The Psychologically Literate Citizen
This page intentionally left blank
The Psychologically Literate Citizen founda...
286 downloads
3286 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
The Psychologically Literate Citizen
This page intentionally left blank
The Psychologically Literate Citizen foundations and global Perspectives
EDITED BY
Jacquelyn Cranney dana s. dunn
1
1 Oxford University Press, Inc., publishes works that further Oxford University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education. Oxfordâ•… New York Aucklandâ•… Cape Townâ•… Dar es Salaamâ•… Hong Kongâ•… Karachi Kuala Lumpurâ•… Madridâ•… Melbourneâ•… Mexico City Nairobiâ•… New Delhiâ•… Shanghaiâ•… Taipeiâ•… Toronto With offices in Argentinaâ•… Austriaâ•… Brazilâ•… Chileâ•… Czech Republicâ•… Franceâ•… Greece Guatemalaâ•… Hungaryâ•… Italyâ•… Japanâ•… Polandâ•… Portugalâ•… Singapore South Koreaâ•… Switzerlandâ•… Thailandâ•… Turkeyâ•… Ukraineâ•… Vietnam
Copyright © 2011 by Oxford University Press, Inc. Published by Oxford University Press, Inc. 198 Madison Avenue, New York, New York 10016 www.oup.com Oxford is a registered trademark of Oxford University Press Oxford University Press is a registered trademark of Oxford University Press, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior permission of Oxford University Press, Inc. ______________________________________________________________ Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data The psychologically literate citizen : foundations and global perspectives / edited by Jacquelyn Cranney, Dana S. Dunn. â•… p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN-13: 978-0-19-979494-2 (hardcover) 1. Psychology—Study and teaching (Higher) 2. Psychology. I. Cranney, Jacquelyn. II. Dunn, Dana. BF77.P758 2011 150.71—dc22 2010053151 ______________________________________________________________ 1╇ 2╇ 3╇ 4╇ 5╇ 6╇ 7╇ 8╇ 9 Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper
We dedicate this volume to the participants of the “Blueprint” project, and to undergraduate psychology students across the world—may the future be yours.
This page intentionally left blank
F o r e wo r d
The P ro m i s e a n d P e r ils o f T h i n k i n g L i k e a P s y ch ol og i s t How wonderful it is to have a volume on the newly emerging construct of psychological literacy. Psychological literacy often starts in the first course in psychology. Introductory Psychology is one of the most popular courses in many universities, and psychology, for many years, has been among the most popular undergraduate majors. If students are going to learn about psychology, why not use it? Why not learn more than just the facts of psychology, but also how to think like a psychologist? In this foreword, I discuss five major challenges of psychological literacy with which we all need to reckon.
1. When Today’s Psychological Literacy Is Tomorrow’s Psychological Illiteracy I came of age as an undergraduate in the waning days of behaviorism, but B. F. Skinner and his cohort were still extremely influential in education and even childrearing. The influence was not merely metaphorical: one year I studied English grammar using a text that was based on Skinnerian learning principles. Although John Watson’s claim that he could transform any child into any type of adult he wanted was not taken wholly seriously, many behavioral (and other) psychologists believed in the almost unlimited power of the environment to shape behavior. Well, that was only my first semester of intro psych. My second semester was a largely Freudian introduction to clinical psychology. My professor put us into a large T-group and, when no one started speaking, he said, “You expect me to be the penis of the group.” That comment did, indeed, get the discussion going. Many of the views—Skinnerian, Freudian, or whatever—that would have constituted psychological literacy then would be considered rather quaint today. Alfred Hitchcock’s Spellbound, for example, was based on Freudian notions of psychology, as were countless other movies of an earlier era. Many of Woody Allen’s films would be impossible to understand without understanding Freud. In the humanities, Freud still plays a dominant role in certain literary criticism, and countless
Foreword
viii
intimate relationships no doubt have been analyzed in terms of Freud’s concepts of the oral, anal, and Oedipus complexes. But going around spouting Skinner or Freud does not have the same cachet in psychology that it once had. So one danger is that today’s psychological literacy will be tomorrow’s psychological illiteracy. We may find that our use of psychological concepts in our daily life will, at some future time, appear to be quaint at best, and misguided at worst. Thankfully, the conceptualization of psychological literacy includes the critical importance of life-long learning (see, for example, the chapters by Cranney and colleagues, and Cranney & Morris), so ideally those who receive a quality undergraduate education in psychology will have the mindset of periodically checking on the currency of the psychological principles they learned during their undergraduate years.
2. The Risks of Over-analysis Anyone who plays golf or tennis knows that there are few better ways to make bad shots than to think carefully and reflectively as one is making a shot. Analyzing the shot as one makes it destroys the shot. The danger of psychology is that one can over-analyze one’s life and the lives of others. Many years ago, I was at a conference and found myself in a curious informal dispute with a colleague. He was a developmental psychologist and said that he and his wife, also a developmental psychologist, religiously applied what they knew about developmental psychology to raising their children. He thought, in particular, that their children could have an edge in school over other children if the parents used their knowledge to push the children along at an accelerated pace through the stages of cognitive development. He believed in the Piagetian stages, but not in the idea that the ages at which children arrive at them are fixed. I said that I sometimes applied the ideas, but was reluctant to use psychology in a highly prescriptive way to rush along my children’s cognitive development. I don’t know what ultimately happened to his children or to him. But I do think there are advantages to joy and spontaneity in life that can be lost if one applies one’s psychology too determinedly to one’s life. Indeed, in one of our studies of love and close relationships (Sternberg, Hojjat, & Barnes, 2001), we found that a lover’s story of a loving relationship in which scientific analysis of the relationship is at the forefront of the relationship is not associated with satisfaction and success. Green and colleagues’ chapter on positive psychology and psychological literacy argues for the integration of the science of positive psychology into education; any psychologically literate graduate should appreciate the benefits of creativity and spontaneity in everyday life.
3. Beyond Knowledge Base The first semester of introductory psychology was a rough experience for me. When I took it, in 1968, it was taught in a way that emphasized factual recall. The tests we received were basically assessments of our factual recall. I received a C in the course
Foreword
ix
and the professor informed me that there was one famous Sternberg in psychology and that there was unlikely to be another. Thirty-five years later I was president of the American Psychological Association and commented to my predecessor, Phil Zimbardo, that it was ironic that the president of APA received a C in intro; he told me that he, too, had gotten a C. Ironically, perhaps, the professor who gave me the C was the chair of the search committee that later hired me to return to Yale, and became one of the most valuable colleagues I ever had. I would like to think that the teaching of psychology has changed greatly since 1968–69. Certainly, the content of the course has changed greatly. But from my experience, the teaching methods used are extremely variable across professors and institutions. There are some faculty members who teach it in a way that inspires reflective thinking, and there are others who teach it for memorization of “facts,” many of which, as I said earlier, will quickly become out of date. It is important to teach psychological literacy in our courses because that is what most will stay with our students, not knowledge of picky facts. One needs knowledge to think reflectively, but rote memorization often leads to an inert knowledge base upon which one is unable to draw to think reflectively. The chapters by McGovern and Bernstein in this volume speak to the need for psychology educators to be role models for psychologically literate citizenship, which would also include taking on the approach of scientist-educator, thus acknowledging the literature on the importance of student engagement and the effectiveness of active learning.
4. The Importance of Analytical, Creative, Practical, and Wise Thinking It is tempting to measure outcomes in terms of tests of so-called critical thinking. A recent book, Academically Adrift (Arum & Roksa, 2011), concludes that students learn virtually nothing in college solely on the basis of test results from a test of critical thinking, the Collegiate Learning Assessment (CLA), that is closely akin to the SAT. But there are important outcomes of college, in general, and of the study of psychology, in particular, beyond the development of critical thinking. Some of the skills that psychological instruction should develop that go beyond critical thinking include creative, practical, and wise thinking (Sternberg, 1995, 2010a, 2010b). For example, during recent years, a major conflict among psychologists has been regarding the role psychologists should play in military interrogations. The issues involved relate more to wise and ethical thinking than they do to critical thinking. Psychological literacy needs to involve sensitivity to ethical issues as much as to issues of inferential validity and fallacy. These issues are very engagingly addressed in the current volume in the chapters by Davidson and Morrissey, and by Sokol and Kuebli.
5. The Forest and the Trees Much of one’s professional life is coming to terms with what one is as opposed to what one hoped to be. When I started my career, I was thrilled with the big thinkers
Foreword
x
I observed in the field, such as Roger Brown at Harvard, Irving Janis at Yale, Roger Shepard at Stanford, Paul Meehl at Minnesota, and Bob Zajonc at Michigan, to name just a few. But as the years went by, the focus of psychology seemed to move to ever-smaller problems. More and more, the rewards seemed to be for extremely microscopic analysis, in whatever domain. The era of the big thinkers seemed to be over. Whereas the leaders of the previous generation were known to all psychology students, more and more, thought leaders were known to students only in increasingly more specialized fields. My hope is that the field, in its desire to mimic the natural and especially biological sciences, will not increasingly lose sight of the forest for the trees. Students need to be trained in broad areas of psychology, not just in their own specialized area, and in thinking across areas, rather than only within areas. Many of the greatest thinkers in the field—Herbert Simon, George Miller, and Amos Tversky—became great in part because they worked across disciplinary boundaries. Desire for such breadth is implicit in many of the contributions in this book. Psychological literacy is a good idea, but we need to nurture it, care for it, and sometimes be wary of it, for the reasons I’ve just reviewed. In sum, I am delighted that such an important volume on psychological literacy has appeared, and I hope it will spawn many offspring that will continue to develop this important field. Robert J. Sternberg Oklahoma State University Provost and Senior Vice President Stillwater, Oklahoma
References Arum, R., & Roksa, J. (2011). Academically adrift: limited learning on college campuses. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Sternberg, R. J. (1995). In search of the human mind. Orlando, FL: Harcourt Brace College Publishers. Sternberg, R. J. (2010a). Teaching for ethical reasoning in liberal education. Liberal Education, 96(3), 32–37. Sternberg, R. J. (2010b). WICS: a new model for cognitive education. Journal of Cognitive Education and Psychology, 9, 34–46. Sternberg, R., Hojjat, M., & Barnes, M. L. (2001). Empirical tests of aspects of a theory of love as a story. European Journal of Personality, 15, 199–218.
P r efac e
Our hope for this volume is that undergraduate psychology educators, curriculum designers, and policy creators will be inspired to re-examine the aims of undergraduate psychology education, and as a consequence reshape pedagogy and curriculum, thus better preparing our students for their increasingly uncertain but potentially very exciting futures. This book was inspired by our involvement in the project that produced the volume Undergraduate Education in Psychology: A Blueprint for the Future of the Discipline (Halpern, 2010a). Jacky, who has been involved in national psychology undergraduate education in Australia for several years, was privileged to be invited to contribute to the first chapter, which outlined the two key concepts pursued in this volume, psychologi cal literacy and the psychologically literate citizen (McGovern et al., 2010). Dana has long contributed to policy and guidelines regarding outcomes and assessment in undergraduate psychology education in the United States, and he led the chapter on defining a core curriculum for undergraduate psychology in the “Blueprint” volume (Dunn et al., 2010). The “Blueprint” volume has already been described as a classic in the field, and was thus deserving of immediate follow-up, with the focus being on expanding the theory and practice around the paradigmatic concepts of psychological literacy and the psychologically literate citizen. McGovern and colleagues (2010) explicitly referred to the global implications of those concepts, and the current volume sought to extend the work of the “Blueprint” volume beyond the shores of the United States. Although most of the chapters were written by U.S. and Australian authors, there are several chapters written by education leaders on other continents, and the chapter by Dudgeon and colleagues gives a distinctly non-Western perspective. Essentially, the primary aim of this volume was to provide some answers from across the world on the “why” and “how” of educating the psychologically literate citizen—the proposed universal outcome of the psychology major. That is, this volume extends into global territories of the paradigm-shifting disciplinary movement initiated by the “Blueprint” volume. It simultaneously links traditional approaches and concepts in psychology to these new concepts in a transformative manner, and provides practical suggestions for embedding these concepts in everyday teaching practice.
xii
Preface
In the introductory chapter, we develop further McGovern and colleagues’ (2010) concepts of psychological literacy and the psychologically literate citizen, in particular by making reference to understandings, from diverse sources, of the concepts of literacy, scientific literacy, citizenship, and global citizenship. The section on “Curriculum Perspectives” addresses several key pedagogical and curriculum aspects such as program structure, core content areas, and key skills. Dunn and coworkers open the section with a consideration of how student learning outcomes related to psychological literacy might shape disciplinary curricula for undergraduates, acknowledging the necessary balance between graduate and undergraduate needs, the balance between cutting-edge and core knowledge, and the need to take a more global perspective. In the context of the increasing complexity of current and projected everyday living, Halpern and Butler argue that critical thinking is a core component of psychological literacy, and Davidson and Morrissey argue that “ethical literacy” is a core component of psychologically literate citizenship. Both of these chapters contain examples and clear links to useful classroom teaching strategies, so that educators can immediately start to integrate this material into their curriculum. White evaluates the social psychological research literature on effective prejudice reduction strategies to promote intergroup harmony and then outlines how students can directly experience and learn from these specific evidence-based strategies to reduce intergroup conflict, both within and outside the classroom. Dudgeon and associates give an indigenous perspective on the history of psychology in Australia, and suggest strategies for initiating the development of cultural competence in the undergraduate psychology program. As they argue, there needs to be increased emphasis on the development of cultural competence in an increasingly globalized world, as well as in countries where First Nation peoples are clearly disadvantaged. It should be noted that this volume explicitly attempts to moderate the use of the dominant Western psychology language without undermining the psychological science that must be both the content and the practice of education in psychology. Burton and McDonald point out that psychology educators are uniquely situated to help students develop aspects of psychological literacy (e.g., critical thinking, selfknowledge) that would (a) be helpful in the transition process for all first-year psychology students, regardless of the program they are undertaking, and (b) build toward university aspirational goals of developing “global citizens.” Thus, they argue that the development of psychological literacy should be the primary aim of firstyear psychology courses. Denson and Ing outline developmental psychology and educational psychology theory relevant to understanding the nature of undergraduate students and their learning processes, and particularly as relevant to different forms of diversity in the university context. They then present evidence for the positive association between culturally diverse classrooms and the development of psychologically literate skills such as critical thinking. Green and colleagues argue for the value of a positive psychology approach in the undergraduate curriculum and how this relates to psychological literacy; they then give examples of evidence-based positive psychology interventions within the curriculum. Halonen and associates
Preface
xiii
provide a comprehensive model for assessing psychological literacy, which is conceptualized as a multilayered developmental model. Finally in this section, Cranney and coworkers argue that students should be given the opportunity to purposefully apply the basic principles of psychology to new problems or in new situations, in an experiential and active manner. They briefly consider the background to the issue of “applied” psychology in undergraduate education, and then give some concrete examples of how applied psychology learning and teaching strategies can be implemented to support the development of psychological literacy. In the “Global Perspectives” section, national leaders in undergraduate psychology education were challenged to discuss the relevance of the two concepts from their particular national perspectives. From the Italian perspective, Job and coauthors identify four features that would allow students to develop psychological literacy during their undergraduate education, and include examples of how psychological literacy is being developed and displayed. Sarwono argues that psychology in Indonesia has been fostering psychological literacy in its students, in its researchers, and also in its population (through the popular media) for the past 60 years. Trapp and Akhurst’s chapter considers the challenging concept of citizenship, particularly in the context of current pressures on undergraduate psychology education in the United Kingdom. They argue that existing course specifications and the U.K. benchmark statements define a high level of psychological literacy. Karandashev contrasts the professionally oriented undergraduate programs that have been typical for Russia (as well as for many European and South American countries) with the liberal arts education tradition typical for the United Kingdom, Australia, and North America. He also emphasizes the importance of distinguishing between general and professional psychological literacy, as well as recognizing different conceptualizations of psychological literacy across cultures. Harré and associates point out that the current ecological crisis is of enormous relevance to psychology teaching, as it is essentially a problem of human behavior. They urge psychology educators to consider how they can nurture the psychologically literate citizen through a focus on ecological sustainability, and present four learning and teaching cases designed to increase student psychological literacy in this important area. Charlton and Lymburner consider how educators can foster the development of psychologically literate global citizenship in their psychology students, and discuss how psychological literacy may manifest itself through some of the key social issues facing Canadians today: volunteerism, environmental sustainability, illicit drug use, healthcare, and multiculturalism and diversity. Methods and examples of how to foster psychological literacy are presented through classroom exercises, case studies, and curriculum development. Cranney and Morris open the section on “Integrative Perspectives” by considering the relationship between psychological literacy and adaptive cognition, defined as global ways of thinking (and consequently behaving) that are beneficial to one’s (and others’) survival and well-being. The adaptive cognition approach draws on a number of perspectives in psychology, including developmental psychology, evolutionary psychology, cultural psychology, and human ecology. Cranney and Morris argue that we are in the privileged position of being able to choose to use strategies
Preface
xiv
that we know will improve our chances of achieving the goals of living a purposeful and fulfilling life, and psychology education is one arena in which this perspective can be shared and experienced. Building on Martin Luther King, Jr.’s claim that “Intelligence plus character╯.╯.╯.╯is the goal of true education,” Sokol and Kuebli explore the parallels between character development and psychological literacy. They argue, in particular, that promoting the skills of psychological literacy must be balanced against principles of citizenship and community in order to avoid the dangers of instrumental reasoning. Bernstein extends the notion of the “scientisteducator” introduced in the “Blueprint” volume and cogently explores the process whereby a scientist-practitioner would seek to provide students with opportunities to develop into psychologically literate citizens. McGovern argues that psychology educators are ideal role models for the psychologically literate citizen and outlines a program for faculty development and sustained renewal that can make explicit the connections between psychological literacy, citizenship, and virtues and character strengths. In their consideration of the alumnus perspective on psychological literacy, Takooshian and Landi present data that clearly demonstrate the increasing number of psychology honors graduates, which again raises the issue of what students acquire during a psychology major, particularly as very few undertake further study in psychology. In the final chapter, we reconsider the concepts of psychological literacy and global psychologically literate citizenship in light of the previous chapters. We argue that there is a global need for the development of psychological literacy in the general population, and undergraduate psychology education is an opportunity that cannot be ignored if we as psychology educators are ourselves psychologically literate. The aims of undergraduate psychology education in several countries are briefly and selectively reviewed, and we argue that the development of psychological literacy is compatible with current aims. We then provide some examples of renewed curricular and pedagogical strategies to enable undergraduate students to gain psychological literacy. We build on Halpern’s (2010b) “Call to Action” to psychology educators to reinvent their pedagogy and curriculum to better meet the needs of our students who will best serve themselves and lead their local and global communities by developing a high level of psychological literacy—that is, by becoming psychologically literate global citizens.
References Dunn, D. S., Brewer, C. L., Cautin, R. L., Gurung, R. A. R., Keith, K. D., McGregor, L. N., Nida, S. A., Puccio, P., & Voight, M. J. (2010). The undergraduate psychology curriculum: call for a core. In D. F. Halpern (Ed.), Undergraduate education in psychology: a blueprint for the future of the discipline (pp. 47–61). Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. Halpern, D. F. (Ed.). (2010a). Undergraduate education in psychology: a blueprint for the future of the discipline. Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association.
Preface
xv
Halpern, D. F. (2010b). Introduction: a call to action. In D. F. Halpern (Ed.), Under graduate education in psychology: a blueprint for the future of the discipline. Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. McGovern, T. V., Corey, L. A., Cranney, J., Dixon Jr., W. E., Holmes, J. D., Kuebli, J. E., Ritchey, K., Smith, R. A., & Walker, S. (2010). Psychologically literate citizens. In D. F. Halpern (Ed.), Undergraduate education in psychology: a blueprint for the dis cipline’s future (pp. 9–28). Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association.
This page intentionally left blank
Ac k n ow l e d g m e n t s
Jacky and Dana wish to thank the team at Oxford, particularly Abby Gross and Joanna Ng, for shepherding the book to publication. Smitha Raj’s careful attention to detail steered the book through the production process. Jacky would like to thank the authors for their motivation to produce thoughtful and original contributions to this volume—in taking up the challenge, the authors ensured that both the process and the product surpassed the original aims for this volume. Let’s continue to work toward achieving the promise inherent in the concepts of psychological literacy and the psychologically literate global citizen. Jacky is eternally grateful to Dana for being a wonderful co-editor—she could not have wished for a better partner in this endeavor. Thanks also to Minshin Song and Jun Mo Jeong for creative assistance with the original cover design image. The University of New South Wales and the Australian Learning and Teaching Council provided the space and stimulation that allowed these ideas and this volume to mature. Jacky thanks her family and friends, including colleagues (Diane and Sue–your encouragement is invaluable), who continually challenge and support her learning–this would not have been possible without you all. As always, Dana appreciates his family’s love and support of his scholarly work. Moravian College continues to provide him with the freedom to pursue his interests. He again thanks Abby Gross for being an ideal editor (third time is a charm, Abby). He is also grateful to the Executive Committee of the Society for the Teaching of Psychology for giving him a smooth presidency in 2010, which allowed him to find some time to work on this book. And finally, Dana wants to thank his hardworking, kind, and thoughtful colleague Jacky Cranney, for inviting him to be co-pilot on this wonderful project; she is now an old friend.
This page intentionally left blank
C on t e n t s
Contributors╇ xxiii PART ONE╇ Introduction 1. Psychological Literacy and the Psychologically Literate Citizen: New Frontiers for a Global Discipline╇ 3 Jacquelyn Cranney and Dana S. Dunn PART TWO╇ Curriculum Perspectives 2. Curriculum Matters: Structure, Content, and Psychological Literacy╇ 15 Dana S. Dunn, Robin L. Cautin, and Regan A. R. Gurung 3. Critical Thinking and the Education of Psychologically Literate Citizens╇ 27 Diane F. Halpern and Heather A. Butler 4. Enhancing Ethical Literacy of Psychologically Literate Citizens╇ 41 Graham R. Davidson and Shirley A. Morrissey 5. The Social Psychology of Intergroup Harmony and the Education of Psychologically Literate Citizens╇ 56 Fiona A. White 6. Changing the Lens: Indigenous Perspectives on Psychological Literacy╇ 72 Pat Dudgeon, Dawn Darlaston-Jones, and Yvonne Clark 7. Introductory Psychology and Psychological Literacy╇ 91 Lorelle J. Burton and Kathie J. McDonald 8. Educational Psychology and Psychological Literacy in Higher Education: Developmental and Cultural Aspects of Racial Diversity╇ 104 Nida Denson and Marsha Ing 9. The Role of Positive Psychology in Creating the Psychologically Literate Citizen╇ 119 Suzy Green, Paula L. Robinson, and Lindsay G. Oades
xx
Contents
10. Departmental Program Approaches for Educating Psychologically Literate Citizens╇ 131 Jane S. Halonen, Dana S. Dunn, Suzanne Baker, and Maureen A. McCarthy 11. Psychological Literacy and Applied Psychology in Undergraduate Education╇ 146 Jacquelyn Cranney, Sue Morris, Frances H. Martin, Steve Provost, Lucy Zinkiewicz, John Reece, Josephine Milne-Home, Lorelle J. Burton, Fiona A. White, Judi Homewood, Joanne K. Earl, and Sherri McCarthy PART THREE╇ Global Perspectives 12. Psychological Literacy: An Italian Perspective╇ 167 Remo Job, Lorella Lotto, and Claudio Tonzar 13. An Indonesian Perspective on Psychological Literacy╇ 178 Sarlito Wirawan Sarwono 14. A U.K. Perspective on Psychological Literacy and Citizenship╇ 191 Annie Trapp and Jacqueline Akhurst 15. Psychological Literacy Goals in Psychology Teaching in Russian Education╇ 206 Victor Karandashev 16. Sustainability and the Psychologically Literate Citizen: A New Zealand Perspective╇ 220 Niki Harré, Taciano L. Milfont, William Helton, and Andrea Mead 17. Fostering Psychologically Literate Citizens: A Canadian Perspective╇ 234 Steve Charlton and Jocelyn Lymburner PART FOUR╇ Integrative Perspectives 18. Adaptive Cognition and Psychological Literacy╇ 251 Jacquelyn Cranney and Sue Morris 19. Psychological Literacy: Bridging Citizenship and Character╇ 269 Bryan W. Sokol and Janet E. Kuebli 20. A Scientist-Educator Perspective on Psychological Literacy╇ 281 Daniel Bernstein
Contents
21. Virtues and Character Strengths of Psychologically Literate Faculty╇ 296 Thomas V. McGovern 22. Psychological Literacy: An Alumni Perspective╇ 306 Harold Takooshian and Giulia Landi 23. What the World Needs Now Is Psychological Literacy╇ 322 Jacquelyn Cranney and Dana S. Dunn Index╇ 337
xxi
This page intentionally left blank
C on t r i bu to r s
Jacqueline Akhurst Principal Lecturer Department of Psychology York St. John University York, United Kingdom
Robin L. Cautin Professor and Chair Department of Psychology Manhattanville College Purchase, New York
Suzanne Baker Professor Department of Psychology James Madison University Harrisonburg, Virginia
Steve Charlton Faculty Member Department of Psychology Kwantlen Polytechnic University Richmond, Canada
Daniel Bernstein Professor Department of Psychology University of Kansas Lawrence, Kansas
Yvonne Clark Senior Lecturer School of Psychology University of Adelaide Adelaide, Australia
Lorelle J. Burton Associate Professor Department of Psychology University of Southern Queensland Toowoomba, Australia
Jacquelyn Cranney Associate Professor School of Psychology The University of New South Wales Sydney, Australia
Heather A. Butler Doctoral Student School of Behavioral and Organizational Sciences Claremont Graduate University Claremont, California
Dawn Darlaston-Jones Head, Behavioral Science School of Arts & Sciences University of Notre Dame Fremantle, Australia
Contributors
xxiv
Graham R. Davidson Emeritus Professor and Lecturer Graduate School of Psychology Assumption University, ABAC Bangkok, Thailand
Jane S. Halonen Dean College of Arts and Sciences University of West Florida Pensacola, Florida
Nida Denson Research Fellow Centre for Educational Research University of Western Sydney Milperra, Australia
Diane F. Halpern Professor Department of Psychology Claremont McKenna College Claremont, California
Pat Dudgeon Adjunct Professor Postdoctoral Research Fellow School of Indigenous Studies University of Western Australia Crawley, Australia
Niki Harré Associate Professor Department of Psychology The University of Auckland Auckland, New Zealand
Dana S. Dunn Professor Department of Psychology Moravian College Bethlehem, Pennsylvania Joanne K. Earl Senior Lecturer School of Psychology University of New South Wales Sydney, Australia Suzy Green Co-Founder, Positive Psychology Institute Adjunct Lecturer Coaching Psychology Unit University of Sydney Sydney, Australia Regan A. R. Gurung Professor Department of Psychology University of Wisconsin Green Bay, Wisconsin
William Helton Associate Professor Department of Psychology University of Canterbury Christchurch, New Zealand Judi Homewood Associate Professor Department of Psychology Macquarie University Sydney, Australia Marsha Ing Assistant Professor Graduate School of Education University of California–Riverside Riverside, California Remo Job Department of Cognitive Science and Education University of Trento Trento, Italy
Contributors
Victor Karandashev Professor Department of Psychology Aquinas College Grand Rapids, Michigan Leningrad State University St. Petersburg, Russia Janet E. Kuebli Associate Professor Department of Psychology Saint Louis University St. Louis, Missouri Giulia Landi Medical Student School of Medicine and Surgery University of Bologna Italy Lorella Lotto Associate Professor Department of Developmental Psychology and Socialization University of Padova Padova, Italy Jocelyn Lymburner Faculty Member Department of Psychology Kwantlen Polytechnic University Surrey, Canada Frances H. Martin Associate Professor School of Psychology University of Tasmania Hobart, Australia Maureen A. McCarthy Professor Department of Psychology Kennesaw State University Kennesaw, Georgia
xxv
Sherri McCarthy Professor of Educational Psychology, Counseling and Human Relations Northern Arizona University Yuma Branch Campus Yuma, Arizona Kathie J. McDonald Post-Graduate Psychology Student Department of Psychology University of Southern Queensland Toowoomba, Australia Thomas V. McGovern Professor of Psychology New College of Interdisciplinary Arts and Sciences Arizona State University West Phoenix, Arizona Andrea Mead Senior Tutor Department of Pychology The University of Auckland Auckland, New Zealand Taciano L. Milfont Senior Lecturer School of Psychology Victoria University of Wellington Wellington, New Zealand Josephine Milne-Home Associate Head of School Learning and Teaching University of Western Sydney Sydney, Australia Sue Morris Research Associate School of Psychology The University of New South Wales Sydney, Australia
Contributors
xxvi
Shirley A. Morrissey Associate Professor and Deputy Head of School School of Psychology Griffith University–Gold Coast Southport, Australia
Bryan W. Sokol Assistant Professor Department of Psychology Saint Louis University St. Louis, Missouri
Lindsay G. Oades Senior Lecturer School of Psychology University of Wollongong Wollongong, Australia
Harold Takooshian Professor of Psychology and Urban Studies Department of Psychology Fordham University New York, New York
Steve Provost Lecturer School of Health & Human Sciences Southern Cross University Coffs Harbour, Australia
Claudio Tonzar Assistant Professor Department of Human Sciences University of Urbino Urbino, Italy
John Reece Associate Professor Discipline of Psychology School of Health Sciences RMIT University Bundoora, Australia
Annie Trapp Director Higher Education Academy Psychology Network University of York York, United Kingdom
Paula L. Robinson Co-Founder, Positive Psychology Institute Doctoral Student and Guest Lecturer School of Psychology University of Wollongong Wollongong, Australia
Fiona A. White Associate Professor School of Psychology University of Sydney Sydney, Australia
Sarlito Wirawan Sarwono Professor Department of Psychology University of Indonesia Depok, Indonesia
Lucy Zinkiewicz Lecturer School of Psychology Deakin University Geelong, Australia
PART ONE
Introduction
This page intentionally left blank
1 Psychological Literacy and the Psychologically Literate Citizen New Frontiers for a Global Discipline J ac qu e ly n Cr a n n e y a n d Da n a S. D un n
Today’s students must prepare themselves for a world in which knowledge is accumulating at a rapidly accelerating rate and in which old problems such as poverty, racism, and pollution join new problems such as global terrorism, a health crisis created by alarming increases in obesity, and the growing gap between the poor and very rich. All of these problems require psychological knowledge, skills and values for their solution. Halpern (2010, p. 162) Although the psychology major remains very popular (88,000 bachelor’s degrees in 2006)—and an increasing percentage of our citizens attend college—most students will not major in our discipline. However, psychol ogy is second only to basic English composition as the most frequently taken course by college graduates, and our potential to affect our future citizenry is enormous. Yet I sometimes wonder how much of what we teach is based on what we want to teach about our discipline (our favored theories and concepts to those we hope to recruit to our field—a most worthy endeavor) and how much is based on what the average person needs to know to be a psychologically literate citizen. Belar (2008, p. 56)
4
A
T he P s y c h o l o g i c a l ly Lite r ate Citi z e n
s educators and psychologists, we believe we have a mandate to prepare students to adapt and survive in their current and future world. More over, we believe that both the teaching and learning of psychological knowledge can serve in this pressing capacity. To this end, we discuss and develop further McGovern and colleagues’ (2010) concepts of “psychological literacy” and the “psychologically literate citizen,” in particular by making reference to the common understandings of the concepts of literacy, citizenship, and global citizenship. To begin, we will provide some historical context. In the northern summer of 2008, about 80 professors of undergraduate (UG) psychology gathered for the National Conference on Undergraduate Education in Psychology at the Univer sity of Puget Sound. Under the leadership of Diane Halpern, the conference aim was to undertake the core work in developing nine chapters for the volume Undergraduate Psychology Education: A Blueprint for the Future of the Discipline (Halpern, 2010). This book was in some sense an update of the 1991 St. Mary’s Conference, which had resulted in McGovern’s (1993) Handbook for Enhancing Undergraduate Education in Psychology. The Blueprint book also acknowledged some core developments since the McGovern work, including The APA Guidelines for the Undergraduate Major (APA, 2007), which listed five psychology-specific and five liberal education-related capabilities, and associated student learning outcomes (SLOs), for the UG psychology major in the United States. McGovern and colleagues (2010) introduced the unifying concepts of “psycho logical literacy” and “the psychologically literate citizen.” Psychological literacy means: • “having a well-defined vocabulary and basic knowledge of the critical subject matter of psychology; • valuing the intellectual challenges required to use scientific thinking and the disciplined analysis of information to evaluate alternative courses of action; • taking a creative and amiable skeptic approach to problem solving; • applying psychological principles to personal, social, and organizational issues in work, relationships, and the broader community; • acting ethically; • being competent in using and evaluating information and technology; • communicating effectively in different modes and with many different audiences; • recognizing, understanding, and fostering respect for diversity; • being insightful and reflective about one’s own and others’ behavior and mental processes” (p. 11). In essence, psychological literacy encapsulates the common graduate attributes or capabilities that students should acquire while undertaking a major in psychol ogy, as exemplified by guidelines and lists of SLOs delineated by many national psychology organizations (e.g., United States: APA, 2007; Australia: Cranney
Psychological Literacy and the Psychologically Literate Citizen
5
