The Primitive Mind and Modern Man By
John Alan Cohan
eBooks End User License Agreement Please read this license agreement carefully before using this eBook. Your use of this eBook/chapter constitutes your agreement to the terms and conditions set forth in this License Agreement. Bentham Science Publishers agrees to grant the user of this eBook/chapter, a non-exclusive, nontransferable license to download and use this eBook/chapter under the following terms and conditions: 1. This eBook/chapter may be downloaded and used by one user on one computer. The user may make one back-up copy of this publication to avoid losing it. The user may not give copies of this publication to others, or make it available for others to copy or download. For a multi-user license contact
[email protected] 2. All rights reserved: All content in this publication is copyrighted and Bentham Science Publishers own the copyright. You may not copy, reproduce, modify, remove, delete, augment, add to, publish, transmit, sell, resell, create derivative works from, or in any way exploit any of this publication’s content, in any form by any means, in whole or in part, without the prior written permission from Bentham Science Publishers. 3. The user may print one or more copies/pages of this eBook/chapter for their personal use. The user may not print pages from this eBook/chapter or the entire printed eBook/chapter for general distribution, for promotion, for creating new works, or for resale. Specific permission must be obtained from the publisher for such requirements. Requests must be sent to the permissions department at E-mail:
[email protected] 4. The unauthorized use or distribution of copyrighted or other proprietary content is illegal and could subject the purchaser to substantial money damages. The purchaser will be liable for any damage resulting from misuse of this publication or any violation of this License Agreement, including any infringement of copyrights or proprietary rights. Warranty Disclaimer: The publisher does not guarantee that the information in this publication is error-free, or warrants that it will meet the users’ requirements or that the operation of the publication will be uninterrupted or error-free. This publication is provided "as is" without warranty of any kind, either express or implied or statutory, including, without limitation, implied warranties of merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose. The entire risk as to the results and performance of this publication is assumed by the user. In no event will the publisher be liable for any damages, including, without limitation, incidental and consequential damages and damages for lost data or profits arising out of the use or inability to use the publication. The entire liability of the publisher shall be limited to the amount actually paid by the user for the eBook or eBook license agreement. Limitation of Liability: Under no circumstances shall Bentham Science Publishers, its staff, editors and authors, be liable for any special or consequential damages that result from the use of, or the inability to use, the materials in this site. eBook Product Disclaimer: No responsibility is assumed by Bentham Science Publishers, its staff or members of the editorial board for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products instruction, advertisements or ideas contained in the publication purchased or read by the user(s). Any dispute will be governed exclusively by the laws of the U.A.E. and will be settled exclusively by the competent Court at the city of Dubai, U.A.E. You (the user) acknowledge that you have read this Agreement, and agree to be bound by its terms and conditions. Permission for Use of Material and Reproduction Photocopying Information for Users Outside the USA: Bentham Science Publishers Ltd. grants authorization for individuals to photocopy copyright material for private research use, on the sole basis that requests for such use are referred directly to the requestor's local Reproduction Rights Organization (RRO). The copyright fee is US $25.00 per copy per article exclusive of any charge or fee levied. In order to contact your local RRO, please contact the International Federation of Reproduction Rights Organisations (IFRRO), Rue du Prince Royal 87, B-I050 Brussels, Belgium; Tel: +32 2 551 08 99; Fax: +32 2 551 08 95; E-mail:
[email protected]; url: www.ifrro.org This authorization does not extend to any other kind of copying by any means, in any form, and for any purpose other than private research use. Photocopying Information for Users in the USA: Authorization to photocopy items for internal or personal use, or the internal or personal use of specific clients, is granted by Bentham Science Publishers Ltd. for libraries and other users registered with the Copyright Clearance Center (CCC) Transactional Reporting Services, provided that the appropriate fee of US $25.00 per copy per chapter is paid directly to Copyright Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers MA 01923, USA. Refer also to www.copyright.com
CONTENTS Preface
i
CHAPTERS PART I: Primitive Societies and Cultural Frameworks 1. Why Study Primitive Cultures?
01
2. Cultural Relativism
22
3. Apollinian and Dionysian Cultures
29
PART II: Primitive Beliefs, Practices and Rituals 4. Mana
37
5. Animism
49
6. Totemism
76
7. Hunting and Cultivation Rituals
83
8. Shamanism: The “Wounded Healer”
95
9. Envy and the Evil Eye
114 PART III: Consciousness and Magical Powers
10. Altered States of Consciousness
127
11. Trance and Possession States
133
12. Magic, Sorcery and Witchcraft
150 PART IV: Conflict and Death
13. Death by Suggestion: Voodoo Death, Taboo Death, and Bone-Pointing
167
14. The Placebo Effect
172
15. Dealing with Conflicts, Aggressive Impulses, Enemies and War
175
16. Treatment of the Dead
192 PART V: Status and Wealth
17. Potlatches
201
18. Status, Prestige, Recognition--the Need for Social Approval
207
PART VI: Cultural Phenomena and Folk Medicine 19. Culture-Bound Syndromes
212
20. Mass Hysteria, Mass Possession
230
21. Folk Medicine
236
PART VII: Women and Children in Primitive Societies 22. The Treatment and the Role of Women in Primitive Cultures
246
23. Child Rearing and the Treatment of Children in Primitive Cultures
255
PART VIII: When Modern Culture Meets Primitive Culture, and a Case Study 24. Cargo Cults
260
25. Nomadic Peoples: A Case Study of the Batek People of Malaysia
266
References
274
Appendix
290
Index
310
i
PREFACE Cultural anthropology is a relatively new discipline, having its origins in 19th century ethnology, which involves the organized comparison of human cultures. It was not until the 1920s that anthropologists started to actually live among primitive people for a considerable period of time, to participate in and observe the social and cultural life of the group. Up until then, an understanding of other people was important mainly to diplomats, military personnel, colonial officials, missionaries, and traders. In fact, once anthropology got going as a discipline, scholars gathered materials from these very groups. Anthropology became a recognized academic discipline in the 1890s. The first department of anthropology was established by the University of California in 1902, and the first course pertained to North American ethnology. The use of the word “primitive” in the title of this book has no derogatory implications whatsoever. “Primitive” does not mean “inferior,” but is derived from the Latin primitivus, meaning “Of or belonging to the first age, period, or stage.” It connotes traits that are simple, fundamental, and of ancient origins, unadulterated by exposure to trends of the industrialized world. “Modern” is also a controversial term, but I use it to refer to industrialized cultures and, to some degree, a materialistic, mechanistic, unnatural, highly commercialized and dehumanized pattern of living. The anthropologist is bound to consider to what extent, if any, the primitive mind differs from the modern mind or is somewhat similar. In this book we will explore the fundamental complexities of human cultures, often replete with rich organization, resilient traditions, clarity of roles and taboos, dynamic interdependence on the natural environment, and the idea that all beings exist in relation to one another. A fundamental principle in anthropology is that cultures should be studied as a whole, and that customs and beliefs can be properly understood only in the context in which they operate. This does not arbitrarily carve out from human culture a segment such as the economy, political systems, law, personality structure, or social relations, but rather focuses on human societies as an interrelated whole. Cultural anthropology seeks to describe and explain the variety of behaviors, customs and beliefs among people of the world, their forms of social organization, the manifold connections between various aspects of human life, and the shared ways of doing, thinking and making things. As we will see throughout this book, characteristics that seem to be most rigorous and distinctive in these cultures are, in many ways, found in the same thought processes and motivations of people in developed cultures. Perhaps the greatest lesson driven home by modern anthropology is the remarkable adaptability of human beings as revealed through the enormous diversity of behavior that anthropologists have discovered among cultures of the world. This book seeks to instill respect for the belief systems of other cultures. We might disagree with what other people regard as “science,” and find their logic to be perplexing, but when we put aside our cultural prejudices and try to understand these beliefs and practices from the perspective of those who engage in them-we can gain new insights about our own practices. Anthropology is of interest because human nature is of interest. Human nature is expressed in fundamentally similar patterns throughout the ages. We see, for instance in Old Testament literature, that human beings display a stream of emotions and tendencies then as they do now-envy, anger, treachery, warlike tendencies, greed, love, lust, hate, cooperation, courage, faith, doubt, generosity, and so on. In the best of circumstances it is impossible to put together a completely representative book about cultural anthropology, given the ever-changing patterns of culture. Though there is a great deal of continuity and stability within cultures from generation to generation, there is no such thing as unchanging traditions. Cultures are subject to constant change by such factors as invention, outside contact, and adaptive drift from within. In an era of
ii
globalization and shrinking borders, even isolated pockets of civilization are subject to an adaptive drift. Thus, cultures are not viewed in a static social equilibrium, but are conceived as a dynamic phenomenon. Anthropology not only explores phenomena such as magic, witchcraft, divination, ritual and ceremony, but a vast array of beliefs that often overlap with our own. Healing practices, for instance, are universal among cultures, and while modern Western medicine has made many strides toward curing disease, a majority of cultures today rely on shamans, witch-doctors and folk healers to diagnose and heal illness. Magic is relied upon in many cultures to produce rain, to overcome one’s enemies, to insure victory in battle, to cause pregnancy, to find lost objects, to prevent or cure sickness, to assure an abundant supply of food, to ward off evil omens, and so on. There are parallel belief systems in modern cultures, as discussed in this book. We will examine how people interact with others, trade, deal with conflicts, organize ceremonies, use rituals and symbols, adapt myths to suit current trends, and we will explore their practices concerning child rearing, the treatment of women, conflict and death, status and wealth, altered states of consciousness, the evil eye, magical powers, healing, witchcraft, hunting and gathering, how peoples cope with death, and other patterns of culture. It has become more important than ever to respect and understand different points of view without being so certain that our own perspective is “right,” while others are “wrong.” The tendency towards ethnocentric attitudes is pervasive in the world. In principle, there is no reason why our own beliefs should be viewed as superior to those of other cultures. Cultural relativism goes hand in hand with a study of anthropology-for from the perspective of each group of people, what is “good” or “bad” may be uniquely different from the next one. At the same time, as brought out in this book, there are certain basic values recognized by all people, suggesting a fundamental uniformity in moral principles—however, differently they may be expressed from culture to culture. In this book we will discover that different values have common cores. Today, the various cultures of the world are of interest to everyone, not only because the behavior of almost any society may have important ramifications in world affairs, but because we can now easily visit distant and formerly inaccessible places, we can develop friendships across the world (at least in cyberspace), and a great many people immigrate to live and work in cultures that have different customs and traditions than learned in their homeland. I have tried to avoid writing a “technical” book so as to engage undergraduate college students studying the social sciences, as well as general readership (“armchair anthropologists”), because I think it is important to present a broad cultural dimension in an accessible format in an age where the world is growing smaller and smaller. This book presents a systematic attempt to introduce, analyze and formulate precise concepts and clear definitions into the subject. This book is intended to make a contribution to our understanding of how various people carry on their lives and solve daily problems, and seeks to evoke the imagination of the reader to instill a genuine appreciation of cultural diversity. Anthropology has so many aspects, its roots and branches penetrate so profusely into the fabric of society, that it is difficult to study anthropology in its entirety. Anthropology today is not just of academic interest. There are numerous fields that have opened up to anthropologists in recent years, with anthropologists working for municipal, state and federal governments. Anthropologists are hired to analyze government data, track population growth, determine the sources of gang warfare, understand traffic patterns, migration patterns, demographic information, and so on. Anthropologists are called upon as expert witnesses in various court proceedings to help the jury understand the motivations behind certain conduct. The military hires anthropologists to help analyze intelligence data and help understand customs of foreign cultures. Anthropologists are hired to help analyze differences between national cultures and regional, ethnic subcultures, and to help formulate organizational as well as international policy. Business anthropology is a growing field: Almost every large company has anthropologists on staff to conduct qualitative research on employee relations, to study work processes so as to help promote greater efficiency, to study
iii
consumer behavior, organizational change, sex differences in the workplace, and to help formulate ways to adjust business practices in foreign markets. In short, the reader should find the information in this book accessible and helpful in understanding the social movements and concerns that so many cultures are confronted with in the midst of globalization.
John Alan Cohan Western State Law School USA
PART I: PRIMITIVE SOCIETIES AND CULTURAL FRAMEWORKS
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man, 2010, 01-21
1
CHAPTER 1 Why Study Primitive Cultures? Abstract. In this chapter we discuss a number of interlinked topics about what we can gain from a study of primitive cultures. What are their patterns of behavior or ways of thinking about life? A principle theme is that the modern mind is fundamentally primitive. We will compare the “primitive” world view with our “modern” counterpart, and come to understand the fundamental richness of primitive cultures. Explanation of the term “primitive.” Primitive mentality sheds light on how our minds work. Many of the practices are still current and can help us understand our own, parallel patterns of living. Discussion of what is meant by “culture,” and “human nature.” Discussion of prevalence of communal lifestyle and social cooperation, conformity to norms, non-market economies, food-sharing, ancestral worship, social atomism of some primitive cultures (i.e., lack of central leadership), prevalence of custom over law, reliance on myths and magical thinking, animistic connection to the environment. We will discuss the trend toward acculturation, the tendency of some indigenous populations to exist side-by-side with the dominant culture, the tension between the pressure to adopt new customs and the pull to retain the old. The desire to resist assimilation into the dominant group, and the inevitability of cultures changing within themselves. We will discuss the downside of acculturation: colonial imperialism, imposition of paternalistic laws outlawing traditional practices, dispossession of lands, deprivation of political power, resettlement, resulting in a demoralized population, trend of making amends for mistreatment of indigenous people in the past. We will discuss the prevalence of nativistic movements to revive and preserve traditional cultural practices.
WHAT WE CAN GAIN FROM A STUDY OF PRIMITIVE CULTURES One of the best ways to understand ourselves is to understand other people. What are the customs and traditions that others hold dear to their hearts? What are their patterns of behavior or ways of thinking about life? What sort of meaning, wisdom, power and other gifts do people preserve in their culture? We can better understand ourselves by a “detour” to other cultures, even if we don’t care to adopt strange patterns of behavior or ways of thinking. At first blush, the way people of other cultures carry on their lives may stand in stark contrast to our “modern” ways. One of the main aims of anthropologists is to discover parallels between primitive lifestyles and our own “modern” way of life. Anthropologists are attracted to this discipline in part because “The opportunity to document, study, and gain insight first hand, from living tradition, is momentous” (Howard, 2002, p. 62). In this book I will compare the “primitive” world view with our “modern” counterpart, and show how we can gain a deeper perspective of our own processes by studying people with different world views than our own. As we will see, despite the apparent contrasts, in many respects there is not really a very wide gulf between primitive and modern ways of thinking. Often enough, we in modern cultures feel a peculiar nostalgia for the richness of simpler, primitive lifestyles. We frequently hear of people who want to replace their lifestyle with something basic and more authentically human. To “downsize” or “return to the sources” seem to be popular new maxims. From the experiences of primitive cultures we can rediscover an inner reality that resonates with new patterns in the industrial world. For instance, many indigenous people have a harmonious, reverential relationship with the natural world around them, and this is something that modern environmentalists find to be a comforting ideal. They tend to see unity in the world of nature, and are quick to discern traces of the sacred everywhere about them. Their cosmology embraces a connection to spirits of the land and ancestors. Perhaps somewhat romanticized, but with some measure of truth, primitive people tend to be happy and for the most part live idyllic lives. Their lives are often (but not always) free of stress or worry, despite a paucity of creature comforts. This was observed particularly in the South Pacific by early explorers reporting of the “natural happiness John Alan Cohan All rights reserved - © 2010 Bentham Science Publishers Ltd.
2 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
and utmost sexual freedom” (Ellenberger, 1970, p. 183) of the natives of Tahiti. To some degree, as we will see, acculturation has pulled the rug from underneath otherwise carefree lifestyles. For instance, in many cases the younger generation has found satisfaction in seeking higher education and working in urban centers in a variety of jobs ranging from day laborers to government bureaucrats. When returning to their ancestral villages there can be a palpable tension with the older generation regarding native customs and the authority of elders. As we come to understand the fundamental richness of primitive cultures, as we take in the complexities of human behavior and allow for diverse perceptions, we can better understand our own inner processes. We can also learn and appreciate that the Western mind are not the only valid approach to experiencing the world. THE MODERN MIND IS FUNDAMENTALLY PRIMITIVE Are you sometimes surprised to find a “savage” nature within yourself? Do you point the finger in dismay at “brutes” in society who commit unspeakably vile acts? The fact is, the “savage” nature sometimes associated with primitives is inside each of us. According to Lucas and Barrett (1995), the primitive mind is a primal force within ourselves. As a presence within the Western self, the primitive may be either an instinctual disordering force which erupts as violence or madness, or alternatively, a wellspring of order which places us in harmonious and healthy touch with nature and our “true selves.” (p. 290) Primitive mentality sheds light on how our minds work. Do all minds function in the same manner, or do primitives have “different” mental processes? At first, it appears that the difference between the primitive, prelogical mind, and the modern mind is great and far-reaching. But as we will see, within this world of difference there is a natural similarity, perhaps most notably in such areas as collective emotion. As stated by Swift (1926): Primitive mentality was probably not essentially different, however, from modern mentality. It was dominated by collective emotion. It is largely so today. Primitive consciousness was group consciousness. It remains very largely so today. The conditions of primitive living required unity of feeling and action in the group as the common method. We, also, speak much of the values of cooperation. And we show by our persistent lapses into primitive emotionalism how near modern life is to the primitive. (p. 539) Indeed, much of modern mentality is dominated by “persistent lapses into primitive emotionalism.” Collective emotions, particularly in times of great stress, show that we have a strong “group consciousness,” as do the primitives. Often the greatest moments in an individual’s life are those that come with common experiences and unity of feeling in groups. According to Jung (1933), civilized human beings display a range of “archaic processes,” and not merely in the form of sporadic “throw-backs” from the level of modern social life. On the contrary, every civilized human being, whatever his conscious development, is still an archaic man at the deeper levels of his psyche. Just as the human body connects us with the mammals and displays numerous relics of earlier evolutionary stages going back even to the reptilian age, so the human psyche is likewise a product of evolution which, when followed up to its origins, shows countless archaic traits. (p. 144) Jung claims that all people share basically the same human world view comprised of the archetypes and the collective unconscious, and this is evidenced by the universal belief in spirits. The belief in spirits-disembodied intelligences that interact with humans-is not only a hallmark of primitive cultures, but is common in highly civilized cultures. Spirits are good or bad, some spirits heal, others do harm, some are wise, others are fools. Spirits are thought to be a force field, concentrated vibrations that exist in a nonphysical domain. They might be equivalent to the soul of people who have died, and retain the personality, knowledge, and motivations of the person who has died. In Christian thought, these souls occupy a spiritual place known as limbo (or purgatory), heaven or hell. These spirits may want to communicate with us on the material plane. Some have tasks that they may wish to complete; some may wish to do harm; others may wish to communicate messages to loved ones.
Introduction
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 3
We all know that as children we talked with spirits or entities that our parents couldn’t see or hear, that we had meaningful interactions with imaginary playmates that were real in our minds, and so on. And for the most part people in modern cultures believe in God, and that entails belief in the spirit realm. The belief in spirits is a recurring theme not only in primitive cultures but is pervasive across cultures from biblical times to the present. It seems to be something hard-wired in human beings. WHY THE TERM, “PRIMITIVE”? There are still nooks and crannies of the world in which people live just as primitively as they did thousands of years ago. We might refer to them as aboriginals, indigenous people, or natives, whether they occupy the hinterlands of Papua New Guinea, rugged regions of Australia, remote islands of the Pacific, Arctic regions, the tundra of North America, the equatorial villages of Africa, or the forests of South America. Some people are nomadic-their lives consist of wandering through a desert or a forest, foraging for wild vegetables and fruits, and hunting for food, perhaps raising livestock. Yes, we all inhabit the Earth, but there are vastly different sorts of environments that people live in. Some groups find themselves in an environment where survival is relatively easy, as in the islands of the Pacific with abundant fruit trees and easy fishing, while for those who live in the Arctic Circle, survival is a constant challenge, and death by starvation not uncommon. When you think of “primitive,” what comes to mind? Anthropologists who studied diverse cultures early in the 20th century started using the term “primitive” in a derogatory sense, implying an inferior, uncivilized, wild people living in isolated pockets of populations. In my usage, the term “primitive” does not mean “inferior,” and is hardly intended in a derogatory sense. The Oxford English Dictionary (Murray, Bradley, Craigie, & Onions, 1989), defines the word as follows: “first or earliest of its kind”; “of or belonging to the first age, period, or stage; “pertaining to early times”; “applied to behaviour or mental processes that apparently originate in unconscious needs or desires and have not been affected by objective logical reasoning”; and as applied in anthropology, a trait that pertains “to a group, or to persons comprising such groups, whose culture, through isolation, has remained at a simple level of social and economic organization.” (vol. XII, pp. 483-484) In addition, “primitive” is a term used to describe modern art of a certain genre; and “primitive” is used to describe certain elegant mathematical formulas. The term “primitive” seems appropriate because many of the traits we will discuss are simple, fundamental, and of ancient origins, unadulterated by exposure to trends of the industrialized world. I use this term because it seems to best contrast with the term “modern,” which often is associated with industrialized cultures and to many conjures up a materialistic, mechanistic, unnatural, highly commercialized and dehumanized patterns of living. Often enough, primitive people are indigenous or original people in a particular area. Many of these cultures predate Christianity, and some were well underway before Egyptian dynastic times. It is estimated that there are at least 300 million indigenous people living in about 75 countries of the world, “from the Maori of New Zealand to the U’wa of Columbia to pastoral nomads in the mountains of Afghanistan” (Cohan, 2001/2002, p. 136). However, not all indigenous people are “primitive,” and in fact many, such as Native Americans and Australian aboriginals, have become almost entirely acculturated to “modern” lifestyles, with the inevitable erosion of cultural traditions. True primitive people tend to be socially isolated from the dominant culture, and usually preserve their traditional way of life, despite pressures by the dominant culture. Primitives, as indigenous people, are those people and groups descended from original populations of a given country. Most definitions agree that indigenous peoples descend from pre-colonial inhabitants, that they have a close connection to traditional lands and other natural resources, and that they maintain a strong sense of cultural, social, economic and linguistic identity. Indigenous peoples include native peoples, tribal peoples, aboriginals, and “first nations” (Cohan, 2001/2002, p. 136).
