The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria
Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration VOLUME 28 Series Editor : GOVINDJEE University of Illinois, Urbana, Illinois, U.S.A.
Consulting Editors: Julian EATON-RYE, Dunedin, New Zealand Christine H. FOYER, Newcastle upon Tyne, U.K. David B. KNAFF, Lubbock, Texas, U.S.A. Anthony L. MOORE, Brighton, U.K. Sabeeha MERCHANT, Los Angeles, California, U.S.A. Krishna NIYOGI, Berkeley, California, U.S.A. William PARSON, Seatle, Washington, U.S.A. Agepati RAGHAVENDRA, Hyderabad, India Gernot RENGER, Berlin, Germany
The scope of our series, beginning with volume 11, reflects the concept that photosynthesis and respiration are intertwined with respect to both the protein complexes involved and to the entire bioenergetic machinery of all life. Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration is a book series that provides a comprehensive and state-of-the-art account of research in photosynthesis and respiration. Photosynthesis is the process by which higher plants, algae, and certain species of bacteria transform and store solar energy in the form of energy-rich organic molecules. These compounds are in turn used as the energy source for all growth and reproduction in these and almost all other organisms. As such, virtually all life on the planet ultimately depends on photosynthetic energy conversion. Respiration, which occurs in mitochondrial and bacterial membranes, utilizes energy present in organic molecules to fuel a wide range of metabolic reactions critical for cell growth and development. In addition, many photosynthetic organisms engage in energetically wasteful photorespiration that begins in the chloroplast with an oxygenation reaction catalyzed by the same enzyme responsible for capturing carbon dioxide in photosynthesis. This series of books spans topics from physics to agronomy and medicine, from femtosecond processes to season long production, from the photophysics of reaction centers, through the electrochemistry of intermediate electron transfer, to the physiology of whole organisms, and from X-ray crystallography of proteins to the morphology or organelles and intact organisms. The goal of the series is to offer beginning researchers, advanced undergraduate students, graduate students, and even research specialists, a comprehensive, up-to-date picture of the remarkable advances across the full scope of research on photosynthesis, respiration and related processes. For other titles published in this series, go to www.springer.com/series/5599
The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria Edited by
C. Neil Hunter University of Sheffield, United Kingdom
Fevzi Daldal University of Pennsylvania, USA
Marion C. Thurnauer Argonne National Laboratory, USA and
J. Thomas Beatty University of British Columbia, Canada
Library of Congress Control Number: 2008932524
ISBN 978-1-4020-8814-8 (HB) ISBN 978-1-4020-8815-5 (e-book) Published by Springer, P.O. Box 17, 3300 AA Dordrecht, The Netherlands. www.springer.com
Cover: Four aspects of purple phototrophic bacteria, from one of their habitats through to atomic resolution structures, are superimposed on a map derived from the genome sequence of Rhodopseudomonas palustris CGA009 supplied by Professor Caroline Harwood, University of Washington, Seattle, USA. Top left. Purple sulfur bacteria (Amoebobacter purpureus) on the shoreline of Mahoney Lake, British Columbia, Canada. Image from Professor J.T. Beatty. Top right. Rhodobacter capsulatus streaked out on an agar plate. Image from Professor J.T. Beatty. Bottom right. Model of a spherical chromatophore vesicle from Rhodobacter sphaeroides constructed by the in silico combination of atomic force microscopy, linear dichroism, electron microscopy, and X-ray crystallography data. Image from Dr. Melih Sener and Professor Klaus Schulten, prepared using VMD (Humphrey et al. (1996) J Mol Graphics 14: 33–38). Bottom left. Structure of the reaction center complex from Rhodobacter sphaeroides showing the subunits and the pathway of electron transfer between cofactors. See Fig. 1, Chapter 20. Image from Professor Colin Wraight, prepared using VMD. The camera ready text was prepared by Lawrence A. Orr, Center for Bioenergy & Photosynthesis, Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona 85287-1604, USA.
Printed on acid-free paper
All Rights Reserved © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V. No part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, microfilming, recording or otherwise, without written permission from the Publisher, with the exception of any material supplied specifically for the purpose of being entered and executed on a computer system, for exclusive use by the purchaser of the work.
This book is dedicated to Roderick K. Clayton, a pioneer of photosynthesis research
From the Series Editor Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration Volume 28: The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria I am delighted to announce the publication, in the Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration (AIPH) Series, of The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria. Four distinguished authorities from three countries (UK, USA and Canada) have edited this Volume: C. Neil Hunter, the Chief Editor, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty. This book is produced as a sequel to Volume 2 of the Series (Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria), published in 1995, and edited by Robert E. Blankenship, Michael T. Madigan and Carl E. Bauer. Published Volumes (2008–1994) • Volume 27 (2008) Sulfur Metabolism in Phototrophic Organisms, edited by Christiane Dahl, Rüdiger Hell, David Knaff and Thomas Leustek, from Germany and USA. 24 Chapters, 551 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 978-4020-6862-1 • Volume 26 (2008): Biophysical Techniques In Photosynthesis, Volume II, edited by Thijs Aartsma and Jörg Matysik, both from The Netherlands. 24 Chapters, 548 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 978-1-4020-8249-8 • Volume 25 (2006): Chlorophylls and Bacteriochlorophylls: Biochemistry, Biophysics, Functions and Applications, edited by Bernhard Grimm, Robert J. Porra, Wolfhart Rüdiger, and Hugo Scheer, from Germany and Australia. 37 Chapters, 603 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 978-140204515-8 • Volume 24 (2006): Photosystem I: The LightDriven Plastocyanin: Ferredoxin Oxidoreductase, edited by John H. Golbeck, from USA. 40 Chapters, 716 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 978-140204255-3 • Volume 23 (2006): The Structure and Function of Plastids, edited by Robert R. Wise and J. Kenneth Wise, from USA. 27 Chapters, 575 pp, Softcover: ISBN: 978-1-4020-6570-6, Hardcover, ISBN: 978-1-4020-4060-3
• Volume 22 (2005): Photosystem II: The LightDriven Water:Plastoquinone Oxidoreductase, edited by Thomas J. Wydrzynski and Kimiyuki Satoh, from Australia and Japan. 34 Chapters, 786 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 978-1-4020-4249-2 • Volume 21 (2005): Photoprotection, Photoinhibition, Gene Regulation, and Environment, edited by Barbara Demmig-Adams, William W. III Adams and Autar K. Mattoo, from USA. 21 Chapters, 380 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 97814020-3564-7 • Volume 20 (2006): Discoveries in Photosynthesis, edited by Govindjee, J. Thomas Beatty, Howard Gest and John F. Allen, from USA, Canada and UK. 111 Chapters, 1304 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 978-1-4020-3323-0 • Volume 19 (2004): Chlorophyll a Fluorescence: A Signature of Photosynthesis, edited by George C. Papageorgiou and Govindjee, from Greece and USA. 31 Chapters, 820 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 978-1-4020-3217-2 • Volume 18 (2005): Plant Respiration: From Cell to Ecosystem, edited by Hans Lambers and Miquel Ribas-Carbo, from Australia and Spain. 13 Chapters, 250 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 978-14020-3588-3 • Volume 17 (2004): Plant Mitochondria: From Genome to Function, edited by David Day, A. Harvey Millar and James Whelan, from Australia. 14 Chapters, 325 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 978-14020-2399-6 • Volume 16 (2004): Respiration in Archaea and Bacteria:Diversity of Prokaryotic Respiratory Systems, edited by Davide Zannoni, from Italy. 13 Chapters, 310 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 97814020-2002-5 • Volume 15 (2004): Respiration in Archaea and Bacteria: Diversity of Prokaryotic Electron Transport Carriers, edited by Davide Zannoni, from Italy. 13 Chapters, 350 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 978-1-4020-2001-8 • Volume 14 (2004): Photosynthesis in Algae,
edited by Anthony W. Larkum, Susan Douglas and John A. Raven, from Australia, Canada and UK. 19 Chapters, 500 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 978-0-7923-6333-0 • Volume 13 (2003): Light-Harvesting Antennas in Photosynthesis, edited by Beverley R. Green and William W. Parson, from Canada and USA. 17 Chapters, 544 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 97807923-6335-4 • Volume 12 (2003): Photosynthetic Nitrogen Assimilation and Associated Carbon and Respiratory Metabolism, edited by Christine H. Foyer and Graham Noctor, from UK and France. 16 Chapters, 304 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 978-07923-6336-1 • Volume 11 (2001): Regulation of Photosynthesis, edited by Eva-Mari Aro and Bertil Andersson, from Finland and Sweden. 32 Chapters, 640 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 978-0-7923-6332-3 • Volume 10 (2001): Photosynthesis: Photobiochemistry and Photobiophysics, by Bacon Ke, from USA. 36 Chapters, 792 pp, Softcover: ISBN: 978-0-7923-6791-8. Hardcover: ISBN: 978-0-7923-6334-7 • Volume 9 (2000): Photosynthesis: Physiology and Metabolism, edited by Richard C. Leegood, Thomas D. Sharkey and Susanne von Caemmerer, from UK, USA and Australia. 24 Chapters, 644 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 978-0-7923-6143-5 • Volume 8 (1999): The Photochemistry of Carotenoids, edited by Harry A. Frank, Andrew J. Young, George Britton and Richard J. Cogdell, from UK and USA. 20 Chapters, 420 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 978-0-7923-5942-5 • Volume 7 (1998): The Molecular Biology of Chloroplasts and Mitochondria in Chlamydomonas, edited by Jean David Rochaix, Michel Goldschmidt-Clermont and Sabeeha Merchant, from Switzerland and USA. 36 Chapters, 760 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 978-0-7923-5174-0 • Volume 6 (1998): Lipids in Photosynthesis: Structure, Function and Genetics, edited by Paul-André Siegenthaler and Norio Murata, from Switzerland and Japan. 15 Chapters, 332 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 978-0-7923-5173-3 • Volume 5 (1997): Photosynthesis and the Environment, edited by Neil R. Baker, from UK. 20 Chapters, 508 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 97807923-4316-5 • Volume 4 (1996): Oxygenic Photosynthesis: The Light Reactions, edited by Donald R. Ort,
and Charles F. Yocum, from USA. 34 Chapters, 696 pp, Softcover: ISBN: 978-0-7923-3684-6. Hardcover: ISBN: 978-0-7923-3683-9 • Volume 3 (1996): Biophysical Techniques in Photosynthesis, edited by JanAmesz and Arnold J. Hoff, from The Netherlands. 24 Chapters, 426 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 978-0-7923-3642-6 • Volume 2 (1995): Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria, edited by Robert E. Blankenship, Michael T. Madigan and Carl E. Bauer, from USA. 62 Chapters, 1331 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 978-0-7923-3682-8 • Volume 1 (1994): The Molecular Biology of Cyanobacteria, edited by Donald R. Bryant, from USA. 28 Chapters, 916 pp, Hardcover. ISBN: 978-0-7923-3222-0 Further information on these books and ordering instructions can be found at
under the Book Series ‘Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration.’ Table of Contents of Volumes 1–25 can be found at . Special discounts are available to members of the International Society of Photosynthesis Research, ISPR (). (See http://www.springer.com/ispr for more information.) About Volume 28: The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria has 48 authoritative Chapters, and is authored by 116 international authorities from 13 countries (Australia; Canada; Czech Republic; France; Germany; Israel; Italy; Japan; Netherlands; Poland; Russia; UK; and USA). It is a truly international book and the Chief Editor of this volume, C. Neil Hunter, and his three coeditors, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty, deserve our thanks and our congratulations for compiling this updated survey of these interesting and important organisms. The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria is a comprehensive survey of all aspects of these fascinating bacteria, most metabolically versatile organisms on Earth. This volume is organized into the following sections: Physiology, Evolution and Ecology; Biosynthesis of Pigments, Cofactors and Lipids; Antenna Complexes: Structure, Function and Orgaviii
nization; Reaction Centre Structure and Function; Cyclic Electron Transfer Components and Energy Coupling Reactions; Metabolic Processes; Genomics, Regulation and Signaling; and New Applications and Techniques. This book is a compilation of 48 chapters, written by leading experts who highlight the huge progress made in spectroscopic, structural and genetic studies of these bacteria since 1995, when the last such book was published (Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria, Volume 2 in the Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration Series, edited by Robert E. Blankenship, Michael T. Madigan and Carl E. Bauer; Kluwer Academic Publishers (now Springer), Dordrecht). This new volume is similarly intended to be the definitive text on these bacteria for many years to come, and it will be a valuable resource for experienced researchers, Ph.D. students, and advanced undergraduates in the fields of ecology, microbiology, biochemistry and biophysics. Scientists interested in future applications of these bacteria which could harness their potential for nanotechnology, solar energy research, bioremediation, or as cell factories, will also find the book useful. The readers can easily find the titles and the authors of the individual chapters in the Table of Content of this book. Instead of repeating this information here, I prefer to thank each and every author by name (listed in alphabetical order) that reads like a ‘Who’s Who’ in the field of purple phototrophic bacteria:
Loach; Chris Mackenzie; Chris Madigan; Michael T. Madigan; Pier Luigi Martelli; Bernd Masepohl; Shinji Masuda; Donna L. Mielke; Osamu Miyashita; Mamoru Nango; Robert A. Niederman; Wolfgang Nitschke; Vladimir I. Novoderezhkin; Dror Noy; U. Mirian Obiozo; Melvin Okamura; Ozlem Onder; Miroslav Papiz; Pamela S. ParkesLoach; William W. Parson; Marcela Ávila Pérez; Tomáš Polívka; Oleg G. Poluektov; Pu Qian; Jason Raymond; Bruno Robert; Brigitte R. Robinson; Simona Romagnoli; Johannes Sander; Carsten Sanders; Hugo Scheer; Simon Scheuring; Barbara Schoepp-Cothenet; Klaus Schulten; Melih K. Şener; Aaron Setterdahl; James P. Shapleigh; James N. Sturgis; Wesley D. Swingley; F. Robert Tabita; Shinichi Takaichi; Banita Tamot; Serdar Turkarslan; Lisa M. Utschig; Rienk van Grondelle; Michael A. van der Horst; Luuk J. van Wilderen; André Verméglio; Paulette M. Vignais; Martin J. Warren; Arieh Warshel; JoAnn C. Williams; Robert D. Willows; Colin A. Wraight; Jiang Wu; Vladimir Yurkov; Davide Zannoni; and Jill Helen Zeilstra-Ryalls. It is a pleasure to note that the following 27 participants in Volume 2 have also contributed to Volume 28; they are (alphabetically): James P. Allen; Judith P. Armitage; Carl E. Bauer; J. Thomas Beatty; Robert E. Blankenship; Richard J. Cogdell; Fevzi Daldal; Harry A. Frank; Caroline S. Harwood; C. Neil Hunter; J. Baz Jackson; Pierre Joliot; Gabriele Klug; Robert G. Kranz; Paul A. Loach; Michael T. Madigan; Melvin Okamura; Pamela S. Parkes-Loach; William W. Parson; Hugo Scheer; F. Robert Tabita; Rienk van Grondelle; André Verméglio; Paulette M. Vignais; Arieh Warshel; JoAnn C. Williams; and Davide Zannoni. It is remarkable that all three editors of Volume 2 (Carl E. Bauer, Robert E. Blankenship (Chief Editor), and Michael T. Madigan) are authors in Volume 28; and 3 of the 4 editors of Volume 28 (J. Thomas Beatty; Fevzi Daldal; and C. Neil Hunter (Chief Editor)) were authors in Volume 2. As Volume 28 is a sequel to Volume 2, it is beneficial for the readers of the new volume to consult and cite chapters in the earlier volume; I present below authors, titles of chapters and page numbers of all the chapters in that book. Please note that this volume was published by Kluwer Academic Publishers which was later acquired by Springer, the publishers of the current volume.
Maxime T.A. Alexandre; James P. Allen; Judith P. Armitage; Herbert Axelrod; Carl E. Bauer; Christoph Benning; Edward A. Berry; Robert E. Blankenship; Francesca Borsetti; Paula Braun; Per A. Bullough; Rita Casadio; Madhusudan Choudhary; Toh Kee Chua; Richard J. Cogdell; Jason W. Cooley; Julius T. Csotony; Christiane Dahl; Fevzi Daldal; Evelyne Deery; Takehisa Dewa; Timothy J. Donohue; Katie Evans; Boris A. Feniouk; Leszek Fiedor; Anthony Fordham-Skelton; Harry A. Frank; Elaine R. Frawley; Mads Gabrielsen; Alastair T. Gardiner; Toni Georgiou; Marie-Louise Groot; Marilyn R. Gunner; Wolfgang Haehnel; Deborah K. Hanson; Caroline S. Harwood; Klaas J. Hellingwerf; Johnny Hendriks; Theresa Hillon; Jonathan Hosler; Li-Shar Huang; C. Neil Hunter; Kouji Iida; J. Baz Jackson; Pierre Joliot; Michael R. Jones; Deborah O. Jung; Wolfgang Junge; Samuel Kaplan; John T. M. Kennis; Gabriele Klug; Hans Georg Koch; Jürgen Köhler; David M. Kramer; Robert G. Kranz; Alison M. Kriegel; Philip D. Laible; Jérôme Lavergne; Dong-Woo Lee; Paul A. ix
Complete List of Chapters in Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria, edited by R.E. Blankenship, M.T. Madigan and C.E. Bauer, Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1995
in purple bacteria, pp 349–372 Chapter 18: H.A. Frank and R.L. Christensen (1995) Singlet energy transfer from carotenoids to bacteriochlorophylls, pp 373–384 Chapter 19: A. Freiberg (1995) Coupling of antennas to reaction centers, pp 385–398 Chapter 20: R.E. Blankenship, J.M. Olson and M. Mette (1995) Antenna complexes from green photosynthetic bacteria, pp 399–435 Chapter 21: P.A. Loach and P.S. Parkes-Loach (1995) Structure-function relationships in core light-harvesting complexes (LHI) as determined by characterization of the structural subunit and by reconstitution experiments, pp 437–471 Chapter 22: C.N. Hunter (1995) Genetic manipulation of the antenna complexes of purple bacteria, pp 473–501 Chapter 23: C.R.D. Lancaster, U. Ermler and H. Michel (1995) The structures of photosynthetic reaction centers from purple bacteria as revealed by X-ray crystallography, pp 503–526 Chapter 24: N.W. Woodbury and J.P. Allen (1995) The pathway, kinetics and thermodynamics of electron transfer in wild type and mutant reaction centers of purple nonsulfur bacteria, pp 527–557 Chapter 25: W.W. Parson and A. Warshel (1995) Theoretical analyses of electron-transfer reactions, pp 559–575 Chapter 26: M.Y. Okamura and G. Feher (1995) Proton-coupled electron transfer reactions of QB in reaction centers from photosynthetic bacteria, pp 577–594 Chapter 27: M. Volk, A. Ogrodnik and M.E. Michel-Beyerle (1995) The recombination dynamics of the radical pair P+H– in external magnetic and electric fields, pp 595–626 Chapter 28: W. Mäntele (1995) Infrared vibrational spectroscopy of reaction centers, pp 627–647 Chapter 29: H. Scheer and G. Hartwich (1995) Bacterial reaction centers with modified tetrapyrrole chromophores, pp 649–663 Chapter 30: U. Feiler and G. Hauska (1995) The reaction center from green sulfur bacteria, pp 665–685 Chapter 31: J. Amesz (1995) The antenna-reaction center complex of heliobacteria, pp 687–697 Chapter 32: R. Feick, J.A. Shiozawa and A. Ertlmaier (1995) Biochemical and spectroscopic properties of the reaction center of the green filamentous bacterium, Chloroflexus aurantiacus, pp 699–708 Chapter 33: R.G. Kranz and D.L. Beckman (1995) Cytochrome biogenesis, pp 709–723
Chapter 1: J.F. Imhoff (1995) Taxonomy and physiology of phototrophic purple bacteria and green sulfur bacteria, pp 1–15 Chapter 2: M.T. Madigan and J.G. Ormerod (1995) Taxonomy, physiology and ecology of heliobacteria, pp 17–30 Chapter 3: B.K. Pierson and R.W. Castenholz (1995) Taxonomy and physiology of filamentous anoxygenic phototrophs, pp 31–47 Chapter 4: H. Van Gemerden and J. Mas (1995) Ecology of phototrophic sulfur bacteria, pp 49–85 Chapter 5: R.W. Castenholz and B.K. Pierson (1995) Ecology of thermophilic anoxygenic phototrophs, pp 87–103 Chapter 6: K. Shimada (1995) Aerobic anoxygenic phototrophs, pp 105–122 Chapter 7: D.E. Fleischman, W.R. Evans and I.M. Miller (1995) Bacteriochlorophyll-containing rhizobium species, 123–136 Chapter 8: M.O. Senge and K.M. Smith (1995) Biosynthesis and structures of the bacteriochlorophylls, pp 137–151 Chapter 9: S.I. Beale (1995) Biosynthesis and structures of porphyrins and hemes, pp 153–177 Chapter 10: J.F. Imhoff and U. Bias-Imhoff (1995) Lipids, quinones and fatty acids of anoxygenic phototrophic bacteria, pp 179–205 Chapter 11: J. Weckesser, H. Mayer and G. Schulz (1995) Anoxygenic phototrophic bacteria: Model organisms for studies on cell wall macromolecules, pp 207–230 Chapter 12: G. Drews and J.R. Golecki (1995) Structure, molecular organization, and biosynthesis of membranes of purple bacteria, pp 231–257 Chapter 13: J. Oelze and J.R. Golecki (1995) Membranes and chlorosomes of green bacteria: Structure, composition and development, pp 259–278 Chapter 14: A. Verméglio, P. Joliot and A. Joliot (1995) Organization of electron transfer components and supercomplexes, pp 279–295 Chapter 15: W.S. Struve (1995) Theory of electronic energy transfer, pp 297–313 Chapter 16: H. Zuber and R.J. Cogdell (1995) Structure and organization of purple bacterial antenna complexes, pp 315–348 Chapter 17: V. Sundström and R. Van Grondelle (1995) Kinetics of excitation transfer and trapping x
Chapter 34: T.E. Meyer and T.J. Donohue (1995) Cytochromes, iron-sulfur, and copper proteins mediating electron transfer from the Cyt bc1 complex to photosynthetic reaction center complexes, pp 725–745 Chapter 35: K.A. Gray and F. Daldal (1995) Mutational studies of the cytochrome bc1 complexes, pp 747–774 Chapter 36: W. Nitschke and S.M. Dracheva (1995) Reaction center associated cytochromes, pp 775–805 Chapter 37: Z. Gromet-Elhanan (1995) The protontranslocating F0F1 ATP synthase-ATPase complex, pp 807–830 Chapter 38: J.B. Jackson (1995) Proton-translocating transhydrogenase and NADH dehydrogenase in anoxygenic photosynthetic bacteria, pp 831–845 Chapter 39: D.C. Brune (1995) Sulfur compounds as photosynthetic electron donors, pp 847–870 Chapter 40: R. Sirevåg (1995) Carbon metabolism in green bacteria, pp 871–883 Chapter 41: F.R. Tabita (1995) The biochemistry and metabolic regulation of carbon metabolism and CO2 fixation in purple bacteria, pp 885–914 Chapter 42: M.T. Madigan (1995) Microbiology of nitrogen fixation by anoxygenic photosynthetic bacteria, pp 915–928 Chapter 43: P.W. Ludden and G.P. Roberts (1995) The biochemistry and genetics of nitrogen fixation by photosynthetic bacteria, pp 929–947 Chapter 44: D. Zannoni (1995) Aerobic and anaerobic electron transport chains in anoxygenic phototrophic bacteria, pp 949–971 Chapter 45: J. Mas and H. Van Gemerden (1995) Storage products in purple and green sulfur bacteria, pp 973–990 Chapter 46: J. Gibson and C.S. Harwood (1995) Degradation of aromatic compounds by nonsulfur purple bacteria, pp 991–1003 Chapter 47: J.P. Armitage, D.J. Kelly and R.E. Sockett (1995) Flagellate motility, behavioral responses and active transport in purple non-sulfur bacteria, pp 1005–1028 Chapter 48: J.C. Williams and A.K.W. Taguchi (1995) Genetic manipulation of purple photosynthetic bacteria, pp 1029–1065 Chapter 49: M. Fonstein and R. Haselkorn (1995) Physical mapping of Rhodobacter capsulatus: Cosmid encyclopedia and high resolution genetic map, pp 1067–1081 Chapter 50: M. Alberti, D.H. Burke and J.E. Hearst (1995) Structure and sequence of the photosynthesis
gene cluster, pp 1083–1106 Chapter 51: J.L. Gibson (1995) Genetic analysis of CO2 fixation genes, pp 1107–1124 Chapter 52: A.J. Biel (1995) Genetic analysis and regulation of bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis, pp 1125–1134 Chapter 53: G.A. Armstrong (1995) Genetic analysis and regulation of carotenoid biosynthesis: Structure and fuction of the crt genes and gene products, pp 1135–1157 Chapter 54: J.A. Shiozawa (1995) A foundation for the genetic analysis of green sulfur, green filamentous and heliobacteria, pp 1159–1173 Chapter 55: P.M. Vignais, B. Toussaint and A. Colbeau (1995) Regulation of hydrogenase gene expression, pp 1175–1190 Chapter 56: R.G. Kranz and P.J. Cullen (1995) Regulation of nitrogen fixation genes, pp 1191–1208 Chapter 57: J.T. Beatty (1995) Organization of photosynthesis gene transcripts, pp 1209–1219 Chapter 58: C.E. Bauer (1995) Regulation of photosynthesis gene expression, pp 1221–1234 Chapter 59: G. Klug (1995) Post-transcriptional control of photosynthesis gene expression, pp 1235–1244 Chapter 60: R.C. Fuller (1995) Polyesters and photosynthetic bacteria: from lipid cellular inclusions to microbial thermoplastics, pp 1245–1256 Chapter 61: E.R. Goldman and D.C. Youvan (1995) Imaging Spectroscopy and combinatorial mutagenesis of the reaction center and light harvesting II antenna, pp 1257–1268 Chapter 62: Michiharu Kobayashi and Michihiko Kobayashi (1995) Waste remediation and treatment using anoxygenic phototrophic bacteria, pp 1269–1282
Future AIPH and Other Related Books The readers of the current series are encouraged to watch for the publication of the forthcoming books (not necessarily arranged in the order of future appearance): • C-4 Photosynthesis and Related CO2 Concentrating Mechanisms (Editors:Agepati S. Raghavendra and Rowan Sage); • Photosynthesis: Perspectives on Plastid Biology, Energy Conversion and Carbon Metabolism (Editors: Julian Eaton-Rye and Baishnab Tripathy); xi
• Abiotic Stress Adaptation in Plants: Physiological, Molecular and Genomic Foundation (Editors: Ashwani Pareek, Sudhir K. Sopory, Hans J. Bohnert and Govindjee); • The Chloroplast: Biochemistry, Molecular Biology and Bioengineering (Editors: Constantin Rebeiz, Hans Bohnert, Christoph Benning, Henry Daniell, Beverley R. Green, J. Kenneth Hoober, Hartmut Lichtenthaler, Archie R. Portis and Baishnab C. Tripathy); • Photosynthesis In Silico: Understanding Complexity from Molecules to Ecosystems (Editors: Agu Laisk, Ladislav Nedbal and Govindjee); and • Lipids in Photosynthesis: Essential and Regulatory Function (Editors: Hajime Wada and Norio Murata).
Readers are encouraged to send their suggestions for these and future Volumes (topics, names of future editors, and of future authors) to me by E-mail (gov@ illinois.edu) or fax (1-217-244-7246). In view of the interdisciplinary character of research in photosynthesis and respiration, it is my earnest hope that this series of books will be used in educating students and researchers not only in Plant Sciences, Molecular and Cell Biology, Integrative Biology, Biotechnology, Agricultural Sciences, Microbiology, Biochemistry, and Biophysics, but also in Bioengineering, Chemistry, and Physics. I take this opportunity to thank and congratulate C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion Thurnauer and Thomas Beatty for their editorial work. My special thanks go to C. Neil Hunter, the Chief Editor of Volume 28, for his painstaking work not only in editing, but also in organizing this book for Springer, and for his highly professional dealing with the typesetting process and his help in preparing this editorial. I particularly thank all the 116 authors (see the list above) of this book: without their authoritative chapters, there would be no such Volume. I give special thanks to Larry Orr for typesetting this book: his expertise has been crucial in bringing this book to completion. We owe Jacco Flipsen, Noeline Gibson and André Tournois (of Springer) thanks for their friendly working relation with us that led to the production of this book. Thanks are also due to Jeff Haas (Director of Information Technology, Life Sciences, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, UIUC), Evan DeLucia (Head, Department of Plant Biology, UIUC) and my dear wife Rajni Govindjee for constant support.
In addition to these contracted books, the following topics, among others, are under consideration: • • • • • • • • • • •
Cyanobacteria Genomics, Proteomics and Evolution Biohydrogen Production ATP Synthase and Proton Translocation Interactions between Photosynthesis and other Metabolic Processes Carotenoids II Green Bacteria and Heliobacteria Ecophysiology Photosynthesis, Biomass and Bioenergy Global Aspects of Photosynthesis Artificial Photosynthesis
May 14, 2008 Govindjee Series Editor, Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Department of Plant Biology, 265 Morrill Hall, 505 South Goodwin Avenue, Urbana, IL 61801-3707, USA E-mail: [email protected]; URL: http://www.life.uiuc.edu/govindjee
xii
Govindjee, Series Editor
Govindjee, born in 1932, obtained his B.Sc. (Chemistry, Biology) and M.Sc. (Botany, Plant Physiology) in 1952 and 1954, from the University of Allahabad, India, and his Ph.D. (Biophysics, under Eugene Rabinowitch), in 1960, from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (UIUC), IL, U.S.A. He is best known for his research on excitation energy transfer, light emission, primary photochemistry and electron transfer in Photosystem II (PS II). His research, with many collaborators, has included the discovery of a short-wavelength form of chlorophyll (Chl) a functioning in the Chl b-containing system, now called PS II, and of the two-light effects in Chl a fluorescence and in NADP (nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate) reduction in chloroplasts (Emerson Enhancement). Further, he has worked on the existence of different spectral fluorescing forms of Chl a and the temperature dependence of excitation energy transfer down to 4 K; basic relationships between Chl a fluorescence and photosynthetic reactions; the unique role of bicarbonate on the acceptor side of PS II, particularly in protonation events involving the QB binding region; the theory of thermoluminescence in plants; picosecond measurements on the primary photochemistry of PS II; and the use of Fluorescence Lifetime Imaging Microscopy (FLIM) of Chl a fluorescence in understanding photoprotection against excess light. His research on photosynthetic bacteria
included the observation of the absence of the Emerson Enhancement Effect (1960s); measurements on the lifetime of bacteriochlorophyll fluorescence (1970s); and the use of the bacterial reaction center structure in homology modeling of Photosystem II, particularly on its electron acceptor side (1990s). His current focus is on the ‘History of Photosynthesis Research,’ in ‘Photosynthesis Education’, and in the ‘Possible Existence of Extraterrestrial Life.’ He has served on the faculty of the UIUC for ~40 years. Since 1999, he has been Professor Emeritus of Biochemistry, Biophysics and Plant Biology at the same institution. His honors include: Fellow of the American Association of Advancement of Science; Distinguished Lecturer of the School of Life Sciences, UIUC; Fellow and Lifetime member of the National Academy of Sciences (India); President of the American Society for Photobiology (1980–1981); Fulbright Scholar and Fulbright Senior Lecturer; Honorary President of the 2004 International Photosynthesis Congress (Montréal, Canada); the 2006 Recipient of the Lifetime Achievement Award from the Rebeiz Foundation for Basic Biology; and the 2007 Recipient of the ‘Communication Award’ of the International Society of Photosynthesis Research (ISPR), presented to him at the 14th International Congress on Photosynthesis, held in Glasgow, Scotland, U.K.
xiii
Contents From the Series Editor
vii
Contents
xv
Preface
xxxi
Author Index
xxxvii
Color Plates
CP1–CP16
Part 1: Physiology, Ecology and Evolution 1
An Overview of Purple Bacteria: Systematics, Physiology, and Habitats Michael T. Madigan and Deborah O. Jung Summary I. Introduction II. Systematics of Purple Bacteria III. Physiology of Purple Bacteria IV. Habitats of Purple Bacteria V. Purple Bacteria in Extreme Environments VI. Final Remarks Acknowledgments References
2
1–15 2 2 3 4 7 9 12 12 12
Evolutionary Relationships Among Purple Photosynthetic Bacteria and the Origin of Proteobacterial Photosynthetic Systems 17–29 Wesley D. Swingley, Robert E. Blankenship and Jason Raymond Summary I. Introduction II. The Alphaproteobacteria III. Aerobic Purple Bacteria IV. The Photosynthesis Gene Cluster and its Role in Evolution V. Proteobacterial Comparative Genomics: Photosynthetic versus NonPhotosynthetic Proteins VI. Origin and Evolution of Proteobacterial Phototrophy VII. Origin and Evolution of Proteobacterial Carbon-fixation VIII. Future Directions: High-Throughput Sequencing and Metagenomics Acknowledgments References
xv
17 18 18 19 20 21 22 24 27 28 28
3
New Light on Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs Vladimir Yurkov and Julius T. Csotonyi
31–55
Summary 31 I. Introduction 32 II. Morphological Diversity, Taxonomic Nuances, Phylogeny and Evolution 34 III. Nutritional Versatility and Peculiarities of Carbon Metabolism 40 IV. Photosynthetic Pigment Composition and Synthesis Reveal Surprises 41 V. The Mysterious Photosynthetic Apparatus of Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs 44 VI. Speculation on Ecological Roles 47 VII. Concluding Remarks and Perspectives 51 Acknowledgments 52 References 52
Part 2: Molecular Structure and Biosynthesis of Pigments and Cofactors 4
Biosynthesis of Bacteriochlorophylls in Purple Bacteria Robert D. Willows and Alison M. Kriegel
57–79
Summary I. Introduction II. δ-Aminolevulinate to Protoporphyrin IX III. Protoporphyrin IX to Bacteriochlorophyll a and b IV. Concluding Remarks Acknowledgments References
5
Vitamin B12 (Cobalamin) Biosynthesis in the Purple Bacteria Martin J. Warren and Evelyne Deery
57 58 59 65 75 75 75
81–95
Summary I. Background II. Function of Cobalamin III. B12 Biosynthesis in Rhodobacter capsulatus and Rhodobacter sphaeroides IV. Summary of Events Required for Cobalamin Biosynthesis V. Biosynthesis of Precorrin-2 and Its Onward Route Towards Siroheme and Cobalamin VI. Control and Regulation of Cobalamin Biosynthesis Acknowledgments References
6
Distribution and Biosynthesis of Carotenoids Shinichi Takaichi Summary I. Introduction II. Carotenogenesis III. Carotenoids in Purple Bacteria Acknowledgments References
xvi
81 81 82 83 84 86 92 92 92
97–117 97 98 101 111 114 114
7
Membrane Lipid Biosynthesis in Purple Bacteria Banita Tamot and Christoph Benning Summary I. Introduction II. Fatty Acids III. Phosphoglycerolipids IV. Glycoglycerolipids V. Betaine Lipid VI. Ornithine Lipid VII. Lipid Function VIII. Perspectives Acknowledgments References
119–134 119 120 122 123 126 128 129 130 131 131 132
Part 3: Antenna Complexes: Structure, Function and Organization 8
Peripheral Complexes of Purple Bacteria Mads Gabrielsen, Alastair T. Gardiner and Richard J. Cogdell Summary I. Introduction II. Structure III. The Biology of Purple Bacterial Antenna Complexes IV. Final Remarks Acknowledgments References
9
Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting Core Complexes of Purple Bacteria Per A. Bullough, Pu Qian and C. Neil Hunter Summary I. Introduction II. The Building Blocks: The α and β Polypeptides of Light-Harvesting Complex 1, and PufX III. Circles, Arcs and Ellipses — The Light-Harvesting 1 Complex IV. Monomeric Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1 Complexes V. Monomeric Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1-PufX Complexes VI. Dimeric Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1-PufX Complexes VII. The Biogenesis of Core Complexes Acknowledgments References
xvii
135–153 135 136 136 146 151 151 151
155–179 155 156 156 160 162 166 168 174 175 175
10 Structure-Function Relationships in Bacterial Light-Harvesting Complexes Investigated by Reconstitution Techniques Paul A. Loach and Pamela S. Parkes-Loach
181–198
Summary I. Introduction II. Reversible Dissociation of Core Light-Harvesting 1 Complexes to a Subunit Form (B820) III. Reversible Dissociation of B820 to its Fundamental Components IV. Cofactor Requirements V. Cofactor – Protein Interactions VI. Cofactor – Cofactor Interactions VII. Protein–Protein Interactions VIII. Effect of PufX on Reconstitution of Light-Harvesting 1 Complexes IX. In vitro versus In vivo Assembly of Complexes X. Reconstitution of the Reaction Center Acknowledgments References
11 Spectroscopic Properties of Antenna Complexes from Purple Bacteria Bruno Robert
181 182 182 183 184 184 188 188 191 192 193 195 195
199–212
Summary 1. Introduction II. The Different Spectral Forms of Antenna Proteins from Purple Bacteria III. Antenna Proteins from Purple Bacteria: Variations Around a Structural Theme IV. The Role of Ground State Interactions in Tuning the Antenna Absorption Transition V. Excitonic Interactions and Disorder in Light-Harvesting Complexes VI. Chromophore Interactions in Light-Harvesting Proteins: Additional Effects VII. Conclusions Acknowledgments References
12 Energy Transfer from Carotenoids to Bacteriochlorophylls Harry A. Frank and Tomáš Polívka
201 203 205 207 208 209 209
213–230
Summary I. Introduction II. Carotenoid Excited States III. Energy Transfer in Light-Harvesting 2 Complexes IV. Energy Transfer in Light-Harvesting 1 Complexes and Reaction Centers V. Outlook Acknowledgments References
xviii
199 200 200
213 214 215 216 226 227 227 227
13 Spectroscopy and Dynamics of Excitation Transfer and Trapping in Purple Bacteria 231–252 Rienk van Grondelle and Vladimir I. Novoderezhkin Summary 232 I. Introduction 232 II. Structure and Exciton Spectra of Light-Harvesting 1 and 2 Bacterial Antenna Complexes 235 III. Equilibration Dynamics 239 IV. Competition of Intraband B800-800 and Interband B800-850 Energy Transfer in the Light-Harvesting 2 Complex 241 V. Energy Trapping in the Core Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1 Complex 243 VI. Slow Conformational Motions and Excitation Dynamics in the B850-LightHarvesting 2 Complex 244 VII. Concluding Remarks 247 Acknowledgments 248 References 248
14 Organization and Assembly of Light-Harvesting Complexes in the Purple Bacterial Membrane 253–273 James N. Sturgis and Robert A. Niederman Summary I. Introduction II. Themes and Variations — Structural Variability of Complexes in Native Membranes III. Principles of Photosynthetic Unit Organization IV. Proposals for the Functional Organization of Photosynthetic Units V. In Vivo Assembly of Light-Harvesting Complexes VI. Perspectives for the Next Ten Years References
15 From Atomic-Level Structure to Supramolecular Organization in the Photosynthetic Unit of Purple Bacteria Melih K. ùener and Klaus Schulten
254 254 255 257 263 267 269 270
275–294
Summary 275 I. Introduction 276 II. Components of the Photosynthetic Unit 278 III. Quantum Physics of Light-Harvesting and Excitation Energy Transfer 279 IV. Effect of Thermal Disorder on the Spectra of Light-Harvesting Complexes 282 V. Physical Constraints Shaping the Structure of Individual Light-Harvesting Complexes 284 VI. Supramolecular Organization of the Photosynthetic Unit 286 VII. An Atomic-level Structural Model for a Photosynthetic Membrane Vesicle 287 VIII. Light-Harvesting and Excitation Transfer across a Photosynthetic Membrane Vesicle 287 IX. Conclusions 289 Acknowledgments 290 References 290
xix
Part 4: Reaction Center Structure and Function 16 Structural Plasticity of Reaction Centers from Purple Bacteria Michael R. Jones
295–321
Summary I. The Plastic Purple Reaction Center II. Biochemical and Genetic Alteration of Polypeptide Composition III. Cofactor Exclusion IV. Cofactor Replacement V. Helix Symmetrization VI. Water and Other Unexpected Things in Electron Density Maps VII. Building New Functionality VIII. Conclusions Acknowledgments References
295 296 297 299 302 307 310 312 313 314 314
17 Structure and Function of the Cytochrome c2:Reaction Center Complex from Rhodobacter sphaeroides Herbert Axelrod, Osamu Miyashita and Melvin Okamura Summary I. Introduction II. History III. Structure of the Cytochrome c2:Reaction Center Complex IV. Electron Transfer Reactions V. Effects of Mutation VI. Mechanism of Inter-Protein Electron Transfer Acknowledgments References
18 Directed Modification of Reaction Centers from Purple Bacteria JoAnn C. Williams and James P. Allen Summary I. Introduction II. Properties of the Cofactors III. Electron Transfer Concepts IV. Pathways of Electron Transfer V. Conclusions Acknowledgments References
xx
323–336 323 324 324 325 327 329 332 333 333
337–353 337 338 338 343 346 349 349 349
19 Mechanism of Charge Separation in Purple Bacterial Reaction Centers William W. Parson and Arieh Warshel Summary I. The Reaction Sequence and Kinetics II. Energies of the Radical-Pair Intermediates III. Unusual Features of the Charge-Separation Reactions IV. Theories of Electron-Transfer Reactions Acknowledgments References
20 The Acceptor Quinones of Purple Photosynthetic Bacteria— Structure and Spectroscopy Colin A. Wraight and Marilyn R. Gunner Summary I. Introduction II. The Acceptor Quinone Reactions III. Structural Features of the Acceptor Quinone Binding Sites IV. Spectroscopy of the Acceptor Quinones V. Functionality of the Two Quinone Positions in the QB Site VI. Conclusions Note Added in Proof Acknowledgments References
355–377 355 356 357 360 363 370 370
379–405 379 380 382 383 389 396 398 398 398 399
Part 5: Cyclic Electron Transfer Components and Energy Coupling Reactions 21 Biogenesis of c-type Cytochromes and Cytochrome Complexes Carsten Sanders, Serdar Turkarslan, Ozlem Onder, Elaine R. Frawley, Robert G. Kranz, Hans Georg Koch and Fevzi Daldal Summary I. Introduction II. Maturation of c-type Cytochromes: Ccm-system I and Ccs-system II III. Biogenesis of Cytochrome Complexes Acknowledgments References
xxi
407–423
407 408 409 415 421 421
22 Structural and Mutational Studies of the Cytochrome bc1 Complex 425–450 Edward A. Berry, Dong-Woo Lee, Li-Shar Huang and Fevzi Daldal Summary I. Introduction II. Structural and Mutational Studies III. Conclusions and Perspectives Acknowledgments References
23 The Cytochrome bc1 and Related bc Complexes: The Rieske/ Cytochrome b Complex as the Functional Core of a Central Electron/Proton Transfer Complex David M. Kramer, Wolfgang Nitschke and Jason W. Cooley
425 426 427 446 447 447
451–473
Summary I. Introduction II. Structures of the Cytochrome bc1 and Related Rieske/Cytochrome b Complexes III. Catalysis in the Rieske/Cytochrome b Complexes: The General Q-cycle Framework IV. Phylogeny and Evolution V. The ‘Third’ Redox Subunit is a Phylogenetic Marker VI. The Rieske/Cytochrome b Complex, a Primordial Enzyme VII. The Molecular Mechanism of the Qo Site: Avoiding Q-Cycle Short Circuits VIII. The Quinone Reduction Site, Qi of the Cytochrome bc1 Complexes IX. The Quinone Reduction Site,Qi of the Cytochrome b6 f and Related Complexes X. The Functional Mechanism of the Rieske/Cytochrome b Complexes is Conserved Acknowledgments References
452 452 453 455 456 458 459 460 467 468 469 469 469
24 Proton Translocation and ATP Synthesis by the FoF1-ATPase of Purple Bacteria Boris A. Feniouk and Wolfgang Junge
475–493
Summary I. Introduction II. Structure and Rotary Catalysis III. Proton Translocation and its Coupling to ATP Synthesis/Hydrolysis III. Role of Proton Translocation in the Regulation of ATP Synthase Acknowledgments References
475 476 476 478 486 487 488
xxii
25 Proton-Translocating Transhydrogenase in Photosynthetic Bacteria J. Baz Jackson and U. Mirian Obiozo
495–508
Summary I. Introduction II. An Overview of the Main Structural Features of Transhydrogenase III. Distribution of Transhydrogenase Among Species IV. Phylogenetic Relationships between Transhydrogenases from Different Species V. The Function of Transhydrogenase in Photosynthetic Bacteria VI. The Mechanism of Coupling Between Hydride Transfer and Proton Translocation in Transhydrogenase VII. Conformational Changes in the Coupling Reactions of Transhydrogenase Acknowledgments References
495 496 496 496 498 500 501 504 505 506
26 Functional Coupling Between Reaction Centers and Cytochrome bc1 Complexes 509–536 Jérôme Lavergne, André Verméglio and Pierre Joliot Summary I. Introduction II. Structure of the Protein Complexes III. The Electron Donors to the Reaction Center IV. Kinetics of P+ Reduction by Mobile Cytochromes V. Donor Side Shuttling and Turnover of the Cytochrome bc1 Complex VI. Quinone Reactions VII. Supramolecular Organization in Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Rhodobacter capsulatus VIII. Quinone Confinement in Rhodobacter sphaeroides IX. Quinone Traffic in the PufX– Mutant of Rhodobacter sphaeroides X. The Supercomplex Model: Difficulties and Alternative Possibilities XI. Mitochondrial Supercomplexes XII. Diffusion and Confinement of Cytochrome c2: Possible Mechanisms XIII. Diffusion and Confinement of Quinones: Possible Mechanisms XIV. Conclusions References
509 510 512 514 515 517 518 519 522 522 524 526 527 528 529 530
Part 6: Metabolic Processes 27 Respiration and Respiratory Complexes 537–561 Davide Zannoni, Barbara Schoepp-Cothenet and Jonathan Hosler Summary I. Aerobic Respiration II. Respiration Utilizing Substrates other than Oxygen III. Respiration versus Photosynthesis: Which One Came First? IV. Respiration and Photosynthesis are Intermingled Acknowledgments References
xxiii
538 538 546 553 553 555 555
28 Carbon Dioxide Metabolism and its Regulation in Nonsulfur Purple Photosynthetic Bacteria Simona Romagnoli and F. Robert Tabita
563–576
Summary I. Introduction II. Regulation of cbb Gene Expression Acknowledgments References
29 Degradation of Aromatic Compounds by Purple Nonsulfur Bacteria Caroline S. Harwood
563 564 564 575 575
577–594
Summary I. Introduction II. Biochemical Themes III. Species that Degrade Aromatic Compounds IV. Aerobic Degradation of Aromatic Compounds by Rhodopseudomonas palustris V. Anaerobic Benzoate Degradation VI. The Molecular Regulation of Anaerobic Aromatic Compound Degradation VII. Comparative Aspects Acknowledgments References
30 Metabolism of Inorganic Sulfur Compounds in Purple Bacteria Johannes Sander and Christiane Dahl Summary I. Introduction II. Sulfur Oxidation Capabilities of Purple Bacteria III. Sulfur Oxidation Pathways IV. Sulfate Assimilation V. Conclusions Acknowledgments References
31 Dissimilatory and Assimilatory Nitrate Reduction in the Purple Photosynthetic Bacteria James P. Shapleigh Summary I. Introduction II. Denitrification III. Assimilation of Nitrogen IV. Conclusion Acknowledgments References
577 578 578 579 579 580 589 590 591 591
595–622 596 596 596 602 612 615 616 616
623–642 623 624 624 636 638 639 639
xxiv
32 Swimming and Behavior in Purple Non-Sulfur Bacteria Judith P. Armitage
643–654
Summary I. Introduction II. Swimming III. Behavioral Responses Acknowledgments References
643 644 644 646 653 653
33 Metals and Metalloids in Photosynthetic Bacteria: Interactions, Resistance and Putative Homeostasis Revealed by Genome Analysis Francesca Borsetti, Pier Luigi Martelli, Rita Casadio and Davide Zannoni
655–689
Summary I. Introduction II. Classification of Metals and Metalloids by their Toxicity or Essentiality to Bacterial Cells (Groups I, II and III). III. Metal Toxicity, Tolerance and Resistance: Generalities IV. General Features on Microbial Metal Resistance/Tolerance Mechanisms V. On the Bacterial Interactions with Metals and Metalloids VI. Metal(loid)s Homeostasis in Phototrophs as Revealed by Genome Analysis VII. Concluding Remarks Acknowledgments References
656 656 656 657 658 666 675 679 682 682
Part 7: Genomics, Regulation and Signaling 34 Purple Bacterial Genomics 691–706 Madhusudan Choudhary, Chris Mackenzie, Timothy J. Donohue and Samuel Kaplan I. II. III. IV.
Introduction Genome Architecture and Characteristics Gene Homologs and Metabolic Versatility Variation in Transcriptional Regulation and Adaptation to Changing Environments V. Transposons and Genomic Rearrangements VI. Circadian Clock and Gas Vesicle Proteins VII. Inorganic Compounds as Reducing Power VIII. Genomic Insights into the Photosynthetic Lifestyle Acknowledgments References
xxv
692 692 696 701 702 702 703 703 704 704
35 Regulation of Gene Expression in Response to Oxygen Tension 707–725 Carl E. Bauer, Aaron Setterdahl, Jiang Wu and Brigitte R. Robinson Summary I. Introduction II. RegB/RegA Two-Component Signal Transduction System III. Aerobic repression by CrtJ IV. Regulation by Fnr Acknowledgments References
36 Regulation of Genes by Light Gabriele Klug and Shinji Masuda
707 707 708 716 721 722 722
727–741
Summary I. Introduction II. Photoreceptors in Purple Photosynthetic Bacteria III. Light-Dependent Responses that Do Not Depend on Photoreceptors IV. Concluding Remarks Acknowledgments References
37 Regulation of Hydrogenase Gene Expression Paulette M. Vignais
727 728 728 735 737 737 737
743–757
Summary I. Introduction II. Regulation of Hydrogenase Gene Expression: Signaling and Transcription Control References
38 Regulation of Nitrogen Fixation Bernd Masepohl and Robert G. Kranz
743 744 744 755
759–775
Summary I. Nitrogen Fixation in Purple Nonsulfur Bacteria II. Three Regulatory Levels of Nitrogen Fixation and Molecular Mechanisms Studied in Rhodobacter capsulatus III. Other Factors that Feed into the Nitrogen Regulatory Circuitry IV. Regulation in Other Purple Photosynthetic Bacteria V. Future Perspectives Acknowledgments References
xxvi
760 760 762 768 770 771 772 772
39 Regulation of the Tetrapyrrole Biosynthetic Pathway Jill Helen Zeilstra-Ryalls
777–798
Summary I. Introduction II. Tetrapyrrole Biosynthesis Genes III. Comparing and Contrasting Oxygen Control of Tetrapyrrole Biosynthesis Genes in Species of Rhodobacter IV. Other Aspects of Transcriptional Regulation of Tetrapyrrole Biosynthesis Genes in Rhodobacter Species V. A Genomics Perspective on the Regulation of Tetrapyrrole Biosynthesis in Other Purple Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria Note Added in Proof Acknowledgments References
40 Bacteriophytochromes Control Photosynthesis in Rhodopseudomonas palustris Katie Evans, Toni Georgiou, Theresa Hillon, Anthony Fordham-Skelton and Miroslav Papiz I. II.
777 778 778 779 789 789 795 795 795
799–809
Introduction Bacteriophytochrome Gene Organization and Regulation of Photosynthesis in Rhodopseudomonas palustris III. Phytochrome Domain Organization IV. Bilin Chromophore Photo-conversion V. Chromophore Binding Domain of Deinococcus radiodurans Bacteriophytochrome VI. Small Angle X-ray Scattering Solution Structure of Bph4 from Rhodopseudomonas palustris VII. Conclusions Acknowledgments References
800 800 803 804 805 805 807 807 807
41 Photoreceptor Proteins from Purple Bacteria 811–837 Johnny Hendriks, Michael A. van der Horst, Toh Kee Chua, Marcela Ávila Pérez, Luuk J. van Wilderen, Maxime T.A. Alexandre, Marie-Louise Groot, John T. M. Kennis and Klaas J. Hellingwerf Summary I. Introduction II. Light, Oxygen, or Voltage Domains III. The BLUF Domain Containing Family of Photoreceptors IV. Comparison Between LOV and BLUF Domains V. The Xanthopsins VI. Bacteriophytochromes VII. Concluding Remarks Acknowledgments References
xxvii
811 812 813 816 822 823 827 831 832 832
Part 8: New Applications and Techniques 42 Foreign Gene Expression in Photosynthetic Bacteria Philip D. Laible, Donna L. Mielke and Deborah K. Hanson Summary I. Introduction II. Design of a Rhodobacter-Based System for the Expression of Membrane Proteins for Structural and Functional Studies III. Production of Foreign Membrane Proteins in Rhodobacter IV. Optimization and Generalization of Heterologous Expression in Rhodobacter V. Advantages Afforded by Rhodobacter VI. Perspectives Acknowledgments References
43 Assembly of Bacterial Light-Harvesting Complexes on Solid Substrates Kouji Iida, Takehisa Dewa and Mamoru Nango Summary I. Introduction II. Atomic Force Microscopy Imaging of Reassociated Bacterial LightHarvesting Complex 1 on a Mica Substrate III. Conductivity of the Bacterial Reaction Center on Chemically Modified Gold Substrates Using Conductive Atomic Force Microscopy IV. Molecular Assembly of Photosynthetic Antenna Core Complex on an Amino-terminated Indium Tin Oxide Electrode V. Concluding Remarks Acknowledgments References
44 Optical Spectroscopy of Individual Light-Harvesting Complexes from Purple Bacteria Jürgen Köhler Summary I. Introduction II. The Experimental Setup III. Energy Transfer, Excitons, Strong and Weak Coupling IV. Spectroscopy of Single Light-Harvesting 2 Antenna Complexes V. Energy Transfer in a Single Photosynthetic Unit Acknowledgements References
xxviii
839–860 840 840 841 847 850 852 856 856 856
861–875 861 862 864 865 869 873 873 873
877–894 877 877 879 880 882 889 891 891
45 De novo Designed Bacteriochlorophyll-Binding Helix-Bundle Proteins Wolfgang Haehnel, Dror Noy and Hugo Scheer
895–912
Summary I. Introduction II. Chlorophyll Structures and Interactions with Natural Proteins III. Challenges in Designing de novo Chlorophyll- and Bacteriochlorophyllbinding Proteins IV. Modular Organized Chlorophyll Proteins Based on Branched Fourhelix Bundle Proteins V. Incorporating Chlorophylls and Bacteriochlorophylls into Self-assembling Protein Maquettes VI. From Water-soluble to Amphiphilic Chlorophyll- and Bacteriochlorophyllprotein Maquettes Acknowledgments References
46 Design and Assembly of Functional Light-Harvesting Complexes Paula Braun and Leszek Fiedor Summary I. Introduction II. Design of Model Light-Harvesting Proteins III. Assembly of Functional Light-Harvesting 1 Complexes IV. Conclusions and Prospects Acknowledgments References
895 896 897 899 901 904 905 907 907
913–940 914 914 916 924 935 935 936
47 The Supramolecular Assembly of the Photosynthetic Apparatus of Purple Bacteria Investigated by High-Resolution Atomic Force Microscopy 941–952 Simon Scheuring Summary I. Introduction II. Atomic Force Microscopy Analysis of the Complexes of the Bacterial Photosynthetic Apparatus III. Conclusions IV. Feasibilities, Limitations and Outlook Acknowledgments References
xxix
941 942 943 949 950 951 951
48 Protein Environments and Electron Transfer Processes Probed with High-Frequency ENDOR Oleg G. Poluektov and Lisa M. Utschig
953–973
Summary I. Introduction II. Low Temperature Interquinone Electron Transfer in the Photosynthetic Reaction Center. Characterization of QB– States III. Electron Transfer Pathways and Protein Response to Charge Separation IV. Concluding Remarks Acknowledgments References
Index
953 954 956 963 968 969 969
975–1013
xxx
Preface This book follows the tradition initiated in 1963, then subsequently extended in 1978 and 1995, of summarizing our knowledge of the photototrophic bacteria in a single volume. The first book was Bacterial Photosynthesis (Howard Gest, Anthony San Pietro and Leo P.Vernon, eds), 1963, Antioch Press, Yellow Springs, Ohio. Fifteen years later, Roderick K. Clayton and William R. Sistrom edited The Photosynthetic Bacteria (1978, Plenum Press, New York), an indispensable book for any scientist in the field at that time. In 1995, Robert Blankenship, Michael Madigan and Carl Bauer edited the most complete survey of the subject, Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria. By that time, the book had been taken under the wing of the Advances in Photosynthesis Series, initiated by Govindjee, as Volume 2 (Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht), and now, in 2008, we come to volume 28, entitled The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria (Springer, Dordrecht). The word “phototrophic” is used because it has become clear that many purple bacteria are incapable of photosynthesis (synthesis of all cellular carbon components from CO2), although they are capable of obtaining energy in the form of ATP from light (using light-harvesting and reaction center complexes that are homologous to those of purple photosynthetic bacteria). This latest survey of the field is restricted to the purple bacteria, and does not attempt to cover, for example, the green sulfur bacteria. There have been so many exciting developments since 1995 that the editors felt that it was sufficiently challenging to summarize thirteen years of research on the purple bacteria. This proved to be the case, and 48 chapters and more than 1000 pages were necessary to encompass the depth and breadth of the progress made in studying these fascinating organisms. Since 1995, there has been an explosion of information available from genome sequencing and related projects. The first 3-D structure of the bacterial cytochrome bc1 complex has been determined, and more structural information has been obtained for light-harvesting and reaction center membrane-protein complexes. Site-directed modifications of light-harvesting and reaction center complexes have been correlated with altered spectroscopic properties, even on a femtosecond timescale. Spectroscopic methods in general have advanced considerably since the last volume in 1995; an important example is the development of single
molecule approaches. New theoretical frameworks have had to keep pace with such technical developments. Through the use of atomic force microscopy it has been possible to examine the organization of clusters of individual light-harvesting and reaction center complexes in their native membranes. We are now beginning to see how the properties of native and modified photosynthetic complexes can be harnessed on the nanoscale for the design of biologically-inspired energy and electron transfer devices. In addition to these advances, we are reminded that many new phototrophic bacteria are still being discovered, and although it has been 45 years since the first book on these bacteria appeared, there is much that we do not know or understand. Recent publications indicate that purple phototrophic bacteria are ubiquitous on Earth, and raise questions about their contributions to global cycles of elements. Certainly, the extraordinary metabolic versatility of the purple bacteria, and their amenability to investigation by genetic, biochemical and biophysical techniques, will ensure that despite the inevitably cyclical and variable nature of science funding, there will always be compelling reasons to carry out research on the purple bacteria. Since 1995, it has become ever easier to obtain information online, and it could be argued that the need for a book on this topic is not as compelling as it might have been thirty years ago. However, there is still much value in having a hard copy of the diverse collection of information represented by the 48 chapters of this book, compiled at this point in time and which can be held in the hand. We have attempted to impart some coherence to this project, a process helped by using the organization of the 1995 volume as a starting point. The editors have adopted a pragmatic approach to the issue of taxonomy and, in the light of the ever-changing nature of specific bacterial names, a rigid policy of using only the most recent ones has not been enforced. Thus, Rhodopseudomonas acidophila is now Rhodoblastus acidophilus, for example, but the former name still predominates in the book. Helpful lists of purple phototrophic bacteria, as well as lists of genes, enzymes, pathways, and many more attributes of these bacteria, appear throughout this book. In addition, a section is included at the end of the present volume on new applications and techniques, with the hope that perhaps some of these will form the basis of a xxxi
fifth book, several years from now. This new volume is intended to be a resource for present and future researchers in the fields of ecology, microbiology, biochemistry and biophysics, some of whom might be interested in harnessing the potential of these bacteria as cell factories, or for bioremediation, nanotechnology or solar energy research. We hope that this book will help to attract a new generation of scientists to this field. We thank the authors of all the chapters for entering into the spirit of this project, which is intended to create a lasting work of reference, and a milestone in the field, a staging post on a journey that still has a long way to run.
We are grateful to various individuals who have offered advice, including Govindjee, (the Series Editor), John Golbeck (Editor of the book on Photosystem I, Volume 24 in the Series), Robert Blankenship (one of the Editors of Volume 2 in the Series) and Hugo Scheer (one of the Editors of Volume 25 that focused on Chlorophylls and Bacteriochlophylls), but above all we thank Larry Orr, whose guidance has underpinned the progress of this book. Finally the editors thank their respective families and members of their laboratories for their patience throughout the editing process. May 14, 2008 C. Neil Hunter Krebs Institute for Biomolecular Research Department of Molecular Biology and Biotechnology University of Sheffield Firth Court, Western Bank Sheffield S10 2TN U.K. Email: c.n.hunter@sheffield.ac.uk Fevzi Daldal Department of Biology University of Pennsylvania Philadelphia, PA 19104 U.S.A. Email: [email protected] Marion C. Thurnauer Argonne National Laboratory Chemistry Division, E125 9700 S. Cass Avenue Argonne, Illinois 60439 U.S.A. Email: [email protected] J. Thomas Beatty Dept. of Microbiology & Immunology University of British Columbia Rm. 4556, 2350 Health Sciences Mall Vancouver, BC, V6T 1Z3 Canada Email: [email protected]
xxxii
C. Neil Hunter was born in 1954 in Yorkshire, U.K., and is a Professor in the Department of Molecular Biology and Biotechnology at the University of Sheffield, U.K. He obtained his B.Sc. Degree at the University of Leicester in 1975, where the lectures of Professor Hans Kornberg and a laboratory project with Professor Peter Henderson inspired a lifelong interest in metabolism and bioenergetics. Wanting to learn about photosynthesis, Hunter moved to Bristol University, where the laboratories of Professors Trevor Griffiths, Owen Jones and Tony Crofts were studying many aspects of this topic, from pigment biosynthesis through to electron transport. Hunter studied for his Ph.D. under the guidance of Professor Owen Jones on the topic of membrane assembly in bacterial photosynthesis, and a sabbatical visit of Professor Robert Niederman to the Jones laboratory in Bristol led, in 1978, to a postdoctoral fellowship at Rutgers University, New Jersey. Hunter’s interests in light-harvesting complexes and membrane assembly developed further at this stage, but research in this
area was hampered by a lack of molecular genetic tools to study Rhodobacter sphaeroides. After returning to Bristol to learn about molecular biology in the laboratory of Professor Geoff Turner, it was possible eventually to use transposon Tn5 mutagenesis to gain access to the genes encoding the enzymes for bacteriochlorophyll and carotenoid biosynthesis and to develop a toolkit for site directed mutagenesis of photosynthetic complexes. In 1984, Hunter was appointed to a Lectureship at Imperial College, London, attached to the group of Professor James Barber. He returned to his native Yorkshire in 1988 to a Senior Lectureship at Sheffield University. In 1996 Hunter was awarded a D. Sc. by Bristol University. He is now the Krebs Professor of Biochemistry at Sheffield, and continues to apply a combination of molecular genetic, biochemical, structural and spectroscopic approaches to dissect the pathways for bacteriochlorophyll and carotenoid biosynthesis, and to investigate the assembly, structure, function and organization of bacterial photosynthetic membranes.
xxxiii
Fevzi Daldal is a Professor in the Department of Biology, University of Pennsylvania. He obtained his BS/MS degrees in 1974 at the Institut National des Sciences Appliquées (INSA) de Lyon, France, where he was first introduced into bacterial research in François Stoeber’s group. He followed his graduate studies on the genetics of Escherichia coli cell division at the Université Louis Pasteur, Strasbourg, France, under the guidance of Drs. Raymond Minck (Director of the Microbiology Institute ) and Maxime Schwartz (who was at the Pasteur Institute in Paris, France), obtaining his doctorate in 1977. From 1969 to 1977, his undergraduate and graduate studies were supported by scholarships from the French Government. In 1978, he joined, as a postdoctoral fellow, Dr. Dan G. Fraenkel at Harvard Medical School, Microbiology and Molecular Genetics Department to work on E. coli intermediary metabolism and on the phosphofructokinase II enzyme. After joining the Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory as a Scientist in 1983, Daldal started his studies with purple non sulfur bacteria Rhodobacter species, focusing on cy-
tochromes, which led him to discover the membrane attached electron carrier cytochrome cy, to co-discover the cytochrome cbb3 oxidase as well as novel genes involved in cytochrome biogenesis. His main work on the cytochrome bc1 complex included many studies, extending from the isolation of the structural genes to the crystallization of the enzyme complex to address detailed structure-function aspects using molecular genetics, biochemistry and biophysical approaches with Rhodobacter. Daldal’s current research is centered on the structure, function, regulation, proteomics and biogenesis of membrane cytochromes in Rhodobacter species. His contributions have been recognized by his election as a Member to the Turkish Academy of Science (2000), the American Academy of Microbiology (2005), the American Association for the Advancement of Science (2006) and Chair of the Gordon Conference on Molecular and Cellular Bioenergetics (2007). Daldal was an Editor of the Archives of Microbiology (2000–2006), and currently is a member of the Editorial Board of the Journal of Bacteriology, and a reviewer for many journals.
xxxiv
Marion C. Thurnauer received a B.A.(1968), M.S.(1969),and Ph.D. (1974) in Chemistry, all from the University of Chicago, Illinois, USA. Her thesis research, under the guidance of Gerhard Closs, was in the area of photochemistry; in particular, she studied magnetic interactions in radical pairs using electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy. In 1974, she became ‘hooked’ on photosynthesis research after accepting a postdoctoral position at the Argonne National Laboratory (ANL), Lemont, IL, USA, to study magnetic resonance properties of excited triplet states of chlorophylls in photosynthetic units and in low temperature solutions. During that period, she and her mentors James R. Norris and Joseph J. Katz demonstrated that the unique electron spin polarization observed in the EPR spectrum of the triplet state of the primary electron donor in the reaction center was due to radical pair induced intersystem crossing. In 1977, she was promoted to staff member at ANL where she served as Group Leader of the Photosynthesis Research Group (1993–1995) and Director of the ANL Chemistry Division (1995–2003). Currently, she is Argonne Distinguished Fellow, Emeritus. Her research involved studies of sequential electron transfer in natural photosynthetic systems of photosynthetic bacteria and oxygenic photosynthesis, using primarily time-resolved EPR methods. She and her
colleagues demonstrated the spin correlated radical pair nature of the transient oxidized primary electron donor and reduced quinone acceptor in photosystem I, and, by comparison in purple photosynthetic bacteria. Her work (together with her colleagues) also extended to development of time-resolved magnetic resonance techniques, particularly for application to study photochemical energy conversion. Collaborating with Tijana Rajh, her research also included EPR studies of photoexcited surface modified nanocrystalline metal oxide colloids to mimic the energy transduction of natural photosynthesis. She served as Chair of the Gordon Research Conference on Photosynthesis: Biophysical Aspects (1994); she has organized several symposia and workshops on magnetic resonance and photosynthesis. During 2002–2003, she served on the Editorial Board of Biophysical Journal. In 2002, she was awarded the 2002 Francis P. Garvan-John M. Olin Medal by the American Chemical Society. Other honors include: the University of Chicago Award for Distinguished Performance at Argonne in 1991; the Agnes Fay Morgan Research Award in 1987; elected as a Fellow of the American Association for the Advancement of Science in 1998. She was the first recipient of the University of Chicago-Argonne Pinnacle of Education Award in 2007.
xxxv
J. Thomas Beatty is a Professor in the Department of Microbiology and Immunology at the University of British Columbia, Canada. He obtained the B.S. degree at the University of Washington in 1976, where a research project under the supervision of James T. Staley sparked Beatty’s interest in phototrophic bacteria. Beatty went on to graduate studies (M.A. in 1978; Ph.D. in 1980) under the guidance of Howard Gest at Indiana University, Bloomington, IN, USA, where he studied the metabolism of purple and green bacteria. Beatty’s postdoctoral research (1980–1983), in Stanley N. Cohen’s laboratory in the Department of Genetics, at the Stanford University School of Medicine, California, USA, included the discovery of differential degradation of light-harvesting 1 (LH1) and reaction center (RC) mRNA segments in the purple bacterium Rhodobacter capsulatus as a process that underlies the relative amounts of LH1 and RC complexes in the cell membrane. After taking up a faculty position at the University of British Columbia in 1983, Beatty has contributed to diverse areas of photosynthesis research: transcrip-
xxxvi
tional regulation of photosynthesis gene expression and elucidation of ‘superoperons’; discovery of the PufX protein and its role in quinone translocation as part of the RC/LH1/PufX core complex; isolation and characterization of new species of phototrophic bacteria; mechanisms of proton translocation into the RC; assembly of photosynthetic complexes; genomics and proteomics of purple bacteria. Beatty’s current research continues on the problems mentioned above, as well as on the ‘gene transfer agent’ (GTA) of Rba. capsulatus. His contributions have been recognized by a prize from the American Society for Microbiology (2002) and a Killam Research Fellowship from the Canada Council for the Arts (2008); he has been featured in popular publications such as the National Geographic and in several newspaper articles. Beatty was an Editor of FEMS Microbiology Letters, and a member of the Editorial Boards of Applied and Environmental Microbiology and the Journal of Bacteriology for many years. He is at present an Editor of Photosynthesis Research.
Author Index Alexandre, Maxime T. A. 811–837 Allen, James P. 337–353 Armitage, Judith P. 643–654 Axelrod, Herbert 323–336
Hillon, Theresa 799–809 Hosler, Jonathan 537–561 Huang, Li-Shar 425–450 Hunter, C. Neil 155–179
Bauer, Carl E. 707–725 Benning, Christoph 119–134 Berry, Edward A. 425–450 Blankenship, Robert E. 17–29 Borsetti, Francesca 655–689 Braun, Paula 913–940 Bullough, Per A. 155–179
Iida, Kouji 861–875
Casadio, Rita 655–689 Choudhary, Madhusudan 691–706 Chua, Toh Kee 811–837 Cogdell, Richard J. 135–153 Cooley, Jason W. 451–473 Csotony, Julius T. 31–55
Kaplan, Samuel 691–706 Kennis, John T. M. 811–837 Klug, Gabriele 727–741 Koch, Hans Georg 407–423 Köhler, Jürgen 877–894 Kramer, David M. 451–473 Kranz, Robert G. 407–423; 759–775 Kriegel, Alison M. 57–79
Dahl, Christiane 595–622 Daldal, Fevzi 407–423; 425–450 Deery, Evelyne 81–95 Dewa, Takehisa 861–875 Donohue, Timothy J. 691–706
Jackson, J. Baz 495–493 Joliot, Pierre 509–536 Jones, Michael R. 295–321 Jung, Deborah O. 1–15 Junge, Wolfgang 475–493
Laible, Philip D. 839–860 Lavergne, Jérôme 509–536 Lee, Dong-Woo 425–450 Loach, Paul A. 181–198
Evans, Katie 799–809 Feniouk, Boris A. 475–493 Fiedor, Leszek 913–940 Fordham-Skelton, Anthony 799–809 Frank, Harry A. 213–230 Frawley, Elaine R. 407–423 Gabrielsen, Mads 135–153 Gardiner, Alastair T. 135–153 Georgiou, Toni 799–809 Groot, Marie-Louise 811–837 Gunner, Marilyn R. 379–405 Haehnel, Wolfgang 895–912 Hanson, Deborah K. 839–860 Harwood, Caroline S. 577–594 Hellingwerf, Klaas J. 811–837 Hendriks, Johnny 811–837
Mackenzie, Chris 691–706 Madigan, Michael T. 1–15 Martelli, Pier Luigi 655–689 Masepohl, Bernd 759–775 Masuda, Shinji 727–741 Mielke, Donna L. 839–860 Miyashita, Osamu 323–336 Nango, Mamoru 861–875 Niederman, Robert A. 253–273 Nitschke, Wolfgang 451–473 Novoderezhkin, Vladimir I. 231–252 Noy, Dror 895–912 Obiozo, U. Mirian 495–493 Okamura, Melvin 323–336 Onder, Ozlem 407–423
xxxvii
Papiz, Miroslav 799–809 Parkes-Loach, Pamela S. 181–198 Parson, William W. 355–377 Pérez, Marcela Ávila 811–837 Polívka, Tomáš 213–230 Poluektov, Oleg G. 953–973
Tabita, F. Robert 563–576 Takaichi, Shinichi 97–117 Tamot, Banita 119–134 Turkarslan, Serdar 407–423
Qian, Pu 155–179
van Grondelle, Rienk 231–252 van der Horst, Michael A. 811–837 van Wilderen, Luuk J. 811–837 Verméglio, André 509–536 Vignais, Paulette M. 743–757
Raymond, Jason 17–29 Robert, Bruno 199–212 Robinson, Brigitte R. 707–725 Romagnoli, Simona 563–576 Sander, Johannes 595–622 Sanders, Carsten 407–423 Scheer, Hugo 895–912 Scheuring, Simon 941–952 Schoepp-Cothenet, Barbara 537–561 Schulten, Klaus 275–294 Şener, Melih K. 275–294 Setterdahl, Aaron 707–725 Shapleigh, James P. 623–642 Sturgis, James N. 253–273 Swingley, Wesley D. 17–29
Utschig, Lisa M. 953–973
Warren, Martin J. 81–95 Warshel, Arieh 355–377 Williams, JoAnn C. 337–353 Willows, Robert D. 57–79 Wraight, Colin A. 379–405 Wu, Jiang 707–725 Yurkov, Vladimir 31–55 Zannoni, Davide 537–561; 655–689 Zeilstra-Ryalls, Jill Helen 777–798
xxxviii
Color Plates
Fig. 1. Schematic comparison of photosynthesis gene clusters (PGC) from various purple bacteria. Lines represent transpositions of syntenous gene regions between two PGC. Numbers annotated above the Rhodospirillum rubrum PGC represent the location on the genome of each separate PGC segment. Genes colored in green represent BChl biosynthesis genes, orange represent carotenoid biosynthesis genes, red represent structural genes of the photosynthetic apparatus, blue represent regulatory genes and other colors represent unique genes. The black and blue lines with arrows represent inversion of the genes contained between the lines and the red lines represent shifts in position without inversions. See Chapter 2, p. 20.
C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty (eds): The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria, pp. CP1–CP16. © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V.
Color Plates
Fig. 2. Photosynthetic and habitat diversity of aerobic anoxygenic phototrophs (AAP) A–E. In vivo absorbance spectra of cells grown under different physiological conditions, with numerals above peaks denoting LH and RC wavelengths. Insets, photographs of liquid cultures. A. Roseicyclus mahoneyensis, illuminated (dashed line) and dark (solid line). B,C. Dashed line, rich organic medium (3 g·l–1 organics); solid line, minimal acetate (1 g·l–1) medium (B. Roseococcus thiosulfatophilus, C. Erythrobacter litoralis). D. Erythromicrobium ramosum, rich organic medium, dark (dashed line) and oligotrophic medium, light:dark regimen of 12h:12h, illuminated with diffuse ambient sunlight (solid line). E. Citromicrobium bathyomarinum strain JF1, rich organic medium (dashed line), minimal glucose medium (dotted line), compared with Erythrobacter litoralis (solid line). F. Hypothetical electron transfer system of aerobic anoxygenic photosynthesis, showing electron flow through major carriers: P870, special pair of BChl in RC (photoexcited state indicated by ‘*’); BChl-BPh, accessory BChl and bacteriophaeophytin in the RC; QA, quinone primary electron acceptor; Cyt bc1, cytochrome bc1 complex; Cyt c2, cytochrome c2. The symbol ‘+’ indicates that the midpoint potential of QA in all tested AAP is positive and higher than in anaerobic phototrophs. G–I. Extreme environment habitats of AAP. G. Hydrothermal vent field in Eastern Pacific Ocean, showing smoker chimney. H. Hypersaline spring system (East German Creek) in Manitoba, Canada: spring pool in foreground and playa in background, with white patches of salt precipitates. I. Cyanobacterial-Thiothrix mat development in thermal springs of Banff National Park, Alberta, Canada. See Chapter 3, p. 39.
CP2
Color Plates
Fig. 3. Representations of the β/α-protomer building blocks that comprise LH2. The β-chains are shown in blue and the α-chains in green. The BChls are shown in red and the carotenoid in pale blue. a) A view of the α/β-protomer with the pigments removed. The main BChl liganding amino acid side chains are shown. b) A view of how two adjacent β/α-protomers interact with each other, again with the pigments removed. c) Similar to b) but looking down onto the two adjacent α/β-protomers from the C-terminal side of the complex. d) The same view as a) but with the pigments included. e) A view of the α/β-protomer from Phaeospirillum (Phs.) molischianum. The main differences between d) and e) are the altered orientation of the B800 bacteriochlorin ring and the different organization of the C-terminal region of the α-apoprotein. f) A view of the α/β-protomer from Rps. acidophila strain 7050. Note the different amino acids shown at the C-terminal end of the α-apoprotein that are responsible for the altered absorption properties of this B800-820 complex. The structures shown in a–d are representations of the structure of the B800-850, LH2 complex from Rps. acidophila strain 10050. See Chapter 8, p. 138.
Fig. 4. The LH2 complex from Rhodopseudomonas (Rps.) acidophila strain 10050. a) A view looking down on the top of the complex from the presumed periplasmic surface of the membrane. (b) A side view looking from within the presumed photosynthetic membrane with the periplasmic side of the complex uppermost. In both panels the LH2α polypeptide is green, LH2β is blue, B850 BChls are purple, B800 BChls are brown and the carotenoids are red. See Chapter 8, p. 140.
CP3
Color Plates
Fig. 5. (A) Dynamics of the transient absorption (TA) spectrum measured upon 1017 nm excitation of the LH1 of Blc. viridis at 77 K (Monshouwer et al., 1998). (B) Measured (points) and calculated (solid lines) red-shift of the TA spectrum between 0 and 400 fs upon 1017 nm excitation of the LH1 of Blc. viridis at 77K (Novoderezhkin and van Grondelle, 2002). (C) Measured (points) and modeled (solid line) TA kinetics at 1050 nm traces upon 1055 nm excitation of the LH1 of Blc. viridis at 77K (Novoderezhkin et al., 2000). See Chapter 13, p. 240.
Fig. 6. Coherent dynamics of the density matrix for a single LH2 complex, i.e., calculated without relaxation of populations and coherences for one realization of the disorder corresponding to a blue-shifted (top), an intermediate (middle), and a red-shifted (bottom) FL spectrum (Novoderezhkin et al., 2006). The initial population corresponds to the thermal equilibrium at room temperature (shown in the inserts by blue, green, and red for the blue-shifted, intermediate, and red-shifted spectra, respectively), initial coherences have arbitrary fixed phases. The figure shows the diagonal elements of the density matrix in the site representation ρ(n,n) as a function of time. The color scale is used to indicate the absolute values of the density matrix from zero (blue) to the maximal value (red). See Chapter 13, p. 247.
CP4
Color Plates
Fig. 7. Structural models of monomeric and dimeric core complexes. In each case a side view and a space-filling representation is used. For the RC the complete structure is present (shown in blue), but for the LH1 (red) and helix W/PufX components (green) only the transmembrane helices are shown. a. The monomeric RC-LH1-W core complex from Rhodopseudomonas palustris (Roszak et al., 2003). b. The dimeric RC-LH1-PufX core complex of Rhodobacter (Rba.) sphaeroides. The coordinates of the LH1 αβ pairs were adopted from Roszak et al. (2003), fitted into the tilted 3-D dimer structure from single particle analysis (Chapter 9, Bullough et al.), and adjusted according to the cryo-EM projection map in Qian et al. (2005). The transmembrane domain of PufX was taken from Tunnicliffe et al. (2006). See Chapter 9, p. 172.
Fig. 8. Organization of the photosynthetic unit (PSU) from the supramolecular architecture to individual chlorophylls and the energy transfer network. The high-light adapted vesicle model for Rba. sphaeroides (Şener et al., 2007) is shown. The three different constituent proteins and their BChls are colored as follows: LH2: green, LH1: red, RC: blue. From left to right three different rendering styles are featured. On the left, the light-harvesting proteins are shown in the tube representation (backbone only, no pigments); in the middle, the proteins are rendered transparently while the BChls are visible represented by their porphyrin rings; on the right, only the BChls are shown but this time together with their respective electronic couplings (Eq. 1). For simplicity only the strongest couplings are shown. The vesicle construction depicted here is based on atomic force microscopy data on intracytoplasmic membranes (Bahatyrova et al., 2004). Figure made with VMD (Humphrey et al., 1996). See Chapter 15, p. 288.
CP5
Color Plates
Fig. 9. Structure of the Cyt c2 : RC complex. A) Side view of the complex. The Cyt c2 is bound with heme positioned directly over the BChl2. A small region of close contact is indicated by the circle. A conformational change, indicated by the arrow, is due to crystal packing interactions with an adjacent bound Cyt. B) View of the structure in the region between the cofactors. The heme and BChl are separated by the planar aromatic ring of Tyr (L162). The closest distance between the conjugated rings in the cofactors is 14.2 Å as shown by the long arrow. A strong tunneling pathway between the two cofactors is indicated by the short arrows. C) Open book view of the interface between the complexes. The two proteins are separated by rotating around the center line. The central region of shortrange contacts (indicated by the circle) is surrounded by charged residues involved in long-range electrostatic interactions. Interacting residues are color coded. The contact between the heme (green) and the ‘hot spot’ Tyr L162 (green) is shown by the arrow. Hydrophobic residues Leu (M191), Val (M192) (black) on the RC interact with Phe (C102) on the Cyt (black). Hydrogen bonds (cyan) are formed between atoms on RC and Cyt. A cation-pi interaction is formed between Tyr (M295) and Arg (C32). Electrostatic interactions occur between negatively charged groups on the RC (red) and positively charged groups on the Cyt (violet). Other groups in van der Waals contact are shown in yellow. Modified from Axelrod et al. ( 2002). See Chapter 17, p. 326.
CP6
Color Plates
Fig. 10. The cytoplasmic surface of a model LM preparation of the Rba. sphaeroides RC. (a) The LM heterodimer is shown as a solid object, with the L- and M-polypeptides shown in yellow and white, respectively, and the quinones shown as spheres with green carbons and red oxygens. The view is along the symmetry axis, and parts of the QA quinone are visible from the outside of the complex. (b) View as in (a) but with amino acids overlaying the quinone sites shown in stick format, revealing the underlying quinones (carbons in yellow (L) or white (M), oxygens in red and nitrogens in blue). In both panels the dotted ovals show the approximate positions of the QA and QB quinones. See Chapter 16, p. 298.
Fig. 11. Region around the HB site in the wild-type and AM149W RC complexes from Rba. sphaeroides. The protein is shown as a solid object, with the L- and M-polypeptides shown in yellow and white, respectively, and bound waters shown in cyan. The BB and QB cofactors are shown as green and beige solid objects, respectively. In (a) the HB cofactor is shown as blue sticks and the phytol chain of PB as red sticks. In (b) the phytol chain of PB in the normal conformation is shown as red sticks and the phytol chain of PB in the alternate conformation is shown as orange sticks. See Chapter 16, p. 302.
CP7
Color Plates
Fig. 12. The reaction center (RC) complex from Rhodobacter sphaeroides comprises three subunits, a heterodimer of similar, but non-identical L (yellow) and M (blue) subunits, and subunit H (green), which caps LM on the cytosolic side of the membrane. The LM dimer binds all the cofactors, while subunit H stabilizes the structure and is involved in H+-ion uptake and transfer associated with electron transfer to the quinones. The L and M subunits and all associated cofactors are arranged around a quasi-2-fold rotational symmetry axis, normal to the plane of the membrane and passing through the primary donor (P), the special pair dimer of bacteriochlorophylls (BChl), and a ferrous (Fe2+) iron midway between the two quinones. Electron transfer proceeds from the excited singlet state of the primary donor (P*), via the A-branch of cofactors — monomer BChl (BA) and BPhe (HA), bound to the L subunit — to the primary quinone, QA, which is bound in a fold of the M subunit. From QA– the electron crosses the symmetry axis to the secondary quinone, QB, bound in a similar fold in the L subunit. (Figure prepared in VMD.) See Chapter 20, p. 381.
Fig. 13. The quinone binding sites — QA (top) and QB (bottom) — are related by the two-fold, rotational symmetry axis of the reaction center, which passes through the iron atom of the acceptor quinone complex. Both quinones are hydrogen bonded through the carbonyl oxygens — hydrogen bonds shown in purple for QA (top) and in green for QB (bottom). The binding sites are predominantly hydrophobic, with the notable exception of GluL212, AspL213 and SerL223 in the QB site, which constitute terminal components of the H+ delivery pathway to QB. Note that the orientations of the methoxy groups of QA and QB do not follow the two-fold rotational symmetry. (Figure prepared in VMD.) See Chapter 20, p. 385.
CP8
Color Plates
Fig. 14. The Ccm-system I components for c-type Cyt maturation. All components of the c-type Cyt maturation, except the thiol-disulfide oxidoreductase DsbA, are located in the cytoplasmic membrane. Both apoCyt c and heme follow different routes to the heme ligation core complex, composed of CcmI, CcmH and CcmF. Apocyt c is translocated via the Sec pathway; its cysteine thiols in the conserved CXXCH motif are first oxidized by the DsbA-DsbB pathway and then reduced by the Cyt c maturation specific CcdA-CcmG and/or CcmH thio-reductive pathway. CcmI is involved in delivering apoCyt c to the core heme ligation complex via its different domains. Heme is translocated across the membrane, possibly via ABC–type transporter CcmABCD and is covalently attached to the conserved His residue of the heme chaperone CcmE. CcmC is involved in attaching heme to CcmE and CcmD enhances holo-CcmE production. CcmA and CcmB promote release of holo-CcmE from CcmC and CcmD. Upon formation of the thioether bonds between the apoCyt c and the heme vinyls, catalyzed by the CcmH-CcmI-CcmF complex, mature holoCyt c is released. See Chapter 21, p. 410.
Fig. 15. The Ccs-system II components for c-type Cyt maturation. Similarly to system I, all components of the system II c-type Cyt maturation pathway are located in the cytoplasmic membrane, with the exception of DsbA. The apoCyt c is translocated across the membrane by the Sec machinery and is oxidized by DsbA, then reduced by CcsX. The transmembrane proteins CcsB and CcsA form a complex that represents the system II synthetase (heme ligation core complex). The reduced apoCyt c is likely bound by the periplasmic domain of CcsB. Heme is translocated by the CcsBA complex, probably through CcsA and binds to the CcsA periplasmic WWD domain before ligation to the reduced apoCyt c. Following covalent ligation of the heme vinyl groups to the reduced cysteines of the apoCyt c CXXCH motif, the holoCyt c folds into its mature form with release from the complex. See Chapter 21, p. 412.
CP9
Color Plates
Fig. 16. Overall structure of the Rhodobacter (Rba.) capsulatus Cyt bc1. Dimeric Cyt bc1 is depicted in the membrane, indicating the likely positions of the boundaries of the membrane lipid bilayer (A). The lower panels show a monomeric Cyt bc1 with the Fe/S protein ED in the b (B) or c1 (C) positions. The substrate Cyt c2 (1C2R.pdb) is modeled into its likely reactive position based on the yeast co-crystal structure (1KYO.pdb). The regions of the Cyt bc1 structure that differ significantly from the mitochondrial enzyme are colored in red, otherwise Cyt b is shown in different shades of blue, Cyt c1 in green, the Fe/S protein in yellow, and Cyt c2 in magenta. Hemes are shown in red, and the [2Fe2S] cluster is shown as a spacefilled structure in yellow and orange. The Qo site inhibitor stigmatellin locks the Fe/S protein ED in the b position. See Chapter 22, p. 427.
Fig. 17. Stereoview of structural details of Q sites in the Rba. capsulatus Cyt bc1. Panel A, helices α-a, A, D, and E making the Qi pocket are colored in light pink, light pink, wine, and green, respectively. Heme bH is shown in gray and quinone bound to the Qi site in yellow as ball-and-stick models. Panels B and C, the surface of Cyt b, showing interaction of the Fe/S protein ED with the ‘binding crater’ at the Qo site when the ED is in the ‘b’ (B) or ‘c1’ (C) positions. Cyt b is depicted using space-filling representation with different regions colored as described below. The white outline demarks the position of the Fe/S protein ED. Four regions surrounding the binding crater, the cd1-cd2 helices, ef-loop, gh loop and α-ef2 portion are indicated in green, magenta, yellow and cyan, respectively. At the bottom-center of the binding crater stigmatellin is shown in red. The side chains of the H135 and H156 residues of the Fe/S protein subunit are shown as ball-and-stick models. Atoms of Cyt b that are in contact (i. e., less than 3.9 Å) with the Fe/S protein ED are colored in gray, and Y302 (light green, with gray OH atom) in the α-ef helix and K329 (lime green with gray Ce and Nz atoms) between the α-ef 2 and F helices are indicated by arrows. See Chapter 22, p. 434.
CP10
Color Plates
Fig. 18. Similarities and differences in the electron transfer chains and core structures of the cyt bc1 and cyt b6 f complexes. The gross functional monomeric structures of the cyt b (blue), cyt c (red) and the ISP (yellow) coordinating portions of the cyt bc1- (left) or cyt b6 ftype (right) complexes are illustrated side-by-side as matching ribbon structures with the cofactors coordinated in each drawn as space filled spheres (colored as the individual subunits to which they belong). The glaring differences of the presence of an extra c-type heme (heme ci) adjacent to the Qi (or QN) site of the cyt b6 f, as well as the presence of the non-redox active chlorophyll molecule (dark green) in this same complex, are readily seen in these side-by-side illustrations. However, in each case, a similar high (red) and low potential (blue) chain of cofactors facilitating bifurcated electron flow following QH2 oxidation is easily envisioned. Both types of complex are shown with the inhibitor, stigmatellin (light green), bound at the Qo (or Qp) site as well as amino acids, pictured as stick models (blue), thought to be important for Qi (or QN) site substrate binding to aid in visually identifying the two spatially distinct Q binding sites. The illustrations have been worked up from the Rhodobacter (Rba.) capsulatus and Mastigocladus laminosus derived atomic coordinate files 1ZRT.pdb and 1VF5.pdb, respectively. See Chapter 23, p. 454.
CP11
Color Plates
Fig. 19. Side reactions that bypass the Q-cycle. Reactions shown are those that differ from the Q-cycle in the fate of the SQ generated at the Qo site. Details are given in the text. See Chapter 23, p. 461.
(a)
(b)
Fig. 20. (a) The hydride-transfer site in 2OO5.pdb. The dI(B) component is shown in blue and dIII in green. The nucleotides are in standard atom colors (except that the C4 atoms are in yellow and are linked by the pink dashed line). H-bonds are show as green dashed lines. (b) The loop E ‘lid’ of dIII and the ‘mobile loop’ of dI closed down over the hydride transfer site of 2OO5.pdb. The nucleotides (NADP+ in dIII, and the NADH analog, H2NADH, in dI) are shown in a space-filling format. The dI(B) polypeptide is shown in green (with its mobile loop in cyan), and the dI(A) polypeptide in yellow. The dIII polypeptide is shown in pink (with its loop E in magenta). Also shown are the RQD loop of dI and helix D/loop D of dIII (see text). See Chapter 25, p. 504.
CP12
Color Plates
Fig. 21. In response to a short flash of light photosynthetic reaction centers generate transmembrane voltage and release quinol (QH2); subsequent oxidation of QH2 by the cytochrome bc1 complex is coupled to proton pumping into the chromatophore lumen. The resultant ~ + drives protons through the ATP synthase and powers ATP synthesis. See Chapter 24 (inset from Fig 3A), page 483. ∆µ H
CP13
Color Plates (i) (a)
(ii)
(iii)
(b)
(c)
(i)
(ii)
Fig. 22. Localization of cytoplasmic chemosensory proteins and loss of localization and position in PpfA mutant. (a) Rba. sphaeroides with a soluble chemoreceptor TlpC-GFP fusion and McpG-GFP, expressed from genomic replacements. (b) Fluorescence images of cells of Rba. sphaeroides expressing both (i) CheW2-YFP and (ii) CheW4-CFP from genomic replacements showing separation of the two chemotaxis pathways; (iii) overlay image. (c)(i) Cephalexin treated Rba. sphaeroides with genomically expressed TlpT-CFP showing localization at single cell distances through the filament. (ii) Cephalexin treated Rba. sphaeroides ∆PpfA showing loss of localization of the chemosensory clusters. The scale bars are 2 µM. See Chapter 32, p. 650.
Fig. 23. BLUF photocycle and active site structure. Panel a: active site receptor state. Panel b: active site signaling state. Panel c: typical photocycle of BLUF-domains. Panels a and b were prepared using the program PyMOL (http://www.pymol.org). Color coding for panels a and b: Grey, Carbon; Blue, Nitrogen; Red, Oxygen; Orange, Phosphorus; Green, hydrogen bond.The structure coordinate file of the BLUF domain of AppA from Rba. sphaeroides (PDB ID: 1YRX) (Anderson et al., 2005) was used to create both panels. Note that for panel b the positions of the side-chain nitrogen and oxygen of Q63 were manually switched to indicate the Q-flip. See Chapter 41, p. 818.
CP14
Color Plates
Fig. 24. The X-ray structure of the chromophore binding domain (CBD) from Deinococcus (D.) radiodurans (Wagner et al., 2005). The PAS-2 (blue) and GAF (yellow) domains are aligned, relative to one another, by a trefoil knot formed from a loop of the GAF domain (yellow) and residues 1-35 (green) N-terminal to PAS-2. Biliverdin IXα (BV-purple) is covalently bound to Cys24 and is located in a pocket within the GAF domain formed from a β-sheet and two α-helices. See Chapter 40, p. 806.
Fig. 25. A small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) ab-initio envelope (transparent orange) of Bph4 from Rhodopseudomonas palustris (Evans et al., 2006). The structure is a homodimer and is modelled with the crystal structures of the CBD (green) (Wagner et al., 2005) and histidine kinase (HK, cyan) (Marina et al., 2005). The positions of the BV (purple), phosphorylating histidine (red) and ATP (orange) are shown. There is no high resolution structure of a PHY domain that can be fitted, but it is assumed to occupy the envelope between CBD and the HK domains. See Chapter 40, p. 807.
CP15
Color Plates
Fig. 26. Top:Helical net representation of shielding helices Si and binding helices Bj. The amino acids that were varied (Xk for Si and Zl for Bj) are emphasized in gray, the ligating histidine of the binding helices in green. The tables contain the amino acids of the individual helices at the varied positions. Long, solid arrows indicate the N→C direction of the peptide chains, dashed arrows the dipole moments of salt bridges. Bottom: photograph of a cellulose membrane carrying 38 modular proteins, after incubation with Ni-BPheide in buffer/ DMF and washing in buffer. Columns 2-7 correspond to identical binding helices Bj (j = 7 – 12), rows 1 - 6 to identical shielding helices Si (i = 1 - 6). The empty spots in columns 1 and 8 correspond to modular proteins that have been punched out for mass spectrometry; the two isolated spots in the rightmost column were not used for the analyses. See Chapter 45, p. 902.
Fig. 27. Stages of LH1 formation in the presence of carotenoids in vitro. See Chapter 46, page 934.
CP16
Chapter 1 An Overview of Purple Bacteria: Systematics, Physiology, and Habitats Michael T. Madigan* and Deborah O. Jung Department of Microbiology, Southern Illinois University, Carbondale, IL 62901, U.S.A.
Summary .................................................................................................................................................................. 2 I. Introduction......................................................................................................................................................... 2 II. Systematics of Purple Bacteria .......................................................................................................................... 3 A. Purple Sulfur Bacteria .......................................................................................................................... 4 B. Purple Nonsulfur Bacteria .................................................................................................................... 4 III. Physiology of Purple Bacteria ............................................................................................................................ 4 A. Purple Sulfur Bacteria .......................................................................................................................... 4 B. Purple Nonsulfur Bacteria .................................................................................................................... 6 1. Photoheterotrophy....................................................................................................................... 6 2. Dark Growth ................................................................................................................................ 7 3. Nitrogen Fixation ......................................................................................................................... 7 IV. Habitats of Purple Bacteria................................................................................................................................. 7 A. Purple Sulfur Bacteria .......................................................................................................................... 7 1. Blooms in Stratified Lakes........................................................................................................... 7 2. Microbial Mats ............................................................................................................................. 8 B. Purple Nonsulfur Bacteria .................................................................................................................... 9 1. Sewage ....................................................................................................................................... 9 2. Purple Nonsulfur Bacteria in Waste Lagoons ............................................................................. 9 V. Purple Bacteria in Extreme Environments.......................................................................................................... 9 A. Thermophilic Purple Bacteria ............................................................................................................. 10 1. Thermochromatium tepidum .................................................................................................... 10 2. Other Thermophilic Purple Bacteria .......................................................................................... 10 B. Halophilic and Alkaliphilic Purple Bacteria ......................................................................................... 10 C. Acidophilic Purple Bacteria ................................................................................................................ 11 D. Purple Bacteria from Permanently Cold Habitats............................................................................... 11 E. Environmental Limits to Photosynthesis in Purple Bacteria ............................................................... 12 VI. Final Remarks .................................................................................................................................................. 12 Acknowledgments ................................................................................................................................................... 12 References .............................................................................................................................................................. 12
*Author for correspondence, email: [email protected]
C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty (eds): The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria, pp. 1–15. © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V.
2
Michael T. Madigan and Deborah O. Jung
Summary Anoxygenic phototrophic purple bacteria are a major group of photosynthetic microorganisms widely distributed in nature, primarily in aquatic habitats. Nearly 50 genera of these organisms are known and some have become prime model systems for the experimental dissection of photosynthesis. Purple sulfur bacteria differ from purple nonsulfur bacteria on both metabolic and phylogenetic grounds, but species of the two major groups often coexist in illuminated anoxic habitats in nature. Purple sulfur bacteria are strong photoautotrophs and capable of limited photoheterotrophy, but they are poorly equipped for metabolism and growth in the dark. By contrast, purple nonsulfur bacteria, nature’s preeminent photoheterotrophs, are capable of photoautotrophy, and possess diverse capacities for dark metabolism and growth. Several purple bacteria inhabit extreme environments, including extremes of temperature, pH, and salinity. Collectively, purple bacteria are important phototrophs because they (1) consume a toxic substance, H2S, and contribute organic matter to anoxic environments by their autotrophic capacities; (2) consume organic compounds, primarily non-fermentable organic compounds, in their roles as photoheterotrophs; and (3) offer scientists in the photosynthesis community a smörgasbord of molecular diversity for the study of photosynthesis. I. Introduction Anoxygenic phototrophic purple bacteria are a major group of phototrophic microorganisms that inhabit aquatic and terrestrial environments. Purple bacteria that inhabit oxic habitats and which carry out photosynthesis only aerobically are called ‘aerobic anoxygenic phototrophs’ and are covered in Chapter 3 (Yurkov and Csotonyi). The current chapter covers only the classical purple bacteria: purple sulfur bacteria and purple nonsulfur bacteria. Purple bacteria are photosynthetic gram-negative prokaryotes that convert light energy into chemical energy by the process of anoxygenic photosynthesis. Purple bacteria contain photosynthetic pigments–bacteriochlorophylls and carotenoids — and can grow autotrophically with CO2 as sole carbon source. Many genera of purple bacteria are known and the organisms share many basic properties with their nonphototrophic relatives. Some general characteristics of purple bacteria are listed in Table 1. Purple bacteria share with oxygenic phototrophic prokaryotes — the cyanobacteria — the ability to conserve energy by photophosphorylation. However, unlike cyanobacteria and aerobic anoxygenic phototrophs, photosynthesis in purple bacteria only occurs under anoxic (O2-free) conditions. This is also true of the other classical anoxygenic phototrophs: green sulfur bacteria, green nonsulfur bacteria, and Abbreviations: BChl – bacteriochlorophyll; LH – light-harvesting; Rba. – Rhodobacter; Rcy. – Rhodocyclus; Rfx. – Rhodoferax; Rps. – Rhodopseudomonas; Rsp. – Rhodospirillum; Tch. – Thermochromatium
the heliobacteria (Blankenship et al., 1995). Purple bacteria require anoxic conditions for phototrophic growth because pigment synthesis in these organisms is repressed by molecular oxygen (Cohen-Bazire et al., 1957). Thus, the competitive success of purple bacteria in nature requires both light and anoxic conditions. This combination is most commonly found in lakes, ponds, estuaries, and other aquatic environments where H2S is present (Pfennig, 1967, 1978a, 1989). Once these general conditions are met, the exact physiochemical nature of the habitat (sulfide concentration, pH, light quality and intensity, temperature) controls the abundance and diversity of purple bacteria that develop there (Pfennig, 1978a, 1989; Madigan, 1988). Purple bacteria participate in the anoxic cycling of carbon both as primary producers (CO2 fixation, photoautotrophy) and as light-stimulated consumers of reduced organic compounds (photoheterotrophy). In certain habitats particularly favorable for their development, purple bacteria have been shown to be significant primary producers (Czeczuga, 1968; Takahashi and Ichimura, 1968; Overmann et al., 1994, 1996, 1999). However, in most illuminated sulfidic habitats the role of purple bacteria as H2S consumers is probably more important than any contribution they make to primary production; H2S is a highly poisonous substance for plants and animals and also for many bacteria. The oxidation of sulfide by purple bacteria yields nontoxic forms of sulfur, such as elemental sulfur (S0) and sulfate (SO42–). Sulfide oxidation thus allows the upper waters of a lake to remain oxic and suitable for plants, animals, and aerobic bacteria.
Chapter 1
Overview of Purple Bacteria
3
Table 1. General properties of anoxygenic purple phototrophic bacteriaa Property
Examples
Groups/phylogeny
Purple sulfur bacteria (gammaproteobacteria); purple nonsulfur bacteria (alphaor betaproteobacteria) Allochromatium vinosum and Thiocapsa roseopersicina (purple sulfur bacteria); Rhodobacter capsulatus, Rhodobacter sphaeroides, Rhodospirillum rubrum, and Rhodopseudomonas palustris (purple nonsulfur bacteria)
Major species studied
Pigments/color of dense cell suspensions
BChl a or b; major carotenoids include spirilloxanthin, spheroidene, lycopene, and rhodopsin, and their derivatives; cell suspensions purple, purple-red, purpleviolet, red, orange, brown, or yellow brown (BChl a-containing species); green or yellow (BChl b-containing species)
Location of pigments in cells
Within intracytoplasmic membranes arranged as membrane vesicles, tubes, bundled tubes, or in stacks resembling lamellae
Absorption maxima of living cells
BChl a-containing species: near 800 nm, and anywhere from 815–960 nm; BChl b-containing species: 835–850 nm and 1010–1040 nm
Electron donors/sulfur globulesb
H2S, S0, S2O32–, H2, Fe2+; if S0 is produced from the oxidation of sulfide, the S0 is stored intracellularly only in certain purple sulfur bacteria (see Fig. 1a)
Photoheterotrophy/dark respiratory growth
Purple sulfur bacteria limited on both accounts; purple nonsulfur bacteria typically diverse on both accounts
a
All purple bacteria are gram-negative prokaryotes. All species contain peptidoglycan and an outer membrane containing lipopolysaccharide. bVirtually all purple bacteria are capable of autotrophic growth. When growing autotrophically, the Calvin cycle (reductive pentose phosphate cycle) is used as the mechanism for CO2 fixation
II. Systematics of Purple Bacteria Purple sulfur bacteria and purple nonsulfur bacteria were originally distinguished on physiological grounds based on their tolerance and utilization of sulfide. Purple sulfur bacteria were species that tolerated millimolar levels of sulfide and oxidized sulfide to sulfur globules stored intracellularly (Fig. 1a), while purple nonsulfur bacteria were species that did neither (van Niel, 1932, 1944). However, classic chemostat experiments by Hansen and van Gemerden (1972) showed that these criteria for classifying purple bacteria were not absolute. At low levels of sulfide, typically less than 0.5 mM, most species of purple nonsulfur bacteria will grow and in so doing, oxidize sulfide to S0, S4O62–, or SO42–. Nevertheless, an important distinction in the sulfide metabolism of purple sulfur and purple nonsulfur bacteria remains: any S0 formed by purple nonsulfur bacteria is not stored intracellularly, but instead is deposited outside the cell (Hansen and van Gemerden, 1972; Brune, 1995) (species of Ectothiorhodospiraceae are an exception here). Thus, when grown on sulfide, it is easy to differentiate a purple sulfur from a purple nonsulfur bacterium because of the microscopically obvious globules of S0 formed (Fig. 1a). Subsequent isolations of purple nonsulfur bacteria from highly sulfidic habitats have shown that
Fig. 1. Phase photomicrographs of phototrophic purple bacteria. (a) Cells of a strain of the purple sulfur bacterium Thermochromatium tepidum isolated from a New Mexico (USA) hot spring. Note the bright refractile intracellular sulfur globules (arrows). (b) Cells of Rhodobaca bogoriensis, an alkaliphilic purple nonsulfur bacterium isolated from Lake Bogoria (Kenya). If purple nonsulfur bacteria oxidize sulfide, any S0 they produce remains outside the cell. Cells of Tch. tepidum are about 1.5 µm wide and cells of Rbc. bogoriensis are about 0.8 µm wide.
many species of this group are actually quite sulfide tolerant. For example, both the marine species Rhodobacter (originally Rhodopseudomonas, Rps.) sulfidophilus and the cold-active species Rhodoferax antarcticus (isolated from the sulfidic bottom waters
4 of the permanently frozen freshwater Lake Fryxell, McMurdo Dry Valleys) can tolerate over 4 mM sulfide (Hansen and Veldkamp, 1973; Jung et al., 2004). This concentration of sulfide is toxic to many purple sulfur bacteria (Pfennig, 1967, 1978a, 1989)! The original classification of purple bacteria on the basis of sulfide metabolism has been supported by molecular criteria. Phylogenetic analyses of purple bacteria based on comparative 16S rRNA sequencing have shown that purple sulfur bacteria are species of gammaproteobacteria while purple nonsulfur bacteria are either alpha- or betaproteobacteria (Imhoff et al., 2005) (Tables 1 and 2).
Michael T. Madigan and Deborah O. Jung phic species (Imhoff et al., 2005). If one considers the fact that the pigments and photocomplexes in the different species of purple nonsulfur bacteria are very similar, this suggests that the acquisition of phototrophic capacity in purple nonsulfur bacteria has occurred by lateral gene transfer. Sequence analyses of photocomplex proteins have confirmed this (Nagashima et al., 1997). Table 2 also lists the three letter genus name abbreviations for both purple sulfur and nonsulfur bacteria; these abbreviations will be used throughout this book. III. Physiology of Purple Bacteria
A. Purple Sulfur Bacteria Over 25 genera of purple sulfur bacteria are now recognized, consisting of a variety of morphological types (Table 2). Purple sulfur bacteria include both species that store S0 inside the cell (family Chromatiaceae, see Fig. 1a), and those that produce extracellular S0 (Ectothiorhodospiraceae) (Table 1). [It should be noted that research on the mechanism of sulfide oxidation by Allochromatium vinosum has shown that the ‘intracellular sulfur’ produced by this organism actually accumulates in the periplasm rather than in the cytoplasm (Pattaragulwanit et al., 1998); this is likely true for all species of Chromatiaceae as well]. Most laboratory studies of purple sulfur bacteria have focused on Allochromatium and Thiocapsa species (Table 1) since these are the most easily grown. Many species of purple sulfur bacteria are ‘extremophilic’ species, including in particular, species that grow best at high salt and/or pH (Table 2). B. Purple Nonsulfur Bacteria Twenty genera of purple nonsulfur bacteria are now recognized (Table 2). Species of Rhodobacter and Rhodopseudomonas have been the workhorses for laboratory studies of anoxygenic photosynthesis (Table 1). But many other interesting species, some of which have one or more unusual metabolic features, are also known. For example, extremophilic species inhabiting hot, cold, salty, alkaline (Fig. 1b), and acidic environments have been isolated and will be discussed in a later section of this chapter (see section V). As shown in Table 2, all purple nonsulfur bacteria are proteobacteria, and phylogenetic trees show the various species to be closely related to nonphototro-
Purple bacteria are relatively easy to grow in laboratory culture; in most cases all that is needed is an anoxic mineral medium supplemented with either sulfide plus bicarbonate (photoautotrophic growth) or an organic compound (photoheterotrophic growth). Because of this, and because anoxygenic photosynthesis is a simpler form of photosynthesis than the oxygenic process, purple bacteria have emerged as ideal model systems for dissecting the physiology, biochemistry and molecular biology of photosynthesis. Moreover, anoxygenic photosynthesis preceded oxygenic photosynthesis on Earth by billions of years. Thus, studies of purple and other anoxygenic phototrophs have contributed in major ways to our understanding of the evolution of photosynthesis (Raymond et al., 2003; Chapter 2, Swingley et al.). A. Purple Sulfur Bacteria The physiology of purple sulfur bacteria is intimately linked to sulfide, and large populations of purple sulfur bacteria are observed in nature only in illuminated environments where sulfide is present (Pfennig, 1967, 1978a, 1989). This implies that the growth of purple sulfur bacteria in nature is primarily phototrophic. If growth is photoautotrophic, sulfide, thiosulfate or H2 are used as photosynthetic electron donors (Trüper and Fischer, 1982; Madigan, 1988; Brune, 1995). A few species can also use ferrous (Fe2+) iron as an electron donor, oxidizing it to ferric (Fe3+) iron (Ehrenreich and Widdel, 1994), and at least one species, a strain of Thiocapsa, can use nitrite (NO2–) as photosynthetic electron donor, oxidizing it to nitrate (NO3–. In addition to autotrophic growth, a few organic carbon sources are photoassimilated by purple sulfur
Chapter 1
Overview of Purple Bacteria
5
Table 2. Genera of anoxygenic phototrophic purple bacteria Taxonomy/Phylogeny Purple Nonsulfur Bacteria Alphaproteobacteria
Betaproteobacteria
Purple Sulfur Bacteria Gammaproteobacteria Family Chromatiaceae b
Family Ectothiorhodospiraceae b
Genus
Genus abbreviation a
Morphology
Rhodobaca c Rhodobacter Rhodovulum Rhodopseudomonas c Rhodoblastusc Blastochloris Rhodomicrobium Rhodobium Rhodoplanes Rhodocistac Rhodospirillum Phaeospirillum Rhodopila c Rhodospira Rhodovibrio c Rhodothallasium c Roseospira Roseospirillum Rhodocyclus Rhodoferaxc Rubrivivax
Rca. Rba. Rdv. Rps. Rbl. Blc. Rmi. Rbi. Rpl. Rcs. Rsp. Phs. Rpi. Rsa. Rhv. Rts. Ros. Rss. Rcy. Rfx. Rvi.
Cocci to short rods Rods Rods-Cocci Budding rods Budding rods Budding rods Budding rods Rods Rods Spirilla Spirilla Spirilla Cocci Spirilla Vibrio Spirilla Spirilla Spirilla Curled vibrios Rods, vibrios Rods, curved rods
Allochromatium Amoebobacter Chromatium Halochromatium c Isochromatium Lamprobacter Lamprocystis Marichromatium Rhabdochromatium Thermochromatium c Thioalkalicoccus c Thiobaca Thiocapsa Thiococcus Thiocystis Thiodictyon Thioflavicoccus Thiohalocapsac Thiolamprovum Thiopedia Thiorhodococcus Thiorhodovibrio Thiospirillum
Alc. Amb. Chr. Hch. Isc. Lpb. Lpc. Mch. Rbc. Tch. Tac. Tba. Tca. Tco. Tcs. Tdc. Tfc. Thc. Tlp. Tpd. Trc. Trv. Tsp.
Rods Cocci in plates or clumps Rods Rods Rods Rods Cocci in clusters Rods Rods Rods Cocci Rods Cocci Cocci Cocci to short rods Rods forming aggregates Cocci Cocci Cocci Cocci, often in plates Cocci Vibrios to spirilla Spirilla
Ectothiorhodospira c Ect. Vibrios to spirilla Hlr. Vibrios to spirilla Halorhodospira c Trs. Vibrios to spirilla Thiorhodospira c Ectothiorhodosinus Ets. Rods a Abbreviations in accordance with Imhoff and Madigan (2004). bSpecies of Chromatiaceae store sulfur from the oxidation of sulfide intracellularly (see Fig. 1A); species of Ectothiorhodospiraceae do not. c Contain one or more extremophilic species growing at an extreme of temperature, pH, or salinity greater than marine salinity
6 bacteria. Organic acids and fatty acids are the preferred substrates, but short-chain alcohols and even carbohydrates are used by certain species (Sojka, 1978). Photoheterotrophic growth of Allochromatium vinosum and other Allochromatium species that are capable of assimilatory sulfate reduction does not require sulfide. However, some purple sulfur bacteria will not grow without sulfide and are also nutritionally quite restricted. These include the large-celled Chromatium species such as Chromatium okenii and Chromatium weissei, and Thiospirillum (Trüper, 1978), as well as the thermophilic species Thermochromatium (Tch.) tepidum (Madigan, 1986) (Fig. 1a). Sulfide is required for growth of these species and the only organic compounds that are photoassimilated are acetate and pyruvate (Trüper 1981; Madigan, 1986). Dark growth of some purple sulfur bacteria is possible. For example, certain Chromatiaceae, including species of Allochromatium, Thiocystis, Amoebobacter, and Thiocapsa, can grow in darkness as either chemoorganotrophs or chemolithotrophs when the oxygen concentration is significantly reduced [microaerobic growth; Kämpf and Pfennig, 1980]. Thiocapsa roseopersicina and Thiocystis violacea are the most oxygen tolerant purple sulfur bacteria (Kondratieva et al., 1976; Kämpf and Pfennig, 1980); however, respiratory growth of these species is very slow compared with phototrophic growth. If one considers that dark growth of purple sulfur bacteria in nature puts them in direct competition with nonphototrophic bacteria as well as with purple nonsulfur bacteria, the ecological significance of dark metabolism by purple sulfur bacteria is probably minor. It is more likely that dark energy metabolism by purple sulfur bacteria helps these organisms survive intermittently oxygenated environments or is used as a means to generate ATP at night, rather than being a major means of supporting extended growth in nature (van Gemerden, 1968). B. Purple Nonsulfur Bacteria Purple nonsulfur bacteria are a physiologically versatile group of purple bacteria that can grow well both phototrophically and in darkness. Growth of some purple nonsulfur bacteria, for example, Rhodobacter (Rba.) capsulatus, is possible under phototrophic conditions with either CO2 or organic carbon, or in darkness by respiration, fermentation, or chemolithotrophy. This makes Rba. capsulatus probably the
Michael T. Madigan and Deborah O. Jung most metabolically versatile of all known bacteria (Madigan and Gest, 1979). Carbon metabolism in purple nonsulfur bacteria has been summarized in the excellent reviews by Tabita (1995) and by Gibson and Harwood (1995); see also Chapter 28, Romagnoli andTabita; and Chapter 29, Harwood. 1. Photoheterotrophy Under phototrophic (anoxic/light) conditions, typical purple nonsulfur bacteria can grow photoautotrophically with H2 or low levels of sulfide as electron donors; a few species can use S2O32– or Fe2+ as photosynthetic electron donors (Ehrenreich and Widdel, 1994; Brune, 1995). However, most purple nonsulfur bacteria grow best as photoheterotrophs in media containing a readily useable organic compound, such as malate or pyruvate, and ammonia as nitrogen source (Sojka, 1978). Yeast extract is a common addition to media formulated for purple nonsulfur bacteria (Biebl and Pfennig, 1981). Yeast extract is a source of B-vitamins, one or more of which are required by the majority of recognized species of purple nonsulfur bacteria. Requirements for thiamine, nicotinic acid, biotin, and p-aminobenzoic acid are the most common. Requirements for B-complex vitamins have never been observed in purple sulfur bacteria, although many species require vitamin B12, a growth factor required by only a handful of purple nonsulfur bacteria (Pfennig, 1978b; Siefert and Koppenhagen, 1982). However, beyond its role as a source of vitamins, yeast extract also stimulates the growth of purple nonsulfur bacteria because of its assortment of organic compounds that can fuel photoheterotrophic growth. Several individual organic compounds support photoheterotrophic growth of purple nonsulfur bacteria. Organic acids, amino acids, fatty acids, alcohols, carbohydrates, and even C-1 compounds are metabolized by different species (Sojka, 1978; Trüper and Pfennig, 1981). With minor exceptions, the citric acid cycle intermediates malate, succinate, and fumarate are universally used, as are pyruvate and acetate; many species also use ethanol, lactate, and propionate (Sojka, 1978; Trüper and Pfennig, 1981). A few purple nonsulfur bacteria photoassimilate aromatic compounds such as benzoate, hydroxy derivatives of benzoate, and cyclohexane carboxylate (Gibson and Harwood, 1995). Enrichment cultures employing benzoate as carbon source typically yield strains of Phaeospirillum (formerly Rhodospirillum)
Chapter 1
Overview of Purple Bacteria
fulvum or Rps. palustris (Gibson and Harwood, 1995). Benzene is not utilized by these or other purple nonsulfur bacteria, but at least one aromatic hydrocarbon, toluene, supports photoheterotrophic growth of certain strains of Blastochloris sulfoviridis (Zengler et al., 1999). Growth of purple nonsulfur bacteria on aliphatic hydrocarbons has not been described. 2. Dark Growth Many of the same organic compounds that are photoassimilated by purple nonsulfur bacteria can also be used as electron donors and carbon sources for dark respiratory growth. Oxygen tolerances for respiratory growth vary among species, but some, such as Rhodobacter species, can be grown with vigorous aeration (Madigan, 1988). Certain purple nonsulfur bacteria can grow under anoxic dark conditions by either fermentation or anaerobic respiration. For example, pyruvate (Uffen and Wolfe, 1970; Gurgen et al., 1976) and certain sugars (Madigan and Gest, 1978; Schultz and Weaver, 1982) support fermentative growth of some purple nonsulfur bacteria, most notably Rhodospirillum (Rsp.) rubrum and Rba. capsulatus. Extensive fermentative growth of Rba. capsulatus requires addition of an accessory oxidant such as dimethyl sulfoxide or trimethylamine-N-oxide (Madigan and Gest, 1978; Schultz and Weaver, 1982). Rba. sphaeroides is capable of true denitrification, reducing NO3– to N2 using nonfermentable carbon sources as electron donors (Satoh et al., 1976). Dark chemolithotrophic growth of certain species of purple nonsulfur bacteria is possible using H2 or S2O32– as electron donors. In Rba. capsulatus, chemolithotrophic growth on H2 occurs and the organism can be grown in a synthetic medium supplied with the gases H2, O2, and CO2 as electron donor, electron acceptor, and carbon source, respectively (Madigan and Gest, 1979). Whether chemolithotrophy is a significant growth strategy for purple bacteria in nature is unknown, but it is likely that the ability to conserve energy from the oxidation of inorganic electron donors gives purple bacteria an added physiological dimension in competition with nonphototrophic bacteria. 3. Nitrogen Fixation With only a couple of known exceptions, purple nonsulfur bacteria can fix nitrogen (N2 + 8H → 2NH3 + H2) (Madigan, 1995). The Rhodobacter species Rba.
7 capsulatus and Rba. sphaeroides grow most rapidly with N2 as sole nitrogen source and show the highest rates of in vivo nitrogenase activity (Madigan et al., 1984). Consequently, Rhodobacter species tend to dominate enrichment cultures for purple nonsulfur bacteria that employ nitrogen fixation as a selective condition. Because in general purple nonsulfur bacteria are excellent nitrogen-fixing bacteria (Madigan et al., 1984), it is likely that the capacity for diazotrophy confers a significant competitive advantage on them in anoxic environments that are limited in fixed nitrogen. IV. Habitats of Purple Bacteria A. Purple Sulfur Bacteria A detailed description of the major habitats of purple bacteria including a wealth of specific examples can be found in the reviews of Madigan (1988), Pfennig (1967, 1978a, 1989), and van Gemerden and Mas (1995). Large masses (blooms) of purple sulfur bacteria often develop in sulfidic aquatic ecosystems exposed to light. Although blooms of phototrophic sulfur bacteria may occur in shallow lagoons polluted by sewage (which triggers the activities of sulfate-reducing bacteria), densely stratified ‘plates’ of purple bacteria form only in the deep waters of lakes protected from excessive wind mixing and which contain sufficient sulfate to support sulfate reduction in the sediments. 1. Blooms in Stratified Lakes Intense microbial activity occurs in the sediments of productive stratified lakes. Organic material reaching the bottom waters is catabolized by fermentation, which releases a variety of reduced organic products, including lactate, ethanol, and fatty acids. In freshwater lakes containing low levels of sulfate, these fermentation products can be photoassimilated by purple nonsulfur bacteria or converted to methane by the cooperative interactions of syntrophic bacteria and methanogenic Archaea. Alternatively, if electron acceptors such as Fe3+ or NO3– are available, the fermentation products will fuel anaerobic respirations supported by these electron acceptors before extensive occurs. If sulfate is present, sulfate-reducing bacteria
8 will be active in the sediments forming sulfide; the sulfide diffuses upwards from the sediments into the water column forming a gradient. Sulfide triggers the growth of purple sulfur bacteria, which develop in specific zones of the water column where light and sulfide are optimal (Pfennig, 1967, 1975, 1978a). If cell numbers are sufficiently high, the lake water itself will become pigmented red, purple, or reddishbrown (Pfennig 1978a, 1989; Overmann et al., 1994, 1996, 1999). When this occurs, it is often possible to identify the major genera of purple bacteria present by simple microscopic examination. In many stratified lakes the bloom of purple bacteria consists of a mixture of species (Caldwell and Tiedje, 1975a,b), while in others, the bloom may contain only a single species (Overmann et al., 1994, 1996, 1999). A nice example of the layering of phototrophic purple bacteria in stratified lakes can be found in the work of Caldwell and Tiedje (1975a,b). These workers examined water samples collected at 1 m intervals from two eutrophic lakes — Wintergreen and Burke — located in southwest Michigan (USA). In these studies, done before the days of molecular microbial ecology, the purple sulfur bacteria could be adequately identified by their characteristic morphologies. Both lakes contained species of Thiopedia, Thiospirillum, Thiocystis, and Chromatium. However, in Burke Lake the Thiospirillum population dominated while in Wintergreen Lake, the Thiopedia population dominated. Although physiochemical profiles of the two lakes were not performed, the dominant population in each case was likely selected by the major characteristics — light, sulfide, pH, dissolved organic carbon, and the like — that defined each lake (Caldwell and Tiedje, 1975a,b). Both Burke and Wintergreen lakes also contained green sulfur bacteria in the waters beneath the purple sulfur bacteria. The green bacterial population contained phototrophic consortia (Overmann and Schubert, 2002) such as ‘Chlorochromatium’ (Caldwell and Tiedje, 1975a,b). Green bacteria can outcompete purple bacteria at low light intensities because they possess large antenna pigment structures called chlorosomes (Kimble and Madigan, 2002; Frigaard and Bryant, 2004). Green bacteria also use different regions of the spectrum than do purple bacteria and are typically much more sulfide tolerant. Thus, green bacteria can exist beneath a layer of purple bacteria in a water column, and this pattern is common in stratified lakes (Pfennig, 1967, 1975, 1978a, 1989).
Michael T. Madigan and Deborah O. Jung In hypersulfidic shallow lakes, such as those in the karstic Banyoles area of northern Spain, millimolar levels of sulfide are present and phototrophic sulfur bacteria bloom throughout the water column. In Lake Cisó, the best studied of these lakes, the entire water column is anoxic, and the lake turns bright red during an active bloom (Guerrero et al., 1985). Both green and purple sulfur bacteria are present in Lake Cisó but the lake is dominated by a Chromatium (probably Allochromatium) species during periods of the most extensive bloom. 2. Microbial Mats Purple sulfur bacteria are also common in microbial mats, including mats that form in marine or hypersaline environments (van Gemerden and Mas, 1995) and in the effluents of thermal springs (Castenholz and Pierson, 1995). Microbial mats are laminated organo-sedimentary structures composed primarily of filamentous cyanobacteria and anoxygenic phototrophs, such as Chloroflexus, but often contain purple bacteria as well. As new growth occurs from the top of the mat, the lower mat layers decompose and sulfate-reduction typically occurs. This supplies the sulfide necessary to trigger growth of purple bacteria, usually purple sulfur bacteria. Mat thickness can vary considerably. In siliceous alkaline hot spring microbial mats, mats can be 4–5 cm thick. Mats containing only purple bacteria, such as those of Tch. tepidum that form in the Mammoth hot springs of Yellowstone are much thinner, up to 0.5 cm in thickness (Ward et al., 1989). Thiocapsa and Allochromatium species are common inhabitants of marine microbial mats. These purple sulfur bacteria often form a dense pigmented layer between the cyanobacteria and the lower layers of the mat. In this niche purple bacteria oxidize sulfide that diffuses upwards from below before it reaches the cyanobacterial layers (van Gemerden and Mas, 1995). Thiocapsa roseopersicina, in particular, is very common in marine mats, probably because of its metabolic versatility. Besides its photoautotrophic and photoheterotrophic capacities, this purple sulfur bacterium can grow in darkness by heterotrophic and chemolithotrophic means (Kondratieva et al., 1976). This versatility allows Thiocapsa roseopersicina to take full advantage of the variable growth conditions that characterize different layers of microbial mats (van Gemerden and Mas, 1995).
Chapter 1
Overview of Purple Bacteria
B. Purple Nonsulfur Bacteria Purple nonsulfur bacteria occasionally form dense blooms in habitats where levels of sulfide are either low or undetectable. Purple nonsulfur bacteria are usually present in only low numbers in blooms of purple sulfur bacteria, probably because of their sulfide sensitivity. Instead of photoautotrophy, purple nonsulfur bacteria specialize in photoheterotrophy. Although this puts them in competition with heterotrophs for organic compounds, photoheterotrophic capacity likely confers a significant selective advantage on purple nonsulfur bacteria. This is because unlike heterotrophs, phototrophs do not need to conserve energy from the carbon sources they photoassimilate; carbon goes almost quantitatively into cell material. However, no known purple nonsulfur bacteria can hydrolyze major polymeric substances such as cellulose or starch, and so ultimately, the phototrophs depend on the heterotrophs to generate the lowmolecular-weight compounds they photoassimilate (Pfennig, 1978a). 1. Sewage Purple nonsulfur bacteria are present in sewage (Holm and Vennes 1970; Siefert et al., 1978). In a detailed study by Siefert et al. (1978), it was shown that the mean number of purple nonsulfur bacteria in a sewage plant in Göttingen, Germany was highest in the activated sludge stage of the treatment process; counts fluctuated between 105 and 106 cells ml–1 but were never greater than 106 cells ml–1 (as measured using plate counting techniques). Purple sulfur bacteria, on the other hand, were quantitatively insignificant in sewage and were detectable by culture only from activated sludge (~103 cells ml–1). A variety of purple nonsulfur bacteria were identified in the sewage plant, including Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus, Rps. palustris and Rps. (now Blastochloris) viridis, Rhodocyclus (now Rubrivivax) gelatinosus and Rhodocyclus (Rcy.) tenuis and Rsp. photometricum. Rba. sphaeroides, Rubrivivax gelatinosus, Rps. palustris, and Rba. capsulatus made up the bulk of the purple bacteria present. Despite these relatively high numbers, it was concluded that purple nonsulfur bacteria probably played only a minor role in organic matter transformations in sewage compared with heterotrophic bacteria, which were present at 108 to 109 cells ml–1. Purple nonsulfur bacteria were also detectable in the strictly anaerobic (and dark)
9 sewage sludge digestor, but these likely represented only transient cells traveling through the system (Siefert et al., 1978). 2. Purple Nonsulfur Bacteria in Waste Lagoons Waste lagoons offer excellent conditions for growth of purple nonsulfur bacteria (Jones, 1956; Cooper et al., 1975; Kobayashi, 1975). For example, a pigmented bloom of purple nonsulfur bacteria was reported from the waste lagoon of a vegetable canning plant in Minnesota (USA); prolific growth leading to intensely red-colored lagoons occurred and the bloom was associated with a significant reduction in odor (Cooper et al., 1975). Rba. sphaeroides, Rba. capsulatus, and Rps. palustris were the key species in this bloom, and it is likely that their consumption of volatile fatty acids produced by fermentation led to the odor reduction observed. The morphologically and phylogenetically unique purple nonsulfur bacterium Rcy. purpureus, isolated by Norbert Pfennig over 30 years ago, was the dominant phototroph in a swine waste lagoon in Iowa (USA) (Pfennig, 1978b). This organism, of which only a single strain has ever been isolated, probably thrived on the combination of organic constituents present in the waste materials. However, it is of interest that Rcy. purpureus, one of the only purple nonsulfur bacteria to lack a nitrogenase system (Madigan et al., 1984; Madigan, 1995), was the dominant purple bacterium in this particular habitat and that it has never been reported from elsewhere. One would expect a swine waste lagoon to be high in amines and thus that nitrogen fixation would be unnecessary. It is thus possible that Rcy. purpureus is somehow selected for in otherwise suitable habitats for purple nonsulfur bacteria that are very high in ammonia and volatile amines. Since Rcy. purpureus is easily cultured, an enrichment study of its distribution in nature using media containing elevated levels of ammonia and amines could yield insight on its ecology. V. Purple Bacteria in Extreme Environments Purple bacteria have been isolated from extreme environments, including hot, cold, acidic, alkaline, and hypersaline (Madigan, 2003). Unfortunately, with a few exceptions, these inherently interesting ‘ex-
10 tremophilic’ purple bacteria have been little utilized in the study of photosynthesis thus far. However, the success of these unusual purple bacteria in their harsh habitats implies that they have evolved important solutions to photosynthesis under stress conditions. We can therefore learn much from studying them. For example, molecular adaptations linked to photosynthesis under extreme conditions should be relatively easy to identify in extremophilic purple bacteria by applying a bioinformatics/structural biology approach to their genomes. A. Thermophilic Purple Bacteria The first extremophilic purple bacteria were discovered in the 1960s and were either halophiles or acidophiles, including extremely halophilic species of the genus Ectothiorhodospira. Into the late 1970s, several new halophilic and haloalkaliphilic purple bacteria were discovered. In the 1980s, the first thermophilic purple bacterium was isolated, Tch. tepidum. Since then, a large diversity of alkaliphilic and halophilic purple bacteria has been isolated. Psychrophilic phototrophs have been described only very recently, with two representatives currently in culture. 1. Thermochromatium tepidum Purple bacteria were first identified in Yellowstone microbial mats over 30 years ago (Castenholz, 1977). But it was not until the 1980s that the purple sulfur bacterium Thermochromatium (originally Chromatium) tepidum was isolated in pure culture (Madigan, 1984, 1986). Tch. tepidum (Fig. 1a) is thermophilic (optimumtemperature ~50 ºC, maximum temperature 57 ºC) and produces a novel light-harvesting (LH) 1 photopigment complex that absorbs maximally near 920 nm (Garcia et al., 1986; Nozawa et al., 1986). The Tch. tepidum LH1 (core) antenna complex has been studied in connection with the mechanism of energy transfer to the reaction center. A biophysical conundrum exists with this photocomplex in that its absorption maximum is 50 nm to the red of that of the reaction center. Nevertheless, because there is a small overlap between spectra of the two components, efficient energy transfer occurs from the Tch. tepidum LH1 complex to the reaction center (Kramer and Amesz, 1996). Examples of long-wavelength-absorbing core antenna complexes even more spectacular than that of Tch. tepidum have been discovered, indicating that in purple bacteria, LH1 complexes
Michael T. Madigan and Deborah O. Jung that absorb very far to the red (963 nm) can still transfer energy to the reaction center (Permentier et al., 2001). The photosynthetic reaction center of Tch. tepidum is similar in most respects to that of other purple bacteria, except for its increased thermal stability (Nozawa and Madigan, 1991). To probe the mechanism behind this, the Tch. tepidum reaction center was crystallized. From this work, key substitutions were identified in the L and M subunits of the Tch. tepidum reaction center that are likely responsible for the thermostability of this photocomplex (Nogi et al., 2000). In addition to thermal stable photocomplexes, a thermophilic ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase (a key enzyme of the Calvin cycle) of the green plant type was characterized from Tch. tepidum and shown to be stable to at least 60 ºC (Heda and Madigan, 1988. 1989). 2. Other Thermophilic Purple Bacteria Other mildly thermophilic purple bacteria (optimum growth temperature ~40 ºC) have been cultured from hot spring microbial mats. These include the BChl b-containing species Rhodopseudomonas sp. strain GI, isolated from a New Mexico hot spring (Resnick and Madigan, 1989), and Rps. cryptolactis (Statwald-Demchick et al., 1990) and Rsp. centenum (Rhodocista centenaria) (Favinger et al., 1989), both isolated from a Thermopolis (Wyoming, USA) hot spring. Rhodocista centenaria in particular has been useful as a model organism for biochemical/genetic research on phototaxis and related issues of motility (see, for example McClain et al., 2002), and its genome has recently been sequenced (C. E. Bauer, personal communication). B. Halophilic and Alkaliphilic Purple Bacteria Several extremophilic purple bacteria are halophilic or haloalkaliphilic (Imhoff et al., 1978, 1979). These include purple sulfur bacteria such as Ectothiorhodospira, Halorhodospira, Halochromatium, Marichromatium, and Thiohalocapsa, and purple nonsulfur bacteria such as Rhodovibrio, Rhodothalassium, Rhodobium, Rhodovulum, and Roseospira. Collectively, these purple bacteria have salt optima that range from seawater salinities to over 20% NaCl (Imhoff, 2001). Interestingly, the Dead Sea purple nonsulfur bacterium Rhodovibrio sodomensis shows a distinct intermediate level salt requirement (optimum
Chapter 1
Overview of Purple Bacteria
at 8–11% NaCl) (Mack et al., 1993), which is very near that of its habitat. Some purple sulfur bacteria can grow in saturated salt solutions, making them the most halophilic of all known phototrophic bacteria (Imhoff, 2001). In the 1990s several new purple bacteria were isolated from low salinity soda lakes. Most of these differed dramatically from known halophilic or haloalkaliphilic species in that they required little if any NaCl for growth. These isolates are, however, strongly alkaliphilic (pH optima near 9) and phylogenetically distinct. These include purple nonsulfur bacteria such as Rhodobaca (Milford et al., 2000), and purple sulfur bacteria such as Thioalkalicoccus (Bryantseva et al., 2000), and Thiorhodospira (Bryantseva et al., 1999). Rhodobaca (Fig. 1b) is of particular interest because it lacks a peripheral (LH2) antenna complex, a rarity among purple nonsulfur bacteria (Glaeser and Overmann, 1999), and it produces several unusual carotenoids that render phototrophic cultures yellow in color (Takaichi et al., 2001). Rhodobaca shows various metabolic peculiarities as well, including an inability to fix N2 and to grow photoautotrophically (Milford et al., 2000); both of these properties are hallmarks of purple nonsulfur bacteria (Madigan, 1988). C. Acidophilic Purple Bacteria The list of acid-loving anoxygenic phototrophs is short, as only two genera (three species) are known. Rhodoblastus acidophilus (formerly Rhodopseudomonas acidophila) is common in mildly acidic environments, such as bogs, marshes, and acidic lakes. In the original description of this organism, several strains were described, some containing orange/brown carotenoids and others purple/red carotenoids. The strains are otherwise similar, and all show a lower limit for growth near pH 4 (Pfennig, 1969). A very similar organism is the species Rhodoblastus sphagnolica (Kulichevskaya et al., 2006). Rhodopila globiformis was isolated from acidic warm sulfide springs (pH 3.5–4) that flow out along the Gibbon River in Yellowstone National Park (Pfennig, 1974). Rhodpila globiformis-like organisms have also been obtained from springs that feed into Nymph Lake, a warm, acidic and sulfidic lake adjacent to the Gibbon River; the pH of the Nymph Lake springs is 3 (Madigan, 2003). Rhodopila globiformis has a low pH optimum for growth similar to that of Rhodoblastus species, but, if carefully tested, would likely be more
11 acid tolerant than Rhodoblastus species because of the more strongly acidic nature of its habitat. Phylogenetically, Rhodopila and Rhodoblastus are quite distinct. No acidophilic purple sulfur bacteria are known and this is likely because at acid pH, sulfide would exist exclusively as H2S, its most toxic form. D. Purple Bacteria from Permanently Cold Habitats Permanently cold environments are habitats for cold-active purple bacteria (Burke and Burton, 1988; Madigan, 1998). The Madigan laboratory has been studying phototrophs that inhabit lakes in the McMurdo Dry Valleys of Antarctica. These are closed basin lakes with a biology that is exclusively microbial, and they remain permanently frozen with ice covers of 4–7 m. Purple nonsulfur bacteria have been isolated from samples of microbial mats that develop along the edge of the lakes as well as from water under the ice. Molecular studies using pufM as a measure of the biodiversity of purple bacteria suggest that species related to known purple nonsulfur bacteria reside in these lakes (Karr et al., 2003). The purple bacterium Rhodoferax antarcticus inhabits both microbial mats and the water column of Lake Fryxell (77º S latitude), a lake supporting major sulfur cycling activities (Sattley and Madigan, 2006). Lake Fryxell is unmixed and weakly stratified, with saline bottom waters overlain by freshwater. A gradient of sulfide is present in Lake Fryxell from micromolar levels at a depth of 9 m to nearly 1.5 millimolar near the sediments (~18 m). Despite these nearly perfect conditions for the development of phototrophic sulfur bacteria, no evidence for purple sulfur bacteria has emerged from enrichment culture or nucleic acid probing studies using pufM (Achenbach et al., 2001; Karr et al., 2003). Instead, Rfx. antarcticus, a very sulfide tolerant purple nonsulfur bacterium (Jung et al., 2004), seems to dominate anoxygenic photosynthesis in Lake Fryxell. Although Rfx. antarcticus is not strongly psychrophilic (optimal growth occurs at 18 ºC and no growth occurs above 24 ºC), it is the first anoxygenic phototroph to show a distinct cold adaptation and growth at 0 ºC (Madigan et al., 2000). Also in the water column of Lake Fryxell, gas vesiculate purple nonsulfur bacteria are present, including a morphologically unique strain of Rfx. antarcticus (betaproteobacteria) and a rod-shaped organism related to Rhodobacter species (alphaproteobacteria). These gas vesiculate
12 purple bacteria position themselves in zones of the water column where photosynthesis can occur optimally (Karr et al. 2003; Jung et al., 2004). Biomass measurements have shown that they localize in the water column at a depth of 10 m and that cell numbers drop off sharply below this depth and are undetectable above this depth (Madigan, unpublished). E. Environmental Limits to Photosynthesis in Purple Bacteria Work with extremophilic purple bacteria has given a good indication of the limits to which photosynthesis can be pushed. Photosynthesis in purple bacteria can occur at temperatures up to at least 57 ºC and down to 0 ºC, pH values as low as 3 or as high as 11, and at salinities up to and including saturated solutions of NaCl (~32%). Although these are probably not the absolute physiochemical limits to photosynthesis in anoxygenic phototrophs, they are likely to be very close to the limits. It is notable that the green nonsulfur bacterium Chloroflexus aurantiacus, which contains a purple bacterial-type photosynthetic reaction center (Achenbach et al., 2001), can grow up to 70 °C (Castenholz and Pierson, 1995). This holds out hope that purple bacteria capable of growth at temperatures above 57 °C (the upper limit for Tch. tepidum, Madigan, 1986) may exist in nature. Further exploration for new purple bacteria in sulfidic hot springs with temperatures above 60 °C should answer this question. VI. Final Remarks Our understanding of purple bacteria goes far beyond what has been discussed here. Through the years purple bacteria have become increasingly important as research tools for the study of basic problems in photosynthesis and have contributed in major ways to our understanding of the biochemistry, genetics and evolution of photosynthesis. And importantly, the beautiful colors and metabolic versatility of purple bacteria continue to attract talented young people to the field. The reader will see the fruits of their labors as well as those of the more seasoned investigators in the following chapters where the biology of purple bacteria will unfold in a spectacular way.
Michael T. Madigan and Deborah O. Jung Acknowledgments Research in the Madigan laboratory is supported by the United States National Science Foundation, most recently by grant MCB0237576. MTM thanks all of his former students and postdoctoral colleagues who did research on purple bacteria in his laboratory. These include Rich Masters, Rick Stegeman, Glenn Wright, Carletta Ooten, Erin Mack, Joseph Mayers, Ghanshyam Heda,Vasiliki Karayiannis, Sol Resnick, Chad Rubin, Gerrit Hoogewerf, Ike Pantazopoulous, Amy Milford, Linda Kimble, Amy Stevenson, Terry Locke, Tiffany Full, Jen Carey, Elizabeth Karr, Jill Crespi, Mahmoud Tayah, Tom Wahlund, Matt Sattley, and Marie Asao. References Achenbach LA, Carey JR and Madigan MT (2001) Photosynthetic and phylogenetic primers for detection of anoxygenic phototrophs in natural environments. Appl Environ Microbiol 67: 2922–2926 Biebl H and Pfennig N (1981) Isolation of members of the family Rhodospirillaceae. In: Starr MP, Stolp H, Trüper HG, Balows A and Schlegel HG (eds) The Prokaryotes — a Handbook on Habitats, Isolation and Identification of Bacteria, pp 267–273. Springer-Verlag, New York Blankenship RE, Madigan MT and Bauer CE (1995) Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 2). Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Brune DC (1995) Sulfur compounds as photosynthetic electron donors. In: Blankenship RE, Madigan MT and Bauer CE (eds) Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 2), pp 847–870. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Bryantseva IA, Gorlenko VM, Kompantseva EI and Imhoff JF (2000) Thioalkalicococcus limnaeus gen. nov., sp. nov., a new alkaliphilic purple sulfur bacterium with bacteriochlorophyll b. Int J Syst Bacteriol 50: 2157–2163 Bryantseva IA, Gorlenko VM, Kompantseva EI, Imhoff JF, Süling J and Mityushina L (1999) Thiorhodospira sibirica gen. nov., sp. nov., a new alkaliphilic purple sulfur bacterium from a Siberian soda lake. Int J Syst Bacteriol 49: 697–703 Burke CM and Burton HR (1988) Photosynthetic bacteria in meromictic lakes and stratified fjords of the Vestfold Hills, Antarctica. Hydrobiologia 165: 13–23 Caldwell DE and Tiedje JM (1975a) A morphological study of anaerobic bacteria from the hypolimnia of two Michigan lakes. Can J Microbiol 21: 362–376 Caldwell DE and Tiedje JM (1975b) The structure of anaerobic bacterial communities in the hypolimnia of several Michigan lakes. Can J Microbiol 21: 377–385 Castenholz RW (1977) The effect of sulfide on the blue-green algae of hot springs II. Yellowstone National Park. Microbial Ecology 3: 79–105 Castenholz RW and Pierson BK (1995) Ecology of thermophilic
Chapter 1
Overview of Purple Bacteria
anoxygenic phototrophs. In: Blankenship RE, Madigan MT and Bauer CE (eds) Anoxygenic Phototrophic Bacteria, pp 87–103. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Cohen-Bazire G, Sistrom WR and Stanier RY (1957) Kinetic studies of pigment synthesis by non-sulfur purple bacteria. J Cell Comp Physiol 49: 25–68 Cooper DE, Rands MB and Woo C-P (1975) Sulfide reduction in fellmongery effluent by red sulfur bacteria. J Water Pollution Control Fed 47: 2088–2100 Czeczuga B (1968) Primary production of the purple sulphuric bacteria, Thiopedia rosea Winogr. (Thiorhodaceae). Photosynthetica 2: 161–166 Ehrenreich A and Widdel F (1994) Anaerobic oxidation of ferrous iron by purple bacteria, a new type of phototrophic metabolism. Appl Environ Microbiol 60: 4517–4526 Favinger J, Stadtwald R and Gest H (1989) Rhodospirillum centenum, sp. nov., a thermotolerant cyst-forming anoxygenic photosynthetic bacterium. Ant van Leeuwenhoek 55: 291–296 Frigaard NU and Bryant DA (2004) Seeing green bacteria in a new light: Genomics-enabled studies of the photosynthetic apparatus in green sulfur bacteria and filamentous anoxygenic phototrophic bacteria. Arch Microbiol 182: 265–276 Garcia D, Parot P, Verméglio A and Madigan MT (1986) The light-harvesting complexes of a thermophilic purple sulfur photosynthetic bacterium Chromatium tepidum. Biochim Biophys Acta 850: 390–395 Gibson J and Harwood CS (1995) Degradation of aromatic compounds by nonsulfur purple bacteria. In: Blankenship RE, Madigan MT and Bauer CE (eds) Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 2), pp 991–1003. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Glaeser J and Overmann J (1999) Selective enrichment and characterization of Roseospirillum parvum, gen. nov. and sp. nov., a new purple nonsulfur bacterium with unusual light absorption properties. Arch Microbiol 171: 405–416 Griffin BM, Schott J and Schink B (2007) Nitrite, an electron donor for anoxygenic photosynthesis. Science 316: 1870 Guerrero R, Montesinos E, Pedrós-Alió C, Esteve I, Mas J, van Gemerden H, Hofman PAG and Bakker JF (1985) Phototrophic sulfur bacteria in two Spanish lakes: Vertical distribution and limiting factors. Limnol Oceanogr 30: 919–931 Gurgen V, Kirchner G and Pfennig N (1976) Fermentation of pyruvate by 7 species of phototrophic purple bacteria. Z Allg Mikrobiolo 16: 573–586 Hansen TA and van Gemerden H (1972) Sulfide utilization by purple nonsulfur bacteria. Arch Mikrobiol 86: 49–56 Hansen TA and Veldkamp H (1973) Rhodopseudomonas sulfidophila, nov. spec., a new species of the purple nonsulfur bacteria. Arch Mikrobiol 92: 45–58 Heda GD and Madigan MT (1988) Thermal properties and oxygenase activity of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase from the thermophilic purple bacterium, Chromatium tepidum. FEMS Microbiol Lett 51: 45–50 Heda GD and Madigan MT (1989) Purification and characterization of the thermostable ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/ oxygenase from the thermophilic purple bacterium Chromatium tepidum. Eur J Biochem 184: 313–319 Holm HW and Vennes JW (1970) Occurrence of purple sulfur bacteria in a sewage treatment lagoon. Appl Microbiol 19: 988–996 Imhoff JF (2001) True marine and halophilic anoxygenic photo-
13 trophic bacteria. Arch Microbiol 176: 243–254 Imhoff JF and Madigan MT (2004) International Committee on Systematics of Prokaryotes Subcommitteee on the taxonomy of phototrophic bacteria. Minutes of the meetings, 27 August 2003, Tokyo, Japan. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 54: 1001–1003 Imhoff JF, Hashwa F and Trüper HG (1978) Isolation of extremely halophilic phototrophic bacteria from the alkaline Wadi Natrun, Egypt. Arch Hydrobiol 84: 381–388 Imhoff JF, Sahl HG, Soliman GSH and Trüper HG (1979) The Wadi Natrun: chemical composition and microbial mass developments in alkaline brines of eutrophic desert lakes. Geomicrobiol J 1: 219–234 Imhoff JF, Hiraishi A and Süling J (2005) Anoxygenic phototrophic bacteria. In: Brenner DJ, Krieg NR and Staley JT (eds) Bergey’s Manual of Systematic Bacteriology, 2nd ed, Vol 2, part A, pp 119–132. Springer, New York Jones BR (1956) Studies of pigmented non-sulfur purple bacteria in relation to cannery waste lagoon odors. Sewage Ind Wastes 28: 883–893 Jung DO, Achenbach LA, Karr EA, Takaichi S and Madigan MT (2004) A gas vesiculate planktonic strain of the purple non-sulfur bacterium Rhodoferax antarcticus isolated from Lake Fryxell, Dry Valleys, Antarctica. Arch Microbiol 182: 236–243 Kämpf C and Pfennig N (1980) Capacity of Chromatiaceae for chemotrophic growth. Specific respiration rates of Thiocystis violacea and Chromatium vinosum. Arch Microbiol 127: 125–135 Karr EL, Sattley WM, Jung DO, Madigan MT and Achenbach LA (2003) Remarkable diversity of phototrophic purple bacteria in a permanently frozen Antarctic lake. Appl Environ Microbiol 69: 4910–4914 Kimble-Long LK and Madigan MT (2002) Irradiance effects on growth and bacteriochlorophyll content of phototrophic heliobacteria, purple and green photosynthetic bacteria. Photosynthetica 40: 629-632 Kobayashi M (1975) Role of photosynthetic bacteria in foul water purification. Prog Water Technol 7: 309–315 Kondratieva EN, Zhukov VG, Ivanovsky RN, Petushkova YP and Monosov EZ (1976) The capacity of phototrophic sulfur bacterium Thiocapsa roseopersicina for chemosynthesis. Arch Microbiol 108: 287–292 Kramer H and Amesz J (1996) Antenna organization in the purple sulfur bacteria Chromatium tepidum and Chromatium vinosum. Photosynth Res 49: 237–244 Kulichevskaya IS, Guzev VS, Gorlenko VM, Liesack W and Dedysh SN (2006) Rhodoblastus sphagnicola sp. nov., a novel acidophilic purple non-sulfur bacterium from Sphagnum peat bog. Intl J Syst Evol Microbiol 56: 1397–1402 Mack EE, Mandelco L, Woese CR and Madigan MT (1993) Rhodospirillum sodomense, sp. nov., a Dead Sea Rhodospirillum species. Arch Microbiol 160: 363–371 Madigan MT (1984) A novel photosynthetic purple bacterium isolated from a Yellowstone hot spring. Science 225: 313–315 Madigan MT (1986) Chromatium tepidum sp. nov., a thermophilic photosynthetic bacterium of the family Chromatiaceae. Int J Syst Bacteriol 36: 222–227 Madigan MT (1988) Microbiology, physiology, and ecology of phototrophic bacteria. In: AJB Zehnder (ed) Biology of Anaerobic Microorganisms, pp 39–111, John Wiley & Sons, New York
14 Madigan MT (1995) Microbiology of nitrogen fixation by anoxygenic photosynthetic bacteria. In: Blankenship RE, Madigan MT and Bauer CE (eds) Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 2), pp 915–928. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Madigan MT (1998) Isolation and characterization of psychrophilic purple bacteria from Antarctica. In: Peschek GA, Löffelhardt W and Schmetterer G (eds) The Phototrophic Prokaryotes, pp 699–706. Plenum, New York Madigan MT (2003) Anoxygenic phototrophic bacteria from extreme environments. Photosynth Res 76: 157–171 Madigan MT and Gest H (1978) Growth of a photosynthetic bacterium anaerobically in darkness, supported by ‘oxidant-dependent’ sugar fermentation. Arch Microbiol 117: 119–122 Madigan MT and Gest H (1979) Growth of the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodopseudomonas capsulata chemoautotrophically in darkness with H2 as the energy source. J Bacteriol 137: 524–530 Madigan MT, Cox SS and Stegeman RA (1984) Nitrogen fixation and nitrogenase activities in members of the family Rhodospirillaceae. J Bacteriol 157: 73–78 Madigan MT, Jung DO, Woese CR and Achenbach LA (2000) Rhodoferax antarcticus sp. nov., a moderately psychrophilic purple nonsulfur bacterium isolated from an Antarctic microbial mat. Arch. Microbiol. 173: 269–277 McClain J, Rollo DR, Rushing BG and Bauer CE (2002) Rhodospirillum centenum utilizes separate motor and switch components to control lateral and polar flagellum rotation. J Bacteriol 184: 2429–2438 Milford AD, Achenbach LA, Jung DO and Madigan MT (2000) Rhodobaca bogoriensis gen. nov. and sp. nov., an alkaphilic purple nonsulfur bacterium from African Rift Valley soda lakes. Arch Microbiol 174: 18–27 Nagashima KVP, Hiraishi A, Shimada K and Matsuura K (1997) Horizontal transfer of genes coding for the photosynthetic reaction centers of purple bacteria. J Mol Evol 45: 131–136 Nogi T, Fathir I, Kobayashi M, Nozawa T and Miki K (2000) Crystal structures of photosynthetic reaction center and highpotential iron-sulfur protein from Thermochromatium tepidum: Thermostability and electron transfer. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 97: 13561–13566 Nozawa T and Madigan MT (1991) Temperature and solvent effects on reaction centers from Chloroflexus aurantiacus and Chromatium tepidum. J Biochem 110: 588–594 Nozawa T, Fukada T, Hatano M and Madigan MT (1986) Organization of intracytoplasmic membranes in a novel thermophilic purple photosynthetic bacterium as revealed from absorption, circular dichroism, and emission spectra. Biochim Biophys Acta 852: 191–197 Overmann J and Schubert K (2002) Phototrophic consortia: Model systems for symbiotic interrelations between prokaryotes. Arch Microbiol 177: 201–208 Overmann J, Beatty JT and Hall KJ (1994) Photosynthetic activity and population dynamics of Amoebobacter purpureus in a meromictic saline lake. FEMS Microbiol Ecol 15: 309–320 Overmann J, Beatty JT and Hall KJ (1996) Purple sulfur bacteria control the growth of aerobic heterotrophic bacterioplankton in a meromictic salt lake. Appl Environ Microbiol 62: 3251–3258 Overmann J, Hall KJ, Northcote TG and Beatty JT (1999) Grazing of the copepod Diaptomus connexus on purple sulphur bacteria
Michael T. Madigan and Deborah O. Jung in a meromictic salt lake. Environ Microbiol 1: 213–221 Pattaragulwanit K, Brune DC, Trüper HG and Dahl C (1998) Molecular genetic evidence for extracytoplasmic localization of sulfur globules in Chromatium vinosum. Arch Microbiol 169: 434–444 Permentier HP, Neerken S, Overmann J and Amesz J (2001) A bacteriochlorophyll a antenna complex from purple bacteria absorbing at 963 nm. Biochemistry 40: 5573–5578 Pfennig N (1967) Photosynthetic bacteria. Ann Rev Microbiol 21: 285–324 Pfennig N (1969) Rhodopseudomonas acidophila, sp. n., a new species of the budding purple nonsulfur bacteria. J Bacteriol 99: 597–602 Pfennig N (1974) Rhodopseudomonas globiformis, sp. n., a new species of the Rhodospirillaceae. Arch Microbiol 100: 197–206 Pfennig N (1975) The phototrophic bacteria and their role in the sulfur cycle. Plant Soil 43: 1–16 Pfennig N (1978a) General physiology and ecology of photosynthetic bacteria. In: Clayton RK and Sistrom WR (eds) The Photosynthetic Bacteria, pp 3–18. Plenum Press, New York Pfennig N (1978b) Rhodocyclus purpureus gen. nov. and sp. nov., a ring-shape, vitamin B12-requiring member of the family Rhodospirillaceae. Int J Syst Bacteriol 28: 283–288 Pfennig N (1989) Ecology of phototrophic purple and green sulfur bacteria. In: Schlegel HG and Bowien B (eds) Autotrophic Bacteria, pp 97–116. Springer-Verlag, Heidelberg Raymond J, Zhaxybayeva O, Gogarten JP and Blankenship RE (2003) Evolution of photosynthetic prokaryotes: A maximumlikelihood mapping approach. Phil Tran Roy Soc Lond B Biol Sci 358: 223–230 Resnick SM and Madigan MT (1989) Isolation and characterization of a mildly thermophilic nonsulfur purple bacterium containing bacteriochlorophyll b. FEMS Microbiol Lett 65: 165–170 Satoh T, Hoshino Y and Kitamura H (1976) Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides forma sp. denitrificans, a denitrifying strain as a subspecies of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. Arch Microbiol 108: 265–269 Sattley WM and Madigan MT (2006) Isolation, characterization and ecology of cold-active, chemolithotrophic sulfur-oxidizing bacteria from perennially ice-covered Lake Fryxell, Antarctica. Appl Environ Microbiol 72: 5562–5568 Schultz JE and Weaver PF (1982) Fermentation and anaerobic respiration by Rhodospirillum rubrum and Rhodopseudomonas capsulata. J Bacteriol 149: 181–190 Siefert E and Koppenhagen VB (1982) Studies on the vitamin B12 auxotrophy of Rhodocyclus purpureus and two other vitamin B12-requiring purple nonsulfur bacteria. Arch Microbiol 132: 173–178 Siefert E, Irgens RL and Pfennig N (1978) Phototrophic purple and green bacteria in a sewage treatment plant. Appl Environ Microbiol 35: 38–44 Sojka GA (1978) Metabolism of nonaromatic organic compounds. In: Clayton RK and Sistrom WR (eds) The Photosynthetic Bacteria, pp 707–718. Plenum Press, New York Stadtwald-Demchick R, Turner FR and Gest H (1990) Rhodopseudomonas cryptolactis, sp. nov., a new thermotolerant species of budding phototrophic purple bacteria. FEMS Microbiol Lett 71: 117–121 Tabita FR (1995) The biochemistry and metabolic regulation of
Chapter 1
Overview of Purple Bacteria
carbon metabolism and CO2 fixation in purple bacteria. In: Blankenship RE, Madigan MT and Bauer CE (eds) Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 2), pp 885–914. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Takahashi M and Ichimura S (1968) Vertical distribution and organic matter production of photosynthetic sulfur bacteria in Japanese lakes. Limnol Oceanog 13: 644–655 Takaichi S, Jung DO and Madigan MT (2001) Accumulation of unusual carotenoids in the spheroidene pathway, demethylspheroidene and demethylspheroidenone, in an alkaliphilic purple nonsulfur bacterium Rhodobaca bogoriensis. Photosynth Res 67:207–214 Trüper HG (1978) Sulfur metabolism. In: Clayton RK and Sistrom WR (eds) The Photosynthetic Bacteria, pp 677–690. Plenum Press, New York Trüper HG (1981) Versatility of carbon metabolism in phototrophic bacteria. In: Dalton H (ed) Microbial Growth on C1 Compounds, pp 116–121. Heyden, London Trüper HG and Fischer U (1982) Anaerobic oxidation of sulphur compounds as electron donors for bacterial photosynthesis. Phil Trans Roy Soc Lond B 298: 529–542 Trüper HG and Pfennig N (1981) Characterization and identification of the anoxygenic phototrophic bacteria. In: Starr MP, Stolp H, Trüper HG, Balows A and Schlegel HG (eds.) The Prokaryotes, a Handbook on Habitatss, Isolation, and Identification of
15 Bacteria, pp 299–312. Springer-Verlag, New York Uffen RL and Wolfe RS (1970) Anaerobic growth of purple nonsulfur bacteria under dark conditions. J Bacteriol 104: 462–472 van Gemerden H (1968) On the ATP generation by Chromatium in darkness. Arch Mikrobiol 64: 118–124 van Gemerden H and Mas J (1995) Ecology of phototrophic sulfur bacteria. In: Blankenship RE, Madigan MT and Bauer CE (eds) Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 2), pp 50–85. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht van Niel CB (1932) On the morphology and physiology of the purple and green sulphur bacteria. Arch Mikrobiol 3: 1–112 van Niel CB (1944) The culture, general physiology, morphology, and classification of the non-sulfur purple and brown bacteria. Bacteriol Rev 8: 1–118 Ward DM, Weller R, Shiea J, Castenholz RW and Cohen Y (1989) Hot spring microbial mats: anoxygenic and oxygenic mats of possible evolutionary significance. In: Cohen Y and Rosenberg E (eds) Microbial Mats: Physiological Ecology of Benthic Microbial Communities, pp 3–15. American Society for Microbiology, Washington, DC Zengler K, Heider J, Rossello-Mora R and Widdel F (1999) Phototrophic utilization of toluene under anoxic conditions by a new strain of Blastochloris sulfoviridis. Arch Microbiol 172: 204–212
Chapter 2 Evolutionary Relationships Among Purple Photosynthetic Bacteria and the Origin of Proteobacterial Photosynthetic Systems Wesley D. Swingley Institute of Low Temperature Science, Hokkaido University, N19W8, Sapporo 060-0819, Japan
Robert E. Blankenship Departments of Biology and Chemistry, Washington University in St. Louis, Campus Box 1337, St. Louis, MO 63130, U.S.A.
Jason Raymond* School of Natural Sciences, University of California-Merced, Merced, CA 95344, U.S.A.
Summary ................................................................................................................................................................. 17 I. Introduction....................................................................................................................................................... 18 II. The Alphaproteobacteria .................................................................................................................................. 18 III. Aerobic Purple Bacteria.................................................................................................................................... 19 IV. The Photosynthesis Gene Cluster and its Role in Evolution ............................................................................ 20 V. Proteobacterial Comparative Genomics: Photosynthetic versus non-Photosynthetic Proteins ....................... 21 VI. Origin and Evolution of Proteobacterial Phototrophy ....................................................................................... 22 VII. Origin and Evolution of Proteobacterial Carbon-fixation .................................................................................. 24 VIII. Future Directions: High-Throughput Sequencing and Metagenomics.............................................................. 27 Acknowledgments ................................................................................................................................................... 28 References .............................................................................................................................................................. 28
Summary The purple bacteria occupy a unique position among photosynthetic bacteria. Nested within the various proteobacterial lineages, the origin and evolution of purple bacterial photosynthesis has been the topic of innumerable debates. Attempts to reconstruct the evolutionary history of individual photosynthetic protein families have further fueled debate over lateral vs. vertical transfer of genetic elements. In this era of high-throughput sequencing we can begin to distance ourselves from this dependency on single-gene and single-protein phylogenies. Here we present automated comparative genomics-based methods useful for reconstructing the genomic history of not only the purple bacterial lineage, but the proteobacterial lineage as a whole. These reconstructions integrate phylogenetic data inferred from 200 to more than 1000 protein families common to all or part of the proteobacterial lineage. This framework allows us to reconstruct the evolutionary history of *Author for correspondence, email: [email protected]
C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty (eds): The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria, pp. 17–29. © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V.
18
Wesley D. Swingley, Robert E. Blankenship and Jason Raymond
each proteobacterial class and parse out the finer relationships among photosynthetic species. By telescoping inward on protein families of interest, we can delve deeper than ever before into the convoluted evolutionary origin of the primary photosynthetic traits, phototrophy and autotrophy. While these full-genome comparisons clarify the nature of many poorly understood phylogenetic relationships, they do not yet serve to resolve the entire mystery surrounding the history of proteobacterial phototrophy. I. Introduction Among six phyla of photosynthetic prokaryotes, the purple proteobacteria are the most metabolically diverse. Unlike some other groups of phototrophs such as cyanobacteria or green sulfur bacteria, in which all members are capable of photosynthesis, the proteobacteria have a remarkable range of metabolic lifestyles. Within this group are organisms that grow aerobically and anaerobically, photoautotrophically and photoheterotrophically, and many that utilize a diverse number of metabolic pathways for energy generation, carbon assimilation, as well as nitrogen, sulfur, and phosphorous metabolism (Imhoff et al., 2005; Chapter 1, Madigan and Jung). This diversity reflects the widespread nature of these organisms throughout the proteobacterial lineage. In many cases, phototrophic proteobacteria share genus-level relationships with non-phototrophs. This fact could be explained as either a loss of ancestral phototrophy or a lateral gain of the genes necessary to produce photosynthetic pigments and proteins. Although the proteobacteria are the most sequenced bacterial phylum to date, with more than 500 genomes complete or in progress (according to NCBI), the purple bacteria have been far less sampled, with fewer than 30 genome projects as of this writing, fewer than half of which are completed. This disparity is, in part, due to the overwhelming medical interest in proteobacteria, but it speaks volumes that the first purple bacterial sequence, Rhodopseudomonas palustris CGA009, was not published until 2004 (Larimer et al., 2004), nine years after the first complete bacterial genome sequence (Fleischmann et al., 1995). Notwithstanding, preliminary sequence data from Rhodobacter capsulatus and Rhodobacter sphaeroides 2.4.1 have been available since 2001 (http://www. integrated genomics.com/genomereleases.html; Mackenzie et al., 2001).
Early purple bacteria sequencing projects focused on model organisms, a common trend throughout the genome sequencing arena, completing the heavily studied species Rhodobacter sphaeroides (Choudhary et al., 2007), Rhodopseudomonas palustris (Larimer et al., 2004), Rhodospirillum rubrum (NCBI), and both phototrophic and nonphototrophic Bradyrhizobia (Kaneko et al., 2002; Giraud et al., 2007). Recently, the focus has begun to shift to those purple bacteria with a significant involvement in oceanic carbon and nutrient cycling, with the completed sequence of Roseobacter denitrificans Och 114 (Swingley et al., 2007) leading the way to a tremendous number of marine organismal genome sequences in progress or recently completed . While all of the above sequences are from the alpha class of proteobacteria, few other phototrophic proteobacteria have been targeted for sequencing. Three of these belong to the gammaproteobacteria, Halorhodospira halophila SL1, Congregibacter litoralis KT71, and the undescribed marine strain HTCC2080 (NCBI). Of these, Halorhodospira and Congregibacter have been characterized as phototrophic (Imhoff and Süling, 1996; Fuchs et al., 2007), but HTCC2080, which carries the genetic capability for phototrophy, has not yet been shown to produce photosynthetic pigments. Two major clades of phototrophic betaproteobacteria, genera Rubrivivax and Rhodoferax, have yet to be sequenced, as the only sequenced members, the former Rubrivivax gelatinosus PM1 (now Methylibium petroleiphilum PM1) and Rhodoferax ferrireducens T118, are non-phototrophic strains. M. petroleiphilum was only recently disambiguated from a cluster of closely-related species (both phototrophic and nonphototrophic) lumped under a relatively small number of genera (Nakatsu et al., 2006). II. The Alphaproteobacteria
Abbreviations: AAP – aerobic anoxygenic phototrophs; BChl – bacteriochlorophyll; GOS – Global Ocean Survey; kb – kilobase(s); PGC – photosynthesis gene cluster; rubisco– ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase
The vast majority of phototrophic proteobacteria are spread throughout the alpha lineage. However, phototrophy is by no means ubiquitous in alphapro-
Chapter 2
Evolution of Purple Bacteria
teobacteria. Less than 22% of all alphaproteobacteria currently sequenced bear signatures of phototrophy (presence of chlorophyll biosynthesis or reaction center genes). While the number of sequenced phototrophic taxa is low, they are widespread throughout the alpha cluster (Fig. 1), which raises important questions on the origin of their phototrophy. Furthermore, a sequencing bias for the large number of agriculturally-important alphaproteobacteria could skew the aforementioned ratio. In fact, 18 of 39 currently available ‘in progress’ proteobacteria genomes at NCBI are potentially phototrophic. Unlike phototrophy, carbon-fixation is not common among alphaproteobacteria. The typical method of autotrophic carbon-fixation in all proteobacteria is through the Calvin Cycle using the key enzyme ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase (rubisco). Variations of this enzyme are found throughout the tree of life (Tabita, 1999), but it is most famously associated with chlorophyll and photoautotrophy in photosynthetic organisms. However, a unique class of alphaproteobacteria (discussed below) grows photoheterotrophically rather than photoautotrophically. As a result, a relatively low proportion of alphaproteobacteria are photoautotrophic when compared to the beta- and gammaproteobacteria, where phototrophy is more rare. III. Aerobic Purple Bacteria Canonically speaking, purple bacteria grow photoautotrophically only at low oxygen levels, while they down-regulate their photosynthetic apparatus under higher oxygen levels and instead grow chemotrophically using organic carbon (Harashima et al., 1982; Yurkov and van Gemerden, 1993; Bauer et al., 2003; Yurkov and Csotonyi, 2003). Recent oceanic metagenomic surveys have created a burgeoning interest in a related class of purple bacteria that grow primarily under aerobic conditions. Dubbed the aerobic anoxygenic phototrophs (AAP or AAnP) or aerobic phototrophic bacteria (APB), these purple bacteria produce photosynthetic pigments and carry out phototrophic metabolism only under aerobic conditions (Shiba et al., 1979; Shiba and Harashima, 1986; Yurkov and van Gemerden, 1993;Yurkov and Beatty, 1998; Chapter 3, Yurkov and Csotonyi). However, they produce bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) a only in the dark, possibly to avoid the potential for oxidative damage caused by the excitation of chlorophyll
19
Fig. 1. 16S rRNA tree of the Proteobacteria, based on sequences from the Ribosomal Database [http://rdp.cme.msu.edu]. To facilitate visualization, 16S rRNA gene data are filtered so that only lineages at 97% or less 16S rRNA gene distance are shown (i.e. filtered at roughly the species level). Bold lineages are those proteobacterial species with one or more genome-sequenced members. Bold, numbered lineages indicate the positions of sequenced purple/phototrophic proteobacteria in the tree. Other lineages have 16S rRNA data available from isolates or environmental samples, but do not have genome projects in progress as of this writing. Proteobacterial classes are shown in Greek letters. Numbered purple proteobacteria are: 1. Rhodospirillum rubrum, 2. Rhodospirillum centenum, 3. Erythrobacter NAP1, 4. Roseobacter denitrificans (multiple strains), 5. Roseovarius sp. (multiple strains), 6. Loktanella, 7. Jannaschia sp. CCS1, 8. Rhodobacter sphaeroides (incl. R. capsulatus), 9. Fulvimarina, 10. Methylobacterium, 11. Bradyrhizobium (multiple species), 12. Rhodopseudomonas palustris (multiple strains), 13. Thermochromatium tepidum (proprietary sequence), 14. Halorhodospira sp. SL1, 15. Rubrivivas gelatinosus (photosynthetic gene cluster only, no genome)
intermediates (Beatty, 2002). While these AAP have long been overlooked in oceanic studies, recent data shows that they are widely distributed in the oceans and, consequently, their contribution to the global carbon cycle could be significant (Kolber et al., 2001; Buchan et al., 2005; Yutin et al., 2007). Historically, the origin of aerobiosis in the AAP has been a puzzling problem, especially in regards to the regulation of photosynthetic gene expression. The largest cluster of AAP, the Roseobacter clade, fall within the order Rhodobacterales and these species are closely related to the model species Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Rhodobacter capsulatus (Yurkov and
20
Wesley D. Swingley, Robert E. Blankenship and Jason Raymond
Fig. 2. Schematic comparison of photosynthesis gene clusters (PGC) from various purple bacteria. Lines represent transpositions of syntenous gene regions between two PGC. Numbers annotated above the Rhodospirillum rubrum PGC represent the location on the genome of each separate PGC segment. The lines with arrows represent inversion of the genes contained between the lines and the other lines represent shifts in position without inversions. See also Color Plate 1, Fig. 1, for a color version with additional information.
Beatty, 1998). Even within this group of organisms the common proteobacterial trend holds true in that not all members are phototrophic. Thus far, nearly all sequenced species in this cluster lack rubisco and thus the ability to fix carbon autotrophically (Swingley et al., 2007). The reason for the seemingly detrimental absence of autotrophic carbon-fixation is unclear. Distantly related families of AAP, such as some Erythrobacter and Congregibacter species, also lack rubisco (Swingley et al., 2007; Yutin et al., 2007). One possibility is that the presence of rubisco with a poor specificity for CO2 vs. O2 is a liability in aerobic conditions, which would lead to a large amount of photorespiration — which has led to multiple rubisco gene losses throughout evolutionary history. The only AAP shown to exhibit photoautotrophic carbon-fixation are several members of the plant endosymbiont genus Bradyrhizobia (Giraud et al., 2007). IV. The Photosynthesis Gene Cluster and its Role in Evolution In all known cases, the majority of the genetic information needed to build the photosynthetic apparatus
in purple bacteria is clustered in large groups of genes known as the Photosynthesis Gene Cluster (PGC). In most organisms, a single cluster of 40–50 kb contains all the structural genes for the photosystem, as well as genes for the latter stages of BChl and carotenoid biosynthesis (Fig. 2). Exceptions to this pattern are Rhodospirillum rubrum and Methylobacterium species, which contain three separate PGC clusters that are widely dispersed in the chromosome. Figure 2 shows gene neighborhoods for the PGC in several purple bacterial species. It is apparent that while the genes are organized into one or a few large clusters, the precise gene organization within the cluster is highly variable. It is possible to produce the various gene synteny arrangements found in PGCs by inversions and rearrangements, as shown in Fig. 2. The dramatic clustering of nearly all genes involved in phototrophy has provided a perfect framework for the lateral spread of phototrophy. It is intriguing that there is not a similar clustering of photosynthesisrelated genes in other groups of phototrophs, with the exception of the heliobacteria (Xiong et al., 1998). The gene organization of the PGC in heliobacteria is not generally similar to that found in the purple bacteria, with the exception of some of the operons
Chapter 2
Evolution of Purple Bacteria
for multisubunit enzyme complexes involved in BChl biosynthesis. This suggests that the assembly of genes into the PGC in the purple bacteria and heliobacteria may have been independent evolutionary events. The heliobacteria seem to have little in common with the purple bacteria in that they have a type I reaction center, are strict anaerobes and are incapable of photoautotrophic metabolism. Why these two very different groups of phototrophs have both assembled the genetic information needed to do photosynthesis into large gene clusters while other groups of phototrophs have not done so is a question for which no answer is yet available. The possible functional role of such extreme clustering of genes that code for functionally related proteins has a long history in biology, starting with the lac operon of Escherichia coli (Jacob and Monod, 1961). The utility of clustering and co-expression of genes that code for parts of a multiprotein complex is easy to appreciate. A single mRNA encoding each component of a complex, which is then translated into proteins that then associate with each other, permits precise control of the expression levels and spatial proximity of the components. However, what is not so clear is the benefit of a large gene cluster such as the PGC, which consists of more than thirty genes. This cluster has genes that are divergently transcribed, so they cannot be part of a single operon, which is confirmed by transcriptional analysis (Kiley and Kaplan, 1988; Wellington and Beatty, 1991). Furthermore, the dosage requirements of the various photosynthetic complexes and biosynthetic enzymes are vastly different. Regulatory elements can easily coordinate gene expression in genes that are distant on the chromosome, so there seems to be little functional need for physical clustering. The ‘selfish operon’ theory as formulated by Lawrence and Roth (Lawrence and Roth, 1996; Lawrence, 2003) proposes that operons assemble to facilitate horizontal transfer of an operon and its easy replacement if it happens to be lost. This theory has been questioned and some predictions of the selfish operon theory have not been observed (Pál and Hurst, 2004; Price et al., 2005). Nagashima et al. (1997) analyzed the gene sequences of the L and M reaction center proteins and concluded that significant amounts of horizontal gene transfer has taken place among purple bacteria. This same conclusion was extended to the PGC in a later study (Igarashi et al., 2001). However, this issue has not been addressed in detail since the advent of large-scale genome sequencing
21 of photosynthetic bacteria and it represents an area that needs to be investigated in more detail. V. Proteobacterial Comparative Genomics: Photosynthetic versus Non-Photosynthetic Proteins The foremost challenge in using a wealth of genomic data to reconstruct evolutionary events is how to integrate thousands of genes worth of (often discordant) phylogenies. One approach to this end involves concatenating multiple aligned gene or protein sequences and inferring a single phylogeny for this concatenated dataset. The underlying assumption for this approach is that the incongruence in single phylogenies, caused by data that are poorly fit by evolutionary models or by horizontal gene transfer, will be overtaken by the reinforcing signal of vertical evolution. Simulation studies have illustrated the robustness of concatenated datasets while raising the important caveat that, under some circumstances, concatenation only serves to reinforce the wrong tree (Gadagkar et al., 2005). No doubt the approach will continue to improve with more rigorous methods for determining which genes are suitable for concatenation. Concatenated phylogenies represent an averaged evolutionary overview of a set of genes or proteins, providing a potentially useful broad brush history but also masking potentially interesting details. It is important that this, and other approaches, be considered along with — not in lieu of — rigorous, single gene or protein phylogenies. Keeping these assumptions and ideas in mind, it is useful to examine the photosynthesis gene phylogeny for a large set of sequenced proteobacteria and contrast this with the 16S rRNA tree. This method involves the concatenation of specific PGC proteins to compare the evolutionary history of proteobacterial photosynthesis with the history of the phylum. Figure 3 (left) shows the phylogeny inferred from concatenating 208 orthologous proteins found in 29 proteobacterial genomes and several non-proteobacterial phototrophic bacteria, yielding an alignment of nearly 69,000 positions. Figure 3 (right) shows the concatenation of 38 proteins from the PGC of Rhodobacter sphaeroides with their homologs in other bacterial phototrophs, which resulted in an alignment of nearly 16,400 positions. The 208-protein (all-protein) concatenation (Fig. 3, left) is generally consistent with the 16S rRNA tree in the distinct
22
Wesley D. Swingley, Robert E. Blankenship and Jason Raymond
Fig. 3. A comparison of purple bacterial phylogeny based on whole genome proteins versus only photosynthesis-related proteins. On the left is the phylogeny based on concatenation of 208 proteins found in all, or all but one, genome from representative proteobacteria and several other phototrophic phyla. The tree on the right shows the phylogeny based on the concatenation of 38 proteins from the photosynthetic gene cluster (PGC) in purple proteobacteria and their homologs in other phototrophic phyla. Taxa in gray are present in only one of the two trees, whereas taxa in black are present in both trees. The lineage line-width is proportional to topological (branching order) differences between the two trees. Proteobacterial classes are indicated by Greek letters and surrounded by dashed lines. PGC protein homologs included in the concatenation are: LhaA, Lhb1, PpaA, PpsR, PucC, PufL, PufM, PufQ, PufX, PuhH, AcsF, BchB, BchC, BchD, BchE, BchF, BchG, BchH, BchI, BchJ, BchL, BchM, BchN, BchO, BchP, BchX, BchY, BchZ, CrtA, CrtB, CrtC, CrtD, CrtE, CrtF, CrtI, CrtK, Idi, and Lha1.
separation of the proteobacterial classes as well as with the branching order of species within these classes. In contrast, the 38-protein PGC concatenation shows no congruence at the class level with either the 16S rRNA tree or the all-protein concatenation. Identical branching is observed at lower taxonomic levels, as seen for instance in the topology of order Rhodobacteriales (Rhodobacter sphaeroides through Roseobacter denitrificans), and also in conservation of the Rhodopseudomonas/Bradyrhizobium clade. At face value, the PGC tree is consistent with the idea of an alpha origin of proteobacterial phototrophy, followed by subsequent horizontal gene transfer into members of the beta- and gammaproteobacterial classes. Note that the position of the non-proteobacterial phototrophs as outgroups on both trees is based on midpoint rooting on the longest branch in the tree; in principle, one could use additional lines of evidence to root the trees along other lineages.
VI. Origin and Evolution of Proteobacterial Phototrophy The scattered distribution of phototrophic organisms throughout the proteobacteria has presented a longstanding puzzle. On one hand, the sheer number of lateral transfer events necessary to accommodate such a distribution seems overwhelming. Conversely, the number of deletion events required seems to rule out a phototrophic proteobacterial ancestor. However, by breaking down the problem into manageable pieces, some conclusions can be drawn. Because the alphaproteobacteria represent the largest repository for phototrophy, they are the best group for studying the elusive origin of this trait. One thing made clear by the growing library of sequence data is that alphaproteobacterial phototrophy is evenly dispersed across evolutionary space (Fig. 1), indicating that vertical transfer coupled with gene loss may be more important than lateral gene transfer in this group. However, it is clear that the earliest
Chapter 2
Evolution of Purple Bacteria
phototrophic ancestor would likely occur after the divergence of the Rickettsiales — none of which are phototrophic — although the highly reduced genomes of these intracellular parasites could have selectively lost such an extraneous metabolic activity. In fact, the next earliest-branching clade includes the genus Acidiphilium, which contains phototrophic species (Hiraishi and Shimada, 2001). One of the largest and best studied alphaproteobacterial lineages is the Rhodobacteraceae. Over half of the in progress or complete phototrophic alpha genomes belong to this clade. However, even though the Rhodobacteraceae is a monophyletic, terminal clade, it contains a large number of non-phototrophic species. The conservation of phototrophy in this cluster suggests that the loss of phototrophy (and indeed photosynthesis as a whole) in these species may be quite common. One possible reason for such a phenomenon stems from the highly diverse metabolic library of Rhodobacteraceae species (Buchan et al., 2005). It is possible that such species modulate their metabolism based on availability of nutrients and/or light availability in their ecological niche. Given that bacterial genomes are generally streamlined, the loss of photosynthesis is likely in environments where photosynthesis is not a practical metabolic option. Most of the other sequenced phototrophic proteobacteria are found in the alphaproteobacterial family Bradyrhizobiaceae. This family is composed of three major genera, Bradyrhizobium, Rhodopseudomonas, and Nitrobacter, of which the former two both contain phototrophic species. Internal membranes in Nitrobacter species that are reminiscent of purple bacterial photosynthetic membranes suggest that this genus may have originated from a phototrophic ancestor. While all known Rhodopseudomonas species are phototrophic, there is only one monophyletic cluster of phototrophic Bradyrhizobium species, typified by the first discovered phototrophic strain Bradyrhizobium sp. BTAi1. Because Bradyrhizobium strains have typically been isolated from legume root nodules, it has been speculated that selective pressure has caused the loss of photosynthetic activity in many species (Giraud et al., 2007). This hypothesis is supported by the fact that all photosynthetic strains have been isolated from light-accessible stem nodules rather than light-inaccessible root nodules (Willems et al., 2003). Naturally, a ‘chicken or egg’ argument can be posed for any case of photosynthesis gene loss vs. gain. In cases such as the Rhodobacteraceae where a vast
23 majority of polyphyletic species are phototrophic, it is likely that phototrophy is a vertically inherited trait. However, in the case of Bradyrhizobium, the monophyletic phototrophic cluster could be the result of a single lateral transfer. While the presence of the closely related phototrophic Rhodopseudomonas and remnant ‘photosynthetic’ membranes in Nitrobacter support a phototrophic ancestry, they are not conclusive proof. A wealth of sequenced Bradyrhizobia, both phototrophic (strains BTAi1 and ORS278) and nonphototrophic (strain USDA110), and other Bradyrhyzobiaceae (five Rhodopseudomonas and three Nitrobacter species) allow for thorough analysis of this problem. One striking case is the similarity of gene orientation (synteny) between the phototrophic and non-phototrophic Bradyrhizobia (Fig. 4). While the number of homologous genes (E-value greater than 10–50) is greater between BTAi1 and ORS278, the overall gene order is more conserved between either of the two phototrophic strains and USDA110. This suggests two possible conclusions: a) genome rearrangement is a common occurrence and syntenic homology between distant strains occurs by coincidence or lower rates of recombination; or b) phototrophic and non-phototrophic strains are more closely related to each other than previous work has shown (Willems et al., 2003). It is very difficult to support the second case, which would contradict multiple phylogenetic reconstructions from 16S rRNA and rRNA ITS sequences as well as that presented in this chapter. The immense library of literature discussing genome rearrangement strongly supports the first conclusion. A high rate of genome rearrangement also leads to an increase in the rate of gene duplication and loss. This could have greater implications on the scattered nature of phototrophy throughout the proteobacterial clade, where a high rate of gene loss could account for numerous closely-related strains with and without phototrophic ability. Recent work by Haffa et al. (A.L. Haffa, personal communication) suggests that viral invasion has had a great influence on both random and directed gene losses in proteobacterial species, a fact that further convolutes evolutionary history in these species. Expanding beyond the phototrophic alphaproteobacteria, we see only a few select phototrophic clades throughout the rest of the proteobacterial tree. Methylibium petroleiphilum strain PM1and Rhodoferax ferrireducens T118 are the only sequenced members from phototrophic betaproteobacterial
24
Wesley D. Swingley, Robert E. Blankenship and Jason Raymond
Fig. 4. Dot-plot comparison representing a genome alignment between Bradyrhizobium species. Dots represent aligned nucleotide regions with higher than 75% identity. Only alignments with a BLAST score better than E=10-50 are shown. Axes represent sequence location in megabases. Dots in sequence along the 1:1 axis represent laterally homologous gene regions. Dots in sequence along the -1:1 axis represent contiguous translocations.
clades. Unfortunately, neither is a phototrophic species. However, Nagashima et al. (1993) sequenced the entire PGC from a phototrophic member of the same family, Rubrivivax gelatinosus, providing the most detailed glimpse so far into betaproteobacterial phototrophy. Halorhodospira halophilum SL1 is the only completely sequenced phototrophic gam-
maproteobacterium. Sequence data for two new phototrophic gammas, Congregibacter litoralis KT71 and unnamed marine strain HTCC2080, are currently available, but as yet incomplete. The sparse distribution of phototrophic beta- and gammaproteobacteria suggests that phototrophy did not originate in these clades. This idea is supported by the evolutionary history of their photosynthetic proteins (Fig. 3, right). Rubrivivax phototrophy appears to originate early on the Bradyrhizobiaceae branch, before the divergence of Rhodopseudomonas and Bradyrhizobium. The lack of conservation in the gene order between Rubrivivax and either alpha PGC suggests that this represents a relatively old lateral transfer event. On the other hand, the PGC gene order in Congregibacter and gamma HTCC2080 shares a great deal of similarity to their apparent origin from a close relative of Fulvimarina pelagi HTCC2506. The lesser homology between Halorhodospira and Fulvimarina illustrates the longer phylogenetic distance between the PGC in these two species; however, the origin is still quite near the Fulvimarina cluster. The precise origin of phototrophy in individual families of beta and gamma proteobacteria will not be resolved until further taxa are sequenced (if not full genomes, then at least PGC sequences). However, this chapter shows that only a few lateral transfer events could account for all non-alpha proteobacterial phototrophy. Less clear is the origin of the few chlorophyll biosynthesis genes that are not always contained within the PGC, such as the aerobic and anaerobic monomethyl ester cyclases (acsF and bchE, respectively) and divinyl reductase (gene not yet identified for all purple bacteria). These genes are not always present in the PGC of beta and gamma phototrophs, implying that they were either transferred independently by a later event or were originally in the PGC and have since translocated away. Such an outward translocation seems in direct opposition to our current understanding of bacterial gene clusters/operons (as discussed above). VII. Origin and Evolution of Proteobacterial Carbon-fixation Carbon-fixation is an inextricable component of photosynthesis. However, when studying purple bacterial photosynthesis we must be careful to extract and analyze the two portions independently. As discussed in the preceding section, phototrophy is
Chapter 2
Evolution of Purple Bacteria
unevenly distributed throughout the proteobacteria and the same is true for carbon-fixation. Nevertheless, these two traits do not appear to be linked in any clear fashion. Certainly there are many species that grow photoautotrophically using Calvin Cycle carbon-fixation, but just as many grow photoheterotrophically. On the other hand, many proteobacterial species fix CO2 without the use of light energy. Unlike photosynthetic proteins, the subunits of rubisco, RbcL/CbbL and RbcS/CbbS, are evolutionarily split into several classes (Watson and Tabita, 1997; Tabita, 1999; Ashida et al., 2005; Tabita et al., 2007). Therefore, while carbon-fixation may appear conserved in any given monophyletic cluster, the actual genes may have very different origins. This
25 is most striking in the Rhodobacteraceae, where some AAP species contain a rubisco that shares a close phylogenetic origin with Type IV rubisco-like proteins (Swingley et al., 2007) (Fig. 5 and Table 1). The role of the Type IV enzymes has not been clearly described; however, they have not been shown to fix CO2 (Hanson and Tabita, 2001; Imker et al., 2007; Tabita et al., 2007). There are also many cases where members of a single genus carry copies of rubisco from different family-types. Most notable among these are the Rhodopseudomonas species — which contain up to four different types of rubisco — and some Rhodobacter species that code for a number of rubisco variations (Table 1). Even with the likelihood of widespread rubisco
Fig. 5. Phylogenetic representation of purple bacterial ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate (rubisco) sequences. Roman numeral labels identify the recognized distinct ‘Form’ family of rubisco or rubisco-like protein. This analysis revealed three divergent groups of Form IV proteins that are further split into types A, B, and C, which are analogous to those described by Tabita (2007): A = IV-DeepYkr, B = IV-Photo, C = IV-NonPhoto.
Wesley D. Swingley, Robert E. Blankenship and Jason Raymond
26
Table 1. Ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate (rubisco) content of the purple bacteria and non-phototrophic members of genera that contain known phototrophs. rubisco Form-types are labeled as shown in Fig. 5 Family
α
β
Organism Bradyrhizobium japonicum USDA 110 Bradyrhizobium sp. BTAi1 Bradyrhizobium sp. ORS278 Dinoroseobacter shibae DFL 12 Erythrobacter litoralis HTCC2594 Erythrobacter sp. NAP1 Erythrobacter sp. SD-21 Fulvimarina pelagi HTCC2506 Jannaschia sp. CCS1 Loktanella vestfoldensis SKA53 Magnetospirillum magneticum AMB-1 Magnetospirillum magnetotacticum MS-1 Methylobacterium chloromethanicum CM4 Methylobacterium extorquens PA1 Methylobacterium sp. 4-46 Oceanicola batsensis HTCC2597 Oceanicola granulosus HTCC2516 Rhodobacter capsulatus Rhodobacter sphaeroides 2.4.1 Rhodobacter sphaeroides ATCC 17025 Rhodobacter sphaeroides ATCC 17029 Rhodocista centenaria Rhodopseudomonas palustris BisA53 Rhodopseudomonas palustris BisB18 Rhodopseudomonas palustris BisB5 Rhodopseudomonas palustris CGA009 Rhodopseudomonas palustris HaA2 Rhodospirillum rubrum ATCC 11170 Roseobacter denitrificans OCh 114 Roseobacter sp. AzwK-3b Roseobacter sp. CCS2 Roseobacter sp. MED193 Roseobacter sp. SK209-2-6 Roseovarius nubinhibens ISM Roseovarius sp. 217 Roseovarius sp. HTCC2601 Roseovarius sp. TM1035 Sulfitobacter sp. EE-36 Sulfitobacter sp. NAS-14.1 Methylibium petroleiphilum PM1 Rhodoferax ferrireducens T118
Form I ID IA, ID (x2) IA, ID ––––-
Form II
Form IV
IVC IVC –II II (×2) ––IVC –IVA IA IC IA, IC IC IA, ID ID ID IA, ID ID ID
II II II II II II II II II II
IVA, IVB IVA, IVB IVA, IVB IVA, IVB IVA, IVB IVA
–––IVC –––ID –––-
IVC (×2)
IC (x2) II
Chapter 2
Evolution of Purple Bacteria
27
Table 1. Continued Family
Organism
Form I
γ
Congregibacter litoralis KT71 Halorhodospira halophila SL1 marine gamma proteobacterium HTCC2080
–IA –-
Chlorobium tepidum TLS Chloroflexus aurantiacus J-10-fl Clostridium acetobutylicum ATCC 824 Desulfitobacterium hafniense Y51 Pelodictyon luteolum DSM 273 Prochlorococcus marinus MIT 9313 Roseiflexus sp. RS-1 Synechococcus sp. JA-2-3B´a(2-13)
lateral gene transfer, some phylogenetic information can be drawn from the proteobacterial genome tree. The aforementioned Rhodopseudomonas and Bradyrhizobium species likely share a Form ID rubiscocontaining ancestor with the related non-phototrophic genus Nitrobacter. However, the presence of many proteins from unrelated species in this phylogenetic cluster indicates that lateral transfer has likely occurred on multiple occasions. The presence of Form II in all Rhodobacter species also indicates that it is ancestral to this genus. Given the lack of autotrophic CO2-fixation in the AAP, Form II rubisco may not be ancestral to the Rhodobacteraceae in general. Nevertheless, the presence of Form IV-like proteins in AAPs suggests its possible ancestry to this group. Although Form IB rubisco, representing the traditional plant and cyanobacterial class of enzymes, is not present in any purple bacteria, other Form I enzymes are common throughout the proteobacteria. Like phototrophy, the origin and evolution of carbon-fixation in purple bacteria is difficult to clarify. The apparently rampant lateral transfer of Calvin Cycle enzymes in proteobacteria (and bacteria/Archaea as a whole) creates a high level of background noise that is difficult to separate from phylogenetic signals. Even with such a confusing situation, carbon-fixation is clearly an ancestral trait for the Bradyrhizobiaceae and likely many other lineages. However, given the current level of sequence coverage, we cannot make any further conclusions on the origin of purple bacterial — or proteobacterial for that matter — carbon-fixation.
Form II
Form IV IVA IVB
–––IVB IA –IB
VIII. Future Directions: High-Throughput Sequencing and Metagenomics One of the exciting recent advances in microbiology is the application of genomics to complex microbial communities taken directly from their natural environments. Environmental genomics, or metagenomics, provides an opportunity to sidestep the so-called cultivation bias: the fact that only a few percent of microbes from natural communities have been grown and studied in a laboratory. Indeed the recent discovery of phototrophy among the phylum Acidobacteria (Bryant et al., 2007) was founded on analysis of a Yellowstone metagenome sequencing project. Environmental sequencing was also used to demonstrate the abundance of rhodopsin-based phototrophy in the oceans (Béjà et al., 2000). This has been borne out in large-scale metagenomics of plankton in the Sargasso Sea (Venter et al., 2004) and other marine samples taken as part of the ongoing Global Ocean Survey (GOS) (Yooseph et al., 2007). These data underscore the remarkable phenotypic diversity that has yet to be characterized in the laboratory. For instance, the GOS dataset contains several hundred homologs of genes encoding the purple reaction center subunits. Homologs to known marine strains are particularly abundant, but the reaction center proteins of nearly every phototrophic proteobacterium discussed in this chapter has multiple close homologs in the GOS data. Beyond the enormous repository of marine metagenomes, a growing number of projects should provide additional insight into the genetic diversity of
28
Wesley D. Swingley, Robert E. Blankenship and Jason Raymond
phototrophy. These include samples from hot springs, wastewater treatment ponds, hypersaline microbial mats, even soil and sediment samples that receive some solar input. While exciting, these approaches also demand new ways of thinking about experimental validation and follow-through. In many cases, clone libraries are built from small inserts of DNA, typically 3–10 kb in length. If and when truly novel discoveries are sifted out of these enormous datasets, tracing the origin of sequences in these data will be a serious challenge. Small insert libraries will provide, at most, a handful of contextual genes that provide almost no insight into the organism’s physiology. Isolating the genome sequence of a single, specific organism from a complex community is incredibly difficult — though it is amenable with genetic ‘clues’ that would come from higher levels of targeted sequencing. This underscores the importance of either sequencing, or at the very least archiving, large insert (>100 kb) libraries that can provide a more substantial glimpse into the neighborhoods surrounding genes of interest. Ultimately, extrapolating useful information from enormous repositories of ‘letters on a page’ will require unprecedented synergism of genomics with clever new microbiological techniques. Acknowledgments WDS is supported by a Postdoctoral Fellowship for Foreign Researchers from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science. Work on the evolution of photosynthesis by REB has been supported by a grant from the Exobiology program from NASA. References Ashida H, Danchin A and Yokota A (2005) Was photosynthetic rubisco recruited by acquisitive evolution from rubisco-like proteins involved in sulfur metabolism? Res Microbiol 156: 611–618 Bauer CE, Elsen S, Swem LR, Swem DL and Masuda S (2003) Redox and light regulation of gene expression in photosynthetic prokaryotes. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 358: 147–154 Beatty JT (2002) On the natural selection and evolution of the aerobic phototrophic bacteria. Photosynth Res 73: 109–114 Béjà O, Aravind L, Koonin EV, Suzuki MT, Hadd A, Nguyen LP, Jovanovich SB, Gates CM, Feldman RA, Spudich JL, Spudich EN and DeLong EF (2000) Bacterial rhodopsin: Evidence for a new type of phototrophy in the sea. Science 289: 1902–1906 Bryant DA, Garcia Costas AM, Maresca JA, Chew AGM,
Klatt CG, Bateson MM, Tallon LJ, Hostetler J, Nelson WC, Heidelberg JF and Ward DM (2007) Candidatus Chloracidobacterium thermophilum: An aerobic phototrophic acidobacterium. Science 317: 523–526 Buchan A, Gonzalez J and Moran MA (2005) Overview of the marine Roseobacter lineage. Appl Environ Microbiol 71: 5665–5677 Choudhary M, Zanhua X, Fu YX and Kaplan S (2007) Genome analyses of three strains of Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Evidence of rapid evolution of chromosome II. J Bacteriol 189: 1914–1921 Fleischmann RD, Adams MD, White O, Clayton RA, Kirkness EF, Kerlavage AR, Bult CJ, Tomb JF, Dougherty BA, Merrick JM, McKenney K, Sutton G, Fitzhugh W, Fields C, Gocayne JD, Scott J, Shirley R, Liu LI, Glodek A, Kelley JM, Weidman JF, Phillips CA, Spriggs T, Hedblom E, Cotton MD, Utterback TR, Hanna MC, Nguyen DT, Saudek DM, Brandon RC, Fine LD, Fritchman JL, Fuhrmann JL, Geoghagen NSM, Gnehm CL, McDonald LA, Small KV, Fraser CM, Smith HO and Venter JC (1995) Whole-genome random sequencing and assembly of Haemophilus influenzae Rd. Science 269: 496–512 Fuchs BM, Spring S, Teeling H, Quast C, Wulf J, Schattenhofer M, Yan S, Ferriera S, Johnson J, Glockner FO and Amann R (2007) Characterization of a marine gammaproteobacterium capable of aerobic anoxygenic photosynthesis. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 104: 2891–2896 Gadagkar SR, Rosenberg MS and Kumar S (2005) Inferring species phylogenies from multiple genes: Concatenated sequence tree versus consensus gene tree. J Exp Zoolog B Mol Dev Evol 304B: 64–74 Giraud E, Moulin L, Vallenet D, Barbe V, Cytryn E, Avarre J-C, Jaubert M, Simon D, Cartieaux F, Prin Y, Bena G, Hannibal L, Fardoux J, Kojadinovic M, Vuillet L, Lajus A, Cruveiller S, Rouy Z, Mangenot S, Segurens B, Dossat C, Franck WL, Chang W-S, Saunders E, Bruce D, Richardson P, Normand P, Dreyfus B, Pignol D, Stacey G, Emerich D, Verméglio A, Medigue C and Sadowsky M (2007) Legumes symbioses: Absence of nod genes in photosynthetic Bradyrhizobia. Science 316: 1307–1312 Hanson TE and Tabita FR (2001) A ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (RubisCO)-like protein from Chlorobium tepidum that is involved with sulfur metabolism and the response to oxidative stress. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 98: 4397–4402 Harashima K, Nakagawa M and Murata N (1982) Photochemical activities of bacteriochlorophyll in aerobically grown cells of aerobic heterotrophs, Erythrobacter species (Och 114) and Erythrobacter longus (Och 101). Plant Cell Physiol 23: 185–193 Hiraishi A and Shimada K (2001) Aerobic anoxygenic photosynthetic bacteria with zinc-bacteriochlorophyll. J Gen Appl Microbiol 47: 161–180 Igarashi N, Harada J, Nagashima S, Matsuura K, Shimada K and Nagashima KVP (2001) Horizontal transfer of the photosynthesis gene cluster and operon rearrangement in purple bacteria. J Mol Evol 52: 333–341 Imhoff JF, Hiraishi A and Suling J (2005) Anoxygenic phototrophic purple bacteria. In: Brenner DJ, Krieg NR and Staley JT (eds) Bergey’s Manual of Systematic Bacteriology, pp 119–132. Springer, New York Imhoff JF and Süling J (1996) The phylogenetic relationship
Chapter 2
Evolution of Purple Bacteria
among Ectothiorhodospiraceae: A reevaluation of their taxonomy on the basis of 16S rDNA analyses. Arch Microbiol 165: 106–113 Imker HJ, Fedorov AA, Fedorov EV, Almo SC and Gerlt JA (2007) Mechanistic diversity in the rubisco superfamily: The ‘enolase’ in the methionine salvage pathway in Geobacillus kaustophilus. Biochemistry 46: 4077–4089 Jacob F and Monod J (1961) On regulation of gene activity. Cold Spring Harb Symp Quant Biol 26: 193 Kaneko T, Nakamura Y, Sato S, Minamisawa K, Uchiumi T, Sasamoto S, Watanabe A, Idesawa K, Iriguchi M, Kawashima K, Kohara M, Matsumoto M, Shimpo S, Tsuruoka H, Wada T, Yamada M and Tabata S (2002) Complete genomic sequence of nitrogen-fixing symbiotic bacterium Bradyrhizobium japonicum USDA110. DNA Res 9: 189–197 Kiley PJ and Kaplan S (1988) Molecular genetics of photosynthetic membrane biosynthesis in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Microbiol Mol Biol Rev 52: 50–69 Kolber ZS, Plumley FG, Lang AS, Beatty JT, Blankenship RE, VanDover CL, Vetriani C, Koblizek M, Rathgeber C and Falkowski PG (2001) Contribution of aerobic photoheterotrophic bacteria to the carbon cycle in the ocean. Science 292: 2492–2495 Larimer FW, Chain P, Hauser L, Lamerdin J, Malfatti S, Do L, Land ML, Pelletier DA, Beatty JT, Lang AS, Tabita FR, Gibson JL, Hanson TE, Bobst C, Torres J, Peres C, Harrison FH, Gibson J and Harwood CS (2004) Complete genome sequence of the metabolically versatile photosynthetic bacterium Rhodopseudomonas palustris. Nat Biotechnol 22: 55–61 Lawrence JG (2003) Gene organization: Selection, selfishness, and serendipity. Annu Rev Microbiol 57: 419–440 Lawrence JG and Roth JR (1996) Selfish operons: Horizontal transfer may drive the evolution of gene clusters. Genetics 143: 1843–1860 Mackenzie C, Choudhary M, Larimer F, Predki P, Stilwagen S, Armitage J, Barber R, Donohue T, Hosler J, Newman J, Shapleigh J, Sockett R, Zeilstra-Ryalls J and Kaplan S (2001) The home stretch, a first analysis of the nearly completed genome of Rhodobacter sphaeroides 2.4.1. Photosynth Res 70: 19–41 Nagashima KVP, Shimada K and Matsuura K (1993) Phylogenetic analysis of photosynthetic genes of Rhodocyclus gelatinosus — possibility of horizontal gene-transfer in purple bacteria. Photosynth Res 36: 185–191 Nagashima KVP, Hiraishi A, Shimada K and Matsuura K (1997) Horizontal transfer of genes coding for the photosynthetic reaction centers of purple bacteria. J Mol Evol 45: 131–136 Nakatsu CH, Hristova K, Hanada S, Meng X-Y, Hanson JR, Scow KM and Kamagata Y (2006) Methylibium petroleiphilum gen. nov., sp. nov., a novel methyl tert-butyl ether-degrading methylotroph of the Betaproteobacteria. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 56: 983–989 Pál C and Hurst LD (2004) Evidence against the selfish operon theory. Trends Genet 20: 232–234 Price MN, Huang KH, Arkin AP and Alm EJ (2005) Operon formation is driven by co-regulation and not by horizontal gene transfer. Genome Res 15: 809–819 Shiba T and Harashima K (1986) Aerobic photosynthetic bacteria. Microbiol Sci 3: 376–378 Shiba T, Simidu U and Taga N (1979) Distribution of aerobic bacteria which contain bacteriochlorophyll a. Appl Environ Microbiol 38: 43–45
29 Swingley WD, Sadekar S, Mastrian SD, Matthies HJ, Hao J, Ramos H, Acharya CR, Conrad AL, Taylor HL, Dejesa LC, Shah MK, O’Huallachain ME, Lince MT, Blankenship RE, Beatty JT and Touchman JW (2007) The complete genome sequence of Roseobacter denitrificans reveals a mixotrophic rather than photosynthetic metabolism. J Bacteriol 189: 683–690 Tabita FR (1999) Microbial ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase: A different perspective. Photosynth Res 60: 1–28 Tabita FR, Hanson TE, Li H, Satagopan S, Singh J and Chan S (2007) Function, structure, and evolution of the RubisCO-like proteins and their RubisCO homologs. Microbiol Mol Biol Rev 71: 576–599 Venter JC, Remington K, Heidelberg JF, Halpern AL, Rusch D, Eisen JA, Wu D, Paulsen I, Nelson KE, Nelson W, Fouts DE, Levy S, Knap AH, Lomas MW, Nealson K, White O, Peterson J, Hoffman J, Parsons R, Baden-Tillson H, Pfannkoch C, Rogers Y-H and Smith HO (2004) Environmental genome shotgun sequencing of the Sargasso Sea. Science 304: 66–74 Watson GMF and Tabita FR (1997) Microbial ribulose 1,5bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase: A molecule for phylogenetic and enzymological investigation. FEMS Microbiol Lett 146: 13–22 Wellington CL and Beatty JT (1991) Overlapping mRNA transcripts of photosynthesis gene operons in Rhodobacter capsulatus. J Bacteriol 173: 1432–1443 Willems A, Munive A, de Lajudie P and Gillis M (2003) In most Bradyrhizobium groups sequence comparison of 16S-23S rDNA internal transcribed spacer regions corroborates DNADNA hybridizations. Syst Appl Microbiol 26: 203–210 Xiong J, Inoue K and Bauer CE (1998) Tracking molecular evolution of photosynthesis by characterization of a major photosynthesis gene cluster from Heliobacillus mobilis. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 95: 14851–14856 Yooseph S, Sutton G, Rusch DB, Halpern AL, Williamson SJ, Remington K, Eisen JA, Heidelberg KB, Manning G, Li W, Jaroszewski L, Cieplak P, Miller CS, Li H, Mashiyama ST, Joachimiak MP, van Belle C, Chandonia J-M, Soergel DA, Zhai Y, Natarajan K, Lee S, Raphael BJ, Bafna V, Friedman R, Brenner SE, Godzik A, Eisenberg D, Dixon JE, Taylor SS, Strausberg RL, Frazier M and Venter JC (2007) The Sorcerer II Global Ocean Sampling expedition: Expanding the universe of protein families. PLoS Biol 5: e16 Yurkov V and van Gemerden H (1993) Impact of light/dark regime on growth rate, biomass formation and bacteriochlorophyll synthesis in Erythromicrobium hydrolyticum. Arch Microbiol 159: 84–89 Yurkov VV and Beatty JT (1998) Aerobic anoxygenic phototrophic bacteria. Microbiol Mol Biol Rev 62: 695–724 Yurkov VV and Csotonyi JT (2003) Aerobic anoxygenic phototrophs and heavy metal reducers from extreme environments. In: Pandalai SG (ed) Recent Research Developments in Bacteriology, pp 247–300. Transworld Research Network, Trivandrum, India Yutin N, Suzuki MT, Teeling H, Weber M, Venter JC, Rusch DB and Béjà O (2007) Assessing diversity and biogeography of aerobic anoxygenic phototrophic bacteria in surface waters of the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans using the Global Ocean Sampling expedition metagenomes. Environ Microbiol 9: 1464–1475
Chapter 3 New Light on Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs Vladimir Yurkov* and Julius T. Csotonyi Department of Microbiology, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada R3T 2N2
Summary ................................................................................................................................................................. 31 I. Introduction....................................................................................................................................................... 32 II. Morphological Diversity, Taxonomic Nuances, Phylogeny and Evolution ........................................................ 34 A. Morphological Richness ..................................................................................................................... 34 B. Taxonomic Diversity ........................................................................................................................... 34 C. Persistent Taxonomic-Phylogenetic Tangles ..................................................................................... 37 D. Evolution ............................................................................................................................................ 38 III. Nutritional Versatility and Peculiarities of Carbon Metabolism ......................................................................... 40 A. Carbon Sources ................................................................................................................................. 40 B. Alternative Electron Donors and Acceptors........................................................................................ 41 IV. Photosynthetic Pigment Composition and Synthesis Reveal Surprises........................................................... 41 A. Carotenoids ........................................................................................................................................ 41 B. Bacteriochlorophyll ............................................................................................................................. 42 C. Highly Evolved Regulation of Pigment Synthesis .............................................................................. 42 V. The Mysterious Photosynthetic Apparatus of Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs.............................................. 44 A. The Reaction Center of Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs Has Purple Bacterial Roots ..................... 44 B. Light-Harvesting Complexes: Ordinary and Extraordinary ................................................................. 45 C. The Riddle of Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophy................................................................................. 46 VI. Speculation on Ecological Roles ...................................................................................................................... 47 A. Technical Challenges of Enumerating Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs .......................................... 47 B. Ocean Surface ................................................................................................................................... 47 C. Vertical Distribution of Deep Ocean Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs .............................................. 50 D. Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs Thrive in Extreme Environments ................................................... 51 E. Soil and Freshwater ........................................................................................................................... 51 VII. Concluding Remarks and Perspectives ........................................................................................................... 51 Acknowledgments ................................................................................................................................................... 52 References .............................................................................................................................................................. 52
Summary Discovered 30 years ago, aerobic anoxygenic phototrophs (AAP) represent an entirely new bacterial functional group that was surprisingly found to constitute nearly 10% of microbial cells in the world’s biggest surface ecosystem, the ocean. These intriguing and colorful descendents of anaerobic anoxygenic phototrophs possess a fully functional photosynthetic apparatus that is paradoxically operative only under oxic conditions. An obviously ancient group, the AAP display numerous extensive evolutionary modifications to their photosynthetic machinery from that of their ancestors, such as different suites of light-harvesting 2 complexes and, in some *Author for correspondence, email: [email protected]
C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty (eds): The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria, pp. 31–55. © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V.