et al., 2008; Europe: Lunt et al., 2001). Although psychology educators interna tionally have been working toward helping students to acquire these attributes for at least the past 50 years, it has been only recently that educators have explicitly delineated attributes and SLOs and have sought to develop appropriate teaching and assessment strategies, including whole-program approaches. From some per spectives, psychological literacy becomes the most important outcome of under graduate education in the discipline. The concept of the psychologically literate citizen, however, is more controver sial than that of psychological literacy, for at least three reasons. First, it raises the issue of the real purpose of UG psychology education (and perhaps higher educa tion generally). Whether stated or implied, the aim in most Western countries is for UG education to provide the foundations for graduate professional training in psychology. Yet in North America, Australia, and Britain, only about one quarter of psychology majors enter graduate professional training programs (e.g., Landrum, Hettich, & Wilner, 2010), so there must be other viable outcomes for psychology major graduates. One purpose that fits particularly well in the North American context is that of liberal education. Indeed, many have argued that the psychology major is possibly one of the best forms of liberal education (e.g., McGovern, Furumoto, Halpern, Kimble, & McKeachie, 1991). The purpose of liberal education is to teach people to write well, reason logically, identify connections among diverse sets of information, recognize what they know and what they still need to learn, engage in critical thinking, and rely on research and data analytic skills to verify observations and conclusions (Dunn & McCarthy, 2010). This notion fits well with the recently stated purpose of universities in many countries to create the so-called “global citizen,” which has been simply defined as “anyone who works to make the world a better place” (Victoria International Development Education Association, n.d.), while global citizen ship “involves understanding the forces that affect cross-cultural connections and being committed to a global community based on human interdependence, equality, and justice” (Franklin Pierce University, n.d.). We explore these concepts further below. A second reason for controversy is a reaction by many within and outside of universities against the word “citizen,” and the implication that higher education institutions should be promoting and encouraging citizenship. We argue, how ever, that the purpose of colleges and universities is to provide students with the kind of education that enables them to participate and provide leadership in both their communities and their nations, whatever form that may take. Indeed, for democratic societies, education is one of the cornerstones of citizenry. A third reason for controversy is that McGovern and colleagues (2010) do not really define “the psychologically literate citizen,” but rather give the sense of a complex process that evolves over time: Psychologically literate citizens intentionally build upon their own psycho logical literacy, integrating it with the interdisciplinary and extracurricular lessons learned during their undergraduate experiences. They try to grow
6
T he P s y c h o l o g i c a l ly Lite r ate Citi z e n
more sophisticated as ethical and socially responsible problem solvers. It is an achievable outcome when faculty provide students with opportunities to use their psychological literacy outside of formal learning environments, and they begin to do so of their own initiative to accomplish goals that are impor tant to them, their families, their colleagues, their communities, and to the larger society, state, nation, or world. (p. 20) McGovern and colleagues (2010) clearly see this concept as an aspirational but achievable outcome of UG education that builds upon psychological literacy, and that also “pulls in” transdisciplinary and other “real-life” experiences. They further discuss the notion of “intentional learners” as those who are “empowered by intellectual and practical skills, informed by knowledge and different ways of knowing, and ethically responsible for their personal actions and civic contri butions” (p. 21); the notion of integrative learning is also described as connecting skills and knowledge from multiple domains, and as applying theory to practice in various settings. Although McGovern and colleagues do not offer a discrete defi nition of the psychologically literate citizen, Halpern (2010) does, in her introduc tion to the Blueprint book: “Psychologically literate citizens have basic knowledge of psychology and can and will apply their knowledge of psychology to a broad range of situations” (p. 7). We expand on this concept in a later section as well.
The Concepts of “Literacy” and “Psychological Literacy” If students encounter a concept or term that they know little about, they are very likely to seek more information on the open-source community-driven encyclo pedia, Wikipedia. Thus, as educators, we decided to embrace the role of student as learner and approach the term “literacy” in the same way. Wikipedia states that literacy has “traditionally been described as the ability to read and write. It is a concept claimed and defined by a range of different theoretical fields” (see http:// en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Literacy). Interestingly, the entry then draws on a docu ment authored by the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO), which defines literacy as the “ability to identify, under stand, interpret, create, communicate, compute and use printed and written mate rials associated with varying contexts. Literacy involves a continuum of learning in enabling individuals to achieve their goals, to develop their knowledge and potential, and to participate fully in their community and wider society” [italics added] (UNESCO, 2004). It is well documented that this kind of literacy is associated with better life opportunities and better physical health outcomes—which is why UNESCO has a focus on such “basic” education in developing countries and also why, in Western countries, we generally take this kind of literacy for granted (despite the fact that a significant percentage of our populations remain illiterate). In a similar way, we argue that, in the face of global problems that are the result of maladaptive human behavior (Marsella, 2007), psychological literacy may well
Psychological Literacy and the Psychologically Literate Citizen
7
become essential to the psychological health of both Western and “developing” nations—that is, it may be necessary to purposefully increase the psychological literacy of our citizens, either through formal education (e.g., the psychology major) or through informal education media (e.g., “edutainment” formats; or the “critical thinking” game being developed by Halpern and others; see http://www. cmc.edu/pages/faculty/dhalpern/index_files/Page792.html). Returning to the formal literature on “literacy,” we do not pretend to be experts in this field, but rather take as an interesting example the article entitled “Literacy Literacy” by Kintgen (1988) in the journal Visible Language. Therein the author examines how the traditional meaning of the word has been extended to terms such as “scientific literacy” and “cultural literacy.” Kintgen summarizes scholarly work that traces the four historical stages of development of the meaning of the core term “literacy,” concluding that we are now in the “analytic” stage, where “readers are expected to analyze and draw inferences from the material they read” (p. 154). By logically generalizing the term to other fields, he argues that “the ability to analyze material from any field, and to draw inferences from it, can be referred to as literacy in that area” (p. 154). However, he also argues that there is an evaluative element to the term that encompasses the analysis and inference aspects, and goes beyond mere descriptive aspects. In essence, literacy means the capacity to both “describe knowledge, and the ability to think, about any field” (p. 155), and also implies mastery of a traditional body of knowledge (p. 162). In his discussion of “cultural literacy,” he explicitly makes reference to psychological notions, such as mental models and schemas, as being essential to comprehension. Finally he states: New experiences of any sort are assimilated by relating them to mental models based on previous experiences; something that is totally novel is incomprehensible. Knowledge is thus an essential component of even the descriptive sense of ‘literacy’, and this leads, almost inevitably, to knowledge as the defining characteristic of the evaluative sense. And thus the title of this paper. (Kintgen, 1988, p. 166) What are the implications of Kintgen’s (1988) analysis for the term “psychologi cal literacy”? First, he acknowledges the importance of the development of a “schema” regarding the discipline of psychology; we argue that his notion of “schema” overlaps with the notion of the “culture” of the discipline, including the sometimes-not-so-explicit rules about the way one thinks if one is a psychologist (or psychological scientist; Cranney et al., 2005; Ewing et al., 2010). This aspect of literacy, which acknowledges that part of the discipline knowledge is “ways of knowing,” can be related to the notion of epistemology. Second, he emphasizes the higher-order cognitive skills of analysis and evaluation, which can be related to Krathwohl’s (2002) revision of Bloom’s taxonomy of educational objectives. In terms of types of knowledge, the levels are factual, conceptual, and procedural knowledge, and the highest level is metacognitive knowledge—the knowledge of cognition in general as well as awareness and knowledge of one’s own thinking. In terms of types of processes, the lowest level is remembering, whereas the highest levels involve
8
T he P s y c h o l o g i c a l ly Lite r ate Citi z e n
evaluating and creating. Third, Kintgen refers to conceptions of scientific literacy as including the ability to evaluate the wider implications of the products of scien tific enterprise on society generally (p. 157); in a similar way, we might also consider as part of psychological literacy the capacity to evaluate the past and predict the future impact of psychological science on society generally. One aspect of this capacity is being able to recognize the strengths and limitations or boundaries of disciplinary knowledge in the context of other disciplines and other knowledge— “meta-metacognition”? In a further play on Kintgen’s paper title, we need to acknowledge that a particularly unusual aspect of psychological literacy (at least compared to other literacies) is that the subject of the literacy is not something external to us, but indeed is the essence of ourselves—our thoughts, feelings, and behaviors. This realization has profound implications for the importance of psycho logical literacy to oneself and one’s fellow human beings, and may also mean that gaining psychological literacy is a particularly challenging enterprise, as it requires one to attempt to hold an objective view of self-relevant subject matter. We argue that a simple definition of literacy is “domain knowledge that is used adaptively,” or more specifically, literacy is “knowledge plus the adaptive use or application of that knowledge.” Thus psychological literacy could be defined as psychological knowledge that is used adaptively. Taking into consideration the Wikipedia, UNESCO, and English scholar’s definitions, however, this definition is not, for many reasons, as simple as it seems. First, use of knowledge implies that one has knowledge to begin with. Second, here “knowledge” includes not only the core content areas, but all the aspects defined by McGovern and coworkers (2010), including critical thinking, research skills, and communication. Third, knowledge also includes ethical knowledge, and we argue that a high level of knowledge acquisition in this area necessarily means that “adaptive use” translates to ethical behavior in all domains of life, not just in the workplace. Fourth, this definition of psychological literacy implies a relatively well-integrated and functional set of schemas that across individuals may show some variability in expression, but in terms of central tendency, can be recognized and assessed as “psychological liter acy.” Finally, regardless of the discipline students decide to pursue, opportunities to develop some aspects of psychological literacy, such as “recognizing, under standing, and fostering respect for diversity” (McGovern et al., 2010), should be formally included in their curriculum to help create truly “global citizens.” Before we move on to notions of citizenship, however, two points should be made. First, different cultures may have different conceptualizations of “psycho logical literacy,” as Karandashev (Chapter 15) makes clear in his discussion of the concept in relation to the history of psychology education in Russia. Second, because a central characteristic of psychology is the use of the scientific method, we also need to consider the concept of “scientific literacy”: Scientific literacy is the knowledge and understanding of scientific concepts and processes required for personal decision making, participation in civic and cultural affairs, and economic productivity . . . Scientific literacy means that . . . a person has the ability to describe, explain, and predict
Psychological Literacy and the Psychologically Literate Citizen
9
natural phenomena. Scientific literacy entails being able to read with under standing articles about science in the popular press and to engage in social conversation about the validity of the conclusions. Scientific literacy implies that a person can identify scientific issues underlying national and local decisions and express positions that are scientifically and technologically informed. A literate citizen should be able to evaluate the quality of scientific information on the basis of its source and the methods used to generate it. Scientific literacy also implies the capacity to pose and evaluate arguments based on evidence and to apply conclusions from such arguments appropri ately (National Science Education Standards, cited by http://literacynet.org/ science/scientificliteracy.html). This definition of scientific literacy fits well with both Kintgen’s (1988) defini tion of literacy emphasizing its evaluative aspects, and our definition emphasizing its adaptive application aspects. Many psychology educators have explicitly stated that scientific literacy is a core attribute that should be acquired by every psychol ogy major (e.g., Beins, 2007). There are challenges to educators in achieving this aim, particularly with students who may not have a science background and who expect primarily to learn “how to help people” during their UG program (e.g., Thieman, Clary, Olson, Dauner, & Ring, 2009); Holmes and Beins (2009) suggest some potential solutions to these challenges.
The Concepts of “Citizen,” “Global Citizenship,” and the “Psychologically Literate Citizen” During the week-long “camp” that produced the core drafts of the Blueprint book (Halpern, 2010), there was some ambivalence about the word “citizen” as it emerged in discussions from the developing chapter dealing with “The Psycho logically Literate Citizen” (McGovern et al., 2010). This ambivalence no doubt reflected different meanings associated with the term (keep in mind the likely “small-L” liberal political leanings of most psychology professors present, in the context of the dominant conservative U.S. government at that time). The notion of citizenship is central in the development of Western civilization and in particular democratic societies, and so has strong cultural meanings. A comprehensive treat ment of this concept is beyond the scope of this chapter (but see Trapp & Akhurst, Chapter 14). However, to introduce this section, we give the following definition: a citizen is a “person owing loyalty to and entitled by birth or naturalisation to the protection of state or nation” (http://www.thefreedictionary.com/citizen). Citizen ship developed as a concept in the Classical era, where there were clearly signifi cant rights and responsibilities (the former outweighing the latter, particularly when non-citizenship often meant slavery) associated with Athenian and Roman citizenry (see, for example, Scullard, 1982, pp. 16–18). Finally, we note that citi zenship is one of the character strengths of the virtue of justice (Peterson & Seligman, 2004; see also Dahlsgaard, Peterson, & Selgman, 2005).
10
T he P s y c h o l o g i c a l ly Lite r ate Citi z e n
If one conducts a search for “global citizenship,” one most often retrieves uni versity or college statements of the aspirational capabilities or attributes they hope to inculcate in their graduates. For example, Australia’s University of New South Wales recently defined global citizens as having an appreciation of (a) relevant applications of their discipline to problems in their local, national, and interna tional context, and (b) the needs to respect diversity, be culturally aware, be socially just/responsible, and be environmentally responsible (Marshall, 2010). This definition pushes strongly into the “values” arena, and contrasts with unin formative conceptualizations of global citizenship as being merely the conse quence of study abroad experiences, or as reflecting the capacity to communicate with people from around the world through Web-based social media (although there is no doubt that these experiences and capabilities have value). If we take Marshall’s (2010) definition, then how does this relate to the “psy chologically literate citizen”? We build upon McGovern and coworkers’ (2010) discussion around these issues by arguing that psychologically literate citizens use their psychological literacy to solve problems in an ethical and socially responsi ble manner in a way that directly benefits their communities. That is, they self lessly and sometimes courageously share their psychological knowledge and skills to directly benefit their communities, large or small. For an alternative but related conceptualization of this concept, see Charlton and Lymburner’s (Chapter 17) “psychologically literate global citizen.”
Conclusion In summary, we argue that psychological literacy is a core component of grad uate literacy in general, and that the psychologically literate citizen is a core com ponent of the “global citizen,” thus providing relevance to tertiary education in general. Psychological literacy should be the core outcome of the psychology UG major. Depending on how one conceptualizes “the psychologically literate citizen,” one might see it as the “high end” of psychological literacy, or as an essen tial outcome of a liberal education in a democratic society. Building upon this latter idea, we argue that we need to renew psychology education, using this con cept of the psychologically literate citizen. The time is ripe (and perhaps overdue) for the psychologically literate citizen, as indicated by U.S. President Barack Obama’s commencement address at Arizona State University in May 2009: . . . we’ll need a fundamental change of perspective and attitude. It’s clear that we need to build a new foundation—a stronger foundation—for our econ omy and our prosperity, rethinking how we grow our economy, how we use energy, how we educate our children, how we care for our sick, how we treat our environment . . . I’m talking about an approach to life—a quality of mind and quality of heart; a willingness to follow your passions, regardless of whether they lead to fortune and fame; a willingness to question conven tional wisdom and rethink old dogmas; a lack of regard for all the traditional
Psychological Literacy and the Psychologically Literate Citizen
11
markers of status and prestige—and a commitment instead to doing what’s meaningful to you, what helps others, what makes a difference in this world . . . Acts of sacrifice and decency without regard to what’s in it for you—that also creates ripple effects—ones that lift up families and communities; that spread opportunity and boost our economy; that reach folks in the forgotten corners of the world.
Acknowledgments We would like to thank Fiona McDonald and Jun Mo Jeong for assistance with this chapter. Jacky would like to thank Gail Huon for suggesting that we “unpack” the notion of “literacy”. Jacky Cranney’s work on this chapter was supported by funding from the Australian Learning and Teaching Council, an initiative of the Australian Government Department of Education, Employment and Work place Relations. The views expressed in this chapter do not necessarily reflect the views of the Australian Learning and Teaching Council Ltd.
References American Psychological Association. (2007). APA guidelines for the undergraduate psychology major. Washington, D. C.: Retrieved from http://www.apa.org/ed/precollege/ about/psymajor-guidelines.pdf. Beins, B. (2007, Spring). Psychology, critical thinking, and scientific literacy. Psychology Teacher Network, 17, 3–4. Belar, C. (2008, November). Increasing psychological literacy. Monitor on Psychology, 39(10), 56. Cranney, J., Kofod, M., Huon, G., Jensen, L., Levin, K., McAlpine, I., Scoufis, M., & Whitaker, N. (2005). Portfolio tools: Learning and teaching strategies to facilitate development of graduate attributes. Proceedings of the Blended Learning in Science Teaching and Learning Symposium, September 30, 2005, University of Sydney. Sydney: UniServe Science. Cranney, J., Provost, S., Katsikitis, M., Martin, F., White, F., & Cohen, L. (2008). Designing a diverse, future-oriented vision for undergraduate psychology in Australia. Strawberry Hills, New South Wales, AU: Australian Learning and Teaching Council Ltd. Dahlsgaard, K., Peterson, C., & Seligman, M. E. P. (2005). Shared virtue: the convergence of valued human strengths across culture and history. Review of General Psychology, 9, 203–213. Dunn, D. S., & McCarthy, M. A. (2010). The capstone course in psychology as liberal education opportunity. In D. S. Dunn, B. C. Beins, M. A. McCarthy, & G. W. Hill, IV (Eds.), Best practices for beginnings and endings in the psychology major (pp. 155–170). New York: Oxford University Press. Ewing, A. T., Andre, J., Blair-Broeker, C. T., Fineburg, A. C., Daniel, J. H., Higa, J. J., et al. (2010). Where and when people learn psychological science: The sun never sets. In D. F. Halpern (Ed.), Undergraduate education in psychology: blueprint for the discipline’s future (pp. 81–94). Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association.
12
T he P s y c h o l o g i c a l ly Lite r ate Citi z e n
Franklin Pierce University (no date). Global citizenship certificate. Retrieved Sept. 6, 2009, from http://www.youshouldvisit.us/academics/ugrad/programs_of_study/ humanÂ�ities/global_citizenship/index.htm. Halpern, D. F. (Ed.). (2010). Undergraduate education in psychology: a blueprint for the future of the discipline. Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. Holmes, J. D., & Beins, B. C. (2009). Psychology is a science: at least some students think so. Teaching of Psychology, 36, 5–11. Kintgen, E. R. (1988). Literacy literacy. Visible Language, 1, 149–168. Krathwohl, D. R. (2002). A revision of Bloom’s Taxonomy: an overview. Theory into Practice, 41, 212–260. Retrived from http://www.unco.edu/cetl/sir/stating_outcome/ documents/Krathwohl.pdf. Landrum, R. E., Hettich, P. I., & Wilner, A. (2010). Alumni perceptions of workforce readiness. Teaching of Psychology, 37, 97–106. Lunt, I., Bartram, D., Döpping, J., Georgas, J., Jern, S., Job, R., Lecuyer, R., Newstead, S., Nieminen, P., Odland, S., Peiró, J. M., Poortinga, Y., Roe, R., Wilpert, B., & Herman, E. (2001). EuroPsyT: a framework for education and training for psychologists in Europe. Report by Project EuroPsyT, funded by the Leonardo da Vinci programme. Retrieved May 10, 2008, from www.europsych.org. Marsella, A. J. (2007). Education and training for a global psychology: foundations, issues, and actions. In M. J. Stevens & U. P. Gielen (Eds.), Toward a global psychology: research, intervention, and pedagogy (pp. 333–361). Mahwah, N.J.: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Marshall, S. (2010). The University of New South Wales Academic Graduate Attributes Framework. Academic Board Document (Aug. 3, 2010). McGovern, T. V. (Ed.). (1993). Handbook for enhancing undergraduate education in psychology. Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. McGovern, T. V., Corey, L. A., Cranney, J., Dixon, Jr., W. E., Holmes, J. D., Kuebli, J. E., Ritchey, K., Smith, R. A., & Walker, S. (2010). Psychologically literate citizens. In D. F. Halpern (Ed.), Undergraduate education in psychology: blueprint for the discipline’s future (pp. 9–28). Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. McGovern, T. V., Furumoto, L., Halpern, D. F., Kimble, G. A., & McKeachie, W. J. (1991). Liberal education, study in depth, and the arts and science major—psychology. American Psychologist, 46, 598–605. Peterson, C., & Seligman, M. E. P. (2004). Character strengths and virtues: a handbook and classification. Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. Scullard, H. H. (1982). From the Gracchi to Nero: a history of Rome from 133 BC to AD 68 (5th ed.). London: Routledge. Thieman, T. J., Clary, E. G., Olson, A. M., Dauner, R. C., & Ring, E. E. (2009). Introducing students to psychological research: general psychology as a laboratory course. Teaching of Psychology, 36, 160–168. United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization. (2004). The plurality of literacy and its implications for policies and programmes (p. 13). Paris, France: UNESCO. Victoria International Development Education Association (no date). What is a global citizen? Retrieved Sept. 6, 2009, from http://www.videa.ca/global/citizen.html.
PART TWO
Curriculum Perspectives
This page intentionally left blank
2 Curriculum Matters Structure, Content, and Psychological Literacy Dana S. Dunn, Robin L. Cautin, and Regan A. R. Gurung
We often teach like everyone is going to graduate school, but graduate school is [for] the minority. Diane F. Halpern (quoted in Goldstein, 2010, p. 23)
P
sychology differs from many other disciplines in that students can readily connect what they learn in their coursework to their own lives (Goldstein, 2010). This distinction is at the root of the idea of psychological literacy as defined by McGovern and colleagues (2010). Promoting psychological literacy entails reorienting what and how we teach students in a way that emphasizes psychology’s relevance. To the extent that the acquisition of core psychological knowledge takes place in the classroom, the obvious channel for cultivating psychological literacy is the undergraduate psychology curriculum. In this chapter, we begin by reviewing the history of psychology curricula in the United States and then consider how learning outcomes related to psychological literacy might shape disciplinary curricula for undergraduates. Such curricular change must address the necessary balance between graduate and undergraduate needs, and the balance between cutting-edge and core knowledge; for this reason, we specifically discuss the range of learning outcomes a psychologically literate curriculum should comprise. We then turn to the competencies that should appear in psychologically literate curricula and address ways to give courses a more global perspective. The next section of the chapter focuses on practical ways to make a departmental curriculum more psychologically literate and offers advice on assessing literacy. We conclude with a call to develop a psychologically literate citizenry.
16
T h e P s y c h o l o gi c a l ly Lit e r at e Citi z e n
A Brief History of Psychology Curricula Curricula Then Informal wrangling notwithstanding, virtually no systematic study of the undergraduate psychology curriculum in the United States happened prior to the 1950s. The earliest concerted efforts, which took place in the 1950s and 1960s respectively, involved two small, self-selected groups of participants (Buxton et al., 1952; McKeachie & Milholland, 1961), each of whom endorsed the notion of psychology as a liberal arts discipline, and who specified preferred curriculum structures. In the 1970s, based on a national survey of schools that did and did not offer a psychology major, a qualitative study of the undergraduate psychology curriculum was advanced (Kulik et al., 1973). It detailed the growing diversity of undergraduate education in psychology and deliberately refrained from stipulating preferred curriculum structures, a decision that reflected a divergence from previous efforts. Throughout the 1980s there was growing demand for curricular guidelines for undergraduate psychology students, and a concomitant call for ongoing assessment of many facets of undergraduate psychology, including the curriculum (McGovern, Furumoto, Halpern, Kimble, & McKeachie, 1991; Scheier & Rogers, 1985). In the mid-1980s, the American Psychological Association’s (APA’s) Committee on Undergraduate Education (CUE) resolved to clarify the function of the undergraduate psychology major in relation to traditional liberal arts education, as well as to detail curricular guidelines. This work inspired the APA’s National Conference on Enhancing the Quality of Undergraduate Education in Psychology, which convened at St. Mary’s College of Maryland in 1991 (see McGovern, 1993). The curriculum report of the St. Mary’s Conference (Brewer et al., 1993) reaffirmed the conception of psychology as a liberal arts discipline, stating that the general goal of an undergraduate education in psychology is to “teach students to think as scientists about behavior and experience” (Brewer et al., 1993, p. 169). Intended to elucidate the common features of all undergraduate psychology programs, the curricular framework for the psychology major described in the Brewer report was not prescriptive in nature. It did, however, recognize four distinct groups of courses, ideally to be taken in the following sequence: the introductory course, methodology courses, content courses, and integrative experiences. A recent comparison of psychology major programs around the nation to programs described 10 years earlier showed some progress had been made in aligning with the Brewer report, although many suggestions (e.g., capstone courses) were still not common (Stoloff et al., 2010).
A Core Curriculum for Now The most recent curricular review (Dunn et al., 2010) was part of the APA’s National Conference on Undergraduate Education in Psychology, which convened at the University of Puget Sound in 2008 (see Halpern, 2010) and sought to address key issues in undergraduate psychology education in light of recent
Curriculum Matters
17
changes and developments both within and outside the discipline of psychology. The curricular report that emerged from the Puget Sound Conference reaffirmed psychology’s place in the liberal arts tradition. Arguing that the increased fragmentation of the field, technological advances, and the rise of a consumerist culture have threatened the traditional identity of psychology, Dunn and colleagues (2010) advocated a core curriculum that not only emphasized scientific methodology, but also ensured breadth and depth in substantive content areas of the field: Biological Bases, Learning/Cognition, Developmental, and Sociocultural (see also APA, 2007; Dunn, McCarthy, Baker, Halonen, & Hill, 2007). This recommendation was intended to provide greater coherence to the undergraduate psychology curriculum in the United States, which could then be attuned to the specific needs and resources of various programs.
Psychological Literacy, Student Learning Outcomes, and the Psychology Curriculum How can a curriculum be tuned to promote psychological literacy? First, we believe that psychology departments should review their current curricula in light of the core curriculum recommended by Dunn and colleagues (2010), and make adjustments as necessary. Psychology departments should also familiarize themselves with the APA Guidelines for the Undergraduate Psychology Major (APA, 2007), the recommendations of which outline the knowledge, skills, attitudes, and values that derive from the undergraduate psychology major and its place in the context of a liberal education. Table 2.1 categorizes two sets of five learning goals, the first more specific to the science and application of psychology, the second more related to the broader goals of a liberal arts education as addressed by psychology (APA, 2007). McGovern and colleagues (2010) note that the APA guidelines are consistent with their definition of psychological literacy and with student learning outcomes (SLOs) created independently by academic psychologists in Australia and Europe. SLOs are concrete statements that indicate what students will know or be able to demonstrate once they have completed an activity, a course, or a major (Angelo & Cross, 1993; Diamond, 2008; Suskie, 2009). For SLOs to be meaningful, departments must also identify useful measures for assessing SLOs. We identify selected learning outcomes consistent with psychological literacy (McGovern et al., 2010) and the core curriculum recommendations made by Dunn and colleagues (2010). What follows is a description of each SLO, along with how each can be achieved via the psychology curriculum.
Writing It is important for students to have the ability to write effectively for a variety of audiences and purposes. An essential skill for psychology students is to be able to employ the discipline’s vernacular and writing style (e.g., APA, 2010; Beins, Smith,
18
T h e P s y c h o l o gi c a l ly Lit e r at e Citi z e n
Table 2.1╇ Learning Goals Advocated in the APA Guidelines for the Undergraduate Psychology Major
Consistent with the Science and Application of Psychology Goal 1: Knowledge Base of Psychology Goal 2: Research Methods in Psychology Goal 3: Critical Thinking Skills in Psychology Goal 4: Application of Psychology Goal 5: Values in Psychology
Consistent with Liberal Arts Education Further Developed in Psychology Goal 6: Information and Technological Literacy Goal 7: Communication Skills Goal 8: Sociocultural and International Awareness Goal 9: Personal Development Goal 10: Career Planning and Development Source: Adapted from APA (2007).
& Dunn, 2010). Thus, the undergraduate psychology curriculum should provide students opportunities to produce discipline-based writing samples, such as empirical laboratory reports or critical literature reviews. Equally important as writing professional discipline-based papers, which require the use of APA style, is the ability to write clear and effective prose in general. Such writing may include composing professional letters, e-mail messages, book reviews, or project proposals, and may be intended for psychologists and non-psychologists alike. Accordingly, we recommend that psychology instructors require students to write in a variety of forms, including reflective or persuasive essays, book reviews, and blogs, in addition to the more traditional discipline-based papers. With respect to writing, the goal of psychological literacy is to be able to write clearly and concisely about psychology for professional and lay audiences alike.
Speaking In addition to being proficient in written communication, psychologically lite� rate students should be able to deliver formal and informal oral presentations to both professional and lay audiences. Such presentations may include delivering a lecture-style talk, engaging in a relatively casual exchange of ideas and reactions, or leading a group discussion, all of which may involve groups of people of varying sizes. An undergraduate psychology curriculum that promotes psychological literacy should offer students speaking opportunities that evolve in length and
Curriculum Matters
19
complexity as students move through their programs of study. For example, oral presentations in introductory psychology courses should be straightforward and of relatively short duration. In contrast, capstone experiences that involve an extensive written project should entail opportunities for significant and relatively formal oral presentation about the students’ work.
Research The use of scientific methodology is a defining feature of psychological science, the objective of which is to understand and predict human behavior. As such, it is imperative that psychology majors not only understand how the discipline’s methodologies distinguish it from other disciplines that use different methods, such as hermeneutics (Donald, 2002), but also that students appreciate what constitutes good science. Students need to develop the scientific acumen to separate the wheat from the chaff when evaluating the evidence for psychological claims. This is truer now than ever, as the public is continuously bombarded with research findings from multiple media sources. To promote psychological literacy, the curriculum should include statistics and a research methods course that exposes students to the variety of research approaches used in psychological research, ranging from highly controlled experimental approaches to field-based naturalistic observation. It is particularly desirable that such courses include laboratories in which students gain more practical experience with the material. Ideally, students would be able to conduct an entire research study, engaging in all the stages of the research process. Research methodology in psychology should be emphasized throughout the curriculum. Indeed, hands-on research experience in general allows students the opportunity to integrate the content they learn with the practice of corresponding skills.
Collaboration The nature of psychologists’ work is often collaborative. In hospitals and clinics, professional psychologists commonly work in interdisciplinary teams, while academic psychologists routinely engage in collaborative teaching and participate in research teams. In addition to being able to work independently, psychologically literate students should be capable of working effectively with others. Thus, a curriculum promoting psychological literacy should provide opportunities for students to work alone (perhaps doing library research) and in teams (possibly designing and executing research projects). Where research teams are concerned, faculty members should make it possible for students to rotate serving as team leader (or principal investigator), affording students opportunities to further develop leadership and organizational skills (see, for example, Beins & Wann, 2010). The ability to collaborate is a hallmark of psychological literacy. In learning to work cooperatively with others, students are able to appreciate the various skills
20
T h e P s y c h o l o gi c a l ly Lit e r at e Citi z e n
and abilities of their peers, develop greater empathy, and learn to constructively resolve conflicts.
Information and Technological Literacy Students should be able to make use of modern information technologies, an established and ubiquitous feature of academia, and life in general. Accordingly, psychology teachers and department administrators should make concerted efforts to incorporate current and emerging technologies into classes within the psychology curriculum and the program’s wider milieu (e.g., Dunn, Wilson, Freeman, & Stowell, 2011). Psychologically literate students should be adept users of psychology databases (e.g., PsycINFO, PsycARTICLES) and of those in the social sciences (e.g., JSTOR, Sociological Abstracts, ERIC) more generally. They should be able to use technological tools to collect, analyze, synthesize, and disseminate Â�information. Students should be comfortable learning new technological skills in and outside of classroom settings.
Students Should Be Able to Define and Describe the Concept of Psychological Literacy Students should understand that psychological knowledge is meant to inform daily life as well as intellectual challenges in the classroom. To this end, teachers should connect psychological principles to “personal, social, and organizational issues in work, relationships, and the broader community” (McGovern et al., 2010, p. 11), thus demonstrating how course material relates to everyday phenomena. Moreover, instructors should develop learning activities that demand the application of psychological knowledge. The rationale for promoting psychological literacy should be introduced immediately and referenced consistently throughout the undergraduate psychology curriculum. Discussing the concept of psychological literacy should not be restricted to one course. Instead, consideration of topics, learning experiences, and SLOs relevant to psychological literacy should be included at all stages of students’ program of study, albeit in an appropriately sequenced fashion. That is, teaching about psychological literacy should be done in a way that reflects the consideration of students’ developmental progress, cognitive abilities, and level of knowledge (cf., Baker, McCarthy, Halonen, Dunn, & Hill, 2010; Halonen et al., 2003). Thus, introductory students should first be introduced to the topical areas in and basic terminology of the discipline, then should acquire knowledge of research methodology and analysis, as well as the discipline’s writing style (both intermediate), and only then should they undertake a project that involves the synthesis of knowledge and the application of skills acquired over the course of their undergraduate curriculum, a distinctive feature of psychological literacy. Such a project may be required as part of a well-designed capstone course (Dunn & McCarthy, 2010) or independent research,
Curriculum Matters
21
or it may derive from a discipline-based internship. As a practical matter, instructors should also identify specific SLOs on course syllabi, indicating those that are linked to psychological literacy.
Students Should Be Able to Think and Act Ethically when Applying Psychological Knowledge Although virtually all psychology students in a research methods course discuss the APA’s (2002) ethical principles and code of conduct, discussions of ethical matters should not be limited to this context. Indeed, ethical principled behavior—a hallmark of the psychologically literate student (and citizen)—should be promoted across the curriculum, and should also bear relevance to students’ personal and professional lives.
