OXF O R D C L A S S I C A L M O N O G R A P H S Published under the supervision of a Committee of the Faculty of Classics in the University of Oxford
The aim of the Oxford Classical Monograph series (which replaces the Oxford Classical and Philosophical Monographs) is to publish books based on the best theses on Greek and Latin literature, ancient history, and ancient philosophy examined by the Faculty Board of Classics.
The Reception and Performance of Euripides’ Herakles Reasoning Madness
KAT H L E E N R I L EY
1
3
Great Clarendon Street, Oxford ox2 6dp Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. It furthers the University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide in Oxford New York Auckland Cape Town Dar es Salaam Hong Kong Karachi Kuala Lumpur Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Nairobi New Delhi Shanghai Taipei Toronto With oYces in Argentina Austria Brazil Chile Czech Republic France Greece Guatemala Hungary Italy Japan Poland Portugal Singapore South Korea Switzerland Thailand Turkey Ukraine Vietnam Oxford is a registered trade mark of Oxford University Press in the UK and in certain other countries Published in the United States by Oxford University Press Inc., New York ß Kathleen Riley 2008 The moral rights of the author have been asserted Database right Oxford University Press (maker) First published 2008 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the prior permission in writing of Oxford University Press, or as expressly permitted by law, or under terms agreed with the appropriate reprographics rights organization. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the scope of the above should be sent to the Rights Department, Oxford University Press, at the address above You must not circulate this book in any other binding or cover and you must impose the same condition on any acquirer British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Data available Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Riley, Kathleen, 1974– The reception and performance of Euripides Herakles : reasoning madness / Kathleen Riley. p. cm. –– (Oxford classical monographs) ‘‘This book began life as an Oxford D.Phil. thesis’’––Pref. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978–0–19–953448–7 1. Euripides. Heracles. 2. Heracles (Greek mythology) in literature. 3. Heracles (Greek mythology)—Drama. 4. Mental illness in literature. I. Title. PA3985.R55 2008 882’.01—dc22 2008006540 Typeset by SPI Publisher Services, Pondicherry, India Printed in Great Britain on acid-free paper by Biddles Ltd., King’s Lynn, Norfolk ISBN 978–0–19–953448–7 1 3 5 7 9 10 8 6 4 2
Parentibus amicisque carissimis Jean and Frank Riley
This page intentionally left blank
Preface This book began life as an Oxford D.Phil. thesis, and I would like to thank the University of Sydney for awarding me the Cooper and E. S. Wood Travelling Scholarships, which, supplemented by an ORS (Overseas Research Students) Award from the British government, substantially funded my three years in residence at Oxford. I am greatly indebted to Fiona Macintosh for her clear-sighted, meticulous, and stimulating supervision of my thesis, and, above all, her friendship and support. Oliver Taplin and Lorna Hardwick examined the thesis and made many valuable suggestions about revising it for publication. I have also valued the comments made on individual chapters by Edith Hall. For their advice and encouragement, my thanks to Stephen Harrison, Alastair Blanshard, Paula and Brian Alprin, and Daniel Algie. From the numerous libraries and collections I have consulted, special thanks must go to the staV of the Taylor Institution Library in Oxford for their courteous assistance, and Penelope Bulloch, Librarian at Balliol College, for making available to me Robert Browning’s manuscript of Aristophanes’ Apology. My thanks to Gerry Foley for his lucid interpretation, and practical demonstration, of key passages from Richard Strauss’s Elektra. I am extremely grateful to Cathy Ludwig and David CoVey for their generous help in rendering into clear English quotations from German texts. Most of all, I wish to thank my parents, Jean and Frank, for their wise counsel and unfailing support during the writing of the thesis and its subsequent revision, and for a lifetime’s love and inspiration. K. R. Extracts from Shirley Barlow’s translation of Euripides’ Herakles reproduced by permission of Aris & Phillips from Euripides: Heracles, edited with an Introduction, Translation, and Commentary by Shirley A. Barlow (Aris & Phillips, 1996).
viii
Preface
Extracts from John Fitch’s translation of Seneca’s Hercules Furens reprinted by permission of the publishers and the Trustees of the Loeb Classical Library from Seneca: Tragedies I, Loeb Classical Library, (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press), Copyright ß 2002 by the President and Fellows of Harvard College. The Loeb Classical Library 1 is a registered trademark of the President and Fellows of Harvard College. Translations of passages from other Greek and Latin texts are the author’s own.
Contents List of illustrations Introduction: reasoning madness and redeWning the hero 1. ‘No longer himself ’: the tragic fall of Euripides’ Herakles 2. ‘Let the monster be mine’: Seneca and the internalization of imperial furor 3. A peculiar compound: Hercules as Renaissance man 4. ‘Even the earth is not room enough’: Herculean selfhood on the Elizabethan stage 5. Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist: the nineteenth-century damnatio of Euripides 6. The Browning version: Aristophanes’ Apology and ‘the perfect piece’ 7. The psychological hero: Herakles’ lost self and the creation of Nervenkunst 8. Herakles’ apotheosis: the tragedy of Superman 9. The Herakles complex: a Senecan diagnosis of the ‘Family Annihilator’ 10. Creating a Herakles for our times: a montage of modern madness Appendix 1. Heraklean madness on the modern stage: a chronology Appendix 2. The Reading school play Bibliography Index
x 1 14 51 92 117 150 182 207 252 279 338 358 366 368 389
List of illustrations Fig. 1. Asteas, The Madness of Herakles, Paestan rf. calyx-krater (350–325 bc). Museo del Prado.
47
Fig. 2. Alessandro Turchi, The Madness of Hercules (c.1620). Bayerische Staatsgema¨ldesammlungen, Alte Pinakothek, Munich.
115
Fig. 3. Theatre programme for Herakles, Vienna, 1902.
223
Fig. 4. Herakles, Archibald MacLeish, Alexandria, VA, 2005. Deborah Rinn Critzer (Mrs Hoadley) and Bruce Alan Rauscher (Hoadley). Photo: Stan Barouh. 306 Fig. 5. Mister Heracles, Simon Armitage, Leeds 2001. Clare McCarron (Megara) and Adrian Bower (Heracles). Photo: Keith Pattison.
315
Fig. 6. Home Front, Daniel Algie, New York City 2006. Joseph Jamrog (Arthur), H. Clark (Ted), and Fletcher McTaggart (Harrison). Photo: Jonathan SlaV.
354
This page intentionally left blank
O matter and impertinency mixed, Reason in madness. (King Lear, iv. vi. 170–1) And this madness that links and divides time, that twists the world into the ring of a single night, this madness so foreign to the experience of its contemporaries, does it not transmit to those able to receive it . . . those barely audible voices of classical unreason, in which it is always a question of nothingness and night, but amplifying them now to shrieks and frenzy? (Michel Foucault, Madness and Civilization: A History of Insanity in the Age of Reason)
Introduction Reasoning madness and redeWning the hero Tales of madness are unsettling. They have a strange and enduring power to fascinate, amuse, and appal beyond the limits of their own historical moment. They seem to be tragicomedy itself: familiar, yet at the same time uncannily removed from everyday experience; entertaining but profoundly disturbing.1
One of the most unsettling tales of madness in Western literature is Euripides’ Herakles, or Herakles Mainomenos (The Madness of Herakles), Wrst produced shortly before 415 bc,2 in which, at the moment of his greatest triumph, Greece’s most celebrated hero is struck down by a supernaturally imposed madness and forced to murder his wife and children. Antiquity recorded a tradition that Euripides was prosecuted by the Athenian politician Cleon for staging at the Dionysia the unseemly spectacle of Herakles descending into madness, and for thus profaning the sacred civic festivities.3 The story is probably apocryphal, but it does reveal an ancient discomfort with this bloody and bewildering drama, a discomfort, moreover, that has endured throughout the centuries. For Herakles remains one of the least-familiar and least-performed plays in the Greek tragic canon. It 1 Salkeld (1993), 8. 2 Herakles Mainomenos, the title given in some MSS, was possibly meant to distinguish this play from the Herakleidae (The Children of Herakles). No traditional date for the Herakles has come down to us from the ancient scholars and external evidence is problematic. The most reliable indicator is internal metrical evidence, which suggests a production a little earlier than Troades of 415 bc (see Cropp and Fick (1985), 5). See also Collard (1981), 2. 3 The Oxyrhynchus Papyri, no. 2400 (vol. 24, 107–9), ll. 10–14.
2
Introduction
is only now, for the Wrst time, experiencing something of a universal renaissance, having been adapted for the stage more times (and in a wide variety of forms) in the last decade than in the whole of its previous history (see Appendix 1). And even now it has almost the status of a last taboo. But why should this be so? The play’s subject matter is unquestionably shocking—madness, uxoricide, Wlicide— but this alone cannot account for its relative neglect, its untouchability. Blinding madness, involving impious crimes against philoi (loved ones), is hardly an uncommon theme in Greek tragedy. Euripides’ other plays on the subject include Medea and Bacchae, both profoundly disturbing. However, these plays do not seem to have unsettled audiences (or prospective adapters) in quite the same way as Herakles, and they have certainly been performed with far greater frequency, making more conspicuous incursions into the popular consciousness. Why, then, is the demented, Wlicidal Herakles an especially unsettling theatrical prospect? The answer lies in the singularity of tragic Herakles. Herakles is a hero whose ontological ambivalence makes him a discomWting tragic anomaly. Euripides’ Herakles and Sophocles’ Trachiniae are the only extant Attic tragedies on the theme of suVering Herakles. Yet in Attic comedy and satyr-drama and in burlesque Herakles featured regularly and prominently, a grotesque character of phenomenal physical strength, prodigious appetites, and oaWsh demeanour. In Euripides’ tragicomic Alcestis he appears as the saviour rather than the suVerer, and his more familiar comic persona as bibulous bungler is still much in evidence. The notable imbalance between comic and tragic representations of Herakles has been partially explained by Victor Ehrenberg and more satisfactorily by Michael Silk. Ehrenberg identiWes Herakles’ divinity as the chief obstacle to the hero’s tragic portrayal: ‘The Heracles of comedy is conWrmation of the fact that the hero’s fate was not tragic, unless it became involved in human frailties and human crimes. Heracles, whether hero or glutton, was always superhuman and therefore essentially untragic.’4 Silk, however, believes the problem is not the hero’s divinity, but his unique interstitial condition as theios ane¯r (divine man) and Monoikos (lone dweller), which makes him the 4 Ehrenberg (1946), 146.
Introduction
3
ultimate outsider and gives him a potentially dangerous complexity as a subject for tragedy: The reason why the tragedians avoid Heracles as suVering hero is that a serious treatment of his suVerings means coming to terms with anomalous status, with crossing the limits, with disturbing contradictions. If (to speak in formulae) tragic-suVering man is man’s image of his own essential condition, and if god is his projection of what he would, but dare not, aspire to, and is, instead, a helpless prey to, then the enactment of tragic-suVering god-man threatens to involve its audience in an existential inquisition of an uncommonly powerful and painful kind. The pure god, pure hero, pure buVoon, are safe subjects. The suVering Heracles, as a project for tragedy, is exceptionally sensitive material, almost too disturbing, almost taboo. And when tragedy does, eventually, dare to focus on this anomaly, disturbance is conspicuous.5
Of the two surviving tragic portraits of Herakles, the Euripidean portrait is the more complex and, therefore, the more ‘dangerous’. Sophoclean Herakles suVers mightily, but he embodies an oversimpliWed and intractable heroism that is not far removed from his untragic personae. In his behaviour and heroic temperament, he is more godlike than human and, as a consequence, unreachable and unappealing. By contrast, Euripidean Herakles has a speciWcally human complexity and, by today’s standards, accessibility. He displays from the beginning an enlightened and atypical heroism, and, before the arrival of Lyssa (Frenzy or Madness), is shown to be mentally and morally sound. To watch the Herakles is, therefore, to confront an impossible conundrum: how do we reconcile this image of human greatness and innocence with the Xagrant injustice of the gods and the inhuman nature of the hero’s mad crimes? In June 2004, reXecting on ‘the current rash of Greek drama . . . directly attributable to the unfolding tragedy in the Middle East’,6 Michael Billington, drama critic for the Guardian, posed the rhetorical question: ‘Where does our theatre instinctively turn in times of 5 Silk (1985), 1–22, at 7. 6 Michael Billington, ‘Terror of Modern Times Sets the Stage for Greek Tragedy’, Guardian, 19 June 2004. The ‘current rash of Greek drama’ included productions of Euripides’ Iphigenia at Aulis at the National Theatre, Martin Crimp’s Cruel and Tender (an adaptation of Sophocles’ Trachiniae) at the Young Vic, Euripides’ Ion at the Mercury Theatre in Colchester, and Euripides Hecuba at the Donmar Warehouse.
4
Introduction
crisis? Not to Shakespeare or Shaw but to the Greeks.’7 Despite the overall sparseness of its performance history, the Herakles is no exception to this rule. Since the Wfth century bc interest in the play has been intermittent, but has always surfaced in historically charged circumstances (e.g. late Julio-Claudian Rome, Tudor England, Wnde-sie`cle Vienna, Cold War and post-9/11 America). Astonishingly, given its infrequent staging, the Herakles has had an undeniable impact on the history of ideas, proving an ideal text for people wanting, or needing, to redeWne the concepts of ‘madness’ and ‘hero’. As an examination of heroism in crisis, a tragedy about the greatest of heroes facing an abyss of despair but ultimately Wnding redemption, it resonates powerfully with individuals and communities at historical and ethical crossroads. However, the impact of the play has not always been a question of direct inspiration or obvious appropriation. Very often it has penetrated the prevailing culture by circuitous or subterranean means, although no less profoundly. The list of writers who have adapted, or in other ways championed, Euripides’ Herakles through the ages is a distinguished and sometimes surprising one. In keeping with its dangerous complexity and strange beauty, the play has consistently attracted rebels and visionaries to its cause. Duncan Salkeld has commented that to read tales of madness ‘is to confront a variety of questions. Can the madness of the past be interpreted in present-day categories of insanity? Should the concepts of real and literary madness be distinguished? Does madness make sense, and if so, what does it mean?’8 The primary interest of this book lies in changing ideas of Heraklean madness, of its causes, its consequences, and its therapy. Writers subsequent to Euripides have tried to ‘reason’ or make sense of the madness, often in accordance with contemporary thinking on mental illness. Diagnoses of Herakles’ condition have included melancholy, epilepsy, hysteria, manic depression, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and have been informed by a range of theories from humoral pathology
7 Michael Billington, ‘Terror of Modern Times Sets the Stage for Greek Tragedy’, Guardian, 19 June 2004. 8 Salkeld (1993), 8.
Introduction
5
to psychoanalysis and beyond. But Euripides’ play is not only a psychologically compelling dramatization of the irrational; it is also a thought-provoking enquiry into the heroic. In addition to the questions identiWed by Salkeld, interpreters of Herakles have had to confront a further question: how are we to understand Herakles’ arete¯ (moral and heroic excellence) in the light of his insane behaviour? Attempts to reason the madness necessarily entail redeWning Herakles’ heroism accordingly. This process of heroic redeWnition is the second focus of my investigation. Euripides himself emphasized a total absence of reason for the madness. The structural Wssion, unparalleled central epiphany, and highly unusual characterization of Herakles and Lyssa establish psychological and ethical discontinuity between Herakles sane and Herakles insane. The madness is senseless and intrusive, an unpardonable mischief conceived by malevolent gods. Against divine unreason, the rehabilitated Herakles emerges as a mature and humanistic hero whose salvation is achieved through human philia (love, friendship) and his own progressive spiritual resolve. Euripides’ play is, of course, itself an adaptation of traditional myth. As an adaptation it contains several innovations, not least of which is to feature the madness and Wlicide as the climax of Herakles’ twelve labours (rather than the labours as atonement for the Wlicide). The eVect of this is to emphasize further Herakles’ innocence and the injustice of the gods, and to concentrate meaning and dramatic tension in Herakles’ recovery from a disaster beyond reason. In adaptations of Euripides’ text, however, the implications of his chronological inversion of the Wlicide and labours have been very diVerently perceived. Later writers generally see a causal link between the violence of the labours and the domestic violence that immediately follows their completion. As a result, the rehabilitation of Herakles, which is the most radical part of Euripides’ play, is made secondary to the question of psychological causation in relation to his explosive madness. The Wrst writer to draw such a link between the labours and the Wlicide, and so begin the process of reasoning Herakles’ madness, was the Roman philosopher and tragedian Seneca. In his Hercules Furens two levels of motivation are apparent, the divine/mythological and
6
Introduction
the human/psychological, with the emphasis on the latter. Seneca internalizes Hercules’ furor, dispensing with the interventionist mischief-makers Iris and Lyssa, and thereby obscuring the boundary between sanity and insanity. He portrays Hercules throughout as a megalomaniac and menacingly autarkic overreacher, whose madness triggers a latent psychosis, and whose hallucinations merely extrapolate his ‘rational’ aspirations. He thus restores the traditional theodicy, which Euripides dismantled, and introduces to this particular tale of madness both psychological and ethical coherence. Hercules, as an idea or type, was an important and ubiquitous presence in the art, literature, and philosophy of the Renaissance. Although he was always primarily deWned as a warrior hero, a performer of civilizing feats, Renaissance Hercules was, in fact, a synthesis and distillation of various classical traditions. His most popular and pervasive incarnation was as Hercules in bivio (Hercules at the Crossroads), the triumphant hero of a Manichean struggle between Virtue and Vice. As such he became omnia omnibus, happily appropriated into civil humanism and Christian metaphysics alike. The Renaissance conception of mad Hercules was very diVerent from this paragon of virtus, reason, and restraint, but an equally composite and adaptable creation. What is known as the ‘Hercules furens tradition’ is neither exclusively Senecan nor essentially tragic. It is a wholesale description applied to a group of overlapping traditions—philosophical, medical, literary, and histrionic—whose ancient sources include Hippocrates, Aristotle, Macrobius, Ovid, and, of course, Seneca. In the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries translations of Seneca’s Hercules Furens appeared in England and on the Continent, helping to establish the Herculean hero as a deWning presence in Renaissance drama. Seneca’s psychologically and ethically challenging Hercules is an especially discernible and inXuential presence in Elizabethan tragedy. Political and cultural similarities between imperial Rome and Tudor England ensured the responsiveness of Elizabethan playwrights to the Senecan overreacher’s magnetism as well as his menace. Madness and tyranny in the plays of Shakespeare and his contemporaries are frequently construed in terms of Herculean furor, which, in turn, is rendered synonymous with an apocalyptic sense of selfhood. Following the Renaissance, mad Herakles eVectively disappeared from the stage and the cultural consciousness, re-emerging only very
Introduction
7
gradually after an interval of nearly 200 years. For much of the nineteenth century Euripidean tragedy was either ignored or else roundly condemned, and the fate of Herakles was to become the preserve of a small but inXuential group of nonconformists. In 1818 Richard Valpy, the charismatic headmaster of Reading School, staged, in ancient Greek, the only documented production of Herakles in the nineteenth century. Later in the century the outspoken classical historian J. P. MahaVy initiated an anti-Aristophanic defence of Euripides, citing Herakles as ‘among the best of the poet’s works’;9 and his pupil, Oscar Wilde, expressed a special familiarity and aYnity with the play, as well as a desire to edit it. The revolutionary German philologist Ulrich von Wilamowitz-MoellendorV began work on a seminal edition of the text in the 1870s as part of his historicist crusade; and Robert Browning made his translation of Herakles in 1875 the pie`ce de re´sistance in a remarkable Euripidean defence (Aristophanes’ Apology). Browning’s version makes no attempt to reason Herakles’ madness. It is instead an extremely sympathetic ampliWcation of Euripides’ own voice, reaYrming, as opposed to redeWning, the play’s hero as redeemer and redeemed. The Modernist reception of mad Herakles has two currents, one psychological, the other philosophical. The Wrst represents the combined theories of Wilamowitz, the critic Herman Bahr, and the playwright Hugo von Hofmannsthal. In his 1889 edition of the Herakles, Wilamowitz proposed his ‘seeds of madness’ theory, portraying Euripides’ hero as a blood-crazed megalomaniac. In 1902 his translation of the play was produced in Vienna and was the Wrst modern revival of Euripides on the European stage. This production, and in particular Bahr’s reaction to it, had a direct impact on the creation of Nervenkunst (neurotic art). Bahr, focusing on line 931 (› PŒŁ Æe q, ‘he was no longer himself ’), believed the mad Herakles to be a hero straight from the pages of Breuer and Freud, symbolizing the terrifying potential in all human beings to lose themselves, to become something ‘other’ than themselves. His reading of line 931 formed the basis of the Wrst explicitly psychoanalytic interpretation of Greek tragedy ever staged, Hofmannsthal’s electrifying Elektra of 1903. Meanwhile, other Modernist writers, namely 9 MahaVy (1879), 81.
8
Introduction
George Cabot Lodge, W. B. Yeats, and Frank Wedekind, conceived of Herakles as the archetypal Nietzschean Superman, reasoning the madness and murders as an inescapable precondition of self-divinity. In the late twentieth century, Cold War fears of nuclear annihilation and post-Vietnam awareness of combat trauma led to the identiWcation in the heroic male psyche of what might be termed a ‘Herakles complex’. Consequently, the adaptations of Euripides’ Herakles by Archibald MacLeish (pub. 1967) and Simon Armitage (pub. 2000) focused speciWcally on the Wlicide and its cultural implications, and applied a Senecan and psychoanalytic reading to the madness and to the Euripidean sequence of labours–Wlicide. MacLeish draws a frightening analogy between Herakles Kallinikos (Glorious Victor) and a Strangelovean scientist bent on dystopian perfection. Armitage portrays a maverick military man, an intuitive berserker lost in the maze of peacetime complexity. In each case the restless, overachieving hero Wts the psychological proWle of what American criminologists categorize as the ‘family annihilator’. MacLeish and Armitage were the Wrst modern playwrights to dramatize the Herakles complex. They were also instigators of the current phase in the reception of Euripides’ Herakles, that of the ‘neo-Senecan Herakles’. Out of the escalating horrors of our post9/11 world, and in direct response to the Iraq War, several new stage adaptations of Herakles have emerged. Apart from their record number, what is fascinating about these productions is that, although they are consciously inspired by Euripides, they have been unconsciously Senecanized, Wltered through a sense of despair that is supremely Senecan and at the same time utterly contemporary. Perhaps more so than at any other stage in his reception, the tragic Herakles of the early twenty-Wrst century is symbolic of acute moral crisis. His loss of self has become a metaphor for an entire civilization that has lost its way. Like Seneca’s portrait of the irredeemably autarkic Hercules, it is a metaphor tempered by little in the way of optimism. At the time of writing, mad Herakles’ latest manifestation is as a deeply traumatized war veteran in Daniel Algie’s powerful play Home Front. The unexpected death of this hero at the hands of the Theseus character, which is portrayed as a type of mercy killing and a Wnal act of friendship, exceeds Seneca in its cancellation of the redemptive might of Euripidean philia.
Introduction
9
The present study has been undertaken at a time when reception studies are becoming an increasingly valuable and respectable component of mainstream classical scholarship. The need to validate the place of reception within the discipline of classics has become less critical than the need for rigorous discussion about reception theory and methodology. One of the latest attempts to answer that need is Classics and the Uses of Reception (2006), edited by Charles Martindale and Richard Thomas. The diversity of contributions to this volume illustrates the current eclecticism of approach and lack of orthodoxy characteristic of classical reception studies. However, among pioneering deWnitions of classical reception and its purpose, which have appeared in the last ten to Wfteen years, some areas of reasonable consensus are apparent, most notably the idea that reception involves a dialogic or mutually illuminating discourse between ancient and modern. Martindale’s original reception manifesto, which appeared in 1993, held that ‘Meaning . . . is always realized at the point of reception’,10 that ‘numerous unexplored insights into ancient literature are locked up in imitations, translations, and so forth’.11 Thirteen years later he restated this thesis in terms of a twoway transmission of meaning: ‘reception involves the acknowledgement that the past and present are always implicated in each other.’12 In 2003 Lorna Hardwick showed how reception studies ‘focus critical attention back towards the ancient source and sometimes frame new questions or retrieve aspects of the source which have been marginalized or forgotten. . . . Reception studies therefore participate in the continuous dialogue between past and present.’13 The following year Edith Hall, formulating a theory of performance reception, advocated as ‘eminently sensible’ the notion ‘that our appreciation of the original texts can be reWned by excavating their afterlife, what they have ‘‘meant’’ in other cultures and epochs than those which originally produced them’.14 My approach to the reception of Euripides’ Herakles has been enlightened by much of this emergent theory, which has then been reinforced at a very practical level in my research. 10 Martindale (1993), 3. 11 Ibid. 7. 13 Hardwick (2003), 4.
12 Martindale (2006), 1–13, at 12. 14 Hall (2004a), 51–89, at 54.
10
Introduction
In an essay on the complexities of Shakespeare’s relationship to, and exploitation of, the classics, Colin Burrow raises an important issue: ‘Misremembering and mishearing the classical tongues can be as much a response to ‘‘the classics’’ as careful imitations and artful echoes.’15 Martindale makes a similar point: ‘One value of reception is to bring to consciousness the factors that may have contributed to our responses to the texts of the past, factors of which we may well be ‘‘ignorant’’ but are not therefore ‘‘innocent’’.’16 The present study, therefore, examines not only instances of explicit adaptation or appropriation, but also, and sometimes more revealingly, instances of implicit, mediated, or subterranean reception (such as the Euripidean and Heraklean essence of Hofmannsthal’s adaptation of Sophocles’ Elektra), and even of what we might cautiously describe as misappropriation (observable in the Wlicidal Herakles’ signiWcant role in Lodge’s doctrine of self-divinity). My methodology then is directed towards the discovery of both the intended and unintended consequences of reception. Examples of the latter could be said to include the recent phenomenon of neo-Senecanism in stage adaptations of Euripides’ text. As my title indicates, this study is also a performance history of Euripides’ Herakles and is, therefore, concerned with how the play has left its mark at crucial junctures of theatrical as well as cultural history. ‘It is the dynamic relationship’, Hall explains, ‘between ancient text, performer, and his or her audience that above all distinguishes Performance Reception from the study of the ways in which ancient texts have been received elsewhere.’17 With regard to a distinguishable methodology for the investigation of this branch of reception, Fiona Macintosh states that ideally performance history ‘works extensively and intensively at the intersection between theatre history, histories of classical scholarship and the history of ideas. . . . For the performance historian, the need to be aware of the importance of all these perspectives is imperative.’18 She also stresses the need for performance history ‘to combine diachronic awareness with synchronic depth together with formalist analysis of the texts in
15 Burrow (2004), 9–27, at 15. 17 Hall (2004a), 51–89, at 52.
16 Martindale (2006), 1–13, at 5. 18 Macintosh (2007), chap. 19.
Introduction
11
question’.19 With these principles in mind, my own practice has involved close textual analysis within a framework of broad historical contextualization. ‘Bigger-picture’ questions relating to social and political developments, theatrical and literary movements, and the education and professional lives of theatre practitioners have proved as pertinent to my investigation of the impact of a performance as questions surrounding the linguistic subtleties of a play and the aesthetics of translation. In Hall’s estimation, the performance historian is essentially a time-traveller with access to a unique conduit of human history, generated by an art form whose consequences belie its supposed ephemerality and exclusivity: Watched in physical company with many other spectators, performance oVers privileged access to mass ideology and collective taste and prejudice, and it is as a source for such phenomena that it tends to be used by social historians. But it simultaneously permits access to the private imaginative worlds of the individual members of previous generations. Theatre happens, and leaves its psychological records, precisely at the intersection of the collective and the individual, the ‘ideological’ and the ‘subjective.’ Theatre critics have, moreover, long been aware that there is something distinctive about the immanent presence of live performance in the human memory. Far from being an ephemeral art, which happens, comes to an end, and vanishes without a trace, a compelling theatrical experience can leave a much deeper impression on the memory even than the printed word or painted image.20
‘Performance issues’, Hall reveals, ‘may often need to be addressed in the negative—why was a play’s performance banned at a particular time . . . or why were there no attempts to stage Aeschylus in the seventeenth century, or Trojan Women in the nineteenth’.21 In the case of Herakles, in addition to the larger issue of the play’s relatively erratic stage history and untouchability, there is a need to address the speciWc impediments to its performance and the lacunae in its reception. For example, there is the question of tragic Herakles’ disappearance from the stage in the post-Renaissance period. There is also the prevalent damnatio of Euripides in the nineteenth century, which contributes both to the neglect and to the eventual rehabilitation of his tragedies. 19 Ibid.
20 Hall (2004a), 51–89, at 68.
21 Ibid. 56.
12
Introduction
As Macintosh makes clear, there are ‘inherent problems with the tools and the sources of performance reception—especially with the review’, so that the ‘need for a wide range of contextual evidence is paramount.’22 My approach to these problems, where possible, has been to examine the performance aspects of a production in close conjunction with the playscript (whether published or unpublished). Occasionally my analysis has been informed by my Wrst-hand knowledge of a performance. More frequently I have utilized a variety of primary sources, including posters, programmes, and visual or printed evidence about translation and production values, performance space, set design, costume, and styles of acting. These primary sources have been augmented by the use of reviews and interviews (conducted by myself or in the media) with a producer, playwright, or director. In examining instances of reception beyond the stage, my research has encompassed a similarly wide range of primary sources. I have, for example, been able to consult the original manuscript of Browning’s Aristophanes’ Apology at Balliol College, Oxford, and make extensive use of Hermann Bahr’s diaries and correspondence. The whole notion of adaptation, which the reception specialist or performance historian must address, is often pejoratively conceived. As Linda Hutcheon points out: ‘an adaptation is likely to be greeted as minor and subsidiary and certainly never as good as the ‘‘original’’.’23 This negativity becomes inevitable when the criterion of judgement is how ‘faithful’ an adaptation is to the original: ‘The morally loaded discourse of Wdelity is based on the implied assumption that adapters aim simply to reproduce the adapted text. Adaptation is repetition, but repetition without replication. And there are manifestly many diVerent possible intentions behind the act of adaptation.’24 Scholars of the ‘classical tradition’, the theoretical forerunner to classical reception studies, tended in their investigations to use terms such as ‘inXuence’ and ‘legacy’, which in turn tended to preserve the ancient text as a yardstick of value or a kind of Urtext edition. Within these parameters the notion of adaptation is in danger of being reduced to a matter of either imitation or degeneration. 22 Macintosh (2007). On the diYculty in using the theatrical review critically, see Hardwick (2003), 53–4. 23 Hutcheon (2006), p. xii. 24 Hutcheon (2006), 7.
Introduction
13
By contrast, as Hardwick notes: ‘The vocabulary of reception studies has moved on from notions of ‘‘legacy’’ to include also the values and practices of the present and future creativity of classical culture. The key evaluative question both for the relationship with the past and for the present, may well be ‘‘what diVerence was made?’’ ’ In my study of the major receptions of Euripides’ Herakles up to the end of 2006, I have been eager to demonstrate what I believe constitutes the play’s Euripidean essence and how, at key moments in history, that essence has been transformed, even to the point of occasional cancellation. However, I do not see this transformative process as one of corruption and decline, but rather as a culturally revealing evolution that conWrms Euripides’ play as a ‘culturally active presence’.25 The Herakles has inspired, and continues to inspire, widely diVering adaptations of the hero and his madness, and as Shirley Barlow insists: ‘That is as it should be with any great work of art. . . . The motivation for Heracles’ madness will continue to be more complex than appears on the surface. And that is hardly surprising when the causes of madness in real life are so often puzzling and paradoxical. That theories so diVerent . . . should arise in regard to the Heracles is not a slur on Euripides, but rather a tribute to his depth.’26 25 Hardwick (2003), 112.
26 Barlow (1981), 112–28, at 126.
1 ‘No longer himself ’: the tragic fall of Euripides’ Herakles ‘Madness’, according to Ruth Padel, ‘is the perfect image of tragic fall’,1 because of its daemonic power to eVect a sudden, comprehensive reversal of fortune and identity, and because it operates outside human control. In the light of this deWnition, there is no more perfect image of tragic fall in dramatic literature than Euripides’ Herakles, the glorious civilizer and saviour who, in a Wt of divinely inspired madness, murders his wife and children. At line 931 of Herakles the Messenger announces the moment of the hero’s insane metamorphosis with the words › PŒŁ Æe q (‘he was no longer himself ’). His terse declaration encapsulates the essence of Herakles’ tragic fall, which is not only a sudden and comprehensive reversal, but an external, arbitrary imposition of ‘otherness’. Lyssa works from within Herakles, merging with his being in a very literal and physical sense, but she is not an extension or manifestation of his psychology. Instead, it is Herakles who manifests Lyssa’s irresistible force and Hera’s implacable will. Herakles becomes something alien; he is no longer himself. An English translation of 931 cannot adequately reproduce its extraordinary impact. With the Greek verse Euripides pithily initiates a series of revolutionary assaults on conventional dramaturgy, morally orthodox thinking, and audience expectations. As an immediate consequence of Herakles’ loss of self, the anticipated Wnale to an Odyssean nostos drama is brutally sabotaged; the chorus’s lyric invocation of Herakles Alexikakos (averter of evil), in all his Pindaric splendour, is 1 Padel (1995), 241.
‘No longer himself ’
15
horrifyingly travestied; and the traditional theodicy, with its attendant consolations, is smashed. But these violations of structural and moral unity are not simply acts of wanton theatrical destruction or ‘an extreme example of Euripidean shock tactics’.2 They constitute a meaningful prelude to the most innovative aspect of Euripides’ treatment of the Herakles myth, namely his hero’s assertion of a radical and enlightened humanism.
A N E S S E N T IA L D I S U N I T Y: T H E P RO B L E M O F T H E P L AY ’ S S T RU C TU R E The most obvious and critically rehearsed feature of the Herakles is its singular structure, in particular ‘the brisk counterpoint of peripeties on which the tragedy turns, wheeling over and over as one action pivots to its opposite, or, juxtaposed, against a sudden illumination, is as suddenly shattered and annulled’.3 At the beginning of the play, while Herakles is in the underworld completing his Wnal labour, his father Amphitryon, wife Megara, and three sons are sentenced to death by the usurping tyrant Lycus. Herakles arrives in time to save his family, but is at that moment struck by madness and forced to murder his wife and children. Thus, the play’s action is violently broken into two apparently discrete dramatic entities or movements: the Wrst is a familiar suppliant action, a rescue story culminating in belated but convincing conWrmation of Providence; the second is inaugurated by a sinister central epiphany and cancels the moral order which the Wrst movement restored. Since the early nineteenth century critics have complained about the lack of organic or causal unity between these two movements,4
2 Michelini (1987), 233. 3 Arrowsmith (1956), 44–59, at 45. 4 The leader of the 19th-century damnatio of Euripides, A. W. Schlegel (1846), 137 put the case against the Herakles plainly: ‘We have another example of two distinct and separate actions in the same tragedy, the Mad Heracles. . . . The one action follows, but by no means arises out of the other.’ For the Schlegelian Euripidesbild, see below, Chap. 5.
16
‘No longer himself ’
branding the eVect ‘episodic’, ‘diptychal’, and even ‘triptychal’.5 ‘[A] shapeless and soulless abortion’,6 ‘broken-backed’,7 and ‘ramshackle’8 are among the more colourful and damning descriptions of the play’s confronting structural violence. Such complaints issue from an Aristotelian standard of tragic construction and focus on Euripides’ undeniably un-Aristotelian use of peripeteia. In the Poetics, Aristotle maintains that a successful plot relies on a logical sequence of cause and eVect, wherein each incident is the result of what has gone before. In a ‘simple’ (i.e. single or continuous) plot an incident can, and ideally should, be unexpected, but never accidental. Everything that happens must be directed by necessity or probability: H b ± ºH Łø ŒÆd æ ø ƃ K ØØØ Nd æØÆØ: ºªø K ØØ FŁ K fiz a K ØØÆ ¼ºººÆ h NŒe h I ªŒ r ÆØ: ØÆFÆØ b ØFÆØ e b H Æ ºø ØH Ø ÆP ; e b H IªÆŁH Øa f ŒæØ · IªøÆÆ ªaæ ØF ŒÆd Ææa c ÆØ
ÆæÆ e FŁ ºº ŒØ ØÆæØ IƪŒ ÆØ e KB: K d b P ºÆ Kd æ ø Ø Iººa ŒÆd æH ŒÆd KºØH; ÆFÆ b ªÆØ ŒÆd ºØÆ ½ŒÆd Aºº ‹Æ ªÆØ Ææa c Æ Ø ¼ºººÆ· e ªaæ ŁÆıÆe oø Ø Aºº j N I e F ÆP ı ŒÆd B ; K d ŒÆd H I e ÆFÆ ŁÆıÆØÆÆ ŒE ‹Æ u æ K ÆÆØ ªªÆØ. (1451b–1452a) Of simple plots and actions the worst are those which are episodic. I call a plot ‘episodic’ in which the episodes come after one another neither probably nor of necessity. Such pieces are composed by bad poets on their own account, and by good poets for the sake of the actors; for, as they write for competition and stretch a plot beyond its capacity, they are often compelled to break the continuity. But this is bad work, since tragedy is an imitation not only of a complete action but also of incidents inspiring fear and pity, and this happens most of all when the incidents occur contrary to expectation and yet follow as cause and eVect; for in this way the incidents will cause more amazement than if they happened of themselves or by chance, since even the most amazing coincidences are those which seem to have happened as if on purpose. 5 Kitto (1961), 235 declared that the Herakles ‘falls into three distinct parts. . . . But a play has no business to be a triptych’. 6 Swinburne (1889), 179. 7 Murray (1946), 112. 8 Norwood (1954), 46.
‘No longer himself ’
17
The same rule applies to a ‘complex’ plot in which a change of fortune ( ÆØ) coincides with a discovery (IÆªæØØ) or reversal ( æØ ØÆ) or both: ÆFÆ b E ªŁÆØ K ÆPB B ı ø F Łı; u KŒ H
檪ø ıÆØ j K I ªŒ j ŒÆa e NŒe ªªŁÆØ ÆFÆ· ØÆæØ ªaæ ºf e ªªŁÆØ Øa j a . (1452a) These things ought to arise from the actual structure of the plot, so that from what has occurred earlier it follows that these things happen either by necessity or according to probability; for what happens on account of these things is very diVerent from what happens after these things.
Measured against this Aristotelian formula, the plot of the Herakles is unsatisfactory because the central change which occurs—the madness—is not a necessary or probable outcome; it is not, for instance, the corrective result of any visible ±ÆæÆ (failure or error) or the revelation of any latent psychological disturbance. In fact, the whole concept of change in the play ‘is seen not as rhythmical and orderly but as violent and capricious’.9 But not everyone has reacted to the Herakles with a sense of ‘outraged Aristotelianism’.10 Many commentators have approached the alleged problem of the play’s structure by advancing positive ‘solutions’. These solutions can be divided into three main types. The Wrst is an attempt to minimize the obvious dislocation of events and unconnected juxtapositions by establishing a coherent and continuous thematic pattern reinforced by linguistic repetitions. Sheppard, for example, believes the key to the play’s overarching unity is the recurrent motifs of friendship, strength, and wealth, explicitly stated in the closing lines (1425–6) and variously embodied throughout.11 The Herakles thus becomes a logical comparative exposition of these values. Following on from Sheppard, Chalk argues for demonstrable organic unity on the basis of ‘a further general concept— Iæ’ and, more particularly, the architectonic question—‘What is the place of human Iæ in the universe?’12 This question, he says, ‘is more than a theme. It is the play: the inexplicable overthrow by
9 Barlow (1981), 112–28, at 124. 11 Sheppard (1916), 72–9.
10 Arrowsmith (1956), 44–59, at 45. 12 Chalk (1962), 7–18, at 8.
18
‘No longer himself ’
Hera of the conventional Iæ of Herakles followed by his recovery of a further Iæ prompt and (tragically) answer precisely this question.’13 Kamerbeek also advocates a unity of form which depends on the recurrence of a number of themes and phrases in the play’s two movements, such as the rare KºŒ simile used in Herakles’ two exit scenes (631 and 1424).14 The second type of solution, whose chief proponent was Ulrich von Wilamowitz-MoellendorV,15 restores to the plot the Aristotelian principles of necessity and probability, but removes the Aristotelian ideal of unexpectedness. It achieves causal unity by locating in the Wrst movement symptoms of mental imbalance, which preWgure the fullblown madness of the second movement.16 To this end, Herakles’ early speeches and behaviour have been scrutinized for signs of megalomania and intuitive bloodlust, or else the madness itself has been diagnosed as epilepsy.17 But, as Kevin Lee argues, these theses of psychological coherence ‘do violence to the text and/or turn the tragedy into a complicated form of case-history’.18 A variation on this solution is Burnett’s notion that the madness is morally, rather than psychologically, preWgured in the Wrst movement. To establish causal unity, she propounds a theory of hamartia, which includes Megara’s unnatural and untenable suppliancy and ‘arrogant agnosticism’,19 Amphitryon’s acquiescence in his daughterin-law’s ‘active unfaith’,20 and Herakles’ hubristic, albeit mostly passive, condition of grandeur: When the opening scenes of the Heracles are compared to their natural foils in other suppliant drama, aberrations and distortions appear that are easily a match for those of the second half of the play. In fact, the two halves of the play, equally deWant of the conventional forms, prove to have positive ethical links that establish something very like a causal sequence between them. Megara’s suppliant drama is an action purposely malformed so that it can lead directly into the grotesque scenes that destroy her.21
13 15 16 17 18 19
Chalk (1962), 7–18, at 9. 14 Kamerbeek (1966), 1–16. On Wilamowitz’s ‘seeds of madness’ theory and its inXuence, see below, Chap. 7. For a more recent solution along these lines, see Ruck (1976), 53–75. On Herakles as epileptic, see Blaiklock (1945), 48–63. Lee (1980), 34–45, at 34. Burnett (1971), 163. 20 Ibid. 162. 21 Ibid. 158–9.
‘No longer himself ’
19
Burnett contends that the ‘true radicalism’ of this suppliant action has been hitherto obscured,22 but the radicalism she deWnes pertains to Megara’s scepticism and not to Euripides’ treatment of the heresy expounded by Megara and personiWed by Herakles. For she later says, in relation to the deaths of Megara and the children, that ‘the poet has unobtrusively insisted that this fate was not only necessary to heaven but freely chosen by those who have suVered it’.23 Thus her own reading of the play, according to which Euripides is clearly endorsing the traditional theodicy, undercuts her claim of radicalism. The claim of radicalism can only be upheld when we recognize that Euripides is on the side of the heretics. The third, and most persuasive, type of solution is to see reXected in the uniquely bifurcated plot Herakles’ unique duality as ŁE Iæ (divine man). Justina Gregory defends the play’s structural and thematic unity by pointing to the motif of Herakles’ shared paternity, which spans every episode, and to the accompanying ‘spiritual contradiction involved in being simultaneously the son of Zeus and Amphitryon’.24 Owing to the emphasis placed on this contradiction, the madness assumes the function of an inevitable crisis, at the end of which the hero has rejected Zeus and his divine inheritance and embraced Amphitryon and his humanity. This function is further explained by Silk, who insists that what appears arbitrary or contradictory in the play is inherent in the myth itself, whereas Euripides’ plot develops in a way consistent with the demands of necessity: ‘[The] explosion—the madness—is presented as an arbitrary explosion such as gods create, but also as a necessary explosion, necessary in metaphysical terms as well as necessary on the level of character. The combination of god and man is unstable and must be blown apart to permit a new, simpler and comprehensible stability, whereby Heracles becomes a suVering man in whom we can believe and to whom we can relate.’25 According to this reading, the two separate actions of the Herakles actually represent one continuous movement towards humanity. 22 Ibid. 158. 23 Ibid. 172. 24 Gregory (1977), 259–75, at 272. On Herakles’ double parentage, see also Furley (1986), 102–13, at 106–7. 25 Silk (1985), 1–22, at 18.
20
‘No longer himself ’
These solutions are ingenious, and sometimes cogent, but they are all fundamentally thematic solutions to what has been invariably diagnosed as a formal problem.26 In the pursuit of thematic unity, the issue of actual formal disunity has been, perhaps too conveniently, circumvented. Moreover, the general failure to engage directly with this formal disunity has meant that the impact of the play in performance has largely been ignored. Thematic, linguistic, ethical, and psychological unity do not necessarily add up to structural unity or to powerful theatre. In terms of the ideas it presents, the Herakles is undoubtedly a coherent piece of drama, but this does not mitigate the jarring juxtaposition of events and wrenching transitions built into the plot, which are, I believe, central to the play’s meaning. On the page, and in performance, Euripides emphasizes contrast, change, and reversal. Linguistically and visually he reinforces the structural irrationalism.27 At 735 the chorus begin their celebration of the joyful metabasis that is Herakles’ return and Lycus’ destruction by exclaiming, ƺa ŒÆŒH (‘Disaster is reversed!’). Their very diVerent reaction to the second major turning-point in the play, the arrival of Iris and Lyssa, is similarly phrased, Æf e PıB ƺ Æø (‘In a moment a god has destroyed the [hero’s] happiness’, 884). The repetition highlights the swiftness with which fate has subverted one set of circumstances and emotions and replaced them with another. At 1015 the Messenger, concluding his account of Herakles’ demented rampage, says of the hero, PŒ r Æ ŁH ‹Ø IŁºØæ (‘I do not know of any man more miserable’). As Galinsky notes, the word IŁºØæ derives from pŁºÆ (labours),28 so that Herakles’ tragic fall is reXected in the changed nature of his most famous feats. Likewise, at 1279 Herakles refers to the murder of his children as his Wnal labour (e ºŁØ ) and, at 1411, as his most diYcult (– Æ Kº ø ŒEÆ H º 26 Cf. Barlow (1982), 115–25, at 115: ‘There have been attempts to gloss the awkward structure by searches for over-arching thematic or linguistic unity which have somehow still obviated the need to take into account too strongly the violent wrenches of fortune which the plot reveals.’ 27 On the meaning and aural impact of Euripides’ linguistic madness, see Kraus (1998), 137–56. 28 Galinsky (1972), 62.
‘No longer himself ’
21
ŒÆŒ , ‘All those labours I endured were less than this’). These allusions to Herakles’ heroic past, within the context of his present abasement, stress ‘the violence of change and its adverse eVects’.29 Euripides also emphasizes the violence of change by setting up contrasting images in structurally parallel positions. As Amphitryon enters the palace at 732–3, he tells the chorus how gladly he anticipates the retribution that now awaits his enemy Lycus: Ø ªaæ a ŁfiŒø Icæ KŁæe ø H æÆø Œ. It has a certain pleasure to see an enemy being killed and paying the penalty for his actions.
The very next image the audience has of Amphitryon is at 1039–41, where he emerges from the palace after witnessing not only the just execution of his KŁæ, but also the senseless slaughter of his grandchildren: › u Ø ZæØ ¼ æ ŒÆÆø TEÆ Œø æı æfiø d
ØŒæa ØŒø XºıØ
æŁ ‹. Here the old man comes, treading a sad path with lagging steps, mourning like a bird mourning the unXedged birth-pang of its young.
In the same way, at 636, Herakles enters the palace as unequivocally the Kallinikos (Glorious Victor). At 1029, however, the ekkuklema presents an image of Herakles in abject defeat—bound, weaponless, and amechanos (helpless), his tragic fall complete. Gregory claims that the unifying theme of dual fatherhood ‘helps to soften the unexpectedness of the episode of madness’,30 and Bond, singling out the question-and-answer contrast at 814–15,31 speaks of the play as having ‘an essential unity’.32 Yet surely the dramatic point being made is an essential ‘disunity’, a point which can be appreciated only when we acknowledge, as Arrowsmith has done, that the structural 29 Barlow (1981), 112–28, at 124. 30 Gregory (1977), 259–75, at 261. 31 The question posed at 814 is whether justice still Wnds favour with the gods (N e ŒÆØ j ŁE IæŒØ). It is answered at 815 by the sudden, chilling arrival of Hera’s envoys. 32 Bond (1981), p. xx.
22
‘No longer himself ’
Wssion is deliberate and dominant, and ought not to have superimposed on it a ‘softening’ rationale or cohesiveness: Beyond question the play falls starkly into two discrete but continuous actions, and between these two actions there is neither causal unity nor even probability: the second action follows but by no means arises out of the Wrst. . . . Against theodicy is put the hideous proof of divine injustice; against the greatness and piety and arete of Heracles in the Wrst action is placed the terrible reward of heroism in the second; against the asserted peace and calm and domestic tenderness which closes the Wrst action is set the utter annihilation of all moral order in the second. The result is a structure in which two apparently autonomous actions are jammed savagely against each other in almost total contradiction, with no attempt to minimize or even modulate the profound formal rift. That rift is, of course, deliberate; nothing, in fact, has been omitted which might support the eVect of total shock in this reversal. Moreover, even a cursory review of the material which Euripides used for his tragedy shows how carefully that material has been ordered to eVect, rather than obviate, this dislocation of structure.33
As the three-pronged defence of structural unity outlined above suggests, surprisingly few critics have happily accepted the fact ‘that it is not possible to make the tragedy please Aristotle’,34 let alone arrived at Arrowsmith’s or Lee’s conclusion that it is precisely ‘the breaking of the rules which Euripides wants to dramatize. Any tidy cause and eVect connection would be incompatible with the unique form of disorder which underpins this play.’35 And, of those who share this view, a good percentage have adopted a theory that, dramatically speaking, is unsound. In an attempt to reconcile what many consider the conventionality and feebleness of the play’s opening scenes with the horriWc vigour of its later scenes, W. G. Arnott declares the entire Wrst movement to be ‘Euripides’ mightiest red herring’. In his estimation, the playwright has committed an act of calculated theatrical incompetence in order to ‘turn the next 350 lines into a caustic series of savage shocks’.36 Michelini, who states plainly that, far from possessing organic unity, the Herakles is actually ‘designed to be unintelligible’,37 subscribes to Arnott’s ‘red-herring’ 33 Arrowsmith (1956), 44–59, at 46. 34 Lee (1980), 34–45, at 34. 35 Ibid. 35. 36 Arnott (1978), 1–24, at 11. 37 Michelini (1987), 232.
‘No longer himself ’
23
theory. She deems the opening scenes ‘a decoy that betrays the audience’s understanding of what they are to expect from a play, even a play by Euripides’.38 ‘We are misled’, she continues, ‘by an elaborate false front or dummy play, from which the real dramatic action emerges startlingly, like a jack from its box.’39 Martin Cropp similarly treats the Wrst part of Herakles as a dummy play. For him the dummy is an Odyssean nostos play which prepares a false climax and, accordingly, magniWes the ‘real’ climax: ‘Heracles . . . is centred, with architectural precision and balance, on the process of ruin, and thus gives equal weight to false expectation and emergent reality. . . . The play’s discrete structure adds impact to the emergence of the ‘‘real truth’’—though it may be felt that it does so at the cost of some banality in the deployment of plot and ethos before the crisis.’40 These ‘red-herring’ theorists are right to search for meaning in the play’s structural dislocation, but they rely too heavily on the unconvincing proposition that Euripides, a skilled dramatist, sacriWced one half of the tragedy in order to heighten the impact of the other half. Euripides often set up ‘false trails’ in his plays, exploiting received myth and familiar dramatic conventions, and luring his audience into precipitate forecasts and erroneous assumptions.41 However, for Euripides to have contrived a counterfeit or throw-away plot of more than 800 lines seems too prolonged and prodigal a theatrical tease, a blase´ and somewhat self-defeating sophistic stunt. His exploitation of the unexpected in Herakles is far more purposeful than playful, and nowhere in his structural design is there an element of the sacriWcial. What, then, is the meaning of the play’s strategic disunity? It is not that the Wrst action is ‘disposable’,42 merely an elaborate deception or an existing false reality by which to intensify an emergent true reality. Rather, as Arrowsmith asserts: ‘The play pivots on two seemingly incompatible realities, and if it insists on the greater reality of what has been created over what has been received, it does so, not by denying reality to receive reality, but by subtly displacing it in the 38 Ibid. 39 Ibid. 232–3. 40 Cropp (1986), 187–99, at 188–9. 41 On Euripides’ clever exploitation of the unexpected, see Arnott (1973), 49–64. See also Raeburn (2000), 149–68. 42 Michelini (1987), 242.
24
‘No longer himself ’
transWguration of its terms.’43 Euripides’ anomalous use of peripeteia is symbolic of Herakles’ loss and subsequent transWguration of self. The structural violence mirrors the fracturing of reason and myth by madness, and underscores the irrationality and injustice of Hera’s revenge. In short, a strategy of disunity is essential to Euripides’ ground-breaking externalization of Herakles’ madness and to his even more ground-breaking humanization of Herakles’ heroism.
EXTERNALIZATION AND HUMANIZATION: THE F I R S T M OV E M E N T ( 1 4 0 – 6 3 6 ) The most conclusive argument against the red-herring theory, and the disposability of the opening scenes, is ‘the fact that an ample portion of this red herring was not caught in the sea of myth, but was of Euripides’ own concoction’.44 The version of the Herakles myth which is presented in the Wrst movement of the play contains two startling and pivotal innovations—the introduction of the usurper Lycus and the placing of the labours before the murder of the children.45 These innovations are proof that the opening scenes have a positive purpose, that they are, in fact, our best guide to interpreting the madness which follows. That purpose is to create a sustained portrait of the hero’s sanity and innocence, and to determine that his tragic fall is the result of an isolated episode of madness, which is, furthermore, externally initiated on an inadequate pretext. For the Wrst 522 lines of the play Herakles ‘is omnipresent as a topic of discussion if not actually in person’.46 By the time he enters, the audience has been able to form a deWnite impression of the hero from Amphitryon’s reply to Lycus’ slanders, from the Wrst stasimon on the twelve labours, and, indeed, from the extreme set of circumstances dominating the play in Herakles’ absence. As Barlow states: 43 Arrowsmith (1956), 44–59, at 50. 44 Lee (1980), 34–45, at 36. 45 On Euripides’ innovative handling of the Herakles myth, see Bond (1981), pp. xxviii–xxx. 46 Hall (2003), pp. vii–xli, at xxiii.
‘No longer himself ’
25
‘The absence of Heracles is not merely the absence of an ordinary man but of an almost superhuman hero of whom miracles in the past have been expected. When he does not appear the despair is therefore that much greater as is the joy when he does.’47 The dependence of oikos and polis on Herakles as a strong, sound, and humane ruler is the keynote of the Wrst movement. In the prologue Amphitryon sets the scene of an imperilled royal household reduced to the indignity of supplication, and a city diseased with civil war ( Ø FÆ, 34). He laments the want, revealed by his son’s prolonged absence, of loyal and able-bodied philoi (55–6), a lament echoed by Megara (84–5) and the chorus (252–74). At 217–26 he scornfully rebukes Thebes and all of Greece for their ingratitude towards their benefactor in failing to help the Heraclidae. The chorus, at 272–4, deplore the sickness of the polis, which has led to the despotic seizure of power by the vicious interloper Lycus: P ªaæ s æE ºØ Ø FÆ ŒÆd ŒÆŒE ıº ÆØ· P ª æ i b KŒÆ. The city is insane, corrupt with civil war and bad counsels. For unless it were insane, it would never have had you as its ruler.
The phrase Ø FÆ repeats Amphitryon’s charge at 34, but the chorus bring an additional and graver charge of insanity against Thebes (P ªaæ s æE).48 At 339 V. Amphitryon turns his bitter reproaches on cuckolding Zeus, declaring: f K b Pa Œæ Ø M ø ºE, IººæØÆ ºŒæÆ Pe ºÆ, fiØ b f f PŒ K ÆÆØ ºı. IÆŁ Ø r Ł; j ŒÆØ PŒ ı. (344–7) You knew how to come secretly into my bed and take someone else’s wife without being invited. Yet you do not know how to save those you love. You are either an ignorant sort of god or else your nature is plain unjust. 47 Barlow (1982), 115–25, at 117. 48 On the interrelated structures of the polis and the psyche, cf. Plato’s Republic 4. 435b.
