Developments in Precambrian Geology, 12
THE PRECAMBRIAN EARTH: TEMPOS AND EVENTS
Developments in Precambrian Geology, 12
THE PRECAMBRIAN EARTH: TEMPOS AND EVENTS
DEVELOPMENTS IN PRECAMBRIAN GEOLOGY Advisory Editor Kent Condie
Further titles in this series 1. B.F.WlNDLEY and S.M. NAQVI (Editors) Archaean Geochemistry 2. D.R. HUNTER (Editor) Precambrian of the Southern Hemisphere 3. K.C. CONDIE Archean Greenstone Belts 4. A. KRONER (Editor) Precambrian Plate Tectonics 5. Y.P.MEI'NIK Precambrian Banded Iron-formations. Physicochemical Conditions of Formation 6. A.F. TRENDALL and R.C. MORRIS (Editors) Iron-Formation: Facts and Problems 7. B. NAGY, R. WEBER, J.C. GUERRERO and M. SCHIDLOWSKI (Editors) Developments and Interactions of the Precambrian Atmosphere, Lithosphere and Biosphere 8. S.M. NAQVl (Editor) Precambrian Continental Crust and Its Economic Resources 9. D.V. RUNDQVIST and F.P. MITROFANOV (Editors) Precambrian Geology of the USSR 10. K.C. CONDIE (Editor) Proterozoic Crustal Evolution 11. K.C. CONDIE (Editor) Archean Crustal Evolution
Developments in Precambrian Geology, 12
THE PRECAMBRIAN EARTH: TEMPOS AND EVENTS Edited by P.G. E R I K S S O N Department of Geology, University of Pretoria Pretoria 0002, Republic of South Africa
W. A L T E R M A N N Centre Biophysique Mo16culaire (CBM) Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS) 45071 Orl6ans, Cedex 2, France
D.R. NELSON Department of Applied Physics, Curtin University of Tectmology Perth, W.A. 6845, Australia and Geological Survey of Western Australia, Mineral House, 100 Plain Street East Perth, 6004, Australia
W.U. MUELLER Departement Sciences de la Terre Universit6 du Qu6bec ~tChicoutimi Chicoutimi, Qu6bec G7H 2B 1, Canada
O. CATUNEANU Department of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences University of Alberta, Edmonton Alberta T6G 2E3, Canada
2004
ELSEVIER
Amsterdam- Boston- Heidelberg- London- New York- Oxford Paris - San Diego - San Francisco - Singapore- Sydney - Tokyo
E L S E V I E R B.V. Sara B u r g e r h a r t s t r a a t 25 P.O. Box 211 1000 A E A m s t e r d a m The Netherlands
ELSEVIER Inc. 525 B Street Suite 1900 San Diego CA 92101-4495 USA
ELSEVIER Ltd The Boulevard Langford Lane Kidlington Oxford OX5 1GB UK
ELSEVIER Ltd 84 Theobalds Road London WC1X 8RR UK
9 2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. This work is protected under copyright by Elsevier B.V., and the following terms and conditions apply to its use: Photocopying Single photocopies of single chapters may be made for personal use as allowed by national copyright laws. Permission of the Publisher and payment of a fee is required for all other photocopying, including multiple or systematic copying, copying for advertising or promotional purposes, resale, and all forms of document delivery. Special rates are available for educational institutions that wish to make photocopies for non-profit educational classroom use. Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier's Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone (+44) 1865 843830, fax (+44) 1865 853333, e-mail: permissions @elsevier.com. Requests may also be completed on-line via the Elsevier homepage (http://www.elsevier.corn/locate/permissions). In the USA, users may clear permissions and make payments through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA; phone: (+1) (978) 7508400, fax: (+1) (978) 7504744, and in the UK through the Copyright Licensing Agency Rapid Clearance Service (CLARCS), 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1P 0LP, UK; phone: (+44) 20 7631 5555; fax: (+44) 20 7631 5500. Other countries may have a local reprographic rights agency for payments. Derivative Works Tables of contents may be reproduced for intemal circulation, but permission of the Publisher is required for external resale or distribution of such material. Permission of the Publisher is required for all other derivative works, including compilations and translations. Electronic Storage or Usage Permission of the Publisher is required to store or use electronically any material contained in this work, including any chapter or part of a chapter. Except as outlined above, no part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission of the Publisher. Address permissions requests to: Elsevier's Rights Department, at the fax and e-mail addresses noted above. Notice No responsibility is assumed by the Publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made.