4 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
And, as indigenous people, primitives share the following traits: (1) close attachment to ancestral territories and natural resources; (2) self-identification and identification by others as members of a distinct cultural group; (3) possession of an indigenous language, which is often distinct from a national language; (4) presence of customary social or political institutions; and (5) subsistence-oriented production systems (Cohan, 2001/2002, p. 136). Some of the practices discussed in this book ended decades ago (e.g., cannibalism); others more recently, but many of the practices are still current and, as we will see, can help us understand our own, parallel patterns of living. We will examine how people interact with others, trade, deal with conflicts, organize ceremonies, use rituals and symbols, adapt their myths to suit current trends, and explore their practices concerning healing, witchcraft, hunting and gathering, and how they cope with death. THE MEANING OF “CULTURE” In this book we will be examining primitive cultures of the world in a quest for understanding some of our own inner processes. But just what is meant by the word “culture”? “Culture” comes from the root that has to do with cultivating a plant or crop. Fundamentally, a culture consists of a society of people who cultivate various skills such that they can harness nature to produce plants or crops. While defined in different ways, sometimes ambiguously, I find the following passage of Seagall (1990) to be helpful. [Culture] includes the products of the behavior of others, especially others who preceded us. It connotes a set of social stimuli that to a very great extent have existence prior to us. Put very simply, culture is already there for all of us as we begin life. It contains values that will be expressed and a language in which to express them.... Culture also includes language, music, and art forms. It includes preferences, appetites, and aversions. It includes rules, norms, and standards. It includes hopes and fears, beliefs and attitudes, convictions and doubts, at least to the extent that such are shared, inculcated, and transmitted from people to people. To be considered part of culture, anything, material or symbolic, need only be of human origin (pp. 26-27). A culture consists of a uniform system of beliefs, values and behavior patterns common among a people. According to Piggott (1954), culture defines “the collective and tangible outcome (pot-making, house-planning, tomb-building) of the material and spiritual traditions of a group of people” (p. 123). Culture implies a state in which there is the training, development and refinement of mind, tastes and manners, and thus culture applies to societies that have advanced beyond a state of nature (see discussion below). All cultures have some system of morals, religion, marriage, and government. Culture does not have to be “high” culture. Humans such as those who lived in the Paleolithic era of France as early as 500,000 B.C., and which left evidence of tools, hunting implements, and pottery, had a “culture.” Culture can apply to all manner of civilization, from the notorious cannibalistic Salomon Islanders, to the ancient Greeks or Egyptians at their height. HUMAN NATURE Insights from primitive cultures helps shed light on human nature writ large. An inquiry into human nature involves such questions as: What are we like as human beings? What actions are we capable of? What motivates us? How do we deal with life issues such as gathering food, raising children, trading or bartering, betrothal, marriage, death, curing of illness, worshiping of gods? How do we deal with emotions, aggression, and with conflicts? In our quest to learn about primitive cultures we will see patterns that are also evident in modern cultures, albeit in different ways. We might say there are core principles, some inherent propensities that make up human nature, that pertain to all of us. While there are many common features of human nature, the expression of these elements may vary from culture to culture. For instance, the belief in supernatural spirits is universal among cultures-though the
Introduction
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 5
type of spiritual entity varies among cultures-from the belief in angels and demons, to communion with the dead, spirits of the forest, of the river, and other beliefs we will explore. The environment in which we each develop has a unique differential. Human nature is not something that can be considered in a vacuum. Certain innate dispositions may be actualized, triggered or suppressed, depending on environmental factors and social contexts. No one growing up in the world is totally shaped by one’s genes. The circumstances in which we are born, the norms that are inculcated from infancy onwards, the need to belong, to be accepted by others, and other factors all play their part in how human nature expresses itself. One of the main themes of this book is that human nature is fundamentally the same for all of us, so that differences among social norms, rules customs and beliefs are more apparent than real. FROM STATE OF NATURE TO SOCIAL COOPERATION A great many people today and in the recent past, live for the most part in a state of nature, as defined below. Many of these people revere the fact that they live in a state of nature. Others have moved out of a state of nature and settled in villages that straddle both worlds, adopting some modern conveniences, while preserving simple and natural conditions in their daily lives. And of course, in modern cultures many of us long to return to a state of nature-hence the popularity of summer camping trips in the forest, of visits to state parks, and the fascination people have with nature documentaries. By “state of nature” I mean circumstances of living in the wilderness, in relatively pristine, insulated conditions, with little or no contact with “civilization.” Sometimes it is the case, particularly with nomads and indigenous people who have for centuries occupied wilderness areas, that the people live much the same way as people did in prehistoric times. In prehistoric times, according to Hobbes (1651/1946) and other theorists, primitive human beings were simply biological machines moved by appetites and aversions, ruled by various passions and impulses, somewhat animalike. In a state of nature, the situation was kill or be killed. Others cannot be trusted, and one should look superior or else one will be perceived as weak. If a conflict occurred in a state of nature, it was resolved by recourse to violence: And therefore if any two men desire the same thing, which nevertheless they cannot both enjoy, they become enemies; and in the way to their end... endeavour to destroy one another. (ch. 13, para. 13.3) Hobbes coined the term homo homini lupus: man is a wolf to his fellow man-suggesting that human beings are vicious and destructive by nature. In the Hobbesian state of nature, there were no values, norms or laws, no contracts or agreements, and no duties. People just did whatever they wanted. People struggled with one another for control over goods needed for survival. There was no such thing as “justice.” Hobbes says that this state was solitary, brutish, nasty and short. In a state of nature reason may have served only a calculating function, to judge and to foresee various available courses of action and their consequences, but did not provide us with a separate motive to act. At a certain point in our development it must have become obvious that it would be collectively self-defeating for people to continue functioning purely from a dog-eat-dog mentality. In the wilderness people started living in groups, and some sort of cooperation was needed to facilitate joint action for the survival of the whole group. Instead of a dog-eat-dog mentality, when we step into social structures we are better off if we control our passions, promote cooperation, tolerate others, and respond to and respect each other’s desires. The idea of social cooperation is often part of what the dominant culture tries to convey when it seeks to acculturate primitive populations. Well-intended government programs seek to “help” the natives come into the “modern age”
6 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
for their own good-so as to enjoy modern health care, formal education for their children, sustainable crop production, and so forth. But as we will see, often enough indigenous people are perfectly happy with their traditional way of life and do not want to have the rug pulled from under them. Today, primitive populations that have little or no contact with “civilization,” nonetheless have rules of social cooperation that contribute to the survival of its members. Even “the simplest hunters already possess a full-fledged moral system, which in specific respects comes closer to our own than that of intermediate peoples” (Lowie, 1941, p. 244). Every primitive culture has its own range of acceptable and unacceptable ways of doing things. Children have to be produced, fed, sheltered and trained. There has to be a system of exchange for goods and services. People operate within a set of laws, norms, duties and customs, and have some method of meting out justice for deviation from those norms. There has to be some mechanism for the settlement of disputes. And so on. These objectives are handled in different ways, as we will see throughout this book. The values people share and the rules they live by may be completely different from what we in modern cultures deem normative. Often there will be self-help approaches to mete out justice for the violation of laws, customs and morals-approaches such as witchcraft, sorcery, or revenge killing, for instance. Until recently many primitive cultures engaged in practices that we would regard as somewhat barbaric-such as head-hunting, cannibalism, and suttee (the sacrifice of widows). COMMUNAL LIFESTYLE, COLLECTIVE INTERDEPENDENCE Rousseau spoke of the “noble savage” that lived in ancient times, when life was dominated by collective emotion and group activity, excluding all individuality. “The significant experiences of primitive man were common experiences. Living, though it be largely mere existence, might be good because it was a shared living, a common life” (Swift, 1926, p. 539). Further, in primitive cultures, The bond of unity was produced through ritual and ceremony. It was a common life, in which all shared and shared for the most part alike. It was the earliest and perhaps the most sincere social democracy. Individuals were “members one of another.” It was this by necessity, for only thus could they live at all. To deny that “I am my brother’s keeper,” easy and common enough nowadays, was the greatest of heresies as well as the most inhuman of sentiments (Swift, 1926, p. 540). One of the most enduring traits of primitive cultures is the tendency to a communal lifestyle in which group support and interdependence are key. These elements are deemed necessary for survival. For primitives a key theme of living is “I am my brother’s keeper.” There is a “we-ness” in these cultures. The collective takes precedence over the individual, that is, the people tend to have “lowered ego boundaries” (Kiev, 1972, p. 50). There is an emphasis on groupthink, on conformity, on cooperation, as opposed to individuality. In Western cultures, in contrast, the underlying ground of being, as portrayed on TV talk shows and sitcoms, is one of expressive individualism. We shun dependency, and the ideal goal of mature adults is to be an autonomously functioning individual. “We measure our individual worth in terms of competitive achievements, material wealth, power, and control”(Kirmayer, 2007, p. 250). Of course, many of us, particularly in work settings, at least unconsciously subscribe to groupthink mentality. And as is well known, teenagers are especially vulnerable to peer pressure to conform to the means and ways of the “in” group, or else suffer as a social outcast. In primitive cultures, people’s lives are structured from early childhood around collective solidarity. There is an emphasis on fellowship, on shared activities. Ceremonial gatherings are part and parcel of social life. People have no individuality as such, but are members of their family, clan and tribe. People in primitive cultures tend to have much stronger and extended kinship ties than people in modern cultures, a matter that we will see in different contexts throughout this book. All the members of a family, for instance, are
Introduction
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 7
responsible for the debt of one of them. Revenge for murder may be exacted against any member of the murderer’s family or clan. In Papua New Guinea, upon harvesting taro from one’s garden, the produce will be given to every person in the clan. This is not for the purpose of “bragging” for being a successful gardener and a good provider to one’s family, but is a way of life expected of every fully participating adult male. Sharing of one’s bounty is a means of avoiding envy, ill will, and the evil eye-revenge in the form of sorcery (see chapter 9, “Envy and the Evil Eye”). People are vigilant to avoid the impression that they are “better off” than others, or that they have accumulated more wealth than others. There is never any boasting. According to Parker (1962), the strong communal nature of the Eskimo is “imposed on them by their physical environment and concomitant food-gathering techniques, such as cooperative hunting from kayaks or the organized caribou drive and hunting for whales” (p. 84). By the way, the word “Eskimo” means “eaters of raw meat,” and was concocted by the Algonquin Indians of eastern Canada, who were neighbors. Today the Eskimos usually prefer to be referred by their own term, “Inuit,” which means “real people.” It is customary for food to be shared, especially if resources are scarce. As long as some members of the community have little to eat, the others are obliged to share their resources. Elaborate rules exist for dividing up the product of a hunt among the individuals who participate in the catch. Although the winter supplies of the Caribou Eskimos ordinarily belong to the families that store them, in time of scarcity anyone who is hungry may simply take from the others’ meat cache without being considered a thief. (Parker, 1962, p. 84) Food-sharing is common in many other cultures. According to French (2002), the Melanesians “in general put a great deal of themselves into producing food and may even feel that the spirits of their ancestors permeate the food that is produced on ancestral land or with the ancestors’ magical assistance,” so, “people may regard sharing food as creating a bond of bodily and spiritual substance. The obligation to share is part of kinship in Melanesia, but-in a way-sharing food also makes people kin” (p. 40). The communal lifestyle also finds its expression in hunting rituals: “The lone Eskimo hunter of Baffin Land and Hudson Bay is sometimes not permitted to eat his catch until he finds company. Among the Unalit of Alaska, the first large game killed by a young hunter is divided and consumed by the villagers ‘without leaving a particle for the young hunter’” (Parker, 1962, p. 84, quoting Nelson). There is a peculiar idea in parts of the world that to catch sight of something confers a sort of right to it. Among the Wodani of Irian Jaya, for instance, a man who sees another man eating a sweet potato can grab it from his hands without explanation. To see a piece of fruit in another’s garden entitles one to take it. In their language the verb “to see” means “to find again,” and expresses the idea of placing something under one’s control (Breton, 2000, p. 569). A kind of food sharing exists in Mexican villages. When someone drops by it is imperative to offer the guest something to eat, and it is equally imperative to accept the invitation. This food and drink exchange is especially important between friends and neighbors. Also in Mexican villages we see a kind of dyadic contractual relationship between people. This custom involves people extending courtesies to each other in a more or less balanced reciprocity, whether providing money, food, accompanying others on errands, or other exchanges that are accepted without question by all villagers (Foster, 1961). The exchange is different from “gifts.” Rather, it is a quid pro quo that simultaneously repays a past debt and incurs a future obligation, and reaffirms the contractual “relationship” between the parties. This dyadic system is different from the “personalismo” or “personalism” relationship in Latin America in which the parties distrust the system and rely on personal ties. And it is different qualitatively from friendships in that there is an ongoing exchange of goods and services, while friends do not ordinarily form this kind of obligation.
8 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
As long as a person continues to give and to receive from a partner, he is assured that the particular relationship is in good order. In modern society, while we often feel proud that we are “free from” traditional and group constraints, we also tend to be estranged from one another. Living becomes an individual problem, perhaps shared with one’s immediate family and friends. “[T]he emphasis is placed on individual initiative, individual responsibility, and technology replaces ritualism” (Swift, 1926, p. 539). Still, despite the vogue for independent lifestyles, the value of cooperation, of a common method of going at things, cannot be denied. In global politics the idea of consensus is the hallmark of such organizations as the United Nations, and in national politics people of all stripes extoll the virtues of seeking “bipartisan” cooperation. And often, in the midst of crisis or calamity, with globalization and instant communication, we see a primitive-like wave of collective emotion permeating the planet. The 9/11 terrorist attacks is an example of how modern cultures can express a kind of group consciousness. In many other situations people in urban centers will erupt with collective outbursts in response to highly charged situations, even rioting-e.g., as masses of people did in Pakistan on the assassination of former prime minister Benazir Bhutto in December, 2007. And in urban centers throughout the world, we often yearn for a connectedness to a greater whole, as seen in peaceful protests, political rallies, in sports and concert audiences, and in other collective group experiences. We lose a sense of individuality, or separation, or alienation, and our personal identity merges with the group identity. But unlike primitives, when we return to our cars and drive home we lose a sense of being part of the collective and return to our individual world. These occasions show that collective consciousness is a human phenomenon that intersects across cultures. NON-MARKET ECONOMIES Many people live in what is known as a non-market economy. That is, people do not buy or sell goods, services or land. Rather, most things of value are produced and distributed according to certain customs, often to do with communal sharing. Instead of the standard market principles in which things are bought or sold, things are distributed and reciprocated as expressions of kinship right or tribal affiliation. This usually goes hand-in-hand with subsistence economies whereby people are able to sustain themselves on their own agricultural endeavors as well as hunting and gathering. In these economies there is a “we” consciousness, a communal-type sharing of the bounty of the Earth, as we noted above, where no one’s livelihood depends on producing things for sale. And in subsistence cultures, while some people might occasionally sell their produce in the marketplace, one’s “success” in the marketplace does not “trickle” down, and market profits don’t help or hinder one’s wellbeing. Indeed, commercial success will usually be frowned upon, viewed with suspicion, and will subject the individual to all sorts of gossip, not to mention the evil eye. What a contrast to life in the big city! Imagine telling someone in a job interview that you frown upon commercial success! But the truth is that even our modern economy has its roots in the barter system. Before the time that the governments started to coin money, the economic survival of people depended precisely on the same type of sharing and exchange as we still see operative in many primitive cultures. In many cultures certain things can be traded only for certain other things: e.g., fish traded for vegetables, certain types of shelled necklaces for certain types of shells or bracelets. People in some cultures, such as in the highlands of Borneo, have a mixed economy. They will utilize currency and are paid in currency if they work, say, at a resort or as a laborer-but for many things they still rely on traditional exchange methods as well. SOCIAL ATOMISM OF SOME PRIMITIVE CULTURES Few people live in groups that are entirely self-sufficient. For most, it is important to have interaction with other social groups, to trade with them, to exchange wives with them, to establish alliances for mutual defense against
Introduction
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 9
enemies. While most primitive cultures tend to be interdependent in lifestyle, there is an opposite tendency that sometimes comes into play. Anthropologists use the term “atomistic” to refer to groups that have little or no social integration or centralization. While these groups retain certain elements of collective living-most notably the sharing of food-we see, particularly in nomadic groups, a kind of leaderlessness and lack of central authority characteristic of atomism. In atomistic cultures there is no formal tribal organization, no institutionalized penal sanctions, no juridical procedures-and no official or central authority to punish crime or settle disputes. Political authority of the chief or elders is weak. There are few mechanisms for reinforcing group social solidarity beyond the individual family unit. In these groups it is not uncommon for family units to break away and live apart from the larger community of which they are a part. In contrast to communal groups, there is little or no economic cooperation outside the family unit: no communal hunting, no sharing of food, and the motto seems more like what Hobbes described for the prehistoric state of nature: Every man is for himself and his own family. The rougher the state of nature that people find themselves in, the more likely the culture will be atomistic. But atomism is also found in some agricultural cultures. Atomistic cultures tend to be those that live in groups that are somewhat isolated from one another, so that it is impossible to know what is going on with the other groups. This is particularly the case with nomadic tribes, such as the Bedouin in the Middle East. Their continuous mobility makes it the case that they do not identify with any particular place, and it is difficult for them to develop a community with political leadership. (See chapter 25, “Nomadic Peoples: A Case Study of the Batek People of Malaysia.”) There is no paramount chief or territorial “center” at which leaders of smaller groups, if there are any, might call the people to assemble for meetings. At the same time the people have a strong sense of unity within because all the people are named after their foundational ancestor, and thus they have kindred feeling towards one another. Actually, we might say that the Bedouins are semi-atomistic, since the people within each tribe and among other tribes are mutually dependent for their survival. Their livelihood depends on free access to pastures, and networks of personal relationships help to coordinate moves based on pasture and water sources. Despite the lack of leadership, there is a kind of loose tribal confederation. Sometimes a pasture will be shared by several tribes, each regarding it as its own territory, based on a kind of priority right. At times the Bedouin, under pressures of hostile neighbors, are compelled to organize leadership, and political association with other tribes, to negotiate with and defend against their enemies (Marx, 1977). According to Turnbill (1961), for the Mbuti Pygmies of the Ituri forest in Zaire, the forest serves as a kind of moral leader: If you ask a Pygmy why his people have no chiefs, no lawgivers, no councils, or no leaders, he will answer with misleading simplicity, “Because we are the people of the of forest.” The forest, the great provider, is the one standard by which all deeds and thoughts are judged; it is the chief, the lawgiver, the leader, and the final arbitrator (p. 125). If the forest were displeased with the people, “it might punish them by causing storms, trees to fall, ill health, and poor hunting” (Edgerton, 1985, p. 133). The forest would be displeased if the people got into disputes or exhibited, laziness, aggressiveness, or disputatiousness, but any conflict that threatened harmony and, therefore, economic cooperation was dangerous. If the forest was to remain beneficent, the Mbuti believed, they had to avoid conflict... and restore peace and harmony as rapidly as possible. (Edgerton, 1985, pp. 133-134) The harsh climate of the Arctic tends to lend itself towards atomism in numerous hunting-gathering groups: In the physical world of the Arctic, hazards include treacherous weather and deceptive landscapes. Wind and temperature continually alter travel conditions; ice can break up under one’s feet and the ground
10 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
disappear altogether in a “whiteout” caused by blowing snow. The markers one needs to find one’s way are subtle and complex, and the appearance of the land changes radically from season to season, by day and by night, when the moon is present and when it is not.... [Even today in emergency situations] one must figure out how to melt water when there is neither fire nor fuel, how to dry caribou hides when there is neither sun nor warmth, and how to open a 45-gallon oil drum without tools. (Briggs, 1991, p. 260) Ecological conditions of the Arctic favor, if not require, dispersal into small settlements. These smaller groups tend to be atomistic in that they do not usually have a “leader.” Today, many Inuits of the Arctic region live in modern camps, so that the perils of harsh winters, food shortages and death by starvation are not what they were in the past (Briggs, 1991). The people are still known for their love of solitude and still are uncomfortable if they have to be in camp at the trading post crowds. Many very old people wish to and do live alone in the wilderness. In the past, because of the difficulty of life, when people got old and unable to take care of themselves, people would kill them, more or less by tacit agreement or custom. The son would kill his father by strangulation or some other quick means (Speck, 1933). Samoa is another culture in which atomism has prevailed. No centralized political authority was possible on the local or the supra-local level because of the nature of their kinship structure. In Samoa most people are members of several descent groups known as septs, and people can freely transfer residence from one of these to another, as long as one provides labor and observes local customs. Only members of the particular sept can live at a given location. Each sept has a particular area of land, and a local chief. Groups of septs live together in villages. Until recent decades social atomism among these people was evident when villages banded together for temporary purposes such as war: no one was accorded anything like “general” command authority. Moreover, local chiefs had little authority because decisions tended to be made by village councils and had to be unanimous in order to elicit concerted action by the village as a whole. And whenever a council of chiefs from several villages was convened, decisions had to be unanimous or else in order to have binding effect. As mentioned, atomism is more the exception than the rule in primitive cultures. In contrast to communal structures, the people tend to have multiple and autonomous divisions, each more or less self-contained, and to the extent there are chiefs, their authority is limited by the requirement of unanimous consent among the people. We will see more of this in our discussion of the Batek people of Malaysia in chapter 25, where decisionmakingsuch as when to pick up camp and move elsewhere-is spontaneous and unanimous. At the same time, none of these groups can entirely escape from communal traits such as food-sharing, particularly in time of need. CUSTOMARY LAW OR PUBLIC OPINION LAW In primitive cultures there usually are no written laws or constitution. Rather, there are unwritten rules, customs and morals that delineate the rights and duties of everyone, and which are regarded as binding upon the people. These rules are what everyone agrees to be customary norms of carrying on, and the basis for these rules is, if nothing else, public opinion, which in effect carries the weight of law. These norms are referred to as customary law, or “public opinion law” (Lips, 1937). One cannot underestimate the importance of public opinion-of the collective will of the community-in these cultures. What other people say about you has great importance. How one appears in the eyes of one’s peers is of supreme importance. Public shame is a powerful social control. Lowie (1947) found the following: Among the Crow personal brawls are looked upon with contempt, and a man will not readily imperil his social position and invite the public derision of his joking-relatives by engaging in fisticuffs with a fellow-tribesman. To become the laughing-stock of his daily associates for minor misdemeanors and to be completely ostracized for graver offenses are terrific punishments for the native and they have a deterrent force of which the infliction of penalties in our sense is often quite devoid (p. 398).