26
‘No longer himself ’
The cumulative eVect of these despairing complaints is to establish Herakles as the sole potential saviour of oikos and polis,49 the one source of Thebes’ moral and political health, and the only worthy object of faithful supplication in a world of human inconstancy and divine indiVerence. As the agon between Lycus and Amphitryon proves, this image of Herakles is not uncontested. The focus of the agon is Lycus’ allegation that Herakles’ use of the bow is a cowardly alternative to the spear and to the hoplite practice of close-quarter combat (158–64). Like Juno’s prologue to Seneca’s Hercules Furens,50 Lycus’ case against Herakles is, to some extent, automatically undermined by the speaker’s obvious prejudice and bad character, but it cannot be discounted. As Barlow indicates, ‘in its terseness and trenchancy it is a powerful attack on the very heart of the Herakles myth’.51 The charges brought by Lycus are indicative of certain challenges in the Wfth century to traditional heroic values and of the deeply rooted ambivalence of the Herakles myth.52 It is signiWcant, therefore, that Euripides not only raises these diYcult issues, but deals directly with them in Amphitryon’s counter-attack, which is a well-reasoned defence of Herakles’ pragmatic courage: Icæ › º Fº KØ H ‹ ºø ŁæÆ Æ ºª PŒ Ø fiH ÆØ Ł Æ IFÆØ; Æ ø IºŒc · ŒÆd EØ ıÆŁEØ sØ c IªÆŁE ÆPe ŁŒ غfiÆ fiB H ºÆ: ‹Ø b Ø Eæ ıØ h; £ b e ºfiH; ıæı Nf Id ¼ººØ e HÆ Þ ÆØ c ŒÆŁÆE; Œa Ig ºı I ÆØ 49 For the idea of the rightful king as the long-awaited saviour of oikos and polis, cf. the Wgures of Odysseus in the Odyssey and Orestes in Aeschylus’ Choephoroe (esp. ll. 115–16 and 138–9) and in Sophocles’ Electra (esp. ll. 160–4, 303–4, and 455–8). On the important relationship between the aristocratic oikos and the polis, and particularly the idea that a man’s competence as a leader in the public sphere should be a reXection of his role as a good father and a responsible head of an oikos, see Hall (1997), 93–126, at 104–5. 50 See below, Chap. 2. 51 Barlow (1996), 131. 52 On the ambivalence of Herakles in literature, see Silk (1985), 1–22, and in cult, see Burkert (1985), 210.
‘No longer himself ’
27
ıºE ›æHÆ P Æ ÆØ e H P øØ E KÆØ; K Pıº Œfiø K· F K fi e ºØÆ; æHÆ ºı ŒÆŒH fiØ e HÆ; c Œ ‰æØ. (190–203) A spearsman is the slave of his weapons and once his spear, his only defence, is shattered he is not able to keep death from his body, and if those in the ranks are not brave, then he himself dies by the cowardice of those near him. They whose hand can aim the bow well have the one supreme advantage: if he shoots a thousand arrows he still has others to rescue himself from death. Standing at a distance he defends himself by striking at the enemy with arrows unseen to their vision and he does not expose his body to his opponents but is secure. This is the most sensible tactic in battle, to preserve yourself and hurt your enemy without being dependent on chance.
Michelini, undermining somewhat her ‘red-herring’ position, maintains that this passage ‘has been treated as an egregious example of Euripidean inconsequence, but is in fact an important part of the portrait of Herakles as a modern and revisionist hero’.53 This is true in that Herakles is here atypically portrayed as a thinking hero, reliant more on expedient tactics than superior force. But what seems more to the point is that Herakles the bowman is a mortal hero, whose resourcefulness in battle is a demonstration of his ordinary human vulnerability.54 A second reply to Lycus’ invective is the lengthy Wrst stasimon (348–441) which, although it has the appearance of a romantic ecphrasis, is just as radical, in its treatment of the Heraklean labours, as Amphitryon’s vindication of Herakles as bowman. The ode is a threnos (dirge) for the supposedly dead hero, but the tone is eulogistic rather than mournful. Stylistically, and in its celebration of Herakles as monster-slayer and civilizer, it owes much to Pindar.55 Euripides’ chronological innovation of placing the labours before the madness and murders dismantles the image of labouring Herakles as 53 Michelini (1987), 244. 54 Cf. Iliad 18. 117–19: Pb ªaæ Pb „æÆŒºB ª ŒBæÆ; j ‹ æ ºÆ Œ ˜Ød ˚æøØ ¼ÆŒØ· j Iºº Eæ K Æ ŒÆd IæªÆº º „æ. 55 On the ode’s metrical and linguistic borrowings from Pindar, see Bond (1981), 146 V. and Barlow (1996), 139 and 142–3.
28
‘No longer himself ’
penitent and gloriWed drudge, and replaces it with an image of him as righteous and altruistic champion. In the whole of the ode there is no suggestion that Herakles performs the labours under duress and, as Lee observes, ‘no sense of indulgence in violence for its own sake, no aggrandizement of self in a context divorced from the good of one’s family and friends’.56 Splendid physical feats though they may be, the labours are commemorated here as supreme aYrmations of moral excellence (ªÆø IæÆd ø, ‘the virtues of noble actions’, 357). The focus of the ode is threefold: the savagery of the vanquished (364–5, 372–4, 377, 382–6, 391–3, 398, 416–17, 420), Herakles’ piety towards the gods (359–60, 378–9), and his selXess service to humanity (391–3, 400–2, 416–17). Its purpose within the play is to demonstrate that there is no moral connection between the violence of the labours and the domestic violence which follows. As Gregory notes: ‘The scene of Heracles’ return oVers the audience its only glimpse of the hero before he is stricken by madness, its only chance to test the reports of him against the actuality of his presence.’57 Throughout this important scene the emphasis is again on the lack of moral connection between Herakles’ heroic past and his imminent collapse, as well as on the lack of psychological continuity. From the moment he arrives on stage, Herakles appears rational and circumspect. His speech and behaviour betray no sign of mental imbalance. In this respect he stands apart from two other notable Euripidean madmen, the matricide Orestes and the doomed voyeur Pentheus. Orestes’ hallucinatory visions of the Erinyes occur early in the play and are clearly the manifestation of his tormented sunesis or conscience (Orestes 396). Pentheus’ confusion is progressive and his hallucinations intermittent (Bacchae 618 V., 624 V., 918– 20), and, although they are directed by Dionysus, ‘it is no less than the suppressed traits of the subconscious which are laid bare as the god takes possession’.58 Dionysus is simply able to exploit the young king’s perceptible prurience and hypocrisy. In the case of both Orestes and Dionysus the emphasis is on the internal causation and inevitability of the madness. 56 Lee (1986), 23–8, at 26. 58 Barlow (1996), 12.
57 Gregory (1977), 259–75, at 264.
‘No longer himself ’
29
Euripides’ pointed humanization of Herakles in this homecoming scene Xatly contradicts that part of Burnett’s hamartia theory which suggests the hero has pretensions ‘to autonomy, knowledge and grandeur that is exclusive of the gods’.59 Herakles does not assume Olympian airs or boast of his conquest of Hades. All his concern is centred on his family and, far from having any hubristic pretension to autonomy, he stresses the importance of cooperative human values (633–6) and accepts the sound advice of his father (606). Herakles’ exclamation, ÆØæø Ø (‘Goodbye to my labours!’, 575) reveals that he puts the welfare of his family before personal kudos. Even the alleged bloodthirstiness of his vengeful threats against Lycus and the treacherous Thebans (566–73) is a measure of his love for his family and, therefore, not disproportionate to the present situation. The Wnal image we have of Herakles before his Wlicidal madness is of a gentle and loving father. It is an image in stark contrast to the hero of Sophocles’ Trachiniae, who is a superman of profound personal failings. As a radical domestic portrait of an awesome hero, it stands beside the brief, tender homecoming of Hektor in Iliad 6 (466–74): Ł æ Y ŒÆd Æ Zø Œ KÆ, , t ª ÆØ Ø, ººª łıB ºÆb æı ÆFÆØ, ŒÆd ŁŁ KH ºø· P ªaæ æøe Pb ıø ºı. p, ¥ PŒ IØA , Iºº I ÆØ ºø fiH Aºº· z K d ıæF; ¼ø ºÆ ª KºŒÆ æE, ÆF S Kºø· ŒÆd ªaæ PŒ IÆÆØ Łæ ıÆ Œø. (624–33) Take courage and don’t cry any more. And you, my wife, take hold of yourself, stop trembling and [children] let go of my clothes. I have no wings and won’t try to escape from those I love. Why, look, they do not let go but clutch my clothes all the more. Were you so much on a knife-edge?
59 Burnett (1971), 179.
30
‘No longer himself ’
I shall take these children by the hand and draw them after me like a ship with its little boats in tow. I don’t refuse to tend my children.
THE C EN TRAL EPIPHANY (815–73) The most compelling textual and dramaturgical reasons for interpreting Herakles’ madness as a wholly external phenomenon are the unusual central epiphany, which functions as a second prologue, and the even more unusual characterization of Lyssa as a rational and reluctant avenger. Bond notes that ‘Euripides seldom presents a divine epiphany except in his prologues and epilogues, where the gods are used to expound the past and the future in the manner commended by Aristotle’60 (see Poetics 1454b2). What makes the epiphany of Iris and Lyssa so remarkable is its unexpected occurrence midway through the play.61 Moreover, these divinities are not merely detached expositors of past and future events; they actively intervene to invalidate the denouement of the Wrst movement and to drive the action in an entirely new direction. The rare and explosive centrality of their entrance62 is, in formal terms, proof positive that Herakles is not mad at the outset. Critics who adopt the Wilamowitzian ‘seeds of madness’ line miss an obvious and crucial dramatic point: if Euripides had wanted to portray a megalomaniac or epileptic Herakles, he would either have placed the divine epiphany in the prologue to the Wrst half of the play or dispensed with these interventionist Wgures altogether, thereby internalizing the madness and presenting it as the logical culmination of a consistent moral and psychological progres60 Bond (1981), 279. 61 Cf. the midway appearances of Dionysus at Bacchae 604 (after he is heard oVstage at 576) and Athena at Rhesus 595. Neither entry has the explosive force of the Iris–Lyssa epiphany. Dionysus may be a sinister Wgure, but he has been an established central character from the play’s opening, and his reappearance at this point is not greatly shocking, while Athena’s appearance to Odysseus and Diomedes is both benign and undramatic. See Bond (1981), 279 and Barlow (1996), 160. For other instances of deities appearing mid-action, see Barrett ap. Carden (1974), 184 f. 62 Iris and Lyssa appear suddenly on high above the ske¯ne¯ ( bæ ø ›æH, ‘I see such an apparition above the palace’, 817). On the dramatic staging of this epiphany, see Taplin (1977), 445.
‘No longer himself ’
31
sion. By not preparing us for the midway arrival of Iris and Lyssa, Euripides leaves us in no doubt about the illogicality and externality of Herakles’ madness. Furthermore, while he may well have drawn on clinical accounts of epilepsy and other maladies in his description of Herakles’ mad symptoms,63 Euripides himself was a dramatist and, therefore, ultimately concerned with the creation of powerful theatre and not with psychological realism. What follows the physical shock of this unique supernatural intrusion is an exchange that is unparalleled in Greek tragedy. In the Wrst place, neither Iris nor Lyssa appears anywhere else in the extant tragic canon.64 More importantly, these divine delegates, charged by Hera with the task of visiting madness upon Herakles, quarrel heatedly about the justice of their commission.65 As Lee points out, it is signiWcant that Hera herself does not appear and that Euripides presents in her stead two deities of equal rank but Wercely conXicting attitudes.66 Iris, traditionally the messenger of the gods, has here the particularized function of Hera’s faithful and unquestioning agent. She Wrmly identiWes herself with the interests and motives of her mistress (ªfiH b e „æÆ x K ÆPfiH º; j Łfi b e K, ‘he may recognize the nature of Hera’s anger, and 63 On the similarities between Herakles 932–4 and Hippocrates’ De Morbo Sacro 7, see below, Chap. 3. 64 Iris makes a brief appearance in Aristophanes’ Birds (1199 V.), in conversation with Peisthetaerus. The personiWed Lyssa appeared in Aeschylus’ lost play Xantriae (fr. 169; see Lloyd-Jones (1957), ii. 435 V.), driving mad the maenads who destroy Pentheus, and possibly in Toxotides (on the death of Actaeon). An Attic red-Wgured vase of around 440 bc, depicting Aeschylus’ Toxotides, shows Lyssa with a dog’s head protruding from the top of her own head, as she urges Actaeon’s hounds to kill their master: see Trendall and Webster (1971), 62. There are no known vase depictions of Lyssa and Herakles. For a discussion of the iconographic evidence for Lyssa, see Kossatz-Deismann’s article in LIMC (1992), 6.1, 322–9. On the treatment of Lyssa in tragedy, see Duchemin (1967), 130–9 and Padel (1992), 162–3. In Homer’s Iliad º Æ is used of martial rage (e.g. 9. 39), and its cognate epithet ºı of the frantic activity of the hero in battle (13. 53). In tragedy º Æ generally describes a frenzy brought by the gods. It is used, for example, to describe Orestes’ madness in Aeschylus’ Choephoroe (287). 65 Lee (1982), 44–53, at 44 remarks: ‘The only even remote parallel is the discussion between Kratos and Hephaistos in Prometheus where the deities speak and act on ground-level and are found not at a crucial turning-point in the middle of the play, but at its beginning, when the disagreement of the speakers is a curtain-raiser to the more signiWcant discord which pervades the drama.’ 66 Ibid. 46–7.
32
‘No longer himself ’
learn mine’, 840–1), and her part in the proceedings against Herakles is to state Hera’s case and supervise the misbegotten hero’s punishment: e K Iæe ÆÆ æÆ , ‹ ÆØ r ÆØ ˘e `ºŒ ¼ . (825–6) Our advance is on the household of one man who men say is Alcmene’s son by Zeus. j Łd b PÆF, a Ła ÆØ ª ºÆ; c Œ. (841–2) Otherwise the gods are worth nothing and men shall prevail, if Herakles does not pay the penalty.
Lyssa, on the other hand, has a will of her own and, given her nocturnal lineage, lupine etymology,67 and her very nature as the personiWcation of frenzy, she exhibits an astounding capacity for reason and compassion. She expresses unreservedly her loathing for her assignment and, paradoxically, provides the play’s most stalwart defence of Herakles’ innocence: ±cæ ‹ PŒ ¼ h K d Łd h K ŁEØ; y K Ø ı· ¼Æ b æÆ ŒÆd Ł ºÆÆ IªæÆ KæÆ ŁH I Øa Ø Æ Iø IæH o . u P ÆæÆØH ª ºÆ ıºFÆØ ŒÆŒÆ. (849–54) This man whose house you send me to, is not obscure on earth and among the gods. He tames inaccessible land and the wild sea, he alone restored the honours of the gods when they were threatening to fall at the hands of wicked men. So I do not encourage you to plot any great wickedness.
Hera’s reasons for attacking her stepson, as conveyed by Iris, are Herakles’ bastardy and the alleged threat to the gods’ supremacy which his greatness poses. Bond, believing ‘Modern scholars are perhaps over-inXuenced by the liberal attitudes to adultery, bastardy, 67 For º Æ as ‘wolWsh rage’, see Lincoln (1991), 131–7.
‘No longer himself ’
33
and revenge fashionable during the present century’,68 maintains that ‘Hera’s conduct to [Herakles] cannot be termed capricious or irrational’.69 Yet, in the context of the Iris–Lyssa debate, her grounds for attack cannot but seem inadequate and illogical. Iris succeeds only in exposing the nature of Hera’s º (840) as purely vindictive. By contrast, Lyssa’s arguments in support of Herakles are both reasonable and irrefutable, and they are given added authority by the fact that Lyssa is so unexpected an advocate of caution and clemency. It is with almost comic irony that Iris castigates Lyssa for her unnaturally moderate stance and sage counsel: "æ. ¸ı. "æ.
c f ıŁØ Ł „æÆ ŒIa ÆÆÆ. K e ºfiH KØ ø Y Id F ŒÆŒF. Pd øæE ª ł Fæ ˜Øe Ææ. (855–7)
iris. Don’t give advice about Hera’s schemes and mine. lyssa. I want to guide your step towards good, not bad. iris. Zeus’ wife did not send you down here to show moderation.
In the end Hera’s will prevails, and Lyssa sets about her repugnant task vigorously and methodically: r ª · h oø Œ ÆØ ø º æ h ªB Øe ŒæÆıF r æ TEÆ ø x Kªg ØÆ æÆFÆØ æ N ˙æÆŒºı· ŒÆd ŒÆÆææø ºÆŁæÆ ŒÆd ı K ƺH, Œ I ŒÆÆ æH. (861–5) Then I shall run races into Herakles’ heart more forcefully than the ocean groaning with breakers or than earthquake, or than the painful impact of the thunderbolt. I shall shatter his house and bring it down upon him. But Wrst I shall have made him kill his children.
The sharp contrast between Lyssa’s rational plea and frenzied invasion, and between her initial deep reluctance and eventual businesslike destructiveness, makes the ensuing scene all the more disturbing and ethically challenging, as it pinpoints chillingly the injustice of the 68 Bond (1981), p. xxv, n. 28.
69 Ibid., p. xxv.
34
‘No longer himself ’
attack and the external causation of Herakles’ madness. Lyssa begins the transformation of her victim while she is still visible on stage. At 867–70 she anticipates the Messenger’s account of Herakles’ physical symptoms at 932 V., and the immediacy of her words conWrms that the Messenger’s statement at 931, › PŒŁ Æe q, is to be taken absolutely literally: Herakles will experience ‘a terrible intrusion of the alien’.70
THE MADNESS (889–1015) While Euripides purposely does not ‘reason’ or rationalize Herakles’ madness in psychological terms, he does provide a brilliantly inventive and psychologically enthralling exposition of ‘reason in madness’,71 that is, ‘the mad logic of a mad person’.72 The madness of Herakles, which is the playwright’s most concentrated study of the condition, is dramatized, paradoxically, in an extremely wellreasoned and orderly manner. Violence and chaos are choreographed by Lyssa with expert precision; the senseless murders of Megara and the children are recounted within the coherent structure of the Messenger’s speech; and Herakles’ hallucinatory exploits, which appear to the bystanders as crazed and haphazard, are, in his mind, one continuous and logical sequence of events. At 836–7 Iris instructs Lyssa, H ŒØæÆÆ j ºÆı ŒØ (‘set his feet leaping, stir him up’), and at 871 Lyssa, resigned to her task, cries out, Æ Kªg Aºº æ ø ŒÆd ŒÆÆıºø fiø (‘I shall soon make you dance more wildly and I shall play upon you a pipe of terror’). Herakles’ madness is thus to take the form of an ecstatic Dionysian dance, arranged by Lyssa to the accompaniment of the aulos.73 The verbs æ ø and ŒÆÆıºø have a violent transitive 70 Wilson (2000), 427–49, at 438. 71 King Lear, iv. vi. 171. 72 Barlow (1981), 112–28, at 121. 73 On Euripides’ deployment in the mad scenes of ‘imagery’ of destructive Dionysian music, see Wilson (2000), 427–49, at 434 V. For the more general Dionysian terms of reference at the onset of Herakles’ madness, see Schlesier (1993), 89–114, at 98; Zeitlin (1993), 147–82, at 150–1; Seaford (1994), 353–5; and Kraus (1998), 137–56, at 151–6.
‘No longer himself ’
35
force,74 which is diYcult to replicate in English.75 The sinister musical metaphor is reinforced by the deliberate echo at 879, æıŁ KÆ ºØ, following the emphatic juxtaposition of ÆØ Ø º ÆØ at 878. As Lyssa leads Herakles in his wild dance inside the palace, a short lyric dialogue between Amphitryon and the chorus conjures up for the audience the murderous progress of the dance and the hideously discordant strains of Lyssa’s maddening pipe: $.
ŒÆ æÆØ æıÆ ¼æ ı
ø P æı ŒÆæØÆ Ł æfiø. `. Ng Ø. $.
æe Æ¥ Æ ; Pd A ˜ØıØ æ ø K d ÆØ ºØA. < `:> ıªfiB; Œ ; KæA: <$:> Ø Ø º K ÆıºEÆØ. ŒıƪE Œø Øøª· h ¼ŒæÆÆ ØØ ¸ Æ ÆŒ Ø.76 `. ÆNÆE ŒÆŒH. (889–98) chorus. The dance begins but a dance without the accompaniment of drums and one which is not given to the joy of Bromios’ thyrsus. amphitryon [within]. Alas for my home! chorus. A dance for blood and not with the pouring of libations of the grape in honour of Dionysus.
[within]. Escape children, be gone! . The tune being played on the pipe is truly murderous. He is hunting his children down. Not without eVect will Madness run Bacchic riot through the house. amphitryon [within]. Oh, what suVerings!
This passage is rich in Bacchic ritual imagery, but the emphasis is on the perversion of normally peaceful ceremonies: Herakles’ maenadic ecstasis is ominously without the accompaniment of the typana; the celebrant is transported not by the frenzied joy of Dionysus, but 74 Bond (1981), 294 notes that æ ø and ŒÆÆıºø are normally words of good omen, which occur in pleasant contexts. 75 Robert Browning’s translation of 871, which retains this transitive force, is, I believe, the most eVective. See below, Chap. 6. 76 ´ÆŒ ø is literally ‘to keep the feast of Bacchus’. It also has a causal meaning, ‘to inspire with frenzy’, and thus recalls 871 and 879. Cf. the transitive verb K Œı at 966.
36
‘No longer himself ’
by the lethal energy of Lyssa racing into his heart; in place of the usual Dionysian libations (ºØA), he performs a human sphagiasmos (sacriWce); and the festive aulos is played as an instrument of death. The role of the chorus in this oV-stage Bacchic revelry is, as Wilson observes, one of acoustic mimesis: ‘For the killings inside the house have taken place in the space ‘‘Wlled’’ by their choral song—one bacchic khoreia overlaying another, the metaphoric and the performative interlacing and merging.’77 Of the essential paradox of carefully choreographed chaos operative in this scene and, more broadly, in the tragic representation of madness, Padel says: ‘Dance images of madness express a central paradox, of unseen disorderly inner movement, articulated and ordered within a composed, choreographed performance. Madness is a non-dancelike ek [sic]: expressed through a genre that is itself a very highly wrought, rehearsed dance.’78 A similar paradox is operative in the Messenger’s speech (922– 1015),79 which is a model of lucid and systematic reportage. Every stage of the madness, from its Wrst physical symptoms through to its violent climax and abrupt ending, is plotted retrospectively and by an impartial witness, yet at the same time vividly and compellingly. In this long description of Herakles’ loss of self and its tragic consequences, no detail of action or reaction has been omitted. The Messenger graphically re-creates the atmosphere in the palace at the moment of Herakles’ deranged descent. At 950–2 the servants’ uneasy, ambivalent response to their master’s aberrant behaviour is captured imaginatively and with acute psychological insight: Ø ºF O ÆE q ªºø Ł ›F, ŒÆ Ø r ; ¼ºº N ¼ºº æÆŒ· —ÆØ æe A j ÆÆØ; AVected with a double emotion the servants began to laugh and tremble both at once. They looked at one another and one of them said, ‘Is our master playing a joke on us or is he mad?’
The inclusion of reported speech, especially the urgent, uncomprehending pleas of Herakles’ family (965–7, 975–6, 988–9), contributes 77 Wilson (2000), 427–49, at 437. 78 Padel (1995), 139. 79 This is the third-longest messenger speech in the Euripidean corpus.
‘No longer himself ’
37
to the immediacy of the narration, while the snatches of Herakles’ delusional conversations (936–46, 982–3) are indicative of his insane logic. The speech as a whole is a psychological and theatrical tour de force, requiring an actor of exceptional versatility and control. Another psychological tour de force, detailing reason in madness, is Herakles’ hallucination, which is a sustained sequence of characteristic Heraklean feats grimly contextualized. Burnett states that Euripides ‘has been careful to give the hallucination a ghastly kinship with reality, and so the will of the sane Heracles seems always present, even as he commits his insane crime’.80 She believes the imagined Mycenean murders are able to distract and dazzle Herakles ‘because they are attractive to him’.81 Certainly the illusions of journeying, feasting, and wrestling, and the very real killings, serve to parody Herakles’ heroic career (cf. the ironic use of Herakles’ traditional epithet, ŒÆººØŒ, at 961). But, contrary to Burnett, I believe the poet has been careful to distinguish the will of the sane Herakles from his insane crimes. This distinction has been recognized by Hartigan, who says: ‘His madness is beyond his control, yet it acts through his virtue—his strength—to achieve his ruin.’82 In other words, the madness is ‘externally caused but internally activated’.83 Herakles does not act independently of Lyssa; she exploits his heroic identity and legitimate bia (force), forcing him to conduct an I º
º (‘a war that was no war’, 1133)84 against ‘wholly irrelevant and innocent victims’.85 There is nothing in Euripides’ portrait of the sane hero to suggest that killing is attractive to him or that his normal use of violence is excessive, which is why I dispute Barlow’s suggestion that Euripides is ‘asking whether there is not a very Wne line between murdering one’s enemies and murdering one’s own friends’.86 This question has been foregrounded in recent adaptations 80 Burnett (1971), 171. 81 Ibid. 170. 82 Hartigan (1987), 126–35, at 128. 83 Ibid. 129. 84 Herakles fought a non-war against children and philoi. On this oxymoron, see Bond (1981), 354. 85 Furley (1986), 102–13, at 102. 86 Barlow (1982), 115–25, at 123. Cf. Chalk (1962), 7–18, at 16–17: ‘The essential diVerence between Lykos and Herakles—their motives for action—the killing of the children does not cancel; but it does reveal what actions good and bad alike have in common—violence. . . . With Herakles himself Euripides is careful not to compromise our impression of his goodness by saying deWnitely that he would kill his children when sane; but he hints through the minor characters and through the veil of
38
‘No longer himself ’
of the play, but there is little in the original text to substantiate a negative reading of Herakles’ sane violence or, indeed, the discovery of a causal link between his past and present murders.87 Like the Bacchic dance and the Messenger’s speech, the hallucination involves a paradox: Herakles’ actions are, in themselves, reasonable, but they have been arbitrarily misplaced in an insane context.
T H E AWA K E N I N G A N D R E H A BI L I TAT I O N OF HERAKLES (1089–428) The Wnal episode of Herakles has two focal points: the hero’s anagno¯risis and his rehabilitation. At 1002–6 the Messenger reports that Herakles’ murderous rampage was halted by Athena’s sudden intervention: Iºº qºŁ NŒ; ‰ ›æA KÆ —ƺºa; ŒæÆÆı ª y K d ºø ŒÆæ y, Œ¼ææØł æ æ N ˙æÆŒºı, ‹ Ø ı ÆæªH ; ŒI o 88 ŒÆŁBŒ. madness disturbingly enough to evoke an awareness that all Æ partakes of the irrational element here embodied in the extreme form of madness.’ 87 At 966–7 Amphitryon asks his son, h ı K Œı ŒæH j R ¼æØ ŒÆØ; (‘Surely the blood of those you have just been killing has not made you mad?’). Wilamowitz seized on these lines as proof of Herakles’ intuitive bloodlust and as a means of rationalizing his insane murders (see below, Chap. 7). However, these are the only lines in the play which draw a connection between the murder of Lycus and the murder of Herakles’ children, and the possibility of such a connection has already been unambiguously cancelled by the remarkable central epiphany. Fitzgerald (1991), 85–95, at 91–2, speaks absurdly of the ‘apparent’ resort to an outside agency to eVect Herakles’ catastrophe and of a direct link between the slaughter of Lycus and the slaughter of Herakles’ children: ‘if Heracles’ values had been other than they have been he may not have found himself in this situation. Certainly if his ‘‘morality’’ had not been one that recommended the blind vengeance, that so deWnes his ‘‘heroic’’ identity, he may, or would, not have been able to do what he did. . . . The ‘‘madness scene’’ expresses what is innate in [his] former self.’ This view completely ignores Herakles’ consistent portrayal as IºŒÆŒ (averter of evil) and thus his dissociation from the ‘amoral vindictiveness’ of Lycus. 88 On Euripides’ ironic use of the familiar idea of ‘sleep after toil’, and Herakles’ o PŒ PÆÆ (‘unhappy sleep’, 1013), see Willink (1988), 86–97.
‘No longer himself ’
39
But there appeared a phantom, or so it seemed to our eyes, Pallas, brandishing her spear. y y . She hurled a stone at Herakles’ breast which checked his murderous rage and reduced him to sleep.
From his enforced palliative sleep Herakles awakes a bound and broken Wgure, remembering nothing of his mad deeds, but aware that his mind has been aVected in some terrible way: ‰ < > Œº øØ ŒÆd æH Ææ ªÆØ
øŒÆ ØfiH. (1091–2) I was swamped somehow by a terrible confusion of mind.
Finding ropes around his chest and arms, his weapons scattered on the ground, and corpses beside him, Herakles experiences an acute and unfamiliar IÆÆ (helplessness, 1105) and ªØÆ (perplexity, 1107). He is conscious of the incongruity between the normal living landscape of sky, earth, and sun (1090) and the ghastly vision of death before him, but he can identify no trace of the infamous inhabitants of Hades (1103–4) to conWrm his return to the infernal regions. He is now in a solitary terrestrial hell. It is Amphitryon who gradually and compassionately guides Herakles out of his dusgnoia and towards his anguished anagno¯risis. The powerful stichomythia between father and son at 1112–45 is the prototype of the corresponding stichomythia at Bacchae 1264–1301 between Cadmus and Agave. In the later scene the father slowly forces his daughter to cast oV her maenadic fury and to recognize that the fresh quarry she is triumphantly brandishing is the head of her son Pentheus. Devereux has termed the exchange between Cadmus and Agave a ‘psychotherapy scene’, which is ‘the natural consequence of the basic outlook of a poet who had already dramatised a clinically Xawless ‘‘supportive therapy’’ scene (Eur. HF 1089 V.)’.89 He compares Cadmus as psychotherapist, and the ‘tactfully gradual manner in which he leads Agave, step by step, back to a painful but inescapable reality’,90 to Amphitryon, whose psychotherapeutic method, at 1119–21, is to ascertain the stability of Herakles’ mind before compelling him towards the grievous knowledge of his crimes. 89 Devereux (1970), 35–48, at 37.
90 Ibid. 41.
40
‘No longer himself ’
DeWning Agave’s progression towards such knowledge, Devereux says, ‘the doer, having recovered her sense of identity, must be made to recognise also her deed’.91 In Herakles’ case, the doer, having recognized the deed (1132), must be made to recognize also his identity as its unwitting perpetrator. For Amphitryon, in the role of psychotherapist, the most painful duty is to redirect his son’s horror and vengeful anger away from a presumed enemy and onto Herakles himself (1133–9). Much has been written on the question of whether, in these postmadness scenes, Herakles’ old heroism is rehabilitated or whether he progresses to a fundamentally new type of heroism. Where one stands on this question depends on how one interprets Herakles’ rejection of suicide, his decision to retain the weapons with which he killed his loved ones, and his acceptance of Theseus’ philia. Chalk, who discerns an intimate connection between philia and arete¯, believes Herakles recovers a new, complex arete¯ of which friendly dependence and submission to fate are positive and active ingredients. Another ingredient, he contends, is Herakles’ old bia (symbolized by his bow and arrows), which is now tempered by his new ‘understanding, induced by suVering, of the hateful implications of action’.92 Directly refuting Chalk’s thesis, which he insists is based on anachronistic ethical standards, Adkins can detect no new arete¯ in the play’s Wnal scenes and, indeed, no arete¯ at all. Philia, he declares, is, according to Wfth-century thinking, incompatible with arete¯; the only desirable condition for the agathos is one of autarkeia: There is nothing whatever in the use of غÆ; º, غE, and Iæ to suggest for a moment that Iæ, whose basic usage is in commending those very qualities in a man which ensure his independence, self-suYciency, and ability to protect his dependants, can be manifested by receiving beneWts from a º. If we look at this play in terms of our values, we may see these transactions [between Herakles and Theseus] in a quite diVerent light; but we are concerned with the values of Euripides and his audience, and in this case with those of the Greeks between Homer and Aristotle generally. . . . Had Euripides wished to redeWne Iæ so radically as to render the IªÆŁ one who received (deserved) beneWts rather than conferring them, he would have had to do so explicitly and at length in order to make comprehensible 91 Devereux (1970), 35–48, at 43.
92 Chalk (1962), 7–18, at 14.
‘No longer himself ’
41
to the audience a view unparalleled in Greek literature up to and including Aristotle. Since he does not do so, we may conclude that, in portraying Hercules as receiving beneWts from Theseus, he was not portraying Hercules as manifesting any Iæ, traditional or new.93
But the incompatibility of philia and arete¯ is here maintained too arbitrarily, and Euripides’ radical agenda too summarily dismissed. The fact is that, already in the play’s Wrst and supposedly traditional half, the poet has redeWned arete¯ in such a way as to stress its relationship to philia, redeWning in the process the true agathos as a true philos. In his pre-madness scenes, when he has unquestionably the status of agathos and is possessed of unassailable arete¯, Herakles is never shown to be entirely self-suYcient or to advocate self-suYciency as a virtue. On the contrary, he espouses the importance of cooperative values and is seen to prize philia more highly than the glory of his labours. Moreover, the philia that is intrinsic to his arete¯ is not about conferring or receiving beneWts but is, rather, the spontaneous expression of unconditional love. The same may be said of Herakles’ expression of philia in his post-madness scenes, particularly at 1265 ( ÆæÆ ªaæ Id ˘e ªFÆØ Kª, ‘I consider you as my father, not Zeus’) and 1401 ( Æø æŁd ÆE ‹ ø ø K, ‘Now that I have lost my sons, I count you as my son’). ‘Both these sentiments’, Barlow suggests, are ‘concerned with spontaneous attitudes and not necessarily deeds.’94 Lee Wnds that Herakles’ crucial decision to endure life (KªŒÆæø , 1351) is not made for positive reasons, that the beneWts of Theseus’ friendship ‘are largely material and do not impinge on the substance of Heracles’ fate’.95 Like Adkins, he overlooks the radicalism of Euripidean philia. Theseus oVers Herakles a home in Athens, puriWcation, wealth, and posthumous honours (1322–33), but the philia he represents cannot be reduced to a matter of material beneWts and reciprocity. What deWnes Theseus as philos is his genuine and unqualiWed love for Herakles, encapsulated in his moving and repeated dismissal of the notion of infectious pollution: 93 Adkins (1966), 193–219, at 216–17. 94 Barlow (1981), 112–28, at 119. The verbs ªFÆØ and ø imply a mental state or attitude. 95 Lee (1980), 34–45, at 42.
42
‘No longer himself ’ Ø æø EæÆ ÆØ ; ‰ c H ºfi æŁª ø; Pb ºØ Ø ª d æ Ø ŒÆŒH: (1218–20)
Why move your hand to warn me that you have a fear? Are you afraid that your greetings might pollute me? I don’t care if I share your suVering. ¨. ÆFÆØ· ı b Eæ æfi ºfiø: ˙æ: Iºº ÆxÆ c E KæøÆØ ºØ: ¨: ŒÆ; ı · PŒ IÆÆØ: (1398–1400) Theseus. Enough. Give your hand to a friend who wants to help you. Herakles. Be careful that the blood of my pollution does not wipe oV on your clothes. Theseus. Wipe away! As much as you like! I do not reject it.
Theseus’ love and loyalty make him a surrogate son to Herakles and thus impinge signiWcantly on the substance of Herakles’ fate. Lee also denies that Herakles progresses to a new type of heroism. He takes particular issue with Arrowsmith’s ‘conversion of reality’ theory,96 stating that, by keeping his weapons, ‘the hero, far from rejecting the old world of his labours, very deliberately clings to it’.97 Yet, Herakles’ decision to retain his weapons is not a reversion to an old arete¯, but a transWguration or deepening of what has already been established as an atypical arete¯. The bow and arrows may be symbolic of the Heraklean labours, but, as Amphitryon’s defence of the bow at 190–203 demonstrated, they are also the symbols of a modern and very human hero. Herakles’ decision at 1377–83 to keep his weapons is the key passage in his rehabilitative process: ºıªæÆd b H ‹ ºø ŒØøÆØ: IÆH ªaæ æ ø j ŁH, L ºıæa Ia æ KæE · ˙E Œ x º ŒÆd ÆæŁ · A Ø 96 See Arrowsmith (1956), 44–59, at 50. 97 Lee (1980), 34–45, at 43. Cf. Fitzgerald (1991), 85–95, at 94: ‘The eventual resumption of his armour suggests the possibility of the resumption eventually of his former ‘‘self ’’.’ This inference is based on Fitzgerald’s glaring misconstruction of Herakles’ ‘old’ morality as deWcient and blameworthy.
‘No longer himself ’
43
ÆØŒı : r Kªg TºÆØ Yø; Œø; Iººa ªıøŁd ‹ ºø f x a Œ ººØ K æÆ K ¯ºº Ø KŁæE KÆıe ƺg ÆNæH Ł ø; P ºØ ; IŁºø b ø. How painfully sweet it is to kiss them and how painful it is too to think of the companionship of my weapons. I do not know whether to keep them or to let them go. They will say as they brush against my side ‘It was with our help you murdered your wife and children. In wearing us you wear the killers of your sons.’ Am I to carry them about? What am I to say? Yet strip me of the very weapons with which I did the most glorious exploits in Greece and shall I not then die in submission at my enemies’ hands? I cannot leave them behind, I must keep them, painful though it is.
The bow and arrows no longer symbolize the hero’s past labours; apart from serving the practical purpose of self-defence, they will symbolize a mature and complex arete¯ based on suVering and moral strength.98 Their companionship will be a constant reminder to Herakles of a deed which has rendered his previous life almost meaningless. Far from clinging to the old world of his labours, Herakles is confronting a brave new world of inWnitely greater labours. Critics who have argued for and against Herakles’ advancement to a new type of heroism have generally had one thing in common—a slightly simplistic reading of the nature of Herakles’ arete¯ in the play’s Wrst half. Arrowsmith sees in the play ‘a conversion of heroism whose model is Heracles, and the heart of that conversion lies in the hero’s passage in suVering from the outworn courage of outward physical strength to a new internal courage, without exemption now but with the addition of love and perseverance against an intolerable necessity’.99 Herakles’ ‘old’ heroism was certainly less complex, and by the end of the play his arete¯ has acquired a greater internal dimension. 98 Dunn (1996), 123 believes Herakles keeps his weapons ‘for a purely negative purpose, for self-defense’, which he insists ‘does little to deWne a hero and does not deWne in a positive or constructive manner either old-fashioned, heroic virtues or new, humanistic ones’. He therefore ignores both the context in which ll. 1382–4 are spoken, especially the idea of ºıªæÆd ŒØøÆØ (1377), and the positive symbolic signiWcance surrounding the weapons’ future practical employment. 99 Arrowsmith (1956), 44–59, at 53.
44
‘No longer himself ’
However, Arrowsmith overemphasizes the novelty of this dimension. He describes the Herakles of the Wrst action as ‘the familiar culturehero of Dorian and Boeotian tradition: strong, courageous, noble, self-suYcient’,100 but, as we have seen, even before his tragic fall Herakles is portrayed as an atypical and technologically sophisticated hero, who preaches the value of philia rather than self-suYciency.101 The conversion of heroism which occurs is not, therefore, a break with Herakles’ former self, but a development or maturation of that self.102 Barlow’s thesis is the nearest to this conclusion. ‘What changes’, she says, ‘is not [Herakles’] innate areteˆ but his perspective. . . . The play is partly about the transition from one order of experience to another.’103 The turning-point, which enables this transition, is Herakles’ rejection of suicide, his movement away from a physically heroic response towards a spiritually heroic response: KªŒÆæø (1351). These words constitute, in Barlow’s estimation, ‘a calculated and positive decision’,104 and are demonstrative of an arete¯ that, because of its progressiveness, is being held in pointed contrast to the arete¯ of Sophocles’ suicidal Ajax.105 Herakles’ rehabilitation entails neither the annulment of an old arete¯ nor the acquisition of a completely new arete¯. It is the full, agonizing realization of an already enlightened form of heroic existence. The truly novel element in Herakles’ post-madness arete¯ is found in his deWnitive renunciation of the anthropomorphic gods 100 Arrowsmith (1956) 44–59, at 49. 101 Interestingly, Athenian male citizens swore their oaths of intra-household philia by Herakles. In fact, the male-only Herakles cult at Athens centred on philiarelationships in sub-military manifestations. 102 Foley (1985), 150 believes that at the end of the play the hero is ritually tamed for the new civic order of Athens. We realize, she says, that it is only Athens and Athenian tragedy which ‘can rescue Herakles from the ‘‘death’’ and anachronism with which he is threatened in the earlier scenes and create an untraditional spritualized hero equal to the mutability of life and valuable for the Athenian polis’. Foley makes the important point that the traditional Herakles is an ambivalent or liminal Wgure in need of some kind of recuperation for the modern democratic audience. However, Euripides begins this recuperative process earlier than Foley and others maintain, purging Herakles of much of his traditional ambivalence. 103 Barlow (1981), 112–28, at 117. 104 Ibid. 112. 105 On Herakles’ rejection of suicide, see James (1969), 10–20, Yoshitake (1994), 135–53, and Romilly (2003), 285–94. Like Barlow, Romilly construes Herakles as an anti-Ajax and argues that Euripides is presenting a new doctrine on suicide.
‘No longer himself ’
45
(1341–6), and his own divinity (1265),106 and his substitution of a transcendent humanism. The hero is eVectively ‘demythologised’.107 He protests against divine amoral indiVerence and proclaims the irrelevancy of the gods to the life stretching before him, in which only human endurance and human philia matter. The true radicalism of Herakles’ demythologized arete¯ and his new humanist philosophy is best summed up by Ehrenberg: The disharmony of a world in which a blind fate destroys good and great men must be resolved into the harmony of human greatness and unselWsh love between human beings. Euripides denies the right of mere individualism,108 but he equally denies superhuman guidance and ordering. Man must rely on himself and his fellow-men to build his world, proudly and courageously defying the blows of fate. In a new sense Protagoras’ sentence becomes true: Man is the measure of all things. . . . The Euripidean man Wnally triumphs over the Wercest onslaught of fate. . . . It is a new generation and a new epoch in the history of the human mind, an epoch in which human reason outgrows and overcomes, for a time at least, the faith in superhuman forces and in the dark secrets of death and after-death. When Herakles rejects suicide, he acts as a true creation of Euripides and of the age of Enlightenment.109
Euripides’ Herakles is a play of strange beauty and brutality. As a piece of theatre, it is immensely powerful and disturbing. It remains, I believe, to this day the most radical and innovative treatment of the madness of Herakles. When Seneca took Euripides’ plot as the basis of his Hercules Furens in the mid-Wrst century ad, he began a process of reasoning the madness and psychologizing the hero which transformed the story’s Euripidean essence. Since then, with one or two notable exceptions, translations or adaptations of Euripides’ text have never quite matched its revolutionary externalization of the madness and humanization of the hero. But before the Hercules Furens is examined in detail, it is worth noting the reception of Herakles Mainomenos in antiquity outside of Euripides and Seneca. 106 See Silk (1985), 1–22, esp. 12 V. 107 Barlow (1996), 141. 108 Cf. Burnett’s notion (1971), 180 that Herakles’ humanist stance is based on autarkeia and not philia: ‘The play does . . . in the end work a kind of restoration for humanity, showing a form of self-salvation in which the chastened Heracles is suYcient unto himself.’ 109 Ehrenberg (1946), 163–5.
46
‘No longer himself ’
A number of sources from the Hellenistic period indicate the presence of mad Herakles in art, literature, and theatre. A poem of 125 lines, entitled ‘Megara’ and thought to belong to Theocritus (c.300–260 bc), gives a picture of Herakles’ wife and mother Alkmene at home in Tiryns while he is abroad undertaking his labours. Megara laments the mad murder of her children at their father’s hand, recalling vividly her frantic helplessness to save them: f b Kªg KE Y OŁÆºEØ Æººı e Ææ; e P ZÆæ XºıŁ ¼ººfiø: P Ø ı IØe ŒÆºıØ IæBÆØ æ ; K d Kªªf IŒ ŒÆŒe q. ‰ ZæØ æÆØ K d æØØ E OººıØ; o ÆNe ZØ Ø Ø Æ Ł Ø K ıŒØEØ ŒÆŁØ· m b ŒÆ ÆPf
øAÆØ Œº ıÆ ºÆ ºØªf ØÆ æ, P ¼æ Ø ŒØØ K ÆæŒÆØ· q ª æ ƒ ÆPfiB p Y ªÆ æ IغŒØ ºæı· S Kªg ÆNŒØÆ º ª ÆN ıÆ ÆØØØ Ø Œ Æ ººe Kø. (17–28) Wretched I saw with my own eyes my children felled by their father’s hand, and that no other has even dreamt of. And although they called out loudly, their mother was powerless to help them, since the evil was near and unconquerable. But just as a bird wails at her young ones perishing, whom a dread serpent devours as they play like children in the thick shrubs, and she, raving mother, Xies above them screeching piercingly, but then is unable to protect her children, for she is greatly afraid to go nearer the unsoothed monster; so I, unhappy mother, bewailing my beloved oVspring, many times roamed wildly throughout the house with frenzied feet.
Of the thirty-eight plays attributed to Rhinthon of Syracuse (c.323–285 bc), the inventor of hilarotragodia (burlesques of tragic subjects, later known as fabulae Rhintonicae), nine titles are known, but very meagre fragments (in Doric) survive. Almost all are burlesques of Euripidean tragedies and among them is Herakles. Euripides’ play itself was still being performed, as we know from the Tegea inscription (SIG3 1080), which records the victories of a Greek champion boxer (sometimes identiWed as Apollogenes) who
‘No longer himself ’
47
was also a tragic actor:110 ‘At the Great Dionysia at Athens in Euripides’ Orestes. At the Delphic Soteria in the Herakles of Euripides111 and the Antaios of Archestratos. At the Alexandrian Ptolemaia in men’s boxing. At the Heraia in Euripides’ Herakles, and Euripides’ Archelaos. At the Naia at Dodona in Euripides’ Archelaos and Chairemon’s Achilles.’112 The madness of Herakles is the subject of a red-Wgured calyxkrater from Paestum (350–325 bc), excavated in 1864 (Fig. 1). The vase, which is signed by the artist Asteas, depicts a scene of indoor mayhem: Herakles, the central Wgure, has broken up the furniture, from which he has constructed a bonWre, and is about to dash one of his children on the ground or hurl the child into the Xames, while a distracted Megara tries to Xee through a door to the right. Watching the scene from a loggia above are, from left to right, Mania (holding a whip), Herakles’ nephew Iolaos, and Alkmene.113 Only here is the instigator of Herakles’ madness identiWed as Mania rather than Lyssa, which, together with the presence of Iolaos and Alkmene, would strongly suggest that the vase represents not Euripides’ play but rather a play inXuenced by Euripides.114 The accounts of Herakles’ madness by three late Hellenistic writers also suggest a tradition independent of Euripides. Apollodorus of Athens (b. c.180 bc), Nicolaus of Damascus (b. c.64 bc), and Diodorus Siculus (who wrote c.60–30 bc) each place the madness before the labours.115 Apollodorus, in his Bibliotheca, a study of Greek heroic mythology, records that Herakles threw his own three sons and two children of Iphicles into a Wre: %a b c æe %Ø Æ ı ÆıfiH ŒÆa Bº „æÆ ÆBÆØ; ŒÆd Nı ÆEÆ; R KŒ %ª æÆ r ; N Fæ KƺE ŒÆd H
110 See Sifakis (1967), 84. 111 On this boxer’s physical suitability for the role of Herakles, see Falkner (2002), 342–61, at 360, n. 61. 112 Translated in Csapo and Slater (1995), 200. 113 Cf. the scene represented here to the description by Philostratus (c.ad 160–245) of what is purportedly a painting in a Neapolitan collection depicting Herakles’ mad murder and burning of his children (Imagines 2.23). 114 See Taplin (2007), no. 45. 115 Cf. the Euripidean chronology of the account given by Hyginus (Fabulae 31–2) around the 2nd century ad.
48
‘No longer himself ’
Fig. 1. Asteas, The Madness of Herakles, Paestan rf. calyx-krater (350–325 bc). Museo del Prado. "ØŒºı · Øe ŒÆÆØŒ Æ ÆıF ıªc ŒÆŁÆæÆØ b e ¨ ı;
ÆæÆª b N ˜ºf ıŁ ÆØ F ŁF F ŒÆØŒØ. (2. 4. 12) And after the battle against the Minyans it came to pass that he was driven mad through the jealousy of Hera and threw his own children, whom he had by Megara, and two children of Iphicles into the Wre; wherefore, having passed sentence of banishment upon himself, he was puriWed by Thespius, and having come to Delphi, he enquired of the god inwhat part of the world he should dwell.
‘No longer himself ’
49
Both he and Nicolaus (F.Gr.Hist. 90 F 13) provide unembellished narratives which imply, rather than state, that the labours were atonement for the murders. Diodorus, however, includes a psychological explanation for the madness—Herakles’ depressed state of mind on learning from the Delphic oracle that he must perform the labours at Eurystheus’ command: ø b æÆŁø › b ˙æÆŒºB K N IŁıÆ P c ıFÆ· ªaæ fiH Æ Øæfiø ıº Ø PÆH ¼Ø ŒæØ B NÆ IæB; fiH ˜Ød ŒÆd Ææd c ŁŁÆØ ŒÆd I æ KÆ ŒÆd I Æ: N
ººc s IÆÆ K ÆPF; „æÆ b ł ÆPfiH º Æ· › b fiB łıfiB ıæH N ÆÆ K . (Bibliotheca 4. 11. 1) At this turn of events Herakles fell into no ordinary despondency; for he judged that to be a slave to an inferior was in no way worthy of his own valour, and yet it seemed inexpedient and impossible not to obey Zeus, who was also his father. While he was thus greatly at a loss, Hera sent a frenzy upon him; and in his vexation of soul he fell into a madness.
Evidence for the madness of Herakles in Roman art and literature before Seneca is much scarcer. There does not seem to have been a Republican tragedy on the subject. Of the twenty known titles by Ennius (b. 239 bc), twelve are Euripidean, but the Herakles is not among them. Hercules did, however, feature in at least two, and possibly three, plays by Accius (b. 170 bc), who was acclaimed in Seneca’s day the greatest of all Roman tragedians. The single fragment of Accius’ Alcestis is from the Messenger’s account of Hercules’ rescue of Alcestis from Hades.116 Hercules has a speaking part in Phinidae, appearing probably to restore the blinded sons of Phineus to health and give them their father’s throne.117 Accius wrote a Philoctetes, but it is not known whether Hercules featured at the end of this version as a deus ex machina. There is also an unassigned Accian fragment which is possibly from a passage telling how Philoctetes witnessed the burning of Hercules on Mount Oeta.118 Hercules speaks the single fragment of Hesiona,119 one of the six known tragic titles attributed to Naevius, and is likely to be the eponymous hero of an anonymous tragedy which included the
116 See Warmington (1961), ii. 332. 118 Ibid. 569. 119 Ibid. 118.
117 Ibid. 520–2.
50
‘No longer himself ’
character of Poeas.120 Despite this fragmentary and inconclusive literary evidence, there is iconographic evidence to suggest that Hercules was considered at Rome the quintessential tragic hero. The tragic muse Melpomene was often portrayed at Rome with Herculean accoutrements, including unmistakably Hercules’ famous club. During the Empire mad Hercules (although probably not the Euripidean-Senecan hero) was a favourite role for both the amateur and professional thespian. A Wrst-century epigram dedicated to the tragic actor Apollophanes lists chief among his props Hercules’ club (Palatine Anthology 11. 169). Suetonius records Nero’s preference for performing publicly the part of mad Hercules (Nero 21. 3), a peculiarity he shared with other emperors.121 Like Nero, the pioneering pantomimus Pylades, who developed a high-Xown, passionate style of balletic interpretation of tragic drama, could carry his impersonation of mad Hercules to dangerous extremes (Macrobius, Saturnalia 2. 7. 16–17). In the dialogue Nigrinus, Lucian (b. c.ad 120) criticizes those actors who
ºº ŒØ j `ªÆ j ˚æ j ŒÆd ˙æÆŒºı ÆPF æø Iغ, æıÆ MØØ ŒÆd Øe º ŒÆd ªÆ Œ ØŒæe ŁªªÆØ ŒÆd Ne ŒÆd ªıÆØŒH ŒÆd B ¯Œ j —ºı
ºf Æ Øæ. (11) often when they have assumed the mask of Agamemnon or Creon or even Herakles himself, clothed in cloth of gold, looking Werce and gaping wide, speak in a voice that is small, thin, and eVeminate, and much too poor for Hecuba or Polyxena.
As can be seen, evidence for the ancient transmission of the Herakles Mainomenos story in antiquity, exclusive of Euripides and Seneca, is widely scattered and does not ultimately contribute to a coherent or conclusive understanding of how other ancients reasoned the madness or redeWned Herakles’ heroism in the light of his mad deeds. What it does indicate is that, in spite of the survival of alternate traditions, it is Euripides’ version of the story that has had the greatest impact on the future reception of Herakles Mainomenos, determining the essential themes which all subsequent adaptations have addressed. 120 See Warmington (1961), ii. 610.
121 See below, Chap. 2.
2 ‘Let the monster be mine’: Seneca and the internalization of imperial furor The only other extant ancient play to feature the madness of Herakles is that attributed to the Roman philosopher Lucius Annaeus Seneca, the Younger (c.4 bc–ad 65), and entitled Hercules Furens. Seneca was attracted in his youth by ascetic philosophy, becoming a vegetarian and a disciple of Pythagorean teaching. However, his father’s counsel, allied to his own considerable literary and political ambition, guided him away from the enclosed life of an ethereal scholar and eventually towards the worldly situation of amicus Principis and senator consularis. Seneca’s dual career as the leading man of letters and most inXuential statesman of his day spanned almost the entire JulioClaudian dynasty, and positioned him fatally at the very heart of an implacable imperial machine. Although now he is probably better known for his moral and philosophical treatises, a group of ten tragedies has been assigned by tradition to Senecan authorship. Of the ten, one (Octavia) is certainly not by Seneca, and another (Hercules Oetaeus) is of dubious authenticity. The text of the tragedies is preserved in two principal groups of manuscripts. E (Codex Etruscus or Laurentianus), written in the late eleventh century and housed in the Laurentian Library in Florence, lacks Octavia and gives the other plays in the following order: Hercules (¼HF), Troades, Phoenissae, Medea, Phaedra, Oedipus, Agamemnon, Thyestes, Hercules (¼HO). A, the ancestor of the vulgate tradition, gives the order and titles as: Hercules Furens, Thyestes, Thebais (¼Phoen.), Hippolytus, Oedipus, Troas, Medea,
52
‘Let the monster be mine’
Agamemnon, Octavia, Hercules Oetaeus.1 Whatever their literary liabilities and assets, and quite apart from their phenomenal and extremely well-documented impact on Renaissance drama, Seneca’s plays have an inherent historical value: ‘They stand, with the exception of a few fragments, as the sole surviving representatives of an extensive Roman product in the tragic drama. They therefore serve as the only connecting link between ancient and modern tragedy.’2 Nor, as Edith Hall insists, does the eternal question of the plays’ ‘performability’, and the unlikelihood of full-blown theatrical productions, detract from their status in performance history: ‘Texts which are declaimed are also ‘‘performed’’; texts which are widely read inform subsequent adaptations of the story they relate. Whatever form of public exposure Senecan tragedy Wrst received, it was only the Wrst step in a process intended to lead to their consumption by a widely dispersed readership.’3 The importance of Seneca’s tragedies to subsequent reception lies not in their performability or otherwise but in their Romanization and politicization of familiar Greek antecedents. The values, sensibilities, and imagery which pervade Senecan drama, and the characters the playwright dissects, belong manifestly to imperial Rome. Moreover, Seneca’s tragic Weltanschauung, the moral and political frame of reference characteristic of his plays, extends far beyond the physically circumscribed world of the Greek polis to encompass the State and the Cosmos.
