1111 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
...
53 downloads
728 Views
906KB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
1111 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
THE SEPTUAGINT AND HOMERIC SCHOLARSHIP IN ALEXANDRIA
1111 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
T HE SE P TU AGINT AND HO MERIC SCHO L ARSHIP IN AL E X A N DRIA A study in the narrative of the Letter of Aristeas
Sylvie Honigman
First published 2003 by Routledge 11 New Fetter Lane, London EC4P 4EE Simultaneously published in the USA and Canada by Routledge 29 West 35th Street, New York, NY 10001 Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2004. © 2003 Sylvie Honigman All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilized in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Honigman, Sylvie, 1965– The Septuagint and Homeric scholarship in Alexandria: a study in the narrative of the Letter of Aristeas/Sylvie Honigman. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. 1. Letter of Aristeas. 2. Bible. O.T. Greek – Versions – Septuagint. I. Title. BS744.A7H66 2003 221.4′8′09–dc21 2003046663 ISBN 0-203-49877-1 Master e-book ISBN
ISBN 0-203-57087-1 (Adobe eReader Format) ISBN 0–415–28072–9 (Print Edition)
1111 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
TO THE MEMORY OF CHARLOTTE ERMAN TO MY PARENTS
1111 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
CONTENTS
Preface and acknowledgements List of abbreviations
ix xi
1
Introduction
1
2
Genre and composition in the Book of Aristeas
13
3
The central narrative: the transfiguration of history into charter myth
37
Enforcing the narrative veracity: the rhetoric of historiography in the Book of Aristeas
65
The origins and early history of the LXX: guidelines for a reconstruction of the past
93
4 5 6 7
The Homeric paradigm: a hypothesis on the genesis of the LXX and the Book of Aristeas
119
Conclusion: the Book of Aristeas between two worlds
145
Appendix: outline of the composition of the Book of Aristeas Notes Selected bibliography Index of sources General index
149 151 191 199 203
vii
1111 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
PREFACE AND ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I first began to work closely on the Book (Letter) of Aristeas in 1995, when Laurence Vianès asked me to write the explanatory notes which were to accompany her new French translation (forthcoming in A. Caquot and M. Philonenko (eds), Écrits intertestamentaires, vol. 2, Paris: Gallimard). This gave me the opportunity to get acquainted with the current state of research. The survey of the relevant bibliography that I was led to make in the preparation of my notes convinced me that the study of the Book of Aristeas was suffering from the lack of a comprehensive monograph. The existing running commentaries were getting outdated in their bibliography and approach. Indeed, the very arrangement of running notes, with its necessary stress on synthesizing existing bibliography, seriously hampers a thorough revision of accepted views. After some time I decided to fill this gap. This was the genesis of the present book. First of all, I would like to thank Laurence Vianès, who led me to take a close interest in the Book of Aristeas. In the genesis and actual redaction of this book I have benefited from discussions and comments from many people. I am grateful to Martin Goodman, Christopher Pelling, Jonathan Price, Alison Salvesen and David Wasserstein, who read large sections of the book and provided both detailed and general comments which were valuable for their sharp insight and deep erudition. John Collins and Tessa Rajak read a preliminary outline of the book, and made important comments at this early stage of my work. Margalit Finkelberg read a chapter and provided detailed comments that helped improve it. I also wish to thank Susan Weingarten who, more than an English editor, was a thorough reader, and contributed numerous remarks and comments about both form and content, which were of considerable help. I have also benefited from long discussions with Sebastian Brock, Alison Salvesen, Tessa Rajak and Benjamin G. Wright III in the field of Septuagint studies. Their help was invaluable in many ways, and was provided most generously. Martin Goodman and Christopher Pelling also contributed many valuable remarks in oral discussions at various stages of my work. I have also profited immensely from reading unpublished ix
PREFACE AND ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
manuscripts that Alison Salvesen, Benjamin G. Wright III and Christopher Pelling kindly made available to me. Christopher Beall, Jean Duhaime, Noach Hacham, Sabrina Inowlocki, Avshalom Laniado, Anne Logeay, Andrea Rotstein, Aviram Tropper, David Wasserstein and Uri Yiftach discussed specific points with me, each in his own field. To them I owe many improvements of detail. I also wish to thank Oswyn Murray for the attention he paid to my work in progress. I was offered the opportunity to present my views on the Book of Aristeas in various lectures: by the Oxford Centre for Hebrew and Jewish Studies; by Martin Goodman, in his Seminar on Judaism in the Graeco-Roman era at Wolfson College, Oxford; by Robert Hayward and Loren Stuckenbruck, in their ‘Seminar for the Study of Judaism in Antiquity’ at the University of Durham, Faculty of Theology; and by Rabbi Jonathan Magonet in the Leo Baeck Institute, London. I would like to thank the participants at these venues and seminars who attended my lectures and contributed useful remarks in the discussions. Professors Hannah Cotton, Irad Malkin, Joseph Mélèze Modrzejewski, Zeev Rubin and Daniel R. Schwartz offered me their support in technical aspects that would eventually lead to the redaction and publication of this book. I would like to thank them for this. Last but not least, I would like to thank my family and friends, without whose constant and warm support this book would have been so much more difficult to write. The Israeli Academy of Sciences provided a generous research grant (grant no. 784/00) which allowed me, among other things, to hire three research assistants, Faia Babaiev, Giora Frenkel and Michal Molcho, whose help in all the technical tasks involved in my research was invaluable. The Oxford Centre for Hebrew and Jewish Studies granted me a Skirball Fellowship and offered me wonderful conditions of work during my five-month sojourn in Yarnton, Oxford. Finally, I am grateful to the Library of the Vatican for the authorization to reproduce the Byzantine illumination for the front cover.
x
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
ABBREVIATIONS
References to journals follow the abbreviations recommended by the Année Philologique. References to papyri follow J. Oates, E. Bagnall, W. Willis and K. Worp, Checklist of Editions of Greek Papyri and Ostraca, 3rd edn (BASP, Suppl. 4), Atlanta, 1985, available on the website: http://scriptorium.lib.duke.edu/ papyrus/texts/clist.html References to inscriptions follow the abbreviations of the Guide de l’épigraphiste: Bibliographie choisie des épigraphies antiques et médiévales, edited by F. Bérard et al., 3rd edn, Paris: Presses de l’École Normale Supérieure, 2000.
Note further: Austin: B.Ar.: Bible grecque des Septante, La: CMG: CIJ: C.Ord.Ptol.2: FGrH: Fraser:
M.M. Austin, The Hellenistic World from Alexander to the Roman Conquest. A Selection of Ancient Sources in Translation, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1983. Book [Letter] of Aristeas. G. Dorival, M. Harl and O. Munnich, La Bible grecque des Septante. Du judaïsme hellénistique au christianisme ancien, Paris: Le Cerf/CNRS, 1988. Corpus Medicorum Graecorum. J.-B. Frey, Corpus Inscriptionum Judaicarum, 2 vols (Sussidi allo studio delle antichità cristiane, 1 and 3), Rome, 1936–1952. M.-T. Lenger, Corpus des Ordonnances des Ptolémées, 2nd edn, Brussels: Académie royale de Belgique, 1980. F. Jacoby, Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker, Leiden: Brill, 1923–56. P.M. Fraser, Ptolemaic Alexandria, Oxford: OUP, 1972, 3 vols. xi
ABBREVIATIONS
GCS:
Die griechische christliche Schriftsteller der ersten Jahrhunderte. Hadas: M. Hadas, Aristeas to Philocrates, New York: Harper & Brothers, 1951; repr. New York: Ktav, 1973. Holladay: C.R. Holladay, Fragments from Hellenistic Jewish Authors, III, Aristobulus, Atlanta, Ga: Scholars Press, 1995. Lies and Fiction: C. Gill and T.P. Wiseman (eds), Lies and Fiction in the Ancient World, Exeter, Devon: Exeter University Press, 1993. Mras: K. Mras, GCS, Eusebius, Praep. Ev. 8, Berlin: Akademie Verlag, 1982, 2 vols. MT: Massoretic text. Parente: F. Parente, ‘La Lettera di Aristea come fonte per la storia del giudaismo alessandrino durante la prima metà del I secolo a.C.’, ANSP, serie iii, 21, 1972, 177–237, and 2/2, 517–67. Pelletier: A. Pelletier, Lettre d’Aristée à Philocrate (Sources chrétiennes 89), Paris: Le Cerf, 1962. RE: Pauly-Wissowa, Real-Encyclopädie der Altertumswissenschaft, Stuttgart, 1892– . Schürer: E. Schürer, The History of the Jewish People in the Age of Jesus Christ (175 B.C.–A.D. 135), vol. 3.1, revised edn by G. Vermes and F. Millar, Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark, 1987. Shutt: R.J.H. Shutt, ‘Letter of Aristeas, Third Century B.C.–First Century A.D. A New Translation and Introduction’, in J.H. Charlesworth (ed.), The Old Testament Pseudepigrapha, vol. 2, Garden City, NY: Doubleday & Co., 1985, pp. 7–34. Stern, GLAJJ: Greek and Latin Authors on Jews and Judaism, edited with Introductions, Translations and Commentary by M. Stern, vol. 1, From Herodotus to Plutarch, Jerusalem: The Israeli Academy of Sciences and Humanities, 1974. Studi ellenistici: B. Virgilio (ed.), Studi ellenistici II, Biblioteca di studi antichi, 54, Pisa: Giardini editori, 1987. Studies in the S. Jellicoe (ed.), Studies in the Septuagint. Origins, Recensions, Septuagint: and Interpretations. Selected Essays, New York: Ktav, 1974. Tcherikover, V.A. Tcherikover, ‘The Ideology of the Letter of Aristeas’, ‘Ideology’: HThR 51 (1958, 59–85 = Studies in the Septuagint), pp. 181–207 (first published in Hebrew in 1949).
xii
1111 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
1 INTRODUCTION
The work traditionally known as the Letter of Aristeas is not a letter at all. Its identification as a letter can be traced back to a fourteenth-century manuscript and no earlier.1 The mediaeval monk who was responsible for this denomination was no doubt led astray by the fact that the story is told in the first person. To make confusion even greater, the work opens with a personal address: the narrator is addressing a certain Philocrates, whom he calls his ‘brother’. However, the custom of dedicating a literary work to a nominal addressee was common in Graeco-Roman literature.2 This practice has nothing to do with epistolary formulae and, in fact, the work that concerns us here has none of the usual salutation formulae conventional in letters, both in their introduction and conclusion. Its length is also unusual for a letter – one of the few parallels that could be proposed of similar length, Alexander’s Letter to Aristotle about India is, in fact, a historical diegesis written in epistolary form.3 None of the ancient sources which mention our book refers to it as a letter. The author himself introduces his text as a diegesis (ch. 1), a term that simply indicates a prose account. Flavius Josephus4 calls it the Book of Aristaios. Epiphanius speaks of a syntagma, or ‘composition’, a term as vague as a diegesis. Eusebius refers to the book as On the Interpretation of the Law of the Jews.5 If our text is not a letter, then the traditional name by which it has been known in modern times is unsuitable. Of the ancient titles which are known to us, Josephus’ and Epiphanius’ are the most neutral. Josephus’ title will be the one adopted in the present study, with the proviso that the name of the (author)/narrator will conform to the spelling given by the document itself in its extant form. Werner Schmidt has argued on the basis of the extant testimonia that the original name was ‘Aristaios’, not ‘Aristeas’. The latter distortion was due to the influence of the name ‘Andreas’ which appears together with it in chs 19, 40 and 43.6 This conclusion would be plausible if our author were unknown. However, Oswyn Murray’s hypothesis that our author is identical with the Aristeas who was author of a work ‘On the Jews’, referred to by Alexander Polyhistor, is no less seductive.7 Thus, keeping to the now traditional name, ‘Aristeas’ will be a way of not choosing between 1
INTRODUCTION
the two spelling possibilities, ‘Aristeas’ and ‘Aristaios’. We shall speak of the Book of Aristeas and use the abbreviation B.Ar. throughout the forthcoming pages. A further problem concerns the name by which we should refer to the author of B.Ar. The label ‘Pseudo-Aristeas’ often used to refer to him is inappropriate, especially if we accept the opinion shared by most scholars that our author is otherwise unknown.8 If this is indeed the case, there is no Aristeas (or Aristaios) to whom to refer a Pseudo-Aristeas (or Aristaios). But even if we do accept the link with the historical Aristeas, Oswyn Murray has noted that the author ‘was inventing himself, not impersonating another.’9 The pseudo form is therefore not suitable in this case either. There is no reason, either, to confuse the author with the narrator by calling him ‘Aristeas’/‘Aristaios’. It will be best to resort to admittedly clumsy but at least neutral denominations such as ‘the author of B.Ar.’. Three things only are certain about our author, all derived from internal analysis of the text. To begin with, the content makes it clear that the author was Jewish. The verbal reminiscences of the Septuagint found in B.Ar. are unthinkable for a non-Jewish author in Ptolemaic times.10 Second, there can be no doubt that the author lived after the period of Ptolemy II, the time in which his story is set. How long after, however, is still debated. The only two safe landmarks we have are, on the one hand, clues in the text that the author was not an eyewitness, but wrote at least one or two generations later. In chs 28 and 182, the narrator speaks of ‘these kings’ (tois basileusi toutois). This locates our author under Ptolemy III (246–222) or IV (222/1–205) at the earliest, but does not preclude a later date. At the other end of the spectrum, a terminus ante quem is provided by Josephus’ paraphrase of B.Ar. in AJ 12.12–118, a work written about 90 CE. All possible solutions in between have been argued for in modern studies. Third, the place of composition must be Alexandria. The text is pervaded with royal Ptolemaic ideology related to the Alexandrian library, as will be made clear below (especially in Chapters 3 and 6). Furthermore, as will be argued in more detail in Chapter 4, the author makes fairly accurate use of technical vocabulary relating to institutions peculiar to Ptolemaic Egypt, while the description of Jerusalem is idealized and broadly fictional. Our author was clearly more familiar with Alexandria than with Jerusalem. The narrator in B.Ar., as distinct from the author, is a court official of Ptolemy II Philadelphus (285/2–246 BCE). In his account he tells of his embassy to the High Priest Eleazar in Judaea. He was allegedly sent there by Ptolemy, together with another ambassador, Andreas, in order to bring back an authoritative scroll of the Law of the Jews from Jerusalem to Alexandria. The King wished to have a translation into Greek based on a reliable version. B.Ar. is thus one of the oldest – in fact probably the oldest – source that tells us about the origins of the LXX. 2
INTRODUCTION
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
Understandably, the work was very popular in Antiquity, first among Hellenized Jews (Philo probably and Josephus certainly knew it and made use of it in their own writings) and later among the Fathers of the Church. We have no means of reconstructing the early oral tradition about the translation of the LXX that must have circulated among Alexandrian Jews from shortly after its completion, and therefore cannot know to what extent B.Ar. followed or modified it. At any rate, the story of the translation is told in B.Ar. in a manner which is both relatively sober and strictly rationalized. Only in subsequent versions does the story appear embellished with miraculous elements designed to confirm the divine character of the translation, and hence the divine nature of the LXX. This process is already discernible in Philo. In its literary form at least, the story thus seems to have taken on an increasingly legendary guise, and it may already have been like this at an early stage in the version that was circulated orally. Even though B.Ar. itself no longer met the need for the marvellous felt in popular circles, the importance of this text did not diminish with time. Although it was not included in the Christian canon, it was inserted into the Byzantine Bible, and in 1471 into the first printed Latin Bible, as an introduction recording the history of the sacred text. In more modern times B.Ar. underwent a dramatic reversal of fortune. Luis Vives in 1522 and Humphrey Hody in 1684 demonstrated that the author of B.Ar. was not the non-Jewish Greek eyewitness he purported to be, but must have been a Jew who, moreover, must have lived after the events he related.11 Once the ‘forger’ had been ‘unmasked’, B.Ar. was regarded with general suspicion and its value as historical evidence for the origins of the Septuagint was severely undermined. The intellectual context of the time certainly played against B.Ar. The Bible itself was by then coming under sharp re-examination. Doubts were being raised as to whether Moses really was the author of the whole Pentateuch. As is well known, the questions raised in this period of intellectual inquiry were the beginning of modern critical study of the Bible, with devastating consequences in the realm of religious belief in Western Europe. Being caught out as a ‘liar’, as B.Ar.’s author was now called, was no small matter in sixteenth- and seventeenth-century Western Europe, especially since B.Ar. had close connections with the Greek Bible.12 The credit enjoyed by B.Ar. was now, therefore, at its lowest ebb. The fate of B.Ar. in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries shows a curious blend of interest and suspicion. This work continued to be at the centre of scholarly interest, especially but not exclusively among LXX exegetes and theologians. The bibliography on it is very large – even if we discount the one or two much vexed issues that elicited huge discussions, such as the date of composition. At the same time, the low esteem in which the work had been held ever since Vives and Hody persisted. Unavoidably, suspicions of B.Ar. had practical consequences for the way scholars reconstructed the 3
INTRODUCTION
early history of the LXX. No longer bound by the version given in B.Ar., they felt free to take as their sole guide ‘common sense’ and personal credo. This was all the easier since virtually no other sources were available on the matter besides B.Ar. A new consensus crystallized on the origins of the LXX, stating that the translation ‘must’ have been initiated by the Jews themselves, not by a Ptolemaic king, ‘since’ ‘only’ Jews would be concerned to have their Law translated into the vernacular. The involvement of the king in B.Ar.’s version was deemed an unhistorical detail inserted in the story for apologetic reasons.13 B.Ar. was accordingly classified as apologetic literature – an opinion consistent with the definition of its author as a ‘liar’, or at best as non-serious.14 However, at the same time as the question of the historical reliability of B.Ar. was considered as settled – in the negative – as far as the origins of the LXX were concerned, the debate over the historical reliability of the text still raged around the realia that appear in it, either in the context of Ptolemaic Egypt or of Palestine.15 To this day, B.Ar. is regularly quoted in academic studies as evidence for the arrival of Jews in Egypt as slaves, on the basis of chs 12–14, and as evidence for Jerusalem in archaeological studies (chs 83–106). These are only the sections most often quoted in modern scholarship – there are many others.16 This dichotomy in the treatment of B.Ar. – dismissal of the central narrative on the one hand, and the use of specific details arbitrarily fished out of their context as raw material for historical reconstruction on the other – stems from a confusion between the notions of plausibility – modern plausibility – and historical reliability. In the case of the description of Jerusalem, reference to B.Ar. as a reliable source is clearly based on a confusion between eyewitness experience and reliable report. Not so long ago, scholars still debated as to whether the author of B.Ar. had made a journey or pilgrimage to Jerusalem, as if this could solve the issue of the value of his account from an archaeological point of view.17 It is, however, doubtful whether this dichotomy of treatment is justifiable. The use of specific sections of B.Ar. as historical evidence ignores the intention of the author in presenting the facts as he does. In other words, it ignores the literary dimension of the text. In recent years there has been a shift in approach. More scholars are ready to accept the version of B.Ar. regarding the origins of the LXX, with a few adjustments. This new attitude is, of course, consistent with the wider trend towards thorough reappraisal of previous readings of ancient texts which is currently affecting the field of Classical studies as a whole. The prevailing trend is to accept that the initiative for the translation came from the Ptolemaic court, as it says in B.Ar., and not from the Jewish community itself. That is, the first part of B.Ar.’s version is being rehabilitated.18 However, scholars, especially LXX students, are still reluctant to accept the second part, namely, that the translation was ordered for the royal library of Alexandria. They still infer that B.Ar. was written to benefit the Jews, 4
INTRODUCTION
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
undeterred by the fact that the text is absolutely silent on this motive. All it says is that Ptolemy wished to show favour to the Jews by ordering a translation of their Law (ch. 38), but this is presented as a side-effect of the main purpose, which is to provide his Library with the book.19 For a work usually deemed apologetic, this omission of the motive would be rather puzzling. However, scholars generally do not appear to feel the need to address this problem. Thus Dominique Barthélemy spoke of a ‘twofold result’:20 the King got a book for his library and a Law for the Jews. Only very recently have scholars begun to accept B.Ar.’s version in its entirety. Thus, after Dorival’s hesitant discussion, Wolfgang Orth and Tessa Rajak have argued assertively that the LXX made its way into the library.21 Orth typically argues with previous opinions on the basis of long-familiar sources only, making it clear that the interpretation of the sources is subjective and influenced by the status quaestionis of broader issues. These last studies thus take the psychological leap that most LXX exegetes, brought up on the view that the translation of the Bible into Greek was an exceptional event, are still reluctant to take: they ‘normalize’ the event by inscribing it in the broader context of Ptolemaic society. Unfortunately, the general reappraisal of B.Ar. that is currently under way is not always based on a reading of the sources which is as critical as one would like. Dorival, for instance, sketched a historical reconstruction of the circumstances of the translation based on an acceptance not only of B.Ar.’s version, but also on later patristic sources which ascribe the initiative to Ptolemy I, not II. Thus, according to Dorival, Ptolemy I initiated the translation at Demetrius’ instigation, and Ptolemy II integrated it in his judicial reform as a law for the Jews.22 This attempt to reconcile ancient Jewish and Christian viewpoints may be praiseworthy on other grounds, but it overlooks the basic principles of source criticism. Orth’s argument basically reflects a change in attitude. The various methodological flaws just emphasized are largely the outcome of the fact that studies dealing with B.Ar. address one question at a time, neglecting other aspects liable to affect the conclusions reached. The only way to tackle the issue of the historical reliability of B.Ar. for any given topic, whether it be the early history of the LXX or the location of the citadel in Jerusalem, is to deal with the text as a whole. This is also the only way to cast new light on pending issues whose resolution has been traditionally held as a prerequisite for a correct understanding of the work – like its dating, or the author’s original purpose. More importantly, however, the methodological approach needs to be revised. Modern research on B.Ar. has suffered from various problems. First and foremost, like all other works written by Jews in Greek, it has suffered from the setting up of a special category, the so-called ‘Judaeo-Hellenistic literature’. As a consequence of the invention of this category, the study of works 5
INTRODUCTION
written by Jews was divorced from the new work that was being done in the broader field of contemporaneous Graeco-Roman literature. With a few notable exceptions, classicists saw no reason to pay any attention either to B.Ar. or to any other ‘Judaeo-Hellenistic works’, while LXX exegetes and theologians, the two groups of scholars who felt primarily concerned with the study of B.Ar. until recently, have been very slow in realizing that the work of classicists and ancient historians could be of direct interest to them.23 New Testament scholars, however, have been prompter to realize the importance of the field of Classical studies for their own field of research. The kind of reappraisal that the present study intends to implement on B.Ar. has actually been under way for about two decades in New Testament studies. Scholarly understanding of the Gospels and Acts (Luke-Acts) has been considerably increased by the use of methods of literary criticism whose relevance for the analysis of ancient texts, especially ancient historiography, is now widely acknowledged. Thus, this general trend is increasingly pervading the various fields connected with the study of the literary output of the Hellenistic world, in the broadest sense of this word.24 It is high time to bring B.Ar. in tune with it. Perhaps it is not superfluous to dwell a little longer on the assertion just made about New Testament studies. Since the beginning of the twentieth century, this field of research has oscillated between claiming absolute originality for the Gospels and Acts, and the opposite endeavour of identifying literary parallels. However, the prevailing trend in the last two decades has been the abolition of any claim to uniqueness and the consequent reintegration of the various units of the New Testament in both their literary environment and their socio-cultural background.25 Compared to this new sweeping trend in New Testament studies, the field of the so-called ‘JudaeoHellenistic literature’ is still often conservative. This is all the more strange, since as far as the study of Jewish history in Hellenistic and Roman times is concerned, the growing trend is to get the Jews out of the imaginary cultural and religious ghetto in which scholars of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries tended to enclose them, and to underline their integration into their Hellenistic environment.26 The study of the literary output of these Jews is only slowly taking into account the implications that this new trend entails. The working hypothesis on which the present study will be based is that of the complete cultural integration of the Jews into their surrounding world. When we come to literary output, this means that there are no grounds to decide a priori that a text written by a Jew is basically different in essence from one produced by any other Hellenistic writer living in the same time and place. This applies not only to the literary forms adopted by a Jewish author, but also, it will be argued here, to the content. We must go beyond the traditional debate as to whether the Jewish author had polemical intentions against Greek culture, or, conversely, advocated ‘Hellenization’. As far 6
INTRODUCTION
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
