . . Museum artefacts have a unique use value for visitors in the sense that no other form of presentation can provide this insight into the past or provide the components for this type of narrative construction. Visitors did not only construct stories around objects they had personal experience of but also with objects from periods beyond their own life time or from other cultural spaces.
These findings present both studies with the opportunity to develop and progress their respective theoretical starting points although for very different reasons. Study A uses the finding to suggest that behavioural assumptions need to accommodate a greater level of individual action which it has tended to lack, while Study B uses a similar finding to propose that commodity theory (which represents the consumer as being alienated from the productive sphere) needs to be modified to incorporate an active or interpretative component. Common or broadly comparable (commensurable) findings are represented through different syntactic conventions, and are used to substantiate different types of arguments and interpretations. The use of numerical and statistical information in Study A is the clearest example of differing conventions (Potter and Wetherell, 1994).
A joint reading of the two pieces of research explicates a basic deterministic assumption running throughout seemingly incommensurable theories of consumption. Study A considers consumer behaviour to be determined by sets of cognitive antecedents, whereas Study B considers consumption to be structurally determined. Both studies argue for a greater recognition of individual facticity in value creation than is generally permitted by either behaviourist or cultural theories. They view the agency of the consumer as constrained although present. Consumption experiences in which the consumer is permitted to take a significant degree of control are perceived to be of greater value and significance than those where control is restricted or maintained by some other group, for example by museum curators: Study A: The largest differences in perceptions of the two museums were related to the interpretative environment, and in particular, the ability of visitors to engage with the objects displayed and to interact with interpretative media. “Being able to touch objects” (p , 0:000, Cramer’s V ¼ 0:49), “using computers” (p , 0:000, Cramer’s V ¼ 0:43) and “using models” (p , :000, Cramer’s V ¼ 0:41) were all more strongly observed in the idea-based museum. For example, 43.0 per cent of respondents rated “being able to touch objects” as extremely likely in the idea-based museum compared to only 8.5 per cent of respondents who found this to be the case for the object-based museum. Study B: The reality principle is a compromise. On one level a video presentation offers greater potential in terms of an accurate depiction of history because it can show far more than the objects alone. It can depict the artefact in use, it can show how the object was integrated into everyday social life and thus represent history more authentically. However, the level of abstraction that such a presentation imposes is considered to be limiting and verging on simulation. It adds a further barrier between the visitor and the already vague and disappearing past. Since close proximity to objects is of principle concern to museum visitors, the video, film or picture media loses its authenticity because of the distance it imposes between artefact and the object-desiring visitor. The object display, as seen in the museum, allows this disadvantage to be overcome – but at a price . . . The visitors’ choice is unanimous. The object discourse is given principle value and the visitor is prepared to ignore and even fail to recognise, the obvious disadvantages.
The influence of post-modern thought, questions over authentic representation, hyper-reality, and the primacy of the image over referents are evidenced in both studies. The then contemporary debate in the museum profession over the importance of the “authentic” and criticisms about the ”disneyfication” of museum interpretation (Cannon-Brookes, 1991; Terrell, 1991) emerge as common traits. Both studies focus on issues of authenticity as a vehicle to contribute to this debate. Rather than being an externally verifiable construct, authenticity is argued to be a subjectively constructed condition. Even when museum exhibits were clearly not “real” in the sense that they were not original or actual examples of the objects being represented, consumers were able to find authenticity in the “fake”. Reality emerges from the experience of being in the position to experience rather than being seen as located in the object presented. This shared interpretation is the strongest evidence against the incommensurability thesis when applied to these studies. From an empirical lived experience of research, the incommensurability thesis is very difficult to sustain in a clear and simple fashion. It is as if incommensurability is itself inappropriate simply because it negates and
Expansion on diversity in research 285
EJM 39,3/4
286
restrains the commonalities between different paradigmatic schools in terms of research practice.
Concluding remarks Adherence to strict or partial incommensurability is shown to be inappropriate in the context of evaluating the contributions provided by these two studies. Our analysis has clearly demonstrated the need to consider alternative epistemological foundations in consumer research but rejects viewing different paradigms as fixed choice alternatives. This analysis has shown that the post-Kuhnian critique of incommensurability is a viable proposition in terms of research practice. It raises a number of critical questions regarding the theoretical basis and pragmatic incorporation of research findings into the marketing and consumer research canon. The fact that marketing and consumer research, now has a breadth that spans a whole spectrum of research identities, including everything from technical and scientific explications, to studies in the arts and literature of consumption, suggests that a more fluid understanding of paradigms is desirable. Far from representing impermeable worldviews or a lack of relational language or common signification, the analysis of these two studies clearly shows “evidence” of commonality, points of shared interest, and mutual experience. The lasting legacy of the incommensurability debate is that it draws attention to, and demarks difference as a core feature of all disciplinary identity. Differences can be the source of conflict and power but also enhanced understanding. An uncritical adherence to the concept of incommensurability can be seen as placing somewhat artificial barriers around the exchange and discussion of research from studies in other paradigmatic camps. A generation of researchers have been trained to conceptualise research issues in terms of paradigmatic boundaries and to underplay their permeability and interrelation. Marketing and consumer research has been subject to what Giddens (1984) terms “opposing error” that has produced state of disunifying dualism. This “error” is manifest in theoretical and methodological oppositions and in terms practice (experience). This paper has shown that adhering to a misplaced reading of paradigm incommensurability in a search to establish credible research identities has made research practices appear oppositional and static when they are essentially undifferentiated and dynamic. The need for paradigmatic consensus as a process of identity validation for our research traditions has seen our methods, procedures, modes of representation, and journal editorial decisions become the dominant source of reason, which then serves to direct research practice (Haslam and McGarty, 2001). If the procedural aspects and representation of research activities account for most or all of the discrepancies between different types of research then there may be little or no need to reify the higher order construct of paradigm incommensurability. If this is the case, locating disagreement and conflict at the inaccessible and non-observable level of paradigms has the potential to stifle initiatives that seek to bridge the gap between specific aspects of research practice. Legislating methodological concerns to the status of first principle where the means through which marketing knowledge or science has become normalised have become ends in themselves and reveals a discipline moving towards homogeneity and standardisation which is paradoxical to the scientific values our discipline has sought to follow.
Our discipline suffers from false confidence (O’Shaughnessy, 1997). We may recognise that research tools and our representation of the procedural aspects of our research endeavours rarely reflect research experiences, but we comply with these conventions as a matter of expediency to obtain journal article acceptance (O’Shaughnessy, 1997; Zaltman, 2000). Compliance to these now established academic conventions, effectively a privileged methodological and representational code, may relegate and ultimately divorce the experience of research practice from its subsequent publication. The production of research comes to rely more heavily on the conventions of style and adherence to a kind of hyper reality of research expectations. The relevance and presence of good research will inevitably suffer, being indistinguishable from a body research that is dislocated and lacking in any sense of reference to the experiences of either the researching or researched community. This trend is of course evident is other social contexts and well reported. As signs lose their referents to reality they eventually become self-referential resulting in a hyper real image that has no value or purpose other than within the boundaries of the simulation itself (Baudrillard, 1981). The debate between interpretivism and positivism for instance often seems to take on a quality of hyper reality, being relevant only to and between itself. To others outside of the narrow community of scholars who engage in the debate the outcomes of such arguments often seem bewildering and intelligible, not to say irrelevant and esoteric. Kavanagh’s (1994) review of the then ongoing sparring match between Shelby Hunt and Paul Anderson and together with contributions from their respective advocates illustrates that such hyper real wrangling only serves to trivialise research processes and alienate a broader readership from engaging with the often genuine and positive insights that emerge from academic research practices, irrespective of the paradigmatic approach taken. We are in serious danger of marginalising potential contribution and diversity both among academic sub-communities and between academics and industry practitioners (Elliott and Jankel-Elliott, 2003; Wotton et al., 2002; Marsden, 2001; Hackley, 1999; Sankey, 1994). Other research traditions that are not burdened by these debates, such as commercial consumer research for example, will take an increasingly visible and powerful position in which principles of reliability and reflexivity are marginalised. Adopting a pragmatic position, although one that is progressive and non-confrontational, Weick (1999) recommends researchers to “drop their heavy tools of paradigms”, which are only relevant to their own modes of representation and constitute a largely internal and academic debate. Common resources, institutions, experiences, distance and vocabulary are shared resources within the marketing and consumer academic research community that should not be underestimated.
References Ajzen, I. (1991), “The theory of planned behaviour”, Organizational Behaviour and Human Decision Processes, Vol. 50, pp. 179-211. Anderson, P.F. (1983), “Marketing, scientific progress and scientific method”, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 47, Fall, pp. 18-31. Anderson, P.F. (1986), “On method in consumer research: a critical relativist perspective”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 13, September, pp. 155-73.
Expansion on diversity in research 287
EJM 39,3/4
288
Arndt, J. (1985), “The tyranny of paradigms: the case for paradigmatic pluralism in marketing”, in Dholakia, N. and Ardnt, J. (Eds), Research in Marketing: Changing the Course of Marketing, JAI Press, London, pp. 3-26. Arnould, E.J. and Price, L.L. (1993), “River magic: extraordinary experience and the extended service encounter”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 20, June, pp. 636-41. Bagozzi, R.P. (1985), “Expectancy-value attitude models: an analysis of critical theoretical issues”, International Journal of Research in Marketing, Vol. 2 No. 1, pp. 43-60. Baker, C., West, J. and Stern, P.N. (1992), “Method slurring: grounded theory/phenomenology example”, Journal of Advanced Nursing Studies, Vol. 17 No. 11, pp. 1355-60. Baudrillard, J. (1981), For a Critique of the Political Economy of the Sign, Telos Press, New York, NY. Belk, R.W. (1988), “Possessions and the extended self”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 15, September, pp. 139-67. Bettany, S. (2002), “Conceptualising marketing theory as an empirical domain: a speculative taxonomy of research approaches to the practice of marketing theory and suggestions for feminist ethnographic interventions”, Proceedings of the Academy of Marketing Conference 2002, Nottingham. Bettencourt, L.A. and Houston, M.B. (2001), “Reference diversity in JCR, JM and JMR: a reexamination and extension of Tellis, Chandy, and Ackerman (1999)”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 28, September, pp. 313-23. Bouchikhi, H. and Kimberley, J.R. (2001), “‘It’s difficult to innovate’: the death of the tenured professor and the birth of the knowledge entrepreneur”, Human Relations, Vol. 55 No. 1, pp. 77-84. Brown, S. (1995), Postmodern Marketing, Routledge, London. Brown, S. (1999), ‘“Marketing and literature’: the anxiety of academic influence”, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 63, January, pp. 1-15. Brown, S. (2002), “Vote, vote, vote for Philip Kotler”, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 36 No. 3, pp. 313-24. Brown, S., Hirschman, E.C. and McLaren, P. (2001), “Always historicise! Researching marketing theory in a post-historical epoch”, Marketing Theory, Vol. 1 No. 1, pp. 49-89. Cannon-Brookes, P. (1991), “Museums, theme parks and heritage experiences”, Museum Management and Curatorship, Vol. 10, pp. 351-8. Celsi, R.L., Rose, R.L. and Leigh, T.W. (1993), “An exploration of high-risk leisure consumption through skydiving”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 20 No. 1, pp. 1-23. Charmaz, K. (1995), “Between positivism and postmodernism: implications for methods”, Studies in Symbolic Interaction, Vol. 17, pp. 43-72. Davidson, D. (1984), Inquiries into Truth and Interpretation, Clarendon Press, Oxford, pp. 183-98. de Cock, C. and Chia, R. (2001), “Diversity and organization: an essay with special reference to the work of Mikhail Bakhtin”, Discussion Papers in Management, Exeter University, Exeter. de Cock, C., Richards, T., Weaver, G.R. and Gioia, D.A. (1995), “A rejoinder and reply from Weaver and Gioia”, Organization Studies, Vol. 16, pp. 669-76. Deshpande, R. (1983), “Paradigms lost: on theory and method in research in marketing”, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 47 No. Fall, pp. 101-10. Eisenhart, K.M. (2000), “Paradox, spirals and ambivalence: the new language or change and pluralism?”, Academy of Management Review, Vol. 25 No. 4, p. 703.