32
Vladimir Yurkov and Julius T. Csotonyi
species, the only zinc-based chlorophyll pigments found anywhere in nature. Whereas AAP are incapable of photoautotrophy and rely on heterotrophy for 80% or more of their cellular energetics, sunlight can double organic carbon assimilatory efficiency over that of strict heterotrophs, making AAP key players in the marine carbon cycle. The AAP inhabit not just soil, rivers and oceans, but also hypersaline waters, thermal springs and even the dark realm of deep ocean hydrothermal vents. Ubiquity and atypical photosynthetic nature has inspired an ever-increasing scientific interest in the AAP, for which there are more exceptions than rules. I. Introduction It is astonishing that a bacterial functional group constituting nearly a tenth of microorganisms in the earth’s largest surface ecosystem, the ocean, could have been overlooked until 1978. Yet, this unlikely tale describes obligately aerobic anoxygenic phototrophs (AAP), which have long lain hidden beneath the shortsighted assumption that anoxygenic photosynthesis, originally evolving to generate metabolic energy from light in reducing Proterozoic environments, has for the past 3.5 billion years remained an exclusively anoxic process. Oxygen does generally repress synthesis of the bacteriochlorophyll (BChl)-containing photosynthetic apparatus in conventional anoxygenic phototrophs, relegating purple, green and heliobacterial light-harvesting to illuminated zones of anaerobic habitats such as stratified lakes and sulfide springs (Pfennig, 1978). However, O2 release by cyanobacteria ~2.5 GYa exerted sufficient selection pressure for an aerobic counterpart to evolve (Beatty, 2002). Indeed, Japanese scientists’ intuitive leap to search for such organisms was met with immediate success (Shiba et al., 1979). Since then, description of new species has increased in pace (Fig. 1A). AAP have turned up in practically every environment probed for them, including rivers, soil, acidic mine drainage, hypersaline springs, nutrient-rich microbial mats, oligotrophic ocean surface waters, and even near marine hydrothermal vents (Yurkov and Csotonyi, Abbreviations: AAP – aerobic anoxygenic phototrophs; BChl – bacteriochlorophyll; Cmi. – Citromicrobium; Cyt – cytochrome; D – Dinoroseobacter; DMSP – dimethylsulfoniopropionate; E. – Erythromicrobium; Erb. – Erythrobacter; GYa – 109 years ago; H. – Hoeflea; IREM – infrared epifluorescence microscopy; IRFRR – infrared fast repetition rate fluorometry; LH – lightharvesting; PEP – phosphoenol pyruvate; PSU – photosynthetic unit; QPCR – quantitative polymerase chain reaction; Qy – electronic transition of BChl a from ground state to lowest excited singlet state; R. – Roseicyclus; Rba. – Rhodobacter; RC – reaction center; Rps. – Rhodopseudomonas; Rsc. – Roseococcus; Rst. – Roseateles; Rubisco – ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase; Rva – Roseovarius; S. – Stappia; Srb. – Sandaracinobacter; Stl. – Staleya; TMAO – trimethylamine N-oxide
2003). Comprehensive reviews have already set the groundwork for an introduction to the AAP (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998; Hiraishi and Shimada, 2001; Yurkov, 2006; Yurkov and Csotonyi, 2003; Rathgeber et al., 2004). However, the veritable explosion of research on this group during the last four years justifies both a synthesis of exciting new findings and suggestion of new investigative directions. Two other branches of bacteria produce BChl exclusively aerobically: photosynthetic methylotrophs such as Methylobacterium extorquens, and photosynthetic rhizobia like Bradyrhizobium denitrificans (van Berkum et al., 2006). Distinct metabolic strategies or specialized plant symbioses impart distinct functional group status on these organisms, and they will not be treated further in this chapter. Interested readers are directed to reviews by Komagata (1989) and Giraud and Fleischman (2004). The AAP are primarily chemoheterotrophic Proteobacteria that nonetheless produce a functional purple bacterial photosynthetic reaction center (RC) and one or more peripheral light-harvesting (LH) complexes that can amend heterotrophic energy generation by up to 20% (Kolber et al., 2001; Yurkov and van Gemerden, 1993). As their name implies, they evolve no O2 photosynthetically, because they do not use water for reducing power. Five overarching traits distinguish AAP from classical anoxygenic phototrophs: (1) requirement of O2 for photosynthesis, granting escape from restrictive anaerobic illuminated environments; (2) inhibition, paradoxically, of BChl synthesis by light; (3) absence of the Calvin cycle and inability to subsist on inorganic carbon; (4) much lower number of photosynthetic units (PSU) per cell; but (5) great abundance of carotenoids (Yurkov and Csotonyi, 2003; Rathgeber et al., 2004). With such a peculiar mixture of characteristics, where do the mysterious yet functionally and numerically significant AAP fit into our conception of the microbial world? On one hand, they are typical proteobacterial cells, constructed from the same building blocks as their relatives, expressing no earth-shatteringly novel metabolic modes, possess-
Chapter 3
Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs
33
Fig. 1. Taxonomic richness and phylogeny of AAP. A. Cumulative growth in number of described genera over 24 years. B. Neighborjoining phylogenetic tree of AAP and select nonphototrophs (marked with asterisks) based on 16S rDNA sequences. Scale bar, 10% substitution rate. Bootstrap values at branch points are based on 500 resamplings. Phylogenetic tree was prepared by E. Stackebrandt and J. Swiderski.
34 ing typical cell walls, synthesizing mostly trivial pigments and electron carriers, etc. On the other hand, evolutionary forces have combined some of these common components in chimeric ways, permitting anoxygenic phototrophy to function under conditions contrary to those for which it originally evolved, thus opening for exploitation huge niches not available to their ancestors. This principal evolutionary development necessarily caused cascades of corollary adaptations, such as major changes to the regulation of photosynthetic pigment synthesis, and proliferation of photoprotective carotenoids. In the end, the peculiar AAP display more exceptions than rules in form and function. II. Morphological Diversity, Taxonomic Nuances, Phylogeny and Evolution A. Morphological Richness The AAP are morphologically as well rounded as are their anaerobic relatives, even expressing properties unique among bacteria (Fig. 2). Pleomorphism is common in the Erythrobacter clade. Erythromicrobium (E.) ramosum was named for its propensity to produce branches (Fig. 2A), while Citromicrobium (Cmi.) bathyomarinum forms unusual Y-cells during trinary division (Yurkov and Csotonyi, 2003) (Fig. 2B). Rathgeber et al. (2005) reported the first AAP that can form cyclical cells, Roseicyclus (R.) mahoneyensis (Fig. 2C), reminiscent of Rhodocyclus purpureus (Pfennig, 1978), to which it is only distantly related. Uncultured spirilloid cells ascribed to AAP have turned up in the Sargasso Sea (Sieracki et al., 2006). Cell accessories and intercellular connective structures provoke further interest, especially ecologically. Pleomorphic Porphyrobacter neustonensis and Porphyrobacter meromictius produce appendages, perhaps enhancing intake of nutrients by maximizing surface-to-volume ratio (Fig. 2D) (Yurkova et al., 2002; Rathgeber et al., 2007). More interestingly, cell chains are connected via bubble-like formations with a central tubular structure, an arrangement heretofore unobserved in the domain Bacteria (Fig. 2E) (Yurkova et al., 2002; Rathgeber et al., 2007). Bubble-like membranous connective structures are also seen between cells of Cmi. bathyomarinum (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998). The relevance of these structures is unknown. Perhaps they facilitate mate-
Vladimir Yurkov and Julius T. Csotonyi rial exchange between cells. Several members of the α-2, α-3 and α-4 Proteobacteria, including Staleya (Stl.) guttiformis, Stappia (S.) marina, Roseovarius (Rva.) mucosus, Roseisalinus antarcticus and deep ocean strain C8 (Fig. 2F) form star-shaped rosettes of cells, joined by unknown means (Biebl et al., 2005a; Labrenz et al., 2005; Kim et al., 2006). The taxonomically unassigned meromictic lake strains BL7 and BL14, however, form the most impressive rosettes, 10 µm or more in diameter and resembling dandelion heads (Fig. 2G) or even brain coral (Fig. 2H), in which cells are linked by a polar hook-like structure (Fig. 2I) (Rathgeber et al., 2004). Interestingly, all of these rosette-forming species except S. marina and C8 are meromictic lake isolates, suggesting that aggregation may bestow an ecological advantage, such as buoyancy regulation, a useful feature in lake habitats where salinity varies with depth. Alternately, the convoluted surface of rosettes may assist in trapping particulate nutrients. B. Taxonomic Diversity AAP are dispersed throughout the Alphaproteobacteria, with one known betaproteobacterial representative, Roseateles (Rst.) depolymerans (Fig. 1B) (Yurkov and Csotonyi, 2003) and a recently described gammaproteobacterial species, Congregibacter litoralis (Fuchs et al., 2007). Thus far, alphaproteobacterial species occur in five cohesive clusters, in all four subclasses. Soil, hot spring and acidophilic isolates define the α-1 cluster, consisting of Acidiphilium, Acidisphaera, Craurococcus, Geminicoccus, Paracraurococcus, Roseococcus and Rubritepida. The exclusively marine α-2 species form two unrelated branches, the first containing Labrenzia, Roseibium and S. marina, the second Hoeflea (H.) phototrophica. The oceanic or halophilic α-3 Roseobacter clade, allied closely with purple nonsulfur Rhodobacter and Rhodovulum, includes Dinoroseobacter, Roseibacterium, Roseicyclus, Roseinatronobacter, Roseisalinus, Roseivivax, Roseobacter, Roseovarius, Rubrimonas, Staleya and Thalassobacter. Finally, Blastomonas natatoria, Citromicrobium, Erythrobacter, Erythromicrobium, Erythromonas, Sandaracinobacter and Sandarakinorhabdus represent the α-4 AAP, hailing from diverse freshwater and marine habitats. Citromicrobium, Erythrobacter, Erythromicrobium and Porphyrobacter form a clade so cohesive that 16S rDNA sequence analysis is often insufficient to place species into proper genera, generic assignment rely-
Chapter 3
Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs
35
Fig. 2. Morphological diversity of AAP. A. Branching in Erythromicrobium ramosum. B. Y-cell of Citromicrobium bathyomarinum. C. Tightly curved vibroid cells of Roseicyclus mahoneyensis. D. Appendage (arrow) of Porphyrobacter meromictius. E. Tube-in-bubble type of intercellular connections of Porphyrobacter meromictius. F. Rosettes of cells in strain C8. G. Dandelion head-like rosettes of strain BL7. H. Brain coral-like rosettes of strain BL14. I. Hooked appendage of strain BL14. C, F, G, H. Phase contrast micrographs. A, B, C (inset), D, E, I. Electron micrographs. Scale bars 0.25 µm (C inset); 0.5 µm (D, I); 1 µm (A, B, E); 2.5 µm (G, H); 5 µm (C, F).
ing heavily on phenotypic characteristics. Rainey et al. (2003) suggested unification of this cluster under a single genus. Instead of taxonomic abridgement, it is advisable to utilize the phenotypic diversity of this group (e.g., presence/absence of the unique B798-832 LH2 in Erythromicrobium and appendage formation in Porphyrobacter) to assign generic and specific status. Perhaps Porphyrobacter dokdonensis, possessing an 835-nm LH2 absorption peak and lacking appendages (Yoon et al., 2006), should have been placed within Erythromicrobium. Additional powerful phylogenetic analysis techniques, such as 23S rRNA sequence analysis (Peplies et al., 2004) or internal transcribed spacer analysis (Brown and Fuhrman, 2005), may be more phyletically infor-
mative for tight clusters than traditional 16S rDNA sequence analysis. The number of known AAP (currently 52 species in 33 genera) is waxing rapidly (Fig. 1A), with 18 new species described in the last four years (Table 1). H. phototrophica represents the first AAP from the α-2 proteobacterial Phyllobacteriaceae, which also contains rhizobia (Biebl et al., 2006). Meanwhile, R. mahoneyensis is the first inland Roseobacter-clade representative (Rathgeber et al., 2005). Description of the nearly completely genome-sequenced C. litoralis is extraordinary because not since 1999 has a new proteobacterial subclass been added to the short list that contains AAP (Fuchs et al., 2007). Gathering interest in this group, use of new high-throughput
beige to light red
reddish-brown pink
pinkish-purple to purple pink
red
Sphingomonadaceae (α-4) Erythrobacter aquamaris, 98.1% Rhodobacteraceae (α-3) Marinosulfonomonas methylotropha, 93%, Rhodobacteraceae (α-3) Ketogulonicigenium vulgare, 92.6% Rhodobacteraceae (α-3) Roseinatronobacter thiooxidans, 98.1% Rhodobacteraceae (α-3) Jannaschia helgolandensis, 94%
meromictic lake water, Canada
sand, Shark Bay, Australia
meromictic lake water, Canada
hypersaline lake, USA
meromictic lake water, Antarctica
Roseibacterium elongatum (Suzuki et al., 2006)
Roseicyclus mahoneyensis (Rathgeber et al., 2005)
Roseinatronobacter monicus (Boldareva et al., 2007)
Roseisalinus antarcticus (Labrenz et al., 2005)
Porphyrobacter meromictius (Rathgeber et al., 2007)
reddish-orange
sea water, East Sea, Korea
Porphyrobacter donghaensis (Yoon et al., 2004b)
Sphingomonadaceae (α-4) Erythromicrobium ramosum, 99.0%
sea water, Dokdo, Korea
Porphyrobacter dokdonensis (Yoon et al., 2006)
reddish-orange
hot spring water, Portugal
Porphyrobacter cryptus (Rainey et al., 2003) Sphingomonadaceae (α-4) Porphyrobacter cryptus, 98.7%
dinoflagellate culture, North Sea Rhodobacteraceae (α-2) Stappia alba and Stappia marina, 98.0%
Labrenzia alexandrii (Biebl et al., 2007) reddish-orange
faint pink
dinoflagellate culture, North Sea Phyllobacteriaceae (α-2) Hoeflea marina, 98.5%
Hoeflea phototrophica (Biebl et al., 2006)
Sphingomonadaceae (α-4) Porphyrobacter tepidarius, 98.3%
colorless to pink
marine aquaculture biofilter, Israel
Geminicoccus roseus (Foesel et al., 2007)
Novel clade (α−1) whitish-grey to pink Candidatus “Alysiosphaera europaea,” 90.8%
dinoflagellate culture, North Sea Rhodobacteraceae (α-3) Jannaschia helgolandensis, 94.1%
Dinoroseobacter shibae (Biebl et al., 2005b)
pink
NOR5/OM60 clade (γ)
sea water, North Sea
Congregibacter litoralis 3 (Fuchs et al., 2007)
Color
Habitat, site of isolation
Species (described by)
Phylogenetic affiliation 2
Table 1. Determinative characteristics of novel species of aerobic anoxygenic phototrophs described since 2003 1.
800, 870
801, 865
N.D.
N.D.
804, 868
In vivo BChl peaks (nm) N.D.4
rod
ovoid
pleomorphic: ovoid, long rod, vibrioid, cyclical rod
rod, variable length
short rod or pleomorphic
800-801, 870
804, 870
805-806, 870-871
800, 879
806-808, 866-867
pleomorphic: cocci, ovoid 808, 867 or rod
pleomorphic: cocci, ovoid 800, 835, 862 or rod
short rod
rod, uneven ends
short rod with capsule
diplococci
cocci or ovoid
pleomorphic
Cell shape
36 Vladimir Yurkov and Julius T. Csotonyi
1 New taxa described before 2003 are covered by Yurkov and Beatty (1998), Yurkov and Csotonyi (2003) and Rathgeber et al., (2004). 2 family (nomenclature after Garrity et al., 2005), proteobacterial subclass (in parentheses), nearest 16S rDNA relative, phylogenetic distance to nearest relative; 3 names in bold indicate novel genera. 4 N.D., not determined.
N.D. ovoid to irregular rod salmon-pink Rhodobacteraceae (α-3) Jannaschia helgolandensis, 95.7% Thalassobacter stenotrophicus (Macián et al., 2005)
sea water, Mediterranean Sea
N.D. N.D. rod Rhodobacteraceae (α-2) Stappia aggregata, 98.5% Stappia marina (Kim et al., 2006)
tidal flat, Korea
N.D. rod orange-red soil, South Korea Sphingomonas kaistensis (Kim et al., 2007)
Sphingomonadaceae (α-4) Sphingomonas oligophenolica, 95.8%
800, 837, 865 rod Sandarakinorhabdus limnophila freshwater lake water, Germany Sphingomonadaceae (α-4) Sandaracinobacter sibiricus, 92.8% (Gich and Overmann, 2006)
orange-red
ovoid to rod whitish to faint pink dinoflagellate culture, North Sea Rhodobacteraceae (α-3) Roseovarius tolerans, 96.4% Roseovarius mucosus (Biebl et al., 2005a)
In vivo BChl peaks (nm) N.D. Cell shape Phylogenetic affiliation 2 Habitat, site of isolation Species (described by)
Table 1. Continued
Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs
Color
Chapter 3
37 isolation methods, and the application of phylogenetic techniques to detect photosynthesis genes are responsible for this taxonomical flurry (Gich et al., 2005). Our current delineation of AAP diversity is by no means the end of the taxonomic tale. Sequencing marine photosynthesis genes or their mRNA, Béjà et al. (2002) and Allgaier et al. (2003) detected much higher AAP diversity than suggested by culture-dependent studies. Description of novel lotic β-proteobacterial species is soon anticipated (Waidner and Kirchman, 2005), while procedures facilitating recent isolation of previously uncultivable SAR11 marine bacterioplankton (Rappé et al., 2002) may yield additional elusive γ-proteobacterial AAP. C. Persistent Taxonomic-Phylogenetic Tangles Embedding a thorn in taxonomists’ sides, 16S ribosomal genes of AAP often ally more closely with non-phototrophs than with purple nonsulfur bacteria. This phyletic interspersion still baffles enough researchers that, regrettably, an old argument must be revisited regarding the confusion of taxonomy with phylogeny in the classification of AAP. Taxonomic convention recognizes major metabolic capabilities such as phototrophy as markers to distinguish genera. After all, in spite of the deceptive visual homogeneity of bacteria harboring divergent metabolic strategies, the difference made by possession of a photosynthetic apparatus is as significant as would be the discovery of a fish breathing nitrate rather than oxygen. Yet, since 2002, no less than nine species of BChl-lacking bacteria have been proposed as members of phototrophic genera (Erythrobacter aquamaris, Erythrobacter citreus, Erythrobacter flavus, Erythrobacter gaetbuli, Erythrobacter luteolus, Erythrobacter vulgaris, Roseovarius crassostreae, Roseovarius nubinhibens) (Denner et al., 2002; Yoon et al., 2003, 2004a, 2005a,b; González et al., 2003; Boettcher et al., 2005; Ivanova et al., 2005). Conversely, and despite repeated appeals to the contrary since 1998 (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998), BChl-producing species such as H. phototrophica and S. marina are included in definitively non-phototrophic genera. Ironically, the very phylogenetic analyses sparking original misclassifications, upon closer inspection, support genus-level distinction of BChl-free isolates from true AAP. New non-phototrophic erythrobacters were sufficiently unrelated to phototrophic congener-
38 ics (16S rDNA sequence similarities as low as 94.1% and DNA-DNA reassociation levels often below 10%) to justify erection of new genera (Yoon et al., 2003, 2004a, 2005a). Similarly, non-phototrophic Rva. nubinhibens and Rva. crassostreae can clearly be differentiated from the phototrophic Roseovarius cluster by specific signature nucleotides at several positions of the secondary structure of the 16S rRNA gene (Biebl et al., 2005a). Judicious phylogenetic analysis supports the repeated insistence by the International Committee on Systematic Bacteriology that phenotypic traits should remain important criteria in delineation of genera (Wayne et al., 1987; Murray et al., 1990; Stackebrandt et al., 2002). Phylogenetic analysis is not sufficiently advanced for consensus on the use of a standard suite of purely genetic techniques for resolution of both macro- and microdiversity, and thus it remains inappropriate to use phylogenetic relatedness as a sole or overriding determinative factor in assigning taxonomic status. Errors are occasionally corrected by reclassifying miscategorized species — see Yurkov and Csotonyi (2003) for examples — but lamentably, some new papers still contain the original misnomers and cite erroneous papers as major references. For instance, Boettcher et al. (2005) alluded to ‘Roseobacter gallaciensis,’ which was long ago reclassified as Ruegeria gallaciensis (Uchino et al., 1998). Clearly, reviewers and editors of premier bacterial systematics journals must exercise greater discrimination when considering proposals of taxonomic placement to avoid subsequent confusion from rearrangements necessary to correct taxonomic faux pas. D. Evolution We must distinguish evolution of aerobic anoxygenic phototrophy as a physiological process from the evolutionary history of its phylogenetic distribution among AAP clades. In hindsight, it is not surprising that aerobic anoxygenic phototrophy arose from anaerobic phototrophy after global oxygenation; given life’s rapid niche-occupying tendency, such a transition ought to occur over 2 billion years after the earth’s atmosphere became oxygenated (Rye and Holland, 1998). This question of how such evolution played out still deserves much research effort, but speculation is fruitful. Similarity of the AAP photosynthetic apparatus to that of purple nonsulfur bacteria implicates the latter as ancestors. Probably
Vladimir Yurkov and Julius T. Csotonyi the most serious hurdle for evolution to clear was aerobic phototoxicity (Beatty, 2002). Exposure of BChl to light in the presence of O2 generates highly reactive chemical species called triplet BChl and singlet oxygen, which can cause considerable oxidative damage to cells (Krinsky, 1971; Beatty, 2002). Hence, repression of aerobic BChl synthesis by anaerobic phototrophs in response to global O2 pollution served as much a protective as a resource conservation role. Interestingly, a logical solution to phototoxicity conveniently explains three definitive features of AAP. First, low PSU abundance minimizes generation of triplet BChl and singlet O2 (Beatty, 2002). Second, BChl is only generated during dark periods, when it is safe to do so (Beatty, 2002). This paradoxical trait seems counterintuitive only until photochemistry is considered. Third, synthesis of light-harvesting photoactive carotenoids by anaerobic phototrophs also preadapted their descendents for an aerobic existence. Not only do carotenoids with more than nine conjugated double bonds filter out high-energy radiation, but also their low lying first excited triplet state enables them to efficiently quench the destructive energy of singlet O2 and triplet BChl (Krinsky, 1971; Fraser et al., 2001). AAP needed only to upregulate carotenoid synthesis to achieve better protection from the dangerous combination of light, O2 and BChl — which is exactly what we see, especially for the particularly photoprotective carotenoid sulfates (Krinsky, 1971; Yurkov and Beatty, 1998). In light of the inherent self-limitation of aerobic phototrophic energy generation, AAP have understandably lost the energetically expensive Calvin cycle for carbon fixation, relying instead on heterotrophy. Beyond explaining their appearance as a functional group, however, phylogenetic interspersion of AAP with non-phototrophs seriously challenges evolutionary microbiologists wishing to trace the phylogenetic roots of each clade. Unfortunately, genetic research has found that many of the pieces of this evolutionary puzzle do not fit snugly. There is little doubt that AAP are polyphyletic at the level of the 16S rRNA gene. However a battle ensues between two opposing views: (1) that phototrophy is ancestral in Proteobacteria, with non-phototrophs such as Paracoccus or Ketogulonicigenium arising through loss of photosynthesis, and (2) that aerobic photosynthetic genes were transferred laterally to unrelated non-phototrophs (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998). The argument hinges on the relative topologies of ribosomal and photosyn-
Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs C
B Absorbance
A
39
Absorbance
Chapter 3
869
857
804
799
400
500
600
700
800
900
1000
400
500
D
E
600
700
800
900
1000
Wavelength (nm)
Wavelength (nm)
P870*
F
Absorbance
BChl BPh
+
QA
E0'
868 836
cyt bc1
799
cyt c2 400
500
600
700
800
900
1000
P870
Wavelength (nm)
G
H
I
Fig. 3. Photosynthetic and habitat diversity of aerobic anoxygenic phototrophs (AAP). A–E. In vivo absorbance spectra of cells grown under different physiological conditions, with numerals above peaks denoting LH and RC wavelengths. Insets, photographs of liquid cultures. A. Roseicyclus mahoneyensis, illuminated (dashed line) and dark (solid line). B,C. Dashed line, rich organic medium (3 g·l–1 organics); solid line, minimal acetate (1 g·l–1) medium (B. Roseococcus thiosulfatophilus, C. Erythrobacter litoralis). D. Erythromicrobium ramosum, rich organic medium, dark (dashed line) and oligotrophic medium, light:dark regimen of 12h:12h, illuminated with diffuse ambient sunlight (solid line). E. Citromicrobium bathyomarinum strain JF1, rich organic medium (dashed line), minimal glucose medium (dotted line), compared with Erythrobacter litoralis (solid line). F. Hypothetical electron transfer system of aerobic anoxygenic photosynthesis, showing electron flow through major carriers: P870, special pair of BChl in RC (photoexcited state indicated by ‘*’); BChl-BPh, accessory BChl and bacteriopheophytin in RC; QA, quinone primary electron acceptor; cyt bc1, cytochrome bc1 complex; cyt c2, cytochrome c2. The symbol ‘+’ indicates that the midpoint potential of QA in all tested AAP is positive and higher than in anaerobic phototrophs. G–I. Extreme environment habitats of AAP. G. Hydrothermal vent field in Eastern Pacific Ocean, showing smoker chimney. H. Hypersaline spring system (East German Creek) in Manitoba, Canada: spring pool in foreground and playa in background, with white patches of salt precipitates. I. Cyanobacterial-Thiothrix mat development in thermal springs of Banff National Park, Alberta, Canada. See also Color Plate 2, Fig. 2.
thetic phylogenetic trees, and on the diversity of the aerobic photosynthetic apparatus. The answer probably lies between opposing schools of thought: loss of phototrophy may account for close non-phototrophic relatives, and lateral gene transfer for the rise of a few
AAP clades. Ribosomal and pufL (the gene encoding the L subunit of the photosynthetic reaction center) cladistic trees agree topologically at the highest level of similarity (such as the Erythrobacter clade), but a few deep incongruities exist (Allgaier et al., 2003).
40 Both α-3 Staleya and β-proteobacterial Roseateles possess pufL genes characteristic of α-4 Erythrobacter (Allgaier et al., 2003). Even more surprising are three marine strains, HTCC2080, HTCC2148 and HTCC2246, which, despite forming a tight 16S rDNA gammaproteobacterial cluster in the NOR5/OM60 clade, possess pufL genes of gammaproteobacterial, α-1 and α-2 proteobacterial affiliation, respectively (Cho et al., 2007). Other studies (Béjà et al., 2002; Oz et al., 2005) have underscored the observed interspersion of photosynthesis genes among different clades, but the emerging picture is complicated, the pattern of interspersion depending on the gene that is sequenced. For example, unlike pufL, the pufM gene of Rst. depolymerans clusters more closely with those of other Betaproteobacteria rather than with those of Erythrobacter (Béjà et al., 2002). It remains to be explained how such a linked gene pair as pufL and pufM can exhibit such phylogenetic topological variety. Furthermore, although the plasmid pBLM2 was used to mobilize the entire photosynthesis gene cluster of Rhodobacter capsulatus, pBLM2 did not induce functional pigment expression in Escherichia coli (Marrs, 1981). Thus, lateral photosynthetic gene transfer might occur successfully only between bacteria that are already phototrophic, possibly because specific membrane configurations are prerequisite for functional photosynthetic machinery (Marrs, 1981). Adding a further twist, the apparent α-proteobacterial origin of the entire 37-kb photosynthetic gene cluster of the β-proteobacterial anoxygenic phototroph Rubrivivax gelatinosus (an anaerobic 16S rDNA close relative of Rst. depolymerans) (Igarashi et al., 2001), implies multiple independent origins of aerobic phototrophy, as Rst. depolymerans probably evolved from a Rubrivivax gelatinosus-like ancestor. Moreover, the difference of LH2 complexes of AAP both from each other and from those of anaerobic phototrophs (see Section V.B.) also implicates multiple origins of aerobic phototrophy even within Alphaproteobacteria. As an attempt to synthesize these arguments into perhaps the most accurate picture of AAP evolution, we suggest that each major AAP clade evolved separately from a different purple nonsulfur bacterial branch. Moderate gene shuffling then occurred only among these phototrophs, and non-phototrophic Proteobacteria arose through loss of phototrophy, as proposed by Woese (1987).
Vladimir Yurkov and Julius T. Csotonyi III. Nutritional Versatility and Peculiarities of Carbon Metabolism A. Carbon Sources Metabolic diversity in AAP is extremely great, as expected for a functional group relying exclusively on heterotrophy for carbon needs. Erythrobacter, Erythromicrobium, Porphyrobacter, Roseicyclus, Roseobacter and Sandaracinobacter are able to grow on most carbon sources tested, including organic acids, carbohydrates, alcohols and complex organics (Yurkov and Csotonyi, 2003). However, some species are more specialized, with a second cluster (deep ocean Citromicrobium; meromictic Mahoney Lake strains ML15, ML17, ML35; Manitoba hypersaline spring strains EG4, EG6 and EG15) growing best on complex organics and on only a few defined carbon sources (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998; Yurkova et al., 2002; Csotonyi and Yurkov, unpublished). Most intriguingly, a third cluster (e.g., Mahoney Lake strains ML37, ML47; Manitoba hypersaline spring strain EG12) requires yeast extract or casamino acids, and subsists on no known defined medium (Yurkova et al., 2002; Csotonyi and Yurkov, unpublished). These species may be adapted to utilizing specific carbon sources produced by organisms or geological processes exclusive to their native environment, and they likely evolved locally by sympatric speciation based on metabolic niche differentiation. Endemism may explain the diversity of AAP in isolated habitats such as meromictic lakes or hypersaline springs. Certain carbon sources exploited by AAP bear ecological significance. Much recent attention focuses on dimethylsulfoniopropionate (DMSP), an osmolyte produced by algae and an important marine store of sulfur. The prominent role of Roseobacter relatives in DMSP consumption by cleavage or demethylation and dethiolation, and the resulting liberation of sulfide or climate-influencing dimethyl sulfide, implicates them as key modulators of the marine sulfur cycle (Wagner-Döbler and Biebl, 2006). The next significant step will be discrimination of BChl-containing obligately aerobic representatives from strict heterotrophs, because phylogenetic and [35S]DMSP-incorporation studies alone cannot distinguish phototrophs from non-phototrophs. Photoautotrophic CO2 fixation is lacking in all physiologically tested AAP, with both enzymological and full genome sequence studies (for Roseobacter
Chapter 3
Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs
(Rsb.) denitrificans and C. litoralis) confirming the absence of the key Calvin cycle enzyme ribulose1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998; Fuchs et al., 2007; Swingley et al., 2007). However, nonexistence of autotrophy in AAP need not contradict the finding of a low level of CO2 fixation in Acidiphilium rubrum, Erythrobacter longus, Rsb. denitrificans, Sandaracinobacter sibiricus and other AAP (Kolber et al., 2001; Rathgeber et al., 2004). All heterotrophs anaplerotically fix CO2 (at efficiencies of 1–4% of that expressed by autotrophs) via phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) carboxylase, a key respiratory enzyme that replaces organic acids sequestered from the citric acid cycle by other biochemical pathways. Light-stimulated citric acid cycle reversal may also account for some carbon fixation (Rathgeber et al., 2004). B. Alternative Electron Donors and Acceptors Although most AAP appear to rely on reduced carbon compounds as electron donors, a few species reflect anaerobic phototrophic ancestry by oxidizing reduced sulfur sources. Interestingly, most S-oxidizers belong to the α-1 proteobacterial lineage (e.g., Acidiphillium acidophilum, Roseococcus (Rsc.) thiosulfatophilus and Rubritepida flocculens). The latter two species, as well as Roseinatronobacter thiooxidans and Roseinatronobacter monicus, oxidize thiosulfate (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998; Yurkov and Csotonyi, 2003; Boldareva et al., 2007), whereas Acidiphilium acidophilum oxidizes elemental S via glutathione at a rate nine to fourteen times as high as that of the lithoautotroph, Acidithiobacillus thiooxidans (Rohwerder and Sand, 2003). Most AAP are described as obligately aerobic, but some species are capable of anaerobic chemoheterotrophic growth, substituting O2 with alternate electron acceptors. Dinoroseobacter (D.) shibae can dissimilatorily reduce nitrate, and Rsb. denitrificans reduces nitrate, nitrite and trimethylamine N-oxide (TMAO), a common odoriferous byproduct of decomposing marine organisms (Yurkov and Csotonyi, 2003; Biebl et al., 2005b). Even more interesting, and of bioremediative value, is the pH-elevating effect of dissimilatory Fe3+-reduction by A. acidophilum, perhaps key to facilitating transition of mine drainage systems from acidic to neutral conditions (Marchand and Silverstein, 2003).
41 IV. Photosynthetic Pigment Composition and Synthesis Reveal Surprises A. Carotenoids A ubiquitous feature of AAP is their diverse range of intense colors, conferred by abundant carotenoids. Colors span the spectrum from watermelon red to brown, orange, yellow, pink, purple and intermediates (Fig. 3A-E and Color Plate 2). Most interestingly, in contrast to the light-harvesting function of carotenoids in anaerobic purple phototrophs, the majority of AAP carotenoids are disengaged from energy transduction, and are distributed evenly throughout the cytoplasmic membrane, cytoplasm and cell wall (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998; Koblížek et al., 2003). The primary purpose of this non-photosynthetic carotenoid pool is uncertain, but preventative or remediative amelioration of phototoxicity is a leading suggestion (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998; Fraser et al., 2001; Beatty, 2002). The photoprotection to which AAP appear to have enlisted the bulk of their carotenoids is reflected not only in up-regulation, but also in extensive structural and compositional modification. Whereas AAP LHbound carotenoids resemble those of anaerobic phototrophs, the LH-dissociated pool displays extreme variety (Fig. 3A–E and Color Plate 2), with E. ramosum possessing about 20 types (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998). Moreover, despite predominance of purple nonsulfur-type spheroidenone and spirilloxanthin in some AAP (e.g., Roseobacter and Acidiphilium), the majority in most species are carotenes, which are more widely distributed among oxygenic than anoxygenic phototrophs and give AAP decidedly more orange hues than in purple nonsulfur bacteria (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998) (Fig. 3A–E and Color Plate 2). Some of these carotenoids are structurally unique among phototrophs (Chapter 6, Takaichi). AAP are especially well-endowed with polar carotenoids, such as the short-chain C30 molecule, 4,4´-diapocarotene-4,4´dioate in Rsc. thiosulfatophilus (Fig. 3B and Color Plate 2), or erythroxanthin sulfate in Erythrobacter and Erythromicrobium (Yurkov and Csotonyi, 2003) (Fig. 3C, D and Color Plate 2). Acquisition of the latter carotenoid, which is particularly antioxidative (Krinsky, 1971), is a logical adaptation to illuminated oxic environments.
42 B. Bacteriochlorophyll One of the namesake features of AAP is their possession of BChl, the remarkable bacterial pigment capable of absorbing the electromagnetic energy of light. All known AAP synthesize BChl a esterified to phytol like many purple nonsulfur bacteria (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998). However, members of the genus Acidiphilium are the only organisms known to naturally chelate the BChl tetrapyrrole ring to Zn instead of to Mg, producing a 7-nm blue-shift in the absorbance spectrum of the aberrant BChl a (Hiraishi and Shimada, 2001). Striking similarity in the electrochemistries of Zn and Mg permits this novel pigment to function, while metals such as Ni would produce ineffective bacteriochlorins, exhibiting too short an excited state lifetime to facilitate photosynthetic electron flow (Cogdell et al., 2002). However, a key difference in the acid chemistries of Zn and Mg explains the ecological significance of this pigment in Acidiphilium. Zn-BChl is 106 times more resistant to loss of the metal ligand (pheophytinization) by acids than is Mg-BChl, granting exceptional acid-stability in habitats with a pH as low as 2. Supporting this idea, the ratio of Zn-BChl to Mg-BChl synthesized by A. rubrum increases with acidity (Hiraishi and Shimada, 2001). Regardless of its chemical form, low cellular BChl content is an important determinative trait of the predominantly heterotrophic AAP (Fig. 3A–E and Color Plate 2), which produce at least ten times less BChl than the ~20 nmol/mg dry weight typical of purple nonsulfur bacteria: 2.0 nmol/mg cells in Erb. longus, 1.0 nmol/mg protein in Srb. sibiricus and too low to reliably measure in Rva. mucosus (Yurkov and Csotonyi, 2003; Biebl et al., 2005a). Consequently, absorbance peaks of BChl integrated into RC and LH complexes are about ten-fold lower than those of carotenoids. However, BChl:carotenoid ratios of 1.33:1 (Manitoba hypersaline spring strain EG14; Csotonyi and Yurkov, unpublished) and 1.2:1 (R. mahoneyensis; Rathgeber et al., 2005) (Fig. 3A–E and Color Plate 2) were also found. These resemble anaerobic phototroph ratios, begging two substantial questions. First, how do these AAP species circumvent phototoxicity incurred by aerobic operation of their high levels of BChl? Perhaps unique membrane environments or particularly antioxidant suites of carotenoids nullify this oxidative hazard. Second, does high BChl content indicate recent divergence from anaerobic phototrophy, or does it bespeak an
Vladimir Yurkov and Julius T. Csotonyi even more advanced condition than exists in other AAP, representing the next stage in evolution toward efficient exploitation of aerobic illuminated environments? Whatever the answers to these questions, the elevated BChl content in such strains makes them ideal candidates for investigation of regulatory factors of photosynthetic pigment expression. C. Highly Evolved Regulation of Pigment Synthesis If, as we propose, there was a transition from an anaerobic to an aerobic mode of existence, this necessitated modifications in the regulation of pigment expression. BChl synthesis in AAP is repressed by light (Fig. 3A and Color Plate 2) more extremely than in anaerobic phototrophs (Yurkov and Csotonyi, 2003). However, AAP also exhibit regulatory systems involving nutrients (Fig. 3B–E and Color Plate 2), temperature, pH and salinity (Alarico et al., 2002, Koblížek et al., 2003; Rathgeber et al., 2004; Macián et al., 2005; Biebl et al., 2006). Ongoing research is elucidating the mechanisms driving these regulatory regimes and delineating the range of responses. Ouchane et al. (2004) recently investigated AcsF, a strictly aerobically-active functional equivalent to the anaerobic Mg-protoporphyrin monomethyl ester cyclase, BchE, both of which catalyze formation of a key intermediate in BChl and Chl synthesis (Chapter 4, Willows and Kriegel). AcsF is thought to require O2, whereas BchE is thought to use H2O for the O atom needed for this step in (B)Chl synthesis (Ouchane et al., 2004). Sequencing studies revealed that whereas the acsF gene was absent in strict anaerobes such as green sulfur bacteria, homologs existed in facultative aerobes (purple and green nonsulfur bacteria) and in strict aerobes (cyanobacteria, green algae and plants), with the latter group lacking bchE (Ouchane et al., 2004). Although AAP would be expected to possess acsF and lack bchE, full genome sequencing of Rsb. denitrificans has turned up both genes (Swingley et al., 2007), making it unclear which genetic elements are responsible for restricting BChl synthesis to aerobic conditions in AAP. The final picture of O2 regulation of BChl synthesis is clearly more complex than indicated simply by presence or absence of two complementary genes. Maximal BChl synthesis in obligately aerobic Rst. depolymerans occurs at an atmospheric O2 content of only 2% (Suyama et al., 2002), and R. thiooxidans best expresses BChl microaerophilically (Yurkov and
Chapter 3
Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs
Csotonyi, 2003) and C. litoralis exhibits chemotactic preference for about 10% O2 concentration (Fuchs et al., 2007). What governs species-specific fine-tuning of optimum O2 concentration for pigment synthesis is currently unknown. When complemented with Rsb. denitrificans homologs of the anaerobic phototrophic two-component O2 regulatory system (RegA and RegB) of pigment synthesis, Rhodobacter capsulatus still only expressed O2-deprived pigment synthesis (Masuda et al., 1999), indicating that the AAP system functions as does the Rhodobacter counterpart (Chapter 35, Bauer et al.). The mechanism by which light regulates pigment synthesis in AAP is even cloudier than is the story for O2. Possibly, light repression of pigmentation is an overexpression of a similar but less potent process that purple nonsulfur bacteria employ in response to dangerously intense radiation. In most AAP, such as Erythromicrobium hydrolyticum, even dim light is strongly repressive to BChl synthesis (Yurkov and van Gemerden, 1993). However, Suyama et al. (2002) demonstrated 25% maximal BChl content in Rst. depolymerans at 10 W/m2 light intensity, while D. shibae produced BChl at 15% of its dark rate in the light (Biebl and Wagner-Döbler, 2006). Most interesting is a recent investigation of pigment synthesis by D. shibae under light-dark cycles of varying periodicity (Biebl and Wagner-Döbler, 2006), an elaboration on similar work by Yurkov and van Gemerden (1993). When the light:dark regimen was changed from 8h:16h (simulating winter conditions) to 16h:8h (summer conditions), the nightly rate of BChl synthesis increased nearly four-fold, indicating not only sensitivity to instantaneous level of illumination, but also a response to the duration of the previous illuminated interval (Biebl and Wagner-Döbler, 2006). Such regulation would be advantageous in the organism’s native marine environment, preparing more photosynthetic pigment on summer nights in anticipation of longer, warmer days, when higher doubling rates more extensively dilute the cell’s PSU complement. The authors suggest that signal transduction systems such as the recently discovered bacteriophytochrome (Evans et al., 2005; Chapter 40, Evans et al.) might mediate the effects of light in BChl synthesis in AAP (Biebl and Wagner-Döbler, 2006). Such speculation sets the stage for exciting future biochemical research. AAP hold additional fascinating surprises. Pigment expression in Thalassobacter stenotrophicus, H. phototrophica and Cmi. bathyomarinum is salt-sensitive;
43 T. stenotrophicus exhibits no pigmentation at 7% salinity, H. phototrophicum produces maximal BChl at 0.6% salinity and no BChl at 3.5% salinity, and Cmi. bathyomarinum manufactures the most BChl in the absence of NaCl, despite the native marine environment (~3.5% salinity) of all three species (Rathgeber et al., 2004; Macián et al., 2005; Biebl et al., 2006). Indeed, numerous studies have demonstrated that AAP tend to upregulate pigment synthesis under suboptimal growth conditions, implying that photosynthesis proves especially advantageous under stress (Rathgeber et al., 2004). Supporting this idea, thermophilic Rubritepida flocculens synthesizes BChl at 30 °C, but not at its preferred growth temperature of 50 °C (Alarico et al., 2002), and whereas marine Erythrobacter relative NAP1 grew optimally at 32.5 °C, BChl production maximized at 22.5 °C and halted at temperatures above 30 °C (Koblížek et al., 2003). Given the prominence of heterotrophic metabolism in AAP, nutritional status is a paramount regulatory factor of photosynthetic pigment synthesis (Beatty, 2002). Sudden carbon source dilution caused Rst. depolymerans to transcriptionally induce BChl synthesis (Suyama et al., 2002). This response makes sense in light of competition for electron carriers by heterotrophy and phototrophy in AAP: redox agents are maximally available for phototrophy when exogenous carbon sources are limiting (Beatty, 2002). Such is the case for E. ramosum, which produces over twice as much BChl when starved as when amended richly with nutrients (Fig. 3D and Color Plate 2). Most unusually, however, BChl synthesis occurred only in stationary phase cultures of Rst. depolymerans, and illumination only extended the viability of mature cultures instead of enhancing growth rate as in E. hydrolyticum and D. shibae (Yurkov and van Gemerden, 1993; Biebl and Wagner-Döbler, 2006). These observations inspired suggestion of an innovative use for the photosynthetic apparatus in some AAP: maintenance of the electrochemical proton gradient by light-induced cyclic electron flow, a condition that is essential for cellular integrity during starvation conditions (Suyama et al., 2002). In other species, the role of nutrients in regulation of pigment synthesis is more obscure. Erythrobacter litoralis produces more carotenoids but the same amount of BChl when organic carbon is limiting (Fig. 3C and Color Plate 2), and production of BChl and carotenoids in Rsc. thiosulfatophilus are both stimulated by a rich organic medium (Fig. 3B and
44 Color Plate 2), necessitating more research to unravel such mysteries. Even more interestingly, regulatory effects of two factors can interact nonlinearly in unexpected ways, best illustrated by exposure of H. phototrophica and strain DFL-11 to 8-hour-long pulses of light and starvation (Biebl and Wagner-Döbler, 2006). Whereas pulses of light or starvation alone had little or no effect on BChl levels, simultaneous exposure to both factors caused an order-of-magnitude increase in BChl, especially significant in these otherwise poorly pigmented species (Biebl and Wagner-Döbler, 2006). Thus, transient illumination and nutrient deprivation may facilitate the detection of BChl in strains in which its presence is uncertain and therefore aid in AAP identification. In light of this discovery, the tirade about incorrect taxonomic assignment of AAP to non-phototrophic genera in Section II.C deserves the balance of an important counterpoint. Several recent isolates, including Rva. mucosus and H. phototrophica, initially tested spectrophotometrically negative for BChl production and were recognized as phototrophs solely by their pufLM genes (Allgaier et al., 2003). The repeated insistence that photosynthetic apparatus expression is a useful taxonomic marker for AAP because BChl is easily detected (e.g., Yurkov and Csotonyi, 2003) must be tempered with caution. Indeed, Rva. mucosus failed to produce measurable BChl even under the pulse of starvation and illumination that induced such a marked increase in pigmentation in H. phototrophica and strain DFL-11 (Biebl and Wagner-Döbler, 2006). Whereas a negative conclusion of BChl production should only follow a reasonably wide application of culture conditions, it is nonetheless conceivable that some isolates will evade all reasonable attempts to induce BChl synthesis, and would therefore understandably be misclassified as non-phototrophs in the absence of genetic sequencing. Aside from applications in taxonomic hair-splitting, this point inspires a potentially informative investigation. A PCR-based screening of described proteobacterial species for pufLM, acsF and bchE genes could delineate the true phylogenetic distribution of aerobic phototrophy in this group. The pufLM genes would establish phototrophic capability, while presence of acsF and absence of bchE could indicate an obligately aerobic nature. Physiological work on species possessing pufLM should then be performed as a precaution, because Swingley et al. (2007) and Fuchs et al. (2007) have reported bchE in the completely or nearly completely
Vladimir Yurkov and Julius T. Csotonyi sequenced genomes of the AAP R. denitrificans and C. litoralis, repspectively. V. The Mysterious Photosynthetic Apparatus of Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs Demonstration that AAP incorporate BChl into a functional photosynthetic apparatus certainly raised eyebrows in a skeptical research community struggling to accept the idea of an aerobic variant of anoxygenic photosynthesis. Nevertheless, AAP proved to possess a properly transcribed, bonafide purple bacterial-type photosynthetic superoperon, encoding apoproteins of RC, LH1 and often LH2 complexes (Yurkov, 2006). Exactly how a sophisticated set of anaerobically evolved pigment-protein complexes was enlisted to operate only aerobically is still debated, and is grievously neglected in recently published research. The striking genetic and structural similarities of AAP photosynthetic machinery to that of purple nonsulfur bacteria may have stifled some interest in this area. Increasing accessibility of relevant tools and techniques should cause this field to burgeon. A. The Reaction Center of Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs Has Purple Bacterial Roots As in anaerobic purple phototrophs, the heart of the AAP photosynthetic apparatus consists of a type II (quinone-type) RC with three structural subunits (L, M and H), four BChls, two bacteriopheophytins, two ubiquinones, a nonheme high-spin Fe2+, and a carotenoid (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998). In purple bacteria, components are encoded on the ~45 kb photosynthesis gene cluster, and superoperons and polycistronic mRNAs contribute to stoichiometric consistency (Klug, 1993). The structural cornerstone of the RC makes the genes encoding the L and M subunits (pufLM) most frequently utilized in genetic surveys for phototrophs (Yutin et al., 2005). RC gene sequences in AAP are similar to genes from anaerobic anoxygenic phototrophs, illustrating that only a few modifications were required to enable anoxygenic phototrophy to function in the presence of O2. As a prime example, a single key replacement of His L168 with glutamic acid in the RC of Acidiphilium may be largely responsible for stabilization and function
Chapter 3
Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs
of Zn-BChl (Nagashima et al., 1997). However, the flip-side of high structural and functional dependence on fine-scale gene sequence variation is that coarse genetic analysis techniques may fail to resolve much diversity. Indeed, introducing greater variation in two new pufM primers returned 14 times as many phototrophic sequences from Eastern Mediterranean Sea water samples as did probes constructed to amplify the single pufM sequence (Yutin et al., 2005). Some reports of diversity in photosynthetic gene organization are controversial. Exemplifying this, the recent claim by Pradella et al. (2004) that the pufLM genes of Roseobacter litoralis and Stl. guttiformis are not chromosomal but reside on linear plasmids of 91 and 120 kb size, respectively, could provide another ‘smoking gun’ for the idea of lateral photosynthetic gene transfer among AAP. However, these conclusions must be weighed hesitantly, because both partial and complete genome sequencing have established a chromosomal location for the puf operon of Rsb. denitrificans (Liebetanz et al., 1991; Swingley, et al., 2007). It seems unlikely that congeneric organisms (two species of Roseobacter) could possess such vastly different genomic arrangements. If further research rules out the possibility of an artifact, then such a discovery would bestow on the AAP uniquely flexible photosynthesis gene location. Great molecular diversity in AAP exists in Cyt electron carriers that close the photosynthetic electron transfer circuit by returning electrons to photo-oxidized BChl in the RC. In Erythrobacter, Erythromicrobium and Mahoney Lake strain ML31, the RC is reduced by a soluble periplasmic Cyt c2, as in Rhodobacter (Rba.) sphaeroides (Rathgeber et al., 2004). In addition to a soluble Cyt, Cmi. bathyomarinum, Erythromonas ursincola, R. mahoneyensis, Rsb. denitrificans, Rsc. thiosulfatophilus and Srb. sibiricus also possess a tetraheme Cyt c (encoded by pufC in Rsb. denitrificans) tightly bound to the RC, a characteristic of the anaerobic anoxygenic phototroph Blastochloris viridis (Rathgeber et al., 2004; Yutin and Béjà, 2005). Interestingly, Rsb. denitrificans lacks the posttranslational N-terminal cleavage of PufC that anchors the resulting tetraheme Cyt c to the membrane via a diacylglycerol molecule in purple bacterial species such as Blastochloris viridis (Hucke et al., 2003). Instead, the elongated N-terminus fastens Cyt c and contains a transmembrane helix motif resembling the core of another polypeptide, PufX. The Rhodobacter PufX protein affects the orientation and dimerization of the RC-LH1-PufX complex (Francia et al., 1999;
45 Siebert et al., 2004; Chapter 9, Bullough et al.), and the pufX gene is located where pufC sits in other species (Yutin and Béjà, 2005). Roseobacter thus opens a unique window on the evolutionary history of the PufX protein, which may have evolved by incomplete deletion of pufC in ancestral phototrophs switching from a RC-bound to a soluble Cyt c that donates electrons to the RC (Hucke et al., 2003). Although AAP have not been shown to contain pufX, bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) cloning vectors constructed from marine samples have yielded putative AAP sequences (such as eBAC 60D04) from uncultured Gammaproteobacteria containing a gene strongly resembling pufX (Yutin and Béjà, 2005). However, ascribing uncultured anoxygenic photosynthetic gene sequences from aerobic environments to the AAP is risky, as purple nonsulfur bacterial sequences may masquerade as AAP to unwary eyes. B. Light-Harvesting Complexes: Ordinary and Extraordinary Surrounding the RC, AAP possess LH antenna complexes that sequester additional photonic energy, both by increasing light-harvesting cross-sectional area and by broadening the range of captured wavelengths. The core LH1 complex, existing in all AAP, shows little variation, but accessory LH2 manifests unexpected diversity. Reflecting the conserved nature of LH1 is its close genetic association with the RC: LH1 subunits β and α are encoded by genes (pufBA) cotranscribed with and immediately upstream of pufLMC (Yutin and Béjà, 2005). Carotenoid-rich LH1 forms an intimate ring of about 30 BChls around the RC (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998), facilitating highly efficient transfer of excitons to the RC primary electron donor, P870. In this respect, AAP strongly resemble purple nonsulfur bacteria such as Rba. sphaeroides, sharing similar RC-LH1 near-IR absorption spectra, with maxima at around 800 nm (RC) and 870 nm (LH1) (Yurkov and Csotonyi, 2003). With the exception of Zn-BChl of Acidiphilium, however, a few AAP display further unexplained spectral deviation of LH1, such as blue-shifting (856 nm maximum) in Rsc. thiosulfatophilus (Fig. 3B and Color Plate 2) or red-shifting (879 nm maximum) in Roseovarius tolerans (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998; Yurkov and Csotonyi, 2003). The structural factors responsible for this spectral fine-tuning remain to be elucidated. In contrast to LH1, the peripheral LH2 complex of AAP varies widely in both expression and structure.
46 In Rhodobacter and Rhodopseudomonas anaerobic phototrophic species, the LH2 genes reside in one or more puc operons, presumably enabling more independent transcriptional regulation (Klug, 1993; Larimer et al., 2004). Most tantalizing is the striking spectral differences of LH2 antennas in AAP from those of purple bacteria. When present, the LH2 complexes of anaerobic purple phototrophic bacteria exist in several spectral forms, their nomenclature denoting primary near-IR absorption maxima in nm: e.g., B800-850 (typical Rhodobacter-type), B800-820 (in Rhodopseudomonas (Rps.) acidophila) and the BChl b-containing B800-1020 (in Ectothiorhodospira) (Steiner and Scheer, 1985; Cogdell et al., 2002). The unusual purple nonsulfur bacterium Rps. palustris possesses four different peripheral LH species, including a monomodal LH2 complex with a single absorption peak (Hartigan et al., 2002). Interestingly, and for reasons unknown, the LH2 spectral classes of AAP often differ from those of their anaerobic relatives: B798-832 (in α-4 Erythromicrobium, Sandarakinorhabdus and Porphyrobacter dokdonensis) (Fig. 3D and Color Plate 2), B800-814 (in α-4 Porphyrobacter donghaensis) and B806 (in the α-3 Roseobacter, Roseicyclus and Rubrimonas) (Fig. 3A and Color Plate 2) (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998; Rathgeber et al., 2004; Yoon et al., 2004b, 2006; Gich and Overmann, 2006). The latter is a rare monomodal LH complex, similar to that found in only one anaerobic species, Rps. palustris (Hartigan et al., 2002). However, a 4 nm difference in its absorption maximum calls into question how structurally similar B806 is to the Rps. palustris LH2, which is an octamer with four BChl per αβ peptide instead of the usual three, each arranged radially rather than tangentially (Hartigan et al., 2002). Cogdell et al. (2002) propose that controlling the rotation of the BChl acetyl group relative to the bacteriochlorin ring plane by adjusting the content of hydrogen bonding amino acid residues at key positions in the LH2 apoprotein permits effective modulation of the Qy absorption band shift. Because loss of hydrogen bonding robustly explains the development of B800-820 from B800-850 (Fowler et al., 1992, 1994), a similar transition may have generated B798-832. Curiously, however, Raman spectroscopy indicates the presence of H bonds to the acetyl substituents of BChl in E. ramosum (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998), meaning that the case is definitely not closed on the source of LH2 Qy band shifts in AAP.
Vladimir Yurkov and Julius T. Csotonyi C. The Riddle of Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophy Exploring PSU biophysics, biochemistry and molecular genetics should resolve the question addressing the definitive quality of AAP, i.e., what allows their PSU to function aerobically. Unfortunately, similarity in RC architecture between AAP and anaerobic phototrophs (Section V.A.) complicates matters. Further smearing the distinction between aerobic and anaerobic phototrophy is the recent discovery of obligately microaerophilic photosynthesis in R. mahoneyensis (Rathgeber et al., 2004). Still, several studies provide a smattering of reasons that may explain why AAP photosynthesis is obligately aerobic. Energy-conserving photosynthetic electron flow in AAP appears to trace a circuit typical of anaerobic anoxygenic phototrophic bacteria, from the photooxidized special pair of BChl (P870+) to auxiliary BChl, bacteriopheophytin, the ubiquinone primary e– acceptor QA, then exiting the RC to the membrane quinone pool, a membrane bound Cyt bc1 complex, Cyt c2, and back to the RC (Fig. 3F and Color Plate 2). AAP differ subtly from purple nonsulfur bacteria at three principal points, the first involving the redox poise of the primary acceptor, QA. In most AAP, QA has a much higher midpoint potential (+5 to +150 mV) than in anaerobic purple bacteria (usually negative potentials), causing it to become and remain overreduced anoxically and halting electron flow (Fig. 3F and Color Plate 2) (Rathgeber et al., 2004). The structural basis of this functional discrepancy remains a mystery, as homology modeling of quinone binding pockets in the RC of Rsb. denitrificans demonstrates remarkably similar interactions between protein and quinone as compared with Rba. sphaeroides (Kohler et al., 2005). The second distinction of AAP is the lack of an alternative quinol oxidase pathway, thought to maintain the quinone pool at a proper redox state for efficient electron transport under photosynthetic conditions (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998). Finally, failure of soluble Cyts to transfer electrons anoxically from the Cyt bc1 complex to the RC-bound Cyt c in Rsb. denitrificans also implicates these components in arresting anaerobic photosynthetic electron flow in AAP (Schwarze et al., 2000). Hence, properties of one or more electron carriers found in the RC, membrane lipid phase and periplasm may prohibit anaerobic photosynthesis in the AAP, but the relative contribution of each element is presently unknown.
Chapter 3
Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs
Whether scarcity of recent publications is a cause or an effect of the recalcitrance of the central biophysical question encompassing obligately aerobic photosynthesis is uncertain, but hopefully this lull will soon end. VI. Speculation on Ecological Roles Despite strides over the last four years in both culture-based and culture-independent studies, AAP ecological understanding is still in its adolescence. Researchers have discovered experimental tools with great potential, but proper combination of techniques to guarantee maximal analytical power still requires refinement. At the crux of the issue, comprehension of ecological significance requires qualitative description of interactions to go hand in hand with both assessment of biogeochemical cycling and reliable enumeration. Whereas some interesting associations have been described, work on elemental cycling is scant. Also, in spite of its seeming triviality, measuring the abundance of AAP in nature has proven exceptionally difficult. A. Technical Challenges of Enumerating Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs AAP were traditionally enumerated by culturing on rich organic media (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998). This technique is very powerful for assessing the abundance of a physiological subset of the community and offers the added benefit that all enumerated organisms can subsequently be examined in physiological and phylogenetic detail. However, realization of the miniscule proportion of microorganisms amenable to cultivation spurs a growing interest in census techniques that circumvent the need to culture organisms. Regrettably, most culture-independent methods possess significant shortfalls. Phylogenetic surveys based on 16S rRNA genes alone, constituting much of marine microbial research, fail to discriminate between closely related phototrophic and non-phototrophic organisms. Efforts to screen for photosynthesis genes, such as quantitative or real-time PCR (Schwalbach and Fuhrman, 2005; Du et al., 2006), overcome this phylogenetic interspersion issue, but using primers constructed from described organisms inherently limits the diversity of detectable phototrophs (Yutin et al., 2005). Even bulk pigment analysis of ocean water by HPLC, or of individual cells by infrared
47 epifluorescence microscopy (IREM) or its variants (Schwalbach and Fuhrman, 2005; Jiao et al., 2006; Sieracki et al., 2006) are faulty as they measure a pool of BChl produced by both AAP and purple nonsulfur bacteria. IREM can even misidentify cyanobacteria as anoxygenic phototrophs and underestimate Prochlorococcus populations (oxygenic phototrophs particularly numerous in oligotrophic ocean waters) by orders of magnitude (Jiao et al., 2006), although newer studies attempt to correct for this effect (Lami et al., 2007). Finally, the sensitivity of BChl synthesis to a slew of environmental factors (Section IV.C.) generates great variation in pigment content from cell to cell, invalidating estimates of overall AAP abundance based on average cellular BChl concentration (e.g., Kolber et al., 2001; Koblížek et al., 2005). Obviously, measuring the abundance of AAP in nature is no trivial task. Thus far, three preferable alternatives exist: (1) infrared fast repetition rate fluorometry (IRFRR), which unfortunately requires state-of-the-art instruments, but can measure and distinguish between aerobic and anaerobic photosynthetic electron transport; (2) QPCR of pufLM (and of genes that can be used to discriminate between aerobic/anaerobic photosynthesis, such as acsF and bchE); and (3) combination of culture-independent ribosomal and photosynthetic gene surveys with cultivation, followed by 16S rDNA genetic analysis of cultured organisms. To date, only a few studies have applied either the first (Kolber et al., 2000, 2001; Koblížek et al., 2003, 2006) or the third (e.g., Gich et al., 2005; Salka et al., 2006) strategy to AAP, and no studies have yet employed the second. The majority of reported marine AAP enumeration must therefore be judged inconclusive, because abundance estimates represent only an upper limit, pooling AAP with nonphototrophs or anaerobic phototrophs, depending on methods employed. B. Ocean Surface Between 2003 and 2006, nearly 75% of approximately 22 ecologically relevant publications focused on marine environments, from which AAP were originally isolated. Three reports likely instigated this return to the sea. First, AAP were surprisingly recovered from deep ocean hydrothermal vent plumes (Yurkov et al., 1999). Second, although AAP have long been known to constitute up to 10 to 30% of the cultivable bacterial community in hypersaline and hydrothermal environments (Yurkov and Csotonyi, 2003) (Fig. 3G, I and
A, B ND NW Atlantic: Sargasso Sea (11–15 m) Sieracki et al. (2006)
Mar 02
1.3–2.5%; (0.71–1.49 × 104 ml–1); 2.4–3.3% of biomass
IREM
A, B ND NW Atlantic: USA coast to Gulf Stream (11–15 m) Sieracki et al. (2006)
Mar 02
0.8–2%; (0.76–2.1 × 104 ml–1); 1.8–2.5% of biomass
IREM
A, B ND NW Atlantic: Sargasso Sea (11–15 m) Sieracki et al. (2006)
Oct 01
0.8–2.6%; (0.82–1.26 × 104 ml–1); 3.4–5% of biomass
IREM
A, B
A, B NW Atlantic: USA E coast to Gulf Stream (11–15 m) Sieracki et al. (2006)
Oct 01
ND
IREM
A, B
2.3–9.4%; (2.16–9.84 × 104 ml–1); 7–12% of biomass
IREM ND
IREM 0.3–2.6 0.8–18%
<1–5% (<1–2.5 × 104 ml–1) North Pacific Gyre (0–100 m) Cottrell et al. (2006)
Aug 03 Mid Atlantic Bight (0–100 m) Cottrell et al. (2006)
Feb 04
B 0.3–2.2 ND 3 Black Sea Koblížek et al. (2006)
Jun 01
IRFRR
0–2.32 0.1–24.2% (up to 1.94 × 105 ml–1) S Pacific (0–270 m) Lami et al. (2007)
Oct–Dec 04
IREM
IREM, QPCR Delaware Estuary (DE, USA) Waidner and Kirchman (2007)
Aug 02–Mar 06
ND 3
Limitations of Method 2 Method 1 BChl a / Chl a (%)
% of Total Bacterial Population; (Absolute AAP Abundance); % of total bacterial biomass 0.9–34% (1.7–5.1 × 105 ml–1) Month & Year of Sampling Location of Sampling Publication
Table 2. Abundance estimates of marine aerobic anoxygenic phototrophs
Color Plate 2), the extraordinary claim by Kolber et al. (2001) that they represent 11% of the vast marine euphotic microbial community suddenly numbered AAP among the most plentiful organisms on earth, greatly elevating their importance in scientists’ eyes. Third, misinterpretation of anaplerotic CO2 incorporation by marine AAP as photosynthetic CO2 fixation (i.e., photoautotrophic growth) led to inflated estimates of their importance to marine carbon cycling (Kolber et al., 2000). The ensuing half decade was rife with arguments for and against the ecological importance of marine AAP, depending on techniques employed and on time and location of sampling (Table 2). The overall picture materializing is complex, but some resolution of disputes is now becoming possible. Integrating results of several studies yields populations of 104–105 cells ml–1, representing about 1 to 10% of all bacteria (Table 2). Seasonal population cycling is at the heart of much of the variation. In the northwest Atlantic, the numbers of AAP declined nearly ten-fold from autumn to spring, which Sieracki et al. (2006) attributed to temperature sensitivity. Positive correlation with water temperature also explains some ocean basin-wide differences, such as values of 0.01–0.06% of total microbes in Antarctic waters versus 0.72% at Bermuda, both sampled during their respective summers (Schwalbach and Fuhrman, 2005). Exceptions, such as consistently greater numbers of AAP in cold northern European waters — 1.37–10% of bacteria (Koblížek et al., 2003; Schwalbach and Fuhrman, 2005) — indicate influence by other factors, such as primary productivity. High relative abundance in nutrient rich temperate estuaries (10.7–34%) (Schwalbach and Fuhrman, 2005; Waidner and Kirchman, 2007) and algae-rich waters (Cottrell et al., 2006; Sieracki et al., 2006) seems to contradict the proposal that AAP experience greatest competitive success in oligotrophic settings (Beatty, 2002), but a recent report of 24.2% relative abundance in the gyre of the South Pacific Ocean, the most oligotrophic portion of the world ocean, contests this conclusion (Lami et al., 2007). Response to algal blooms, which generate irregular or quasiregular nutrient pulses, may account for long-term fluctuations in AAP populations (Schwalbach and Fuhrman, 2005; Sieracki et al. 2006). Exemplifying the reliance of some AAP on concentrated nutrient sources, Roseobacter-clade species frequently form close associations with dinoflagellates such as Alexandrium (Table 1; Allgaier et al.,
A, B A, C A, B
Vladimir Yurkov and Julius T. Csotonyi
48
Aug 03, Aug 98 Dec 93–Jan 94 May 90, Jun 94 Sep 90, Jul 94, Apr 98 Mar 98, Mar 99 Jul 93, Aug 96 Dec 00–Jul 01
Schwalbach and Fuhrman (2005) NW Atlantic: USA E coast estuaries (2 sites)
Schwalbach and Fuhrman (2005) Antarctica (4 sites)
Schwalbach and Fuhrman (2005) Caribbean Sea (Bermuda, Barbados)
Schwalbach and Fuhrman (2005) W Pacific (Singapore, Philippines, Fiji)
Schwalbach and Fuhrman (2005) SW Pacific (New Caledonia, Great Barrier Reef)
Schwalbach and Fuhrman (2005) NE Atlantic (France, Norway)
E Pacific (CA, USA)
NE Pacific
Goericke (2002)
Kolber et al. (2001)
11%
ND
1.37%, 2.28%
0.51%, 0.73%
0.30%, 0.71%, 0.92%
0.12–1.42%, 0.72%
0.01–0.06%
10.70%, 18.74%
1.17%
0.8
0.1–2.0
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
0.12–0.65
3–10%; (0.7–5 × 105 ml–1) 1.66%
BChl a / Chl a (%)
% of Total Bacterial Population; (Absolute AAP Abundance); % of total bacterial biomass
IRFRR, IREM, HPLC
HPLC
QPCR
QPCR
QPCR
QPCR
QPCR
QPCR
QPCR
TIREM
KF
Method 1
B
A
A, C
A, C
A, C
A, C
A, C
A, C
A, C
A
A
Limitations of Method 2
Kolber et al. (2000) E Pacific (OR, USA) Nov 99 ND 0.7–10 IRFRR B 1 Method codes: HPLC, high performance liquid chromatography; IREM, infrared epifluorescence microscopy; IRFRR, infrared fast repetition rate fluorometry; KF, kinetic fluorometry; QPCR, quantitative polymerase chain reaction; TIREM, time–dependent infrared epifluorescence microscopy. 2 Legend: (A) no distinction of AAP genes or BChl from that of anaerobic phototrophs, (B) potentially underestimates Prochlorococcus, (C) detection of gene sequences limited to only those primers used. 3 ND, not determined.
Jul 00
Jul 01–Aug 02
Schwalbach and Fuhrman (2005) E Pacific (CA, USA)
Aug–Sep 03 Jul 01–Aug 02
Baltic Sea transect (54–60° N)
Koblížek et al. (2005)
Month & Year of Sampling
Schwalbach and Fuhrman (2005) E Pacific (CA, USA)
Location of Sampling
Publication
Table 2. Continued
Chapter 3 Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs 49
50 2003). Establishing relationships with reliable producers of organic carbon, such as DMSP-producing algae, circumvents the need to diminish cell size as a means to maximize uptake rates of dissolved organic matter. Attachment to motile photoautotrophs such as dinoflagellates also minimizes energy expended on regulating vertical position for optimal light interception. So where do marine AAP reside on the trophic pyramid? Assessments of in situ physiological activity are rare, but an IRFRR study by Kolber et al. (2000) established that AAP can account for 2–5% of photosynthetic electron flux in the upper ocean. Kolber et al. (2001) calculated that light-stimulated CO2-fixation contributed to 1% of the total carbon anabolism in marine AAP cultures grown in 2 to 20 mM organic medium. However, they then reasoned that in the thousand-fold lower concentration of dissolved organic matter in the oligotrophic ocean, CO2-fixation would contribute proportionally more to anabolism. Regrettably, the flawed assumption that anaplerotic carboxylation rates are independent of organic carbon assimilation rates led to the erroneous inference that AAP are capable of photoautotrophy and to a gross overestimate (Fenchel, 2001) of their contribution to the marine carbon budget. Whereas AAP are not primary producers, the two-fold higher efficiency in organic carbon utilization over heterotrophs facilitated by ‘accessory phototrophy’ nevertheless enables them to exert a disproportionately greater influence on marine carbon cycling than their numbers would suggest, signifying keystone consumer status. As Sieracki et al. (2006) elegantly put it, ‘AAP bacteria may act as a sunlight-accelerated shunt of energy between the large pool of oceanic dissolved organic matter and higher trophic levels.’ Three factors additional to standing population size critically influence the AAP trophic significance: cellular pigment content, cell size, and rate of population turnover. Pigment content obviously influences energetics and therefore rate of carbon turnover. Sieracki et al. (2006) calculated cell quotas of BChl for northwest Atlantic AAP in the range of 0.03 to 0.17 fg BChl cell–1, which did not correlate with local marine trophic status even after normalizing pigment content to biomass. This value differs markedly from 0.0098 fg BChl cell–1 for northeastern Pacific AAP (Kolber et al., 2001), underscoring the importance of unknown factors in determining contribution of AAP to euphotic electron flux. One likely factor, cell size, is ecologically significant because it di-
Vladimir Yurkov and Julius T. Csotonyi rectly influences standing crop. Oddly, size spectrum determinations by microscopy indicated that most northwest Atlantic putative AAP cells were 1.3 to 2.6 times larger than other bacteria (Sieracki et al., 2006), and that South Pacific AAP also had two-fold greater biovolumes than other bacteria (Lami et al., 2007), making their relative biomass correspondingly more prominent. Perhaps these AAP placed greater emphasis on nutrient storage than did the rest of the microbial community. Increased size should drive higher turnover rates because of more intense grazing pressure from heterotrophic protists (Sieracki et al., 2006), as observed for AAP in the Baltic Sea, where diel BChl fluctuation translated into mortality rates of 0.7–2.3 day–1 along a latitudinal transect from 54.5° N to 59° N (Koblížek et al., 2005). Follow-up results indicated AAP doubling rates of 1.44–2.13 day–1 from the productive North Atlantic and 0.72–1.03 day–1 in oligotrophic North and South Atlantic gyres, which is ten-fold greater than typically reported for bacteria in oceanic gyres (Koblížek et al., 2007). Rapidly cycling populations represent greater temporally integrated supplies of carbon to higher trophic levels. If research continues to confirm large cell size and high cellular turnover rates of AAP by more direct measures of biomass, then their trophic impact on the ocean is greater than abundance indicates. C. Vertical Distribution of Deep Ocean Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs Undoubtedly the most bizarre aspect of AAP ecology has been the discovery of deep ocean (~2000 m) populations of Cmi. bathyomarinum, comprising 4 to 30% of the microbial community cultured on a rich organic medium (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998) (Fig. 3G and Color Plate 2). Fueled by the hypothesis that near-IR radiation emitted by superheated water from hydrothermal vents is sufficient to support phototrophic growth (possibly explaining the recovery of a green sulfur bacterium from the hydrothermal vent environment; Beatty et al., 2005), a recent study found Cmi. bathyomarinum to possess a completely functional photosynthetic apparatus (Rathgeber et al., unpublished) (Fig. 3E and Color Plate 2). Adding intrigue to the tale, culture-based techniques demonstrated that Cmi. bathyomarinum may be confined to the deep ocean (Rathgeber et al., unpublished). Vertical transects on- and off-axis from the Juan de Fuca Ridge in the eastern Pacific Ocean yielded twelve yellow AAP from within the plume at
Chapter 3
Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs
depths between 500 and 2379 m. Based on 16S rDNA sequences, these strains clustered closely with Cmi. bathyomarinum (99.7–99.8% similarity), whereas a single yellow strain isolated from the ocean surface was 96.9% similar to Erb. litoralis (Rathgeber et al., unpublished) and probably represents a typical member of the euphotic zone AAP (Cottrell et al., 2006; Sieracki et al., 2006). Absence at the surface suggests that Cmi. bathyomarinum may be endemic to deep vent plumes and possibly garners benefit from hydrothermal effluent components. D. Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs Thrive in Extreme Environments The decade preceding the marine ecological campaign stimulated by the startling results of Kolber et al. (2000) was rich in studies of AAP from inland extreme environments (Fig 3H, I and Color Plate 2), because the first non-marine species were isolated from Russian thermal springs in 1990 (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998). Hypersaline ecotopes and acidic coal refuse heaps also yielded numerous novel AAP (Yurkov and Csotonyi, 2003), reflecting the discovery that phototrophy in AAP maximally enhances fitness under suboptimal conditions (Section IV.C.). Perhaps this feature, under pressure to escape competition, has driven many AAP to evolve extremotolerance or extremophily. Halotolerance is especially frequently observed in AAP, and a plethora of species inhabit meromictic lakes (Yurkova et al., 2002; Karr et al., 2003), various salt flats (Yurkov and Csotonyi, 2003) and hypersaline springs (Csotonyi and Yurkov, unpublished) (Fig 3H and Color Plate 2). Yurkov and Csotonyi (2003) comprehensively reviewed the ubiquity of AAP in extreme environments. Aside from enumerating and characterizing novel AAP, though, microbial ecologists have barely scratched the surface of biogeochemical cycling by AAP in extreme environments. E. Soil and Freshwater As microbiologists converge on a rough understanding of marine AAP ecology, attention is turning to environments in which AAP are most likely to interact with humans: soil, freshwater lakes and rivers. Impetus for this shift appears divided between academics and conservation. First, not only were two genera (Craurococcus and Paracraurococcus) isolated from urban soils, but the only known beta-
51 proteobacterial representative (Roseateles) is lotic (Yurkov and Csotonyi, 2003). A fosmid library from the Delaware river recently yielded unique puf (RC gene) sequences in uncultured α-3 and betaproteobacterial AAP, which may be particularly abundant in rivers (Waidner and Kirchman, 2005). The authors conscientiously screened not only pufLM genes, but also acsF and bchE (see Section IV.C.), and the oxygen-dependent oxidase-encoding hemN, to aid in discrimination between aerobic and anaerobic phototrophs using a purely genetic approach. Second, increasing human-induced environmental damage means that enumeration of AAP in ecologically sensitive habitats will valuably contribute to catalogues of biodiversity. A prime Canadian example is the Banff thermal springs (Fig. 3I and Color Plate 2), in which phototrophic bacteria may form an important dietary component of the endangered Banff springs snail (P. johnsoni) (Bilyj, Pacas and Yurkov, unpublished). Ability of AAP such as Blastomonas natatoria, Stl. guttiformis, S. sibiricus, and coastal sand strains 15s. b. and 23s.b. to secrete copious polymers and form multi-layered biofilms (Yurkov and Beatty, 1998; Ivanova et al., 2002; Rickard et al., 2002) may even involve AAP in soil structural development. VII. Concluding Remarks and Perspectives Atmospheric oxygenation ~2 GYa drove convergence of incompatible cellular processes resulting in the AAP, bacteria capable of anoxygenic phototrophy even in the presence of ‘toxic’ O2. Because this abundant cosmopolitan group was discovered only 28 years ago, many questions remain unanswered, and exciting research directions remain to be explored. Regarding photosynthesis gene expression and function, satisfactory answers to why AAP photosynthesis functions only oxically and how these mechanisms vary among clades remain elusive. The molecular rheostats that fine-tune pigment levels in response to levels of light, oxygen, nutrients and other environmental factors are incompletely understood, as is the range of the roles played by photosynthetically disengaged carotenoids. Why AAP possess different suites of LH2 complexes in comparison with some anaerobic anoxygenic bacteria begs an answer, as does the question of whether any AAP have retained autotrophy. More daunting will be delineation of the proportion of currently classified heterotrophs that possess genes for photosynthesis
52 and whether any bacteria possess a nonfunctional or partial photosynthetic gene cluster, because thus far, no such case has been identified. On the contrary, completely functional photosynthetic complexes have turned up in unexpected habitats, such as the deep ocean, where light is not completely absent. Although our familiarity with the ecological role of AAP in marine environments waxes, researchers need to develop reliable standards for enumerating AAP, and they need to place greater emphasis on assessing the role of this functional group in elemental cycling in both ‘middle-of-the-road’ ecotopes and extreme environments. On a more globally relevant scale, a currently less amenable but more significant question considers how AAP may impact global climate through involvement in carbon and sulfur cycles, and conversely, how climate change will affect them via altered water temperature, pH and nutrient status. Finally, in fields of applied science and industry, the tendency of AAP toward extremophily and metallotolerance (Yurkov and Csotonyi, 2003) opens opportunities for bioremediative studies. Recent burgeoning interest in the AAP has uncovered more questions than answers, indicating that we have only begun to raise the floodgates of knowledge on this fascinating and significant group of bacteria, which doubtless hold a wealth of discoveries for the near and long term future. Acknowledgments This work was supported financially by a Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council grant held by V. Yurkov. We thank E. Stackebrandt and J. Swiderski for generous help with the phylogenetic tree preparation. We thank the following scientists for providing published and unpublished results on AAP research: Drs. O. Béjà, R. Blankenship, I. Wagner-Döbler, G. Drews, V. Gorlenko, D. Green, D. Kirchman, M. Koblížek , M. Labrenz and J. Overmann. References Alarico S, Rainey FA, Empadinhas N, Schumann P, Nobre MF and Da Costa MS (2002) Rubritepida flocculans gen. nov., sp. nov., a new slightly thermophilic member of the α-1 subclass of the Proteobacteria. Syst Appl Microbiol 25: 198–206 Allgaier M, Uphoff H, Felske A and Wagner-Döbler I (2003) Aerobic anoxygenic photosynthesis in Roseobacter clade bacteria from diverse marine habitats. Appl Environ Microbiol 69: 5051–5059
Vladimir Yurkov and Julius T. Csotonyi Beatty JT (2002) On the natural selection and evolution of the aerobic phototrophic bacteria. Photosynth Res 73: 109–114 Beatty JT, Overmann J, Lince MT, Manske AK, Lang AS, Blankenship RE, van Dover CL, Martinson TA and Plumley FG (2005) An obligately photosynthetic bacterial anaerobe from a deep-sea hydrothermal vent. Proc Natl Acad Sci 102: 9306–9310 Béjà O, Suzuki MT, Heidelberg JF, Nelson WC, Preston CM, Hamada T, Elsen JA, Fraser CM and DeLong EF (2002) Unsuspected diversity among marine aerobic anoxygenic phototrophs. Nature 415: 630–633 Biebl H and Wagner-Döbler I (2006) Growth and bacteriochlorophyll a formation in taxonomically diverse aerobic anoxygenic phototrophic bacteria in chemostat culture: Influence of light regimen and starvation. Proc Biochem 41: 2153–2159 Biebl H, Allgaier M, Lünsdorf H, Pukall R, Tindall BJ and WagnerDöbler I (2005a) Roseovarius mucosus sp. nov., a member of the Roseobacter clade with trace amounts of bacteriochlorophyll a. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 55: 2377–2383 Biebl H, Allgaier M, Tindall, BJ Koblížek M, Lünsdorf H, Pukall R and Wagner-Döbler I (2005b) Dinoroseobacter shibae gen nov., sp. nov., a new aerobic phototrophic bacterium isolated from dinoflagellates. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 55: 1089–1096 Biebl H, Tindall BJ, Pukall R, Lünsdorf H, Allgaier M and WagnerDöbler I (2006) Hoeflea phototrophica sp. nov., a novel marine aerobic alphaproteobacterium that forms bacteriochlorophyll a. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 56: 821–826 Biebl H, Pukall R, Lünsdorf H, Schulz S, Allgaier M, Tindall BJ and Wagner-Döbler I (2007) Description of Labrenzia alexandrii gen. nov., sp. nov., a novel alphaproteobacterium containing bacteriochlorophyll a, and a proposal for reclassification of Stappia aggregata as Labrenzia aggregata comb. nov., of Stappia marina as Labrenzia marina comb. nov. and of Stappia alba as Labrenzia alba comb. nov., and emended descriptions of the genera Pannonibacter, Stappia and Roseibium, and of the species Roseibium denhamense and Roseibium hamelinense. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 57: 1095–1107 Boettcher KJ, Geaghan KK, Maloy AP and Barber BJ (2005) Roseovarius crassostreae sp. nov., a member of the Roseobacter clade and the apparent cause of juvenile oyster disease (JOD) in cultured Eastern oysters. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 55: 1531–1537 Boldareva EN, Bryantseva IA, Tsapin A, Nelson K, Sorokin DY, Tourova TP, Boichenko VA, Stadnichuk IN and Gorlenko VM (2007) The new alkaliphilic bacteriochlorophyll a-containing bacterium Roseinatronobacter monicus sp. nov. from the hypersaline soda Mono Lake (California, United States). Microbiology 76: 82–92 Brown MV and Fuhrman JA (2005) Marine bacterial microdiversity as revealed by internal transcribed spacer analysis. Aquat Microbial Ecol 41: 15–23 Cho JC, Stapels MD, Morris RM, Vergin MS, Schwalbach MS, Givan SA, Barofsky DF and Giovannoni SJ (2007) Polyphyletic photosynthetic reaction centre genes in oligotrophic marine Gammaproteobacteria. Environ Microbiol 9: 1456–1463 Cogdell RJ, Howard TD, Isaacs NW, McLuskey K and Gardiner AT (2002) Structural factors which control the position of the Qy absorption band of bacteriochlorophyll a in purple bacterial antenna complexes. Photosynth Res 74: 135–141 Cottrell MT, Mannino A and Kirchman DL (2006) Aerobic anoxygenic phototrophic bacteria in the Mid-Atlantic Bight and the North Pacific Gyre. Appl Environ Microbiol 72: 557–564
Chapter 3
Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs
Denner, EBM, Vybiral D, Koblížek M, Kämpfer P, Busse H and Velimirov B (2002) Erythrobacter citreus sp. nov., a yellowpigmented bacterium that lacks bacteriochlorophyll a, isolated from the western Mediterranean Sea. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 62: 1655–1661 Du H, Jiao N, Hu Y and Zeng Y (2006) Real-time PCR for quantification of aerobic anoxygenic phototrophic bacteria based on pufM gene in marine environment. J Exp Mar Biol Ecol 329: 113–121 Evans K, Fordham-Skelton AP, Mistry H, Reynolds CD, Lawless AM and Papiz MZ (2005) A bacteriophytochrome regulates the synthesis of LH4 complexes in Rhodopseudomonas palustris. Photosynth Res 85: 169–180 Fenchel T (2001) Marine bugs and carbon flow. Science 292: 2444–2445 Fleischman D and Kramer D (1998) Photosynthetic rhizobia. Biochim Biophys Acta 1364: 17–36 Foesel BU, Gößner AS, Drake HL and Schramm A (2007) Geminicoccus roseus gen. nov., sp. nov., an aerobic phototrophic Alphaproteobacterium isolated from a marine aquaculture biofilter. Syst Appl Microbiol 30: 581–586 Fowler GJS, Visschers RW, Grief GG, van Grondelle R and Hunter CN (1992) Genetically modified photosynthetic antenna complexes with blueshifted absorbance bands. Nature 355: 848–850 Fowler GJS, Sockalingum GD, Robert B and Hunter CN (1994) Blue shifts in bacteriochlorophyll absorbance correlate with changed hydrogen bonding patterns in light harvesting LH2 mutants of Rhodobacter sphaeroides with alterations at Tyr44 and Tyr45. Biochem. J. 299: 695–700 Francia F, Wang J, Venturoli G, Melandri BA, Barz WP and Oesterhelt D (1999) The reaction center-LH1 antenna complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides contains one PufX molecule which is involved in dimerization of this complex. Biochemistry 38: 6834–6845 Fraser NJ, Hashimoto H and Cogdell RJ (2001) Carotenoids and bacterial photosynthesis: The story so far… Photosynth Res 70: 249–256 Fuchs BM, Spring S, Teeling H, Quast C, Wulf J, Schattenhofer M, Yan S, Ferriera S, Johnson J, Glöckner FO and Amann R (2007) Characterization of a marine gammaproteobacterium capable of aerobic anoxygenic photosynthesis. Proc Natl Acad Sci 104: 2891–2896 Gich F and Overmann J (2006) Sandarakinorhabdus limnophila gen. nov., sp. nov., a novel bacteriochlorophyll a-containing, obligately aerobic bacterium isolated from freshwater lakes. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 56: 847–854 Gich F, Schubert K, Bruns A, Hoffelner H and Overmann J (2005) Specific detection, isolation, and characterization of selected, previously uncultured members of the freshwater bacterioplankton community. Appl Environ Microbiol 71: 5908–5919 Giraud E and Fleischman D (2004) Nitrogen-fixing symbiosis between photosynthetic bacteria and legumes. Photosynth Res 82: 115–130 González JM, Covert JS, Whitman WB, Henriksen JR, Mayer F, Scharf B, Schmitt R, Buchan A, Fuhrman JA, Kiene RP and Moran MA (2003) Silicibacter pomeroyi sp. nov. and Roseovarius nubinhibens sp. nov., dimethylsulfoniopropionatedemethylating bacteria from marine environments. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 53: 1261–1269 Hartigan N, Tharia HA, Sweeney F, Lawless AM and Papiz MZ
53 (2002) The 7.5-Å electron density and spectroscopic properties of a novel low-light B800 LH2 from Rhodopseudomonas palustris. Biophys J 82: 963–977 Hiraishi A and Shimada K (2001) Aerobic anoxygenic photosynthetic bacteria with zinc-bacteriochlorophyll. J Gen Appl Microbiol 47: 161–180 Hucke O, Schiltz E, Drews G and Labahn A (2003) Sequence analysis reveals new membrane anchor of reaction centrebound cytochromes possibly related to PufX. FEBS Lett 535: 166–170 Igarashi N, Harada J, Nagashima S, Matsuura K, Shimada K and Nagashima KVP (2001) Horizontal transfer of the photosynthesis gene cluster and operon rearrangement in purple bacteria. J Mol Evol 52: 333–341 Ivanova EP, Pham DK, Wright JP and Nicolau DV (2002) Detection of coccoid forms of Sulfitobacter mediterraneus using atomic force microscopy. FEMS Microbiol Lett 214: 177–181 Ivanova EP, Bowman JP, Lysenko AM, Zhukova NV, Gorshkova NM, Kuznetsova TA, Kalinovskaya NI, Shevchenko LS and Mikhailov VV (2005) Erythrobacter vulgaris sp. nov., a novel organism isolated from the marine invertebrates. Syst Appl Microbiol 28: 123–130 Jiao N, Zhang Y and Chen Y (2006) Time series observation based InfraRed Epifluorescence Microscopic (TIREM) approach for accurate enumeration of bacteriochlorophyll-containing microbes in marine environments. J Microbiol Meth 65: 442–452 Karr EA, Sattley WM, Jung DO, Madigan MT and Achenbach LA (2003) Remarkable diversity of phototrophic purple bacteria in a permanently frozen Antarctic lake. Appl Environ Microbiol 69: 4910–4914 Kim B-C, Park JR, Bae J-W, Rhee S-K, Kim K-H, Oh J-W and Park Y-H (2006) Stappia marina sp. nov., a marine bacterium isolated from the Yellow Sea. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 56: 75–79 Kim MK, Schubert K, Im W-T, Kim K-H, Lee S-T and Overmann J (2007) Sphingomonas kaistensis sp. nov., a novel alphaproteobacterium containing pufLM genes. Int J Syst Microbiol Ecol 57:1527–1534 Klug G (1993) Regulation of expression of photosynthesis genes in anoxygenic photosynthetic bacteria. Arch Microbiol 159: 397–404 Koblížek M, Béjà O, Bidigare RR, Christensen S, BenetizNelson B, Vetriani C, Kolber MK, Falkowski PG and Kolber ZS (2003) Isolation and characterization of Erythrobacter sp. strains from the upper ocean. Arch Microbiol 180: 327–338 Koblížek M, Stoń-Egiert J, Sagan S and Kolber ZS (2005) Diel changes in bacteriochlorophyll a concentration suggest rapid bacterioplankton cycling in the Baltic Sea. FEMS Microbiol Ecol 51: 353–361 Koblížek M, Falkowski PG and Kolber ZS (2006) Diversity and distribution of photosynthetic bacteria in the Black Sea. DeepSea Res II 53: 1934–1944 Koblížek M, Mašín M, Ras J, Poulton AJ and Prášil O (2007) Rapid growth rates of aerobic anoxygenic phototrophs in the ocean. Environ Microbiol 9: 2401–2406 Kohler S, Schwarze C, Herter S, Gad’on N, Drews G and Labahn A (2005) Exploring the structure of the reaction center from the aerobic photosynthetic bacterium Roseobacter denitrificans with fourier transform infrared spectroscopy. In: van der Est
54 A and Bruce D (eds) Photosynthesis: Fundamental Aspects to Global Perspectives, pp 202–204. Alliance Communications Group, Lawrence Kolber ZS, Van Dover CL, Niederman RA and Falkowski PG (2000) Bacterial photosynthesis in surface waters of the open ocean. Nature 407: 177–179 Kolber ZS, Plumley G, Lang AS, Beatty JT, Blankenship RE, Van Dover CL, Vetriani C, Koblížek M, Rathgeber C and Falkowski PG (2001) Contribution of aerobic photoheterotrophic bacteria to the carbon cycle in the ocean. Science 292: 2492–2495 Komagata K (1989) Taxonomy of facultative methylotrophs. In: Harashima K, Shiba T and Murata N (eds) Aerobic Photosynthetic Bacteria, pp 25–38. Japan Scientific Societies Press, Tokyo and Springer-Verlag, Berlin Krinsky (1971) IX. Function. In: Isler O (ed) Carotenoids, pp 670–716. Birkhäuser Verlag, Basel Labrenz M, Lawson PA, Tindall BJ, Collins MD and Hirsch P (2005) Roseisalinus antarcticus gen. nov., sp. nov., a novel aerobic bacteriochlorophyll a-producing α-proteobacterium isolated from hypersaline Ekho Lake, Antarctica. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 55: 41–47 Lami R, Cottrell MT, Ras J, Ulloa O, Obernosterer I, Claustre H, Kirchman DL and Lebaron P (2007) High abundances of aerobic anoxygenic phototrophic bacteria in the South Pacific Ocean. Appl Environ Microbiol 73: 4198–4205 Larimer FW, Chain P, Hauser L, Lamerdin J, Malfatti S, Do L, Land, ML, Pelletier DA, Beatty JT, Lang AS, Tabita FR, Gibson JL, Hanson TE, Bobst C, Torres JLTy, Peres C, Harrison FH, Gibson J and Harwood CS (2004) Complete genome sequence of the metabolically versatile photosynthetic bacterium Rhodopseudomonas palustris. Nature Biotech 22: 55–61 Liebetanz R, Hornberger U and Drews G (1991) Organization of the genes coding for the reaction center L and M subunits and B870 antenna polypeptides alpha and beta from the aerobic photosynthetic bacterium Erythrobacter sp. OCh114. Mol Microbiol 5: 1459–1468 Macián MC, Arahal DR, Garay E, Ludwig W, Schleifer KH and Pujalte MJ (2005) Thalassobacter stenotrophicus gen. nov., sp. nov., a novel marine α-proteobacterium isolated from Mediterranean sea water. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 55: 105–110 Marchand EA and Silverstein J (2003) The role of enhanced heterotrophic bacterial growth on iron oxidation by Acidithiobacillus ferrooxidans. Geomicrobiol J 20: 231–244 Marrs B (1981) Mobilization of the genes for photosynthesis from Rhodopseudomonas capsulata by a promiscuous plasmid. J Bacteriol 146: 1003–1012 Masuda S, Matsumoto Y, Nagashima KVP, Shimada K, Inoue K, Bauer CE and Matsuura K (1999) Structural and functional analyses of photosynthetic regulatory genes regA and regB from Rhodovulum sulfidophilum, Roseobacter denitrificans and Rhodobacter capsulatus. J Bacteriol 181: 4205–4215 Murray RGE, Brenner DJ, Colwell RR, De Vos P, Goodfellow M, Grimont PAD, Pfennig N, Stackebrandt E and Zivarzin GA (1990) Report of the ad hoc committee on approaches to taxonomy within Proteobacteria. Int J Syst Bacteriol 40: 213–215 Nagashima KVP, Matsuura K, Wakao N, Hiraishi A and Shimada K (1997) Nucelotide sequences of genes coding for photosynthetic reaction centers and light-harvesting proteins of Acidiphilium rubrum and related aerobic acidophilic bacteria. Plant Cell Physiol 38: 1249–1258
Vladimir Yurkov and Julius T. Csotonyi Ouchane S, Steunou A, Picaud M and Astier C (2004) Aerobic and anaerobic Mg-protoporphyrin monomethyl ester cyclases in purple bacteria. J Biol Chem 279: 6385–6394 Oz A, Sabehi G, Koblížek M, Massana R and Béjà O (2005) Roseobacter-like bacteria in Red and Mediterranean Sea aerobic anoxygenic photosynthetic populations. Appl Environ Microbiol 71: 344–353 Peplies J, Glöckner FO, Amann R and Ludwig W (2004) Comparative sequence analysis and oligonucleotide probe design based on 23S rRNA genes of Alphaproteobacteria from North Sea bacterioplankton. Syst Appl Microbiol 27: 573–580 Pfennig N (1967) Photosynthetic bacteria. Ann Rev Microbiol 21: 285–384 Pfennig N (1978) Rhodocyclus purpureus gen. nov. and sp. nov., a ring-shaped vitamin B12-requiring member of the family Rhodospirillaceae. Int J Syst Bacteriol 28: 283–288 Pradella S, Allgaier M, Hoch C, Päuker O, Stackebrandt E and Wagner-Döbler I (2004) Genome organization and localization of the pufLM genes of the photosynthesis reaction center in phylogenetically diverse marine Alphaproteobacteria. Appl Environ Microbiol 70: 3360–3369 Rainey FA, Silva J, Bobre MF, Silva MT and da Costa MS (2003) Porphyrobacter cryptus sp. nov., a novel slightly thermophilic, aerobic, bacteriochlorophyll a-containing species. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 53: 35–41 Rappé MS, Connon SA, Vergin KL and Giovannoni SJ (2002) Cultivation of the ubiquitous SAR11 marine bacterioplankton clade. Nature 418: 630–633 Rathgeber C, Beatty JT and Yurkov V (2004) Aerobic phototrophic bacteria: new evidence for the diversity, ecological importance and applied potential of this previously overlooked group. Photosynth Res 81: 113–128 Rathgeber C, Yurkova N, Stackebrandt E, Schumann P, Beatty JT and Yurkov V (2005) Roseicyclus mahoneyensis gen nov., sp. nov., an aerobic phototrophic bacterium isolated from a meromictic lake. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 55: 1597–1603 Rathgeber C, Yurkova N, Stackebrandt E, Schumann P, Humphrey E, Beatty JT and Yurkov V (2007) Porphyrobacter meromictius sp. nov., an appendaged bacterium, that produces bacteriochlorophyll a. Curr Microbiol 55: 356–361 Rickard AH, Leach SA, Hall LS, Buswell CM, High NJ and Handley PS (2002) Phylogenetic relationships and coaggregation ability of freshwater biofilm bacteria. Appl Environ Microbiol 68: 3644–3650 Rohwerder T and Sand W (2003) The sulfane sulfur of persulfides is the actual substrate of the sulfur-oxidizing enzymes from Acidithiobacillus and Acidiphilium spp. Microbiology 149: 1699–1709 Rye R and Holland HD (1998) Paleosols and the evolution of atmospheric oxygen: A critical review. Am J Sci 298: 621–672 Salka I, Jost G, Jürgens K and Labrenz M (2006) Diversity and distribution of aerobic BChl a-producing bacteria in a depth profile of the central Baltic Sea. In: BIOspectrum Abstracts, VAAM Tagung Jena (PE42), p 142. Spektrum Akademischer Verlag GmBH, Heidelberg Schwalbach MS and Fuhrman JA (2005) Wide-ranging abundances of aerobic anoxygenic phototrophic bacteria in the world ocean revealed by epifluorescence microscopy and quantitative PCR. Limnol Oceanogr 50: 620–628 Schwarze C, Carluccio AV, Venturoli G and Labahn A (2000) Photo-induced cyclic electron transfer involving cytochrome bc1
Chapter 3
Aerobic Anoxygenic Phototrophs
complex and reaction center in the obligate aerobic phototroph Roseobacter denitrificans. Eur J Biochem 267: 422–433 Shiba T, Simidu U and Taga N (1979) Distribution of aerobic bacteria which contain bacteriochlorophyll a. Appl Environ Microbiol 38: 43–45 Siebert CA, Qian P, Fotiadis D, Engel A, Hunter CN and Bullough PA (2004) Molecular architecture of photosynthetic membranes in Rhodobacter sphaeroides: the role of PufX. EMBO J 23: 690–700 Sieracki ME, Gilg IC, Their EC, Poulton NJ and Goericke R (2006) Distribution of planktonic aerobic photoheterotrophic bacteria in the northwest Atlantic. Limnol Oceanogr 51: 38–46 Stackebrandt E, Frederiksen W, Garrity GM, Grimont PAD, Kämpfer P, Maiden MCJ, Nesme X, Roselló-Mora R, Swings J, Trüper HG, Vauterin L, Ward AC and Whitman WB (2002) Report of the ad hoc committee for the re-evaluation of the species definition in bacteriology. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 52: 1043–1047 Steiner R and Scheer H (1985) Characterization of a B800/1020 antenna from the photosynthetic bacteria Ectothiorhodospia halochloris and Ectothiorhodospia abdelmalekii. Biochim Biophys Acta 3: 278–284 Suyama T, Shigematsu T, Suzuki T, Tokiwa Y, Kanagawa T, Nagashima KVP and Hanada S (2002) Photosynthetic apparatus in Roseateles depolymerans 61A is transcriptionally induced by carbon limitation. Appl Environ Microbiol 68: 1665–1673 Suzuki T, Mori Y and Nishimura Y (2006) Roseibacterium elongatum gen. nov., sp. nov., an aerobic, bacteriochlorophyllcontaining bacterium isolated from the west coast of Australia. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 56: 417–421 Swingley WD, Gholba S, Mastrian SD, Matthies HJ, Hao J, Ramos H, Acharya CR, Conrad AL, Taylor HL, Dejesa LC, Shah MK, O’Huallachain ME, Lince MT, Blankenship RE, Beatty JT and Touchman JW (2007) The complete genome sequence of Roseobacter denitrificans reveals a mixotrophic as opposed to photosynthetic metabolism. J Bacteriol 189: 683–690 Uchino Y, Hirata A, Yokota A and Sugiyama J (1998) Reclassification of marine Agrobacterium species: Proposals of Stappia stellulata gen. nov., comb. nov., Stappia aggregata, sp. nov., nom. rev., Ruegeria atlantica gen. nov., comb. nov., Ruegeria gelatinovora comb. nov., Ruegeria algicola comb. nov., and Ahrensia kieliense gen. nov., sp. nov., nom. rev. J Gen Appl Microbiol 44: 201–210 van Berkum P, Leibold JM and Eardly BD (2006) Proposal for combining Bradyrhizobium spp. (Aeschynomene indica) with Blastobacter denitrificans and to transfer Blastobacter denitrificans (Hirsch and Muller, 1985) to the genus Bradyrhizobium as Bradyrhizobium denitrificans (comb. nov.). Syst Appl Microbiol 29:207–215 Wagner-Döbler I and Biebl H (2006) Environmental biology of the marine Roseobacter lineage. Ann Rev Microbiol 60: 255–280 Waidner LA and Kirchman DL (2005) Aerobic anoxygenic photosynthesis genes and operons in uncultured bacteria in the Delaware River. Environ Microbiol 7: 1896–1908 Waidner LA and Kirchman DL (2007) Aerobic anoxygenic phototrophic bacteria attached to particles in turbid waters of the Delaware and Chesapeake Estuaries. Appl Environ Microbiol 73: 3936–3944
55 Wayne LG, Brenner DJ, Colwell RR, Grimont PAD, Kandler O, Krichevsky MI, Moore LH, Moore WEC, Murray RGE, Stackebrandt E, Starr MP and Trüper HG (1987) Report of the ad hoc committee on reconciliation of approaches to bacterial systematics. Int J Syst Bacteriol 37: 463–464 Woese CR (1987) Bacterial evolution. Microbiol Rev 51: 221–271 Yoon J-H, Kim H, Kim I-G, Kang KH and Park Y-H (2003) Erythrobacter flavus sp. nov., a slight halophile from the East Sea in Korea. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 53: 1169–1174 Yoon J-H, Kang KH, Oh T-K and Park Y-H (2004a) Erythrobacter aquimaris sp. nov., isolated from sea water of a tidal flat of the Yellow Sea in Korea. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 54: 1981–1985 Yoon J-H, Lee M-H and Oh T-K (2004b) Porphyrobacter donghaensis sp. nov., isolated from sea water of the East Sea in Korea. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 54: 2231–2235 Yoon J-H, Kang KH, Yeo S-H and Oh T-K (2005a) Erythrobacter luteolus sp. nov., isolated from a tidal flat of the Yellow Sea in Korea. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 55: 1167–1170 Yoon J-H, Oh T-K and Park Y-H (2005b) Erythrobacter seohaensis sp. nov. and Erythrobacter gaetbuli sp. nov., isolated from a tidal flat of the Yellow Sea in Korea. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 55: 71–75 Yoon J-H, Kang S-J, Lee M-H, Oh HW and Oh T-K (2006) Porphyrobacter dokdonensis sp. nov., isolated from sea water. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 56: 1079–1083 Yurkov VV (2006) Aerobic phototrophic proteobacteria. In: Dworkin M, Falkow S, Rosenberg E, Schleifer K-H and Stackebrandt E (eds) Prokaryotes (3rd Edition), Vol 5, pp 562–584. Springer-Verlag, New York Yurkov VV and Beatty JT (1998) Aerobic anoxygenic phototrophic bacteria. Microbiol Mol Biol Rev 62: 695–724 Yurkov VV and Csotonyi JT (2003) Aerobic anoxygenic phototrophs and heavy metalloid reducers from extreme environments. In: Pandalai SG (ed) Recent Research Developments in Bacteriology, Vol 1, pp 247–300. Transworld Research Network, Trivandrum Yurkov V and van Gemerden H (1993) Impact of light/dark regimen on growth rate, biomass formation and bacteriochlorophyll synthesis in Erythromicrobium hydrolyticum. Arch Microbiol 159: 84–89 Yurkov VV, Krieger S, Stackebrandt E and Beatty JT (1999) Citromicrobium bathyomarinum, a novel aerobic bacterium isolated from deep-sea hydrothermal vent plume waters that contains photosynthetic pigment-protein complexes. J Bacteriol 181: 4517–4525 Yurkova N, Rathgeber C, Swiderski J, Stackebrandt E, Beatty JT, Hall KJ and Yurkov V (2002) Diversity, distribution and physiology of the aerobic phototrophic bacteria in the mixolimnion of a meromictic lake. FEMS Microbiol Ecol 40: 191–204 Yutin N and Béjà O (2005) Putative novel photosynthetic reaction centre organizations in marine aerobic anoxygenic photosynthetic bacteria: insights from metagenomics and environmental genomics. Environ Microbiol 7: 2027–2033 Yutin N, Suzuki MT and Béjà O (2005) Novel primers reveal wider diversity among marine aerobic anoxygenic phototrophs. Appl Environ Microbiol 71: 8958–8962
Chapter 4 Biosynthesis of Bacteriochlorophylls in Purple Bacteria Robert D. Willows* and Alison M. Kriegel Department of Chemistry and Biomolecular Sciences, Macquarie University, North Ryde, 2109, Australia
Summary ................................................................................................................................................................. 57 I. Introduction....................................................................................................................................................... 58 II. δ-Aminolevulinate to Protoporphyrin IX ............................................................................................................ 59 A. δ-Aminolevulinic acid Synthase.......................................................................................................... 60 B. δ-Aminolevulinic acid Dehydratase ................................................................................................... 62 C Hydroxymethylbilane Synthase ........................................................................................................... 63 D. Uroporphyrinogen III Synthase .......................................................................................................... 63 E. Uroporphyrinogen III Decarboxylase .................................................................................................. 64 F. Coproporphyrinogen Oxidase............................................................................................................. 64 G. Protoporphyrinogen Oxidase ............................................................................................................. 65 III. Protoporphyrin IX to Bacteriochlorophyll a and b ............................................................................................ 65 A. Magnesium Chelatase........................................................................................................................ 66 B. S-Adenosyl-L-methionine:Magnesium Protoporphyrin IX-O-methyltransferase................................. 71 C. Magnesium-protoporphyrin IX Monomethylester Oxidative Cyclase ................................................. 71 D. Modification of Vinyl Groups on Rings I and II ................................................................................... 72 E. Protochlorophyllide Oxidoreductase and Chlorin Reductase ............................................................. 73 F. Esterification to the Propionate on Ring IV ........................................................................................ 74 IV. Concluding Remarks ........................................................................................................................................ 75 Acknowledgments ................................................................................................................................................... 75 References .............................................................................................................................................................. 75
Summary The purple bacteria make bacteriochlorophylls for the photosynthetic mode of growth. These pigments are made from the simple precursors glycine and succinyl CoA and the initial steps in the pathway of bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis are shared with the vitamin B12 and heme biosynthetic pathways. This chapter concentrates on the biochemical properties of the enzymes involved in each step of the pathway and the discovery and assignment of the genes encoding these enzymes. The characterization of purple bacterial enzymes involved in these steps has been crucial in understanding similar enzymes from other sources. The characterization of the early steps in the pathway within purple bacteria, such as δ-aminolevulinate synthase, contributed significantly to the understanding of the mammalian enzymes in the 1950s and 1960s. More recently the study of the purple bacterial enzymes toward the end of the pathway has been instrumental in identifying and characterizing the orthologous enzymes from cyanobacteria and plants. In this review we present the details of the properties of these enzymes from the purple bacteria, such as purification methods and kinetic analyses from the early literature, through to more recent studies using recombinant purple bacterial enzymes. *Author for correspondence, email: [email protected]
C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty (eds): The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria, pp. 57–79. © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V.
58 I. Introduction The purple photosynthetic bacteria are able to derive their cellular energy from light, organic compounds, or inorganic compounds depending on the chemical and physical environment. This remarkable versatility usually means that one mode of metabolism is utilized at a time so as to prevent unnecessary biosynthesis of alternative energy systems. Thus photosynthetic metabolism and hence pigment biosynthesis only occurs under a limited set of conditions. In regard to their ability to produce bacteriochlorophyll there appear to be two main groups within the purple bacteria. The first group includes Rhodobacter (Rba.) sphaeroides, Rba. capsulatus, and Rhodospirillum rubrum, which photosynthesize and thus make bacteriochlorophyll anaerobically in the light; they can also synthesize significant amounts of pigment in the dark, but only under low aeration conditions. This indicates an oxygen and light dependent control over the genes encoding the enzymes involved in the synthesis of these pigments. The second group, which includes Rhodovulum sulfidophilum, Roseobacter sp. and Rubrivivax (Rvi.) gelatinosus, is able to synthesize pigments and to photosynthesize under both anaerobic and aerobic conditions in the light. As we shall see in this chapter the differences between these two groups are reflected in a number of the enzymes in the bacteriochlorophyll biosynthetic pathway. This is the first recent review devoted to the biosynthesis of bacteriochlorophylls in purple bacteria, although several recent reviews have been published on broader or more narrow aspects (Armstrong, 1998; Willows, 2003; Bollivar, 2006). As such we have attempted to include all references to the primary literature which span several decades. For some of the enzymatic steps in purple bacteria there has been limited study since the 1950s and 1960s, while a few enzymes have received considerable recent attention. In this chapter we will limit our discussion to the biosynthesis of bacteriochlorophylls which are found in the purple bacteria and the properties of the purple bacterial enzymes. We will not discuss the regulation of bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis Abbreviations: ALA – δ-aminolevulinate; ALAD – δ-aminolevulinic acid dehydratase; ALAS – δ-aminolevulinic acid synthase; CPO – coproporphyrinogen III oxidase; DPOR – dark allowed protochlorophyllide reductase; E. – Escherichia; HMB – hydroxymethylbilane; HMBS – hydroxymethylbilane synthase; MPE – magnesium protoporphyrin IX monomethyl ester; PPO – protoporphyrinogen oxidase; Rba. – Rhodobacter; Rvi. – Rubrivivax; SAM – S-adenosylmethionine
Robert D. Willows and Alison M. Kriegel in detail as this is covered elsewhere in this volume (Chapter 39, Zeilstra-Ryalls). Hemes, chlorophylls and bacteriochlorophylls are all tetrapyrroles and have the same basic tetrapyrrole skeleton. Apart from the differences in the substituent groups attached to the macrocycle the other key difference between these molecules is the degree of reduction of the macrocycle. Fig. 1 highlights the key differences in the position and level of reduction of the macrocycle of these molecules together with that of a porphyrinogen. Porphyrinogens, porphyrins and chlorin macrocycles are all found as intermediates in the synthesis of bacteriochlorophyll a, which has a bacteriochlorin-type macrocycle. The IUPAC numbering scheme will be used throughout this chapter as detailed in Fig. 2 but the trivial names of the bacteriochlorophylls and their biosynthetic intermediates will generally be used for both clarity and consistency with the primary literature rather than using the more complex systematic names. The structures of bacteriochlorophylls a and b, which are the primary photosynthetic pigments found in the purple bacteria, are shown in Fig. 2. The alcohol esterified to the 17-propanoate is usually phytol although Rhodospirillum rubrum has geranylgeraniol. The other major bacteriochlorophyll found in the purple bacteria is bacteriochlorophyll b which differs from bacteriochlorophyll a in that it has an 8-ethylidene instead of an 8-ethyl group. Mutagenesis studies have been a key feature in identifying the structural genes for the enzymes involved in the biosynthesis of bacteriochlorophyll. The later genes which are specific for bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis are located in what is termed the photosynthetic gene cluster in all purple bacteria which have been studied to date. The genes involved in bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis are given the prefix ‘bch.’ The earlier genes in the pathway have the prefix ‘hem’ as they are also involved in heme biosynthesis. As such the enzymes responsible for the synthesis of bacteriochlorophyll are shared with the heme biosynthetic pathway up to the intermediate protoporphyrin IX when the two pathways diverge with either insertion of iron by ferrochelatase to make heme or the insertion of magnesium by magnesium chelatase to make the first committed precursor of bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis, magnesium protoporphyrin IX. The following sections are divided into the reactions common to both heme and bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis followed by the reactions starting from protoporphyrin IX, which are unique to bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis.
Chapter 4
Bacteriochlorophyll Biosynthesis
59
Fig. 1. Tetrapyrrole macrocycles. Shading emphasizes conjugated double bond systems within the tetrapyrroles to highlight their differences.
Fig. 2. IUPAC numbering and structure of bacteriochlorophylls a and b.
Fig. 3. The two pathways for ALA biosynthesis. Gltx, glutamyl tRNA synthetase. Gtr, glutamyl tRNA reductase. HemL, glutamate-1semialdehyde aminotransferase. HemA, δ-aminolevulinate synthase
II. δ-Aminolevulinate to Protoporphyrin IX All tetrapyrroles are synthesized from the universal 5-carbon precursor δ-aminolevulinate (ALA). ALA can be synthesized via two different routes, shown in Fig. 3, which are known as the Shemin pathway and the C-5 pathway. The C-5 pathway is utilized
by all photosynthetic eukaryotes, archeae and most bacteria with the exception of the alpha-proteobacteria. Vertebrates, non-photosynthetic eukaryotes and the alpha-proteobacterial group of bacteria, which include the purple bacteria, utilize the Shemin pathway for ALA synthesis. The biosynthetic pathway from ALA to protopor-
Robert D. Willows and Alison M. Kriegel
60
Fig. 4. Biosynthesis of protoporphyrin IX from ALA. See Table 1 for details.
phyrin IX is shown in Fig. 4. Briefly, the enzyme ALA dehydratase catalyzes the condensation of 2 ALA molecules to produce the pyrrole porphobilinogen; 4 porphobilinogen molecules are then condensed to form the linear tetrapyrrole hydroxymethylbilane (HMB) by the enzyme HMB synthase; HMB is then cyclized to uroporphyrinogen III by uroporphyrinogen III synthase; uroporphyrinogen III is decarboxylated by uroporphyrinogen III decarboxylase to coproporphyrinogen III; coproporphyrinogen III is oxidatively decarboxylated to protoporphyrinogen IX by coproporphyrinogen III oxidase; and protoporphyrinogen IX is then oxidized to protoporphyrin IX by protoporphyrinogen IX oxidase. The individual reactions and the properties of the genes and enzymes are covered in detail in the following sections; mutations in genes encoding these activities as well as enzyme names and EC numbers are shown in Table 1. A. δ-Aminolevulinic acid Synthase The first committed step in the tetrapyrrole pathway is the formation of ALA. In animals, fungi, faculta-
tive aerobic bacteria and photosynthetic bacteria this reaction is catalysed by the enzyme δ-aminolevulinic acid synthase (ALAS). The enzyme was first isolated from Rba. sphaeroides (Kikuchi et al., 1958) and has since been isolated from a number of sources including other bacteria, fungi, yeast and animals (Ferreira and Gong, 1995; Oh-hama, 1997). The reaction catalysed by ALAS involves the condensation of glycine and succinyl-CoA. ALAS is highly specific for the substrate glycine. No other amino acids can be substituted in the reaction (Ferreira and Gong, 1995) while specificity for the second substrate, succinyl-CoA, is less stringent. Other acyl-CoA derivatives including malonyl-, β-hydroxybutyryl- and acetoacetyl-CoA allow reasonable enzyme activity, while acetyl- and n-valeryl-CoA are inactive substrates (Shoolingin-Jordan et al., 1997). Kinetic analysis shows the reaction takes place with an ordered bi-bi mechanism with glycine binding to the enzyme first, followed by succinyl-CoA with CoA being released first before ALA (Fanica-Gaignier and Clement-Metral, 1973). The reaction mechanism, shown in Fig. 5, is one
Chapter 4
Bacteriochlorophyll Biosynthesis
61
Table 1. Details of enzyme names, EC numbers, gene and mutant names for the purple bacterial enzymatic steps shown in Figs. 3 and 4. Enzyme ALA synthase
EC# 2.3.1.37
Gene names hemA hemT
References Neidle and Kaplan (1993b)
Notes on mutants Rba. sphaeroides mutants in which one or both genes are inactivated, mutants with a single gene mutation grew fine, whereas double mutants required exogenous ALA for growth
hemA
Wright et al. (1987)
Rba. capsulatus unable to synthesize ALA, requires exogenous ALA for aerobic growth and bacteriochlorophyll synthesis
ALA dehydratase
4.2.1.24
hem B
Hydroxymethylbilane synthase
2.5.1.61 (formerly 4.3.1.8)
hemC
Uroporphryinogen III synthase
4.2.1.75
hemD
Uroporphryinogen III decarboxylase
4.1.1.37
hemE
Coproporphryinogen oxidase
1.3.3.3 1.3.99.22
hemF hemN hemZ
Zeilstra-Ryalls and Schornberg (2006); Coomber et al. (1992)
Rba. sphaeroides requires HemF for aerobic growth
hemN (formerly hemF)
Coomber et al. (1992)
Rba. sphaeroides incapable of photosynthetic growth; excretes coproporphyrin III
Protoporphyrinogen oxidase
1.3.3.4
hemG hemY
in which glycine forms a Schiff ’s base with the pyridoxal phosphate cofactor, which is necessary for the activation of ALAS (Burnham and Lascelles, 1963). Studies with tritiated glycine show that condensation with succinyl-CoA subsequently takes place with the removal of the pro-R hydrogen atom of glycine (Akhtar and Jordan, 1968; Zaman et al., 1973). The condensation mechanism proceeds with stereochemical inversion (Abboud et al., 1974). It is, however, unclear if decarboxylation proceeds before or after release of the product from the pyridoxal cofactor. After the initial discovery of ALAS in Rba. sphaeroides (Kikuchi et al., 1958), the enzyme was purified from a number of sources. Early studies on ALAS from Rba. sphaeroides by Tuboi et al. (1970b) revealed two isoforms of the enzyme that could be separated by ion exchange chromatography on diethylaminoethyl-cellulose. These isoforms had similar kinetic properties (Km for glycine of 5 mM and for succinyl-CoA of 5 µM) but their relative
amounts differed with the growth conditions (Tuboi et al., 1970a). The first gene to encode ALAS (hemA) cloned from a photosynthetic bacterium was from a Rba. capsulatus cosmid library (Biel et al., 1988) and this is the only ALAS gene in this bacterium. Rba. sphaeroides, on the other hand, has two separate genes, as implied by the Tuboi study. The two genes, hemA and hemT (each 1,224 nucleotides in length with 407 codons), encode two isozymes which are homologous to each other as well to other previously characterized ALAS (Neidle and Kaplan, 1993a). A single functional hemA or hemT gene is sufficient to provide approximately wild-type ALA synthase levels (Neidle and Kaplan, 1993b). The two genes are, however, located on separate chromosomes and are subject to different regulation (Neidle and Kaplan, 1993a); see Chapter 39 (Zeilstra-Ryalls) on regulation of the tetrapyrrole pathway.
62
Robert D. Willows and Alison M. Kriegel
Fig. 5. Enzymatic mechanism for ALA synthase (Burnham and Lascelles, 1963; Akhtar and Jordan, 1968; Zaman et al., 1973; Abboud et al., 1974)
B. δ-Aminolevulinic acid Dehydratase The reaction catalysed by δ-aminolevulinic acid dehydratase (ALAD) represents the first step in the pathway conserved by all organisms that biosynthesize tetrapyrroles. ALAD, also called porphobilinogen synthase, catalyses the asymmetric condensation of two molecules of ALA to form porphobilinogen (PBG) and release two molecules of water. The ALAD-catalysed reaction is necessary to ensure that two ALA molecules condense in parallel, as opposed to the antiparallel reaction that occurs nonenzymatically. First identified in duck blood (Shemin and Russell, 1953), ALAD has since been isolated from a number of sources. The protein sequences
of ALADs are highly homologous across a broad range of species including mammals, yeast, plants and bacteria (Jaffe, 1995). The conserved nature of these sequences suggests that the catalytic function is probably the same for all organisms. Early work by Shemin (1976) and Nandi et al. (1968) on ALAD isolated from Rba. sphaeroides determined that the 8-subunit enzyme required the presence of a thiol reagent to maintain reducing conditions, and a metal cation to remain functional. In addition, they provided the first evidence that a Schiff ’s base is formed between the enzyme and substrate (Nandi et al., 1968; Shemin, 1976). Pyrrole synthesis requires two distinct binding sites on the ALAD enzyme for two identical ALA
Chapter 4
Bacteriochlorophyll Biosynthesis
63
substrates, termed ‘A-site’ and ‘P-site.’ The binding sites accept the ALA molecule that will form the acetic acid side chain (A-side ALA) and the propanoic acid side chain (P-side ALA) of the resulting porphobilinogen. Studies with human ALAD show that ALA binds first to the P-site of the enzyme and establishes a Schiff ’s base with a reactive lysine (Jordan and Gibbs, 1985). The detailed mechanism of the Pseudomonas aeruginosa ALAD was determined with the aid of crystal structures (Frankenberg et al., 1999; Frere et al., 2002). The reaction begins with the formation of a Schiff’s base between the 4-keto group of P-side ALA with a conserved lysine, Lys-260, in this sequence, followed by an additional molecule of ALA that binds to the A-site of the enzyme. The reaction proceeds with an aldol condensation and Schiff’s base formation with Lys-205. The removal of H+ from C-3 of the A-site yields an enamine. An aldol condensation allows the formation of a C-C bond between the A and P-site ALA before a Schiff ’s-base exchange produces an additional C-N bond. An H+ transferred to Lys 260 allows the trans-elimination of the P-site lysine. Finally, the pro-R H is removed from C5 of the P-site ALA resulting in the aromatization and release of the porphobilinogen. ALADs are metalloenzymes and the specific metal ion necessary varies among different species; bacterial enzymes rely exclusively on Mg2+ or on both Mg2+ and Zn2+, plant enzymes contain Mg2+ and mammalian enzymes generally utilize Zn2+. Some Mg2+ bacterial enzymes such as ALAD from Rba. sphaeroides are further activated by monovalent cations such as K+ (Nandi et al., 1968; Shemin, 1976). While the exact function of the metal ions has not been elucidated, Jaffe (1995) has suggested three different types of metal-binding sites called A, B and C harboring metals MeA, MeB and MeC. MeA is believed to aid in A-side ALA binding and reactivity. MeB does not appear necessary for activity, although its cysteine ligands were proposed to be involved in proton removal during product formation. MeC is proposed to bind at the subunit interface and to act as an allosteric activator.
al., 1979; Jordan et al., 1979). HMBS, encoded by the gene hemC, was originally referred to as uroporphyrinogen I synthase, thought to catalyze the formation of uroporphyrinogen I from four molecules of porphobilinogen. It is HMB, however, that cyclizes spontaneously to uroporphyrinogen I in the absence of uroporphyrinogen III synthase, the next enzyme in the pyrrole pathway (Burton et al., 1979; Jordan et al., 1979). Initial studies with HMBS isolated from Rba. sphaeroides confirmed that a covalent interaction was established with the first porphobilinogen, which becomes ring I. Subsequent porphobilinogen units are added while ring I remains covalently bound to the enzyme (Jordan and Berry, 1981). HMBSs have been isolated from a number of sources. Protein sequences are highly conserved across species. The structure of the E. coli HMBS was elucidated using X-ray crystallographic methods (Louie et al., 1992). It is made up of three distinct domains of approximately equal size connected by linkers that allow much flexibility as the pyrrole chain elongates. The activity of HMBS relies on a unique prosthetic group, a dipyrromethane cofactor. Through a thioether linkage, the cofactor is covalently attached to a cysteine residue in the active site of the enzyme (Jordan and Warren, 1987). The cofactor then serves as the covalent docking point for the 4 pyrroles to be added sequentially leading to the intermediates; ES, ES2, ES3 and ES4 (Berry et al., 1981, Warren and Jordan, 1988). The product, HMB is released while the cofactor remains attached to the enzyme. E. coli hemC mutants show the importance of highly conserved arginine residues in the binding site for the acetic acid and propionic acid side chains of the cofactor, as well as the substrate and intermediate complexes (Jordan and Woodcock, 1991; Lander et al., 1991) . The arginine residues are thought to help neutralize the amassed negative charges that build up from 12 carboxyl side chains in the ES4 intermediate. The presence of the cofactor may also help neutralize the electropositivity from these Arg residues in the active site (Louie et al., 1992).
C Hydroxymethylbilane Synthase
D. Uroporphyrinogen III Synthase
Hydroxymethylbilane synthase (HMBS), also called porphobilinogen deaminase, catalyzes the tetrapolymerization of porphobilinogen to yield HMB, an unstable linear tetrapyrrole intermediate (Burton et
Uroporphryinogen III synthase [4.2.1.75] catalyzes the conversion of HMB to uroporphyrinogen III by rearrangement and cyclization. The enzyme catalysed reaction occurs more quickly than the non-enzymatic
64 conversion to uroporphyrinogen I (Burton et al., 1979; Jordan et al., 1979) The enzyme encoded by hemD was originally called cosynthase. In this step of the tetrapyrrole pathway, the I and IV rings are joined in an asymmetrical manner to the reverse of the IV ring so that the pattern of alternating acetic and propionic acid side chains is disrupted, resulting in the type III asymmetry. Although uroporphyrinogen III synthase genes have been isolated from a number of different sources (though from an extremely limited number of purple bacteria), the proteins show little sequence similarity. Even the hemD sequences from three different strains of Rhodopseudomonas palustris show great variation with as little as 67% identity between protein sequences (Kanehisa, 1997; Kanehisa and Goto, 2000; Kanehisa et al., 2006). The crystal structure of the human uroporphyrinogen III synthase identified considerable flexibility in the active site and mutagenesis of 10 active site residues resulted in little variation in enzymatic activity (Mathews et al. 2001). Mutagenesis of the cyanobacterial uroporphyrinogen III synthase identified a tryptophan residue that was important but not essential for activity which is possibly involved in orientating the substrate in the active site (Roessner et al. 2002). Therefore little can be said for any inferred mechanism for this enzyme. E. Uroporphyrinogen III Decarboxylase The next step in the pathway involves the conversion of uroporphyrinogen III to coproporphyrinogen III and is catalyzed by the enzyme uroporphyrinogen III decarboxylase. The genes/cDNAs have been isolated from a number of prokaryotic and eukaryotic species and the HemE proteins show strong sequence identity, indicating that the enzyme mechanism is likely to be similar across different organisms (Jones and Jordan, 1993; Whitby et al., 1998). Studies with uroporphyrinogen III decarboxylase isolated from Rba. sphaeroides (Jones and Jordan, 1993) suggested the importance of both cysteine and arginine residues for the activity of the enzyme. Uroporphyrinogen III decarboxylase is interesting in that the enzyme isolated from both human (Deverneuil et al., 1983) and bovine (Straka and Kushner, 1983) sources needed no cofactors to remain active. Early studies based on porphyrin intermediates found in the feces of rats poisoned with hexachlorobenzene, suggests the decarboxylation of uroporphyrinogen III to coproporphyrinogen III takes
Robert D. Willows and Alison M. Kriegel place in an ordered sequence starting with ring IV, followed by I, II and III, consecutively (Jackson et al., 1976). In vitro studies with uroporphyrinogen III decarboxylase purified to homogeneity from Rba. sphaeroides suggest that the decarboxylation steps occur in a random order (Jones and Jordan, 1993). However, the substrate specificity of this enzyme is reduced in the presence of high substrate concentration giving a random order of decarboxylations while at low substrate concentration the decarboxylations occur in an ordered sequence (Kawanishi et al., 1983, Lash, 1991). Comparisons between the structures of both the human enzyme (Whitby et al., 1998) and that from Nicotiana tabacum (Martins et al., 2001) show a high degree of structural conservation. However, even with these structures, the mechanism of action of uroporphyrinogen III decarboxylase is still unclear. F. Coproporphyrinogen Oxidase The enzyme coproporphyrinogen III oxidase (CPO) catalyses the oxidative decarboxylation of the propanoates on rings I and II to vinyl groups to form protoporphyrinogen. Three isoforms exist; oxygendependent CPO, encoded by hemF, is found in eukaryotic and bacterial species and oxygen-independent CPO enzymes, encoded by hemN and the orthologous hemZ, are prevalent in prokaryotes that synthesize heme. The hemF genes are not widely represented among bacteria, and bacteria with hemF tend also to have hemN (Panek and O’Brian, 2002). HemN and HemF are unique in their protein sequence and utilize different cofactors. Both aerobic and anaerobic CPO activities were originally demonstrated in Rba. sphaeroides by Tait (1969). Oxygen-dependent CPO activity was localized in the soluble fraction of a crude cellular extract. This CPO activity required the presence of oxygen as the enzymatic reaction did not occur under anaerobic conditions, even when additional cofactors (see below) were added (Seehra et al., 1983). The oxygen-independent CPO required the combination of both the insoluble and soluble cellular fractions, in addition to the cofactors ATP, Mg2+, methionine, NADH and NADP+ for enzymatic activity (Seehra et al., 1983; Tait, 1972). The oxygen-independent CPO in Rba. sphaeroides was originally designated as a putative hemF as mutations in this gene resulted in coproporphyrin into the media. The sequence of this putative HemF had
Chapter 4
Bacteriochlorophyll Biosynthesis
little homology to HemF protein sequences in other species. The activity required ATP, methionine, Mg2+ and NADPH, which indicated that it was an anaerobic coproporphyrinogen oxidase (Coomber et al., 1992) and it has subsequently been determined that it is a HemN-type protein. The correct Rba. sphaeroides hemF gene, with homology to other HemF proteins was recently confirmed to be an oxygen-dependent CPO and the hemF gene is necessary for aerobic growth and is also differentially regulated by oxygen and light (Zeilstra-Ryalls and Schornberg, 2006). Two putative oxygen-independent isoenzymes, hemN (Coomber et al., 1992) and hemZ (ZeilstraRyalls and Kaplan, 1995), have been isolated from Rba. sphaeroides while Rba. capsulatus has a single isoform, orthologous to hemZ, which appears to be essential for heme production under both aerobic and anaerobic conditions (Smart et al., 2004). The oxygenindependent HemN orthologs are free radical SAM enzymes (Sofia et al., 2001). The proposed enzymatic mechanism for HemN shown in Fig. 6 was elucidated based on the crystal structure of E. coli CPO, HemN (Layer et al., 2003; Layer et al., 2005). G. Protoporphyrinogen Oxidase The final step in the formation of protoporphyrin IX is the six-electron oxidation of protoporphyrinogen IX. The enzyme protoporphyrinogen oxidase (PPO) catalyses this reaction, however, the reaction will proceed spontaneously in presence of molecular oxygen. PPO activity was demonstrated in Rba. sphaeroides by Jacobs and Jacobs (1981). Protoporphyrinogen oxidizing activity was associated with the membrane fraction under both aerobic and anaerobic growth conditions. Membranes from aerobically grown cells exhibited about 50% of the enzyme activity of membranes from anaerobically grown cells. The PPO activities of membranes from cells grown in both conditions were inhibited by cyanide. The genes encoding PPO have been identified from eukaryotes, designated hemG, and a number of prokaryotes, designated hemG or hemY. However no homologs to either hemG or hemY have been identified in the genomes of purple bacteria (Kanehisa, 1997; Kanehisa and Goto, 2000; Kanehisa et al., 2006). This situation is not unique as pointed out by Panek and O’Brian (2002); 14 out of 28 prokaryotic genera examined had no hemG or hemY homologs. The authors suggest the possibility that either an
65 unidentified PPO exists or a known protein has additional PPO activity. III. Protoporphyrin IX to Bacteriochlorophyll a and b The enzymatic steps from protoporphyrin IX onwards are unique to bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis unlike earlier steps which are shared with the heme and vitamin B12 biosynthetic pathways. Early work on this section of the pathway utilized inhibitors of bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis and mutants of Rba. sphaeroides to define some of the intermediates in the pathway. Some of the intermediates which accumulated in these mutants were the same as the intermediates which accumulated in Chlorella mutants characterized by Granick (Granick, 1948, 1949, 1950). This indicated that the pathways to chlorophyll and bacteriochlorophyll were likely to be similar. The use of mutants and inhibitors and the characterization of pigments which accumulated was one of the more useful methods in characterization of the pathway from protoporphyrin IX onwards (Jones, 1967). This methodology was continued using molecular genetic studies by Marrs and coworkers utilizing Rba. capsulatus to identify the genetic loci required for individual steps in bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis (Yen and Marrs, 1976; Marrs, 1981; Zsebo and Hearst, 1984; Young et al., 1989; Bauer et al., 1991). Similar studies were carried out on Rba. sphaeroides using complementation and transposon mutagenesis approaches (Hunter and Coomber 1988; Coomber and Hunter 1989; Coomber et al., 1990b) All of these studies pointed to a clustering of genes for pigment biosynthesis and photosystem proteins in both Rba. capsulatus and Rba. sphaeroides, an arrangement that has become known as the photosynthesis gene cluster. It has since been confirmed that all of the purple bacteria examined thus far exhibit some degree of clustering of photosynthesis-related genes, with the genes arranged in subclusters encoding bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis, carotenoid biosynthesis and photosystem components although there is overlap between these subclusters. There is also evidence of ‘superoperonal’ arrangement of genes with overlapping operons within the cluster (Bauer et al., 1991; Young et al., 1989). Initially it was believed that the order of genes within these clusters is conserved among the purple bacteria (Yildiz et al., 1992) although a comprehensive survey
66
Robert D. Willows and Alison M. Kriegel
Fig. 6. CPO free radical SAM mechanism (Layer et al., 2003; Layer et al., 2005). Scheme I shows the generation of the 5´deoxyadenosyl radical from SAM with release of methionine by HemN. Scheme II shows that reaction catalysed by HemN utilizing the 5´deoxyadenosyl radical to oxidatively decarboxylate the propionate on ring I to a vinyl group.
has recently shown that the gene arrangement is not conserved across the proteobacteriaceae although the genes are still clustered into functional groups (Béjà et al., 2002). The functions of the genes within these clusters has been probed by using transposon and insertional based mutagenesis procedures coupled with complementation and marker rescue techniques. The identity of the genes responsible for bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis was based on analysis of the pigments which accumulated and in many cases has since been confirmed by heterologous expression of the genes in E. coli and demonstration of enzymatic activity which will be discussed in detail below for the individual enzymes. These mutational studies and the corresponding references are summarized in Table 2 and the structures of the biosynthetic intermediates are shown in Fig. 7. A. Magnesium Chelatase Magnesium chelatase catalyses the ATP hydrolysis dependent insertion of magnesium into protoporphyrin IX and is a complex enzyme consisting of three distinct types of subunits. It is the first committed
step in chlorophyll biosynthesis as the preceding steps in the pathway are shared by the heme biosynthetic pathway (Willows and Hansson, 2003). Early studies by Gorchein (1972, 1973) indicated that the magnesium chelatase is a complex enzyme. Experiments with spheroplasts of Rba. sphaeroides suggested that ATP was necessary for enzymatic function and that activity was lost when the spheroplasts were lysed (Gorchein, 1972, 1973). Gorchein subsequently developed a continuous assay using spheroplasts (Gorchein, 1994) and later developed an in vitro magnesium chelatase assay using lysed Rba. capsulatus and Rba. sphaeroides cells (Gorchein, 1997). However, the first report of in vitro magnesium chelatase activity from a bacterial source was with the Rba. sphaeroides BchI, BchD and BchH proteins which were heterologously expressed in E.coli and the extracts mixed to yield magnesium chelatase activity (Gibson et al., 1995). Most of the subsequent details of the catalytic mechanism for magnesium chelatase have been gleaned from studies of heterologously expressed Rhodobacter and Synechocystis enzymes. Although the enzymes from different sources have slightly different properties the overall mechanism is likely to be
Chapter 4
Bacteriochlorophyll Biosynthesis
67
Table 2. Details of enzyme names, EC numbers, gene names, references and properties of mutants for the purple bacterial enzymatic steps detailed in Fig. 7. Enzyme Magnesium chelatase
EC# 6.6.1.1
Gene names bchI bchD bchH
Magnesium protoporphyrin IX: SAM O-methyltransferase
2.1.1.11
bchM
Magnesium protoporphyrin IX monomethyl ester oxidative cyclase/s
1.14.13.81
bchE acsF
Taylor et al. (1983); Hunter and Coomber (1988); Pinta et al. (2002)
Accumulate MPE
Protochlorophyllide reductase
1.18.-.-
bchLNB
Biel and Marrs (1983); Bollivar et al. (1994b); Yen and Marrs (1976); Marrs (1981); Coomber et al. (1990a)
Accumulate protochlorophyllide
8-Vinyl reductase
1.3.1.75
bchJ
Suzuki and Bauer (1995); Bollivar et al. (1994b)
Excretes divinyl protochlorophyllide
Chlorin reductase
1.18.-.-
bchX, bchY and bchZ
Young et al. (1989); Bollivar et al. (1994b) McGlynn and Hunter (1993)
Accumulates 3-hydroxyethyl chlorophyllide a.
3-Vinyl bacteriochlorophyllide a hydroxylase
bchF
Bollivar et al. (1994b)
Appears to accumulate 3vinyl bacteriochlorophyll a
3-Hydroxyethyl bacteriochlorophyllide a dehydrogenase
bchC
Wellington and Beatty (1990); McGlynn and Hunter (1993)
Accumulates 3-hydroxyethyl bacteriochlorophyllide a
bchG
Bollivar et al. (1994b); Coomber et al. (1990a); Addlesee et al. (2000)
Accumulates bacteriochlorophyllide a
bchP
Bollivar et al. (1994b); Addlesee and Hunter (1999)
Accumulates bacteriochlorophyll with geranyl geraniol esterified
Bacteriochlorophyll synthase
Geranylgeranyl reductase
2.5.1.62
similar but we will concentrate on the properties of the purple bacterial enzymes. Magnesium chelatase is now known to consist of three separate subunits, with the proteins called BchI, BchD and BchH in bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesizing organisms with orthologous proteins ChlI, ChlD and ChlH in organisms which synthesize chlorophyll (Jensen et al., 1996; Willows and Hansson, 2003). The first magnesium chelatase assay using purified components used the BchH, BchI and BchD proteins of Rba. sphaeroides that were heterologously expressed in E. coli (Gibson et al., 1995). The BchI and BchD proteins were expressed together as the genes for these proteins are part of the same operon. The BchI protein was highly expressed but no ap-
References Bollivar et al. (1994b); Coomber et al. (1990a); Gorchein et al. (1993); Marrs (1981); Taylor et al. (1983); Zsebo and Hearst (1984)
Notes on mutants Accumulate protoporphyrin IX
Reported mutations not definitively in bchM gene
parent expression of the BchD protein was observed on SDS-PAGE gels. The BchH protein was highly expressed and the cells and cell lysate were visibly red from accumulation of protoporphyrin IX, which was thought to be bound to the soluble BchH protein. Magnesium chelatase activity was only reconstituted when a cell extract from the BchI plus BchD coexpression strain was mixed with an extract from cells expressing the BchH protein in a buffer containing an ATP regenerating system. This indicated that all three proteins were required for activity and that the protoporphyrin bound to the BchH subunit was used as a substrate (Gibson et al., 1995). The first magnesium chelatase proteins to be purified to apparent homogeneity were the BchI and BchH
68
Robert D. Willows and Alison M. Kriegel
Fig. 7. Biosynthetic pathway for bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis from protoporphyrin IX. The gene products required for catalysis of each step are indicated. Further details of enzyme names are given in Table 2.
Chapter 4
Bacteriochlorophyll Biosynthesis
proteins from Rba. sphaeroides (Willows et al., 1996). The BchD protein was not purified to homogeneity but copurified with the E. coli chaperonin protein GroEL. When the BchH protein was purified to near homogeneity from the cell lysate, protoporphyrin IX was still found to be bound to the protein. Magnesium chelatase activity required all three proteins, ATP and magnesium but exogenous protoporphyrin IX was not absolutely required as it was bound to the BchH protein. The addition of protoporphyrin IX yielded higher activity and deuteroporphyin could be substituted for protoporphyrin as a substrate (Willows et al., 1996). The BchI, BchD and BchH proteins of Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus were heterologously expressed in E.coli both with and without an N-terminal 6xHis-Tag (Willows and Beale, 1998; Gibson et al., 1999). The purified BchH proteins had protoporphyrin IX bound (Willows et al., 1996; Willows and Beale, 1998) in a pigment to protein ratio of 1.3:1 (Willows et al., 1996) indicating that the protein has at least one high affinity porphyrin binding site. The BchH protein of Rba. capsulatus was slowly inactivated by light, presumably because of the bound protoporphyrin IX (Willows and Beale, 1998). While both the BchH and BchI proteins were soluble the BchD proteins formed insoluble inclusion bodies and required refolding from 6M urea. Effective refolding of the BchD subunits required ATP, MgCl2 and BchI protein. Thus the BchI appeared to be acting as a molecular chaperone to allow BchD to fold correctly or to stabilize the BchD once it was folded (Willows and Beale, 1998; Gibson et al., 1999). Magnesium chelatase activity was only reconstituted when all three subunits were present in the assay together with protoporphyrin IX, Mg2+ and ATP. Curiously although both the 6xHis-Tagged and non-His-Tagged Rba. sphaeroides proteins were able to reconstitute magnesium chelatase activity, the His-Tagged BchI protein of Rba. capsulatus could not reconstitute magnesium chelatase activity and only the non-His-tagged BchI worked in magnesium chelatase assays (Willows and Beale, 1998). In continuous assays a lag period was observed for both the Rba. sphaeroides (Willows et al., 1996) and Rba. capsulatus (Willows and Beale, 1998) enzymes before magnesium protoporphyrin IX was produced at a constant rate. This was similar to the lag period observed for the pea enzyme (Walker and Weinstein, 1994). This lag period could be overcome by preincubation of the BchI and BchD proteins with Mg-ATP
69 prior to addition of BchH and protoporphyrin IX to initiate the assay. This lag period was suggested to be due to the formation of an ATP dependent activation complex between the BchI and BchD proteins which was dependent on both the relative concentrations of subunits and the presence of ATP (Willows et al., 1996; Willows and Beale, 1998). This activation complex catalyses magnesium insertion into protoporphyrin only when combined with the BchH protein, Mg-ATP, protoporphyrin IX and Mg2+. In addition to the activation complex the BchH protein behaves as a substrate in the magnesium chelatase reaction and the purple bacterial enzyme has a Km of 1.34 µM (Willows et al., 1996; Willows and Beale, 1998; Gibson et al., 1999). The reported Km for protoporphyrin was 1.23 µM for the Rba. capsulatus enzyme (Willows and Beale, 1998) and 0.15 µM to 0.36 µM for the Rba. sphaeroides enzyme (Willows et al., 1996; Gibson et al., 1999). The kinetic constants for ATP and Mg2+ were also reported for the Rba. sphaeroides enzyme with Km values for Mg2+ of 0.12 ± 0.02 mM (Gibson et al., 1999) to 0.166 mM (Willows et al., 1996) and Km values for ATP of 1.7 mM (Willows et al., 1996) to 3.3 mM (Gibson et al., 1999). Binding affinity of deuteroporphyrin IX to the BchH subunit of Rba. sphaeroides was estimated using tryptophan fluorescence quenching, with the Kd estimated at 0.53 µM (Karger et al., 2001). The structure of the BchI protein from Rba. capsulatus was determined by X-ray crystallography and is shown as a ribbon diagram in Fig. 8 (Fodje et al., 2001). The BchI protein has an ATPase domain, shown as sections A and B in Fig. 8, and a four helix bundle domain, section C in Fig. 8. Both the structure and primary sequence of BchI show that it belongs to the extended ATPases Associated with a variety of cellular Activities (AAA+) class of proteins. Most structures of AAA+ proteins have two domains, an ATPase domain and a second domain that is positioned close to the ATP binding site. The position of this second domain in BchI, the four helix bundle domain, differs markedly from other AAA+ proteins as it is not close to the ATP binding site. In addition the ATPase domain has a number of extensions, see section A in Fig 8, which are not present in other AAA proteins (Fodje et al., 2001). The BchD protein also has an AAA+ domain at its N-terminus. AAA+ proteins are one of the largest and most diverse classes of proteins known and are represented in all organisms from all kingdoms (Confalonieri and Duguet, 1995; Glockner et al., 2000). The AAA+ proteins are
70
Fig. 8. Structure of BchI from Rba. capsulatus (Fodje et al., 2001) as a ribbon diagram. The ATPase domain is shown as segments labeled A and B. Section C is a four helix bundle domain. See text for further details.
known to form nucleotide-dependent ring structures, which are usually hexameric, and many types can form double hexameric rings. The BchI subunit was shown to form ATP dependent oligomers (Hansson et al., 2002) and these oligomers were found to be hexameric rings using single particle analysis of negatively stained electron micrograph images (Willows et al., 2004). The overall shape of the BchI subunit is wedge shaped suggesting that it fits into a hexameric complex. Site directed mutagenesis suggested that the ATPase activity of BchI was dependent on amino acid residues predicted to lie in adjacent positions in neighboring subunits within a predicted hexameric ring structure. Specifically, Arg289 was required for ATPase activity as when mutated to a Lys, ATPase activity was lost (Hansson et al., 2002). Arg289 is a so-called arginine finger found in other AAA+ proteins and is thought to mediate the ATPase activity and this residue is only adjacent to the ATP binding site when a neighboring subunit is present in a hexameric structure (Hansson et al., 2002). In AAA+ modules which form double ring structures the second ring often has an inactive ATPase and this ring presumably has a structural role. AAA+ proteins have also been called mechanoenzymes due to observed large conformational changes that
Robert D. Willows and Alison M. Kriegel occur upon ATP hydrolysis and also the mechanical nature of the processes in which many of these proteins are involved (Glockner et al., 2000). Both BchI and BchD have AAA+ domains which led to the suggestion that these subunits also form these double hexameric ring structures (Fodje et al., 2001; Willows and Hansson, 2003). Such a double ring structure would also be consistent with the ATP dependent activation phase required between BchI and BchD (Willows and Beale, 1998; Gibson et al., 1999) and the demonstration that an I-D complex can be formed in the presence of Mg2+ and ATP. The double ring structure would presumably catalyze an ATP-dependent conformational change in BchH to effect magnesium insertion into protoporphyrin IX which is bound to BchH (Karger et al., 2001; Hansson et al., 2002; Willows and Hansson, 2003). ATPase and phosphate exchange activities have been measured for BchI of Rba. sphaeroides and the BchH and BchD subunits had ATPase activity, although the BchD subunit was not pure (Hansson and Kannangara, 1997). The BchH ortholog of Synechocystis was also reported to have ATP hydrolysis activity, although the specific activity was 155-fold lower than for ChlI (Jensen et al., 1999) indicating that there was no significant ATPase activity. However, Mg-ATP increased the KD for porphyrin binding to ChlH (Karger et al., 2001) and also protected the ChlH from inactivation by a thiol modifying reagent (Jensen et al., 2000) suggesting that ChlH has a Mg-ATP binding site possibly involved in regulation (Karger et al., 2001). In contrast Mg-ATP had no effect on porphyrin binding to BchH from Rba. sphaeroides (Karger et al., 2001). A re-examination of the ATPase activity of the purple bacterial enzyme from Rba. capsulatus has shown that no ATP hydrolysis activity is associated with BchH of Rba. capsulatus and it is not required for protoporphyrin IX binding to BchH (Sirijovski et al., 2006). The purpose of the phosphate exchange activity in BchI is unclear but it is possible that the complex of six BchI subunits hydrolyses ATP sequentially and the exchange activity may be a measure of the reverse reaction. A number of inhibitors of the purple bacterial magnesium chelatases have been reported. The most unusual inhibitors were reported for the Rba. sphaeroides magnesium chelatase which was inhibited by both chloramphenicol and p-aminosalicylic acid in a study which showed that the enzyme activity was associated with ribosomes (Kannangara et al., 1997). Light has been shown to inhibit the magnesium
Chapter 4
Bacteriochlorophyll Biosynthesis
chelatase of Rba. capsulatus (Willows and Beale, 1998) and this mode of inhibition probably occurs via photooxidative damage of the BchH subunit (Willows and Beale, 1998; Willows et al., 2003). Sulfhydryl modifying agents were reported to inhibit the purple bacterial enzyme (Gorchein, 1997). These inhibitors have been used to analyze the Synechocystis enzyme. It was discovered that the cysteines in the ChlD subunit are not essential while those in ChlI and ChlH are essential. As mentioned above, inhibition of ChlH by thiol modifying reagents was partially alleviated by preincubation of ChlH with Mg-ATP and protoporphyrin IX before the treatment (Jensen et al., 2000). B. S-Adenosyl-L-methionine:Magnesium Protoporphyrin IX-O-methyltransferase S-adenosylmethionine:magnesium protoporphyrin IX-O-methyltransferase catalyses the S-adenosylmethionine (SAM) dependent methylation of the carboxyl group of the 13-propionate on magnesium protoporphyrin IX to form magnesium protoporphyrin IX monomethyl ester (MPE). This enzyme is membrane associated and the activity has been characterized for two Rhodobacter species, reviewed in Bollivar (2003). Characterization of this activity first occurred with the Rba. sphaeroides enzyme in the 1960s. The enzyme was found to be associated with the chromatophores, which are small vesicles on which the photosystems are assembled in these bacteria. The activity of cell-free extracts was characterized in terms of the substrate specificity and inhibition by substrate analogs. The methyl donor was S-adenosylmethionine and effective porphyrin substrates were magnesium protoporphyrin IX, zinc protoporphyrin IX and calcium protoporphyrin IX. However, non metal containing porphyrins as well as ferric protoporphyrin IX, ferrous protoporphyrin IX, manganic protoporphyrin IX and manganous protoporphyrin IX were not substrates for the monomethyl ester transferase (Gibson et al., 1963). The enzyme was partially purified and kinetically characterized from chromatophores of Rba. sphaeroides. The membrane bound activity was solubilized from the chromatophores with 1% w/v sodium cholate. The solubilized enzyme was then purified using S-adenosyl homocysteine coupled agarose. The kinetic mechanism was found to be sequential equilibrium ordered and the Km for SAM was given as 106 µM but no Km was given for magnesium pro-
71 toporphyrin IX (Hinchigeri et al., 1984). It was confirmed that the bchM gene encoded the methyltransferase in both Rba. capsulatus and Rba. sphaeroides when both enzymes were heterologously expressed in E. coli and the extracts shown to have S-adenosylmethionine:magnesium protoporphyrin IX-O-methyltransferase activity (Bollivar et al., 1994a; Gibson and Hunter, 1994). The activity of S-adenosyl-L- methionine:magnesium protoporphyrin IX methyltransferase, present in the membranes of an expression strain of E. coli into which the bchM gene of Rba. capsulatus had been cloned, was enhanced when mixed with recombinant BchH protein or with membranes of a bchH mutant of Rba. capsulatus, which did not have detectable methyltransferase activity (Hinchigeri et al., 1997). The authors took this to mean that the BchH protein stimulates the BchM activity however considering that the bchH mutant also stimulated activity it could also be taken to mean that the BchH and the membranes carried a stimulatory factor for the methyltransferase. More recent work using quenched flow analysis on purified proteins from the cyanobacterium Synechocystis suggests shows that the ChlH subunit affects methyltransferase activity during the pre-steady-state phase of the reaction and hence is involved in the reaction chemistry (Shepherd et al., 2005). C. Magnesium-protoporphyrin IX Monomethylester Oxidative Cyclase An oxidative cyclization is required to create the fifth ring of bacteriochlorophyll; this reaction is catalysed by magnesium protoporphyrin IX monomethyl ester oxidative cyclase. The 131-132 acrylate, the 131-hydroxy and the 131-keto derivatives of MPE were suggested as intermediates in the conversion of MPE to divinyl-protochlorophyllide by Granick (1949). However, although the hydroxy and keto intermediates have been detected in plants there is no evidence for the acrylate intermediate; for a review see Bollivar (2003). The origin of the oxo-group in ring V has been studied in the purple bacteria using 18O2 and/or H218O. It was found in Rba. sphaeroides that the oxo group is derived from water rather than molecular oxygen indicating that the reaction is catalysed by a hydratase (Porra et al., 1995). In contrast, the purple bacteria Roseobacter denitrificans and Rhodovulum sulphidophilum appear to incorporate 18O from both oxygen and water into the oxo-group on the
72 fifth ring of bacteriochlorophyll (Porra et al., 1996, 1998). Unlike Rba. sphaeroides, these two species make bacteriochlorophyll under both anaerobic and aerobic conditions which suggested that they have two different enzymes for oxidative cyclization. Molecular oxygen is preferentially incorporated into the oxo group on ring V in bacteriochlorophyll a when cultures of these bacteria are grown under aerobic conditions and oxygen from water is preferentially incorporated when the bacteria are cultured anaerobically (Porra et al., 1996, 1998). Mutation of the bchE gene in Rba. sphaeroides (Hunter and Coomber, 1988) and Rba. capsulatus (Yen and Marrs, 1976; Bollivar et al., 1994b) resulted in accumulation of MPE although it was not confirmed until later that it was MPE which accumulated (reviewed in Bollivar, 2003). The BchE protein sequences have a predicted 4Fe-4S cluster which may be involved in the reaction mechanism (Ouchane et al., 2004). Sequence analysis of BchE by Gough et al. (2000), found a putative cobalamin binding site within the BchE sequence. This binding site was suggested to have a functional role in a cobalamin mediated free radical mechanism in which an adenosyl radical from adenosyl cobalamin was used at each of five steps in the suggested seven step reaction mechanism to generate the isocyclic ring. An in vivo oxidative cyclase assay was developed using two different vitamin B12 requiring mutants of Rba. capsulatus grown in vitamin B12 deficient media. Addition of vitamin B12 under anaerobic conditions to this assay system restored oxidative cyclase activity with cyano cobalamin being most effective followed by adenosyl cobalamin. In addition the vitamin B12 requiring mutants of Rba. capsulatus were found to accumulate MPE when vitamin B12 was limiting, even when the cells were supplemented with methionine which requires vitamin B12 for its synthesis (Gough et al., 2000). Further sequence analysis of the BchE protein suggests that it is a free radical SAM enzyme like HemN as it contains the conserved CXXXCXXC motif (Sofia et al., 2001). This motif forms the previously mentioned 4Fe-4S cluster and is used as an electron donor to generate a 5´-deoxyadenosyl radical which acts as a proton radical acceptor to generate a radical on the propanoate side chain of the porphyrin (see Fig. 6). The mechanism shown in Fig. 9 is the one suggested by Gough et al. (2000) which involves adenosyl cobalamin as the free radical donor. In this mechanism the 4Fe-4S cluster acts as the electron do-
Robert D. Willows and Alison M. Kriegel nor to generate the radical from adenosyl cobalamin. This radical may be a deoxyadenosyl radical similar to the HemN mechanism or some other radical. In contrast to HemN the radical donor is used to create a 131-radical. However, unlike coproporphyrinogen III which has a free carboxyl group, decarboxylation cannot occur on MPE as the carboxyl group is methylated. The 131-hydroxy intermediate is then generated by loss of an electron to create a carbocation which reacts with a water molecule. Subsequent rounds of radical generation would result in generation of the 131-keto- intermediate and subsequently the final product. The gene encoding a protein required for the oxidative cyclase which incorporates molecular oxygen into the oxo-group of the isocyclic ring has been identified by mutagenesis of Rvi. gelatinosus. This organism is able to synthesize bacteriochlorophyll a under both aerobic and anaerobic conditions. Disruption of the acsF gene of Rvi. gelatinosus prevents bacteriochlorophyll a synthesis and causes accumulation of MPE under aerobic conditions but not under conditions of low aeration. The designation acsF stands for aerobic cyclization system Fe-containing subunit, as AcsF and its homologs have a conserved putative binuclear-iron-cluster motif (Pinta et al., 2002). The AcsF protein is homologous to previously identified genes in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii called Crd1 (Moseley et al., 2000) and Cth1 (Moseley et al., 2002) and homologs of AcsF were also identified in Arabidopsis thaliana and Synechocystis (Pinta et al., 2002). D. Modification of Vinyl Groups on Rings I and II Virtually all photosynthetic organisms require reduction of the 8-vinyl group of chlorophyll to an ethyl group. In the purple bacteria it was discovered that disruption of the bchJ gene results in excretion of divinyl protochlorophyllide but bacteriochlorophyll a was still produced (Bollivar et al., 1994b) When protochlorophyllide reductase mutants are generated in a disrupted bchJ strain of Rba. capsulatus a mixture of mono and divinyl protochlorophyllide accumulated but with the ratio skewed in favor of the divinyl form (Suzuki and Bauer, 1995). These reports suggested that the bchJ encoded an 8-vinyl reductase and also that the protochlorophyllide reductase favored the mono-vinyl substrate over the divinyl substrate. However, recent work has shown that bchJ does not
Chapter 4
Bacteriochlorophyll Biosynthesis
73
Fig. 9. Postulated free radical mechanism for the anaerobic cyclase reaction. X and •X are either 5´ deoxy adenosine and 5´ deoxyadenosine radicals or an alternative radical and product supplied from adenosyl cobalamin respectively.
encode an 8-vinyl reductase and the 8-vinyl reductase is encoded by the bciA gene in Chlorobium tepidum. These authors suggest that BchJ may be important in substrate channeling within the pathway (Chew and Bryant, 2006). The stereochemistry of the reduction of the 8-vinyl group in the purple bacteria was analyzed in the early 1980s by Battersby and Akhtar. The saturation of the double bond occurs with proton addition to the 81 and 82 carbons occurring in trans. The addition of the proton on the 82-position occurs from the re-face (Battersby et al., 1981) of the divinyl structure as is drawn in Fig. 6, while the proton addition to the 81position occurred on the si-face (Emery and Akhtar, 1985a). The modification of the 3-vinyl group of bacteriochlorophyll has been analyzed at the genetic level. The genes responsible for conversion of the vinyl into an acetoxy group have been identified by mutagenesis. The bchF gene product BchF appears to be responsible for hydration of the vinyl group to generate a hydroxyl intermediate. The bchC gene product BchC further oxidizes the hydroxyl group to a ketone. The enzyme which catalyses the first step appears to be able to utilize both protochlorophyllide or chlorophyllide as substrate based on the accumulation both hydroxy chlorophyllide and hydroxy proto-
chlorophyllide when bchC and bchXYZ are disrupted (Wellington et al., 1991; Bollivar et al., 1994b). E. Protochlorophyllide Oxidoreductase and Chlorin Reductase Two types of enzymes have been identified that reduce the D pyrrole ring of protochlorophyllide to form chlorophyllide in both the chlorophyll and bacteriochlorophyll biosynthetic pathways. Of these two enzymes the NADPH-protochlorophyllide oxidoreductase (EC 1.3.1.33 or EC 1.6.99.1, abbreviated POR) has been the subject of a large number of reviews (Hendrich and Bereza, 1993; Fujita, 1996; Reinbothe and Reinbothe, 1996; Reinbothe et al., 1996a,b; Adamson et al., 1997; Lebedev and Timko, 1998; Schoefs, 1999, 2001; Rüdiger, 2003; Heyes and Hunter, 2005). However this light dependent enzyme is not found in the purple bacteria. The purple bacterial enzyme is also known as a protochlorophyllide reductase and it is able to convert protochlorophyllide to chlorophyllide in the absence of light and hence has been given the acronym DPOR for dark allowed protochlorophyllide reductase to distinguish it from the single subunit light dependent enzyme (Armstrong, 1998; Fujita and Bauer, 2003). The genes encoding DPOR were identified from
74 tagged mutants which accumulated protochlorophyllide. Three tagged genetic loci, known as bchB, bchL and bchN, were identified in Rba. capsulatus (Zsebo and Hearst, 1984; Yang and Bauer, 1990; Burke et al., 1993b; Bollivar et al., 1994b) and Rba. sphaeroides (Coomber et al., 1990a) that resulted in protochlorophyllide accumulation. These genes have sequence similarity to polypeptides of the multisubunit eubacterial nitrogenase enzyme. Thus BchL is similar to NifH (Hearst et al., 1985; Burke et al., 1993a,b), BchN is similar to NifD and BchB is similar to NifK(Fujita and Bauer, 2003). In addition three other genes called bchX, bchY, and bchZ encode proteins which are similar to the to the BchL, BchN and BchB respectively (Burke et al., 1993c) and when these genes are disrupted they result in accumulation of chlorophyllide and chlorophyllide derivatives (Young et al., 1989; Bollivar et al., 1994b). Functional expression and purification of both the DPOR and the chlorin reductase from Rba. capsulatus have been achieved (Fujita and Bauer, 2000; Nomata et al., 2005; Nomata et al., 2006). For the DPOR expression in Rba. capsulatus, BchN and BchL proteins were produced with an N-terminal Strep-tag (S-tag) for purification. The proteins were purified using S-agarose under anaerobic conditions and the BchB protein copurified as a complex with the S-tagged BchN in what appeared to be a 1:1 stoichiometric ratio by SDS-PAGE. Reconstitution of protochlorophyllide reductase activity required the S-tagged BchN:BchB complex, S-tagged BchL, 1 mM ATP, an ATP regeneration system, 5 mM MgCl2, 10 mM sodium dithionite (an electron donor), and 2 µM protochlorophyllide (Fujita and Bauer, 2000). Optimization of the expression system resulted in higher yields of these proteins and protein complexes required for further biochemical analysis (Nomata et al., 2005). Kinetic analysis of the DPOR revealed an apparent Km of 10.6 µM for protochlorophyllide. Dithionite could be replaced as the electron donor by ferredoxin from maize together with NADPH and ferredoxin reductase indicating that ferredoxin is the likely electron donor in vivo. Gel filtration analysis of the BchN:BchB complex gave an estimated molecular weight of 200 kDa indicative of a tetramer consisting of 2 BchN subunits and 2 BchB subunits similar to the heterotetramer of nitrogenase. BchL chromatographed as a dimer which is also similar to nitrogenase where the orthologous NifH is also a dimer (Nomata et al., 2005).
Robert D. Willows and Alison M. Kriegel The chlorin reductase has also been expressed in Rba. capsulatus using the same strategy as for DPOR subunit expression. Similar to the DPOR expression the non-S-tagged BchZ copurified with S-tagged BchY on S-agarose in what appeared to be a 1:1 ratio and S-tagged BchX was also purified using S-agarose. Reconstitution of chlorin reductase activity required the S-tagged BchY : BchZ complex, S-tagged BchX, 2 mM ATP, an ATP regeneration system, 5 mM MgCl2, 0.7 mM sodium dithionite (an electron donor), and 2 µM chlorophyllide a. The product generated in this reaction was 3-vinyl bacteriochlorophyllide a (Nomata et al., 2006). Protochlorophyllide was not a substrate for the chlorin reductase. Both of these expression systems will allow further biochemical analysis of the proteins and protein complexes and will facilitate comparative studies of the two enzymes to understand the catalytic mechanism and substrate specificity. F. Esterification to the Propionate on Ring IV Bacteriochlorophyll a synthesis is completed with the esterification of bacteriochlorophyllide a with a geranylgeraniol onto the 17 propanoate moiety. This is then followed by reduction of this esterified geranylgeraniol to phytol. The esterification reaction is catalysed by bacteriochlorophyll synthase. The bacteriochlorophyll synthase gene, bchG, has been cloned and heterologously expressed in E. coli from both Rba. capsulatus (Oster et al., 1997) and Rba. sphaeroides (Addlesee et al., 2000). BchG is orthologous to the plant chlorophyll synthase ChlG but the recombinant bacteriochlorophyll synthase could not utilize chlorophyllide as substrate. Both phytyl-pyrophosphate and geranylgeranyl-pyrophosphate are substrates for bacteriochlorophyll synthases of Rba. capsulatus with phytyl-pyrophosphate being the preferred substrate (Oster et al., 1997). The mechanism of esterification was shown by Emery and Akhtar (1985b) to be one of nucleophilic attack as the oxygens of the carboxyl group are retained in the esterification process. It appears that reduction of geranylgeraniol to phytol may occur either before or after esterification to bacteriochlorophyllide a. BchP was heterologously expressed in E. coli and the expressed product was demonstrated to convert bacteriochlorophyll a esterified with geranylgeraniol into bacteriochlorophyll a esterified with phytol. It is not clear if the enzyme could convert geranylgeranyl-pyrophosphate
Chapter 4
Bacteriochlorophyll Biosynthesis
into phytyl-pyrophosphate (Addlesee and Hunter, 1999). IV. Concluding Remarks From this chapter it is obvious that there are significant gaps in our knowledge on bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis in purple bacteria. To correct this shortfall in our knowledge of this pathway genes encoding the protoporphyrinogen oxidase and the genes responsible for bacteriochlorophyll b synthesis need to be identified. This should be possible given that the complete genome sequences for a number of purple bacteria are known. In addition a number of biosynthetic steps have not been the subject of any significant biochemical analysis or have been recalcitrant to further analysis. These steps include those catalyzed by magnesium-protoporphyrin IX monomethylester oxidative cyclase, 3-vinyl bacteriochlorophyllide a hydroxylase and 3-hydroxyethyl bacteriochlorophyllide a dehydrogenase. It is hoped that these shortfalls in our knowledge and understanding of this pathway will be addressed in the near future. Acknowledgments This work was made possible thanks to a Macquarie University Research Development Grant to R.D.W. Thanks also to D. W. Bollivar for supplying a preprint of his review. References Abboud MM, Jordan PM and Akhtar M (1974) Biosynthesis of 5-aminolevulinic acid: Involvement of a retention-inversion mechanism. J Chem Soc Chem Comm: 643–644 Adamson HY, Hiller RG and Walmsley J (1997) Protochlorophyllide reduction and greening in angiosperms: An evolutionary perspective. J Photochem Photobiol B 41: 201–221 Addlesee HA and Hunter CN (1999) Physical mapping and functional assignment of the geranylgeranyl-bacteriochlorophyll reductase gene, bchP, of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Bacteriol 181: 7248–7255 Addlesee HA, Fiedor L and Hunter CN (2000) Physical mapping of bchG, orf427, and orf177 in the photosynthesis gene cluster of Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Functional assignment of the bacteriochlorophyll synthetase gene. J Bacteriol 182: 3175–3182 Akhtar M and Jordan PM (1968) Mechanism of action of δaminolaevulate synthetase and synthesis of stereospecifically tritiated glycine. Chem Comm: 1691–1692
75 Armstrong GA (1998) Greening in the dark: Light-independent chlorophyll biosynthesis from anoxygenic photosynthetic bacteria to gymnosperms. J Photochem Photobiol 43: 87–100 Battersby AR, Gutman AL, Fookes CJR, Gunther H and Simon H (1981) Stereochemistry of formation of methyl and ethyl groups in bacteriochlorophyll-a. J Chem Soc Chem Comm: 645–647 Bauer CE, Buggy JJ, Yang ZM and Marrs BL (1991) The superoperonal organization of genes for pigment biosynthesis and reaction center proteins is a conserved feature in Rhodobacter capsulatus: Analysis of overlapping bchB and puhA transcripts. Mol Gen Genet 228: 433–444 Béjà O, Suzuki MT, Heidelberg JF, Nelson WC, Preston CM, Hamada T, Eisen JA, Fraser CM and DeLong EF (2002) Unsuspected diversity among marine aerobic anoxygenic phototrophs. Nature 415: 630–633 Berry A, Jordan PM and Seehra JS (1981) The isolation and characterization of catalytically competent porphobilinogen deaminase-intermediate complexes. FEBS Lett 129: 220–224 Biel AJ and Marrs BL (1983) Transcriptional regulation of several genes for bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis in Rhodopseudomonas capsulata in response to oxygen. J Bacteriol 156: 686–694 Biel SW, Wright MS and Biel AJ (1988) Cloning of the Rhodobacter capsulatus hemA gene. J Bacteriol 170: 4382–4384 Bollivar DW (2003) Intermediate steps in chlorophyll biosynthesis: Methylation and cyclization. In: Kadish KM, Smith K and Guilard R (eds) The Porphyrin Handbook II, Vol 13 pp 49–69. Academic Press, New York Bollivar DW (2006) Recent advances in chlorophyll biosynthesis. Photosynth Res 89: 1–22 Bollivar DW, Jiang ZY, Bauer CE and Beale SI (1994a) Heterologous expression of the bchM gene product from Rhodobacter capsulatus and demonstration that it encodes S-adenosylL-methionine:Mg-protoporphyrin IX methyltransferase. J Bacteriol 176: 5290–5296 Bollivar DW, Suzuki JY, Beatty JT, Dobrowolski JM and Bauer CE (1994b) Directed mutational analysis of bacteriochlorophyll a biosynthesis in Rhodobacter capsulatus. J Mol Biol 237: 622–640 Burke DH, Hearst JE and Sidow A (1993a) Early evolution of photosynthesis: Clues from nitrogenase and chlorophyll iron proteins. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 90: 7134–7138 Burke DH, Alberti M and Hearst JE (1993b) bchFNBH bacteriochlorophyll synthesis genes of Rhodobacter capsulatus and identification of the third subunit of light-independent protochlorophyllide reductase in bacteria and plants. J Bacteriol 175: 2414–2422 Burke DH, Alberti M and Hearst JE (1993c) The Rhodobacter capsulatus chlorin reductase-encoding locus, bchA, consists of three genes, bchX, bchY, and bchZ. J Bacteriol 175: 2407–2413 Burnham BF and Lascelles J (1963) Control of porphyrin biosynthesis through a negative-feedback mechanism—studies with preparations of δ-aminolaevulate synthetase and δ-aminolaevulate dehydratase from Rhodopseudomonas spheroides. Biochem J 87: 462–472 Burton G, Fagerness PE, Hosozawa S, Jordan PM and Scott AI (1979) C-13 NMR evidence for a new intermediate, pre-uroporphyrinogen, in the enzymic transformation of porphobilinogen into uroporphyrinogen-I and -uroporphyrinogen-III. J Chem Soc Chem Comm: 202–204
76 Chew AGM and Bryant DA (2006) Characterization of a plantlike protochlorophyllide a divinyl reductase in green sulfur bacteria J Biol Chem 282: 2967–2975 Confalonieri F and Duguet M (1995) A 200-amino acid ATPase module in search of a basic function. Bioessays 17: 639–650 Coomber SA and Hunter CN (1989) Construction of a physical map of the 45 kb photosynthetic gene cluster of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Archives of Microbiology 151: 454–458 Coomber SA, Chaudri M and Hunter CN (1990a) The cloning and organization of genes for bacteriochlorophyll and carotenoid biosynthesis in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. FEMS Symposium 53: 49–56 Coomber SA, Chaudhri M, Connor A, Britton G and Hunter CN (1990b) Localized transposon Tn5 mutagenesis of the photosynthetic gene cluster of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Mol Microbiol 4: 977–989 Coomber SA, Jones RM, Jordan PM and Hunter CN (1992) A putative anaerobic coproporphyrinogen III oxidase in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. I. Molecular cloning, transposon mutagenesis and sequence analysis of the gene. Mol Microbiol 6: 3159–3169 Deverneuil H, Sassa S and Kappas A (1983) Purification and properties of uroporphyrinogen decarboxylase from humanerythrocytes. A single enzyme catalyzing the 4 sequential decarboxylations of uroporphyrinogen-I and uroporphyrinogen-III. J Biol Chem 258: 2454–2460 Emery VC and Akhtar M (1985a) Stereochemistry of the generation of the ethyl group in bacteriochlorophyll a biosynthesis. J Chem Soc Chem Comm: 1646–1647. Emery VC and Akhtar M (1985b) Mechanistic studies on the phytylation step in bacteriochlorophyll a biosynthesis: An application of the oxygen-18 induced isotope effect in carbon-13 NMR spectroscopy. J Chem Soc Chem Comm: 600–601 Fanica-Gaignier M and Clement-Metral J (1973) 5-Aminolevulinic-acid synthetase of Rhodopseudomonas spheroides Y. Kinetic mechanism and inhibition by ATP. Eur J Biochem 40: 19–24 Ferreira GC and Gong J (1995) 5-Aminolevulinate synthase and the first step of heme-biosynthesis. J Bioenerg Biomem 27: 151–159 Fodje MN, Hansson A, Hansson M, Olsen JG, Gough S, Willows RD and Al-Karadaghi S (2001) Interplay between an AAA module and an integrin I domain may regulate the function of magnesium chelatase. J Mol Biol 311: 111–122 Frankenberg N, Erskine PT, Cooper JB, Shoolingin-Jordan PM, Jahn D and Heinz DW (1999) High resolution crystal structure of a Mg2+-dependent porphobilinogen synthase. J Mol Biol 289: 591–602 Frere F, Schubert WD, Stauffer F, Frankenberg N, Neier R, Jahn D and Heinz DW (2002) Structure of porphobilinogen synthase from Pseudomonas aeruginosa in complex with 5fluorolevulinic acid suggests a double Schiff base mechanism. J Mol Biol 320: 237–247 Fujita Y (1996) Protochlorophyllide reduction: A key step in the greening of plants. Plant Cell Physiol 37: 411–421 Fujita Y and Bauer CE (2000) Reconstitution of light-independent protochlorophyllide reductase from purified BChl and BchN-BchB subunits. In vitro confirmation of nitrogenase-like features of a bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis enzyme. J Biol Chem 275: 23583–23588 Fujita Y and Bauer C (2003) The light-independent protochlorophyllide reductase: A nitrogenase-like enzyme catalyzing a
Robert D. Willows and Alison M. Kriegel key reaction for greening in the dark. In: Kadish KM, Smith K and Guilard R (eds) The Porphyrin Handbook II, Vol 13, pp. 109–156, Academic Press, New York Gibson KD, Neuberger A and Tait GH (1963) Biosynthesis of porphyrin and bacteriochlorophyll by Rhodopseudomonas spheroides. IV. S-Adenosylmethionine-magnesium protoporphyrin methyltransferase. Biochem J 88: 325–334 Gibson LCD and Hunter CN (1994) The bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis gene, bchM, of Rhodobacter sphaeroides encodes S-adenosyl-L-methionine: Mg protoporphyrin IX methyltransferase. FEBS Lett 352: 127–130 Gibson LCD, Willows RD, Kannanagara CG, von Wettstein D and Hunter CN (1995) Magnesium-protoporphyrin chelatase of Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Reconstitution of activity by combining the products of the bchH, -I, and -D genes expressed in Escherichia coli. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 92: 1941–1944 Gibson LCD, Jensen PE and Hunter CN (1999) Magnesium chelatase from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: initial characterization of the enzyme using purified subunits and evidence for a BchI-BchD complex. Biochem J 337: 243–251 Glockner G, Rosenthal A and Valentin K (2000) The structure and gene repertoire of an ancient red algal plastid genome. J Mol Evol 51: 382–390 Gorchein A (1972) Magnesium protoporphyrin chelatase activity in Rhodopseudomonas spheroides. Studies with whole cells. Biochem J 127: 97–106 Gorchein A (1973) Control of magnesium-protoporphyrin chelatase activity in Rhodopseudomonas spheroides. Role of light, oxygen, and electron and energy transfer. Biochem J 134: 833–845 Gorchein A (1994) Uptake of protoporphyrin and continuous spectrophotometric assay for magnesium chelatase in Rhodobacter spheroides. Biochem J 299: 869–874 Gorchein A (1997) Cell-free activity of magnesium chelatase in Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Rhodobacter capsulatus. Biochem Soc Trans 25: 82S Gorchein A, Gibson LCD and Hunter CN (1993) Gene expression and control of enzymes for synthesis of magnesium protoporphyrin monomethyl ester in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochem Soc Trans 21: 201S Gough SP, Petersen BO and Duus JO (2000) Anaerobic chlorophyll isocyclic ring formation in Rhodobacter capsulatus requires a cobalamin cofactor. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 97: 6908–6913 Granick S (1948) Protoporphyrin IX as a precursor of chlorophyll. J Biol Chem 172: 717–727 Granick S (1949) The structural and functional relations between heme and chlorophyll. Harvey Lectures Ser 44: 220–245 Granick S (1950) Magnesium vinyl pheoporphyrin a5, another intermediate in the biological synthesis of chlorophyll. J Biol Chem 183: 713–730 Hansson A, Willows RD, Roberts TH and Hansson M (2002) Three semidominant barley mutants with single amino acid substitutions in the smallest magnesium chelatase subunit form defective AAA+ hexamers. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 99: 13944–13949 Hansson M and Kannangara CG (1997) ATPases and phosphate exchange activities in magnesium chelatase subunits of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 94: 13351–13356 Hearst JE, Alberti M and Doolittle RF (1985) A putative nitrogenase reductase gene found in the nucleotide sequences
Chapter 4
Bacteriochlorophyll Biosynthesis
from the photosynthetic gene cluster of R. capsulata. Cell 40: 219–220 Hendrich W and Bereza B (1993) Spectroscopic characterization of protochlorophyllide and its transformation. Photosynthetica 28: 1–16 Heyes DJ and Hunter CN (2005) Making light work of enzyme catalysis: Protochlorophyllide oxidoreductase. Trends Biochem Sci 30: 642–649 Hinchigeri SB, Nelson DW and Richards WR (1984) The purification and reaction mechanism of S-adenosyl-L-methionine: magnesium protoporphyrin methyltransferase from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. Photosynthetica 18: 168–178 Hinchigeri SB, Hundle B and Richards WR (1997) Demonstration that the BchH protein of Rhodobacter capsulatus activates S-adenosyl-L-methionine:magnesium protoporphyrin IX methyltransferase. FEBS Lett 407: 337–342 Hunter CN and Coomber SA (1988) Cloning and oxygen-regulated expression of the bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis genes bch E, B, A and C of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Gen Microbiol 134: 1491–1497 Jackson AH, Sancovich HA, Ferramola AM, Evans N, Games DE, Matlin SA, Elder GH and Smith SG (1976) Macrocyclic Intermediates in biosynthesis of porphyrins. Phil Trans Royal Soc London B-Biol Sci 273: 191–206 Jacobs NJ and Jacobs JM (1981) Protoporphyrinogen oxidation in Rhodopseudomonas-spheroides, a step in heme and bacteriochlorophyll synthesis. Arch Biochem Biophys 211: 305–311 Jaffe EK (1995) Porphobilinogen synthase, the first source of heme symmetry. J Bioenerg Biomem 27: 169–179 Jensen PE, Gibson LCD, Henningsen KW and Hunter CN (1996) Expression of the chlI, chlD, and chlH genes from the cyanobacterium Synechocystis PCC6803 in Escherichia coli and demonstration that the three cognate proteins are required for magnesium-protoporphyrin chelatase activity. J Biol Chem 271: 16662–16667 Jensen PE, Gibson LCD and Hunter CN (1999) ATPase activity associated with the magnesium-protoporphyrin IX chelatase enzyme of Synechocystis PCC6803: evidence for ATP hydrolysis during Mg2+ insertion, and the MgATP-dependent interaction of the ChlI and ChlD subunits. Biochem J 339: 127–134 Jensen PE, Reid JD and Hunter CN (2000) Modification of cysteine residues in the ChlI and ChlH subunits of magnesium chelatase results in enzyme inactivation. Biochem J 352: 435–441 Jones OTG (1967) Intermediates in chlorophyll biosynthesis in Rhodopseudomonas spheroides. Effects of substrates and inhibitors. Phytochemistry 6: 1355–1362 Jones RM and Jordan PM (1993) Purification and properties of the uroporphyrinogen decarboxylase from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochem J 293: 703–712 Jordan PM and Berry A (1981) Mechanism of action of porphobilinogen deaminase. The participation of stable enzyme substrate covalent intermediates between porphobilinogen and the porphobilinogen deaminase from Rhodopseudomonasspheroides. Biochem J 195: 177–181 Jordan PM and Gibbs PNB (1985) Mechanism of action of 5-aminolaevulinate dehydratase from human-erythrocytes. Biochem J 227: 1015–1020 Jordan PM and Warren MJ (1987) Evidence for a dipyrromethane cofactor at the catalytic site of Escherichia coli porphobilinogen deaminase. FEBS Lett 225: 87–92 Jordan PM and Woodcock SC (1991) Mutagenesis of arginine
77 residues in the catalytic cleft of Escherichia coli porphobilinogen deaminase that affects dipyrromethane cofactor assembly and tetrapyrrole chain initiation and elongation. Biochemical J 280: 445–449 Jordan PM, Burton G, Nordlov H, Schneider MM, Pryde L and Scott AI (1979) Pre-uroporphyrinogen: Substrate for uroporphyrinogen-III cosynthetase. J Chem Soc Chem Comm: 204–205 Kanehisa M (1997) A database for post-genome analysis. Trends Gen. 13: 375–376 Kanehisa M and Goto S (2000) KEGG: Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes. Nucleic Acid Res 28: 27–30 Kanehisa M, Goto S, Hattori M, Aoki-Kinoshita KF, Itoh M, Kawashima S, Katayama T, Araki M and Hirakawa M (2006) From genomics to chemical genomics: New developments in KEGG. Nucleic Acid Res 34: D354–D357 Kannangara CG, Vothknecht UC, Hansson M and von Wettstein D (1997) Magnesium chelatase: Association with ribosomes and mutant complementation studies identify barley subunit Xantha-G as a functional counterpart of Rhodobacter subunit BchD. Mol Gen Genet 254: 85–92 Karger GA, Reid JD and Hunter CN (2001) Characterization of the binding of deuteroporphyrin IX to the magnesium chelatase H subunit and spectroscopic properties of the complex. Biochem 40: 9291–9299 Kawanishi S, Seki Y and Sano S (1983) Uroporphyrinogen decarboxylase. Purification, properties, and inhibition by polychlorinated biphenyl isomers. J Biol Chem 258: 4285–4292 Kikuchi G, Kumar A, Talmage P and Shemin D (1958) The enzymatic synthesis of δ-aminolevulinic acid. J Biol Chem 233: 1214–1219 Lander M, Pitt AR, Alefounder PR, Bardy D, Abell C and Battersby AR (1991) Studies on the mechanism of hydroxymethylbilane synthase concerning the role of arginine residues in substrate binding. Biochem J 275: 447–452 Lash TD (1991) Action of uroporphyrinogen decarboxylase on uroporphyrinogen-III: A reassessment of the clockwise decarboxylation hypothesis. Biochemical J 278: 901–903 Layer G, Moser J, Heinz DW, Jahn D and Schubert WD (2003) Crystal structure of coproporphyrinogen III oxidase reveals cofactor geometry of radical SAM enzymes. EMBO J 22: 6214–6224 Layer G, Grage K, Teschner T, Schunemann V, Breckau D, Masoumi A, Jahn M, Heathcote P, Trautwein AX and Jahn D (2005) Radical S-adenosylmethionine enzyme coproporphyrinogen III oxidase HemN: Functional features of the [4Fe-4S] cluster and the two bound S-adenosyl-L-methionines. J Biol Chem 280: 29038–29046 Lebedev N and Timko MP (1998) Protochlorophyllide photoreduction. Photosynth Res 58: 5–23 Louie GV, Brownlie PD, Lambert R, Cooper JB, Blundell TL, Wood SP, Warren MJ, Woodcock SC and Jordan PM (1992) Structure of porphobilinogen deaminase reveals a flexible multidomain polymerase with a single catalytic site. Nature 359: 33–39 Marrs B (1981) Mobilization of the genes for photosynthesis from Rhodopseudomonas capsulata by a promiscuous plasmid. J Bacteriol 146: 1003–1012. Mathews MA, Schubert HL, Whitby FG, Alexander KJ, Schadick K, Bergonia HA, Phillips JD and Hill CP (2001) Crystal structure of human uroporphyrinogen III synthase. EMBO J
78 20: 5832–5839 Martins BM, Grimm B, Mock HP, Huber R and Messerschmidt A (2001) Crystal structure and substrate binding modeling of the uroporphyrinogen-III decarboxylase from Nicotiana tabacum. Implications for the catalytic mechanism. J Biol Chem 276: 44108–44116 McGlynn P and Hunter CN (1993) Genetic analysis of the bchC and bchA genes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Mol Gen Genet 236: 227–234 Moseley J, Quinn J, Eriksson M and Merchant S (2000) The Crd1 gene encodes a putative di-iron enzyme required for photosystem I accumulation in copper deficiency and hypoxia in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. EMBO J 19: 2139–2151 Moseley JL, Page MD, Alder NP, Eriksson M, Quinn J, Soto F, Theg SM, Hippler M and Merchant S (2002) Reciprocal expression of two candidate di-iron enzymes affecting photosystem I and light-harvesting complex accumulation. Plant Cell 14: 673–688 Nandi DL, Baker-Cohen K and Shemin D (1968) δ-aminolevulinic acid dehydratase of Rhodopseudomonas spheroides. I. Isolation and properties. J Biol Chem 243: 1224–1230. Neidle EL and Kaplan S (1993a) Expression of the Rhodobacter sphaeroides hemA and hemT genes, encoding two 5-aminolevulinic acid synthase isozymes. J Bacteriol 175: 2292–2303 Neidle EL and Kaplan S (1993b) 5-Aminolevulinic acid availability and control of spectral complex formation of HemA and HemT mutants of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Bacteriol 175: 2304–2313 Nomata J, Swem LR, Bauer CE and Fujita Y (2005) Overexpression and characterization of dark-operative protochlorophyllide reductase from Rhodobacter capsulatus. Biochim Biophys Acta 1708: 229–237 Nomata J, Mizoguchi T, Tamiaki H and Fujita Y (2006) A second nitrogenase-like enzyme for bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis: Reconstitution of chlorophyllide a reductase with purified Xprotein (BchX) and YZ-protein (BchY-BchZ) from Rhodobacter capsulatus. J Biol Chem 281: 15021–15028 Oh-hama T (1997) Evolutionary consideration on 5-aminolevulinate synthase in nature. Orig Life Evol Biosph 27: 405–412 Oster U, Bauer CE and Rüdiger W (1997) Characterization of chlorophyll a and bacteriochlorophyll a synthases by heterologous expression in Escherichia coli. J Biol Chem 272: 9671–9676 Ouchane S, Steunou A-S, Picaud M and Astier C (2004) Aerobic and anaerobic Mg-protoporphyrin monomethyl ester cyclases in purple bacteria: A strategy adopted to bypass the repressive oxygen control system. J Biol Chem 279: 6385–6394 Panek H and O’Brian MR (2002) A whole genome view of prokaryotic haem biosynthesis. Microbiology 148: 2273–2282 Pinta V, Picaud M, Reiss-Husson F and Astier C (2002) Rubrivivax gelatinosus acsF (previously orf358) codes for a conserved, putative binuclear-iron-cluster-containing protein involved in aerobic oxidative cyclization of Mg-protoporphyrin IX monomethylester. J Bacteriol 184: 746–753 Porra RJ, Schaefer W, Katheder I, Scheer H, Gad’on N and Drews G (1995) Evidence for two different pathways for the formation of isocyclic ring E of bacteriochlorophyll a in Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Roseobacter denitrificans using 18 O-labeling and mass spectrometry. In: Mathis P (ed) Photosynthesis: From Light to Biosphere: Proceedings of the Xth International Photosynthesis Congress, Vol 3, pp 881–885
Robert D. Willows and Alison M. Kriegel Porra RJ, Schaefer W, Gad’on N, Katheder I, Drews G and Scheer H (1996) Origin of the two carbonyl oxygens of bacteriochlorophyll a. Demonstration of two different pathways for the formation of ring E in Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Roseobacter denitrificans, and a common hydratase mechanism for 3-acetyl group formation. Eur J Biochem 239: 85–92 Porra RJ, Urzinger M, Winkler J, Bubenzer C and Scheer H (1998) Biosynthesis of the 3-acetyl and 131-oxo groups of bacteriochlorophyll a in the facultative aerobic bacterium, Rhodovulum sulphidophilum. The presence of both oxygenase and hydratase pathways for isocyclic ring formation. Eur J Biochem 257: 185–191 Reinbothe S and Reinbothe C (1996) The regulation of enzymes involved in chlorophyll biosynthesis. Eur J Biochem 237: 323–343 Reinbothe S, Reinbothe C, Lebedev N and Apel K (1996a) PORA and PORB, two light-dependent protochlorophyllide-reducing enzymes of angiosperm chlorophyll biosynthesis. Plant Cell 8: 763–769 Reinbothe S, Reinbothe C, Apel K and Lebedev N (1996b) Evolution of chlorophyll biosynthesis—The challenge to survive photooxidation. Cell 86: 703–705 Roessner CA, Ponnamperuma K and Scott AI (2002) Mutagenesis identifies a conserved tyrosine residue important for the activity of uroporphyrinogen III synthase from Anacystis nidulans. FEBS Lett 525: 25–28 Rüdiger W (2003) The last steps of chlorophyll biosynthesis. In: Kadish KM, Smith K and Guilard R (eds), The Porphyrin Handbook II, Vol 13, pp 71–108. Academic Press, New York Schoefs B (1999) The light-dependent and light-independent reduction of protochlorophyllide a to chlorophyllide a. Photosynthetica 36: 481–496 Schoefs B (2001) The light-dependent protochlorophyllide reduction: From a photoprotecting mechanism to a metabolic reaction. Rec Res Develop Plant Physiol 2: 241–258 Seehra JS, Jordan PM and Akhtar M (1983) Anaerobic and aerobic coproporphyrinogen-III oxidases of Rhodopseudomonas spheroide. Mechanism and stereochemistry of vinyl group formation. Biochem J 209: 709–718 Shemin D (1976) 5-Aminolaevulinic acid dehydratase: Structure, function, and mechanism. Phil Trans Royal Soc London B-Biol Sci 273: 109–115 Shemin D and Russell CS (1953) δ-aminolevulinic acid, its role in the biosynthesis of porphyrins and purines. J Am Chem Soc 75: 4873–4874 Shepherd M, McLean S and Hunter CN (2005) Kinetic basis for linking the first two enzymes of chlorophyll biosynthesis. FEBS J 272: 4532–4539 Shoolingin-Jordan PM, LeLean JE and Lloyd AJ (1997) Continuous coupled assay for 5-aminolevulinate synthase. Methods Enzymol 281: 309–316 Sirijovski N, Olsson U, Lundqvist J, Al-Karadaghi S, Willows RD and Hansson M (2006) ATPase activity associated with the magnesium chelatase H-subunit of the chlorophyll biosynthetic pathway is an artefact. Biochem J 400: 477–484 Smart JL, Willett JW and Bauer CE (2004) Regulation of hem gene expression in Rhodobacter capsulatus by redox and photosystem regulators RegA, CrtJ, FnrL, and AerR. J Mol Biol 342: 1171–1186 Sofia HJ, Chen G, Hetzler BG, Reyes-Spindola JF and Miller NE (2001) Radical SAM, a novel protein superfamily linking
Chapter 4
Bacteriochlorophyll Biosynthesis
unresolved steps in familiar biosynthetic pathways with radical mechanisms: Functional characterization using new analysis and information visualization methods. Nucleic Acids Res 29: 1097–1106 Straka JG and Kushner JP (1983) Purification and characterization of bovine hepatic uroporphyrinogen decarboxylase. Biochemistry 22: 4664–4672 Suzuki JY and Bauer CE (1995) Altered monovinyl and divinyl protochlorophyllide pools in bchJ mutants of Rhodobacter capsulatus. Possible monovinyl substrate discrimination of light-independent protochlorophyllide reductase. J Biol Chem 270: 3732–3740 Tait GH (1969) Coproporphyrinogenase activity in extracts from Rhodopseudomonas spheroides. Biochem Biophys Res Comm 37: 116–122 Tait GH (1972) Coproporphyrinogenase activities in extracts of Rhodopseudomonas spheroides and Chromatium strain D. Biochem J 128: 1159–1169 Taylor DP, Cohen SN, Clark WG and Marrs BL (1983) Alignment of genetic and restriction maps of the photosynthesis region of the Rhodopseudomonas capsulatus chromosome by a conjugation-mediated marker rescue technique. J Bacteriol 154: 580–590 Tuboi S, Kim HJ and Kikuchi G (1970a) Differential induction of fraction-I and fraction-II of δ-aminolevulinate synthetase in Rhodopseudomonas spheroides under various incubation conditions. Arch Biochem Biophys 138: 155–159 Tuboi S, Kim HJ and Kikuchi G (1970b) Occurrence and properties of 2 types of δ-aminolevulinate synthetase in Rhodopseudomonas spheroides. Arch Biochem Biophys 138: 147–154 Walker CJ and Weinstein JD (1994) The magnesium-insertion step of chlorophyll biosynthesis is a two-stage reaction. Biochem J 299: 277–284 Warren M J, Jordan PM (1988) Investigation into the nature of substrate binding to the dipyrromethane cofactor of Escherichia coli porphobilinogen deaminase. Biochemistry 27: 9020–9030 Wellington CL Taggart, AKP, Beatty, JT (1991) Functional significance of overlapping transcripts of crtEF, bchCA, and puf photosynthesis gene operons in Rhodobacter capsulatus J Bact 173: 2954–2961 Whitby FG, Phillips JD, Kushner JP and Hill CP (1998) Crystal structure of human uroporphyrinogen decarboxylase. EMBO J 17: 2463–2471 Willows RD (2003) Biosynthesis of chlorophylls from protoporphyrin IX. Nat Prod Rep 20: 327–341 Willows RD and Beale SI (1998) Heterologous expression of the
79 Rhodobacter capsulatus BchI, -D, and -H genes that encode magnesium chelatase subunits and characterization of the reconstituted enzyme. J Biol Chem 273: 34206–34213 Willows RD and Hansson M (2003) Mechanism, structure and regulation of magnesium chelatase, In: Kadish KM, Smith K and Guilard R (eds) The Porphyrin Handbook II, Vol 13 pp. 1–48 Academic Press, New York Willows RD, Gibson LCD, Kanangara CG, Hunter CN and von Wettstein D (1996) Three separate proteins constitute the magnesium chelatase of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Eur J Biochem 235: 438–443 Willows RD, Lake V, Roberts TH and Beale SI (2003) Inactivation of Mg chelatase during transition from anaerobic to aerobic growth in Rhodobacter capsulatus. J Bacteriol 185: 3249–3258 Willows RD, Hansson A, Birch D, Al-Karadaghi S and Hansson M (2004) EM single particle analysis of the ATP-dependent BchI complex of magnesium chelatase: An AAA+ hexamer. J Struct Biol 146: 227–233 Wright MS, Cardin RD and Biel AJ (1987) Isolation and characterization of an aminolevulinate-requiring Rhodobacter capsulatus mutant. J Bacteriol 169: 961–966 Yang ZM and Bauer CE (1990) Rhodobacter capsulatus genes involved in early steps of the bacteriochlorophyll biosynthetic pathway. J Bacteriol 172: 5001–5010 Yen HC and Marrs B (1976) Map of genes for carotenoid and bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis in Rhodopseudomonas capsulata. J Bacteriol 126: 619–629 Yildiz FH, Gest H and Bauer CE (1992) Conservation of the photosynthesis gene cluster in Rhodospirillum centenum. Mol Microbiol 6: 2683–2691 Young DA, Bauer CE, Williams JC and Marrs BL (1989) Genetic evidence for superoperonal organization of genes for photosynthetic pigments and pigment-binding proteins in Rhodobacter capsulatus. Mol Gen Genet 218: 1–12 Zaman Z, Jordan PM and Akhtar M (1973) Mechanism and stereochemistry of the 5-aminolaevulinate synthetase reaction. Biochem J 135: 257–263 Zeilstra-Ryalls JH and Kaplan S (1995) Aerobic and anaerobic regulation in Rhodobacter sphaeroides 2.4.1: the role of the fnrL gene. J Bacteriol 177: 6422–6431 Zeilstra-Ryalls JH and Schornberg KL (2006) Analysis of hemF gene function and expression in Rhodobacter sphaeroides 2.4.1. J Bacteriol 188: 801–804 Zsebo KM and Hearst JE (1984) Genetic-physical mapping of a photosynthetic gene cluster from R. capsulata. Cell 37: 937–947
Chapter 5 Vitamin B12 (Cobalamin) Biosynthesis in the Purple Bacteria Martin J. Warren* and Evelyne Deery Protein Science Group, Department of Biosciences, University of Kent, Canterbury CT2 7NJ, U.K.
Summary ................................................................................................................................................................. 81 I. Background ...................................................................................................................................................... 81 II. Function of Cobalamin ..................................................................................................................................... 82 III. B12 Biosynthesis in Rhodobacter capsulatus and Rhodobacter sphaeroides ................................................ 83 IV. Summary of Events Required for Cobalamin Biosynthesis .............................................................................. 84 V. Biosynthesis of Precorrin-2 and Its Onward Route Towards Siroheme and Cobalamin .................................. 86 VI. Control and Regulation of Cobalamin Biosynthesis ......................................................................................... 92 Acknowledgments ................................................................................................................................................... 92 References .............................................................................................................................................................. 92
Summary Vitamin B12 (cobalamin), the antipernicious anemia factor, is unique among the vitamins in that its synthesis is restricted to the prokaryotic world. In fact, cobalamin is made along one of two related biosynthetic pathways, which differ in their timing of cobalt insertion and requirement for molecular oxygen. The purple bacteria appear to utilize, exclusively, the pathway requiring oxygen (aerobic route). In this chapter, the aerobic pathway for cobalamin biosynthesis is described. The biosynthetic pathway for cobalamin is shared, in part, with that for other modified tetrapyrroles such as heme, bacteriochlorophyll and siroheme. Cobalamin biosynthesis diverges from heme and chorophyll at uroporphyrinogen III, the first macrocyclic intermediate of the pathway. The transformation of uroporphyrinogen III into cobalamin requires the addition of eight S-adenosyl-L-methionine derived methyl groups, ring contraction, decarboxylation, amidation, cobalt insertion, adenosylation and the attachment of a lower nucleotide loop that houses an unusual base in the form of dimethylbenzimidazole. In total, around thirty enzymes are required for the complete de novo biosynthesis of the coenzyme form of cobalamin, a coenzyme that appears to be required for a number of cellular activities in the purple bacteria including the formation of the active photosynthetic apparatus.
I. Background Vitamin B12 (cobalamin) was first identified as a nutrient in the 1920s when Whipple and Robscheit-Robbins (1925) and Minot and Murphy (1926) demonstrated that crude liver extracts could be used to cure pernicious anemia. The active factor within the liver was purified, crystallized (Rickes et al., 1948; Smith, 1948) and the structure of the vitamin determined by the pioneering efforts of Dorothy Hodgkin (Brink et al., 1954; *Author for correspondence, email: [email protected]
C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty (eds): The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria, pp. 81–95. © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V.
82
Martin J. Warren and Evelyne Deery
Fig. 1. The structure of vitamin B12. The diagram outlines the numbering and lettering system used to describe the corrin ring component of the molecule. The various components of the vitamin are described.
Hodgkin et al., 1956), exposing it as a molecule of much greater complexity than had been predicted. The structure revealed that vitamin B12 (see Fig. 1) is a modified tetrapyrrole that belongs to the same family of compounds as heme, bacteriochlorophyll and siroheme (Warren et al., 2002), prosthetic groups that are also made in the purple bacteria. Although it shares the same basic architecture as these compounds, it differs from them in a number of important ways including the identity of the central metal ion (cobalt) and the fact that the molecule contains both upper and lower axial ligands for the metal. Moreover, the tetrapyrrole framework within vitamin B12 has lost one of the bridging carbons, thereby allowing the direct connection of the pyrrole-derived rings D and A (Fig. 1). This cobalt containing, macrocyclic contracted system is called a corrin ring, whereas the corrin ring with its lower axial ligand attached through a linking aminopropanol spacer is called cobalamin. In vivo, cobalamin is generally found in one of two key functional biological forms, methylcobalamin and adenosylcobalamin, which differ in the nature of their upper axial ligand (Fig. 1) (Warren et al., 2002; Banerjee and Ragsdale, 2003). Commercial B12 is generally cyanocobalamin, where the upper Abbreviations: DMB – 5,6-dimethylbenzimidazole; HBA – hydrogenobyrinic acid; P. – Pseudomonas; Rba. – Rhodobacter; SAM – S-adenosyl-L-methionine
axial ligand has been displaced by cyanide, which is done to facilitate the purification of the vitamin. The complexity of the molecule means that a chemical synthesis is not practical and hence cobalamin is produced from bacterial cultures (Martens et al., 2002). However, although cyanocobalamin is not itself functional in biological systems, it is rapidly converted into adenosylcobalamin. Uniquely among the vitamins, B12 is made de novo only by prokaryotes; its synthesis does not seem to have survived the prokaryotic to eukaryotic transition (Roth et al., 1996; Croft et al., 2005). II. Function of Cobalamin Currently, three classes of B12-dependent enzymes are recognized and are termed the isomerases, the methyltransferases and the reductive dehalogenases (Banerjee and Ragsdale, 2003). The latter are generally found in anaerobic microbial systems and are associated with the detoxification of chlorinated carbon compounds. There are no examples of such enzymes in the purple bacteria. However, the purple bacteria do house cobalamin-dependent isomerases and methyltransferases. The isomerases catalyze the 1,2 interchange between a variable substituent and a hydrogen atom on a neighboring carbon (Banerjee and Ragsdale, 2003). The commonest B12 isomerase,
Chapter 5
B12 Biosynthesis
and perhaps the best studied, is methylmalonyl CoA mutase, which uses adenosylcobalamin as a coenzyme and promotes catalysis using radical chemistry (Marsh and Drennan, 2001). The Rhodobacter (Rba.) sphaeroides sequencing project (Mackenzie et al., 2001) has shown that this enzyme is encoded within the genome and is likely to be involved in the degradation of several amino acids and odd-chain fatty acids via propionyl-CoA to the tricarboxylic acid cycle. The B12-dependent methyltransferases are involved in the biosynthesis of the amino acid methionine and, especially in the archaea, in C1 metabolism and CO2 fixation (Banerjee and Ragsdale, 2003). In the purple bacteria, the majority of organisms appear to have a B12-dependent methionine synthase. Here the enzyme catalyses the transfer of a methyl group from a donor (methyl tetrahydrofolate) to homocysteine to give methionine and tetrahydrofolate. With reference to cobalamin in purple bacteria, there has been comparatively little work reported. There has been no study on the B12-requiring enzymes although in Rba. sphaeroides it is known that B12 is required for methionine synthase (Cauthen et al., 1967). However, it has been shown on several occasions that there is a correlation between B12 availability and the ability to form bacteriochlorophyll (Pollich and Klug, 1995; Pollich et al., 1996; Gough et al., 2000; Chapter 4, Willows and Kriegel). The correlation between B12 and bacteriochlorophyll synthesis was first noticed in green sulfur bacteria (Fuhrmann et al., 1993), where cobalamin deficiency not only led to a decrease in the bacteriochlorophyll content but also prevented the formation of chlorosomes. In purple sulfur bacteria, a parallel observation was made with B12-auxotrophs in that a lack of the vitamin led to reduced bacteriochlorophyll synthesis (Pfennig and Lippert 1966). Finally, disruption of the B12 biosynthetic pathway in Rba. capsulatus was found to cause a reduction in the formation of the photosynthetic apparatus under semiaerobic growth conditions (Pollich and Klug, 1995; Pollich et al., 1996). An explanation for the apparent relationship between B12 availability and bacteriochlorophyll synthesis was forwarded when it was suggested that B12 may function as a coenzyme in the isocyclic ring formation of bacteriochlorophyll (Gough et al., 2000). This conclusion was based on several compelling pieces of evidence, including the observation that B12 auxotrophic mutants of Rba. capsulatus, grown without B12, accumulated Mg2+-porphyrins, and that in vitro activity of the cyclase enzyme was dependent
83 upon the addition of B12 (Gough et al., 2000). However, no direct evidence for the presence of B12 in the cyclase has yet been presented. The cyclase belongs to the radical S-adenosyl-L-methionine (SAM) class of enzymes, and although the presence of a Fe4-S4 centre was reported on a recombinant form of this enzyme, there was no report of a bound cobalamin (Ouchane et al., 2004). III. B12 Biosynthesis in Rhodobacter capsulatus and Rhodobacter sphaeroides Research mainly carried out during the 1990s had revealed two pathways for cobalamin biosynthesis which are referred to as the aerobic and the anaerobic routes (Blanche, 1993; Scott, 1994; Raux et al., 1999). The aerobic route is so-called because it has been shown that the pathway requires molecular oxygen as a substrate, whereas the anaerobic pathway has no such requirement and can operate in the presence or absence of oxygen. Although the two pathways are clearly related and share a number of orthologous enzymes, they are nonetheless quite distinct at both a biochemical and a genetic level (Blanche, 1993). The two pathways differ in the timing of cobalt insertion and the method that is employed to contract the ring (Scott 1994; Raux et al., 1999). In the aerobic pathway cobalt is inserted at a comparatively late stage, after the tetrapyrrole-derived ring has undergone its ring contraction. An outline of the aerobic pathway can be viewed in Table 1. Significantly, when bacteria that operate this pathway are grown under cobalt-limiting conditions, cobalt-free corrinoids are found to accumulate (Toohey, 1965; Toohey, 1966; Dresow et al., 1980). In fact, this was first observed in a range of purple bacteria. This, together, with the initial publication of the gene sequences for cobalamin biosynthesis in Rba. capsulatus (Vlcek et al., 1997), which bore most of the genetic hallmarks of the aerobic pathway, supported the idea that the purple bacteria made their cobalamin along the aerobic pathway (Raux et al., 1999). The organization of the cobalamin biosynthetic genes in Rba. capsulatus is presented in Fig. 2. The aerobic pathway was largely elucidated from research undertaken on Pseudomonas (P.) denitrificans (Blanche, 1993; Blanche et al., 1995). In analyzing the biosynthetic pathway that is found in organisms such as Rba. capsulatus and Rba. sphaeroides, much will be drawn and inferred from
84 the earlier work on the aerobic pathway elucidated in P. denitrificans. The genetic similarities of the cobalamin biosynthetic genes/proteins between these three organisms are highlighted in Table 1. The major reason for believing that Rba. capsulatus operates an aerobic cobalamin biosynthetic pathway comes from the presence of cobN, S and T, which encode the subunits of the cobaltochelatase required for insertion of cobalt into hydrogenobyrinic acid (HBA) (Raux et al., 1999). The genome also contains cobF, which encodes a methyltransferase that also only appears to segregate with the aerobic pathway (Rodionov et al., 2003). However, somewhat worryingly, there was no sign of the monooxygenase required for the oxygen-dependent ring contraction process. The absence of this protein from the repertoire of pathway enzymes led to the suggestion that Rba. capsulatus may operate a different way of catalyzing this step (Raux et al., 1999). Indeed, as will be highlighted later, this was found to be the case (McGoldrick et al., 2005). In terms of genetic layout, in Rba. capsulatus 28 cobalamin biosynthetic genes are found at a single locus, making it one of the most complete cobalamin biosynthetic operons found in nature (Vlcek et al., 1997). Indeed, only three genes are located elsewhere in the chromosome and thus the vast majority of the enzymes required for the transformation of uroporphyrinogen III into adenosylcobalamin are sequestered at this region. The genetic organization of this region is highlighted in Fig. 2. In Rba. sphaeroides,
Martin J. Warren and Evelyne Deery the cobalamin biosynthetic genes are somewhat more dispersed. Although there is again only one major operon, it contains a mere 12 genes. The remaining B12 biosynthetic genes are found dispersed throughout the genome. A comparison of the organization of the cobalamin biosynthetic genes in Rba. capsulatus and Rba. sphaeroides is shown in Fig. 2. IV. Summary of Events Required for Cobalamin Biosynthesis The biosynthesis of adenosylcobalamin represents one of the most intricate metabolic processes undertaken by living systems, involving a multifarious cocktail of enzyme activities and cofactors (Raux et al., 2000). The synthesis is initiated by the construction of the tetrapyrrole framework, which then undergoes a range of modifications that includes peripheral methylation by the addition of 8 SAMderived methyl groups, ring contraction and decarboxylation to generate a metal-free corrinoid, HBA (Warren et al., 2002). The subsequent steps see a combination of cobalt insertion, lateral amidations and the cosseting of the cobalt ion by the attachment of the upper axial ligand in the form of adenosine. In this way the synthesis of the corrin ring is completed, and sets up the synthetic finale whereby the lower nucleotide assembly is secured on to the macrocyclic framework. This involves the piecing together of the
Fig. 2. Genetic organization of B12 operons in Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus. The organization of the known cobalamin biosynthetic genes is outlined.
Chapter 5
B12 Biosynthesis
85
Table 1. Comparison of genes and their functions associated with cobalamin biosynthesis Reaction
Pathway Intermediate
methylation at C2 and C7
⏐ ↓
methylation at C20
⏐ ↓
C20 hydroxylation γ lactone formation
⏐ ↓
methylation at C17 ring contraction
⏐ ↓
methylation at C11
↓
Enzyme encoded in P. denitrificans
Enzyme encoded in Rba. capsulatus
Enzyme encoded in Rba. sphaeroides
CobA
CobA
CobA
CobI
CobI
CobI
CobG
CobZ
?
CobJ
CobJ
CobJ
CobM
CobM
CobM
CobF
CobF
CobF
CobK
CobK
CobK
uroporphyrinogen III
precorrin-2
precorrin-3A
precorrin-3B
precorrin-4 precorrin-5 methylation at C1 acetic acid loss
⏐ ↓
C18-C19 reduction
↓
precorrin-6A precorrin-6B methylation at C5
↓
CobL
CobL
CobL
methylation at C15 and decarboxylation
⏐ ↓
CobL
CobL
CobL
methyl rearrangement C11 to C12
⏐ ↓
CobH
CobH
CobH
a, c- amidation
↓
CobB
CobB
CobB
CobN, S & T
CobN, S & T
CobN, S & T
CobR
CobR
CobR
CobO
CobO
CobO
CobQ
CobQ
CobQ
CobD, C & protein α
CobD, C
CobD, C
CobP
CobP
CobP
?
BluB
BluB
CobU
CobU
CobU
CobV
CobV
CobV
precorrin-8x
hydrogenobyrinic acid hydrogenobyrinic acid a,c-diamide cobalt insertion
↓
cob(II)yrinic a,c-diamide cobalt reduction
↓
adenosylation
↓
cob(I)yrinic a,c-diamide ado-cob(I)yrinic a,c-diamide b, d, e, g- amidation
⏐ ↓
aminopropanol phosphate synthesis and attachment
⏐ ↓
phosphorylation & GMP addition
⏐ ↓
ado-cobyric acid
ado-cobinamide
ado-GDP-cobinamide Synthesis of dimethylbenzimidazole α-ribazole 5´ phosphate synthesis & dephosphorylation α-ribazole attachmnent
⏐ ⏐ ↓ ↓
ado-cobalamin
86 components of the lower nucleotide, which is then tethered to the corrin via a carbon-based linker to yield adenosylcobalamin (Fig. 1). V. Biosynthesis of Precorrin-2 and Its Onward Route Towards Siroheme and Cobalamin As with all modified tetrapyrroles, cobalamin is synthesized from uroporphyrinogen III (Warren et al., 2002; Chapter 4, Willows and Kriegel). In fact, the branch of the pathway responsible for cobalamin biosynthesis diverges from the branches for heme and chlorophyll at this intermediate (Fig. 3). Thus, for cobalamin biosynthesis, uroporphyrinogen III is methylated by an enzyme that transfers two SAMderived methyl groups to positions 2 and 7 of the framework to generate precorrin-2 (Fig. 3). This enzyme, termed the S-adenosyl-L-methionine uroporphyrinogen III methyltransferase, is encoded by cobA and is unique in its ability as a methyltransferase to mediate two distinct methylations within a single active site (Blanche et al., 1989). The structure of CobA has recently been determined and some of the amino acids that are key to orchestrating the temporal and regiospecificity of the enzyme have been identified (Vevodova et al., 2004). The topology of the enzyme is similar to five of the other methyltransferases (CobI, J, M, F and L) (Schubert et al., 2003) that are required to decorate this molecular masterpiece. These enzymes have clearly evolved from a common
Martin J. Warren and Evelyne Deery ancestor (Roth et al., 1993), and this relationship has important implications for understanding how the pathway may have appeared since it suggests a model of retrograde evolution (Horowitz, 1945). The synthesis of the yellow precorrin-2 brings the pathway to another junction, where the pathways for siroheme and cobalamin diverge (Fig. 3). The removal of two protons and two electrons converts precorrin-2 into sirohydrochlorin and insertion of ferrous iron yields siroheme (Fig. 3) (Raux et al., 2003). There is evidence that since Rba. capsulatus seems to harbor an assimilatory NADH-nitrite reductase, which requires siroheme as a cofactor, that the organism must be able to make this prosthetic group (Olmo-Mira et al., 2006). Moreover, in the Rba. sphaeroides genome there is also a gene that encodes a protein with a high degree of similarity to SirB, the sirohydrochlorin ferrochelatase that is required in the final step of siroheme synthesis (Raux et al., 2003). However, to direct precorrin-2 towards cobalamin synthesis, the intermediate undergoes another methylation to generate a trimethylpyrrocorphin (Fig. 4). This next enzyme in the pathway methylates precorrin-2 at position C20 to produce precorrin 3A in a reaction catalysed by CobI which, like all the cobalamin biosynthetic methyltransferases, utilizes SAM as the methyl donor (Fig. 4) (Thibaut et al., 1990a). In P. denitrificans, precorrin-3A acts as the substrate for CobG, a monooxygenase that hydroxylates precorrin-3A at C20 and stimulates gamma lactone formation on ring A (Fig. 4) (Debussche et al., 1993; Min, 1993; Spencer et al., 1994). This
Fig. 3. Transformation of uroporphyrinogen III into precorrin-2 and siroheme. Uroporphyrinogen III represents the first branchpoint in the synthesis of modified tetrapyrroles, as methylation at positions 2 and 7 produce precorrin-2 and directs the intermediate away from the branch that leads to heme and chlorophyll. Oxidation of precorrin-2 to sirohydrochlorin followed by ferrochelation generates siroheme. Although the genome of Rba. sphaeroides contains a sirohydrochlorin ferrochelatase (SirB), there is no evidence of a recognized precorrin dehydrogenase.