as the literary modes of expression and, likewise, the way of thinking are concerned, Hellenization is there.27 The dialogue with the environment took place at a level more subtle than that. To be sure, differences in content may emerge between a text written by a Jew and one written by a Greek. It will, indeed, be argued in the following pages that the author of B.Ar. displays some originality in his writing. Innovations or, more modestly, peculiarities of form directly related to content will be pointed out. It is unsound method, however, to take for granted that these differences are the result of religious uniqueness. They must be explained through an ad hoc, matter-of-fact analysis. The basis for assessing B.Ar.’s conformity or originality in the field of Graeco-Roman – or, more accurately, Hellenistic – literature, and, more generally, the basis for assessing the nature of this work and the intention of its author, will be the correct identification of the literary genre to which it belongs. It will be argued in this study (especially in Chapters 2 and 4) that B.Ar. has close links with Hellenistic historiography.28 Reading B.Ar. in this light is essential for the reassessment of its inner literary logic and, needless to say, for a correct assessment of the issues of reliability versus untrustworthiness, and ‘truth’ versus ‘lies’. Some of the studies cited above make it clear that attempts at evaluating the reliability of B.Ar. as historical evidence are often based on a simple positivist reading of the text. Assessments of B.Ar.’s author as a ‘liar’ or as non-serious stem from the ignorance of the operation of the concepts of ‘truth’ and ‘lie’ within the culture in which the work was produced. Only an approach based on an analysis of these aspects can provide a new and more appropriate formulation of the issue of the historical reliability of B.Ar. The level of ‘reliability’ our author looked for suited the content and connotations that this concept was given in his own days, and his work must be appreciated against the standards accepted in Hellenistic historiography. Fortunately, studies on Classical historiography in the last few decades have considerably increased our understanding of this genre and its conventions. They have led, in particular, to a complete reappraisal of the standards of ‘truth’ which guided it. Current studies pay considerable attention to the literary dimension of historical writing, and to the relationship of the latter to ancient rhetoric.29 In light of these studies, it is clear that the author of B.Ar. resorted to all the rhetorical means which were commonly used by contemporary historians in order to enforce the reliability of their accounts. Pace Hadas, B.Ar. is a serious text. It does not tell any ‘lies’ either, if we know how to read it properly, that is, not from the standpoint of our own culturally determined prejudices. For all its importance, the comparison with Hellenistic historiography, in fact, falls short of accounting for all the features characterizing B.Ar. in both its rhetorical dimension and content – and we are touching here on the main feature of B.Ar.’s originality. While Hellenistic historiography could be 7
INTRODUCTION
sensationalist – it has even been compared to modern yellow journalism30 – B.Ar. is, in a sense, too ‘serious’ to be mere historiography. My contention here (to be developed in Chapter 3) is that the author of B.Ar. did not intend to write an account of past events merely for the sake of keeping them alive in the memory of generations to come. He aimed at endowing the LXX with a charter myth about its origins, with the purpose of giving the LXX the status of a sacred text. The identification of B.Ar. as a ‘charter myth’ is inspired by a seminal study on this text published in 1987 by Oswyn Murray.31 The notion of ‘charter myth’ will be discussed in more detail in Chapter 3. Let it suffice for now to recall that a charter myth is usually a myth aimed at legitimizing a social practice. In our case, the charter myth comes to confirm, or rather, using its own logic, to found, the status of the LXX as a sacred text, in fact the sacred text of Alexandrian Jews. B.Ar. builds up a story that aims at persuading its readers that the LXX or, rather, as we shall see, a specific manuscript of it (Chapters 3 and 6), is authoritative. ‘Myth’ is of course not to be understood in the sense usual in the realm of Classical studies. The myth we are concerned with in B.Ar. better meets the definition of ‘political myth’ familiar in the field of sociological studies. The latter identify this category of myths in every human society, usually beginning with the Roman Republic. There is no reason a priori to set the Hellenistic period, and even Classical Greece, outside this definition, as will be argued in Chapter 3. As already intimated, a correct reassessment of the historical reliability of B.Ar., both its main issue (the origins of the LXX) and more limited topics (like the history of the Jews in early Hellenistic Egypt, or the topography of Jerusalem), implies tackling B.Ar. as a whole. In other words, specific issues must be subordinated to a comprehensive and coherent (re-)reading of the work. This is not to deny that important reappraisals of B.Ar. have been formulated in papers that focused on limited points. But the multiplicity of limited reappraisals bearing on specific aspects in B.Ar. intensifies the need for a study that will build up an inclusive picture of the text through the harmonization and updating of the scattered new readings. Generally speaking, there is at present no comprehensive study of this sort which uses the methodological tools now commonly accepted in historical research. The purpose of the present book is to provide such a study. Of the existing editions, Moses Hadas’ translation with commentary published in 1951, and reprinted ever since without revision, remains by far the most valuable. In many matters, Hadas stressed the necessity of reading B.Ar. against the general background of Hellenistic literature. In this sense, the present study is heavily indebted to Hadas’ approach. Unfortunately, however, all the valuable remarks articulated in Hadas’ introduction remained curiously subordinated to checking the issue of the date, a stance which limited the scope of his study. Moreover, it is now possible, half a 8
INTRODUCTION
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
century later, to go further than Hadas did on most of the topics he dealt with. Although the 1962 edition by the French scholar André Pelletier offered an improved text and translation, his commentary unfortunately represents a regression to rather conservative views, bringing the text back to the realm of Jewish literature conceived of in isolation. Of the recent monographs of any length, that of Werner Schmidt is limited in scope and adopts a rather conservative approach.32 Norbert Meisner advocates the need for investigating B.Ar. from a wider perspective than that of LXX or theological studies, and for examining the work in its Greek context. However, he concentrates on the symposium, since his working hypothesis is that this section, the longest in B.Ar., provides the key to understanding the purpose of the work as a whole.33 A seminal study in the process of the reappraisal of B.Ar. was the fifteen-page overview published in 1987 by Oswyn Murray.34 Needless to say, the limited length of the paper makes it a preliminary study only. Moreover, although I owe to Murray some basic concepts central to my approach, especially the notion of ‘charter myth’, some of the conclusions of his paper are now more arguable. Although it is older, Victor Tcherikover’s ‘The Ideology of the Letter of Aristeas’, a paper first published in Hebrew in 1949 and in English in 1958, should be mentioned here, since it anticipated many of the conclusions that this book will seek to defend.35 As will be clear from the foregoing remarks, it is necessary to start our study of B.Ar. with an analysis of its genre and literary composition. Chapter 2 addresses these issues. In the absence of any surviving Alexandrian prose, comparison with Alexandrian narrative poetry will further lead to a reappraisal of the literary function of the so-called digressions and their raison d’être in the overall structure of the text. Chapter 3 focuses on the main narrative, as opposed to the digressions. It will be shown that the central story of B.Ar. is built up of two intertwined narrative paradigms – typically, one Alexandrian (linked to royal propaganda about the Library), and the other biblical (linked to the book of Exodus). The delineation of these narrative paradigms has important bearings on issues that go beyond genre and literary composition: both convey an implicit message and it is their combination that gives its real meaning to B.Ar. as a whole. In this sense, these narrative paradigms function very much like those of myths: the message is conveyed not through straightforward exposition appealing to the rational intelligence of the reader, but through a narrative illustration appealing more to the emotional register. It will be contended that these two combined narrative paradigms which both focus on the story of the LXX are responsible for turning B.Ar.’s account into a charter myth. Chapter 4 tackles the issue of ‘truth’ as this would have been understood by B.Ar.’s author and his readers. This chapter examines the rhetorical tools that our author resorted to in order to enforce the status of his text as a 9
INTRODUCTION
‘truth-telling’ story. B.Ar.’s affinities with Hellenistic historiography are emphasized. At this point, the discussion should have reached a clear view of B.Ar.’s intrinsic logic. This is, indeed, the indispensable prerequisite to the investigation of the value of B.Ar. as a potential source of information for reconstructing the early history of the LXX in a way that meets modern standards of historical research. The issue of the relation between ‘text’ and ‘historical past’ are addressed in the last two chapters of this book. Since any reconstruction of the early history of the LXX is bound to remain hypothetical, Chapter 5 has been conceived as a kind of preliminary step. This chapter reviews the various hypotheses about the origins and early history of the LXX currently debated among modern scholars. The aim will be to sort out those hypotheses, or aspects of them, which are definitely plausible and should be taken into consideration for further investigation, and those that would be better eliminated. The purpose of this review is to build up a kind of working framework, with the hope that it may serve as a basis for further investigation into the origins of the LXX. It will provide for the necessary flexibility of approach that a single, coherent and, inevitably, partly speculative reconstruction of a single scenario is, by its nature, unable to retain. The method of reappraisal proposed in this chapter will be the comparison of the various extant hypotheses with external data. By this I mean philological studies on the LXX, studies on various aspects of the society of Ptolemaic Egypt – directly or indirectly related to the Jews – all deriving from recent research in these fields. Chapter 6 spells out a new reconstruction of the circumstances surrounding the translation of the LXX and its early history, as well as a reconstruction of the circumstances surrounding the redaction of B.Ar. in the mid-second century BCE. It proposes that the many parallels drawn in B.Ar. between the translation of the LXX and the edition of Homer are meaningful. It will be argued that this pervasive comparison between the LXX and Homer reflects, above all, the perception that the Alexandrian Jews themselves had of the undertaking of the translation of the LXX. I further contend, admittedly in a more speculative way, that this perception, in fact, either influenced or reflected the way things were actually carried out. Any reconstruction of the early history of the LXX is bound to remain hypothetical, the one that will be proposed here no less than any other. Even though its historical value cannot be argued beyond plausibility, it is hoped that the reconstruction that will be proposed in this book will at least demonstrate that B.Ar.’s version of the early origins of the LXX may, indeed, serve as a basis for a historical reconstruction meeting modern requirements. At the very least, the present study hopes to demonstrate that a reconstruction that takes B.Ar. seriously is, on the whole, no less plausible and, therefore, perhaps more legitimate, than those which do not. 10
INTRODUCTION
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
Before proceeding further, it is indispensable for the clarity of the discussion to state beforehand the position that will be adopted in this book with regard to some basic issues. The conclusions stated here will be defended at greater length in the course of the study. •
•
•
•
The date of B.Ar.: The present study will adopt the dating which has been gaining wider acceptance in recent years: a date ranging from the middle to the later part of the second century BCE. This dating will be examined in more detail in Chapter 6. The date of the translation of the LXX Pentateuch: The reign of Ptolemy II will be accepted as a basis for the present study, and discussed in more detail in Chapter 6. ‘LXX’ will refer to the Pentateuch only in this book, unless otherwise stated. The subject matter and purpose of B.Ar.: The ancient sources (Philo, Josephus, Eusebius) see this as an apology for the translation. But what was this for, if the work, as scholars now agree, was written several generations post eventum? To this some answer that B.Ar. was aimed at defending the translation against new ones (some add: from Leontopolis), or at forestalling revisions of the text.36 An alternative answer, which has become generally accepted in recent years, is that B.Ar. was actually intended as a comprehensive presentation of Judaism.37 The discussion about the generic composition of B.Ar. in Chapter 2 will show that it is necessary to revert to the conservative understanding of our text: the subject matter of B.Ar. is the translation of the LXX. More precisely, B.Ar. is concerned with the quality of the translation of the LXX, a key element in the building of a charter myth for the LXX. As far as the subject of B.Ar. is concerned, the present study will thus revert to the older positions defended by Victor Tcherikover in 1949 and Harry Orlinsky in 1975, with the slight difference that these authors put the stress on the sanctity of the translation, not its quality.38 As it will be argued in this study, however, both these concepts are closely related. The audience of B.Ar.: The definition of B.Ar.’s account as a charter myth is inseparable from the view that the intended readership was Jewish – more precisely the Jewish Alexandrian elite. Some details in the text do indeed point to a Jewish readership in a completely unambiguous way, as will be seen in Chapter 2.
Inasmuch as the present study will propose a comprehensive and coherent re-reading of B.Ar., it will not include an exhaustive discussion of the previous bibliography, nor even come close to this. As already noted, the modern bibliography on B.Ar. is huge, even if we leave aside those studies which are unanimously considered outdated today. Addressing all proposed possible readings of this text in order to buttress the one advocated here would take us very far astray, and readers might become exhausted long 11
INTRODUCTION
before the bibliography is. The discussion below will, therefore, address the studies that seem to this writer to be more important or influential, or those that seem to her to be representative of an important historiographical trend in relation either to B.Ar. or to the issue of the origins of the LXX. The selection will be unavoidably subjective, but it is hoped that the historiographical discussion as it stands will provide enough contextualization for the positions advocated in this book. This is the place to acknowledge the debt owed by this study to the contribution of Elias Bickerman to the early history of the LXX in various papers, besides the studies on B.Ar. by Hadas, Murray, Orlinsky and Tcherikover already mentioned. The form of the names used in this book is as follows: the characters found in B.Ar. are treated as literary characters, and are distinguished from their historical counterparts by a capital letter. Thus, ‘King’ refers either to the character in B.Ar.’s story or, occasionally, in other literary stories, while ‘king’ refers to a historical figure from the Ptolemaic dynasty. Likewise, ‘Ptolemy’ refer to the literary character, while ‘Ptolemy I’ and ‘Ptolemy II’ refer to the historical figures. Beside the King, Demetrius the Librarian, Eleazar the High Priest and the Library are treated like literary characters or entities fulfilling a literary function, in Vladimir Propp’s sense of the word.39 For the sake of consistency, lower case letters will be used when referring to the historical museum and library in Alexandria, although they are usually written with a capitalized initial. In the case of ambiguity between fictional and historical characters or entities, the stress will be put on the literary dimension and the use of the capital letter will prevail. The citations from B.Ar. reproduced in this book are borrowed from R.J.H. Shutt’s translation, unless otherwise stated. Modifications bearing on the form of names will not be specified (e.g. ‘King’ for ‘king’).
12
1111 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
2 GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
Moses Hadas in his introduction to B.Ar. noted that this work ‘is a Greek book.’1 Indeed, B.Ar. occupies an exceptional place in Alexandrian literature, for it is one of the rare samples of Alexandrian prose writing to have survived complete. Almost all other Hellenistic prose works were swept away by the revolution in literary taste that took place in the late first century BCE.2 Literary critics and readers of the Roman imperial era continued to admire the Classical literature of the fifth and fourth centuries BCE, both prose and poetry, and to consider the poetry of the Archaic age as a major source for moral education. But Alexandrian and other Hellenistic prose was now deemed unworthy of imitation as a literary model. While some at least of the works of the major poets survived, Hellenistic prose was no longer copied. The fate of Hellenistic works written by Jews, however, was different. The Christian tradition took care to transmit them, not because of their style but because of their content. It is because of this peculiar situation that we now possess in B.Ar. a precious sample of Alexandrian prose writing, reflecting the typical sort of composition otherwise known to us only through poetical works, in particular narrative pieces like those of Callimachus or Theocritus. When trying to define B.Ar.’s genre and literary quality it is, therefore, important to set this work in its original Alexandrian context. A comparison with other Alexandrian works or, in their absence, with further Hellenistic works, may well provide us with satisfying answers to some issues that have been seen as problematic up to now, such as the purpose of B.Ar., and the status and role of the long digressions found in its text – as well as, incidentally, the intended readership. The composition structure of B.Ar. has been a major source of unease for modern scholarship. The translation motif occupies barely 50 sections of the text out of 322 (chs 9–11, 28–50, 121, 172–3, 301–16), and the actual deed of translation takes up only one (ch. 302). Thus, more than five-sixths of B.Ar. is taken up by mere digressions, a baffling proportion by modern standards. A tempting way to solve this problem, of course, was to try to prove that at least some of these ‘digressions’ were late interpolations. J.-G. Février, therefore, proposed in 1925 that there had been several stages of 13
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
redaction, with final completion only in imperial times.3 After this obsession with alleged ‘later interpolations’ became unfashionable among scholars, the clue to the explanation of the structure of B.Ar. was sought in a new comprehensive understanding of the text. In the last few decades, the argument that the real purpose of B.Ar. is not merely an apology for the translation but, more widely, a multi-faceted presentation of Judaism, has thus begun to crystallize.4 This new interpretation was also useful in that it solved a further major problem raised by the traditional interpretation of B.Ar.’s subject matter. Earlier modern studies took the subject of B.Ar. to be the translation of the LXX. More precisely, B.Ar. was understood to have been written in order to defend the LXX either against competing translations or from potential textual revisions. Whatever the case, B.Ar. was seen as apologetic. However, this definition of B.Ar.’s topic and purpose was an embarrassment from several points of view. First of all, identifying B.Ar.’s purpose as apologetic hardly accounts for the timespan of several generations which elapsed between the presumed time of the translation of the LXX and the date of redaction of B.Ar. Why write an apology for a translation from some two or three generations earlier? This point was, in fact, used by Paul Kahle to support his claim that B.Ar. was written to defend a translation that was made close to its own time, not in the days of Ptolemy II.5 The question was asked again recently from a different perspective by Gilles Dorival.6 The circumstances of the redaction of B.Ar. will be discussed in Chapters 5 and 6. Given its implications, the composition structure of B.Ar. needs to concern us first. As far as the so-called digressions are concerned, these must be appreciated in the context of the literary tastes of Alexandrian and Hellenistic literature: the principle of ring composition, the concept of poikilia – thematic and stylistic variation – and generic eclecticism. Conclusions about the aim of B.Ar. are also dependent on a correct assessment of the genre to which B.Ar. belongs. Thus, our analysis of B.Ar. must begin with the questions of genre and structural composition, beginning with the latter.
Poikilia and eclecticism With the beginning of Greek literary criticism in the generation of Plato and Aristotle, the first classifications were made of different genres, precise definitions were given for each one, and the boundaries and differences between the genres were made explicit. Even though this classificatory undertaking was, in fact, neither completely perfect nor absolutely systematic, literary criticism had by then become a matter of self-conscious and reflexive discourse. From now on literary genres were defined by written rules. The activity of a new generation of literary critics who were also practitioners in third-century BCE Alexandria, opened a new chapter in the history of Greek literature. Alexandria became the centre for major developments 14
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
in the tradition of literary criticism and creation. As L.E. Rossi has put it, while the Classical period was a time of ‘written and abiding rules’, the Hellenistic period was a time of ‘written, and non-respected rules.’7 The rules were evaded and broken in every way possible, with a high degree of consciousness and intentionality. Taking an anti-Aristotelian stance, the critic and poet Callimachus, a contemporary of Ptolemy II, advocated the exploration of ‘untrodden paths’ for the poet. By this he meant breaking the generic boundaries defined in the fourth century by Aristotle. The straining of already existing genres to their limits and beyond, the creation of new forms and the blending of genres characterize the new literary taste. Concomitantly, since the fourth century BCE, rhetoric had become a fundamental part of the curriculum of Greek advanced education. This remained true in the Hellenistic period and beyond.8 It is probable that already at an early stage handbooks of rhetoric had begun gathering and describing the various kinds of preparatory exercises, the progymnasmata, by which rhetoricians trained their pupils. The whole system remained more or less static throughout the subsequent centuries of Classical culture – as Francis Cairns has noted, Classical literature was a ‘time-free zone’.9 Thus, although the handbooks which have come down to us are relatively late, ranging from the late Republic to the fourth century CE, they can safely be taken to reflect earlier practices.10 These two different aspects, changes in literary taste and practice on the one hand, and the place of rhetoric as the common lore of educated people in Hellenistic society on the other, form the background against which B.Ar. must be appreciated as a literary work. Placed back in this context, B.Ar. is certainly a reasonably representative example of contemporary Alexandrian literature. It may be described both as an heir to the thirdcentury explorations, and as a product of an age of widespread rhetorical education. Two key notions may serve to define B.Ar. from a generic point of view: ring composition, and the blending of genres. In other words, the influence of Callimachus left its distinctive mark on B.Ar. Ring composition is responsible for the compositional feature that has most puzzled modern commentators of B.Ar.: the presence of the so-called ‘digressions’. There are four of them: the Description of the gifts sent by the King to the Temple in Jerusalem (chs 51b–83a); the Journey to Jerusalem (chs 83b–120); the Apology for the Law by the High Priest Eleazar (chs 128–71) and the Symposium (chs 187–300). Allowing for some short transitional sections, these four digressions form a cluster at the centre of the work, ranging from ch. 51b to ch. 300, while what may be called the main narrative is divided into two sections, chs 9–51a and 301–21. The expected introduction (chs 1–8) and a short conclusion (ch. 322) frame the work. (An outline of B.Ar. is available in the Appendix to this book.) The blending of genres is recognizable first and foremost in the four digressions, but the central narrative also adds its own contribution. Various kinds 15
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
of progymnasmata are embedded in B.Ar., and each of the four digressions belongs to a different literary genre, whether or not it is a progymnasma. The overall effect achieved by this compositional structure is poikilia, diversity. In poetry the principle of poikilia is well known from Callimachus’ book of Iambi, where both dialects and metres are mixed.11 Parallels for the sort of composition found in B.Ar. are not hard to find in poetry either. In his survey of Alexandrian poetry, Peter Fraser analyses several pieces of narrative poetry that give the modern reader the same sort of impression of patchwork composition: Callimachus’ Hecale, Theocritus’ Dioscuri (Idyll 22) and Moschus’ Europa.12 When it comes to prose writing, however, we need to turn to much later works to find examples of this kind of generic composition: one of the best known examples is Himerius’ Oration 48, in the fourth century CE.13 In other words, B.Ar. can be said to provide us with a very early example in prose of literary features familiar to us from works of later date, ranging from Augustan literature to the fourth-century CE revival of the Second Sophistic. Following this logic, and relocating B.Ar. in the relevant broader literary context between post-Callimachaean Alexandria and the Greek prose of Roman times also enables us to appreciate its originality – and B.Ar. does, indeed, offer some originality.14 In order to gauge the extent of this it is necessary to start from a correct definition of originality in Greek literature of the time. While recent studies emphasize that the normative definition of genre was much more flexible and open to innovation in the major prose genres than was hitherto believed,15 the notion of genre was still important in poetry. Once the major innovations were achieved by the scholar-poets of third-century Alexandria, the new genres became patterns to be imitated in their turn. It goes without saying that progymnasmata by their very nature were characterized by conservatism and reflected the importance given to set forms. We may, therefore, apply to progymnasmata Cairns’ remarks about Hellenistic and Roman poetry. Cairns insisted that the originality of a writer lay not in his invention of new forms, but in his ability to introduce variations in the re-use of the traditional material available to him. Conservatism not only ruled the genres, but also imposed the choice of topics, to a large extent. Theocritus’ originality consisted in blending together genres and topics not normally associated with each other.16 The degree of innovation displayed by B.Ar. is easy to pin down: the form is Greek, but the thematic material is Jewish. This is true especially of the digressions. Incidentally, how much of this material is due to the author of B.Ar. himself, and how much to Jewish predecessors from whom he borrowed or at least took inspiration, is hard for us to judge. However, the fact remains that B.Ar. provides evidence for the existence of a Jewish literary tradition in Alexandria which was eager to blend Greek forms and Jewish topics and, thus, to demonstrate that Jewish culture was an integral part of Greek culture. One chapter in B.Ar. can be taken as symptomatic of this Jewish 16
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
aspiration to be recognized as part of Greek culture. Upon their arrival in Alexandria, the 72 Elders brought from Jerusalem together with the scroll of the Jewish Law are entrusted by the chief steward Nicanor to the care of Dorotheus. The latter was the official in charge of these visitors’ accommodation. Thereupon, the narrator adds (ch. 182): For such was the arrangement instituted by the King, which you may observe in use even now. For as many cities as there are which have special usages in drink and food and mode of reclining, so many officials were assigned, and then whenever guests visited the reigning King preparations were made according to their usages, so that there should be nothing to discomfort them and they could pass the time in good cheer.17 In other words, for all their peculiarities, the Jews are no more peculiar than any other Greek people. Their specificity is part of the multifarious diversity of the Greek world, and the Jews form just one polis among the others. This statement epitomizes the trend that runs through the four digressions in B.Ar. Taken together, the digressions build up a comprehensive presentation of Judaism in B.Ar., appropriately embedded in a work whose main topic is the translation of the Jewish Law. Obviously, then, the digressions were not included only for the sake of improving the literary quality of the work. They also contribute an important, though ancillary, aspect of the work.