Students Should Be Able to Demonstrate an Understanding of and Respect for Diversity Psychologically literate individuals understand that diversity—how people differ from one another—is multifaceted: gender, sexual orientation, ethnicity, disability, race, religion, culture, social class, age, inter alia, are categories within which people vary. The breadth of diversity should be recognized and incorporated into the entire psychology curriculum (Gurung & Prieto, 2009). The ultimate goal is for students not only to understand and respect individuals from different groups within or beyond their culture, but also to interact with them in cordial and open ways. One means by which to teach students about diversity is to expose them to global issues regarding psychology. In this way, the notion of internationalizing the undergraduate curriculum (e.g., Lutsky et al., 2005) can be realized. Students should learn about the psychological science being conducted around the world and not only that produced in the United States and other Western nations. Cultural perspectives and folkways, for example, can inform research and practice, and psychologically literate persons—as global citizens—should be both sensitive to and interested in variations among nations. Minimally, instructors should look for ways to include theories, methodologies, and research findings from different nations in the undergraduate psychology curriculum. Study abroad experiences, too, should be encouraged, especially those that might have an experiential component allowing for some application of psychological knowledge.
Importing a Global Perspective Around the world, more and more students are taking psychology classes. For example, during the 1970s there were only four departments of psychology in China, whereas today there are nearly 250 (Kan, 2008, in Halpern, 2010).
22
T h e P s y c h o l o gi c a l ly Lit e r at e Citi z e n
This trend is reflected in other countries, including the United Kingdom and Yemen (Halpern, 2010). Correspondingly, psychology curricula abroad can inform our own (Sexton & Hogan, 1992). What is nominally called psychology in some countries is quite similar to American psychology. Other countries, in contrast, have developed more indigenous psychologies that differ markedly from their American counterpart. What lessons may be gleaned from the world’s psychology curricula? A systematic and comprehensive survey of psychology curricula around the world is beyond the scope of the chapter, but even a cursory review reveals a noteworthy trend: curricula abroad tend to require more interdisciplinary coursework. In Argentina, for example, students are required to take sociology and anthropology courses as part of their psychology program. Such interdisciplinary requirements are worth considering, particularly given the degree to which psychology influences and is informed by the work of other disciplines (Cacioppo, 2007). For example, given the current biological emphasis in psychology and concomitant rise of neuroscience, perhaps requiring coursework in biology as part of the Â�psychology curriculum may be worthy of consideration. Beyond courses for inclusion in the curriculum, a look abroad provides us with models for how we should look at curriculum. As stated previously, in the United States there have been only a few thorough examinations of the psychology curriculum (e.g., the St. Mary’s and Puget Sound conferences). In contrast, it seems that psychology curricula are evaluated more frequently overseas. For example, after education leaders from 29 European countries met in Bologna in 1999 to create a European Higher Education Area (EHEA), members of participating countries (numbering 47 in 2007) began to meet biennially to “arrive at consensus objectives that will not homogenize national educational systems but provide tools to connect them” (McGovern et al., 2010, p. 16). Similar meetings take place in the Asia-Pacific region and in Canada. Such international movements suggest an additional curricular component for psychology. For example, to earn a European Certificate in psychology, students are required to appreciate non-psychological theories, such as sociological, anthropological, and philosophical, underscoring the value of interdisciplinary education. In Australia, undergraduate programs must integrate cross-cultural and indigenous issues, and proÂ�mote increasing indigenous participation at all levels of psychology training (McGovern et al., 2010, p. 18). Each of these examples suggests thought-provoking ways in which American psychology curricula can be modified.
Advice on Promoting Psychological Literacy in Psychology Curricula Beyond evaluating student learning outcomes in the context of the undergraduate psychology curriculum and infusing the curriculum with a more global perspective, how else can psychology curricula promote psychologically literacy? To address this question, we offer concrete advice concerning the following three areas: program mission, planning, and assessment.
Curriculum Matters
23
Reflect on Program Mission and Current Learning Goals Before undertaking any curriculum revision, psychology department members should review their respective mission statement (Dunn, McCarthy, Baker, & Halonen, 2011), verifying that it reflects the department’s long-term goals, including the cultivation of psychological literacy. Departments should also evaluate the extent to which student learning goals in psychology are achieved at their institutions. Mission statements and learning goals should be adjusted as necessary to incorporate psychological literacy into the curricular framework of departments.
Creating and Implementing a Plan Curricular reviews often occur as part of a larger evaluative process, such as an external review or self-study, or in the context of personnel changes, such as new hires. We encourage readers to avail themselves of the myriad sources with�in the discipline that champion the importance of fostering psychological literacy and provide practical, relevant information regarding the planning and implementation of curricular reviews (e.g., Dunn et al., 2007; Dunn, McCarthy, Baker, & Halonen, 2011; Halpern, 2010; Pusateri, Poe, Addison, & Goedel, 2004).
Ongoing Assessment Following curricular change, routine assessment of SLOs should occur to ensure that student learning goals related to psychological literacy are being achieved. Curricular adjustments (and follow-up assessment) can be implemented accordingly. As the curriculum matures, individual course assessments can be scheduled on a rotating basis (e.g., every 2 or 3 years) rather than each semester. Given that the concept of psychological literacy has important implications for students well beyond their undergraduate years, postgraduate surveys of alumni seem worthwhile. Such surveys can query graduates about the extent to which their psychological knowledge informs and contributes to their current professional and private lives.
Educating a Literate Citizenry Beyond the formal undergraduate curriculum (see Dunn et al., 2010), we hope that all students—including those who do not pursue careers or education related to the discipline—will retain a lifelong interest in psychology and an appreciation of its relevance to everyday life. A curriculum designed to promote psychological literacy should equip students with the intellectual tools necessary to becoming “socially responsible problem solvers” (McGovern et al., 2010, p. 20). Such a curriculum can foster the development of individuals ready to combat societal ills
24
T h e P s y c h o l o gi c a l ly Lit e r at e Citi z e n
and work for the betterment of daily life for men and women across the socioeconomic and cultural spectrum. Indeed, the ultimate goal of a curriculum designed to promote psychological literacy is the cultivation of a psychologically literate citizenry.
References American Psychological Association. (2002). Ethical principles of psychologists and code of conduct. American Psychologist, 57, 1060–1073. American Psychological Association. (2007). APA guidelines for the undergraduate psychology major. Retrieved April 11, 2010, from http://www.apa.org/ed/psymajor_ guideline.pdf. American Psychological Association. (2010). Publication manual of the American Psychological Association (6th ed.). Washington, D. C.: Author. Angelo, T. A., & Cross, K. P. (1993). Classroom assessment techniques: a handbook for college teachers (2nd ed.). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Baker, S. C., McCarthy, M. A., Halonen, J. S., Dunn, D. S., & Hill, G. W., IV. (2010). DevelÂ� oping scientific reasoning skills in beginning and ending students. In D. S. Dunn, B. C. Beins, M. A. McCarthy, & G. W. Hill, IV (Eds.), Best practices for beginnings and endings in the psychology major (pp. 349–363). New York: Oxford University Press. Beins, B. C., Smith, R. A., & Dunn, D. S. (2010). Writing as a developmental process. In D. S. Dunn, B. C. Beins, M. A. McCarthy, & G. W. Hill, IV (Eds.), Best practices for beginnings and endings in the psychology major (pp. 253–278). New York: Oxford University Press. Beins, B. C., & Wann, P. D. (2010). Research teams: developing a capstone experience with programmatic research. In D. S. Dunn, B. C. Beins, M. A. McCarthy, & G. W. Hill, IV (Eds.), Best practices for beginnings and endings in the psychology major: research, cases, and recommendations (pp. 187–203). New York: Oxford University Press. Brewer, C. L., Hopkins, J. R., Kimble, G. A., Matlin, M. W., McCann, L. I., McNeil, O. V., Nodine, B. F., Quinn, V. N., & Saundra. (1993). Curriculum. In T. V. McGovern (Ed.), Handbook for enhancing undergraduate education in psychology (pp. 161–182). Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. Buxton, C. E., Cofer, C. N., Gustad, J. W., MacLeod, R. B., McKeachie, W. J., & Wolfle, D. (1952). Improving undergraduate instruction in psychology. New York: Macmillan. Cacioppo, J. (2007, September). Psychology is a hub science. APS Observer, 20(5), 42. Diamond, R. M. (2008). Designing and assessing courses and curricula: a practical guide (3rd ed.). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Donald, J. G. (2002). Learning to think: disciplinary perspectives. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Dunn, D. S., Brewer, C. L., Cautin, R. L., Gurung, R. A. R., Keith, K. D., McGregor, L. N., Nida, S. A., Puccio, P., & Voight, M. J. (2010). The undergraduate psychology curriculum: call for a core. In D. F. Halpern (Ed.), Undergraduate education in psychology: a blueprint for the future of the discipline (pp. 47–61). Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. Dunn, D. S., & McCarthy, M. A. (2010). The capstone course in psychology as liberal education opportunity. In D. S. Dunn, B. C. Beins, M. A. McCarthy, & G. W. Hill, IV (Eds.),
Curriculum Matters
25
Best practices for beginnings and endings in the psychology major (pp. 155–170). New York: Oxford University Press. Dunn, D. S., McCarthy, M., Baker, S., Halonen, J. S., & Hill, G. W., IV. (2007). Quality benchmarks in undergraduate psychology programs. American Psychologist, 62, 650–670. Dunn, D. S., McCarthy, M. A., Baker, S. & Halonen, J. S. (2011). Using quality benchmarks for assessing and developing undergraduate programs. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Dunn, D. S., Wilson, J. C., Freeman, J., & Stowell, J. R. (Eds.). (2011). Getting connected: best practices for technology-enhanced teaching and learning in psychology. New York: Oxford University Press. Goldstein, R. (2010). Major developments in undergraduate education. Observer, 23(3), 23–26. Gurung, R. A. R., & Prieto, L. (Eds.) (2009). Getting culture: incorporating diversity across the curriculum. Arlington, VA: Stylus. Halonen, J. S., Bosack, T., Clay, S., & McCarthy, M. (with Dunn, D. S., Hill IV, G. W., McEntarfer, R., Mehrotra, C., Nesmith, R., Weaver, K., & Whitlock, K.) (2003). A rubric for authentically learning, teaching, and assessing scientific reasoning in psychology. Teaching of Psychology, 30, 196–208. Halpern, D. F. (Ed.). (2010). Undergraduate education in psychology: a blueprint for the future of the discipline. Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. Kulik, J. A., Brown, D. R., Vestewig, R. E., & Wright, J. (1973). Undergraduate education in psychology. Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. Lutsky, N., Torney-Purta, J., Velayo, R., Whittlesey, V., Woolf, L., & McCarthy, M. (2005). American Psychological Association working group on internationalizing the undergraduate psychology curriculum: Report and recommended learning outcomes for internationalizing the undergraduate curriculum. Retrieved April 13, 2010, from http:// www.apa.org/international/governance/cirp/s08-agenda-20-exhibit-1.pdf. McGovern, T. V. (Ed.). (1993). Handbook for enhancing undergraduate education in psychology. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association. McGovern, T. V., Corey, L., Cranney, J., Dixon, W. E., Jr., Holmes, J. D., Kuebli, J. E., Ritchey, K. A., Smith, R. A., & Walker, S. J. (2010). Psychologically literate citizens. In D. F. Halpern (Ed.), Undergraduate education in psychology: a blueprint for the future of the discipline (pp. 9–27). Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. McGovern, T. V., Furumoto, L., Halpern, D. F., Kimble, G. A., & McKeachie, W. J. (1991). Liberal education, study in depth, and the arts and science major—psychology. American Psychologist, 46, 598–605. McKeachie, W. J., & Milholland, J. E. (1961). Undergraduate curricula in psychology. Chicago: Scott, Foresman. Pusateri, T. P., Poe, R. E., Addison, W. E., & Goedel, G. D. (2004). Designing and implementing psychology program reviews. In D. S. Dunn, C. M. Mehrotra, & J. S. Halonen (Eds.), Measuring up: educational assessment challenges and practices for psychology (pp. 65–89). Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. Scheirer, C. J., & Rogers, A. M. (1985). The undergraduate psychology curriculum: 1984. Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. Sexton, V. S., & Hogan, J. D. (1992). International psychology: views from around the world. Omaha, NE: University of Nebraska Press.
26
T h e P s y c h o l o gi c a l ly Lit e r at e Citi z e n
Stoloff, M., McCarthy, M., Keller, L., Varfolomeeva, V., Lynch, J., Makara, K., et al. (2010). The undergraduate psychology major: an examination of structure and sequence. Teaching of Psychology, 37(1), 4–15. doi:10.1080/00986280903426274. Suskie, L. (2009). Assessing student learning: a common sense guide (2nd ed). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
3 Critical Thinking and the Education of Psychologically Literate Citizens D i a n e F. H a l p e r n a n d H e a t h e r A . B u t l e r
A
s we began working on this chapter, a student stopped by to discuss his plans for the future. He was two courses away from graduating with a bachelor’s degree in psychology at a prestigious liberal arts college in the United States. In the course of our conversation he explained that he had no interest in counseling, teaching, or research, so we asked him what did interest him about psychology. He said he had a theory, which does not merit repeating here, about the singular etiology of all mental illness. After discussing the flaws of his theory with him, it became clear that he had never taken a class on the subject, nor had he done much independent reading on the topic of mental illness, but he was still eager to share his insights despite the fact that he had no knowledge of the topic. In fact, he did not recognize the need for knowledge: he was content discussing his (uninformed) opinion with us. This hapless student did not understand the definition or importance of a theory. He went on to explain that he believed in palmistry (palm-reading) and asked our opinion of it. At that point in the conversation we exchanged disappointed, knowing glances. How could a senior psychology major at a highly selective college exhibit such poor critical thinking and psychological literacy? Fortunately, we have considerable data showing that he is exceptional in his illiteracy, but having this student appear, as though on cue, as we began this chapter, made us even more committed to make a convincing case for providing an effective education in thinking like a psychological scientist. As educators we must be resolute in training our students to think critically, make informed decisions, and become educated consumers.
The Need for Psychological Literacy We live in a world that becomes more complex and technical with each passing day. Average users in the United States spend 12 hours a week on the internet (Kerr, 2009), and few of today’s young adults can imagine a time when information was not literally at their fingertips. Students today need to be savvy navigators of the
28
T h e P s y c h o l o g i c a l ly Lit e r at e Citi z e n
information superhighway and to think carefully about the massive quantities of information they consume. There are undeniable benefits to the new ways of obtaining information that have come with massive Internet use, but there are important caveats that go along with increased access to multiple forms of data. Internet scams have become increasingly sophisticated, hate sites are often disguised as scientific data, and social media networks are being used for cyber-bullying and illegal activities. The tsunami of information that is deluging all of us is of value only if we can discern what is credible, read with comprehension, recognize pseudoscience, and think critically about the myriad of topics that confront us in our everyday personal and professional lives. Access to information from distant countries has made us all potentially, at least, global citizens, even if we have never traveled outside our hometown, and as such we need to be able to see issues from multiple perspectives without losing sight of the fact that all information is not equally good. Many people have questioned whether today’s students, who are tomorrow’s workforce, will be smart enough to meet the demands of the future (Hunt, 1995). The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics for 2010–11 reports an increased demand for “knowledge workers” or “symbol analysts.” These terms describe workers who can complete multistep operations, manipulate abstract symbols, understand complex ideas, acquire new accurate information efficiently, and are flexible in their thinking. These new workers must also recognize that change is inevitable, retraining is probable, and continuous learning is necessary to meet the demands of a complex world. As educators in a changing world we must ask ourselves: Are we training our students to meet the demands of the future? Recently, there has been a call for the reform of undergraduate psychology education (Halpern, 2010b). Most of what students are explicitly taught in the classroom is domain-specific, with little thought or effort about using what is learned inside the classroom in out-of-classroom settings. In the jargon of psychology, few faculty members actually teach for transfer, yet it is transfer that is the reason for a formal education. College faculty assess learning with various methods (mostly tests) in each class, but the real test of what is learned occurs outside the university campus, at some time in the future, and at a place that is not very similar to a college classroom. Will the students who sit in our classrooms today be able to use their knowledge of child development when they make decisions about their own children or when they vote on measures that pertain to education? Will they use what they learn in cognitive development to improve their memory or make better decisions? Can they recognize error variance and statistical principles when they are confronted with issues in the workplace where these principles are relevant? Sadly, for most students, a majority of this domain-specific information will not be applied outside of the classroom unless it is specifically relevant to their lives and unless they recognize the links between what happens in class and life outside of class. The main job of college faculty is to teach in ways that make transfer across time, space, setting, and academic disciplines more likely. We want graduates who can and will use the skills and content they learn in school when they are making decisions about their family life, in their workplace, and in the exercise of responsible citizenship.
Critical Thinking and the Education of Psychologically Literate Citizens
29
Most psychology majors choose psychology because they believe that the skills they learn as psychology majors can be applied to a variety of careers in business, healthcare, government, and education. Unfortunately, there is a mismatch between students’ expectations and how faculty members prepare their courses. In the United States, most undergraduate psychology courses are designed to prepare graduates for advanced graduate-school training, even if that is not the stated objective: how else could we justify some of the more abstruse concepts that we include in our classes—ones with little relevance in any setting outside of academia? But the overwhelming majority of psychology majors will never attend graduate school. What do they need to know and be able to do in their future lives as they develop careers in commerce, the law, teaching, medicine, finance, and the multitude of other professions they are likely to enter? Based on these contemporary demands, psychological literacy has been identified as a universal goal of an education in psychology.
Conceptual Underpinnings of Psychological Literacy Virtually everyone will agree that educated citizens need to know how to use quantitative information and read with a high level of comprehension. We use the term “literacy” for these ways of understanding mathematical and verbal information. McGovern and colleagues (2010) extended the list of basic literacies to include both knowledge about psychological concepts and the willingness and ability to think like a psychological scientist. At the heart of psychological literacy is an answer about what we want our students to know and be able to do when they graduate from college. It is a body of knowledge, skills, and disposition that all college graduates should possess. Essential knowledge about human thought and behavior is necessary for all educated adults, but we would expect a higher level of psychological literacy from students who graduate with a degree in psychology. According to McGovern and colleagues (2010), psychological literacy is: • Having a well-defined vocabulary and basic knowledge of the critical subject matter of psychology • Valuing the intellectual challenges required to use scientific thinking and the disciplined analysis of information to evaluate alternative courses of actions • Taking a creative and amiable-skeptic approach to problem solving • Applying psychological principles to personal, social, and organizational issues in work, relationships, and the broader community • Acting ethically • Being competent in using and evaluating information and technology • Communicating effectively in different modes and with many different audiences • Recognizing, understanding, and fostering respect for diversity • Being insightful and reflective about one’s own and others’ behavior and mental processes.
30
T h e P s y c h o l o g i c a l ly Lit e r at e Citi z e n
McGovern and colleagues (2010) provide numerous examples of psychological literacy in action. For example, when evaluating the effect of a community housing unit for adults with mental disabilities, the psychologically literate citizen will respond to the “not in my backyard” (NIMBY) responses of neighbors who are concerned that crime rates will increase and property values will decline. The response to these and other psychology-related concerns is to look for relevant research. What actually happened when homes for mentally disabled adults were opened in other neighborhoods? Are the neighbors’ fears justified based on what we know from the research literature? The psychologically literate adult will look for information that would inform the decision and will effectively communicate research findings, so that those who live in any neighborhood where group homes for psychologically disabled adults are being planned can respond in a reasoned manner that is based on relevant information instead of responding based on fear and ignorance. In addition, the psychologically literate adult will call upon knowledge about mental disabilities that he or she learned in college classes. Thus, psychological literacy is both a disposition to seek and interpret relevant information and a conscious effort to recall and use knowledge about psychologically related topics.
Critical Thinking and Psychological Literacy Are Overlapping Constructs Readers with a solid background in the literature on critical thinking will recognize that there is considerable overlap between psychological literacy and critical thinking (Fig. 3.1). This conceptual overlap is not surprising given that both constructs are firmly rooted in the methods and content of psychology. Critical thinking has been described in a variety of different ways, but researchers generally agree that it involves an attempt to achieve a desired outcome by thinking rationally in a goaloriented fashion and reasoning in an open-ended manner (e.g., Ennis, 1993; Halpern, 2003; Moseley et al., 2005; Sternberg, Roediger, & Halpern, 2007). Halpern (1998, 2003) defines critical thinking as: the use of those cognitive skills or strategies that increase the probability of a desirable outcome. It is used to describe thinking that is purposeful, reasoned, and goal directed—the kind of thinking involved in solving problems, formulating inferences, calculating likelihoods, and making decisions, when the thinker is using skills that are thoughtful and effective for the particular context and type of thinking task. (p. 6) We think of psychological literacy as consisting of two parts: (a) content knowledge, consisting of knowledge about psychological research and basic constructs, and (b) critical thinking, or thinking like a psychological scientist. The content portion of psychological literacy consists of essential knowledge about the brain bases of thinking, learning, and emotion; how people learn and remember; the way social
Critical Thinking and the Education of Psychologically Literate Citizens
31
Content
Scientific Reasoning
Critical Thinking Skills
Dispositions
Figure 3.1╇ Psychological literacy consists of the content matter in psychology, critical thinking skills and disposition, and scientific reasoning, which in a subset of all three components.
situations affect behavior; how people develop emotionally and cognitively; and basic concepts regarding mental disorders and their treatment—in short, essential knowledge that can be found in most good introductory psychology textbooks. For psychologically literate citizens, this essential knowledge is not inert—it is frequently retrieved and modified by interacting with others at work, at home, and in other settings. The critical thinking portion of psychological literacy refers to the use of critical thinking skills across a wide range of contexts and the willingness to do the hard work of thinking. Unfortunately, critical thinking is sometimes confused with negative thinking because the word “critical” is often used to connate negative values. For example, you might describe a colleague’s feedback on a manuscript as being too critical, which is intended to mean that the colleague’s feedback was too negative. However, the “critical” in “critical thinking” refers to careful evaluation that elaborates on both the positive and negative aspects of a problem or argument. Whereas critical thinking is good thinking, non-critical thinking is poor thinking. Non-critical thinkers would not dismiss palmistry, or would believe in palmistry, without giving their belief much conscious thought, or would decide about the desirability of having a home for mentally disabled adults in their neighborhood based on some “gut” feeling or intuition without considering the information that is relevant to decisions about where to house mentally disabled adults. Critical thinkers entertain the validity of palmistry or any other topic by investigating the evidence. They might read research articles testing the ability to know something about someone’s future by “reading” the palms of his or her hands to determine whether it was a reliable phenomenon, and they would seek credible theories that relate the lines in one’s hands to life outcomes such as longevity and love. (In case you are
32
T h e P s y c h o l o g i c a l ly Lit e r at e Citi z e n
curious, there is no empirical evidence suggesting that palmistry is valid or reliable). We think of critical thinkers as amiable skeptics, not cynics. They examine the evidence before arriving at their conclusion and remain open to different types of evidence, even when the evidence runs counter to an existing belief or preferred outcome. Critical thinking is both a disposition and a learned skill (Halpern, 2003). Critical thinkers have developed an attitude or disposition toward approaching problems. They are motivated thinkers who effortfully (deliberately) process information. Critical thinkers spend more time preparing and planning than do non-critical thinkers. They are more flexible and open-minded. Critical thinkers are persistent and exert mental energy working on difficult problems. Critical thinkers are willing to admit when they are wrong and will change their mind if the evidence changes. Unlike poor thinkers, who may operate on autopilot much of the time, critical thinkers are willfully engaged in the task at hand. Although critical thinking is a disposition, it also can be a learned behavior. There is a substantial body of empirical evidence that indicates critical thinking skills can be learned and can transfer to other domains. A review of this literature is beyond the scope of this chapter (for reviews, see Chance, 1986; Halpern, 2003; Moseley et al., 2005; Nisbett, 1992), but we will elaborate on a few tests of this hypothesis. Researchers have used a variety of methods to assess whether critical thinking skills can be effectively taught and whether critical thinking skills can transfer to other domains. Some of these methods include self-reported critical thinking abilities (Walsh, Seldomridge, & Badros, 2007), randomized controlled experiments that used control groups and blind-raters to rate the quality of oral arguments and essays (Herrnstein, Nickerson, de Sanchez, & Swets, 1986), standardized Piagetian cognitive development tasks (Fox, Marsh, & Crandall, 1983; McKinnon & Renner, 1971), argument mapping (Davies, 2008), coding discussions and blog entries for examples of critical thinking and examples of poor thinking (Wang, Woo, & Zhao, 2009), requiring students to justify and explain their ideas (Barak, 2009), multiple-choice tests of critical thinking skills (Lehman, Lempert, & Nisbett, 1988), and real-world argument analysis (Fong, Krantz, & Nisbett, 1986). Nisbett and his colleagues conducted a series of interesting experiments that provide the strongest support for the idea that critical thinking skills can be learned. In one such experiment, Fong, Krantz, and Nisbett (1986) contacted students who had previously received instruction involving statistical thinking skills (e.g., the law of large numbers) under the façade of a phone survey. The students spontaneously used their critical thinking skills while completing the phone survey. The students identified the appropriate skill for the problems and used that skill. Additionally, the knowledge that the students learned transferred from academia to a real-world situation (i.e., the phone interview) months after the students were finished with the course. These findings suggest that critical thinking skills can be taught and can transfer to other domains. Psychology is not the only discipline to have aspirational goals for its majors. In the United States, nursing, for example, has adopted a list of necessary
Critical Thinking and the Education of Psychologically Literate Citizens
33
competencies for its graduates, and critical thinking is an explicit learning goal for future nurses (Giddens & Gloeckner, 2005). The impetus for learning outcomes in nursing and other medical fields has come, in large part, from concern over patient safety (Proctor, Compton, Grossman, & Fanjiang, 2005). Clinical judgment in nursing is often assessed with a series of videotaped vignettes that depict common problems that can occur in a wide variety of situations, such as a change in the mental status of a patient or the effect of anxiety on clinical symptoms (Performance Management Systems, 2006). Not surprisingly, an increased emphasis on critical thinking has also dominated much of the literature on medical education. Wilson (2010) described the trend toward evidence-based medicine in much the same way as colleagues in other disciplines are discussing evidence-based education and evidence-based practices in clinical psychology. He described evidence-based practice as “a new paradigm in how information is to be used and prioritized in caring for patients” (p. 398). Although Wilson criticizes the unthinking use of evidence-based approaches, the advantages of developing the habit of looking for and using relevant research seem evident. This approach is similar to the idea of psychological literacy, which can be thought of as evidence-based psychology. A major difference is that psychological literacy is a desirable, perhaps even necessary, outcome for all educated adults because everyone needs basic knowledge about child development, mental disorders, thinking and learning, and the other core topics in psychology. The skills in understanding and applying empirically validated research should be enhanced in psychology majors relative to students who major in other disciplines, but it is a necessary educational outcome for all educated adults. In addition to content knowledge, psychological literacy includes the skills of critical thinking and the willingness to employ those skills across a variety of contexts. There are a variety of known clearly identifiable critical thinking skills; idenÂ� tifying which skill is the appropriate skill for a particular problem is one of the greatest challenges of becoming a critical thinker. The Halpern Critical Thinking Assessment (Halpern, 2010a) categorizes these skills into five categories: (a) verbal reasoning skills, (b) argument analysis skills, (c) skills in thinking as hypothesis testing, (d) using likelihood and uncertainty, and (e) decision-making and problem-solving skills. Together, these five categories define an organizational rubric for a skills approach to critical thinking. They have face validity and can be easily communicated to the general public, and they offer one possible answer to the question of what students need to know and be able to do when they enter the workforce or what employees need to know and be able to do to advance to a stage in their career that requires higher-order thinking skills. The Halpern Critical Thinking Assessment consists of 25 everyday scenarios, each of which is briefly described and presented using common language. For each scenario, respondents are first asked an open-ended (i.e., constructed response) question, which is followed by a forced-choice question (e.g., multiple choice, ranking, or rating of alternatives), such as select the best alternative, rate each of the alternatives in terms of their relevance, or indicate which two of the following alternatives would
34
T h e P s y c h o l o g i c a l ly Lit e r at e Citi z e n
be a good response. Cognitive psychologists differentiate between free recall and recognition processes in memory, and these two types of questions are designed to take advantage of the different cognitive processes. The total score is (approximately) equally weighted between constructed response and forced-choice questions. The Halpern Critical Thinking Assessment is being used in multiple languages and in multiple countries around the world (Ku, 2009). Critical thinking skills cross disciplinary boundaries, and as such, they are an essential component of psychological literacy. Halpern (1998, 2003) previously proposed a four-part model for teaching critical thinking skills for effective transfer to other domains. The model involves (a) explicitly learning critical thinking skills, (b) developing a disposition or attitude toward effortful thinking and learning, (c) directing learning activities in ways that increase the probability of transcontextual transfer (structure training), and (d) making metacognitive monitoring explicit and overt. This model should also be appropriate for the training of psychological literacy. The first step in the four-part model of learning to think critically is to explicitly learn the critical thinking skills. The following is a list of skills we should be teaching our students in order to strengthen their critical thinking skills and their psychological literacy: • Recognize semantic slanting and guilt by association. • Seek out contradictory evidence. • Use metacognitive knowledge that allows novices to monitor their own performance and decide when additional help is needed. • Make risk/benefit assessments. • Generate a reasoned method for selecting among several possible courses of actions. • Give reasons for choices as well as varying the style and amount of detail in explanations depending on who is receiving the information. • Recall relevant information when it is needed. • Use skills for learning new techniques efficiently and relating new knowledge to information that was previously learned. • Use numerical information, including the ability to think probabilistically and express thoughts numerically. • Understand basic research principles. • Demonstrate an advanced ability to read and write complex prose. • Present a coherent and persuasive argument on a controversial, contemporary topic. • Provide complex instruction in language that is appropriate for the audience. • Use matrices and other diagrams for communication. • Synthesize information from a variety of sources. • Determine credibility and use this information in formulating and communicating decisions.
Critical Thinking and the Education of Psychologically Literate Citizens
35
Dispositions for Critical Thinking The second part of the critical thinking model is the development of the dispositional or attitudinal aspect of thinking and learning. This is one area where there is considerable overlap between critical thinking and psychological literacy. Students must be encouraged to value thinking critically because many of the logical errors that people make occur not because they do not have the ability to think critically, but because they simply fail to do so. Poor thinking and the use of heuristic shortcuts is easier than thinking critically, so we must encourage our students to be prepared for action—the work of thinking critically. Students should be encouraged to (a) plan ahead, because critical thinkers often spend more time in preparation, (b) be flexible and avoid dogmatic thinking, (c) be persistent in solving complicated problems, (d) be willing to self-correct, admit errors, and change their mind, and (e) be mindful of what and how they are thinking. This disposition is consistent with the values we encourage in psychologically literate citizens: specifically, the valuing of intellectual challenges required to use scientific thinking and taking an amiable-skeptic approach to problem solving. Both of these principles of psychological literacy relate to dispositions of critical thinkers that educators can encourage. The third part of the model is related to developing teaching methods that allow transfer of critical thinking skills to other domains. Critical thinkers need to recognize the same structural cues present in non-academic and non-psychological domains. For example, one major psychological truism is that you cannot determine causality using correlational methods (“correlation does not mean causation”). While many students may correctly identify this problem inside a classroom or in the domain of psychology, they may fail to transfer that knowledge to the real world. A recent example of this was seen on the popular “news” program that airs daily on U.S. television, The Today Show with Kathie Lee and Hoda. The co-hosts interviewed the writer of a new book about marriage. The author reported data from a large study in the United States, and she asked Kathie Lee and Hoda the following question, “People who listen to which type of music are having the most sex?” and the response options were (a) rock and roll, (b) jazz, (c) hip-hop, or (d) country. After listening to the co-hosts’ responses the author exclaimed, “Jazz lovers have about 30% more sex than the others, so turn on that jazz music!” In this real-world example, the author of the book made a causal statement about an observed correlational relationship (i.e., music choice and amount of sex). Critical thinkers and those who are psychologically literate should be able to identify the problem with this author’s argument even though it was not presented in the context it was taught in. More generally, knowledge transfer can be fostered by requiring students to perform knowledge transfer and by drawing attention to the structural aspects of a problem, so that students can identify similar structural problems in the real world. This is what is meant by applying psychological principles to personal, social, and organizational issues at work, in relationships, and in the broader community, a major tenet of psychological literacy. The following is a list of knowledge transfer exercises that Halpern (2003)