F i r s t edition 2 0 0 4
ISBN: 0-444-51506-2 (hardbound) I S B N : 0 - 4 4 4 - 5 1 5 0 9 - 7 (paperback)
|
T h e p a p e r u s e d in this p u b l i c a t i o n
( P e r m a n e n c e o f Paper). P r i n t e d in T h e N e t h e r l a n d s .
meets
the r e q u i r e m e n t s
of A N S I / N I S O
Z39.48-1992
CONTRIBUTING AUTHORS D.H. ABBOTT
Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory, University of Columbia, Palisades, New York, NY 10964, USA (dallass@ ldeo.columbia.edu; phone: 845-3658664;fax: 845-3658156) F.E ALKMIM
Departamento de Geologia, Universidade Federal de Ouro Preto, Ouro Preto, MG-Brazil, CP 35400 (
[email protected]; fax: 31-5512334) W. ALTERMANN
Centre Biophysique Moleculaire, Exobiologie, Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Rue CharlesSadron, 45071 Orleans Cedex 2, France (
[email protected]; phone: 33-238-255569; fax: 33-238631517) EW.U. APPEL
Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland, r geus.dk; phone: 45-38-142214; fax: 45-38-142050)
Voldgade 10, DK-1350 Copenhagen, Denmark (pa@
N. ARNDT
LGCA, Universitd de Grenoble, 38041 Grenoble Cedex, France (
[email protected]; phone: 33-4-76635931; fax: 33-4-76514058) L.B. ASPLER
23 Newton Street, Ottawa, Ontario K1S 2S6, Canada (
[email protected]; phone: 908-6470180x7152; fax: 908-5803523) L.D. AYRES
Department Geological Sciences, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Manitoba R3T 2N2, Canada (ayres@ms. umanitoba, ca; phone: 204-4749371; fax: 204-4747623) S. BANERJEE
Dept. of Earth Sciences, liT Bombay, Pawai, Mumbai 400 076, India (
[email protected]; phone: 22-5767282; fax: 5767253) J.G. BLOCKLEY
76 Beach Street, Bicton, WA 6157, Australia (
[email protected]; phone: 8-93171775) P.K. BOSE
Dept. of Geological Sciences, Jadavpur University, Kolkata 700 032, India (
[email protected]; fax: 33-4731484) M.D. BRASIER
Earth Sciences Department, Oxford University, Parks Road, Oxford OX1 3PR, United Kingdom (Martin.
[email protected]; phone: 1865-272074;fax: 1865-272072) K.L. BUCHAN
Geological Survey of Canada, 601 Booth St., Ottawa, Ontario KIA OE8, Canada (
[email protected]; phone: 613-9477341;fax: 613-9477396)
Contributing authors
vi
A.J. BUMB Y
Dept. of Geology, University of Pretoria, Pretoria 0002, South Africa (
[email protected]; phone: 27-12-4202238; fax: 27-12-3625219) G.R. BYERLY
Dept. of Geology and Geophysics, Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, LA 70803-4101, USA (gbyerly@ geol.lsu.edu; phone: 225-5785318; fax: 225-5782300) O. CATUNEANU
Dept. of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences, 1-26 Earth Sciences Building, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta T6G 2E3, Canada (
[email protected]; phone: 780-4926569; fax: 780-4922030) J.R. CHIARENZELLI
Dept. of Geology, State University of New York, Potsdam, NY 13676, USA (
[email protected]; phone: 315-2673401; fax: 315-2672695) E.H. CHOWN
90 Dickens Drive, Kingston, Ontario K7M 2M8, Canada (
[email protected]; phone: 1-613-5475632) K.C. CONDIE
Dept. of Earth and Environmental Sciences, New Mexico Tech., Socorro, NM 87801, USA (
[email protected]; phone: 505-8355531; fax: 505-8356436) P.L. CORCORAN
Dept. of Earth Sciences, University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario N6A 5B7, Canada (pcorcor@ uwo.ca; phone: 519-6612111x86836; fax: 519-6613198) B.L. COUSENS
Dept. of Earth Sciences, Carleton University, 1125 Colonel By Drive, Ottawa, Ontario KIS 5B6, Canada (brian_cousens@ carleton.ca; phone: 613-5202600x4436; fax: 613-5202569) R. DAIGNEAULT
Sciences de la terre, Universit~ du Quebec ~ Chicoutimi, 555 Blvd. De l'Universite, Chicoutimi, Quebec G7H 2B1, Canada (