The digressions Building up a comprehensive image of Judaism through literary poikilia The digressions make the main contribution to the compositional poikilia of B.Ar. As already noted, each one corresponds to a different literary genre. The description of the gifts sent by the King to the Temple in Jerusalem (chs 51b–83a) corresponds to the genre of ecphrasis, or ‘description (of an object)’ which is listed in handbooks of rhetoric as one of the progymnasmata.18 Callixenus of Rhodes wrote a book with a description of Alexandria which seems to have belonged to the genre of ecphrasis. Unfortunately, most of this work has been lost, but the description of the Great Procession which took place in Alexandria under Ptolemy II still survives in a summary by Athenaeus which contains many descriptions similar to the description of the gifts sent to the Temple in B.Ar.19 Similarly, versified descriptions of Alexandrian monuments were included in the advanced school curriculum of Hellenistic Egypt, as some papyri show.20 Another such ‘preparatory exercise’ in B.Ar., of more complex elaboration, is the so-called Apology for the Law by the High Priest Eleazar (chs 128–71). 17
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
The section is presented as a long answer to a question by Aristeas. Moses Hadas has compared it to the chreia genre, like the homilies of the Cynics and the Stoics.21 More accurately, it is an elaboration (ergasia) of a chreia, since the chreia itself was characterized as ‘a concise and praiseworthy reminiscence about some character’.22 The two remaining digressions in B.Ar. do not fit the genre of progymnasmata, but reflect other literary genres – what Cairns calls ‘non-rhetorical genres’ – which were common in the Hellenistic period. The Journey to Jerusalem (chs 83b–120) corresponds to the Hellenistic travelogue and the genre of utopian geography. The closest parallel to it is Euhemerus’ journey to the island of Panchaea, known to us through various excerpts.23 The Symposium (chs 187–300) also has close affinities with the genre of the philosophic symposium, among which the Deipnosophistae, by the later Athenaeus of Naucratis, is one of the best preserved.24 From a literary point of view, the Symposium, which amounts to one-third of the whole composition, is, as we might expect, the section of the book most carefully worked out. Although changes in literary taste make it close to unreadable for modern readers (like much of the Deipnosophistae), we must recognize its virtuosity as a literary exercise. The basic concept is that of variation on a set pattern, repeated 72 times: the King first poses a question to one of the Elders invited to the seven-night-long banquet. After the answer is given, the King displays his approval, and immediately turns to the Elder’s neighbour for the next question. Each of these 72 units represents a short chreia. Variation plays its part in the choice of the vocabulary used to refer to the King’s approval of each answer, as well as his hailing of his next interlocutor. As to the composition of the whole piece, it can be seen again as a blend of genres, merging the description of the banquet as an occasion for philosophical exchange (apparently in an anachronistic way), a treatise about kingship, and a Jewish element, the reference to the Jewish God.25 Apart from these four long sections, several smaller pieces corresponding to more limited progymnasmata are embedded in B.Ar., either in the central narrative or, more frequently, within the digressions. The description of the High Priest’s garments (chs 96–9) is a paraphrase of a text, in this case the LXX (LXX Ex. 28–9). The comparison between Jerusalem and Alexandria (chs 107–11) corresponds to the synkrisis exercise, the ‘comparison’. The King bowing before the scroll brought from Jerusalem, and later again before the scroll of the translation, may be seen as two instances of an ‘action chreia’.26 Last, the insertion of official documents – a royal edict (chs 22–5), an administrative report (chs 28–34a), an exchange of correspondence (34b–40 and 41–51a) and the list of the 72 translators (chs 47–50) – appears to be a technique borrowed from the ancient historians, and further contributes to the generic poikilia of the composition. The royal edict of chs 22–5 may perhaps also be seen as a kind of paraphrase. The moralizing tone which burdens the decree of liberation of the Jewish slaves (chs 22–5) and is out 18
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
of place in a genuine administrative decree, may further recall the genre of Egyptian instruction literature, of which at least one example is known in Greek: P.Tebt. 703 (= Austin, no. 256), a memorandum of a dioiketes to a subordinate official written in the late third century BCE, which ends with a general exhortation (ll. 261–80). The document was long taken to be a strictly matter-of-fact piece of administrative correspondence. However, it is now recognized that ‘the mixture of general exhortation with practical application, of both maxims and precepts is . . . a feature of Egyptian instruction literature’: the tradition goes back to the Pharaonic period.27 So much for the literary importance of these digressions. Needless to say, the assumption sometimes articulated by scholars at the beginning of the twentieth century,28 that these digressions were later interpolations, completely misses the compositional quality of B.Ar., which may well have been the aspect its author was most proud of. However, literary enjoyment is not incompatible with utility, quite the contrary. While the main narrative in B.Ar. focuses on a narrow, albeit central, topic – the translation of the Jewish Law into Greek – the digressions allowed the author to broaden the scope of his work to include a comprehensive presentation of this Law, as well as of the people abiding by it. The blend of Greek form and Jewish content may be seen, in itself, as a kind of manifesto of ‘Jewish Greekness’. B.Ar. offers a systematic and highly self-conscious articulation of this aspiration to make the best of both worlds. The Elders sent by Eleazar the High Priest conform to an ideal type of individuals combining Greek education and Jewish training (chs 121–2). The High Priest himself is implicitly endowed with similar qualities (ch. 3). Jerusalem is consistently presented as a Greek polis in B.Ar., endowed with the proper civic institutions (chs 42, 46). As we shall see in Chapter 3, the equation of Jerusalem with a Greek polis is precisely what gives credible support to the revival of the twelve biblical tribes in the Hellenistic period. Elsewhere, the Jews, in Jerusalem and throughout the inhabited world, are described as politai (ch. 3).29 In chs 15–16 the reader is assured that Greeks and Jews revere the same God under different names. A detailed review of the various sections that build up the picture of Judaism in B.Ar. shows that the blending of Greek forms with Jewish topics, or, more subtly, of Greek and Jewish topics, is pervasive. An example of a Greek form combined with a Jewish content is found in the Ecphrasis of the gifts sent by the King to the Temple in Jerusalem. The main piece of the section is the description of the table.30 Beyond the substitution of a Jewish object for a Greek one as the subject of the ecphrasis – a rather simple and inconspicuous effect of variation – a more interesting effect of variation with regard to genre requirements is achieved by the author. The description of the Great Procession of Ptolemy II by Callixenus emphasized the gigantic dimensions of the objects displayed in the procession. Praise for impressive measurements and lavishness are common clichés in the genre of 19
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
ecphrasis. In B.Ar., however, an unusual element is introduced that qualifies the motif of size. After a preliminary statement that the King’s initial plan was to make the table ‘outstanding in its measurements’ (ch. 52), the leitmotif in the description is the King’s refraining from his original plan out of concern to abide by the more modest measurements prescribed by the Jewish Law (chs 54–8). The variation is justified by the King’s wish for his table to actually be used in the ritual service of the Jerusalem Temple. The description is thus dominated by a hint of piety which prevails here over the conventional motives belonging to the genre of ecphrasis. The usual motif of lavishness is, however, also present, while the rich technical vocabulary seems to balance the modest measurements of the object described. The other digressions display features which are more interesting than simply Jewish content in a Greek form. In all three, the blending of Jewish and Greek aspects is related to the content. The compositional principle underlying the Symposium has already been described above. As has long been recognized, each of the 72 answers given by the Elders to the King’s questions is composed of two parts, one giving general advice in keeping with ordinary Greek philosophy, the second introducing a reference to the Jewish God. This sort of blend of Greek and Jewish philosophy may well have been innovative. As compared to the Symposium, the Apology (chs 128–71)31 appears less innovative, even if its inner organization deviates somewhat from the usual arrangement of the elaboration of the chreia advocated by the rhetorical handbooks.32 Hermogenes, for instance, lists eight sections for the ergasia, in the following order: [1] praise; [2] paraphrase; [3] rationale; [4] statement from the opposite; [5] statement from analogy; [6] statement from example; [7] statement from authority; [8] exhortation. Aphthonius is more detailed, and provides a concrete illustration of the theory. He follows the same order.33 Analysing B.Ar. in the light of these recommendations, the following picture emerges. Eleazar’s answer to Aristeas, which constitutes the elaboration of the chreia, begins with a long introduction (chs 130–3), explicitly described as such in the text (134). The initial praise [1] is logically omitted, since the chreia is not concerned with the statement of an individual, but with an explanation of the Law. Then the reference to the Lawgiver (130–1) may be seen as the paraphrase [2] of Aristeas’ question, which in this case includes a sort of displacement of the initial question to a broader perspective. The statement about the unity of God that follows probably stands for the rationale [3]. Further sentences in the passage may also be seen as rationales (139, 141–2). In conformity with the order given by the handbooks, the detailed treatment of the answer starts with a statement from the opposite [4] in chs 134–8. In fact, two successive statements are given, one concerning the Greeks (134–7), and the other concerning the Egyptians (138). Thus, what has sometimes been taken as an attack on Greeks and Egyptians at variance with the rest of the work34 turns out to be a conven20
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
tional requirement, when re-situated in the context of the generic rules of the progymnasma. We shall return to these so-called attacks below. The mention of the Egyptian priests in ch. 140 clearly stands for the statement from authority [7]. Then a long section (144–64), marked off by a ring composition around the mention of ‘mice and weasels’ (144 and 163–4), provides a series of statements from examples [6]. The inner composition of this passage is complex, amounting to a sort of elaboration in the elaboration. It includes a statement from the opposite, referring to incest and homosexuality (152), and a rationale, or perhaps a paraphrase, in ch. 155, with biblical quotations. Chapters 166–7 are a statement from analogy [5] complimentary to the king. Chapters 168–71 provide the final exhortation [8], again complicated by inner variations: a new rationale in 169, and further examples in 170–1. There is no real originality in the content of the chreia, either. It is clear that the vitality and diversity of the religious and philosophical quest in the Hellenistic period must have allowed for the most variegated religious and philosophical affiliations to compete over the homiletic genre as a vehicle for presenting their tenets and practices. The Apology for the Law is so inconspicuous in its religious boldness that it is misleading to assume, as has been done on occasion,35 that it contains some violent polemics against Greeks stemming from a Jewish monotheistic point of view.36 First of all, this section polemicizes with philosophical viewpoints, not with actual social practices, as we shall see in a moment. Next, it is dubious whether the arguments stated in B.Ar. are at all unusual within the realm of Greek thought. It has often been noted that the allegorical interpretation applied by B.Ar.’s author to the Jewish dietary laws has affinities with the technique of interpretation applied to other Jewish customs at about the same time by another Alexandrian Jewish writer, Aristobulus.37 However, in a recent discussion of the symbolic interpretation of the dietary laws in the Apology of the High Priest, Katell Berthelot cogently evinced that the arguments of the High Priest in explaining the Jewish dietary laws is best compared to the Pythagorian tradition of akousmata, or symbolic interpretations, of which a large part consists in interpreting dietary taboos.38 There are grounds for believing that the author of B.Ar. was making use of pre-existing material in this Apology for the Law. The borrowing from earlier sources is particularly recognizable in the attacks against the Cynics and in the polemics with Euhemerist ideas found in the Apology. The stance of B.Ar.’s author in this case should certainly not be seen as that of a Jewish philosopher targeting ‘pagan’ views en bloc. His shafts come from within the realm of Greek philosophical polemic. In fact, the arguments found in B.Ar. do not go far beyond conventional clichés, and in this sense the Apology for the Law does not display any more philosophical originality than the 72 sayings of the Symposium (chs 187–300). Thus, the reference to Egyptian zoolatry in ch. 138 is a cliché.39 21
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
The attack against incestuous intercourse in ch. 152 does not target a social practice allegedly common in contemporary Egypt, as is sometimes assumed,40 let alone the royal house of the Ptolemies.41 The offenders targeted are Stoics and Cynics, as is demonstrated by a direct allusion to a statement made by Chrysippus and known to us through a critical comment by Plutarch: In one of his books of Exhortations, he [Chrysippus] says that sexual intercourse with mothers or daughters or sisters, eating certain food, and proceeding straight from childbed or deathbed to a temple have been discredited without reason.42 This is worded slightly differently in B.Ar. (152): The majority of other men defile themselves in their relationships . . . : they not only procure the males, they also defile mothers and daughters. The omission of the ‘sisters’ in B.Ar., as compared with Plutarch’s reference to Chrysippus, may indeed seek to avoid offending the Ptolemaic dynasty. It may also simply result from the fact that the reference in B.Ar. is inaccurate. It is, in fact, difficult to decide whether our author knew Chrysippus’ text directly and was responsible for this modification, or whether he was quoting from another Hellenistic author who was himself less careful in his quotations than the author of B.Ar. usually is. It is, likewise, not quite certain whether he amalgamated early Stoic permissiveness in regard to incestuous intercourse with permissiveness in regard to homosexuality. This second element does not necessarily need to be specifically Jewish either. Although homosexuality was a widely accepted practice, we know that laws against it existed in the Roman Republican legislation and were occasionally invoked in the Late Republic, more as a weapon in political manoeuvres than for genuine moralistic reasons. It would not be impossible to imagine condemnations of pederasty in the Alexandrian Hellenistic literature, although they have (not surprisingly) left no traces in the extant sources, and were (even less surprisingly) absolutely ineffective in daily life.43 One point is certain: B.Ar.’s attack on the provocative prescriptions of the Stoics and Cynics is neither different in essence nor more violent in tone than those launched by other Greek philosophers of anti-Stoic affiliation – as the essay by Plutarch cited above makes quite clear.44 The same applies to the critique of Euhemerism in B.Ar. 134–7. Apart from these attacks on Greek schools, the description of the Jewish faith in chs 139–41 and elsewhere in this digression equates it with the religion of the (Greek) philosophers. In other words, it is necessary to assess the philosophical and religious content of the Apology and, indeed, of B.Ar. in 22
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
general, in more subtle terms than simply the opposition of Judaism and ‘paganism’. The attacks contained in the Apology are aimed at specific aspects of Greek (and Egyptian) philosophy and religion that were widely criticized by Greeks themselves. Moreover, these attacks are combined with an endeavour to present Judaism as a religion of philosophers, in a way popular in the Hellenistic age.45 The most interesting digression, as far as the blending together of Jewish and Greek topics is concerned, is the Travelogue, the Journey to Jerusalem (chs 83–120). In fact, this passage breaks down into five consecutive sections, each one modelled on a different literary form: the description of Jerusalem, which is an elaborate paraphrase of Aristotle, Politics, 7.11 (chs 83–106); the comparison between Alexandria and Jerusalem (chs 107–9); paraphrases of a royal Ptolemaic decree (ch. 110),46 and then of Aristotle, Constitution of the Athenians, 16 (ch. 111) which will be analysed elsewhere47 and, last, the description of Judaea (chs 112–20), which is reminiscent of the genre (or sub-genre) of utopian geography. The first and last sections of the Travelogue digression are closely related, both topically and generically, so that the digression keeps its unity as a whole. The section dealing with the description of the city of Jerusalem, chs 83–106, is directly inspired by Aristotle’s depiction of the ideal polis in Book vii of his Politics, with biblical allusions sewn into the text.48 The use of Aristotle in this passage is an excellent illustration of the skill of B.Ar.’s author in creative re-writing.49 The description of Jerusalem in B.Ar. introduces a systematic shift in emphasis as compared to the source used: prescriptions which, in Aristotle’s text, apply to the polis as a whole, are shifted in B.Ar. on to the Temple. For example, the detailed description of the combined sources supplying water to the Temple (chs 88–91) finds its raison d’être in Aristotle’s insistence on the need for the polis to enjoy a good water supply, both in quality and quantity (Politics, 7.11.3–4, 1330b 1–12). Even more striking is the case of the citadel (chs 100–4). B.Ar. is conspicuously vague about its precise location. Topographical accuracy was obviously not a point that mattered much for our author. We may suspect that he was interested above all in the very mention of a citadel adjacent to the Temple. The key for a correct understanding of this passage is again to be found in Aristotle, who establishes a direct link between the politeia or political regime prevailing in a particular polis and the corresponding arrangement of the defensive system: As to fortified positions, what is expedient is not the same for all forms of constitutions (politeiai) alike; for example, a citadel-hill (acropolis) is suitable for oligarchy and monarchy, and a level site for democracy; neither is favourable to an aristocracy, but rather several strong positions.50 23
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
Aristotle’s discussion is predicated on the basic scheme of three constitutions that is usual in Greek political theory – monarchy, aristocracy and democracy. The three basic regimes further branch out into straight and deviating forms, hence the distinction between oligarchy and aristocracy found in this citation. The depiction, in B.Ar., of a citadel linked to the Temple, implicitly fits a fourth kind of politeia, a theocracy, in which the polis is ruled not by a king, but by a high priest. This is, indeed, the political structure described by Hecataeus of Abdera in his excursus on the Jews, in a passage quoted by Diodorus. According to Hecataeus, the Jews had never had a king, but had always been ruled by a high priest (Diodorus, 40.3.5). In our extant sources, Josephus was the first to give a name to this politeia peculiar to the Jews alone: the neologism theokratia appears in his Against Apion, 2.165.51 The description of Jerusalem found in B.Ar. suggests, however, that although Josephus is our first extant reference for this Neubildung he probably did not invent the term himself.52 Speculation about the peculiar form of politeia to be found in Judaea, if not the word ‘theokratia’ itself, was already current in Alexandria by the generation of B.Ar.’s author at the latest. Thus, Jerusalem in B.Ar. is the encapsulation of the ideal Greek state. The description of Judaea in chs 112–20 summarizes in a remarkably synthetic way standard motifs recurrent in contemporary works belonging to the genre of utopian geography, such as natural bounty, dense population (polyanthropia), an outstanding river ensuring fertility, etc. The genre of utopian geography conflated the Greek tradition of ethnographical geography going back to Herodotus and beyond with the genre of philosophical speculation about the ideal politeia that flourished in the late fifth and the fourth centuries BCE. The new genre that resulted from this merging quickly developed its own rules and set topics. The latter are routinely spelled out in the works that have come down to us, such as the description of Egypt by Hecataeus of Abdera, summarized by Diodorus in the first book of his Historical Library, or that of India by Megasthenes (Diodorus, 2.35–42).53 In terms of variation on a set form, the effect of surprise created by B.Ar. was probably highest in the progymnasma found in chs 107–9, the comparison between Alexandria and Jerusalem. Jerusalem is defined as an ‘average’ city, built with symmetria, while Alexandria is the city of ‘great size’. This passage is usually understood in modern scholarship as an acknowledgement of Alexandria’s superiority over Jerusalem – a superiority that ‘even a Jew of Alexandria, however pious’, was ‘compelled’ to admit.54 But the case is quite the contrary: the terms of the comparison are derogatory to Alexandria, not to Jerusalem. They echo the Aristotelian prescription of a moderate size for the ideal city (Politics, 7.4.4, 1326a 5–b 25). The Travelogue digression actually refers to a ‘town’ rather than a ‘polis’, but this transposition was typical of the Hellenistic period. Beyond Aristotle, however, the idea that Jerusalem is closer to the ideal city than Alexandria consciously elaborates 24
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
on contemporary Alexandrian concerns. The urban plan of Alexandria has been defined by modern scholars as a combination of the rigid geometrical conceptions of the Miletan school of urbanism and the taste for grandiose and imposing scale inherited from the Egyptian and Near-Eastern traditions. The excess size of the Ptolemaic capital jeopardized the principle of symmetria, harmony in moderation, inherited from the Classical tradition.55 Thus, we may read in B.Ar. a discreet reference to Alexander’s debate with his architect Deinocrates about the foundation of Alexandria. This debate is known to us in two versions, one in Vitruvius, 2, praef. 1–4, the other in Pseudo-Callisthenes’ Romance of Alexander, 1.31.6–7, with a different emphasis.56 The story in Vitruvius amusingly stresses Alexander’s megalomaniac ambitions for his city, and the gigantic size of Alexandria. Thus, the reference in B.Ar. to the notion of symmetria and, through it, to Aristotle’s urbanistic tenets, creates a reversal of values to the benefit of Jerusalem. At the same time, the large city as the place of all pleasures had become a common topic of Alexandrian poetry in the third century BCE. One of the finest examples of the positive version of this topic is Theocritus’ Idyll 15, the Adoniazusae. However, this topic of the large city also had a negative component, as we see from the longing for an idealized nature which pervades bucolic poetry like Theocritus’ Idylls and other works related to the genre Peter Green has described as ‘urbanised pastoralism’. Similarly, the popularity in Alexandria of sculptures and terracotta statuettes of old peasants may reflect the same trend, at least to some extent. Even more striking is the idealized primitivism praising the ‘noble savage’, embodied in such figures as Agatharcides’ Trogodytes in his work On the Red Sea.57 The author of B.Ar. is simply presenting a variation on a topic that was apparently common in contemporary Alexandria. Thus, the digressions inserted in B.Ar. fulfil the literary function normally associated with digressions: they add variety, and hence increase the pleasure of reading the work. However, the digressions in B.Ar. are not designed for mere entertainment. They clearly play a role in the economy of the central narrative, to which they are closely subordinated. The homogeneity of the Book of Aristeas The identification in B.Ar. of a principle of ring composition typical of Hellenistic Alexandrian literature definitely negates the view that the ‘digressions’ found in this work were later interpolations. B.Ar. must now be seen as a homogeneous work. At the same time, however, the identification of passages of progymnasmata in B.Ar. may raise another problem. There can be no doubt that B.Ar.’s author used literary sources, and perhaps also official documents – although the traditional view on this matter has recently been challenged by Werner Schmidt.58 The documents presented in B.Ar. 25
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
stand in striking contrast to those found in the Romance of Alexander. In the case of the latter, Reinhold Merkelbach has shown that the letters inserted in the Romance originally belonged to a distinctly different setting, most probably an epistolary novel.59 Pseudo-Callisthenes inserted them in his own text without modifying them to harmonize with his own narrative. Merkelbach thus inferred that Pseudo-Callisthenes treated these letters he had found as if they were genuine documents. In contrast, Oswyn Murray has emphasized that the author of B.Ar. treated both the official documents that he had found in the royal archives, and the Greek or Jewish literary works that he was re-using, in a similar, even-handed way. None of these sources was simply copied out in a servile manner. On the contrary, the models were systematically re-written before they were carefully crafted into the narrative. B.Ar.’s description of Jerusalem provides a good illustration of this process of re-writing a literary source. The heavily idealized description of Jerusalem by Pseudo-Hecataeus, preserved in Josephus, Against Apion, 1.194–9 (= FGH, 264, F 21), was one of the several literary sources used by B.Ar.’s author for his description.60 ‘Hecataeus’ (in fact both Hecataeus of Abdera and the Jewish Pseudo-Hecataeus) is referred to by name in ch. 31, so that there can be no doubt that our author was acquainted with Pseudo-Hecataeus’ work. However, he arbitrarily modifies the figures given by his source regarding the number of priests, the city’s circumference, and the area of arable land, as if to demonstrate his independence from it.61 This handling of the sources by B.Ar.’s author resulted in the high literary quality of the work as well as its stylistic homogeneity. Murray has suitably called this way of processing the sources ‘creative adaptation’, or ‘creative plagiarism’.62 However, it is this very skill in redaction which makes it difficult for modern critics to delineate the boundary between source and original text in B.Ar., and to pin down borrowings in the absence of the original model. At least at a theoretical level, we might imagine that large sections of B.Ar. were in fact taken over from earlier sources. However, this is improbable for two sets of reasons. First of all, the principle of ring composition would have led our author, like any other Alexandrian writer, to compose long digressions of his own, in order to display his literary virtuosity. It is unthinkable that B.Ar.’s author was only responsible for chapters 1–51 and 301–22. The second set of arguments relates to the thorough consistency displayed throughout the work in the depiction of Judaism. The isolated touches supporting the picture of an Hellenized Judaism noted above (chs 3, 15–16, 42, 46, 121–2, 182) are decisive from this point of view. These details appear outside the digressions, in the introduction, the transitional sections, and the main narrative. They demonstrate a level of conceptual harmonization between the main narrative and the various sections of B.Ar. that would be very surprising if our author were only responsible for the superficial matching of a patchwork of composite sources. A particularly complex case of harmonization is the status 26
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
of the ruler in Jerusalem. The title of ‘high priest’ was far from self-evident for the Jews themselves, as is made clear by Philo’s obvious discomfort with it (Life of Moses, 2.31). Philo refers to it twice in the same passage, and on the first occasion he links it to the title of ‘king’.63 The status of Jerusalem’s ruler as a high priest has ideological significance in B.Ar. It is to be understood in terms of a political utopia. Its precise significance derives from the implicit claim in the description of Jerusalem and Judaea in the Travelogue digression: Jerusalem’s politeia is a theocracy. This last case demonstrates that B.Ar.’s author was not simply complying with his readership’s expectations in depicting Jerusalem in ideal terms. Far from being content with some trivial rehearsal of well-known clichés, one suspects that he was pushing forward his own vision of things. Above all, however, this example shows what a high degree of internal consistency has been achieved by the author of B.Ar. in the various parts of his work. This is, indeed, a remarkably homogeneous work. This can only mean that, whatever the size and number of sources he used, B.Ar.’s author made them his own by thorough adaptation. The identification of these sources, therefore, has only a limited interest. The intended readership The digressions present a further interest for modern readers: from some of the features seen above in relation to the digressions it is possible to infer that the original readership for which B.Ar. was intended was Jewish and not Greek; more precisely, the target readership was Alexandrian Jews. Inasmuch as our author is in full control of his text, as has just been claimed, any clue we find to an intended readership must reflect his genuine intention. In practical terms, identification of such clues consists in discerning, as best we can, which segment(s) of the population (Greeks or Jews, learned or otherwise) would have been positively receptive in some way or another to the allusions or the ideas articulated in the text. Attempts at identifying B.Ar.’s targeted readership must rely on intertextual references. As in the case of the learned Alexandrian poetry of the third century BCE, which abounded in intertextual references,64 we must also admit that our author built on the ability of his readers to recognize literary allusions. Pleasure comes from the identification of references arousing a familiar resonance in one’s memory – not from the feeling that one is more ignorant than he should be. Some literary references may be ambiguous, since they refer to common Greek literary training. Some of them are not too demanding, intellectually speaking. Thus, B.Ar.’s author expected his readers to be familiar with ‘Hecataeus’, and, as we just saw, both Hecataeus of Abdera and PseudoHecataeus are referred to under this name. Hecataeus of Abdera was popular among all learned Alexandrians, whatever their ethnic identity, thanks to his lost book on Egypt, on which the first book of Diodorus’ Historical Library 27
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
is based. There was an excursus on Judaea in this work, which might explain how his name came to be appropriated by a Jewish author.65 In terms of the level of Greek education, crediting an Alexandrian readership with familiarity with ‘Hecataeus’ was not too bold a bet. Likewise, the narrator’s statement, in the introductory section (ch. 6), that he owed his information on Jews to Egyptian priests may also have found a positive resonance with readers familiar only with Hecataeus. It is true that this topos belongs to a well-established tradition in Greek literature, going back to Book II of Herodotus’ Histories. It was used by numerous fourth-century writers with oligarchic sympathies: Plato’s Atlantis account is only the bestknown example of this literature.66 However, reference to knowledge received from Egyptian priests was also to be found in Hecataeus’ monograph on Egypt. B.Ar.’s author is more demanding of his reader (and hence more flattering) with his references to further intellectual and literary figures, like the philosopher Menedemus of Eretria (ch. 201); the historian Theopompus and the tragic poet Theodectus (chs 314, 316). He further ascribes to his readers a varnish of Greek philosophy, which was the indispensable prerequisite for them to enjoy reading the longest section of his book, the Symposium. Thus, the author of B.Ar. reckoned with a highly educated Alexandrian readership. Further points, however, allow us to specify that the intended readers were Jewish. As is well known, the first scholar to challenge the prevailing view that B.Ar. was intended for a Greek readership and argue for a Jewish one was Victor Tcherikover.67 In his wake, Harry Orlinsky adduced the numerous linguistic allusions to the LXX in support of the claim that the original readership was Jewish.68 Orlinsky rightly identified such allusions in the scene of new Revelation that closes B.Ar., in chs 308–11, referring in particular to LXX Exodus 24. Another well-known example of such allusions is the description of the High Priest’s garments in chs 96–9, where many commentators have pointed out the direct textual dependence on LXX Exodus 28–9. Nobody other than Jews would have been receptive to these allusions, or able to understand the implicit meaning of the text in the cases pointed out by Orlinsky. Further arguments may be added to those adduced by Tcherikover and Orlinsky. Some minor features in the book are better understood as aiming at a Jewish readership: for instance, the fact that all names of the Greek officers at Ptolemy’s court (Sosibios, Andreas, Aristeas, Nicanor and his subordinate Dorotheos, chs 12, 43, 182–3) are religiously neutral. Distinctively theophoric Greek names (such as Athenodoros or Diodorus) are avoided.69 The implicit message is the same as in ch. 16: Greeks and Jews revere the same God under different names. It may be argued that Jews, rather than Greeks, would have been interested by the religious statements of chs 15–16. However, it may be conceded that the audience targeted by these religious messages is still ambiguous. 28
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
In contrast, the comparison between Alexandria and Jerusalem found in chs 107–11, is clearly aimed at Jews, if we admit that the comparison is derogatory to Alexandria. Inverse ethnocentrism (or self-derogatory discourse idealizing the culture embodying the opposite of one’s own) is by essence polemical, and Greek writers of the Hellenistic period were definitely able to produce such a discourse themselves. However, our text can by no means be identified with the Alexandrian trend of inverse ethnocentrism, since the latter usually translated into a longing for primitivism.70 Jerusalem and its country are not described as primitive, quite the contrary. In such conditions, it is hard to imagine that Greek Alexandrians would have readily accepted B.Ar.’s comparison between Alexandria and Jerusalem. Imagining a Greek readership for B.Ar. therefore implies a level of polemic going far beyond that displayed elsewhere in the work. (The polemic against the early Stoic and Cynic concept of nature in B.Ar., as we saw, is strictly conventional.) In contrast, if a Jewish readership were the target, the comparison is merely self-indulgent – and incidentally, this would imply a Jewish readership that was also expected to be sensitive to Aristotelian concepts of urbanism. The intended readership of B.Ar., therefore, was Jewish. However, these were not Jews secluded from Greek culture. On the contrary, B.Ar.’s readers were Jews who could no doubt identify with the description of the 72 Jewish Elders who were brought from Jerusalem together with the Law: they were trained in the finest Greek paideia (chs 121–7), but were also well learned in their own tradition. In short, B.Ar.’s readers were highly educated Alexandrian Jews.