36
T h e P s y c h o l o g i c a l ly Lit e r at e Citi z e n
has recommended for use in any course where the main objective is transfer of knowledge: • Draw a diagram or other graphic display that organizes the information. • List additional information you would want before answering a question. • Explain why a particular multiple-choice alternative was selected. Which is second best? Why? • State the problem in at least two ways. • Identify which information is most important. Which information is least important? Why? • Categorize the findings in a meaningful way. • List two solutions for problems. • Identify what is wrong with an assertion that was made in the question. • Present two reasons that support the conclusion and two reasons that do not support the conclusion. • Identify the type of persuasive technique being used. • Present two actions you would take to improve the design of a study that was described. The fourth part of the critical thinking model is metacognitive monitoring. Metacognition is an awareness of one’s thought processes or knowing what we do and do not know. Practicing metacognition requires self-reflection, self-awareness, and the ability to self-regulate or manage one’s cognitive abilities (Dean & Kuhn, 2003). Critical thinkers evidence more metacognitive monitoring than non-critical thinkers (Halpern, 2003; Wang, Woo, & Zhao, 2009). There is also empirical evidence suggesting that critical thinking can be improved through metacognitive monitoring (Cohen, Freeman, & Wolf, 1996). Metacognition is involved in selecting which learning strategy to use and determining how resources are allocated. The idea of metacognitive monitoring relates to two principles of psychological literacy: being competent using and evaluating information and technology, and being insightful and reflective about one’s own and others’ behavior and mental processes. Educators can encourage metacognitive monitoring by requiring students to explain their reasoning and any evidence that supports or refutes their position. Having to explain both the supportive and non-supportive evidence is critical to increasing metacognition and identifying biased assumptions.
Scientific Reasoning, Critical Thinking, and Psychological Literacy The constructs of critical thinking and psychological literacy also share considerable overlap with the knowledge and skills required in scientific reasoning. We conceptualize scientific reasoning as a component of both critical thinking and psychological literacy. Scientific reasoning involves understanding the scientific method and using that knowledge as a guide for evaluating research and for
Critical Thinking and the Education of Psychologically Literate Citizens
37
designing studies that can answer empirical questions. It is not a set of skills that are required only for scientists; the general public needs to be wise consumers of research and other activities that are sometimes dressed up and labeled as research, even though they do not adhere to the basic principles of scientific inquiry. Research methods and the use of statistical inference are at the heart of the major in psychology, so psychology is a primary major for the development of scientific reasoning skills in college students. Psychologically literate citizens (who could also be called critical thinkers) will know what questions to ask when they are presented with research findings. These findings can come from diverse topics, including the use of plant food to increase plant growth, facilitated communication in which autistic children (supposedly) communicate for the first time when aides guide their hands over keyboards or similar devices, and the likelihood that students will learn more when their teachers receive higher pay. In all of these examples, and countless others, the students we are preparing for the future need to ask good questions about the quality of the evidence that is offered in support of conclusions, seek empirical information, recognize flaws, and make informed decisions based on their knowledge of psychology and their ability to think critically.
Assessing Psychological Literacy We have conceptualized psychological literacy as part critical thinking, which includes the skills and the disposition to think critically, and fluency with the content matter of psychology. But merely calling on higher education to educate students in psychological literacy is hollow unless we provide a means for assessing how well individual students and institutions achieve this goal. This is an ideal time to propose an assessment of psychological literacy because the movement to assess learning outcomes is gaining traction throughout the world. Higher education in Europe is being restructured under the “Bologna Process,” which is transforming education in 47 countries. According to a recent report, 53 percent of the countries involved in this process have developed learning outcomes for all courses, and another 32 percent have developed them for some courses (Sursock & Smidt, 2010). Similar efforts are underway in the countries that make up the African Union and Latin American and Caribbean Higher Education Area (Redden, 2010). In the United States, multiple projects are being conducted in which employers, alumni, current students, and faculty are identifying general and subject-area competencies. It is against this backdrop of assessment activities that we propose a standardized assessment of psychological literacy. An assessment of psychological literacy would include a variety of scenarios, similar to the concern over having a home for disabled adults in one’s neighborhood that was used as an exemplar by McGovern and colleagues (2010). Students could demonstrate their knowledge of psychology and critical thinking skills by responding to a series of questions about each scenario, in much the same way that critical thinking skills are assessed across domains of knowledge with the Halpern Critical Thinking Assessment (2010). For example, students could be
38
T h e P s y c h o l o g i c a l ly Lit e r at e Citi z e n
asked to identify additional information they would need to formulate a quality response or explain how they would design a study to answer a research question. Scenarios would reflect the range of topics where knowledge of psychological principles and critical thinking skills are needed for a reasoned response. Some possible examples include an advertisement for a drug that claims to improve memory, a simulation of a jury that is deliberating about the use of eyewitness testimony, an evaluation of a therapy for autism, an editorial claiming that girls and boys are so different that they need separate educational experiences, a blog about a program designed to reduce smoking in adolescents, and so on. The list of psychology-relevant topics is virtually endless. Once standardized, institutions could gauge whether they are making progress in graduating psychologically literate students, and individual students could learn how they fare relative to other students at similar and dissimilar institutions. We urge interested readers to join us in developing this assessment. It will not be easy to educate our students for tasks that are often ambiguous and out of our control and depend on effortful processing. But it is our most important task as college faculty, and with our own hard work and thoughtful effort, we can educate psychologically literate citizens with the dispositions and skills of critical thinkers and the specific knowledge of research methods to be wise consumers of research.
References Barak, M. (2009). Idea focusing versus idea generating: A course for teachers on inventive problem solving. Innovations in Education and Teaching International, 46, 345–356. DOI: 10.1080/14703290903301743. Bureau of Labor Statistics. (2010–2011). Occupational outlook handbook, 2010–2011 edition. Retrieved from http://www.bls.gov/oco/ocos021.htm. Chance, P. (1986). Thinking in the classroom: a survey of programs. New York: Teachers College, Columbia University. Cohen, M. S., Freeman, J. T., & Wolf, S. (1996). Metarecognition in time-stressed decision making: Recognizing, critiquing, and correcting. Human Factors, 38, 206–219. doi: 10.1518/001872096779048020. Davies, W. M. (2008). “Not quite right”: helping students to make better arguments. Teaching in Higher Education, 13, 327–340. DOI: 10.1080/13562510802045352. Dean, D., & Kuhn, D. (2003). Metacognition and critical thinking. New York: Teachers College, Columbia University. Ennis, R. H. (1993). Critical thinking assessment. Theory Into Practice, 32, 179–186. Fong, G. T., Krantz, D. H., & Nisbett, R. E. (1986). The effects of statistical training on thinking about everyday problems. Cognitive Psychologist, 18, 253–292. doi:10.1016/0010–0285(86)90001–0. Fox, L. S., Marsh, G., & Crandall, J. C., Jr. (1983). The effect of college classroom experiences on formal operational thinking. Paper presented at the 1983 Annual Convention of the Western Psychological Association, San Francisco.
Critical Thinking and the Education of Psychologically Literate Citizens
39
Giddens, J., & Gloeckner, G. W. (2005). The relationship of critical thinking to performance on the NCLEX-RN. Journal of Nursing Education, 44, 85–89. Halpern, D. F. (1998). Teaching critical thinking for transfer across domains: dispositions, skills, structure training, and metacognitive monitoring. American Psychologist, 53, 449–455. Halpern, D. F. (2003). Thought and knowledge: an introduction to critical thinking (4th ed.). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Halpern, D. F. (2010a). Halpern Critical Thinking Assessment. SCHUHFRIED (Vienna Test System). www.schuhfried.at. Halpern, D. F. (2010b). Undergraduate education in psychology: a blueprint for the future of the discipline. Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. Herrnstein, R. J., Nickerson, R. S., de Sanchez, M., & Swets, J. A. (1986). Teaching thinking skills. American Psychologist, 41, 1279–1289. doi: 10.1037/0003–066X.41.11.1279. Hunt, E. (1995). Will we be smart enough? A cognitive analysis of the coming workforce. New York: Russell Sage Foundation. Kerr, D. (2009, June 26). Overall time spent online remains static. Digital Media, Cnet news. Retrieved from http://news.cnet.com/8301–1023_3–10297935-93.html. Ku, K. Y. L. (2009). Assessing students’ critical thinking performance: urging for measurements using multi-response format. Thinking Skills and Creativity, 2, 70–76. doi:10.1016/j.tsc.2009.02.001. Lehman, D. R., Lempert, R. O., & Nisbett, R. E. (1988). The effects of graduate training on reasoning: formal discipline and thinking about everyday-life events. American Psychologist, 43(6), 431–442. doi: 10.1037/0003–066X.43.6.431. McGovern, T. V., Corey, L., Cranney, J., Dixon Jr. W.E., Holmes, J. D., Kuebli J. E., Ritchey K. A., Smith R. A., & Walker, S. J. (2010). Psychologically literate citizens. In D. F. Halpern (Ed.), Undergraduate education in psychology: a blueprint for the future of the discipline (pp. 9–27). Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. McKinnon, J. W., & Renner, J. W. (1971). Are colleges concerned with intellectual development? American Journal of Psychology, 39, 1047–1052. Moseley, D., Baumfield, V., Elliott, J., Gregson, M., Higgins, S., Miller, J., & Newton D. P. (2005). Frameworks for thinking: a handbook for teaching and learning. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Nisbett, R. E. (1992). Rules for reasoning. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. Performance Management Services, Inc. (2006). What is PBDS?. Retrieved from http:// www.pmsi-pbds.com on July 11, 2007. Proctor, P., Compton, W., Grossman, J., & Fanjiang, G. (2005). Building a better delivery system: a new engineering/health care partnership. Institute of Medicine and National Academy of Engineering. Washington, D. C.: The Nationals Academies Press. Redden, E. (2010). Bologna beyond Europe. Higher Education News. Retrieved from http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2010/06/07/bologna. Sternberg, R. J., Roediger, H. L., III., & Halpern, D. F. (Eds.). (2007). Critical thinking in psychology. New York: Cambridge University Press. Sursock, A., & Smidt, H. (2010). Trends 2010: a decade of change in European higher education. EUA Publications. Retrieved from http://www.eua.be/fileadmin/user_ upload/files/Publications/Trends_2010.pdf. Walsh, C. M., Seldomridge, L. A., & Badros, K. K. (2007). California Critical Thinking Disposition Inventory: further factor analytic examination. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 104, 141–151. Doi: 10.2466/PMS.104010141–151.
40
T h e P s y c h o l o g i c a l ly Lit e r at e Citi z e n
Wang, Q., Woo, H. L., & Zhao, J. (2009). Investigating critical thinking and knowledge construction in an interactive learning environment. Interactive Learning Environments, 17, 95–104. Doi: 10.1080.10494820701706320. Wilson, K. (2010). Evidence-based medicine. The good, the bad, the ugly. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice. 16, 398–400. doi:10.1111/j.1365–2753.2010.01408.x.
4 Enhancing Ethical Literacy of Psychologically Literate Citizens Graham R. Davidson and Shirley A. Morrissey
C
onsider the case of an undergraduate student who works casually as a respite carer for a local nongovernmental organization to help pay her university tuition fees. Her role brings her into contact with some fulltime welfare professionals and family guardians who, in her opinion, do not always act in the welfare interests of disabled clients for whom she cares. She would like to understand better these welfare professional standards, the legal and moral rights of her disabled clients, the rights of family guardians, and her own responsibilities to ensure her clients are treated safely and with dignity. Consider the case of an undergraduate student who works casually at a fastfood outlet where he notices that one of the supervisors behaves in an overly familiar fashion with some casual employees from ethnic minority backgrounds. The employees who grin and bear the advances seem to get the extra shifts. As a fellow employee whom they respect, he hears their dissatisfaction with the supervisor’s conduct but, at the same time, he needs the work and does not wish to rock the boat. Lastly, consider the case of the cash-poor undergraduate student who finds a wallet containing identification documents and a sizeable sum of money. The student contemplates keeping the cash but returning the wallet to its owner on the pretext that it contained only the identification documents when it was found on the sidewalk. Like it or not, psychology undergraduates are very likely to encounter situations that challenge their personal sense of good and bad, right and wrong, and efforts to do what they think is right, irrespective of whether they undertake further study required for licensing as a psychologist. With this in mind, there is increasing acknowledgment that undergraduate psychology education should ensure that psychology students receive, at the very least, some foundational knowledge about ethics to enhance their psychological literacy (McGovern et al., 2010). The definition of psychological literacy also incorporates the notion that recipients understand and respect diversity. Although diversity is undefined, in
42
T h e P s y ch o l o g i cally L i t e r at e C i t i z e n
this context it might reasonably be interpreted as ethnic, linguistic, cultural, and social diversity. Graduates demonstrate psychological literacy (i.e., act as citizens) by applying their psychological and ethical knowledge in ways that enhance their positive engagement with the community at large. Globally literate citizenry fosters intercultural understanding and engagement (Cranney & Dunn, Chapter 1 in this volume)—but in this context, what is meant by ethical literacy, acting ethically, respecting diversity, and engaging ethically with others? This chapter addresses those questions, along with questions about how educators may enhance ethical literacy in the course of undergraduate psychology education. This essential goal of ethical literacy is commensurate with the stated undergraduate quality guidelines (American Psychological Association [APA], 2007) and program accreditation standards (Australian Psychology Accreditation Council [APAC], 2009) for undergraduate psychology education respectively in the United States and Australia. In the former jurisdiction, the APA (2007) guidelines for undergraduate psychology, which elaborate on the APA (2002) Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct, include among their education goals: (1) imparting a general understanding of the ethical princiÂ�ples and code of conduct (APA, 2002, goal 1.2); (2) acting ethically generally and in research (goals 2.5 and 5.1); (3) identifying ethical issues that might ensue from psychological applications (goal 4.5); (4) using information and technology in an ethical manner (goal 6.3); (5) being sensitive to ethnic and cultural issues (goal 7.4); and (6) managing professional conflicts in an ethical manner (goal 7.5). The Australian Psychology Accreditation Council (APAC, 2009) accreditation standards are less prescriptive about undergraduate ethics education but contain a requirement for 3-year graduates to (1) acquire knowledge of the Australian Psychological Society’s (APS) Code of Ethics (2007) and Ethical Guidelines; (2) evaluate research and other ethical conduct in accordance with the Code and Guidelines (graduate attribute 4); and (3) use information ethically (graduate attribute 4). In the fourth year, students should receive instruction in professional and research ethics (standÂ� ard 4.1.8). Thus, it is reasonable to assume that undergraduate psychology education in Australia and North America imparts some aspects of ethical literacy. However, the reality of undergraduate psychology education, at least in Australia, does not support this assumption. An analysis of Australian undergraduate psychology syllabi by Davidson, Garton, and Joyce (2003) found, despite accreditation standards, that ethics education appeared in less than one quarter of syllabi for years 1 to 3 (which constitutes the bachelor degree in Australia, in contrast to the 4-year bachelor degree in the United States) and approximately 90% of syllabi for years 4 (an additional preprofessional, honors-level year, involving a research project as well as introductory professional training) and years 5 to 7 (master’s and doctoral training). There was an emphasis on some form of integrative approach in years 1 to 3 and approximately equal emphasis on integration and separation in year 4 (where integration means integrating ethical issues into other content; and separation means teaching “stand-alone” courses on ethics). Within the small proportion of 3-year undergraduate syllabi that included ethics, there was approximately equal emphasis
Enhancing Ethical Literacy of Psychologically Literate Citizens
43
on philosophical and code-based instruction, but instruction in year 4 was mainly based on the APS Code of Ethics. Lastly, research ethics was the predominant theme in years 1 to 3, followed by a comprehensive listing of professional topics in year 4. It is worth remembering that 4-year graduates in Australia may register with provisional conditions as psychologists. The lack of emphasis on ethics education in Australian programs is reflected in graduates’ negative perceptions of their ethics preparation for practice. For example, 16% to 20% of practicing psychologists surveyed in Australia held negative opinions about the ethics education they received, and more than half of comÂ� pleting fourth-year students reported receiving inadequate ethics instruction (Morrissey & Symons, 2006; Sullivan, 2005). Lipp and colleagues (2006) reported that Australian psychology educators place little importance on pre-professional ethics education. These findings paint a sufficiently gloomy picture of underÂ� graduate psychology education as preparation for ethical psychological practice. They offer no encouragement that such an education provides sufficient grounding for ethical reasoning and action in everyday living. This attribute of psyÂ�chological literacy is clearly absent from Australian undergraduate psychology education. Contemporary practice overall in undergraduate psychology education in the United States is less well documented, although there is a substantial body of literature on how to teach ethics, which we address later. Some evidence suggests that ethics education for undergraduate psychology students might be done better. For example, Amsel and Kay (2006) compared the performance of psychology and non-psychology undergraduate majors at various year levels on tests of methodological and ethical reasoning. While first-year students scored significantly lower on ethical reasoning than seniors, the correlation between ethical reasoning scores and the number of psychology courses completed was close to zero. These findings may reflect the number of courses in the syllabus that contain a component on ethics. Dunn and associates (2010) recommended that psychology syllabi incorporate ethics and diversity issues across all coursework components rather than covering ethics topics in only a limited set of courses, such as research methods and clinical and social psychology. Although expansion of the ethics component in the curriculum is very important, it is unlikely to be beneficial unless there are educational templates for developing ethically literate citizens that address questions about what is meant by ethical literacy, what the ethically literate citizen should know and comprehend, and how ethical literacy might be imparted.
Ethical Literacy A basic definition of ethics may assist with answers to these questions. Ethics is defined here as “the philosophical study of good conduct” (Ross, 1930, p. 102) and ethical decision making as making moral choices that are based on philosophical theories of good conduct. Ethical conduct, therefore, encompasses thoughts and actions that are commensurate with philosophical theories of good conduct.
44
T h e P s y ch o l o g i cally L i t e r at e C i t i z e n
Ethical theory is any theory that offers an account of ethical thought and action and makes provision in one way or another for testing the correctness of the assumptions on which the theory is based. Good conduct involves acts or omissions that are morally good or right. Rightness and wrongness are terms that refer to what is done (i.e., acts), while goodness and badness are terms that involve judgments about motives that give rise to those acts (Ross, 1930). Our cash-poor student above, for example, may return the wallet with the cash, partly out of sympathy for the owner and partly out of concern for being seen to remove the money; but the right thing to do is to return the wallet and contents intact irrespective of the reason for doing this. On what theoretical assumptions should instructors, supervisors, and students proceed, therefore, when faced with everyday moral decisions? Although the undergraduate psychology guidelines and standards summarized above require that psychology students acquire knowledge of the relevant national research and professional codes, they do not outline ethical theories that are broadly acceptable for the purpose of examining the moral dimension of either professional or personal conduct. The national research and professional codes themselves (e.g., APA, 2002; APS, 2007; NHMRC, 2007) uniformly adopt a deontological (principlebased) approach to professional and research ethics, which is acknowledged as having certain strengths and weaknesses (Davidson, 2006). It is also important to realize that the APS (2007) and APA (2002) codes of ethics or conduct do not apply to psychologists’ personal conduct, which is exempt from scrutiny, barring exceptional circumstances where disreputable or illegal personal conduct is sufficiently serious so that it weakens public confidence in the profession (but see McGovern, Chapter 21 in this volume, on character strengths of faculty). How then should undergraduate psychology syllabi be framed in order to foster awareness of moral decision making beyond the research laboratory or consulting room? How might our cash-poor student above determine whether to return the wallet intact or return the wallet but keep the cash? How might our fast-food worker above weigh his personal financial interests against the safety needs and dignity of vulnerable coworkers? The literature contains some useful exemplars for teaching ethical theory to psychology undergraduates. Fine and Ulrich (1988) suggested a course of study for inclusion in professional training that taught students about the basic precepts underpinning utilitarian and deontological ethics, which are briefly described below. The course curriculum they outlined began with students learning about those two ethical theories, followed by some rules for ethical decision making. Everyday life issues such as health, illness, suicide, and mental health were then discussed using those ethical frameworks. In the process, students examined their personal ethical reasoning about everyday issues. However, ideal utilitarian (maximization of good) and deontological (selfevident principles) theories are not necessarily every student’s preferred personal moral reasoning framework. Miner (2006) constructed a curriculum that outlines and considers the philosophical pros and cons of ideal utilitarianism, deontological
Enhancing Ethical Literacy of Psychologically Literate Citizens
45
theories, normative relativism (group standards), and classical virtue theory (being of good character). We suggest that hedonistic utilitarianism (maximization of pleasure), intuitionism (discretionary principles), radical relativism (individual values), and moral skepticism (uncertainty about the existence of moral values and standards) could usefully be included in this list. Students are directed to examine each philosophical alternative in terms of their own personal views of what is right or good and then to consider how their personal values and beliefs influence their views of morality. Miner suggested a set of decision-making steps that require students not only to consider questions that each of the major ethical theories may pose in relation to the matter under consideration but also to evaluate the quality and truthfulness of their argument, the reasonableness of the conclusion reached, the proposed course of action, and the benefits of those decision outcomes over alternative conclusions and actions. Miner’s comprehensive decision model would offer our respite carer an opportunity to compare principle-based, discretionary duty, utilitarian, and virtue-based analyses of her work predicament. Davidson (2006) examined the relevance of prima facie (discretionary) duty theory (Ross, 1930, 1939) for professional decision making, comparing and contrasting its advantages with the limitations imposed on ethical reasoning by ideal utilitarian, deontological, and classical virtue theories of ethics. Davidson set out a series of seven decision steps, based on Ross’s theory and priority ordering of conditional responsibilities, for determining the rightness or wrongness of alternative courses of action. According to Ross (1930), such decisions about what is right or wrong must be discretionary because one may have competing responsibilities to more than one other party. Our respite carer above must consider her duty to the disabled clients for whom she cares as well as to family guardians for whom she offers temporary relief from the care role. Davidson maintained that these decision steps and Ross’s priority ordering of moral responsibilities are equally applicable in situations where a moral dilemma or no moral dilemma exists as well as in situations involving personal or professional decision making. They are equally applicable, for example, to decisions about returning a lost wallet, keeping a meeting appointment, fidelity in intimate friendships, assisting a cowÂ� orker, respecting the environment, or assisting a loved one to die, as they are to respecting clients’ and carers’ rights to autonomy or safeguarding the best interests of research participants. So what are the essentials of ethical literacy and what might reasonably be expected of psychology undergraduates? • Ethically literature citizens have a disciplined knowledge of, and theoretical approach to, moral decision making. They have a vocabulary for talking about morality. Their vocabulary acquires meaning from their knowledge of a number of moral philosophical perspectives. • They understand the rules imposed on moral decision making by those different theories.
46
T h e P s y ch o l o g i cally L i t e r at e C i t i z e n
• They are familiar with, and practice using, an ethical decision framework for identifying and prioritizing alternative ways of responding when they are confronted with a moral issue. They understand the implications of different moral perspectives for evaluating those alternatives (although they may prefer one moral perspective over other moral perspectives and, thus, one alternative course of action over others). • They understand and apply appropriate evaluative criteria provided by their preferred moral perspective to determine whether their proposed or actual conduct is ethical. • Finally, they are meta-ethical and reflective in the sense that they are able to generalize their ethics vocabulary, knowledge of theory, decision steps, and evaluative criteria to help them understand what is right or wrong, good or bad, in a diversity of personal and professional situations. • All other things being equal, in their personal and professional lives they do what is right and for the right reasons rather than for the wrong reasons and not what is wrong. What are some key everyday ethical challenges for which students might, and should, be prepared? It is reasonable, using the vocabulary and theoretical perspectives to which students have been introduced, that they are able to generalize from classroom-based vignettes to questions about ethics in the workplace, in their relationships with others, and in society at large. They understand the demands of moral agency (personal responsibility). As psychologically literate citizens, they understand psychology’s ethical base and health ethics more generally and, as consumers of health services, they have a clear understanding of their consumer rights and where those rights come from. In developing respect for the rights and dignity of others, they examine the ethical underpinnings of social justice and responsibility, including the ethics of social advocacy and social and cultural tolerance. They examine the precepts of intellectual and commercial honesty. They appreciate that ethics is not only about how one treats others but also how one treats oneself. They understand the philosophical basis of self-development and self-care. They are aware of legal systems and organizational policies that intersect with moral considerations. Finally, with those other considerations in mind, students are able to determine where they would “start” if the need to exercise their own, or others,’ moral rights and responsibilities arises. This set of considerations includes strategies that might be used to resolve ethical disagreements. Although there may be other suitable curriculum models for teaching ethics to psychology undergraduates, it is important that there should be a curriculum component that involves formal instruction in ethics. The literature suggests that leaving learning about ethics to chance or to vicarious experience—learning ethics by osmosis (Handelsman, 1986)—is ineffective. A clear curriculum commitment is required. However, didactic approaches to ethics instruction by themselves are not necessarily the most effective approaches for engaging students in ethical examination of their everyday lives and self-reflection about their own behavior. We now offer some suggestions for bringing ethics education “to life.”
Enhancing Ethical Literacy of Psychologically Literate Citizens
47
Methods for Enhancing Ethical Literacy If psychology undergraduates are to become meta-ethical citizens (i.e., responsible citizens who, as a starting point, consciously examine the ethics of any personal or professional situation), a traditional didactic approach to teaching ethics may not work well as a means of developing a moral framework for refÂ� lection and action. Although formal courses in interdisciplinary and medical ethical decision making (e.g., Allegretti & Frederick, 1995; Self & Olivarez, 1996; Self, Baldwin, & Wolinsky, 1992) and formal training in ethical theory (Bloch, 1988; Bruneau, 1998; Fine & Ulrich, 1988) have been shown to improve students’ ability to analyze ethical issues, our recommendation is for integrating formal instruction in ethical theory with a variety of experiential approaches that allow students to apply theories and moral precepts they have learned, practice steps in their ethical decision-making framework, and question the moral status quo. Integrative approaches may involve conventional classroom-based instruction, such as incorporating aspects of professional and research ethics into undergraduate teaching sessions (e.g., Dunn et al., 2010; Fisher & Kuther, 1997), or problembased learning approaches that take students outside of the classroom. There are already various innovative approaches to undergraduate and graduate ethics education that suit this purpose, and the latter can be generalized to the undergraduate classroom. Conventional classroom-based experiential approaches are known to be powerful instructional methods of teaching ethics. A number of these approaches have involved analysis of cases, vignettes, or examples of moral dilemmas (Chen, 2003; Fisher & Kuther, 1997; Sapp, 1995; Self, Olivarez, & Baldwin, 1998; Self, Wolinsky, & Baldwin, 1989). Others have employed various role-play methods (Haddad, 1988; Rosnow, 1999; Strohmetz & Skleder, 1999). Johnson and Corser (1998) subjected students to the experience of appearing before a mock professional complaints committee consisting of other class members. Students rotated through the roles of complaints committee member and respondent in the complaint. The mock committees ran in class for about 2 hours each week during the semester. Students rated their experiences of the mock committees and related lecture and discussion activities very highly. Plante (1998) used a uniquely extensive combination of formal instruction, video presentations of health and community critical incidents, facilitated group discussion, structured ethical decision making, and reflective journals and assessments. Formal instruction focused on culturally relative, egoistic, social contract, virtue, and deontological ethical theories, which were then compared and contrasted as the experiential components of the curriculum were introduced. Students also undertook a placement as a volunteer with a community organization and discussed ethical issues that arose in the course of their placement. At the end of the semester, students rated the course overall, group discussions, and the volunteer placement experience very highly. Smith, Fryer-Edwards, Diekema, and Braddock (2004) compared instruction involving written case analyses alone with written case analyses combined with class discussions. Medical students who had the added advantage of class discussions improved
48
T h e P s y ch o l o g i cally L i t e r at e C i t i z e n
their analysis of ethical scenarios noticeably more over the course of the semester than those students for whom class discussions were not scheduled. There is further evidence for using discursive instruction in the teaching of ethics. Molewijk, Abma, Stopler, and Widdershoven (2008) based their ethical instruction of medical students on ethical perspectives of pragmatic hermeneutics and dialogical ethics. The pragmatic hermeneutic perspective eschews fixed ethical principles and abstract reasoning, focusing instead on social and historical complexities of presenting issues and seeking resolution through careful examination of all available contextual contingencies. Dialogical perspectives seek resolution through exploring shared understandings of the issues and possible solutions. Everyday practical moral challenges become storied accounts through and by which teachers and their students interpret and understand the right course of action or about the character of the student as practitioner. These storied exchanges (moral case deliberations) may be directed toward moral cases that present themselves to students in their healthcare placements or in related extracurricular employment settings. Formulating an understanding of the perspectives of welfare professionals, family guardians, and organizational management and of relevant legal and professional issues pertaining to care, and then being able to discuss those perspectives and issues with an instructor, may better assist our respite carer above to determine the right course of action in response to future concerns about her clients’ care than simply just expecting that she will intuit the right course of action from her reading of relevant law, professional standards, and organizational policies. We believe also that our fast-food worker above and the vulnerable coworkers who have placed their faith in him would benefit from him having the opportunity to discuss with an instructor the right course of action in the circumstances, including the pros and cons of ignoring the work supervisor’s behavior. We argue that educators should not draw the line on developing our fast-food worker’s ethical literacy just because his immediate work is not psychology. Molewijk and colleagues (2008) found that both students and supervising professionals rated these moral case deliberations as essential, valuable components of the supervised placement experience, but two pedagogical issues became clear as the trial progressed. Field supervisors need to be trained to understand and apply these theoretical perspectives on ethics; and adopting a discursive stance on the actual ethical challenges confronting students on healthcare placement can be extremely demanding in terms of time, cognitive effort, and emotional preoccupation, which can lead to burnout for supervisors. This model of discursive instruction is not dissimilar from the models explored by Ewashen and Lane (2007), who cautioned health placement supervisors about the need to maintain firm boundaries around discursive encounters so that they do not assume a therapeutic role with placement students. Other mixed models of narrative encounters designed to encourage a discursive understanding of everyday ethics have been suggested. Ogur, Hirsh, Krupat, and Bor (2007) tested what they described as an integrated clerkship program for medical students. In addition to providing supervised services for medical patients, students participated in weekly case-based tutorials and received regular
Enhancing Ethical Literacy of Psychologically Literate Citizens
49