Introduction
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 11
To suffer disapproval or shame is the gravest indignity in these cultures, and nothing is more powerful a motivator to conform to norms than public opinion. (For a discussion on “saving face” and the importance of public opinion in these cultures, see chapter 18, “Status, Prestige, Recognition-the Need for Social Approval.”) For the Montagnais-Naskapi Indians of Labrador, the main “legal” principal has been that of mutual assistance. Bad luck in hunting, sickness, or unfavorable weather meant possible starvation-unless one is in good standing with one’s neighbors. The attitude of the community towards you is important because in time of need you must turn to neighbors or else starve. Habitual troublemakers are ostracized, and this can literally lead to death by starvation in this extremely harsh environment. Their system of public opinion law is preventive rather than punitive for the most part. In the vast woods of Labrador people would put up a “signal post” indicating illness, accident or hunger-set in the snow at the edge of a hunting ground or on a path-pointing to the direction of the tent of the man seeking help, and indicating the distance. One who passes by the signal post will rush to provide aid as soon as possible. The custom of mutual assistance was so strong that even the most hated neighbor or the most bitter enemy would come to to assist upon seeing a signal post. If it became known that anyone maliciously disregarded a signal erected in extreme need, the result would be that he would likewise be disregarded in case of his own need. Another aspect of mutual aid in this culture was that hunting rights could be violated due to necessity. Even beaver rights, which were especially treasured, could be violated if one were really in need. Necessity also permitted one to take food from a food depot of another Indian without asking permission and without paying, although return of what was taken was customary. Customary law among primitive cultures also pertains to offenses that are regarded as sins against supernatural spirits, taboo violations, and behavior that dead ancestors would find offensive. As we will see in chapter 6, “Totemism,” the belief that unseen powers will avenge certain wrongs is a strong motivator to behave properly in many cultures. Throughout this book we will see a variety of ways in which public opinion law, or customary law, manifests. In our modern lives, we can relate to the idea of “customary law” in that a great deal of our behavior is governed by unwritten rules, such as how to treat others with respect, what it means to be kind or polite, how not to step on other peoples’ toes, and things of that sort. If we violate the unwritten rules of society we might not anticipate being punished by the spirits of dead ancestors, but we can expect to suffer social ostracism, gossip, humiliation, loss of reputation and other undesirable consequences. PROXEMICS Proxemics has to do with how we structure space-how close we stand next to others in conversation or in other daily situations such as waiting for our turn at an ATM machine, the extent of eye contact, the loudness of voices, the extent of body contact such as touching, sleeping arrangements in families, and so forth (Hall, 1968). Proxemics also deals with the organization of space in interiors and the layout of towns. The Asian practice of Feng Shui is a wellestablished art of proxemics, involving organizing furniture in one’s home, finding a burial site and agricultural planning-for optimum good luck and blessings from the gods. Different cultures have different customs to do with proxemics. Different proxemics patterns are most noticeable in the spatial distances of social interaction. Americans usually have a lot of space between them while conversing: it is annoying if someone encroaches within that zone. In contrast, in Middle Eastern cultures, in India, and in many other parts of the world people are accustomed to speaking practically “in-your-face.” In all cultures there is a sense of entitlement for the one who first comes into territorial possession of a space. According to Stevens (2003): As with most territorial species, the ‘first come, first served’ principle operates. A man seated in a train compartment has the right to stare at a newcomer without being thought impolite. The interloper recognizes the occupant’s
12 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
territorial rights by asking ‘Is this seat taken?’ or even formally requesting permission to enter and sit. Similar behaviour is to be observed in crowded restaurants. Apparently the territorial ‘rules’ decree that he who occupies a territory first possesses certain inalienable rights which must be uncritically accorded to him: this made possible the building of empires (‘planting the flag’) and the staking out of claims to land in the Far West. (p. 268) People of different cultures have drastically different customs pertaining to touching. In France it is customary for a man to kiss a woman on both cheeks or at least to kiss her hand, when being introduced, while in Arab countries it is against the law for a man and a woman to be caught committing khalwat, or being in close proximity, in public, unless they are married or otherwise related. In some cultures the language has certain limitations in words describing feelings, so that the face may assume a curious expression, and these facial expressions are formalized as part of the language. The same is true of intonation and gesture. For example, among the Kaingang Indians of Brazil feelings and ideas that are expressed easily in other languages are expressed in this culture by means of intonation, changes in pitch, gesture and facial expression (Henry, 1936). As we will see, for the most part in primitive cultures there is very little privacy, people live in closely grouped clusters, and often it is acceptable to trespass on other peoples’ gardens, or visit unannounced. MYSTICAL, MAGICAL MINDS Just what constitutes reality is, of course, a fundamental philosophical question. Both modern science and primitive cultures seek order, regularity and simplicity in the apparent disorder and randomness of nature. Both seek to understand underlying causes so as to provide an explanation of the here and now. But people of primitive cultures tend to perceive the way the world works-the world of causality, space, time and matter-and the contents of their lives, in entirely different ways than we do. What we might judge to be an objective fact-such as an illness being caused by a bacterial infection-will likely be explained by primitives as sorcery, the evil eye, or some other supernatural cause. Primitive people generally have little conception of the future: they live solely in the present and the past, particularly the primeval past. Life in the present is possible only through continual contact with the primeval past. There is a tendency towards mystical perception-something that has been all but lost in modern civilization. By mystical perception I mean that people view things not just as the visual and aural images that come from ordinary sense perception. Rather, the phenomena of perception are viewed as having meaning above and beyond the ordinary. On this point, T. S. Eliot offered this: The mystic properties with which things and beings are imbued form an integral part of the idea to the primitive, who views it as a synthetic whole. It is at a later stage of social evolution that what we call a natural phenomenon tends to become the sole content of perception to the exclusion of the other elements, which then assume the aspect of beliefs, and finally appear superstitious. (as quoted in Harmon, 1976, p. 800) Primitive cultures tend to be extremely animistic, as we will see in some detail in chapter 5 (“Animism”). That is, they have a profound sense that they are mysteriously linked to everything in the environment, they are part of the universal whole, and that all life, and even inanimate features of nature, have a kind of consciousness. They have a profound sense of what lies beyond death and of what exists outside one’s body. To them, accidents, disease, drought and death are never “natural,” or “accidental” or a product of chance, but are caused by some mystical agency. Primitive people do not put much faith in what we would call “logical” or “intellectual” conclusions or “objective data,” “external facts,” “generally accepted ideas,” or “scientific truths.” The nature of rationality for them is different than for many of us in the modern world. Their inner logic is entirely different from our own-they do not see the causal relations that we think are valid, and instead place great credence on intuition. They do not have logically consistent ideas or motivations. To us, they may seem to rely on things that might seem irrelevant or bizarre. Malinowski (1925) argued that primitive man
Introduction
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 13
has no sober moods at all, that he is hopelessly and completely immersed in a mystical frame of mind. Incapable of dispassionate and consistent observation, devoid of the power of abstraction, hampered by “a decided aversion towards reasoning,” he is unable to draw any benefit from experience, to construct or comprehend even the most elementary laws of nature.... Nor can there exist for them any clear idea of substance and attribute, cause and effect, identity and contradiction. Their outlook is that of confused superstition, “pre-logical,” made of mystic “participations” and “exclusions.” (p. 28, quoting Lucien Levy-Bruhl) According to Jung (1933), this “illogical” outlook only strikes us in this way because we start from assumptions wholly different from those of primitive man. If we were as convinced as he is of the existence of sorcerers and of mysterious powers, instead of believing in so-called natural causes, his inferences would seem to us perfectly reasonable. As a matter of fact, primitive man is no more logical or illogical than we are. His presuppositions are not the same as ours, and that is what distinguishes him from us. His thinking and his conduct are based on assumptions other than our own. To all that is in any way out of the ordinary and that therefore disturbs, frightens or astonishes him, he ascribes what we should call a supernatural origin. For him, of course, these things are not supernatural; on the contrary, they belong to his world of experience. (p. 146) Also according to Jung (1940), primitives perceive phenomena as “psychic events”: The mind of the primitive is little concerned with an objective explanation of obvious things, but has an imperative need or, rather, its unconscious psyche has an irresistible urge to assimilate all experience through the outer senses into inner, psychic happening. The primitive is not content to see the sun rise and set; this external observation must at the same time be a psychic event-that is, the sun in its course must represent the fate of a god or hero who dwells, in the last analysis, nowhere else than in the psyche of man. (p. 54) Thus, concerns that we might have in life about the “causes” of phenomena-simply do not exist in their world view. Rather, invisible powers, inaccessible to the senses, are part of reality, and explain what occurs. These invisible influences are, to them, more real than data gleaned by the senses. Yet to a large degree, modern man also relies on irrational factors in decision-making. We can see every form of mental contagion, from the crudest sentimentalism to the most subtle, secret poisoning of reason, and this among the so-called normal people-the average individuals who largely make up a nation or a state. Their amazing defencelessness against suggestions, even against the wildest social and political ideas and ideals, is not exactly a proof of the strength of consciousness and reason. But since there must be strength somewhere, it is presumably in that which overcomes reason-in the irrational and emotional factors. (Jung, 1940, p. 10) Primitive cultures, for the most part, view the spirit world with fear and distrust. Regarding the spiritual or unknown world as evil and to be feared is in contrast to the Christian one of love and faith in the unknown. In primitive cultures one continually engages in a mythic battle of dualistic forces of good and evil. This is particularly evident in healing practices where people seek to restore a sense of order, either in their outer or internal lives. The shaman acts as a mediator of power, to counter-balance disorder, so as to restore harmony in the patient. (Of course, in modern society we also are concerned about the struggle between good and evil forces, but we approach the problem in a different way.) There are three main areas of “invisible forces” that preoccupy primitive peoples: (1) spirits of the dead; (2) spirits of nature, associated with animals, plants, sacred spaces, rocks, streams, artifacts and so forth; and (3) forces from witchcraft, curses, the evil eye, evil spirits, and forces generated by violating a taboo. The explanation for, say, too much or too little rain, or the death of a pig, or an earthquake, or a hunting accident, or the death of a child-will be that witchcraft was afoot or that an ancestor has been offended by something the people have done, and so on.
14 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
Thus, as we will see in more detail in chapter 12 (“Magic, Sorcery and Witchcraft”), primitive minds simply do not follow the sort of chain or reasoning we usually employ as to the causes of an accident, illness, or death: If someone’s baby gets sick, the mother or father will be accused of violating some taboo held to be sacrosanct by the people, so that a shaman or medicine-man will be engaged to perform a ritual to restore the status quo. If a group of women are washing clothes in the stream and one of them is taken by a crocodile and killed, the other two will be accused of witchcraft, as well as whoever lives nearby. If someone on a hunting excursion suffers an injury, the other men in the group will be accused of witchcraft. And if one man in a group of fisherman catches a really good amount of fish, while the others don’t, his ill-begotten gain will be attributed to sorcery and the man will be shunned. While it is perfectly understandable to us that people die of advanced age or as the result of diseases that are recognized to be fatal, this is not the case with primitive man. When old persons die, he does not believe it to be as a result of age. He argues that there are persons who have grown much older. Likewise, no one dies as the result of disease, for there have been other people who recovered from the same disease, or never contracted it. To him, the real explanation is always magic. Either a spirit has killed the man, or sorcery has done so. Many primitive tribes recognize death in battle as the only natural death. Still other tribes regard even death in battle as unnatural, holding that the adversary who brought it about must either have been a sorcerer or have used a charmed weapon. (Jung, 1933, p. 144) An illness might be caused by touching a certain tree, vine or other spirit-inhabited object that belongs to another tribe. If a pregnant woman does this her child might be born deaf or blind. Relief of illness in such cases is by revisiting the site, finding the offended tree or other plant, and making a gift of money and food (e.g., by hanging a string of shells on the branches, rubbing the trunk with pig fat). For illness caused by infringement of social rules (e.g., cutting down someone else’s tree), one must offer the owner compensation for the infringement; and the appeased owner then applies medicinal plants and barks on the victim’s skin or gives him a meal of pork. The magical thinking of primitive peoples, if viewed under the lens of Western psychiatry, might be classified as Schizotypal Personality Disorder, Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder or even schizophrenia (Lucas & Barrett, 1995, p. 296). Western psychiatry describes schizophrenia “as a weakening of the ego, a loss of self-possession, a vulnerability to external influence, or a merging of the self with others” (Lucas & Barrett, 1995, p. 296). And symptoms of Schizotypal Personality Disorder include the tendency to place “incorrect” or “unusual” interpretations on the cause of events, and the belief in the efficacy of magical rituals. (For further discussion, see “Psychopathic Tendencies of Shamans?” in chapter 8.) As we will emphasize in some detail later, as the Western world becomes more multicultural, we need to be better informed about the belief systems of a variety of ethnic and cultural backgrounds, for this will contribute to our understanding of humanity as a whole. Just what constitutes a mental disorder and how that varies across cultures will be discussed in chapter 19 (“Culture-Bound Syndromes”). MYTHS Myths, form a rich fabric in the lives of indigenous peoples, whether they are Native Americans or some of the more primitive cultures. Throughout history, myths have been a potent factor shaping the world view of people in highly advanced as well as primitive civilizations. Through myths, people confirm their identities as members of a tribe or other social unit. No pre-scientific society could possibly distinguish between myth and non-myth since there was no scientific criteria available. According to (Niles, 2007), For those people who believe in them, myths are regarded as embodying a truth beyond truth, a sacred narrative so definitive and important that anyone who doubts its truth stands in danger of being regarded as a subversive or a heretic. At the same time, the events portrayed in a myth are often so outrageously fantastic, when measured against the ordinary events of nature, that one may well find that if taken literally, a myth is patently absurd. (p. 2)
Introduction
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 15
Myths are “value-charged.” Myths represent how the people see themselves. The people do not think of them as “myths” because they are thought to be true (Gotesky, 1952). The theme of many myths is that divine powers govern human fate. People will use myths to justify many of their cultural beliefs and practices. Myth and reality, history and legend are one and the same. If people believe something is real then actions taken in accordance with their belief are likewise real to them. Myths often are at odds with scientific information about how the world works, just as creationism-the idea that God created the world in seven days-is at odds with the theory of evolution. Some myths are not susceptible to scientific proof or falsification because they lie outside of experience and therefore cannot be “tested” at any time (e.g., the belief in the coming of the Messiah or the end of the world). When myths originate-and every society creates its own myths-people believe them to be true. It is at a later time where the story becomes a myth in the sense that it is no longer believed, for it is now known to be false, perhaps through science. Still, a myth can easily persist despite being proven false-so that there can be a (false) belief in spite of evidence disproving the myth. That is, people may recognize that a myth is not true, but they will believe in it anyway. As is well known in social studies, human beings are subject to the phenomenon of cognitive dissonance, so that even in the face of evidence that disproves a cherished belief, individuals will continue to believe what is false. Many people disagree as to whether certain biblical accounts are historical facts or myths-such as Adam and Eve, the parting of the Red Sea by Moses, the plagues of Egypt, and so on. Many religious wars have been fought over doctrinal differences-the Crusades being a notable example. Do you believe in certain modern day myths? Do you believe in the 9/11 conspiracy, for instance? In modern society some myths are known to be false by overwhelming counter-factual information, yet people persist in believing them because of their “value-charge” or “value-significance.” The persistence of a myth in the minds of people can help establish a strong bond among like-minded people who are dedicated to a “cause.” The belief in certain myths provides a sense of solidarity among “true believers” against the dominant culture, against defeat, frustration, and disappointment. And among people in more primitive cultures, myths help to preserve traditional customs, institutions and institutional process. Primitive superstitions, long outgrown by modern society and thrust into the background, continue to live in the souls of people. They are never completely rooted out. In times of crisis or chaos, when a higher faith goes to pieces and one knows not what to believe is true-older superstitions are apt to rise once more to the surface and gain credence. For example, even in modern society, if people are diagnosed with a serious illness, often their first thought is that God is punishing them for some sin-an idea on par with the primitive belief that illness is caused by spirits, or by the angry ancestors. PRIMITIVES ARE CONSERVATIVE, TRADITION BOUND, AND RESISTANT TO CHANGE Primitive cultures tend to be tradition bound. They tend to adhere vigilantly to the same customs, myths, traditions and modes of living that have prevailed for many generations. Indeed, for the most part their morals, mythology and sacred traditions are not only compulsory to all members of the tribe, but no difference of opinion is tolerated. Indigenous people often react with quizzical amusement when anthropologists ask about certain long-standing practices in their culture. They don’t spend time reflecting on what they do or how they do it, but simply take their traditions for granted. Quite often the explanation for certain customs practiced in primitive cultures is elusive. These customs are of ancient origin, which manifestly had a meaning back in time, and now are carried on based on tradition, without a clear idea of their meaning. Original motives often disappear from the consciousness of the group, and habit becomes the primary force for the ongoing pattern. If we could go back in time and interview the ancestors who started certain practices, we might not get satisfactory information as to their purpose, for strong impulses might be imbued with unconscious processes that defy logical explanation. According to Newell (1906), ...[A]s we recede in time and in the order of culture, formality, habit, rigid custom, precise ritual, appears to prevail. Go back as far as we may, we never arrive at origins, or at simple and natural opinions; we find
16 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
only artificial and complicated systems of belief and worship, built on the ruins of other antecedent systems, extending farther than the eye can reach. (p. 9) The anthropologist Franz Boas (1910) once considered why certain of the Eskimos had a taboo against eating caribou and seal meat on the same day. Boas pointed out that the Eskimos lived, alternating at different times the year, inland and at the coast. When hunting inland there are deer to be had, but no seals; on the coast there are seals but no deer. Over time, these facts may have simply given rise to a rule. A simple fact about the environment somehow led to a deeply felt tendency to avoid eating both of these meats on the same day. According to Jung (1958), if you ask yourself what the meaning is of long-standing traditions that are part of your own heritage, you, too might be hardpressed to provide a coherent answer: You may ask many civilized people in vain for the reason and meaning of the Christmas tree or of the coloured eggs at Easter, because they have no idea about the meaning of these customs. The fact is, they do things without knowing why they do them. I am inclined to believe that things were generally done first and that only a long time afterwards somebody asked a question about them, and then eventually discovered why they were done (p. 115). Primitive people are intensely conservative and are misoneists, that is, haters of novelty, and thus they adhere as much as possible to traditional customs. They will resist adopting new practices, despite the best efforts of missionaries and colonial interlopers. The idea of adopting ways that are new, improved, better-is simply unpersuasive. They even resist changes that they themselves might recognize as an improvement. To implement a new and better way of working with iron, or of treating certain native diseases, or discovering new methods of harvesting-is to arouse suspicion. Once a custom is established, for whatever reason, the custom acquires a life of its own. Children learn the custom, and the custom is carried forward more or less without questioning its rationale. In many cultures people have little awareness of the distraction, excesses and overstimulation of consumerism that plagues modern society. Even those who have moved to urban centers, as we will see in our discussion of acculturation in the next section, often tend to stick to their traditional way of life, customs, beliefs, values and norms, despite contrary pressures in their new setting. As we alluded to in the preceding section, irrational thinking is, perhaps to the surprise of some, a common phenomenon in modern as well as primitive cultures. Our decisionmaking is to a large extent motivated by unconscious emotions and motivations. Maternal love, friendship, romance, artistic creativity, faith in an afterlife, and heroic greatness are examples of the life-affirming power of the irrational in our lives. We recognize in our own behavior, something essentially absurd in irrational acts, for which no explanation can be given. People failing to abide by the rules of logic is something behavioralists claim is a consistent and persistent human trait. In other words, irrational tendencies in human cognition are systematic and predictable. (Cohan, 2002, p. 282) Western behavioralists have extensively studied irrationality and cognitive biases in how people think, documenting “how we form initial beliefs or hypotheses outside of rational or logical norms, and how we then maintain a bias for the persistence of these beliefs even when we are confronted with thoroughly discrediting evidence” (Cohan, 2002, p. 282). This phenomenon of holding onto beliefs that may no longer serve a useful purpose is actually quite common in the Western corporate world, where “initial beliefs may persevere in the face of a subsequent invalidation of the evidence on which they are based” (Anderson, Lepper & Ross, 1980, p. 1045), even where the basis for a belief may be weak. Could it be that there is something hard wired in human nature that makes people resistant to change? Perhaps innovation and change are things that people of all stripes tend to resist, at least until they get accustomed to the new ways. From the perspective of primitives, perhaps they fear that innovations would require modifying their traditional customs, and this would anger their ancestors, and as punishment their yams and sago would not grow,
Introduction
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 17
and their fields would lie barren. Anyone who succeeds in greater measure than others, or has crop in greater abundance than others-due for instance to some innovative farming technique-will be immediately accused of witchcraft-and plotted against by others-unless the individual distributes his newfound wealth to others. We will see numerous examples of the tension between traditional customs and the pressure to adopt new ways, throughout this book. LACK OF CONCERN FOR “MEANING” IN LIFE Among primitive peoples there is an apparent lack of concern for the question of whether one’s life has meaning or whether one is a “success” life-questions that permeate modern society. While we might ponder whether we have made a difference in the world and whether our lives have meaning-these are questions of no importance to people in primitive cultures. It does not matter much to them, either, whether they are “productive” in their endeavors, and the idea of whether what they do is “fulfilling” simply does not enter their minds. We take it to be something fundamental to ascribe some meaning to our lives, whether that meaning has subjective value or whether there is some objective standard by which we can ascribe “meaning.” Most people seem to behave in ways that suggest they are looking for worthwhile things to do with their lives. We tend to organize our lives around some focal or guiding concern. We actively seek projects to which we are attracted and which we believe are worthwhile and give our lives meaning. We want to assure ourselves and convince others that our lives are important and meaningful, and we are proud of our accomplishments, people we have known, places we have visited, and prestige we have garnered. When we eulogize the deceased we emphasize what their passions and accomplishments were. Primitive cultures tend to be existential when it comes to the search for meaning in life. They see meaning in dreams, in oracles, in communication from the spirit realm, from dead ancestors, from spirits of the forest, of the mountains, and from animals, and so on-but they do not ponder what philosophers and theologians often take to be so fundamental-the meaning of life itself, and whether an individual’s life is “meaningful” or “successful.” Nor are the primitive cultures plagued with a nihilistic angst-a sense that life is all for naught, that nothing, not even great accomplishments, can take away from the meaninglessness of life and the human condition. As we will see in our discussion of animism in chapter 5, primitive cultures believe they are connected to all of life. They are contented with their identity and that of their community. It takes very little to make them happy. To the extent that discontent emerges in primitive cultures, this seems to be a product of external influences such as hegemony on the part of colonial interlopers, pressures by the dominant culture to change, the whittling away of their sacred sites by industry, and similar incursions that erode their traditional way of life-issues we will explore throughout this book. THE TREND TOWARDS ACCULTURATION In an era when travel across the globe is so accessible, we can be profoundly affected by how others live their lives when we visit and experience diverse cultures. We can see that others are happy with relatively few possessions, for instance, or with significantly constrained infrastructures. Such admissions can show us that our understanding of human flourishing need not be confined to the status quo of our point of view. Indeed, “downsizing” is something of a trend in modern society, particularly when forced into this by economic and other external circumstances. People find that they can get on perfectly well with less. There seems to be a trend in globalization to understand and absorb the perspectives and experiences of people from distinctly different cultures and to avoid parochialism, the tendency to see all issues and evaluate all norms through the lens of one’s own culture. (Cohan, 2001/2002, p. 135)
18 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
In some instances indigenous populations exist side-by-side in relative insularity with the dominant culture. People want to preserve obscure languages, traditional apparel, cuisines and other elements of their culture. But for hundreds of years European explorers viewed strange new cultures as populated by degenerate, inferior, barbaric, superstitious, savage, fallen beings. Even today, The dominant culture may be convinced that because the indigenous cultures are savage and heathen, this gives it the right to “look out for” them and speak for them. (Cohan, 2001/2002, p. 138) However, Indigenous peoples generally, by definition, do not want to be assimilated into the dominant culture or even that of other indigenous groups, nor want to have their cultural identity suppressed, or their land and resource based traditions denied or denigrated. (Cohan, 2001/2002, p. 138) Acculturation refers to the assimilation of the old culture into a new one, with adoption of new traditions and new ways of life, with radically different perspectives. Often this is a voluntary process. For example, if a villager moves from India to take on a job in the Silicon Valley of California, the individual might seek to adopt an entirely different lifestyle, and formulate new ideas as to what is good for human flourishing-as a way of more or less fitting into the new culture. No culture is trapped in a particular tradition forever. Cultures change within themselves, which we have seen many times in history. We see a certain social Darwinism that can generate a veritable psychological shift of attitude within cultures. For instance, societies may undergo collective movements for peace and cooperation in rebuilding their infrastructure after a period of war. Or conflicts within a society regarding certain norms may be a potent force impacting on what the people tolerate or accept. An example of this is the movement towards the legalization of same sex marriage-and other civil rights movements born out of frustration with the establishment’s hostility towards various minorities. Rather than conform to what the establishment wishes to perpetuate, people will form civil rights movements and work towards encouraging a greater toleration, and even acceptance, of a new norm. In our own culture the norm in the 1950s was the nuclear family model, and unwed mothers and even unmarried couples living together were stigmatized. Later, the feminist movement, a burgeoning divorce rate and other pulls generated a shift in our culture’s collective attitude, so that for the most part there has emerged a tolerance of diversity in lifestyles. But these examples are not acculturation, but simply a process of change within a society due to political and social dynamics from within the culture. ACCULTURATION AND CULTURAL IMPERIALISM The arrival of foreigners who, through colonial rule or other hegemony, become the dominant culture over indigenous peoples, often carries with it inevitable pressures for the natives to change their ways. Historically, acculturation and demoralization-cultural imperialism-go hand in hand. We saw this with the treatment of Native Americans, and on multiple levels a similar pattern has repeated itself in other parts of the world. The story is appalling in much the same way, whether in Papua New Guinea or India: Indigenous people are pushed around, some of their customs are outlawed, they are deprived of political power, dispossessed of their lands, and subjected to forced resettlement and colonial “plans” for their absorption into the dominant society. Authorities pressure indigenous people into accepting new housing, modern medicine instead of folk healing, and the schooling of their children in the dominant language. Much of ancient wisdom and the richness of folklore can be lost in the process, resulting in a demoralized population. The loss of indigenous knowledge is something that affects not only their own people, but is a loss to people in other cultures. And, as was observed when Columbus explored America, there is the risk of exposing indigenous people to diseases for which they lack immunity. Columbus himself learned that European-carried diseases could be a leading cause of the demise of native populations. It is only in recent years that developed nations have become sensitive to the errors of the past, and in various ways have tried to make amends for the mistreatment of indigenous peoples. For instance, the Australian Prime Minister
Introduction
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 19
issued a formal apology to the aboriginal people of his country, who for many years were subjected to forced relocations and discriminatory policies. The government of Canada formally apologized to Native Canadians for forcing about 150,000 native children into government-financed and church operated residential schools starting in the 1920s. The schools were dedicated to eradicating the languages, traditions and customs of Native Canadians (Austen, 2008). Today, in an era of globalization, while colonial hegemony seems to be a thing of the past, some primitive cultures straddle two worlds. They remain relatively insular, and are vigilant to retain and hand down their customary way of life-and at the same time they participate in global trade and other aspects of “modernity.” For example, in many regions we see native populations agreeing to export resources important in world trade-timber, phosphorus, ore, gold, oil. Repeated exposure to globalized business practices influences many people to choose to adopt Western attitudes and reject old native patterns of their own. Whether it ultimately to their advantage or not, the remolding of indigenous people appears to be inevitable. In some cases indigenous people are eager to embrace new ways, in others the process is disquieting. Clearly, the main fallout in the intrusion of “modernity,” particularly when indigenous people become “homogenized” with the dominant culture, is the elimination of traditional cultural and religious practices. COLONIAL PACIFICATION OF “BRUTE NATIVES” During European colonialism all over the world-something that extended well into the 20th Century and continues to some extent today-the occupying authorities seem to act out a sort of ethnocentricism-the idea that one’s own way of life is to be preferred over all others. A “social demoralization” develops when the dominant group “actively deprecates the things others hold to be of value” (Herskovits, 1972, p. 103). Often, colonial “pacification” of indigenous people requires the latter to observe a new set of taboos-no more polygamy, no more raids, no more headhunting, inter-tribal fighting, or burial of bodies within the home. No more use of tobacco, no more obscene language, no more adultery, no more magic, witchcraft or shamanism. This causes a profound shift in their moral orientation and relationships among themselves. With colonial rule authorities might “severely lecture” the people for infractions, and serious violations such as revenge homicide are dealt with by arrest and trial before a regional magistrate. From the standpoint of colonial authorities and missionaries, these new rules are in the best interest of the native people. In fact paternalistic laws-laws designed to protect people from their own foolishness-form a large part of laws in all societies (e.g., seat belt laws). Despite colonial efforts to outlaw certain practices, natives would often persist in their traditional practices, albeit underground, and today in a post-colonial era, shamanism, folk medicine, witchcraft and other practices are extremely widespread. In Siberia, for instance, after an extended period during which shamans were imprisoned under Stalin’s anti-religious campaigns, shamans today have re-emerged as a vibrant element of indigenous culture. Acculturation can result in some people ending up completely rejecting their traditional practices-throwing out the baby with the bath water. This occurred among the Ambonwari people of East Sepik Province, Papua New Guinea. In the 1950s after Roman Catholic missionaries visited their village, the people embraced the new religion, and this started a process resulting some 40 years later in the people abandoning their traditional animistic-based religion. Formerly, people would speak to and consult spirits whom they believed were present everywhere. “Whenever there was a serious sickness in the village, the men put a pig’s head into a men’s house asking spirit-crocodiles for their help, while other men decorated a stick with shells and stuck it into the ground at the front of their men’s house” (Telban, 2008, p. 229). In recent years villagers started to embrace a Catholic Charismatic movement. They began practicing laying of the hands and singing of prayers as a means of healing the sick. They stopped going to traditional healers. They stopped post-mortem divination. They took all carved spirits into the forest and left them to rot. They tore down the men’s houses and rebuilt them into recreational “wind houses.” They visited formerly tabooed areas and cut down the trees. Not only did Ambonwari abandon their relationships with the spirits, they blame them for all illnesses and deaths in the past, for them living so remote from the rest of the world, for their having violent relationships with their neighbours, and for their not receiving any wealth (Telban, 2008, p. 230).