The central narrative: the Book of Aristeas as a historical monograph The consistent use of digressions to build up a comprehensive picture of Judaism in B.Ar., together with the importance of the digressions as compared to the main narrative, explains why there has been a tendency in recent scholarship to claim that the real purpose of this work was to give an interpretative presentation of Judaism, and not merely the limited topic of the translation. However, this contention is based on the failure to identify the compositional structure of B.Ar. Logically, the definition of the subject must refer to the central narrative of the work, not the digressions – whatever their importance in the overall economy of B.Ar. Furthermore, the principle of ring composition used in B.Ar. that was identified above still leaves open the question of the genre to which B.Ar. belongs. Both issues, genre and subject of the work, are related. The keys to both issues are to be sought first and foremost in the author’s own statements about his work. Logically, both the introduction and the conclusion (chs 1–8 and 322) may be expected to provide key information on this matter. 29
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
Both in the introduction and the conclusion B.Ar. is defined as a die¯ge¯sis. This word is synonymous with the term found in Aphthonius’ handbook, die¯ge¯ma.71 Both are technical terms of Classical rhetoric referring to a kind of progymnasma, a narrative in prose. Ancient grammarians distinguished between three types of diegema or diegesis: mythological, historical and political. Inasmuch as B.Ar. is presented by the author/narrator as an account of events which took place in his own days, the work was clearly conceived as a historical diegesis. In other words, B.Ar. is related to the genre of Hellenistic historiography. As we shall see below and in the forthcoming chapters, the author certainly made abundant use of the rhetorical and technical means identified in his days with historical writing. The introduction itself (ch. 2) describes Philocrates, the addressee of the book, who is presented as the narrator’s brother, as a ‘man who has tried continually to increase his learning and understanding’, both ‘through research’ (kata tas historias) into things and events where he was not present himself, or ‘by actual experience of affairs’ (kat’ auto to pragma pepeirameno¯ ).72 These are two ways of acquiring knowledge which would have been immediately recognizable to a historian like Polybius (cf. Histories, 12.25e, 25h and 27) or Diodorus (Historical Library, 1.1.1–2). According to the conventions of Greek historiography, the introduction is expected to state precisely what the subject matter of the account that will follow will be. B.Ar.’s author kept to this rule. Formally, B.Ar. is a diegesis ‘of the meeting which we had with Eleazar, High Priest of the Jews’ (ch. 1). The author/narrator will relate the content (peri ho¯n) and purpose (dia ti) of his mission. The topic is further defined in ch. 3: [I] offered [myself] as a deputation (to Eleazar . . .) with a view to the translation of the divine Law, because it was written by them on parchments in Hebrew characters.73 Thus, B.Ar. is a kind of historical monograph.74 What about its topic? In a recent study John Marincola has questioned the rigid classification of ancient works of historiography inherited from Felix Jacoby.75 He argued that the generic boundaries were much more open than Jacoby thought. However, the treatment of military and political events still seems to have enjoyed a particular prestige. This would explain why, as Guido Schepens has stressed, works concerned with these topics are over-represented in the extant sources, even though many ancient historians were interested in dealing with a much wider array of subject matters in the Herodotean tradition.76 Ancient historians themselves refer to the subjects of monographs as the ‘deeds of countries or cities or dynasts’ (Polybius 9.1), or the ‘deeds of kings or cities self-contained from beginning to end’ (Diodorus, 16.1.1).77 The author of B.Ar. chose to present his topic in conformity with the most prestigious models. Among ‘political deeds’, embassies qualified as perfectly 30
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
respectable and traditional topics. It looks as if the opening sentences of B.Ar. sought to give the work a guise of perfect normality. However, further elements in the introduction show that the principle of blending, so characteristic of B.Ar.’s composition as a whole, is also to be found at the very core of the central narrative. Chapter 4 appears to introduce a blend of topics. This sentence refers, in an incidental mode, to the episode of the liberation of the Jewish slaves: We undertook this task [i.e. the deputation] with enthusiasm, seizing an opportunity with the King in connection with those who were transported to Egypt from Judaea by the King his father . . . It is worthwhile telling you this as well. The episode of the liberation of the Jewish slaves is usually held by modern scholarship to be an inopportune digression. This judgement is belied by this last quotation. The author of B.Ar. obviously considered this episode to be an important matter – central enough to be recorded in his introduction. It follows, then, that the liberation of the slaves must be seen as a component of the central narrative. The incidental mode used to introduce it, however, suggests that it is subordinated to the topic of the deputation. In other words, the evidence of the introduction presents the central narrative in B.Ar. as composed of a main topic, the deputation, and a secondary one, the liberation of the slaves. Thus, the structural composition of the central narrative, with its two-storeyed arrangement, appears somewhat complex for a historical monograph – although, it should be insisted, the use of the incidental mode in order to introduce the secondary theme preserves the formal topical unity of the diegesis. However, under the blanket format of a conventional subject matter (the deputation), the specifically Jewish topic is innovative. The purpose of the diplomatic mission is neither conventional political ties nor political entanglements, nor does it involve a matter of peace and war. The matter at stake is cultural – obtaining a scroll of the Jewish Law, together with translators. Marincola has insisted on the importance of innovation in ancient historical writing, as indeed in other genres, as one ‘of the most important elements of ancient literary creation’. ‘One of the primary goals of composition was to be both traditional and innovative, to follow the models of established excellence . . . while making something slightly different, something that was one’s own.’ As a result, the definition of a genre is to be seen as dynamic, not static.78 According to this approach, the degree of innovation of B.Ar.’s author is in no way exceptional. However, restricting ourselves to this observation may miss the point. We should probably take seriously the fact that our author chose ‘political deeds’ as his model. By introducing the topic of his work as the account of an embassy, he could play on the ‘horizon of expectations’ of his readers.79 In this way, he was probably seeking 31
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
to transform the translation of the Law into a ‘major event’. Incidentally, we may identify here an interesting precedent for those parts of the New Testament that modern scholarship sometimes compares to the genre of historiography, the Acts of the Apostles and, likewise, the Gospels, which transformed the birth and gospel of Jesus into a ‘major event’.80 Ever since Herodotus, the proemium of a historical work was not only expected to introduce the subject matter of the book, but also to provide the author’s justification for committing this particular topic to writing. While Herodotus wrote to prevent great deeds from falling into oblivion, the justification put forward in the Hellenistic period was frequently the ‘bestowal of (moral) benefit’.81 We find something similar indeed in B.Ar.: the incentive for writing referred to is the ‘love of learning’82 (prosmanthanein) ascribed by the author/narrator to his fictional addressee, Philocrates, who obviously stands for the real readers he is aiming at (ch. 1).83 Diodorus’ proemium to his universal history, his Historical Library, presents topics that are conventional in the introduction of a historical work together with topics borrowed from Stoic philosophy. However, Diodorus does not really blend both semantic fields in one section, but rather stitches together, somewhat clumsily, two successive introductions, one more conventional in Greek historiography (1.1–2), and the second one bringing in the Stoic elements (1.3–6). This second section of Diodorus’ introduction is usually thought to be borrowed from Poseidonius.84 This means, then, that the introduction of philosophical insights into the proemium of a historical work was not something unknown by our author’s time. As compared to Diodorus’ proemium, B.Ar.’s merges both topics more closely – although the comparison is a little unfair, given the difference in length between the two proemia. The comparison with Diodorus is still interesting, however, since it makes an important difference apparent: the topic intertwined with historiography in the narrow sense of the word in B.Ar.’s proemium is not exactly moral benefit or philosophical insights, but religion. Thus, besides being an account of a past event to which the author/narrator claims to be an eyewitness, B.Ar. is introduced as an exposition on religious matters. Again, the mixing of registers, history and religion, should not surprise us if we accept that the boundaries of prose genres were not rigid ones. In the study already referred to, Marincola discussed a series of works that have been seen by modern scholars to eschew classification as historical works, in order to show that generic boundaries were, indeed, subject to constant re-definition and innovation. The juxtaposition of topics conventional in historiography and in religious matters in B.Ar. is no bolder than the innovations presented by works such as Xenophon’s Anabasis, Caesar’s Gallic Wars, or Tacitus’ Agricola.85 Various elements contribute to the topic of religious matters in B.Ar. In ch. 6, the present diegesis is stated to be the second work (anagraphe¯) of a diptych – or rather a triptych, since the conclusion will announce a further 32
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
work to come. Whether real or imaginary,86 this earlier work alluded to in the introduction was about the Jews. The context suggests that the contents dealt with the Jewish religion (or ‘philosophy’), and that it was not a politeia, that is, a systematic exposition of their customs and history. The narrator claims to have ‘received this account of the people of the Jews from the most renowned high priests in renowned Egypt’. The pastiche of a long tradition of Greek historians and philosophers claiming to have received their knowledge from Egyptian priests is unmistakable, as we saw above. Still, the precedent of Herodotus’ second book on the Egyptians demonstrates that the reference to a previous book need not take the reader too far from historiography. The key word of the second topic, however, is that of ‘piety’ (eusebeia). The word appears explicitly in ch. 2. André Pelletier has rightly pointed out that this piety is Greek and not Jewish: it derives from knowledge – and not knowledge from piety.87 However, even in this Greek, and not Jewish form, the semantic field of piety, of knowledge for the sake of enhancing the soul, oversteps the narrow realm of historiography. The narrator, further, explicitly states that he offered himself as a deputation to Eleazar because he has ‘a set purpose devoted to the special study of the things of God’ (ch. 3). The semantic field of piety, then, which runs throughout B.Ar.’s introduction, infuses historiography with a topic borrowed from a quite different literary genre which became very common from the fourth century BCE on: the philosophical epistle – even though B.Ar. is not formally a letter. However, we must remain cautious before we credit the author of B.Ar. with too much originality or oddity in his blending of historiography and religious matters, and perhaps the philosophical epistle is not the most appropriate genre for comparison. It is unfortunate that the original text of Euhemerus’ account of his journey to Panchaea is lost. It is impossible to get a clear idea about the content and mood of the original proemium from the extant excerpts, in Diodorus and elsewhere.88 We can only surmise that this work, and possibly others of the kind, may have provided a good basis for comparison. More generally speaking, B.Ar. blends historiography with philosophy or religion in the same way that the social utopias of the Hellenistic period like Euhemerus’ work resulted from a blend of the travelogue with the philosophical essays on the ideal city of fourthcentury Greece. Since the travelogue derived from the genre of ethnogeography which had been closely related to historiography ever since Herodotus, B.Ar. was perhaps not quite as unusual as it now looks in its blending of topics. Defining the prevailing tone in B.Ar. as that of historiography has important implications for our understanding of the author’s intention. Greek historiography was defined as an account, a diegesis, of events which had really happened. The claim that the account in B.Ar. is true is, indeed, 33
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
explicitly articulated in the conclusion of the work, in the farewell address to Philocrates (ch. 322): There you have, Philocrates, as I promised, my narrative (die¯ge¯sis). These matters I think delight you more (terpein) than the books of the mythographers, (ta to¯n mythologo¯n biblia). Two topics common in Hellenistic literature are found here. Concern for pleasure (he¯done¯, or, as here, the verb terpein) is a predominant claim of Hellenistic literature. Pleasure was derived above all from the stylistic quality of the work, but the concept also involved matters of content. First of all, the arrangement of the subject matter so as to provide poikilia, diversity, in the narrative, reflected the author’s concern for vividness. Dwelling too long on the same topic held the risk of deterring the readers with boredom. Hence, the importance of ‘digressions’ in monographs, or the custom, in universal histories, of alternating between one Mediterranean scene and another, as in Polybius.89 The notion of ‘pleasure’ in relation to the content of the work per se, particularly preoccupied the historians of the so-called school of ‘tragic historiography’. This was a style that was first theorized and practised by Duris of Samos in the fourth century BCE.90 Even though the terminology used to refer to the concept of ‘pleasure’ may vary, its definition was quite constant. Duris himself appears to have been concerned with theorizing the most effective way of providing a ‘dramatic re-enactment of events’ (in J.R. Morgan’s words) through the notions of ‘pleasure’ and ‘imitation’ (mime¯sis), but his followers took ‘pleasure’ in a much lighter way. In their view, the historian had to strive for vividness (enargeia) and sensational rendering through detailed descriptions of town sieges or other potentially ‘dramatic’ events, as a means to reach out to the readers’ emotions.91 Such a conception of history was not universally endorsed. Polybius is particularly hostile to it. However, Polybius’ own relationship to the notion of ‘pleasure’ is not unambiguous. At times, he rejected it altogether from historiography, relegating it to the realm of tragedy; historiography, in contrast, was to remain the realm of ‘truth’, in order to ‘benefit’ the reader.92 Thus, ‘pleasure’ was opposed to ‘utility’. Elsewhere, however, Polybius felt that he could not simply dispose of the notion of ‘pleasure’, probably because by his time the latter was too thoroughly rooted in both the practice of contemporary historians and their readers’ expectations. He thus strove to endow this concept with a new definition. ‘Pleasure’ in historiography derived, in Polybius’ sense, from its utility.93 On the face of it, the reference by the author of B.Ar. to ‘benefiting the mind’ may be compared to Polybius’ appeal to utility. These two writers, however, do not refer to the same kind of ‘utility’. Polybius’ utility is historical, implying political benefit, whereas our author has philosophical benefit in mind. For all this, there is a considerable degree of similarity in their 34
GENRE AND COMPOSITION IN THE BOOK OF ARISTEAS
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
blurring of the distinction between ‘pleasure’ and ‘utility’, amounting to an assimilation of the former into the latter. It is, further, clear from the combined references to ‘getting delight from’ and ‘benefiting the mind’ in B.Ar. that, in our author’s view, the philosophical ‘utility’ of his work was predicated on the truth of its content – B.Ar. is not a philosophical allegory, but a ‘true’ diegesis. Indeed, this is the second topic found in B.Ar.’s concluding sentence: the implicit claim that the account just given is true and is about a serious matter. To be sure, explicit reference to ale¯theia, ‘truth’, or akribeia, ‘exactness’, is lacking here. Our author was primarily interested in putting the stress on moral utility, not on truth. However, moral benefit can be derived only from a reliable account, and the claim to be a true narrative is made, although in an implicit manner. As we saw above, Classical rhetoric distinguished between three types of diegeseis. Mythos was one of them, corresponding to myth or tragedy.94 Mythologia, ‘myth-telling’, the field of ‘false’ narrative, is explicitly contrasted by our author with his own work in his conclusion. If we follow the tri-partite classification of diegesis by the grammarians, there can be no doubt that by doing so our author was categorizing his own work as the opposite of myth, that is ‘true history’. The claim that the narrative is true is a fundamental organizing principle in B.Ar. The author used all the possible means at his disposal to enforce it, as we shall see in Chapter 4. Before this, however, we need to look more closely at the main narrative of B.Ar.
35
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
3 THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE The transfiguration of history into charter myth
Delineating the topic The identification of a two-fold topic in the proemium of B.Ar., as seen in Chapter 2, allows us a different appreciation of the overall balance of the composition of this text than was hitherto the case. Four sections of the text are genuine digressions: the Ecphrasis (the description of the gifts), the Travelogue (the journey to Jerusalem), the Apology for the Law, and the Symposium. The rest, including sections which have sometimes been seen as digressions, belong either to the main, or to the secondary, theme of the central narrative. Seen in this way, the place occupied by the digressions is no greater than usual in Hellenistic prose accounts. As to the two-fold diegesis, there can be no doubt that both components complement each other. The central theme, which is defined in the proemium as the account of the embassy, is mainly concerned with the nature of the scroll on which the translation of the LXX was based. The central point of the argument is that the scroll was a genuine manuscript of the Law of the Jews and the best possible text, with the implication that the translation of the scroll that is based on it is the best possible – indeed, it is perfect. The secondary theme is composed of several episodes. It is introduced in the proemium not by an abstract and comprehensive definition, but by its incipit, that is, the first of the episodes which compose it: the liberation of the Jewish slaves. Referring to a work by its incipit was a regular practice in Classical Antiquity.1 The catalogues drawn up by Callimachus referred thus to the many books deposited in the Alexandrian library. The proemium of B.Ar. applies this practice, quite naturally, to a sub-topic of the narrative, leaving us with the delicate task of linking together the various episodes and reconstructing the meaning of the theme as a whole. It will be argued in this chapter that this secondary theme is aimed at equating B.Ar.’s account of the translation with the account of the Hebrew Law as seen in the Book of Exodus. The aim of drawing a parallel between these respective stories is to give them an equal status. 37
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
The skilful intertwining of both components of the central diegesis is best exemplified by the fact that the bringing of the scroll from Jerusalem belongs to the main theme, while the proclamation of the translation, which is more or less the closing scene of B.Ar., is part of the secondary one. Such elaborate merging leaves little doubt that the resulting blurring of the two parts was intentional. As a result, the compositional structure is elusive even for modern readers, even though the arrangement of the B.Ar.’s proemium leaves little doubt as to the presence of two interwoven narrative topics in the text. What makes their delineation possible is the fact that each of them is modelled on a distinct literary paradigm. It will be argued in this chapter that the narrative paradigms in which the author cast his account are crucial in conveying meaning to the story told in B.Ar. Such a resort to a literary pattern rather than to explicit exposition in order to convey meaning is somewhat reminiscent of the characteristics of traditional mythtelling. The use of this methodology by the author of B.Ar. strongly suggests that in informing his account with narrative paradigms, his purpose in writing B.Ar. was more than the immortalization of a past event by relating its story. The intent was to transfigure it. It will be contended here, in the wake of a hypothesis first formulated by Oswyn Murray,2 that the writer meant to give his account the status of a charter myth and, specifically, a charter myth for the origins of the LXX. The resort to the form of historiography, with all its rhetorical appurtenances, was simply the natural way in the Hellenistic period for an author to give his account the status of true narrative which was required for the myth to really function. But the real strength of the narrative derives from its quasi-mythic dimension. As we saw in Chapter 2, B.Ar. is too serious a work to be only history. The Book of Aristeas as a charter myth The concept of ‘charter myth’ was coined by the anthropologist Bronislaw Malinowski in 1926. More recently Geoffrey Kirk has clarified its meaning: it refers to myths which ‘provide a record and validation of titles, lands, families, privileges, customs, and of course rituals’.3 The term ‘myth’ is ambiguous, since it may refer to several things. First of all, it may serve to define one realm against another one, that of ‘real’ or ‘true’ events. However, the distinction between ‘myth’ and ‘history’ plays a role both in ancient and modern inquiry about the past, but in both cases the basic categories involved are, in fact, quite different. A late but particularly clear articulation of the distinction as it was perceived in the ancient world is Plutarch’s prologue to his Life of Theseus, in which to mytho¯des is opposed to historia.4 However, even though Plutarch queries many aspects of the tradition about Theseus he does not query the basic fact that Theseus had existed. In the same way, even though Thucydides may rationalize 38
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
Homer’s account in the ‘Archaeology’ of his first book, this does not mean that he had any qualms about the ‘reality’ of the Trojan war. This ambiguity about the concept of myth concerns the category of traditional myths (in the modern sense of the word) with which ancient Greek culture is usually associated. Yet another, different connotation is involved in the category of ‘historical myths’, the category that concerns us in the case of B.Ar. As Irad Malkin has defined it, ‘a myth may become historical either through the transformation of a real event into a myth or through the transformation of a myth into history’.5 The latter process is by far the most common in the Greek world in the Archaic and Classical periods, as Malkin rightly stresses, although the case of the battle of Marathon in fifthand fourth-century Athens demonstrates that the former process was not altogether alien to Classical society. In the case of B.Ar., we are concerned with the former process, the transformation of a real event into a myth. Clearly, what this transformation implies has nothing to do with the intrinsic ‘historical’ value of the account. That the ‘event’ lying at the core of it, the conditions surrounding the origins of the LXX, may not be ‘historical’ in the proper, modern sense of the word is immaterial. The original readers did regard the event told in B.Ar. as ‘real’. The real difference between ‘history’ and ‘myth’ is one of intention and reception, not of content. For past events to be turned into a myth, an emotional load must be added to their account. Historiography, especially in the Hellenistic period, appeals either to the intellect or to the emotions in order to entertain – or to the intellect, not to the emotions, in the case of a didactic moral purpose. Myth appeals to the emotions in order to create adherence, and in order to shape an attitude, engender pride and a correct stance. In fact, the definitions of ‘myth’ that prove most useful for the analysis of the narrative of B.Ar. are the definitions of ‘political myth’ found in sociological studies.6 The concept of ‘political myth’ is usually used in connection with modern societies. In his monograph dedicated to the conceptual and historical study of this notion, however, Henry Tudor starts his historical survey with the late Roman Republic: he rightly emphasizes that the Roman foundation myth fits the definition of ‘political myth’ as he works it out in this study.7 Later, in the Augustan period, the battle of Actium, turned into the victory of civilization and order against Eastern decadence and barbarism, was celebrated in Rome in a way that endeavoured to transfigure the event into a myth.8 There can be little doubt that the process of formation and political use of myths in the Hellenistic period shows up Hellenistic society as closer to late Republican and imperial Rome than to the society of Classical Greece. The figure of Alexander, in particular, was subject to hijacking on behalf of the various Hellenistic dynasties. Besides simple political manipulation, the formation of genuine political myths may be recognized:9 the Hellenistic kernel of the Alexander Romance may be seen as 39
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
a popular reflection of the powerful impact of the figure of Alexander.10 It is, therefore, legitimate to use the modern sociological definitions of ‘political myth’ for a text which is a product of Hellenistic society. Henry Tudor’s definition may serve as an appropriate starting point for the discussion of the nature of B.Ar.’s narrative: A myth, I suggest, is an interpretation of what the myth-maker (rightly or wrongly) takes to be hard fact. It is a device men adopt in order to come to grips with reality; and we can tell that a given account is a myth, not by the amount of truth it contains, but by the fact that it is believed to be true and, above all, by the dramatic form into which it is cast.11 The key concepts in this definition are the ‘dramatic form’, in other words, the narrative, and the notion of collective adherence to the perceived truth of the story in the form in which it is circulated. We may supplement this basic definition with additional elements found in other definitions provided by modern authors. Altogether these definitions bring the concept of political myth very close to the definition of ‘charter myth’ with which Classicists are more familiar. One such definition is given by C. Friedrich and Z. Brzezinski: A myth is typically a tale concerned with past events, giving them a special meaning and significance for the present and thereby reinforcing the authority of those who are wielding power in a particular community.12 Stalin’s retrospective reconstruction of the October Revolution is a myth in this sense, as Nachman Ben Yehuda notes in his own elaboration of Friedrich and Brzezinski’s definition.13 In his comment on this definition, Tudor notes that Friedrich and Brzezinski emphasize two points: the first has just been noted: ‘a myth is, by definition, a story, that is, a narrative of events in dramatic form’. The second stresses a new and important addition: ‘a myth is told not for the sake of amusement, but in order to promote some practical purpose.’14 In our assessment of the nature of B.Ar.’s narrative, both in its ‘historical’ and ‘mythical’ dimensions, we must keep in mind that the concept of history and history telling was different in Classical Antiquity from what it is now. In Classical Antiquity, the intrusion of literary conventions into historiography implies that the relation between ‘narrative’ and ‘hard facts’ was much looser than is required by modern standards. Furthermore, the part played by the historian’s ‘reconstruction’ of the past was much wider. For all this, the real difference between ‘history’ and ‘myth’ remains one of 40
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
reception, not of content. This does not imply, to be sure, any difference in the attitude of the audience as far as their belief in the reliability of the account is concerned. In order to be operative, a myth must be taken to be true by its original audience.15 The difference in the reception of history or myth lies elsewhere, but is nonetheless important: it involves intellectual or moral interest in the former case, emotional adherence in the latter. The contention of the present book is that the role and purpose of B.Ar. was to turn the story of the origins of the LXX into a myth.16 This was achieved basically through configuring the story on specific literary patterns. The present discussion will be concerned with the process of the formation of the myth on its literary level. This implies not only delineating the two intertwined motifs, but also bringing out their underlying meaning. Further questions bearing on the genesis of the narrative, whether it is a pure scholarly construct deriving from the author’s mind only, or a literary reshaping of a pre-existing popular tradition, will be addressed briefly at the end of the discussion. However, it is doubtful whether we have the means to provide a definite answer. The issue of the precise function and purpose of the charter myth embedded in B.Ar must be postponed to Chapter 6, since it is closely related to the Sitz im Leben of B.Ar. itself, and not to the historical origins of the LXX. Further questions, such as the intention of the author, the mental attitude which lies behind his literary intervention and, finally, the conditions of the reception of the narrative in its present form by the population originally targeted, will be dealt with in the next chapter. Inasmuch as the forthcoming discussion is concerned with the literary level, the characters found in B.Ar. will be treated as literary characters, and will be distinguished from their historical correspondents by a capital letter, following the rule stated at the end of Chapter 1 above.
The main theme: the embassy to Eleazar the High Priest The story of Aristeas’ embassy to Eleazar, the High Priest of the Jews in Jerusalem is, in fact, the story of the scroll. The whole account is clothed in Alexandrian ideology. It is therefore not surprising that the narrative pattern which informs this story is essentially Alexandrian. The delineation of this literary pattern can be further ascertained by adducing comparative material. Several stories formed along the same lines have been preserved, all of them linked in some way or another to Alexandria, and more precisely, to the Ptolemaic dynasty. Taken together, this small corpus of texts demonstrates that beyond the literary composition it is possible to speak of a narrative paradigm. For the sake of convenience this will be called the Alexandrian paradigm here. Let us first point out its basic components in B.Ar.’s narrative (see the outline of B.Ar. in the Appendix): 41
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
1
2
3 4
Demetrius the Librarian informs the King that the Law of the Jews is lacking in his Library, and must first be translated; thereupon the King takes the necessary steps in order to have the Law of the Jews translated and put into the Library. The King sends an embassy to the High Priest of the Jews in Jerusalem, together with wonderful gifts for the Temple, so that the High Priest will agree to send an authoritative scroll of the Law on which to base the translation to be made for the Library, and to send translators together with it. The translators are selected and the requested scroll is willingly sent to Alexandria to the King. The enterprise is carried out and the will of the King is fulfilled.
The skeleton sketch of the plot appears to be: 1 2 3 4
A preliminary step, which may not have been systematically included: the King wants something which is lacking in Alexandria and which would add to his prestige. The means to achieve the goal: he sends an embassy with a letter and financial means to a destination abroad, in order to have the item requested sent to him in Alexandria. First stage of fulfilment, namely, an importation: the requested item is sent. Final stage of fulfilment of the King’s wishes: the item is settled in its assigned location in Alexandria.