mentoring, as well as studying a social science curriculum designed to encourage self-reflection and build community awareness and cultural competence. Donohoe and Danielson (2004) suggested a healthcare training model called medical humanities, involving interdisciplinary classrooms of healthcare, literature, and other majors, with the aim being to expose healthcare majors to diverse storied accounts of health, illness, and morality (see also Andre et al., 2003). These classroom-based experiential approaches, when used separately or in combination with formal instruction, have generally resulted in improvements in students’ ethical decision-making performance. However, they have limitations. Ethics is not just a matter of determining what the right course of action in any set of circumstances is, but of doing the right thing. Students need to have practice at doing what is right and to experience the challenges of acting ethically when doing so is socially, organizationally, or professionally unpopular, or when it means confronting real practical obstacles. Our respite carer above may be encouraged not only to obtain relevant information on welfare professional standards and guardianship policies but also to discuss her concerns about her disabled clients’ care in a respectful manner with the welfare professional or family guardian. Second, classroom critical incident analysis leaves open the possibility of students learning to compartmentalize their ethical decision making. In a carefully constructed hypothetical situation the right way forward may be clear and logical. In everyday situations, however, the right way forward may be less clear and more difficult to implement. Moreover, we have already mentioned that professional codes usually apply only when one is acting professionally. Thus, there may be a tendency for students to compartmentalize behavior into that which is covered by workplace and professional codes and that which is personal and part of private life. Not only may students not be challenged to practice what they know they should do; they may not be challenged to think about the type of person they should be. Our cash-strapped student should reasonably understand that returning the wallet sans cash is as equally wrong as embellishing a work résumé, irrespective of whether or not the wallet’s owner appears well-to-do, the act goes undetected, or the rent remains unpaid. Some educators have responded to such concerns by exploring applications of classical virtue theories (e.g., in health services training). Begley (2006), for example, placed emphasis on the Aristotelian concept of moral virtue or good character. She maintained that good character is a skill that can be taught and that the measure of success is the extent to which people display their moral character through their wise judgment and actions (cf., Peterson & Seligman, 2004, on character strengths and virtues; see also McGovern, Chapter 21 in this volume). Good character is acquired by practicing virtuous conduct as well as by observing others who display excellence in character through their actions, wise judgment, and counsel. However, acquisition of good character also requires critical selfreflection, which leads to a transcendental (self-actualizing) understanding of what is good and the attainment of good character. If excellence in character comes with practice, it might be expected that undergraduates start as ethical novices but, through observation, understanding, and the practice of good, become
50
T h e P s y ch o l o g i cally L i t e r at e C i t i z e n
ethical experts (cf., Halonen et al., 2003, on development of scientific, ethical, and value-based insight in undergraduate research training). Knowledge of good character may be acquired through self-reflection on, and sharing understanding about, not only the examples teachers set for their students but also other storied accounts of virtuous conduct contained in literature, cinema, and other media. Kopelman (1999), too, argued that no instructional engagement is value-free but that instructors model excellent character through the topics they include formally in the curriculum and raise informally in class, the readings they set, the ethical vignettes they choose for analysis, and their examples of good and poor character in storied accounts of ethical conduct. Kopelman’s account of teaching the virtues emphasizes the importance of teachers reflecting on the values that underpin these aspects of their teaching as well as on how and when they overtly model good conduct for their students. There are existing precedents for Â�character education in formal schooling (Prestwich, 2004).
Implications for Undergraduate Learning and Teaching Ethically literate citizens have knowledge of moral theory and terminology; understand and apply models of ethical decision making; comprehend contextual complexities in which moral, legal, organizational, and other factors influence how they might respond; demonstrate the ability to apply their knowledge and decision-making capabilities in everyday situations; demonstrate an intellectual commitment to moral issues such as respect for people’s rights, social justice, and inclusivity; and behave morally when the situation requires them to act. Ethics instruction should include a formal introduction to moral theory followed by, and/or integrated with, a variety of experiential and storied learning opportunities that allow students to practice sound ethical reasoning and good character. However, there are some impediments to this aspirational model of ethics education in the undergraduate psychology curriculum. Space needs to be found in the syllabus for classes on moral theory. Lipp and colleagues (2006) reported on curriculum overcrowding in Australian undergraduate psychology education and on a lack of commitment among Australian psychology educators to the teaching of ethics. Introducing instruction in moral theory may require compromise on what is compulsory in the undergraduate syllabus (Donohoe & Danielson, 2004). Second, our aspirational model depends on educators who have sufficient grounding in moral philosophy to be able to teach it, a commitment to raising students’ awareness of morally significant issues, and the knowledge and confidence required for them to be role models for students (Davidson, Garton, & Joyce, 2003). Educators should also be confident about sharing stories that contain instances of both morally good and morally questionable conduct. Intensive engagement with students through storied exchanges on ethical issues may tax educators who teach this aspect of the syllabus and may have resource implications (Molewijk et al., 2008).
Enhancing Ethical Literacy of Psychologically Literate Citizens
51
Finally, to be of good character or, alternatively, to decipher and do the right thing, students need to be able to “practice” being ethical (Begley, 2006) and share stories about the decisions they make, the reasons for their decisions, and how decisions are translated into action (Molewijk et al., 2008). They require opportunities to transfer their classroom knowledge to other everyday situations that challenge them ethically. These experiences seemingly are easier to incorporate into postgraduate professional training than into undergraduate programs. MoreÂ� over, we suggest that interpretation and application of the scientist-practitioner training model in Australian psychology education, as well as unduly conservative concerns about breaching registration (licensing) legislation, has actively discouraged undergraduate psychology programs from including some form of work experience. The integration of undergraduate classroom and experiential learning opportunities resembles recent initiatives that have been labeled work-integrated learning (WIL), but such initiatives have had limited uptake. There is a need to expand WIL initiatives in innovative ways to provide psychology undergraduates with an opportunity to gain experience of the ethical challenges that workplaces generate before, and not after, they graduate. Various forms of workplace experience could be incorporated into capstone courses for all undergraduate psychology majors. Psychology is capable of producing ethically literate baccalaureates, but syllabi, educators’ professional development, instructional approaches, and workplace oppÂ� ortunities need to change for this to become the norm rather than the exception.
Suggested Curriculum Activities Keeping in mind the range of relevant interactive and dialectical instructional strategies outlined briefly above, as well as the importance of contextualizing ethical action in real-world work and personal situations, we now offer several classroom activities for enhancing ethical literacy. • Students study the novel Sophie’s World (Gaarder, 1995). Class discussion and written assessment focus on students’ overview of the origins of moral philosophy, how they would describe their own philosophical leaning, and the novel’s message. • Students observe a peaceful, social demonstration. Through class discussion and written assessment, students reflect on the issues of social concern, related moral perspectives, and the act of demonstration. Students discuss whether psychological knowledge should influence social policy and which types of social action are ethically justifiable. They consider social causes to which they may have a moral commitment. • Students undertake some form of unsupervised work placement or volunteer work and keep a reflective journal on the ethical issues with which they were confronted.
52
T h e P s y ch o l o g i cally L i t e r at e C i t i z e n
• Students keep a file of contemporary social and environmental issues in the media and, through class discussion and written assessment, reflect on the moral dimensions of those issues. • Students watch a movie such as Road to Guantanamo and, in class, debate the moral rightness of treating innocent people unjustly (i.e., as collateral damage) in order to safeguard the freedom, safety, security, or quality of life of the majority. Students learn about and discuss the concept of “just war.” • Students explore examples of ethically problematical research in which individuals’ rights have been infringed allegedly for the benefits of society at large. • Students study a publicly well-documented, high-profile case involving breaches of professional ethics. Such cases may relate to a breach of health, business, or other professional systems of ethics. Students analyze the case from a variety of theoretical perspectives (e.g., deontological, ideal utilitarian, virtue) as well as from the ethical perspective of the professional group in question. Students reflect, where possible, on the moral questions raised in public coverage of the case. Finally, students reflect on, and discuss, what they might have done if they (or a close colleague, friend, or relative) were the professional practitioner in question or an aggrieved party. • Students search the Web, Yellow Pages, or print media for what may be morally questionable public statements, articles, or advertisements about products and services. Students analyze those statements from a variety of theoretical perspectives, as well as from the ethical perspective of the group or industry in question and fair trading legislation. Finally, students reflect on, and discuss, what may constitute a morally defensible course of action if a person is aggrieved by one or more of these statements.
References Allegretti, C. L., & Frederick, J. N. (1995). A model for thinking critically about ethical issues. Teaching of Psychology, 22, 46–48. American Psychological Association. (2002). Ethical principles of psychologists and code of conduct. American Psychologist, 57, 1060–1073. American Psychological Association. (2007). APA guidelines for the undergraduate psychology major. Washington, D. C.: Author. Amsel, E., & Kay, T. S. (2006). The growth of methodological and ethical reasoning among psychology students. Paper presented at the Rocky Mountain Psychological Association Annual Meeting, Park City, Utah, April 20–22, 2006. Downloaded from PsycInfo on 06/04/2010, Unique Identifier 576822006–001. Andre, J., Brody, H., Fleck, L., Thomason, C. L., & Tomlinson, T. (2003). Ethics, professionalism, and humanities at Michigan State University College of Human Medicine. Academic Medicine, 78, 968–972.
Enhancing Ethical Literacy of Psychologically Literate Citizens
53
Australian Psychological Society. (2007). Code of ethics. Melbourne, VIC: Author. Australian Psychology Accreditation Council. (2009). Rules for accreditation and accreditation standards for psychology courses. Melbourne, VIC: Author. Begley, A. M. (2006). Facilitating the development of moral insight in practice: teaching ethics and teaching virtue. Nursing Philosophy, 7, 257–265. Bloch, S. (1988). Teaching psychiatric ethics. Medical Education, 22, 550–553. Bruneau, S. (1998). Adding PEP (protocol, ethics, and policies) to the preparation of new professionals. Ethics and Behavior, 8, 249–267. Chen, D. T. (2003). Curricular approaches to research ethics training for psychiatric investigators. Psychopharmacology, 171, 112–119. Davidson, G. R. (2006). Toward an ethical framework for psychological practice. In S. A. Morrissey & P. Reddy (Eds.), Ethics and professional practice for psychologists (pp. 1–13). Melbourne, VIC: Thomson. Davidson, G. R., Garton, A. F., & Joyce, M. (2003). Survey of ethics education in Australian university schools and departments of psychology. Australian Psychologist, 38, 216–222. Donohoe, M., & Danielson, S. (2004). A community-based approach to the medical humanities. Medical Education, 38, 204–217. Dunn, D. S., Brewer, C. L., Cautin, R. L., Gurung, R. A. R., Keith, K. D., McGregor, L. N., Nida, S. A., Puccio, P., & Voight, M. J. (2010). The undergraduate psychology Â�curriculum: call for a core. In D. F. Halpern (Ed.), Undergraduate education in Â�psychology: a blueprint for the future of the discipline (pp. 47–61). Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. Ewashen, C., & Lane, A. (2007). Pedagogy, power and practice ethics: clinical teaching in psychiatric/mental health settings. Nursing Inquiry, 14, 255–262. Fine, M. A., & Ulrich, L. P. (1988). Integrating psychology and philosophy in teaching a graduate course in ethics. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 19, 542–546. Fisher, C. B., & Kuther, T. L. (1997). Integrating research ethics into the introductory psychology course curriculum. Teaching of Psychology, 24, 172–175. Gaarder, J. (1995). Sophie’s world: a novel about the history of philosophy. London, UK: Phoenix House. Haddad, A. M. (1988). Teaching ethical analysis in occupational therapy. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 42, 300–304. Halonen, J. S., Bosack, T., Clay, S., & McCarthy, M. (with Dunn, D. S., Hill IV, G. W., McEntarfer, R., Mehrotra, C., Nesmith, R., Weaver, K., & Whitlock, K.). (2003). A rubric for authentically learning, teaching, and assessing scientific reasoning in psychology. Teaching of Psychology, 30, 196–208. Handelsman, M. M. (1986). Problems with ethics training by “osmosis.” Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 17, 371–372. Johnson, W. B., & Corser, R. (1998). Learning ethics the hard way: facing the ethics committee. Teaching of Psychology, 25, 26–28. Kopelman, L. M. (1999). Values and virtues: how should they be taught? Academic Medicine, 74, 1307–1310. Lipp, O. et al. (2006). Learning outcomes and curriculum development in psychology. Chippendale, NSW: Carrick Institute. http://www.carrickinstitute.edu.au/carrick/ webdav/site/carricksite/users/siteadmin/public/grants_2005project_learningoutcomes_psychology_finalreport.pdf (downloaded 7 January, 2008).
54
T h e P s y ch o l o g i cally L i t e r at e C i t i z e n
McGovern, T. V., Corey, L., Cranney, J., Dixon, W. E., Holmes J. D., Kuebli, J. E., et al. (2010). Psychologically literate citizens. In D. F. Halpern (Ed.), Undergraduate education in psychology: a blueprint for the future of the discipline (pp. 9–27). Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. Miner, M. (2006). A proposed comprehensive model for ethical decision-making. In S. A. Morrissey & P. Reddy (Eds.), Ethics and professional practice for psychologists (pp. 25–37). Melbourne, VIC: Thomson. Molewijk, A. C., Abma, T., Stolper, M., & Widdershoven, G. (2008). Teaching ethics in the clinic: the theory and practice of moral case deliberation. Journal of Medical Ethics, 34, 120–124. Morrissey, S. A., & Symons, M. (2006). Teaching ethics for professional psychological practice. In S. A. Morrissey & P. Reddy (Eds.), Ethics and professional practice for psychologists (pp. 113–125). Melbourne, VIC: Thomson. National Health and Medical Research Council. (2007). National statement on ethical conduct in human research. Canberra, Australia: Author. Ogur, B., Hirsh, D., Krupat, E., & Bor, D. (2007). The Harvard Medical School–Cambridge integrated clerkship: an innovative model of clinical education. Academic Medicine, 82, 397–404. Peterson, C., & Seligman, M. E. P. (2004). Character strengths and virtues: a handbook and classification. New York: Oxford University Press; Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. Plante, T. G. (1998). Teaching a course on psychology ethics to undergraduates. Teaching of Psychology, 25, 286–287. Prestwich, D. L. (2004). Character education in America’s schools. School Community Journal, 14, 139–150. Rosnow, R. L. (1999). Teaching research ethics through role-play and discussion. In M. E. Ware & C. L. Brewer (Eds.), Handbook for teaching statistics and research methods (2nd ed., pp. 137–139). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Ross, W. D. (1930). The right and the good. Oxford: The Clarendon Press. Ross, W. D. (1939). Foundations of ethics. Oxford: The Clarendon Press. Sapp, M. (1995). Teaching ethics to mental health practica students at the master’s level: a comparative study. College Student Journal, 29, 333–339. Self, D. J., Baldwin, D. C. Jr., & Wolinsky, P. O. (1992). Evaluation of teaching medical ethics by an assessment of moral reasoning. Medical Education, 26, 178–184. Self, D. J., & Olivarez, M. (1996). Retention of moral reasoning skills over the four years of medical education. Teaching and Learning in Medicine, 8, 195–199. Self, D. J., Olivarez, M., & Baldwin, D. C. Jr. (1998). The amount of small-group casestudy discussion needed to improve moral reasoning skills of medical students. Academic Medicine, 73, 521–523. Self, D. J., & Olivarez, M. (1996). Retention of moral reasoning skills over the four years of medical education. Teaching and Learning in Medicine, 8, 195–199. Self, D. J., Walinsky, F. D., & Baldwin, DeW. C. Jr. (1989). The effect of teaching medical ethics on medical students’ moral reasoning. Academic Medicine, 64, 755–759. Smith, S., Fryer-Edwards, K., Diekema, D. S., & Braddock, C. H. III. (2004). Finding effective strategies for teaching ethics: a comparison trial of two interventions. Academic Medicine, 79, 265–271.
Enhancing Ethical Literacy of Psychologically Literate Citizens
55
Strohmetz, D. B., & Skleder, A. A. (1999). The use of role-play in teaching research ethics: a validation study. In M. E. Ware & C. L. Brewer (Eds.), Handbook for teaching statistics and research methods. (2nd ed., pp. 140–142). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Sullivan, K. (2005). Finding out about ethics: what sources of information do Australian psychologists find useful? Australian Psychologist, 40, 187–189.
5 The Social Psychology of Intergroup Harmony and the Education of Psychologically Literate Citizens Fiona A. White
Critical Overview
I
f the concept of a psychologically literate citizen refers to students respecting diversity and using their knowledge in ethically and socially responsible ways to directly benefit their communities (McGovern et al., 2010), then students who respond in non-prejudiced or socially inclusive ways can be considered highly literate global citizens. The psychological concepts of prejudice, intergroup bias, social inclusiveness and intergroup harmony fall within the discipline of social psychology, a core area studied in most psychology majors (e.g., Dunn et al., 2010). The challenge for social psychology educators is to effectively guide their undergraduate students to think and act in socially inclusive ways toward all racial and ethnic groups—whether it is their ethnic ingroup or “us,” the group to which they belong, OR the ethnic outgroup or “them,” the group to which they do not belong. The terms ingroup and outgroup will be used throughout this chapter and were made salient by Tajfel and Turner’s (1979) Social Identity Theory (SIT). SIT describes how people automatically classify themselves and others into groups according to sex, race, religion, or virtually any category to which they might belong, and people’s social identification to their (ethnic or religious) ingroup can provide them with a positive sense of self or self-esteem. The societal problem of intergroup bias and prejudice results when these automatic categorizations are associated with negative evaluations and actions toward outgroups. Importantly, this chapter will examine various strategies that social psychology educators can use in their teaching to effectively encourage socially inclusive thinking and behavior among their undergraduate students. In doing so, the primary goal of creating psychologically literate citizens will be one step closer to being achieved.
The Social Psychology of Intergroup Harmony
57
Current Trends to Reduce Racial Prejudice and Improve Intergroup Harmony Cooperative Contact: Direct, Extended, and Imagined Although several countries, such as Canada, the United States, and Australia, have espoused and supported multiculturalism, racial prejudice remains a societal problem. The prolongation of prejudice may be related to people’s perceptions of multiculturalism policy. Research shows that the majority of people still perceive multiculturalism as a passive policy where cultural diversity is tolerated, rather than an active policy where cultural diversity and integration between different ethnic groups is actually encouraged (Ginges & Cairns, 2000). The concept of prejudice has a long history in social psychology. One of the first definitions of prejudice was by Gordon Allport: “An antipathy based upon a faulty and inflexible generalization. It may be felt or expressed. It may be directed toward a group as a whole, or toward an individual because he [sic] is a member of that group” (1954, p. 9). Since Allport’s seminal work, there have been thousands of research publications outlining the causes of prejudice and the conditions that can reduce its deleterious effects. Policies, interventions, and education programs that passively impart cultural/ religious outgroup knowledge alone have been shown to have only short-term effects on reducing prejudice (Hill & Augoustinos, 2001; Pettigrew, Christ, Wagner, & Stellmacher, 2007). Educators need to actively involve undergraduate psychology students in teaching and research activities rather than passively measuring their outgroup attitudes. Similarly, simply defining psychological literacy and describing its merits to students is not sufficient; educators must directly provide their students with the appropriate skills to be active global citizens beyond the classroom. A plethora of social psychological research has repeatedly revealed the theoretical and practical merits of intergroup contact for reducing prejudice. For example, Pettigrew and Tropp’s (2006) meta-analysis of 696 samples conclusively revealed that greater intergroup contact is associated with lower levels of prejudice (mean r = –.22). Altogether, 94% of the samples in their analyses showed an inverse relationship between intergroup contact and prejudice. At the core of many of these successful intervention strategies to reduce prejudice is the concept of cooperative contact, an idea first formulated by Allport in his Contact Hypothesis. In fact, much of this research has included, to varying levels, Allport’s (1954) four facilitating conditions on how contact can reduce prejudice: (1) equal status of all of the groups, (2) intergroup cooperation, (3) common goals, and (4) support from an authority. One popular interpretation for this robust inverse relationship is that cooperative contact reduces the salience of the original ingroup–outgroup (ethnic) category and negative intergroup schema, which in turn improves the positive nature of the group interaction. Most noticeably, Pettigrew and Tropp (2006) concluded that not only did attitudes toward immediate
58
T he P s y cho l ogica l ly Literate C iti z e n
participants become more favorable, but so did attitudes toward the entire outgroup, outgroup members in other situations, and even outgroups not involved in the contact situation. Importantly, these findings all bode well for results to generalize beyond the classroom to ethnic outgroups that psychology undergraduate students come in contact with. Complementary explanations have been proposed in an attempt to understand the mechanisms underlying this robust effect. For instance, Dovidio, Kawakami, and Gaertner (2000) propose that the functional relations between groups change from actual competition to cooperation when racially diverse small groups participate in joint activities to achieve a common or superordinate goal. In addition, Fiske (2000) conducted a series of experiments demonstrating that the social interdependence that is inherent in cooperative interactions toward common goals is what gives contact situations their power to reduce prejudice. While the relationship between direct outgroup contact and prejudice has been widely tested, recent research studies (Cameron, Rutland, & Brown, 2007; Paolini, Hewstone, Cairns, & Voci, 2004; Turner, Hewstone, & Voci, 2007) have begun to examine indirect or extended contact. One of the original research studies on extended contact was conducted by Wright, Aron, McLaughlin-Volpe, and Ropp (1997), who showed that having ingroup friends who have outgroup friends was related to reduced levels of outgroup prejudice. Alternatively, Cameron and coworkers (2007) tested extended contact by having children read stories featuring ingroup and outgroup children in a friendship context. Other innovative ways to operationalize extended contact include White and Abu-Rayya’s (2009) Web technology or Internet approach. Here, over a 10-session program, two pairs of students from different religious backgrounds used a synchronous Internet chat tool to interact with one another without ever meeting face to face. The two pairs of students formed one group or team and the group goal was to use the online interaction time to develop an environmental solution that would benefit their country, Australia. This technologically innovative form of the extended contact paradigm is an efficient option for psychology educators, especially when it is difficult to get two segregated ethnic/religious student groups to directly interact because they are attending ethnically homogenous schools, colleges, or universities. An even more simple, resource-efficient classroom paradigm, and one of the newest intergroup contact paradigms at the moment, is imagined contact. Imagined contact involves no physical contact between the groups at hand, and is the “mental simulation of a social interaction with a member or members of an outgroup category” (Crisp & Turner, 2009, p. 34). For instance, in the experimental imagined contact condition, students should receive task instructions such as: “We would like you to spend the next 2 minutes imagining yourself meeting a Group X stranger for the first time. Imagine that during this encounter you find out some interesting and unexpected things about this person. List the interesting and unexpected things you learnt about this person.”
The Social Psychology of Intergroup Harmony
59
The reliance solely on student imagination of the contact situation makes it a particularly attractive paradigm for psychology educators to use in their classroom to improve intergroup harmony and develop psychological citizenship among their students. The imagined intergroup contact paradigm serves not only as a novel research paradigm in which the mechanisms underlying actual contact can be explored, but also offers an alternative educational intervention strategy to be used when physical contact is restricted or impractical. There has been strong empirical support for the imagined intergroup contact paradigm. For example, Turner, Crisp, and Lambert (2007) found that simply imagining contact with an elderly man or a gay man led to more positive evaluations of them. Turner and Crisp (2010), too, observed similar positive effects on a measure of implicit attitudes toward elderly and Muslim outgroups. Stathi and Crisp (2008) found that imagining a positive contact with an individual outgroup member led to greater projection of positive traits to the outgroup as a whole, whereas Husnu and Crisp (2010) found that Turkish Cypriot students who imagined contact with Greek Cypriots reported greater intentions toward future contact compared to those students in the no-contact control condition. In all of these studies it is not enough to have students just think about the outgroup, as this may exacerbate negative stereotypes; rather, it is the unique mental simulation of a positive contact situation that improves intergroup attitudes (Husnu & Crisp, 2010). According to Crisp and Turner (2009), the real value of imagined contact may be as an important facilitating component of an envisaged and integrated intervention package. Therefore, it may be a useful first-stage intervention tool, where at a later stage extended Internet contact or direct contact can occur— what Crisp and Turner (2009, p. 238) refer to as a “continuum of contact interventions.” The extent of the multi-method approach will depend on the amount and type of resources available to social psychology educators.
Recategorization Toward a Dual Identity A second avenue of research found to improve intergroup harmony involves a dual identity framework and has the potential to effectively complement the strategy of cooperative contact. A dual identity framework requires individuals to simultaneously maintain their ingroup identity (e.g., Catholic) as well as a common group identity (e.g., Irish) shared by the outgroup (e.g., “Protestant”). Researchers propose that recategorization in terms of a dual identity representation (e.g., “Catholic Irish” or “Protestant Irish”) reduces intergroup biases and increases intergroup harmony by extending the benefits of ingroup favoritism to former outgroup members who are now included members of the created common ingroup (e.g., “Irish”). The implementation of a dual identity frameÂ� work is particularly beneficial in multicultural societies where ethnic and religious identities are fundamental aspects of individuals’ self-concepts and are
60
T he P s y cho l ogica l ly Literate C iti z e n
unlikely to be readily abandoned. Also, attempts to produce a single group identity at the expense of one’s ethnic identity may threaten ingroup belonging and thus exacerbate outgroup prejudice (Dovidio et al., 2000). In fact, Dovidio and colleagues (2000) found that students who described themselves as both American and members of their Asian ethnic group (e.g., Asian American) had less prejudice than those who described themselves in terms of a single identity (e.g., Asian or American). Importantly, the development of a dual identity, in which the original and superordinate group membership are simultaneously salient, has been found to be beneficial for both minority and majority members. For example, research has found that minority members who adopt a dual identity style of thinking report more positive attitudes towards majority members (Gonzalez & Brown, 2006), and majority members report more positive attitudes towards minority members (Guerra, Rebelo, Monteiro, Riek, Mania, Gaertner, & Dovidio, 2010). Taking all of this into account, social psychology educators need to develop educational programs that encourage their undergraduate students to actively adopt a combination of cooperative contact and dual identity practices, or coop erative dual identity practices, to improve intergroup harmony both within and beyond the classroom.
Relationship Between Intergroup Harmony and Psychological Literacy in Undergraduate Students The cooperative dual identity research reviewed in this chapter would readily transfer to tertiary educational classroom settings. The techniques to promote intergroup harmony among our undergraduate students have the potential to be integrated into social psychology curricula that aim to increase tolerance and social inclusiveness thinking and behavior, a key aspect of psychological literacy. Traditional tertiary curricula often require passive involvement of undergraduate psychology students via lectures and/or classroom discussions of the theories and problems of prejudice or racism. In contrast, the cooperative dual identity interventions highlighted in this chapter create an active involvement of our undergraduate students that triggers cognitive and affective processes involved in intergroup contact. As children approach adolescence their attitudes about racial groups become more coherent, complex, and intense (White, Hayes, & Livesey, 2010). With increasing cognitive flexibility and widening socialization experiences compared to early adolescents (Katz & Ksansnak, 1994), late adolescence is an obvious developmental stage to continue to foster positive intergroup attitudes. In addition, university students entering the developmental period of late adolescence are most likely to include the next generation of social policymakers (White, Wooten et al., 2009)—therefore the greater their social inclusiveness education, the better. Taking this sociocognitive developmental context into account, undergraduate psychology students or late adolescents are prime candidates for
The Social Psychology of Intergroup Harmony
61
intergroup harmony interventions such as the cooperative dual identity practices reviewed here. The empirical literature indicates that cooperative dual identity practices can be easily integrated into undergraduate curricula and fostered in classrooms to increase intergroup harmony and thus psychological literacy in our underÂ�graduate psychology students. This educational goal can be achieved if social psychology educators can bridge the gap between conceptual representations of cooperative contact and how it is actually experienced in everyday life. Systems of segregation continue to pervade everyday life where having ingroup friends who have outgroup friends is less realistic—for example, when students attend a predominantly white college. Consequently, new and different educational methods for operationalizing direct, extended, or imagined contact among our students need to be formulated and tested. Extended contact via the Internet bypasses the formal systems of segregation. A further advantage of examining extended contact is the consistent research finding that intergroup anxiety is lower under circumstances of extended contact than during direct contact (Paolini et al., 2004). Previous frameworks have failed to incorporate the social strengths of cooperative contact and the cognitive advantages of dual identity recategorization to enhance interethnic harmony. This new integrated framework directly addresses this limitation. Recategorization in the form of dual identity provides cooperative contact situations with the cognitive mechanism needed to achieve the superorÂ� dinate or common goal—the main driver behind prejudice reduction and the promotion of intergroup harmony. The dual identity recategorization strategy would involve encouraging ethnically or religiously diverse students to think of ways in which their ethnic/religious identities can actively contribute to achieving a common goal, something that can be attained only if both ethnic/religious groups cooperate. For example, White and Abu-Rayya (2009) implemented a dual identity recategorization where high school students retained either their “Muslim” or “Catholic” identity as well as an “environmentally sustainable Australian” identity, their common identity. Allowing diversity with commonality is an essential element of any framework attempting to promote positive intergroup relations (Pedersen, Walker, & Wise, 2005). A common goal, a condition of cooperative contact, is more likely to be achieved with the recategorization of a common identity (while retaining one’s ethnic/religious identity). The integrated cooperative dual identity framework allows for a successful refashioning of a common national identity of creating an environmentally sustainable future for the country that all students call their home. A reinvigorated sense of social inclusion via a cooperative dual identity framework can begin to refashion this common national identity and restore the values of intergroup trust, respect, harmony, and citizenship. With the acquisition of these values our undergraduate students can then be truly considered psychologically literate citizens. The next section will highlight how social psychology educators can integrate this cooperative dual identity framework into the classroom to guide the development of intergroup harmony, and therefore psychologically literate citizenship, in their undergraduate students.
62
T he P s y cho l ogica l ly Literate C iti z e n
The Relationship Between Intergroup Harmony and the Psychologically Literate Global Citizen According to the Victoria International Development Education Association (n.d), a global citizen is anyone who works to make society a better place. This chapter has highlighted how global citizenship can be fostered in the social psychology classroom if educators target cooperative dual identity practices to enhance intergroup harmony among their students. It is important to recognize that beyond the classroom these students are likely to be our community leaders of the future. Creating students who are psychologically literate global citizens can be achieved by (1) ensuring that lecture content explains the importance of identifying and targeting the causes of prejudiced attitudes and discrimi� natory behavior to reduce their deleterious effects, and (2) actively involving undergraduate students in research projects to equip them with the thinking, behavior, and practical research skills needed to refashion prejudiced attitudes toward outgroups to more socially inclusive attitudes. Today, prejudice and intergroup conflict continues to thrive outside the social psychology classroom. This fact suggests that there is still much to accomplish for social psychology educators and their undergraduate students, as future global citizens, to make society a better place. Several steps can be taken toward achieving global citizenship: (1) ensuring that undergraduate students are equipped with sufficient knowledge to be able to recognize prejudice outside the classroom, but more importantly encouraging them to have the courage of their convictions to practice the principles of intergroup harmony among their friends and family when they hear or see prejudice; (2) encouraging undergraduate students to actively choose to socialize and work with people from diverse ethnic and religious backgrounds; and (3) encouraging undergraduate students to actively communicate and share their knowledge about intergroup harmony principles, social inclusion, and cooperative contact with friends and family who may not have had similar tertiary educational opportunities. Therefore, the key to becoming a global citizen involves students not only being equipped with the knowledge and skills to promote intergroup harmony, but also having the courage of their convictions to actually practice these principles at every opportunity that requires it.
Intergroup Harmony Resources Promoting Development of Psychological Literacy in Undergraduate Psychology Courses This resource can be used in either second- or third-year Social Psychology practical/tutorial class. It takes approximately 40 minutes to complete over two
The Social Psychology of Intergroup Harmony
63
class sessions, and was designed by this chapter’s author. The resource actively involves undergraduate students in an imagined contact dual identity task. The dual identity aspect asks students to hold simultaneously salient (a) their original ingroup membership and (b) their superordinate group membership (the social psychology student) with the imagined stranger. The overall aim of this resource is to promote intergroup harmony, an important aspect of the psychologically literate global citizen. By the end of this practical intergroup harmony exercise, students will have acquired the following graduate attributes and related student learning outcomes that constitute psychological literacy (see McGovern et al., 2010): 1. Knowledge and understanding of theoretical and empirical evidence relating to imagined cooperative contact and dual identity, factors that promote intergroup harmony 2. Research methods from being actively involved in the design of a social psychology experiment, formulating hypotheses, and collecting and analyzing data 3. Critical thinking involved in evaluating the research findings and the research implications of the experiment, and completing a self-reflection exercise on how this study has the potential to make psychology students better global citizens 4. Values in psychology about enhancing intergroup harmony, respect, and trust within a culturally diverse society 5. Communication skills involved in writing up these research findings as a report and/or presenting these research findings orally to colleagues 6. Learning and application of psychology is achieved by students’ active participation in the imagined contact dual identity framework, and having them explain this paradigm to family and friends outside the classroom. Aim: Effective Strategies to Reduce Intergroup Bias Teaching Plan: Materials and Procedure Decide on an intergroup relationship (e.g., youth and the elderly; heterosexual and homosexual; ethnic majority and ethnic minority; people with and without disabilities) worthy of a research investigation. In Week 1 allocate all students in your class to a four-digit ID code that they must remember for Week 2, and ask them to complete the demographic questions (feel free to add additional questions); the Brown, Condor, Mathews, Wade, and Williams’ (1986) 10-item Ingroup Identification scale, inserting the appropriate ingroup being researched (Table 5.1); and the Intergroup Questionnaire, inserting the appropriate outgroup being researched (Table 5.2). Collect responses/questionnaires from students and enter the data into an appropriate statistical package.
Table 5.1╇ Demographic Questions ID Code: _ _ _ _ 1. What year were you born in? 2. What is your gender?  Female  Male 3.What country were you born in?___________________ Ingroup Identification Scale:
NEVER
SELDOM SOMETIMES
OFTEN
VERY OFTEN
╇ 1
I am a person who considers the Ingroup important.