Elliott, R. (1996), “Discourse analysis: exploring action, function and conflict in social texts”, Marketing Intelligence & Planning, Vol. 14 No. 6, pp. 65-8. Elliott, R. and Jankel-Elliott, N. (2003), “Using ethnography in strategic consumer research”, Qualitative Market Research, Vol. 6 No. 4, pp. 215-23. Ferber, R. (1977), “Can consumer research be interdisciplinary?”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 4, June, pp. 19-28. Feyerabend, P.K. (1965), in Colodny, R.G. (Ed.), Beyond the Edge of Certainty, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, pp. 145-260. Firat, A.F. and Dholakia, N. (1998), Consuming People: From Political Economy to Theatres of Consumption, Routledge, London. Firat, A.F. and Venkatesh, A. (1995), “Liberatory postmodernism and the reenchantment of consumption”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 22, December, pp. 239-67. Flax, J. (1990), Thinking Fragments: Psychoanalysis, Feminism, and Postmodernism in the Contemporary West, University of California Press, Berkeley, CA. Frank, R.E. (1974), “The Journal of Consumer Research: an introduction”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 1, June, pp. iv-vi. Giddens, A. (1984), Constitution of Society, Polity Press, Oxford. Gioia, D. and Pitre´, E. (1990), “Multiparadigm perspectives on theory building”, Academy of Management Review, Vol. 15 No. 4, pp. 584-602. Goulding, C. (1999), “Consumer research, interpretive paradigms and methodological ambiguities”, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 33 No. 9/10, pp. 859-73. Guba, E. and Lincoln, Y.S. (1998), Paradigm Dialogue, Sage, Newbury Park, CA. Gummesson, E. (2001), “Are current approaches to marketing leading us astray?”, Marketing Theory, Vol. 1 No. 1, pp. 17-48. Hackley, C.E. (1999), “Tacit knowledge and the epistemology of expertise in strategic marketing management”, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 33 No. 7/8, pp. 720-35. Haslam, S.A. and McGarty, C. (2001), “100 years of certitude? Social psychology, the experimental method and the management of scientific uncertainty”, British Journal of Social Psychology, Vol. 40 No. 1, pp. 1-21. Hassard, J. (1988), “Overcoming hermeticism in organization theory: an alternative to paradigm incommensurability”, Human Relations, Vol. 41 No. 3, pp. 247-59. Heath, T.B. (1992), “The reconciliation of humanism and positivism in the practice of consumer research: a view from the trenches”, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, Vol. 20 No. 2, pp. 107-18. Hirschman, E.C. (1985), “Scientific style and the conduct of consumer research”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 12, September, pp. 225-39. Hirschman, E.C. and Holbrook, M.B. (1982), “The experiential aspects of consumption: consumer fantasies, feelings and fun”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 9, September, pp. 132-40. Hirschman, E.C. and Holbrook, M.B. (1992), Postmodern Consumer Research: The Study of Consumption as Text, Sage, Newbury Park, CA. Holbrook, M.B. and Schindler, R.M. (1989), “Some exploratory findings on the development of musical tastes”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 16, June, pp. 119-224. Howe, K.R. (1988), “Against the quantitative-qualitative incompatibility thesis or dogmas die hard”, Educational Researcher, Vol. 17, November, pp. 10-16.
Expansion on diversity in research 289
EJM 39,3/4
290
Howe, K.R. (1992), “Getting over the quantitative-qualitative debate”, American Journal of Education, Vol. 100, February, pp. 236-56. Hudson, L.A. and Ozanne, J.L. (1988), “Alternative ways of seeking knowledge in consumer research”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 14, March, pp. 508-21. Hunt, S.D. (1990), “Truth in marketing theory and research”, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 54, July, pp. 1-15. Hunt, S.D. (1991), “Positivism and paradigm dominance in consumer research – towards critical pluralism and reapproachment”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 18, June, pp. 32-44. Hunt, S.D. (1992), “Marketing is . . .”, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, Vol. 20 No. 4, pp. 301-11. Hunt, S.D. (1994), “On rethinking marketing: our discipline, our practice, our methods”, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 28 No. 3, pp. 13-25. Iacobucci, D. (2001), “Commonalties between research methods for consumer science and biblical scholarship”, Marketing Theory, Vol. 1 No. 1, pp. 109-33. Kaplan, A. (1964), The Conduct of Enquiry, Chandler, San Francisco, CA. Kavanagh, D. (1994), “Hunt versus Anderson: Round 16”, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 23 No. 3, pp. 26-41. Kernan, J.B. (1995), “Framing the rainbow, focusing the light: JCR’s first twenty five years”, Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 22, pp. 488-96. Kotler, P. (1979), “Strategies for introducing marketing into nonprofit organizations”, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 43, January, pp. 37-44. Kuhn, T.S. (1968), “History of science”, International Encyclopaedia of the Social Sciences, Vol. XIV, Macmillan, New York, NY, pp. 74-83. Kuhn, T.S. (1970a), The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, 2nd ed., University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL. Kuhn, T.S. (1970b), “Reflections on my critics”, in Musgrave, A. and Lakatos, I. (Eds), Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Kuhn, T.S. (1983), “Commensurability, comparability, communicability”, in Asquith, P.D. and Nickels, T. (Eds), PSA 1982: Proceedings of the 1982 Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association, Vol. 2, Philosophy of Science Association, East Lansing, MI, pp. 669-88. Lauden, L. (1984), “Reconstructing methodology”, in Anderson, P.F. and Ryan, M.J. (Eds), Scientific Method in Marketing, AMA Winter Educators’ Conference, American Marketing Association, Chicago, IL, pp. 1-4. Leong, S.M., Sheth, J. and Tan, C.T. (1994), “An empirical study of the scientific styles of marketing academics”, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 28 No. 8/9, pp. 12-26. Levy, S.J. (2002), “Revisiting the marketing domain”, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 36 No. 2, pp. 299-304. Lewis, M.W. and Grimes, A.J. (1999), “Metatriangulation: building theory from multiple paradigms”, Academy of Management Review, Vol. 24 No. 4, pp. 672-90. Lowenstein, G. (2001), “The creative destruction of decision research”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 28 No. 3, pp. 499-505. Lynch, J.G. (1998), “Presidential address: reviewing”, Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 25, pp. 1-6.
McAlexander, J., Schouten, J. and Koenig, H. (2002), “Building brand community”, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 66 No. 1, pp. 38-54. McCracken, G. (1988), Culture and Consumption: New Approaches to the Symbolic Character of Consumer Goods and Activities, Indiana University Press, Indianapolis, IN. McQuarrie, E.F. and Mick, D.G. (1992), “On resonance: a critical pluralistic inquiry into advertising rhetoric”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 19, September, pp. 180-97. Marsden, D. (2001), “Deconstructing consumer behaviour: theory and practice”, Journal of Consumer Behaviour, Vol. 1 No. 1, pp. 9-21. Mick, D.G. (1999), “From the editor-elect”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 25, March, pp. iv-vi. Murray, J.A., O’Driscoll, A. and Torres, A. (2002), “Discovering diversity in marketing practice”, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 36 No. 3, pp. 373-90. Nagel, E. and Newman, J.R. (1971), Godel’s Proof, Routledge, London. O’Shaughnessy, J. (1997), “Temerarious directions for marketing”, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 31 No. 9/10, pp. 677-705. O’Shaughnessy, J. and O’Shaughnessy, N. (2002), “Ways of knowing and their applicability”, Marketing Theory, Vol. 2 No. 2, pp. 147-64. Ozanne, J.L. and Hudson, L.A. (1989), “Exploring diversity in consumer research”, in Hirschman, E.C. (Ed.), Interpretive Consumer Research, Association of Consumer Research, Provo, UT, pp. 1-99. Peter, J.P. and Olson, J.C. (1983), “Is science marketing?”, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 47, Fall, pp. 111-25. Piercy, N.F. (2002), “Research in marketing: teasing with trivia or risking relevance?”, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 36 No. 3, pp. 350-63. Potter, J. and Wetherell, M. (1994), “Analyzing discourse”, in Bryman, A. and Burgess, R.G. (Eds), Analyzing Qualitative Data, Routledge, London, pp. 47-66. Putman, H. (1981), Reason, Truth and History, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Remenyi, D. (2002), “Research strategies – beyond the differences”, Electronic Journal of Business Research, Vol. 1 No. 1, pp. 39-41. Rescher, N. (1996), Process Metaphysics: An Introduction to Process Philosophy, State University of New York Press, New York, NY. Riley, R.W. and Love, L.L. (2000), “The state of tourism research”, Annals of Tourism Research, Vol. 27 No. 4, pp. 164-82. Rose, H. (2001), “Life after the science wars”, in Philo, G. and Miller, D. (Eds), Market Killing, Longman, Harlow, pp. 110-24. Rossiter, J.R. (2001), “What is marketing knowledge? Stage I: forms of marketing knowledge”, Marketing Theory, Vol. 1 No. 1, pp. 9-26. St Pierre, E.A. (1997), “Methodology in the fold and the irruption of transgressive data”, International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, Vol. 10 No. 2, pp. 175-89. Sankey, H. (1994), Incommensurability Thesis, Ashgate Publishing, Aldershot. Savitt, R. (1990), “Pre-Aldersonian antecedents to macromarketing: insights from the textual literature”, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, Vol. 18 No. 4, pp. 293-301. Sayers, B. (1987), “Wittgenstein, relativism, and the Strong thesis in sociology”, Philosophy of Social Sciences, Vol. 17, pp. 133-45. Schmidt, V.H. (2001), “Oversocialised epistemology: a critical appraisal of constructivism”, Sociology, Vol. 35 No. 3, pp. 135-57.
Expansion on diversity in research 291
EJM 39,3/4
292
Schultz, M. and Hatch, M. (1996), “Living with multiple paradigms: the case of paradigm interplay in organizational cultural studies”, Academy of Management Review, Vol. 21 No. 2, pp. 529-57. Shankar, A. and Patterson, M. (2001), “Interpreting the past, writing the future”, Journal of Marketing Management, Vol. 17, pp. 481-501. Sherry, J.F. (1991), “Postmodern alternatives in the interpretive turn in consumer research”, in Kassarjian, H.H. and Robertson, T.S. (Eds), Handbook of Consumer Behavior, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, pp. 548-91. Sherry, J.F. (2000), “Place, technology, and representation”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 27 No. 2, pp. 273-8. Silverman, D. (1997), Qualitative Research, Theory, Methods and Practice, Sage, London. Szmigim, I. and Foxhall, G. (2000), “Interpretive consumer research: how far have we come?”, Qualitative Market Research, Vol. 3 No. 4, pp. 187-9. Sutton, R.I. and Shaw, B.M. (1995), “What theory is not”, Administrative Science Quarterly, Vol. 40, pp. 371-84. Tellis, G.J., Chandy, R.K. and Ackerman, D.S. (1999), “In search of diversity: the record of major marketing journals”, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol. 36, February, pp. 120-31. Terrell, J. (1991), “Disneyland and the future of museum anthropology”, American Anthropologist, Vol. 93 No. 1, pp. 149-53. Thompson, C.J. and Troester, M. (2002), “Consumer value systems in the age of postmodern fragmentation: the case of natural health micro-culture”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 28 No. 4, pp. 550-71. Thompson, C. (1990), “Eureka! And other tests of significance: a new look at evaluating interpretive research”, Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 17, pp. 25-30. Thompson, C.J. (1993), “Modern truth and postmodern incredulity: a hermeneutic deconstruction of the metanarrative of scientific truth in marketing research”, International Journal of Research in Marketing, Vol. 10, pp. 325-38. Thompson, C.J. (2002), “A re-inquiry on re-inquiries: a postmodern proposal for a critical-reflexive approach”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 29 June, pp. 142-5. Trocchia, P.J. and Berkowitz, D. (1999), “Getting doctored: a proposed model of marketing doctoral student socialisation”, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 33 No. 7/8, pp. 746-59. Van Mannen, J. (1995), “Style as theory”, Organization Science, Vol. 6 No. 1, pp. 133-43. Venkatesh, A. (1985), “Is marketing ready for Kuhn?”, in Dholakhia, N. and Arndt, J. (Eds), Research in Marketing: Changing the Course of Marketing, JAI Press, London, pp. 45-68. Vickers, G. (1995), The Art of Judgement: A Study of Policy Making, Sage, London. Weick, K.E. (1989), “Theory construction as disciplined imagination”, Academy of Management Review, Vol. 14, pp. 516-31. Weick, K.E. (1999), “Theory construction as disciplined reflexivity: tradeoffs in the ’90s”, Academy of Management Review, Vol. 24 No. 4, pp. 797-806. Wells, W.D. (2001), “The perils of N ¼ 1”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 28 No. 3, pp. 494-8. Wilk, R.R. (2001), “The impossibility and necessity of re-inquiry: finding middle ground in social research”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 28, September, pp. 308-12. Wotton, N., Moore, K. and Elliott, R. (2002), “When theories become tools: toward a framework for pragmatic validity”, Human Relations, Vol. 55 No. 10, pp. 1227-49.
Zaltman, G. (2000), “Consumer researchers: take a hike!”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 26 No. 4, pp. 423-8. Zinkan, G.M., Roth, M.S. and Saxton, M.J. (1992), “Knowledge development and scientific status in consumer behavior research: a social exchange perspective”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 19, September, pp. 282-91.
Expansion on diversity in research
Further reading Kuhn, T.S. (1962), The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, 1st ed., University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL. Lacher, K.T. (1989), “Hedonic consumption: music as a product”, Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 16, pp. 488-96.