Chapter 5
B12 Biosynthesis
spring loads the molecule in anticipation of ring contraction. However, as mentioned earlier, there is no homolog of CobG in the genome of Rba. capsulatus (Fig. 2 and Table 1) (Vlcek et al., 1997; Raux et al., 1999). Nonetheless, the main cob operon does contain another open reading frame that is not found in other cobalamin biosynthetic operons. This gene is predicted to encode a 97 kDa protein, the N-terminus of which displays some similarity to flavoproteins such as succinate dehydrogenase and TcuA, whereas the C-terminus has similarity to a protein originally called CitB but which is now known as TcuB (Lewis et al., 2004). Moreover, the C-terminal region of the protein was predicted to contain a number of transmembrane regions, suggesting that it is an integral membrane protein (McGoldrick et al., 2005). In order to investigate whether this protein is involved in cobalamin biosynthesis, an artificial operon was constructed in which all the genes encoding the enzymes for HBA synthesis except for CobG were cloned into a suitable plasmid. When cobG was added to this plasmid, the resulting construct when transformed into E. coli endowed the host bacterium with the ability to make HBA, a compound that E. coli cannot normally make. When cobG was deleted from the plasmid and replaced with the unknown open reading frame from Rba. capsulatus, E. coli strains transformed with the new plasmid were found to also make HBA. The conclusion from these experiments was that the open reading frame within the main Rba. capsulatus B12 biosynthetic operon must encode an enzyme that is isofunctional with CobG — that is it must be able to transform precorrin-3A into precorrin-3B (McGoldrick et al., 2005). As the gene encodes a new cobalamin biosynthetic enzyme it was designated cobZ. To understand how this enzyme works, CobZ was overproduced recombinantly in E. coli. Upon short induction in E. coli a protein of 97 kDa was observed in cell extracts, but with longer induction times this protein appeared to break down and a soluble peptide of approximately 50 kDa was observed. This peptide was purified and was shown to contain the N-terminal region of CobZ. Moreover, the purified protein was yellow indicating that it contained a flavin, which was characterized as FAD. The full-length CobZ (97 kDa protein) was also purified after detergent extraction. The appearance of the purified protein here was somewhat surprising as, rather than yellow, it had an orange coloration and presented with a complex spectrum that included a large Soret peak. The Soret
87 peak could be reduced with dithionite indicating that the protein must contain a heme. Moreover, the protein sequence also suggested that the protein may contain several Fe-S centers. EPR analysis of the protein revealed that the protein did indeed contain two Fe4-S4 centers. Based on the characterization of the protein, a putative mechanism for the enzyme was proposed. In this scheme, CobZ is deemed to act as a monooxygenase. The reduced flavin, housed in the N-terminal region of the protein, reacts with molecular oxygen to form a 4-hydroxyperoxide intermediate. This is then able to methylate the incoming precorrin-3A at the C20 position and generates precorrin-3B. To regenerate the flavin cofactor for the next round of catalysis it is proposed that it is reduced by the transfer of electrons via the heme and Fe-S centers, possibly by drawing on reducing equivalents from the quinol pool in the membrane. In Rhodospirillum rubrum, cobZ is found as two separate genes, suggesting that in Rba. capsulatus CobZ may have arisen through gene fusion (McGoldrick et al., 2005). It is interesting to note that with CobZ and CobG, two quite distinct enzymes have evolved that play an essential role in the ring contraction process, highlighting how the B12 pathway has also employed a patchwork model of evolution (Bartlett et al., 2003). However, to add interest to intrigue, it is noteworthy that the genome of Rba. sphaeroides does not contain a homolog to either of these genes (Table 1 and Fig. 2), so presumably Rba. sphaeroides must employ yet another enzyme system to help promote ring contraction. The ring contraction process is completed by the action of CobJ, a methyltransferase that elicits the macrocyclic ring shrinkage (Fig. 4) (Scott et al., 1993; Thibaut, 1993). The contraction process results in the extrusion of the C20 adduct and the addition of another SAM-derived methyl group to the porphin framework, this time at C17. The product of the reaction is called precorrin-4. The next two enzymes in the pathway see further SAM-derived methyl groups added at C11 and C1, by CobM and F, respectively (Fig. 4) (Thibaut et al., 1990b; Thibaut 1993). Strangely, a look at the final cobalamin molecules reveals that there is no methyl group at C11. This is because later on in the pathway the methyl group at C11 is moved to C12. The methyltransferase that methylates at C1 is also thought to be involved in the final elimination of the C20 adduct through the deacylation of the C1 position. The actions of CobM and F see the transformation of precorrin-4 into precorrin-5 and finally onto precorrin-6A (Fig. 4).
88
Martin J. Warren and Evelyne Deery
Fig. 4. The transformation of precorrin-2 into hydrogenobyrinic acid. This transformation requires the addition of a further 6 methyl groups, ring contraction, deacylation and decarboxylation.
At this stage in the reaction sequence, the pathway intermediate is reduced by the action of CobK, an enzyme that utilizes NADPH as its source of reducing equivalents, resulting in the synthesis of precorrin 6B (Fig. 4) (Blanche et al., 1992c). The final two methyl groups are then added to the emerging corrin ring by
the action of CobL, a multifunctional enzyme that not only methylates both C5 and C15, but also decarboxylates the acetate side chain attached to C12 (Fig. 4) (Blanche et al., 1992a). In fact, it would appear from sequence analysis that CobL is really a fusion between two distinct methyltransferases, which in some organ-
Chapter 5
B12 Biosynthesis
89
Fig. 5. Synthesis of adenosylcobyric acid from hydrogenobyrinic acid. These series of reactions see the amidation of six of the carboxylic acid side chains, cobalt insertion and the adenosylation of the cobalt ion.
isms are encoded by two separate genes (Roth et al., 1993). Thus, the N-terminal region of CobL houses a canonical cobalamin biosynthetic methyltransferase, which is thought to methylate C5, whereas the C-terminal region of CobL is thought to possess a different class of methyltransferase that methylates C15 and is also responsible for the decarboxylation (Roessner and Scott, 2006; Santander et al., 2006). These deductions have actually come from work on the anaerobic pathway, where the ortholog of CobL is found as two distinct proteins termed CbiE and T. On the basis of some biosynthetic studies with CbiT, it seems likely that methylation precedes decarboxylation. The net result of the actions of CobL is the synthesis of precorrin-8 (Fig. 4). Finally, the basic corrin carbon scaffold is completed by the action of CobH which catalyses the rearrangement of the methyl group attached to C11 to C12, resulting in the synthesis of HBA (Fig. 4) (Thibaut et al., 1992; Shipman et al., 2001). A crystal structure of
this enzyme with its bound product has provided an insight into how a conserved histidine residue helps to mediate this 1,5 sigmatropic methyl shift (Shipman et al., 2001). The next steps in the biosynthesis of the corrin ring component of the macrocycle see modification to the acidic side chains and the insertion of cobalt into the core of the molecule (Fig. 5). Initially, HBA is amidated by an enzyme (CobB) that amidates the carboxylic acid groups on the a and c acetate side chains (Debussche et al., 1990). This enzyme amidates the c side chain followed by the a side chain in an ATP-dependent manner, with the amido donor being glutamine. The result of this reaction is hydrogenobyrinic acid a,c-diamide (Fig. 5), which acts as the substrate for the cobaltochelatase. The cobalt-inserting step is catalysed in a reaction that requires three subunits, CobN, S and T (Debussche et al., 1992). The three subunits, Co2+ and Mg-ATP are all required for cobalt insertion into hydrogenobyrinic
90 acid a,c-diamide, although the enzyme complex will also insert cobalt into a range of derivatives. For cobaltochelatase activity, CobS (molecular mass 38 kDa) and T (molecular mass 80 kDa) are thought to form a complex with a combined mass of 450 kDa, and this complex interacts with CobN (molecular mass of 140 kDa) in the presence of ATP to generate the product cob(II)yrinic acid a,c-diamide (Fig. 5). The cobalt chelatase displays significant similarities to the Mg2+ chelatase of bacteriochlorophyll biosynthesis, where the CobN, S and T subunits are homologous to the BchH, I and D subunits (Gibson et al., 1995). After the insertion of cobalt, the next step is to provide an upper ligand for the metal ion. This is accomplished by adenosylating the complex. Initially this requires the reduction of the cobalt ion to the Co(I) form, which acts as a powerful nucleophile to attack the C5 position on the ribose of ATP, with the release of triphosphate, to give the adenosyl form. The reduction of the cobalt ion is catalysed by an enzyme called the cob(II)yrinic acid a,c-diamide reductase, an enzyme that was purified from crude cell extracts (Blanche et al., 1992b). The enzyme was shown to be a flavoprotein and was able to catalyze the reduction of cobalt (II) to cobalt (I) (Fig. 5). However,
Martin J. Warren and Evelyne Deery although the enzyme was purified to homogeneity and its N-terminus sequenced, no gene sequence encoding the enzyme was identified. Recently, this gene has been identified and termed cobR (Warren, unpublished). Once reduced, the Co(I) form is acted upon by the adenosyltransferase, encoded by cobO, in the presence of ATP to give the adenosylcobyrinic acid a,c-diamide (Fig. 5) (Debussche et al., 1991). The remaining 4 amidations are undertaken by CobQ to generate adenosylcobyric acid (Fig. 5) (Blanche et al., 1991a). As an amidase, CobQ is related to CobB and utilizes glutamine as the amide donor. The reactions are carried out in a stepwise fashion, resulting in the amidation of carboxyl groups b, d, e, and g, although the exact order was not determined. Adenosylcobyric acid is converted into adenosylcobinamide (Fig. 6) by the attachment of an aminopropanol linking group to the f side chain of the corrin (Debussche et al., 1993; Blanche et al., 1995). In fact, this side chain is probably made from threonine O-3-phosphate by the action of CobC which, on the basis of the orthologous enzyme from the anaerobic pathway, is likely to act as a pyrixodal phosphatedependent decarboxylase that generates (R)-1-aminopropan-2-ol O-phosphate (Fig. 6) (Brushaber et al.,
Fig. 6. Adenosylcobinamide phosphate synthesis. The figure describes the synthesis and attachment of the aminopropanol linker group.
Chapter 5
B12 Biosynthesis
1998). This linker group is subsequently attached to the corrin by the action of CobD and an unknown 38 kDa protein that was termed protein α (Blanche et al., 1995). The reaction is dependent upon ATP/Mg2+ and the enzyme only recognizes the adenosylated form of cobyric acid, generating adenosylcobinamide phosphate (Fig. 6). The final stages of the synthesis of the coenzyme form of cobalamin require the synthesis and attachment of the lower nucleotide loop (Fig. 7). Initially, a transfer of GMP to adenosylcobinamide phosphate is mediated by CobP, which utilizes GTP as a substrate (Blanche et al., 1991b). The product of the reaction is adenosyl-GDP-cobinamide (Fig. 7). The lower axial ligand is an unusual nucleoside, which is sometimes referred to as the α-ribazole, containing a modified base called 5,6-dimethylbenzimadazole linked by an N-α-glycosidic bond to the ribose sugar. The modified base in the aerobic pathway is made from reduced flavin mononucleotide, in a remarkable reaction catalysed by a single enzyme called BluB (Fig. 7) (Campbell et al., 2006). The gene encoding this enzyme was first identified in
91 Rba. capsulatus, where it was implicated in the later stages of cobalamin biosynthesis (Pollich and Klug, 1995). Further work on a Sinorhizobium meliloti bluB mutant revealed that mutant strains were unable to grow in minimal media and that the cobalamin deficient defects could be rescued by the addition of the modified base 5,6-dimethylbenzimidazole (DMB) (Campbell et al., 2006). Biochemical analysis demonstrated that the bluB mutant does not produce cobalamin unless DMB is supplied. The α-ribazole is made as α-ribazole 5´-phosphate from the phosphoribosyltransferase activity of CobU that utilizes DMB and β-nicotinate mononucleotide as substrates (Fig. 7) (Cameron et al., 1991; Blanche et al., 1995; Warren et al., 2002). The final step in the synthesis then sees the transfer of adenosylcobinamide phosphate of adenosyl-GDP-cobinamide to the α-ribazole 5´-phosphate in a reaction catalysed by CobV, to generate adenosylcobalamin (Fig. 7) (Cameron et al., 1991; Blanche et al., 1995; Warren et al., 2002). Within this sequence of events there are still some genes that are thought to encode cobalamin
Fig. 7. The synthesis of adenosylcobalamin. The final stages of the synthesis of adenosylcobalamin are described, outlining the construction of the lower nucleotide loop and its attachment to the corrin ring component.
92 biosynthetic proteins but for which no role has been ascribed. These include cobW and cobE, in which mutations lead to reduced B12 levels (Blanche et al., 1995). There is some evidence that CobW may be involved in cobalt delivery as the protein contains a histidine rich region that would be capable of binding metal and, moreover, the protein is often found closely associated with the gene encoding the large cobalt chelatase subunit (CobN) (see Fig. 2). CobE may have a function in helping to open the γ-lactone and eliminating the C2 unit that is extruded during the ring contraction process (Fig. 4) as the protein shares some similarity with CbiG for which equivalent functions have been assigned (Roessner and Scott, 2006). On top of these are also some proteins that have been identified as being involved in B12 synthesis in Rba. capsulatus that have no ortholog in P. denitrificans. These include BluE and BluF (Fig. 2), where mutations in the genes produce a B12 phenotype (Pollich and Klug, 1995; Pollich et al., 1996). In fact, the mutations lead to a reduction in the formation of the photosynthetic apparatus under semiaerobic growth conditions, preventing them from ‘blushing’ (hence the prefix blu) (Pollich and Klug, 1995). The phenotype could be corrected by the addition of cobalamin, presumably reflecting the apparent need for cobalamin in bacteriochlorophyll synthesis (Gough et al., 2000). However, disruption of bluE also results in reduced expression of the puf and puc operons, which encode apoproteins of the photosynthetic apparatus (Pollich et al., 1993; Pollich and Klug, 1995). In some non-phototrophic bacteria, there is evidence that a light regulated transcription regulator may bind B12, and regulate carotenogenesis (Cervantes and Murillo, 2002). There is always the possibility that something similar happens in the purple bacteria although there is no evidence that this is the case. More detailed analyses of the bluE and bluF mutations have suggested that both their gene products are involved in the transformation of cobinamide into adenosylcobalamin as both phenotypes can be corrected by the addition of cobinamide to the culture medium (Pollich and Klug 1995; Pollich et al., 1996). However, their precise roles in cobalamin biosynthesis are not known. In the cobalamin biosynthetic operon in both Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus a ferredoxin (fer in Fig. 2) is also found, but again no function for this protein has been described.
Martin J. Warren and Evelyne Deery VI. Control and Regulation of Cobalamin Biosynthesis There are very few B12 auxotrophs known for the purple bacteria (Pollich and Klug, 1995), suggesting that most are able to make their own cobalamin. The essential nature of the vitamin, especially for methionine synthesis and its likely involvement in bacteriochlorophyll synthesis, acts as a strong selection pressure to maintain the de novo synthesis within these bacteria. Moreover, as bacteriochlorophyll, heme and cobalamin are all made along a branched biosynthetic pathway, and as cobalamin is required for bacteriochlorophyll synthesis and heme required for cobalamin synthesis (Gough et al., 2000; McGoldrick et al., 2005), there must be regulatory mechanisms in place to ensure that these modified tetrapyrroles are produced to the correct level. The syntheses of all these compounds requires SAM as a substrate. As SAM is made from methionine in a cobalamindependent process, it is likely that there will be a larger global level of regulation involving cobalamin. However, there have been no studies on the regulation of cobalamin made along the aerobic pathways as such studies have been exclusively undertaken on the anaerobic pathway. Nonetheless, bioinformatic analysis of the Rba. capsulatus and Rba. sphaeroides genomes has revealed the presence of B12 elements, which are thought to repress gene expression by direct binding of adenosylcobalamin most likely by interfering with translation (Vitreschak et al., 2003). More research is required to understand this process in detail and to obtain a clearer overall view of tetrapyrrole metabolism in these organisms. Acknowledgments We thank the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) of the UK and the European Union Viteomics Research Training Network for funding. References Banerjee R and Ragsdale SW (2003) The many faces of vitamin B12: Catalysis by cobalamin-dependent enzymes. Annu Rev Biochem 72: 209–247 Bartlett GJ, Borkakoti N and Thornton, JM (2003) Catalyzing new reactions during evolution: Economy of residues and
Chapter 5
B12 Biosynthesis
mechanism. J Mol Biol 331: 829–860 Blanche F, Debussche L, Thibaut D, Crouzet J and Cameron B (1989) Purification and characterization of S-adenosyl-Lmethionine: Uroporphyrinogen III methyltransferase from Pseudomonas denitrificans. J Bacteriol 171: 4222–4231 Blanche F, Couder M, Debussche L, Thibaut D, Cameron B and Crouzet J (1991a) Biosynthesis of vitamin B12: Stepwise amidation of carboxyl groups b, d, e, and g of cobyrinic acid a,c-diamide is catalyzed by one enzyme in Pseudomonas denitrificans. J Bacteriol 173: 6046–6051 Blanche F, Debussche L, Famechon A, Thibaut D, Cameron B and Crouzet J (1991b) A bifunctional protein from Pseudomonas denitrificans carries cobinamide kinase and cobinamide phosphate guanylyltransferase activities. J Bacteriol 173: 6052–6057 Blanche F, Famechon A, Thibaut D, Debussche L, Cameron B and Crouzet, J (1992a) Biosynthesis of vitamin B12 in Pseudomonas denitrificans: The biosynthetic sequence from precorrin-6y to precorrin-8x is catalyzed by the cobL gene product. J Bacteriol 174: 1050–1052 Blanche F, Maton L, Debussche L and Thibaut, D (1992b) Purification and characterization of cob(II)yrinic acid a,c-diamide reductase from Pseudomonas denitrificans. J Bacteriol 174: 7452–7454 Blanche F, Thibaut D, Famechon A, Debussche L, Cameron B and Crouzet J (1992c) Precorrin-6x reductase from Pseudomonas denitrificans: Purification and characterization of the enzyme and identification of the structural gene. J Bacteriol 174: 1036–1042 Blanche F, Thibaut D, Debussche L, Hertle R, Zipfel F and Müller G (1993) Parallels and decisive differences in vitamin B12 biosyntheses. Angew Chem Int Ed Engl 32: 1651–1653 Blanche F, Cameron B, Crouzet J, Debussche L, Thibaut D, Vuilhorgne M, Leeper FJ and Battersby AR (1995). Vitamin B12: How the problem of its biosynthesis was solved. Angew Chem Int Ed Engl 34: 383–411 Brink C, Hodgkin DC, Lindsey J, Pickworth J, Robertson JR and White JG (1954) X-ray crystallographic evidence on the structure of vitamin B12. Nature 174: 1169–1171 Brushaber KR, O’Toole GA and Escalante-Semerena JC (1998) CobD, a novel enzyme with L-threonine-o-3-phosphate decarboxylase activity is responsible for the synthesis of (R)-1amino-propanol o-2-phosphate, a proposed new intermediate in cobalamin biosynthesis in Salmonella typhimurium LT2. J Biol Chem 273: 2684–2691 Cameron B, Blanche F, Rouyez MC, Bisch D, Famechon A, Couder M, Cauchois L, Thibaut D, Debussche L and Crouzet J (1991) Genetic analysis, nucleotide sequence, and products of two Pseudomonas denitrificans cob genes encoding nicotinate-nucleotide: Dimethylbenzimidazole phosphoribosyltransferase and cobalamin (5´-phosphate) synthase. J Bacteriol 17: 6066–6073 Campbell GR, Taga ME, Mistry K, Lloret J, Anderson PJ, Roth JR and Walker GC (2006) Sinorhizobium meliloti bluB is necessary for production of 5,6-dimethylbenzimidazole, the lower ligand of B12. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 103: 4634–4639 Cauthen SE, Pattison JR and Lascelles J (1967) Vitamin B12 in photosynthetic bacteria and methionine synthesis by Rhodopseudomonas spheroides. Biochem J 102: 774–781 Cervantes M and Murillo FJ (2002) Role for vitamin B12 in light induction of gene expression in the bacterium Myxococcus
93 xanthus. J Bacteriol 184: 2215–2224 Croft MT, Lawrence AD, Raux-Deery E, Warren MJ and Smith AG (2005) Algae acquire vitamin B12 through a symbiotic relationship with bacteria. Nature 438: 90–93 Debussche L, Thibaut D, Cameron B, Crouzet J and Blanche F (1990) Purification and characterization of cobyrinic acid a,cdiamide synthase from Pseudomonas denitrificans. J Bacteriol 172: 6239–6244 Debussche L, Couder M, Thibaut D, Cameron B, Crouzet J and Blanche F (1991) Purification and partial characterization of cob(I)alamin adenosyltransferase from Pseudomonas denitrificans. J Bacteriol 173: 6300–6302 Debussche L, Couder M, Thibaut D, Cameron B, Crouzet J and Blanche F (1992) Assay, purification, and characterization of cobaltochelatase, a unique complex enzyme catalyzing cobalt insertion in hydrogenobyrinic acid a,c-diamide during coenzyme B12 biosynthesis in Pseudomonas denitrificans. J Bacteriol 174: 7445–7451 Debussche L, Thibaut D, Cameron B, Crouzet J and Blanche F (1993) Biosynthesis of the corrin macrocycle of coenzyme B12 in Pseudomonas denitrificans. J Bacteriol 175: 7430–7440 Dresow B, Schlingmann G, Ernst L and Koppenhagen VB (1980) Extracellular metal-free corrinoids from Rhodopseudomonas spheroides. J Biol Chem 255: 7637–7644 Fuhrmann S, Overmann J, Pfennig N and Fischer U (1993) Influence of vitamin B12 and light on the formation of chlorosomes in green- and brown-coloured chlorobium species. Arch Microbiol 160: 193–198 Gibson LCD, Willows RD, Kannangara CG, von Wettstein D and Hunter CN (1995) Magnesium-protoporphyrin chelatase of Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Reconstitution of activity by combining the products of the bchH, -I, and -D genes expressed in Escherichia coli. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 92: 1941–1944 Gough SP, Petersen BO and Duus JO (2000) Anaerobic chlorophyll isocyclic ring formation in Rhodobacter capsulatus requires a cobalamin cofactor. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 97: 6908–6913 Hodgkin DC, Kamper J, Mackay M, Pickworth J, Trueblood KN and White JG (1956) Structure of vitamin B12. Nature 178: 64–66 Horowitz NH (1945) On the evolution of biochemical syntheses. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 31: 153–157 Lewis JA, Horswill AR, Schwem BE and Escalante-Semerena JC (2004) The tricarballylate utilization (tcuRABC) genes of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium LT2. J Bacteriol 186: 1629–1637 Mackenzie C, Choudary M, Larimer FW, Predke PF, Stilwagen S, Armitage JP, Barber RD, Donohue TJ, Hosler JP, Newman JE, Shapleigh JP, Sockett RE, Zeilstra-Ryalls J and Kaplan S (2001) The home stretch, a first analysis of the nearly completed genome of Rhodobacter sphaeroides 2.4.1. Photosynth Res 70:19–41 Marsh EN and Drennan CL (2001) Adenosylcobalamin-dependent isomerases: New insights into structure and mechanism. Curr Opin Chem Biol 5: 499–505 Martens JH, Barg H, Warren MJ and Jahn D (2002) Microbial production of vitamin B12. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 58: 275–285 McGoldrick HM, Roessner CA, Raux E, Lawrence AD, McLean KJ, Munro AW, Santabarbara S, Rigby SE, Heathcote P, Scott AI and Warren MJ (2005) Identification and characterization of
94 a novel vitamin B12 (cobalamin) biosynthetic enzyme (CobZ) from Rhodobacter capsulatus, containing flavin, heme, and Fe-S cofactors. J Biol Chem 280: 1086–1094 Min C, Atshaves BA, Roessner CA, Stolowich NJ, Spencer JB and Scott AI (1993) Isolation, structure and genetically engineered synthesis of precorrin-5. J Am Chem Soc 115: 10380–10381 Minot GR and Murphy WP (1926) Treatment of pernicious anemia by a special diet. Journal of the American Medical Association 87: 470–476 Olmo-Mira MF, Cabello P, Pino C, Martinez-Luque M, Richardson DJ, Castillo F, Roldan MD and Moreno-Vivian C (2006) Expression and characterization of the assimilatory NADHnitrite reductase from the phototrophic bacterium Rhodobacter capsulatus E1F1. Arch Microbiol 186: 339–344 Ouchane S, Steunou AS, Picaud M and Astier C (2004) Aerobic and anaerobic Mg-protoporphyrin monomethyl ester cyclases in purple bacteria: A strategy adopted to bypass the repressive oxygen control system. J Biol Chem 279: 6385–6394 Pfennig N and Lippert KD (1966) Uber das vitamin B12-bedurfnis phototropher schwefelbakterien. Arch Mikrobiol 55: 245–256 Pollich M and Klug G (1995) Identification and sequence analysis of genes involved in late steps in cobalamin (vitamin B12) synthesis in Rhodobacter capsulatus. J Bacteriol 177: 4481–4487 Pollich M, Jock S and Klug G (1993) Identification of a gene required for the oxygen-regulated formation of the photosynthetic apparatus of Rhodobacter capsulatus. Mol Microbiol 10: 749–757 Pollich M, Wersig C and Klug G (1996) The bluF gene of Rhodobacter capsulatus is involved in conversion of cobinamide to cobalamin (vitamin B12). J Bacteriol 178: 7308–7310 Raux E, Schubert HL, Roper JM, Wilson KS and Warren MJ (1999) Vitamin B12; insights into biosynthesis’s mount improbable. Bioorganic Chem 27: 100–118 Raux E, Schubert HL and Warren MJ (2000). Biosynthesis of cobalamin (vitamin B12): A bacterial conundrum. Cell Mol Life Sci 57: 1880–1893 Raux E, Leech HK, Beck R, Schubert HL, Santander PJ, Roessner CA, Scott AI, Martens JH, Jahn D, Thermes C, Rambach A and Warren MJ (2003) Identification and functional analysis of enzymes required for precorrin-2 dehydrogenation and metal ion insertion in the biosynthesis of sirohaem and cobalamin in Bacillus megaterium. Biochem J 370: 505–516 Rickes EL, BN, Koniuszy FR, Wood TR, Folkers K (1948) Crystalline vitamin B12. Science 107: 396–397 Rodionov DA, Vitreschak AG, Mironov AA and Gelfand MS (2003) Comparative genomics of the vitamin B12 metabolism and regulation in prokaryotes. J Biol Chem 278: 41148–41159 Roessner CA and Scott AI (2006) Fine-tuning our knowledge of the anaerobic route to cobalamin (vitamin B12). J Bacteriol 188: 7331–7334 Roth JR, Lawrence JG, Rubenfield M, Kieffer-Higgins S and Church GM (1993) Characterization of the cobalamin (vitamin B12) biosynthetic genes of Salmonella typhimurium. J Bacteriol 175: 3303–3316 Roth JR, Lawrence JG and Bobik TA (1996) Cobalamin (coenzyme B12): Synthesis and biological significance. Annu Rev Microbiol 50: 137–181 Santander PJ, Kajiwara Y, Williams HJ and Scott AI (2006) Struc-
Martin J. Warren and Evelyne Deery tural characterization of novel cobalt corrinoids synthesized by enzymes of the vitamin B12 anaerobic pathway. Bioorg Med Chem 14: 724–731 Schubert HL, Blumenthal RM and Cheng X (2003) Many paths to methyltransfer: A chronicle of convergence. Trends Biochem Sci 28: 329–335 Scott AI (1994) On the duality of mechanism of ring contraction in vitamin B12 biosynthesis. Heterocycles 39: 471–476 Scott AI, Roessner CA, Stolowich NJ, Spencer JB, Min C and Ozaki SI (1993) Biosynthesis of vitamin B12. Discovery of the enzymes for oxidative ring contraction and insertion of the fourth methyl group. FEBS Lett 331: 105–108 Shipman LW, Li D, Roessner CA, Scott AI and Sacchettini JC (2001) Crystal structure of precorrin-8X methyl mutase. Structure 9: 587–596 Smith EL (1948) Purification of anti-pernicious anemia factors from liver. Nature 161: 638–639 Spencer JB, Stolowich NJ, Santander PJ, Pichon C, Kajiwara M, Tokiwa S, Takatori K and Scott AI (1994) Mechanism of the ring contraction step in vitamin B12 biosynthesis—the origin and subsequent fate of the oxygen functionalities in precorrin3X. J Am Chem Soc 116: 4991–4992. Thibaut D, Couder M, Crouzet J, Debussche L, Cameron B and Blanche F (1990a) Assay and purification of S-adenosyl-Lmethionine:Precorrin-2 methyltransferase from Pseudomonas denitrificans. J Bacteriol 172: 6245–6251 Thibaut D, Debussche L and Blanche F (1990b) Biosynthesis of vitamin B12: Isolation of precorrin-6X, a metal-free precursor of the corrin macrocycle retaining five S-adenosylmethioninederived peripheral methyl groups. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 87: 8795–8799 Thibaut, D Couder M, Famechon A, Debussche L, Cameron B, Crouzet J and Blanche F (1992) The final step in the biosynthesis of hydrogenobyrinic acid is catalyzed by the cobH gene product with precorrin-8X as the substrate. J Bacteriol 174: 1043–1049 Thibaut D, Debussche L, Frechet D, Herman F, Vuilhorgne M and Blanche F (1993). Biosynthesis of vitamin B12 - the structure of factor-IV, the oxidized form of precorrin-4. J Chem Soc, Chem Commun: 513 Toohey JI (1965) A vitamin B12 compound containing no cobalt. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 54: 934–942 Toohey JI (1966) Cobalt-free corrinoid compounds from photosynthetic bacteria. Fed Proc 25: 1628–1632 Vévodová J, Graham RM, Raux E, Schubert HL, Roper DI, Brindley AA, Scott AI, Roessner CA, Stamford NPJ, Stroupe EM, Getzoff ED, Warren MJ and Wilson KS (2004) Structure/function studies on a S-adenosyl-L-methionine-dependent uroporphyrinogen III C methyltransferase (SUMT), a key regulatory enzyme of tetrapyrrole biosynthesis. J Mol Biol 344: 419–433 Vitreschak AG, Rodionov DA, Mironov AA and Gelfand MS (2003) Regulation of the vitamin B12 metabolism and transport in bacteria by a conserved RNA structural element. RNA 9: 1084–1097 Vlcek C, Paces V, Maltsev N, Paces J, Haselkorn R and Fonstein M (1997) Sequence of a 189-kb segment of the chromosome of Rhodobacter capsulatus SB1003. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 94: 9384–9388 Warren MJ, Raux E, Schubert HL and Escalante-Semerena JC
Chapter 5
B12 Biosynthesis
(2002) The biosynthesis of adenosylcobalamin (vitamin B12). Nat Prod Rep 19: 390–412 Whipple GH and Robscheit-Robbins FS (1925) Favourable
95 influence of liver, heart and skeletal muscle in diet on blood regeneration in anemia. Am J Physiol 72: 408–418
Chapter 6 Distribution and Biosynthesis of Carotenoids Shinichi Takaichi* Department of Biology, Nippon Medical School, Kosugi-cho 2, Nakahara, Kawasaki 211-0063, Japan
Summary ................................................................................................................................................................. 97 I. Introduction....................................................................................................................................................... 98 II. Carotenogenesis ............................................................................................................................................ 101 A. Classification of Carotenogenesis .................................................................................................... 101 B. Carotenogenesis Genes and Gene Clusters.................................................................................... 103 C. Isopentenylpyrophosphate (IPP) and Phytoene Synthesis .............................................................. 103 D. Desaturation of Phytoene to Lycopene ............................................................................................ 103 E. Biosynthesis of Spirilloxanthin .......................................................................................................... 104 1. The Normal Spirilloxanthin Pathway ....................................................................................... 104 2. The Unusual Spirilloxanthin Pathway...................................................................................... 106 3. The Spheroidene Pathway ...................................................................................................... 107 4. The Carotenal Pathway........................................................................................................... 108 F. Biosynthesis of Okenone .................................................................................................................. 108 1. The Okenone and the R.g.-keto Carotenoid Pathways .......................................................... 108 G. Biosynthesis of Carotenoid Glucosides and their Fatty Acid Esters ................................................ 109 III. Carotenoids in Purple Bacteria....................................................................................................................... 111 A. Anaerobic Purple Bacteria................................................................................................................ 111 1. Alphaproteobacteria and Betaproteobacteria ....................................................................... 111 2. Gammaproteobacteria ........................................................................................................... 112 B. Aerobic Photosynthetic Bacteria ...................................................................................................... 112 Acknowledgments ................................................................................................................................................. 114 References ............................................................................................................................................................ 114
Summary Purple bacteria including aerobic photosynthetic bacteria belong to the Proteobacteria, and 75 genera including around 160 species have been described. These bacteria produce around 100 different carotenoids, which are essential for photoprotection and light-harvesting. This chapter summarizes the distribution and biosynthesis of carotenoids in all of the purple bacteria described so far. All of the carotenogenesis genes from Rhodobacter capsulatus, Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Rubrivivax gelatinosus, and some genes from other purple bacteria have been functionally confirmed, and the characteristics of their products have been investigated. When one enzyme of the typical spirilloxanthin pathway is lacking or is present with reduced activity, the carotenoid composition of the bacterium will be expected to change; indeed, the variation of the spirilloxanthin pathways can be explained by this idea. Based on these new findings, two main pathways within purple bacteria have been proposed; the spirilloxanthin pathway (normal spirilloxanthin, unusual spirilloxanthin, spheroidene, and carotenal pathways) and the okenone pathway (okenone and R.g.-keto carotenoid pathways). In addi*Email: [email protected]
C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty (eds): The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria, pp. 97–117. © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V.
98
Shinichi Takaichi
tion, carotenoid glucosides and carotenoid glucoside fatty acid esters have also been found in some species. Purple bacteria classified as Alphaproteobacteria and Betaproteobacteria have the spirilloxanthin pathway, while those in the Gammaproteobacteria have either the spirilloxanthin or the okenone pathway depending on genus or species. The aerobic photosynthetic bacteria described so far are classified as Alphaproteobacteria and Betaproteobacteria, and most species have the spirilloxanthin pathway. Furthermore most of these species also have unusual carotenoids including ‘non-photosynthetic’ carotenoids, such as carotenoid sulfates and carotenoic acids, which seem to have no photosynthetic functions. I. Introduction Anoxygenic photosynthetic bacteria include purple bacteria, green sulfur bacteria, green filamentous bacteria and heliobacteria, and they necessarily synthesize not only bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) but also carotenoids. About three decades ago, Schmidt (1978) summarized the carotenoids in 19 genera including 38 species of photosynthetic bacteria. Subsequently, Takaichi (1999) summarized carotenoids and carotenogenesis pathways in 55 genera including 133 species. Since then, many novel genera and species have been recognized, and some species have been re-classified based on the results of new classification techniques (Imhoff et al., 1998a, 1998b). Now, around 90 genera including around 200 species of photosynthetic bacteria have been described. Purple bacteria, including the aerobic photosynthetic bacteria, belong to Phylum Proteobacteria and are distributed between 3 Classes (Alphaproteobacteria, Betaproteobacteria and Gammaproteobacteria); 7 Orders, 14 Families and 75 Genera, and 164 species have been described (Table 1) (Brenner et al., 2005). Around 50 different carotenoids have been found in the anaerobic purple bacteria, and most of their chemical structures are distinct from those found in algae, fungi, higher plants and non-photosynthetic bacteria. These carotenoids have been characterized in the following ways by Takaichi (1999) and some newly found characteristics are also added: (1) They most often occur as acyclic compounds. (2) They often contain the tertiary hydroxy and the methoxy groups at C-1. (3) There are frequently double bonds in the C-3,4 position. (4) Keto groups in conjugation with the polyene chain are found attached to C-2 or C-4 of the ψ end group. (5) Aldehyde groups in conjugation Abbreviations: BChl – bacteriochlorophyll; Erb. – Erythrobacter; Erb-type – Erythrobacter-type; IPP – isopentenylpyrophosphate; LH – light-harvesting; LH1 – light-harvesting 1 complex; LH2 – light-harvesting 2 complex; Rba. – Rhodobacter; RC – reaction center; Rps. – Rhodopseudomonas; Rsp. – Rhodospirillum; Rvi. – Rubrivivax
with the polyene chain are sometimes present at the C20 position. (6) Cyclic carotenoids, such as okenone, have aromatic rings of the χ end group, synthesized from the β end group. (7) Some species have carotenoid glucosides and/or their fatty acid esters. (8) In many cases, there are small amounts of intermediates occurring later than neurosporene or lycopene. (9) Further, most aerobic photosynthetic bacteria have spirilloxanthin, and some have additional unusual carotenoids including ‘non-photosynthetic’ carotenoids, such as carotenoid sulfates, carotenoic acids and hydroxy derivatives of β-carotene. Most carotenoids have trivial names, and moreover all carotenoids have been named semisystematically based on IUPAC-IUB nomenclature (IUPAC Commission on Nomenclature of Organic Chemistry and the IUPAC-IUB Commission on Biochemical Nomenclature, 1975). A list of both the names and the structures of all known naturally occurring carotenoids, and references giving data for each compound are presented in the Carotenoids Handbook (Britton et al., 2004), and in the Web of Bioactive Lipid Database (Carotenoids) (http://lipidbank.jp/). Two main pathways for carotenogenesis within the purple bacteria are summarized based on the carotenoid compositions (Schmidt, 1978; Takaichi, 1999). Note that the compositions are rather variable depending on the culture conditions, such as light intensity (Gardiner et al., 1993), oxygen concentration (Goodwin, 1956), and growth phases (Schwerzmann and Bachofen, 1989), and also depending on the strain in some species, such as Rbl. acidophilus (previously Rps. acidophila) (Gardiner et al., 1993) and Rhodocyclus tenuis (Schmidt, 1978). Identification of carotenoids is based on the description given in each reference (Table 1), although it should also be noted that some were doubtful or were identified without sufficient data. Classically, carotenogenesis pathways in organisms were determined based on the carotenoid composition of the wild type, and comparison with the carotenoids in spontaneous mutants and the mutants induced by
Chapter 6
Carotenoid Biosynthesis
99
Table 1. Classification and carotenogenesis pathways of the purple bacteria Classification a,b,c Class I. Alphaproteobacteria Order I. Rhodospirillales (alpha-1) Family I. Rhodospirillaceae Genus I. Rhodospirillum (Rsp.) Genus V. Phaeospirillum (Phs.) Genus VI. Rhodocista (Rcs.) Genus VII. Rhodospira (Rsa.) Genus VIII. Rhodovibrio (Rhv.) Genus IX. Roseospira (Ros.) Genus. Rhodothalassium (Rts.) Family II. Acetobacteraceae * Genus II. Acidiphilium (Acp.) * Genus III. Acidisphaera (Acs.) * Genus VII. Craurococcus (Crc.) * Genus XII. Paracraurococcus (Pcr.) Genus XIII. Rhodopila (Rpi.) * Genus XIV. Roseococcus (Rsc.) * Genus XV. Rubritepida (Rut.) Order III. Rhodobacterales (alpha-3) Family I. Rhodobacteraceae Genus I. Rhodobacter (Rba.) Genus XVIII. Rhodobaca (Rca.) Genus XX. Rhodovulum (Rdv.) * Genus XXI. Roseibium (Rib.) * Genus XXII. Roseinatronobacter (Rna.) * Genus XXIII. Roseivivax (Rsv.) * Genus XXIV. Roseobacter (Rsb.) * Genus XXV. Roseovarius (Rva.) * Genus XXVI. Rubrimonas (Rum.) * Genus XXIX. Staleya (Stl.) * Genus. Dinoroseobacter * Genus. Roseibacterium * Genus. Roseicyclus * Genus. Roseisalinus Order IV. Sphingomonadales (alpha-4) Family I. Sphingomonadaceae * Genus II. Blastomonas * Genus III. Erythrobacter (Erb.) * Genus IV. Erythromicrobium (Erm.) * Genus VII. Porphyrobacter (Por.) * Genus IX. Sandaracinobacter (San.) * Genus. Citromicrobium (Cmi.) * Genus. Sandarakinorhabdus
Number of species
Carotenogenesis pathways found in the genus d,e
2 2 2 1 2 4 1
Normal, Unusual Unusual, G Normal Unusual Normal Unusual Normal
6 1 1 1 1 1 1
Normal Normal, Acid Normal, Acid Normal, Acid R.g.-keto C30-Acid, G-FA Normal
5 1 8 2 2 2 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1
Spheroidene Spheroidene Spheroidene (no data) Spheroidene (no data) Spheroidene Normal, Spheroidene (no data) (no data) Spheroidene (no data) (no data) (no data)
2 2 3 6 1 1 1
Spheroidene Erb-type Erb-type Erb-type (no data) (no data) Erb-type
Shinichi Takaichi
100 Table 1. Continued Classification a,b,c Order VI. Rhizobiales (alpha-2) Family I. Rhizobiaceae * Genus I. Rhizobium Family V. Phyllobacteriaceae * Genus. Hoeflea Family VIII. Bradyrhizobiaceae * Genus I. Bradyrhizobium Genus VIII. Rhodoblastus (Rbl.) Genus IX. Rhodopseudomonas (Rps.) Family IX. Hyphomicrobiaceae Genus VII. Blastochloris (Blc.) Genus XVI. Rhodomicrobium (Rmi.) Genus XVII. Rhodoplanes (Rpl.) Family X. Methylobacteriaceae * Genus I. Methylobacterium (Mtb.) Family XI. Rhodobiaceae Genus I. Rhodobium (Rbi.) Genus II. Roseospirillum (Rss.) Class II. Betaproteobacteria Order I. Burkholderiales Family IV. Comamonadaceae Genus XIII. Rhodoferax (Rfx.) Genera incertae sedis * Genus IV. Roseateles (Rst.) Genus V. Rubrivivax (Rvi.) Order VI. Rhodocyclales Family I. Rhodocyclaceae Genus I. Rhodocyclus (Rcy.) Class III. Gammaproteobacteria Order I. Chromatiales Family I. Chromatiaceae Genus I. Chromatium (Chr.) Genus II. Allochromatium (Alc.) Genus IV. Halochromatium (Hch.) Genus V. Isochromatium (Isc.) Genus VI. Lamprobacter (Lpb.) Genus VII. Lamprocystis (Lpc.) Genus VIII. Marichromatium (Mch.) Genus XI. Rhabdochromatium (Rbc.) Genus XIII. Thermochromatium (Tch.) Genus XIV. Thioalkalicoccus (Tac.) Genus XV. Thiobaca (Tba.) Genus XVI. Thiocapsa (Tca.) Genus XVII. Thiococcus (Tco.)
Number of species
Carotenogenesis pathways found in the genus d,e
1
Normal
1
Spheroidene
1 2 6
Normal and Canthaxanthin Normal, Carotenal, G Normal, Unusual
2 1 2
Normal, Unusual Unusual, β-Carotene Normal
18
Normal, Acid, C-30 Acid
2 1
Normal Normal
2
Normal and Spheroidene
1 2
Normal Normal and Spheroidene
2
Carotenal
2 3 2 1 1 2 3 1 1 1 1 5 1
Okenone Normal, Unusual, Carotenal Normal, Unusual Carotenal Okenone Carotenal, Okenone Normal, Unusual, Okenone Unusual Unusual Unusual Unusual Normal, Okenone, R.g.-keto Unusual, Carotenal
Chapter 6
Carotenoid Biosynthesis
101
Table 1. Continued Classification a,b,c Genus XVIII. Thiocystis (Tcs.) Genus XIX. Thiodictyon (Tdc.) Genus XX. Thioflavicoccus (Tfc.) Genus XXI. Thiohalocapsa (Thc.) Genus XXII. Thiolamprovum (Tlp.) Genus XXIII. Thiopedia (Tpd.) Genus XXIV. Thiorhodococcus (Trc.) Genus XXV. Thiorhodovibrio (Trv.) Genus XXVI. Thiospirillum (Tsp.) Family II. Ectothiorhodospiraceae Genus I. Ectothiorhodospira (Ect.) Genus V. Halorhodospira (Hlr.) Genus IX. Thiorhodospira (Trs.)
Number of species
Carotenogenesis pathways found in the genus d,e
4 2 1 1 1 1 3 1 1
Normal, Carotenal, Okenone, R.g.-keto Carotenal Unusual Normal, Okenone, R.g.-keto Normal Okenone Unusual, Carotenal Unusual Unusual
4 4 1
Normal, Unusual Normal, Unusual, G, G-FA Unusual
a
Bremner et al. (2005), and new genera and species are added. b Genus with asterisk (*) contains aerobic photosynthetic bacteria. c Recommended 3-letter abbreviations for genera of the purple bacteria proposed by International Committee on Systematics of Prokaryotes Subcommittee on the Taxonomy of Phototrophic Bacteria (Imhoff and Madigan, 2004) are indicated in parentheses. d Carotenogenesis pathways and unusual carotenoids found in the genus are indicated. e Acid – carotenoic acid; Carotenal – carotenal pathway; Erb-type – Erythrobacter-type carotenoids; G – carotenoid glucoside; G-FA – carotenoid glucoside fatty acid ester; Normal – normal spirilloxanthin pathway; Okenone – okenone pathway; R.g.-keto – R.g.-keto carotenoid pathway; Spheroidene – spheroidene pathway; Unusual – unusual spirilloxanthin pathway.
mutagenesis. In the 1980s some carotenogenesis genes were cloned and functionally confirmed, and characteristics of enzymes were investigated. In the early 1990’s carotenogenesis gene clusters were found in some bacteria, such as Rhodobacter (Armstrong et al., 1989; Lang et al., 1995) and Pantoea (previously Erwinia) (Misawa et al., 1990), and their complete carotenogenesis pathways were determined. Furthermore, parts of the pathways were investigated in organisms lacking gene clusters, such as the green sulfur bacteria, cyanobacteria and higher plants. At present, the genome sequences of around 100 bacteria have been determined, which has led to the identification of some carotenogenesis gene clusters and some non-clustered genes, based on sequence homologies. II. Carotenogenesis A. Classification of Carotenogenesis On the basis of the analyses of carotenoid compositions Schmidt (1978) proposed the spirilloxanthin, the spheroidene and the okenone pathways for
carotenogenesis in the purple bacteria. Since then, many new species have been described, and some carotenogenesis genes have been cloned and the characteristics of their products have been investigated (Table 2) (Armstrong, 1995, 1997; Sandmann, 1994, 1997). Based on these results and the changes in the classification of the purple bacteria, two main pathways within the purple bacteria were suggested by Takaichi (1999): 1. The spirilloxanthin pathway (normal spirilloxanthin, unusual spirilloxanthin, spheroidene, and carotenal pathways: see Fig. 6). 2. The okenone pathway (okenone, and R.g.-keto carotenoid pathways: see Fig. 7). The normal spirilloxanthin pathway is fundamental and can account for the variation of carotenoids in the purple bacteria, which would arise when one enzyme of this normal spirilloxanthin pathway is lacking or is present with reduced activity. The aerobic photosynthetic bacteria described so far are classified in the purple bacteria, and although most have the spirilloxanthin pathway, some have
(crtE)
Roseobacter denitrificans
crtI.c
crtC
(crtC)
(crtC)
(crtD)
(crtD)
crtD
crtD
(crtD)
crtD
crtD
(crtF)
(crtF)
(crtF)
crtF
(crtF)
(crtF)
crtF
(crtF)
(crtA)
crtA
crtA
crtA
crtA
crtY
crtY
crtW
14
13
12
11
10
6–9
5
4
3
2
1
Reference
a
Methylobacterium extorquens (crtE) (crtB) crtI (crtC) (crtD) (crtF) 15 Parentheses indicate that the functions of the genes are not confirmed, but the genes are suggested from DNA base sequence homology and their presence in the carotenogenesis gene cluster (See Table 3 and Fig. 2). b The upper row is a gene cluster for spirilloxanthin synthesis, and the lower one is that for canthaxanthin synthesis. 1. Reslewic et al. (2005); 2. Armstrong et al. (1989); 3. Lang et al. (1995); 4. Maeda et al. (2005); and Maeda, personal communication; 5. Shimada, personal communication; 6. Ouchane et al. (1997a); 7. Ouchane et al. (1997b); 8. Harada et al. (2001); 9. Pinta et al. (2003); 10. Kovács et al. (2003); 11. Swingley et al. (2007); 12. Matsumura et al. (1997); 13. Hannibal et al. (2000); 14. Giraud et al. (2004); 15. van Dien et al. (2003).
crtB.c
crtE.c
(crtI.s)
(crtB.s)
Bradyrhizobium ORS278 b
(crtE.s)
crtI
(crtI)
Erythrobacter longus
(crtB)
(crtI)
crtC
(crtE)
crtI
Thiocapsa roseopersicina
crtB
(crtE)
Rubrivivax gelatinosus
crtI
crtC
crtC
(crtB)
crtI
crtC
(crtE)
crtB
crtI
(crtD)
Carotenogenesis genes a (crtC)
Rhodopseudomonas palustris
crtE
Rhodobacter sphaeroides
crtB
(crtI)
crtC
crtE
Rhodobacter capsulatus
(crtB)
Rhodovulum sulfidophilum
(crtE)
Rhodospirillum rubrum
Species
Table 2. Carotenogenesis genes in the purple bacteria
102 Shinichi Takaichi
Chapter 6
Carotenoid Biosynthesis
additional unusual carotenoids as described below. The relationship between the classification of the purple bacteria, including the aerobic photosynthetic bacteria, and the carotenogenesis pathways is summarized in Table 1. B. Carotenogenesis Genes and Gene Clusters The first carotenogenesis genes to be cloned and functionally confirmed were found in a gene cluster in Rba. capsulatus (Armstrong et al., 1989) and in Pantoea ananatis (previously Erwinia uredovora) (Misawa et al., 1990). Some bacteria, including some purple bacteria (Table 2) and two species of Pantoea, have a carotenogenesis gene cluster, while others, such as Chlorobaculum (previously Chlorobium) tepidum (green sulfur bacteria), cyanobacteria, algae and higher plants, have no such clusters. The carotenogenesis gene clusters and some genes functionally confirmed from the purple bacteria are summarized in Table 2, although some genes are identified only from homology searches. C. Isopentenylpyrophosphate (IPP) and Phytoene Synthesis IPP, a C5-compound, is the source of isoprenoids, carotenoids, and phytol of (bacterio)chlorophylls. The biosynthesis of IPP via the mevalonate pathway was studied in the 1950s. More recently, in the 1990s, a new pathway via 1-deoxy-D-xylulose-5-phosphate was found, termed the DOXP pathway. In plastids of higher plants, IPP is synthesized by the DOXP pathway, whereas the mevalonate pathway is used in the cytoplasm. Rhodopseudomonas (Rps.) palustris, Rhodospirillum (Rsp.) rubrum, Rbl. acidophilus (previously Rps. acidophila), Allochromatium (previously Chromatium) vinosum and cyanobacteria produce IPP by the DOXP pathway, while Chlorobium limicola (green sulfur bacteria) and Chloroflexus aurantiacus (green filamentous bacteria) employ the mevalonate pathway. These two pathways are widely distributed among prokaryotes, and their distributions seem not to follow any pattern of taxonomic classification (Lichenthaler, 1999; Rohmer, 1999). Most carotenoids are tetraterpenoids consisting of eight IPP units. Farnesyl pyrophosphate (C15) is synthesized from three IPPs. Then, one IPP is added to farnesyl pyrophosphate by geranylgeranyl pyrophosphate synthase (CrtE) to yield geranylgeranyl
103 pyrophosphate (C20). In a condensation of the two C20-compounds, phytoene (C40) is formed by phytoene synthase (CrtB) using ATP (Sandmann, 1997). This pathway has been confirmed by the cloning of the genes from Rhodobacter and Pantoea (Sandmann, 1994, 1997; Armstrong, 1995, 1997). D. Desaturation of Phytoene to Lycopene Phytoene, the starting compound in carotenogenesis, is desaturated to neurosporene or lycopene in the purple bacteria. Subsequent reactions produce carotenes by desaturation, saturation, cyclization and aromatization, or xanthophylls by introduction of oxy-groups, such as hydroxy, methoxy, keto and aldehyde groups. These reactions found in the purple bacteria are summarized in Table 3 and Fig. 1. Four desaturation steps are known in the conversion from phytoene to lycopene by phytoene desaturase (CrtI) (Fig. 2). Usually the final product of CrtI is lycopene. This was confirmed by the functional expression of crtI genes of Pantoea ananatis (Misawa et al., 1990; Linden et al., 1991) and Rps. palustris (K. Shimada, personal communication) in Escherichia coli in a phytoene background. In the case of crtI genes of Rba. capsulatus (Linden et al., 1991) and Rba. sphaeroides (Lang et al., 1994, 1995), the final product is three-steps desaturated neurosporene. The crtI mutant of Rba. sphaeroides produces phytoene, and by the functional expression of crt genes or crtI gene from Pantoea stewartii (previously Erwinia herbicola) in the mutant, it produces lycopene (Hunter et al., 1994; Garcia-Asua et al., 2002). In the case of Rubrivivax (Rvi.) gelatinosus, the final products are around 90% neurosporene and 10% lycopene (Harada et al., 2001). The deduced amino acid sequences of the bacterial crtI genes including these species show significant similarity, but the final products are different (Sandmann, 1994; Armstrong, 1995; Harada et al., 2001). FAD is a cofactor for CrtI from Rba. capsulatus (Raisig et al., 1996). Diphenylamine is an inhibitor of CrtI (Sandmann, 1994). The mechanisms for determination of the final product, and for recognition of the desaturating position on carotenoids by CrtI, are still unknown. Phytoene takes the 15-cis form in most cases. Isomerization from the 15-cis form to the all-trans form is reported to occur non-enzymatically during the desaturation reactions, since there are no isomerase genes in the carotenogenesis gene clusters of bacteria described above, and gradual conversion of 15-cis
104
Shinichi Takaichi
Fig. 1. Types of reactions and enzymes seen in carotenogenesis within the purple bacteria. Parentheses indicate abbreviations of the reactions and the enzymes (see Table 3).
phytoene to all-trans lycopene is found when the crtI gene is expressed in Escherichia coli in a phytoene background (Misawa et al., 1990). On the other hand, poly-cis-carotenes are produced during desaturation to lycopene, and are changed to the all-trans form by light or by carotene isomerase, which is CrtH in green sulfur bacteria and cyanobacteria and CrtISO in higher plants (Giuliano et al., 2002). In the phytoene desaturation reaction, two pathways are known, via ζ-carotene or asymmetrical ζ-carotene (Fig. 2). The ζ-carotene pathway is found in Rba. capsulatus, Rba. sphaeroides (S. Takaichi, unpublished), Rvi. gelatinosus (Harada et al., 2001) and Roseobacter denitrificans (Harashima and Nakada, 1983), while the asymmetrical ζ-carotene pathway is found in Rsp. rubrum (Davies, 1970), Rhodopila globiformis (Schmidt and Liaaen-Jensen, 1973), Rhodomicrobium vannielii (Britton et al., 1975), Blastochloris (previously Rps.) viridis (S. Takaichi, unpublished) and Erythrobacter longus (Takaichi et al., 1990). These two pathways seem not to be related
to the final products of CrtI, neurosporene and lycopene, and to the classification of purple bacteria. E. Biosynthesis of Spirilloxanthin 1. The Normal Spirilloxanthin Pathway The biosynthesis of spirilloxanthin, a final product of the normal spirilloxanthin pathway, is found in a large number of species of purple bacteria (Table 1). Spirilloxanthin is a symmetrical compound containing the methoxy groups at C-1 and C-1´ and additional double bonds in the C-3,4 and C-3´,4´ positions. It has 13 conjugated double bonds (Fig. 3). A sequence of the reactions leading from lycopene to spirilloxanthin has been confirmed (Fig. 3). This sequence includes successive reactions of (1) hydration at C-1,2 by a hydratase, CrtC, (2) desaturation at C-3,4 by a desaturase, CrtD, and (3) methylation of the tertiary hydroxy group at C-1 by a methyltransferase, CrtF. These reactions occur initially on one
Chapter 6
Carotenoid Biosynthesis
105
Table 3. Types of reactions seen in carotenogenesis within the purple bacteria, and the corresponding genes (see Fig. 1) for the functions a Reactions Geranylgeranyl pyrophosphate synthesis Phytoene synthesis Desaturation of phytoene C-3,4 Desaturation C-1,2 Saturation Lycopene cyclization Aromatization from β to χ end group C-1,2 Hydration Methylation Ketolation at C-2 of ψ end group Ketolation at C-4 of ψ end group Ketolation at C-4 of β end group Hydroxylation at C-20 Aldehyde at C-20 Glucosylation Fatty acid esterification
Genes crtE crtB crtI crtD
Abbreviations b
– 2H + 2H
crtY crtC crtF crtA
+ H2O + Me 2-Keto 4-Keto
crtW 20-OH 20-Aldehyde cruC c, crtX d cruD c
a Since aerobic photosynthetic bacteria contain many unusual carotenoids, only known genes are listed. b These abbreviations are used in Fig. 1–8. c Chlorobaculum (previously Chlorobium) tepidum (Maresca and Bryant, 2006). d Pantoea ananatis (previously Erwinia uredovora) (Misawa et al., 1990).
Fig. 2. Desaturation from phytoene to lycopene by phytoene desaturase (CrtI).
half of the molecule to yield anhydrorhodovibrin, and then on the other half. The major product is
spirilloxanthin, and usually small amounts of all or a few of five intermediates are also found (Fig. 3).
Shinichi Takaichi
106
Fig. 3. The normal spirilloxanthin pathway. Enzymes are indicated in parentheses (see Table 3).
Other postulated intermediates are, however, rarely found as described below. These genes are found in the carotenogenesis gene clusters from Rps. palustris and Rsp. rubrum (Table 2). At present, the way in which the successive reactions are controlled, with reactions first on one half of the carotenoid and then on the other, has not been elucidated. 2. The Unusual Spirilloxanthin Pathway When one enzyme of the normal spirilloxanthin pathway is lacking or is present with reduced activity, the carotenoid composition of the bacterium will be expected to change (Takaichi, 1999). Indeed, some species have been reported to have such unusual compositions (Table 1). Lycopene is accumulated in Rhabdochromatium marinum (Dilling et al., 1995) and Thiobaca trueperi (Rees et al., 2002), and this may be due to low activity of C-1,2 hydratase (CrtC) (Fig. 3). Rhodopin is the major carotenoid in some species: Rsp. photometricum and Phaeospirillum (previously Rsp.) molischianum (Matsuura and
Shimada, 1993), Rhodomicrobium vannielii, and Allochromatium (previously Chromatium) vinosum (Schmidt, 1978), Thiorhodovibrio winogradskii (Overmann et al., 1992), Thiorhodococcus minor (Guyoneaud et al., 1997), and Rps. palustris, Thermochromatium (previously Chromatium) tepidum and Ectothiorhodospira marismortui (S. Takaichi, unpublished). This may be due to low activity of C-3,4 desaturase (CrtD), and the rhodopin may not be a suitable substrate for the methylation enzyme (CrtF) due to the single bond at C-3,4 (Fig. 3). On the other hand, 3,4,3´,4´-tetrahydrospirilloxanthin (Fig. 6) is the major component in Rhodospira trueperi (Pfennig et al., 1997), Thioalkalicoccus limnaeus (Bryantseva et al., 2000), Thiocapsa pfennigii (Eimhjellen et al., 1967) and Thioflavicoccus mobilis (Imhoff and Pfennig, 2001) probably due to lack of CrtD, but in these cases rhodopin can be methylated by CrtF in spite of the single bond at C-3,4. The same carotenoid is also found in a carotenogenesis mutant (crtD) of Rsp. rubrum (Komori et al., 1998).
Chapter 6
Carotenoid Biosynthesis
107
Fig. 4. The spheroidene pathway. Enzymes are indicated in parentheses (see Table 3). The pathway from chloroxanthin to 3,4-dihydrospheroidene might not be involved in vivo, and 3,4-dihydrospheroidene might not be changed to spheroidene.
3. The Spheroidene Pathway Three genera, Rhodobacter, Rhodobaca and Rhodovulum, and some genera of aerobic photosynthetic bacteria (Table 1) produce spheroidene and its derivatives. Spheroidene is an asymmetrical compound containing the same end group as spirilloxanthin on one side and the 7,8-dihydro-ψ end group on the other (Fig. 4). All of the seven carotenogenesis genes in Rba. capsulatus (Armstrong et al., 1989) and Rba. sphaeroides (Lang et al., 1995) have been found to form a gene cluster. The characteristics of their products have been investigated (Fig. 4). Phytoene desaturase (CrtI) produces neurosporene from phytoene in three desaturation steps. Then, successive reactions include hydration at C-1,2 by hydroxyneurosporene synthase (CrtC) to yield chloroxanthin (hydroxyneurosporene), desaturation at C-3,4 by methoxyneurosporene dehydrogenase (CrtD) to yield demethylspheroidene, and methylation at the C-1 hydroxy group by hydroxyneurosporene-O-methyltransferase (CrtF) to yield spheroidene. Further, CrtC can more or less hydrate at the 7´,8´-dihydro-ψ end group to yield OH-spheroidene depending on the species. Under semi-aerobic conditions, spheroidene monooxygenase (CrtA) introduces the keto group at C-2 to yield
spheroidenone. The 1´-hydroxy-7´,8´-dihydro-ψ end group cannot be modified further due to the single bond at C-7´,8´. The keto group of spheroidenone from Roseobacter denitrificans is in the single bond cis-conformation around the conjugated double bond (Fig. 4) (Takaichi et al., 1991b). Water is a substrate for CrtC in Rba. sphaeroides (Yeliseev and Kaplan, 1997). The hydrogen acceptor of CrtD in Rba. sphaeroides is molecular oxygen (Albrecht et al., 1997). The methyl residue in the methoxy groups arises from S-adenosylmethionine in Rba. sphaeroides (Singh et al., 1973) and Rba. capsulatus (Scolnik et al., 1980). The oxygen of the keto group at C-2 is derived directly from the atmosphere in Rba. sphaeroides (Shneour, 1962) and Rhodovulum sulfidophilum (Maeda et al., 2006). 3,4-Dihydrospheroidene (methoxyneurosporene), which is rarely found in the wild type strains, is found in two strains of the carotenoid mutants, Rba. capsulatus MT1131 (Frank et al., 1986) and Rba. sphaeroides Ga (S. Takaichi, unpublished), accompanied by neurosporene and chloroxanthin (Fig. 4). These strains may be crtD gene mutants. When the crtD gene of Rba. sphaeroides is disrupted, the three carotenoids described above are accumulated (Lang et al., 1995). Further, in in vitro experiments, 3,4dihydrospheroidene is not able to be the substrate
Shinichi Takaichi
108 for CrtD from Rba. sphaeroides (Albrecht et al., 1997). These results indicate that CrtC, CrtD and CrtF work sequentially in this order, and a part of the chloroxanthin can be the substrate for CrtF only when chloroxanthin accumulates significantly. Consequently, 3,4-dihydrospheroidene may not be involved in carotenogenesis in the spheroidene pathway (Fig. 4). Similarly, in the normal spirilloxanthin pathway, 3,4-dihydroanhydrorhodovibrin (Fig. 6) and 3,4-dihydrospirilloxanthin (Fig. 8), which are produced by methylation prior to desaturation, are rarely found in the wild type strains. This may be also due to similar properties of CrtD and CrtF. Since Rhodobaca bogoriensis accumulates demethylspheroidene and demethylspheroidenone, activity of CrtF of this bacterium may be low (Fig. 4) (Takaichi et al., 2001a). Rvi. gelatinosus produces carotenoids of both the spheroidene and the spirilloxanthin pathways (Table 1; see Fig. 6). When the Rvi. gelatinosus crtI gene is expressed in Escherichia coli in a phytoene background, the products are around 90% neurosporene and 10% lycopene (Harada et al., 2001). The crtC mutant accumulates both neurosporene and lycopene (Ouchane et al., 1997a). These results indicate that phytoene desaturase (CrtI) of Rvi. gelatinosus can produce both neurosporene and lycopene. When the crtD gene is disrupted, neurosporene, chloroxanthin, 3,4-dihydrospheroidene, lycopene and rhodopin are accumulated (Ouchane et al., 1997a). Thus, Rvi. gelatinosus produces spheroidene and spirilloxanthin from neurosporene and lycopene, respectively. Although the reaction of ketolation at C-2 of the ψ end group (CrtA) is usually involved in the spheroidene pathway and not in the normal spirilloxanthin pathway (Fig. 3), this bacterium can also oxidize spirilloxanthin to 2,2´-diketospirilloxanthin (Fig. 8) by CrtA. Further, Rhodoferax antarcticus (Jung et al., 2004) and Roseobacter denitrificans (Harashima and Nakada, 1983) are also reported to have both of these keto-carotenoids. Thus, the spheroidene pathway is a variant of the unusual spirilloxanthin pathway as a result of the different properties of the phytoene desaturases (CrtI) and the additional enzyme CrtA.
13-cis form of rhodopin. Usually, small amounts of rhodopinol, lycopenol and lycopenal can also be detected. Methoxylycopenal is found as a major component in Lamprocystis roseopersicina (Pfennig et al., 1968; Francis and Liaaen-Jensen, 1970), and tetrahydrospirilloxanthinal is found in Thiococcus (previously Thiocapsa) pfennigii (Eimhjellen et al., 1967). Rbl. acidophilus (previously Rps. acidophila) strain 7050 contains rhodopinal glucoside (Fig. 6) as a major component (Gardiner et al., 1993) and small amount of methoxylycopenal (Schmidt, 1971). Spirilloxanthin and its precursors are often found in Rbl. acidophilus (Schmidt, 1971; Gardiner et al, 1993), Thiocystis (previously Chromatium) violascens and Thiocystis violacea (Schmidt et al., 1965), while in other species, spirilloxanthin intermediates occurring later than rhodopin are not found. From the structure of these carotenals, Francis and Liaaen-Jensen (1970) have postulated a branched path for each of the derivatives of cross-conjugated carotenals. Up to now, further support for this has not been reported, and the partially modified carotenogenesis pathway is shown in Fig. 5. Rhodopin and lycopene are hydroxylated at C-20 to yield rhodopinol and lycopenol, and then the hydroxy groups are oxidized to the aldehyde groups to yield rhodopinal and lycopenal, respectively. Whether lycopenol and lycopenal are precursors of rhodopinol and rhodopinal, respectively, has not been confirmed. Since all of these carotenals have a C-3,4 single bond, the C-3,4 desaturase (CrtD) may be inactive. Further, the activity of methylation to the hydroxy group at C-1 (CrtF) is none or low. Additional enzymes for hydroxylation at C-20 and for oxidation to the aldehyde group may be involved in this pathway, whereas nothing is known about how the aldehyde group is introduced under anaerobic conditions. The position is necessarily at C-20, rather than C-20´ or C-19, and the 13-cis form, is found since it is more stable than the all-trans form, because of the hydroxy or the aldehyde groups at C-20. The spirilloxanthin pathways (normal spirilloxanthin, unusual spirilloxanthin, spheroidene and carotenal pathways) are summarized in Fig. 6.
4. The Carotenal Pathway
F. Biosynthesis of Okenone
Four kinds of cross-conjugated carotenals (Fig. 5) are found in 8 genera including 12 species (Table 1). Most species contain rhodopinal as a major component, which has an aldehyde group at C-20 with the
1. The Okenone and the R.g.-keto Carotenoid Pathways R.g.-keto carotenoids are found in Rhodopila globi-
Chapter 6
Carotenoid Biosynthesis
109
Fig. 5. The carotenal pathway. The predicted pathway for the carotenogenesis of cross-conjugated carotenals and their structures are indicated.
formis, and okenone, together with small amounts of R.g.-keto carotenoids, is found in 8 genera and 10 species of Gammaproteobacteria, such as Chromatium okenii and Thiocystis gelatinosa (Table 1). Okenone has one aromatic χ end group (Fig. 7), and one aliphatic ψ end group substituted with the methoxy group at C-1 and the keto group at C-4. The keto group of okenone from Marichromatium (previously Chromatium) purpuratum is in the single bond trans-conformation around the conjugated double bond (Fig. 7) (Fujii et al., 1998). R.g.-keto III is a symmetrical carotenoid having end groups the same as one end of okenone. A small amount of lycopene is found in Rhodopila globiformis (S. Takaichi, unpublished) and in the diphenylamine-inhibited culture of Chromatium okenii (Schmidt et al., 1963). The carotenogenesis pathways of okenone and R.g.-keto carotenoids could start from lycopene rather than from neurosporene (Fig. 7).
The biosynthesis of both of these carotenoids may have a close relationship (Schmidt, 1978), and these pathways may be distinguished at the level of the cyclase, γ-carotene synthase; it could be present (the okenone pathway) or absent (the R.g.-keto carotenoid pathway). Nothing is known about how the keto group is introduced under anaerobic conditions. G. Biosynthesis of Carotenoid Glucosides and their Fatty Acid Esters The occurrence of carotenoid glucosides and their fatty acid esters in the purple bacteria is regarded as unusual; however, more recently, the wide distribution of such carotenoid derivatives among various species has become clear. They have also been found in some non-photosynthetic bacteria, green sulfur bacteria, green filamentous bacteria, heliobacteria (Takaichi, 1999) and cyanobacteria. Rbl. acidophilus (previously
110
Shinichi Takaichi
Fig. 6. Summary of the spirilloxanthin pathways. The normal spirilloxanthin, unusual spirilloxanthin, spheroidene and carotenal pathways are summarized.
Rps. acidophila) has three carotenoid glucosides; rhodopin, rhodopinol and rhodopinal glucosides (Fig. 6, Fig. 8) (Schmidt et al., 1971), and the total glucoside contents are 20 to 70% of total carotenoids depending on the culture conditions and the strains (Gardiner et al., 1993). Rhodopin glycoside has also been found in Phaeospirillum (previously Rsp.) fulvum (Table 1) (S. Takaichi, unpublished). Furthermore, two species of Halorhodospira have dihydroxylycopene diglucoside and its fatty acid diesters (Fig. 8) (Takaichi et al., 2001b). Roseococcus thisulfatophilus (Yurkov et al., 1993) and Methylobacterium rhodinum (Kleinig et al., 1979) have di(acyl-glucosyl)-diapocarotenedioate (Fig. 8). In all known cases, the hydroxy or the carboxylic groups of carotenoids form a glycosidic linkage with β-D-glucoside, and often a fatty acid is esterified at the C-6 hydroxy group of glucoside (Fig. 8). In vitro experiments with Pantoea stewartii (previously Erwinia herbicola) demonstrate that UDP-glucose is the substrate for the formation of zeaxanthin diglucoside (Hundle et al., 1992). Recently, chlorobactene glucosyltransferase (CruC) and chlorobactene lauroyltransferase (CruD) have been functionally confirmed in the green sulfur bacterium Chlorobaculum (previously Chlorobium) tepidum (Maresca and Bryant, 2006).
Fig. 7. The predicted okenone and R.g.-keto carotenoid pathways and their structures.
Although the localization of rhodopin glucoside in the light-harvesting 2 (LH2) complex of Rbl. acidophilus (previously Rps. acidophila) has been established
Chapter 6
Carotenoid Biosynthesis
111
Fig. 8. Structures of some unusual carotenoids found in the purple bacteria.
by X-ray crystallography (McDermott et al., 1995; Chapter 8, Gabrielsen et al.), the functions of the glucoside and ester moieties in photosynthesis are still unknown. III. Carotenoids in Purple Bacteria A. Anaerobic Purple Bacteria 1. Alphaproteobacteria and Betaproteobacteria Purple non-sulfur bacteria belong to Alphaproteo-
bacteria and Betaproteobacteria (Table 1) (Brenner et al., 2005). Their major BChl is BChl a or b. The functions of carotenoids in photosynthetic bacteria have been investigated in most detail in the purple non-sulfur bacteria. Carotenoids necessarily exist in reaction center (RC), RC-light-harvesting 1 (LH1) and LH2 antenna complexes, and have functions of light-harvesting and/or photoprotection, as well as playing possible structural roles. These aspects of carotenoids are covered in other chapters in this book (Chapter 8, Gabrielsen et al.; Chapter 12, Frank and Polívka; Chapter 46, Braun and Fiedor). The spirilloxanthin pathway is found in all these bacteria except for one genus, Rhodopila, which
112 has the okenone pathway (Table 1). Most genera have the normal spirilloxanthin or the unusual spirilloxanthin pathways (Fig. 6). The spheroidene pathway is found only in three genera from Rhodobacterales (alpha-3) of Rhodobacter, Rhodobaca and Rhodovulum. Rhodoferax and Rubrivivax, which belong to Betaproteobacteria, have both the normal spirilloxanthin and the spheroidene pathways. All of the carotenogenesis genes have been functionally confirmed in Rba. capsulatus, Rba. sphaeroides and Rvi. gelatinosus (Table 2). The carotenal pathway is found in Rbl. acidophilus (previously Rps. acidophila) (Alphaproteobacteria) and Rhodocyclus (Betaproteobacteria). The okenone pathway (R.g.-keto carotenoid) is found only in Rhodopila globiformis (Schmidt and Liaaen-Jensen, 1973). β-Carotene is found only in Rhodomicrobium vannielii (Ryvarden and Liaaen-Jensen, 1964). Carotenoid glucoside is found in Phaeospirillum (previously Rsp.) fulvum (S. Takaichi, unpublished), Rbl. acidophilus (Gardiner et al., 1993) and Rbl. sphagricola. Carotenes with the 1,2-dihydro-ψ end group, such as 1,2-dihydroneurosporene and 1,2-dihydro-3,4-dehydrolycopene (Fig. 8) are found in Blastochloris (previously Rps.) viridis (Malhotra et al., 1970). 2. Gammaproteobacteria Purple sulfur bacteria belong to Gammaproteobacteria (Table 1) (Brenner et al., 2005). Their major BChl is BChl a or b. These bacteria have either the spirilloxanthin pathway (normal spirilloxanthin, unusual spirilloxanthin and carotenal pathways) or the okenone pathway (Table 1). In four genera, Lamprocystis, Marichromatium, Thiocapsa and Thiocystis, some species have only the spirilloxanthin pathway (Fig. 6) and others have only the okenone pathway (Fig. 7). Exceptionally, two species Thiohalocapsa (previously Thiocapsa) halophila (Caumette et al., 1991) and Thiocapsa marina (Caumette et al., 2004) have both pathways. Halorhodospira abdelmalekii and Halorhodospira halochloris (Ectothiorhodospiraceae) contain dihydroxylycopene diglucoside, its fatty acid esters and methoxy-hydroxylycopene glucoside (Fig. 8) as major components and no spirilloxanthin (Takaichi et al., 2001b). Therefore, the carotenogenesis pathways are not consistent with the classification of these bacteria in Gammaproteobacteria. BChl b is found only eight species of anaerobic
Shinichi Takaichi purple bacteria, three species of Alphaproteobacteria and five species of Gammaproteobacteria. Concerning carotenoids of these bacteria, four species have 3,4,3´,4´-tetrahydrospirilloxanthin (Fig. 6), two species of Blastochloris have the derivatives of lycopene (Fig. 8), and two species of Halorhodospira have the derivatives of dihydroxylycopene (Fig. 8) as described above. Thus, these species lack CrtD activity. Therefore, there is a relationship between the presence of BChl b and lack of CrtD activity, but the distribution of types of carotenoids and BChls is inconsistent with the classification of these purple sulfur bacteria. B. Aerobic Photosynthetic Bacteria Recently, many obligately aerobic bacteria have been found that have a photosynthetic apparatus and BChl a, and all of them belong to Alphaproteobacteria and Betaproteobacteria (Table 1) (Brenner et al., 2005; Chapter 3, Yurkov and Csotonyi). Some genera also contain non-photosynthetic species. They are distinguished from anaerobic photosynthetic bacteria in that they synthesize BChl only under aerobic conditions and cannot grow without oxygen even in the light. Photosynthetic activity has been demonstrated in some species (Harashima et al., 1982). The low content of BChl, unique composition of carotenoids, and the presence of carotenoids that appear to have no photosynthetic activities are also marked characteristics. RC complexes purified from Roseobacter denitrificans (Shimada et al., 1985; Takamiya et al., 1987) and also from Acidiphilium rubrum (Shimada et al., 1998) are similar to those of the anaerobic purple bacteria. RC-LH1 complexes have been found in most species, while many species also contain LH2 complexes. The properties of these antenna complexes are also similar to those of the anaerobic purple bacteria (Shimada, 1995). In some species, the pigments have been clearly identified, but in others no identification has been reported (Table 1). The only BChl found was BChl a with a phytol ester. Exceptionally, the acidophilic genus Acidiphilium has Zn-BChl a, where the central metal is zinc instead of the usual magnesium, although a small amount of the usual Mg-BChl a is also present (Wakao et al., 1996; Hiraishi et al., 1998). The carotenoid compositions of most of these bacteria are different from those of the anaerobic purple bacteria (Table 1) (Takaichi, 1999). Most species so
Chapter 6
Carotenoid Biosynthesis
far investigated contain spirilloxanthin, the content of which varies from low to high depending on species. These bacteria can be classified into five groups based upon their carotenoid composition. The first group has spirilloxanthin and its precursors, and spirilloxanthin is dominant. Acidiphilium (alpha-1), Rhizobium (alpha-2) and Roseoateles (beta) belong to this group. The second has spheroidene and its derivatives, and spheroidenone is dominant. Roseobacter (alpha-3) and Erythromonas (alpha-4) belong to this group. The third has a small amount of spirilloxanthin and large amounts of other carotenoids. Craurococcus (alpha-1), Paracraurococcus (alpha-1) and Methylobacterium (alpha-2) contain unidentified carotenoic acids, and Bradyrhizobium (alpha-2) contains canthaxanthin (Fig. 8). In the fourth group, Roseococcus thiosulfatophilus (alpha-1) and Methylobacterium rhodinum (alpha-2) have the diapocarotene derivative di(acyl-glucosyl)-diapocarotene-dioate (Fig. 8). Unidentified carotenoic acids in the third group seem to be different from this diapocarotene derivative (S. Takaichi, unpublished). The fifth group has unique Erythrobacter-type (Erb-type) carotenoids including spirilloxanthin and its precursors, γ-carotene and its cross-conjugated aldehyde derivative, β-carotene and its poly-hydroxy derivatives, and carotenoid sulfates. This group is found only in Sphingomonadales (alpha-4): Erythrobacter, Porphyrobacter and Erythromicrobium. Bradyrizobium sp. ORS278 produces both spirilloxanthin and canthaxanthin (Fig. 8), and two complete carotenogenesis gene clusters have been found (Table 2) (Hannibal et al., 2000; Giraud et al., 2004). Therefore, it has two each of crtE, crtB and crtI, and also lycopene cyclase (CrtY) and β-carotene ketolase (CrtW) for canthaxanthin synthesis. The functions of CrtI and CrtY from Erythrobacter (Erb.) longus (Matsumura et al., 1997) and CrtI from Methylobacterium extorquens (van Dien et al., 2003) have been confirmed. Erb. longus produces typical Erb-type carotenoids. More than 20 different carotenoids have been identified including some novel ones (Fig. 9) (Takaichi and Shimada, 1992; Takaichi et al., 1988, 1990, 1991a). About 70% of the total are the carotenoid sulfates, erythroxanthin sulfate and caloxanthin sulfate. The presence of such carotenoid sulfates is very rare in nature (Britton et al., 2004). These carotenoid sulfates do not function as light-harvesting pigments (Noguchi et al., 1992), and indeed they cannot bind to either
113 the RC or the LH1 complexes (Shimada et al., 1985). The carotenoids bound to the RC-LH1 complex are less polar ones. Among them, bacteriorubixanthinal is a unique carotenoid (Fig. 9). It has a cross-conjugated aldehyde group at C-19´, the ψ end group is methoxylated and 3,4-desaturated, and the other end group is a 3-hydroxy-β end group, which is a typical end group of plant carotenoids. β-Carotene and its poly-hydroxy derivatives, caloxanthin and nostoxanthin, are also found in the RC-LH1 complex. It should be noted that spirilloxanthin, which is a typical carotenoid in anaerobic purple bacteria, is also found in this RC-LH1 complex, although the amount is small. Bacteriorubixanthinal, and zeaxanthin or nostoxanthin are the major components in the RCLH1 complex of the Erb-type bacteria. Interestingly, these carotenoids seem to share the same binding site in the complex despite their structural differences (K. Shimada, personal communication). In Methylobacterium radiotolerans (previously Pseudomonas radiora), spirilloxanthin is the dominant carotenoid in the RC-LH1 complex (Saitoh et al., 1995), while carotenoic acids are found in the outer membranes accompanied by no BChls and have no photosynthetic functions (S. Saitoh, personal communication). Two species of Methylobacterium also have carotenoic acids similar to those of Methylobacterium radiotolerans, and two species of the fourth group described above have polar carotenoids, which are diapocarotenoic acid derivatives. These highly polar carotenoids in the third, the fourth and the fifth groups may be ‘non-photosynthetic’ carotenoids, which are not bound to the photosynthetic pigmentprotein complexes (Shimada, 1995). Although their functions are not known, there is the possibility that they protect the photosynthetic apparatus from the outside aerobic conditions. The carotenoid composition of the first and the second groups is somewhat different from the other groups, since they lack ‘non-photosynthetic’ carotenoids. The RC-LH1 complex of Acidiphilium rubrum (Wakao et al., 1996; Shimada et al., 1998), and the RC-LH1 and LH2 complexes of Roseobacter denitrificans (Shimada et al., 1985) contain all the cellular carotenoids. In conclusion, most aerobic photosynthetic bacteria have the purple bacteria-like photosynthetic apparatus including BChl a, and many species have spirilloxanthin, as well as additional polar ‘non-photosynthetic’ carotenoids.
Shinichi Takaichi
114
β-Carotene β-Cryptoxanthin
Zeaxanthin Caloxanthin Nostoxanthin Caloxanthin sulfate Erythroxanthin sulfate
R2 H H H OH OH OH H
R3 H OH OH OH OH OH O-SO2OH
R4 H2 H2 H2 H2 H2 H2 O
R2´ H H H H OH H OH
R3´ H H OH OH OH O-SO2OH OH
Fig. 9. Structures of the major Erb-type carotenoids.
Acknowledgments The author wishes to thank K. Shimada for reading the manuscript. References Albrecht M, Ruther A and Sandmann G (1997) Purification and biochemical characterization of a hydroxyneurosporene desaturase involved in the biosynthetic pathway of the carotenoid spheroidene in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Bacteriol 179: 7462–7467 Armstrong GA (1995) Genetic analysis and regulation of carotenoid biosynthesis: Structure and function of the crt genes and gene products. In: Blankenship RE, Madigan MT and Bauer CE (eds) Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 2), pp 1135–1157. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Armstrong GA (1997) Genetics of eubacterial carotenoid biosynthesis: A colorful tale. Annu Rev Microbiol 51: 629–659 Armstrong GA, Alberti M, Leach F and Hearst JE (1989) Nucleotide sequence, organization, and nature of the protein products of the carotenoid biosynthesis gene cluster of Rhodobacter capsulatus. Mol Gen Genet 216: 254–268 Brenner DJ, Krieg NR and Staley JT (2005) Bergey’s Manual of Systematic Bacteriology, 2nd edition, Vol 2, The Proteobacteria. Springer, New York
Britton G, Singh RK, Goodwin TW and Ben-Aziz A (1975) The carotenoids of Rhodomicrobium vannielii (Rhodospirillaceae) and the effect of diphenylamine on the carotenoid composition. Phytochemistry 14: 2427–2433 Britton G, Liaaen-Jensen S and Pfander H (eds) (2004) Carotenoids Handbook. Birkhaüser, Basel Bryantseva IA, Gorlenko VM, Kompantseva EI and Imhoff JF (2000) Thioalkalicoccus limnaeus gen. nov., sp. nov., a new alkaliphilic purple sulfur bacterium with bacteriochlorophyll b. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 50: 2157–2163 Caumette P, Baulaigue R and Matheron R (1991) Thiocapsa halophila sp. nov., a new halophilic phototrophic purple sulfur bacterium. Arch Microbiol 155: 170–176 Caumette P, Guyoneaud R, Imhoff JF, Süling J and Gorlenko V (2004) Thiocapsa marina sp. nov., a novel, okenone-containing, purple sulfur bacterium isolated from brackish coastal and marine environments. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 54: 1031–1036 Davies BH (1970) A novel sequence for phytoene dehydrogenation in Rhodospirillum rubrum. Biochem J 116: 93–99 Dilling W, Liesack W and Pfennig N (1995) Rhabdochromatium marinum gen. nom. rev., sp. nov., a purple sulfur bacterium from a salt marsh microbial mat. Arch Microbiol 164: 125–131 Eimhjellen KE, Steensland H and Traetteberg J (1967) A Thiococcus sp. nov. gen., its pigments and internal membrane system. Arch Mikrobiol 59: 82–92 Francis GW and Liaaen-Jensen S (1970) Bacterial carotenoids: XXXIII. Carotenoids of Thiorhodaceae: 9. The structures of the carotenoids of the rhodopinal series. Acta Chem Scand 24: 2705–2712 Frank HA, Chadwick BW, Taremi S, Kolaczkowski S and Bowman
Chapter 6
Carotenoid Biosynthesis
MK (1986) Singlet and triplet absorption spectra of carotenoids bound in the reaction centers of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides R26. FEBS Lett 203: 157–163 Fujii R, Chen CH, Mizoguchi T and Koyama Y (1998) 1H NMR, electronic-absorption and resonance Raman spectra of isomeric okenone as compared with those of isomeric β-carotene, canthaxanthin, β-apo-8´-carotenal and spheroidene. Spectrochim Acta A54: 727–743 Garcia-Asua G, Cogdell RJ and Hunter CN (2002) Functional assembly of the foreign carotenoid lycopene into the photosynthetic apparatus of Rhodobacter sphaeroides achieved by replacement of the native 3-step phytoene desaturase with its 4-step counterpart from Erwinia herbicola. Mol Microbiol 44: 233–244 Gardiner AT, Cogdell RJ and Takaichi S (1993) The effect of growth conditions on the light-harvesting apparatus in Rhodopseudomonas acidophila. Photosynth Res 38: 159–167 Giraud E, Hannibal L, Fardoux J, Jaubert M, Jourand P, Dreyfus B, Sturgis JN and Verméglio A (2004) Two distinct crt gene clusters for two different functional classes of carotenoid in Bradyrhizobium. J Biol Chem 279: 15076–15083 Giuliano G, Giliberto L and Rosati C (2002) Carotenoid isomerase: A tale of light and isomers. Trends Plant Sci 7: 427–429 Goodwin TW (1956) The carotenoids of photosynthetic bacteria: II. The carotenoids of a number of non-sulphur purple photosynthetic bacteria (Athiorhodaceae). Arch Mikrobiol 24: 313–322 Guyoneaud R, Matheron R, Liesack W, Imhoff JF and Caumette P (1997) Thiorhodococcus minus, gen. nov., sp. nov., a new purple sulfur bacterium isolated from coastal lagoon sediments. Arch Microbiol 168: 16–23 Hannibal L, Lorquin J, D’Ortoli NA, Garcia N, Chaintreuil C, Masson-Boivin C, Dreyfus B and Giraud E (2000) Isolation and characterization of canthaxanthin biosynthesis genes from the photosynthetic bacterium Bradyrhzobium sp. strain ORS278. J Bacteriol 182: 3850–3853 Harada J, Nagashima KVP, Takaichi S, Misawa N, Matsuura K and Shimada K (2001) Phytoene desaturase, CrtI, of the purple photosynthetic bacterium, Rubrivivax gelatinosus, produces both neurosporene and lycopene. Plant Cell Physiol 42: 1112–1118 Harashima K and Nakada H (1983) Carotenoids and ubiquinone in aerobically grown cells of an aerobic photosynthetic bacterium, Erythrobacter species OCh 114. Agric Biol Chem 47: 1057–1063 Harashima K, Nakagawa M and Murata N (1982) Photochemical activities of bacteriochlorophyll in aerobically grown cells of aerobic heterotrophs, Erythrobacter species (OCh 114) and Erythrobacter longus (OCh 101). Plant Cell Physiol 23: 185–193 Hiraishi A, Nagashima KVP, Matsuura K, Shimada K, Takaichi S, Wakao N and Katayama Y (1998) Phylogeny and photosynthetic features of Thiobacillus acidophilus and related acidophilic bacteria: Its transfer to the genus Acidiphilium as Acidiphilium acidophium comb. nov. Int J Syst Bacteriol 48: 1389–1398 Hundle BS, O’Brien DA, Alberti M, Beyer P and Hearst JE (1992) Functional expression of zeaxanthin glucosyltransferase from Erwinia herbicola and a proposed uridine diphosphate binding site. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 89: 9321–9325 Hunter CN, Hundle BS, Hearst JE, Gardiner AT, Takaichi S and Cogdell RJ (1994) Introduction of new carotenoids into the
115 bacterial photosynthetic apparatus by combining the carotenoid biosynthetic pathways of Erwinia herbicola and Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Bacteriol 176: 3692–3697 Imhoff JF and Madigan MT (2004) International Committee on Systematics of Prokaryotes Subcommittee on the taxonomy of phototrophic bacteria. Minutes of the meetings, 27 august 2003, Tokyo, Japan. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 54: 1001–1003, and Erratum 1907 Imhoff JF and Pfennig N (2001) Thioflavicoccus mobilis gen. nov., sp. nov., a novel purple sulfur bacterium with bacteriochlorophyll b. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 51: 105–110 Imhoff JF, Petri R and Süling J (1998a) Reclassification of species of the spiral-shaped phototrophic purple non-sulfur bacteria of the α-Proteobacteria: description of the new genera Phaeospirillum gen. nov., Rhodovibrio gen. nov., Rhodothalassium gen. nov. and Roseospira gen. nov. as well as transfer of Rhodospirillum fulvum to Phaeospirillum fulvum comb. nov., of Rhodospirillum molischianum to Phaeospirillum molischianum comb. nov., of Rhodospirillum salinarum to Rhodovibrio salinarum comb. nov., of Rhodospirillum sodomense to Rhodovibrio sodomensis comb. nov., of Rhodospirillum salexigens to Rhodothalassium salexigens comb. nov. and of Rhodospirillum mediosalinum to Roseospira mediosalina comb. nov. Int J Syst Bacteriol 48: 793–798 Imhoff JF, Süling J and Petri R (1998b) Phylogenetic relationships among the Chromatiaceae, their taxonomic reclassification and description of the new genera Allochromatium, Halochromatium, Isochromatium, Marichromatium, Thiococcus, Thiohalocapsa and Thermochromatium. Int J Syst Bacteriol 48: 1129–1143 IUPAC Commission on Nomenclature of Organic Chemistry and the IUPAC-IUB Commission on Biochemical Nomenclature (1975) Nomenclature of carotenoids. Pure Appl Chem 41: 407–431 Jung DO, Achenbach LA, Karr EA, Takaichi S and Madigan MT (2004) A gas vesiculate planktonic strain of the purple non-sulfur bacterium Rhodoferax antarcticus isolated from Lake Fryxell, Dry Valleys, Antarctica. Arch Microbiol 182: 236–243 Kleinig H, Schmitt R, Meister W, Englert G and Thommen H (1979) New C30-carotenoic acid glucosyl esters from Pseudomonas rhodos. Z Naturforsch 34 c: 181–185 Komori M, Ghosh R, Takaichi S, Hu Y, Mizoguchi T, Koyama Y and Kuki M (1998) A null lesion in the rhodopin 3,4-desaturase of Rhodospirillum rubrum unmasks a cryptic branch of the carotenoid biosynthetic pathway. Biochemistry 37: 8987–8994 Kovács ÁT, Rákhely G and Kovács KL (2003) Genes involved in the biosynthesis of photosynthetic pigments in the purple sulfur photosynthetic bacterium Thiocapsa roseopersicina. Appl Environ Microbiol 69: 3093–3102 Lang HP, Cogdell RJ and Hunter CN (1994) Early steps in carotenoid biosynthesis: Sequence and transcriptional analysis of the crtI and crtB genes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Overexpression and reactivation of crtI in Escherichia coli and Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Bacteriol 176: 3859–3869 Lang HP, Cogdell RJ, Takaichi S and Hunter CN (1995) Complete DNA sequence, specific Tn5 insertion map, and gene assignment of the carotenoid biosynthesis pathway of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Bacteriol 177: 2064–2073 Lichtenthaler HK (1999) The 1-deoxy-D-xylulose-5-phosphate pathway of isoprenoid biosynthesis in plants. Annu Rev Plant
116 Physiol Plant Mol Biol 50: 47–65 Linden H, Misawa N, Chamovitz, D, Pecker I, Hirscherg and Sandmann G (1991) Functional complementation in Escherichia coli of different phytoene desaturase genes and analysis of accumulated carotenes. Z Naturforsch 46 c: 1045–1051 Maeda I, Yamashiro H, Yoshioka D, Onodera M, Ueda S, Miyasaka H, Umeda F, Kawase M, Takaichi S and Yagi K (2005) Unusual accumulation of demethylspheroidene in anaerobicphototrophic growth of crtA-deleted mutants of Rhodovulum sulfidophilum. Curr Microbiol 51: 193–197 Maeda I, Yamashiro H, Yoshioka D, Onodera M, Ueda S, Kawase M, Miyasaka H and Yagi K (2006) Colorimetric dimethyl sulfide sensor using Rhodovulum sulfidophilum cells based on intrinsic pigment conversion by CrtA. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 70: 397–402 Malhotra HC, Britton G and Goodwin TW (1970) A novel series of 1,2-dihydro carotenoids. Int J Vit Res 40: 315–322 Maresca JA and Bryant DA (2006) Two new encoding new carotenoid-modifying enzymes in the green sulfur bacterium Chlorobium tepidum. J Bacteriol 188: 6217–6223 Matsuura K and Shimada K (1993) Electrochromic spectral band shift of carotenoids in the photosynthetic membranes of Rhodospirillum molischianum and Rhodospirillum photometricum. Biochim Biophys Acta 1140: 293–296 Matsumura H, Takeyama H, Kusakabe E, Burgess JG and Matsunaga T (1997) Cloning, sequencing and expressing the carotenoid biosynthesis genes, lycopene cyclase and phytoene desaturase, from the aerobic photosynthetic bacterium Erythrobacter longus sp. strain OCh 101 in Escherichia coli. Gene 189: 169–174 McDermott G, Prince SM, Freer AA, Hawthornthwaite-Lawless AM, Papiz MZ, Cogdell RJ and Isaacs NW (1995) Crystal structure of an integral membrane light-harvesting complex from photosynthetic bacteria. Nature 374: 517–521 Misawa N, Nakagawa M, Kobayashi K, Yamano S, Izawa Y, Nakamura K and Harashima K (1990) Elucidation of the Erwinia uredovora carotenoid biosynthetic pathway by functional analysis of gene products expressed in Escherichia coli. J Bacteriol 172: 6704–6712 Noguchi T, Hayashi H, Shimada K, Takaichi S and Tasumi M (1992) In vivo states and functions of carotenoids in an aerobic photosynthetic bacterium, Erythrobacter longus. Photosynth Res 31: 21–30 Ouchane S, Picaud M, Vernotte C, Reiss-Husson F and Astier C (1997a) Pleiotropic effects of puf interposon mutagenesis on carotenoid biosynthesis in Rubrivivax gelatinosus. J Biol Chem 272: 1670–1676 Ouchane S, Picaud M, Vernotte C and Astier C (1997b) Photooxidative stress stimulates illegitimate recombination and mutability in carotenoid-less mutants of Rubrivivax gelatinosus. EMBO J 16: 4777–4787 Overmann J, Fischer U and Pfennig N (1992) A new purple sulfur bacterium from saline littoral sediments, Thiorhodovibrio winogradskyi gen. nov. and sp. nov. Arch Microbiol 157: 329–335 Pfennig N, Markham MC and Liaaen-Jensen S (1968) Carotenoids of Thiorhodaceae: 8. Isolation and characterization of a Thiothece, Lamprocystis and Thiodictyon strain and their carotenoid pigments. Arch Mikrobiol 62: 178–191 Pfennig N, Lünsdorf H, Süling J and Imhoff JF (1997) Rhodospira trueeperi gen. nov., spec. nov., a new phototrophic Proteobacterium of the alpha group. Arch Microbiol 168: 39–45
Shinichi Takaichi Pinta V, Ouchane S, Picaud M, Takaichi S, Astier C and ReissHusson F (2003) Characterization of unusual hydroxy- and ketocarotenoids in Rubrivivax gelatinosus: Involvement of enzyme CrtF or CrtA. Arch Microbiol 179: 354–362 Raisig A, Bartley G, Scolnik P and Sandmann G (1996) Purification in an active state and properties of the 3-step phytoene desaturase from Rhodobacter capsulatus overexpressed in Escherichia coli. J Biochem 119: 559–564 Rees GN, Harfoot CG, Janssen PH, Schoenborn L, Kuever J and Lünsdorf H (2002) Thiobaca trueperi gen. nov., sp. nov., a phototrophic purple sulfur bacterium isolated from freshwater lake sediment. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 52: 671–678 Reslewic S, Zhou S, Place M, Zhang Y, Briska A, Gokdstein S, Churas C, Runnheim R, Forrest D, Lim A, Lapidus A, Han CS, Roberts GP and Schwartz DC (2005) Whole-genome shotgun optical mapping of Rhodospirillum rubrum. Appl Environ Microbiol 71: 5511–5522 Rohmer M (1999) The discovery of a mevalonate-independent pathway for isoprenoid biosynthesis in bacteria, algae and higher plants. Nat Prod Rep 16: 565–574 Ryvarden L and Liaaen-Jensen S (1964) Bacterial carotenoids: XIV. The carotenoids of Rhodomicrobium vannielii. Acta Chem Scand 18: 643–654 Saitoh S, Takaichi S, Shimada K and Nishimura Y (1995) Identification and subcellular distribution of carotenoids in the aerobic photosynthetic bacterium, Pseudomonas radiora strain MD-1. Plant Cell Physiol 36: 819–823 Sandmann G (1994) Carotenoid biosynthesis in microorganisms and plants. Eur J Biochem 223: 7–24 Sandmann G (1997) High level expression of carotenogenic genes for enzyme purification and biochemical characterization. Pure Appl Chem 69: 2163–2168 Schmidt K (1971) Carotenoids of purple nonsulfur bacteria: Composition and biosynthesis of the carotenoids of some strains of Rhodopseudomonas acidophila, Rhodospirillum tenue, and Rhodocyclus purpureus. Arch Mikrobiol 77: 231–238 Schmidt K (1978) Biosynthesis of carotenoids. In: Clayton RK and Sistrom WR (eds) The Photosynthetic Bacteria, pp 729–750. Plenum Press, New York Schmidt K and Liaaen-Jensen S (1973) Bacterial carotenoids: XLII. New keto-carotenoids from Rhodopseudomonas globiformis (Rhodospirillaceae). Acta Chem Scand 27: 3040–3052 Schmidt K, Liaaen-Jensen S and Schlegel HG (1963) Die Carotinoide der Thiorhodaceae: I. Okenon als Hauptcarotinoid von Chromatium okenii Perty. Arch Mikrobiol 46: 117–126 Schmidt K, Pfennig N and Liaaen-Jensen S (1965) Carotenoids of Thiorhodaceae: IV. The carotenoid composition of 25 pure isolates. Arch Mikrobiol 52: 132–146 Schmidt K, Francis GW and Liaaen-Jensen S (1971) Bacterial carotenoids: XXXVI. Remarkable C43-carotenoid artefacts of cross-conjugated carotenals and new carotenoid glucosides from Athiorhodaceae spp. Acta Chem Scand 25: 2476–2486 Schwerzmann RU and Bachofen R (1989) Carotenoid profiles in pigment-protein complexes of Rhodospirillum rubrum. Plant Cell Physiol 30: 497–504 Scolnik PA, Walker MA and Marrs BL (1980) Biosynthesis of carotenoids derived from neurosporene in Rhodopseudomonas capsulata. J Biol Chem 255: 2427–2432 Shimada K (1995) Aerobic anoxygenic phototrophs. In: Blankenship RE, Madigan MT and Bauer CE (eds) Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria (Advances in Photosynthesis and
Chapter 6
Carotenoid Biosynthesis
Respiration, Vol 2), pp 105–122. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Shimada K, Hayashi H and Tasumi M (1985) Bacteriochlorophyll-protein complexes of aerobic bacteria, Erythrobacter longus and Erythrobacter species OCh 114. Arch Microbiol 143: 244–247 Shimada K, Itoh S, Iwaki M, Nagashima KVP, Matuura K, Kobayashi M and Wakao N (1998) Reaction center complex based on Zn-bacteriochlorophyll from Acidiphilium rubrum. In: Garab G (ed) Photosynthesis: Mechanism and Effects, Vol II, pp 909–912. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Shneour EA (1962) The source of oxygen in Rhodopseudomonas spheroides carotenoid pigment conversion. Biochim Biophys Acta 65: 510–511 Singh RK, Britton G and Goodwin TW (1973) Carotenoid biosynthesis in Rhodopseudomonas spheroides: S-adenosylmethionine as the methylating agent in the biosynthesis of spheroidene and spheroidenone. Biochem J 136: 413–419 Swingley WD, Sadekar S, Mastrian SD, Matthies HJ, Hao J, Ramos H, Acharya CR, Conrad AL, Taylor HL, Dejesa LC, Shah MK, O’Huallachain ME, Lince MT, Blankenship RE, Beatty JT and Touchman JW (2007) The complete genome sequence of Roseobacter denitrificans reveals a mixotrophic rather than photosynthetic metabolism. J Bacteriol 189: 683–690 Takaichi S (1999) Carotenoids and carotenogenesis in anoxygenic photosynthetic bacteria. In: Frank HA, Young AJ, Britton G and Cogdell RJ (eds) The Photochemistry of Carotenoids (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 8), pp 39–69. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Takaichi S and Shimada K (1992) Characterization of carotenoids in photosynthetic bacteria. Methods Enzymol 213: 374–385 Takaichi S, Shimada K and Ishidsu J (1988) Monocyclic crossconjugated carotenal from an aerobic photosynthetic bacterium, Erythrobacter longus. Phytochemistry 27: 3605–3609 Takaichi S, Shimada K and Ishidsu J (1990) Carotenoids from the aerobic photosynthetic bacterium, Erythrobacter longus: β-carotene and its hydroxyl derivatives. Arch Microbiol 153: 118–122 Takaichi S, Furihata K, Ishidsu J and Shimada K (1991a) Carot-
117 enoid sulphates from the aerobic photosynthetic bacterium, Erythrobacter longus. Phytochemistry 30: 3411–3415 Takaichi S, Furihata K and Harashima K (1991b) Light-induced changes of carotenoid pigments in anaerobic cells of the aerobic photosynthetic bacterium, Roseobacter denitrificans (Erythrobacter species OCh 114): Reduction of spheroidenone to 3,4-dihydrospheroidenone. Arch Microbiol 155: 473–476 Takaichi S, Jung DO and Madigan MT (2001a) Accumulation of unusual carotenoids in the spheroidene pathway, demethylspheroidene and demethylsphroidenone, in an alkaliphilic purple nonsulfur bacterium Rhodobaca bogoriensis. Photosynth Res 67: 207–214 Takaichi S, Maoka T, Hanada S and Imhoff JF (2001b) Dihydroxylycopene diglucoside diesters: a novel class of carotenoids from the phototrophic purple sulfur bacteria Halorhodospira abdelmalekii and Halorhodospira halochloris. Arch Microbiol 175: 161–167 Takamiya K, Iba K and Okamura K (1987) Reaction center complex from an aerobic photosynthetic bacterium, Erythrobacter species OCh 114. Biochim Biophys Acta 890: 127–133 van Dien, SJ, Marx CJ, O’Brien BN and Lidstrom ME (2003) Genetic characterization of the carotenoid biosynthetic pathway in Methylobacterium extorquens AM1 and isolation of a colorless mutant. App Environ Microbiol 69: 7563–7566 Wakao N, Yokoi N, Isoyama N, Hiraishi A, Shimada K, Kobayashi M, Kise H, Iwaki M, Itoh S, Takaichi S and Sakurai Y (1996) Discovery of natural photosynthesis using Zn-containing bacteriochlorophyll in an aerobic bacterium Acidiphilium rubrum. Plant Cell Physiol 37: 889–893 Yeliseev AA and Kaplan S (1997) Anaerobic carotenoid biosynthesis in Rhodobacter sphaeroides 2.4.1: H2O is a source of oxygen for the 1-methoxy group of spheroidene but not for the 2-oxo group of spheroidenone. FEBS Lett 403: 10–14 Yurkov V, Gad’on N and Drews G (1993) The major part of polar carotenoids of the aerobic bacteria Roseococcus thiosulfatophilus RB3 and Erythromicrobium ramosum E5 is not bound to the bacteriochlorophyll a-complexes of the photosynthetic apparatus. Arch Microbiol 160: 372–376
Chapter 7 Membrane Lipid Biosynthesis in Purple Bacteria Banita Tamot and Christoph Benning* Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI 48824-1319
Summary ............................................................................................................................................................... 119 I. Introduction..................................................................................................................................................... 120 II. Fatty Acids...................................................................................................................................................... 122 III. Phosphoglycerolipids ..................................................................................................................................... 123 A. Phosphatidic Acid and Cytidine Diphosphate Diacylglycerol ........................................................... 123 B. Phosphatidylethanolamine ............................................................................................................... 124 C. Phosphatidylglycerol and Cardiolipin ............................................................................................... 124 D. Phosphatidylcholine ......................................................................................................................... 125 IV. Glycoglycerolipids .......................................................................................................................................... 126 A. Glycerolipids Containing Glucose or Galactose ............................................................................... 126 B. Sulfoquinovosyldiacylglycerol........................................................................................................... 127 V. Betaine Lipid................................................................................................................................................... 128 VI. Ornithine Lipid ................................................................................................................................................ 129 VII. Lipid Function ................................................................................................................................................. 130 A. Changes in Lipid Composition in Response to the Environment ..................................................... 130 B. Interaction of Lipids with Membrane Proteins .................................................................................. 131 VIII. Perspectives ................................................................................................................................................... 131 Acknowledgments ................................................................................................................................................. 131 References ............................................................................................................................................................ 132
Summary Membranes are essential to all living cells. They provide the boundary to the surrounding environment, allow the controlled exchange of compounds through membrane transporters, and serve as a matrix for membrane associated enzymes and protein complexes involved in the generation of energy or communication with the environment. Biomembranes are built from amphipathic, polar lipids that either on their own or in mixtures with other lipids spontaneously form a bilayer in aqueous solutions. Proteins are embedded into this lipid matrix serving many different functions. Photosynthetic purple bacteria have a very rich complement of membrane lipids including phospholipids not commonly found in bacteria such as phosphatidylcholine, glycolipids typical for plant chloroplasts such as sulfoquinovosyldiacylglycerol, and the betaine and ornithine lipids. These latter lipids lack phosphorus presumably allowing purple bacteria to outcompete other organisms in a phosphorusdepleted environment. Advances in the genetic analysis of lipid metabolism of purple bacteria and related bacteria of the α-proteobacteria group have provided us with many genes encoding enzymes for the biosynthesis of polar membrane lipids beyond those described for Escherichia (E.) coli. Lipid genes discovered first in *Author for correspondence, email: [email protected]
C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty (eds): The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria, pp. 119–134. © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V.
120
Banita Tamot and Christoph Benning
Rhodobacter (Rba.) sphaeroides include the sqd genes required for sulfoquinovosyldiacylglycerol biosynthesis and the bta genes required for betaine lipid biosynthesis. Similar approaches in the closely related bacterium Sinorhizobium (Sr.) meliloti in combination with genome comparison provided the genes of purple bacteria encoding proteins of ornithine lipid biosynthesis and a new pathway for phosphatidylcholine biosynthesis. Advances in the analysis of membrane associated protein complexes gave new insights into specific interactions of lipids with these complexes. I. Introduction Much of what we know today about membrane lipid biosynthesis and the basic pathways for the biosynthesis of phospholipids in Gram-negative bacteria is based on work with E. coli as recently reviewed (Cronan, 2003). However, E. coli membranes are limited in the number of polar lipids with the bulk provided by phosphatidylethanolamine (PtdEtn), phosphatidylglycerol (PtdGro) and cardiolipin (CL). Beyond these lipids, membranes of purple bacteria such as Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus contain phosphatidylcholine (PtdCho), glycolipids such as sulfoquinovosyldiacylglycerol (SQDG), the betaine lipid diacylglycerol-N,N,N,-trimethylhomoserine (DGTS) and the ornithine lipid (OL). Moreover, some strains of Rba. sphaeroides are known to produce considerable amounts of the xenobiotic lipid phosphatidyl Tris when grown in tris-hydroxymethylaminomethane (Tris) buffer (Schmid et al., 1991). The polar lipid and fatty acid composition of different purple bacteria and other anoxygenic photosynthetic bacteria have been extensively studied and reviewed (Imhoff et al., 1982; Imhoff, 1991; Imhoff and Bias-Imhoff, 1995; Benning, 1998b). Whenever fatty acid and polar lipid profiles are considered, it is important to note that the lipid composition of purple bacteria and other bacteria is dependent on the growth conditions. In particular phosphate-limited growth conditions can drastically increase the relative proportions of non-phosphorous lipids in purple bacteria (Benning et al., 1995), restricting the usefulness of lipid profiles for taxonomic classification of purple bacteria. However, because the completed genome sequences Abbreviations: ACP – acyl carrier protein; AdoHcy – S-adenosylhomocysteine; AdoMet – S-adenosylmethionine; CDP – cytidine diphosphate; CL – cardiolipin; CMP – cytidine monophosphate; CTP – cytidine triphosphate; DAG – diacylglycerol; DGTS – dicaylglycerol-N,N,N,-trimethylhomoserine; E. – Escherichia; OL – ornithine lipid; PtdCho – phosphatidylcholine; PtdEtn – phosphatidylethanolamine; PtdGro – phosphatidylglycerol; Rba. – Rhodobacter; SQDG – sulfoquinovosyldiacylglycerol; Sr. – Sinorhizobium; Tris – tris-hydroxymethylaminomethane
of many bacteria are now publicly available, direct DNA sequence comparison has become the primary measure for evolutionary relationships and the basis for taxonomic classifications of bacteria. As of September, 2006, the US National Center for Biological Information (NCBI) genome web site (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/genomes/lproks.cgi) lists 48 completed genomes of α-proteobacteria including 9 genomes of purple bacteria. A large number of additional α-proteobacterial genome projects are under way. Here we take advantage of this information and provide the accession numbers for membrane lipid genes of Rba. sphaeroides 2.4.1 as an example representative for the purple bacteria (Table 1). We chose to focus on this particular organism because sequences for its two chromosomes and five plasmids (Mackenzie et al., 2001) are publicly available at NCBI and because several genes encoding enzymes involved in the biosynthesis of lipids specific to purple bacteria such as SQDG and DGTS were originally discovered in this bacterium. For the description of enzymes of basic phospholipid metabolism we rely on the annotations extrapolated from the experimentally confirmed orthologs of E. coli. In the case of PtdCho and OL biosynthesis the original work has been performed in Sr. meliloti or Rba. capsulatus and we refer to these organisms. In general, the focus will be on the biosynthesis of the major lipids found in the membranes of purple bacteria and the currently known biosynthetic pathways for these lipids. The availability of lipid-deficient genetic mutants and the presence of specific lipids in high-resolution crystal structures of several membrane associated complexes of purple bacteria led to new clues towards the function of membrane lipids. These findings are now providing a promising framework to better understand the complex lipid composition of purple bacterial membranes, as well as the remodeling of membranes under adverse conditions such as phosphate deficiency. These findings will be briefly summarized.
Chapter 7
Membrane Lipids
121
Table 1. Assignments of lipid genes in the Rba. sphaeroides 2.4.1 reference genome1 Enzyme
Gene
Chr
GenBank Protein ID
References2
Phospholipids Glycerol 3-phosphate 1-O- acyltransferase
plsB
unidentified
1-O-acylglycerol 3-phosphate 2-O-acyltransferase Phosphatidyl cytidyltransferase
plsC
1
YP_353812
cdsA
1
YP_352763
Phosphatidylserine synthase
pss
1
YP_353797
Phosphatidylserine decarboxylase
psd
1
YP_353796
Phosphatidylglycerol 3-phosphate synthase Phosphatidylglycerol 3-phosphate phosphatase
pgsA pgpA
1 1
YP_354158 YP_352878
Cardiolipin synthase
cls
1
YP_353546
Phosphatidylethanolamine N-methyltransferase Phosphatidylcholine synthase
pmtA pcs
1 1
YP_353798 YP_353639
Glycolipids Diacylglycerol glycosyltransferase Monoglycosyldiacylglycerol glycosyltransferase UDP-sulfoquinovose synthase
sqdB
1
YP_352627
Required for SQDG biosynthesis Required for SQDG biosynthesis
sqdA sqdC
1 1
YP_352034 YP_352625
UDP-sulfoquinovose sulfoquinovosyltransferase
sqdD
1
YP_352626
Betaine lipid Diacylglycerolhomoserine synthase
btaA
1
YP_353939
Diacylglycerolhomoserine N-methyltransferase
btaB
1
YP_353940
Ornithine lipid Lyso-ornithine beta-hydroxy acyltransferase
olsA
2
YP_354512
predicted (ubiquitous in Gram-negative bacteria) predicted (ubiquitous in Gram-negative bacteria) predicted (ubiquitous in Gram-negative bacteria) predicted (ubiquitous in Gram-negative bacteria) confirmed (Dryden and Dowhan, 1996) predicted (ubiquitous in Gram-negative bacteria) confirmed (Tamot and Benning, unpublished) confirmed (Arondel et al., 1993) predicted from confirmed Sinorhizobium meliloti ortholog (Sohlenkamp et al., 2000; Martinez-Morales et al., 2003)
unidentified unidentified confirmed (Benning and Somerville, 1992a; Benning et al., 1993) confirmed (Benning and Somerville, 1992b) confirmed (Benning and Somerville, 1992a; Rossak et al., 1997) confirmed (Benning and Somerville, 1992a; Rossak et al., 1995)
confirmed (Klug and Benning, 2001; Riekhof et al., 2005a) confirmed (Klug and Benning, 2001; Riekhof et al., 2005a)
predicted from confirmed Rba. capsulatus ortholog (Aygun-Sunar et al., 2006) Ornithine 2-N-acyltransferase olsB 2 YP_354511 predicted from confirmed Rba. capsulatus ortholog (Aygun-Sunar et al., 2006) 1 Chromosome 1, NC_007493, Chromosome 2, NC_007494, Copeland, A., Lucas, S., Lapidus, A., Barry, K., Detter, J.C., Glavina, T., Hammon, N., Israni, S., Pitluck, S., Richardson, P., Mackenzie, C., Choudhary, M., Larimer, F., Hauser, L.J., Land, M., Donohue, T.J. and Kaplan, S., The Rhodobacter sphaeroides Genome Consortium. GenBank submission by the US DOE Joint Genome Institute. 2 The notation ‘confirmed’ indicates that genetic or biochemical evidence is available for Rba. sphaeroides. In some cases, a confirmed sequence from a closely related bacterium was used to identify the putative Rba. sphaeroides 2.4.1 ortholog.
Banita Tamot and Christoph Benning
122 II. Fatty Acids With few exceptions, the biosynthesis of fatty acids and the proteins involved in this process have not been directly studied in purple bacteria. An acyl carrier protein (ACP) from Rba. sphaeroides has been purified (Cooper et al., 1987) as well as two long-chain acyl-CoA thioesterases involved in the metabolism of fatty acids taken up from the medium (Boyce and Lueking, 1984; Seay and Lueking, 1986). However, the inner workings of the type II fatty acid synthase typical for proteobacteria were elucidated primarily in E. coli. Crystal structures for most of the components are available and the complex was mechanistically explored in great detail as recently reviewed (White et al., 2005). For details, the reader is referred to this review and the references therein. Type II fatty acid synthases assemble from multiple components encoded by different genes. Their β-ketoacyl-ACP component is highly sensitive to cerulenin, which also inhibits fatty acid synthesis at low concentrations in Rba. sphaeroides (Broglie and Niederman, 1979). Furthermore, the anti-infective agent triclosan inhibits the enoyl-ACP-reductase associated with type II fatty acid synthases (McMurry et al., 1998). Based on the similarity of confirmed
E. coli proteins to translated peptide sequences from the genome of Rba. sphaeroides, the orthologous components of type II fatty acid synthase can be predicted as summarized in Table 2. Ultimately, these assignments need to be confirmed by biochemical analysis. As already mentioned, the genome of Rba. sphaeroides is comprised of two chromosomes and several plasmids (Mackenzie et al., 2001). Most of the proteins involved in fatty acid biosynthesis are encoded on chromosome 1 except for one β-ketoacyl-ACP synthase (FabA), β-hydroxydecanoyl-ACP dehydratase (FabA) and one enoyl-ACP reductase (Table 2). The fatty acid composition of membrane lipids in purple bacteria is relatively simple (Imhoff et al., 1982; Imhoff, 1991; Imhoff and Bias-Imhoff, 1995) as they lack desaturases that introduce specific double bonds into acyl chains post synthesis. Fatty acids typically found in membrane lipids of purple bacteria include palmitate, stearate and vaccenate (Fig. 1A). In addition, the ornithine lipid contains 3-hydroxy stearate. In glycerolipids, these acyl chains are esterified to the sn-1 and sn-2 position of the glycerol giving rise to the diacylglycerol moiety of the lipid molecule (Fig. 1B). An added layer of complexity arises from the fact that different molecular species
Table 2. Assignments of fatty acid biosynthetic genes in the Rba. sphaeroides 2.4.1 reference genome1
1
Gene
Enzyme
Chromosome
GenBank Protein ID2
acpP
Acyl carrier protein (ACP)
1
YP_352523
acpS
ACP synthase
1
YP_351722
accA
Carboxyltransferase subunit (CT-α) of AcetylCoA carboxylase (ACC)
1
YP_351821
accB
Biotin carboxyl carrier protein subunit of ACC (BCCP)
1
YP_353262
accC
Biotin carboxylase subunit of ACC (BC)
1
YP_353263
accD
Carboxyltransferase subunit of ACC (CT-β)
1
YP_354012
fabD
Malonyl-CoA:ACP-trasnacylase
1
YP_352738
fabH
β-ketoacyl-ACP synthase III
1
YP_352670
fabB
β-ketoacyl-ACP synthase I
2
YP_354693
fabF
β-ketoacyl-ACP synthase II
1
YP_352524
fabG
β-ketoacyl-ACP reductase
1
YP_352522
fabA
β-hydroxydecanoyl-ACP dehydratase
2
YP_354694
fabZ
β-hydroxyl-ACP dehydratase
1
YP_352769
fabI
Enoyl-ACP reductase I
1
YP_352401
Enoyl-ACP reductase similar to FabI
2
YP_354692
Enoyl-ACP reductase similar to FabI
1
YP_354336
Chromosome 1, NC_007493, Chromosome 2, NC_007494, Copeland, A., Lucas, S., Lapidus, A., Barry, K., Detter, J.C., Glavina, T., Hammon, N., Israni, S., Pitluck, S., Richardson, P., Mackenzie, C., Choudhary, M., Larimer, F., Hauser, L.J., Land, M., Donohue, T.J. and Kaplan, S., The Rhodobacter sphaeroides Genome Consortium. GenBank submission by the US DOE Joint Genome Institute. 2 All assignments are predictions based on sequence comparison with the E. coli orthologs.
Chapter 7
Membrane Lipids
123
Fig. 1. Common acyl groups found in membrane lipids of purple bacteria (A) and structure of divaccenoylglycerol (B). The full carbon numbering is given for stearate (A) and the glycerol moiety (B).
in each lipid class contain different combinations of acyl groups in the diacylglycerol moiety. III. Phosphoglycerolipids In phosphoglycerolipids a phosphate diester links the diacylglycerol sn-3 hydroxyl group with the terminal hydroxyl of the lipid head group. Phosphoglycerolipids are the prevalent lipids in cell membranes of animals and model organisms such as E. coli. Accordingly, phosphoglycerolipid biosynthesis has been well characterized in E. coli, as recently reviewed (Cronan, 2003), providing the paradigm for proteobacteria. Table 1 shows predicted and in some cases directly confirmed orthologs of enzymes involved in glycerolipid biosynthesis in Rba. sphaeroides. An overview of the pathways leading to the biosynthesis of the different phosphoglycerolipids is shown in Fig. 2. All phosphoglycerolipids described, up to cardiolipin, are also present in E. coli. The other lipids described below reflect the complex nature of membrane lipids and their biosynthesis in purple bacteria.
A. Phosphatidic Acid and Cytidine Diphosphate Diacylglycerol Phosphoglycerolipid biosynthesis starts with the formation of phosphatidic acid by sequential acylation of glycerol 3-phosphate at the sn-1 and sn-2 positions (Fig. 2). Different acyl-ACPs serve as acyl donors in these reactions. In E. coli and presumably in purple bacteria two acyltransferases PlsB and PlsC are involved, but sequence comparison identified only a possible ortholog for PlsB in Rba. sphaeroides (Table 1). There are other open reading frames encoding proteins with acyltransferase motifs, but the specific gene encoding the glycerol 3-phosphate acyltransferase remains to be identified by using genetic or biochemical methods. The assembly of some of the non-phosphorous glycerolipids present in purple bacteria starts with the formation of diacylglycerol. A phosphatidic acid phosphatase could be involved, but has not yet been implicated in purple bacteria. For the biosynthesis of phosphoglycerolipids, phosphatidic acid is converted to CDP-diacylglycerol. A predicted ortholog of the
124
Banita Tamot and Christoph Benning
Fig. 2. Biosynthesis of phosphoglycerolipids in purple bacteria. Enzyme nomenclature as shown in Table 1. DMPE, N,N-dimethyl phosphatidylethanolamine; MMPE, N-monomethyl phosphatidylethanolamine.
E. coli phosphatidate cytidylyltransferase, CdsA, is encoded in the genome of Rba. sphaeroides (Table 1). B. Phosphatidylethanolamine Phosphatidylethanolamine (PtdEtn) is at 70 – 80 mol% the predominant membrane lipid in E. coli. Phosphatidylethanolamine is required for growth unless large concentrations of divalent cations are present in the medium (DeChavigny et al., 1991). Furthermore, it acts as a molecular chaperone for the assembly of polytopic integral membrane proteins (Bogdanov et al., 1996). In purple bacteria such as Rba. sphaeroides PtdEtn is present at lower concentrations of 35–45 mol% (Russell and Harwood, 1979; Benning and Somerville, 1992b), but it is still the most abundant membrane lipid. The biosynthesis of PtdEtn from CDP-diacylglyc-
erol involves the transfer of serine and the release of CMP (Fig. 2). This reaction is catalyzed in E. coli by phosphatidylserine synthase (Pss) and a predicted ortholog is present in Rba. sphaeroides (Table 1). Biochemical analysis of Pss in Rba. sphaeroides suggests that unlike the E. coli ortholog the Rba. sphaeroides enzyme is membrane–bound and magnesium dependent (Radcliffe et al., 1989). Phosphatidylserine is an intermediate that does not accumulate, as it is rapidly converted to PtdEtn by phosphatidylserine decarboxylase (Psd). A predicted ortholog is present in Rba. sphaeroides suggesting that the biosynthesis in purple bacteria proceeds as determined for E. coli. A direct analysis of these enzymes in purple bacteria is still lacking. C. Phosphatidylglycerol and Cardiolipin Like PtdEtn, phosphatidylglycerol (PtdGro) is
Chapter 7
Membrane Lipids
synthesized from CDP-diacylglycerol. Glycerol 3phosphate serves as the head group donor leading to the formation of CMP and phosphatidylglycerol 3-phosphate (Fig. 2). The enzyme responsible, phosphatidylglycerol 3-phosphate synthase, PgsA (Table 1), was biochemically characterized in Rba. sphaeroides (Radcliffe et al., 1989), and the respective gene was identified (Dryden and Dowhan, 1996). Expression of the Rba. sphaeroides gene in an E. coli pgsA mutant could functionally replace the E. coli enzyme and overexpression of the gene in Rba. sphaeroides led to increased phosphatidylglycerol 3-phosphate synthase activity (Dryden and Dowhan, 1996). However, the phospholipid composition of the resulting strain was not significantly affected suggesting that the enzyme is regulated post-transcriptionally. Similarly, overexpression in E. coli did not affect the lipid composition suggesting that the Rba. sphaeroides and E. coli orthologs are similarly regulated. Phosphatidylglycerol is formed following the dephosphorylation of phosphatidylglycerol 3-phosphate. The gene encoding the respective phosphatase, PgpA, has been predicted for Rba. sphaeroides (Table 1). In bacteria the combination of two PtdGro molecules releases glycerol and leads to the formation of bisphosphatidylglycerol (cardiolipin, CL; Fig. 2). The CL synthase from Rba. sphaeroides, Cls, has been recently identified (Table 1) and a CL-deficient Rba. sphaeroides cls disruption mutant has been generated (Tamot and Benning, unpublished). Expression of the open reading frame in trans led to the restoration of CL biosynthesis. As observed for the respective E. coli mutant (Pluschke et al., 1978; Nishijima et al., 1988), small amounts of cardiolipin are still formed in the Rba. sphaeroides mutant. This mutant also produces more PtdGro, the precursor of CL biosynthesis. Results from a cls, pss-1 double mutant of E. coli suggest that phosphatidylserine synthase might be responsible for the formation of small amounts of cardiolipin in the cls mutant (Shibuya et al., 1985). The presence of an alternative Cls in Rba. sphaeroides has not yet been explored. The relative amount of CL is strongly increased in Rba. sphaeroides following osmotic stress (Catucci et al., 2004). Whether this is due to the upregulation of Cls activity or the activation of an alternative pathway is not yet clear. D. Phosphatidylcholine Phosphatidylcholine (PtdCho) is found in most eu-
125 karyotic cells with few exceptions, e.g. the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii (Giroud et al., 1988), but it is not as prevalent in bacteria (Sohlenkamp et al., 2003). Based on estimates derived from sequenced bacterial genomes, approximately 10–20% of bacteria contain genes predicted to encode enzymes involved in PtdCho biosynthesis. The first gene directly required for bacterial PtdCho biosynthesis, pmtA, was discovered in Rba. sphaeroides (Arondel et al., 1993) and encodes a PtdEtn N-methyltransferase. Expression of the pmtA gene in E. coli led to the accumulation of PtdCho, which is normally absent from E. coli. The PmtA enzyme catalyzes the transfer of three methyl groups from AdoMet onto the terminal amino group of PtdEtn (Fig. 2). Interestingly, Sr. meliloti, an α-proteobacterium closely related to Rba. sphaeroides, uses a different form of PmtA (de Rudder et al., 1997). In general, bacteria capable of synthesizing PtdCho use either one or the other type of PmtA (Sohlenkamp et al., 2003). Introduction of PmtA from Sr. meliloti into E. coli led to the formation of PtdCho, thus confirming its potential for PtdCho biosynthesis. However, inactivation of the pmtA gene in Sr. meliloti did not cause a loss of PtdCho. Geiger and colleagues subsequently discovered a second pathway of PtdCho biosynthesis in Sr. meliloti (de Rudder et al., 1999) involving the transfer of choline onto CDP-DAG (Fig. 2). The enzyme responsible is the unique bacterial PtdCho synthase, Pcs, (Sohlenkamp et al., 2000). A survey of a number of bacteria suggests that most, but not all bacterial species with PmtA activity also have Pcs activity in their cell extracts (Martinez-Morales et al., 2003). One notable exception was Rba. sphaeroides that did not incorporate labeled choline into PtdCho, consistent with previous observations that the pmtA mutant of Rba. sphaeroides lacked PtdCho (Arondel et al., 1993). As the Rba. sphaeroides genome harbors a gene potentially coding for a protein similar to Pcs of Sr. meliloti (Martinez-Morales et al., 2003; Sohlenkamp et al., 2003), it is not clear whether Pcs activity is truly absent, or whether Pcs is only active under certain growth conditions. In this context, it is important to note that the predicted Pcs listed in Table 1 still needs to be verified. One can only speculate why some bacteria have two pathways for PtdCho biosynthesis. The PmtA pathway can be considered a de novo synthesis pathway for PtdCho required for bacteria to grow outside possible host cells. The Pcs pathway is a salvage pathway that could provide an energy advantage to
126 the bacterium when choline is present, e.g., when a bacterium has entered a symbiotic relationship with a host as is the case for plant nodule-forming bacteria such as Sr. meliloti. Similarly, pathogenic bacteria inside host cells would benefit from choline provided by the host. Depending on the environment to which a bacterium has adapted, one or the other pathway, or both, might have been lost during evolution. IV. Glycoglycerolipids Glycoglycerolipids are non-phosphorous because their head groups are not connected to the diacylglycerol moiety by phosphodiester bonds. Instead, a hexose is found in a glycosidic linkage with the sn-3 hydroxyl group of the diacylglycerol moiety (Fig. 3). The most abundant glycoglycerolipids found in nature are the plant galactoglycerolipids (Dörmann and Benning, 2002). It is generally assumed that the prevalence of these lipids in plants with their extensive photosynthetic membrane system provides a strategy for conserving phosphorus, because inorganic phosphate is one of the limiting factors for biomass production in land-based and marine environments
Banita Tamot and Christoph Benning (Vance et al., 2003; Van Mooy et al., 2006). Bacteria can remodel their membrane lipid composition in response to phosphate deprivation by degrading phosphoglycerolipids and synthesizing glycoglycerolipids (Minnikin et al., 1974; Benning et al., 1993, 1995). Recently, support for this hypothesis was provided in a natural environment. Apparently, substitution of the phospholipid PtdGro by the sulfoglycolipid sulfoquinovosyldiacylglycerol (SQDG; Fig. 3B) enables marine picocyanobacteria to outcompete heterotrophic microorganisms (Van Mooy et al., 2006). Likewise, purple bacteria synthesize neutral glycoglycerolipids and the acidic sulfolipid SQDG (Fig. 3), particularly during phosphate limitation. A. Glycerolipids Containing Glucose or Galactose Beyond plants, glycoglycerolipids are present in many bacteria, but their structures differ in subtle ways. Accordingly, the responsible lipid glycosyltransferases are not necessarily directly related in different organisms. For example, the biosynthesis of the major plant galactolipid involves the transfer of a galactosyl residue from UDP-Gal onto diacylglycerol giving rise
Fig. 3. Biosynthesis of glycoglycerolipids in Rba. sphaeroides. (A) Proposed formation of β-D-galactosyldiacylglycerol (MGDG) and α-D-glucosyl-(1→4)-O-β-D-galactosyldiacylglycerol (GGDG), and (B) of sulfoquinovosyldiacylglycerol (SQDG). LGT1 and LGT2 designate proposed lipid glycosyltransferases that still need to be identified. Loci genetically implicated in different steps of SQDG biosynthesis are indicated (sqdA, B, C, D). DAG, diacylglycerol; NDP-Gal, nucleoside diphosphogalactose; NDP-Glu, nucleoside diphosphoglucose; UDP-Glc, UDP-glucose; UDP-SQ, UDP-sulfoquinovose.
Chapter 7
Membrane Lipids
to β-D-galactosyldiacylglycerol. A second transfer of a galactosyl residue from UDP-Gal leads to the formation of α-D-galactosyl-(1→6)-O-β-D-galactosyldiacylglycerol. The two enzymes involved in Arabidopsis are non-processive galactosyltransferases, MGD1 and DGD1 (Benning and Ohta, 2005). Two galactoglycerolipids identical in head group structure to the plant galactoglycerolipids exist in cyanobacteria, but the first enzyme is a glucosyltransferase transferring a glucosyl residue onto diacylglycerol followed by an epimerase converting the glucosyl residue into the galactosyl head group (Awai et al., 2006). In Bacillus subtilis and in Staphylococcus aureus processive glucosyltransferases produce βD-glucosyldiacylglycerol and β-D-glucosyl-(1→6)O-β-D-glucosyldiacylglycerols (Jorasch et al., 1998, 2000). In the mycoplasma Acholeplasma laidlawii the formation of α-D-glucosyldiacylglycerol, and αD-glucosyl-(1→2)-O-β-D-glucosyldiacylglycerol is catalyzed by a distinct set of retaining, non-processive UDP-glucose dependent glucosyltransferases (Berg et al., 2001; Edman et al., 2003). Purple bacteria, as analyzed thus far, produce a set of glycoglycerolipids different from those found in plants and other bacteria. Membranes of Blastochloris viridis contain β-D-galactosyldiacylglycerol and β-D-galactosyl-(1→6)-O-β-D-galactosyldiacylglycerol (Linscheid et al., 1997). Following phosphate-deprivation, Rba. sphaeroides produces β-D-galactosyldiacylglycerol and α-D-glucosyl-(1→ 4)-O-β-D-galactosyldiacylglycerol (Benning et al., 1995). In both cases the identity of the glycosyltransferases is not known. Given the diversity of the lipid glycosyltransferases in different organisms, we could not predict Rba. sphaeroides glycosyltransferases involved in the biosynthesis of this lipid. However, based on analogy to other bacterial enzyme systems, we propose that the biosynthesis of α-D-glucosyl(1→4)-O-β-D-galactosyldiacylglycerol involves two different glycosyltransferases (LGT1 and LGT2; Fig. 3). One can only marvel at the diversity of glycoglycerolipids in bacteria and speculate about their function and origin. In general, the respective monohexosyldiacylglycerol represents a non-bilayer forming lipid, while the respective dihexosyldiacylglycerol usually forms bilayers in mixtures with water (Webb and Green, 1991). Mixtures of both lipid types may provide organisms with a lipid environment suitable for proper function of the membrane. Indeed, expression of the gene for monoglucosyldiacylglycerol
127 synthase from A. laidlawii in the PtdEtn deficient pss mutant of E. coli alleviated the growth defects (Wikstrom et al., 2004; Xie et al., 2006), indicating that compositionally very different non-bilayer-forming glycerolipids can substitute for each other. The great diversity of glycoglycerolipids in bacteria due to the recruitment of different glycosyltransferases is presumably facilitated by the fact that different lipids can be readily substituted as long as their basic biophysical properties are similar. B. Sulfoquinovosyldiacylglycerol The sulfolipid, sulfoquinovosyldiacylglycerol (SQDG), was discovered by Benson and coworkers in plants, algae, and the purple bacterium Rhodospirillum rubrum (Benson et al., 1959). It is a glycoglycerolipid with a 6-deoxy-6-sulfo-α-D-glucosyl head group bound to the sn-3 hydroxyl of the diacylglycerol backbone (Fig. 3B). It should be noted that the head group is a sulfonate and not a sulfate ester. As such its pKa is low and it is resistant to loss of the sulfur group by hydrolysis. In essence, SQDG is an anionic glycoglycerolipid at biological pH values. This particular lipid is widespread in bacteria and plants and its presence in different species of purple bacteria is well documented (Wood et al., 1965; Imhoff, 1991; Gage et al., 1992; Imhoff and Bias-Imhoff, 1995). However, in some purple bacteria, including Rba. capsulatus, no SQDG was detected (Imhoff, 1991). Searching protein sequences encoded by the Rba. capsulatus genome with the highly conserved protein sequence for SqdB (see below) from Rba. sphaeroides at the Integrated Genomics web site (http://www. ergo-light.com/ERGO/) did not provide a positive result suggesting that Rba. capsulatus might indeed lack the capability to synthesize SQDG. On the other hand, sulfolipid is present in the related, but nonphotosynthetic nodule-forming bacterium Sr. meliloti (Cedergren and Hollingsworth, 1994). Genetic analysis of SQDG metabolism in Rba. sphaeroides was instrumental in identifying the bacterial, and subsequently the plant genes involved in SQDG biosynthesis (Benning, 1998a; Frentzen, 2004). Mutants of Rba. sphaeroides deficient in SQDG biosynthesis were identified by thin-layer chromatography of lipid extracts from chemically mutagenized cells. Restoration of SQDG biosynthesis following the introduction of wild-type DNA led to the isolation of the sqdA gene (Benning and Somerville, 1992b) and an operon encoding the sqd-
128 BCD open reading frames (Benning and Somerville, 1992a). Subsequently, the sqdBCD open reading frames were individually inactivated and shown to be required for SQDG biosynthesis (Benning et al., 1993; Rossak et al., 1995, 1997). The sqdB gene of Rba. sphaeroides served in the identification of the cyanobacterial ortholog (Güler et al., 1996) and later the plant SQD1 protein (Essigmann et al., 1998). Of the four proteins encoded by the sqd genes, SqdB is most conserved and best studied. The SqdB protein is similar to sugar nucleotide-modifying proteins (Benning and Somerville, 1992a). While the Rba. sphaeroides SqdB enzyme has not been further analyzed, the recombinant plant ortholog SQD1 catalyzes the incorporation of sulfite into UDP-Glc producing UDP-sulfoquinovose (UDP-SQ, Fig. 3B) (Sanda et al., 2001). The structure of the SQD1 protein was modeled and determined by X-ray crystallography providing insights into the reaction mechanism of this enzyme (Essigmann et al., 1999; Mulichak et al., 1999). The SQD1 enzyme is a dimer and contains a tightly bound NAD+ nucleotide which participates in the reaction cycle and is intermittently reduced. Much less is known about the biochemical function of the other three Sqd proteins from Rba. sphaeroides. The predicted SqdA protein is similar to bacterial acyltransferases, SqdC to a small molecule reductase, and SqdD to glycogenin, an autoglycosylating glycosyltransferase. Specific inactivation of SqdD led to the accumulation of UDP-SQ in Rba. sphaeroides (Rossak et al., 1995). In view of the similarity of SqdD to glycosyltransferases this result suggests that SqdD transfers sulfoquinovose from UDP-SQ onto an acceptor. Unlike the SqdB protein, the SqdD protein is not conserved in cyanobacteria and plants. Both contain similar SQDG synthases, but both are different from SqdD of Rba. sphaeroides (Güler et al., 2000; Yu et al., 2002). Biochemical analysis of the plant enzyme suggest that it uses diacylglycerol as an acceptor (Heinz et al., 1989; Seifert and Heinz, 1992), but this may not be the case for SqdD from Rba. sphaeroides. Indeed, when the sqdC gene was specifically inactivated, sulfoquinovosyl-1-O-dihydroxyacetone accumulated in the mutant (Rossak et al., 1997). This result suggests that a compound such as dihydroxyacetone or dihydroxyacetone phosphate serves as an acceptor for the UDP-SQ:sulfoquinovosyl transferase presumably encoded by sqdD. The SqdC amino acid sequence is similar to that of a small molecule reductase which potentially could reduce the β-ketogroup of the dihydroxyacetone resi-
Banita Tamot and Christoph Benning due to the glycerol. As the SqdA amino acid sequence is similar to that of an acyltransferase, the SqdA protein could be involved in acylation of one or both hydroxyl groups of a sulfoquinovosyl 1-O-glycerol or a sulfoquinovosyl-1-O-dihydroxyacetone precursor. At this time, the proposed scenario is speculative, but it is very likely that SQDG is assembled in Rba. sphaeroides by a route different from that in plants or cyanobacteria. A detailed biochemical analysis of the Sqd proteins should provide the answer. V. Betaine Lipid The betaine lipid diacylglycerol-N,N,N,-trimethylhomoserine (DGTS) is a non-phosphorous glycerolipid with its head group ether-linked to the sn-3 hydroxyl of the diacylglycerol moiety (Fig. 4). This interesting lipid is similar in structure and biophysical properties to PtdCho (Sato and Murata, 1991). It is present in many algae and non-seed plants, as well as fungi as summarized by (Klug and Benning, 2001). DGTS has been discovered in bacteria such as Rba. sphaeroides (Benning et al., 1995) and Sr. meliloti (Geiger et al., 1999). In both bacteria this lipid accumulates following phosphate deprivation. Labeling studies with Rba. sphaeroides (Hofmann and Eichenberger, 1996) suggested that DGTS is produced in this bacterium by transfer of the 3-amino-3-carboxypropyl group of AdoMet onto diacylglycerol (Fig. 4), giving rise to diacylglycerolhomoserine. Subsequent transfer of three methyl groups from AdoMet would lead to the end product, DGTS. This reaction sequence was similar to the proposed biosynthesis pathway in eukaryotes based on labeling studies as summarized by Klug and Benning (2001). The discovery of DGTS in Rba. sphaeroides provided an ideal opportunity to identify the first genes involved in DGTS biosynthesis. A similar genetic approach as described for the sqd genes above was used to isolate an operon consisting of two open reading frames, btaA and btaB, involved in DGTS biosynthesis in Rba. sphaeroides (Klug and Benning, 2001). Mutation of the btaA gene resulted in the loss of DGTS accumulation during phosphate starvation. When the btaB gene was disrupted, a new lipid, diacylglycerylhomoserine, accumulated (Klug and Benning, 2001). Based on these results it was proposed that btaA encodes an AdoMet:diacylglycerol 3-amino-3-carboxypropyl transferase. This hypothesis was recently confirmed by expression of
Chapter 7
Membrane Lipids
129
Fig. 4. Biosynthesis of diacylglycerol-N,N,N,-trimethylhomoserine and the role of the two enzymes BtaA and BtaB. AdoHcy, S-adenosylhomocysteine; AdoMet, S-adenosylmethionine; DAG, diacylglycerol; DGHS, Diacylglycerolhomoserine; DGTS, diacylglycerolN,N,N,-trimethylhomoserine; 5´MTA, 5´-methylthioadenosine.
the btaA gene in E. coli and the direct biochemical analysis of the BtaA protein (Riekhof et al., 2005a). Co-expression of the btaA and btaB genes in E. coli led to DGTS biosynthesis in this bacterium which normally lacks DGTS. This result also confirmed that btaB encodes the N-methyltransferase (Riekhof et al., 2005a). The discovery of the two genes involved in DGTS biosynthesis in Rba. sphaeroides led to the identification of an orthologous protein, BTA1, in the eukaryotic alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii (Riekhof et al., 2005b). Interestingly the BTA1 amino acid sequence contains two domains, each similar to the bacterial BtaA and BtaB sequences, respectively.
VI. Ornithine Lipid All of the membrane lipids described above are glycerolipids. In contrast, in ornithine lipids of purple bacteria and related α-proteobacteria, the α-amino group of ornithine is amide-linked to a 3-hydroxy fatty acid (Fig. 1 and Fig. 5). A second fatty acid, e.g. vaccenic acid, is esterified to the 3-hydroxy group (Brooks and Benson, 1972; Gorchein, 1973). This lipid is also present in Sr. meliloti and an operon with two open reading frames, olsA and olsB, was isolated using a genetic complementation approach as described above for the isolation of the sqd and bta genes from
Fig. 5. Proposed biosynthesis of ornithine lipid (OL). The two acyltransferases OlsA and OlsB proposed to be involved are indicated. ACP, acyl carrier protein.
130 Rba. sphaeroides (Weissenmayer et al., 2002; Gao et al., 2004). Acylation of lyso-ornithine lipid in protein extracts of wild type cells and reduced acylation activity in extracts of an olsA mutant of Sr. meliloti (Weissenmayer et al., 2002) indicated that OlsA is an acyltransferase catalyzing the second reaction of ornithine lipid biosynthesis (Fig. 5). Expression of olsB in E. coli led to the formation of lyso-ornithine lipid, consistent with a role for OlsB in the first acylation reaction (Gao et al., 2004). The olsAB genes of Rba. capsulatus were recently identified during a screen targeted at the identification of cytochrome c deficient respiratory mutants (Aygun-Sunar et al., 2006). Several c-type cytrochromes were found to be absent in mutants, which were primarily deficient in the biosynthesis of ornithine lipid. We used these olsAB genes from Rba. capsulatus to identify putative orthologs in the genome of Rba. sphaeroides as shown in Table 1. VII. Lipid Function The extensive repertoire of membrane lipids in purple bacteria raises questions regarding the biological role of this complexity, and the mechanisms that regulate membrane lipid composition. The lipid composition under defined growth conditions is generally stable (homeostatic) as bacterial cells grow and divide, but is known to alter in bacteria in response to changing environmental factors such as nutrient supply. Understanding the regulation of membrane lipid homeostasis and of changes in lipid composition in response to environmental cues remains one of the frontiers in cell biology and biochemistry. Two recent advances have been most helpful in assigning specific functions to individual membrane lipids beyond their role as bulk membrane building blocks. These are the increasing availability of mutants with disrupted lipid biosynthetic genes facilitated by the availability of genome sequences of different purple bacteria, and an increasing number of crystal structures for integral membrane protein complexes. A. Changes in Lipid Composition in Response to the Environment Phosphate deprivation is the most effective known environmental factor that leads to membrane lipid composition changes, as first recognized for Pseudomonas sp. (Minnikin and Abdolrahimzadeh, 1974;
Banita Tamot and Christoph Benning Minnikin et al., 1974). Purple bacteria (Benning et al., 1993, 1995) and related α-proteobacteria such as Sr. meliloti (Geiger et al., 1999) also change their lipid composition in response to decreases in phosphate concentration in the growth medium. In fact, some of the lipids discussed above, e.g. the betaine lipid, are not even detectable unless the cells are phosphate depleted (Benning et al., 1995; Geiger et al., 1999). It has been hypothesized that SQDG can substitute for the anionic phospholipid PtdGro in Rba. sphaeroides, based on the fact that an SQDG deficient mutant contains increased levels of PtdGro and ceases to grow sooner than the wild type strain under phosphate-limited conditions (Benning et al., 1993). Similar conclusions with regard to the role of SQDG based on mutant analysis are drawn for cyanobacteria (Güler et al., 1996) and plants (Yu et al., 2002). This glycolipid vs. phospholipid hypothesis has recently gained further recognition due to the discovery that SQDG is prevalent in marine picocyanobacteria. The ability to synthesize SQDG presumably provides these photosynthetic bacteria with a competitive advantage over heterotrophic microorganisms lacking the ability to synthesize SQDG (Van Mooy et al., 2006). Similar studies of DGTS-deficient mutants are not yet available. However, it is reasonable to assume that, because the structural and biophysical properties of DGTS resemble within limitations those of PtdCho (Sato and Murata, 1991), the betaine lipid DGTS can substitute for PtdCho in purple bacteria and α-proteobacteria under phosphate-limited conditions. The expression of the bta genes of Sr. meliloti responsible for DGTS biosynthesis was found to be under the control of the PhoB regulator, which governs the expression of genes responsive to phosphate limitation (Geiger et al., 1999). Most intriguing is the observation that addition of Tris to the growth medium leads to the accumulation of phosphatidyl Tris in membranes of Rba. sphaeroides (Schmid et al., 1991). This is a xenobiotic compound which apparently provides the cell with a suitable bulk membrane lipid. How this lipid is synthesized is not known, but it seems possible that Tris enters phospholipid biosynthesis at the level of one of the CDP-diacylglcyerol utilizing enzymes (Fig. 2). Certain strains of Rba. sphaeroides, including strain 2.4.1, discriminate against Tris and cannot form phosphatidyl Tris (Donohue et al., 1982), which was initially misidentified as N-acylphosphatidylserine. It is interesting to note in this context that Rba. sphaer-
Chapter 7
Membrane Lipids
oides 2.4.1 also apparently lacks PtdCho synthase (Pcs) activity (Arondel et al., 1993; Sohlenkamp et al., 2003), and it seems possible that Pcs (Fig. 2) might be responsible for the formation of phosphatidyl Tris in some strains of Rba. sphaeroides. However, this hypothesis remains to be tested. Environmental factors more subtly affecting membrane lipid composition in purple bacteria are light illumination (quality and intensity) and oxygen tension (Russell and Harwood, 1979; Onishi and Niederman, 1982; Campbell and Lueking, 1983). Furthermore, increasing osmolarity in the medium led to an increased conversion of PtdGro to CL (Catucci et al., 2004), presumably stabilizing the cell membrane bilayer under these conditions. The availability of a new CL-deficient mutant (Tamot and Benning, unpublished) will allow this hypothesis to be tested.
131 Paracoccus denitrificans (Ostermeier et al., 1997) and bovine heart (Tsukihara et al., 2003) showed that most alkyl chains resolved in the structures were conserved. Several of these belong to a previously identified CL associated with the complex. A recently isolated CL-deficient mutant of Rba. sphaeroides (Tamot and Benning, unpublished) should provide a tool to test the function of this CL associated with CcO. Already, work on an ornithine lipid-deficient mutant of Rba. capsulatus has shown that OL is required to maintain steady state amounts of c-type cytochromes (AygunSunar et al., 2006). Given that CL is found tightly associated with the photosynthetic reaction center and the CcO integral membrane complexes, one might expect to observe drastic effects on the growth and physiology of a CL-deficient mutant. VIII. Perspectives
B. Interaction of Lipids with Membrane Proteins The recent progress in the structural elucidation of integral membrane complexes from different organisms including purple bacteria has led to the discovery of specific lipid protein interactions at a level previously not possible (Palsdottir and Hunte, 2004; Hunte, 2005). Several crystal structures are available for the Photosystem II-like reaction center of Rba. sphaeroides and one emerging theme is the presence of one CL molecule in what appears to be a specific binding site at the protein lipid interface (McAuley et al., 1999; Wakeham et al., 2001; Jones et al., 2002; Katona et al., 2003). In addition, PtdCho and glucosylgalactosyldiacylglycerol were found in the structure of the Rba. sphaeroides reaction center complex, and were confirmed by mass spectrometry (Camara-Artigas et al., 2002). The functionality of the lipid interaction with the reaction center was tested in vitro and it was shown that CL, PtdGro and PtdCho affect the free energy levels of the quinones bound in the reaction center complex (Rinyu et al., 2004; Nagy et al., 2004). A second integral membrane complex that received much attention is a terminal complex of the respiratory chain, cytochrome c oxidase (CcO). Six PtdEtn molecules were resolved in the crystal structure of the four subunit CcO complex of Rba. sphaeroides (Svensson-Ek et al., 2002). Overlaying a more recent subunit I-II structure of CcO of Rba. sphaeroides (Quin et al., 2006) with orthologous structures from
Due to their lipid-rich membrane composition, purple bacteria provide ideal models to study the biosynthesis and function of some of the more unusual lipids found in nature. In addition, their ability to adapt to different environments by changing their membrane lipid composition provides fertile ground for studies addressing the regulation of lipid homeostasis. Furthermore, the flexibility in membrane lipid composition of purple bacteria and their ability to incorporate even xenobiotic compounds into their membranes challenge our current hypotheses about the roles of specific lipids, in particular phospholipids. The increasing repertoire of lipid biosynthetic mutants in Rba. sphaeroides provides the tools to test the function of individual lipid classes as predicted by their presence in high-resolution structures of integral membrane proteins. Moreover, as Rba. sphaeroides is proposed to serve as a suitable host for high-yield and possibly high-throughput production of integral membrane proteins (Laible et al., 2004), lipid mutants could be developed into a tool kit to adjust the lipid composition of the host cell, optimizing the lipid environment for membrane protein production. Acknowledgments We are grateful to Carrie Hiser and Wayne Riekhof for carefully reading the manuscript and helpful discussions. Work on membrane lipids in the Benning Lab is supported in part by grants from the US
132 National Science Foundation, the US Department of Energy, and the Michigan State University Research of Excellence Center for the Structural Biology of Membrane Proteins. References Arondel V, Benning C and Somerville CR (1993) Isolation and functional expression in Escherichia coli of a gene encoding phosphatidylethanolamine methyltransferase (EC 2.1.1.17) from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Biol Chem 268: 16002–16008 Awai K, Kakimoto T, Awai C, Kaneko T, Nakamura Y, Takamiya K, Wada H and Ohta H (2006) Comparative genomic analysis revealed a gene for monoglucosyldiacylglycerol synthase, an enzyme for photosynthetic membrane lipid synthesis in cyanobacteria. Plant Physiol 141: 1120–1127 Aygun-Sunar S, Mandaci S, Koch HG, Murray IV, Goldfine H and Daldal F (2006) Ornithine lipid is required for optimal steady-state amounts of c-type cytochromes in Rhodobacter capsulatus. Mol Microbiol 61: 418–435 Benning C (1998a) Biosynthesis and function of the sulfolipid sulfoquinovosyl diacylglycerol. Annu Rev Plant Physiol Plant Mol Biol 49: 53–75 Benning C (1998b) Membrane lipids in anoxygenic photosynthetic bacteria. In P-A Siegenthaler, N Murata, eds, Lipids in Photosynthesis: Structure, Function and Genetics, pp 83–101. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Benning C and Ohta H (2005) Three enzyme systems for galactoglycerolipid biosynthesis are coordinately regulated in plants. J Biol Chem 280: 2397–2400 Benning C and Somerville CR (1992a) Identification of an operon involved in sulfolipid biosynthesis in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Bacteriol 174: 6479–6487 Benning C and Somerville CR (1992b) Isolation and genetic complementation of a sulfolipid-deficient mutant of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Bacteriol 174: 2352–2360 Benning C, Beatty JT, Prince RC and Somerville CR (1993) The sulfolipid sulfoquinovosyldiacylglycerol is not required for photosynthetic electron transport in Rhodobacter sphaeroides but enhances growth under phosphate limitation. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 90: 1561–1565 Benning C, Huang ZH and Gage DA (1995) Accumulation of a novel glycolipid and a betaine lipid in cells of Rhodobacter sphaeroides grown under phosphate limitation. Arch Biochem Biophys 317: 103–111 Benson AA, Daniel H and Wiser R (1959) A sulfolipid in plants. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 45: 1582–1587 Berg S, Edman M, Li L, Wikstrom M and Wieslander A (2001) Sequence properties of the 1,2-diacylglycerol 3-glucosyltransferase from Acholeplasma laidlawii membranes. Recognition of a large group of lipid glycosyltransferases in eubacteria and archaea. J Biol Chem 276: 22056–22063 Bogdanov M, Sun J, Kaback HR and Dowhan W (1996) A phospholipid acts as a chaperone in assembly of a membrane transport protein. J Biol Chem 271: 11615–11618 Boyce SG and Lueking DR (1984) Purification and characterization of a long-chain acyl coenzyme A thioesterase from Rho-
Banita Tamot and Christoph Benning dopseudomonas sphaeroides. Biochemistry 23: 141–147 Broglie RM and Niederman RA (1979) Membranes of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides: Effect of cerulenin on assembly of chromatophore membrane. J Bacteriol 138: 788–798 Brooks JL and Benson AA (1972) Studies on the structure of an ornithine-containing lipid from Rhodospirillum rubrum. Arch Biochem Biophys 152: 347–355 Camara-Artigas A, Brune D and Allen JP (2002) Interactions between lipids and bacterial reaction centers determined by protein crystallography. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 99: 11055–11060 Campbell TB and Lueking DR (1983) Light-mediated regulation of phospholipid synthesis in Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. J Bacteriol 155: 806–816 Catucci L, Depalo N, Lattanzio VM, Agostiano A and Corcelli A (2004) Neosynthesis of cardiolipin in Rhodobacter sphaeroides under osmotic stress. Biochemistry 43: 15066–15072 Cedergren RA and Hollingsworth RI (1994) Occurrence of sulfoquinovosyl diacylglycerol in some members of the family Rhizobiaceae. J Lipid Res 35: 1452–1461 Cooper CL, Boyce SG and Lueking DR (1987) Purification and characterization of Rhodobacter sphaeroides acyl carrier protein. Biochemistry 26: 2740–2746 Cronan JE (2003) Bacterial membrane lipids: Where do we stand? Annu Rev Microbiol 57: 203–224 de Rudder KE, Thomas-Oates JE and Geiger O (1997) Rhizobium meliloti mutants deficient in phospholipid N-methyltransferase still contain phosphatidylcholine. J Bacteriol 179: 6921–6928 de Rudder KE, Sohlenkamp C and Geiger O (1999) Plant-exuded choline is used for rhizobial membrane lipid biosynthesis by phosphatidylcholine synthase. J Biol Chem 274: 20011–20016 DeChavigny A, Heacock PN and Dowhan W (1991) Sequence and inactivation of the pss gene of Escherichia coli. Phosphatidylethanolamine may not be essential for cell viability. J Biol Chem 266: 5323–5332 Donohue TJ, Cain BD and Kaplan S (1982) Alterations in the phospholipid composition of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides and other bacteria induced by Tris. J Bacteriol 152: 595–606 Dörmann P and Benning C (2002) Galactolipids rule in seed plants. Trends Plant Sci 7: 112–118 Dryden SC and Dowhan W (1996) Isolation and expression of the Rhodobacter sphaeroides gene (pgsA) encoding phosphatidylglycerophosphate synthase. J Bacteriol 178: 1030–1038 Edman M, Berg S, Storm P, Wikstrom M, Vikstrom S, Ohman A and Wieslander A (2003) Structural features of glycosyltransferases synthesizing major bilayer and nonbilayer-prone membrane lipids in Acholeplasma laidlawii and Streptococcus pneumoniae. J Biol Chem 278: 8420–8428 Essigmann B, Güler S, Narang RA, Linke D and Benning C (1998) Phosphate availability affects the thylakoid lipid composition and the expression of SQD1, a gene required for sulfolipid biosynthesis in Arabidopsis thaliana. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 95: 1950–1955 Essigmann B, Hespenheide BM, Kuhn LA and Benning C (1999) Prediction of the active-site structure and NAD+ binding in SQD1, a protein essential for sulfolipid biosynthesis in Arabidopsis. Arch Biochem Biophys 369: 30–41 Frentzen M (2004) Phosphatidylglycerol and sulfoquinovosyldiacylglycerol: Anionic membrane lipids and phosphate regulation. Curr Opin Plant Biol 7: 270–276
Chapter 7
Membrane Lipids
Gage DA, Huang ZH and Benning C (1992) Comparison of sulfoquinovosyl diacylglycerol from spinach and the purple bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides by fast atom bombardment tandem mass spectrometry. Lipids 27: 632–636 Gao JL, Weissenmayer B, Taylor AM, Thomas-Oates J, LopezLara IM and Geiger O (2004) Identification of a gene required for the formation of lyso-ornithine lipid, an intermediate in the biosynthesis of ornithine-containing lipids. Mol Microbiol 53: 1757–1770 Geiger O, Röhrs V, Weissenmayer B, Finan TM and ThomasOates JE (1999) The regulator gene phoB mediates phosphate stress-controlled synthesis of the membrane lipid diacylglyceryl-N,N,N-trimethylhomoserine in Rhizobium (Sinorhizobium) meliloti. Mol Microbiol 32: 63–73 Giroud C, Gerber A and Eichenberger W (1988) Lipids of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. Analysis of molecular species and intracellular site(s) of biosynthesis. Plant Cell Physiol 29: 587–595 Gorchein A (1973) Structure of the ornithine-containing lipid from Rhodopseudomonas spheroides. Biochim Biophys Acta 306: 137–141 Güler S, Seeliger A, Härtel H, Renger G and Benning C (1996) A null mutant of Synechococcus sp. PCC7942 deficient in the sulfolipid sulfoquinovosyl diacylglycerol. J Biol Chem 271: 7501–7507 Güler S, Essigmann B and Benning C (2000) A cyanobacterial gene, sqdX, required for biosynthesis of the sulfolipid sulfoquinovosyldiacylglycerol. J Bacteriol 182: 543–545 Heinz E, Schmidt H, Hoch M, Jung KH, Binder H and Schmidt RR (1989) Synthesis of different nucleoside 5´-diphospho-sulfoquinovoses and their use for studies on sulfolipid biosynthesis in chloroplasts. Eur J Biochem 184: 445–453 Hofmann M and Eichenberger W (1996) Biosynthesis of diacylglyceryl-N,N,N-trimethylhomoserine in Rhodobacter sphaeroides and evidence for lipid-linked N methylation. J Bacteriol 178: 6140–6144 Hunte C (2005) Specific protein-lipid interactions in membrane proteins. Biochem Soc Trans 33: 938–942 Imhoff JF (1991) Polar lipids and fatty acids in the genus Rhodobacter. System Appl Microbiol 14: 228–234 Imhoff JF and Bias-Imhoff U (1995) Lipids, quinones and fatty acids of anoxygenic phototrophic bacteria. In: RE Blankenship, MT Madigan, CE Bauer, eds, Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria, pp 179–205. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Imhoff JF, Kushner DJ, Kushwaha SC and Kates M (1982) Polar lipids in phototrophic bacteria of the Rhodospirillaceae and Chromatiaceae families. J Bacteriol 150: 1192–1201 Jones MR, Fyfe PK, Roszak AW, Isaacs NW and Cogdell RJ (2002) Protein-lipid interactions in the purple bacterial reaction centre. Biochim Biophys Acta 1565: 206–214 Jorasch P, Wolter FP, Zahringer U and Heinz E (1998) A UDP glucosyltransferase from Bacillus subtilis successively transfers up to four glucose residues to 1,2-diacylglycerol: Expression of ypfP in Escherichia coli and structural analysis of its reaction products. Mol Microbiol 29: 419–430 Jorasch P, Warnecke DC, Lindner B, Zahringer U and Heinz E (2000) Novel processive and nonprocessive glycosyltransferases from Staphylococcus aureus and Arabidopsis thaliana synthesize glycoglycerolipids, glycophospholipids, glycosphingolipids and glycosylsterols. Eur J Biochem 267: 3770–3783 Katona G, Andreasson U, Landau EM, Andreasson LE and
133 Neutze R (2003) Lipidic cubic phase crystal structure of the photosynthetic reaction centre from Rhodobacter sphaeroides at 2.35Å resolution. J Mol Biol 331: 681–692 Klug RM and Benning C (2001) Two enzymes of diacylglycerylO-4´-(N,N,N,-trimethyl)homoserine biosynthesis are encoded by btaA and btaB in the purple bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 98: 5910–5915 Laible PD, Scott HN, Henry L and Hanson DK (2004) Towards higher-throughput membrane protein production for structural genomics initiatives. J Struct Funct Genomics 5: 167–172 Linscheid M, Diehl BW, Övermöhle M, Riedl I and Heinz E (1997) Membrane lipids of Rhodopseudomonas viridis. Biochim Biophys Acta 1347: 151–163 Mackenzie C, Choudhary M, Larimer FW, Predki PF, Stilwagen S, Armitage JP, Barber RD, Donohue TJ, Hosler JP, Newman JE, Shapleigh JP, Sockett RE, Zeilstra-Ryalls J and Kaplan S (2001) The home stretch, a first analysis of the nearly completed genome of Rhodobacter sphaeroides 2.4.1. Photosynth Res 70: 19–41 Martinez-Morales F, Schobert M, Lopez-Lara IM and Geiger O (2003) Pathways for phosphatidylcholine biosynthesis in bacteria. Microbiology 149: 3461–3471 McAuley KE, Fyfe PK, Ridge JP, Isaacs NW, Cogdell RJ and Jones MR (1999) Structural details of an interaction between cardiolipin and an integral membrane protein. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 96: 14706–14711 McMurry LM, Oethinger M and Levy SB (1998) Triclosan targets lipid synthesis. Nature 394: 531–532 Minnikin DE and Abdolrahimzadeh H (1974) The replacement of phosphatidylethanolamine and acidic phospholipids by an ornithine-amide lipid and a minor phosphorus-free lipid in Pseudomonas fluorescens NCMB 129. FEBS Lett 43: 257–260 Minnikin DE, Abdolrahimzadeh H and Baddiley J (1974) Replacement of acidic phosphates by acidic glycolipids in Pseudomonas diminuta. Nature 249: 268–269 Mulichak AM, Theisen MJ, Essigmann B, Benning C and Garavito RM (1999) Crystal structure of SQD1, an enzyme involved in the biosynthesis of the plant sulfolipid headgroup donor UDPsulfoquinovose. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 96: 13097–13102 Nagy L, Milano F, Dorogi M, Agostiano A, Laczko G, Szebenyi K, Varo G, Trotta M and Maroti P (2004) Protein/lipid interaction in the bacterial photosynthetic reaction center: Phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylglycerol modify the free energy levels of the quinones. Biochemistry 43: 12913–12923 Nishijima S, Asami Y, Uetake N, Yamagoe S, Ohta A and Shibuya I (1988) Disruption of the Escherichia coli cls gene responsible for cardiolipin synthesis. J Bacteriol 170: 775–780 Onishi JC and Niederman RA (1982) Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides membranes: Alterations in phospholipid composition in aerobically and phototrophically grown cells. J Bacteriol 149: 831–839 Ostermeier C, Harrenga A, Ermler U and Michel H (1997) Structure at 2.7 Å resolution of the Paracoccus denitrificans two-subunit cytochrome c oxidase complexed with an antibody FV fragment. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 94: 10547–10553 Palsdottir H and Hunte C (2004) Lipids in membrane protein structures. Biochim Biophys Acta 1666: 2–18 Pluschke G, Hirota Y and Overath P (1978) Function of phospholipids in Escherichia coli. Characterization of a mutant deficient in cardiolipin synthesis. J Biol Chem 253: 5048–5055 Quin L, Hiser C, Mulichak A, Garavito RM and Ferguson-Miller
134 S (2006) Identification of conserved lipid/detergent binding sites in a high resolution structure of the membrane protein cytochrome c oxidase. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA in press: Radcliffe CW, Steiner FX, Carman GM and Niederman RA (1989) Characterization and localization of phosphatidylglycerophosphate and phosphatidylserine synthases in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Arch Microbiol 152: 132–137 Riekhof WR, Andre C and Benning C (2005a) Two enzymes, BtaA and BtaB, are sufficient for betaine lipid biosynthesis in bacteria. Arch Biochem Biophys 441: 96–105 Riekhof WR, Sears BB and Benning C (2005b) Annotation of genes involved in glycerolipid biosynthesis in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii: Discovery of the betaine lipid synthase BTA1Cr. Eukaryot Cell 4: 242–252 Rinyu L, Martin EW, Takahashi E, Maroti P and Wraight CA (2004) Modulation of the free energy of the primary quinone acceptor (QA) in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: contributions from the protein and protein-lipid(cardiolipin) interactions. Biochim Biophys Acta 1655: 93–101 Rossak M, Tietje C, Heinz E and Benning C (1995) Accumulation of UDP-sulfoquinovose in a sulfolipid-deficient mutant of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Biol Chem 270: 25792–25797 Rossak M, Schäfer A, Xu N, Gage DA and Benning C (1997) Accumulation of sulfoquinovosyl–1-O-dihydroxyacetone in a sulfolipid-deficient mutant of Rhodobacter sphaeroides inactivated in sqdC. Arch Biochem Biophys 340: 219–230 Russell NJ and Harwood JL (1979) Changes in acyl lipid composition of photosynthetic bacteria grown under photosynthetic and non-photosynthetic conditions. Biochem J 181: 339–345 Sanda S, Leustek T, Theisen M, Garavito M and Benning C (2001) Recombinant Arabidopsis SQD1 converts UDP-glucose and sulfite to the sulfolipid head precursor UDP-sulfoquinovose in vitro. J Biol Chem 276: 3941–3946 Sato N and Murata N (1991) Transition of lipid phase in aqueous dispersions of diacylglyceryltrimethylhomoserine. Biochim Biophys Acta 1082: 108–111 Schmid PC, Kumar VV, Weis BK and Schmid HH (1991) Phosphatidyl-Tris rather than N-acylphosphatidylserine is synthesized by Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides grown in Tris-containing media. Biochemistry 30: 1746–1751 Seay T and Lueking DR (1986) Purification and properties of acyl coenzyme A thioesterase II from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. Biochemistry 25: 2480–2745 Seifert U and Heinz E (1992) Enzymatic characteristics of UDPsulfoquinovose:diacylglycerol sulfoquinovosyltranferase from chloroplast envelopes. Bot Acta 105: 197–205 Shibuya I, Miyazaki C and Ohta A (1985) Alteration of phospholipid composition by combined defects in phosphatidylserine and cardiolipin synthases and physiological consequences in Escherichia coli. J Bacteriol 161: 1086–1092 Sohlenkamp C, de Rudder KE, Rohrs V, Lopez-Lara IM and Gei-
Banita Tamot and Christoph Benning ger O (2000) Cloning and characterization of the gene for phosphatidylcholine synthase. J Biol Chem 275: 18919–18925 Sohlenkamp C, Lopez-Lara IM and Geiger O (2003) Biosynthesis of phosphatidylcholine in bacteria. Prog Lipid Res 42: 115–162 Svensson-Ek M, Abramson J, Larsson G, Tornroth S, Brzezinski P and Iwata S (2002) The X-ray crystal structures of wild-type and EQ(I–286) mutant cytochrome c oxidases from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Mol Biol 321: 329–339 Tsukihara T, Shimokata K, Katayama Y, Shimada H, Muramoto K, Aoyama H, Mochizuki M, Shinzawa-Itoh K, Yamashita E, Yao M, Ishimura Y and Yoshikawa S (2003) The low-spin heme of cytochrome c oxidase as the driving element of the proton-pumping process. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 100: 15304–15309 Van Mooy BA, Rocap G, Fredricks HF, Evans CT and Devol AH (2006) Sulfolipids dramatically decrease phosphorus demand by picocyanobacteria in oligotrophic marine environments. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 103: 8607–8612 Vance CP, Uhde-Stone C and Allan DL (2003) Phosphorus acquisition and use: critical adaptations by plants for securing a nonrenewable resource. New Phytol 157: 423–447 Wakeham MC, Sessions RB, Jones MR and Fyfe PK (2001) Is there a conserved interaction between cardiolipin and the type II bacterial reaction center? Biophys J 80: 1395–1405 Webb MS and Green BR (1991) Biochemical and biophysical properties of thylakoid acyl lipids. Biochim Biophys Acta 1060: 133–158 Weissenmayer B, Gao JL, Lopez-Lara IM and Geiger O (2002) Identification of a gene required for the biosynthesis of ornithine-derived lipids. Mol Microbiol 45: 721–733 White SW, Zheng J, Zhang YM and Rock (2005) The structural biology of type II fatty acid biosynthesis. Annu Rev Biochem 74: 791–831 Wikstrom M, Xie J, Bogdanov M, Mileykovskaya E, Heacock P, Wieslander A and Dowhan W (2004) Monoglucosyldiacylglycerol, a foreign lipid, can substitute for phosphatidylethanolamine in essential membrane-associated functions in Escherichia coli. J Biol Chem 279: 10484–10493 Wood BJB, Nichols BW and James AT (1965) The lipids and fatty acid metabolism of photosynthetic bacteria. Biochim Biophys Acta 106: 261–273 Xie J, Bogdanov M, Heacock P and Dowhan W (2006) Phosphatidylethanolamine and monoglucosyldiacylglycerol are interchangeable in supporting topogenesis and function of the polytopic membrane protein lactose permease. J Biol Chem 281: 19172–19178 Yu B, Xu C and Benning C (2002) Arabidopsis disrupted in SQD2 encoding sulfolipid synthase is impaired in phosphate-limited growth. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 99: 5732–5737
Chapter 8 Peripheral Complexes of Purple Bacteria Mads Gabrielsen, Alastair T. Gardiner and Richard J. Cogdell* Microbial Photosynthesis Laboratory, Glasgow Biomedical Research Centre, 120 University Place, University of Glasgow, G12 8TA, U.K.
Summary ............................................................................................................................................................... 135 I. Introduction..................................................................................................................................................... 136 II. Structure ......................................................................................................................................................... 136 A. The α/β Heterodimer ........................................................................................................................ 137 B. Pigments .......................................................................................................................................... 139 C. Low-light Conditions ......................................................................................................................... 143 D. Organization of Detergents in Crystals of the Light-Harvesting 2 Complex .................................... 145 III. The Biology of Purple Bacterial Antenna Complexes..................................................................................... 146 A. The Role of Peripheral Antenna Within the Photosynthetic Unit ...................................................... 146 B. Synthesis of Peripheral Antenna Complexes ................................................................................... 147 1. The Upper Pigmented Band ................................................................................................... 147 2. The PucC Protein ................................................................................................................... 147 C. Variations on a Theme ..................................................................................................................... 148 D. Have We Only Scratched the Surface of Natural Variation?............................................................ 149 1. Genes of Purple Peripheral Antenna Complexes .................................................................. 149 2. Too Many Peripheral Antenna Polypeptides Make Life Difficult ............................................. 150 3. Nomenclature .......................................................................................................................... 150 IV. Final Remarks ................................................................................................................................................ 151 Acknowledgments ................................................................................................................................................. 151 References ............................................................................................................................................................ 151
Summary This chapter uses the LH2 complex from Rhodopseudomonas acidophila strain 10050 as an example to describe the current understanding of the structure of purple bacterial peripheral antenna complexes. It summarizes both what is and what is not understood. So far the structures of ‘standard’ LH2 complexes, such as those from Rhodopseudomonas acidophila, are rather well characterized. In contrast, there is a dearth of structural information on complexes with more unusual spectroscopic properties. There is also very little information available on how these antenna complexes are assembled.
*Author for correspondence, email: [email protected]
C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty (eds): The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria, pp. 135–153. © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V.
136
Mads Gabrielsen, Alastair T. Gardiner and Richard J. Cogdell
I. Introduction The first committed, irreversible step in the photosynthetic light-reactions is the separation of charge across the membrane. This charge separation event occurs in the reaction center (RC). However, if photosynthesis relied solely on photons that can be harvested by the pigments of the RC then the majority of the RCs would spend most of their time waiting for the arrival of an incoming photon. To get around this problem, sets of pigment-protein complexes have evolved that are able to harvest a far greater proportion of photons striking the membrane and then to pass on this energy to the RC. These pigment-protein complexes, which effectively increase the cross-sectional area available for photon capture, are called antenna complexes. In purple bacteria if the cell is growing photosynthetically, invaginations from the inner membrane, termed the intracytoplasmic membrane (ICM), contain mature photosynthetic complexes. These pigment-protein complexes consist of integral membrane proteins that bind, non-covalently, the light absorbing pigments, bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) and carotenoids. Typically there are two types of antenna complexes. The LH1 antenna complex is intimately associated with the RC and is commonly referred to as the ‘core’ complex. All species of purple bacteria have this core complex. Most species then also have a second type of antenna complex called LH2. The LH2 complexes are arranged more peripherally and funnel excitation energy to the RC via LH1. This funnel exists because the Qy absorption bands of the BChls present within LH2 are at shorter wavelengths (at higher energy) than the corresponding absorption band in LH1. For example, the well known LH2 complex from Rhodopseudomonas (Rps.) acidophila strain 10050 has near infra-red (NIR) absorption maxima at 800 and 850 nm (hence this complex is also called B(bulk)800-850), whereas the LH1 complex absorbs at 880nm (B880). To illustrate this gradient, Abbreviations: (B)Chl – (bacterio)chlorophyll a; AFM – atomic force microscopy; B – bulk; Chr. – Chromatium; DPG – diphosphatidylglycerol; HL – high light; HPTO – heptane-1,2,3-triol; ICM – intracytoplasmic membrane; LDAO – lauryl dimethyl amine-N-oxide; LH – light-harvesting; LL – low light; NIR – near infra-red; PC – phosphatidylcholine; PE – phosphatidylethanolamine; Phs. – Phaeospirillum; PSU – photosynthetic unit; Rba. – Rhodobacter; RC – reaction center; Rdv. – Rhodovulum; Rps. – Rhodopseudomonas; Rsp. – Rhodospirillum; Rvi. – Rubrivivax; UDAO – N,N-dimethyundecylamine-N-oxide; UPB – upper pigmented band
Fig.1. Absorbance spectra of the peripheral, LH2 antenna (solid line) and the RC-LH1 ‘core’ complex from Rps. acidophila strain 10050 (dashed line). The Qy absorption bands of the BChl molecules present in LH2 absorb at 800 nm and 850 nm, hence this complex is also called B800-850. Similarly the Qy absorption band of the BChls in LH1 absorbs at approximately 890 nm (approximately 875 nm in some species). The smaller absorbance bands in the RC-LH1 complex at approximately 800 and 760 nm arise from the RC.
absorbance spectra of purified Rps. acidophila LH2 B800-850 and RC-LH1 ‘core’ complexes have been overlaid in Fig. 1. This chapter will examine peripheral, LH2 antenna complexes from purple bacteria from structural, molecular biological and physiological viewpoints. The biophysical processes involved in light-harvesting will be mentioned only as they relate to an understanding of the structure. The reader is directed to further chapters in Part 3 of this volume for complementary perspectives on peripheral antennas and/or the RC-LH1 ‘core’ complexes and for details of the energy-transfer reactions that take place in the LH2 complexes. II. Structure The structure of the peripheral antenna complexes from both Rps. acidophila and Phaeospirillum (Phs.) molischianum have been solved using Xray crystallography at resolutions between 2.0 and 2.5 Å (McDermott et al., 1995; Koepke et al., 1996; McLuskey et al., 2001; Papiz et al., 2003; Cherezov et al., 2006). The structure described in detail below is the one from Rps. acidophila, strain 10050, solved by McDermott et al. (1995) and Prince et al. (1997) to 2.5 Å and further improved by Papiz et al. (2003) to 2.0 Å [PDB accession codes 1KZU and 1NKZ
Chapter 8
Peripheral Complexes of Purple Bacteria
respectively]. PDB nomenclature has been adopted for designating atoms in the polypeptide chain. A. The α/β Heterodimer The antenna complex is composed of protomers, formed by heterodimers of polypeptide chains, named α and β, and their associated pigments (Figs. 2a–f), which aggregate to form the intact oligomeric structure. The short polypeptide chains (53 and 41 amino acids, respectively) span the membrane, with the N-termini on the cytoplasmic side (Papiz et al., 2003). The α-chain starts with a modified methionine with a carboxyl group attached N-terminally that is ligated to the Mg2+ ion of the B800 BChl (Papiz et al., 2003), followed by a three-residue loop involved in coordination of a BChl a molecule (Prince et al., 1997), giving way to a 310 helix that penetrates the membrane surface. This 310 helix is linked to a seventurn transmembrane helix via a three-residue section. The transmembrane helix is approximately parallel to the membrane normal. The C-terminal part of the α-chain is made up of a short linking section, a twoturn α-helix and an extended stretch (Prince et al., 1997; Papiz et al., 2003). The β-chain N-terminal residues begin in an extended section, followed by a single transmembrane helix, which is curved slightly with an inclination angle of about 15° towards the membrane normal (Prince et al., 1997). Apart from Asp17 and Arg20, which form a salt bridge, the transmembrane helical part of β is made up of hydrophobic residues (McDermott et al., 1995). The C-terminal polypeptides terminate in a short loop. The turns at both ends are exposed to the aqueous environment, and are characterized by side-chain to main-chain hydrogen bonds involving hydrophilic residues (Prince et al., 1997). The α-chains form a tightly-bound ring in the membrane, maintained by helix-helix interactions. The β-chains form a more open outer ring where the distances between the polypeptides do not allow any direct β- to β- interactions (Fig. 2b, 3a). No α/β apoprotein helix-helix interactions occur within the transmembrane part of the complex (Prince et al., 1997). The inner ring is stabilized by hydrogen bonds between the C-terminal part of one polypeptide and residues in adjacent chains, advanced or retarded by one unit. The α/β pairs interact via hydrogen bonds between residues in the N-terminal loops of both chains, but largely through protein-pigment
137
interactions (McDermott et al., 1995). Details of the hydrogen bonding between the polypeptides are presented in Table 1. The B800-850, LH2, complex from Rps. acidophila strain 10050 is made up of nine α/β pairs, forming a double ring with diameters of 36 Å and 68 Å for the inner and outer circles, respectively (Fig. 3a, 4). At the time of writing, three high-resolution crystal structures of LH2s are available; the B800-850 complex from Rps. acidophila strain 10050 (McDermott et al., 1995), the B800-820 from Rps. acidophila strain 7050 (McLuskey et al., 2001) and the B800850 from Phs. molischianum (Koepke et al., 1996). The Rps. acidophila structures are nonamers of the basic α/β-heterodimer repeating unit, whereas the Phs. molischianum structure is an octamer. Electron crystallography and atomic force microscopy (AFM) experiments performed on Rba. sphaeroides (Walz et al., 1998; Scheuring et al., 2003), Rhodovulum sulfidophilum (Montoya et al., 1995) and Rubrivivax (Rvi.) gelatinosus (Scheuring et al., 2001) all confirm that the LH2 complexes from these species are also nonameric, whereas the low-resolution crystal structure of low-light B800 LH2 from Rps. palustris (Hartigan et al., 2002), and the crystal structure of Phs. molischianum (Koepke et al., 1996) (Fig. 3b) both show octameric assemblies. For the first time, one report (Scheuring et al., 2004) has asserted that the ICM of Rhodospirillum (Rsp.) photometricum contains LH2 molecules of variable stoichiometry, with decamers and octamers being present in addition to the majority nonamers (see also Chapter 14, Sturgis and Niederman; Chapter 47, Scheuring). If this work can be confirmed by biochemical purification and spectroscopic analysis of the putative 8-, 9- and 10-mer ring sizes, they will prove an invaluable aid towards understanding the factors controlling ring size. The B800-850, LH2 complex from Phs. molischianum was solved to a resolution of 2.4 Å by Koepke et al. (1996) [PDB accession code 1LGH]. The α- and β-apoproteins from Phs. molischianum have a sequence identity of 26 % and 31 %, with respect to the corresponding apoproteins from Rps. acidophila. The Phs. molischianum structure is built up by protomer units (Fig. 2e) similar to those found in LH2 from Rps. acidophila strain 10050 (Fig. 2d), however, the overall complex is an octamer rather than a nonamer, leaving the diameters of the α-inner and β-outer helical rings as 31 Å and 62 Å respectively (Koepke et al., 1996) (Fig. 3b). The polypeptides of
138
Mads Gabrielsen, Alastair T. Gardiner and Richard J. Cogdell
Fig. 2. Representations of the β/α-protomer building blocks that comprise LH2. The β-chains are shown in black and the α-chains in pale gray. The BChl and the carotenoid are shown in wireframe. The C-terminal regions are uppermost. a) A view of the β/α protomer with the pigments removed. The main BChl liganding amino acid side chains are shown. b) A view of how two adjacent α/β protomers interact with each other, again with the pigments removed. The chains, from left to right, are in the order α, β, α, β. c) Similar to b) but looking down on to the two adjacent α/β-protomers from the C-terminal side of the complex. The β chains are darker than the α chains. d) The same view as a) but with the pigments included. e) A view of the β/α protomer from Phs. molischianum. The main differences between d) and e) are the altered orientation of the B800 bacteriochlorin ring and the different organization of the C-terminal region of the α-apoprotein. f) A view of the β/α protomer from Rps. acidophila strain 7050. Note the different amino acids shown at the C-terminal end of the α-apoprotein that are responsible for the altered absorption properties of this B800-820 complex. The structures shown in a–d) are representations of the structure of B800-850, the LH2 complex from Rps. acidophila strain 10050. See also Color Plate 3, Fig. 3.
the nonameric and the octameric structures are very similar in the transmembrane region, but differ at their ends. The α-polypeptide from Phs. molischianum has a longer C-terminal helix, and this helix is at a greater angle to the membrane-spanning helix compared to the α-chain from Rps. acidophila (140°
and 100°, respectively) (Koepke et al., 1996). The Nterminal 310 helices of the α-apoproteins are similar in structure, despite an important sequence difference in the N-terminal residue of the Phs. molischianum α-chain, which is a serine, as opposed to a methionine in Rps. acidophila.
Chapter 8
Peripheral Complexes of Purple Bacteria
139
Fig. 3. A comparison of the LH2 complexes from Rps. acidophila strain 10050 and Phs. molischianum. a) The Rps. acidophila 10050 nonameric structure viewed perpendicular to the membrane normal with b) the Phs. molischianum octameric structure. The doughnut shape of the whole molecular complex is apparent, with the two polypeptide rings (β- outside, α-inside) darkly shaded and the pigments shown with lighter tones.
Recent computational studies suggest that the difference in oligomerization is based on differences in the interaction angle between two subunits. In theory these are 45° for a ring consisting of eight protomers, and 40° for a ring consisting of nine protomers (Janosi et al., 2006). Modeling how two protomers associate reveals that the free energy profile minimum is located at about 45.2° for Phs. molischianum and at 38.5° for Rps. acidophila. Further, the free energy profiles exhibit a clear angular separation, requiring 5.5 kcal/ mol to force the subunits from Phs. molischianum into the Rps. acidophila angle, and 8.5 kcal/mol vice versa (Janosi et al., 2006). The data presented by these authors suggests that the preferred angle between the subunits plays an important role in the assembly of the complex and at least partly determines the ring size and oligomerization state. The modeling data suggest that the preferred angles between the two subunits are determined by the surface interactions in the transmembrane regions (Janosi et al., 2006). The authors speculate that there is a motif in the Cterminal ends of the Rps. acidophila polypeptides that plays a role in constraining the angle between the subunits in addition to the hydrophobic surface contacts. This double constraint on the angle may explain why nonamers are found more often than other ring sizes (Janosi et al., 2006).
B. Pigments The double ring of α- and β-polypeptides functions as a scaffold for the pigments. There are three BChls a per LH2 protomer, two B850 molecules sandwiched between the polypeptides, and one B800 parallel to the membrane surface (Fig. 2d, 5). The two B850 molecules form closely coupled dimers perpendicular to the membrane surface, so that they are edge on when observed from above (Freer et al., 1996). The intact holocomplex LH2 from Rps. acidophila then consists of a ring of 18 overlapping B850 pigments (McDermott et al., 1995). The primary contact between the B850 molecules and the peptide chains is co-ordination of the central magnesium ion through histidine residues (αHis 31 and the Mg2+ of αB850, and βHis30 and the Mg2+ of βB850) (Prince et al., 1997). The B850 α/β pair has an Mg-Mg separation of 9.6 Å, whereas the adjacent protomer Mg is separated by 8.9 Å (Freer et al., 1996). The closest ring–ring distances are 3.54 Å within the B850 α/β pair and 3.63 Å between adjacent pairs. A hydrogen bond is formed between the C3-acetyl group on ring A of BChl and αTrp45 NE1 for αB850 and (+)αTyr44 OH for βB850 (a bracketed plus or minus sign indicates that the residue belongs to an adjacent protomer). Further, both B850 molecules interact with their respective apoproteins so the phytyl chains are
140
Mads Gabrielsen, Alastair T. Gardiner and Richard J. Cogdell
Fig. 4. The LH2 complex from Rhodopseudomonas (Rps.) acidophila strain 10050. a) A view looking down on the top of the complex from the presumed periplasmic surface of the membrane. (b) A side view looking from within the presumed photosynthetic membrane with the periplasmic side of the complex uppermost. In both panels the LH2α polypeptide is in gray, LH2β is black. See also Color Plate 3, Fig. 4.
directed from the bacteriochlorin plane towards the transmembrane helices, forming hydrophobic interactions with the polypeptides (Prince et al., 1997). The remaining protein-pigment interactions are made up of van der Waals interactions and are detailed in Table 2. The phytyl chain of αB850 makes contact with a number of residues on two α-chains, before passing the edge of the B800 bacteriochlorin ring, making contacts with O1A, O1D and CBD (Papiz et al., 2003). The βB850 phytyl chain forms contacts
with residues on the β-chain, passing over the B800 bacteriochlorin ring of this BChl in the same protomer, forming contacts between the two pigments (Papiz et al., 2003). There are nine B800 BChl molecules present in the antenna complex located approximately 16 Å into the membrane and inserted between the β-polypeptides. These BChl molecules lie in a plane parallel to the membrane surface (Figs. 2b, 5). The primary contact between the polypeptides and the B800 molecule is the co-ordination of the magnesium central ion and the carboxylated αMet1 (Papiz et al., 2003). This modification is supported by several hydrogen bonds donated from the surrounding residues N-αAsn2, N-αGln3 and NE2-βHis12 (Papiz et al., 2003). The C3-acetyl group on ring A forms a hydrogen bond to βArg20 (Prince et al., 1997). The last pigment making up the protomer is the carotenoid, which, in Rps acidophila, strain 10050, is rhodopin glucoside. The glucoside head group is the only part capable of forming strong interactions such as hydrogen bonds, it is, therefore, interesting that the head group seems able to adopt two distinct conformations (Prince et al., 1997). The carotenoid runs in the space between the α and β pairs, in the same region as the phytyl chains of the BChls and is important for the structural stability of the transmembrane units (Lang and Hunter, 1994). The protein-carotenoid and carotenoid-BChl contacts are detailed in Table 3. The carotenoid takes up a helical confirmation, which imparts chirality to the conjugated double-bond system (Prince et al., 1997). This may affect the photochemical properties of the carotenoid (Nagae et al., 1993). It has been suggested that evidence in favor of a second carotenoid can be found in the uninterpreted non-protein parts of the electron density map of LH2, and this has been modeled in the structure solution by Papiz et al (2003). However, a recent structure of LH2 from Rps. acidophila strain 10050, obtained following crystallization using lipidic cubic phases, shows that this density is better explained by a superposition of mixtures of β-octylglucoside and lauryl dimethyl amine-N-oxide (LDAO) detergent molecules (Cherezov et al., 2006) rather than a second carotenoid. The density described in the Papiz structure is most likely, therefore, to be caused by a mixture of detergents binding throughout the crystal, rather than a pigment. This explanation is strongly supported by recent spectroscopic studies, which have shown that there is no second carotenoid present, either in solu-
Chapter 8
Peripheral Complexes of Purple Bacteria
141
Table 1. Hydrogen bonds between polypeptides Residue COO-Met α1
Atom O1
Residue His β12
Atom NE2
Distance (Å) 2.96
COO-Met α1
SD
Arg β20
NH2
3.31
Gly α4
O
Ser β8
OG
2.65
Gly α4
O
Ser β8
O
3.30
Trp α7
N
Ser β8
OG
3.07
Trp α7
NE1
His β12
ND1
3.01
Trp α7
O
Leu β3
N
2.96
Asn α11
OD1
Ala β1
N
2.67
Thr α39
N
Gln (+)α46
OE1
2.85
Thr α39
OG1
Gln (+)α46
NE2
2.83
Trp α40
NE1
Trp (+)α45
O
2.89
Tyr α44
OH
Trp (-)β39
NE1
3.31
Trp α45
O
Trp (-)α40
NE1
2.87
Gln α46
OE1
Thr (-)α39
N
2.90
Gln α46
NE2
Thr (-)α39
OG1
2.88
Lys α50 NZ His (-)β41 ND1 2.86 The (+) represents an adjacent polypeptide in a counterclockwise direction (as seen from the N-terminal side of the complex). The (-) represents an adjacent polypeptide in a clockwise direction (as seen from the N-terminal side of the complex). Modified from Prince et al. (1997).
tion or in crystals of LH2 (Gall et al., 2006). Lycopene is the major carotenoid present in the Phs. molischianum B800-850 complex (Germeroth et al., 1993), with rhodopin as a minor species (Koepke et al., 1996). Although different from the carotenoid found in the Rps. acidophila structure, they adopt a similar orientation, with a minor deviation close to the B850 molecules (Koepke et al., 1996). Some density has been found in the region where the ‘second carotenoid’ has been suggested in the structure by Papiz et al. (2003), but has been modeled as a detergent molecule in Koepke et al. (1996). The BChl binding in the crystal structure of the Phs. molischianum LH2 (Figs. 2e, 3b) is similar to that in the Rps. acidophila complex. The overall complex comprises a ring of 8 B850 dimers, in a circle perpendicular to the membrane surface, and another ring made up of 8 B800 BChls parallel to
the membrane surface. The two apoprotein rings are stabilized by hydrogen bonds detailed in Table 4. The finding that these two hydrogen bonds are confined within an α/β protomer in Phs. molischianum may well be why this complex is more like LH1. The B850 BChls in Phs. molischianum are co-ordinated with the polypeptide chains via the central magnesium ions and conserved histidines (α34 and β35, respectively), with minimum distances between the αB850 and βB850 rings within a dimer of 3.66 Å, and of 3.74 Å to the next protomer. Two tryptophans (αTrp45 and βTrp44) are involved in hydrogen bonds between the C3-acetyl group on ring A of BChl a αB850 and βB850, respectively (Koepke et al., 1996). The binding environment for the B800 bacteriochlorin ring is hydrophilic, in contrast to the B850 binding site. The B800 bacteriochlorin ring in
Mads Gabrielsen, Alastair T. Gardiner and Richard J. Cogdell
142
Table 2. Contacts formed between the polypeptides and the B850 bacteriochlorophylls of Rps. acidophila 10050 LH2 B850 atom αMg
Residue His α31
Atom NE2
Distance (Å) 2.34
αO3
Trp α45
NE1
2.97
αC5
Phe α41
CZ
3.73
αC32
Val (–)α30
CG1
αC71
Tyr α44
αC81
Table 3. Rhodopin glucoside contacts to the polypeptides from Rps. acidophila 10050 LH2. The carotenoid labeling scheme used is that outlined by Freer et al. (1996). Residue
Atom
Ile (–)α6
CA
3.81
4.36
Lys (–)α5
O
3.78
CE2
4.00
Val (–)α9
CG2
3.70
Trp α40
CH2
3.73
CM3
Tyr β14
CD2
3.43
αC88
Ile α34
CD1
3.98
C6
Leu β11
CD2
4.10
αC121
Ala β33
CB
4.14
CM4
Gln (–)α3
OE1
3.54
αC13
Ala β29
CB
3.43
C12
Val β15
O
3.87
αO131
His β30
CE1
3.19
C13
Leu α20
CD2
3.82
Ala β26
CA
3.43
CM3
Gly β18
O
3.66
αC134
Leu β25
CB
3.56
C14
Thr β19
OG1
3.37
αO173
Ala α27
CB
3.35
C15
Phe β22
CB
4.26
αOP
Phe β22
CE1
3.34
C18
Val α23
CG2
3.64
βMg
His β30
NE2
2.34
C25
Ile α26
CG2
3.73
βO31
Tyr (+)α44
OH
2.64
CM8
Ala (+)α27
CB
4.06
βC10
Ile α34
CD1
3.63
Ile (+)α28
CG1
4.02
βC7
Trp β39
CE2
3.43
βC71
Trp (+)α45
CD1
3.54
βC82
Trp α40
CH2
3.98
Thr β37
CG2
4.09
Ala β33
CB
3.88
Val α30
CG1
3.64
βC121
His α31
CE1
3.41
1
βO13
Ala α27
CB
3.51
4
βC13
Val α23
O
3.72
Ile α26
CG2
4.12
Leu β23
CA
3.86
Ala β26
CB
3.28
1
βC12
βO173
βOP Phe β22 CD2 3.48 The (+) represents an adjacent polypeptide in a counterclockwise direction (as seen from the N-terminal side of the complex). The (–) represents an adjacent polypeptide in a clockwise direction (as seen from the N-terminal side of the complex). Modified from Prince et al. (1997).
Rhodopin glucoside atom C4
Distance (Å)
C27 His (+)α31 NE2 4.11 The (+) represents an adjacent polypeptide in a counterclockwise direction (as seen from the N-terminal side of the complex). The (–) represents an adjacent polypeptide in a clockwise direction (as seen from the N-terminal side of the complex). Modified from Prince et al. (1997).
Phs. molischianum is tilted 20° with respect to the corresponding one in Rps. acidophila (Koepke et al., 1996). Furthermore, in Phs. molischianum the B800 bacteriochlorin ring is rotated by 90° relative to that in Rps. acidophila. The carboxylated methionine in the N-terminal sequence of Rps. acidophila is replaced by a serine in the sequence in Phs. molischianum. This sequence difference leads to the central Mg2+ of the B800 BChl molecule being co-ordinated via the OD1 of αAsp6 (2.45 Å) so that the second carboxyl oxygen of αAsp6 in close proximity to the amide ND of αAsn2, creates a strong hydrogen bond between these residues (Koepke et al., 1996). The binding of the B800 molecule is further secured via a water molecule and a contact between NE2 of βHis17 and a carbonyl oxygen on the BChl ring (Koepke et al., 1996).
Chapter 8
Peripheral Complexes of Purple Bacteria
143
Fig. 5. An overall picture of the arrangement of the BChls and carotenoids in the LH2 complex from Rps. acidophila strain 10050. At the top the ring of 18 tightly coupled BChl molecules that give rise to the absorbance band at 850nm can be clearly (dark wireframe). The well separated B800 BChl molecules (gray wireframe) can be seen with their bacteriochlorin rings lying perpendicular to those of the B850 ring. The carotenoid molecules can be seen in an all-trans configuration with a pronounced twist along their long axes.
Table 4. Hydrogen bonds involved in the complexation of Phs. molischianum LH2 Residue Trp α10
Atom O
Residue Ser β6
Atom OG
Distance (Å) 2.50
Leu α11
O
Ser β6
N
2.75
Leu α11
O
Leu β5
N
3.08
Tyr α7
ON
Glu β10
OE2
2.83
Trp α10
NE1
His β17
ND1
3.12
Asn α2
ND2
Gln (+)β19
OD1
3.16
Asn α2
OD1
Gln (+)β19
NE2
3.12
Ser α53 OG Pro (-)β43 O 3.53 The (+) represents an adjacent polypeptide in a counterclockwise direction (as seen from the N-terminal side of the complex). The (-) represents an adjacent polypeptide in a clockwise direction (as seen from the N-terminal side of the complex). Modified from Prince et al. (1997).
C. Low-light Conditions The differences in the spectroscopic properties between the different LH2 complexes must be explained
through differences in their structures. Comparing the B800-850 LH2 complex from Rps. acidophila strain 10050 with the structure of the low-light B800-820 complex from Rps. acidophila strain 7050 (also
Mads Gabrielsen, Alastair T. Gardiner and Richard J. Cogdell
144
known as the LH3 complex), solved by McLuskey et al (2001) [PDB accession code 1IJD], reveals that the overall structures are similar with nine protomers forming a circle. The protomers are composed of an α- and a β-polypeptide as well as three BChl a molecules and when superposed onto α- and β- from B800-850 gives a root mean square deviation of 0.34 Å for all main chain atoms (McLuskey et al., 2001) (Fig. 2f). The B800 molecule is bound to what has been assigned as a formylated methionine residue (McLuskey et al., 2001), but it may be that a higher resolution structure will reveal that this methionine is carboxylated like B800-850 from Rps. acidophila (Papiz et al., 2003). Due to the relatively low resolution of this structure (3.0 Å), the identity of the carotenoid could not be assigned unambiguously (McLuskey et al., 2001). However, previous biochemical studies have shown that rhodopinal glucoside is the major carotenoid present in B800-820 (Gardiner et al., 1993). The residues involved in the contacts to the pigments are detailed in Table 5. When aligning the amino acid sequence of B800850 and B800-820 α- and β-polypeptides are highly similar, and only a few residues differ (Fig. 6). These
residues include αTyr44 and αTrp45 in B800-850, which form hydrogen bonds with the C3-acetyl group on ring A on B850. The equivalent residues in the B800-820 complex are Phe and Leu, both unable to form hydrogen bonds. This leaves the βB820 molecule co-ordinated through its central Mg2+ to a His residue, but leaves the C3-acetyl group and the C131 keto group without any hydrogen bonds. The αB820 is co-ordinated through its central Mg2+ to a His residue, and by a hydrogen bond formed between the C3-acetyl group and αTyr41, leaving the C131 keto group with no H-bond (McLuskey et al., 2001). This lack of a H-bond results in the acetyl group being free to rotate relative to the plane of the bacteriochlorin ring and giving B820 C3-acetyl group torsion angles of 132° and 135° (for α- and β-, respectively,) compared with the equivalent values from B800-850 of –166° and 156° (McLuskey et al., 2001). It is currently believed that this rotation is the major cause of the difference in absorption maxima between the B800-850 and B800-820 complexes. This theory is supported by the results described by Fowler et al. (1992), who performed mutational studies on two C-terminal residues on the α chain of the LH2 complex from Rhodobacter (Rba.)
Table 5. Contacts between the pigments and the residues of Rps. acidophila strain 7070 B800-820 Pigment atom B800 Mg
Residue f-Met α1
Atom OF
Distance (Å) 2.49
B800 O31
Arg β21
NE
3.08
αB820 Mg
His α31
NE2
2.42
αB820 O31
Tyr α41
OH
2.74
βB820 Mg
His α31
NE2
2.43
αB820 C2
(+)βB820
C2
3.95
αB820 C12
βB820
C12
3.52
Carotenoid C26
(+)αB820
C20
3.93
Carotenoid C11
(-)B800
O13´
3.47
B800 Mg
(+)αB820
Mg
17.62
B800 Mg
βB820
Mg
18.35
αB820 Mg
βB820
Mg
9.51
βB820 Mg (+)αB820 Mg 8.97 The (+) represents an adjacent polypeptide in a counterclockwise direction (as seen from the N-terminal side of the complex). The (-) represents an adjacent polypeptide in a clockwise direction (as seen from the N-terminal side of the complex). Modified from Prince et al. (1997).