20 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
Young men in the community “began to question the deepest cosmological and cultural aspects of their lives, including initiation rituals. If the latter were once essential for the rebirth and revitalization of the village and its cosmology, they suddenly became a synonym for illness, dying and destruction” (Telban, 2008, p. 230). On the other hand, there are still quite a few who, while they practice Christianity, also maintain “good relations” with the spirits of their village. The children attend a local school. The villagers use guns for hunting, they use cotton mosquito nets, kerosene lamps and outboard motors, which they know how to repair. If someone buys a new outboard motor, he will have an inauguration ceremony performed at the men’s house so that the motor can receive its own name and become an Ambonwari being. They buy rice, tinned foods and other commercial products. They have radios and tune into news of the world. Some of them work on tourist boats and in a nearby lodge, and some open trade stores. However, these stores usually fail. People understand that a business can be successful only if goods are paid for, but the owners are continually obliged to give them either on indefinite loan or for nothing. Thus all businesses in Ambonwari collapse shortly after they begin. If one does not follow the “good way” of giving things, someone will break into the store and steal the goods.... Whenever men who earn wages return to the village they are put under pressure... by others who ask them for money, petrol, purchased goods, and so on. (Telban, 1998, p. 225) The example of the Ambonwari is a theme is echoed in many other tribal communities that have been influenced by missionaries of all sects. Sometimes people will adopt a hybrid form of belief, combining animistic rituals with Christian liturgy. In other cases there may be outright hostility towards the efforts of missionaries. For indigenous people in Fiji there has been significant social unease due to ongoing competition between Methodist leaders and traditional chiefs, with infighting among themselves for political power, on top of feelings of hostility towards indentured Indian laborers. In some places, such as Malaysia and Borneo, native people have a cultural commitment to “live in both worlds.” People in isolated villages often travel by motor boat or on new roads and bridges to regional towns to conduct trading. They will certainly want to get a radio, blue jeans, canned goods, store-bought stockings, baseball hats, tshirts, and modern tools. They return home with new perceptions of the world around them-but in returning to their ancestral village they are content to follow their indigenous language, customs and morals. In other cases the intrusion of modernity creates tension among villagers, particularly between parents and children. Younger people tend to be more susceptible to breaching cultural boundaries. Younger people often leave the villages seeking new lives and relief from the oppressive social life and obligations in the village, with the attraction of economic success, material goods, high social status, privacy and modern sanitation in urban centers, where they can cast away their own “cultural baggage.” These young adults bring back their new lifestyles and personal stories when they return home. There is an inevitable clash with ancestral norms. By the same token, we see this same inter-generational clash between parents and children in all cultures, but it is more striking in primitive cultures because of the tremendous contrast between their traditional practices and urban lifestyles. On the other hand, many think that village life has its own kind of autonomy. Smith (2002), for examples, states: Villagers may be enveloped in a web of kinship obligations, but they are not nakedly dependent for their basic livelihoods on a boss, a distant government department, or a mercurial national economy. And fellow villagers can see each other as whole people, not just as bosses and employees, buyers and sellers, cogs in a bureaucracy, or inhabitants of different social strata. (p. 165) In Papua New Guinea we see evidence that young people in villages often want to meld their own ancestral practices with those introduced by the dominant culture. In that region social changes are often induced by the introduction of a cash economy, by Christianity, by travel and school education, all of which require new, or rather, different values to be embodied in a person belonging to the nation state of Papua New Guinea. As one old man commented, once
Introduction
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 21
upon a time the big men directed village life, but today it is the young people’s decisions which dominate the village. Nevertheless, because opposition to practices and habits which are at the same time also part of young people’s lives would seriously threaten the stability of the village, even young people endorse those activities which they see as providing that stability. Young people also recognize the powers of their ancestors and their spirits, and when they go on a trip they say that the village spirit will follow them and protect them. (Telban, 1998, p. 200) If rapid change occurs in native populations, this tends not only to cause erosion of traditional customs, but will often cause community fragmentation, the breakdown of family structures, the breakdown of individuals, and an increase in mental illness, so that “society goes mad, literally” (Sow, 1980, p. 238). On the other hand, in some cases, people are pleased to acculturate to the ways of the dominant culture. Take Angaur, which is in the southernmost of the Palau group of islands (Micronesia, part of Caroline Islands). During World War II the Americans took over the islands from the Japanese, who had been in colonial control. (Prior to that the Germans and Spanish had colonial control.) The Americans thought that they would be encountering primitive lifestyles, but a half century of Japanese influence brought the people of Angaur many attributes of modern civilization. They had adopted new and deeply ingrained Japanese customs: e.g., bowing in greeting. The people were not interested in returning to their aboriginal style of dress. Once the Americans took occupation of the island, children were more interested in learning American customs than their old customs; youth wanted to do Western dances, not ancient dances; and Western movies were more popular than native festivals (Useem, 1945). NATIVISTIC MOVEMENTS Often in response to acculturation, particularly in urban centers, we see what is called “nativistic” movements. According to Linton (1943), nativistic movement is “any conscious, organized attempt on the part of a society’s members to revive or perpetuate selected aspects of its culture” (p. 230). We might call this a response to a feeling of inequality and disrespect that the people feel from the dominant culture, and to frustration that their practices are at odds with what be rapid social change. This is largely a conscious process in which people have a deep seated desire to rekindle and hand down to their children their own cultural traditions rather than that of the new culture. Thus, nativistic movements focus on revitalizing cultural patterns of old, and perpetuating them. Nativistic movements often are evidenced by the formation of neighborhoods within urban centers-such as Chinatown, Koreatown, or “Little India”-thus helping people preserve their cultural heritage and maintain social solidarity. In Philippine, Chinese, Irish, and Mexican neighborhoods, to name a few examples, nativistic movements seek to preserve particular cultural elements of culture, not necessarily the culture as a whole. For instance, where ethnic populations abound people will seek to preserve folk healing practices or certain rules of modesty for women that are part of their customs, but not all elements of their traditions. People will seek to preserve ancient languages, as seen in Ireland with many seeking a Celtic language revival. We will see many other examples throughout this book. Sometimes companies will advertise and promote commercial products to indigenous populations as if the products were aligned with traditional ways of life. For instance, in Papua New Guinea, PepsiCo and Arnott’s Biscuits have produced advertising that conveys cultural images such as models wearing traditional costumes and accessories, while holding up the company’s product. These efforts seek to capitalize on native themes to convey the idea that there is full consonance “between a completely traditional identity and a fully modern soft drink-consuming, biscuiteating identity” (Errington & Gewertz, 1996, p. 118). What this comes to is a redefining of the traditional and passing off new values for old-in an effort to manipulate a shift in the way indigenous people make choices as consumers. Of course, that is what advertising is always after-influencing consumer choices. There are many reasons why people wish to revitalize their native culture. People might find that certain aspects of their ancestry appear desirable in hindsight. People can gain a sense of comfort in the face of frustrations with the dominant culture in which they find themselves entrenched. Preserving traditional patterns helps bring back memories of when their society was happy or great. And nativistic movements help the people enjoy a sense of pride over their native culture in the face of adverse conditions.
22
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man, 2010, 22-28
CHAPTER 2 Cultural Relativism Abstract. There are tremendous variations in how people carry on their lives across cultures. All cultures have some sort of system of “public morals” or norms or rules that provide a structure that guides behavior. Cultural relativism holds that moral principles are relative, so that there is no such thing as a “one-size-fits-all” morality. The forms under which good and evil appear are different. By coming to know the presuppositions of people, we can better understand their moral perspective. We will discuss idea that, despite variations in behavior patterns among cultures, there are certain basic moral concepts recognized by all peoples-e.g., respect for life and property, some form of religious faith. All societies have some means of dealing with social outcasts, criminals, cheats and the like. The dilemma of cultural relativism is whether it is appropriate to interfere with practices of other cultures that we regard as morally repugnant. Today the activities within one culture can affect people in other cultures-most notably in the arena of environmental pollution. People have a limit as to what sort of things they will tolerate in other cultures. All nations condemn genocide, slave trade, torture, the use of human subjects for experimentation, and summary execution. In studying diverse cultures we should keep an open mind in taking in the practices that we might find offensive or repugnant or even barbaric. Change is particularly difficult when cultures sincerely believe, as they do, that their moral practices are sound, well-founded and of fundamental importance to their very identity as people.
THE DIVERSITY OF NORMS ACROSS CULTURES Anthropology has learned that there are tremendous variations in how people carry on their lives across cultures. This is one of the big things anthropology has “discovered” in the past century or so-that people often live with unique or distinct norms that are at odds with those of other cultures. All cultures have some sort of system of “public morals” which arise from standards developed by the people over time. All of us share a common orientation and understanding of the “rules of the game.” These rules provide a structure that guides our behavior, and which most of us do not easily question. These rules involve what a society has come to deem appropriate for its flourishing and survival, and are handed down so that we learn what is approved of by our community in early childhood. Any society that lacks a value system can easily break down. We not only guide our own action with reference to these rules, but we learn that praise or blame is based on compliance or deviation from those norms. If there is confusion in a community as to what norms of behavior apply, this can lead to the disorganization, disintegration, and breakdown of values, leading to a transition and establishment of a revised value system. The term moral relativism (or ethical relativism) holds that moral principles are relative, so that there is no such thing as a “one-size-fits-all” morality. Moral principles are not self-evident propositions that are truth assessable, final or certain. Terms such as “right” and “good” are relative terms so that if I say “X is good,” that simply means “My culture regards X as good.” A different culture might claim that “X is bad,” and this inconsistency is explained simply by the idea that there is no objective truth in the matter. Here is the essence of cultural relativism: The fact that diverse cultures have different solutions to moral dilemmas makes it inappropriate to argue that a particular norm is good or bad for everyone. There is a wide diversity among cultures in how human beings carry on in their relations with one another. While people of one culture might disapprove of certain practices, in another culture these same practices might be morally approved. Jung (1933) commented that Primitive man is no less prompt than we are to value an ethical attitude. His good is just as good as ours, and his evil is just as bad as ours. Only the forms under which good and evil appear are different; the process of ethical judgement is the same (p. 147). Jung (1933) further observed: John Alan Cohan All rights reserved - © 2010 Bentham Science Publishers Ltd.
Cultural Relativism
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 23
the fact that the primary assumptions of archaic man differ essentially from ours-that he lives, if I may use the expression, in a different world. Until we come to know his presuppositions, he is a riddle hard to read, but when we know them, all is relatively simple. We might equally well say that primitive man ceases to be a riddle when we have come to know our own presuppositions (p. 149). Therefore, the validity of a moral code is context-dependent, and must be analyzed, if at all, with reference to the distinct cultural backdrop of the particular culture. To make sense, statements about values must be linked to specific circumstances of a culture-the myths that operate in the culture, the environment, long-held traditions with obscure origins, and other factors. People tend to regard their own patterns and customs as “good.” All cultures “regard that which contributes to the need and survival of the group as good,” and there is no culture that does “not condemn conduct interfering with the satisfaction of common needs and threatening the stability of social relations” (Ginsberg, 1953, p. 124). There are often significant differences in the moral codes of different cultures. By moral codes I am referring to obligatory norms that are binding on all people within the culture, which are not subject to human “discretion,” and the violation of which the people regard to be sinful or immoral. Foster (1965) states that [t]he members of every society share a common cognitive orientation which is, in effect, an unverbalized, implicit understanding of the “rules of the game” of living imposed upon them by their social, natural and supernatural universes. A cognitive orientation provides the members of the society it characterizes with basic premises and assumptions normally neither recognized nor questioned which structure and guide behavior (p. 293). There are many contrasting moral codes among cultures. One broad divide can be seen is this: In the West, according to Kantian morality, we must always act in such a way that we treat people (including ourselves) as ends in themselves, never merely as a means. It is a kind of Golden Rule-treat others as you would want them to treat you under like circumstances. Kant doesn’t argue that there is something wrong with treating people as a means-we do this all the time-when we ask someone for traffic directions or make a purchase from a vendor, and thereby use the other as a means to an end. We can’t live without treating each others as means-but Kant’s point is that we should never treat others merely as a means. In other words the dignity of humanity requires that we treat each other with respect, never that we treat others as “things.” And according to Kant, there are categorical imperatives, that is, certain things are right or wrong absolutely-universally, under all circumstances. This is in contrast to other cultures that think it is all right to treat people as a means to ends. For instance, the Gahuku-Gama, and other tribes of the Eastern Highlands of New Guinea, do not have a moral system that appeals to abstract principles, but rather they emphasize the practical consequence of moral deviation. Morality is a means to an end rather than an end in itself. That is, “If you don’t help others, others won’t help you” or “Give food to those who visit you so they will think well of you.” In that culture there are no “universal” norms; that is, injunctions against adultery, against lying, theft and slander and murder are right or wrong, depending on the circumstances. In particular, one has no moral duties to people of other tribes; it is justifiable to kill them, to steal from them and to seduce their women. And within the tribe, one’s moral obligations to others are differentially apportioned depending on one’s social position and kinship ties. The social context largely determines the moral character of a particular action. Cultural variants appears to be commonplace not only among human cultures, but other species as well. Certain behavioral variations among groups of animals apparently are due to the same sort of cultural variants that we humans display. For example, primatologists have seen that there are important differences in behavior patterns among various groups of chimpanzees in West and Central Africa, including the ways they fish for ants with a probe, pound food with a stone, dance in the rain, and aim and throw stones.
24 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
ARE THERE CORE HUMAN VALUES? Despite variations in behavior patterns among cultures, anthropologists have found there are certain basic moral concepts recognized by all peoples. These are broad core values-e.g., “justice is a virtue,” or “murder is wrong,” or “empathy is good.” The prevalence of these categories suggests that “behind the seemingly endless diversity of cultural patterns there is a fundamental uniformity” (Linton, 1952, p. 646). Boas (1962) observed that all cultures seem to hold that it is the duty of every person [in one’s own society] to respect life, well-being and property of his fellows, and to refrain from any action that may harm the group as a whole. All breaches of this code are threatened with social or supernatural punishment (p. 225). All cultures have some form of religious belief, and these beliefs invariably include rituals for worshipping of specific deities, animals or natural phenomena, a system of prayers of petition for desired objectives, beliefs in the immortality of the soul, of an afterlife, of offerings of praise and sacrifice, and of exoneration for sins. Perhaps the biological fact that everyone must die drives cultures to devise explanations for life and death. Every culture has its individual complexion, feel, and attitude, just like individual cities have their particular “feel,” and companies and hierarchical organizations have their particular cultural feel. The “feel” in being part of IBM is entirely different than being part of a Farming-Coop. But that does not mean that the separate entities subscribe to a separate set of moral principals. It could be that they have divergent moral principles, but that is not entailed merely because they have different ways of conducting business. Cultural relativism recognizes that even though all cultures seem to share many core values, people of different cultures will interpret and pursue these values in different ways. For example, all cultures regard justice to be a virtue, and that just deserts are to be meted out in proportion to one’s offense, but there are different methods of apportioning and meting out justice. Some cultures regard revenge to be an appropriate instance of justice. The American Navahoes and cultures of the Middle East have endorsed an “eye for eye” system of justice, so that exacting retribution by way of a precise form of “justice” means visiting upon a wrongdoer the same act for which culpability was found. In former times murder and accidental killing were regarded with equal gravity so that, either way, the wrongdoer was killed in retribution. Even within the same culture-take the United States for instance-certain agreed upon human values may have no precise, authoritative interpretation. The Supreme Court is often divided on the interpretation of some very important core values-such as whether the facts of a case show unlawful discrimination, cruel or unusual punishment, the violation of due process or the violation of other constitutional rights. Equally intelligent and reasonable people can agree that freedom and democracy are core values, but there is never-ending political debate as to what these ideas actually mean in practice. The ways of dealing with society’s outcasts, the criminally accused, varies considerably across cultures and has varied throughout civilized history. In Saudi Arabia the protocol for dealing with convicted thieves is to cut off their right hand. In the West we impose a relatively small prison term, or probation, for first-time offenders. In the past, criminal offenders were dealt with by torture, drawing and quartering, crucifixion, burning at the stake, and other brutal measures. Today these practices are universally condemned. Still, in Somalia and other Muslim nations blood revenge will be tolerated or even encouraged. For instance, it is not uncommon for people to have a public killing, by stoning to death, of women-even girls-accused of adultery. Other cultures, such as the European Union, have questioned whether the death penalty itself is ever morally permissible, however humanely it might be administered, and have therefore abolished it. Even the mode of execution varies considerably across cultures that have the death penalty, with hanging or stoning to death being practiced in Middle Eastern cultures, and lethal injection employed in the United States. The Isneg farmers of the Philippines regard people as cowards unless they exact full satisfaction for misdeeds committed against themselves or their kin. Even if one’s own family member is a malefactor, people are expected to
Cultural Relativism
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 25
make sure there is full satisfaction paid for the misdeed. There are no police: The one who has been damaged takes revenge on his own. The taking of the life of another without just provocation is considered wrong by all peoples. However, there are variations in what constitutes “just provocation.” To some, an act of sorcery could be “just provocation” to justify a revenge killing. Anthropological accounts show that no human group approves of indiscriminate lying, cheating or stealing, although cultures differ in their reasons for disapproval and their definition of the terms, and the conditions under which lying or stealing is tolerable or even socially approved. Lying in Latin America about extramarital activity is condoned, but is generally not regarded with approval in the United States. In some cultures the so-called polite lie is accepted, when socially convenient. In the Lovedu of the Transvaal in Africa, one can tell a lie to get out of difficulties, and children are told to lie to strangers if asked about village affairs. But all these cultures regard lying to be morally wrong. Empathy seems to be a universal psychological trait of human nature, and acts of charity are regarded as a universal good, but coming to the aid of the needy and distressed or to strangers beyond one’s clan or country might be thought of as bad in some cultures, and good in others. VARIATIONS IN AESTHETICS NORMS It is easier to accept norms that are different from our own in nonmoral contexts, even if we don’t understand them. We may readily accept differences in tastes and aesthetics as simply a form of cultural diversity. In aesthetics-what people regard as beautiful-we often respect and even learn to enjoy the tastes of other cultures. A culture might regard bands in women’s noses as beautiful. In some cultures modesty is not a virtue. Mild to moderate obesity is considered to be a sign of beauty and health in many cultures. And, according to Berry (2007), ... a few cultures admire teeth sharpened to points as a sign of beauty.... Some cultures elongate the neck by encircling it with brass rings, insert lip plates, and paint their teeth as signs of beauty. Other cultures seek out women for features that we in the West would dislike, such as droopy breasts. In other words, the dominant culture in any society determines what good looks are and are not (p. 3). What is regarded as good food varies significantly. For instance, we in the West are not inclined to eat monkeys, and we would probably decline to eat them out of disgust, but the Kababish and others in Africa, and natives of Malaysia, enjoy eating monkeys. Many other variations in food preference can be cited: India and Thailand favor very spicy foods; the Naim-Naim people between the White Nile and Congo Basin eat dogs and rats; and in many parts of the world, locusts, snakes, lizards, or caterpillars are “normal” food choices. The Pygmies of the Congo region eat gazelle, monkey and baboons, warm melted butter is considered a special drink by the Yakuts of Siberia, the Canton of China love to eat ducks’ tongues and a glutinous substance found in birds’ nests, Arabs eat locusts boiled in salt and water then dried in the sun, (St. John the Baptist is mentioned as nourishing himself upon locusts and wild honey (Matt. 3:4)), the Nambikuara in upper Madeira River, western Matto Gorsso, Brazil eat crickets, rats, snakes, lizards, beetle larvae (Australian aboriginals, people in the Eastern Highlands of New Guinea and others also eat beetle larvae), the Batek of Malaysia eat porcupines, scaly anteaters, the bamboo rat, bats and hornbills, Tasmanians eat snakes, lizards, grubs and worms, and the list goes on (Davenport, 1945). The cultural style of art and music radically varies. In the West, we know music by the half-tone scale, which we learn to find pleasing from an early age. In India and China people learn the quarter-tone scale, which many in the West might at first find “unnatural” or unpleasant. Appreciation is at the level of learning. The diverse aesthetic preferences are each valid. They are constructs of a particular culture. Someone brought up in one culture will come to appreciate the dynamics of that culture’s aesthetics, and may find it difficult to appreciate aesthetics that deviate from the norm. Quite often it takes a certain amount of repeated exposure and understanding in order to appreciate radically different aesthetic preferences in other cultures, because we are so habituated to entirely different customs. In any case, no one has any moral qualms with another culture’s sense of aesthetics even though they are an entirely different sort of aesthetics from what one has learned.