[email protected]; phone: 418-5455011x5636; fax: 418-5455012) J.R. DEVANEY
Petro-Canada Oil and Gas, P.O. Box 2844, Calgary, Alberta T2P 3E3, Canada (ion.devaney @backpacker,corn; phone: 403-2964243; fax: 403-2963030) S.T. DE VRIES
Department of Sedimentology, Institute of Earth Sciences, Utrecht University, Postbus 80021, 3508 TA Utrecht, The Netherlands (
[email protected]) J.A. DONALDSON
Ottawa-Carleton Geoscience Centre, Department of Earth Sciences, Carleton University, Colonel By Drive, Ottawa, Ontario K1S 5B6, Canada (
[email protected]; phone: 613-5203515; fax: 613-5202569) J. DOSTAL
Department of Geology, Saint Mary's University, Halifax B3H 3C3, Canada (
[email protected]; phone: 902-4205747; fax: 902-4968104) A.F. EMBRY
Geological Survey of Canada, 3303 33rd Street N.W., Calgary, Alberta T2L 2A7, Canada (AEmbry@ NRCan.gc.ca; phone: 403-2927125; fax: 403-2925377)
Contributing authors
vii
K.A. ERIKSSON
Dept. of Geological Sciences, Virginia Tech., Blacksburg, VA 24061, USA (
[email protected]; phone: 540-2316521; fax: 540-2313386) P.G. ERIKSSON
Dept. of Geology, University of Pretoria, Pretoria 0002, South Africa (
[email protected]; phone: 12-4202238; fax: 12-3625219) R.E. ERNST
Geological Survey of Canada, 601 Booth St., Ottawa, Ontario KIA OE8, Canada (
[email protected]; phone: 613-9477341; fax: 613-9477396) A.D. FOWLER
Department of Earth Sciences, University of Ottawa, Ontario KIN 6N5, Canada (
[email protected]; phone: 613-5625800x6273; fax: 613-5625192) H.E. FRIMMEL
Dept. of Geological Sciences, University of Cape Town, Rondebosch 7701, South Africa (
[email protected]. za; phone: 21-6502901; fax: 21-6503783) A.M. GELLATLY
Dept. of Geological Sciences, University of Missouri, Columbia, MO 65211, USA (
[email protected]; phone: 573-8826328; fax: 573-8825458) J.T. HAGSTRUM
U.S. Geological Survey, 345 Middlefield Road, MS 937, Menlo Park, CA 94025, USA (
[email protected]; phone: 650-3294672; fax: 650-3294664) A.H. HICKMAN
Geological Survey of Western Australia, Department of Industry and Resources, Mineral House, 100 Plain Street, East Perth, WA 6004, Australia (
[email protected]; phone: 9-2223333; fax: 9-2223633) A.W. HOFMANN
Max-Planck-Institut fur Chemie, Abteilung Geochemie, 55020 Mainz, Germany (
[email protected]) G. HUDAK
Department of Geology, University of Wisconsin Oshkosh, W154901-8649, USA (
[email protected]; phone: 920-4244463; fax: 920-4240240) L.C. KAH
Dept. of Geological Sciences, University of Tennessee, Knoxville, TN 37996, USA (
[email protected]; phone: 865-9742366; fax: 865-9742368) J. KAZMIERCZAK
Institute of Paleobiology, Biogeology Division, Polish Academy of Sciences, Twarda 51/55, PL-00818 Warsaw, Poland (
[email protected]; phone: +48-22-697887;fax: +48-22-6206225) S. KEMPE
Institute of Applied Geosciences, University of Technology Darmstadt, Schnittspahnstr. 9, D-64287 Darmstadt, Germany (kempe @geo.tu-darmstadt.de; phone: +49-6151-162471; fax: +49-6151-166539) A.N. KONILOV
Laboratory of the Early Precambrian Tectonics, Geological Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Pyzhevsky Street 7, 109017 Moscow, Russia (
[email protected]; phone: 095-2308346; fax: 095-9510443)
Contributing authors
viii
J.E LINDSAY
JSC Astrobiology Institute, NASA,JSC (SA-13), Houston, Texas, TX 77058, USA (john.f
[email protected]; phone: 281-2445119; fax: 281-4831573) D.G.E LONG
Department of Earth Sciences, Laurentian University, Sudbury, Ontario P3E 2C6, Canada (dlong@nickel. laurentian.ca; phone: 705-6751151x2268;fax: 705-6754898) D.R. LOWE
Geological and Environmental Sciences Dept., Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305-2115, USA (dlowe@ pangea.stanford.edu; phone: 650-7253040;fax: 650-7250979) T.W. LYONS