Chapter 8
Peripheral Complexes of Purple Bacteria
145
Fig. 6. A sequence comparison of a selection of LH2 α- and β-apoproteins. Pal- Rps. palustris, Ac- Rps. acidophila, sph- Rba. sphaeroides, mol- Phs. molischianum. The numbers beside Ac represent the different strains of Rps. acidophila. The Rps. palustris sequences are deduced from gene sequences. Those from Rps. acidophila are all protein sequences, apart from one example labeled (gene). Both the Rba. sphaeroides and the Phs. molischianum sequences are from the proteins. The degree of identity is represented by the intensity of the greyscale. It is noticeable that the gene sequences tend to show C-terminal extensions that are processed away in the mature polypeptides. At present there is no information about how this is accomplished or for what reason. The sequences Pal-PucBb and PalPucAb appear to be anomalous. Whether in fact these sequences do represent a LH2 complex is not yet clear. The sequence differences that result in the absorption shift from B50 to B820 in Rps. acidophila have been highlighted in the box. References for these sequences are given in the text.
sphaeroides, Tyr44 and Tyr45 (in Rps. acidophila, these residues correspond to αTyr44 and αTrp45, respectively). When a single mutant, αTyr44 → Phe, was introduced, the absorbance maximum of the 850 nm band is shifted 11 nm to 839 nm (Fowler et al., 1992). A double mutant, αTyr44 → Phe, αTyr45 → Leu, led to the absorbance maximum shifting 24 nm, to 826 nm, resembling the B800-820 complex from Rps. acidophila. The differences in the Qy absorption bands in LH2 and LH1 create an energetic funnel as described above. These differences are dependent on the environment and the organization of the BChl molecules, where the Qy absorption bands can be shifted from 800 nm up to 875 nm. The arrangement of the bacteriochlorin rings in LH2 is such that the Qy transition dipoles of both the B800 and B850 BChls are approximately parallel to each other, even though their bacteriochlorin rings are perpendicular to each other. The C(3) acetyl group discussed elsewhere in this chapter differs between the B800 and the B850
molecules in that the torsion angle is opposite that of the B850 molecules for B800 (180° compared with 0° for B850). The B800 carbonyl points toward the Qy axis in B800, and the reverse occurs for B850, leading to a slight rotation of the Qy transition dipole in B800 with respect to B850 (Freer et al., 1996). D. Organization of Detergents in Crystals of the Light-Harvesting 2 Complex Crystallization of membrane proteins is dependent on the presence of detergents as these interact with the hydrophobic segments of membrane proteins to maintain their stability and solubility. The packing of detergents around the LH2 complex from Rps. acidophila strain 10050 has been studied in detail using neutron diffraction (Prince et al., 2003). The outer surface of the complex (β-polypeptides) is surrounded by a 15 Å thick band (at maximum) of detergent tails, with the height of the external detergent tails varying between 26 Å at maximum height to less than 10 Å
146
Mads Gabrielsen, Alastair T. Gardiner and Richard J. Cogdell
(Prince et al., 2003). On the N-terminal side of LH2, the detergent tails reach the level of the array of B800 BChl molecules, and the charge distribution from the Arg/Asp ion pair in this region seems to delimit the band, whereas on the C-terminal side the limit is more variable (Prince et al., 2003). Within the LH2 complex a continuous detergent cylinder was observed corresponding to the hydrophobic segments of the α-polypeptides. The height of this detergent cylinder is 40 Å corresponding to full thickness of the LH2 complex. The detergent tails seem to associate with the protein parts in an individual manner and do not appear to be involved in the crystalline lattice, confirming these crystals as Type II (Prince et al., 2003). It is possible that residual phospholipid or the detergent LDAO remains in the micelle. However, these would only be observed if they form distinct volumes within the crystals. Displacement of the observed detergent tails’ match-points for the hydrogenated and deuterated detergent samples suggests that a degree of mixing of detergent/lipid tails, with the major factor in the variation not caused by the presence of residual LDAO or phospholipid (Prince et al., 2003). The central detergent cylinder is consistent with it being filled by two β-octylglucoside micelles fused with the inner surface of the central hole. The interface may contain a significant number of benzamidine molecules (the amphiphile used in the crystal conditions) intercalating with the glucoside groups of the detergent moieties (Prince et al., 2003). In the ICM, this central cylinder would be filled by naturally present phospholipids. In Phs. molischianum density was observed that was assigned to the detergent N,N-dimethyundecylamine-N-oxide (UDAO). UDAO was fitted close to the B850 BChl, in the position where the putative ‘second carotenoid’ was fitted in the structure from Rps. acidophila by Papiz (2003). The amphiphile heptane-1,2,3-triol (HPTO) was fitted in another pocket on the outside of the octamer. Interestingly, within the central cylinder several pieces of electron density were observed, which have been assigned to three HPTO molecules and one detergent molecule. The amphiphile is in direct contact with the protein, whereas the detergent forms a second layer beyond the HPTO molecules (Koepke et al., 1996). It is possible that there is actually a mix of residual phospholipids with the detergents Work has been done on the presence of lipids in Rps. acidophila, strain 10050, from the whole cell membranes and in the purified B 800-850 complex
(Russell et al., 2002). Compared with whole cell membranes, the antenna complex only retained approximately equal proportions of phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) and phosphatidylcholine (PC), together with 15% diphosphatidylglycerol (DPG). However, there were no traces of phosphatidylglycerol (PG) (Russell et al., 2002). Further, the proportions of some of the unsaturated lipids are altered between the whole cell membranes, and the purified B850-800 sample, e.g., 2-OH 16:1 and 18:1∆11 were increased whilst 16:1∆9 was decreased (Russell et al., 2002). There is no information on whether specific residual lipids are structurally or functionally important for LH2 complexes. III. The Biology of Purple Bacterial Antenna Complexes A. The Role of Peripheral Antenna Within the Photosynthetic Unit Through classic experiments with the green alga Chlorella, Emerson and Arnold (1932) were the first to advance the concept of the ‘photosynthetic unit’ (PSU). The PSU has in subsequent years become established to mean the number of interconnected pigments per RC. Over the years a detailed, kinetic, but by no means complete, understanding of the energy transfer events within the bacterial PSU has been achieved; Fleming and van Grondelle (1997), Sundström et al. (1999) and van Grondelle and Novoderezhkin (2001) are useful starting references and interested readers can also refer to the other chapters in Part 3 of this volume (Chapter 11, Robert; Chapter 13, van Grondelle and Novoderezkhin; Chapter 14, Sturgis and Niederman; Chapter 15, Şener and Schulten; Chapter 47, Scheuring). X-ray crystallography has made it possible to obtain high-resolution structural data on the individual components of the PSU. However, what is now needed is a detailed description of the in vivo organization of the PSU. AFM has emerged in the past few years as an extremely useful method for measuring the topology of membranes and surfaces (refer to Chapter 47, Scheuring), enabling the direct visualization of reconstituted complexes (Stamouli et al., 2003; Gonçalves et al., 2005b) in lipid bilayers or the native ICM and its constituent components (Bahatyrova et al., 2004; Scheuring et al., 2006). AFM images, though, must be treated with great caution to avoid over interpretation. Neverthe-
Chapter 8
Peripheral Complexes of Purple Bacteria
less, images now being produced from the laboratories of Scheuring and Hunter are revealing new insights into the long-range organization of the PSU, i.e., the in vivo relationship between LH2 and the RC-LH1 complexes. This point is illustrated by recent AFM experiments on Rba. sphaeroides (Bahatyrova et al., 2004), which revealed for the first time two distinct domains of LH2 present in the ICM. The first forming regions of LH2 (‘energy conduits’) interspersed closely within the rows of dimer RC-LH1-PufX complexes, resembling closely a model proposed in 1976 on the basis of fluorescence quenching experiments (Monger and Parson, 1977), and a second clustered pool of non-associated LH2s (for more details readers are asked to refer to Chapter 14, Sturgis and Niederman). As an aside, interestingly from a historical perspective, these images support strongly the idea that energy transfer within the PSU is a combination of both the ‘lake’ and ‘puddle’ models of exciton migration (Vredenberg and Duysens, 1963). It can be envisioned that the LH2 molecules associated with the energy conduits are ‘puddle’ molecules, those free in the membrane are ‘lake’ molecules but with both functioning in concert to supply excitons to the RC-LH1-PufX arrays. Furthermore, the proposal that there are two distinct domains of LH2 molecules, one relatively invariant in response to changes in light intensity (the rows of LH2 ‘energy conduits’), and the other a variable LH2 pool without the LH1-RCPufX rows. This ground-breaking work has enabled a great stride to be taken towards understanding the native molecular organization of the ICM within chromatophores from Rba. sphaeroides. It is now seems clear from the various AFM studies published from a wide range of purple bacteria (Scheuring et al., 2001, 2003, 2004, 2006; Bahatyrova et al., 2004; Gonçalves et al., 2005a) that the previous assumption of LH2 complexes uniformly distributed within the ICM lipid bilayer is no longer valid. Rather, although the precise details may vary, there are clearly different domains of LH2 complexes and these modulate the energy transfer processes within the PSU and the photosynthetic membrane. B. Synthesis of Peripheral Antenna Complexes It has long been a challenge for biologists to understand the cellular processes whereby a translated polypeptide becomes part of a large, membrane bound, multimeric complex. In the case of LH2
147
complexes, although the apoproteins are very small and traverse the membrane only once, they act as a scaffold to hold the pigments in a very precise orientation. The complex assembly machinery must bring together two different 5–7 KDa polypeptides, α- and β-, three BChl molecules and one carotenoid to form a protomer. The protomers must then be assembled into the intact oligomeric holocomplex. Although all the molecular details of LH2 assembly are far from being understood, two components have been identified as being crucial to this process. The first is the upper-pigmented band (UPB) and the second is a protein called PucC. 1. The Upper Pigmented Band It has previously been shown that when Rba. sphaeroides cells are disrupted a membrane fraction can be isolated from sucrose density gradients which is less dense than the standard chromatophores (Niederman et al., 1979). This membrane fraction has been called the upper-pigmented band (UPB). It contains high levels of BChl synthase, the terminal enzyme of the BChl pathway. Pulse-chase experiments with radio-labeled, newly-synthesized photosynthetic complexes showed that initially they passed through the UPB on their way into the mature ICM (Reilly and Niederman, 1986). Further complementary membrane fractionation experiments and spectroscopic measurements have led to the conclusion that the UPB is the link between the cytoplasmic membrane and ICM. It appears that the UPB represents sites of ICM development (Hunter et al., 2005). 2. The PucC Protein In purple bacteria the structural genes that encode the β- and α-polypeptides are called pucBA and are part of the larger puc operon. Downstream of pucBA other genes have been found whose products have a role in LH2 biosynthesis. Original experiments with Rba. capsulatus showed that in this species the puc operon consists of pucBACDE. In particular it was suggested that the PucC protein is intimately associated with assembly of the LH2 complex (Tichy et al., 1991). PucC genes have also been described downstream from a puc multigene cluster in Rps. acidophila and downstream from pucBA in Rubrivivax (Rvi.) gelatinosus, although in this latter case it does not form an operon with pucBA as the pucC gene is transcribed off the opposite strand (Simmons et al.,
148
Mads Gabrielsen, Alastair T. Gardiner and Richard J. Cogdell
2000). Genes encoding PucC or related proteins have been identified from Rhodovulum sulfidophilum and Rsp. rubrum (Bérard et al., 1989) as well. Deletion of pucC in either Rba. capsulatus or Rba. sphaeroides produces cells that lack LH2 (Gibson et al., 1992). However, at least in Rvi. gelatinosus, other factors are certainly also involved since in this case a PucC mutant has been shown to still be able to produce LH2 under photosynthetic conditions albeit at very low-levels (Steunou et al., 2004). Two additional Rba. capsulatus genes within the photosynthetic cluster, namely lhaA and orf428, have also been suggested to encode proteins with analogous functions to PucC, but which are involved in the assembly of LH1 and membrane located BChl synthesis respectively (Bauer et al., 1991). A sequence alignment shows high similarity between the various PucC proteins (Simmons et al., 2000) and hydropathy analysis predicts that it is probably an integral membrane protein with 12 membrane spanning helices (LeBlanc and Beatty, 1996) as, indeed, is LhaA (Young and Beatty, 1998). The precise role of PucC in LH2 assembly is still unresolved, however it is thought to function in the delivery of BChl to the assembling LH2 complex ( Young and Beatty, 1998; Young et al., 1998). Both PucC and LhaA have homology to other members of the Major Facilitator Superfamily (MFS), a loosely related group of membrane bound secondary carrier proteins that transport a large range of substrates; for general MFS reviews see Pao et al. (1998) and Chang et al. (2004). C. Variations on a Theme In response to growth at high light (HL) or low light (LL) intensities, Rps. acidophila strain 10050 adjusts the amount of the LH2 complex present in the ICM probably in a manner broadly similar to that described above for Rba. sphaeroides. Even at very HL intensities, this strain of Rps. acidophila always synthesizes some LH2 (i.e., the LH2/LH1 ratio never falls below a certain value). As yet no growth conditions have yet been discovered where Rps. acidophila strain 10050 synthesizes any LH2 complex other than B800-850 (Figs. 1 and 7a). However, other strains of Rps. acidophila have been described that are able to produce, in response to changes in growth conditions, different LH2 complexes with altered NIR absorption spectra (Gardiner et al., 1993). Rps. acidophila strain 7750 produces a different LH2 complex in
response to growth at LL and/or less than the optimum growth temperature, while strain 7050 produces its different type of LH2 complex only in response to LL growth (Fig. 7b). These additional types of LH2 complexes have NIR absorption maxima blue-shifted from 850 nm to 820 nm, hence, the complex is called B800-820 (as described above). The carotenoid composition of the 7750 peripheral complexes is rather independent of light intensity, always containing the orange-colored rhodopin glucoside. In strain 7050, however, the carotenoid composition is markedly different in the B800-820 complex. In this case rhodopin glucoside is replaced by the purple colored carotenoid rhodopinal glucoside (Gardiner et al., 1993; Chapter 6, Takaichi). Other species, in addition to Rps. acidophila, also have the ability to synthesize a range of spectroscopically different LH2 complexes in response to changes in growth conditions. Rps. palustris produces a complex at LL with a greatly reduced 850 nm NIR absorption maximum (Fig. 7c) (van Mourik et al., 1992; Gall and Robert, 1999; Tharia et al., 1999). This complex has been called both B800 and LH4 (Evans et al., 2005). Also in response to LL, Chromatium (Chr.) vinosum will produce a B800 complex (Fig. 7d) (Thornber, 1970) and Rps. cryptolactis a B800-820 complex (Halloren et al., 1995). For completeness and rather intriguingly, under extreme selective stress, i.e., deletion of the B800-850 complex, revertants of Phs. molischianum are able to express a B800-820 complex (Koepke et al., 1996). This species had not previously been observed to change the type of LH2 in response to changes in light intensity, so this novel B800-820 complex had never been reported before. Some other species such as Chr. purpuratum only produce a B800-830 complex (Cogdell et al., 1990). The question can be asked as to why some species of purple bacteria, under LL conditions, have evolved an ability to produce a completely different LH2? The answer would appear to be that this complex confers a selective advantage on the cells under these conditions. An indication of the nature of this advantage has been gained from fluorescence excitation and annihilation experiments on Rps. acidophila strain 7750 (Deinum et al., 1991). At HL the ICM contains B800-850 and RC-LH1 with a BChl absorption at 880 nm (B880). Excitons are transferred from the B850 BChl of LH2 to the B880 BChl with a rate constant of 2–4 ps (Hess et al., 1995; Sundström et al., 1999). However, due to a large spectral overlap the ‘back-reaction’, i.e., from B880 to B850, can
Chapter 8
Peripheral Complexes of Purple Bacteria
also occur. This escape of the exciton back into the peripheral antenna is not detrimental to the cell as at HL photons are plentiful. However, under LL conditions the number of photons available is limited and must be harvested efficiently to enable the cell to maintain a competitive advantage. Under LL conditions Rps. acidophila 7050 produces the B800-820 complex. Forward energy transfer is fast and efficient from B820 to B880 in spite of the smaller spectral overlap, however, the energetically uphill, back-reaction from B880 to B820 is much less favorable. The energy jump (0.11 eV) provides an efficient barrier that serves to restrict the loss of the exciton, therefore, after arriving at the RC-LH1 complex the exciton is unable to escape and is retained in close proximity to the RC and so favors trapping. Similar reasoning is thought to apply to the LL complexes present in Rps. palustris, Chr. vinosum, etc. Interestingly, the carotenoid rhodopinal glucoside, which is present in the B800-820 complex at LL from Rps. acidophila 7050 also has an increased light harvesting capability compared with rhodopin glucoside in HL B800-850 (Angerhofer et al., 1986). When studying the types of LH2 complexes that any given species of purple bacteria are able to synthesize, it is important to realize the differences between growing cells in the laboratory under well controlled, standard growth conditions and those which cells will experience in the wild. Natural growth conditions are much more variable and usually less optimal than those we all use in the laboratory. It is probable that we will only understand the reasons for the wide range of types of LH2 when we are able to explore the effects of natural growth conditions on their competitiveness. D. Have We Only Scratched the Surface of Natural Variation? Purple photosynthetic bacteria are recognized as being among the most metabolically versatile of all organisms. Purple non-sulfur bacteria are capable of growth by aerobic and anaerobic respiration, fermentation and anoxygenic photosynthesis. Purple sulfur bacteria have less metabolic versatility but are able to utilize a bewildering number of sulfur compounds as electron donors (Chapter 30, Sander and Dahl). This versatility has ensured that a wide range of ecologically distinct habitats have been colonized by purple bacteria. It follows, therefore, that the total number of species under cultivation in the laboratory are prob-
149
ably only a very small sample of the many species that exist in the wild. Current strategies for isolating purple bacteria from the environment involve ‘enrichment culture.’ This has been a very successful strategy but has the disadvantage that the choice of the enrichment media and growth conditions biases which species grow. Very often when the enrichment conditions are varied new species are found. This is how Howard Gest discovered Heliobacterium chlorum (H. Gest, personal communication) when his technician made a mistake with the standard enrichment media. Some purple bacterial species have already been characterized that require ‘non-standard’ growth conditions such as the thermotolerant Rps. cryptolactis (Stadtwald-Demchick et al., 1990), the halophilic Rhodobium marinum (Hiraishi et al., 1995) and the acidophilic Rps. acidophila (Pfennig, 1969). It is worth bearing in mind, therefore, that our current knowledge about purple bacteria in general and their photosynthetic complexes in particular, is founded on a very limited number of species that, in the main, are those that are easily cultured. We expect that many interesting variations on the ‘standard’ B800-850 LH2 complex still remain to be discovered! 1. Genes of Purple Peripheral Antenna Complexes One would expect intuitively that a LH2 complex containing one α- and one β- polypeptide would be expressed by a single pucBA gene pair. This appears to be the case in Rvi. gelatinosus where one, and so far only one, pucBA gene locus has been identified (Simmons et al., 1999; Steunou et al., 2004). Also where multiple types of LH2 complexes exist multiple puc operons might be expected. It has been known for many years that the genomes of Rps. palustris and Rps. acidophila do indeed contain multiple, additional, copies of the puc operon genes (Fig. 6) (Tadros and Waterkamp, 1989; Tadros et al., 1993; Gardiner et al., 1996). However, there are more gene copies than might be predicted based on the number of types of LH2 complex. There are five different, but highly homologous pucBA gene copies present in the Rps. palustris genome (pucAB-a through to pucAB-e), with their expression differentially regulated by light-intensity. Similarly, Rps. acidophila strains 10050 (Simmons et al., 2000) and 7050 (Gardiner et al., 1996) each have at least four highly homologous pucBA gene copies (not eight in strain 10050 as erroneously reported in Simmons et al.,
150
Mads Gabrielsen, Alastair T. Gardiner and Richard J. Cogdell
2000). The obvious question to ask, therefore, is if a single β/α pair is all that is required to form an LH2 complex then why is it necessary to have so many pucBA genes? Furthermore, if only some but not all of these genes supply polypeptides for LH2 complexes, then why in a fluid, continually recombining bacterial genome under constant selective pressure are so many, apparently superfluous gene pairs, retained by the cell? The complete genome of Rps. palustris has been sequenced (Larimer et al., 2004) so the total number of pucBA gene pairs from this organism will remain at five. However, the estimate of four pucBA gene pairs from Rps. acidophila is almost certainly a minimum number, (as none of the four predicted Rps. acidophila 7050 pucBA-encoded polypeptides has 100% sequence identity with the polypeptides isolated from either the B800-850 or B800-820 complexes) and probably the true number is much higher. Even the superficially straightforward example of pucBA in Rba. sphaeroides turns out not to be so straightforward after all. For many years it was presumed that the pucBAC operon was present as a single copy in the genome. Recently a second pair of pucBA genes has been discovered, designated puc2BA, located on Chromosome 1 at approximately 1.36Mbp clockwise from the original pucBAC operon (Zeng et al., 2003). The puc2B-encoded polypeptide is predicted to have 94% identity with the original β-polypeptide, whereas the puc2A is predicted to encode 263aa compared with the 54aa puc1A-encoded polypeptide (although the first 48aa of the putative Puc2A have 58% aa identity to the original puc1A-encoded polypeptide). The puc2BA genes are expressed and approximately 30% of the wild-type LH2 complexes contain the Puc2B polypeptide. In contrast, puc1A is the sole source of α-polypeptides for the LH2 complex in this species, as neither Puc2A nor its truncated 48aa N-terminal derivative are able to enter into LH2 formation. Furthermore, if puc1B is deleted in-frame, then the ability to form LH2 is strongly reduced. This is a surprising result bearing in mind that Puc2B can be incorporated into the native complex. Interestingly, when the gene sequences for pucA are compared with those of PucA proteins, there is usually significant C-terminal processing (Fig. 6). This means that the mature proteins are always shorter than might be expected from the gene sequences. There is no information as to the mechanism of this process. Why do some species exist successfully with a single pucBA gene pair while others require
multiple copies? At present we only have the question not the answer. 2. Too Many Peripheral Antenna Polypeptides Make Life Difficult There is also a low-resolution (7.5 Å) projection map available for a peripheral antenna complex from Rps. palustris strain 2.1.6 that is synthesized during growth at low-light intensities (Hartigan et al., 2002). This complex has a single BChl absorption at 800nm, hence the B800 (and also LH4) designation. The structure reveals an octameric ring with very similar dimensions to the high-resolution, octameric B800850 structure from Phs. molischianum (Koepke et al., 1996). AFM pictures from LL-adapted Rps. palustris show that the great majority of complexes present in these membranes are octamers (Scheuring et al., 2006; Chapter 47, Scheuring). However, the spectrum presented in Fig. 7c also originates from a complex purified from LL-adapted Rps. palustris membranes yet this spectrum has a pronounced peak at 850nm. Does, therefore, the spectrum in Fig. 7c arise from a heterogeneous population of B800 and residual B800-850 molecules? Or is the Fig. 7c spectrum a homogeneous, true B800-850 preparation, which if over-purified would produce a modified B800 only absorbing form? Perhaps this complex is in fact not a single complex, rather a product of multiple pucBA genes. 3. Nomenclature At the time of writing, there are seventeen species stored by the German Collection of Microorganisms and Cell Cultures (Deutsche Sammlung von Mikroorgnismen und Zellkulturen GmbH, Braunschweig, Germany; DSMZ) for the genus Rhodopseudomonas alone, a number that will certainly grow. There are about ten different genera of purple bacteria in common laboratory ‘use.’As more purple bacterial species are characterized, (hopefully) many more interesting and novel antenna complexes will be discovered. We would like to remind all researchers in the field that just as B875, B890 and B1020 spectral forms are all LH1 complexes that it would be best to consider B800-850, B800-820, B800 and B800-830 all to be LH2s. To us it seems sensible to avoid the confusion involved with adopting the naming sequence LH3, LH4 and so on and to persist with LH1 and LH2.
Chapter 8
Peripheral Complexes of Purple Bacteria
151
Fig. 7. Examples of variable NIR absorbance spectra found in different species of purple photosynthetic bacteria. a) the B800-850 complex from Rps. acidophila strain 10050, b) the low light B800-820 complex from Rps acidophila strain 7050, c) the low light B800-850 complex from Rps. palustris and d) the low light B800 complex from Chr. vinosum.
The spectral form can then be designated separately and everybody will then understand what type of complex is being discussed. IV. Final Remarks A lot is known about the structure of the peripheral light-harvesting complexes and the influence of the structure upon their spectroscopic properties. The protomer of each complex is very similar, regardless of multimer state (Fig. 2d-f). However, much is still unclear, e.g., what decides the quaternary structure, or ring size, of the complex? Is this an inherent property in the α/β dimer, or is it controlled during the assembly process? Can a single complex be formed from a heterologous mixture of antenna apoproteins? Are there LH2 complexes with ring sizes different from the currently available 8- and 9-mers? Future research will be needed to answer these questions. Acknowledgments The authors would like to thank the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council for financial support.
References Angerhofer A, Cogdell RJ and Hipkins MF (1986) A spectral characterization of the light-harvesting pigment-protein complexes from Rhodopseudomonas acidophila. Biochim Biophys Acta 848: 333–341 Bahatyrova S, Frese RN, Siebert CA, Olsen JD, van der Werf KO, van Grondelle R, Niederman RA, Bullough PA, Otto C and Hunter CN (2004) The native architecture of a photosynthetic membrane. Nature 430: 1058–1062 Bauer CE, Buggy JJ, Yang ZM and Marrs BL (1991) The superoperonal organization of genes for pigment biosynthesis and reaction center proteins is a conserved feature in Rhodobacter capsulatus — analysis of overlapping bchB and puhA transcripts. Mol Gen Gen 228: 433–444 Bérard J, Bélanger G and Gingras G (1989) Mapping of the puh messenger-RNAs from Rhodospirillum rubrum — evidence for tandem promoters. J Biol Chem 264: 10897–10903 Cherezov V, Clogston J, Papiz MZ and Caffrey M (2006) Room to move: Crystallizing membrane proteins in swollen lipidic mesophases. J Mol Biol 357: 1605–18 Cogdell RJ, Hawthornthwaite AM, Evans MB, Ferguson LA, Kerfeld C, Thornber JP, van Mourik F and van Grondelle R (1990) Isolation and characterization of an unusual antenna complex from the marine purple sulfur photosynthetic bacterium Chromatium purpuratum Bn5500. Biochim Biophys Acta 1019: 239–244 Deinum G, Otte SCM, Gardiner AT, Aartsma TJ, Cogdell RJ and Amesz J (1991) Antenna organization of Rhodopseudomonas acidophila — a study of the excitation migration. Biochim Biophys Acta 1060: 125–131 Evans K, Fordham-Skelton AP, Mistry H, Reynolds CD, Lawless AM and Papiz MZ (2005) A bacteriophytochrome regulates the synthesis of LH4 complexes in Rhodopseudomonas palustris. Photosynth Res 85: 169–180
152
Mads Gabrielsen, Alastair T. Gardiner and Richard J. Cogdell
Fleming GR and van Grondelle R (1997) Femtosecond spectroscopy of photosynthetic light-harvesting systems. Cur Op Struc Biol 7: 738–748 Fowler GJ, Visschers RW, Grief GG, van Grondelle R and Hunter CN (1992) Genetically modified photosynthetic antenna complexes with blueshifted absorbance bands. Nature 355: 848–850 Freer A, Prince S, Sauer K, Papiz M, Hawthornthwaite-Lawless A, McDermott G, Cogdell R and Isaacs NW (1996) Pigment-pigment interactions and energy transfer in the antenna complex of the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodopseudomonas acidophila. Structure 4: 449–462 Gall A and Robert B (1999) Characterization of the different peripheral light-harvesting complexes from high- and low-light grown cells from Rhodopseudomonas palustris. Biochemistry 38: 5185–5190 Gall A, Gardiner AT, Cogdell RJ and Robert B (2006) Carotenoid stoichiometry in the LH2 crystal: No spectral evidence for the presence of the second molecule in the α/β-apoprotein dimer. FEBS Lett 580: 3841–3844 Gardiner AT, Cogdell RJ and Takaichi S (1993) The effect of growth-conditions on the light-harvesting apparatus in Rhodopseudomonas acidophila. Photosynth Res 38: 159–167 Gardiner AT, MacKenzie RC, Barrett SJ, Kaiser K and Cogdell RJ (1996) The purple photosynthetic bacterium Rhodopseudomonas acidophila contains multiple puc peripheral antenna complex (LH2) genes: Cloning and initial characterisation of four beta/alpha pairs. Photosynth Res 49: 223–235 Germeroth L, Lottspeich F, Robert B and Michel H (1993) Unexpected similarities of the B800-850 light-harvesting complex from Rhodospirillum molischianum to the B870 light-harvesting complexes from other purple photosynthetic bacteria. Biochemistry 32: 5615–5621 Gibson LCD, McGlynn P, Chaudhri M and Hunter CN (1992) A putative anaerobic coproporphyrinogen III oxidase in Rhodobacter sphaeroides II Genetic analysis of a region of the genome encoding hemF and the puc operon. Mol Micro 6: 3171–3186 Gonçalves RP, Bernadac A, Sturgis JN and Scheuring S (2005a) Architecture of the native photosynthetic apparatus of Phaeospirillum molischianum. J Struc Biol 152: 221–228 Gonçalves RP, Busselez J, Lévy D, Seguin J and Scheuring S (2005b) Membrane insertion of Rhodopseudomonas acidophila light harvesting complex 2 investigated by high resolution AFM. J Struc Biol 149: 79–-86 Halloren E, McDermott G, Lindsay JG, Miller C, Freer AA, Isaacs NW and Cogdell RJ (1995) Studies on the light-harvesting complexes from the thermotolerant purple bacterium Rhodopseudomonas cryptolactis. Photosynthesis Research 44: 149–155 Hartigan N, Tharia HA, Sweeney F, Lawless AM and Papiz MZ (2002) The 7.5-Å electron density and spectroscopic properties of a novel low-light B800 LH2 from Rhodopseudomonas palustris. Biophys J 82: 963–977 Hess S, Chachisvilis M, Timpmann K, Jones MR, Fowler GJS, Hunter CN and Sundström V (1995) Temporally and spectrally resolved subpicosecond energy transfer within the peripheral antenna complex (LH2) and from LH2 to the core antenna complex in photosynthetic purple bacteria. PNAS 92: 12333–12337 Hiraishi A, Urata K and Satoh T (1995) A new genus of marine
budding phototrophic bacteria, Rhodobium gen-nov, which includes Rhodobium orientis Sp-Nov and Rhodobium marinum Comb-Nov. Int J Syst Bacteriol 45: 226–234 Hunter CN, Tucker JD and Niederman RA (2005) The assembly and organization of photosynthetic membranes in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Photochem Photobiol Sci 4: 1023–1027 Janosi L, Keer H, Kosztin I and Ritz T (2006) Influence of subunit structure on the oligomerization state of light-harvesting complexes: A free energy calculation study. Chem Phys 323: 117–128 Koepke J, Hu X, Muenke C, Schulten K and Michel H (1996) The crystal structure of the light-harvesting complex II (B800-850) from Rhodospirillum molischianum. Structure 4: 581–97 Lang HP and Hunter CN (1994) The relationship between carotenoid biosynthesis and the assembly of the light-harvesting LH2 complex in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochem J 298: 197–205 Larimer FW, Chain P, Hauser L, Lamerdin J, Malfatti S, Do L, Land ML, Pelletier DA, Beatty JT, Lang AS, Tabita FR, Gibson JL, Hanson TE, Bobst C, Torres J, Peres C, Harrison FH, Gibson J and Harwood CS (2004) Complete genome sequence of the metabolically versatile photosynthetic bacterium Rhodopseudomonas palustris. Nature Biotechnology 22: 55–61 LeBlanc HN and Beatty JT (1996) Topological analysis of the Rhodobacter capsulatus PucC protein and effects of C-terminal deletions on light-harvesting complex II. J Bact 178: 4801–4806 McDermott G, Prince SM, Freer AA, Hawthornthwaite-Lawless AM, Papiz MZ, Cogdell RJ and Isaacs NW (1995) Crystal structure of an integral membrane light-harvesting complex from photosynthetic bacteria. Nature 374: 517–521 McLuskey K, Prince SM, Cogdell RJ and Isaacs NW (2001) The crystallographic structure of the B800-820 LH3 light-harvesting complex from the purple bacteria Rhodopseudomonas acidophila strain 7050. Biochemistry 40: 8783–8789 Monger TG and Parson WW (1977) Singlet-triplet fusion in Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides chromatophores — probe of organization of photosynthetic apparatus. Biochim Biophys Acta 460: 393–407 Montoya G, Cyrklaff M and Sinning I (1995) Two-dimensional crystallization and preliminary structure analysis of light harvesting II (B800-850) complex from the purple bacterium Rhodovulum sulfidophilum. J Mol Biol 250: 1–10 Nagae H, Kakitani T, Katoh T and Mimuro M (1993) Calculation of the excitation transfer-matrix elements between the S2 or S1 state of carotenoid and the S(2) or S(1) state of bacteriochlorophyll. J Chem Phys 98: 8012–8023 Niederman RA, Mallon DE and Parks LC (1979) Membranes of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides: Isolation of a fraction enriched in newly synthesized bacteriochlorophyll alpha-protein complexes. Biochim Biophys Acta 555: 210–220 Papiz MZ, Prince SM, Howard T, Cogdell RJ and Isaacs NW (2003) The structure and thermal motion of the B800-850 LH2 complex from Rps. acidophila at 2.0 Å resolution and 100K: New structural features and functionally relevant motions. J Mol Biol 326: 1523–38 Pfennig N (1969) Rhodopseudomonas acidophila, Sp N, a new species of budding purple nonsulfur bacteria. J Bact 99: 597–602 Prince SM, Papiz MZ, Freer AA, McDermott G, HawthornthwaiteLawless AM, Cogdell RJ and Isaacs NW (1997) Apoprotein
Chapter 8
Peripheral Complexes of Purple Bacteria
structure in the LH2 complex from Rhodopseudomonas acidophila strain 10050: modular assembly and protein pigment interactions. J Mol Biol 268: 412–423 Prince SM, Howard TD, Myles DA, Wilkinson C, Papiz MZ, Freer AA, Cogdell RJ and Isaacs NW (2003) Detergent structure in crystals of the integral membrane light-harvesting complex LH2 from Rhodopseudomonas acidophila strain 10050. J Mol Biol 326: 307–315 Reilly PA and Niederman RA (1986) Role of apparent membrane growth initiation sites during photosynthetic membrane-development in synchronously dividing Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. J Bact 167: 153–159 Russell NJ, Coleman JK, Howard TD, Johnston E and Cogdell RJ (2002) Rhodopseudomonas acidophila strain 10050 contains photosynthetic LH2 antenna complexes that are not enriched with phosphatidylglycerol, and the phospholipids have a fatty acyl composition that is unusual for purple non-sulfur bacteria. Biochim Biophys Acta 1556: 247–253 Scheuring S, Reiss-Husson F, Engel A, Rigaud JL and Ranck JL (2001) High-resolution AFM topographs of Rubrivivax gelatinosus light-harvesting complex LH2. EMBO J 20: 3029–3035 Scheuring S, Seguin J, Marco S, Lévy D, Breyton C, Robert B and Rigaud JL (2003) AFM characterization of tilt and intrinsic flexibility of Rhodobacter sphaeroides light harvesting complex 2 (LH2). J Mol Biol 325: 569–580 Scheuring S, Rigaud JL and Sturgis JN (2004) Variable LH2 stoichiometry and core clustering in native membranes of Rhodospirillum photometricum. EMBO J 23: 4127–4133 Scheuring S, Gonçalves RP, Prima V and Sturgis JN (2006) The photosynthetic apparatus of Rhodopseudomonas palustris: Structures and organization. J Mol Biol 358: 83–96 Simmons AE, Mackenzie RC and Cogdell RJ (1999) Cloning and sequencing of the pucBA genes from two strains of Rubrivivax gelatinosus. Photosynth Res 62: 99–106 Simmons AE, Barrett SJ, Hunter CN and Cogdell RJ (2000) Cloning, sequencing and analysis of the pucC genes from Rubrivivax gelatinosus strain 151 and Rhodopseudomonas acidophila strain 10050. Photosynth Res 65: 69–82 Stadtwald-Demchick R, Turner FR and Gest H (1990) Rhodopseudomonas cryptolactis, Sp-Nov, a new thermotolerant species of budding phototrophic purple bacteria. FEMS Microbiol Lett 71: 117–121 Stamouli A, Kafi S, Klein DC, Oosterkamp TH, Frenken JW, Cogdell RJ and Aartsma TJ (2003) The ring structure and organization of light harvesting 2 complexes in a reconstituted lipid bilayer, resolved by atomic force microscopy. Biophys J 84: 2483–2491 Steunou AS, Ouchane S, Reiss-Husson F and Astier C (2004) Involvement of the C-terminal extension of the α polypeptide and of the PucC protein in LH2 complex biosynthesis in Rubrivivax gelatinosus. J Bact 186: 3143–3152 Sundström V, Pullerits T and van Grondelle R (1999) Photosyn-
153
thetic light-harvesting: Reconciling dynamics and structure of purple bacterial LH2 reveals function of photosynthetic unit. J Phys Chem B 103: 2327–2346 Tadros MH and Waterkamp K (1989) Multiple copies of the coding regions for the light-harvesting B800-850 alpha-polypeptide and beta-polypeptide are present in the Rhodopseudomonas palustris genome. EMBO J 8: 1303–1308 Tadros MH, Katsiou E, Hoon MA, Yurkova N and Ramji DP (1993) Cloning of a new antenna gene-cluster and expression analysis of the antenna gene family of Rhodopseudomonas palustris. Eur J Biochem 217: 867–875 Tharia HA, Nightingale TD, Papiz MZ and Lawless AM (1999) Characterisation of hydrophobic peptides by RP-HPLC from different spectral forms of LH2 isolated from Rps. palustris. Photosynth Res 61: 157–167 Thornber JP and Sokoloff MK (1970) Photochemical reactions of purple bacteria as revealed by studies of 3 spectrally different carotenobacteriochlorophyll-protein complexes isolated from Chromatium, Strain-D. Biochemistry 9: 2688–2698 Tichy HV, Albien KU, Gadon N and Drews G (1991) Analysis of the Rhodobacter capsulatus puc operon — the pucC gene plays a central role in the regulation of LH2 (B800-850 complex) expression. EMBO J 10: 2949–2955 van Grondelle R and Novoderezhkin V (2001) Dynamics of excitation energy transfer in the LH1 and LH2 light-harvesting complexes of photosynthetic bacteria. Biochemistry 40: 15057–15068 van Mourik F, Hawthornthwaite AM, Vonk C, Evans MB, Cogdell RJ, Sundström V and van Grondelle R (1992) Spectroscopic characterization of the low-light B800-850 light-harvesting complex of Rhodopseudomonas palustris, Strain 216. Biochim Biophys Acta 1140: 85–93 Vredenberg WJ and Duysens LNM (1963) Transfer of energy from bacteriochlorophyll to a reaction centre during bacterial photosynthesis. Nature 197: 355–357 Walz T, Jamieson SJ, Bowers CM, Bullough PA and Hunter CN (1998) Projection structures of three photosynthetic complexes from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: LH2 at 6 Å, LH1 and RC-LH1 at 25 Å. J Mol Biol 282: 833–45 Young CS, Reyes RC and Beatty JT (1998) Genetic complementation and kinetic analyses of Rhodobacter capsulatus ORF1696 mutants indicate that the ORF1696 protein enhances assembly of the light-harvesting I complex. J Bact 180: 1759–1765 Young CY and Beatty JT (1998) Structural and functional analysis of the orf1696/PucC family of light-harvesting complex assembly proteins. In: Peschek GA, Loeffelhardt W and Schmetterer G (eds) The Phototrophic Prokaryotes. 113–126 Kluwer Academic Publishers/Plenum Press. New York Zeng XH, Choudhary M and Kaplan S (2003) A second and unusual pucBA operon of Rhodobacter sphaeroides 2.4.1: genetics and function of the encoded polypeptides. J Bact 185: 6171–6184
Chapter 9 Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting Core Complexes of Purple Bacteria Per A. Bullough, Pu Qian and C. Neil Hunter* Krebs Institute for Biomolecular Research, Department of Molecular Biology and Biotechnology, University of Sheffield, Firth Court, Western Bank, Sheffield S10 2TN, U.K.
Summary ............................................................................................................................................................... 155 I. Introduction..................................................................................................................................................... 156 II. The Building Blocks: The α and β Polypeptides of Light-Harvesting Complex 1, and PufX........................... 156 A. Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Studies of Light-Harvesting Complex 1 Polypeptides ...................... 156 B. PufX ................................................................................................................................................. 157 C. The Solution Structure of PufX......................................................................................................... 159 III. Circles, Arcs and Ellipses — The Light-Harvesting 1 Complex ...................................................................... 160 IV. Monomeric Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1 Complexes ......................................................................... 162 A. The Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1 Complex of Blastochloris viridis ..................................... 162 B. The Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1 Complex of Phaeospirillum molischianum ...................... 163 C. The Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1 Complex of Rhodospirillum rubrum ................................ 163 D. Mutant Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1 Complexes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides .................. 164 E. The Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1 Complex of Rhodospirillum photometricum ................... 165 F. Models of Monomeric Core Complexes .......................................................................................... 165 V. Monomeric Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1-PufX Complexes ................................................................ 166 A. The Rhodopseudomonas palustris Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1-W Complex..................... 166 A. The Rhodobacter veldkampii Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1-PufX Complex ......................... 166 VI. Dimeric Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1-PufX Complexes ...................................................................... 168 A. The Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Rhodobacter blasticus Core Dimers ...................................... 168 B. Structural and Functional Roles for PufX ......................................................................................... 170 1. PufX: Core Dimerization and Membrane Curvature................................................................ 170 2. PufX: Membrane Domains, Excitation Sharing and Quinone Sequestration .......................... 172 VII. The Biogenesis of Core Complexes ............................................................................................................... 174 Acknowledgments ................................................................................................................................................. 175 References ............................................................................................................................................................ 175
Summary Reaction center-light-harvesting 1 (RC-LH1) complexes, the fundamental photosynthetic units, are fascinatingly diverse in their aggregation state, with both monomers and dimers found in membranes. Some complexes also contain the PufX polypeptide in addition to the RC and LH1 complexes. Many structural techniques have been applied to RC-LH1 complexes, in order to analyze their shape, variation in conformation, the individual polypeptide structures, and the overall organization in the membrane. Thus, the unique capabilities of cryo- and negative stain electron microscopy (EM), X-ray crystallography, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectros*Author for correspondence, email: c.n.hunter@sheffield.ac.uk
C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty (eds): The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria, pp. 155–179. © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V.
156
Per A. Bullough , Pu Qian and C. Neil Hunter
copy and atomic force microscopy (AFM) have all complemented one another in the analysis of membranes and purified protein complexes, from both wild type and mutated strains of photosynthetic bacteria. However, many unsolved problems remain; for example, the ways in which quinones and quinols exchange at the RC QB site despite the apparent barrier arising from the encircling LH1 complex are still not resolved, and this hints at still unexplored flexibility and dynamics associated with the LH1 complex and with the photochemistry of the RC. Other controversies currently involve the structure, location and function of the PufX polypeptide, and most basic of all, there is still a need for high-resolution structures of core complexes. Finally, the assembly pathways of core complexes are not known. This chapter attempts to convey the diversity of experimental approaches used to investigate core complexes and it summarizes the current state of progress in this evolving field. I. Introduction RC-LH1 complexes are often termed ‘core’ complexes, since, as the name implies, they are central to bacterial photosynthesis. Indeed many bacteria, such as Rhodospirillum (Rsp.) rubrum, employ core complexes exclusively for both light harvesting and photochemical functions, and they dispense with peripheral complexes such as LH2, at the expense of a lowered capacity to absorb light. The complex which is solely responsible for light harvesting in the core, LH1, surrounds and interconnects one or two RCs. The RC, the site of the photochemical reactions which generate quinol for consumption by the cytochrome bc1 complex (see Chapters 22, Berry et al. and Chapter 23, Kramer et al. for reviews of the cytochrome bc1 complex), is not considered further in this chapter as the structural and functional properties of this complex merit an entire section of this book (Chapters 16 through 20). The main purpose of this chapter is to summarize the current state of structural information available for core complexes, starting with the structures of the small repeating units which comprise the LH1 antenna, the LH1 α and β polypeptides, and building up towards the whole core complex. Chapter 10 by Loach and Parkes-Loach summarizes the in vitro reconstitution of LH complexes from LH1 polypeptides. Several approaches for the analysis of core complexes (directed mutagenesis, NMR, EM, X-ray crystallography, AFM) have revealed either monomeric or dimeric structures, depending on the bacterium used, as well as the presence in some cases Abbreviations: 2-D – two-dimensional; 3-D – three-dimensional; AFM – atomic force microscopy; BChl – bacteriochlorophyll; Blc. – Blastochloris; Cryo-EM – cryo-electron microscopy; LD – linear dichroism; LH – light-harvesting; NMR – nuclear magnetic resonance; Phs. – Phaeospirillum; Rba. – Rhodobacter; RC – reaction center; Rps. – Rhodopseudomonas; Rsp. – Rhodospirillum
of additional components such as PufX. The structures represented in this chapter reflect this diversity. The consequences of building a photosynthetic unit from monomeric or dimeric cores are felt at the level of membrane organization; for a discussion of these issues see Chapter 14, Sturgis and Niederman and Chapter 47, Scheuring. However, many uncertainties remain, partly through a lack of atomic level structural data. This is reflected in a number of alternative structural models in the current literature. II. The Building Blocks: The ␣ and  Polypeptides of Light-Harvesting Complex 1, and PufX A. Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Studies of Light-Harvesting Complex 1 Polypeptides Bacterial light-harvesting complexes are composed of α and β polypeptides. The pioneering studies of Zuber and coworkers, who determined the primary structures of antenna polypeptides from a diverse selection of photosynthetic bacteria, revealed the similarities and differences between the α and β components. In general they are relatively short (between 40 and 70 amino acid residues), they possess a ‘three-domain’ structure in which polar N- and C-terminal domains lie either side of a hydrophobic transmembrane span, and they possess a conserved histidine residue which was proposed as the ligand to bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) (Zuber, 1985; Brunisholz and Zuber, 1992; Zuber and Cogdell, 1995). This residue, termed His0, was used as the reference point for numbering all LH polypeptides, so that a residue N-terminal to His0 was designated Trp–10, for example. This numbering system will be used in this chapter. Further analysis by Zuber revealed correlations between antenna type, namely LH2 and LH1 complexes, as well as suggestions for residues that
Chapter 9
Core Complexes of Purple Bacteria
determine wavelength shifts in absorption maxima. This primary sequence information was then used to produce models of the basic αβ unit (Olsen and Hunter, 1994; Zuber and Cogdell, 1995), accurately predicting turns and hydrogen bonding residues. The way in which αβ units formed beautiful circular structures was finally revealed for the LH1 and LH2 complexes by EM and X-ray crystallographic studies (Karrasch et al., 1995; McDermott et al., 1995; see below and also Chapter 8, Gabrielsen et al.). At the time of writing, the LH1 complex has resisted attempts to provide a level of structural detail comparable to that available for LH2, although much progress has been made, and this is reviewed elsewhere in this chapter. However, the small size of LH polypeptides does provide an alternative method for structural analysis, namely NMR. Since LH1 complexes are assembled from multiple copies of small repeating units, the LH1α and β polypeptides, the solution structures of the individual components provide important clues to the structure of the whole complex. LH1β was chosen for the first NMR study (Conroy et al., 2000), because the reconstitution studies of Loach and co-workers (see Chapter 10, Loach and Parkes-Loach, and also Chapter 46, Braun and Fiedor) had previously shown that although a B820 subunit complex (a building block of the whole LH1 complex) could be formed from LH1α and β polypeptides, the β polypeptide alone could also form a B820-type subunit complex (putatively ββ BChl2; Parkes-Loach et al., 1988). The solution structure of the LH1β polypeptide from Rba. sphaeroides was determined in organic solvent (Conroy et al., 2000), the rationale being that structural integrity is generally maintained in organic solvents in spite of removal of the protein from its native environment (Pervushin et al., 1994). The LH1β structure comprises two alpha-helical regions; the N-terminal helix (residues –34 to –15) is suggested to lie in the lipid head groups or in the cytoplasm, and the C-terminal helix (–11 to +6) forms the membrane-spanning region (Fig. 1c). These two helices are connected by a flexible linker consisting of four residues (MSGL) in the –14 to –10 region. A subsequent NMR study of the LH1β polypeptide from Rba. sphaeroides determined a similar structure, but in a detergent micelle, which more closely mimics a membrane environment (Sorgen et al., 2002). BChl binding to the LH1β polypeptides was possible, although the micelle environment did not permit the hydrogen bond known to exist in intact, membrane-
157 bound LH1 complexes between the β Trp+9 and the C2 acetyl carbonyl of one of the LH1 BChls (Sturgis et al., 1997). The micellar environment (Sorgen et al., 2002) accentuated the bend in LH1β, with the N-terminal helix lying along the micelle surface, in contrast to the less ordered ensemble of structures in organic solvent (Conroy et al., 2000). However, it is likely that whatever its disposition in either organic solvent or micelles this N-terminal helix has to accommodate the enclosed RC complex in vivo. This would be the case if the model proposed by Conroy et al. (2000) and refined subsequently (Fotiadis et al., 2004) is accurate (see also section IV.D). One interesting aspect of the helix-hinge-helix solution structure is a possible role for LH1β in allowing rapid quinone exchange. Indeed the projection structure of the RCLH1-PufX dimer complex of Rba. sphaeroides shows a relatively diffuse density for LH1β in the vicinity of the RC QB site (see Section VI), which has been suggested to arise from the flexible hinge region, and which could promote rapid quinol/quinone exchange (Qian et al., 2005). In light of the two NMR studies on the LH1β polypeptide from Rba. sphaeroides (Conroy et al., 2000; Sorgen et al., 2002), the solution structures of both the LH1α and β polypeptides from Rsp. rubrum were especially interesting, given the monomeric nature of the RC-LH1 core complex in this bacterium, and the lack of a PufX component of the LH1 ring (Wang et al., 2005). LH1α was shown to consist of a short Nterminal helix of four residues, then a three residue unstructured loop followed by a long, slightly curved 32-residue helix (Fig. 1a). In the middle of this helix there is the BChl ligand, His0 (corresponding to His29 in the conventional numbering system). In marked contrast to the helix-hinge-helix arrangement found in the LH1β polypeptide from Rba. sphaeroides, the LH1β from Rsp. rubrum is composed of a single membrane-spanning helix of 32 amino acid residues with the pigment-coordinating residue His0 (His38) at a position close to the C-terminal end of the helix (Fig. 1b). The availability of a structure for both LH1 polypeptides of Rsp. rubrum allowed Wang et al. (2005) to propose a model for the αβBChl2 (B820) subunit, the building block of the LH1 complex identified and characterized in reconstitution experiments (see Chapter 10, Loach and Parkes-Loach). B. PufX PufX was shown to be important for photosynthetic
158
Per A. Bullough , Pu Qian and C. Neil Hunter
Fig. 1. Ribbon representation of solution structures of (a) the LH1α polypeptide from Rsp. rubrum (PDB code 1XRD) (b) LH1β from Rsp. rubrum (1WRG) (c) the LH1β polypeptide from Rba. sphaeroides (1DX7) (d) the PufX polypeptide from Rba. sphaeroides (2NRG). The ribbons denote α-helices. Positive and negative symbols denote lysine/arginine and glutamic/aspartic acids, respectively. Glycines are represented by dark shading, and H denotes histidine. Tryptophan sidechains are shown. A suggested position for the membrane is shown, with the darker gray regions showing the lipid head group region and the lighter gray regions representing the hydrophobic core of the membrane. Figure prepared by Richard Tunnicliffe.
growth in a series of deletion and complementation experiments conducted on Rba. capsulatus and Rba. sphaeroides (Klug and Cohen, 1988; Farchaus et al., 1990; Lilburn et al., 1992). However, no such requirement was seen in a mutant lacking LH1 (McGlynn et al., 1994), and a series of papers showed that intergenic suppressor mutants could at least partially compensate for loss of PufX, by altering or destabilizing the LH1 complex so it could not form a barrier to quinol release ( Lilburn and Beatty, 1992; Lilburn et al., 1992, 1995; Barz and Oesterhelt, 1994). A detailed study of the PufX/LH1 relationship revealed that the loss of PufX is only deleterious when the size of the LH1 ring exceeds 20 BChls per RC (McGlynn et al., 1996). All of these observations were consistent with the idea that PufX acted in some way to restrain LH1 from completely encircling the RC, and in doing so, this restraint permitted quinol/quinone exchange at the QB site of the RC (Barz et al., 1995a,b). The PufX polypeptide was suggested to lie adjacent to the RC QB site and to form part of the LH1 assembly (Cogdell et al., 1996). A kinetic study showed that removal of PufX and closure of the LH1 ring created a barrier adjacent to the RC QB site, so that the time taken for quinone turnover increased from ~1.6 to
~3.5 ms, and the time for reduction of the cytochrome bc1 complex by quinol increased from ~7 to ~14 ms (Comayras et al., 2005). However, these slowed reactions are not thought to explain the inability of the PufX-minus mutant to sustain photosynthetic growth under reducing conditions. Instead, these authors conclude that the lack of PufX modifies the RC QB pocket and stabilizes the RC-bound QB– state; this in turn results in an unexpected accumulation of closed RC complexes in the QA– state. In the last ten years in vivo and in vitro analyses have helped to establish the membrane topology and functional roles of the extrinsic and membrane spanning regions of PufX. The PufX polypeptide has a predicted molecular mass of approximately 9 kDa corresponding to 82 residues in Rba. sphaeroides, but there is relatively little homology (29%) between the PufX polypeptides of Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus, despite homologies of between 70 and 80% for LH and RC subunits. Nevertheless, it was found that the Rba capsulatus PufX could substitute for the Rba. sphaeroides protein (Fulcher et al., 1998). The N-terminus of PufX is exposed on the cytoplasmic surface of the cell membrane (Pugh et al., 1998). Mild detergent fractionation revealed that LH1 is essential
Chapter 9
Core Complexes of Purple Bacteria
for the correct binding of PufX to the core complex; however, in the growing photosynthetic membrane the PufX polypeptide is incorporated into the assembling RC-LH1-PufX core complex before the encirclement of the RC by LH1 α and β polypeptides, presumably to avoid obstruction of the RC QB site (Pugh et al., 1998). It was proposed that a RC-PufX-(LH1αβBChl2) complex is formed initially at the earliest stages of the assembly of the core, and that subsequently LH1αβBChl2 units are progressively added to this complex (Pugh et al., 1998). Evidence for a tight association between LH1 α and PufX emerged during attempts to purify PufX from Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus (Recchia et al., 1998). Analysis of purified PufX indicated that C-terminal processing takes place, with 12 and 9 residues missing from the proteins, respectively (Parkes-Loach et al., 2001). Experiments with isolated, chemically synthesized components showed that segments of PufX containing the putative transmembrane segment inhibited the oligomerization of B820 units to form the complete LH1 ring, and that neither the N- nor the C-terminal regions of PufX had this property. Interactions of the glycine-rich transmembrane region of PufX were proposed, firstly with a similarly glycine-rich region within the first membrane-spanning region of the RC M subunit, and secondly with LH1 α (Parkes-Loach et al., 2001). Finally, it has been shown that PufX can bind BChl in vitro, possibly at the C-terminal (residues 60–68) region (Law et al., 2003), or at an alternative binding site involving two glycines at either end of the transmembrane segment (Aklujkar and Beatty, 2006). These authors also propose that PufX modulates the binding of carotenoids to LH1 (Aklujkar and Beatty, 2005). C. The Solution Structure of PufX The small size of PufX makes it suitable for structure determination by NMR. The Rba. sphaeroides PufX was overproduced in Escherichia coli, labeled with 15 N and 13C, and purified. Determination of the solution structure in CD3OH/CDCl3 (1:1) revealed a long α-helical structure of 34 residues with a significant bend of approximately 120° approximately in the middle (Tunnicliffe et al., 2006). A model of PufX shows that the most N-terminal region of PufX is almost unstructured; it contains the site of proteinase K digestion determined in studies of PufX topology in the membrane bound RC-LH1-PufX complex (Pugh et al., 1998). This is followed by a structured helical
159 domain positioned so that Trp and basic residues are at the membrane interface (Fig. 1d), allowing the basic amino acids within the N-terminal part of the helix to lie near the membrane surface, and Trp 22 to play a membrane anchoring role. There is a bent, less rigid, region in the PufX polypeptide in the region of residues 30–35 (GAGWA), and the transmembrane region spans residues 30–52. This positioning of PufX requires that the C-terminal helix, residues 30–52, is almost perpendicular to the membrane plane. The exposure of the PufX C-terminus on the periplasmic side of the membrane is consistent with the observation of posttranslational cleavage, which removes its last 12 residues (Parkes-Loach et al., 2001). It has been shown that PufX can bind BChl in vitro, with a binding site proposed in this C-terminal (residues 60–68) region (Law et al., 2003), The NMR data do not rule out BChl binding in vivo, although there is a lack of obvious candidates for BChl ligands. Tunnicliffe et al. (2006) also titrated labeled PufX with unlabelled LH1 α and β polypeptides, and found that chemical shift changes with LH1 α were much larger, indicating specific binding, in this solvent environment at least. The PufX residues interacting with LH1 α were Val 51, Met 54, Arg 53 and Ile 57, close to the periplasmic end of the C-terminal helix. A subsequent NMR paper proposed a different solution structure for PufX, with no bend in the polypeptide (Wang et al., 2007). PufX is depicted as a long, almost straight helix running from residues 19 to 51 and flanked by disordered, but straight, Nand C-terminal domains, and therefore, somewhat surprisingly, projecting out from the membrane at both ends, with the hydophilic Lys29 within the transmembrane region. A projecting N-terminus has not been observed in AFM topographs of this side of the core complex in native membranes (Bahatyrova et al., 2004). The transmembrane part of this structure is proposed to span residues 24 to 44, which places the glycine-rich sequence GAGWA in the middle of the transmembrane domain, rather than forming a bend near the membrane interface as in Tunnicliffe et al. (2006). This glycine-rich domain is proposed to form a site for quinone exchange between the RC QB site and the external quinone pool. Other consequences of a transmembrane location for glycine-rich GAGWA sequence include a potential for interaction with GXXXG and other dimerization motifs, which is precluded by the bent structure in Tunnicliffe et al. (2006). In fact, PufX possesses a ‘double’ GXXXG mo-
160 tif, and such sequences are known to promote the dimerization of transmembrane helices (Russ and Engelman, 2000). This glycine-rich region is located towards the cytoplasmic surface of the membrane bilayer in Fig. 1d, but in the transmembrane region in the model of Wang et al. (2007). The most obvious role of these glycine residues, if the bent structure for PufX is correct, is to allow a structurally and functionally necessary bend to form between the Nterminal and transmembrane helices (Fig. 1d), but it has been proposed that homodimerization of PufX transmembrane regions drives dimerization of the core, on the basis of TOXCAT analysis (Aklujkar and Beatty, 2006; Russ and Engelman, 1999) and AFM and EM data (Scheuring et al., 2004, 2005; Busselez et al., 2007). At the time of writing, many aspects of the structure and function of PufX are uncertain, and even controversial, although undeniably interesting and important. A more detailed discussion of the structural role of PufX can be found in Sections V.B and VI.B of this chapter. III. Circles, Arcs and Ellipses — The LightHarvesting 1 Complex Moving on from the structures of the individual LH1 and PufX components of the core complex we now discuss the structures of higher order molecular assemblies involving these components, firstly assemblies of LH1 subunits and then complexes of LH1 and PufX with the RC. As noted earlier, Chapter 10, Loach and Parkes-Loach and Chapter 46, Braun and Fiedor cover the assembly of LH1 assemblies using in vitro reconstitution methods. The LH1 complex was first purified from Rba. sphaeroides and Rsp. rubrum (Broglie et al., 1980; Picorel et al., 1983). Subsequent work used lithium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis to fractionate the Rba. sphaeroides LH1 into a series of LH1αβBChl2 oligomers (Westerhuis et al., 2002), estimated to range in size from (αβ)4 to (αβ)13 (Westerhuis et al., 1999). The first structural work on LH1 complexes was performed on the LH1 from Rsp. rubrum, which was found to form vesicular structures spontaneously in solution, which, when examined by freeze-fracture electron microscopy, contained pseudo-hexagonally close-packed 120 Å particles (Ghosh et al., 1990). Further studies on negatively stained 2-D crystals reconstituted from a carotenoidless LH1 from Rsp. rubrum revealed
Per A. Bullough , Pu Qian and C. Neil Hunter pseudo-hexagonally packed ring-like structures with an outer diameter of 120 Å and an inner diameter of 55 Å (Ghosh et al., 1993). dA similar crystal form was observed for LH1 purified from Rhodopseudomonas (Rps.) marina (Meckenstock et al., 1992). In the absence of higher resolution information at the time, it seemed natural to propose a hexagonal ring symmetry for these purified LH1 complexes. However Karrasch et al. (1995) ultimately achieved a resolution high enough to allow the first reliable symmetry determination. 2-D crystals of LH1 from a strain of Rsp. rubrum containing wild-type carotenoids were reconstituted from detergent-solubilized protein complexes with a synthetic phospholipid, dioleoyl-9, 10-phosphatidylcholine (DOPC). Frozen hydrated samples were analyzed by cryo-EM and a projection map was calculated to 8.5 Å. The map showed 16 subunits in a 116 Å diameter ring with a 68 Å hole in the center (Fig. 2a). These dimensions are sufficient to incorporate a single RC in vivo. Within each subunit, densities for the α- and the β-polypeptide chains were clearly resolved, and the density for the BChl could be assigned. The inner face of the ring shows 16 very large densities separated by ~15 Å. These peaks have the appearance of α-helices viewed end on, and indeed a significant proportion (40%) of the two polypeptide chains had been predicted to be in an α-helical conformation with the helices lying roughly perpendicular to the membrane plane. The outer face of the ring consists of 16 peaks of density separated from each other by ~20 Å and from the inner peaks by ~15 Å. These peaks represent the projected α-helical density from the second polypeptide chain. Between the inner and outer rings of the peaks lies a third ring of densities, the smallest density of the three sets and lying 11 Å away from both the inner and outer peaks. It is likely that some of this central density represents an edge-on view of a pair of BChl a molecules bound between the inner and outer helices (Fig. 2a). The apparently closed ring structure raised questions about the mechanism of quinone transfer between the RC and the spatially distant cytochrome bc1 complex during cyclic electron transport. It was suggested that breathing motions of the LH1 ring might allow transient opening for quinone passage (Walz and Ghosh, 1997), and indeed there was clear evidence of flexibility in LH1 with Karrasch et al. (1995) observing LH1 rings with varying degrees of ellipticity. Furthermore, subsequent AFM analysis of individual LH1 rings from Rba. sphaeroides was not
Chapter 9
Core Complexes of Purple Bacteria
161
Fig. 2. Projection maps of the potential distribution within 2-D crystals of photosynthetic complexes of Rsp. rubrum. Lighter regions of density represent the protein. The circle diameter is approximately 110 Å. (a) projection of LH1 showing inner and outer rings of α-helical densities sandwiching density arising partly from the BChl (Karrasch et al., 1995) (b) RC-LH1 complex in a tetragonal crystal form, showing a central complex of LH1 subunits surrounding a 16-fold averaged density for the RC. Segments of neighboring complexes within the crystal can also be seen (Jamieson et al., 2002) (c) RC-LH1 in an orthorhombic crystal form, again showing a central complex surrounded by segments from neighboring complexes. The small deviation of the LH1 subunits from a perfect circle can be seen. The RC density is only two-fold averaged in this crystal form (Jamieson et al., 2002).
dependent on averaging of multiple images, unlike cryoEM; this explicitly demonstrated for the first time an extraordinary variety of shapes and sizes adopted by LH1 (Bahatyrova et al., 2004b), only hinted at by Karrasch et al. (1995). Although this AFM work was performed on Rba. sphaeroides LH1 complexes (Fig. 3) the particular LH1-only strain used in this study did not contain the pufX gene, and thus the complex was analogous to the LH1 complex from Rsp. rubrum or Blastochloris (Blc.) viridis. In contrast to LH1, Bahatyrova and co-workers (Bahatyrova et al., 2004b) could find no similar pliability in the LH2 complex of Rba. sphaeroides and they suggested that this reflected differences in the arrangement of H-bonds between the C-terminal regions of LH complexes and the C2 acetyl carbonyls of the bound BChl. The effect is that each αβBChl2 unit within LH1 has a certain degree of autonomy within the complex. Indeed, in a detergent environment, LH1 can be disassembled into individual αβBChl2 units (B820) (Miller et al., 1987). It can also be fractionated into a series of oligomers varying in size from 2–3 to 10–11 αβBChl2 units (Westerhuis et al., 2002). LH1 can also assemble in vitro from its constituent αβBChl2 units (Miller et al., 1987) and indeed the 16-fold LH1 ring imaged by Karrasch et al. (1995) was constructed from solubilized αβBChl2 units. The work of Bahatyrova et al. (2004b) demonstrated that the linkage between adjacent αβBChl2 units is flexible and even breakable at room temperature in a detergent-free membrane bilayer (Fig. 3). This makes the argument for the transient opening and closing of LH1 units as a means for quinone exchange additionally appealing. A recent steered molecular dynamics
Fig. 3. (a) Schematic diagram of an αβBChl2 unit, depicted as a building block of the LH1 complex in (b). The four panels show high magnification AFM topographs of individual LH1 complexes prepared from an LH1-only mutant of Rba. sphaeroides (Bahatyrova et al., 2004b).
simulation of quinone shuttling across a ‘closed’ LH1 boundary calculated that this diffusion process took ~8 × 10–3 s (Aird et al., 2007), a timescale compatible with known turnover rates determined for PufX– RCLH1 complexes (Comyras et al., 2005). To date, there is no high-resolution 3-D structure for
162 an LH1 ring. This is partly a reflection of the flexibility of the complex making it difficult to grow large, well ordered crystals for X-ray diffraction. Attempts have been made to determine the 3-D structure of LH1 from Rsp. rubrum by cryo-EM of tilted 2-D crystals. However difficulties in indexing Fourier transforms of the images from tilted crystals are likely to make this impractical. IV. Monomeric Reaction Center-LightHarvesting 1 Complexes A number of low-resolution electron microscopic studies have shown that the RC forms an intimate complex with LH1 (Miller, 1982; Stark et al., 1984; Engelhardt et al., 1986; Meckenstock et al., 1992; Boonstra et al., 1994; Walz et al., 1998; Jungas et al., 1999; Siebert et al., 2004). Based on higher resolution data from ice-embedded samples, Karrasch et al. (1995) proposed that one RC can be accommodated within the 16-fold LH1 ring of Rsp. rubrum. However, the LH1 crystals in this study were reconstituted from detergent-solubilized αβ subunits, raising the question of whether the intact LH1 antenna surrounding the RC really forms a complete, circular ring of 16 subunits in vivo. A. The Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1 Complex of Blastochloris viridis The earliest detailed analysis of electron micrographs was performed on photosynthetic membranes from Blc. viridis, which appeared to contain hexagonally close-packed photoreceptor units (Welte and Kreutz, 1982). Miller (1982) determined the 3-D structure of this RC-LH1 complex at low resolution by EM and Fourier analysis of images of natural 2-D crystals embedded in negative stain. A large central structure was revealed to protrude from both surfaces of the membrane apparently surrounded by six smaller centers of mass. It was proposed that this represented a RC surrounded by light-harvesting BChl-protein complexes. It should be noted, however, that the interpretation of low resolution images of close-packed arrays of RC-LH1 complexes to show six-fold or 12-fold symmetry within the LH1 ring has largely arisen from the tendency of many such complexes to adopt a pseudo-hexagonal packing arrangement. In cases where higher resolution was achievable,
Per A. Bullough , Pu Qian and C. Neil Hunter subsequent work has without exception revealed the true symmetry to be higher. Stark and co-workers extended the resolution achieved by Miller (Stark et al., 1984). They undertook an electron crystallographic and heavy metal shadowing analysis of membranes treated with the detergent Triton X-100. These workers characterized the photoreceptor unit as consisting of a central core extending through the membrane and protruding on the periplasmic side by ~40 Å. The core was proposed to be surrounded by a ring of 12 subunits giving a diameter of ~120 Å on the cytoplasmic side and ~100 Å on the periplasmic side. Scheuring et al. (2003) presented high-resolution AFM topographs of the photosynthetic core complex in native Blc. viridis membranes (For a review of the AFM of this and other core complexes, see Chapter 47, Scheuring). The topographs of Blc. viridis membranes at 10 Å lateral and ~1 Å vertical resolution revealed a single RC surrounded by a closed ellipsoidal ring of 16 LH1 subunits. The LH1 subunits rearranged into a circle after removal of the RC from the core complex using the AFM tip. Protrusions from the membrane surface of ~48 Å in height were interpreted as being the tetraheme cytochrome subunit suggesting that only the periplasmic surface was exposed to the AFM tip. Given that the samples were grown by fusion of smaller membrane fragments this implies that fusion always took place between identically oriented membranes. Removal of the putative tetraheme cytochrome subunit led to a change of height, resulting in an RC–LH1 complex protruding ~15 Å from the membrane bilayer. Removal of the tetraheme cytochrome–RC complex led to an empty LH1 ring complex protruding ~7 Å and forming a closed circle with an ~100 Å top diameter. The particles from Blc. viridis appeared to have 16fold rotational symmetry as previously shown for Rsp. rubrum (Karrasch et al., 1995; Jamieson et al., 2002). Scheuring and coworkers proposed that the RC had a ‘noncentered’ location within the LH1 (Scheuring et al., 2003). However unlike cryoEM, AFM does not reveal the internal structure of the transmembrane domain of the RC (the L and M subunits) and this finding is somewhat at odds with the conclusions of Jamieson et al. (2002) working on Rsp. rubrum using cryoEM. However, as had previously been shown the LH1 complex can adopt an ellipticity of between 5% and 10% in the presence of RC, indicating a likely flexibility in the LH1 ring (Jamieson et al., 2002).
Chapter 9
Core Complexes of Purple Bacteria
B. The Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1 Complex of Phaeospirillum molischianum The structures of two types of isolated light-harvesting antenna complexes from Phs. molischianum were studied by EM and image analysis (Boonstra et al., 1994). For the RC-LH1 complexes, two distinct projections were obtained, namely top and side views. The RC-LH1 complex formed an almost circular particle with a diameter in the plane of the membrane of about 110 Å. It was suggested that a complex consists of a RC surrounded by most likely 12 LH1 subunits. An asymmetrical protrusion was seen in side views, consisting of the cytochrome subunit giving the RC an apparent height of ~115 Å. The cytochrome subunit was not lost during the purification procedure, which suggests a similar mode of binding to that seen in Blc. viridis (Deisenhofer et al., 1985). The core complexes appeared to have a larger diameter on the periplasmic side and a smaller diameter on the cytosolic side, suggesting that the LH1 subunits are tilted relative to the membrane plane. Gonçalves et al. (2005) obtained AFM images of native membranes allowing the calculation of averages of the photosynthetic complexes using single particle alignment procedures (see also Chapter 47, Scheuring). The LH1 assembly appeared slightly elliptical, with long and short axes of 95 ± 3 Å and 85 ± 3 Å, although the authors do not explicitly state which side of the molecule was viewed. Nevertheless, this clearly showed the LH1 completely surrounding the RC, but the resolution was insufficient to determine the number of LH1 subunits; the authors speculated that it would be 16. C. The Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1 Complex of Rhodospirillum rubrum 8.5 Å resolution projection structures of the Rsp. rubrum RC-LH1 complex (Figs. 2b and c) were determined from two crystal forms by cryo-EM (Jamieson et al., 2002). Cryo-EM probed the internal structure of the complex as opposed to the essentially surface views revealed by AFM and negative stain EM. The projection maps were sufficiently detailed to clearly show, for the first time in any species, 16 LH1 subunits arranged in a closed ring around the central RC density. The rotational power spectrum of the tetragonal crystal form showed an unambiguous 16-fold symmetry; no significant difference was observed between the densities representing the crys-
163 tallographically independent LH1 subunits, leading to the conclusion that the RC is surrounded by 16 identical protein subunits (Fig. 2c). In maps of both crystal forms, the area enclosed within the LH1 ring was occupied by significant density corresponding to the RC, as proposed by earlier workers for RC-LH1 complexes from a number of species (Miller, 1982; Stark et al., 1984; Engelhardt et al., 1986; Boonstra et al., 1994; Karrasch et al., 1995; Walz and Ghosh, 1997; Stahlberg et al., 1998; Walz et al., 1998). Tetragonal crystals from a carotenoidless mutant had previously been reported by Walz and Ghosh (1997) and Stahlberg et al. (1998); by treating RC-LH1 complexes in negatively stained crystals as single particles, they showed that individual RCs adopted one of four possible orientations with respect to the crystal axes. This could account for the four-fold symmetry seen in the analysis of one of the crystal forms found by Jamieson et al. (2002). Although the resolution was higher, their strictly crystallographic approach to the image analysis necessarily resulted in the superposition of all RCs in these four possible orientations to give an apparent four-fold symmetry. However, the rotational power spectrum of the RC density at higher radius, in addition to showing a four-fold component, showed an even stronger 16fold harmonic, suggesting that there must also be a 16-fold symmetry to the RC density. This implied a propensity of the RC to adopt up to 16 discrete orientations thereby suggesting that there must be a specific interaction binding the RC within the 16fold LH1 ring. An analysis of a second, orthorhombic, crystal form by Jamieson et al. (2002) indicated only two major orientations for the RC. The structure of this orthorhombic form clearly demonstrated for the first time the ability of the LH1 ring to adopt circular and elliptical conformations (Fig. 2c). The LH1 ring could clearly distort to pack round the RC, when subjected to external packing constraints in this orthorhombic crystal lattice. Jamieson et al. modeled this two-fold symmetric RC density using atomic coordinates derived from the Rba. sphaeroides RC structure. The long axis of the RC model coincides approximately with the major axis of the elliptical LH1 ring. The pseudo two-fold axis of the RC running through the Fe and between the ‘special pair’ of BChls lies within 2−3 Å of the crystallographic two-fold axis. With the uncertainties that arise from calculating model density at low resolution in such a complex environment of lipid, protein, pigment and glucose, the uncertainty
164 in orientation must be at least ±3°. However, within this degree of uncertainty, the planes of the BChl porphyrin rings make an angle of ~43° with the major axis of the LH1 ring. Within the membrane, the only RC transmembrane helices that could interact with the putative LH1 α-helices would be LA, MA and possibly LB and MB; all other helices are much further than 10 Å from their nearest LH1 neighbors. This would be consistent with a helix−helix packing arrangement of LA and MA against nearest-neighbor LH1 α-subunits. This type of packing is also observed in the higher resolution X-ray structure of the core complex of Rps. palustris between LA and its nearest LH1 α-subunit (Roszak et al., 2003). One difference between the RC-LH1 complex of Rsp. rubrum and core complexes from other bacteria is that the BChl macrocycle is esterified with geranylgeraniol, instead of the phytol found elsewhere. Phytol or geranylgeraniol constitute ~30% of the molecular mass of the pigment, and play a significant structural role in assembly and stability of the core complex. Rsp. rubrum is now known to harbor a mutation in the bchP gene, preventing the final step of BChl biosynthesis, which converts geranylgeraniol to phytol (Addlesee and Hunter, 2002). This lost function was restored to Rsp. rubrum by transferring the bchP gene from Rba. sphaeroides, and this new RC-LH1 core complex was purified and reconstituted into wellordered 2-D crystals with a p4212 plane group (Qian et al., 2003). Although interesting differences were observed in the carotenoid content and spectroscopic properties of the complex, a projection map calculated to 9 Å showed that a 16-subunit LH1 ring was present in the mutant that surrounds the RC, as found for the wild type complex (Jamieson et al., 2002). The projection maps appeared to confirm the proposal by Karrasch et al. (1995) that the RC is indeed completely enclosed by 16 identical LH1 subunits. Thus the mechanism of quinone transfer remained unclear. In the absence of any evidence for a ‘quinone channel’ or fixed opening in the LH1 ring, the alternative possibilities of a close approach of quinone molecules either side of the LH1 or ‘breathing motions’ in LH1 must be entertained, at least for quinone transfer in Rsp. rubrum and probably for all monomeric RC-LH1 complexes, most of which are likely to contain ~16 LH1 subunits. Certainly, the LH1 is not a rigid assembly, as shown by the circular and elliptical forms found in this study and that of Scheuring et al. (2003) and in work on LH1 complexes in the absence of the RC (Bahatyrova et al., 2004b).
Per A. Bullough , Pu Qian and C. Neil Hunter As mentioned earlier, a recent molecular dynamics study demonstrated that diffusion of quinone through an LH1 assembly is feasible (Aird et al., 2007). The Rsp. rubrum core complex has so far defied all attempts at growing diffraction quality crystals for X-ray work. Moreover, attempts at imaging and analysis of 2-D crystals in three dimensions have encountered the same problems as Rsp. rubrum LH1 (see above, Qian, Hunter and Bullough, unpublished). In an alternative approach to visualizing the 3-D structure, high-resolution atomic force microscopy (AFM) was used to image 2-D crystals of the RC-LH1 complex (Fotiadis et al., 2004). The AFM topographs showed that the RC-LH1 complex is ~94 Å in height, the RC-H subunit protrudes from the cytoplasmic face of the membrane by 40 Å, and it sits 21 Å above the highest point of the surrounding LH1 ring (Fig. 4.a and g). In contrast, the RC on the periplasmic side is at a lower level than LH1, which protrudes from the membrane by 12 Å, roughly comparable with the equivalent height measured for Blc. viridis (Scheuring et al., 2003). Remarkably, in this exceptionally high resolution AFM study, two distinct rings, one for LH1α and the other for LH1β, could be seen (Fig. 4c). AFM imaging demonstrated the general ellipticity of the LH1 ring at the cytoplasmic and periplasmic sides of the membrane, in both the presence and absence of the RC. However, the RC-LH1 complex was seen to adopt an irregular shape in regions of uneven packing forces in the crystals, reflecting a likely flexibility in the natural membrane and which might indeed be functionally important for allowing the export of quinol. D. Mutant Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1 Complexes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides Wild-type RC-LH1 complexes from Rba. sphaeroides RC-LH1 contain an additional polypeptide, PufX, which promotes the formation of dimeric RC-LH1 complexes (see below). The present discussion will be restricted to RC-LH1 complexes from mutant strains of Rba. sphaeroides that assemble monomeric RC-LH1 complexes. The earliest negative stain EM study was carried out by Walz et al. (1998) on 2-D crystals reconstituted from RC-LH1 complexes, purified from an LH2-minus, PufX-minus strain of Rba. sphaeroides, which appeared to contain roughly circular LH1 rings completely surrounding the RC. At this resolution (~30 Å) the RC appeared to adopt random orientations with respect to the crystal lattice.
Chapter 9
Core Complexes of Purple Bacteria
165
Fig. 4. (a) High-resolution AFM topograph of a single molecule of the Rsp. rubrum RC-LH1 complex. (b) Topograph of a complex lacking the RC-H subunit, showing underlying L and M subunits, (c) topograph of a complex with no central RC complex, showing only the LH1 ring. (d) Tilted representation of the RC-LH1 complex of Rsp. rubrum. The RC is the Rba. sphaeroides homolog (1M3X) structure, surrounded by the LH1 complex, which was modeled on the LH1αβ dimer from Conroy et al. (2000) and fitted to the EM projection map of the Rsp. rubrum RC-LH1 complex in Jamieson et al. (2002). (e) Tilted view of the RC-LH1 complex with no RC-H subunit. (f) Tilted view of the LH1 complex with no RC. (g) Side view of the complex. The relative heights of the RC and LH1 complexes and their positions in the membrane were obtained from the AFM data in Fotiadis et al. (2004). HG is the head group region of the membrane, and HC represents the hydrophobic core region of the lipids. The dimensions of the complex and membrane bilayer are indicated in Å. (h) Side view, showing the positions of RC and LH1 BChl cofactors, and their location with respect to the membrane bilayer.
Native membranes isolated from such a strain were shown to contain closely-packed hexagonal arrays of monomeric RC-LH1 complexes, reminiscent of those naturally found in wild-type Blc. viridis, which also lacks a PufX analog (Siebert et al., 2004). In fact, mutants of the core complex date back to early studies of bacterial photosynthesis in the 1960s by Clayton, who isolated a carotenoid-less mutant, R26 (LH2-minus, LH1-RC), which played a pivotal role in the development of the reaction center concept, and which facilitated the subsequent purification and crystallization of the RC complex (Clayton and Smith, 1960; Clayton, 1962, Clayton and Wang, 1971; Feher, 1971; Allen et al., 1987). This is just one example, and the topic of mutant core complexes is too large to be adequately reviewed here, but from a purely structural point of view it is interesting to note that it is possible to generate a series of mutants with decreasing ratios of LH1 BChls per RC. Starting from 29 LH1 BChls/RC in the wild-type core complex, progressive deletion of between 5 and 16 residues from the C-terminus of LH1 α yielded gradually diminished core complexes, eventually with only 10–11 LH1 BChls/RC for the largest deletion. The effect was to create a permanent gap for quinone exchange, so that PufX was no longer necessary. A threshold level of LH1/RC BChls was found, so that when there were fewer than 20 LH1 BChls per RC (about 10 αβ-units) there was no requirement for PufX (McGlynn et al., 1996).
E. The Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1 Complex of Rhodospirillum photometricum Scheuring and Sturgis (2005) imaged the cytoplasmic membrane surface of intact chromatophores from Rsp. molischianum; large elliptical shapes were identified as core complexes. The LH1 array of the core complex was found to form a closed ellipse of 16 LH1 subunits surrounding a single RC reminiscent of that observed in Blc. viridis (Scheuring et al., 2003) and Rsp. rubrum (Jamieson et al., 2002). A recent review summarizes the AFM data on a variety of core complexes from photosynthetic bacteria (Scheuring, 2006). Additional information can be found in Chapter 14, Sturgis and Niederman, and Chapter 47, Scheuring. F. Models of Monomeric Core Complexes Early attempts to model the LH1 ring involved creation of a ‘generic’ model of LH1 using the atomic coordinates of the αβ-pairs of LH2 from Rps. acidophila as a framework and building them into a 16-fold ring (Papiz et al., 1996). Subsequently, the LH1 complex of Rba. sphaeroides was modeled computationally as a hexadecamer of αβ-heterodimers, based on a close homology of the heterodimer to that of LH2 of Rsp. molischianum (Hu and Schulten, 1998). The resulting structure yielded a projection map showing good general agreement with the experimentally determined projection map of LHI from Rsp. rubrum (Karrasch et al., 1995).
166 A 3-D model of the RC-LH1 complex is shown in Fig. 4g, which is based on a number of experimental inputs. The lateral positions of the LH1 polypeptides are based on the cryo-EM data (Jamieson et al., 2002) and the vertical positions are taken from the AFM height measurements (Fotiadis et al., 2004). The LH1β structure is taken from the NMR data on this polypeptide (Conroy et al., 2000), and the LH1α structure is based on LH2α from the structure of the Phs. molischianum LH2 complex (Koepke et al., 1996). The reason for this was the similarity of the LH polypeptides of this complex to LH1, rather than LH2 sequences (Germeroth et al., 1993). The sequence of the Rba. sphaeroides LH1α was interpolated into this structure and additional constraints for the BChl binding sites and turns in the C-terminal regions were provided from site directed mutagenesis and resonance Raman studies of the Rba. sphaeroides LH1 complex (Olsen et al., 1994, 1997; Sturgis et al., 1997). In this model there are two belts of aromatic residues for the LH1 complex, which coincide with the measured position of the membrane interface (Fig. 4g). The positive belts of surface charges on both the cytoplasmic and periplasmic sides are in a position to interact with the lipid phosphate groups (Fotiadis et al., 2004). In Fig. 4h it can also be seen that the special pair BChls are located in the hydrophobic core of the membrane. The Fe atom on the cytoplasmic side of the complex lies just outside the head group region of the membrane. The ring of LH1 BChls falls into alignment with the special pair BChls of the RC, in such a way that excitation energy could transfer along a horizontal plane from LH1 to the RC special pair BChls, as suggested by Hunter et al. (1989). However, in the absence of sufficient experimental data, the more detailed features of all such models should be viewed with some caution. V. Monomeric Reaction Center-LightHarvesting 1-PufX Complexes A. The Rhodopseudomonas palustris Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1-W Complex The highest resolution 3-D view of a bacterial core complex was provided by the X-ray crystallographic study of Roszak et al. (2003) who determined the structure of the RC-LH1-helix W complex of Rps.
Per A. Bullough , Pu Qian and C. Neil Hunter palustris to 4.8 Å.. The resolution was sufficient to reveal the basic features of the complex, namely an elliptical ring of 15 LH1 αβ subunits surrounding the RC (modeled on the Rba. sphaeroides complex). More recently, in a novel application of single molecule spectroscopy, modeling of the experimental data was shown to be consistent with an elliptical array of 15 BChl dimers, as well as a gap in the ellipse along the long side of the array (Richter et al., 2007a,b). Another notable feature of the structure determined by crystallography is the presence of helix W which lies near to the gap in the LH1 ring which would correspond to a missing sixteenth LH1 αβ subunit (Fig. 5a). The elliptical shape of the LH1 ring is consistent with previous cryo-EM data on the Rsp. rubrum RC-LH1 core complex (Jamieson et al., 2002; see below), as well as with AFM images of the Blc. viridis RC-LH1 complex (Scheuring et al., 2003), but the Rps. palustris LH1 is more tightly wrapped round the RC than in these other complexes, as discussed in Qian et al. (2005). The structural basis for this flexibility in LH1, which accommodates varying degrees of ellipticity, is discussed in Section III above. Helix W has not been identified at present, but in view of its location, adjacent to the hydrophobic tail of the ubiquinone molecule which projects outwards from the RC QB site, and the known role of PufX in the Rhodobacter core complex as a facilitator of quinone exchange (Barz et al., 1995a), it is likely that helix W is a functional homolog of PufX. The monomeric nature of the Rps. palustris core complex in the 3-D structure (Roszak et al., 2003) appears to reflect its native state in the membrane. AFM studies of membranes from this bacterium show the presence of monomeric RC-LH1-W complexes of a size and shape that broadly agree with the crystallographic data (Scheuring et al., 2006; Chapter 47, Scheuring). The exception to this is that the topographic feature assigned to helix W in this AFM study is not restricted to one position in relation to the enclosed RC complex, which argues against its role in quinone exchange, and which also presents difficulties in preparing homogeneous samples for 3-D crystallization. This conflict requires improved resolution for both crystallographic and AFM approaches. A. The Rhodobacter veldkampii Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1-PufX Complex Gubellini et al. (2006) performed a structural and
Chapter 9
Core Complexes of Purple Bacteria
167
Fig. 5. Schematic representation of (a) the monomeric Rps. palustris and (b) the dimeric Rba. sphaeroides RC-LH1-PufW/X complexes. Transmembrane helices and pigments are shown in cartoon form and stick form, respectively. Working from the outside of the complex they are: LH1β ring (unshaded), BChl (black), LH1α ring (shaded dark grey), single PufW or PufX helix (unshaded) and reaction center (highlighted with a grey surround) with black pigments and white quinone. The RC protein is composed of the three chains: L (grey boxes), M (unshaded) and H (diagonal lines). The figure was constructed initially with Pymol (DeLano Scientific) using the PDB coordinates 1PYH of the complete Rps. palustris complex. A crude model of the Rba. sphaeroides complex was constructed using EM data from Qian et al. (2005) as a basis along with the reaction center crystal structure (PDB code 1PCR), the solution structures of PufX (2NRG), LH1α from Rsp. rubrum (1XRD) and LH1β from Rba. sphaeroides (1DX7), and LH1 BChl coordinates from the aforementioned Rps. palustris complex. For clarity, the coordinates were edited to show only transmembrane helices and phytol chains were removed from pigments. For consistency, coordinates of QB from the Rba. sphaeroides reaction center were modeled to the Rps. palustris complex based on the homology of the two structures.
functional analysis of the photosynthetic apparatus of Rhodobacter veldkampii. A core complex was purified and analyzed by sedimentation, size exclusion chromatography, mass spectrometry, and EM. A PufX subunit identified by MALDI-TOF was found to be associated with the core complex. Sedimentation and electron microscopy showed the core complex to be monomeric, suggesting that in Rba. veldkampii, PufX is involved in the photosynthetic growth but is unable to induce the dimerization of the core complex. It should be noted that in Rba. veldkampii, the requirement of PufX for anaerobic, photosynthetic growth has not been proven by deletion of the pufX gene. However, analysis of Cyt b561 reduction kinetics showed that the quinol-quinone exchange at the QB site of the RC occurred in Rba. veldkampii membranes as rapidly as in wild type Rba. sphaeroides chromatophores, suggesting that the PufX protein might also facilitate cyclic electron flow in Rba. veldkampii. Gubellini et al. (2006) concluded that the native membrane has either a monomeric organization or a much less stable dimeric organization of the core complex than that prevalent in Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. blasticus. They suggested that amino acids in PufX involved in the core complex dimerization may lie within the N-terminal region, since it is known
that N-terminal deletion of PufX in Rba. sphaeroides reduces the level of core complex dimerization (Francia et al., 2002). This deletion work had suggested a role for amino acids 7–19 in the interaction between two PufX proteins; alignment of the PufX N-terminus from Rba. sphaeroides (amino acids 9–16) and Rba. capsulatus (amino acids 9–16) revealed two conserved oppositely charged amino acids in the DXXNXXXK sequence that might be involved in the stabilization of the dimer. It was suggested that the corresponding DXXXK sequence in Rba. veldkampii might be too short for such an interaction (Gubellini et al., 2006). In a recent development of this work cryo-EM was used for a 3-D reconstruction of the Rba. veldkampii core complex at 12 Å resolution (Busselez et al., 2007). Interestingly, this complex was found to be larger and less elliptical than the monomeric RC-LH1-W complex from Rps. palustris, but the two complexes are similar in overall architecture, in the sense that the RC is surrounded by an LH1 assembly of 15 subunits, and there is a gap in the structure, in the case of the Rba. veldkampii of ~40 Å. The QB site of the RC faces the gap. The preferred model of this complex employs the ‘straight’ PufX NMR structure (Wang et al., 2007), as opposed to the ‘bent’ structure determined by Tunnicliffe et al. (2006), since only
168 the former sterically allows two adjacent GXXXG (GXXXV in Rba. veldkampii) putative dimerization motifs to drive the association of two monomers to form a dimer. In the model favored by Qian et al. (2005) the much greater distance between two PufX molecules within a dimer requires that, instead, the N-termini are essential for stabilizing the core dimer. There are several problems with reconciling the Qian et al. cryo-EM data with the PufX-PufX helix-helix model (Scheuring et al., 2004, 2005; Busselez et al., 2007): (1) PufX is located near to the RC QB site, so (2) a PufX-PufX transmembrane association therefore requires that the RC is rotated within the dimer structure to a point where it no longer fits with the known EM density, nor with the linear dichroism (LD) data for the Qy transition of the RC special pair BChls determined by Frese et al. (2000), then applied to the negative stain EM of dimer-only membranes (Siebert et al., 2004). However, only better structural data can resolve these differences. VI. Dimeric Reaction Center-LightHarvesting 1-PufX Complexes A. The Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Rhodobacter blasticus Core Dimers Much of the work on RC-LH1-PufX complexes has been facilitated by mutants lacking LH2 complexes. The elongated tubular membranes from these mutants, which have diameters of between 50 and 75 nm and lengths of 50 to 2000 nm (Siebert et al., 2004), are ideal material for negative stain analysis by EM because they contain naturally crystalline helical arrays of RC-LH1-PufX complexes (Jungas et al., 1999; Siebert et al., 2004). Freeze-fracture electron microscopy of whole cells of M21, a mutant lacking LH2 complexes (Ashby et al., 1987), also showed the presence of elongated tubular membranes with a highly ordered helical array of closely packed, dimeric particles with dimensions of ~100 Å × ~200 Å lying along the longitudinal axis. It was suggested that these particles represent dimers of RC-LH1-PufX complexes (Westerhuis et al., 2002). Subsequently, membranes from mutants lacking LH2 complexes provided a convenient starting point for purification of RC-LH1-PufX dimers, and their crystallization (Qian et al., 2005). Jungas et al. (1999) analyzed negatively stained tubular membranes and obtained a low-resolution
Per A. Bullough , Pu Qian and C. Neil Hunter (~25 Å) structure of the RC-LH1-PufX complex. This first view of the Rba. sphaeroides core complex revealed a dimeric structure in projection, with two RC complexes enclosed by an S-shaped LH1 assembly. Some of the electron density had been tentatively assigned to the cytochrome bc1 complex, so a subsequent study was conducted to resolve this issue and also to investigate the effect of deleting PufX (Siebert et al., 2004). Highly purified tubular membranes were prepared, and the absence of the cytochrome bc1 complex was verified by western blotting. These membranes were composed solely of dimeric RC-LH1-PufX complexes. The absence of PufX had a remarkable effect, transforming the tubular cell membranes into flattened sheets comprised of closely packed hexagonal arrays of monomeric RC-LH1 complexes. The low-resolution structures of these monomers showed that an LH1 ring completely enclosed each RC (Siebert et al., 2004). Francia et al. (1999) had already shown that dimerization of the core was abolished in the absence of PufX, and the EM study (Siebert et al., 2004) showed the macroscopic consequences of deleting PufX. Following the initial observations of Jungas et al. (1999) independent verification of the ordered nature of dimeric RC-LH1-PufX complexes was obtained by measuring the capacity of oriented tubular membranes to absorb polarized light. This LD study clearly showed that PufX induces the long-range alignment of transition dipoles of BChls within the RC (Frese et al., 2000). Importantly, LD also established the angle between the RC special pair BChls and the longitudinal tube (orientation) axis. Superposition of tshe LD data onto the negative stain projection map places the RC QB site adjacent to the opening in the LH1 assembly (Siebert et al., 2004), an arrangement that would permit quinol access to the membrane milieu. The suggestion was made that PufX was also near this opening in the LH1 structure, consistent with the 500-fold reduction in Q/QH2 exchange observed in a mutant with no PufX (Barz et al., 1995b). This proposed location of PufX, the orientation of the RC within the complex, and the extent to which the LH1 complex was really ‘open’ were all aspects of the dimer structure in need of improved structural resolution, beyond the capacity of the naturally crystalline membrane material used, and analysis by negative stain EM. Using such RC-LH1-PufX (no LH2) membranes as a starting point, highly purified dimeric complexes were prepared, and 2-D crystals were grown with
Chapter 9
Core Complexes of Purple Bacteria
169
Fig. 6. Comparison of the 8.5 Å resolution projection map of the Rba. sphaeroides RC-LH1-PufX dimer with previous core complex structures. (a) Comparison with negatively stained complexes from natural tubular membranes of Rba. sphaeroides (Siebert et al., 2004). (b) Comparison of the X-ray crystal structure of RC-LH1-helix W complex of Rps. palustris (Roszak et al., 2003).
sufficient size and order to enable the calculation of a projection map to 8.5 Å (Qian et al., 2005). This revealed the α-helices that comprise the RC and LH1 components, as well as a possible location for PufX. A continuous LH1 assembly, consisting of 28 αβ subunits, snakes round the two RC complexes within the dimer structure (Fig. 5b). Figure 6a compares the negative stain projection map (Siebert et al., 2004) with the higher resolution structure (Qian et al., 2005). Examination of the cryo-EM projection map shows that there is no ‘gap’ as such in each half of the LH1 assembly; however, the αβ pairs are more separated in this region and the relatively weak and diffuse density could arise from mobility of LH1β, namely movement of the whole polypeptide, or selective motion of just part of LH1β (Fig. 6a). This possibility was raised by the solution structure of LH1β (Conroy et al., 2000). One crucial feature of this projection map is the orientation of the RC within the dimer, unequivocally established by fitting the known RC structure known from X-ray crystallographic data to the projection map obtained by cryo-EM (Fig. 5b). This places the RC in an orientation which not only locates the QB site adjacent to the more widely spaced and mobile LH1β polypeptide, it also places the Qy transition dipole of the special pair BChls in approximate agreement with the orientation proposed on the basis of earlier LD and negative stain data (Frese et al., 2000; Siebert et al., 2004). Finally, this orientation of the RC places the QB site next to the ‘extra’ density in the cryo-EM projection map, which lies outside both the LH1 arc and the envelope of density arising from the RC (Fig. 6a). On the basis that this extra region of density arises from a single transmembrane helix, and that the only unassigned
component in the structure is PufX, this density was assigned to PufX (Fig. 5b), close to the region proposed earlier (Siebert et al., 2004). The RC provides a valuable reference structure for aligning and comparing structures of core complexes; accordingly it was possible to compare the dimeric core complex from Rba. sphaeroides with the monomeric Rps. palustris complex (Roszak et al., 2003). The result is that helix W of the Rps. palustris structure and the PufX location proposed for the dimer structure lie within ~10 Å of each other. However, another EM analysis of 2-D crystals prepared from the Rba. sphaeroides core dimer has concluded that there are 24 LH1 αβ subunits (compared to 28 in the 8.5 Å structure), and that the two PufX polypeptides of the dimer are located at the junction between the two halves of the structure (Scheuring et al., 2004). PufX is known to drive the dimerization process (Francia et al., 1999; Siebert et al., 2004), and this arrangement allows the proximity of the transmembrane helices of PufX to drive the formation of the dimer, whereas in the 8.5 Å structure (Qian et al., 2005) an interaction between the N-termini is more likely. The proposed location of the PufX transmembrane helix adjacent to the RC QB site, a position analogous to that of helix W in the monomeric RC-LH1 complex (Roszak et al., 2003), requires an N-terminal region of at least 40 Å reaching towards the dimer interface to promote dimer formation (Qian et al., 2005). This is compatible with the solution structure of the Rba. sphaeroides PufX polypeptide, showing such an extended N-terminal region (Tunnicliffe et al. 2006; Fig. 1d). Consistent with this idea, a mutagenesis study demonstrated that deletion of N-terminal residues destabilizes dimer formation (Francia et al., 2002).
170 An AFM analysis of the core complex from Rba. blasticus (Scheuring et al., 2005) also proposes a PufX-PufX transmembrane interaction at the dimer junction (Fig. 7), as well as an orientation of the RC which differs from that proposed by Qian et al. (2005). Homodimerization of the PufX transmembrane regions (Fig. 7) is proposed to drive core dimer formation (Scheuring et al., 2004; Scheuring et al., 2005; Aklujkar and Beatty, 2006). The interaction of two such closely associated transmembrane helices implies a center-to-center helix spacing of ~10 Å (MacKenzie et al., 1997). The densities in the 8.5 Å projection map of the Rba. sphaeroides core complex dimer reveal no such spacings at the interface between the two halves of the dimer (Qian et al., 2005). However, as already pointed out in the earlier section on the monomeric Rba. veldkampii core complex, only a higher resolution structure will resolve these issues. Whatever the determinants of PufX are that drive dimerization, they can be disrupted in such a way that a homogeneous population of monomeric core complexes is produced. This is shown clearly by the work of Abresch et al. (2005), who used an LH2minus mutant, together with a 6-Histidine tag on the RC-H subunit, as a source of material. It is possible that the use of the detergent diheptanoyl-sn-glycero-3phosphocholine (DHPC) for solubilization is responsible for conversion of dimers into monomers, since this was also the experience of the authors (P. Qian, C.N. Hunter and P.A. Bullough, unpublished). The fact that a homogeneous population of monomers is produced, to the extent that it was possible to use them to grow 3-D crystals that diffracted to 12 Å, shows that core dimers split symmetrically to form a uniform population; Abresch et al. (2005) estimated that each monomer comprised 13.3 ± 0.9 LH1 subunits per RC, in good agreement with the ratio of 14 found for each half of the dimer (Qian et al. 2005). B. Structural and Functional Roles for PufX It has been suggested that there is a relationship between PufX and the N-terminal segment of the cytochrome subunit which forms an integral component of the RC complex from the aerobic bacterium Roseobacter denitrificans (Hucke et al., 2003). Although such comparisons are hampered by the inherently low similarity between even better known PufX homologs, this interesting suggestion provides another possible insight into the origin of PufX and
Per A. Bullough , Pu Qian and C. Neil Hunter
Fig. 7. The Rba. blasticus dimeric core complex, imaged by AFM. (a) Two-fold symmetrized image of the periplasmic surface of a single molecule of the complex. Scale bar: 5 nm; (b) corresponding assembly model. Two RC complexes are surrounded by two C-shaped LH1 assemblies each consisting of 13 subunits, and connected by a PufX dimer at the two-fold axis. Adapted from Scheuring et al. (2004).
its interaction with the RC and LH1 complexes. PufX and its analogs would appear to fulfill two roles in some cases, namely to facilitate quinonequinol exchange and to stabilize dimeric core complexes. Clearly dimerization is not essential for a photosynthetic phenotype, as evidenced by the monomeric core complexes discussed above. It is possible, though, that dimerization is important for membrane organization, antenna connectivity, excitation transfer and for quinone-mediated communication with cytochrome bc1 complexes by influencing distribution of the quinone pool (Frese et al., 2000; Francia et al., 2004; Siebert et al., 2004; Bahatyrova et al., 2004a; Comayras et al., 2005). See Chapter 14, Sturgis and Niederman, and Chapter 15, Şener and Schulten, for discussions of membrane architecture and the functional consequences of differing arrangements and stoichiometries of complexes. 1. PufX: Core Dimerization and Membrane Curvature A recent 3-D reconstruction of the RC-LH1-PufX core dimer from Rhodobacter sphaeroides, calculated from single particle EM analysis of negatively stained complexes (Qian et al., 2008; P. Qian, P.A. Bullough and C.N. Hunter, unpublished), shows how PufX can indirectly mediate membrane curvature. This study reveals that the two halves of the dimer molecule incline toward each other on the periplasmic side at an angle of ~146º, forming a distinct ‘V’ shape (Fig. 8a). Such a possibility was raised earlier by Geyer and Helms (2006a) who predicted an angle of 154º. The intrinsic curvature of this dimer drives the for-
Chapter 9
Core Complexes of Purple Bacteria
171
Fig. 8. (a) 3-D reconstruction of the core RC-LH1-PufX dimer of Rba. sphaeroides. Left: examples of the classes of negatively stained single particles used for the 3-D reconstruction. Middle: surface views of the 3-D reconstruction of the dimeric RC-LH1-PufX complex viewed from different angles. LH1 appears to form a continuous density, which surrounds central densities arising from the RCs. The RC-H subunits, protruding from LH1 ring, can be seen clearly on the cytoplasmic surface of the complex. The two LH1 rings are inclined towards each other on the periplasmic side forming a ‘V’ shape. Right: 3-D model of the arrangement of RC-LH1-PufX dimers in the native tubular membrane. The long pitch helix formed from associations between the long axes of the dimers is colored in dark gray. The outer, cytoplasmic face of the tubular membrane is shown. (b) The influence of PufX, and the consequent formation of core dimers and monomers, on membrane morphology in LH2-minus mutants. Elongated cells (top) as well as tubular membranes (bottom) are assembled from PufX+ dimer-containing cores (core model on left), but flattened membrane sheets result from PufX-minus monomeric cores (core model on right). The structural models of the core complexes are shown in more detail in Fig. 9.
mation of the membrane that houses it, and the angle of 146º explains the size and shape of the tubular membranes observed in negatively stained thin sections of core-only mutants that lack the LH2 complex (Hunter et al., 1988; Kiley et al., 1988; Westerhuis et al., 2002). These early EM thin section and freezefracture studies showed that, in the absence of any other interactions, core dimers of Rba. sphaeroides have a tendency to pack to form helical arrays. Many such arrays form elongated tubes, with a diameter of approximately 70 nm (Hunter et al., 1988; Jungas et al., 1999; Siebert et al., 2004). Figure 8b shows the effect of deletion of pufX; in
such mutants (which also lack LH2) membranes comprising flattened sheets of pseudo-hexagonally packed arrays of monomeric core complexes form, rather than tubes (Siebert et al., 2004). Figure 9 shows a comparison of the monomeric RC-LH1-helix W core complex from Rps. palustris (Roszak et al., 2003) and the modeled dimeric RC-LH1-PufX complex of Rba. sphaeroides, using the location of PufX assigned in Qian et al. (2005), and a space-filling representation in each case. These contrasting shapes of core complex can be expected to impose differing morphologies on the membranes in which they sit. In the wild-type, as opposed to the situation in LH2-
172
Per A. Bullough , Pu Qian and C. Neil Hunter
Fig. 9. Structural models of monomeric and dimeric core complexes. In each case a side view and a space-filling representation is used. For the RC the complete structure is present (shown in black), but for the LH1 (gray) and helix W/PufX components (white) only the transmembrane helices are shown. a. The monomeric RC-LH1-W core complex from Rps. palustris (Roszak et al., 2003). b. The dimeric RC-LH1-PufX core complex of Rba. sphaeroides. The coordinates of the LH1 αβ pairs were adopted from Roszak et al. (2003), fitted into the tilted 3-D dimer structure from single particle analysis (Chapter 9, Bullough et al.), and adjusted according to the cryo-EM projection map in Qian et al. (2005). The transmembrane domain of PufX was taken from Tunnicliffe et al. (2006). See also color plate 5, Fig. 7.
minus mutants, this tendency of core dimers to stack has to be resisted; if it were otherwise, the spherical invaginations seen in the wild-type could not assemble, and tubular structures would form instead. Thus, only a few dimers — a rough model suggests no more than 4 or 5 — can stack along their long axes before it becomes necessary to ‘cap’ the growing membrane with LH2-rich domains (Fig. 10). It is interesting that in the AFM images of wild-type membrane patches, the number of dimers in a row rarely exceeded 5 (Bahatyrova et al., 2004a). Thus, although invagination of the intracytoplasmic membrane proceeds with the preferential assembly of core complexes, it is important that LH2 incorporation prevails during the latter stages of membrane invagination. It is relevant to note here that Niederman et al. (1976) observed a stepwise sequence of photosynthetic unit assembly with LH1 complexes dominating the early stages of membrane growth, eventually giving way to LH2 in the later stages. The suitability of LH2 domains for ‘capping’ growing membrane invaginations is consistent with the known intrinsic curvature of the LH2 complex in Rba. sphaeroides, and it is known that LH2-only membranes form spherical structures (Hunter et al., 1988). It is not clear, in the absence of a high resolution structure of the Rba. sphaeroides LH2 complex, whether the intrinsic curvature arises from the protein complex itself, or from tightly bound lipids. An LD study of the organization of complexes in intact wild-type membrane vesicles concluded that rows of dimers, running ‘north-south’ were capped by LH2-rich domains (Frese et al., 2004).
From the above, it is clear that the well-documented role of PufX in driving dimerization of core complexes (Francia et al., 1999; Siebert et al., 2004) also has the effect of promoting membrane curvature in Rba. sphaeroides. Although the effect of PufX on membrane curvature is observed in Rba. sphaeroides mutants (Fig. 8), this work raises a more general possibility that bacteria with monomeric complexes (see sections IV and V) will tend to assemble lamellar structures, rather than spherical or tubular membranes, and that these alternative morphologies are related in some way to the absence of PufX or to the lack of dimerization motifs in the PufX homologs present. However, there is a notable exception; Rsp. rubrum assembles spherical intracytoplamic membranes packed with monomeric core complexes. In order to understand more about membrane curvature and domain formation, it has been necessary to invoke the application of colloid theory (see below). 2. PufX: Membrane Domains, Excitation Sharing and Quinone Sequestration AFM of Rba. sphaeroides membranes shows that the core dimers and LH2 complexes partition within the membrane, but the mechanisms for formation of domains of membrane proteins within a membrane bilayer are unclear. Why do core and LH2 complexes not distribute randomly throughout the membrane in Rba. sphaeroides? A recent modeling study used Monte Carlo simulations to demonstrate that depletion interactions, known from colloid theory (for
Chapter 9
Core Complexes of Purple Bacteria
173
Fig. 10. Model of spherical intracytoplasmic membrane vesicles of Rba. sphaeroides, showing rows of dimers interspersed with LH2 complexes, as in Bahatyrova et al. (2004), and modeled to correspond approximately to the arrangement of complexes in Sener et al. (2007). A large domain composed of LH2 complexes caps the vesicle and prevents the rows of dimers from extending the invagination further, a process which would eventually form a tubular structure.
example, Eldridge et al., 1993), could produce ordered states within the membrane (Frese et al., 2008). Domain formation was shown to be driven, at least in part, by the size mismatch between the relatively large, elongated core dimers and the smaller, circular LH2 complexes. An additional factor also came into play in this analysis, namely curvature mismatch between the interacting outer faces of core and LH2 complexes as they pack together. For example, LH2 complexes tend to associate with one another to form tightly curved spherical arrays ~50 nm in diameter, in contrast to the ~70 nm tubular membranes formed by core dimers. Thus, incompatibilities between the interacting surfaces of these complexes can arise in mixed populations of LH2 and core dimers, giving rise to the curvature mismatch factor. Thus, taking all of the work detailed in this section into account, it is possible to trace connections between PufX, core dimerization, membrane curvature and domain formation. For further analysis and a review of membrane organization in bacterial photosynthetic membranes see Chapter 14, Sturgis and Niederman. The tendency of core dimers to stack has a structural role, but is there a functional role as well? Modelling of excitation transfer in wild-type membranes predicts a significant degree of excitation sharing within a dimer array (Şener et al., 2007; Chapter 15, Şener and Schulten). It is possible that, in the event of one or more RCs being in the closed state, linear arrays of core dimers might optimize energy trapping by allowing migration of the excitation along
the dimer array to an open RC. The necessity for such an arrangement might be dictated not only by energy transfer considerations, but also by turnover at the RC QB site, and migration of quinol/quinone and cytochrome c2 to and from the cytochrome bc1 complex. The interdependence of these processes is nicely illustrated in a modeling paper by Geyer and Helms (2006b). Another interesting aspect of the 3-D reconstruction of the Rba. sphaeroides core dimer is the identification of an apparent space within each half of the molecule, situated within the LH1 ring near the LH1 αβ14 subunit (Fig. 11) (Qian et al., 2008). The favored position of PufX assigned in Qian et al. (2005), but still subject to some debate, as noted in previous sections, is indicated by a single helix. A space-filled RC QB molecule is also shown in Fig. 11. A detailed analysis of the kinetics of charge separation, together with the phospholipid and quinone content of core dimers, showed that approximately 10–15 quinone molecules and 80–90 phospholipid molecules per reaction center are retained by purified, detergent washed core dimer complexes (Dezi et al., 2007). The 3-D model of the dimer in Fig. 11 shows that there is a space between the inner face of the LH1 ring and the outer surface of the RC which could accommodate lipids. An area of approximately 250 Å2 is required to accommodate ~10 quinone molecules within each half of the core complex, and lipid molecules are also likely to be present in this region, since they form a flexible environment for quinone movement (Jones, 2007). Each of the two spaces
174
Per A. Bullough , Pu Qian and C. Neil Hunter
Fig. 11. 3-D model of the RC-LH1-PufX dimer viewed from the cytoplasmic side showing the transmembrane helices of the LH1 complex positioned according to the cryo-EM projection map in Qian et al. (2005). The LH1 αβ14 pair is colored in dark gray to differentiate it from the other LH1 αβ pairs. The transmembrane domain of PufX, represented by a ribbon and labeled ‘X’, was taken from Tunnicliffe et al. (2006). The 3-D reconstruction from single particle data (see Fig. 8) is represented by a mesh. The RC QB molecule, labeled U10, is shown using a space-filling representation. The space adjacent to LH1 αβ14, which might accommodate a quinone pool, is labeled ‘Q’.
within the dimer in Fig. 11 is roughly equivalent to a circular area of diameter ~20 Å, consistent with the estimate in Dezi et al. (2007). This space appears to have been penetrated by stain, which may reflect the more open and mobile nature of the quinone/lipid environment compared with the dense hydrophobic stain-excluding interior of the protein. This space within the complex occupies a good strategic location for a holding area or vestibule for quinones, since it is adjacent to PufX, the RC QB site and the loose region of the LH1 ring, where the flexibility of the αβ transmembrane helices could facilitate the exit and ingress of quinol/quinone molecules. Clearly, higher resolution 3-D structural data are required to examine this point. VII. The Biogenesis of Core Complexes The early work of Youvan, Marrs and Hearst discovered genes involved in assembly of the core complex, and one of these, orf1696, is required for assembly of the RC-LH1-PufX complex in Rba. capsulatus (Youvan et al., 1982; Zsebo and Hearst, 1984). Orf1696 encodes a hydrophobic protein of approximately 50 kDa. Subsequent studies verified its role in core complex assembly (Young et al.,
1998), and proposed a topological model comprising 12 transmembrane spans (Young and Beatty, 1998). The sequence similarity between the gene products of orf1696, designated as lhaA, and pucC, an analogous assembly factor for LH2, was also noted (Young and Beatty, 1998). Disruption of both the lhaA and RC-H subunit genes showed the likelihood of an LhaA assembly factor in Rba. sphaeroides (Sockett et al., 1989). Other insertional mutagenesis work had already revealed another gene for assembly of core complexes, orf214, which is located next to the puhA gene and near to lhaA (Wong et al., 1996), and yet another gene product, Orf162b, appears to play a role in enhancing the assembly or stability of RC-LH1-PufX complexes (Aklujkar et al., 2000). As more genomic sequences become available, it is clear that lhaA, orf214 and orf162b all have counterparts in other photosynthetic bacteria (Aklujkar et al., 2000; Aklujkar et al., 2005). Further analysis of orf241, which designated this gene as puhB, assigned the encoded protein as a RCspecific assembly factor with only an indirect effect on LH1; a role in dimerization of the RC-LH1-PufX complex was proposed (Aklujkar et al., 2005). One view of the RC-H subunit is that it has a role in core complex assembly, since early work on puhA mutants showed that only LH2 assembly appeared to survive
Chapter 9
Core Complexes of Purple Bacteria
inactivation of puhA. In contrast, inactivation of the puhA gene in Rsp. rubrum does not impair assembly of the LH1 complex, unless carotenoid synthesis is also prevented (Lupo and Ghosh, 2004). As a result the RC-H subunit was proposed to have a chaperonelike function in forming assembly sites prior to the arrival of the other RC subunits (Varga and Kaplan, 1993). Subsequently, a different model proposed that, instead, RC-M is a nucleus for assembly, with the arrival of RC-L followed by RC-H (Tehrani et al., 2003; Tehrani and Beatty, 2004). Niederman and co-workers investigated the timing of assembly of the core complex by initiating membrane assembly in low aeration cell suspensions, following a transfer from high aeration conditions which suppress the biogenesis of photosynthetic complexes (Niederman et al., 1976). Subsequently, it was shown that prior to the induction of membrane assembly, which took place over a 400 minutes time course, the RC-H subunit was detectable by western blotting (Pugh et al., 1998). Levels of RC-M and RC-L were not monitored. The next protein to be synthesized was PufX, and this was followed by LH1 α and β polypeptides. It was suggested that a RCPufX-LH1αβ complex is formed at the earliest stages of the assembly of the core, and also that LH1αβBChl2 complexes are progressively added to this complex to drive the encirclement of the RC. The early arrival of PufX would prevent blockage of the RC QB site by LH1αβBChl2 units. The fact that LH1 complexes from a variety of bacteria can be reversibly dissociated into αβBChl2 (B820) complexes in the presence of detergents supports this concept of LH1αβBChl2 units as building blocks of LH1, both in vitro and in vivo (see Section III above, and Chapter 10, Loach and Parkes-Loach for a thorough discussion of B820 complexes, and Chapter 46, Braun and Fiedor, for a model of LH1 assembly). Resonance Raman studies of site directed mutants of LH1 revealed that the network of H-bonds stabilizes each αβBChl2 unit (Olsen et al., 1994, 1997; Sturgis et al., 1997). Thus, the four possible H-bonds to the pair of BChls are ‘internal’ to the αβBChl2 unit (Fig. 3), providing a significant driving force to stabilize this putative assembly intermediate (Davis et al., 1997). More recently, a possible intermediate of LH1 assembly, iB873, has been demonstrated using a new in vitro reconstitution method, the important difference from earlier work being that this complex contains carotenoids. It was speculated that iB873 is a smaller complex than the mature LH1 assembly (Fiedor and Scheer, 2005).
175 Several factors that influence the insertion of LH1 α and β polypeptides into the membrane have been
investigated in Rba. capsulatus. This topic has been reviewed (Drews, 1996; Drews and Niederman, 2002), but briefly it has been shown that a positively charged N-terminal domain of LH1α is essential for assembly of the whole LH1 complex. Surprisingly, the corresponding domain of the LH1β polypeptide is negatively charged (Stiehle et al., 1990). The highly conserved residues Trp–24 and Pro–19 located within the LH1α N-terminal domain were also examined, with the former residue essential for LH1 assembly, but mutations in the Pro were tolerated to some extent (Richter et al., 1991). Phosphorylation of LH1α has also been reported, detected using both monoclonal antibodies and radio-labeling approaches. The role of this processing in assembly of the LH1 complex is still unclear, as is the proportion of LH1 polypeptides that undergo this modification, but the factors that influence phosphorylation include a light-driven proton gradient and a redox potential in excess of +200mV (Pucheu et al., 1996). Certainly, the value of using an in vitro transcription-translation system is clear, since this allows some control over the proteins and insertion factors present (Chory and Kaplan, 1982; Meryandini and Drews, 1996). Acknowledgments The authors gratefully acknowledge funding from the Biotechnology and Biological Research Council, U.K. References Abresch EC, Axelrod HLA, Beatty JT, Johnson JA, Nechustai R and Paddock ML (2005) Characterization of a highly purified, fully active, crystallizable RC-LH1-PufX core complex from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Photosynth Res 86: 61-70 Addlesee HA and Hunter CN (2002) Rhodospirillum rubrum possesses a variant of the bchP gene, encoding geranylgeranylbacteriopheophytin reductase. J Bacteriol 184: 1578–1586 Aklujkar M and Beatty JT (2005) The PufX protein of Rhodobacter capsulatus affects the properties of bacteriochlorophyll a and carotenoid pigments of light-harvesting complex 1. Arch Biochem Biophys 443: 21–32 Aklujkar M and Beatty JT (2006) Investigation of Rhodobacter capsulatus PufX interactions in the core complex of the photosynthetic apparatus. Photosynth Res 88: 159–171 Aklujkar M, Harmer AL, Prince RC and Beatty JT (2000) The orf162b sequence of Rhodobacter capsulatus encodes a protein
176 required for optimal levels of photosynthetic pigment-protein complexes. J Bacteriol 182: 5440–5447 Aklujkar M, Prince RC and Beatty JT (2005) The PuhB protein of Rhodobacter capsulatus functions in photosynthetic reaction center assembly with a secondary effect on light-harvesting complex 1. J Bacteriol 187: 1334–1343 Allen JP, Feher G, Yeates TO, Komiya H and Rees DC (1987) Structure of the reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides R26: The protein subunits. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 84: 6162–6166 Ashby MK, Coomber SA and Hunter CN (1987) Cloning, nucleotide sequence and transfer of genes for the B800-850 light-harvesting complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. FEBS Lett 213: 245–248 Bahatyrova S, Frese RN, Siebert CA, Olsen JD, van der Werf KO, van Grondelle R, Niederman RA, Bullough PA, Otto C and Hunter CN (2004a) The native architecture of a photosynthetic membrane. Nature 430: 1058–1062 Bahatyrova S, Frese RN, van der Werf KO, Otto C, Hunter CN and Olsen JD (2004b) Flexibility and size heterogeneity of the LH1 light-harvesting complex revealed by atomic force microscopy: Functional significance for bacterial photosynthesis. J Biol Chem 279: 21327–21333 Barz WP and Oesterhelt D (1994) Photosynthetic deficiency of a pufX deletion mutant of Rhodobacter sphaeroides is suppressed by point mutations in the light-harvesting complex genes pufB and pufA. Biochemistry 33: 9741–9752 Barz WP, Francia F, Venturoli G, Melandri BA, Verméglio A and Oesterhelt D (1995a) Role of the PufX protein in photosynthetic growth of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. 1. PufX is required for efficient light-driven electron transfer and photophosphorylation under anaerobic conditions. Biochemistry 34: 15235–15247 Barz WP, Verméglio A, Francia F, Venturoli G, Melandri BA and Oesterhelt D (1995b) Role of the PufX protein in photosynthetic growth of the Rhodobacter sphaeroides. 2. PufX is required for efficient ubiquinone/ubiquinol exchange between the reaction centre QB site and the cytochrome bc1 complex. Biochemistry 34: 15248–15258 Boonstra AF, Germeroth L and Boekema EJ (1994) Structure of the light-harvesting antenna from Rhodospirillum molischianum studied by electron microscopy. Biochim Biophys Acta 1184: 227–234 Broglie RM, Hunter CN, Delepelaire P, Niederman RA, Chua NH and Clayton RK (1980) Isolation and characterization of the pigment-protein complexes of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides by lithium dodecyl sulfate/polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 77: 87–91 Brunisholz RA and Zuber H (1992) Structure, function and organization of antenna polypeptides and antenna complexes from the three families of Rhodospirillaneae. J Photochem Photobiol B-Biol 15: 113–140 Busselez J, Cottevieille M, Cuniasse P, Gubellini F, Boisset N and Lévy D (2007) Structural basis for the PufX-mediated dimerization of bacterial photosynthetic core complexes. Structure 15: 1674–1683 Chory J and Kaplan S (1982) The in vitro transcription-translation of DNA and RNA templates by extracts of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. Optimization and comparison of template specificity with Escherichia coli extracts and in vivo synthesis. J Biol Chem 257: 15110–15121 Clayton RK (1962) Primary reactions in bacterial photosynthesis.
Per A. Bullough , Pu Qian and C. Neil Hunter I. The nature of light-induced absorbency changes in chromatophores; evidence for a special bacteriochlorophyll component. Photochem Photobiol 1: 201–210 Clayton RK and Smith C (1960) Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides: High catalase and blue-green double mutants. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 3: 143–145 Clayton RK and Wang RT (1971) Photochemical reaction centers from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. In: San Pietro A (ed) Methods in Enzymology Vol XXIII, pp 696–704. Academic Press, New York Cogdell RJ, Fyfe PK, Barrett SJ, Prince SM, Freer AA, Isaacs NW, McGlynn P and Hunter CN (1996) The purple bacterial photosynthetic unit. Photosynth Res 48: 55–63 Comayras R, Jungas C and Lavergne J (2005) Functional consequences of the organization of the photosynthetic apparatus in Rhodobacter sphaeroides — II. A study of PufX(-) membranes. J Biol Chem 280: 11214–11223 Conroy MJ, Westerhuis WH, Parkes-Loach PS, Loach PA, Hunter CN and Williamson MP (2000) The solution structure of Rhodobacter sphaeroides LH1β reveals two helical domains separated by a more flexible region: structural consequences for the LH1 complex. J Mol Biol 298: 83–94 Davis CM, Bustamante PL, Todd JB, Parkes-Loach PS, McGlynn P, Olsen JD, McMaster L, Hunter CN and Loach PA (1997) Evaluation of structure-function relationships in the core lightharvesting complex of photosynthetic bacteria by reconstitution with mutant polypeptides. Biochemistry 36: 3671–3679 Deisenhofer J, Epp O, Miki K, Huber R and Michel H (1985) Structure of the protein subunits in the photosynthetic reaction centre of Rhodopseudomonas viridis at 3 Å resolution. Nature 318: 618–624 Dezi M, Francia F, Mallardi A, Colafemmina G, Palazzo G and Venturoli G (2007) Stabilization of charge separation and cardiolipin confinement in antenna reaction center complexes purfied from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochim Biophys Acta 1767: 1041–1056 Drews G (1996) Formation of the light-harvesting complex I (B870) of anoxygenic phototrophic purple bacteria. Arch Microbiol 166: 151–159 Drews G and Niederman RA (2002) Membrane biogenesis in anoxygenic photosynthetic prokaryotes. Photosynth Res 73: 87–94 Eldridge MD, Madden PA and Frenkel D (1993) Entropy-driven formation of a superlattice in hard-sphere binary mixture. Nature. 365: 35–37 Engelhardt H, Engel A and Baumeister W (1986) Stoichiometric model of the photosynthetic unit of Ectothiorhodospira halochloris. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 83: 8972–8976 Farchaus JW, Gruenberg H and Oesterhelt D (1990) Complementation of a reaction center-deficient Rhodobacter sphaeroides pufLMX deletion strain in trans with pufBALM does not restore the photosynthesis-positive phenotype. J Bacteriol 172: 977–985 Feher G (1971) Some chemical and physical properties of a bacterial reaction center particle and its primary photochemical reactants. Photochem Photobiol 14: 373–387 Fiedor L and Scheer H (2005) Trapping of an assembly intermediate of photosynthetic LH1 antenna beyond B820 subunit: Significance for the assembly of photosynthetic LH1 antenna. J Biol Chem 280: 20921–20926 Fotiadis D, Qian P, Philippsen A, Bullough PA, Engel A and Hunter
Chapter 9
Core Complexes of Purple Bacteria
CN (2004) Structural analysis of the RC-LH1 photosynthetic core complex of Rhodospirillum rubrum using atomic force microscopy. J Biol Chem 279: 2063–2068 Francia F, Wang J, Venturoli G, Melandri BA, Barz WP and Oesterhelt D (1999) The reaction center-LH1 antenna complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides contains one PufX molecule which is involved in dimerization of this complex. Biochemistry 38: 6834–6845 Francia F, Wang J, Zischka H, Venturoli G and Oesterhelt D (2002) Role of the N- and C-terminal regions of the PufX protein in the structural organization of the photosynthetic core complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Eur J Biochem 269: 1877–1885 Francia F, Dezi M, Rebecchi A, Mallardi A, Palazzo P, Melandri BA and Venturoli G (2004) Light-harvesting complex 1 stabilizes P+QB– charge separation in reaction centres of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 43: 14199–14210 Frese RN, Olsen JD, Branvall R, Westerhuis WHJ, Hunter CN and van Grondelle R (2000) The long-range supraorganization of the bacterial photosynthetic unit: A key role for PufX. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 97: 5197–5202 Frese R, Siebert CA, Niederman RA, Hunter CN, Otto C and van Grondelle R (2004) The long-range organization of a native photosynthetic membrane. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 101: 17994–17999 Frese RN, Pàmies JC, Olson JD, Bahatyrova S, van der Weij-de Wit CD, Aartsma TJ, Otto C, Hunter CN, Frenkel D and van Grondelle R (2008) Protein shape and crowding drive domain formation and curvature in biological membranes. Biophys J 19: 640–647 Fulcher TK, Beatty JT and Jones MR (1998) Demonstration of the key role played by the PufX protein in the functional and structural organization of native and hybrid bacterial photosynthetic core complexes. J Bacteriol 180: 642–646 Germeroth L, Lottspeich F, Robert B and Michel H (1993) Unexpected similarities of the B800-B850 light-harvesting complex of Rhodospirillum molischianum to the B870 light-harvesting complexes from other purple photosynthetic bacteria. Biochemistry 32: 5615–5621 Geyer T and Helms V (2006a) A spatial model of the chromatophore vesicles of Rhodobacter sphaeroides and the position of the cytochrome bc1 complex. Biophys J 91: 921–926. Geyer T and Helms V (2006b) Reconstruction of a kinetic model of the chromatophore vesicles from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biophys J 91: 927–937. Ghosh R, Hoenger A, Hardmeyer A, Mihailescu D, Bachofen R, Engel A and Rosenbusch JP (1993) Two-dimensional crystallization of the light-harvesting complex from Rhodospirillum rubrum. J Mol Biol 231: 501–504 Ghosh R, Kessi J, Hauser H, Wehrli E and Bachofen R (1990) Quarternary structure of the B875 light-harvesting complex from Rhodopseudomonas rubrum G9+. FEMS Microbiol Lett 53: 245–252 Gonçalves RP, Bernadac A, Sturgis JN and Scheuring S (2005) Architecture of the native photosynthetic apparatus of Phaeospirillum molischianum. J Struct Biol 152: 221–228 Gubellini F, Francia F, Busselez J, Venturoli G and Levy D (2006) Functional and structural analysis of the photosynthetic apparatus of Rhodobacter veldkampii. Biochemistry 45: 10512–10520 Hu X and Schulten K (1998) Model for the light-harvesting complex I (B875) of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biophys J
177 75: 683–694 Hucke O, Schiltz E, Drews G and Labahn A (2003) Sequence analysis reveals new membrane anchor of reaction centrebound cytochromes possibly related to PufX. FEBS Lett 535: 166–170 Hunter CN, Pennoyer JD, Sturgis JN, Farrelly D and Niederman RA (1988) Oligomerisation states and associations of light-harvesting pigment-protein complexes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides as analysed by lithium dodecyl sulphate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Biochemistry 27: 3459—3467 Hunter CN, van Grondelle R and Olsen JD (1989) Photosynthetic antenna proteins: 100 ps before photochemistry starts. Trends Biochem Sci 14: 72–76 Jamieson SJ, Wang P, Qian P, Kirkland JY, Conroy MJ, Hunter CN and Bullough PA (2002) Projection structure of the photosynthetic reaction centre-antenna complex of Rhodospirillum rubrum at 8.5 Å resolution. EMBO J 21: 3927–3935 Jones MR (2007) Lipies in photosynthetic reaction centres: Structural roles and functional holes. Prog Lipid Res 46: 56–87 Jungas C, Ranck JL, Rigaud JL, Joliot P and Verméglio A (1999) Supramolecular organization of the photosynthetic apparatus of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. EMBO J 18: 534–542 Karrasch S, Bullough PA and Ghosh R (1995) The 8.5 Å projection map of the light-harvesting complex I from Rhodospirillum rubrum reveals a ring composed of 16 subunits. EMBO J 14: 631–638 Kiley PJ, Varga A and Kaplan S (1988) Physiological and structural analysis of light-harvesting mutants of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Bacteriol 170: 1103–1115 Klug G and Cohen SN (1988) Pleiotropic effects of localized Rhodobacter capsulatus puf operon deletions on production of light-absorbing pigment-protein complexes. J Bacteriol 170: 5814–5821 Koepke J, Hu XC, Muenke C, Schulten K and Michel H (1996) The crystal structure of the light-harvesting complex II (B800-B850) from Rhodospirillum molischanum. Structure 4: 581–597 Law CJ, Chen J, Parkes-Loach PS, Loach PA (2003) Interaction of bacteriochlorophyll with the LH1 and PufX polypeptides of photosynthetic bacteria: Use of chemically synthesized analogs and covalently attached fluorescent probes. Photosynth Res 75: 193–210 Lilburn TG and Beatty JT (1992) Suppressor mutants of the photosynthetically incompetent pufX deletion mutant Rhodobacter capsulatus ∆RC6(pTL2). FEMS Microbiol Lett 100: 155–159 Lilburn TG, Haith CE, Prince RC and Beatty JT (1992) Pleiotropic effects of pufX gene deletion on the structure and function of the photosynthetic apparatus of Rhodobacter capsulatus. Biochim Biophys Acta 1100: 160–170 Lilburn TG, Prince RC and Beatty JT (1995) Mutation of the Ser2 codon of the light-harvesting B870 polypeptide of Rhodobacter capsulatus partially suppresses the pufX phenotype. J Bacteriol 177: 4593–4600 Lupo D, Ghosh R (2004) The reaction center H subunit is not required for high levels of light-harvesting complex 1 in Rhodospirillum rubrum mutants. J Bacteriol 186: 5585–5595 MacKenzie KR, Prestegard J and Engelman DM (1997) A transmembrane helix dimer: Structure and implications. Science 276: 131–133 McDermott G, Prince SM, Freer AA, Hawthornthwaite-Lawless AM, Papiz MZ, Cogdell RJ and Isaacs NW (1995) Crystal
178 structure of an integral membrane light-harvesting complex from photosynthetic bacteria. Nature 374: 517–521 McGlynn P, Hunter CN and Jones MR (1994) The Rhodobacter sphaeroides PufX protein is not required for photosynthetic competence in the absence of a light-harvesting system. FEBS Lett 349: 349–353 McGlynn P, Westerhuis WH, Jones MR and Hunter CN (1996) Consequences for the organization of reaction centre-lightharvesting antenna 1 (LH1) core complexes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides arising form deletion of amino acid residues at the C terminus of the LH1 α polypeptide. J Biol Chem 271: 3285–3292 Meckenstock RU, Brunisholz RA and Zuber H (1992) The light-harvesting core-complex and the B820-subunit from Rhodopseudomonas marina. 1. Purification and characterization. FEBS Lett 311: 128–134 Meryandini M, Drews G (1996) Import and assembly of the α and β-polypeptides of the light-harvesting complex I (B870) in the membrane system of Rhodobacter capsulatus investigated in an in vitro translation system. Photosynth Res 47: 21–31 Miller JF, Hinchigeri SB, Parkes-Loach PS, Callahan PM, Sprinkle JR, Riccobono JR and Loach PA (1987) Isolation and characterization of a subunit form of the light-harvesting complex of Rhodospirillum rubrum. Biochemistry 26: 5055–5062 Miller KR (1982) Three-dimensional structure of a photosynthetic membrane. Nature 300: 53–55 Niederman RA, Mallon DE and Langan JJ (1976) Membranes of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. IV. Assembly of chromatophores in low-aeration cell suspensions. Biochim Biophys Acta 440: 429–447 Olsen JD and Hunter CN (1994) Protein structure modeling of the bacterial light-harvesting complex. Photochem Photobiol 60: 521–535 Olsen JD, Sockalingum GD, Robert B and Hunter CN (1994) Modification of a hydrogen bond to a bacteriochlorophyll a molecule in the light-harvesting 1 antenna of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 91: 7124–7128 Olsen JD, Sturgis JN, Westerhuis WH, Fowler GJS, Hunter CN and Robert B (1997) Site-directed modification of the ligands to the bacteriochlorophylls of the light-harvesting LH1 and LH2 complexes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 36: 12625–12632 Papiz MZ, Prince SM, Hawthornthwaite-Lawless AM, McDermott G, Freer AA, Isaacs NW and Cogdell RJ (1996) A model for the photosynthetic apparatus of purple bacteria. Trends Plant Sci 1: 198–206 Parkes-Loach PS, Sprinkle JR and Loach PA (1988) Reconstitution of the B873 light-harvesting complex of Rhodospirillum rubrum from the separately isolated α- and β-polypeptides and bacteriochlorophyll a. Biochemistry 27: 2718–2727 Parkes-Loach PS, Law CJ, Recchia PA, Kehoe J, Nehrlich S, Chen J and Loach PA (2001) Role of the core region of the PufX protein in inhibition of reconstitution of the core light-harvesting complexes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Rhodobacter capsulatus. Biochemistry 40: 5593–5601 Pervushin KV, Orekhov VY, Popov AI, Musina LY and Arseniev AS (1994) Three-dimensional structure of (1-71)bacterioopsin solubilized in methanol/chloroform and SDS micelles determined by 15N-1H heteronuclear NMR spectroscopy. FEBS J 219: 571–583 Picorel R, Belanger G and Gingras G (1983) Antenna holochrome-
Per A. Bullough , Pu Qian and C. Neil Hunter B880 of Rhodospirillum rubrum S1-pigment, phospholipid, and polypeptide composition. Biochemistry 22: 2491–2497 Pucheu NL, Kerber NL, Pardo P, Brand M, Drews G and Garcia AF (1996) Bioenergetic factors controlling in vitro phosphorylation of LHIα (B870) polypeptides in membranes isolated from Rhodobacter capsulatus. Arch of Microbiol 165: 119–125 Pugh RJ, McGlynn P, Jones MR and Hunter CN (1998) The LH1RC core complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Interaction between components, time-dependent assembly, and topology of the PufX protein. Biochim Biophys Acta 1366: 301–316 Qian P, Addlesee HA, Ruban AV, Wang P, Bullough PA and Hunter CN (2003) A reaction center-light-harvesting 1 complex (RC-LH1) from a Rhodospirillum rubrum mutant with altered esterifying pigments. J Biol Chem 278: 23678–23685 Qian P, Hunter CN and Bullough PA (2005) The 8.5 Å projection structure of the core RC-LH1-PufX dimer of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Mol Biol 349: 948–960 Qian P, Bullough PA and Hunter CN (2008) 3-D reconstruction of a membrane-bending complex: The RC-LH1-PufX core dimer of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Biol Chem 283: 14002-14011 Recchia PA, Davis CM, Lilburn TG, Beatty JT, Parkes-Loach PS, Hunter CN and Loach PA (1998) Isolation of the PufX protein from Rhodobacter capsulatus and Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Evidence for its interaction with the α-polypeptide of the core light-harvesting complex. Biochemistry 37: 11055–11063 Richter MF, Baier J, Prem T , Oellerich S, Francia F, Venuroli G, Oesterhelt D, Southall J, Cogdell RJ and Köhler J (2007a) Symmetry matters for the electronic structure of core complexes from Rhodopseudomonas palustris and Rhodobacter sphaeroides PufX–. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 104: 6661–6665 Richter MF, Baier J, Southall J, Cogdell RJ, Oellerich S and Köhler J (2007b) Refinement of the X-ray structure of the RC-LH1 core complex from Rhodopseudomonas palustris by single-molecule spectroscopy. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 104: 20280–20284 Richter P, Cortez N and Drews G (1991) Possible role of the highly conserved amino-acids Trp-8 and Pro-13 in the N-terminal segment of the pigment-binding polypeptide LH1α of Rhodobacter-capsulatus. FEBS Lett 285: 80–84 Roszak AW, Howard TD, Southall J, Gardiner AT, Law CJ, Isaacs NW and Cogdell RJ (2003) Crystal structure of the RC-LH1 core complex from Rhodopseudomonas palustris. Science 302: 1969–1972 Russ WP and Engelman DM (1999) TOXCAT: A measure of transmembrane helix association in a biological membrane. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 96: 863–868 Russ WP and Engelman DM (2000) The GxxxG motif: A framework for transmembrane helix-helix association. J Mol Biol 296: 911–919 Scheuring S (2006) AFM studies of the supramolecular assembly of bacterial photosynthetic core-complexes. Curr Opin in Chem Biol 10: 387–393 Scheuring S and Sturgis JN (2005) Chromatic adaptation of photosynthetic membranes. Science 309: 484—487 Scheuring S, Seguin J, Marco S, Levy D, Robert B and Rigaud JL (2003) Nanodissection and high-resolution imaging of the Rhodopseudomonas viridis photosynthetic core complex in native membranes by AFM. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 100: 1690–1693 Scheuring S, Francia F, Busselez J, Melandri BA, Rigaud JL and
Chapter 9
Core Complexes of Purple Bacteria
Levy D (2004) Structural role of PufX in the dimerization of the photosynthetic core-complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Biol Chem 279: 3620–3626 Scheuring S, Busselez J, Levy D (2005) Structure of the dimeric PufX-containing core complex of Rhodobacter blasticus by in situ atomic force microscopy. J Biol Chem 280: 1426–1431 Scheuring S, Gonçalves RP, Prima V, Sturgis JN (2006) The photosynthetic apparatus of Rhodopseudomonas palustris: Structures and organization. J Mol Biol 358: 83–96 Şener MK, Olsen JD, Hunter CN and Schulten K (2007) Atomic level structural and functional model of a bacterial photosynthetic membrane vesicle (2007) Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 104: 15273–15278. Siebert CA, Qian P, Fotiadis D, Engel A, Hunter CN and Bullough PA (2004) Molecular architecture of photosynthetic membranes in Rhodobacter sphaeroides: The role of PufX. EMBO J 23: 690–700 Sockett RE, Donohue TJ, Varga AR and Kaplan S (1989) Control of photosynthetic membrane assembly in Rhodobacter sphaeroides mediated by puhA and flanking sequences. J Bacteriol 171: 436–446 Sorgen PL, Cahill SM, Krueger-Koplin RD, Krueger-Koplin ST, Schenck CC and Girvin ME (2002) Structure of the Rhodobacter sphaeroides light-harvesting 1 beta subunit in detergent micelles. Biochemistry 41: 31–41 Stahlberg H, Dubochet J, Vogel H and Ghosh R (1998) Are the light-harvesting I complexes from Rhodospirillum rubrum arranged around the reaction centre in a square geometry? J Mol Biol 282: 819–831 Stark W, Kühlbrandt W, Wildhaber I, Wehrli E and Muhlethaler K (1984) The structure of the photoreceptor unit of Rhodopseudomonas viridis. EMBO J 3: 777–783 Stiehle H, Cortez N, Klug G and Drews G (1990) A negatively charged N-terminus in the α-polypeptide inhibits formation of light-harvesting complex-I in Rhodobacter capsulatus. J Bacteriol 172: 7131–7137 Sturgis JN, Olsen JD, Robert B and Hunter CN (1997) Functions of conserved tryptophan residues of the core light-harvesting complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 36: 2772–2778 Tehrani A and Beatty JT (2004) Effects of precise deletions in Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction center genes on steady-state levels of reaction center proteins: A revised model for reaction center assembly. Photosynth Res 79: 101–108 Tehrani A, Prince RC and Beatty JT (2003) Effects of photosynthetic reaction center H protein domain mutations on photosynthetic properties and reaction center assembly in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 42: 8919–8928 Tunnicliffe RB, Ratcliffe EC, Hunter CN and Williamson MP (2006) The solution structure of the PufX polypeptide from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. FEBS Lett 580: 6967–6971 Varga AR and Kaplan S (1993) Synthesis and stability of reaction center polypeptides and implications for reaction center assembly in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Biol Chem 268: 19842–19850
179 Walz T and Ghosh R (1997) Two-dimensional crystallization of the light-harvesting I reaction centre photounit from Rhodospirillum rubrum. J Mol Biol 265: 107–111 Walz T, Jamieson SJ, Bowers CM, Bullough PA and Hunter CN (1998) Projection structures of three photosynthetic complexes from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: LH2 at 6 Å, LH1 and RC-LH1 at 25 Å. J Mol Biol 282: 833–845 Wang ZY, Gokan K, Kobayashi M and Nozawa T (2005) Solution structures of the core light-harvesting α and β polypeptides from Rhodospirillum rubrum: Implications for the pigment-protein and protein-protein interactions. J Mol Biol 347: 465–477 Welte W and Kreutz W (1982) Formation, structure and composition of a planar hexagonal lattice composed of specific proteinlipid complexes in the thylakoid membranes of Rhodopseudomonas viridis. Biochim Biophys Acta 692: 479–488 Westerhuis WHJ, Hunter CN, van Grondelle R and Niederman RA (1999) Modeling of oligomeric-state dependent spectral heterogeneity in the B875 light-harvesting complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides by numerical simulation. J Phys Chem B 103: 7733–7742 Westerhuis WHJ, Sturgis JN, Ratcliffe EC, Hunter CN and Niederman RA (2002) Isolation, size estimates, and spectral heterogeneity of an oligomeric series of light-harvesting 1 complexes from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 41: 8698–8707 Wong DH, Collins WJ, Harmer A, Lilburn TG and Beatty JT (1996) Directed mutagenesis of the Rhodobacter capsulatus puhA gene and Orf 214: Pleiotropic effects on photosynthetic reaction center and light-harvesting 1 complexes. J Bacteriol 178: 2334–2342 Young CS and Beatty JT (1998) Topological model of the Rhodobacter capsulatus light-harvesting complex I assembly protein LhaA (previously known as ORF1696). J Bacteriol 180: 4742–4745 Young CS, Reyes RC and Beatty JT (1998) Genetic complementation and kinetic analyses of Rhodobacter capsulatus ORF1696 mutants indicate that the ORF1696 protein enhances assembly of the light-harvesting I complex. J Bacteriol 180: 1759–1765 Youvan DC, Elder JT, Sandlin DE, Zsebo K, Alder DP, Panopoulos NJ, Marrs BL and Hearst JE (1982) R-prime site-directed transposon Tn7 mutagenesis of the photosynthetic apparatus in Rhodopseudomonas capsulata. J Mol Biol 162: 17–41 Zsebo KM and Hearst JE (1984) Genetic-physical mapping of a photosynthetic gene cluster from Rhodopseudomonas capsulata. Cell 37: 937–947 Zuber H (1985) Structure and function of light-harvesting complexes and their polypeptides. Photochem Photobiol 42: 821–844 Zuber H and Cogdell RJ (1995) Structure and organization of purple bacterial antenna complexes. In: Blankenship RE, Madigan, MT, Bauer CE (eds) Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 2), pp 315–348. Kluwer Academic Publishers
Chapter 10 Structure-Function Relationships in Bacterial LightHarvesting Complexes Investigated by Reconstitution Techniques Paul A. Loach* and Pamela S. Parkes-Loach Department of Biochemistry, Molecular Biology and Cell Biology, Northwestern University, 2205 Tech Drive, Evanston, IL 60208-3500, U.S.A.
Summary ............................................................................................................................................................... 181 I. Introduction..................................................................................................................................................... 182 II. Reversible Dissociation of Core Light-Harvesting 1 Complexes to a Subunit Form (B820)........................... 182 III. Reversible Dissociation of B820 to its Fundamental Components................................................................. 183 IV. Cofactor Requirements .................................................................................................................................. 184 V. Cofactor – Protein Interactions ....................................................................................................................... 184 A. Mg Coordination of Bacteriochlorophyll............................................................................................ 184 B. Bacteriochlorophyll – Protein Hydrogen Bonds ................................................................................ 186 C. Steric Requirements for Bacteriochlorophyll Binding ....................................................................... 187 VI. Cofactor – Cofactor Interactions ..................................................................................................................... 188 VII. Protein – Protein Interactions .......................................................................................................................... 188 A. B820 ................................................................................................................................................. 188 B. Light-Harvesting 1 and 2 Complexes .............................................................................................. 190 VIII. Effect of PufX on Reconstitution of Light-Harvesting 1 Complexes ............................................................... 191 IX. In vitro versus In vivo Assembly of Complexes .............................................................................................. 192 A. Oligomerization of B820 ................................................................................................................... 192 B. Reconstitution of B820 and Reaction Center Complexes to Form a Photoreceptor Complex ......... 192 C. Role of Carotenoids ......................................................................................................................... 193 X. Reconstitution of the Reaction Center............................................................................................................ 193 Acknowledgments ................................................................................................................................................. 195 References ............................................................................................................................................................ 195
Summary Exploration of conditions to achieve the reversible dissociation of the core light-harvesting complexes (LH1) of photosynthetic bacteria led to the isolation of the fundamental subunit complex, B820. Further reversible dissociation of B820 provided conditions for reconstitution of both this subunit complex and LH1 from separately isolated polypeptides and bacteriochlorophyll (BChl). Native-like LH1 complexes have also been reconstituted using BChl, isolated polypeptides from Rhodospirillum (Rsp.) rubrum or Rhodobacter (Rba.) sphaeroides and carotenoid. The reconstitution methodology has also been applied to the peripheral light-harvesting complex (LH2) of Phaeospirillum (Phs.) molischianum in which it was demonstrated that LH2 contained the same B820-type subunit structure found in LH1. Since the interaction between B820 and its individual components could be studied under equilibrium condi*Author for correspondence, email: [email protected]
C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty (eds): The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria, pp. 181–198. © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V.
182
Paul A. Loach and Pamela S. Parkes-Loach
tions, many structure-function questions could be addressed as well as thermodynamic parameters established. The subunit structure was shown to consist of α1β1•2BChl with overlap at rings III and V of the BChls. Minimal requirements for B820 formation include (1) a polypeptide of at least 26 amino acids, 18 of which constitute an α-helix with hydrophobic side chains, (2) a His residue for coordination and hydrogen bonding to BChl and (3) a Trp residue for hydrogen bonding to the C31 carbonyl of BChl. The His interaction accounted for over half of the stabilization energy of the B820 complex. Hydrogen bonds involving the Trp residues provide a second major stabilization of approximately 3.5 kcal/Trp. Finally, some stabilization is provided by specific interactions between the α and β polypeptides in their N-terminal regions, most likely exhibiting the same structural motif as found in the crystal structure of Phs. molischianum LH2. Reconstitution methodology has also been used to study formation of the reaction center-LH1 (RC-LH1) core complex, which exhibited physical properties analogous to the native complex, and to study the interaction and function of PufX. Currently, the isolation and reconstitution methodology is being applied to reconstitute the RC from its fundamental components. I. Introduction In order to thoroughly understand the structurefunction relationships of supramolecular systems, it is immensely useful if the system can be reversibly dissociated into sub-complexes. Even more powerful in probing how structure enables function is the ability to reconstitute a supramolecular system from its fundamental components. Because of limited solubility, development of methodology for reconstitution of supramolecular complexes that reside in membranes has been especially challenging. This chapter reviews the successful reversible dissociation and reconstitution of light-harvesting (LH) and photoreceptor complexes (PRC) of photosynthetic bacteria. First, the core (LH1) and secondary (LH2) light-harvesting complexes will be discussed, then reconstitution of PRC from the LH1 and RC complexes and finally progress on reconstitution of the RC from its fundamental components. An emphasis is placed on the wealth of information and insights that can be obtained using reconstitution methodology. Abbreviations: BChl – bacteriochlorophyll; BChl a is implied unless BChl b is indicated; CD – circular dichroism; EM – electron microscopy; HPLC – high performance liquid chromatography; KA – association constant for binding; KD – dissociation constant for binding; LH1 – core light-harvesting complex, also called B875, B890, etc. depending on the far-red absorption maximum; LH2 – peripheral light-harvesting complex, also called B800-850, for example; NMR – nuclear magnetic resonance; PAGE – polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis; Phs. – Phaeospirillum; PRC – photoreceptor complex which contains LH1 and RC; QB – quinone on the B-side of the reaction center; Rba. – Rhodobacter; RC – reaction center; Rps. – Rhodopseudomonas; RR – resonance Raman; Rsp. – Rhodospirillum; SDS – sodium dodecyl sulfate; UQ – ubiquinone; β-OG – n-octyl β-D-glucopyranoside; λmax – wavelength of maximum absorption
Ultimately, complete understanding of how supramolecular complexes work can only be achieved by putting the system together from its simplest parts. II. Reversible Dissociation of Core LightHarvesting 1 Complexes to a Subunit Form (B820) Since LH1 of photosynthetic bacteria is a complex containing 12 to 16 molecules each of α and β polypeptides and 24 to 32 molecules of bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) (Loach and Sekura, 1968; Francke and Amesz, 1995; Loach and Parkes-Loach, 1995; Chapter 9, Bullough et al.), it seemed likely that this structure was formed from oligomerization of a subunit complex whose structure would consist of αnβn•2nBChl where n is a small number (Loach and Sekura, 1968; Miller et al., 1987; Francke and Amesz, 1995; Loach and Parkes-Loach, 1995). Early attempts to use detergents to reversibly dissociate LH1 were largely unsuccessful until carotenoid components were first removed either by extraction or by studying mutants in which carotenoid biosynthesis was blocked (Miller et al., 1987; Loach and Parkes-Loach, 1995). In addition, the availability of new types of detergent (e.g., n-octyl β-D-glucopyranoside (β-OG), lauryl maltoside) that were more gentle than lauryl dimethyl amine oxide, Triton X-100 and sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), but more effective than sodium cholate and deoxycholate, enabled the preparation of subunit complexes that could be re-associated to form LH1 (Miller et al., 1987). Careful control of dissociating conditions enabled a quantitative yield of B820 from Rsp. rubrum LH1 which could also be quantitatively re-associated to re-form LH1.
Chapter 10
Light-Harvesting Reconstitution Studies
The B820 complex has been extensively studied. It was initially prepared from LH1 complexes of Rsp. rubrum (Miller et al., 1987), Rba. sphaeroides (Chang et al., 1990b) and Rba. capsulatus (Heller and Loach, 1990). Subsequently, it has also been prepared from LH1 complexes of Rhodopseudomonas (Rps.) viridis (Parkes-Loach et al., 1994), Rps. marina (Meckenstock et al., 1992), Rhodocyclus gelatinosus (Jirsakova and Reiss-Husson, 1993) and Chromatium purpuratum (Kerfeld et al., 1994) and the LH2 complex of Phaeospirillum (Phs.) molischianum (Todd et al., 1998). It appears to be the fundamental subunit of light-harvesting complexes of photosynthetic bacteria. B820 has been shown to have a composition of α1β1•2BChl. The two BChls strongly interact at van der Waals distance as determined by absorption (Miller et al., 1987; Chang et al., 1990a; ParkesLoach et al., 1995), circular dichroism (CD) (Miller et al., 1987; Chang et al., 1990a; Parkes-Loach et al., 1995) fluorescence (Chang et al., 1990a), nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) (Wang et al., 2002), electron paramagnetic resonance (Srivatsan and Norris, 2001), singlet-singlet and singlet-triplet annihilation (van Mourik et al., 1991) spectroscopies. Absorption spectra indicate that one or more intermediates are formed during dissociation and reassociation of LH1 (Miller et al., 1987; van Mourik et al., 1992; Loach and Parkes-Loach, 1995; Pandit et al., 2001, 2003). In the presence of carotenoid, B820 associates to form an LH1-type complex with at least one intermediate species (Davis et al., 1995; Fiedor and Scheer, 2005; Chapter 46, Braun and Fiedor). B820 can also be re-associated in the presence of RCs and phospholipid to form an RC-LH1 complex displaying many of the characteristics of the native PRC (Bustamante and Loach, 1994). III. Reversible Dissociation of B820 to its Fundamental Components Under appropriate conditions of concentration, temperature, pH and detergent concentration, B820 can be reversibly dissociated to its fundamental components and the separately-isolated polypeptides and BChl can be used to reconstitute B820 and LH1 (Fig. 1) (Parkes-Loach et al., 1988, 1994; Chang et al., 1990b; Heller and Loach, 1990). The following equilibria have been demonstrated (Sturgis and Robert, 1994; Loach and Parkes-Loach, 1995; Law et al., 2003).
183
Fig. 1. Reconstitution of B820 and LH1 using the native α- and β-polypeptides of Rba. sphaeroides and BChl. Spectra were recorded at 0.90% β-OG (dashed curve), 0.75% β-OG (diamond symbols), 0.66% β-OG after chilling on ice for 1 hour (solid black curve) and 0.66% β-OG after chilling overnight (grey curve). Concentrations of reactants were: 3.1 µM α-polypeptide, 2.2 µM β-polypeptide, and 1.1 µM BChl, at 0.66% β-OG. Spectra were recorded in 1 cm cuvettes and the data at 0.90% and 0.75% β-OG were multiplied by appropriate factors to compare each spectrum at the polypeptide concentrations of 0.66% β-OG.
α + BChl
α•BChl
(1)
β + BChl
β•BChl
(2)
α•BChl + β•BChl
B820
(3)
Under conditions where KD for eq. (3) is much smaller than the KDs for eqs. (1) and (2), the equilibrium measured at low concentrations (Law et al., 2003) may be expressed by: α + β + 2BChl ↔ B820
(4)
which is the result of addition of eqs. (1), (2) and (3). The KD for eq. (4) equals the product of the KDs for eqs. (1), (2) and (3). The equations for these equilibria are not complete in that they ignore the role of interacting detergent molecules. BChl and each polypeptide, as well as each complex formed, are ‘solvated’ by detergent to form mixed micelles. Thus, as each complex is formed, ‘bound’ detergent is released as the hydrophobic surface area of the complex is less than the sum of those for the separately interacting species. Because of this, the β-OG concentration dependence of KD for the reactions of equations (1) to (4) can be different and the relationship between the KDs may change with detergent concentration. It would
184
Paul A. Loach and Pamela S. Parkes-Loach
be expected that the KD for reaction (3) would have a greater dependence on detergent concentration than those for reactions (1) and (2) because a larger number of β-OG molecules should be released as the B820 complex forms. It should also be noted that the number of bound detergent molecules will depend on the hydrophobic surface of each polypeptide and is therefore dependent on the amino acid sequence and secondary structure. IV. Cofactor Requirements Even though the effects of detergent would be expected to vary somewhat with variations in the structure of the chromophore and protein, this contribution to a change in KD can probably be neglected relative to the effect of small but important changes in structure. Thus, measurements of KD for a series of BChl analogs at constant β-OG concentration can be assumed to reflect the effects of structural change of the analog on the complex irrespective of small changes in βOG interaction. The first measurements of this type examined analogs of BChl with LH1 polypeptides from two different organisms, Rsp. rubrum and Rba. sphaeroides (Parkes-Loach et al., 1990; Davis et al., 1996). These systems showed the following common requirements for formation of the subunit complex and LH1: (1) Mg or a metal of similar size and coordination chemistry (e.g., Zn, Cd, Ni), (2) a bacteriochlorin oxidation state of the macrocyclic ring, (3) a 132 carbomethoxy group (see Fig. 2 for numbering of BChl), and (4) an intact ring V. Some structural features were not as critically important. For example, the subunit complex and LH1 could be formed with both sets of polypeptides and BChl b instead of BChl a, as well as with analogs of BChl a containing either short (ethanol) or long (phytol) esterifying alcohols. Two derivatives were identified that behave differently with the two sets of polypeptides. The 3-acetyl group is required to form LH1 in both bacteria, although a subunit-type complex was readily formed with [3-vinyl] BChl a and the polypeptides of Rsp. rubrum but formed only slightly under special conditions with polypeptides of Rba. sphaeroides. [132OH] BChl ap formed both subunit- and LH1-type complexes with the α and β polypeptides of Rba. sphaeroides but not with those of Rsp. rubrum. Thus, some subtle differences in the BChl binding sites exist in the LH1 complexes of these two bacteria. The greater stability of the B820-type
Fig. 2. Structure of BChl.
complex with the Zn analog of BChl has been used to advantage in many biomimetic studies (Kashiada et al., 2000a,b; Wendling et al., 2002; Nagata et al., 2003a,b; Dewa et al., 2005). V. Cofactor – Protein Interactions A. Mg Coordination of Bacteriochlorophyll From the amino acid sequences of the α and β polypeptides of LH1 and LH2 complexes (Fig. 3), it was predicted that these proteins would have one transmembrane α-helical span and that a conserved His located within this spanning segment would provide the ligand coordinated to the Mg atom of BChl (Zuber and Brunisholz, 1991). Consistent with the importance of this role for His, mutation of this residue to other amino acids resulted in complete loss, or a severely limited expression, of LH1 (Bylina et al., 1988; Olsen, 1994; Davis et al., 1997; Olsen et al., 1997). Further confirmation of this role for His came from the early application of resonance Raman (RR) spectroscopy to studying preparations of LH1 and LH2. From the comparison with model complexes, it was concluded that His side chains may be the Mg ligands (Robert and Lutz, 1985). Also derived from early
Chapter 10
Light-Harvesting Reconstitution Studies
RR studies was the assignment that the coordination number of the central Mg was 5, indicating a squarepyramidal complex (Cotton and van Duyne, 1981). Final confirmation of Mg coordination in LH2 came from the determination of the crystal structure of the LH2 complex from Rps. acidophila (McDermott et al., 1995; Prince et al., 1997) and Phs. molischianum (Koepke et al., 1996). To evaluate the importance of this His residue, mutants of Rba. sphaeroides were prepared in which His0 was changed to Asn, Tyr, or Leu (Olsen, 1994). By spectral examination of the whole cells, only the mutant cells containing βHis0→ Asn exhibited a slight LH1 complex absorbance. A β polypeptide was isolated in very low yield from the βHis0→Asn mutant; when this polypeptide was tested in the reconstitution assay, formation of a sub-
185
unit-type complex could not be observed under our assay conditions (Davis et al., 1997). The inability to demonstrate formation of a subunit-type complex means that the stabilization of this complex by His coordination by the β polypeptide is at least 4.5 kcal mol–1. From model studies, imidazole coordination to BChl to form a 5-coordinate complex is expected to occur with 4.5–5.5 kcal mol–1 binding energy (Cotton, 1976). In the case of the α-polypeptide isolated from the mutant αHis0→Asn, an LH1-type complex could not be formed. Because the conditions used to reconstitute an LH1-type complex employ lowering the β-OG concentration to below the critical micelle concentration, it is surprising that even this driving force is insufficient to overcome the absence of the His ligand.
Fig. 3. Amino acid sequences of the light-harvesting polypeptides of some photosynthetic bacteria. Sources: 1, 2, 4, 7, 8, 10, 11 (Zuber and Cogdell, 1995); 3, 9 (Youvan et al., 1984; Theiler et al., 1985); 5 (Visschers et al., 1995); 6 (Germeroth et al., 1993). For ease of comparison, the sequences have been aligned relative to the BChl-liganding His residue, labeled position 0. Asterisk: The first approximately 7 amino acids of the LH1 β and the last 2 amino acids of the LH1 α polypeptides of Phs. molischianum could not be definitely identified by sequencing. See Visschers et al. (1995).
Paul A. Loach and Pamela S. Parkes-Loach
186 B. Bacteriochlorophyll – Protein Hydrogen Bonds The results obtained from reconstitution experiments using analogs of BChl indicated that the C31 acetyl group and the C132 keto group were important for formation of B820 and LH1. Since these groups would be very good hydrogen bond acceptors, it was assumed that amino acid side chains, or possibly peptide backbone N-H groups, would be the hydrogen bond donors. Using site-directed mutants, Fowler et al. (1994) demonstrated that the tyrosine side chains of the α polypeptide at positions +13 and +14 (see Fig. 3 for numbering) on the α subunit interact with the acetyl carbonyl groups of BChl responsible for the 850-nm absorption in LH2 of Rba. sphaeroides. This was confirmed in the crystal structure of LH2 of Rps. acidophila (McDermott et al., 1995, Prince et al., 1997). Correspondingly, in the LH1 complex of Rba. sphaeroides, the acetyl carbonyls of BChl were shown to interact with Trp residues, one with αTrp+11 and one with βTrp+9 (Olsen et al., 1994; Sturgis et al., 1997) which is consistent with the crystal structure of LH2 from Phs. molischianum (Koepke et al., 1996) whose LH2 shows many common features to LH1 (Germeroth et al., 1993). Reconstitution experiments with α and β LH1
polypeptides isolated from Rba. sphaeroides modified by site-directed mutagenesis also demonstrated the importance of αTrp+11 and βTrp+9 of Rba. sphaeroides in stabilizing B820 as well as LH1 (Davis et al., 1997; Kehoe et al., 1998). Unique to these measurements was the ability to determine the magnitude of the energy of stabilization contributed by these hydrogen bonding interactions (see Table 1 and Kehoe et al., 1998). The role of hydrogen bonding to the C132 carbonyl group of BChl was indicated to also change somewhat in B820 compared with LH1 (Visschers et al., 1993) suggesting a change in hydrogen bonding to the protein. From the crystal structures of LH2 of Phs. molischianum (Koepke et al., 1996; Hu and Schulten, 1998) and mutational studies of Olsen et al. (1997), His0, in addition to providing the coordinated ligand to BChl, was indicated to form a hydrogen bond with the C132 carbonyl group of BChl coordinated to the partner polypeptide. Thus, a kind of cross-hydrogen bonding occurs which would help stabilize the subunit structure. By conducting reconstitution experiments with a chemically-synthesized β polypeptide in which 3-methylhistidine was substituted for His0, the magnitude of this stabilization energy was estimated to be quite significant for subunit formation (Parkes-Loach et al., 2004). In addition, reconstitution experiments with this analog established that B820 has the dimeric
Table 1. Association constants of reconstituted subunit complexes System Rsp. rubrum
Rba. sphaeroides
Polypeptide (µM at 0.75% β−OG) native β (2.0) + native α (1.7)
@0.90% β−OG 126
KA (M3 x 10–16) @0.75% β−OG ≤300
native β (3.7)
2
24
rrβ31 (4.9) (chemically synthesized)
12
120
native β (1.8) + native α (1.2)
38
≤300
native β (6.1)
23
200
enzyme-truncated sphβCP2 (4.9) + native α (2.4)
≤0.1
0.7
sphβ31 (5.5) (chemically synthesized)
40
≤300
sphβ37 (5.4) (chemically synthesized)
26
≤300
sphβ41 (5.6) (chemically synthesized) + native α (6.8)
19
≤300
sphβ41 (5.6) (chemically synthesized)
8.3
79
sphβ31W+6→F (5.5) (chemically synthesized)
1.5
22
sphβ31R+7→L (6.0) (chemically synthesized)
0.5
6
sphβ31W+9→F (14.2) (chemically synthesized)
≤0.1
0.5
Data and polypeptide nomenclature from Kehoe et al., 1998.
Chapter 10
Light-Harvesting Reconstitution Studies
187
Fig. 4. One quarter of the ring structure of Phs. molischianum LH2 (Koepke et al., 1996) showing BChl and the coordinated His side chains.
structure with π-overlap at rings III and V (Fig. 4) which involves cross-hydrogen bonding from His0. This conclusion is also consistent with the NMR experiments of Wang et al. (2002) in which overlap at rings III and V was observed. These experiments provide important information on the structure of B820 because it has not yet been possible to solve its structure by NMR or by crystallization of this subunit form. C. Steric Requirements for Bacteriochlorophyll Binding Binding the relatively flat BChl molecules to the cylindrical α-helical transmembrane segments of the α and β polypeptides requires amino acids at the –4 position to have small side chains. As pointed out in the extensive work of Zuber and co-workers (Zuber and Brunisholz, 1991), this amino acid is usually Ala and changes to amino acids with side chains larger than Val resulted in the lack of expression of LH1 and LH2 (Bylina et al., 1988). The phytyl or geranylgeranyl esterifying alcohol accounts for about 40% of the mass of the cofactor. It would therefore be expected that it would be important for hydrophobic packing of LH1 and LH2. Although this may be true, substitution of an ethyl group for the geranylgeranyl esterifying alcohol made little difference to B820 or LH1 formation, although LH1 was less stable than when native BChl was used (ParkesLoach et al., 1990; Davis et al., 1996). It would appear that detergent molecules (β-OG) can largely replace the hydrophobic tail of BChl in the B820 heterodimer and in oligomerization to form LH1. In the crystal structures of LH2, the esterifying alcohol of BChl may play a more specific role as the esterifying alcohol of the B850 BChls interdigitate with carotenoid and the
esterifying alcohol of the B800 BChl (McDermott et al., 1995; Koepke et al., 1996; Prince et al., 1997; Chapter 8, Gabrielsen et al.). In addition to hydrogen bond formation between BChl and Trp residues in the C-terminal segments of the α and β polypeptides, other structural constraints exist in these C-terminal regions. As the polypeptides progress from the N-termini through the middle α-helical segments, they then turn to protect the edge of BChl from the aqueous environment outside the membrane and provide the Trp side chains for hydrogen bonding. The amino acids in this region (Fig. 3) appear to be specifically chosen to serve this function. In particular, the sequence from +4 to +9 in the β polypeptide of LH1 seems most restrictive and requires the amino acids W/Y X W R/K P W. Several reconstitution experiments support this conclusion. On the other hand, the Phe at +10 of the β polypeptide in Rba. sphaeroides was shown to be unnecessary for reconstitution (Kehoe et al., 1998). Consistent with this observation, the amino acid at this location is not conserved. Although some variability is found at position +4, changing the Tyr (the residue found in the Rba. sphaeroides β polypeptide) to Met (the residue found in the Rba. capsulatus β polypeptide) substantially weakens B820 formation (Davis et al., 1997). The importance of this region from +4 to +9 was also underscored in experiments testing what modifications would need to be made to the LH2 β polypeptide of Rba. sphaeroides to enable it to form homodimeric B820. In this regard, it was found that substitution of the LH1 amino acid sequence from +4 to +10 into the LH2 β polypeptide was sufficient to enable the modified LH2 β polypeptide to form a B820-type complex (Todd et al., 1999). As mentioned earlier, it is especially noteworthy that the LH2 β polypeptide of Phs. molischianum
188 has been demonstrated to form a B820-type complex (Todd et al., 1998). This further underscores the importance of the C-terminal segment in which the LH2 β polypeptide of Phs. molischianum has the same amino acid sequence (W V W K P W) as found in the LH1 β polypeptides. Interestingly, the LH2 β polypeptide of Phs. molischianum, in the absence of other polypeptides, also formed a further red-shifted complex whose spectrum resembled the 850-nm absorption band of LH2. As further indication of the versatility of this polypeptide, in the presence of the LH1 α polypeptide of Rsp. rubrum or Phs. molischianum, an LH1-type complex was formed, but in the presence of the LH2 α polypeptide of Phs. molischianum an LH2 complex was formed (Todd et al., 1998). This is the first reported reconstitution of an LH2 complex using only isolated LH2 polypeptides and BChl. It is also the first example of an LH2 β polypeptide that can form an LH1 subunit-type complex and an LH1-type complex when paired with an LH1 α polypeptide. Somewhat greater variability seems acceptable for the C-terminal segment of the LH1 α polypeptides. The amino acids from +4 to +13 seem most conserved, requiring much of the sequence L S/G T (D) R/K N W M (D/E). The C-terminal amino acids of the Rsp. rubrum α polypeptide could be removed after Glu+13 with no apparent effect on B820 or LH1 formation (Meadows et al., 1995). Also, deletion of amino acids beyond +12 in the Rba. sphaeroides α polypeptide did not affect the ability to form B820 and LH1 although the wavelength maximum was blue-shifted (Davis et al., 1997) and LH1 was not well expressed when residues +13 to the C-terminus were omitted (McGlynn et al., 1996). VI. Cofactor – Cofactor Interactions The purpose of the protein structure of LH1 and LH2 appears to be to organize BChl molecules in such a way that they form a large overlapping array so that energy is absorbed in the near infrared and the excited state is quickly delocalized among the many molecules and easily transferred to other LH complexes or the RC. The mechanism of formation of LH1 and LH2 involves the oligomerization of an αβ heterodimer, B820. The spatial relationship and interaction of the two BChls in B820 were apparent from the shift of λmax compared with monomeric BChl (Miller et al., 1987; Chang et al., 1990a), from
Paul A. Loach and Pamela S. Parkes-Loach the CD spectrum (Miller et al., 1987; Chang et al., 1990a), from fluorescence polarization (Visschers et al., 1991), and from singlet-singlet annihilation spectroscopy (van Mourik et al., 1991). More recent experiments demonstrating close association of the two BChls of B820 include NMR (Wang et al., 2002) and EPR (Srivatsan and Norris, 2001) spectroscopies. The excitonic coupling of the two BChls, their center-to-center distance and parallel or antiparallel orientation of Qy axes were concluded from the spectroscopic data well before the LH2 crystal structures were known. Comparison of this early model for Rsp. rubrum B820 (van Mourik et al., 1991) to a subunit called the αβ heterodimer in the crystal structure of Phs. molischianum LH2 (Koepke et al., 1996) is striking in its accuracy in that the distance between Mg atoms in the αβ heterodimer of the crystal structure was 9.2 Å (compared with 11 Å in the model), the Qy axes of the BChl are antiparallel to each other and parallel to the membrane plane as proposed by the model and the π-overlap of the two macrocycles assures excitonic coupling. Even the rotation of 17o along an axis perpendicular to the membrane plane used to fit CD data for B820 is consistent with a similar angle between BChls in the LH2 structure of Phs. molischianum. The B820 subunit complexes readily associate to form LH1 or LH2, depending on the subtleties of cofactor-protein and protein-protein interactions. The structures of LH1 and LH2 have been modeled based on association of a fundamental subunit (Hu and Schulten, 1998; Fotiadis et al., 2004; Georgakopoulou et al., 2002, 2006). Although it is possible that small changes in hydrogen bonding occur as LH1 is formed (Sturgis and Robert, 1994), the overall B820 structure remains intact as is evident in the crystal structure of Phs. molischianum LH2 (Koepke et al., 1996). Clearly, the BChl ensembles in LH2 and LH1 have been optimized for light absorption and energy transfer. It is impressive that this regularity of structure has been accomplished with minimal protein involvement to provide the scaffold, protect the BChl and achieve an ideal spatial distribution for optimal absorption of light. VII. Protein – Protein Interactions A. B820 As a result of hybrid reconstitution experiments in-
Chapter 10
Light-Harvesting Reconstitution Studies
volving the α and β polypeptides from four different bacteria, little specificity was found to be required for B820 formation in the membrane-spanning middle segment (Loach et al., 1994). This is consistent with a highly variable amino acid sequence in this region except for His0 and Ala-4. In addition, the fact that the two BChls exist as a closely interacting dimer with π-overlap would require the α and β polypeptides to be separated by the BChl dimer in their α-helical middle segments. These conclusions were solidified when the crystal structures of two LH2 complexes were completed (McDermott et al., 1995; Koepke et al., 1996; Prince et al., 1997). With regard to protein-protein interaction at the N-terminus, B820-type complexes could be formed with only the LH1 β polypeptides, even when the Nterminal segment was greatly shortened by proteolytic removal (Meadows et al., 1995) or in chemically-synthesized analogs (Meadows et al., 1998). Also, much of the C-terminal segment of the α polypeptide could be removed by proteolysis without effect on B820 formation (Meadows et al., 1995; Parkes-Loach et al., 2004). Thus, there is little protein-protein interaction required for homodimeric B820 formation using only the β polypeptide in reconstitution experiments. The stabilization of the homodimeric B820 complex formed is the result of coordination of His0 to Mg of BChl, the cross hydrogen bonding from His0 to the 132 keto carbonyl of the other BChl and hydrophobic complementarity between the BChls and the hydrophobic surfaces of the polypeptides. On the other hand, while heterodimeric B820 formation as found in native complexes is also stabilized by interactions similar to those in the homodimeric complex, it is further stabilized by interactions between the N-terminal segments of the α and β polypeptides (Parkes-Loach et al., 2004). On the basis of results with the chemically synthesized polypeptides, protease-modified polypeptides and mutants, the importance of a stretch of 9–13 amino acids at the N-terminal end of the α and β polypeptides is underscored. A progressive loss of interaction with the LH1 β polypeptide was found as the first three N-terminal amino acids of the LH1 α-polypeptide of Rsp. rubrum were removed. The absence of the N-terminal formylmethionine (fMet), or conversion of the sulfur in this fMet to the sulfoxide, resulted in a decrease in LH1 formation. In addition to the removal of fMet, removal of the next two amino acids also resulted in a decrease in KA for B820 formation and nearly eliminated the ability to form LH1. It was suggested
189
that the first three amino acids (fMetTrpArg) of the LH1 α-polypeptide of Rsp. rubrum form a cluster that is most likely involved in close interaction with the side chain of His-18 of the β polypeptide and also participates in hydrophobic interactions with the β polypeptide (Arluison et al., 2004; Parkes-Loach et al., 2004). These results provide evidence that the folding motif of the α- and β-polypeptides in the N-terminal region observed in crystal structures of Phs. molischianum LH2 is also present in LH1 and contributes significantly to stabilizing the complex. In experiments designed to determine the minimal protein structure that would form a B820 complex with BChl, the proteolytic enzyme endoprotease GluC was used to prepare a Rba. sphaeroides β polypeptide in which the N-terminal segment was removed up through Glu-20. This 30 amino acid polypeptide displayed good activity for forming a homodimeric B820-type complex. To further explore this region of the β polypeptide, a chemically-synthesized polypeptide of 31 amino acids with an amino acid sequence identical to that of the Rba. sphaeroides β polypeptide between residues –20 and +10 was prepared and demonstrated to support formation of B820 with as high a binding affinity as the native Rba. sphaeroides β polypeptide (Table 1). From the subsequent use of trypsin, more of the N-terminus of the Rsp. rubrum β polypeptide was removed through Lys-17. This polypeptide would still form a B820type complex but with a lower affinity (Meadows et al., 1995). In agreement with this result, Nango et al. (2002) chemically-synthesized a polypeptide of 27 amino acids reproducing the amino acid sequence of the Rba. sphaeroides β polypeptide from residue –16 to +10 and found that a B820-type complex was readily formed by reconstitution with BChl. Interestingly, an analog of this polypeptide with a C-terminal Cys also readily formed a B820-type complex (Nango et al., 2002). An even shorter polypeptide containing 24 amino acids was chemically-synthesized by Noy and Dutton (2006) and shown to form a B820type complex. This latter polypeptide reproduced the amino acid sequence of the Rba. sphaeroides β polypeptide from residue –8 to +10 and also contained the sequence from –20 to –16 attached to the N-terminus. In further experiments with shorter synthetic polypeptides, our laboratory showed that a synthetic polypeptide of 16 amino acids reproducing the sequence of the Rba. sphaeroides β polypeptide from residue –5 to +10 would not support homodimeric
Paul A. Loach and Pamela S. Parkes-Loach
190 B820 formation (Meadows et al., 1998). This latter polypeptide was also lengthened by adding LysIleSerLys to the N-terminus to improve solubility, but this 20 amino acid polypeptide also failed to support formation of a B820-type complex (Meadows et al., 1998). Nango et al. (2002) also chemicallysynthesized a polypeptide of 22 amino acids with a sequence identical to that of the Rba. sphaeroides β polypeptide from residue –11 to +10 and found that it also would not support formation of a B820-type complex. One might interpret these experiments with variable lengths of the N-terminal part of the Rba. sphaeroides β polypeptide to indicate that the α-helical middle segment must be of sufficient length to stabilize the hydrophobic esterifying alcohols of BChl. This apparently requires at least 13 N-terminal amino acids to His 0 to provide almost 4 complete turns of the helix (about 20 Å long). Consistent with this conclusion is the location of the B850 BChl esterifying alcohol in the crystal structure of Phs. molischianum (Koepke et al., 1996). The minimal requirements to support formation of a B820-type complex are summarized in Table 2. Three of these seem to be essential properties of both the α and β polypeptides (or for only the β polypeptide in forming a homodimeric B820-type complex): (1) an α-helical segment of at least five to six turns in which the amino acid side chains are predominantly hydrophobic groups (Meadows et al., 1995, 1998); (2) His at position 0 (Bylina et al., 1988; Davis et al., 1997; Olsen et al., 1997) whose interaction with BChl provides over half of the stabilization energy (Loach and Parkes-Loach, 1995), and (3) appropriate placement of amino acids with relatively small hydrophobic side chains (e.g., at position –4) to allow appropriate packing of BChl and the α-helical portions of the protein (Bylina et al., 1988). Additional structural features that are very important are Trp+9 in the β polypeptide (Davis et al., 1997; Sturgis et
al., 1997; Kehoe et al., 1998) and Trp+11 in the α polypeptide (Olsen et al., 1994; Sturgis et al., 1997). Other structural features that seem to be collectively important in the β polypeptide are Trp (or Tyr) at position +4, Trp at position +6 (Davis et al., 1997; Sturgis et al., 1997; Kehoe et al., 1998) and an Arg or Lys at position +7 (Davis et al., 1997; Kehoe et al., 1998). Any one of these latter structural features seems to be expendable for subunit-type and LH1 complex formation. B. Light-Harvesting 1 and 2 Complexes Oligomerization of B820 to form LH1 or LH2 requires interaction between BChl dimers as well as protein-protein interactions. In the structure of LH2 of Phs. molischianum, the BChls of the B820 subunit overlap at ring I to about the same extent that the two BChls within B820 overlap at rings III and V. Thus, an extensive array of BChls is formed which effectively absorbs and transfers quanta of light. In addition to the π-π interactions of BChl, the α and β polypeptides interact to help stabilize the complex. His -18 of the β polypeptide of Rba. sphaeroides has been shown to be important in this regard. Changing this amino acid to Val by site-directed mutagenesis only slightly affected the formation of B820 but eliminated the ability to form LH1 under the usual reconstitution conditions (Todd et al., 1999). An LH1type complex could be formed at higher protein and BChl concentrations. As discussed earlier, the N-terminal regions of the α and β polypeptides interact to help stabilize heterodimeric B820 (Parkes-Loach et al., 2004). This region of B820 also interacts upon association to stabilize LH1 formation (Parkes-Loach et al., 2004). Several lines of evidence demonstrate that it is the structure of the α polypeptide that determines the λmax of the LH complex upon oligomerization. For
Table 2. Energies of stabilizing interactions in subunit complexes Structure β His 0
Stabilization energy > 6 kcal mol–1
4 – 6 turns of α-helix Small amino acid at –4 β Trp or Tyr at +4 β Trp at +6 β Arg or Lys at +7 β Trp at + 9
Necessary Necessary 1.0 kcal mol–1 1.4 kcal mol–1 2.0 kcal mol–1 3.7 kcal mol–1
References Bylina et al., 1988; Davis et al., 1997; Loach and Parkes-Loach, 1995 Meadows et al., 1995 Bylina et al., 1988 Davis et al., 1997 Sturgis et al., 1997; Kehoe et al., 1998 Kehoe et al., 1998 Kehoe et al., 1998
Chapter 10
Light-Harvesting Reconstitution Studies
example, in hybrid reconstitution experiments, addition of the α polypeptide of Phs. molischianum LH1 with the LH2 β polypeptide of Phs. molischianum resulted in a LH1 type-complex with an absorption maximum at 869 nm whereas the reconstitution of the same Phs. molischianum LH2 β polypeptide with the Phs. molischianum LH2 α polypeptide resulted in a LH2-type complex with an absorption maximum at 848 nm (Todd et al., 1998). It is unclear how the α polypeptide steers the associative process but it might provide an explanation for why the LH complexes are composed of heterodimers instead of homodimers. That is, the α polypeptide may have evolved to fine tune the absorption maximum of the associated complex in order to optimize light absorption in its environment. VIII. Effect of PufX on Reconstitution of Light-Harvesting 1 Complexes The importance of the PufX protein in bacterial photosynthesis became evident when it was found that deletion of the pufX gene in Rba. capsulatus caused changes in the LH1 content (Klug and Cohen, 1988) and also resulted in photosynthetic incompetence (Farchaus et al., 1990b; see also Chapter 9, Bullough et al.). Moreover, adding pufX back to pufX– strains resulted in a recovery of photosynthetic competence (Farchaus et al., 1990a). Using mutant strains of Rba. capsulatus and Rba. sphaeroides in which the pufX gene had been deleted, it was possible to identify, by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), membrane protein components present in pufX + cells but absent in pufX– cells. Using a combined approach of organic solvent extraction and HPLC, PufX was isolated from these two bacteria (Recchia et al., 1998). From the behavior of the PufX protein and the αpolypeptide of LH1 on HPLC, qualitative evidence was obtained that the two proteins have a high affinity for each other. In reconstitution assays with BChl and the LH1 α and β polypeptides of Rba. capsulatus, the PufX protein of Rba. capsulatus was inhibitory to LH1 formation at low concentration. A similar inhibition was exhibited by Rba. sphaeroides PufX protein for reconstitution of LH1 with BChl and the LH1 α and β polypeptides of Rba. sphaeroides. In both cases, the ratios of concentrations of the PufX protein to the α polypeptide causing 50% inhibition were approximately 0.5.
191
The mature forms of these PufX proteins contain 9 and 12 fewer amino acids, respectively, at the Cterminal end of the protein than are encoded by their pufX genes. To identify the portion of PufX responsible for inhibition of LH1 formation in reconstitution experiments, different regions (N-terminus and several core regions containing different lengths of the C-terminus) of Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus PufX were chemically synthesized. Neither the N- nor C- terminal polypeptides of Rba. sphaeroides were inhibitory to LH1 reconstitution. In order to examine the role of the core regions of PufX, two large segments of this protein were chemically synthesized, one reproducing the amino acid sequence of the core segment predicted for Rba. sphaeroides PufX and the other reproducing the amino acid sequence predicted for the core segment of Rba. capsulatus PufX. Both of these core segments were found to be inhibitory to LH1 formation although higher concentrations were required relative to the native PufX proteins (ParkesLoach et al., 2001). CD measurements indicated that the core segment containing 39 amino acids of Rba. sphaeroides PufX exhibited 47% α-helix in trifluoroethanol while the core segment containing 43 amino acids of Rba. capsulatus PufX exhibited 59 and 55% α-helix in trifluoroethanol and in 0.80% β-OG in water, respectively. Thus, as predicted from the amino acid sequence, the hydrophobic middle segment is largely α-helical and presumed to span the membrane. Each chemically-synthesized core segment was covalently labeled with a fluorescent probe and tested for energy transfer to BChl (Law et al., 2003). Each was found to bind BChl with an affinity similar to the affinity of the LH1 polypeptides for BChl. It is suggested that PufX binds BChl and interacts with a BChl α-polypeptide component of LH1 to truncate, or interrupt, the LH1 ring adjacent to the location of the QB binding site of the RC. In other biochemical experiments evaluating the role of PufX, Francia et al. (1999) found that PufX was present in an isolated RC-LH1 complex in a 1:1 stoichiometry with the RC, and that a dimeric form of the core complex depended on the presence of PufX. In further mutagenic studies, it was shown that the N-terminal segment of PufX was required for dimerization of the core complex, the middle segment was required for cell growth and the C-terminal segment seemed to be involved in assembly (Francia et al., 2002). The possible location of PufX in the membrane of
192 Rba. sphaeroides has been studied by cryoelectron microscopy by Qian et al. (2005) in which 8.5 Å resolution was obtained. A dimeric RC-LH1-PufX structure was observed with an S-shaped LH1 array containing 28 LH1 αβ subunits within the dimer. An additional electron dense area was attributed to PufX which was located between LH1 and the RC near the QB binding site of the RC. This structure was similar to the results of Jungas et al. (1999) that first found evidence by negative staining EM for a dimeric structure for the RC-LH1 complex in natural tubular membranes. It is presumed that the role of PufX is to interrupt the cyclization of the LH1 αβ subunits at the QB site of the RC to enable reduced QB to communicate with the Q-pool in the membrane. A somewhat similar result was found by Scheuring et al. (2005) studying Rba. blasticus membranes using atomic force microscopy. Once again, evidence was provided that an S-shaped LH1 array exists, but with 13 LH1 αβ subunits per RC connected in the middle by what was assumed to be a PufX dimer. IX. In vitro versus In vivo Assembly of Complexes A. Oligomerization of B820 When B820 is exposed to in vitro conditions in which it reassociates to form LH1, several intermediate species are presumed to be formed which would reflect different numbers of subunits associated as the complex grows and eventually forms a closed ring. In addition, once a cyclic structure is formed, some rearrangement of interacting segments of the protein may occur on a slower time scale. Evidence for the formation of intermediates was first provided in the dissociation and reassociation experiments where separate sets of isosbestic points were observed during the course of the kinetic process (Miller et al., 1987). In stopped-flow experiments following B820 association to LH1, van Mourik et al. (1992) could fit the reassociation kinetics assuming a two-step process involving a species with a λmax at 850 nm, but it was suggested that more intermediates might be present. Evidence for a second spectral intermediate was obtained in further studies and the 850-nm species was suggested to be due to a tetrameric aggregate consisting of two B820 subunits (Pandit et al., 2003). Attempts to observe the B820 subunit as LH1 is assembled in vivo has so far not been successful.
Paul A. Loach and Pamela S. Parkes-Loach This laboratory has studied the formation of LH1 in whole cells of the G-9 mutant of Rsp. rubrum at very early periods of cell growth, but did not find evidence of B820 as an intermediate (P. Loach, unpublished results). It can be assumed that the equilibria lie far toward LH1 formation when precursors are present in the membrane so that any B820 subunits would be at very low concentration. Interaction of LH1 and its precursors with the RC may also stabilize the oligomeric state, further minimizing the concentration of any intermediates. B. Reconstitution of B820 and Reaction Center Complexes to Form a Photoreceptor Complex B820 and isolated RC of Rsp. rubrum have been reassociated to form the RC-LH1 core complex (Bustamante and Loach, 1994). The resulting complex displayed the same wavelength maxima, CD spectrum and high quantum yield for photochemistry as the in vivo complex. The experimental conditions for this reconstitution began with B820 in 0.80% β-OG to which phospholipids and RC were added. The mixture was then cooled or diluted to allow B820 to oligomerize around the RC as lipid vesicles were formed. From these experiments, it is clear that the LH1 subunit can reassociate with RC to form nativelike core complexes. The in vivo assembly of the photoreceptor RCLH1 complex may or may not follow a similar pattern. It would perhaps be expected that the RC would assemble before the B820 subunits in order that they could then oligomerize around it, otherwise complete LH1 circles might be formed without an RC inside. Consistent with this idea, in the case of Rba. sphaeroides where PufX is involved, Pugh et al. (1998) found that PufX appeared to interact with the RC before encirclement with LH1. However, this assumes that LH1 (and LH2) are static once a complete circular structure is formed. These complexes may, in fact, be quite flexible and even dynamic (Jamieson et al., 2002; Bahatyrova et al., 2004). The forces involved in maintaining a B820 subunit within a circular structure in a membrane environment are probably modest except where interaction with the RC is significant. Indeed, the complete encirclement of the RC in Rsp. rubrum and Rps. viridis may not be a problem for reduced QB of the RC to communicate with the Q-pool because a B820 subunit may readily dissociate from the circle at the QB binding site.
Chapter 10
Light-Harvesting Reconstitution Studies
C. Role of Carotenoids All wild-type photosynthetic bacteria contain carotenoids. It has long been known that the major functions of carotenoids, in addition to serving as accessory light absorbing pigments, are to stabilize LH and RC complexes and to retard photodegradation of BChl (Frank and Cogdell, 1995). Carotenoidless mutants such as G-9 of Rsp. rubrum are much more susceptible to degradation of BChl by conditions of combined light and oxygen than wild-type Rsp. rubrum. In LH complexes, carotenoid removal, or use of carotenoidless mutants, is usually required in order to reversibly dissociate the complex to B820 (Loach and Parkes-Loach, 1995). Moreover, addition of carotenoid to the LH1 α and β polypeptides and BChl under reconstitution conditions leads to a decrease in the concentration of the free B820 subunit because of enhanced oligomerization to form LH1 (Davis et al., 1995; Fiedor and Scheer, 2005; Chapter 46, Braun and Fiedor). From the crystal structures of LH2 (McDermott et al., 1995; Koepke et al., 1996; Prince et al., 1997), carotenoid molecules extend across the membrane between subunits. Thus, they act as a kind of glue stabilizing LH1, but also making intimate contact with BChl. In the absence of carotenoid, it is assumed that lipid replaces the carotenoid in vivo in carotenoidless mutants and that detergent replaces carotenoid in isolated B820 complexes. X. Reconstitution of the Reaction Center The foregoing discussion summarizes the many contributions reconstitution experiments have added to understanding structure-function relationships in light-harvesting and photoreceptor complexes. Complex LH systems have been comprehensively described; this includes evaluations of BChl structural requirements, thermodynamic properties, BChlBChl, BChl-protein and protein-protein interactions, as well as developing insights into the assembly process. If it were possible to achieve a comparable reconstitution of the RC, many unresolved questions could be addressed and groundwork laid for building nanodevices (Chapter 43, Iida et al). Toward this end, this laboratory has developed non-detergent methodology to isolate the RC-L, RC-M and RC-H polypeptides, a prerequisite for reconstitution studies (P. Loach, unpublished). Although these proteins can be isolated by SDS-
193
polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) and other procedures requiring detergents such as lauryl dimethyl amine oxide (Sutton et al., 1982), proteins are often irreversibly denatured by these methods. The organic solvent extraction and HPLC methodology developed for isolation of LH polypeptides (Tonn et al., 1977; Brunisholz et al., 1981, 1984; Miller et al., 1987; Loach and Parkes-Loach, 1995) has been extended to the isolation of the RC polypeptides. As can be seen by HPLC and SDS-PAGE analyses (Fig. 5), such a preparation of pure RC-H from Rsp. rubrum has been achieved. RC-M has also been isolated utilizing solvent extraction methodology, although the preparation still contains a small amount of RC-L (Fig. 6) A comparable preparation of RC-L of Rsp. rubrum is still under development, but the preparation containing RC-M and a small amount of RC-L may be useful for subsequent separation of RC-M and RC-L. RC reconstitution experiments have been initiated using the protocol that was successful in the reconstitution of LH1 and LH2. In the case of the RC, not only are BChl, the RC polypeptides, bacteriopheophytin, ubiquinone and iron required, but also lipids such as cardiolipin and possibly metals, such as Zn. Thus, there are many variables that will need to be tested. The results of preliminary experiments are shown in Fig. 7. The absorption spectrum shows a red-shifted absorption band at 843 nm with shoulders at about 780 and 900 nm. Control experiments are essential in this kind of work. Neither RC-H nor RC-M alone with BChl form species with a red-shifted absorption band. On the other hand, BPhe alone oligomerizes to form a species absorbing at 840 nm, but without the long wavelength shoulder. To evaluate whether a RC-type complex might be formed, the sample of Fig. 7 was illuminated and a light-dark difference spectrum recorded. A very small change was noted which showed some of the changes expected for a native RC (Fig. 8A). The experiment shown in Fig. 7 contained adequate RC-H and RC-M to interact fully with the BChl, BPhe and UQ. However, only about 0.1 equivalent of RC-L was present. It is possible that the light-induced absorption change of Fig. 8A reflects a RC-type complex formed with the small amount of RC-L present. If a symmetrical RC was reconstituted incorporating only RC-M and RC-H, one would expect its absorption spectrum to be similar to that of native RC (Fig. 8B). However, the quantum yield for its photochemical charge separation would
194
Paul A. Loach and Pamela S. Parkes-Loach
a
Fig. 6. RC-M containing fraction after separation on a Sephadex LH60 column. From left to right, lanes 1 & 5, chromatophores; lane 3 & 4, LH60 void volume at two concentrations; lane 2, second protein band (slower) containing small polypeptides.
b
Fig. 5. (a) HPLC of the RC-H polypeptide. Top, supernatant from solvent extraction. Middle, second HPLC of 14 min peak (RC-H). Bottom, third HPLC of 14 min peak. (b). SDS-PAGE of RC-H fractions. Lanes 1 and 5, standards of 194, 115, 97, 53, 37, 29, 20 and 7 kDa (top to bottom). Lane 4, chromatophores. Lane 3, 14 min peak after the first HPLC (Fig. 5a Top). Lane 2, 14 min peak after second HPLC (Fig. 5a middle).
Fig. 7. Absorption spectrum of an RC reconstitution trial in which RC-H, RC-M, small amount of RC-L, BChl, Bph, UQ and Mn(Ac)2 were present in 0.66% β-OG at room temperature.
be predicted to be substantially lower than for native RC since electron transfer apparently proceeds down the L-side much more efficiently (Parson, 1991; Okamura and Feher, 1992). In order to measure the light-induced charge separation of such a RC-M-only RC-type complex, it might require a more intense exciting light and faster kinetic capability than used in the preliminary experiments. Clearly, the preparation of RC-L must be refined to allow much greater quantities of this protein to be obtained. Although the results of our preliminary experiments should be interpreted with considerable caution, it is clear that the reconstitution procedure
Chapter 10
Light-Harvesting Reconstitution Studies
a
195
b
Fig. 8. (a) Light minus dark spectrum of reaction mixture of Fig. 7. Continuous illumination with tungsten light passed through a Corning 4-96 filter. Recorded with a Cary 50 spectrophotometer using 90o illumination. (b) Light minus dark absorbance spectrum of chromatophores of Rsp. rubrum. Same set up as for Fig. 8A. Absorbance of sample was 1.0 at 881 nm.
will allow effective mixing of all components, will provide a basis for systematic variation of conditions and will allow for running extensive controls. It should be noted that our first experiments in the reconstitution of B820 and LH1 provided only very small signs of success, but allowed us to refine conditions to the point that anyone can now easily reconstitute B820 and LH1. In conclusion, development of methodology that will allow reconstitution of the RC and the RC-LH photoreceptor complex would be of immense benefit to studies of structure-function relationships, just as it has been for LH1. In addition, important questions about the assembly of the PRC can be addressed which is expected to provide insights into the assembly of supramolecular complexes in general. Is it possible to reconstitute the PRC from individual components? Since the photosynthetic bacteria have been doing it for almost four billion years, it is certainly possible. Whether it can soon be accomplished under in vitro conditions in the laboratory will depend on producing the right conditions with the right components. Acknowledgments This work was supported by research grants from the National Science Foundation (MCB-0111255) and Northwestern University. References Arluison V, Seguin J, Le Caer J-P, Sturgis JN and Robert B (2004) Hydrophobic pockets at the membrane interface: An original
mechanism for membrane protein interactions. Biochemistry 43: 1276–1282 Bahatyrova S, Frese RN, van der Werf KO, Otto C, Hunter CN and Olsen JD (2004) Flexibility and size heterogeneity of the LH1 light harvesting complex revealed by atomic force microscopy — functional significance for bacterial photosynthesis. J Biol Chem 279: 21327–21333 Brunisholz RA, Cuendet PA, Theiler R and Zuber H (1981) The complete amino acid sequence of the single light harvesting protein from chromatophores of Rhodospirillum rubrum G-9+. FEBS Lett 129: 150–154 Brunisholz RA, Suter F and Zuber H (1984)The light-harvesting polypeptides of Rhodospirillum rubrum.1. The amino-acidsequence of the second light-harvesting polypeptide B880-β (B-870-β) of Rhodospirillum rubrum S-1 and the carotenoidless mutant G-9+. Aspects of the molecular structure of the two lightharvesting polypeptides B880-α (B870-α) and B880-β (B870-β) and of the antenna complex B880 (B870) from Rhodospirillum rubrum. Hoppe-Seyler’s Z Physiol Chem 365: 675–688 Bustamante PL and Loach PA (1994) Reconstitution of a functional photoreceptor complex with isolated subunits of core light-harvesting complex and reaction centers. Biochemistry 33: 13329–13339 Bylina E J, Robles S J, and Youvan DC (1988) Directed mutations affecting the putative bacteriochlorophyll-binding sites in light-harvesting I antenna of Rhodobacter capsulatus. Israel J Chem 28: 73–78 Chang MC, Callahan PC, Parkes-Loach PS, Cotton TM and Loach PA (1990a) Spectroscopic characterization of the lightharvesting complex of Rhodospirillum rubrum and its structural subunit. Biochemistry 29: 421–429 Chang MC, Meyer L and Loach PA (1990b) Isolation and characterization of a structural subunit from the core light-harvesting complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides 2.4.1 and puc705-BA. Photochem Photobiol 52: 873–881 Cotton TM (1976) Spectroscopic investigations of chlorophyll a as donor and acceptor: A basis for chlorophyll a interaction in vivo. PhD Thesis, Northwestern University, Evanston, Illinois Cotton TM and van Duyne RP (1981) Characterization of bacteriochlorophyll interactions in vitro by resonance Raman spectroscopy. J Am Chem Soc 103: 6020–6024
196 Davis CM, Bustamante PL and Loach PA (1995) Reconstitution of the bacterial core light-harvesting complexes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Rhodospirillum rubrum with isolated α- and β-polypeptides, bacteriochlorophyll and carotenoid. J Biol Chem 270: 5793–5804 Davis CM, Parkes-Loach PS, Cook CK, Meadows KA, Bandilla M, Scheer H and Loach PA (1996) Comparison of the structural requirements for bacteriochlorophyll binding in the core light-harvesting complexes of Rhodospirillum rubrum and Rhodobacter sphaeroides using reconstitution methodology with bacteriochlorophyll analogs. Biochemistry 35: 3072–3084 Davis CM, Bustamante PL, Todd JB, Parkes-Loach PS, McGlynn P, Olsen JD, McMaster L, Hunter CN and Loach PA (1997) Evaluation of structure-function relationships in the core light-harvesting complex (LH1) of photosynthetic bacteria by reconstitution with mutant polypeptides. Biochemistry 36: 3671–3679 Dewa T, Yamada T, Ogawa M, Sugimoto M, Mizuno T, Yoshida K, Nakao Y, Kondo M, Iida K, Yamashita K, Tanaka T and Nango M (2005) Design and expression of cysteine-bearing hydrophobic polypeptides and their self-assembling properties with bacteriochlorophyll a derivatives as a mimic of bacterial photosynthetic antenna complexes. Effect of steric confinement and orientation of the polypeptides on the pigment/polypeptide assembly process. Biochemistry 44: 5129–5139 Farchaus JW, Gruenberg H, Gray KA, Wachveitl J, DeHoff B, Kaplan S and Oesterhelt D (1990a) The puf L, M, X deletion strain. In: Drews G and Dawes EA (eds) Molecular Biology of Membrane-Bound Complexes in Phototropic Bacteria, pp 65–76. Plenum Press, New York Farchaus JW, Gruenberg H and Oesterhelt D (1990b) Complementation of a reaction center-deficient Rhodobacter sphaeroides pufLMX deletion strain in trans with pufBALM does not restore the photosynthesis-positive phenotype. J Bacteriol 172: 977–985 Fiedor L and Scheer H (2005) Trapping of an assembly intermediate of photosynthetic LH1 antenna beyond B820 subunit. J Biol Chem 280: 20921–20926 Fotiadis D, Qian P, Pilippsen A, Bullough PA, Engel A and Hunter CN (2004) Structural analysis of the RC-LH1 photosynthetic core complex of Rhodospirillum rubrum using atomic force microscopy. J Biol Chem 279: 2063–2068 Fowler GJS, Sockalingum GD, Robert B and Hunter CN (1994) Blue shifts in bacteriochlorophyll absorbance correlate with changed hydrogen bonding patterns in light-harvesting 2 mutants of Rhodobacter sphaeroides with alterations at α-Tyr-44 and α-Tyr-45. Biochem J 299: 695–700 Francia F, Wang J, Venturoli G, Melandri BA, Barz WP and Oesterhelt D (1999) The reaction center-LH1 antenna complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides contains one PufX molecule which is involved in dimerization of this complex. Biochemistry 38: 6834–6845 Francia F, Wang J, Venturoli G and Oesterhelt D (2002) Role of the N- and C-terminal regions of the PufX protein in the structural organization of the photosynthetic core complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Eur J Biochem 269: 1877–1885 Francke C and Amesz J (1995) The size of the photosynthetic unit in purple bacteria. Photosynth Res 46: 347–352 Frank HA and Cogdell RJ (1995) Carotenoids in photosynthesis. Photochem Photobiol 63: 257–264 Georgakopoulou S, Frese RN, Johnson E, Koolhaas C, Cogdell R,
Paul A. Loach and Pamela S. Parkes-Loach van Grondelle R and van der Zwan G (2002) Absorption and CD spectroscopy and modeling of various LH2 complexes from purple bacteria. Biophys J 82: 2184–2197 Georgakopoulou S, van Grondelle R and van der Zwan G (2006) Explaining the visible and near-infrared circular dichroism spectra of light-harvesting 1 complexes from purple bacteria: A modeling study. J Phys Chem B 110: 3344–3353 Germeroth L, Lottspeich F, Robert B and Michel H (1993) Unexpected similarities of the B800-850 light-harvesting complex from Rhodospirillum molischianum to the B870 light-harvesting complexes from other purple photosynthetic bacteria. Biochemistry 32: 5615–5621 Heller BA and Loach PA (1990) Isolation and characterization of a subunit form of the B875 light-harvesting complex from Rhodobacter capsulatus. Photochem Photobiol 51: 621–627 Hu X and Schulten K (1998) Model for the light-harvesting complex I B875 of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biophys J 75: 683–694 Jamieson SJ, Wang P, Qian P, Kirkland JY, Conroy M, Hunter CN and Bullough PA (2002) Projection structure of the photosynthetic reaction centre-antenna complex of Rhodospirillum rubrum at 8.5 Å resolution. EMBO J 21: 3927–3935 Jirsakova V and Reiss-Husson F (1993) Isolation and characterization of the core light-harvesting complex B875 and its subunit form, B820, from Rhodocyclus gelatinosus. Biochim Biophys Acta 1138: 301–308 Jungas C, Ranck J-L, Rigaud J-L, Joliot P and Verméglio A (1999) Supramolecular organization of the photosynthetic apparatus of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. EMBO J 18: 534–542 Kashiwada A, Watanabe H, Mizuno T, Iida K Miyatake T, Tamiaki H, Kobayashi M and Nango M (2000a) Structural requirements of zinc porphyrin derivatives on the complex-forming with light-harvesting polypeptides. Chem Lett 29: 158–159 Kashiwada A, Watanabe H, Tanaka T and Nango M (2000b) Molecular assembly of zinc bacteriochlorophyll a by synthetic hydrophobic 1α-helix polypeptides. Chem Lett 29: 24–25 Kehoe JW, Meadows, KA, Parkes-Loach PS and Loach PA (1998) Reconstitution of light-harvesting complexes of photosynthetic bacteria using chemically synthesized polypeptides: II. Determination of structural features that stabilize complex formation and implications on the structure of the subunit complex. Biochemistry 37: 3418–3428 Kerfeld CA, Yeates TO and Thornber JP (1994) Biochemical and spectroscopic characterization of the reaction center-LHI complex and the carotenoid-containing B820 subunit of Chromatium purpuratum. Biochim Biophys Acta 1185: 193–202 Klug G and Cohen SN (1988) Pleiotropic effects of localized Rhodobacter capsulatus puf operon deletions on production of light-absorbing pigment-protein complexes. J Bacteriol 170: 5814–5821 Koepke J, Hu X, Muenke C, Schulten K and Michel H (1996) The crystal structure of the light-harvesting complex II (B800-850) from Rhodospirillum molischianum. Structure 4: 581–597 Law CJ, Chen J, Parkes-Loach PS and Loach PA (2003) Interaction of bacteriochlorophyll with the LH1 and PufX polypeptides of photosynthetic bacteria: Use of chemically synthesized analogs and covalently attached fluorescent probes. Photosynth Res 75: 193–210 Loach PA and Parkes-Loach PS (1995) Structure-function relationships in core light-harvesting complexes (LHI) as determined by characterization of the structural subunit and by reconstitution
Chapter 10
Light-Harvesting Reconstitution Studies
experiments. In: Blankenship RE, Madigan MT and Bauer CD (eds) Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 2), pp 437–471. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Loach PA and Sekura DL (1968) Primary photochemistry and electron transport in Rhodospirillum rubrum. Biochemistry 7: 2642–2649 Loach PA, Parkes-Loach PS, Davis CM and Heller BA (1994) Probing protein structural requirements for formation of the core light-harvesting complex of photosynthetic bacteria using hybrid reconstitution methodology. Photosynth Res 40: 235–246 McDermott G, Prince SM., Freer AA., Hawthornthwaite-Lawless AM, Papiz MZ, Cogdell RJ and Isaacs NW (1995) Crystal structure of an integral membrane light-harvesting complex from photosynthetic bacteria. Nature 374: 517–521 McGlynn P, Westerhuis WHJ, Jones MR and Hunter CN (1996) Consequences for the organization of reaction center-light harvesting antenna 1 (LH 1) core complexes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides arising from deletion of amino acid residues from the C terminus of the LH1 α polypeptide. J Biol Chem 271: 3285–3292 Meadows KA, Iida K, Kazuichi T, Recchia PA, Heller BA, Antonio B, Nango M and Loach P (1995) Enzymatic and chemical cleavage of the core light-harvesting polypeptides of photosynthetic bacteria: Determination of the minimal polypeptide size and structure required for subunit and light-harvesting complex formation. Biochemistry 34: 1559–1574 Meadows KA, Parkes-Loach PS, Kehoe JW and Loach PA (1998) Reconstitution of light-harvesting complexes of photosynthetic bacteria using chemically synthesized polypeptides: I. Minimal requirements for subunit formation. Biochemistry 37: 3411–3417 Meckenstock RU, Brunisholz RA and Zuber H (1992) The lightharvesting core-complex and the B820-subunit from Rhodopseudomonas marina. Part 1. Purification and characterization. FEBS Lett 311: 128–134 Miller JF, Hinchigeri SB, Parkes-Loach PS, Callahan PM, Sprinkle JR, Riccobono JR and Loach PA (1987) Isolation and characterization of a subunit form of the light-harvesting complex of Rhodospirillum rubrum. Biochemistry 26: 5055–5062 Nagata M, Nango M, Kashiwada A, Yamada S, Ito S, Sawa N, Ogawa M, Iida K, Kurono Y and Ohtsuka T (2003a) Construction of photosynthetic antenna complex using light-harvesting polypeptide-α from photosynthetic bacteria, R. rubrum with zinc substituted bacteriochlorophyll α. Chem Lett 32: 216–217 Nagata M, Yoshimura Y, Inagaki J, Suemori Y, Iida K, Ohtsuka T and Nango M (2003b) Construction and photocurrent of lightharvesting polypeptides/zinc bacteriochlorophyll a complex in lipid bilayers. Chem Lett 32: 852–853 Nango M, Kashiwada A, Watanabe H, Yamada S, Yamada T, Ogawa M, Tanaka T and Iida K (2002) Molecular assembly of bacteriochlorophyll a using light-harvesting model 1α-helix polypeptides and 2α-helix polypeptide with disulfide-linkage. Chem Lett 2002: 312–314 Noy D and Dutton PL (2006) Design of a minimal polypeptide unit for bacteriochlorophyll binding and self-assembly based on photosynthetic bacterial light-harvesting proteins. Biochemistry 45: 2103–2113 Okamura MY and Feher G (1992) Proton transfer in reaction
197
centers from photosynthetic bacteria. Annu Rev Biochem 61: 861–896 Olsen JD (1994) The role of highly conserved amino-acid residues in the light-harvesting 1 complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. PhD Thesis, University of Sheffield Olsen JD, Sockalingum GD, Robert B and Hunter CN (1994) Modification of a hydrogen bond to a bacteriochlorophyll a molecule in the light-harvesting 1 antenna of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 91: 7124–7128 Olsen JD, Sturgis JN, Westerhuis WHJ, Fowler GJS, Hunter CN and Robert B (1997) Site-directed modification of the ligands to the bacteriochlorophylls of the light-harvesting LH1 and LH2 complexes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 36: 12625–12632 Pandit A, Visschers RW, van Stokkum IHM, Krayenhof R and van Grondelle R (2001) Oligomerization of light-harvesting I antenna peptides of Rhodospirillum rubrum. Biochemistry 40: 12913–12924 Pandit A, van Stokkum IHM, Georgakopoulou S, van der Zwan G and van Grondelle R (2003) Investigations of intermediates appearing in the reassociation of the light-harvesting 1 complex of Rhodospirillum rubrum. Photosynth Res 75: 235–248 Parkes-Loach PS, Sprinkle JR and Loach PA (1988) Reconstitution of the B873 light-harvesting complex of Rhodospirillum rubrum from the separately-isolated α- and β-polypeptides and bacteriochlorophyll a. Biochemistry 27: 2718–2727 Parkes-Loach PS, Michalski TJ, Bass WJ, Smith U and Loach PA (1990) Probing the bacteriochlorophyll binding site by reconstitution of the light-harvesting complex of Rhodospirillum rubrum with bacteriochlorophyll a analogues. Biochemistry 29: 2951–2960 Parkes-Loach PS, Jones SM and Loach PA (1994) Probing the structure of the core light-harvesting complex (LHI) of Rhodopseudomonas viridis by dissociation and reconstitution methodology. Photosynth Res 40: 247–261 Parkes-Loach PS, Law CJ, Recchia PA, Kehoe J, Nehrlich S, Chen J and Loach PA (2001) Role of the core region of the PufX protein in inhibition of reconstitution of the core light-harvesting complexes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Rhodobacter capsulatus. Biochemistry 40: 5593–5601 Parkes-Loach PS, Majeed AP, Law CJ and Loach PA (2004) Interactions stabilizing the structure of the core light-harvesting complex (LH1) of photosynthetic bacteria and its subunit (B820). Biochemistry 43: 7003–7016 Parson WW (1991) Reaction centers. In: Scheer H (ed) Chlorophylls, pp 1153–1180. CRC Press, Boca Raton Prince SM, Papiz MZ, Freer AA, McDermott G, HawthornthwaiteLawless AM, Cogdell RJ and Isaacs NW (1997) Apoprotein structure in the LH2 complex from Rhodopseudomonas acidophila strain 10050: Modular assembly and protein pigment interactions. J Mol Biol 268: 412–423 Pugh RJ, McGlynn P, Jones MR and Hunter CN (1998) The LH 1-RC core complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Interaction between components, time-dependent assembly, and topology of the PufX protein. Biochim Biophys Acta 1366: 301–316 Qian P, Hunter CN and Bullough PA (2005) The 8.5 Å projection structure of the core RC-LH1-PufX dimer of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Mol Biol 349: 948–960 Recchia PA, Davis CM, Lilburn TG, Beatty JT, Parkes-Loach PS, Hunter CN and Loach PA (1998) Isolation of the PufX protein from Rhodobacter capsulatus and Rhodobacter sphaeroides:
198 Evidence for its interaction with the α-polypeptide of the core light harvesting complex. Biochemistry 37: 11055–11063 Robert B and Lutz M (1985) Structure of antenna complexes of several Rhodospirillales from their resonance Raman spectra. Biochim Biophys Acta 807: 10–23 Scheuring S, Busselez J and Levy D (2005) Structure of the dimeric PufX-containing core complex of Rhodobacter blasticus by in situ atomic force microscopy. J Biol Chem 280: 1426–1431 Srivatsan N and Norris JR (2001) Electron paramagnetic resonance study of oxidized B820 complexes. J Phys Chem B 105: 12391–12398 Sturgis J and Robert B (1994) Thermodynamics of membrane polypeptide oligomerization in light-harvesting complexes and associated structural changes. J Mol Biol 238: 445–454 Sturgis JN, Olsen JD, Robert B and Hunter CN (1997) Functions of conserved tryptophan residues of the core light-harvesting complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 36: 2772–2778 Sutton MR., Rosen D, Feher G and Steiner LA (1982) Aminoterminal sequences of the L, M, and H subunits of reaction centers from the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides R-26. Biochemistry 21: 3842–3849 Todd JB, Parkes-Loach PS, Leykam JF and Loach PA (1998) In vitro reconstitution of the core and peripheral light-harvesting complexes of Rhodospirillum molischianum from separately isolated components. Biochemistry 37: 17458–17468 Todd JB, Recchia PA, Parkes-Loach PS, Olsen JD, Fowler GJS, McGlynn P, Hunter CN and Loach PA (1999) Minimal requirements for in vitro reconstitution of the structural subunit of light-harvesting complexes of photosynthetic bacteria. Photosynth Res 62: 85–98 Tonn SJ, Gogel GE and Loach PA (1977) Isolation and characterization of an organic solvent soluble polypeptide component from photoreceptor complexes of Rhodospirillum rubrum.
Paul A. Loach and Pamela S. Parkes-Loach Biochemistry 16: 877–885 van Mourik F, van der Ord JR, Visscher KJ, Parkes-Loach PA, Loach PA, Visschers, RW, and van Grondelle R (1991) Exciton interactions in the light-harvesting antenna of photosynthetic bacteria studied with triplet-singlet spectroscopy and singlettriplet annihilation on the B820 subunit form of Rhodospirillum rubrum. Biochim Biophys Acta 1059: 111–119 van Mourik F, Corten EPM, van Stokkum IHM, Visschers RW, Loach PA, Kraayenhof R and van Grondelle R (1992) Self assembly of the LH-1 antenna of Rhodospirillum rubrum, a time-resolved study of the aggregation of the B820 subunit form. In: Murata N (ed) Research in Photosynthesis, pp 101–104. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Visschers RW, Chang MC, van Mourik F, Parkes-Loach PS, Heller BA, Loach PA and van Grondelle (1991) Fluorescence polarization and low-temperature absorption spectroscopy of a subunit form of light-harvesting complex I from purple photosynthetic bacteria. Biochemistry 30: 5734–5742 Visschers RW, van Grondelle R and Robert B (1993) Resonance Raman spectroscopy of the B820 subunit of the core antenna from Rhodospirillum rubrem G9. Biochim Biophys Acta 1183: 369–373 Wang Z, Muraoka Y, Shimonaga M, Kobayashi M and Nozawa T (2002) Selective detection and assignment of the solution NMR signals of bacteriochlorophyll a in a reconstituted subunit of a light-harvesting complex. J Am Chem Soc 124: 1072–1078 Wendling M, Lapouge K, van Mourik F, Novoderezhkin V, Robert B and van Grondelle R (2002) Steady-state spectroscopy of zinc-bacteriopheophytin containing LH1—an in vitro and in silico study. Chem Physics 275: 31–45 Zuber H, & Brunisholz RA (1991) Structure and function of antenna polypeptides and chlorophyll-protein complexes: Principles and variability. In: Scheer H (ed) Chlorophylls, pp 627–703. CRC Press, Boca Raton
Chapter 11 Spectroscopic Properties of Antenna Complexes from Purple Bacteria Bruno Robert* CEA, Institut de Biologie et de Technologie de Saclay, and CNRS, 91191 Gif/Yvette, France
Summary ............................................................................................................................................................... 199 1. Introduction..................................................................................................................................................... 200 II. The Different Spectral Forms of Antenna Proteins from Purple Bacteria ...................................................... 200 III. Antenna Proteins from Purple Bacteria: Variations Around a Structural Theme ........................................... 201 IV. The Role of Ground State Interactions in Tuning the Antenna Absorption Transition ................................... 203 V. Excitonic Interactions and Disorder in Light-Harvesting Complexes ............................................................. 205 VI. Chromophore Interactions in Light-Harvesting Proteins: Additional Effects .................................................. 207 VII. Conclusions .................................................................................................................................................... 208 Acknowledgments ................................................................................................................................................. 209 References ............................................................................................................................................................ 209
Summary This chapter describes the known factors which shape the electronic (and thus the functional) properties of light-harvesting (LH) complexes of purple bacteria. Although a variety of high- and low-resolution structures from LH complexes are now available, they do not provide, per se, a detailed picture of the electronic properties of the pigments in these complexes. However they constitute a framework which has helped, through the use of wide range of techniques, most often combining site-selection mutagenesis and advanced spectroscopies, to make progress in determining which parameters are important for the function of these proteins. Today, antenna proteins from purple photosynthetic bacteria are probably the best-understood photosynthetic LH proteins, and among the best-characterized membrane proteins in any biological field. However, there are still some discrepancies about the precise relationship between their structure and function. This chapter attempts to describe, as simply as possible, the physical mechanisms which are thought to underlie the tuning of the absorption properties of bacteriochlorophyll molecules in these proteins, as well as the results which are at the origin of the running arguments.
*Email: [email protected]
C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty (eds): The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria, pp. 199–212. © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V.