293
The Emerald Research Register for this journal is available at www.emeraldinsight.com/researchregister
EJM 39,3/4
294 Received January 2003 Revised September 2003 Accepted January 2004
The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available at www.emeraldinsight.com/0309-0566.htm
Grounded theory, ethnography and phenomenology A comparative analysis of three qualitative strategies for marketing research Christina Goulding Department of Marketing and Economics, Wolverhampton Business School, Wolverhampton University, Wolverhampton, UK Abstract Purpose – The paper aims to look at some of the problems commonly associated with qualitative methodologies, suggesting that there is a need for a more rigorous application in order to develop theory and aid effective decision making. Design/methodology/approach – The paper examines three qualitative methodologies: grounded theory, ethnography, and phenomenology. It compares and contrasts their approaches to data collection and interpretation and highlights some of the strengths and weaknesses associated with each one. Findings – The paper suggests that, while qualitative methodologies, as opposed to qualitative methods, are now an accepted feature of consumer research, their application in the truest sense is still in its infancy within the broader field of marketing. It proposes a number of possible contexts that may benefit from in-depth qualitative enquiry. Originality/value – The paper should be of interest to marketers considering adopting a qualitative perspective, possibly for the first time, as it offers a snap-shot of three widely-used methodologies, their associated procedures and potential pitfalls. Keywords Marketing theory, Ethnography, Qualitative research Paper type Conceptual paper
European Journal of Marketing Vol. 39 No. 3/4, 2005 pp. 294-308 q Emerald Group Publishing Limited 0309-0566 DOI 10.1108/03090560510581782
Introduction Within the field of marketing the positivism versus interpretivism debate is showing signs of slowing down, with a growing acceptance of the diverse range of methods of representing marketing phenomenon (Brown, 2003). The last two decades have seen a steady increase in the number of qualitative papers appearing in the premier journals, and while we may be a long way from reaching a full Kuhnian paradigm revolution, it is fair to say that qualitative research is no longer viewed as merely “speculative”, or “soft”, as was generally held to be the case by many in the past. However, that is not to say that some of the criticisms levied against qualitative research in marketing are not entirely without foundation. Just as there are many quantitative papers that fail to give full attention to design and statistical checks, there are many instances of papers claiming to be, for example grounded theory, that are based on purposive sampling and a handful of interviews which are then described, but lack theoretical sensitivity (Glaser, 1992). This has led to accusations that grounded theory is being used as an “anything goes” approach (Locke, 1996, p. 244). There are also “phenomenological” accounts which are free from any guiding philosophy and described in terms of content analysis and even statistics (see for example Masberg and Silverman’s (1996)
phenomenological study of visitor experiences at heritage sites), and ethnographic descriptions which are based on snap-shot observations and limited participatory interaction (Goulding, 2002). However, there is increasing acknowledgement, not only in academic circles, but also among marketing practitioners, of the need for the application of qualitative methodologies in their truest and most fundamental sense in order to gain valid insights, develop theory and aid effective decision making. This paper examines three qualitative methodologies, grounded theory, ethnography, and phenomenology, which have seen a steady growth in their application within marketing. It points to a number of studies that have applied the techniques and summarises the key procedures associated with each in order to differentiate between them and highlight their potential for future marketing research. A grounded theory approach Although traditionally associated with sociology (Glaser and Strauss, 1967; Glaser, 1978, 1992, 1998; Strauss and Corbin, 1990), nursing and health (Sandelowski, 1995; Morse, 1994), and organisational studies (Parry, 1998; Hunt and Ropo, 1995; Brown, 1994, 1995; Turner, 1981, 1988), grounded theory has, in recent years, started to enter the repertoire of marketing and consumer research (Goulding, 1998, 1999a, 2000a; Pettigrew, 2000). For instance, the “Odyssey” team (Belk et al., 1989) utilised aspects of grounded theory in their ground breaking analysis of the sacred and profane in consumer behaviour. Other examples include Hirschman and Thompson’s (1997) grounded theory analysis of advertising and the mass media, Burchill and Fine’s (1997) examination of product concept development, De la Cuesta’s (1994) study of marketing and health visiting, Houston and Venkatesh’s (1996) interpretation of health care consumption practices by Asian immigrants, and Goulding’s (1999b, c, 2000b, c) research into consumer experiences at heritage sites and museums. However, in comparison to other qualitative methodologies its application is still fairly confined to experiential consumer behaviour, despite its potential for theoretical developments across a range of marketing phenomenon that are predicated on a behavioural component. Contextualising grounded theory Essentially, grounded theory has its origins in symbolic interactionsim, a paradigm which holds that individuals engage in a world that requires reflexive interaction as averse to environmental response. Accordingly, behaviour is goal driven, evolving from social interaction that is highly symbolic in itself. This behaviour involves various forms of communication, both verbal and non-verbal and the notion of symbols is intrinsic to the perspective (Schwandt, 1994). Nonetheless, while symbolic interactionism was a key school within sociology particularly during the 1950s and 1960s, there were few guidelines for using its concepts to conduct research. Much of the work evolving from this paradigm was also emerging at a time when qualitative research was under attack for lacking “scientific” procedures and rigour. Consequently there was recognition of the need for a methodology that could track and validate the process of theory building. During this period two American sociologists, Barney Glaser, who was trained at Columbia University New York and was heavily influenced by the formal theorising of Paul Lazarsfeld, Paul Merton, and Herbert Hyman, and Anselm Strauss, a scholar
Analysis of three qualitative strategies 295
EJM 39,3/4
296
tutored in the philosophies of critical and qualitative methodologies of the Chicago School (Locke, 1996), set out to develop a more systematic and defined procedure for the collection and analysis of qualitative data. The methodology they devised was labelled grounded theory to reflect, as the name suggests, theory that is grounded in the words and actions of those individuals under study. Indeed the richness of the methodology has largely been attributed to the influences of the broader sociological schools of symbolic interactionism, ethnography and Glaser’s background in formal theorising. Consequently, grounded theory is suitable to the study of any behaviour that has an interactional element to it. Grounded theory process According to the basic principles of grounded theory, once an area of research has been identified, the researcher should enter the field as soon as possible. Consequently the literature is not exhausted prior to the research, as in many studies, rather it is consulted as part of an iterative, inductive and interactional process of data collection, simultaneous analysis, and emergent interpretation. In other words, the developing theory should direct the researcher to appropriate extant theories and literature that have relevance to the emerging, data grounded concepts. However, it must be noted that the way this has been expressed in the earlier works of Glaser and Strauss has resulted in confusion regarding the nature of “induction”. A common misconception is that the researcher is expected to enter the field ignorant of any theory or associated literature relating to the phenomenon and wait for the theory to emerge purely from the data. Such perceptions have resulted in accusations that both originators have “conned” those they have influenced by preaching the notion of theoretical avoidance, while marching into the field themselves armed with a life-time of concepts and experiences (Goulding, 2002). Nevertheless, this was not necessarily the case. Indeed Glaser and Strauss (1967, p. 253) state that: The core categories can emerge in the sociologist’s mind from his reading, life experiences, research and scholarship; [furthermore] no sociologist can possibly erase from his mind all the theory he knows before he begins his research. Indeed the trick is to line up what one takes as theoretically possible or probable with what one is finding in the field.
For marketers the dilemma is just the same. It involves a delicate balancing act between drawing on prior knowledge while keeping a fresh and open mind to new concepts as they emerge from the data. This means using the literature differently as the process evolves, getting closer to direct sources as the conceptual categories take shape and gain explanatory power. In addition to the use of literature grounded theory differs in a number of respects from other qualitative methodologies, particularly with regard to sampling. According to Coyle (1997), most sampling is purposive and defined before data collection commences. In the case of grounded theory, sampling begins as a “commonsense” process of talking to those informants who are most likely to provide early information. This information is then analysed through the application of open coding techniques, or line-by-line analysis (looking for words and sentences in the text that have meaning), which should help to identify provisional explanatory concepts and direct the researcher to further “theoretically” identified samples, locations, and forms of data. According to the original rules of grounded theory, the researcher should not leave the
field and stop sampling until saturation is reached, or when no additional information is found in the data. On this subject, one of the appeals of grounded theory is that it allows for a wide range of data, the most common of which are in-depth interviews, observations, and memos which describe situations, record events, note feelings and keep track of ideas. However, these are not exhaustive, as noted by Glaser (1978, p. 6):
Analysis of three qualitative strategies
Grounded theory method although uniquely suited to fieldwork and qualitative data, can be easily used as a general method of analysis with any form of data collection: survey, experiment, case study. Further, it can combine and integrate them. It transcends specific data collection methods.
297
Therefore, data may comprise of life histories (McKinley-Wright, 1995; Clondinin and Connelly, 1994), secondary data (Szabo and Strang, 1997), introspection (Corbin, 1998), and even numbers (Glaser and Strauss, 1967). Nevertheless, despite the open and flexible nature of the data that may be used in a grounded theory study, there exist a set of specific principles for analysing and abstracting the information. These include the “constant comparison” method, where, for example, interview texts are analysed line by line, provisional themes noted, and subsequently compared with other transcripts in order to ensure consistency and also to identify negative cases. The next stage is to search for links through the identification of concepts that may go some way to offering an explanation of the phenomenon under study. This process is normally associated with axial coding that is achieved by specifying relationships and delineating a core category or construct around which the other concepts revolve. Axial coding is the appreciation of concepts in terms of their dynamic interrelationships and they should form the basis for theory construction (Spiggle, 1994). The final stage of the theory development process is the construction of a core category (Glaser and Strauss, 1967). A core category pulls together all the concepts in order to offer an explanation of the phenomenon. It should have theoretical significance and should be traceable back through the data. This is usually when the theory is written up and integrated with existing theories to show relevance, fit, and/or extension. Grounded theory as a methodology emerged from the discipline of sociology, an area of enquiry that is focused on society and the individual. However, given the broadening of the marketing discipline over the last two decades to incorporate such issues as ethical marketing, social marketing, green issues and experiential consumption, all of which have significant behavioural implications, the application of grounded theory would seem appropriate. The rigours of the approach force the researcher to look beyond the superficial, to apply every possible interpretation before developing final concepts, and to demonstrate these concepts through explication and data supported evidence. The main problems associated with the methodology appear to stem largely from its misuse and abuse. Examples include studies labelled grounded theory that have not followed the principles of theoretical sampling, inductive coding, constant comparison and so on. However, this is possibly truer of studies stemming from the organisational behaviour literature than it is of marketing. For example, Mullins and Roessier’s (1998) research into employment outcomes ignored theoretical sampling and constant comparison, drew on an established model and collected data through structured mail surveys which featured a rating scale. Consequently, while the study may well have been rigorous, it is hard to claim that it produced a “grounded” theory in the accepted sense.
EJM 39,3/4
298
This practice of methodological muddling (Baker et al., 1992) has traditionally been perceived as a violation of the principles of grounded theory (Locke, 1996), although there is now recognition that it is valid to use grounded theory in part, alongside other approaches so long as the objectives are made clear (Skodal-Wilson and Ambler-Hutchinson, 1996). A good example of this can be seen in Belk et al.’s (1989) “Odyssey” paper which combined a number of methodologies in order to address various questions as the research progressed. Pettigrew (2000) on the other hand discusses the “marriage” of grounded theory with ethnography to gain a deeper insight into consumer experiences. Yet despite the evolving nature of grounded theory and its application to an increasing number of contexts, there remains one outstanding issue; namely that most grounded theory studies are concluded at the “substantive” level (context specific) rather than developed to the general level. The answer to this may lie in a number of factors, not the least of which is time. The development of a general theory involves taking the research into a variety of contexts, ensuring full theoretical sampling and the production of a theory that has applications to other settings and populations (Morse, 1994). This may take years and involve research teams as averse to lone academics, which combined with the pressure to publish means that few have either the time or the resources to commit to such an endeavour. A final significant issue that may act as a deterrent to using grounded theory is that theoretical saturation of the data and the interpretation of that data can make it difficult to anticipate an accurate time scale for the research. This, while problematic in the general sense of planning research strategies, creates even greater difficulties when applying for research grants (Goulding, 2002). However, grounded theory is only one of a wide range of qualitative methodologies currently being used to investigate contemporary marketing phenomenon. The next section examines the ethnographic position within marketing by first discussing its application before providing an overview of the ethnographic process. An ethnographic approach The roots of ethnography lie in cultural anthropology, with its focus on small-scale societies and the original central concept remains paramount today; that is a concern with the nature, construction and maintenance of culture. Ethnographies are always informed by this concept as ethnographers aim to look beyond what people say to understand the shared system of meanings we call “culture”. In her review of ethnography in consumer research Pettigrew (2000) argues that consumption represents a phenomenon that can be effectively addressed with the use of ethnographic techniques, based on the understanding that the social meanings found in material possessions can be viewed as cultural communicators. Arnould (1998, p. 86) provides an in-depth discussion of consumer-oriented ethnography suggesting that “ethnography attempts to explicate structured patterns of action that are cultural and/or social rather than merely cognitive, behavioural or affective”. Stebbins (1997) further illustrates the potential of ethnographic research to the study of lifestyles given the cultural or sub-cultural context within which they are enacted, while Arnould and Wallendorf (1994) discuss the relevance of market-oriented ethnography to developing marketing strategy. Indeed within marketing, the ethnographic turn in enquiry is becoming widespread (Brown, 1998) and critically appraised (Brownlie, 1997). Moreover, there is a growing body of literature, based on ethnographic methods, which
act as exemplars for those wishing to apply the methodology. For example, Arnould and Price’s (1993) much quoted “River magic”, Hill’s (1991) study of homeless women and the meaning of possessions, and Schouten and McAlexander’s (1995) longitudinal study of the new “biker” culture in the USA. From a British perspective Ritson and Elliott’s (1999) analysis of adolescents and their use of advertisements was based on extended encounters with groups of teenagers, including teaching part-time in the schools that they were attending in order to develop trust and rapport, and gain a sense of the dynamics and systems within the environment. Ethnography, therefore, has its own distinct procedures for collecting data, but it is also highly concerned with the cultural context. The next part of this paper attempts to contextualise ethnography before examining the primary techniques associated with ethnographic research. Contextualising ethnography It is important for the researcher considering using ethnography to understand the various types of investigation that may potentially form the framework for analysis. Ethnography can be any full or partial description of a group (ethno – folk, graphy – description), as a means of identifying common threads, whether these be religion, social relationships or management style. Ethnographies may be cross sectional such as Goffman’s (1961) study of asylums which looked at a cross section of “total” institutions (Fine and Martin, 1990), or ethnohistorical, which describe the cultural reality of the present as the historical result of events in the past. They may be classified on the basis of spatial or geographic dimensions, by language, by theory, or in any number of diverse ways; there are few limitations to the cultural contexts to which it can be applied (Boyle, 1994). Ethnographic process A key feature of ethnography is that it is labour intensive and always involves prolonged direct contact with group members in an effort to look for rounded, holistic explanations. The hallmark of ethnography is fieldwork; working with people in their natural settings. The voices of participants are an important source of data and should be allowed to be heard in the written end-product, which should be a coherent, fluent and readable narrative (Boyle, 1994; Muecke, 1994). Arnould (1998) offers a useful summary of ethnography and its role in consumer research, which includes: . Ethnography should aim to explain the ways that culture constructs and is constructed by the behaviours and experiences of its members. . Ethnography involves prolonged participation within a specific culture or sub-culture. . Ethnography in consumer research tends to be particularistic rather than generalisable, espousing pluralistic accounts of consumption. . The potential for ethnography lies in applying multiple data collection methods at a single phenomenon. These may range from surveys to observational data, video tapes, photographs and recordings of speech in action. . Ethnography requires tactics for representing research findings. These representations should aim to unravel the layered meanings that marketing activities hold for the customer.