Dept. of Geological Sciences, University of Missouri, 101 Geological Sciences Building, Columbia, MO 65211, USA (
[email protected]; phone: 573-8826328; fax: 573-8825458) M.A. MARTINS-NETO
Departamento de Geologia, Universidade Federal de Ouro Preto, Caixa Postal 173, 35400-000 Ouro Preto/MG, Brazil (
[email protected]; fax: 31-5512334) NUPETRO N~cleo de Geologia do Petr61eo/ Fundafao Gorceix, Ouro Preto, Caixa Postal 173, 35400-000, Ouro Preto/TVIG, Brazil (
[email protected]) -
J.G. MEERT
Dept. of Geological Sciences, 274 Williamson Hall University of Florida, Gainesville, FL 32611, USA (
[email protected]; phone: 352-8462414; fax: 352-3929294) L.T. MIDDLETON
Northern Arizona University, Department of Geology, P.O. Box 4099, Building 12, Rm 100, Flagstaff, AZ 86011-4099, USA (
[email protected]; phone: 928-5234561; fax: 928-5239220) M.V. MINTS
Laboratory of the Early Precambrian Tectonics, Geological Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Pyzhevsky Street 7, 109017 Moscow, Russia (
[email protected]; phone: 095-2308346; fax: 095-9510443) E.M. MOORES
Dept. of Geology, University of California, Davis, CA 95616, USA (
[email protected]; phone: 530,7520352; fax: 530-7520951) P. MOSTERT
Dept. of Geology, University of Pretoria, Pretoria 0002, South Africa (
[email protected]; phone: 12'4202238;fax: 12,3625219) W.U. MUELLER
Sciences de la terre, Universit~ du Qudbec ~ ChicoutimL 555 Blvd. De l'Universite, Chicoutimi, Quebec G7H 2B1, Canada (wmueller@uqac,ca; phone: 418,5455013; fax: 418-5455012) J.S. MYERS
Department of Earth Sciences, Memorial University, St John's, Newfoundland AIB 3E5, Canada (jmyers@ esd.mun.ca; phone: 709-7378000;fax: 709-7374569) D.R. NELSON
Geological Survey of Western Australia, Mineral House, 100 Plain Street, East Perth, WA 6004, Australia. Department of Applied Physics, Curtin University of Technology, GPO Box U1987, Perth, WA 6001, Australia (
[email protected],au; phone: 89-2663736;fax: 89-2662377)
Contributing authors
ix
H.W. NESBITT
Dept. of Earth Sciences, University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario N6A 5B7, Canada (
[email protected]; phone: 519-6613194; fax: 519-6613198) W. NIJMAN
Department of Sedimentology, Institute of Earth Sciences, Utrecht University, Postbus 80021, 3508 TA Utrecht, The Netherlands (
[email protected]) H. OHMOTO
Department of Geosciences, 435A Deike Building, Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA 16802, USA (
[email protected]; phone: 814-8654074) A. POLAT
Department of Earth Sciences, University of Windsor, Windsor, Ontario N9B 3P4, Canada (polat@uwindsor ca; phone: 519-253 3000, ext. 2498) M. POPA
Dept. of Geology, University of Pretoria, Pretoria 0002, South Africa (
[email protected]; phone: 0124202242; fax: 012-3625219) A. PROKOPH
SPEEDSTAT, 36 Corley, Ottawa, Ontario K1V 877, Canada (aprokocon@aoLcom; phone: 613-9477341; fax: 613-9477396) R.H. RAINBIRD
Geological Survey of Canada, Continental Geoscience Division, 615 Booth Street, Room 609, Ottawa, Ontario K1A OE9, Canada (
[email protected]; phone: 613-9477341; fax: 613-9477396) E RAMAEKERS 832 Parkwood Drive, S.E., Calgary, Alberta T2J 3W7, Canada (
[email protected]; paulramaekers@
home.corn; phone: 403-2789423; fax: nil) S. SARKAR
Dept. of Geological Sciences, Jadavpur University, KoIkata 700 032, India (jugeoss@vsnLnet fax: 33-4731484) J. SCHIEBER
Dept. of Geological Sciences, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN 47405, USA (
[email protected]; phone: 812-8564740;fax: 812-8557899) J.W. SCHOPF
CSEOL- Center for the Studies of the Evolution of Life, Geology Building, University of California Los Angeles (UCLA), CA 90024-1567, USA (
[email protected]; phone: +1-310-8251170) B.M. SIMONSON