╇ 2
I am a person who identifies with the Ingroup.





╇ 3
I am a person who feels strong ties with the Ingroup.





╇ 4
I am a person who is glad to belong to the Ingroup.





╇ 5
I am a person who sees myself as belonging to the Ingroup.





╇ 6
I am a person who makes excuses for belonging to the Ingroup.





╇ 7
I am a person who tries to hide belonging to the Ingroup.





╇ 8
I am a person who feels held back by the Ingroup.





╇ 9
I am a person who is annoyed to say I’m a member of the Ingroup.





10
I am a person who criticizes the Ingroup.





Note: The scores for items 6–10 are reversed to give a possible range of 10–50 for the whole scale. Higher scores reveal stronger ingroup identification.
Table 5.2╇ Intergroup Questionnaire The following set of questions concerns how you would feel mixing socially with members of the outgroup. It does not matter whether you personally have very little or no contact with members of the outgroup; we are interested in your attitude. 1. Imagine you are put in a group that is totally made up of outgroup members and you are the only ingroup member. 2. Use the following scale to explain how you would feel amongst the outgroup, compared to how you would feel within your ingroup.
NOT AT ALL
SOMEWHAT
EXTREMELY
1
I would feel HAPPY around the Outgroup.







2
I would feel AWKWARD around the Outgroup.







3
I would be SELF-CONSCIOUS around the Outgroup.







4
I would be CONFIDENT around the Outgroup.







5
I would be RELAXED around the Outgroup.







6
I would feel DEFENSIVE around the Outgroup.







7
I would feel WARM toward the Outgroup.







8
I would feel COLD toward the Outgroup.







9
I would feel NEGATIVE about the Outgroup.







Table 5.2╇ (continued)
NOT AT ALL
SOMEWHAT
EXTREMELY
10 I would feel POSITIVE about the Outgroup.