The particulars of the story which flesh out the basic outline in B.Ar. all emphasize the mutual good-will. The story is thoroughly idealized. Typically, the financial means resorted to are splendid gifts. The High Priest is most eager to comply with Ptolemy’s request. The Alexandrian paradigm is recognizable in at least two or three more anecdotes, which are also interesting for the variants in their particulars. All the extant stories are connected with deeds of the Ptolemies, more specifically the first three kings of the dynasty. The scroll of the Law of the Jews and the books of the Athenian tragic poets The closest parallel to B.Ar.’s version of this Alexandrian pattern of storytelling is known from Galen, in his Commentary on the Epidemics of Hippocrates:17 That Ptolemy was so eager about the possession of all ancient books, he says that what he plotted against the Athenians bears no little 42
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
evidence: he gave them a security of 15 talents (= 90,000 drachmas) of silver and took the books of Sophocles, Euripides, and Aeschylus, on the pretext that he only wished to copy them, and would immediately give them back safe. After preparing a costly copy on the very finest quality of papyrus, he kept the books that he received from Athens and sent back the copies he himself had prepared, inviting them to keep the 15 talents and take the new books for the old ones they gave him. As for the Athenians, even if Ptolemy had not sent new books, but retained the old ones, there would have been nothing else left for them to do, and they would have kept the money, according to the agreement that they would keep it if he kept the books. For this reason they took the new books and kept the money.18 The official copy of the works of the three great Athenian fifth-century tragic poets was established in Athens at Lycurgus’ instigation (338–326 BCE) and deposited in the public archives. According to Galen, this copy was obtained by the Alexandrian library under Eratosthenes’ librarianship, in the reign of Ptolemy III Euergetes (247–221 BCE).19 The specific colour given by these particulars is divertingly cynical. The stress is on the tricky behaviour of the King, who is depicted as more greedy for books than for money and ready to resort to any expedient in order to achieve his means.20 This is reminiscent of the tone of chapter 2 of Pseudo-Aristotle’s Economics, a collection of anecdotes relating cunning tricks used by various rulers and cities in order to get money. The first stage of our narrative paradigm is missing in Galen’s account, but is partly provided by his introductory comment. In stages 2 and 3, the financial means involved are represented by the deposit of 15 silver talents, which is aimed at luring the Athenians into handing over the coveted scrolls. The 15 talents are eventually turned by the King into a gesture of mocking generosity towards the stunned Athenians. In the last step, the King’s desire is fulfilled: the best and most authentic edition of the Athenian tragic poets is deposited in his Library.21 The idea underpinning this story is obvious: since copying involved the risk of introducing errors, the only manuscript worthy of the King’s Library was the official Athenian edition. It is, indeed, true that the Ptolemies aimed at endowing their library not only with as many texts as possible, but with the best editions of these texts. The background to this is to be found in the ideology which had infused the work of Alexandrian scholars since Zenodotus, the first head of the library, and which reached its peak with Aristarchus, who was active under Ptolemy VI in the first half of the second century BCE: their deep conviction that the original text of the Greek Classical authors could be retrieved by proper emendation of corrupted manuscripts. This could be achieved simply by careful editorial work on the manuscripts which were at their disposal.22 This ideology was, in fact, 43
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
actively promoted by the Ptolemaic dynasty, and may be said to have been part of the Alexandrian royal propaganda. Since the foundation of the library, either at the instigation of Demetrius of Phalerum under Ptolemy I, or later under Ptolemy II, Alexandrian scholars had been active in gathering authoritative editions of texts from all over the Greek world. As far as the Homeric epics are concerned, official copies from every possible city (the so-called civic editions) were collected in Alexandria. These were considered as the most reliable copies which could serve as a basis for the reconstruction of the ‘original’ text of Homer. Zenodotus, who was probably the first chief librarian, was also the first to establish a critical edition of Homer. He is believed to have selected one copy of Homer, perhaps the Athenian one, as a basis for his work, and to have based his emendations either on other civic editions, or on his own personal assessment. Zenodotus’ method, hampered as it was with arbitrariness, was improved by his successors, down to the edition of Aristarchus which was to supersede all its predecessors around 150 BCE.23 The story of the ‘acquisition’ by Ptolemy III of the official edition of Aeschylus’, Sophocles’ and Euripides’ tragedies established in Athens under Lycurgus shows that as far as other Classical authors besides Homer were concerned, the Alexandrian ideology of the library meant possessing the canonical texts. Explicit statements in the text of B.Ar. make it unambiguously clear that this ideology emanating from the circles of Alexandrian grammarians pervades the story of the embassy to the scroll. The clearest occurrence is found in the written report which Demetrius the Librarian presents to the King at the beginning of B.Ar., in the phase corresponding to stage 1 in the Alexandrian paradigm: 30. Scrolls of the Law of the Jews, together with a few others, are missing [from the Library], for these [works] are written in Hebrew characters and language. But they have been transcribed (sese¯mantai) somewhat carelessly and not as they should be, according to the report of the experts, because they have not received royal patronage. 31. These [books] also must be in your Library in an emended form (die¯kribo¯mena), because this legislation, as could be expected from its divine nature, is very philosophical and genuine.24 The terminology and ideas found in Demetrius’ report sound familiar to anyone acquainted with Alexandrian scholarship. The message encapsulated in the story of the scroll as it is presented in B.Ar. was thus made quite explicit to the original readership right at the beginning of this work: the scroll on which the translation of the LXX had been based in Ptolemy II’s time was the most reliable text, since the King was eager to obtain the official edition of the Law of the Jews kept in Jerusalem. It is implicitly stated in ch. 31 that the copy imported from Jerusalem had undergone thorough 44
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
textual emendation. The Greek verb used, diakriboun, is one of the verbs regularly used to refer to the textual emendations made on the manuscripts of Homer in the grammarians’ undertaking to retrieve the original text.25 It is clear that the motif of the importation is pivotal in our pattern of story-telling in conveying the notion of authenticity and quality, as exemplified both in B.Ar. and in Galen. This impression is strengthened by the association of both the scroll and the translators as objects of the embassy to Eleazar. Since the case of the Law of the Jews involves not only securing the original copy but also translating it, the topic of authenticity and quality is split, in B.Ar., between the scroll and the translators. Not only must the scroll be perfect, but the translators must be too: they are imported together with the scroll. The warranty for good quality is given not to the scroll, but to the translators. This shift deliberately blurs the distinction between official edition and translation. The following chapter in Demetrius’ report reads as follows (ch. 32): If you approve, O King, a letter shall be written to the High Priest at Jerusalem, asking him to dispatch elders of the most exemplary lives and mature experience, skilled in matters pertaining to their Law, six in number from each tribe, so that after the examination of the text agreed by the majority, and the achievement of accuracy in the translation, we may produce an outstanding version in a manner worthy both of the contents and of your purpose. The blurring between the notions of textual emendation and translation is further achieved by the choice of terminology used: the process of translation is described in the same terms as the process of textual criticism implemented by Alexandrian scholars linked to the library, as was first pointed out by Günther Zuntz in a 1959 paper.26 The assimilation was facilitated by the ambiguous meaning of the verb metagraphein, which can express both the ideas of ‘translating’ and ‘transcribing’. The confusion between the processes of translation and transcription in B.Ar. has elicited various comments in modern studies. It has been argued that the author of B.Ar did not have a clear idea of what the process of translation is.27 The hypothesis of a blunder on the part of B.Ar.’s author, however, is not credible. A comparison with the prologue to Ben Sirach (prol. 15–26) as well as the colophon of Esther in its LXX version (LXX Esther 10.3 l) demonstrates that by the time B.Ar. was written the difference between translation and transcription could be made quite clear in the Greek language.28 Various clues in the text suggest that our author was perfectly capable of distinguishing between both processes, had he so wished. At a factual level, the comparison between the script (characte¯res) of the Jews and the arrangement of their letters (he¯ to¯n grammato¯n thesis) by the Egyptians in ch. 11, together with the following clarification in the same chapter that 45
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
the Jews had their own language, demonstrates the necessity of a translation beyond any possible confusion even to the most distracted readers. Our author was capable of distinguishing between the notions of ‘translating’ and ‘transcribing’, or ‘copying’ even at the semantic level, as is proved by his use of two distinct terms in chs 9–11 and in ch. 15: in chs 9, 10 and 15, metagraphe¯ means ‘transcription’, while in ch. 11 hermeneia means ‘translation’ rather than ‘transcription’ or ‘transliteration’. As to the compound verb, diermeneuein, used in ch. 15, Zuntz has underlined the fact that by the Hellenistic period it had come to be used with the specialized meaning of ‘translation’.29 Elsewhere in B.Ar., our writer exploits the potential semantic ambiguity vested in these Greek terms, especially metagraphein. It is hard to escape the conclusion that his ‘confusion’ between both terms and processes was deliberate. The description of the translators at work in chs 301–7 further strengthens the claim that the confusion between translation and transcription was deliberate. First of all, the description of their work in B.Ar. chs 302–3 portrays a close collaboration between the Elders: 302. They set to completing their several tasks, reaching agreement among themselves on each by comparing versions. 303. The result of their agreement thus was made into a fair copy by Demetrius. This picture of the translators at work was already introduced in Demetrius’ initial report to the King. Demetrius referred in it to the future text to be achieved by the translators as the result of an agreement by the majority (ch. 32). In order to understand this passage properly we need to refer to the new standards of textual editions introduced by Aristotle in his school in fourth-century Athens. As one modern scholar has described it, the novelty of Aristotle’s method of work was characterized as: A wide and likewise systematic amassing of information and material for certain purposes, generally in order to make possible a survey of a whole field of knowledge. Close cooperation between the head of the school and his fellow-scholars. And finally, most important of all, the scientific outlook and the strictly scientific method.30 It is believed by many scholars that the Peripatetic school had a decisive and overwhelming influence on the organization of the museum and the library in Alexandria. It would be only logical to infer that Aristotelian influence was also noticeable in the method of work used by the Alexandrian grammarians.31 From this to the claim that the depiction of a team of Elders collectively working on the translation of the LXX, unprecedented in Jewish tradition, echoes the working methods of the grammarians of the library, is only a small step. No wonder that B.Ar. is often considered to be our most 46
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
detailed source of evidence about the working method of the grammarians in Alexandria.32 With hindsight it seems that, apart from the biblical connotations of the precise number of 72 translators, the mere fact of a collective translation would have reminded B.Ar.’s original readers of the work of the Alexandrian grammarians. The translation and interpretation of ch. 305b proposed by Arie van der Kooij points in the same direction:33 They turned to the reading aloud (anagno¯sis) and the interpretation (diasaphe¯sis) of every passage.34 Again, this passage is supposed to describe the translators of the LXX at work. However, van der Kooij compared the two-step technique depicted here with the technique of commenting on Homer implemented by Alexandrian grammarians. Dionysius Thrax, a disciple of Aristarchus, similarly describes two steps: first, the ‘reading aloud’ (anagno¯sis) of a text, which consists in ‘reading “with correct dramatic expression” . . . rendering “correctly the musical side of the words employed” . . . and marking “correctly the intervals” . . .’. This first step is followed by the interpretation (exe¯ge¯sis) of the text, the latter being ‘determined by the poetical tropes’ – Dionysius Thrax is thinking primarily of poetical texts, like Homer.35 The equation of diasaphe¯sis, whose exact meaning has puzzled modern scholars, with the more familiar exe¯ge¯sis makes sense. Thus, the author of B.Ar. is once again equating the practice of the translators with that of the grammarians. In fact, van der Kooij went further and argued for genuine similarities between the technique of the grammarians commenting on Homer and the technique of the translators of the LXX. Arguing that the latter must have been scribes well acquainted with the text they were setting themselves to translate, he reminded us that oriental scribes were primarily trained in ‘reading aloud’ ancestral books. This practice implied two aspects: ‘a clear pronunciation of each word, and a clear intonation related to a division of words into clauses and sentences’. Pronunciation, for a Hebrew text, involves vocalization. However, if we disregard the necessary linguistic differences, the technique used by oriental scribes is comparable with the ‘reading aloud’ applied to Homer by Greek grammarians. As van der Kooij sees it, the translation of the Torah into Greek would thus have involved three steps: the ‘reading’ of the Hebrew at clause or sentence level; the ‘interpretation’ of the Hebrew text, which could relate to ‘words, idioms or clauses’; and the rendering into Greek. In this model, the first two steps may be compared with the work of the Greek grammarians. If we accept this conclusion it may help us understand how the author could so easily make a bridge between translation and editing in his text and in his readers’ minds. Even if we do not follow van der Kooij to his ultimate conclusion, one important point remains clear: the translation of the LXX is equated throughout B.Ar. 47
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
with the process of textual editing and, more specifically, with the kind of work carried out on Homer by the Alexandrian grammarians. This presentation is not the result of a blunder: it is deliberate. In fact, the modern suggestion that B.Ar.’s author did not have a clear view of the difference between the process of translation and that of textual editing was intended to meet a further difficulty raised by ch. 30. Scholars have been puzzled by the argument given by B.Ar.’s author, through Demetrius’ report to the King, justifying the need for a translation of the Law of the Jews. Demetrius refers to manuscripts of the Law carelessly transcribed. An earlier reaction was to try to find a different meaning for the verb ‘sese¯mantai’. The primary meaning of the verb se¯mainein is ‘to signify’. Some scholars sought to support the existence of a derived sense meaning ‘to interpret’ and hence ‘to translate’. This translation was then used to support the interpretation, advocated mainly by Paul Kahle, that the author of B.Ar. was referring to the existence of texts translated into Greek carelessly. Chapter 30 was correspondingly adduced as evidence for the existence of translations of the Torah into Greek before the LXX.36 In an important study, Zuntz showed, both by linguistic analysis and a study of the context in which the Greek word appears, that this ‘derived’ sense is unwarranted.37 The only derived sense supported by the evidence is ‘to write’ or ‘copy’ or ‘transcribe’.38 Zuntz’s conclusions have subsequently been universally accepted. Using this translation, the verb sesemantai in B.Ar., ch. 30, can refer only to Hebrew manuscripts carelessly copied, not to a Greek translation.39 However, Zuntz’s interpretation did not settle the matter entirely. It was still necessary to explain the reference to careless Hebrew manuscripts in ch. 30. Hence, David Gooding’s attempt to find further connotations in the verb semainein,40 or Oswyn Murray’s hypothesis of a blunder on the part of B.Ar.’s author. The problems about the meaning of ch. 30 disappear if we agree to read it in the light of the Alexandrian paradigm. Referring this section of B.Ar. to this narrative paradigm allows a shift in focus in the meaning it conveys. By informing his account with this paradigm, B.Ar.’s author was, first and foremost, interested in convincing his readers that the translation of the LXX was the best possible one, primarily because it was based on the most authentic original. Establishing the quality of the translation was an indispensable prerequisite before he could establish the claim which really mattered for him and which was to be conveyed by the secondary theme of the central narrative: that the LXX is a sacred text. Sacredness implies first of all flawless quality. He presented this quality in the form that was most natural both for him and his well-educated Alexandrian readers, namely, the Alexandrian ideology related to the recovering of original texts by textual emendation as practised by the grammarians subsidized by the Ptolemaic dynasty. The reference to careless Hebrew manuscripts in ch. 30 may be understood not as a realistic description but a symbolic one. (We shall discuss the alternative of understanding it as a retro-projection of 48
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
circumstances in the time of B.Ar.’s author onto the origins of the LXX in Chapter 6.) Whatever the case, this reference to careless manuscripts makes no sense unless we remember the situation current in the field of Homeric studies in Alexandria by the time our author wrote B.Ar. There may be a further implicit message in the deliberate blurring of the distinction between textual editing and translation. In an edited text, the only text which is worth retaining is the one resulting from scholarly efforts. In our present case, the LXX would represent this text, while the Hebrew original is equivalent to poor quality manuscripts. The message may be that the Hebrew original can be forgotten now that the LXX has been achieved. If this reading is correct, this message would parallel the one conveyed by the secondary literary paradigm, as we will see in a moment. The passage from Demetrius’ report quoted above (ch. 30) brings forward a further fundamental element: it illuminates the functional role played by the King and the Library in the story of the translation of the LXX. Concern for retrieving the genuine text is not a simple matter: this involves appropriate financial means to meet the costs of the provision of the requested scroll, as well as, perhaps, the technical means provided by the library and highly trained scholars. In other words, it takes a king to carry out this task properly and adequately. Pinpointing such a functional role for the King and the Library in B.Ar.’s version of the origins of the LXX does not militate a priori in favour of the historical genuineness of these details. On the contrary, it could well foster the view that these details are unhistorical. Any attempt at supporting the historical genuineness of a royal involvement, as will be proposed in the last chapter of this book, must thus remain cautious. The Alexandrian paradigm and the origins of Sarapis A completely different example of the pattern we have called the Alexandrian paradigm is offered by the version of the origins of the god Sarapis which Tacitus chooses to tell in detail in his Histories 4.83–4. Here, one of the first Ptolemies (Tacitus knows of variants involving the first, the second and the third king of that name) has the statue of the god brought from Sinope¯, a city on the shores of the Black Sea. It is worth quoting the text: 83. Where the god Sarapis came from is a problem which has not yet been brought before the attention of the public by Roman writers. The Egyptian priests give the following account. It concerns Ptolemy, the first Macedonian king of Egypt . . . While he was engaged in providing the newly-founded city of Alexandria with walls, temples and religious cults, he dreamed that he met a young man of remarkable beauty and more than human stature, who instructed him to send his most trusty courtiers to Pontus to fetch a statue of himself. This, he said, would cause the kingdom to 49
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
prosper . . . Thereupon, . . . this same youth appeared to ascend into heaven in a blaze of fire. [Ptolemy consults the Egyptian priests about this nocturnal vision. The latter fail to interpret the dream. Ptolemy then consults a priest from Athens, Timotheus.] Timotheus . . . found out that the country [of Pontus] contained a city called Sinope, near which was a temple long famous in the neighbourhood and dedicated to Jupiter Dis. [But Ptolemy forgot about the whole matter]. In the end the same vision appeared before him, now in a more terrifying and urgent aspect and threatening both king and kingdom with ruin unless its orders were obeyed. Then Ptolemy had ambassadors and gifts assembled for an approach to King Scydrothemis, the then ruler of Sinope. [The ambassadors first travel to Delphi]. 84. On reaching Sinope, they addressed the offerings, requests and instructions of their King to Scydrothemis. The latter found it hard to make up his mind. [Three years elapse]. Then a dreadful apparition confronted Scydrothemis in a dream, forbidding him to delay further the purposes of the god. When he still hesitated, he was vexed by all manner of disasters, by plague and by the manifestation of a divine wrath which became daily more grievous. [But the common folk still oppose the move.] At this point, the story became even more impressive, telling how the god embarked of his own accord upon the fleet, which was moored by the coast. Then comes the remarkable account of their sailing into Alexandria after completing the long voyage in only three days. A temple worthy of a great metropolis was built in the quarter called Rhacotis.41 The existence of alternative traditions about the origins of Sarapis bolsters the view that the specific story recorded by Tacitus follows a narrative paradigm.42 In fact, Tacitus’ version of the story is polysemic, in the sense that it combines the basic structure of the Alexandrian paradigm with the structure of the evocatio of a god from one city to another, and likewise the religious elements normally found in stories of the foundation of cults.43 The bestknown example of an evocatio is the introduction of Cybele, the Magna Mater, from Pessinus in Phrygia to Rome (Livy, 29.11.3–8). Other attested cases are the introduction of Asclepius (Livy, 29.11.1), or Camillus’ evocatio of Juno from Veies to Rome (Plutarch, Camillus, 5–6). The most striking parallel to the motif of the evocatio found in the Sarapis story is Ovid’s poetic elaboration of the transfer of Cybele to Rome in Fasti 4.247–349, as was already noted by Isidore Lévy.44 We find the constituent elements of an oracle, which parallels the dream in Tacitus’ account, ordering the fetching of the goddess (that is, her statue), the puzzlement of the senators, the reception of the oracle, the consultation of the priest who elucidates the oracle, the initial refusal by the local King, Attalus, to let the goddess go (while Attalus is 50
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
compliant in Livy’s version), portents and miracles manifesting the goddess’s will to go (in this case, she speaks, as does Juno’s statue in the hands of Camillus). In this variant, in contrast to Tacitus’ story of King Scydrothemis, King Attalus quickly changes his mind and lets the statue go, and the statue is put in the ship by human hands, instead of boarding the ship on her own. However, she had almost boarded on her own on a previous occasion, when Aeneas took the sacred objects from Troy to Italy (Fasti 4.248–52). As in stories of cult foundations, we find in Tacitus’ version of the origins of Sarapis the leitmotif of the reluctance of all to fulfil the will of the god (a motif which is not inherent to stories of evocatio), and the god’s forcing them into eventually obeying him. The Alexandrian pattern is modified accordingly: in stage 1, the initiative comes from the god himself, who sends a dream to the King. The King is first reluctant, but is then compelled by the god to fulfil his will. This first stage is even doubled, as the King forgets about his dream. In stage 2, the embassy is ill-received by the addressee. The latter, both ruler and people, are again reluctant. In the first two stages, time is stretched beyond reasonable measure. In stage 2 again, the initiative is the god’s.45 Then the indispensable miracle takes place, in order to make stage 3 happen. Further elements belonging to the religious setting may be noted: the consultation of priests in stage 1, the journey to Delphi in stage 2.46 Is there a way to assess the presence of a ‘historical kernel’ underlying the various stories shaped on the Alexandrian paradigm? There can be little doubt that it was the feverish gathering of books from overseas under the first Ptolemies, supported by the active royal propaganda around this undertaking that provided the historical basis from which the pattern of story-telling that we have called the Alexandrian paradigm developed. The recurrence of the same literary pattern in various anecdotes revolving round the Alexandrian intellectual institutions is therefore not surprising. Were there only these, we might perhaps believe that this recurrent pattern of story-telling was banally prompted by some recurring behaviourpattern of the Ptolemies. The case of Tacitus, however, shows that the lowest common denominator of the stories reflecting this paradigm was an importation from abroad by one of the (first?) Ptolemies, not specifically the involvement of the library. Tacitus’ text is even more important in that it may provide a concrete example of how the story pattern operated as a narrative paradigm re-shaping the reality in a more or less thoroughly fictional way. Modern scholarship has almost unanimously accepted Ulrich Wilcken’s argument that the origin of the god Sarapis is the Memphite Osor-Hapi. It was pointed out that a slope in the Memphis area bore a name phonetically close to the Greek Sinope, or rather, that Sinopion was the Greek transcription of the name of the temple of Apis in Memphis (Se-n-H . p) which suggests that this may be the source of the confusion at the core of Tacitus’ 51
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
story.47 Rather than a confusion, however, the version given by the Roman historian appears to have evolved out of a false etymology aimed at explaining the god’s epithet of Sino¯pite¯s, which was the kind that the Greek mythographers were so fond of, especially in Hellenistic and Roman times. Etymological word-plays were one of their favourite tools for rationalizing traditional myths: they could be used as springboards for introducing thorough modifications in the original story, in order to make it more palatable to their readers’ taste. For all that, the final literary product would not have offended contemporary standards of intellectual probity. In the case of the origins of Sarapis, all the details converge to foster the view that the narrative pattern is a scholarly construct remote from reality, which is added to the religious elements already pointed out, which may perhaps be the outcome of a folkloristic re-shaping. However, even in this case, the manipulation of facts may be less blatant than would appear a priori. Tacitus’ story is about the statue of the god. There can be little doubt that the iconographic type of the Alexandrian Sarapis was Greek in inspiration, not Egyptian. In Greek religion, as indeed in most religions of the time around the Mediterranean basin and in the Near East, the introduction of a god or a goddess meant in concrete terms the reception into the community of a material symbol of the deity, e.g. a snake in the case of Asclepius or a large stone in the case of the Mother of the Gods from Pessinus in Phrygia.48 Thus, Tacitus’ narrative may have conflated two episodes or two stages in the creation of the Alexandrian god rather than built a narrative out of nothing. Moreover, before dismissing Tacitus’ account as fictional, we should remember that the standards for accepting a discrepancy between the way something ‘really’ happened and its transcription in an acceptable literary form were much looser in Classical Antiquity than they are nowadays. The historian of the Hellenistic period, whether Greek or Roman, was expected to embroider almost as much as he wanted over the thinnest of historical cores. Clichés, conventional images and narrative patterns were the common stock from which he drew freely in order to improve his work rhetorically. In spite of all these adornments, the account would be deemed faithful to the ‘truth’, provided the core of the account reflected actual events. These aspects will be dealt with in more detail in Chapter 4 in connection with B.Ar.’s account. Pinpointing the elements which show similarities with the Alexandrian paradigm is a more rewarding exercise than asking whether the account of the origins of Sarapis preserved by Tacitus is ‘real’ or ‘fictional’. The status of the motif of importation in the origins of the Sarapis cult is particularly important for a comparison with B.Ar.’s account about the origins of the LXX. If we accept Wilcken’s conclusions that the cult of Sarapis originated in Memphis, we may have a case for considering the importation as a fictional element, belonging to the layer of the narrative or literary elaboration. 52
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
However, more recent studies by Ana Swiderek make the matter less clear. This scholar has argued for a pre-Ptolemaic origin for the god, and an early currency in the Mediterranean basin.49 What could be the relationship between the story of Sarapis and the Alexandrian paradigm, which seems to be more specifically centred on the library? It would seem that the basic pattern of the Alexandrian paradigm was a secularized derivation from the pattern of the evocatio stories.