200 1. Introduction More than hundred years ago, it was noticed that purple bacteria are able to grow photosynthetically under near infrared illumination, at wavelengths much higher than the maximum absorbance of the isolated pigments (Molisch, 1907). As early as 1921, Lubimenko interpreted this red-shift as evidence that these pigments were bound to proteins (cited in Pardee et al., 1952). In the following years, the unusual absorption of the bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) molecules, as observed in vivo, was extensively used to monitor and control the harshness of the first biochemical protocols designed to isolate the components of the photosynthetic apparatus from these organisms, as well as the intactness of the resulting purified fractions. Because of this very useful internal control, the biochemistry of pigment protein complexes of purple bacteria developed early: French (1940) reported the first extraction of intracytoplasmic membranes of various strains retaining their native absorption properties and, less than twenty five years later, the first successful attempt to purify photoactive protein fractions from these membranes (Clayton, 1963). In addition to their very important role in guiding the pioneer biochemists as they took these first steps in membrane protein science, these red-shifted electronic transitions were intriguing: depending on the bacterial strain, they could exhibit completely different shapes and positions, always different from those of isolated BChl molecules, and sometimes redshifted by as much as 1500 cm–1 or 130 nm relative to the purified pigment. If the antenna proteins for purple photosynthetic bacteria are nowadays probably the best-characterized membrane proteins, it is likely that this originates from these fascinating electronic transitions, which are so easy to observe in intact bacteria. In the last twenty five years, light-harvesting (LH) proteins from purple bacteria have been extensively studied, both from experimental and theoretical points of view. These studies have developed far beyond the field of photosynthesis, and the detailed analysis of the bacterial antenna complexes has led to the development of concepts which are of interest for most fields in molecular biology. For Abbreviations: BChl – bacteriochlorophyll; CD – circular dichroism; Gpa – GigaPascal; LH – light-harvesting; Rba. – Rhodobacter; RC – reaction center; Rps. – Rhodopseudomonas; Rsp. – Rhodospirillum
Bruno Robert instance, calculating the electronic properties of the peripheral light-harvesting 2 (LH2) complex from its crystallographic structure leads to predictions that are obviously wrong. The electronic properties may actually be predicted correctly, but only by taking into account molecular disorder, a phenomenon inherently present in the macromolecular structure of any complex. In this particular case, one may thus consider that theoretical advances on light-harvesting complexes from purple photosynthetic bacteria have yielded one of the most accurate descriptions of disorder and its effects in any biological structure. In this short review article, I will summarize the present state of our knowledge on the electronic properties of these proteins, with the constant aim of linking complex theoretical developments and the structure of these complexes. II. The Different Spectral Forms of Antenna Proteins from Purple Bacteria In photosynthetic purple bacteria, the LH system generally contains a core antenna, also called LH1, which transfers excitation energy directly to the reaction centers (RCs). In BChl a-synthesizing bacteria, LH1 complexes typically absorb at 870–890 nm (Fig. 1). BChl b-containing LH1 complexes exhibit near infrared transitions above 1000 nm. Many bacterial species also contain peripheral antenna complexes, LH2, which transfer excitation energy to the RCs via LH1. LH2 complexes usually exhibit two major absorption transitions in the near infrared, at 800 and 850 nm in BChl a-containing bacteria (Fig. 1). In these organisms, the electronic properties of the LH complexes funnel excitation energy towards the RC, a process driven by the energy gradient of the electronic transitions of the different LH complexes. In that sense, understanding the electronic properties of the LH proteins of purple bacteria is particularly important, as they are the major factor underlying the vectorial flow of excitation energy transfer towards the RCs. Some bacterial species, in low illumination conditions or when grown at low temperature, are able to synthesize additional LH2, the lower transition of which is downshifted to 820 nm (Fig. 1). LH1 and LH2 thus generally exhibit electronic transitions considerably red-shifted relative to the absorption of isolated, monomeric BChl a or b (770 and 800 nm in most organic solvents, respectively). In LH complexes, BChl molecules responsible for a given
Chapter 11
Spectroscopic Properties of Antenna Complexes
201
also the case for complexes of thermophilic bacteria: a 920 nm-absorbing LH1 complex has been isolated from the thermophilic Chromatium tepidum species (Garcia et al., 1986; Fathir et al., 1998). III. Antenna Proteins from Purple Bacteria: Variations Around a Structural Theme
Fig. 1. Electronic absorption spectra (Qy transitions) of LH1 from Rsp. rubrum, strain G9+ (top), and of LH2 from Rps. acidophila, strain 10050 (middle trace: B800-850, bottom : B800-820). It must be emphasized that the spectra chosen here correspond to those of the most-commonly studied types of bacterial LH complexes, but that it is unclear whether they represent the most commonly found in purple bacteria.
Qy absorption transition are usually referred to as B followed by the position of this transition, e.g., B800, B850. In addition to these proteins with ‘classical’ absorption properties, a number of strains are able to synthesize antenna proteins with unusual absorption transitions. This is the case, for example, with Rhodopseudomonas (Rps.) palustris strain 2.6.1, which, when grown at low light intensity, produces a modified peripheral antenna complex mainly absorbing at 800 nm (Robert et al., 1985). Chromatium purpuratum, also produces a peripheral antenna complex with a single strong absorption band at 830 nm and a small shoulder at 800 nm (Cogdell et al., 1990). Antenna complexes from marine, aerobic species of purple photosynthetic bacteria often exhibit unusual properties (Chapter 3, Yurkov and Csotonyi). For instance, a 865 nm-absorbing LH1 has been reported in Roseococcus thiosulfatophilus (Gall et al., 1999). This is
As discussed elsewhere in this book (Chapter 8, Gabrielsen et al.; Chapter 9, Bullough et al.; Chapter 10, Loach and Parkes-Loach) antenna complexes from purple photosynthetic bacteria are oligomers of an elementary unit, composed of a pair of small (5–7 kDa), very hydrophobic, apoproteins, called α and β, each of which contains a single transmembrane helix as the major structural element (Zuber and Brunisholz, 1991). Since the cryo-electron microscopy studies on 2-D crystals of LH1 from Rhodospirillum (Rsp.) rubrum (Karrasch et al., 1995), and the determination of the 3-D structure of LH2 from Rps. acidophila (McDermott et al., 1995), we know that LH complexes are composed of circular associations of αβ subunits. Fully-assembled LH complexes are comprised of two concentric rings of helical α- (inside ring) and β- (outside ring) polypeptides (Isaacs et al., 1995). Sixteen αβ subunits are required to produce a complete, closed LH1 ring (Karrasch et al., 1995). The central hole of these rings is large enough to contain the RC, and 2-D crystals of RCLH1 complexes clearly show that it does (Walz and Ghosh, 1997; Walz et al., 1998; Jamieson et al., 2002). Whether these closed, 16-membered rings truly exist in vivo has been a matter of debate. It has become clear that the precise structure of LH1 depends on the bacterial species considered. In Rps. viridis, for instance, evidence for closed rings has been provided by atomic force microscopy on native membranes (Scheuring et al. 2003; Chapter 47, Scheuring). In contrast, in Rhodobacter (Rba.) sphaeroides, it is now well established that LH1 comprises two incomplete αβ rings that associate to form a dimer, which surrounds two RCs (Jungas et al., 1999; Siebert et al., 2004; Bahatyrova et al., 2004b; Qian et al., 2005). This organization is dependent on the presence of an additional component in the RC-LH1 complex, named PufX (Francia et al., 1999; Frese et al., 2000; Siebert et al., 2004). In Rps. palustris, the LH1 complex is also a ring, nearly closed, but interrupted by the presence of a hydrophobic polypeptide, located adjacent to the RC on the side opposite to the transmembrane
202 helix of the RC-H subunit (Roszak et al., 2003). In the case of LH2, structural studies, involving either X-ray crystallography of 3-D crystals or cryo-electron microscopy on 2-D crystals, have shown that these complexes are formed by a smaller ring, involving a smaller number of α and β polypeptides. The 2.5 Å crystal structure of LH2 from Rps. acidophila (Isaacs et al., 1995; Prince et al., 1997) revealed that it consists of a nonameric circular association of αβ heterodimers. A similar organization has been shown for LH2 from Rhodovulum sulfidophilus (Savage et al., 1996) as well as for the 820 nm-absorbing LH2 from Rps. acidophila (McLuskey et al., 1999). In contrast, the structure of the LH2 complex from Rsp. molischianum is an octameric ring of α and β apoproteins (Koepke et al., 1996). This difference in quaternary structure is likely to be due to the peculiarity of the sequences of the polypeptide which constitute this protein (Germeroth et al., 1993). Parallel to this rather simple view of the structure of these complexes, it has been shown recently that in vivo LH complexes exhibit some structural variability around these canonical structures (Bahatyrova et al., 2004a; Scheuring et al., 2004). The extent to which complex-to-complex structural heterogeneity is important for the functional properties of the LH proteins has not yet been measured experimentally. This is, however, an essential point which has to be addressed in the near future (see below). In all antenna complexes, the α and β polypeptides each bind a single BChl molecule, through a conserved histidine in the hydrophobic phase of the membrane. In the fully assembled LH complex, this pattern of BChl binding results in a ring of closely interacting BChl molecules, sandwiched between the two polypeptide rings (see Fig. 2, and Chapter 8, Gabrielsen et al.), and oriented perpendicular to the membrane plane. In LH1 and LH2, these rings (or portions of rings, in the case of LH1) are thus formed by 24 to 32 and 16 to 18 BChl molecules, respectively. Such associations of many BChl molecules within van der Waals contact gives rise to the red-most absorption transition of the complexes; see, for example, van Grondelle et al. (1994). In LH2 complexes, each αβ subunit binds one additional BChl molecule near the interface between the membrane and the cytosol. The structure of the binding site and the orientation of these molecules is clearly species dependent. In Rps. acidophila, these molecule lie close to parallel to the membrane plane, and their central Mg ion is bound by the oxygen atom of the formylated N-ter-
Bruno Robert
Fig. 2. Organization of the BChl arrays in LH2 from Rps. acidophila. Top: 850-nm absorbing array. Bottom: 800-nm absorbing array.
minal of the α polypeptide. This binding site is very polar and is mainly composed of aminoacids from the β polypeptide. These BChls form an additional ring of nine molecules, spaced by about 21 Å and thus weakly interacting with each other. They give rise to the 800 nm absorption band of these proteins. In Rsp. molischianum LH2, the plane of these B800 molecules is rotated by 90 degrees compared with the LH2 from Rps. acidophila, and is tilted away from
Chapter 11
Spectroscopic Properties of Antenna Complexes
203
the membrane plane (Koepke et al., 1996). In addition, the nature of the aminoacids interacting with the B800 molecules is different. LH2 from purple sulfur bacteria exhibit not one but two transitions around 800 nm (Krikunova et al., 2002). It is not yet clear whether an additional binding site is present in these complexes. In LH2 synthesized in low light by Rps. palustris, the transition at 800 nm much larger and broader as compared to Rps. acidophila LH2 (Robert et al., 1985). It is clear that, in these complexes also, the overall organization of the B800 molecules must differ from that observed in the crystal structure of Rps. acidophila LH2 (Gall and Robert, 1999; Hartigan et al., 2002). IV. The Role of Ground State Interactions in Tuning the Antenna Absorption Transition As described above, the lowest energy transition (Qy) of BChl molecules in LH proteins are generally red-shifted in comparison with that of BChl in organic solvents. The least red-shifted Qy transition is that of the B800 molecules in the LH2 complexes, which represents a red-shift just a bit less than 500 cm–1, compared to the 770 nm position observed for BChl in acetone. The B800 BChl molecules interact only weakly with each other. From the structure, the calculated B800/B800 coupling is only about 30 cm–1. The 770 to 800 nm red-shift experienced by the Qy transition of these molecules can thus only arise from BChl/protein interactions. The protein matrix may influence pigment absorption in different ways, i) by providing aminoacids able to interact with the pigments, ii) through dispersive forces, which are the result of the protein environment with anisotropic dielectric properties and iii) through steric hindrance, by inducing pigment conformational changes, which in turn influence their electronic properties. In the Rps. acidophila LH2 complex, the acetyl carbonyl of each B800 molecule interacts with the amine group of the arginine β21 (McDermott et al., 1995). The C=O stretching frequency of this group, as observed by resonance Raman spectroscopy, indicates that this group is strongly H-bonded by this aminoacid (Robert and Lutz, 1985; Gall et al., 1997). In mutants of LH2 from Rba. sphaeroides where this aminoacid has been altered, the Qy transition of the B800 BChl molecules blue-shifts by about 10 nm, towards 790 nm (Fowler et al., 1997; Gall et al., 1997;
Fig. 3. Influence of the β21 arginine on the 800 nm electronic transition of LH2 from Rba. sphaeroides. Electronic absorption spectra at room temperature of LH2 from (top to bottom) wildtype, β21 asparagine, β21 leucine, β21 glutamic acid, β21 lysine, β21 histidine, β21 methionine (redrawn from Gall et al., 1997).
see Fig. 3). The strong H-bond between the arginine β21 and the acetyl carbonyl of the B800 molecule is thus responsible of a ca 180 cm–1 red-shift of the Qy of these molecules. Such an effect of H-bonds involving the acetyl carbonyl of BChl molecules had actually been predicted by rather simple molecular
204 calculations (Gudowska-Nowak et al., 1990). In LH2 mutants where this H-bond has been broken, the Qy absorption of the B800 BChl is observed to vary between 780 and 792 nm. This reflects an additional influence from the protein environment, and more particularly from the precise chemical nature of the amino acid sidechain at position β21. For instance, a leucine residue at position β21 results in a Qy position of the B800 molecules at 787 nm, while this transition is observed at 782 nm, in the presence of the more polar asparagine residue at this position (Fowler et al., 1997). Resonance Raman measurements led to the proposal that this additional 12 nm (160 cm–1) shift was due to local changes in the local dielectric constant around the BChl (Gall et al., 1997). The combined effects of the H-bond together with the low dielectric constant around the B800 molecules are almost sufficient to account for the Qy red-shift of B800 molecules in LH2 (Gall et al., 1997). These experiments provide direct evidence that the H-bonding state, as well as the dielectric properties of the environment affect the BChl absorption in proteins. In excitonically coupled BChl systems, these parameters should influence the energy site of each participating molecule, and thus in turn affect the excitonically-coupled levels of the ensemble. This was elegantly shown by site-mutagenesis, performed on LH2 from Rba. sphaeroides: when the residues Tyr α44 and Trp α45 are replaced by phenylalanine and leucine, respectively, the lower energy transition of these complexes is shifted from 850 to 826 nm (Fowler et al., 1992). Both these aminoacids are involved in H-bond interactions with the acetyl carbonyl of the 850 nm-absorbing BChl molecules (Fowler et al.¸ 1994). It is of note that these mutations are naturally observed between the sequences of the α polypeptides of 820 nm-absorbing LH2 complexes (Brunisholz et al., 1987). The tuning of the absorption of these complexes should thus naturally occur through variations of the H-bonding state of the BChl molecules. The study of a number of natural and artificial variants of LH complexes, including naturally 820-nm absorbing LH2 (Sturgis et al., 1995a,b; Sturgis and Robert, 1997), genetically engineered LH1 proteins (Olsen et al., 1994; Sturgis et al., 1997), and unusual complexes from Roseococcus thiosulfatophilus LH1 proteins (Gall et al., 1999) unambiguously showed that this is actually the case. Crystallographic studies of 820 nm-absorbing complexes from Rps. acidophila have led to somewhat different conclusions. From the electronic density map obtained from X-ray
Bruno Robert studies of these proteins, it was proposed that, in these complexes, the acetyl carbonyl of the B850 BChl molecules would be rotated out of the plane of the dihydrophorbin macrocycle (McLuskey et al., 1999). It was proposed that this could be the main reason of the observed blue-shift. However, for such a blue-shift to occur, the rotation should induce the deconjugation of the acetyl carbonyl. This should in turn result in the disappearance of the contribution of its stretching vibrations from resonance Raman spectra. Such effect has been observed in resonance Raman spectra of BChl bound to the bacterial RC (Ridge et al., 2000). However, in resonance Raman spectra from the 820 nm-absorbing complexes from Rps. acidophila, there is a clear, and rather intense, contribution arising from the stretching mode of these carbonyl groups (Sturgis et al., 1995). This suggests that this group is still enough in plane to be conjugated with the electronic transition of the BChl molecule. Under these conditions, the observed rotation should have a very limited effect on the Qy electronic absorption of the LH2 complexes, and it is unlikely that it is alone at the origin of the observed blue shift. In any case, the description of the structure of the 820 nm-absorbing complexes from X-ray crystallographic studies (McLuskey et al., 1999) fully validated the idea that the difference in absorption between the 820 nm- and 850 nm-absorbing LH2 complexes is mainly due to differences in BChl-protein ground state interaction, and not to differences in excitonic coupling between the BChl molecules. This structure shows that both the B820 and the B850 rings have similar, if not identical, structures, thus ruling out the possibility of major differences in BChl/BChl interactions between the two complexes. Although other parameters could play a role in tuning the BChl energy site, such as the H-bonding state of the other, conjugated carbonyl of these molecules, namely the keto one, it was clearly shown in two cases that this is not the case. In both the LH1 and LH2 complexes from Rba. sphaeroides, it was possible to break an H-bond between this carbonyl and a neighboring aminoacid, by site-selected mutagenesis, without any detectable influence on the position of the main Qy transition of these complexes (Olsen et al., 1997; Kwa et al., 2004). The interaction state of the keto carbonyl group of the BChl molecules is thus not a major parameter for tuning BChl absorption. This is probably due to the fact that the keto carbonyl group is less conjugated with the conjugated macrocycle of the BChl molecule, as indicated by its lower
Chapter 11
Spectroscopic Properties of Antenna Complexes
stretching frequency (Robert and Lutz, 1985). The conformation of the BChl dihydrophorbin macrocycle is also likely to play a role in tuning the absorption of BChl molecules (Gudowska-Nowak et al., 1990). Up to now, no steric hindrance large enough could be created by site-selected mutagenesis to perturb the conformation of any of the LH-bound BChl molecules. Crystallographic studies showed that the BChl bound to the β polypeptide of the 850 nm-absorbing pair in LH2 from Rps. acidophila could be significantly distorted (Prince et al., 1997). However, determining the precise conformation of a proteinbound cofactor is a particularly difficult task for crystallographers. Spectroscopic studies confirmed that some of the BChl molecules responsible for the lower electronic transition in both LH2 and LH1 were indeed distorted, as compared to the relaxed conformation observed in organic solvent (Lapouge et al., 1999). This distortion may also be observed when modified cofactors are artificially introduced in these complexes (Lapouge et al., 2000). In the absence of direct experimental evidence of the effect of such distortion, it is unclear yet whether it has any influence on the BChl absorption, and even less at which extent it perturbs its electronic properties. However, interpreting the dichroic properties of the Qy electronic transitions of the LH2 complexes requires the two BChl molecules bound to the α and β polypeptides to be spectrally different, with the β BChl about 300 cm–1 redder than the α BChl (Koolhaas et al., 1998). A similar difference was predicted by quantum chemical calculations (Alden et al., 1997). These calculations suggest, although indirectly, that the conformation of BChls influence their electronic properties in LH complexes. V. Excitonic Interactions and Disorder in Light-Harvesting Complexes We have seen that ground-state interactions play an important role in tuning the position of the lower energy transition of antenna complexes of purple bacteria. However, ground-state interactions alone do not explain more than a fraction of the observed red-shift experienced by this transition. Early fluorescence depolarization studies (i.e., more than a decade before the structure was known) led to the prediction of the cylindrical symmetry of the involved cluster of BChl molecules (Kramer et al., 1984). These experiments also indicated the efficiency of excitation
205
energy transfer between the 850 nm-absorbing BChl molecules. Since then, a wide range of spectroscopic measurements have established that excitation energy transfers between the 850 nm-absorbing BChl molecules occur on an ultrafast timescale (Visser et al., 1995; Jimenez and Fleming, 1996; Jimenez et al., 1997; Kennis et al., 1997b; Chachisvilis et al., 1997; Nagarajan et al., 1999). This, together with the intense dichroic signal of the 850 nm transition indicates that the lower energy electronic transition arises from excitonically coupled BChl molecules. Spectroscopic measurements, as well as calculations based on the atomic structure of the LH2 complex, estimate the coupling strength between adjacent BChl molecules as ca 300 cm–1. In the structure of LH complexes from purple bacteria the large circular arrays of BChl cofactors in close contact must be considered as excitonically coupled systems. Taking into account the strength of the BChl/BChl excitonic interactions, these circular arrays should formally give rise to absorption transitions corresponding not to the sum of the absorption transitions of each of the individual BChls, but to one giant electronic transition reflecting their collective property. This pure exciton model is able to predict the correct position and shape of the absorption transition of the LH complex (see e.g., McDermott et al. (1995) or Sauer et al (1996)). However, such a prediction alone does not validate the pure exciton model (Sturgis and Robert, 1996; Monshouwer and van Grondelle, 1996). Moreover, in the pure exciton model, the lowest excitonic level must have close to zero dipole strength. A straightforward consequence of this conclusion is that LH2 complexes should not be fluorescent at very low temperature. However a number of experiments show clearly that this prediction is wrong; LH2 complexes from Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus both fluoresce with a rate 2–3 times faster than monomeric BChl in solvent (Monshouwer et al., 1997). It may thus be concluded that the direct use of the molecular structure of LH protein for calculating its functional properties leads to wrong predictions. This is a fascinating feature of the LH proteins, the properties of which can only be understood if defaults are introduced in their molecular structure. The first experiments which showed that disorder was an important factor for explaining the functional properties of LH were actually performed in the 1980s, when it was discovered that the position of their fluorescence electronic transition at low temperature depends on the position of the excita-
206 tion wavelength. These experiments suggested the existence of subpopulations of LH complexes, but, as no such subpopulation could be detected, they had to be taken as evidence that, in a biochemically homogeneous set of LH proteins, not all share the same electronic properties (van Mourik et al., 1992). Such heterogeneity may either be due to differences in the local physico-chemical properties of the BChl molecules, arising either from slight differences in conformation and/or the conformation of the immediate surroundings, or from dynamic fluctuations of the system (these two effects are usually referred to as static and dynamic disorder). Because of the existence of disorder in the structure, each of the otherwise chemically identical BChl molecules shares slightly different properties, and they will tend to retain their individual physico-chemical properties despite their interactions. This, in turn, will tend to localize the excited state onto a subset of BChls within the interacting ensemble. It is worth underlining here that an appropriate estimation of the disorder in the LH complexes from purple bacteria constitutes a crucial point in many respects. Firstly, it is essential for the proper understanding and modeling of the electronic properties of these proteins (in particular their fluorescence properties). Second, the whole physical description of the dynamics of the excitation energy in these complexes will depend on the extent of disorder. Depending on whether the excitation energy is localized on a subset of molecules, or whether it is entirely delocalized on the BChl ring, the physical processes which will underlie its evolution will be entirely different. In the first case, absorption of the photon will be followed by an ultrafast relaxation process, and then by incoherent hopping of the excitation energy from a subset to another. In the second case, the whole system may be described as one unique supermolecule, with electronic levels given by diagonalization of the interaction Hamiltonian. On this one supermolecule, the only phenomenon possible is the relaxation between these energy levels, through energy exchange with vibrations of the system (phonon-induced relaxation). The LH complexes are probably the biological macromolecules best-suited for studying disorder in biological system. This is due to the fact that i) the events in these proteins are on the same timescale as the protein motion and ii) the interacting BChl molecules constitute a system exquisitely sensitive to disorder. As stated above, in the absence of disorder, LH2 complexes should exhibit no fluorescence at very low temperature. Measuring the fluorescence properties
Bruno Robert of LH2 as a function of temperature is probably one of the best methods to evaluate the consequence of disorder on the excitonically-coupled systems in these proteins. This yields a value for the disorder about two times larger than the pigment-pigment coupling strength (van Grondelle et al., 1997), and a localization of the excitation in the 850-nm absorbing ring over a few (2–4) BChl molecules (Monshouwer et al., 1997). Similar values have been deduced from a variety of spectroscopic measurements ( Pullerits et al., 1996; Kennis et al., 1997a; Kuhn and Sundström, 1997). The LH rings thus constitute systems of strongly coupled pigments, where the disorder is large enough to destroy the delocalization of the exciton over the whole set of molecules. However, neither can they be fully considered as assemblies of these small sets of pigments, as each of these is still part of the whole circular array. Circular dichroism (CD) measurements clearly reveal the dual character of these rings. In the strong, conservative CD signal of LH2 (Cogdell and Scheer, 1985) the zero crossing point does not coincide with the absorption maximum but is slightly shifted to the red (Sauer et al., 1996; Koolhaas et al., 1997, 2000). Furthermore, in a mutant of Rba. sphaeroides lacking the B800 BChls, a broad, weak, negative CD-band around 780 nm (Koolhaas et al., 1998) was observed which was ascribed to the upper exciton band of the B850 ring. The contribution to the LH2 CD signal from neighboring BChl molecules is small, as they have almost parallel transition dipoles. Modeling the CD from LH2 thus requires taking into account all of the BChl molecules of the 850 nm ring, as the maximum CD contribution originates from interactions between dipoles separated by about a quarter of the ring (Koolhaas et al., 1997). Thus, although disorder induces a localization of the excitation on a few molecules, the ensemble of BChl/BChl interactions in the whole ring is necessary to model the CD of the LH2 (Somsen et al., 1996; Koolhaas et al., 1998; Georgakopoulou et al., 2002). LH1 proteins, in which similar or stronger BChl-BChl interactions would be expected, exhibit a more complex, weaker, non-conservative signal in the 875 nm region, which may vary from complex to complex. Modeling the CD of LH1 has proven to be an extremely difficult task (Georgakopoulou et al., 2006), probably because the transition dipoles in LH1 are oriented even more in the plane of the ring than in LH2. As a consequence, all contributions to the CD cancel and the signal becomes sensitive to small variations in the orientation and position of the transition dipoles. Of course, disorder-induced localization of the
Chapter 11
Spectroscopic Properties of Antenna Complexes
excitation should wipe out most of the details of the exciton manifold which can be deduced from the symmetry of the LH structure. In addition, structural differences such as i) ellipiticity of the LH1 induced by the interaction with the reaction centers (Jamieson et al., 2002; Scheuring et al., 2003), or ii) interruption of the ring by the PufX component (Roszak et al., 2003) or even iii) absence of part of the subunits in an LH1 ring (Bahatyrova et al., 2004a) should not have any detectable influence on the electronic properties of the complexes, which should be primarily dominated by the disorder. This view has been challenged by fluorescence experiments on single LH complexes performed at very low temperature. Fluorescence excitation spectra of single LH2 in the 850 nm region suggest the presence of two perpendicularly polarized transitions (Bopp et al., 1999; van Oijen et al., 1999a; see also Chapter 44, Köhler, for a discussion of single molecule methodology and the results on LH2 complexes). This would indicate that disorder, either static or dynamic, is not large enough to fully destroy excitation collectiveness in LH2. However, in these experiments, the splitting between the two transitions is too large to be accounted by the X-ray crystallographic structure of the complexes. It was thus further concluded that the BChl/BChl coupling was modulated by an elliptical deformation of the B850 ring (van Oijen et al., 1999b; Ketelaars et al., 2001; Matsushita et al., 2001). In the complete absence of experimental evidence of such LH2 structures (see Chapter 8, Gabrielsen et al.; Chapter 14, Sturgis and Niederman, and references therein) definitive interpretation of these experiments is probably still quite open. More recently it has been proposed, still from single protein fluorescence experiments at low temperature, that interrupting the LH1 ring by the PufX protein would result in a change in the LH1 symmetry which would, in turn, affect the exciton manifold of the 32 (or less) B875 BChl molecules (Richter et al., 2007). Indeed, in the exciton picture, breakage of the perfect symmetry should result in a gain of oscillator strength by the lowest excitonic level. A sharp transition was observed in the LH1 from Rps. palustris, where crystallographic studies suggest that the LH1 ring is indeed interrupted by an equivalent of the PufX protein is present (Roszak et al., 2003). Such a sharp transition was attributed to a gain of oscillator strength by the lowest excitonic level, due to symmetry breaking. These experiments tend to favor a picture of LH complexes where the disorder has little influence, if at all, on the exciton manifold of the excitonically coupled BChl molecules. However, one may wonder whether such a detailed conclusion
207
may be drawn from these experiments. LH complexes from Rps. palustris are poorly characterized. The fact that it is possible to obtain a crystallographic structure from a LH preparation does not, in the absence of detailed spectroscopic characterization, indicate that the obtained structure is representative of the average structure present in biochemical preparations of LH1, and even less that it is relevant for describing the structure of the few LH1 molecules studied by single molecule fluorescence. Again, single molecule fluorescence experiments challenge the commonly accepted view of LH as a disorder-dominated structure, but not in an undisputable way. In contrast, room temperature fluorescence experiments performed on LH complexes have reported sudden changes in the fluorescence spectra (Rutkauskas et al., 2004, 2005, 2006). Such large changes strongly suggest that LH2 goes through a number of conformational substates at room temperature, thus reinforcing the idea that the dynamic disorder is large in these complexes. A quantitative analysis of these results was recently proposed, based on the modified Redfield theory and the disordered exciton model (Novoderezhkin et al., 2006; see also Chapter 13, van Grondelle and Novoderezhkin). Interestingly, from such a model, developed for interpreting single molecule fluorescence, it may be predicted that the electronic absorption transition of the LH2 ensemble should exhibit a temperature dependence between 0 and 60 °C (L. Valkunas, personal communication), which has been recently observed (J. Seguin and M. Paternostre, personal communication). VI. Chromophore Interactions in LightHarvesting Proteins: Additional Effects In the previous paragraphs, we have only considered the interactions between BChl molecules from an excitonic point of view. Excitonic interactions are likely to be one of the dominant parameters for tuning the electronic absorption of the LH complexes. However, other aspects of BChl/BChl interactions must be considered. In the B850/B875 BChl rings from LH2/LH1, each BChl molecule provides an environment for its neighbors. In these rings, the molecular situation is thus different from, for example, that of the B800 BChl molecules. As the spectroscopic properties of the BChl molecules are expected to be sensitive to influences from their surrounding environment, solvation mechanisms may play a role in tuning the electronic properties of LH proteins. It is clear
Bruno Robert
208 that BChl/BChl interactions influence the shape of the lower energy transition in these proteins. Rapid fluctuations in the environment, related to vibrations of the pigments and the surrounding protein, indeed define the homogeneous line shape of the electronic transitions (see Chapter 13, van Grondelle and Novoderezhkin). The nature of the environment of the B800 and B850 BChl molecules being different, the homogeneous line shapes of their electronic transitions are also different (Urboniene et al., 2007). In a sense, BChl/BChl interactions in BChl rings partly ‘shape’ the lowest electronic transitions in LH complexes. On the other hand, the very tight packing of the BChl in LH1 and LH2 rings may lead to a quite complex situation. The BChl/BChl interactions, eventually in combination with the asymmetric electrostatic environment provided by the protein, may perturb the properties of the excited states. The asymmetry of the electron density in the excited state may become larger, and the excited state may, in these conditions exhibit charge-transfer character. For both LH1 and LH2, it actually was shown by Stark spectroscopy that the Qy transitions exhibit a strong charge-transfer character, with LH1 significantly larger than LH2 (Gottfried et al., 1991; Beekman et al., 1997a,b). This charge-transfer character is not present in the Qy transitions of monomeric pigments, and must thus arise from the influence of αβ polypeptides on the BChl molecule array. It was proposed that the existence of such a charge-transfer character of the Qy transition of LH1 and LH2 is one of the reasons why this transition experiences such a large red-shift in these proteins (Somsen et al., 1998). Measurements conducted at high hydrostatic pressure, have shown that the Qy transition of LH1 and LH2 gradually shift to the red according to pressure (Timpmann et al., 2001), This pressure dependence of the Qy transition may be very large (as large as 1000 cm–1/GPa in LH1 (Sturgis et al., 1998)) although the conformations and the specific protein/BChl interactions are generally not affected below 0.7 GPa (Sturgis et al., 1998; Gall et al., 2003) (Fig. 4). It is worth noting that there seems to be a correlation between the sensitivity to pressure of the Qy transition of the complex and its charge-transfer character, as deduced from Stark measurements. This suggests that charge-transfer character is an important parameter in the pressure behavior of these transitions. Additional experiments are however needed to clarify the causes of the pressure-induced red-shift of the LH complexes, and they
Fig. 4. Pressure-induced redshift on the lower energy transition of LH1 from Rsp. rubrum, strain S1. Pressures at which each spectrum was recorded is indicated in GPa on the figure.
may clarify the role of the charge-transfer character in tuning the absorption of LH complexes. VII. Conclusions LH complexes of purple photosynthetic bacteria are biological molecules which have been characterized at an unprecedented level of physics and physical chemistry. In recent years, theoretical and experimental developments have reached such a point that most of the electronic properties of these proteins are understood. There are, however, a number of open questions which require further developments. Among these questions, the most important one is probably which structural parameters determine that an LH protein is an LH1 or an LH2, and how precisely the difference in the structure of these complexes determines the difference in their spectroscopic properties. The few experiments conducted in this direction (Hu et al., 1998) have not yet yielded any clearly confirmed conclusion. Many structural factors may play a role in determining the nature of LH complexes, such as the presence of an additional BChl ring in LH2, or the different organization of the H-bond network between the polypeptides and the BChl responsible for the lower energy transition. If it is now quite clear that most of the differences between the lower energy electronic transitions of LH1 and LH2 arise from the difference in the orientation of the BChl dipoles both relative to each other and in the plane of the LH ring, it is often difficult to accurately (and uniquely) relate these parameters with the spectroscopic properties of large and small circular arrays of
Chapter 11
Spectroscopic Properties of Antenna Complexes
BChl molecules. This is due, in particular, to the fact that only small (16–18) and large (32) circular arrays of BChl molecules have been accessible to experimental work. We are clearly at a point, in this field, where new proteins have to be characterized, which would comprise intermediate circular oligomers of polypeptides, and in which would exist circular arrays of BChl molecules of intermediate size, with symmetries that differ from those already described. There have been some preliminary reports that such LH complexes do exist. Their extensive characterization will certainly constitute, in a near future, the basis for new breakthroughs in the description and modeling of the spectroscopic properties of light-harvesting proteins from purple photosynthetic bacteria. Acknowledgments The author thanks the French Agence Nationale de la Recherche (programs Mastrit and Caroprotect) and the European Union (program INTRO2) for financial support. References Alden RG, Johnson E, Nagarajan V, Parson WW, Law CJ, and Cogdell RJC (1997) Calculations of spectroscopic properties of the LH2 bacteriochlorophyll-protein antenna complex from Rhodopseudomonas acidophila. J Phys Chem B 101: 4667–4680 Bahatyrova S, Frese RN, van der Werf KO, Otto C, Hunter CN and Olsen JD (2004a) Flexibility and size heterogeneity of the LH1 light harvesting complex revealed by atomic force microscopy Functional significance for bacterial photosynthesis. J Biol Chem 279: 21327–21333 Bahatyrova S, Frese RN, Siebert, CA, van der Werf KO, van Grondelle R, Niederman RA, Bullough PA, Otto C, Olsen JD and Hunter CN (2004b) The native architecture of a photosynthetic membrane. Nature 430: 1058–1062 Beekman LMP, Frese RN, Fowler GJS, Ortiz de Zarate I, Cogdell RJ, van Stokkum I, Hunter CN and van Grondelle R (1997a) Characterization of the light-harvesting antennas of photosynthetic purple bacteria by Stark spectroscopy. 2. LH2 complexes: Influence of the protein environment. J Phys Chem B 101: 7293–7301 Beekman LMP, Steffen M, van Stokkum I, Olsen JD, Hunter CN, Boxer SG and van Grondelle R (1997b) Characterization of the light-harvesting antennas of photosynthetic purple bacteria by Stark spectroscopy. 1. LH1 antenna complex and the B820 subunit from Rhodospirillum rubrum. J Phys Chem B 101: 7284–7292 Bopp MA, Sytnik A, Howard TD, Cogdell RJ and Hochstrasser RM (1999) The dynamics of structural deformations of im-
209
mobilized single light-harvesting complexes. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 96: 11271–11276 Brunisholz RA, Bissig I, Niederer E, Suter F and Zuber H (1987) Structural studies on the light-harvesting polypeptides of Rp. acidophila. In: Biggins J (ed) Progress in Photosynthesis Research, Proceedings 7th International Congress of Photosynthesis, pp 13–16. Nijhoff, Dordrecht Clayton RK (1963) Towards the isolation of a photochemical reaction center in Rhodopseudomonas spheroides. Biochim Biophys Acta 75: 312–323 Chachisvilis M, Kuehn O, Pullerits T and Sundström V (1997) Excitons in photosynthetic purple bacteria: Wavelike motion or incoherent hopping? J Phys Chem B 101: 7275–7283 Cogdell RJ and Scheer H (1985) Circular dichroism of lightharvesting complexes from purple photosynthetic bacteria. Photochem Photobiol 42: 669–678 Cogdell RJ, Hawthornthwaite AM, Evans MB, Ferguson LA, Kerfeld C, Thornber JP, Van Mourik F and van Grondelle R (1990) Isolation and characterization of an unusual antenna complex from the marine purple sulfur photosynthetic bacterium Chromatium purpuratum BN5500. Biochim Biophys Acta 1019: 239–244 Fathir I, Ashikaga M, Tanaka K, Katano T, Nirasawa T, Kobayashi M, Wang Z-Y and Nozawa T (1998) Biochemical and spectral characterization of the core light harvesting complex 1 (LH1) from the thermophilic purple sulfur bacterium Chromatium tepidum. Photosynth Res 58: 193–202 Fowler GJS, Visschers RW, Grief GG, van Grondelle R and Hunter CN (1992) Genetically modified photosynthetic antenna complexes with blueshifted absorbance bands. Nature 355: 848–850 Fowler GJS, Sockalingum GD, Robert B and Hunter CN (1994) Blue shifts in bacteriochlorophyll absorbance correlate with changed hydrogen bonding patterns in light-harvesting 2 mutants of Rhodobacter sphaeroides with alterations at α-Tyr-44 and α-Tyr-45. Biochem J 299: 695–700 Fowler GJS, Hess S, Pullerits T, Sundström V and Hunter CN (1997) Role of β Arg-10 in the B800 bacteriochlorophyll and carotenoid pigment environment within the light-harvesting LH2 complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 36: 11282–11291 Francia F, Wang J, Venturoli G, Melandri BA, Barz WP and Oesterhelt D (1999) The reaction center-LH1 antenna complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides contains one PufX molecule which is involved in dimerization of this complex. Biochemistry 38: 6834–6845 French CS (1940) The pigment protein compound of photosynthetic bacteria. J Gen Physiol 23: 483–494 Frese RN, Olsen JD, Branvall R, Westerhuis WHJ, Hunter CN and van Grondelle R (2000) The long-range supraorganization of the bacterial photosynthetic unit: A key role for PufX. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 97: 5197–5202 Gall A and Robert B (1999) Characterization of the different peripheral light-harvesting complexes from high- and low-light grown cells from Rhodopseudomonas palustris. Biochemistry 38: 5185–5190 Gall A, Fowler GJS, Hunter CN and Robert B (1997) Influence of the protein binding site on the absorption properties of the monomeric bacteriochlorophyll in Rhodobacter sphaeroides LH2 complex. Biochemistry 36: 16282–16287 Gall A, Yurkov V, Verméglio A and Robert B (1999) Certain species
210 of the Proteobacteria possess unusual bacteriochlorophyll a environments in their light-harvesting proteins. Biospectroscopy 5: 338-345 Gall A, Ellervee A, Sturgis JN, Fraser NJ, Cogdell RJ, Freiberg A and Robert B. (2003) Membrane protein stability: High pressure effects on the structure and chromophore-binding properties of the light-harvesting complex LH2. Biochemistry 42: 13019–13026 Garcia D, Parot P, Verméglio A and Madigan MT (1986) The light-harvesting complexes of a thermophilic purple sulfur photosynthetic bacterium Chromatium tepidum. Biochim Biophys Acta 850: 390–395 Georgakopoulou S, Frese RN, Johnson E, Koolhaas MHC, Cogdell RJ, van Grondelle R and van der Zwan G (2002) Absorption and CD spectroscopy and modeling of various LH2 complexes from purple bacteria. Biophys J 82: 2184–2197 Georgakopoulou S, van der Zwan G, Olsen JD, Hunter CN, Niederman RA and van Grondelle R (2006) Investigation of the effects of different carotenoids on the absorption and CD signals of light harvesting 1 complexes. J Phys Chem B. 110: 3354–3361 Germeroth L, Lottspeich F, Robert B and Michel H (1993) Unexpected similarities of the B800-850 light-harvesting complex from Rhodospirillum molischianum to the B870 light-harvesting complexes from other purple photosynthetic bacteria. Biochemistry 32: 5615–21 Gottfried DS, Stocker JW and Boxer SG (1991) Stark effect spectroscopy of bacteriochlorophyll in light-harvesting complexes from photosynthetic bacteria. Biochim Biophys Acta 1059: 63–75 Gudowska-Nowak E, Newton MD and Fajer J (1990) Conformation and environmental effects on bacteriochlorophyll optical spectra: Correlations of calculated spectra with structural studies. J Phys Chem 94: 5795–5801 Hartigan N, Tharia HA, Sweeney F, Lawless AM and Papiz MZ (2002) The 7.5-Å electron density and spectroscopic properties of a novel low-light B800 LH2 from Rhodopseudomonas palustris. Biophys J. 82: 963–977 Hu Q, Sturgis JN, Robert B, Delagrave S, Youvan DC and Niederman RA (1998) Hydrogen bonding and circular dichroism of bacteriochlorophylls in the Rhodobacter capsulatus lightharvesting II complex altered by combinatorial mutagenesis. Biochemistry 37: 10006–10015 Isaacs NW, Cogdell RJ, Freer AA and Prince SM (1995) Lightharvesting mechanisms in purple photosynthetic bacteria. Curr Opin Struct Biol 5:794–797 Jamieson SJ, Wang P, Qian P, Kirkland JY, Conroy MJ, Hunter CN and Bullough PA. (2002) Projection structure of the photosynthetic reaction centre-antenna complex of Rhodospirillum rubrum at 8.5 Å resolution. EMBO J 21: 3927–3935 Jimenez R and Fleming GR (1996) Ultrafast spectroscopy of photosynthetic systems. Adv Photosynth 3: 63–73 Jimenez R, van Mourik F, Yu JY and Fleming GR (1997) Threepulse photon echo measurements on LH1 and LH2 complexes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides: A nonlinear spectroscopic probe of energy transfer. J Phys Chem B 101: 7350–7359 Jungas C, Ranck J-L, Rigaud J-L, Joliot P and Verméglio A (1999) Supramolecular organization of the photosynthetic apparatus of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. EMBO J 18: 534–542 Karrasch S, Bullough PA and Ghosh R (1995) The 8.5 Å projection map of the light-harvesting complex I from Rhodospiril-
Bruno Robert lum rubrum reveals a ring composed of 16 subunits. EMBO J 14: 631–368 Kennis JTM, Streltsov AM, Permentier H, Aartsma TJ and Amesz J (1997a) Exciton coherence and energy transfer in the LH2 antenna complex of Rhodopseudomonas acidophila at low temperature. J Phys Chem B 101: 8369–8374 Kennis JTM, Streltsov AM, Vulto SIE, Aartsma TJ, Nozawa T and Amesz J (1997b) Femtosecond dynamics in isolated LH2 complexes of various species of purple bacteria. J Phys Chem B 101: 7827–7834 Ketelaars M, Van Oijen AM, Matsushita M, Köhler J, Schmidt J and Aartsma TJ (2001) Spectroscopy on the B850 band of individual light-harvesting 2 complexes of Rhodopseudomonas acidophila I. experiments and Monte Carlo simulations. Biophys J 80: 1591–1603 Koepke J, Hu X, Muenke C, Schulten K and Michel H (1996) The crystal structure of the light-harvesting complex II (B800-850) from Rhodospirillum molischianum. Structure 4: 581–597 Koolhaas MHC, van der Zwan G, Frese RN and van Grondelle R (1997) Red shift of the zero crossing in the CD spectra of the LH2 antenna complex of Rhodopseudomonas acidophila: A structure-based study. J Phys Chem B 101: 7262–7270 Koolhaas MHC, Frese RN, Fowler GJS, Bibby TA, Georgakopoulou S, van der Zwan G, Hunter CN, and van Grondelle R (1998) Identification of the upper exciton component of the B850 bacteriochlorophylls of the LH2 antenna complex, using a B800-free mutant of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 37: 4693–4698 Koolhaas MHC, van der Zwan G and van Grondelle R (2000) Local and nonlocal contributions to the linear spectroscopy of light-harvesting antenna systems. J Phys Chem B 104: 4489–4502 Kramer HJM, van Grondelle R, Hunter CN, Westerhuis WHJ and Amesz J (1984) Pigment organization of the B800-850 antenna complex of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. Biochim Biophys Acta 765: 156–165 Kuhn O and Sundström V (1997) Pump-probe spectroscopy of dissipative energy transfer dynamics in photosynthetic antenna complexes: A density matrix approach. J Chem Phys 107: 4154–4164 Kwa LG, Garcia-Martin A, Vegh AP, Strohmann B, Robert B and Braun P. (2004) Hydrogen bonding in a model bacteriochlorophyll-binding site drives assembly of light harvesting complex. J Biol Chem. 279:15067–15075 Krikunova M, Kummrow A, Voigt B, Rini M, Lokstein H, Moskalenko, AA, Scheer H, Razjivin A and Leupold D (2002) Fluorescence of native and carotenoid-depleted LH2 from Chromatium minutissimum originating from simultaneous two-photon absorption in the spectral range of the presumed (optically ‘dark’) S1 state of carotenoids. FEBS Lett 530: 227–229 Lapouge K, Näveke A, Gall A, Seguin J, Scheer H, Sturgis J and Robert B (1999) Conformation of bacteriochlorophyll molecules in photosynthetic proteins from purple bacteria. Biochemistry 38: 11115–11121 Lapouge K, Näveke A, Robert B, Scheer H and Sturgis JN (2000) Exchanging cofactors in the core antennae from purple bacteria: structure and properties of Zn-bacteriopheophytin-containing LH1. Biochemistry 39: 1091–1099 Matsushita M, Ketelaars M, Van Oijen AM, Köhler J, Aartsma TJ and Schmidt J (2001) Spectroscopy on the B850 band of
Chapter 11
Spectroscopic Properties of Antenna Complexes
individual light-harvesting 2 complexes of Rhodopseudomonas acidophila II. Exciton states of an elliptically deformed ring aggregate. Biophys J 80: 1604–1614 McDermott G, Prince SM, Freer AA, Hawthornthwaite-Lawless AM, Papiz MZ, Cogdell RJ and Isaacs NW (1995) Crystal structure of an integral membrane light-harvesting complex from photosynthetic bacteria. Nature 374: 517–521 McLuskey K, Prince SM, Cogdell RJ and Isaacs NW (1999) Crystallization and preliminary X-ray crystallographic analysis of the B800-820 light-harvesting complex from Rhodopseudomonas acidophila strain 7050. Acta Cryst D55: 885–887 Molisch H (1907) Die Purpurbakterien nach neuen Untersuchungen. Gustav Fisher, Jena Monshouwer R and van Grondelle R (1996) Excitations and excitons in bacterial light-harvesting complexes. Biochim Biophys Acta 1275: 70–75 Monshouwer R, Abrahamsson M, van Mourik F and van Grondelle R (1997) Superradiance and exciton delocalization in bacterial photosynthetic light-harvesting systems. J Phys Chem B 101: 7241–7248 Nagarajan V, Johnson ET, Williams JC and Parson WW (1999) Femtosecond pump-probe spectroscopy of the B850 antenna complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides at room temperature. J Phys Chem B 103: 2297–2309 Novoderezhkin VI, Rutkauskas D and van Grondelle R (2006) Dynamics of the emission spectrum of a single LH2 complex: Interplay of slow and fast nuclear motions. Biophys J 90: 2890–2902 Olsen JD, Sockalingum GD, Robert B and Hunter CN (1994) Modification of a hydrogen bond to a bacteriochlorophyll a molecule in the light-harvesting 1 antenna of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 91: 7124–7128 Olsen JD, Sturgis JN, Westerhuis WHJ, Fowler GJS, Hunter CN and Robert B (1997) Site-directed modification of the ligands to the bacteriochlorophylls of the light-harvesting LH1 and LH2 complexes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 36: 12625–12632 Pardee AB, Schachman HK and Stanier RY (1952) Chromatophores of Rhodospirillum rubrum. Nature 169: 282–283 Prince SM, Papiz MZ., Freer AA, McDermott G, Hawthornthwaite-Lawless AM, Cogdell RJ, and Isaacs NW (1997) Apoprotein structure in the LH2 complex from Rhodopseudomonas acidophila strain 10050: Modular assembly and protein pigment interactions. J Mol Biol 268: 412–423 Pullerits T, Chachisvilis M and Sundström V (1996) Exciton delocalization length in the B850 antenna of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Phys Chem 100: 10787–10792 Qian P, Hunter CN and Bullough PA (2005) The 8.5Å projection structure of the core RC-LH1-PufX dimer of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Mol Biol 349: 948–960 Richter MF, Baier J, Prem T, Oellerich S, Francia F, Venturoli G, Oesterhelt D, Southall J, Cogdell RJ and Köhler J (2007) Symmetry matters for the electronic structure of core complexes from Rhodopseudomonas palustris and Rhodobacter sphaeroides PufX−. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 104: 6661–6665 Ridge JP, Fyfe PK, McAuley KE, van Brederode ME, Robert B, van Grondelle R, Isaacs NW, Cogdell RJ and Jones MR (2000) An examination of how structural changes can affect the rate of electron transfer in a mutated bacterial photoreaction centre. Biochem J 352: 567–578 Robert B and Lutz M (1985) Structures of antenna complexes of
211
several Rhodospirillales from their resonance Raman spectra. Biochim Biophys Acta 807: 10–23 Robert B, Andrianambinintsoa S and Lutz M. (1985) Structural characterization of high 800 nm-absorbing light-harvesting complexes from Rhodospirillales from their resonance Raman spectra. J. Biochem. 98: 349–354 Roszak AW, Howard TD, Southall J, Gardiner AT, Law CJ, Isaacs, NW and Cogdell RJ (2003) Crystal structure of the RC-LH1 core complex from Rhodopseudomonas palustris. Science 302: 1969–1972 Rutkauskas D, Novoderezhkin V, Cogdell RJ and van Grondelle R (2004) Fluorescence spectral fluctuations of single LH2 complexes from Rhodopseudomonas acidophila strain 10050. Biochemistry 43: 4431–4438 Rutkauskas D, Novoderezhkin V, Cogdell RJ and van Grondelle R (2005) Fluorescence spectroscopy of conformational changes of single LH2 complexes. Biophys J 88: 422–435 Rutkauskas D, Novoderezhkin V, Gall A, Olsen J, Cogdell RJ, Hunter CN and van Grondelle R (2006) Spectral trends in the fluorescence of single bacterial light-harvesting complexes: Experiments and modified Redfield simulations. Biophys J 90: 2475–2485 Sauer K, Cogdell RJ, Prince SM, Freer A, Isaacs NW and Scheer H (1996) Structure-based calculations of the optical spectra of the LH2 bacteriochlorophyll-protein complex from Rhodopseudomonas acidophila. Photochem Photobiol 64: 564–576 Savage H, Cyrklaff M, Montoya G, Kühlbrandt W and Sinning I (1996) Two-dimensional structure of light harvesting complex II (LHII) from the purple bacterium Rhodovulum sulfidophilum and comparison with LHII from Rhodopseudomonas acidophila. Structure 4: 243–252 Scheuring, S, Seguin J, Marco S, Lévy D, Robert B and Rigaud J-L (2003) Nanodissection and high-resolution imaging of the Rhodopseudomonas viridis photosynthetic core complex in native membranes by AFM. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 100: 1690–1693 Scheuring S, Rigaud JL and Sturgis JN (2004) Variable LH2 stoichiometry and core clustering in native membranes of Rhodospirillum photometricum. EMBO J 23: 4127–413 Siebert CA, Qian P, Fotiadis D, Engel A, Hunter CN and Bullough PA (2004) Molecular architecture of photosynthetic membranes in Rhodobacter sphaeroides: The role of PufX. EMBO J 23: 690–700 Somsen OJG, Valkunas L and van Grondelle R (1996) A perturbed two-level model for exciton trapping in small photosynthetic systems. Biophys J 70: 669–683 Somsen OJG, Chernyak V, Frese RN, van Grondelle R and Mukamel S (1998) Excitonic interactions and Stark spectroscopy of light harvesting systems. J Phys Chem B 102: 8893–8908 Sturgis JN and Robert B (1996) The role of chromophore coupling in tuning the spectral properties of peripheral light-harvesting protein of purple bacteria. Photosynth Res 50: 5-10 Sturgis JN and Robert B (1997) Pigment binding-site and electronic properties in light-harvesting proteins of purple bacteria. J Phys Chem B 101: 7227–7231 Sturgis JN, Hageman G, Tadros MH, and Robert B (1995a) Biochemical and spectroscopic characterization of the B800-850 light-harvesting complex from Rhodobacter sulfidophilus and its B800-830 spectral form. Biochemistry 34: 10519–10524 Sturgis JN, Jirsakova V, Reiss-Husson F, Cogdell RJ and Robert B (1995b) Structure and properties of the bacteriochlorophyll
212 binding site in peripheral light-harvesting complexes of purple bacteria. Biochemistry 34:517–523 Sturgis JN, Olsen JD, Robert B and Hunter CN (1997) Functions of conserved tryptophan residues of the core light-harvesting complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 36:2772–2778 Sturgis JN, Gall A, Ellervee A, Freiberg A and Robert B (1998) The effect of pressure on the bacteriochlorophyll a binding sites of the core antenna complex from Rhodospirillum rubrum. Biochemistry 37: 14875–14880 Timpmann K, Ellervee A, Pullerits T, Ruus R, Sundström V and Freiberg A (2001) Short-range exciton couplings in LH2 photosynthetic antenna proteins studied by high hydrostatic pressure absorption spectroscopy. J Phys Chem B 105: 8436–8444 Urboniene V, Vrublevskaja O, Trinkunas G, Gall A, Robert B and Valkunas L. (2007) Solvation effect of bacteriochlorophyll excitons in light-harvesting complex LH2 Biophys J 93: 2188–2198 van Grondelle R, Dekker JP, Gillbro T and Sundström V (1994) Energy transfer and trapping in photosynthesis. Biochim Biophys Acta 1187: 1–65 van Grondelle R, Monshouwer R, and Valkunas L (1997) Photosynthetic light-harvesting. Pure Appl Chem 69: 1211–1218 Van Mourik F, Visschers RW and van Grondelle R (1992) Energy transfer and aggregate size effects in the inhomogeneously
Bruno Robert broadened core light-harvesting complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Chem Phys Lett 193: 1–7 Van Oijen AM, Ketelaars M, Köhler J, Aartsma TJ and Schmidt J (1999a) Unraveling the electronic structure of individual photosynthetic pigment-protein complexes. Science 285: 400–402 Van Oijen AM, Ketelaars M, Köhler J, Aartsma TJ and Schmidt J (1999b) Spectroscopy of individual LH2 complexes of Rhodopseudomonas acidophila: Localized excitations in the B800 band. Chem Phys 247: 53–60 Visser HM, Somsen OJG, von Mourik F, Lin S, van Stokkum IHM and van Grondelle R (1995) Direct observation of sub-picosecond equilibration of excitation energy in the light-harvesting antenna of Rhodospirillum rubrum. Biophys J 69: 1083–1099 Walz T and Ghosh R (1997) Two-dimensional crystallization of the light-harvesting I-reaction center photounit from Rhodospirillum rubrum. J Mol Biol 265:107–111 Walz T, Jamieson SJ, Bowers CM, Bullough PA and Hunter CN (1998) Projection structures of three photosynthetic complexes from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: LH2 at 6 Å, LH1 and RC-LH1 at 25 Å. J Mol Biol 282: 833–845 Zuber H, and Brunisholz RA (1991) Structure and function of antenna polypeptides and chlorophyll-protein complexes: principles and variability. In Scheer H (ed) Chlorophylls, pp 627–703. CRC, Boca Raton
Chapter 12 Energy Transfer from Carotenoids to Bacteriochlorophylls Harry A. Frank Department of Chemistry, University of Connecticut, Storrs, CT 06269-3060 U.S.A.
Tomáš Polívka* Institute of Physical Biology, University of South Bohemia, Zamek 136, CZ-373 33 Nove Hrady Czech Republic; and Biological Centre, Czech Academy of Sciences, Czech Republic
Summary ............................................................................................................................................................... 213 I. Introduction..................................................................................................................................................... 214 II. Carotenoid Excited States .............................................................................................................................. 215 III. Energy Transfer in Light-Harvesting 2 Complexes......................................................................................... 216 A. Energy Transfer via the S2 State ...................................................................................................... 216 B. Energy Transfer via the S1 State ...................................................................................................... 219 C. The S* State ..................................................................................................................................... 222 D. Other Pathways................................................................................................................................ 224 E. The Role of B800 ............................................................................................................................. 225 IV. Energy Transfer in Light-Harvesting 1 Complexes and Reaction Centers ..................................................... 226 V. Outlook ........................................................................................................................................................... 227 Acknowledgments ................................................................................................................................................. 227 References ............................................................................................................................................................ 227
Summary The photosynthetic apparatus contains light-harvesting (LH) pigment-protein complexes that capture light energy from the sun and transfer it efficiently to the reaction center. In photosynthetic bacteria, carotenoids supplement the non-optimal LH capacity of bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) in the 400–500 nm region of the visible spectrum. Thus, carotenoid-to-BChl energy transfer provides an essential process for enhancing the ability of these systems to capture light energy and convert it into useful work. Carotenoids have at least two states involved in energy transfer to BChl. These are the S2 state into which absorption from the ground state, S0, is strongly allowed, and a low-lying, S1 state into which absorption is forbidden by symmetry. These two states represent the primary energy donors for carotenoid-to-BChl energy transfer. The S2 state transfers energy with an efficiency between 30 and 70%, the value of which is only slightly dependent on the structure of the carotenoid. The S1-mediated energy transfer pathway depends strongly on the π-electron conjugation length of the carotenoid. This route is essentially closed for carotenoids with eleven or more conjugated carbon-carbon double bonds because in these cases the S1 energy of the carotenoid lies too low to enable transfer to BChl. *Author for correspondence, email: [email protected]
C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty (eds): The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria, pp. 213–230. © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V.
214
Harry Frank and Tomáš Polívka
Besides the main S2 and S1 pathways, the past few years of investigations have raised the prospect of other carotenoid excited states participating in energy transfer. The possibilities include vibrationally hot S1 states, a state denoted S* thought to be formed by a branched deactivation pathway from S2, and a state with symmetry representation 1Bu– predicted on the basis of theoretical computations to lie between S1 and S2. This chapter reviews the evidence for these states and discusses their possible involvement as energy donors in the process of light-harvesting in photosynthetic bacteria. I. Introduction Carotenoids in antenna complexes of purple bacteria have multiple functions. Besides their key roles in photoprotection and structure stabilization, purple bacteria utilize carotenoids as efficient LH agents covering the 400–550 nm spectral region. This part of the spectrum is of crucial importance, because it matches the maximum of the solar irradiance curve at the Earth’s surface, and it is where the main photosynthetic pigment of purple bacteria, BChl a, has very low absorption (Fig. 1). Purple bacterial antenna systems are ideal for studying carotenoids as LH pigments in photosynthetic pigment-protein complexes. This is because detailed structural knowledge exists and provides an ideal platform for experimental and theoretical investigations of mechanisms and pathways of energy transfer between carotenoids and BChl. To date, the structures of a few LH complexes have been reported. In 1995, the 2.5 Å structure of an outer antenna complex called LH2 from Rhodopseudomonas (Rps.) acidophila containing the carotenoid rhodopin glucoside (McDermott et al., 1995) became a landmark study of purple bacterial antenna complexes. A 2.4 Å structure of the LH2 complex from Rhodospirillum (Rsp.) molischianum containing lycopene followed shortly after (Koepke et al., 1996). Subsequently, the structure of the related complex LH3 (McLuskey et al., 2001) was reported, as well as the structure of the LH1 antenna complex surrounding the reaction center (Roszsak et al., 2003). These studies revealed the common theme of a ring-shaped protein motif containing either two (LH1) or three (LH2, LH3) BChl a molecules, and one carotenoid molecule per fundamental unit (Gall et al., 2006). The BChl a molecules in LH2 are arranged in two layers. One consists of two strongly coupled BChl a molecules absorbing at 850 nm (B850). The Abbreviations: BChl a – bacteriochlorophyll a; LDS – lithium dodecyl sulfate; CD – circular dichroism; LH – light harvesting; RC – reaction center
second is a monomeric BChl a absorbing at 800 nm (B800). For other complexes, the strongly-coupled BChl a absorb at different wavelengths, giving rise to a B875 band in LH1 or a B820 band in the LH3 complex. The monomeric BChl a molecule absorbs at 800 nm in all complexes except LH1 which lacks this BChl a completely. The carotenoids are in close contact with both types of BChl a molecules allowing them to serve as efficient energy donors in the light-harvesting process. The detailed knowledge about the arrangement of pigments in purple bacterial antenna complexes provided a structural basis for both experimental and theoretical studies of energy transfer between carotenoids and BChl a. The studies of carotenoid to BChl a energy transfer are also facilitated by the fact that many antenna complexes from purple bacteria accumulate only one major carotenoid. However, different species of purple bacteria utilize distinct ca-
Fig. 1. Absorption spectra of LH2 complexes from Rba. sphaeroides containing carotenoids with different conjugation lengths: neurosporene, N = 9 (solid); spheroidene, N = 10 (dotted); spheroidenone N = 10 + C=O (dashed). All spectra are normalized to the maximum of the B850 band.
Chapter 12
Carotenoid-to-BChl Energy Transfer
215
rotenoid types in their antenna complexes (Fig. 2). It was known long before X-ray structures were resolved that the structure of a particular carotenoid affects its ability to carry out energy transfer to BChl a. Using fluorescence excitation spectroscopy, carotenoid-toBChl energy transfer efficiencies of 80–100% have been reported for Rhodobacter (Rba.) sphaeroides containing spheroidene (Cogdell et al., 1981; van Grondelle et al., 1982; Angerhofer et al., 1995), while values between 35–70% have been obtained for Rps. acidophila containing rhodopin glucoside (Angerhofer et al., 1986, 1995; Chadwick et al., 1987). The carotenoid-BChl energy transfer yield drops to ~30% for LH1 of Rsp. rubrum containing spirilloxanthin (Rademaker et al., 1980). These values were later confirmed and/or refined by a variety of time-resolved spectroscopic techniques that enabled the pathways of energy transfer between carotenoids and BChl a to be followed. Despite the fact that this topic has been studied extensively for more than ten years, and summaries of the achievements obtained during this period can be found in specialized reviews (Frank and Cogdell, 1996; Ritz et al., 2000; Fraser et al., 2001; Polívka and Sundström, 2004), the details concerning the mechanisms, pathways, participating donor and acceptor states and the molecular factors controlling energy transfer are still a matter of considerable debate. This is mainly because the excited state properties of carotenoids in solution, which serve as models for interpreting the data obtained from carotenoid excited-state dynamics in purple bacterial antenna complexes, are still not sufficiently well known. Fig. 2. Structures of carotenoids commonly occurring in LH complexes of purple bacteria.
II. Carotenoid Excited States The LH function of carotenoids in the LH2 complex relies on their ability to transfer energy from the low-lying excited states to both Qx and Qy states of BChl a. Consequently, knowledge of the details of the carotenoid excited state manifold, including energies of the excited states and dynamics following the excitation is a necessary prerequisite to understanding carotenoid-BChl energy transfer in antenna complexes of purple bacteria. Much of our current understanding of mechanisms and pathways of carotenoid-BChl energy transfer stems from numerous experimental studies of carotenoids in solution. Until the late nineties much of the photophysics of carotenoids was interpreted in terms of the allowed
S2 state (1B+u in C2h symmetry) responsible for the strong absorption of carotenoids in the 400–550 nm region, and the symmetry-forbidden S1 state (2Ag–), which is located a few thousand reciprocal centimeters below the S2 state. Thus, in contrast to other naturally-occurring dyes, the lowest excited state is a dark state. A number of spectroscopic studies have demonstrated that after being promoted to the S2 state a carotenoid molecule will relax in less than 300 fs to the S1 state. The lifetime of the S1 state is determined by conjugation length of carotenoid and varies from 300 ps for short conjugated chains to ~1 ps for the longest (Polívka and Sundström, 2004). Recent reports, however, have suggested that a
216 few other states denoted as 1Bu– and 3Ag– (Furuichi et al., 2002) and predicted by calculations on polyenes (Tavan and Schulten, 1987), or S* and S‡ (Gradinaru et al., 2001; Papagiannakis et al., 2002; Larsen et al., 2003), and whose origin and properties remain to be firmly established, may be located either between or in proximity to the S1 and S2 states. All of these states represent potential donors in the process of carotenoid-BChl energy transfer in LH2 complexes. In addition, novel excited state properties were recently discovered for carotenoids containing a conjugated carbonyl group. Unlike other carotenoids their photophysics is strongly affected by the polarity of the environment. This behavior was attributed to a presence of another excited state having a charge transfer character (Frank et al., 2000; Zigmantas et al., 2004), and added to the complexity of the carotenoid excited state manifold. Because some carbonyl carotenoids, e.g., spheroidenone or okenone (Fig. 2), are constituents of purple bacterial antenna complexes and reaction centers, the charge transfer state may also be involved in energy transfer processes taking place in these organisms. A scheme showing the current view of the carotenoid excited state ordering together with possible energy transfer pathways to BChl is depicted in Fig. 3. A detailed description of carotenoid excited states in solution is beyond the scope of this chapter and can be found in specialized reviews (Frank et al., 2001; Hashimoto et al., 2004; Koyama et al., 2004; Polívka and Sundström, 2004). III. Energy Transfer in Light-Harvesting 2 Complexes The large complexity of carotenoid excited states described in the previous section was not revealed until the end of the last century. Thus prior suggestions regarding mechanisms and pathways of carotenoidBChl energy transfer in LH2 complexes involved only the S1 and S2 states. Moreover, because of the extremely fast deactivation of the S2 state, the S1 state was suggested to be the primary donor responsible for carotenoid-BChl energy transfer. The forbidden nature of transitions to and from the S1 state imply a negligible transition dipole moment of the S1 state and led to the suggestion that the Dexter electron exchange mechanism should be active in this process (Naqvi, 1980; van Grondelle, 1985; Cogdell and Frank, 1987). However, time-resolved experiments performed in the early nineties showed that following excitation of ca-
Harry Frank and Tomáš Polívka
Fig. 3. Scheme of energy levels of carotenoid and BChl in light harvesting complexes of purple bacteria. Wavy arrows denote intramolecular relaxation processes, while the dashed arrow represents the long-lived BChl a fluorescence. Solid arrows represent the dominating energy-transfer channels involving the S2 and S1 states. The dotted lines represent minor energy-transfer channels that usually contribute only fractionally to the total energy transfer: the pathway via higher vibrational levels of the S1 state, the pathway via the S* state and the Bu– pathway were proposed to be active for some LH2 complexes. See text for details.
rotenoids, the B850 Qy state was populated in less than 200 fs, indicating that, despite its very short lifetime, the S2 state participates as a donor in carotenoid-BChl energy transfer (Trautman et al., 1990; Shreve et al., 1991). This suggestion was supported by calculations carried out by Nagae et al. (1993) who showed that for the carotenoid neurosporene both the S1 and S2 states can efficiently participate in energy transfer. When LH2 structures at atomic resolution became available, a number of experimental and theoretical investigations of energy transfer mechanisms and pathways between carotenoids and BChls bolstered the initial proposal that both the S1 and S2 states are involved in energy transfer. It was also concluded that the precise pathways and directions of energy flow are governed mainly by the conjugation length of the carotenoid. In addition, new experimental approaches and improved methods of data analysis have revealed alternate pathways that may contribute substantially to the overall carotenoid-BChl energy transfer in LH complexes of purple bacteria. A. Energy Transfer via the S2 State Absorption spectra of carotenoids in LH2 complexes resemble those obtained for carotenoids in solution,
Chapter 12
Carotenoid-to-BChl Energy Transfer
except for a red shift of ~1000 cm–1 caused by interaction with the protein environment (Fig. 1). The vibrational sub-structure of the carotenoid S0-S2 spectra of LH2 complexes is usually very similar to that obtained in solution, although for some carotenoids the protein environment represents a confinement of the carotenoid structure, leading to a better resolution of vibrational bands of the spectra (Polívka et al., 2002; Georgakopolou et al., 2004). Early experimental data on energy transfer via the S2 state was obtained by fluorescence up-conversion (Ricci et al., 1996). S2 emission decays of spheroidene in LH2 complexes of Rba. sphaeroides yielded a time constant of 80 fs. Comparing this result with the markedly longer decays in solution (150–250 fs), it was concluded that energy transfer via the S2 state takes place with a time constant of 170 fs, which corresponded to an efficiency of 47%. Thus, these experiments clearly demonstrated that energy transfer via the S2 state can successfully compete with fast S2-S1 internal conversion. On the basis of spectral overlap, it was also concluded that energy transfer via the S2 state occurs to the Qx state of BChl a (Ricci et al., 1996). Similar results were reported for the LH3 complex from Rps. acidophila containing rhodopin glucoside, which has a longer conjugation length than spheroidene (Fig. 2). Analysis of up-conversion kinetics supported by calculations yielded an S2-Qx energy transfer rate of (120–150 fs)–1. Based on this, the S2-Qx channel was concluded to be the dominating one, accounting for 60% of the total energy transfer efficiency (Krueger et al., 1998). Later, a similar value was obtained when up-conversion experiments were carried out on the LH2 complex of Rps. acidophila (Macpherson et al., 2001). An observed 51% efficiency of S2-mediated energy transfer is close to that obtained for LH3, suggesting that small structural differences between LH2 and LH3 complexes have no effect on carotenoid-BChl energy transfer. Instead, energy transfer efficiency appears to be primarily determined by the structure of the carotenoid. The fast and efficient S2 energy transfer pathway was also observed by transient absorption measurements. Although the data obtained from this method are more complicated to analyze than the data obtained from fluorescence up-conversion, recently introduced advanced methods of global fitting data analysis (van Stokkum et al., 2004) allowed for reliable separation of signals originating from different excited states. Application of these methods to transient absorp-
217 tion data measured in a broad spectral range for the LH2 complex from Rps. acidophila determined the efficiency of the S2-mediated energy transfer to be 45–50%; the range is given by the model used for the global fitting of the transient absorption data (Papagiannakis et al., 2006a). Essentially the same value was obtained by Rondonuwu et al. (2004) who concluded that S2 state of rhodopin glucoside in LH2 from Rps. acidophila transfers energy to BChl a with 48% efficiency. A different method of data treatment using evolutionary target analysis determined the efficiency of the S2 pathway in the same system to be 42% (Wohlleben et al., 2003). Thus, for the LH2 complex of Rps. acidophila, independent experiments utilizing different types of data analysis gave values of S2-mediated energy transfer efficiency in the range of 42–51%. This mild discrepancy between different experiments points to an intrinsic problem in determining the S2mediated energy transfer efficiencies. The calculation of efficiency requires a precise knowledge of the rate constant for S2-S1 internal conversion in LH2. However, this depends on the environment, and it is thus impossible to determine an accurate value for the intrinsic (without energy transfer) lifetime of the S2 state in the protein environment. This problem, discussed in detail by Macpherson et al. (2001), puts a limitation on the precision with which the S2 energy transfer efficiency may be determined. Another limitation is the time resolution of the experiments. The measured S2 lifetimes of rhodopin glucoside in LH2 complexes are on the sub-100 fs time scale, which in most cases is faster than the limits of time resolution of the instrument. However, recent experiments employing 10 fs pulses to study carotenoid to BChl a energy transfer in the LH2 complex of Rps. acidophila yielded a value for the efficiency of the S2-mediated energy transfer of 49% (Polli et al., 2006), confirming the values obtained from earlier experiments. It is also worth noting that the 70 fs value of the S2 lifetime of rhodopin glucoside in LH2 was also obtained on the basis of modeling homogeneous linewidths of the absorption and CD bands (Georgakopolou et al., 2004), further supporting the results obtained from time-resolved experiments. Besides the LH2 complex from Rps. acidophila, Papagiannakis et al. (2002) studied S2-mediated energy transfer from spheroidene in the LH2 from Rba. sphaeroides and obtained an energy transfer efficiency of 57%, which is in good agreement with the up-conversion data obtained by Ricci et al. (1996).
218 Another system studied by transient absorption spectroscopy is the LH2 complex from Chromatium purpuratum which binds the carotenoid okenone (Fig. 2). The data obtained on this complex are more complicated to analyze, because the long conjugated chain of okenone (Fig. 2) shifts the 0-0 band of the S2 state so much to the red that it partially overlaps with the Qx band of BChl a (Andersson et al., 1996). Consequently, partial excitation of the Qx band makes the determination of energy transfer efficiency difficult. Moreover, okenone possesses a conjugated carbonyl group that makes the excited state properties sensitive to the polarity of environment (Frank et al., 2000b; Zigmantas et al., 2004). Andersson et al. (1996) reported the S2-mediated energy transfer time from okenone to be 50–100 fs, which taking into account the ~150 fs S2 lifetime of okenone in solution, gave energy transfer efficiencies over 50%. These experiments were recently repeated by Polli et al. (2006) with the significantly better time resolution of 10 fs. These authors compared the excited state dynamics of okenone in a few solvents and in LH2 and concluded that the protein environment is best mimicked by CS2. By comparing the S2 lifetimes of okenone in CS2 and in LH2 they obtained an energy transfer rate constant of (56 fs)–1 yielding a 65% efficiency of the S2 channel (Polli et al., 2006). An even higher efficiency of 70% for the S2-mediated energy transfer was reported by Zhang et al. (2001) for the LH2 complex from Rba. sphaeroides G1C which contains neurosporene (conjugation length N=9). Comparing the results on LH2 complexes containing carotenoids with N=9-13, there is a trend to higher efficiency of S2 energy transfer for shorter carotenoids. This trend is supported by experiments on LH2 of the carotenoidless mutant Rba. sphaeroides R26.1 incorporated with spheroidene analogs of different conjugation lengths (Desamero et al., 1998). Using S2-S1 internal conversion rates measured in solution, overall carotenoid-BChl energy transfer efficiencies, and S1-mediated energy transfer efficiencies, the efficiencies of S2 energy transfer were calculated. Although the LH2s with spheroidene analogs having N=8,9 were observed to have slightly less efficient S2 energy transfer than LH2 with spheroidene (N=10), the systematic decrease of S2 efficiency from 50% (spheroidene) to 12% for the analog having N=13, supported the observed trend of decreasing S2-mediated energy transfer efficiency with increasing conjugation length (Desamero et al., 1998). On the other hand, essentially no change in
Harry Frank and Tomáš Polívka the efficiency of the S2 channel was found by Rondonuwu et al. (2004), who explored a series of LH2 complexes possessing different carotenoids. For the S2-mediated energy transfer, no dependence on carotenoid structure and conjugation length was found. A narrow 46–48% range of values was determined for neurosporene (N=9) and spheroidene (N=10) in LH2 from Rba. sphaeroides, lycopene (N=11) in LH2 from Rsp. molischianum, and rhodopin glucoside (N=11) in LH2 from Rps. acidophila (Koyama et al., 2004; Rondonuwu et al., 2004). For neurosporene and spheroidene these values are significantly lower than those obtained in other experiments (Zhang et al., 2001; Papagiannakis et al., 2002), which is likely caused by additional decay channels included in the analysis performed by Rondonuwu et al. (2004) who assumed other carotenoid excited states act as energy donors in addition to the S2 state. These potential additional energy transfer channels are discussed below. Although the precise values of the S2 transfer efficiencies are still a matter of debate, mainly because of possible involvement of other states, it is clear that the S2 energy transfer route operates with efficiencies in the range 30–70% in all purple bacterial antenna complexes studied so far. Thus, the S2 channel successfully competes with S2-S1 internal conversion for a number of LH2 complexes. This competition of S2 energy transfer with the S2-S1 internal conversion has been rationalized theoretically. The contribution of the electron-exchange Dexter energy transfer mechanism to the S2 energy transfer pathway has been computed to be negligible with the Förster-type mechanism dominating (Nagae et al., 1993; Krueger et al., 1998; Damjanovic et al., 1999). Even without detailed structural information, Nagae et al. (1993) calculated the Coulombic couplings between the S0-S2 transition of neurosporene and the Qx transition of BChl a for a few hypothetical configurations. They concluded that S2 energy transfer can be faster than 100 fs, if the proper orientation of donor and acceptor is realized (Nagae et al., 1993). Determination of the LH2 structure provided detailed information about the mutual orientation of pigments within LH2, allowing more precise calculations of couplings between carotenoids and BChl a. Krueger et al., applied an advanced method, the so-called transition density cube method, to calculate full Coulombic couplings between pigments in both LH3 (Krueger et al., 1998a) and LH2 (Krueger et al., 1998b) complexes from Rps. acidophila. This method replaces the vector
Chapter 12
Carotenoid-to-BChl Energy Transfer
description of the transition dipole moments by threedimensional transition density volumes, and gives a more accurate account of the interaction between molecules (Krueger et al., 1998b). The couplings of the S0-S2 transition of rhodopin glucoside with all possible transitions of neighboring BChl a were calculated for the LH3 complex, yielding values larger than 100 cm–1 for β-B820 Qx, B800 Qy and also for the B800 Qy transition of BChl a located in the neighboring building unit. However, due to the small value of the spectral overlap integral for the Qy states, only the S2-B820 Qx yielded an appreciable energy transfer rate constant of (240 fs)–1 (Krueger et al., 1998a). Similar results were obtained for the LH2 complex. Although the actual couplings were slightly different from those calculated for the LH3 complex, the S2-B850 Qx channel again represented the dominant route with an energy transfer rate constant of (135 fs)–1 (Krueger et al., 1998b). The results of these calculations are in very good agreement with the observed depopulation rates of the S2 state, but predict no S2 transfer to the B800 BChl a molecule which contradicts experimental observation (Macpherson et al., 2001). On the other hand, similar calculations using full Coulombic couplings performed on the basis of the LH2 structure of Rsp. molischianum containing the carotenoid lycopene, yielded appreciable couplings of the S0-S2 transition with both the B850 and B800 BChls, resulting in comparable S2 energy transfer rate constants of ~(200 fs)–1 for both B850 and B800 acceptors (Damjanovic et al., 1999). A similar result was obtained by calculations of the lycopene-BChl couplings in LH2 by means of the collective electronic oscillators algorithm (Tretiak et al., 2000). It is interesting to note that these calculations also proposed strong coupling between the Bx (Soret) band of both B800 and B850 BChls and the S2 state of lycopene, indicating a possibility of efficient energy transfer from BChl a Soret to lycopene (Tretiak et al., 2000), but no experimental evidence for such transfer has been given so far. Also, calculations of couplings were carried out for either isolated molecules in LH2 complexes or in a dielectric medium simulating the mean field created by the protein environment. The effect of the dielectric medium on couplings involving the S2 state were quite significant, underlining the importance of protein effects (Tretiak et al., 2000). An interesting aspect of the carotenoid-BChl energy transfer in LH2 is the fact that by proper shaping of excitation pulses it is possible to control
219 the ratio between S2-S1 internal conversion and energy transfer. However, as was shown for rhodopin glucoside in LH2 from Rps. acidophila, only a decrease in energy transfer efficiency can be achieved. Herek et al. (2002) showed that the S2 population of rhodopin glucoside can be steered to the S2-S1 channel, as demonstrated by increase of the signal due to the S1 state by a factor 1.4. In the coherent control experiments carried out by Herek et al. (2002) the increase in proportion of S2-S1 internal conversion was achieved by optimizing the envelope and phase of the excitation pulses (Herek et al., 2002; Wohlleben et al., 2005). Recently, Papagiannakis et al. (2006a) showed that also incoherent effects, such as annihilation and saturation can lead to similar control of the S2-S1/S2-BChl ratio, demonstrating that the actual value of S2 energy transfer efficiency depends also on the intensity of excitation pulses. B. Energy Transfer via the S1 State Despite the forbidden nature of the S1 state, energy transfer via the S1 route is straightforward to study by means of transient absorption spectroscopy because of the strong S1-Sn band readily observed in the visible spectral region (Polívka and Sundström, 2004). The position and shape of this band is characteristic of each carotenoid (Fig. 4) and the dynamics of this band can be used to determine the S1 lifetimes of carotenoids in various environments. Thus, comparison of S1 lifetimes in solution and in antenna complexes allows for determining energy transfer efficiencies via the S1 state. To study the effect of conjugation length on energy transfer in LH2 complexes, this method was applied to the Rba. sphaeroides R26.1 mutant with incorporated spheroidene analogs of different conjugation lengths (Desamero et al., 1998). Although for conjugation lengths N≥11 the S1 energy transfer was undetectable, quenching of the S1 state due to energy transfer was observed for shorter carotenoids. This result was explained in terms of spectral overlap between hypothetical S1 fluorescence and the B850 absorption band, which becomes small for longer carotenoids. A similar study was carried out by Zhang et al. (2000) using three LH2 complexes with different carotenoids. On the basis of measured S1 lifetimes of neurosporene (N=9), spheroidene (N=10) and lycopene (N=11) in solution and LH2, a significant decrease of S1 energy transfer efficiency was observed; it dropped from 94% (neurosporene) to 82 % (spheroidene) and further to
220
Harry Frank and Tomáš Polívka
Fig. 4. Transient absorption spectra in the S1-Sn region measured 1 ps after excitation into the lowest vibrational band of the carotenoid S2 state for LH2 complexes from Rba. sphaeroides with neurosporene (Neu), spheroidene (Sph) and spheroidenone (Spn). All spectra are normalized to the S1-Sn maximum.
less than 30 % (lycopene), as the conjugation length increased from 9 to 11. The significant drop in energy transfer via the S1 state was also confirmed for spheroidene and rhodopin glucoside in LH2 complexes from Rba. sphaeroides and Rps. acidophila by means of measurements of S1-Sn kinetics either after two-photon excitation of the S1 state (Walla et al., 2000) or after one-photon excitation of the S2 state (Polívka et al., 2002). These authors confirmed the ~1.7 ps S1 lifetime of spheroidene in LH2 indicating energy transfer. For rhodopin glucoside, however, no change in S1 lifetime was observed upon going from solvent to LH2, demonstrating that in this complex the S1 state does not transfer energy (Fig. 5). A few other studies confirmed this trend and established that LH2 complexes utilizing carotenoids with N≥11 are incapable of energy transfer via the S1-route as its efficiency does not exceed 5% (Macpherson et al., 2001; Wohlleben et al., 2003; Koyama et al., 2004; Rondonuwu et al., 2004; Polli et al., 2006). The importance of the carotenoid structure was shown in a study of a Rba. sphaeroides mutant incorporating the longer (N=11) lycopene instead of spheroidene (N=10) naturally present in wild type LH2. When lycopene is present in the complex, the efficiency of S1-mediated energy transfer drops to a few percent, while more than 80% is achieved when spheroidene is present in the wild
Fig. 5. Kinetics recorded at the maximum of the S1-Sn transition after excitation of the 0-0 band of the S0-S2 transition of the carotenoids. The S1 decays of the carotenoids in solution (open symbols) and in the LH2 complex (full symbols) are compared for the LH2 complexes from Rba. sphaeroides (a) and Rps. acidophila (b). The corresponding fits of the kinetics are represented by solid lines. Excitation wavelengths are 515 nm (Rba. sphaeroides) and 525 nm (Rps. acidophila).
type (Billsten et al., 2002a). Further evidence that carotenoids with N=11 are on the edge of capability to transfer energy via the S1 state was provided by studies of LH2 complexes from Rba. sphaeroides R26.1 reconstituted with spirilloxanthin (N=13) (Papagiannakis et al., 2003a) or LH2 complexes from Chromatium purpuratum containing okenone (N~12) (Polli et al., 2006). These studies showed that no (or very little) S1-mediated energy transfer is achieved by these long carotenoids as essentially no S1-mediated energy transfer was observed for spirilloxanthin, and an upper limit of 6% was found for okenone. The obvious relation between the conjugation length and efficiency of the S1-mediated energy transfer can be explained by a decrease of the S1 energy with increasing conjugation length. To achieve efficient energy transfer the S1 energies of carotenoids must be higher than those of the acceptor states.
Chapter 12
Carotenoid-to-BChl Energy Transfer
While the determination of the energy is a trivial task for the S2 state, the forbidden nature of the S1 state prevents a direct measurement of the S1 energy. In the late nineties a few papers appeared describing different methods for determining S1 energies of carotenoids: 1) measurement of the extremely-weak S1 emission (Fujii et al., 1998); 2) measurements of resonance Raman profiles (Sashima et al., 1998); 3) time-resolved measurements of the S1-S2 spectra (Polívka et al., 1999); and 4) two-photon absorption (Krueger et al., 1999). Detection of S1 fluorescence and measurements of resonance Raman profiles, however, could not provide unambiguous information about S1 energies in LH2 and related LH systems. However, since it was known that S1 energies are usually insensitive to solvent properties (except for carbonyl carotenoids that are not typical for purple bacterial LH complexes; Polívka and Sundström, 2004), it was reasonable to assume that the S1 energies in LH2 complexes should be very close to those determined for carotenoids in solution. Under this assumption, S1 energies of carotenoids with N≤10 were calculated to be high enough to allow sufficient overlap between carotenoid S1 emission and Qy bands of BChl a. This conclusion was later verified by direct measurements of the S1 energies of neurosporene, spheroidene and rhodopin glucoside in LH2 complexes by recording the S1-S2 spectra. S1 energies of 14500 cm–1, 13400 cm–1, and 12550 cm–1 were determined for neurosporene, spheroidene, and rhodopin glucoside, respectively (Polívka et al., 2002, 2004), showing that the difference of 850 cm–1 between S1 energies of spheroidene and rhodopin glucoside makes a significant change in the energy transfer pathways in LH2 complexes. These experiments also justified the approximation of S1 energies in LH2 complexes using energies obtained in solution. In the case of spheroidene, the S1 energy extracted from the S1-S2 spectra is the same as that determined by this method in solution (Polívka et al., 2001). For rhodopin glucoside the S1 energy is 250 cm–1 lower than that in solution. This difference was explained by confinement of rhodopin glucoside in the LH2 structure, which narrows the distribution of conformers compared to that in solution. This was also supported by modeling CD and absorption spectra of carotenoids in LH2 complexes (Georgakopoulou et al., 2004). Another direct measurement of S1 energies in the LH2 complex from Rba. sphaeroides was carried out by means of two-photon fluorescence excitation
221 (Krueger et al., 1999). Using this technique the S1 state can be excited directly because the S0-S1 transition is allowed for a two-photon transition. By measuring B850 emission after two-photon excitation of the S1 state achieved by exciting in the 1200–1500 nm spectral range, the two-photon excitation spectrum placed the 0-0 energy of spheroidene in LH2 at 13900 cm–1, confirming the similarity of the S1 energies in LH2 and in solution. Together with measurements of S1 energies, calculations of the couplings between the S0-S1 transition and Qy transitions of both B800 and B850 demonstrated that the S1 transfer rates can be explained in terms of the same energy transfer mechanism as for the S2 route. Although the very small transition dipole moment of the S0-S1 transition led initially to a suggestion that the Dexter mechanism had to be invoked (Naqvi, 1980; van Grondelle, 1985; Cogdell, 1987), more detailed calculations later showed that the Dexter contribution is negligible and that higher-order Coulombic and polarization interactions dominate the S1-mediated energy transfer (Nagae et al., 1993; Scholes et al., 1997; Krueger et al., 1998; Damjanovic et al., 1999; Tretiak et al., 2000). In some studies (Damjanovic et al., 1999; Zhang et al., 2000), the Coulombic couplings for the S1 state were obtained by scaling down the couplings calculated for the S2 state and using an estimate that the transition dipole moment of the S0-S1 transition is about 4–6% of the S0-S2 transition. Although the results of this approach were promising, the calculated rates did not reproduce the measured energy transfer rates. To resolve this problem, an increase of S0-S1 Coulombic coupling via intensity borrowing from the allowed S2 state due to S2-S1 mixing was proposed (Damjanovic et al., 1999; Zhang et al., 2000). Under the assumption that the degree of mixing is inversely proportional to the square of the S1-S2 energy gap, Zhang et al. (2000) calculated S1 energy transfer rates for LH2 from Rsp. molischianum that were reasonably close to the measured values. Further improvement of the agreement between experiment and theory was obtained by calculations of Coulombic couplings by means of time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) (Walla et al., 2000; Hsu et al., 2001). This method, which allows ab initio calculations of the S1 couplings with Qy states of BChl, confirmed that small mixing between S2 and S1 states plays an important role in the Coulombic coupling. S1 energy transfer rates for LH2 complexes from three different species of purple bacteria were
222 calculated using the Coulombic couplings obtained from TDDFT, and the obtained values (9 ps)–1 (Rsp. molischianum), (1.2 ps)–1 (Rba. sphaeroides) and (3 ps)–1 (Rba. sphaeroides G1C) (Hsu et al., 2001) are very close to the experimental ones of (12 ps)–1, (2.4 ps)–1 and (1.4 ps)–1 (Zhang et al., 2001). For LH2 from Rps. acidophila, an S1 energy transfer time >25 ps was calculated (Hsu et al., 2001), also in agreement with the very low efficiency obtained experimentally (Macpherson, 2001; Polívka et al., 2002; Wohlleben, 2003). Although the trend of decreasing efficiency of the S1-mediated energy transfer was confirmed by experiments using LH2 complexes from Rba. sphaeroides having the different carotenoids, neurosporene, spheroidene, and spheroidenone, the drop in efficiency when going from spheroidene to spheroidenone was less than expected on the basis of a change in spectral overlap. The S1 lifetimes of carotenoids in LH2 complexes of 1.4, 1.5 and 1.4 ps for neurosporene, spheroidene, and spheroidenone were compared with their lifetimes in solution (24, 8.5 and 6 ps), resulting in energy transfer efficiencies of 94, 82 and 76% (Polívka et al., 2004). Knowing that the S1 energy of spheroidenone is around 13000 cm–1 (Zigmantas et al., 2004), the efficiency of energy transfer from spheroidenone does not match that expected from calculations by Hsu et al. (2001). Also, comparison of 76% with the nearly zero efficiency of the S1-mediated energy transfer obtained for rhodopin glucoside that has a LH2 S1 energy of 12550 ± 150 cm–1 (Polívka et al., 2002) would imply that ~500 cm–1 decrease in energy is enough to decrease efficiency from 76 to 5%. Taking into account that S1 emission of carotenoids is quite broad (Fujii et al., 1998; Frank et al., 2000a), such a drop can be hardly explained as due solely to change in the spectral overlap (Ritz et al., 2000). Thus, it indicates that other factors besides conjugation length may play a role. One possibility is that the high efficiency of the S1mediated energy transfer of spheroidenone is related to the fact that it belongs to the family of carbonyl carotenoids, which possess an excited state with chargetransfer character (Frank et al., 2000b; Zigmantas et al., 2004) that may enhance the spheroidenone-BChl coupling. Another explanation was offered by Ritz et al. (2000) who noted that the conjugated systems of neurosporene and spheroidene, which systematically exhibit highly-efficient energy transfer via the S1 state, have a non C2h-symmetrical arrangement of their methyl side groups. This is, however, not
Harry Frank and Tomáš Polívka the case for lycopene and rhodopin glucoside, both exhibiting very low efficiencies of the S1-mediated energy transfer. Consequently, Ritz et al. (2000) suggested that symmetry breaking of neurosporene and spheroidene may be an important factor in explaining why energy transfer via the S1 state is much more efficient for these carotenoids compared to lycopene and rhodopin glucoside. Since the conjugated system of spheroidenone has also asymmetric arrangement of methyl groups (Fig. 2), the observation of efficient S1-mediated energy transfer, despite its low S1 energy, provides further support for the conjecture proposed by Ritz et al. (2000). In addition to the S1-mediated energy transfer occurring from a thermalized S1 state discussed above, it has been proposed that a portion of the pathway may involve a vibrationally hot S1 state. Using global analysis, Papagiannakis et al. (2002) reported the decay of a species associated spectrum corresponding to the vibrationally hot S1 state, suggesting the presence of an energy transfer channel via this route. However, the contribution of this pathway to the total energy transfer efficiency was only 5%. Indirect evidence for the presence of this channel also could be found in experiments carried out by Krueger et al. (1999) who measured the spectral profile of the S0-S1 transition in the LH2 complex by two-photon excitation techniques that detect emission from BChl a. The 0-0 band of the S0-S1 transition was very weak but the intensity of higher vibrational bands was high which may be due to energy transfer occurring from the hot vibrational states. In any case, this energy transfer channel plays only a minor role in the overall carotenoid-BChl energy transfer in LH2. An upper limit of 3% was found in the LH2 complex from Rps. acidophila for this channel (Wohlleben et al., 2003). Moreover, as no evidence for energy transfer via a hot S1 state was provided by a number of other experiments using various LH2 complexes (Papagiannakis et al., 2003a; Koyama et al., 2004; Rondonuwu et al., 2004; Polli et al., 2006), further experiments using both advanced experimental approaches and sophisticated data analysis will be needed to verify the presence of this energy transfer channel. C. The S* State Reports of other carotenoid excited states located between the S2 and S1 states (see Polívka and Sundström, 2004, for a review) initiated lively debates regarding whether these states act as energy donors
Chapter 12
Carotenoid-to-BChl Energy Transfer
in carotenoid-BChl energy transfer. New ways of data analysis allowed for a more rigorous assignment of various excited state species (van Stokkum et al., 2004), and it was shown in a number of cases that the two-state (S2 and S1) model is not sufficient to describe all features revealed in experimental data. The so-called S* state is the best studied in this respect; it was first reported in the excited state manifold of the carotenoid spirilloxanthin in both solution and the LH1 complex of Rsp. rubrum (Gradinaru et al., 2001). Using global analysis of data in the 470–720 nm spectral region, it was shown that the S1-Sn band of spirilloxanthin in solution (peaking at 590 nm) possessed a distinct shoulder at ~540 nm. While the 590 nm band decayed with 1.4 ps corresponding to the S1 lifetime of spirilloxanthin, the 540 nm shoulder exhibited a much longer decay time of ~6 ps (Gradinaru et al., 2001). This result was explained in terms of two parallel pathways of S2 depopulation; a major part (70%) decaying to form the S1 state, while a minor pathway (30%) leads to population of the S* state which then decays to the ground state with a 6 ps lifetime. Interestingly, as shown in subsequent studies (Papagiannakis et al., 2002; Papagiannakis et al., 2003a; Wohlleben et al., 2003), the S* state is formed with much higher yield when carotenoids are incorporated into purple bacterial LH complexes. Moreover, in LH1 and LH2 complexes the S* state was found to be a precursor of fast carotenoid triplet state formation. A relatively high triplet yield of 25–30% was explained to be a result of a conformational distortion of spirilloxanthin in the LH1 complex, promoting triplet formation via singlet homofission from the S* state (Gradinaru et al., 2001). Further studies confirmed the triplet state formation via the S* state for other complexes containing different carotenoids. The yields of triplet formation varied from nearly 40% for rhodopin glucoside in LH2 from Rps. acidophila (Wohlleben et al., 2003) to less than 10% for spheroidene in both native LH2 from Rba. sphaeroides (Papagiannakis et al., 2002) and incorporated into the Rb. sphaeroides R26.1 mutant (Papagiannakis et al., 2003a). The fact that no triplet formation is observed in solution suggests that the protein environment is a crucial factor governing the formation of the triplet via singlet homofission, and it strongly supports the conclusion that the deviation from planar conformation in antenna complexes of purple bacteria is a necessary condition for efficient triplet formation (Papagiannakis et al., 2003a).
223 However, it turns out that the decay to the S0 state and triplet formation are not the only possible fates of the S* state in LH2 complexes. In LH2 complexes containing either spheroidene or rhodopin glucoside, the S* state also contributes to carotenoid-BChl energy transfer. For spheroidene in the LH2 of Rba. sphaeroides, S*-mediated energy transfer contributes 10–15% to the total spheroidene-BChl energy transfer (Papagiannakis et al., 2002). For rhodopin glucoside in Rps. acidophila LH2, the S*-mediated channel was found to be ~10% efficient; i.e., even higher than the energy transfer efficiency from the S1 state (Wohlleben et al., 2003). The possibility of carotenoid-BChl energy transfer via the S* state provided important information for determining the origin of the S* state, which is still a matter of debate. The presence of the S*-mediated energy transfer puts the S* energy above the Qy bands of BChl a, eliminating one of the proposed origins, a vibrationally hot ground state (Wohlleben et al., 2004). Instead, it seems that S* is indeed a separate excited state as originally suggested by Gradinaru et al. (2001), but its symmetry and relation to other states remains unknown. It also must be noted that although only a few carotenoids were subject to studies focusing on the S* state so far, it seems obvious that the lifetime of the S* state does not follow any clear dependence on conjugation length. While the S1 lifetime is changed systematically from ~9 ps (spheroidene) to 4.1 ps (rhodopin glucoside) and 1.5 ps (spirilloxanthin) as a result of increased conjugation length from 10 to 13 (Polívka and Sundström, 2004), the intrinsic S* lifetimes (in the absence of energy transfer) in LH2 and LH1 complexes are scattered in the 6 to 30 ps range without any obvious relation to the conjugation length (Gradinaru et al., 2001; Papagiannakis et al., 2002, 2003a, 2006a; Wohlleben et al., 2003). The lack of correlation between lifetime and conjugation length also casts doubts on assignment of the S* state to the 1Bu– state proposed by some authors (Papagiannakis et al., 2002; Wohlleben et al., 2003). A recent thorough study of the S* state in LH2 complexes from Rps. acidophila and Rba. sphaeroides revealed another aspect of the spectroscopic properties of the S* state in LH2 complexes. Population of the S* state exhibits a dependence on intensity of excitation pulses that differs from that observed for the S1 state (Papagiannakis et al., 2006a), indicating that the S* and S1 state cannot have a common precursor, the S2 state, as previously thought. These authors proposed
224 two models to explain their data. One assumes two different ground-state populations each leading to population of either S1 or S* state, the other involves higher excited states. These upper excited states are populated via excited state absorption from the S2 state that is resonant with the excitation pulse, thus the S2 population created by the front of the excitation pulse can be re-excited into higher excited states by photons arriving in the tail of the pulse. These higher excited states exhibit a relaxation pattern that favors population of the S* state. Because increasing excitation intensity increases the probability of the re-excitation, the S* state gets more populated with higher excitation intensities (Papagiannakis et al., 2006a). This model involving higher excited states has gained support from another study showing that direct excitation of high-lying excited states enhances population of the S* state (Billsten et al., 2005). These authors also suggested that the S* state in solution may be related to a conformational change of the carotenoid molecule. This possibility was later supported by a study on a series of carotenoids with different structures, indicating that the S* state may be a minimum in the S1 potential surface corresponding to a conformational change (Niedzwiedzki et al., 2006). This conclusion also explains why the S* state is preferentially populated in LH2 complexes where such distortions have been confirmed by X-ray crystallography. D. Other Pathways Another excited state widely discussed as a potential energy donor in carotenoid-BChl energy transfer in LH2 complexes is the 1Bu– state. Its presence in the excited state manifold was predicted two decades ago by calculations on polyenes carried out by Tavan and Schulten (1987), and it was shown that for conjugation lengths corresponding to naturally-occurring carotenoids (N = 9-13) it may be located below the strongly absorbing S2 state. Due to the forbidden nature of the 1Bu– state (it is forbidden for both oneand two-photon transitions from the ground state), experimental verification of the presence of the 1Bu– state between the S2 and S1 states is very difficult. In the late nineties Sashima et al. (1999) detected this state using measurements of resonance Raman profiles. Later, the 1Bu– state was also proposed to be active in energy transfer between carotenoids and BChl in LH2 complexes (Rondonuwu et al., 2004; Koyama et al., 2004). Based on previous assignments
Harry Frank and Tomáš Polívka of spectral signatures thought to be associated with the 1Bu– state in transient absorption spectra recorded in the near-infrared and visible ranges (Koyama et al., 2004), Rondonuwu et al. (2004) used global analysis of data taken on a few LH2 complexes containing different carotenoids and concluded that the 1Bu– state transfers energy to BChl with ~20% efficiency. This corresponds to an energy transfer time of ~0.6 ps for neurosporene and spheroidene in the LH2 complexes from Rba. sphaeroides. This pathway was proposed to be inactive for LH2 complexes accommodating the longer carotenoids lycopene and rhodopin glucoside. The absence of this channel in these complexes was explained by the 1Bu– state lying below the Qx state of BChl a, which was assumed to be the energy acceptor. For these carotenoids, however, it was hypothesized that another dark excited state, the 3Ag– state, may be active in carotenoid-BChl energy transfer because the expected 3Ag– energies may be favorable for this state to act as an energy donor. However, no experimental evidence for such a pathway was given (Rondonuwu et al., 2004). It must be noted that both 1Bu– lifetimes and spectral signatures in the visible region obtained by Rondonuwu et al. (2003) are essentially identical to those assigned earlier to the hot S1 state (Billsten et al., 2002b; de Weerd et al., 2002). Consequently, the data by Rondonuwu et al. (2004) may also be interpreted in terms of the hot S1 state being the energy donor instead of the 1Bu– state. Another issue that awaits further clarification is the relationship between the 1Bu– and S* states. It has been proposed that the 1Bu– state is identical with the S* state (Papagiannakis et al., 2002, Wohlleben et al., 2003; Rondonuwu et al., 2003). This assignment may seem correct as the symmetry and origin of the S* state are still unknown, and the 1Bu– state was predicted to be a precursor of ultrafast triplet formation (Rondonuwu et al., 2004; Koyama et al., 2004), the same process reported for the S* state (Gradinaru et al., 2001; Papagiannakis et al., 2002). On the other hand, for the S* state it was shown that there is no S1 ↔ S* conversion (Gradinaru et al., 2001; Papagiannakis et al., 2002; Wohlleben et al., 2003), which is in contradiction with the 1Bu– state being an intermediate state in S2-S1 internal conversion (Koyama et al., 2004). Similarly, the 1Bu– lifetimes (see Koyama et al., 2004, for a review) are about an order of magnitude shorter than those measured for the S* state, which argues that the 1Bu– and S* states are not equivalent.
Chapter 12
Carotenoid-to-BChl Energy Transfer
E. The Role of B800 For the LH2 and LH3 complexes, B850 (B820 in LH3) and B800 BChl a molecules may be acceptors in carotenoid-BChl energy transfer. The question of partitioning between these two possible acceptors has been addressed in a few studies. Macpherson et al. (2001) investigated S2-mediated energy transfer by fluorescence up-conversion in B800-B850 and B850only LH2 complexes from Rps. acidophila. Upon combining the results for these two LH2 complexes, they concluded that the S2 state of rhodopin glucoside transfers energy with 20% efficiency to B800 and with 31% efficiency to B850, leading to the total efficiency of 51% (Macpherson et al., 2001). Similar analysis was carried out by Papagiannakis et al. (2003a) who used transient absorption spectroscopy to study LH2 from a carotenoidless Rba. sphaeroides R26.1 mutant lacking the B800 BChl but incorporated with spheroidene. It was reported that the S2 pathway operates with 25% efficiency, which, when compared with the 57% efficiency of this pathway known for the wild type B800-B850 complex, allowed them to conclude that approximately half of the S2 population transfers energy to B800 (Papagiannakis et al., 2003a). It should be noted that although this work clearly showed that B800 accepts up to 50% of energy from the S2 state, calculations based on the X-ray structure of the LH2 complex from Rps. acidophila gave appreciable couplings only for the S2-B850 Qx channel (Krueger et al., 1998). On the other hand, similar calculations using full Coulombic couplings performed on the basis of the LH2 structure of Rsp. molischianum, yielded appreciable couplings of the S0-S2 transition with both the B850 and B800 BChls, resulting in close to a 1:1 branching ratio between the B800 and B850 acceptors (Damjanovic et al., 1999). Essentially the same results were obtained by calculations of the lycopene-BChl couplings by means of the collective electronic oscillators algorithm (Tretiak et al., 2000). Regarding energy acceptors in the S1-mediated energy transfer route, both B800 and B850 BChls are capable of accepting energy from carotenoids, but the S1-B800 channel seems to dominate. In experiments employing samples having spheroidene incorporated into LH2 from the carotenoidless Rba. sphaeroides R26.1 mutant lacking B800 BChl, the efficiency of energy transfer via the S1 pathway reached only 35% (Papagiannakis et al., 2003a). This is significantly less than the ~80% observed for the LH2 containing both
225 B800 and B850 (Walla et al., 2000; Zhang et al., 2000; Polívka et al., 2002), signaling that the main pathway involves B800 as an acceptor. The same conclusion was reached for LH2 from Rps. acidophila. Although the S1 efficiency is only 4–5% in the wild type complex, selective removal of the B800 BChls led to a complete absence of S1 energy transfer (Macpherson et al., 2001). Polívka et al. (2007) used lithium dodecyl sulfate (LDS) which selectively perturbs the B800 site (Chadwick et al., 1987). The LDS-treated complexes lack the B800 band and can be therefore used to investigate the role of B800 in energy transfer (Fig. 6). By measuring the S1 lifetimes of neurosporene, spheroidene and spheroidenone in LDS-treated LH2 complexes and comparing them with data taken on untreated complexes (Fig. 6), Polívka et al. (2007) showed that the carotenoid S1 lifetime has values in the range 1.4–1.8 ps for the untreated LH2 complexes, but it is prolonged to 2.7–3.5 ps for LDS-treated complexes. This is consistent with slower energy transfer via the S1 state. The S1 state branching ratios for energy transfer to the B850 and B800 BChls were calculated using the S1 lifetimes of the carotenoids in solution and in untreated and LDS-treated LH2 complexes. The calculations showed that the B800: B850 branching ratio remained essentially the same regardless of the conjugation length of the carotenoid. The values were 65:35 for LH2 with spheroidene and 60:40 for the complexes containing neurosporene
Fig. 6. Kinetics recorded at the maximum of the S1-Sn band for LH2 complexes from Rba. sphaeroides containing spheroidene. Kinetics are shown for spheroidene in solution (open triangles), LDS-treated LH2 complexes (open circles) and untreated LH2 complexes (full squares). The LH2 complexes were excited in the 0-0 band of the carotenoid S2 state at 515 nm. All kinetics are normalized to maximum. Solid lines represent fits.
226 or spheroidenone. This confirmed further that the B800 BChl a represents the dominant acceptor in carotenoid-BChl energy transfer via the S1 state. Interestingly, the B800:B850 branching ratio was not affected by conjugation length, indicating that even for spheroidenone having an S1 energy of ~13000 cm–1, the S1-B800 pathway remains dominant. The significance of the B800 BChl a molecule is further underlined by reports that it is likely the only acceptor in the minor energy transfer routes via the hot S1 state or the S* state (Papagiannakis et al., 2003a). IV. Energy Transfer in Light-Harvesting 1 Complexes and Reaction Centers Carotenoid-BChl energy transfer in LH1 complexes has been much less studied, and most of our current knowledge is limited to information provided by time-resolved studies of the LH1 complex from Rsp. rubrum. First experiments, however, were carried out by Ricci et al. (1996) who demonstrated efficient energy transfer via the S2 state of spheroidene in the LH1 complex from Rba. sphaeroides. Based on the comparison between fluorescence up-conversion data on spheroidene in solution and in LH1 they concluded that S2-mediated energy transfer operates with 65% efficiency (energy transfer time of 90 fs), which is even more efficient than for the spheroidenecontaining LH2 complex (Ricci et al., 1996). Later experiments on LH1 complexes from Rsp. rubrum containing the long (N=13) carotenoid, spirilloxanthin, revealed only 35% efficient S2-mediated energy transfer (Gradinaru et al., 2001). Moreover, it was shown that no energy transfer proceeds via the S1 state of spirilloxanthin. Thus, 35% is the total efficiency of the spirilloxanthin-BChl energy transfer, in agreement with earlier results based on measurements of fluorescence excitation spectra (Rademaker et al., 1980). The absence of the S1-mediated energy transfer pathway for spirilloxanthin likely results from its very long conjugated system which pushes its S1 energy too low to transfer energy to BChl a. Measurements of the S1-S2 spectra of spirilloxanthin in the LH1 complex determined the S1 energy of the carotenoid to be 11500 cm–1, which is below the energy of both B800 and B850 Qy transitions (Papagiannakis et al., 2003b). An investigation of LH1 complexes reconstituted with carotenoids with conjugation lengths in the range 9–13 showed that carotenoid-BChl energy transfer
Harry Frank and Tomáš Polívka in LH1 obeys the same trend as shown earlier for LH2. The overall carotenoid-BChl energy transfer decreases with increasing conjugation length, dropping from 78% for LH1 with neurosporene (N=9) to 36% for the spirilloxanthin-containing LH1 complex (Akahane et al., 2004). These are slightly less than values obtained for LH2. These authors found efficiencies for the S1-mediated energy transfer of 20 and 19% for LH1 complexes reconstituted with neurosporene or spheroidene, respectively. No transfer via the S1 state (efficiency <3%) was observed for carotenoids with N≥11, in agreement with previous studies (Akahane et al., 2004). The values of 20 and 19% for neurosporene and spheroidene are much lower than 94 and 82% obtained for LH2 complexes (Zhang et al., 2000; Polívka et al., 2004). However, it should be noted that the low efficiency of the S1-mediated energy transfer obtained by Akahane et al. (2004) may be attributed to involvement of the 1Bu– state that, according to the data analysis by Akahane et al. (2004), both transfers energy to BChl a and forms a triplet state with appreciable efficiency. Thus, as the 1Bu– state was not included in the analysis carried out by Zhang et al. (2000) or Polívka et al. (2004), the values are not directly comparable. Besides the 1Bu– pathway suggested by Akahane et al. (2004), the LH1 complex of Rsp. rubrum is also a system in which the S* state yield is pronounced. In this case, S* does not transfer energy to BChl a, but it is a precursor for the fast (~12 ps) formation of a spirilloxanthin triplet state. A relatively high triplet yield of 25–30% was explained on the basis of a conformational distortion of spirilloxanthin in the LH1 complex, promoting triplet formation via singlet homofission from the S* state (Gradinaru et al., 2001). Carotenoid-BChl energy transfer has also been studied in reaction centers (RC) of purple bacteria. Unlike the antenna complexes, RCs bind carotenoid in a 15,15´-cis configuration. Each RC has one carotenoid that is located in proximity to the BChl a monomer (BB) in the B branch (Allen et al., 1987). Earlier studies of RC from Rba. sphaeroides employing fluorescence excitation measurements reported ~75% efficiency of energy transfer from spheroidene to the primary donor (P), and BB BChl a was suggested to play a role of a mediator in this process (Frank et al., 1993). Later, these findings were elaborated by means of femtosecond time-resolved spectroscopy. Lin et al. (2003) studied the RC from aerobically grown Rba. sphaeroides that contains the carotenoid spheroidenone. By comparing the spheroidenone S1
Chapter 12
Carotenoid-to-BChl Energy Transfer
lifetime in RC (1.6 ps) with that in solution (6 ps), they concluded that energy transfer occurs preferentially from the S1 state of the carotenoid with an efficiency of 75%. This work was recently extended to RCs accommodating neurosporene and spheroidene (Lin et al., 2006). For these two carotenoids the S1mediated energy transfer operated with 96 and 84% efficiencies, respectively, matching perfectly the values obtained for the S1-mediated energy transfer in LH2 complexes (Zhang et al., 2000, Polívka et al., 2004). Thus, regardless of whether the carotenoid is in all-trans (LH2) or 15,15´-cis (RC) configuration, the S1-mediated energy transfer proceeds with the same efficiency. Lin et al. (2006) also found that at least 30% of energy must proceed via the S2 channel. This group also studied a mutant where the BB pigment was replaced by bacteriopheophytin which has a higher S1 energy than BB. In this mutant, the efficiency of total energy transfer from spheroidenone to P decreased substantially, supporting the earlier notion that the BB BChl a is a mediator for carotenoid to P energy transfer in RCs (Lin et al., 2006). V. Outlook Structural information in combination with advances in time-resolved spectroscopic techniques and data analysis during the past few years has vastly improved our knowledge of energy transfer processes between carotenoids and BChl in LH2 and LH1 complexes. On the other hand, these improvements brought a number of yet unanswered questions regarding origin of the involved states, routes and efficiencies of energy transfer, and effects of protein environment. An important issue is understanding the roles of the S* and 1Bu– states proposed as energy donors in carotenoid-BChl energy transfer, because the results obtained by the various research groups are often contradictory (see Polívka and Sundström, 2004, for review). The recent finding that the excited state dynamics of carotenoids in LH2 complexes depend on the intensity of excitation pulses adds a new dimension to the problem (Papagiannakis et al., 2006a). Clearly, intensity dependencies should be included in all future experiments. Although Papagiannakis et al. (2006) explored only the intensity dependence of S* state formation, it is likely that similar patterns may also be expected for the 1Bu– state. Ultrafast spectral features assigned earlier to a short-lived intermediate state (Cerullo et al., 2002) were subsequently
227 identified as being due to nonlinear effects caused by high-intensity femtosecond pulses (Kosumi et al., 2005). Another issue that deserves attention in future experiments is the role of vibrational relaxation in energy transfer. Although it was included in some data analyses, most studies attempting to disentangle the complex pattern of carotenoid-BChl energy transfer do not include vibrational levels (Koyama et al., 2004). To resolve these issues, new experimental approaches will be particularly interesting, for example the recently introduced ultrafast methods to control energy flow in LH2 complexes (Wohlleben et al., 2005). Pump-dump-probe (Papagiannakis, 2006c), femtosecond resonance Raman (McCamant et al., 2003) and two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy (Zigmantas, 2006) all hold the promise for elucidating the controlling features of energy transfer pathways in these systems. Acknowledgments This research is supported in the laboratory of HAF by the National Institutes of Health (GM-30353), the National Science Foundation (MCB-0314380), and the University of Connecticut Research Foundation. TP thanks the Czech Ministry of Education (MSM6007665808 and AV0Z50510513) for financial support. References Akahane J, Rondonuwu FS, Fiedor L, Watanabe Y and Koyama Y (2004) Dependence of singlet-energy transfer on the conjugation length of carotenoids reconstituted into the LH1 complex from Rhodospirillum rubrum G9. Chem Phys Lett 393: 184–191 Allen JP, Feher G, Yeates TO, Komiya H and Rees DC (1987) Structure of the reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26 — the cofactors. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 84: 5730–5734 Andersson PO, Cogdell RJ and Gillbro T. (1996) Femtosecond dynamics of carotenoid-to-bacteriochlorophyll a energy transfer in the light-harvesting antenna complexes from the purple bacterium Chromatium purpuratum. Chem Phys 210: 195–217 Angerhofer A, Cogdell RJ and Hipkins M. (1986) A spectral characterization of the light-harvesting pigment-protein complexes from Rhodopseudomonas acidophila. Biochim Biophys Acta 848: 333–341 Angerhofer A, Bornhäuser F, Gall A and Cogdell RJ (1995) Optical and optically detected magnetic-resonance investigation on purple photosynthetic bacterial antenna complexes. Chem Phys 194: 259–274 Billsten HH, Herek JL, Garcia-Asua G, Hashøj L, Polívka T,
228 Hunter CN and Sundström V (2002a) Dynamics of energy transfer from lycopene to bacteriochlorophyll in geneticallymodified LH2 complexes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 41: 4127–4136 Billsten HH, Zigmantas D, Sundström V and Polívka T (2002b) Dynamics of vibrational relaxation in the S1 state of carotenoids having 11 conjugated C=C bonds. Chem Phys Lett 355: 465–470 Billsten HH, Pan JX, Sinha S, Pascher T, Sundström V and Polívka T (2005) Excited-state processes in the carotenoid zeaxanthin after excess energy excitation. J Phys Chem A 109: 6852–6859 Cerullo G, Polli D, Lanzani G, De Silvestri S, Hashimoto H and Cogdell RJ (2002) Photosynthetic light harveting by carotenoids: Detection of an intermediate excited state. Science 298: 2395–2398 Chadwick B, Zhang C, Cogdell RJ and Frank H (1987) The effects of lithium dodecyl-sulfate and sodium-borohydride on the absorption-spectrum of the B800-850 light-harvesting complex from Rhodopseudomonas acidophila 7750. Biochim Biophys Acta 893: 444–451 Cogdell RJ and Frank HA (1987) How carotenoids function in photosynthetic bacteria. Biochim Biophys Acta 895: 63–79 Cogdell RJ, Hipkins MF, MacDonald W and Truscott TG (1981) Energy transfer between the carotenoid and the bacteriochlorophyll within the B800-850 light-harvesting pigment-protein complex of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. Biochim Biophys Acta 634: 191–202 Damjanović A, Ritz T and Schulten K (1999) Energy transfer between carotenoids and bacteriochlorophylls in light-harvesting complex II of purple bacteria. Phys Rev E 59: 3293–3311 Desamero RZB, Chynwat V, van der Hoef I, Jansen FJ, Lugtenburg J, Gosztola D, Wasielewski MR, Cua A, Bocian DF and Frank HA (1998) Mechanism of energy transfer from carotenoids to bacteriochlorophyll: Light-harvesting by carotenoids having different extents of π-electron conjugation incorporated into the B850 antenna complex from the carotenoidless bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26.1. J Phys Chem B 102: 8151–8162 de Weerd FL, van Stokkum IHM and van Grondelle R (2002) Subpicosecond dynamics in the excited state absorption of all-trans β-carotene. Chem Phys Lett 354: 38–43 Frank HA (2001) Spectroscopic studies of the low-lying singlet excited electronic states and photochemical properties of carotenoids. Arch Biochem Biophys 385: 53–60 Frank HA and Cogdell RJ (1996) Carotenoids in photosynthesis. Photochem Photobiol 63: 257–264 Frank HA, Chynwat V, Hartwich G, Meyer M, Katheder I and Scheer H (1993) Carotenoid triplet-state formation in Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26 reaction centers exchanged with modified bacteriochlorophyll pigments and reconstituted with spheroidene. Photosynth Res 37: 193–203 Frank HA, Bautista JA, Josue JS and Young AJ (2000a) Mechanism of nonphotochemical quenching in green plants: Energies of the lowest excited singlet states of violaxanthin and zeaxanthin. Biochemistry 39: 2831–2837 Frank HA, Bautista JA, Josue J, Pendon Z, Hiller RG, Sharples FP, Gosztola D and Wasielewski MR (2000b) Effect of the solvent environment on the spectroscopic properties and dynamics of the lowest excited states of carotenoids. J Phys Chem B 104: 4569–4577
Harry Frank and Tomáš Polívka Fraser NJ, Hashimoto H and Cogdell RJ (2001) Carotenoids and bacterial photosynthesis: The story so far. Photosynth Res 70: 249–256 Fujii R, Onaka K, Kuki M, Koyama Y and Watanabe Y (1998) The 2Ag– energies of all-trans-neurosporene and spheroidene as determined by fluorescence spectroscopy. Chem Phys Lett 288: 847–853 Furuichi K, Sashima T and Koyama Y (2002) The first detection of the 3Ag– state in carotenoids using resonance-Raman excitation profiles. Chem Phys Lett 356: 547–555 Gall A, Gardiner AT, Cogdell RJ and Robert B (2006) Carotenoid stoichiometry in the LH2 crystal: No spectral evidence for the presence of the second molecule in the α/β-apoprotein dimer. FEBS Lett 580: 3841–3844 Georgakopoulou S, van Grondelle R and van der Zwan G (2004) Circular dichroism of carotenoids in bacterial light-harvesting complexes: Experiments and modeling. Biophys J 87: 3010–3022 Gradinaru CC, Kennis JTM, Papagiannakis E, van Stokkum IHM, Cogdell RJ, Fleming GR, Niederman RA and van Grondelle R (2001) An unusual pathway of excitation energy deactivation in carotenoids: Singlet-to-triplet conversion on an ultrafast timescale in a photosynthetic antenna. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 98: 2364–2369 Hashimoto H, Yanagi K, Yoshizawa M, Polli D, Cerullo G, Lanzani G, De Silvestri S, Gardiner AT and Cogdell RJ (2004) The very early events following photoexcitation of carotenoids. Arch Biochem Biophys 430: 61–69 Herek JL, Wohlleben W, Cogdell RJ, Zeidler D and Motzkus M (2002) Quantum control of energy flow in light harvesting. Nature 417: 533–535 Hsu CP, Walla PJ, Head-Gordon M and Fleming GR (2001) The role of the S1 state of carotenoids in photosynthetic energy transfer: The light-harvesting complex II of purple bacteria. J Phys Chem B 105:11016–11025 Koepke J, Hu X, Muenke C, Schulten K and Michel H (1996) The crystal structure of the light-harvesting complex II (B800-850) from Rhodospirillum molischianum. Structure 4: 581–597 Kosumi D, Komukai M, Hashimoto H and Yoshizawa M (2005) Ultrafast dynamics of all-trans-β-carotene explored by resonant and nonresonant photoexcitations. Phys Rev Lett 95: 213601–213604 Koyama Y, Rondonuwu FS, Fujii R and Watanabe Y (2004) Lightharvesting function of carotenoids in photosynthesis: The roles of the newly found 1Bu– state. Biopolymers 74: 2–18 Krueger BP, Scholes GD, Jimenez R and Fleming GR (1998a) Electronic excitation transfer from carotenoid to bacteriochlorophyll in the purple bacterium Rhodopseudomonas acidophila. J Phys Chem B 102: 2284–2292 Krueger BP, Scholes GD and Fleming GR (1998b) Calculation of couplings and energy-transfer pathways between the pigments of LH2 by the ab initio transition density cube method. J Phys Chem B 102: 5378–5386 Krueger BP, Yom J, Walla PJ and Fleming GR (1999) Observation of the S1 state of spheroidene in LH2 by two-photon fluorescence excitation. Chem Phys Lett 310: 57–64 Larsen DS, Papagiannakis E, van Stokkum IHM, Vengris M, Kennis JTM and van Grondelle R (2003) Excited state dynamics of β-carotene explored with dispersed multi-pulse transient absorption. Chem Phys Lett 381: 733–742 Lin S, Katilius E, Taguchi AKW and Woodbury NW (2003) Ex-
Chapter 12
Carotenoid-to-BChl Energy Transfer
citation energy transfer from carotenoid to bacteriochlorophyll in the photosynthetic purple bacterial reaction center of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Phys Chem B 107: 14103–14108 Lin S, Katilius E, Ilagan RP, Gibson GN, Frank HA and Woodbury NW (2006) Mechanism of carotenoid singlet excited state energy transfer in modified bacterial reaction centers. J Phys Chem B 110: 15556–15563 Macpherson AN, Arellano JB, Fraser NJ, Cogdell RJ and Gillbro T (2001) Efficient energy transfer from the carotenoid S2 state in a photosynthetic light-harvesting complex. Biophys J 80: 923–930 McCamant DW, Kukura P and Mathies RA (2003) Femtosecond time-resolved stimulated Raman spectroscopy: Application to the ultrafast internal conversion in beta-carotene. J Phys Chem A 107: 8208–8214 McDermott G, Prince SM, Freer AA, Hawthornwaite-Lawless AM, Papiz MZ, Cogdell RJ and Isaacs NW (1995) Crystal structure of an integral membrane light-harvesting complex from photosynthetic bacteria. Nature 374: 517–521 McLuskey K, Prince SM, Cogdell RJ and Isaacs NW (2001) The crystallographic structure of the B800-820 LH3 light-harvesting complex from the purple bacteria Rhodopseudomonas Acidophila strain 7050. Biochemistry 40: 8783–8789 Nagae H, Kakitani T, Katoh T and Mimuro M (1993) Calculation of the excitation transfer-matrix elements between the S2 or S1 state of carotenoid and the S2 or S1 state of bacteriochlorophyll. J Chem Phys 98: 8012–8023 Naqvi KR (1980) The mechanism of singlet-singlet excitation energy transfer from carotenoids to chlorophyll. Photochem Photobiol 31: 523–524 Niedzwiedzki DM, Sullivan JO, Polívka T, Birge RR and Frank HA (2006) Femtosecond time-resolved transient absorption spectroscopy of xanthophylls. J Phys Chem B 110: 22872–22885 Papagiannakis E, Kennis JTM, van Stokkum IHM, Cogdell RJ and van Grondelle R (2002) An alternative carotenoid-to-bacteriochlorophyll energy transfer pathway in photosynthetic light harvesting. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 99: 6017–6022 Papagiannakis E, Das SK, Gall A, Stokkum IHM, Robert B, van Grondelle R, Frank HA and Kennis JTM (2003a) Light harvesting by carotenoids incorporated into the B850 light-harvesting complex from Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26.1: Excited-state relaxation, ultrafast triplet formation, and energy transfer to bacteriochlorophyll. J Phys Chem B 107: 5642–5649 Papagiannakis E, van Stokkum IHM, van Grondelle R, Niederman RA, Zigmantas D, Sundström V and Polívka T (2003b) A near-infrared transient absorption study of the excited-state dynamics of the carotenoid spirilloxanthin in solution and in the LH1 complex of Rhodospirillum rubrum. J Phys Chem B 107: 11216–11223 Papagiannakis E, van Stokkum IHM, Vengris M, Cogdell RJ, van Grondelle R and Larsen DS (2006a) Excited-state dynamics of carotenoids in light-harvesting complexes. 1. Exploring the relationship between the S1 and S* states. J Phys Chem B 110: 5727–5736 Papagiannakis E, Vengris M, Valkunas L, Cogdell RJ, van Grondelle R and Larsen DS (2006b) Excited-state dynamics of carotenoids in light-harvesting complexes. 2. Dissecting pulse structures from optimal control experiment. J Phys Chem B 110: 5737–5746 Papagiannakis E, Vengris M, Larsen DS, van Stokkum IHM, Hiller RG and van Grondelle R (2006c) Use of ultrafast dispersed
229 pump-dump-probe and pump-repump-probe spectroscopies to explore the light-induced dynamics of peridinin in solution. J Phys Chem B 110: 512–521 Papiz MZ, Prince SM, Howard TD, Cogdell RJ and Isaacs NW (2003) The structure and thermal motion of the B800–850 LH2 complex from Rps. acidophila at 2.0 Å resolution and 100 K: New structural features and functionally relevant motions. J Mol Biol 326: 1523–1538. Polívka T and Sundström V (2004) Ultrafast dynamics of carotenoid excited states — From solution to natural and artificial systems. Chem Rev 104: 2021–2071 Polívka T, Herek JL, Zigmantas D, Åkerlund HE and Sundström V (1999) Direct observation of the (forbidden) S1 state in carotenoids. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 96: 4914–4917 Polívka T, Zigmantas D, Frank HA, Bautista JA, Herek JL, Koyama Y, Fujii R and Sundström V (2001) Near-infrared time-resolved study of the S1 state dynamics of the carotenoid spheroidene. J Phys Chem B 105: 1072–1080 Polívka T, Zigmantas D, Herek JL, He Z, Pascher T, Pullerits T, Cogdell RJ, Frank HA and Sundström V (2002) The carotenoid S1 state in LH2 complexes of purple bacteria Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Rhodopseudomonas acidophila: S1 energies, dynamics, and carotenoid radical formation. J Phys Chem B 106: 11016–11025 Polívka T, Pullerits T, Frank HA Cogdell RJ and Sundström V (2004) Ultrafast formation of a carotenoid radical in LH2 antenna complexes of purple bacteria. J Phys Chem B 108: 15398–15407 Polívka T, Niedzwiedski D,Fuciman M, Sundström V and Frank HA (2007) Role of B800 in carotenoid-bacteriochlorophyll energy and electron transfer in LH2 complexes from the purple bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Phys Chem B 111: 7422–7431 Polli D, Cerullo G, Lanzani G, De Silvestri S, Hashimoto H and Cogdell RJ (2006) Carotenoid-bacteriochlorophyll energy transfer in LH2 complexes studied with 10-fs time resolution. Biophys J 90: 2486–2497 Rademaker H, Hoff AJ, van Grondelle R and Duysens LNM (1980) Carotenoid triplet yields in normal and deuterated Rhodospirillum rubrum. Biochim Biophys Acta 592: 240–257 Ricci M, Bradforth SE, Jimenez R and Fleming GR (1996) Internal conversion and energy transfer dynamics of spheroidene in solution and in the LH1 and LH2 light-harvesting complexes. Chem Phys Lett 259: 381–390 Ritz T, Damjanovic A, Schulten K, Zhang JP and Koyama Y (2000) Efficient light harvesting through carotenoids. Photosynth Res 66: 125–144 Rondonuwu FS, Watanabe Y, Fujii R and Koyama Y (2003) A first detection of singlet to triplet conversion from the 1Bu– to the 3Ag state and triplet internal conversion from the 3Ag to the 3 Bu state in carotenoids: dependence on the conjugation length. Chem Phys Lett 376: 292–301 Rondonuwu FS, Yokoyama K, Fujii R, Koyama Y, Cogdell RJ and Watanabe Y (2004) The role of the 1Bu– state in carotenoid-tobacteriochlorophyll singlet-energy transfer in the LH2 antenna complexes from Rhodobacter sphaeroides G1C, Rhodobacter sphaeroides 2.4.1, Rhodospirillum molischianum and Rhodopseudomonas acidophila. Chem Phys Lett 390: 314–322 Roszak AW, Howard TD, Southall J, Gardiner AT, Law CJ, Isaacs NW and Cogdell RJ (2003) Crystal structure of the RC-LH1 core complex from Rhodopseudomonas palustris. Science
230 302: 1969–1972 Sashima T, Nagae H, Kuki M and Koyama Y (1999) A new singlet-excited state of all-trans-spheroidene as detected by resonance-Raman excitation profiles. Chem Phys Lett 299: 187–194 Scholes GD, Harcourt RD and Fleming GR (1997) Electronic interactions in photosynthetic light-harvesting complexes: The role of carotenoids. J Phys Chem B 101: 7302–7312 Shreve AP, Trautman JK, Frank HA, Owens TG and Albrecht AC (1991). Femtosecond energy transfer processes in the B800-850 light-harvesting complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides 2.4.1. Biochim Biophys Acta 1058: 280–288 Tavan P and Schulten K (1987) Electronic Excitations in Finite and Infinite Polyenes. Phys Rev B 36: 4337–4358 Trautman JK, Shreve AP, Violette CA, Frank HA, Owens TG and Albrecht AC (1990) Femtosecond dynamics of energy transfer in B800-850 light-harvesting complexes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 87: 215–219 Tretiak S, Middleton C, Chernyak V and Mukamel S (2000) Bacteriochlorophyll and carotenoid excitonic couplings in the LH2 system of purple bacteria. J Phys Chem B 104: 9540–9553 van Grondelle R (1985) Excitation energy transfer, trapping and annihilation in photosynthetic systems. Biochim Biophys Acta 811: 147–195 van Grondelle R, Kramer H and Rijgersberg C (1982) Energy transfer in the B800-850-carotenoid light-harvesting complex of various mutants of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides and of Rhodopseudomonas capsulatus. Biochim Biophys Acta 682: 208–215 Walla PJ, Linden PA, Hsu CP, Scholes GD and Fleming GR (2000). Femtosecond dynamics of the forbidden carotenoid
Harry Frank and Tomáš Polívka S1 state in light-harvesting complexes of purple bacteria observed after two-photon excitation. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 97: 10808–10813 Wohlleben W, Buckup T, Herek JL, Cogdell RJ, and Motzkus M (2003) Multichannel carotenoid deactivation in photosynthetic light harvesting as identified by an evolutionary target analysis. Biophys J 85: 442–450 Wohlleben W, Buckup T, Hashimoto H, Cogdell RJ, Herek JL and Motzkus M (2004) Pump-deplete-probe spectroscopy and the puzzle of carotenoid dark states. J Phys Chem 108: 3320–3325 Wohlleben W, Buckup T, Herek JL and Motzkus M (2005) Coherent control for spectroscopy and manipulation of biological dynamics. Chem Phys Chem 6: 850–857 Zhang JP, Fujii R, Qian P, Inaba T, Mizoguchi T, Koyama Y, Onaka K and Watanabe Y (2000) Mechanism of the carotenoid-to-bacteriochlorophyll energy transfer via the S-1 state in the LH2 complexes from purple bacteria. J Phys Chem B 104: 3683–3691 Zhang JP, Inaba T, Watanabe Y and Koyama Y (2001) Partition of carotenoid-to-bacteriochlorophyll singlet-energy transfer through two channels in the LH2 complex from Rhodobacter sphaeroides G1C. Chem Phys Lett 340: 484–492 Zigmantas D, Hiller RG, Sharples FP, Frank HA, Sundström V and Polívka T (2004) Effect of a conjugated carbonyl group on the photophysical properties of carotenoids. Phys Chem Chem Phys 6: 3009–3016 Zigmantas D, Read EL, Mančal T, Brixner T, Gardiner AT, Cogdell RJ and Fleming GR (2006) Two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy of the B800–B820 light-harvesting complex. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 103: 12672–12677
Chapter 13 Spectroscopy and Dynamics of Excitation Transfer and Trapping in Purple Bacteria Rienk van Grondelle* Department of Biophysics, Faculty of Sciences, Vrije Universiteit, De Boelelaan 1081, 1081 HV Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Vladimir I. Novoderezhkin A. N. Belozersky Institute of Physico-Chemical Biology, Moscow State University, Leninskie Gory, 119992, Moscow, Russia
Summary ............................................................................................................................................................... 232 I. Introduction..................................................................................................................................................... 232 A. Collective Electronic Excitations in Photosynthetic Complexes ....................................................... 232 B. Modified Redfield and Generalized Förster Theories ....................................................................... 233 II. Structure and Exciton Spectra of Light-Harvesting 1 and 2 Bacterial Antenna Complexes .......................... 235 A. Structure and the Excited-state Properties....................................................................................... 235 B. Disordered Exciton Model ................................................................................................................ 235 C. Steady-state Spectra........................................................................................................................ 236 D. Multiple Exciton Delocalization Sizes ............................................................................................... 237 E. Superradiance and Anomalously High Nonlinear Responses.......................................................... 238 F. Exciton Transitions Viewed by Polarized Single Molecule Spectroscopy ........................................ 238 III. Equilibration Dynamics ................................................................................................................................... 239 A. Exciton Relaxation and Dynamic Red-Shift...................................................................................... 239 B. Interplay of Excitonic and Vibrational Coherences ........................................................................... 240 IV. Competition of Intraband B800-800 and Interband B800-850 Energy Transfer in the Light-Harvesting 2 Complex ........................................................................................................................................................ 241 A. Excitation-wavelength Dependent Decay of the B800 Band ............................................................ 241 B. Multiple Pathways of B800 to B850 Transfer ................................................................................... 243 C. Origin of the B800 Anisotropy Decay ............................................................................................... 243 V. Energy Trapping in the Core Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1 Complex ................................................. 243 A. Trapping Kinetics.............................................................................................................................. 243 B. Exciton Control of Antenna-Reaction Center Transfer Rates........................................................... 243 C. Detrapping Efficiency ....................................................................................................................... 244 VI. Slow Conformational Motions and Excitation Dynamics in the B850-Light-Harvesting 2 Complex ............... 244 A. Dynamics of Conformational Changes ............................................................................................. 244 B. Fluctuations of Spectral Shapes in a Single Complex...................................................................... 245 C. Exciton Dynamics in the Different Conformational States................................................................ 246 VII. Concluding Remarks ...................................................................................................................................... 247 Acknowledgments ................................................................................................................................................. 248 References ............................................................................................................................................................ 248
*Author for correspondence, email: [email protected]
C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty (eds): The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria, pp. 231–252. © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V.
232
Rienk van Grondelle and Vladimir I. Novoderezhkin
Summary In this chapter we discuss the transfer and trapping of excitation energy in the light-harvesting antenna of purple bacteria. The determination of high-resolution X-ray crystal structures of a variety of bacterial light-harvesting complexes has allowed an interpretation of the steady-state and time-resolved picosecond/femtosecond spectral responses of these complexes at a quantitative level using the disordered exciton model in combination with the generalized Förster and modified Redfield theories. Thus a consistent physical picture of energy transfer and trapping has been obtained including a precise assignment of the energy transfer pathways together with a direct visualization of the full excitation dynamics where various regimes ranging from coherent motion of the delocalized exciton to the hopping of localized excitations are superimposed. In a single complex it is possible to observe the switching between these regimes driven by slow conformational motions. I. Introduction In photosynthetic purple bacteria solar photons are absorbed by a set of membrane-associated pigmentproteins (the light-harvesting antenna complexes LH1 and LH2) and the electronic excited state is efficiently transferred to a reaction center (RC), where it is converted into a charge separation eventually leading to the build-up of a transmembrane electro-chemical potential difference (Van Grondelle et al., 1994; Van Amerongen et al., 2001). Antenna complexes consist of ordered arrays of bacteriochlorophylls (BChls) as main light-harvesting pigments, which together with other cofactors are non-covalently bound to proteins (Chapter 8, Gabrielsen et al.; Chapter 9, Bullough et al.). The peripheral LH2 complex consists of a highly symmetric circular aggregate of 9 (or 8) pigment-protein subunits, each subunit containing 2 trans-membrane polypeptide helixes that bind 3 BChls, forming a tightly packed ring of 18 (or 16) BChls with a second ring of 9 (or 8) weakly interacting BChls (McDermott et al., 1995; Koepke et al., 1996; Papiz et al., 2003). These rings determine the well-known absorption features of LH2 with intense absorption bands at 850 and 800 nm, respectively (also called B850 and B800). The LH1 core complex has 16 or 15 subunits with 2 BChls each, forming ‘circular’ structures with 32 BChls (Karrasch et al., 1995; Scheuring et al., 2003) or an open circle with 30 BChls (Rozak et al., 2003) surrounding the RC. Abbreviations: B850, B800 – spectral bands with the 850 or 800 nm absorption; BChl – bacteriochlorophyll; Blc. – Blastochloris; CD – circular dichroism; FL – fluorescence; LH1 – core lightharvesting complex of purple bacteria; LH2 – peripheral lightharvesting complex of purple bacteria; PR – participation ratio; Qy, Qx, By, Bx – four electronic transitions of BChl; Rba. – Rhodobacter; RC – reaction center; Rps. – Rhodopseudomonas; Rsp. – Rhodospirillum; TA – transient absorption
A. Collective Electronic Excitations in Photosynthetic Complexes The distance between nearest-neighbor BChls in the tightly packed rings of LH1/LH2 is about 9 Å, thus giving rise to strong electrostatic pigment-pigment interactions. These interactions produce a coherent superposition of the excited states of the individual BChls giving rise to collective excitations (excitons) delocalized over a certain number of pigments. The weakly coupled BChls in the second (B800) ring of LH2 produce more localized excitations. In order to obtain the structure of the excited states of the whole antenna it is necessary to account for all the pigment-pigment interactions. The resulting exciton Hamiltonian can be expressed in the basis of the local excited-state wavefunctions |n〉, which correspond to the excitation of the n-th pigment: N
N
n=1
n≠ m
H = ∑ En n n + ∑ M nm n m
(1)
where N is the number of BChls in the antenna, En is the electronic transition energy of the n-th molecule, Mnm is the interaction energy between the n-th and m-th molecules. We only consider excitation of the lowest excited state of BChl corresponding to the Qy transition. Generalization of Eq. (1) taking into account the Qy, Qx, By, and Bx transitions of BChls is straightforward (Scherz and Parson, 1984; Alden et al., 1997; Koolhaas et al., 1997a). Excitations of individual pigments with the energies En are no longer eigenstates of the system due to the presence of the off-diagonal energies Mnm that reflect the excitonic coupling between the pigments. The energies ωk and wavefunctions |k〉 of the exciton eigenstates can be obtained by diagonalization of the Hamiltonian (Eq. 1):
Chapter 13
Spectroscopy and Dynamics of Excitation Transfer
N
H = ∑ ωk k k k =1
N
;
k = ∑ cnk n n=1
(2)
where the collective exciton states |k〉 contain a coherent superposition of the individual molecular excitations |n〉. In Eq. (2) the wavefunction amplitudes cnk reflect the participation of the n-th site in the k-th exciton state. B. Modified Redfield and Generalized Förster Theories Absorption of a solar photon by LH2 populates the exciton states of the antenna. Since this population is generally not in thermal equilibrium, the system will relax. The ensuing dynamics include energy transfer between the excitonic states |k〉, where the rate of population transfer from state k´ to state k is given by Zhang et al., (1998) and Yang and Fleming (2002): ∞
Rkkk ' k ' = 2 Re ∫ dt Ak (t ) Fk*' (t ) Vkk ' (t ) 0
Ak (t ) = exp { − iω k t − gkkkk (t )
{
}
Fk ' (t ) = exp − iω k ' t − gk* ' k ' k ' k ' (t ) + 2iλ k ' k ' k ' k ' t
} (3)
where F(t) and A(t) are line-shape functions corresponding to fluorescence (FL) of the donor state and absorption of the acceptor, respectively, while V describes the electrostatic interaction between donor and acceptor. The function gkkkk(t) determines the line-broadening of the k-th exciton state due to exciton-phonon coupling, λkkkk is the corresponding reorganization energy. These quantities are (Mukamel, 1995; Zhang et al., 1998): gkkkk (t ) = ∑ ( cnk )4 gn (t ) ; λ kkkk = ∑ ( cnk )4 λ n ; n
n
∞
dω Cn (ω ) ⎡⎣ coth 2 kωBT (cos ωt − 1) − i ( sin ωt − ωt ) ⎤⎦ g n (t ) = − ∫ 2 −∞ 2πω λn =
∞
∫
−∞
dω C (ω ) 2πω n
(4)
where gn(t) and λn correspond to the line-broadening function and reorganization energy of the n-th molecule, which are related to the spectral density Cn(ω) of the exciton-phonon coupling, T is the temperature, kB is the Boltzmann constant. The spectral
233
density in Eq. (4) reflects a fast modulation of the transition energies of the pigments En due to phonons (intramolecular vibrations, pigment-pigment and pigment-protein modes). The phonon-induced modulation of the couplings Mnm can be included into Eq. (4) as well (Meier et al., 1997b). If the donor and acceptor states are localized at the m-th and n-th sites (i.e., cmk´ = 1 and cnk = 1) then V is given by Vkk ' (t ) = M nm
2
(5)
where Mnm is the interaction energy corresponding to a weak coupling between the localized sites n and m. Switching to the Fourier-transforms of F(t) and A(t) we can rewrite the integral in a form of donor-acceptor spectral overlap (Yang and Fleming, 2002). Thus, we obtain the Förster formula (Förster, 1965). The standard Förster formula can be generalized to the case of energy transfer between two weakly connected clusters (Novoderezhkin and Razjivin, 1994; 1996; Sumi, 1999; Scholes and Fleming 2000; Jang et al., 2004). The rate of energy transfer from the k´-th exciton state of one cluster to the k-th state of the other cluster is 2
Vkk ' (t ) =
∑ cnk M nm cmk'
(6)
n ,m
where n and m designate molecules belonging to different clusters. In this generalized Förster formula, the donor and acceptor states k´ and k can have an arbitrary degree of delocalization (corresponding to arbitrarily strong excitonic interactions within each cluster). But it is important to note that the intercluster interactions Mnm are weak, thus producing only a small spatial overlap between the k´ and k wavefunctions. In the case of significant spatial overlap of the wavefunctions cmk´ and ckn the transfer rate cannot be calculated by treating Mnm as a perturbation. In this case the energy transfer should be calculated in the basis of the exciton states of the whole system. The rates of relaxation between these states (with arbitrary wavefunction overlap) are given by their interaction with phonons. The modified Redfield approach gives (Zhang et al., 1998; Yang and Fleming, 2002):
Rienk van Grondelle and Vladimir I. Novoderezhkin
234 Vkk ' (t ) = exp(2 g k ' k ' kk (t ) + 2iλ k ' k ' kk t ) × × ⎡⎣ g&&kk ' k ' k (t ) − { g& k ' kk ' k ' (t ) − g& k ' kkk (t ) + 2iλ k ' kk ' k ' } × × { g& k ' k ' kk ' (t ) − g& kkkk ' (t ) + 2iλ k ' k ' kk ' } ⎤⎦
(7) N
gkk ' k '' k ''' (t ) = ∑ cnk cnk ' cnk '' cnk ''' gn (t ) ; n=
N
λ kk ' k '' k ''' = ∑ cnk cnk ' cnk '' cnk ''' λ n n=
The exponential term in Eq. (7) contains the linebroadening function gk´k´kk(t) which is proportional to the wavefunction overlap ∑n(ck´n ckn)2. In the localized limit ck´n = 1, whereas ckn is close to zero. Considering the coupling energy Mnm between the two sites as a weak perturbation we have ckn = Mnm/(En – Em), where En and Em are the site energies. Thus, in the limit of weak interaction Eq. (7) reduces to Eq. (5) and we recover the Förster formula. As an example we calculate the energy transfer rates within a dimer as a function of the energy gap (E1–E2) between the two molecules (Fig. 1). We use the Förster (Eq. 5) and modified Redfield (Eq. 7) expressions. In the calculation we use the spectral density Cn(ω) containing one overdamped Brownian oscillator and 48 high-frequency modes with the parameters taken from the experiment (Peterman et al., 1997). The difference between energy transfer rates as predicted by the two theories is compared with the delocalization (del) length calculated as the inverse participation ratio of the exciton wavefunctions, i.e., Ndel = PR−1, where PR = (c1k)4+(ck2)4. For a dimer the inverse participation ratio (PR) varies from 1 (in the localized limit) to 2, where the excitation is uniformly delocalized over the two molecules. Figure 1 shows that in the case where the energy difference is large (E1–E2 > 5M) the excitation is almost localized (1 < Ndel < 1.1). The energy transfer has the form of hopping between the two molecules. In this case the Förster and Redfield theories give approximately the same rate. Decreasing the energy gap (E1–E2 < 5M) results in formation of delocalized states (with Ndel increasing from 1.1 up to 2). In this case the excitonic interactions create a coherent mixing of the two sites. Instead of an excitation jumping from one site to the other, we now have a relaxation between two delocalized states. Increase of the spatial overlap between the
Fig. 1. The energy transfer rate as a function of the energy gap between two molecules calculated with the Förster and modified Redfield theories (only downhill rates are shown). The delocalization length Ndel is calculated as the inverse participation ratio of the exciton wavefunctions. The Ndel = 1 line is shown to highlight the deviations from the localized limit. The two frames correspond to Mnm = 255 and 55 cm−1. We use the exciton-phonon spectral density measured for the plant light-harvesting complex (Peterman et al., 1997). The relaxation rates have been calculated for 77 K. The specific non-monotonous dependence of the rates on the energy gap is determined by the shape of the phonon wing.
delocalized wavefunctions corresponds to having much faster transfer. The deviation of the Redfield rates compared with those predicted by the Förster equation increases in proportion to the deviation of delocalization length from the localized limit. This example suggests that interband transfers in purple bacteria (for example the energy transfer from B800 to B850, which corresponds to a large energy gap and small coupling) can be calculated using the generalized Förster approach. On the contrary, intraband dynamics (for instance the B850-B850 equilibration corresponding to a small energy gap and large exciton couplings) should be modeled by the Redfield theory.
Chapter 13
Spectroscopy and Dynamics of Excitation Transfer
II. Structure and Exciton Spectra of LightHarvesting 1 and 2 Bacterial Antenna Complexes A. Structure and the Excited-state Properties Since the determination of the crystal structure of the peripheral B800-B850 LH2 antenna of purple bacteria Rhodopseudomonas (Rps.) acidophila (McDermott et al., 1995) and Rhodospirillum (Rsp.) molischianum (Koepke et al., 1996) a direct calculation of the exciton Hamiltonian (Eq. 1) from first principles has become possible (Alden et al., 1997; Scholes et al., 1999; Tretiak et al., 2000a,b; Damjanović et al., 2002; Hu et al., 2002). These calculations revealed strong exciton couplings of the Qy transitions within the tightly packed B850 ring. The corresponding values of nearest-neighbor interaction energy vary around 250–300 cm−1, depending on the method of computation; see Tretiak et al. (2000b) for a review. Such strong interactions produce a broad exciton band with the lowest states near 850 nm and higher exciton states spreading up to the 800 nm region where they are superimposed with the degenerate levels of the B800 ring (Dracheva et al., 1996; Sauer et al., 1996; Alden et al., 1997; Hu et al., 1997; Koolhaas et al., 1997b; Wu et al., 1997b; Georgakopoulou et al., 2002; Novoderezhkin et al., 2003). The B800 ring is characterized by weak pigment-pigment couplings of about 30 cm−1, corresponding to localized excited states. Nevertheless, the excitonic interactions should be taken into account to correctly reproduce the B800 line shapes (Cheng and Silbey, 2006) and the excitation dynamics within the B800 ring (Novoderezhkin et al., 2003; Zigmantas et al., 2006). Interaction of the exciton states with the phonons induces a homogeneous line broadening (given by the function gkkkk), a red-shift of the pure electronic (zero-phonon) transitions (due to reorganization effects determined by λkkkk), and the transfer of excitation energy in the complex (relaxation or hopping between different states or sites). All these features are determined by the exciton-phonon spectral density Cn(ω) that can be extracted from spectroscopic data (for example, from the low-temperature FL spectra (Kühn et al., 2002)), or obtained numerically using molecular dynamics and quantum chemical calculations (Damjanović et al., 2002).
235
B. Disordered Exciton Model Besides fast nuclear motion (phonons and vibrations) the excitonic transitions are affected by slow conformational motion of the proteins. Such motion induces random shifts (quasi-static disorder) in the transition energies En and couplings Mnm. The exciton energies and wavefunctions become perturbed correspondingly. In conventional bulk spectroscopies (with averaging over many complexes) the conformational disorder produces inhomogeneous line broadening. In single molecule techniques a slow conformational motion can be viewed as fluctuations of the spectral shapes on a time scale from milliseconds to minutes. In the homogeneous limit (without disorder) all the dipole strength of the circular aggregate (made up of N molecules having almost in-plane orientation of the Qy transition dipoles) is concentrated in a degenerate pair of levels (k = ±1). The participation ratio is PR = 1/N and 3/(2N) (i.e., 0.056, and 0.083 for N = 18) for the lowest and higher states, respectively. This homogenous exciton structure is changed dramatically in the presence of disorder depending on the ratio between the disorder width σ and the nearest neighbor interaction energy M (Monshouwer et al., 1997; Alden et al., 1997; Novoderezhkin et al., 1999a). An example of how weak, moderate, and strong disorder (σ/M = 0.52, 1.29, and 2.23) affect the absorption spectrum of the B850 antenna (with N = 18) is shown in Fig. 2. In the case of weak disorder (σ/M = 0.52) the disorder value is less than the nearest neighbor interaction energy and the exciton structure is close to that of the homogeneous limit. The k = ±1 levels are almost degenerate and each have a dipole strength of about 8.5 (in the units of monomeric dipole strength). The lowest k = 0 state becomes weakly allowed borrowing a dipole strength of about 1 from the k = ±1 levels. The PR values are 0.6–1.2 and 0.9–1.1 for k = 0 and higher levels, respectively. In the second case the disorder value exceeds the exciton coupling (σ/M = 1.29), producing significant mixing of the exciton wavefunctions. The splitting between the k = ±1 states increases to 70 cm−1. The lowest state becomes superradiant (with dipole strength of 2) and more localized (with PR values increasing to 0.4–0.5 for the red-shifted realizations). Higher states become allowed and more localized (PR is spread between 0.09 and 0.2).
236
Rienk van Grondelle and Vladimir I. Novoderezhkin
Fig. 2. Top frames: Measured (open circles) and calculated (solid lines) absorption spectra for the LH2-B850 antenna of Rps. acidophila at room temperature. The calculated absorption is shown together with the individual exciton components (thin lines). Bars show dipole strengths of the exciton components (in units of monomeric dipole strength) averaged over disorder. Line shapes are obtained with the spectral density modeled by an overdamped Brownian oscillator with coupling value of λ0 = 200 cm−1 and width (inverse bath relaxation time) of γ0 = 100 cm−1. The energies of the 1α1β, 1β2α, 1α2α, 1β2β, and 1α2β interactions were taken to be 291, 273, −50, −36, and 12 cm−1.The absorption spectrum is averaged over disorder, which was modeled by uncorrelated shifts of the site energies (diagonal disorder) taken from a Gaussian distribution with FWHM of σ = 150, 375, and 650 cm−1. Bottom frames: Participation ratio PR(k) = ∑n(cnk)4 for the 7 lowest exciton levels (i.e., k = 0, −1, 1, −2, 2, −3 and 3) calculated for 2000 realizations of the disorder. Each point shows the PR value for one exciton state for one realization as a function of the wavelength corresponding to the zero-phonon line (ZPL) of this state.
A further increase of the disorder (σ/M = 2.23 in the third case) produces an even more uniform distribution of the dipole strength. The lowest state has (on average) become more superradiant, with an average dipole strength of 3. On the other hand, there are red-shifted realizations with an almost localized lowest state (with PR value up to 0.6–0.8). The higher states are more localized as well (with PR values distributed between 0.09 and 0.35). The LH1 antenna has a structure similar to that of the B850 ring of LH2. The larger size (N = 30–32 instead of 16–18 in LH2) results in less spacing between the zero-order exciton levels, which in turn produces stronger disorder-induced mixing of the
exciton states. In particular, the lowest k = 0 state becomes more superradiant and the higher k = ±2 states (which in LH2 stay almost forbidden even with moderate disorder) now give a significant contribution to the absorption profile (Novoderezhkin et al., 1999a; 2000; 2002). C. Steady-state Spectra The steady-state spectroscopic properties of LH1/ LH2 were studied with polarized light spectroscopy (Van Mourik et al., 1992; Visschers et al., 1995), nonlinear polarized absorption (Leupold et al., 1996), hole-burning (Reddy et al., 1991, 1992, 1993; Wu
Chapter 13
Spectroscopy and Dynamics of Excitation Transfer
et al., 1997a), low-temperature FL (Freiberg et al., 2003), superradiance (Monshouwer et al., 1997), circular dichroism (CD) (Koolhaas et al., 1997b, 1998; Georgakopoulou et al., 2002), Stark spectroscopy (Beekman et al., 1997), and single-molecule techniques (Bopp et al., 1997, 1999; Van Oijen et al., 1998, 1999a,b; Tietz et al., 1999; Ketelaars et al., 2001; Gerken et al., 2003a,b; Hoffman et al., 2003; Rutkauskas et al., 2004, 2005, 2006).The data revealed important details of the exciton structure such as the exciton splitting value, disorder values (for different types of disorder), dipole strengths of the exciton transitions, and the delocalization length. The majority of the steady-state spectroscopic results can be explained within the framework of the exciton theory taking into account the influence of the static disorder. Low temperature polarized FL (Van Mourik et al., 1992) and hole-burning (Reddy et al., 1992) data revealed the presence of the allowed lowest k = 0 level together with intense higher levels broadened due to relaxation. A specific shape of the CD spectra with a red-shift of the zero-crossing (Koolhaas et al., 1997b) reflects a collective (coherent) contribution of the pigments within a large part of a complete ring. The disorder manifests itself through a mixing of the k = ±1 exciton states with the k = 0 state producing a strongly allowed superradiant lowest state observed in FL experiments (Monshouwer et al., 1997). On the other hand, it appeared that including uncorrelated disorder into the exciton model is not sufficient to explain the large splitting between the k = 0 and k = ±1 states observed in hole-burning spectra and consequently correlated disorder was introduced (Wu et al., 1997b). Also, the large splitting between the orthogonally polarized transitions observed in single molecule FL excitation spectra was explained in terms of correlated disorder produced by an elliptical deformation of the ring (Van Oijen et al., 1999b; Ketelaars et al., 2001). The simple exciton model with static disorder (uncorrelated or correlated) also fails to explain the anomalously broad FL profiles observed for LH1/LH2 at low temperature (Freiberg et al., 2003; Timpmann et al., 2004). The data suggested the presence of strong exciton-phonon coupling producing polaron features in the low temperature emission spectra (Freiberg et al., 2003; Timpmann et al., 2004). Including strong exciton-phonon coupling into the modified Redfield theory (see Eqs. 3, 4, and 7) yields more realistic line shapes with reorganization shifts
237
and phonon-induced broadening of the exciton levels in addition to the exciton splitting. These phonon-induced effects, proportional to the PR value according to Eq. (4), are more pronounced for the lowest k = 0 state (especially for strongly disordered realizations giving rise to a localized and red-shifted k = 0 state as seen in Fig. 2). This produces a much broader low-temperature FL profile as compared to the simple exciton model with just static disorder. On the other hand, the disorder of the reorganization shift values produces additional splitting between the exciton states and additional inhomogeneous broadening. Application of the modified Redfield approach allowed a quantitative explanation of the shapes of FL profiles and fluctuations of the FL peak positions observed in a single LH2 complex (Novoderezhkin et al., 2006; Rutkauskas et al., 2006; see Section VI). D. Multiple Exciton Delocalization Sizes The precise character of the excitation within the circular aggregates of the B850-LH2 and LH1 antennae, such as the degree of delocalization, multiple coherence sizes, dynamic localization, etc., has been the subject of intense debate (Reddy et al., 1992; Novoderezhkin and Razjivin, 1993, 1994, 1995a; Bradforth et al., 1995; Dracheva et al., 1995, 1997; Pullerits et al., 1996; Alden et al., 1997; Monshouwer et al., 1997; Nagarajan et al., 1999; Freiberg et al., 2003) and was critically reviewed and summarized in Novoderezhkin et al. (1999b); Meier et al. (1997c); Dahlbom et al. (2001). It should be noted that there exist many different definitions of the degree of delocalization which implies that even for the same system one may find different sizes of an exciton. Delocalization of individual exciton states can be characterized by the inverse participation ratio PR(k), which is different for different states (as illustrated in Fig.2). The effective (averaged over k) delocalization of the exciton wavefunctions Neff can be defined as PR−1(k) weighed with the populations of the exciton states at thermal equilibrium (Meier et al., 1997a). Typically the excited state in the antenna is given by a superposition of exciton states, i.e., an exciton wavepacket is formed whose evolution in time is described by the timedependent density matrix (Mukamel, 1995; Kühn and Sundström, 1997b; Meier et al., 1997a,b,c). The coherence length (or delocalization length) of the wavepacket Ncoh can be defined as the width of antidiagonal distribution of the density matrix in the site
238 representation (Kühn and Sundström, 1997). Modeling of the LH1 and LH2 antenna proteins in the presence of static disorder gave the values Neff = 5–11 (Jimenez et al., 1996; Alden et al., 1997; Meier et al., 1997c; Novoderezhkin et al., 1999) and Ncoh = 4–6 (Kühn and Sundström, 1997b; Novoderezhkin et al., 1999a,b) at room temperature. The dynamic disorder induced by exciton-phonon coupling may give rise to a further reduction of these exciton sizes due to polaron formation (Meier et al., 1997a). Notice that both Neff and Ncoh values reflect some kind of nonuniformity of the shape of the exciton wavefunction, but not a true ‘physical size.’ Generally, spectral responses of a strongly coupled aggregate reflect the cooperative behavior of some number of pigments which can be very different from the effective localization sizes, Neff , Ncoh (Koolhaas et al., 1997b; Meier et al., 1997c; Koolhaas et al., 2000). The number of molecules that contribute to the spectral response can also be different for different spectroscopic techniques. For example, the shape of the CD spectra of the B850 band of the LH2 antenna is determined by cooperativity within at least 10–12 molecules (Koolhaas et al., 1997b; 2000). The shape and amplitude of the transient absorption measured for B850 can only be reproduced by taking into account the exciton coupling between more than 12 molecules of the antenna (Novoderezhkin et al., 1999b). One could define the spectroscopic subunit as the minimal fragment of the ring which is big enough to reproduce all spectral features of the whole antenna (Koolhaas et al., 2000). Due to disorder, the size of such a subunit is less than the aggregate size N, but larger than both effective localization sizes, Neff and Ncoh. E. Superradiance and Anomalously High Nonlinear Responses One of the manifestations of the collective character of excitations in the antenna is an increase in dipole strength of the lowest exciton states (i.e., k = 0 and k = ±1 states as shown in Fig. 2). An anomalously high dipole strength of the main k = ±1 transitions gives rise to an increase of the nonlinear response amplitudes in proportion to N (Novoderezhkin and Razjivin, 1993; 1995b; Leupold et al., 1996; Novoderezhkin et al., 1999b). Pump-probe studies on the core RC-LH1 complex revealed bleaching amplitudes in the antenna that were several times bigger than those corresponding
Rienk van Grondelle and Vladimir I. Novoderezhkin to the bleaching of the special pair due to oxidation of the RC (Novoderezhkin and Razjivin, 1993, 1995b; Kennis et al., 1994; Xiao et al., 1994). In the LH2 complex the bleaching amplitude of the B850 ring was found to be much higher than for the B800 monomeric band (Kennis et al., 1996). Quantitative modeling of the shapes and relative amplitudes of the TA spectra for the LH2 antenna and isolated B820 dimeric subunit (Novoderezhkin et al., 1999b) provided direct evidence for a delocalization of the exciton over many BChls in the B850 ring; corresponding to effective localization sizes for the B850 antenna of Neff = 7.87 and Ncoh = 5.0. The dipole strength of the lowest exciton state (sensitive to the amount of the static disorder) can be determined from the low-temperature transient absorption (TA) (Kennis et al., 1997b) and superradiance (Monshouwer et al., 1997) data. Thus, the integrated intensity of the stimulated emission component in B850 corresponds to the dipole strength of the lowest exciton level of 2.3–3.4 (Kennis et al., 1997b). From the low-temperature superradiance data this value was estimated as 2.8 and 3.8 for the LH2 and LH1 antenna, respectively (Monshouwer et al., 1997). Taken together, these nonlinear spectroscopic results have lead to the disordered exciton model for the LH2-B850 and LH1 antennae (Novoderezhkin et al., 1999a). F. Exciton Transitions Viewed by Polarized Single Molecule Spectroscopy One of the most prominent manifestations of excitonic effects in the LH2-B850 and LH1 antennae is the polarization of the two main transitions (k = ±1) of a circular aggregate. Even in the presence of disorder the largest part of the dipole strength is still concentrated in the original two k = ±1 transitions that have perpendicular polarization in the plane of the ring (Novoderezhkin et al., 1999a). In contrast, localization of the excitation at one site (or on one dimeric BChl subunit) would produce N (or N/2) transitions with different (almost in-plane) polarizations having angles uniformly distributed between 0 and 2π. Such localized features were indeed observed in a single molecule study of the monomeric B800 band of LH2 (Van Oijen et al., 1999b). On the other hand, FL excitation spectra in the 850 nm region (Bopp et al., 1999; van Oijen et al., 1999a) demonstrated the existence of just two perpendicularly polarized transitions in a single LH2 complex, thus giving
Chapter 13
Spectroscopy and Dynamics of Excitation Transfer
direct evidence for pronounced excitonic features in the B850 antenna. Such a confirmation of one of the main predictions of the exciton model was not evident a priori, since in a real pigment-protein complex the ideal exciton picture may easily be destroyed by slow conformational dynamics of the complex inducing quasi-static energetic disorder, and fast phonons producing polaron self-trapping. The anomalously large splitting of the two major orthogonal excitonic transitions observed in the low temperature FL spectra of LH2 was attributed to a modulation of the coupling strength in the B850 ring that was asserted to be associated with an elliptical deformation of the LH2 ring (Bopp et al., 1999; van Oijen et al., 1999a; Mostovoy and Knoester, 2000; Ketelaars et al., 2001; Matsushita et al., 2001) (see also Section VI). III. Equilibration Dynamics The energy transfer dynamics within LH2 includes migration of localized excitations around the BChl 800 outer ring, superimposed on excitation transfer to the exciton states of the BChl 850 inner ring with subsequent equilibration in the B850 exciton manifold and the motion of the quasi-steady-state wavepacket (delocalized over 4–6 BChls) around the B850 inner ring (see Sundström et al., 1999; Renger et al., 2001; Van Grondelle and Novoderezhkin, 2001, 2006 for reviews.). The dynamics within the B850 band was studied by fs FL up-conversion (Jimenez et al., 1996), relative measurements of the induced absorption changes (Novoderezhkin et al., 1999b, Kennis et al., 1996), polarized pump-probe (Nagarajan et al., 1996, 1999; Chachisvilis et al., 1997; Vulto et al., 1999), and photon-echo (Joo et al., 1996; Jimenez et al., 1997). Modeling has included the quantitative fitting of linear and nonlinear responses (Kühn and Sundström, 1997b; Novoderezhkin et al., 1999b, 2003; Brüggemann and May, 2004). The dynamics within the LH1 antenna are very similar to the equilibration dynamics within the B850 band of LH2. But due to its larger size the LH1 antenna is characterized by a more pronounced contribution to the absorption from higher exciton levels (k = ±2 and ±3) and this feature is responsible for the increased amplitude of the dynamic Stokes shift observed in LH1 as compared with LH2 (Monshouwer et al., 1998; Novoderezhkin and Van Gron-
239
delle, 2002). Another specific property of LH1 is the stronger coupling to some low-frequency vibrations, manifested as more pronounced oscillatory features in nonlinear responses due to vibrational coherences (Chachisvilis and Sundström, 1996; Monshouwer et al., 1998; Novoderezhkin et al., 2000). A. Exciton Relaxation and Dynamic Red-Shift The direct observation of excitation dynamics in the tightly packed ring-like aggregates of the LH1 and B850-LH2 antennae (including relaxation of the exciton states and migration of the quasi-steady-state exciton wavepacket) is possible by transient absorption studies via the ps/fs pump-probe technique. Such measurements have revealed the initial ultrafast (sub100 fs) relaxation in LH1/LH2 complexes followed by slower (ps) dynamics (Xiao et al., 1994; Visser et al., 1995, 1996; Nagarajan et al., 1996, 1999; Savikhin and Struve, 1996; Chachisvilis et al., 1997; Kennis et al., 1997a,b; Monshouwer et al., 1998; Vulto et al., 1999; Polívka et al., 2000; Book et al., 2001). Fast relaxation in such a system gives rise to specific TA dynamics typical of assemblies of excitonically coupled antenna pigments, but absent from isolated dimeric subunits and monomers. Thus, Visser et al. (1995) found pronounced TA dynamics for LH1 of Rsp. rubrum with an 8–12 nm red-shift reflecting fast exciton equilibration, whereas no dynamic red-shift was found in the lowest-state absorption band of either the B820 dimeric subunit or for monomeric BChl. Short-pulse (35–50 fs) pump-probe studies of LH1 and LH2 of Rhodobacter (Rba.) sphaeroides (Nagarajan et al., 1996, 1999; Chachisvilis et al., 1997; Vulto et al., 1999) showed relaxation components in the 10–100 fs range; short-lived <20 fs components appear when tuning the wavelength to the blue (Chachisvilis et al., 1997). Selective excitation with longer pulses at the blue side of the LH2 absorption resulted in a dynamic red-shift of the TA spectrum by 3–5 nm with a time constant of 80–110 fs (Nagarajan et al., 1999; Vulto et al., 1999). This shift (attributed to relaxation from higher to lower exciton levels) was almost absent upon red excitation. Upon blue-side excitation of the LH1 of Blastochloris (Blc.) viridis (formerly Rhodopseudomonas viridis) a dynamic red-shift was observed with a time constant of 130–150 fs accompanied by a decay of the TA anisotropy with a similar time constant of about 150 fs (Monshouwer et al., 1998). The amplitude of this red-shift (15–20 nm) is several times larger than
240
Rienk van Grondelle and Vladimir I. Novoderezhkin
Fig. 3. (A). Dynamics of the TA spectrum measured upon 1017 nm excitation of the LH1 of Blc. viridis at 77K (Monshouwer et al., 1998). (B). Measured (points) and calculated (solid lines) red-shift of the TA spectrum between 0 and 400 fs upon 1017 nm excitation of the LH1 of Blc. viridis at 77K (Novoderezhkin and van Grondelle, 2002). (C). Measured (points) and modeled (solid line) TA kinetics at 1050 nm traces upon 1055 nm excitation of the LH1 of Blc. viridis at 77K (Novoderezhkin et al., 2000). See also Color Plate 4, Fig. 5.
in LH2 and is similar to that obtained for other LH1 antennae in earlier experiments (Xiao et al., 1994; Visser et al., 1995). Upon tuning the excitation wavelength to the middle of the band the amplitude of the dynamic red-shift was significantly reduced. At delays shorter than 400 fs the TA dynamics are determined mostly by a large dynamic red-shift due to fast exciton relaxation (Fig. 3A). These relaxation dynamics were explained quantitatively (Fig. 3B) using the Redfield relaxation theory and disordered exciton model, with uncorrelated diagonal disorder (Novoderezhkin and Van Grondelle, 2002). The relaxation-induced lifetimes of the higher exciton states have been calculated as 75, 41, 23, 17, and 12 fs for k = –1, 1, –2, 2, and –3, respectively. In the disordered exciton model the red-shift dynamics upon blue-side excitation are determined by relaxation from strongly allowed higher k = ±2 levels. Upon middleband excitation, corresponding to excitation of the k = ±1 levels, the red-shift is much less pronounced. Notice that for the models with correlated disorder (for instance due to elliptical deformations, correlated shift of the site energies, etc.) the absorption spectrum is determined mostly by the k = ±1 states, whereas the k = ±2 states remain forbidden (Mostovoy and Knoester, 2000; Matsushita et al., 2001; Rutkauskas
et al., 2005; Novoderezhkin et al., 2006). As a consequence these models predict that the shift towards the red of the TA upon blue excitation is almost the same as for middle-band excitation (Novoderezhkin and Van Grondelle, 2002), in contradiction of the experiment. B. Interplay of Excitonic and Vibrational Coherences Excitation dynamics in the ring-shaped antenna complexes LH1 and B850-LH2 studied in the subps to ps time range using fs pump-probe, transient grating, FL upconversion and photon-echo spectroscopies revealed pronounced oscillatory features due to vibrational coherences (Chachisvilis et al., 1994, 1995; Bradforth et al., 1995; Chachisvilis and Sundström, 1996; Joo et al., 1996; Kumble et al., 1996, Jimenez et al., 1997, Monshouwer et al., 1998). These coherences were found to be more intense and more long-lived in LH1. Thus, experimental studies of the TA dynamics for the LH1 antenna of Blc. viridis (Monshouwer et al., 1998) revealed the coupling to two vibrational modes with frequencies of about 60 and 105 cm−1, which produce oscillations in the TA signals that persist for 1–1.5 ps with a surprisingly
Chapter 13
Spectroscopy and Dynamics of Excitation Transfer
large damping time constant (600-800 fs). This time significantly exceeds the time of exciton relaxation or hopping as determined by the ultrafast redshift of the difference absorption and by anisotropy decay. At short delays (<200 fs) the oscillatory features due to vibrational coherences have a smaller amplitude than the red-shift TA dynamics, while at longer delays (after exciton relaxation) the oscillations are clearly distinguishable. The wavelength-dependent oscillatory pattern was modeled using the Redfield theory in the basis of exciton-vibrational eigenstates (Novoderezhkin et al., 2000). The impulsive excitation of electronic levels coupled to specific nuclear modes creates a wavepacket in nuclear space (both in the ground state and in the one-exciton manifold). Coherent motion of the ground state wavepacket yields oscillations in the photobleaching (PB), whereas the excited state wavepacket produces similar oscillations (but with different phase) in the one-exciton stimulated emission and the one-to-two exciton absorption. Superposition of these three contributions results in a complex wavelength-dependent pattern of oscillations in the total TA signal that can be quantitatively reproduced by the model (Fig. 3C). The simultaneous fit of the TA traces upon different excitation/detection wavelengths yields precise estimates of the frequencies, coupling parameters, and damping constants of the nuclear modes. For details, see Novoderezhkin et al. (2000). It is important to note that the relaxation of the initially created exciton wavepacket within 150 fs (shown in Fig 3) does not shorten the long-lived (within 1–1.5 ps) coherent oscillations. However, further migration of the wavepacket along the circular antenna induces an additional decay of the vibrational coherences. The time constant of this decay estimated from a fit of the oscillatory patterns is τhop = 0.9–1.5 ps (Novoderezhkin et al., 2000) and this was interpreted as the effective time of migration over a distance comparable with the delocalization length. The latter is equal to 8 BChl molecules at 77 K (Novoderezhkin et al., 1999a; Novoderezhkin and Van Grondelle, 2002). Recall that at room temperature the delocalization length in LH1/LH2 is 4–6 BChls. The hopping time of the wavepacket in this case must be shorter than τhop = 0.9–1.5 ps as suggested by the 77 K data. For instance, modeling of the room-temperature single-molecule LH2 data (see Section IV) gave τhop = 350 fs.
241
IV. Competition of Intraband B800-800 and Interband B800-850 Energy Transfer in the Light-Harvesting 2 Complex Following the determination of the structure of the LH2 complex of Rps. acidophila considerable efforts have been made to build up a consistent picture of excitation energy transfer within the whole B800B850 complex. One of the most puzzling and intriguing questions is the interplay of intraband B800 → B800 and interband B800 → B850 energy transfers. This problem has been the subject of intense studies by hole burning spectroscopy (Van der Laan et al., 1990; Reddy et al., 1991; de Caro et al., 1994; Wu et al., 1996), pump-probe techniques (Hess et al., 1993, 1995; Joo et al., 1996; Monshouwer et al., 1995; Ma et al., 1997, 1998; Kennis et al., 1996, 1997a; Pullerits et al., 1997; Ihalainen et al., 2001; Wendling et al., 2003), three-pulse photon echo techniques (Salverda et al., 2000; Agarval et al., 2001) together with quantitative modeling of nonlinear responses (Novoderezhkin et al., 2003). New insight into the problem has been reached in a recent 2-D-photon echo study of the B800-820 complex (Zigmantas et al., 2006). A. Excitation-wavelength Dependent Decay of the B800 Band Typically pump-probe kinetics measured in the B800 band show a biexponential decay of the isotropic TA (Hess et al., 1993, 1995; Monshouwer et al., 1995; Kennis et al., 1996, 1997a; Ma et al., 1997, 1998; Pullerits et al., 1997; Ihalainen et al., 2001; Wendling et al., 2003). A slow component of 1.2–1.9 ps is taken to reflect the B800 → B850 transfer, whereas a fast phase of 0.3–0.8 ps has been assigned to the B800→ B800 hopping. The anisotropy decays with approximately the same (about 0.3–0.5 ps) time, thus lending support to the assignment of the fast component to intraband B800 → B800 transfer. Modeling of energy transfer within B800-B850 complexes was done using generalized Förster theory (Sumi, 1999; Mukai et al., 1999; Scholes and Fleming 2000; Jang et al., 2004) and Redfield theory (Kühn and Sundström, 1997a; Novoderezhkin et al., 2003). The generalized Förster approach allows the correct modeling of the transfer from B800 to the lower exciton states of the B850 band (due to the big energy gap between these bands — see Section I).
242 But intraband dynamics within the B800 and B850 bands should be described by Redfield theory. At first glance the B800 dynamics corresponds to the case of non-coherent migration of localized excitations. But due to the almost iso-energetic character of the excited states even weak coupling between them creates sizable excitonic coherences that should be taken into account in order to reproduce the spectra (Cheng and Silbey, 2006), pump-probe (Novoderezhkin et al., 2003) and 2-D photon echo kinetics (Zigmantas et al., 2006) observed within the B800 band. In the combined Förster-Redfield approach (Zigmantas et al., 2006) intra-B800 and intra-B850(B820) equilibration is described by modified Redfield, whereas B800-B850(B820) transfer is calculated using generalized Förster. However, in such an approach, the resonant mixing between the B800 states and the upper exciton levels of the B850 band (B850* states) is neglected. Modeling of the whole B800-850 dynamics with the Redfield theory (Novoderezhkin et al., 2003) allows the description of all types of transfers including dynamics of the coherences between one-exciton states. The latter is important for a correct interpretation of the assignment of the B800 → B800 dynamics (see below).
Rienk van Grondelle and Vladimir I. Novoderezhkin An example of one-color polarized TA kinetics measured for LH2 of Rsp. molischianum at 77K (Wendling et al., 2003) and modeled with the Redfield theory (Novoderezhkin et al., 2003) is shown in Fig. 4. The isotropic kinetics (Fig 4A) slow down when tuning the excitation to the red side of the 800 nm band, but they become faster again in the red-most edge of the band. The anisotropy kinetics (Fig 4B) show a fast decay (from 0.42 to 0.2 with about 0.5 ps time constant) which is followed by a slower ps decay (from 0.2 to 0.1 between 1 and 8 ps delay). All these features are satisfactorily reproduced by a model taking into account all the excitonic interactions (including BChl 800-800 and BChl 850-800 couplings), site inhomogeneity (which mix the forbidden B850* states near 800 nm with the B800 states), and the full Redfield relaxation tensor (including relaxation of one-exciton populations and coherences between one-exciton states as well as non-secular terms, like coherence transfer). From this model a detailed picture of the energy transfer pathways in LH2 complex has emerged as shown in Fig. 4C; for more details, see Novoderezhkin et al. (2003).
Fig. 4. (A). One-color isotropic (magic angle) pump-probe kinetics at 793, 797, 800, and 806 nm measured (points) and modeled (solid lines) for the LH2 antenna of Rsp. molischianum at 77K (Wendling et al., 2003; Novoderezhkin et al., 2003). The difference absorption values are normalized to the maximal bleaching amplitude (reached near zero delay) and inverted. (B). Fitting of the anisotropy kinetics measured at 797 nm for the LH2 antenna of Rsp. molischianum at 77 K (Wendling et al., 2003). Experimental data (points) are compared with the kinetics calculated using the non-secular Redfield theory (solid lines), in the secular approximation (dashed curve) and in the non-coherent limit (dotted curve) (Novoderezhkin et al., 2003). (C). The exciton energy level scheme and the averaged (over disorder and over levels within the corresponding subbands) relaxation time constants for LH2 at 77K (van Grondelle and Novoderezhkin, 2006). For simplicity each of the B800, B850* and B850 manifolds is represented by two levels corresponding to the blue and red side of the band. At the blue side of the B800 band two coherently excited levels are indicated.
Chapter 13
Spectroscopy and Dynamics of Excitation Transfer
B. Multiple Pathways of B800 to B850 Transfer According to this model excitation of the B800 band creates coherence between pairs of B800 states, which decays with a time constant of 0.3–0.5 ps. This is followed by a slow migration of the localized exciton around the BChl 800 ring with a time constant of 1–3 ps (depending on the relative energies of neighboring BChls). In the energy level diagram such a migration corresponds to the population of the lowest state of the B800 excited state manifold (as shown in Fig 4C). Besides direct B800 → B850 transfer there is an additional pathway for energy transfer from the outer to inner ring, i.e., transfer through the B850* band. The effectiveness of this channel is determined by fast (600–800 fs) B800 → B850* transfer, followed by even faster (60–200 fs) B850* → B850* and B850* → B850 relaxation. The relative contribution of the B800 → B850* → B850 pathway is equal (or at least comparable) to the contribution of the direct B800→ B850 transfer. Notice that fast back B850* → B800 transfer could in principle contribute to the fast anisotropy decay observed at 800 nm, but such a ‘detour’ pathway B800 → B850* → B800 (suggested in Wu et al., 1996; Kühn and Sundström, 1997a; Renger et al., 2001) is not significant due to the fast B850* → B850* and B850* → B850 relaxations. C. Origin of the B800 Anisotropy Decay The fast decay of one-exciton coherences in the B800 band is mirrored by the sub-ps anisotropy decay from 0.4 to 0.2 in the B800 pump-probe signals, whereas the slow migration produces a further ps depolarization from 0.2 to 0.1. Note that a calculation without including coherences (taking into account the population dynamics only) gives an initial TA anisotropy of about 0.2 which decays to 0.1 with a time constant of a few ps, thus reproducing the experimental anisotropy dynamics for delays larger than 1ps (Fig. 4B). Therefore we conclude that the fast anisotropy decay is not connected with any energy migration around the ring, as was thought for the past 10 years (Hess et al., 1993, 1995; Monshouwer et al., 1995; Kennis et al., 1996, 1997a; Ma et al., 1997, 1998; Pullerits et al., 1997; Ihalainen et al., 2001; Wendling et al., 2003). Actually, the real B800 → B800 population transfer is relatively slow, even slower than the B800 → B850 transfers (having a time constant of about 1 ps — see
243
Fig. 4), in agreement with the three-pulse-photonecho-peak-shift results (Salverda et al., 2000). V. Energy Trapping in the Core Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1 Complex A. Trapping Kinetics Energy trapping in RC-LH1 core complexes occurs with a time constant of τ = 60-80 ps for Rba. sphaeroides (Sebban et al., 1984; Borisov et al., 1985) and τ = 50–70 ps for Rsp. rubrum as revealed by FL (Borisov et al., 1985) and absorbance kinetics (Razjivin et al., 1982; Nuijs et al., 1985; Sundström et al., 1986) at room temperature. The probability of back transfer from the RC to the antenna (upon selective excitation of the RC’s absorption band at 800 nm) was estimated as η<10–20% for Chromatium minutissimum (Abdourakhmanov et al. 1989), η < 10–15% (Danielius and Razjivin, 1987) and η = 25% (Timpmann et al., 1993) for Rsp. rubrum, η = 15% for Rba. capsulatus (Xiao et al., 1994), and η<10% for Blc. viridis (Otte et al., 1993). Analysis of the kinetics in the 77–300 K range (Visscher et al., 1989; Bergström et al., 1989; Beekman et al., 1994) showed that the trapping is limited by slow antenna-RC transfer and can be considered as almost single-step hopping from the antenna with a time constant of about 50 ps and with a small probability of back transfer, the ‘transfer-to-the-trap-limited’ model (Somsen et al, 1996). This hopping occurs to the special pair of the RC, whose lowest exciton level is in resonance with the long-wavelength absorption band of LH1 (peaking at 870 nm for Rsp. rubrum and Rba. sphaeroides, and 1015 nm for Blc. viridis). B. Exciton Control of Antenna-Reaction Center Transfer Rates Large distances between the antenna BChls and the special pair, i.e., 4–5 nm, correspond to a very slow hopping time (about 300 ps) if the excitation is assumed to be localized on one BChl of the antenna (Novoderezhkin and Razjivin, 1996). The experimental value of 50 ps can only be reproduced using the generalized Förster theory taking into account the delocalized character of excitations in the antenna (Novoderezhkin and Razjivin, 1994, 1996). It can be shown that the matrix element connecting the k-th exciton level of the antenna and the RC’s special pair
244 (given by Eq. (6)) is proportional to the dipole strength of the exciton level, d2k if the special pair is located in the center of the ring (Novoderezhkin and Razjivin, 1994). This yields an enhancement of the trapping rate of the same magnitude as the superradiance of the lowest exciton levels. It is noteworthy that the temperature dependence of the antenna-RC trapping rate and the antenna superradiance are similar, i.e., both are almost temperature independent (Visscher et al., 1989; Monshouwer et al., 1997). The trapping length (i.e., the increase in trapping rate relative to the completely localized limit) should be close to the thermally averaged superradiance length estimated as 3.8 BChls for LH1 at room temperature (Monshouwer et al., 1997). In fact the trapping length is slightly larger (about 5–6 BChls) due to a better overlap of the special pair lowest excitonic level with the emission from the higher k = ±1 states of the antenna. Upon cooling to ultralow temperatures the trapping becomes extremely heterogeneous and very dependent on the particular realization of the disorder for each RC-LH1 core (Somsen et al., 1994). This is connected with a big spread of delocalization lengths of the lowest exciton level induced by the disorder (Fig. 2). C. Detrapping Efficiency In the exciton model the interaction of the RC with the antenna is mostly determined by its interaction with the three lowest exciton levels, i.e., k = 0 and k = ±1. This can be interpreted as an interaction with three ‘supermolecules’ having anomalously large dipole moments. The effectiveness of back transfer is then roughly three times faster than the direct 50 ps hopping, i.e., about 17 ps (Novoderezhkin and Razjivin, 1994). Bearing in mind that the rate of charge separation in the RC is 3 ps (Martin et al., 1986) we obtain a detrapping efficiency of about 3/17, i.e., a bit less than the experimentally measured value of 0.2. Notice that assuming localization of the excitation at one of the N = 30–32 sites would give approximately N-times faster detrapping, corresponding to a much higher probability of escape. VI. Slow Conformational Motions and Excitation Dynamics in the B850-LightHarvesting 2 Complex Studies of excitation dynamics with conventional
Rienk van Grondelle and Vladimir I. Novoderezhkin bulk spectroscopies, although sensitive to details of the dynamics on the fs time scale, are restricted to averaging over disorder (i.e., over a large number of complexes in different conformational states). Contemporary single molecule techniques do not have fs/ps time resolution, but allow a direct visualization of the conformational changes of individual complexes (through their spectral signatures) on a ms/s time scale. Based on low- and room-temperature single molecule experiments it has been proposed that the LH2 ring can deviate from the ideal circular structure (Bopp et al., 1999; Van Oijen et al., 1999a, Ketelaars et al., 2001). The anomalously large splitting of the two major orthogonal excitonic transitions of the B850 band observed in low-temperature polarized FL excitation spectra was accounted for by introducing correlated shifts of the site energies and/or interaction energies (induced by elliptical deformation) and reducing the amount of uncorrelated disorder (Van Oijen et al., 1999a; Mostovoy and Knoester, 2000; Matsushita et al., 2001). On the other hand, the changes in the FL profile related to the abrupt movements of the FL peak observed at ambient temperatures (Rutkauskas et al., 2004, 2005, 2006) strongly suggest a large value of the uncorrelated disorder in LH2. Modeling based on the modified Redfield theory and the disordered exciton model (Novoderezhkin et al., 2006) allowed a quantitative explanation of the observed spectral fluctuations. The model suggested an evolution of an individual LH2 complex through a number of conformational sub-states with specific disorder patterns producing different types of emission profiles, each corresponding to a different regime of the excitation dynamics. A. Dynamics of Conformational Changes Figure 5A shows time-dependent fluctuations of the FL peak position measured at room temperature for a single LH2 complex (Rutkauskas et al., 2005). On a time scale of seconds the system undergoes a lot of FL peak fluctuations within the 865-875 nm range superimposed with rare large jumps to the blue (855860 nm) and also rare and even larger jumps to the red (up to 900–910 nm). Typically these large jumps produce relatively long-lived states perturbed by fast 2–3 nm fluctuations. The observed dynamics of these spectral shifts can be quantitatively reproduced by a multistate conformational model (Novoderezhkin et al., 2007),
Chapter 13
Spectroscopy and Dynamics of Excitation Transfer
245
Fig. 5. (A). Fluctuations of the FL peak position measured for a single LH2 complex of Rps. acidophila at room temperature (Rutkauskas et al., 2005). (B) Fluctuation of the FL peak calculated using a four-state conformational model (see text). To facilitate the comparison between experiment and model we selected a calculated fragment with a similar history as in the measured fragment. (C) Measured (points) and calculated (solid) fluorescence profiles corresponding to realizations with the peak positions in the range 859–861 nm (top), 869-871 nm (middle), and 889-891 nm (bottom). Calculated FL profiles are shown together with contributions of the three lowest exciton states (thin solid).
where the disorder of the site energies is modeled by assuming a finite number of conformational sub-states for each pigment and the conformational dynamics is then described by introducing phenomenological transfer rates between these sub-states. The relative values of rate constants are adjusted in order to approximate the continuous Gaussian distribution of the site energies used in the disordered exciton model. The simplest discrete model includes just two states i.e., two conformations for each pigment of the complex with different electronic transition energies (Valkunas et al., 2007). The two-state model explains the fast small-size (±10 nm) fluctuations within 860880 nm. Larger-sized jumps (especially 15–35 nm jumps to the red) clearly present in the experimental data can only be reproduced by adding one more pair of conformational states, with one state to the red and one state to the blue. Dynamics calculated with this simple four-state model, shown in Fig. 5B, (Novoderezhkin et al., 2007) display the same character of fluctuations as in the measured trace, suggesting that indeed fluctuations in only a few structural coordinates (i.e., two coordinates responsible for the small and large energy shifts, respectively) in large part determine the experimentally observed disorder.
B. Fluctuations of Spectral Shapes in a Single Complex It is important to note that large spectral shifts (Fig. 5A) are accompanied by changes in spectral shapes. Fig. 5C shows averages of FL profiles with a blue-shifted (859–861 nm), intermediate (869–871 nm), and red-shifted (889–891 nm) peak position. Red-shifted single molecule emission profiles on the average are significantly broadened and have a specific shape with a broader short-wavelength wing. Spectra with intermediate and blue-shifted peak positions feature regular FL asymmetry, i.e., a broader long-wavelength tail. Notice that blue-shifted spectra are also broader than those having an intermediate peak position. The observed spectral changes can be reproduced by calculating the line shapes with the modified Redfield theory (Fig. 5C). Remarkably, the data can be quantitatively fitted by using a discrete (four-state) distribution of the site energies or the continuous Gaussian distribution. The modeling revealed that the spectra of the three classes of realizations (shown in Fig. 5) correspond to three different types of exciton structure characterized by different relative positions, line shapes, and delocalization of the lowest exciton components k = 0, k = −1, and k = 1. The exciton states in the blue-shifted realizations are not significantly destroyed by the
246 disorder. As a result in this case the exciton structure is also not too different from that of the homogeneous ring, i.e., most of the dipole strength is concentrated in two degenerate levels (k = ±1), whereas the lowest state (k = 0) is almost forbidden due to the symmetry of the ring. The room-temperature emission originates mostly from the degenerate k = ±1 pair giving rise to a blue-shifted and broadened FL. FL profiles with intermediate peak positions result from realizations with stronger static disorder. This situation gives rise to an increase in splitting between the exciton levels and a more localized character of the exciton states. The red-shifted and more localized k = 0 state also becomes more radiant, borrowing some of the dipole strength from higher levels, and as a result its contribution to the FL profile becomes more significant. For the red-shifted FL profiles the exciton structure is very strongly affected by the disorder, which causes a large splitting between the energy levels, in particular, the splitting between the k = ±1 and the lowest k = 0 state has increased significantly (as compared with the blue-shifted and intermediate spectral profiles). Due to this large splitting between excitonic energy levels most of the FL originates from the lowest state, which is now strongly allowed and red-shifted. Its localized character gives rise to an increase in the effective phonon coupling. Such increased coupling results in a broadening of the FL profile together with an additional red-shift. It is important to note that the shape of the FL profile with intermediate and red-shifted peak position is largely determined by the shift and broadening of the k = 0 level, a feature that is the key property of the disordered ring and which is absent in the case of correlated disorder (where the k = 0 state is almost forbidden). For instance, the model with elliptical deformation and only a limited amount of uncorrelated disorder yields only a small shift of the spectrum and no significant change of its shape (Novoderezhkin et al., 2006). The increased splitting between the levels accompanied by enhanced phonon coupling is the origin of the increasingly larger broadening of the FL spectra in red-shifted realizations. The increased width of the blue-shifted FL spectra is due to another line broadening factor namely exciton relaxation. For the blue-shifted realizations a significant part of the emission originates from the higher k = ±1 levels, but due to predominant downhill relaxation the inverse lifetime increases for these higher levels. Thus the
Rienk van Grondelle and Vladimir I. Novoderezhkin more pronounced relaxation broadening of the k = ±1 levels causes the larger width of the blue-shifted FL spectra. C. Exciton Dynamics in the Different Conformational States The dynamics of the exciton wavepacket given by the time evolution of the density matrix in the site representation shows three different regimes corresponding to the three types of realizations (Fig. 6). Dynamics calculated for the blue realization shows a wavelike motion of the wavepacket delocalized over 4–5 molecules around the ring. (Notice that the delocalization length of the wavepacket is less than Ndel = 11 for the individual wavefunctions). The initially created wavepacket has its maximum at n = 15–16 (see Fig. 6) and in addition a smaller maximum at n = 2. The passage of the main maximum over half the ring occurs in 100 fs. At this point the main maximum collides with the second maximum moving in the opposite direction. For realizations with intermediate FL position the excitation is typically delocalized over a small group of pigments (in our example over sites n = 2–4 or n = 10–13). The dynamics are strongly reminiscent of hopping from one group of pigments to another with a time constant of about 350 fs. The wavelike motion is almost absent, but the signature of some wavelike flow of excitation density from one group to another can be observed to occur through the intermediate site n = 7. Due to strong disorder the wavelike motion is destroyed by scattering on impurities, producing many secondary waves moving in both directions. This results in a complicated non-uniform standing-wave pattern with oscillating populations at some sites (whereas other sites are almost not populated). Of course in an ensemble experiment a mixture of the wavelike motion and hopping-type dynamics will occur with typical time constants of 100 and 350 fs. These time constants will determine the experimentally observed dynamics for instance as reflected by the FL anisotropy decay. This estimation is in remarkable agreement with the observed bi-exponential FL anisotropy decay with 100 and 400 fs components in FL up-conversion experiments for LH1 (Bradforth et al., 1995) and the B850 ring of LH2 (Jimenez et al., 1996). The red-shifted realizations are created by a conformational change that causes a large red-shift (exceeding the interpigment coupling) at one site.
Chapter 13
Spectroscopy and Dynamics of Excitation Transfer
247
We conclude that the realizations of static disorder observed in single molecule experiments correspond to physically different limits of the excitation dynamics, i.e., coherent wavelike motion of a delocalized exciton (with a 100 fs pass over half the ring), hopping-type motion of the wavepacket (with 350 fs jumps between separated groups of 3–4 molecules), and self-trapping of the excitation that does not move from its localization site. VII. Concluding Remarks
Fig. 6. Coherent dynamics of the density matrix for a single LH2 complex, i.e., calculated without relaxation of populations and coherences for one realization of the disorder corresponding to a blue-shifted (top), an intermediate (middle), and a red-shifted (bottom) FL spectrum (Novoderezhkin et al., 2006). The initial population corresponds to the thermal equilibrium at room temperature (shown in the inserts); initial coherences have arbitrary fixed phases. The figure shows the diagonal elements of the density matrix in the site representation ρ(n,n) as a function of time. See also Color Plate 4, Fig. 6.
This produces the localization of excitation at this site (in our example at the n = 4 site) without any hopping to one of the other sites. But there is still some oscillatory modulation of the n = 4 population due to small coherences between the n = 4 and neighboring sites.
We show that nonlinear spectroscopy in combination with modeling based on high-resolution structures have unveiled the pathways of energy transfer in the bacterial antenna complexes LH1/LH2. In these complexes strongly coupled clusters of light-harvesting pigments are present together with weakly coupled aggregates, giving rise to a complicated interplay of interband conversion and intraband dynamics including fast exciton relaxation and slow migration. Obviously, the traditional Förster theory for excitation energy transfer among weakly coupled chromophores does not work in this case. We demonstrate that a self-consistent description of the dynamics and the spectroscopy can be obtained with the modified Redfield approach, where arbitrary delocalization and arbitrary strong coupling to phonons (at least for diagonal exciton-phonon coupling) are included explicitly. A combination of increasingly realistic physics with new experimental results provides a unique opportunity to reveal the exact nature of elementary events and their interplay in the total excitation dynamics using global systematic modeling. We show examples of simultaneous quantitative fits of the steady-state spectra and nonlinear kinetics for the complexes under study. To make the analysis more critical to the parameter choice it is important to use a simultaneous fit of the data obtained by several complementary nonlinear spectroscopic techniques reflecting different aspects of the dynamic behavior of the system (time- and frequency-domain techniques, pump-probe and photon echo, measurements of isotropic kinetics and anisotropy decays, etc.). For these complex systems such an approach reveals limitations (or even complete failure) of qualitative pictures based on fragmentary fittings. Besides establishing the unperturbed site energies, it is important to know the statistics of their random
248 shifts induced by slow conformations. These shifts can have dramatic effects on the excitation dynamics. To obtain an insight into the origins of the energetic disorder it is useful to combine the bulk (ensembleaveraged) spectroscopies with the single-molecule studies. The parameters of the antenna determined by the modeling allow us to determine the pathways and timescales of energy transfer and a visualization of the excitation dynamics, thus leading to a consistent physical picture of how photosynthetic pigment-proteins perform their function in storing solar energy. In this way nature has taught us how to construct a successful artificial light-harvesting sytem for future application in storing solar energy. Acknowledgments V. I. N. was supported by Russian Foundation for Basic Research (Grant 06-04-48917) and Dutch Foundation for Basic Research (NWO). References Abdurakhmanov IA, Danielius RV and Razjivin AP (1989) Efficiency of excitation trapping by reaction centers of complex B890 from Chromatium minutissimum. FEBS Letters 245: 47–50 Agarwal R, Yang M, Xu QH and Fleming GR (2001) Three pulse photon echo peak shift study of the B800 band of the LH2 complex of Rps. acidophila at room temperature: A coupled master equation and nonlinear optical response function approach. J Phys Chem B 105: 1887–1894 Alden RG, Johnson E, Nagarajan V, Parson WW, Law CJ and Cogdell RJ (1997) Calculation of spectroscopic properties of the LH2 bacteriochlorophyll-protein antenna complex of Rhodopseudomonas acidophila. J Phys Chem B 101: 4667–4680 Beekman LMP, Van Mourik F, Jones MR, Visser HM, Hunter CN and Van Grondelle R (1994) Trapping kinetics in mutants of the photosynthetic purple bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Influence of the charge separation rate and consequences for the rate-limiting step in the light-harvesting process. Biochemistry 33: 3143–3147 Beekman LMP, Frese RN, Fowler GJS, Picorel R, Cogdell RJ, Van Stokkum IHM, Hunter CN and Van Grondelle R (1997) Characterization of the light-harvesting antennas of photosynthetic purple bacteria by Stark spectroscopy. 2. LH2 complexes: Influence of the protein environment. J Phys Chem B 101: 7293–7301 Bergström H, Van Grondelle R and Sundström V (1989) Characterization of excitation energy trapping in photosynthetic purple bacteria at 77 K. FEBS Lett 250: 503–508 Book LD, Ostafin AE, Ponomarenko N, Norris JR and Scherer NF
Rienk van Grondelle and Vladimir I. Novoderezhkin (2000) Exciton delocalization and initial dephasing dynamics of purple bacterial LH2. J Phys Chem B 104: 8295–8307 Bopp MA, Jia Y, Li L, Cogdell RJ and Hochstrasser RM (1997) Fluorescence and photobleaching dynamics of single light-harvesting complexes. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 94: 10630–10635 Bopp MA, Sytnik A, Howard TD, Cogdell RJ and Hochstrasser RM (1999) The dynamics of structural deformations of immobilized single light-harvesting complexes. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 96: 11271–11276 Borisov AY, Freiberg AM, Godik VI, Rebane KK, and Timpmann KN (1985) Kinetics and picosecond bacteriochlorophyll fluorescence in vivo as a function of reaction center state. Biochim Biophys Acta 809: 221–229 Bradforth SE, Jimenez R, Van Mourik F, Van Grondelle R and Fleming GR (1995) Excitation transfer in the core light-harvesting complex (LH-1) of Rhodobacter sphaeroides: An ultrafast fluorescence depolarization and annihilation study. J Phys Chem 99: 16179–16191 Brüggemann B and May V (2004) Exciton exciton annihilation dynamics in chromophore complexes. II. Intensity dependent transient absorption of the LH2 antenna system. J Chem Phys 120: 2325–2336 Chachisvilis M and Sundström V (1996) Femtosecond vibrational dynamics and relaxation in the core light-harvesting complex of photosynthetic purple bacteria. Chem Phys Lett 261: 165–174 Chachisvilis M, Pullerits T, Jones MR, Hunter CN and Sundström V (1994) Vibrational dynamics in the light-harvesting complexes of the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Chem Phys Lett 224: 345–351 Chachisvilis M, Fidder H, Pullerits T and Sundström V (1995) Coherent nuclear motions in light-harvesting pigments and dye molecules, probed by ultrafast spectroscopy. J Raman Spectroscopy 26: 513–522 Chachisvilis M, Kühn O, Pullerits T and Sundström V (1997) Excitons in photosynthetic purple bacteria: Wavelike motion or incoherent hopping? J Phys Chem B 101: 7275–7283 Cheng YC and Silbey RJ (2006) Coherence in the B800 ring of purple bacteria LH2. Phys Rev Lett 96: 028103(1–4) Dahlbom M, Pullerits T, Mukamel S and Sundström V (2001) Exciton delocalization in the B850 light-harvesting complex: comparison of different measures. J Phys Chem B 105: 5515–5524 Damjanovic A, Kosztin I, Kleinekathoefer U and Schulten K (2002) Excitons in a photosynthetic light-harvesting system: A combined molecular dynamics, quantum chemistry, and polaron model study. Phys Rev E 65: 031919(1–24) Danielius RV and Razjivin AP (1987) New data on the state of excitations in the light-harvesting antenna and their trapping by reaction centers. In: Rudzikas Z, Piscarskas AS and Baltramiejunas R (eds) Ultrafast Phenomena in Spectroscopy, pp 231–239. Word Scientific, Singapore Davydov AS (1971) Theory of Molecular Excitons. Plenum Press, New York De Caro CD, Visschers RW, Van Grondelle R and Völker S (1994) Inter- and intraband energy transfer in LH2-antenna complexes of purple bacteria. A fluorescence line-narrowing and holeburning study. J Phys Chem 98: 10584–10590 Dracheva TV, Novoderezhkin VI and Razjivin AP (1995) Exciton theory of spectra and energy transfer in photosynthesis:
Chapter 13
Spectroscopy and Dynamics of Excitation Transfer
Spectral hole burning in the antenna of purple bacteria. Chem Phys 194: 223–235 Dracheva TV, Novoderezhkin VI and Razjivin AP (1996) Exciton delocalization in the antenna of purple bacteria: Exciton spectra calculation using X-ray data and experimental site inhomogeneity. FEBS Lett 378: 81–84 Dracheva TV, Novoderezhkin VI and Razjivin AP (1997) Exciton delocalization in the light-harvesting LH2 complex of photosynthetic purple bacteria. Photochem Photobiol 66: 141–146 Förster T (1965) Delocalized Excitation and Excitation Transfer. In Sinanoğlu (ed) Modern Quantum Chemistry, Part III. B. Action of Light and Organic Crystals, pp 93–137. Academic Press, New York. Freiberg A, Rätsep M, Timpmann K, Trinkunas G and Woodbury NW (2003) Self-trapped excitons in LH2 antenna complexes between 5 K and ambient temperature. J Phys Chem B 107: 11510–11519 Georgakopoulou S, Frese RN, Johnson E, Koolhaas MHC, Cogdell RJ, Van Grondelle R and Van der Zwan G (2002) Absorption and CD spectroscopy and modeling of various LH2 complexes from purple bacteria. Biophys J 82: 2184–2197 Gerken U, Jelezko F, Götze B, Branschädel M, Tietz C, Ghosh R and Wrachtrup J (2003a) Membrane environment reduces the accessible conformational space available to an integral membrane protein. J Phys Chem B 107: 338–343 Gerken U, Lupo D, Tietz C, Wrachtrup J and Ghosh R (2003b) Circular symmetry of the light-harvesting 1 complex from Rhodospirillum rubrum is not perturbed by interaction with the reaction center. Biochemistry 42: 10354–10360 Hess S, Feldchtein F, Babin A, Nurgaleev I, Pullerits T, Sergeev A and Sundström V (1993) Femtosecond energy transfer within the LH2 peripheral antenna of the photosynthetic purple bacteria Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Rhodopseudomonas palustris LL. Chem Phys Lett 216: 247–257 Hess S, Åkesson E, Cogdell RJ, Pullerits T and Sundström V (1995) Energy transfer in spectrally inhomogeneous lightharvesting pigment protein complexes of purple bacteria. Biophys J 69: 2211–2225 Hofmann C, Francia F, Venturoli G, Oesterhelt D and Köhler J (2003) Energy transfer in a single self-aggregated photosynthetic unit. FEBS Letters 546: 345–348 Hu X, Ritz T, Damjanović A and Shulten K (1997) Pigment organization and transfer of electronic excitation in the photosynthetic unit of purple bacteria. J Phys Chem B 101: 3854–3871 Hu X, Ritz T, Damjanović A, Autenrieth F and Schulten K (2002) Photosynthetic apparatus of purple bacteria. Q Rev Biophys 35: 1–62 Ihalainen JA, Linnanto J, Myllyperkiö P, Van Stokkum IHM, Ücker B, Scheer H and Korppi-Tommola JEI (2001) Energy transfer in LH2 of Rhodospirillum molischianum, studied by subpicosecond spectroscopy and configuration interaction exciton calculations. J Phys Chem B 105: 9849–9856 Jang S, Newton MD and Silbey RJ (2004) Multichromophoric Förster resonance energy transfer. Phys Rev Lett 92: 218301(1–4) Jimenez R, Dikshit SN, Bradforth SE and Fleming GR (1996) Electronic excitation transfer in the LH2 complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Phys Chem 100: 6825–6834 Jimenez R, Van Mourik F, Yu J-Y and Fleming GR (1997) Threepulse photon echo measurements on LH1 and LH2 complexes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides: A nonlinear spectroscopic probe
249
of energy transfer. J Phys Chem B 101: 7350–7359 Joo T, Jia Y, Yu J-Y, Jonas DM and Fleming GR (1996) Dynamics in isolated bacterial light harvesting antenna (LH2) of Rhodobacter sphaeroides at room temperature. J Phys Chem 100: 2399–2409 Karrasch S, Bullough PA and Ghosh R (1995) The 8.5 A projection map of the light-harvesting complex I from Rhodospirillum rubrum reveals a ring composed of 16 subunits. EMBO J 14: 631–638 Kennis JTM, Aartsma TJ and Amesz J (1994) Energy trapping in the purple bacteria Chromatium vinosum and Chromatium tepidum. Biochim Biophys Acta 1188: 278–286 Kennis JTM, Streltsov AM, Aartsma TJ, Nozava T and Amesz J (1996) Energy transfer and exciton coupling in isolated B800-850 complexes of the photosynthetic purple sulfur bacterium Chromatium tepidum. The effect of structural symmetry on bacteriochlorophyll excited states. J Phys Chem 100: 2438–2442 Kennis JTM, Streltsov AM, Vulto SIE, Aartsma TJ, Nozava T and Amesz J (1997a) Femtosecond dynamics in isolated LH2 complexes of various species of purple bacteria. J Phys Chem B 101: 7827–7834 Kennis JTM, Streltsov AM, Permentier H, Aartsma TJ and Amesz J (1997b) Exciton coherence and energy transfer in the LH2 complex of Rhodopseudomonas acidophila at low temperature. J Phys Chem B 101: 8369–8374 Ketelaars M, Van Oijen AM, Matsushita M, Köhler J, Schmidt J and Aartsma TJ (2001) Spectroscopy on the B850 band of individual light-harvesting 2 complexes of Rhodopseudomonas acidophila I. Experiments and Monte Carlo simulations. Biophys J 80: 1591–1603 Koepke J, Hu X, Muenke C, Schulten K and Michel H (1996) The crystal structure of the light-harvesting complex II (B800-850) from Rhodospirillum molischianum. Structure 4: 581–597 Koolhaas MHC, Van der Zwan G, Van Mourik F and Van Grondelle R (1997a) Spectroscopy and structure of bacteriochlorophyll dimers. I. Structural consequences of non-conservative CD spectra. Biophys J 72: 1828–1841 Koolhaas MHC, Van der Zwan G, Frese RN and Van Grondelle R (1997b) Red shift of the zero crossing in the CD spectra of the LH2 antenna complex of Rhodopseudomonas acidophila: A structure-based study. J Phys Chem B 101: 7262–7270 Koolhaas MHC, Frese RN, Fowler GJS, Bibby TS, Georgakopoulou S, Van der Zwan G, Hunter CN and Van Grondelle R (1998) Identification of the upper exciton component of the B850 bacteriochlorophylls of the LH2 antenna complex, using a B800-free mutant of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 37: 4693–4698 Koolhaas MHC, Van der Zwan G and Van Grondelle R (2000) Local and nonlocal contributions to the linear spectroscopy of light-harvesting antenna systems. J Phys Chem B 104: 4489–4502 Kühn O and Sundström V (1997a) Energy transfer and relaxation dynamics in light-harvesting antenna complexes of photosynthetic bacteria. J Phys Chem B 101: 3432–3440 Kühn O and Sundström V (1997b) Pump-probe spectroscopy of dissipative energy transfer dynamics in photosynthetic antenna complexes: A density matrix approach. J Chem Phys 107: 4154–4164 Kühn O, Sundström V and Pullerits T (2002) Fluorescence depolarization dynamics in the B850 complex of purple bacteria.