26 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
But in moral contexts we have a different reaction. We might not fight a war over it, but people would get extremely upset if people India re-implemented the ancient custom of suttee-in which widows are forced to sacrifice themselves on funeral pyre of their husbands. PRINCIPLE OF NON-INTERFERENCE In an era of global relations and commerce, we want to enhance peace among nations, and this requires a toleration and respect for the ways different cultures carry on their lives. As mentioned, moral relativism suggests that there are culture-bound notions of what is good and bad, right and wrong. A controversy concerning moral relativism is the principle of non-interference-which holds that we must not interfere with the customs and morals of other cultures. Non-interference means that if a culture believes that cannibalism, infanticide, or slavery are good institutions, we cannot say that they are wrong or try and interfere with their practices, even though we are outraged at their barbarism. It would be improper to interfere with the Samurai’s practice of testing his sword by using a live human subject, and so on. Infanticide was once an acceptable and necessary practice in some cultures, for example those who lived in small groups such as the Northern Algonkians of Canada. It was justified if a mother died in childbirth and there was no other woman able to suckle the infant. In other cultures certain tribal beliefs held that if an infant has not nursed for the first time, it is not yet part of the group-not really a human being-and can be disposed of if unwanted. In West Africa there was a supernatural fear of twins, and one or both were killed at birth lest they become sorcerers if allowed to live. In Iran anyone convicted of homicide (including manslaughter or murder) will be executed at the option of the victim’s family-and this applies even to juvenile offenders. The vast majority of nations simply do not allow revenge sentences imposed by the victim’s family, but rely on the judges to impose the sentence. We barely tolerate these and other practices (e.g., female genital mutilation, child labor, etc) in other cultures. Diplomats, nongovernmental organizations and local activists (to the extent they are permitted to express dissent) seek to change such practices. But from the Iranian standpoint, all legal authority is derived from the Koran, so a fundamental shift away from Koranic law would be needed for such a change to take place, and this cannot come easily in a culture that has been so imbued in Islam for so many centuries. It seems hard to accept the idea, suggested by moral relativism, that in all situations it would be wrong to criticize, condemn or intervene in the practices of other cultures. In an age of globalization with increasingly porous borders and with instant communication and widespread international commerce, the activities within one culture can affect people in other cultures-most notably in the arena of environmental pollution. Domestic corruption affects international commerce. Diseases can spread from one culture to another. And so on. The fact of the matter is that nations have a limit as to what sort of things they will tolerate in other cultures, particularly when fundamental human rights are at issue. Today we have a substantial body of international treaties and accords declaring certain human rights as universal, so that they must not violated under any circumstances. These are rights that make up a core of morality founded on considerations of humanity-norms from which no derogation is permitted. Based on these principles, all nations condemn genocide, slave trade, torture, the use of human subjects for experimentation, and summary execution, among other things. Membership in the United Nations and in other international organizations “means that the participating state accepts the right of its fellow members to intervene in domestic affairs if it has failed in its most fundamental obligations to protect its own citizens-a kind of conditional social contract” (Slaughter, 2004, p. 286). Today in international relations, by passing resolutions in the United Nations, states can and do interfere with the sovereignty of other states by imposing standards of good governance and human rights norms. Today It is not at all clear why the membership in one culture precludes people from assessing the moral worth of what goes on in another culture, or that one culture should in effect be morally isolated from the next. We might not want to start a war over practices of other cultures that we find abhorrent, but at the same time, the principle of non-
Cultural Relativism
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 27
interference, in this day and age, does not preclude “public persuasion, coercion, shaming, economic sanctions, isolation, and in more egregious cases, by humanitarian intervention” (Cohan, 2006, p. 941). MORAL PROGRESS Another problem with moral relativism is that for the sake of consistency, the principle of non-interference would need to be applied within one’s own culture. Thus, we could not say that slavery of the past was morally repugnant in our own culture, or that it was bad to deny women the right to vote. The logical conclusion of relativism is that our own culture’s morality is perfect. That is, we could not say that the practices of a past era in our own culture were wrong. But as a society we believe that we have made moral progress, and we want to continue to make moral progress. For that to be true, we must be able to criticize or call into question the propriety of past practices of our own culture. We must also be able to debate and evaluate present practices. Moral growth occurs only if people go behind established norms, identities and commitments, and criticize the assumptions behind them. In order for moral progress to take place we must allow that changed circumstances in the human condition can lead to the transformation or erosion of certain values. Often there may be no rhyme or reason to explain certain long-standing traditions beyond the myths, legends, folklore, superstition or ignorance that the people embrace. Quite often the explanation for certain customs practiced in primitive cultures is elusive. These customs are of ancient origin, which manifestly had a meaning back in time, and now are carried on based on tradition, without a clear idea of their meaning. Original motives often disappear from the consciousness of the group, and habit becomes the primary force for the ongoing pattern. If we could go back in time and interview the ancestors who started certain practices, we might not get satisfactory information as to their purpose, for strong impulses might be imbued with unconscious processes that defy logical explanation. But it is extremely difficult to persuade natives to make “moral progress” by discarding some of their such strongly entrenched traditions. As mentioned in the earlier part of this chapter, in all cultures the people come to have a kind of consensus among themselves about their moral practices. There is a certain coercive power to the standards of behavior that are approved by a community. From childhood onwards, we all tend to build habits of behavior in conformity to the customs in our culture. Because habits can become firmly ingrained patterns in a culture, deviation from these norms can usually be met with outright hostility. Because of the compelling force behind the customs in a given culture, we often see that there is an aversion to moral progress. If a society practices cannibalism, for instance, or sacrificial slaughter of first-born or of suttee of widows, it may take a period of time for people in a culture to adopt and become accustomed to new norms. When slavery was abolished in the United States, it took over a century until old patterns of discrimination in the South became uprooted, and still today there are remnants of racial hatred. Sometimes certain customs of a culture might, objectively speaking, be harmful to its people. Even though for the most part we might want to adopt a live-and-let-live attitude about the practices of other cultures, we also might want to intervene to help people change practices that are clearly harmful to their well being. This is what missionaries had in mind in trying to convince natives that illness is caused by invasive germs and such-not by sorcery or some other supernatural agency-and that the people would be better off to come to the health clinics, where they could be treated with modern medicines, and thereby get well-instead of relying solely on their traditional healing practices. If we can call into question the customs of a past era, if we can enact laws in the present to eradicate certain practices so as to advance human rights, and if the notion of moral progress is to have any validity, then it is hard to fully embrace moral relativism. We want to live and let live, but also to influence the ways people approach moral issues in their own culture. It may not be any of our concern, and we might be mistaken in seeking to “impose” our standards on another culture’s-as missionaries and colonialists did so often with mixed results-but the dilemma is that to some extent, it is necessary to assess the morality of the practices of not only our own, but of other cultures. We simply live in too small a world for it to be otherwise. But it is a decidedly delicate matter. We might try to intervene to correct a culture’s misunderstanding of facts. If a culture believes that an infant is not a human being until it is breast fed, we might try to vividly inform the people
28 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
about the relevant scientific facts about human life. Once a culture is informed of all the relevant facts on a given subject, new information and new knowledge may shift peoples’ belief on that issue. But there are more difficult cases. For instance, a great many cultures believe witchcraft is responsible for misfortune of all kinds, including illness. To them, it is perfectly logical to seek out a medicine-man who will perform countermeasures to cure the patient. We might vehemently disagree with the entire philosophy behind illness in their culture, and we might want to help them save children from contracting diseases that can be prevented through modern medicine. It may seem irrational to us that people would ascribe witchcraft as the cause of illness, but in many cultures this philosophy makes perfect sense, and the people do not think there is anything superstitious or ignorant about their beliefs. There is no talking them out of it. Of course, we easily forget that for centuries witchcraft was thought to be a real phenomenon in the West, so much so that it was a common law crime, punishable by death. But again, we see that values can and do change with the times. As a result of political and scientific debate, and exposure to norms of other cultures, people in a culture will from time to time come to agree that certain practices, such as suttee or infanticide or cannibalism are thoroughly objectionable despite long-standing traditions. Then there will be a paradigm shift of sorts in how the people regard the particular custom. The culture will come to regard its past practices as superstitious or self-defeating, from the manner of growing crops to the manner of curing the sick, to the manner of raising children. New attitudes yield new norms. There invariably is some resistance to change, and sometimes it can take decades for certain practices to be replaced by new norms. In studying diverse cultures we should keep an open mind in taking in the practices that we might find offensive or repugnant or even barbaric. We can obtain valuable information about human diversity, the human creative possibility, and human nature itself by resisting the temptation to debase or vulgarize the cultural practices of others. Other cultures might have strange ideas and practices, but is of intrinsic interest to learn how diverse cultures carry on, how they solve basic human problems, how they deal with illness and misfortune, how they resolve conflicts, how they interpret and carry out justice, and so forth. It is not possible to resolve the issue of cultural relativism. One must accept that there is a dilemma in the matter: On the one hand we want to respect the moral practices of other cultures even though we might not agree with them, and on the other hand we would be lacking in humanity, compassion and fundamental respect for human rights if we stood by and did nothing to at least educate others and encourage them to consider discarding harmful practices. It is, of course, inevitable that change will continue to occur-as occurred over time with the practice of cannibalism-but change is particularly difficult when cultures sincerely believe, as they do, that their moral practices are sound, wellfounded and of fundamental importance to their very identity as a people.
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man, 2010, 29-36
29
CHAPTER 3 Apollonian and Dionysian Cultures Abstract. Ruth Benedict (1934) opened up a whole line of thinking regarding two types of culture: Apollinian and Dionysian. Dionysian cultures exhibit certain extremes in behavior, and there is importance ascribed to dreams and visions, also to self-fulfillment, self-expression, rights, liberties and individual accomplishment. Moreover, the idea of escape from the five senses through altered states of consciousness, intoxication, torture, self-mutilation, deprivation, etc. Dionysian cultures are imbued with magical thinking, i.e., the belief that thoughts, words or actions have causal power. Dreams and visions are very important because they are thought to contain messages from the spirit realm or direct visitations from ancestors. The contradiction in Dionysian cultures is that they tend to be tenaciously tradition-bound-yet at the same time they seek to escape from limitations through supernatural experiences, ecstatic trances, orgiastic ceremonies, and other excessive behavior that, at least under everyday circumstances, would be frowned upon. Paradoxically Dionysian cultures celebrate harmony and cooperation, and yet individuality, which at times can be a threat to unity. Apollinian cultures, in contrast, embrace moderation, steadfastness, conservatism, conformity, measured attitudes, precedent and tradition. There is distrust of individualism and emotionalism. Power comes from cult membership, verbatim ritual, conformity, sobriety, suffering, self-denial, introvertism, and moderation.
INTRODUCTION In her best selling book, Patterns of Culture (1934) Ruth Benedict introduced an idea that has had a profound impact in the study of cultures. She opened up a whole line of analysis that, for the most part, divides cultures into two camps: Dionysian and Apollonian. DIONYSIAN EXTREMES The majority of cultures, including much of the industrialized West, seem to be Dionysian. Personal, subjective experiences, unlimited personal freedom, self-reliance, individualism, initiative, power and the tossing aside of tradition are hallmarks of Dionysian cultures. A Dionysian seeks both an uninhibited, extravagant, passionate pursuit of pleasure, even to excess, and at the same time, paradoxically, a transcendence of sensate experience into a higher order of experience. Self-fulfillment, self-expression, rights, liberties and individual accomplishment are the hallmark of a Dionysian culture. As we will see, there are paradoxes and contradictions among Dionysian people: for instance, many primitive cultures are tenaciously tradition-bound, and the people do not deviate from norms that have been around since time immemorial-yet at the same time they will engage in ceremonies in an effort to transcend the here and now and behave in extravagant ways that, at least under everyday circumstances, would be frowned upon. America itself seems to be a Dionysian culture, with the emphasis on rugged individualism. According to Kirmayer (2007), To be a person is to be a unique individual. Each individual is autonomous and uniquely deserving of the free pursuit of his or her own private goals. People are valued for how richly developed and articulated their inner sense of self is and how strong and coherent their self-direction (p. 240). In her discussion of Dionysian culture, Ruth Benedict (1934) borrows Nietzsche’s description, “the annihilation of the ordinary bounds and limits of existence” (pp. 78-79). The Dionysian seeks to escape from the limitations imposed upon by our five senses, to break through into a different order of experience, perhaps to attain supernatural experiences such as ecstatic trances or union with god. Or the goal might be simply to gain a certain psychological state of excess. The philosophy is, as William Blake described, that “the path of excess leads to the palace of wisdom” (as quoted in Benedict, 1934, p. 79). This breaking into supernatural experiences might be accomplished by excessive behavior such as drunkenness, drug induced euphoria, frenzy in dance, or through the opposite of excess-self-denial, fasting, self-mutilation, John Alan Cohan All rights reserved - © 2010 Bentham Science Publishers Ltd.
30 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
torture, or other extreme forms of deprivation. With either mode, we can break out of our ordinary sense experience into a higher state of awareness. Paradoxically, while individualism is a Dionysian trait, so is universal harmony. Nietzsche (1872/1967) points out: ... Nature which has become alienated, hostile, or subjugated, celebrates once more her reconciliation with her lost son, man. Freely, earth proffers her gifts, and peacefully the beasts of prey of the rocks and desert approach.... Now, with the gospel of universal harmony, each one feels himself not only united, reconciled, and fused with his neighbor, but as one with him, as if the veil of maya had been torn aside and were now merely fluttering in tatters before the mysterious primordial unity (§1). DIONYSIAN DREAMS AND VISIONS Dionysian cultures are imbued with magical thinking, i.e., the belief that thoughts, words or actions have causal power. For the Dionysian, dreams and visions are very important because they are thought to contain messages from the spirit realm or direct visitations from ancestors. In Dionysean cultures the dreamer interacts with an ancestor who makes a vivid appearance as if in the flesh. In the West, many of us, like primitives and like children, have a great deal of magical thinking going on in our daily affairs. As we will see in chapter 12 (“Magic, Sorcery and Witchcraft”), magical thinking is a common and widespread technique we use to cope with uncertainty, anxiety and the unknown. It is a way of exerting some sort of power in situations where we feel powerless. In the West, as in primitive cultures, many of us take dreams to be serious matters that invite our attention and analysis. Freud and Jung, among other psychoanalysts, have laid great importance on dreams and how they intersect our conscious lives. People in many Dionysian cultures do not discriminate between dreams and reality as we do in the West. They do not draw distinctions between the validity of knowledge gained from ordinary sense experience and that obtained from dreams, visions, from animals, from supernatural forces, and intuition. To the aboriginal people of Australia, a dream is a real objective experience equivalent to the waking state, except that time and space are no longer obstacles. The dreamer takes the information gained from dreams as having great importance. In these cultures that regard dreams to be part of objective experience, if a man injures you in a dream, when you awake you are justified in avenging yourself against him. Similarly, in Inuit culture if you dream that you have committed an act of ill-will towards someone, you are obliged to apologize for the dreamed offense-because the dream itself is thought to carry a certain power. If a dead man visits you in a dream this is taken to be proof of his continued existence, and that he has come to you or that you have gone to visit him. According to Levy-Bruhl (1926), among the Cherokees, when a man dreams that he has been bitten by a snake, he must follow the same treatment as if he had really been bitten, for it is a witch-snake that has done the injury, and if he did not, swelling and ulceration would ensue, possibly even many years later (p. 57). Among the Tanala of Madagascar and the Mohave Indians of the Southwest United States, people tend to not make much distinction between dreams and “normal waking experiences” (Silverman, 1967). It is not uncommon for people to have intense self-absorbed states that are similar to the initiation phase that many shamans go through, in which the individual’s awareness is now that of a twilight state between waking and dreaming: his facial expression is that of absorption in ecstatic inner experiences, and his behavior is peculiar to the degree that he no longer eats or sleeps, or tends to any of the routines of life (Sullivan, 1953, p. 133). Carl Jung suggested that waking and dreaming states are part of a seamless continuum, with no clear boundary. He suggested that primitives do not distinguish between inner and outer experiences. To the primitive, “the world is a more or less fluid phenomenon within the stream of his own fantasy, where subject and object are undifferentiated and in a state of mutual interpenetration.” According to Jung (1953), the “outside”
Apollonian and Dionysian Cultures
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 31
has an a priori structure of its own that antedates all conscious experience. It is quite impossible to conceive how “experience” in the widest sense, or, for that matter, anything psychic, could originate exclusively in the outside world. The psyche is part of the inmost mystery of life, and it has its own peculiar structure and form like every other organism. Whether this psychic structure and its elements, the archetypes, ever “originated” at all is a metaphysical question and therefore unanswerable (p. 39). We know very little about the phenomenon of dreams, despite over a century of psychoanalytic and neurological research into the subject. Have you ever had a dream that seemed like, or turned out to be, a premonition? Have you ever had a dream that helped solve a problem that you were unable to solve the day before? Have you had dreams in which you vividly felt you were being visited by dead ancestors? To primitives, these sort of dream experiences are normal and expected parts of their lives. DIONYSIAN SELF-MUTILATION OR TORTURE One of the main traits of the Dionysian, according to Benedict (1934), is to “escape from the boundaries imposed on him by his five senses, to break through into another order of experience” (p. 79). One way of inducing an altered state of consciousness is to seek out various types of deprivation, torture and other ordeals. These can be a means towards breaking through the boundaries of ordinary experience to attain altered states of consciousness (Another way, intoxication, is discussed below). Many of the American Indian tribes practiced self-mutilation and various forms of self-torture as a mode of gaining visions and hence getting in touch with their guardian spirits. There might be cutting off of finger joints, cutting of strips of skin from arms and legs and other means in obtaining the vision. In village tribes it was not possible to discover a single man advanced in years who had his full number of fingers. The torture is sometimes part of the Sun Dance or other sun rituals. One might feed the sun with coin-shaped bits cut from one’s flesh. The central point of all this was a vision quest. The Dionysian mode of mortification of the flesh and other austerities helps one turn away from deriving any pleasure from the gross body, to attain a union with God and the graces that go with that. For some in the East that might mean release from the necessity of rebirth. Or, the individual might simply gain energy from some universal store and thereby be strengthened. An example of self-torture to induce an altered state of consciousness is seen among the Plains tribes of North America. According to Jilek (1982), Younger braves would propitiate supernatural agencies by the sacrifice of their pain and at the same time obtain individual spirit powers as well as the recognition of their fellow tribesmen. The devotee’s skin was pierced with sharp skewers at breast, shoulders, or back, and fastened by strong thongs to the center pole or to buffalo skulls. For many hours he would then dance while leaning back, his weight hanging at the pole, or, if attached to buffalo skulls, he would drag them around the entire camp circle. Among the Oglala Sioux, the prestige of a man depended on his having undergone the tortures of the Sun Dance and possessing the scars to prove it (p. 333). In Greek mythology, Dionysus was torn to pieces as a boy by the Titans and then was worshiped in this state as Zagreus. Nietzsche (1872/1967) says: “In this existence as a dismembered god, Dionysus possesses the dual nature of a cruel, barbarized demon and a mild, gentle ruler.” (§ 10) In India for ages there have been many full-time ascetics, imposing on themselves penance in the form of intense suffering, self-torture to a degree seen nowhere else, as a way of honoring the gods, or in return for some favor, or to acquire merit. All over India one sees men establishing themselves under trees and, by some act of severe penanceattracting many onlookers. Penitents will bury themselves in a standing position until only the head remains above ground; or walk on iron spikes; or dance and carry a kavadi on the shoulder (a heavy decorated frame of wood); or roll in the dust and rocks in the intense heat of the day. Other extreme modes observed in India include holding an arm upright for years until the tissues wither and it becomes impossible ever again to bring the arm into a normal position; walking for long distances on sharp spikes;
32 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
sleeping or “relaxing” on a bed of thorns (actually nail-like spikes); rolling hundreds of miles in sun and storm, through dust and mud; hanging for half an hour by the feet, head down, over a smoldering fire; or swinging on poles at religious festivals by a flesh-hook fastened into the muscles at the back (though the British made this practice illegal). Others will spend 90% of their time balanced on a slack wire in the forest, like laying in a hammock consisting only of a slim wire. Men who engage in severe mortification of the flesh become themselves an object of veneration and fame; miracles are attributed to them; money and food flow in. St. Simon Stylites was a Syrian saint who spent 37 years sitting for the most part on top of a high pillar. He endured the scorching heat by day and the biting frost by night, so that he might overcome evil passions and be nearer heaven. Some turn to self-denial because they are world-weary, sorrowful, miserable, discomforted in the world of strife or unhappy in domestic life. These people are called Sadhu and the practices called Sadhuism-detached from human interests, a philosophical outlook that life is an evil. They have a preference for the spiritual over the material, and believe that all phenomena is illusion, that true knowledge is gained only by contemplation and austerities. But a principal motivation for self-deprivation and self-torture, as seen across cultures, is to transcend ordinary consciousness, attain a higher state of consciousness, and come into a fuller union with the gods or the spirits that be. DIONYSIAN INTOXICATION As an alternative to self-denial, Dionysian intoxication is another way of pushing oneself into a higher state of consciousness. Benedict (1934) asserts: The desire of the Dionysian, in personal experience or in ritual, is to press through it toward a certain psychological state, to achieve excess. The closest analogy to the emotions he seeks is drunkenness, and he values the illumination of frenzy. With Blake, he believes “the path of excess leads to the palace of wisdom.” The Apollonian distrusts all this, and has often little idea of the nature of such experiences. He finds means to outlaw them from his conscious life. He “knows but one law, measure in the Hellenic sense.” He keeps the middle of the road, stays within the known map, does not meddle with disruptive psychological states (p. 79). Nietzsche (1872/1967) says that the Dionysian impulse is something like intoxication: Either under the influence of the narcotic draught, of which the songs of all primitive men and peoples speak, or with the potent coming of spring that penetrates all nature with joy, these Dionysian emotions awake, and as they grow in intensity everything subjective vanishes into complete self-forgetfulness (§ 1). Nietzsche (1872/1967) also says: In song and dance man expresses himself as a member of a higher community; he has forgotten how to walk and speak and is on the way toward flying into the air, dancing. His very gestures express enchantment. Just as the animals now talk, and the earth yields milk and honey, supernatural sounds emanate from him, too: he feels himself a god, he himself now walks about enchanted, in ecstasy, like the gods he saw walking in his dreams. He is no longer an artist, he has become a work of art: in these paroxysms of intoxication the artistic power of all nature reveals itself to the highest gratification of the primordial unity (§ 1). In Dionyian cultures we have “extravagant sexual licentiousness,” “barbarian” festivals-in which “the most savage natural instincts were unleashed, including even that horrible mixture of sensuality and cruelty which has always seemed to me to be the real ‘witches brew’” (Nietzsche, 1872/1967, § 2). Ruth Benedict notes that among the Native Americans of the Pacific Northwest, particularly the Kwakiutl of Vancouver Island, their religious ceremonies aimed for ecstasy. The chief dancer would lose normal control of
Apollonian and Dionysian Cultures
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 33
himself, froth at the mouth, tremble violently and do things that would be bizarre in a normal state. They celebrated this madness as a supernatural infusion-as a gift of the spirit, a real, supernatural friend that comes to annihilate reason. The Kwakiutl had a cult called the Cannibal Dancers. The people regarded cannibalism with repugnance, but the dance glorified the horrible and the forbidden. The dance expressed the eating of human flesh, which Benedict (1934) says was a “fitting expression of the Dionysian virtue that lies in the terrible and the forbidden” (p. 179). In the Sun Dance of today in Native American ceremonies, the rhythmic sensory stimulation, with singing and drumming, has been demonstrated to induce trance behavior among the participants. This same effect is seen in ceremonies among indigenous people in Siberia, Africa, Indonesia and elsewhere (Jilek, 1982). The Sun Dance, according to Jilek (1982), focuses on the acquisition of supernatural power which may be sought by a devotee for his own health and success, to propitiate spiritual forces, to comfort suffering and bereaved kinspeople, or to counteract evil influences. In essence, this is shamanic power, and on the basis of comparative analysis we can say that the Sun Dance has the characteristics of a shamanic initiation. It includes calling and instruction by dream visions, guidance and tutoring by a shaman, and enduring an ordeal with fasting, thirsting, and painful self-torture in the quest for a personal power-vision (p. 333). Jung (1971) has this commentary on Nietsche’s conception of Dionysian culture: The Dionysian impulse... means the liberation of unbounded instinct, the breaking loose of the unbridled dynamism of animal and divine nature; hence in the Dionysian rout man appears as a satyr, god above and goat below. The Dionysian is the horror of the annihilation of the principium individuationis [principal of individuation] and at the same time “rapturous delight” in its destruction. It is therefore comparable to intoxication, which dissolves the individual into his collective instincts and components-an explosion of the isolated ego through the world. Hence, in the Dionysian orgy, man finds man: “alienated Nature, hostile or enslaved, celebrates once more her feast of reconciliation with her prodigal son - Man.” Each feels himself “not only united, reconciled, merged with his neighbour, but one with him.” His individuality is entirely obliterated. “Man is no longer the artist, he has become the work of art.” “All the artistry of Nature is revealed in the ecstasies of intoxication.” Which means that the creative dynamism, libido in instinctive form, takes possession of the individual as though he were an object and uses him as a tool or as an expression of itself. It is permissible to conceive the natural creature as a “work of art,” then of course man in the Dionysian state has become a natural work of art too; but in so far as the natural creature is decidedly not a work of art in the ordinary sense of the word, he is nothing but sheer Nature, unbridled, a raging torrent, not even an animal that is restricted to itself and the laws of its being (pp. 138139). As mentioned above, we have a paradox: on the one hand, the Dionysian is a rugged individualist, yet, through intoxication or through ascetic practices the individual is destroyed and becomes merged with the collective. The Dionysian side makes one “forget both himself and his humanity” and turns one “into a mere creature of instinct” (Jung, 1971, p. 140). Jung (1971) goes on to describe the Dionysian’s psychological qualities: “a streaming outwards and upwards, a diastole, as Goethe called it; a motion embracing the whole world, as Schiller also describes it in his ‘Ode to Joy’” (p. 143): Approach, ye millions, and embrace! To the whole world my kiss shall swell! ... All the world may draughts of joy
34 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
From the breasts of Nature take; Good and ill alike employ Pains to trace joy’s rosy wake. Kisses gave she and the grape, And the faithful, lifelong friend; Even the worm its joy can shape, Heavenwards the cherubs wend. (as quoted in Jung, 1971, p. 143) Jung goes on to say: This is Dionysian expansion. It is a flood of overpowering universal feeling which bursts forth irresistibly, intoxicating the senses like the strongest wine. It is intoxication in the highest sense of the word.... What breaks out in this state has more the character of pure affect, something instinctive and blindly compelling, that finds specific expression in an affection of the bodily sphere (p. 144). APOLLONIAN CULTURES In contrast, we have Apollonian cultures. These embrace moderation, measured attitudes, not rocking the boat, sticking to the middle of the road, the known map, and avoiding messing with psychological states. People are committed to precedent, to tradition. There is distrust of individualism. Individualism is disruptive and uncongenial to the society’s institutions, even if it refines upon and enlarges the tradition itself. We mentioned in Chapter 1, many cultures are tradition-bound, and this is an Apollonian trait. In these cultures people are conformity-directed, and group norms are expected to be observed by everyone. There is no “struggle” for a separate personal identity. To diverge from the values of the community would be considered disloyal. In these cultures power comes from cult membership, verbatim ritual, conformity, sobriety, and moderation. At the same time, many of these cultures are predominately, paradoxically, Dionysian, although “acting out” in intoxicating ways and the breaking of rules is only allowed during Dionysian rituals. The self-denial in Apollonian cultures does not have the transcendental goal that it has in Dionysian cultures. Rather, it is an end in itself. Nietzsche (1872/1967) says that Apollo “shows us how necessary is the entire world of suffering, that by means of it the individual may be impelled to realize the redeeming vision, and then, sunk in contemplation of it, sit quietly in his tossing bark, amid the waves.” (§ 4) In Apollonian cultures there is a “measured restraint, that freedom from the wilder emotions, that calm of the sculptor god” (Nietzshe, 1872/1967, § 1). Schopenhauer says: “Just as in a stormy sea that, unbounded in all directions, raises and drops mountainous waves, howling, a sailor sits in a boat and trusts in his frail bark: so in the midst of a world of torments the individual human being sits quietly, supported by and trusting in the principium individuationis [principle of individuation].” (as quoted in Nietzsche, 1872/1967, § 1) Jung (1971) has this comment to Nietzsche’s conception: The Apollonian impulse produces the state comparable to dreaming, the Dionysian the state comparable to intoxication. By “dreaming” Nietzsche means, as he himself says, essentially an “inward vision,” the “lovely semblance of dream-worlds.” Apollo “rules over the beautiful illusion of the inner world of
Apollonian and Dionysian Cultures
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 35
fantasy,” he is “the god of all shape-shifting powers.” He signifies measure, number, limitation, and subjugation of everything wild and untamed. “One might even describe Apollo himself as the glorious divine image of the principium individuationis.” (p. 138) Jung adds: ...[T]he Apollonian is a perception of inner images of beauty, of measure, of controlled and proportioned feelings. The comparison with dreaming clearly indicates the character of the Apollonian state: it is a state of introspection, of contemplation turned inwards to the dream world of eternal ideas, and hence a state of introversion (p. 144). The dreamlike introspection of Apollonian culture is an illusion, has a plastic cookie-cutter quality; whereas the dreams in the Dionysian world are full-blown, bigger than life, expansive, breaking through limitations, and taken to be real. COMPARISON OF DIONYSIAN AND APOLLONIAN PATTERNS As we have seen, there are contradictory and paradoxical aspects between Dionysian and Apollonian cultures. Perhaps the best key words for Dionysian are “individualism” and “intoxication,” while the best key words for Apollonian are “group conformity” and “introvertism.” Yet this is inadequate, for in both instances there are contradictions. The Dionysian will seek a collective unity, a wholeness, in going into an altered state of consciousness-which seems the opposite of individualism. The Dionysian in fact might seek this through asceticism, suffering, self-torture or this might be sought through intoxication, ecstatic orgies, dancing, wild excesses. The Dionysian, if practicing asceticism as a means of transcendence of sensate experiences, must be controlled and measured in order to do so-Apollonian traits. As Nietzsche (1872/1967) points out, perhaps Dionysian transcendence is due to a narcotic influence, of which the songs of all primitive men and peoples speak, or with the potent coming of spring that penetrates all nature with joy, these Dionysian emotions awake, and as they grow in intensity everything subjective vanishes into complete self-forgetfulness.” (§ 1) Nietzsche (1872/1967) further points out: In song and in dance man expresses himself as a member of a higher community; he has forgotten how to walk and speak and is on the way towards flying into the air, dancing. His very gestures express enchantment. Just as the animals now talk, and the earth yields milk and honey, supernatural sounds emanate from him, too: he feels himself a god, he himself now walks about enchanted, in ecstasy, like the gods he saw walking in his dreams. He is no longer an artist, he has become a work of art: in these paroxysms of intoxication the artistic power of all nature reveals itself to the highest gratification of the primordial unity. The noblest clay, the most costly marble, man, is here kneaded and cut, and to the sound of the chisel strokes of the Dionysian world-artist rings out the cry of the Eleusian mysteries: ‘Do you prostrate yourselves, millions? Do you sense your Maker, world?’ (§ 1) The Apollonian is tradition bound, controlled, introspective, and does not rock the boat-seeking ideas from the dream world. Too, the Dionysian relies on the dream world, but not so much as part of introverted thinking; rather, as a means of enlightenment, of communication with the spirit world. The Dionysian, by identifying with nature, by closely interpreting dreams-does not do so to be introspective, but to break through to a higher consciousness and to experience a collective unity. The Apollonian influence is the stoic, emotionless, balanced, measured, purely intellectual influence in culture. It is represented in rationality, mathematical precision and the intellect. Seeking of scientific truth is Apollonian. In contrast, the Dionysian revels in the truths reaped through experiencing the passions to their fullest rather than denying or controlling them. Thus there is a duality, “just as procreation depends on the duality of the sexes, involving perpetual strife with only periodically intervening reconciliations” (Nietzsche, 1872/1967, § 1).