11 I would feel FRIENDLY toward the Outgroup.







12 I would feel HOSTILE toward the Outgroup.







13 I would be SUSPICIOUS of the Outgroup.







14 I would feel TRUSTING toward the Outgroup.







15 I would feel RESPECT for the Outgroup.







16 I would feel CONTEMPT for the Outgroup.







17 I would feel ADMIRATION for the Outgroup.







18 I would feel DISGUST toward the Outgroup.







Note: The scores for items 1, 4, 5, 7, 10, 11, 14, 15, and 17 are reversed to give a possible range of scores from 18–126 for the whole scale. Higher scores reveal more negative outgroup attitudes.
The Social Psychology of Intergroup Harmony
67
In Week 2 randomly allocate half the students in the classroom to the control condition and ask them to write the 4-digit ID code that was allocated to them in Week 1. Have the control condition read the following instruction: “We would like you to spend the next 2 minutes imagining an outdoor scene. Try to imagine aspects of the scene about you (e.g., is it a beach, a forest, are there trees or hills, what’s on the horizon). “Now spend 2 minutes listing the different things that you saw in the scene that you imagined.” (This instruction is designed to reinforce the effect of the imagery task.) Allocate the other half of the class to the experimental condition and ask them to write the 4-digit ID code that was allocated to them in Week 1. Have the experimental condition read the following instruction: “We would like you to spend the next 2 minutes imagining yourself meeting a person from Outgroup X, who happens to also be a social psychology student from your college/university. Imagine that during the encounter you find out some other interesting and unexpected things about this person. “Now spend 2 minutes listing the different things you learnt about the person.” (This, too, is designed to reinforce the effect of the imagery task.) Following these instructions, have all students complete the Intergroup Questionnaire for a second time (see Table 5.2), noting their 4-digit ID code on this questionnaire to ensure that their Week 2 responses can be matched to their Week 1 responses. Collect responses/questionnaires from all students and enter the data into an appropriate statistical package. Possible Ways to Analyze the Results/Findings 1. Have the teacher/student correlate the Ingroup Identification total scores with Intergroup Questionnaire total scores. According to the existing prejudice literature, the stronger one’s ingroup identification, the higher one’s negative attitudes toward the outgroup. As a consequence, one would expect to find a negative correlation between these two scores. 2. Within the Control condition calculate Week 2’s Intergroup Questionnaire mean score and then do the same for the Experimental “Imagined Cooperative Dual Identity Contact” condition. Conduct an independent samples t-test analysis to compare the Intergroup Questionnaire mean scores for each condition. According to the imagined contact literature, simply imagining a positive interaction with an outgroup member should improve one’s positive attitudes toward that outgroup. Moreover, having a common identity with that outgroup
68
T he P s y cho l ogica l ly Literate C iti z e n
member (i.e., being a social psychology student) should further increase one’s positive attitudes. Together, one would expect to find that the experimental condition has a significantly lower Intergroup Questionnaire mean score, or lower negative outgroup attitudes, than the control condition. Class Discussion Questions 1. Did you find the expected positive relationship between Week 1’s Ingroup Identification score and Intergroup Questionnaire score? Why or why not? 2. Was the expected difference between Intergroup Questionnaire mean scores for control and imagined cooperative condition found? Why or why not? 3. If you had to explain these research findings to your friends and/or family who may not have had the opportunity to study social psychology, how would you do this? 4. To what extent has this research study helped you understand how to promote intergroup harmony and social inclusiveness, and become a better global citizen?
Conclusion Intergroup harmony provides an important means by which to establish psychological literacy in our undergraduate students. This chapter has evaluated relevant theory and empirical evidence underpinning a readily transferable and robust research paradigm to promote intergroup harmony: imagined contact dual identity. This easily applied paradigm is particularly useful when actual or direct intergroup contact is impossible, as may be the case in the classroom. Moreover, this paradigm has been found to reduce the fears and negative expectations sometimes related to direct face-to-face intergroup contact, and thus can open students’ minds to the potential for successful intergroup encounters in the future (Crisp et al., 2008). Importantly, because undergraduate students are actively involved in the imagined contact dual identity paradigm, the acquisition of social inclusive thinking is also more direct, as is the acquisition of appropriate skills and values necessary for the development of psychologically literate global citizenship beyond the classroom. Finally, as psychology educators there are three important steps we can adopt to increase the likelihood that our teachings of intergroup harmony will help develop psychological literacy in our undergraduate students: 1. Ensure that our students have sufficient knowledge to be able to recognize prejudice outside the classroom, but more importantly, to
The Social Psychology of Intergroup Harmony
69
support them to have the courage of their convictions to practice the principles of intergroup harmony when they hear or see prejudice 2. Having directly learned the benefits of cooperative contact within this classroom exercise, to encourage our students to actively choose to socialize and work with people from different backgrounds outside the classroom 3. To encourage our students to actively communicate and share their knowledge on intergroup harmony, social inclusion, and cooperative contact with friends and family who may not have had the same tertiary educational opportunities. If these steps can be carried out, then we as educators can have some confidence that the message about the benefits of intergroup harmony fostering psychological literacy has become a global message.
References Allport, G. W. (1954). The nature of prejudice. Reading, MA: Addison Wesley. Brown, R., Condor, S., Mathews, A., Wade, G., & Williams, J. (1986). Explaining intergroup differentiation in an industrial organization. Journal of Occupational Psychology, 59, 273–286. Cameron, L., Rutland, A., & Brown, R. (2007). Promoting children’s positive intergroup attitudes towards stigmatised groups: extended contact and multiple classification skills training. International Journal of Behavioural Development, 31, 454–466. Crisp, R. J., Stathi, S., Turner, R. N., & Husnu, S. (2008). Imagining intergroup contact: theory, paradigm, and practice. Social and Personality Psychology Compass, 3, 1–18. Crisp, R. J., & Turner, R. N. (2009). Can imagined interactions produce positive perceptions? American Psychologist, 64, 231–240. Dovidio, J. F., Kawakami, K., & Gaertner, S. L. (2000). Reducing contemporary prejudice: combating explicit and implicit bias at the individual and intergroup level. In S. Oshkamp (Ed.), Reducing prejudice and discrimination (pp.137–163). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Dunn, D. S., Brewer, C. L., Cautin, R. L., Gurung, R. A. R., Keith, K. D., McGregor, L. N., Nida, S. A., Puccio, P., & Voight, M. J. (2010). The undergraduate psychology curriculum: call for a core. In D. F. Halpern (Ed.), Undergraduate educa tion in psychology: a blueprint for the future of the discipline (pp. 47–61). Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. Fiske, S. T. (2000). Interdependence and the reduction of prejudice. In S. Oshkamp (Ed.), Reducing prejudice and discrimination (pp.115–135). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Ginges, J., & Cairns, D. (2000). Social representations of multiculturalism: a faceted analysis. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 30, 1345–1370.
70
T he P s y cho l ogica l ly Literate C iti z e n
Gonzalez, R., & Brown, R. (2006). Dual identities in intergroup contact: group status and size moderate the generalization of positive attitude change. Journal of Experi mental Social Psychology, 42, 753–767. Guerra, R., Rebelo, M., Monteiro, M. B., Riek, B. M., Mania, E. W., Gaertner, S. L., & Dovidio, J. F. (2010). How should intergroup contact be structured to reduce bias among majority and minority children? Group Processes & Intergroup Relations, 13, 445–460. Hill, M. E., & Augoustinos, M. (2001). Stereotype change and prejudice reduction: short-and long-term evaluation of a cross-cultural awareness programme. Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology, 11, 243–262. Husnu, S., & Crisp, R. J. (2010). Imagined intergroup contact: a new technique for encouraging greater inter-ethnic contact in Cyprus. Peace and Conflict, 16, 97–108. Katz, P. A., & Ksansnak, K. R. (1994). Developmental aspects of gender role flexibility and traditionality in middle childhood and adolescence. Developmental Psychology, 30, 272–282. McGovern, T. V., Corey, L. A., Cranney, J., Dixon, Jr., W. E., Holmes, J. D., Kuebli, J. E., Ritchey, K., Smith, R. A., & Walker, S. (2010). Psychologically literate citizens. In D. Halpern (Ed.), Undergraduate education in psychology: blueprint for the discipline’s future (pp. 9–27). Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. Paolini, S., Hewstone, M., Cairns, E., & Voci, A. (2004). Effects of direct and indirect cross-group friendships on judgements of Catholics and Protestants in Northern Ireland: the mediating role of an anxiety-reduction mechanism. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 30, 770–786. Pedersen, A., Walker, I., & Wise, M. (2005). “Talk does not cook rice”: beyond anti-racism rhetoric to strategies for social action. Australian Psychologist, 40, 20–30. Pettigrew, T. F., & Tropp, L.R. (2006). A meta-analytic test of intergroup contact theory. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 90, 751–783. Pettigrew, T. F., Christ, O., Wagner, U., & Stellmacher, J. (2007). Direct and indirect intergroup contact effects on prejudice: a normative interpretation. International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 31, 41–425. Stathi, S., & Crisp, R. J. (2008). Imagining intergroup contact promotes projection to outgroups. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 44, 943–957. Tajfel, H. & Turner, J. C. (1979). An integrative theory of intergroup conflict. In: W. G. Austin & S. Worchel (Eds.), The social psychology of intergroup relations (pp.33–53). Monterey, CA: Brooks/Cole. Turner, R. N., & Crisp, R. J. (2010). Imagining intergroup contact reduces implicit preÂ� judice. British Journal of Social Psychology, 49, 129–142. Turner, R. N., Crisp, R. J., & Lambert, E. (2007). Imagining intergroup contact can improve intergroup attitudes. Group Processes and Intergroup Relations, 10, 427–441. Turner, R. N., Hewstone, M., & Voci, A. (2007). Reducing explicit and implicit outgroup prejudice via direct and extended contact: the mediating role of self-disclosure and intergroup anxiety. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 93, 369–388. Victoria International Development Education Association (n.d.). What is a global citizen? Retrieved Sept. 6, 2009, from http://www.videa.ca/global/citizen.html. White, F. A., & Abu-Rayya, H. (2009). Cooperative dual identity: A new approach to promote ethnic harmony between Muslim and non-Muslim Australians. Australian Research Council Discovery Project Grant.
The Social Psychology of Intergroup Harmony
71
White, F. A., Hayes, B., & Livesey, D. (2010). Developmental psychology: from Infancy to adulthood (2nd ed.). Sydney: Pearson Education Australia. White, F. A., Wooten, B., Man, J., Diaz, H., Rasiah, J., Swift, E., & Wilkinson, A. (2009). Adolescent racial prejudice development: the role of friendship quality and interracial contact. International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 33, 524–534. Wright, S. C., Aron, A., McLaughlin-Volpe, T., & Roppe, S. A. (1997). The extended contact effect. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 73, 73–90.
6 Changing the Lens Indigenous Perspectives on Psychological Literacy Pat D u d g e o n, Daw n Da r l a s to n - J o n e s, and Yvonne Clark
A
n essential type of psychological literacy that is required in all psychology courses is an understanding of and ability to work with the many cultural groups that make up a given society. This understanding and competence should include principles of social justice and how social injustice develops and is maintained. Social justice is about developing societies that are based on principles of equality and that value the human rights and dignity of all peoples, irrespective of their cultural background. This is particularly pertinent for Indigenous peoples who continue to struggle for basic human rights. Social justice is a key value in community psychology (Dalton, Elias, & Wandesman, 2007; Fox, 2000; Nelson & Prilleltensky, 2010; Prilleltensky & Nelson, 2002); however, we argue that its importance and necessity transcend subdisciplinary boundaries and should be a foundation to all psychology education. Proponents of critical psychology argue that psychology can no longer delude itself that it is a value-neutral endeavor (Prilleltensky & Fox, 1997). Psychology as a profession is part of a society that is shaped and directed by the values, norms, and biases that characterize a cultural and temporal location in history. Similarly, psychology practitioners and scientists operate within a spatial and temporal zone (not in a vacuum), and these practitioners and scientists are not immune from the socialization processes that construct the identities of the individuals that make up society (Prilleltensky & Fox, 1997). In this chapter we provide an overview of developments in Indigenous Australian1 studies in the psychology curriculum. The Indigenous Australian population is made up of two different cultural groups: mainland Aboriginal 1. In Australia there are many Indigenous nations, languages, and cultures, and it is difficult to identify terminology that is appropriate and acceptable to all these groups. However, the preferred term for Indigenous Australian people is “Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander.” The authors use different terms according to the context in which they are situated.
Changing the Lens
73
people (90%) and Torres Strait Islander people (10%). Currently the population is over 500,000 Indigenous people, representing 2.5% of the total Australian population. There is great diversity within the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander population. Australian Aboriginal culture is one of the oldest continuous cultures on earth. The history of Indigenous peoples in Australia, like that of other colonized peoples, is a bleak one involving dispossession of lands, warfare, and genocide and subsequent removal into reserves and missions (Dudgeon et al., 2010). Various policies were enacted in all states that stripped Aboriginal people of basic civil rights. These laws were not repealed until a historic referendum in 1967. Although progress has been made in Indigenous affairs, the consequence of a history of colonization has meant that Indigenous people face profound health and social inequalities. Racism continues to be a major issue for Indigenous Australians (Dudgeon et al., 2010). This situation is not unique but is one shared across the globe, particularly in settler countries where oppressed peoples are have been engaged in a struggle for equality and cultural rights (Smith, 1999). Providing opportunities for cultural understanding is a key part of achieving psychological literacy so that the institutions of society can work towards including disadvantaged and marginalized groups such as Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples. Until recently this aspect has been neglected in Australian psychological undergraduate and graduate courses, and until recently Australian psychology has not equipped students to address Indigenous disadvantage or to provide services that are meaningful for Indigenous people. In addition, Australian psychology has not attracted and retained Indigenous students. Although this chapter focuses upon the Indigenous Australian context, we propose that a psychologically literate citizen anywhere is one who is culturally competent. Cultural competence requires that individuals and organizations “have a defined set of values and principles, and demonstrate behaviours, attitudes, policies and structures that enable them to work effectively cross-culturally” and further, that it is “a developmental process that evolves over an extended period. Both individuals and organizations are at various levels of awareness, knowledge and skills along the cultural competence continuum” (Cross et al., 1989, cited in NCCC, 2006, p. 1). This perspective translates into a need for a philosophical shift whereby cultural competence becomes the lens through which other content and learning is viewed, and while all university courses should include cultural competence in this manner, it is particularly pertinent for psychology. To develop genuine psychological literacy within the context of the rich narrative currently being composed in global higher education about psychologists’ social responsibilities and commitments (McGovern et al., 2010), the discipline needs to continue to move strongly towards acknowledging that we are part of a social history, and what we do as individuals and professionals has an impact on our society now and in the future. We need to acknowledge our cultural backgrounds and histories and develop a critical awareness of ourselves as individuals, as a profession, and as a discipline. Indigenous researchers have highlighted
74
T he P s y ch o l o gically L iterate C iti z en
the need for Australian psychology to recognize Australian Indigenous cultural difference, and to be culturally aware. For instance, Dudgeon and Pickett (2000) wrote: Psychologists need to seek out culturally appropriate practice in interactions with those from different cultural backgrounds—not only Indigenous people, but all the cultural groups that make up the multicultural society—so that the practitioner’s own conditioned values, assumptions, and perspectives of social reality are not imposed on others. (p. 86) Since then, considerable changes have taken place in psychology, yet more needs to occur. The recent Overcoming Indigenous Disadvantage Report (SCRGSP, 2009) identified ongoing Indigenous disadvantage in areas such as health, mental health, housing, employment, education, and the justice system, and cannot be addressed until there is an understanding that service provision within the prevailing discourses does little to enhance understanding of why this disadvantage remains. A major shift in the knowledge base of the professions and the wider community is needed so that those with the power to effect change do so. Undergraduate and graduate students are still being taught within the dominant knowledge constructions and subsequently graduate without an understanding or awareness of their lack of cultural competence. This problem in turn is an important factor in the lack of appropriate services being offered to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples and contributes in no small way to the cycles of disadvantage experienced by individuals and communities. Addressing this deficit in the training of psychology students through the advancement of cultural competence is one mechanism that has the potential to shift the balance and contribute to a socially responsive society predicated on the principles of social justice and human rights.
Indigenous Australians As mentioned, developing psychological literacy in terms of cultural awareness and competence needs to be a fundamental part of training in the discipline. However, the historical exclusion of groups on the basis of ethnicity, gender, or class makes this a social justice position that can be generalized across all marginalized groups. The national Overcoming Indigenous Disadvantage Report (SCRGSP, 2005-2009) shows that Indigenous people are the most disadvantaged group in Australia. IndigÂ�enous disadvantage is evident across all key indicators. The National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Survey: Australia, 2004–05 (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2006) shows that Indigenous people report high to very high rates of psychological distress, up to twice that of other Australians. Relationships between social determinants and health and psychological distress are well documented (Kelly, Dudgeon, Gee, & Glaskin, 2010).
Changing the Lens
75
With regard to physical and mental health, the life expectancy of Indigenous people is 10 years less than that for other Australians, and Indigenous death rates across all age groups are higher. Suicide and self-harm rates are almost twice those of non-Indigenous Australians. Indigenous people, both men and women, are over four times more likely to be hospitalized for alcohol-related mental and behavioral disorders than others. In law and justice, both men and women experience higher victimization rates, and imprisonment rates for men, women, and youths are appallingly higher (SCRGSP, 2005/2009). Other key indicators such as housing, education, employment, and income continue to show Indigenous Australians as a most disadvantaged group (SCRGSP, 2007). This evidence of impoverishment and disadvantage in a wealthy First World nation is shameful. Importantly, racism at individual and institutional levels continues to reproduce the impoverishment and disadvantage experienced by most Indigenous Australians (SCRGSP, 2009). Current campaigns, government policies, and community-driven interventions are promising, with the intention to close the gap on Indigenous health inequalities. The discipline of psychology can also play an important role in addressing such disadvantage.
Historical Background Like any other institution, psychology has a history of exclusion towards different cultural groups. It could be proposed that psychology, like other institutions, has been complicit in the oppression of powerless groups, particularly IndigeÂ�nous peoples in Australia (Dudgeon & Pickett, 2000) and in other countries (Howitt & Owusu-Bempah, 1994). As well as cultural boundedness, there are pervasive effects of cultural and institutionalized racism that exist within professions, disciplines, and institutions. These can take the form of the dominant group being seen as “normal” or the standard against which all else is judged, while those who are not part of the dominant group are viewed as “abnormal” or “inferior” and in need of correction (Rickwood, Dudgeon, & Gridley, 2010). All disciplines need to examine their historical and contemporary roles within the social and political structures and systems that give rise to, and perpetuate, racism and exclusion. Psychology as a discipline and profession has historically been grounded in Western culture and has been identified with the dominant European cultural tradition in Australia (see Dudgeon & Pickett, 2000; Garvey, Dudgeon, & Kearins, 2000; Rickwood, Dudgeon, & Gridley, 2010). The issues of concern include the assumption of universal applicability of psychology—that is, that truths about human behavior can be established and applied to all members of a given society without concern for cultural, historical, and political contexts. Another concern is an implicit individual orientation that underlies the discipline, in that individualism is the primary site of analysis for the profession. This approach fails to recognize the multiple ways that identity is constructed and that different people or cultural groups might construct self as part of a relational construct including family, language group, country, and spirit. Failure to examine the contributing
76
T he P s y ch o l o gically L iterate C iti z en
effects of culture, history, economics, politics, and the institutions that support and contribute to the development of the person presents a limited understanding of human behavior and its consequences (Glover, Dudgeon, & Huygens, 2005; Smith, 1999). We need to be critically aware that like our society, our discipline is neither value-free nor entirely objective. Australian psychology has only recently engaged with Indigenous people as partners rather than subjects (since around 1980; Garvey, Dudgeon, & Kearins, 2000). It was only in 1995 that the first Indigenous keynote speaker presented at the Australian Psychological Society annual conference. This conference also included the first-ever Aboriginal welcome to country as part of the opening ceremony. That speaker, Rob Riley, delivered an important, historic paper, in the hope that it would make a difference to the discipline. His words continue to have merit years afterwards, and the challenge remains: How many psychologists have an understanding of Aboriginal people? How many of you╯.╯.╯.╯have an understanding of Aboriginal culture, history and contemporary issues? For many of you, this work is crucial given the social conditions and your work environment in such places as prisons and the welfare sector and where there are large numbers of Aboriginal clients. It is your responsibility to seek that knowledge and understanding now, and to ensure that it is available for future generations of psychologists, in psychological training and education programs. (Riley, 1997, p. 15–16)
Indigenous Mental Health Significant shifts have occurred since Riley’s (1997) speech. Most importantly, an Indigenous mental health movement came about that was part of a greater positive social change for Indigenous Australia in the early 1990s (Dudgeon & Pickett, 2000). Landmark reports and frameworks were developed that capture the change in how mental health was perceived by Indigenous Australians (see for example AHMAC, 2004; HREOC, 2007). One of the most significant events affecting Indigenous mental health was the Ways Forward report (Swan & Raphael, 1995). This report was developed after national consultations, a landmark national conference, and the subsequent report about Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander mental health. Indigenous politically and culturally informed constructions of health and mental health began to emerge. Changes came about in perceptions of Indigenous mental health, and rather than the “disease model” perspective there was a prioritizing of wellness, holistic health, and culturally informed and appropriate approaches. These principles should be explicitly included in psychology education as the foundation on which all health-related knowledge is acquired. These changes in perceptions toward Indigenous mental health were underpinned by key elements that included a philosophical approach of empowerment and selfdetermination in the provision of mental health services for Indigenous people.
Changing the Lens
77
In other mental health areas, professionals were beginning to engage with these changes and different conceptualizations. Psychiatrist Ernest Hunter (1997) wrote: ‘Self Determination’, ‘quality of life’, ‘well-being’╯.╯.╯.╯these are terms that have only recently entered the vocabulary of mental health professionals working in Indigenous settings. They are unfamiliar and handled with uncertainty and at times temerity. But they are also unavoidable. (p. 6) Services that worked with Indigenous people needed to ensure that mechanisms were in place for collaboration and direction from the client groups, and Indigenous people needed to be fully involved in any mental health activity for Indigenous people. Indigenous people themselves needed to direct the engagement at all levels, whether this was an interaction between a psychologist and a client, or establishing services and developing policy. Psychologists have gradually acknowledged this changed perspective, but the philosophical orientations on which these changes are based have yet to become the foundation of psychology training. It is this vocabulary of change that needs to become visible in the undergraduate and graduate education of psychologists in order for them to play a meaningful role in the shifts that must occur if Australia is to succeed in its goal of closing the gap in health equality.
The Professional Bodies In the context of psychology education in Australia, the Health Practitioner Regulation (Administrative Arrangements) National Law Act of 2008 provides that the Australian Psychology Accreditation Council (APAC) has oversight of the training and education of psychology. This means that it is APAC that sets (minimal) curriculum requirements for the course content, certain aspects of teaching practices, and staffing of psychology education, and as such is the most influential body in psychology education and training. These requirements, along with the process for accrediting the educational institutions providing psychology education, are set out in the Rules for Accreditation and Accreditation Standards for Psychology Courses (APAC, 2010). Standard 3.1 argues that a 3-year undergraduate sequence must form “adequate foundational preparation upon which later study at the advanced level is built” (APAC, 2010, p. 40). In addition, StanÂ� dard 3.1.7 under Graduate Attribute 1: Core knowledge and understanding stipulates that psychology education must include “intercultural diversity and indigenous psychology” (APAC, 2010, p. 41). This is the only specific mention of cultural diversity and Indigenous content in the graduate attributes for psychology education; it is also listed as the last of 12. Given the earlier discussions, these requirements could be much stronger. Translation from standards to teaching has been discussed in other papers; specifically in relation to the teaching of research skills it was argued that it is the interpretation of the APAC standards (previously the Australian Psychological
78
T he P s y ch o l o gically L iterate C iti z en
Society [APS] Guidelines) that is problematic rather than the standards per se (Breen & Darlaston-Jones, 2010; Sullivan, 2008). If the purpose of psychology education is to understand, explain, and predict human behavior, with the intention of improving well-being (APS, 2010), then arguably an understanding of the cultural, political, economic, and social contexts in which such behavior occurs must also be essential (Gergen, 1999). This perspective, in turn, strongly supports the proposition that content concerned with critical analysis of society should be included not as an elective area of study but as integral to the education and training of psychology students. An illustration of a promising development along these lines relates to the 12 National Practice Standards for the Mental Health Workforce (NPSMHW, 2002), which the government intended would ensure that mental health professionals have a baseline set of competencies. These standards are aspirational but provide a way for psychology to examine how they are reflected in the curriculum and in professional practice. The 12 standards include rights, responsibilities, safety and privacy, consumer and carer participation, awareness of diversity, knowledge of mental health problems, mental disorders, promotion and prevention, and early detection and intervention. Also listed are evidence-based assessment, treatment, relapse prevention and support services that could prevent relapse, integration and partnership, service planning, development and management, documentation and information systems, evaluation and research, and ethical practice and professional responsibilities. These standards, if incorporated into the curriculum, have the potential to shift the perspective of psychology students and graduates and therefore contribute to social change by facilitating the provision of culturally appropriate services to a diverse society. They are mentioned in the APAC Standards under Graduate Attribute 4: Values, Research and Professional Ethics as being part of the ethical framework (along with the APS code of ethics and the complementary “ethical guidelines”) for psychology education (see p. 42). Indigenous content and issues can fit under any of these 12 standards. A survey conducted by the APS showed that many aspects of the NPSMHW were covered in both undergraduate and graduate psychology education (Mathews, Katsikitis, & Littlefield, 2005). However, it is largely left to the individual educator within schools and departments of psychology as to how they might be incorporated into the psychology curriculum. In addition, this inclusion is not only relatively recent but also has occurred without the requirement for mandatory professional development for existing psychologists or psychology educators. The consequence of this is likely to be that those practitioners who already subscribe to an inclusive value base would actively seek out professional development opportunities to improve their skills, while others might not see the relevance of doing so. While the accreditation requirements are designed to ensure that this content is covered, the accreditation process may fall short on assessing the extent to which the material is covered, the philosophical orientation in which it is presented, and the understanding or knowledge of the educator delivering it. The Australian Indigenous Psychologists Association (AIPA) has developed cultural competence training for mental health professionals
Changing the Lens
79
within these principles and has led the way with a number of initiatives seeking to advance the knowledge of and respect for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander culture and tradition. Therefore, there is scope for the newly established Psychology Board of Australia to require all practitioners to undertake professional development in cultural competence.
Teaching Indigenous Studies in Higher Education In comparison to Australia, a recent and recommended U.S. model for the undergraduate psychology curriculum suggests that discussion of ethical issues, including matters such as race, prejudice, discrimination, and equality, should appear in all courses (Dunn et al., 2010.) Discussions about the need to include Indigenous Studies in the university curriculum have been in place for some years in Australia. The Indigenous Higher Education Advisory Council (IHEAC) has taken up the issue with governments. Based on principles of respect for Indigenous people, knowledge, and culture, one of the visions of IHEAC for the Australian higher education system is to ensure that Indigenous people and their culture and knowledge are visible and valued on university campuses (Commonwealth of Australia, 2006). Most importantly, IHEAC has recognized that while Indigenous disadvantages are critical and need to be addressed, there should also be a focus on the unique positive and distinctive contributions that Indigenous people and culture make to universities. IHEAC also recommended that Indigenous cultural competence be recognized as a graduate attribute for all Australian higher education graduates (Commonwealth of Australia, 2008). An outstanding example of a discipline area including Indigenous content in the curriculum in a systemic manner is in medical education, where the Committee of Deans of Australian Medical Schools (CDAMS, 2004) Indigenous Health Curriculum Framework has been adopted to ensure that Indigenous content in the curriculum is a central issue. Here, not only are student attributes identified but equally importantly, so too are the pedagogical principles by which the students are taught. The CDAMS framework also provides a set of guidelines to assist medical schools to develop and deliver Indigenous health content in medical education, thereby ensuring the development of cultural competence in medical graduates. The framework was adopted by the Australian Medical Council in accreditation processes to ensure that Indigenous content in the curriculum is a central issue.
Teaching About Culture as Psychological Literacy For most Australian psychologists, there were few opportunities to have Indigenous studies or social justice issues included in their education experience. It has only been in recent times that books on Indigenous mental health such as Working with Indigenous Australians: A Handbook for Psychologists (Dudgeon,
80
T he P s y ch o l o gically L iterate C iti z en