250 Chem Phys 275: 15–30 Kumble R, Palese S, Visschers RW, Dutton PL and Hochstrasser RM (1996) Ultrafast dynamics within the B820 subunit from the core (LH-1) antenna complex of Rs. rubrum. Chem Phys Lett 261: 396–404 Leupold D, Stiel H, Teuchner K, Novak F, Sandner W, Ucker B and Scheer H (1996) Size enhancement of transition dipoles to one- and two-exciton bands in a photosynthetic antenna. Phys Rev Lett 77: 4675–4678 Ma YZ, Cogdell RJ and Gillbro T (1997) Energy transfer and exciton annihilation in the B800–850 antenna complex of the photosynthetic purple bacterium Rhodopseudomonas acidophila (strain 10050). A femtosecond transient absorption study. J Phys Chem B 101: 1087–1095 Ma YZ, Cogdell RJ and Gillbro T (1998) Femtosecond energytransfer dynamics between bacteriochlorophylls in the B800820 antenna complex of the photosynthetic purple bacterium Rhodopseudomonas acidophila (Strain 7750). J Phys Chem B 102: 881–887 Martin J-L, Breton J, Hoff A, Migus A and Antonetti A (1986) Femtosecond spectroscopy of electron transfer in the reaction center of the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides R-26: Direct electron transfer from the dimeric bacteriochlorophyll primary donor to the bacteriopheophytin acceptor with a time constant of 2.8 ± 0.2 psec. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 83: 957–961 Matsushita M, Ketelaars M, Van Oijen AM, Köhler J, Aartsma TJ and Schmidt J (2001) Spectroscopy on the B850 band of individual light-harvesting 2 complexes of Rhodopseudomonas acidophila II. Exciton states of an elliptically deformed ring aggregate. Biophys J 80: 1604–1614 McDermott G, Prince SM, Freer AA, Hawthornthwaite-Lawless AM, Papiz MZ, Cogdell RJ and Isaacs NW (1995) Crystal structure of an integral membrane light-harvesting complex from photosynthetic bacteria. Nature 374: 517–521 Meier T, Zhao Y, Chernyak V and Mukamel S (1997a) Polarons, localization, and excitonic coherence in superradiance of biological antenna complexes. J Chem Phys 107: 3876–3893 Meier T, Chernyak V and Mukamel S (1997b) Femtosecond photon echoes in molecular aggregates. J Chem Phys 107: 8759–8774 Meier T, Chernyak V and Mukamel S (1997c) Multiple exciton coherence sizes in photosynthetic antenna complexes viewed by pump-probe spectroscopy. J Phys Chem B 101: 7332–7342 Monshouwer R, De Zarate IO, Van Mourik F and Van Grondelle R (1995) Low-intensity pump-probe spectroscopy on the B800 to B850 transfer in the light harvesting 2 complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Chem Phys Lett 246: 341–346 Monshouwer R, Abrahamsson M, Van Mourik F and Van Grondelle R (1997) Superradiance and exciton delocalization in bacterial photosynthetic light-harvesting systems. J Phys Chem B 101: 7241–7248 Monshouwer R, Baltuška A, Van Mourik F and Van Grondelle R (1998) Time-resolved absorption difference spectroscopy of the LH1 antenna of Rhodopseudomonas viridis. J Phys Chem A 102: 4360–4371 Mostovoy MV and Knoester J (2000) Statistics of optical spectra from single-ring aggregates and its application to LH2. J Phys Chem B 104: 12355–12364 Mukamel S (1995) Principles of Nonlinear Optical Spectroscopy. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Rienk van Grondelle and Vladimir I. Novoderezhkin Mukai K, Abe S and Sumi H (1999) Theory of rapid excitationenergy transfer from B800 to optically-forbidden exciton states of B850 in the antenna system LH2 of photosynthetic purple bacteria. J Phys Chem B 103: 6069–6102 Nagarajan V, Alden RG, Williams JC and Parson WW (1996) Ultrafast exciton relaxation in the B850 antenna complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 93: 13774–13779 Nagarajan V, Johnson ET, Williams JC and Parson WW (1999) Femtosecond pump-probe spectroscopy of the B850 antenna complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides at room temperature. J Phys Chem B 103: 2297–2309 Novoderezhkin VI and Razjivin AP (1993) Excitonic interactions in the light-harvesting antenna of photosynthetic purple bacteria and their influence on picosecond absorbance difference spectra. FEBS Lett 330: 5–7 Novoderezhkin VI and Razjivin AP (1994) Exciton states of the antenna and energy trapping by the reaction center. Photosynthesis Research 42: 9–15 Novoderezhkin VI and Razjivin AP (1995a) Exciton dynamics in circular aggregates: Application to antenna of photosynthetic purple bacteria. Biophys J 68: 1089–1100 Novoderezhkin VI and Razjivin AP (1995b) Excitation delocalization over the whole core antenna of photosynthetic purple bacteria evidenced by non-linear pump-probe spectroscopy. FEBS Lett 368: 370–372 Novoderezhkin VI and Razjivin AP (1996) The theory of Förstertype migration between clusters of strongly interacting molecules: application to light-harvesting complexes of purple bacteria. Chem Phys 211: 203–214 Novoderezhkin V and Van Grondelle R (2002) Exciton-vibrational relaxation and transient absorption dynamics in LH1 of Rhodopseudomonas viridis: A Redfield theory approach. J Phys Chem B 106: 6025–6037 Novoderezhkin V, Monshouwer R and Van Grondelle R (1999a) Disordered exciton model for the core light-harvesting antenna of Rhodopseudomonas viridis. Biophys J 77: 666–681 Novoderezhkin V, Monshouwer R and Van Grondelle R (1999b) Exciton (de)localization in the LH2 antenna of Rhodobacter sphaeroides as revealed by relative difference absorption measurements of the LH2 antenna and the B820 subunit. J Phys Chem B 103: 10540–10548 Novoderezhkin V, Monshouwer R and Van Grondelle R (2000) Electronic and vibrational coherence in the core light-harvesting antenna of Rhodopseudomonas viridis. J Phys Chem B 104: 12056–12071 Novoderezhkin V, Wendling M and Van Grondelle R (2003) Intraand interband transfers in the B800-B850 antenna of Rhodospirillum molischianum: Redfield theory modeling of polarized pump-probe kinetics. J Phys Chem B 107: 11534–11548 Novoderezhkin VI, Rutkauskas D and Van Grondelle R (2006) Dynamics of the emission spectrum of a single LH2 complex: Interplay of slow and fast nuclear motions. Biophys J 90: 2890–2902 Novoderezhkin VI, Rutkauskas D and Van Grondelle R (2007) Multistate conformational model of a single LH2 complex: Quantitative picture of time-dependent spectral fluctuations. Chem Phys 341: 45–56 Nuijs AM, Van Grondelle R, Joppe HLP, Van Bochove AC and Duysens LNM (1985) Singlet and triplet excited carotenoid and antenna bacteriochlorophyll of the photosynthetic purple
Chapter 13
Spectroscopy and Dynamics of Excitation Transfer
bacterium Rhodospirillum rubrum as studied by picosecond absorbance difference spectroscopy. Biochim Biophys Acta 810: 94–105 Otte SCM, Kleinherenbrink FAM and Amesz J (1993) Energy transfer between the reaction center and the antenna in purple bacteria Biochim Biophys Acta 1143: 84–90 Papiz MZ, Prince SM, Howard T, Cogdell RJ and Isaacs NW (2003) The structure and thermal motion of the B800-850 LH2 complex from Rps. acidophila at 2.0 Å resolution and 100 K: New structural features and functionally relevant motions. J Mol Biol 326: 1523–1538 Peterman EJG, Pullerits T, Van Grondelle R and Van Amerongen H (1997) Electron-phonon coupling and vibronic fine structure of light-harvesting complex II of green plants: Temperature dependent absorption and high-resolution fluorescence spectroscopy. J Phys Chem B 101: 4448–4457 Polívka T, Pullerits T, Herek JL and Sundström V (2000) Exciton relaxation and polaron formation in LH2 at low temperature. J Phys Chem B 104: 1088–1096 Pullerits T, Chachisvilis M and Sundström V (1996) Exciton delocalization length in the B850 antenna of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Phys Chem 100: 10787–10792 Razjivin AP, Danielius RV, Gadonas RA, Borisov AYu and Piskarskas AS (1982) The study of excitation transfer between light-harvesting antenna and reaction center in chromatophores from purple bacterium Rhodospirillum rubrum by selective picosecond spectroscopy. FEBS Lett 143: 40–44. Reddy NRS, Small GJ, Seibert M and Picorel R (1991) Energytransfer dynamics of the B800-B850 antenna complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides — a hole burning study. Chem Phys Lett 181: 391–399 Reddy NRS, Picorel R and Small GJ (1992) B896 and B870 components of the Rhodobacter sphaeroides antenna — a hole burning study. J Phys Chem 96: 6458–6464 Reddy NRS, Cogdell RJ, Zhao L and Small GJ (1993) Nonphotochemical hole burning of the B800-B850 antenna complex of Rhodopseudomonas acidophila. Photochem Photobiol 57: 35–39 Redfield AG (1965) The theory of relaxation processes. Adv Mag Res 1: 1–32 Renger Th, May V and Kühn O (2001) Ultrafast excitation energy transfer dynamics in photosynthetic pigment-protein complexes. Phys Rep 343: 137–254 Roszak AW, Howard TD, Southall J, Gardiner AT, Law KJ, Isaacs NW and Cogdell RJ (2003) Crystal structure of the RC-LH1 core complex from Rhodopseudomonas palustris. Science 302: 1969–1972 Rutkauskas D, Novoderezhkin V, Cogdell RJ and Van Grondelle R (2004) Fluorescence spectral fluctuations of single LH2 complexes from Rhodopseudomonas acidophila strain 10050. Biochemistry 43: 4431–4438 Rutkauskas D, Novoderezhkin V, Cogdell RJ and Van Grondelle R (2005) Fluorescence spectroscopy of conformational changes of single LH2 complexes. Biophys J 88: 422–435 Rutkauskas D, Novoderezhkin V, Gall A, Olsen J, Cogdell RJ, Hunter CN, Van Grondelle R (2006) Spectral trends in the fluorescence of single bacterial light-harvesting complexes: experiments and modified Redfield simulations. Biophys J 90: 2475–2485 Salverda JM, Van Mourik F, Van der Zwan G, and Van Grondelle
251
R (2000) Energy transfer in the B800 rings of the peripheral bacterial light-harvesting complexes of Rhodopseudomonas acidophila and Rhodospirillum molischianum studied with photon echo techniques. J Phys Chem B 104: 11395–11408 Sauer K, Cogdell RJ, Prince SM, Freer A, Isaacs NW and Scheer H (1996) Structure-based calculations of the optical spectra of the LH2 bacteriochlorophyll-protein complex from Rhodopseudomonas acidophila. Photochem Photobiol 64: 564–576 Savikhin S and Struve WS (1996) Temperature dependence of electronic energy transfer within B850 antennae of the NF57 mutant of purple bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Chem Phys 210: 91–100 Sebban P, Jolchine G and Moya I (1984) Spectra of fluorescence lifetime and intensity of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides at room and low temperature. Comparison between the wild type, the C71 reaction center-less mutant and the B800–850 pigmentprotein complex. Photochem Photobiol 39: 247–253 Scherz A and Parson WW (1984) Exciton interactions in dimers of bacteriochlorophyll and related molecules. Biochim Biophys Acta 766: 666–678 Scheuring S, Seguin J, Marco S, Levy D, Robert B and Rigaud JL (2003) Nanodissection and high-resolution imaging of the Rhodopseudomonas viridis photosynthetic core complex in native membranes by AFM. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 100: 1690–1693 Scholes GD and Fleming GR (2000) On the mechanism of light harvesting in purple bacteria: B800 to B850 energy transfer. J Phys Chem B 104: 1854–1868 Scholes GD, Gould IR, Cogdell RJ and Fleming GR (1999) Ab initio molecular orbital calculations of electronic couplings in the LH2 bacterial light-harvesting complex of Rps. acidophila. J Phys Chem B 103: 2543–2553 Somsen OJG, Van Mourik F, Van Grondelle R and Valkunas L (1994) Energy migration and trapping in a spectrally and spatially inhomogeneous light-harvesting antenna. Biophys J 66: 1580–1596 Somsen OJG, Van Grondelle R and Valkunas L (1996) A perturbed two-level model for exciton trapping in small photosynthetic systems. Biophys J 70: 669–683 Sumi H (1999) Theory on rates of excitation-energy transfer between molecular aggregates through distributed transition dipoles with application to the antenna system in bacterial photosynthesis. J Phys Chem B 103: 252–260 Sundström V, Van Grondelle R, Bergstrem H, Akesson E and Gilbro T (1986) Excitation energy transport in the BChl antenna systems of Rhodospirillum rubrum and Rhodobacter sphaeroides studied by low-intensity picosecond spectroscopy. Biochim Biophys Acta 851: 431–446 Sundström V, Pullerits T and Van Grondelle R (1999) Photosynthetic light-harvesting: Reconciling dynamics and structure of purple bacterial LH2 reveals function of photosynthetic unit. J Phys Chem B 103: 2327–2346 Tietz C, Chekhlov O, Dräbenstedt A, Schuster J and Wrachtrup J (1999) Spectroscopy on single light-harvesting complexes at low temperature. J Phys Chem B 103: 6328–6333 Timpmann KN, Zhang FG, Freiberg AM and Sundström V (1993) Detrapping of excitation energy from the reaction centre in the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodospirillum rubrum. Biochim Biophys Acta 1183: 185–193 Timpmann K, Rätsep M, Hunter CN and Freiberg A (2004)
252 Emitting excitonic polaron states in core LH1 and peripheral LH2 bacterial light-harvesting complexes. J Phys Chem B 108: 10581–10588 Tretiak S, Middleton C, Chernyak V and Mukamel S (2000a) Exciton Hamiltonian for the bacteriochlorophyll system in the LH2 antenna complex of purple bacteria. J Phys Chem B 104: 4519–4528 Tretiak S, Middleton C, Chernyak V and Mukamel S (2000b) Bacteriochlorophyll and carotenoid excitonic couplings in the LH2 system of purple bacteria. J Phys Chem B 104: 9540–9553 Valkunas L, Janušonis J, Rutkauskas D and Van Grondelle R (2007) Protein dynamics revealed in the excitonic spectra of single LH2 complexes. J Lumines 127: 269–275 Van Amerongen H, Valkunas L and Van Grondelle R (2000) Photosynthetic Excitons. World Scientific Publishers, Singapore Van der Laan H, Schmidt Th, Visschers RW, Visscher KJ, Van Grondelle R and Völker S (1990) Energy transfer in the B800–850 antenna complex of purple bacteria Rhodobacter sphaeroides: A study by spectral hole-burning. Chem Phys Lett 170: 231–238 Van Grondelle R and Novoderezhkin V (2001) Dynamics of excitation energy transfer in the LH1 and LH2 light-harvesting complexes of photosynthetic bacteria. Biochemistry 40: 15057–15068 Van Grondelle R and Novoderezhkin V (2006) Energy transfer in photosynthesis: Experimental insights and quantitative models. Phys Chem Chem Phys 8: 793–807 Van Grondelle R, Dekker JP, Gillbro T and Sundström V (1994) Energy transfer and trapping in photosynthesis. Biochim Biophys Acta 1187: 1–65 Van Mourik F, Visschers RW and Van Grondelle R (1992) Energy transfer and aggregate size effects in the inhomogeneously broadened core light-harvesting complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Chem Phys Lett 193: 1–7 Van Oijen AM, Ketelaars M, Köhler J, Aartsma TJ and Schmidt J (1998) Spectroscopy of single light-harvesting complexes from purple photosynthetic bacteria at 1.2 K. J Phys Chem B 102: 9363–9366 Van Oijen AM, Ketelaars M, Köhler J, Aartsma TJ and Schmidt J (1999a) Unraveling the electronic structure of individual photosynthetic pigment-protein complexes. Science 285: 400–402 Van Oijen AM, Ketelaars M, Köhler J, Aartsma TJ and Schmidt J (1999b) Spectroscopy of individual LH2 complexes of Rhodopseudomonas acidophila: Localized excitations in the B800 band. Chem Phys 247: 53–60 Visscher KJ, Bergström H, Sundström V, Hunter CN and Van Grondelle R (1989) Temperature dependence of energy transfer from the long wavelength antenna BChl-896 to the reaction center in Rhodospirillum rubrum, Rhodobacter sphaeroides (w.t. and M21 mutant) from 77 to 177 K, studied by picosecond absorption spectroscopy. Photosynth Res 22: 211–217
Rienk van Grondelle and Vladimir I. Novoderezhkin Visschers RW, Germeroth L, Michel H, Monshouwer R and Van Grondelle R (1995) Spectroscopic properties of the lightharvesting complexes from Rhodospirillum molischianum. Biochim Biophys Acta 1230: 147–154 Visser HM, Somsen OJG, Van Mourik F, Lin S, Van Stokkum IHM and Van Grondelle R (1995) Direct observation of sub-picosecond equilibration of excitation energy in the light-harvesting antenna of Rhodospirillum rubrum. Biophys J 69: 1083–1099 Visser HM, Somsen OJG, Van Mourik F, Lin S, Van Stokkum IHM and Van Grondelle R (1996) Excited-state energy equilibration via subpicosecond energy transfer within the inhomogeneously broadened light-harvesting antenna of LH-1-only Rhodobacter sphaeroides mutants M2192 at room temperature and 4.2 K. J Phys Chem 100: 18859–18867 Vulto SIE, Kennis JTM, Streltsov AM, Amesz J and Aartsma TJ (1999) Energy relaxation within the B850 absorption band of the isolated light-harvesting complex LH2 from Rhodopseudomonas acidophila at low temperature. J Phys Chem B 103: 878–883 Wendling M, Van Mourik F, Van Stokkum IHM, Salverda JM, Michel H and Van Grondelle R (2003) Low-intensity pumpprobe measurements on the B800 band of Rhodospirillum molischianum. Biophys J 84: 440–449 Wu H-M, Savikhin S, Reddy NRS, Jankowiak R, Cogdell RJ and Small GJ (1996) Femtosecond and hole-burning studies of B800’s excitation energy relaxation dynamics in the LH2 antenna complex of Rhodopseudomonas acidophila (strain 10050). J Phys Chem 100: 12022–12033 Wu H-M, Reddy NRS and Small GJ (1997a) Direct observation and hole burning of the lowest exciton level (B870) of the LH2 antenna complex of Rhodopseudomonas acidophila (Strain 10050). J Phys Chem B 101: 651–656 Wu H-M, Ratsep M, Lee I-J, Cogdell RJ and Small GJ (1997b) Exciton level structure and energy disorder of the B850 ring of the LH2 antenna complex. J Phys Chem B 101: 7654–7663 Xiao W, Lin S, Taguchi AKW and Woodbury NW (1994) Femtosecond pump-probe analysis of energy and electron transfer in photosynthetic membranes of Rhodobacter capsulatus. Biochemistry 33: 8313–8322 Yang M and Fleming GR (2002) Influence of phonons on exciton transfer dynamics: Comparison of the Redfield, Förster, and modified Redfield equations. Chem Phys 275: 355–372 Zhang WM, Meier T, Chernyak V and Mukamel S (1998) Exciton-migration and three-pulse femtosecond optical spectroscopies of photosynthetic antenna complexes. J Chem Phys 108: 7763–7774 Zigmantas D, Read EL, Mančal T, Brixner T, Gardiner AT, Cogdell RJ and Fleming GR (2006) Two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy of the B800-820 light-harvesting complex. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 103: 12672–12677
Chapter 14 Organization and Assembly of Light-Harvesting Complexes in the Purple Bacterial Membrane James N. Sturgis Laboratoire d’Ingénierie des Systèmes Macromoléculaires, UPR 9027, Institute de Biologie Structurale et Microbiologie, CNRS, 31 Chemin Joseph Aiguier, 13402 Marseille, France
Robert A. Niederman* Department of Molecular Biology and Biochemistry, Rutgers University, 604 Allison Road, Nelson Biological Laboratories, Piscataway, NJ 08854-8082, U.S.A.
Summary .............................................................................................................................................................. 254 I. Introduction..................................................................................................................................................... 254 II. Themes and Variations — Structural Variability of Complexes in Native Membranes ................................... 255 A. Size Heterogeneity of the Light-Harvesting 2 Complex.................................................................... 255 B. Structural Variability in Reaction Center-Light-Harvesting 1 Core Complexes ................................ 255 III. Principles of Photosynthetic Unit Organization .............................................................................................. 257 A. Models for Organization Based Upon Spectroscopic Probes .......................................................... 257 B. Multiple Patterns of Organization as Revealed by Atomic Force Microscopy of Intact Intracytoplasmic Membranes ........................................................................................................... 258 1. Blastochloris viridis and Rhodospirillum rubrum ................................................................... 258 2. Rhodospirillum photometricum and Phaeospirillum molischianum ....................................... 259 3. Rhodobacter sphaeroides ..................................................................................................... 260 4. Rhodobacter blasticus ........................................................................................................... 261 5. Rhodopseudomonas palustris ............................................................................................... 261 6. Common Points Revealed by Atomic Force Microscopy Studies ........................................... 262 IV. Proposals for the Functional Organization of Photosynthetic Units ............................................................... 263 A. Supercomplexes............................................................................................................................... 263 B. Quinone Pools .................................................................................................................................. 264 C. Functional Importance of the Observed Organization...................................................................... 264 V. In Vivo Assembly of Light-Harvesting Complexes.......................................................................................... 267 A. Complex-Specific Assembly Factors ................................................................................................ 268 B. General Membrane Assembly Factors ............................................................................................. 268 VI. Perspectives for the Next Ten Years.............................................................................................................. 269 References ........................................................................................................................................................... 270
*Author for correspondence, email: [email protected]
C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty (eds): The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria, pp. 253–273. © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V.
254
James N. Sturgis and Robert A. Niederman
Summary Recent in situ surface images of the intracytoplasmic membrane (ICM) of purple photosynthetic bacteria obtained at submolecular resolution by atomic force microscopy (AFM), have revealed multiple, species-dependent patterns of supramolecular organizations for their light-harvesting (LH) antennas, suggested earlier from spectroscopic studies. These have varied from highly ordered linear arrays of dimeric reaction center-lightharvesting 1-PufX (RC-LH1-PufX) core complexes in Rhodobacter (Rba.) sphaeroides, with the peripheral LH2 antenna either interspersed between them or arranged in larger clusters, to a less orderly arrangement found in several other purple bacteria, in which randomly organized, monomeric RC-LH1-enriched domains co-exist with large, paracrystalline hexagonally packed LH2 domains. In addition, regions with apparently crystalline core complexes were observed in Rhodopseudomonas (Rps.) palustris, along with a protein-free lipid bilayer. Likely bases for the absence of the ATP synthase and cytochrome bc1 complex from the AFM topographs are discussed, including the possibility that they localize at the poles of ICM vesicles either out of view of flat regions imaged by AFM, or are removed during membrane preparation. We also discuss how the observed arrangements of LH2 and core complexes may specifically control quinol escape from the RC, emphasizing the importance of short-range diffusion within the disordered regions of the membrane in promoting the passage of quinone, and how this process may be augmented by quinone exclusion from large, ordered fields of the LH2 antenna. Possible forces that drive in vitro autoassembly of LH complexes are assessed along with the roles that complex-specific and general membrane assembly factors may play in driving the assembly and organization of photosynthetic units within the cell. Finally, we address likely perspectives for further studies on the organization and assembly of bacterial antenna complexes over the next decade. I. Introduction It was just over ten years ago that the last volume on the anoxygenic photosynthetic bacteria appeared (Blankenship et al., 1995), and since that time, an explosive growth in research on the purple bacterial LH complexes has occurred. Much of this progress stems directly from the X-ray structure of the peripheral LH2 complex of Rps. acidophila by McDermott et al. (1995), reported during the same year. As the first atomic-resolution structure to emerge for any integral membrane light-harvesting complex, this represented a major landmark in photosynthesis research. In addition, the cryo-electron microscopy studies of Karrasch et al. (1995), which appeared earlier that year, gave rise to an 8.5 Å projection map of the reconstituted LH1 core complex of Rhodospirillum (Rsp.) rubrum. As a consequence of these seminal contributions, Abbreviations: 2-D – 2-dimensional; AFM – atomic force microscopy; bc1 complex – ubiquinol-cytochrome c2 oxidoreductase; BChl – bacteriochlorophyll a; Blc. – Blastochloris; BP – bacteriophytochrome; CM – cytoplasmic membrane; E. – Eschericha; ICM – intracytoplasmic membrane; LD – linear dichroism; LH – light-harvesting; LH1 – core light-harvesting complex; LH2 – peripheral light-harvesting complex; Phs. – Phaeospirillum; PS II – Photosystem II; PSU – photosynthetic unit consisting of LH1-reaction center core structures with LH2 arranged at their peripheries; Rba. – Rhodobacter; RC – reaction center; Rps. – Rhodopseudomonas; Rsp. – Rhodospirillum
extensive efforts have focused on such aspects as the revisiting of LH2 and LH1 structure, the dynamics of intra- and inter-complex excitation energy transfer, structure-function relationships as assessed by spectroscopic and reconstitution techniques, and the modeling of photosynthetic unit (PSU) behavior (see Chapter 8, Gabrielsen et al.; Chapter 9, Bullough et al.; Chapter 10, Loach and Parkes-Loach; Chapter 11, Robert; Chapter 12, Frank and Polívka; Chapter 13, van Grondelle and Novoderezhkin; Chapter 15, Şener and Schulten). Such pioneering structural studies also laid the groundwork for the elucidation of the supramolecular organization of light-harvesting units in the native intracytoplasmic membrane (ICM), which is the subject of this chapter. Accordingly, we will consider the structural variability of the LH2 and LH1 complexes in native photosynthetic membranes, and the multiple patterns of organization of the PSU, consisting of LH2 and RC-LH1 complexes, that have been suggested from spectroscopic studies and visualized more recently by AFM. The basic physical principles that ultimately govern the observed organizations of these various pigment-protein complexes will be discussed, along with considerations on how they accommodate exciton trapping and excitation energy transfer, as well as the flow of reducing equivalents to and from the RC and to other components that catalyze light-driven
Chapter 14
In Situ Organization of Light-Harvesting Complexes
cyclic flow. In particular, we will discuss how the observed PSU arrangements may specifically control quinone diffusion and escape from the RC. Additional topics that will be addressed include the forces that drive the in vitro autoassembly of LH complexes, and how the PSU is assembled and organized in the cell. We conclude with perspectives for research on LH complexes over the next 10 years. II. Themes and Variations — Structural Variability of Complexes in Native Membranes The availability of crystallographic structures for the various LH components of the photosynthetic apparatus initially suggested that these integral membrane proteins exist in a fixed stoichiometry of heterodimeric subunits that do not undergo structural variability. However, it is becoming increasingly clear that considerable structural heterogeneity exists in the bacterial LH apparatus. This heterogeneity operates at various levels; thus we have now observed heterogeneity between species, between distinct products of gene families in the same species, and between individual complexes. The realization of the extent of this diversity is relatively new and covers both the peripheral LH2 complexes and the core complexes. A. Size Heterogeneity of the LightHarvesting 2 Complex The high-resolution structure of the LH2 antenna complex of Rps. acidophila, as resolved by X-ray crystallography, showed that it exists in a cyclic nonameric arrangement (McDermott et al., 1995), while a subsequent X-ray crystallographic analysis revealed that LH2 in Phaeospirillum (Phs.) molischianum (Koepke et al., 1996) exists as a cyclic octamer. Since these initial studies, many different peripheral antenna complexes have been studied in 2- and 3-D crystals and found to form either nonameric or octameric rings (Chapter 8, Gabrielsen et al.). There is thus a large body of evidence to suggest that while most LH2 complexes form nonameric rings, certain species are able to form smaller octameric complexes. Several studies have revealed a variability in the size of the different LH2 complexes produced by a single species. Thus, in Rps. palustris, where the peripheral antenna complexes that are synthesized depend on growth conditions, complexes isolated
255
from cells grown at very low light intensity were able to form crystals of an octameric complex designated as high-800 type LH2 (Hartigan et al., 2002), while recent AFM images of membranes from cells grown at higher light intensities showed predominantly nonameric LH2 (B800-850) complexes (Scheuring et al., 2006). It was thus a surprise to observe a variety of antenna ring sizes in an AFM analysis of native membranes of Rsp. photometricum (Fig. 1)(Scheuring et al., 2004a). The majority of LH2 antenna rings in the membrane were observed to be nonameric, with a diameter of 5.2 nm; however, considerable heterogeneity was shown to exist both in complex size (diameter) which varied between 3.8 nm and 8.8 nm, and in the number of subunits which appeared to vary from 7 to 14. While it was not possible to observe individual subunits in the rare complexes of most extreme size, individual subunits were observed in complexes made up of 8, 9 and 10 αβ pairs. As would be expected, this size heterogeneity appeared to be associated with spectral heterogeneity (Fig. 1), as first described for LH2 by Westerhuis et al. (1992), in which the absorption spectra of the smaller complexes are gradually blue shifted relative to those of the larger complexes. Thus, the above experimental results would seem to indicate that in some photosynthetic bacteria, the peripheral antenna forms rings of somewhat heterogeneous size, ranging from small rings of seven or even fewer αβ pairs up to large rings possibly containing a dozen or more αβ pairs. As also noted above, these rings appear to have slightly different spectral characteristics, as would be expected from the modified interchromophore coupling. Recently, free energy calculations (Janosi et al., 2006) suggest that although the fixed number of oligomers observed in the crystal structure are close to the lowest energy structures, the angular potential is relatively soft and thus little energy is required to modify the oligomeric size. These theoretical calculations would seem entirely consistent with the observed heterogeneity. B. Structural Variability in Reaction CenterLight-Harvesting 1 Core Complexes Over the past decade, as structural information began to emerge, it became apparent that considerable variability exists in the structures of RC-LH1 core complexes. The 8.5 Å projection map obtained from two-dimensional (2-D) crystals of the LH1 complex
256
James N. Sturgis and Robert A. Niederman
Fig. 1. Structural variability of LH2 complexes in the membrane. (a, b) high resolution AFM images of Rsp. photometricum photosynthetic membranes, showing large as indicated by arrow, (a) and mostly small (b) LH2 complexes in situ (scale bar 5 nm). (c) Class averages of LH2 complexes with 8, 9 and 10 heterodimeric αβ subunits. (d) Spectral and size heterogeneity of complexes solubilized from membranes by β-dodecylmaltoside and separated by gel filtration. The chromatogram traces, left hand scale, show that rechromatography of different fractions from the upper trace confirms a size difference, lower traces. The LH2 complexes also change the position of their main absorption band (right hand scale, and near straight line), as a function of their position in the chromatograph. See Scheuring et al. (2004a) for further details.
of Rsp. rubrum by Karrasch et al. (1995) revealed a closed ring of 16 apparent αβ heterodimers, sufficiently large to enclose the RC (Chapter 9, Bullough et al.). This was subsequently confirmed when these cryo-EM and image processing procedures were applied to the Rsp. rubrum RC-LH1 core complex (Jamieson et al., 2002). In contrast to this monomeric core structure, an EM analysis of negatively-stained tubular membranes from an LH2- strain of Rhodobacter (Rba.) sphaeroides by Jungas et al. (1999) suggested that this core complex is dimeric and consists of an open S-shaped assembly in which two RCs are surrounded by two C-shaped arcs of LH1 lacking several of the heterodimeric building blocks of the 16-membered ring structure. This basic proposal has been confirmed by the recent 8.5 Å projection structure, derived from 2-D crystals of the core RCLH1-PufX dimer of Rba. sphaeroides (Qian et al., 2005), in which 28 LH1 αβ heterodimers form an ellipsoidal, double lobed structure (14 αβ heterodimers per RC-LH1 monomer) that encloses the α-helices
of two RCs. The QB site of the RC is adjacent to the putative position of the PufX polypeptide, near the openings in each of the LH1 helical arrays. PufX, encoded by the pufX gene within the pufQBALMX operon (also encoding the β- and α-subunits of LH1 and the L- and M-subunits of the RC) has been established as an RC-LH1 core organizing protein (Frese et al., 2000, 2004), thought to facilitate ubiquinoneubiquinol exchange (Barz et al., 1995) through the gates in the dimeric core structure. A discussion of how these quinone redox species may be exchanged across the seemingly impenetrable barrier of α-helices, confronted in the closed LH1 ring-like structures, is presented below. Recent AFM topographs of photosynthetic membranes from a variety of purple bacteria (see Section III.B below for details) have shown that a dimeric RC-LH1 core structure also exists in Rba. blasticus (Scheuring et al., 2005a), while in Blastochloris (Blc.) viridis (Scheuring et al., 2003), Rsp. photometricum (Scheuring et al., 2004b), and Phs. molischianum
Chapter 14
In Situ Organization of Light-Harvesting Complexes
(Gonçalves et al., 2005), monomeric, closed elliptical assemblies of 16 LH1 αβ-heterodimers have been observed. In addition, X-ray crystallography has revealed that the Rps. palustris RC-LH1 core complex crystallizes as a monomeric, elliptical assembly, modeled with 15 LH1 transmembrane αβ-heterodimers, interrupted by the α-helix of polypeptide W, an apparent PufX homolog (Roszak et al., 2003). This monomeric core complex structure has been confirmed recently in an AFM study of photosynthetic membranes from Rps. palustris (Scheuring et al., 2006). III. Principles of Photosynthetic Unit Organization The organization of the photosynthetic apparatus in the membrane is governed by two different kinds of constraints. On the one hand, for efficient light harvesting, the RC must be functionally connected to both the LH1 and LH2 complexes, and they must be as close as possible to the RCs to ensure efficient light collection. On the other hand, the electron transfer chain requires an efficient quinol transfer from the RC to the cytochrome bc1 complex, capable of regenerating the quinone necessary for continued photosynthesis. These two different constraints both depend on migration within the plane of the photosynthetic membrane, either of excitation energy between LH complexes or of quinones/quinols between the RC and cytochrome bc1 complex. Various different solutions to these competing constraints, including the clustering of RCs, seem to have been adopted by different species. A. Models for Organization Based Upon Spectroscopic Probes Although in past years, the architecture of the ICM, as well as the localization of photosynthetic complexes, was extensively investigated by freeze-fracture electron microscopy (reviewed by Drews and Golecki, 1995), the different particles appearing in membrane fracture planes could not always be identified with certainty. In contrast, a variety of spectroscopic probes has provided sensitive techniques for assessing the distribution of functionally identified components of the PSU, from which it is possible to deduce their supramolecular organization. The reader is referred to the article by Parson and Nagarajan (2003) for a
257
more thorough description of the bases of these different techniques. Among the earliest application of laser-based probes to the elucidation of the structural organization of the photosynthetic apparatus was the examination of singlet-triplet quenching efficiencies in various strains of Rba. sphaeroides by Monger and Parson (1977). The results suggested that the LH1 complex is arranged in clusters that surround and interconnect several RCs, with LH2 positioned peripherally in large ‘lakes.’ Subsequently, singlet-singlet annihilation measurements have provided a procedure for quantitative refinement of this proposal, as well as estimates of the size and organization of antenna domains over which excitations can migrate in ICM vesicles (chromatophores) from a variety of photosynthetic bacteria (Bakker et al., 1983; Hunter et al., 1985; Vos et al., 1986; Deinum et al., 1989, 1991; Kramer et al., 1995). The results obtained at 4 K for Rba. sphaeroides by Vos et al. (1986) were explained by an arrangement in which ~4 RCs are embedded in core assemblies of ~100 LH1 BChl molecules, with LH2 BChls interspersed between them, similar to the arrangement now visualized directly by AFM in Rba. sphaeroides membranes (see Section III.B.3 below). At room temperature, thermal separation of the core clusters no longer exists, and many RCs become connected as a result of energy equilibration among >1000 BChls, again in accord with AFM images. It is also noteworthy that the rows of dimeric RC-LH1 complexes observed in AFM represent domains of LH1 BChls of a size similar to those calculated from singlet-singlet annihilation measurements (Vos et al., 1988) on membranes from a mutant lacking the LH2 complex, while the number of LH2 BChl molecules that were visualized between these rows of core complexes was also of the same order of magnitude as the connected LH2 BChl molecules deduced in excitation annihilation studies of LH2-only membranes. More recently, singlet-singlet annihilation measurements have been applied to the determination of the number of BChls remaining connected after dilution of membrane bilayer phospholipid by fusion of Rba. sphaeroides chromatophores with unilamellar liposomes (Westerhuis et al., 1998). Core assemblies, containing ~50 LH1 BChls, were dissociated into units of about half their original size, while LH2 clusters were apparently detached as single LH2 rings. These results suggest that efficient energy transfer in the membrane ultimately relies upon dense packing of the complexes, rather than on strong, specific
258 intermolecular associations, shown by these studies to be insufficiently robust to withstand bilayer dilution (discussed further in Section IV.C). Linear dichroism (LD) provides a method for direct determination of electronic transition-dipole moment orientations of selected chromophores, relative to the orientation axis of the interrogated sample. LD has thus proved to be a valuable spectroscopic probe for assessing the long-range pattern of structural organization existing within the ICM bilayer (Frese et al., 2000, 2004). Interestingly, this technique has been successfully employed to demonstrate that in Rba. sphaeroides, the PufX protein, known to be essential for dimerization of RC-LH1 core particles, and the exchange of ubiquinone redox species at the RC QB site, also induces a non-random orientation of the RC within the LH1 ring, and the alignment of all RC-LH1 cores in regular arrays. This effect was first demonstrated in membrane tubules from an RCLH1 core only strain (Frese et al., 2000), but has been extended more recently to wild-type membranes in which core arrays coexist with large domains of LH2 in the native ICM (Frese et al., 2004). B. Multiple Patterns of Organization as Revealed by Atomic Force Microscopy of Intact Intracytoplasmic Membranes In recent years, AFM has evolved into a powerful tool for obtaining surface images of membrane proteins at subnanometer resolution. Recent applications of this highly revealing structural probe to the native ICM of purple photosynthetic bacteria have provided the first in situ surface views of the supramolecular organization of any multicomponent biological membrane (reviewed by Scheuring et al., 2005b; Chapter 47, Scheuring). The earliest AFM topographs of bacterial LH complexes were obtained with the LH2 protein of Rubrivivax gelatinosus reconstituted into lipid bilayers as densely packed 2-D crystals (Scheuring et al., 2001). Although this permitted the identification of a nonameric LH2 ring structure along with membrane protruding domains, as well as the first subatomic glimpse of the LH1 rings which were present as a contaminant, recent direct AFM images of a variety of bacterial photosynthetic complexes in their native ICM environments (Fig. 2), have provided valuable structural information on their in situ oligomerization states and the intactness and flexibility of their ring-like structures, without the
James N. Sturgis and Robert A. Niederman need to resort to complicated purification, isolation and reconstitution procedures and the use of highly ordered 2-D crystals. 1. Blastochloris viridis and Rhodospirillum rubrum Blc. viridis and Rsp. rubrum represent purple photosynthetic bacteria with simplified PSUs that lack the LH2 complex. After membrane disruption, only relatively small chromatophores can be isolated from Blc. viridis, which necessitated their fusion by freezethaw cycles in order to obtain membrane preparations suitable for AFM imaging (Scheuring et al., 2003). Single RCs surrounded by a closed ellipsoid of 16 LH1 αβ-heterodimers were observed (Fig. 2a), from which the tetraheme cytochrome subunit could be nanodissected by applying a loading force to the AFM tip. This revealed that the underlying RC-L and -M subunits adopt a preferred asymmetric topography, arranged with a fixed distance distribution from the short ellipsis axis of the LH1 complex, which may represent an important constraint for energy transfer. Upon removal of the RC, the LH1 complex rearranges into a circular structure, and it was suggested that this flexible behavior could promote breathing motions that would serve to facilitate quinone/quinol passage through the normally closed LH1 structure (see Section IV.C). Although an AFM analysis of the RC-LH1 complex of Rsp. rubrum has thus far been confined to 2-D crystal of the purified core complex reconstituted into lipid bilayers, a closed ring of 16 αβ-heterodimers positioned around a central RC density has been consistently observed (Jamieson et al., 2002; Fotiadis et al., 2004). The latter study demonstrated that depending on packing constraints within the crystals, the LH1 ring is able assume a wide variety of architectures; however, their physiological importance awaits their direct AFM analysis in the Rsp. rubrum ICM. Such an in situ AFM analysis would also be of importance for understanding the arrangement of connected LH1 BChl domains in Rsp. rubrum as deduced from the singlet-singlet annihilation measurement of Vos et al. (1986). At 4 K, they were estimated to comprise ~150 BChls connecting 4 RCs, while at room temperature, an energy barrier is overcome, and the number of connected BChls was near 1,000, approaching the total number in a single chromatophore.
Chapter 14
In Situ Organization of Light-Harvesting Complexes
259
Fig. 2. Membrane organization observed in several species of purple photosynthetic bacteria by high-resolution AFM, as discussed in the text. a Blastochloris viridis, b Rhodospirillum photometricum, c Rhodobacter sphaeroides, d Rhodobacter blasticus, e and f Rhodopseudomonas palustris grown under low (e) and high (f) light intensities. In the different panels the scale bar represents 10 nm. In each panel typical monomeric (M) or dimeric (D) core complexes are indicated, and the smaller LH2 rings (2) in panels b – e. Note that in panel f, the RC-H subunit hides the details of the core complex structure.
2. Rhodospirillum photometricum and Phaeospirillum molischianum Imaging of complex membrane architectures at submolecular resolution using AFM has recently allowed the description of several new types of PSU organizations, in which the protein mixture is more complex and the organization less regular than in Blc. viridis. Among the first native multicomponent photosynthetic systems to be observed by AFM was that of Rsp. photometricum (Scheuring et al., 2004b), which unlike the closely related bacterium Rsp. rubrum, forms PSUs with an LH2 complex. Although the photosynthetic apparatus of Rsp. photometricum is localized in stacked, disk-like vesicular ICMs, sufficiently large for AFM analysis, in this study, they gave rise to chromatophore vesicles that did not collapse onto mica supports, requiring that the weakly attached upper membrane layer be removed by nanodissection with the AFM tip. This exposes the periplasmic ICM surface for direct AFM imaging. The initial observations made in this manner, as well as several subsequent ones made directly on native
membranes (Scheuring et al., 2004a; Scheuring and Sturgis 2005), showed an intriguing in situ organization of the different photosynthetic complexes (Fig. 2b). First, the main complexes observed were a monomeric oval core complex and a circular nonameric LH2 antenna complex, with no clear images of the cytochrome bc1 complex, despite the demonstration that this protein complex was present in the membrane preparations. Second, the proteins were very densely packed with an overall surface occupancy approaching 80% (Scheuring and Sturgis, 2006), posing serious questions about how such membranes might function. Third, and most unexpectedly, the proteins were not organized homogeneously, but rather they appeared to be distributed between RC-LH1-rich domains and nearly crystalline, hexagonally packed LH2 domains, again posing functional questions. The RC-LH1-rich and randomly organized domains were found to contain a constant proportion of about 3.5 LH2 complexes per core complex. A very similar organization was observed more recently in the closely related and more completely characterized bacterium, Phs. molischianum (Gonçalves et al., 2005). In particular, the membrane was
260 observed to contain a similar separation into two structurally different types of domains; paracrystalline, hexagonally packed LH2 domains, this time containing the octameric Phs. molischianum LH2, and mixed domains containing core complexes and a relatively small amount of LH2 (as in Rsp. photometricum, about 3.5 LH2 rings per core complex). Using the observed AFM images together with the known LH2 structure (Koepke et al., 1996), it was possible to precisely calculate the pigment distances between the neighboring complexes. The modulation of this organization in response to varying composition was examined in Rsp. photometricum (Scheuring and Sturgis, 2005); these observations have been extended more recently to Phs. molischianum (Gonçalves et al., 2005). In common with many photosynthetic bacteria, these species show a chromatic adaptation, varying their pigment composition in response to the environmental conditions (Cohen-Bazire et al., 1956). Surprisingly, modification of the membrane composition by addition of large quantities of LH2 does not simply dilute the core complexes, forcing them further apart. Instead the additional LH2 is added exclusively to the paracrystalline LH2 domains maintaining the original core connectivity with the disordered domains of mixed composition (Scheuring and Sturgis, 2005). This eutectic-type phase organization of the membrane is suggested to arise from the hierarchy of interactions between the different components and these essential features could be mimicked with a simple model. It has been suggested that this eutectic phase behavior is important for maintaining core complex-cytochrome bc1 connectivity (see below and Scheuring and Sturgis, 2006). 3. Rhodobacter sphaeroides Rba. sphaeroides is among the best characterized species of purple photosynthetic bacteria and has provided a unique combination of accessible molecular genetics with an ICM that is amenable to an unparalleled variety of biochemical, spectroscopic and ultrastructural probes. It was thus of considerable importance to study the native surface architecture of the otherwise well characterized Rba. sphaeroides ICM. In order to produce membrane fragments for AFM that adhered as a single layer to mica supports, it was necessary to pretreat isolated chromatophore vesicles with subsolubilizing amounts of the detergent
James N. Sturgis and Robert A. Niederman β-dodecyl maltoside. The resulting AFM topographs of these ICM fragments (Bahatyrova et al., 2004b) revealed a much more organized arrangement for the LH and RC components than that observed in other LH2-containing species (Fig. 2c). In these images, the central protruding feature within the RC-LH1 core complexes corresponded to the RC-H subunit, indicating that the cytoplasmic face of the ICM was uniformly exposed. In addition to the distinctive organization of ICM domains, crucial new features relating to the relative positions and functional associations of LH2, together with the core RC-LH1 complex, were also observed. Two types of organization were exhibited by the LH2 complex; in the first type, 10–20 molecules of LH2 formed light capture domains that interconnect linear arrays of mainly dimeric RC-LH1-PufX core complexes. In the second, LH2 existed as larger clusters in separate domains; these apparently represent the light-responsive LH2 complement as observed for Rsp. photometricum (Scheuring and Sturgis, 2005), which forms during chromatic adaptation to lowered light intensity. The close packing also observed in Rba. sphaeroides for the linear RC-LH1-PufX arrays, often separated by only narrow LH2 energy channels, demonstrates an elegant economy in photosynthetic membrane arrangement. The physical continuity between individual LH2 complexes and between LH2 and RC-LH1-PufX core dimers, assures that excitations are transferred from LH2 to LH1, and subsequently to the RC, to initiate the primary photochemical events. Moreover, the LH1 complex is ideally positioned to serve as a collection hub for excitations obtained from LH2, which are then rapidly transferred to the RC. The LH2 complexes situated between rows of RC-LH1-PufX dimers form a relatively invariant complement of pigment-protein complexes that optimally fulfill the basic requirement for efficient trapping and transmission of light energy (see also Chapter 15, Şener and Schulten). The RC-LH1-PufX core complexes are usually found in dimeric associations, arranged in rows of up to six dimers, such that an LH1 excitation can migrate along a series of dimers until an ‘open’ RC is found. These AFM images also explain why mutant cells lacking LH2 form elongated tubular membranes, which in freeze-fracture replicas showed a striking pattern of closely packed, highly ordered rows of dimeric particles arrayed helically along their entire length (Westerhuis et al., 2002); these particles were identified as open S-shaped assemblies of dimeric
Chapter 14
In Situ Organization of Light-Harvesting Complexes
261
RC-LH1-PufX complexes in an image analysis of isolated tubules after negative staining (Siebert et al., 2004). Because of the tilt of the RC-LH1-PufX complexes, it was not possible to visualize the PufX polypeptide in the AFM analysis of native ICM fragments, or to assess whether the LH1 ring is complete; however, as discussed above in Section II.B, definitive information on these structural parameters has been revealed by the recent 8.5 Å projection map of 2-D crystals of the Rba. sphaeroides core RC-LH1 dimer (Qian et al., 2005).
the forced flattening of normally curved membranes onto a flat support might modify the organization of components; however, for Rba. sphaeroides, LD measurements of oriented, untreated chromatophore preparations were consistent with the same type of organization for the LH2 and core complexes as that observed in AFM of the flat membrane patches (see Sections III.A and III.B.3 above), and further showed that this arrangement was extended over the entire chromatophore vesicle surface.
4. Rhodobacter blasticus
Recent AFM images obtained with native ICM preparations from Rps. palustris grown under different levels of illumination (Scheuring et al., 2006) clearly reflect the very versatile photosynthetic system formed by this species. Several unique organizations for the PSU components were revealed, as well as a number of similarities to arrangements described above, albeit in a novel context. Areas with mixed domains were most common under low illumination (Fig. 2e), along with crystalline peripheral antenna, while regions with apparently crystalline LH1-core complexes were observed under high illumination (Fig. 2f); a protein-free lipid bilayer was found under both light intensities. Interestingly, chromatic adaptation resulted in the modification of both the absorption and ring sizes of LH2 complexes. Thus, the unique 800 nm absorbing low-light (LL)-LH2 complex, with a ring size of eight αβ-heterodimers, was present under high intensity illumination at approximately the same level as the standard LH2 complex, with absorption bands at 800 and 850 nm and a ring size of nine αβ-heterodimers (ratio of ~1.0:0.5:0.5 for core complex/LH2 rings/ LL-LH2 rings). In contrast, the LL-LH2 became the predominant complex at low light intensity, where this ratio changed to ~1.0:0.2:2.0. As noted above in Section II.B, these AFM views were of sufficient resolution to confirm the X-ray crystallography derived model for the monomeric Rps. palustris RC-LH1 core complex (Roszak et al., 2003). It was also shown in the AFM study that the inner RC assembly induces the observed ellipticity upon the core complex (Scheuring et al., 2006), An important point to stress in interpreting the AFM studies in Rps. palustris and other purple bacteria is that a mosaic composition is expected to exist within the cytoplasmic membrane (CM)ICM continuum, representing the different stages of
For the AFM analysis on native membranes of the closely related LH2-containing species Rba. blasticus, it was necessary, as in Blc. viridis, to fuse the small isolated chromatophore vesicles by repeated cycles of freeze-thaw sonication (Scheuring et al., 2005a). This resulted in a mixture of complexes with alternating transverse orientations; however, in sufficiently large ICM domains of uniform orientation, AFM demonstrated components structured similarly to those in Rba. sphaeroides (Fig. 2d). These consist of S-shaped dimeric core complexes together with nonameric LH2 rings, but the mixing of the LH2 and core components in the Rba. blasticus membranes is much greater than that observed for Rba. sphaeroides (or indeed in Rsp. photometricum or Phs. molischianum). Thus, no lines of RCs or clearly separated antenna domains were observed, but rather a well mixed arrangement of core complexes and LH2, with no other visible components, or apparent space for additional machinery of the photosynthetic apparatus. These divergent observations merit comment concerning sample preparation; unlike the other species studied by AFM, both Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. blasticus form an ICM consisting of small, connected vesicular structures that upon cell disruption give rise to chromatophore vesicles. These isolated vesicles are inappropriate for high resolution imaging by scanning probe microscopy, as they do not adhere to the support to give sufficiently flat surfaces. As noted above, to overcome this difficulty, either freeze-thaw-induced membrane fusion (Scheuring et al 2003, 2005a), or treatment with sub-solubilizing levels of detergent (Bahatyrova et al., 2004b), were used to obtain membrane fragments suitable for imaging from Rba. blasticus and Rba. sphaeroides, respectively. It is possible that such treatments, or
5. Rhodopseudomonas palustris
262 membrane development and the distinct domains in which they occur. This ranges between unpigmented respiratory membrane, partially pigmented membrane invagination sites and fully pigmented ICM (see below). Representative membrane fractions arising form each of these regions can be isolated from Rba. sphaeroides (Parks and Niederman, 1978; Niederman et al., 1979), but only fragments of the mature ICM have thus far been examined by AFM (Bahatyrova et al., 2004b). Like Rsp. photometricum and Phs. molischianum, Rps. palustris forms infoldings of the CM that take the form of regular bundles of flattened thylakoid-like sacks. These ICM structures are differentiated into stacked and unstacked lamellae, and in freeze-fracture electron micrographs (EMs), a higher particle density was observed in the stacked regions (Varga and Staehelin, 1983). These regions may represent the membranes that were densely packed with core and LH2 complexes when visualized by AFM (Scheuring et al., 2006); however, the purely lipid membranes seen in the AFM analysis were not found in the freeze-fracture study. It is noteworthy that in freeze-fracture electron micrographs of Rba. sphaeroides cells undergoing differentiation to form the ICM, large lipid-enriched tubules attached to the CM were observed, representing an apparent developmental stage in ICM formation (Chory et al., 1984). 6. Common Points Revealed by Atomic Force Microscopy Studies A number of recurrent points seem to be worth reiterating concerning the observed membrane organizations. First, in none of the species studied have recognizable components other than peripheral light-harvesting complexes and core complexes been observed. Second, in all the reported cases the organization is not entirely random, with in most cases evidence for both core clustering and the formation of peripheral antenna domains. These effects seem to manifest themselves somewhat differently between species and with changes in the light intensity, but are nevertheless consistent factors. The lack of other components is particularly puzzling as in at least one of the species studied (Rba. sphaeroides), it has been suggested that the cytochrome bc1 complex is in close association with the RCs (Jungas et al., 1999, Joliot et al., 2005; Chapter 26, Lavergne et al; see Section IV. A). It should be noted, however, that the model of Jungas et al. (1999) for localization of the bc1 complex was proposed for
James N. Sturgis and Robert A. Niederman tubules in a strain lacking LH2, but that no bc1 complexes could be found in the tubules isolated from this strain by Siebert et al. (2004). Although all four subunits of the Rba. sphaeroides bc1 complex were demonstrated in Western blots of the ICM patches analyzed by AFM, including subunit IV which is thought to be localized largely on the cytoplasmic surface that was imaged in these preparations, it should be emphasized that in many of the images unattributed structures or gaps where the bc1 complex could be located are absent over large areas, as noted for Rsp. photometricum (Scheuring and Sturgis, 2005). Nevertheless, estimates of membrane composition in Rba. sphaeroides suggest that each 45 nm chromatophore vesicle should contain about 10 dimeric core complexes, 60 peripheral antenna complexes, 5 dimeric bc1 complexes and an ATP synthase (Geyer and Helms, 2006b), the precise numbers depending on the LH complex composition, and the related chromatophore size (Sturgis and Niederman, 1996). In this connection, Bahatyrova et al. (2004b) have suggested that a 70 nm chromatophore vesicle would comprise 15 RC-LH1-PufX dimers and approximately 100 LH2 complexes, in line with earlier estimates based on singlet-singlet annihilation data (Hunter et al., 1985). In some species and systems, it appears that a separation of the bc1 complexes and ATP synthase to other regions may exist (Geyer and Helms, 2006a; C. Mascle-Allemand, J. Lavergne and J. N. Sturgis (unpublished). The formation of separate core complex and LH2-rich regions is particularly interesting from a mechanistic point of view. First, it implies that the LH system might be sub-optimal, in light collection terms, as the LH-RC distances are not minimized. Second, it means that a complex hierarchy of interactions between the different components exists that serve to assure not only the differentiation of a stable photosynthetic membrane, but also the organization of different complexes in an evolutionarily optimal manner within these membranes. Several critical points have been raised concerning the remarkable images that have been published, or are reproduced here. These all center around the extent to which sample preparation and imaging conditions might have perturbed the surface organization of the membrane. In the earlier work, several different techniques were used to assure the adherence of sufficiently large flat membrane regions to the mica support, notably freeze-thaw fusion (Scheuring et al., 2003, 2005a), or sub-solubilizing detergent treatments (Bahatyrova et al., 2004b). As discussed above,
Chapter 14
In Situ Organization of Light-Harvesting Complexes
such treatments could well modify the organization of proteins in the membrane by altering membrane mechanical properties, assisting equilibration of kinetically trapped systems, or undermining the intermolecular interactions that determine the phase behavior of proteins in membranes. In the more recent work, such pre-treatments have proved to be unnecessary, and the membranes are deposited on the support directly after isolation (Gonçalves et al., 2005, Scheuring and Sturgis, 2005; Scheuring et al., 2006). Under these circumstances it is still possible that changes in membrane curvature or dynamics might modify the intra-molecular interactions. However, in several cases the supported structures observed by AFM strongly resemble those deduced from electron crystallography studies in terms of size, shape and curvature (reviewed by Scheuring et al., 2005b). A further argument against support driven modification of the imaged surface is that in several cases, they were not attached directly but are resting on another membrane adhering to the support (Scheuring and Sturgis, 2005). In view of the coherence of the picture that appears to be emerging, and despite differences in preparation techniques, it seems probable that most of these concerns are unjustified. Finally, it is useful to point out that all of the experimental observations described here have arisen from poorly ordered systems and therefore their interpretations do not easily lend themselves to any coherent theoretical description. While there is an increasing desire to study integrated systems in biology, we are currently somewhat deprived of the vocabulary necessary to describe such systems. As long as the structures described are homogeneous and well ordered, the idea of a supercomplex provides the necessary conceptual framework (see below). However, in the majority of environments within photosynthetic membranes, supercomplexes provide an overly structured view of an organization that is actually more diverse. Unfortunately at present, we cannot describe these systems effectively and thus fully appreciate their partially organized, as well as disorganized nature. IV. Proposals for the Functional Organization of Photosynthetic Units In this section, we will attempt to place the diversity of observed structural organizations into a coherent functional framework. First, the status of functional models involving supercomplexes, including ordered
263
quinone arrangements, will be evaluated in light of observed supramolecular arrangements. Because little structural support is found for these proposals, alternative views for the mechanism of quinone diffusion in the bilayer are presented that permit electron flow between the RC and remotely located cytochrome bc1 complexes. Finally, explanations for how paracrystalline antenna arrays may efficiently function in excitation energy transfer, as well as some possible physical bases for the self-assembly of the LH complexes, are also offered. A. Supercomplexes Thermodynamic studies of light-driven cyclic electron flow in whole Rba sphaeroides cells (most recently reviewed by Joliot et al., 2005; see also Chapter 26, Lavergne et al.), have formed the basis for a proposal in which the photosynthetic electron transfer chain is organized into supercomplexes consisting of a dimeric cytochrome bc1 complex sandwiched between two dimeric RC-LH1-PufX complexes, which interact with soluble cytochrome c2. With all the electron carriers arranged in this manner, a thermodynamic equilibrium between the primary RC donor and the high-potential Rieske FeS protein and cytochrome c1 components of the bc1 complex is thought to be mediated in <1 ms by the cytochrome c2 trapped in a single supercomplex. In contrast, equilibration between the different supercomplexes would occur 103 times more slowly. The highly ordered particles first seen in freeze-fracture electron micrographs of the tubular membranes of the LH2– strain M21 (Westerhuis et al., 2002), together with the requirement of PufX for the formation of RC dimers surrounded by open LH1 rings (Francia et al., 1999) were thought to provide structural bases for the supercomplex model. Joliot et al. (2005) have recently suggested that most of the UQ formed at the Qo site of the bc1 complex is also apparently trapped in supercomplexes. Paradoxically, the kinetic behavior attributed to electron flow within supercomplexes in whole cells cannot be demonstrated in isolated chromatophores. This has been attributed to a heterogeneity in the distribution of redox components among chromatophore vesicle populations in which cytochrome c2 is able to diffuse freely, owing to the perturbation of supercomplex structure during chromatophore preparation (Crofts et al., 1998). As a consequence, cytochrome c2 is able to diffuse within the intravesicular space in an unimpeded manner. Any model for supercomplex organization in the
264 ICM of purple bacteria would seem to require a close association between the RC and the bc1 complex; however, this is not supported by any of the submolecular ICM surface views provided by the recent AFM topographs from a variety of purple bacteria, in which no bc1 complex was visualized. The possibility has been considered that the bc1 complex might be located close to the CM or at the edges of ICM invaginations, out of view of the flat surfaces imaged in the topographs (Fig. 3) (Scheuring et al., 2005b). This might place some of the RCs at too great a distance from the bc1 complex for rapid functional coupling. This enigma is further discussed below (Section IV.C). Before leaving the topic of supercomplexes, it should be noted that in contrast to the purple bacterial ICM, considerable support now exists for the possibility that the oxidoreductase complexes of the mitochondrial respiratory chain exist in such an arrangement (recently reviewed by Boekema and Braun, 2007). The principal experimental evidence comes from the non-ionic detergent based co-purification of associated complexes (e.g., I + III2, consisting of Complex I (NADH dehydrogenase) together with the dimeric Complex III (cytochrome bc1 complex); III2 + IV1–2 (IV, cytochrome c oxidase), and large I+III2+IV1–4 supercomplexes), which were revealed by single particle EM analysis to exist in defined arrangements and stoichiometries. Such an approach has resulted in the isolation of a I+III4+IV4 supercomplex from Paracoccus dentrificans (Stroh et al., 2004); a similar supercomplex organization may hold for the oxidoreductases of the CM respiratory chain of closely related purple bacteria when grown aerobically. Under lowered aeration, the CM is the starting point for invaginations that differentiate into an ICM in which pigment-protein complexes are packed (see Section V), which could result in the disruption of supercomplex organization. More definitive evidence for functional supercomplex associations in the mitochondrial inner membrane and bacterial plasma membrane will require non-invasive techniques such as AFM of intact membrane surfaces in aqueous solution. B. Quinone Pools In a similar vein to the supercomplex model, it has more recently been proposed that the quinone pool is a misnomer and that, on metabolically relevant time scales, the assemblage of quinones is not well
James N. Sturgis and Robert A. Niederman
Fig. 3. Model of a Rba. sphaeroides chromatophore loosely based on that proposed by Geyer and Helms (2006b) showing dimeric RCs, LH complexes, the cytochrome bc1 complex, and ATP synthase in a 65 nm diameter vesicle. The vesicle backbone is formed by a linear band of dimeric RC-LH1 core complexes, similar to those observed in AFM topographs of ICM fragments by Bahatyrova et al. (2004b), with partially ordered LH2 complexes placed above and below this core dimer band. The ATP synthase is situated at the ‘North pole’ of the lower regions of the chromatophore. The LH2 rings are nonameric, as expected in Rba. sphaeroides (Walz et al., 1998). The dimeric core complex arrangement favored by Scheuring et al. (2004c) is depicted here. Note the model is also at odds with the arrangement and number of LH2 and core complexes proposed for semispherical ICM vesicles by Frese et al. (2004), on the basis of LD and AFM measurements. Important objectives in the next years include obtaining further experimental assessment of such models, refining them to include information on the stochastic variability and dynamics of such integrated systems, and defining the processes and rules involved in their assembly both in vivo and in vitro.
mixed and each quinone molecule can only access a limited number of RCs (Comayras et al., 2005a,b). This proposal was based on the effects of RC inhibitors on the apparent size of the quinone pool. These observations are related to the idea, at least in Rba. sphaeroides, that a functional unit for the electronic circuit contains two RCs, the quinone molecules and a dimeric cytochrome bc1 complex. However, in light of the inability to observe the bc1 complex in either Rba. sphaeroides chromatophore patches (Bahatyrova et al., 2004b) or isolated tubules (Siebert et al., 2004), the structural and functional measurements are not easily reconciled. C. Functional Importance of the Observed Organization Although a variety of architectures are observed for the photosynthetic apparatus, they obviously permit these systems to function efficiently in the native
Chapter 14
In Situ Organization of Light-Harvesting Complexes
environments of the different bacterial species. It is thus not surprising that distinct ecological constraints result in different solutions for the organization of the membrane to allow efficient photosynthesis. In this section, we will discuss two different aspects of these architectures; what might be the functional reasons behind the observed organizations, and what could be the forces and interactions responsible for the formation of these remarkable structures? As noted above, at the functional level, the organization of the photosynthetic complexes has to resolve several important paradoxes. First, for maximal efficiency of the LH system, it might be expected that the RC would be completely surrounded by antennae in a homogenous arrangement that minimizes the distances from the LH apparatus to the RC. Second, in order to avoid energy losses from closed RCs, the core complexes should be connected to allow energy transfer between them under intense illumination (Bahatyrova et al., 2004b; Scheuring et al., 2005b). Third, it would seem reasonable that the bc1 complex should be located in close proximity to the RC to permit closure of the electronic circuit by quinone/quinol diffusion in the membrane. Obviously, these different constraints cannot all be satisfied simultaneously. In light of the observed architectures, the apparent location of the cytochrome bc1 complex at some distance from the RC poses a major problem for quinone diffusion in the membrane bilayer. To begin with, the mode of escape of the quinol from the RC QB site through the closed LH1 ring found in many species is not readily apparent. In species such as Rba. sphaeroides, in which the RC is dimeric, the core antenna does not form closed rings, and thus escape is probably relatively simple. Here, the strategic placement of PufX, together with evidence for adjacent, highly mobile LH1 α-helices (Qian et al., 2005), implicates this region in the optimization of quinone/quinol exchange, which may also be aided by the overall flexibility demonstrated for the LH1 ring (Bahatyrova et al., 2004a). For Rps. palustris, quinone/quinol escape and re-entry appear to be facilitated through the built-in interruption by the α-helix of polypeptide W, observed within the LH1 ring (Roszak et al., 2003). In species such as Rsp. photometricum, however, in which the ring appears to be closed, quinone transfer across the LH1 wall would be dependent upon the dynamics of the process by which the integrity of the ring is breached. In this connection, it has been suggested that the several closed elliptical forms observed in AFM topographs
265
of 2-D crystals of the RC-LH1 core complex of Rsp. rubrum, reflect a flexible structure that could facilitate transient exchange of the quinone redox species through a dynamic series of molecular motions (Jamieson et al., 2002; Fotiadis et al., 2004). Support for such a diffusion process is provided by a recent molecular dynamics simulation study of possible ubiquinone shuttling pathways through the protein environment of the LH1 ring in Rsp. rubrum (Aird et al., 2007). An upper limit of the passage time for ubiquinone diffusion of ~8 × 10–3 s was calculated, compared with a turnover rate of ~3.5 ×10–3 s determined experimentally for electron transfer in monomeric RC-LH1 complexes with closed LH1 rings from a Rba. sphaeroides pufX– strain (Comayras et al., 2005b). It is relevant to this discussion that on the basis of the recent X-ray structure of Photosystem II (PS II), Loll et al. (2005) have identified a diffusion cavity for the secondary plastoquinone (PQB) that transfers redox equivalents from PS II to the photosynthetic electron transfer chain. This cavity is thought to provide a flexible, lipophilic environment for PQ/ PQH2 diffusion through an opening between the PQB-binding site and the PQ pool. The PS II protein PsbJ, which is located in a position that flanks this opening in the membrane, has been shown to influence electron transfer between PQA, PQB and the PQ pool, reminiscent of the role played by PufX, and reflecting an apparent functional evolutionary convergence. Additional details on an analogous lipophilic QB binding pocket in the Rba. sphaeroides RC can be found in the recent review of Jones (2007); see also Chapter 16 (Jones). Finally, the low resolution 3-D structure of the RC-LH1-PufX dimer from Rba. sphaeroides also reveals a possible location for a sequestered quinone pool adjacent to each RC (Chapter 9, Bullough et al.). The next difficulty faced by the quinone is diffusion in the membrane plane to reach the cytochrome bc1 complex through a crowded membrane. This problem has been studied recently by examining the dynamics of complexes in the Rsp. photometricum membrane using time-lapse AFM and Monte-Carlo simulations (Scheuring and Sturgis, 2006). It was shown that the para-crystalline regions of LH2 complexes were essentially static on long time scales, with no evidence for long-range or short-range diffusion, and packed so closely that insufficient space exists for quinones to diffuse within these arrays. In contrast, the disordered regions showed short-range corralled diffusion
266 of sufficient amplitude that would allow quinone molecules in the membrane plane to pass between complexes. This heterogeneity of dynamics, together with the exclusion of metabolically active quinones from the crystalline regions, is suggested to optimize electron transfer if the diameter of antennae domains is about the same as the distance between the RC and the cytochrome bc1 complex. This proposal seems consistent with the dynamics of electron transfer recently observed in Rsp. photometricum and Phs. molischianum (C. Mascle-Allemand, J. Lavergne and J. N. Sturgis (unpublished). The observation that the crystalline regions of the purple bacterial membrane are static, and the realization that the packing density is so great that there is insufficient space for quinone diffusion between complexes, poses a serious problem for the metabolic activity of core complexes that form crystalline domains as seen in Blc. viridis (Scheuring et al., 2003) or Rps. palustris (Scheuring et al., 2006). A possible explanation for their functional role might be that the complexes embedded in such domains are not active in cyclic electron transfer, but rather operate as light-sensitive batteries in which the stabilized charge separation between the cytochromes and bound quinones drive a rapid change in membrane potential in response to light. One of the surprises in the recent observations of the architecture of bacterial photosynthetic membranes was the clustering of peripheral LH complexes. As mentioned above, in certain species this arrangement may aid in directing electron transfer; however, the formation of large domains of LH2 was considered unlikely because of the adverse effect such domains might have on the excitation energy transfer and lightharvesting processes. Indeed, their formation can considerably increase the distance between certain LH complexes and the nearest RC. In spite of this, photosynthesis remains remarkably efficient in lowlight membranes even when antennae-RC distances are increased, though there is a small increase in the fluorescence yield (C. Mascle-Allemand, J. Lavergne and J.N. Sturgis, unpublished). In retrospect, however, this is perhaps not so surprising as LH2-LH2 energy transfer is very fast (~5 ps; Agarwal et al., 2002) compared to the excited-state B850 lifetime of ~1 ns (Bergström et al., 1988), allowing long-range exciton diffusion in the very well connected para-crystalline domains. The highly organized nature of the various protein arrays found in photosynthetic membranes poses the
James N. Sturgis and Robert A. Niederman question as to how this is achieved. Here, it should be pointed out that different ways of describing the organizations exist, and none is entirely satisfactory. On the one hand, the observed arrangements can be considered as a series of structured antenna-RC supercomplexes with some heterogeneity; such a view allows the construction of increasingly large assemblages (Scheuring et al., 2007). Alternatively, the organizations can be regarded as a disordered system in which the phase-physics and statistical properties can be examined (Scheuring and Sturgis, 2005). Because we lack the necessary vocabulary for properly describing and studying these organizations, as noted above, neither of these approaches is wholly suitable. Several observations should be highlighted in considering the detailed organization of proteins in the membrane. First, in several species, but most clearly in Rps. palustris (Scheuring et al., 2006), membrane areas rich in photosynthetic proteins are contiguous with flat lipid-rich membrane areas, emphasizing the stability of the organization of the photosynthetic apparatus (C. Mascle-Allemand, J. Lavergne and J.N. Sturgis, unpublished). It also implies that the system is able to self-assemble and thus represents an energetically favored organization. The second point worth noting is that a very simple model of interaction forces (Scheuring and Sturgis, 2005) was able to mimic the self-assembly of the two-phase organization as is observed in Rsp. photometricum or Phs. molischianum. This emphasizes the fact that the complexes can self-assemble with the final organization reflecting the interaction potentials that drive assembly. Of particular importance in this respect, are not only the interaction forces, but also the ranges of interaction (Noro and Frenkel, 2001), such that the formation of dense disordered systems appears to rely, at least in sufficiently simple systems, on the presence of long-range interactions. Because of this, it is possible that the observed membrane organization could be driven by long-range attractive forces between the components, with a species-specific hierarchy of interaction strengths defining the final arrangement (J.N. Sturgis, unpublished). However, the physical nature of these proposed long-range interactions remains obscure. The observation of very similar membrane organization in Rsp. photometricum and Phs. molischianum (Scheuring et al., 2004b; Gonçalves et al., 2005) gives some insight into the type of interactions that might be involved in organizing the different complexes
Chapter 14
In Situ Organization of Light-Harvesting Complexes
in the membrane. While these two organisms share a common supramolecular organization, the symmetry of the underlying complexes is different. In Rsp. photometricum, the LH2 complex is nonameric, while in the case of Phs. molischianum the complex is octameric; nonetheless, both complexes can form densely packed hexagonal arrays. This situation cannot be due to strong specific interactions between the LH2 complexes because of the change in symmetry, which implies, in contrast, that the association of LH2 complexes, and possibly the whole photosynthetic apparatus, is driven by non-specific interactions. Such non-specific interactions could be considered alternatively as an insolubility of the photosynthetic complexes in the lipid bilayer. A solubility problem of this magnitude could arise from several different origins, e.g., a hydrophobic mismatch as proposed in the membrane mattress model (Mouritsen and Bloom, 1984). In certain species, a difference in membrane curvature between photosynthetic membranes and cytoplasmic membranes, as previously proposed (Sturgis and Niederman, 1996) can be imagined, as well as several other elastic or chemical differences between the surfaces of the proteins and the membrane phospholipids. V. In Vivo Assembly of Light-Harvesting Complexes Owing to the numerous practical advantages pointed out above in Section III.B.3, Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus have, over the years, provided an ideal model systems for examining the biogenesis and assembly of photosynthetic membranes. When grown photoheterotrophically (anaerobically in the light), the levels of LH2 relative to RC-LH1 core complexes are related inversely to light intensity (Cohen-Bazire et al., 1956) and shifts in illumination levels have offered a valuable paradigm for examining differential biosynthesis of photosynthetic complexes during chromatic adaptation. Although ICM formation is repressed by high oxygen tension under chemoheterotrophic growth conditions, lowering oxygen partial pressure initiates a gratuitous induction of ICM assembly in the dark (greening) by invagination of the CM, together with the synthesis and assembly of the LH and RC complexes (Takemoto and Lascelles, 1973). In Rba. sphaeroides, it is possible to isolate these CM invagination sites in the form of an upperpigmented band that sediments more slowly than the
267
ICM-derived chromatophore vesicle fraction during rate-zone centrifugation on sucrose density gradients (Niederman et al., 1979; Niederman, 2006). This membrane fraction provides a basis for the application of a variety of definitive biochemical, biophysical and ultrastructural probes to the membrane development process (Niederman et al., 1979; Bowyer et al., 1985; Hunter et al., 1988; Sturgis and Niederman, 1996; Hunter et al., 2005; Koblízek et al., 2005). These studies (reviewed recently by Niederman, 2006), demonstrated that photosynthetic units are assembled sequentially, with RC-LH1 core structures inserted initially into the CM in a form that is largely inactive in forward electron transfer. This is followed by the activation of functional electron flow, together with the addition of LH2, resulting in membrane invagination and vesicularization to form the ICM. LH2 is thought to initially pack between the linear arrays of dimeric core complexes, and to ultimately form the clusters of LH2-only domains that represent the light-responsive peripheral antenna complement. Interestingly, a rather similar mechanism of sequential assembly has been established for both PS I and PS II in cyanobacteria, and there are suggestions that the initial synthesis of thylakoid membranes in plant proplastids may involve invagination of the inner envelope, into which thylakoid proteins are first inserted (Cline, 2003). The developmental changes occurring within the CM-ICM continuum of purple bacteria are under the control of a number of interrelated two-component regulatory circuits that act at the transcriptional level to regulate the formation of both the pigment and apoprotein components of the LH and RC complexes in response to oxygen and light (see contributions in Chapter 35, Bauer et al.; Chapter 36, Klug and Masuda, for detailed descriptions of these elegant systems). Light-mediated regulation in anoxygenic phototrophs is also controlled by newly discovered bacteriophytochromes (BPs) (Giraud et al., 2002) that act as far-red(fr)/red(r) light sensors through reversible BPr to BPfr structural transformations to control expression of photosynthetic complex genes. One of the BPs from Rps. palustris has recently been shown by Evans et al. (2006) to possess a plant-like phytochrome structure consisting of N-terminal biliverdin binding (phytochrome) and C-terminal histidine kinase domains, and to function in maintaining high levels of the unique 800 nm absorbing LL-LH2 complex under low light intensity via a phosphorelay response regulator system (Evans et
268 al., 2005; Giraud et al., 2005; Chapter 40, Evans et al). Another BP of Rps. palustris is involved in the regulation of RC-LH1 core complex levels; further description of roles played by the multiple BPs of purple bacteria can be found in the recent review of Cogdell et al. (2006). The above mechanisms assure that the correct transcripts of the LH apoprotein genes are made. Subsequent stages in the formation of functional antenna complexes include: (i) the folding of the resulting nascent polypeptides into membrane insertion-competent conformations; (ii) their insertion and integration into the membrane; (iii) the binding of their BChl and carotenoid chromophores; (iv) the oligomerization of the pigment-protein protomers into their final oligomeric annular structures, and (v) their supramolecular organization into functional PSUs. With the advent of accessible molecular genetic systems, a number of site-directed mutagenesis studies have identified apoprotein regions and individual residues that are important for the assembly, chromophore attachment, and spectral tuning of both the LH1 and LH2 complexes (recently reviewed by Cogdell et al., 2006; see also Chapter 11, Robert; Chapter 46, Braun and Fiedor). These authors have pointed out that this in vivo approach exploits the cell’s normal assembly processes and the ability to provide the required pigments. Very little is known about these processes, and in the remainder of this section, we summarize the current state of knowledge in these areas and provide some speculations on how the many missing details may ultimately play out. A. Complex-Specific Assembly Factors Considerable effort in recent years has focused upon complex-specific assembly factors that are encoded by genes within photosynthesis gene clusters, and serve to assist either directly or indirectly, in LH and RC protein assembly in developing membranes (reviewed by Young and Beatty, 2003). These include the LH1-specific assembly factor LhaA, and the related LH2-specific factor PucC, that are both members of the putative ‘chlorophyll delivery branch’ of the major facilitator superfamily. A possible role for LhaA in BChl cofactor assembly is suggested by its co-enrichment with the BChl synthase protein, BchG, in the Rba. sphaeroides upper pigmented band (C.N. Hunter, personal communication; Hunter et al., 2005). These findings, together with radiolabeling studies using the heme precursor δ-aminolevulinate, suggest
James N. Sturgis and Robert A. Niederman that the upper pigmented fraction contains membrane sites for both the preferential biosynthesis of BChl cofactors and their attachment to the LH1 and RC apoproteins, which are also assembled preferentially at these sites (Niederman et al., 1979). This raises the question of whether a targeting process delivers the nascent apoproteins to the membrane at the precise location of BChl availability through the coordination of protein integration with pigment synthesis (see below). In addition to PufX, whose role in dimerization of RC-LH1 cores and their supramolecular organization is discussed above, complex-specific assembly factors encoded within the photosynthesis gene cluster in Rba. capsulatus and Rba. sphaeroides include PuhB, PuhC and PuhE, encoded by open reading frames located immediately 3´ of the puhA gene encoding the RC-H subunit (Young and Beatty 2003; Chapter 9, Bullough et al.); homologs of these open reading frames have also been identified in the Rps. palustris genome. These factors have roles in the biogenesis of RC-LH1 core complexes: PuhB has been shown to serve as an apparent dimeric RC assembly factor with secondary effects on LH1 assembly; PuhC is required for optimal RC-LH1 levels, and is thought to be involved in the reorganization of core complex (Aklujkar et al., 2006); and PuhE is a negative modulator of BChl synthesis (Aklujkar et al., 2005). PufQ, located at the 5´ end of the puf operon (Hunter et al., 1991), stimulates BChl production, acts as a putative carrier of intermediates of the BChl biosynthetic pathway, and is thought to assist in the assembly of LH1 and LH2. With regard to carotenoid attachment to the LH apoproteins, pigment composition studies have demonstrated preferential associations of all-trans species with LH apoproteins, in contrast to the 15-cis species found in the RC (Koyama and Fujii 1999), consistent with their respective lightharvesting and photoprotective functions in these protein environments. No information, however, is available on factors that may assist in the attachment of carotenoids to LH complexes. B. General Membrane Assembly Factors In contrast to the complex-specific assembly factors, very little is known about the general membrane assembly factors of purple bacteria, which undoubtedly represent more ancient homologs of the well-studied factors from Escherichia (E.) coli, since anoxygenic phototrophs are generally believed to be among the
Chapter 14
In Situ Organization of Light-Harvesting Complexes
oldest life forms. Factors studied thus far include soluble chaperonins DnaK and GroEL, which in a cell-free, transcription-translation system of Rba. capsulatus, have been shown to play roles in the synthesis and stable assembly of the LH1 apoprotein (Drews, 1996). The translocation ATPase, SecA, has also been examined in Rba. capsulatus, and is apparently involved in the movement of c-type apocytochromes to the periplasm for heme attachment (Helde et al., 1997). Other factors detected in a search of available Rba. sphaeroides genome sequences include homologs of the SecY translocon, the YidC membrane chaperonin, the SecDF membrane insertion components, and the prokaryotic signal recognition particle homologs, Fth/FtsY. In E. coli, YidC functions both independently as a membrane-protein insertase, or in conjunction with the Sec membraneprotein insertion pathway, where YidC is thought to serve as an integrase which folds transmembrane segments of nascent polypeptides to ensure their lateral integration (Dalbey and Kuhn, 2004). SecY, a homolog of the Sec61 protein-conducting channel of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), is the major pore component of the SecYEG translocon (Van den Berg et al., 2004). The SecDF/YajC membrane insertion components have recently been shown to be involved in the Sec translocon independent pathway (Chen et al., 2005), and alternatively to link SecYEG to YidC. Targeting to the Sec translocon is mediated by the Ffh/FtsY homolog of the ER-associated signal recognition particle that recognizes the membrane targeting sequences of integral membrane proteins (Luirink and Sinning 2004). It is noteworthy that in proteomic analyses of Rps. palustris photosynthetic membranes (Fejes et al., 2003; VerBerkmoes et al., 2006), PuhB, PuhC, DnaK, GroEL, SecA, SecF, SecD, and YajC were identified. How such factors may be involved in the assembly of the PSUs of purple bacteria is unknown and remains an important topic for future investigation. Structural considerations (Hu et al., 2002) suggest that, in addition to roles for the DnaK and GroEL chaperonins, the putative Chl delivery factors and other complex-specific factors, at least some of these additional soluble and membrane-bound general assembly factors are needed to support LH1 and LH2 polypeptide membrane targeting and insertion, as well as their assembly into functional annular complexes. These factors may well include SecA, YidC, SecDF, Ffh/FtsY and the Sec translocon. While it is possible that the LH proteins in an appropriately folded state,
269
are inserted spontaneously into the lipid bilayer, the balance of recent evidence in E. coli suggests that the membrane insertion process, even for such small proteins, is enzymatically controlled by interacting membrane assembly factors, ensuring that a defined topology is assumed within the membrane (Facey and Kuhn 2004; Chen et al., 2005). Structural models for the Rba. sphaeroides LH1 and LH2 αβ-heterodimers (Olsen and Hunter, 1994; Hu et al., 2002) suggest that the apoprotein subunits each consist of single transmembrane α-helices of 23–28 residues, with charged C-terminal periplasmic extensions of 17–22 residues in the case of the α-polypeptides. Translocation of such hydrophilic domains across the membrane would be expected to require participation of an electrochemical proton gradient (Dierstein and Drews, 1986), and an enzymatically-assisted passage. Moreover, during LH protein folding within the lipid bilayer, YidC may also facilitate associations with membrane-bound proteins that function in the later stages of pigment biosynthesis and in the attachment of these cofactors, a role that has been suggested in the assembly of LH chlorophyll proteins (LHCPs) for the chloroplast YidC homolog, Oxa1p (Dalbey and Kuhn 2004). VI. Perspectives for the Next Ten Years Research over the next decade should see a continued growth in studies of ICM structure, and in particular, on the assembly processes that direct ICM formation. Among other areas that are likely to progress significantly are the development of high-resolution experimentally based models along the lines of that presented by Geyer and Helms (2006a,b)(Fig. 3), as well as the relationship between ICM architecture and ecological niches. Several aspects of the assembly process seem ripe for significant developments especially in view of the recent explosion of structural detail on the molecular organization of the ICM. These include the roles of assembly factors, the energetics of this process, and the role of protein sequence in controlling ICM organization. In this connection, it has recently been shown that PufX, which is responsible for the supramolecular dimeric organization of RC-LH1-PufX complexes in the Rba sphaeroides ICM (Siebert et al., 2004; Frese et al., 2004; Chapter 9, Bullough et al.), is present in monomeric RC-LH1-PufX complexes in the related
270 but independently evolved species Rba. veldkampii (Gubellini et al., 2006). While the kinetics of flashinduced cytochrome b561 reduction suggested that PufX apparently facilitates the quinone-mediated interaction between the RC and bc1 complexes in the same manner in both Rba. veldkampi and Rba sphaeroides, it is thought that a difference in the sequence of the cytoplasmic N-terminal domain may account for the inability of the Rba. veldkampii PufX protein to facilitate core complex dimerization. With the recent determination of the solution NMR structure of the PufX protein (Tunnicliffe et al., 2006; Wang et al., 2007), further clarification of the various assembly (Aklujkar and Beatty, 2005, 2006) and functional (Comayras et al., 2005b) roles proposed for this important core complex component should now become possible. The new knowledge of the molecular organization of the ICM, largely obtained by AFM, will make advances possible in many different unresolved aspects of this process. This can be exemplified in the need for improvement in models such as that of Geyer and Helms (2006b), depicted in Fig. 3, and this is to be expected over the course of the next decade at the level of refining the structures of the individual components and improving our vision of the organization of the elusive cytochrome bc1 and ATP synthase complexes. Other issues to be resolved include a better understanding of the stochastic variations between chromatophores, both in their nature and origin, and the further examination of the dynamics of the ICM at this level of structural resolution under different time scales (femtoseconds to milliseconds to hours). While we visualize that these essentially descriptive advances are likely to take place over the next 10 years, our understanding of the fundamental processes involved may well advance more slowly. However, we would expect a number of advances, in particular on the molecular determinants of ICM organization, a domain that was inaccessible prior to our current picture of the surface arrangement of photosynthetic complexes at submolecular resolution. It is further expected that the newer methods, such as proteomics and AFM will find application in all these types of studies, since the employment of these techniques together in the ICM of purple bacteria offers unique structural proteomic approaches currently unavailable with any other complex energy transducing membrane. AFM used in combination with confocal fluorescence microscopy (Kassies et al., 2005) also holds considerable promise. This atomic
James N. Sturgis and Robert A. Niederman force fluorescence microscopy (AFFM) technique is capable of simultaneous topographic and optical imaging with single molecule resolution in both the visible and near-IR spectral regions. The resulting molecular topography data can be integrated with specific fluorescence emission spectra for the identification of individual developing complexes, and it has been shown that these spectral imaging capabilities are sufficiently sensitive to distinguish LH1 and LH2 within the native PSU. The AFM-based nanomanipulation capabilities are also retained in the AFFM, such as the application of loading forces and measurements of forces of interaction and adhesion. References Agarwal R, Rizvi AH, Prall BS, Olsen JD, Hunter CN and Fleming GR (2002) The nature of disorder and inter-complex energy transfer in LH2 at room temperature: A three pulse photon echo peak shift study. J Phys Chem A 106: 7573–7578 Aird A Wrachtrup J, Schulten K and Tietz C (2007) Possible pathway for ubiquinone shuttling in Rhodospirillum rubrum revealed by molecular dynamics simulation. Biophys J 92: 23–33 Aklujkar M, Prince RC and Beatty JT (2005) The puhE gene of Rhodobacter capsulatus is needed for optimal transition from aerobic to photosynthetic growth and encodes a putative negative modulator of bacteriochlorophyll production. Arch Biochem Biophys 437: 186–198 Aklujkar M, Prince RC and Beatty JT (2006) The photosynthetic deficiency due to puhC gene deletion in Rhodobacter capsulatus suggests a PuhC protein-dependent process of RC/LH1/PufX complex reorganization. Arch Biochem Biophys 454: 59–71 Bakker JGC, van Grondelle R and den Hollander WTF (1983) Trapping, loss and annihilation of excitations in a photosynthetic system. II. Experiments with the purple bacteria Rhodospirillum rubrum and Rhodopseudomonas capsulata. Biochim. Biophys Acta 725: 508–518 Bahatyrova S, Frese RN, van der Werf KO, Otto C, Hunter CN and Olsen JD (2004a) Flexibility and size heterogeneity of the LH1 light harvesting complex revealed by atomic force microscopy: Functional significance for bacterial photosynthesis. J Biol Chem 279: 21327–21333 Bahatyrova S, Frese RN, Siebert, CA, van der Werf KO, van Grondelle R, Niederman RA, Bullough PA, Otto C, Olsen JD and Hunter CN (2004b) The native architecture of a photosynthetic membrane. Nature 430: 1058–1062 Barz WP, Verméglio A, Francia F, Venturoli G, Melandri BA and Oesterhelt D (1995) Role of the PufX protein in photosynthetic growth of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. 2. PufX is required for efficient ubiquinone/ubiquinol exchange between the reaction center QB site and the cytochrome bc1 complex. Biochemistry 34: 15248–15258 Bergström H, Sundström V, van Grondelle R, Gillbro T and Cogdell R (1988) Energy transfer dynamics of isolated B800–850 and B800–820 pigment-protein complexes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Rhodopseudomonas acidophila. Biochim Biophys Acta 936: 90–98
Chapter 14
In Situ Organization of Light-Harvesting Complexes
Blankenship RE, Madigan MT and Bauer CE (eds) (1995) Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 2). Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Boekema EJ and Braun HP (2007) Supramolecular structure of the mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation system. J Biol Chem 282: 1–4 Bowyer JR, Hunter CN, Ohnishi T and Niederman RA (1985) Photosynthetic membrane development in Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. Spectral and kinetic characterization of redox components of light-driven electron flow in apparent photosynthetic membrane growth initiation sites. J Biol Chem 260: 3295–3304 Chen M, Xie K, Yuan J, Yi L, Facey SJ, Pradel N, Wu LF, Kuhn A and Dalbey RE (2005) Involvement of SecDF and YidC in the membrane insertion of M13 procoat mutants. Biochemistry 44: 10741–10749 Chory J, Donohue TJ, Varga AR, Staehelin LA and Kaplan S (1984) Induction of the photosynthetic membranes of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides: Biochemical and morphological studies. J Bacteriol 159: 540–554 Cline K (2003) Biogenesis of green plant thylakoid membranes. In: Green BR and Parson WW (eds) Light-Harvesting Antennas in Photosynthesis (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 13), pp 353–372, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Cogdell RJ, Gall A and Kohler J (2006) The architecture and function of the light-harvesting apparatus of purple bacteria: from single molecules to in vivo membranes. Q Rev Biophys 39: 227–324 Cohen-Bazire G, Sistrom WR and Stanier RY (1956) Kinetic studies of pigment synthesis by non-sulfur purple bacteria. J Cell Comp Physiol 49: 25–68 Comayras F, Jungas C and Lavergne J (2005a) Functional consequences of the organization of the photosynthetic apparatus in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. I. Quinone domains and excitation transfer in chromatophores and reaction center antenna complexes. J Biol Chem 280: 11203–11213 Comayras F, Jungas C and Lavergne J (2005b) Functional consequences of the organization of the photosynthetic apparatus in Rhodobacter sphaeroides: II. A study of PufX- membranes. J Biol Chem. 280: 11214–11223 Crofts A, Guergova-Kuras M and Hong S (1998) Chromatophore heterogeneity explains phenomena seen in Rhodobacter sphaeroides previously attributed to supercomplexes. Photosynth Res 55: 357– 362 Dalbey RE and Kuhn A (2004) YidC family members are involved in the membrane insertion, lateral integration, folding, and assembly of membrane proteins. J Cell Biol 166: 769–774 Deinum G, Aartsma TJ, van Grondelle R and Amesz J (1989) Singlet-singlet annihilation measurements on the antenna of Rhodospirillum rubrum between 300 and 4 K. Biochim Biophys Acta 976: 63–69 Deinum G, Otte SCM, Gardiner AT, Aartsma TJ, Cogdell RJ and Amesz J (1991) Antenna organization of Rhodopseudomonas acidophila: a study of the excitation migration. Biochim Biophys Acta 1060: 125–131 Dierstein R and Drews G (1986) Effect of uncoupler on assembly pathway for pigment-binding protein of bacterial photosynthetic membranes. J Bacteriol 168: 167–172 Drews G (1996) Formation of the light-harvesting complex I (B870) of anoxygenic phototrophic purple bacteria. Arch
271
Microbiol 166: 151–159 Drews G and Golecki JR (1995) Structure, molecular organization, and biosynthesis of membranes of purple bacteria. In: Blankenship RE, Madigan MT, Bauer CE (ed) Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 2), pp 231–257. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Evans K, Fordham-Skelton AP, Mistry H, Reynolds CD, Lawless AM and Papiz MZ (2005) A bacteriophytochrome regulates the synthesis of LH4 complexes in Rhodopseudomonas palustris. Photosynth Res 85: 169–180 Evans K, Grossmann JG, Fordham-Skelton AP and Papiz MZ. (2006) Small-angle X-ray scattering reveals the solution structure of a bacteriophytochrome in the catalytically active Pr state. J Mol Biol 364: 655–666 Facey SJ and Kuhn A (2004) Membrane integration of E. coli model membrane proteins. Biochim Biophys Acta 1694: 55–66 Fejes AP, Yi EC, Goodlett DR and Beatty JT (2003) Shotgun proteomic analysis of a chromatophore-enriched preparation from the purple phototrophic bacterium Rhodopseudomonas palustris. Photosynth Res 78: 195–203 Fotiadis D, Qian P, Philippsen A, Bullough PA, Engel A and Hunter CN (2004) Structural analysis of the reaction center light-harvesting complex I photosynthetic core complex of Rhodospirillum rubrum using atomic force microscopy. J Biol Chem 279: 2063–2068 Francia F, Wang J, Venturoli G, Melandri BA, Barz WP and Oesterhelt D. (1999) The reaction center-LH1 antenna complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides contains one PufX molecule which is involved in dimerization of this complex. Biochemistry 38: 6834–6845 Frese RN, Olsen JD, Branvall R, Westerhuis WH, Hunter CN and van Grondelle R (2000) The long-range supraorganization of the bacterial photosynthetic unit: A key role for PufX. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 97: 5197–5202 Frese RN, Siebert CA, Niederman RA, Hunter CN, Otto C and van Grondelle R (2004) The long-range organization of a native photosynthetic membrane. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 101: 17994–17999 Geyer T and Helms V (2006a) Reconstruction of a kinetic model of the chromatophore vesicles from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biophys J 91: 927–937 Geyer T and Helms V (2006b) A spatial model of the chromatophore vesicles of Rhodobacter sphaeroides and the position of the cytochrome bc1 complex. Biophys J 91: 921–926 Giraud E, Fardoux J, Fourrier N, Hannibal L, Genty B, Bouyer P, Dreyfus B and Verméglio A (2002) Bacteriophytochrome controls photosystem synthesis in anoxygenic bacteria. Nature 417: 202–205 Giraud E, Zappa S, Vuillet L, Adriano JM, Hannibal L, Fardoux J, Berthomieu C, Bouyer P, Pignol D and Verméglio A (2005) A new type of bacteriophytochrome acts in tandem with a classical bacteriophytochrome to control the antennae synthesis in Rhodopseudomonas palustris. J Biol Chem 280: 32389–32397 Gonçalves RP, Bernadac A, Sturgis JN and Scheuring S (2005) Architecture of the native photosynthetic apparatus of Phaeospirillum molischianum. J Struct Biol 152: 221–228 Gubellini F, Francia F, Busselez J, Venturoli G and Levy D (2006) Functional and structural analysis of the photosyn-
272 thetic apparatus of Rhodobacter veldkampii. Biochemistry 45: 10512–10520 Hartigan N, Tharia HA, Sweeney F, Lawless AM and Papiz MZ (2002) The 7.5-Å electron density and spectroscopic properties of a novel low-light B800 LH2 from Rhodopseudomonas palustris. Biophys J 82: 963–977 Helde R, Wiesler B, Wachter E, Neubuser A, Hoffschulte HK, Hengelage T, Schimz KL, Stuart RA and Müller M. (1997) Comparative characterization of SecA from the alpha-subclass purple bacterium Rhodobacter capsulatus and Escherichia coli reveals differences in membrane and precursor specificity. J Bacteriol 179: 4003–4012 Hu X, Ritz T, Damjanovic A, Autenrieth F and Schulten K (2002) Photosynthetic apparatus of purple bacteria Q Rev Biophys 35: 1–62 Hunter CN, Kramer HJM and van Grondelle R (1985) Linear dichroism and fluorescence emission of antenna complexes during photosynthetic unit assembly in Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. Biochim Biophys Acta 807: 44–51 Hunter CN, Pennoyer JD, Sturgis JN, Farrelly D and Niederman RA (1988) Oligomerization states and associations of lightharvesting pigment-protein complexes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides as analyzed by lithium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Biochemistry 27: 3459–3467 Hunter CN, McGlynn P, Ashby MK, Burgess JG and Olsen JD (1991) DNA sequencing and complementation/deletion analysis of the bchA-puf operon region of Rhodobacter sphaeroides: In vivo mapping of the oxygen-regulated puf promoter. Molecular Microbiology 5: 2649–2661 Hunter CN, Tucker JD and Niederman RA (2005) The assembly and organisation of photosynthetic membranes in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Photochem Photobiol Sci 4: 1023–1027 Jamieson SJ, Wang P, Qian P, Kirkland JY, Conroy MJ, Hunter CN and Bullough PA. (2002) Projection structure of the photosynthetic reaction centre-antenna complex of Rhodospirillum rubrum at 8.5 Å resolution. EMBO J 21: 3927–3935 Janosi L, Kosztin I and Damjanovic A (2006) Theoretical prediction of spectral and optical properties of bacteriochlorophylls in thermally disordered LH2 antenna complexes. J Chem Phys 125: 014903 Joliot P, Joliot A and Verméglio (2005) Fast oxidation of the primary electron acceptor under anaerobic conditions requires the organization of the photosynthetic chain of Rhodobacter sphaeroides in supercomplexes. Biochim Biophys Acta 1706: 204–214 Jones MR (2007) Lipids in photosynthetic reaction centres: Structural roles and functional holes. Prog Lipid Res 46: 56–87 Jungas C, Ranck JL, Rigaud JL Joliot P and Verméglio A (1999) Supramolecular organization of the photosynthetic apparatus of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. EMBO J 18: 534–542 Karrasch S, Bullough PA and Ghosh R (1995) The 8.5 Å projection map of the light-harvesting complex I from Rhodospirillum rubrum reveals a ring composed of 16 subunits. EMBO J 14: 631–638 Kassies R, van der Werf KO, Lenferink A, Hunter CN, Olsen JD, Subramaniam V and Otto C (2005) Combined AFM and confocal fluorescence microscope for applications in bionanotechnology. J Microsc 217: 109–116 Koblízek M, Shih JD, Breitbart SI, Ratcliffe EC, Kolber ZS, Hunter CN and Niederman RA. (2005) Sequential assembly of
James N. Sturgis and Robert A. Niederman photosynthetic units in Rhodobacter sphaeroides as revealed by fast repetition rate analysis of variable bacteriochlorophyll a fluorescence. Biochim Biophys Acta 1706: 220–231 Koepke J, Hu X, Muenke C, Schulten K and Michel H (1996) The crystal structure of the light-harvesting complex II (B800-850) from Rhodospirillum molischianum. Structure 4: 581–597 Koyama, Y and Fujii R (1999) Cis–trans carotenoids in photosynthesis: Configurations, excited state properties and physiological functions. In: Frank HA, Young AJ, Britton G and Cogdell RJ (eds) The Photochemistry of Carotenoids (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 8), pp 161–188. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Kramer H, Deinum G, Gardiner AT, Cogdell RJ, Francke C, Aartsma TJ and Amesz J (1995) Energy transfer in the photosynthetic antenna system of the purple-non-sulfur bacterium Rhodopseudomonas cryptolactis. Biochim Biophys Acta 1231: 33–40 Loll B, Kern J, Saenger W, Zouni A and Biesiadka J (2005) Towards complete cofactor arrangement in the 3.0 Å resolution structure of photosystem II. Nature 438: 1040–1044 Luirink J and Sinning I (2004) SRP-mediated protein targeting: structure and function revisited. Biochim Biophys Acta 1694: 17–35 McDermott G, Prince SM, Freer AA, Hawthornthwaite-Lawless AM, Papiz MZ, Cogdell RJ and Isaacs NW (1995) Crystal structure of an integral membrane light-harvesting complex from photosynthetic bacteria. Nature 374: 517–521 Monger TG and Parson WW (1977) Singlet-triplet fusion in Rhodopseudomonas spheroides chromatophores. A probe of the organization of the photosynthetic apparatus. Biochim Biophys Acta 460: 393–407 Mouritsen OG and Bloom M (1984) Mattress model of lipidprotein interactions in membranes. Biophys J 46: 141–153 Niederman RA (2006) Structure, function and formation of bacterial intracytoplasmic membranes. In: Shively JM (ed) Complex Intracellular Structures in Prokaryotes, Microbiology Monographs, Vol 2, pp 193–227. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg Niederman RA, Mallon DE and Parks LC (1979) Membranes of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. VI. Isolation of a fraction enriched in newly synthesized bacteriochlorophyll a-protein complexes. Biochim Biophys Acta 555: 210–220 Noro MG and Frenkel D (2001) Phase behavior of a simple model for membrane proteins. J Chem Phys 114: 2477–2483 Olsen JD and Hunter CN (1994) Protein structure modelling of the bacterial light harvesting complex. Photochem Photobiol 60: 521–535 Parks LC and Niederman RA (1978) Membranes of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. V. Identification of bacteriochlorophyll a-depleted cytoplasmic membrane in phototrophically grown cells. Biochim Biophys Acta 511: 70–80 Parson WW and Nagarajan V (2003) Optical spectroscopy in photosynthetic antennas. In: Green BR and Parson WW (eds) Light-Harvesting Antennas in Photosynthesis (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 13), pp 83–127. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Qian P, Hunter CN and Bullough PA (2005) The 8.5Å projection structure of the core RC-LH1-PufX dimer of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Mol Biol 349: 948–960 Roszak AW, Howard TD, Southall J, Gardiner AT, Law CJ, Isaacs,
Chapter 14
In Situ Organization of Light-Harvesting Complexes
NW and Cogdell RJ (2003) Crystal structure of the RC-LH1 core complex from Rhodopseudomonas palustris. Science 302: 1969–1972 Scheuring S and Sturgis JN (2005) Chromatic adaptation of photosynthetic membranes. Science 309: 484–487 Scheuring S and Sturgis JN (2006) Dynamics and diffusion in photosynthetic membranes from Rhodospirillum photometricum. Biophys J 91: 3707–3717 Scheuring S, Reiss-Husson F, Engel A, Rigaud JL and Ranck JL (2001) High-resolution AFM topographs of Rubrivivax gelatinosus light-harvesting complex LH2. EMBO J 20: 3029–3035 Scheuring S, Seguin J, Marco S, Lévy D, Robert B and Rigaud JL (2003) Nanodissection and high-resolution imaging of the Rhodopseudomonas viridis photosynthetic core complex in native membranes by AFM. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 100: 1690–1693 Scheuring S, Rigaud JL and Sturgis JN (2004a) Variable LH2 stoichiometry and core clustering in native membranes of Rhodospirillum photometricum. EMBO J 23: 4127–413 Scheuring S, Sturgis JN, Prima V, Bernadac A, Lévy D and Rigaud JL (2004b) Watching the photosynthetic apparatus in native membranes. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 101: 11293–11297 Scheuring S, Francia F, Busselez J, Melandri BA, Rigaud J-L and Lévy D (2004c) Structural role of PufX in the dimerization of the photosynthetic core complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Biol Chem 279: 3620–3626 Scheuring S, Busselez J and Lévy D (2005a) Structure of the dimeric PufX-containing core complex of Rhodobacter blasticus by in situ atomic force microscopy. J Biol Chem 280: 1426–1431 Scheuring S, Lévy D and Rigaud JL (2005b) Watching the components of photosynthetic bacterial membranes and their in situ organisation by atomic force microscopy. Biochim Biophys Acta 1712: 109–127 Scheuring S, Gonçalves RP, Prima V and Sturgis JN (2006) The photosynthetic apparatus of Rhodopseudomonas palustris: Structures and organization. J Mol Biol 358: 83–96 Scheuring S, Boudier T and Sturgis JN (2007) From high-resolution AFM topographs to atomic models of supramolecular assemblies. J Struct Biol 159: 268–276 Siebert CA, Qian P, Fotiadis D, Engel A, Hunter CN and Bullough P (2004) The role of PufX in the molecular architecture of photosynthetic membranes in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. EMBO J 23: 690–700 Stroh A, Anderka O, Pfeiffer K, Yagi T, Finel M, Ludwig B and Schägger H (2004) Assembly of respiratory complexes I, III, and IV into NADH oxidase supercomplex stabilizes complex I in Paracoccus denitrificans. J Biol Chem 279: 5000–5007 Sturgis JN and Niederman RA (1996) The effect of different levels of the B800-850 light-harvesting complex on intracytoplasmic membrane development in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Arch Microbiol 165: 235–242 Takemoto J and Lascelles J (1973) Coupling between bacteriochlorophyll and membrane protein synthesis in Rhodopseudomonas
273
sphaeroides. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 70: 799–803 Tunnicliffe RB, Ratcliffe EC, Hunter CN and Williamson MP (2006) The solution structure of the PufX polypeptide from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. FEBS Lett. 580: 6967–6971 Van den Berg B, Clemons WM, Collinson I, Modis Y, Hartmann E, Harrison SC and Rapoport TA (2004) X-ray structure of a protein-conducting channel. Nature 427: 36–44 Varga AR and Staehelin LA. (1983) Spatial differentiation in photosynthetic and non-photosynthetic membranes of Rhodopseudomonas palustris. J Bacteriol 154: 1414–1430 VerBerkmoes NC, Shah MB, Lankford PK, Pelletier DA, Strader MB, Tabb DL, McDonald WH, Barton JW, Hurst GB, Hauser L, Davison BH, Beatty JT, Harwood CS, Tabita FR, Hettich RL and Larimer FW (2006) Determination and comparison of the baseline proteomes of the versatile microbe Rhodopseudomonas palustris under its major metabolic states. J. Proteome Res. 5: 287–298 Vos M, van Grondelle R, van der Kooij FW, van de Poll D, Amesz J and Duysens LMN (1986) Singlet-singlet annihilation at low temperatures in the antenna of purple bacteria. Biochim Biophys Acta 850: 501–512 Vos MH, van Dorssen RJ, Amesz J, van Grondelle R and Hunter CN (1988) The organisation of the photosynthetic apparatus of Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Studies of antenna mutants using singlet-singlet quenching. Biochim Biophys Acta 933: 132–140 Walz T, Jamieson SJ, Bowers CM, Bullough PA and Hunter CN (1998) Projection structures of three photosynthetic complexes from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: LH2 at 6Å, LH1 and LH1-RC at 25Å. J Mol Biol 282: 833–845 Wang ZY, Suzuki H, Kobayashi M and Nozawa T (2007) Solution structure of the Rhodobacter sphaeroides PufX membrane protein: Implications for the quinone exchange and proteinprotein Interactions. Biochemistry 46: 3635–3642 Westerhuis WHJ, Xiao Z and Niederman RA (1992) Oligomerization-state dependent spectroscopic properties of the B850 light-harvesting complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26.1. In Murata N (ed) Research in Photosynthesis, Vol. 1, pp 93–96. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Westerhuis WHJ, Vos M, van Grondelle R, Amesz J and Niederman RA (1998) Altered organization of light-harvesting complexes in phospholipid-enriched Rhodobacter sphaeroides chromatophores as determined by fluorescence yield and singlet-singlet annihilation measurements. Biochim Biophys Acta 1366: 317–329 Westerhuis WHJ, Sturgis JN, Ratcliffe EC, Hunter CN and Niederman RA (2002) Isolation, size estimates, and spectral heterogeneity of an oligomeric series of light-harvesting 1 complexes from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 41: 8698–8707 Young CS and Beatty JT (2003) Multi-level regulation of purple bacterial light-harvesting complexes. In: Green BR and Parson WW (ed) Light-harvesting antennas in photosynthesis (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 13), pp 449–470. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht
Chapter 15 From Atomic-Level Structure to Supramolecular Organization in the Photosynthetic Unit of Purple Bacteria Melih K. ùener* and Klaus Schulten* Beckman Institute, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Urbana, IL 61801, U.S.A.
Summary ............................................................................................................................................................... 275 I. Introduction..................................................................................................................................................... 276 II. Components of the Photosynthetic Unit ......................................................................................................... 278 III. Quantum Physics of Light-Harvesting and Excitation Energy Transfer.......................................................... 279 A. Effective Hamiltonian Formulation of Electronic Excitations ............................................................ 279 B. Excitation Energy Transfer in a Pigment Assembly ......................................................................... 280 C. Detrapping and Sharing of Excitations and the Sojourn Expansion................................................. 281 IV. Effect of Thermal Disorder on the Spectra of Light-Harvesting Complexes ................................................... 282 V. Physical Constraints Shaping the Structure of Individual Light-Harvesting Complexes................................. 284 VI. Supramolecular Organization of the Photosynthetic Unit ............................................................................... 286 VII. An Atomic-level Structural Model for a Photosynthetic Membrane Vesicle.................................................... 287 VIII. Light-Harvesting and Excitation Transfer across a Photosynthetic Membrane Vesicle ................................. 287 IX. Conclusions .................................................................................................................................................... 289 Acknowledgments ................................................................................................................................................. 290 References ............................................................................................................................................................ 290
Summary The purple bacterial photosynthetic unit (PSU) is a macromolecular assembly of remarkable simplicity that harvests sunlight with the cooperation of only half a dozen different kinds of proteins. This chapter provides a summary of recent research on the architectural and biophysical aspects of the PSU and its constituents. First, a brief overview is provided of the structure of light-harvesting components. Then the effects of thermal disorder and spectral universality on the light-harvesting function of the pigment-protein complexes is discussed, followed by an account of the physical constraints that shape the evolution of light-harvesting complexes in general. Finally, a summary is provided of recent research on the in silico assembly of an entire PSU in atomic detail. This supramolecular reconstruction of the PSU is made possible by the recent availability of not only the structural data on the individual constituent proteins but also on their global arrangement. The reconstruction is performed by combining data from X-ray crystallography, nuclear magnetic resonance, cryo-electron microscopy, and atomic force microscopy using computational modeling. The architecture of the PSU vesicle that emerges constitutes nearly two hundred light-harvesting proteins, containing around four thousand chlorophylls, which act cooperatively to maintain a very high quantum yield in a pigment array distributed over a pseudo-spherical intracytoplasmic membrane domain with an inner diameter of 60 nm.
*Authors for correspondence, email: [email protected], [email protected]
C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty (eds): The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria, pp. 275–294. © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V.
276 I. Introduction Photosynthetic organisms, and in turn almost all terrestrial life, are powered by the fixation of light energy in the form of chemical bonds. This stabilization and storage of energy is rarely performed by individual chlorophylls (Chls). As suggested already by the work of Emerson and Arnold (1932), up to thousands of Chls distributed over hundreds of proteins cooperate by forming a PSU which converts light energy into increasingly more stable forms usable by the cell. This is described in several reviews (Xu and Schulten, 1992; Hu et al., 1997; Ritz et al., 1998; Schulten, 1999; van Amerongen et al., 2000; Govindjee, 2000; Ritz and Schulten, 2001; Blankenship, 2002; Hu et al., 2002; Ritz et al., 2002; Şener and Schulten, 2005; Cogdell et al., 2006; Chapter 13, van Grondelle and Novoderezkhin; Chapter 14, Sturgis and Niederman). In a PSU, light energy initially migrates via radiationless excitation transfer (Oppenheimer, 1941; Förster, 1948; Arnold and Oppenheimer, 1950) from light-harvesting complexes to a reaction center (RC) initiating a charge separation (Marcus, 1956a,b; Onuchic et al., 1986) across the membrane, which is later utilized for ATP synthesis (Junge et al., 1997; Fillingame, 2000; Fillingame et al., 2000; Chapter 24, Feniouk and Junge). The structure and function of the biomolecules that constitute the PSU have been studied over many decades. Elucidation of individual aspects of light-harvesting in the PSU has brought Nobel prizes to Wilstätter (1915) and Fischer (1930) for the purification and the subsequent study of the chemical properties of Chls; to Karrer (1937) and Kuhn (1938) for determining the structure and function of carotenoids; to Deisenhofer, Huber, and Michel (1988) (Deisenhofer et al., 1985) for crystallographic determination of the RC structure; and to Marcus (1992) (Marcus, 1956a,b) for his theory of electron transfer reactions. The availability of high resolution atomic structures of the constituent light-harvesting proteins is essential for our current molecular level understanding of photosynthesis. In purple bacteria, the PSU is built from a small number of different protein types. In the order of Abbreviations: AFM – atomic force microscopy; bc1 complex – ubiquinol-cytochrome c2 oxidoreductase; BChl – bacteriochlorophyll; Chl – chlorophyll; cryo-EM – cryo-electron microscopy; LD – linear dichroism; LH1 – light-harvesting complex 1; LH2 – light-harvesting complex 2; PS I – Photosystem I; PSU – photosynthetic unit; RC – reaction center
Melih K. ùener and Klaus Schulten energy flow, these are the peripheral light-harvesting complex, LH2, the core light-harvesting complex, LH1 (McDermott et al., 1995; Karrasch et al., 1995; Hu et al., 1995; Koepke et al., 1996; Papiz et al., 2003; Roszak et al., 2003; Chapter 8, Gabrielsen et al.; Chapter 9, Bullough et al.), and the RC (Deisenhofer et al., 1985; Allen et al., 1987; Ermler et al., 1994; Camara-Artigas et al., 2002). The RC reduces quinone to hydroquinone as a result of electron transfer; subsequently the ubiquinol-cytochrome c2 oxidoreductase (bc1 complex) (Crofts et al., 1983; Velasco and Crofts, 1991; Gennis et al., 1993; Xia et al., 1997; Chapter 22, Berry et al., Chapter 23, Kramer et al.) oxidizes hydroquinone and reduces cytochrome c2, which completes the cycle by shuttling electrons back to the RC (Chapter 17, Axelrod et al.). The ATP-synthase (Junge et al., 1997; Fillingame et al., 2000; Fillingame, 2000; Chapter 24, Feniouk and Junge) makes use of the resulting proton gradient. The purple bacterial PSU displays a certain simplicity in contrast to its counterpart in plants and cyanobacteria. The components of the oxygenic light-harvesting apparatus (Krauss et al., 1993; Krauß et al., 1996; Jordan et al., 2001; Zouni et al., 2001; Ben-Shem et al., 2003; Bibby et al., 2003; Loll et al., 2005; Nelson and Yocum, 2006; Amunts et al., 2007; Murray and Barber, 2007) are notably more complex than their bacterial analogs as they are located higher on the evolutionary tree (Xiong et al., 2000). The structural simplicity displayed by the modular, cylindrically symmetric purple bacterial light-harvesting proteins also brings about a lower packing efficiency in terms of pigment density (see Fig. 1). The RC-LH1 complex contains 1 bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) per 72 amino acids and LH2 contains 1 BChl per 33 amino acids, whereas the cyanobacterial Photosystem I (PS I) contains 1 Chl per 27 amino acids (PS I is better compared to a RC-LH1 complex with two accompanying LH2 complexes, which together have approximately 1 BChl per 40 amino acids). However, the quantum efficiency itself is not strongly affected by the packing density and is nearly unity for both systems due to the Förster radius, defined as the distance over which energy transfer efficiency reduces by half, being much larger than the typical inter-(B)Chl separation. Quantum mechanics is fundamentally important for the description of photosynthesis as it is necessary to portray the interaction of light with living matter and the dynamics of the electronically excited quantum states of the pigments (van Grondelle et
Chapter 15
Supramolecular Organization of the Photosynthetic Unit
277
Fig. 1. Structural hierarchy and comparison of light-harvesting components. The modular architectures of the PSU light-harvesting complexes are readily visible from the corresponding structures. Three BChl molecules (illustrated in (a) in terms of the porphyrin ring) and two rhodopin glucoside molecules (rendered in the following in licorice representation in black and gray, respectively) accompany each α-β subunit (b), nine of which join to form the LH2 complex of Rps. acidophila, shown in side view (from the plane of the cytoplasmic membrane) in (c) and in top view in (d) (Papiz et al., 2003) (PDIB: 1NKZ). The same modularity is seen in the (pseudo-)cylindrical LH1 complex surrounding the RC shown in (e). A structural model for the S-shaped RC-LH1 dimer of Rba. sphaeroides based on cryo-EM images (Qian et al., 2005) was constructed in Şener et al. (2007), shown in (f) (BChls only). Finally, comparison with the cyanobacterial PS I (g) shows that evolutionarily more advanced photosynthetic species adapted a higher packing density at the expense of modularity.
al., 1994; Mukamel, 1995; Hu et al., 1997; Treutlein et al., 1988a,b; Schulten and Tesch, 1991; Nonella and Schulten, 1991; Xu and Schulten, 1994; Ritz et al., 1998; Hu et al., 1998; Hu and Schulten, 1998; Krueger et al., 1998; Sundström et al., 1999; Scholes et al., 1999; Tretiak et al., 2000; Damjanović et al., 2000a,b; Ritz et al., 2000; Şener and Schulten, 2002; Park et al., 2003; Şener et al., 2002, 2004,
2005, 2007; Damjanović et al., 2002a,b; Kosztin and Schulten, 2008; Chapter 13, van Grondelle and Novoderezhkin). This is further complicated by the presence of thermal disorder. Ordinary zero-temperature quantum theory is not sufficient to account for the spectral properties of the pigment complexes at a finite temperature. Thermal effects must be accounted for in terms of dynamic (Damjanović et al.,
278 2002a; Kosztin and Schulten, 2008) or static (Şener and Schulten, 2002) disorder models. The physics that governs the light-harvesting process, including the effects of finite temperature disorder, provides integral design constraints that appear to have shaped the evolution of pigment-protein complexes (Şener and Schulten, 2005). A combination of structural data with physicsbased computational models can accurately portray the light-harvesting function of a pigment-protein complex as discussed in the subsequent sections. However, a greater challenge lies in the description of hundreds of proteins that cooperate to form a functional unit. The supramolecular organization of the constituent proteins is difficult to determine and must be ascertained by combining atomic force microscopy (AFM) (Bahatyrova et al., 2004; Scheuring et al., 2004, 2005; Fotiadis et al., 2004), cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) (Jungas et al., 1999; Jamieson et al., 2002; Siebert et al., 2004; Qian et al., 2005), and linear dichroism (LD) (Frese et al., 2004) studies. Furthermore, the sheer size of the resulting molecular aggregate provides entirely new challenges for computational models. The intracytoplasmic vesicle which forms the PSU is a pseudo-spherical region of an inner diameter of approximately 60 nm. The energy transfer that follows light absorption must be described as a partially coherent and partially incoherent quantum mechanical process over this large domain containing thousands of BChls (Şener et al., 2007). The organization of this review is as follows: in the next section we discuss the structures of the proteins that constitute the PSU with emphasis on the pigment-protein complexes; the quantum mechanical aspects of light-harvesting and excitation transfer processes across a pigment-assembly, including one distributed over multiple proteins, are outlined in Section III. The effects of thermal disorder on the spectral properties of a pigment array are discussed in Section IV followed, in Section V, by a summary of the physical constraints that shape the structure of a light-harvesting complex; Section VI discusses the experimental data and theoretical models on the supramolecular organization of the PSU which is brought together in an atomistic model of an entire vesicle in Section VII. Finally, an account of the quantum mechanical process of light-harvesting and energy transfer across the resulting photosynthetic vesicle is given in Section VIII.
Melih K. ùener and Klaus Schulten II. Components of the Photosynthetic Unit Studies of light-harvesting components of the purple bacterial PSU currently benefit from the availability of a large body of structural information (McDermott et al., 1995; Koepke et al., 1996; Conroy et al., 2000; Camara-Artigas et al., 2002; Papiz et al., 2003; Fotiadis et al., 2004). Since it is beyond the scope of this manuscript to provide a comparison of all related structural data, the reader is instead referred to a recent review (Cogdell et al., 2006) and other chapters in this volume (Chapter 8, Gabrielsen et al.; Chapter 9, Bullough et al.). In the following, we present the structures and structural models for LH2, LH1 and RC complexes of the Rhodobacter (Rba.) sphaeroides PSU. These structures are of integral importance for the atomic-detail reconstruction of an entire intracytoplasmic membrane described in Section VII. A notable common feature of all PSU light-harvesting complexes is the modularity of their structure. A (pseudo-)cylindrical arrangement of α−β subunits (a pair of transmembrane helices) which non-covalently bind BChls and carotenoids forms the building blocks of both LH1 and LH2 (Chapter 10, Loach and ParkesLoach; Chapter 46, Braun and Fiedor). For instance, in Rhodospirillum (Rsp.) molischianum the pigmentprotein complexes display an eight-fold symmetry (Koepke et al., 1996) whereas in Rhodopseudomonas (Rps.) acidophila (McDermott et al., 1995; Papiz et al., 2003) and Rba. sphaeroides (Walz et al., 1998) the symmetry is nine-fold. A collection of the relevant light-harvesting complexes is displayed in Fig. 1. This modular construction is in great contrast to the analogous cyanobacterial and plant systems (Jordan et al., 2001; Bibby et al., 2003; Ben-Shem et al., 2003; Loll et al., 2005; Nelson and Yocum, 2006; Amunts et al., 2007; Murray and Barber, 2007) which show a greater degree of complexity (See Fig. 1g). The symmetry of the pigment-protein complexes is subtly broken in many cases. Notably, a small polypeptide, PufX, that likely plays a role in quinone traffic in and out of the RC, constitutes a discontinuity on the LH1 ring surrounding the RC. In Rba. sphaeroides RC, LH1, and PufX form S-shaped dimeric supercomplexes as observed in negative stain EM of intact membranes and cryo-EM projection maps of purified complexes (Jungas et al., 1999; Frese et al., 2000, 2004; Siebert et al., 2004; Qian et al., 2005; Scheuring and Sturgis, 2005). There are currently no atomic structures available for the RC-
Chapter 15
Supramolecular Organization of the Photosynthetic Unit
LH1-PufX supercomplex. A structural model of the pigments based on cryo-EM data (Qian et al., 2005) was constructed and described in Şener et al. (2007) as shown in Fig. 1(f). Recent data indicate that the RC-LH1-PufX supercomplex is actually bent out of the plane in a manner consistent with a curvature which corresponds to that of the spherical invaginations of the intracytoplasmic membrane (Chapter 9, Bullough et al.). For every RC there are about five to ten LH2 units in a typical PSU. In Rba. sphaeroides, the LH2 contains a total of 27 BChls, 18 of which form the strongly coupled B850 band whereas the remaining 9 form the weakly coupled B800 band. The stronger coupling of the B850 BChls is a direct reflection of the corresponding inter-pigment distances (around 10 Å vs. 20 Å). The stronger coupling results in delocalization of B850 excitonic states over the entire ring, which subsequently is broken by the effects of thermal disorder (Şener and Schulten, 2002; Damjanović et al., 2002a; Kosztin and Schulten, 2008). In LH1, excitonically coupled BChls absorb at 875 nm. In addition to the light-harvesting complexes, LH2, LH1, and RC, the purple bacterial PSU contains biomolecules which convert electronic excitation energy to a charge gradient and finally to stable chemical bonds. Upon receiving an electronic excitation the RC initiates a transmembrane electron transfer reducing the membrane-diffusible electron carrier quinone to hydroquinone. Subsequently, hydroquinones diffuse through the cell membrane to the cytochrome bc1 complex (Crofts et al., 1983; Velasco and Crofts, 1991; Gennis et al., 1993; Xia et al., 1997), which in turn oxidizes hydroquinone by transferring the electrons to the cytochrome c2 complex while pumping protons across the membrane. The proton gradient, thus created, is used for ATP synthesis by ATP synthase (Junge et al., 1997; Fillingame et al., 2000; Fillingame, 2000). The circuit is completed by the cytochrome c2 which shuttles the electrons back to the RC resetting the system. With the exception of cytochrome c2 all aforementioned components are embedded in the membrane. The components responsible for the electron transfer reactions or the process of ATP synthesis are not considered further in this review as the vesicle construction in Section VII concentrates explicitly on light-harvesting complexes only. This focus also reflects the absence of the bc1 complex and ATP synthase from AFM data of the membranes (Bahatyrova et al., 2004; Scheuring et al., 2004, 2005; Frese et al., 2004; Fotiadis et al.,
279
2004) which renders it impossible to unambiguously assign locations for these complexes in the membrane (see Section VI). III. Quantum Physics of Light-Harvesting and Excitation Energy Transfer A. Effective Hamiltonian Formulation of Electronic Excitations Interaction of light with biomolecules is necessarily described by quantum theory. Past research has shown that the biophysical processes involved in photosynthesis can be accurately modeled in atomic detail at the quantum mechanical level (Hu et al., 1997, 1998; Ritz et al., 1998; Hu and Schulten, 1998; Sundström et al., 1999; Scholes et al., 1999; Tretiak et al., 2000; Şener and Schulten, 2002; Şener et al., 2002, 2004, 2005, 2007; Damjanović et al., 2002a; Kosztin and Schulten, 2008). Central to these formulations is the construction of an effective Hamiltonian for the light-harvesting pigment assembly in terms of electronic excited states. In the simplest case, such a Hamiltonian is given in terms of the lowest excited state of the BChl molecule, the Qy state (Scheer, 1991). Therefore, a set of basis states for an effective Hamiltonian is given by | i 〉 = |φ1 : φ2 : … φ*i : … : φN〉 in which the ith BChl is Qy-excited and all other BChls are in their ground states. In this basis the effective Hamiltonian is given by (Hu et al., 1997, 1998; Ritz et al., 1998; Damjanović et al., 1999; Tretiak et al., 2000; Damjanović et al., 2000a; Ritz et al., 2001; Şener and Schulten, 2002; Şener et al., 2002) ⎛ ε1 V12 ⎜V ε2 H = ⎜ 21 ⎜L L ⎜ ⎝ VN 1 VN 2
V13 V23 L VN 3
L V1N ⎞ L V2 N ⎟ ⎟ L L⎟ ⎟ L εN ⎠
(1)
where N is the total number of BChls, εi denotes the site energy of excited BChl i, and Vij are the interBChl electronic couplings. For most typical interBChl distances the so-called excitonic couplings Vij are dominated by the direct Coulomb contribution (Förster, 1948) rather than the electron exchange term (Dexter, 1953). For BChls that are sufficiently far apart the couplings Vij can be approximated by the induced dipole-induced dipole interactions of the BChl Qy
Melih K. ùener and Klaus Schulten
280 states, which are given by
(
)(
⎛ d ⋅d 3 r ij ⋅ d i r ij ⋅ d j i j Vij = C ⎜ − 3 ⎜⎝ rij rij5
) ⎞⎟ ⎟⎠
between BChls i and j is given by (Förster, 1948; Ritz et al., 2001; Şener et al., 2002) (2)
where di is the unit vector along the transition dipole moment of the Qy state of BChl i, and C is a constant determined empirically. The value of the constant C has been taken to be 348000 Å3 cm–1 in order to reproduce LH2 exciton spectra (Knox and Spring, 2003; Şener and Schulten, 2002; Şener et al., 2007). As the inter-pigment distances approach 10 Å or less, the dipole-dipole approximation becomes increasingly inaccurate, requiring the evaluation of the couplings by quantum chemistry methods (Cory et al., 1998; Tretiak et al., 2000; Şener et al., 2002). Specifically, the nearest neighbor couplings of the LH2 B850 ring are taken to be 363 cm–1 and 320 cm–1 (Tretiak et al., 2000; Şener and Schulten, 2002); the nearest neighbor couplings of the LH1 B875 ‘S-band’ are taken to be 300 cm–1 and 233 cm–1 (Koolhaas et al., 1998; Damjanović et al., 2000a). The intra- and inter-subunit couplings alternate in both proteins because of the modular structure. The special pair BChl coupling is taken to be 500 cm–1 (Eccles et al., 1988; Damjanović et al., 2000a). All other couplings are computed according to the dipole-dipole approximation (Eq. 2) regardless of whether the pigments belong to different proteins. BChl site energies are determined by spectroscopic data as well as taken from earlier models (Eccles et al., 1988; Koolhaas et al., 1998; Groot et al., 1998; Damjanović et al., 2000a; Ritz et al., 2001; Şener and Schulten, 2002). B. Excitation Energy Transfer in a Pigment Assembly The effective Hamiltonian given by Eq. (1) determines on the one hand the spectral properties and on the other hand the energy transfer dynamics of the assembly. The description of spectral properties at finite temperature is discussed in the next section whereas this subsection provides an overview of excitation transfer dynamics according to Förster theory (Förster, 1948; Ritz et al., 2001). In a pigment-protein complex that is under the influence of thermal disorder electronic excitations travel in the form of excitons that are delocalized over only a few pigments. The rate of excitation transfer
Tij =
2 2π Vij J ij ,
J ij = ∫ SiD ( E )S jA ( E ) dE
(3)
where Vij are the electronic couplings introduced in Eq. (1) and Jij is the spectral overlap between the donor emission spectrum SiD(E) and the acceptor absorption spectrum SjA(E), which are in general temperature dependent. Transfer times between nearby BChls are typically in the sub-picosecond range. The probability pi(t) that BChl i is electronically excited at a given time t is governed by a master equation d p (t ) = ∑ K ij p j (t ) dt i j ⎞ ⎛ K ij = T ji − δ ij ⎜ ∑ Tik + k diss + δ i,RC k ET ⎟ ⎠ ⎝ k
(4)
where δi,RC is one if the BChl i belongs to the reaction center and zero otherwise. The dissipation rate of kdiss=(1 ns)–1 and the electron transfer rate of kET = (3 ps)–1 are determined empirically. The average excitation lifetime τ, the quantum yield q, and the dissipation probability d can be solved from the master equation Eq. (4) to yield (Ritz et al., 2001; Şener et al., 2002) τ=−
1 1 K −1 1 N
(5)
q=−
1 k RC K −1 1 N ET
(6)
d=−
1 k 1 K −1 1 N diss
(7)
where |RC 〉 ≡ Σi δi,RC |i〉 and |1〉 ≡ Σi|i〉. The quantum yield q is related to the dissipation probability d by the relation q = 1 – d = 1 – kdissτ. The excitation migration model thus introduced in terms of single-exciton hopping events is insufficient to adequately describe transfer events involving strongly coupled BChl groups such as the B850 BChls of LH2, B875 BChls of LH1, or the special pair BChls in the RC. This model must be superseded
Chapter 15
Supramolecular Organization of the Photosynthetic Unit
by one that involves coherent energy transfer between resonant states of neighboring BChl clusters. Thus, the rate of excitation transfer TDA between a donor BChl cluster D and an acceptor BChl cluster A follows from the assumption that the donor excited states are populated according to the Boltzmann distribution (Ritz et al., 2001; Şener et al., 2004, 2005) − E D /k T
TDA
2 2π e m B = VmnDA ∫ dE S mD ( E )S nA ( E ) ∑ ∑ D − E /k T m∈D n∈A ∑ e l B l∈D
(8) where EDm are the donor energy levels; spectral overlaps are computed similar to Eq. (3). In terms of the cluster-transfer rates TDA (Eq. 8), the excitation lifetime τ and the quantum yield q of the system is given by (Ritz et al., 2001; Şener et al., 2002, 2004, 2007) τ=−
1 1 K −1 0 M M cl
q=−
1 k RC K cl −1 0 M ET
(9)
⎞ ⎛ ( K cl )ij = T ji − δ ij ⎜ k ET δ i,RC + k diss + ∑ Tik ⎟ ⎠ ⎝ k
Section VII contains nearly 4000 BChls and therefore is studied within the framework of Förster theory. C. Detrapping and Sharing of Excitations and the Sojourn Expansion An electronic excitation that arrives at a RC does not always initiate a charge transfer event and may instead escape the RC to be recaptured at the same or another RC. This nonzero detrapping probability, which is around 20–30%, results from the excitation back-transfer rate of (8 ps)–1 at the RC being not small compared to the charge separation rate of (3 ps)–1 (Timpmann et al., 1995; Bernhardt and Trissl, 2000; Amesz and Neerken, 2002; Ritz et al., 1998; Şener et al., 2007). Subsequently, the excitation migration process in the PSU can be described in terms of an expansion involving repeated detrapping and retrapping (sojourn) events. This sojourn expansion of the average excitation lifetime (Eq. 9) is based on separating from Kcl the operator ∆cl that describes detrapping events from any of the RCs (Şener et al., 2002, 2004, 2007) K cl ≡ κ cl + ∆ cl M
where |0〉 denotes the initial state and Kcl is the M×M matrix given by (10)
Here M is the number of BChl clusters. All indices run over clusters and not individual pigments. For the PSU, separate BChl clusters include the B850 and B800 bands for the LH2, B875 band for the LH1, and the RC BChls. Of these groups, the LH2 B800 band is actually not very strongly coupled and is treated as a cluster only for computational simplicity. The Förster theory formulation outlined above becomes increasingly less accurate for strong coupling, fast timescale processes in which case it can be supplemented by the more accurate modified Redfield theory (Yang and Fleming, 2002; Rutkauskas et al., 2005; van Grondelle and Novoderezhkin, 2006; Chapter 13, van Grondelle and Novoderezkhin). However, the computational complexity of the latter method is considerable and its application does not typically go beyond systems containing several dozen pigments. The intracytoplasmic membrane vesicle introduced in
281
∆ cl ≡ ∑
∑T
k =1 j∈RC
jk
k
j
(11)
The subscript ‘cl’ indicates that the matrix indices refer to the BChl clusters rather than individual BChls. The matrix Kcl can be expanded in terms of repeated detrapping events K cl −1 = (κ cl + ∆ cl ) −1 = κ cl −1 − κ cl −1 ∆ cl κ cl −1 + κ cl −1 ∆ cl κ cl −1 ∆ cl κ cl −1 − L
(12) Subsequently, the average excitation lifetime τ is given in terms of the expansion τ = τ 0 + τ1 + τ 2 L
(
∆ cl κ −1 τ k = − 1 κ −1 cl cl
)
k −1
0 ,k >0
(13)
The term τ0 is the first usage time corresponding to an excitation lifetime with no detrapping events. The expansion in Eq. (13) can be expressed in terms of detrapping and cross-transfer probabilities to yield
Melih K. ùener and Klaus Schulten
282 (Şener et al., 2002, 2004, 2007)
(
)
τ = τ 0 + τ soj ⋅ 1 M − Q X ⋅ Q D
(14)
where (τsoj)j is the sojourn time defined as the average excitation lifetime subsequent to an immediate detrapping from RC j, (QD)j is the detrapping probability from the same reaction center, and 1M denotes the identity matrix of dimension M. The term (QX)jk is the conditional cross-transfer probability between the RCs j and k corresponding to a retrapping of excitation at RCj subsequent to a detrapping at RCk: Q jkX = − k ET RC j K cl−1 Tk
(15)
where |Tk〉 is the quantum state resulting from a detrapping event at RCk. In Section VIII these crosstrapping probabilities are presented as a measure of excitation sharing between up to 36 RCs of a PSU vesicle (Şener et al., 2007). IV. Effect of Thermal Disorder on the Spectra of Light-Harvesting Complexes Zero temperature quantum theory is insufficient to describe light-harvesting processes accurately at physiological temperatures. Finite temperature effects are more than a mere modeling challenge for studies of pigment-protein complexes since photosynthetic systems depend on thermal disorder for their function. Thermal broadening of spectral line-shapes enables efficient energy transfer across a greater range of frequencies. For example, the quantum yield in Photosystem I in cyanobacteria and plants (Kennis et al., 2001; Melkozernov, 2001; Melkozernov et al., 2001; Gobets et al., 2001; Şener et al., 2002, 2004; Şener and Schulten, 2005) drops with decreasing temperature from nearly unity at room temperature for a wide range of wavelengths to about 50% or less and becomes wavelength dependent as the excitation runs the risk of being trapped at low energy pigments without reaching the RC. Effects of thermal disorder on spectral properties can be introduced either as temporal averages of the dynamics of one light-harvesting complex or as ensemble averages of multiple complexes. The first approach is referred to as dynamic disorder (Damjanović et al., 2002a; Kosztin and Schulten,
2008) whereas the second is called static disorder (Şener and Schulten, 2002). These two different models of thermal disorder are, in principle, related to one another by virtue of the ergodic theorem. The effect of dynamic disorder on the electronic properties of light-harvesting complexes was studied in Damjanović et al. (2002a) combining molecular dynamics (MD) with quantum chemistry and a polaron model analysis. The exciton-phonon coupling that enters into the polaron model, and the corresponding phonon spectral function were derived from MD and quantum chemistry simulations. It was predicted that excitons in the B850 BChl ring are delocalized over five pigments at room temperature. The polaron model permits the calculation of the absorption and circular dichroism spectra of the B850 excitons from the sole knowledge of the autocorrelation function of the excitation energies of individual BChls (Damjanović et al., 2002a; Kosztin and Schulten, 2008). Static disorder in a thermal ensemble of BChl rings was described in Şener and Schulten (2002) for the B850 band of LH2 in Rsp. molischianum using analytical methods of random matrix theory (Efetov, 1995; Guhr et al., 1998; Şener, 1999). Random matrix models introduce disorder at the level of the effective Hamiltonian formalism by adding a random disorder term to the noise-free, zero-temperature Hamiltonian. The physics of such deterministic-plus-random systems has traditionally been studied analytically in the large N-limit (N being the dimension of the Hamiltonian). However, typical light-harvesting systems are mesoscopic in size (for example, N=16 for the B850 band of LH2 in Rsp. molischianum), resulting in considerable challenges in adopting readily available analytical methods. Thermal disorder models of light-harvesting complexes aim to compute spectral quantities such as the absorption spectrum αT (ω) and the density of states ρT (ω) at a finite temperature T as a function of the zero-temperature spectral properties of the Hamiltonian (Eq. 1). In terms of the effective Hamiltonian in Eq. (1), the density of states and the directionally averaged absorption spectrum are defined by N
ρT (ω) =
∑ δ(ω − E )
(16)
i
i=1
α T (ω) =
4π 2 ωn 3c
∑D i
2 i
δ(ω − Ei )
(17)
Chapter 15
Supramolecular Organization of the Photosynthetic Unit
where Di is the transition dipole moment for the eigenstate i and the ensemble averages are defined with respect to a temperature dependent weight function. A simple approach to introducing thermal disorder is the Gaussians-on-sticks picture of spectral quantities which ‘dress’ the discrete spectrum N
ρ0 (ω) = ∑ δ(ω − Ek ) k =1
of the effective Hamiltonian H of the pigment complex with Gaussians: N
ρT (ω) : ∑ k =1
(ω − E ) exp(− k
2υ 2
2
)
283
describing the overall width of disorder and is mostly independent of the shape and the total number of the disorder terms Ri (Efetov, 1995; Guhr et al., 1998; Şener, 1999; Şener and Schulten, 2002) (see Fig. 2). Spectral universality becomes more accurate as the system size N increases and becomes exact for N→∞. This result is conceptually similar to the ubiquity of the central limit theorem which establishes that summing up random variables will generally yield a Gaussian distribution regardless of the shape of the original random function. Spectral universality is the reason why many diverse and disjoint disorder models succeed in modeling bulk thermal effects in light-harvesting systems whereas they are bound to fail to distinguish various forms of disorder from one another. Since spectral universality theorems of random
where the temperature dependent width υ is determined heuristically. Unfortunately, this approach becomes highly inaccurate as multiple energy levels become near degenerate (as compared to the disorder parameter υ). This is because the energy levels Ek(T) of a disordered quantum system actually begin to separate as a result of the avoided level crossings during the onset of disorder (Efetov, 1995; Andreev et al., 1996; Guhr et al., 1998). Another approach for treating static disorder is to numerically diagonalize an ensemble of effective Hamiltonians containing noise terms H T = H 0 + R1 + R2 + L
(18)
where the random terms Ri (in the simplest case only a single term R) are chosen from ensembles of matrices with given weight functions. For example, site energy fluctuations may be assigned as diagonal disorder terms whereas thermal fluctuations of interpigment couplings are introduced as off-diagonal disorder terms (Cogdell et al., 2006). The shapes of the disorder terms Ri are typically taken as Gaussians, and their widths are determined empirically. However, as a result of the spectral universality theorems of random matrix theory (Guhr et al., 1998), different ‘shapes’ of disorder (such as diagonal versus off-diagonal disorder) are largely indistinguishable from one another in terms of their effects on spectra. Thus, the average spectrum of the random ensemble in Eq. (18) is dependent largely on a single parameter
Fig. 2. Spectral universality under different classes of disorder. The density of states (a) (Eq. 16) and the absorption spectrum (b) (Eq. 17) for the LH2 B850 band of Rsp. molischianum are shown for three different forms of disorder (Şener and Schulten, 2002). Real-symmetric (orthogonal) disorder: solid line, complex-hermitian (unitary) disorder: dashed line, diagonal disorder: dotted line. Only the zero-temperature spectrum and the width of each disorder distribution determines the bulk shape of the finite temperature spectral properties, not the class of disorder. The approximate agreement between different forms of disorder shown here becomes more pronounced as the system size N increases.
Melih K. ùener and Klaus Schulten
284 matrix theory (Guhr et al., 1998) imply that various forms of disorder result in the same spectral shape, it is convenient to compute spectral quantities for the mathematically simplest of disorder models. Analytical results are most easily obtained for unitary disorder (Guhr et al., 1998). In Şener and Schulten (2002) the finite temperature density of states of a system of arbitrary size N was analytically evaluated. The result can be expressed in a closed and compact, if combinatorially complex, form in terms of the system size N and the eigenvalues Ei (Şener and Schulten, 2002): ρT ( ω ) =
∞
1 dα A0 A1 π ∫0 ∞
A0 =
N 1 Im ∫ dξ e -ξ Π i=1 π -∞
N ⎛ −η dη e Π ⎜η− ∫ i=1 ⎝ −∞ ∞
A1 =
1
2
2
ξ − iε − 1 2υ T
(ω + υ α − E )
1
2 T
2υ T
i
⎞
( ω + υ α − E )⎟ 2 T
i
⎠
(19) Here the only free parameter is the disorder term υT corresponding to the overall width of disorder.
An effective field theory approximation to Eq. (19) can be introduced for systems of larger N where the combinatorial cost to evaluate this analytical expression becomes high. None of the aforementioned computational methods for modeling thermal disorder effects has so far been applied to systems containing more than a handful of pigment-protein complexes. It remains a challenge to properly account for thermal effects for a system as large as the PSU vesicle consisting of up to 200 light-harvesting proteins and four thousand pigments as presented in Section VII. V. Physical Constraints Shaping the Structure of Individual Light-Harvesting Complexes A comparison of pigment-protein complexes from both oxygenic and anoxygenic species reveals a number of common design principles dictated by the physics of the light-harvesting process shaping the evolution of the related proteins. These principles, which are also relevant for engineering artificial
light-harvesting systems, are briefly summarized below; see also the reviews of Şener and Schulten (2005); Cogdell et al. (2006); Chapter 10, Loach and Parkes-Loach; Chapter 46, Braun and Fiedor. A comparison is also provided between the purple bacterial photosynthetic apparatus and the oxygenic systems in terms of their architectural contrast. The overall efficiency of a light-harvesting system is constrained by any bottlenecks in the sequence of processes leading to the storage of energy in the form of chemical bonds. Therefore, photosynthesis needs to be efficient at all the steps of photon absorption, excitation migration, and charge transfer. As discussed in the previous section thermal broadening of line shapes increases both the range of frequencies over which photons are absorbed as well as the efficiency of resonant energy transfer between neighboring pigments. It is not a coincidence that the spread of site energies in the PSU of around 230 cm–1 (Sumi, 2000, 2001; Cogdell et al., 2006) is of the same magnitude as kBT (for T=300 K). A funnel-like arrangement of BChl energies (B800 → B850 → B875) facilitates a downhill transfer of energy in the PSU. However, a comparison with Photosystem I (Damjanović et al., 2002b; Şener et al., 2002) reveals that an energy funnel toward the RC is not necessary for a high quantum yield at room temperature. In fact, the socalled red Chl pool of Photosystem I (Pålsson et al., 1998; Gobets et al., 2001; Zazubovich et al., 2002), which constitutes a trap for excitation at cryogenic temperatures, extends the functionality of light-harvesting into longer wavelengths without a noticeable loss of efficiency. It follows from Eq. (3) that efficient transfer of energy between pigments requires, in addition to a strong spectral overlap Jij, a strong inter-coupling coupling Vij. This is achieved by inter-pigment separations that are much smaller than the Förster radius. Thus, a high pigment density facilitates more efficient excitation transfer. As mentioned in the Introduction, the pigment density increases in the evolutionarily more advanced plant and cyanobacterial light-harvesting complexes. The modular structure of the purple bacterial light-harvesting complexes and the implication of their symmetry on the nature of excitonic quantum states appear to be largely irrelevant when thermal disorder effects are taken into account. Exciton bands that would be delocalized over the entire ring at zerotemperature are localized over a handful of pigments (Damjanović et al., 2002a) at physiological tempera-
Chapter 15
Supramolecular Organization of the Photosynthetic Unit
tures. Thus modularity was likely a structural artifact at the early stages of photosynthesis evolution that was superseded later. A similar scenario of modularity based on gene-duplication was also proposed for the early evolution of Photosystem I (Nelson and BenShem, 2004; Kosztin and Schulten, 2008). A notable exception to the aforementioned demand on high pigment density is the immediate vicinity of the RC. Both bacterial and plant systems display a no-fly zone (also called a cordon sanitaire) referring to an absence of pigments within about 20 Å of the electron transfer chain (see Fig. 3). This is to avoid the loss of transported electrons along the electron transfer chain. Electron transfer requires a direct overlap of electronic wavefunctions and therefore direct spatial proximity between pigments. The electron transfer rate decays exponentially with distance. In contrast, excitation transfer decays as 1/r6 where r is the pigment-pigment distance. Thus, with a ‘no-fly zone’-architecture it is possible to maintain efficient excitation transfer into the RC without having a substantial loss of electrons away from the electron transfer chain. Not surprisingly, the RC is the most demanding structural component of the light-harvesting assembly. For example, photosystems I and II in cyanobacteria have developed special mechanisms to deal with iron deficiency which poses a challenge on the synthesis and assembly of new RCs (Bibby et al., 2001a,b, 2003). Reflecting this prominence of the RC, photosynthetic systems including the PSU have evolved to regulate the number of pigments per RC in a way to avoid keeping the RCs idle. Thus, the total number of BChls in the PSU times the light intensity (in terms of photons/BChl/second) roughly equals the charge separation rate times the number of RCs. Therefore, growth conditions, especially the light intensity, affect the stoichiometry of the PSU (Şener et al., 2007). Oxygenic and anoxygenic light-harvesting systems display differences in terms of the optimization of their pigment architectures. A robustness and optimality of Chl geometries and site energies was reported for cyanobacterial and plant photosystems I and II (Şener et al., 2002, 2004; Damjanović et al., 2002b; Yang et al., 2003; Vasil’ev and Bruce, 2004; Vasil’ev et al., 2004). Robustness is manifested in the form of a parameter insensitivity, enabling a high quantum yield irrespective of site energy fluctuations resulting from thermal disorder or modifications to the geometry of the pigment network. Another aspect of robustness is
285
Fig. 3. Exclusion of chlorophylls from the immediate vicinity of the RC. Both in anoxygenic (a; RC-LH1) and oxygenic (b; PS I) light-harvesting systems a ‘no-fly-zone’ surrounds the RC, where the presence of pigments that are not part of the electron transfer chain is excluded to prevent the escape of electrons subsequent to the trapping of excitation.
graceful degradation, referring to a tolerance for the loss of individual components. Removing a pigment at random from the network usually does not have a substantial effect on the overall efficiency. Graceful degradation provides a protective buffer against photodamage and constitutes part of the mechanism that photosynthetic systems have evolved to handle harmful effects of excess light energy. Optimality, on the other hand, indicates that within the narrow range (near unity) of quantum yields corresponding to different pigment geometries and site energies, the one corresponding to the actual pigment architecture
286 found in nature is nearly the highest. This is likely a result of the selective pressure during the evolution projecting itself on to one of the dimensions of the fitness landscape (the quantum yield). It is important to note that while the aforementioned robustness, which follows largely from the high pigment density as compared with the Förster radius, is universally present in oxygenic and anoxygenic systems alike, the signs of optimality of the pigment geometry are only prominent for the oxygenic photosynthetic systems. No comparable optimization of BChl geometries was reported among the modular architectures of the evolutionarily simpler purple bacterial PSU. It is possible that the circular, modular arrangement of pigments in LH2 and LH1 is simply an artifact of the simplest feasible assembly scheme, namely one based on identical subunits. Thermal disorder at physiological temperatures likely overrides any quantum mechanical concerns which would be valid at zero temperature. The regular arrangement of pigments is apparently traded for higher pigment density at higher tiers of evolution. VI. Supramolecular Organization of the Photosynthetic Unit Structure and function of individual light-harvesting proteins discussed above must be reconciled with the global architecture of the PSU before system-level functional models can be constructed that connect multiple steps of the light-harvesting process. In this section and the next a computational model for a PSU vesicle (Şener et al., 2007) is presented that contains hundreds of light-harvesting proteins based on AFM, cryo-EM, LD, and X-ray crystallography data. EM of negatively stained thin sections of photosynthetically grown cells shows that the PSU of Rba. sphaeroides forms pseudo-spherical intracytoplasmic protrusions with an inner diameter of approximately 60 nm. Radiolabeling, biochemical, and spectroscopic techniques reveal that it is the clustering of RC-LH1-PufX and LH2 pigment-protein complexes combined with lipid biosynthesis that is responsible for the membrane curvature causing the PSU to invaginate (Niederman et al., 1979; Hunter et al., 1985; Pugh et al., 1998; Hunter et al., 2005). This curvature-inducing assembly process, likely akin to the clustering of heavy beads on an elastic surface, has been modeled recently using an application of colloid theory (Frese et al., 2008) as well as molecular
Melih K. ùener and Klaus Schulten dynamics simulations (Chandler et al., 2008). See Chapter 9, Bullough et al. for further discussion of membrane curvature. In a PSU vesicle up to two hundred light-harvesting complexes containing around three to four thousand chlorophylls surround approximately 30 RCs (Hunter et al., 1985). Recent AFM data (Bahatyrova et al., 2004; Scheuring et al., 2004, 2005) reveal that the RC-LH1-PufX dimers form linear arrays that are surrounded by a ‘lake’ of LH2s. Notably, neither the bc1 complex nor the ATP synthase has been observed directly in AFM images. A likely explanation of the absence of the bc1 complexes from AFM data is that they may populate the neck region of the vesicle which is not imaged by AFM. In fact, noninvaginated cytoplasmic membrane regions not only lack photosynthetic complexes, but are also enriched in respiratory components (Parks and Niederman, 1978). ATP synthase is expected to be found in most, but not necessarily all, vesicles at a ratio of about one per vesicle; some vesicles possibly lack a directly associated ATP synthase complex (Feniouk et al., 2002) which argues that ATP synthase is located outside of the bulbous chromatophore. The stoichiometry of the bc1 complex was suggested earlier to be one bc1 complex per two RCs (Crofts et al., 1983) and nine bc1 complexes per vesicle (Velasco and Crofts, 1991). However, a recent model of electron transport components concludes about five bc1 complexes per vesicle (Geyer and Helms, 2006). The precise stoichiometry of the PSU depends on growth conditions, especially the light intensity. While there is not sufficient information to unambiguously model the electron transport components, a model of the light-harvesting components of the PSU vesicle can be constructed by combining a multitude of AFM images. This construction requires, firstly, the mapping of the planar domains containing LH2 and RC-LH1-PufX complexes on to a spherical region. This plane-to-sphere mapping process is outlined in the next section (Snyder, 1987). Subsequently, the individual LH-domains must be oriented with respect to one another and to the cytoplasmic membrane. Adopting a directional convention that the vesicle is connected at its ‘south pole’ to the cell membrane, LD data (Frese et al., 2004) and the observed kinetics of LH2 incorporation (Niederman et al., 1976, 1979; Hunter et al., 2005) suggest that the RC-LH1-PufX dimers are oriented in a north-south alignment. This is also consistent with an aggregation model of the vesicle where the addition of new RC-LH1-PufX
Chapter 15
Supramolecular Organization of the Photosynthetic Unit
dimers with accompanying LH2s deepens the invagination toward the cytoplasm. In fact, elongated RC-LH1-PufX dimer arrays were reported in mutants lacking LH2 (Jungas et al., 1999; Frese et al., 2000; Siebert et al., 2004). VII. An Atomic-level Structural Model for a Photosynthetic Membrane Vesicle In this section, the spatial arrangement of the lightharvesting components discussed above are combined with the atomic structures of individual complexes to provide a structural model for a PSU vesicle at atomic-detail level. There are several difficulties associated with combining planar AFM images (Bahatyrova et al., 2004) to produce a pseudo-spherical chromatophore model. First, the preparation process for AFM imaging tears and distorts the vesicle patches during their flattening. This process is not area-preserving and alters the packing density of the light-harvesting complexes. Also, the vesicles are not necessarily of an exact spherical shape and their approximate diameter prior to imaging is not known. Finally, the relative alignment of individual patches with respect to one another is not known. The patches were aligned in accord with the LD data of intact membrane vesicles (Frese et al., 2004). The conversion of planar images onto spherical patches was performed using an area-preserving transformation, the inverse-Mollweide projection (Snyder, 1987; Şener et al., 2007), that maps a point (x,y) on the plane onto a point (φ,λ) on a sphere of radius R, where φ is the latitude and λ is the longitude
πx / R
(20)
2 2 cos ( Θ )
where
(
Θ = sin −1 y / 2 R
)
on the plane. Another advantage of the transformation in Eq. (20) is that it maps an infinitesimal circle on the plane onto a circle of equal area on the target sphere. Thus, deformations of the relative geometry of the light-harvesting complexes are minimized as long as multiple small patches are used instead of a few large ones. The inverse-Mollweide transformation (Eq. 20) was applied for mapping the atomic structures of the individual complexes introduced in Section II onto a spherical vesicle. However, the transformation was used not for mapping individual atomic coordinates, but the center of mass and the relative orientation of each complex, thereby avoiding distortion artifacts within individual complexes. The resulting assembly was then manually edited to remove steric clashes as well as gaps between proteins. A lower than natural packing density would adversely affect the overall quantum efficiency of the system. Two vesicle assemblies with a 60 nm inner diameter were constructed in Şener et al. (2007) corresponding to different light intensity growth conditions. The first vesicle contains 18 RC-LH1-PufX dimers and 101 LH2 complexes with a total of 3879 BChls and an overall BChl:RC ratio of 108, corresponding to a highlight growth condition. The second vesicle contains 9 RC-LH1-PufX dimers and 144 LH2 complexes with a total of 4464 BChls and an overall BChl:RC ratio of 248, corresponding to a low-light growth condition. The overall BChl:RC ratios follow those obtained for wild type chromatophores (Aagaard and Sistrom, 1972). The high-light vesicle is depicted in Fig. 4 whereas planar projections of both vesicles are shown in Fig. 6. VIII. Light-Harvesting and Excitation Transfer across a Photosynthetic Membrane Vesicle
⎛ 2Θ + sin ( 2Θ ) ⎞ φ = sin −1 ⎜ ⎟ π ⎠ ⎝ λ=
287
(21)
The inverse-Mollweide projection is used in geography to produce the familiar rendering of the globe which maps the circles of latitude onto parallel lines
The atomic-level reconstruction of the PSU vesicles outlined in the previous section makes it possible to describe the excitation migration process over a pigment network stretched across hundreds of proteins. Following the methods presented in Section III, an effective Hamiltonian (Eq. 1) for the pigment ensemble (see Figs. 4, 5, and 6) was constructed in Şener et al. (2007) and the rates of excitation transfer between BChl groups (B800, B850, B875, and RC BChls; see Section III.B and Fig. 5) were computed according to Eq. (8). Not surprisingly, the excitation transfer rates for
288
Fig. 4. Organization of the PSU from the supramolecular architecture to individual chlorophylls and the energy transfer network. The high-light adapted vesicle model for Rba. sphaeroides (Şener et al., 2007) is shown. The three different constituent proteins and their BChls are shown: LH2, LH1, and RC. From left to right three different rendering styles are featured. On the left, the light-harvesting proteins are shown in the representation (backbone only, no pigments); in the middle, the proteins are rendered transparently, revealing the BChls, represented by their porphyrin rings; on the right, only the BChls are shown but this time together with their respective electronic couplings (Eq. 1). Only the strongest couplings are shown. The vesicle construction depicted here is based on AFM data on intracytoplasmic membranes (Bahatyrova et al., 2004). Figure made with VMD (Humphrey et al., 1996). See also Color Plate 5, Fig. 8.
B800 → B850 (<1 ps), B850 → B850, and B850 → B875 (for neighboring LH2 pairs or LH2 → LH1 transfers; approximately 10 ps) agree with results of earlier models (Ritz et al., 1998, 2001; Hu et al., 1998; Damjanović et al., 1999, 2000a). The computed B875 → RC forward transfer time of 20 ps also compares favorably with a value of 15 ps reported in earlier studies (Damjanović et al., 2000a; Ritz et al., 2001). However, when the effective Hamiltonian parameters of the monomeric circular RC-LH1 complex are substituted for the dimeric S-shaped RC-LH1-PufX structure found in Rba. sphaeroides, the computed RC → LH1 backtransfer time (1.4 ps) is too fast compared to the empirically supported value of 8 ps. This back-transfer time is especially sensitive to the Hamiltonian parameters of the RC BChls which are not known accurately for the dimeric complex. Therefore, this disagreement for the back transfer time is likely due to lack of sufficient structural data
Melih K. ùener and Klaus Schulten
Fig. 5. Excitation transfer between the bacteriochlorophyll groups of the PSU vesicle. Shown are BChl groups of the highlight adapted vesicle model for Rba. sphaeroides (Şener et al., 2007). RC and LH1 B875 BChls are depicted in black, whereas LH2 B850 and B800 BChls are depicted in dark and light gray, respectively. Also shown are the center of mass of each B850 and B875 BChl cluster, rendered as a sphere of the same cluster, and the excitation transfer rates between them. The radii of the bonds connecting two centers of mass are proportional to the logarithm of the excitation transfer between the corresponding BChl groups computed according to Eq. (8). For the sake of clarity only the strongest transfer rates between BChl groups are rendered and transfers involving the B800 and RC BChls are not shown. Figure made with VMD (Humphrey et al., 1996).
for computing more accurate Hamiltonian parameters and shortcomings of the cluster-cluster transfer picture (Eq. 8) when the assumptions of coherent transfer and Boltzmann equilibrium become suspect. In Şener et al. (2007) a heuristic RC → LH1 back-transfer time of 8 ps was adopted corresponding to a detrapping probability of 27% in approximate agreement with the observed value of 20% previously reported (Timpmann et al., 1995; Bernhardt and Trissl, 2000; Amesz and Neerken, 2002). The transfer rates thus computed between BChl clusters enable the evaluation of the average excitation lifetime τ and the overall quantum efficiency q of the pigment network according to Eqs. (5,6) (see Section III.B). For the first (high-light adapted) vesicle, an average excitation lifetime of 50 ps and a corresponding quantum efficiency of 95% were reported in Şener et al. (2007) in accord with observations (Sundström et al., 1999). The second (low-light adapted) vesicle features a longer 162 ps lifetime with
Chapter 15
Supramolecular Organization of the Photosynthetic Unit
289
Fig. 6. Excitation transfer dynamics of two PSU vesicles. The distributions of average excitation lifetime as a function of the initially excited BChl are shown for (a) the high-light adapted and (b) the low-light adapted vesicles modeled in Şener et al. (2007). The second vesicle displays an increased average lifetime due to the increased mean-free path for excitations to travel to a RC. Excitation sharing between nearby RCs is depicted in (c) and (d) for the two respective vesicles in terms of the cross-trapping probability of excitation at a given RC after it has detrapped from the RC shown at the center of the coordinate system. The probability of excitation detrapped at the central RC to be retrapped at the same RC is only 13% denoting significant excitation sharing between the RCs of the same dimer cluster.
only an 84% efficiency due to a greater mean-free path for excitations to travel from further LH2 complexes. For both vesicles, a continuous distribution of excitation lifetimes was reported as a function of the initial BChl-RC distance indicating a seamlessly connected, efficient energy transfer network. Notably, a substantial degree of excitation sharing is reported among neighboring RCs. In fact, the average probability that a detrapped excitation is recaptured at the same RC is only about 13% (Şener et al., 2007) (see Fig. 6). The cross-trapping probabilities Q Xjk among RCs, computed according to Eq. (15) correspond to the coefficients of the sojourn expansion describing repeated detrapping-retrapping events (see Section III.C). It is not yet clear how much excitation sharing is exploited by nature, for example at high light intensities, as a measure of maintaining high efficiency and preventing photodamage. It is entirely possible that the rationale for the linear clustered arrangement of RC-LH1 dimers is to simplify chromatophore assembly and facilitate quinone diffusion rather than to optimize excitation migration.
IX. Conclusions For the first time, modeling techniques permit us to describe the fundamental biochemical processes underlying photosynthesis all the way down from the atomic detail level up to the system level, bridging timescales ranging from femtoseconds to milliseconds. This accomplishment of decades-long collaboration between experimental and theoretical studies provides an example of constructing working structural models for entire cellular organelles by combining imaging techniques such as AFM, cryoEM, X-ray crystallography, and spectroscopy. Future system-level PSU studies must put greater emphasis on the processes subsequent to excitation migration such as charge transfer, quinone diffusion, and ATP synthesis. This is only possible by a closer cooperation between what have long been disjointed fields of study. Specifically, there is now a great need for more refined data on the architecture and development of the PSU, especially in reference to the location of the missing components such as the bc1 complex or the ATP synthase.
290 We expect that over the next decade all-atom dynamical models combining the structural and functional aspects of entire vesicles will become commonplace. Such models can describe the steps of photosynthesis from light-harvesting all the way to the storage of energy in chemical bonds, also accounting fully for the effects of thermal disorder, thus paving the way for the design of efficient man-made light-harvesting devices. Acknowledgments The authors would like to thank Neil Hunter and Marion Thurnauer for editorial assistance. K. S. has been supported by NSF grant MCB 0234938, NIH grant PHS 2 P41 RR05969, and by a Humboldt Foundation award. M. K. Ş. acknowledges the support of the Department of Physiology and Biophysics and Institute for Computational Biomedicine of Weill Cornell Medical College. References Aagaard J and Sistrom W (1972) Control of synthesis of reaction center bacteriochlorophyll in photosynthetic bacteria. Photochem Photobiol 15: 209–225 Allen J, Yeates T, Komiya H and Rees D (1987) Structure of the reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26: The protein subunits. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 84: 6162–6166 Amesz J and Neerken S (2002) Excitation energy trapping in anoxygenic photosynthetic bacteria. Photosynth Res 73: 73–81 Amunts A, Drory O and Nelson N (2007) The structure of a plant Photosystem I supercomplex at 3.4 Å resolution. Nature 447: 58–63 Andreev AV, Agam O, Altshuler BL and Simons BD (1996) Quantum chaos, irreversible classical dynamics, and random matrix theory. Phys Rev Lett 76: 3947–3950 Arnold W and Oppenheimer JR (1950) Internal conversion in the photosynthetic mechanism of blue-green algae. J Gen Physiol 33: 423–435 Bahatyrova S, Frese RN, Siebert CA, Olsen JD, vander Werf KO, van Grondelle R, Niederman RA, Bullough PA, Otto C and Hunter CN (2004) The native architecture of a photosynthetic membrane. Nature 430: 1058–1062 Beekman LMP, van Mourik F, Jones MR, Visser HM, Hunter CN and van Grondelle R (1994) Trapping kinetics in mutants of the photosynthetic purple bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides: the influence of the charge separation rate. Biochemistry 33: 3143–3147 Ben-Shem A, Frolow F and Nelson N (2003) Crystal structure of plant Photosystem I. Nature 426: 630–635 Bernhardt K and Trissl H-W (2000) Escape probability and trapping mechanism in purple bacteria: Revisited. Biochim Biophys Acta 1457: 1–17
Melih K. ùener and Klaus Schulten Bibby TS, Nield J and Barber J (2001a) Iron deficiency induces the formation of an antenna ring around trimeric Photosystem I in cyanobacteria. Nature 412: 743–745 Bibby TS, Nield J and Barber J (2001b) Three-dimensional model and characterization of the iron stress-induced CP43´Photosystem I supercomplex isolated from the cyanobacterium Synechocystis PCC 6803. J Biol Chem 276: 43246–43252 Bibby TS, Nield J, Chen M, Larkum AWD and Barber J (2003) Structure of a Photosystem II supercomplex isolated from Prochloron didemni retaining its chlorophyll a/b light-harvesting system. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 100: 9050–9054 Blankenship RE (2002) Molecular Mechanisms of Photosynthesis. Blackwell Science, Malden Camara-Artigas A, Brune D and Allen JP (2002) Interactions between lipids and bacterial reaction centers determined by protein crystallography. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 99: 11055–11060 Chandler D, Hsin J, Harrison CB, Gumbart J and Schulten K (2008) Intrinsic curvature properties of photosynthetic proteins in chromatophores. Biophys J, in press Cogdell RJ, Gall A and Köhler J (2006) The architecture and function of the light-harvesting apparatus of purple bacteria: From single molecules to in vivo membranes. Quart Rev Biophys 39: 227–324 Conroy MJ, Westerhuis W, Parkes-Loach PS, Loach PA, Hunter CN and Williamson MP (2000) The solution structure of the Rhodobacter sphaeroides LH1 polypeptide reveals two helical domains separated by a flexible region: Structural consequences for the LH1 complex. J Mol Biol 298: 83–94 Cory MG, Zerner MC, Hu X and Schulten K (1998) Electronic excitations in aggregates of bacteriochlorophylls. J Phys Chem B 102: 7640–7650 Crofts AR, Meinhardt SW, Jones KR and Snozzi M (1983) The role of the quinone pool in the cyclic electron transfer chain of Rps sphaeroides: A modified Q-cycle mechanism. Biochim Biophys Acta 723: 202–218 Damjanović A, Ritz T and Schulten K (1999) Energy transfer between carotenoids and bacteriochlorophylls in a light harvesting protein. Phys Rev E 59: 3293–3311 Damjanović A, Ritz T and Schulten K (2000a) Excitation energy trapping by the reaction center of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Int J Quantum Chem 77: 139–151 Damjanović A, Ritz T and Schulten K (2000b) Excitation transfer in the peridinin-chlorophyll-protein of Amphidinium carterae. Biophys J 79: 1695–1705 Damjanović A, Kosztin I, Kleinekathoefer U and Schulten K (2002a) Excitons in a photosynthetic light-harvesting system: A combined molecular dynamics, quantum chemistry and polaron model study. Phys Rev E 65: 031919 Damjanović A, Vaswani HM, Fromme P and Fleming GR (2002b) Chlorophyll excitations in Photosystem I of Synechococcus elongates. J Phys Chem B 106: 10251–10262 Deisenhofer J, Epp O, Mikki K, Huber R and Michel H (1985) Structure of the protein subunits in the photosynthetic reaction centre of Rhodopseudomonas viridis at 3 Å resolution. Nature 318: 618–624 Dexter D (1953) A theory of sensitized luminescence in solids. J Chem Phys 21: 836–850 Eccles J, Honig B and Schulten K (1988) Spectroscopic determinants in the reaction center of Rhodopseudomonas viridis. Biophys J 53: 137–144 Efetov K (1995) Supersymmetry in quantum chaos and meso-
Chapter 15
Supramolecular Organization of the Photosynthetic Unit
scopic physics. Physica D83: 151–162 Emerson R and Arnold A (1932) The photochemical reaction in photosynthesis. J Gen Physiol 16: 191–205 Ermler U, Fritzsch G, Buchanan SK and Michel H (1994) Structure of the photosynthetic reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides at 2.65Å resolution: Cofactors and protein-cofactor interactions. Structure 2: 925–936 Feniouk BA, Cherepanov DA, Voskoboynikova NE, Mulkidjanian AY and Junge W (2002) Chromatophore vesicles of Rhodobacter capsulatus contain on average one F0F1-ATP synthase each. Biophys J 82: 1115–1122 Fillingame RH (2000) Getting to the bottom of the F1-ATPase. Nature Struct Biol 7: 1002–1004 Fillingame RH, Jiang W and Dmitriev OY (2000) Coupling H+ transport to rotary catalysis in F-type ATP synthases: Structure and organization of the transmembrane rotary motor. J Exp Biol 203: 9–17 Förster T (1948) Zwischenmolekulare Energiewanderung und Fluoreszenz. Ann Phys (Leipzig) 2: 55–75 Fotiadis D, Qian P, Philippsen A, Bullough PA, Engel A and Hunter CN (2004) Structural analysis of the reaction center light-harvesting complex I photosynthetic core complex of Rhodospirillum rubrum using atomic force microscopy. J Biol Chem 279: 2063–2068 Frese RN, Olsen J, Branvall R, Westerhuis W, Hunter CN and van Grondelle R (2000) The long-range supraorganization of the bacterial photosynthetic unit: A key role for PufX. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 97: 5197–5202 Frese RN, Siebert CA, Niederman RA, Hunter CN, Otto C and van Grondelle R (2004) The long-range organization of a native photosynthetic membrane. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 101: 17994–17999 Frese RN, Pàmies, JC, Olsen, JD, Bahatyrova S, van der Weij-de Wit CD, Aartsma TJ., Otto C, Hunter CN, Frenkel D and van Grondelle R (2008) Protein shape and crowding drive domain formation and curvature in biological membranes. Biophys J 19: 640–647 Gennis RB, Barquera B, Hacker B, Van Doren SR, Arnaud S, Crofts AR, Davidson E, Gray KA and Daldal F (1993) The bc1 complexes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Rhodobacter capsulatus. J Bioener Biomemb 25: 195–209 Geyer T and Helms V (2006) Reconstruction of a kinetic model of the chromatophore vesicles from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biophys J 91: 927–937 Gobets B, van Stokkum IH, Rögner M, Kruip J, Schlodder E, Karapetyan NV, Dekker JP and van Grondelle R (2001) Timeresolved fluorescence emission measurements of Photosystem I particles of various cyanobacteria: A unified compartmental model. Biophys J 81: 407–424 Govindjee (2000) Milestones in photosynthesis research. In: Yunus M, Pathre U and Mohanty P (eds) Probing Photosynthesis: Mechanisms, Regulation, and Adaptation, pp 9–39. Taylor and Francis, New York Groot M, Yu J, Agarwal R, Norris JR and Fleming GR (1998) Three-pulse photon echo measurements on the accessory pigments in the reaction center of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Phys Chem B 102: 5923–5931 Guhr T, Muller-Groeling A and Weidenmuller HA (1998) Random matrix theories in quantum physics: Common concepts. Phys Rep 299: 189–425 Hu X and Schulten K (1998) A model for the light-harvesting
291
complex I (B875) of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biophys J 75: 683–694 Hu X, Xu D, Hamer K, Schulten K, Koepke J and Michel H (1995) Predicting the structure of the light-harvesting complex II of Rhodospirillum molischianum. Prot Sci 4: 1670–1682 Hu X, Ritz T, Damjanović A and Schulten K (1997) Pigment organization and transfer of electronic excitation in the purple bacteria. J Phys Chem B 101: 3854–3871 Hu X, Damjanović A, Ritz T and Schulten K (1998) Architecture and function of the light harvesting apparatus of purple bacteria. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 95: 5935–5941 Hu X, Ritz T, Damjanović A, Autenrieth F and Schulten K (2002) Photosynthetic apparatus of purple bacteria. Quart Rev Biophys 35: 1–62 Humphrey W, Dalke A and Schulten K (1996) VMD — Visual Molecular Dynamics. J Mol Graphics 14: 33–38 Hunter CN, Kramer HJM and van Grondelle R (1985) Linear dichroism and fluorescence emission of antenna complexes during photosynthetic unit assembly in Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. Biochim Biophys Acta 807: 44–51 Hunter CN, Tucker JD, Niederman RA (2005) Perspective on the assembly and organisation of photosynthetic membranes in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Photochem Photobiol Sci 4: 1023–1027 Jamieson SJ, Wang P, Qian P, Kirkland JY, Conroy MJ, Hunter CN and Bullough PA (2002) Projection structure of the photosynthetic reaction centre-antenna complex of Rhodospirillum rubrum at 8.5 Å resolution. J Mol Biol 21: 3927–3935 Jordan P, Fromme P, Witt HT, Klukas O, Saenger W and Krauß N (2001) Three-dimensional structure of cyanobacterial Photosystem I at 2.5 Å resolution. Nature 411: 909–917 Jungas C, Ranck J, Rigaud J, Joliot P and Verméglio A (1999) Supramolecular organization of the photosynthetic apparatus of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. EMBO J 18: 534–542 Junge W, Lill H and Engelbrecht S (1997) ATP synthase: An electrochemical transducer with rotatory mechanics. Trends Biochem Sci 22: 420–423 Karrasch S, Bullough P and Ghosh R (1995) 8.5 Å projection map of the light-harvesting complex I from Rhodospirillum rubrum reveals a ring composed of 16 subunits. EMBO J 14: 631–638 Kennis JTM, Gobets B, van Stokkum IHM, Dekker JP, van Grondelle R and Fleming GR (2001) Light harvesting by chlorophylls and carotenoids in the Photosystem I core complex of Synechococcus elongatus: A fluorescence upconversion study. J Phys Chem B 105: 4485–4494 Knox RS and Spring BQ (2003) Dipole strengths in the chlorophylls. Photochem Photobiol 77: 497–501 Koepke J, Hu X, Muenke C, Schulten K and Michel H (1996) The crystal structure of the light harvesting complex II (B800-850) from Rhodospirillum molischianum. Structure 4: 581–597 Koolhaas MHC, Frese RN, Fowler GJS, Bibby TS, Georgakopoulou S, van der Zwan G, Hunter CN and van Grondelle R (1998) Identification of the upper exciton component of the B850 bacteriochlorophylls of the LH2 antenna complex, using a B800-free mutant of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 37: 4693–4698 Kosztin I and Schulten K (2008) Molecular dynamics methods for bioeletronic systems in photosynthesis. In: Aartsma T and Matysik J (eds) Biophysical Techniques in Photosynthesis II (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 26), pp
292 445–464. Springer, Dordrecht Krauss N, Hinrichs W, Witt I, Fromme P, Pritzkow W, Dauter Z, Betzel C, Wilson KS, Witt HT and Saenger W (1993) 3-dimensional structure of system-I of photosynthesis at 6 Ångström resolution. Nature 361: 326–331 Krauß N, Schubert W-D, Klukas O, Fromme P, Witt HT and Saenger W (1996) Photosystem I at 4 Å resolution represents the first structural model of a joint photosynthetic reaction centre and core antenna system. Nature Struct Biol 3: 965–973 Krueger BP, Scholes GD and Fleming GR (1998) Calculation of couplings and energy-transfer pathways between the pigments of LH2 by the ab initio transition density cube method. J Phys Chem B 102: 5378–5386 Loll B, Kern J, Saenger W, Zouni A and Biesiadka J (2005) Towards complete cofactor arrangement in the 3.0 Å resolution structure of Photosystem II. Nature 438: 1040–1044 Marcus RA (1956a) Electrostatic free energy and other properties of states having nonequilibrium polarization II. J Chem Phys 24: 979–989 Marcus RA (1956b) On the energy of oxidation-reduction reactions involving electron transfer I. J Chem Phys 24: 966–978 McDermott G, Prince SM, Freer AA, Hawthornthwaite-Lawless AM, Papiz MZ, Cogdell RJ and Isaacs NW (1995) Crystal structure of an integral membrane light-harvesting complex from photosynthetic bacteria. Nature 374: 517–521 Melkozernov AN (2001) Excitation energy transfer in Photosystem I from oxygenic organisms. Photosynth Res 70: 129–153 Melkozernov AN, Lin S, Blankenship RE and Valkunas L (2001) Spectral inhomogeneity of Photosystem I and its influence on excitation equilibration and trapping in the cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp PCC6803 at 77 K. Biophys J 81: 1144–1154 Mukamel S (1995) Principles of Nonlinear Optical Spectroscopy. Oxford University Press, New York Murray JW and Barber J (2007) Structural characteristics of channels and pathways in Photosystem II including the identification of an oxygen channel. J Struct Biol 159: 228–237 Nelson N and Ben-Shem A (2004) The complex architecture of oxygenic photosynthesis. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol 5: 971–982 Nelson N and Yocum CF (2006) Structure and Function of Photosystems I and II. Annu Rev Plant Biol 57: 521–565 Niederman RA, Mallon DE and Langan JJ (1976) Membranes of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. IV. Assembly of chromatophores in low-aeration cell suspensions. Biochim Biophys Acta 440: 429–447 Niederman RA, Mallon DE and Parks LC (1979) Membranes of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. VI. Isolation of a fraction enriched in newly synthesized bacteriochlorophyll a-protein complexes. Biochim Biophys Acta 555: 210–220 Nonella M and Schulten K (1991) Molecular dynamics simulation of electron transfer in proteins: Theory and application to QA → QB transfer in the photosynthetic reaction center. J Phys Chem 95: 2059–2067 Onuchic JN, Beratan DN and Hopfield JJ (1986) Some aspects of electron-transfer reaction dynamics. J Phys Chem 90: 3707–3721 Oppenheimer JR (1941) Internal conversion in photosynthesis. In: Proceedings of the American Physical Society. Phys Rev 60: 158 Papiz MZ, Prince SM, Howard T, Cogdell RJ and Isaacs NW (2003) The structure and thermal motion of the B800-850 LH2
Melih K. ùener and Klaus Schulten complex from Rps. acidophila at 2.0 Å resolution and 100K: New structural features and functionally relevant motions. J Mol Biol 326: 1523–1538 Park S, Şener MK, Lu D and Schulten K (2003) Reaction paths based on mean first-passage times. J Chem Phys 119: 1313–1319 Parks LC and Niederman RA (1978) Membranes of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. V. Identification of bacteriochlorophyll a-depleted cytoplasmic membrane in phototrophically grown cells. Biochim Biophys Acta 511: 70–82 Pålsson L-O, Flemming C, Gobets B, van Grondelle R, Dekker JP and Schlodder E (1998) Energy transfer and charge separation in Photosystem I: P700 oxidation upon selective excitation of the long-wavelength antenna chlorophylls of Synechococcus elongatus. Biophys J 74: 2611–2622 Pugh R, McGlynn P, Jones M and Hunter CN (1998) The LH1-RC core complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Interaction between components, time-dependent assembly, and topology of the PufX protein. Biochim Biophys Acta 1366: 301–316 Qian P, Hunter CN and Bullough PA (2005) The 8.5Å, projection structure of the core RC-LH1-PufX dimer of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Mol Biol 349: 948–960 Ritz T and Schulten K (2001) Physik der Photosynthese. Physikalische Blaetter 57: 49–53 Ritz T, Hu X, Damjanović A and Schulten K (1998) Excitons and excitation transfer in the photosynthetic unit of purple bacteria. J Lumin 76-77: 310–321 Ritz T, Damjanović A, Schulten K, Zhang J and Koyama Y (2000) Efficient light harvesting through carotenoids. Photosynth Res 66: 125–144 Ritz T, Park S and Schulten K (2001) Kinetics of excitation migration and trapping in the photosynthetic unit of purple bacteria. J Phys Chem B 105: 8259–8267 Ritz T, Damjanović A and Schulten K (2002) The quantum physics of photosynthesis. Chem Phys Chem 3: 243–248 Roszak AW, Howard TD, Southall J, Gardiner AT, Law CJ, Isaacs NW and Cogdell RJ (2003) Crystal structure of the RC-LH1 core complex from Rhodopseudomonas palustris. Science 302: 1969–1972 Rutkauskas D, Novoderezhkin VI, Cogdell RJ and van Grondelle R (2005) Fluorescence spectroscopy of conformational changes of single LH2 complexes. Biophys J 88: 422–435 Scheer H (1991) Chlorophylls. CRC Press, Boca Raton Scheuring S, Levy D and Rigaud J-L (2005) Watching the components of photosynthetic bacterial membranes and their in situ organisation by atomic force microscopy. Biochim Biophys Acta 1712: 109–127 Scheuring S and Sturgis J (2005) Chromatic adaptation of photosynthetic membranes. Science 309: 484–487 Scheuring S, Sturgis JN, Prima V, Bernadac A, Levy D and Rigaud J-L (2004) Watching the photosynthetic apparatus in native membranes. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 91: 11293–11297 Scholes G, Gould I, Cogdell R and Fleming G (1999) Ab initio molecular orbital calculations of electronic couplings in the LH2 bacterial light-harvesting complex of Rps Acidophila. J Phys Chem B 103: 2543–2553 Schulten K (1999) From simplicity to complexity and back: Function, architecture and mechanism of light harvesting systems in photosynthetic bacteria. In: Frauenfelder H, Deisenhofer J and Wolynes PG (eds) Simplicity and Complexity in Proteins and
Chapter 15
Supramolecular Organization of the Photosynthetic Unit
Nucleic Acids, pp 227–253. Dahlem University Press, Berlin Schulten K and Tesch M (1991) Coupling of protein motion to electron transfer: Molecular dynamics and stochastic quantum mechanics study of photosynthetic reaction centers. Chem Phys 158: 421–446 Şener MK (1999) Universality in random matrix models of quantum chromodynamics. PhD thesis, State University of New York at Stony Brook, Dept. of Physics, Stony Brook, NY Şener M and Schulten K (2002) A general random matrix approach to account for the effect of static disorder on the spectral properties of light harvesting systems. Phys Rev E 65: 031916 Şener M and Schulten K (2005) Physical principles of efficient excitation transfer in light harvesting. In: Andrews DL (ed), Energy Harvesting Materials, pp 1–26. World Scientific, Singapore Şener MK, Lu D, Ritz T, Park S, Fromme P and Schulten K (2002) Robustness and optimality of light harvesting in cyanobacterial Photosystem I. J Phys Chem B 106: 7948–7960 Şener MK, Park S, Lu D, Damjanović A, Ritz T, Fromme P and Schulten K (2004) Excitation migration in trimeric cyanobacterial Photosystem I. J Chem Phys 120: 11183–11195 Şener MK, Jolley C, Ben-Shem A, Fromme P, Nelson N, Croce R and Schulten K (2005) Comparison of the light harvesting networks of plant and cyanobacterial Photosystem I. Biophys J 89: 1630–1642 Şener MK, Olsen JD, Hunter CN and Schulten K (2007) Atomic-level structural and functional model of a bacterial photosynthetic membrane vesicle. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 104: 15723–15728 Siebert CA, Qian P, Fotiadis D, Engel A, Hunter CN and Bullough P (2004) The role of PufX in the molecular architecture of photosynthetic membranes in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. EMBO J 23: 690–700 Snyder JP (1987) Map Projections—A working Manual. U S Geological Survey Professional Paper 1395. US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC Sumi H (2000) Structural strategies in the antenna system of photosynthesis on the basis of quantum-mechanical coherence among pigments. J Luminesc 87-89: 71–76 Sumi H (2001) Bacterial photosynthesis begins with quantummechanical coherence. Chem Record 1: 480–493 Sundström V, Pullerits T and van Grondelle R (1999) Photosynthetic light-harvesting: Reconciling dynamics and structure of purple bacterial LH2 reveals function of photosynthetic unit. J Phys Chem B 103: 2327–2346 Timpmann K, Freiberg A and Sundström V (1995) Energy trapping and detrapping in the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodopseudomonas viridis: Transfer-to-trap-limited dynamics. Chem Phys 194: 275–283 Tretiak S, Middleton C, Chernyak V and Mukamel S (2000) Bacteriochlorophyll and carotenoid excitonic couplings in the LH2 system of purple bacteria. J Phys Chem B 104: 9540–9553 Treutlein H, Schulten K, Deisenhofer J, Michel H, Brünger A and Karplus M (1988a) Molecular dynamics simulation of the primary processes in the photosynthetic reaction center of Rhodopseudomonas viridis. In: Breton J, Verméglio A (eds) The Photosynthetic Bacterial Reaction Center: Structure and Dynamics, Vol 149, pp 139–150, NATO Sci Ser A. Plenum, New York Treutlein H, Schulten K, Niedermeier C, Deisenhofer J, Michel H
293
and Devault D (1988b) Electrostatic control of electron transfer in the photosynthetic reaction center of Rhodopseudomonas viridis. In: Breton J, Verméglio A (eds), The Photosynthetic Bacterial Reaction Center: Structure and Dynamics, Vol 149, pp 369–377, NATO Sci Ser A. Plenum, New York van Amerongen H, Valkunas L and van Grondelle R (2000) Photosynthetic Excitons. World Scientific, Singapore van Grondelle R and Novoderezhkin VI (2006) Energy transfer in photosynthesis: Experimental insights and quantitative models. Phys Chem Chem Phys 8: 793–807 van Grondelle R, Dekker JP, Gillbro T and Sundström V (1994) Energy transfer and trapping in photosynthesis. Biochim Biophys Acta 1187: 1–65 Vasil’ev S and Bruce D (2004) Optimization and evolution of light harvesting in photosynthesis: The role of antenna chlorophyll conserved between Photosystem II and Photosystem I. Plant Cell 16: 3059–3068 Vasil’ev S, Shen J-R, Kamiya N and Bruce D (2004) The orientations of core antenna chlorophylls in Photosystem II are optimized to maximize the quantum yield of photosynthesis. FEBS Lett 561: 111–116 Velasco F and Crofts AR (1991) Complexes or super complexes: Inhibitor titrations show that electron transfer in chromatophores from Rb. sphaeroides involves a dimeric ubiquinol: cytochrome c oxidoreductase, and is delocalized. Biochem Soc Trans 19: 588–593 Visscher KJ, Bergstrom H, Sundström V, Hunter CN and van Grondelle R (1989) Temperature dependence of energy transfer from the long wavelength antenna BChl-896 to the reaction center in Rhodospirillum rubrum, Rhodobacter sphaeroides (wt and M21 mutant) from 77 to 177 K, studied by picosecond absorption spectroscopy. Photosynth Res 22: 211–217 Walz T, Jamieson SJ, Bowers CM, Bullough PA and Hunter CN (1998) Projection structures of three photosynthetic complexes from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: LH2 at 6 Å, LH1 and LH1-RC at 25 Å. J Mol Biol 282: 833–845 Xia D, Yu C-A, Kim H, Xia J-Z, Kachurin AM, Zhang L, Yu L and Deisenhofer J (1997) Crystal structure of the cytochrome bc1 complex from bovine heart mitochondria. Science 277: 60–66 Xiong J, Fischer WM, Inoue K, Nakahara M and Bauer CE (2000) Molecular evidence for the early evolution of photosynthesis. Science 289: 1724–1730 Xu D and Schulten K (1992) Multi-mode coupling of protein motion to electron transfer in the photosynthetic reaction center: Spin-boson theory based on a classical molecular dynamics simulation. In: Breton J and Verméglio A (eds), The Photosynthetic Bacterial Reaction Center: II Structure, Spectroscopy and Dynamics, pp 301–312. NATO Sci Ser A. Plenum Press, New York Xu D and Schulten K (1994) Coupling of protein motion to electron transfer in a photosynthetic reaction center: Investigating the low temperature behaviour in the framework of the spin-boson model. Chem Phys 182: 91–117 Yang M and Fleming GR (2002) Influence of phonons on exciton transfer dynamics: comparison of the Redfield, Förster, and modified Redfield equations. Chem Phys 282: 163–180 Yang M, Damjanović A, Vaswani HM and Fleming GR (2003) Energy transfer in Photosystem I of cyanobacteria Synechococcus elongatus: Model study with structure-based semi-empiri-
294 cal Hamiltonian and experimental spectral density. Biophys J 85: 140–158 Zazubovich V, Matsuzaki S, Johnson TW, Hayes JM, Chitnis PR and Small GJ (2002) Red antenna states of Photosystem I from cyanobacterium Synechococcus elongatus: A spectral
Melih K. ùener and Klaus Schulten hole burning study. Chem Phys 275: 47–59 Zouni A, Witt H-T, Kern J, Fromme P, Krauss N, Saenger W and Orth P (2001) Crystal structure of Photosystem II from Synechococcus elongatus at 3.8 Å resolution. Nature 409: 739–743
Chapter 16 Structural Plasticity of Reaction Centers from Purple Bacteria Michael R. Jones* Department of Biochemistry, School of Medical Sciences, University of Bristol, University Walk, Bristol, BS8 1TD, U.K.
Summary ............................................................................................................................................................... 295 I. The Plastic Purple Reaction Center ............................................................................................................... 296 II. Biochemical and Genetic Alteration of Polypeptide Composition................................................................... 297 A. Depletion of the H-Polypeptide......................................................................................................... 297 B. Depletion of the Cytochrome Subunit............................................................................................... 298 C. Chimeric RCs ................................................................................................................................... 298 III. Cofactor Exclusion ......................................................................................................................................... 299 A. Carotenoid Exclusion ....................................................................................................................... 299 B. Quinone Exclusion ........................................................................................................................... 301 C. Bacteriochlorin Exclusion ................................................................................................................. 301 IV. Cofactor Replacement.................................................................................................................................... 302 A. Bacteriochlorin Replacement ........................................................................................................... 302 B. Quinone Replacement...................................................................................................................... 303 C. Carotenoid Replacement ................................................................................................................. 304 D. Iron Removal and Replacement....................................................................................................... 305 E. Genetic Approaches to Cofactor Replacement ................................................................................ 305 V. Helix Symmetrization...................................................................................................................................... 307 A. DLL, Cousins and Offspring ............................................................................................................... 307 B. Sym-1 and Siblings .......................................................................................................................... 308 C. QAQA and A6D1 ................................................................................................................................ 309 VI. Water and Other Unexpected Things in Electron Density Maps .................................................................... 310 VII. Building New Functionality ............................................................................................................................. 312 VIII. Conclusions .................................................................................................................................................... 313 Acknowledgments ................................................................................................................................................. 314 References ............................................................................................................................................................ 314
Summary The purple bacterial reaction center has made major contributions to our understanding of photosynthetic energy transduction and biological electron transfer. A major element in this work has been alteration of the structure and/or composition of the reaction center through site-directed mutagenesis or biochemical treatments, and much of the usefulness of the reaction center as an experimental system has come from its (sometimes surprising) tolerance of significant changes in cofactor composition or amino acid sequence. The purpose of this chapter is to illustrate this structural plasticity, by documenting the extent to which the structure and composition of the reaction center has been altered in order to investigate details of its mechanism, or general *Email: [email protected]
C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty (eds): The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria, pp. 295–321. © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V.
296
Michael R. Jones
principles pertaining to biological electron transfer. For the cofactors, the article looks at how and why individual cofactors have been replaced and the main outcomes of such studies. For the protein, the emphasis is placed on mutations involving large numbers of amino acids or single mutations that alter the cofactor composition of the complex. The chapter also considers the significant influence that changes in solvent (water) structure can have on reaction center structure and mechanism, attempts to construct chimeric reaction centers, and protein engineering aimed at introducing new functionality into the reaction center. I. The Plastic Purple Reaction Center According to the Encyclopaedia Britannica Online (2006), ‘plasticity’ is defined as ‘the ability of certain solids to flow or to change shape permanently when subjected to stresses of intermediate magnitude between those producing temporary deformation, or elastic behavior, and those causing failure of the material, or rupture.’ Even more concisely, Wikipedia defines ‘plasticity’ in a physics and engineering context as ‘the propensity of a material to undergo permanent deformation under load’ (Wikipedia-The Free Encyclopedia, 2006). The purpose of this chapter is to document the extent to which the purple bacterial reaction center (RC) has been remolded in terms of structure and composition in order to investigate its innate function as a transducer of light energy, and during use as a tool to investigate broader subjects such as biological electron transfer. Such remolding can either be achieved genetically, through site-directed mutagenesis and the like, or through biochemical treatments that affect either the protein or the cofactors. On the genetic side, it is obvious that a detailed account of the structural and functional consequences of every single mutation ever engineered into the RC would be a mammoth task, and so the chapter focuses mainly on larger scale alterations involving multiple amino acids, or point mutations that change the cofactor composition. On the biochemical side changes to both protein and cofactors are considered, but emphasis is placed mainly on work carried out during the last ten years or so. All purple bacterial RCs have a core domain made Abbreviations: BA – A-side monomeric BChl; BB – B-side monomeric BChl; BChl – bacteriochlorophyll; Blc. – Blastochloris; BPhe – bacteriopheophytin; Chl – chlorophyll; Em P/P+ – mid-point redox potential of P/P+; HA – A-side BPhe; HB – B-side BPhe; LDAO – lauryldimethylamine oxide; LH1 – core light harvesting complex; LH2 – peripheral light harvesting complex; P – primary electron donor; PA – A-side P BChl; PB – B-side P BChl; QA – primary acceptor quinone; QB – secondary (dissociable) acceptor quinone; Rba. – Rhodobacter; RC – reaction center
up from the H-, L- and M-polypeptides, encoded by the puhA, pufL and pufM genes, respectively. These polypeptides encase the bacteriochlorophyll (BChl), bacteriopheophytin (BPhe), quinone and carotenoid cofactors in a three-dimensional arrangement that has become very familiar since the publication of crystal structures in the mid-1980’s for the RCs from Blastochloris (Blc.) viridis (formerly Rhodopseudomonas viridis) and Rhodobacter (Rba.) sphaeroides (see Hoff and Deisenhofer,1997, for a comprehensive review that includes original references). In many species, including Blc. viridis, a fourth C-polypeptide is bound to the periplasmic faces of the L- and M-polypeptides, and binds heme groups that act as the electron donor to the photo-oxidized BChl cofactors. Gene deletion experiments have shown that the H-, L- and M-polypeptides are indispensable for assembly of the RC (Tehrani et al., 2003; Tehrani and Beatty, 2004), but in some species it is possible to delete the gene encoding the C-polypeptide and still retain photosynthetic growth (Nagashima et al., 1996; Masuda et al., 2002). Unlike the H-, L- and M-polypeptides that form their scaffold, not all of the intramembrane cofactors are essential for assembly of the RC. Figure 1 summarizes the arrangement of the polypeptides (Fig. 1a) and cofactors (Fig. 1b) of the Rba. sphaeroides RC. Two membrane-spanning branches of cofactors extend from a pair of BChls on the periplasmic side of the membrane (denoted P — formed by the PA and PB BChls) to a quinone on the cytoplasmic side (denoted QA and QB on the so-called A- and B-branches, respectively). On each branch the P BChls are connected to the quinone cofactor by a ‘monomeric’ BChl (BA and BB) and a BPhe (HA and HB) (Fig. 1b). The wild-type RC also has a carotenoid cofactor located close to the BB monomeric BChl and an iron atom between the QA and QB quinone. The structure and mechanism of the purple bacterial RC has been extensively reviewed (Parson, 1991; Deisenhofer and Norris, 1993; Woodbury and Allen, 1995; Parson, 1996; Hoff and Deisenhofer, 1997; Okamura et al., 2000; van Brederode and Jones, 2000;
Chapter 16
Reaction Center Structural Plasticity
297 such as the light-harvesting 2 (LH2) antenna found in Rba. sphaeroides. II. Biochemical and Genetic Alteration of Polypeptide Composition A. Depletion of the H-Polypeptide
Fig. 1. The structure of the Rba. sphaeroides RC. (a) The Lpolypeptide (dark-grey ribbon) and M-polypeptide (light-grey ribbon) form a heterodimeric scaffold that encases the 10 cofactors (grey spheres). The H-polypeptide (light-grey tube) has a single membrane-spanning helix and a cytoplasmic domain. Grey boxes denote the approximate position of the membrane. (b) The BChl (PA, PB, BA, BB), BPhe (HA, HB) and ubiquinone (QA, QB) cofactors form two membrane-spanning branches around an axis of pseudo-twofold symmetry (dotted line). The monomeric BChls are highlighted in dark grey and the hydrocarbon side-chains of the bacteriochlorins and quinones have been removed for clarity. Also shown are the carotenoid (Crt), the non-heme iron (Fe) and the route of light-driven electron transfer (arrows).
Wraight, 2004), and various aspects of structure and mechanism are addressed in other chapters in this volume. In all purple photosynthetic bacteria the RC is closely associated with a light-harvesting-1 (LH1) antenna pigment-protein, forming the socalled RC-LH1 core complex, and in many species these RC-LH1 complexes are surrounded by one or more peripheral light-harvesting antenna complexes
As outlined above, the L- and M-polypeptides of the RC bind the electron transfer cofactors and are indispensable components of the complex (Tehrani and Beatty, 2004). Gene deletion experiments have shown that the H-polypeptide is also needed for assembly of the Rba. sphaeroides RC (Wong et al., 1996; Chen et al., 1998), but once assembled and solubilized from the membrane using detergent it is possible to remove the H-polypeptide from this complex by incubation for 1 hour at 25 °C with a mixture of LiC1O4, CaCl2, ethanol, Tris-HC1, sodium cholate and EDTA (Debus et al., 1985) The remaining ‘LM’ complex retains the non-heme iron and both quinones, shows only very minor changes in bacteriochlorin absorbance, and carries out charge separation to form P+QA– (Debus et al., 1985). The H-polypeptide can also be reconstituted to yield RCs with essentially wild-type properties (Debus et al., 1985; Utschig et al., 1997). Figure 2a shows a view of the cytoplasmic surface of the Rba. sphaeroides RC with the H-polypeptide removed. The QA, QB and Fe binding sites are located just below the now-exposed cytoplasmic surfaces of the L- and M-polypeptides, consistent with the observation that these cofactors are not released when the H-polypeptide is removed. However the QA quinone is partially visible from the outside of the LM complex in this model (highlighted in darkgrey in Fig. 2a). As shown in Fig. 2b the head-groups of the QA and QB quinones (dark-grey spheres) are overlaid by just a few amino acids from the M- and L-polypeptides, respectively (shown as sticks in Fig. 2b), and so will be much closer to the aqueous phase on the cytoplasmic side of the membrane than is the case when the H-polypeptide is present. The main effects of H-polypeptide depletion are a two-fold acceleration in the rate of P+QA– recombination and a 102–103-fold slowing in the rate of electron transfer from QA– to QB (Debus et al., 1985), effects consistent with a significant change in the environment of these quinones. There is also a decrease in the affinity of the QB site for quinone (Debus et al., 1985). LM preps have been used to study the influence of the
Michael R. Jones
298
polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. This protocol produces a preparation containing the L- and M-polypeptides and associated cofactors but lacking both the H-polypeptide and the tetra-heme cytochrome subunit (Fukushima et al., 1988; Matsuura et al., 1988). In the same report it was commented that the cytochrome subunit was rather easily separated from the Rvi. gelatinosus RC using detergents such as sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) or lauryldimethylamine oxide (LDAO), or chaotropes such as NaSCN or KClO4. In a subsequent report (Matsuura et al., 1988), it was established that water-soluble Rvi. gelatinosus cytochrome c2 or horse-heart cytochrome c can directly reduce the photo-oxidized primary donor in such LM preparations of the Rvi. gelatinosus RC, demonstrating that the tetra-heme cytochrome subunit is dispensable in this species in vitro. Studies involving disruption of the gene for the cytochrome subunit in Rvi. gelatinosus and Rhodovulum sulfidophilum have also led to the conclusion that this component of the RC is dispensable in these species, with strains of bacteria lacking the cytochrome subunit being capable of photosynthetic growth, albeit at a reduced rate (Nagashima et al., 1996; Masuda et al., 2002). C. Chimeric RCs
Fig. 2. The cytoplasmic surface of a model LM preparation of the Rba. sphaeroides RC. (a) The LM heterodimer is shown as a solid object, with the quinones shown as dark-grey spheres. The view is along the symmetry axis, and parts of the QA quinone are visible from the outside of the complex. (b) View as in (a) but with amino acids overlaying the quinone sites shown in stick format, revealing the underlying quinones. In both panels the dotted ovals show the approximate positions of the QA and QB quinones. See also Color Plate 7, Fig. 10.
H-polypeptide on electron transfer from HA– to QA (Liu et al., 1991a; Schelvis et al., 1992; Utschig et al., 1997; Tang et al., 1999; Knox et al., 2001) and carotenoid triplet states (Sebban and Lindqvist, 1987). A protocol for the depletion of the H-polypeptide from the Rps. viridis RC has also been reported (Hara et al., 1998). B. Depletion of the Cytochrome Subunit Fukushima and co-workers have described a protocol involving treatment of RC-LH1 core complexes from Rubrivivax (Rvi.) gelatinosus with octyl thioglucoside, urea and Triton X-100, followed by preparative
The L-, M- and H-polypeptides are all required for RC assembly, but there have been some reports of the construction of chimeric RCs that contain polypeptides from more than one species. Expression of the puf operon from Rba. sphaeroides in a puf operon deletion strain of Rba. capsulatus has been found to produce a RC comprising the Rba. sphaeroides L- and Mpolypeptides and the Rba. capsulatus H-polypeptide (Zilsel et al., 1989). Fluorescence measurements on the resulting strain were interpreted in terms of some RC misassembly, but nevertheless the resulting RCs were capable of supporting photosynthetic growth at near-to-normal rates at moderate light intensity. Along similar lines, Tehrani and co-workers have examined whether parts of the H-polypeptide of the Rba. sphaeroides RC can be replaced with equivalent sequences from the Blc. viridis H-polypeptide (Tehrani et al., 2003). The large cytoplasmic domain could not be exchanged without abolishing RC assembly, but a construct containing a Blc. viridis sequence between residues 1 and 34, encompassing the small (11 amino acid) periplasmic domain and the membrane-spanning helix of the H-polypeptide, yielded RCs capable of supporting photosynthetic growth, as did a construct in which just the membrane-span-
Chapter 16
Reaction Center Structural Plasticity
ning helix was substituted. Findings with these and related constructs have been used to develop a model for assembly of the RC (Tehrani et al., 2003; Tehrani and Beatty, 2004). Taguchi and co-workers have also reported the construction of chimeric RCs in an intriguing experiment in which sequences of the pufM gene from Rba. sphaeroides were used to restore photosyntheticallycompetent RCs to a strain of Rba. capsulatus with a 43 bp deletion in the pufM gene (Taguchi et al., 1993). This deletion removed a loop of amino acids that form part of the binding pocket of the QA quinone at the cytoplasmic end of the membrane-spanning D-helix. A number of photosynthetically-competent derivative strains were generated in which all or part of the C-terminal end of the defective Rba. capsulatus M-polypeptide was replaced by the equivalent sequence from Rba. sphaeroides. All of these included the whole of the membrane-spanning D-helix and the adjacent short surface helix (denoted ‘de’ as it connects the D and E membrane-spanning helices). Although most protein engineering studies have been carried out on Rba. sphaeroides or Rba. capsulatus RCs, studies of the tetra-heme cytochrome that forms an extramembrane component of many purple bacterial RCs has necessitated work with other species. The X-ray crystal structure of the cytochrome subunit in the Blc. viridis RC is known, but this organism presents experimental challenges due to its poor growth under non-photosynthetic conditions. In order to examine the cytochrome component in a more experimentally-amenable organism, Maki and co-workers have constructed a chimeric RC by expressing the pufC gene from Blc. viridis in a pufC-deletion strain of Rvi. gelatinosus (Maki et al., 2003). The first point worthy of note is that the uncomplemented pufC deletion strain of Rvi. gelatinosus was capable of photosynthetic growth at approximately half the rate exhibited by the wild-type strain, demonstrating that functional RCs can assemble in this organism in the absence of the cytochrome component (Nagashima et al., 1996) (see above). Secondly, when the Blc. viridis pufC gene was added the resulting RCs were also capable of supporting photosynthetic growth, showed evidence for rapid reduction of the RC BChls by a cytochrome and biochemical evidence for association of the cytochrome with the remainder of the RC (Maki et al., 2003). This was despite the fact that the pucC gene product shows only 45% identity between the two species, and only 8 out of 30 cytochrome residues
299 involved at the interface with the L/M polypeptides are conserved. The chimera also included exchange of 34 amino acids from the C-terminus of the Mpolypeptide, a region that shows a little over 60% identity between the two species. The chimeric RC was sufficiently robust to withstand additional point mutations of the cytochrome subunit (Alric et al., 2004, 2006), although detergent purification of this chimeric RC has not been reported. Finally, Kortluke and co-workers have described the expression of the puf operon from Roseobacter (Rsb.) denitrificans in a double puf and puc deletion mutant of Rba. capsulatus (Kortluke et al., 1997). The latter strain lacks RCs due to the absence of the pufLM genes, the LH1 antenna due to the absence of the pufBA genes, and the LH2 antenna due to the absence of the pucBA genes. Expression of the Rsb. denitrificans puf operon in this double deletion mutant, together with the Rba. capsulatus pufQ and pufX genes, produced a strain that showed spectroscopic and biochemical evidence of RC assembly at a reduced level. Photoexcitation of membranes containing these chimeric RCs produced spectroscopic evidence for the P+QA– radical pair state but not a longer lived P+QB– state, and the RCs were not capable of supporting photosynthetic growth of the transconjugant strain (Kortluke et al., 1997). III. Cofactor Exclusion A. Carotenoid Exclusion A useful feature of the RC is that it can be induced to assemble without certain cofactors, with a very limited impact on the structure of the rest of the pigment-protein complex. In fact a significant proportion of the research carried out on the Rba. sphaeroides RC has involved a particular variant isolated from a carotenoid-deficient strain, the so-called R-26 RC (Clayton and Smith, 1960; Reed and Clayton, 1968). The R-26 strain has lowered levels of the LH2 light harvesting complex, assisting purification of the RC and providing biochemists with an easier way to satisfy sample-hungry spectroscopists and crystallographers. The RC from the related strain R-26.1, which differs from R-26 in the profile of antenna complexes present (Davidson and Cogdell, 1981; Hunter, 1995), has also used been used as a carotenoid-less RC in a number of studies. The expression level of the RC is not adversely af-
300
Michael R. Jones
Fig. 3. Stereo view of structural changes in the carotenoid-deficient R-26.1 RC. The structures of the wild-type (light-grey) and R-26.1 (dark grey) RCs are overlaid. Most components are shown as stick models with oxygen or nitrogen atoms highlighted as small spheres. The alpha-carbon of Gly M71 is shown as a large sphere. In the R-26.1 RC a molecule of LDAO (thick dark-grey sticks) occupies the central part of the binding pocket of the carotenoid found in the wild-type RC (thick light-grey sticks). The phytol chains of the HB and BB bacteriochlorins are shown from the point that their conformations start to deviate in the two structures (atom nearest the label).
fected by a lack of carotenoid in the R-26 strain, and structural comparisons have shown that the absence of the carotenoid does not produce large scale changes in the structure of the complex, or changes in conformation of the majority of amino acid side chains lining the carotenoid binding pocket. The structure of the R-26 RC at a resolution of 2.8 Å shows that a molecule of the detergent LDAO occupies part of the carotenoid binding pocket (Yeates et al., 1988), and this was also found to be the case in a more recent comparison of the structures of the R-26.1 RC and a carotenoid-containing Rba. sphaeroides RC (Roszak et al., 2004). Figure 3 shows a stereo view of an overlay of the two structures from the latter study. In addition to the presence of an LDAO, the only significant structural consequences of the lack of carotenoid were shifts in the positions of the phytol tails of the BB BChl and HB BPhe, which form part of one end of the carotenoid binding pocket, and the side chain of Phe M162. This residue undergoes significant movement into the empty carotenoid pocket in the R-26.1 RC (Fig. 3), and has been proposed to act as a ‘gatekeeper,’ occluding one end of the binding pocket in the absence of carotenoid and so preventing insertion of carotenoid into the complex from the wrong end (Roszak et al., 2004). The polar end of the carotenoid engages in a bonding interaction with Trp M75 at the opposite end of the binding pocket (McAuley et al., 2000), and this is also shown in Fig. 3.
The RC from carotenoid-containing strains of Rba. sphaeroides can be engineered to be carotenoid-deficient by a single mutation. The carotenoid is exposed at the intramembrane surface of the RC at both ends of its curved binding pocket, one end passing between the A and B helices of the M-polypeptide and the other between the C helix of the M-polypeptide and the phytol tail of the BB accessory BChl. A Gly, M71, is located at the point at which the carotenoid emerges between the A and B helices of the M-polypeptide, and mutagenesis to a larger Leu (GM71L) blocks the binding pocket with the result that carotenoid is not incorporated into the GM71L RC during assembly (Ridge et al., 1999). The alpha-carbon of this Gly is shown as a large sphere in Fig. 3. An X-ray crystal structure of the GM71L RC, determined to a resolution of 2.65 Å, showed that the carotenoid binding pocket was empty (Ridge, 1998), which could indicate that the LDAO depicted in Fig. 3 inserts from the ‘Gly M71 end’ of the carotenoid binding pocket, consistent with the gatekeeper role of Phe M162 (see above). The principal function of the RC carotenoid is to quench the energy of BChl triplet states before they can react to produce singlet oxygen, and so this GM71L mutation provides a means to engineer a RC in which BChl triplet states are long-lived, as well as providing a means of expressing a carotenoid-less RC in the presence of carotenoid-containing antenna complexes.
Chapter 16
Reaction Center Structural Plasticity
B. Quinone Exclusion Occupancy of the QB site in purified RCs is variable, due to the dissociable nature of the QB quinone, but the structure of the binding pocket does not seem to be affected by the presence or absence of the quinone. In the case of the QA quinone, mutations have been reported that either completely prevent incorporation of the quinone during assembly of the RC, or loosen its binding to such an extent that the quinone is lost on purification of the complex. The best characterized of these is an Ala to Trp change at the M260 position (AM260W), that causes the RC to assemble without a QA quinone by filling up space in the binding pocket normally occupied by the quinone head-group. The absence of quinone at QA in both membrane-bound and purified RCs has been demonstrated through a variety of spectroscopic techniques (Ridge et al., 1999; Wakeham et al., 2003, 2004) and X-ray crystallography (McAuley et al., 2000). This mutation blocks electron transfer along the A-branch of RC cofactors, and leaves the QB cofactor as the sole quinone in the complex, and so has been used by a number of research groups looking into mutations that promote B-branch electron transfer (for a review, see Wakeham and Jones, 2005, and also Paddock et al., 2005). Structural changes caused by steric exclusion of the QA quinone are restricted to part of a short loop of amino acids connecting the membrane-spanning E-helix of the M subunit with the de-helix (M256M260), and residue Gln H32 (McAuley et al., 2000). A chloride ion is also incorporated into the vacant QA binding pocket (see below). Although not characterized in as much depth, the mutation Ala M248 to Trp also causes the RC to assemble without a QA quinone (Ridge et al., 1999). A second class of mutations loosen binding of the QA quinone such that, although the QA site is wholly or partially occupied in membrane-embedded RCs, the QA site is unoccupied in detergent purified complexes. This has been achieved by mutating Trp M252 to a range of alternatives in Rb sphaeroides (Stilz et al., 1994), or the equivalent Trp M250 to Val (TM250V) in Rba. capsulatus (Coleman and Youvan, 1990). The structural consequences of mutation of this Trp residue are not known, but the TM250V change has been used as a QA-removing mutation in studies of B-branch electron transfer (Laible et al., 1998; Kirmaier et al., 2003; Laible et al., 2003). In the cases of mutation of Trp M252 to Phe and Tyr it is possible to reconstitute quinone into the QA site,
301 but this does not occur if this Trp is replaced by a non-aromatic amino acid (Stilz et al., 1994). In line with this, incubation of the purified TM250V RC with 30 – 40 molar equivalents of ubiquinone-6 achieves selective reconstitution of the QB ubiquinone (Laible et al., 1998, 2003; Kirmaier et al., 2003). C. Bacteriochlorin Exclusion Although they are larger than either quinone or carotenoid, certain of the bacteriochlorin cofactors can also be excluded from the RC by single point mutations. The best characterized of these is Ala M149 to Trp (AM260W), which causes the Rba. sphaeroides RC to assemble without the B-branch BPhe (Watson et al., 2005). This absence of the HB cofactor, which is evident from the X-ray crystal structure and absorbance spectra of membrane-bound RCs, has no obvious effect on function. The reported 3.4 Å resolution crystal structure (Watson et al., 2005), and a subsequent structure at 2.2 Å resolution (Watson, 2005), show that the absence of the HB BPhe has very little impact on the structure of the binding pocket and the neighboring cofactors. This is illustrated in Fig. 4, which shows the structure of the RC in the vicinity of the HB binding site in the wild-type and AM260W RC. The only significant change in the structure of the RC is a change in the conformation of the last 25 or so carbon atoms of the phytol chain of one of the special pair BChls (PB) in a proportion of the RCs in the crystal. In the wild-type RC this phytol chain projects laterally out of the RC between the phytol chain of HB and the BB cofactor (mid-grey sticks in Fig. 4b). In the AM149W RC the phytol tail of PB adopts roughly this conformation in around 40% of the RCs, and in the remainder occupies space deep in the HB binding pocket that is vacated by loss of the HB cofactor (shown as dark-grey sticks projecting vertically in Fig. 4b). This aside, the loss of the BPhe cofactor has very little impact on the structure of the HB binding pocket and neighboring cofactors, as can be seen by comparing the protein topology in Figs. 4a and 4b. This lack of any gross structural changes suggests a rather rigid protein structure, which would be consistent with the finding that many of the RC cofactors can be extracted from the complex and replaced by alternatives (see below). As with the carotenoid binding pocket it is not clear what fills the remainder of the HB pocket in the membrane-bound AM149W RC, but presumably lipid chains can extend into the cavity that is created.