36 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
The calm repose of Apollo is a sublime expression-and Apollo himself might be called “the glorious divine image of the principium individuationis [principle of individuation], through whose gestures and eyes all the joy and wisdom of “illusion,” together with its beauty, speak to us” (Nietzsche, 1872/1967, § 1).
PART II. PRIMITIVE BELIEFS, PRACTICES AND RITUALS
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man, 2010, 37-48
37
CHAPTER 4 Mana Abstract. The idea of mana permeates the customs of many cultures, including modern cultures. Mana provides the theoretical basis for such beliefs as animism, totemism, witchcraft, and sorcery. Mana is the means by which power is transmitted from one being to another. It means, roughly speaking, power, but a force altogether distinct from physical power-a power associated with a spirit, a totemic ancestor, or other supernatural agency. All things are thought to possess a “vital essence” that can be transferred by contact. Mana is thought to be expressed most notably through thoughts and words, and this is evident in shamanic healing, folk medicine, or simply prayer intended for healing. The conviction of a person uttering an incantation is thought to be an element relating to the efficacy of a prayer, curse or ritual. There is widespread belief that mana subsists in names, as well as in artifacts, tools and weapons. A club or spear of a great warrior, for example, is the abode of powerful mana. Objects such as amulets and charms are thought to be imbued with mana, either intrinsically, or after being consecrated for certain purposes, usually for the purpose of averting evil or to secure good fortune.
WHAT IS MANA? The mystical orientation of primitive cultures attributes the success or failure of things to unseen powers. In order to understand primitive ways of thinking, a good starting point is the concept of mana. The idea of mana permeates the customs and practices of many cultures, in many ways, and as we will see it is is evident in modern cultures as well. Mana provides the theoretical basis for such beliefs as animism, totemism, witchcraft, and sorcery. Mana is the means by which power is transmitted from one being to another, from one soul to another, from a sacred space to the people around it, and so forth. Mana is the means in which magic has causal efficacy. Mana means melesian psysis or phyo, “to bring forth.” It is also thought to be derived from a Maori term. It is difficult to find English equivalents. It means, roughly speaking, power. It is equivalent to the New Testament pneuma, or Holy Spirit or Holy Ghost. The term “manna” in the Bible is a different word, but some like to link the two terms. “Manna” was the miraculous food that God gave the Israelites. Psalm 78:24 begins, “And he rained down on them manna to eat” (English Standard Version). The anthropologist R. H. Codrington (1891) has this description of mana: There is a belief in a force altogether distinct from physical power, which acts in all kinds of ways for good and evil, and which it is of the greatest advantage to possess or control. This is mana... It is a power or influence, not physical, and in a way supernatural; but it shows itself in physical force, or in any kind of power or excellence which a man possesses (pp. 118-120). Further, mana is not fixed in anything, and can be conveyed in almost anything. It works to affect everything which is beyond the ordinary power of men, outside the common processes of nature, it is present in the atmosphere of life, attaches itself to persons and to things, and is manifested by results which can only be ascribed to its operation (Codrington, 1891, p. 119). Codrington (1891) also describes mana as that invisible power which is believed by the natives to cause all such effects as transcend the regular course of nature, and to reside in spiritual beings, whether in the spiritual part of living men or in the ghosts of the dead, being imparted by them to their names and to various things that belong to them (p. 191). John Alan Cohan All rights reserved - © 2010 Bentham Science Publishers Ltd.
38 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
Codrington (1891) adds: If a man has been successful in fighting, it has not been his natural strength of aim, quickness of eye, or readiness of resource that has won success; he has certainly got the mana of a spirit or of some deceased warrior to empower him, conveyed in an amulet of stone around his neck, or a tuft of leaves in his belt, in a tooth hung from a finger of his bow hand, or in a form of words with which he brings supernatural assistance to his side. If a man’s pigs multiply, and his gardens are productive, it is not because he is industrious and looks after his property, but because of the stones full of mana for pigs and yams that he possesses. Of course a yam naturally grows when planted, that is well known, but it will not be very large unless mana comes into play; a canoe will not be swift unless mana be brought to bear upon it, a net will not catch many fish, nor an arrow inflict a mortal wound (p. 120). Thus, mana is a supernatural power associated with a spirit, a totemic ancestor, a personality, or anything that is strong, powerful or dangerous in a ritual sense. Mana is thought of as “both a force and a material substance that can be localized; it is also spiritual-a sort of conglomerate power of force, soul, and substance in one. It is the essential nature, the influence, the potency of things in purest form” (Nemeroff & Rozin, 1994, pp. 159-160). It is a force field, a field of energy. Schwimmer (1963) found that to the indigenous Maori people, mana was “A powerful thing in the olden days-you could do nothing without it” (p. 398). He further states that mana is regarded as “[a] sort of will-power,” and that the “people who have it think no one can question them or discuss any matter concerning their lives or background” (p. 398). Things of all kinds are thought to contain and emanate mana. The mana in an object is what will provide optimal utility. According to Mauss (1902/1971), mana is “what causes the net to bring in a good catch... and keeps the canoe sailing smoothly. In the farms it is fertility; on an arrow it is the substance which kills” (p. 111). Mageo (1991) argues that mana, exerting a kind of magical power, is said to be similar to electricity in its effects: When a person with little mana comes in contact with one who has great mana, some of the charge is drained from the more highly charged member of the interaction and transferred to the lesser member. The lesser member becomes overcharged and, therefore, sick, even unto death (p. 361). Mana implies that people “transfer” some of their “vital essence” to anything they hold or come into contact with, whether clothing they wear, gardens they work in, or children they raise (Nemeroff & Rozin, 1994, p. 159). A stark example of how strong the belief in mana is is seen among the Hindus in India, where the lowest cast, the “untouchables,” are literally thought to be so inferior to other classes that contact between them and anyone of a higher cast will defile the latter. Another example is seen in families where a close kin has committed a heinous crime, such as serial murder. The family members and their offspring are thought to be polluted, shunned by others because they somehow “carry” the same “essence” of their infamous kin. Some people have especially strong force fields, others not. Shamans, witch-doctors, charismatic leaders, and ghosts are, among other entities, strong bearers of mana. Sometimes mana is used to describe a person’s power or charisma. Schwimmer (1963) offers this example: The fisherman who catches fish has mana, because success in fishing is essentially uncertain. The soldier who wins a victory, the witchdoctor who cures a patient are all, in their own spheres, prevailing over a fateful hazard (p. 398). All things, all creatures, are imbued with mana, in varying degrees. It is hard to generalize, but some people, such as shamans, have more mana than other people. Sacred objects or places have more mana than ordinary objects or places. Intuitively, in modern society we tend to place a “premium” or special value on goods and artifacts that are made in exotic places, as if “marked by the inalienable qualities associated with their unusual places or sources of origin” (Helms, 1993, p. 99).
Mana
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 39
In primitive cultures it is thought that people’s mana can be retained or increased, and also lost if they transgress certain norms. “...[I]t is hard to be a man with mana. Maintaining it in all circumstances is a constant strain” (Helms, 1993, p. 99). Many primitives are fearful of photography because the picture could capture the individual’s soul-force. The idea of mana seems intuitive. Anyone-and that is most of us-who can sense an “energy field” or “force field” that other people give off is sensing mana. Our energy field or “aura” seems to extend quite a distance. In public places there is a lot of energy intersecting, and that helps explain why one feels exhausted after visiting crowded public places. If you believe in prayer or ESP-you must also believe in mana. ESP or thought transference takes into account the idea that thoughts are mana that have an effect at a distance. Even Freud (1933) thought that psychic phenomena such as telepathy was a real perception: Naturally not all cases have equal evidential value, nor in all cases is it equally possible to rule out more rational explanations; but taking all the evidence together there remains a heavy weight of probability in favour of the reality of thought-transference (p. 63). Mana helps explain how thoughts made in prayer are conveyed from the supplicant’s mind to the intended god or gods. If you believe that certain objects-such as heirlooms in your family or objects owned by a deceased person you loved, or objects owned by famous people-have a special feel or a special value, you must believe in mana. When we touch objects we impart some of our own mana into the objects, thus making them a kind of extension or embodiment of ourselves. If one loses something there often is a deep sense of grief above and beyond the material value involved. Some people are “packrats” or compulsive hoarders and can’t part with anything in their home, not even letters, receipts, bills or old medication, due to some strange inexplicable sentimental attachment. Sometimes people hoard things for fear that something bad will happen if possessions are discarded. Perhaps this can be explained because their own mana, their essence, and those of loved ones, impregnates these objects. The objects take on a life, a vitality, from the mana that has been absorbed in them. One is thus reluctant to throw them away, for they contain the life force of oneself or others. One identifies with these objects. Even the most neglected object has an intrinsic dignity of its own, so that it would be “murder” to throw it in the trash. In modern society, when a loved one dies we tend to want to cherish things that belonged to that person. The personal effects of the deceased become treasured items because they are imbued with the mana of the deceased. Thus, mana helps to explain why we attach great sentimental value to family heirlooms that, in and of themselves, might have have little intrinsic worth. The fact that an heirloom was worn by one’s grandmother, even if it is an ordinary ring of little value, makes it special in terms of the energy it contains. Perhaps a touching example of the special value associated with objects owned by the deceased involves a slain marine’s parents, who adopted a military dog wounded in Iraq in the same rocket attack that killed their son. The family adopted the bomb-sniffing German shepherd named Lex who was granted early retirement. The soldier’s mother said she believed that her son’s spirit would live on through the dog because of their close bond and because they were together during the final moments of her son’s life. “It was blood on blood. We can’t get Dustin back, but we have Lex” (Associated Press, 2007). Another example of mana in modern society is that people everywhere think that something bearing the autograph of a famous person somehow has unique intrinsic value. The same can be said of clothing, furnishings and other objects owned by famous people. Such objects command premium prices at auctions, particularly if the person has died. By the way, this is true whether the individual is famous or infamous-whether a Hitler or a Michael Jackson-in either case the property becomes more valuable after the person dies. Perhaps mana helps explain why some people get homesick when they are away. Everyone has at one time or another experienced being homesick. It is a situation where one is away from home and feels listless, unhappy,
40 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
anxious-and there is a strong longing to return home. Why should this be? Mana supplies an explanation: One’s home is imbued with the mana of one’s family and of oneself. To be cut off from this energy field is like being deprived of a certain vital force that nourishes you, so that there is a feeling of longing to be back at home. Mana could be the explanation of a recent study published in the British Medical Journal (Fowler & Christakis, 2008) showing that happiness can spread from person to person within social networks. That is, the happiness of others can cause happiness for oneself. The study showed that “happy people tend to be connected to one another,” that there is an “emotional contagion” that can be transferred from one person to another. The reverse is true. Having a depressed roommate, for instance, can over a relatively short time result in emotional contagion of the depression. As between strangers happiness is said to be contagious even in fleeting contact, such as when a waiter or clerk provides service with a happy demeanor. And within the framework of a social network consisting of friends and friends of friends, there is significant evidence that happiness of a remote person in the network-a friend of a friend, for example-is contagious even when there is some social distance between people. If a co-worker wins the lottery and is elated about it, others in the workplace who are not close to the individual will share a happy feeling, more then enough to override the ordinary feelings of envy that often erupt in such cases. The bottom line of the report is that one’s personal happiness depends in large part on whether others in one’s social network are happy. “Happiness, in other words, is not merely a function of individual experience or individual choice but is also a property of groups of people.” (Fowler & Christakis, 2008). The scientists who conducted this study were unable to explain their findings. However, mana provides a simple and persuasive explanation. Since good or bad mana can be absorbed by objects, sometimes we see a fetishism that deeply influences people. For instance, even in modern urban settings, we see a pattern of demolishing structures where bad situations have taken place-such as school shootings, the office building of the Oklahoma City bombing, and so on. In Israel the government has had a long-standing policy of demolishing or sealing houses that belong to the families of Palestinians who had gone on deadly rampages or committed a security offense (Kershner, 2009). Many believe that if a crime is committed in a particular space, such as a particular room, or in a yard, or in a church, that the space thereby becomes polluted, and a special act of reconciliation or consecration is necessary before it can be used again. The idea is that the place is imbued with the misfortune that occurred there, and if not destroyed or purified ritually, other occupants will suffer from the vibes or experience the same fate. Realtors are often required by law to inform prospective buyers if a murder has taken place in a house being offered for sale. Another example consists of “killing fields” where massacres have occurred against innocent people. Permission to build a hotel on a site used by Nazis in Kiev, where more than 33,700 Jews were shot to death over a two-day period in 1941, and where, in a ravine an estimated 100,000 bodies were deposited in the ensuing months-was rejected by authorities due to public outcry (Associated Press, 2009). Often such sites are dedicated to the public as memorial parks or given protection as historic sites. And in English common law there was the doctrine of deodand, meaning “given to God.” Under this law any personal property found by a jury of twelve to have immediately caused the death of a person or animal would be forfeit to the king, and the proceeds given to alms. Thus, if a horse and cart run over and kill someone, the objects would be forfeit; or if someone is accidentally killed with a sword, or falls from a ladder and is killed, the sword or the ladder would be forfeit; and so on. Objects that have been touched by saints or other holy people are thought to be especially powerful vehicles for conveying graces and blessings. All over the world, the relics of saints are revered, kissed, put on display, and prayed to. Holy relics continue to be thought of as fetishes that have the power to cure illness and to protect against danger. Mere images, pictures, statutes of saints are similarly credited with miraculous efficacy. And certain objects in nature are thought to be particularly rich in mana. Stones or objects of striking or unusual shape or appearance are thought to have the power of increasing their possessor’s soul-stuff and protecting against evil spirits, and are carried about on one’s person as amulets (We will discuss amulets and other protective fetishes in chapter 9, “Envy and the Evil Eye”).