THE PSYCHOLOGY OF ABSOLUT E POWER Hercules Furens is a particularly instructive example of Seneca’s Romanization of Greek myth. Although certain stage directions, and the fact that the madness is enacted on stage, probably denote the inXuence of an intermediary Hercules-drama or dramas,4 the essentials of the story are derived ultimately from Euripides’ Herakles. The hero 1 For detailed studies of the MS tradition see esp. Zwierlein (1983), 7–181; Tarrant (1985), 23–87; Fitch (1987), 53–7; and Billerbeck (1999), 39–89. 2 Miller (1917), p. ix. 3 Hall (2005), 53–75, at 64. 4 See Fitch (1987), 45–7.
‘Let the monster be mine’
53
returns from his twelfth labour, his triumph over the Underworld, to discover Thebes in the hands of the tyrannical Lycus and his family under sentence of death. He kills the usurper and is immediately driven mad by his malevolent stepmother Juno. In his madness he murders his wife and children, whom he has just rescued. On learning of his crime, once sanity is restored, he resolves to commit suicide, but is persuaded against this course of action and taken by Theseus to Athens where he will receive puriWcation. But while Seneca’s primary source is obvious, the play is, above all, a product of its time and of its author’s personal experience and agenda. Along with the rest of the Senecan tragic corpus, Hercules Furens is distinctly post-classical in structure and style, not least in its conspicuous rhetoricity. The declamatory speeches, lengthy ecphrases, and the dominant style of shock and hyperbole, which the modern reader might reasonably consider tedious fustian, were, in fact, characteristic of a generic tendency among Silver Latin poets and, more importantly, as Boyle asserts, part of the wider contemporary idiom: Seneca’s astonishing fusion of spectacle, bombast, paradox, epigram, brevity, plenitude, abstraction, grandeur, violence, disjunction, allusion, sensuousness is no arbitrarily chosen mode; it is product of a baroque, post-classical sensibility and grounded in the semiotic forms of contemporary Roman life. It is index of an age: the age of fourth-style Roman painting, the baroque in Roman architecture and sculpture, the ‘pointed’, declamatory style in poetry. It was a spectacular, histrionic age. It was a world of grandiose, almost strident aesthetics.5
Scattered throughout the text of Hercules Furens are also signiWcant echoes of the Augustan writers, and important aspects of the characterization of Juno and Hercules can be traced to the VirgilianOvidian tradition. Seneca’s most radical development of, or divergence from, his Attic model is his reasoning of the madness of Hercules, his introduction of the idea of psychological causation. Whereas Euripides’ meticulous staging of the madness emphasizes at every phase the externality and gratuitousness of the hero’s aZiction, Seneca internalizes the furor and 5 Boyle (1997), 18–19.
54
‘Let the monster be mine’
consistently represents it as the inevitable outcome of an extreme modus vitae and an ingenium unbalanced by megalomania and obsession.6 This internalization has a historical and didactic basis, and is a creative consequence of what Braden identiWes as Seneca’s ‘interest in a certain kind of achievement psychology’,7 the psychology of real and unlimited power. In ways not dissimilar to Virgil’s Aeneid, Hercules Furens is a critique of the ambivalent achievement of Empire. Virgil’s ambivalence towards imperial achievement in general, and the ideological basis of the Augustan principate in particular, becomes most apparent in Book 12 of the Aeneid. Witness Aeneas’ pius furor8 throughout; the double simile, at 521–8, which links the murderous exploits of Aeneas and Turnus; and, above all, Aeneas’ ultimately vengeful killing of Turnus which reveals the unsettling disjunction between pietas and humanitas.9 Seneca likewise exposes the private or human cost of a public life dedicated to conquest and acquisition, as well as the hazardously Wne frontier separating greatness from excess. 6 The locus classicus for Roman internalization of madness, in contrast to Greek externalization, is Cicero’s rationalization in Pro Roscio Amerino (24. 66–7) of the Erinyes as the ıØ, the tormented conscience, of the matricide Orestes: ‘magnam vim, magnam necessitatem, magnam possidet religionem paternus maternusque sanguis; ex quo si qua macula concepta est, non modo elui non potest verum usque eo permanat ad animum ut summus furor atque amentia consequatur. Nolite enim putare, quem ad modum in fabulis saepenumero videtis, eos, qui aliquid impie scelerateque commiserunt, agitari et perterreri Furiarum taedis ardentibus. Sua quemque fraus et suus terror maxime vexat, suum quemque scelus agitat amentiaque adWcit, suae malae cogitationes conscientiaeque animi terrent; hae sunt impiis adsiduae domesticaeque Furiae quae dies noctesque parentium poenas a consceleratissimis Wliis repetant.’ (‘The blood of a father and mother has great power, great compulsion, great sanctity; if any stain has been received from this, not only can it not be washed away, but in fact it penetrates all the way to the heart, so that extreme frenzy and madness follow. For do not think, as you oftentimes see in plays, that those who have perpetrated some wicked and impious deed are disturbed and terriWed by the Wery torches of the Furies. His own crime and his own dread plagues each one above all else; his own wicked deed disquiets each one and madness attacks; his own evil imaginings and the remorse of his heart terrify him. For the wicked these are the unremitting and internal Furies, which, night and day, demand expiation for parents from most depraved sons.’) 7 Braden (1970), 5–41, at 13. 8 See Mackie (1982), 190. 9 On the controversial ending of the Aeneid, and its moral and political implications, see esp. Johnson (1965), 359–64; Burnell (1987), 186–200; Stahl (1990), 174–211; and Galinsky (1994), 191–201.
‘Let the monster be mine’
55
He exploits the ambivalence of the mythical Hercules (ŁE Iæ; monster-slayer and Wlicide; altruistic civilizer and hubristic overreacher) in creating an imperial Roman tragic hero of enormous but divided potential. His Hercules is princeps and imperator, an exemplar of virtus and pietas, but also a victim of warring adfectus and ungovernable ira, an ira that culminates in murderous furor. As a product of the imperial system, and both a witness to and a participant in its intrigues, cruelties, and corruption, Seneca was well placed to examine closely the ambivalence and the underlying mania of imperial achievement. Indeed, in his own character and conduct he reXected the moral paradox of Empire. His extravagant sybaritic lifestyle gravely compromised the Stoic precepts he taught; the naked pragmatism of his dealings as a wealthy usurer10 and political sophisticate sat oddly with the idealized virtues fundamental to his philosophy. Seneca recognized these and more egregious contradictions in the individual rulers at whose command he proWted and suVered. He knew from Wrst-hand experience the menacing caprice to which men of absolute power, with a commensurate capacity for good or evil, were prone. Born in the second half of the Augustan principate, he reached maturity in the bloody reign of Tiberius, narrowly escaped execution after arousing the jealous suspicions of Caligula, and was exiled to Corsica by Claudius through the machinations of the empress Messalina. He was recalled to Rome in 49 at the behest of Agrippina, Claudius’ new consort, and entrusted with the education of her son Domitius (Nero). On Nero’s accession in 54 he exchanged the role of tutor for that of chief minister, and maintained a seemingly unassailable position of inXuence until his fall from grace in 62. In 65 he was compelled by his former prote´ge´ to commit suicide for his alleged complicity in the failed Pisonian conspiracy. His painfully protracted death, memorably recorded by Tacitus (Ann. 15. 63–4), was a prototype of Stoic courage and composure, redeeming in some measure a life of ignoble contradictions. Boyle has commented: ‘The declamatory themes of the schools—vengeance, rage, power-lust, incest, hideous death, fortune’s savagery—were the stuV of [Seneca’s] life. His literary response was twofold: the consolatory discourse of Stoic moral philosophy, reXected in his prose 10 See Tacitus, Annales 13. 42.
56
‘Let the monster be mine’
works, and the tragedies, which articulate a world quite diVerent from that of the dialogues and epistles.’11 Where, then, in the chronology of Seneca’s turbulent career does Hercules Furens occur, and to what set of circumstances is it a response? Reliable evidence for the absolute dating of Seneca’s tragedies is scarce,12 but for the Hercules Furens we do at least have a terminus ante quem of late 54, established by the fact that the play is parodied in sections 7 and 12 of Seneca’s Apocolocyntosis Divi Claudii (The GourdiWcation of the Divine Claudius),13 a ribald Menippean satire on the emperor’s apotheosis, which almost certainly belongs to November or December of 54.14 In this short work, Claudius arrives in heaven and Jupiter instructs his henchman, the deiWed Hercules, who has travelled the whole world over and encountered all possible monsters, to Wnd out the stranger’s nationality. The Hercules of the Apocolocyntosis is the familiar comic buVoon and braggart but, in order to make himself terrifying to Claudius, he temporarily assumes, in Menippean fashion, the exalted guise of a tragic actor (‘tragicus Wt’). Accordingly, he conducts his interrogation of Claudius in tragic iambics: exprome propere, sede qua genitus cluas, hoc ne peremptus stipite ad terram accidas; haec clava reges saepe mactavit feros. Quid nunc profatu vocis incerto sonas? Quae patria, quae gens mobile eduxit caput? Edissere. Equidem regna tergemini petens longinqua regis, unde ab Hesperio mari Inachiam ad urbem nobile advexi pecus, vidi duobus imminens Xuviis iugum, quod Phoebus ortu semper obverso videt, ubi Rhodanus ingens amne praerapido Xuit, Ararque dubitans, quo suos cursus agat, tacitus quietis adluit ripas vadis. Estne illa tellus spritus altrix tui? (Apoc. 7) 11 Boyle (1997), 32. 12 Fitch (1981), 289–307 has attempted to establish a relative order of composition from Seneca’s use of sense-pauses. 13 See Fitch (1987), 50–3. 14 See GriYn (1976), 129, n. 3.
‘Let the monster be mine’
57
State quickly, what country hail’st thou from, lest slain by this bough thou fall’st to earth; this club hath often slaughtered savage kings. Why mumble now thy words in tones unclear? What land, what race bore that shaking head? Speak out. Verily, when seeking the far-oV realms of the triple king, whence I brought the noble herd from the Western sea to the city of Inachus, I beheld a mountain crest looking down upon two rivers, which the Sun regards right opposite each day he doth arise, where mighty Rhone with rapid torrent Xows, and the Saone, in doubt where it should run, noiselessly washes against the banks with silent shallows. Is this the land that nursed thy soul?
This bravura piece of mock-tragic verse recalls in subject matter and phraseology speciWc lines in Hercules Furens (e.g. 1296, 662 V., 762, 711–16, 680, 1108, 1127–30). Such reminiscences underline the contrast in Apocolocyntosis between the Xorid tragic register, which the mock-heroic Hercules employs, and the ludicrous situation in which he delivers his speech: Hercules is not confronting a fearsome monster but the doddery and inWrm Claudius. Seneca’s burlesque of his tragic Hercules (cf. mentis suae non est, ‘he is out of his mind’, Apoc. 7) suggests not only the priority of Hercules Furens over Apocolocyntosis, but also the chronological proximity of the two works. As Fitch observes: ‘The ease with which Seneca adapts phrases from Hercules Furens suggests that the tragedy was fresh in his mind and had either been written, or at any rate presented in a recitatio, within a year or two of 54.’15 The probability, therefore, is that the play was written at a period when the character and actions of Nero were ‘the obsessive center of [Seneca’s] life’.16 A further tenable inference is that Seneca conceived it partly as a seasonable and salutary warning to the adolescent imperial heir about the importance of moderate government and self-restraint. In form and subject the lesson was well suited to his pupil’s histrionic tastes. Nero’s fondness for performing in public is legendary, and Suetonius tells us that ‘Mad Hercules’17 was a favourite piece in the emperor’s tragic repertoire: 15 Fitch (1987), 53. 16 Stambler (1986), 35–8, at 38. 17 Fitch (1987), 49, n. 70 indicates: ‘One cannot tell whether the role of mad Hercules enacted by Nero came from a tragedy, nor whether it predated Sen. HF. Certainly it was not the role created by Seneca, as it required Hercules to be bound with chains.’
58
‘Let the monster be mine’
Inter cetera cantavit Canacen parturientem, Oresten matricidam, Oedipodem excaecatum, Herculem insanum. In qua fabula fama est tirunculum militem positum ad custodiam aditus, cum eum ornari ac vinciri catenis, sicut argumentum postulabat, videret, accurrisse ferendae opis gratia. (Nero 21. 3)18 Among other parts he sang Canace in Labour, Orestes the Matricide, Oedipus Blinded, and Mad Hercules. In which drama [Mad Hercules] they say that a young recruit, posted to guard the entrance, when he saw him Wtted out and bound with chains, as the theme required, hastened forth to render assistance.
Nero’s identiWcation with Hercules did not end there. He had coins minted inscribed with the legend ‘Herculi Augusto’, and sought comparison with the hero’s superhuman strength by artfully staging battles in imitation of the labours: Destinaverat etiam, quia Apollinem cantu, Solem aurigando aequiperare existimaretur, imitari et Herculis facta; praeparatumque leonem aiunt, quem vel clava vel brachiorum nexibus in amphitheatri harena spectante populo nudus elideret. (ibid. 53) Because he was reckoned to rival Apollo in singing and the Sun in chariotdriving, he had likewise determined to emulate the achievements of Hercules; and they say that a lion had been prepared, which he could crush naked in the arena of the amphitheatre, with the people looking on, either with a club or by the clasping of his arms.
Herculean impersonation was an idiosyncrasy shared by other Roman emperors and featured by historians as a metaphor for megalomania and tyrannical excess.19 Dio reports that Caligula (ad 37–41) impersonated Hercules (and other deities) as a means of demanding that he be worshipped on earth as a god and of giving himself a pretext for his Olympian proXigacy: ŒÆd H b læøÆ H b Łe ÆPe Iƌƺ ø, ØH Kæ: Mı b ªaæ ŒÆd ææ bæ ¼Łæø ŁÆØ, ŒÆd fiB &ºfi ıªªªŁÆØ ŒÆd e B ˝Œ ÆFŁÆØ ºª, ˘ r ÆØ 18 See also Dio 63. 9. 4. 19 Herculean impersonation is not peculiar to Rome’s imperial rulers. As Blanshard points out in his biography of Hercules (2005, p.xvii), throughout history ‘there has been no end of candidates willing to cast themselves as the ‘‘new Hercules’’ ’. Historical claimants to Hercules’ lion-skin include Alexander the Great, Charlemagne, Cardinal Richelieu, Napoleon, and Mussolini.
‘Let the monster be mine’
59
K º , ŒÆd ŒÆa F ŒÆd ªıÆØd ¼ººÆØ ººÆE ŒÆd ÆE IºÆE ºØÆ ıEÆØ æÆÆ, ŒÆd —ØH ÆsŁØ, ‹Ø F ŁÆº æ ı, ˙æÆŒºÆ ˜Øı ` ººø ¼ººı, P ‹Ø f ¼ææÆ Iººa ŒÆd a ŁºÆ, Œæ. (Roman History 59. 26. 5–6) And when some called him a demigod and others a god, he fairly lost his head. Indeed, even before this he had been demanding that he be regarded as more than a human being, and was wont to claim that he had intercourse with the Moon, that Victory put a crown upon him, and to pretend that he was Jupiter, and he made this a pretext for seducing numerous women, particularly his sisters; again, he would pose as Neptune, because he had bridged so great an expanse of sea; he also impersonated Hercules, Bacchus, Apollo, and all the other divinities, not merely males but also females.
The emperor would go to exceptional lengths to achieve accuracy in the various parts he assumed: b b ªaæ ŁºıæØ øæA ŒÆd ŒæÆBæÆ ŒÆd Ł æ r, b b Iææø , ŒÆd Þ Æº ŒÆd ºB j ŒÆd Œæ I Æ KæØ (‘Now he would be seen as a woman, holding a wine-bowl and thyrsus, and again he would appear as a man equipped with a club and lion’s skin or perhaps a helmet and shield’, ibid. 7). This image of Caligula alternating between bacchantic and Herculean personae, with appropriate paraphernalia, recalls the Euripidean Herakles whose madness Lyssa choreographs as a maenadic dance. The emperor Commodus (ad 180–92), son of Marcus Aurelius, regarded himself as the very incarnation of Hercules, adding the title of ‘Roman Hercules’ to his extraordinary nomenclature (the Emperor Caesar Lucius Aelius Aurelius Commodus Augustus Pius Felix Sarmaticus Germanicus Maximus Britannicus, PaciWer of the Whole Earth, Invincible, the Roman Hercules, Pontifex Maximus, Holder of the Tribunician Authority for the eighteenth time, Imperator for the eighth time, Consul for the seventh time, Father of his Country), which Dio accounts an unmistakable symptom of superlative madness (73. 15. 4). Vast numbers of statues were erected representing Commodus in the garb of Hercules,20 and it was voted that his age 20 Mussolini’s attempts at Herculean self-representation likewise extended to statuary. Among his grandiose architectural plans for Rome was a great new forum to be dominated by a colossal bronze statue of Hercules, its features those of Mussolini himself and its hand raised in a fascist salute. However, according to Scobie
60
‘Let the monster be mine’
should be designated the ‘Golden Age’ (Dio refers to the emperor derisively as y › æıF, y › ˙æÆŒºB, y › Ł, ‘this golden one, this Hercules, this god’, 73. 16. 1). Like Nero, Commodus is alleged to have re-enacted Herculean labours in the amphitheatre. According to Dio, the spurious contests he fought involved actual violence and were engineered expressly to indulge the emperor’s perverted brand of savagery: K Øc ºª ØBºŁ ‹Ø FÆ ØÆ KŁºØ u æ › ˙æÆŒºB a &ıƺÆ: ŒÆd K Ø Ł ª y › ºª, K Ø
Æ f H
H K fiB ºØ e ı j ŒÆd æÆ Øe ıæA Kæı IŁæÆ æÆŒø ØÆ ÆPE Y æd a ªÆÆ æØ º, ŒÆd ªªı Id ºŁø ººØ f I ŒØ Æ Þ
ºfiø Æø ‰ ªªÆÆ. (73. 20. 2–3) A report spread abroad that he would want to shoot a few of the spectators in imitation of Hercules and the Stymphalian birds. And this story was believed, too, because he had once got together all the men in the city who had lost their feet as the result of disease or some accident, and then, after fastening about their knees some likenesses of serpents’ bodies, and giving them sponges to throw instead of stones, had killed them with blows of a club, pretending that they were giants.
These examples of Herculean impersonation and self-mythiWcation are illustrative of Braden’s deWnition of imperial derangement as ‘in great part the derangement of the classical competitive ethos with nowhere to go—having survived, in a sense, its own culmination. Furor is heroic anger diVused uncontrollably when the honoriWc borders it had once maintained become elusive and unreal. . . . Seneca depicts his hero’s madness precisely as a momentum of unstoppable competitiveness under the spell of his own name.’21 Two passages in particular support the theory that Hercules Furens is intended, on one level, to correct certain tendencies in the young Nero that Seneca knew might easily lead to manifold abuses of power and to the hubristic appropriation of godhead and divine (1990, 2): ‘When the bronze for a foot had been poured, the project for the statue was abandoned. Hercules was too expensive.’ Mussolini also commissioned sixty Herculean statues for his Stadio dei Marmi, an arena built outside Rome for the 1944 Olympic Games, postponed by World War II. Made of white marble, these 12-foot statues stood atop 6-foot pedestals surrounding the stadium. See Mott (2003). 21 Braden (1985), 14–15.
‘Let the monster be mine’
61
prerogative. The Wrst is Juno’s criticism, at 39–40, that Hercules’ indomita virtus colitur et toto deus j narratur orbe (‘his indomitable valour is revered, and throughout the whole world he is storied as a god’). Although the verb colo may simply denote honour or reverence, Juno seems to imply that Hercules is not only fabled as a god but also worshipped as one. When Hercules appears, he gives substance to this implication by arrogating to himself a position equivalent to Jupiter’s as an object of prayerful devotion, as though he has already been deiWed. The second passage is contained in Theseus’ lengthy description of the Underworld (662–827),22 and concerns the post-mortem judgement of domini and duces: quod quisque fecit, patitur; auctorem scelus repetit, suoque premitur exemplo nocens. vidi cruentos carcere includi duces et impotentis terga plebeia manu scindi tyranni. quisquis est placide potens dominusque vitae servat innocuas manus et incruentum mitis imperium regit animaeque parcit, longa permensus diu vivacis aevi spatia vel caelum petit vel laeta felix nemoris Elysii loca, iudex futurus. sanguine humano abstine quicumque regnas: scelera taxantur modo maiore vestra. (735–47)23 22 T. S. Eliot (1951, 69) ridiculed this narrative as an absurdly long and untimely digression: ‘While Hercules is . . . engaged in a duel on the result of which everybody’s life depends, the family sit down calmly and listen to a long description by Theseus of the Tartarean regions.’ However, others have seen the infernal horrors recounted as a metaphor for the irrational. Galinsky (1972), 172 believes Theseus’ description is ‘the unparalleled centre piece of the tragedy’, its purpose ‘to reXect Herakles’ state of mind’. Similarly, Mueller (1980), 24–5 asserts: ‘This mythical world, described in the gloomiest colours of Senecan rhetoric, is plainly a metaphor for the destructive psychic reality that the spectator is about to witness.’ 23 Hercules himself brieXy echoes this message after the slaying of Lycus: ‘victima haud ulla amplior j potest magisque opima mactari Iovi, j quam rex iniquus’ (‘No victim more choice or bounteous could be slaughtered to Jove than an unrighteous king’, 922–4). John Milton translated HF 922–4 in his pamphlet The Tenure of Kings and Magistrates, published in 1649 following the execution of King Charles, which Milton defended: ‘There can be slain j No sacriWce to God more acceptable j Than an unjust and wicked king.’ On Milton and regicide, see Boehrer (1992), 132–7.
62
‘Let the monster be mine’
What each man did, he suVers: the crime recoils on its perpetrator, and the criminal is plagued by the precedent he set. I saw bloodstained leaders immured in prison, and a ruthless tyrant’s back Xayed by the hands of the plebs. But anyone who governs mildly, who keeps his hands guiltless as master of life and death, who conducts a gentle, bloodless reign and spares lives—he measures the long sweep of a life full of years, and then reaches either heaven or the happy setting of the blessed Elysian grove, to serve as judge. Avoid shedding human blood, all you who reign: your crimes are assessed with heavier penalties.
Seneca’s exclusive focus on sinful rulers is a remarkably un-Euripidean and un-Virgilian treatment of the traditional theme of infernal punishments, and, as Fitch asserts, ‘is clearly inXuenced by the political experience of his age’.24 Lines 739–45, which advocate bloodless and temperate sovereignty, anticipate Seneca’s advice to Nero in De Clementia, written in December 55/6 when the emperor could still be swayed by his old tutor and, as a consequence, Rome enjoyed a brief period of stability and sober administration.25 Boyle remarks of this passage: ‘It is as if the character has stepped out of the play and is haranguing the audience (or certain members in it). Seneca could not be less opaque.’26 ‘Hercules,’ declares Stambler, ‘of all Seneca’s great characters, shows the closest aYnities to Nero’s potential for good and for evil: cruelty moving into actual violent madness, and then succeeded by acts of gentle, sweet consideration. Is this Seneca’s portrait of Nero? Or his hope that Nero might be thus transformed?’27 Certainly, Hercules’ dual nature and divided potential have distinctly Neronian overtones. Nero perilously combined youth, vicious ancestry, instinctive depravity, singular energy, and consuming vanity, and his tutor was keenly aware of how the added circumstance of absolute power would augment and intensify the danger. Stambler’s questions, however, solicit too simplistic a response to Senecan Hercules. A determinedly allegorical reading of the character, which seeks speciWc correspondences with Nero, is both hazardous and unproWtable. Hercules Furens is not so much a portrait of Nero as a portrait of power, one that elicits its elements of design from the world of late 24 Fitch (1987), 311. 26 Boyle (1997), 109.
25 See esp. De Clementia 1. 7. 1–3 and 1. 11. 2–3. 27 Stambler (1986), 35–8, at 38.
‘Let the monster be mine’
63
Julio-Claudian politics and morality. And, like so much of Senecan tragedy, it ‘follows a cultural given to its incredible and cataclysmic conclusion’.28
JUNO’S PROLOGUE (1–124) AND HERCULES’ ENTRANCE (592–639) Any reading of the madness of Seneca’s Hercules is largely and unavoidably contingent upon our interpretation of Juno’s prologue and Hercules’ behaviour on his Wrst entrance. Analysts of these vital preparatory scenes have tended towards diametrically opposed conclusions. On one side are the many who believe Hercules to be an impious and hubristic villain, the demented instrument of his own destruction. Their dissenters, inferior in number, discern in Seneca’s hero a Stoic sage, a godly human of exemplary pietas and virtus, and a sane mind persecuted by an insanely hostile goddess. Among the former group the most extreme position is that of Henry and Walker, who claim: ‘At no point in the play does Hercules reveal heroic or impressive qualities of character; he does not reveal even real strength.’29 Although they see Juno ‘in the same absurd light as her adversary’,30 Henry and Walker note that, in the prologue, ‘there is no intention on the part of the dramatist to arouse sympathy for Hercules. He is merely a doer, lacking all discrimination and earning merely contempt.’31 Bishop construes Juno’s prologue as an ‘adequate report’ of Hercules’ ‘punishable status’, of ‘an oVence committed and proved’,32 and he portrays Juno herself as a legitimate avenger of the violated ordo mundi: ‘In Act I Juno plainly tells us that Hercules’ type of life is tragically outrageous. . . . His physical capacity and accomplishments and his psychological readiness are dangerous. That is, the kind of man Hercules is, coupled with the kind of deeds he does produces a violence of action which Juno abhors because it is contrary to the ordo mundi, regardless of the results and intentions of the doer.’33 In her exposition of the prologue, Shelton goes so far as to 28 Braden (1970), 13. 29 Henry and Walker (1965), 11–22, at 18. 30 Ibid. 31 Ibid. 17. 32 See Bishop (1966), 216–24, at 216–17. 33 Ibid. 221–22.
64
‘Let the monster be mine’
remove altogether Juno’s agential function and to redesignate the goddess as ‘a vivid dramatization of the disorder in the human mind’.34 According to this construction, Juno’s words describe accurately, and in real time, Hercules’ self-activated descent into madness: ‘Rather than examining the problems of man in an irrational universe, as Euripides had done, Seneca examines the problems of the irrational man. Hercules, not the gods, is responsible for his own disaster, because emotional excess (ambitious pride) has gained dominance over the rational element in his soul.’35 Common to these negative interpretations of Hercules’ ‘sane’ behaviour is an understanding of Seneca’s internalization of the furor, which is communicated in terms of either a tragic Xaw (hamartia) or a pre-existing psychological disorder. However, this understanding is founded substantially on a readiness to accept at face value Juno’s denunciatory allegations. The Wrst critics to counter this lopsided reading of the prologue were Motto and Clark, who argued: ‘[Hercules] is, as usual, persecuted by Juno—and persecuted by her for what he is, not for what he does. It is the function of Juno’s prologue to the play to make their relationship patently obvious prior to the events of the play. Hence this deiWc and triumphant Herculean story in the Hercules Furens is nothing less (and nothing other) than the story of deliberately oppressed and maligned greatness.’36 They further insist that Hercules cannot be considered impious or hubristic since he is more than mortal and ‘one among a number of contending gods; he is not simply to be judged as a man’.37 Having dismissed the notion of hamartia, they attack the suggestion that Hercules is irrational from the play’s outset and spurred by megalomaniac aspirations: ‘At no time when he is sane does he suggest that he will invade the skies or scale the heavens to seize the reins of power. On the contrary, this is Juno’s furious premonition and delirious vision (64), which is later echoed by the maddened Hercules infected by Juno’s own disease (957–73).’38 Lawall continued and expanded on Motto and Clark’s thesis when he complained that the ‘ ‘‘naturalistic’’ interpretation of Hercules’ madness may appeal to twentieth-century psychological 34 Shelton (1978), 23. 35 Ibid. 13–14. 36 Motto and Clark (1981), 101–17, at 111. 37 Ibid. 110. 38 Ibid. 111.
‘Let the monster be mine’
65
critics, but it fails to account for the literary tradition behind the Wgure of Juno in Seneca’s play’.39 As he correctly demonstrates, ‘Juno’s opening words place her Wrmly in the Vergilian-Ovidian tradition’.40 She appears as the vengeful wife unseated from her celestial throne by a succession of paelices, and as the relentless enemy of Jupiter’s illegitimate oVspring. Motto, Clark, and Lawall introduce a necessary caveat about Juno’s odium and ira, but their concomitant description of Hercules as the mentally sound and blameless victim of an Olympian vendetta is Xawed on two counts. First, and rather glaringly, it is actually a description of the Euripidean Herakles and ignores, therefore, Seneca’s very diVerent conception and staging of the madness. Secondly, it fails to consider the Augustan literary tradition behind the characterization of Hercules in the prologue and in the moments following his return. The polarity of critical opinion on Hercules’ temperament and normal state of mind belies both the real complexity of the character and the essential fact that in Seneca’s world there is no palpable distinction between good and evil, heroes and villains, for, as Braden perceives, ‘the mental mechanism is the same’: ‘The dramatic point is not that good people think this way and bad ones think that way, but that everyone in sight is thinking in much the same way, and there is this result. Hence Hercules can perform as both hero and villain without changing his personality.’41 More recently, Fitch and Boyle42 have recognized that what is stressed throughout the play, and particularly in the prologue and Hercules’ Wrst scene, is the hero’s ambivalence and the ease with which his celebrated strength may be unreasonably and criminally misdirected. Juno begins her prologue by identifying herself as ‘Soror Tonantis’ (‘Sister of the Thunder God’, 1), a bitter variation of the familiar formula ‘soror et coniunx’.43 She then scornfully lists the constellations which have shamelessly immortalized Jupiter’s various amorous intrigues (6–18). Her grievances are brought up to date with her allusion to Alcmena’s son (23), the target of her undying enmity: 39 Lawall (1983), 6–26, at 6. 40 Ibid. 41 Braden (1970), 5–41, at 14, n. 3. 42 See Fitch (1987), 15–24 and Boyle (1997), 106–7. 43 Cf. Virgil, Aen. 1. 46 f. (‘regina, Iovisque j et soror et coniunx’) and Ovid, Met. 3. 265 f. (‘si sum regina, Iovisque j et soror et coniunx, certe soror’).
66
‘Let the monster be mine’ non sic abibunt odia; vivaces aget violentus iras animus, et saevus dolor aeterna bella pace sublata geret. (27–9)
Even so, my hatred will not just evaporate. My mind will aggressively pursue undying anger, and my Werce resentment will abolish peace and wage eternal warfare.
Juno’s catalogue of constellations (cf. Ovid’s treatment of the Callisto story in Met. 2.409 V.) and her pledge of eternal warfare (cf. Virgil, Aen. 1.8–11, 25–8, and 46–8) form a clear index of the literary context in which the veracity and objectivity of her subsequent accusations against Hercules are to be measured.44 The VirgilianOvidian Juno, whom Seneca conjures up in these opening lines, is the humiliated spouse and rebel warrior whose cherished novercal odium and perseverance in anger are pathological. She is not motivated by righteous concern for the ordo mundi but by a fanatical sense of personal injury. The grandiosity of Senecan Juno’s arraignment of Hercules (30–88) conforms to her Virgilian-Ovidian persona. She addresses her stepson as ‘superbe’ (89), and represents his katabasis and abduction of Cerberus, which she ordered, as the aggressive and sacrilegious expression of overweening ambition: nec satis terrae patent:45 eVregit ecce limen inferni Iovis et opima victi regis ad superos refert. vidi ipsa, vidi nocte discussa inferum et Dite domito spolia iactantem patri fraterna. cur non vinctum et oppressum trahit ipsum catenis paria sortitum Iovi Ereboque capto potitur et retegit Styga? parum est reverti, foedus umbrarum perıˆt, patefacta ab imis manibus retro via est et sacra dirae Mortis in aperto iacent. (46–56) Even the earth is not room enough. See, he has broken through the gates of nether Jove, and brings spoils of triumph over that conquered king back to 44 See Lawall (1983), 6–26, at 6–8. 45 Ironically, Hercules echoes this phrase at 605–6: ‘non satis terrae patent j Iunonis odio’ (‘For Juno’s hatred the earth is not broad enough’).
‘Let the monster be mine’
67
the upper world. With my own eyes I watched him, after he had shattered the gloom of the Underworld and subdued Dis, as he showed oV to his father spoils won from that father’s brother. Why not drag oV Dis himself, bound and loaded with chains—the god who drew a lot equal to Jove’s? Why not rule over captured Erebus, and unroof the Stygian world? It is not enough to return: the terms governing the shades have been breached, a way back to earth has been opened from the deep Underworld, and the sanctities of dread death lie in plain view.
Warming to her subject, she accuses Hercules of planning to commit a still more Xagrant oVence (‘magna meditantem’, 75)—an invasion of the heavens and seizure of his father’s sceptre: caelo timendum est, regna ne summa occupet qui vicit ima—sceptra praeripiet patri. nec in astra lenta veniet ut Bacchus via; iter ruina quaeret et vacuo volet regnare mundo. robore experto tumet, et posse caelum viribus vinci suis didicit ferendo; subdidit mundo caput nec Xexit umeros molis immensae labor meliusque collo sedit Herculeo polus. immota cervix sidera et caelum tulit et me prementem. quaerit ad superos viam. (64–74) It is heaven we must fear for—that after conquering the lowest realm he may seize the highest. He will usurp his father’s sceptre! And he will not reach the stars by a gradual approach, like Bacchus: he will forge a path by destruction, and he will want to rule in an empty sky. Swollen with conWdence in his welltested might, he has learnt through bearing the heavens that his strength can conquer them. When he bent his head to support the sky, the toil of that immense weight did not bow his shoulders; no, the Wrmament rested more securely on Hercules’ neck. Without budging, his back supported the stars and heavens—and my pressure. Yes, he is seeking a path to the gods.
Shelton contends that these lines chart ‘the progressive stages in the development of Hercules’ pride, ambition and madness’, and provide ‘an explanation of a psychological development’.46 This contention takes for granted Juno’s status as a prescient and objective observer. It 46 Shelton (1978), 21.
68
‘Let the monster be mine’
also relies on an erroneous interpretation of the signiWcance of the shift in tense from ‘quaeret’ (67) to ‘quaerit’ (74): Juno describes a sequence of events and thoughts in Hercules’ mind, and, as she speaks, the point of time moves forward rapidly. First she fears that Hercules, Wlled with conWdence about his strength, may challenge Heaven (iter ruina quaeret, 67) and seize power from Jupiter (sceptra praeripiens patri, 65). Next she states that he is actually challenging Heaven (quaerit ad superos viam, 74). Juno’s words reXect the change in Hercules’ own attitude. The shift in tense from quaeret (future) to quaerit (present) . . . signiWes that dramatic time has advanced in this scene, from Hercules’ return from the Underworld to his insane attack on Heaven.47
‘Quaerit’ does not signify an actual development, either temporal or attitudinal. Rather, it is a generalizing present, and represents, at this stage at least, an unwarranted inference on the part of hostile Juno, based on Hercules’ deeds of prowess (‘robore experto’, 68). The sole progression, which the shift in tense does chart, is that taking place in Juno’s own mind: ‘What begins as a fear (timendum est) is no sooner voiced than it turns into an expectation (praeripiet, veniet, quaeret, volet); its likelihood is then backed up by arguments (68–74) which turn it into a certainty in the present (quaerit). . . . Juno seems determined to believe the worst of her stepson, and to Wnd any excuse to intensify her persecution of him.’48 It has been shown that Juno’s odium and ira in the prologue are Virgilian-Ovidian topoi, that her portrait of Hercules is an extremely prejudiced one, and that her fears, and the extravagance with which she voices them, are disproportionate to the existing or proven threat posed by Hercules. Nonetheless, when we strip away the conventional bombast we Wnd, like Galinsky, that Juno’s ‘objections to Herakles hybris do not lack an objective justiWcation’.49 Seneca’s Hercules is by no means a straightforward victim of persecution. He too is a product of Augustan literary tradition and, as such, an ambivalent hero with dangerous potential. Juno’s version of Hercules’ twelfth labour as a violent and vainglorious assault on Pluto’s throne has a basis in Aeneid 6, where pius Aeneas’ peaceful mission to the Underworld is contrasted with Hercules’ belligerence. At 392–6 a wary Charon declares: 47 Shelton (1978), 20. 49 Galinsky (1972), 169.
48 Fitch (1987), 141.
‘Let the monster be mine’
69
nec vero Alciden me sum laetatus euntem accepisse lacu. . . . Tartareum ille manu custodem in vincla petivit ipsius a solio regis traxitque trementem. In truth I was not glad to have received Alcides as he passed over the lake. . . . He by his hand wrested the Tartarean guard in chains from the throne of the king himself, and dragged him away trembling.
In Horace, Odes 1. 3, Hercules is paired with Daedalus as a hubristic transgressor of the natural limitations imposed on humankind: expertus vacuum Daedalus aera pennis non homini datis: perrupit Acheronta Herculeus labor. nil mortalibus ardui est: caelum ipsum petimus stultitia neque per nostrum patimur scelus iracunda Iovem ponere fulmina. (34–40) Daedalus made trial of the empty air on wings not given to man: Herculean toil forced a way through Acheron. There is no such thing as diYculty for mortals: heaven itself we seek in our folly, and through our sin we suVer not Jupiter to set down the thunderbolts of his wrath.
Juno’s description of Hercules as an impetuous youth (‘violento iuveni’, 43–4), exultant in his physical strength and both unthinking and unrestrained in his fury, also has corroborative parallels in Augustan poetry. The story of Hercules’ defeat of the Wre-breathing demon Cacus in Aeneid 8 is an ultimately laudatory foundation myth, but at the same time an interestingly unsanitized account of the savagery of the venerated monster-slayer. Here Hercules’ anger, although vented on an abhorrent creature and not without justiWcation, is shown to be precipitate and excessive in nature, and thus a species of furor:50 50 In his long poem Contra iudices, Theodulf of Orle´ans (c.760–821), who was, next to Alcuin, the most distinguished and learned member of the Carolingian court, attributes the violent killing of Cacus directly to ‘furor Herculeus’, while downplaying the justiWcation for the killing. In doing so he has followed the interpretation of the Hercules–Cacus episode in Book 9 of Augustine’s De Civitate Dei, in which Cacus is cast as a victimized outsider destroyed by Hercules’ bloodlust and megalomania. Theodulf may also have been aware of Lactantius’ attack on Hercules’ celebrated
70
‘Let the monster be mine’ hic vero Alcidae furiis exarserat atro felle dolor: rapit arma manu nodisque gravatum robur, et ae¨rii cursu petit ardua montis. (219–21)
Hereupon with black bile the wrath of Alcides blazed out in madness: he seized in his hand his weapons and his heavily knotted club, and rushed with speed at the top of the lofty mountain. ecce furens animis aderat Tirynthius omnemque accessum lustrans huc ora ferebat et illuc, dentibus infrendens. (228–30) Behold! the Tirynthian drew near, frenzied with wrath, and, surveying every entrance, turned his face this way and that, gnashing his teeth. non tulit Alcides animis, seque ipse per ignem praecipiti iecit saltu, qua plurimus undam fumus agit nebulaque ingens specus aestuat atra. hic Cacum in tenebris incendia vana vomentem corripit in nodum complexus, et angit inhaerens elisos oculos et siccum sanguine guttur. (256–61) In his wrath Alcides did not put up with this, and with a headlong leap he hurled himself through the Wre, where the smoke pushes its wave forward in a great mass and the vast cave heaves with a black mist. Here he seized Cacus as he was vomiting forth vain Wres in the darkness, clasping him as in a knot, and, clinging, throttled him till the eyes squeezed out and the throat was drained of blood.)
In the tale of Hercules’ battle with the river Achelous for the hand of Deianira, in Metamorphoses 9, Ovid paints a similar image of a hero quick to anger and unmerciful. Invincible Hercules is boastful of his might and contemptuous of his rival’s eloquence: strength in De Divinis Institutionibus 1. 9: ‘Surely, he who subdues a lion is not to be considered stronger than he who subdues anger, the wild beast shut up within himself. . . . Excited by rage and madness, this same Wgure slew his wife together with his children—and men think him a god!’ (trans. McDonald (1964), 40–2). Nees (1991), 30 states: ‘Theodulf ’s Hercules is a hero whose virtue is ambiguous and tainted. . . . Theodulf has drastically condensed the Vergilian passage of nearly one hundred lines down to ten and condensed it in such a way that the brutality of Hercules’ retribution is dramatically highlighted.’
‘Let the monster be mine’
71
accensae non fortiter imperat irae, verbaque tot reddit: ‘melior mihi dextra lingua. dummodo pugnando superem, tu vince loquendo’ congrediturque ferox. (28–31) Not manfully did he control his inXamed rage, and he replied in so many words: ‘My right hand is better than my tongue. You prevail by speaking, provided that I overcome by Wghting’, and he came at me Wercely.
‘Dextra’ (29) in this context provides an illuminating key to understanding the ambivalent nature and dual potential of Seneca’s Hercules. Boyle notes that the words manus and dextra ‘dominate the linguistic texture of this play [HF] as of no other, and pervade most especially Hercules’ own dialogue and the descriptions by others of Hercules’ power’.51 The mighty hand of Hercules has rid the world of monsters and brought peace and civilization to the ends of the earth (Pax est Herculea manu j Auroram inter et Hesperum, 882–3), but it ‘is also the instrument of anger, violent aggression and narcissistic, megalomaniacal ambition, an amalgam of passions or aVectus which move easily into madness and genocide’.52 This paradox is illustrated in Metamorphoses 12, where Nestor is made to recall Hercules’ slaughter of his brothers and his career of destruction in the Peloponnese. The old king is still full of grief and rage when he reveals to Hercules’ son, Tlepolemus, his father’s murderous deeds: quid me meminisse malorum cogis et obductos annis rescindere luctus inque tuum genitorem odium oVensasque fateri? ille quidem maiora Wde, di! gessit et orbem implevit meritis, quod mallem posse negare. . . . ille tuus genitor Messenia moenia quondam stravit et inmeritas urbes Elinque Pylonque diruit inque meos ferrum Xammamque penatis inpulit, utque alios taceam, quos ille peremit, bis sex Nelidae fuimus, conspecta iuventus, 51 Boyle (1997), 106.
52 Ibid. 107.
72
‘Let the monster be mine’ bis sex Herculeis ceciderunt me minus uno viribus. (542–6, 549–55)53
Why do you force me to remember evil things and to tear open a grief that has been healed by the years, and to acknowledge my hatred and sense of outrage towards your father? He has of course accomplished things beyond belief, Heaven knows! and Wlled the earth with beneWts, which I wish I could deny. . . . [But] that father of yours once razed Messene’s walls and demolished the guiltless cities, Elis and Pylos, and wielded Wre and sword against my own home. To say nothing of the others whom he slew, there were twelve of us sons of Neleus, a striking band of youths, and all twelve, save me alone, fell by Herculean might.
In Book 6 of the Aeneid Caesar Augustus is proclaimed Hercules’ successor: nec vero Alcides tantum telluris obivit, Wxerit aeripedem cervam licet, aut Erymanthi pacarit nemora et Lernam tremefecerit arcu. (801–3) Nor, to be sure, did Alcides traverse so much of the earth, even if he pierced the deer with feet of bronze, or made peaceful the woods of Erymanthus, and with his bow made Lerna tremble.
This comparison underlines the ambivalence common to both Wgures in their superhuman achievements. Virgil does not denigrate or even directly question the greatness of these semi-divine heroes, but he does ensure that the dark side of such greatness, and its proximity to tyranny, madness, and other forms of excess, are never far from the reader’s consciousness. In the prologue of Hercules Furens Seneca similarly exposes the kinship between imperial greatness and excess, albeit through the transparently immoderate viewpoint of Juno. The goddess relates the spectacle of Hercules leading Cerberus through the cities of Greece in terms of a Roman triumph, with Hercules the conquering imperator and the dog his spolia opima: 53 Homeric Nestor’s reference to this same episode at Iliad 11. 690–3 is signiWcantly less emotional and less condemnatory of Hercules. The account given in Ovid is in the spirit of Lucretius’ ironical disparagement of the alleged beneWts conferred by Hercules on humankind (De Rerum Natura 5. 22 V.).
‘Let the monster be mine’
73
at ille, rupto carcere umbrarum ferox, de me triumphat et superbiWca manu atrum per urbes ducit Argolicas canem. (57–9) But he, in his arrogance at having smashed the prison of the ghostly dead, is celebrating his triumph over me, and high-handedly parading the black hound through Argive cities.
The verbs ‘triumphat’ and ‘ducit’ are not in themselves pejorative, and, indeed, resonate with noble Roman values, but here they are juxtaposed with the adjectives ‘ferox’ and ‘superbiWca’.54 Allowing for Juno’s bias and overstatement, the juxtaposition of these morally loaded words urges us to consider the diVerence between triumph and triumphalism, and to evaluate the reasonableness of Hercules’ actions when he Wnally appears with Cerberus in tow. Among the many charges brought by Juno against Hercules, one in particular stands out as veriWable and revealing—her imputation that he derives perverse enjoyment from her constant animosity and the cruel tasks she prescribes (crescit malis j iraque nostra fruitur, ‘he grows greater through hardships, thrives on my anger’, 33–4; laetus imperia excipit, ‘he receives my orders cheerfully’, 42). This idea that there is something compulsive and unbalanced about the relish with which Hercules executes each command, and the impatience with which he awaits new challenges, is fundamental to Seneca’s innovative portrait of the hero. Almost immediately on his return to Thebes Hercules asks: quid restat aliud? vidi et ostendi inferos. da si quid ultra est, iam diu pateris manus cessare nostras, Iuno; quae vinci iubes? (613–15) What else remains? I have seen and revealed the Underworld. Assign any further task, Juno, you have left my hands idle too long: what do you bid me conquer?
These lines are, of course, laden with dramatic irony, as we know from Juno that the only thing left for Hercules to conquer is himself 54 The compound adjective superbiWcus is found only here. See Billerbeck (1999), 216.
74
‘Let the monster be mine’
(nemo est nisi ipse; bella iam secum gerat, ‘There is none but himself. Now he must war with himself’, 85; se vincat, ‘let him conquer himself’, 116), that his most terrible labour is imminent. But as well as being ironic, Hercules’ demands substantiate Juno’s claims at 33–4 and 42, and reveal him to be a driven, restless, and obsessive personality. Hercules’ Wrst speech in the play also establishes that he is a character who is self-obsessed and autarkic, features which strongly distinguish him from Euripides’ Herakles. When Euripidean Herakles arrives home (523 V.), he Wrst greets his house and expresses his joy at having returned. He is then instantly alert to his family’s desperate plight and asks his wife what has happened in his absence. By contrast, Senecan Hercules is preoccupied with his recent and future conquests and apparently unaware of anyone else’s presence until line 616. He manifests, moreover, a disposition to megalomaniac fantasy: si placerent tertiae sortis loca, j regnare potui (‘if the regions of the third lot pleased me, I could have reigned there’, 609–10). Commentators have made much of Hercules’ alleged bloodthirstiness in spurring himself to action against Lycus: mactetur impar, hanc ferat virtus notam Watque summus hostis Alcidae Lycus. ad hauriendum sanguinem inimicum feror. (634–6) Though not my equal, he must be slaughtered; my valour must bear this stigma, and Alcides’ Wnal foe must be Lycus. I leave to drain his hateful blood.
Fitch, for example, speaks of ‘the relish which he takes in the task, reXected in language which verges on the brutal’.55 But, in fact, Hercules’ statement of revenge is far more succinct and restrained than the words employed by Euripides’ hero at this point:
æH b r Ø ŒÆd ŒÆÆŒ łø ı ŒÆØH ıæ ø, ŒæAÆ IØ g Þłø ŒıH ºŒÆ· ˚Æø ‹ı ŒÆŒf K æ s ÆŁÆ K KF fiH ŒÆººØŒfiø fiH ‹ ºfiø ØæÆØ, f b æøE ØÆæH ÆØ 55 Fitch (1987), 274.
‘Let the monster be mine’
75
ŒæH – Æ "e K ºø ı, ˜æŒ AÆ ºıŒe ÆƒÆŁÆØ: (566–73) First I shall go and raze to the ground the palace of this new king, I shall cut oV his unholy head and throw it for the dogs to tear at. Those of the Thebans whom I have found to be treacherous in spite of being well treated by me, these I shall overcome with my conquering club. Dispersing others with my winged arrows, I shall Wll the whole of the river Ismenus with bloody corpses and the clear stream of Dirce shall run red with gore.
What seems more pertinent is that Hercules’ brevity and comparative restraint are intrinsic to his restlessness and self-centredness, his lack of demonstrative aVection for his family: me bella poscunt: diVer amplexus, parens, coniunxque diVer. nuntiet Diti Lycus me iam redisse. (638–9) Battle calls me: postpone your embraces, father; wife, postpone them. Lycus must carry to Dis the news of my return.
He exhibits none of the tenderness towards his children that Herakles does at 622–36 of Euripides’ play; Hercules’ chief concern is his virtus (634), and he treats the killing of Lycus as a new labour, a fresh summons to ruthless action. Herakles, on the other hand, explains that his extreme bloodthirstiness stems from his love for his family and his overwhelming need to protect them, a duty which eclipses in signiWcance the feats of his labours: fiH ª æ I Ø Aºº j ÆæØ æc ŒÆd ÆØd ŒÆd ªæØ; ÆØæø Ø· ªaæ ÆPf H Aºº XıÆ: ŒÆd E bæ H , Y æ ¥ bæ Ææ, ŁfiŒØ I · j ŒÆºe oæfi Æ b KºŁE K º ¯PæıŁø ÆEØ, H KH Œø PŒ KŒ ø Ł Æ; PŒ ¼æ ˙æÆŒºB › ŒÆººØŒ ‰
æØŁ ºÆØ: (574–82) For whom should I protect if not my wife and children and father? Goodbye to my labours! They are useless in comparison to these. If they, the children,
76
‘Let the monster be mine’
were prepared to die for their father, I must die in defending them. Otherwise what shall we say is so glorious about doing battle with a hydra and a lion on Eurystheus’ orders, if I do not exert myself over the death of my children? I shall never then be called as I once was, ‘gloriously conquering Herakles’.
One Wnal observation to be made about Hercules’ ambivalence in his Wrst scene is that the hero’s own words highlight, with heavy tragic irony, his dual potential and prepare us for the catastrophic inversion of roles madness will occasion: Watque summus hostis Alcidae Lycus (‘and Alcides’ Wnal foe must be Lycus’, 635). The emphatic juxtaposition of ‘Alcidae Lycus’ reinforces Braden’s point that the mental mechanism is the same for Seneca’s heroes and villains. Bishop, however, misapprehends the signiWcance of the similarity when he says that Hercules and Lycus ‘are men of the same basic quality. Since this is tragedy, what happens to one is pattern, parallel, precedent for the other.’56 The real message is surely that Hercules, a greater man than Lycus—greater in strength, virtue, and achievement—has, in proportion to his greatness, a capacity for transgression and suVering far in excess of his enemy’s (cf. quicumque regnas: scelera taxantur modo j maiore vestra, ‘all you who reign: your crimes are assessed with heavier penalties’, 746–7).
THE MADNESS (926–1053) Hercules’ transition from hero to villain, his metamorphosis into his own ‘summus hostis’, is not the sudden, inexplicable event that it is in Euripides’ play. Euripides’ strikingly un-Aristotelian structure, with its wrenching use of peripeteia, focuses our attention on the discontinuity between Hercules’ sane and insane behaviour; the deliberate structural violence emphasizes the dislocation of existing reason and moral order by a hostile and irrational external force. The emphasis in Seneca’s structure, however, is on continuity and consistency, and reXects an original interest in the inward, psychological actuation of the madness. Critics, like Motto and Clark, who view Hercules in 56 Bishop (1966), 216–24, at 220.
‘Let the monster be mine’
77
much the same light as his Euripidean counterpart, that is, in terms of ‘deliberately oppressed and maligned greatness’, completely fail to account for this crucial diVerence in structural emphasis between the Greek and Roman plays. The importance of Euripides’ startling central epiphany to the externalization of Herakles’ madness cannot be overstated. The audience is in no way prepared during the Wrst half of the play for the savage upheaval of the second half; the madness is unexpected and explosive. There is no omniscient deity to prologize and forewarn, and no indication in Herakles’ early behaviour of incipient madness or punishable hubris. Although Hera is mentioned in the prologue as the instigator of Herakles’ labours, Amphitryon concentrates not on the goddess’ jealous anger but rather on his son’s protracted absence and the present, increasingly hopeless situation in Thebes. Amphitryon’s prologue leads into a suspenseful rescue drama, the denouement of which is merely the prelude to an electrifying reversal initiated by the unannounced and highly dramatic midway appearance of Hera’s emissaries. Euripides’ personiWcation of a reluctant but chillingly methodical Lyssa makes immediate and unambiguous both the supernatural causation of Herakles’ temporary psychosis and the iniquity of the attack. Lyssa vividly activates the madness on stage, announcing at 867 V. the physical signs of her successful entry into Herakles’ heart: j N · ŒÆd c Ø Ø ŒæAÆ Æºø ¼ ŒÆd ØÆæı ºØ EªÆ ªæªø f ŒæÆ, I a P øæØ, ÆFæ S K Kº, Øa ıŒAÆØ : Look at him! He is already shaking his head at the start of his race, rolling his distorted Xashing eyes without speaking. His breathing is uncontrolled like a bull ready to attack, and he bellows terribly.
Seneca could easily have made Furor a character in his tragedy, but he chose instead to conWne the level of divine motivation to the prologue, where Juno summons up from Hell Discordia, Scelus, Impietas, Error, and Furor. The omission of the interventionist Wgures of Iris and Lyssa from the scene of Hercules’ insane transformation obscures the boundary between reason and distraction,
78
‘Let the monster be mine’
and lends psychological realism to the onset of madness which in Seneca’s version occurs on stage: —Sed quid hoc? medium diem cinxere tenebrae. Phoebus obscuro meat sine nube vultu. quis diem retro fugat agitque in ortus? unde nox atrum caput ignota profert? unde tot stellae polum implent diurnae? (939–44) But what is this? Midday is shrouded in darkness. Phoebus’ face is obscured, though not by clouds. Who chases the daylight back and drives it to its dawning? Why is this strange night rearing its black head? Why are so many stars Wlling the heavens in daytime?
The madness of Euripides’ Herakles ends, as it began, violently and as a result of sudden divine intervention. A phantasmic Pallas Athene hurls a stone at Herakles’ chest, causing him to collapse into a deep palliative sleep (1002–6). In Seneca the supernatural element is again omitted and replaced by a naturalistic loss of consciousness, as Hercules is tranquillized by exhaustion: vultus in somnum cadit et fessa cervix capite summisso labat; Xexo genu iam totus ad terram ruit, ut caesa silvis ornus aut portum mari datura moles. (1044–7) His eyes are closing in sleep, his head sinking, his weary neck drooping. Now his knees bend and his whole body collapses on the ground, as heavily as an ash tree felled in the woods, or a mass of masonry dropped in the sea to create a harbour.
In Euripides the moment at which madness overcomes Herakles is clearly signalled, Wrst by Lyssa herself when she exclaims j N , and later by the Messenger, who reports › PŒŁ Æe q (931). Both announcements are followed by detailed accounts of Herakles’ demented physiognomy (867–70 and 932–5). In Seneca’s text this moment is less precisely and abruptly deWned, largely because the symptoms of Hercules’ madness are predominantly psychological
‘Let the monster be mine’
79
rather than physical. Amphitryon asks Hercules at 952, Quod subitum hoc malum est? (‘What is this sudden trouble?’), but the onset of madness is, in fact, gradual and arguably precedes Hercules’ Wrst overt display of delirium, that is, his initial hallucination in which he envisions a solar eclipse and interstellar warfare. In 1994 Motto and Clark penned a note on lines 926–39 of Hercules Furens which was eVectively a revisionary addendum to the article they published thirteen years earlier. They acknowledge in this note that Hercules’ prayer for alta pax ‘smacks of hubris in the extreme’,57 that it evinces ‘a host of unusual traits’,58 chieXy supreme naivety and prodigious ego. In their attempt to rationalize what they regard as aberrant conduct, Motto and Clark propose that the fantastic aspirations expressed in the prayer suggest that the madness sent by Juno is already operative at this stage: ‘In short, lines 926–39 portray a Hercules who is steadily and incrementally becoming more and more rash, illusionary, and unstable.’59 They legitimately dispute the traditional conjecture that the madness commences at line 939, and their proposition of an earlier onset is well supported by the evidence of mental unbalance in the wording of Hercules’ prayer for a new Golden Age. However, contrary to Motto and Clark, I believe that the psychological traits exhibited in lines 926–39 are consistent with Hercules’ characterization earlier in the drama. The prayer for an impossible peace is, in essence, an ampliWcation of the obsessive (particularly self-obsessive) and megalomaniac tendencies manifest in Hercules’ Wrst speech at 592–615, which is also a prayer that evolves into a soliloquy. Hercules’ petition at 926 V. begins with a general plea for cosmic and terrestrial harmony, but the speciWcs of this petition, listed at 931–6, are exceedingly unrealistic and reveal an irrational desire to arrest the natural order, to eliminate seasonal and meteorological extremes: Ipse concipiam preces Iove meque dignas. stet suo caelum loco tellusque et aequor; astra inoVensos agant aeterna cursus, alta pax gentes alat; ferrum omne teneat ruris innocui labor 57 Motto and Clark (1994), 269–72, at 269. 59 Ibid. 271.