302
Michael R. Jones
Fig. 4. Region around the HB site in the wild-type and AM149W RC complexes from Rba. sphaeroides. The protein is shown as a solid light-grey object, and the BB and QB cofactors as a solid mid-grey object. In (a) the HB cofactor is shown as dark-grey sticks and the phytol chain of PB as mid-grey sticks. In (b) the phytol chain of PB in the normal conformation is shown as mid-grey sticks (white arrow) and the phytol chain of PB in the alternate conformation is shown as dark-grey sticks (black arrow). See also Color Plate 7, Fig. 11.
A second mutant RC that lacks one of the RC BPhes, termed DLL, is discussed in Section V.A below. Two ‘dimer-less’ mutants of the Rba. sphaeroides RC have been described that appear to lack the primary donor BChls. The simplest of these has a Val to Arg mutation at position L157, which is located close to ring III of the PA BChl (Jackson et al., 1997). Purified VL157R RCs have a BChl:BPhe ratio of 1.25, which is consistent with the loss of an average of 1.5 BChls per RC, and the QY absorbance band of the P BChls is completely absent from the room temperature absorbance spectrum. This suggests that most, but perhaps not all, of the P BChls are absent from purified VL157R RCs. The second dimer-less RC has a triple glycine mutation (HL168G/HL173G/ HM202G – Triple-G) that removes the three His residues that engage in bonding interactions with the P BChls (Moore and Boxer, 1998). Purified RCs have a BChl:BPhe ratio of 1.1 which could indicate the loss of up to two BChls per RC, and again absorbance spectra of the Triple-G RC lack a P QY band. IV. Cofactor Replacement A. Bacteriochlorin Replacement Much of the site-directed mutagenesis carried out on
the RC has been aimed at modulating the properties of the cofactors, particularly in the case of the bacteriochlorins responsible for primary charge separation. So for example extensive use has been made of mutations that alter the redox potential of BChl or BPhe, or which substitute BChl for BPhe or vice versa (see below). An alternative approach, applied by Scheer and co-workers in particular, has been to use biochemical treatments to replace the native BChl a or BPhe a by an alternative bacteriochlorin. This subject and the underlying methodology has been reviewed in detail by Scheer and Struck (1993) and Scheer and Hartwich (1995), and so the following will be confined to a brief résumé of what is possible with this approach. The first reports of successful BChl replacement concerned the accessory cofactors BA and BB of the Rba. sphaeroides complex and involved incubating carotenoid-less R-26 RCs (see above) with a 20fold excess of the replacement bacteriochlorin for 90 min at 42.2 °C in Tris buffer containing 0.08 % LDAO and 10 % methanol. Similar experiments with wild-type RCs achieved selective replacement of the BA BChl (Scheer and Hartwich, 1995). Scheer and Struck (1993) have commented that temperature is a crucial factor in these exchange experiments, it being necessary to heat the protein to close to its ‘melting temperature’ in order to induce sufficient flexibility in the protein structure that the native cofactors can
Chapter 16
Reaction Center Structural Plasticity
exchange with the excess of replacement cofactor in solution, but without causing irreversible structural changes or denaturation. Franken and co-workers have reported that selective exchange of BA can be achieved in R26 RCs through variation of the incubation temperature (Franken et al., 1997a,b). Exchange of the BPhe cofactors HA and HB has also been achieved using this type of approach (Meyer and Scheer, 1995; Franken et al., 1997a), and bacteriochlorin exchange has also been reported for the RCs from Rsp. rubrum and Blc. viridis (Scheer and Hartwich, 1995). A variety of bacteriochlorins has been successfully introduced at the accessory BChl and BPhe locations, including 132-hydroxy, 3-(α-hydroxyethyl), 3-vinyl and (3-vinyl)-132-hydroxy derivatives of BChl a. A range of other bacteriochlorins has also been tested but with negative results, suggesting that the cofactor binding pockets do exert some selectivity on the type of bacteriochlorin that can be bound (see Storch et al., 1996, for experiments on stereoselectivity). The native Mg bacteriochlorins have also been replaced with Zn- and Ni-BChl a analogs in order to further vary redox potential (Scheer and Hartwich, 1995). It has not proven possible to replace BChl a with chlorophyll a, perhaps due to a lack of flexibility of the macrocycle (Scheer and Struck, 1993), but the native BPhe a cofactors have been successfully replaced by pheophytin a, pheophytin b and a number of derivatives thereof with altered substituent groups, as well as derivatives of BPhe a (Meyer and Scheer, 1995; Scheer and Hartwich, 1995). RCs with replaced bacteriochlorins have been used for a variety of purposes. Complexes with replaced accessory BChls have been used to examine ultrafast energy transfer and relaxation events amongst the accessory and P BChls (Hartwich et al., 1995a), assignments of the QY absorbance bands of the BA, BB and P BChls (Hartwich et al., 1995b), the role of BA in primary charge separation (Finkele et al., 1992, Sporlein et al., 2000), and the role of BB in the transfer of triplet state energy to the carotenoid (Frank et al., 1993, 1996). This last study involved replacement of BB with 132-hydroxy-Zn-BChl a or (3-vinyl)-132-hydroxy-BChl a in carotenoid-less R-26 RCs followed by reconstitution of spheroidenone into the carotenoid binding pocket. Complexes with pheophytin a in place of the BPhe a have been used to examine the issue of whether primary charge separation between P and HA is a two-step reaction involving BA– as a discrete intermediate, the pheophytin a providing a means of
303 altering the free energy of the P+HA– state to a point approximately isoenergetic with that of P+BA– (Shkuropatov and Shuvalov, 1993; Schmidt et al., 1994; Kennis et al., 1997; Huber et al., 1998, Sporlein et al., 2000). BPhe a replacement by pheophytin a, by the same method as that applied to R-26 RCs (Meyer and Scheer, 1995; Franken et al., 1997a), has also been applied to a mutant Rba. sphaeroides RC with a relatively long-lived primary donor singlet excited state (Shkuropatov et al., 2003). To date there does not appear to have been a report of exchange of the primary donor BChls by the technique outlined above. These BChls are rather less exposed to the intramembrane phase than the accessory BChls or BPhes, and therefore it is conceivable that they are less able to detach from the RC during the ‘protein breathing’ (Scheer and Struck, 1993) brought on by moderate heating of RCs in detergent. Partial (~30%) replacement of the primary donor BChls by Zn-BChl a has been reported by Kobayashi and co-workers using a somewhat different procedure in which the bacteriochlorin cofactors were released from Rba. sphaeroides R26 RCs in buffer with 5% octylglucoside using a 3-fold volume of acetone that contained an excess of either BChl a or Zn-BChl a (Kobayashi et al., 2004). The sample was then freezedried and the dried material was resuspended in water. A solution of Rba. sphaeroides lipids in buffer with 0.5 % deoxycholate was then added, and the detergent removed by dialysis. This procedure produced RCs at a yield of around 30% with a near-to-normal QY absorbance spectrum when added BChl a was used, and produced RCs with an altered spectrum when Zn-BChl a was used. HPLC analysis of these Zn-BChl a containing RCs indicated a 6:4 ratio of BChl to Zn-BChl, and simulation of absorbance and CD spectra suggested that 30% of the primary donor BChls had been replaced by Zn-BChl. Although the exchange is not stoichiometric, and the RCs containing Zn-BChl require further analysis, this appears to be an intriguing method for cofactor exchange involving reconstitution of extracted cofactors into the protein concurrent with reconstitution of RCs into liposomes. B. Quinone Replacement One of the first procedures to be developed for significantly altering the structure of the purple bacterial RC involved removal of the QA quinone from its intraprotein binding pocket, and its replacement
Michael R. Jones
304 by alternative quinone or non-quinone molecules (Okamura et al., 1975). Such QA-removed and QAsubstituted RCs have been used for a variety of purposes, but they have made particular contributions to study of the mechanism of biological electron transfer (Moser et al., 1992), through studies of the free energy dependence of the HA– to QA and QA– to P+ reactions. Changing the quinone species at the QA site alters the mid-point reduction potential of this cofactor, and so alters the free energy of the P+QA– state relative to the ground state or other radical pairs such as P+HA– or P+QB– . Incubation of purified RCs at 25 °C with LDAO and the quinone site inhibitor o-phenanthroline causes dissociation of the QA quinone without causing irreversible denaturation of the protein (Okamura et al., 1975). Quinone removal can be achieved by binding RCs to an ion exchange column and washing with the quinone removal buffer. Either native or non-native quinone species can then be reconstituted into the site by incubation of the QA-depleted RCs with an excess of the quinone in question (Okamura et al., 1975). A number of protocols have been described for QA depletion and reconstitution in both Rba. sphaeroides (Okamura et al., 1975; Gunner at al, 1986; Woodbury et al., 1986; Kálmán and Maroti, 1994) and Blc. viridis (Liu and Hoff, 1990; Breton, 1997), including procedures also involving depletion or replacement (with Zn2+) of the non-heme Fe (Liu et al., 1991b) (see below for more details). Non-quinone species have also been substituted into the QA site and tested for QA function (Warncke and Dutton, 1993a). RCs modified in this way have been used for a variety of purposes, including examining characteristics of the reduction of QA by HA– (Gunner and Dutton, 1989; Schelvis et al., 1992; Warncke and Dutton, 1993a; Laporte et al., 1995), the relationship between the rate and free energy for P+QA– recombination (Gopher et al., 1985; Kleinfeld et al., 1985; Gunner at al, 1986; Woodbury et al., 1986; Lersch and Michel-Beyerle, 1987; Kálmán and Maroti, 1994; Turzo et al., 2000; Xu and Gunner, 2000; Hucke et al., 2002), proton binding on reduction of QA (Kálmán and Maroti, 1994), P+QB– recombination (Labahn et al., 1995; Allen et al., 1998; Schmid and Labahn, 2000), features of the P+QA– radical pair state (Sebban, 1988; McPherson et al., 1990; van den Brink et al., 1994a; Morris et al., 1995; Hulsebosch et al., 1999), electron transfer from QA to QB (Graige et al., 1996, 1998, 1999; Li et al., 1998; Paddock et al., 1999b; Li et al., 2000b), affinity of the QB site for
various quinones (Giangiacomo and Dutton, 1989), enthalpy and volume changes on P+QA– formation using photoacoustic spectroscopy (Edens et al., 2000) and detailed analysis of the quinone environment using isotopically-labeled quinones (Breton et al., 1994a,b,c; Brudler et al., 1994; van den Brink et al., 1994b; van Liemt et al., 1995). The quinone replacement approach has also been used to study the affinity of the QA site for quinone (Warncke and Dutton, 1993b; Mallardi et al., 1998), including the influence of different types of tail (Warncke et al., 1994), and various substituents on the head-group that affect size and/or charge (Warncke and Dutton, 1993a; Hucke et al., 2002; Katz et al., 1991; Madeo and Gunner, 2005). In one case, for a RC with anthraquinone substituted into the QA site, the X-ray crystal structure has been determined to a resolution of 2.4 Å. The structure showed no detectable changes to the conformation of the backbone and residues that form the QA site (Kuglstatter et al., 2000), the three ring anthraquinone being oriented approximately coplanar to the native ubiquinone. Hydrogen bonding of the anthraquinone to the surrounding protein via its carbonyl groups was similar to that seen for ubiquinone in the wildtype RC (Kuglstatter et al., 2000). Electron density in the region of the isoprenoid quinone tail, which is absent in anthraquinone, was attributed to a molecule of LDAO (Kuglstatter et al., 2000). C. Carotenoid Replacement Experiments involving the reconstitution of non-native carotenoids have mainly involved carotenoid-less strains of purple bacteria such as Rba. sphaeroides strains R-26 and R-26.1 and Rsp. rubrum strain G9. A number of protocols have been described for the reconstitution of non-native carotenoids into such carotenoid-less RCs (Boucheret al., 1977; Agalidis et al., 1980; Davidson and Cogdell, 1981), and in the case of the R-26.1 RC this is achieved by sonication of a mixture of RCs and added carotenoid in the dark and on ice, followed by column chromatography to remove excess unbound carotenoid (Roszak et al., 2004). RCs with reconstituted carotenoids have been used to examine the influence of substituent groups and the extent of the conjugated π electron system on the ability of the carotenoid to carry out its photoprotective function, quenching of primary donor triplet states (Chadwick and Frank, 1986; Frank et al., 1986; Farhoosh et al., 1997), the role
Chapter 16
Reaction Center Structural Plasticity
played by the BA BChl in triplet transfer (Frank et al., 1993, 1996) and issues relating to the 15–15´-cis stereochemistry of the carotenoid in Rba. sphaeroides (Gebhard et al., 1991; Kok et al., 1994, 1997; Bautista et al., 1998). In the most recent studies Yanagi et al. (2005) have used R-26.1 RCs reconstituted with 3,4-dihydrospheroidene to examine the effect of the carotenoid cofactor on the electrostatic environment of the primary donor BChls, and Roszak and co-workers have used R-26.1 RCs reconstituted with spheroidene or 3,4-dihydrospheroidene to examine structural factors that ensure unidirectional binding of the carotenoid cofactor into its elongated, tubular binding pocket (Roszak et al., 2004). D. Iron Removal and Replacement Perhaps the most extensively employed structural modification of the RC is the removal of the nonheme iron atom, and its replacement with alternative divalent metals such as zinc. This iron replacement is a prerequisite to studies of the detailed structure and properties of the radical anions QA– • and QB– • through electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy (EPR), and related techniques such as ENDOR (electron nuclear double resonance) and ESEEM (electron spin-echo envelope modulation). This is because in the wild-type RC these radicals are strongly magnetically coupled to the high-spin Fe2+, and so only very broad EPR spectra can be obtained (see Utschig and Thurnauer (2004) for a review). Removal of the iron, or its replacement with the diamagnetic Zn2+, yields more detailed spectroscopic information. A number of protocols have been developed for both iron removal and metal exchange in Rba. sphaeroides (Debus et al., 1986; Utschig et al., 1997, 2005; Poluektov et al., 2005) and Blc. viridis (Gardiner et al., 1999; Utschig et al., 2005). In general these protocols involve incubating RCs with o-phenanthroline and a high concentration of lithium- or potassium thiocyanate to prepare Fe-removed RCs, followed by addition of ZnCl2 or ZnSO4 to prepare Zn-replaced RCs. Hermes and co-workers have also recently described a procedure in which Rba. sphaeroides was grown on a malate yeast medium in which FeSO4 was replaced with MnSO4 (Hermes et al., 2006 ). This resulted in complete replacement of the Fe atom with Mn, negating the need to carry out a biochemical exchange (see also discussion in Debus et al., 1986). Although it has only modest effects on the rate of electron transfer from QA– to QB (Debus et al., 1986),
305 Fe2+ removal causes an approximately 20-fold reduction in the rate of electron transfer from HA– to QA (Kirmaier et al., 1986). If Zn2+ is substituted into the site then a normal rate can be obtained for this reaction, depending on the procedure used (see Utschig et al., 1997, for a discussion and a review of earlier data). This effect on the HA– to QA reaction has been attributed to a change in reorganization energy for this step following Fe2+-depletion (Tang et al., 1999). Fe-removed and Zn-substituted RCs have been used for a variety of purposes; see the following for reviews of the older literature (Stehlik and Mobius, 1997; Lubitz and Feher, 1999; Möbius, 2000; Lubitz et al., 2002; Utschig and Thurnauer, 2004). Most recently, these preparations have been used to study how QA– and QB– hydrogen bond to the surrounding protein (Lubitz and Feher, 1999; Schnegg et al., 2002; Flores et al., 2006), protein reorganization on photogeneration of P+QA– (Zech et al., 1997; Borovykh et al., 1998; Poluektov et al., 2001; Poluektov et al., 2005), properties of the P+HA– state (Hulsebosch et al., 1999), light-induced conformational changes in and around the QB pocket (Utschig et al., 2005), the temperature dependence of the conformational flexibility of RCs (Borovykh et al., 2005), and spin-spin interactions between the iron and quinone or BPhe radicals (Calvo et al., 2002) and between QA– and QB– (Calvo et al., 2000, 2001). Fe2+-removed and Cu2+- substituted RCs have also been used to identify a Cu2+ binding site on the surface of the RC that modulates the rate of electron transfer from QA– to QB (Utschig et al., 2000; Utschig et al., 2001), similar to the Zn2+ binding site that also exerts this effect (Utschig et al., 1998). E. Genetic Approaches to Cofactor Replacement The use of site-directed mutagenesis to change the chemical character of the RC cofactors has focused on the bacteriochlorins, involving replacement of BChl by BPhe or vice versa. Each of the primary donor BChls has been replaced by BPhe by mutating the His residue that provides the axial ligand to the central Mg to a residue that cannot provide such a ligand, producing a BChl:BPhe heterodimer. This is achieved by mutating either His M202 to Leu for PA or His M173 to Leu for PB (Bylina and Youvan, 1988; Kirmaier et al., 1988). Mutation of His M202 to Glu also produces a heterodimer phenotype (Nabedryk et al., 2000). These heterodimer mutants have been heavily characterized, and their
306 properties and uses have been covered in a number of reviews (Coleman and Youvan, 1990; Woodbury and Allen, 1995; Parson, 1996; Hoff and Deisenhofer, 1997). Most recently they have been used in studies assessing the contribution of electronic coupling to B-branch electron transfer (Kirmaier et al., 2005), examining how the protein influences electronic asymmetry in the primary donor BChls (Moore et al., 1999), investigating alternative pathways for charge separation initiated by excitation of BA (van Brederode et al., 1999) and examination of the effects of hydrogen bond mutations on the electronic structure of the heterodimer (Nabedryk et al., 1998). The heterodimer mutants have also been structurally characterized using FTIR spectroscopy (Albouy et al., 1997; Nabedryk et al., 2000) and the X-ray crystal structure of the HM202L mutant has been reported (Camara-Artigas et al., 2002). The latter shows good preservation of the structure of the bacteriochlorin dimer. The mutation does produce very small shifts in the positions of backbone and side-chain atoms for residues M196-M206, but no longer range changes in the structure of the protein component. A water molecule normally located between the side-chain of His M202 and the keto carbonyl of BA is absent in the HM202L mutant; this water has a strong influence on the rate of primary charge separation (Potter et al., 2005) and so the effects of the heterodimer mutation on this process are likely to be due to a combination of the replacement of the BChl by BPhe and loss of this water. In the case of the accessory BChls, mutagenesis of His M182 to Leu causes replacement of the BB BChl with BPhe (Katilius et al., 1999). This mutant has been used in studies of B-branch electron transfer (for a review, see Wakeham and Jones, 2005) and has also been used to demonstrate the role of BB as an intermediate in singlet energy transfer from the carotenoid to P (Lin et al., 2006). On the A-branch, mutagenesis of His L153 to Leu in Blc. viridis causes the BA BChl to be replaced by BPhe. The main effect of this is to produce a very long-lived P+BA– state (Arlt et al., 1996). In Rba. sphaeroides the equivalent mutation (or a HL153F change) does not produce a clean replacement of BChl by BPhe, but rather produces more complex effects including alterations in the properties of the P BChls (Katilius et al., 2004). His L153 has also been replaced by Asp, Glu, Gln, Gly, Ser, Tyr and Val, and purified RCs from many of these mutants also show evidence of significant changes to the properties of P
Michael R. Jones in addition to blue-shifts of the QX and QY absorbance bands of BA (Katilius et al., 2004). Thus it would appear that replacement of His L153 without causing larger scale structural disturbance is possible in Blc. viridis but not in Rba. sphaeroides, possibly because the presence of the cytochrome subunit in the former helps to stabilize the structure of the L-polypeptide on the periplasmic side of the membrane. For the BPhe cofactors, mutagenesis of Leu M214 to His in Rba. sphaeroides (Kirmaier et al., 1991) or the equivalent Leu M212 to His in Rba. capsulatus (Heller et al., 1995b) causes replacement of BPhe by BChl. The properties of this so-called beta mutant have again been characterized in depth, and have been covered in a number of reviews (Woodbury and Allen, 1995; Parson, 1996; Hoff and Deisenhofer, 1997). These mutations have been particularly useful in studies of B-branch electron transfer (see Wakeham and Jones, 2005, for a review and for more recent reports see Kirmaier et al., 2005; Paddock et al., 2005; Kee et al., 2006). In addition the X-ray crystal structure of a Rba. sphaeroides RC with multiple mutations including the LM214H change has been reported, showing a clean replacement of BPhe by BChl with no additional significant changes in the structure of the protein or neighboring cofactors (Paddock et al., 2005). The HA BPhe is also replaced by BChl following mutation of Ala L124 to His, and a double mutation of Phe L121 to His and Phe L97 to either Val or Cys (Heller et al., 1995a). The structural basis for the latter changes is less obvious than for the more heavily characterized LM214H mutant, as the Phe at the L121 position does not sit over the center of the BPhe macrocycle, and so the new His could not donate a ligand to Mg without some more complex structural changes. One possibility is that water molecules are involved in the binding of BChl (Heller et al., 1995a) (see below). On the B-branch, mutation of Leu L185 to His causes replacement of the HB BPhe by BChl (Watson et al., 2005). This residue is the symmetrical equivalent of Leu M214 on the A-branch. In addition to site-directed mutagenesis, interruption or augmentation of the biosynthetic pathway for BChl has been used to alter the cofactor composition of the RC. In particular, this approach has been used to investigate whether the chemical nature of the ‘tail’ of BChl, a C20 isoprenoid, has an effect on assembly of the RC or its function. Bollivar and co-workers have reported a strain of Rba. capsulatus that produces BChl a esterified with geranylgeraniol rather than the
Chapter 16
Reaction Center Structural Plasticity
native phytol due to a lesion in the gene bchP (Bollivar et al., 1994). This gene encodes a biosynthetic enzyme, termed BchlaGG reductase, that is responsible for hydrogenation of the geranylgeraniol tail to phytol through the removal of three (of four) C=C bonds. The larger number of double bonds in geranylgeraniol is expected to affect properties such as the flexibility of the BChl a side chain. The mutant strain, designated DB391, was capable of photosynthetic growth at a six-fold reduced rate which appeared to be due to (again six-fold) lowered levels of the photosynthetic apparatus (Bollivar et al., 1994). RCs isolated from the DB391 strain showed largely normal absorbance and functional properties, apart from a small blueshift of the absorbance band of the accessory BChls that could indicate some small changes in structure of the complex, but showed evidence of a markedly decreased stability. This combination of properties would be consistent with a RC in which the tetrapyrrole rings are correctly positioned in the structure, producing normal functional properties, but where the esterified side-chains are incorrectly packed into the structure, compromising the stability of the complex. Addlesee and Hunter (1999) have produced an equivalent Rba. sphaeroides mutant with a lesion in bchP. This mutant showed a 27 % reduction in photosynthetic growth rate and around a 30% reduction in levels of light harvesting complex, consistent with the findings of Bollivar et al., but perhaps indicating a less serious effect on levels of RC complex in Rba. sphaeroides compared to Rba. capsulatus. In Rhodospirillum (Rsp.) rubrum the BChl synthesis pathway naturally produces BChl a esterified with geranylgeraniol as the end product for incorporation into RCs. Addlesee and Hunter (2002) have shown that heterologous expression of the bchP gene from Rba. sphaeroides in Rsp. rubrum causes the photosystem to assemble with BChl a esterified with phytol. The RCs and LH1 complexes from this strain were capable of supporting photosynthetic growth and showed only modest changes in spectroscopic properties (Qian et al., 2003). V. Helix Symmetrization The majority of spectroscopic studies aimed at probing RC mechanism are precluded in wild-type strains due the presence of the BChl and/or carotenoid cofactors of the antenna complexes. RCs therefore have to be removed from the membrane and purified, a procedure which is straightforward for wild-type
307 RCs but which can provide a stumbling block for studies on less stable mutant complexes. To overcome this problem, genetic systems involving gene deletions or point mutations have been devised for both Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus that remove the LH1 and LH2 antenna complexes, isolating the RC as the sole BChl-containing complex in the cell. The most widely used of these are the U43 strain of Rba. capsulatus, first constructed by Youvan and co-workers (Youvan et al., 1985), and the DD13 and DD13/G1 strains of Rba. sphaeroides, first constructed by Hunter and co-workers (Jones et al., 1992a,b). Strains of this type have proven particularly useful for studying RCs with large scale mutations, such as those described in the rest of this section. A. DLL, Cousins and Offspring The two-fold rotational structural symmetry displayed by the RC is in marked contrast to its strong functional asymmetry, and this intriguing aspect of RC design prompted a number of experiments aimed at ‘symmetrizing’ the RC through large scale mutations. In addition to producing a number of interesting phenotypes, this approach has illustrated the structural robustness of the purple bacterial RC, particularly when embedded in the native membrane. The best known and most extensively characterized RC of this type is the so-called DLL mutant of Rba. capsulatus, in which residues 192 to 217 of the M-polypeptide were replaced by the structurallyequivalent residues 165 to 190 of the L-polypeptide, a change equivalent to 13 single point mutations (Robles et al., 1990). The resulting RC assembles without a BPhe at the HA site, blocking A-branch electron transfer and greatly extending the lifetime of the primary donor excited state P*. Figure 5a shows the central location of the residues in question, in a model of the L- and M-polypeptides of the Rba. capsulatus RC constructed by Foloppe and coworkers (Foloppe et al., 1995). The replaced section of the M-polypeptide includes part of the D-helix and a loop connecting this to a helix exposed at the periplasmic surface of the complex (light-grey ribbon), and this crosses the symmetrically-equivalent section of the L-polypeptide (dark-grey ribbon) in the core of the RC. Figure 5b shows a more detailed view of the replaced region of the M-polypeptide and the adjacent HA BPhe (left), and an equivalent view of the D-helix of the L-polypeptide. In the region adjacent to the HA BPhe the most obvious differences between the two helices are a Trp in place of Leu at
Michael R. Jones
308
Fig. 5. Sequences involved in the DLL mutant from Rba. capsulatus. (a) The LM heterodimer in a model of the Rba. capsulatus RC (see text). In the DLL mutant residues 192-217 of the M-polypeptide (light-grey ribbons) are replaced by residues 165–190 of the Lpolypeptide (dark-grey ribbons). The location of residue L237 is indicated by the spheres. (b) Residues M192-217 and the adjacent HA BPhe (left) and an equivalent view of residues L165-190 (right). Color coding is as for (a) and residues mentioned in the text are labeled.
the position closest to the center of the HB macrocycle (locus M212), and a Thr in place of Gly at a position one turn further along the helix (locus M209) (Fig. 5b). It has been suggested that these two differences could be responsible for the lack of a HA BPhe in the DLL RC, the larger Trp and Thr preventing insertion of the BPhe into the complex (Foloppe et al., 1995). In support of this idea, the strain containing the DLL RC was able to regain the capacity to grow under photosynthetic conditions (at varying rates) after undergoing one or more spontaneous mutations that restored assembly of the RC with an HA BPhe (Robles et al., 1990). These mutations were
WM212L and WM212L/IM204T, which remove the large Trp residue adjacent to the expected position of the HA macrocycle, and MM216V and MM216T which reduce the volume of the side chain one turn of the helix away from this Trp (Fig. 5b). However, in Rba. sphaeroides at least, mutation of the Leu/Gly pair at the equivalent of the M212/M209 positions to Trp/Met does not cause the RC to assemble without this BPhe (unpublished observations). The principal use of the DLL RC has been in examining the properties of the P* state, and, because it is not stable in detergents such as LDAO, these studies have been carried out on DLL RCs embedded in native antenna-deficient membranes (Vos et al., 1991, 1993; Foloppe et al., 1995). Most recently this large scale mutation has been used in studies of B-branch electron transfer employing RCs solubilized in the detergent Deriphat 160-C, and purified using a His-tag (Chuang et al., 2006). The DLL mutation was combined with three additional changes, His M195 to Phe and His L168 to Phe to restore the mid-point redox potential of the P/P+ couple (Em P/P+) to close to the value in wild-type RCs, and a Phe L181 to Tyr change which, together with the Tyr M208 to Phe change already in the DLL multiple mutation, promotes B-branch electron transfer. The resulting mutant (named DLL-FYLFM) has a yield of 70% electron transfer along the B-branch to form P+HB–, more than twice that reported for any other mutant RC (Chuang et al., 2006). DMM helix-symmetrization and DLM helix-swap mutants have also been constructed, but these RCs are not stable, even when in the native membrane (Robles et al., 1990). This illustrates the point that although the RC can tolerate large scale mutation, whether or not the assembly or stability of the RC is compromised depends on the exact location and extent of the mutations, and symmetrical mutations do not always yield complementary results. Finally, a strain containing the DMM RC was able to regain the capacity for photosynthetic growth after undergoing the mutation FL187L or AL237P. The FL187L mutation restores the native, smaller side chain on the opposite side of the helix to the BPhe binding pocket, suggesting that incorrect helix packing could be the source of the instability of the DMM mutant. B. Sym-1 and Siblings In the so-called sym-1 mutant of Rba. capsulatus, residues 187 to 203 of the M-polypeptide were replaced with residues 160 to 176 of the L-polypeptide,
Chapter 16
Reaction Center Structural Plasticity
corresponding to 9 point mutations (Taguchi et al., 1992). The most notable effect of this large scale mutation was a large increase in Em P/P+, an effect common to the DLL mutant and attributed to replacement of Phe M195 by His (Stocker et al., 1992). This mutation causes donation of a new hydrogen bond to the acetyl carbonyl group of the PM BChl which could increase Em P/P+ (Wachtveitl et al., 1993; Mattioli et al., 1994, 1995), although Spiedel and co-workers have proposed that the strong increase in Em P/P+ is actually attributable to a charge-dipole interaction between P and the new His side chain (Spiedel et al., 2002). Subsequently, Taguchi and co-workers reported the construction of nine further symmetrizing mutations that, together with sym-1, cumulatively replaced 113 residues between positions 162 and 280 of the Mpolypeptide by the structurally-equivalent residues from the L-polypeptide (Taguchi et al., 1996). These mutations involved changes of stretches of between 5 and 24 amino acids, corresponding to between 4 and 16 point mutations in any one mutant. Five of these mutants were capable of photosynthetic growth, and of the remaining four only one did not appear to assemble RCs. Photosynthetic growth seemed particularly sensitive to mutations near the quinones, and in two of the non-photosynthetic mutants (sym0 and sym2-2) a photosynthetic-positive phenotype could be restored through a single point mutation in the M-polypeptide. Three of the mutants, sym0, sym2-1 and sym5-2 were subsequently studied by ultrafast transient absorption spectroscopy and the sym2-1 mutant in particular showed a reduced (35%) yield of A-branch charge separation and some evidence of 10–20 % electron transfer along the B-branch (Lin et al., 1996). The sym2-1 RC had a replacement of residues M205 to M210 by their L-polypeptide counterparts, and despite the altered primary photochemistry was still capable of supporting photosynthetic growth (Taguchi et al., 1996). This sym2-1 RC was subsequently used to study spectrally-distinct conformations of the RC that can be interchanged through alterations in ionic strength, detergent concentration or temperature (Eastman et al., 2000). The spectral changes involved the long-wavelength QY band of the P BChls, which also underwent a reversible change of around 30 mV in Em P/P+. C. QAQA and A6D1 Perhaps the most remarkable symmetrizing muta-
309
Fig. 6. Sequences involved in the QAQA and A6D1 mutants from Rba. capsulatus. In the QAQA mutant residues L193-227 (light grey ribbons) from around the QB quinone (light-grey spheres on right) are replaced by residues M220-261 (dark-grey ribbons) from around the QA quinone (light-grey spheres on left). In the A6D1 mutant residues Met M144 and Ala M145 (dark-grey spheres) are replaced by Ile and Ser, respectively.
tion is that seen in the so-called QAQA RC of Rba. capsulatus, in which 35 residues of the L-polypeptide (193–227) are replaced by 42 residues from the M-polypeptide (220–261) in a region of very weak sequence homology between the two (Coleman and Youvan, 1993). The location of the relevant sequences is shown in Fig. 6, which again is based on a model of the Rba. capsulatus RC by Foloppe and co-workers (Foloppe et al., 1995). In each polypeptide the sequence in question corresponds to two loops and a short helix that connect the cytoplasmic ends of the D and E membrane-spanning helices, and forms part of the contact surface between the membrane-embedded LM heterodimer and the cytoplasmic domain of the H-polypeptide. The mutation constructed by Coleman and Youvan replaced the region of the protein that comprises the QB binding pocket with an equivalent region from the QA binding pocket, and according to the alignment presented by Li et al. (2000a) this corresponds to 31 point mutations together with the introduction of an additional seven amino acids. Among the residues mutated by this large scale resculpting are groups known to be key to QB function such as Glu L212, Asp L213 and Ser L223. Perhaps not surprisingly the strain containing the QAQA RC was not capable of photosynthetic growth, but a remarkable result obtained with a derivative of the QAQA RC illustrates another aspect of the structural plasticity of the purple
310 bacterial RC. Returning to definitions of plasticity, in neuroscience the term neuroplasticity refers to the capacity of an area of the brain to assume some of the function of a damaged area. In a (slightly contrived) parallel, the Rba. capsulatus RC shows remarkable structural plasticity in response to the loss of photosynthetic function induced by the QAQA mutation, the RC regaining the capacity to support photosynthetic growth through just two spontaneous point mutations near the HB cofactor (Coleman and Youvan, 1993). These mutations, of Met M144 to Ile and Ala M145 to Ser, are located in a region of M-polypeptide well outside the symmetrized region (see Fig. 6) and arose in response to incubation of the QAQA strain under photosynthetic growth conditions. The resulting so-called A6D1 complex was stable in detergent solution and, despite the extensive mutagenic alteration, showed only modest changes in the characteristics of electron transfer reactions involving QB. The affinity of ubiquinone for the new QB site was only three-fold lower than that in wild-type RC, and the strongest effect was a ~500-fold reduction in the rate of the first electron transfer from QA– to QB (Li et al., 2000a). Although Met M144 is rather close to the head-group of the QB quinone (Fig. 6), in the absence of direct structural information it is difficult to understand how these two point mutations can partially overcome the impairment of function engendered by the large scale QAQA mutation, and produce a QB site that is sufficiently functional to support photosynthetic growth. Studies of mutants of Glu L212 and Asp L213, two key residues in the QB site involved in proton delivery to QB (for reviews, see Okamura et al., 2000; Wraight, 2004), have also shown how photosynthetic function can be restored by mutations somewhat removed from the original mutation site. Around a dozen mutations have been identified that restore photosynthetic capacity to RCs with mutations at these key acidic amino acids, some of which are a considerable distance from the QB site. A feature of many of these mutations is that they either introduce a negative charge or remove a positive charge, indicating that their primary influence is electrostatic (Okamura et al., 2000). However the distance of some of these mutations from the QB site suggests that larger scale structural changes may also be involved, altering the electrostatic contributions made by a number of residues (Sebban et al., 1995; Paddock et al., 1999a; Tandori et al., 2001).
Michael R. Jones VI. Water and Other Unexpected Things in Electron Density Maps For some of the suppressor mutations outlined in the last section it is possible to rationalize the restoration of QB function, but for others this is not easy, particularly in the case of more distant mutations. One possibility that has to be borne in mind for many of these mutations is a change in the number and position of bound water molecules near the QB site. Water, due to its polar character, propensity to form H-bonds and ability to act as a proton donor, can exert significant effects that can be difficult to predict when designing a mutagenesis experiment. As an example, mutation of Ser L223 to Ala or Asn produces a RC with a non-functional QB site, whereas mutation to Gly does not impair QB function (Paddock et al., 1995). Similarly, it has been found that a Glu L212 to Gln mutant is non-functional whereas a Glu L212 to Ala mutant retains function (Miksovska et al., 1997). In both cases it has been proposed that the smaller side chain creates a cavity that is occupied by a water that is able to substitute for the native Ser or Glu (Paddock et al., 1995; Miksovska et al., 1997). This is not possible when the Ser is replaced by a larger Ala or Asn, or when Glu is replaced by Gln. Changes in water structure have also been proposed to explain restoration of QB function by a Leu L227 to Phe mutation (Miksovska et al., 1997). Water is also thought to play a role in BChl binding in mutants where the His residues that donate the axial ligands to the P BChls are replaced by Gly. Mutation of either of these His residues (L173 and M202) to a non-polar side-chain such as Leu or Phe is documented to cause the RC to assemble with a BPhe in place of the native BChl, forming a so-called heterodimer RC with a BChl:BPhe primary electron donor. In order to explain the presence of a largely unperturbed BChl:BChl pair in a HL173G and HM202G mutant, Goldsmith et al. (1996) proposed that a water molecule occupies the cavity created by the His to Gly change and provides the essential fifth ligand to the BChl Mg (see also, Czarnecki et al., 2006). A similar explanation has been put forward by Heller et al. (1995a) to explain replacement of the active branch BPhe by BChl in a FL97V/FL124H double mutant where the new L124 His is poorly positioned to be the ligand donor (see above). In order to be certain as to the extent of any functional influence of new (or excluded) waters and other small molecules in a mutant complex it is advanta-
Chapter 16
Reaction Center Structural Plasticity
311
Fig. 7. Stereo view of the distribution of water molecules in an X-ray crystal structure of the Rba. sphaeroides RC. Waters are shown as dark-grey spheres.
geous to combine spectroscopic investigations with X-ray crystallography. However, even then it may not be easy to be certain about the role played by an individual water. The numbers of water molecules included in the various structures for the purple bacterial RC are highly variable, reflecting variations in the quality of electron density from one dataset to the next. Figure 7 shows the distribution of 368 water molecules included in a recently published structure for a mutant Rba. sphaeroides RC, at 2.4 Å resolution (Potter et al., 2005). Waters are mainly grouped at the periplasmic and cytoplasmic sides of the membrane, with relatively few in the region of the protein that occupies the hydrophobic core of the membrane. However significant numbers of waters are found in the vicinity of the P BChls and the quinones, and as the individual located half-way across the membrane demonstrates it is possible for water molecules to be found buried deep in the intramembrane region of the protein interior. The number and arrangement of waters is particularly varied in parts of the structure where the electron density map is complex, such as surface-exposed areas and regions such as the QB site. The latter is particularly challenging as the quinone can be bound at substoichiometric levels and in at least two binding positions (Lancaster and Michel, 1997; Stowell et al., 1997; Kuglstatter et al., 2001), and the number and position of water molecules
may vary depending on the presence and position of the quinone. Obtaining an accurate picture of the arrangement of water molecules in a particular RC is challenging, but is often important if the properties of a particular mutant are to be fully understood. An example of a mutant RC where the influence of an individual water molecule is revealed is the GM203L RC of Rba. sphaeroides, where a Gly residue located between the primary donor BChls and the BA BChl is changed to a larger Leu (Potter et al., 2005). One result of this mutation is an approximately eight-fold slowing in the rate of primary electron transfer, one of the strongest effects reported for a single point mutation. Immediately adjacent to the Gly side chain at the M202 position is a water molecule that is in hydrogen bond distance to the keto carbonyl group of BA and to the side-chain of His M202. The X-ray crystal structure of the GM203L mutant shows that the larger Leu side-chain takes up the volume normally occupied by this water, excluding it from the structure (Potter et al., 2005). The mutation thus removes any electrostatic or hydrogen bond interactions that exist between this water and the primary electron donor on one side, and the primary electron acceptor on the other. Although the exact reason(s) for the slowing of primary electron transfer in response to removal of this water remain to be determined, and could
312 arise from more than one source (see discussion in Yakovlev et al., 2005), it is clear the water has a strong influence on the kinetics of the reaction. This underscores the importance of treating the solvent as a significant element of the structure of the RC, alongside the protein and cofactors, and the need to be aware of the significant effects that changes in the structure of this solvent can have on the properties of mutant RCs, particularly when larger scale changes in structure are being attempted. An aspect of the X-ray crystal structure of the QAdeficient AM260W RC described above is the presence of a feature in the QA binding pocket assigned as a chloride ion (McAuley et al., 2000; Paddock et al., 2005). This ion fills part of the space usually occupied by the head-group of the QA quinone and is in bonding distance to nitrogens in the side chains of His M219, Trp M252 and the new Trp M260. The presence of this ion was only detected when the X-ray crystal structure of the AM260W RC was solved and its effects on the functional properties of the RC (if any) are unclear. One possibility that has been raised is that a negatively charged ion at this location could influence the binding position of the QB quinone, although this remains speculation. This finding highlights a further hazard of protein engineering that produces significant changes in structure – the potential for additional ions or small molecules of uncertain influence being incorporated into the altered protein structure – and underscores the need for structural data to be obtained where possible. A chloride is also present in almost exactly the same position in the X-ray crystal structure of the AM248W RC, which as mentioned above also lacks the QA quinone (M. R. Jones and P. K. Fyfe, unpublished). As with the AM260W RC, the chloride sits in a cavity that is lined by nitrogen atoms of the side-chains of a His and two Trp residues. The electronegative chloride therefore is not only an appropriate size to fit into this particular cavity, but also can solvate the partial positive charges on the surrounding side-chain nitrogens. On this theme, Takahashi and Wraight (2006) have recently proposed that small molecules can penetrate the interior of the RC protein and influence functional properties by showing that a variety of weak acids can restore proton transfer to the QB quinone in a double mutant RC (Asp L210 to Asn and Asp M17 to Asn) that has a very strong impairment of proton transfer ability. These acidic amino acids are located in the middle of a putative proton transfer pathway that leads
Michael R. Jones from the cytoplasmic surface of the H-polypeptide to the buried QB site, and it has been suggested that smaller weak acids such as azide or fluoride can penetrate into the interior of the RC and partially overcome the lesion created when these acidic amino acids are mutated to Asn. If this is correct then this represents another example of a non-native molecule being incorporated into the structure of the RC and influencing functional properties of the complex. VII. Building New Functionality The first steps have been taken towards building new functionality into the purple bacterial RC, with the engineering of Rba. sphaeroides RCs capable of the photo-oxidation of tyrosine and, more recently, the tight binding and oxidation of manganese. These experiments address a major difference between the purple bacterial RC and Photosystem II, with chlorophyll photo-oxidation in the latter producing water oxidation in the so-called manganese cluster as a result of a series of electron transfer reactions facilitated by an intervening tyrosine residue. To achieve a potential sufficiently oxidizing to extract an electron from a Tyr, Kálmán and co-workers raised the mid-point potential for single electron oxidation of the primary donor BChls by several hundred millivolts to around +0.8 V through mutation of Leu L131, Leu M160 and Phe M197 to His, and Tyr M210 to Trp (Kálmán et al., 1999). Evidence for tyrosine oxidation was then seen in RCs carrying an additional tyrosine substitution at Arg M164, Arg L135 or Phe L167, namely the spectral signature of a tyrosyl radical obtained through EPR spectroscopy (Kálmán et al., 1999, 2003b). Histidine mutations were also introduced near each of these engineered tyrosines, and near the native Tyr L162 and Tyr M193 residues, to provide an acceptor for the phenolic proton of the Tyr that is released on photo-oxidation (Narváez et al., 2004). This study showed that each of the two native or three engineered tyrosines can be photooxidized to form a neutral tyrosyl radical, with yields that were influenced by pH and the availability of a proton acceptor. RCs with the triple His mutation at residues Leu L131, Leu M160 and Phe M197 have also been shown to be capable of oxidizing weakly bound manganese (Kálmán et al., 2003a), and more recently Thielges and co-workers have reported structural modifications of the RC that result in the tight-binding of a
Chapter 16
Reaction Center Structural Plasticity
313
Fig. 8. An engineered Mn2+ binding site on the periplasmic surface of the Rba. sphaeroides RC. The stereo view shows the protein as a solid object except for amino acids (sticks) and waters (mid-grey spheres) involved in binding the Mn2+ (dark-grey sphere). For the amino acids, nitrogen or oxygen atoms are shown in mid-grey. The residues are (left to right) Glu M173, Glu M168, Tyr M164, Asp M288, His M193 and Asp M292.
photo-oxidizable manganese (Thielges et al., 2005). The design of this site was based around residue Glu M173 which occupies an approximately equivalent position to residue Asp 170 of the D1 polypeptide in Photosystem II, a key residue involved in binding of the manganese cluster (see Thielges et al., 2005, for a detailed discussion of design principles). Four mutant RCs with different combinations of Asp and Glu residues near Glu M173 were constructed, using a background that included the LL131H, LM160H, FM197H and YM210W mutations that raise the oxidation potential of P, and the RM164Y mutation that introduces a photo-oxidizable Tyr near the primary donor. Of the four mutants constructed, three were found to bind manganese and the most tightly-binding of these, termed M2, had a dissociation constant of 1 µM and transferred an electron from the manganese to the photo-oxidized primary donor with a lifetime of 12 ms (Thielges et al., 2005). The binding of Mn was found to be pH dependent, and around pH 8 binding was concomitant with the release of two protons (Kálmán et al., 2005). The M2 mutant, which contained the changes Met M168 to Glu and Gly M288 to Asp in addition to those detailed above, was also characterized by Xray crystallography, and the key structural features are depicted in Fig. 8. Although caution has to be
exercised with this structure given a limited resolution (4.5 Å), it shows a manganese ion and two water molecules bound to the periplasmic surface of the RC and engaging in interactions with four acidic residues and a His. Residue Glu M173 is shown on the left in Fig. 8, together with (left to right) the engineered Glu M168 and Asp M288, and the native residues His M193 and Asp M292. Immediately below this surface-exposed binding site is the engineered Tyr M164. Thielges and co-workers have discussed the extent to which this structure matches the original design for a Mn site involving these mutations and, returning to a theme explored above, have commented on the unanticipated role played by water in forming part of the binding site (Thielges et al., 2005). As well as providing interesting insights into the rational design of a new binding site for a redox-active metal cofactor, this work addresses evolutionary connections between the purple bacterial RC and its water oxidizing counterpart from oxygenic photosynthetic organisms. VIII. Conclusions To close, the structural plasticity exhibited by the purple bacterial RC has made a major contribution
314 to our understanding of the mechanism of photosynthetic energy transduction and biological electron transfer. Although often difficult to predict, the tolerance displayed to significant changes in structure and composition makes this protein an ideal tool for uncovering the more deeply-buried secrets of these fundamental biological processes, and opens the door to the engineering of new biological function based around light-activated redox chemistry. Acknowledgments The author thanks laboratory members and collaborators past and present for enjoyable discussions, and the Biotechnology and Biological Research Council for financial support. All Figures were produced using PyMOL (DeLano, 2002) References Addlesee HA and Hunter CN (1999) Physical mapping and functional assignment of the geranylgeranyl-bacteriochlorophyll reductase gene, bchP, of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Bact 181: 7248–7255 Addlesee HA and Hunter CN (2002) Rhodospirillum rubrum possesses a variant of the bchP gene, encoding geranylgeranylbacteriopheophytin reductase. J Bact 184: 1578–1586 Agalidis I, Lutz M and Reiss-Husson F (1980) Binding of carotenoids on reaction centers from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides R-26. Biochim Biophys Acta 589: 264–274 Albouy D, Kuhn M, Williams JC, Allen JP, Lubitz W and Mattioli TA (1997) Fourier transform Raman investigation of the electronic structure and charge localization in a bacteriochlorophyll-bacteriopheophytin dimer of reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochim Biophys Acta-Bioenerg 1321: 137–148 Allen JP, Williams JC, Graige MS, Paddock ML, Labahn A, Feher G and Okamura MY (1998) Free energy dependence of the direct charge recombination from the primary and secondary quinones in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Photosynth Res 55: 227–233 Alric J, Cuni A, Maki H, Nagashima KVP, Verméglio A and Rappaport F (2004) Electrostatic interaction between redox cofactors in photosynthetic reaction centers. J Biol Chem 279: 47849–47855 Alric J, Lavergne J, Rappaport F, Verméglio A, Matsuura K, Shimada K and Nagashima KVP (2006) Kinetic performance and energy profile in a roller coaster electron transfer chain: A study of modified tetraheme-reaction center constructs. J Am Chem Soc 128: 4136–4145 Arlt T, Dohse B, Schmidt S, Wachtveitl J, Laussermair E, Zinth W and Oesterhelt D (1996) Electron transfer dynamics of Rhodopseudomonas viridis reaction centers with a modified binding site for the accessory bacteriochlorophyll. Biochemistry
Michael R. Jones 35: 9235–9244 Bautista JA, Chynwat V, Cua A, Jansen FJ, Lugtenburg J, Gosztola D, Wasielewski MR and Frank HA (1998) The spectroscopic and photochemical properties of locked-15,15´-cis-spheroidene in solution and incorporated into the reaction center of Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26.1. Photosynth Res 55: 49–65 Bollivar DW, Wang SJ, Allen JP and Bauer CE (1994) Molecular-genetic analysis of terminal steps in bacteriochlorophyll a biosynthesis — characterization of a Rhodobacter capsulatus strain that synthesizes geranylgeraniol-esterified bacteriochlorophyll a. Biochemistry 33: 12763–12768 Borovykh IV, Dzuba SA, Proskuryakov II, Gast P and Hoff AJ (1998) Light-induced structural changes in photosynthetic reaction centers studied by ESEEM of spin-correlated D+QA– radical pairs. Biochim Biophys Acta-Bioenerg 1363: 182–186 Borovykh IV, Gast P and Dzuba SA (2005) ‘Glass transition’ near 200 K in the bacterial photosynthetic reaction center protein detected by studying the distances in the transient P+QA– radical pair. J Phys Chem B 109: 7535–7539 Boucher F, van der Rest M and Gingras G (1977) Structure and function of carotenoids in photoreaction center from Rhodospirillum rubrum. Biochim Biophys Acta 461: 339–357 Breton J (1997) Efficient exchange of the primary quinone acceptor QA in isolated reaction centers of Rhodopseudomonas viridis. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 94: 11318–11323 Breton J, Boullais C, Burie JR, Nabedryk E and Mioskowski C (1994a) Binding-sites of quinones in photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers investigated by light-induced FTIR difference spectroscopy — assignment of the interactions of each carbonyl of QA in Rhodobacter sphaeroides using site-specific C13-labeled ubiquinone. Biochemistry 33: 14378–14386 Breton J, Burie J-R, Berthomieu C, Berger G and Nabedryk EC (1994b) The binding-sites of quinones in photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers investigated by light-induced FTIR difference spectroscopy: Assignment binding of the QA vibrations in Rhodobacter-sphaeroides using 18O- or 13C-labeled ubiquinone and vitamin K1. Biochemistry 33: 4953–4965 Breton J, Burie JR, Boullais C, Berger G and Nabedryk E (1994c) Binding-sites of quinones in photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers investigated by light-induced FTIR difference spectroscopy — binding of chainless symmetrical quinones to the QA site of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 33: 12405–12415 Brudler R, De Groot HJM, van Liemt WBS, Steggerda WF, Esmeijer R, Gast P, Hoff AJ, Lugtenburg J and Gerwert K (1994) Asymmetric binding of the 1-C=0 and 4-C=0 groups of QA in Rhodobacter sphaeroides R26 reaction centers monitored by Fourier-transform infrared-spectroscopy using site-specific isotopically labeled ubiquinone-10. EMBO J 13: 5523–5530 Bylina EJ and Youvan DC (1988) Directed mutations affecting spectroscopic and electron-transfer properties of the primary donor in the photosynthetic reaction center. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 85: 7226–7230 Calvo R, Abresch EC, Bittl R, Feher G, Hofbauer W, Isaacson RA, Lubitz W, Okamura MY and Paddock ML (2000) EPR study of the molecular and electronic structure of the semiquinone biradical QA–• QB– • in photosynthetic reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Am Chem Soc 122: 7327–7341 Calvo R, Isaacson RA, Paddock ML, Abresch EC, Okamura MY, Maniero AL, Brunel LC and Feher G (2001) EPR study of the semiquinone biradical QA–• QB– • in photosynthetic reaction cen-
Chapter 16
Reaction Center Structural Plasticity
ters of Rhodobacter sphaeroides at 326 GHz: Determination of the exchange interaction Jo. J Phys Chem B 105: 4053–4057 Calvo R, Isaacson RA, Abresch EC, Okamura MY and Feher G (2002) Spin-lattice relaxation of coupled metal-radical spindimers in proteins: Application to Fe2+-cofactor (QA– •, QB– •, Φ – •) dimers in reaction centers from photosynthetic bacteria. Biophys J 83: 2440–2456 Camara-Artigas A, Magee C, Goetsch A and Allen JP (2002) The structure of the heterodimer reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides at 2.55 Ångstrom resolution. Photosynth Res 74: 87–93 Chadwick BW and Frank HA (1986) Electron-spin-resonance studies of carotenoids incorporated into reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides R26.1. Biochim Biophys Acta 851: 257–266 Chen X-Y, Yurkov V, Paddock ML, Okamura MY and Beatty JT (1998) A puhA gene deletion and plasmid complementation system for facile site directed mutagenesis studies of the reaction center H protein of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Photosynth Res 55: 369–373 Chuang JI, Boxer SG, Holten D, Kirmaier C (2006) High yield of M-side electron transfer in mutants of Rhodobacter capsulatus reaction centers lacking the L-side bacteriopheophytin. Biochemistry 45: 3845–3851 Clayton RK and Smith C (1960) Rhodopseudomonas spheroides: High catalase and blue-green double mutants. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 3: 143–145 Coleman WJ and Youvan DC (1990) Spectroscopic analysis of genetically modified photosynthetic reaction centers. Ann Rev Biophys Biophys Chem 19: 333–367 Coleman WJ and Youvan DC (1993) Atavistic reaction center. Nature 366: 517–518 Czarnecki K, Chen L, Diers JR, Frank HA, Bocian DF (2006) Low-frequency resonance Raman studies of the H(M202)G cavity mutant of bacterial photosynthetic reaction centers. Photosynth Res 88: 31–41 Davidson E and Cogdell RJ (1981) The polypeptide composition of the B850 light-harvesting pigment-protein complex from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides, R26.1. FEBS Letts 132: 81–84 Debus RJ, Feher G and Okamura MY (1985) LM complex of reaction centers from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides R26 — characterization and reconstitution with the H-subunit. Biochemistry 24: 2488–2500 Debus RJ, Feher G and Okamura MY (1986) Iron-depleted reaction centers from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides R26.1 — characterization and reconstitution with Fe2+, Mn2+, Co2+, Ni2+, Cu2+, and Zn2+. Biochemistry 25: 2276–2287 Deisenhofer J and Norris JR (eds) (1993) The Photosynthetic Reaction Center. Vols 1 and 2. Academic Press, San Diego DeLano WL (2002) The PyMOL Molecular Graphics System, DeLano Scientific, San Carlos. http://pymol.sourceforge.net/ (July 06, 2007) Eastman JE, Taguchi AKW, Lin S, Jackson JA and Woodbury NW (2000) Characterization of a Rhodobacter capsulatus reaction center mutant that enhances the distinction between spectral forms of the initial electron donor. Biochemistry 39: 14787–14798 Edens GJ, Gunner MR, Xu Q and Mauzerall D (2000) The enthalpy and entropy of reaction for formation of P+QA– from excited reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Am
315 Chem Soc 122: 1479–1485 Encyclopaedia Britannica Online. http://www.britannica.com (July 27, 2006) Farhoosh R, Chynwat V, Gebhard R, Lugtenburg J and Frank HA (1997) Triplet energy transfer between the primary donor and carotenoids in Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26.1 reaction centers incorporated with spheroidene analogs having different extents of π-electron conjugation. Photochem Photobiol 66: 97–104 Finkele U, Lauterwasser C, Struck A, Scheer H and Zinth W (1992) Primary electron transfer kinetics in bacterial reaction centers with modified bacteriochlorophylls at the monomeric sites BA,B. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 89: 9514–9518 Flores M, Isaacson R, Abresch E, Calvo R, Lubitz W and Feher G (2006) Protein-cofactor interactions in bacterial reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26: I. Identification of the ENDOR lines associated with the hydrogen bonds to the primary quinone QA•–. Biophys J 90: 3356–3362 Foloppe N, Breton J and Smith JC (1995) Conformational energetics of a partially symmetrized photosynthetic reaction center. Chem Phys Letts 242: 238–243 Frank HA, Chadwick BW, Taremi S, Kolaczkowski S and Bowman MK (1986) Singlet and triplet absorption-spectra of carotenoids bound in the reaction centers of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides R26. FEBS Letts 203: 157–163 Frank HA, Chynwat V, Hartwich G, Meyer M, Katheder I and Scheer H (1993) Carotenoid triplet-state formation in Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26 reaction centers exchanged with modified bacteriochlorophyll pigments and reconstituted with spheroidene. Photosynth Res 37: 193–203 Frank HA, Chynwat V, Posteraro A, Hartwich G, Simonin I and Scheer H (1996) Triplet state energy transfer between the primary donor and the carotenoid in Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26.1 reaction centers exchanged with modified bacteriochlorophyll pigments and reconstituted with spheroidene. Photochem Photobiol 64: 823–831 Franken EM, Shkuropatov AY, Francke C, Neerken S, Gast P, Shuvalov VA, Hoff AJ and Aartsma TJ (1997a) Reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26 with selective replacement of bacteriopheophytin by pheophytin a. I. Characterisation of steady-state absorbance and circular dichroism, and of the P+QA– state. Biochim Biophys Acta 1319: 242–250 Franken EM, Shkuropatov AY, Francke C, Neerken S, Gast P, Shuvalov VA, Hoff AJ and Aartsma TJ (1997b) Reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26 with selective replacement of bacteriopheophytin by pheophytin a. II. Temperature dependence of the quantum yield of P+QA– and 3P formation. Biochim Biophys Acta 1321: 1–9 Fukushima A, Matsuura K, Shimada K and Satoh T (1988) Reaction center-B870 pigment protein complexes with bound cytochromes c-555 and c-551 from Rhodocyclus gelatinosus. Biochim Biophys Acta 933: 399–405 Gardiner AT, Zech SG, MacMillan F, Käss H, Bittl R, Schlodder E, Lendzian F, and Lubitz W (1999) Electron paramagnetic resonance studies of zinc-substituted reaction centers from Rhodopseudomonas viridis. Biochemistry 38: 11773–11787 Gebhard R, van der Hoef K, Violette CA, de Groot HJM, Frank HA and Lugtenburg J (1991) C13 magic angle spinning NMR evidence for a 15,15´-Z configuration of the spheroidene chromophore in the Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction center — synthesis of C13-labeled and H2-labeled spheroidenes. Pure Applied Chem 63: 115–122
316 Giangiacomo KM and Dutton PL (1989) In photosynthetic reaction centers, the free-energy difference for electron-transfer between quinones bound at the primary and secondary quinonebinding sites governs the observed secondary site specificity. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 86: 2658–2662 Goldsmith JO, King B and Boxer SG (1996) Mg coordination by amino acid side chains is not required for assembly and function of the special pair in bacterial photosynthetic reaction centers. Biochemistry 35: 2421–2428 Gopher A, Blatt Y, Schonfeld M, Okamura MY, Feher G and Montal M (1985) The effect of an applied electric field on the charge recombination kinetics in reaction centers reconstituted in planar lipid bilayers Biophys. J. 48: 311–320 Graige MS, Paddock ML, Bruce JM, Feher G and Okamura MY (1996) Mechanism of proton-coupled electron transfer for quinone QB reduction in reaction centers of Rb sphaeroides. J Am Chem Soc 118: 9005–9016 Graige MS, Feher G and Okamura MY (1998) Conformational gating of the electron transfer reaction QA– • QB– • → QAQB– • in bacterial reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides determined by a driving force assay. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 95: 11679–11684 Graige MS, Paddock ML, Feher G and Okamura MY (1999) Observation of the protonated semiquinone intermediate in isolated reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Implications for the mechanism of electron and proton transfer in proteins. Biochemistry 38: 11465–11473 Gunner MR and Dutton PL (1989) Temperature and ∆G° dependence of the electron-transfer from Bph– to QA in reaction center protein from Rhodobacter sphaeroides with different quinones as QA. J Am Chem Soc 111: 3400–3412 Gunner MR, Robertson DE and Dutton PL (1986) Kinetic-studies on the reaction center protein from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides — the temperature and free-energy dependence of electron-transfer between various quinones in the QA site and the oxidized bacteriochlorophyll dimer. J Phys Chem 90: 3783–3795 Hara M, Kaneko T, Nakamura C, Asada Y and Miyake J (1998) Redox properties of an H-subunit-depleted photosynthetic reaction center from Rhodopseudomonas viridis. Biochim Biophys Acta-Bioenerg 1363: 199–208 Hartwich G, Friese M, Scheer H, Ogrodnik A and Michel-Beyerle ME (1995a) Ultrafast internal conversion in 132-OH-Ni-bacteriochlorophyll in reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides R26. Chem Phys 197: 423–434 Hartwich G, Scheer H, Aust V, Angerhofer A (1995b) Absorption and ADMR studies on bacterial photosynthetic reaction centers with modified pigments. Biochim Biophys Acta-Bioenerg 1230: 97–113 Heller BA, Holten D and Kirmaier C (1995a) Characterization of bacterial reaction centers having mutations of aromatic residues in the binding-site of the bacteriopheophytin intermediary electron carrier. Biochemistry 34: 5294–5302 Heller BA, Holten D and Kirmaier C (1995b) Control of electron-transfer between the L-side and M-side of photosynthetic reaction centers. Science 269: 940–945 Hermes S, Bremm O, Garczarek F, Derrien V, Liebisch P, Loja P, Sebban P, Gerwert K and Haumann M (2006) A time-resolved iron-specific X-ray absorption experiment yields no evidence for an Fe2+ → Fe3+ transition during QA → QB electron transfer in the photosynthetic reaction center. Biochemistry 45: 353–359
Michael R. Jones Hoff AJ and Deisenhofer J (1997) Photophysics of photosynthesis: Structure and spectroscopy of reaction centres of purple bacteria. Physics Reports-Review Section of Physics Letters 287: 2–247 Huber H, Meyer M, Scheer H, Zinth W and Wachtveitl J (1998) Temperature dependence of the primary electron transfer reaction in pigment-modified bacterial reaction centers. Photosynth Res 55: 153–162 Hucke O, Schmid R and Labahn A (2002) Exploring the primary electron acceptor QA-site of the bacterial reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides — binding mode of vitamin K derivatives. Eur J Biochem 269: 1096–1108 Hulsebosch RJ, Borovykh IV, Paschenko SV, Gast P and Hoff AJ (1999) Radical pair dynamics and interactions in quinone-reconstituted photosynthetic reaction centers of Rb. sphaeroides R26: A multifrequency magnetic resonance study. J Phys Chem B 103: 6815–6823 Hunter CN (1995) Genetic manipulation of the antenna complexes of purple bacteria. In: Blankenship RE, Madigan MT and Bauer CE (eds) Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 2), pp 473–501. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Jackson JA, Lin S, Taguchi AKW, Williams JC, Allen JP and Woodbury NW (1997) Energy transfer in Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centers with the initial electron donor oxidized or missing. J Phys Chem B 101: 5747–5754 Jones MR, Fowler GJS, Gibson LCD, Grief GG, Olsen JD, Crielaard W and Hunter CN (1992a) Construction of mutants of Rhodobacter sphaeroides lacking one or more pigment-protein complexes and complementation with reaction centre, LH1 and LH2 genes. Mol Microbiol 6: 1173–1184 Jones MR, Visschers RW, van Grondelle R and Hunter CN (1992b) Construction and characterisation of a mutant of Rhodobacter sphaeroides with the reaction centre as the sole pigment-protein complex. Biochemistry 31: 4458–4465 Kálmán L and Maroti P (1994) Stabilization of reduced primary quinone by proton uptake in reaction centers of Rhodobactersphaeroides. Biochemistry 33: 9237–9244 Kálmán L, LoBrutto R, Allen JP and Williams JC (1999) Modified reaction centres oxidize tyrosine in reactions that mirror Photosystem II. Nature 402: 696–699 Kálmán L, LoBrutto R, Allen JP and Williams JC (2003a) Manganese oxidation by modified reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 42: 11016–11022 Kálmán L, LoBrutto R, Narváez AJ, Williams JC and Allen JP (2003b) Correlation of proton release and electrochromic shifts of the optical spectrum due to oxidation of tyrosine in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 42: 13280–13286 Kálmán L, Thielges MC, Williams JC and Allen JP (2005) Proton release due to manganese binding and oxidation in modified bacterial reaction centers. Biochemistry 44: 13266–13273 Katilius E, Turanchik T, Lin S, Taguchi AKW and Woodbury NW (1999) B-side electron transfer in a Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction center mutant in which the B-side monomer bacteriochlorophyll is replaced with bacteriopheophytin. J Phys Chem B 103: 7386–7389 Katilius E, Babendure JL, Lin S and Woodbury NW (2004) Electron transfer dynamics in Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction center mutants with a modified ligand for the monomer bacteriochlorophyll on the active side. Photosynth Res 81:
Chapter 16
Reaction Center Structural Plasticity
165–180 Katz EY, Shkuropatov AY, Klevanik AV, Adanin VM and Shuvalov VA (1991) Effect of the structure of exogenous quinone on its ability to function as the primary quinone in the reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26. Biol Memb 8: 468–475 Kee HL, Laible PD, Bautista JA, Hanson DK, Holten D and Kirmaier C (2006) Determination of the rate and yield of B-side quinone reduction in Rhodobacter capsulatus reaction centers. Biochemistry 45: 7314–7322 Kennis JTM, Shkuropatov AY, van Stokkum IHM, Gast P, Hoff AJ, Shuvalov VA and Aartsma TJ (1997) Formation of a long-lived P+BA– state in plant pheophytin-exchanged reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides R26 at low temperature. Biochemistry 36: 16231–16238 Kirmaier C, Holten D, Debus RJ, Feher G and Okamura MY (1986) Primary photochemistry of iron-depleted and zinc-reconstituted reaction centers from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 83: 6407–6411 Kirmaier C, Holten D, Bylina EJ and Youvan DC (1988) Electron-transfer in a genetically modified bacterial reaction center containing a heterodimer. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 85: 7562–7566 Kirmaier C, Gaul D, DeBey R, Holten D and Schenck CC (1991) Charge separation in a reaction center incorporating bacteriochlorophyll for photoactive bacteriopheophytin. Science 251: 922–927 Kirmaier C, Laible PD, Hanson DK and Holten D (2003) B-side charge separation in bacterial photosynthetic reaction centers: Nanosecond time scale electron transfer from HB– to QB. Biochemistry 42: 2016–2024 Kirmaier C, Bautista JA, Laible PD, Hanson DK and Holten D (2005) Probing the contribution of electronic coupling to the directionality of electron transfer in photosynthetic reaction centers. J Phys Chem B 109: 24160–24172 Kleinfeld D, Okamura MY and Feher G (1985) Charge recombination kinetics as a probe of protonation of the primary acceptor in photosynthetic reaction centers Biophys J 48: 849–852 Knox PP, Churbanova IY, Zakharova NI, Krasil’nikov PM, Lukashev EP, Rubin AB and Shaitan KV (2001) Effects of extraction of the H-subunit from Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centers on relaxation processes associated with charge separation. Biochem-Moscow 66: 91–95 Kobayashi M, Takaya A, Kanai N, Ota Y, Saito T, Wang Z-Y and Nozawa T (2004) Reconstitution and replacement of bacteriochlorophyll a molecules in photosynthetic reaction centers. J Biochem 136: 363–369 Kok P, Kohler J, Groenen EJJ, Gebhard R, van der Hoef K, Lugtenburg J, Hoff AJ, Farhoosh R and Frank HA (1994) Towards a vibrational analysis of spheroidene — resonance Ramanspectroscopy of C13-labeled spheroidenes in petroleum ether and in the Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction center. Biochim Biophys Acta 1185: 188–192 Kok P, Kohler J, Groenen EJJ, Gebhard R, vanderHoef I, Lugtenburg J, Farhoosh R and Frank HA (1997) Resonance Raman spectroscopy of H2-labelled spheroidenes in petroleum ether and in the Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centre. Spectrochim Acta A-Mol Biomol Spec 53: 381–392 Kortluke C, Breese K, Gadon N, Labahn A and Drews G (1997) Structure of the puf operon of the obligately aerobic, bacteriochlorophyll a-containing bacterium Roseobacter denitrificans
317 OCh114 and its expression in a Rhodobacter capsulatus puf puc deletion mutant. J Bact 179: 5247–5258 Kuglstatter A, Miksovska J, Sebban P and Fritzsch G (2000) Structure of the photosynthetic reaction centre from Rhodobacter sphaeroides reconstituted with anthraquinone as primary quinone QA. FEBS Letts 472: 114–116 Kuglstatter A, Ermler U, Michel H, Baciou L and Fritzsch G. (2001) X-ray structure analysis of photosynthetic reaction center variants from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Structural changes induced by point mutations at position L209 modulate electron and proton transfer. Biochemistry 40: 4253–4260 Labahn A, Bruce JM, Okamura MY and Feher G (1995) Direct charge recombination from D+QAQB– to DQAQB in bacterial reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides containing low potential quinone in the QA site. Chem Phys 197: 355–366 Laible PD, Kirmaier C, Holten D, Tiede DM, Schiffer M and Hanson DK (1998) Formation of P+QB– via B-branch electron transfer in mutant reaction centers. In: Garab G (ed) Photosynthesis: Mechanisms and Effects, pp 849–852. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Laible PD, Kirmaier C, Udawatte CSM, Hofman SJ, Holten D and Hanson DK (2003) Quinone reduction via secondary Bbranch electron transfer in mutant bacterial reaction centers. Biochemistry 42: 1718–1730 Lancaster CRD and Michel H (1997) The coupling of lightinduced electron transfer and proton uptake as derived from crystal structures of reaction centres from Rhodopseudomonas viridis modified at the binding site of the secondary quinone, QB. Structure 5: 1339–1359 Laporte L, Kirmaier C, Schenck CC and Holten D (1995) Free-energy dependence of the rate of electron-transfer to the primary quinone in beta-type reaction centers. Chem Phys 197: 225–237 Lersch W and Michel-Beyerle ME (1987) Implications of spin dynamics for the charge recombination in iron-depleted and quinone-substituted reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26. Biochim Biophys Acta 891: 265–274 Li JL, Gilroy D, Tiede DM and Gunner MR (1998) Kinetic phases in the electron transfer from P+QA– QB to P+QAQB– and the associated processes in Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26 reaction centers. Biochemistry 37: 2818–2829 Li J, Coleman WJ, Youvan DC and Gunner MR (2000a) Characterization of a symmetrized mutant RC with 42 residues from the QA site replacing residues in the QB site. Photosynth Res 64: 41–52 Li JL, Takahashi E and Gunner MR (2000b) –∆G°AB, and pH dependence of the electron transfer from P+QA– QB to P+QAQB– in Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centers. Biochemistry 39: 7445–7454 Lin S, Xiao WZ, Eastman JE, Taguchi AKW and Woodbury NW (1996) Low-temperature femtosecond-resolution transient absorption spectroscopy of large-scale symmetry mutants of bacterial reaction centers. Biochemistry 35: 3187–3196 Lin S, Katilius E, Ilagan RP, Gibson GN, Frank HA and Woodbury NW (2006) Mechanism of carotenoid singlet excited state energy transfer in modified bacterial reaction centers. J Phys Chem B 110: 15556–15563 Liu BL and Hoff AJ (1990) QA-depletion and reconstitution of a reaction center preparation from the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodopseudomonas viridis. FEBS Letts 269: 354–357 Liu BL, van Kan PJM and Hoff AJ (1991a) Influence of the H-
318 subunit and Fe2+ on electron-transport from I– to QA in Fe2+-free and or H-free reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26. FEBS Letts 289: 23–28 Liu BL, Yang LH and Hoff AJ (1991b) On the depletion and reconstitution of both QA and metal in reaction centers of the photosynthetic bacterium Rb sphaeroides R-26. Photosynth Res 28: 51–58 Lubitz W and Feher G (1999) The primary and secondary accepters in bacterial photosynthesis III. Characterization of the quinone radicals QA•– and QB•– by EPR and ENDOR. Appl Mag Res 17: 1–48 Lubitz W, Lendzian F and Bittl R (2002) Radicals, radical pairs and triplet states in photosynthesis. Acc Chem Res 35: 313–320 Madeo J and Gunner MR (2005) Modeling binding kinetics at the QA site in bacterial reaction centers. Biochemistry 44: 10994–11004 Maki H, Matsuura K, Shimada K and Nagashima KVP (2003) Chimeric photosynthetic reaction center complex of purple bacteria composed of the core subunits of Rubrivivax gelatinosus and the cytochrome subunit of Blastochloris viridis. J Biol Chem 278: 3921–3928 Mallardi A, Giustini M and Palazzo G (1998) Binding of ubiquinone to photosynthetic reaction centers. 2. Determination of enthalpy and entropy changes for the binding to the QA site in reverse micelles. J Phys Chem B 102: 9168–9173 Masuda S, Tsukatani Y, Kimura Y, Nagashima KVP, Shimada K and Matsuura K (2002) Mutational analyses of the photosynthetic reaction center-bound triheme cytochrome subunit and cytochrome c2 in the purple bacterium Rhodovulum sulfidophilum. Biochemistry 41: 11211–11217 Matsuura K, Fukushima A, Shimada K and Satoh T (1988) Direct and indirect electron transfer from cytochromes c and c2 to the photosynthetic reaction center in pigment-protein complexes isolated from Rhodocyclus gelatinosus. FEBS Lett 237: 21–25 Mattioli TA, Williams JC, Allen JP and Robert B (1994) Changes in primary donor hydrogen-bonding interactions in mutant reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Identification of the vibrational frequencies of all the conjugated carbonyl groups. Biochemistry 33: 1636–1643 Mattioli TA, Lin X, Allen JP and Williams JC (1995) Correlation between multiple hydrogen-bonding and alteration of the oxidation potential of the bacteriochlorophyll dimer of reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 34: 6142–6152 McAuley KE, Fyfe PK, Ridge JP, Cogdell RJ, Isaacs NW and Jones MR (2000) Ubiquinone binding, ubiquinone exclusion, and detailed cofactor conformation in a mutant bacterial reaction center. Biochemistry 39: 15032–15043. McPherson PH, Nagarajan V, Parson WW, Okamura MY and Feher G (1990) pH-dependence of the free-energy gap between DQA and D+QA– determined from delayed fluorescence in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26. Biochim Biophys Acta 1019: 91–94 Meyer M and Scheer H (1995) Reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides R26 containing C-3 acetyl and vinyl (bacterio)pheophytins at sites HA,B . Photosynth Res 44:55– 65 Miksovska J, Kálmán L, Schiffer M, Maroti P, Sebban P and Hanson DK (1997) In bacterial reaction centers rapid delivery of the second proton to QB can be achieved in the absence of
Michael R. Jones L212Glu. Biochemistry 36: 12216–12226 Möbius K (2000) Primary processes in photosynthesis: What do we learn from high-field EPR spectroscopy? Chem Soc Rev 29: 129–139 Moore L and Boxer SG (1998) Inter-chromophore interactions in pigment-modified and dimer-less bacterial photosynthetic reaction centers. Photosynth Res 55: 173–180 Moore LJ, Zhou HL and Boxer SG (1999) Excited-state electronic asymmetry of the special pair in photosynthetic reaction center mutants: Absorption and stark spectroscopy. Biochemistry 38: 11949–11960 Morris AL, Snyder SW, Zhang YN, Tang J, Thurnauer MC, Dutton PL, Robertson DE and Gunner MR (1995) Electron-spin polarization model applied to sequential electron-transfer in iron-containing photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers with different quinones as QA. J Phys Chem 99: 3854–3866 Moser CC, Keske JM, Warncke K, Farid R S and Dutton PL (1992) Nature of biological electron transfer. Nature 355: 796–802 Nabedryk E, Breton J, Williams JC, Allen JP, Kuhn M and Lubitz W (1998) FTIR characterization of the primary electron donor in double mutants combining the heterodimer HL(M202) with the LH(L131), HF(L168), FH(M197), or LH(M160) mutations. Spectrochim Acta A-Mol Biomol Spec 54: 1219–1230 Nabedryk E, Schulz C, Muh F, Lubitz W and Breton J (2000) Heterodimeric versus homodimeric structure of the primary electron donor in Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centers genetically modified at position M202. Photochem Photobiol 71: 582–588 Nagashima KVP, Shimada K and Matsuura K (1996) Shortcut of the photosynthetic electron transfer in a mutant lacking the reaction center-bound cytochrome subunit by gene disruption in a purple bacterium, Rubrivivax gelatinosus. FEBS Letts 385: 209–213 Narváez AJ, LoBrutto R, Allen JP and Williams JC (2004) Trapped tyrosyl radical populations in modified reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 43: 14379–14384 Okamura MY, Isaacson RA and Feher G. (1975) Primary acceptor in bacterial photosynthesis — obligatory role of ubiquinone in photoactive reaction centers of Rhodopseudomonas spheroides. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 72: 3491–3495 Okamura MY, Paddock ML, Graige MS and Feher G (2000) Proton and electron transfer in bacterial reaction centers. Biochim Biophys Acta: Bioenerg 1458: 148–163 Paddock ML, Feher G and Okamura MY (1995) Pathway of proton transfer in bacterial reaction centers: Further investigations on the role of Ser-L223 studied by site-directed mutagenesis. Biochemistry 34: 15742–15750 Paddock ML, Axelrod HL, Abresch EC, Yeh AP, Rees DC, Feher G and Okamura MY (1999a) Crystal structure of a photosynthetic revertant from Rb. sphaeroides: Mechanism of action of a long distant suppressor mutation. Biophys J 76: A141-A141 Paddock ML, Graige MS, Feher G and Okamura MY (1999b) Identification of the proton pathway in bacterial reaction centers: Inhibition of proton transfer by binding of Zn2+ and Cd2+. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 96: 6183–6188 Paddock ML, Chang C, Xu Q, Abresch EC, Axelrod HL, Feher G and Okamura MY (2005) Quinone (QB) reduction by Bbranch electron transfer in mutant bacterial reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Quantum efficiency and X-ray structure. Biochemistry 44: 6920–6928 Parson WW (1991) Reaction centers. In: Scheer H (ed) Chloro-
Chapter 16
Reaction Center Structural Plasticity
phylls, pp 1153–1180. CRC Press, Boca Raton Parson WW (1996) Photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers. In: Bendall DS (ed) Protein Electron Transfer, pp 125–160. BIOS Scientific Publishers, Oxford Poluektov OG, Utschig LM, Tang J, Dubinski AA, Schlesselman S, Thurnauer MC (2001) High-frequency EPR approach to the electron spin-polarization effects observed in the photosynthetic reaction centers. Appl Mag Res 21: 311–323 Poluektov OG, Utschig LM, Dubinskij AA and Thurnauer MC (2005) Electron-transfer pathways and protein response to charge separation in photosynthetic reaction centers: timeresolved high-field ENDOR of the spin-correlated radical pair P865+QA–. J Am Chem Soc 127: 4049–4059 Potter JA, Fyfe PK, Frolov D, Wakeham MC, van Grondelle R, Robert B and Jones MR (2005) Strong effects of an individual water molecule on the rate of primary charge separation in the Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centre. J Biol Chem 280: 27155–27164 Qian P, Addlesee HA, Ruban AV, Wang PY, Bullough PA and Hunter CN (2003) A reaction center-light-harvesting 1 complex (RC-LH1) from a Rhodospirillum rubrum mutant with altered esterifying pigments. J Biol Chem 278: 23678–23685 Reed W and Clayton RK (1968) Isolation of a reaction center fraction from Rhodopseudomonas spheroides. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 30: 471–475 Ridge JP (1998) The role of the protein during energy transduction in the bacterial reaction centre. PhD Thesis, University of Sheffield Ridge JP, van Brederode ME, Goodwin MG, van Grondelle R and Jones MR (1999) Mutations that modify or exclude binding of the QA ubiquinone and carotenoid in the reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Photosynth Res 59: 9–26 Robles SJ, Breton J and Youvan DC (1990) Partial symmetrization of the photosynthetic reaction center. Science 248: 1402–1405 Roszak AW, McKendrick K, Gardiner AT, Mitchell IA, Isaacs NW, Cogdell RJ, Hashimoto H and Frank HA (2004) Protein regulation of carotenoid binding: Gatekeeper and locking amino acid residues in reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Structure 12: 765–773 Scheer H and Hartwich G (1995) Bacterial reaction centers with modified tetrapyrrole chromophores. In: Blankenship RE, Madigan MT and Bauer C (eds) Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 2), pp 649–663, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Scheer H and Struck A (1993) Bacterial reaction centers with modified tetrapyrrole chromophores. In: Deisenhofer J and Norris JR (eds) The Photosynthetic Reaction Center, Vol. 1, pp 157–192. Academic Press, San Diego Schelvis JPM, Liu BL, Aartsma TJ and Hoff AJ (1992) The electron-transfer rate from BphA– to QA in reaction centers of Rhodobacter-sphaeroides R-26 -influence of the H-subunit, the QA and Fe2+ cofactors, and the isoprene tail of QA. Biochim Biophys Acta 1102: 229–236 Schmid R and Labahn A (2000) Temperature and free energy dependence of the direct charge recombination rate from the secondary quinone in bacterial reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Phys Chem B 104: 2928–2936 Schmidt S, Arlt T, Harem P, Huber H, Nagele T, Wachtveitl J, Meyer M, Scheer H and Zinth W (1994) Energetics of the primary electron transfer reaction revealed by ultrafast spec-
319 troscopy on modified bacterial reaction centers. Chem Phys Letts 223: 116–120 Schnegg A, Fuhs M, Rohrer M, Lubitz W, Prisner TF and Möbius K (2002) Molecular dynamics of QA– • and QB– • in photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers studied by pulsed high-field EPR at 95 GHz. J Phys Chem B 106: 9454–9462 Sebban P (1988) Activation-energy of the rate-constant of P+QA– absorption decay in reaction centers from Rhodobactersphaeroides reconstituted with different anthraquinones. FEBS Letts 233: 331–334 Sebban P and Lindqvist L (1987) Kinetic-study of PF and CarT states in the LM subunit purified from the wild-type Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centers. Photosynth Res 13: 57–67 Sebban P, Maroti P, Schiffer M and Hanson DK (1995) Electrostatic dominoes — long-distance propagation of mutational effects in photosynthetic reaction centers of Rhodobacter capsulatus. Biochemistry 34: 8390–8397 Shkuropatov AY and Shuvalov VA (1993) Electron transfer in pheophytin a-modified reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides (R-26). FEBS Letts 322: 168–172 Shkuropatov AY, Neerken S, Permentier HP, de Wijn R, Schmidt KA, Shuvalov VA, Aartsma TSJ, Gast P and Hoff AJ (2003) The effect of exchange of bacteriopheophytin a with plant pheophytin a on charge separation in Y(M210)W mutant reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides at low temperature. Biochim Biophys Acta-Bioenerg 1557: 1–12 Spiedel D, Jones MR and Robert B (2002) Tuning of the redox potential of the primary electron donor in reaction centres of purple bacteria: Effects of amino acid polarity and position. FEBS Letts 527: 171–175 Sporlein S, Zinth W, Meyer M, Scheer H and Wachtveitl J (2000) Primary electron transfer in modified bacterial reaction centers: Optimization of the first events in photosynthesis. Chem Phys Letts 322: 454–464 Stehlik D and Möbius K (1997) New EPR methods for investigating photoprocesses with paramagnetic intermediates. Ann Rev Phys Chem 48: 745–784 Stilz HU, Finkele U, Holzapfel W, Lauterwasser C, Zinth W and Oesterhelt D (1994) Influence of M-subunit Thr222 and Trp252 on quinone binding and electron-transfer in Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centers. Eur J Biochem 223: 233–242 Stocker JW, Taguchi AKW, Murchison HA, Woodbury NW and Boxer SG (1992) Spectroscopic and redox properties of Sym1 and (M)F195H — Rhodobacter capsulatus reaction center symmetry mutants which affect the initial electron-donor. Biochemistry 31: 10356–10362 Storch KF, Cmiel E, Schafer W and Scheer H (1996) Stereoselectivity of pigment exchange with 132-hydroxylated tetrapyrroles in reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides R26. Eur J Biochem 238: 280–286 Stowell MHB, McPhillips TM, Rees DC, Soltis SM, Abresch E and Feher G (1997) Light-induced structural changes in photosynthetic reaction center: Implications for mechanism of electron-proton transfer. Science 276: 812–816 Taguchi AKW, Stocker JW, Alden RG, Causgrove TP, Peloquin JM, Boxer SG and Woodbury NW (1992) Biochemical characterization and electron transfer reactions of Sym1, a Rhodobacter capsulatus reaction center symmetry mutant which affects the initial electron donor. Biochemistry 31: 10345–10355 Taguchi AKW, Stocker JW, Boxer SG and Woodbury NW (1993)
320 Photosynthetic reaction center mutagenesis via chimeric rescue of a non-functional Rhodobacter capsulatus puf operon with sequences from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Photosynth Res 36: 43–58 Taguchi AKW, Eastman JE, Gallo DM, Sheagley E, Xiao WZ and Woodbury, NW (1996) Asymmetry requirements in the photosynthetic reaction center of Rhodobacter capsulatus. Biochemistry 35: 3175–3186 Takahashi E and Wraight CA (2006) Small weak acids reactivate proton transfer in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides mutated at Asp(L210) and Asp(M17). J Biol Chem 281: 4413–4422 Tandori J, Baciou L, Alexov E, Maroti P, Schiffer M, Hanson DK and Sebban P (2001) Revealing the involvement of extended hydrogen bond networks in the cooperative function between distant sites in bacterial reaction centers. J Biol Chem 276: 45513–45515 Tang J, Utschig LM, Poluektov O and Thurnauer MC (1999) Transient W-band EPR study of sequential electron transfer in photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers. J Phys Chem B 103: 5145–5150 Tehrani A and Beatty JT (2004) Effects of precise deletions in Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction center genes on steady-state levels of reaction center proteins: A revised model for reaction center assembly. Photosynth Res 79: 101–108 Tehrani A, Prince RC and Beatty JT (2003) Effects of photosynthetic reaction center H protein domain mutations on photosynthetic properties and reaction center assembly in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 42: 8919–8928 Thielges M, Uyeda G, Cámara-Artigas A, Kálmán L, Williams JC and Allen JP (2005) Design of a redox-linked active metal site: Manganese bound to bacterial reaction centers at a site resembling that of Photosystem II. Biochemistry 44: 7389–7394 Turzo K, Laczko G, Filus Z and Maroti P (2000) Quinonedependent delayed fluorescence from the reaction center of photosynthetic bacteria. Biophys J 79: 14–25 Utschig LM and Thurnauer MC (2004) Metal ion modulated electron transfer in photosynthetic proteins. Acc Chem Res 37: 439–447 Utschig LM, Greenfield SR, Tang J, Laible PD and Thurnauer MC (1997) Influence of iron-removal procedures on sequential electron transfer in photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers studied by transient EPR spectroscopy. Biochemistry 36: 8548–8558 Utschig LM, Ohigashi Y, Thurnauer MC and Tiede DM (1998) A new metal-binding site in photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers that modulates QA to QB electron transfer. Biochemistry 37: 8278–8281 Utschig LM, Poluektov O, Tiede DM and Thurnauer MC (2000) EPR investigation of Cu2+-substituted photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers: Evidence for histidine ligation at the surface metal site. Biochemistry 39: 2961–2969 Utschig LM, Poluektov O, Schlesselman SL, Thurnauer MC and Tiede DM (2001) Cu2+ site in photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides, Rhodobacter capsulatus, and Rhodopseudomonas viridis. Biochemistry 40: 6132–6141 Utschig LM, Thurnauer MC, Tiede DM and Poluektov OG (2005) Low-temperature interquinone electron transfer in photosynthetic reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Blastochloris viridis: Characterization of QB-states by
Michael R. Jones high-frequency electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and electron-nuclear double resonance (ENDOR). Biochemistry 44: 14131–14142 van Brederode ME and Jones MR (2000) Reaction centres of purple bacteria. In: Scrutton NS and Holzenburg A (eds) Enzyme-Catalysed Electron and Radical Transfer, pp 621–676. Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, New York van Brederode ME, van Stokkum IHM, Katilius E, van Mourik F, Jones MR and van Grondelle R (1999) Primary charge separation routes in the BChl:BPhe heterodimer reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 38: 7545–7555 van den Brink JS, Hulsebosch RJ, Gast P, Hore PJ and Hoff AJ (1994a) QA binding in reaction centers of the photosynthetic purple bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides R26 investigated with electron spin polarization spectroscopy. Biochemistry 33: 13668–13677 van den Brink JS, Spoyalov AP, Gast P, van Liemt WBS, Raap J, Lugtenburg J and Hoff AJ (1994b) Asymmetric binding of the primary acceptor quinone in reaction centers of the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides R26, probed with Q-band (35 GHz) EPR spectroscopy. FEBS Letts 353: 273–276. van Liemt WBS, Boender GJ, Gast P, Hoff AJ, Lugtenburg J and de Groot HJM (1995) C13 magic-angle-spinning NMR characterization of the functionally asymmetric QA binding in Rhodobacter sphaeroides R26 photosynthetic reaction centers using site-specific C13-labeled ubiquinone-10. Biochemistry 34: 10229–10236 Vos MH, Lambry JC, Robles SJ, Youvan DC, Breton J and Martin JL (1991) Direct observation of vibrational coherence in bacterial reaction centers using femtosecond absorptionspectroscopy. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 88: 8885–8889 Vos MH, Rappaport F, Lambry JC, Breton J and Martin JL (1993) Visualization of coherent nuclear motion in a membrane-protein by femtosecond spectroscopy. Nature 363: 320–325 Wachtveitl J, Farchaus JW, Das R, Lutz M, Robert B and Mattioli TA (1993) Structure, spectroscopic and redox properties of Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centers bearing point mutations near the primary electron donor. Biochemistry 32: 12875–12886 Wakeham MC and Jones MR (2005) Rewiring photosynthesis: engineering wrong-way electron transfer in the purple bacterial reaction centre. Biochem Soc Trans 33: 851–857 Wakeham MC, Goodwin MG, McKibbin C and Jones MR (2003) Photo-accumulation of the P+QB– radical pair state in purple bacterial reaction centres that lack the QA ubiquinone. FEBS Letts 540: 234–240 Wakeham MC, Breton J, Nabedryk E and Jones MR (2004) Formation of a semiquinone at the QB site by A-branch or Bbranch electron transfer in the reaction centre from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 43: 4755–4763 Warncke K and Dutton PL (1993a) Influence of QA site redox cofactor structure on equilibrium binding, in situ electrochemistry, and electron-transfer performance in the photosynthetic reaction center protein. Biochemistry 32: 4769–4779 Warncke K and Dutton PL (1993b) Experimental resolution of the free-energies of aqueous solvation contributions to ligand protein-binding — quinone-QA site interactions in the photosynthetic reaction center protein. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 90: 2920–2924 Warncke K, Gunner MR, Braun BS, Gu LQ, Yu CA, Bruce JM
Chapter 16
Reaction Center Structural Plasticity
and Dutton PL (1994) Influence of hydrocarbon tail structure on quinone binding and electron-transfer performance at the QA and QB sites of the photosynthetic reaction-center protein. Biochemistry 33: 7830–7841 Watson AJ (2005) Stability and interactions of the purple bacterial reaction centre. PhD Thesis, University of Bristol Watson AJ, Fyfe PK, Frolov D, Wakeham MC, Nabedryk E, van Grondelle R, Breton J and Jones MR (2005) Replacement or exclusion of the B-branch bacteriopheophytin in the purple bacterial reaction centre: the HB cofactor is not required for assembly or core function of the Rhodobacter sphaeroides complex. Biochim Biophys Acta: Bioenerg 1710: 34–46 Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. http://en.wikipedia.org (July 27, 2006) Wong DK-H, Collins WJ, Harmer A, Lilburn TG and Beatty JT (1996) Directed mutagenesis of the Rhodobacter capsulatus puhA gene and orf 214: Pleiotropic effects on photosynthetic reaction center and light-harvesting 1 complexes. J Bact 178: 2334–2342 Woodbury NW and Allen JP (1995) The pathway, kinetics and thermodynamics of electron transfer in wild-type and mutant bacterial reaction centers of purple nonsulfur bacteria. In: Blankenship RE, Madigan MT and Bauer CE (eds) Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 2), pp 527–557. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Woodbury NW, Parson WW, Gunner MR, Prince RC and Dutton PL (1986) Radical-pair energetics and decay mechanisms in reaction centers containing anthraquinones, naphthoquinones or benzoquinones in place of ubiquinone. Biochim Biophys Acta 851: 6–22 Wraight CA (2004) Proton and electron transfer in the acceptor
321 quinone complex of photosynthetic reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Frontiers in Biosciences 9: 309–337 Xu Q and Gunner MR (2000) Temperature dependence of the free energy, enthalpy, and entropy of P+QA– charge recombination in Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26 reaction centers. J Phys Chem B 104: 8035–8043 Yakovlev AG, Jones MR, Potter JA, Fyfe PK, Vasilieva LG, Shkuropatov AYa and Shuvalov VA (2005) Primary charge separation between P* and BA: Electron-transfer pathways in native and mutant GM203L bacterial reaction centers. Chem Phys 319: 297–307 Yanagi K, Shimizu M, Hashimoto H, Gardiner AT, Roszak AW and Cogdell RJ (2005) Local electrostatic field induced by the carotenoid bound to the reaction center of the purple photosynthetic bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Phys Chem B 109: 992–998 Yeates TO, Komiya H, Chirino A, Rees DC, Allen JP and Feher G (1988) Structure of the reaction center from Rhodobactersphaeroides R-26 and 2.4.1-protein-cofactor (bacteriochlorophyll, bacteriopheophytin, and carotenoid) interactions. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 85: 7993–7997 Youvan DC, Ismail S and Bylina EJ (1985) Chromosomal deletion and plasmid complementation of the photosynthetic reaction center and light-harvesting genes from Rhodopseudomonas capsulata. Gene 38: 19–30 Zech SG, Bittl R, Gardiner AT and Lubitz W (1997) Transient and pulsed EPR spectroscopy on the radical pair state P+•865QA–• to study light-induced changes in bacterial reaction centers. App Mag Res 13: 517–529 Zilsel J, Lilburn TG and Beatty JT (1989) Formation of functional inter-species hybrid photosynthetic complexes in Rhodobacter capsulatus. FEBS Letts 253: 247–252
Chapter 17 Structure and Function of the Cytochrome c2:Reaction Center Complex from Rhodobacter sphaeroides Herbert Axelrod Stanford Synchrotron Radiation Laboratory, 2575 Sand Hill Rd., Menlo Park, CA 94025, U.S.A.
Osamu Miyashita Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biophysics, University of Arizona, 1041 East Lowell Street, Tucson, AZ 85721, U.S.A.
Melvin Okamura* Department of Physics, University of California, San Diego, 9500 Gilman Dr., La Jolla, CA 92093-0354, U.S.A.
Summary ............................................................................................................................................................... 323 I. Introduction..................................................................................................................................................... 324 II. History ............................................................................................................................................................ 324 III. Structure of the Cytochrome c2:Reaction Center Complex ............................................................................ 325 IV. Electron Transfer Reactions ........................................................................................................................... 327 V. Effects of Mutation ......................................................................................................................................... 329 A. Effects on Binding, KD ..................................................................................................................... 329 B. Effects on Electron Transfer in the Bound State, ke ........................................................................ 330 C. Effects on the Second Order Rate Constant, k2 .............................................................................. 330 VI. Mechanism of Inter-Protein Electron Transfer................................................................................................ 332 A. First Order Electron Transfer............................................................................................................ 332 B. Second Order Electron Transfer ...................................................................................................... 332 Acknowledgments ................................................................................................................................................. 333 References ............................................................................................................................................................ 333
Summary In purple non-sulfur photosynthetic bacteria, a c-type heme protein, cytochrome (Cyt) c2, serves as the electron donor to the reaction center (RC) which is the site of the initial photochemical electron transfer. The second order rate of electron transfer from Cyt c2 to the RC is diffusion limited and optimized to facilitate electron transfer through the photosynthetic apparatus. This review summarizes the X-ray crystal structure of the Cyt c2:RC complex from Rhodobacter (Rba.) sphaeroides and studies based on the structure that elucidate the molecular basis for the role of the complex in electron transfer. The structure of the complex shows the heme cofactor in van der Waals contact with the reaction center and in close proximity to the bacteriochlorophyll *Author for correspondence, email: [email protected]
C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty (eds): The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria, pp. 323–336. © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V.
324
Herbert Axelrod, Osamu Miyashita and Melvin Okamura
dimer, the primary electron donor. The binding interface region includes: a) a solvent-separated region with long-range electrostatic interactions between complementary charged residues on Cyt c2 and the RC which play a role in protein docking and binding, and b) a small central region with short-range interactions, including hydrophobic, hydrogen bonding, and a cation-π interaction, which play a role in binding the Cyt in close contact to the RC surface to facilitate strong electronic coupling between cofactors for rapid inter-protein electron transfer. Both types of interactions contribute to the binding. However, the two types of interactions have markedly different effects on the electron transfer kinetics. The long-range electrostatic interactions change the second order rate constant by changing the association rate but not the electron transfer rate in the bound state. The short-range interactions do not affect the association rate but change the dissociation rate as well as the electron transfer rate in the bound state. The strength of the binding interactions is optimized to allow sufficiently fast dissociation of the oxidized Cyt c2 that does not limit the rate of cyclic electron transfer. I. Introduction Inter-protein electron transfer plays an important role in the machinery for energy conversion in photosynthesis and respiration. The primary light induced reactions and proton pumping electron transfer processes take place in the reaction center (RC), a membrane protein that is embedded in the photosynthetic membrane. In order for electron transfer to occur rapidly, Cyt c2 a mobile electron transfer protein carries electrons between the RC and other membrane protein components. The electron transfer reactions between the mobile carrier and membrane bound proteins are optimized for rapid association, electron transfer, and dissociation. A crystal structure of the Cyt c2:RC complex from Rhodobacter (Rba.) sphaeroides has been determined (Axelrod et al., 2002). In this review we discuss the interactions between Cyt c2 and the RC, focusing on structural information from the crystal structure of the complex and studies of interactions identified in this structure that elucidate the molecular basis for the inter-protein electron transfer. For more comprehensive discussion of earlier studies see Dutton and Prince (1978) and Tiede and Dutton (1993). For an earlier review of the structure and function of the Cyt c2:RC complex see Axelrod and Okamura (2005). The photosynthetic electron transfer components in membranes of purple bacteria are shown in Fig. 1 (Blankenship, 2002). The initial photochemistry occurs in the RC where light induced electron transfer proceeds from a primary donor, D, a bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) dimer (BChl2), through a series of Abbreviations: BChl – bacteriochlorophyll; BChl2 – bacteriochlorophyll dimer; Blc. – Blastochloris; Cyt c2 – cytochrome c2; Rba. – Rhodobacter; RC – reaction center; Rps. – Rhodopseudomonas; Rsp. – Rhodospirillum; Tch. – Thermochromatium
acceptors, doubly reducing a bound quinone QB. The doubly reduced QB binds two protons and dissociates from the RC molecule and is oxidized by Cyt bc1 complex. The electron transfer cycle is completed by Cyt c2 which shuttles the electron from Cyt bc1 back to the RC. In the process, protons are pumped across the membrane, creating a membrane potential that drives ATP synthesis. In photosynthetic bacteria lacking Cyt c2 other mobile electron carriers replace this Cyt. (Meyer and Donohue, 1995). Other photosynthetic bacteria such as Blastochloris (Blc.) viridis (previously Rhodopseudomonas (Rps.) viridis) and Thermochromatium (Tch.) tepidum contain a RC associated Cyt complex that serves as the electron donor to the RC (Nitschke and Dracheva, 1995). The interactions of mobile electron carriers with RC associated Cyts in Blc. viridis and Tch. tepidum have been discussed (Nogi et al., 2005). II. History The reactions between Cyt c2 and the RC are readily followed by transient optical absorption changes upon illumination and were some of the first biophysical studies of electron transfer in photosynthesis. The oxidation of BChl (Duysens, 1952) and Cyt (Vernon and Kamen, 1953; Duysens, 1954; Chance and Smith, 1955) were observed upon illumination of Rhodospirillum (Rsp.) rubrum membranes. However, the nature of the primary reaction was not fully established until the definitive time resolved measurements of Parson (1968) showed that the fast oxidation of BChl was followed by its reduction in 2 µs with the concomitant oxidation of the bound Cyt in Chromatium vinosum chromatophores. Studies using isolated RCs from Rba. sphaeroides by Ke et al. (1970) using exogenous mammalian Cyt and Prince et al. (1974) using Cyt c2
Chapter 17
Cytochrome c2 Interactions
325
Fig. 1. The photosynthetic electron transfer apparatus in purple bacterial membranes. Modified from Axelrod and Okamura (2005).
showed that the rate of reaction between RC and Cyt varied with Cyt concentration indicating a second order reaction. The second order rate constant was dependent on the ionic strength of the medium indicating an electrostatic interaction between the Cyt and the RC. At low ionic strength, the second order rate constant for the reaction between the RC and Cyt c2 was extremely fast (k2 ~109 s–1 M–1), close to the diffusion limit. At higher concentrations of Cyt c2, Overfield et al. (1979) observed that the oxidation of Cyt c2 was biphasic with fast and slow kinetic phases. The fast (τ ~1 µs) phase was found to be first order (independent of Cyt concentration) and was attributed to the electron transfer from bound Cyt c2. From the Cyt concentration dependence of the fraction of RCs with fast phase kinetics, dissociation constants (KD ≅ 1–10µM) for the Cyt have been determined (Tiede and Dutton, 1993). III. Structure of the Cytochrome c2:Reaction Center Complex The structures of the RC (Allen et al., 1986; Chang et al., 1986; Ermler et al., 1994) and Cyt c2 (Axelrod et al., 1994) from Rba. sphaeroides are known from X-ray crystallography. Experimental approaches involving cross-linking (Rosen et al., 1983; Drepper et al., 1997), chemical modification (Long et al., 1989) and site directed mutation (Caffrey et al., 1992) showed the importance of electrostatic
interactions in positioning of the Cyt on the RC surface. The periplasmic surface of the RC contains a cluster of negatively charged residues surrounding the central region directly over the BChl2. The heme edge of the Cyt c2 is solvent exposed and is surrounded by a positively charged region that can interact with a negatively charged region on the RC. Several proposals for the structure of the complex were made based on electrostatic complementarity between the two proteins as well as the structure of the Blc. viridis RC which contains a bound tetra-heme cytochrome positioned over the BChl2 (Deisenhofer and Michel, 1989). Allen et al. (1987) modeled the Cyt c2 directly above the BChl2 similar to that of the permanently bound Cyt in the RC of Blc. viridis in a position that is optimized for electron transfer. Tiede and Chang (1988) modeled the Cyt c2 tilted slightly to increase electrostatic contacts between the Cyt and RC surface consistent with optical dichroism measurements (Tiede, 1987). Adir et al. (1996) modeled the Cyt c2 off-center on the RC M-subunit side of the periplasmic surface over a cluster of negatively charged residues, based on electrostatic calculations and a low resolution electron density map of the Cyt: RC complex. The definitive model for the complex comes from X-ray crystallography. The structure of the Cyt c2:RC complex from Rba. sphaeroides was determined from co-crystals of Cyt c2 and RC obtained by crystallization of a mixture of the two proteins at low ionic strength. Two structures were obtained at resolutions
326
Herbert Axelrod, Osamu Miyashita and Melvin Okamura
of 3.25 and 2.4 Å, from two crystal forms of the complex (Axelrod et al., 2002). Under these conditions the stoichiometry of the bound Cyt was high (0.9 Cyt/RC). The co-crystals were assayed for activity by micro-spectrophotometry. They displayed electron transfer from Cyt to RC with a transfer time (τ = 0.9 ± 0.1 µs) identical to the value measured for electron transfer between Cyt and RC in solution. Since the electron transfer rate is extremely sensitive to the distance between donor and acceptor, this indicates that the structure in the crystal is very similar to the structure in solution. The overall structure of the complex is shown in Fig. 2A. The cytochrome is positioned in the center
of the periplasmic surface of the RC with the solventexposed heme edge directly over the BChl dimer, in position for fast electron transfer. This position of the heme is similar to that found in the structure of the Blc. viridis RC (Deisenhofer and Michel, 1989). An interesting feature of the structure is the kink in a polypeptide chain of the RC (shown by the arrow in Fig. 2A). This kink is far from the Cyt binding site and is due to lattice contacts with a Cyt c2 molecule bound to an adjacent RC in the crystal. Apparently, the binding of the Cyt c2 onto the RC surface alters the conformation due to packing constraints. Since the electron transfer rates in the crystal and in solution are identical and the rates are exquisitely sensitive
Fig. 2. Structure of the Cyt c2 : RC complex. A) Side view of the complex. The Cyt c2 is bound with heme positioned directly over the BChl2. A small region of close contact is indicated by the circle. A conformational change, indicated by the arrow, is due to crystal packing interactions with an adjacent bound Cyt. B) View of the structure in the region between the cofactors. The heme and BChl are separated by the planar aromatic ring of Tyr L162. The closest distance between the conjugated rings in the cofactors is 14.2 Å as shown by the long arrow. A strong tunneling pathway between the two cofactors is indicated by the short arrows. C) Open book view of the interface between the complexes. The two proteins are separated by rotating around the center line. The central region of shortrange contacts (indicated by the circle) is surrounded by charged residues involved in long-range electrostatic interactions. Interacting residues are color coded (see color plate XX). The contact between the heme of Cyt c2 and the ‘hot spot’ Tyr L162 of the RC is shown by the arrow. Hydrophobic residues Leu M191, Val M192 on the RC interact with Phe C102 on the Cyt. Hydrogen bonds are formed between atoms on the RC and the Cyt. A cation-π interaction is formed between Tyr M295 and Arg C32. Electrostatic interactions occur between negatively charged groups on the RC and positively charged groups on the Cyt. Other groups in van der Waals contact are also shown. Modified from Axelrod et al. ( 2002). See also Color Plate 6, Fig. 9.
Chapter 17
Cytochrome c2 Interactions
to distance, this result indicates that the binding of the Cyt on the RC in the crystal is at a rigidly-fixed, specific site. At the center of the binding region, the two proteins exhibit close van der Waals contacts that are important for binding and electron transfer. The small number of hydrophobic interactions between the Cyt and RC in the region of the heme edge are shown in Fig. 2B. The solvent exposed methyl group of the heme is in van der Waals contact with Tyr L162 on the RC directly above the BChldimer. In addition, there is an interaction between Phe (C102) from the cytochrome with Val M192 and Leu M191. The closest distance between the donor and acceptor molecules, (heme and BChl2) is 8.4 Å. This is the distance between the methyl group on the heme and the methyl group on the BChl which are separated only by the ring of Tyr L162. Neither of these two methyl groups is in conjugation with the aromatic ring of either cofactor but they are ends of covalent extensions of the cofactors that are proposed to be important in a tunneling pathway for electron transfer from the Cyt to the RC (Aquino et al., 1997; Miyashita et al., 2003a). The closest distance between conjugated atoms in the cofactors is 14.2 Å. The electron transfer rates calculated from this structure will be discussed later. The interface region between the Cyt and the RC can be divided into two domains—a central domain having short-range contacts, surrounded by a longrange electrostatic domain of complementary charged residues (Fig. 2C). The short-range interactions include hydrophobic interactions, hydrogen bonding interactions and a novel cation-π interaction. The hydrophobic interactions are between Tyr L162, Leu M191 and Val M192 on the RC and Phe C102 and the heme methyl group on the Cyt c2. Hydrogen bonds are observed between amide residues Gln L258, Asn M187, and Asn M188 on the RC with backbone atoms on the Cyt. A cation-π complex is formed between Tyr M295 on the RC and Arg C32 on the Cyt. The short-range interaction region is tightly packed with a low solvent accessibility. Surrounding this region of close contact is a region of solvent separated charged residues. The negatively charged residues on the RC are around Tyr L162 and are predominantly on the M side of the periplasmic surface. The positively charged residues of the Cyt are located opposite the negatively charged residues in the complex. In the space between charged residues, the protein surfaces are farther apart than in the central region and the residues exhibit a higher solvent acces-
327 sibility. The positively charged residues on the Cyt c2 and negatively charged residues on the RC are further than 4.5 Å apart and do not exhibit ion-paired close contact interactions. Thus, the interactions are due to long-range electrostatic attraction between solvated charged groups. The interactions between residues in both the hydrophobic short-range interaction region and electrostatic long-range interaction region are important for binding as shown by studies of sitedirected mutations. However, mutations of residues having electrostatic interactions have very different effects on electron transfer rates than mutations of residues having hydrophobic interactions. These effects will be discussed below. IV. Electron Transfer Reactions The inter-protein electron transfer between Cyt c2 and RC involves the processes of binding and electron transfer. The simplest scheme for the overall reaction is shown below, K A =1/ K D
⎯⎯ ⎯⎯ ⎯⎯ ⎯ → Cyt 2+: DQ Cyt 2+ + DQ ← ⎯
↓
hν Cyt
2+
hν
+D Q +
–
k on
↓
⎯⎯ ⎯⎯ → Cyt 2+: D + Q – ⎯k⎯ → Cyt 3+ + DQ – ← k e
off
(1) where D represents the donor, Q represents the bound quinone. Before illumination (top line) the RC and Cyt are in equilibrium between a bound state and unbound state with a dissociation constant KD which represents the binding of the reduced Cyt to the RC. After illumination (bottom line) the fraction of RCs in the bound state reacts with first order rate constant ke or dissociates with a dissociation rate koff. The RCs in the unbound state react with unbound Cyt with a rate that is proportional to the Cyt concentration, with a second order constant k2. The value of the second order rate constant k2 depends on the association rate (kon), dissociation rate (koff) and electron transfer rate (ke) (Bendall, 1996). k2 =
kon ke ke + koff
(2)
Two cases with different electron transfer behavior can be delineated. In the diffusion limited case, ke >>
ABSORBANCE CHANGE, $A (865nm)
0.02 0.00
A)
Native RCs (R26) 0.7 M M
0.02
0.00
B) YA (L162)
0.01
0.04
0.3 M M
0.06
0.10
7 MM
0.03
no cyt c
0
2
4
2
Time [ms]
6
8
96 MM
27 MM
0.02
0.1 M M
0.08
0.12
ABSORBANCE CHANGE, $A (865nm)
Herbert Axelrod, Osamu Miyashita and Melvin Okamura
328
no cytc2 0
200
400
TIME (Ms)
600
800
laser flash
Fig. 3. Electron transfer kinetics of the reaction between Cyt c2 and the RC. The oxidation and recovery of the BChl2 is monitored at 865 nm. A) Native RCs (diffusion-limited) – the recovery due to the reaction with Cyt c2 is biphasic. The relative amplitudes of the fast and slow phases and the rate of thes slow phase depend on the Cyt c2 concentration. B) Mutant RCs in which Tyr (L162) is changed to Ala (fast exchange limit). The recovery, due to reaction with Cyt c2, is monophasic. The rate of recovery is dependent on Cyt c2 concentration.
koff , the second order rate constant is the association rate constant, i.e., k2 = kon. The diffusion limit applies to native RCs in which ke = 106 s–1 >> koff = 103 s–1. In this case, electron transfer occurs upon each binding event. In the diffusion limited case the rate limiting step is not the electron transfer rate but is determined by the formation of the bound state. A different behavior occurs when the dissociation rate is faster than the electron transfer rate, the fast exchange limit (i.e., koff >> ke). In this case electron transfer does not occur upon each binding event and depends upon the electron transfer rate and the occupancy of the bound state. In the fast exchange limit, the second order rate constant becomes k2 ≅ ke/KD, and monophasic rather than biphasic kinetics is observed in flash kinetic experiments (i.e., no fast first order rate is observed). The different features of the kinetics for electron transfer following a single saturating laser flash in the diffusion-limited and fast exchange regimes are shown in Fig. 3. For native RCs for which the reaction with Cyt is diffusion-limited, the reduction of the oxidized primary donor monitored at 865 nm is biphasic (Fig. 3A). The fast phase is due to electron transfer from bound Cyt c2. The time constant for this reaction (unresolved in this trace) is τe = 1µs. The slow phase has decays with a rate that is dependent on the Cyt concentration: k = k2 [Cyt]. The relative amplitudes of the fast and slow phases and the rate of the slow phase depend on the cytochrome concentration. For some mutant RCs having changes to hydrophobic residues the reaction rates and binding
affinity lead to reaction dynamics in the fast exchange limit (Fig. 3B). In the fast exchange limit the donor reduction is monophasic and the rate is dependent on the Cyt c2 concentration, reaching a limit at high Cyt concentration (Gong et al., 2003). A critical parameter in the electron transfer process is the dissociation rate koff. Graige (1998) measured the dissociation rate for Cyt c2 from the RC (Rba. sphaeroides) and found koff = 1.7 × 103 s–1 by using two laser flashes in the presence of Cyt c2 where reduction of the oxidized donor after the second flash was limited by the rate of dissociation of oxidized Cyt. Gerencser et al. (1999) found a dissociation rate for horse heart Cyt c from Rba. sphaeroides RC to be koff =103 s–1 and showed that at low ionic strength the dissociation rate of horse heart Cyt became the rate limiting step for turnover at high light intensities. The dissociation rate of electron transfer found in these studies is fast enough not to be rate limiting in photosynthetic membranes under physiological light conditions (Crofts and Wraight, 1983). To a rough approximation the dissociation rate may be estimated from the dissociation constant and the association rate. At low ionic strength this gives a value of approximately koff = kon × KD = 109 × 10–6 = 103 s–1. However, this is a rough estimate since kon is measured for the association of reduced Cyt, and koff is measured for the dissociation of oxidized Cyt and the dissociation and association rates, and thus the binding constant, can depend on the redox state of the Cyt and D. However, several studies indicate that the differences of binding constants and rates between
Chapter 17
Cytochrome c2 Interactions
oxidized and reduced forms are relatively small. In early studies Rosen (1980) measured the KD values for reduced and oxidized Rba. sphaeroides Cyt c2 to the Rba. sphaeroides RC (10 mM Tris pH 8) to be 1.0 and 1.5 µM, respectively. Larson and Wraight (2000) found a preferential binding of oxidized horse Cyt to Rba. sphaeroides RC compared to the reduced form by a factor of 3. However, experiments by Devanathan et al. (2004) on membrane reconstituted RCs using plasmon-waveguide resonance spectroscopy have found larger differences in binding of oxidized and reduced forms. They find two binding sites, a high affinity and low affinity site, and preferential binding of the reduced Cyt to the high affinity site. In some kinetic studies involving Cyt c2 and RCs, a slow first order component (τ~500 µs) was observed in addition to the slow second order phase (Overfield et al., 1979; Moser and Dutton, 1988). This slow phase has been proposed to be due to the transition from a configuration in which the Cyt is bound in an inactive state to an active configuration. However, the presence of the slow first order phase is variable and not observed in all studies. The amount of the slow phase varies with different preparations (Tiede and Dutton, 1993). Two other explanations for the 500 µs phase have been advanced: 1) dissociation of a fraction of oxidized Cyt, and 2) heterogeneity of the RC preparation due to aggregation. Larson and Wraight (2000) reported a problem of double-hits to RCs excited with xenon flash lamps leading to multiphasic kinetics which may explain results from earlier experiments. The longer illumination times result in the excitation of RCs containing oxidized Cyt giving rise to an additional slow phase where donor reduction is rate limited by the dissociation of oxidized Cyt. Tiede (2000) used neutron diffraction and found that different preparations of isolated RCs are in different states of aggregation. The presence of the slow first order phase was found in aggregated RCs but not in monomeric RCs. He suggested that the slow first order phase is due to aggregation of RCs. The presence of aggregation effects agrees with recent studies which indicate that the apparent KD for Cyt c2 binding increases at higher RC concentrations which could be due to an aggregation of RC that blocks Cyt binding (E. Abresch, unpublished). More recent measurements of the dissociation constant and second order rate constant have been routinely performed at low RC concentrations (~0.1 µM) in order to reduce the effect of aggregation (Tetreault et al., 2001; Gong et al., 2003).
329 In summary, the high second order rate of electron transfer, the rapid first order rate of electron transfer, and the relatively low binding affinity (giving a dissociation rate that is not rate limiting for turnover) are well optimized for the function of the electron transfer cycle through the RC. The electron transfer rates and binding will be discussed in more detail below in relation to the structure of the Cyt:RC complex. V. Effects of Mutation A. Effects on Binding, KD Residues in the interface region between the Cyt and the RC were mutated to determine how changing the interactions between the two proteins affects binding. Tetreault et al. (2001) found that mutation of negatively charged acid residues to neutral or positively charged residues on the RC increased KD. The largest change (~1000 fold) was obtained for the mutation of Asp M184 → Lys. Asp M184 is in the center of a cluster of acid residues and close to Tyr L162 in the center of the interface region. Gong et al. (2003) found that mutation of RC hydrophobic residues Tyr L162 and Leu M191 to Ala and other residues increased KD. The largest increase in KD (~100-fold) due to Ala substitution was observed for the mutation of Tyr L162. This residue is located in the center of the short-range interaction domain (see Fig. 2C). This large change in binding shows that Tyr L162 is a ‘hot spot’ for binding. Similar, ‘hot spots’ have been observed in studies of Ala replacement mutagenesis on protein-protein association (Bogan and Thorn, 1998). Interestingly, the mutation of Val M192 to Ala resulted in an increase in binding affinity. The changes in binding affinity due to Ala mutation were found to correlate with the solvent accessibility of the mutated residues. Tyr L162, whose mutation produced a large decrease in binding affinity, was inaccessible to solvent in the Cyt:RC complex, while Val M192 whose mutation resulted in increased binding affinity was solvated in the Cyt:RC complex. These results support the idea that the hydrophobic binding interaction is due to a closely fitting association between protein residues with the exclusion of solvent. The function of the cation-S interaction between Lys C32 and Tyr M295 in the Cyt:RC complex was studied by mutation of both residues (Paddock et al., 2005). The mutation of Tyr M295 to non-aromatic
Herbert Axelrod, Osamu Miyashita and Melvin Okamura
330
A) Electrostatic
8
B) Hydrophobic
6
10
5
7
ke (s )
10
-1
-1
ke (s )
10
10
4
10
6
10
3
3
10
4
10
5
10
6
7
10
10
8
10
-1
KA=1/KD (M )
10
3
10
4
10
5
10
6
10
7
10
-1
KA=1/KD (M )
Fig. 4. Electron transfer rate ke with Cyt c2 in the bound state vs. the association constant KA for different mutant RCs. A) RCs modified by changes to charged residues (Tetreault et al., 2001). B) RCs modified by changes to hydrophobic residues (Gong et al., 2003).
residues had only a relatively small (3-fold ) effect on KD in contrast to theoretical estimates which predict a large binding interaction for the complex (Gallivan and Dougherty, 1999). The small effect on binding due to the mutation probably results from the energy needed for desolvation of the positively charged Arg C32 in order to form the cation-π complex. This desolvation energy reduces the binding energy for formation of the cation-π bond. Mutation of residues forming hydrogen bonds across the Cyt:RC interface resulted in changes in KD (up to six-fold) indicating that hydrogen bonding interactions stabilize the bound state. (Abresch et al., 2006) As with the case of hydrophobic interactions the magnitude of the change in KD was correlated with solvent accessibility. The residues exhibiting the largest changes in KD showed the lowest solvent accessibility in the Cyt:RC complex. B. Effects on Electron Transfer in the Bound State, ke Residues in the interface region were mutated to determine how structural changes affect electron transfer. The changes to ke were different for mutations of charged residues or mutations of residues having short-range inter-protein contacts. Mutation of charged residues changed the binding affinity KA=1/KD but did not change the electron transfer rate, ke, in the bound state (Fig. 4A) (Tetreault et al., 2001; Tetreault et al., 2002). In contrast, the mutation of hydrophobic residues changed both the binding affinity and electron transfer rate (Fig. 4B) (Gong et al., 2003). These results can be understood
in terms of changes in the electronic coupling interaction between donor and acceptor groups, which is responsible for electron transfer. The electronic coupling interaction decreases exponentially with increasing distance between donor and acceptor and depends on the pathway for electron transfer between donor and acceptor. The mutational results indicate that the pathway for electron transfer is through the short-range interaction domain around Tyr L162 in contact with the heme edge (Fig. 2C). The mutations of charged residues change the binding energy, but do not change the structure of the tunneling contact region in the bound state. Thus, ke is not changed by mutation of charged residues. On the other hand, mutations of residues in the short-range interaction region change the short-range contacts between the electron donor (heme) and acceptor (BChl2). Modifications of these contacts change the electronic coupling responsible for electron transfer. Thus, ke is changed by mutations in the short-range interaction region. An interesting feature of the results of mutations is the strong correlation between the changes in binding affinity KA and in the change in electron transfer rate ke. The correlation suggests that there is a relationship between the interactions responsible for electron transfer and the interactions responsible for binding (Gong et al., 2003). C. Effects on the Second Order Rate Constant, k2 The effects of mutations on the second order rate constant k2 for electron transfer between Cyt c2 and the RC were studied to determine the mechanism of
Cytochrome c2 Interactions
Chapter 17
331
10
10
9
10
k2 (s M )
9
1
1
10
1
1
k2 (s M )
A) Electrostatic
8
10
B) Hydrophobic
8
10
7
10 3
10
4
10
5
6
10
7
10
10
8
10
- -11
K =1/K (M ) A
D
3
10
4
5
10
6
10
10
K =1/K A
D
7
10
-1
(M )
Fig. 5. Second order electron transfer rate constant, k2, vs. association constant KA for reaction between Cyt c2 and mutant RCs. A) RCs modified by changes to charged residues (Tetreault et al., 2001). B) RCs modified by changes to hydrophobic residues (Gong et al., 2003). The triangles indicate reactions displaying single exponential (fast exchange) kinetics.
the reaction. Lin et al. (1994) showed that the driving force dependence of k2 is independent of the driving force for electron transfer. This finding indicates that electron transfer is not the rate limiting step for thesecond order rate. Instead, the association process for the formation of the bound state is the rate limiting step expected for a diffusion limited reaction. (i.e., k2 = kon ). The mutation of charged residues on the RC (Tetreault et al., 2001, 2002) and on the Cyt (Caffrey et al., 1992) changed the second order rate constant, indicating the role of electrostatic interactions in the association process. The changes in k2 due to mutations that modify charge were generally smaller than the changes in KD but were correlated (Fig. 5A). The effects of charge changes on k2 can be understood in terms of transition state theory for a chemical reaction. The transition state is the configuration in which the Cyt is in position to form the bound state of the Cyt: RC complex. Electrostatic interactions stabilize the Cyt in the transition state. However, since the distance between the Cyt and the RC is greater in the transition state than in the bound state, the electrostatic effect due to the Coulomb potential energy (which falls as 1/r ) is smaller for the transition state (affecting k2) than for the bound state (affecting KD). The relative changes in k2 and KD can be accounted for if the Cyt in the transition state is about 10 Å farther away from the RC than in the bound state (Tetreault et al., 2001; Miyashita et al., 2003b). The changes in k2 due to mutations of hydrophobic residues (Gong et al., 2003) showed complex behavior (Fig. 5B). Hydrophobic mutations resulting in small
decreases in KA resulted in only small changes in k2 (i.e., the slope is low on the right side of Fig. 5B). These small changes in k2 indicate that kon is almost unaffected by short-range interactions. The hydrophobic mutations change KD by changing koff. Mutations that produced large decreases in KA resulted in large decreases in k2. (i.e., the slope is higher on the left side of Fig. 5B). The onset of the large decreases in k2 was coincident with the appearance of monophasic rather than biphasic kinetics (triangles in Fig. 5B). This change in kinetics indicates a change from the diffusion limit (ke >> koff) to the fast exchange limit ke << koff. The switch from the diffusion limit to the fast exchange limit is caused by two factors; a faster dissociation rate koff resulting from disruption of short-range interactions, and a decrease in the electron transfer rate ke, resulting from disruption of electron transfer pathways. These studies show that short-range hydrophobic interactions are important for the second order rate constant. The hydrophobic interactions bind the Cyt in the active site for a time long enough for electron transfer to occur. This allows the reaction to proceed in the diffusion limited regime. The fact that some hydrophobic mutations change KA but not k2 (i.e., the mutations plotted on the right side of Fig. 5B) is not an indication that hydrophobic interactions are unimportant. These mutations shorten the lifetime in the bound state, but do not reduce the lifetime enough to allow dissociation to occur before electron transfer. The insensitivity of k2 to small changes at the short- range interaction interface is an indication of the robustness in the functional design of the photosynthetic machinery.
Herbert Axelrod, Osamu Miyashita and Melvin Okamura
332
In summary, the long-range electrostatic interactions are important in docking the Cyt on the RC surface. The short-range interactions affect the dissociation rate and the electron transfer rate and help to optimize the two rates so that the second order electron transfer reaction is in the diffusion limited regime. VI. Mechanism of Inter-Protein Electron Transfer A. First Order Electron Transfer The first order electron transfer rate can be calculated based on the X-ray crystal structure of the Cyt:RC complex using theory for electron transfer between fixed sites in a protein. The general form for the rate of electron transfer follows Fermi’s Golden Rule (Devault, 1980) ke =
2 2π T ( FC) DA
(3)
where TDA is the tunneling matrix element coupling the electron donor and acceptor (which is distance dependent) and FC is the Franck-Condon factor (which depends on the free energy difference). Moser and Dutton (1992) use a phenomenological approach, where the distance dependence of the rate is fit with an exponential decay k = koe–βr (β =1.4 Å–1) and the Franck-Condon factor is fit using a function similar to the Marcus equation (Marcus, 1964). Using the measured value of 14.2 Å for the distance between aromatic atoms in heme and BChl gives a value for the electron transfer rate ke = 6 × 105 s–1 close to the observed value of 106 s–1. In this calculation the values of reorganization energy λ = 0.5 eV and free energy difference ∆G = –0.16 eV were used (Lin et al., 1994). Alternatively, electron transfer rates can be calculated including the details of the structure of the protein using the Pathway model of Beratan et al. (1991). Calculation of the electron transfer from Cyt to RC gives a lower electron transfer rate due to the two through-space jumps between heme and Tyr L162 and Tyr L162 and BChl, greatly reducing the electronic coupling between electron donor and acceptor (Aquino et al., 1997; Miyashita et al., 2005). However, recent quantum mechanical studies (Prytkova et al., 2005; Kurlancheek and Cave, 2006)
Fig. 6. Reaction coordinate diagram for the diffusion controlled electron transfer reaction. The Cyt and RC approach to form an electrostatic Encounter Complex followed by passage over the Transition State barrier to the Active Complex in which electron transfer occurs. Mutations to charged residues change the energies of the Active Complex, Transition State and Encounter Complex (dashed line). Modified from Tetrault et al. (2001).
indicate a stronger through-space coupling than in the original Pathway model. Values for the electron transfer rate from Cyt to RC calculated using the modified Pathway model gave a value ke =5 × 106 s–1 close to the experimental results (O. Miyashita, unpublished). In this calculation the Pathway model (Beratan et al., 1991) was used with values for through-space jumps given by Kurlancheek and Cave (2006). The Marcus equation for the Franck-Condon factor and tunneling matrix element estimated by Hopfield (1974) were used. These results indicate that the fast electron transfer rate across the protein boundary can be reasonably accounted for by the structure of the Cyt:RC complex which brings the two proteins in close contact. B. Second Order Electron Transfer The mechanism of inter-protein electron transfer reactions has been discussed in terms of key encounter complex and transition state intermediates. These states are involved in docking and electron transfer, determining the second order reaction rate that is important for rapid delivery of electrons to the RC (Bendall, 1996). These are shown on the reaction coordinate diagram for the reaction between Cyt and RC in Fig. 6. As the RC and Cyt approach each other the free energy increases due to the reduced translational entropy of the complex until the electrostatic interactions between complementary charged groups lower the energy of the two proteins, thus forming a loosely-bound electrostatic encounter complex.
Chapter 17
Cytochrome c2 Interactions
This is followed by passage across the transition state barrier that leads to the active complex within which electron transfer occurs. Computational results on the Cyt:RC complex have provided a detailed picture of the association process (Miyashita et al., 2003b, 2004; Autenrieth et al., 2004). The encounter complex was found to be a diffuse ensemble of configurations in which the Cyt is generally positioned with its positively charged active surface over the negatively charged M-subunit side of the RC surface, with the cytochrome at a solvent-separated distance from the RC surface and the heme edge not oriented (Tiede et al., 1993; Adir et al., 1996; Miyashita et al., 2003b). The transition state, in contrast, was found to have the cytochrome still at a solvent separated distance (~10 Å) but oriented with its heme edge directed toward Tyr L162, the ‘hot spot’ for binding and electron transfer (Miyashita et al., 2003b, 2004). The positioning of the Cyt within proximity of the binding surface of the RC in the transition state is followed by the collapse to the active state which is assumed to have the co-crystal structure. In this process the solvent is excluded from the region between the proteins. The role of water molecules in the binding process has been studied (Autenrieth et al., 2004). Short-range hydrophobic contacts are then established and the heme edge is positioned in Van der Waals contact with Tyr L162 optimized for rapid electron transfer. The short-range hydrophobic and hydrogen bonded contacts do not contribute to the association rate kon as shown by the mutation results presented in Fig. 5B, consistent with the large separation between Cyt and RC at the transition state. However, they serve to hold the Cyt on the RC surface long enough for electron transfer to occur before dissociation (i.e., ke > koff ), thus allowing the reaction to proceed in the diffusion-limited regime. In addition, the binding interactions are weak enough to allow a dissociation rate (koff ~ 103 s–1) fast enough not to be rate limiting in turnover. This mechanism for electron transfer between Cyt and RC explains the highly optimized diffusion-limited rate constant that is important for the rapid turnover. The role of a specific complex between electron transfer partners may vary for different systems. Several stable protein complexes have been studied in which the cofactors are in position for fast electron transfer as in the case for the Cyt:RC complex. These include complexes between cytochrome c and cytochrome c peroxidase (Pelletier and Kraut, 1992) and cytochrome c and cytochrome bc1 (Hunte et al., 2002).
333 On the other hand, in other systems a stable complex between the two proteins has not been observed. For these systems the reactions most likely occur in the fast-exchange regime by a dynamic docking mechanism (Liang et al., 2004). When a permanent bound state is not observed, the electron transfer can occur from transient formation of a specific complex in which rapid electron transfer occurs. In this case the rapid electron transfer (k2 = ke/KD) would be enhanced by close tunneling contacts between donor and acceptor that increase ke to compensate for a large KD. Such a specific complex may explain the reaction between the Cyt c2 and RC from Rsp. rubrum where the kinetics are strictly monophasic (van der Wal et al., 1987). Although there is no direct evidence for complex formation, a computational study of the binding between Cyt c2 and the RC from Rsp. rubrum shows that a complex similar to that found in Rba. sphaeroides can be formed but with lower binding affinity (Pogorelov et al., 2007). Alternatively, electron transfer may occur from an ensemble of states such as in a non-specific electrostatic encounter complex. In this case, the complex between the two proteins may not be very specific or well optimized for electron transfer as suggested in the ‘Velcro model’ of McClendon (1991) and the electron transfer may proceed through longer distances through water. Studies that indicate that long distance electron transfer through water can occur (Lin et al., 2005; Miyashita et al., 2005). The actual electron transfer mechanism for these systems depends upon the relative rates and occupancies at different docking positions. Further studies of the electron transfer are needed to establish the mechanisms that form the molecular basis for these critical biological processes. Acknowledgments We wish to thank the many colleagues who contributed to the work from our group on the cytochrome: RC complex reported here. Special thanks to George Feher, Mark Paddock, Ed Abresch and Charlene Chang for contributions to ongoing research and to José Onuchic for theoretical discussions. Work supported by NIH grant GM 41637. References Abresch EC, Villalobos M, Paddock ML, Chang C and Okamura MY (2006) The importance of buried H-bonds on binding and
334
Herbert Axelrod, Osamu Miyashita and Melvin Okamura
electron transfer in the cytochrome c2:reaction center complex. Biophysical Society Meeting Abstracts, Biophys J, Supplement, 503a, Abstract, 2400 Adir N, Axelrod H, Beroza P, Isaacson R, Rongey S, Okamura M and Feher G (1996) Co-crystallization and characterization of the photosynthetic reaction center-cytochrome c2 complex from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 35: 2535–2547 Allen JP, Feher G, Yeates TO, Rees DC, Deisenhofer J, Michel H and Huber R (1986). Structural homology of reaction centers from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides and Rhodopseudomonas viridis as determined by x-ray diffraction. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 83: 8589–8593 Allen JP, Feher G, Yeates TO, Komiya H and Rees DC (1987) Structure of the reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26: The protein subunits. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 84: 6162–6166 Aquino A, Beroza P, Reagan J and Onuchic J (1997) Estimating the effect of protein dynamics on electron transfer to the special pair in the photosynthetic reaction center. Chem Phys Lett 275: 181–187 Autenrieth F, Tajkhorshid E, Schulten K and Luthey-Schulten Z (2004) Role of water in transient cytochrome c2 docking. J Phys Chem B 108: 20376–20387 Axelrod H and Okamura M (2005) The structure and function of the cytochrome c2:reaction center electron transfer complex from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Photosynth Res 85: 101–114 Axelrod H, Feher G, Allen J, Chirino A, Day M, Hsu B and Rees D (1994) Crystallization and X-ray structure determination of cytochrome c2 from Rhodobacter sphaeroides in three crystal forms. Acta Cryst D: Biol Crystallogr 50: 596–602 Axelrod HL, Abresch EC, Okamura MY, Yeh AP, Rees DC and Feher G (2002) X-ray structure determination of the cytochrome c2:reaction center electron transfer complex from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Mol Biol 319: 501–515 Bendall D (1996) Interprotein electron transfer. In: Bendall D (ed) Protein Electron Transfer, pp 43–68. Bios Scientific Publishers Ltd, Oxford Beratan D, Betts J and Onuchic J (1991) Protein electron transfer rates set by the bridging secondary and tertiary structure. Science 252: 1285–1288 Blankenship RE (2002) Molecular Mechanisms of Photosynthesis. Blackwell Science, London Bogan A and Thorn K (1998) Anatomy of hot spots in protein interfaces. J Mol Biol 280: 1–9 Caffrey MS, Bartsch RG and Cusanovich MA (1992) Study of the cytochrome c2-reaction center interaction by site-directed mutagenesis. J Biol Chem 267: 6317–6321 Chance B and Smith L (1955) Respiratory pigments of Rhodospirillum rubrum. Nature 175: 803–806 Chang C-H, Tiede D, Tang J, Smith U, Norris J and Schiffer M (1986) Structure of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides R-26 reaction center. FEBS Lett 205: 82–86 Crofts AR and Wraight CA (1983) The electrochemical domain of photosynthesis. Biochim Biophys Acta 726: 149–185 Deisenhofer J and Michel H (1989) The photosynthetic reaction center from the purple bacterium Rhodopseudomonas viridis. EMBO J 8: 2149–2170 Devanathan S, Salamon Z, Tollin G, Fitch J, Meyer T and Cusanovich M (2004) Binding of oxidized and reduced cytochrome c2 to photosynthetic reaction centers: Plasmon-waveguide resonance
spectroscopy. Biochemistry 43: 16405–16415 Devault D (1980) Quantum Mechanical Tunneling in Biological Systems. Q Rev Biophys 13: 387–564 Drepper F, Dorlet P and Mathis P (1997) Cross-linked electron transfer complex between cytochrome c2 and the photosynthetic reaction center of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 36: 1418–1427 Dutton PL and Prince RC (1978) Reaction center driven cytochrome interactions. In: Clayton RK and Sistrom WR (eds) The Photosynthetic Bacteria, pp 525–570. Plenum Press, New York Duysens L (1952) Transfer of excitation energy in photosynthesis. Doctoral dissertation. Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands Duysens L (1954) Reversible photo-oxidation of a cytochrome pigment in photosynthesizing Rhodospirillum rubrum. Nature 173: 692–693 Ermler U, Fritsch G, Buchanan S and Michel H (1994) Structure of the photosynthetic reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides at 2.65 Å resolution — Cofactors and protein cofactor interactions. Structure 2: 925–936 Hopfield JJ (1974) Electron transfer between biological molecules by thermally activated tunneling. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 71: 3640–3645 Gallivan JP and Dougherty DA (1999) Cation-π interactions in structural biology. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 96: 9459–9464 Gerencsér L, Laczkó G and Maróti P (1999) Unbinding of oxidized cytochrome c from photosynthetic reaction center of Rhodobacter sphaeroides is the bottleneck of fast turnover. Biochemistry 38: 16866–16875 Gong X, Paddock M and Okamura M (2003) Interactions between cytochrome c2 and photosynthetic reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Changes in binding affinity and electron transfer rate due to mutation of interfacial hydrophobic residues are strongly correlated. Biochemistry 42: 14492–14500 Graige M, Feher G and Okamura M (1998) Conformational gating of the electron transfer reaction QA–.QB → QAQB–. in bacterial reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides determined by a driving force assay. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 95: 11679–11684 Hunte C, Solmaz S and Lange C (2002) Electron transfer between yeast cytochrome bc1 complex and cytochrome c: A structural analysis. Biochim Biophys Acta 1555: 21–28 Ke B, Chaney TH and Reed DW (1970) The electrostatic interaction between the reaction center bacteriochlorophyll derived from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides and mammalian cytochrome c and its effects on light activated electron transport. Biochim Biophys Acta 216: 373–383 Kurlancheek W and Cave RJ (2006) Tunneling through weak interactions: A comparison of through-space, H-bond, and throughbond mediated tunneling. J Phys Chem 110: 14018–14028 Larson J and Wraight C (2000) Preferential binding of equine ferricytochrome c to the bacterial photosynthetic reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 39: 14822–14830 Liang ZX, Kurnikov IV, Nocek JM, Mauk AG, Beratan DN and Hoffman BM (2004) Dynamic docking and electron-transfer between cytochrome b5 and a suite of myoglobin surface-charge mutants. Introduction of a functional-docking algorithm for protein-protein complexes. J Am Chem Soc 126: 2785–2798
Chapter 17
Cytochrome c2 Interactions
Lin J, Balabin I and Beratan D (2005) The nature of aqueous tunneling pathways between electron-transfer proteins. Science 310: 1311–1313 Lin X, Williams JC, Allen J and Mathis P (1994) Relationship between rate and free energy difference for electron transfer from cytochrome c2 to the reaction center in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 33: 13517–13523 Long J, Durham B, Okamura M and Millett F (1989) Role of specific lysine residues in binding cytochrome c2 to the Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction center in optimal orientation for rapid electron transfer. Biochemistry 28: 6970–6974 Marcus RA (1964) Chemical and electrochemical electron transfer theory. Ann Rev Phys Chem 15: 155–196 McLendon G (1991) Control of biological electron transport via molecular recognition and binding: The ‘Velcro’ model. Struct Bond 75: 160–174 Meyer T and Donohue T (1995) Cytochromes, Iron-sulfur, and copper proteins mediating electron transfer from the Cyt bc1 complex to photosynthetic reaction center complexes. In: Blankenship RE, Madigan MT and Bauer CE (eds) Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 2), pp 725–745. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Miyashita O, Okamura MY and Onuchic JN (2003a) Theoretical understanding of the interprotein electron transfer between cytochrome c2 and the photosynthetic reaction center. J Phys Chem B 107: 1230–1241 Miyashita O, Onuchic JN and Okamura MY (2003b) Continuum electrostatic model for the binding of cytochrome c2 to the photosynthetic reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 42: 11651–11660 Miyashita O, Onuchic J and Okamura M (2004) Transition state and encounter complex for fast association of cytochrome c2with bacterial reaction center. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 101: 16174–16179 Miyashita O, Okamura and Onuchic J (2005) Interprotein electron transfer from cytochrome c2 to photosynthetic reaction center: Tunneling across an aqueous interface. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 102: 3558–3563 Moser C and Dutton PL (1988). Cytochrome c and c2 binding dynamics and electron transfer with photosynthetic reaction center protein and other integral membrane redox proteins. Biochemistry 27: 2450–2461 Moser C and Dutton P (1992) Engineering protein structure for electron transfer in photosynthetic reaction centers. Biochim Biophys Acta 1101: 171–176 Nitschke W and Dracheva SM (1995) Reaction center associated cytochromes. In: Blankenship RE, Madigan MT and Bauer CE (eds) Anoxygenic Photosynthetic Bacteria (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration), pp 775–805. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Nogi T, Hirano Y and Miki K (2005) Structural and functional studies on the tetraheme cytochrome subunit and its electron donor proteins: The possible docking mechanisms during the electron transfer reaction. Photosynth Res. 85: 87–99 Overfield RE, Wraight CA and Devault DC (1979) Microsecond photooxidation kinetics of cytochrome c2 from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides: In vivo and solution studies. FEBS Lett. 105: 137–142 Paddock M, Weber K, Chang C and Okamura M (2005) Interac-
335 tions between cytochrome c2 and the photosynthetic reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: The cation-π interaction. Biochemistry 44: 9619–9625 Parson W (1968) The role of P870 in bacterial photosynthesis. Biochim Biophys Acta 153: 248–259 Pelletier H and Kraut J (1992) Crystal structure of a complex between electron transfer partners, cytochrome c peroxidase and cytochrome c. Science 258: 1748–1755 Pogorelov T, Autenrieth F, Roberts E and Luthey-Schulten Z (2007) Cytochrome c2 exit strategy: Dissociation studies and evolutionary implications. J Phys Chem B 111: 618–634 Prince RC, Cogdell RJ and Crofts AR (1974) The photo-oxidation of horse heart cytochrome c and native cytochrome c2 by reaction centres from Rhodopseudomonas spheroides R-26. Biochim Biophys Acta 347: 1–13 Prytkova TR, Kurnikov IV and Beratan DN (2005) Ab initio based calculations of electron-transfer rates in metalloproteins. J Phys Chem B 109: 1618–1625 Rosen D, Okamura MY and G Feher (1980) Interaction of cytochrome c with reaction centers of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides R-26: Determination of number of binding sites and dissociation constants by equilibrium dialysis. Biochemistry 19: 5687–5692 Rosen D, Okamura MY, Abresch EC, Valkirs GE and Feher G (1983) Interaction of cytochrome c with reaction centers of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides R-26: Localization of the binding site by chemical cross-linking and immunochemical studies. Biochemistry 22: 335–341 Tetreault M, Rongey SH, Feher G and Okamura M (2001) Interaction between cytochrome c2 and the photosynthetic reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Effects of charge-modifying mutations on binding and electron transfer. Biochemistry 40: 8452–8462 Tetreault M, Cusanovich M, Meyer T, Axelrod H and Okamura M (2002) Double mutant studies identify electrostatic interactions that are important for docking cytochrome c2 onto the bacterial reaction center. Biochemistry 41: 5807–5815 Tiede D (1987) Cytochrome c orientation in electron transfer complexes with photosynthetic reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides and when bound to the surface of negatively charged membranes: Characterization by optical linear dichroism. Biochemistry 26: 397–410 Tiede DM and Chang CH (1988) The cytochrome-c binding surface of reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Isr J Chem 28: 183–191 Tiede D and Dutton P (1993) Electron transfer between bacterial reaction centers and mobile c-type cytochromes. In: Deisenhofer J and Norris J (eds) The Photosynthetic Reaction Center, Vol 1, pp 258–288. Academic Press, San Diego Tiede D, Vashishta A and Gunner M (1993) Electron-transfer kinetics and electrostatic properties of the Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction center and soluble c-cytochromes. Biochemistry 32: 4515–4531 Tiede DM, Littrell K, Marone PA, Zhang R and Thiyagarajan P (2000) Solution structure of a biological bimolecular electron transfer complex: characterization of the photosynthetic reaction center-cytochrome c2 protein complex by small angle neutron scattering. J Appl Cryst 33: 560–564 van der Wal H, van Grondelle R, Millett F and Knaff D (1987) Oxidation of cytochrome c2 and of cytochrome c by reaction cen-
336
Herbert Axelrod, Osamu Miyashita and Melvin Okamura
ters of Rhodospirillum rubrum and Rhodobacter sphaeroides. The effect of ionic strength and of lysine modification on oxidation rates. Biochim Biophys Acta 893: 490–498 Vernon L and Kamen M (1953) Studies on the metabolism of
photosynthetic bacteria. XV. Photoautoxidation of ferrocytochrome c in extracts of Rhodospirillum rubrum. Arch Biochem Biophys 44: 298–311
Chapter 18 Directed Modification of Reaction Centers from Purple Bacteria JoAnn C. Williams and James P. Allen* Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry and Center for Bioenergy & Photosynthesis, Arizona State University, Tempe AZ 85287-1604, U.S.A.
Summary ................................................................................................................................................................... 1 I. Introduction......................................................................................................................................................... 2 II. Properties of the Cofactors................................................................................................................................. 2 A. Identity, Substitution, and Removal ...................................................................................................... 2 B. Optical Spectra ..................................................................................................................................... 3 C. Oxidation/Reduction Midpoint Potentials ............................................................................................. 4 D. Modeling the Electronic Structure of the Bacteriochlorophyll Dimer .................................................... 6 III. Electron Transfer Concepts................................................................................................................................ 7 A. Energetics ............................................................................................................................................ 7 B. Coupling ............................................................................................................................................... 9 C. Dynamics ............................................................................................................................................. 9 IV. Pathways of Electron Transfer ......................................................................................................................... 10 A. B-side Electron Transfer..................................................................................................................... 10 B. New Electron Transfer Reactions....................................................................................................... 12 V. Conclusions ...................................................................................................................................................... 13 Acknowledgments ................................................................................................................................................... 13 References .............................................................................................................................................................. 13
Summary Reaction centers from purple bacteria form a superb test system for the manipulation of electron transfer parameters. The wealth of cofactors and electron transfer reactions provides opportunities for directed modification of specific properties. In particular, the energies of each cofactor can be selectively changed by mutations of neighboring amino acid residues. The starting point for the initial electron transfer, the bacteriochlorophyll dimer, has proven to be exceptionally malleable, allowing large changes in energetics and rates. Most of the other cofactors can be exchanged or eliminated entirely, permitting considerable alteration of pathways. By orchestrating multiple changes in the reaction center, the light-initiated electron transfer pathway can be directed towards alternate ends, for example down the B branch of cofactors rather than the naturally preferred A branch. Extensive modeling of features of electron transfer such as the energetics, the coupling, and the protein dynamics has been corroborated by observed changes in the characteristics of the reactions after modification of the cofactor properties. For example, the maximum rates for several electron transfer reactions, determined by application of Marcus theory to the rates of reactions in a range of mutants, show a correlation with the
*Author for correspondence, email: [email protected]
C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty (eds): The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria, pp. 337–353. © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V.
338
JoAnn C. Williams and James P. Allen
distance between the cofactors. Other measurements revealing the intimate interaction of the protein and cofactors show that protein motion controls the rate of the initial electron transfer. Thus the reaction center provides a natural and modifiable template for understanding the factors governing electron transfer. I. Introduction What happens when the reaction center is excited by light? The light energy is converted into chemical energy through a series of electron and proton transfer reactions involving the cofactors of the reaction center. These reactions are able to proceed with essentially every light photon producing useful reactions, corresponding to a quantum efficiency of nearly 100%. The balancing act of capturing light energy while not destroying the molecules involved or producing unfavorable side reactions is achieved by fine tuning the properties of the cofactors through interactions with the protein in which they are embedded. The protein can influence several aspects of electron transfer identified by theoretical treatments, including the energetics, the coupling, and the protein dynamics. Although it is difficult to separate the contributions of each of these components, experiments have probed their effects, notably by altering the light-induced reactions in specific ways. This chapter will review the partnership between the cofactors and the protein scaffold as it relates to the parameters of electron transfer models, focusing on examples where changes in the properties have measurable effects on electron transfer. The examples will be primarily of reaction centers from Rhodobacter (Rba.) sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus, the two commonly studied reaction center systems of purple bacteria. II. Properties of the Cofactors A. Identity, Substitution, and Removal The reaction center from Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus is an integral membrane protein complex composed of three proteins: the L, M, and H subunits. The L and M subunits form the core of the protein and are largely composed of five transmembrane helices Abbreviations: BA – bacteriochlorophyll monomer on A branch of cofactors; BB – bacteriochlorophyll monomer on B branch of cofactors; HA – bacteriopheophytin on A branch of cofactors; HB – bacteriopheophytin on B branch of cofactors; P – bacteriochlorophyll dimer; QA – quinone on A branch of cofactors; QB – quinone on B branch of cofactors; Rba. – Rhodobacter
that are structurally related to each other by an approximate two-fold symmetry axis. The H subunit is more peripheral, containing one transmembrane helix and a large cytoplasmic domain. Embedded in the middle of the L and M subunits are ten cofactors, all of which can participate in some manner in energy or electron transfer. The ten cofactors in the reaction center are: two bacteriochlorophyll a molecules that form a dimer (P), two bacteriochlorophyll a monomers (BA and BB), two bacteriopheophytin a molecules (HA and HB), two ubiquinone molecules (QA and QB), a carotenoid molecule, and an iron (Fig. 1). These cofactors are arranged into two branches, identified as the A and B branches, which are related by the same two-fold symmetry as found for the L and M subunits. Although the cofactors are normally expressed with a well-defined composition, some of these cofactors can be substituted by molecules in the same class, for example bacteriochlorophylls for bacteriopheophytins. The monomer bacteriochlorophylls and bacteriopheophytins, the quinones, the carotenoid, and the iron can be biochemically removed and replaced. Mutagenesis can also result in biosynthetic substitutions, primarily by replacement of the amino acid residues coordinating the cofactors. For example, when the ligand to one of the central Mg atoms of P is changed, a bacteriopheophytin is incorporated rather than bacteriochlorophyll in a mutant that has been termed a heterodimer (His L173 to Leu and His M202 to Leu in Rba. sphaeroides, L173 and M200 in Rba. capsulatus) (Bylina and Youvan, 1988; Kirmaier et al., 1988; McDowell et al., 1991; Allen et al., 1996; van Brederode et al., 1999; King et al., 2001). Both halves of the dimer can be individually replaced this way, although the double bacteriopheophytin dimer appears to be unstable. Similarly the binding site for the B-side bacteriochlorophyll monomer is found to contain a bacteriopheophytin when the residue forming its Mg ligand is changed (φ mutant, His M182 to Leu in Rba. sphaeroides), although analogous mutations on the A side do not appear to have the same substitution effect (Katilius et al., 1999, 2004). Conversely, the bacteriopheophytin on the A side can be converted to bacteriochlorophyll by introduction of a residue to act as a ligand (β mutant, Leu M214
Chapter 18
Reaction Center Alteration
Fig. 1. Three-dimensional structure of the cofactors of the reaction center from Rba. sphaeroides R-26. Shown are the bacteriochlorophyll a dimer (P) (shaded dark), the two bacteriochlorophyll a monomers (BA and BB), the two bacteriopheophytin a molecules (HA and HB), the two ubiquinone molecules (QA and QB), and the iron (Fe). Although the carotenoid is present in wild type, it is not present in the R-26 strain. The view is perpendicular to the approximate two-fold symmetry axis that passes from P to Fe in the plane of the paper.
to His in Rba. sphaeroides, M212 in Rba. capsulatus) (Kirmaier et al., 1991). The addition of a histidine near the bacteriopheophytin on the B branch also results in incorporation of a bacteriochlorophyll (Leu L185 to His in Rba. sphaeroides) (Watson et al., 2005). Changing iron ligands results in a loss of metal specificity, and in one case a significant amount of zinc is incorporated (His M266 to Cys in Rba. sphaeroides) (Williams et al., 2007). In addition to altering the cofactor composition, some of the cofactors can be removed or their incorporation can be blocked. Many studies of reaction centers have been performed on a carotenoid-less strain of Rba. sphaeroides, identified as R-26, which shows properties essentially identical to the carotenoid-containing wild type except for the loss of the ability to trap excess energy. The quinones can be taken out by exposing the reaction centers to a detergent treatment, which initially results in a decrease in QB followed by loss of QA. Biosynthetic incorporation of QA can be blocked by substitution of amino acid residues forming the binding pocket,
339 for example by removing the tryptophan in van der Waals contact with QA (M252 in Rba. sphaeroides and M250 in Rba. capsulatus), or adding a tryptophan in place of a smaller residue (Ala M260 to Trp in Rba. sphaeroides) (Breton et al., 2004). Certain mutations near P result in reaction centers that lack a functional P (Val L157 to Arg, His L153 to Glu, Leu, Gln, or Tyr, His L173 to Gly, and His M202 to Gly in Rba. sphaeroides) (Jackson et al., 1997; Moore and Boxer, 1998; Katilius et al., 2004). The loss of HA is one outcome of the large-scale alterations of the DLL mutant, in which the D transmembrane sequence of the M subunit is replaced with the symmetry-related segment of the L subunit (M192 to M217 replaced with L165 to L190 in Rba. capsulatus) (Robles et al., 1990). Similarly, the B-branch bacteriopheophytin is not required for assembly of the reaction center as shown by a mutant with the change of an alanine that is adjacent to HB to tryptophan (M149 in Rba. sphaeroides)(Watson et al., 2005). A loss of bacteriochlorophyll (presumably in the dimer) was also reported to be due to structural and electrostatic changes in a residue located between BB and P (Ile L177 to His in Rba. sphaeroides) (Khatypov et al., 2005). See Chapter 16, Jones, for a summary of the effects of exclusion and replacement of reaction center cofactors. The ability to alter the cofactor composition provides the opportunity to manipulate the electron transfer reactions as discussed below. B. Optical Spectra One of the most accessible properties of the cofactors is the absorption spectrum (Fig. 2). The tetrapyrrole pigments (P, BA, BB, HA, and HB) have absorption peaks in the near-infrared region, the visible region and the UV region, and the quinones have an unresolved band in the visible region. The bacteriopheophytins, monomer bacteriochlorophylls, and dimer bacteriochlorophylls can be distinguished from each other in the near-infrared peaks at 760 nm, 800 nm, and 865 nm, respectively. In the visible region, the 540 nm peak arises from the bacteriopheophytins, and the 590 nm peak is from all four bacteriochlorophylls. The A and B branch pigments of the same type overlap, except at low temperature where the broad peak in the 540 nm region of the spectrum is resolved into two peaks at 533 nm and 546 nm associated with HB and HA, respectively. The contributions of the tetrapyrrole pigments in the Soret region have been delineated, with H contributing primarily on the
340
Fig. 2. Absorption spectrum of reaction centers from wild-type Rba. sphaeroides. The primary contributions of the bacteriochlorophyll dimer (P), bacteriochlorophyll monomers (B), and bacteriopheophytin monomers (H) to each of the absorption bands are identified. The Soret band arises from all the tetrapyrrole cofactors.
blue side and P absorbing on the red side (Wang et al., 2006). The carotenoid has a major but poorly resolved contribution to the absorption near 500 nm, where absorption of the other cofactors is weak, and can transfer excitation energy to the bacteriochlorophylls, performing a light-harvesting function in addition to photoprotection (Lin et al., 2003). The absorption peaks in the near-infrared region are shifted from the solution spectra, notably in the shift of the bacteriochlorophyll bands to longer wavelengths, presumably because of their protein environment. However, specific alteration of the spectrum generally has not been amenable to mutagenesis. Modeling of the excited states has also proven difficult (Dahlbom and Reimers, 2005). However in certain instances, shifts in the spectrum are attributed to changing particular residues. A notable example is the change in the visible region peak of the bacteriopheophytins due to changing a hydrogen bond to the keto group of HA, which established the assignment of these optical bands to the individual bacteriopheophytins (Bylina et al., 1988). However, changing a hydrogen bond is not typically correlated with a shift in the peak of the tetrapyrrole pigments. Another relatively malleable absorption peak is that of the dimer. It can shift up to approximately 15 nm to shorter wavelengths as a result of mutations, mostly mutations in which a hydrogen bond to the acetyl group is changed, precipitating a rotation of this side group. Major changes in the absorption spectra also occur when substitutions
JoAnn C. Williams and James P. Allen of the cofactors are introduced. For example, the nearinfrared absorption peak of the dimer is significantly different in the heterodimer mutant. Likewise, shifts in the both the visible and near-infrared regions of the spectra are observed in mutants with alterations of ligands to the monomer bacteriochlorophylls that result in pigment changes (Katilius et al., 1999, 2004). Thus, the optical spectrum is a sensitive indicator of the effects of certain types of modifications to the reaction center. The absorption bands in the near-infrared region arise from transitions from the ground state to the first excited state and so are markers of the excited state energy, indicating the maximum amount of energy that can be captured. For the primary donor of Rba. sphaeroides, the absorption peak at 865 nm corresponds to an energy difference of 1.4 eV. The properties of the reaction center can also be characterized from measurement of the spontaneous and stimulated emission of the excited state of the dimer, centered near 915 nm. Because the absorption and emission bands change as the cofactors undergo excitation, oxidation, and reduction, transient optical spectroscopy is one of the major techniques utilized to follow the light-induced transfer of electrons in the reaction center. C. Oxidation/Reduction Midpoint Potentials The oxidation/reduction midpoint potentials of the reaction center cofactors are critical properties for their function as electron transfer components. The midpoint potential of the dimer, at approximately 500 mV, is the only one easily measured directly (Fig. 3). The midpoint potentials of the other cofactors can only be inferred. A change in the chemical nature of a cofactor has a direct effect on its midpoint potential. For example, incorporation of a bacteriopheophytin in the heterodimer mutant increases the potential by approximately 130 mV due to the intrinsically higher potential of bacteriopheophytin (Allen et al., 1996). In addition, the energies of the electronic states are sensitive to the environment so protein interactions with the dimer, including hydrogen bonds and electrostatic forces from charged residues, can affect the dimer midpoint potential and be modulated by mutagenesis. The midpoint potentials of other tetrapyrroles in the reaction center can presumably also be changed by similar modifications, although the evidence is based upon alterations of the electron transfer rates rather than direct measurements.
Chapter 18
Reaction Center Alteration
341
Fig. 3. (Left) The near-infrared region of the absorption spectrum showing a systematic decrease in the band associated with the bacteriochlorophyll dimer as the ambient potential is increased. The absorbance of this band is used to determine the fraction of P+ at any given potential compared to the total amount of P. (Right) Fits of the dependence of the fraction of P+ on the ambient potential are used to determine the oxidation-reduction midpoint potential, Em. A shift in the midpoint potential is observed for a number of different mutants (Allen and Williams, 1995).
Whereas some modifications lead to large changes, analysis of various mutations indicates that most result in small (<50 mV) increases in the P/P+ midpoint potential (Spiedel et al., 2002). The predominance of increases in the midpoint potential of P, rather than a mix of increases and decreases, is probably because the midpoint potential is poised by the protein interactions at a minimum value, and perturbations primarily disrupt this poise. The effect of hydrogen bonds to the conjugated carbonyl molecules on the oxidation/reduction midpoint potential of the dimer is well documented (Allen and Williams, 1995, 2006). An additional hydrogen bond raises the potential by 60 to 120 mV while loss of the hydrogen bond present in the wild type decreases the potential by approximately 80 mV (Stocker et al., 1992; Williams et al., 1992; Murchison et al., 1993). Multiple systematic changes in the hydrogen bonding pattern produce a wide range of midpoint potentials (Lin et al., 1994a) and provide the opportunity to investigate the effect of altered energetics on the properties of the reaction center as discussed below. Hydrogen bonds have been introduced to the monomer bacteriochlorophylls, but with little effect on the primary photochemistry (Chen et al., 2004). A water molecule is found in the wild type between P and BA in hydrogen bonding position to the keto carbonyl of BA. This water molecule can be displaced by mutations (at M203 in Rba. sphaeroides), resulting in alteration in the electron transfer characteristics, including a slowing of the primary electron transfer
rates, suggesting that BA is more difficult to reduce, although other factors, such as an increase in the reorganization energy (see below), would also result in a slower rate (Potter et al., 2005; Yakovlev et al., 2005). Hydrogen bonds to bacteriopheophytins are also probably influencing their midpoint potentials. On the A side, a hydrogen bond between the 131 keto of HA and a glutamic acid residue (L104 in Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus) is naturally occurring, and the equivalent situation on the B side can be achieved by mutagenesis (Val M131 to Asp in Rba. capsulatus, M133 in Rba. sphaeroides) (Bylina et al., 1988; Müh et al., 1998; Kirmaier et al., 2002a). The presence of the hydrogen bonds most likely makes the bacteriopheophytins easier to reduce, consistent with the observed changes in electron transfer rates in the mutants. The potential of each cofactor is also shaped by electrostatic interactions with charged and polar amino acid residues. Insertion or removal of ionizable residues at several different locations approximately 10 to 15 Å from P (L135, L155, L164, L170, L247 and M199 in Rba. sphaeroides) leads to a midpoint potential decrease up to 60 mV due to a negative charge and an increase up to 50 mV due to a positive charge (Williams et al., 2001; Johnson and Parson, 2002; Johnson et al., 2002). The effect of the charges on the potential is relatively modest because of screening of the charge-charge interactions by the surrounding protein. The energies of BA and BB can be significantly changed by altering the polarity of residues near
342 these tetrapyrroles, including replacing a conserved tyrosine residue with phenylalanine (M210 in Rba. sphaeroides, M208 in Rba. capsulatus), and changing a conserved phenylalanine to tyrosine (L181 in Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus), as measured by changes in the electron transfer rates (Finkele et al., 1990; Nagarajan et al., 1990; Jia et al., 1993) and Stark spectra (Treynor et al., 2004). Theoretical calculations suggest that electrostatic fields near BA and BB are influenced by the polarity of these residues, and consequently mutations result in energetic shifts for the oxidized states (Alden et al., 1996; Gunner et al., 1996). In general, the sensitivity of the cofactors to specific protein interactions provides a means to test the role of the energies of the charge-separated states in determining the electronic structure of the cofactors and the rates of electron transfer as presented in the subsequent sections. D. Modeling the Electronic Structure of the Bacteriochlorophyll Dimer The close overlap of the two tetrapyrroles in P results in a sharing of the electron orbitals and hence changes in the properties of P compared to bacteriochlorophyll monomers. For example, one effect of the dimerization is a shift in the absorption band to a longer wavelength than is observed for the bacteriochlorophyll monomers. In a simple Hückel molecular orbital model, the two conjugated molecules can be considered to be coupled together, resulting in the electrons being distributed over the two bacteriochlorophylls in molecular orbitals that
JoAnn C. Williams and James P. Allen are split by an energy 2β (Fig. 4). An additional term represents the difference in the energies of the two sides arising from the inhomogeneous nature of the protein surrounding P. When P is oxidized, the higher molecular orbital loses an electron, leaving one unpaired electron. In the Hückel model, the predominant contribution to the higher molecular orbital is from the side with the higher energy (Plato et al., 1992). In the wild-type reaction center, measurement of the unpaired electron spin densities using the magnetic resonance technique called electron nuclear double resonance yields a 2:1 ratio for the spin density on the L side bacteriochlorophyll compared to the M side. The energy difference between the two sides can be manipulated by introduction of hydrogen bonds to P, resulting in systematic changes in the molecular energies and hence the ratio of the spin densities (Fig. 4) (Artz et al., 1997; Müh et al., 2002). In general, a hydrogen bond between the side chain of an amino acid residue and the M side of P stabilizes the energy of that side and increases the energy difference of the molecular orbitals, making the spin ratio more asymmetric. A hydrogen bond to the L side of P stabilizes that side and hence decreases the energy difference for the molecular orbitals and produces a more symmetrical spin distribution. In both cases, the additional hydrogen bond lowers the energy of the highest molecular orbital, which is coupled to the midpoint potential, making P more difficult to oxidize. More extensive modeling involving additional factors, such as the contribution of vibrational states, provides estimates for the positions of bands seen in the infrared region of the optical spectrum (Müh et
Fig. 4. A two-orbital Hückel model of the bacteriochlorophyll dimer. In wild type, the energy splitting of the molecular orbitals of P is determined by the energy difference between the two sides of P and the coupling. Mutations that introduce a hydrogen bond to the M side of P stabilize the energy of the M side bacteriochlorophyll, resulting in a more asymmetrical dimer with a larger energy difference for the molecular orbitals and a larger midpoint potential (Em). Introducing a hydrogen bond to the L side results in a more symmetrical dimer while still increasing Em.
Chapter 18
Reaction Center Alteration
343
al., 2002; Reimers and Hush, 2004; Kanchanawong et al., 2006). In comparison to P in the bacterial reaction center, the electronic structure of the primary electron donor of Photosystem I, P700, is very asymmetrical with a ratio of at least 3:1 in spin density distribution over the two tetrapyrroles (Webber and Lubitz, 2001). Two factors contribute to this asymmetry. The primary donor has a heterodimeric nature as the Bside tetrapyrrole is a chlorophyll a´, which contains an epimeric configuration at the 132 position, rather than a chlorophyll a as found on the A side. Whereas both sides are axially coordinated by histidines, only the chlorophyll a´ has a hydrogen bond (between Thr 739 of the PsaA subunit and the 131 position). The presence of this hydrogen bond likely stabilizes the chlorophyll a´ side of P700 resulting in the chlorophyll a side having a much higher energy and hence a much larger unpaired spin density. Mutation of Thr 739 to Ala results in a 60 mV decrease in the oxidation/reduction potential while a 30 mV decrease is observed for a Val mutation (Witt et al., 2002; Li et al., 2004). Associated with the loss of the hydrogen bond is a small redistribution of the electron spin density from the B side to the A side of P700 as expected based upon the theoretical model. Thus, the understanding developed from the bacterial system appears to be applicable to other photosystems. III. Electron Transfer Concepts According to Marcus theory, the rate, k, of electron transfer between a donor and acceptor can be written in terms of the temperature, T, the effective electronic matrix element, or coupling, V, and energetics according to: k=
⎛ ( ∆G o + λ )2 ⎞ ⎟ 4 λRT ⎠
−⎜ 4π 3 ⎝ 2 V e h2 λRT
(1)
with two contributions to the energetics: the free energy difference between the final and initial states, ∆G°, and the reorganization energy, λ, which represents the rearrangement energy associated with the charge transfer (Marcus and Sutin, 1985). The exponential dependence of the rate on the energy terms is due to the activation energy associated with the process. Electrons can flow over long distances in biological systems because of a careful balance,
mediated by the protein, involving the free energy difference, the reorganization energy and the coupling between distant redox cofactors. The factors that influence the energetics and coupling in protein complexes are considered below. A. Energetics The electron transfer rate has an exponential dependence upon the free energy difference and reorganization energy (Eq. 1). The free energy differences between various states formed during electron transfer steps in wild type range from relatively small values of approximately 200 meV for the initial electron transfer to a value of approximately 500 meV for charge recombination from the primary and secondary quinones. Mutants with altered P/P+ midpoint potentials have corresponding changes in the free energy differences for the electron transfer steps. For example, a higher P/P+ midpoint potential increases the free energy difference between the PQA ground state and the P+QA– state. By measuring the rates for different mutants, the dependence of the electron transfer rates on the free energy difference can be experimentally determined. The dependence of the electron transfer rate typically is shown as the logarithm of the rate versus the free energy difference, yielding a parabolic curve (Fig. 5). The value of the free energy difference at the peak of the curve is equal to the reorganization energy, because for that value the exponential term has a maximal value of one. The rate at the peak of the parabola is proportional to the coupling for the reaction. In principle, the energies of the cofactors, including their charged states, can be established by theoretical calculations based upon the three-dimensional structure of the protein. However, for large pigmentprotein complexes, these efforts remain a challenge due to the large number of interactions and the uncertainties in the atomic positions often found in structural models that are limited by the resolution of the X-ray diffraction data. Electrostatic potentials calculated for the reaction center from Blastochloris viridis show a strong asymmetry in the electrostatic potential for the two branches, with the A branch being substantially more positive than the B branch, significantly favoring electron transfer along the A branch (Gunner et al., 1996). The oxidation/reduction midpoint potential for P680 of Photosystem II is calculated to have a significantly higher potential than P in bacterial reaction centers, in agreement with
344
JoAnn C. Williams and James P. Allen
Fig. 5. (Left) The dependence of the electron transfer rate on the free energy difference for four reactions: the initial P* decay, electron transfer from bound cytochrome c2 to P+, and charge recombinations from the primary and secondary quinones. The lines are fits according to the Marcus relationship (Eq. 1). The data points and fits are from previous publications (Lin et al., 1994b; Allen et al., 1998; Haffa et al., 2002). (Right) The maximum rate from each fit is proportional to the coupling for the reaction and yields a rate that is predicted to be exponentially related to the separation distance between the electron donor and acceptor. For the P* decay, the maximum rate is plotted for transfer to two possible acceptors, BA and HA. The fit shown is from Dutton and coworkers (Noy et al., 2006).
the experimental data (Ishikita et al., 2006). These calculations also suggest that the specific orientation of the 132 ester of bacteriochlorophylls has a strong influence on the potential (Ishikita et al., 2005). Calculations making use of dynamics and alternate values for the dielectric constant result in different values for the potentials but are still in agreement with favorable transfer along the A branch (Parson et al., 1990; Gehlen et al., 1994). Experimentally, the strength of the electrostatic fields can be established using a technique known as electroabsorption or Stark spectroscopy, in which changes in the optical spectrum due to the application of an electric field across a sample are measured. These optical changes can be interpreted in terms of the interactions of the applied electric field with the dipole moments of the cofactors. For the bacterial reaction center, such measurements lead to estimates of a strong field of 106 V/cm near the bacteriochlorophyll dimer (Middendorf et al., 1993). The electrostatic field around P changes by approximately 10% when comparing reaction centers with and without the carotenoid (Yanagi et al., 2005). Because the electron transfer rates are insensitive to the presence or absence of the carotenoid, the electrostatic field is not a major determinant for the directionality along the A branch.
Replacement of one of the coordinating histidine residues of P with leucine produces the heterodimer, while mutants with the histidine replaced with glycine are very similar to wild type in their properties, presumably due to the incorporation of water as a ligand in place of the histidine (M202 in Rba. sphaeroides) (Goldsmith et al., 1996). Likewise, replacement of the histidine coordinating BA with a small amino acid residue (His L153 to Ser or Gly in Rba. sphaeroides, Thr or Ser in Rba. capsulatus, and Cys in Blastochloris viridis) results in mutants with properties that are very similar to those of wild type, while mutation to leucine alters the pigment composition (Bylina et al., 1990; Arlt et al., 1996; Katilius et al., 2004). Thus, these bacteriochlorophylls are tolerant of coordination changes, with the energetics of P and BA being only weakly dependent upon the nature of the coordination. Protein interactions such as hydrogen bonds to the intermediate electron acceptors also influence the energetics of electron transfer. Removal of the hydrogen bond between a glutamic acid residue (L104 in Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus) and the keto group at the 131 position of HA results in a small decrease in the forward electron transfer rate from P* (Bylina et al., 1988), consistent with a decrease in the free energy difference due to a change in the
Chapter 18
Reaction Center Alteration
energy of HA–. In Photosystem I, loss of the hydrogen bond between a tyrosine residue and either of the chlorophyll monomers located in positions analogous to HA and HB (Tyr 696 of the PsaA subunit near the 131 position of ec3A or Tyr 676 of the PsaB subunit near ec3B) alters the electron transfer ratio of the two branches, suggesting that in Photosystem I, the rates are very sensitive to the energetics established by the pigment-protein interactions (Li et al., 2006). B. Coupling In addition to controlling the energies of the cofactors, the protein must provide an environment that establishes a suitable coupling, or formally the effective electronic matrix element, between the cofactors poised in their excited or charged states for the reactions. In theoretical models, coupling can be considered as arising from a pathway from the donor to the acceptor. In these models, the protein is considered to consist of a complex array of bonds as well as close but non-bonding contacts. A theoretical framework has been developed to express the protein as a network of covalent bonds, hydrogen bonds, and through-space jumps along which electron transfer proceeds in many steps (Lin et al., 2005; Gray and Winkler, 2005). Rather than making use of explicit calculations, coupling is more commonly estimated by assuming that the protein environment is relatively homogeneous, with the coupling being primarily dependent upon only the distance between the donor and acceptor (Gray and Winkler, 2005; Noy et al., 2006). In this simplified case, the coupling exponentially decreases with increasing separation (Fig. 5) showing that the maximal electron transfer rates can span a range of nearly 1012 s–1 for cofactors in close contact to a rate of 25 s–1 when the separation is 23 Å. Because of the exponential dependence on distance, electron transfer in biological systems often makes use of a series of steps involving closely positioned cofactors rather than utilizing a single step between more distantly located cofactors. In order to meet the critical demands for efficient electron transfer, careful positioning of the cofactors and fine control of the energies of the cofactors is essential. For this reason, electron transfer in the reaction center from P* to QB involves a series of intermediate acceptors, BA, HA, and QA. In general, the initial steps have very fast electron transfer rates between closely aligned cofactors. The approximate two-fold symmetry for the two branches suggests comparable couplings
345 as has been found by consideration of the relative rates in various mutants (Katilius et al., 2002b). Comparison of the P* to P+HA– and P* to P+HB– rates and free energy differences indicates that the slower rate for the B-branch transfer is not accounted for entirely by the energetics, and so the coupling does have a contribution, although modest (Kirmaier et al., 2001, 2005). The charge recombination reactions illustrate how the maximal rate is primarily determined by the distance. In the wild type, the two quinones have observed recombination rates that differ by a factor of 10, although the two quinones are approximately equidistant from P. However, charge recombination from P+QB– has a significantly larger reorganization energy than that from P+QA–, as evident by the peak of the parabola being at a higher free energy difference, resulting in very comparable maximum rates as predicted by their similar distances to P (Allen et al., 1998). These theoretical models to describe electron transfer within proteins can be expanded to also understand electron transfer between cofactors found in two different proteins (Lin and Beratan, 2005; Lin et al., 2005; Miyashuta et al., 2005). In interprotein transfer, additional factors must be considered, such as the docking of the proteins and the involvement of water molecules at the protein interface. For example, cytochrome c2 is a water-soluble protein that transfers an electron only after binding to the reaction center (Chapter 17, Axelrod et al.). In this case, coupling is established by the ability of interfacial water molecules to form multiple hydrogen bonding pathways that connect the tunneling pathways for each of the proteins (Miyashita et al., 2005). C. Dynamics The conventional Marcus theory (Eq. 1) rests on the assumption that the electronic transition from the initial to the final state is much faster than nuclear motion. Theories have been developed that explicitly account for dynamics (Sumi and Marcus, 1986; Warshel et al., 1989; Gehlen et al., 1994). However, dynamical contributions are rarely used because of difficulties in experimentally measuring the contributions. Although the initial electron transfer has been well characterized, including the free energy dependence for the rate (Haffa et al., 2002), certain aspects of the transfer have been puzzling. The kinetics of the changes in the spectra of the pigments are complex,
346
JoAnn C. Williams and James P. Allen
and the three-fold increase in the electron transfer rate as the temperature decreases from 298 to 4 K is unusual. To determine the contribution of dynamics to the initial rate, this reaction has been analyzed by probing nearby amino acid residues, measured by absorbance changes in tryptophan residues (Wang et al., 2007). These measurements show that the protein dynamics is the limiting factor in the initial electron transfer rate rather than the energetics. In the classical picture of electron transfer, the protein undergoes structural changes only after the electron transfer to the acceptor is complete (Fig. 6). This observed dependence on the dynamics shows that the protein motions occur during the process and control the observed rate by overcoming the activation barriers described in the classical Marcus theory. IV. Pathways of Electron Transfer A. B-side Electron Transfer In wild-type reaction centers, electron transfer proceeds along the A branch with a nearly 100% efficiency. Manipulation of the various factors influencing electron transfer comes in most dramatically in experiments aimed at getting the electron to go the ‘wrong’ way. Mutations that increase B-branch electron transfer have been reviewed by Wakeham and Jones (2005). Achieving a significant amount of transfer along the B branch requires a combination of mutations, such as blocking the A side by mutations that prevent incorporation of QA or HA, altering the energies of the A-side states to make electron transfer less favorable by mutations near BA and HA, and altering the energies of the B side states to make electron transfer more favorable by mutations near BB (Fig. 7). Although reaction centers from Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus have very similar electron transfer rates, the effect of many subtle differences involved in the branching is illustrated by a lower propensity of reaction centers from Rba. sphaeroides for electron transfer along the B branch (Kirmaier et al., 2002b). In early experiments on altering the branching ratios, only electron transfer to HB was observed, but now transfer to QB has been achieved with reasonable efficiency. The difference in the energy levels of the states P+BA– and P+BB– with respect to P* is an important factor in determining the branching ratio. Mutations that only increase the lifetime of P* are insufficient
Fig. 6. Light results in formation of the charge-separated state P+HA– in reaction centers. In the traditional static view of electron transfer, the movement of dipoles from protein side chains and water molecules is considered to be very slow compared to the initial electron transfer rate. In contrast, in the dynamic model of the reaction center, dipoles rearrange in response to the lightinduced formation of P*CT , the excited state of P, which has a charge-transfer character, followed by transfer of the electron. Recent measurements of the dynamics of the reaction center show that these rearrangements play a critical role in determining the rate of the electron transfer process (Wang et al., 2007).
for switching to B-side electron transfer (de Boer et al., 2002). Changing the energetics along the two branches can be accomplished by the introduction of an aspartic acid residue near BA (for Gly M201 in Rba. capsulatus, M203 in Rba. sphaeroides), showing that individual residues can influence the balance between A-side electron transfer, B-side electron transfer, and charge recombination (Heller et al., 1995). Similarly, a lysine residue introduced near BB results in an alteration of the branching ratio (at Ser L178 in Rba. capsulatus) (Kirmaier et al., 1999), as does a combination of mutations that destabilizes P+BA and stabilizes P+BB (at L181 in Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus, and at M210 in Rba. sphaeroides, M208 in Rba. capsulatus) (Kirmaier et al., 2004). The φB mutant, in which BB is replaced with a bacteriopheophytin (because of the His M182 to Leu mutation in Rba. sphaeroides), is observed to form the state P+BB– with a yield of 35%, although no electron transfer to HB is observed, probably because
Chapter 18
Reaction Center Alteration
347
Fig. 7. In wild-type reaction centers, electron transfer occurs almost exclusively along the A branch of cofactors. In reaction centers with a set of four mutations, a significant percentage of electron transfer is observed to occur along the B side. For the YFHV mutant in Rba. capsulatus (Kirmaier et al., 2003), the Phe L181 to Tyr mutation lowers the energy of P+BB– while three changes make electron transfer along the A branch unfavorable: the Tyr M208 to Phe mutation raises the energy of BA–, the Leu M212 to His mutation results in HA being replaced with a bacteriochlorophyll (β), and the Trp M250 to Val mutation prevents the incorporation of QA.
the state P+BB– is lower in energy than P+HB– (Katilius et al., 1999, 2002a,b, 2003). Thus raising the free energy of P+BA– and lowering the free energy of P+BB– has been key in promoting electron transfer down the B side to give P+HB–. Yields of P+HB– of greater than approximately 30% are accomplished by combining mutations near the monomer bacteriochlorophylls with mutants that impede electron transfer along the A branch. A number of these combination mutants incorporate the β mutation, in which HA is replaced by a bacteriochlorophyll, resulting in a substantially higher energy for the P+β – state compared to P+HA– (Kirmaier et al., 2002a, 2003; Kee et al., 2006). An exceptionally high yield of 70% P+HB– was achieved by joining together mutations that alter the energies of BA and BB with changes derived from the DLL mutant, for which electron transfer along the A branch is blocked because of the lack of HA in that mutant (Chuang et al., 2006). On the other hand, relatively small changes in the energies of HA and HB, such as by addition of a hydrogen bond to HB to lower the energy level of
P+HB–, are insufficient to increase the yield of B-side transfer (Kirmaier et al., 2002a). A number of mutants with changes near the bacteriochlorophylls and bacteriopheophytins produce P+HB– but do not have significant electron transfer to QB, attributed to the forward reaction being unable to compete with charge recombination (de Boer et al., 2002). The rate of electron transfer from P+HB– to P+QB– is much slower than the rate from P+HA– to P+QA–, and so competes less well with charge recombination (Kirmaier et al., 2003; Kee et al., 2006). Several factors could influence the difference in the two rates (Kirmaier et al., 2003; Paddock et al., 2005). For example, the much larger reorganization energy associated with formation of QB– compared to QA–, as discussed above, would favor a much faster rate for QA– formation. Also contributing could be the free energy differences for the bacteriopheophytin to quinone electron transfer on the two sides being slightly different. Although the bacteriopheophytin to quinone separation distances for the two sides are comparable, differences in the coupling are suggested
348 by distinct interactions of the quinones with nearby aromatic amino acid residues (Trp M252 in Rba. sphaeroides and M250 in Rba. capsulatus near QA and Phe L216 near QB). Electron transfer can get all the way to QB via Bbranch electron transfer if the A branch is blocked (Laible et al., 2003). Removal of QA also allows one to observe spectra of QB generated only by B-side transfer (de Boer et al., 2002; Breton et al., 2004; Paddock et al., 2005, 2006). The yield of QB– when the A branch is blocked depends on what other mutations are present (Wakeham et al., 2003, 2004; Frolov et al., 2005). Mutations near QB that decrease the polarity (Glu L212 to Ala and Asp L213 to Ala in Rba. sphaeroides) increase the yield of QB– by B-branch electron transfer, postulated to be either by changing the rate through altering the oxidation-reduction potential and therefore the driving force or altering the reorganization energy (Wakeham et al., 2003). Although coupling has been modeled extensively, its effects on establishing the branching of electron transfer are somewhat difficult to measure experimentally, as it is not clear how to rationally change the spatial orbital overlaps. However, the heterodimer mutations afford a way to change the electron density distribution, which is also involved in the coupling. Mutants constructed by Kirmaier and coworkers (2005) to assess the coupling involve combining either the A or B side heterodimers and the β mutation that replaces HA with a bacteriochlorophyll. This combination of mutations has the effect of making the states P+BA– and P+HB– approximately equal in energy (thus equalizing the free energy contribution) while raising the monomer states such that the mechanism (superexchange) of the initial electron transfer should be the same on both branches. Although the yield of B-side transfer is low in both cases, it is approximately four-fold less for the mutant with the A-side heterodimer. Because the energies for the heterodimer mutants with the bacteriochlorophyll on either side are assumed to be comparable, the difference in yields is attributed to a small but real difference in coupling of the dimer to HA and HB. This coupling difference should contribute to the A-side preference for electron transfer found in other mutants and wild type. The pathway of electron transfer also appears to be dependent on the wavelength of the excitation energy. Blue light excitation into the Soret band gives rise to a transient BB+HB– state, which decays in picoseconds at room temperature but is longer lived at low temperature (Lin et al., 2001; Haffa et al.,
JoAnn C. Williams and James P. Allen 2003). Although energy transfer is fast, alternate photochemistry upon differing excitation wavelengths shows that energy transfer and electronic relaxation do not always precede electron transfer (Wang et al., 2006). These surrogate conduits for the dissipation of excitation energy suggest that the function of the B branch remains to rapidly quench higher excited states (Lin et al., 2001). Thus the B branch is poised to form charge-separated states but not to result in a terminal electron transfer as the A side is. This is consistent with the location of the carotenoid, also thought to be involved in photoprotection (Lin et al., 2003), on the B branch. The pathway of electron transfer, in addition to being dependent on wavelength, can also be dependent upon electrostatic interactions involving a cofactor and a nearby charged amino acid residue. Introduction of protonatable residues (His L168 to Glu and Asn L170 to Asp in Rba. sphaeroides) results in a pH dependence for the states generated by light excitation (Haffa et al., 2004). Because the charges on the ionizable residues depend on their protonation state, and the protonation state is pH dependent, the pathway then becomes pH dependent, demonstrating an ability to switch the pathway by adjustment of the pH. In summary, the highly efficient transfer of electrons along the A branch in wild type can be manipulated by mutagenesis to generate charge-separated states involving the B-branch cofactors. Overall, electron transfer to HB is largely limited by the unfavorable energy of BB and its limited coupling to P*. Electron transfer to QB can be observed but only when the normal electron transfer pathway along the A branch is blocked. The yield of electron transfer to QB is influenced by several factors, but most likely is limited by the rate being slow due to a high reorganization energy associated with formation of QB–. B. New Electron Transfer Reactions Whereas most of the emphasis concerning electron transfer in reaction centers has been on elucidating the factors that control the rates and the asymmetry of electron transfer, other manipulations have introduced new pathways into the reaction center (see also Chapter 16, Jones). The focus in these experiments has been on exploiting the environment near P so as to introduce novel secondary donors. In Rba. sphaeroides, P is normally reduced by a water-soluble cytochrome c2 (see Chapter 17, Axelrod et al.). In the absence of the cytochrome, P remains oxidized for
Chapter 18
Reaction Center Alteration
approximately 1 s until charge recombination from QB– occurs. By comparison, after light excitation and charge separation, the oxidized primary electron donor of Photosystem II is rapidly reduced by a redox active tyrosine (Tyr 161 of the D1 subunit), which is usually identified as YZ. The electron transfer continues with YZ+ being reduced by the Mn cluster where the four equivalents are stored until oxygen is evolved. Because of the relatively low midpoint potential of 500 mV for P, the bacterial reaction centers are normally not capable of oxidizing tyrosine or manganese. However, after hydrogen bonds are added to the dimer, P becomes highly oxidizing and is capable of oxidizing tyrosine residues, including a tyrosine introduced at a location analogous to that of YZ (Kálmán et al., 1999, 2003a,b; Narváez et al., 2002, 2004). Likewise, the modified reaction centers are capable of oxidizing manganese, which can be bound after amino acid residues acting as ligands are introduced (Fig. 8) (Thielges et al., 2005; Kálmán et al., 2005). These results demonstrate that new electron transfer pathways can be introduced, and such approaches can be used to delineate the complex evolutionary process by which anoxygenic photosynthetic complexes evolved into oxygenic complexes.
349
Fig. 8. Comparison of the three-dimensional structures of the Mn binding mutant (Thielges et al., 2005) and Photosystem II shows many similar features. In both cases, three critical amino acid residues are present, a carboxylate (M173 and D1-170), a tyrosine (M164 and YZ), and a histidine (M193 and D1-190). In addition, both complexes have a bound redox active Mn (a mononuclear and a Mn4 cluster for the mutant and Photosystem II respectively; Mn atoms shown as small spheres) that can serve as a rapid secondary electron donor to the oxidized primary donor.
V. Conclusions When a reaction center is excited by light, the interplay between the cofactors and the surrounding protein determines the route of electron transfer. The remarkable robustness of the reaction center to both biochemical manipulation and mutagenesis provides the opportunity to probe the features that influence electron transfer. The standard route down the A branch is observed to have the characteristics of energetics, coupling and dynamics that make it a durable electron transfer pathway. However multiple perturbation of the system makes possible other opportunistic reactions. Acknowledgments Our work is supported by the National Science Foundation, grant MCB0640002. We thank Aileen Taguchi for Fig. 6.
References Alden RG, Parson WW, Chu ZT and Warshel A (1996) Orientation of the OH dipole of tyrosine (M)210 and its effect on electrostatic energies in photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers. J Phys Chem 100: 16761–16770 Allen JP and Williams JC (1995) Relationship between the oxidation potential of the bacteriochlorophyll dimer and electron transfer in photosynthetic reaction centers. J Bioenerg Biomembr 27: 275–283 Allen JP and Williams JC (2006) The influence of protein interactions on the properties of the bacteriochlorophyll dimer in reaction centers. In: Grimm B, Porra RJ, Rüdiger W and Scheer H (eds) Chlorophylls and Bacteriochlorophylls: Biochemistry, Biophysics, Functions and Applications (Advances in Photosynthesis and Respiration, Vol 25), pp 283–295. Springer, Dordrecht Allen JP, Artz K, Lin X, Williams JC, Ivancich A, Albouy D, Mattioli TA, Fetsch A, Kuhn M and Lubitz W (1996) Effects of hydrogen bonding to a bacteriochlorophyll-bacteriopheophytin dimer in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 35: 6612–6619 Allen JP, Williams JC, Graige MS, Paddock ML, Labahn A, Feher G and Okamura MY (1998) Free energy dependence of the direct charge recombination from the primary and secondary
350 quinones in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Photosynth Res 55: 227–233 Arlt T, Dohse B, Schmidt S, Wachtveitl J, Laussermair E, Zinth W and Oesterhelt D (1996) Electron transfer dynamics of Rhodopseudomonas viridis reaction centers with a modified binding site for the accessory bacteriochlorophyll. Biochemistry 35: 9235–9244 Artz K, Williams JC, Allen JP, Lendzian F, Rautter J and Lubitz W (1997) Relationship between the oxidation potential and electron spin density of the primary electron donor in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 94: 13582–13587 Breton J, Wakeham MC, Fyfe PK, Jones MR and Nabedryk E (2004) Characterization of the bonding interactions of QB upon photoreduction via A-branch or B-branch electron transfer in mutant reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochim Biophys Acta 1656: 127–138 Bylina EJ and Youvan DC (1988) Directed mutations affecting spectroscopic and electron transfer properties of the primary donor in the photosynthetic reaction center. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 85: 7226–7230 Bylina EJ, Kirmaier C, McDowell L, Holten D and Youvan DC (1988) Influence of an amino-acid residue on the optical properties and electron transfer dynamics of a photosynthetic reaction centre complex. Nature 336: 182–184 Bylina EJ, Kolaczkowski SV, Norris JR and Youvan DC (1990) EPR characterization of genetically modified reaction centers of Rhodobacter capsulatus. Biochemistry 29: 6203–6210 Chen L, Holten D, Bocian DF and Kirmaier C (2004) Effects of hydrogen bonding and structure of the accessory bacteriochlorophylls on charge separation in Rb. capsulatus reaction centers. J Phys Chem B 108: 10457–10464 Chuang JI, Boxer SG, Holten D and Kirmaier C (2006) High yield of M-side electron transfer in mutants of Rhodobacter capsulatus reaction centers lacking the L-side bacteriopheophytin. Biochemistry 45: 3845–3851 Dahlbom MG and Reimers JR (2005) Successes and failures of time-dependent density functional theory for the low-lying excited states of chlorophylls. Mol Phys 103: 1057–1065 de Boer AL, Neerken S, de Wijn R, Permentier HP, Gast P, Vijgenboom E and Hoff AJ (2002) B-branch electron transfer in reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides assessed with site-directed mutagenesis. Photosynth Res 71: 221–239 Finkele U, Lauterwasser C, Zinth W, Gray KA and Oesterhelt D (1990) Role of tyrosine M210 in the initial charge separation of reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 29: 8517–8521 Frolov D, Wakeham MC, Andrizhiyevskaya EG, Jones MR and van Grondelle R (2005) Investigation of B-branch electron transfer by femtosecond time resolved spectroscopy in a Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centre that lacks the QA ubiquinone. Biochim Biophys Acta 1707: 189–198 Gehlen JN, Marchi M and Chandler D (1994) Dynamics affecting the primary charge transfer in photosynthesis. Science 263: 499–502 Goldsmith JO, King B and Boxer SG (1996) Mg coordination by amino acid side chains is not required for assembly and function of the special pair in bacterial photosynthetic reaction centers. Biochemistry 35: 2421–2428 Gray HB and Winkler JR (2005) Long-range electron transfer. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 102: 3534–3539
JoAnn C. Williams and James P. Allen Gunner MR, Nicholls A and Honig B (1996) Electrostatic potentials in Rhodopseudomonas viridis reaction centers: Implications for the driving force and directionality of electron transfer. J Phys Chem 100: 4277–4291 Haffa ALM, Lin S, Katilius E, Williams JC, Taguchi AKW, Allen JP and Woodbury NW (2002) The dependence of the initial electron-transfer rate on driving force in Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centers. J Phys Chem 106: 7376–7384 Haffa ALM, Lin S, Williams JC, Taguchi AKW, Allen JP and Woodbury NW (2003) High yield of long-lived B-side charge separation at room temperature in mutant bacterial reaction centers. J Phys Chem B 107: 12503–12510 Haffa ALM, Lin S, Williams JC, Bowen BP, Taguchi AKW, Allen JP and Woodbury NW (2004) Controlling the pathway of photosynthetic charge separation in bacterial reaction centers. J Phys Chem B 108: 4–7 Heller BA, Holten D and Kirmaier C (1995) Control of electron transfer between the L- and M-sides of photosynthetic reaction centers. Science 269: 940–945 Ishikita H, Loll B, Biesiadka J, Galstyan A, Saenger W and Knapp EW (2005) Tuning electron transfer by ester-group of chlorophylls in bacterial photosynthetic reaction center. FEBS Lett 579: 712–716 Ishikita H, Saenger W, Loll B, Biesiadka J and Knapp EW (2006) Energetics of a possible proton exit pathway for water oxidation in Photosystem II. Biochemistry 45: 2063–2071 Jackson JA, Lin S, Taguchi AKW, Williams JC, Allen JP and Woodbury NW (1997) Energy transfer in Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centers with the initial electron donor oxidized or missing. J Phys Chem B 101: 5747–5754 Jia Y, DiMagno TJ, Chan CK, Wang Z, Du M, Hanson DK, Schiffer M, Norris JR, Fleming GR and Popov MS (1993) Primary charge separation in mutant reaction centers of Rhodobacter capsulatus. J Phys Chem 97: 13180–13191 Johnson ET and Parson WW (2002) Electrostatic interactions in an integral membrane protein. Biochemistry 41: 6483–6494 Johnson ET, Müh F, Nabedryk E, Williams JC, Allen JP, Lubitz W, Breton J and Parson WW (2002) Electronic and vibronic coupling of the special pair of bacteriochlorophylls in photosynthetic reaction centers from wild-type and mutant strains of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Phys Chem B 106: 11859–11869 Kálmán L, LoBrutto R, Allen JP and Williams JC (1999) Modified reaction centres oxidize tyrosine in reactions that mirror Photosystem II. Nature 402: 696–699 Kálmán L, Williams JC and Allen JP (2003a) Proton release upon oxidation of tyrosine in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. FEBS Lett 545: 193–198 Kálmán L, LoBrutto R, Narváez AJ, Williams JC and Allen JP (2003b) Correlation of proton release and electrochromic shifts of the optical spectrum due to oxidation of tyrosine in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 42: 13280–13286 Kálmán L, Thielges MC, Williams JC and Allen JP (2005) Proton release due to manganese binding and oxidation in modified bacterial reaction centers. Biochemistry 44: 13266–13273 Kanchanawong P, Dahlbom MG, Treynor TP, Reimers JR, Hush NS and Boxer SG (2006) Charge delocalization in the specialpair radical cation of mutant reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides from Stark spectra and nonadiabatic spectral simulations. J Phys Chem B 110: 18688–18702 Katilius E, Turanchik T, Lin S, Taguchi AKW and Woodbury NW
Chapter 18
Reaction Center Alteration
(1999) B-side electron transfer in a Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction center mutant in which the B-side monomer bacteriochlorophyll is replaced with bacteriopheophytin. J Phys Chem B 103: 7386–7389 Katilius E, Katiliene Z, Lin S, Taguchi AKW and Woodbury NW (2002a) B side electron transfer in a Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction center mutant in which the B side monomer bacteriochlorophyll is replaced with bacteriopheophytin: Low-temperature study and energetics of charge-separated states. J Phys Chem B 106: 1471–1475 Katilius E, Katiliene Z, Lin S, Taguchi AKW and Woodbury NW (2002b) B-side electron transfer in the HE(M182) reaction center mutant from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Phys Chem B 106: 12344–12350 Katilius E, Babendure JL, Katiliene Z, Lin S, Taguchi AKW and Woodbury NW (2003) Manipulations of the B-side chargeseparated states’ energetics in the Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction center. J Phys Chem B 107: 12029–12034 Katilius E, Babendure JL, Lin S and Woodbury NW (2004) Electron transfer dynamics in Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction center mutants with a modified ligand for the monomer bacteriochlorophyll on the active side. Photosynth Res 81: 165–180 Kee HL, Laible PD, Bautista JA, Hanson DK, Holten D and Kirmaier C (2006) Determination of the rate and yield of B-side quinone reduction in Rhodobacter capsulatus reaction centers. Biochemistry 45: 7314–7322 Khatypov RA, Vasilieva LG, Fufina TY, Bolgarina TI and Shuvalov VA (2005) Substitution of isoleucine L177 by histidine affects the pigment composition and properties of the reaction center of the purple bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry (Moscow) 70: 1527–1533 King BA, de Winter A, McAnaney TB and Boxer SG (2001) Excited state energy transfer pathways in photosynthetic reaction centers. 4. Asymmetric energy transfer in the heterodimer mutant. J Phys Chem B 105: 1856–1862 Kirmaier C, Holten, D, Bylina EJ and Youvan DC (1988) Electron transfer in a genetically modified bacterial reaction center containing a heterodimer. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 85: 7562–7566 Kirmaier C, Gaul D, DeBey R, Holten D and Schenck CC (1991) Charge separation in a reaction center incorporating bacteriochlorophyll for photoactive bacteriopheophytin. Science 251: 922–927 Kirmaier C, Weems D and Holten D (1999) M-side electron transfer in reaction center mutants with a lysine near the nonphotoactive bacteriochlorophyll. Biochemistry 38: 11516–11530 Kirmaier C, He C and Holten D (2001) Manipulating the direction of electron transfer in the bacterial reaction center by swapping Phe for Tyr near BChlM (L181) and Tyr for Phe near BChlL (M208). Biochemistry 40: 12132–12139 Kirmaier C, Cua A, He C, Holten D and Bocian DF (2002a) Probing the M-branch electron transfer and cofactor environment in the bacterial photosynthetic reaction center by addition of a hydrogen bond to the M-side bacteriopheophytin. J Phys Chem B 106: 495–503 Kirmaier C, Laible PD, Czarnecki K, Hata AN, Hanson DK, Bocian DF and Holten D (2002b) Comparison of M-side electron transfer in Rb. sphaeroides and Rb. capsulatus reaction centers. J Phys Chem B 106: 1799–1808 Kirmaier C, Laible PD, Hanson DK and Holten D (2003) B-side
351 charge separation in bacterial photosynthetic reaction centers: nanosecond time scale electron transfer from HB– to QB. Biochemistry 42: 2016–2024 Kirmaier C, Laible PD, Hanson DK and Holten D (2004) B-side electron transfer to form P+HB– in reaction centers from the F(L181)Y/Y(M208)F mutant of Rhodobacter capsulatus. J Phys Chem B 108: 11827–11832 Kirmaier C, Bautista JA, Laible PD, Hanson DK and Holten D (2005) Probing the contribution of electronic coupling to the directionality of electron transfer in photosynthetic reaction centers. J Phys Chem B 109: 24160–24172 Laible PD, Kirmaier C, Udawatte CSM, Hofman SJ, Holten D and Hanson DK (2003) Quinone reduction via secondary Bbranch electron transfer in mutant bacterial reaction centers. Biochemistry 42: 1718–1730 Li Y, Lucas MG, Konovalova T, Abbott B, MacMillan F, Petrenko A, Sivakumar V, Wang R, Hastings G, Gu F, van Tol J, Brunel LC, Timkovich R, Rappaport F and Redding K (2004) Mutation of the putative hydrogen-bond donor to P700 of Photosystem I. Biochemistry 43: 12634–12647 Li Y, van der Est A, Lucas MG, Ramesh VM, Gu F, Petrenko A, Lin S, Webber AN, Rappaport F and Redding K (2006) Directing electron transfer within Photosystem I by breaking H-bonds in the cofactor branches. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 103: 2144–2149 Lin J and Beratan DN (2005) Simulation of electron transfer between cytochrome c2 and the bacterial photosynthetic reaction center: Brownian dynamics analysis of the native proteins and double mutants. J Phys Chem B 109: 7529–7534 Lin J, Balabin IA and Beratan DN (2005) The nature of aqueous tunneling pathways between electron-transfer proteins. Science 310: 1311–1313 Lin S, Katilius E, Haffa ALM, Taguchi AKW and Woodbury NW (2001) Blue light drives B-side electron transfer in bacterial photosynthetic reaction centers. Biochemistry 40: 13767–13773 Lin S, Katilius E, Taguchi AKW and Woodbury NW (2003) Excitation energy transfer from carotenoid to bacteriochlorophyll in the photosynthetic purple bacterial reaction center of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Phys Chem B 107: 14103–14108 Lin X, Murchison HA, Nagarajan V, Parson WW, Allen JP and Williams JC (1994a) Specific alteration of the oxidation potential of the electron donor in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 91: 10265–10269 Lin X, Williams JC, Allen JP and Mathis P (1994b) Relationship between rate and free energy difference for electron transfer from cytochrome c2 to the reaction center in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 33: 13517–13523 Marcus RA and Sutin N (1985) Electron transfers in chemistry and biology. Biochim Biophys Acta 811: 265–322 McDowell LM, Gaul D, Kirmaier C, Holten D and Schenck CC (1991) Investigation into the source of electron transfer asymmetry in bacterial reaction centers. Biochemistry 30: 8315–8322 Middendorf TR, Mazzola LT, Lao K, Steffen MA and Boxer SG (1993) Stark effect (electroabsorption) spectroscopy of photosynthetic reaction centers at 1.5 K: Evidence that the special pair has a large excited-state polarizability. Biochim Biophys Acta 1143: 223–234 Miyashita O, Okamura MY and Onuchic JN (2005) Interprotein electron transfer from cytochrome c2 to photosynthetic reaction
352 center: Tunneling across an aqueous interface. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 102: 3558–3563 Moore LJ and Boxer SG (1998) Inter-chromophore interactions in pigment-modified and dimer-less bacterial photosynthetic reaction centers. Photosynth Res 55: 173–180 Müh F, Williams, JC, Allen JP and Lubitz W (1998) A conformational change of the photoactive bacteriopheophytin in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 37: 13066–13074 Müh F, Lendzian F, Roy M, Williams JC, Allen JP and Lubitz W (2002) Pigment-protein interactions in bacterial reaction centers and their influence on oxidation potential and spin density distribution of the primary donor. J Phys Chem B 106: 3226–3236 Murchison HA, Alden RG, Allen JP, Peloquin JM, Taguchi AKW, Woodbury NW and Williams JC (1993) Mutations designed to modify the environment of the primary electron donor of the reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Phenylalanine to leucine at L167 and histidine to phenylalanine at L168. Biochemistry 32: 3498–3505 Nagarajan V, Parson WW, Gaul D and Schenck C (1990) Effect of specific mutations of tyrosine-(M)210 on the primary photosynthetic electron-transfer process in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 87: 7888–7892 Narváez AJ, Kálmán L, LoBrutto R, Allen JP and Williams JC (2002) Influence of the protein environment on the properties of a tyrosyl radical in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 41: 15253–15258 Narváez AJ, LoBrutto R, Allen JP and Williams JC (2004) Trapped tyrosyl radical populations in modified reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 43: 14379–14384 Noy D, Moser CC and Dutton PL (2006) Design and engineering of photosynthetic light-harvesting and electron transfer using length, time, and energy scales. Biochim Biophys Acta 1757: 90–105 Paddock ML, Chang C, Xu Q, Abresch EC, Axelrod HL, Feher G and Okamura MY (2005) Quinone (QB) reduction by B-branch electron transfer in mutant bacterial reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: quantum efficiency and X-ray structure. Biochemistry 44: 6920–6928 Paddock ML, Flores M, Isaacson R, Chang C, Abresch EC, Selvaduray P and Okamura MY (2006) Trapped conformational states of semiquinone (D+•QB–•) formed by B-branch electron transfer at low temperature in Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centers. Biochemistry 45: 14032–14042 Parson WW, Chu ZT and Warshel A (1990) Electrostatic control of charge separation in bacterial photosynthesis. Biochim Biophys Acta 1017: 251–272 Plato M, Lendzian F, Lubitz W and Möbius K (1992) Molecular orbital study of electronic asymmetry in primary donors of bacterial reaction centers. In: Breton J and Verméglio A (eds) The Photosynthetic Bacterial Reaction Center II: Structure, Spectroscopy, and Dynamics, pp 109–118. Plenum, New York Potter JA, Fyfe PK, Frolov D, Wakeham MC, van Grondelle R, Robert B and Jones MR (2005) Strong effects of an individual water molecule on the rate of light-driven charge separation in the Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction center. J Biol Chem 280: 27155–27164 Reimers JR and Hush NS (2004) A unified description of the electrochemical, charge distribution, and spectroscopic properties of the special-pair radical cation in bacterial photosynthesis.
JoAnn C. Williams and James P. Allen J Am Chem Soc 126: 4132–4144 Robles SJ, Breton J and Youvan DC (1990) Partial symmetrization of the photosynthetic reaction center. Science 248: 1402–1405 Spiedel D, Jones MR and Robert B (2002) Tuning of the redox potential of the primary electron donor in reaction centres of purple bacteria: Effects of amino acid polarity and position. FEBS Lett 527: 171–175 Stocker JW, Taguchi AKW, Murchison HA, Woodbury NW and Boxer SG (1992) Spectroscopic and redox properties of sym1 and (M)F195H: Rhodobacter capsulatus reaction center symmetry mutants which affect the initial electron donor. Biochemistry 31: 10356–10362 Sumi H and Marcus RA (1986) Dielectric relaxation and intramolecular electron transfers. J Chem Phys 84: 4272–4276 Thielges M, Uyeda G, Cámara-Artigas A, Kálmán L, Williams JC and Allen JP (2005) Design of a redox-linked active metal site: Manganese bound to bacterial reaction centers at a site resembling that of Photosystem II. Biochemistry 44: 7389–7394 Treynor TP, Yoshina-Ishii C and Boxer SG (2004) Probing excited-state electron transfer by resonance Stark spectroscopy: 4. Mutations near BL in photosynthetic reaction centers perturb multiple factors that affect BL* → BL+ HL–. J Phys Chem B 108: 13523–13535 van Brederode ME, van Stokkum IHM, Katilius E, van Mourik F, Jones MR and van Grondelle R (1999) Primary charge separation routes in the BChl:Bphe heterodimer reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 38: 7545–7555 Wakeham MC and Jones MR (2005) Rewiring photosynthesis: Engineering wrong-way electron transfer in the purple bacterial reaction centre. Biochem Soc Trans 33: 851–857 Wakeham MC, Goodwin MG, McKibbin C and Jones MR (2003) Photo-accumulation of the P+QB– radical pair state in purple bacterial reaction centres that lack the QA ubiquinone. FEBS Lett 540: 234–240 Wakeham MC, Breton J, Nabedryk E and Jones MR (2004) Formation of a semiquinone at the QB site by A- or B-branch electron transfer in the reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 43: 4755–4763 Wang H, Lin S and Woodbury NW (2006) Electronic transitions of the Soret band of reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides studied by femtosecond transient absorbance spectroscopy. J Phys Chem B 110: 6956–6961 Wang H, Lin S, Allen JP, Williams JC, Blankert S, Laser C and Woodbury NW (2007) Protein dynamics control the kinetics of initial electron transfer in photosynthesis. Science 316: 747–750 Warshel A, Chu ZT and Parson WW (1989) Dispersed polaron simulations of electron transfer in photosynthetic reaction centers. Science 246: 112–116 Watson AJ, Fyfe PK, Frolov D, Wakeham MC, Nabedryk E, van Grondelle R, Breton J and Jones MR (2005) Replacement or exclusion of the B-branch bacteriopheophytin in the purple bacterial reaction centre: The HB cofactor is not required for assembly or core function of the Rhodobacter sphaeroides complex. Biochim Biophys Acta 1710: 34–46 Webber AN and Lubitz W (2001) P700: The primary electron donor of Photosystem I. Biochim Biophys Acta 1507: 61–79 Williams JC, Alden RG, Murchison HA, Peloquin JM, Woodbury NW and Allen JP (1992) Effects of mutations near the bacteriochlorophylls in reaction centers from Rhodobacter
Chapter 18
Reaction Center Alteration
sphaeroides. Biochemistry 31: 11029–11037 Williams JC, Haffa ALM, McCulley JL, Woodbury NW and Allen JP (2001) Electrostatic interactions between charged amino acid residues and the bacteriochlorophyll dimer in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 40: 15403–15407 Williams JC, Paddock ML, Way YP and Allen JP (2007) Changes in metal specificity due to iron ligand substitutions in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Appl Magn Reson 31: 45–58 Witt H, Schlodder E, Teutloff C, Niklas J, Bordignon E, Carbonera D, Kohler S, Labahn A and Lubitz W (2002) Hydrogen bonding to P700: site-directed mutagenesis of threonine A739 of
353 Photosystem I in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. Biochemistry 41: 8557–8569 Yakovlev AG, Jones MR, Potter JA, Fyfe PK, Vasilieva LG, Shkuropatov AY and Shuvalov VA (2005) Primary charge separation between P* and BA: Electron-transfer pathways in native and mutant GM203L bacterial reaction centers. Chem Phys 319: 297–307 Yanagi K, Shimizu M, Hashimoto H, Gardiner AT, Roszak AW and Cogdell RJ (2005) Local electrostatic field induced by the carotenoid bound to the reaction center of the purple photosynthetic bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Phys Chem B 109: 992–998
Chapter 19 Mechanism of Charge Separation in Purple Bacterial Reaction Centers William W. Parson* Department of Biochemistry, Box 357350; University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195-7350, U.S.A.
Arieh Warshel Department of Chemistry, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA 90007, U.S.A.