Mana
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 41
There is a great deal of mana emitted in music. Music is important in all cultures, and is very important in the rituals of medicine men and shamans. Music and its concomitants-singing, playing of instruments, dancing-are potent vehicles for healing, for attaining altered states of consciousness and for producing other results in rituals. Howard (2002), found: To Aristotle, flute music aroused the emotions and offered cathartic release. To Cassiodorus, music in the aeolian mode could treat mental ailments, while the lydian mode was suitable for soothing children. AlKindik, the 9th century Islamic philosopher, described “celestial harmonics” created by a universal chorus built from the vibrating rays emitted by all entities. Boethius, in the 6th century, described the healing properties of music; this evolved as the four humours of Renaissance musicology and the harmony of the spheres in the French Age of Enlightenment. Marsilio Ficino (1433-1499) took from Plotinus to describe the “magic of music”. Plato, in The Republic, discussed the use of modes to create a reign of moderation, and in Elements of Harmony organised his zodiacal calendar according to musical scales. To Baroque composers, keys described moods and emotions. Isaac Newton, taking from Descartes, saw musical pitch as an organising force in the universe.... Alfred Nieman argued that composed music provides the stimulus on which “the unconscious mind receiving [it] acts as a catalyst and returns the music back to its original symbolic nature.” (pp. 66-67) The evil eye is a belief in many cultures that people (and even animals) can cause harm simply by looking enviously at another person or admiring someone’s possessions. This is explained by mana, a power that emanates from the eyes. If someone, particularly a stranger, admires something belonging to a neighbor-whether an animal, a child or anything else-this look from the eyes, in and of itself, has power to produce harm (see Chapter 9, “Envy and the Evil Eye”). Related to this is the idea that distinct types of mana reside in various parts of the body such as the eyes, the organs, hair, nails, saliva, etc., and might be called “soul-stuff” According to Chapman (1921): The soul pervades the whole body, all the members of which are sharers in the soul-stuff, and therefore have a life of their own, a feeling of their own, and a will of their own. It is not the man who sees and hears and walks and breathes, but the eye sees, the ear hears, the foot walks and the mouth breathes. It is not the man who feels pain, but the part of the body where the pain is located.... In man and beast this soul-stuff is found specially abundant in the head.... Head hunting has its root in this idea. The vital power and courage of the dead man is appropriated by him who possesses his skull.... There is much soul-stuff in the blood, for life ebbs away with the blood.... Strength is imparted by drinking the blood of the slain foe.... There is a mysterious connection between the placenta and the child.... The decayed piece of umbilical cord is carefully preserved. The hair also contains much soul power, and is therefore not cut by the heathen.... Saliva is medicinal, because it contains soul power.... The sweat also, as a secretion of the body, contains soul-stuff.... The souls of men, animals, plants and even those of lifeless things invigorate one another. One can augment or invigorate one’s own soul-stuff through that of others (pp. 299-300). This idea is reflected in cultures that believe the spit of a sick person must not be burned for it will take away some of the person’s vitality; the hair must not be burned for the same reason. Old people sometimes put their spit into the mouths of children to bring them good luck; if someone is fortunate or lucky, one will ask him to spit into one’s mouth; sick people are breathed upon by the healthy in order to bring them healthy soul-stuff. If the sick person is too far gone, they won’t do it lest their souls should be entangled with the departing soul and leave them. The above quotation suggests that the organs of the human body have a certain mana, a certain personality or an autonomous identity. Today, transplants of organs from one person to another is a fairly common surgical procedure. The question arises-to what extent, if any does the spirit of the donor or personality of the donor, say, in a heart transplant, transfer itself to the recipient of the organ? Is it possible that the donee might have a new outlook on things in virtue of the soul-stuff in the donated organ? There is much anecdotal and scientific evidence in support of the idea of “cellular memory,” in which the donor’s spirit has not yet “moved on” (Sylvia, 1997; Pearsall, 1998; Pearsall, Schwartz, & Russek, 2000). Linton (2003), for example, asserts:
42 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
...[B]ecause of the suddenness of many donor’s deaths, the donor’s spirit may not have yet realized that its body is dead. Thus, the transplanted heart continues to function as if it were in its original body, not realizing that its original owner is no longer there. A typical example of how seriously people take the idea of mana is seen in Nepal, where a 10-day festival called Chhechu consists of sportive plays and rituals. This culminates in the distribution by Buddhist lamas of “power balls” (wang ro ro) to the principal headman, allies, their wives, and villagers who participate. These balls are made of dough, are placed on the altar, and are thought to get infused with power during the festival. People then make the dough into images of various gods, and take them home to place in grain storage rooms to ensure plentiful grain, abundance, and good health (Holmberg, 2000). MANA IN THOUGHTS AND WORDS The primitive mind attributes extraordinary power to thoughts and words, particularly by the magician or shaman. We have all heard the expression, “Thoughts are things.” And thoughts, of course, consist of words. Many books have been written about the power of thoughts, the “science of mind”-how to become rich through mastering one’s power of the mind. Many people practice auto-suggestion in meditation or self-hypnosis, repeating words such as “I am whole,” “I am free of pain,” or “I am becoming prosperous.” The affirmation of the words is believed to help produce the reality. The primitive mind totally embraces this point of view. This is perhaps an ancient truth: that words themselves have a special power or mana, above and beyond the literal meaning of the words. Whether for good or for evil, words are thought to have real power to produce the condition they evoke. This is particularly true in cultures that believe in shamanic healing, folk medicine, or simply prayer intended for healing. The underlying theme is that healing power can be transmitted through ritual language and objects that are imbued with healing energy. Tembiah (1968) has offered this: Since words exist and are in a sense agents in themselves which establish connexions and relations between both man and man, and man and the world, and are capable of “acting” upon them, they are one of the most realistic representations we have of the concept of force which is either not directly observable or is a metaphysical notion which we find necessary to use (p. 184). The idea that words, in and of themselves, have power to produce effects in their own right is expressed in this passage of Isaiah (55.11): “... So shall my word be that goeth forth out of my mouth: it shall not return unto me void, but it shall accomplish that which I please, and it shall prosper in the thing whereto I sent it.” And the beginning of the Gospel According to St. John famously tells of that the Word (Greek notion of logos) was in the beginning with God, that the Word was made flesh in Jesus Christ, and that those who followed Christ became the sons of God, and so on. A great example of the mana as word-power is found in the words, Hoc est corpus meum-the words of consecration in the Mass. According to Catholic tradition, simply by uttering these words during the Mass the bread and wine thereby turn into the body and blood of Christ, even if the priest is thinking about something else or is not in a state of grace. In healing ceremonies of various religions, the ritual use of words is thought to have a healing effect, particularly glossolalic prayer (prayer in “tongues”). (For a discussion of charismatic healing practices, See chapter 11, “Trance and Possession States”). In Eastern meditation, the recitation of mantras is a form of ritual language believed to have a power for the individual for whom it is personally chosen, or for certain situations, certain parts of the body, or for certain social or emotional needs. Mantras are supposed to harness the power of the gods themselves. These are believed to vibrate on the ether and not on latent forces which are here. Magicians use mana to obtain control over over invisible beings and the occult powers of nature, and to exert power over persons and their belongings, either to help them or harm them. In magic, ritual words are at least as important as other actions performed by the practitioner. There is power in the words themselves, or more correctly, in the
Mana
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 43
words when uttered in a ritual context, with appropriate intention (For a full discussion, see chapter 12, “Magic, Sorcery and Witchcraft”). Thoughts alone can be powerful enough to work harm on another-and presto, the mischief is wrought. According to primitive belief, anyone has the power to affect fate by merely wishing that something should come true. Anyone can cast a spell and bewitch another merely by wishing it. Sometimes we all have made a wish in a moment of anger or impatience, wishing someone were dead-and the other person according to primitive thinking indeed could die of the wish. Desire alone has the power to kill. Voodoo death is but just one example of wishing the death of another, coupled with a special intense act of the will through the use of an effigy of the victim. The enemy is “doomed” simply by impregnating the fetish with one’s “mana” of violent intent, exercised upon the symbol (See chapter 13, “Death by Suggestion: Voodoo Death, Taboo Death, and Bone-Pointing”). THE ROLE OF THE HUMAN AGENT AND THE MEDIUM OF CONVEYANCE OF THE WORDS As mentioned, in casting a spell and in other rituals it is believed that the words alone are causally potent. But not all utterances have the same degree of power. The extent of mana emitted in the utterance of a spell, or in a shaman’s healing power or in the words of vocalization in song-depend on the intention behind the human agent. The conviction or faith of the individual reciting the words-whether in a curse or of a prayer-may be critical. Thus, some healers are more effective than others, not so much because of the words they use, but because of the energy or force of will they bring to the ritual. The more forcefully the shaman sings the chant, the more strongly the witch wishes something to happen-the greater the efficacy of the energy being generated. And the words of a magician can have especial potency if uttered not just into space, but into a substance associated with the the victim. Westermarck (1906), argues: The efficacy of a wish or curse depends not only on the potency which it possesses from the beginning, owing to certain qualities in the person from whom it originates, but also on the vehicle by which it is conducted-just as the strength of an electric shock depends both on the original intensity of the current and on the condition of the conductor (p. 586). The magician can utter the words of a curse-silently or out loud-directing this into the ether, or directing it into an object which becomes “contaminated” with the energy. Therefore, magicians will seek to obtain drops of the person’s blood, nail or hair clippings, food leavings, saliva, sweat, a portrait, a piece of clothing that has the victim’s smell on it, or even a footprint. All alike become vehicles of the ritual forces conveyed by the magician’s words or actions. In Fiji a medicine-man who wishes to do harm will stab at foot prints of the victim, in turn causing him to get foot trouble. One always splits open the coconut after drinking from it, before throwing it away, or else a medicine-man could find it and work a spell on the drinker; opening it up causes the emanation of oneself which entered at drinking to escape. In voodoo an effigy of the individual to be cursed is “filled” with the words of the voodoo priest. The magician might silently transmit evil intent directly in the presence of the victim-by touching him, or uttering a spell over the subject’s footprint, or through some other medium such as blood, saliva, food leavings, or a drink in which the curse is transmitted. Thus, in many cultures people will secretly bury the remains of their food so that no residue of the meal might be utilized by someone to cast a magic spell. It may also be important for the person seeking healing to have a reverential, hopeful attitude in the ceremony, particularly in in shamanic healing, where the patient is a central participant. As we will see in chapter 14 (“The Placebo Effect”), often the patient’s attitude-whether of optimism or despair-can dramatically affect the efficacy of the healing regimen. On the other hand, in ordinary prayer people usually do not think that the cooperation or even knowledge of the person prayed for is relevant in order for the healing energy to do its work. THE NATURE OF A CURSE Cursing occurs when someone seeks to inflict harm upon another by the mere enunciation of hostile words, backed by a powerful intention. The belief in curses is as old as mankind. Anyone can do it, either silently or out loud.
44 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
The power of God to bestow curses is seen throughout the Old Testament (e.g., the plagues of Egypt). The power of the Church to declare someone excommunicated is in effect a curse. In Richard Wagner’s Ring of the Niebelungen the dwarf, Alberich, gets the whole drama going by uttering a curse on the ring he has made from the Rhinemaidens’ gold, when it was taken from him by the god, Wotan-and during the remainder of the story anyone who possessed the ring met a violent death. The motivation for issuing a curse is vengeance. The poor and injured who are too weak to avenge themselves use this power as a means of retaliation; it is a method of the weak against the strong. A curse might take the form of a fervent prayer that a heavy vengeance befall someone for some transgression such as unjust treatment. One of the first things that people ponder if they think they have come under a curse is who in the community might have a grudge against them-and that person will be the prime suspect of witchcraft. In primitive cultures, the mere knowledge that a curse has been uttered against someone has dramatic, even fatal consequences-so deep is the belief in its efficacy (See Chapter 13, “Death by Suggestion: Voodoo Death, Taboo Death, and Bone-Pointing”). Arabs, when being cursed, will lie on the ground so that the curse may fly over them. The opposite of a curse is a blessing. A blessing, too, usually takes the form of words and contains mana-a power of an entirely different order than a curse, and is usually accompanied with a full heart. MANA IN NAMES The belief in the power behind names lies at the root of fetishism, idolatry, witchcraft, and shamanism. Each of our names has mana. Our name is an entity, an integral part of ourselves. To know someone’s name is to have power over that person. In primitive cultures the people prize a person’s real name beyond all other names associated with the individual. Life for the primitives is often a struggle, and people are ever on the watch against maliciousworking agencies. Thus, primitive people do not disclose their names to strangers. There are various precautions to conceal their names, especially from enemies. Sometimes they will adopt a pseudonym, concealing their true name from all but their closest kin. In many cultures women will not even utter their husband’s name. In many cultures parents will give an unpleasant or hateful name to children to make the envious spirits believe that the child is inferior. There is a Chinese custom of giving a girl’s name to boys to deceive the gods, or calling the child such derogatory things as “little pig,” or “little dog” (Clodd, 1920, p. 99). Numerous mystical names and titles are attached to Jesus Christ-such as the Good Shepherd, King of the Patriarchs, Joy of Angels, and Master of the Apostles. In the Lord’s Prayer we find the following reference to God: “Hallowed by thy Name.” In the Jewish tradition it is blasphemy to utter God’s name, and in the Ten Commandments we are warned: “Thou shalt not take the name of the Lord thy God in vain...” In 1913 a monk named Ilarion at the monastery of St. Pantelemon, on Mt. Athos put forward the theory that the Name of God is an integral part of God, and, therefore, itself divine. This idea was denounced by the Archbishop (and referred to as the “Heresy of God’s Name”) The names of places also have mana that express the power or energy of the place. For example, the natives of Greenland had the custom of not speaking the name of a glacier as they rowed past it, for fear that it would be offended and cast off an iceberg (Clodd, 1920, p. 99). For the Nivkh people of Southeast Siberia each dwelling has a spirit or patron saint. Each structural feature of the home is given a name of symbolic significance and is used in rituals. Each of the seven windows has a name indicating both its location and symbolic association. Posts, beams, sleeping benches and above all, fire places, have a name (Black, 1973). MANA AND HEAD-HUNTING Head-hunting was a prized activity in many parts of the world, as a means of showing bravery or of acquiring the “soul substance” of the victim in order to prolong one’s own life, or simply to wreak vengeance against enemies. In Papua New Guinea the main motivation in head-hunting, was to acquire a “head-name”-the name of the victim whose head has been acquired (van der Kroef, 1952).
Mana
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 45
In killing someone, the head-hunter is entitled to transfer the name of the victim to his child or a friend. In Papua New Guinea there was great social pressure, and indeed it was a moral duty, for fathers to acquire a head-name for each of his children. The head-name becomes a badge of honor, indeed a prized status symbol, with whom the bearer becomes completely identified. The name of the victim of course has to be ascertained. Usually killing was done by ruse-pretending to be friendly to individuals casually met on the beach or in the forest, eat a meal with them, talk about their places of origin, find out their names-and the hunter will suddenly attack his victim and take his head. Or, spies would be sent to the outskirts of a village to observe its life and to learn the names of some of the villagers. Sometimes in a dawn raid of a village, people who are captured alive were secured and placed in a group in order to determine their names before killing them. Or, survivors of the village, especially children, would be forced to tell the names of the victims who had been killed. Elaborate preparations were made for raids. A formal proposal to go on a head-hunt was placed before the village council, the elders are consulted, a targeted village is decided upon, and the time of the raid is decided upon. In raids, head-hunters would spare children, who would then be adopted by the wives of the hunters. But women and men alike were killed, and when feasible, this was done by beheading. In any event, the heads were always severed and taken home. Cannibalism, however, was not very common to the people of Papua New Guinea. Before bringing the heads home, they were prepared for preservation on the spot. They were dried, filled with clay and grass, the eye sockets filled with shells or beads, and the brain cavities emptied. This required much skill. At home there was always a great celebration. The heads were hung in the men’s house and viewed by the elders. People tell their stories. Preparations for an elaborate feast ensue-sometimes taking months of preparation. Among the Ilongots, a horticultural and hunting people in Northern Luzon, Philippines, headhunters justified their practices as follows, according to Rosaldo (1983): In severing and tossing human heads, Ilongot men recount, they could relieve hearts burdened with the “weight” of insult, envy, pain, and grief; and in discarding “heavy” thoughts, they could achieve an “anger” that yields “energy,” makes shy and burdened youths “the same” or equal to their peers, and “lightens” both their footsteps and the feelings in their hearts (p. 137). MANA AND WEAPONS, TOOLS, AND ARTIFACTS In many cultures there is a certain kind of power associated with weapons, tools and many types of artifacts. It is thought that mana resides in some of these objects. A club or spear of a great warrior, for example, is the abode of powerful mana. Some claim that a chief’s weapon will continually vibrate with convulsive movements when sitting at rest. In addition, the clothing, utensils and other possessions of a good hunter convey virtue. The potent mana from a weapon can be conveyed to another person: In Tonga, for example, the owner of a weapon endowed with supernatural force will lay it across the open palm of someone, then rub and squeeze the stem of a banana tree in his hands to express the juice, then rub that over the weapon and the hand of the other person. This conveys the power from the weapon to the other person. In Richard Wagner’s opera, Siegfried, the sword that Siegfried fashions from broken fragments left by his father-possesses unsurpassed strength. Often the object is thought of as having a symbiotic relationship with the human body, particularly the person who has made or uses the object. According to Telban (1998): The ‘life’ of things such as small canoes, stools, paddles, spears, adzes for pulverizing sago, axes, bush knives, hand drums, mats, baskets, body decorations, and so on is derivative in that it depends on the life of humans. Most of this equipment is handled only by those who own them, and the identities of these things are determined by the people who use them. A thing becomes ‘something’ only when a person uses it.... A typical round stool, for example, becomes a part of the person who sits on it, absorbs his ‘dirt’, and is not supposed to be used by anyone else. While being used, a thing ‘gives something’ to its user.... A
46 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
paddle, for instance, gives its user the ability to move a canoe on the river, its usefulness gives existence, identity, and value to the paddle (p. 162). Often people will have a blessing ceremony performed “whenever an important object such as a canoe or a men’s house is completed, or when an outboard motor or gun is acquired. In this way the thing receives a name and becomes a being itself” (Telban, 1998, p. 105). The custom of patting and rubbing a gun or other implement that has fallen to the ground is to restore the soul that has suffered a shock, just as a man’s soul is restored under the same circumstances. During his voyage to search for the Northwest Passage, Captain Cook encountered a king on the Tonga Islands who took particular liking to the ship’s pewter plates. The king wanted to replace his old wooden bowl with a pewter plate from Captain Cook’s kitchen. The king’s bowl was considered a sacred vessel to which the natives paid homage during the king’s absence, as if directly to the king. The bowl was also used as a mode of trial by ordeal: people accused of a crime would be summoned, one by one, and asked to touch the bowl. If the guilty man touched the vessel he would fall dead on the spot; and if he refused to touch the bowl he would be adjudged guilty (Hildebrand, 1927, p. 127). The Huichol Indians of the rugged Sierra Madre mountains in northwest Mexico have for generations made beautiful yarn paintings that are intended to function as prayers. They believe the paintings have the power to bring about whatever is painted on them-often personal dreams or visions of the artist. Their art has been exhibited in museums and galleries throughout the world and is now sold all around the world (Maclean, 2005). MANA AND MASKS Masks are in widespread use in cultures throughout the world in spectacular ceremonies to appease the forces of nature, often during which there is the intense release of emotions, that, if successful, will allay their fears. In these cultures people are often preoccupied with primordial fears to do with forces that cause catastrophies, misfortune and illness. These ceremonies of appeasement dominate the lives of primitive peoples throughout Melanesia, in many parts of Africa, and in quite a few other regions of the world. The mask of a dead man is said to contain his spirit; mourners will bring the mask into the men’s house so that his spirit can be installed there (Gewertz & Errington, 1991, p. 136). In other cultures, such as the Ammassalik Inuits of Western Greenland, masks are not employed to appease the forces of nature, but are part of folk dances. The people are fond of dancing with masks, or using masks to scare children. Masks are works of art, often in bold coloring, embodying different legends and ideals of the people. The artist will usually have an outpouring of emotion in crafting the mask. Often the masks will have distorted, highly stylized superhuman features, sometimes with animal features, with bizarre, weird, elated or frightening expressions intended to be part of a dramatic ritual that relates to supernatural forces. These ceremonies are of all kinds: to accompany the initiation of young men into the secret societies, to placate or worship the gods, to honor ancestral spirits, to insure a successful harvest, to ward off sickness, hunger or calamity. Those who wear the masks in the ceremonies are thought to become channels between the people and the spirits, as they do their terrifying dances, accompanied by singing and drumming by the crowd. Often the masks will be in the custody of leaders of the society, and the masks themselves are thought to embody the accumulated wisdom of the people (Kaeppler, 1963). People in Malaysia use expressionistic masks with exaggerated features, with maximum use of color contrast (e.g., black, white and red), faces with terrorizing grimaces, a nervous intense look well calculated to inspire fear and awe. In the Solomon Islands and part of Papua New Guinea the masks are more formal rather than expressionistic in style (i.e., without the terrifying, bizarre style). According to Kaeppler (1963):
Mana
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 47
The style suggests a submission to the supernatural forces of the universe, the acceptance of the unknown. Influenced by excesses all about him, the artist reflects these excesses in over-exaggeration and through exaggeration comes the emotional quality of expressionism. It is an emotional feeling that is culturally induced by ceremonies and manifested in an art style (p. 122). Masks can have an unusual effect on the wearer, “particularly in promoting unconventional and uninhibited conduct” (Honigmann, 1977, p. 274). Perhaps it is the anonymity provided by the disguise that encourages such conduct. Obviously, a criminal is likely to behave more boldly by using a mask, for this helps the culprit elude being recognized. However, in the masking ceremonies such as those mentioned above, the mask wearers are generally known since they live in a tight-knit community. Perhaps it is that “hiding behind a false face somehow gives the wearer an illusion that he himself is covered and, therefore, that his ego is not responsible for the antics of the new character” (Pollaczek & Homefield, 1954, p. 299). The wearer’s identity is separated from the behavior being enacted. Moreover, as can be seen in Carnival celebrations and in dance rituals alike, this shielding of one’s normal identity helps the individual overcome the need to conform to everyday roles and break into uninhibited behavior patterns. MANA AND PROTECTIVE FETISHES: AMULETS AND CHARMS Objects such as amulets and charms are clearly regarded as to be imbued with certain powers, either intrinsically, or after being consecrated for certain purposes, or for their symbolic significance. Their use is extremely prominent everywhere, not only among primitive cultures, but also in the developed world. They are worn on the person, displayed in cars, or set up in some convenient place, for the purpose of guarding against some evil, or to secure good fortune. They are hung over the doorway of the house to ward off evil, hung from the bow of the canoe to insure a successful journey, worn by the new-born infant to ward off illness, or worn on the arm in hunting to assure a successful hunt (For a more complete discussion of amulets and charms, see chapter 9, “Envy and the Evil Eye”). Amulets and charms are fetishes. Some objects must be “animated,” i.e., blessed by consecrating hands of a priest, medicine-man or shaman who “localizes” the power into the object. Otherwise, the object does not possess supernatural powers. The American Indian warrior went into battle naked above the waist. His only protection was “some sacred powder, the claw of an animal, the head of a bird, or some other small object.... Its virtue depended entirely on the ceremony of the consecration and not on size or texture” (Mooney, 1991, p. 790 ). War paint also had to be properly consecrated in order to insure its magic power of protection. But certain objects are thought to innately possess extraordinary powers, and thus do not require consecration: a rabbit’s foot in itself is thought to be a good luck charm; in West Africa, the bones from the legs of the tortoise are thought to insure endurance to the wearers. Practically anything can serve as an amulet or charm in warding off evil or securing good fortune-depending on the skill of the person who has consecrated it: a rock, a piece of cloth, a string, a bead, shells, teeth of animals, you name it. But often there is a logical connection between the object chosen and its function: e.g., for bravery or strength, one might choose some part of a leopard or an elephant. If an amulet or charm fails to do the job-if the hunter comes back empty handed, for instance, the person who has concocted it will be blamed. And perhaps the response will be that an enemy possesses an amulet or charm containing a more powerful spirit, which made the hunter miss his mark. The medicine-man will then offer to make a new and more powerful charm, for a price. In modern society amulets are ubiquitous. Certain objects-keys, knots and lucky pennies, for instance-are used as amulets for their symbolic significance. According to Gonzalaz-Wippler (2007): Their shape is a clear indication of the influence they are to manifest. For example, a key is worn as an amulet so that it will open all the doors of opportunity to its wearer. Knots are worn to invite unions, usually between lovers. Lucky pennies are carried around for money and good luck. Sometimes bracelets made entirely of coins are worn for the same purpose. Bells and tassels are worn so that the sound and the movement they make will frighten away evil spirits. Anchors are associated with the sea and are said to
48 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
bring stability to their owners. Arrowheads are worn as protections against enemies. Axes are used for the same purpose (p. 145). As we have seen, mana is a concept that people in modern cultures believe, whether consciously or unconsciously, as evident in the patterns of behavior associated with “good luck” charms, thoughts and words, tools, clothing, heirlooms and other cherished possessions, and so on. As we will see in chapter 5 (“Animism”), the energy that is known as mana is such that animals, plants and natural things of nature such as mountains and streams, are thought to be “animated,” with a life force that must be respected or else there will be undesirable consequences.
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man, 2010, 49-75
49
CHAPTER 5 Animism Abstract. The idea behind animism takes mana one step further and proposes that all of nature is animated, that is, imbued with consciousness, or with life, that all phenomena of nature, including rocks, caves, mountains rain, thunder, lightning, stars, etc., are imbued with a life essence or soul. Animism is a kind of environmental philosophy-that not only are people to be respected, but all of creation must be respected. A good deal of the ceremonies as well as practical guidance in primitive cultures pertain to communication with the spirits of animals, of plants, and of objects of nature. Many modern day superstitions are animistic in orientation (e.g., if a black cat crosses your path, this means bad luck). Soothsayers, medicine men, and fortune-tellers use animistic means to forecast the future (e.g., interpreting signs from the clouds or the cries of animals). Animism accounts for the reverence accorded animals in many cultures (e.g., tuna reverence, bear reverence, totemic protection of certain animal species). People of all cultures will talk to their plants to influence their growth. Indigenous populations have great attachment and reverence to their land, which they believe have sacred properties and healing energies. Even idols and figureheads on ships are thought to possess protective and communicative powers (e.g., touching or kissing the statute will impart a certain blessing). Sacred ceremonial objects, such as the shaman’s drum, are thought to be potent vehicles for connecting between the human and spirit worlds. Children of all cultures are particularly prone towards animistic beliefs and practices (e.g., endowing personality to dolls, attributing consciousness to other inanimate objects). The idea of artificial intelligence borrows animistic ideas.
INTRODUCTION Primitive cultures all over the world have one main thing in common: They believe that there is a mutual involvement of God and nature. “Sky and god, rain and deity are somehow together, aspects of the same thing” (Redfield, 1953, p. 102). The idea behind animism is that a “vital force” or mana permeates all nature, a topic we discussed in chapter 4. Animism is associated with mana but goes one step further. It holds that everything is animated, that is, imbued with consciousness, or with life. The concept of mana, standing alone, simply pertains to the idea that everything emits energy. Animism takes the view that all things are conscious-living beings in their own right-whether human, animal, plant or mineral-they are all qualitatively equivalent. All phenomena of nature, including rocks, caves, mountains rain, thunder, lightning, stars, etc. are imbued with a life essence or soul. The word “animism” is used because of the idea that all reality is animate, or alive. In animistic cultures human traits are attributed to all types of phenomena. These traits include self-consciousness, language, imagination, thinking, symbolic thought, feelings, and other features that in the West we think are unique to human beings. Animism is a kind of environmental philosophy-that not only are people to be respected, but all of creation must be respected because all things are connected or engaged with one another, and there is a shared content, or commonality, of experience among all things. Animism holds that people are informed or communicated to by animals, plants, objects and places by spirits that are capable of separate existence. This is referred to as hyperphysical animism (Read, 1915, p. 7). A good deal of the ceremonies in primitive cultures pertain to communication with the spirits of animals, of plants, and of objects of nature. According to Telban (1991): Almost any unusual event may be attributed to spirits, such as the creaking of a house floor, the sound of unknown voices or unfamiliar noises, the shaking of a canoe, or a glimmer of light in the bush at night. If men are fishing at night and a torch bulb burns out they will say it is because a spirit looked at the torch (p. 172). Even comets, lightning and other occurrences are thought to bear messages to the people-some sort of divine communication or prophesy. In modern society we, too, often regard comets and other unusual occurrences in nature John Alan Cohan All rights reserved - © 2010 Bentham Science Publishers Ltd.