Analysis of three qualitative strategies 299
EJM 39,3/4
300
Holbrook (1998) provides an interesting departure from the traditional participatory observational approach to ethnography in his description of his “ethnoscopic” journey to Kroywen. In his study he borrows from cultural anthropology and visual sociology, making use of photographs and other pictorial records to reveal revelationary collages based on intense introspection and reflection. The reflexive nature of ethnography is a characteristic which implies that the researcher is part of the world that is under study and is consequently affected by it (Boyle, 1994). In a catch 22 situation, this view has resulted in criticisms of “value laden” interpretations (Borman and Preissle-Goez, 1986). However, the interpreter does not take the data on face value, but considers it as a field of inferences in which hypothetical patterns can be identified and their validity tested. This usually entails a long and discursive process over data interpretation, reasoning, and the fit to related studies (Agar, 1983; Borman and Preissle-Goez, 1986). Additionally, with ethnography, insider and outsider views combine to provide deeper insights than would be possible by the “native” alone. This two-sided view produces a third dimension that rounds off the ethnographic picture, which is a theoretical explanation of the phenomena under study. The emic perspective is at the heart of ethnography, while the etic perspective is the researchers abstractions or scientific explanations of reality (Boyle, 1994). Boyle further suggests, that although ethnographies vary, most combine some element of etic and emic analysis, although the emphasis may differ according to the philosophy of the researcher. With regard to the analysis of ethnographic data, this involves the search for patterns, and ideas that will help explain the existence of these patterns, taking into consideration emic and etic interpretations. This is frequently done through the application of content analysis, a technique for making inferences from text data. Each word or phrase in a text is categorised by applying labels that reflect concepts such as aggression, denial and so forth inherent within it. Some counting may be done (but not always), and some researchers use factor analysis, although this runs the risk of substituting numbers for rich description and it is rare to see this in an ethnographic study. More often than not, the ethnographer identifies categories and instances within the data by desegregating the text (notes) into a series of fragments which are then regrouped under a set of thematic headings. Comprehension is thought to be complete when the researcher can describe the events, incidents and exceptions from an emic perspective (Morse, 1994). Synthesis, involves coding and content analysis where the data is pooled and the constructed categories are linked. Often, however, ethnographic analysis is not developed beyond the level of “thick description”, presented as informants’ stories and case studies. Furthermore, the analytical phase of theorising is seldom separated from the descriptive discourse and treated as a separate level with a distinct purpose (Morse, 1994). With regard to theory, ethnography is embedded in cultural theory and the establishment of macro/micro, or etic/emic, distinctions are ultimately linked to established theory. Finally, recontextualisation is achieved by forcing the theory to a level of abstraction, the degree of which determines the generalisability of the theory. However, according to Atkinson and Hammersley (1995) the degree to which ethnography is conducted in its “truest” form is sometimes controversial. To some it constitutes a philosophical paradigm to which one makes a total commitment, for others it designates a method that one uses where and when appropriate. Furthermore
they propose that the nature of participatory observation is something that has attracted criticism on ethical grounds and it is argued that the following should be made explicit: . Whether the researcher is known to be a researcher by those studied. . How much, and what is known by the participants about the research. . What sort of activities are and are not engaged in by the researcher. . What is the orientation of the researcher and how involved is he/she in the situation. While these factors are not necessarily unique to ethnography, the matter of involvement and participation brings them very much to the fore. A further bone of contention stems from those who adopt a critical stance toward ethnography. Critical ethnography, comprising largely of feminist and post-modernist perspectives, is thought to present an impressionistic collage, an image that represents only a “slice” of time and context and therefore challenges the claims of holistic interpretations (Muecke, 1994). The final part of this paper looks at phenomenology, a methodology that has seen increasing use, especially in the field of consumer behaviour. A phenomenological approach Phenomenology, as both a philosophy and a methodology has been used in organisational and consumer research in order to develop an understanding of complex issues that may not be immediately implicit in surface responses. However, within the field of marketing, it is probably the work of Craig Thompson that has done more to highlight both the underlying principles of phenomenology (Thompson, 1997, 1998; Thompson et al., 1989) and its application to various research situations. Examples of these include Thompson’s (1996) exploration of gendered consumption and lifestyle, Thompson and Hirschman’s (1995) analysis of self care practices and self conceptions, Thomson et al.’s (1990) study of the everyday consumption practices of married women, and Thompson and Haykto’s (1997) deconstruction of the meaning of fashion discourses and the link to identity and self conceptions. Other consumer studies which have adopted a phenomenological position include Mick and Demoss’s (1990) exploration of self gift giving, O’Guinn and Faber’s (1989) work on compulsive shopping, Woodruffe-Burton et al.’s (2002) research into gender and addictive consumption, Goulding et al.’s (2002) analysis of dance culture, the link to postmodern identity fragmentation and the emergence of neo-communities, and Seebaransingh et al.’s (2002) insightful account of the relationship between cosmetic surgery and the construction of identity. These studies provide examples of phenomenology in practice, however it is necessary to understand the origins and particular techniques associated with the methodology in order to distinguish it from other forms of qualitative enquiry. Contextualising phenomenology With regard to the development and application of phenomenology it is probably fair to say that it has had a long, controversial, and often confusing history within the social sciences (Rehorick and Taylor, 1995). Moreover, depending on one’s epistemological and ontological position, it is either conceptualised as a philosophy,
Analysis of three qualitative strategies 301
EJM 39,3/4
302
for those who adhere to the thinking of Husserl (1962) and Heidegger (1962), or a methodology, for those who adopt the position put forward by Schutz (1967). While Husserl’s intention was to develop a schema for describing and classifying subjective experiences of what he termed the life world (Langenbach, 1995), Schutz (1967) developed the approach as a method which incorporated details of experience often at the level of mundane everyday life. The lifeworld is defined as the world in which we, as human beings among fellow human beings, experience culture and society, take a stand with regard to their objects, are influenced by them, and act on them (Schutz, 1966). Gregova (1996), distinguishes between the lifeworld and the social world, proposing that the lifeworld consists of formal structures about which we are less explicitly aware, while the social world relates to everyday familiar actions and experiences. Essentially, the goal of phenomenology is to enlarge and deepen understanding of the range of immediate experiences (Spiegelberg, 1982). Merleau-Ponty (1962, p. vii) suggests that the results of phenomenological enquiry should be “a direct description of our experience without taking account of its psychological origin”. Phenomenology therefore is a critical reflection on conscious experience, rather than subconscious motivation, and is designed to uncover the essential invariant features of that experience (Jopling, 1996). Phenomenological process As one of the major influences on phenomenological enquiry Schutz proposed that individuals approach the life world with a stock of knowledge made up of common sense constructs and categories that are essentially social in action. These stocks of knowledge produce familiarity, but they are always incomplete and open ended. Naming requires the interpretative application of a category to the concrete particulars of a situation (Holstein and Gubrium, 1994). Language is the central medium for transmitting meaning and as such provides a methodological orientation for a phenomenology of social life that is concerned with the relation between language use and the objects of experience. The meaning of a word is taken to be what it references, corresponds with, or stands for in the real world. This is based on the premise that the essential task of language is to convey information and describe “reality”. It is also assumed that there is a degree of commonalty in that others experience the world in fundamentally the same way, intersubjectively sharing the same meaning. The basic assumption is that a person’s life is a socially constructed totality in which experiences interrelate coherently and meaningfully. With regard to the process of enquiry, the phenomonologist has only one legitimate source of data, and that is the views and experiences of the participants themselves. This in itself assumes that the participant’s view is taken as “fact”. Furthermore, participants are selected only if they have lived the experience under study. Sampling is therefore purposive and prescribed from the start and the main instrument of data collection is the interview. Thompson (1998) suggests that the relevant implication of the life-world is that the consumer as text metaphor needs to be reflectively adapted and enriched through a dynamic combination of consumers who interpret their experiences and consumer researchers who interpret consumer’s narratives. In other words “it is important to recognise that human existence has some text like qualities but it is not text per se” (Thompson, 1998, p. 129). As a means of interpretation, Thompson (1997) in his analysis of consumer experiences, advocates part to whole analysis of participant
accounts by proceeding through an interactive process. This involves reading texts (interview transcripts) in full, in order to first gain a sense of the whole picture. After several readings of the text, the next stage is hermeneutic endeavour (Thompson et al., 1990), or intertextuality (Thompson, 1997), whereby patterns and differences are sought across transcripts. This strategy of interpretation must broaden the analysis to include a wider range of considerations that helps the researcher arrive at a holistic interpretation. There must also be recognition that the final explanation represents a fusion of horizons between the interpreter’s frame of reference and the texts being interpreted (Thompson, 1997). This is largely concurrent with the process outlined by Colaizzi (1978) who suggests a series of seven steps: (1) The first task of the researcher is to read the participants narratives, to acquire a feeling for their ideas in order to understand them fully. (2) The next step “extracting significant statements”, requires the researcher to identify key words and sentences relating to the phenomenon under study. (3) The researcher then attempts to formulate meanings for each of these significant statements. (4) This process is repeated across participants’ stories and recurrent meaningful themes are clustered. These may be validated by returning to the informants to check interpretation. (5) After this the researcher should be able to integrate the resulting themes into a rich description of the phenomenon under study. (6) The next step is to reduce these themes to an essential structure that offers an explanation of the behaviour. (7) Finally, the researcher may return to the participants to conduct further interviews or elicit their opinions on the analysis in order to cross check interpretation. These structures provide the researcher with an understanding of the world that contributes towards the development of theory. On the question of theory Morse (1994) suggests that phenomenologists do not label themselves as theorists in the strictest sense, rather linkages from the data to theory are based on reflections of theoretical literature. Recontextualisation comes from writing and rewriting, which as a practice sensitises the researcher and provides new insights. This increases the level of abstraction by moving from the “particular” sphere to a “universal” sphere where themes are readily comprehensible to the humans which they seek to describe. However, there are a number of misconceptions and ad hoc interpretations of phenomenology to be found in the literature. First, the philosophy that underpins phenomenology is often misused to refer to the qualitative paradigm as a whole. This is not the case. Phenomenologists seek guidance from existential philosophers in the interpretation of their data. Through careful study of individuals they hope to discover the deeper meaning of the “lived” experience in terms of the individual’s relationship with time, space and personal history (Stern, 1994). The collection and analysis of data using this methodology is also specifically prescribed. Phenomenology demands that intense reflection is an integral part of the process, but above all, the primacy of the subjective experience is felt to be crucial. Analysis is conducted by scrutinising the text
Analysis of three qualitative strategies 303
EJM 39,3/4
304
for meaning “units” which describe the central aspects of the experience. These are then synthesised to provide a general description of the “whole”. Conclusion This paper has looked at three different qualitative methodologies, each quite distinct in their procedures for data collection, interpretation and theoretical development. For example, grounded theory is flexible in terms of data, but insists on theoretical sampling and saturation of both data and theory before theory development can be claimed. It is also a methodology particularly suited to situations that have a symbolic and, or, an interactional element to them. Consequently, it has potential for a number of research directions and contexts that go beyond consumer behaviour, for example, relationship marketing or even the sales situation. Ethnography is generally concerned with culture and power with the main forms of data generally participatory observation and interviews. Again, research agendas that focus on, for example, inter-departmental dynamics, gender issues, ethical marketing or green consumption, may well benefit from the application of an ethnographic approach. Finally, phenomenology has its own unique characteristics and philosophy, which may be beneficial in terms of theory building based around lived experiences, whether these be consumption or strategic decision making. In sum, each has its own strengths and weaknesses, but each are suited to the study of marketing phenomenon. However, despite the flexibility of the methodologies described, their application remains largely in the field of experiential consumer behaviour with their potential for theory development within the broader field of marketing yet to be fully realised. Possibly, this may be the next step in the development of qualitative research with marketing. References Agar, M. (1983), “Ethnographic evidence”, Urban Life, Vol. 12 No. 10, pp. 32-48. Arnould, E.J. (1998), “Daring consumer-oriented ethnography”, in Stern, B. (Ed.), Representing Consumers: Voices, Views and Visions, Routledge, London. Arnould, E.J. and Price, L. (1993), “River magic: extraordinary experience and the extended service encounter”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 20, June, pp. 24-45. Arnould, E.J. and Wallendorf, M. (1994), “Market oriented ethnography: interpretation building and marketing strategy formulation”, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol. 31, November, pp. 484-504. Atkinson, P. and Hammersley, M. (1995), Ethnography, 2nd ed., Routledge, London. Baker, C., West, J. and Stern, P. (1992), “Method slurring; the grounded theory/phenomenology example”, Journal of Advanced Nursing, Vol. 17 No. 11, pp. 1355-60. Belk, R.W., Wallendorf, M. and Sherry, J.F. (1989), “The sacred and the profane in consumer behaviour: theodicy on The Odyssey”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 16, June, pp. 1-37. Borman, K. and Preissle-Goez, J. (1986), “Ethnographic and qualitative research design and why it doesn’t work”, American Behavioural Scientist, Vol. 30 No. 1, pp. 42-57. Boyle, J.S. (1994), “Styles of ethnography”, in Morse, J.M. (Ed.), Critical Issues in Qualitative Research Methods, Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA. Brown, A. (1994), “Politics, symbolic action and myth making in pursuit of legitimacy”, Organization Studies, Vol. 15 No. 6, pp. 861-78.