Summary ............................................................................................................................................................... 355 I. The Reaction Sequence and Kinetics ............................................................................................................ 356 II. Energies of the Radical-Pair Intermediates .................................................................................................... 357 A. P+HA– ................................................................................................................................................. 357 B. P+BA– and P+BB– ................................................................................................................................. 357 III. Unusual Features of the Charge-Separation Reactions................................................................................. 360 A. Speed and Temperature Dependence ............................................................................................ 360 B. Specificity ........................................................................................................................................ 360 C. Multiphasic Kinetics ......................................................................................................................... 361 D. Coupling to Vibrational Wavepackets ............................................................................................. 362 E. Stability to Mutations ........................................................................................................................ 363 IV. Theories of Electron-Transfer Reactions........................................................................................................ 363 A. Marcus Theory and Semiclassical Surface-hopping ....................................................................... 363 B. Coupling to Quantized Vibrational Modes ....................................................................................... 367 C. Density-Matrix Treatments .............................................................................................................. 368 Acknowledgments ................................................................................................................................................ 370 References ............................................................................................................................................................ 370
Summary This chapter discusses the pathway, kinetics and energetics of the initial electron-transfer steps in reaction centers (RCs) from purple photosynthetic bacteria. We consider the unusual dependence of the kinetics on temperature, the strong specificity of the reactions for electron acceptors on the ‘A’ side of the RC, effects of vibrational wavepackets, the multiphasic nature of the kinetics, effects of mutations and pigment substitutions, and links between the kinetics of electron transfer and vibrational equilibration. We then discuss some of the theories that have been used to rationalize the dynamics and temperature dependence of the electron-transfer reactions, including Marcus theory, coupling to quantized vibrational modes and density-matrix treatments. Our discussion illustrates the power of microscopic simulations for connecting structural information with mechanistic interpretations. *Author for correspondence, email: [email protected]
C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty (eds): The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria, pp. 355–377. © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V.
356 I. The Reaction Sequence and Kinetics All the known reaction centers (RCs) of purple photosynthetic bacteria (Proteobacteria) contain a bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) dimer that serves as the ‘primary’ electron donor. This ‘special pair’ of BChls (P) contributes the RC’s main absorption band in the region of 865 to 885 nm in species such as Rhodobacter (Rba.) sphaeroides, Rba. capsulatus, Chromatium vinosum and Thermochromatium tepidum, which contain BChl a, and near 960 nm in Blastochloris (Blc.) viridis and other species that contain BChl b. When P is raised to its first excited singlet state (P*), it transfers an electron to a molecule of bacteriopheophytin (BPhe), generating a transient radical-pair state, P+HA– or P+HL–. The reduced BPhe (HA– or HL–) then passes an electron to a quinone (QA). The oxidized special pair (P+) subsequently extracts an electron from a c-type cytochrome, while QA– sends an electron on to a second quinone (QB). At this point, the RC has moved an electron across a membrane that is topologically contiguous with the cell’s plasma membrane, and all the primary reactants are back in their original states, ready to transfer another electron. At room temperature, transfer of an electron from P* to HA takes 3 to 5 ps in RCs of Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus and about 2 ps in Blc. viridis (Holten et al., 1980; Paschenko et al., 1985; Woodbury et al., 1985, 1994; Breton et al., 1986; Martin et al., 1986; Wasielewski and Tiede, 1986; Kirmaier and Holten, 1988; Holzapfel et al., 1989, 1990; Lauterwasser et al., 1991; Peloquin et al., 1994; Holzwarth and Muller, 1996; Huppman et al., 2002). Reduction of QA by HA– takes about 200 ps (Kaufmann et al., 1975; Rockley et al., 1975; Holten et al., 1978), whereas the time constant for oxidation of the cytochrome by P+ ranges from about 0.5 to 50 µs depending on the bacterial species (Chapter 17, Axelrod et al.). The kinetics of formation of P+HA– can be measured by following either the decay of stimulated emission from P* or the development of a broad absorption band of HA– in the region of 650 to 670 nm. Other absorbance changes (between 780 and 805 nm in the BChl a species and 800–830 nm in the BChl b Abbreviations: BA, BB – monomeric BChls that serve as electron acceptors in the RC; BChl – bacteriochlorophyll; BPhe – bacteriopheophytin; HA, HB – BPhes that serve as electron acceptors; MD – molecular dynamics; P – the special pair of BChls that acts as the primary electron donor; Pheo – pheophytin; RC – reaction center; UV – ultra-violet
William W. Parson and Arieh Warshel species) signal loss of the Qy absorption band of HA and disruption of interactions of the BPhe with the neighboring BChls. Electron transfer from P* to HA almost certainly occurs in two discrete steps, with the ‘accessory’ BChl BA (also called BL) serving as an intermediary electron carrier. Although the first crystal structures of RCs from Blc. viridis and Rba. sphaeroides showed BA situated between P and HA in what appeared to be a good position to play this role, compelling experimental evidence for the transient reduction of the BChl was slow to emerge. The difficulty evidently is that electron transfer from P* to BA is rate-limiting, so that the product of this first step (P+BA–) decays to P+HA– almost as rapidly as it is formed. In addition, transient bleaching of an absorption band of BA is not necessarily diagnostic for formation of BA– because similar absorbance changes could result from formation of an excited singlet state or a change in exciton interactions of the pigments. The stimulated emission from P* was found to contain a fast decay component that could reflect a multi-step kinetic process (Holzapfel et al., 1989, 1990; Chan et al., 1991a,b; Lauterwasser et al., 1991), but time-dependent shifts in the emission due to vibrational relaxations and the oscillatory motions of nuclear wavepackets made the interpretation of this component ambiguous. The negative results of early attempts to detect P+BA– in pump-probe experiments suggested that this state was not formed as a true intermediate, but rather served to couple P* with P+HA– by mixing with both states quantum mechanically, a process known as superexchange. However, measurements in the region of 1020 nm eventually revealed a transient absorption band that could be assigned persuasively to BA– (Arlt et al., 1993; van Stokkum et al., 1997). The rise and decay of this band in Rba. sphaeroides RCs at room temperature are consistent with a kinetic scheme in which an electron moves from P* to BA with a time constant of about 3.5 ps and then from BA– to HA with a time constant of 0.9 ps (Arlt et al., 1993). Time constants of 1 to 3 ps are obtained for both steps if the reactions are assumed to be reversible (Holzwarth and Muller, 1996; van Stokkum et al., 1997). Perhaps the most convincing experimental support for the two-step mechanism with P+BA– as an intermediate is the observation that the amplitude and lifetime of the absorption signals assigned to P+BA– increase if bacteriopheophytin HA is replaced by pheophytin a (Pheo) (Shkuropatov and Shuvalov, 1993; Schmidt et al., 1994; Schmidt et al., 1995; Kennis et al., 1997)
Chapter 19
Mechanism of Charge Separation
357
or bacteriochlorophyll (Kirmaier et al., 1995a,b). Because Pheo and BChl have more negative reduction potentials (Ems) than BPhe, either of these substitutions would be expected to slow the decay of P+BA–. Replacing a Phe residue near HA by Asp, which should raise the free energy of P+HA– if the Asp is ionized, appears to have a similar inhibitory effect on electron transfer from BA– to HA (Heller et al., 1996; Roberts et al., 2001). Mutations that should raise the free energy of P+BA– also slow charge separation, in this case probably by impairing electron transfer from P* to BA (Nagarajan et al., 1990, 1993; Chan, et al., 1991; Jia et al., 1993; Shochat et al., 1994; Beekman et al., 1996; Roberts et al., 2001; Haffa et al., 2002; Katilius et al., 2004; Chapter 16, Jones). Conversely, a long-lived P+BPhe– radical pair is seen in mutants that incorporate BPhe instead of BChl in the BA site, which should lower the free energy of transferring an electron here (Arlt et al., 1996b). Alternative pathways leading to P+HA– may open up if BA or HA is excited instead of P (van Brederode et al., 1997, 1999), or if RCs are excited with multiple photons (Lin et al., 1999) or with blue light (Lin et al., 2001). BA* evidently can extract an electron directly from P, although it also transfers its excitation energy to P with a time constant of about 0.1 ps. The reaction BA* → P+BA– is seen most clearly at low temperatures in Y(M)210F mutant RCs, where electron transfer from P* to BA is slowed. The higher energy of BA* relative to P* could enable BA* to drive the formation of P+BA– when the reaction from P* fails. Under some conditions, BA* also may transfer an electron directly to HA. However, the quantitative importance of these pathways is unclear, because some of the spectroscopic properties of RCs appear to be inconsistent with fast electron transfer to or from BA* (Zhou and Boxer, 1998a,b; King et al., 2001).
10 to 20 ns that matches the decay of the absorption signals associated with P+HA– (Shuvalov and Klimov, 1976; Godik and Borisov, 1979; Rademaker and Hoff, 1981; Godik et al., 1982; Schenck et al., 1982; Woodbury and Parson, 1984; Hörber et al., 1986; Woodbury et al., 1986; Goldstein and Boxer, 1988; Ogrodnik, 1990; Ogrodnik et al., 1994; Peloquin et al., 1994). Some of the faster decay components probably reflect relaxations of P+HA–. The relative amplitude of the slow component in Rba. sphaeroides RCs at 295 K indicates that the standard free energy of the relaxed P+HA– is between 0.21 and 0.26 eV (4.8 - 6.0 kcal/mol) below that of P*. The free energy of P+HA– also was obtained from the equilibrium constant between this state and an excited triplet state of P (3P). If electron transfer from HA– to QA is blocked, 3P forms from P+HA– with a quantum yield of about 30% in Rba. sphaeroides RCs at 295 K (Parson et al., 1975). The phosphorescence emission spectrum (Takiff and Boxer, 1988) and the activation energy for thermal repopulation of the excited singlet state (Shuvalov and Parson, 1980) put 3P 0.42 eV below P*. 3P decays largely via thermal excitation back to P+HA–, followed by charge recombination to the ground state. The formation and decay of 3P are sensitive to external magnetic fields because they require interconversion between singlet and triplet forms of the radical pair (1[P+HA–] and 3[P+HA–]), which have very similar energies in the absence of an external field but split apart in the presence of a field (Blankenship et al., 1977; Haberkorn and Michel-Beyerle, 1979; Hoff, 1981; Boxer et al., 1983). Analyses of the effects of magnetic fields and temperature on the decay kinetics indicate that P+HA– sits between 0.25 and 0.26 eV below P*, in good accord with the fluorescence measurements (Chidsey et al., 1985; Goldstein and Boxer, 1988; Ogrodnik et al., 1988; Takiff and Boxer, 1988; Boxer et al., 1989).
II. Energies of the Radical-Pair Intermediates
B. P+BA– and P+BB–
A. P+HA– The free energy difference between P* and P+HA– was obtained by measuring the equilibrium between the two states when electron transfer from HA– to QA is prevented by reducing QA beforehand or removing the quinone from the RCs. Under these conditions, fluorescence from P* decays in a multiphasic manner, but most of the decay occurs with a time constant of
Estimates of the free energy of P+BA– rest on weaker ground because of the difficulty of accessing this state experimentally. One approach is to calculate the energy by working backward from the free energy of P+HA–, using the difference between the measured Em values of BChl and BPhe in solution and incorporating calculated solvation energies of BChl– and BPhe– in solution and of P+BA– and P+HA– in the RC (Creighton et al., 1988; Parson et al., 1990; Alden et al., 1995; Parson and Warshel, 2006; Warshel et
358 al., 2006). The calculated solvation energies include electrostatic interactions of P and the electron acceptor with each other, as well as with the surrounding protein, water and (in some treatments) electrolytes. Quantum calculations of the gas-phase energy of P+BA– also have been used instead of the Em values and solvation energies (Scherer and Fischer, 1989, 1998; Thompson et al., 1991; Marchi et al., 1993; Gunner et al., 1996; Blomberg et al., 1998; Hasegawa and Nakatsuji, 1998; Ivashin et al., 1998; Hughes et al., 2001), although this approach probably entails greater uncertainties because of the large size of the BChl cluster and the complex effects of local electric fields on the quantum energies. The effects of dielectric screening in the protein can be evaluated by assigning macroscopic dielectric constants to the protein and solvent and using the Poisson-Boltzmann equation (Gilson et al., 1985; Gunner et al., 1996), or by including microscopic induced dipoles explicitly and representing the solvent by Langevin dipoles (Warshel and Russell, 1984; Parson et al., 1990; Alden et al., 1995). Dielectric effects in periodic systems can be treated by Ewald sums, and this also has been done with RCs (Procacci et al., 1997; Ceccarelli and Marchi, 2003). This approach, however, appears to be less reliable than using a spherically symmetrical model with proper polarization at the boundaries of the region that is treated explicitly (Warshel and Russell, 1984; Hunenberger et al., 1995; Figueirido et al., 1997; Sham and Warshel, 1998; Parson and Warshel, 2006; Warshel et al., 2006). Classical molecular-dynamics (MD) simulations and free-energy perturbation techniques can be used to examine how rearrangement of the protein around the charged species affects the energy of P+BA– (Creighton et al., 1988; Alden et al., 1995; Warshel and Parson, 2001; Parson and Warshel, 2006; Warshel et al., 2006). Because the protein and the surrounding water include a vast number of atoms, it is necessary to define a generalized reaction coordinate for electron transfer rather than focusing on an individual nuclear position or bond length. The most useful choice probably is the difference between the electrostatic energies of the product and reactant states (X = ∆Velec). After recording X as a function of time during an MD trajectory on the potential-energy surface of P* or P+BA–, one can generate a histogram (p(X)) of the probability of finding various values of X. These probabilities can be converted to free energies with the relationship g(X) = go -RTln(p(X)),
William W. Parson and Arieh Warshel where go = 0 for the reactant state and go = ∆ Go (the standard free energy change) for the product state. Better sampling of the relevant conformational space can be obtained by combining results from trajectories on the potential surfaces of both P* and P+BA–, or on a series of intermediate ‘mapping’ potentials comprised of linear combinations of these two potentials (see Warshel and Parson (2001) and Parson and Warshel (2006) for reviews). Comparisons of the calculated free energy of P+HA– with the measured values described above provide a useful check on the methods, although fortuitous agreements here have sometimes been misleading. Figure 1A shows calculated free energy curves for generating P+BA– from P* in the Ermler et al. (1994) crystal structure of Rba. sphaeroides RCs (Warshel and Parson, 2001; Parson and Warshel, 2006). The free energies of P* and P+BA– are plotted as functions of the reaction coordinate, and ∆Go is indicated. The calculations give ∆Go ≈ –2 kcal/mol, putting P+BA– in a good position to act as an intermediate between P* and P+HA–. Calculations on Blc. viridis RCs gave similar results (Parson et al., 1990, 1998; Alden et al., 1995, 1996a). The reorganization energy (λ), which is the free energy change associated with moving along the reaction coordinate from the equilibrium position of P* to that of P+BA–, is about 2 kcal/mol. Because the calculations have an estimated uncertainty of about ±2 kcal/mol, they do not exclude the possibility that P+BA– is slightly above P*. However, calculations that found P+BA– to be far above P* (Marchi et al., 1993) were shown to be in error as a result of an incorrect treatment of dielectric screening (Alden et al., 1995, 1996a; Gunner et al., 1996; Ceccarelli and Marchi, 2003). Other calculations that gave high free energies for P+BA– (Thompson et al., 1991; Gunner et al., 1996; Hasegawa and Nakatsuji, 1998) neglected the selfenergies of the charged species or assigned what now appears to be an unrealistically low dielectric constant to the protein (see Parson and Warshel, 2006). Calculations of the energy for P+BB–, the radical-pair created by electron transfer from P* to the monomeric BChl on the ‘B’ or ‘M’ side of the RC, put this state considerably above P* (Fig. 1B). The consequences of this higher energy, and the electrostatic interactions that underlie the difference between the energies on the two sides, are discussed in Section III. The free energy of P+BA– also has been estimated from the effects of replacing BPhe HA by Pheo, which has a more negative reduction potential than BPhe
Chapter 19
Mechanism of Charge Separation
359
Fig. 1. Calculated free energies of P*, P+BA– and P+BB– in Rba. sphaeroides RCs at 300 K, expressed relative to the minimum free energy of P*. Panel A shows the free energy of P+BA– as a function of the reaction coordinate for P* → P+BA–; panel B, the free energy of P+BB–, as a function of the reaction coordinate for P* → P+BB–. The reaction coordinate is the electrostatic energy difference between the diabatic product and reactant states in each case. The free energies were obtained by free-energy perturbation calculations as described (Warshel and Parson, 2001; Parson and Warshel, 2006), using separate 1-ns MD trajectories in the reactant and product states. The energy of transferring an electron from P* to a BChl at infinite distance in a vacuum was adjusted arbitrarily within the estimated uncertainties of the calculations so that the energies of P+BA– and P* coincide at the origin. This adjustment does not affect the calculated difference between the minimum energies of P+BA– and P+BB– (∆∆Go ≈ 6 kcal/mol). The asymmetry of the individual curves is probably an artifact of inadequate sampling of the conformational space in regions away from the minima (Warshel and Parson, 2001). The standard free energy change (∆Go) and the reorganization energy (λ) are indicated for each reaction.
(Schmidt et al., 1994, 1995). As mentioned above, transient absorbance changes following excitation of the modified RCs show an increased population of P+BA– in equilibrium with P+Pheo–. From the apparent equilibrium constant and the assumed free energy difference between P+Pheo– and P+HA–, P+BA– in native RCs was calculated to be 0.06 eV (1.4 kcal/mol) below P*, in good agreement with the calculations described above. A potential problem with this approach is that the difference between the energies of P+Pheo– and P+HA– depends partly on interactions of Pheo– and HA– with the protein, and so can not be determined simply from the Em values of the pigments in solution. This concern could be addressed by calculations of the solvation energies. Another approach is to use site-directed mutations or pigment exchanges to shift the free energy of P+BA– by predictable or measurable amounts relative to its value in wild-type RCs, and to fit the resulting changes in the rate of electron transfer with a theoretical expression that has the absolute free energy in wild-type RCs as an adjustable parameter (Williams et al., 1992; Jia et al., 1993; Murchison
et al., 1993; Nagarajan et al., 1993; Egger and Mak, 1994; Bixon et al., 1995, 1996; Arlt et al., 1996a; Holzwarth and Muller, 1996; Sim and Makri, 1997; Zusman and Beratan, 1998; Spörlein et al., 2000; Roberts et al., 2001; Haffa et al., 2002; Huppman et al., 2002; Ivashin and Larsson, 2002). A variety of theoretical formalisms have been used for this, including the classical Marcus equation (see Section IV), quantum mechanical expressions with a single high-frequency vibrational mode and a continuum of low-frequency modes, and path-integral treatments with many vibrational modes. These studies appear to have converged on an energy close to, and somewhat below, the energy of P* in native RCs, in agreement with the results described above. Using a phenomenological theoretical expression in this way is not without potential pitfalls, however. The analyses that have been described generally assume that the mutations change only a single parameter and that vibrational equilibration occurs rapidly relative to electron transfer.
360 III. Unusual Features of the ChargeSeparation Reactions A. Speed and Temperature Dependence The reactions that generate P+HA– have several remarkable features. To begin with, they are extremely fast. This in itself is perhaps not surprising, considering that some of the atoms in the π system of BA are only 3 to 4 Å from atoms of P or HA. After all, photosynthetic bacteria have had several billion years to evolve reactions that achieve charge separation with a quantum yield close to 100% (Wraight and Clayton, 1974; Trissl et al., 1990; Volk et al., 1998). But the centers of P and HA are some 18 Å apart. Moving an electron this far creates a large electric dipole that one would expect to interact strongly with the surrounding protein. In solution, such reactions require a major reorganization of the solvent, which usually makes them slow and strongly dependent on temperature. Electron transfer from P* to HA in the RC behaves in just the opposite manner, becoming even faster with decreasing temperature (Woodbury et al., 1985, 1994; Breton et al., 1988; Fleming et al., 1988; Nagarajan et al., 1990, 1993; Lauterwasser et al., 1991; Jia et al., 1993; Haffa et al., 2002; Huppman et al., 2002, 2003). Formation of P+HA– at temperatures below 20 K occurs with an overall time constant of about 1.2 ps in Rba. sphaeroides and 0.9 ps in Blc. viridis. Electron transfer from HA– to QA also speeds up with decreasing temperature (Schenck et al., 1981; Kirmaier et al., 1985b; Gunner and Dutton, 1989). Although the interactions of the radical-pair states with their surroundings are attenuated by delocalization of the charges over the macrocyclic ring systems and the two BChls of P+, the acceleration of the charge-separation reactions with decreasing temperature demands an explanation. We will return to this question in Section IV. B. Specificity Perhaps the most remarkable aspect of the chargeseparation reactions is their high specificity for the electron acceptors on the ‘A’ or ‘L’ side of the RC’s axis of approximate C2 symmetry (BA and HA) (Kirmaier et al., 1985a, 2001, 2004; Kellog et al., 1989; Mar and Gingras, 1990; Robles et al., 1990a; Heller et al., 1995; de Boer et al., 2002a; Katilius et al., 2002; Haffa et al., 2004). HA can be distinguished from HB, the BPhe on the inactive (‘B’ or ‘M’) side, because a
William W. Parson and Arieh Warshel hydrogen bond to a protonated Glu residue shifts the Qx and Qy absorption bands of HA to slightly longer wavelengths relative to those of HB (Bylina et al., 1988). Electron transfer from P* to HB is undetectable in wild-type RCs. The specificity of the reactions is surprising because the arrangement of the electron carriers is highly symmetric, and most of the amino acid residues in homologous positions on the two sides are identical or structurally similar. But as shown in Fig. 1B, the P+BB– radical-pair is calculated to be about 6 kcal/mol above P+BA– in energy, which (if correct) puts P+BB– significantly above P* (Parson et al., 1990; Parson and Warshel, 2006). The difference between the calculated energies of P+BB– and P+BA– results partly from the phenolic –OH group of Tyr M210 in Rba. sphaeroides (M208in Blc. viridis and Rba. capsulatus), which probably is oriented so as to stabilize BA– (Parson et al., 1990; Alden et al., 1996b). The homologous residue on the other side of the RC, Phe L181, cannot stabilize BB– in this way. In agreement with this picture, replacing Tyr M210 by Trp or other amino acids slows charge separation and increases the activation energy (Finkele et al., 1990; Nagarajan et al., 1990, 1993; Chan et al., 1991b; Shochat et al., 1994; Beekman et al., 1996). In Rba. capsulatus, the double mutation Y(M)208F/ F(L)181Y partly reverses the specificity of charge separation, resulting in formation of P+HB– with a quantum yield of 15 to 30% (Kirmaier et al., 2001, 2004). The Y(M)208F and F(L)181Y mutations affect the rate of charge separation in Rba. sphaeroides in essentially the same way, although they do not lead to formation of P+HB– in detectable amounts (Chan et al., 1991b). Other mutations or pigment substitutions designed to stabilize P+BB– relative to P+BA– also have been found to promote electron transfer to the B side (Taguchi et al., 1992, 1996; Heller et al., 1995, 1996; Kirmaier et al., 1995a,b, 1999, 2001, 2002, 2004; Lin et al., 1996b; Czarnecki et al., 1999; Katilius et al., 1999, 2002, 2004; de Boer et al., 2002a,b; Wakeham and Jones, 2005; Chuang et al., 2006; Chapter 16, Jones). Formation of P+HB– in a yield of 70% was achieved by first interchanging multiple residues from the D helices of the L and M subunits, which disrupts the binding of BPhe HA and completely prevents charge separation, and then introducing the F(L)181Y, H(M)195F and H(L)168F mutations to lower the energy of P+BB– (Chuang et al., 2006). Together, these observations provide compelling evidence that
Chapter 19
Mechanism of Charge Separation
the relative energies of P+BA–, P* and P+BB– shown in Fig. 1 are at least qualitatively correct, and that the favorable energy of P+BA– plays a key role in the specificity of the charge-separation reactions in wildtype RCs. A conflicting set of calculations that put P+BB– below both P* and P+BA– in energy (Ceccarelli and Marchi, 2003) could possibly reflect the use of periodic boundary conditions and the problematic Ewald-sum method to treat electrostatic interactions (see Section II.B). Several authors have found that P* has greater orbital overlap with BA than with BB, and have suggested that the resulting difference in the electronic coupling factor or ‘tunneling matrix element’ (J) accounts for the specificity of the initial electrontransfer reaction (Ivashin et al., 1998; Kolbasov and Scherz, 1998, 2000; Zhang and Friesner, 1998). If J is small relative to the energy difference between the reactant and product states, the rate of electron transfer is expected to depend on J 2 and to fall off rapidly with the distance between the electron donor and acceptor (Parson et al., 1987; Warshel et al., 1988; Moser et al., 1992; Gray and Winkler, 1996; Newton, 2003; Skourtis et al., 2005). This explanation of the specificity is difficult to test experimentally because a mutation or pigment substitution that changes J is likely to change the energetics of the reactions as well. However, the density-matrix theory described in Section IV suggests that J is large enough so that the calculated differences in its magnitude would have relatively minor effects on the rate of electron transfer (Parson and Warshel, 2004a,b). Fluctuations in the distances between the electron carriers are likely to reduce the differences in J (Warshel et al., 1988). A difference between the dielectric properties of the protein on the A and B sides also has been suggested to be an important factor in the specificity of electron transfer (Steffen et al., 1994). However, the calculated reorganization energies, which express the energetic costs of rearranging the protein around the charged products, are essentially the same on the two sides (see Fig. 1). The contributions of electronic induced dipoles to the calculated free energies of P+BA– and P+BB– also do not differ significantly (Parson et al., 1990). The favorable free energy of P+BA– thus appears to depend primarily on interactions with pre-arranged groups in the protein, rather than on dielectric effects.
361 C. Multiphasic Kinetics The electron-transfer kinetics are more complex than one might anticipate, even allowing for the formation of P+BA– as an intermediate. In addition to the major component with a time constant of 3 to 4 ps, the decay of the stimulated emission and absorbance changes associated with P* has a small component lasting 10 to 20 ps (Vos et al., 1991, 1992; Du et al., 1992; Hamm et al., 1993; Stanley and Boxer, 1995; Beekman et al., 1996; Holzwarth and Muller, 1996; Ogrodnik et al., 1999; Wang et al., 2007). It is unclear whether the two components represent distinctly different processes, or are early and later parts of a single process with a nonexponential time course. Explanations that have been suggested for the slower component include static or dynamic heterogeneity in the energy of the reaction (Kirmaier and Holten, 1990; Becker et al., 1991; Jia et al., 1993; Wang et al., 1993; Gehlen et al., 1994; Hartwich et al., 1998), relaxations of the protein around P+HA– (Peloquin et al., 1994; Woodbury et al., 1994; Ogrodnik et al., 1999), relaxations of P* (Nagarajan et al., 1993; Wang et al., 2007), and reversible transfer of an electron to BB or HB (Hamm et al., 1993). Spectral hole-burning experiments argue against gross heterogeneity as an explanation for the multiphasic kinetics (Small et al., 1992; Lyle et al., 1993; Small, 1995). The main observation here is that the width and shape of the zero-phonon hole burned by exciting RCs near the 0-0 transition energy at low temperatures agree well with those expected if P* decays with a time constant of about 1 ps. A significant population of RCs that reacted at a much lower rate should give rise to a correspondingly narrower hole that probably would have been resolved experimentally. Further, the electron-transfer rate calculated from the hole width does not vary significantly when the excitation wavelength is scanned across the inhomogeneous distribution of 0-0 transition energies (Small et al., 1992; Lyle et al., 1993). This indicates that the electron-transfer kinetics are not correlated with the 0-0 transition energy, as one might expect them to be if the multiphasic decay kinetics of stimulated emission from P* reflected heterogeneity in the RCs. Infra-red absorbance changes seen at short times after an excitation pulse suggest that P* undergoes an internal relaxation with a time constant of 0.2 ps at 285 K, possibly to a state with increased chargetransfer character (Hamm and Zinth, 1995). However,
William W. Parson and Arieh Warshel
362 the finding that the 1 ps time constant derived from the zero-phonon hole width matches the time constant for electron transfer argues against the possibility that P* evolves into a different electronic state on a time scale much shorter than this, at least at low temperatures (Johnson et al., 1990; Middendorf et al., 1991; Reddy et al., 1992; Lyle et al., 1993). Whether the infra-red absorbance changes occur at low temperatures is not known. Sub-picosecond reorientations of water molecules around P* have been invoked to account for the high efficiency with which RCs trap energy from the antenna (Borisov and Fok, 1999), but have not been studied experimentally. D. Coupling to Vibrational Wavepackets The absorption band at 1020 nm that is assigned to BA– apparently does not simply rise and decay once, as it would in a classical two-step kinetic scheme. It develops and disappears again several times on a picosecond time scale, suggesting that P+BA– is generated in concert with nuclear motions that are launched when RCs are excited with a short pulse of light. (Yakovlev et al., 2000, 2002, 2003; Yakovlev and Shuvalov, 2000; Shuvalov and Yakovlev, 2003). Because a subpicosecond excitation pulse includes a broad band of frequencies, it can project molecules simultaneously into many different vibrational substates of P*. The wavefunctions for a harmonic vibrational mode (m) have the form Ψ nm ( rm , t ) = χ nm ( rm ) exp ⎡⎣ −iEmn (t + δ ) / ប ⎤⎦ = χ nm ( rm ) exp ⎡⎣ −iω m ( n + 1 / 2)(t + δ ) / ប ⎤⎦
(1) where n = 0, 1, 2, …, χnm (rm) is a spatial (harmonic oscillator) wavefunction of nuclear coordinate rm, Enm is the energy of level n, ωm is the wavenumber (reciprocal wavelength) of the mode, ប is Planck’s constant divided by 2π, t is time, and δ is a phase shift. Population of several such levels at the same time (δ ≈ 0) creates a linear combination of these wavefunctions (wavepacket) that moves back and forth on rm much like a classical particle. As the wavepacket moves, its spatial overlap with various vibrational levels of the ground electronic state changes, causing the emission spectrum of the excited state to oscillate. Such oscillations have been seen in both the stimulated and spontaneous emission of P* (Vos et al., 1991,
1992, 1993, 1994a,b, 1996, 2000; Stanley and Boxer, 1995; Martin and Vos, 1992; Rischel et al., 1998; Spörlein et al., 1998; Vos and Martin, 1999). Fourier analysis of the oscillations reveals components with energies ranging from below 30 cm–1 to about 250 cm–1, with the upper limit probably being set by the spectral width of the excitation pulse. Shuvalov and coworkers (Yakovlev et al., 2000; Yakovlev and Shuvalov, 2000; Yakovlev et al., 2002, 2003; Shuvalov and Yakovlev, 2003) have suggested that P+BA– forms reversibly each time the P* wavepacket crosses the potential energy surface of P+BA–, but returns to P* and is regenerated several times before it is trapped by relaxations of the surrounding protein. Transient peaks in the amount of P+BA– also could be explained by stepwise formation of P+BA– followed by rapid conversion to P+HA– rather than return to P* (Parson and Warshel, 2004a, 2004b). The oscillations of P* and P+BA– have not yet been assigned definitively to particular motions of the BChls or the surrounding protein. Normal-mode calculations and resonance Raman spectra of isotopically labeled BChl suggest that out-of-plane deformation of the C2 acetyl groups contributes a strong mode at 35-cm–1, whereas several types of deformation of the macrocyclic rings contribute to a band around 130 cm–1 (Czarnecki et al., 1997). Motions of the protein or bound water molecules also appear to be important, however, because mutations can modify the oscillation frequencies substantially (Rischel et al., 1998; Yakovlev et al., 2003). At low temperatures where charge separation occurs with a time constant of about 1 ps, the wavepacket motions of P* disappear with essentially the same kinetics as the excited state itself. In RCs carrying a point mutation that slows charge-separation, damping of the wavepacket precedes electron transfer but still occurs on the time scale of 1 to 2 ps, with high-frequency components of the motions decaying more rapidly than low-frequency components (Vos et al., 1996). The time constant for damping of the wavepacket under these conditions probably reflects stochastic relaxations that take the vibrational sublevels of P* to thermal equilibrium and are analogous to T1 processes in NMR. Vibrational coherence also can decay by ‘pure dephasing’ caused by fluctuations of the vibrational energies (T2-type processes), but this process likely is slower under most conditions. The observed time constants of 1 to 2 ps therefore indicate that vibrational relaxations of P* take place on the same time scale as electron transfer.
Chapter 19
Mechanism of Charge Separation
By extension, vibrational relaxations of P+BA– and P+HA– probably occur on the same time scale, which raises the question of whether they limit the overall rate of charge separation. Several models in which relaxations of the product state are rate-limiting have been suggested (Kitzing and Kühn, 1990; Peloquin et al., 1994; Woodbury et al., 1994; Lin, Taguchi et al., 1996; Yakovlev et al., 2000, 2002, 2003; Yakovlev and Shuvalov, 2000; Shuvalov and Yakovlev, 2003). However, the density-matrix analysis described in Section IV suggests that these relaxations are fast enough so that further increases in their speed would not increase the rate of charge separation greatly, and could even decrease it (Parson and Warshel, 2004a, 2004b). In an attempt to probe relaxations of the protein more directly, Wang et al. (2007) have measured absorbance changes at 280 nm that could reflect the effects of changing electric fields on tryptophan residues near the electron carriers. Absorbance changes at this wavelength develop with little or no lag after RCs are excited, and then decay with a multi-exponential time course with time constants on the order of 3, 10 and 190 ps. The rise and decay kinetics are not affected by mutations that alter the rate of charge separation, suggesting that the signals are initiated by the initial excitation of P rather than the formation of P+BA– or P+HA–. Wang et al. (2007) therefore interpret the 3- and 10-ps components of the decay kinetics as reflecting dielectric relaxation of the protein around P*. The 190-ps component appears to accompany electron transfer from HA– to QA because it has a much smaller amplitude in RCs that are depleted of the quinone. Studies of mutants in which individual Trp residues near P, BA or HA are replaced by Tyr or Phe should help to identify the residues that are responsible for the absorbance changes, and to elucidate why these residues appear to respond more strongly to P* than to the much larger dipoles of P+BA– and P+HA–. E. Stability to Mutations Charge separation in RCs is surprisingly robust to mutations. Although mutations that raise the energy of P+BA– relative to P* slow charge separation, photoreduction of HA still occurs with a relatively high quantum yield as long as the RC assembles completely and contains P, BA and HA (Robles et al., 1990a,b; Lin et al., 1996b; Taguchi et al., 1996). No single amino acid residue appears to be essential for charge separation to the level of P+HA–. For example,
363 mutations that reverse the charge of arginine L135 or M164, the ionizable residues closest to P, have very little effect on the kinetics (Johnson et al., 2003). Mutations that add or remove hydrogen bonds between the electron carriers and the protein generally have larger, but still relatively modest effects (Williams et al., 1992; Haffa et al., 2002; Huppman et al., 2002). And although mutations that change the relative energies of P+BA– and P+BB– can increase the probability of electron transfer to the acceptors on the B side of the RC, inducing a significant fraction of the charge-separation to proceed in this direction requires multiple mutations (Taguchi et al., 1992, 1996; Lin et al., 1996b; Kirmaier et al., 2001, 2004; de Boer et al., 2002b; Chuang et al., 2006). Even mutations that raise the energy of P+BA– enough to slow the initial electron-transfer by a factor of 10 or more generally do not prevent charge separation from occurring at cryogenic temperatures (Nagarajan et al., 1993; Haffa et al., 2002). IV. Theories of Electron-Transfer Reactions A. Marcus Theory and Semiclassical Surfacehopping Much of the discussion of the charge-separation reactions has been based on the general theory of electron-transfer processes developed by R. A. Marcus (Marcus, 1956, 1964, 1993). Consider the free energy surfaces of the diabatic electronic states P* and P+BA– shown in Fig. 1. The term diabatic means that a system in one of these states is not stationary, but rather has some probability of making a transition to the other state. In a quantum mechanical description, P* and P+BA– do not diagonalize the Hamiltonian of the system. Overlap of the molecular orbitals of P* and BA– gives rise to off-diagonal terms in the Hamiltonian, and it is these off-diagonal terms (the electronic coupling factor J and its complex conjugate) that bring about transitions between the two states. The stationary states that diagonalize the interaction Hamiltonian are described as adiabatic. Classically, transitions between two states occur only at the intersection of the potential energy surfaces, where a transition conserves energy and momentum. For parabolic surfaces with the same curvature, the free energy of the intersection relative to the minimum free energy of the reactant state, i.e., the activation free energy of the reaction (∆G‡),
William W. Parson and Arieh Warshel
364 is given by ∆G‡ = (∆Go + λ)2/4λ, where ∆Go is the free energy difference between the two minima and λ again is the reorganization energy (see Fig. 1). In transition-state theory, the probability of finding the system at the transition point is taken to be exp(–∆G‡/kBT), where kB is the Boltzmann constant and T the temperature. (Marcus, 1956, 1964) wrote the rate constant for electron transfer as the product of this probability and a factor that depends mainly on the electronic coupling:
(
)
(
k12 = π1/ 2 J 2 ប λk BT exp ⎡ − ∆G o + λ ⎢⎣
)
2
4λk BT ⎤ ⎥⎦ (2)
This expression assumes that the system has only a small probability of making a transition from one diabatic state to the other each time it passes through the intersection point, which will be the case if J is much smaller than the fluctuating interactions of the system with its surroundings. Electron transfer in this regime is said to be nonadiabatic. In the opposite limit of very strong coupling, the system tends to remain on the lower adiabatic surface as it approaches the intersection, so that transitions between the diabatic states have a high probability; electron transfer then is described as adiabatic. According to Eq. (2), k12 has a maximal value when ∆Go = –λ. The diabatic energy surfaces then intersect at the minimum of state 1; ∆G‡ is zero; and the pre-exponential factor causes the rate to increase weakly with decreasing temperature. The calculated free energy curves for P* and P+BA– are qualitatively consistent with this situation (Fig. 1A). The Marcus equation thus can rationalize the unusual temperature dependence of the charge-separation reactions. It also can account for the sensitivity of the rate and specificity of the initial reaction to changes in the energy of P+BA– or P+BB–. However, the Marcus equation generally underestimates the rate at low temperatures where nuclear tunneling and zero-point vibrational energies become important (Warshel et al., 1989). In particular, it fails to explain how charge separation can continue to occur at low temperatures in RCs with mutations that raise the energy of P+BA– (Haffa et al., 2002). Equation (2) also rests on the assumption that the vibrational sublevels of each electronic state reach thermal equilibrium rapidly relative to the rate of electron transfer. As discussed in Section III, this assumption appears to break down for the initial steps of charge separation. The Marcus equa-
tion nevertheless provides a useful, semiquantitative basis for discussing the rate and specificity of charge separation. It is important to distinguish thermodynamic quantities such as ∆Go and ∆G‡ from the microscopic properties of an individual RC. Thermodynamic quantities represent mean values of fluctuating microscopic quantities over a large ensemble of particles, which are equivalent to averages over an extended period of time for an individual particle. The fluctuating gap (X(t)) between the electrostatic energies of P+BA– and P* can be recorded as a function of time during a classical MD simulation of an individual RC, and can be used to simulate a nonadiabatic electron-transfer reaction with a semiclassical ‘surface-hopping’ model that converges with the Marcus equation at high temperatures. Transitions between the two diabatic states again occur mainly when the energy gap is close to zero (Tully and Preston, 1971; Miller and George, 1972; Warshel, 1982; Warshel and Hwang, 1986; Warshel and Parson, 2001). Figs 2A and B show typical records of time-dependent energy gaps for forming P+BA– and P+BB– during MD simulations of Rba. sphaeroides RCs at 300 K, and Fig. 3A shows the predicted kinetics of electron transfer from P* to BA in a simplified surface-hopping model. In these simulations, the energy gap for forming P+BA– (Fig. 2A) crossed zero about 20 times per ps (2 × 1013 s–1), while that for P+BB– (Fig. 2B) had no crossings (<109 s–1). If the energy gap for P+BB– fluctuates rapidly over a range of about ±2 kcal/mol, as these and other MD simulations indicate, mutations that change the mean value of the energy gap by less than this should have only minor effects on the electron-transfer kinetics. This point is illustrated in Fig. 3A, where increasing the mean energy gap by 1 kcal/mol has virtually no effect whereas shifting the mean value by more than 2 kcal/mol slows the reaction considerably. Surfacehopping simulations of charge separation by a reversible, two-step kinetic model with a small negative ∆Go in each step give dynamics similar to those seen experimentally (Creighton et al., 1988; Warshel and Parson, 1991). Including a more rigorous integration of the transition probabilities near the crossings has only minor effects on the results. The Marcus equation has been extended to include a time-dependent solvent coordinate with diffusional kinetics and its own reorganization energy, in addition to the rapid fluctuations illustrated in Figs. 2A and B (Sumi and Marcus, 1986; Okada, 2000; Ando and
Chapter 19
Mechanism of Charge Separation
365
Fig. 2. (A) Calculated time-dependent energy gap (∆Velec) between P+BA– and P* in Rba. sphaeroides RCs during a 1-ns MD trajectory at 300 K (Warshel and Parson, 2001). The potential surface for the ground state was used as a surrogate for the potential surface of P*. (B) Same as A but for the energy gap between P+BB– and P* during a similar trajectory. (C) A portion of the autocorrelation function of the energy gap shown in A, normalized to 1.0 at t = 0. (D) A portion of the normalized autocorrelation function of the energy gap shown in B. The autocorrelation functions also have a component with an ultrafast (~50 fs) decay that is off scale at the top of the graphs. This component reflects dephasing of oscillations at different frequencies and is independent of vibrational relaxations (Parson and Warshel, 2004a). (E) Fourier transform of the autocorrelation function shown in C. Insert: Fourier transform of the autocorrelation function of fluctuations of the CE2-CZ-OH-HOH dihedral angle of Tyr M210 during a similar trajectory. (F) Fourier transform of the autocorrelation function shown in D.
Sumi, 2003). Motions of an ensemble of particles on such a coordinate can make ∆Go and the total reorganization energy, and thus ∆G‡, evolve with time. Wang et al. (2007) have used the decay kinetics of the ultra-violet (UV) absorbance changes initiated by excitation of P (see above) as a measure of the mean position along a similar ‘slow’ coordinate. They were able to reproduce the nonexponential kinetics of charge separation for both wild-type RCs and mutants with altered values of the initial ∆Go. It was necessary
to adjust the initial ∆Go phenomenologically for each mutant, but the adjustments were generally consistent with other observations. Since Wang et al. (2007) obtain the relaxation kinetics experimentally, the essential feature of their analysis is not that some of the RCs’ motions resemble diffusion, but simply that the mean energy difference between P* and P+BA– changes with time as the protein relaxes around P*. The dynamics of this evolution can be explored by MD simulations in several different
366
William W. Parson and Arieh Warshel
Fig. 3. (A) Simulated kinetics of electron transfer from P* to BA in a surface-hopping model with a single, irreversible step. The population of P* was assumed to split each time the fluctuating energy gap between P+BA– and P* passed through zero in either direction, with 3% of the population at that point going to P+BA– and 97% remaining as P*. The resulting decay curve was averaged over all possible starting times in a cyclically permuted record of the energy gap from a 1-ns MD trajectory in the reactant state (Fig. 2A). For curve 1, the mean energy gap was taken to be zero; for curves 2, 3 and 5, the mean was set at 1.0, 2.0 or 2.4 kcal/mol, respectively. For curve 4 (dashed line), the mean energy gap was increased from 2.0 to 2.4 kcal/mol with a time constant of 1.5 ps to simulate an exponential decrease in the energy of P*. (B) Simulated kinetics of electron transfer from P* to BA in a density-matrix model in which electron transfer was coupled to a single vibrational mode with wavenumber 30 cm–1. The minimum energies of P+BA– and P+HA– were set, respectively, 175 and 1000 cm–1 (0.5 and 2.86 kcal/mol) below that of P*. The dimensionless displacement of P* from the ground state on the vibrational coordinate was 2.5, the displacement of P+BA– relative to P* was 3.7, the electronic coupling factor (Jel) was 6 cm–1, and T1o was 2.5 ps. The RC was assumed to start with the vibrational sublevels of the ground state in thermal equilibrium at 80 K, and was excited either coherently (solid lines) or incoherently (dashed lines). The excitation pulse had a Gaussian spectral distribution with full width at halfmaximum amplitude of 150 cm–1 centered on the 0-0 transition energy. P+BA– was assumed to decay stochastically to P+HA– with a time constant of 0.5 ps. The parameter values used in this one-mode model were chosen to illustrate aspects of the density-matrix treatment, and are not estimates of the values for any particular vibrational mode of the RC. (C) The time-dependent expectation value of the energy gap (X(t)) for RCs in the P* state in the density-matrix model considered in B.
ways. According to the fluctuation-dissipation theorem (Kubo, 1966), the linear response of an ensemble of systems to a small, external perturbation such as impulsive creation of an electric dipole is given by the autocorrelation function of the fluctuations of the ensemble at equilibrium. The normalized autocorrelation function of a fluctuating function x(t) is defined as C(t) = 〈x(t´)x(t´+t)〉/〈x(t´)x(t´)〉, where 〈...〉 denotes the average value of the quantity in the brackets. Panels C and D of Fig. 2 show autocorrelation functions for the energy gaps for forming P+BA– and P+BB– in Rba. sphaeroides RCs at 300 K (Parson and Warshel, 2004a, 2004b). Following an ultrafast step that is off scale in the figures, the autocorrelation functions exhibit complex oscillations that are damped on the
time scale of 1 to 10 ps. The center of these oscillations decays to zero on the same time scale. Essentially identical dynamics are obtained by averaging the time-dependent energy gaps in many independent MD trajectories of P+BA– beginning when this state is created from P* (Parson and Warshel, 2004a). Judging from the decay of the autocorrelation functions, an ensemble of RCs thus appears to complete most of its response to an impulsive electrostatic perturbation within about 10 ps. This is consistent with the relaxations of the UV absorbance changes described by Wang et al. (2007), which probably provide a more sensitive probe of small components of the relaxation that continue on longer time scales. The effects of a slow change in the mean energy
Chapter 19
Mechanism of Charge Separation
gap between P* and P+BA– can be illustrated by the simple surface-hopping model used in Fig. 3A. For the simulation shown as curve 4, the mean energy gap (〈X 〉) was written as 〈X(t)〉 = 2.4 – exp(–t/τ) kcal/mol, with a relaxation time constant (τ) of 1.5 ps. The mean gap thus began with the value used for curve 3 but increased progressively to that used for curve 5. The resulting electron-transfer kinetics are decidedly non-exponential, in qualitative accord with the kinetics seen experimentally. Note that the rate constants for the fast and slow component of the electron-transfer kinetics depend on the random fluctuations about the initial and asymptotic values of 〈X 〉, not the time constant for approaching the asymptote. If the initial value of 〈X 〉 were negative rather than positive as assumed here, the rate of electron transfer would increase with time and then could decrease again when 〈X 〉 became positive. Note also that non-exponential kinetics will be seen only if the relaxation occurs on the same time scale as the faster component of electron transfer, as appears to be the case in RCs. B. Coupling to Quantized Vibrational Modes To deal with quantum mechanical effects that are missing in the treatments described above, BornOppenheimer vibronic wavefunctions commonly are written in the form ⎫ ⎧ ψ k (r, t ) = ⎨φk ∏ χ nm( m,k ) ( rm ) ⎬ exp( −iEk t / ប ) ⎭ ⎩ m
(3)
Here φk is an electronic wavefunction, χmn(m,k) (rm) is a harmonic-oscillator wavefunction of vibrational coordinate rm, r is the complete vector of coordinates, and n(m,k) is the excitation level (number of phonons) of mode m in vibronic state k. Ek, the energy of vibronic state k, is Ek = Ek ,0 + ∑ [ n( m, k ) + 1 / 2]បω m
(4)
m
where Ek,0 is an electronic energy. We have neglected phase shifts for simplicity. In a system with a single vibrational mode (r1), the interaction matrix element for transitions from a vibronic state comprised of electronic state j and u phonons to a state comprised of electronic state k and n phonons is the product of a purely electronic factor (Jel) and a vibrational overlap integral,
367 F1n,u =
∞
∫ χ1 χ1 dr1 n
u
−∞
The Franck-Condon factor for the transition is |F1n,u|2, which can differ from zero only if wavefunction χ1n is displaced from χ1u along r1. The requirement for a non-zero Franck-Condon factor replaces the classical principle that transitions occur only at intersections of the diabatic energies. Overlapping tails of the reactant and product wavefunctions thus allow electron transfer to occur at low temperatures even if the only vibrational levels of the reactant state with significant populations lie below the intersection of the diabatic surfaces. More generally, the Franck-Condon factor involves a product of many vibrational overlap integrals, one for each vibrational mode that is coupled to the transition, i.e., for each coordinate along which the energy minima of the reactant and product states are displaced. The overall rate of electron transfer depends on a sum of Franck-Condon factors for transitions between various possible initial and final vibrational states, with each Franck-Condon factor weighted by the population of the initial state. Several expressions for the rate constant have been developed using this general formalism. Kubo and Toyozawa (1955) gave the exact expression for a multidimensional harmonic system. Jortner, Bixon and coworkers have derived expressions for a single high-frequency mode and a continuum of low-frequency modes, and have used them to fit the dependence of the charge-separation kinetics on temperature and on mutations that change ∆Go (Bixon and Jortner, 1968, 1986, 1999; Kestner et al., 1974; Rips and Jortner, 1988). Instead of the single maximum predicted by Eq. (2), the quantum treatment with even a single vibrational mode can give a series of maxima where the energy of the initial state matches the energies of successive steps in the ladder of possible final states (Sarai, 1980). Information on the vibrations that are coupled to charge separation can be obtained from molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of the reaction. In the dispersed polaron theory developed by Warshel and coworkers, the fluctuations of the time-dependent energy gap (X(t)) recorded during an MD trajectory are related to the frequencies of the vibrational motions that are coupled to the reaction (Churg and Warshel, 1985; Hwang and Warshel, 1987; Hwang et al., 1988; Warshel et al., 1989; Warshel and Parson, 1991). A Fourier transform of the autocorrelation function of X(t) has a peak at the frequency of each
368 of these vibrational modes, and the amplitude of the peak is proportional to the square of the displacement of the energy minima along the corresponding vibrational coordinate. The Franck-Condon factors for transitions between different vibronic states of the system can be obtained straightforwardly from the vibrational frequencies and displacements. The frequencies and displacements can be used directly in Kubo and Toyozawa’s (1955) expression for the rate constant (Warshel et al., 1989), or can be used to build a density-matrix model as discussed in the following section. The dispersed polaron treatment is formally identical to the spin boson treatment (Garg et al., 1985; Leggett et al., 1987; Bader et al., 1990; Schulten and Tesch, 1991), which was developed about the same time but initially did not capitalize on the potential of using classical MD simulations to address quantum effects in condensed phases. See Hwang and Warshel (1997) for a discussion of the equivalence of the two treatments and Warshel and Parson (2001) for a review. In retrospect, the important advance was not the development of a formal expression for the rate of electron transfer, since Kubo had already provided that, but the realization that the door was open to microscopic simulations of quantum effects on electron-transfer reactions in proteins. Figure 2 illustrates a dispersed-polaron analysis of the vibrational modes that are coupled to formation of P+BA– and P+BB– in Rba. sphaeroides. The time-dependent energy gaps (panels A and B) and their autocorrelation functions (C and D ) have been discussed above. Fourier transforms of the autocorrelation functions are shown in panels E and F. The bands between 300 and 400 cm–1 that appear prominently in Fig. 2E but not in Fig. 2F can be assigned to torsional motions of the phenolic –OH group of Tyr M208, because peaks at the same frequencies appear in Fourier transforms of the correlation function of the torsional angle itself (Fig. 2E, insert), and both sets of peaks are lost if the Tyr is replaced by Phe in the computer model (unpublished observations). As discussed above, the calculated energy of P+BA– depends strongly on the orientation of the –OH group, while the energy of P+BB– does not. Motions of the –OH group are not coupled strongly to excitation of P, and so do not figure significantly in the wavepackets discussed in Section III. (They also have too high a frequency for many levels to be excited coherently by the excitation flashes that have been used so far.) The bands in the regions of 35, 70
William W. Parson and Arieh Warshel and 130 cm–1 have frequencies similar to some of the oscillations seen experimentally in P* and P+BB–, but have not yet been assigned to particular motions of the protein. Although the fine structures of the spectra for P+BA– (Fig. 2E) and P+BB– (Fig. 2F) differ in these regions, the overall shapes and amplitudes of the two spectra are similar. In principle, the dispersed-polaron/spin-boson treatment provides the frequencies and displacements of all the vibrational modes that are coupled to an electron-transfer reaction, just as the autocorrelation function of the energy gap contains the complete dielectric response of the system to a perturbation. Capturing very low-frequency modes and very slow relaxations of course requires sufficiently long MD trajectories. High-frequency intramolecular modes of the electron carriers also are unlikely to be captured properly by classical MD simulations, but can be treated by simulations that use mixed quantumclassical fields. Mercer et al. (1999) have described such a treatment of vibronic coupling in excitation of BChl. In addition, the vibrational frequencies and displacements and other information obtained from a classical MD simulation at room temperature can be transformed to a quantum mechanical model that should remain valid at low temperatures (Parson and Warshel, 2004a). C. Density-Matrix Treatments Density-matrix formalisms (Slichter, 1963; Redfield, 1965; Davidson, 1976; Blum, 1996) provide a way to introduce stochastic vibrational relaxations and dephasing in the context of the dispersed-polaron/ spin-boson theory, and so to obviate the assumption that vibrational thermalization occurs rapidly relative to electron transfer. In this approach, the wavefunction for an ensemble of RCs is written as a linear combination of vibronic wavefunctions (see Eqs. 3 and 4): ⎫ ⎧ Ψ(r, t ) = ∑ ck (t ) ⎨φk ∏ χ nm( m,k ) ( rm ) ⎬ = k ⎭ ⎩ m ⎫ ⎧ ∑ Ck (t ) exp(−iEk t / ប ) ⎨φk ∏ χnm( m,k ) (rm ) ⎬ k ⎭ ⎩ m
(5) The reduced density matrix (ρ) of the system then can be defined by the elements
Chapter 19
Mechanism of Charge Separation
ρ j ,k (t ) = c j (t ) ck *(t ) = C j (t ) Ck *(t ) exp ⎡⎣ −i( E j − Ek )t / ប ⎤⎦
(6)
where the bar denotes an average over an ensemble of molecules. In this representation, (t) contains the complete dependence of the ensemble on time. The diagonal matrix element ρj,j(t) gives the population of vibronic state j at time t, while the off-diagonal element ρj,k(t) conveys the coherence between states j and k (i.e., the ensemble average of exp[–i(Ej – Ek)t / ប]). The expectation value of any dynamic observable can be computed as the trace of the product (t)⋅õ, where õ is a matrix representation of the operator corresponding to the observable. The time dependence of the density matrix is given by the stochastic Liouville equation, ∂ρ j ,k ∂t
=
i ∑ ⎡ρ ⋅ J - J j ,u ⋅ ρu,k ⎤⎦ + ប u ⎣ j ,u u ,k ∑ ∑ R j ,k ,u,v ⋅ ρu,v u
(7)
v
where Ju,k is the coupling factor for transitions between states k and u (the product of an electronic factor and the vibrational overlap integrals) and the Rj,k,u,v are elements of the Redfield relaxation tensor (Slichter, 1963; Redfield, 1965; Jean et al., 1992; Walsh and Coalson, 1992; Jean and Fleming, 1995; Pollard et al., 1996; Parson and Warshel, 2004a, 2004b). Rj,j,k,k is the rate constant for stochastic transitions from vibronic state k to state j; Rk,k,k,k is –1 times the sum of the rate constants for transitions from state k to all the other states; Rj,k,j,k is –1 times the rate constant for decay of coherence between states j and k; and Ri,j,k,l is for transfer of coherence from one pair of states (k and l) to another (i and j). The density matrix at time t can be obtained by starting at t = 0 with an initial density matrix that reflects the absorption spectrum of P and the energy and shape of a given excitation pulse, and then integrating Eq. 7 numerically up to time t (Parson and Warshel, 2004b). To evaluate the elements of the relaxation tensor, one needs the rate constants for stochastic transitions between different sublevels of each vibrational mode that is coupled to electron transfer. The necessary rate constants can be obtained by calculating the autocorrelation function of the energy gap (X(t)) both from the MD simulations and from a density-matrix model
369 with equivalent vibrational modes, and adjusting the microscopic rate constants in the density-matrix model to make the two functions similar. Although this might seem to require a vast number of free parameters, it can be done surprisingly well by adjusting a single parameter, the time constant for equilibration of the two lowest levels of a vibrational mode (T1o) (Parson and Warshel, 2004a,b). The time constant for equilibration of any other pair of levels can be related straightforwardly to T1o and the numbers of phonons in these levels. The necessary value of T1o for Rba. sphaeroides RCs is on the order of 1 to 2 ps at 80 K and is not very dependent on temperature. Values of T1o in this range are consistent with the damping of the oscillations of stimulated emission and excitedstate absorption seen after RCs are excited with a short flash (see Section II.D). The overall decay of the oscillations of the energy gap (Fig. 2C, D) can take longer than T1o, because it represents the approach to thermal equilibrium among a large number of microscopic states. Figures 3B and C illustrate the behavior of a simple density-matrix model in which electron transfer from P* to BA is coupled to a single vibrational mode with an energy of 30 cm–1, the fundamental vibrational transition time (T1o) is 2.5 ps, and P+BA– decays to P+HA– stochastically with a time constant of 0.5 ps. When the ensemble of RCs is excited coherently (solid lines), the population of P+BA– exhibits damped oscillations during the first few picoseconds after the excitation pulse, with the rate of electron transfer peaking whenever the energy gap goes to, or close to, zero. Only small hints of the oscillatory features can be seen if the ensemble is excited incoherently with a pulse of the same energy (dashed lines), although the overall rate of electron transfer is essentially the same except at the shortest times. With the parameter values used in Figs. 3B and C, the oscillating energy gap following coherent excitation makes only one excursion across zero and back before vibrational relaxations destroy most of the ensemble’s coherence. However, nuclear tunneling allows electron transfer to continue with a lower rate constant even though the energy gap is not zero. The density-matrix model thus can reproduce the biphasic kinetics induced by shifting the average value of the energy gap in the surface-hopping model (Fig. 3A), as well as the more complex, oscillatory behavior at short times. Energy is conserved by interactions of the system with the surroundings, which do not need to be enumerated explicitly.
370 In a model with five vibrational modes and T1o ≈ 2 ps, the density-matrix treatment reproduces the measured rate of electron transfer from P* to BA well if the purely electronic part of the coupling factor (Jel) is taken to be on the order of 20 cm–1 (Parson and Warshel, 2004b). This agrees with the values that have been obtained by molecular orbital theory (Ivashin et al., 1998; Kolbasov and Scherz, 1998, 2000; Zhang and Friesner, 1998). The theory also accounts easily for the increase in the rate with decreasing temperature (Parson and Warshel, 2004a,b), but the explanation for the unusual temperature dependence differs from that offered by Marcus theory. In the density-matrix theory, when vibrational relaxation occurs more slowly than electron transfer, temperature affects the rate mainly through the Boltzmann distribution of P among the vibrational sublevels of the ground state before the RC is excited, rather than by affecting P* directly. For example, a vibrational mode of P that is at its zero-point level at low temperatures can be projected into various higher levels in P*, depending on the corresponding Franck-Condon factors. The electron-transfer rate therefore is not necessarily maximal when ∆Go = –λ as in the Marcus theory. Similarly, the maximal electron-transfer rate in the density-matrix theory generally does not occur when P* is at its potential minimum, but rather when the vibrational energy is somewhat higher than this. The rate therefore should fall off if the initial energy of P* is lowered by moving the excitation flash to the red of the 0-0 excitation energy. However, this effect probably would be detectable only at temperatures below about 10 K, and would be lost if Jel is large enough to drive electron transfer between vibronic states that are well off resonance. It has not been seen experimentally (Peloquin et al., 1995, 1996; Lin et al., 1996a; H. Wang, S. Lin and N. Woodbury, personal communication). Modest changes of T1o in the region of 2 ps have little effect on the calculated rate of electron transfer in the density-matrix model. However, decreasing T1o below about 0.5 ps can slow electron-transfer (Parson and Warshel, 2004a,b). This is partly because relaxations of P* compete with electron transfer from ‘hot’ vibrational states that are populated by the excitation pulse. In addition, because transitions from P* to P+BA– occur only by way of off-diagonal elements of ρ, they are thwarted if the off-diagonal elements decay too rapidly. The overall rate of electron transfer also decreases if the off-diagonal elements of ρ are destroyed rapidly by fluctuations of the
William W. Parson and Arieh Warshel vibronic energies (pure dephasing) or by electron transfer from BA– to HA. The last effect, an interesting illustration of the ‘quantum Zeno’ or ‘watched pot’ paradox, is unknown in classical chemical kinetics, where increasing the rate constant for the second of a two-step process never decreases the overall rate. The density-matrix model thus appears to capture the unusual features of the initial steps of charge separation reasonably well. It is particularly satisfying that values for almost all the parameters of the model can be obtained from MD simulations and quantum calculations based on the actual structure of the RC. The main obstacle to using MD simulations to find the rate constants for vibrational relaxations probably is the difficulty of extending MD trajectories much beyond several ns. Without sufficiently long trajectories, small, long-lived components of the autocorrelation function are difficult to distinguish from noise. It should be possible to use UV absorbance changes (Wang et al., 2007) or other experimental measures of dielectric relaxation to refine the relaxation tensor, but this probably will require additional adjustable parameters that are not determined uniquely. Acknowledgments Preparation of this chapter was supported by National Science Foundation grant MCB-9904618 to W. W. P. and National Institutes of Health grants (GM24492 and GM40283) to A. W. We thank Neal Woodbury for helpful discussions and communicating recent results from his laboratory. References Alden RG, Parson WW, Chu ZT and Warshel A (1995) Calculations of electrostatic energies in photosynthetic reaction centers. J Am Chem Soc 117: 12284–12298 Alden RG, Parson WW, Chu ZT and Warshel A (1996a) Macroscopic and microscopic estimates of the energetics of charge separation in bacterial reaction centers. In: Michel-Beyerle ME (ed) Reaction Centers of Photosynthetic Bacteria: Structure and Dynamics, pp 105–116. Springer-Verlag, Berlin Alden RG, Parson WW, Chu ZT and Warshel A (1996b) Orientation of the OH dipole of tyrosine (M)210 and its effect on electrostatic energies in photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers. J Phys Chem 100: 16761–16770 Ando K and Sumi H (2003) Path-integral Monte Carlo calculation of reaction-diffusion equation. J Chem Phys 118: 8315–8320 Arlt T, Schmidt S, Kaiser W, Lauterwasser C, Meyer M, Scheer H and Zinth W (1993) The accessory bacteriochlorophyll: A real electron carrier in primary photosynthesis. Proc Natl Acad
Chapter 19
Mechanism of Charge Separation
Sci USA 90: 11757–11762 Arlt T, Bibikova M, Penzkofer H, Oesterhelt D and Zinth W (1996a) Strong acceleration of primary photosynthetic electron transfer in a mutated reaction center of Rhodopseudomonas viridis. J Phys Chem 100: 12060–12065 Arlt T, Dohse B, Schmidt S, Wachtveitl J, Laussermaier E, Zinth W and Oesterhelt D (1996b) Electron transfer dynamics of Rhodopseudomonas viridis reaction centers with a modified binding site for the accessory bacteriochlorophyll. Biochemistry 35: 9235–9244 Bader JS, Kuharski RA and Chandler D (1990) Role of nuclear tunneling in aqueous ferrous-ferric electron transfer. J Chem Phys 93: 230–236 Becker M, Nagarajan V, Middendorf D, Parson WW, Martin JE and Blankenship RE (1991) Temperature dependence of the initial electron-transfer kinetics in photosynthetic reaction centers of Chloroflexus aurantiacus. Biochim Biophys Acta 1057: 299–312 Beekman LMP, van Stokkum IHM, Monshouwer R, Rijnders AJ, McGlynn P, Visschers RW, Jones MR and van Grondelle R (1996) Primary electron transfer in membrane-bound reaction centers with mutations at the M210 position. J Phys Chem 100: 7256–7268 Bixon M and Jortner J (1968) Intramolecular radiationless transitions. J Chem Phys 48: 715–726 Bixon M and Jortner J (1986) Coupling of protein modes to electron transfer in bacterial photosynthesis. J Phys Chem 90: 3795–3800 Bixon M and Jortner J (1999) Electron transfer. From isolated molecules to biomolecules. Adv Chem Phys 106: 35–202 Bixon M, Jortner J and Michel-Beyerle ME (1995) A kinetic analysis of the primary charge separation in bacterial photosynthesis. Energy gaps and static heterogeneity. Chem Phys 197: 389–404 Bixon M, Jortner J and Michel-Beyerle ME (1996) Energetics of the primary charge separation in bacterial photosynthesis. In: Michel-Beyerle ME (ed) The Reaction Center of Photosynthetic Bacteria: Structure and Dynamics, pp 287–296. Springer-Verlag, Berlin Blankenship RE, Schaafsma TJ and Parson WW (1977) Magnetic field effects on radical-pair intermediates in bacterial photosynthesis. Biochim Biophys Acta 461: 297–305 Blomberg MRA, Siegbahn PHM and Babcock GT (1998) Modeling electron transfer in biochemistry: A quantum chemical study of charge separation in Rhodobacter sphaeroides and photosystem II. J Am Chem Soc 120: 8812–8824 Blum K (1996) Density Matrix Theory and Applications. Plenum Press, New York Boxer SG, Chidsey ED and Roelofs MG (1983) Magnetic field effects on reaction yields in the solid state: An example from photosynthetic reaction centers. Ann Rev Phys Chem 34: 389–417 Boxer SG, Goldstein RA, Lockhart DJ, Middendorf TR and Takiff L (1989) Excited states, electron-transfer reactions, and intermediates in bacterial photosynthetic reaction centers. J Phys Chem 93: 8280–8294 Breton J, Martin J-L, Migus A, Antonetti A and Orszag A (1986) Femtosecond spectroscopy of excitation electron transfer and initial charge separation in the reaction center of the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodopseudomonas viridis. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 83: 5121–5175
371 Breton J, Martin J-L, Fleming GR and Lambry J-C (1988) Low temperature femtosecond spectroscopy of the initial step of electron transfer in reaction centers from photosynthetic purple bacteria. Biochemistry 27: 8276–8284 Bylina EJ, Kirmaier C, McDowell L, Holten D and Youvan DC (1988) Influence of an amino-acid residue on the optical properties and electron transfer dynamics of a photosynthetic reaction centre complex. Nature 336: 182–184 Ceccarelli M and Marchi M (2003) Simulation and modeling of the Rhodobacter sphaeroides bacterial reaction center II: Primary charge separation. J Phys Chem B 107: 5630–5641 Chan CK, DiMagno TJ, Chen LXQ, Norris JR and Fleming GR (1991a) Mechanism of the initial charge separation in bacterial photosynthetic reaction centers. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 88: 11202–11206 Chan CK, Chen LXQ, Dimagno TJ, Hanson DK, Nance SL, Schiffer M, Norris JR and Fleming GR (1991b) Mechanism of the initial charge separation in photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers. Chem Phys Lett 176: 366–372 Chidsey CED, Takiff L, Goldstein RA and Boxer SG (1985) Effect of magnetic fields on the triplet state lifetime in photosynthetic reaction centers: Evidence for thermal repopulation of the initial radical pair. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 82: 6850–6854 Chuang JI, Boxer SG, Holten D and Kirmaier C (2006) High yield of M-side electron transfer in mutants of Rhodobacter capsulatus reaction centers lacking the L-side bacteriopheophytin. Biochemistry 45: 3845–3851 Churg AK and Warshel A (1985) Modeling the activation energy and dynamics of electron transfer reactions in proteins. In: Clementi E, Corongiu G, Sarma MH and Sarma RH (ed) Structure and Motion: Membranes, Nucleic Acids and Proteins, pp 361. Adenine Press, Guilderland, NY Creighton S, Hwang J-K, Warshel A, Parson WW and Norris J (1988) Simulating the dynamics of the primary charge separation process in bacterial photosynthesis. Biochemistry 27: 774–781 Czarnecki K, Chynwat V, Erickson JP, Frank HA and Bocian DF (1997) Characterization of the strongly coupled, low-frequency vibrational modes of the special pair of photosynthetic reaction centers via isotopic labeling of the cofactors. J Am Chem Soc 119: 415–426 Czarnecki K, Kirmaier C, Holten D and Bocian DF (1999) Vibrational and photochemical consequences of an Asp residue near the photoactive accessory bacteriochlorophyll in the photosynthetic reaction center. J Phys Chem A 103: 2235 –2246 Davidson ER (1976) Reduced Density Matrices in Quantum Chemistry. Academic Press, London de Boer AL, Neerken S, de Wijn R, Permentier HP, Gast P, Vijgenboom E and Hoff AJ (2002a) High yield of B-branch electron transfer in a quadruple reaction center mutant of the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 41: 3081–3088 de Boer AL, Neerken S, de Wijn R, Permentier HP, Gast P, Vijgenboom E and Hoff AJ (2002b) B-branch electron transfer in reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides assessed with site-directed mutagenesis. Photosynth Res 71: 221–239 Du M, Rosenthal SJ, Xie X, DiMagno TJ, Schmidt M, Hanson DK, Schiffer M, Norris JR and Fleming GR (1992) Femtosecond spontaneous emission studies of reaction centers from photosynthetic bacteria. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA: 8517–8521 Egger R and Mak CH (1994) Dissipative three-state system and
372 the primary electron transfer in the bacterial photosynthetic reaction center. J Phys Chem 98: 9903–9918 Ermler U, Fritzsch G, Buchanan SK and Michel H (1994) Structure of the photosynthetic reaction centre from Rhodobacter sphaeroides at 2.65 Å resolution: Cofactors and protein-cofactor interactions. Structure 2: 925–936 Figueirido F, Del Buono GS and Levy RM (1997) On the finite size corrections to the free energy of ionic hydration. J Phys Chem B 101: 5622–5623 Finkele U, Lauterwasser C, Zinth W, Gray KA and Oesterhelt D (1990) Role of tyrosine M210 in the initial charge separation of reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 29: 8517–8521 Fleming GR, Martin J-L and Breton J (1988) Rates of primary electron transfer in photosynthetic reaction centers and their mechanistic implications. Nature 333: 190–192 Garg A, Onuchic JN and Ambegaokar B (1985) Effect of friction on electron transfer in macromolecules. J Chem Phys 83: 4491–4503 Gehlen JN, Marchi M and Chandler D (1994) Dynamics affecting the primary charge-transfer in photosynthesis. Science 263: 499–502 Gilson MK, Rashin A, Fine R and Honig B (1985) On the calculation of electrostatic interactions in proteins. J Mol Biol 184: 503–516 Godik VI and Borisov AY (1979) Short-lived delayed luminescence of photosynthetic organisms. I. Nanosecond afterglows in purple bacteria at low temperatures. Biochim Biophys Acta 548: 296–308 Godik VI, Kotova EA and Borisov AY (1982) Nanosecond recombination luminescence of purple bacteria. The lifetime temperature dependence in Rhodospirillum rubrum chromatophores. Photobiochem Photobiophys 4: 219–226 Goldstein RA and Boxer SG (1988) The effect of very high magnetic fields on the reaction dynamics in bacterial reaction centers: Implications for the reaction mechanism. Biochim Biophys Acta 977: 70–77 Gray HB and Winkler JR (1996) Electron transfer in proteins. Ann Rev Biochem 65: 537–561 Gunner MR and Dutton PL (1989) Temperature and -∆Go dependence of the electron transfer from BPh• – to QA in reaction center protein from Rhodobacter sphaeroides with different quinones as QA. J Am Chem Soc 111: 3400–3412 Gunner M, Nichols A and Honig B (1996) Electrostatic potentials in Rhodopseudomonas viridis reaction centers: Implications for the driving force and directionality of electron transfer. J Phys Chem 100: 4277–4291 Haberkorn R and Michel-Beyerle ME (1979) On the mechanism of magnetic field effects in bacterial photosynthesis. Biophys J 26: 489–498 Haffa ALM, Lin S, Katilius E, Williams JC, Taguchi AKW, Allen JP and Woodbury NW (2002) The dependence of the initial electron-transfer rate on driving force in Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centers. J Phys Chem B 106: 7376–7384 Haffa ALM, Lin S, Williams JC, Bowen BP, Taguchi AKW, Allen JP and Woodbury NW (2004) Controlling the pathway of photosynthetic charge separation in bacterial reaction centers. J Phys Chem B 108: 4–7 Hamm P and Zinth W (1995) Ultrafast initial reaction in bacterial photosynthesis revealed by femtosecond infrared spectroscopy. J Phys Chem 99: 13537–13544
William W. Parson and Arieh Warshel Hamm P, Gray KA, Oesterhelt D, Feik R, Scheer H and Zinth W (1993) Subpicosecond emission studies of bacterial reaction centers. Biochim Biophys Acta 1142: 90–105 Hartwich G, Lossau H, Michel-Beyerle ME and Ogrodnik A (1998) Nonexponential fluorescence decay in reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides reflecting dispersive charge separation up to 1 ns. J Phys Chem B 102: 3815–3820 Hasegawa J and Nakatsuji H (1998) Mechanism and unidirectionality of the electron transfer in the photosynthetic reaction center of Rhodopseudomonas viridis: SAC-CI theoretical study. J Phys Chem B 102: 10420–10430 Heller BA, Holten D and Kirmaier C (1995) Control of electron transfer between the L- and M-sides of the photosynthetic reaction center. Science 269: 940–945 Heller BA, Holten D and Kirmaier C (1996) Effects of Asp residues near the L-side pigments in bacterial reaction centers. Biochemistry 35: 15418–15427 Hoff AJ (1981) Magnetic field effects on photosynthetic reaction centers. Quart Rev Biophys 14: 599–665 Holten D, Windsor MW, Parson WW and Thornber JP (1978) Primary photochemical processes in isolated reaction centers of Rhodopseudomonas viridis. Biochim Biophys Acta 501: 112–126 Holten D, Hoganson C, Windsor MW, Schenck GC, Parson WW, Migus A, Fork RL and Shank CV (1980) Subpicosecond and picosecond studies of electron transfer intermediates in Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides reaction centers. Biochim Biophys Acta 592: 461–477 Holzapfel W, Finkele U, Kaiser W, Oesterhelt D, Scheer H, Stilz HU and Zinth W (1989) Observation of a bacteriochlorophyll anion radical during the primary charge separation in a reaction center. Chem Phys Lett 160: 1–7 Holzapfel W, Finkele U, Kaiser W, Oesterhelt D, Scheer H, Stilz HU and Zinth W (1990) Initial electron transfer in the reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 87: 5168–5172 Holzwarth AR and Muller MG (1996) Energetics and kinetics of radical pairs in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. A femtosecond transient absorption study. Biochemistry 35: 11820–11831 Hunenberger PH, Mark AE and van Gunsteren WF (1995) Fluctuation and cross-correlation analysis of protein motions observed in nanosecond molecular dynamics simulations. J Mol Biol 252: 492–503 Huppman P, Arlt T, Penzkofer H, Schmidt S, Bibikova M, Dohse B, Oesterhelt D, Wachtveit J and Zinth W (2002) Kinetics, energetics, and electronic coupling of the primary electron transfer reactions in mutated reaction centers of Blastochloris viridis. Biophys J 82: 3186–3197 Huppmann P, Sporlein S, Bibikova M, Oesterhelt D, Wachtveitl J and Zinth W (2003) Electron transfer in reaction centers of Blastochloris viridis: Photosynthetic reactions approximating the adiabatic regime. J Phys Chem A 107: 8302–8309 Hwang J-K and Warshel A (1987) Microscopic examination of free energy relationships for electron transfer in polar solvents. J Am Chem Soc 109: 715–720 Hwang J-K and Warshel A (1997) On the relationship between the dispersed polaron and spin-boson models. Chem Phys Lett 271: 223–225 Hwang J-K, Creighton S, King G, Whitney D and Warshel A (1988) Effects of solute-solvent coupling and solvent saturation
Chapter 19
Mechanism of Charge Separation
on solvation dynamics of charge transfer reactions. J Chem Phys 89: 859–865 Hörber JKH, Göbel W, Ogrodnik A, Michel-Beyerle M-E and Cogdell RJ (1986) Time-resolved measurements of fluorescence from reaction centers of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. FEBS Lett 198: 273–278 Hughes JM, Hutter, MC, Reimers JR and Hush NS (2001) Modeling the bacterial photosynthetic reaction center. 4. The structure, electrochemical, and hydrogen-bonding properties of 22 mutants of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Am Chem Soc 123: 8550–8563 Ivashin N and Larsson S (2002) Vibrational mechanism for primary charge separation in the reaction center of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Phys Chem B 106: 3996–4009 Ivashin N, Källenbring B, Larsson S and Hansson Ö (1998) Charge separation in photosynthetic reaction centers. J Phys Chem B 102: 5017–5022 Jean JM and Fleming GR (1995) Competition between energy and phase relaxation in electronic curve crossing processes. J Chem Phys 103: 2092–2101 Jean JM, Friesner RA and Fleming GR (1992) Application of a multilevel Redfield theory to electron-transfer in condensed phases. J Chem Phys 96: 5827–5842 Jia Y, DiMagno TJ, Chan C-K, Wang Z, Du M, Hanson DK, Schiffer M, Norris JR, Fleming GR and Popov MS (1993) Primary charge separation in mutant reaction centers of Rhodobacter capsulatus. J Phys Chem 97: 13180–13191 Johnson ET, Nagarajan V, Zazubovich V, Riley K, Small GJ and Parson WW (2003) Effects of ionizable residues on the absorption spectrum and initial electron-transfer kinetics in the photosynthetic reaction center of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 42: 13673–13683 Johnson SG, Tang D, Jankowiak R, Hayes JM, Small GJ and Tiede DM (1990) Primary donor state mode structure and energy transfer in bacterial reaction centers. J Phys Chem 94: 5849–5855 Katilius E, Turanchik T, Lin S, Taguchi AKW and Woodbury NW (1999) B-side electron transfer in a Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction center mutant in which the B-side monomer bacteriochlorophyll is replaced with bacteriopheophytin. J Phys Chem B 103: 7386–7389 Katilius E, Katiliene Z, Lin S, Taguchi AKW and Woodbury NW (2002) B-side electron transfer in the HE(M182) reaction center mutant from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Phys Chem B 106: 12344–12350 Katilius E, Babendure JL, Lin S and Woodbury NW (2004) Electron transfer dynamics in Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction center mutants with a modified ligand for the monomer bacteriochlorophyll on the active side. Photosynth Res 81: 165–180 Kaufmann KJ, Petty KM, Dutton PL and Rentzepis PM (1975) Picosecond kinetics of events leading to reaction center bacteriochlorophyll oxidation. Science 188: 1301–1304 Kellog EC, Kolaczkowski S, Wasielewski MR and Tiede DM (1989) Measurement of the extent of electron transfer to the bacteriopheophytin in the M-subunit in reaction centers of Rhodopseudomonas viridis. Photosynth Res 22: 47–59 Kennis JT, Shkuropatov AY, van Stokkum IHM, Gast P, Hoff AJ, Shuvalov VA and Aartsma TJ (1997) Formation of a long-lived P+BA– state in plant pheophytin-exchanged reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides R26 at low temperature. Biochemistry
373 36: 16231–16238 Kestner NR, Logan J and Jortner J (1974) Thermal electron transfer reactions in polar solvents. J Phys Chem 78: 2148–2166 King BA, de Winter A, McAnaney T and Boxer SG (2001) Excited state energy transfer pathways in photosynthetic reaction centers. 4. Asymmetric energy transfer in the heterodimer mutant. J Phys Chem B 105: 1856–1862 Kirmaier C and Holten D (1988) Subpicosecond spectroscopy of charge separation in Rhodobacter capsulatus reaction centers. Israel J Chem 28: 79–85 Kirmaier C and Holten D (1990) Evidence that a distribution of bacterial reaction centers underlies the temperature and detection-wavelength dependence of the rates of the primary electron transfer reactions. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 87: 3552–3556 Kirmaier C, Holten D and Parson WW (1985a) Picosecond photodichroism studies of the transient states in Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides reaction centers at 5 K: effects of electron transfer on the six bacteriochlorin pigments. Biochim Biophys Acta 810: 49–61 Kirmaier C, Holten D and Parson WW (1985b) Temperature and detection-wavelength dependence of the picosecond electron-transfer kinetics measured in Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides reaction centers. Resolution of new spectral and kinetic components in the primary charge-separation process. Biochim Biophys Acta 810: 33–48 Kirmaier C, Laporte L, Schenck CC and Holten D (1995a) The nature and dynamics of the charge-separated intermediate in reaction centers in which bacteriochlorophyll replaces the photoactive bacteriopheophytin. 1. Spectral characterization of the transient state. J Phys Chem 99: 8903–8909 Kirmaier C, Laporte L, Schenck CC and Holten D (1995b) The nature and dynamics of the charge-separated intermediate in reaction centers in which bacteriochlorophyll replaces the photoactive bacteriopheophytin. 2. The rates and yields of charge separation and recombination. J Phys Chem 99: 8910–8917 Kirmaier C, Weems D and Holten D (1999) M-side electron transfer in reaction center mutants with a lysine near the nonphotoactive B bacteriochlorophyll. Biochemistry 38: 11516–11530 Kirmaier C, He C and Holten D (2001) Manipulating the direction of electron transfer in the bacterial reaction center by swapping Phe for Tyr near BChlM (L181) and Tyr for Phe near BChlL (M208). Biochemistry 40: 12132–12139 Kirmaier C, Laible PD, Czarnecki K, Hata AN, Hanson DK, Bocian DF and Holten D (2002) Comparison of M-side electron transfer in Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus reaction centers. J Phys Chem B 106: 1799–1808 Kirmaier C, Laible PD, Hanson DK and Holten D (2004) B-side electron transfer to form P+HB– in reaction centers from the F(L181)Y/Y(M208)F mutant of Rhodobacter capsulatus. J Phys Chem B 108: 11827–11832 Kitzing E and Kühn H (1990) Primary electron transfer in photosynthetic reaction centers. J Phys Chem 94: 1699–1702 Kolbasov D and Scherz A (1998) Matrix elements play a significant role in asymetric electron transfer in bacterial reaction centers. In: Garab G (ed) Photosynthesis: Mechanisms and Effects, Vol II, pp 719–722. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Kolbasov D and Scherz A (2000) Asymmetric electron transfer in reaction centers of purple bacteria strongly depends on different electron matrix elements in the active and inactive branches. J Phys Chem B 104: 1802–1809
374 Kubo R (1966) The fluctuation-dissipation theorem. Rept Progr Theor Phys 29: 255–284 Kubo R and Toyozawa Y (1955) Application of the method of generating function to radiative and non-radiative transitions of a trapped electron in a crystal. Prog Theor Phys 13: 160–182 Lauterwasser C, Finkele U, Scheer. H and Zinth W (1991) Temperature dependence of the primary electron transfer in photosynthetic reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Chem Phys Lett 183: 471–477 Leggett AJ, Chakravarty S, Dorsey AT, Fisher MPA, Garg A and Zwerger W (1987) Dynamics of the dissipative two-state system. Rev Mod Phys 59: 1–85 Lin S, Taguchi AKW and Woodbury NW (1996a) Excitation wavelength dependence of energy transfer and charge separation in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Evidence for adiabatic electron transfer. J Phys Chem 100: 17067–17078 Lin S, Xiao W, Eastman JE, Taguchi AKW and Woodbury NW (1996b) Low-temperature femtosecond-resolution transient absorption spectroscopy of large-scale symmetry mutants of bacterial reaction centers. Biochemistry 35: 3187–3196 Lin S, Jackson JA, Taguchi AKW and Woodbury NW (1999) B-side electron transfer promoted by absorbance of multiple photons in Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26 reaction centers. J Phys Chem B 103: 4757 –4763 Lin S, Katilius E, Haffa ALM, Taguchi AKW and Woodbury NW (2001) Blue light drives B-side electron transfer in bacterial photosynthetic reaction centers. Biochemistry 40: 13767 –13773 Lyle PA, Kolaczkowski SV and Small GJ (1993) Photochemical hole-burned spectra of protonated and deuterated reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. J Phys Chem 97: 6924–6933 Mar T and Gingras G (1990) Relative phototrapping rates of the two bacteriopheophytins in the photoreaction center of Ectothiorhodospira sp. Biochim Biophys Acta 1017: 112–117 Marchi M, Gehlen JN, Chandler D and Newton M (1993) Diabatic surfaces and the pathway for primary electron transfer in a photosynthetic reaction center. J Am Chem Soc 115: 4178–4190 Marcus RA (1956) On the theory of oxidation-reduction reactions involving electron-transfer. I. J Chem Phys 24: 966–978 Marcus RA (1964) Chemical and electrochemical electron transfer theory. Ann Rev Phys Chem 15: 155–196 Marcus RA (1993) Electron-transfer reactions in chemistry— theory and experiment (Nobel lecture). Angew Chem Int Ed Engl 32: 1111–1121 Martin J-L, Breton J, Hoff AJ, Migus A and Antonetti A (1986) Femtosecond spectroscopy of electron transfer in the reaction center of the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides R-26: Direct electron transfer from the dimeric bacteriochlorophyll primary donor to the bacteriopheophytin acceptor with a time constant of 2.8 ± 0.2 psec. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 83: 957–961 Martin J-L and Vos MH (1992) Femtosecond biology. Ann Rev Biophys Biomol Struct 21: 199–222 Mercer IP, Gould IR and Klug DR (1999) A quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical approach to relaxation dynamics: Calculation of the optical properties of solvated bacteriochlorophyll-a. J Phys Chem B 103: 7720–7727 Middendorf TR, Mazzola LT, Gaul DF, Schenck CC and Boxer SG (1991) Photochemical hole-burning spectroscopy of a
William W. Parson and Arieh Warshel photosynthetic reaction center mutant with altered charge separation kinetics: Properties and decay of the initially excited state. J Phys Chem 95: 10142–10151 Miller WH and George TF (1972) Semiclassical theory of electronic transitions in low energy atomic and molecular collisions involving several nuclear degrees of freedom. J Chem Phys 56: 5637–5652 Moser CC, Keske JM, Warncke K, Farid RS and Dutton PL (1992) Nature of biological electron transfer. Nature 355: 796–802 Murchison HA, Alden RG, Allen JP, Peloquin JM, Taguchi AK, Woodbury NW and Williams JC (1993) Mutations designed to modify the environment of the primary electron donor of the reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Phenylalanine to leucine at L167 and histidine to phenylalanine at L168. Biochemistry 32: 3498–3505 Nagarajan V, Parson WW, Gaul D and Schenck C (1990) Effect of directed mutations of the tyrosine at site (M)210 on the primary photosynthetic electron transfer process in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 87: 7888–7892 Nagarajan V, Parson WW, Davis D and Schenck CC (1993) Kinetics and free energy gaps of electron-transfer reactions in Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centers. Biochemistry 32: 12324–12336 Newton MD (2003) Electronic coupling in electron transfer and the influence of nuclear modes: theoretical and computational probes. Theor Chem Acc 110: 307–321 Ogrodnik A (1990) The free energy difference between the excited primary donor 1P* and the radical pair state P+H– in reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochim Biophys Acta 1020: 65–71 Ogrodnik A, Volk M, Letterer R, Feik R and Michel-Beyerle M-E (1988) Determination of free energies in reaction centers of Rb. sphaeroides. Biochim Biophys Acta 936: 361–371 Ogrodnik A, Keupp W, Volk M, Auermeier G and Michel-Beyerle ME (1994) Inhomogeneity of radical pair energies in photosynthetic reaction centers revealed by differences in recombination dynamics of P+HA– when detected in delayed emission and in absorption. J Phys Chem 98: 3432–3439 Ogrodnik A, Hartwich G, Lossau H and Michel-Beyerle ME (1999) Dispersive charge separation and conformational cooling of P+HA– in reaction centers of Rb. sphaeroides R26: A spontaneous emission study. Chem Phys 244: 461–478 Okada A (2000) Qualitative features of electron transfer reaction for high viscosity of solvent and low activation barrier. J Phys Chem A 104: 7744–7750 Parson WW and Warshel A (2004a) A density-matrix model of photosynthetic electron transfer with microscopically estimated vibrational relaxation times. Chem Phys 296: 201–206 Parson WW and Warshel A (2004b) Dependence of photosynthetic electron-transfer kinetics on temperature and energy in a density-matrix model. J Phys Chem B 108: 10474–10483 Parson WW and Warshel A (2006) Calculations of electrostatic energies in proteins using microscopic, semimicroscopic and macroscopic models and free-energy perturbation approaches. In: Aartsma TJ and Matysik J (eds) Biophysical Techniques in Photosynthesis, Vol 2. in press. Springer, Dordrecht Parson WW, Clayton RK and Cogdell RJ (1975) Excited states of photosynthetic reaction centers at low redox potentials. Biochim Biophys Acta 387: 265–278 Parson WW, Creighton S and Warshel A (1987) Calculations of spectroscopic properties and electron transfer kinetics of
Chapter 19
Mechanism of Charge Separation
photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers. In: Kobayashi T (ed) Primary Processes in Photobiology, pp 43–51. SpringerVerlag, Berlin Parson WW, Chu ZT and Warshel A (1990) Electrostatic control of charge separation in bacterial photosynthesis. Biochim Biophys Acta 1017: 251–272 Parson WW, Chu ZT and Warshel A (1998) Reorganization energy of the initial electron-transfer step in photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers. Biophys J 74: 182–191 Paschenko VZ, Korvatovskii BN, Kononenko AA, Chamorovsky SK and Rubin AB (1985) Estimation of the rate of photochemical charge separation in Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides reaction centers by fluorescence and absorption picosecond spectroscopy. FEBS Lett 191: 245–248 Peloquin JM, Williams JC, Lin X, Alden RG, Taguchi AKW, Allen JP and Woodbury NW (1994) Time-dependent thermodynamics during early electron transfer in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 33: 8089–8100 Peloquin JM, Lin S, Taguchi AKW and Woodbury NW (1995) Excitation wavelength dependence of bacterial reaction center photochemistry. 1. Ground state and excited state evolution. J Phys Chem 99: 1349–1356 Peloquin JM, Lin S, Taguchi AKW and Woodbury NW (1996) Excitation wavelength dependence of bacterial reaction center photochemistry. 2. Low-temperature measurements and spectroscopy of charge separation. J Phys Chem 100: 14228–14235 Pollard WT, Felts AK and Friesner RA (1996) The Redfield equation in condensed-phase quantum dynamics. Adv Chem Phys 93: 77–134 Procacci P, Darden TA, Paci E and Marchi M (1997) ORAC: A molecular dynamics program to simulate complex molecular systems with realistic electrostatic interactions. J Comp Chem 18: 1848–1862 Rademaker J and Hoff AJ (1981) The balance between primary forward and back reaction in bacterial photosynthesis. Biophys J 34: 325–344 Reddy NRS, Lyle PA and Small GJ (1992) Applications of spectral hole burning spectroscopies to antenna and reaction center complexes. Photosynth Res 31: 167–194 Redfield AG (1965) The theory of relaxation processes. Adv Magn Res 1: 1–32 Rips I and Jortner J (1988) Activationless solvent-controlled electron transfer. J Chem Phys 88: 818–822 Rischel C, Spiedel D, Ridge JP, Jones MR, Breton J, Lambry JC, Martin J-L and Vos MH (1998) Low frequency vibrational modes in proteins: Changes induced by point-mutations in the protein-cofactor matrix of bacterial reaction centers. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 95: 12306–12311 Roberts JA, Holten D and Kirmaier C (2001) Primary events in photosynthetic reaction centers with multiple mutations near the photoactive electron carriers. J Phys Chem B 105: 5575–5584 Robles SJ, Breton J and Youvan DC (1990a) Partial symmetrization of the photosynthetic reaction center. Science 248: 1402–1405 Robles SJ, Breton J and Youvan DC (1990b) Transmembrane helix exchanges between quasi-symmetric subunits of the photosynthetic reaction center. In: Michel-Beyerle M-E (ed) Reaction Centers of Photosynthetic Bacteria, pp 283–291. Springer, Berlin
375 Rockley MG, Windsor MW, Cogdell RJ and Parson WW (1975) Picosecond detection of an intermediate in the photochemical reaction of bacterial photosynthesis. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 72: 2251–2255 Sarai A (1980) Possible role of protein in photosynthetic electron transfer. Biochim Biophys Acta 589: 71–82 Schenck CC, Parson WW, Holten D, Windsor MW and Sarai A (1981) Temperature dependence of electron transfer between bacteriopheophytin and ubiquinone in protonated and deuterated reaction centers of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. Biophys J 36: 479–489 Schenck CC, Blankenship RE and Parson WW (1982) Radical-pair decay kinetics, triplet yields, and delayed fluorescence from bacterial reaction centers. Biochim Biophys Acta 680: 44–59 Scherer POJ and Fischer SF (1989) Long-range electron transfer within the hexamer of the photosynthetic reaction center Rhodopseudomonas viridis. J Phys Chem 93: 1633–1637 Scherer POJ and Fischer SF (1998) Charge transfer states of the reaction center. Spectrochim Acta A 54A: 1191–1199 Schmidt S, Arlt T, Hamm P, Huber H, Naegele T, Wachtveitl J, Meyer M, Scheer H and Zinth W (1994) Energetics of the primary electron transfer reaction revealed by ultrafast spectroscopy on modified bacterial reaction centers. Chem Phys Lett 223: 116–120 Schmidt S, Arlt T, Hamm P, Huber H, Nägele T, Wachtveitl J, Meyer M, Scheer H and Zinth W (1995) Primary electron-transfer dynamics in modified bacterial reaction centers containing pheophytin-a instead of bacteriopheophytin-a. Spectrochim Acta A 51A: 1565–1578 Schulten K and Tesch M (1991) Coupling of protein motion to electron transfer: Molecular dynamics and stochastic quantum mechanics study of photosynthetic reaction centers. Chem Phys 158: 421–446 Sham YY and Warshel A (1998) The surface constrained all atom model provides size-independent results in calculations of hydration free energies. J Chem Phys 109: 7940–7944 Shkuropatov AY and Shuvalov VA (1993) Electron transfer in pheophytin a-modified reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides (R-26). FEBS Lett 322: 168–172 Shochat S, Arlt T, Francke C, Gast P, van Noort PI, Otte SC, Schelvis HPM, Schmidt S, Vijgenboom E, Vrieze J, Zinth W and Hoff AJ (1994) Spectroscopic characterization of reaction centers of the (M)Y210W mutant of the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Photosynth Res 40: 55–66 Shuvalov VA and Klimov VV (1976) The primary photoreactions in the complex cytochrome-P-890 . P-760 (bacteriopheophytin760) of Chromatium minutissimum at low redox potentials. Biochim Biophys Acta 440: 587–599 Shuvalov VA and Parson WW (1980) Energies and kinetics of radical pairs involving bacteriochlorophyll and bacteriopheophytin in bacterial reaction centers. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 78: 957–961 Shuvalov VA and Yakovlev AG (2003) Coupling of nuclear wavepacket motion and charge separation in bacterial reaction centers. FEBS Lett 540: 26–34 Sim E and Makri N (1997) Path integral simulation of charge transfer dynamics in photosynthetic reaction centers. J Phys Chem B 101: 5446 –5458 Skourtis SS, Balabin IA, Kawatsu T and Beratan DN (2005) Protein dynamics and electron transfer: Electronic decoherence and non-Condon effects. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 102:
376 3552–3557 Slichter CP (1963) Principles of Magnetic Resonance with Examples from Solid State Physics. Harper & Row, New York Small GJ (1995) On the validity of the standard model for primary charge separation in the bacterial reaction center. Chem Phys 197: 239–257 Small GJ, Hayes JM and Silbey RJ (1992) The question of dispersive kinetics for the initial phase of charge separation in bacterial reaction centers. J Phys Chem 96: 7499–7501 Spörlein S, Zinth W and Wachtveitl J (1998) Vibrational coherence in photosynthetic reaction centers observed in the bacteriochlorophyll anion band. J Phys Chem B 102: 7492–7496 Spörlein S, Zinth W, Meyer M, Scheer H and Wachtveitl J (2000) Primary electron transfer in modified bacterial reaction centers: Optimization of the first events in photosynthesis. Chem Phys Lett 322: 454–464 Stanley RJ and Boxer SG (1995) Oscillations in spontaneous fluorescence from photosynthetic reaction centers. J Phys Chem 99: 859–863 Steffen MA, Lao KQ and Boxer SG (1994) Dielectric asymmetry in the photosynthetic reaction center. Science 264: 810–816 Sumi H and Marcus RA (1986) Dynamical effects in electron transfer reactions. J Chem Phys 84: 4894–4914 Taguchi AKW, Stocker JW, Alden RG, Causgrove TP, Peloquin JM, Boxer SG and Woodbury NW (1992) Biochemical characterization and electron-transfer reactions of sym1, a Rhodobacter capsulatus reaction center symmetry mutant which affects the initial electron donor. Biochemistry 31: 10345–10355 Taguchi AKW, Eastman JE, Gallo DM, Sheagley E, Xiao W and Woodbury NW (1996) Asymmetry requirements in the photosynthetic reaction center of Rhodobacter capsulatus. Biochemistry 35: 3175–3186 Takiff L and Boxer SG (1988) Phosphorescence from the primary electron donor in Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Rhodopseudomonas viridis reaction centers. Biochim Biophys Acta 932: 325–334 Thompson MA, Zerner MC and Fajer J (1991) A theoretical examination of the electronic structure and spectroscopy of the photosynthetic reaction center from Rhodopseudomonas viridis. J Am Chem Soc 113: 8210–8215 Trissl HW, Breton J, Deprez J, Dobek A and Leibl W (1990) Trapping kinetics, annihilation and quantum yield in the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodopseudomonas viridis as revealed by electric measurement of the primary charge separation. Biochim Biophys Acta 1015: 322–333 Tully JC and Preston RM (1971) Trajectory surface hopping approach to nonadiabatic molecular collisions: The reaction of H+ with D2. J Chem Phys 55: 562–572 van Brederode ME, Jones MR, van Mourik F, van Stokkum IHM and van Grondelle R (1997) A new pathway for transmembrane electron transfer in photosynthetic reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides not involving the excited special pair. Biochemistry 36: 6855–6861 van Brederode ME, van Mourik F, van Stokkum IHM, Jones MR and van Grondelle R (1999) Multiple pathways for ultrafast transduction of light energy in the photosynthetic reaction center of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 96: 2054–2059 van Stokkum IHM, Beekman LMP, Jones MR, van Brederode ME and van Grondelle R (1997) Primary electron transfer kinetics in membrane-bound Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centers:
William W. Parson and Arieh Warshel A global and target analysis. Biochemistry 36: 11360–11368 Volk M, Aumeier G, Langenbacher T, Feick R, Ogrodnik A and Michel-Beyerle M-E (1998) Energetics and mechanism of primary charge separation in bacterial photosynthesis. A comparative study on reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Chloroflexus aurantiacus. J Phys Chem B 102: 735 –751 Vos M and Martin J-L (1999) Femtosecond processes in proteins. Biochim Biophys Acta 1411: 1–20 Vos MH, Lambry JC, Robles SJ, Youvan DC, Breton J and Martin J-L (1991) Direct observation of vibrational coherence in bacterial reaction centers using femtosecond absorption spectroscopy. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 88: 8885–8889 Vos MH, Lambry JC, Robles SJ, Youvan DC, Breton J and Martin J-L (1992) Femtosecond spectral evolution of the excited state of bacterial reaction centers at 10 K. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 89: 613–617 Vos MH, Rappaport F, Lambry J-H, Breton J and Martin J-L (1993) Visualization of coherent nuclear motion in a membrane protein by femtosecond spectroscopy. Nature 363: 320–325 Vos MH, Jones MR, Hunter CN, Breton J and Martin J-L (1994a) Coherent nuclear dynamics at room temperature in bacterial reaction centers. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 91: 12701–12705 Vos MH, Jones MR, Hunter CN, Breton J, Lambry J-C and Martin J-L (1994b) Coherent dynamics during the primary electron-transfer reaction in membrane-bound reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 33: 6750–6757 Vos MH, Jones MR, Breton J, Lambry JC and Martin J-L (1996) Vibrational dephasing of long- and short-lived primary donor excited states in mutant reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 35: 2687–2692 Vos MH, Rischel C, Jones MR and Martin J-L (2000) Electrochromic detection of a coherent component in the formation of the charge pair P+HL– in bacterial reaction centers. Biochemistry 39: 8353 –8361 Wakeham MC and Jones MR (2005) Rewiring photosynthesis: Engineering wrong-way electron transfer in the purple bacterial reaction center. Biochem Soc Trans 133: 851–857 Walsh AM and Coalson RD (1992) Redfield theory is quantitative for coupled harmonic oscillators. Chem Phys Lett 198: 293–299 Wang HW, Lin S, Allen JP, Williams JC, Blankert S, Laser C and Woodbury NW (2007) Protein dynamics control the kinetics of initial electron transfer in photosynthesis. Science 316: 747–750 Wang Z, Pearlstein RM, Jia Y, Fleming GR and Norris JR (1993) Inhomogeneous electron-transfer kinetics in reaction centers of bacterial photosynthesis. Chem Phys 176: 421–425 Warshel A (1982) Dynamics of reactions in polar solvents. Semiclassical trajectory studies of electron-transfer and protontransfer reactions. J Phys Chem 86: 2218–2224 Warshel A and Hwang J-K (1986) Simulation of the dynamics of electron transfer reactions in polar solvents: semiclassical trajectories and dispersed polaron approaches. J Chem Phys 84: 4938–4957 Warshel A and Parson WW (1991) Computer simulations of electron transfer reactions in solution and photosynthetic reaction centers. Ann Rev Phys Chem 42: 279–309 Warshel A and Parson WW (2001) Dynamics of biochemical and biophysical reactions: insight from computer simulations. Quart Rev Biophys 34: 563–679 Warshel A and Russell ST (1984) Calculations of electrostatic
Chapter 19
Mechanism of Charge Separation
interactions in biological systems and in solutions. Quart Rev Biophys 17: 283–290 Warshel A, Creighton S and Parson WW (1988) Electron-transfer pathways in the primary event of bacterial photosynthesis. J Phys Chem 92: 2698–2701 Warshel A, Chu ZT and Parson WW (1989) Dispersed polaron simulations of electron transfer in photosynthetic reaction centers. Science 246: 112–116 Warshel A, Sharma PK, Kato M and Parson WW (2006) Modeling electrostatic effects in proteins. Biochim Biophys Acta 1764: 1647–1676 Wasielewski MR and Tiede DM (1986) Sub-picosecond measurements of primary electron transfer in Rhodopseudomonas viridis reaction centers using near-infrared excitation. FEBS Lett 204: 368–372 Williams JC, Alden RG, Murchison HA, Peloquin JM, Woodbury NW and Allen JP (1992) Effects of mutations near the bacteriochlorophylls in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 31: 11029–11037 Woodbury NWT and Parson WW (1984) Nanosecond fluorescence from isolated reaction centers of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. Biochim Biophys Acta 767: 345–361 Woodbury NW, Becker M, Middendorf D and Parson WW (1985) Picosecond kinetics of the initial photochemical electrontransfer reaction in bacterial photosynthetic reaction centers. Biochemistry 24: 7516–7521 Woodbury NW, Parson WW, Gunner MR, Prince RC and Dutton PL (1986) Radical-pair energetics and decay mechanisms in reaction centers containing anthraquinones, naphthoquinones or benzoquinones in place of ubiquinone. Biochim Biophys Acta 851: 6–22 Woodbury NW, Peloquin JM, Alden RG, Lin X, Taguchi AKW, Williams JC and Allen JP (1994) Relationship between thermodynamics and mechanism during photoinduced charge separation in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 33: 8101–8112
377 Wraight CA and Clayton RK (1974) The absolute quantum efficiency of bacteriochlorophyll photooxidation in reaction centres of Rhodopseudomonas spheroides. Biochim Biophys Acta 333: 246–260 Yakovlev AG and Shuvalov VA (2000) Formation of bacteriochlorophyll anion band at 1020 nm produced by nuclear wavepacket motion in bacterial reaction centers. J Chin Chem Soc 47: 1–6 Yakovlev AG, Shkuropatov AC and Shuvalov AV (2000) Nuclear wavepacket motion producing a reversible charge separation in bacterial reaction centers. FEBS Lett 466: 209–212 Yakovlev AG, Shkuropatov AY and Shuvalov VA (2002) Nuclear wavepacket motion between P* and P+BA– potential surfaces with subsequent electron transfer to HA in bacterial reaction centers. 1. Room temperature. Biochemistry 41: 2667–2674 Yakovlev AG, Vasilieva LG, Shkuropatov AY, Bolgarina TI, Shkuropatova VA and Shuvalov VA (2003) Mechanism of charge separation and stabilization of separated charges in reaction centers of Chloroflexus aurantiacus and of YM210W(L) mutants of Rhodobacter sphaeroides excited by 20 fs pulses at 90 K. J Phys Chem A 107: 8330–8338 Zhang LY and Friesner RA (1998) Ab initio calculation of electronic coupling in the photosynthetic reaction center. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 95: 13603–13605 Zhou H and Boxer SG (1998a) Probing excited-state electron transfer by resonance Stark spectroscopy. 1. Experimental results for photosynthetic reaction centers. J Phys Chem B 102: 9139–9147 Zhou H and Boxer SG (1998b) Probing excited-state electron transfer by resonance Stark spectroscopy. 2. Theory and application. J Phys Chem B 102: 9148–9160 Zusman LD and Beratan DN (1998) Electron transfer in the photosynthetic reaction center: Mechanistic implications of mutagenesis studies. Spectrochim Acta A 54A: 1211–1218
Chapter 20 The Acceptor Quinones of Purple Photosynthetic Bacteria— Structure and Spectroscopy Colin A. Wraight* Department of Biochemistry, and Center for Biophysics & Computational Biology, University of Illinois, Urbana, IL 61801 U.S.A.
Marilyn R. Gunner Department of Physics, City College of New York, New York, NY 10031 U.S.A.
Summary ............................................................................................................................................................... 379 I. Introduction..................................................................................................................................................... 380 II. The Acceptor Quinone Reactions .................................................................................................................. 382 III. Structural Features of the Acceptor Quinone Binding Sites ........................................................................... 383 A. The Primary Quinone, QA ................................................................................................................ 384 1. The Methoxy Groups of QA .................................................................................................... 384 B. The Secondary Quinone, QB ........................................................................................................... 385 1. The Two QB Binding Sites Found in the X-ray Structures ....................................................... 387 2. The Methoxy Groups of QB .................................................................................................... 388 C. Hydrogen Bonding in the Quinone Binding Sites ............................................................................. 389 IV. Spectroscopy of the Acceptor Quinones ........................................................................................................ 389 A. The Primary Quinone, QA .................................................................................................... 390 B. The Reduced Primary Quinone, QA– ................................................................................................ 392 1. Magnetic Resonance Studies of QA– ....................................................................................... 393 2. Infra-red Spectroscopic Studies of QA– .................................................................................... 394 C. The Secondary Quinone, QB ........................................................................................................... 395 D. The Semireduced Secondary Quinone, QB– .................................................................................... 395 1. Magnetic Resonance Studies of QB– ....................................................................................... 395 2. Vibrational Spectroscopy of QB– .............................................................................................. 396 V. Functionality of the Two Quinone Positions in the QB Site ............................................................................. 396 VI. Conclusions .................................................................................................................................................... 398 Note Added in Proof .............................................................................................................................................. 398 Acknowledgments ................................................................................................................................................. 398 References ............................................................................................................................................................ 399
Summary Type II reaction centers (RCs) have two acceptor quinones that act in series. The primary quinone, QA, cycles between the oxidized quinone and singly reduced semiquinone. QA is tightly bound to the protein as a prosthetic group. The secondary quinone, QB, is reduced by QA–, first to the semiquinone and then to the doubly reduced, fully protonated quinol, QH2. QB freely associates with the protein in the quinone and quinol states. The prop*Author for correspondence, email: [email protected]
C. Neil Hunter, Fevzi Daldal, Marion C. Thurnauer and J. Thomas Beatty (eds): The Purple Phototrophic Bacteria, pp. 379–405. © 2009 Springer Science + Business Media B.V.
Colin A. Wraight and Marilyn R. Gunner
380
erties of the two quinones that facilitate this process are largely determined by the nature of the two quinone binding sites. Many reaction center crystal structures show these interactions, although there are significant uncertainties in the conformations of the two quinones, and in the significance of the variable location of QB in the protein. Consequently the influence of structure on quinone function is only very crudely understood. These issues are discussed with emphasis on the quinone reactions in the reaction center from the photosynthetic bacterium, Rhodobacter (Rba.) sphaeroides, which is the best characterized. The structural features of the quinones and their local protein environments are examined in the light of extensive spectroscopic studies, especially by Fourier transform infra-red spectroscopy (FTIR), electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR), on the quinones in their functional redox states. I. Introduction The initial events of photosynthesis, in plants and bacteria, consist of electron transfer from an excited state of (bacterio)chlorophyll, followed by stabilization of the separated charges. This is achieved with retention of a significant portion of the photon free energy. The reaction sequence occurs within a reaction center (RC), a membrane pigment-protein of varying complexity in different species but in all cases based on a homologous pattern of cofactors and protein arrangements with strong two-fold symmetry. There appear to be only two basic types of RC, defined by the nature of their terminal electron acceptor species — Type I and Type II (Heathcote et al., 2002). Type I RCs use iron sulfur complexes to transfer electrons from an intermediate acceptor quinone to a soluble ferredoxin, for export of reducing equivalents one at a time. They operate at low redox potentials and are found in green and brown sulfur bacteria (Chlorobiaceae, and Heliobacteriaceae), and in Photosystem I of oxygenic bacteria (Cyanobacteria) and plants. Type II RCs use the asymmetric function of two acceptor quinones to export reducing equivalents in pairs, as quinol. They operate at higher redox potentials and are found in all purple bacteria (sulfur-oxidizing Chromatiaceae and nonsulfur Rhodobacteraceae, etc), in green, filamentous bacteria (Chloroflexaceae), and in the water-oxidizing Photosystem II of oxygenic photosynthesis. In purple photosynthetic bacteria, the functional core of the RC complex is a heterodimer of similar, Abbreviations: BChl – bacteriochlorophyll; Bphe – bacteriopheophytin; Blc. – Blastochloris; DFT – density functional theory; ENDOR – Electron Nuclear Double Resonance; EPR – Electron Paramagnetic Resonance; FTIR – Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy; IR – infra-red; NMR – Nuclear Magnetic Resonance; QA,B – primary and secondary quinone acceptors; Rba. – Rhodobacter; RC – reaction center; UQ – ubiquinone (2,3-dimethoxy -5-methyl-6-isoprenyl-1,4-benzoquinone)
but non-identical, L and M subunits1 that bind all the active cofactors: four bacteriochlorophylls (BChl), two bacteriopheophytins (BPhe), two quinones and an iron atom. A third polypeptide, the H-subunit, contributes stability to the whole complex and is involved in proton (H+-ion) binding and transfer processes coupled to the electron transfer between the two quinones. The arrangement of cofactors and protein subunits is now well known from the X-ray structures of RC complexes from Blastochloris (Blc.) (formerly Rhodopseudomonas) viridis (Deisenhofer et al., 1985; Deisenhofer and Michel, 1989b, 1991; Lancaster and Michel, 1996a,b), Rba. sphaeroides (Allen et al., 1988; Chang et al., 1991; Ermler et al., 1994; Stowell et al., 1997), and Thermochromatium tepidum (Nogi et al., 2000) (Fig. 1). The A and B cofactor branches show a high degree of rotational (C2) symmetry, as do the surrounding L and M subunits, which also have substantial sequence homology. However, electron transfer from the primary donor, P, is not symmetrical and occurs exclusively via BChlA and BPheA on the L-subunit, to the primary quinone, QA, and then to the secondary quinone, QB. The function of Type II RCs (hereafter, just RC) is to produce fully reduced quinol (or hydroquinone, QH2), as a reductant to drive electron transfers in other membrane-bound enzymes. This results in the formation of an electrochemical gradient of protons across the membrane that drives the chemiosmotic processes of ATP synthesis, ion and substrate transport, flagellar rotation, and reversed electron transport. To produce quinol, the acceptor quinones of RCs, QA and QB, act in series to accumulate two reducing equivalents from the one-electron photoreactions, with two protons taken up from the aqueous solution on the cytoplasmic side of the membrane. After two RC turnovers, QH2 is released from the QB site, which is then refilled by an oxidized quinone to complete the 1
The L and M polypeptides that bind QA and QB are 33.9% identical in Rba. sphaeroides RCs (Williams et al., 1986)
Chapter 20
Acceptor Quinones of Purple Photosynthetic Bacteria
Fig. 1. The reaction center (RC) complex from Rhodobacter sphaeroides comprises three subunits, a heterodimer of similar, but non-identical L and M subunits, and subunit H, which caps LM on the cytosolic side of the membrane. The LM dimer binds all the cofactors, while subunit H stabilizes the structure and is involved in H+-ion uptake and transfer associated with electron transfer to the quinones. The L and M subunits and all associated cofactors are arranged around a quasi-2-fold rotational symmetry axis, normal to the plane of the membrane and passing through the primary donor (P), the special pair dimer of bacteriochlorophylls (BChl), and a ferrous (Fe2+) iron midway between the two quinones. Electron transfer proceeds from the excited singlet state of the primary donor (P*), via the A-branch of cofactors — monomer BChl (BA) and BPhe (HA), bound to the L subunit — to the primary quinone, QA, which is bound in a fold of the M subunit. From QA– the electron crosses the symmetry axis to the secondary quinone, QB, bound in a similar fold in the L subunit. (Figure prepared in VMD.) See also Color Plate 8, Fig. 12.
acceptor quinone cycle (reviewed in Okamura and Feher, 1992, 1995; Shinkarev and Wraight, 1993; Okamura et al., 2000; Paddock et al., 2003; Wraight, 2004, 2005) (Fig. 2). The reduction of quinone to quinol in the QB site relies on significant functional differences between the two quinones (Wraight, 1982, 2004; Shinkarev and Wraight, 1993). QA interfaces between the subnanosecond one-electron transfers needed for initial charge stabilization and the micro- to millisecond reduction of QB, where two electrons are accumulated to produce the stable product, QH2. QA is a tightly bound, one-electron redox couple, operating between the quinone and semiquinone forms, while QB is a reversibly bound, two-electron couple, with
381
Fig. 2. The acceptor quinone cycle of Type II reaction centers. Following each flash, an electron is transferred to the acceptor quinones. (The photooxidized primary donor, P+, is re-reduced by secondary donor (Cyt c2 in vivo in bacteria), and is omitted in the scheme). After the first flash, the anionic semiquinone charge induces pKa changes in some ionizable amino acid residues and H+ are taken up to the protein. This subsequently provides the 2nd proton, H+(2), transferred to QB, after the second flash. After a second flash, the transfer of the second electron from QA– only takes place after QB– has been protonated.
quinone, semiquinone and quinol states all involved in turnover. QA– reduces both the quinone and semiquinone in the QB site. Furthermore, in many species, including Rba. sphaeroides, QA and QB are chemically identical. For both reduction steps to be energetically favorable, significant alterations are required in the quinone physico-chemical properties compared to their behavior in solution. These distinct properties must be imparted by interactions with the protein in their respective binding sites. Thus, the structural and compositional symmetry of the RC, which extends to all the cofactors, contrasts with its functional asymmetry, making the RC a powerful model for studying the molecular basis of protein function. In this chapter, we summarize current knowledge of the structural features of the RC acceptor quinone complex, derived from X-ray crystallography and spectroscopy. We focus on the RC from Rba. sphaeroides, but some reference will be made to other species where useful comparisons can be made.
382
Colin A. Wraight and Marilyn R. Gunner
II. The Acceptor Quinone Reactions When the RC is activated by light, an electron is transferred in about 200 ps from the excited singlet state of the primary donor (P*), via BChlA and BPheA in the active path, to QA, and thence to QB, if available, in ≈100 µs (Fig. 3). Light activation generates the charge separated state, P+QA–, even at temperatures as low as 1 K (Arnold and Clayton, 1960) — and at a rate that is actually three-fold faster at cryogenic temperatures (Schenck et al., 1981; Woodbury et al., 1985; Kirmaier and Holten, 1990; Woodbury and Allen, 1995). Thus, the changes in protein and quinone conformation needed to form P+QA– can be accomplished in a frozen sample, without the full relaxation of the product that would occur at room temperature (McMahon et al., 1998; Xu and Gunner, 2000). The QA site has been shown to bind a wide range of quinones and quinonoid compounds, many of which reconstitute function, and such studies provided some of the first clues to the nature of the QA binding site (Okamura et al., 1975; Gunner et al., 1985, 1986; Woodbury et al., 1986; Warncke et al., 1987; Warncke and Dutton, 1993b; Labahn et al., 1995; Graige et al., 1998; Schmid et al., 1999; Hucke et al., 2002). For example, compounds as large as substituted anthraquinones are able to bind with good affinity, but double methyl-substitution at the 5 and 8 positions results in failure to bind (Gunner et al., 1985). Many non-quinone compounds also bind, even if functionally inactive, and reveal additional aspects of hydrogen bonding requirements of the QA site (Gunner et al., 1985; Warncke and Dutton, 1992, 1993a,b). Quinone reconstitution has also been used to vary the electrochemistry of QA, modifying the free energy of the QA dependent electron transfer reactions (see Fig. 3), including P+H–QA → P+HQA– (Gunner and Dutton, 1989), P+HQA– → PHQA (Gunner and Dutton, 1989; Franzen et al., 1990; Lin et al., 1994), P+HQA– QB → PHQAQB– (Li et al., 2000) and P+HQAQB– → PHQAQB (Allen et al., 1998; Schmid and Labahn, 2000), where H is the BPhe electron acceptor. Together with studies on mutant RCs, all of these reaction rates have been shown to vary as described by Marcus electron transfer theory (Gunner and Dutton, 1989; Moser et al., 1992; Lin et al., 1994; Schmid and Labahn, 2000). Thus, in these reactions, where the electron transfer process itself is rate determining, the rate is maximal at a free energy (–∆G°) equal to the reorganization
Fig. 3. Electron transfer pathways in Rba. sphaeroides reaction centers with no external electron donor, i.e., the fate of the first electron. Dashed lines show routes for the uphill thermal back reactions (charge recombination). Following light absorption, the singlet excited state of P (P*) reduces H, the A-branch bacteriopheophytin, in 3 ps. The electron is transferred to QA in 200 ps and then to QB in 5–200 µs. At each stage in the reaction cycle there are competing charge recombination reactions that transfer the electron back to P+. If there is no QA present, this will occur from H– in ≈10 ns (kHP is 7 × 107 s–1). Once the electron reaches the quinones it can return to P+ either by direct tunneling (kAP in P+QA– or kBP in P+QB– RCs) or via a thermal back reaction, e.g., kAHP is the rate of P+QA– charge recombination via P+H–QA, while kBAP represents the back reaction from P+QAQB– via P+QA–QB; the obs obs or kBP are the sum of the rates by all routes observed rates kAP (see Shinkarev, 1993 for a detailed description). In native RCs, the back reaction from UQA– (i.e., when there is no QB) occurs obs obs ≈ kAP is 10 s–1), and from UQB– in ≈1 s (kBP ≈ in ≈100 ms (kAP kBAP is 1 s–1).
energy, λ, and it slows as the driving force either increases or decreases (DeVault, 1980; Marcus, 1964; Marcus and Sutin, 1985; Moser et al., 1992). In contrast to QA, QB cannot easily be reconstituted by other quinones. Comparative studies indicate that the affinity of substituted benzoquinones and naphthoquinones bind to the QB site 7–30-fold weaker than to the QA site (McComb et al., 1990; Warncke et al., 1994; X. Zhang and M. R. Gunner, unpublished). In
Chapter 20
Acceptor Quinones of Purple Photosynthetic Bacteria
some part, the limited range of effective substitution is due to this weaker binding and the low solubility of many analogs of interest, but an important energetic constraint is also evident. No quinones other than ubiquinone (UQ – 2,3-dimethoxy-5-methyl6-isoprenyl-1,4-benzoquinone) and rhodoquinone (2-methoxy-3-amino-5-methyl-6-isoprenyl-1,4-benzoquinone) have been found to effectively replace both QA and QB function simultaneously in the same protein (McComb et al., 1990; Graige et al., 1999; X. Zhang and M. R. Gunner, unpublished). However, several studies have shown that replacing QA by a quinone with a midpoint potential (Em) lower than UQA reveals functional electron transfer to some non-native quinones as QB (Giangiacomo and Dutton, 1989; Graige et al., 1996; Li et al., 1998; Li et al., 2000; X. Zhang and M. R. Gunner, unpublished). Thus, the modulation of redox potential to allow favorable forward electron transfer is peculiar to UQ. Only the head group is required as the tailless 2,3-dimethoxy, 5-methyl benzoquinone (UQ-0) is active in homologous electron transfer (McComb et al., 1990; Warncke et al., 1994). The electron transfer reaction from QA– to QB is the first in the forward sequence to exhibit significant activation enthalpy, slowing as the temperature is lowered (Mancino et al., 1984), with no reaction seen below 200 K (Kleinfeld et al., 1984a; Xu and Gunner, 2001). Thus, there are rearrangements of the quinone or protein that cannot be accomplished at low temperature before QA– returns its electron to P+, in ≈100 ms. However, when the RCs are illuminated while freezing, they are trapped in the charge separated state P+QB–, which slowly undergoes charge recombination to the ground state. These RCs are now capable of full QB reduction at temperatures as low as 50 K (Kleinfeld et al., 1984a; Xu and Gunner, 2001, 2002). Thus, sufficient rearrangements are frozen into the protein-quinone conformation, leaving a new ground state conformation where any necessary conformational changes can be achieved at low temperature. Room temperature experiments have been carried out with different quinones in the QA site reducing UQB. The electron transfer reaction is largely independent of the driving force ∆GAB° (Graige et al., 1998), providing support that the rate determining step for this reaction is a conformational change rather the electron transfer reaction itself. However, a fast component has been reported to exhibit ∆G°AB dependence (Li et al., 2000). On the basis of the
383
slower, ∆G°AB-independent kinetics, the reaction mechanism for QA– QB → QA QB– has been described as being ‘gated’, i.e., other changes such as in quinone position, protein conformation or protonation, rather then the electron transfer itself, are the rate determining step (Tiede et al., 1996; Graige et al., 1998; Li et al., 1998, 2000; Wraight, 2004). Ultimately, the equilibrium properties of QA and QB, and the rates, temperature and pH dependence, of their oxidation/reduction reactions should be understandable in terms of the structure and dynamics of the protein. III. Structural Features of the Acceptor Quinone Binding Sites X-ray crystallography has shown the acceptor quinones to be symmetrically positioned about a nonheme iron atom (FeII, S = 2), which is liganded by four histidines (residues L190, L230, M219, M266) and a glutamate (M234), giving a net charge of +1. In this ‘acceptor quinone complex’, each quinone is bound in the fold of an interhelical loop — QA in the loop between the D and E helices of the M subunit and QB in the symmetry related position between helices D and E of the L subunit. Both quinones are involved in rather similar hydrogen bond interactions between the two carbonyl groups and a His side chain and an amide backbone. Much of this has been reviewed, based on the original X-ray structures of Blc. viridis (PDB entry 1prc; Deisenhofer et al., 1985; Deisenhofer and Michel, 1989b) at a resolution of 2.8 Å, and Rba. sphaeroides (PDB entries 4rcr (Allen et al., 1987a,b) and 2rcr (Chang et al., 1991) for the carotenoidless strain R26, and 1yst (Arnoux et al., 1995) and 1pss (Chirino et al., 1994) for carotenoid-containing strains), at resolutions between 2.8–3.3 Å. There are currently 47 structures of Rba. sphaeroides RCs, 20 of them with resolution between 1.8 and 2.5 Å (as of March 2007). The quinone binding sites are deeply buried in bacterial RCs, but the protein environment is very rich in ionizable amino acids, with highly networked interactions. In the RC 33% of the titratable residues are buried, a proportion similar to that found in the average protein (Gunner et al., 2000; Kim et al., 2005). The QB site is separated from the aqueous phase by a region of unusually high charge density (Zhu and Karlin, 1996), comprising a web of more than 20 residues whose ionization is strongly coupled
384 together (Beroza et al., 1995; Sebban et al., 1995; Lancaster et al., 1996; Alexov and Gunner, 1999; Ishikita et al., 2003). This feature is not apparent in Photosystem II (pdbs: 1s5l and 2axt), which lacks an H subunit homolog, and provides access to the surface through a single residue, His 252 of the D1 subunit (homologous with L) (Ferreira et al., 2004; Loll et al., 2005; Krivanek et al., 2007). However, tight membrane appression in plants and bulky phycobilisomes in cyanobacteria may serve to restrict solvent accessibility in Photosystem II. One result of the internal buffering in the bacterial RC is that mutations made to modify the charge environment of the quinone often have far smaller impact than might be expected for simple charge removal (Alexov et al., 2000). A. The Primary Quinone, QA In bacterial Type II RCs, QA may be a menaquinone (e.g., Blc. viridis, Allochromatium vinosum, Thermochromatium tepidum) or a ubiquinone (e.g., Rba. sphaeroides, Rba. capsulatus and Rhodospirillum rubrum; Parson, 1978). In Rba. sphaeroides, QA is ubiquinone-10 (UQ-10) and the X-ray structures show it to be hydrogen bonded through both carbonyl oxygens. The average lengths of the two hydrogen bonds are almost identical: 2 O1 to the peptide NH of Ala M260 is 2.79±0.09 Å, and O4 to NδH of His M219 is 2.80±0.15 Å. In Blc. viridis, where QA is menaquinone-9 (MQ-9) (Shopes and Wraight, 1985; Gast et al., 1985), the hydrogen bond arrangement is essentially the same; the hydrogen bonds are longer, at 2.98 ± 0.14 Å and 2.84 ± 0.07 Å, respectively, although the difference is not statistically significant. The main features of the quinone binding sites in Rba. sphaeroides are shown in Fig. 4. For the QA site, the major contributions to the immediate binding site (atoms within 4 Å of the QA headgroup) are from residues (sidechain or backbone) Met M218, His M219, Thr M222, Ala M248, Ala M249, Trp M252, Asn M259, Ala M260, Thr M261, Met M262 and 2 Two atom numbering conventions are in common use for ubiquinone in the biochemical literature. One, based on benzoquinone as the parent compound, identifies C1 as the carbonyl carbon proximal to the isoprene chain (which is considered attached to C6) and the other carbonyl as C4. The other convention, which is used in several X-ray structures, is based on toluene as the parent compound and identifies the methylsubstituted carbon as C1. The carbonyl groups are then at C2 (equivalent to C4) and C5 (equivalent to C1). In this article the former convention is used.
Colin A. Wraight and Marilyn R. Gunner Ile M265, with single atom contacts from Leu M215 and Ile M223 in some structures. Trp M252, which has been implicated in the rapid electron transfer from BPheA– to QA (Coleman et al., 1990b; Stilz et al., 1994), is in close contact and almost parallel to the quinone plane, and is held in this position by a hydrogen bond between the indole nitrogen and the OH of Thr M222 (Stilz et al., 1994). Also, Phe M251 is perpendicular to the Trp ring in a classic aromatic bond configuration (Burley and Petsko, 1985). On the other side of the quinone ring, Ile M265 points directly at the methoxy C3M, the C4 carbonyl, C5 and the C5´-methyl group. The first two isoprene units of the tail of QA are contacted by Leu M214, Leu M215, Met M218, Met M256, Phe M258, Trp M268 and Met M272. Only the first two isoprene units are well packed in the protein. Thus, the first isoprene methyl (C10) has 6.6 ± 1.7 protein atom neighbors within 4.0 Å while the second methyl (C15) has only 1.1 ± 0.7 neighbors. The extended tail can be seen lying outside the protein structure. The tail kinks to bend around Met M256 as it passes through the binding channel (Warncke et al., 1994). The first 2 isoprene units are also bounded by Trp M268 and Met M218. The lack of interaction of the later isoprene groups is seen by the affinity becoming independent of tail length after the third isoprene unit (McComb et al., 1990; Warncke et al., 1994). 1. The Methoxy Groups of QA The environments of the two methoxys are quite different, including a significant difference in packing around them. There are 7.4 ± 1.2 atoms within 4 Å of C2M and 3.9 ± 1.4 within 4 Å of C3M. However, the environment is somewhat variable in the different structures. Thus, Met M262 is within 4 Å of C3M in 79% of the structures, His M219 in 74%, Ile M265 in 65%, and Ile M223 in 47% of the structures. Thr M221, Thr M222, and Ala M223 are in contact in less than 10% of the structures. Likewise, there is variability in the contacts for C2M with Ala M260 (94%), Thr M261 (74%), Ala M249 (65%), Ala M245 (32%), Ala M248 (21%) and Asn M259 (9%) within 4 Å in the different structures. Of the 34 structures with resolution ≤2.8 Å (see Table 1) there is a probable long hydrogen bond, with an average length of 3.5 Å, between the 2-methoxy oxygen (O2M) and the amide N of Ala M249, with 40% also having the amide N of Ala M260 within 4 Å. In some structures, the angles
Chapter 20
Acceptor Quinones of Purple Photosynthetic Bacteria
385
Fig. 4. The quinone binding site — QA (top) and QB (bottom) — are related by the two-fold, rotational symmetry axis of the reaction center, which passes through the iron atom of the acceptor quinone complex. Both quinones are hydrogen bonded through the carbonyl oxygens — hydrogen bonds shown in purple for QA (top) and in green for QB (bottom). The binding sites are predominantly hydrophobic, with the notable exception of GluL212, AspL213 and SerL223 in the QB site, which constitute terminal components of the H+ delivery pathway to QB. Note that the orientations of the methoxy groups of QA and QB do not follow the two-fold rotational symmetry. (Figure prepared in VMD.) See also Color Plate 8, Fig. 13.
are poor for both donors. In contrast, the 3-methoxy oxygen (O3M) has no available hydrogen bond donors within 4 Å. Although the methoxy dihedral angles are not definitive for either quinone, it is noteworthy that the orientation of the 3-methoxy of QA is the best established by the X-ray data, with a dihedral angle of –77 ± 8°, in spite of the lack of any hydrogen bond donor to the oxygen. The 2-methoxy, on the other hand, is less well defined, although it seems to have a weak hydrogen bonding partner within reach (peptide N of Ala M249 at about 3.5 Å). With a dihedral angle of 139 ± 25° it is somewhat closer to being in-plane, and a few structures have the 2-methoxy almost fully in-plane and potentially hydrogen bonded to both Ala M249 and Ala M260. B. The Secondary Quinone, QB In all purple bacteria known to date, QB is a ubi-
quinone (UQ-10 in Rba. sphaeroides), although it is menaquinone in the Type II RC of Chloroflexus aurantiacus (Bruce et al., 1982). The functionally reversible binding of QB leads to partial extraction during isolation, and the X-ray diffraction data show variable and incomplete occupancy of this site. In the initial X-ray structures of Blc. viridis and Rba. sphaeroides, QB occupancy was largely restored by soaking the crystals with short chain analogs (UQ-1 or UQ-2). The headgroup was then modeled into the QB pocket with H-bonds between O4 and Nδ of His L190 and between O1 and Oγ of Ser L223 (Allen et al., 1987a,b; Deisenhofer et al., 1985; Deisenhofer and Michel, 1989a; El-Kabbani et al., 1991). This has become known as the proximal position. Later, an independent, higher resolution Rba. sphaeroides structure (1pcr) revealed QB to be positioned quite differently, in a ‘distal’ position with the headgroup rotated almost 180° and 5 Å away from the original
Colin A. Wraight and Marilyn R. Gunner
386 Table 1. Structure files with resolution ≤ 2.8 Å.1 PDB Rhodobacter sphaeroides 1RZH 1AIJ 1YF6 1E6D 1RZZ 1DS8 1DV6 2GMR 1M3X 1FNP 1FNQ 1PCR 1RVJ 1SOO 1OGV 1L9B 1KBY 2BNS3 1MPS 1JGY 1JGZ 2BNP 1JGW 1UMX 1QOV 1RY5 2GNU 2BOZ 1DV3 1RG5 1AIG 1E14 1RQK 1F6N 1RGN Blastochloris viridis4 1DXR
R
QA
QB
Modifications & Additions2
1.8 2.2 2.3 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.6 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.6 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.7 2.7 2.7 2.8 2.8 2.1 2.1 2.2 2.4 2.5 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.7 2.8 2.8
UQ10 UQ10 None UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 None UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10 UQ10
Distal Distal Distal Distal Distal Distal Distal Distal Distal Distal Distal Distal Distal Distal&Proximal None None None None None None None None None None Proximal Proximal Proximal Proximal Proximal Proximal Proximal Proximal Proximal Proximal Proximal
L213DN, M233RC R26 L181YF, M203DG, M210FY, M214HL, M260WA M197RF, M115FW L213DN, M233RC R26 + Cd2+ R26 + Zn2+ L210DN M197FR, M177YF L209PF L209PE R26 L213DN, H177RH, H8GQ L213DN, M233RC R26 R26; with Cyt c2 M202HL (heterodimer) R26. P+QA– M197FR, M177YF M76YF M76YK R26 M21TL M267RL M260AW L213DN R26 M203GL R26 + Cd2+, P+QB– R-26.1 R26, P+QB– R26; with Cyt c2 R-26.1, + 3,4-dihydrospheroidene L209PY R-26.1, + spheroidene
2.0
MQ9
MST
L168HF, + 2-t-butylamino-4-ethylamino-6-methylthio1,3,5-triazine
1VRN 1PRC 2PRC 3PRC 4PRC 5PRC
2.2 2.3 2.5 2.4 2.4 2.4
MQ9 MQ7 MQ7 MQ7 MQ7 MQ7
UQ7(Prox) UQ1(Prox) UQ2(Prox) None SMA ATZ
6PRC
2.3
MQ7
CEB
+ stigmatellin A + 2-chloro-4-isopropylamino-6-ethylamino-1,3,5-triazine + 2-chloro-4-ethylamino-6-(s(-)-2´-cyano-4-butylamino)-1,3,5-triazine
Chapter 20
Acceptor Quinones of Purple Photosynthetic Bacteria
387
Table 1. Continued PDB 7PRC
R 2.7
QA MQ7
QB CET
Modifications & Additions2 + 2-chloro-4-ethylamino-6-(r(+)-2´-cyano-4-butylamino)-1,3,5-triazine
2I5N 2.0 MQ9 UQ1(Prox) Thermochromatium tepidum 1EYS 2.3 MQ8 None 1 Of the 47 Rba. sphaeroides structures as of March 2007, 36 have a resolution ≤2.8 Å. 2 Non-mutant structures are from R26 or R26.1 (carotenoidless) strains; mutations are in non-R26 (carotenoid-containing) backgrounds e.g., strains Ga or 2.4.1 3 Crystal structures of protein maintained in the P+QA– state under illumination at 100 K (2bns) do show larger structural changes in the H subunit and increased susceptibility to protease digestion (Katona et al., 2005). 4 In the earlier Bcl. viridis structures (1PRC-7PRC) QA was identified as MQ7, but this should probably read MQ9, which is the major prenylog in this species (Parson, 1978; Gast et al., 1985; Shopes and Wraight, 1985).
determination (Ermler et al., 1994). In this position the quinone has moved along the channel holding the tail in the proximal structure, with the headgroup now visible from outside the protein. The novel position was tentatively ascribed to QB being in the quinol state, reduced by ascorbic acid in the isolation medium (Ermler et al., 1994). Subsequently, however, this arrangement was also found for the oxidized quinone (Stowell et al., 1997), although the occupancy is variable (Fritzsch et al., 2002; Pokkuluri et al., 2004). Reexamination of the Blc. viridis structure revealed a similar binding configuration for the native UQ-9, with partial occupancy (Lancaster and Michel, 1997), whereas UQ-2, added to saturate the site, appeared to bind proximally (Lancaster, 1998). A matched pair of X-ray structures was prepared from Rba. sphaeroides RCs frozen in the dark in the PQAQB state and frozen in the light, presumably in the P+QAQB– state (Stowell et al., 1997). Freezing RCs in the charge separated state traps the protein/quinone complex in a conformation that is capable of QB reduction (Kleinfeld et al., 1984a; Xu and Gunner, 2001). The frozen-in-the-dark structure (1aij) has the quinone in the outer, distal position. The frozen-inthe-light structure (1aig) has it in the inner, proximal position. No other significant structural changes in the QB binding site region accompany the distal-toproximal movement of the quinone, and the RMSD between the two L subunits is only 0.3 Å. However, more significant changes have since been reported in the H-subunit (Fritzsch et al., 2002; Katona et al., 2005). 1. The Two QB Binding Sites Found in the X-ray Structures The inner, proximal position of QB is shown in
Fig. 4. The hydrogen bond from O4 to His L190 is 2.69±0.23 Å, perhaps not significantly different from the distance to His M219 in the QA site, but notably not longer; it is also similar in Blc. viridis RCs. In different structures, O1 can make a hydrogen bond to the side chain of Ser L223 (2.81±0.25 Å) or the backbone of Ile L224 (2.91±0.24 Å) or Gly L225 (3.09 ± 0.16 Å), and usually more than one. The Ser Oγ is closest to the carbonyl in 75% of the structures. Residues within 4 Å of the QB headgroup in the proximal site in most structures are Leu L189, His L190, Leu L193, Glu L212, Asp L213, Ser L223, Ile L224, Gly L225, Thr L226 and Ile L229, a single atom in Val L194, and one or two water molecules. Phe L216 is symmetry-related to Trp M252 in the QA site, but it does not appear to be close enough (≥ 4.2 Å) or appropriately oriented to make either a parallel or perpendicular ‘aromatic’ interaction with QB in the proximal position. However, Phe L216does contact the first isoprene unit of the ubiquinone tail. Additional contacts with the first two isoprene units of the tail are made by Leu L185, Ala L186, Tyr L222, Ile L224, Ile L229 and Leu L232. The conversion between proximal and distal QB positions is not a simple translation, with most reports describing at as a ‘propeller twist,’ requiring also a 180° flip of the headgroup around the isoprene chain to switch the O4 carbonyl H-bond from His L190 to Ile L224 (Stowell et al., 1997). In the distal position, O4 is 2.89 ± 0.22 Å from the Ile L224 backbone NH, although in two structures (1m3x and 1fnp) the Ser L223 hydroxyl oxygen is closer. There is now no good hydrogen bond donor for O1. Ala L186 is the closest, but the average distance is >4 Å. The C1=O is the closest quinone carbonyl to Nδ of His L190 but is at a distance of 6.7 Å. The quinone appears to be stabilized by π- π interactions with Phe L216,
388 which is roughly parallel to and above the plane of the quinone ring, 3.8–4.2 Å away. Additional contacts are made with residues Ala L186, Leu L189, Tyr L222, Ile L224, and Ile L229. In the distal position, the tail is almost completely out of the RC protein structure — beyond the first isoprene unit it is only contacted on one side. The orientations of the methoxy groups in the distal quinone are very ill-defined, with large standard deviations. The distal position for QB is presumed to be nonfunctional. The distance from QA is 1.6 Å further than for the proximal position, measured between nearest carbonyl oxygens, or 2.4 Å larger measured from ring center to center. As electron transfer slows exponentially with distance, the rate kAB is expected to be 1–2 orders of magnitude slower than to the proximal site (Marcus and Sutin, 1985; Moser et al., 1995; Moser et al., 2003). Also, the calculated Em in the distal site is 250 mV lower than in the proximal site, largely because it is further from the non-heme iron and lacks hydrogen bonds to one carbonyl (Rabenstein et al., 2000; Zhu and Gunner, 2005). Recent work with mutant RCs that exhibit electron transfer to QB from HB, along the B branch, indicates that even though the distal site is closer to HB it is not active, suggesting that the driving force for quinone reduction by HB– is inadequate to compete with recombination from P+HB– (Laible et al., 2003; Breton et al., 2004; Wakeham et al., 2004; Paddock et al., 2005; Paddock et al., 2006). The difficulties in defining the QB binding configurations are well illustrated by a very recent collection of high resolution structures, determined by Fritzsch and coworkers, of RCs frozen in the dark or light, and at several pH values (Koepke et al., 2007). They report roughly equal populations of proximal and distal occupancies under all conditions, i.e., including RCs frozen in the light, which are supposedly trapped in the P+QB– state. The presence of both QB positions means that even at the very good resolutions obtained (down to 1.87 Å), the orientation of the ring and many of the substituent interactions are ambiguous. Nevertheless, they conclude that the distal position is not flipped relative to the proximal position. The earlier work on dark-frozen RCs, at lower resolution, also either had a mixture of QB positions, or additional water molecules modeled in to account for electron density (Stowell et al., 1997; Pokkuluri et al., 2002, 2004). Thus, this issue must be considered open.
Colin A. Wraight and Marilyn R. Gunner Occupancy of both QB sites in the light-frozen samples, as suggested by Koepke et al. (2007), would have major consequences for functional models of the acceptor quinones, and for understanding the origin of the quinone properties. However, in spite of the high overall resolution of these data, the QB binding site structures have some physically highly improbable features, including hydrogen bonds as short as 2.26 Å (heavy atom distance), and substantial distortions of some quinone ring substituents. 2. The Methoxy Groups of QB In the proximal QB site, the orientations of the methoxy groups of QB are uncertain, as is the case for QA. For QB, this problem is exacerbated by the smaller set of structures and less well resolved quinone position. Nevertheless, ignoring the earliest structures, which have gross anomalies in the quinone placements, the large majority of structures with QB in the proximal position (13 structures) yields a consensus with both methoxy groups strongly out of plane, with dihedral angles of –90 ± 9° and 88 ± 20° for 2- and 3-methoxy, respectively, which is superficially similar to the conformation for QA. (Several new structures from Koepke et al. (2007) show a very wide range of conformations for the 3-methoxy group, and are not included in this average). The similarity of the QA and QB infra-red (IR) bands at 1263 and 1287 cm–1 supports similar methoxy orientations in the two sites (Remy et al., 2003) (but see below). However, the amino acid composition of the QB site and a departure from the approximate C2 symmetry of the overall RC structure provide very distinct hydrogen-bonding patterns for the methoxy groups of QA and QB. The 2-methoxy oxygen of proximal QB is well endowed with potential donors, notably the peptide nitrogens of Gly L225 and Thr L226. For the 3-methoxy group, the oxygen lone pairs generally point away from the carboxyl group of Glu L212 and the most prevalent hydrogen bonding interaction is with Nδ of His L190,. In the somewhat better defined QB site structures of the Blc. viridis RC, this histidine forms bifurcated H-bonds to the carbonyl O4 and methoxy O3. It is noteworthy that this interaction cannot occur for QA in Rba. sphaeroides because the methoxy groups of QA and QB are almost 180° out of phase and the 3-methoxy lone pairs of QA are too distant (>4.4 Å) and point away from His M219. This represents a striking departure from the overall
Chapter 20
Acceptor Quinones of Purple Photosynthetic Bacteria
389
Fig. 5. View down the two-fold rotational symmetry axis, showing that the methoxy groups (C2M and C3M) of QA (left) and QB (right) violate the symmetry that is followed by the isoprene tail and the major features of the reaction center organization (cofactor positions and architecture of the L and M subunits).
C2 symmetry relating the two sites (Fig. 5). C. Hydrogen Bonding in the Quinone Binding Sites There is a variety of evidence for the importance of hydrogen bonding of the two quinones of the RC. The carbonyls and the methoxy oxygens are both nominally capable of functioning as hydrogen bond acceptors, and hydrogen bonds to the carbonyls, in particular, are expected to affect the affinity and specificity of QA and QB binding and to modify their physico-chemical properties to be sufficient for the reduction of quinone to quinol. In general, however, the resolution of the X-ray structures is too low to allow unequivocal assignment of the interactions between the quinones and their binding sites, and the energetics and specific properties of, e.g., hydrogen bonds, must be determined from spectroscopy and computation. The crystal structures, measurements of affinity of modified quinones, electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR), electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR), solid state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and Fourier transfer infra-red (FTIR) spectroscopy all offer complementary pictures of the quinone interactions. Fruitful comparisons might also be expected with an increasing selection of approximately 30 structurally defined quinone and 10 inhibitor binding sites in other proteins (Fisher and Rich, 2000), including cytochromes bc1 and b6 f, succinate dehydrogenase and fumarate reductase, as well as the binding of inhibitors as quinone or quinol analogs such as stigmatellin in RCs and cytochromes bc1 and b6 f complexes. However, the crystal structures residing in the protein databank in March 2007 reveal a very wide variation of hydrogen bond partners to quinone carbonyls, with no evident motifs defining a canonical quinone binding site. Thus, the quinone site architecture found in RCs is not replicated in
any other known quinone binding sites and useful correlations will require considerable sophistication, if they exist at all. IV. Spectroscopy of the Acceptor Quinones Vibrational spectroscopy provides an independent source of data on the quinone binding interactions, and FTIR spectroscopy in particular has provided significant insights, while magnetic resonance methods have been applied with great effect to the semiquinones. An advantage of IR absorbance and Raman over magnetic resonance spectroscopies is that the former can see all redox states of the quinones, not just the radical species. The use of light-induced (or redox potential-induced) difference spectra has allowed excellent resolution of the difference between quinone and semiquinone states in RCs, against the much greater background of mostly unchanging protein vibrations (for reviews, see Breton and Nabedryk, 1996; Nabedryk and Breton, 2008). The theoretical and experimental bases for the IR spectra of ubiquinones, in solution, have been systematically explored by Breton and Nonella and coworkers (Nonella and Brändli, 1996; Burie et al., 1997; Nonella, 1997, 1998; Nonella et al., 2003), and others (Boesch and Wheeler, 1997; O’Malley, 2001; Wheeler, 2001). The IR absorbance spectrum of isoprenyl ubiquinone (UQ-n) in solution, at room temperature, is characterized by a C=C stretch at 1610 cm–1 and two C=O stretches at 1665 and 1650 cm–1. The C=C and C=O modes are substantially coupled to each other but those of the two carbonyls are not. The splitting indicates asymmetry of substitution, which, for ubiquinone, arises from the conformation of the two methoxy groups, since an in-plane methoxy donates electrons into the ring while those out of plane are electron withdrawing (Burie et al.,
390 1997; Meyerson, 1985). The lone pair electrons of an in-plane methoxy oxygen are conjugated to the quinone C=C—C=O π electron system, decreasing the bond order, downshifting the distal C=O stretch frequency and upshifting the proximal C=O (Nonella and Brändli, 1996; Burie et al., 1997; Boullais et al., 1998; Nonella et al., 2003). The in-plane conformation is favored by the stabilizing electron resonance but is countered by unfavorable van der Waals interactions with any adjacent substituents.3 The steric clash is diminished by the larger bond angle arising from increased sp2 character with hydridization of the inplane methoxy oxygen. There is only room for one of the adjacent methoxy groups in UQ to be in-plane at a time, so the two carbonyls are not equivalent. However, both carbonyls contribute equally to both C=O stretch frequencies since neither methoxy has precedence in solution (Burie et al., 1997; Boullais et al., 1998; Remy et al., 2003). The quinone C=O and C=C bands are generally not very sensitive to changing from a protic (hydrogen bonding) to an aprotic solvent (Bauscher and Mäntele, 1992; Burie et al., 1995). This reflects the relatively weak hydrogen bonding propensity of β-unsaturated carbonyls (Rasmussen et al., 1949; Bellamy, 1968; 1975). Extensive IR studies have been made of the quinones in bacterial RCs (reviewed in Breton and Nabedryk, 1996; Boullais et al., 1998). The two C=O vibrations are very weakly coupled, if at all, indicating at least as much conformational and environmental asymmetry as is found in solution. Also as in solution, both carbonyls are substantially mixed with the C=C stretch. Assignment of the dominant C1=O, C4=O and C2=C3 and C5=C6 stretch bands has been made through the use of site-specific isotopic labels (Breton et al., 1994a, 1995; Brudler et al., 1994, 1995). A. The Primary Quinone, QA For QA, the quinone mode dominated by C1=O, associated with a hydrogen bond to the backbone of Ala M260, is found at 1660 cm–1, close to the average of the two solution values. A band at 1628 cm–1 is identified as having major C=C character, signifi3 Both the methyl and the non-conjugated lone pair electrons of the methoxy oxygen interact with adjacent groups — the proximal carbonyl oxygen and the other methoxy group. In the absence of a neighboring substituent, the preferred in-plane conformation is with the methoxy methyl group pointing away from the carbonyl. However, even a methyl in the adjacent position hinders this conformer significantly more than the other in-plane alignment, which is therefore preferred.
Colin A. Wraight and Marilyn R. Gunner cantly up-shifted from solution (1610 cm–1) but still recognizable. However, the C4=O stretch, hydrogen bonded to His M219, has been convincingly assigned to a band at 1601 cm–1, which is downshiftedfrom the solution value by 50–65 cm–1 (Breton et al., 1994a; Brudler et al., 1994). The relative positions of the C1=O and C4=O stretch frequencies are consistent with the C2- and C3-methoxy groups being roughly in-plane and outof-plane, respectively, but the magnitude of the C4=O downshift is far larger than can be accounted for by this effect. Furthermore, a substantially in-plane orientation for either group is not well supported by a consensus of the more recent X-ray structures, nor by an FTIR analysis of the methoxy marker bands at 1260-1290 cm–1 (Remy et al., 2003). However, FTIR spectra of RCs reconstituted with monomethoxy-ubiquinone-4 analogs (with tetra-isoprenyl sidechains) show that absence of the 2-methoxy group does result in an upshift of the C4=O stretch, although only by about 10 cm–1 (A. Vakkasoglu, B. Lipshutz and C. A. Wraight, unpublished). Consistent with such a role, tetramethylbenzoquinone (duroquinone) does not exhibit a substantially downshifted C=O stretch, although small, tailless quinones also appear to be distinct from isoprenylated analogs in other ways (Breton et al., 1994b). Strong hydrogen bonding has been suggested as the origin of the C4=O stretch frequency, but it is a very large shift, especially since hydrogen bonding by protic solvents has little influence on the C=O stretch frequency (Bauscher and Mäntele, 1992). Linear relationships between hydrogen bond strength and relative frequency shift (∆νC=O /νC=O), have been shown; a specific dependence of 4 x 10–3 (kcal/mol)–1, reported by Zadorozhnyi and Ishchenko (1965) for both intra- and intermolecular hydrogen bonds, has been widely cited. Using the relationship of Zadorozhnyi and Ishchenko, the 50–65 cm–1 frequency shift for C4=O of QA (depending on whether 1665 or 1650 cm–1 is used as a reference, see above) would correspond to a hydrogen bond strength (enthalpy) of about 7.5–10 kcal/mol. This is a large value, but IR and Raman band shifts have suggested hydrogen bond strengths of this magnitude in other enzyme systems (Deng and Callender, 1999). However, other solution studies have shown that, unlike the classic Badger-Bauer relationship for νOH, different carbonyl species do not fall on a unique line but exhibit distinct linear dependencies (Bellamy and Pace, 1970; Thijs and Zeegers-Huyskens, 1984; Meyerson, 1985).
Chapter 20
Acceptor Quinones of Purple Photosynthetic Bacteria
Thus, caution is needed in applying the Zadorozhnyi and Ishchenko linear relationship, as it has not been validated for quinones Some support for one strong hydrogen bond to QA comes from measurements of the binding affinity of the QA site of Rba. sphaeroides RCs for a series of compounds with different numbers of carbonyls (Gunner et al., 1985; Warncke and Dutton, 1992; 1993a). Thus, anthrone (one C=O) is found to bind 1.2 kcal/mol weaker than 9,10-anthraquinone, while 9,10-dimethyl-anthracene (no C=O) binds more than 6.5 kcal/mol weaker (Gunner et al., 1985). This is consistent with quinone binding utilizing one strong and one weak hydrogen bond but does not prove it, since the removal of one carbonyl could strengthen the remaining interaction. Despite the evidence of the affinity measurements, assigning the C=O band shift in the protein to hydrogen bonding is not well founded for quinones, which show only weak interactions with hydrogen bonding solvents (Bauscher and Mäntele, 1992). Large downshifts of the carbonyl bands are seen in quinones capable of intramolecular hydrogen bonding, such as anthraquinones with OH-substituted in the α position adjacent to the carbonyl (Flett, 1948). However, this is thought not to be primarily due to the hydrogen bonding, per se, but to the electronic redistribution made possible through resonance in a dimer that is stabilized by H-bonding (Rasmussen et al., 1949; Bloom et al., 1959). In contrast, the O-H band for these compounds is greatly shifted by hydrogen bonding, in a typical Badger-Bauer relationship (Badger and Bauer, 1937; Gordy, 1940; Rao et al., 1975). Similar conclusions have been drawn from studies on quinhydrones (dimers of quinone and hydroquinone in a charge transfer complex), which suggest that π electronic interactions make the major contribution to the C=O downshift rather than a strong H-bonding between the quinone carbonyl and adjacent hydroquinone hydroxyl (Bloom et al., 1959; Slifkin and Walmsley, 1969; Kruk et al., 1993). Other evidence that the downshift of the C4=O stretch is not due to strong hydrogen bonding is that incubation with D2O has no effect on the 1601 cm–1 QA band (Breton and Nabedryk, 1995; Wells et al., 2003). It was suggested that no (or very slow) H/D exchange occurred at His M219. Slow exchange is supported by ENDOR data, which showed very slow D2O exchange of two proton hyperfine interactions with identical half times of ≈3 hrs (Okamura and Feher, 1986). More recent ENDOR studies found
391
one of the two hyperfine interactions (assigned to the peptide NH of Ala M260) to exchange in about 1 hour, significantly more quickly than the other (assigned to NδH of His M219), which takes several hours at room temperature (Flores et al., 2006).4 However, H/D shifts are seen in the semiquinone IR spectrum (Breton and Nabedryk, 1995; Wells et al., 2003), suggesting that the light-dark cycling used in IR difference spectroscopy may accelerate the exchange. Thus, the lack of a significant D/H-shift in the quinone C=O stretch at 1600 cm–1 may not be due to lack of exchange, but to insensitivity to the isotopic substitution. This would not be supportive of an unusually strong H-bond. Considering X-ray structures with a resolution ≤2.8 Å, the heavy atom distances from O4 to Nδ of His M219 and O1 to the carbonyl of Ala M260 are both about 2.8 Å — neither bond is particularly short and both are of similar length. In addition neither Ala nor His donor N is in plane with the carbonyl, which is not optimal. The hydrogen bonding strength has been estimated using a standard molecular mechanics force field, which considers the Lennard-Jones attractive and repulsive terms and the electrostatic interactions that the quinone makes with the protein. In 1aig the interactions with the His sidechain are estimated at only –1.6 kcal/mol, and –0.4 kcal/mol for the amide backbone, neither of which are especially strong (Zhu and Gunner, 2005). Solid state NMR studies on 13C-labeled quinones in RCs also provide little support for the strong hydrogen bond to C4=O (van Liemt et al., 1995), although de Groot (1995) has made a brave effort to show that the expected chemical shift could be masked by other effects. Thus, although the FTIR and NMR results may not be fundamentally inconsistent, it seems fair to say that the origin of the C4=O frequency shift for 4 A mutant RC with His M266 changed to cysteine (mutant M266HC) has been widely used for ENDOR studies of the semiquinones, because it readily incorporates Zn in place of Fe (Williams et al., 1991). Although no substantial perturbations are seen in the X-ray structure (E. C. Abresch, unpublished, reported in Lubitz and Feher, 1999), Paddock et al. (1999) have reported much faster H/D exchange (<10 s) for one carbonyl, suggesting some perturbation of the acceptor quinone complex. This is also supported by electron spin echo envelope modulation (ESEEM studies, which show M266HC RCs to be almost completely lacking the 14N quadrupole couplings assigned to His M219 (Spoyalov et al., 1996), even though no kinetic disparities have been reported. The g-tensor values are also very similar to wild type, with only gx somewhat decreased (Lubitz and Feher, 1999).
392 QA is far from clear and other explanations should be considered. An abnormally strong interaction between the quinone and His M219 could arise from the His being liganded to the high spin FeII that lies between the two quinones. The pKa of the NδH group (imidazolate NH/N–) is normally in excess of 14 in solution, but can be lowered by several pH units when ligated to some metals. However, there is little precedent for this from model compounds with FeII, in contrast to FeIII (Sundberg and Martin, 1974). Enhanced acidity of the NδH proton would make it a more effective hydrogen bond donor, but one might still expect this to show up as the significantly shorter of the two carbonyl linkages, and to manifest effects of H/D exchange on the hydrogen-bonded C=O stretch. Furthermore, QB in the proximal position is very similarly arranged, making a hydrogen bond to His L190, which is one of the other ligands to the non-heme iron, but the QB C4=O stretch is not shifted by an unusual amount. Another source of the carbonyl frequency shift might be the π-π interaction between QA and Trp M252, which is roughly parallel to the quinone headgroup and approaches to within 3.5 Å. Tryptophan M252 is between QA and the active BPhe and has been shown to contribute to the fast electron transfer to QA (Coleman et al., 1990a; Stilz et al., 1994), as well as to the binding of the quinone (Stilz et al., 1994). This residue is electronically coupled to both QA and the BPhe (Plato et al., 1989), although not so strongly as to significantly perturb the visible spectra. Furthermore, mutating this residue to tyrosine was found to have negligible effect on the hyperfine parameters (nitrogen quadrupole couplings) of QA– (Spoyalov et al., 1996). Calculations of the electronic structure parameters of QA– in bacterial RCs showed only minor effects of both Trp M252 and Ile M265 (Fritscher et al., 2006). Nevertheless, a role for tryptophan-(semi)quinone interactions has been suggested for quinone function in bacterial RCs and Photosystem I on the basis of density functional theory (DFT) calculations, despite the analysis showing that the in vivo π-stacked configuration has only a small effect on the semiquinone g-tensor (Kaupp, 2002; Kacprzak and Kaupp, 2004). The remaining and likely influence is proteinimposed constraints on the dihedral angle of the methoxy groups. This affects not only the bond order (and hence vibrational frequencies) of the C=C and C=O bonds, as discussed above, but also the electron affinity (redox potential) of the quinone and the ba-
Colin A. Wraight and Marilyn R. Gunner sicity of the carbonyl oxygens (Breen, 1975; Prince et al., 1983; Prince et al., 1988; Robinson and Kahn, 1990). The lower frequency of the C4=O stretch is consistent with a more nearly in-plane position for the 2-methoxy, allowing the lone pair to enter the conjugated C2=C3–C4=O π-bond system. This would also enhance the charge density on the C4=O carbonyl oxygen, making it more basic and a stronger hydrogen bond acceptor. However, an in-plane conformation for the 2-methoxy group is only approached in very few RC crystal structures. Furthermore, the IR bands of the methoxy C–O stretch modes at 1263 and 1287 cm–1 are very similar (±1 cm–1) for both QA and QB, for pool quinone in the native membrane (Mezzetti et al., 2003), and for ubiquinone in solution where the methoxy groups are out-of-plane, suggesting they have the same conformation in the RCs. On this basis, Gerwert and coworkers have concluded that the methoxy group dihedral angles cannot contribute significantly to the differences between QA and QB properties, such as the IR spectra or redox energies (Remy et al., 2003). This is at odds with the observation that only ubiquinones can simultaneously function as QA and QB. Furthermore, recent results with mono-methoxy ubiquinone-4 analogs show that simultaneous function as QA and QB specifically requires only the 2-methoxy group (A. Vakkasoglu, B. Lipshutz and C. A. Wraight, unpublished). This suggests that the 2-methoxy group is involved in generating the necessary difference in redox potential between QA and QB, which is also consistent with the ability of rhodoquinone to function simultaneously as QA and QB (Graige et al., 1999). The necessary redox potential difference is quite small (approx. 75 mV for the 1-electron couples, Q/Q–, involved in the first electron transfer (Wraight, 1979; Blankenship and Parson, 1979; Kleinfeld et al., 1984b; Mancino et al., 1984; Shinkarev and Wraight, 1997)) and might not result in a significant spectroscopic difference. In fact, whatever the origin of the unusual C4=O IR band, which has garnered a lot of attention, it may not be indicative of something essential for normal function. In a mutant with Ala M260 replaced by cysteine, the C4=O frequency is upshifted by 30–40 cm–1, with only minor perturbations of the QA to QB electron transfer (Breton et al., 2007). It is now only 15–20 cm–1 downshifted from the solution value. B. The Reduced Primary Quinone, QA– The semiquinone QA– can be generated in RCs by light
Chapter 20
Acceptor Quinones of Purple Photosynthetic Bacteria
excitation and charge separation (forming P+QA–) at temperatures down to 1K (Arnold and Clayton, 1960), or by chemical reduction. PQA– can also be trapped for minutes in samples where an electron donor is added to reduce P+. Optical and IR spectroscopy, which can distinguish between Q– and QH, have shown that the equilibrium species for the QA semiquinone is the unprotonated anion, QA–. The hydrogen bond and matrix environment of QA– has been explored by magnetic resonance measurements and by FTIR. 1. Magnetic Resonance Studies of QA– The EPR spectrum of QA– in native RCs is extremely broad and unrecognizable as a free radical signal, due to strong distortion by the integral spin system of the FeII atom (S = 2). It is centered at g = 1.82, with a gx component at g = 1.68 in X-band EPR (Feher et al., 1972; Leigh and Dutton, 1972). The origin of this signal has been explored in many studies, most extensively by Butler et al. (1980, 1984), who showed that the iron was equidistant from QA and QB and not directly coordinated to either. However, the complexity of the system does not allow extraction of any electronic information pertaining to the quinones themselves. Fortunately, the iron can be exchanged for other metals, including diamagnetic zinc (see Section IV.A and Footnote 4, above), which unveils the semiquinone free radical signal and allows the whole panoply of magnetic resonance methods to be applied. The disposition of hydrogen bonds to the semiquinones was first investigated in ENDOR and EPR studies by Feher and coworkers (Feher et al., 1985, 1988; Lubitz et al., 1985; Isaacson et al., 1996), who quantified the hyperfine interactions for exchangeable and non-exchangeable protons, as well as for 17O in the carbonyl groups. A marked asymmetry is evident in the spin density distribution of the QA– radical, distinct from solution behavior and consistent with unequal hydrogen bond lengths to the two ‘carbonyl’ oxygens of QA– — one suggestive of a strong bond, and one indicating a more typical H-bond. However, the calculation assumed the O—H bond axis to His M219 or to the Ala M260 backbone is in the plane of the quinone ring, which, from the X-ray structures, is likely not true. The hyperfine coupling of the methyl (C5´) group is weaker than that seen in solution studies, implying a lower spin density on C5 (and, hence, higher on
393
C4 and C6). In good agreement with this, Q-band EPR studies of 13C-labeled Q-10 in RCs, show the spin density to be enhanced on C2, C4, C6 and O1 (van den Brink et al., 1994; Lubitz and Feher, 1999). The anionic charge is distributed in a complementary fashion5, with more on O4 than O1, promoting stronger hydrogen bonding to C4– –O. Specific identification of the hydrogen bonding partner was made by the pulsed EPR method, electron spin echo envelope modulation (ESEEM) (Bosch et al., 1995), which revealed 14N nuclear quadrupole coupling parameters that are consistent only with a strong histidine/QA– interaction. Subsequent work revealed the weaker coupling of C1– –O to a peptide nitrogen (Spoyalov et al., 1996). Thus, hydrogen bonding in the semiquinone state appears to be asymmetrical, with C4– –O more strongly bonded to Nδ-His M219 than is C1– –O to N-Ala M260. Recent ENDOR experiments (Flores et al., 2003; Flores et al., 2006, 2007) and DFT studies (Fritscher et al., 2006; Sinnecker et al., 2006) have substantially refined the earlier results, and a qualitative distinction between the hydrogen bonds to the two quinone oxygens is confirmed. Consensus values, calculated without using the point dipole approximation, are: for the C4– –O bond to His M219, the H-bond length, rO–H is 1.60-1.66 Å and the heavy atom distance (O–N) is 2.66-2.72 Å; for C1– –O and Ala M260, the H-bond length, rO–H is 1.71-1.77 Å and the heavy atom distance (O–N) is 2.78-2.84 Å. All studies confirmed that the H-bonds were significantly out of the plane of the quinone ring, rendering a pointdipole calculation inaccurate due to the enhanced interaction between the proton and the p-π electron density on the oxygens. The out-of-plane configuration is consistent with an increased sp3 hybridization on the oxygens expected for the radical state, and as previously calculated for benzoquinone in solution (O’Malley, 1997b, 2001). DFT calculations on a model QA– binding site showed that a positive charge on the histidine ligand (modeled as imidazoleH+) is necessary to approximate the correct spin distribution in QA– (O’Malley, 1997a, 2003). This suggests a role for charge delocalization from the divalent Fe2+ — or Zn2+, which 5 If this seems counterintuitive, imagine the neutral semiquinone: the H-O covalent bond will require a valence pair of electrons, so the unpaired spin cannot predominantly reside there. However, when the proton is dissociated to form the semiquinone anion, the negative charge will be largely on this oxygen.
394 is often used as a diamagnetic substitute in the RC. Consistent with this, Fritscher et al. (2006) found a metal ion, in this case Zn2+, to be necessary to reproduce the asymmetry parameter for His M219 in DFT calculations, but the geometry optimization did not show the expected shortening of the His-quinone hydrogen bond length. Interestingly, geometry optimization in DFT indicates there should be a small rotation of QA upon reduction, leading to more linear — and therefore stronger — hydrogen bonds (Fritscher et al., 2006). (See Note Added in Proof.) Nevertheless, the calculated bond from QA– to His M219 does not appear to be unusually strong. Furthermore, the optimized geometry for oxidized QA shows the expected lengthening of the heavy atom distances for the neutral quinone, by 0.17 Å for C4=O to His M219, and 0.13 Å for C1=O to Ala M260 (Sinnecker et al., 2006). This also does not seem to provide much support for the strong H-bond interpretation of the unusual IR frequency of the C4=O stretch of QA. 2. Infra-red Spectroscopic Studies of QA– The IR spectra of semiquinones are sensitive to the protonation state of the radical. In alcoholic solution, protonated ubisemiquinone, UQH, absorbs at ≈1520 cm–1 (C– –O), 1475 cm–1 (C– –O) and 1415 cm–1 (C– –C) (Burie et al., 1995), while the anion, UQ–, exhibits a single main peak at ≈1465 cm–1 of complex origin (Bauscher and Mäntele, 1992). The hydrogen bond strengths of the anionic semiquinone carbonyls are expected to be significantly stronger than for neutral quinone and the semiquinone IR spectra are found to be quite sensitive to hydrogen bonding, with the anion band at ≈1485 cm–1 in aprotic solvent (Bauscher and Mäntele, 1992). In RCs, the IR spectrum of QA– is more complex than in vitro and the features between 1420-1480 cm–1 are referred to as the ‘anion band’. Unlike the independent C=O bands of the neutral quinone, the semiquinone C– –O vibrations are substantially coupled as well as exhibiting greater mixing of the C– –C and C– –O modes, as clearly demonstrated by the frequency shifts in response to specific isotopic substitution (Breton et al., 1994a; Brudler et al., 1994). For unlabeled ubiquinone-10, the main QA– anion band is at 1466 cm–1, with smaller peaks or shoulders at 1484, 1457, 1445 and 1422 cm–1. Isotopic (13C and 18 O) labeling identifies the main band (1466 cm–1)
Colin A. Wraight and Marilyn R. Gunner as predominantly C– –O, appropriate for a hydrogen bonded group (Breton et al., 1994a; Brudler et al., 1994), and the small band at 1422 cm–1 may be predominantly C– –C in character (Bauscher and Mäntele, 1992; Breton et al., 1994a; Brudler et al., 1994). The 1484 cm–1 band seems best assigned to a C– –C ring mode (Breton and Nabedryk, 1996). Breton and Nabedryk suggested that the 1466 and 1445 cm–1 bands correspond to the C1– –O and C4– –O groups, respectively, based on the effect of specific 13 C labeling at the C1 and C4 positions and on the fact that the 1445 cm–1 band shifts to ≈ 1432 cm–1 upon H2O/D2O exchange (Breton and Nabedryk, 1996). This is consistent with the proposed strongly hydrogen bonded character of the semiquinone C4=O group. Clouding the issue is the fact that the 1466 cm–1 band does not shift in D2O, although a shoulder at 1456 cm–1 shifts to higher frequency, by about 8 cm–1 (Wells et al., 2003). Thus, the anion band assignments are not completely satisfying and it is possible that some of the complexity, which is almost unique to the isoprenyl-ubiquinones (i.e., not including methyl-Q-0) (Breton et al., 1994b), arises from subtle matching of modes, i.e., Fermi resonance. Raman spectroscopy, which could resolve some of these issues, has been applied to the RC quinones only to a very limited extent. Raman-active bands at 1600–1620 cm–1 (C– –C), expected for the semiquinone species (Schuler et al., 1983; Burie et al., 1995; Zhao et al., 1997a; Zhao and Kitagawa, 1998), are seen in a strong resonance Raman peak at 1607 cm–1 for QA– (Zhao et al., 1997b). This band is not seen in the IR spectrum, in spite of the low symmetry of the molecule and its environment. If the assignments by Breton and coworkers (Breton and Nabedryk, 1996) of the C1– –O and C4– –O IR bands of the QA semiquinone are correct, the smaller splitting (∆ν ≈20 cm–1), compared to the C1=O and C4=O quinone bands (∆ν ≈60 cm–1), would be consistent with more symmetrical binding of the semiquinone than the quinone. In Blc. viridis, where QA is menaquinone, or in Rba. sphaeroides with naphthoquinone derivatives substituted as QA, the very distinctive C– –O contribution to the anion band (at 1478 cm–1) is not split at all in the QA– spectrum, although the quinone C=O bands are split for QA (Breton et al., 1994b; Breton et al., 1994c). No significant differences in the positions of QA– and QA are detected in the crystal structures (Abresch et al., 1998; Stowell et al., 1997), or by comparison of EPR
Chapter 20
Acceptor Quinones of Purple Photosynthetic Bacteria
(Van der Est et al., 1997), ENDOR (Isaacson et al., 1995) or FTIR (Breton et al., 2002) signatures of samples prepared at low and ambient temperatures. However, the symmetrization of QA– vs. QA could easily be achieved with very little movement, beneath the detection limits of these comparisons. (See Note Added in Proof.) C. The Secondary Quinone, QB For the oxidized QB spectrum, Breton and coworkers found only one C=O IR stretch, at 1641 cm–1 (Breton et al., 1995). Upon labeling at both carbonyls with 18 O this was shifted to 1621 cm–1, a relatively small shift indicative of substantial mixing with the C=C mode. Specific 13C-labeling at either C1 or C4 also demonstrated the equivalence of the two carbonyls, with downshifts of about 20 cm–1. Using the scale of Zadorozhnyi and Ishchenko (1965), with the caveat that the relationship was not derived from quinone species, as discussed above, the QB carbonylfrequency shift from the solution values of 10-25 cm–1 (depending on which peakis used as a reference) corresponds to hydrogen bond strengths of about 1.5–3.75 kcal/ mol. This is consistent with the order of magnitude weaker binding affinity of quinones measured for the QB site, compared to the QA site (McComb et al., 1990; Warncke et al., 1994; X. Zhang and M. R. Gunner, unpublished). Unexpectedly, Breton and coworkers found that the C=C stretch was not equivalently affected by labeling at C1and C4, but was downshifted (from ≈1616 cm–1 to 1600 cm–1) only when C1 was labeled with 13C. They suggested that binding of QB holds the 5-methyl group (Breton et al., 1995) or 3-methoxy (Breton and Nabedryk, 1996) very tightly, thereby restricting its motion coupled to C4=O. The same effect was seen in Blc. viridis (Breton et al., 1995). In contrast, Gerwert and coworkers reported two distinct IR signatures for QB in Rba. sphaeroides (Brudler et al., 1995). The dominant one (≈75%) exhibited a single C=O stretch frequency of 1641 cm–1, as observed by Breton et al. (1995), but a minor population (≈25%) showed split peaks at 1664/1651 cm–1, very close to free quinone. Because of this distinction and, especially, because they assigned different isotope shifts to the main 1641 cm–1 band, Brudler et al. did not report any unusual C1 vs. C4 labeling effect on the C=C stretch as proposed by Breton et al., but interpreted the differences in the
395
spectra as being due to cancellation of overlapping spectral contributions from two populations of QB.6 Furthermore, they found that specific 13C-labeling at C5 or C6 has the same effect on the C=C stretch. Thus, any asymmetry in the coupling between C=O and C=C modes, as described by Breton et al. (1995), would have to involve the C2=C3 bond, uniquely, therefore implicating the 3-methoxy rather than the 5-methyl group. In view of the X-ray studies showing two positions for QB and the possibility of a large scale motion of QB after light activation, the mixed population of QB reported by Brudler et al. (1995) takes on particular significance. No sub-populations were evident in the QB– semiquinone IR spectrum. This is consistent with a dark-adapted state where the quinone equilibrates between distal and proximal positions, and a light state in which QB– is locked into the single, functional proximal site. The free carbonyl character of the minor quinone population, at 1664/1651 cm–1, could be consistent with the nature of the distal binding site, in which only one carbonyl (C4=O) is hydrogen bonded, to the peptide NH of Ile L224. This is discussed further in Section V. D. The Semireduced Secondary Quinone, QB– Although the secondary quinone functions in all three redox states, quinone, semiquinone and quinol, no spectroscopic signatures of the quinol, QBH2, have been reported. However, Mezzetti et al. (2003) have reported the IR spectrum of pool quinones in native membranes of Rba. sphaeroides. Notably, the methoxy marker bands at 1264 and 1288 cm–1 of oxidized pool UQ are indistinguishable from those of QA and QB. Under prolonged illumination, reduction to quinol of up to 20 pool quinones per RC was observed, with main bands at 1491, 1470, 1433, and 1388–1375 cm–1. 1. Magnetic Resonance Studies of QB– Magnetic resonance studies of QB– are not as extensive as for QA–, but they serve to make some important distinctions. In native RCs, the magnetic interaction between QB– and FeII yields an EPR signal like that for QA–, centered at g = 1.82, but even broader with 6 It may be helpful to note that Brudler et al. (1994, 1995), Remy et al. (2003) and van Liemt et al. (1995) use yet another quinone atom numbering system (see Footnote 2).
396 a high field component at g = 1.63 in X-band EPR (Wraight, 1978; Butler et al, 1984). In zinc substituted RCs, the QA– and QB– free radical signals are also very similar, but the small difference in gx-tensor component is consistent with a more polar environment for QB– (Isaacson et al., 1995). Hyperfine coupling constants (hfcs) for QA– and QB–, determined using 17O-labeled (Feher et al., 1985; Lubitz and Feher, 1999) and 13C-labeled (Isaacson et al., 1996) ubiquinones, showed the spin densities on the carbonyls of QB– to be much less asymmetric than in QA–. Similarly, ENDOR studies of QB– show hyperfine splittings similar to those of UQ– in alcoholic solution (Lubitz and Feher, 1999). Potential hydrogen bonding interactions for QB– were indicated by two significant hyperfine couplings seen in 1H-ENDOR using M266HC mutant RCs, which provide a high yield of Zn-replacement of the Fe (Lubitz and Feher, 1999). Both lines disappeared when subjected to D2O/H2O, one much faster than the other, as also seen for QA–. (Note, however, that M266HC mutant RCs exhibit much greater proton lability than WT RCs — see Footnote 4). Only one set of 14N-nuclear quadrupole parameters have been detected for QB–, assigned to the NδH of a histidine (Lendzian et al., 1996), but the absence of any additional resonances is not diagnostic. Indeed, the almost equal spin densities on the carbonyls strongly imply hydrogen bonds of similar strength at each carbonyl oxygen, but the proton hyperfine coupling to QB– has not yet been evaluated with the sophistication applied to QA–. The X-ray structures, which show at least two and possibly three H-bond donors to the C1=O carbonyl, suggest that a refined analysis of the geometry may be difficult. However, Paddock et al. (2007) have identified a new hyperfine coupling in Q-band ENDOR, which they assign to H-bonding from Ser L223 on the basis of comparisons with mutant RCs. They used a quintuple mutant lacking QA but able to reduce QB through the normally inactive B-pathway, both at room temperature and at low temperature. The novel hfc was seen when the state P+QB– is permanently trapped in the quintuple mutant by illuminating while freezing, but not when P+QB– is generated de novo at low temperature, nor in the light trapped state in RCs with Ser L223 mutated to Ala. It was suggested that the coupling reflects a hydrogen bond between Ser L223 and QB– contributes to stabilizing the semiquinone state when formed at permissive temperatures. However, it was previously shown for
Colin A. Wraight and Marilyn R. Gunner wild-type RCs, using high-field ENDOR, that there is no detectable difference between the stable, freezetrapped P+QB– state and one generated by a different illumination regime that decays non-exponentially in 10 –100 s at low temperature (Utschig et al., 2005). This suggests that stabilization is contributed by multiple factors. 2. Vibrational Spectroscopy of QB– In contrast to the QB spectrum, the major features of the QB– semiquinone IR spectrum are largely agreed upon (Breton et al., 1995; Brudler et al., 1995). As with QA–, QB– is unprotonated. The main peak at 1479 cm–1 arises from both C– –O groups, which remain equivalent in 18O and uniform 13C-labeling. The position of this band is at higher frequency than those of QA– (1466 and 1445 cm–1), consistent with weaker hydrogen bonding for QB–. Upon uniform 13C-labeling, the 1479 cm–1 band downshifts by ≈ 52 cm–1, showing this mode to be strongly coupled to C– –C modes (Breton et al., 1995). Selective 13C-labeling at either C1 or C4 shifts and splits the C– –O band equivalently, with new peaks at 1438 and ≈1417 cm–1 (possibly shifted from a minor band at 1461 cm–1) confirming the near equivalence of the two C– –O (and C=O) environments. However, specific labeling at C5 and C6 gave no significant isotopic shifts in the semiquinone anion band (Brudler et al., 1995). This may indicate that the C– –O/C– –C coupling is so extensive over the ring system as to dilute any single atom labeling below detection. Alternatively, the C– –O/C– –C coupling might involve the C2– –C3 bond only. The C– –C and ring modes of the QB– semiquinone are weak but are tentatively assigned, with varying admixtures of C– –O, at 1490, 1461, 1441 and 1422 cm–1, similar to QA–. Also similarly to QA–, QB– exhibits a strong resonance Raman band at 1613 cm–1 (C– –C) (Zhao et al., 1997b) that is not seen in the IR spectrum. V. Functionality of the Two Quinone Positions in the QB Site The motion of QB between the distal and proximal positions was suggested to represent a rate limiting ‘gating’ event that precedes the first electron transfer from QA– (Stowell et al., 1997; Graige et al., 1998), but its functional significance has been challenged by subsequent crystal structures, and by FTIR and kinetic studies. Currently (Spring 2007) there are 12
Chapter 20
Acceptor Quinones of Purple Photosynthetic Bacteria
structures with resolution ≤2.8 Å with the quinone in the inner, proximal site, 12 with it in the outer distal site and 10 with no quinone. One structure (1s00) is modeled with a 50:50 mixture of distal and proximal position. While the structures frozen in the light (2bns, 1dv3, and 1aig) have the quinone in the proximal position, a number of dark structures do as well. At slightly lower resolution, Schiffer and colleagues found that RCs in the trigonal crystal form frozen in the dark exhibit a 4:1 proximal:distal configuration (Pokkuluri et al., 2004). It was noted that the quinone position may be sensitive to the crystal packing (the Stowell structure is from tetragonal crystals), to whether the measurements are made at room temperature or in frozen crystals, and to the presence of cryoprotectant (Pokkuluri et al., 2004). Fritzsch et al. (2002) have found both quinone positions occupied in the dark adapted structure and an increased occupancy of proximal quinone in the ‘charge separated’ protein. This may be partly dependent on the length of the tail as UQ-2 appears to be more localized in the proximal site of Blc. viridis RCs (2prc) than UQ-9 (Lancaster, 1998). However, time resolved X-ray diffraction studies of Blc. viridis RCs have shown that long tail quinone (native UQ-9 and reconstituted UQ-10) can be in the proximal site in the light or dark, with no change in occupancy of the proximal position at least during a 6 s cycle time (Baxter et al., 2004). Also, Rba. sphaeroides RCs with a mutation of Pro L209 to Tyr have been found to have the quinone in the proximal position, while for mutation to Phe or Glu it is mostly distal (Kuglstatter et al., 2001); nevertheless the first electron transfer reaction is very similar in mutants that exhibit quite different occupancies of the two QB sites (Tandori et al., 1999, 2002) even at cryogenic temperatures (Xu et al., 2002). Simulations have suggested that the relative occupancy of the distal and proximal positions is influenced by the ionization state of acidic residues such as Glu L212 and Asp L213 in the QB site (Grafton and Wheeler, 1999; Zachariae and Lancaster, 2001; Taly et al., 2003). This is very weakly supported, if at all, by crystallographic studies (Koepke et al., 2007). Computational analyses of the Em of the ubiquinone in the distal and proximal sites support the assumption that only the proximal site can support quinone reduction, i.e., the free energy for quinone reduction is calculated to be significantly more unfavorable than in the proximal site (Rabenstein et al., 2000; Zhu and Gunner, 2005). The ability to move
397
from the distal to proximal sites has been subjected to modeling and molecular dynamics simulations. With the quinone headgroup in the proximal-like orientation, i.e., with O1 directed towards His L190, translation encounters no significant barriers and QB can very rapidly equilibrate between the two sites (Grafton and Wheeler, 1999), although translation could be controlled by other features of the protein conformation including protonation (Walden and Wheeler, 2002). Molecular mechanics calculations on QB translation in Blc. viridis RCs showed that there is a significant barrier if the quinone must flip over while confined in or near the distal binding site (Zachariae and Lancaster, 2001). However, it may be that the quinone simply leaves the protein if it enters the binding channel incorrectly. Spectroscopic studies also provide strong argument against a kinetic role or relevance of the distal to proximal motion in QB reduction. First, the Pro L209→Tyr mutant discussed above, for which the X-ray crystal structure shows a proximal QB position, yields a single C=O IR frequency for QB (1641 cm–1), essentially unchanged from the wild type (Breton et al., 2002). An extensive FTIR study of wild type RCs also showed no difference in the QB/QB– spectrum when activated at room temperature (when such motion would be allowed) or at 90K after freezing in the light (when QB would be trapped in the light-activated, proximal position) (Breton, 2004). These results do not support the occurrence of one hydrogen bonded and one non-bonded C=O in the wild type RC. Kinetic behavior also mitigates against a functionally significant influence of the proximal-distal transition. Short chain ubiquinones have been cited as favoring the proximal position (Lancaster and Michel, 1996a, 1997), possibly consistent with a proposed anticooperative influence of the headgroup and hydrocarbon tail on binding (McComb et al., 1990). However, the length of the tail has no significant effect on the first electron transfer rate, kAB(1), at room temperature (McComb et al., 1990), and the rate and temperature dependence are the same in RCs with UQ-10 and UQ-1 down to 160 K (Xu and Gunner, 2002). On the other hand, UQ-0, lacking any substituent at position 6, exhibits significant differences in the FTIR spectrum, indicating some difference in binding configuration (Breton et al., 1994b). UQ-0 also has a two-fold larger first electron transfer equilibrium constant, K(1) AB, than the tailed ubiquinones (McComb et al., 1990). Finally, in chromatophore membranes of Rba.
398 capsulatus, Lavergne et al. (1999) found that the first and second electron transfers exhibit essentially identical kinetic properties. Since QB is clearly bound proximally (as QB–) for the second electron transfer, they argue that neither electron transfer is gated by any physical motion of the quinone, in vivo. Thus, in spite of the clear evidence for proximal and distal binding in many X-ray crystal structures, the preponderance of computational, spectroscopic and time resolved studies indicate that the movement, per se, does not have an essential role in single turnover studies, and is not generally seen in multiple turnovers required for signal averaging. Thus, the equilibrium position for quinone binding must generally favor the proximal position. Indeed, it may be that the distribution of distal:proximal occupancy can be modulated by factors unique to the crystallization procedure. Nevertheless, some non-electron transfer event does control the first electron transfer in RCs, as the major phases of this reaction are independent of the driving force (Graige et al., 1998). The nature of these changes, be they changes in protonation or hydrogen bonding networks in surrounding residues, or other conformational changes, remains an open question. VI. Conclusions Ultimately, the functional behavior and properties of the acceptor quinones arise from the environment provided by the protein. This, however, is not a static entity. As impressive and beguiling as the structural pictures are, a great deal of uncertainty resides in the interpretation of the spectroscopic markers, and the relationship between structure and the function of the acceptor quinones is still obscure. This is both exciting and frustrating, but reflects the complexity of events that are intimately coupled to protein conformational dynamics and to the solution through proton uptake. It is certainly clear that a great deal of work remains for us to understand ‘structure-function’ in this system, and the structural data must be supported and extended by computation and spectroscopy, in order to develop the energetics and dynamics of the interactions.
Colin A. Wraight and Marilyn R. Gunner that QA may move upon reduction, have gained some experimental support from two separate high-field, pulsed EPR studies, reported in 2007, although they are not in full agreement. Using orientation-resolved pulsed electron dipolar high-field EPR spectroscopy, Möbius and coworkers (Savitsky et al., 2007) have determined the relative orientations of the partners in the spin-correlated state of P+QA– of dark frozen RC samples at 150 K. Comparison of the positions and relative orientations of the precursor cofactors, P and QA, known from X-ray crystallography, shows a small (14°) rotation of the QA– headgroup around the x-axis (joining the carbonyl groups) compared to QA. In contrast, Kothe and coworkers (Heinen, et al., 2007) determined the structure of P+QA–, within 200 nanoseconds of flash photoexcitation from dark frozen RC samples at 70 K, using time-resolved (high time resolution) high-field EPR. Their results show a 60° rotation about the QA– z-axis (normal to the ring plane), relative to the quinone position seen in crystal structures. They suggest that the structure they observe represents the ‘initial’ neutral QA position prior to photoexcitation of the RC, and the 60° rotation constitutes the event that gates electron transfer from QA– to QB. Such a significant motion is likely to alter the H-bonding interactions at one or both carbonyl groups. It may be worth noting that the first crystal structure of Rba. sphaeroides RCs showed QA in position to H-bond between C4=O and Thr M222 rather than His M219 (Allen et al., 1988). Also, molecular dynamics simulations can result in switching the H-bond from His M219 to Thr M222 (L.Rinyuand P. Maróti, personal communication). To account for the position of QA determined from the crystal structure, Heinen et al. (2007) suggest that radiation-induced chemistry may lead to a reduced QA, in many X-ray structures, and this could explain the observation that the crystal structures are similar for room temperature and low temperature; as otherwise, the proposed gating mechanism of Heinen et al. (2007) would seem to require that the rotation of QA– occurs at low temperature. Regardless, these new studies reinforce the conclusion, above, that much remains to be learned in this seemingly welldefined system. Acknowledgments
Note Added in Proof The calculations of Fritscher et al. (2006), suggesting
The preparation of this chapter was supported by NSF grant MCB 03-44449 to CAW, and by USDA
Chapter 20
Acceptor Quinones of Purple Photosynthetic Bacteria
grant CREES 2003-02123 to MRG. Infrastructure support from NIH 5G12 RR03060 (National Center for Research Resources) to MRG is also gratefully acknowledged. References Abresch EC, Paddock ML, Stowell MHB, McPhillips TM, Axelrod HL, Soltis SM, Rees DC, Okamura MY and Feher G (1998) Identification of proton transfer pathways in the X-ray crystal structure of the bacterial reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Photosynth Res 55: 119–125 Alexov E and Gunner MR (1999) Calculated protein and proton motions coupled to electron transfer: Electron transfer from QA– to QB in bacterial photosynthetic reaction centers. Biochemistry 38: 8254–8270 Alexov E, Miksovska J, Baciou L, Schiffer M, Hanson DK, Sebban P and Gunner MR (2000) Modeling effects of mutations on the free energy of the first electron transfer from QA– to QB in photosynthetic reaction centers. Biochemistry 39: 5940–5952 Allen JP, Feher G, Yeates TO, Komiya H and Rees DC (1987a) Structure of the reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26: The cofactors. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 84: 5730–5734 Allen JP, Feher G, Yeates TO, Komiya H and Rees DC (1987b) Structure of the reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26: The protein subunits. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 84: 6162–6166 Allen JP, Feher G, Yeates TO, Komiya H and Rees DC (1988) Structure of the Reaction Center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26: Protein-cofactor (quinones and Fe2+) Interactions. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 85: 8487–8491 Allen JP, Williams JC, Graige M, Paddock ML, Labahn A, Feher G and Okamura MY (1998) Free energy dependence of the direct charge recombination from the primary and secondary quinones in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Photosynth Res 55: 227–233 Arnold W and Clayton RK (1960) The first step in photosynthesis: Evidence for its electronic nature. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 46: 769–776 Arnoux B, Gaucher JF, Ducruix A and Reiss-Husson F (1995) Structure of the photochemical-reaction center of a spheroidenecontaining purple bacterium, Rhodobacter sphaeroides Y, at 3 Å resolution. Acta Crystallographica D 51: 368–379 Badger RM and Bauer SH (1937) Spectroscopic studies of the hydrogen bond. II. The shift of the O-H vibrational frequency in the formation of the hydrogen bond. J Chem Phys 5: 839–851 Bauscher M and Mäntele W (1992) Electrochemical and infraredspectroscopic characterization of redox reactions of p-quinones. J Phys Chem 96: 11101–11108 Baxter RHG, Ponomarenko N, Srajer V, Pahl R, Moffat K and Norris JR (2004) Time-resolved crystallographic studies of light-induced structural changes in the photosynthetic reaction center. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 101: 5982–5987 Bellamy LJ (1968) Advances in Infrared Group Frequencies. Methuen & Co. Ltd, London Bellamy LJ (1975) The Infrared Spectra of Complex Molecules. Chapman and Hall, London, New York
399
Bellamy LJ and Pace RJ (1970) Hydrogen bonding in alcohols and phenols. III. Hydrogen bonds between alcohols and carbonyl groups. Spectrochimica Acta A 27: 705–713 Beroza P, Fredkin DR, Okamura MY and Feher G (1995) Electrostatic calculations of amino acid titration electron transfer, QA–QB → QAQB–, in the reaction center. Biophys J 68: 2233–2250 Blankenship RE and Parson WW (1979) The involvement of iron and ubiquinone in electron transfer reactions mediated by reaction centers from photosynthetic bacteria. Biochim Biophys Acta 545: 429–444 Bloom H, Briggs LH and Cleverley B (1959) Physical properties of anthraquinone and its derivatives. Part I. Infrared spectra. J Chem Soc 1959: 178–185 Boesch SE and Wheeler RA (1997) Structures and properties of ubiquinone-1 and its radical anion predicted from a hybrid Hartree-Fock/density functional method. J Phys Chem A 101: 5799–5804 Bosch MK, Gast P, Hoff AJ, Spoyalov AP and Tsvetkov YD (1995) The primary acceptor quinone QA in reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides R26 is hydrogen bonded to the Nδ(1)-H of His M219. An electron spin echo study of QA–•. Chem Phys Lett 239: 306–312 Boullais C, Nabedryk E, Burie J-R, Nonella M, Mioskowski C and Breton J (1998) Site-specific isotope labeling demonstrates a large mesomeric resonance effect of the methoxy groups on the carbonyl frequency in ubiquinones. Photosynth Res 55: 247–252 Breen, DL (1975) Coenzyme Q: A molecular orbital study. J Theor Biol 53: 101–113 Breton J (2004) Absence of large-scale displacement of quinone QB in bacterial photosynthetic reaction centers. Biochemistry 43: 3318–3326 Breton J and Nabedryk E (1995) Protein and bacteriopheophytin response to QA reduction in photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers from Rb. sphaeroides and Rp. viridis investigated by 1 H/2H exchange and light-induced FTIR difference spectroscopy. In: Mathis P (ed) Photosynthesis: From Light to Biosphere, Vol I, pp 395–400. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Breton J and Nabedryk E (1996) Protein-quinone interactions in the bacterial photosynthetic reaction center: Light-induced FTIR difference spectroscopy of the quinone vibrations. Biochim Biophys Acta 1275: 84–90 Breton J, Boullais C, Burie J, Nabedryk E and Mioskowski C (1994a) Binding sites of quinones in photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers investigated by light-induced FTIR difference spectroscopy: Assignment of the interactions of each carbonyl of QA in Rhodobacter sphaeroides using site-specific 13C-labeled ubiquinone. Biochemistry 33: 14378–14386 Breton J, Burie J, Boullais C, Berger G and Nabedryk E (1994b) Binding sites of quinones in photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers investigated by light-induced FTIR difference spectroscopy: Binding of chainless symmetrical quinones to the QA site of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 33: 12405–12415 Breton J, Burie J-R, Berthomieu C, Berger G and Nabedryk E (1994c) The binding sites of quinones in photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers investigated by light-induced FTIR difference spectroscopy: Assignment of the QA vibrations in Rhodobacter sphaeroides using 18O- or 13C-labeled ubiquinone and vitamin K1. Biochemistry 33: 4953–4965 Breton J, Boullais C, Berger G, Mioskowski C and Nabedryk E
400 (1995) Binding sites of quinones in photosynthetic bacterial reaction centers investigated by light induced FTIR difference spectroscopy: symmetry of the carbonyl interactions and close equivalence of the QB vibrations in Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Rhodopseudomonas viridis probed by isotopic labeling. Biochemistry 34: 11606–11616 Breton J, Boullais C, Mioskowski C, Sebban P, Baciou L and Nabedryk E (2002) Vibrational spectroscopy favors a unique QB binding site at the proximal position in wild-type reaction centers and in the Pro-L209→Tyr mutant from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 41: 12921–12927 Breton J, Wakeham MC, Fyfe PK, Jones MR and Nabedryk E (2004) Characterization of the bonding interactions of QB upon photoreduction via A-branch or B-branch electron transfer in mutant reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochim Biophys Acta 1656: 127–138 Breton J, Lavergne J, Wakeham MC, Nabedryk E and Jones MR (2007) The unusually strong hydrogen bond between the carbonyl of QA and His M219 in the Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction center is not essential for efficient electron transfer from QA– to QB. Biochemistry 46: 6468–6476 Bruce BD, Fuller RC and Blankenship RE (1982) Primary photosynthesis in the facultative aerobic green photosynthetic bacterium Chloroflexus aurantiacus. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 79: 6532–6536 Brudler R, de Groot HJM, van Liemt WBS, Steggerda WF, Esmeijer R, Gast P, Hoff AJ, Lugtenburg J and Gerwert K (1994) Asymmetric binding of the 1- and 4-C=O groups of QA in Rhodobacter sphaeroides R26 reaction centers monitored by Fourier transform infra-red spectroscopy using site-specific isotopically labelled ubiquinone-10. EMBO J 13: 5523–5530 Brudler R, de Groot HJM, van Liemt WBS, Hoff AJ, Lugtenburg JL and Gerwert K (1995) FTIR spectroscopy shows weak symmetric hydrogen bonding of the QB carbonyl groups in Rhodobacter sphaeroides R26 reaction centres. FEBS Lett 370: 2–14 Burie J-R, Boussac A, Boullas C, Berger G, Mattioli T, Mioskowski C, Nabedryk E and Breton J (1995) FTIR spectroscopy of UVgenerated quinone radicals: Evidence for an intramolecular hydrogen atom transfer in ubiquinone, naphthoquinone, and plastoquinone. J Phys Chem B 99: 4059–4070 Burie J-R, Boullais C, Nonella M, Mioskowski C, Nabedryk E and Breton J (1997) Importance of the conformation of methoxy groups on the vibrational and electrochemical properties of ubiquinones. J Phys Chem B 101: 6607–6617 Burley SK and Petsko GA (1985) Aromatic-aromatic interaction: A mechanism of protein structure stabilization. Science 229: 23–28 Butler WF, Johnston DC, Shore HB, Fredkin DR, Okamura MY and Feher G (1980) The electronic structure of Fe2+ in reaction centers from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides I. Static magnetization measurements. Biophys J 32: 967–992 Butler WF, Calvo R, Fredkin DR, Isaacson RA, Okamura MY and Feher G (1984) The electronic structure of Fe2+ in reaction centers from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides III. EPR measurements of the reduced acceptor complex. Biophys J 45: 947–973 Chang C-H, El-Kabbani O, Tiede D, Norris J and Schiffer M (1991) Structure of the membrane-bound protein photosynthetic reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 30: 5352–5360
Colin A. Wraight and Marilyn R. Gunner Chirino AJ, Lous EJ, Huber M, Allen JP, Schenck CC, Paddock ML, Feher G and Rees DC (1994) Crystallographic analyses of site-directed mutants of the photosynthetic reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Biochemistry 33: 4584–4593 Coleman WJ, Bylina EJ and Youvan DC (1990a) Reconstitution of photochemical activity in Rhodobacter capsulatus reaction centers containing mutations at trytophan M-250 in the primary quinone binding site. In: Baltscheffsky M (ed) Current Research in Photosynthesis, Vol 1, pp 149–152. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Coleman WJ, Youvan DC, Aumeier W, Eberl U, Volk M, Lang E, Siegl J, Heckmann R, Lersch W, Ogrodnik A and Michel-Beyerle ME (1990b) How conclusive is mutagenic replacement of Trp M250 in photosynthetic reaction centers? In: Baltscheffsky M (ed) Current Research in Photosynthesis, Vol 1, pp 153–156. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht De Groot HJM (1995) Asymmetric primary quinone hydrogen bonding in Rhodobacter sphaeroides reaction centers. In: Mathis P (ed) Photosynthesis: From Light to Biosphere, I, pp 401–406. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht Deisenhofer J and Michel H (1989a) The photosynthetic reaction center from the purple bacterium Rhodopseudomonas viridis. Science 245: 1463–1473 Deisenhofer J and Michel H (1989b) The photosynthetic reaction centre from the purple bacterium Rhodopseudomonas viridis. EMBO J 8: 2149–2170 Deisenhofer J and Michel H (1991) High-resolution structures of photosynthetic reaction centers. Annu Rev Biophys Chem 20: 247–266 Deisenhofer J, Epp O, Miki R, Huber R and Michel H (1985) Structure of the protein subunits in the photosynthetic reaction center of Rhodopseudomonas viridis at 3 Å resolution. Nature 318: 618–624 Deng H and Callender R (1999) Raman spectroscopic studies of the structure, energetics, and bond distortions of substrates bound to enzymes. Methods Enzymol 308: 176–201 DeVault D (1980) Quantum-mechanical tunneling in biological systems. Q Rev Biophys 13: 387–564 El-Kabbani O, Chang C-H, Tiede D, Norris J and Schiffer M (1991) Comparison of reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Rhodopseudomonas viridis: Overall architecture and protein-pigment interactions. Biochemistry 30: 5361–5369 Ermler U, Fritzsch G, Buchanan SK and Michel H (1994) Structure of the photosynthetic reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides at 2.65 Å resolution: Cofactors and protein-cofactor interactions. Structure 2: 925–936 Feher G, Okamura MY and McElroy JD (1972) Identification of an electron acceptor in reaction centers of Rhodopseudomonas spheroides by EPR spectroscopy. Biochim Biophys Acta 267: 222–226 Feher G, Isaacson RA, Okamura MY and Lubitz W (1985) ENDOR of semiquinones in reaction centers from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. In: Michel-Beyerle ME (ed) Antennas and Reaction Centers of Photosynthetic Bacteria—Structure, Interactions and Dynamics, pp 174–189. Springer-Verlag, Berlin Feher G, Isaacson RA, Okamura MY and Lubitz W (1988). ENDOR of exchangeable protons of the reduced intermediate acceptor in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26. In: Breton J and Verméglio A (eds) The Photosynthetic Bacterial Reaction Center, Cadarache, France, Plenum Press
Chapter 20
Acceptor Quinones of Purple Photosynthetic Bacteria
Ferreira KN, Iverson TM, Maghlaoui K, Barber J and Iwata S (2004) Architecture of the photosynthetic oxygen-evolving center. Science 303: 1831–1838 Fisher N and Rich PR (2000) A motif for quinone binding sites in respiratory and photosynthetic systems. J Mol Biol 296: 1153–1162 Flett MSC (1948) The application of infra-red spectroscopy to structural problems in the anthraquinone field. J Chem Soc 1948: 1441–1448 Flores M, Isaacson RA, Calvo R, Feher G and Lubitz W (2003) Probing hydrogen bonding to quinone anion radicals by 1H and 2H ENDOR spectroscopy at 35 GHz. Chem Phys 294: 401–413 Flores M, Isaacson R, Abresch E, Calvo R, Lubitz W and Feher G (2006) Protein-cofactor interactions in bacterial reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26: I. Identification of the ENDOR lines associated with the hydrogen bonds to the primary quinone QA–. Biophys J 90: 3356–3362 Flores M, Isaacson R, Abresch E, Calvo R, Lubitz W and Feher G (2007) Protein-cofactor interactions in bacterial reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26: II. Geometry of the hydrogen bonds to the primary quinone QA•– by 1H and 2H ENDOR spectroscopy. Biophys J 92: 671–682 Franzen S, Goldstein RF and Boxer SG (1990) Electric field modulation of electron transfer reaction rates in isotropic systems: Long distance charge recombination in photosynthetic reaction centers. J Phys Chem 94: 5135–5149 Fritscher J, Prisner TF and MacMillan F (2006) Theoretical investigation of QA–ligand interactions in bacterial reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Appl Mag Res 30: 251–268 Fritzsch G, Koepke J, Diem R, Kuglstatter A and Baciou L (2002) Charge separation induces conformational changes in the photosynthetic reaction centre of purple bacteria. Acta Cryst D 58: 1660–1663 Gast P, Michalski, TJ, Hunt JE and Norris JR (1985) Determination of the amount and the type of quinones present in single crystals from reaction center protein from the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodopseudomonas viridis. FEBS Lett 179: 325–328 Giangiacomo KM and Dutton PL (1989) In photosynthetic reaction centers, the free energy difference for electron transfer between quinones bound at the primary and secondary quinonebinding sites governs the observed secondary site specificity. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 86: 2658–2662 Gordy W (1940) Spectroscopic evidence for hydrogen bonds: Effects of chelation on the carbonyl frequency. J Chem Phys 8: 516–519 Grafton AK and Wheeler RA (1999) Amino acid protonation states determine binding sites of the secondary ubiquinone and its anion in the Rhodobacter sphaeroides photosynthetic reaction center. J Phys Chem B 103: 5380–5387 Graige MS, Paddock ML, Bruce JM, Feher G and Okamura MY (1996) Mechanism of proton-coupled electron transfer for quinone (QB) reduction in reaction centers of Rb. sphaeroides. J Am Chem Soc 118: 9005–9016 Graige MS, Feher G and Okamura MY (1998) Conformational gating of the electron transfer reaction QA– •QB → QAQB– • in bacterial reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides determined by a driving force assay. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 95: 11679–11684 Graige MS, Paddock ML, Feher G and Okamura MY (1999) Observation of the protonated semiquinone intermediate in
401
isolated reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Implications for the mechanism of electron and proton transfer in proteins. Biochemistry 38: 11465–11473 Gunner MR and Dutton PL (1989) Temperature and –∆G dependence of the electron transfer from BPh•– to QA in reaction center protein from Rhodobacter sphaeroides with different quinones as QA. J Am Chem Soc 111: 3400–3412. Gunner MR, Braun BS, Bruce JM and Dutton PL (1985) The characterization of the QA binding site of the reaction center of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides. In: Michel-Beyerle ME (ed) Antennas and Reaction Centers of Photosynthetic Bacteria: Structure, Interactions and Dynamics, pp 298–304. SpringerVerlag, Berlin Gunner MR, Robertson DE and Dutton PL (1986) Kinetic studies on the reaction center protein from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides: The temperature and free energy dependence of electron transfer between various quinones in the QA site and the oxidized bacteriochlorophyll dimer. J Phys Chem 90: 3783–3795 Gunner MR, Saleh MA, Cross E, ud-Doula A and Wise M (2000) Backbone dipoles generate positive potential in all proteins: Origins and implications of the effect. Biophys J 78: 1126-1144 Heathcote P, Fyfe PK and Jones MR (2002) Reaction centres: The structure and evolution of biological solar power. Trends Biochem Sci 27: 79–87 Heinen U, Utschig LM, Poluektov OG, Link G, Ohmes E and Kothe G (2007) Structure of the charge separated state P865+QA– in the phootosynthetic reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides by quantum beat oscillations and high-field electron paramagnetic resonance: Evidence for light-induced QA– reorientation. J Am Chem Soc 129: 15935–15946 Hucke O, Schmid R and Labahn A (2002) Exploring the primary electron acceptor (QA)-site of the bacterial reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Binding mode of vitamin K derivatives. Eur J Biochem 269: 1096–1108 Isaacson RA, Lendzian F, Abresch C, Lubitz W and Feher G (1995) Electronic structure of Q–A in reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. I. Electron paramagnetic resonance in single crystals. Biophys J 69: 311–322 Isaacson RA, Abresch EC, Lendzian F, Boullais C, Paddock ML, Mioskowski C, Lubitz W and Feher G (1996). Asymmetry of the binding sites of QA– and QB– in reaction centers of Rb. sphaeroides probed by Q-Band EPR with 13C-labeled quinones. In: Michel-Beyerle ME (ed) The Reaction Center of Photosynthetic Bacteria: Structure and Dynamics, pp 353–368. Springer-Verlag, Berlin Ishikita H, Morra G and Knapp E-W (2003) Redox potential of quinones in photosynthetic reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Dependence on protonation of Glu-L212 and Asp-L213. Biochemistry 42: 3882–3892 Kacprzak S and Kaupp M (2004) Electronic g-tensors of semiquinones in photosynthetic reaction centers. A density functional study. J Phys Chem B 108: 2464–2469 Katona G, Snijder A, Gourdon P, Andréasson U, Hansson Ö, Andréasson L-E and Neutze R (2005) Conformational regulation of charge recombination in a photosynthetic bacterial reaction center. Nature Struct Mol Biol 12: 630-631 Kaupp M (2002) The function of Photosystem I. Quantum chemical insight into the role of tryptophan-quinone interactions. Biochemistry 41: 2895–2900
402 Kim J, Mao J and Gunner MR (2005) Are acidic and basic groups in buried proteins predicted to be ionized? J Mol Biol 348: 1283–1298 Kirmaier C and Holten D (1990) Evidence that a distribution of bacterial reaction centers underlies the temperature and detection-wavelength dependence of the rates of the primary electrontransfer reactions. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 87: 3552–3556 Kleinfeld D, Okamura MY and Feher G (1984a) Electron-transfer kinetics in photosynthetic reaction centers cooled to cryogenic temperatures in the charge separated state: Evidence for lightinduced structural changes. Biochemistry 23: 5780–5786 Kleinfeld D, Okamura MY and Feher G (1984b) Electron transfer in reaction centers of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides: I. Determination of the charge recombination pathway of D+QAQB– and free energy and kinetic relations between QA– QB and QAQB–. Biochim Biophys Acta 766: 126–140 Koepke J, Krammer EM, Klingen AR, Sebban P, Ullmann GM and Fritzsch G (2007) pH modulates the quinone position in the photosynthetic reaction center from Rhodobacter sphaeroides in the neutral and charge separated states. J Mol Biol 371: 396–409 Krivanek R, Kern J, Zouni A, Dau H and Haumann M (2007) Spare quinones in the QB cavity of crystallized Photosystem II from Thermosynechococcus elongatus. Biochim Biophys Acta 1767: 520–527 Kruk J, Strzalka K and Leblanc RM (1993) Fourier transform infrared studies on charge-transfer interactions of plastoquinones and α-tocopherol quinone with their hydroquinone forms and monogalactosyldiacylglycerol. Biophysical Chemistry 45: 235–244 Kuglstatter A, Ermler U, Michel H, Baciou L and Fritzsch G (2001) X-ray structure analysis of photosynthetic reaction center variants from Rhodobacter sphaeroides: Structural changes induced by point mutations at position L209 modulate electron and proton transfer. Biochemistry 40: 4253–4260 Labahn A, Bruce JM, Okamura MY and Feher G (1995) Direct charge recombination from D+QAQB– to DQAQB in bacterial reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides containing low potential quinone in the QA site. Chem Phys 197: 355–366 Laible PD, Kirmaier C, Udawatte CS, Hofman SJ, Holten D and Hanson DK (2003) Quinone reduction via secondary Bbranch electron transfer in mutant bacterial reaction centers. Biochemistry 42: 1718–1730 Lancaster CRD (1998) Ubiquinone reduction and protonation in photosynthetic reaction centres from Rhodopseudomonas viridis — X-ray structures and their functional implications. Biochim Biophys Acta 1365: 143–150 Lancaster CRD and Michel H (1996a) New Insights into the X-ray structure of the reaction center of Rhodopseudomonas viridis. In: Michel-Beyerle ME (ed) The Reaction Center of Photosynthetic Bacteria: Structure and Dynamics, pp 23–35. Springer-Verlag, Berlin Lancaster CRD and Michel H (1996b) Three-dimensional structures of photosynthetic reaction centers. Photosynth Res 48: 65–74 Lancaster CRD and Michel H (1997) The coupling of lightinduced electron transfer and proton uptake as derived from crystal structures of reaction centres from Rhodopseudomonas viridis modified at the binding site of the secondary quinone, QB. Structure 5: 1339–1359 Lancaster CRD, Michel H, Honig B and Gunner MR (1996)
Colin A. Wraight and Marilyn R. Gunner Calculated coupling of electron and proton transfer in the photosynthetic reaction center of Rhodopseudomonas viridis. Biophys J 70: 2469–2492 Lavergne J, Matthews C and Ginet N (1999) Electron and proton transfer on the acceptor side of the reaction center in chromatophores of Rhodobacter capsulatus: Evidence for direct protonation of the semiquinone state of QB. Biochemistry 38: 4542–4552 Leigh JS and Dutton PL (1972) The primary electron acceptor in photosynthesis. Biochem Biophys Res Comm 46: 414–421 Lendzian F, Rautter J, Käß H, Gardiner A and Lubitz W (1996) ENDOR and pulsed EPR studies of photosynthetic reaction centers: Protein-cofactor interactions. Ber Bunsenges Phys Chem 100: 2036–2040 Li J, Gilroy D, Tiede DM and Gunner MR (1998) Kinetic phases in the electron transfer from P+QA– QB to P+QAQB– and the associated processes in Rhodobacter sphaeroides R-26 reaction centers. Biochemist