58 Ibid. 270.
80
‘Let the monster be mine’ ensesque lateant. nulla tempestas fretum violenta turbet, nullus irato Iove exiliat ignis, nullus hiberna nive nutritus agros amnis eversos trahat. venena cessent, nulla nocituro gravis suco tumescat herba. non saevi ac truces regnent tryanni. si quod etiamnum est scelus latura tellus, properet, et si quod parat monstrum, meum sit.
I shall pronounce prayers, ones worthy of Jove and of myself. May heaven stand in its place, and earth and sea. May the eternal stars pursue their courses unhindered. May deep peace nurture the nations, may iron be used only in the harmless toil of the countryside, and may swords be hidden away. May no violent storm disturb the seas, may no Wre streak down from angry Jove, may no river fed with winter snows ravage the uptorn Welds. May poisons disappear, and may no deadly herb swell with harmful juices. May no Werce and cruel tyrants reign. If the earth is even now to produce some wickedness, let it come quickly; if she is furnishing some monster, let it be mine.
Hercules’ irrationalism is compounded by his hubristic assumption that he is the sole agent of peace and an invulnerable saviour Wgure equal to Jupiter (‘Iove meque dignas’,60 927). His assertion of a proprietary right over any remaining monster recalls lines 613–15 of his Wrst speech, and especially the command ‘da si quid ultra est’. In both instances Hercules’ words are tragically ironic, but at the same time symptomatic of his mental instability, his obsessiveness and manic restlessness. The ‘monstrum’ referred to at line 938 is, of course, Hercules. As Juno intended, Hercules is to do battle with himself, the one earthly opponent equal to his strength. Juno launches the battle and determines its course, but, in eVect, she does no more than exploit and exacerbate a pre-existing or semilatent mania, a fact best illustrated by the content of Hercules’ hallucinations at 939–1038. The madness of Euripides’ Herakles consists of a single coherent hallucination. He imagines himself travelling by chariot to Mycenae 60 Boyle (1997), 108 notes that the use of dignus with the ablative ‘may well have been a mannerism of Nero’s’, and he cites as evidence Suet. Nero 23. 1, in which the historian claims to quote an imperial rescript from ad 66/7: ‘ut Nerone dignus revertar.’ Cf. HF 957: ‘dignus Alcide labor.’
‘Let the monster be mine’
81
in order to kill his great enemy Eurystheus. Along the way he prepares a banquet for himself and wrestles with an imaginary adversary. Finally, with his bow and club he murders his own wife and children under the illusion that he is wreaking revenge on the family of Eurystheus. These demented exploits have a logical sequence, and, in a diVerent context and directed at the right target, the violence, which culminates in serial slaughter, would not be considered anomalous or excessive. As Barlow states, ‘the illusions take place within the framework of normal and habitual acts’.61 By contrast, Seneca’s Hercules experiences a series of hallucinations with an ‘associative, rather than logical, connection between some of the visions’.62 ‘It is the relevance of the visions to Hercules’ individual psychology’, Fitch maintains, ‘that is of primary importance in the play.’63 His is not simply a case of misdirected normal aggression; the delusions themselves are megalomaniac and impious. In the same way as the preceding prayer for peace, the hallucinations reXect on a grand scale the preoccupations and abnormalities of the hero’s ‘sane’ mind. Juno may be orchestrating the madness as commander-inchief in Hercules’ war against himself, but the content of the hallucinations is psychologically consistent with the symptoms of mental disturbance previously displayed by Hercules. Just like Euripides, Seneca has conceived a madness ‘which is Wtted to this particular man’.64 The second of Hercules’ hallucinations, in which he plans an allout assault on heaven, converts his usual obsession with new challenges and punitive action, and his self-equation with Jupiter (cf. 907, 914, 922–4, 927), based on his promised deiWcation, into explicit Oedipal aggression towards his father: Perdomita tellus, tumida cesserunt freta, inferna nostros regna sensere impetus: immune caelum est, dignus Alcide labor in alta mundi spatia sublimis ferar, petatur aether: astra promittit pater. —quid, si negaret? non capit terra Herculem tandemque superis reddit. en ultro vocat 61 Barlow (1996), 165. 63 Ibid. 29.
62 Fitch (1987), 29. 64 Barlow (1996), 166.
82
‘Let the monster be mine’ omnis deorum coetus et laxat fores, una vetante. recipis et reseras polum? an contumacis ianuam mundi traho? dubitatur etiam? vincla Saturno exuam, contraque patris impii regnum impotens avum resolvam. (955–67)
Earth is subdued, the swollen seas have yielded, the infernal realm has felt my onslaught: heaven is untouched, a labour worthy of Alcides. I must travel on high to the lofty expanses of the cosmos, and make for the sky: the stars are my father’s promise. What if he should now refuse? The earth cannot contain Hercules, and at last yields him to the world above. See, the whole company of the gods spontaneously summons me and opens the doors, with one goddess forbidding it. Will you receive me and unbar the Wrmament? Or must I tear down the door of the stubborn heaven? Do you still hesitate? I shall strip oV Saturn’s chains, and against my unnatural father’s unbridled rule I shall loose my grandfather.
This proposed attack is not indicative of Hercules’ habitual behaviour, but it is certainly an extension of his habitual psychology, especially his habitual megalomania. The phrase ‘dignus Alcide labor’ (957) recalls Hercules’ assumption of parity with Jupiter at 927 (‘Iove meque dignas’), while his pronouncement ‘non capit terra Herculem’ (960) recalls Juno’s claim at 46 (‘nec satis terrae patent’), a belief apparently shared by Hercules (cf. 609). Braden sees in lines 955 V., and in the momentum of Hercules’ mounting insanity, ‘a logical extrapolation of the pax Herculea’65 (929 V.): ‘The hallucinatory but lethal assault on the gods . . . reXects an ugly light back on the vision of the new golden age: as if that vision itself were merely imperial megalomania tilting on the edge.’66 At 976 V. Hercules envisages, in typically grandiose fashion, a rebellion by the Giants: Quid hoc? Gigantes arma pestiferi movent. profugit umbras Tityos, ac lacerum gerens et inane pectus quam prope a caelo stetit! labat Cithaeron, alta Pellene tremit
65 Braden (1993), 245–64, at 250.
66 Ibid.
‘Let the monster be mine’
83
marcentque Tempe. rapuit hic Pindi iuga, hic rapuit Oeten, saevit horrendum Mimas. What is this? The pestilential Giants are in arms. Tityos has escaped the Underworld, and stands so close to heaven, his chest all torn and empty! Cithaeron lurches, high Pallene shakes, and Tempe’s beauty withers. One Giant has seized the peaks of Pindus, another has seized Oeta, and Mimas rages fearfully.
These images are an extreme manifestation of Hercules’ habitual obsession with order and chaos and with bringing to account the recalcitrant forces of cosmic anarchy. ‘Sed ecce’ at 987 marks a sudden shift in this feverish hallucinatory sequence67 to a less distant and expansive sphere of action, as Hercules catches sight of his children and believes they are those of Lycus. Each of the subsequent murders is apparently carried out oV-stage, while Amphitryon, with a view of events inside the palace, describes the killings as they occur. Hercules continues to be audible and intermittently visible throughout the scene. Having shot the Wrst boy through the neck with an arrow, he prepares to hunt down his remaining two sons: Ceteram prolem eruam omnesque latebras. quid moror? maius mihi bellum Mycenis restat, ut Cyclopia eversa manibus saxa nostris concidant. (995–8) I shall unearth the other oVspring and all their hiding-places. Why delay? A greater struggle awaits me at Mycenae, to overthrow the Cyclopean walls with my bare hands.
Hercules’ reference, in the middle of his Wlicidal rampage, to a future confrontation with Eurystheus is characteristic of the restlessness and overzealousness that delirium has aggravated. He seizes the second son and dashes him against the palace walls (1005–7). The third son dies of terror before his father can strike a blow (1023–4). Of considerable psychological signiWcance is the fact that Hercules confuses Megara with Juno (Teneo novercam, ‘I have caught my stepmother’, 1018), even though he is conscious of her relationship to the child being pursued 67 Cf. ‘Sed quid hoc?’ (939) and ‘Quid hoc?’ (976).
84
‘Let the monster be mine’
(ante matrem parvulum hoc monstrum j occidat, ‘before the mother let this little monster be killed’, 1020). Just as the delusional plan to depose Jupiter brought to the surface a latent Oedipal aggression, so the killing of Megara is the climactic expression of Hercules’ intense resentment of Juno.68 Seneca introduces into the hallucinations a degree of culpability which is notably absent from Euripides’ text. Herakles’ mad deeds are criminal but he is innocent of criminal intent; the false reality he enacts does not in itself deviate markedly from the heroic norm. Hercules’ imagined reality, on the other hand, entails behaviour far outside the norm by which even a nonpareil, semi-divine hero is to be judged. His actions, regardless of context, and directed at the supposed target, would constitute gross impietas and nefas, and are, to some extent, a vindication of Juno’s fears. This Senecan theodicy contrasts strongly with Euripides’ insistence on an absolute lack of justiWcation for divine anger.
T H E AWA K E N I N G A N D R E H A BI L I TAT I O N OF HERCULES (1138–1344) Act Five of Hercules Furens corresponds to lines 1089 V. of Euripides’ play, in which Herakles regains consciousness, is gradually restored to sanity and cognizance, and forced to come to terms with his misdeeds. Seneca’s emphasis in these post-madness scenes is once again on the continuity of Hercules’ attitudes and behaviour with those of the previous acts. In place of Euripides’ physical portrait of the waking Herakles, which dwells on the hero’s awareness of his immediate natural surroundings, his hot unsteady breath, bodily constraint, and lack of weapons, Seneca presents a psychological portrait. Herakles, on waking, reasonably infers from the evidence of carnage nearby, and his unusual state of defencelessness, that he has
68 In the light of the Oedipal paradigm behind Hercules’ hallucinatory attack on Jupiter, it is also tempting to read his imagined killing of Juno as an oblique reference to, or an ironic warning of, Nero’s incestuous relationship with Agrippina and the matricide he eventually commits.
‘Let the monster be mine’
85
returned to Hades. Hercules’ sense of dusgnoia (perplexity) and displacement is typically on a grander scale: Quis hic locus, quae regio, quae mundi plaga? ubi sum? sub ortu solis, an sub cardine glacialis Ursae? numquid Hesperii maris extrema tellus hunc dat Oceano modum? quas trahimus auras? quod solum fesso subest? certe redimus. (1138–43) What place is this, what region, what tract of the earth? Where am I? Beneath the sun’s rising, or beneath the turning point of the icy Bear? Can this be the limit set to Ocean’s waters by the farthest land on the western sea? What air do I breathe? What ground lies under my weary body? Certainly I have returned.
The grandiosity of these cumulative interrogatives,69 through which Hercules expresses his disorientation, is perhaps not unreasonable in view of his accustomed expeditions to the ends of the earth, but it is also consistent with his equally accustomed self-aggrandizing modes of thinking and discourse. Interestingly, in his 1999 translation of the play Ranjit Bolt drastically reduces the extravagant tone of lines 1138–43 and, therefore, their psychological signiWcance: ‘Where am I? South or North or West or East? j What is this ground I’m lying on? At least j I know one thing: I’ve left the lower world.’70 ‘So too’, says Fitch, ‘with Hercules’ narcissistic concern with himself, or rather with an image of himself as invincible hero.’71 On discovering that his famous lion-skin and bow are missing, Hercules construes the loss as a loss of primacy and virtus: arma quis vivo mihi detrahere potuit? spolia quis tanta abstulit ipsumque quis non Herculis somnum horruit? libet meum videre victorem, libet— 69 Cumulative interrogatives are a peculiarly Roman rhetorical feature, known as percontatio (a persistent asking). Percontatio is a series of ‘wh-’ questions, as distinct from interrogatio, which is generally a ‘yes-or-no’ type of enquiry. Quintilian uses percontatio in the legal sense of interrogation or cross-examination (Insitutio Oratoria 5. 7. 27). 70 Bolt (1999), 62. 71 Fitch (1979), 240–8, at 243.
86
‘Let the monster be mine’ exsurge, virtus! quem novum caelo pater genuit relicto? cuius in fetu stetit nox longior quam nostra? (1153–8)
Who could strip my armour from me while I lived? Who stole such mighty spoils and had no dread of Hercules even in his sleep? I long to see my conqueror. Rouse yourself, my courage! What new son did my father leave heaven to sire? For whose begetting was night delayed longer than mine?
The emphatic placement of the personal pronoun, which forms part of the dative of disadvantage ‘vivo mihi’ (1153), and the pointed reference to ‘Herculis’ (1155) and ‘meum victorem’ (1156), show plainly Hercules’ egocentric perspective of the situation. Similarly, when Hercules recognizes his dead wife and children, his response to the murders is dominated by a sense of outrage at the violation of his virtus and heroic self-image: quis Lycus regnum obtinet,72 quis tanta Thebis scelera moliri ausus est Hercule reverso? quisquis Ismeni loca, Actaea quisquis arva, qui gemino mari pulsata Pelopis regna Dardanii colis, succurre, saevae cladis auctorem indica. ruat ira in omnes: hostis est quisquis mihi non monstrat hostem. victor Alcidae, lates? (1161–8) What Lycus holds the kingdom? Who dared encompass such crimes in Thebes once Hercules had returned? All you who dwell in the districts of Ismenos, the Welds of Attica, and the realms of Dardan Pelops, beaten by two seas: run to help, point out the source of this cruel carnage. My anger must pour out on all: my enemy is anyone who does not identify my enemy. Are you hiding, conqueror of Alcides?
The emphatically positioned ablative absolute ‘Hercule reverso’ (1163), which has a concessive force, and the phrase ‘victor Alcidae’ (1168) represent the most important aspect of the killings as far as Hercules is concerned. He measures the enormity of the ‘nefas’ (1159) committed by the perpetrator’s audacity (‘ausus est’, 1162). 72 This line and ‘victor Alcidae’ (1168) recall, with even greater tragic irony, Hercules’ command at 635: ‘Watque summus hostis Alcidae Lycus.’
‘Let the monster be mine’
87
Hercules’ ensuing call to action is also ‘in character’. At 1175 he orders Amphitryon and Theseus to postpone their tears (diVerte Xetus), recalling closely his injunction to father and wife, at 638–9, ‘diVer amplexus’. In these parallel instances Hercules’ obsessive haste in administering retributive violence takes precedence over expressions of love or grief between himself and his family. Later, in a brief but moving moment of self-analysis, he curses his sacriWce of human tenderness to the heroic condition, and speciWcally his inability to weep as a father: Pectus o nimium ferum! quis vos per omnem, liberi, sparsos domum deXere digne poterit? hic durus malis lacrimare vultus nescit. (1226–9) O heart too Werce! Who can weep worthily for you children, scattered throughout the house? This face, hardened by suVerings, is incapable of weeping.
The stichomythia between Amphitryon and Hercules at 1186–91 is a contracted version of the corresponding exchange at 1111–45 of Euripides’ Herakles. It involves, moreover, a very diVerent dynamic. In the earlier text Amphitryon, acting the role of psychotherapist, slowly and gently leads his son out of his trance-like state and towards full recognition of his crimes. But in the Senecan stichomythia Amphitryon is merely the voice of caution and grief, and not the agent of anagno¯risis. Hercules has already discovered for himself the corpses’ identities, and it is the ghastly evidence of his own bloodied manus that dramatically betrays the identity of their killer: Miserere, genitor, supplices tendo manus. quid hoc? manus refugit: hic errat scelus. unde hic cruor? quid illa puerili madens harundo leto? tincta Lernaea est nece. iam tela video nostra. non quaero manum. quis potuit arcum Xectere aut quae dextera sinuare nervum vix recedentem mihi? ad vos revertor, genitor: hoc nostrum est scelus? tacuere: nostrum est. (1192–9)
88
‘Let the monster be mine’
Have pity, father, I hold out my hands in supplication. What? He pulled back from my hands: the crime is lurking here. Why this blood? What of that shaft, soaked by a boy’s death? It is steeped in the Hydra’s fatal blood. Now I see my weapons. I need not ask about the hand. Who could have bent that bow, what hand Xexed the string that barely yields to me? I turn to both of you again, father: is this crime mine? They are silent: it is mine.
By not having Amphitryon as a central unifying presence, and by drastically reducing Theseus’ part in the rehabilitative process, Seneca has completely altered the structural emphasis and thematic basis of the Wnal scene. Euripides emphasized philia, human solidarity and unconditional love, as the keynote in Herakles’ rehabilitation; Seneca substitutes autarkeia, the hero’s aggressive self-assertion and prized sense of self-suYciency. Hercules is not saved from suicidal despair by Theseus’ constancy, wisdom, and willingness to share his friend’s pollution and suVering (cf. Eur. Her. 1400: ŒÆ, ı · PŒ IÆÆØ, ‘Wipe away! As much as you like! I do not reject it’). Rather, his determination to kill himself is checked by Amphitryon’s desperate counter-threat of suicide, in what Fitch classiWes as a species of the ‘Passion-versus-Restraint’73 scene: sic statue, quidquid statuis, ut causam tuam famamque in arto stare et ancipiti scias: aut vivis aut occidis. hanc animam levem fessamque senio nec minus fessam malis in ore primo teneo. tam tarde patri vitam dat aliquis? non feram ulterius moram, letale ferrum pectori impresso induam; hic, hic iacebit Herculis sani scelus. (1306–13) Whatever you decide, do so on the understanding that your glory and the verdict about you is in a tight and critical position. Either you live, or you kill. I am holding on my very lips this fragile life of mine, wearied with old age and no less wearied with troubles. Can anyone be so slow in granting his father life? I shall not endure further delay, I shall set my breast against the deadly blade and thrust it in. The crime lying here will belong to the sane Hercules.
73 See Fitch (1979), 240–8, at 245–6.
‘Let the monster be mine’
89
Several critics have interpreted Hercules’ decision to go on living as a moral victory, an exemplum of Stoic endurance and Wlial piety.74 But this is another instance of mistaking Seneca’s hero for the Euripidean Herakles. Herakles’ moving resolution KªŒÆææø (‘I shall have the courage to endure life’, 1351) is indeed a moral victory and a crucial moral progression, but Hercules’ exhortation to his virtus, ‘vivamus’ (1317), is, at best, an act of delayed and grudging pietas. Herakles’ decision to endure the painful companionship of his bow and club (Her. 1377–85) is symbolic of his advancement to a more mature and profound type of heroism, one exacting spiritual strength and courage. In Seneca, Hercules at Wrst determines to destroy his weapons to atone for his sons’ murders (1231–5), but he quickly changes tack: arma, arma, Theseu, Xagito propere mihi subtracta reddi. sana si mens est mihi, referte manibus tela; si remanet furor, pater, recede: mortis inveniam viam. (1242–5) My arms, my arms, Theseus, I demand that my stolen arms be quickly returned. If my mind is sane, give my hands back their weapons; if my madness remains, father, stand away; I shall Wnd a path to death.
His decision to retain his weapons for the purpose of self-immolation is symbolic not of his moral progress to heroic maturity, but of precipitate reversion to punitive action. It is also, as Miola points out, ‘an act of self-assertion, a validation of heroic identity. The language of Seneca’s play, particularly the insistent metaphors of exploration, suggests the implicit hubris. Hercules’ declaration, ‘‘mortis inveniam viam’’ (1245, ‘‘I shall Wnd a way to death’’), recalls his last great
74 Motto and Clark (1981), 101–17, at 105, for example, claim ‘the Senecan Hercules contests not with a Theseus on the grounds of ‘‘friendship’’ and philia, but with his father over the concepts of kinship, responsibility, honor, and duty. Seneca’s Hercules is not the old, aristocratic Ajax of Sophocles, who, ‘‘caught in new and anti-heroic circumstances which degrade him and make him ludicrous . . . consistently prefers suicide to a life of absurdity in an alien time.’’ Rather, his is ultimately the heroic commitment to survive, to protect, to endure.’
90
‘Let the monster be mine’
labour, the Wnding of a way to Hades and back out. It also recalls his greatest aspiration, the Wnding of a path to the stars (958–61).’75 The Wnal image of Euripides’ Herakles is of a dependent Wgure who, through immense suVering, has deepened his understanding of the value of human love and friendship. Underlining this image is the epholkides (little boats in tow) simile, repeated at 1424, and Herakles’ epigrammatic last words: ‹Ø b ºF j Ł Aºº ºø IªÆŁH AŁÆØ ºÆØ ŒÆŒH æE. (1425–6) Whoever wants to acquire wealth or power rather than good friends is a fool.
In stark contrast, the end of Seneca’s tragedy highlights Hercules’ isolation, his incapacity for loving dependence, and thus his failure to be fully or genuinely rehabilitated. The hero’s Wnal words are a prayer for obscurity and death: redde me infernis, precor, umbris reductum, meque subiectum tuis substitute vinclis; ille me abscondet locus— sed et ille novit. (1338–40) Return me, I pray you, to the shades of the Underworld, and reinstate me in your chains as your replacement. That place will hide me—but it too knows me.
Seneca’s dramatic portrait of the mad Hercules, which introduced the concepts of psychological causation and moral culpability, was eVectively a mirror of the excesses of the late Julio-Claudian age. In reasoning the madness as the furor of imperial overachievement and absolute power, Seneca also redeWned Hercules’ heroism in Roman and imperial terms, creating an imperialist Hercules of tragically divided potential, a Wgure increasingly isolated by megalomania and destroyed by a sense of selfhood that is unmitigated by selfknowledge or self-mastery. In Braden’s words: ‘A vision of furor conquered and enchained yields to a vision of furor beyond all limits and hope. For the very force that was to restrain the world’s violence 75 Miola (1992), 168.
‘Let the monster be mine’
91
has become, as Blake would say, what it beheld: the emperor is mad.’76 There is little optimism in this portrait, a symptom of the palpable inexorability of the times. Although Hercules Furens is unquestionably a product of the Senecan world and the Senecan experience, it has had an enormous inXuence on succeeding generations of playwrights, most notably in the Renaissance depiction of princely distraction and ambitious selfhood, and, fascinatingly, in late twentieth- and early twentyWrst-century adaptations of Euripides’ Herakles, beginning with a version by Archibald MacLeish. The modern theatre seems to have rediscovered in Seneca’s ambivalent and autarkic hero a powerful analogy for the mad excess and inexorable conceit of its own day. 76 Braden (1985), 8.
3 A peculiar compound: Hercules as Renaissance man In a variety of ways and for a variety of reasons, Roman Hercules seized upon the Renaissance imagination. His ability to excite wonder, to be assimilated into diVerent ideologies and artistic media, was extraordinary. Around him two main traditions evolved, one focusing on his heroic virtue, the other on his madness. In each case he was a distinguishable type, and it was explicitly as a type that the Renaissance received Hercules. The principal mode of reception was allegorical interpretation, its motivating concern what Hercules and his achievements signiWed morally. Outside the tragic stage, where Hercules retained a spiritual rather than physical presence, the hero was transformed from a character or being into an abstract idea.
VIRTUS HEROICA VERSUS FUROR Renaissance Hercules represents a synthesis of various classical traditions. As an exemplum of virtus heroica he is also a distillation of his complex classical self. For the most part he is recognized as a civilizing hero of superhuman endurance and valour, who rid the world of monsters and liberated it from chaos. But, unlike his ancient counterpart, he is a Wgure of startling propriety and intellectual consequence. Hercules the overreacher, the transgressor of boundaries, becomes a paradigm of moderation. And where his propensity for excess is apparent, it is justiWed as a manifestation of superior
A peculiar compound
93
virtue. The newly decorous Hercules conforms to both courtly and Christian ideals. As the hero of the Wrst two books of Raoul Le Fe`vre’s Le Recueil des hystoires de Troyes (1464),1 he exhibits the moral and martial virtues of the true knight. What is more, Le Fe`vre interprets many of Hercules’ labours, such as supporting the heavens and slaying the hydra, as intellectual feats rather than merely physical exploits. Hercules is also celebrated for his strength of mind in Natale Conti’s Mythologiae libri decem (1551) and Vincentio Cartari’s Le Imagini con la Spositione de i Dei de gli Antichi (1556), where his victories over the monsters and tyrants are explained as triumphs of the mind over all sorts of vice. Similarly, in his Iconologia (1593) Cesare Ripa depicts Hercules as a perfect fusion of the three constituent parts of heroic virtue: the moderation of anger; the tempering of greed; and contempt for strife and pleasure. Hercules’ club accordingly symbolizes reason, while his lion’s skin represents generosity of mind and the conquest of concupiscence. In the late Middle Ages Hercules was viewed as a standard-bearer for the contemplative life. Guido da Pisa, in his Expositiones et Glose super Comediam Dantis, construed the hostile relations between Juno and her stepson as a clash between Juno as the active life and Hercules as the life devoted to contemplation and virtue. This interpretation contrasts markedly with Seneca’s portrait of a restless, overachieving Hercules who gives some substance to Juno’s worst fears. However, beginning with the poetess Christine de Pisan in the early Wfteenth century, Hercules was adopted as a symbol of the active life, and, as such, he attracted the attention of the Florentine humanists. His other appeal to the humanists was as an emblem of eloquence, a quality with which he was rarely associated in antiquity. Importantly, the Renaissance concept of eloquence implied not only verbal Xuency but also cultural aspiration. It could further imply moral goodness: the notion that to be eloquent one had to be vir bonus. The crusader Rinaldo in Torquato Tasso’s Allegory of Jerusalem Delivered (1575) is a Herculean hero who exempliWes active virtue. He is also, incidentally, an example of virtuous excess.
1 In 1475 William Caxton published a translation of Le Fe`vre’s work in England. Like the original, Caxton’s version enjoyed great popularity.
94
A peculiar compound
The most popular allegorization of Hercules in the Renaissance was Hercules in bivio. In his quest for happiness at the crossroads of life, the hero chooses plain Virtue with her steep and rugged path on his right, and rejects the seductive path of ease and pleasure oVered by Vice on his left. This parable, which seems to have originated with the Wfth-century sophist Prodicus and Wrst appears in Xenophon’s Memorabilia, ‘intellectualizes the older concept of the hero as a redoubtable muscleman by making him an exemplar of reason and his moral choice a heroic act’.2 SigniWcantly, the story as derived from Prodicus is ultimately motivated by the pursuit of undying glory and not by any abstract notion of goodness. In the Renaissance Hercules’ choice was evoked in iconography,3 emblem books, mythographies, plays, pageants, and educational manuals. Among the artists who employed this motif were Du¨rer, Raphael, Rubens, Poussin, and most famously Annibale Carracci.4 Emblem 40 of GeVrey Whitney’s A Choice of Emblemes (1586) shows Hercules at the Forum Romanum courted by the opposing goddesses Minerva and Venus. In The Pilgrim’s Progress Bunyan has the pilgrim Christian confront such a choice, and in The Merchant of Venice Bassanio’s choice of the lead casket is just such a choice as Hercules had made before him. For obvious reasons, Hercules in bivio became associated with ‘the ontological condition of the Christian torn between the forces of good and evil’.5 He was, moreover, perceived as a model of Christian asceticism, his choice serving as a parable for the rejection of the body in favour of the spirit. Naturally enough, Hercules’ labours, his descent into hell, and his apotheosis were also Christianized during the Renaissance, and Hercules himself was often identiWed with Christ. In his Hymne de l’Hercule Chrestien, the French poet Pierre de Ronsard controversially proclaimed Hercules another Christ. Dante compared Hercules’ katabasis with that of Christ, while at the climax of Paradise Regained, Milton used the defeat of Antaeus by Hercules as a simile for Christ’s victory over the Tempter (4.562–71). 2 Zimmermann (2006), 356–78, at 364. 3 Reid (1993), 527–9 lists 30 such depictions between 1500 and 1650. Panofsky (1930) remains the most important study of the iconography of Hercules in bivio. 4 For an analysis of Carracci’s iconic painting of the Choice of Hercules for the Farnese ceiling, see Braider (2004), 111–43. 5 Zimmermann (2006), 356–78, at 364.
A peculiar compound
95
Part of the Renaissance process of purifying and moralizing the Hercules myth was a rationalization of the hero’s madness in suitable allegorical terms. In keeping with his chivalric conception of Hercules, Le Fe`vre conceived Hercules’ furor as the stuV of romantic tragedy: the courtly lover is roused to anger by Linceus’ (Lycus’) false accusations of adultery, and kills both him and the innocent Megara. A more extreme attempt to justify the violence was made by the Florentine humanist Coluccio Salutati. In De Laboribus Herculis (c.1406), which he began in response to a request from a friend to explain Seneca’s Hercules Furens, he reasoned Hercules’ madness as a kind of righteous excess beyond the understanding of lesser men, but intrinsic to his quest to overcome the terrestrial impedimenta to spiritual perfection: Inter hec [sic] autem furere Hercules videtur quia mundana abicientes eternorum amore in nostris oculis insanire videntur. Unde Pater Augustinus: ‘Necesse est ut ab impiis et dissimilibus patiantur opprobria et despiciantur tanquam stulti et insani qui presentia bona perdunt et invisibilia ac futura sibi promittunt.’6 Among these Hercules seems to rage because those who throw oV mundane things out of love for eternal things seem to be insane in our eyes. Whence Father Augustine: ‘It is necessary that they who lose present goods and dedicate themselves to invisible and future goods endure the scorn of the impious and those unlike them and be despised as foolish and insane.’
The slaying of Megara is, therefore, extolled as a victory of the soul over the Xesh, while Hercules’ three sons are murdered because they symbolize irascibility, sensuality, and concupiscence. However, more or less concurrent with the tradition of Hercules moralizatus was the so-called Hercules furens tradition, which, in contrast to the former, centred precisely on the inconsistencies and darkest recesses of the myth, on the hero as raving misWt and murderer. In his study of ‘The Madness of Hercules and the Elizabethans’, Rolf Soellner reveals that the Hercules furens tradition is an amalgamated tradition and by no means the preserve of tragedy: ‘The tradition of the mad Hercules as it evolved from the ancients to the Renaissance is a peculiar compound. While Seneca’s Hercules furens was its center, various theories and explanations arose, partly around 6 Salutati, De Laboribus Herculis, in Ullman (1951), ii. 596–7.
96
A peculiar compound
it, partly independent of it, strangely blending literary, medical, philosophical, and popular ideas.’7 The hero of the Hercules furens tradition, in its popular and generic sense, is indeed a remarkably composite character, a character ‘importantly, but not exclusively, Senecan in shape’.8 There is, for example, the melancholic genius who gives rise to the proverbial morbus Herculanus; the histrionic Hercules, comically blustering exponent of English Seneca; and a Hercules Oetaeus maddened by the blood of Nessus. Layered on top of this composite tradition are a number of distinct motifs derived from Seneca’s Hercules Furens.
M OR BUS HE RCULANUS: T H E M E L A N C H O L I C H E RO In Renaissance popular imagination Hercules furens was identiWed with a particular medical condition which, in turn, was associated with madness. He was the archetypal melancholic hero. As with Renaissance Hercules in general, the pathological diagnosis of Herculean furor did not originate in the Renaissance but was actually a continuation and synthesis of ancient thinking. One of the central tenets of the Hippocratic Corpus9 is a theory based on the four humours: blood, yellow bile, phlegm, and black bile (respectively linked to the qualities of heat, cold, moisture, and dryness), and, although the Corpus contains no systematic discussion of melancholia, it does identify melancholia (along with haemorrhoids, dysentery, and skin eruptions) as a disease caused by an excess of black bile. In the treatise De Morbo Sacro, humoral theory is applied to epilepsy, which is pronounced a natural, not a ‘sacred’ disease. An epileptic Wt is said to occur when a surplus of cold phlegm from the brain Xows into the warm blood in the veins. The suVerer loses his speech and foams at the mouth, his hands are contracted, and the eyes contorted. In De Morbis Mulierum (1. 7) the term ˙æ ŒºØ appears as an 7 Soellner (1958), 309–24, at 314. 8 Miola (1992), 124. 9 The Hippocratic Corpus consists of some 60 medical treatises collected under Hippocrates’ name. The majority of these are dated to the later decades of the Wfth century bc or early decades of the fourth century.
A peculiar compound
97
eponym of epilepsy, reXecting a common belief that Herakles suVered from the disease.10 Euripides contributed, in no small part, to the dissemination of this belief. For, while he avoids any medical rationalization of the madness and emphatically presents the hero’s aZiction as an external and temporary condition senselessly inXicted by vengeful gods, the physiognomy and symptoms, such as ØÆæ (or rolling of eyes), which he gives the demented Herakles closely resemble a clinical description of an epileptic Wt: K æÆEØ O ø KŁÆæ ÞÆ K ZØ ÆNÆH Æ KŒÆºg Iæe ŒÆÆ hæØ ªØ . (932–4) His face contorted, he rolled his eyes so that their bloodshot roots protruded and froth dripped down his Wne-bearded chin.
Barlow has noted the similarities between this account and the Hippocratic symptomatology of epilepsy in De Morbo Sacro (7).11 Von Staden, however, sees these correspondences as limited. He insists that they ‘could equally well be read as instances of Euripides’ deployment of tragic topoi used to describe pathological mental conditions’,12 and he cites examples from other Euripidean tragedies where one or more of these symptoms occur. Yet in the Herakles it is the presence of all these symptoms in the one character that is remarkable. In the Problemata Physica, which were ascribed to Aristotle and as such enjoyed considerable fame during the Renaissance, Herakles is held to be the epitome of melancholic genius, in support of the assumption that brilliance and achievement are always associated with black bile: ˜Øa
‹Ø æØd ªªÆØ ¼æ j ŒÆa ØºÆ j ºØØŒc j Ø j Æ ÆÆØ ºÆªºØŒd Z; ŒÆd ƒ b oø u ŒÆd
10 ˙æ ŒºØ and Herculanus or Herculeus morbus are regularly listed in proverb anthologies. See Dicaearchus, quoted by Zenobius 4. 26; Diogenianus 5. 8; Apostolius 8. 64; Pseudo-Plutarch, Proverbia Alexandrinorum 36. 11 See Barlow (1996), 166, on 933–5. 12 Von Staden (1992), 131–50, at 139.
98
A peculiar compound
ºÆ ŁÆØ E I e ºÆ ºB IææøÆØ; x ºªÆØ H æøœŒH a æd e ˙æÆŒºÆ; ŒÆd ªaæ KŒE ØŒ ªŁÆØ Æ B ø; Øe ŒÆd a IææøÆÆ H K غ ØŒH I KŒı æªæı ƒ IæÆEØ ƒæa : ŒÆd æd f ÆEÆ ŒÆØ ŒÆd æe B IÆø K ˇYfi H ºŒH ŒıØ ª F ºE· ŒÆd ªaæ F ªÆØ ººE I e ºÆ ºB. (30. 935a) Why is it that all men who are outstanding in philosophy, politics, poetry, or the arts are melancholic, and some to such an extent that they are infected by the diseases arising from black bile, as the story of Herakles among the heroes tells? For Herakles seems to have been of this character, so that the ancients called the disease of epilepsy the ‘sacred disease’ after him. This is proved by his frenzy towards his children and the eruption of sores which occurred before his disappearance on Mount Oeta; for this is a common aVection among those who suVer from black bile.
This passage demonstrates how Hippocratic humoral theory shaped non-medical as well as medical views of melancholy. Herakles is here stated to have suVered from two speciWc melancholic diseases, epilepsy during the murder of his family, and dermatological eruptions while on Mount Oeta. The author of the Problemata is thus attributing the two explosions of Herculean furor, familiar from tragedy, to the same source, and, in line with Hippocratic thinking, reasoning the madness in physiological rather than supernatural terms.13 Humoral theory provided a general model for European conceptions of disease and illness, and indeed the diagnosis and prognosis of mental disorders, up to the seventeenth century.14 Certainly the Renaissance understanding of madness, including Herculean furor, was greatly inXuenced by the humoral and corporeal discourses on the subject found in Hippocratic, Galenic, and Aristotelian texts. In his notes to Act 4 of Hercules Furens, Thomas Farnaby, the Wrst English editor of Seneca’s tragedies, deWned the furor as wild delirium 13 IdentiWcation of certain states of melancholy with madness was common among the ancients. In Tusculanae Disputationes (3. 5. 11), Cicero, having seen ºÆªºÆ so often associated with temporary insanity, assumes that the Greek term is equivalent to the Latin furor: ‘Graeci autem manı´an unde appellent, non facile dixerim; eam tamen ipsam distinguimus nos melius quam illi. Hanc enim insaniam, quae iuncta stultitiae patet latius a furore disiungimus. Graeci volunt illi quidem, sed parum valent verbo: quem nos furorem, melagcolı´an illi vocant.’ 14 On Renaissance conceptions and deWnitions of madness, see Salkeld (1993), esp. 7–33, and Neely (2004), esp. 1–26.
A peculiar compound
99
and melancholy. Hercules’ sensation of darkness at 939 V., he reasoned, was caused by excretions of black bile rising from the stomach to the brain: ‘Veluti caligant oculi a sublato de ventriculo vapore: ita ubi halitus turbidi ab atra bile sursum feruntur concipiunturque in cerebri venis, imaginatio laeditur unde falso iudicant sensationes: & insequitur ŁæØ ÆæÆæıc & ºÆªºÆ, quae tamen summis ingeniis plerunque accidit. sic Herculi coelum falsum.’15 Hercules must fall asleep, Farnaby continued, and exhale the black humour before his furor can subside: ‘Ita quamvis Herculis ºÆªºØŒe
Ł somno mulceatur ac sedetur non tamen plane atrum atque acrem humorem exspiravit.’ Like the eponymous ˙æ ŒºØ in the ancient world, morbus Herculanus (and its variants) became during the Renaissance a proverb for epilepsy or ‘the falling sickness’, and, as such, was lexicographically enshrined. Soellner notes that the term ‘was regularly listed in Renaissance Latin dictionaries and explained in standard reference works’.16 Erasmus accepted the term Herculanus morbus in his Adagia (2.4.27), adding an explanatory essay in which (like Seneca) he gave a human as well as divine reason for Hercules’ aZiction: the strain of the twelve labours added to the threats of Juno. Thomas Cooper’s Thesaurus Linguae Romanae et Britannicae (1563) and Thomas Thomas’s Dictionarium (1596) both list ‘Herculanus morbus’ as ‘The Falling Sickness’. In Book 7, Chapter 10 (‘De epilencia vel de morbo caduco’) of Bartholomaeus Anglicus’ De Proprietatibus Rerum, one of the great encyclopedias of the High Middle Ages, it is claimed that epilepsy is named ‘morbus Herculeus’ because the disease ‘is strong as Hercules was’. This encyclopedia of natural science helped to codify and formalize humoral theory, and it is worth noting that Batman’s 1582 English translation of De Proprietatibus Rerum has often been referred to as ‘Shakespeare’s Encyclopaedia’. The identiWcation of Hercules with epilepsy was not conWned to medical and encyclopedic texts. The furor displayed by at least two Herculean heroes in Elizabethan drama is diagnosed as the falling sickness. As Iago’s insinuations of Desdemona’s unfaithfulness take their toll, Shakespeare’s Othello suVers a complete physical and emotional collapse. He trembles and raves at the ‘ocular proof ’ of 15 Farnaby (1613), 39.
16 Soellner (1958), 309–24, at 314.
100
A peculiar compound
Desdemona’s lost handkerchief, before falling into what the stage directions describe as a ‘trance’. When Cassio appears on the scene, Iago explains: My lord is fallen into an epilepsy; This is his second Wt, he had one yesterday. . . . The lethargy must have his quiet course, If not, he foams at mouth, and by and by Breaks out to savage madness. (iv. i. 50–1, 53–5)
John Marston’s melancholic hero Antonio appears to be an amalgam of Seneca’s Hercules furens and Hercules Oetaeus. He is given to extravagant outbursts of grief and rage, which are frequently pathological in nature: antonio [aside] O how impatience cramps my cracke`d veins, And curdles thick my blood with boiling rage! O eyes, why leap you not like thunderbolts Or cannon-bullets in my rival’s face? Ohime` infelice misero, o lamentevol fato! [He falls to the ground] alberto What means the lady fall upon the ground? rosaline Belike the falling sickness. (Antonio and Mellida, ii. i. 195–201)
In his passion he resembles Hercules with the shirt of Nessus upon him: A sudden horror doth invade my blood; My sinews tremble, and my panting heart Scuds round about my bosom to go out, Dreading the assailant, horrid passion. (iv. i. 278–81)
Antonio himself makes the Herculean comparison explicit: Behold a prostrate wretch laid on his tomb; His epitaph thus: Ne plus ultra.17 Ho! Let none out-woe me; mine’s Herculean woe. (Antonio’s Revenge, ii. ii. 132–4) 17 ‘Ne plus ultra’ is the motto purportedly inscribed on the Pillars of Hercules, the limits of the classical known world.
A peculiar compound
101
‘Quite possibly’, Soellner surmises, ‘Marston used ‘‘Herculean woe’’ in the sense of ‘‘morbus Herculanus’’ and as equivalent to ‘‘falling sickness’’.’18
‘ERCLES’ VEIN’: THE HAM ACTOR In An Apology for Actors (1612), a spirited defence of the theatre against Puritan attacks, Thomas Heywood (1573–1641)19 records a strange, improbable story about the histrionic exploits of Julius Caesar. Towards the end of the second book, entitled ‘Of Actors and their ancient Dignitie’, he says: Iulius Caesar himselfe for his pleasure became an Actor, being in shape, state, voyce, iudgement, and all other occurrents, exterior, and interior excellent. Amongst many other parts acted by him in person, it is recorded of him, that with general applause in his owne Theater he played Hercules Furens, and amongst many other arguments for his compleatnesse, excellence, and extraordinary care in his action, it is thus reported of him. Being in the depth of a passion, one of his servants (as his part then fell out) presenting Lychas, who before had from Deianeira brought him the poysoned shirt, dipt in the bloud of the Centaure Nessus: he in the middest of his torture and fury, Wnding this Lychas hid in a remote corner (appointed him to creep into of purpose) although he was, as our tragedians use, but seemingly to kill him by some false imagined wound, yet was Caesar so extremely carryed away with the violence of his practised fury, and by the perfect shape of the madnesse of Hercules to which he had fashioned all his native spirits, that he slew him dead at his foot, and after swoong him terque quaterque (as the Poet sayes)20 about his head.21
The Hercules Furens which Julius Caesar is claimed to have performed is notably not the story dramatized by Euripides and Seneca, 18 Soellner (1958), 309–24, at 320. 19 A possible relation of Jasper Heywood’s (translator of Seneca’s Hercules Furens), but little is certain about his birth, family background, or formative years. Clark (1931) remains the authoritative source for information about Heywood’s life and canon. Other biographical and critical studies of the dramatist include Cromwell (1928), Boas (1950), Grivelet (1957), and Baines (1984). 20 The phrase ‘terque quaterque’ is taken from Ovid, Met. 9. 217. 21 Heywood (1612; repr. 1973), E3˘.
102
A peculiar compound
but a version, after Ovid, of the madness of Hercules Oetaeus—a version which Heywood himself adapted for the stage (see below). But the real signiWcance of this curious anecdote lies not in what it reveals about alternative traditions of Hercules’ madness or about Julius Caesar, who is unlikely to have ever indulged in Herculean impersonation on stage in the fashion of the aesthetic Nero. Rather, it lies in the revelation of a particular theatrical tradition of Hercules furens in the Renaissance, a tradition synonymous with frenzied overacting. The Roman grammarian and philosopher Macrobius had recorded a similar tale, which was well known in the Renaissance, about the pantomime dancer Pylades of Cilicia being transported to risible extremes of simulated rage in his portrayal of Herakles mainomenos: Cum in Herculem furentem prodisset et non nullis incessum histrioni convenientem non servare videretur, deposita persona ridentes increpuit: øæ; ÆØ OæFÆØ. hac fabula et sagittas iecit in populum.22 (Saturnalia 2. 7. 16–17) When he had come on to dance The Madness of Hercules, some of the spectators thought that he was not keeping to action suited to the stage. Whereupon he took oV his mask and rebuked those laughing at him with the words: ‘Fools, my dancing is intended to represent a madman.’ It was in this play too that he shot arrows at the spectators.
Thus, in his reference to Caesar being ‘carryed away with the violence of his practised fury’, Heywood is continuing an ancient tradition about a furious stage Hercules. In his refutation of Heywood’s Apology, the critic I.G. (John Greene), far from disputing the veracity of the Caesarean anecdote, uses the probability of such a spectacle repeating itself as an indictment of actors’ ‘ancient and moderne indignity’ and of the theatre as a ‘heathenish and diabolicall institution’: ‘Next doth M. Actor recite a memorable example of Iulius Caesar, that slew his own servant whiles he acted Hercules furens on the Stage. Which example indeed greatly doth make against their Playes. For it’s not unlikely but a Player might doe the like now, as 22 Lucian (Salt. 83) tells a similar story of a pantomimus who overacted the part of ‘mad Ajax’: he tore the clothes of one of the scabillarii, snatched a Xute from an instrumentalist, and with it struck the actor playing Odysseus a near-fatal blow.
A peculiar compound
103
often they have done. And then what a lamentable project would there be for the Spectators to behold.’23 The most egregious exponent of the Herculean acting tradition is Nick Bottom in Shakespeare’s A Midsummer Night’s Dream. A brawny, conceited, and mock-heroic character, he is the incarnation of overconWdent, overzealous, and overblown theatrical amateurism.24 When he is allotted the part of Pyramus in the Mechanicals’ production of ‘The most lamentable comedy, and most cruel death of Pyramus and Thisby’ (a show of ‘exaggerated Senecanism’25), he announces to the director Peter Quince, ‘my chief humour is for a tyrant. I could play Ercles rarely, or a part to tear a cat in, to make all split’ (i. ii. 25–6).26 He then proceeds to give an impromptu audition in ‘Ercles’ vein’ (i. ii. 37): The raging rocks, And shivering shocks, Shall break the locks Of prison-gates; And Phibbus’ car Shall shine from far And make and mar The foolish fates.
‘As the tyrant Ercles,’ Miola observes, ‘Bottom swaggers in a bombastic style, replete with pompous diction, alliterative thunderclap, animated naturalism, and cosmic magniloquence.’27 The satirical target of his ‘lofty’ Herculean improvisation has been supposed by 23 Greene (1615; repr. 1973), 28. 24 Actors throughout the years have enjoyed playing up Bottom’s self-conceit and theatrical amateurism. Among 20th-century interpreters of the role, comedian Frankie Howerd was praised for his ‘glorious representation of that universal type, the over-conWdent amateur whom friends and relations have encouraged to believe himself a Roscius’ (Daily Telegraph, 27 Jan. 1958), while Pete Postlethwaite’s performance captured the full ghastliness of ‘the amateur dramatic society bore’ (Jewish Chronicle, 25 July 1986). See GriYths (1996), 104–5. 25 Miola (1992), 186. Brooks (1979), pp. lxii–lxiii, believes Seneca is a major neglected source of A Midsummer Night’s Dream, and supports his argument with a number of parallel passages. 26 I quote Shakespeare, including line numbers, from the Arden Shakespeare Complete Works (1998). 27 Miola (1992), 181.
104
A peculiar compound
several scholars to be John Studley’s translation of Seneca’s Hercules Oetaeus (1581), with speciWc reference to two separate passages:28 O Lorde of ghostes! whose fyrye Xashe That forth thy hande doth shake, Doth cause the trembling lodges twayne, Of Phœbus’ carre to shake. Raygne reachlesse nowe: in every place Thy peace procurde I have, AloVe where Nereus lookes up lande, Empalde in winding wave. The roring rocks have quaking sturd, And none thereat have pusht; Hell gloummy gates I have brast oape, Where grisly ghosts all husht Have stood.29
However, David P. Young and John Velz have separately raised the alternative possibility that Bottom’s alliterative rant is a travesty of certain lines of Seneca’s Hercules Furens in Jasper Heywood’s translation of 1561.30 Whatever the intended literary target, this specimen of ‘Ercles’ vein’ alludes to more than the worst faults of ‘English Seneca’. In his portrayal of Bottom, Shakespeare is invoking what is obviously a familiar dramatic type. The Herculean hero was well known to Elizabethan audiences from Christopher Marlowe’s enormously popular Tamburlaine, the Great,31 and they would have immediately identiWed in Bottom (a role probably created by the legendary clown William Kempe) a parody of the grandiose acting style of Edward Alleyn, Marlowe’s original Tamburlaine.32 In his Groatsworth of Wit (1592) Robert Greene ridiculed the trend of Herculean grandiloquence in contemporary theatre. His Player-Patron, supplying 28 The suggestion was Wrst put forward by Rolfe (1879), 133. See also Koeppel (1911), 190–1. 29 Quoted in Rolfe (1879), 133. 30 See Young (1966), 35 f. and Velz (1968), 376. 31 See below, Chap. 4. 32 The character of the cowardly braggart Pistol in 2 Henry IV also parodies Alleyn’s tragic style. For the connection between Alleyn and Shakespeare, and between the diVerent companies performing in the 1590s, see Southworth (2000).
A peculiar compound
105
a resume´ of his stage experience, boasts to Roberto: ‘The Twelve Labours of Hercules have I terribly thundered on the stage.’33 Bottom is also a burlesque of recognizable Herculean characteristics, in particular the Herculean style of selfhood. This burlesque draws on a number of diVerent versions of the Hercules myth, including the Madness. In fact, throughout A Midsummer Night’s Dream mad transformation and transforming madness are powerful motifs. Bottom himself undergoes a famous metamorphosis of self, an ‘assiWcation’,34 which is followed by a restorative sleep and confused awakening. He, therefore, perfectly illustrates the ‘peculiar compound’35 that is the Hercules furens tradition. A Midsummer Night’s Dream is not the only play in the Shakespearean canon in which we Wnd Hercules furens invoked as a theatrical cliche´, a byword for ludicrous declamation and shameless ‘hamming’. In Antony and Cleopatra, the Egyptian queen mocks her Roman lover for playing admirably the role of his enraged ancestor, a role clearly reckoned to invite histrionic bluster: antony You’ll heat my blood. No more. cleopatra You can do better yet; but this is meetly. antony Now by my sword— cleopatra And target. Still he mends, But this is not the best. Look, prithee, Charmian, How this Herculean Roman does become The carriage of his chafe.36 (i. iii. 81–6)
‘Cleopatra’, Waith perceives, ‘both accentuates and modiWes what is Herculean in Antony. Like Caesar, she admires the man of valour and noble rage, but she also encourages his carousals.’37 Her taunting invocation here of a tragicomic Hercules reinforces the ambivalence and inconstancy38 of Antony’s Herculean role-playing. Antony the colossus, the ‘demi-Atlas of this earth’ (i. v. 24), emulates the semi-divine, 33 Carroll (1994), 69. 34 On Bottom’s ‘translation’, see Kott (1987), 73–85. 35 Soellner (1958), 309–24, at 314. 36 ‘The carriage of his chafe’ ¼ ‘the bearing or demeanour of his fury’. 37 Waith (1962), 120. 38 On Antony’s ambivalence and deliberate inconstancy, his refusal to tie ‘himself to a single consistent and predictable self ’, see Miles (1996), 175–85.
106
A peculiar compound
world-conquering Hercules, but Antony the maverick warrior and debauchee ‘looks like a good example on the stage of life of the braggart sham-Herakles of comedy’.39
THE MADNESS OF HERCULES O E TA E U S Thomas Heywood was apparently the only writer of the English Renaissance to put Hercules furens on stage,40 but, as mentioned, the furor he dramatized was Hercules’ death agony on Mount Oeta. His furious Hercules is not the Euripidean or Senecan Wlicide but the slayer of Lichas, the messenger who brought Hercules the poisoned shirt of Nessus from Deianira. Hercules’ Wnal tribulation and death were familiar to the Elizabethans and Jacobeans more from Ovid’s Metamorphoses 9 than from Seneca’s Hercules Oetaeus (considered as genuinely Senecan throughout the Renaissance). Ovid describes Hercules, with the fatal mantle upon him, as raging like a bull that bears a hunting-spear deep in its side. His blood bubbles and hisses, dark perspiration streams from every pore, his scorching sinews crackle, and his marrow melts. He roars at the mountain and brings great pines crashing down. As he catches sight of Lichas, his pain mounts up to madness: ‘utque dolor rabiem conlegerat omnem’ (9.212). This verse is the likely source of Thomas Heywood’s depiction of Hercules’ excruciating pain as a type of madness in The Brazen Age, containing The Labours and death of Hercules, the second of his four Ages which were successfully staged at the Red Bull during Shakespeare’s last few years in the London theatre (c.1611–13).41 As Ewbank comments: 39 Galinsky (1972), 141. On the importance of the comic Hercules to the ambivalent portrayal of Antony, see also Miola (1992), 130. 40 Listed under 1595 in the Annals of English Drama 975–1700 are two anonymous lost plays, I Hercules and II Hercules, under the auspices of the Admiral’s Men (see Harbage (1989, 3rd edn.), 64–5). Listed under 1561, together with Jasper Heywood’s translation of Hercules Furens, is Queen Elizabeth I’s fragmentary MS translation of Seneca’s Hercules Oetaeus (ibid. 38–9). This is a free translation of the second chorus, although the Wrst 31 lines have no parallel in the Latin. Horace Walpole transcribed the piece in 1806, and identiWed it as Elizabeth’s work: see Share (1998), 69–72. 41 Heywood Wrst put the Lichas episode into verse in his Troia Britannica (1602?), a poetic tale based largely on William Caxton’s version of Raoul Le Fe`vre’s Recueil des hystoires de Troyes (pub. 1467).
A peculiar compound
107
These Ages were an enterprise aiming even more ambitiously, and at greater length, than John Barton’s Tantalus, to put all Greek myth on stage, beginning in The Golden Age with ‘The Lives of Jupiter and Saturn’ and ending with the death of everyone except Ulysses at the end of The Iron Age—which Age had gone down so well as to prompt a Second Part (like a kind of Godfather Two). Not driven by a Shakespearian, or Bartonesque, urge to work out an idea or a theme, Heywood simply packs everything in to provide entertainment for a popular London audience.42
Perhaps because of this sweeping popular treatment, Heywood’s Hercules comes across as an uncouth strongman and inveterate braggart. The sound and fury of his ‘fustian heroism’43 led Galinsky to pronounce The Brazen Age ‘in all essentials the dramatization of a mythological comic strip’ and ‘the nadir of the Herakles tradition in literature’.44 Yet, while little case can be made for its literary merit, The Brazen Age is an important link in the Hercules furens tradition and in the Renaissance conception of the Herculean hero. Heywood’s version of Hercules’ Oetaean ravings represents an unusual intersection of Ovidian and Senecan threads. When Heywood’s Hercules puts on the poisoned shirt, his increasing physical anguish recalls the onset of the madness in Seneca’s Hercules Furens (939 V.). His whole countenance changes and his intense fury expresses itself in extravagant and impious threats of violence against Jupiter and the heavens: herc. Are all the furies with their tortures, Their whips and lashes crept into my skin? Hath any sightlesse and infernall Wre Laid hold upon my Xesh? when did Alcides Thus shake with anguish? thus change face, thus shrinke? . . . jason What alteration’s this? a thousand pangues I see even in his visage, in his silence He doth expresse even hell. priest Thou sacred Jove Behold us at thy Altar prostrate here 42 Ewbank (2005), 37–52, at 44. 44 Ibid. 232.