Brown, A. (1995), “Managing understandings: politics, symbolism, niche marketing and the quest for legitimacy in IT implementation”, Organization Studies, Vol. 16 No. 6, pp. 951-69. Brown, S. (1998), Postmodern Marketing 2: Telling Tales, Thompson Business Press, London. Brown, S. (2003), “Crisis, what crisis? Marketing, Midas, and the Croesus of representation”, Qualitative Marketing Research: An International Journal, Vol. 6 No. 3, pp. 194-205. Brownlie, D. (1997), “Beyond ethnography: towards writerly accounts of organising in marketing”, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 31 No. 3/4, pp. 263-82. Burchill, G. and Fine, C. (1997), “Time versus market orientation in product concept development: empirically-based theory generation”, Management Science, Vol. 43 No. 4, pp. 465-78. Clondinin, D.J. and Connelly, F.M. (1994), “Personal experience methods”, in Denzin, N. and Lincoln, Y. (Eds), Handbook of Qualitative Research, Sage, London. Colaizzi, P. (1978), “Psychological research as a phenomenologist views it”, in Valle, R. and King, M. (Eds), Existential Phenomenological Alternatives for Psychology, Oxford University Press, New York, NY. Corbin, J. (1998), “Alternative interpretations: valid or not?”, Theory and Psychology, Vol. 8 No. 1, pp. 121-8. Coyle, I.T. (1997), “Sampling in qualitative research. purposeful and theoretical sampling; merging or clear boundaries?”, Journal of Advanced Nursing, Vol. 26 No. 3, pp. 623-30. De la Cuesta, C. (1994), “Marketing: a process in health visiting”, Journal of Advanced Nursing, Vol. 19 No. 2, pp. 347-53. Fine, G. and Martin, D. (1990), “A partisan view: sarcasm, satire, and irony as voices in Erving Goffman’s asylums”, Journal of Contemporary Ethnography, Vol. 19 No. 1, April, pp. 89-115. Glaser, B. (1978), Theoretical Sensitivity, The Sociology Press, Mill Valley, CA. Glaser, B. (1992), Basics of Grounded Theory Analysis: Emergence v. Forcing, The Sociology Press, Mill Valley, CA. Glaser, B. (1998), Doing Grounded Theory: Issues and Discussions, Sociology Press, Mill Valley, CA. Glaser, B. and Strauss, A. (1967), The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research, Aldine, Chicago, IL. Goffman, E. (1961), “Asylums”, in Cressey, D. (Ed.), Holt, Rhinenhart, Winston, New York, NY. Goulding, C. (1998), “Grounded theory: the missing methodology on the interpretivist agenda”, Qualitative Marketing Research: An International Journal, Vol. 1 No. 1, pp. 50-7. Goulding, C. (1999a), “Consumer research, qualitative paradigms, and methodological ambiguities”, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 33 No. 9/10, pp. 859-73. Goulding, C. (1999b), “Heritage, nostalgia, and the ‘grey’ consumer”, The Journal of Marketing Practice: Applied Marketing Science, Vol. 5 No. 6/7/8, pp. 177-99. Goulding, C. (1999c), “Museum culture and consumer behaviour”, Journal of Marketing Management, Vol. 15, November, pp. 647-72. Goulding, C. (2000a), “Grounded theory and consumer behaviour: principles, practice, and pitfalls”, Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 27, September. Goulding, C. (2000b), “The museum environment and the visitor experience”, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 34 No. 3/4, pp. 433-52.
Analysis of three qualitative strategies 305
EJM 39,3/4
306
Goulding, C. (2000c), “The commodification of the past, postmodern pastiche, and the search for authentic experiences at contemporary heritage attractions”, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 34 No. 7, pp. 835-53. Goulding, C. (2002), Grounded Theory; A Practical Guide for Management, Business and Market Researchers, Sage, London. Goulding, C., Shankar, A. and Elliott, R. (2002), “Working weeks, rave weekends: identity fragmentation and the emergence of new communities”, Consumption, Markets and Culture, Vol. 5 No. 4, pp. 261-84. Gregova, M. (1996), “Restructuring of the life world of socialism”, International Sociology, Vol. 11 No. 1, pp. 63-78. Heidegger, M. (1962), Being and Time, Harper & Row, New York, NY. Hill, R. (1991), “Homeless women, special possessions and the meaning of home: an ethnographic case study”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 18, December, pp. 298-310. Hirschman, E.C. and Thompson, C. (1997), “Why media matter: toward a richer understanding of consumers’ relationships with advertising and mass media”, The Journal of Advertising, Vol. 26 No. 1, pp. 43-60. Holbrook, M. (1998), “Journey to Kroywen: an ethnoscopic auto-auto-auto-driven stereographic photo-essay”, in Stern, B. (Ed.), Representing Consumers: Voices, Views and Visions, Routledge, London. Holstein, J. and Gubrium, J. (1994), “Phenomenology, ethnography and interpretative practice”, in Denzin, N. and Lincoln, Y. (Eds), Handbook of Qualitative Research, Sage, Beverly Hills, CA. Houston, H.R. and Venkatesh, A. (1996), “The health-care consumption patterns of Asian immigrants: grounded theory implications for consumer acculturation theory”, Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 23, pp. 418-23. Hunt, J.G. and Ropo, A. (1995), “Multi-level leadership: grounded theory and mainstream theory applied to the case of General Motors”, Leadership Quarterly, Vol. 6 No. 3, pp. 379-412. Husserl, E. (1962), The Crisis of European Sciences and Transcendental Phenomenology, trans. by Carr, D., Northwestern University Press, Evanston, IL. Jopling, D. (1996), “Sub-phenomenology”, Human Studies, Vol. 19 No. 2, pp. 153-73. Langenbach, M. (1995), “Phenomenology, intentionality, and mental experiences”, History of Psychiatry, Vol. 5, pp. 209-24. Locke, K. (1996), “Rewriting the discovery of grounded theory after 25 years?”, Journal of Management Inquiry, Vol. 5 No. 3, pp. 239-45. McKinley-Wright, M. (1995), “I never did any fieldwork, but I milked an awful lot of cows! Using rural women’s experience to reconceptualise models of work”, Gender and Society, Vol. 9 No. 2, pp. 216-35. Masberg, B. and Silverman, L. (1996), “Visitor experiences at heritage sites: a phenomenological approach”, Journal of Travel Research, Vol. 34 No. 4, pp. 20-5. Merleau-Ponty, M. (1962), Phenomenology of Perception, trans. by Smith, C., Routledge & Kegan Paul, London. Mick, D.G. and Demoss, M. (1990), “Self gifts: phenomenological insights from four contexts”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 17, December, pp. 322-32. Morse, J.M. (1994), “Emerging from the data: the cognitive process of analysis in qualitative enquiry”, in Morse, J.M. (Ed.), Critical Issues in Qualitative Research Methods, Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA.
Muecke, M.A. (1994), “On the evaluation of ethnographies”, in Morse, J.M. (Ed.), Critical Issues in Qualitative Research Methods, Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA. Mullins, J. and Roessier, R. (1998), “Improving employment outcomes; perspectives of experienced counsellors regarding the importance of counselling tasks”, Journal of Rehabilitation, Vol. 64 No. 2, pp. 12-18. O’Guinn, T.C. and Faber, R.J. (1989), “Compulsive buying: a phenomenological exploration”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 16 September, pp. 147-57. Parry, K.W. (1998), “Grounded theory and social process: a new direction for leadership research”, Leadership Quarterly, Vol. 9 No. 1, pp. 85-105. Pettigrew, S. (2000), “Ethnography and grounded theory: a happy marriage?”, Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 27, pp. 256-60. Rehorick, D. and Taylor, G. (1995), “Thoughtful incoherence: first encounters with the phenomenological-hermeneutic domain”, Human Studies, Vol. 18, pp. 389-414. Ritson, M. and Elliott, R. (1999), “The social uses of advertising: an ethnographic study of adolescent advertising audiences”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 26, June, pp. 260-77. Sandelowski, M. (1995), “Focus on qualitative methods: sample size in qualitative research”, Research in Nursing and Health, Vol. 18, pp. 179-83. Schouten, J.W. and McAlexander, J.H. (1995), “Subcultures of consumption: an ethnography of the new bikers”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 22, June, pp. 43-62. Schutz, A. (1966), “Some structures of the lifeworld”, Collected Papers, Vol. 3, Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague. Schutz, A. (1967), The Phenomenology of the Social World, Northwestern University Press, Evanston, IL. Schwandt, T.A. (1994), “Constructivist, interpretivist approaches to human enquiry”, in Denzin, N.K. and Lincoln, Y.S. (Eds), Handbook of Qualitative Research, Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA. Seebaransingh, N., Patterson, M. and O’Malley, L. (2002), “Finding ourselves: women, breast augmentation and identity”, Gender, Marketing and Consumer Behaviour, Vol. 6, pp. 15-16. Skodal-Wilson, H. and Ambler-Hutchinson, S. (1996), “Methodological mistakes in grounded theory”, Nursing Research, Vol. 45 No. 2, pp. 122-4. Spiegelberg, H. (1982), The Phenomenological Movement: A Historical Introduction, Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague. Spiggle, S. (1994), “Analysis and interpretation of qualitative data in consumer research”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 21 No. 3, pp. 491-503. Stebbins, R. (1997), “Lifestyle as a generic concept in ethnographic research”, Quality and Quantity, Vol. 31 No. 4, pp. 347-60. Stern, B. (1994), “Classical and vignette television advertising dramas: structural models, formal analysis and consumer effects”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 19, June, pp. 601-15. Strauss, A. and Corbin, J. (1990), Basics of Qualitative Research: Grounded Theory Procedures and Techniques, Sage, London. Szabo, V. and Strang, V.R. (1997), “Secondary analysis of qualitative data”, Advances in Nursing Science, Vol. 20 No. 2, pp. 66-74. Thompson, C.J. (1996), “Caring consumers: gendered consumption meanings and the juggling of lifestyle”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 22, March, pp. 388-407.