Box 6.1 Personal Reflection: Pat Dudgeon When I was studying psychology many years ago there was very little about Indigenous issues in my courses. When I graduated I wondered whether my qualifications would be useful to the Aboriginal community at all. The discipline was extremely Eurocentric and it was difficult to see how it had any relevance to Indigenous people. I felt alienated in my undergraduate studies and was much more comfortable with anthropology, which considered other cultures. In psychology, when we tried to match up to issues such as Indigenous cognition, child development, and so on, it left us bereft. We did not fit, and there was a sense that we were somehow at fault. However, one day I read a book called Black Psychology by African American psychologists (Jones, 1972), and it was a revelation: a new world opened, showing me that there could be other paradigms in psychology. I was then fortunate to be part of the development of the different perspectives in Indigenous mental health in Australia. At this point, we realized that the issue was not about us “not fitting,” but it had been about the discipline not fitting us. Australian psychology has changed since then to now include paradigms that are relevant to Indigenous peoples. Personal Reflection: Dawn Darlaston-Jones My experience as a non-Indigenous woman means that I am faced with multiple challenges in my role as an educator and citizen in what is purported to be a multicultural country. Not only am I a non-Indigenous woman, but I am also a British migrant and therefore need to continually negotiate my position and identity in a society that continues to experience the damage caused by British colonialism. In addition, choosing to embrace an anti-racism framework in my teaching practice presents further challenges not only in terms of my position, identity, and role, but also in regard to the practicalities of how to teach within this philosophical orientation. This requires critical reflection in relation to content, assessments, and overcoming resistance from non-Indigenous students as well as the broader systemic issues of the assumptions that underpin education, including cultural imperialism and whiteness. Undergraduate psychology education failed to provide me with any foundation on which to develop a different understanding or approach in my professional life. My postgraduate studies in community psychology, however, saw me take a unit on cultural issues delivered by Associate Professor Christopher Sonn, and this became the turning point in my life, professionally and personally. This class introduced me to different ways of experiencing the world and the consequences of contributing to a system that marginalizes and oppresses members of society, not necessarily through acts of overt discrimination but by a set of assumptions and philosophies that reinforce social conventions that see certain people and groups as less than those members of the dominant society.
Changing the Lens
81
This introduction was the turning point for me and has led me on a journey of critical reflection, reading, investigation, and learning that contributed to my evolution personally and professionally. Personal Reflection: Yvonne Clark As an Aboriginal student studying psychology in the 1990s there was very little Indigenous and cultural content in my psychology courses. Although I found various aspects of the content interesting and useful, much of it didn’t fit with who I was, nor my experiences of growing up, my values, nor my way of thinking and understanding in the world. At times I found much of the content and concepts incongruent and hard to grasp. One particular psychology lecturer, who I sought out for clarification on a specific topic, informed me arrogantly that “what we have here is an indoctrination process” and if I didn’t grasp it, use the concepts, language, and information, and become fully engaged (in other words, become indoctrinated) then I would not become a “true” professional. This was upsetting, as these words and attitude rendered me and my cultural differences as insignificant. At the time the existing power imbalance between student and lecturer did not give me the confidence to challenge the lecturer; I did, however, debrief with my honors supervisor, who helped me see past the arrogance and reflect on what I wanted to do with the experience of it. I decided and made a pact to myself that I was going to stay true to myself, my identity, and my values as an Aboriginal person within this institution and not be bullied into a process and system that I was uncomfortable with. Aboriginal people have endured many years under assimilation policies that attempted to strip identities, and I was not about to let this similar process deny me my place within this system. As a consequence of not fully engaging in psychology I felt I was always on the “outer” and felt quite alone, being the only Aboriginal student. However, despite this, I succeeded. I am now a lecturer at the very same university and feel honored to be in such a position and to teach within a cultural competence framework. I provide various lectures within cross-cultural, intercultural, Indigenous psychology, and mental health subjects within the undergraduate program. I also provide some practical lectures on Indigenous social and emotional well-being in the graduate program. However, this lectureship brings many challenges in terms of how to teach a different paradigm that embraces concepts and understandings of cultural difference: anti-racism, equity, and disadvantage. I start with analyzing the broader systems in order to move from tokenism to genuine commitment and competence in Indigenous issues and mental health. There are further challenges when I encounter pockets of resistance from non-Indigenous students in embracing these different concepts. Despite these challenges, I know that among the pockets of resistance there is also growing support and willingness to embrace cultural competence, and there has never been a better time than now to nurture such growth.
82
T he P s y ch o l o gically L iterate C iti z en
Garvey, & Pickett, 2000), Working Together: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Mental Health and Wellbeing Principles and Practices (Purdie, Dudgeon, & Walker, 2010), and other psychology texts that included Indigenous issues and chapters such as Psychology, 2nd Australian and New Zealand Edition (Burton, Westen, & Kowalski, 2009) have been available. Even now, for those who have committed to ensuring that psychological literacy in Indigenous perspectives is a part of the education they provide, it is a challenging situation at a number of levels. Not only are appropriate resources scarce, but there remains a lack of understanding at the decision-making and implementation levels that cultural competence needs to be included—which we argue should become the foundation to any practice. At the heart of this practice is a commitment to social change, a recognition that not only does the individual need to change his or her view, but that this change also needs to transfer to the broader community in terms of the social norms and assumptions that predicate interactions and belief systems (Prilleltensky & Gonick, 1996). It is in this context that education, particularly tertiary education, plays a crucial role. This includes the environment and culture of the university, the discipline content of the courses, and the interactions between the students and the students and staff. Therefore, the subject material about cultural norms and value systems needs to be reflected in the norms and values of the student; the educator, who is likely to be a member of the dominant group and who needs to share a sense of connection with those whom he or she seeks to educate; and the manner in which the classroom reflects and reinforces dominant societal positions. Establishing a climate of mutual trust and respect provides the basis for a healthy inclusive environment that maximizes learning and outcomes. However, the value of any experience depends not on the experience per se but on the struggles around the way it is interpreted and defined (Giroux, 1983, 2001); therefore, what is important is not the interaction that occurs in the classroom as a function of being a student or educator, but the interpretation of the interaction that occurs as each person struggles to negotiate new spaces and ways of thinking, and the subsequent effect this has on the individual. Students who represent the dominant group in society are often resistant to a view that positions them in a different way to that which they have been socialized to expect, and this can lead to tensions within the individual student and within the class. The key is not to position students as problematic, but rather to encourage them to explore the social constructions of other members of society and therefore by extension examine their own subject position in light of this analysis. This process of exploration means that it is not simply the content of the unit that is critical, but also the pedagogical approach that is applied to its delivery. Consequently, critical reflexivity, power, and its consequences take on particular importance. Critical reflexivity in both the student and the educator is essential in terms of understanding how each contributes to either the maintenance or challenge of the status quo; there needs to be a recognition and understanding of the role of power and how this translates in society to either privilege or disadvantage. It is this notion of power that needs to become visible within the training of
Changing the Lens
83
psychology students as well as the broader educational context. It is also the effect of the experience of exploring these issues in relation to the long-term outcome for the graduate, in essence his or her personal growth and development, and how this is played out in the broader fabric of society, that is crucial. Perhaps most importantly, an understanding of the role of whiteness in constituting society on a national and international stage, as well as the consequences of this for members of both dominant and marginalized groups, also needs to have a central role in the classroom. Students who are members of minority groups usually welcome such an approach because it is often the first time that their social position and voice has been identified, and the detrimental consequences of marginalization as a direct result of power and whiteness has been examined. Creating environments for psychology students to become literate in ethical issues and social justice is important. Perhaps even more important is the issue of the type of student who is being recruited and retained within psychology and how this affects society. Given that the underlying philosophical assumptions of higher education and in particular psychology education are ones based on Western ideals of individualism and consumerism—usually more so than on the ideals of social responsibility and social justice—students may not have any opportunity to learn other values. It is important that concepts of a just and well society are not lost in favor of a concept that emphasizes individual achievement over compassion (Apple, 1982, 2000b;, Aronowitz, 2000; Aronowitz & Giroux, 1991; Biesta, 2001; Prilleltensky & Nelson, 2002). This perspective of education means that five issues (Tanaka, 2002) gain greater relevance in understanding the student experience and how it relates to the educational experience and the effects on citizenship. Each issue raises a series of questions designed to facilitate the necessary critical reflection and therefore collectively provide a valuable framework for assessing each area of education and practice and their consequences. These issues are: • Voice: whether or not students are heard in the university context. Are they able to be seen as having “subject position” or are they objectified by the dominant consumer focus adopted by higher education? • Power: How do the multiple manifestations of power play out in higher education? Are these stated explicitly, therefore making them open to critique and challenge? Do we (students and educators alike) examine how power and knowledge are connected? Do we question the Eurocentric nature of knowledge that explicitly excludes minority groups? Do educators acknowledge the ways in which teaching practices reinforce the dominant perspective and so contribute to cultural hegemony? • Authenticity: Do educators and policymakers acknowledge that students are situated in their own cultural space that includes issues of social, economic, and political power? • Reflexivity: Do we as individuals (students and educators) explore our place in society and our role in constituting the taken-for-granted norms
84
T he P s y ch o l o gically L iterate C iti z en
that operate? Do we understand that the university is a cultural place and that we (students and educators) contribute to its creation? • Reconstitution: Are we as students, researchers, and educators able to effect change and create a learning environment conducive to the development of individual and collective well-being? The ability to explore these questions demands a conceptual and theoretical framework that allows analysis not only of the learning experience itself and how this is interpreted and made sense of by the individual student, but also of how this relates to well-being on the individual, relational, and community levels within and beyond the university context. Accepting the concept proposed by Prilleltensky and Nelson (2002) that community well-being is predicated on individual and relational well-being means that the role of the university in contributing to well-being at all levels (in the professions and society as a whole) takes on greater meaning. This is because universities can be conceptualized as communities in their own right as well as being a constituent of the broader society; therefore, the content of the psychology curriculum plays a significant role not only in the ongoing education of psychologists but also in their power to affect understanding of behaviors in a broader context (Giroux, 2001; Prilleltensky, 1997, 2003a, b). The power of the educational setting in contributing to the socialization process (Leistyna, 1999) is well recognized, and therefore the student becomes the focus of the institution and the institution is nested within the community. If the university processes and practices are beneficial to the individual, this will translate into wider benefit for the community, but the same is true if these practices are detrimental to the individual. The social justice of equitable access to education for all peoples requires an awareness of the diversity of the student population and a commitment to the creation of a pluralist university based on mutual respect between the informants (Fox & Prilleltensky, 1997; Prilleltensky & Nelson, 2002); therefore, it becomes imperative that the unspoken assumptions that underpin the liberal democracy of Australian society be brought into focus and challenged, and this includes issues of cultural imperialism and whiteness. In Australia, some universities do attempt to include Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander perspectives and content into the degree structure in psychology. There are two broad approaches to this undertaking. The first can be conceptualized as a “stand-alone” model, which is illustrated well at the University of South Australia (UniSA). The second approach is an “embedded” model, which is the approach taken by the Bachelor of Behavioural Science at the University of Notre Dame (UNDA). At UniSA, students undertake a compulsory unit of study in their first year that examines Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander culture and the impact of colonization. This foundation knowledge can be expanded on with students electing to take an additional unit of study in their third year, which explores the nexus between the discipline and Indigenous peoples. Pedagogically, these units are predicated on notions of critical reflexivity that encourage students to understand their own subject position within a historical and contemporary social
Changing the Lens
85
context (Cleland, 2010). This scaffolded approach across the curriculum encourages ongoing learning and provides the opportunity for personal shifts in understanding among the students gradually over the course of their studies. This form of educational practice sets students along the path to achieving cultural competence, and prepares them to build on this competence throughout their careers. At UNDA’s Fremantle campus, the Bachelor of Behavioural Science has been conceptualized and developed with a strong commitment to including appropriate theoretical frameworks through which human behavior can be understood, and this includes an understanding of the Australian context through an anti-colonial standpoint. This approach leads to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples being reconceptualized as First Nations Peoples, and therefore psychological knowledge is presented in significantly different ways relative to dominant narratives. The concept of First Nations originated in Canada and is designed to recognize the sovereignty of Canadian Aboriginal populations other than Inuit and Métis. Unlike the Canadian context, the notion of sovereignty has no legal standing in Australia. However, applying this philosophical position establishes a foundation of respect toward Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples and encourages a change of focus in subsequent discussions and analysis of social interactions. In every unit of the degree program at UNDA there is an emphasis on critical reflexivity, concepts of power, and understanding the role of whiteness in constituting society (Apple, 2000a, b; Prilleltensky, 1989; Rappaport, 1984, 2000; Tanaka, 2003; Wink, 1997). Pedagogical practices are founded on principles that contextualize the student within a specific social, cultural, historical, political, and economic space and examine the relationship between power and persons within that space (Freire, 1970, 1998, 1999). Once again knowledge is scaffolded to provide students with the opportunity to build their understanding over time and in relation to the range of content knowledge contained in the degree. Students can also undertake a unit that comprises a 4-week immersion in a remote Aboriginal community as part of the Gelganyem Youth and Community Wellbeing Programme (Morgan & Drew, 2010). This initiative is a partnership between the university and the Gelganyem Trust, representing seven Aboriginal Traditional Owner family groups in East Kimberley (Northwestern Australia). Students travel with a staff member and are engaged in a range of activities from the delivery of out-of-school programs, helping with breakfast club, developing grant applications, and other community needs as identified by the community. Students are oriented prior to engaging with community by completing a campus preparation unit on Indigenous studies and critical whiteness. Critical to the success of this program is the fact that it is initiated by and on behalf of the Aboriginal Traditional Owners and therefore it has community control. The importance of building and maintaining relationships with community members, and for the university team members to see their role as working for or with the community in respectful partnership, is a key element of the learning outcomes from this experience and reflects the foundation principles of the degree. Graduates of Behavioural Science emerge with an understanding of and the ability to critique existing discourses and how these create and maintain privilege and disadvantage.
86
T he P s y ch o l o gically L iterate C iti z en
While each of these different approaches to incorporating Indigenous content into the curriculum has strengths and deficits, both models provide students with the essential knowledge components for them to engage critically with their professional roles and identity within contemporary society and therefore to work towards social change. Perhaps the greatest challenge in developing an embedded model such as the one at UNDA is the capacity of academic staff to teach within this framework. As mentioned previously, undergraduate and graduate training in psychology usually does not readily provide this knowledge, and so educators need to teach themselves not only in the content knowledge but also in the pedagogical approaches to teach effectively in a social justice framework. The positive consequence of this approach, however, is that course content is obtained from different disciplines, which not only increases transdisciplinary engagements but also situates psychological knowledge and practice in a more holistic manner. This in turn ensures that psychology graduates are better able to meet the needs of an increasingly diverse population, and to increase the applicability of psychology and psychologists to the complexities of the social context. Unfortunately, developing staff with this knowledge background can be difficult, and the creation of courses of study predicated on such philosophical foundations is often tied to individual staff, making succession planning another consideration. The 2010 symposium at the International Conference of Psychology Education (ICOPE) in Sydney identified the theoretical and practical issues related to incorporating Indigenous voices, knowledge, culture, and history into the training of psychology students to effect social change. Emerging from this symposium is an initiative to develop strategies to promote change in three key areas: 1. To “Indigenise” the curriculum in psychology and other disciplines 2. To increase the number of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students enrolled in psychology 3. To increase opportunities for psychologists to undertake cultural compeÂ� tence education.
Conclusions We addressed the need for psychologists and psychology education to become psychologically literate with respect to cultural understandings. Our perspective incorporates a social justice standpoint that recognizes the impacts of history and particularly power imbalances that result in groups remaining marginalized and disempowered. Undergraduate students, whether or not they become professional psychologists, need to be culturally competent to fully participate in employment and social settings that are becoming increasingly globalized, and in particular to optimize their capacity to work with different cultural groups. This perspective requires a philosophical shift in the way that psychology education and training is conceptualized so that cultural competence becomes the lens through which all knowledge is assessed and understood. Consequently, not only is the content of
Changing the Lens
87
psychology education important, but so too is the manner in which it is taught. These two parallel imperatives are essential if psychology, as a discipline, and psychologists, as professionals, are to contribute in a meaningful way to the social change agenda.
References Apple, M. (1982). Cultural and economic reproduction in education. London, UK: Routledge & Kegan Paul. Apple, M. (1996). Cultural politics and education. New York: Teachers College Press. Apple, M. (2000a). Can critical pedagogies interrupt rightist policies? Educational Theory, 50, 229–254. Apple, M. (2000b). Official knowledge. New York: Routledge. Aronowitz, S. (2000). The knowledge factory. Boston, MA: Beacon Press. Aronowitz, S., & Giroux, H. (1991). Postmodern education: politics, culture, and social criticism. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press. Australian Bureau of Statistics. (2006). The National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Survey, 2004–2005. Canberra: Australian Bureau of Statistics. Australian Health Ministers Advisory Council (AHMAC) (2004). The National Strategic Framework for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders Peoples Mental Health and Social and Emotional Wellbeing, 2004–2009. Canberra: AHMAC. Australian Psychology Accreditation Council (2010). Rules for accreditation and accredita tion standards for psychology courses. Melbourne: APAC. Retrieved Aug. 22, 2010, from http://www.apac.psychology.org.au/Assets/Files/APAC_Rules_for%20_Accreditation_ and_Accreditation_Standards_for%20_Psychology_Courses_Ver_10_June_2010.pdf. Australian Psychological Society Website (2010). http://www.psychology.org.au/AboutUs/ Biesta, G. (2001). How difficult should education be? Educational Theory, 51, 385–401. Breen, L., & Darlaston-Jones, D. (2010). Moving beyond the enduring dominance of positivism in psychological research: an Australian perspective. Australian Psychologist, 45(1), 67–76. Burton, L., Westen, D., & Kowalski, R. (2009). Psychology, 2nd Australian and New Zealand edition. Australia: John Wiley & Sons. Cleland, A. (2010). Cultural competency development: responding to resistance in preparing human service graduates to work effectively with Indigenous Australian people. Journal of Australian Indigenous Studies, 13(3&4), 76–88. Commonwealth Department of Health and Aging, (2002). National Practice Standards for the Mental Health Workforce. Canberra: Commonwealth Department of Health and Aging. Committee of Deans of Australian Medical Schools. (2004). Indigenous Health Curric ulum Framework. Melbourne: VicHealth Koori Health Research and Community Development Unit, University of Melbourne. Commonwealth of Australia. Indigenous Higher Education Advisory Council. (2006). Improving indigenous outcomes and enhancing indigenous culture and knowledge in Australian higher education report. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia. Commonwealth of Australia. Indigenous Higher Education Advisory Council. (2008). Ngapartji Ngapartji–Yerra: Stronger Futures. Report of the 3rd Annual IHEAC ConÂ�ference. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia.
88
T he P s y ch o l o gically L iterate C iti z en
Dalton, J., Elias, M., & Wandesman, A. (2007). Community psychology: linking Â�individuals and communities (2nd ed.). Australia: Thomson. Dudgeon, P., Wright, M., Paradies, Y., Garvey, D., & Walker, I. (2010). The social, cultural and historical context of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. In N. Purdie, P. Dudgeon, & R, Walker (Eds.), Working together: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander mental health and wellbeing principles practices (pp. 25–42). Canberra: ACER. Dudgeon, P. L., Garvey, D., & Pickett, H. (Eds.). (2000). Working with Indigenous Australians: a handbook for psychologists. Perth: Gunada Press. Dudgeon, P. L., & Pickett, H. (2000). Psychology and reconciliation: Australian perspectives. Australian Psychologist, 35(2), 82–87. Dunn, D. S., Brewer, C. L., Cautin, R. L., Gurung, R. A. R., Keith, K. D., McGregor, L. N., et al, (2010). The undergraduate psychology curriculum: call for a core. In D. F. Halpern (Ed.), Undergraduate education in psychology: a blueprint for the future of the discipline (pp. 47–61). Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. Fox, D. (2000). The critical psychology project: transforming society and transforming psychology. In T. Sloan (Ed.), Critical psychology: voices for change. New York: St Martin’s Press. Fox, D., & Prilleltensky, I. (1997). Introducing critical psychology: values, assumptions, and status quo. In D. Fox & I. Prilleltensky (Eds.), Critical psychology: an introduction (pp. 3–20). London: Sage Publications. Freire, P. (1970). Pedagogy of the oppressed. New York: Continuum. Freire, P. (1998). Pedagogy of freedom: ethics, democracy, and civil courage. New York: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers Inc. Freire, P. (1999). Making history and unveiling oppression. Dulwich Centre Journal, 3, 37–39. Garvey D., Dudgeon, P., & Kearins, J. (2000). Australian psychology has black history. In P. Dudgeon, D. Garvey, & H. Pickett (Eds.), Working with Indigenous Australians: a handbook for psychologists (pp. 231–248). Perth: Gunada Press. Gergen, K. (1999). An invitation to social construction. London: Sage. Giroux, H. (1983). Theory and resistance in education: a pedagogy for the opposition. South Hadley, MA: Bergin & Garvey Publishers Inc. Giroux, H. (2001). Pedagogy of the depressed: beyond the new politics of cynicism. College Literature, 28(3), 1–32. Glover, M., Dudgeon, P., & Huygens, I. (2005). Colonization and racism. In G. Nelson & I. Prilleltensky (Eds.), Community psychology: in pursuit of well-being (pp. 330–347). New York: Palgrave and Macmillan. Howwitt, D., & Owusu-Bemph, J. (1994). The racism of psychology: time for a change. New York: Harvester Wheatsheaf. Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (HREOC) (2007). Close the gap: national Indigenous health equality targets. Outcomes from the National Indigenous Health Equality Summit. Sydney: HREOC. Hunter, E. (1997). Double talk: changing and conflicting constructions of Indigenous mental health. Paper presented to the National Conference on Mental Health Services, Policy and Law Reform into the Twenty-First Century. University of Newcastle, Feb. 14, 1997. Jones, R. (Ed.). (1972). Black psychology. New York: Harper & Row. Kelly, K., Dudgeon, P., Gee, G. & Glaskin. (2009). Living on the edge: social and emotional wellbeing and risk and protective factors for serios psychological distress
Changing the Lens
89
among Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. Discussion paper series: No 10. Cooperative Research Centre for Aboriginal Health. Leistyna, P. (1999). Presence of mind: education and the politics of deception. Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Mathews, R., Katsikitis, M., & Littlefield, L. (2005). An evaluation of education and training in the National Practice Standards for the Mental Health Workforce within Australian university psychology programs. Inpsych. June 2005. Available at: http:// www.psychology.org.au/publications/inpsych/evaluation/ McGovern, T. V., Corey, L., Cranney, J., Dixon, J. R., Jeffrey, D., Holmes, J. E., et al. (2010). Psychologically literate citizens. In D. F. Halpern (Ed.), Undergraduate educa tion in psychology: a blueprint for the future of the discipline (pp. 9–27). Washington, D. C.: American Psychological Association. Morgan, M., & Drew, N. (2010). Principled engagement: Gelganyem youth and com munity well being program. In N. Purdie, P. Dudgeon, & R. Walker (Eds.), Working together: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander mental health and wellbeing principles and practice. Canberra: Department of Health & Aging. National Centre for Cultural Competence (NCCC) (2006). Conceptual frameworks/ models, guiding values, and principles. Washington, D. C.: Georgetown University Child Development Center. Nelson, G., & Prilleltensky, I. (Eds) (2010). Community Psychology: In pursuit of libera tion and well-being (2nd Ed). Basingstoke, Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan. Prilleltensky, I. (1989). Psychology and the status quo. American Psychologist, 44, 795–802. Prilleltensky, I. (1997). Values, assumptions, and practices: assessing the moral implications of psychological discourse and action. American Psychologist, 52, 517–535. Prilleltensky, I. (2003a). The role of power in wellness, oppression, and liberation: the promise of psychopolitical validity. Retrieved from http://members.optushome.com. au/psydeas/power.htm. Prilleltensky, I. (2003b). Understanding, resisting, and overcoming oppression: toward psychopolitical validity. American Journal of Community Psychology, 31, 195–201. Prilleltensky, I., & Fox, D. (1997). Introducing critical psychology: values, assumptions, and the status quo. In D. Fox & I. Prilleltensky (Eds.), Critical psychology: an introduc tion. (pp.3–20). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Prilleltensky, I., & Gonick, L. (1996). Politics change, oppression remains: on the psychology and politics of oppression. Political Psychology, 17, 127–147. Prilleltensky, I., & Nelson, G. (2002). Doing psychology critically: making a difference in diverse settings. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan. Purdie, N., Dudgeon, P., & Walker, R. (Eds.). (2010). Working together: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander mental health and wellbeing principles and practices. Canberra: Australian Council for Education Research. Rappaport, J. (1984). Studies in empowerment: introduction to the issue. Prevention in Human Services, 5, 1–7. Rappaport, J. (2000). Community narratives: tales of terror and joy. American Journal of Community Psychology, 28, 1–24. Rickwood, D., Dudgeon, P., & Gridley, H., (2010). A history of psychology in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander mental health. In N. Purdie, P. Dudgeon, & R. Walker
90
T he P s y ch o l o gically L iterate C iti z en
(Eds.), Working together: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander mental health and well being principles and practices (pp. 13–24). Canberra: Australian Council for Education Research. Riley, R. (1997). From exclusion to negotiation: the role of psychology in Aboriginal social justice. Discussion Paper. Perth, Curtin Indigenous Research centre. Smith, L. (1999). Decolonising methodologies: research and Indigenous peoples. Dunedin: University of Otago Press. Sullivan, G. B. (2008). What is the status of theoretical psychology in Australia and New Zealand? An investigation of contemporary teaching and research issues. Australian Psychologist, 43, 61–73. Steering Committee for the Review of Government Services Provision. (2005/9). Overcoming Indigenous disadvantage: key indicators 2005/7. Canberra: Productivity Commission, Commonwealth of Australia. Swan, P., & Raphael, B. (1995). “Ways forward”: national consultancy report on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander mental health. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia. Australian Government Publishing Services. Tanaka, G. (2002). Higher education’s self-reflexive turn: toward an intercultural theory of student development. Journal of Higher Education, 73, 263–296. Tanaka, G. (2003). The intercultural campus: transcending culture and power in American higher education. New York: Peter Lang. Watson, I., Buchanan, J., Campbell, I., & Briggs, C. (2003). Fragmented futures: new challenges in working life. Sydney: Federation Press. Wink, J. (1997). Critical pedagogy: notes from the real world. New York: Longman.
7 Introductory Psychology and Psychological Literacy L o r e ll e J . B u r t o n a n d K a t h i e J . M
c
Donald
T
he world of higher education has changed rapidly in recent years. For example, large-scale reviews such as the Bradley Report (Bradley, Noonan, Nugent, & Scales, 2008) have identified key challenges that the sector faces in Australia, and have subsequently initiated structural reform. The way universities teach undergraduate students and the graduate outcomes that they target are also changing (Cranney et al., 2009). This evolution poses both challenges and opportunities for the discipline and profession of psychology. As psychology educators, we have to adapt and embrace the challenge of change. We cannot be left behind while a new model of tertiary education takes off. At the same time, we have the chance to be at the forefront of that change, and lead the ongoing evolution of tertiary education. One key opportunity that we have is to champion the benefits for students in developing “psychological literacy” not just for those enrolled in psychology, but as a building block to success for all commencing tertiary students. This chapter will examine the broader challenges facing the higher education sector, the way psychology is taught, the particular challenges that first-year students face, and the concept of developing “psychologically literate citizens.”
Higher Education in Australia The Bradley Report (Bradley et al., 2008) has provided a checkpoint for tertiary education in Australia. The report puts into focus the state of the national higher education sector in comparison to that of similar countries, and its findings have directed us down a challenging path. The report found international consensus that “the reach, quality and performance of a nation’s higher education system would be key determinants of its economic and social progress” (Bradley et al., 2008, p. xi); that is, Australia’s continued development will be underpinned by the strength of our tertiary sector. It is concerning, then, that the Bradley Report also found that Australia lagged behind countries in some educational measures, sitting below the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
92
T h e P s y c h o l o g ica l ly Literate C iti z en
average in terms of graduates from tertiary education. As a result, the report has recommended challenging targets to help redress that gap, particularly increasing (a) the overall percentage of the population having at least a bachelor’s degree qualification, and (b) the proportion of university students from previously underrepresented groups. Achieving those targets presents multifaceted and complex problems. How do educators, administrators, and/or faculty members ensure that underrepresented groups aspire to, enroll in, and complete higher education studies? How will higher education keep regional universities sustainable, so that underrepresented rural populations have access to the sector? Many of these outcomes require wider social or systemic change. The current federal government intends to tackle the challenge by implementing a new national management system. In the psychology profession, recent health practitioner reforms in Australia have created additional structural changes for learning and teaching. From July 1, 2010, the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law Act of 2009 became the legislative framework under which psychologists, and nine other health professions, operate. The Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency will support the health practitioner management in Australia via 10 health professional boards. For psychologists, this body is the Psychology Board of Australia, which reviews and accepts accreditation of tertiary psychology programs made by a separate accreditation body, the Australian Psychology Accreditation Council, which has had this role since its formation in 2003 (Australia Psychology Accreditation Council, 2009). So, the tertiary sector in Australia (and the psychology profession in particular) faces significant change in coming years as a result of the structural and aspirational reforms now on the table. What does this mean for learning and teaching in the tertiary sector, and for learning and teaching in psychology in particular?
Psychological Literacy and the First-Year Student Experience At a time when increasing emphasis is rightly being placed on teaching and learning in universities around Australia, it is important for the discipline of psychology to examine its own teaching environment, particularly at first-year level. The study of psychology is concerned with understanding why people act and think as they do, and how people differ. Psychology education is based on the scientistpractitioner model, which provides a rigor that some other disciplines lack. Psychology uses scientifically validated principles, which are then applied to address practical issues and problems. Typically, first-year psychology courses are designed to provide students with an understanding of the major concepts, methods, and theoretical perspectives in psychology; to learn about the research process; and t