43 Galinsky (1972), 231.
108
A peculiar compound
To beg attonement ’tweene our sins and thee, Lend us a gracious eare and eye. herc. Priest no more, I’le rend thy Typet, hurle Joves Altars downe, Havock his OVerings, all his Lamps extinguish, Raze his high Temples, and skale heaven it selfe Unlesse he stay my tortures. jason Warlike Theban, Whence comes this fury? is this madnes forc’t, That makes Alcides thus blaspheme the Gods. tell. Patient your selfe. herc. I will not Jason, cannot Tellamon, A stipticke poyson boyles within my veines, Hell is within me, for my marrow fries, A vulture worse then that Prometheus feeles, Fiers on my entrails, and my bulke in Xames. jason Yet be your selfe, renowned Hercules, Strive with your torture, with your rage contend Seek to ore-come this anguish. . . . omp. What strange fury Hath late possest him to be thus disturb’d?45
The reactions of the onlookers to Hercules’ rage are a further evocation of Seneca’s hero. Jason and Tellamon, recalling Seneca’s Amphitryon at 952 (‘Quod subitum hoc malum est?’), diagnose Hercules’ condition as a sudden loss or transformation of self (‘What alteration’s this?’, ‘Patient your selfe’, ‘Yet be your selfe’), while Omphale speaks of a kind of demonic possession. In Ovid, Lichas is the haplessly convenient victim of Hercules’ wrath, in the wrong place at the wrong time. Heywood’s tortured Hercules, however, does not merely catch sight of Lichas, he hunts the messenger down, and the murder is preceded by a particularly bloodthirsty Xow of rhetoric: Lychas, where’s he that brought this poyson’d shirt, That I may teare the villaine lim from lim, And shake his body small as Winters snow, His shattered Xesh shall play like parched leaves, And dance in th’ aire, tost by the sommer winds.46 45 Heywood (1874), iii. 249–50.
46 Ibid. 251.
A peculiar compound
109
Returning to Ovid’s account, Heywood has Hercules swing Lichas about his head and hurl him into the Euboean Sea. The Argonauts again interpret his actions as madness, a frenzy surpassing physical trauma and confounding the physician’s skill: jason Princes, his torments are ’bove Physicke helpe, And they that wish him well, must wish his death, For that alone gives period to his anguish. tell. In vaine we follow and pursue his rage, There’s danger in his madnesse.47
Unlike Ovid, who immediately follows the slaying of Lichas with Hercules’ construction of his own funeral pyre, Heywood attributes a second murder to Hercules’ furor on Mount Oeta, that of the Lydian queen Omphale whom Hercules mistakes for Deianira. This case of mistaken identity leading to violent death places Heywood’s Hercules in the tradition of Euripides and Seneca’s deluded killer. The connection between the hero’s unbalanced state of mind and his homicidal behaviour is underlined by Hercules’ self-diagnosis. Before fatally striking Omphale with a rock, he cries: Art thou not Deyaneira come to mocke Alcides madnesse, and his pangues deride?48
This self-diagnosis of madness distinguishes Heywood’s Hercules from the hero of the Senecan Hercules Oetaeus, who expressly contradicts the opinion of the bystanders that he has again succumbed to madness: ‘Resistite’ inquit, ‘non furor mentem abstulit, furore gravius istud atque ira malum est: in me iuvat saevire.’ (823–5) ‘Wait!’ he said. ‘Madness has not stolen away my senses, this evil is deeper than madness or wrath: it delights to rage against me.’
Heywood was not the Wrst post-Ovidian writer to associate the events on Mount Oeta with Herculean furor. In the Carolingian poem Contra iudices, Theodulf of Orle´ans explicitly links the brutal and 47 Ibid. 252.
48 Ibid. 253.
110
A peculiar compound
entirely unjust murder of the ‘unfortunate Lichas’ (miseri Lichae) to ‘furor Herculeus’, the hero’s inability to govern his animal instincts. Theodulf reproduces from Metamorphoses 9 Hercules’ disregard for Lichas’ suppliant pleas for mercy, but he omits the climactic apotheosis which follows. Of Theodulf ’s anti-Herculean, anti-pagan exploitation of his ‘irreverent’ Ovidian model, Nees has remarked: ‘Surely it ought to be clear from his transformation of his literary sources that Theodulf does not intend this passage to convey a paean to Hercules as a personiWcation of virtue, but rather a warning against the dangers even to an otherwise virtuous man of the vices of anger and lust.’49 Among Heywood’s contemporaries and near-contemporaries, the Oetaean strand of the Hercules furens tradition was reasonably uncommon but not unique. The Renaissance mythographer Natalis Comes sees furor depicted in both of Seneca’s Hercules plays, that is, in Hercules’ Juno-inspired Wlicidal frenzy and in his Nessusinduced rage on Oeta.50 In Antony and Cleopatra, which was probably staged about Wve years before The Brazen Age, the Wgure of Hercules Oetaeus is clearly part of Shakespeare’s grammar of furor.51 Enraged at what he believes is Cleopatra’s treachery, her capitulation to Caesar at Actium, Antony invokes and emulates the furor of his divine ancestor Hercules:52 Better ’twere Thou fell’st into my fury, for one death Might have prevented many. Eros, ho! The shirt of Nessus is upon me. Teach me Alcides, thou mine ancestor, thy rage; Let me lodge Lichas on the horns o’th’ moon, And with those hands that grasped the heaviest club Subdue my worthiest self. The witch shall die. (iv. xii. 40–7)
49 Nees (1991), 31. 50 See Mythologiae (1567; repr. 1976), 203ˇ, 208. 51 The Hercules–Cacus episode in Aeneid 8. 193 V. (see above, Chap. 2) undoubtedly also forms part of the Shakespearean grammar of furor. 52 While Antony and Cleopatra as a whole is something other than the tragedy of a Herculean hero, it nevertheless contains a major treatment of the type. See Waith (1962), 113–21.
A peculiar compound
111
Antony blames his downfall and imminent death on female perWdy, a ‘Triple-turned whore’ (iv. ii. 13), thus missing the irony of Deianira’s innocence.
THE SENECAN TRADITION A signiWcant component of the Hercules furens tradition in the Renaissance was, of course, a more direct engagement with Seneca’s Hercules Furens. This was evidenced by the appearance in England and on the Continent of translations of the text and by the undoubted impact of such translations on the more creative appropriation of the Senecan Hercules. The Wrst English translation of certain date and identity53 was by Jasper Heywood in 1561. Heywood was born in London in 1535, the son of the epigrammatist John Heywood (c.1497–1580). Related on his mother’s side to Thomas More, he was also the uncle of John Donne. A Catholic, he Xed England on the accession of Elizabeth, but returned in 1581 as head of the Jesuit mission. After arrest and imprisonment he was exiled, and died in Naples in 1598.54 Hercules Furens was Heywood’s third and Wnal translation of Seneca: his Troas was printed in 1559 and Thyestes in 1560.55 In 1581 all three translations were reprinted as the nucleus of Thomas Newton’s The Tenne Tragedies of Seneca. C. S. Lewis, cataloguing the manifold faults of ‘Drab Age Verse’, described this collection of English Seneca as ‘execrable: the metre a torment to the ear, the language at once artless and unnatural’.56 T. S. Eliot oVered a kinder assessment in his essay ‘Seneca in Elizabethan Translation’, which introduced the 1927 reissue of Newton’s edition: ‘If we look at the dates we cannot overlook the probability that these translations helped to direct the course of events. . . . It is not only as an embryonic 53 Harbage (1989), 209 includes in a supplementary list an extant anonymous translation of Hercules Furens, which probably dates from the late 17th century. 54 Herbermann et al. (1910), vii. 319. See also Reed (1926), 66–7 and 90; Southern (1950), 56; and Share (1998), 12. 55 Heywood’s Troas, Thyestes, and Hercules Furens were edited by Vocht (1913). See also Spearing (1912). For an analysis of the three translations, see O’Keefe (1974). 56 Lewis (1954), 256.
112
A peculiar compound
form of Elizabethan tragedy that these translations have documentary interest. They represent the transformation of the older form of versiWcation into the new—consequently the transformation of language and sensibility as well.’57 Of the Wve translators who contributed to the collection, Heywood is generally acknowledged as the most proWcient. What is interesting about his Senecan translations as a group or series is that, like Robert Browning’s trio of major transcriptions from Greek tragedy (Euripides’ Alkestis and Herakles, and Aeschylus’ Agamemnon), published in the 1870s,58 each one employs a distinct translational technique, ranging from free and interpretative adaptation to determined literalism. Lewis styled this progression a movement ‘from a medieval to a humanistic conception of his task’ as translator.59 In the second act of Troas Heywood introduces the ghost of Achilles (‘the Wrst vengeful ghost of Tudor revenge tragedy’60), and substitutes for the geographically baZing third chorus another which is partly a translation of a chorus in Phaedra. For the Thyestes he invented a prologue in which he asks the Fury of Seneca’s Wrst scene for inspiration. Heywood’s Hercules Furens was his most literal translation and appeared side by side with the Latin, in what Lewis called ‘an eclectic text of his own manufacture’.61 As with his earlier translations, and all but one of the translations in Newton’s Tenne Tragedies, it was composed in ‘fourteeners’, the fourteen-syllable line of seven iambic feet. The title-page read: ‘The Wrst tragedie of Lucius Anneus Seneca, intituled Hercules furens, newly perused and of all faultes whereof it did before abound diligently corrected, and for the proWt of young schollers so faithfully translated into English metre, that ye may se verse for verse tourned as farre as the phrase of the english permitteth by Iasper Heywood studient in Oxford.’62 Heywood’s conWdent precursory deWnition of faithfulness, his objective of rendering the original text ‘verse for verse . . . as farre as the phrase of the english permitteth’, anticipates Browning’s defence of literalism in the preface to his Agamemnon in 1877: ‘If, because of the immense fame of the following Tragedy, I wished to acquaint myself with it, and could only do so by the help of a translator, I should require him to be 57 Eliot (1951), 98, 101. 59 Lewis (1954), 254. 61 Lewis (1954), 255.
58 See below, Chap. 6. 60 See Kerrigan (1996), 112–13. 62 Heywood (1561), sig. A.
A peculiar compound
113
literal at every cost save that of absolute violence to our language. . . . I would be tolerant for once,—in the case of so immediately famous an original,—of even a clumsy attempt to furnish me with the very turn of each phrase in as Greek a fashion as English will bear.’63 In practice, Heywood’s translation of Hercules Furens is generally free of tautology and embellishment. He preserves closely the original word-order, although sometimes too laboriously, a fault compounded by the occasional infelicitous choice of word. His rendering of lines 937–44 (the onset of Hercules’ madness) and 1138–42 (Hercules’ awakening) are illustrative of his technique: But yf to lyght some other mischiefe bryng The grownde yet shall, let it make haste: and any monstrous thyng If it prepare, let yt bee myne. but what means this? myd daye The darknes have encloasde abowt, lo Phoebus goethe his ways With face obscure without a clowde. who dryves the daye to Xyght, And turns to east? from whence doth now his dusky hed the nyght Unknown bryng forth? whence fyl the peaks so many rownde about Of datyme starres?64 What place is this? What region? or of the worlde what coaste? Where am I? under ryse of sanne? or bonde els uttermoste Of th’ycy bear? or els doothe here of sea of Hesperye The farthest grownde appoynte a bonde For th’ocean sea to lye? What ayre drawe me? to weery myght what grownde is undersette? Of truthe we are returnde from hell?65 63 Browning (1877), in Kenyon (1912), viii. 293–365, at 293. See further below, Chap. 6. 64 Heywood (1561), sigs I 6–7. 65 Ibid., sig. L 2.
114
A peculiar compound
At its best, Heywood’s literalism is allied with a certain amount of poetic instinct and sensitivity. Eliot made special mention of the ‘singular beauty’ of Heywood’s translation of 1131 V., lines addressed by the chorus to Hercules’ slain children: Ite ad Stygios, umbrae, portus ite, innocuae, quas in primo limine vitae scelus oppressit patriusque furor; ite, iratos visite reges. To Stygian havens goe ye of shade and night, goe hurtles souls, whom mischief hath opprest Even in Wrst porche of lyfe but lately hadde, And fathers furye goe unhappy kynde O litle chyldren, by the way full sadde Of journeye knowne. Goe, see the angrye kyngs.66
‘Nothing can be said of such a translation,’ Eliot declared, ‘except that it is perfect. It is a last echo of the earlier tongue, the language of Chaucer, with an overtone of that Christian piety which disappears with Elizabethan verse.’67 The following century, the Dutch poet and dramatist Joost van den Vondel (1587–1679), who published translations of Seneca’s Troades (1626) and Hippolytus (1628), made a prose version of Hercules Furens as a private exercise. His published translations of ancient tragedy also included Euripides’ Iphigenia in Tauris (1666) and Sophocles’ Trachiniae (1668). Renaissance France, meanwhile, witnessed a profusion of translations and adaptations of Seneca’s Hercules Furens, including those by Roland Brisset (1589), Pierre Mainfray (1625), Benoist Baudyn (1629), Maurice de Chalvet (1638), Nicolas L’He´ritier (whose Hercule furieux (1639) is also known by the title of Amphitrion), and Pierre Linage (1650). Like Heywood’s translation in England, these French versions contributed to a more popular awareness of Seneca’s play as well as to the invocation by dramatists of mad Hercules as a type of stage hero, and to a proliferation of original works incorporating ‘Furens’ in their titles. 66 Heywood (1561), sig. L.
67 Eliot (1951), 104.
A peculiar compound
115
Fig. 2. Alessandro Turchi, The Madness of Hercules (c.1620). Bayerische Staatsgema¨ldesammlungen, Alte Pinakothek, Munich.
While Hercules in bivio was a far more popular subject for Renaissance artists, Senecan Hercules inspired at least one seventeenthcentury painting, Alessandro Turchi’s The Madness of Hercules of c.1620 (Fig. 2). In its general composition and treatment the picture denotes the inXuence of Michelangelo, although the colour-scheme is Venetian. In the centre of the painting Hercules is depicted holding one of his children aloft and on the verge of hurling its helpless form to the ground. Another child lies dead at his feet, and behind him Megara, her remaining sons, and women of the household kneel, recoil, or scatter in terror. Senecan Hercules also found his way into Italian opera. During the wedding celebrations for Cosimo III de Medici and Marguerite Louise d’Orlea`ns in 1661, the Florentine court prepared a theatre festival dominated by the production of Jacopo Melani’s Ercole in
116
A peculiar compound
Tebe. As Blanshard wryly observes: ‘At Wrst sight, scenes of domestic violence make a strange choice for a wedding celebration, even if they are set to ballet music. Yet their use here provides a clear indication of the way in which these scenes were enjoyed for their dramatic potential far more than their content.’68 The title role was performed by the tenor Antonio Cesti, himself a celebrated composer of operas. The production inaugurated Florence’s beautifully restored Teatro della Pergola, and was especially notable for the emphasis it placed on the dance, including four end-of-act balli. During the Renaissance two distinct Herculean traditions arose concurrently. Both centred predominantly on the typological use of the hero. The more general and proliWc tradition established Hercules as the incarnation of active virtue, of reason, triumphant temperance, and eloquence. He became simultaneously an analogue of Christ’s Passion and Resurrection and an emblem of supreme humanist endeavour. However, the peculiarly composite Hercules furens tradition, and especially its morally challenging Senecan strain, held the greater literary potential and had arguably the greater creative impact. As Galinsky indicates, the appropriation of Seneca’s Hercules by Renaissance dramatists was not a case of ‘inventing modern adventures for [him] . . . and putting him into modern costume’. Writers ‘preferred to do without the physical appearance of Herakles and instead transfer some of his spiritual qualities to some other hero’.69 Thus, it is through characters such as Marlowe’s Tamburlaine or Shakespeare’s Macbeth and Coriolanus that Hercules furens Wnds a new and resonant theatrical voice. 68 Blanshard (2005), 59–60.
69 Galinsky (1972), 186.
4 ‘Even the earth is not room enough’: Herculean selfhood on the Elizabethan stage Immediately before his madness sets in, Seneca’s Hercules prays, si quod etiamnum est scelusjlatura tellus, properet, et si quod parat monstrum, meum sit (‘If the earth is even now to produce some wickedness, let it come quickly; if she is furnishing some monster, let it be mine’, 937–9). Later, with his reason restored, and having discovered for himself his identity as the murderer of his children, he says of his crime, laudanda feci iussus; hoc unum meum est (‘My praiseworthy deeds I did under orders; this alone is mine’, 1268). Both moments—one of hubristic triumph, the other suicidal despair—encapsulate the hero’s tragic autarkeia. For Hercules’ tragedy is that he remains to the very end a victim of his own unshakeable sense of selfhood and impenetrable isolation. The dramatization of these attributes is arguably Seneca’s greatest and darkest legacy to the Elizabethan theatre. While none of the major Elizabethan playwrights wrote a Hercules play based on the Euripidean-Senecan plot,1 Seneca’s tragic Hercules lies behind several of the most famous madmen and megalomaniacs of the Renaissance English stage, providing dramatists with ‘a rich and resonant grammar of furor, an essential and expressive code of thought and feeling’.2 The reasons for this have a great deal to do with the political and cultural aYnity between Julio-Claudian Rome and Tudor England, as Braden asserts: It is documentable that Renaissance tragedians were far more interested in their Roman than in their Athenian predecessors, and there are reasons for that beyond mere linguistic diYculties. An important part of what, at least 1 See Chap. 3, n. 40.
2 Miola (1992), 122.
118
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
in its usual deWnition, distinguished the Renaissance as a period is the newly imperial cast of its politics and the individualistic cosmopolitanism of its culture—and the style of unappeasably ambitious selfhood that becomes the central subject of Renaissance tragedy has, in general, more authentic aYnities with the nihilistic villains of Seneca’s universe than with their more temperate and socialized Greek antecedents.3
As we have seen, Seneca’s Hercules Furens is a mirror of the excesses of the late Julio-Claudian age. Its hero is a Wgure of tragically divided potential and with a fatal, all-consuming sense of selfhood. The furor he embodies from the outset is the obsessive, restless ambition of the imperial overreacher; the monster he becomes represents the perversion, through absolute power, of the competitive ethos, natural boundaries, heroic anger, and the bonds of kinship. For the Elizabethan tragedians this psychological portrait of power held enormous dramatic appeal, as did Seneca’s Weltanschauung pertaining to State and Cosmos. The Tudor monarchs, like the Julio-Claudian emperors, were a highly dysfunctional dynasty that wielded an unprecedented authority. Until the 1534 Act of Supremacy no English sovereign had been head of Church and State. The Royal Supremacy was the apotheosis of monarchy, making Henry VIII the ‘one supreme head and king’ of a body politic in which spirituality and temporality were indivisible concepts. He was the vicar of God and, in his own words, the ‘soul of the whole kingdom’, with the divine mission to ‘animate, rule and save’ his people.4 This destiny, Henry believed, showed him to be the legitimate inheritor of the authority of Rome’s emperors. With the establishment of a national Church of England, ‘a powerful new national epic’ was born, ‘telling how for generations England had groaned under the tyranny of the bishops of Rome; [how the popes had] usurped the authority of those to whom all obedience is due, God’s vicars on earth—Roman emperors and their successors, the princes of Christendom—how the hour had come to throw oV this usurpation . . . and restore the pristine right order’.5 3 Braden (1993), 245–64, at 257. 4 Foxe, Acts and Monuments in Pratt (1874), v. 535; ‘Treatise on Royal Power’ in Public Record OYce, State Papers 1/238, fol. 245. 5 Scarisbrick (1997), 386–7.
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
119
At the same time as this apotheosis occurred, a new idea of nationhood emerged which became inextricably interwoven with the Tudors’ extraordinary style of selfhood. As Guy indicates: ‘It is striking that, whereas in 1500 the word ‘‘state’’ had possessed no political meaning in English beyond the ‘‘state or condition’’ of the prince or the kingdom, by the second half of Elizabeth’s reign it was used to signify the ‘‘state’’ in the modern sense. In the reigns of Henry VII and Henry VIII politicians had spoken only of ‘‘country’’, ‘‘people’’, ‘‘kingdom’’, and ‘‘realm’’, but by the 1590s they began to conceptualize the ‘‘state’’.’6 The concept of the ‘state’, Guy continues, identiWed England as ‘a sovereign government which recognized no superior in political, ecclesiastical, and legal matters’.7 The implications of this identiWcation were ethnographic as much as political and religious. Henry’s anti-papal campaign and ‘imperial’ theory of kingship, and Elizabeth’s war with Spain sharpened the deWnition of ‘Englishness’. A vision of England as patria, and of her sovereign as an Augustan pater patriae, took shape. In the promotion as well as the analysis of this vision, the English language and the native literature were crucial. According to Braden, ‘Seneca presents us with a compelling version of classical man, exaggerated and simpliWed to reveal something of his essence. That in turn is what Renaissance writers see and respond to in Seneca.’8 In Seneca’s compelling version of the mad Hercules, Elizabethan dramatists saw and responded to the classical hero’s ambivalent essence, a greatness that is both magnetic and repellent. They saw reXected in this uncompromising Herculean heroism the danger facing their own society—that ‘such superhuman aspirations may tip over into amoral self-assertion’.9 Thus the archetypal Herculean hero of Renaissance English tragedy, Tamburlaine, is a celebration of the Herculean overreacher, but a celebration suVused with absolute awareness of the overreacher’s lethal menace. With Shakespeare the Herculean hero reaches an apex of psychological and moral complexity. His tragedies of madness and cataclysmic selfhood, which belong most securely to a Hercules furens tradition—Othello, Macbeth, Coriolanus, and King Lear—are, to borrow 6 Guy (1988), 352. 8 Braden (1985), 2.
7 Ibid. 9 Miles (1996), 61.
120
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
Braden’s phrase, the ultimate ‘magnifying lenses’10 for making sense of the Latin text and even, on occasion, the Greek text.
THE MAT TER OF SENECAN ‘INFLUENCE’ The inXuence of Seneca tragicus on the Elizabethan stage has become almost a scholarly commonplace; the critical quest to deWne its nature and extent has been an extremely proliWc endeavour.11 In 1893 John W. CunliVe produced a seminal thesis on the subject, in which he submitted as categorical proof of his assertion of inXuence a clinical itemization of verbal echoes and parallel passages. F. L. Lucas followed suit in 1922 with an equally categorical exposition of Senecan inXuence, which relied on an equally problematic investigative method. For many years after, Seneca’s impact, for better or worse, on the development of English tragedy remained undisputed, a ‘given’ of literary criticism. In addition to parallel passages, discussion of Senecan inXuence on Elizabethan playwrights centred on elements of formal imitation (the Wve-act structure, stichomythia, and stock characters); the borrowing of Senecan sententiae; and a shared fondness for the rhetorical, the melodramatic, the supernatural, and the gruesomely violent.12 The selection of these elements largely explains why even those critics who most ardently and conscientiously dissected Senecan inXuence rarely judged it a particularly positive thing. ‘Since the late eighteenth century,’ Braden records, ‘a belief in the manifest inferiority of Senecan drama has made that linkage [between Seneca and the Renaissance] seem an 10 Braden (1993), 245–64, at 257. 11 For an overview of the inXuence of Seneca on Renaissance English drama, see CunliVe (1893); Theobald (1909), 323–7; Charlton (1921), pp. cxxxviii–cc; Lucas (1922); Baker (1939); Wells (1944), 71–84; Johnson (1948), 33–53; Eliot (1951), 65–105 and 126–40; Hunter (1967), 17–26 and (1974), 166–204; Brower (1971), 141– 72; Kiefer (1978), 17–34 and (1985), 129–42; Muir (1978); Braden (1984), 277–92 and (1985); Miola (1992) and (2000), 116–25; Kerrigan (1996), 111–141; and Boyle (1997), 141–212. On the inXuence of Senecan prose on Shakespeare, see Miles (1996), 38–62. On Shakespeare’s classical reading, see Velz (1968); Martindale (1990); and Martindale and Taylor (2004). 12 Many of these elements were, in fact, borrowed indirectly, through the medium of 16th-century Italian tragedy. See Herrick (1965), esp. 115 and 292.
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
121
unsatisfactory business: at best a puzzle, and often an embarrassment or worse.’13 It is also the principal reason why the common assumption of ‘inXuence’ was eventually challenged or at least qualiWed. Renewed critical scrutiny in the second half of last century prompted the counter-assertion that the putative Senecan legacy was, in reality, slender and elusive. In 1967 G. K. Hunter stressed the shortcomings of the ‘scientiWc’ approach typiWed by CunliVe, whereby the literary excavator would ransack a chosen Elizabethan text (‘B’) for detectable and quantiWable linguistic relics of Senecan tragedy (‘A’). Such an approach, he argued, oversimpliWed the search for inXuence by ignoring the syncretism and eclecticism of the Renaissance era, the fact that ‘B’ was part of a whole intellectual climate, and subject, therefore, to a complex of competing inXuences, both classical and Christian.14 ‘B’ texts, such as the last plays of Shakespeare, were, he said, ‘too rich, various and diYcult to place to be put under the inXuence. They refuse to stay etherized upon the table.’15 Hunter’s corrective remarks belonged to a necessary reaction against the earlier absolutist acceptance of Seneca’s inXuence and the reductionism of the ‘parallelpassage’ mode of enquiry. The exponents of this counter-movement, however, frequently indulged in their own form of reductive reasoning. Hunter, for instance, concluded that the Elizabethan debt to Seneca was, if not actually negligible, certainly vastly overestimated and, at any rate, impossible to isolate from the ‘stream of tendency raining down upon’16 English tragedy: ‘If Seneca’s tragedies had not survived, some details would have had to be changed—but the overall picture would not have been altered.’17
13 Braden (1985), 1. 14 Hunter (1967), 17–26, at 18–19. 15 Ibid. 18. Contained in Hunter’s obvious allusion here to line 3 of T. S. Eliot’s ‘The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock’ is a further allusion to Eliot’s famous essays of 1927 on Seneca and the Elizabethans. Eliot was, in fact, one of the Wrst critics to move away from the traditional parallel-passage method and to suggest a less formalistic and quantitative approach to Senecan inXuence. At the end of his essay ‘Shakespeare and the Stoicism of Seneca’ (repr. in Eliot (1951), 126–40), he wrote: ‘The inXuence of Seneca on Elizabethan drama has been exhaustively studied in its formal aspect, and in the borrowing and adaptation of phrases and situations; the penetration of Senecan sensibility would be much more diYcult to trace’ (140). 16 Hunter (1967), 17–26, at 18. 17 Ibid. 24.
122
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
The Elizabethans’ dramatic sources were undeniably many and diVuse, a fact more recently acknowledged by Inga-Stina Ewbank: ‘Intertexts move promiscuously on the Elizabethan and Jacobean stage; the eclectic richness of texts is part of the strength of its drama; and, when originals have been mediated through layers of classical and native texts, apparent likenesses can be deceptive.’18 However, an acceptance of Renaissance England’s discursive literary inheritance, its ‘eclectic richness’, should not automatically diminish or negate Seneca’s considerable sway. A far more illuminating approach to the problem of inXuence, than either the ‘QED’ technique of CunliVe and Lucas or the ‘eclecticism’ theory of Hunter, is that of Robert Miola, who undertakes to trace Seneca’s inXuence on Shakespeare. Miola’s interest is ‘in stylistic minutiae and in oblique, audacious eVects’,19 ‘not only individual echoes and elements, but also . . . larger patterns of concatenation and conWguration’.20 His proWle of Senecan Shakespeare, which he assembles through close textual analysis and a readiness to think laterally, embraces language and imagery, characterization and psychology, atmosphere and setting, tragic sensibility and tragic vision. Crucially, he views Seneca not as ‘a terminus a quo’, but rather ‘as an intermediary legatee, himself heir to the great and complex traditions of ancient tragedy’.21 The combined breadth and detail of Miola’s modus operandi provide a valuable model for investigating the impact of individual Senecan tragedies on Elizabethan and Jacobean drama, and especially the subterranean, and often subtle, inXuence of the Hercules Furens. In considering speciWcally the inXuence of Hercules Furens on Elizabethan tragedy, one point above all needs to be determined: what is it that makes Hercules Furens peculiarly Senecan? The basic dramatic sequence which Soellner designates ‘the Hercules furens tradition’, and which he ascribes to Seneca’s inXuence, involves a sudden and temporary Wt of insanity followed by a palliative sleep and an interrogative awakening. Other ‘traditional’ features include the sensation of darkness accompanying the onset of madness, and violence arising from mistaken identities. But, in truth, this scenario, which is fundamentally Euripidean, is not necessarily what gives the Hercules furens 18 Ewbank (2005), 37–52, at 38. 20 Ibid. 10.
19 Miola (1992), 9. 21 Ibid. 9.
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
123
tradition, as a tragic tradition, its distinctive and demonstrable Senecan essence. To extract and analyse this essence, we need to do more than simply compile from the Elizabethan tragic corpus a checklist of plot components and physical symptoms. The arbitrariness of such a checklist is evident in Soellner’s pointed exclusion, from an otherwise informative survey, of two of the most signiWcant Herculean heroes in Elizabethan tragedy, Thomas Kyd’s Hieronimo and Shakespeare’s Lear.22 The real Senecan strain of the Hercules furens tradition is discovered in those aspects of the myth that were original to Seneca (and strikingly at odds with his major Attic source, Euripides’ Herakles), namely, his psychological conception of the madness and his characterization of Hercules as an autarkic hero at war with his own nature. Equally, in investigating possible aYnities between Shakespeare’s tragic heroes and Euripides’ Herakles, we need to focus on the Herakles’ peculiarly Euripidean features.
‘ B E L L A I A M S E C U M G E R AT ’: OT H E L LO In the prologue to Hercules Furens, Juno explicitly outlines the strategy she will employ in her campaign against Hercules: quaeris Alcidae parem? j nemo est nisi ipse; bella iam secum gerat (‘Do you need a match for Alcides? There is none but himself. Now he must war with himself ’, 84–5). Her masterly expedient is in se semper armatus Furor (‘mad Rage, always armed against itself ’, 98). Hercules, the peerless embodiment of heroic virtus, will be made to do battle with himself, and thus his greatest victory will be simultaneously his most comprehensive and ignominious defeat. Later, the hero’s own words foreshadow, with tragic irony, the genius and eYcacy of Juno’s nefarious plan: Watque summus hostis Alcidae Lycus (‘Alcides’ Wnal foe must be Lycus’, 635); si quod parat j monstrum, meum sit (‘if [the 22 Soellner (1958), 309–24, at 315: ‘Unless the writer refers directly to Hercules or uses several distinct features of the tradition, we cannot claim that the raging hero hovered in his imagination. On these grounds we must exclude from consideration some very famous examples of temporary madness on the Elizabethan stage, such as Kyd’s Hieronimo and Shakespeare’s Lear. Their resemblance to Hercules does not go much beyond the simple fact that they become temporarily insane.’
124
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
earth] is furnishing some monster, let it be mine’, 938–9). The goddess determines the timing and outcome of Hercules’ madness, but, in complete contrast to Euripides’ Herakles, the hero himself, through his character and actions, suggests the nature of the attack and provides his stepmother with her most powerful weapon. Juno succeeds by exploiting and exacerbating a pre-existing or semi-latent mania, a personality already in conXict with itself. Juno’s strategy of activating a self-destructive furor is also, as Somerville indicates, the strategy devised by Shakespeare’s arch-manipulator Iago, whose function in Othello is agential rather than generative: ‘[Iago is] the agent in the play for bringing about the overthrow of a mind full of conXicting thoughts and emotions. The explosive charges were ready. He was the spark that set them oV. He was the Diabolus ex machina, the evil god brought in to complete a debacle in place of a beneWcent power introduced to save the situation.’23 At the end of Act i, Iago anticipates the ease with which he will execute his plan to make Othello suspect Desdemona of inWdelity: The Moor is of a free and open nature That thinks men honest that but seem to be so; And will as tenderly be led by th’ nose As asses are. (i. iii. 397–400)
However, it is not merely his master’s candour and credulity that Iago exploits; even more insidiously and unscrupulously he exploits Othello’s Herculean duality, the opposition between his nobility and the ‘bloody passion’ that ‘shakes [his] very frame’ (v. ii. 44). Othello, like Hercules, is a civilizing hero, a mighty warrior for order and justice, and a benefactor to the far-Xung regions of earth. The beginning of the play sees him confronting an external threat in the form of a Turkish invasion of Cyprus, just as Hercules, on his Wrst appearance in Seneca’s play, confronts the threat posed by the tyrant Lycus. In each case, once the external threat has been averted a more lethal internal threat must be faced. As Miola states: ‘The initial external struggle sets up the conXict that the main action deconstructs, as each hero confronts the loathed other within himself.’24 The prototype for 23 Somerville (1979), 76.
24 Miola (1992), 126.
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
125
this deconstruction is Euripides’ Herakles, but there the action in each of the play’s contrasting halves is externally motivated. Seneca and Shakespeare introduce a double motivation: external design and orchestration plus internal conXict and susceptibility. In Hercules Furens the juxtapositions at 635 (‘Alcidae Lycus’) and 939 (‘monstrum meum’) highlight Hercules’ potential to become Lycus and his own monstrous prey. In the same way, Othello becomes the inWdel Turk, a raging barbarian who murders the gentle and faithful Desdemona. And, following the Herculean pattern, it is in a burst of righteous anger that Othello’s capacity for self-destructive furor is Wrst revealed. Roused by a drunken brawl between Cassio and Montano, which has been carefully contrived by Iago, he fears the ‘collying’ (darkening) of his senses as he threatens the combatants with death: Now, by heaven, My blood begins my safer guides to rule, And passion, having my best judgement collied, Assays to lead the way: if I once stir,— Or do but lift this arm, the best of you— Shall sink in my rebuke. (ii. iii. 196–201)
In the wake of his catastrophic madness, the decision of Euripides’ Herakles to retain the instruments of his family’s destruction, his famed bow and club, is emblematic of the transformation, or rather deepening, of his characteristic arete¯ into something greater and more spiritually exacting (1377–85). Seneca’s Hercules, surveying the bodies of his murdered wife and children, calls for his arms with the intention Wrst of destroying them (1231–5), then of destroying himself (1242–5), and thereby seeks to reassert his heroic identity. He is thwarted in his second purpose only by his father’s desperate counter-threat of suicide. His understanding and manifestation of virtus remains unchanged. Faced with the knowledge of his crime, Othello also seeks to reclaim his virtus and does so momentarily by fulWlling Hercules’ intention to kill himself. Yet, as Brower points out, Othello’s suicide has meaning beyond the heroic: With the recovery of a true vision of Desdemona and the attainment of true knowledge of his evil acts, Othello’s attitude is nearer the suVering Christian’s than the hero’s: This look of thine will hurl my soul from heaven . . .
126
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
For the ‘happiness’ of his death is more than a Wnal assertion of his heroic self; it is also an acceptance of the damnation that he knows is his due, and an act of self-sacriWce.25
But even in terms of the heroic standards prescribed by Greco-Roman or humanist tradition, Othello does not die unchanged. Whereas Seneca’s Hercules remarks bitterly on his inability to weep for his children as a father should (1228–9), Othello, like Euripides’ Herakles (1354–6), arrives at a deeper and agonizing recognition of his humanity, which declares itself in his unaccustomed facility in weeping: Then must you speak . . . Of one whose subdued eyes, Albeit unused to the melting mood, Drop tears as fast as the Arabian trees Their medicinal gum. (v. ii. 343, 348–51)
Othello is denied a Herculean apotheosis, but before his death he experiences, at least partially, a Heraklean transWguration of virtus.
‘NON CAPIT TERRA HERCULEM’: TAMBURLAINE AND HIERONIMO ‘With Tamburlaine,’ Braden declares, ‘Marlowe places at the head of Elizabethan drama perhaps the least compromising version of the Herculean hero on any Renaissance stage.’26 Part I of Tamburlaine chronicles the hero’s ascent from Scythian shepherd to King of Persia, his defeat of the Turkish emperor Bajazet, and his marriage to Zenocrate, daughter of the Sultan of Egypt. In Part II the hero’s pride, cruelty, and insatiable desire ‘to soar above the highest sort’ (ii. vii. 33) lead eventually to his ruin. On the question of whether Tamburlaine is presented with approval or disapproval, Waith believes Marlowe’s ‘concept of heroic character is suYciently complex to include what appear to be contradictory elements and that his attitude, going beyond simple approval or disapproval, remains constant’.27 25 Brower (1971), 27.
26 Braden (1985), 186.
27 Waith (1962), 63.
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
127
And Braden contends: ‘The ambivalence that marks our response to Herculean Wgures is heightened in Tamburlaine to perhaps the breaking point.’28 Marlowe’s bipartite structure emphasizes the contradictory elements in Tamburlaine’s character and actions, his Herculean duality, as well as the Elizabethans’ ambivalent attitude towards the type of hero he exempliWes. The Wrst part can be read as a celebration of the glorious and charismatic Herculean overreacher, while the second part portrays the dangers and the mania inherent in a life deWned by overreaching. Like Hercules, Tamburlaine is a Wgure of inWnite aspiration, imagination, and restlessness: The thirst of reign and sweetness of a crown, That caused the eldest son of heavenly Ops To thrust his doting father from his chair, And place himself in the imperial heaven, Mov’d me to manage arms against thy state. What better precedent than mighty Jove? Nature, that fram’d us of four elements Warring within our breasts for regiment, Doth teach us all to have aspiring minds: Our souls, whose faculties can comprehend The wondrous architecture of the world, And measure every wandering planet’s course, Still climbing after knowledge inWnite, And always moving as the restless spheres, Wills us to wear ourselves and never rest, Until we reach the ripest fruit of all, That perfect bliss and sole felicity, The sweetness of an earthly crown. (Part I, ii. vii. 12–29)
Here he invokes the divine precedent of unWlial Jupiter, maps out the cosmic dimensions of his soul, and, in ‘a daring exaltation of worldliness’,29 envisions the fruition of his godlike pursuit in an earthly crown. Thus, in true Herculean fashion, Tamburlaine does not belong entirely either to heaven or to earth.30 He exists in an intermediate, or entirely 28 Braden (1985), 187. 29 Martin (1978), 248–64, at 254. 30 Cf. Silk’s description (1985), 1–22, at 6, of Herakles: ‘Heracles lies on the margins between human and divine; he occupies the no-man’s-land that is also nogod’s-land; he is a marginal, transitional or, better, interstitial Wgure.’
128
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
separate, sphere in which his energy and ambition are without equal or consummation. As an intermediate or ‘interstitial’ Wgure, he is both vulnerable and dangerous.31 His isolation is the result of his greatness, but also his ‘colossal individuality’,32 self-absorption, obsessive concern for his virtus and the absolute primacy of his will (‘This is my mind and I will have it so’, Part I, iv. ii. 91), and his conviction that he is the sole executant of a divine purpose (‘I that am term’d the Scourge and Wrath of God’,33 Part I, iii. iii. 44). In Part II Tamburlaine’s most telling Herculean speech, and most violent assertion of autarkeia, reaches a climax in the sacriWcial-style murder of his cowardly son Calyphas (iv. i. 111–20): Here, Jove, receive his fainting soul again; A form not meet to give that subject essence Whose matter is the Xesh of Tamburlaine, Wherein an incorporeal spirit moves, Made of the mould whereof thyself consists, Which makes me valiant, proud, ambitious, Ready to levy power against thy throne, That I might move the turning spheres of heaven; For earth and all this airy region Cannot contain the state of Tamburlaine. [stabs Calyphas]
Following the pattern set by Seneca’s Hercules furens, Tamburlaine claims parity with Jupiter before issuing impious threats against Jupiter’s sovereignty. Lines 118–20 immediately recall Juno’s allegation against her stepson, nec satis terrae patent (‘Even the earth is not room enough’, 46), and Hercules’ deluded declaration of war on his father’s Olympian throne: in alta mundi spatia sublimis ferar, petatur aether: astra promittit pater. —quid, si negaret? non capit terra Herculem tandemque superis reddit. (958–61) 31 On the vulnerability and dangers of the interstitial Wgure, see Douglas (1969), 95–6 and 104. 32 Waith (1962), 77. 33 In Seneca’s Hercules Oetaeus, the hero, addressing Jupiter, refers to himself in similar terms: ‘ille qui pro fulmine j tuisque facibus natus in terris eram’ (‘He who was born on earth in place of your Wery thunderbolt’, 1143–4).
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
129
I must travel on high to the lofty expanses of the cosmos, and make for the sky: the stars are my father’s promise. What if he should now refuse? The earth cannot contain Hercules, and at last yields him to the world above.
Both heroes have outgrown the limits imposed by heaven and earth; they rage prodigiously and alone. A quite diVerent but equally compelling example of Herculean aspiration and autarkeia is the character of Hieronimo in Kyd’s The Spanish Tragedy. Braden argues: ‘Whatever the exact chronological relationship between Kyd’s play and Marlowe’s, The Spanish Tragedy provides the logical succession to Tamburlaine. . . . Kyd brings England’s unusually expansive version of Senecan selfhood into the crucial arena of revenge tragedy, where Renaissance drama forces that selfhood into its most intimate dealings with the lives around it.’34 Hieronimo, Knight Marshall of Spain, is driven mad with grief by the murder of his son Horatio, and, failing to secure justice, he plots to carry out his personal revenge. In common with Hercules, his mania, isolation, and restless punitive quest coalesce in titanic and tragic fashion; his solitude becomes pathological, unreachable. As he spurs himself to the task of vengeance in Act iii, he compares his uncompromising mission to Hercules’ destructive katabasis, employing language which simultaneously recalls Hercules’ hallucinatory assault on heaven: The upper billows, course of waves to keep, Whilst lesser waters labour in the deep, Then sham’st thou not, Hieronimo, to neglect The sweet revenge of thy Horatio? Though on this earth justice will not be found, I’ll down to hell, and in this passion Knock at the dismal gates of Pluto’s court, Getting by force, as once Alcides did, A troop of Furies and tormenting hags To torture Don Lorenzo and the rest. Yet lest the triple-headed porter should Deny my passage to the slimy strand, The Thracian poet thou shalt counterfeit: Come on, old father, be my Orpheus, And if thou canst no notes upon the harp, Then sound the burden of thy sore heart’s grief, 34 Braden (1985), 200.
130
‘Even the earth is not room enough’ Till we do gain that Proserpine may grant Revenge on them that murdered my son. Then will I rend and tear them thus and thus, Shivering their limbs in pieces with my teeth. (iii. xiii. 106–23)
As with Herculean Tamburlaine, earth cannot contain the rage and the vengeful aspirations of Hieronimo. In enlisting a ‘troop of Furies and tormenting hags’ (114), Hieronimo is also likening himself to Seneca’s Juno, who marshals against Hercules the infernal army of Dis, Scelus, Impietas, Error, and Furor (95–9). Brower maintains that the most important feature of the Senecan hero and his style of speech (and the one which particularly distinguishes him from Homeric and Virgilian heroes) is ‘the immense sense of self, and the accompanying use of language to direct attention to the self ’.35 As we have observed in the speeches of Tamburlaine, this ‘immense sense of self ’ is also one of the main features of the Herculean hero. Characteristic of Senecan Hercules’ sane and insane discourse is his habit of referring to himself in the third person, or using his name as an aggressive assertion of self (631, 635, 957, 960, 990, 1152, 1155, 1163, 1168, 1218, 1295, 1316). This habit is an intrinsic part of Hieronimo’s autarkic rhetoric: Who calls Hieronimo? Speak, here I am. (ii. v. 4) Hieronimo, ’tis time for thee to trudge. Down by the dale that Xows with purple gore Standeth a Wery tower; there sits a judge Upon a seat of steel and molten brass, And ’twixt his teeth he holds a Wrebrand, That leads unto the lake where hell doth stand 35 Brower (1971), 169. T. S. Eliot found repugnant the Senecan hero’s self-assertiveness and self-absorption. Of Othello’s last great speech (v. ii. 338–56), in which the Moor refers to himself in the third person, he wrote (1951, 130–1): ‘What Othello seems to me to be doing in making this speech is cheering himself up. He is endeavouring to escape reality, he has ceased to think about Desdemona, and is thinking about himself. Humility is the most diYcult of all virtues to achieve; nothing dies harder than the desire to think well of oneself. Othello succeeds in turning himself into a pathetic Wgure, by adopting an aesthetic rather than a moral attitude, dramatizing himself against his environment. He takes in the spectator, but the human motive is primarily to take in himself.’
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
131
Away, Hieronimo, to him be gone! He’ll do thee justice for Horatio’s death. . . . Justice, O justice to Hieronimo! (iii. xii. 6–13, 27) See, see, O see thy shame, Hieronimo. (iii. xiii. 95)
Similarly, in the Wnal act, Hieronimo’s triumphant exclamations before killing himself, ‘know I am Hieronimo’ (iv. iv. 83) and ‘now behold Hieronimo, j Author and actor in this tragedy’ (iv. iv. 146–7), are moments of autarkic epiphany which correspond strongly to Hercules’ declaration that he is the author of his family’s and his own destruction (‘hoc unum meum est’, 1268).
‘ H I C E R R AT S C E LUS ’ : M AC B E T H The most psychologically and morally complex incarnation of Herculean autarkeia in the Elizabethan tragic canon is Shakespeare’s Macbeth, whose Xight to exalted selfhood and the resulting crash to ordinary mortality are, as Miola notes, clearly ‘plotted along Senecan coordinates’.36 Like Seneca’s Hercules, Macbeth’s immoderate hopes (‘spes immanes’, 162) to scale ad astra ‘start him on a vertiginous descent to hell’.37 His ‘restless ecstasy’ (iii. ii. 22) is especially Herculean (cf. HF 613–14: ‘quid restat aliud? . . . da si quid ultra est’ and 996: ‘quid moror?’); he ‘is always in an emergency, desperate to overtake, to leap over, to outrun’.38 The tragic essence of both heroes is captured in Braden’s analysis of extreme autarkeia: To choose the way of self-conscious horror, a way systematically opposed to all other human desires and responsibilities, is to certify an absolute lack of ulterior motivation; no other part of the soul is being gratiWed or even courted. ‘What I was praised for doing, I did on orders,’ says Seneca’s Hercules, looking on the bodies of his murdered family, ‘only this is my own’ (Herc.f. 1268). Heroic evil is the ultimate autarceia [sic], enforcing and exploiting a radical split between the self’s needs and the claims of its context.39 36 Miola (1992), 111. On the Senecan resonances in Macbeth, see Peyre´ (2004), 141–55. 37 Miola (1992), 111. 38 Poole (1987), 42. 39 Braden (1985), 47.
132
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
The terrifying results of this radical split are enacted in the heroes’ anagno¯riseis. Hercules’ anagno¯risis in Act v is consistent with, and potently symbolic of, his tragic selfhood. Boldly deviating from Euripides’ psychotherapeutic stichomythia between father and son, Seneca reveals to us the terrible workings of the autarkic conscience. Hercules is the self-proclaimed author of his crime; unaided in his recognition, his bloodstained hands betray his guilt: Miserere, genitor, supplices tendo manus. quid hoc? manus refugit: hic errat scelus. unde hic cruor? quid illa puerili madens harundo leto? tincta Lernaea est nece. iam tela video nostra. non quaero manum. quis potuit arcum Xectere aut quae dextera sinuare nervum vix recedentem mihi? ad vos revertor, genitor: hoc nostrum est scelus? tacuere: nostrum est. (1192–9) Have pity, father, I hold out my hands in supplication. What? He pulled back from my hands: the crime is lurking here. Why this blood? What of that shaft, soaked by a boy’s death? It is steeped in the Hydra’s fatal blood. Now I see my weapons. I need not ask about the hand. Who could have bent that bow, what hand Xexed the string that barely yields to me? I turn to both of you again, father: is this crime mine? They are silent: it is mine.
In the wake of his Wrst crime, the murder of Duncan, Macbeth, focusing on his ‘hangman’s hands’, undergoes a correspondingly autarkic anagno¯risis. The diVerence is that Macbeth’s anagno¯risis marks only the beginning of his madness and his hellish odyssey into the darkest reaches of his soul: macbeth One cried, ‘God bless us!’ and, ‘Amen,’ the other, As they had seen me with these hangman’s hands. List’ning their fear, I could not say, ‘Amen,’ When they did say, ‘God bless us!’ lady macbeth Consider it not so deeply. macbeth But wherefore could not I pronounce ‘Amen’? I had most need of blessing, and ‘Amen’ Stuck in my throat. lady macbeth These deeds must not be thought After these ways: so, it will make us mad.
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
133
macbeth Methought, I heard a voice cry, ‘Sleep no more! Macbeth does murther Sleep,’—the innocent Sleep; Sleep, that knits up the ravell’d sleeve of care, The death of each day’s life, sore labour’s bath, Balm of hurt minds,40 great Nature’s second course, Chief nourisher in life’s feast;— lady macbeth What do you mean? macbeth Still it cried, ‘Sleep no more!’ to all the house: ‘Glamis hath murther’d Sleep, and therefore Cawdor Shall sleep no more; Macbeth shall sleep no more!’ lady macbeth Who was it that thus cried? Why, worthy Thane, You do unbend your noble strength, to think So brainsickly of things. Go, get some water, And wash this Wlthy witness from your hand.— . . . macbeth Whence is that knocking?— How is’t with me, when every noise appals me? What hands are here? Ha! they pluck out mine eyes. (ii. ii. 26–46, 56–8)
This anagno¯risis takes the form of a virtual soliloquy in which the terror of Macbeth’s subconscious mind is projected onto the screen of his consciousness. He seems not to hear his wife, but to communicate in a state of solitary Wxation, responsive only to the importunate sounds and images conjured up from his raw conscience. The auditory hallucinations of Duncan’s disembodied voice and the knocking, and the visual hallucination of the hands that pluck out Macbeth’s eyes, are, as Somerville describes, ‘the expression in consciousness of the content of a mental conXict, and the acuteness of the fear is . . . directly proportional to the severity of the conXict’.41 Somerville interprets the hero’s incipient madness in this scene as a ‘distortion in his a-social personality’.42 In other words, Macbeth’s guilt intensiWes, to the point of mania, an already abnormal aloofness—the self-imposed isolation and inverted altruism of the Herculean overreacher. 40 Muir (1959), 56 believes it ‘probable that ‘‘balm of hurt minds’’ was suggested by the situation in Hercules Furens, where the Chorus invokes Sleep to cure the madness of the hero’. The relevant lines are HF 1065–7: ‘tuque, o domitor j Somne malorum, requies animi, j pars humanae melior vitae’ (‘And you, o Sleep, subduer of troubles, rest for the spirit, sweeter part of human life’). 41 Somerville (1979), 48. 42 Ibid. 42.
134
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
The words manus and dextra dominate the linguistic texture of Hercules Furens, continually underlining the duality of the Herculean nature and modus vitae. Often they are used as metonyms for the hero’s celebrated strength and civilizing deeds. As the focus of Hercules’ anagno¯risis, they vividly symbolize the realization of the monster-slayer’s potential to turn monster. The stain attached literally to Hercules’ hands, and Wguratively to his soul, is commensurate with his greatness and his extravagant style of selfhood: quis Tanais aut quis Nilus aut quis Persica violentus unda Tigris aut Rhenus ferox Tagusve Hibera turbidus gaza Xuens abluere dextram poterit? Arctoum licet Maeotis in me gelida transfundat mare et tota Tethys per meas currat manus, haerebit altum facinus. (1323–9)43 What Tanais or what Nile or what Persian Tigris with its violent waters or Werce Rhine or Tagus, turbid with Spanish treasure, can wash my right hand clean? Though chill Maeotis should pour its northern seas over me and all the Ocean stream across my hands, the deed will stay deeply ingrained.
In his parallel anagno¯risis, Shakespeare uses Seneca’s hand motif to symbolize Macbeth’s Herculean scelus and indelible miasma: Will all great Neptune’s ocean wash this blood Clean from my hand?44 No, this my hand will rather The multitudinous seas incarnadine, Making the green one red. (ii. ii. 59–62)45 43 Cf. Seneca’s Phaedra 715–18, in which Hippolytus cries out after being polluted by his stepmother’s attempted seduction: ‘quis eluet me Tanais aut quae barbaris j Maeotis undis Pontico incumbens mari? j non ipse toto magnus Oceano pater j tantum expiarit sceleris’ (‘What Tanais will wash me or what Maeotis pressing barbarous Xoods into the Pontic sea? Not the mighty father himself with all his Ocean will expiate such a crime’). 44 C. B. Young (cited by Muir (1959), 58) points out that Shakespeare’s echo at ii. ii. 59–60 is closer to the original than Jasper Heywood’s translation of HF 1328 (‘And al the water therof shoulde now pas by my two handes’). 45 On the familiar possibility that Macbeth ii. ii. 59–62 is an amalgamation of Hercules Furens 1323–9 and Phaedra 715–18, see Muir (1959), 57–8. Miola (1992, 112–14) persuasively argues for Hercules Furens as a source. The hand motif is, of course, peculiar to the Hercules passage.
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
135
In so doing, he exploits the autarkic intensity of the original lines, their revealing combination of horror, aspiration, and exhilaration. As Poole explains: ‘[Macbeth] is overwhelmed by the sheer excitement of possibility, of beginning. The great lines about the multitudinous seas acknowledge the vast magical forces that lie beyond his control, but they also express the absurd, magniWcent desire to tame and possess those powers for himself, to reduce multitudinousness to oneness.’46 The diVerence between the two passages is one of placement and of psychological and moral emphasis. The Senecan passage comes at the close of the play and is accompanied by a preWgurement, however bleak and brieXy sketched, of Hercules’ absolution. Seneca’s main interest in the Herculean psychology and morality is located in the scenes up to and including the madness. Unlike Euripides’ Herakles, the nature of Hercules’ heroism does not undergo signiWcant development or transformation as a result of his furor and scelus. Shakespeare’s main interest is diVerently located. As Miola discerns, the displacement of the anagno¯risis from the end of Hercules Furens to the second act of Macbeth ‘enables more searching exploration of the eVects of scelus, measured in terms personal, social, and universal’.47 Macbeth’s is almost a Herculean journey in reverse, a journey further and further away from absolution and redemption. What both heroes share, however, near the end of their respective journeys, is an acute sense of autarkic desolation: Cur animam in ista luce detineam amplius morerque nihil est; cuncta iam amisi bona, mentem arma famam coniugem natos manus, etiam furorem. (1258–61) There is no reason for me to keep lingering in this light any further. I have lost all of value: my mind, my weapons, glory, wife, sons, hands—even my madness. I have lived long enough. My way of life Is fall’n into the sere, the yellow leaf, And that which should accompany old age, As honour, love, obedience, troops of friends, I must not look to have. (Macbeth, v. iii. 22–6) 46 Poole (1987), 47.
47 Miola (1992), 112.
136
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
Each is essentially aphilos, not merely friendless but beyond the reach of human philia, a condition plainly demonstrated by Hercules’ inability to weep for his murdered sons (‘lacrimare vultus nescit’, 1229) and by Macbeth’s impassive acceptance of the news of his wife’s death (v. v. 17–28).
‘HOC UNUM MEUM EST ’: CORIOLANUS Aspiration and corruptibility render Macbeth aphilos; for him, as for Tamburlaine and Hieronimo, isolation is a corollary of his restlessness. But for Shakespeare’s incorruptible Coriolanus the condition of aphilia, the ‘drive toward superior isolation’,48 is an end in itself. He hugs his solitariness to him; it is what sustains him, and the only means by which he believes he can claim authorship of himself. It is his persistence in this belief which brings him closest to the tragic core of Seneca’s Hercules. The main source of Coriolanus is Plutarch’s ‘Life of Caius Martius Coriolanus’ in his Lives of the Noble Grecians and Romans, which Shakespeare read in the English translation by Thomas North (1579). Shakespeare’s departures from Plutarch’s biography are what make his hero more Senecan. Most importantly, to the account of the battle in which Martius earns his cognomen he adds a single crucial word, ‘alone’.49 This becomes a recurring theme: Following the Xiers at the very heels, With them he enters; who, upon the sudden, Clapp’d to their gates; he is himself alone, To answer all the city. (i. iv. 49–52) Within these three hours, Tullus, Alone I fought in your Corioles walls, And made what work I pleas’d. (i. viii. 7–9) 48 McCanles (1967), 44–53, at 49. 49 Cf. Plutarch’s version in Brooke (1909, 149): ‘But he looking about him, and seeing he was entered the city with very few men to help him . . .’.