Analysis of three qualitative strategies 307
EJM 39,3/4
308
Thompson, C.J. (1997), “Interpreting consumers: a hermeneutic framework for deriving marketing insights from the texts of consumers’ consumption stories”, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol. XXXIV, November, pp. 438-55. Thompson, C.J. (1998), “Living the texts of everyday life: a hermeneutic perspective on the relationships between consumer stories and life-world structures”, in Stern, B. (Ed.), Representing Consumers: Voices, Views and Vision, Routledge, London. Thompson, C.J. and Haykto, D.L. (1997), “Consumers uses of fashion discourses and the appropriation of countervailing cultural meanings”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 25, March, pp. 139-53. Thompson, C.J. and Hirschman, E.C. (1995), “Understanding the socialised body: a poststructuralist analysis of consumers’ self conceptions, body images, and self care practices”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 25 No. 2, pp. 139-53. Thompson, C.J., Locander, W.B. and Pollio, H.R. (1989), “Putting consumer research back into consumer behaviour: the philosophy and method of existential phenomenology”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 16 September, pp. 133-46. Thompson, C.J., Locander, W.B. and Pollio, H.R. (1990), “The lived meaning of free choice: an existential phenomenological description of everyday consumer experiences of contemporary married women”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 17, December, pp. 346-61. Turner, B. (1981), “Some practical aspects of qualitative data analysis: one way of organising the cognitive process associated with the generation of grounded theory”, Quality and Quantity, Vol. 15, pp. 225-47. Turner, B. (1988), “Connoisseurship in the study of organizational cultures”, in Bryman, A. (Ed.), Doing Research in Organizations, Routledge, London. Woodruffe-Burton, H., Eccles, S. and Elliott, R. (2002), “The effect of gender on addictive consumption: reflections on men, shopping and consumption meaning”, Gender, Marketing and Consumer Behaviour, Vol. 6, pp. 239-56. Further reading Anderson, P.F. (1986), “On method in consumer research: a critical relativist perspective”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 13, September, pp. 155-73. Annells, M. (1996), “Grounded theory method: philosophical perspectives, paradigm of enquiry, and postmodernism”, Qualitative Health Research, Vol. 6 No. 3, pp. 379-93. Atkinson, P. and Hammersley, M. (1994), “Ethnography and participant observation”, in Guba, G. and Lincoln, Y. (Eds), Handbook of Qualitative Research, Sage, Beverly Hills, CA. Bloch, C. (1996), “Emotions and discourse”, Human Studies, Vol. 16 No. 3, pp. 323-41. Calder, B. and Tybout, A. (1987), “What consumer research is”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 14 June, pp. 136-40. Chock, P. (1986), “Irony and ethnography”, Anthropology Quarterly, Vol. 52 No. 2, pp. 87-96. Hirschman, E. (1985), “Scientific style and the conduct of consumer research”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 12 No. 2, pp. 225-39. Srubar, I. (1998), “Phenomenological analysis and its contemporary significance”, Human Studies, Vol. 21, pp. 121-39. Strauss, A. and Corbin, J. (1994), “Grounded theory methodology: an overview”, in Denzin, N. and Lincoln, Y. (Eds), Handbook of Qualitative Research, Sage, Beverly Hills, CA.
The Emerald Research Register for this journal is available at www.emeraldinsight.com/researchregister
The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available at www.emeraldinsight.com/0309-0566.htm
Qualitative research in marketing Road-map for a wilderness of complexity and unpredictability Evert Gummesson
Qualitative research in marketing 309
School of Business, Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden Abstract
Received March 2003 Revised November 2003 Accepted January 2004
Purpose – To discuss and analyse three themes in qualitative research in marketing which are objects of both frustration and confusion: analysis and interpretation; theory generation; and a quest for scientific pluralism and individual researcher lifestyles. Design/methodology/approach – Underpinning the discussion is that complexity, ambiguity, fuzziness, chaos, change, uncertainty and unpredictability are characteristics of a market economy; that qualitative and subjective interpretation is necessary to add the spark of life to marketing data; and that general marketing theory needs more attention from researchers. Practical implications – The proper use of methodology and the generation of better marketing theory will make it easier for practitioners to reach the right decisions. Findings – Quantitative and qualitative research processes are not by nature antagonistic, although their advocates may be; quantitative methodology carries qualitative “bugs”, necessary for its sustenance. Originality/value – The article ends with a recommendation that every researcher in marketing should design his or her individual research approach, one that suits the personality of the researcher. As an example, the author presents his own current methodology-in-use, interactive research. Keywords Qualitative research, Marketing theory Paper type Conceptual paper
Marketing: established – but without clout? Let me begin with my perception of the current state of research in marketing. It can of course be argued against, but it can also be accepted as a vantage point for a scientific discourse. The purpose then is not to prove whether I am right or wrong, but to assess what value a journey from my personally chosen departure point can add to research in marketing. Marketing is an established discipline in business schools and an established function in enterprises, where, at best it is part of the corporate culture, at worst it is encapsulated in its own silo. But has marketing indeed got any clout in the boardroom and among top management? Very often marketing seems to be reduced to customer satisfaction studies and planning. Despite confessions to customer-orientation, my feeling is that the prime time of the CEO’s agenda is occupied by finance, accounting, and technology, most commonly information technology. On the academic side Brown (1993, p. 28) laments “marketing’s perennial search for academic respectability” and “the discipline’s lowly standing in a scholarly caste system”; and Piercy (2002, p. 352) argues that in research in marketing “. . . there is a pathology of mediocrity and a process of trivialization . . .which threatens its scientific status, its practical importance, and its future as a major part of business-school curricula”. I too have doubts about the contribution of marketing as an academic
European Journal of Marketing Vol. 39 No. 3/4, 2005 pp. 309-327 q Emerald Group Publishing Limited 0309-0566 DOI 10.1108/03090560510581791
EJM 39,3/4
discipline and the way research is performed. According to Alvesson and Willmott (1996, p. 128): . . . marketing is perhaps the subdiscipline of management to which critical theory (and related intellectual traditions) can contribute most, and yet it is also in this specialism that the influence of critical analysis is weakest.
310
Their approach is critical theory and Habermas’ (1972) “illusion of pure theory”, and the necessity to challenge the foundation of research and the societal consequences of its practice. A dialogue on the standing of marketing could also start with Kuhn’s (1970) conflict between mainstream science and paradigm shifts; DeBono’s (1971) vertical thinking versus lateral thinking; or Feyerabend’s (1975) doubts about the value of scientific methods. Saunders (1999, p. 85) succinctly expresses a solution: Quantitative methods take marketing from an art to a science, from conjecture to rigour.
This article is inclined to argue that: . being quantitative can contribute to raise the scientific status of marketing but is not sufficient; . quantitative methods cannot achieve scientific excellence without a clear awareness of their qualitative dependency; and . a merger of the best of both worlds – rather than a one-sided acquisition – will add substantial synergy to research in marketing. This resonates the words of Van Maanen (2000, p. x): Meaning and interpretation are required to attach significance to counts and classifications and these are fundamentally qualitative matters. The two approaches are then bound together, neither capturing truth alone nor trumping the other.
The theme of this article is qualitative methods, but seeing those as intertwined with quantitative methods; their shared ground – which is less noted than their differences – will be part of the discussion. Several questions could be raised about research in marketing and its contribution to academe, business practice and society. Do we really come up with results of any impact? Do we offer anything novel that also has practical relevance? Do we make things happen? Do we even react when things happen or do we just follow the “research as usual” daily routine? Where were we during the dotcom craze? How many warned and asked the simple but crucial questions about what the e-shopping advocates and trend gurus were peddling when their prophecies were so blatantly inconsistent? Is our voice heard in the current recession? Is research methodology with its techniques mainly producing trivial and shallow results with little import? This article cannot offer answers to all these questions, but it attempts to explore issues that I consider important for improving research in marketing and its relevance. From the many areas of qualitative research that could be discussed, I will limit myself to three that particularly engage my mind: analysis and interpretation; theory generation; and the individual researcher’s approach to science. Each in turn will be treated in the following sections.
Analysis and interpretation Marketing situations are not easy to grasp. It should be unnecessary to say that marketing decisions and actions are not just based on analyses of data, because data are mostly hard to find, hard to define, and they are incomplete. The reason I mention this is that there seems to be a scholarly dream that if we just do more research and collect more data (“get all the facts”) we will eliminate uncertainty and risk and make rational decisions. However, the real world does not allow this. The marketing manager entering 2003 suffered the aftermath of a brief passage of fast-growing dotcoms with skyrocketing stock prices on volatile exchanges, partly based on fraudulent information. The stock prices took a sharp dive and hit the ground. Soon after, the recently deregulated and more than 100-year-old telecommunications sector imploded and was left in severe crisis. The general economic and political climate facing the marketing manager was a long drawn-out recession; deregulation of markets turning out to be more irregular than expected; European Union expansion plans with unknown future effects on marketing; the business effects of global terrorism; and a host of other uncertainties. Although it is tremendously important how you collect data, it is just as important what you do with the data once collected. In reports based on qualitative research, data collection is usually described, sometimes at length, whereas analysis and interpretation stand out as the Achilles’ heel. Analysis and interpretations are part and parcel of the same issue: how to make sense of data. The term “analysis” is primarily associated with techniques and research designs that are explicit and rigorous and can be replicated by others, that is primarily quantitative research. Interpretation is more linked with qualitative approaches. Its process is not as explicit, transparent and orderly as in analysis, and replication is more difficult. Hermeneutics was once the science of interpreting biblical texts. In today’s research practice, hermeneutics is a general approach to interpretation. Marketing hermeneutics is perhaps not so far from the original application, considering the shopping and consumption evangelism of the modern market economy. Interpretation is a necessity in all human effort to understand the world and specific aspects of interpretation appear in all types of research, not only in qualitative approaches as will be shown later. Hermeneutics does not offer a set of rules for the researcher; it is rather a name for a conscious search for meaning and understanding. I am, however, inspired by the work of O¨dman (1985) and the guidelines he has worked out for hermeneutic research practice. Noting that researchers in marketing have difficulties in analysing and interpreting qualitative data, I have chosen to list a series of strategies that might be helpful in research practice. These can be extracted from manuals on qualitative market research, sociology, educational science and ethnography. More books are also appearing that apply qualitative methods specifically to research in management (for example, Remenyi et al., 1998; Easterby-Smith et al., 2002) and in marketing (for example, Carson et al., 2001). Instead of complying with the traditional article format of having a number of references to back up whatever I say, I have taken the liberty to merge literature with my own experience, and furthermore to mix philosophical issues with technical, handbook-like instructions. It is not until you have tried methods in research practice that they become a living reality.
Qualitative research in marketing 311
EJM 39,3/4
312
Strategies for qualitative analysis/interpretation In listing strategies I have not attempted to make a clear separation between analysis and interpretation as the two partly overlap: . Causality and understanding. Quantitative techniques are mostly used to try to pinpoint causality, usually between two or a few variables where the independent and dependent variables are defined. Qualitative methodology is primarily directed to understanding the complex and the elusive in a systemic perspective more than to establish unambiguous cause and effect relationships between single variables. It is built on the notion that life cannot be broken down into well-defined constituent components. Reality is more than the sum of its parts; there are also synergy effects. . Simultaneity and data generation. Qualitative research is characterised by data collection, analysis and interpretation in part taking place simultaneously, and tentative conclusions being drawn during fieldwork and the reading of archival records. I prefer the term data generation to data collection since data in a social environment do not consist of objects, which can be readily collected. Data are generated, meaning that they are the construction of the researcher. Even if data are taken from secondary sources such as statistical tables and annual reports, the researcher will have to assess and check their credibility, make a selection and combine them in formats chosen by the researcher, such as graphs or texts. Data are often created in interaction, for example, with a respondent in an interview. It means that even at this early stage of the empirical research, the researcher is engaged in analysis/interpretation; pure, value-free and complete description is the exception – if it exists at all. . Comparison. A key to qualitative research analysis is comparison. Data are compared with data, with existing theory, and with results from previous research. This continuous comparison is part of a sense-making process where patterns are formed and turned into concepts, categories and eventually theories. . Condensing data. To have access to an overwhelming richness of data is positive per se, but difficult when it comes to analysis. Therefore it is often said that we need to reduce data to make them manageable. The term is unfortunate as it may lure us to look for the average or the typical, thus rejecting variety and anomalies as exceptions. Instead we need to condense data, to make the same information more compact and manageable but not lose weight. . Transparency. A desirable property of scholarly research is that the reader can follow the actions and thoughts of the researcher. This may seem difficult to do with ordinary verbal language where verbal trickery may blur the real insights. A consolation is that formalised mathematical language is no guarantee for objectivity, and lying with statistics is a well-known and prevalent scam. Considering the large amount of data and links between them that are common in qualitative applications, for example, in case study research, as well as the researcher’s implicit paradigm, pre-understanding and tacit knowledge, it is often not possible to make all steps in the analysis transparent to the consumer of the research. This may feel uncomforting, but is a reality that we had better learn to live with constructively rather than sweep it under the carpet. It makes it
.
.
.
difficult, often even irrelevant, to try to fulfil requirements for reliability and replicability which is adamant in quantitative research and experiments. Techniques. The literature on qualitative analysis offers a smorgasbord of techniques to structure data, such as matrices and graphs (Miles and Huberman, 1994; Yin, 1994). Strauss and Corbin (1991) offer a stepwise approach to qualitative analysis inspired by grounded theory, and books on grounded theory give instructions for analysis (Glaser, 1978). Next to being supervised by a researcher who is experienced in implementing qualitative analysis, reading other researcher’s reports where the implementation of projects is accounted for is recommended. In Bryman and Burgess (1994) researchers tell how they implemented qualitative projects, and Glaser has compiled several readers of grounded theory projects (see, for example, Glaser, 1993). Computer software. Software can store data in an orderly way, provide structures and hierarchies of data, perform certain analytical tasks and respond to questions that the researcher puts to the data, thus facilitating the life of the qualitative researcher and increase research productivity (see, for example, Bazeley and Richards, 2000). Software assists, but does not take over the human researcher’s role as analyst/interpreter and the need continuously to fine-tune analytical/interpretive skills. This conclusion is just as valid in quantitative research which will be explained further with the help of “The research edifice” (see Figure 1). Intuitive and experiential – but systematic and rigorous. Rigorous research techniques need to be combined with such human qualities as intuition, common sense, experience, sound judgement, wisdom, insights, tacit knowledge, empathy
Qualitative research in marketing 313
Figure 1. The research edifice
EJM 39,3/4
314
.