The secondary theme: equating the status of the LXX with that of the Hebrew Law As already noted, the main and secondary themes of the central narrative in B.Ar. are not only closely intertwined in the overall narrative structure of the work, they are also intimately connected as far as their narrative function goes. Both of them contribute to building up the dimension of charter myth, each supplying a different angle of meaning. The main theme is concerned with the quality of the translation, in two important respects: the quality of the manuscript on which the translation was based, and its fidelity to the Hebrew original. This latter concern is articulated through the praise given to the eminent qualities of the translators. The secondary theme is made up of three episodes. Together they form the outline of a rewriting of the story of the Exodus; we will call this the Exodus paradigm. The function of the Exodus paradigm in B.Ar. is easier to pin down than was the case with the main theme. This paradigm equates the story of the translated Law, the LXX, with the story of the original Hebrew Law, the Torah. Equating their stories is, implicitly, a way of equating the status of both texts. By the end of B.Ar., the LXX has been turned into the sacred text of the Alexandrian Jews who, in turn, stand for the whole people of Israel. The first episode of the triptych composing the Exodus paradigm is set at the beginning of B.Ar.’s account, while the last one is the last important scene of the text, the proclamation of the translation in Alexandria. The middle episode, the selection of the translators in Jerusalem, is located more or less midway through the work. Thus, the Exodus paradigm provides the text with its fundamental narrative framework. This is an additional clue to its importance. The first episode: the liberation of the Jewish slaves The first episode corresponds to the account of the origins of the Jews in Egypt. It deals with two chronological stages together: first, the arrival of the Jews in Egypt as prisoners of war turned into slaves under Ptolemy I, and then their subsequent liberation by Ptolemy II at Aristeas’ request (chs 12–27 and 33–7). Interestingly, the main section (chs 12–27) is bracketed 53
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
between Demetrius’ initial oral report to the King that he does not have the Law of the Jews in his Library (chs 9–11) and the Librarian’s formal written report re-stating the matter (chs 28–32). Chapters 33–7, in turn, contain a re-statement of the episode included in Ptolemy’s letter to Eleazar, with the introduction of some new elements. This arrangement, narrowly intertwining the beginning of the two themes that compose the central narrative in an a-b-a-b sequence, is hardly accidental. It shows once more the care taken in the composition of the work. The text of the first section is found in chs 12–14, as follows: 12. I considered that it was an opportunity in connection with matters on which I had often asked [Sosibius and Andreas], concerning the release of those deported from Judaea by the father of the King. He invaded the whole of Coele-Syria and Phoenicia, and . . . deported some and took others prisoners, bringing everything into subjection by fear. In the course of this he removed from the land of the Jews into Egypt up to one hundred thousand people, 13. from whom he armed about thirty thousand chosen men and settled them throughout the land in forts. [Aristeas mentions earlier immigration under the Persians and even earlier under Psammetichus] 14. . . . [Ptolemy son of Lagus] selected the best, outstanding in youth and strength, and armed them. The remaining number, old men, children, and women also, he let go into slavery . . . There can be little doubt that there is a core of historical reality in the circumstances of the arrival of the Jews in Egypt in the early Hellenistic period as depicted in this section. Documentary papyri bear witness to the presence in Egypt of slaves from the Near East. These are usually referred to as Syrians, but among these ‘Syrians’, some bear distinctively Jewish names, and are therefore certainly ethnic Jews.50 One papyrus mentions prisoners of war settled in the countryside, following a war with Syria,51 although we do not have any concrete evidence that Jews arrived in Egypt in this way. Papyri document the presence of Jews among the military settlers in the chora, the Egyptian countryside, as early as the third century BCE, but we do not know their origin.52 As for the pre-Hellenistic period, we know for certain that there were Jewish mercenaries in the service of Persian rulers. The literary evidence from the Bible has been corroborated beyond any doubt by the discovery of the Aramaic papyri from Elephantine.53 The author of B.Ar. was elaborating on the collective memory and real experience of his Alexandrian Jewish readership. Likewise, the statement that Ptolemy I conquered Judaea and the surrounding areas using harsh measures reflects some sort of historical situation. A recent study by Bezalel Bar-Kochva relying on the quite considerable amount of external literary evidence corroborates this conclusion.54 54
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
However, this historical core hardly warrants treating this passage of B.Ar. as a factual reference worthy of being featured in the footnotes of serious modern scholarly works alongside other literary or papyrological evidence – and there are, indeed, plenty of modern works which take B.Ar. seriously.55 The problem can be summed up in one simple observation. That there is some historical truth in the fact that some Jews were brought to Egypt as slaves is one thing – although B.Ar.’s account claims that most of the Jewish presence in Egypt originated in slavery, which is questionable on historical grounds. That the author of B.Ar. opted to present the early history of the Jews in Egypt in this light, perhaps the most ignominious one possible, is quite another matter. This choice is all the more suspicious since B.Ar. is not the only extant text in the Alexandrian Jewish literature to give an account of the way the Jews arrived in Egypt in early Hellenistic times. Comparison with the version given by Pseudo-Hecataeus is instructive: Hecataeus goes on to say that after the battle of Gaza [in 312 BCE] Ptolemy became master of Syria, and that many of the inhabitants, hearing of his kindliness and humanity, desired to accompany him to Egypt and to associate themselves with his realm. ‘Among these (Hecataeus says) was Ezechias, a High Priest of the Jews, a man of about sixty-six years of age, highly esteemed by his countrymen, well-learned in his soul, and moreover an able speaker and experienced as no one else as a statesman. [. . .] This man, after obtaining an honour [from Ptolemy?] assembled some of his friends and read them [a statement showing] all the advantages [of their settlement in Egypt]; for he had in writing the conditions attaching to their settlement and their status.’56 The contrast with B.Ar.’s version could not be more blatant. Submission by terror in one text, ‘kindliness and humanity’ in the other, both describe Ptolemy I Soter’s conquest of Judaea. The important point that arises from comparing these accounts shows that there were various accounts circulating among Alexandrian Jews about the origins of the Jews in Egypt. Had the author of B.Ar. wanted to give a more self-gratifying one, he could have done so.57 The fact is that he did not. That his story seems ‘plausible’ to us is irrelevant for the correct appreciation of this passage and the author’s intention in writing it this way. The fact that he himself did not feel quite comfortable with his own version may be seen in the form in which the topic detailed in chs 12–14 is introduced in the proemium of B.Ar.: in ch. 4 no explicit reference to slavery is to be found, the nomenclature describing the abduction of the Jews to Egypt is that of colonization.58 These remarks lead us to conclude that the author of B.Ar. was primarily interested in drawing a parallel between the contemporary history of the 55
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
Jews in Egypt and their history in ancient times – the history of the biblical period. In the Book of Exodus Jews were made slaves in Egypt. The real purpose of the parallel with the account of Exodus can be best understood, however, if we shift the focus from the account of the arrival of the Jews in Egypt as slaves to the later part of the story, their liberation by Ptolemy II. The account of the liberation of the slaves is told at some length (chs 12–27), including a copy of the royal decree stipulating this measure in chs 22–5. Here, Ptolemy is acting in the role of Pharaoh. Contrary to his biblical counterpart, however, the Ptolemaic King is staged as a benevolent Pharaoh, willingly liberating the Jews at Aristeas’ request. Nor is Ptolemy short of lavish gestures: he is ready to incur huge expenses to carry out this good deed (chs 19–20). If we accept this reading, then one specific element, which appears in the re-statement of the episode in Ptolemy’s letter to Eleazar in ch. 37, gets a new connotation: 37. We have freed more than a hundred thousand prisoners . . . Those at the peak of their youth we have appointed to the army, and those who are able to be at our court, being worthy of confidence in our household, we have put in charge of (some) ministries. Heirs of the biblical Joseph have thus been raised to provide wise advisers to the new Pharaoh.59 Ptolemy’s willingness to set the Jews free has an important consequence. In the Bible, the Jews escape from Egypt not only to material freedom, but also to be given the Law on Mount Sinai, before they are finally led into the Promised Land. Ptolemy’s benevolence means that there is now no need to flee. The Law can and will be received in Alexandria. B.Ar. is the story of a non-Exodus. The second episode: the selection of the Elders in Jerusalem The second episode which builds up the equation between the story of the LXX and that of the Hebrew Law is the selection of the Elders in Jerusalem (chs 46–50). Functionally speaking, this is a preparatory step to the third and last episode in which the analogy culminates: the proclamation of the translation in Alexandria. The close link between both passages has already been underlined by Harry Orlinsky.60 In the letter he sends in reply to King Ptolemy, Eleazar the High Priest informs the King that ‘in the presence of all, we selected Elders, honourable men and true, six from each tribe, with whom we have sent the book of the Law’ (ch. 46).61 Appended to the end of Eleazar’s letter is a list of the names of the Elders, arranged by tribe. The tribes are numbered, but not named (chs 47–50). 56
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
Two elements in this passage are significant: the revival of the twelve tribes of Israel, as well as the number of Elders selected – six Elders per tribe, multiplied by twelve tribes, which makes 72 Elders. The selection of the Elders is said to be done ‘in the presence of all’ (paronto¯n panto¯n). Who is meant by this? The author obviously plays on the ambiguity: two levels of reading are involved in this episode as a whole. On the face of it we are in a Greek polis, witnessing a process of appointment of representatives of the civic body of whatever kind – officials, judges or ambassadors. The selection of the Elders took place right after the High Priest read Ptolemy’s letter to the people who had been called up for a gathering (‘synagagontes to pan ple¯thos’ (ch. 42)). The ‘plethos’ is the civic body of Jerusalem. Here, as in any Greek city, the civic body, the demos or plethos, is divided into civic tribes. The number of officials appointed is proportional to the number of tribes. According to the circumstances they may be selected at a rate of one per tribe, or ten, forty or fifty per tribe. Lists of any grouping of citizens, such as officials, ephebes, or soldiers fallen in the battlefield, would be arranged by tribe, as shown in so many public inscriptions. In Athens the tribes could be listed by numerical order. A civic paradigm is thus easily recognizable in the process of selection of the Elders in B.Ar. The number twelve is even plausible in the context of a polis. From the end of the sixth century BCE on, Athens had ten, and, even more interestingly, Plato’s ideal city in the Republic had twelve tribes. Thus, the civic reference lends perfect verisimilitude to the revival of the biblical tribes of Israel far into the Hellenistic period. Moreover, the assimilation of the biblical tribes to civic ones was already familiar to B.Ar.’s author and probably also to its readers: Hecataeus of Abdera’s description of Judaea preserved in a quotation by Diodorus already conceived of it in terms of a polis (Diodorus, 40.3).62 We may perhaps surmise that the author of B.Ar. was directly influenced by Hecataeus in the present case, as in many others. But this need not necessarily be the case. After all, Jerusalem is described as the ideal Greek polis in the Travelogue (chs 83–120), so that the division of its plethos into tribes is only a matter of coherence.63 The level of reading that conveys the real meaning of our section, however, is the biblical one. The designation of the Elders ‘in the presence of all’, together with their selection by tribe, turns them into delegates of the whole people of Israel. In the scene of the proclamation of the Torah discussed below they stand symbolically for the whole people of Israel: the newly translated Law is read to the Jews ‘in their presence’ (ch. 308), just as they were selected ‘in the presence of the whole people’ in Jerusalem. As Orlinsky has pointed out, following Meecham, the word plethos, which appears both in ch. 42, and in this same ch. 308, in the phrase ple¯thos to¯n Ioudaio¯n, the ‘plethos of the Jews’, ‘is used [in both these instances] (as elsewhere, e.g. in I and II Macc. and in Acts) “in an official sense” ’. Orlinsky, therefore, translates ‘the Jewish people’, rather than ‘the community of the Jews’ (ch. 308).64 This 57
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
rendering fits the occurrence in ch. 42 too – all the more so as official Greek nomenclature used the same term, ‘demos’ or ‘plethos’, to speak either of the whole body of citizens or of the civic assembly. The real purpose of the biblical paradigm is revealed in the number of Elders selected: 72 was as close as the author of B.Ar. could get to 70 if he wished to keep to a civic model, which implied selecting a strictly even number of representatives from each tribe. This explains the number of Elders selected per tribe, six, which is somewhat unparalleled in Greek civic practice. Seventy, as many commentators have already pointed out, was the number of Elders who accompanied Moses, together with Aaron, Nadab and Abihu, to Mount Sinai for the gift of the Law (Exodus 24.1 and 9).65 That 70 was the ‘true’ number of Elders behind the civic fiction of 72, was plainly understood by the later tradition about the Greek translation of the Pentateuch: its name, Septuaginta (70), was formally derived from the legend of the translators, while emphasizing at the same time the reference to Exodus 24. Whether the name of the translation, Septuaginta, is an alteration of the legend as related in B.Ar., or is genuine, while B.Ar.’s 72 is a secondary elaboration, cannot be decided. The answer depends on whether B.Ar. was the point of departure of the legend, or a scholarly re-writing of an oral tradition already in circulation by the author’s days. The new Revelation: the proclamation of the translation in Alexandria (chs 308–11) The scene of the proclamation of the newly achieved translation to the Jews gathered in Alexandria has been the subject of two important studies by Harry Orlinsky and André Paul. In the main the following will be a summary of their papers.66 As soon as the translation is completed, the Jews of Alexandria are called to a gathering and the new text read out to them (ch. 308). The reading is followed by the acclamation of the Jews – either the Jewish community of Alexandria, or the Jewish people: the dual layer of meaning is to be read into this section too. Then the leaders of the Jews stand up and make the following statement: ‘Since this was translated rightly and reverently, and in every respect accurately, it is good that it should remain as it is, and that there should be no revision’ (ch. 310).67 There follows a malediction uttered by the whole people against anyone who might make any addition or change to the text (ch. 311). As Orlinsky has convincingly shown, the successive elements in this scene correspond in an accurate manner to the ‘biblical procedure in designating a document as official and binding, in other words, as divinely inspired, as Sacred Scripture’. The most important biblical parallel to the reading aloud of a text followed by an acclamation by the whole people is Ex. 24.3–7, which is part of the Revelation at Mount Sinai. The pledge or oath not to 58
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
change the text in any manner, followed by a curse against trespassers, amounts to a deed of canonization, as in Deut. 4.1–2.68 Orlinsky’s analysis is convincing; it is also supported by philological reminiscences of LXX Deut. in B.Ar. But this is not the whole story. Here, as in so many other instances in his work, the author of B.Ar. seems to be combining two models: a Jewish, and in this case, a biblical model, and a Greek one. The process described in chs 308–11 is not unlike the process of the promulgation of official editions of texts of the classical authors in Greek cities. There was presumably something similar in Alexandria from the moment the library was organized. This may be inferred from the text of Pseudo-Plutarch describing the establishment and enforcement of the State edition of the tragedies of Aeschylus, Sophocles and Euripides in Athens under Lycurgus’ leadership, which reads as follows: Lycurgus passed three laws, [the second was] . . . to transcribe and keep in the public archives their tragedies [i.e. of Aeschylus, Sophocles and Euripides], and the public secretary was to read them aloud (paranagino¯skein) for collation to the actors; for it was not permitted to make a performance in discrepancy with them.69 The same verb, paranagi(g)no¯sko¯, is used both by Pseudo-Plutarch and in B.Ar., 308. According to H.G. Liddell and R. Scott’s Greek-English Lexicon, this word has two meanings. The first – ‘read beside, compare, collate one document with another’ – is regularly used in judicial contexts to point to the reading aloud of laws.70 Pseudo-Plutarch’s text evidently uses it in this sense. However, the occurrence in B.Ar. fits the second definition better: ‘to read publicly’. This sense echoes the biblical scene, as Orlinsky has pointed out. But we may suspect that the author of B.Ar. was perfectly well aware of the further connotations of the word he was using when he described the scene of the proclamation of the translation. Once again, the translated work is equated to an edition of a text. It is not clear whether Demetrius is reading a translation, or an official edition of the Jewish Law. A mark of compositional coherence in B.Ar. is the fact that both components of the central narrative complement each other, both in their content and at a structural level. Both contribute to build up the status of the LXX as a sacred text. Together they testify that the translation was made out of a perfect scroll, was perfect itself, and was acclaimed as such by official recognition, following the regular procedure of ratification and canonization. This was not enough, however. The author of B.Ar. apparently felt that one further crucial question needed to be addressed in order to buttress the claim conveyed by the main threads of his narrative: did the new text enjoy divine consent, beyond the human recognition? The answer to this question is carefully built in the text, through what may be recognized as a further, though more diluted, secondary theme: the motif of piety. 59
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
Divine consent: the motif of piety Right after the translation is read out to the Jews and then to the King, a crucial question is raised: ‘How is it that after such great works were (originally) completed, none of the historians or poets took it on himself to refer to them?’, the King asks Demetrius (ch. 312). Demetrius replies that attempts to refer to this text were made, but failed, because the reckless writers ‘were smitten by God’ and had to ‘refrain from their design’ (ch. 313). Demetrius then illustrates his assertion with two examples, one from a historian, Theopompus (chs 314–15), the other from a tragic poet, Theodectus (ch. 316). There are, in fact, two different questions at once in this section. The first, as we have just seen, is articulated explicitly. Such questions as ‘Why did the Greek writers not speak about us or quote our Law?’, and the like, were an object of concern among Alexandrian Jews. The whole of the first book of Josephus’ Against Apion deals with exactly this kind of issue. In the competition for cultural prestige in the Hellenistic East, being mentioned by ancient writers was crucial. For the Greeks, only Greek writers were of any import. The answer provided by B.Ar.’s author to this anxious question differs from that of Josephus. Josephus (or his Alexandrian source) emphasizes that the Jews were mentioned by other ancient and respected people, if not by the Greeks. Our author tells us that such quotation was impossible, due to the sacred nature of the Law of the Jews. Theopompus and Theodectus tried and failed. The reader might be tempted to ask a further question here, wondering what text Theopompus and Theodectus could have used in their unfortunate attempts, since they are not supposed to have had access to the original Hebrew. However, this question is simply evaded in our text, since it is irrelevant. The King completely ignores the language barrier in his question to Demetrius. The newly proclaimed text as presented in B.Ar. is definitely more of an edition, supported by an act of transcription, than a translation. As a consequence, the new translation is not equated with the Law, it is the Law, both from now on and retroactively.71 This is not the only place where the author of B.Ar. incidentally tackles an issue which was very much in the air amid Alexandrian Jewry. His insistence that Hebrew is distinct from Syrian, in ch. 11, probably reflects the same kind of concern. This remark is superfluous to the context of the section to which it belongs. Its incidental insertion, then, is better understood as meeting an external concern. The thrust of the incidents involving Theopompus and Theodectus, however, lies elsewhere. Their example demonstrates that not just anyone is entitled to manipulate the sacred text, either to use it, or to translate or transcribe it. Literary skills and learning are not enough. A further quality is needed in order to avoid bringing divine wrath upon the reckless: since Demetrius explicitly names the sacred nature of the Law as the reason why Greek writers failed to make use of it in their 60
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
writings (ch. 313), this quality must be piety. Even Greeks as acceptable as Theopompus and Theodectus do not qualify for the task. It does not matter who Theopompus and Theodectus were in historical terms: there can be little doubt that the author of B.Ar. picked them out as emblematic examples because of their names. Both bear theophoric names which point to the right God, not to Zeus or Athena. Needless to say, their names are programmatic: they stand as symbols for their personalities. In other words, one does not need to be a sworn pagan to be smitten by God for having dealings with the sacred text. Only the most pious men are entitled to do so. The author has carefully prepared the ground for this culminating scene. The mere fact that not one of the many persons involved in the process of translation of the Law was smitten by God, unlike Theopompus and Theodectus, means that their enterprise enjoyed divine approval. This was given because all the persons involved were demonstrably pious individuals. Indeed, the motif of piety and religious reverence is central in B.Ar., as is clear from the fact that it is explicitly mentioned in two key sections of the work: the word ‘piety’ (eusebeia) itself appears in the proem (ch. 2). The related idea of reverence of the Divine is found in the statement about the quality of the translation issued by the leaders of the Jewish community in Alexandria after the Law was read out to the gathering of the Jews (ch. 310): Since this was translated rightly and reverently (hosio¯s), and in every respect accurately . . .72 The motif of piety further underpins the attitude of each individual who is involved in any way in the process of the translation/edition. A short review will easily demonstrate this point. We may leave aside the High Priest of the Jews: he may be considered pious, as it were, ex officio. The piety of the 72 Elders is demonstrated by their daily ritual: they wash their hands in the sea to pray to God before engaging in the translation (ch. 305). While Greeks would care for their body, the Elders care for their souls: hand washing is a token of innocence, as they explain to the inquiring Aristeas (ch. 306). They had previously displayed their concern for God in the Symposium. While a Greek would have been content simply with a philosophical comment in his reply to the King’s questions, each one of the Elders ends his reply with a reference to God (chs 187–300). As for the King, his piety can be adduced from various actions. The most obvious is his bowing before the scroll of the Law when the Elders arrive from Jerusalem, an action which he repeats before the scroll of the translation (chs 177 and 317). Needless to say, the similarity of the King’s attitude towards both scrolls emphasizes still further the similarity between both Laws, the old, brought from Jerusalem, and the new, now revealed in Alexandria. Likewise, the lavish gifts that Ptolemy sends to Jerusalem 61
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
together with his request for an authoritative scroll are intended for the Temple. In his description of the table, the author/narrator repeatedly insists that the King restrained his desire for lavishness out of respect for divine prescriptions. The dimensions of the table are kept modest, in order to fit both the written prescriptions of the Law and ritual needs. Only where the Law was silent did the King allow splendour to prevail (chs 52–6). Even more important in the present context is his liberation of the Jewish slaves. This deed is suggested to the King by Aristeas, but the King is only too ready to comply with the request. In some way, this episode may be credited both to the King’s and to Aristeas’ merits. Aristeas, in fact, presents this matter as a logical side-effect of the King’s decision to have the Law of the Jews translated. This link is not to be understood in the practical, but in the ethical sense. The translation needs a justification (logos), and it would be impossible to give any if so many Jews had remained slaves in Ptolemy’s kingdom, argues Aristeas (ch. 15). Their freedom is a necessary prerequisite, all the more so, he adds, because ‘the (same) God who has given them their Law guides your kingdom also, as I have learned in my researches’ (ibid.).73 Thus, for Ptolemy, liberating the Jews is tantamount to acknowledging that the Law of the Jews binds him too. Incidentally, the word ‘piety’ itself (eusebeia) appears in the edict of liberation issued by the King (ch. 24). One last item is to be put to the King’s credit: at Ptolemy’s court, live Greek officers who, on the evidence of their names, are no mere pagans. The King’s servants are named Sosibius, Andreas, Aristeas, Nicanor, and his subordinate Dorotheus (chs 12, 43, 182–3) and, even, the philosopher Menedemus of Eretria (ch. 201). One conspicuous exception to this rule is, of course, Demetrius the Librarian. As the case of Theopompus, Theodectus and Menedemus shows, the fact that Demetrius was a well-known figure is not a sufficient explanation of why the author of B.Ar. should have included a person with such a pagan name in his narrative. The assumption that he was bound by a pre-existing oral tradition about Demetrius seems to be the best explanation – we shall come back to this point in Chapter 4. Aristeas’ piety hardly needs elaboration. Piety is an important topic of the introduction of his letter to Philocrates (ch. 2). There, Aristeas emphasizes his own concern for religious matters and later claims that this is why he was chosen as an ambassador to Eleazar the High Priest (ch. 3). Aristeas does not miss any opportunity either to inquire about the Law of the Jews before competent authorities: the so-called ‘Apology for the Law’ by the High Priest is prompted by a question from him (chs 128–9). Aristeas displays the same curiosity and concern for understanding with the Elders (ch. 306). He has inquired enough about the God of the Jews to feel confident to tell the King about His nature and His powers (chs 15–16); these statements come as a preliminary to his request to set the Jewish slaves free, a matter which had been of concern to him for some while (ch. 12). 62
THE CENTRAL NARRATIVE
1111 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
Demetrius has a discrete and, in fact, crucial place in this series. Demetrius initiated the translation by alerting the King to the need to have the Law of the Jews included in his Library. However, he does this out of professional concern: it was his task to collect all the books in the world for the Library and to be vigilant about possible gaps (ch. 9). Again, his role in the translation as well as in the scene of proclamation of the Law is purely technical: he writes the translation down, but under the Elders’ dictation (ch. 302). He gathers the Jews together for the reading, and is asked to hand a copy of the translation over to their leaders (chs 308–9). Indeed, he is acclaimed by the Jewish plethos together with the translators (ibid.). Beside these discrete actions, Demetrius’ piety is eventually disclosed in the final scene: he is the one who acknowledges the Law as divine, by giving the correct answer to the King’s puzzled query as to why the Law had thus far never been mentioned by either a historian or a poet: ‘because the Law was holy and had come from God’ (ch. 313).74 With such a cluster of figures involved in the translation and transcription, the new Law was duly entitled to receive divine consent. The omnipresence of the piety motif throughout the work adds a religious tint to the otherwise highly ‘scientific’ tone of the narrative: innumerable details are included in the text to build up the status of the narrative as a true account. Thus, the same blending of myth and history that is recognizable in the central narrative of B.Ar. also appears throughout the work in its secondary motifs. The working out of the piety motif, however, is quite straightforward in the text. The elaboration on the credibility, indeed the veracity of the narrative is, on the contrary, a far more complex matter. All the rhetorical and technical means standing at the disposal of an ancient historian are implemented. In order to understand this properly, however, one has to realize what ‘history’ was in the Hellenistic period. This topic will be examined in more detail in the next chapter.
63
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
4 ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY The rhetoric of historiography in the Book of Aristeas
Back in the 1950s, Moses Hadas did not take B.Ar. seriously. Nor did he believe that its author himself did, or his original readers. After discussing the tri-partite division of narrative (narratio) commonly accepted by ancient grammarians, namely, ‘true history’, ‘false history’ and ‘quasi-true history’ or plasma, he concludes: Aristeas [i.e. B.Ar.] is a plasma, and its chief purpose, in the intention of the author and the understanding of the reader, is to produce a general ethical effect rather than to communicate trustworthy historical data. The author is neither the impostor nor plagiarist we should have to label him if we thought that he expected his implications as to his own person and date to be believed.1 Plasma, in Hadas’ definition, is ‘an imaginative treatment of history which should, however, preserve historical verisimilitude and present a higher “poetical” truth’.2 Hadas’ assessment of B.Ar. sounded fairly reasonable in the 1950s. Half a century later, it needs serious emendation. Numerous studies have been dedicated since then to the concept of fiction as defined in the theoretical works of Graeco-Roman grammarians and rhetoricians. These studies all stress that the criteria for distinguishing between the ‘true narrative’ usually identified by ancient theoreticians with history, and ‘quasi-true history’ in Classical rhetoric are thoroughly at odds with modern ones.3 Concomitant studies on Graeco-Roman historiography have shown that the articulation of a ‘true report’ in prose writing was ruled by norms quite different from our own. We may add that Hellenistic historiography shares many of the features that have been described as characterizing Roman Republican works of history. The conclusions reached by recent works on Roman historiography may, therefore, be profitably adduced as evidence for our own study of B.Ar.4 65
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
The first conclusion to be derived from these converging re-assessments of the notion of ‘true narrative’ in Classical culture is that the author of B.Ar. meant his readers to take him seriously. In fact, this is exactly what he says in the concluding sentence of his work, which was discussed in Chapter 2. Two distinct, though related, aspects are implied in the definition of B.Ar. as a true narrative. One has to do with the author’s bona fides and intentions. Lest we maintain the old view that the author of B.Ar. was a ‘liar’, we need to accept two basic assumptions. First, insofar as B.Ar.’s author was re-using previous material as sources for his own work, we must assume that he was confident about its historical reliability. More importantly, we must admit that the literary means he resorted to in writing his account do not infringe the conventions about ‘truth-telling’ which were normative in his own days. These literary devices would include the use of first-person narrative combined with a fictitious persona for the narrator, the composition of documents and the modelling of B.Ar.’s account on narrative paradigms. The second aspect concerns the readers’ reception of the work. The claim that B.Ar. functioned as a true narrative implies a positive response to it on the part of the targeted readers. It can, in fact, be shown that none of the aspects of B.Ar. that bother modern critics would have had the same effect on the original readership. Chronological and factual inaccuracies, the blending of fact and fiction – none of these would have undermined the reliability of the narrative in the eyes of the author’s contemporary readers. Even the fictitious persona of the narrator may have created more confusion in modern readers than in ancient ones. The tacit convention between author and readers about the fictitious persona of the narrator was certainly much less instrumentalist than some modern commentators would have it, since it probably did not occur to anyone among the readers, and certainly not to the author, that B.Ar. could be intended for outsiders. The present chapter will address itself to these issues, focusing first on the author’s side and on the rhetorical means he used to enforce the status of his account as a true story, and then on aspects related to readers’ reception.