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
137
Know, Rome, that all alone Martius did Wght Within Corioles gates. (ii. i. 162–3) Alone he enter’d The mortal gate of th’ city . . . (ii. ii. 110–11)
It is also, Waith stresses, ‘one of the touches which reveals most unequivocally [Shakespeare’s] heroic conception of the character. In Coriolanus the opposition of the individual might of the hero to the superior forces of nature and fate is pushed to the uttermost.’50 Coriolanus’ isolationism takes many forms. In the Wrst place he harbours a pathological distaste for the ordinary citizenry, making it his mission to be at perpetual variance with their cause: He seeks their hate with greater devotion than they can render it him, and leaves nothing undone that may fully discover him their opposite. (ii. ii. 18–21)
In contrast to his friend and father-Wgure Menenius, he refuses, even at the cost of the consulship, to aVect aVability and bestow blandishments, in short, to play the politician. He is ‘too absolute’ (iii. ii. 39), ‘too noble for the world’ (iii. i. 25). Nor is his lack of political mildness and ease compensated for by the revelation of a domestic self. At no point in the play do we see Coriolanus enjoying his home and family. His parting from his family at the opening of Act iv is perfunctory (‘Come, leave your tears. A brief farewell!’), and recalls precisely the instructions of Seneca’s Hercules to his loved ones (diVer amplexus, ‘postpone your embraces’, 638; diVerte Xetus, ‘postpone your tears’, 1175). Perhaps to an even greater degree than Hercules, Coriolanus is an interstitial hero. He is set apart by his superhuman martial prowess (‘And with a sudden reinforcement struck j Corioles like a planet’, ii. ii. 113–14), his colossal physical presence (‘He’ll shake your Rome about your ears. j As Hercules j Did shake down mellow fruit’, iv. vi. 99–101), and his godlike aura (‘the nobles bended j As to Jove’s statue’, ii. i. 265–6). Above 50 Waith (1962), 142.
138
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
all, what separates himis his unwillingness to belong, to be part of awhole. He must be entire of himself. When he is banished from Rome, he declares deWantly, ‘There is a world elsewhere!’ (iii. iii. 135). Yet, so determined is he to be both aphilos and apolis that he has no real place in any world; he is neither Roman nor Volscian, but remains ‘a kind of nothing, titleless’ (v. i. 13). His otherworldliness is perceived by the Roman general Cominius, observing Coriolanus’ eVect on the Volscian forces: ‘He leads them like a thing j Made by some other deity than nature, jThat shapes man better’ (iv. vi. 91–3). On leaving Rome, Coriolanus tells his mother Volumnia: ‘I go alone, j Like to a lonely dragon that his fen j Makes fear’d and talk’d of more than seen’ (iv. i. 29–31). According to the Oxford English Dictionary, this is the Wrst recorded use of the word ‘lonely’ in the English language.51 ‘It is’, says Poole, ‘as if Shakespeare were making Martius Wnd a new syllable, to ‘‘exceed the common’’. ’52 Immediately after Coriolanus’ banishment, Volumnia rouses herself by invoking the wrath of Hercules’ stepmother: ‘In anger, Juno-like. Come, come, come!’ (iv. ii. 53). The self-comparison is apt, for in the last act it is she who initiates Coriolanus’ decisive war against himself, the battle between his desire for superior isolation and the constraints of Wlial love. As ‘the honour’d mould j Wherein this trunk was fram’d’ (v. iii. 22–3), she is the source of his isolated being, his counsel in self-truth, and as such he must honour her. Coriolanus is thus ‘perfectly trapped by the Wssure in the nature created by his mother’s nurture’.53 Having aligned himself with his great enemy AuWdius in the pursuit of vengeance against Rome, he resolves to be merciless: ‘Wife, mother, child, I know not’ (v. ii. 81). At the approach of the familial embassy mustered under Volumnia, he summons his intransigent, unnatural solitariness: But out, aVection! All bond and privilege of nature break! Let it be virtuous to be obstinate. What is that curtsy worth? or those doves’ eyes, Which can make gods forsworn? I melt, and am not Of stronger earth than others. My mother bows, As if Olympus to a molehill should In supplication nod; and my young boy Hath an aspect of intercession which Great nature cries, ‘Deny not’. Let the Volsces 51 OED (2001), viii. 1122.
52 Poole (1988), 76.
53 Ibid., 105.
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
139
Plough Rome and harrow Italy: I’ll never Be such a gosling to obey instinct, but stand As if a man were author of himself And knew no other kin. (v. iii. 24–37)
But his hope of authorship of himself is eventually vanquished by the ‘colder reasons’ (v. iii. 86) of his one true author, Volumnia, whose admonitions and entreaties recall those of Seneca’s Amphitryon (HF 1306–13): For myself, son, I purpose not to wait on fortune till These wars determine. If I cannot persuade thee Rather to show a noble grace to both parts, Than seek the end of one, thou shalt no sooner March to assault thy country than to tread— Trust to’t, thou shalt not—on thy mother’s womb That brought thee to this world. (v. iii. 118–25)
Coriolanus knows that his capitulation is a fatal act of treason against himself. He has allowed his mother to penetrate the solitariness that sustains him: O mother, mother! What have you done? Behold, the heavens do ope, The gods look down, and this unnatural scene They laugh at. O my mother, mother! O! You have won a happy victory to Rome; But for your son, believe it, O believe it, Most dangerously you have with him prevail’d, If not most mortal to him. But let it come. (v. iii. 185–92)
Her victory is visible in her son’s alien tears: ‘it is no little thing to make j Mine eyes to sweat compassion’ (v. iii. 199–200). Yet, ultimately, it is not Coriolanus’ capitulation to the bonds of philia which destroys him, but rather his reassertion of his aphilos self. In the Wnal scene AuWdius taunts Coriolanus with the very emblems of the latter’s surrender of self-authorship: ‘thou boy of tears!’ (v. vi. 101). It is this accusation, far more than AuWdius’ cries
140
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
of ‘traitor’, which cuts Coriolanus to the quick. He responds by inviting his own death in a chilling utterance of autarkic perfection: Cut me to pieces, Volsces, men and lads, Stain all your edges on me. Boy! False hound! If you have writ your annals true, ’tis there, That like an eagle in a dove-cote, I Flutter’d your Volscians in Coriole. Alone I did it. Boy! (v. vi. 111–16)
The Herculean Coriolanus, who seeks self-authorship through extreme aphilia, is in many ways a preWgurement of the Nietzschean Herakles who emerges in the Modernist period in the work of Lodge, Yeats, and Wedekind.54 In both cases, the hero’s isolation is a dangerous creed of transcendence, which holds the self as divinity and universe. It is a creed as far removed from Euripidean philia as is possible to get.
‘QU I S H I C LOC U S? ’ : K I N G L E A R A ND PE R I C L E S Act v of Hercules Furens memorably opens with the hero’s disorientated and rhetorically grandiose awakening from the restorative sleep that has overtaken madness: Quis hic locus, quae regio, quae mundi plaga? ubi sum? sub ortu solis, an sub cardine glacialis Ursae? numquid Hesperii maris extrema tellus hunc dat Oceano modum? quas trahimus auras? quod solum fesso subest? certe redimus. (1138–43) What place is this, what region, what tract of the earth? Where am I? Beneath the sun’s rising, or beneath the turning point of the icy Bear? Can this be the limit set to Ocean’s waters by the farthest land on the western sea? What air do I breathe? What ground lies under my weary body? Certainly I have returned.
This ‘interrogative awakening into painful self-consciousness was a topos variously employed on the Elizabethan stage’,55 and frequently 54 See below, Chap. 8.
55 Miola (1992), 166.
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
141
by means of direct quotation or adaptation of the Senecan passage. In Part III (5.3) of Richardus Tertius (1580), Thomas Legge quotes lines 1138–9 of Hercules Furens to indicate the perplexity and fear of Henry Tudor alone and lost on the battleWeld: Quis hic locus? quae regio? quae regni plaga? ubi sum? ruit nox. hei ubi satellites? inimica cuncta. fraude quis vacat locus? quenquam rogabo? tuta sit Wdes vide. nativus artus reliquit internos calor rigore frigent membra vix loquor metu tremisco totus. (14–20) What place is this, what region, what quarter of the kingdom? Where am I? The night hastens on. Ah! where are my followers? All around is hostile. What place is free from deceit? Shall I ask anyone? Take care that his loyalty is assured! The natural warmth has left my inward joints; my limbs are frozen with stiVness. I can scarcely speak for fear. I tremble all over.
In Jack Drum’s Entertainment (1600), John Marston uses the same two lines to signal the beginning of Pasquill’s furor, and in Alaham (1600), Fulke Greville presents his own version of Senecan percontatio and Herculean dusgnoia: But what is this? Wake I, or doe I dreame? If chang’d; with whom, or into whom am I? Doth Horror dazell sense, or multiply? What world is this? Where’s Alaham? Where my Sonne? (v. iii. 99–102)
Other contemporaneous examples of the Herculean sequence of temporary insanity, palliative sleep, and confused awakening include Bomelio in the anonymous The Rare Triumphs of Love and Fortune (1582) and the hero of Robert Greene’s Orlando Furioso (1591). Like Seneca’s Hercules, Bomelio’s madness begins with the sensation of darkness and has two levels of causation—internal and external; his melancholic disposition is worsened by the goddess Fortuna’s persecution of him. Greene’s Orlando twice imagines himself in his madness to be Hercules, and his furor causes him to mistake his servant for his enemy Medor and violently to attack Medor’s accomplice.
142
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
With the latter’s detached leg in his hand, he swings it about as though it were Hercules’ club, and calls for a lion’s skin, declaring: ‘Thou seest I now am mightie Hercules j Look, wheres my massie club upon my necke’ (ii. i). Later he orders his servant to fetch from Apollo the shirt of Nessus (iv. ii). The Herculean ravings of Bomelio and Orlando are cured only by sleep. Two satirical treatments of this ‘awakening’ topos are found in the academic play Lingua (1607) and James Shirley’s Love Tricks (1625). In the earlier work the boisterous coward Tactus becomes raving mad, and ‘cannot be persuaded but he is Hercules furens’. He is eventually bound by Somnus and his delirium remedied by sleep. Although a satirical creation, Tactus owes something to Seneca’s characterization of Hercules as a tragic miles gloriosus, an impetuous braggart constrained by an unthinking, unfeeling brand of heroism. These stage representations of remedial sleep in the context of Herculean furor also reXect contemporary medical opinion and pharmaceutical practice. As Blanshard observes: ‘Seventeenth-century physicians even recommended a ‘‘sleep cure’’ for madness based on the period of unconsciousness experienced by Hercules before he regained his sanity. Such a period of oblivion they reasoned allowed the black bile that had ascended from the stomach to the brain to be breathed out.’56 Narcotics such as opium and tobacco were commonly prescribed for this purpose. The most famous Herculean awakening in Elizabethan drama occurs in Shakespeare’s King Lear, Act iv, scene vii: Where have I been? Where am I? Fair daylight? I am mightily abused. I should ev’n die with pity To see another thus. I know not what to say. I will not swear these are my hands: let’s see— I feel this pinprick. Would I were assured Of my condition. . . . I fear I am not in my perfect mind. Methinks I should know you and know this man, 56 Blanshard (2005), 60. For an overview of medical perspectives on sleep in this period, see Dannenfeldt (1986), 415–41. On Renaissance beliefs in both the remedial and harmful eVects of sleep, and in sleep as a near-relation to death, see Pollard (2005), 67–8.
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
143
Yet I am doubtful; for I am mainly ignorant What place this is and all the skill I have Remembers not these garments; nor I know not Where I did lodge last night. Do not laugh at me, For, as I am a man, I think this lady To be my child Cordelia. (iv. vii. 52–6, 63–9)
Here we have the same ‘slow drift back into consciousness, the disordered sense of place, the fearful possibility that this waking is a waking into damnation’.57 But what is remarkable about this scene is its Euripidean rather than Senecan substance. As in the case of Euripides’ Herakles, Lear’s awakening marks the beginning of his rehabilitation which is achieved through philia, through the loyalty of Gloucester and Kent and, above all, the redemptive love of his daughter Cordelia who, in common with Euripides’ Amphitryon, plays the part of the gentle psychotherapist and agent of anagno¯risis: O my dear father, restoration hang Thy medicine on my lips, and let this kiss Repair those violent harms that my two sisters Have in thy reverence made. (iv. vii. 26–9)
Lear’s interrogative awakening is more muted and less grandiose than Hercules’, more naturalistic and less rhetorical. In place of Hercules’ rage and self-assertion he exhibits humility, contrition, and a Heraklean sense of aidos. He also aYrms his humanity (‘as I am a man’).58 Unlike Herakles, of course, Lear wakes to the joyous realization that the child whom he wronged (not in his madness, but in full consciousness) is alive. Yet, it is this very diVerent realization that starts Lear on a Heraklean journey towards forgiveness and salvation. In contrast to Senecan Hercules’ autarkeia, Lear’s restoration and recognition are characterized by a new, childlike dependence and vulnerability (‘this child-changed father’, iv. vii. 17), which, paradoxically, enable the 57 Braden (1993), 245–64, at 259. 58 Cf. Euripidean Herakles’ bitter scepticism towards Zeus and his acknowledgement of mortal Amphitryon as his true father at 1263–65. As Barlow (1996, 178) notes: ‘Here Heracles is questioning his very identity.’
144
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
rehabilitation of his majesty and fatherhood.59 The progress of this rehabilitative scene recalls Arrowsmith’s description of Euripides’ Herakles as ‘a play which imposes suVering upon men as their tragic condition, but . . . also discovers a courage equal to that necessity, a courage founded on love’.60 The scene ends with Cordelia leading her father oV ‘in a brief but indelible version of Herakles’ exit with Theseus’.61 ¨. ı æfi c Eæ ; ›ªø Kª. (theseus. ‘Put your arm round my neck, and I shall lead you’, 1402) . . . ˙æ. E IÆºÆ ÆN ÆØ j ¨E
ÆºØ łŁ KºŒ. (herakles. ‘I who have desolated my house with shame and am utterly destroyed, shall follow Theseus like a small boat in tow’, 1423–4). cordelia Will’t please your highness walk? lear You must bear with me. Pray you now, forget and forgive; I am old and foolish. (iv. vii. 82–4)
‘Shakespeare’, Braden perceives, ‘in eVect restores to the Senecan scene an important part of what Seneca cuts out of Euripides; the proud man’s discovery of a dependence and comfort that in fact will restore his ruined standing (he is again ‘‘your Highnesse’’).’62 As we know, the happy ending promised by that discovery is prematurely annulled by the deaths of Cordelia and Lear. With this Wnal peripeteia Shakespeare takes us ‘from a consolation beyond Euripides’ to a despair beyond Seneca’s. . . . [His] recasting of the classical scene recapitulates its past and exceeds it’.63 But, for reasons which Brower articulates, the play does not end with Seneca’s nihilistic despair; it ends, like Euripides’ Herakles, with an image and an aYrmation of transcendent love in the midst of insupportable fortune: Lear’s demand for love, with which King Lear began, was an assertion of self, and the only answer to that demand is Cordelia’s. But ‘love suVreth long and is kind’, though the answer is ‘nothing’. Hence the overwhelming eVect of Lear’s last words, that in the face of ‘No, no, no life!’ he looks for life, and he loves. . . . Lear 59 As in Euripides, the roles of parent and child are reversed. Cf. King Lear, v. iii. 10–11, where, Brower (1971), 412 states: ‘As father kneels to child and asks forgiveness, a new and tender inversion of relations takes place.’ 60 Arrowsmith (1956), 44–59, at 53. 61 Braden (1993), 245–64, at 260. 62 Ibid. 63 Ibid. 261.
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
145
dies loving and looking for life—that is ‘the wonder’, a kind of greatness more remarkable than the power of endurance that Kent marvels at. To love and hope with full tragic knowledge of the injustice, cruelty, and confusion of life is to pass beyond god-like hero to something god-like indeed.64
In Act v, scene i of the tragicomic Pericles, Prince of Tyre, which has several points of similarity with Act iv, scene vii of King Lear, Shakespeare again recapitulates and transcends the Herculean anagno¯risis. To paraphrase Miola, Pericles is the antitype of a Senecan protagonist and endures a kind of anti-furor, which culminates not in a scelus of cosmic proportions but in a moving reunion scene between father and daughter:65 pericles This is the rarest dream that e’er dull sleep Did mock sad fools withal; this cannot be My daughter, buried. . . . How came you in these parts? where were you bred? marina The king my father did in Tarsus leave me; Till cruel Cleon, with his wicked wife, Did seek to murder me; and having woo’d A villain to attempt it, who having drawn to do’t, A crew of pirates came and rescu’d me; Brought me to Mytilene. But, good sir, Whither will you have me? Why do you weep? It may be You think me an impostor: no, good faith; I am the daughter to King Pericles, If good King Pericles be. (v. i. 162–4, 170–80)
T. S. Eliot discerned the Herculean subtext beneath the climactic moment of Pericles’ recovery and recognition, selecting the beginning of Hercules’ anagno¯risis (1138) as an epigraph to his poem ‘Marina’ (1930), which opens with a striking enjambement of Senecan percontatio: What seas what shores what grey rocks and what islands What water lapping the bow And scent of pine and the woodthrush singing through the fog What images return O my daughter. (1–5) 64 Brower (1971), 415.
65 Miola (1992), 194.
146
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
The Senecan epigraph implicitly contrasts Pericles’ joyful recognition of his daughter Marina, whom he believed was dead, with Hercules’ tragic recognition of his murdered children. In a postscript to his letter presenting the draft of ‘Marina’ to the Bodleian Library, Eliot wrote: ‘I intend a criss-cross between Pericles Wnding alive, and Hercules Wnding dead—the two extremes of the recognition scene—but I thought that if I labelled the quotation it might lead readers astray rather than direct them. It is only an accident that I know Seneca better than I know Euripides.’66 Eliot’s self-confessed greater familiarity with the Senecan version may account for his failure to discern the Euripidean subtext beneath Pericles’ recognition and Shakespeare’s subtle repudiation of Herculean autarkeia in favour of Heraklean philia. If Seneca is ‘the closest Shakespeare ever got to Greek tragedy’,67 the very fact of a discernible Euripidean subtext in his plays raises fascinating, if ultimately unanswerable, questions. The close aYnities in essence between the rehabilitative awakenings of Herakles, Lear, and Pericles also illustrate Burrow’s point about the imaginative complexity of Shakespeare’s mobilization of classical allusion: ‘A large part of the creativity of Shakespeare lies in his willingness to overlayer one shard of ‘‘the classics’’ with another, to misremember, and to reinvent what he has read.’68 Seneca’s charismatic and uncontainable Hercules, who is nourished and made desolate by the same ferocious sense of selfhood, assumed many roles on the Elizabethan stage. As character and concept he became a tragic archetype for Shakespeare and his contemporaries. However, his subsequent inXuence was never as profound or pervasive, and for a time the Herculean hero of Senecan tradition eVectively disappeared from the English stage. The causes of his disappearance are bound up with changes, which were initiated during the Restoration, in audience composition, theatrical tastes, and heroic ideals. The greatest achievement of the Restoration stage was the wit and social satire of its comedy of manners, which laid the foundations of 66 Quoted in Moody (1994), 158. 67 Martindale (1990), 44. See also Silk (2004), 241–57, at 241. 68 Burrow (2004), 9–27, at 24.
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
147
a quintessentially English comic mode. By contrast, the Restoration heroic play was one of the more short-lived forms in the history of the theatre. Its most proliWc exponent was John Dryden (1631– 1700), who endeavoured unsuccessfully to acclimatize the trappings of French neoclassicism in English. With Dryden the heroic genre rose, Xourished, and fell. In his major plays, The Conquest of Granada (1670), Aureng-Zebe (1675), and All for Love (1677), we Wnd ‘legitimate descendants of the earlier Herculean heroes. However . . . these descendants speak and behave very diVerently from their forebears. One of the reasons why they do so is the acknowledged inXuence of the romance, and especially of the French romance.’69 Likewise, there are echoes of the Herculean hero in Nicholas Rowe’s Tamerlane (1702), but the distance between this play and the Senecan world of Marlowe is vast. Restoration heroic drama was not part of the problematizing tragic tradition. Its aim was to inspire admiration and wonder, and a happy ending, which witnessed poetic justice for the brave and noble, was de rigueur. Sober emphasis was placed on the virtues of valour, honesty, and love, and, above all, on decorum and propriety. Propriety required, for example, Nahum Tate in his version of King Lear (1681) to restore Lear to his throne and marry Cordelia to Edgar. In the same way, in his adaptation of Shakespeare’s Coriolanus, The Ingratitude of a Commonwealth (published in 1682), Tate replaced the desolate spectacle of Martius’ Wercely autarkic death with ‘an impeccable funeral tableau; Martius dies with his wife under one arm and his son under the other, the perfect family man’.70 Towards the end of the Restoration, and at the beginning of the Georgian era, theatre audiences became more numerous and less sophisticated, and were now more likely to comprise members of 69 Waith (1962), 154. Nearer in essence to the earlier Herculean heroes is the hero of Dryden and Nathaniel Lee’s Oedipus (1678), whose deWant last words call to mind Seneca’s grandiloquent and bombastic overreacher. On Dryden and Lees’s debt, in this Wnal speech, to Seneca and to Milton’s Samson Agonistes, see Macintosh (2005a), 1–29, at 20. 70 Poole (1988), 120. The autarkic intensity of Shakespeare’s ending is also missing from James Thomson’s Coriolanus (Wrst performed posthumously in 1749), in which the hero, recalling his victory at Corioles, says nothing of being ‘alone’. As Waith remarks, the omission of this word ‘makes all the plainer the consequences of Shakespeare’s climactic emphasis on Coriolanus as an individual who can never be assimilated into a city, his own or another’ (1962, 143).
148
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
the professional and merchant classes than the aristocracy. The change in audiences was accompanied by a shift in the type of plays presented: sentiment supplanted comedy, and pathos substituted for tragedy. Under these new conventions, the psychologically and morally complex Herculean hero lost his theatrical appeal. In the early to mid-eighteenth century the work of dramatists such as George Lillo (1693–1739), who is best remembered for his play The London Merchant; or, the History of George Barnwell (1731), inXuenced the development of bourgeois tragedy and domestic drama, the prototypes of Arthur Miller’s tragedy of the common man. The discovery and elevation of the ordinary entailed a suspension of dramatic interest in the extraordinary, and the semi-divine Hercules, greatest of all classical heroes, was an obvious casualty of this movement. Waith mentions a slightly later development, which had similar consequences for tragic Hercules—the rise of the novel: Admiration for the uncompromisingly individual warrior ceases for a time, to begin again in a somewhat diVerent form in the Romantic movement. HeathcliV and Captain Ahab, diVerent as they both are from Tamburlaine or Morat, are loved and feared for somewhat similar reasons. Their shocking infractions of the code of ordinary decency are similarly accepted as integral parts of their heroism. That the most obvious examples of the type occur in the novel rather than on the stage is one of many indications of the absorption by the novel of themes formerly sacred to epic and tragedy.71
The lengthy absence of the Herculean hero from English drama reXects a more universal neglect. Following his Renaissance revival, there is a hiatus of almost two centuries in the reception of mad Herakles, the hero of Euripidean-Senecan tradition. He Wrst reappears at the turn of the nineteenth century, not in literary or dramatic form but in the work of Venetian sculptor Antonio Canova, one of the few artists ever to have attempted to capture the moment of Herakles’ Wlicidal rampage.72 On the theme of ‘Hercules in his Madness Killing his Sons’, Canova executed a preliminary sketch, an oil painting, a wax bozzetto, and Wnally, in 1803–4, a plaster relief, which is housed in the Canova Museum in his home town of 71 Waith (1962), 201. 72 Canova’s better-known depiction of Hercules, and indeed one of his most celebrated works, is his marble sculpture Hercules and Lichas, completed in 1815.
‘Even the earth is not room enough’
149
Possagno. This last conveys an extraordinary sense of space and momentum.73 Hercules, an immense form of grim unstoppability, leans far to the left, extending his bow to the full. At the extreme right is the half-Xeeing, half-turning Wgure of Megara, cradling a dead son in her left arm. Her other sons are scattered about the scene in various attitudes of terror and supplication. In the centre of the relief Amphitryon hurls himself before Hercules in a futile attempt to avert complete disaster. This central Wgure of frantic intercession reveals Canova’s chief source to be Euripides’ Herakles, a fact known to copyists who, in engravings of the relief, provided act and scene numbers. As Blanshard comments, ‘Canova doesn’t just want us to look, he wants us to read’.74 In terms of documented performance, the gap is even greater; Euripides’ Herakles does not reappear, in his own right, on a professional stage anywhere in the world until the beginning of the twentieth century.75 His rediscovery occurs gradually and mainly through the personal and progressive eVorts of a few individuals in the late nineteenth century and early Modernist period. It is intrepid philological enquiry allied with rare poetic vision which engineers Herakles’ eventual reinstatement and reinvention in theatres across Britain, Europe, and the United States. 73 For detailed descriptions of the scene depicted in the relief, see Licht (1983), 262 and Blanshard (2005), 41–6. 74 Blanshard (2005), 46. 75 Euripides’ Herakles does, however, appear in his own right in a production by Reading School in the late Georgian period. See Appendix 2. See also Hall (1997b), 59–81, at 68. Antonis Varveris apparently directed a performance of Herakles in Greece in 1879, but very few details of this production have been recorded.
5 Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist: the nineteenth-century damnatio of Euripides The nineteenth century represents a crucial transitional stage in the reception of Euripides’ Herakles. It was an era in which interest in ancient drama generally was rekindled, when substantial studies of the tragic genre were undertaken, and a time when beliefs in the comparative merits of its best-known authors were devoutly witnessed. For most of the century Euripides was dogmatically cast as the least of the poets who made up the Wfth-century tragic triumvirate; and the diYcult and disturbing Herakles was, like many of his plays, not so much singled out for scorn or condemnation, as ignored. Consistent, however, with the overall historical pattern of the Herakles’ reception, whereby each generation has produced few, but notable, advocates of the play’s worth, the nineteenth century fostered a small number of eminent, and sometimes surprising, champions whose heresy was both peculiar to its time and in advance of it. The staunchest and most radical of these champions was the poet Robert Browning, in his Aristophanes’ Apology of 1875. In order to appreciate the full signiWcance of this work, it is Wrst necessary to understand the critical and literary orthodoxy against which Browning’s radicalism asserted itself, as well as the emergent, but tentatively voiced, heterodoxy which he energized. What follows is essentially a survey of the nineteenth century’s reception of Euripides and, in particular, the Herakles. The survey is not intended to be exhaustive, but rather to record the principal studies made of the playwright and to illustrate the views expressed by his chief detractors and disciples. It is conWned to Germany and Britain, where the century’s major scholarship on Greek tragedy
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
151
and the text of Herakles, and certainly that which had the most direct impact on Browning and his contemporaries, was centred. It ends in 1880, before the most intensive phase of Euripides’ rehabilitation in the Modernist era. This rehabilitation was distinguished by the progressive works of three notable scholars: Ulrich von WilamowitzMoellendorV, who substituted historicism for classicism as a methodology for the investigation into Wfth-century tragedy; A. W. Verrall, who applied to Euripides’ plays an extreme brand of rationalism; and Gilbert Murray, who ‘viewed the plays primarily as pieces of theatre which were to be relished and criticized as such’.1 Finally, with regard to the scope of the present survey, it will encompass not only literary criticism and scholarly editing, but also translation and poetry.
T H E NATURE OF NINETEENTH-CENTURY HELLENISM Ironically, many twentieth-century critics have tended towards the sort of generalizations and conWdent assertions which, they contend, are characteristic of nineteenth-century Hellenism, in their own attempts to scrutinize the trends of Euripidean criticism in the nineteenth century. Gilbert Murray, writing in 1913 in Euripides and His Age, from a Modernist perspective and with almost immediate hindsight of the Victorian era, identiWed this tendency, and indeed equally embodied it, in his analysis: The Victorian Age had, amid enormous diVerences, a certain similarity with the Periclean in its lack of self-examination, its rush and chivalry and optimism, its unconscious hypocrisy, its failure to think out its problems to the bitter end. And in most of the current criticism on things Victorian, so far as it is not mere fashion or folly, one seems to feel the Victorian spirit itself speaking. It arraigns Victorian things by a Victorian standard.2
Murray identiWes two general aspects of the nineteenth century’s reception of Euripides. The Wrst, outlined in Euripides and His Age,
1 Barrett (1996), 39–50, at 47.
2 Murray (1913), 6.
152
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
is the pronounced polarization of opinion and allegiances surrounding the philosophical and political import of the extant Euripidean corpus in the nineteenth century: ‘As a thinker he [Euripides] is even to this day treated as a personal enemy by scholars of orthodox and conformist minds; defended, idealized and sometimes transformed beyond recognition by various champions of rebellion and the free intellect.’3 The second aspect of the nineteenth century’s reception identiWed by Murray (slightly later, in 1915) is the pejorative stamp which the classicist reading of Attic drama had placed on Euripides: ‘Greek drama has always suVered from a school of critics who approach a play with a greater equipment of aesthetic theory than of dramatic perception. This is the characteristic defect of classicism. One mark of the school is to demand from dramatists heroes and heroines which shall satisfy its own ideals.’4 Murray’s last remark is echoed, much later in the century, in Richard Jenkyns’s assessment of the comparative levels of favour in which Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Euripides were held during the Victorian age. ‘The Victorians’, he says, ‘tended to worship those artists who were most unlike themselves—Homer, Raphael, Bach— and perhaps the supposed modernity of Euripides did not help his reputation.’5 Ann Norris Michelini, in her outline of the history of Euripidean interpretation, makes the same point: The antimodernist or classicist stance that was associated with the educational mission of ancient or ‘classical’ studies made it diYcult to assimilate an artist who was perceived as similar to the moderns. In fact it was only in comparison with modern poetry like that of Racine that Euripidean art was likely to appear at all admirable. This negative view of Euripides was pervasive and powerful throughout almost all the nineteenth century.6
However true, in a broad sense, these generalizing remarks are, they fail to do justice to the complexity of nineteenth-century Hellenism. Jenkyns, for example, after taking to task Victorian critics’ convenient labelling of the three tragedians according to their supposedly deWnitive qualities, oVers his own, perhaps overly tidy, classiWcation: ‘Speaking crudely, one can say that Aeschylus was the most inXuential 3 Murray (1913), 1. 5 Jenkyns (1980), 107.
4 Murray (1915), p. vi. 6 Michelini (1987), 6.
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
153
of the three in the romantic period, Sophocles in the middle of the Victorian age and Euripides towards the end of the century.’7 Jenkyns is clearly acknowledging the somewhat arbitrary nature of his demarcation, but what such a generalization does is occlude the role played by Euripides earlier in the century. Shelley’s Prometheus Unbound (1820) and Hellas8 (1822) demonstrate that, in many respects, the Romantics did indeed ‘discover’ Aeschylus. At the same time, however, Sophocles and Euripides were also favourites of Shelley, as The Cenci9 (1820) and his surprising translation of The Cyclops10 (published posthumously in 1824) prove. More surprising still is the apparent interest of Shelley’s contemporary, Byron, in the Euripidean-Senecan Herakles. In Don Juan Byron makes two slightly enigmatic references to Hercules Furens, the Wrst in an aside, the second in a simile. In Canto 11. 52 (1823) he describes ‘That prodigy, Miss Araminta Smith j (Who at sixteen translated Hercules Furens j Into as furious English)’, and in Canto 17. 11 (1824), detailing his changes of temperament, he likens himself at times to ‘a sort of ‘‘Hercules furens’’ ’.11 Towards the midcentury, Mendelssohn’s Antigone, which was performed at Covent Garden in January 1845, led to wide interest in the play, and in Sophocles as the classical exemplar.12 In the same period, however,
7 Jenkyns (1980), 106. 8 Hellas was based on Aeschylus’ Persae. See Hall’s introduction to her edition of the Persians (1996), 1–33, and Wallace (1997), 196–205. 9 The Cenci was inXuenced by Sophocles’ Oedipus Tyrannus and Wrst staged in 1886. For a study of Shelley’s Greek translations, see Webb (1976), chaps. 1–3, and of The Cenci, esp. 36–7 and 212–13. 10 The Cyclops was a translation of Euripides’ satyr play. See Webb (1976), 79–87 and Wallace (1997), 71–5. 11 Byron’s references to Hercules furens are unusual. The episode of Herakles’ madness scarcely features in the concordances to the major English poets of the 19th century. However, the choice, labours, and death of Herakles were comparatively fertile and popular themes for 19th-century writers and artists. See Reid (1993), 515–61, esp. 530, 545–6, and 551. 12 This production, which was overseen by Friedrich Wilhelm IV, employed Johann Jakob Christian Donner’s translation of Sophocles’ text as well as Mendelssohn’s orchestral introduction and choral settings. It premie`red in Potsdam in October 1841, and was performed in Paris in 1844 before transferring to London the following year. For the inXuence of the ‘Mendelssohn Antigone’ on the 19th century, see Macintosh (1997), 284–323, at 286–9.
154
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
stage adaptations of Euripides’ Medea13 and Alcestis14 were inXuencing popular and parliamentary debate about the marital state generally, and divorce legislation speciWcally, which precipitated Britain’s Divorce and Matrimonial Causes Act in 1857. And whilst at the end of the century Euripides was in many ways ‘rediscovered’, predominantly by the sympathetic scholarship of Wilamowitz, Murray, Verrall, and Norwood, it is also true that Aeschylus, and especially his Agamemnon, became hugely popular from the 1880s onwards.15 In the audience at Frank Benson’s presentation of the Agamemnon at Balliol College, Oxford, in 1880 were Browning, Tennyson, and Oscar Wilde. When the production transferred to London, among those who saw it were George Eliot, Henry Irving, and Ellen Terry. Sophocles also found favour in the last two decades of the century, as shown by the choice of Ajax as the inaugural Cambridge Greek play in 1882.
TH E SC H L E G E L I A N E U R IP I D E S B I L D The most inXuential and durable appraisal of Euripides in the period between 1800 and 1880 was by August Wilhelm Schlegel (1767–1843). This appraisal had a complex genesis that is frequently overlooked or misunderstood by modern commentators. Schlegel and his younger brother Friedrich (1772–1829) were largely responsible for popularizing and enshrining the Romanticist approach to the study of ancient Greek poetry, an approach fuelled by hostility towards French neoclassicism. They idealized for modern poets and critics the quality of completion (Volkommenheit) in ancient literature, and made the inseparableness of moral and aesthetic values, of personality and art, an article of faith. Friedrich Schlegel concentrated much of his eVorts on Greek epic poetry, while his brother is best known for his Vorlesungen
13 See Hall (1999), 42–77 and Macintosh (2000), 75–99, esp. 80: ‘The Wgure of Medea, the abandoned wife and mother, was adopted and adapted on the stage to illuminate the discussion about divorce legislation from, at least, the mid-1840s onwards.’ 14 See Macintosh (2001), 281–308, and particularly her discussion of Frank Talfourd’s burlesque production of Alcestis, Wrst staged at London’s Strand Theatre in 1850. 15 See Macintosh (2005b), 139–62.
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
155
u¨ber dramatische Kunst und Literatur (Lectures on Dramatic Art and Literature), which were delivered in Vienna in 1808, ten years before his appointment as Professor of Art and Literary History at Bonn University. Between them the Schlegels disseminated a theory, which prevailed virtually unchallenged for two-thirds of the nineteenth century, of Verfall, of literature’s progressive degeneration from the Greeks to the moderns.16 A. W. Schlegel exercised this theory to compelling eVect in his treatment of the Greek tragedians. Of his thirty lectures, nearly half are concerned with the ancient drama and, in these, it is Sophocles who is held up as the sublime exemplum of the classic standards of harmony, completion, and dignity, and Euripides who represents the antitheses of these qualities. What has seldom been made clear, however, is that in regard to Euripides the Schlegels were not of one mind. Ernst Behler, redressing the misconception, initiated by August Wilhelm, that Friedrich Schlegel’s views on Euripides were indistinguishable from his own, maintains: ‘August Wilhelm simpliWed his brother’s complex and ambiguous image of Euripides to an almost entirely negative one.’17 By appropriating and magnifying Friedrich’s concept of a sudden fall from Aeschylus and Sophocles to Euripides, ‘August Wilhelm Schlegel inaugurated a phenomenon that we may describe as the nineteenthcentury damnatio of Euripides’.18 Behler reconstructs Friedrich’s view of Euripides from a broad range of sources, including extant unpublished material for an uncompleted history of Attic tragedy, earlier articles on Greek literature, and later histories on ancient and modern literature. His close examination of these sources reveals an ambivalent and not unsympathetic attitude, which Behler terms Friedrich’s ‘dual evaluation of Euripides’.19 While Friedrich Schlegel found much to criticize and regret in Euripides’ dramaturgy, his essentially progressive literary and historical philosophy yielded a less monochromatic portrait of the poet than is commonly assumed. It was his brother’s
16 Such ‘evolutionary’ literary theories were not uncommon in the 18th and 19th centuries and were not conWned to tragedy. Epic poetry was frequently plotted and studied according to a scale which descended from the noble primitivism of Homer to the modern elegance of Virgil. See e.g. Jenkyns (1980), 8. 17 Behler (1986), 335–67, at 359. 18 Ibid. 335. 19 Ibid. 350. See also 351–4.
156
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
critique of Euripides, however, that was the more sustained and publicized. In his eighth lecture, entitled ‘Euripides: His Merits and Defects— Decline of Tragic Poetry Through Him’, August Wilhelm Schlegel expounded a denunciatory catalogue of complaints which became, for most of the century, the received classicist view of Euripides as populist, libertine, atheist, misogynist, and subversive sophist. He prefaces this catalogue with an exposition of his urgent didactic purpose, namely to arrest the decadence plaguing contemporary dramaturgy: When we take him in his connexion with the history of art, when we look at each of his pieces as a whole, and again at the general scope of his labours, as revealed to us in the works which have come down to us, we are forced to censure him severely on many accounts. . . . He either wanted the lofty earnestness of purpose, or the severe artistic wisdom, which we reverence in Aeschylus and Sophocles, to regulate the luxuriance of his certainly splendid and amiable qualities. His constant aim is to please, he cares not by what means; hence is he so unequal: frequently he has passages of overpowering beauty, but at other times he sinks into downright mediocrity. We have, besides, a particular reason for censuring without reserve the errors of this poet; the fact, namely, that our own age is infected with the same faults with those which procured for Euripides so much favour, if not esteem, among his contemporaries. In our times we have been doomed to witness a number of plays which, though in matter and form they are far inferior to those of Euripides, bear yet in so far a resemblance to them, that while they seduce the feelings and corrupt the judgement, by means of weakly, and sometimes even tender, emotions, their general tendency is to produce a downright moral licentiousness.20
For a modern reader, Schlegel’s portrait of Euripides, and the ‘revolution’ he wrought, depicts a Wfth-century equivalent of the ‘angry young man’ or ‘kitchen-sink’ dramatist, a tormentor of respectable conservatism.21 Euripides used as his framework the dramatic conventions of his day in order to reinterpret the subjects, both divine and mortal, 20 Schlegel (1846, rev. English edn.), 111–12. 21 John Osborne worked within a traditional three-act structure when, in 1956, he gave a new dramatic voice to a classless and leaderless section of post-war British society in Look Back in Anger. See Kenneth Tynan’s review of the original Royal Court production (Observer, 13 May 1956). For alternative readings of the ‘revolutionary’ Angry Young Men, see Rebellato (1999) and Carpenter (2002).
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
157
of the well-known myth cycles.22 Accordingly he had, in Schlegel’s estimation, domesticated, or even trivialized, the tragic register exempliWed by his predecessors and had infused familiar tales and sacred notions with an all-too-modern scepticism: [Euripides] endeavours to Wll up, or to build over the chasm that yawned between his contemporaries and that wondrous olden world, and to come upon the gods and heroes in their undress. . . . He introduces his spectators to a sort of familiar acquaintance with them; he does not draw the supernatural and fabulous into the circle of humanity, but within the limits of the imperfect individuality. . . . He takes delight in depicting the defects and moral failings of his characters.23
Schlegel does not name the Herakles in the course of his attack. With the exception of a comparative review of Aeschylus’ Choephoroe and the Sophoclean and Euripidean versions of Electra, his pronouncements on the tragedians are generally made without illustration from the plays themselves. He does mention the Herakles in his tenth lecture, where he comments brieXy on the lack of causal unity between the two halves of the play.24 Nevertheless, the general faults which Schlegel enumerates would seem to have particular application to the Herakles. The other main charge brought against Euripides by Schlegel was that of agnosticism, or indeed atheism, which was linked in the critic’s eyes to a sneering and morally destabilizing intellectualism: ‘He thinks it too vulgar a thing to believe in the gods after the simple manner of the people, and he therefore seizes every opportunity of interspersing something of the allegorical interpretation of them, and carefully gives his spectators to understand that the sincerity of his own belief was very problematical.’25 Implicit in this judgement is the notion, which Nietzsche later developed into the pivotal tenet of his 22 J. A. Symonds and Gilbert Murray each drew a distinction between the traditionalism of Euripides’ dramatic technique and the radicalism of his ideas: ‘All the cumbrous paraphernalia of the Aeschylean theatre environed the men and women of Euripides, who cut but a poor Wgure in the garb of demigods’, Symonds (1893), 21; ‘In speculation he is a critic and a free lance; in artistic form he is intensely traditional. He seems to have loved the very stiVness of the form in which he worked. He developed its inherent powers in ways undreamed of, but he never broke the mould or strayed away into shapelessness or mere realism’, Murray (1913), 7. 23 Schlegel (1846), 114–15. 24 Ibid. 137. 25 Ibid. 116.
158
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
attack on Euripides, of the pernicious force of ‘Socratism’ operative in Euripides’ plays. Throughout the nineteenth century the issue of Euripides’ alleged agnosticism and irreverence was a regular, and often crucial, feature of the debate surrounding his poetic merit. Among the few to speak in Euripides’ defence on this point was John Keble (1792–1866), who, while Professor of Poetry at Oxford in the 1830s, argued that the poet’s depiction of the purest chastity (ŒÆŁÆæ) in his Hippolytus preWgured Christ’s promise that the pure in heart shall see God (Matthew 5: 8).26 Towards the end of the century a theory arose according to which the Bacchae was written as a palinode (recantation), and provides evidence of Euripides’ oldage conversion to religious orthodoxy. Walter Pater (1839–94) expounded this theory in an essay on the Bacchae which formed part of his Greek Studies of 1895: Writing in old age, he is in that subdued mood, a mood not necessarily sordid, in which (the shudder at the nearer approach of the unknown world coming over him more frequently than of old) accustomed ideas, comfortable to a sort of common sense regarding the unseen, oftentimes regain what they may have lost, in a man’s allegiance. It is a sort of madness, he begins to think, to diVer from the received opinions thereon. . . . Euripides has said, or seemed to say, many things concerning Greek religion, at variance with received opinion; and now, in the end of life, he desires to make his peace—what shall at any rate be peace with men. He is in the mood for acquiescence, or even for a palinode, and this takes the direction, partly of mere submission to, partly of a reWning upon, the authorised religious tradition. . . . It is this extravagant phase of religion, and the latest-born of the gods, which as an amende honorable to the once slighted traditions of Greek belief, he undertakes to interpret.27
The ‘merits’ which Schlegel ascribes to Euripides are few and seldom unequivocally conceded, but are usually precursory to an ever-more damning indictment of the playwright’s transgressions. In the concluding remarks of his eighth lecture, for example, he declares that Euripides:
26 See Jenkyns (1980), 92. For the notion of Euripides as a proto-Christian, cf. Browning’s The Ring and the Book, 10. 1717–25. 27 Pater (1895), 50, 55. On the ‘palinode’ theory and its prevalence in the 19th century, see Dodds (1960), pp. xl–xlii. Dodds remarks on the irony that ‘good Christian editors seem to have been gratiWed by this notion of their poet’s eleventh-hour conversion to pagan orthodoxy’ (p. xl).
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
159
has a particular strength in portraying the aberrations of a soul diseased, misguided, and franticly abandoned to its passions. He is admirable where pathos and moral beauty are united. Few of his pieces are without passages of the most ravishing beauty. It is by no means my intention to deny him the possession of the most astonishing talents; I have only stated that these talents were not united with a mind in which the austerity of moral principles, and the sanctity of religious feelings, were held in the highest honour.28
Schlegel is not insensitive to Euripides’ Wner poetic qualities, but his sensitivity and occasional enthusiasms are much muted. Moreover, when he lists Euripides’ contemporary detractors, Schlegel singles out, with particular praise for his ‘inWnite cleverness and inexhaustible Xow of wit’,29 the comic poet Aristophanes who, he says, ‘seems almost ordained to be his [Euripides’] perpetual scourge, that none of his moral or poetical extravagances might go unpunished’.30 This reverential nod to the comic poet provides one of the most important keys to the Schlegelian Euripidesbild and, indeed, the nineteenthcentury damnatio of Euripides. Schlegel’s evaluation of Euripides is famously encapsulated in the line: ‘He has neither the dignity and energy of Aeschylus, nor the chaste sweetness of Sophocles.’31 The inXuence of his estimation of the Greek tragedians was profound and widespread. The fact that his comments had been embraced at both a popular and a scholarly level accounted for the longevity of the century’s classicist perspective of its literary ancestry. Schlegel’s antipathy towards Euripides, however, was not received entirely without dissent by his contemporaries. Most notable among those of his countrymen who opposed him was Goethe (1749–1832). In a conversation with Johann Peter Eckermann, which Eckermann records as having taken place on Wednesday, 28 March 1827, Goethe condemned Schlegel’s biased and dubiously founded criticism of the drama. The conversation begins with a consideration of Hinrich’s book on the nature of antique tragedy, and progresses through Sophocles and Molie`re to Schlegel’s treatment of Molie`re and the Greek tragedians in his lectures. Goethe’s scathing response to the critic, and his own high opinion of Euripides, are clearly set forth: 28 Schlegel (1846), 121. 30 Ibid.
29 Ibid. 31 Ibid. 120.
160
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
He [Schlegel] is . . . just to Aeschylus and Sophocles; but this does not seem to arise so much from a lively conviction of their extraordinary merit as from the tradition among philologists to place them both very high; for, in fact, Schlegel’s own little person is not suYcient to comprehend and appreciate such lofty natures. If this had been the case, he would have been just to Euripides too, and would have gone to work with him in a diVerent manner. But he knows that philologists do not estimate him very highly, and he feels no little delight that he is permitted, upon such high authority, to fall foul of this mighty ancient, and to schoolmaster him as much as he can. I do not deny that Euripides has his faults; but he was always a very respectable competitor with Sophocles and Aeschylus. If he did not possess the great earnestness and the severe artistic completeness of his two predecessors, and as a dramatic poet treated things a little more leniently and humanely, he probably knew his Athenians well enough to be aware that the chord which he struck was the right one for his contemporaries. A poet whom Socrates called his friend, whom Aristotle lauded, whom Menander admired, and for whom Sophocles and the city of Athens put on mourning on hearing of his death, must certainly have been something. If a modern man like Schlegel must pick out faults in so great an ancient, he ought only to do it upon his knees.32
Schlegel’s Vienna lectures gained enormous currency through their subsequent publication in four editions (1809, 1816, 1845, and 1846) and their translation into almost every European language. In 1815 the lectures were Wrst translated into English by John Black. A second English edition appeared in 1840, and was followed in 1846 by a ‘Revised Edition According to the Last German Edition’ by A. J. W. Morrison. By the middle of the century the impact of Schlegel on British classical scholarship was easily discernible.
MAT THEW AR NO LD’S SILENCE Schlegelian Romanticism, and German Hellenism in general, played a vital role in formulating the concept of Hellenism which informed the poetry and criticism of Matthew Arnold (1822–88), one of the Victorian age’s most proliWc and decided theorists on Greek culture.33 It is 32 Trans. Oxenford, in Eckermann (1850), 377–8. 33 For a detailed discussion of Matthew Arnold’s Hellenism, see Turner (1981), 17–36.
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
161
useful, when considering his opinions on ancient tragedy, to bear in mind that, despite its ubiquity and inXuence, Arnold’s Hellenism is strangely unrepresentative of, or at least unresponsive to, the period of scholarship in which it was formulated. According to Turner: ‘The content of Arnold’s Hellenism was largely uninformed by recent classical scholarship. Arnold had read widely in Greek literature, but not deeply in contemporary classical studies. From his earliest prose works through the discussion in Culture and Anarchy Arnold’s concept of Hellenism and what the Greeks had been like combined the intellectual elements of English humanism and German aesthetic Hellenism.’34 The signiWcance of Arnold to Euripidean reception in the nineteenth century resides in his studied silence on the tragedian, and his inaugural lecture as Professor of Poetry at Oxford35 in November 1857 (published in 1869) was programmatic in this regard. The lecture, entitled ‘The Modern Element in Literature’, opens with a broad statement of Arnold’s cultural belief and prepares the standard by which his judgement of literature is to be delivered: An intellectual deliverance is the peculiar demand of those ages which are called modern; and those nations are said to be imbued with the modern spirit most eminently in which the demand for such a deliverance has been made with most zeal, and satisWed with most completeness. Such a deliverance is emphatically, whether we will or no, the demand of the age in which we ourselves live. All intellectual pursuits our age judges according to their power of helping to satisfy this demand; of all studies it asks, above all, the question, how far they can contribute to this deliverance.36
Arnold Wnds ‘a mighty agent of intellectual deliverance’37 in the literature of ancient Greece, and he employs ‘the idea of the common modernity of Periclean Athens and Victorian Britain to assert the direct relevance of the literary achievement of Greece for British literary life’.38 He praises Aeschylus and especially Sophocles for their idealized representation of the heroic world and their ‘positive cultural function in their own modern age’.39 Aristophanes, whom, 34 Turner (1981), 22. 35 Arnold was the Wrst Professor of Poetry at Oxford whose lectures were delivered in English rather than Latin. 36 Arnold (1857a), in Super (1960), i. 18–37, at 19. 37 Ibid. 20. 38 Turner (1981), 28. 39 Ibid. 29.
162
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
to a large extent over the next two decades, Arnold assimilated to his own critical and literary creed, is defended for his equally positive value to Wfth-century Athenian society in his ability to expose fundamental truths through comedy. Euripides is barely mentioned40 in the course of Arnold’s lecture, and is thus condemned by exclusion. Unlike Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Aristophanes, Euripides did not provide in his drama the requisite intellectual deliverance, which Arnold sought for his own age of confusion from the literature of the Greeks. In one respect Arnold’s silence on Euripides was less detrimental than his voluble praise of Sophocles; at least he had not made Euripides the prosaic emblem of a reactionary cause. In his inaugural lecture at Oxford, Arnold’s deWnition of Sophocles’ supreme attribute and greatest legacy comes as a thunderous anticlimax: ‘The peculiar characteristic of the highest literature—the poetry—of the Wfth century in Greece before the Christian era, is its adequacy; the peculiar characteristic of the poetry of Sophocles is its consummate, its unrivalled adequacy.’41 As Jenkyns wryly comments: ‘Arnold made Sophocles, the man who ‘‘saw life steadily, and saw it whole’’, the patron saint of his crusade against the Philistines, but he made him sound so dull. . . . Who would join a crusade that had ‘‘Adequacy’’. . . emblazoned upon its banners?’42 On the rare occasions when Arnold breaks his silence on Euripides, in order to compare him unfavourably with Aeschylus and Sophocles, he does not entirely do him a disservice. In the Preface to Merope (also written in 1857), for example, Arnold distances himself from those critics who condemn Euripides outright and, in the process of declaring the moral essence of Euripides’ work inferior to that of Aeschylus and Sophocles, he manages to make Euripides sound an intriguing and colourful, if ethically problematic, poet: ‘In none of the extant dramas of Aeschylus or Sophocles is there a character which is entirely bad. For such a character we must go to Euripides; we must go to an art—wonderful indeed, for I entirely dissent from the unreserved disparagers of this great poet—but an 40 Euripides is mentioned just once, and in passing, towards the end of the lecture, where he is grouped with Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Aristophanes as one of the chief dramatic poets of the 5th century whose work has survived. 41 Arnold (1857a), in Super (1960), i. 18–37, at 28. 42 Jenkyns (1980), 105.
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
163
art of less moral signiWcance than the art of Sophocles and Aeschylus; we must go to tragedies like the Hecuba, for villains like Polymestor.’43 As Jenkyns implies,44 Arnold’s creation of a dull Sophocles and a shadowy Euripides may have unwittingly contributed to a general revival of interest in Euripides in late nineteenth-century Britain.
NIETZSCHE AND THE SOCRATIC MASK At the beginning of 1872 a new and extreme form of assault on Euripides was launched within Germany with the publication of Friedrich Nietzsche’s (1844–1900) Die Geburt der Trago¨die aus dem Geiste der Musik (The Birth of Tragedy from the Spirit of Music). The novelty of Nietzsche’s assault lay not in his treatment of Euripides, but in the nature of his overall reading of Greek tragedy, wherein, against the entrenched classicism of his day and its championship of Sophocles, he proclaimed a primitivism, or archaism, which had Aeschylus as its prototype. Its extremism, on the other hand, was in the thesis itself and, speciWcally, Nietzsche’s apportionment of blame for the demise of the tragic medium. Nietzsche had adopted, and taken to its utmost limit, Schlegel’s evolutionary scheme, his theory of degeneration in literature. Whereas Schlegel had seen Euripides as the agent through which tragedy’s decline was eVected, Nietzsche branded him its very murderer.45 Nietzsche had Wrst made this accusation publicly two years earlier, in the second of two lectures on ancient drama, ‘Sokrates und die Trago¨die’ (‘Socrates and Tragedy’), which was delivered on 1 February 1870. In this lecture he based his argument on what was commonly accepted as the Aristophanic interpretation of Athenian culture (as derived principally from The Frogs), and drew a direct link between Socratic rationalism in Euripidean drama and the death of the Aeschylean tragic form. He develops this thesis in chapters 43 Arnold (1857b), in Super (1960), i. 38–64, at 55. 44 Jenkyns (1980), 105–6. 45 As Henrichs (1986), 369–97, at 381 points out, Nietzsche added to the familiar Romantic cycle of birth, maturity and death, a ‘post-mortem phase, which he perceived as a new birth, or a modern renaissance’.
164
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
11–14 of The Birth of Tragedy.46 In the opening chapters he sets out the antithesis, which will dominate his argument, between the Apolline and Dionysiac impulses in art, that is, according to Nietzsche, the only genuine impulses in art. In chapter 12 he declares: Dionysus had already been scared from the tragic stage, and in fact by a demonic power which spoke through Euripides. Even Euripides was, in a certain sense, only a mask: the deity that spoke through him was neither Dionysus nor Apollo, but an altogether new-born demon, called Socrates. This is the new antithesis: the Dionysian and the Socratic, and the art-work of Greek tragedy was wrecked on it. . . . The most magniWcent temple lies in ruins. . . . And even that Euripides has been changed into a dragon as a punishment by the art-critics of all ages—who could be content with this wretched compensation.47
Henrichs demonstrates convincingly that the fundamentals of Nietzsche’s invective against Euripides are derived from Schlegel, and that Nietzsche oVers little that is original, insightful, or based on a close reading of the poet he maligns. Moreover, Henrichs rightly argues that the Euripidesbild in The Birth of Tragedy is Schlegelian theory unqualiWed and unmitigated, a direct consequence of the climate attending its embryonic form: Nietzsche was raised in an intellectual climate rife with harsh criticism of Euripides. When he entered the elite boarding school of Schulpforta in the fall of 1858, the modern depreciation of Euripides that began, in Germany, with Johann Gottfried Herder (1744–1803) and culminated in the Schlegels, had attained the status of absolute academic orthodoxy. Two generations of schoolmasters and university professors had managed to deprive August Wilhelm’s verdict of its Wner, more conciliatory touches and to reduce it to a crude catalogue of the poet’s worst sins against dramatic convention and good taste.48
Nietzsche’s condemnation of Euripides motivated two polemical pamphlets in response from a fellow alumnus of Schulpforta four years his junior, Ulrich von Wilamowitz-MoellendorV (1848–1931), who had been compelled by Rudolph Scho¨ll to review the book and was destined to become, in William M. Calder III’s phrase ‘sospitator 46 For an exposition of Nietzsche’s argument in these chapters, see Silk and Stern (1981), 73–77. 47 Nietzsche (1872), in Levy (1909), i. 95–6. 48 Henrichs (1986), 369–97, at 373.