50 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
as bearing prophetic messages or warnings to us, and it is quite common for us to talk to their dogs or cats or other animals. Lott and Hart (1977) assert: Man is one of the few species to enter into an extended and complex social relationship with other species. In some instances, such as the shepherd with his dog and the cowboy with his horse, this may involve staking his well-being, and even his life, on the success of a close social relationship with members of another species (p. 174). People in primitive cultures have a remarkable and thoroughgoing practical knowledge of the life, origin, habits, behavior, capacities, and structure of animals in their environment. They can point out individual plants or trees or birds and ascribe certain traits to them. Animals are thought to have the same sort of vitality, consciousness and will to survive as do human beings. They are thought to have a language of their own and can understand what human beings are saying and doing. They live a life that is parallel in many respects to that of human societies. The modern environmental movement is in large part animistic, with concerns that we have lost touch with how connected we are to the Earth: For a long time now, we have been unable to remember our former closeness with the Earth. Due to this amnesia, the ecological problems now thrust upon us have come as a shock.... We notice the emergence of an amnesia that is really a double forgetting, wherein a culture forgets, and then forgets it has forgotten how to live in harmony with the planet (Devereux, Steele & Kubrin, 1989, pp. 2-3). Animism goes hand in hand with totemism, which we will discuss in the next chapter. Many cultures associate their own identity with certain animals or plants-their totems. PHILOSOPHICAL, RELIGIOUS AND SCIENTIFIC GROUNDING OF ANIMISM Animism takes into account the reality that life is difficult to define, the criteria of what constitutes life is far from certain, and the difference between living and nonliving entities is hard to make out. As a matter of fact, scientists cannot define life, so that there “may not be an absolutely rigorous distinction between inanimate matter and matter in a living state” (Sebeck, 1988, p. 72). Aristotle said: “Nature proceeds little by little from inanimate things to living creatures, in such a way that we are unable, in the continuous sequence, to determine the boundary line...” (as quoted in Lloyd, 1966, p. 258). Quantum physicist David Bohm says: Dividing the universe up into living and non-living things has no meaning. Animate and inanimate matter are inseparably interwoven and life, too, is enfolded throughout the totality of the universe. Even a rock is in some way alive,... for life and intelligence are present not only in all of matter, but in “energy,” “space,” “time,” the fabric of the entire universe (as quoted in Talbot, 1991, p. 50). A central feature of animism is the idea that the soul is not unique to humans. What constitutes the soul and why in principle souls should be the exclusive province of human beings are deep philosophical questions. The idea of a soul is that we possess, at the same time of having a material body, an intangible and insensible spark of life-a unique identity-perhaps capable of a separate existence from the body. The soul might be thought of as an ethereal aspect or counterpart of our bodies, but more permanent than bodies, perhaps eternal. Warneck comments that the soul is “an elixir of life, a life-stuff, which is found everywhere in nature” (as quoted in Chapman, 1921, p. 298). Usually primitives believe in the preexistence of souls, the future existence of souls, the existence of souls in the lower animals and in inanimate objects, in the power of one soul to affect another, and particularly the power of the spirit of one who has recently died to attract to itself the spirits of the living. The ancient Greek philosopher, Thales, held that “all things are full of gods,” and that magnets and amber have souls (as quoted in Lloyd, 1966, pp. 233-234). Heraclitus thought that fire was alive, that it made human souls (Lloyd, 1966, p. 237). Plato thought that the world, the sun, stars and planets are living creatures with souls (Lloyd, 1966, pp. 254, 257).
Animism
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 51
It is not entirely clear how we can be sure that other species do not have parallel workings of their brains with features we think are unique to us, such as self-consciousness, that is, an indubitable sense that we exist, an awareness of ourselves, of what we perceive and think. Adler (1967) observes: ... I would say that if man differs only in degree from other animals, then a sharp line cannot be drawn to separate the world of persons from the world of things; in fact, the distinction between person and thing becomes meaningless or at best arbitrary if there are only differences in degree, since that distinction is either a distinction in kind or no distinction at all (p. 257). We are, after all, animals along with other animal species. We share some of the same traits with the animal nature of other creatures such as states of fear, aggression and sociability, to name only a few. Harvey (2005) asserts: ...[T]here is plenty of scientifically acceptable evidence of consciousness in animals. For example, some primates and some birds (New Caledonian crows at least) use tools; bees think, buffaloes play, and dolphins get depressed; birds not only sing to define territories and alert potential mates or opponents of their presence, they enjoy singing. In short, ethologists recognise the cognitive competence of a wide range of other-than-human persons (p. 188). We can learn more about what features are unique or special to ourselves by understanding the characteristics and capacities that we share with other animals. This approach was called conciliance by the l9th century philosopher of science William Whewell, and it means the melding of inferences drawn from separate subjects or discipline (Wilson, 1971). We know, according to the theory of evolution, that we are linked to all other animals because we have emerged from other species in the course of evolution. We share common characteristics of animal nature with other species in virtue of common evolutionary origins-particularly with the other primates. Indeed, we share traits common to all life forms, both plant and animal, even microbes. Each life form is a system or entity with parts that have a function towards supporting the system in its persistence in life, taking in energy, secreting waste products, reproducing, passing on DNA, growth, and decay. Among other things, we share the following traits with many of the higher order animals: (1) instinct or intuitioninnate tendencies, desires, pushings, motivations; (2) desire for persisting in one’s own state, i.e., self-preservationthe conatus principle; (3) looking for sex and other kinds of excitement; (4) fearing and fighting against the unknown that threatens to upset or destroy ourselves. Powell (2004) relegates animism to a kind of “indeterminate energy” (p. 85). Powell takes the view that there is a process flowing throughout nature that he calls “natural intelligence” (Powell, 2004, p. 49). He claims natural intelligence is “the deliberate and purposeful movement of matter into energy and then back into matter,” a process that underlies all of life (Powell, 2004, p. 49). The connectedness of things in nature is reflected in the phenomenon that physicists call “quantum entanglement born of a singular wave function” or “nonlocality.” In this phenomenon, two photons are created together and travel away from each other at the speed of light, but despite their separation, anything that happens to one of them affects the other. In other words, two quanta of light, given off from a single source and traveling at the speed of light in opposite directions, can maintain their connection to one another. These photons are affected by what happens to their “twins” at a distance. Thus, the idea of separation in space and time is an illusion, so that spatially separate events are not independent, but connected. Scientists have concluded that “The essential features of the implicate order are that the whole universe is in some way enfolded in everything, and that each thing is enfolded in the whole” (Bohm & Hiley, 1993, p. 382). This is precisely what Leibniz (1686/1902) postulated in his theory of Monads and Pre-established Harmony, in which each Monad contains information about every other point in space-time. What happens to one substance in a sense may be viewed as the cause of what happens in another. God, in creating things to perform particular actions at given times, creates all other things in such a way as to reflect that action at that time. All things are related in some way to every other. Each created Monad represents the whole universe. Leibniz (1686/1902) said: “The action of one finite substance on another consists only in the increase of the degree of expression together with the diminution of the expression of the other, insofar as God requires them to accommodate themselves to one another.”
52 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
(§ 15) From Leibniz as well as from quantum physics we get the idea that since everything is made of the same stuff and is connected to everything else, permeated with a life force-it makes sense to treat all creatures and things with care, compassion and respect. The astronomer Johannes Kepler and the physicist Gustav Fechner thought that planets and stars are animate (Heim, 1953). Teilhard de Chardin (1959) asserted that consciousness extends throughout the cosmos. Hegel regarded the entire cosmos as one living system (Eckman, 1986). Astrology is a kind of animism in which planets and zodiacs are assigned certain attributes. Sir Walter Raleigh noted this in saying: If we cannot deny but that God hath given virtue to springs and fountains, to cold earth, to plants and stones, minerals and to the excremental parts of the basest creatures, why should we rob the beautiful stars of their working powers? For, seeing they are many in number and of eminent beauty and magnitude, we may not think that in the treasure of his wisdom who is infinite there can be wanting, even for every star, a peculiar virtue and operation; as every herb, plant, fruit, flower, adorning the face of the earth hath the like (as quoted in Harrison, 2001, p. 51). In the Bible God treats the stars as living beings. The stars received commandments from God: “I have given a commandment to all the stars” (Isaiah 45:12). What are these commandments? Namely, that each star, in its order and course, should bestow upon the world the amount of splendor which has been entrusted to it. Planets move in one type of orbit, and stars in a different pattern. The movements of these bodies occur, it is thought, with a soul. The very orderliness and progression of heavenly bodies seems to suggest a rational nature. In Jeremiah the moon is called the queen of heaven (Jeremiah 7:18). In Job it was said “The stars also are not clean in Thy sight” (Job 25:5), suggesting that they are “animated” in that they have the capacity to be good or evil through their own diligent efforts, either to acquire for themselves a body of greater brightness, or through their sloth to make the one they have less pure. Elsewhere in the Bible animism seems to be eerily suggested. In Genesis 1:24: “Let the earth bring forth living soul,” referring to the spirit (ruah) of the First Adam, which accordingly is not a pneuma blown into him, but an earth-spirit, a vital potency dwelling in the earth. The idea that both man and animals have souls is seen in the general similarity by which God made both man and beast: “Out of the ground the Lord God formed every beast” (Genesis 2:19). God breathed the breath of life into man: “And the Lord God formed man of the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and the man became a living soul” (Genesis 2:7). But also, God breathed the breath of life into animals: “Pairs of creatures that have the breath of life in them came to Noah and entered the ark” (Genesis 7:15), and “Everything on dry land that had the breath of the spirit of life died” (Genesis 7:22). Thus, in the biblical account, both man and beast were composed of earth and animated by the breath of God. The encyclopedist Denis Diderot said that “the world, like a huge animal, has a soul [which] may be an infinite system of perceptions,” and that “From the elephant to the flea, from the flea to the living, sensitive molecule there is not a point in all nature which does not suffer and rejoice” (as quoted in Guthrie, 1993, p. 58). Many modern authors believe in the idea of Gaia, that is, the Earth as a living organism (Lovelock, 1987, p. 4). During the Renaissance, a tide of animism swept through Europe: Instead of being regarded as an inanimate mass, the Earth itself was deemed to be alive. The universe was peopled by a hierarchy of spirits, and thought to manifest all kinds of occult influences and sympathies. The cosmos was an organic unity in which every part bore a sympathetic relationship to the rest. Even colours, letters and numbers were endowed with magical properties (Thomas, 1971, p. 265). Zoologist Jakob von Uexkull (1864-1944) held that all living organisms inhabit their own subjective worlds-the Umwelt- defined by their sensory capacities. Organisms live by the exchange and interpretation of signs. Ecosystems
Animism
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 53
are not merely flows of energy and matter, but are more fundamentally flows of signs, communicative flows between myriads of living subjects. Nature is in other words just as much founded on communication as in the human social realm. Human communication is but a subset of communication that goes on within the total community of living things. Nietzsche (1951) had this to say about animism: The most amazing thing within my experience is the unconscious way men and women take it for granted that they are the natural superiors of the flora and fauna about them. What, for instance, do we know about animals, plants and birds that can possibly justify such a conclusion? As a matter of sober fact, we don’t even look better, and sometimes we look many fathoms worse. I once saw in a zoo an animal with a face so beautiful and benign that I had to think of St. Francis of Assisi to match it in grandeur. What an extraordinary piece of arrogance, I thought, looking at the face of that beast, it would be for me to calmly take it for granted that what transpired behind that furry brow was of less importance than what goes on behind my thin-skinned one (ch. 3, § 73). Freud (1918) in his famous monograph, Totem and Taboo, theorized that people impute personhood and agency to animals and things. Jung (1968) alluded to animism as a normal human instinct when he described theriomorphism as “a visualization of the unconscious self manifesting itself through ‘animal’ impulses.” (p. 145) Animism is seen in Buddhist doctrine suggesting that merit making, which includes charity to the poor and to Buddhist monks-extends to all living creatures, so that merit can be made by giving gifts to animals. From the theory of evolution we would have to conclude that if we are descended from animals, our bodies and our souls have an animal origin. If we have souls, then it follows that animals have some kind of soul. “Perhaps some would say that judging from his courage in danger, his devotion to his master, his spirit of self-sacrifice, a dog’s soul cannot be so very far behind the human variety in point of excellence” (Archer, 1931, p. 42). For centuries up into the 1800’s, animism was reflected in the laws of many cultures. In Europe, criminal “intent” was attributed to animals of all kinds, and hundreds of trials, if not thousands, were held against animals. Animals were thought to be rational beings, capable of acting as responsible agents. Thus, animals were held liable in criminal law for injuring or “murdering” humans. A guilty verdict in court resulted in execution of the animal (Cohen, 1986). In 1522, some rats were put on trial in Autun, France, charged with a felony of having wantonly destroyed some barley crops. Eventually a default judgment was entered (Evans, 1906). In 1545 in St. Julien, some wine growers sued a species of beetles that infested their vineyards: After consultations with counsel for both sides, the court issued a proclamation, dated 8 May 1546, which observed that God had ordained that the earth should bring forth herbs and fruits, not only for the sustenance of rational human beings, but also for the preservation and support of his lesser creatures, the insects; it would be more fitting for the humans to implore the mercy of heaven, and to seek pardon for their sins, than to proceed rashly against the beetles. The proclamation prescribed prayer, contrition, and the saying of High Mass three times in the vineyards. The insects are reported to have thereupon disappeared from the village (Ewald, 1995, p. 1902). Forty-one years later another beetle infestation occurred. This time a compromise was reach in court: A distant piece of ground would be supplied with plants and herbs, reserved for use by the beetles in perpetuity. Everyone agreed that the insects had the legal right to life, and were entitled to sustenance from the earth’s bounty (Ewald, 1995, p. 1902). This is quite in contrast to today’s practice of wholesale extermination of farm pests! In 1621 a cow in Leipzig, Germany was condemned to death for killing a pregnant woman (Ewald, 1995, p. 1904). Even today trials against animals are not unheard of: A court in Bitola, Macedonia convicted a bear of “stealing honey from a beekeeper and damaging his hives. Because the bear had no owner and is classified as a protected
54 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
species, the court ordered the state to pay the beekeeper $3,500 for the damage to the hives” (Reuters, 14th March 2008). And the custom exists throughout the modern world that if a wild animal such as a bear attacks a human, the authorities will hunt down and kill the animal. Often if a domestic pet, such as a pit bull, mauls or kills someone, the authorities will impound the animal and usually it will be euthanized. Note that animism is different from anthropomorphism-the attribution of human traits, such as language and symbolism, to non-human entities and events, such as God, other animals, or mountains. Guthrie (1993) argues: We often animate and anthropomporphize at the same time. We animate but do not anthropomorphize, for example, if we say an automobile purrs like a kitten, and anthropomorphize but do not animate if we speak to our pet turtle. If we speak to our automobile, however, we both animate and anthropomorphize (p. 39). The “worship of nature” is a primitive form of religion. Thus, for primitives it is important to feel veneration for the Earth, the Sun, the mountains, rivers and animals-and many of us in modern society, particularly in the environmental movement, feel a similar veneration for nature. Victor Sanchez (1996) in his book, Toltecs of the New Millennium, speaks of the importance of the natural flow of Spirit-the expression of spirit in nature. That is why men of knowledge seek “teachers” in a ravine, mountain, a tree, or in animals such as a wolf or deer. According to Sanchez, mountains have spirit owners with whom one must engage in a respectful manner. It is the idea that “everything has its own voice,” and that all natural objects and phenomena have souls. The extent to which nonhuman entities are endowed with their own “voice” depends on the type of object, with mountains having a more abstract voice than, say wild animals such as the bear. THE COMMUNICATION FEATURE OF ANIMISM As mentioned above, animism takes into account the environment as a whole, with the belief that all things are alive or “animated.” In animistic cultures there is an environmental reverence, a respect for the dignity of the environment. Animistic cultures believe there is an interconnectedness and interdependence between human species and the whole of the planet. The universe is not an impersonal objective reality, but distinctly personalistic. Animism harkens to the time when dawning human consciousness was still wholly bound to nature. So many cultures have supernatural associations with animals that this seems to be a universal pattern that probably goes back to ancient times. In ancient Egypt animals were often gods, manifestations of gods, or associated with gods, and animals were often associated with magical or religious rites. In all cultures, animals figure prominently in myths, stories, dance, ritual, art, design and other areas. With animism, the focus of attention is not only on animals and plants, but also to non-living objects of nature that move spontaneously, such as the winds, streams, echoes, the sun, the moon, planets, shooting stars, the waves, fire, volcanoes, and even slow-moving glaciers. But as we will see, animism even extends to things in nature that are more or less immobile-such as mountains, and artifacts that cannot move on their own-such as a drum or ceremonial mask. Animism is the sense that one’s soul is bound up with natural forces. One interprets the cries or movements of certain creatures as a way of guiding one’s destiny for good or ill. Some animals are thought to be guardians for a particular group of people. The Inuit people go so far as to say that animals, objects and places have an inua, its “person” or “owner,” that has to be respected. There is a close relationship between owner and the owned, a kind of identity between the inua and the subject (Laugrand, Gosten, & Trudel, 2002). According to the Penobscot mind, the order of birds, like themselves, constitutes tribes and bands, separated by their different structure, manners and utterances, as each tribe, though subdivided into smaller groups, retains its form in customs and language particular to that nation or genus from which it seems to have descended (Hallowell, 1926, p. 7).
Animism
The Primitive Mind and Modern Man 55
Just like birds, the Indian tribes have their head chiefs, minor chiefs, and local groups. In Hawaiian tradition, there are many animistic customs and superstitions regarding communications from animals. If a number of cocks crowed at night, a large number of guests were expected to visit the village. The appearance of other animals-dogs, flies, spiders-indicate one may expect a visitor. If a spider drops to the floor at night, kill it or one will hear of a friend’s death. If a lizard drops in front of you, you will have a present; if it falls upon a woman, she will have a lover (Green & Beckwith, 1928). Many modern day superstitions are animistic in orientation. If a black cat crosses your path, this means bad luck; keep cats away from babies because they “suck the breath” from the child; carrying and rubbing a rabbit’s foot brings good luck; a howling dow means that death is near; if a bird flies into your house this foretells and important message; if the first butterfly you see in the year is white, you will have good luck all year; throw back the first fish you catch, and then you will be luck the whole day fishing; if you dream of fish, that means someone you know is pregnant; a horseshoe hung above the doorway will bring good luck-and so on. In Hawaii there once was a lore of the clouds. That is, certain soothsayers called Poe-kilo-ouli, interpreted signs from the clouds. The cloud signs are usually those which lie low along the horizon. The diviners distinguished spirits of the dead in the clouds and made connections between them and events to come. Ordinary people also took notice of cloud formations to determine how things will go for them. Rain at night after a supplication by day is a sign assuring the petitioner of a gracious answer to his prayer. A particularly loud clap of thunder means that someone has broken a taboo. The fact that natural phenomena, such as rain, is animated gives the people some measure of control over them. That is, since the rain, for instance, has a kind of consciousness, people can appeal to its guardian spirits to bring forth rain if there is a drought, or to make the rain go away if there is too much of it. In animistic cultures, omens can take the form of the cries of animals, the flight of birds, the direction they come from or in which they are going, and so on. In starting a journey or a hunt, the appearance of a bad omen-e.g., the appearance of certain animals that are taboo-will immediately cause the plans to be postponed until there is a favorable omen. The more dangerous an enterprise, the more important the need for favorable omens. A favorable omen is indispensable because it does not merely announce success, but guarantees success (Levy-Bruhl, 1923, p. 128). Omens can also take the form of natural disasters, discussed later in this chapter. In numerous Native American tribes, particularly the Choctaw, the fire and the sun are supposed to have constant intercourse with each other, and the fire acts as an informant to the sun. If one did anything wrong in the presence of the fire, the fire would tell the sun of it. Many phenomena of nature can be extremely dangerous, such as thunder and lightning, tsunamis, hurricanes and volcanoes. Lightening that has killed a man, therefore, has a spirit. The natives of the West Pacific used to climb to the top of volcanoes and bring sacrifices to appease it, throwing coconuts and yams into the crater. ANIMISM IN RELATION TO ANIMALS In primitive cultures animals have a very important, symbolic relationship with humans. Animistic cultures first of all regard animals to be species that, like humans, have consciousness and a soul. There is almost never an indifferent attitude towards animals. Animals are thought to be related to humans. This is expressed in various modes of interaction-principally a caring, if not affectionate approach in the exploitation of the animals. The affinity between man and animals is easily understood: like man, animals move, make vocal sounds, express emotions, have bodies, experience pain and pleasure, and have faces that express a variety of feelings. Animals inspire feelings of admiration and fear. Often, the power of animals are superior to those of humans: the bird flies, fish survive under water, reptiles can camouflage themselves, and snakes shed their skin.
56 The Primitive Mind and Modern Man
John Alan Cohan
Throughout animistic cultures we see a reverence expressed towards animals, especially in connection with hunting, killing and consuming animals. To respect the bear, for instance, in ceremonies of reverence for the animal, insures a continued flow of animal gifts to hunters. And when hunters respect animals in certain practical ways, such as strategic self-restraint in hunting, there is a sustainability of the animal, and the people remain in good stead with the spirits of the animals. Some animals are taboo and cannot be killed or eaten because the people regard them as totems-i.e., the animals are part of their lineage (See chapter 6, “Totemism”). Other animals are revered and, at the same time, employed in ritual sacrifices to appease the gods for sins committed by the people, or as a way of achieving communion with the gods. An example of reverence for animals can be seen in the traditional Nivkh culture. These people, who have never exceeded 6,000 in population, live in the extreme southeast of Siberia (“Russian Far East”)-the Lower Amur River valley, including the delta, a coastal strip to the north and south of the river’s mouth known as the Liman estuary, adjacent areas on the coast of the Sea of Okhotsk, and the northern part of the island of Sakhalin. There is archaeological evidence of settlements in that region, quite plausibly their ancestors, as far back as 5,000 B.C., but clearly they flourished in this region as far back as 1200 A.D., when they were trading partners with the Chinese. In the 19th and 20th centuries there was continual conflict between the Nivkh and the Russian and Japanese governments vying for strategic control of the area. There was economic exploitation of Nivkh lands by Russians, particularly overfishing that resulted in recurring famines. There was a large Russian prison colony whose escaped convicts often robbed, killed or raped the Nivkh, and Stalin imposed mass arrests and forced resettlements of the Nivkh for purported espionage for Japan. Also, Nivkh shamans were imprisoned and executed during Stalin’s antireligious campaigns. In more recent years the Nivkh lands have been seriously eroded by forestry, mining, and oildrilling (Black, 1973). A deeply animistic culture, the Nivkh people believe that animals play a role, as part of the universe themselves, in perpetuating the universe. They believe, in common with many other cultures, that animals literally consent to be killed in a process of giving themselves to humans. The people give gifts to hunted animals in the form of food, as a show of respect for the animals’ souls as they journey into the afterlife. Bones of slain animals are reverentially returned to the elements. Slain animals, especially seals, dolphins and white whales, are “fed” with special grasses gathered by fishermen for this purpose. Other forms of respect are shown: Dolphin heads are preserved by the sea on poles; bones of sea mammals, including smashed skulls, eyes, etc., are reverently returned to the sea as materials for future regeneration and recreation of the species. One of the most prevalent animals that animistic cultures regard with reverence are birds o