Enforcing reliability with the tools of a historian Hadas’ contention that the author of B.Ar. was writing a fictitious story for the sake of entertainment was his way to absolve our author from the charge of cheating his readers. Hadas’ solution, however, completely misses the author’s real purpose, because he was reading him with modern eyes. A correct assessment of the author’s intention in B.Ar. means we must re-site the rhetorical means he uses to compose his story in their original intellectual context. This involves dealing, first of all, with the literary conventions of writing a true account that were current at the time. 66
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
Features such as ego-narrative and the insertion of documents of dubious genuineness have been pounced on by modern critics as proofs for the poor historical value of the work. They supposedly disclose the author’s lack of bona fides. In fact, these various elements are demonstrably accepted devices used by Greek historians and, by extension, all writers who wished to lend their work a guise of historicity in Antiquity. Generally speaking, comparison with the common practices of Hellenistic historiography shows that B.Ar.’s author implemented all the technical and rhetorical means at the disposal of contemporary historians to lend his narrative the indispensable note of trustworthiness that he aimed at. Most of the aspects in B.Ar. that have most puzzled modern scholars can be read back into this perspective. First-person narrative: the author of the Book of Aristeas and ‘lying historians’ Ego-narrative, the channel for eyewitness testimony, expressed the ideal stance of ancient historians. In prose writing the authorial ‘I’ is first and foremost that of Herodotus, as well as of a long tradition of historians in his wake.5 The distinction between autopsy (first-hand eyewitness testimony) and akoe¯ (report of a story either heard from a witness, or read in a written record or an earlier historical work) dates back to Herodotus, and was later refined by Polybius.6 All ancient historians insisted on the precedence of the former over the latter, beginning with Herodotus.7 Personal involvement in the events they wished to report was still occasionally invoked by historians of the Hellenistic period both as their main incentive and as a justification for writing.8 The use of ego-narrative in B.Ar. fulfils the same function as the authorial ‘I’ in Greek historiography. It strengthens the claim to truth-telling in the narrative. This equation, however, requires some further qualification. In the Hellenistic period, factual report deriving from historical ‘inquiry’ diversified into a whole range of genres, from reliable historiography to novelistic works. The resort to first-person narrative followed this trend. Because of its positive connotations, this narrative mode was frequently adopted by authors wishing to lend a guise of veracity to their account. Egonarrative was used in works of the most varied kinds that are today recognized as fictional, but whose status their authors deliberately sought to blur. Greek novels – although not the earliest – belong here. Apuleius’ Metamorphoses (or Golden Ass) and Achilles Tatius’ Leucippe and Clitophon are told in the first person.9 Among earlier works, travelogues such as those of Iambulus and Euhemerus, which are known mainly through Diodorus’ summaries, seem to have been ego-narratives.10 The ‘we-passages’ in the somewhat later Acts of the Apostles may also be noted here, since this work has sometimes been compared with the genre (or sub-genre) of travelogues.11 67
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
Closely related to travelogues are some paradoxographical writings, such as the Letter of Alexander to Aristotle about India – also an ego-narrative, as its name implies.12 There is indirect evidence that this means was indeed efficient in blurring the boundaries between factual and fictional report. As we saw in Chapter 2, Reinhold Merkelbach argued that the author of the Alexander Romance treated the letters he inserted in his narrative as factual documents.13 A further clue is provided by the important discussion about Euhemerus and Pytheas’ accounts that will be examined below. However, the case of the Letter about India makes it clear that even authors writing in genres which were easily identifiable as fanciful – or more accurately, as ‘lying stories’ – by ancient criteria, resorted to the stance of the ego-narrative and explicitly claimed to be writing true narratives. Even in these cases, the stance of autopsy conveyed by the first-person narrative was seen as a means of demonstrating the truth-value of the account, which was all the more necessary the more incredible the contents. Indeed, works of this kind were the target of fierce parody by Seneca and Lucian, showing up the fact that historiography had become a blanket-genre for paradoxography, romances and all sorts of fanciful accounts carelessly jostling verisimilitude.14 In short, all kinds of literary genres whose common denominator was a desire to blur the boundary between factual report and fiction, novels as well as what Niklas Holzberg has labelled ‘fringe genres’ of the novel (such as travelogues),15 were potential bidders to take over the characteristics of historical narrative. Ancient ‘serious’ historians had no means of differentiating their works from romancing counterfeits. A priori, this leaves open the possibility that the author of B.Ar., like the romancers, was deliberately cheating his readership. However, B.Ar. is not a work of mere entertainment. Our author’s stance is better compared to that of Euhemerus and other authors of social utopias and religious pamphlets of this kind. In their case, the guise of truth-telling techniques was aimed at bolstering the impact of the message conveyed. From this point of view, Euhemerus and B.Ar. come close to the pseudepigraphical letters ascribed to leading philosophical figures of the Classical period or to other prominent characters such as Alexander the Great, which proliferated in Hellenistic and Roman times.16 As already noted in passing, one particular detail precludes the possibility that B.Ar.’s author conceived of his work as a kind of novel aimed at pure entertainment: the thorough rationalization of the narrative. The complete absence of paradoxography in the Travelogue (the Journey to Jerusalem) is particularly conspicuous. It is well known that in the wake of authors like Ctesias in the late fifth century BCE, many writers of history indulged in inserting descriptions of wonders, portents and miracles in their work. Accounts of journeys to remote countries such as India were the pretext for 68
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
long catalogues mixing up strange human beings and monsters of the most scaring appearance and amazing customs, to their readers’ great delight. Contemporary taste was so fond of this kind of literature that paradoxography soon evolved into a distinct genre. Nothing of this kind is found in B.Ar. The Journey to Jerusalem may be contrasted with Iambulus’ account of his own journey, as epitomized in Diodorus 2.55–60. Although Iambulus was depicting a social utopia, like the author of B.Ar., he could not resist indulging in paradoxographical touches.17 Broadly speaking then, it is quite striking that B.Ar. displays only the most respectable features of contemporary prose writing. It would seem that the interwoven dimension of charter myth prompted the author to refrain from inserting purely entertaining features in his narrative, in order to establish his work as an account of undisputable veracity. Thus, B.Ar. may well provide us with a rare case of dissociation between true narrative and entertainment – if we leave aside the feature of variation examined in Chapter 2. It will, therefore, be interesting to look at the wide array of conventional topics normally expected in Hellenistic works of history and see what the author of B.Ar. retains and what he leaves out. The items he drops, like paradoxographical clichés and long set speeches are, indeed, precisely those which elicited the most violent attacks from ancient critics of historians and their like.18 Conversely, the insertion of fabricated official letters or decrees modelled after real ones was deemed legitimate by B.Ar.’s author. This may teach us that there was indeed a boundary between ‘lies’ and ‘truth’, but that the latter operated at a level distinct from our own.19 As for first-person narrative, this was one of the most salient devices available to an ancient writer for bolstering his readers’ confidence. Ego-narrative and fictional identity: the narrator in the Book of Aristeas Analysis of the use of ego-narrative in B.Ar. is complicated by the fact that it combines two distinct aspects: a stance of autopsy and a disguise of identity. In the Hellenistic period, autopsy becomes above all a basic device of ‘serious’ historiography. Disguising identity, on the other hand, is to be found (at least in prose writing) only in fictional works: either pseudepigraphical letters, or ancient novels or genres on the fringe of the novel. In the pseudepigraphical letters we may posit an intellectual affiliation between the real authors and the philosophers whose name they usurped. In contrast, the fictional identity of B.Ar.’s narrator introduces an important shift as compared to the real author.20 The real author was most probably a learned Alexandrian Jew, but the fictional identity he takes on is that of a Greek courtier of Ptolemy II. The choice of a Greek official as the assumed identity of the narrator has prompted some modern commentators to surmise that B.Ar. was aimed 69
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
at a Greek audience. In fact, there are more than enough hints pointing to a Jewish audience, as was shown in Chapter 2. Why, then, this fictional identity? Victor Tcherikover, among others, interpreted this device as apologetic,21 aimed at flattering the Jews with the wishful thinking that the Greeks themselves acknowledged their God. Other Jewish works such as Aristobulus show that learned Jewish circles in Alexandria were actually engaged in cultural competition of this sort throughout the Hellenistic period from quite an early date.22 However, in the case of B.Ar. apologetics is only a secondary aspect. In the first place, the fictive identity of the narrator gives coherence, and hence likelihood, to the narrative. As such, it plays a paramount role in demonstrating its status as a true narrative. As we have already seen, one salient feature in B.Ar. is the author’s care to provide his narrative with an air of total plausibility. Beyond the most obvious consequences of this deliberate endeavour, namely, rationalization of the narrative and refraining from paradoxography, our author carefully avoids inner contradictions in which a malevolent reader could catch him out. As a matter of fact, all the ‘inconsistencies’ and blatant ‘blunders’ which modern readers have accused him of were not perceived as such by his contemporaries, as we shall see below. Since B.Ar. shows the initiative for the translation coming from the Alexandrian court, a court official was the only viable option for the narrator to impersonate.23 Only thus could the author provide his narrator with a comprehensive account of the story without overstepping the boundaries of likelihood. In fact, the eyewitness stance imposed a restricted viewpoint, entailing heavy restrictions on the scope of the account. The device used by our author to supply an alternative source of information whenever the eyewitness standpoint proved deficient was the consultation of royal archives (chs 297–300) – in obvious imitation of the means available for a historian to pursue his inquiry.24 Our author is even careful enough to insert a comment reassuring sceptics about the plausibility of the means: the narrator stresses that ‘these kings’ had much more activity recorded in writing than was the case ‘nowadays’, i.e. more than could be known by his readers through their contemporary experience (ch. 28). Needless to say, only a courtier close to the king could have had access to court documents. Once our author had opted for this setting, one is impressed by the remarkable consistency with which he kept to it – in contrast, for instance, with Achilles Tatius.25 Thus, the narrator gives a detailed description of the outside aspect of the Jerusalem Temple, but remains silent about the Holy of Holies (chs 84–8), or specifies that he owes to Eleazar the High Priest the details he does give (ch. 112). In order to be able to give a description of the activity carried out in the inner precinct of the sacred compound, to which non-Jews had no access, the author has his narrator observe the scene from the citadel above it (ch. 100).26 As to the character’s personal reactions, 70
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
it goes without saying that they are congruent with his social status and, of course, with his being a Greek – B.Ar.’s author cannot be expected to display interest in personal psychology, since only social psychology was dealt with in his time.27 If we try to imagine a Jew in the role of the narrator, daunting disadvantages immediately crop up. The clearest obstacle to having the story told by a Jewish narrator is the section of the Apology for the Law. The pattern of question and answer was the most obvious for our author to choose for this section, for it was very common in Hellenistic literature for the exposition of philosophical or religious ideas. It would have been very clumsy to have a Jewish ambassador ask the High Priest Eleazar to enlighten him about peculiarities relating to the Law of the Jews. It may even be contended that this would have infringed the rules of social psychology and thus jeopardized the credibility of the whole account. Having a Jew request from the King the freeing of the Jewish slaves does not contradict factual likelihood in itself, but this would have diminished the benevolence of Ptolemy and thereby weakened the contrast with Pharaoh’s hardheartedness. (Perhaps the author also considered it sacrilegious to equate his narrator with Moses.) In short, inasmuch as B.Ar.’s author was interested in securing for his account the benefits of ego-narrative, the best, if not the sole possible option was to choose not only a Greek, but very precisely a court official in order to impersonate the narrator. The alternative option would have been to renounce whole sections of the book, which were vital either to the plot itself (the liberation of the Jewish slaves) or to the literary quality of the work (the digressions). If the primary purpose of ego-narrative in B.Ar. was to give the narrative the air of historiography, the last aspects mentioned show just how much potential lay in giving the narrator a Greek identity. This is especially true for the dimension of charter myth which our author aimed at for his account. Given that B.Ar. was written in a Greek cultural and literary environment, the choice of a Greek narrator was, in a sense, imperative. Only a Greek voice could give the account the necessary tone of objectivity and, paradoxically, only such a voice could remove all polemical undertones from the narrative. A charter myth was not to be parochial, but universal – and ‘universal’, in the Greek cultural context, meant Greek. Only this Greek voice could give the text a universal dimension. As to apologetics, although they are discernible in B.Ar., it is dubious whether their import reaches much beyond what can be expected from any positive, nonpolemical presentation. The insertion of ‘official’ documents The insertion of documents in a narrative is, first and foremost, the practice of historians. To be effective, however, a comparison between the documents 71
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
inserted in B.Ar. and general historiographical practice needs to start from a correct assessment of the concept of ‘document’ in the Graeco-Roman tradition. It is now fully recognized that the handling of documents in the Classical period was at odds with modern standards of practice. Free quotation was the rule, and ancient historians freely re-worked the wording of archive documents they consulted for the sake of rhetorical embellishment. Occasionally we also find alleged documents which modern scholarship has identified as downright forgeries. Recent studies have brought a thorough re-assessment, however, of the issue of the author’s intentionality in this practice. Forging or inventing documents was, at that time, a much more legitimate proceeding than in our modern ‘over-literate’ society, to use Rosalind Thomas’ definition.28 If we leave aside straightforward forgeries fabricated in order to gain concrete benefits, it may be said that, in a sense, the same array of intentions was at play in the insertion of documents as in that of speeches. Set speeches were the conventional device used by historians in order to insert their own analysis of the situation into their narrative, and they had, therefore, a very serious function. They could also be inserted for mere entertainment.29 The five documents recorded in B.Ar., the royal decree (chs 22–5), Demetrius’ report (chs 29–32), the two letters between Ptolemy and Eleazar (chs 34b–40 and 41–51a), and the list of names included in the appendix to the second letter (chs 47–50), are fictional.30 It is probable that the author of B.Ar. was, himself, the fabricator, although this issue cannot be finally decided. However, realizing this does not advance us very far towards understanding their function in the text. In keeping with the conventions of the time, it must be admitted that the function of these inserted documents was to bolster the plausibility of the narrative. The epistolary exchange between King Ptolemy and Eleazar the High Priest (chs 34b–40 and 41–51a) recalls the huge correspondence that was ascribed to Alexander the Great in Hellenistic times, especially Alexander’s exchange of letters with Darius III, which is recorded by the historical tradition. The letters attributed to Alexander are known both in an independent form and as insertions in historical and novelistic works. In fact, the insertion of letters in Greek literature was a common device. No contemporary reader would have questioned the legitimacy of our author’s inserting letters into his text, even though the latter were the output of his own calamus.31 Incidentally, we may note that the genuine nature of the extant versions of these letters has been a matter of debate among modern scholars.32 If modern readers could get lost over the matter of their authenticity, all the more so ancient ones. The list of names of the 72 translators from Judaea appended to Eleazar’s answer to Ptolemy (chs 47–50) may be associated with the ‘antiquarian’ taste of the Greeks. More precisely, the redaction of lists of all kinds became a literary genre very popular in Hellenistic times, concomitantly with a higher 72
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
level of education. Lists of personal, ethnic, geographical and other sorts of names were aimed at facilitating the study of Homer, be it for educational or scholarly purposes.33 Also relevant here, perhaps, are Callimachus’ Pinakes, the catalogue lists set in the library of Alexandria. Callimachus drew heavily on this kind of literature to write his erudite poetry. These are genuine lists, including names actually found in Homer, real rivers or gods, or librarians and real books included in the Alexandrian library. Spurious lists, however, are also a widespread phenomenon in the Greek world. They usually come to fill in gaps, and are but one manifestation of what Peter Wiseman has called ‘the horror of the void’ characteristic of Roman historians of the Republic but not only of them.34 Filling up the gaps between generations was a common device in the field of genealogy. The purpose was primarily to link an individual, an aristocratic family, a royal dynasty, or a people’s history with a mythical event or character. Lists blending together historical and legendary data are found alongside entirely spurious or fictitious ones.35 However, this tendency of filling up the gaps was not confined to history and genealogy. Rafaella Cribiore has pointed to a similar phenomenon in a context certainly unexpected for the modern mind, the making up of words to fill a gap in a syllabary used by a school-teacher.36 Where the original tradition left secondary protagonists anonymous, oral tradition or scholars would supply public curiosity with the desired information. This latter phenomenon is directly relevant for our case. Long before B.Ar.’s days, Ctesias presented his Greek readers with a largely spurious list of Assyrian kings.37 One good parallel to the document found in B.Ar. is the list of twenty of Lycurgus’ thirty friends who helped him seize power in Sparta. This list was supplied by Hermippus (a pupil of Callimachus), and quoted by Plutarch in his Life of Lycurgus, 5.7. The discrepancy between the number of names recorded in Hermippus’ list and the total number of Lycurgus’ friends given by Plutarch is interesting. Plutarch, or his source, probably merged two traditions about Lycurgus’ followers, but did not feel entitled to supplement Hermippus’ list in order to harmonize the data. The chronological gap between the days of B.Ar.’s author and Plutarch’s time may be responsible for this diverging attitude towards the source used. The (final?) redactor of the list in B.Ar. was also responsible for the number of Elders being 72 and not 70. If the oral tradition that circulated before the redaction of B.Ar. knew of 70, and not 72, Elders, the author of B.Ar. either made up the whole list, or at least added two names, and was responsible for its final division into tribes.38 In general, the assumption that he was re-using a pre-existing document would entail complications that may be seen as unnecessary. However, the possibility cannot be entirely dismissed. Fortunately, the assumption that the list of names may not come from B.Ar.’s author himself does not require further speculation about the 73
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
possibility of its being genuine. Several studies have, indeed, tried to clarify whether this list stemmed from Judaea or Egypt, on the basis of a philological study of the names recorded.39 The motivation was to check whether the list was genuine or spurious, the underlying assumption being that a Palestinian list must be genuine, and thus demonstrate the reliability of B.Ar.’s story. This issue has now become pointless. Internal analysis of the LXX leaves no doubt that the translation was made by people acquainted with the Greek vernacular in Egypt, not Judaea. In other words, the translators were Jews living in Egypt. On the face of it, we could modify the premise and say that if the names can be shown to be Palestinian, then the author of B.Ar. cannot be held responsible for this list. A Palestinian origin for this list is, however, made improbable by two decisive arguments. Beside the fact that the LXX was translated by Egyptian Jews, and not by translators imported from Judaea, the tradition about the origins of the LXX and especially the theme of the importation from abroad is clearly Alexandrian, as shown by its configuration on an Alexandrian narrative paradigm. In these circumstances, therefore, the interest of a detailed investigation of this list is strictly philological and cannot have historical implications.40
Literary elaboration and historical reliability according to Classical standards ‘Hard-core facts’, Ciceronian literary ‘elaboration’, and the Exodus paradigm A further and, in some ways, more fundamental problem in the relationship between the rhetorical techniques used in B.Ar. and the status of this text as a ‘truth-telling account’ is the presence of narrative patterns in the story told. Here again, the norms regulating the presentation of a ‘true report’ in the prose writing of the Classical world were very different from our own, as has now been fully recognized by numerous studies on Classical historiography. A historical account had to start from a core of ‘hard facts’, but these were regularly wrapped up in an imaginative setting to a much greater extent than modern standards would tolerate. Texts that were clearly (at least for modern readers) the product of sheer imagination had no difficulty in imitating the literary conventions that set the norms for historiography. An important study in pointing out the differences between ancient and modern standards for factually reliable reporting was Anthony Woodman’s commentary on two texts of Cicero’s in which the Roman philosopher sets out his conception of the work of the historian. These texts are a letter to Lucceius (Ad Fam. 5.12) and, more importantly, De Oratore 2.51–4 and 62–4.41 Through a revised translation of Cicero’s terminology, Woodman demonstrated that the Roman philosopher held literary elaboration around 74
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
the ‘hard-core facts’ as not only legitimate, but indispensable. For Cicero, it was literary elaboration which turned annalistic records into history. Woodman further argued that by literary elaboration (exornatio), Cicero meant plain invention. In order to turn the bare bones of the facts in the annals which constituted his starting point into an acceptable literary work, the historian was expected to process them using elaborated literary embroidery. The finished product had to present a comprehensive account, fully endowed with detailed descriptions of all the successive stages of the action which accepted conventions made the reader entitled to expect. Wherever the concrete data for reconstructing a specific stage was missing, as Peter Wiseman argued, the historian was expected to fill the gap with a development of his own.42 The legitimacy of supplementing missing factual data with literary clichés was predicated on the certitude shared by contemporary philosophy that human nature and material conditions are ruled by immutable laws and are, therefore, predictable. This is the same certitude which led Thucydides to feel entitled to reconstruct speeches that he did not personally hear.43 However, Woodman may have pushed his argument too far. Other scholars have been keen to maintain that ancient historians were not as lightminded with ‘truth’ as implied by Woodman’s interpretation of Cicero. In a recent study, Christopher Pelling argued that an author like Plutarch could, indeed, be quite concerned about getting the reconstruction of the past right, even or especially when dealing with biographies that he himself acknowledged to be constantly bordering on myth (in the ancient sense of the word).44 Thus, echoes found in B.Ar. of recommendations given by Cicero or later manuals of rhetoric need not necessarily be taken as straightforward proof that B.Ar. is a mere fanciful account. Such echoes are indeed found. If we leave aside for now the specific issue of the two interwoven narrative paradigms in B.Ar., the compositional structure of this work meets the conventions about the division of the account into set chronological stages which Cicero and later manuals of rhetoric recommend. The manuals of the grammarians and some historians themselves invariably advocate a tri-partite exposition of the historical event the historian sets out to relate, adding to the event itself what preceded and what followed it.45 If we take the motif of the translation in B.Ar. to be the central ‘event’ lying at the core of the work, then the report by Demetrius the Librarian to the King that there is no authorized copy of the Jewish Law in his Library (chs 9–11 and 18–34a) (see the outline of the literary composition of B.Ar. in the Appendix at the end of this book), as well as the subsequent correspondence between King Ptolemy and Eleazar the High Priest about the sending of the scroll and the translators to Alexandria (34b–51a) constitute the preliminaries. These episodes adequately replace in B.Ar. ‘the generals’ speeches, the outlay on both sides, and their fears’ which ancient readers would have expected in a 75
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
war description. The description of the translation in chs 301–7 (admittedly short by Hellenistic literary standards) comes in place of ‘the attacks, the slaughter, and the dead’. Then follows the solemn proclaiming of the translation (chs 308–17), appropriately substituted for the ‘victory trophy, the triumphal songs of the victors, the tears and enslavement of the victims’ as required on the battlefield.46 The presence of a secondary topic in B.Ar., however, necessarily results in a compositional structure more complex than would be expected in a historical monograph keeping strictly to the theoretical model. The motif of the liberation of the Jewish slaves is, itself, presented in two distinct stages, not three: a ‘reminder’ of the circumstances in which the Jews were deported (a kind of preliminary) and the account of their liberation (the core of the story). As to the expected concluding section, it merges, as it were, into the structure of the main topic: the letter sent by Ptolemy to Eleazar the High Priest recording the freeing of the Jews is both a conclusion of this ‘event’ and a kind of preliminary to his request of carrying out the translation – chronologically second, but in fact a more encompassing ‘event’. For all the complications entailed, the identification of a double topic in B.Ar. is not a hindrance to the claim that the work’s structure met Hellenistic standards of historical writing. If we turn now to the two narrative paradigms that make up B.Ar.’s story, the theoretical problems raised appear to be more complex. Cicero’s theory of literary elaboration in historiography falls short of explaining the technique of literary composition followed by our author in this case. In fact, it would seem that the latter remained off the scope of Classical literary theory – like so many other features related to the new prose genres which were rapidly steering historiography towards fiction. In terms of compositional technique, the Exodus paradigm is the easier to tackle, since we can be certain in this case that the imitation of the literary model was conscious and deliberate. The textual allusions to the LXX found in B.Ar. could not be explained otherwise. Basically, the compositional principle involved amounts to duplicating the narrative structure of a reference text in the new account. This mechanism of literary imitation that underlies the Exodus paradigm in B.Ar. is far from isolated in the Hellenistic period. A good example of the use of a similar compositional process is to be found in the social utopias, by then a flourishing genre. Plato’s Republic provided the basic model, usually blended with the genre of the travelogue deriving from the Herodotean tradition of ethnographical writing. Euhemerus’ travel to the island of Panchaea is, perhaps, the best instance of a social utopia taking its inspiration from Plato, typically blended with topics borrowed from travel literature.47 In all cases of imitation the starting point for the interest in the reference text is not compositional, but topical, while the prestige of the reference text – Plato in one case, the LXX in the other – is also important. The reference text provides, first and foremost, a source 76
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
of inspiration for the content of the new work. Since content and form are linked, it then naturally provides the necessary literary and compositional model as well.48 Seen in these terms, the Exodus paradigm in B.Ar. may thus be approached with the conceptual theory proposed by Hayden White. White’s main contention is that the ‘traces of the past’, what he calls the ‘primitive’ elements of the historical account – roughly corresponding to Anthony Woodman’s ‘kernel of historical facts’ – are necessarily ‘emplotted’ by the historian into a narrative form. The ‘emplotment’, or ‘encodation of the facts contained in the chronicle as components of specific kinds of plot structures’, necessarily takes on literary forms culturally familiar to the audience targeted. In modern Western society the four basic types of story in which a historical account may be emplotted are ‘tragic, comic, romantic, or ironic’.49 Although the Exodus paradigm is designed in reference to a text, not to a literary form, we may speak of the same kind of ‘emplotment’ in this case as in those envisaged by White. As for the literary form of B.Ar., it was familiar to its Alexandrian Jewish readers. Although our author was writing a charter myth, an ‘epic’ emplotment would not do. The changing taste of the Hellenistic readers precluded such a choice, and the epic genre had, moreover, undergone a thorough delegitimization after Callimachus. The Exodus paradigm should perhaps be described as a kind of ‘dulled and embourgeoisé epic’ emplotment.50 Whatever the definition we choose, the choice of the reference text is what furnishes B.Ar. with meaning, more than its up-dated emplotment. B.Ar.’s claim to originality thus lies in the choice of the text imitated. In other cases, this kind of writing based on the imitation of either specific works or genres, or more accurately, on a combination of both (Plato and ethnography in the social utopias) is what led to the development of new literary genres in the Hellenistic period.51 Once the genre was crystallized, not merely in theory, but in actual practice, any explicit reference to the text(s) which had inspired it could fade away, as happened in the genre of utopian geography. At this point the affinities with the technique of writing conforming to the rules set down by the grammarians are obvious, especially since the manuals of rhetoric reflected common practice as much as they tried to influence it. Inasmuch as Graeco-Roman literary criticism was conservative in the extreme, however, this technique of imitation lacked a proper theoretical framework. Intellectual tools for distinguishing ‘truth’ from ‘lies’ in an account Ever since Herodotus, the use of historia, scientific investigation, in the account of past events had involved the development of conceptual tools enabling the Greek ‘historian’ in his inquiry to distinguish between truth 77