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
165
Euripidis’.49 On 30 May 1872 Wilamowitz published a thirty-two-page attack entitled Zukunftsphilologie! Eine erwidrung auf Friedrich Nietzsches ‘Die Geburt der Trago¨die’ (Future-Philology! A Rejoinder . . . ). Erwin Rohde (1845–98), for many years before his Wnal apostasy a staunch friend and defender of Nietzsche’s, counterattacked with his own pamphlet Afterphilologie (Pseudo- (or ‘Backside’) Philology), which prompted a twenty-four-page rejoinder from Wilamowitz, Zukunftsphilolgie! Zweites Stu¨ck, published on 21 February 1873.50 To an even greater extent than Schlegel,51 Nietzsche’s argument is constructed largely on generalizations, and his references to the actual plays of Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Euripides are made in a very desultory fashion.52 The only Euripidean play on which he comments is the Bacchae in chapter 12, while the Alcestis is alluded to in chapter 8. As Henrichs maintains, the function of Euripides within the design of The Birth of Tragedy was essentially a negative one; but, ultimately and ironically, the portrait of Euripides that emerged from Nietzsche’s study had a positive impact on the playwright’s subsequent reception by re-igniting the debate on ancient tragedy in the last decades of the nineteenth century: ‘Nietzsche was not interested in Euripides per se, but he needed him as a reverse image of Aeschylus, the true tragedian, and as negative proof for his 49 ‘Sospitator Euripidis’ forms part of the title of a discussion by Calder (1986), 409–30, of Wilamowitz’s rehabilitative work on Euripides. He opens this discussion by citing some striking bibliographical statistics: ‘Athenian tragedy always remained a center of his [Wilamowitz’s] interest. Within this center he wrote least on Sophocles, more on Aeschylus, but most on Euripides. The Hiller/KlaVenbach bibliography lists 45 items on Euripides, against 19 on Aeschylus and 18 on Sophocles’ (409). 50 Wilamowitz’s pamphlets are reprinted in Gru¨nder (1969), 27–55 and 113–35. See also Calder (1983), 214–54, and Silk and Stern (1981) 95–107. Lloyd-Jones (1982), 178 has summarized the dispute between Nietzsche and Wilamowitz thus: ‘Wilamowitz asked, ‘‘What can we do for philology?’’; Nietzsche preferred to ask, ‘‘What can philology do for us?’’ To the classicists, with whom Nietzsche’s standpoint has so much in common, the ancients had supplied a pattern, an ideal standard of excellence; for the historicists with their relativistic outlook no such thing could exist.’ 51 Henrichs’s claim (1986), 369–97, at 381 that ‘Schlegel’s points are always speciWc and based on a close reading of Euripides’ cannot be supported by the relevant Lectures themselves. 52 According to Silk and Stern (1981), 62, crude generalizations are a consistent Xaw in Nietzsche’s argument: ‘Nietzsche frequently alludes, without explaining the allusions, to more or less well-known features of Greek tragedy or the Greek world; he gives virtually no dates for artists, thinkers, or events, ancient or modern; and he sometimes makes points that rest, clearly enough, on unstated presuppositions.’
166
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
overall concept of tragedy. That concept, for better or worse, turned out to be an inWnitely greater source of inspiration for subsequent critics than anything Schlegel ever said on the subject of tragedy.’53 Silk and Stern arrive at a very similar conclusion, believing that, despite his gross unfairness to Euripides, Nietzsche’s treatment of the poet had the virtue of being ‘consistently right in raising the right issues’,54 and that, of the three tragedians, it is Euripides whom Nietzsche unwittingly succeeds in bringing to life: It is perhaps to the point that if Nietzsche shows no sympathy with Euripides, he nevertheless pays him the compliment of empathy. Where Aeschylus and Sophocles remain shadowy Wgures, Euripides is made real. He sits in the theatre and thinks (§11); he is a ‘passionate actor’ (§12); in the ‘evening of his life’ he recants (§12). Accurately or not, Nietzsche ‘goes into’ him, in fact he psychologizes him—and thereby, without any such intention, vindicates one of Euripides’ own supreme innovations.55
THE BEGINNING OF EURIPIDES’ REHABILITATION That The Birth of Tragedy made little immediate impression on English criticism is attested by the fact that in 1873 it is Schlegel’s attack on Euripides to which John Addington Symonds (1840–93) responds in the Wrst series of the Wrst edition of his Studies of the Greek Poets. What Symonds has in common with Nietzsche, however, is his deployment of Schlegel’s degeneration theory as a premise and point of departure for his own interpretation of tragedy’s evolution; the diVerence being that Symonds is now acting as an apologist for Euripides. Symonds begins his interpretation with the claim: ‘The law of inevitable progression in art, from the severe and animated embodiment of an idea to the conscious elaboration of merely aesthetic motives and brilliant episodes, has hitherto been neglected by the critics and historians of poetry.’56 Symonds refers, Wrst in broad terms, to three generations of artists and to the qualities that necessarily deWne each of these, concluding of the third generation: 53 Henrichs (1986), 369–97, at 385. 55 Ibid. 262.
54 Silk and Stern (1981), 258. 56 Symonds (1873), i. 207.
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
167
They have either to reproduce their models—and this is stiXing to true genius; or they have to seek novelty at the risk of impairing the strength or the beauty which has become stereotyped. Less deeply interested in the great ideas by which they have been educated, and of which they are in no sense the creators, incapable of competing on the old ground with their elders, they are obliged to go aWeld for striking situations, to force sentiment and pathos, to subordinate the harmony of the whole to the melody of the parts, to sink the prophet in the poet, the hierophant in the charmer.57
He then applies this law of sequence to Greek sculpture, the three orders of Greek architecture, proto-Renaissance and Renaissance painting, and Wnally to the three tragedians. He draws a parallel between Correggio and Euripides, whose function in this schema is to illuminate their artistic genealogy and serve as archetypal specimens of that genealogy’s natural end: ‘Those who rightly understand them must, we imagine, be prepared to accept with gratitude the existence of Correggio and Euripides, both as complementing Giotto and Æschylus and also as accounting for the meridian splendour of Sophocles and Raphael. Without the cadence of Euripides the majestic aria of Sophocles would hardly be played out. . . . It is thus, as it were, that like projectiles, arts describe their parabolas and end.’58 Symonds’s strategy, therefore, is not to deny the majority of defects of which Schlegel accuses Euripides, but instead to demonstrate that these defects have an intrinsic historical and evolutionary value: ‘Cultivated in all innovations of morality and creed, Euripides belonged essentially to his own day. As far as a tragic dramatist can be the mouthpiece of his age, Euripides was the mouthpiece of Athenian decline. . . . Aeschylus was the Titanic product of a bygone period; Sophocles displayed the pure and perfect ideal; but Euripides was the artist who, without improving on the spirit of his age, gave it a true and adequate expression.’59 The achievement of Euripides, Symonds insists, must be gauged within the context of its own time. He voices his impatience with adherents to Schlegel’s school of thought, whom he brands a ‘malevolent generation of critics’.60 These critics, he argues, oVend against the law of sequence, which he applies to art, by making comparisons across the generations and neglecting the inherent 57 Ibid. 208. 59 Ibid. 201.
58 Ibid. 209. 60 Ibid. 211.
168
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
worth of each of art’s evolutionary phases: ‘It is false criticism, surely, to do as Schlegel, Mu¨ller, and Bunsen have successively done to measure Euripides by the standard of the success of his predecessors, or to ransack his plays for illustrations of pet dramatic theories, and then because he will not bear these tests, to refuse to see his own distinguished merits.’61
THE I RISH REBELS: MAHAFFY AND WILDE In a footnote to his commendation of Browning’s Balaustion’s Adventure in the second volume of the third edition of his Studies in 1893, Symonds acknowledges: ‘Since this chapter was Wrst published, Mr. Browning has still further enforced his advocacy of Euripides by Aristophanes’ Apology, while the great tragic poet has found a staunch defender from the carping criticasters of the Schlegel school in Dr. MahaVy.’62 The Revd John Pentland MahaVy (1839–1919) was a Fellow, and later Provost, of Trinity College, Dublin, and Professor of Ancient History in the University of Dublin. Having converted from philosophy to the study of history early in his career, his best-known works are his Social Life in Greece from Homer to Menander (1874), Rambles and Studies in Greece (1876), a four-volume History of Classical Greek Literature (1880), and Greek Life and Thought from the Death of Alexander to the Roman Conquest (1887). MahaVy was a complex character, whose scholarship reXected an interesting paradox in his thinking. He believed resolutely that the value of scholarly enquiry into ancient civilizations was as a guide to the complexities of modern life and to understanding the universality of human nature. He attracted controversy, notoriety, and eventually allegations of heresy with his unromantic portrait of the Greeks and their seemingly modern failings, his candid discussion of the Greek practice of homosexuality, and his conviction that ‘sophisticated Christianity absorbed, to its advantage, much of the higher ethics of classical antiquity’.63 But, while his outspokenness on these issues earned him the reputation of a maverick, he betrayed, 61 Symonds (1873), 230.
62 Ibid. ii. 57.
63 Stanford (1984), 241.
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
169
politically and temperamentally, little aYnity with the ideals of Periclean Athens. According to Stanford: ‘MahaVy’s favourite form of citizenship in the classical world was not that of a small freedomloving city-state like Athens or Sparta. He would have preferred to have been a citizen of one of the great Hellenistic monarchies (whose kings were generous patrons of scholarship) that arose after the death of Alexander the Great, and he saw their nearest modern equivalent in the British Empire.’64 Moreover, as a staunch Unionist he was deeply hostile to Irish culture and political nationalism in any form; it has been argued that ‘MahaVy did not merely embody reactionary Hellenism, he sought to justify British imperialism in Ireland through his work as a classical scholar as well’.65 In his pronouncements on Euripides, however, MahaVy is seen at his least reactionary and most provocative. Indeed, his partiality for the tragedian, which he demonstrated on several occasions throughout his career, became a facet of his notoriety. In 1867, at the theatre of the Royal College of Science in Dublin, he delivered a lecture entitled ‘Three Epochs in the Social Development of the Ancient Greeks’, in the course of which he judged Euripides to be superior to Sophocles. In 1879 he produced, as part of a ‘Classical Writers’ series, a primer on the playwright, outlining Euripides’ biographical details and the chief stylistic and dramatic qualities of his verse. As Stanford and McDowell indicate: ‘Though intended for beginners, it was by no means negligible for scholars, especially in a period when Euripides was still generally regarded as inferior to Sophocles.’66 Most unusually for a general study of Euripides in this era, MahaVy provides some discussion of the Herakles, and in a manner that is neither perfunctory nor depreciatory. He Wrst mentions the play in chapter 5, where it is lauded as being ‘among the best of the poet’s works’,67 and used as an anomalous example in an analysis of Euripides’ dramas of character and situation, because it ‘is so striking in its combination of two subjects that it almost deserves to be called a drama of plot’.68 In chapter 7, after summarizing the plot, and particularly the progression of Herakles’ rehabilitation in the 64 Ibid. 220. 65 Macintosh (1994), 5. 66 Stanford and McDowell (1971), 160. 67 MahaVy (1879), 81. 68 Ibid. 82.
170
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
second half of the play, MahaVy aYrms that Herakles, in the aftermath of madness, is one of Euripides greatest and most complete tragic creations: ‘The dignity of a great nature asserts itself against the utmost which a spiteful Providence can do to break it down. . . . Here then we have a truly great and tragic Wgure, one worthy of a permanent place in the temple of Fame.’69 MahaVy sees Herakles as exceptional among Euripidean characters in having a stature and grandeur commensurable with the heroes found in Aeschylus and Sophocles. In chapter 8 he lists verse 1163 of Herakles as an example of Euripides’ ‘peculiarly eVective’ use of lyric metre: ‘Theseus enters as a digniWed stranger, and marvels at the confusion of the house and the bodies of the dead, the aged Amphitryon answers his iambic questioning in extraordinarily hurried and agitated metre (resolved dochmaics), which give a peculiarly dramatic eVect to a splendid scene.’70 Chapter 10 of MahaVy’s study is a synopsis of the history of Euripidean reception, beginning with Aristophanes: ‘We may say that no Greek poet ever received more constant and unsparing adverse criticism, and from the ablest possible critic [i.e. Aristophanes]. To have outlived, nay, to have conquered such attacks, is in my mind an astonishing proof of genius.’71 When he reaches his own century, MahaVy, like Symonds, takes particular issue with Schlegel: The weak points of Schlegel’s criticism were his dislike of the French and depreciation of Euripides. Perhaps on account of Racine’s, Voltaire’s, and AlWeri’s preference, and in opposition to it, every fault was found with Euripides and every merit denied. . . . The fashion at last set in against the poet, and the jibes of Aristophanes were exalted into the canons of criticism. The present century, while correcting the antipathies of Schlegel’s school, has nevertheless not reinstated Euripides completely into his former position. . . . Many recent editors and historians, and one of our greatest poets, Mr. Browning, have set themselves to assert for Euripides his true and independent position beside these rivals, who have failed to obscure or displace him. The Germans, still infected by Schlegel, talk of Euripides as the poet of ochlocracy, that debased democracy which they have invented at Athens after the suggestion of Thucydides.72 69 MahaVy (1879), 107. 71 Ibid. 129–30.
70 Ibid. 119. 72 Ibid., 142–3.
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
171
MahaVy’s advocacy of Euripides’ genius, and his nonconformist regard for the Herakles, may well have had a profound inXuence on the most famous of his pupils, Oscar Wilde (1854–1900). MahaVy, whom Wilde credited as ‘my Wrst and best teacher’ and ‘the scholar who showed me how to love Greek things’,73 was Wilde’s tutor from the commencement of his three years at Trinity College, Dublin (1871–4), during which time he was awarded both a Foundation Scholarship and the Berkeley gold medal for achievement in Greek. After Wilde went on a Demyship up to Magdalen College, Oxford, with MahaVy’s blessing, he maintained reasonably close contact with his former tutor, even assisting him in the revision and proof-reading of his Social Life in Greece and Rambles and Studies in Greece. In April 1877 Wilde accompanied MahaVy on a tour through Greece.74 Part of MahaVy’s purpose in inviting Wilde was to prevent the latter’s intended pilgrimage to Rome, prompted by his developing interest in Catholicism, and to sway him ‘from Popery to Paganism’.75 While at Oxford, Wilde kept a commonplace book76 in which the scope of his reference extended well beyond the prescribed texts of his course, and he routinely applied himself to questions of art and beauty and demonstrated a facility for interweaving classical and contemporary issues. The commonplace book contains ten references to Euripides, including citations of four speciWc plays (Bacchae, Ion, Cyclops, and Electra).77 The Wrst of these references is part of a brief discussion of the Aristophanic legacy in Euripidean reception: The Frogs of Aristophanes form an era both in the development of comedy, and the history of literary criticism. Euripides, who was criticised by the conservatives of his own day much as Swinburne is by the Philistines of ours, is there attacked for the laxity and extravagance of his metres as well as for the immorality of his teaching: and there are in the main the two channels into which the stream of Greek 73 In a letter probably written in 1893. See Ellman (1987), 27. A change in their relationship is signalled by Wilde’s anonymous and predominantly scathing review in the Pall Mall Gazette (1887) of MahaVy’s Greek Life and Thought. An irrevocable breach in their friendship occurred after Wilde’s arrest and disgrace. 74 See Stanford and McDowell (1971), 38 V. 75 MahaVy in a letter to his wife (dated 2 April 1877), quoted in Stanford and McDowell (1971), 41. 76 Repr. in Smith and Helfand (1989), 107–74, with notes at 175–201. 77 On Wilde’s treatment of Euripides in his commonplace book, see ibid. 26–7.
172
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
literary criticism Xowed—poets were criticised on ethical grounds, and on the grounds of style.78
In a later entry, which appears opposite comments on the stage history of the Bacchae, Wilde continues the theme of Euripidean reception, noting some of the poet’s more recent disciples, among whom he counts himself: Cited by the orators as a patriot, by Aristotle as the most tragic of poets, he was to the age of Menander the model and the delight[;] more than this, Euripides witnessed to nature in the stilted rhetoric of the Roman stage, in the studied pomp of the French Court: He fed the youth of Racine and of Voltaire, fanned into a Xame the genius of AlWeri, and occupied [such] great poets as Shelley, Schiller, Browning with the task of translating him. And we who toil in the heated quarries of modern life may perhaps—or is it only a fancy—gain some freedom of soul from his genius who was the great humanist of Hellas, the cor cordium of antiquity[.]79
Wilde’s other mentor at Trinity was Robert Yelverton Tyrrell, who had been appointed Professor of Latin at the age of 25 and was the founder and editor of the magazine Kottabos, to which Wilde contributed a number of translations and original poems. Among Wilde’s contributions was a sonnet entitled ‘A Vision’, which was Wrst published in Kottabos 2, Hilary Term 1877.80 It was inspired in part by Dante’s Divine Comedy and Elizabeth Barrett Browning’s ‘A Vision of Poets’, and is a poetic statement of the nineteenth-century reception of the three tragedians, Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Euripides: Two crowne`d Kings, and One that stood alone With no green weight of laurels round his head, But with sad eyes as one uncomforted, And wearied with man’s never-ceasing moan For sins no bleating victim can atone, And sweet long lips with tears and kisses fed. Girt was he in a garment black and red, And at his feet I marked a broken stone Which sent up lilies, dove-like, to his knees. Now at their sight, my heart being lit with Xame
78 CB [23] and [25], repr. in ibid. 113. 79 CB [130], repr. in ibid. 132. 80 The sonnet was later published in Poems, 1881.
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
173
I cried to Beatrice´, ‘Who are these?’ And she made answer, knowing well each name, ‘Æschylus Wrst, the second Sophokles, And last (wide stream of tears!) Euripides.’
Most remarkable of all, for the purposes of this survey, is a letter written by Wilde to George Macmillan, of the publishing Wrm, on 22 March 1879, Wve months after taking his degree and at a time when Wilde was seriously contemplating an academic career. Macmillan had been a member of MahaVy’s touring party in Greece in 1877, was a founder of the Hellenic Society,81 and, since January 1879, a full partner in his father’s Wrm, with special responsibility for publications on music, the classics, and natural history. In the letter, after expressing a desire to translate selections from Herodotus, Wilde writes: ‘I do not know how many Greek plays you intend publishing, but I have been working at Euripides a good deal lately and should of all things wish to edit either the Mad Hercules or the Phoenissae: plays with which I am well acquainted. I think I see what style of editing is required completely.’82 In his reply to this suggestion, two days later, Macmillan goes so far as to oVer Wilde a fee for the tendered work: half-proWts and an advance of £25 or £30 for Herodotus and halfproWts or £45 down for the plays. Unfortunately these negotiations never came to fruition, and Wilde’s ambitions as a scholarly editor seem to have been abandoned in the wake of his failure to secure a Fellowship at Magdalen.83 Nevertheless, the very fact that so celebrated and iconic a literary Wgure should, in the formative years of his career, have expressed a particular familiarity with, and wish to edit, what was at that time still a relatively obscure play, remains extraordinary.84 It is interesting to speculate that, had the proposed edition of Herakles been submitted and published within a reasonable 81 Founded in 1879. MahaVy was a co-founder of the Society, which counted Wilde and John Addington Symonds among its members. 82 Repr. in Holland and Hart-Davis (2000), 78. 83 See Guy and Small (2000), 67. 84 Calder (in correspondence with the author, 5 May 2002) believes the subconscious reason behind Wilde’s attraction to the Herakles is that ‘it is the dream play for a male homosexual: the super athlete/hero/big guy murders wife and children to run oV with boyfriend’. This psychoanalytic explanation seems unlikely, and there is certainly no evidence to suggest that Wilde’s interest in the play was based on a homoerotic reading of the relationship between Herakles and Theseus.
174
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
period of time after Wilde’s correspondence with Macmillan, it would have been the Wrst separate nineteenth-century edition of the text published in Britain and would have preceded Wilamowitz’s seminal edition by several years.
SWINBURNE’S SCENIC SOPHIST Wilde’s pairing in his commonplace book of Euripides and the English poet and essayist Algernon Charles Swinburne (1837–1909) as objects of philistine scorn would have been regarded by Swinburne, at best, as a most unholy alliance and a comparison deeply degrading to himself. A younger contemporary of the Brownings, Swinburne nurtured a lifelong hatred, of fantastic and almost pathological proportions, towards Euripides—a hatred, moreover, in which he always asserted he was supported by Benjamin Jowett. In a letter to his friend Sir Edmund Gosse, dated 2 January 1876, he expressed, with scatological frenzy, violent indignation at the description, which had appeared in the previous day’s Athenaeum, of his Erectheus as ‘a translation from Euripides’: When a fourth form boy could see that as far as it can be said to be modelled after anybody, it is modelled throughout after the earliest style of Æschylus—the simple three-parts-epic style of the Suppliants, Persians, and Seven against Thebes: the most radically contrary style to that of the scenic sophist (with his ‘droppings,’ as Mrs. Browning aptly rather than delicately puts it) that could possibly be conceived. I should very much like to see the play of Euripides which contains 500 consecutive lines that could be set against as many of mine. I did introduce a good deal of the ‘long and noble fragment’ referred to, into Praxithea’s Wrst long speech—but the translated verses (I must say it) were so palpably and pitiably inferior both in thought and expression to the rest that the Wrst persons I read that part of the play to in MS . . . remarked the falling oV at once—the discrepancy, and blot on the face of my work—so I excised the sophist—wiped up and carted oV his ‘droppings’—only keeping a hint or two, and one or two of his best lines. If this sounds ‘outrecuidant’ or savouring of ‘surquedry,’ you may remember that I always have maintained it is far easier to overtop Euripides by the head and shoulders than to come up to the waist of Sophocles or the knee of Æschylus.
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
175
‘Sympathetic touch which distinguishes the two—there are but two— tragic poets’! Have such critics neither eyes nor ears? Or is there really a human reader who does actually Wnd Phædra, Hecuba, Medea, Iphigenia, more pathetic than Antigone, or the Oresteia? . . . And then—the ‘prodigality of splendid imagery such as Wnds no place’ (heavens and earth!) ‘in Greek literature’!!! Well, it certainly doesn’t in Euripides, who was troubled with a dysentery of feeble imagination and a diarrhœa of rhetorical sophistry.85
Thirteen years later, in a discussion of Ben Jonson’s Discoveries, Swinburne referred to Euripides with alliterative venom as ‘that Xuent and facile dealer in Xaccid verse and sentimental sophistry’.86 Later in the same study, deploring Jonson’s egregious lapse of literary judgement in ascribing perfection to Euripides, he singles out the Herakles as proof of Euripides’ outrageous crimes: It is unlucky that . . . Ben Jonson should have committed himself to the assertion that Euripides, of all men, ‘is sometimes peccant, as he is most times perfect.’ The perfection of such shapeless and soulless abortions as the Phoennissae and the Hercules Furens [n.b. the two Euripidean works which Oscar Wilde particularly wished to edit] is about as demonstrable as the lack of art which Ben Jonson regretted and condemned in the author of Hamlet and Othello.87
PHILOLO GY A ND TRA NSL ATION Paradoxically, while Germany was the centre for the century’s most persistent and vociferous disparagement of Euripides, it also produced the most sustained and large-scale editorial work, which fostered a revival of interest in the poet and a movement towards his rehabilitation. Throughout the whole of the nineteenth century very few separate editions of the Herakles were published. The Wrst was that of Gottfried Hermann (1772–1848) in 1810. Hermann had been made Professor of Poetry at Leipzig in 1809, and the Herakles was the Wrst of thirteen Euripidean plays which he edited separately between 1810 and 1841. In his introduction to the text he remarks on
85 Repr. in Gosse and Wise (1927), viii. 221–2. 86 Swinburne (1889), 139. 87 Ibid. 179.
176
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
the paucity of inexpensive and satisfactory critical editions of Euripides with which he himself had been confronted, and elucidates his reasons for choosing to work on the Herakles: Quum Euripidis aliquam fabulam in publicis meis scholis interpretari constituissem, neque invenirem editionem, quae et exiguo pretio parabilis esset, nec textum haberet a criticis aut nimis, aut minus, quam par videretur, mutatum: ipse animum adieci ad edemdam aliquam huius poetae tragoediam. Praetuli autem aliis Herculem furentem, tum quod haec fabula in melioribus est, tum quod non est ex his, quae in carminibus antistrophicis nihil proprium habent, tum denique quod diYcultates, quibus laborat, maximam partem vinci posse videbatur.88 When I had decided to expound on some play or other of Euripides in my public lectures, I could not Wnd an edition that was readily available at a small price, nor could I obtain a text that had not been altered by editors either too much, or less than seemed proper. I turned my mind to the task of publishing some tragedy of this poet myself. But I preferred Hercules Furens to the others, not only because this play is among the better ones, but also because it is not among those which have nothing individual in the antistrophic verses, and Wnally because it seemed that the problems with which the play is aZicted were, for the most part, surmountable.
Just before his premature death August Julius Edmund PXugk (1803– 39) edited seven plays of Euripides, including Herakles, for a series produced at Go¨ttingen in which Wunder’s edition of Sophocles also appeared. For the next Wfty years in Germany, prior to Wilamowitz’s ground-breaking edition in 1889, it was only in complete editions of Euripides’ extant dramas that the Herakles received attention. These editions include those of August Matthiae (1769–1835), published in nine volumes, along with the Fragments and Scholia, between 1813 and 1829; the brothers Karl Wilhelm (1802–83) and Ludwig Dindorf (1805–71)—the younger brother edited Euripides in 1825 and Wilhelm Dindorf edited all the Greek dramatists, with notes and Scholia, for the Clarendon Press between 1832 and 1863;89 August Nauck (1822–92) in 1854; and Adolf KirchhoV in 1855. In addition to these works, Johann Adam Hartung (1802–67), a fervent admirer of 88 Hermann (1810), III. 89 A text of the whole was Wrst published in a single volume in 1830 as the Poe¨tae Scenici Graeci.
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
177
Euripides, analysed all the plays in his Euripides Restitutus, published between 1843 and 1845. During this period Wilamowitz produced his earliest work on Euripides, beginning in 1867 when he carefully scrutinized the entire preserved Euripidean corpus, including Rhesus, in composing his Valediktionsarbeit at Pforta. In this he cited verses 674–77 of the Herakles, a passage on lifelong service to the Muses, which supplied him with his motto: P Æ ÆØ a $ æØÆ ÆE % ÆØØ ıªŒÆÆØª ; Æ ııªÆ. c fi IıÆ, ÆNd K ØØ Y. I will never stop blending [in song] the Graces with the Muses, that most charming conjunction of goddesses. I don’t want to live without the Muses’ gifts; may I ever be among the crowned.
The passage reappeared on the dedication page of his edition of the play (dedicated to Schulpforta) and in the Nachwort to the second volume of his Platon. Wilamowitz’s schoolboy estimation of Euripides’ artistry conformed unreservedly to the contemporary orthodoxy. In his valedictory address he declared the playwright ‘a middling poet and a poor tragedian’, but his thorough and historical approach to Euripides’ plays was something radical and refreshing.90 Throughout his undergraduate years Wilamowitz’s opinion of Euripides gradually improved, and, most importantly, he realized that Euripides was the ideal poet with whom to launch his revolutionary hermeneutics. In 1875, the year of Browning’s Aristophanes’ Apology, he published his Habilitationsschaft, Analecta Euripidea, a programmatic work in which he initiated certain lines of enquiry that were later developed in his Herakles commentary. Above all, he rejected the canonized Sophocles and nineteenth-century classicism, and in place of these he substituted the ‘unclassical’ Euripides and historicism, ‘the art of seeing the Greek world as the Greeks saw it’.91 He approached philological interpretation in the manner of a biographer; he was concerned with the historical context in which a play was produced, and he was anxious to stress the similarities rather 90 See Calder (1986), 409–30, at 412.
91 Fowler (1990), 489–522, at 493.
178
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
than the diVerences between ancients and moderns. In the Analecta Euripidea Wilamowitz also demonstrated an early interest in the question of staging, the notion of the play as performance. The work includes an essay on the staging of Hippolytus. Although his maximum opus did not oYcially appear until 1889, Wilamowitz had formulated a plan to edit the Herakles as early as January 1877. At Greifswald on 10 September 1879 a manuscript version, comprising a text and translation,92 was presented as a gift to his father-in-law Theodor Mommsen (1817–1903) on the occasion of his silver wedding anniversary. The appropriateness of the gift was, on the face of it, extremely dubious in view of the play’s uxoricide and infanticide, not to mention Mommsen’s intransigent hostility towards Euripides.93 The point of the presentation, however, was as a scholarly tribute to Mommsen as mentor and as one whom, at that stage in his career, Wilamowitz revered as the Herakles of Wissenschaft and as a ŁE Iæ.94 In England, before the middle of the century, a few critical commentaries were printed in English (as opposed to Latin) on single plays of Euripides, but no attempt was made to annotate a collected edition. The three-volume edition of Euripides, Wrst published for Bibliotheca Classica between 1857 and 1860, by Frederick Apthorp Paley (1816–88) was unique in scale and remained the automatic recourse of English-speaking Euripidean commentators until at least the 1880s. Paley’s general method of annotation is described by Collard: Theatrical moments are rarely remarked. . . . What he gives his reader is a mixture of text-critical, grammatical, lexical, interpretative and contextual comment, with succinctly pointed comparative illustration, in a direct and unpretentious way. Metrical comment is conWned to identiWcation of the rhythms, except in dialogue trimeters. . . . In all this, Paley holds true to the editorial principles of the Bibliotheca Classica, but in one important respect he goes further: he is discreetly suggestive to the sensibility or emotions.95 92 Wilamowitz (1879). 93 Mommsen had roundly denounced Euripides in his Ro¨mische Geschichte (1854–6). He held several of the Aristophanic and Schlegelian prejudices against the poet, including an abhorrence of Euripidean women, as well as two of his own. He believed Euripides, the prophet of the oikoumene¯, to be subversive and anti-nationalistic, criticisms which anticipated the anti-Semitism and anti-Cosmopolitanism expressed in the third volume of his Ro¨mische Geschichte. 94 See Calder (1985), 80–110, at 95–6 and (1986), 409–30, at 418–19. 95 Collard (1996), 67–80, at 74.
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
179
The Herakles is the Wrst play in the third volume of Paley’s edition. Paley begins his account of its history by stating: ‘In several respects the Mad Hercules is a remarkable play. It diVers materially in the style and treatment from the other dramas of Euripides.’96 SigniWcantly, he Wnds in the play borrowings from the Aeschylean style of diction and Œ ºØ. He maintains that the Herakles ‘can hardly be said as yet to have obtained the editorial care that it deserves’,97 but he seems somewhat undecided as to its success. On the one hand, he says: ‘We shall be disposed, while we attach some value to it as a tragic experiment, not perhaps altogether congenial to the author’s mind, to doubt whether, for that very reason, the success was commensurate with the eVort,’98 while, on the other hand, he charges K. O. Mu¨ller with not having given the play’s merits a high enough estimate.99 In addressing the complaint of Mu¨ller and other German critics about the incongruity of the two main actions of the plot, Paley oVers a solution in the form of an aetiological connection between these two movements: The Wrst part of the play has . . . this direct relation to the last, that it represents the hero not only as a self-sacriWcing benefactor of mankind, but as the greatest deliverer of the Theban people, who, at the very moment of their joy and gratitude to the family of Hercules, are deprived of them by a crime which renders it legally impossible to retain Hercules in their city. Thus excluded from both Argos and Thebes, he has Athens only left as an asylum. The play therefore as a whole may be deWned to be ‘the history of the connexion of Hercules with the Athenian people’.100
The timing of Herakles’ madness and the signiWcance of the central epiphany and peripeteia are left unaccounted for by Paley. In 1875 J. T. Hutchinson and A. Gray of Cambridge University produced an edition of the Herakles ‘with introduction, notes, and analysis’, the text of which was based mainly on the editions of Paley and Nauck. In a prefatory note, dated December 1875, the editors acknowledge ‘the translation of the play contained in Browning’s Apology of Aristophanes [sic], which is especially remarkable for its Wdelity to the original’.101 What is also noteworthy is that Hutchinson and Gray anticipated the use of their edition in schools, 96 Paley (1860), iii. 3. 97 Ibid. 99 Ibid. 4. 100 Ibid. 6.
98 Ibid. 101 Hutchinson and Gray (1875), preface.
180
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
by quoting at length passages by classical authors to which they have referred. Between 1800 and 1880 no separate translation of the Herakles was published in England with the exception of Robert Browning’s, which formed part of Aristophanes’ Apology. All nineteen extant plays of Euripides, however, were translated literally in two volumes by Theodore Alois Buckley of Christ Church, Oxford, and Wrst published in 1850. A later edition of this work was among the nine editions of Euripides’ dramas in Browning’s library on its dispersal in 1913, and would appear to have been a more immediate galvanizing force behind Browning’s defence of Euripides in Balaustion’s Adventure and Aristophanes’ Apology than the work of either Schlegel or Matthew Arnold. In his introduction Buckley denigrates Euripides with such vehemence that it is astonishing that he regarded the considerable task of translation deserving of his time and labour, and the plays themselves of a wider English readership. ‘The inferiority of our author to the great tragedians’, he professed, ‘prevents our feeling much desire to enter upon the respective merits and demerits of his several plays, especially as we are completely anticipated by Schlegel, with whose masterly analysis every reader ought to be acquainted.’102 Despite this initial protestation of reluctance, Buckley swiftly summons the will to reiterate the most condemnatory of Schlegel’s assertions, including Euripides’ responsibility for the decline of tragic poetry, and to endorse the classicist conception of a correlation between the artist’s character and his art: ‘So great is the prodigality of slaughter throughout his dramas, that we can but imagine morbid cruelty to have formed a considerable ingredient in the disposition of Euripides. Even his pathos is somewhat tinctured with his taste for painful images.’103 Having noted the shortcomings, in subject, morality, and technique, which he, after Schlegel, Wnds in the poet’s work, and having bypassed any degree of subtlety or ambivalence present in Schlegel’s critique, Buckley is conWdent that ‘there is no true tragedy in Euripides’.104 Browning scribbled his wrathful response to this particular damnatio in his own copy of Buckley’s edition, and, according to DeVane, he ‘expressed himself so violently in Greek that the matter is better 102 Buckley (1850), i. p. vi.
103 Ibid. x.
104 Ibid.
Sophist, sceptic, sentimentalist
181
not translated’.105 What Browning must have objected to most strongly in Buckley’s crude attack was the translator’s observation ‘that the study of Aristophanes is indissolubly connected with that of our author. If the reader discover the painful fact that the burlesque writer is greater than the tragedian, he will perhaps also recollect that such a literary relation is, unfortunately, by no means conWned to the days of Aristophanes.’106 In Buckley’s attempt to perpetuate the Aristophanic caricature of Euripides, we Wnd his wearisome regurgitation of the most negative aspects of the Schlegelian position; and with the pedestrian and pedagogic quality of his literal prose translation and his querulous notes on the clumsiness of Euripides’ phrasing, Browning found much to censure and correct. The nineteenth-century damnatio of Euripides was a robust and clamorous orthodoxy which few were daring or fervent enough to challenge. As a consequence, before 1875 attempts to rehabilitate Euripides were desultory and largely unproductive. Admiration for this emblem of decadence amounted almost to a guilty pleasure, and was often deemed a symptom of maverick tastes and unsteady scholarship. While the Herakles excited modest interest in some distinguished quarters, until Browning and Wilamowitz it did not inspire a major piece of rehabilitative criticism or composition. There was a failure by Euripidean critics and champions alike to engage in a precise or meaningful way with the plays themselves. The prevailing portrait of Euripides during this period was, in essence, the annexation by Schlegel and others of an Aristophanic burlesque. The success of any rehabilitative counter-movement would therefore depend on a readiness to dismantle Aristophanic tradition and delve deeply into Euripidean tragedy for its own sake. 105 DeVane (1955), 352.
106 Buckley (1850), i. p. xi.
6 The Browning version: Aristophanes’ Apology and ‘the perfect piece’ Gilbert Murray’s self-confessed generalization that, throughout the ages, Euripides has been ‘loved by poets and despised by critics’,1 can, with some justiWcation, be applied to the nineteenth century and especially its attitude towards the Herakles. The greatest artistic contribution to the rehabilitation of Euripides as tragedian, which began in the latter half of the century, and to the nascent awareness of the Herakles’ excellence in particular, was undoubtedly made by Robert Browning (1812–89). In Aristophanes’ Apology (1875) Browning applies himself valiantly, and at length, to the whole issue of Euripidean reception, both ancient and modern; and, as the coup de graˆce in his defence of the playwright, he translates Herakles in full. The play is deemed by Browning ‘the consummate Tragedy’ (AA 3526), ‘the perfect piece’ (3534) by which to ‘test true godship’ (3529).
THE BROWNINGS AND EURIPIDES THE HUMAN Robert Browning’s enthusiasm for Euripides was largely inspired by his wife, Elizabeth Barrett (1806–61). A mutual love of Greek tragedy had been at the centre of their courtship, throughout which Barrett reworked her translation of Aeschylus’ Prometheus Bound, published in 1833, in close consultation with Browning. In their correspondence with each other, the two poets incorporated Promethean language and 1 Murray (1913), 1.
The Browning version
183
imagery into the context of their burgeoning relationship in a way that reXected the constraints of their respective situations.2 Barrett’s favourite tragedian was Euripides, and in her poem ‘Wine of Cyprus’ (1844), written two years before her elopement with Browning, she conceived in praise of the ancient poet an epithet and accompanying image that would often be invoked, and occasionally parodied, by other writers: Our Euripides, the human With his droppings of warm tears, And his touches of things common Till they rose to touch the spheres. (89–92)
Browning reprinted these lines as the preface to Balaustion’s Adventure, and in the epilogue, which follows the dramatic recitation of Alcestis in that poem, Balaustion professes to know The poetess who graved in gold, Among her glories that shall never fade, This style and title for Euripides, The Human with his droppings of warm tears. (2668–71)
After his wife’s death in 1861 and his subsequent relocation from Florence to London, Browning engaged in an intensive study of Euripides, who, King says, ‘became his frequent companion. Both his personal loss and the tragic vision of the aged poet helped sharpen the sense of reality which informs The Ring and the Book.’3 The Ring and the Book, the longest, and universally recognized as one of the greatest, of Browning’s works, was published in instalments between 1868 and 1869, and was based on the proceedings of a trial in Rome at the beginning of 1698 in which Count Guido Franceschini was charged with the murder of his young wife, Pompilia. There are ten verse narratives in the poem, which all concern the same crime and are each written from a distinct perspective. Contained in Book 10 is a startling defence of Euripides against the common imputation of atheism. Browning resurrects Euripides 2 See Prins (1991), 435–51 and Hardwick (2000), 32. 3 King (1968), 129.
184
The Browning version
and puts into his mouth a lengthy dissertation, addressed directly to Pope Innocent XII, in which the tragedian assumes the persona of a monotheistic prophet and proto-Christian whose particular form of paganism anticipated, by half-a-millennium, many aspects of Pauline teaching: Five hundred years ere Paul spoke, Felix heard,— How much of temperance and righteousness, Judgement to come, did I Wnd reason for, Corroborate with my strong style that spared No sin, nor swerved the more from branding brow Because the sinner was called Zeus and God? How nearly did I guess at what Paul knew? How closely came, in what I represent As duty, to his doctrine yet a blank? (1717–25)
Euripides is also made to assert, in marked contradiction of Schlegel and his disciples, that he ‘Adopted virtue as my rule of life’ (1710), and to claim for his work, far from a populist motive, a moral and didactic mission: And, what my heart taught me, I taught the world, And have been teaching now two thousand years. Witness my work,—plays that should please, forsooth! ‘They might please, they may displease, they shall teach, For truth’s sake,’ so I said, and did, and do. (1712–16)
In the preface to Prince Hohenstiel-Schwangau, Saviour of Society (1871), Browning quotes and supplies his own translation of lines 1275–80 of Herakles, in which the hero speaks bitterly of his frenzied murder of his family as his last crowning labour. But the poet’s most concentrated and large-scale defences of Euripides were Balaustion’s Adventure in 1871 and Aristophanes’ Apology in 1875, which included ‘transcriptions’ of Alkestis and Herakles respectively. Balaustion’s Adventure preceded the vindication of Euripides attempted by Symonds and MahaVy, and was written primarily in tribute to the memory of Elizabeth Barrett and her love of the tragedian. It deals with the theme of miraculous salvation, with Herakles emerging as a
The Browning version
185
Christ-like saviour Wgure, a fully rounded spiritual hero who exercises transcendent powers over Death.4 In Aristophanes’ Apology, however, can be found Browning’s ultimate expression of his personal kinship with the ancient poet and his ultimate riposte to Euripides’ critics and his own.
AR IS TOPHANES’ APOLOGY: CONTEMPORARY AND SUBSEQUENT RECEPTION Aristophanes’ Apology was published on 15 April 1875. It comprised 5,705 lines of verse, making it the third-longest of Browning’s works after The Ring and the Book and Sordello, and four times the length of any extant Greek tragedy.5 The poem was revised for the collected edition of 1888–9 and Browning added six lines throughout the text. It has a complex narrative and temporal structure of multiple layers. The subsuming narrative mode is a dramatic monologue spoken by the heroine Balaustion as she and her husband Euthukles sail to Rhodes after the destruction of Athens’ long walls by the Spartans. Within the ‘present’ of this monologue is built a dialogue, an extended agon between Balaustion and the comic poet Aristophanes, recollected from one year previously when Euthukles brought Balaustion news of Euripides’ death. Part of this dialogue is a transcription from Euripides, an uninterrupted and unedited recital of the Herakles which occupies 1,549 lines of the complete text. 4 Poole (1987), 139 observes that in Balaustion’s interpolative narrative Herakles ‘loses nothing of his rollicking pagan pedigree, but he acquires the aura of a spiritual life-force, which in its turn reinterprets the Wgure of Christ’. On Herakles’ Christ-like attributes in Balaustion’s Adventure, see Roberts and Prins (forthcoming), general introduction, sec. 4. With more speciWc reference to Euripides’ Herakles, Elizabeth Hasell (1874), 545–67, at 567, contemplated ‘the full spiritual signiWcance of the legend. . . . There are hints, but no more than hints, in the ‘‘Frenzied Hercules’’ of the dim inexplicable feeling which we cannot doubt haunted the mind of antiquity, that if ever the bonds of Hades were burst and its gates thrown open, it could only be at the cost of unexampled anguish . . . that if ever human nature raised above the stars it could only be in the person of one whose sorrows as well as his deeds should alike transcend the measure of human doing and suVering.’ 5 The Ring and the Book was published in monthly instalments from November 1868 to February 1869. It comprises twelve books (21,204 lines). Sordello was published in March 1840 and comprises six books (5,981 lines).
186
The Browning version
Contemporary critics,6 giving their attention mainly to the poem’s recondite style and the esoteric nature of its ostensible subject matter, typically treated the Apology as a scholarly curiosity. The reviewer for the Athenaeum of 17 April 1875 suggested, much to Browning’s annoyance, that the poem was conceived during a discussion of the conclusion of Plato’s Symposium between the poet and Benjamin Jowett, the Master of Balliol College (Browning was Jowett’s friend and an Honorary Fellow of Balliol).7 This suggestion is probably less than earnest, but, in making it, the reviewer has uncovered an important point, that the dramatic narrative surrounding the transcription is far more Platonic than Euripidean. The reaction of novelist and critic Margaret Oliphant, writing in Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine (July 1875), was indicative of the bewilderment and irritation that the Apology excited in many quarters: Three-fourths of the readers of English poetry are absolutely indiVerent to the question why Aristophanes attacked Euripides in his comedies, which is exactly one of those details which the dilettante critic delights in, but which convey neither information nor ediWcation to any one else. . . . The fact remains that Englishmen are not Greeks, and that no poem nor other work plentifully besprinkled with classic vocables, and made up of classic allusions, ever will or can be anything but caviare to the multitude, and never can or will be anything original or great.8
While there was consensus among the critics regarding the Apology’s demonstration of the poet’s erudition, there was a mixture of opinion on the quality of the verse. John Addington Symonds, whose review in the Academy (17 April 1875), although not unqualiWed in its praise, oVered the most favourable assessment of the poem’s merits, wrote: ‘Mr. Browning is unrivalled in the art of following thought through all its windings, tracing and retracing labyrinths of sophistry and prejudice, blending the specious and the true as he conceives them, the coarse and the reWned, spinning with words a closely-Wtting veil of gossamer for the spirit he imprisons in his verse.’9 By contrast, the
6 A representative selection of contemporary criticism on Aristophanes’ Apology is reproduced in Litzinger and Smalley (1970), 398–403. 7 For Browning’s reaction to this suggestion, see Hood (1933), 171. 8 Repr. in Litzinger and Smalley (1970), 401–2. 9 Ibid. 398.
The Browning version
187
reviewer in the Spectator (3 July 1875) thought Browning’s mastery of the stylistic elements of the Apology very dubious: Mr. Browning permits the passion for analysing character so to dominate him, that he becomes careless of things essential to his art. Sweetness, brightness, grace, melody, eloquence are either absent, or present at but the rarest intervals. Here and there he condescends to give us a glimpse of them. Once in some twenty pages or so comes a beautiful line, even a beautiful passage, though seldom this latter without some harshness to blot it.10
Other reviewers considered the poetry of the Apology inferior to the lyricism of Balaustion’s Adventure, and that, as a sequel, the work was a disappointing failure. A common feature of these immediate responses to Aristophanes’ Apology is their silence on the transcription from Euripides. Mrs Oliphant did make reference to Browning’s earlier transcription of Euripides’ Alkestis, and conceded that his most recent eVort was ‘a good translation of a great poem’.11 However, she saw the translation as a separate concern, and in no way a mitigation of the oVence she believed Browning had committed by his intellectual posturing, the ‘prank’ he had played ‘for the gratiWcation of a small and select audience’.12 In other reviews the translation is altogether ignored. The translation did, however, attract the appreciative attention of two notable contemporaries of Browning’s, the Greek scholar MahaVy and the historian, critic, and essayist Thomas Carlyle. MahaVy clearly regarded Browning as a great poet and a superior translator. In his concise survey of Euripides’ life and works, published in 1879, he reproduced the poet’s translation of two choric stanzas of Hippolytus (beginning at line 525), which, as he proudly revealed, Browning had specially made for him on 18 December 1878, ‘so that the general reader may not miss the meaning and spirit of the ode’.13 In chapter 5 of this volume MahaVy described the translation of Herakles in Aristophanes’ Apology as ‘admirable’14 and an invaluable resource for the English reader, and in his conclusion 10 Ibid. 402. 11 Ibid. 401. 12 Ibid. 402. 13 MahaVy (1879), 115. MahaVy used the translation again in A Survey of Greek Civilization (1897), paying tribute to ‘this great poet’. 14 MahaVy (1879), 82.
188
The Browning version
he included the Browning versions of Herakles and Alkestis in a list of ‘the best and most accessible helps to the study of the poet’.15 Soon after the publication of Aristophanes’ Apology, Carlyle wrote to Browning: ‘Ye won’t mind, though it’s the last advice I may give ye, but ye ought to translate the whole of the Greek tragedians—that’s your vocation.’16 This substantial endorsement of his skills as a translator persuaded Browning to undertake a translation of Aeschylus’ Agamemnon, which was published two years later. In his preface to this later work, Browning in fact states that Carlyle commanded him to do the translation, a responsibility that Carlyle was quick to disavow when he saw the ‘unreadable’17 result of his earlier exhortation. Browning sent a copy of Aristophanes’ Apology to Matthew Arnold soon after its publication, a gesture to which Arnold responded gallantly and graciously.18 It is also probable that Oscar Wilde had read the poem, since in June 1881 he sent Browning the Wrst copy of his poems as ‘the only tribute I can oVer you in return for the delight and the wonder which the strength and splendour of your work has given me from my boyhood’.19 In the twentieth century, scholarship on the Apology focused largely on the question of Browning’s classical sources and how necessary a knowledge of these is to a proper appreciation of the poem. Critics also asked whether the apologiae of Balaustion and Aristophanes relate to Wfth-century Athenian dramaturgy or whether they actually represent a clash of literary e¯the¯ in Victorian Britain; and they explored the ways in which Browning’s advocacy of Euripides’ poetic principles can be related to his own aesthetics. Seldom in these discussions, however, was Browning’s translation of Herakles more than cursorily examined. 15 MahaVy (1879), 144. 16 Quoted in GriYn (1910), 256. 17 See Carlyle’s comments on Browning’s translation of the Agamemnon recorded in Litzinger and Smalley (1970), 432–3. 18 In a letter dated May 20 1875, and reprinted in Lang (2000), iv. 262, Arnold thanked Browning for the poem, ‘which I shall keep to read when my summer holiday comes and I can read a poem steadily. It is sure to leave me with the impression which your writings from the Wrst have given me and which the writings of so few other living people give me—that the author is what the French call a grand esprit.’ 19 Holland and Hart-Davis (2000), 111. Wilde was certainly aware of Browning’s translations of Euripides since he refers to them in his Oxford commonplace book ([130], repr. in Smith and Helfand (1989) 132).
The Browning version
189
Sir F. G. Kenyon, editor of the 1912 centenary edition of The Works of Robert Browning, makes several pronouncements which are typical of the critical attitude that has persisted in relation to the transcription. In his introduction to Aristophanes’ Apology, Kenyon says: ‘Whereas in the earlier work [Balaustion’s Adventure] the main object was the translation, with which the comparatively slight setting was inextricably interwoven, in Aristophanes’ Apology, the main interest is in the setting and the translation might be detached, or ‘‘taken as read,’’ without aVecting the main theme.’20 He further maintains that the ‘discussion is complete in itself; the translation of the Hercules is only introduced by way of illustration of Balaustion’s triumphant advocacy of her beloved poet. It is a Wne translation of a Wne— though by no means perfect—play; but its interest is eclipsed by Browning’s own poem.’21 Kenyon’s comments are instructive because they demonstrate, Wrst, the misconception that the literalness of Browning’s translation, and the absence of authorial comment on the play, make the interest of the transcription to the reading of the poem minimal, and secondly, the opinion, long current, that the Herakles was a Xawed component of the Euripidean corpus. Similarly, William DeVane22 and R. A. King,23 in their evaluations of the Apology, believe the translation to be subordinate to the rest of the poem. DeVane seems to judge the comparative signiWcance of the translation and the surrounding debate in terms of length. ‘It is obvious’, he states, ‘that the Herakles holds no such central place in Aristophanes’ Apology as the Alcestis holds in Balaustion’s Adventure. The arguments of Balaustion and Aristophanes, in point of space, overwhelm the play by Euripides.’24 Donald Smalley25 and Jane McCusker26 have each made an interesting study of how the Apology aVords the reader insights into the conXicting ideals of poetry and the role of the poet espoused by Browning and his contemporaries. But they have failed to consider how, and to what extent, the translation of the Herakles is made relevant to an oblique commentary on the literary landscape of Victorian Britain, and how it is used to attest the truth of Browning’s 20 22 24 26
Kenyon (1912), viii. pp. v–vi. See DeVane (1955), 350 V. DeVane (1955), 376. See McCusker (1984), 783–96.
21 Ibid., p. vi. 23 See King (1968), 203 V. 25 See Smalley (1940), 823–38.
190
The Browning version
poetic creed. Towards the end of her essay, ‘Browning’s Aristophanes’ Apology and Matthew Arnold’, McCusker emphasizes that ‘the reader’s understanding of the poetic situation and of the poetic debates is created by the eVect of the whole poem, including Browning’s translation of the Herakles’.27 Yet, while she oVers a very thorough and cogent exposition of the way speciWc lines in the poem relate to details in the debate between Browning and Matthew Arnold, she never addresses the question of exactly what the choice of text for transcription contributes to ‘one of Browning’s fullest examinations of poetic theory’.28 More recently, Adam Roberts29 and Daniel Karlin,30 recognizing that the Apology has been a greatly neglected and misunderstood work, have presented fresh perspectives on the issue of Browning’s deployment of sources. Karlin explores the complex framework of dualities and oppositions in the poem and its central antithesis between love and hate, while Roberts treats the poem as ‘one of Browning’s most complex statements on the nature of Art and humanity’.31 Neither of these revisionist theses, however, deals with the translation of the Herakles. This brief synopsis of the major critical discourse on Aristophanes’ Apology since its publication should give some indication of how Browning’s Herakles has been the casualty of serious scholarly neglect. Two critics, however, while by no means providing a comprehensive dissection of the translation, have at least acknowledged its importance within the context of the poem. Frederick Monroe Tisdel sees Balaustion’s reply to Aristophanes as ‘Browning’s real contribution to the criticism of his time on the merits of Greek drama. It is his answer to the estimate of Schlegel, his eVort to do justice to the enduring worth of Euripides.’32 Although he erroneously states that the discussion between Balaustion and Aristophanes ‘closes’33 with the reading of the Herakles, Tisdel is conscious that, in determining how the translation aids a defence of Euripides’ genius, ‘the important consideration . . . is the way in which the play illustrates the 27 29 31 33
See McCusker (1984), 796. 28 Ibid. 795. See Roberts (1990–1), 32–45. 30 See Karlin (1993), chap. 7. Roberts (1990–1), 32–45, at 32. 32 Tisdel (1927), 1–46, at 11. Ibid. 5. In fact 626 lines (5,085–711) follow the transcription.
The Browning version
191
argument’.34 He thus lists, with appropriate examples, four ways in which the characterization, action, and language of the Herakles plainly answer the strictures of Aristophanes, and by extension Schlegel, upon Euripides.35 This list comprises Euripides’ humanization of Herakles; his humanization of the gods; his moralization on the subject of fate; and his use of maxims. If Browning’s intention in the transcription of Herakles is to answer Schlegel’s criticisms, his choice of text is a bold one. By selecting the Herakles, in which humanization of the heroic status and scepticism about the gods and accepted myths are critical elements, his purpose seems not categorically to refute Schlegel’s charges by proving their opposite, but rather to confront them directly by means of a literal translation through which the power and beauty of the original might be discovered and appreciated anew. Deviating in certain aspects from Tisdel’s thesis, Clyde De L. Ryals oVers a more complete understanding of the signiWcance of Browning’s very literal translation of Herakles to the structural and philosophical design of the poem.36 He attributes the eVectiveness of Browning’s defence of the tragedian not to the words spoken by Balaustion, but rather to the translation, which, he says, the poet ‘wished to be as neutral and objective in style as possible’.37 Within the framework of the Apology, Browning intended the Herakles to serve as the ‘pure statement, distinct from the biased utterances of Aristophanes and Balaustion’.38 The unembellished transcription, therefore, is made separate from the rather myopic arguments employed by Balaustion and Aristophanes, who each make concessions to the other’s viewpoint only for those concessions to be swiftly withdrawn and the pair’s original polar positions to be resumed. Ryals further maintains: ‘Browning must have reasoned that one way to circumvent the subjectivity of his monologist was to provide within the monologue a full-Xedged drama, the most objective of literary forms, unedited and without commentary.’39 He contends that Balaustion and Aristophanes each represent one pole of a dialectic—transcendental versus descendental, or soul versus 34 Tisdel (1927), 18. 35 See ibid. 18–22. 36 See Ryals (1975), chap. 5 and (1993), 196–9. 38 Ibid. 105. 39 Ibid. 104.