.
.
and ethics. It is not only in exceptional cases that research can be irrelevant and erroneous and thus harmful if the human aspect is overlooked. In qualitative research the researcher remains the most important instrument and whether we acknowledge it or not, analysis/interpretation is dependent on the individual’s intuition. Intuition is often scorned at as anti-science, but good intuition means that we quickly process and synthesise data and draw conclusions based on the enormous masses of data and synapses (linkages) which are stored in our brains. Intuition can of course harbour bias, but that is also true with other techniques for analysis/interpretation. In our daily efforts to get on with our lives, we keep interpreting events. What then differentiates research practice from mere personal day-to-day practice? The difference is rather a matter of degree and transparency. It is high time to merge the systematic and overt procedures of western science with the methods of handling experiences. All is data. Hermeneutics in a broad sense can be applied to all types of data. In the flow of spoken and written words and numbers, symbols, observations, feelings and thoughts, interpretation becomes an integral part of a marketer’s daily life. Marketing hermeneutics can help us find meaning and it mirrors what a marketer does in his or her practice. Hermeneutics is also concerned with the interpretation of subtle expressions of human life, where the researcher tries to transform tacit knowledge into words. Nonaka and Takeuchi (1995), with reference to Japanese industry, have stressed the importance of making tacit knowledge explicit. In comparing the US and Japanese knowledge strategies, Cohen (1998) notes that the Japanese focus is on tacit knowledge and the nurturing of knowledge cultures and communities instead of as in the USA on explicit knowledge, projects and measurement. Linestone and Zhu (2000) note that the combined perspectives of the East and the West can offer insights that could not be obtained by just applying one of the perspectives. Both perspectives are necessary to address the variety and complexity of systems such as corporations and marketing networks. By not only merging western science with western common sense, but also with eastern philosophy we can arrive at a higher state of knowledge than by just applying either of these. The hidden agenda. All research builds in part on assumptions and restrictions that established researchers share – intersubjectively, not objectively – through tradition or agreement. In the extension of interpretation, hermeneutic processes also embrace the researcher’s paradigm, pre-understanding, understanding and contributions to explanation. Pre-understanding is what we know about the phenomenon of study when we start out on a research expedition; understanding is the (hopefully) improved knowledge that we come up with as a result of the research. Explanation is usually claimed to require unambiguous cause and effect relationships established through numbers, but as business life is in many ways ambiguous, less definitive and more transient explanations are required in practice. The hermeneutic helix. This is an expansion of the hermeneutic circle; the helix version bringing more dimensions in focus. Going from a circle to a helix we introduce advancement, moving research frontiers upwards, not just staying on the same level. We move from pre-understanding to understanding on a higher
.
.
.
.
level; we move from parts to the whole and to parts again, but now with greater understanding; and we move back and forth between the substantive, specific level to the abstract and general level, each time stretching ourselves along the helix. There is thus interaction between what we knew and what we have just learned, between slices of data and a systemic whole, and the concrete and the abstract. We can only give meaning to parts if we can put them in a context, a theory. We interpret and re-interpret data in a continuous trial-and-error process of both theory generation and theory testing. Through this process, qualitative research is not just left to generate theory, but it also tests theory in the sense of constantly improving its validity. Evaluation of sources. Researchers in marketing should be more critical to data and their sources – but in a constructive spirit. Newspapers and gossip are unreliable sources that need to be double-checked, we are aware of that. It seems to be less understood that official statistics can be a pack of lies, defined for a specific political or business purpose and compiled under a series of assumptions that are not known to the user of the statistics. Interviews with CEOs, marketing directors, consultants and politicians are often misleading, as they are speaking for their sake. Annual reports and accounts as well as statements from financial analysts can be outright deception, not just in such spectacular cases as in 2002 in Enron, Arthur Andersen and many other companies throughout the world. The dazzling elegance of statistics and the equally dazzling eloquence of words can communicate almost anything that has been asked for by a client, a political party or a company. Without sound judgement and ethics, the rigour and systematic modus operandi of researchers, does not become knowledge but ignorance, albeit rigorous and systematic ignorance. Full report. Data should be accounted for in a transparent, thick, rich and complete way and contradictory data must not be left out. This strategy takes readers closer to reality, but a mere detailed description is not sufficient; the account must offer conceptualisation and condensation or the researcher has not contributed interpretation and meaning. Alternative interpretations. To increase credibility, the researcher should offer possible alternative interpretations and argue both for and against them. As marketing reality is often complex, there is a shortage of simple cause and effect explanation between well-defined independent and dependent variables; there are multiple, sometimes innumerable, possibilities. When causal explanations are straightforward, however, they should be dealt with accordingly. Privileged bias. Two privileges influence interpretation. One is the privilege to define the problem to be researched. In an ideal and free academy this should be the privilege of anyone, but in reality a PhD candidate is dependent on the preferences of the supervising professor and the research culture of a university department. The professor in turn is dependent on the preferences of evaluation and grant committees, companies and governments that control the money. The other is the privilege to interpret the research. Who draws the conclusions and who has the credibility or power to endorse a certain interpretation and publish it?
Qualitative research in marketing 315
EJM 39,3/4
316
Enter the research edifice “The research edifice” in Figure 1 structures analytical/interpretive and objective/subjective phases, underscoring the omnipresence of the qualitative in research and the dependency of quantitative research on qualitative features. The qualitative bug is there; in fact, you do not have much choice as there is no pesticide to kill it without serious side-effects. It is a benign bug though, and you will find it to be a necessary part of the ecology of social life – once you accept it on its own terms and do not see it as a threat. Let’s sneak into the building through the basement. The basement. All research starts with a foundation of the researcher’s paradigm and pre-understanding. Here we make a mix of subjective, intersubjective and objective choices and assumptions such as what to research, which research questions to ask, how to find an answer, and in marketing that a market economy is better than a planned economy and that competition spawns innovation, productivity and low prices. These are mainly qualitative assumptions representing our interpretation of the world. They can be very personal but also be embedded in a specific research culture and discipline and be influenced by objective knowledge. The middle floors. If we press the lift button to the middle floors of the research edifice, we find ourselves confronted with data generation and analysis/interpretation. If the researcher chooses to do a quantitative study, a goal is to be explicitly systematic and rigorous, with little subjective influence on the research by the individual researcher or the team. Accompanying this process are, however, both intersubjectively agreed assumptions and choices, and subjective judgement call. On these floors, data should also be conceptualised and compared to theory and other research. If the goal is theory generation, the researcher has to conceptualise the data and compare them with extant models and theory, or they remain mere description leaving the finishing interpretive touch to the reader and listener. If it is a quantitative survey the questionnaire and its scales, response alternatives, sample, the collection of incoming questionnaires, and the registration and analysis of data can be rigorously handled, but still give rise to judgement calls and interpretation. One example of pseudo-objectivity in data generation and analysis is offered by surveys in which questionnaires are sent to businesses to find out, for example, how their marketing planning is done, how their customer relationship management (CRM) systems are working, how their key account managers operate, or what product or service development they will offer in the future. A lower and lower response rate of 10 per cent or even less is currently considered adequate – but only intersubjectively, not objectively. The resulting slices of data are accepted as amenable to statistical treatment. The explanation for accepting low response rates is that: . it is difficult to get businesses to reply; and . if you send out enough questionnaires you get a lot of data to process anyway; and that there is (after some additional checks) nothing to indicate that the data are skewed and not representative of the studied population. If instead qualitative case study research is performed, there will usually be little numbers and statistical conjecture (note, though, that case study research does not exclude quantitative elements). By doing case studies and applying various data generating techniques – all the way from reading texts to in-depth interviews, ethnographic observation and action research – complex and ambiguous issues can be
penetrated. The rigour may not be as obvious as with quantitative methods but it can still be substantial. However, this kind of research would require much more personal and subjective interpretation of data, a necessity in order to attract and accept the wealth of data that complex, chaotic and unpredictable markets offer. The penthouse. The last stop is the top floor, the penthouse. We are now as close to the sky as we can get in research. Here the research data, results and conclusions are presented, traditionally in written, oral and visual form. Even if it is pure academic research and the focus is on balanced and reflective conclusions, it might also include more speculative, innovative results. If the research is focused on practical action, the researcher could make recommendations and then those concerned have to make decisions, execute decisions, monitor the outcome, and make amendments. Whether the research is aimed to theory generation or to consulting to help solve a specific problem, interpretation is required. There were no simple, exclusively objective formulas to be found in the basement, and the dilemma returns in the penthouse. In fact, the results from our current research should ideally contribute to a more solid foundation of the research edifice and become part of the basement of future research. In summary, Figure 1 shows that the totally systematic and objective pursuit of the truth is a myth. The systematic and objective part is only a fraction of the research, albeit sometimes a pivotal fraction. In this sense it is immaterial whether research is qualitative or quantitative. Generation of marketing theory Four observations in particular have prompted me to bring theory generation into focus. First, theory generation is more often the outcome of a conceptual and qualitative process, whereas theory testing is more associated with empirical, quantitative hypotheses testing. Strange as it is to me, hypotheses testing has been placed on the highest level of scientific excellence in social sciences, including academic work in marketing. Second, researchers in marketing seem to settle for theory on a low level of abstraction or generality and have difficulties seeing the broader, systemic context; the core of a phenomenon is obscured by details and fragments. Third, researchers seem to get stuck in the middle, neither being firmly based in real world data, nor reaching a sufficient level of abstraction. Fourth, researchers are also stuck in the past and an unwarranted notion that theory advancement is a cumulative process. Marketing theory must reinvent itself and be refined, redefined, generated, and regenerated – or it will inevitably degenerate. Much of marketing knowledge resists time and change and should be retained; much is obsolete or was never up to par and should be dumped, and much is not yet discovered. This is in line with Kuhn’s (1970, p. 169) statement that new paradigms “usually preserve a great deal of the most concrete parts of past achievement and they always permit additional concrete problem-solutions besides”. This, however, is misunderstood by many. A paradigm shift, even if the new paradigm includes elements from the past, is not an incremental change based on the bulk of previous literature; it is a new foundation. It is the job of the scholar to separate the chaff from the wheat and not keep the established or accept the new just because it appears in certain journals or comes from the writings of currently popular “masters”. Even if the new is contrary to our beliefs, vested careers and interests, and poses a threat and initial frustration, we should receive a paradigm shift with enthusiasm rather than with apprehension. Schumpeter’s
Qualitative research in marketing 317
EJM 39,3/4
318
(1950) famous demand for creative destruction through innovation seems universal and applicable to marketing theory, too. My general stance is that theory in marketing is not really developing beyond conventional concepts, piecemeal models, current events and success stories (Gummesson, 2002a). The outcome is a world of “textbook theory“ that is taught in business schools. Textbooks are too quick to jump on the hype, for example dotcom, e-shopping, and software-based CRM. They are too slow to merge – not just list or add in a paragraph or note – fundamental, long-term developments, for example, services marketing, business-to-business (B2B) marketing, and the philosophy of relationship marketing, with already existing marketing management knowledge. Research in marketing is often limited to collecting standardised data on consumers, competitors and others without getting beyond statistical or verbal description. To earn the label “marketing intelligence” the research must include informed interpretation, conceptualisation and theory generation. To me it stands out as increasingly important that researchers help to interpret what is happening in the market and in the application of marketing strategy, not least in today’s high-velocity economy. Marketing metrics with relevant indicators can assist, but they are primarily historical and rarely self-sufficient and future-oriented. Their predictive capacity rests on certain assumptions, and qualitative interpretation is indispensable. We need theory to condense reality to something comprehensible so that we can adapt and manage. That is what theory does – when it is good. I should like to draw special attention to two key issues here: conceptualisation and contextualisation. They are interwoven and stress different aspects of theory generation. Concepts are needed, and in times of major changes new concepts – reconceptualisation – are urgently needed. There is a common mix-up between the term, which is a label, and a concept, which is an idea and the content behind the fac¸ade provided by the label. This mix-up is referred to as reification, mistaking the representation of an object for the object itself. Re-labelling is not the same as re-conceptualisation although branding and re-branding are used in marketing to create perceptions among customers about the content of a product or service, sometimes linked to improvements, but sometimes without altering the content. A postmodern marketer, though, may claim that the customer’s perception of the brand is the reality and that the real reality is unreal. An old term in marketing theory gives the reader associations to the old, even if the content is revised or new. For example, to understand services it is not sufficient to compare it to goods, which has so far been common (Lovelock and Gummesson, 2004). Services are treated with the use of goods terminology, and are defined in comparison with goods. This does not give room for understanding services on their own premises. It turns out, however, that it can be difficult to introduce a new term to represent a new concept and it seems quite accidental if the term is accepted or not. Contextualisation refers to the need to place single data in a broader context, that is, generate theory. Theory orders data in a context. A theory is a roadmap and a good roadmap makes it possible to navigate in a territory that is unknown to the traveller. When conceptualisation has taken place but not been extended enough to provide a context, bits and pieces of knowledge risk to be misunderstood and misused. Customers do not live isolated lives and consume one service or product at a time as if these were stand-alones. Customers live in a context. They consume a mix of many