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
and lies in factual reports. As has been noted repeatedly in recent studies, this dichotomic categorization of ‘truth’ and ‘lies’ left out the concept of fiction, that is, false report which plays on a tacit convention between writer and reader (or more generally sender and recipient) to act as though it were true, although both are aware that it is not.52 The intellectual tools that were actually available for the critical reader to assess the truth of a factual report may be illustrated by the following well-known discussion in Strabo: 1. . . . Pytheas, by whom many have been misled; for after asserting that he travelled over the whole of Britain that was accessible, Pytheas of Massilia . . . added his story about Thule¯ and about those regions in which there was no longer either land properly so-called, or sea, or air, but a kind of substance concreted from all these elements, resembling a sea-lungs . . . Now, as for this thing that resembles a sea-lungs, he says that he saw it himself, but that all the rest he tells from hearsay. Then, Pytheas adds that on his return from those regions he visited the whole coast-line of Europe from Gades to Tanaïs. 2. Now, Polybius says that, in the first place, it is incredible that a private individual, and a poor man too, could have travelled such distances by sea and by land; and that, though Eratosthenes was wholly at a loss whether he should believe these stories, nevertheless he has believed Pytheas’ account of Britain, and of the regions about Gades, and of Iberia; but he says it is far better to believe Euhemerus, the Messenian, than Pytheas. Euhemerus, at all events, asserts that he sailed only to one country, Panchaea, whereas Pytheas asserts that he explored in person the whole northern region of Europe as far as the ends of the world – an assertion which no man would believe, not even if Hermes made it. And as for Eratosthenes – adds Poseidonius – though he calls Euhemerus a Bergaean [i.e. a fabulist], he believes Pytheas, and that, too, though not even Dicaearchus believed him. . . . While we may pardon Eratosthenes and Dicaearchus, because they had not seen those regions with their own eyes, yet who could pardon Polybius and Poseidonius? Nay, it is precisely Polybius who characterises as ‘popular notions’ the statements made by Eratosthenes and Dicaearchus in regard to the distances in those regions and many other regions, though he does not keep himself free from the error even where he criticises them.53 This text presents a group of the prominent intellectual figures of their time, Eratosthenes, Poseidonius, Dicaearchus, Polybius and Strabo, in heated argument as to the comparative reliability of two travelogues by Pytheas of Massilia and Euhemerus of Messenia.54 The reaction of these five 78
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
commentators towards Euhemerus’ and Pytheas’ writings illustrates how the notion of fiction was alien to Greek thought or at the least, that it had not been conceptualized. As with his predecessors, Strabo’s only conceptual tools were those of the ‘true’ or the ‘lying’ account. Polybius’ readiness to accept Euhemerus’ account while condemning Pytheas’ as fake is predicated on a typical method: the assessment of objective, material data. Polybius evaluates whether the material conditions of the journey are plausible or not, using common sense as his yardstick for this matter. Strabo, Josephus and Plutarch proceed in a similar manner. Strabo’s best reason for believing that Alexander did not meet Thalestria, queen of the Amazons, is to point out that his best sources do not mention their encounter, and then to say that Thalestria lived too far away from Thermodon to pay Alexander a visit there (Geography 11.5.4). Material impossibilities and chronological inconsistency are some of the arguments Josephus resorts to in the first book of his Against Apion in order to refute the collection of slanderous narratives about the Jews he has gathered from Alexandrian literature.55 Outright contradiction of either the Biblical narrative (281–5) or of two anti-Jewish slanders (293–7) is another of his methods of argument, but this latter technique is hardly more commendable as methodology if we judge it by modern standards. But the Greek writer of later times could safely conclude that the story reported was true when all his ancient sources coincided. Thus, Plutarch was able to conclude that the story of Hippolytus and Phaedra was historically true because the historians and the tragic poets agreed on the subject (Life of Theseus, 1.3 and 28.2).56 In general terms, the criterion for distinguishing between ‘true’ and ‘false’ accounts, according to Graeco-Roman literary critics, was whether they conformed to the laws of nature. Any factual report which did not offend these laws was ‘true’, whether Heracles, Achilles, or Pericles was the hero of the story. Miracles and monsters, on the other hand, belonged to the realm of ‘lies’. Gauged against these criteria, B.Ar. is a perfectly trustworthy account. Nothing in this work can be charged with trespassing natural laws. Neither portents, nor monsters, or anything of the kind are to be found in B.Ar., not even in the Travelogue – a genre which was traditionally particularly prone to such ‘wonders’, paradoxa. The scroll of the Law is brought from Alexandria to Jerusalem in the most mundane way. On this point, B.Ar.’s account may be contrasted to the miraculous bringing of the statue of Sarapis from Sinope to Alexandria (Tacitus, Histories, 4.83–4), an account which follows the same pattern of story-telling, as we saw in Chapter 3. The transcription and translation of the LXX is also carried out by strictly human scientific means – in sharp contrast with later descriptions of the same event, for example in Philo’s Life of Moses, 2.37–40. Strabo’s text quoted above presents an interesting point of comparison with B.Ar. on another matter. Polybius does not address a number of aspects 79
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
in Euhemerus’ account that modern readers immediately pick up as fictional. Thus, some details in Euhemerus’ description of life on the island of Panchaea, like the community of wealth, are directly borrowed from Plato’s depiction of the ideal city in his Republic, while the division into three castes in Diodorus 5.45.3 may echo Aristotle’s depiction of Peisistratus’ time in the Athenian Constitution, 13.2 rather than Plato’s own contemporary social organization.57 These and further details build up Panchaea as a social utopia. Modern critics immediately identify such details as a literary construct which can easily be traced back to a long literary tradition in Greek culture. Polybius’ and Strabo’s reactions were obviously different, and the difference between modern and ancient Greek perception and reception of the intertextual allusions embedded in Euhemerus’ work is clearly culturally determined. In a recent discussion of the influence of both ‘extra-textual experience’ and intertextuality on readers and other sections of a population, both ancient and modern, Christopher Pelling has argued that ‘readers [. . . are] more inclined to find a story plausible when it maps on to a pattern which is already familiar’.58 Thus, he argues, an American jury in a real-life trial is liable to find plausible a story whose pattern sounds familiar because it is reminiscent of a story heard in the television program LA Law. He goes on to show that Graeco-Roman historians frequently borrowed story-patterns from their predecessors. Thus, ‘Tacitus borrow[ed] patterns from Livy, Herodotus from Homer, or Thucydides from Herodotus’.59 Such borrowings create a recurrent pattern. In this way, intertextuality generates not only plausibility but, as Pelling puts it, ‘intelligibility’ ‘by locating [events] against a more general pattern of human experience: such things happen, life is like that’.60 The fact that Panchaea resembled Plato’s Republic brought confirmation that such social structures do exist. Reactions to the patterning of B.Ar. on the Alexandrian paradigm should be seen in the same light. What gives the narrative away as ‘unhistorical’ to modern readers is precisely what strengthened its reliability for the original Alexandrian audience, to whom the Alexandrian paradigm was familiar. These various points bring us to a specific detail in B.Ar. In ch. 307 it is stated that the 72 Elders completed their work of transcription and translation in 72 days, ‘as if such a result was achieved by some deliberate design’. Nothing in this goes against the laws of nature. The statement is legitimate according to ancient standards. However, we may wonder what this statement is aimed at. Should it be understood as the rationalization of an earlier popular stage of the legend which included marvellous details cut out by the author of B.Ar.? In scholarly circles, the traditional myths recorded by the poets were seen as historical events embedded in an accretion of lies due to poetic licence or deformation through misunderstanding. All the scholar had to do in order to retrieve the ‘historical’ core of the story was to implement his own rational faculties and rid the account of these parasitic accretions. This rationalization of myths mainly consisted in expurgating all 80
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
the ‘unlikely’ elements contradicting the laws of nature.61 Our author could well have done the same with a popular legend circulating among Alexandrian Jews, and the notation found in ch. 307 might possibly result from a process of expurgation.62 However, this would be the only instance of this technique in B.Ar. Moreover, the process of rationalization applied by ancient historians to traditional stories that appeared to them ‘mythical’ (in the ancient sense of the word) was often characterized by an artificial twisting of the received version. Thus, Heracles’ journey through Italy with Geryon’s cows is explained as the story of an invading army headed by Heracles.63 In contrast, B.Ar.’s account is rational without involving any contortions of the material. Another and better way of understanding the recurrence of the number 72 is to identify it as patterning. A pattern of the same kind is found in Thucydides.64 He notes that the Peloponnesian wars lasted 27 years (three times nine years, Thuc. 5.26.1 and 4) altogether. A lunar eclipse delayed the decisive battle between Athenians and Syracusans which put such a lamentable end to the Sicilian expedition, for 27 days (three times nine days, Thuc. 7.50.4).65 Now, it is unlikely that Thucydides would have seen in this ‘coincidence’ the sign of divine intervention – especially not in a passage in which he is criticizing Nicias’ superstition. In the same way, it would probably be misguided to see the patterning around the number of 72 in B.Ar. as a divine sign. B.Ar. is certainly as rationalized as Thucydides’ work. A hypothesis about the genesis of the Alexandrian paradigm The creation of recurrent patterns in historical works may be the product of a conscious borrowing by one author from another. As in the case of Tacitus borrowing patterns from Livy, and Thucydides from Herodotus, conscious borrowing can be posited in the Exodus paradigm, or again in the modelling of the description of Jerusalem upon Aristotle’s Politics in B.Ar., chs 83–106, which was seen in Chapter 2. The mechanism at play in these examples is that of deliberate choice: the author consciously seeks to inform the narrative with a reference to a pattern that is fully recognized and endorsed, even if the author is usually not willing to acknowledge his debt. The degree of self-awareness is more difficult to assess when it comes to more elusive patterns. The genre of utopian geography, for instance, resulted from a blend between ethnography in the Herodotean tradition, and the philosophical works of the late fifth and the fourth centuries BCE which were concerned with conceptualizing the ideal city. Out of this blend, the new genre developed its own rules and designed its own set topics. The latter are routinely spelled out in the works preserved – the description of Egypt by Hecataeus of Abdera, for example, or that of India by Megasthenes.66 81
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
In fact, the author of B.Ar., himself, seems to have consciously modelled his description of Judaea (chs 112–20) on the topics of utopian geography – in contrast with his description of Jerusalem. On the contrary, the modelling of B.Ar.’s account on the Alexandrian paradigm probably resulted from an unconscious process, similar to that referred to by Pelling when he compares real-life trials and LA Law – the kind of unconscious patterning that recalls the mechanism of ‘emplotment’ described by Hayden White.67 Vladimir Propp’s approach in The Morphology of the Folktale may also contribute to our theoretical understanding of the genesis of the Alexandrian paradigm, since it seems to be a narrative paradigm deriving from a popular oral tradition, and not a (strictly) literary paradigm.68 Propp’s concept of ‘functions’ embodied by folktale characters, in particular, seems useful for a literary analysis of the Alexandrian paradigm – especially the importing of an item from abroad, which may correspond to a narrative syntagma, to use modern terminology.69 Likewise, Propp’s concept of the characters’ ‘roles’ may clarify the part played by someone like the King in B.Ar. Indeed, we might well ask whether Propp’s ‘functions’ would not also be useful for the analysis of the set topics recurring in the genre of utopian geography, such as natural bounty, dense population (polyanthropia), an outstanding river ensuring fertility, etc.70 Propp’s model may help us to explain the function of the characters and situations in our story. However, in order to understand its genesis, we need to refer to the process of collective memory.71 The process of re-shaping the past into a set narrative pattern is now well known for Archaic Greece, which was an oral society. One may think of the legend about the birth and infancy of a ruler, which is common to no less than 122 characters in the ancient Near East and related cultures, including Cyrus the Great (Herodotus, Histories, 1.107–8), Cypselus, tyrant of Corinth in the later half of the seventh century BC (Herodotus, 5.92), Romulus and Remus, Moses and Jesus, besides many Mesopotamian kings. This legend re-shaped the biography of rulers who lacked a dynastic legitimacy. These outsiders, founders of a new royal line, or their like, had to draw their legitimacy from divine election: hence, the recurring motifs of miraculous salvation, feeding by a sacred beast embodying a manifestation of the divinity, prophecy received on the verge of adulthood, etc.72 In the same way, Christiane Sourvinou-Inwood has analysed a series of myths which illustrate what she calls the ‘“father-son hostility” schema’, and to which she also links stories of patricide and matricide. The term ‘schema’ corresponds to our ‘paradigm’, and Sourvinou-Inwood points out that it breaks down into a four-stage composition, with variations from one version to another. She identifies this mythical schema in a historicized version, Herodotus’ account of the tyranny of Corinth and the failed succession between Periander and his son Lykophron (3.48 and 50–3).73 82
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
These stories from Archaic Greece illustrate the process of mythopoetic creation typical of an oral society. In her study of the ‘father-son hostility’ schema found in Herodotus’ account about the Kypselids, Sourvinou-Inwood has argued that the ‘historical kernel’ was minimal. It consisted at best of a historical situation of failed succession, since Lykophron did not succeed Periander. The whole mythical structuring of the story could even more simply have been triggered off by the fact that the dynasty of the Kypselids did not last beyond the third generation.74 Criticizing the attempts of modern historians at extracting ‘historical facts’ for modern historical reconstruction, she states the following: [A]ny historical ‘raw material’ that may have gone into the making [of the narrative] has been radically recast; for the mythological mentality, operating through a process of bricolage, structures narratives by means of the schemata through which it operates, and articulates ‘new’ stories using any available historical material as building blocks, to be recast and reshaped to fit the ‘spacings’ required by the schema.75 The concept of bricolage is borrowed from Claude Lévi-Strauss. ‘The bricoleur’, as summarized by Mary Douglas, ‘is a craftsman who works with material that has not been produced for the task he has in hand’.76 If we were to accept it, an analogy between our Alexandrian paradigm and the process of mythopoetic creation and the concept of bricolage would cast heavy doubt on the historicity of the mention of the King and the Library in the Alexandrian paradigm, not to mention the importation motif. However, it is questionable whether the gap between what a modern mind sees as ‘reality’ and its translation into a narrative pattern could be as important in the Hellenistic world as in Archaic Greece. Legends informed by a set pattern certainly existed in the Hellenistic period. The pattern of the religious evocatio was briefly reviewed in Chapter 3, in the discussion of the legend of the origins of Sarapis recorded by Tacitus (Hist. 4.83–4). We find it again, for instance, in a private letter in a papyrus, P.Cairo Zen. 59034, which will be quoted extensively in Chapter 5. Another example of a narrative pattern used to recast historical events involves military deeds, from Caesar’s crossing of the Rubicon to Constantine’s battle of the Milvian Bridge in 312.77 In these cases, the part played by political manipulation by the figure involved, either Caesar or Constantine, as opposed to the part of the spontaneous growth of the legend, is hard to unravel – like in the story of Sarapis’ origins. In order to assess the relation of such stories to ‘reality’, it may be wiser to adduce comparison from material gathered by sociologists in relation to modern societies – those deemed ‘over-literate’ – not to oral societies, or to turn to more theoretical works concerned with the process of memory and 83
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
recollection, both individual and collective. In literate societies, the process of elaboration from ‘historical reality’ to recollection, the reconstructed narrative of the past, operates differently than in a society characterized by ‘the mythological mentality’. The gap between reality and narrative is both narrower and of a different nature. In the wake of Henri Bergson’s works on the subject, memory is now understood to be, in Peter Berger’s words, a ‘reiterated act of interpretation. As we remember the past, we reconstruct it in accordance with our present ideas of what is important and what is not.’78 Both the spheres of social and individual memories provide countless illustrations of this mechanism: both in the individual and the collective realm the selection of significative past events is guided by the need to build an ‘effective’ past for the present.79 Likewise, the building of a charter myth, as we posit in B.Ar., implies some instrumentalism of this kind in the finality of the reconstruction. Let us take one example from the individual sphere, which is relevant to our concerns inasmuch as the social pressure it involves is not political, as is usually the case in the modelling of collective memory: this example concerns what we may call the ‘conversion narrative’, specific to groups among what are now known as the New Religious Movements. Sociologists have called attention to the fact that inside a given religious movement, members tend to relate their conversion to the group in similar terms. Beyond their particulars, the accounts of all the individual experiences appear to follow the same pattern. Sociologists tend to explain this phenomenon as the result of mutual influences inside the group. In their first acquaintance with the group, would-be converts attend meetings during which individuals who have just gone through the whole process (the category of members of the religious movement with whom the newcomers would identify more easily) would share their own experience with them. Repeatedly hearing about the conversion process experienced by fellow-members, the new adherent is progressively impregnated with these redundant stories. When the new convert reflects on his own process of conversion, his previous familiarization with stories heard from other fellowmembers will trigger in him an unconscious process of selection in his recollection: he will tend to give more importance to details that fit the pattern with which he was impregnated, while dropping as negligible details which happen to be at odds with it.80 To sum up: the genesis of the Alexandrian paradigm may be explained through a combined reference to several elements: first, sociological studies on social and individual memory provide the fundamental notion that the past is reconstructed through a selection of elements bearing significance for the present. Second, Hayden White provides us with the notion of ‘emplotment’, which can be refined through two additional models in order to fit the specific conditions of the Hellenistic period. Thus, the notion of narrative elaboration derived from Cicero may explain the possible addition of 84
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
fanciful elements (the import of the translators from abroad?, the involvement of the King?). Finally, Propp’s emphasis on the functional role of both characters and situations in the folktale casts light on the fact that the raison d’être of these possible additions is not necessarily related to external concerns, such as apologetic propaganda, but may derive from an inner need of the story.
Factual and chronological inaccuracies: the building up of a ‘story world’ As Peter Wiseman has put it, if modern ‘historical thinking’, as defined by R.G. Collingwood, is for the historian to put his ‘authorities’ to the question, then ancient Greek and Roman historians are characterized by ‘unhistorical thinking’.81 Caught as they were between laxity and the practical difficulties of cross-checking their sources beyond conformity to the ‘laws of nature’, ancient historians are often found by modern ones to be guilty of inaccuracy in their chronology or the personal ascription of a specific deed. One example may be given, which is of particular relevance for us: Strabo (13.1.54, C608) explicitly says that ‘[Aristotle] [was] the first man . . . to have taught the kings of Egypt how to arrange their library’.82 Clearly this cannot be literally true. Aristotle was dead by the time Ptolemy gained control of Egypt. It is most likely that Strabo means that the organization of the material in the library was modelled on Aristotle’s own private library.83 In his comment on Strabo’s quotation, Andrew Erskine has suggested that the tradition reported by the geographer may originate in Ptolemaic propaganda seeking to create a parallel between Aristotle’s role at the Alexandrian court, and his role at the court of Philip II. This would only be one more item in the Ptolemaic endeavours to bolster Ptolemy’s spiritual affiliation with Alexander through the mediation of Aristotle.84 Apparently, then, Strabo was misled by Ptolemaic propaganda. For all his careless chronological shortcomings, however, the geographer undoubtedly reported a tradition he deemed plausible, to the best of his personal critical capability. Moderns can doubt the reliability of his report, not his good faith. Let us approach the issue from the other end of the spectrum. The most ancient Greek novels, especially those from the Hellenistic period (such as the Ninus and Sesonchosis Romances), framed their story with references to wellknown historical characters or events.85 Their allusive, or intertextual, value contributed to build up what Niklas Holzberg has called a ‘guise of historicity’ – or what Andrew Laird has labelled, in reference to later and more openly fictional works, a ‘story world’.86 In practice, the difference between both the cases illustrated by Strabo and the novels is slight. It rests mainly on authorial intentionality. If we turn now to B.Ar., how are we to assess the author’s intention behind the chronological inaccuracies and dubious or spurious ascriptions which have 85
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
long since been identified in the text? It seems that both attitudes in turn are illustrated in our work: bona fide inaccuracies, and the deliberate building of a ‘story world’. As might be expected, it is not always easy for us to decide – and even if it were, there is still a gap between an author’s bona fides and his reliability according to modern standards of factual accuracy.87 The deficiencies of the critical tools that stood at the disposal of ancient historians are particularly problematical if we assume the presence of an oral tradition at the core of B.Ar.’s story. Modern readers may have problems discerning inaccuracies. As for B.Ar.’s original readers, they just did not care, as was rightly emphasized by Oswyn Murray.88 The most obvious hint of this indifference is the anachronism twice encountered in the text (chs 28 and 182): the narrator refers to the Ptolemies as ‘those kings’, a phrase blatantly incompatible with his alleged position as an eyewitness. This chronological inconsistency is precisely what betrayed B.Ar.’s author to modern critics, and has prompted so many scholars ever since the sixteenth century to hail him a ‘liar’. But modern reactions are no warrant for ancient ones. The use of realia (i.e. the institutions or the items of everyday life) to build up a ‘story world’ is relatively easy to analyse. Andrew Laird has argued that setting their narrative in a world familiar to the reader is an important device used by modern novelists to build their fiction, hence the importance of realistic descriptions. Laird further convincingly shows that a very similar mechanism was demonstrably at work in ancient novels. It plays a role in B.Ar. also. Laird’s analysis may help to solve the highly vexed issue of the historical reliability of the realia mentioned in our text. The concept of ‘story world’ helps us to posit different treatments for Hellenistic Egypt and for Judaea in B.Ar. Inasmuch as B.Ar. is a work written in Alexandria for an Alexandrian readership, we may assume that the details pertaining to Ptolemaic realities are realistic up to a point, given the chronological gap between the author’s days and the precise setting of the story. As a matter of fact, the technical vocabulary related to Egypt is rooted in reality. However, even the realistic use of this technical vocabulary cannot be pushed too far. To begin with, its specific use in the text is, for the most part, inaccurate or anachronistic. Moreover, the references to Ptolemaic realia are undermined by too many intertextual allusions for them to be historically reliable. The fate of the word ‘politeuma’, which occurs in ch. 310, will be discussed below in Chapter 5. Technical vocabulary also appears in ch. 40. Here too, a close examination of the data shows inaccurate use of the nomenclature. The title to¯n archiso¯matophylako¯n is both anachronistic and inaccurate. In the form of a partitive genitive, as B.Ar. has it, this title is known for the first time under Ptolemy VI Philometor (180–145 BCE), and cannot be earlier than 163 BCE, the date of Ptolemy VI’s temporary expulsion from power by his brother, later to become Ptolemy VIII Euergetes II. (Its earlier recorded 86
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
1111 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011 1 2 3111 4 5 6 7 8 9 20111 1 2 3 4 5111 6 7 8 9 30111 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40111 1 2 3 44111
occurrence dates to 155 BCE.) It was a later addition to a reform set up by Ptolemy V Epiphanes in the years 197/94. This reform introduced a system of honorific titles derived from the original aulic titulatures. However, the titles promoted by this reform no longer pointed to actual members of the court, but to high officials in charge of various administrative and military positions across the country. Among the titles referring to the six ranks of this new system are archiso¯matophylax and to¯n so¯matophylako¯n but not to¯n archiso¯matophylako¯n. The title of to¯n archiso¯matophylako¯n was added some thirty years later. Like the earlier titles, it no longer had anything to do with aulic titulature, and was born by high-ranking administrative officials across the country, not by courtiers.89 To sum up: the author of B.Ar. confused the administrative rank-title, to¯n archiso¯matophylako¯n, a late addition to a hierarchy first inaugurated in 197/4, and the aulic title archiso¯matophylax, which was actually in use in the third century BCE. Thus, the concept of a story world warns us against taking even the factual details relating to Ptolemaic Egypt at face value. The technical vocabulary is correct but its use is fanciful. As for Jerusalem and Judaea, this geographical area formed an altogether abstract and faraway reality. As such, this space tended to function as a recipient for idealizing aspirations. Indisputable instances of this idealization can, indeed, be pointed out in the digression formed by the Travelogue, as was seen in Chapter 2. The most conspicuous clue to its non-realistic content is the comparison between the Jordan river and the Nile, ch. 116. This instance casts doubt on the reliability of the whole description. We must not expect any of the realia relating to Judaea to be reliable from a ‘factual’ point of view. The contrast just established between the realia relating to Ptolemaic Egypt and those relating to Judaea does not imply, however, that all the sections in B.Ar. referring to Egypt should be taken for realia, anachronistic or not. The allusions may also target an intellectual debate, and not a concrete reality. This is clearly the case with the digression of the Apology for the Law, chs 128–71. As was emphasized in Chapter 2, it would be a mistake to look for direct hints of the social reality of contemporary Egypt in this section of B.Ar., throughout which the author is clearly polemicizing against philosophical views. The references to the Alexandrian Library that are found in B.Ar. are more difficult to tackle, as we shall see in Chapter 6. Intertextuality further interferes with the use of technical vocabulary. Moses Hadas has already pointed out that the comparison between Jerusalem and Alexandria, in chs 107–11, includes a free quotation from Aristotle’s Athenian Constitution, 16, referring to Peisistratus’ rule in sixth-century Athens.90 Aristotle’s text is carefully re-written, in the sense that the technical vocabulary found in the original text is systematically modified to fit the corresponding realia of Hellenistic Egypt. For example, the judges, dikastai in the Athenian Constitution, 16.5, become chre¯matistai in B.Ar., 111. This last term, which refers to circuit judges, is indeed attested in documentary 87
ENFORCING THE NARRATIVE VERACITY
papyri stemming from Ptolemaic Egypt.91 Likewise, the ‘demes’, the local administrative divisions in Athens, are turned into ‘nomes’, the administrative districts of Egypt. As to the phrase prostatai te¯s poleo¯s, ‘the chief men of the city’ in Shutt’s translation, its meaning is not clear at all – although it is true that the institutions of Hellenistic Alexandria are poorly known. However, we cannot exclude an attempted adaptation of the phrase prostate¯s tou de¯mou, ‘leader of the people’, or perhaps even ‘protector of the people’. This phrase recurs several