37 Ibid. 104–5.
192
The Browning version
body—and that the translation demonstrates that Euripides, by contrast, ‘speaking to both soul and sense, creates the kind of drama reXective of a true understanding of human nature’.40
T H E EV ID E N C E OF T H E B A L L I O L M A N U S C R I P T Ryals makes two elementary, but frequently overlooked, points which together suggest a radical approach to the study of the poem. He recalls the fact that the translation of Herakles preceded the composition of the surrounding poem by fourteen months,41 and insists that ‘the translation is not a mere Xexion of Browning’s classical muscles but an organic part of the work whose full title is Aristophanes’ Apology; Including a Transcript from Euripides: Being the Last Adventure of Balaustion’.42 Far from dismissing the transcription as a subordinate or detachable element in the work, Ryals in fact proposes that the Herakles is a logical point of entry into an analysis of the poem. Moreover, this approach to the poem accords with the order and method of construction which Browning himself followed and which can be deduced from the manuscript of Aristophanes Apology housed in Balliol College Library.43 In the manuscript the transcription and the beginning and conclusion of the poem are written on paper that is clearly margined and of superior quality to that on which the bulk of the work is composed.44 These sections were probably composed in London. The transcription itself is dated at the end ‘June 17 ’73.’ Some half-sheets of the same quality as the transcription have been pasted into the sections immediately preceding and following the Herakles, signalling the probability that while Browning was making the translation he was already giving thought to a context in which to place it. On the Wnal page of the manuscript Browning has written: ‘Begun about August 11—ended Saturday, Nov. 7 ’74, Mers Picardy.’ The 40 See Ryals (1975), chap. 5 and (1993), 112. 41 Ibid. 101–2. 42 Ibid. 104. 43 Balliol MS 389. 44 DeVane (1955), 376 has remarked on the diVering quality of the paper used in the ms to show that the composition of the poem had at least two distinct stages. He does not, however, draw any conclusions about the signiWcance of the order in which these stages occurred.
The Browning version
193
transcription has been numbered twice, Wrst, as folios 1–32 in the same black pen as the transcription itself and, secondly, in a brown pen as folios 112–70. Throughout the rest of the manuscript the pages have been numbered three and even four times, indicating the various stages of composition and reorganization. The chronological development of Aristophanes’ Apology suggests the following conclusion: that Browning wrote his translation of the Herakles as a complete work, an intellectual exercise in its own right and for its own sake, but that, at the same time, he envisaged the translation as a central part of a whole, the focal point of a comprehensive treatise on the reception of ancient drama and Euripides’ place in the tragic canon, and by extension a profession of poetic faith and a labour of love. I believe, therefore, that by observing the poet’s known modus operandi, and examining in detail his transcription of Herakles and the theory of translation by which it has been fashioned, the true substance of Browning’s consummate defence of Euripides is to be found.
B ROW N I N G’ S G R E E K A N D T H E NINETEENTH-CENTURY TRANSLATION DEBATE The principle of translation which Browning applies in the Herakles is key to understanding its intended signiWcance within Aristophanes’ Apology, especially when this principle is examined in terms of a comparison with the poet’s two other major transcriptions from Greek tragedy, namely Euripides’ Alkestis (1871) and Aeschylus’ Agamemnon (1877). In each of the three translations a distinct theory and methodology are discernible, and a diVerent experience of Greek tragic drama made available to the reader. The composition of these works coincided with an intense scholarly debate on the method which those attempting translations of Greek and Latin texts should employ. As Lorna Hardwick indicates: ‘The variety of approaches to translation and the broadening spectrum of authorship in the nineteenth century oVer evidence of Werce debate, not only about the nature and purposes of translation and its cultural and political implications, but also about the role of translation
194
The Browning version
in the lives and work of writers and in the perceptions of both the classically educated and the broader readership.’45 Crucial to this dispute, and not unfamiliar to our own era, was the question of ‘faithfulness’ to the original: how to deWne this abstraction in a way that was neither nebulous nor arbitrary, but that would provide translators with practical guidelines for their task. In order to arrive at any sort of deWnition, the theorist had to contend with several interrelated issues: the virtue, or otherwise, of literalism as a translational system; the beneWt to be gained from, and the sheer linguistic attainability of, lexical, syntactical, and conceptual accuracy; and the more philosophical and ethical dilemma of whether translation should entail a process of alienation or acculturation, that is, whether the translation should communicate to the reader a sense of the remoteness, in time, culture, and language, of the original text, or render Xuent and accessible what may be fractured and distancing. Two of the chief combatants in this controversy were Francis William Newman (1805–97) and Matthew Arnold. Newman’s translation of the Iliad (1856) into unrhymed English metre was made according to his theory that what was diYcult or strange in the original should be replicated in the translation by deliberate archaisms, in his case by the use of alliterative verse and words of Anglo-Saxon origin. Arnold heavily criticized this technique in his lectures ‘On Translating Homer’ (1860–1), which were intended to give practical advice to would-be translators of Homeric epic, accusing Newman of substituting his own eminent ignobility for Homer’s eminent nobility.46 Co-opting and paraphrasing Coleridge, Arnold proposes a contrasting theory: ‘It may be said of that union of the translator with his original, which alone can produce a good translation, that it takes place when the mist which stands between them—the mist of alien modes of thinking, speaking and feeling on the translator’s part—‘‘defecates to a pure transparency,’’ and disappears.’47 The conXict in approach between Newman and Arnold led to a surge in the publication of translations and essays on the practice of translation. It was against this background that Browning published 45 Hardwick (2000), 24. See also Daniel Weissbort’s general synopsis of 19th-century verse-translation theories in France (2000), 89–96, esp. 91–2, and the discussion by A. D. P. Briggs of how these theories were applied to the Greek tragedians, ibid. 356–67. 46 Arnold (1861), in Super (1960), i. 97–216, at 103. See contra, Newman (1861). 47 Arnold (1860–61), in Super (1960), i. 97–216, at 103.
The Browning version
195
his three complete transcriptions from Greek tragedy within the space of six years. His contribution to the debate, therefore, was one of practical demonstration; and the hallmark of his experimentation in the Weld of translation was versatility. It is Browning’s ability with these three translations to traverse the expanse between Newman and Arnold that is most noteworthy. Each translation serves a unique purpose and engages a technique appropriate to, and elucidative of, that purpose. Browning’s transcription of the Alkestis in Balaustion’s Adventure is essentially an adaptation of the Euripidean original, and has a number of features in common with a working playscript. In reciting, interpreting, and revising the text before a small audience of friends, the heroine Balaustion performs the role of a dramaturge presenting a read-through of the play. Similar to the structure of Aristophanes’ Apology, the recitation is, in fact, part of the adventure narrative in which Balaustion recalls how, making for Athens after the Sicilian disaster, she rescued herself and fellow Rhodians from attack by the Syracusans when she recited solo Euripides’ Alkestis. Her vivid reading of the drama is interspersed with lively descriptions of the action and characters, stage directions in verse, and explanatory digressions. Balaustion also outlines for her audience a new moral direction for the play, whereby Admetus’ character is purged of much of its weakness and ignobility. Ryals construes this method as ‘not a criticism but a ‘‘higher criticism’’ of the text. . . . Just as a modern hermeneuticist may look behind the literal accounts of the gospels to grasp the essence of the Christian message, Balaustion looks beyond the actual text to seize upon Euripides’ essential meaning.’48 Browning’s Alkestis is a recasting of Euripides, a creative appropriation that endows the ancient poet with an anachronistic historical consciousness. It demonstrates, therefore, a theory of translation which is almost the reverse of that operative in his two later transcriptions. The Agamemnon is Browning’s most literal translation, but its literalism is of a very diVerent order from that of his Herakles, and one for which the poet was greatly castigated at the time and has rarely been commended since. It is the only one of the three translations to which Browning appended a preface. In this he protests: 48 Ryals (1993), 177–8.
196
The Browning version
If, because of the immense fame of the following Tragedy, I wished to acquaint myself with it, and could only do so by the help of a translator, I should require him to be literal at every cost save that of absolute violence to our language. . . . I would be tolerant for once,—in the case of so immediately famous an original,—of even a clumsy attempt to furnish me with the very turn of each phrase in as Greek a fashion as English will bear. . . . Further, if I obtained a mere strict bald version of thing by thing, or at least word pregnant with thing, I should hardly look for an impossible transmission of the reputed magniloquence and sonority of the Greek. . . . I should expect the result to prove very hard reading indeed if it were meant to resemble Aeschylus. . . . All I can say for the present performance is, that I have done as I would be done by, if need were.49
Despite this anticipatory defence, Browning’s approach was most unwelcome. The extremely demanding, and often baZing, nature of his English was met with frustration and oVence. Even Browning’s usual admirers expressed perplexity and mild chagrin. Kenyon labelled the translation ‘a perverse tour de force’,50 and saw in it an oblique attempt by Browning to show his beloved Euripides in a favourable light by contrast. William Cranston Lawton believed Browning failed in the Agamemnon because he had misguidedly applied to Aeschylus the same literalist method which he had applied to the ‘easier’ verse of Euripides: ‘When Browning attempts to render these most diYcult Aeschylean choral songs in English verse, and rhymed verse, and at the same time to be niggardly, solemnly, absolutely literal, the result is too often but the disjecta membra of articulate speech.’51 In more recent times Yopie Prins has discerned a method to Browning’s madness and a purpose to his alleged perversity. She argues: The translation presents English as a foreign language that must be translated back into Greek in order to be understood. Ultimately, Browning’s Agamemnon undoes the opposition between the two languages altogether, as it moves into an interlingual realm that John Addington Symonds criticized for being ‘neither English nor Greek.’ However, rather than criticizing this
49 Browning (1877), in Kenyon (1912), viii. 293–365, at 293–4. The wording of Browning’s apologia closely recalls Jasper Heywood’s literalist cause as stated in the title-page of his translation of Seneca’s Hercules Furens. See above, Chap. 3. Undoubtedly, Browning was aware of Heywood’s translation. 50 Kenyon (1912), viii., p. xi. 51 Lawton (1897), 363–87, at 384.
The Browning version
197
radical linguistic estrangement, we might ponder how Browning’s translation serves as metaphor for the act of reading itself.52
Prins’s suggestion is that ‘Browning is interested in translation as a process of alienation that is also exacted in the process of reading’.53 She believes that ‘Aeschylus’ obscurity poses certain challenges to the reader, who must interact with the text in order to reenact both its meaning and its resistance to meaning. On this model of reading, the obscure is a necessary condition for the sublime.’54 This idea of purposeful obscurity appears much earlier in MahaVy’s assessment of Aeschylus’ ‘pregnant obscurity, as contrasted with the redundant obscurity of some modern poets or the artiWcial obscurity of the Attic epoch’.55 W. B. Stanford, writing half-a-century after MahaVy, qualiWes this by saying: ‘The poets of the 1930s and 1940s are nearer Aeschylus in their obscurities and ambiguities than were the ‘‘modern’’ poets of MahaVy’s day, though among them Browning and Hardy show Aeschylus’ direct inXuence.’56 Prins maintains that in the diYculty and obscurity of Aeschylean verse, Browning found ‘a precursor for his style, which is often described in terms of a catachrestic or ‘‘grotesque’’ literalism’.57 Stanford uses the word ‘catachresis’ to categorize instances where Aeschylus deliberately alters the meanings of words to suit his needs.58 Discussing Aeschylus’ neologisms, which are, for the most part, compound words, he states, ‘Aeschylus is straining language almost to the breaking point. One is reminded of the strained, distorted, almost grotesque, Wgures of a painting by El Greco.’59 Browning re-creates a similar tension in his translation of the Agamemnon, and, in so doing, resembles Gerard Manley Hopkins (1849–89), who broke with the conventional poetic diction of his time in reviving archaisms, appropriating dialect words, and employing coinages of his own to communicate hitherto unexpressed concepts, and produced in his verse an overall eVect of strangeness or, as he called it himself, ‘queerness’.60 52 Prins (1989), 151–70, at 152. 53 Ibid. 54 Ibid. 156. 55 MahaVy (1880), i. 275. 56 Stanford (1942), 128. 57 Prins (1989), 151–70, at 157. 58 Stanford (1942), 64. 59 Ibid. 65–6. 60 According to Gardner (1948), i. 112: ‘Taken altogether, his [Hopkins’s] lexical and syntactical neologisms, like his innovations in rhythm, produce an air of strangeness more marked than in any other English poet. . . . The aim of poetry being to move, to excite, the ‘‘foreign air’’ or strongly idiosyncratic Xavour of his verse is a powerful emotive factor.’
198
The Browning version
The diYcult style of Browning’s Agamemnon has also been accounted useful and eVective by British poet Tony Harrison (b. 1937) who, surprisingly, claims that the translation had a direct inXuence on his own version of the Oresteia, which opened at the National Theatre in November 1981: It is certainly Browning’s feel for the consonantal, potentially clogging, energy of Aeschylus’ verse, his awareness of the oral physicality and what George Steiner calls the ‘aural density’ of the original language, that distinguishes Browning’s Agamemnon translation. It may clog but it never cloys like so much inferior Victorian poetry. Somewhere though, almost more than in any other English-speaking poet who has tackled Aeschylus, I have always felt, even before I began to think of translating him myself, there were clues to the way Aeschylus might sound in English in the Browning version.61
While he is alert to the Xaws in Browning’s translation, Harrison believes it is neither unreadable nor, it seems, lacking in dramatic potential. He says in reply to Kenyon’s charge of perversity, ‘somewhere, I think, those very perversities point the way to a means of making the text massive and megalithic, doing honour to the daunting Dunkelheit of Aeschylus but without renouncing the intelligibility at the heart of all theatrical communication’.62 Harrison’s reference to George Steiner invokes a comparison between Browning’s Agamemnon and the literalist techniques adopted by Friedrich Ho¨lderlin (1770–1843) in his translations of Sophocles. Ho¨lderlin saw a need to re-primitivize Sophocles’ text for his German audience through a process of estrangement from ‘natural’ German. According to Steiner, by this practice Ho¨lderlin was ‘polemicizing, obliquely, against Schiller’s idealization of the harmonic universality of Greek art and against F. W. Schlegel’s insistence on the never-to-be-rivalled perfection of the classical’.63 His technique was extremely unpopular in his own lifetime, but was rediscovered and treated in a positive light in the early and mid-twentieth century, an experience analogous to that of Browning with his Agamemnon. The publication in 1804, and subsequent editions in 1808 and 1846, of Ho¨lderlin’s Oedipus der Tyrann and Antigona were regarded as ‘the tragic indices of mental crisis and 61 Harrison (2002), 9.
62 Ibid. 12.
63 Steiner (1984), 67.
The Browning version
199
decay’,64 a view which persisted until the rehabilitative judgements of Norbert von Hellingrath in 1911 and Karl Reinhardt in 1951. Between the digressive style of Browning’s Alkestis, with its ‘interpretative paraphrase’,65 and the extreme literalism of the Agamemnon stands the Herakles, the most successful, and yet the least familiar and least studied, of Browning’s three translational experiments. It is successful because, of the three, it comes closest to achieving the impossible, namely the transmission of much of the linguistic power of the original text simultaneous with the creation of a highly readable work of English poetry which is seldom strained or inelegant. The transcription has a Xuency and a simplicity that are often wanting in Browning’s own surrounding verse. Two judgements, read before the Boston Browning Society at the close of the nineteenth century, endorse Browning’s Herakles as an exemplary essay in the art of translation. Philip StaVord Moxom declared: ‘As a translation it leaves almost nothing to be desired in faithfulness to the original. In this respect it serves as a model for the ablest workers in the Weld of translation from the Greek classics.’66 William Cranston Lawton, meanwhile, predicted: ‘The Heracles may long remain the best single version in English of a masterly Greek drama.’67
HE RAKLES TRANSCRIBED The transcription of Herakles, like the rest of Aristophanes’ Apology, is composed mainly in blank verse. Apart from the choral odes, which are in rhyme, Browning’s use of rhyme in the translation is sporadic but striking in its re-creation of the original dramatic impact of a scene. For example, in translating the lyric dialogue between Amphitryon and the chorus at verses 1042–88 of Euripides’ text, Browning has employed a varied and highly eVective rhyme-scheme which captures the suspense and nervous movement of the original passage as well as the extraordinary tension, palpable in the characters’ language, between the emotional 64 Ibid. 66. 65 Moxom (1897), 411–37, at 413. 66 Ibid. Moxom Wrst made his address, ‘Balaustion’s Opinion of Euripides’, on 25 February 1896. 67 Lawton (1897), 363–87, at 386. Lawton Wrst made his address, ‘The Classical Element in Browning’s Poetry’, on 31 December 1895.
200
The Browning version
and practical necessities imposed by the situation. Browning’s version of the scene, at lines 4659–721, begins and ends in blank verse, but the greater part of the exchange alternates between rhyme at the end of every line and rhyme at the end of every second line. This alternation reproduces the shifts between fearful urgency and calm resolution controlled by Euripides’ use of agitated dochmaics interspersed with iambics. As well as retaining Euripides’ combination of short, sharp imperatives and enjambement, Browning rhymes the last line of the Wrst speaker with the Wrst line of the second speaker, creating the eVect of a fraught dialogue in which the interlocutors talk across one another: choros Old man, the fate of thy son! amphitruon Hush, hush! Have done! He is turning about! He is breaking out! Away! I steal And my body conceal, Before he arouse, In the depths of the house. choros Courage! The Night Maintains her right On the lids of thy son there, sealed from sight! amphitruon See, see! To leave the light And, wretch that I am, bear one last ill, I do not avoid; but if he kill Me his own father. (4685–99)
Another striking example of Browning’s manipulation of rhyme to recreate the force of the original is his rendering of verses 861–6 of Lyssa’s speech in which she makes her chilling disclosure of the destruction she will visit on Herakles. Barlow remarks of the original lines, ‘there is an extraordinary energy from the pent-up movement, sight and sound, impressions concentrated within a short space to parallel the explosive force with which Heracles’ madness is created’.68 It is this momentum and density of images that Browning has impressively reproduced: 68 Barlow (1996), 162.
The Browning version
201
Go I will! and neither the sea, as it groans with its waves so furiously, Nor earthquake, no, nor the bolt of thunder gasping out heaven’s labor-throe, Shall cover the ground as I, at a bound, rush into the bosom of Herakles! And home I scatter, and house I batter, Having Wrst of all made the children fall,— And he who felled them is never to know He gave birth to each child that received the blow, Till the Madness, I am, have let him go! (4447–54)
At line 4449 the blank verse sharply breaks oV, just as the imagery, which Lyssa employs, changes from the metaphorical and universal to the literal and particular. A short, concentrated passage of rhyme follows, within which Browning shifts briskly between internal rhyme in lines 4450 and 4451 and rhyme at the end of the next three lines. The overall movement of the passage is at once frenetic and unrelenting. The system of spelling Greek proper nouns, which Browning employs in the Herakles, is one he adopted in ‘Artemis Prologuizes’ (Dramatic Lyrics, 1842) and adhered to in all his subsequent transcriptions from classical Greek. In deWance of the more conventional Latinizations or Anglicizations, whereby y is substituted for ı, c for Œ, and ae for ÆØ, Browning provides very precise transliterations of Greek names. In the preface to his translation of the Agamemnon Browning protests the soundness and increasing currency of this practice in anticipation of its detractors: Just a word more on the subject of my spelling—in a transcript from the Greek and there exclusively—Greek names and places precisely as does the Greek author. I began this practice, with great innocency of intention, some six-and-thirty years ago. . . . I supposed I was doing a simple thing enough. But there has been till lately much astonishment at os and us, ai and oi, representing the same letters in Greek. Of a sudden, however, whether in translation or out of it, everybody seems committing the oVence, although the adoption of u for ı still presents such diYculty that it is a wonder how we have hitherto escaped ‘Eyripides.’69 69 Browning (1877), in Kenyon (1912), viii. 293–365, at 295–6.
202
The Browning version
This system, however, relies on a Xawed premise, as Kenyon indicates with reference to the Agamemnon: ‘If Greek and English vowel sounds were identical, transliteration would no doubt be the correct procedure, but since they are not, transliteration is often as far from the truth as the more common Latinisation.’70 In the Herakles, while Browning has transliterated most names and their adjectival forms according to this system (e.g. Amphitruon, Alkaios, Eurustheus, Thebai, Lukos, Kadmeian, Euboia, Minuai, Hudra, Mukenaian, Kuklopian, Olumpos), there are a few names for which he has simply given an English equivalent, for example ‘Madness’ for ¸ Æ, ‘Night’ for ˝ , and ‘Heaven’ for ˇPæÆ. This is a surprising inconsistency in view of the fact that the poet’s insistence on ‘accuracy’ extended to ordinary nouns and even exclamations of grief. At 4485 he translates the cry Ng Ø (891),71 which refers to Amphitryon’s NŒ, as ‘O ye domes!’, and at 4831 he gives ‘peploi’ for ºØØ (1198). The chorus’ lament OE (875) is reproduced at 4463 as ‘Otototoi.’ A remarkable feature of Browning’s literal rendering of the text is the way it often achieves simultaneously Wdelity to the Greek phraseology and an arresting quality in the English verse. This achievement is demonstrated in his translation of Iris’ instructions to Madness (834–42): Up then, collecting the unsoftened heart, Unwedded virgin of black Night! Drive, drag Frenzy upon the man here—whirls of brain Big with child-murder, while his feet leap gay! Let go the bloody cable its whole length! So that,—when o’er the Acherousian ford He has sent Xoating, by self-homicide, His beautiful boy-garland,—he may know First, Here’s anger, what it is to him, And then learn mine. The gods are vile indeed And mortal matters vast, if he ’scape free! (AA 4418–28)
Here Browning has retained much of Euripides’ asyndetic structure and concentration of imperatives. His literal transcriptions of the 70 Kenyon (1912), viii. p. xii. 71 This and all subsequent numbers in parentheses (unless marked AA) refer to the line-numbers in Euripides’ text.
The Browning version
203
participial phrase ÆØŒı j æH ÆæÆªf (835–6)72 and the clause ‰ i æ Æ . . . j e ŒÆºº ÆØÆ Æ ÆPŁfi fiø (838–9) are appropriately graphic and successfully emulate Euripides’ grotesque juxtapositions of the imagery of Dionysiac ritual with the stark vision of infanticide and of innocence with evil. Similarly, Browning has translated the future verbs in Lyssa’s announcement at verse 871, Æ Kªg Aºº æ ø ŒÆd ŒÆÆıºø fiø, as powerful and portentous transitive verbs that communicate the direct and violent operation of Madness through Herakles: Ay, and I soon will dance thee madder, and pipe thee quite out of thy mind with fear!73 (AA 4459)
Browning remains equally faithful to Euripidean imagery in passages where his style becomes less literal and more allusive and condensed. For example, in the stichomythia between Amphitryon and Herakles, in which the father acts as psychotherapist to the son, Browning has replaced Euripides’ direct Bacchic metaphor in lines 1119 and 1122 with the idea of the literal and Wgurative intoxication associated with the worshippers of Bacchus: amphitruon If thou no more art Haides-drunk,—I tell! herakles I bring to mind no drunkenness of soul. (AA 4755–6)
One very notable aberration from his own methodology, however, is the poet’s handling of the repeated simile of the ‘little boats in tow.’ At lines 628–32 Euripides uses the rare word KºŒ to describe the manner in which Herakles’ children trail after their father upon their reprieve and re-entry into the house: p, ¥ PŒ IØA ; Iºº I ÆØ ºø fiH Aºº· z d ıæF; 72 Cf. Barlow’s translation (1996, 79) of the adjective ÆØŒı as a Wnal clause (‘so that he kills his children’), which tends to weaken its dramatic impact. 73 Cf. Barlow’s translation (ibid. 83) of verse 871, which invests æ ø with a causal rather than a transitive force: ‘I shall soon make you dance more wildly and I shall play upon you a pipe of terror.’
204
The Browning version ¼ø ºÆ ª KºŒÆ æE, ÆF S Kºø.
Browning translates these lines accurately: Ah,— No letting go for these, who all the more Hang to my garments! Did you foot indeed The razor’s edge? Why, then I’ll carry them— Take with my hands these small craft up, and tow Just as a ship would. (AA 4226–231)
Echoing this passage, Euripides uses KºŒ at the end of the play, but this time the word applies to Herakles and his newly formed dependence on his friend Theseus: E IÆºÆ ÆN ÆØ ¨E ÆºØ łŁ KºŒ. (1423–4)
The repetition is pronounced. In her translation of verses 1423–4, Barlow’s choice of words preserves the parallel with the earlier simile in order to highlight the tragic irony of the Wnal scene and the important role reversal experienced by the hero: I who have destroyed my house with shame and am utterly destroyed, shall follow Theseus like a small boat in tow.74
By contrast, Browning’s translation of the same verses diverges from the original in both linguistic and thematic terms: Myself,—who with these shames Have cast away my house,—a ruined hulk, I follow—trailed by Theseus—on my way. (AA 5076–8)
What Browning has given us in these lines is a portrait of grand and noble wreckage (‘a ruined hulk’), a tragic fall certainly, but signiWcantly 74 Barlow (1996), 121.
The Browning version
205
not, as Euripides intended, to the vulnerable condition of a ‘childchanged father’.75 Herakles is still the ship, while Theseus is the boat in tow. Two further general features of Browning’s method of transcription, which are characteristic of his attempt to retrieve for the English reader something of the experience of reading ancient Greek poetry, are his respect for the original word order and its dependent emphases and his imitation of certain Greek idioms. Browning has not slavishly reproduced the word order of the Greek text at the expense of good sense and sound verse, but, within the constraints of an uninXected and less economical language, he has as far as possible adhered to it. A clue to Browning’s thinking on the subject of word order is found in his manuscript, where his translation of lines 631–2 appears thus: 3 2 1 Take / up / these small craft / with my hands / and tow Just as a ship would.
In the Wrst version he made of these lines, Browning maintained almost exactly the Greek word order. In the second version, which is indicated by his numbering, he worked out an order that produced a more poetic verse in English. By his careful positioning of words Browning has also ensured that his translation, where it cannot or does not reXect the original word order, at least retains the emphasis intended by Euripides. This is best illustrated by his translation of the important verse 931, › PŒŁ Æe q, which powerfully signals the immediate and very physical invasion of Herakles by Madness. Browning translates this literally (‘But he was himself j no longer’) and, in order to achieve in English an eVect comparable to the Greek, he places the most important words emphatically at the end and beginning of the lines. In his essay to the Boston Browning Society two decades after the publication of Aristophanes’ Apology, William Cranston Lawton remarked of the transcription: ‘The little detail he has added is rarely modern or in any way un-Hellenic. Indeed, the minute faithfulness and self-suppression of this task must have been most irksome to a nature so alert and self-moved.’76 An example of the Hellenic detail 75 King Lear, iv. vii. 17.
76 Lawton (1897), 363–87, at 382.
206
The Browning version
evident in Browning’s style is the way he imitates the rhetorical doubling between verb and object favoured in Greek. Thus, in his rendering of line 1093, a Łæa ø, as ‘breathings hot I breathe’, he keeps the original word order and doubling. He employs this idiom even where it does not occur in Euripides’ text, translating Herakles’ exhortation at line 1390 to the people of Thebes, ı ŁÆ , as ‘lament one wide lament’. The value of the translation of Herakles to Browning’s defence of Euripides is intimately connected to the method of translation Browning employs. In contrast to his Alkestis, the poet avoids interposing comment, either explicatory or reinterpretative. In contrast to his Agamemnon, his literalism here is regulated and not a deliberate cause of estrangement. In most respects, by allowing Euripides’ own voice to be heard, Browning’s translation restored to the Herakles its dramatic and moral essence, something which had been altered, or removed altogether, by the majority of translators of the text since Seneca, and which has been largely absent from modern versions in which the writers’ personal agenda are given precedence. Without denying or diminishing the individual character of his translation, it could be argued that Browning’s agenda in his version of the Herakles was, in a sense, precisely to eschew any ideological intrusion of an overtly private or contemporary nature, and was, therefore, a reaYrmation of Euripidean thinking. Galinsky, assessing the importance of the translation to the nineteenth century, concludes: At Wrst sight, it may seem paradoxical that in the Herakles Browning’s contribution to the tradition is precisely that he refrained from adapting and, thus, tampering with Euripides’ portrait of the hero. At a time when Matthew Arnold used classical themes for escapism, when Swinburne dismissed Euripides as a ‘botcher’ and a ‘scenic sophist’, and when Wilamowitz pronounced Herakles’ madness to be the result of his megalomania, Browning sounded the true and authentic Euripidean note by helping the poet speak for himself.77
Truth and authenticity in this context are thorny notions, and their application perilous. But if we understand the process involved in the translation of classical literature as a dialogue between the ancient writer and his modern interpreter, the Browning version of Herakles reads as a remarkably empathetic and immediate exchange with the tragic poet. 77 Galinsky (1972), 263–4.
7 The psychological hero: Herakles’ lost self and the creation of Nervenkunst If Browning’s main contribution to the reception of Herakles was his boldly sympathetic transcription of its unreasoned madness, the next decade marked the beginning of a process of appropriation which assumed the speciWc form of psychologizing the hero and internalizing his madness, and discovered in the text an electrifying prototype of Modernist neuroses. Two charismatic individuals, Ulrich von Wilamowitz-MoellendorV and Hermann Bahr, were pre-eminently responsible for ensuring that the Modernist era can be regarded conWdently as the most decisive in the history of the play’s reception. The Wrst, Wilamowitz (1848–1931), was the great German classical scholar, whose monumental two-volume edition of Herakles, published in 1889, is widely regarded as ‘the foundation of modern classical scholarship, the Wrst modern commentary on a Greek tragedy, the one book every classical scholar must know’.1 Hermann Bahr (1863–1934) was Austria’s self-appointed architect and diagnostician of ‘Die Moderne’. Their separate life missions—one philological, the other cultural—coincided in fortuitous combination to facilitate the interest of the later twentieth century’s directors and 1 Fowler (1990), 489–522, at 498. August Nauk (1822–92), the best Hellenist of his day, was the Wrst to review the edition. In a letter he wrote to Wilamowitz on 2 October 1889, Nauck described the Bearbeitung as ‘unvergleichliche’: ‘Dies Werk, das ich wa¨hrend der letzten Tage kaum aus den Ha¨nden gelegt habe, macht einen u¨berwa¨ltigenden Eindruck. Es gibt wohl kaum ein Gebiet des philologischen Wissens, wo Sie nicht sichtend und lichtend die Wunderkraft Ihrer Genialita¨t beta¨tigen’ (‘This work, which I have hardly put down over the last days, leaves an overwhelming impression. There seems no area of philological knowledge unilluminated by the wonder of your penetrating genius’). See Calder (1977), 375–85.
208
The psychological hero
dramatists in the mad Herakles, and the ongoing theatrical appropriation of Euripides’ hero as a means of exploring private and historical crises. Euripides’ Herakles had a profound eVect on both men, when each was in his fortieth year (his akme¯, in the ancient sense), and, although they pursued distinct objectives, their work intersected at an important intellectual watershed. On 6 January 1902 the Wrst and only performance of Wilamowitz’s translation of the Herakles was staged at Vienna’s Theater in der Josefstadt, and was reviewed by Hermann Bahr in a lengthy feuilleton. This production, and its powerful impact on Bahr, occurred simultaneously with the emergence in Wn-de-sie`cle Vienna of revolutionary movements in literature, art, theatre, and music, and with the focal shift, identiWed by Carl E. Schorske, within these convergent spheres, from rational man to psychological man.2 Viennese Modernism became synonymous with irrationalism, subjectivity, individual instinct, dreams, and above all, nerves and nervous complaints. Herakles played a key part in one of the ‘big bangs’ of European thought, which led (amongst other things) to the psychoanalytic rediscovery of Attic tragedy, a phenomenon demonstrative of the predominant inward-turning of Wn-de-sie`cle Vienna, and of which Sigmund Freud’s ‘Oedipus complex’ is the best-known example. Pioneering psychoanalysts like Freud (1856–1939) extracted from the archaic Greek myths, as reinterpreted by the Wfth-century tragedians, paradigmatic diagnoses of repression and hysteria.3 At the same time, classical scholars began to make use of the new science of psychology in their work and to consider the tragic representation of madness in terms of clinical accuracy. A creative corollary of this reciprocal interest in the psychic life of the ancients was the development of what Bahr deWned as the Nervenkunst (neurotic art) of Modernism. The initial cause ce´le`bre, and the enduring ideal, of Nervenkunst was Hugo von Hofmannsthal’s free and (as contemporary critics believed) ‘ungriechisch’ adaptation of Sophocles’ Elektra, which premie`red in Berlin 2 See Schorske (1979), esp. chaps. 1 and 4. 3 For a comprehensive discussion of how antiquity is implicated in psychoanalytic theory, and how Freud appropriated Wgures and themes from classical mythology, see Armstrong (2005).
The psychological hero
209
in 1903, revealing modern hysteria in classical guise.4 It is my belief, however, that Hofmannsthal’s engagement with the ‘pathological’ in Greek tragedy and the Nachtseite of human psychology was inXuenced, at a very deep level, by Euripides’ Herakles, through the agency of Hermann Bahr in his capacity as cultural mediator to the Jung-Wien generation. Hofmannsthal (1874–1929), like others among his literary circle, was both fascinated and disturbed by Bahr’s theory of the lost self or ‘die Unsicherheit des Ich’,5 which Bahr derived directly from verse 931 of Herakles (› PŒŁ Æe q) and held to be the essence of Euripidean tragedy. Hofmannsthal’s Elektra, which broke violently with his earlier lyrical dramas,6 was an almost immediate response to Bahr’s implicit challenge, towards the end of his review of Herakles, to the writers of his day to ‘lose’ themselves in the eternal insecurity of the self and to depict, in contemporary terms, the terrifying potential within all human beings suddenly to be borne away from themselves. My purpose in this chapter, therefore, is to uncover the wider signiWcance of the 1902 Viennese Herakles, which, in the century since its performance, has been completely overlooked, and to propose that it was indeed this production that, through the intermediate dynamism of Hermann Bahr, inspired Hofmannsthal’s psychologically explicit Elektra of the following year. The timing of the Viennese Herakles and its place in the reception history of Euripides are extremely noteworthy. Wilamowitz, Bahr, and Hofmannsthal were, in their varying ways, initiators of the change in Hellenism that occurred at the close of the nineteenth century, a change speciWcally concerned with attitudes towards Euripides and which led to the dethroning of Schlegelian and Arnoldian classicism. Despised for most of the 1800s for his ‘modernity’, his Xagrant disharmony and decadence, Euripides became the tragedian best suited to the age of unreason, a poet and prophet of the mental and spiritual disquietude that ushered in the nervous new century.
4 Gustav Zieler, in a review of Hofmannsthal’s Elektra (Kreuz-Zeitung, 31 Oct. 1903), proclaimed the characters ‘moderne Hysteriker, die sich in ein antikes Gewand gehu¨llt haben’ (‘modern hysterics who have wrapped themselves in the cloak of antiquity’). 5 Bahr (1904), 93. 6 See e.g. McMullen (1985), 637–51, at 639.
210
The psychological hero
Not only was Euripides now appreciated for his modern attributes, but through him critics and writers also arrived at a new understanding of the nature of Sophocles. Hofmannsthal’s Hellenism was grounded largely in a desire ‘to make Euripides anew’ and to invest the ancient poet with the Dionysian element that Nietzsche had accused Euripides of removing from tragedy. Hofmannsthal’s Elektra, in both its dramatic and operatic forms, presented audiences with an alien and unromantic perspective of Sophocles, a Sophocles stripped of his classicist habiliments; it signiWed the making anew of Sophocles through the medium of Euripides.
WILAMOW ITZ AND THE SEEDS OF MADNESS In response to the passage in the Aristotelian Problemata Physica (30.953a), in which Herakles is categorized, along with Empedocles, Plato, and Socrates, as a ‘melancholic man’ or unstable genius, Wilamowitz says that Herakles has been placed ‘in die Reihe der Heroen des Geistes’ (‘in the order of the heroes of the mind’).7 A major part of Wilamowitz’s contribution to the reception of Euripides’ Herakles was his internalization and rationalization of the madness as the climax of a pre-existing disorder: ‘die Tat aber ist eine Folge der Herakleischen eignen Natur geworden’ (‘however, the deed has become the consequence of the Heraklean nature itself’).8 He concludes that what makes Herakles a great hero is also what drives him over the edge into psychopathy and, therefore, the seeds of madness are in him before the arrival of Hera’s emissaries. With this interpretation Wilamowitz sought to resolve the persistent problem of the play’s disjunctive structure, the apparent irreconcilability of its two halves. Like Seneca before him, he problematizes Herakles’ physis through the revelation of the hero’s pathogenic mentality of revenge and slaughter, in short, his megalomania. His argument, which is founded exclusively on verses 562–82 and 966–7, is that Herakles’ mind has been unbalanced by years of killing and, on his return to Thebes from the Labours, his normal heroic bloodlust has reached the point of insane excess. 7 Wilamowitz (1959), ii. 93.
8 Wilamowitz (1895), i. 128.
The psychological hero
211
Herakles’ speech at 562–82, in which he sets out the revenge he will take upon the usurper Lycus and the disloyal citizens of Thebes, is construed by Wilamowitz as evidence of incipient madness. The critical lines are 566–73:
æH b rØ ŒÆd ŒÆÆŒ łø ı ŒÆØH ıæ ø, ŒæAÆ IØ g Þłø ŒıH ºŒÆ· ˚Æø ‹ı ŒÆŒf K æ s ÆŁÆ K KF fiH ŒÆººØŒfiø fiH ‹ ºfiø ØæÆØ, f b æøE ØÆæH ÆØ ŒæH – Æ "e K ºø ı, ˜æŒ AÆ ºıŒe ÆƒÆŁÆØ. First I shall go and raze to the ground the palace of this new king, I shall cut oV his unholy head and throw it for the dogs to tear at. Those of the Thebans whom I have found to be treacherous in spite of being well treated by me, these I shall overcome with my conquering club. Dispersing others with my winged arrows, I shall Wll the whole of the river Ismenus with bloody corpses and the clear stream of Dirce shall run red with gore.
Wilamowitz believes this passage to be a display, not of heroic anger, but of manic intemperance: Ob Lykos ein Haus hat, ob seine Demolirung Zweck hat, davon weiss Her. nichts. Beides ist auch gar nicht der Fall. Es lodert eben der Ja¨hzorn in ihm ¨ bertreibung und bringt ihn schon hier zu to¨richten Pla¨nen, die er in wilder U prahlend ausruft: auch nachher, wenn der verderbliche Wahnsinn ihn beherrscht, ist die Zertru¨mmerung des Schlosses seines Feindes sein Haupt¨ berfu¨lle von Kraft sucht sich eine mo¨glichst gewaltige Aufgabe.9 wunsch: die U Herakles does not know if Lykus has a house or if there is a purpose to his demolition. Neither is the case. Rather his violent temper blazes up and already at this point leads him to foolish plans, which he proclaims boastfully in wild exaggeration; even afterwards, when he is ruled by pernicious insanity, his main wish is the total destruction of his enemy’s palace: the superabundance of strength seeks out the most violent task.
Herakles’ graphically violent language shows him relishing the grisly duty ahead of him, a sure sign, according to Wilamomitz’s reading of ØÆæH at 571, of the conquering hero’s mental imbalance: 9 Ibid. ii. 131, on v. 566.
212
The psychological hero
ØÆæE zerreißen, zerXeischen, ist eigentlich fu¨r den Erfolg der Pfeilschu¨sse ein zu grausames Wort, das eher dem Schlage der Keule zukommt. Die Phantasie des Her. labt sich am grassesten und blutigsten: die Inconcinnita¨t ist also wohlberechtigt.10 ØÆæE to rip up, to tear apart, is actually too awful a word for the results of arrow shots. It would apply more to the blows of the club. Herakles’ fantasy feeds on the superlatives of crassness and bloodiness: his roundabout use of the word here is therefore justiWed.
Amphytrion’s question to his son, h ı K Œı ŒæH j R ¼æØ ŒÆØ; (‘Surely the blood of those you have just been killing has not made you mad?’, 966–7), suggests to Wilamowitz a rational explanation for Herakles’ homicidal rampage, that the madness is a psychological reaction to the murders he has just performed in defence of his family, and the inevitable consummation of a bloodlust of such enormous proportions as that manifest in verses 566–73. This explanation better applies to Seneca’s Hercules Furens, in which the epiphany of Iris and Lyssa does not occur, and Hercules, in his madness, imagines that his victims are the children of Lycus (HF 987–8) rather than those of Eurystheus. Wilamowitz’s psychological interpretation of Herakles’ madness was adopted by several leading Euripidean scholars well into the next century. The Wrst to acknowledge his debt to Wilamowitz was A. W. Verrall (1851–1912), who took the rationalization of the madness to an extreme and outlandish conclusion. Verrall, the Wrst holder of a chair of English Literature at Cambridge, contributed greatly to the late nineteenth-century rehabilitation of Euripides and to the undermining of the Schlegelian position. His championship of the ancient poet relied on an exciting and original, but sometimes dangerous and self-defeating, hypothesis. In 1895, the year Wilamowitz’s revised edition of Herakles appeared, Verrall published Euripides the Rationalist, in which he claimed that Euripides’ genius could not be appreciated until one had accepted that beneath the surface of his plays lay a satiric or ironic viewpoint. He insisted that, while the plays outwardly conformed to popular and traditional thinking, their real meaning and hidden scepticism were only intelligible to the educated among the original audience. Verrall’s obituarist in the Classical Review admitted 10 Wilamowitz (1895), 131–2, on v. 571.
The psychological hero
213
that this position could lead him astray, although it was nonetheless valuable for that reason: ‘It would be foolish for even his most ardent admirer to deny that this very IªØÆ at times betrayed him into error. . . . But in Verrall’s case these occasional aberrations were hardly to be regretted, for his advocacy of an untenable position was as likely as not to be more suggestive and stimulating than many a note unimpeachably correct.’11 Recent critics, such as Michelini, have taken a more exacting view of Verrall’s approach: ‘His methods amount almost to parodies of traditional scholarship. . . . Instead of athetizing or emending diYcult passages, he introduced fanciful interpretations that were intended to eliminate the diYculties and preserve the text.’12 Perhaps most fanciful of all was his essay on Herakles, ‘A Soul’s Tragedy’, published in 1905. Taking his cue from Herakles’ protestation at verse 1346, IØH ¥ Ø ºªØ (‘These are the miserable tales of poets’), Verrall asserts: The legend of Heracles, as commonly told, is not supposed as part of the story, but replaced by some totally diVerent conception of Heracles, and of his mental and physical history. . . . In these circumstances it would seem imperative, as the next step, at least to attempt the interpretation of the play upon the hypothesis that the hero is not a superhuman personage, nor his story supernatural, but he a man, however great, like other men, and the scene of his action, however remote in time and diVerent in circumstances from the age of Euripides or from our own, nevertheless no other in its physical laws than that same world which the Athenians knew and we know. Not only is this the truth, but upon the perception of it depends all the coherence of the play, all its meaning to the intelligence, and the better part of its appeal to the emotions.13
He concurs with Wilamowitz that Herakles is mad from his Wrst entrance, but his attempt to rationalize the events of the story becomes an extraordinary exercise in reductionism. Among his claims are that the divine epiphany at 815 V. is merely an apparition dreamt up by a member of the chorus;14 Cerberus is an ordinary dog;15 and Herakles’ descent into Hades was nothing more than a mine disaster.16
11 BayWeld (1912), 172–3, at 172. 13 Verrall (1905), 136–7. 15 Ibid. 193–4.
12 Michelini (1987), 15. 14 Ibid. 171. 16 Ibid. 185–6.
214
The psychological hero
Verrall’s theory on the Herakles was reproduced Wfteen years later by Gilbert Norwood: ‘Herakles suVers from a growing tendency to madness; in his moods he knows that all his story is human, all the nobler for its humanity, but in his dark hours he accepts the vulgar splendours which rumour throws round his adventures, at such times lending nascent myth the support of his own false witness. The tragedy of his life has been this mental distemper, which has Wnally caused him to destroy his wife and children.’17 The inXuence of Wilamowitz is also clear in Norwood’s argument that, although the appearance of Iris and Lyssa seems to overthrow the idea of Herakles’ madness as internally motivated, ‘the past scene [562– 82], before ever Frenzy arrives, has shown the hero not mad, yet not in full possession of his senses’.18 One of Wilamowitz’s staunchest disciples was Gilbert Murray (1866–1957), whose rehabilitative work on Euripides owed a great deal to the German scholar’s ‘historical insight and singular gift of imaginative sympathy with ancient Greece’.19 Murray had been overwhelmed by Wilamowitz’s edition of the Herakles, although he remained ambivalent in his opinion of the play itself: ‘It is brokenbacked; it has too much conventional rhetoric; but for sheer loftiness of tragic tone the last act, after Heracles awakes from the trance in which he has murdered his children, will stand beside anything in ancient drama.’20 His pronouncement on the nature of Herakles’ madness conforms faithfully to the position of Wilamowitz: When a writer of Wction wishes to make a character go mad or change his nature he has obviously a choice before him, a choice between contrast and preparation. Suppose, as here, it is a case of violent homicidal rage, produced by some external accident, he can get an eVect by making the victim in his normal state a particularly gentle and reasonable person who is utterly transformed. . . . Or he can equally get an eVect by showing certain slight tendencies in the normal man which blaze out into excess in the new conditions. It is clear that Euripides in his treatement of Heracles follows the second method and not the Wrst. Heracles is a warm-hearted and passionate Wghter who goes mad passionately and pugnaciously.21
17 Norwood (1920), 232. 20 Murray (1946), 112.
18 Ibid. 233. 21 Ibid.
19 Murray (1897), preface.
The psychological hero
215
E. R. Dodds (1893–1979), in an essay on ‘Euripides the Irrationalist’ published in 1929, described the ‘scientiWc care’22 and ‘fascinated precision’23 with which Euripides explored the dark, irrational side of human nature, giving as an example Herakles, ‘whose insanity is clearly marked as belonging to the manic-depressive type’.24 Dodds concludes his article with the observation that the present threat to the supremacy of rationalism posed by Dr Jung and Dr Freud, among others, is one reason why Euripides ‘is for our generation one of the most sympathetic Wgures in the whole of ancient literature’,25 and this is why his Herakles is the Wn-de-sie`cle text. G. M. A. Grube’s thesis on Herakles in 1941 aimed to redress the extravagances of Verrall’s interpretation and subsequent readings of the internalization of Herakles’ madness, which paid too little heed to Euripides’ dramatic intention by discrediting the play’s supernatural agents. He found the theories of Wilamowitz and Verrall on the seeds of madness illuminating but not conclusive: [Heracles] promises vengeance on Lycus; his words become more and more violent; he speaks like one intoxicated with his own strength and greatness until he seems to pass from greatness to megalomania. . . . The reckless wildness of the promised vengeance argues a dangerous exaltation, and the grandiloquent words in which he boasts of his own might—great though that be—stand out uncomfortably. . . . The cause of Heracles’ madness, however, seems to lie entirely outside himself, which is no doubt why it is represented externally, by this sudden divine appearance. . . . We Wnd little of the psychological motivation at which Euripides is such a past master. We have Madness and Iris instead.26
The inXuence of Wilamowitz’s psychological explanation of Herakles’ madness continued right up to the close of the twentieth century, as critics and dramatists located the seeds of madness in the play’s Wrst part in order to make sense of the violence of the second part. In 1945 E. M. Blaiklock, taking his cue from ancient and Renaissance humoral theory, proposed that the madness was an epileptic furor.27 Two decades later J. C. Kamerbeek rationalized the
22 Dodds (1929), 97–104, at 99. 23 Ibid. 100. 24 Ibid. 25 Ibid. 104. 26 Grube (1941), 252–6. 27 Blaiklock (1945), 48–63. Repr. in Blaiklock (1952), 122–40.
216
The psychological hero
murders as ‘the violent reaction to the overstrain of a burdensome life’,28 a kind of ‘executive stress’. In the Herakles of American poet Archibald MacLeish (1892–1982), staged in 1965, the delusion, which causes the hero to slaughter his sons, is linked directly to his megalomaniac progress towards deiWcation. British poet Simon Armitage (b. 1963), in his millennial version of the tragedy, Mister Heracles, portrayed the hero’s condition as psychosis induced by combat trauma and desensitization to the act of killing.29
T H E P H I LO LO G I S T A S ACTO R Wilamowitz’s role in the rehabilitation of the Herakles and its author, and the breadth of his inXuence, were not conWned to the world of scholarship and exegetic discourse. He was also responsible for the Wrst performance of the Herakles of the twentieth century and, indeed, the Wrst professional revival of a Euripidean tragedy30 on the European stage prior to the productions of Gilbert Murray’s translations which Harley Granville-Barker (1877–1946) presented in London.31 Wilamowitz’s translations of Greek tragedy for the stage were part of a lifelong obsession with theatre and tragic drama. From the obituary he wrote for himself in about 1912, it is clear that he ‘thought of himself Wrst as a soldier, second as an actor, third as a teacher, fourth as a scholar’.32 As an 18-year-old schoolboy at Pforta he had played Goethe’s tragic hero Egmont, a revelatory and liberating experience which, at the time, he described in ecstatic or epiphanic terms as though it were a kind of religious conversion.33 The lasting potency of his hour upon the stage and his close identiWcation 28 Kamerbeek (1966), 1–16, at 14. 29 On MacLeish and Armitage’s versions of Herakles, see below, Chap. 9. 30 Adolf Wilbrandt had directed his own translation of Euripides’ satyr play Cyclops at Vienna’s Burgtheater in 1882, as an afterpiece to Sophocles’ Elektra. 31 The Wrst of these was Hippolytus for the Stage Society at the Court Theatre in 1904. See Hall and Macintosh (2005), 492 V. 32 Calder (1994a), 355–8, at 358. 33 See Wilamowitz’s letter to his mother, probably written two days after the performance on 7 March 1867, and signed ‘Ulrich, Graf von Gaure’. Published for the Wrst time in Calder (1994b) 371–6, at 372–4.
The psychological hero
217
with the isolated Wgure of the aristocratic, idealistic, and uncompromising Egmont had, as Calder points out, ‘great implications for the history of tragic exegesis’.34 The passion of the young Thespian remained with the mature scholar and informed his whole approach to the critical interpretation of ancient texts. At the end of the ‘Einleitung’ of his Herakles, Wilamowitz explicitly rejected the Nietzschean ideal of the philologist as prophet. Instead he asserted that the philologist’s assignment should be comparable to that of the actor, but he was careful to distinguish between bravura acting and vain histrionics, and to stress the ability of the true artist to submerge his own personality and to inhabit and animate a diVerent character: Wie wir unser Gescha¨ft nur dann recht besorgen, wenn wir in jedes alte Buch, das wir unter den Ha¨nden haben, nicht unsern Geist hineintragen sondern das herauslesen, was darin steht, so liegt u¨berhaupt die speziWsch philologische Aufgabe in dem Erfassen einer fremden Individualita¨t. Es gilt sich in eine fremde Seele zu versenken, sei es die eines einzelnen, sei es die eines Volkes. In der Aufopferung unserer eigenen Individualita¨t liegt unsere Sta¨rke. Wir Philologen als solche haben nichts vom Dichter noch vom Propheten, was beides bis zu einem gewissen Grade der Historiker sein muß. Dagegen mu¨ssen wir etwas vom Schauspieler in uns tragen, nicht vom Virtuosen, der seiner Rolle eigene Lichter aufsetzt, sondern vom echten Ku¨nstler, der dem toten Worte durch das eigene Herzblut Leben gibt.35 Just as we only do our work properly when, in every ancient book that comes into our hands, we read out of it what is there rather than put our own spirit into it, so it is the speciWc task of the philologist to comprehend an alien individuality. The task is to immerse ourselves in an alien soul, be it of an individual or of a people. Our strength lies in our giving up our own individuality. We philologists as such do not have much of the poet or prophet in us, both of which a historian must have to a certain extent. No, we must have something of the actor in us— not the virtuoso who interprets his role in his own way but rather the true artist who through his heart’s blood gives life to the dead word.
The equivalence of Wilamowitz’s own hermeneutic methods to the craft of the ‘Schauspieler’ or ‘echten Ku¨nstler’ was nowhere more discernible than in his peculiar empathy with the character of Herakles,36 while the 34 Ibid. 372. 35 Wilamowitz (1959), i. 257. 36 On Wilamowitz’s ‘profound personal aYnity’ with the Wgure of Herakles and his perception of himself as a ˙æÆŒºB, see Calder (1985), 80–110, at 91–101.
218
The psychological hero
image he fervently evoked of giving life to dead words was practically expounded in his eVorts to revive Greek tragedy on the modern German stage in actable translations. The return of Greek tragedy to the German stage had been initiated in the late nineteenth century by the poet, novelist, and dramatist Adolf Wilbrandt (1837–1911), who was director of the Burgtheater in Vienna between 1881 and 1887. While he was an eminently practical man of theatre, Wilbrandt had a respectable academic background, including a doctorate. The son of a professor at the University of Rostock, he had brieXy studied law there before making the transition to philology and history and continuing his studies at Berlin and Munich. During his literary career he had the rare distinction of being twice awarded the prestigious Grillparzer Prize, Wrst in 1875 for his tragedy Gracchus der Volkstribun and again in 1890 for his dramatic poem Der Meister von Palmyra. In the mid1860s Wilbrandt published translations of Sophocles with the express design of making the plays stageworthy in a modern sense. To this end he simpliWed the tragedies’ mythological references, substituted German iambic pentameter for the Greek trimeters, and reduced the choral passages to speaking parts. His translations were performed in the next two decades in Meiningen, Darmstadt, Berlin, and Munich, but he exercised little directorial control over these productions. It was not until his tenure at the Burgtheater that Wilbrandt achieved recognition as a director of Sophoclean tragedy, beginning in 1882 with his Elektra, the inaugural production of his newly instituted repertory. His greatest triumph was his staging of Oedipus Tyrannus, which opened on 29 December 1886 and starred the Hungarian actor Emerich Robert, whom Wilbrandt recalled in his memoirs ‘in griechischer Wohlgestalt und Beredsamkeit, aber mit der Freiheit, dem Feuer, den Seelento¨nen unserer Tage’ (‘in Greek comeliness and eloquence, but with the freedom, the Wre, the soul tones of our day’).37 In his review of the premie`re, Ludwig Speidel, the critic for the liberal Viennese newspaper Neue Freie Presse, conWdently announced: ‘Wien ist fu¨r die große Trago¨die, von der es sich fru¨her mehr oder minder wehleidig zu verschließen pXegte, mu¨ndig geworden’ (‘Vienna used to close its mind to great tragedy, more or less in a 37 Wilbrandt (1905), 44.
The psychological hero
219
self-pitying way, but has now come of age’).38 It is very possible that Freud saw Wilbrandt’s Oedipus, either in its Wrst presentation a few months after his return to Vienna from Paris (where he had seen and been deeply impressed by the great Jean Mounet-Sully’s deWnitive Oedipus at the Come´die Franc¸aise39), or in one of its thirty revivals at the Burgtheater prior to 1900. One whose receptiveness to Wilbrandt’s Elektra and Oedipus can, with more certainty, be conWrmed is Hugo von Hofmannsthal. He had attended the Burgtheater productions as a teenager, and his own ground-breaking Sophoclean adaptations were partly a progression of Wilbrandt’s work. It is as a precursor and a facilitator that, in Hellmut Flashar’s estimation, Wilbrandt ranks highly in the German reception of Greek tragedy, having prepared both the stage and public sentiment for the radicalism of his theatrical heirs: Diese Inszenierungen sind Marksteine auf dem Wege der Einbu¨rgerung des antiken Dramas auf der Bu¨hne der eigenen Zeit. Die zuvor gea¨ußerte Skepsis, ob die griechische Trago¨die u¨berhaupt auf dem modernen Theater ein Existenzrecht habe, ist ein fu¨r alle Male beseitigt, jedenfalls was Sopho¨ bersetzungen Wilbrandts werden nun auf den Bu¨hnen kles betriVt. Die U mehrerer Sta¨dte (Berlin, Mu¨nchen, Nu¨rnberg, Mannheim, Stuttgart) gespielt. Ohne sie sind die dann weitergehenden Schritte von Wilamowitz und Max Reinhardt nicht denkbar.40 These productions are milestones on the road to establishing ancient drama on the contemporary stage. The former scepticism, which doubted if Greek tragedy even had the right to exist in modern theatre, has been removed once and for all, at least with regards to Sophocles. Wilbrandt’s translations are played on the stages of several cities (Berlin, Munich, Nuremberg, Mannheim, Stuttgart). The work of Wilamowitz and Max Reinhardt builds upon these translations and goes one step further and is therefore unthinkable without them. 38 Cited in Smekal (1916), 216. 39 Between 30 October 1885 and 28 February 1886 Freud studied with the neurologist Jean-Martin Charcot at the Salpe