goods and services in all sorts of combinations. If I am treated well in a store I am likely to go back. If the taxi driver to the hotel was unpleasant, I will be in a bad mood entering the hotel and that will affect my behaviour and my perception of the hotel. Theory generation, moving from raw data and description to conceptualisation and contextualisation, may be the most valuable contribution a scholar can offer. As researchers in marketing we are rarely if ever innovators; we rather start out as observers and messengers. However, it is not enough to be reporters of events. We have to add value to the phenomena we present; that is what scholarship is all about. One of Glaser’s (2001) latest books is specifically concerned with the move from description to conceptualisation. The further discourse is linked to Figure 2, a structure of the route from mere description to conceptualisation, from slices of raw substantive data to contexts of increasingly abstract, formal and general theory. The ensuing text will take the reader through the figure. The general framework of the figure starts at the bottom with real world data and a process to generate substantive, specific theories within a limit area of application. In the next phase, these areas are synthesised to a higher level of abstraction and theory of more general application is tentatively formed. The generated theory is compared with other theories that the researcher considers have an affinity or can add a contribution. The process goes on in alignment with the hermeneutic helix towards higher abstraction and generality. For the purpose of illustration, the general framework is clad in my own research in marketing, where the heavy parts are marketing management with services marketing and relationship marketing/CRM at its core, and with input from other relevant research. It starts with service research based on data from different service areas. The data are categorised and conceptualised, forming the beginnings of specific theories: a theory for the marketing of professional services, another for e-services, and so on. These theories in turn are merged into a general theory of services marketing, which later becomes one of several inputs to a theory of relationship marketing/CRM. This is en route to a general theory of marketing and a theory of management. However, the journey as such may be the significant result as long as the journey is guided by vision and commitment. To add to the realism of research, many iterations in the spirit of the hermeneutic helix may be required. If you start inductively with the raw real world data and move on the way up to becoming more general, you will have to dive down again to connect with the descriptive level. There is an ever-present risk that pre-defined categories may not be adequate because they are not properly grounded in the real world and thus are not a valid representation of the studied phenomena. If you start on the abstract level, you have no lifeline to the ground. Soon you hover freely in thinner and thinner air. Unfortunately, when theories are not well grounded, going back and test is not enough; because of the preconceived hypotheses, concepts and categories the test may just become a self-fulfilling prophecy. Is research in marketing really climbing a generality ladder, or does it stay put on the substantive level? Maybe not even that. Because of too superficial contact with reality, it may just stay put on a medium conceptual level with little contact upwards and little contact downwards. What is called marketing management today has its origin in consumer goods marketing of packaged mass products in the USA. It moved up from
Qualitative research in marketing 319
EJM 39,3/4
320
Figure 2. The route from specific description to increasingly general theory
substantive data to a certain level of abstraction and claimed to be general marketing theory. From that point it tried to force, for example, services and B2B marketing into its theory, thus missing the substance of these areas. When services marketing and B2B marketing through research based on real world data, extracted relationships, networks and interaction as core variables, these areas were marked as special cases, despite the fact that they constitute the bulk of all marketing. Later relationship marketing and CRM where labelled a special case, whereas in my view they offer a paradigm shift (Gummesson, 2002b). By generating theory continuously and following the format of the hermeneutic helix there is no strict distinction between generating and testing theory. If the researcher is guided by a desire to understand more and improve theory continuously, the never-ending journey becomes a continuous test of ever-tentative theory. Invitation to scientific pluralism and individual methodologies-in-use In my view, no one could ever claim that he or she has found the golden key to knowledge and science. They are elusive phenomena. We have to respect that; that is their karma and lifestyle. We are therefore in an eternal dilemma, constantly having to ask the questions: What do we really know? What is it worth? How do we get to know more? This ongoing journey is a fascinating treasure hunt for many but for others it is the avoidance or assassination – a scary monster. We probably all would like law and order and simplicity and security. To get that, however, we will have to do away with the magic of life and convert science to a set of regulations. In the process we restrict the scientist – the discoverer and entrepreneur – to a controlled and manageable bureaucrat heeding pre-set routines. But new knowledge should not be a threat even if it temporarily might shatter our careers, received theories and beliefs. The genes of researchers differ and so do researcher experiences, incentives and motives. This variety of researcher personalities offers science a disparate army of two-legged, individual paradigms. To me this is preferable to what I perceive as progressively stronger power demonstrations from established mainstream professors, promotion and grant committees, quality and ranking agencies to beget a centipede paradigm where all 100 feet march in the same direction. With a pluralistic strategy we will develop a diverse community of individual “knowers”, offering a medley of “processes of knowing” and consequently a variety in what is “known” (to use the Samitha concepts from the ancient Vedic culture; see Gustavsson (2003) and Zhu (2003)). In my view, pluralism is the only way to keep science alert, innovative and entrepreneurial. In marketing terms, it is the same as saying that a free market of science is likely to function better than a planned command economy. Interactive research: a two-legged paradigm illustration Here is an example of my personal choice of methodology – a two-legged paradigm. It is an example and not the doctor’s orders; use it if you find it appealing or compose your own methodological symphony (for a fuller account, see Gummesson (2001)). My experience of marketing and research is derived from a wide range of roles: being an around-the-clock consumer in a commerce-centric society; doing scholarly research and reading that of others; doing market research for companies as a consultant; designing and implementing marketing strategy; being a buyer of market research data and strategy advice from consultants; using market research data as
Qualitative research in marketing 321
EJM 39,3/4
322
input to decisions and action; and seeing how market research enters management processes, not seldom as part of internal politics rather than for rational decision making, planning and action. From these experiences I have arrived at a synthesis of research that I have found to be meaningful for me. I have chosen the label interactive research for my current methodology-in-use, the reason being that interaction has stood out as its core variable. Progressively my mindset has adopted a view that life, including both marketing methodology and theory, can be seen as networks of relationships within which interaction takes place. Instead of searching for strict and partial causality, I search for the understanding of a systemic whole, a context, with individual and complex patterns of interactive relationships. Important guidelines throughout my research are close access to reality – which requires researcher involvement – and validity of results. Interactive research embraces five components, which will be briefly reviewed in the next paragraphs. Case study research. This is my overarching approach. In case study research one or several cases are used to arrive at specific or general conclusions about certain phenomena, recognising the multitude of variables, complex interrelations and ambiguities of business life. Case study research provides the researcher with an input of real world data from which concepts can be formed and propositions and theory can be tried. A case study could be primarily inductive where the case provides data for conceptualisation and theory generation, or primarily deductive where cases are used to test existing theory. Case study research is systemic and holistic, aimed to give full and rich accounts of the relationships and interactions between a host of events and factors. It becomes largely interpretive. Quality criteria for quantitative studies, such as reliability and representativeness, cannot in general be applied to case study research. For example, a general rule for the number of cases needed to draw conclusions cannot be set up. The sample is theoretical and purposeful, looking for cases that give maximum information, and preferably be guided by saturation, the point where no or little new information is added. A single case study of a successful launch of new technology not only helps us understand the specific case, but also can teach us general lessons about marketing. For an extensive checklist of quality criteria for case study research, see Gummesson (2000, pp. 185-8). Inductive research and grounded theory. Simply put, inductive research lets reality tell its story on its own terms and not on the terms of extant theory. I have found inductive, empirical research a great source of inspiration, especially the strategies of grounded theory as developed by Glaser and Strauss (see Glaser, 1978, 2001; Locke, 2001). Grounded theory strives to be realistic and valid. To start a theory generating research project by first designing clear-cut categories and criteria in a complex and dynamic domain like marketing can severely impede our perception. But isn’t the researcher’s paradigm and pre-understanding – the basement of the research edifice – the capital of the professional’s work? It may seem odd to ignore existing knowledge to be able to receive new knowledge; we are used to hear that knowledge is cumulative and that what we do must have support in previously published journal articles. Viewing all knowledge as tentative, however, researchers have to train themselves to listen to reality without preconceived ideas. At a later phase the results can be
compared with existing concepts and theory and will thus proceed as an interplay between the inductive and the deductive. Grounded theory concepts and guidelines are clearly underused in marketing. All are not necessarily unique but they have been coherently ordered and reached a high degree of completeness in combining theoretical sensitivity, memos, comparative analysis, theoretical sampling, saturation, open and selective coding, the identification of core variables, and the generation of specific and general theory. Marketing anthropology. The prevailing qualitative research strategy in marketing is verbal data from personal interviews and surveys. In anthropology/ethnography data are generated through direct or participant observation, supplemented by interviews and conversations. The research is systematic and in-depth, documented not only in field-notes, but also in photos, films, audiotapes and artefacts. To make anthropology operational in a business setting, an adapted variant could be called corporate anthropology, or for marketing-specific applications marketing anthropology. Characteristic of true anthropology is the long periods over which a culture is studied – several months or years – as compared to the minutes or hours allocated to interviews and self-administered questionnaires. When a company and market is local and accessible, the researcher can be reasonably present and register what happens. Companies that operate in many locations and time zones require careful selection of the points of observation. Their marketing and sales staff is more often on the road or in the air, in hotels, and at their client’s premises, than they are at their home base. In consumer research – for example, to find out how people really eat breakfast or watch television – the true and complete behaviour can only be observed by being there, or let cameras act as “spies”. Marketing action research. In a job we get professional experience, perhaps 40 hours a week. As consumers we live in a marketing laboratory 24 hours a day. Action research entails dialogue and reflection based on data from experience through active involvement in the process being studied. It is akin to introspection found in postmodern consumer research and self-ethnography is an introspective and reflective extension of participant observation, but its scope is broader. We are actors, we make decisions and we have to face the real life consequences. But data formed through experience are sparsely used as empirical input in research, mainly because the method is unknown or off putting to the conventional researcher who favours detached research and is suspicious of subjective data. Action research gives rise to reflection, an inner dialogue. To paraphrase terminology from CRM: through systematic research based on personal experiences we can build data warehouses and models for future datamining. Involvement gives better access to data than detached research. To claim that involvement and the use of the researcher’s personality and subjectivity makes the researcher corrupted by the phenomenon under study and thus biased, and that the detached researcher is objective and uncorrupted, is no more than a subjective assumption. The scientific quality of subjective reflection and introspection is dependent on the researcher’s personal maturity and professional skills. The experience of a single researcher, however reflective and introspective that person may be, is usually not sufficient, although it has the advantage of datamining from close access. Data could be mined parallel to a dialogue with others and their experiences. The term action research is reserved for situations when researchers assume the role of change agents of the processes and events they are simultaneously studying.
Qualitative research in marketing 323
EJM 39,3/4
324
We have that role both as consumers and when working in organizations. Management action research is an application to the study of business phenomena, and a subdiscipline could be named marketing action research. The action researcher does scholarly research and is both an academic researcher and either a marketing practitioner or an external consultant. His or her purpose is twofold: to contribute to science and to help solve a practical problem. By being involved, the object of study creeps under the skin of the researcher in a way that is not possible in the study of documents or in interviews, even in participant observation. The access is as close as can be, and tacit and embedded knowledge can be uncovered. Further discussion on action research applied to management and marketing is found in Gummesson (2000), Coghlan and Brannick (2001), and a special issue of European Journal of Marketing (Perry, 2004); and for a review of introspection research, see Wallendorf and Brucks (1993). Narrative research. Narrative research is concerned with the ways “. . . in which social actors produce, represent and contextualise experiences through narratives” (Coffey and Atkinson, 1996, p. 54). Narratives are accounts – stories – about experiences, and they can take many forms. There is usually an initial state of affairs, then actions and events occur and there is perhaps a plot, and there is an end, at least a temporary end and more rarely the definitive ”and they lived happily ever after”. Narratives can be chronological but can also weave a web of events around various themes or concepts: story-telling. If marketing anthropology could be documentary that intimately reveals decisions, conflicts and actions – we even find this as entertainment in soap operas these days – narrative research is more of an epic film. By presenting research as a story, we avoid the fragmentation that is inevitable when we break down networks of events into abstract concepts and categories. Minett (2002) consults with B2B companies using cases of successful marketing to communicate with the general public and specific trades through the media, but also to help a selling company better understand its marketing. These stories must be told in a readable and condensed way or they will not get published, nor get read by practitioners. They become story-telling and an informed interpretation of reality, but not fiction. Story-telling in the research sense has close affinity to investigative journalism but with proper research and efforts to pin-point the essentials of reality, it becomes both a marketing tool and an input to general understanding of marketing. From a scholarly perspective such stories must of course be critically scrutinised as they are published in a company’s self-interest. But so must interviews and other data, not least official statistics, provided to researchers from companies or governments. Summing up Interactive research represents various interactions, such as between the researcher and the object of study and its actors; between your consciousness and qualities of your inner self; between substantive data and general concepts; between the parts and the whole; between words, numbers, body language and tacit language; between the researcher and audiences; and between data, analysis, interpretation and conclusions. The elements of interactive research all strive to reach a high level of validity. Interactive research perhaps only operationalises the best of common sense and sound judgement, adding a more systematic and transparent quality to everyday experience. It encompasses a string of strategies that are less