Dept. of Geology, Oberlin College, Oberlin, OH 44074-1044, USA (
[email protected]; phone: 440-7758347; fax: 440-7758038) E.L. SIMPSON
Dept. of Physical Sciences, Kutztown University of Pennsylvania, Kutztown, PA 19530, USA (simpson@ kutztown.edu; phone: 610-6834445;fax: 610-6831352) J. STIX
Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec H3A 2A7, Canada (
[email protected]; phone: 514-3985391;fax: 514-3984680)
x
Contributing authors
E. TAMRAT
Dept. of Geological Sciences, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL 32611, USA (
[email protected]; phone: 352-8462414; fax: 352-3929294) P.C. T H U R S T O N
Department of Earth Sciences, Laurentian University, Sudbury, Ontario P3E 2C6, Canada (pthurston @nickel. laurentian.ca; phone: 705-6751151x2372; fax: 705-6736508) A.E T R E N D A L L
Dept. of Applied Physics, Curtin University of Technology, Perth, WA 6004, Australia (
[email protected]. edu.au; trendall @iinet.net.au; phone: 898-451006) R. VAN D E R M E R W E
Dept. of Geology, University of Pretoria, Pretoria 0002, South Africa (
[email protected]; phone: 27-(0)82-5775004; fax: 27-12-3625219) M.J. VAN K R A N E N D O N K
Geological Survey of Western Australia, Department of Industry and Resources, Mineral House, 100 Plain Street, East Perth, WA 6004, Australia (
[email protected]; phone: 9-2223333; fax: 9-2223633) E WESTALL
Centre Biophysique Moleculaire, Exobiologie, Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Rue CharlesSadron, 45071 Orleans Cedex 2, France (
[email protected]; phone: 33-238- 2557912; fax: 33-238-631517) J.D.L. W H I T E
Geology Department, University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand (
[email protected]; phone: 63-3-4799009; fax: 63-3-4797527) G.E. W I L L I A M S
Department of Geology and Geophysics, University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA 5005, Australia (george. williams@ adelaide.edu.au; phone: 8-83035843; fax: 8-83034347) G.M. YOUNG
Dept. of Earth Sciences, Faculty of Science, University of Western Ontario, Biology and Geology Building, London, Ontario N6A 5B7, Canada (
[email protected]; phone: 519-6613193; fax: 519-6613198) T.E. ZEGERS
European Space Agency, ESTEC, Keplerlaan 1, 2201 AZ Noordwijk, The Netherlands (
[email protected]; phone: 31-71-5656585)
CONTENTS
Contributing authors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . PREFACE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . W.U. Mueller, W. Altermann, O. Catuneanu, P.G. Eriksson and D.R. Nelson
Chapter 1. 1.1. 1.2. 1.3. 1.4. 1.5.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D.R. Nelson Earth's Formation and First Billion Years . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D.R. Nelson The Early Precambrian Stratigraphic Record of Large Extraterrestrial Impacts . . . . . . . . . . . . . B.M. Simonson, G.R. Byerly and D.R. Lowe Strategies for Finding the Record of Early Precambrian Impact Events . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D.H. Abbott and J.T. Hagstrum Commentary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........... D.R. Nelson
Chapter 2. 2.1. 2.2.
2.3.
2.4.
2.5. 2.6.
2.7. 2.8.
THE EARLY EARTH . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Editor: D.R. Nelson
GENERATION OF CONTINENTAL CRUST Editors: D.R. Nelson and W.U. Mueller
..........................
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
W.U. Mueller and D.R. Nelson Isua Enigmas: Illusive Tectonic, Sedimentary, Volcanic and Organic Features of the > 3.7 Ga Isua Greenstone Belt, Southwest Greenland . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . J.S. Myers Geochemical Diversity in Volcanic Rocks of the > 3.7 Ga Isua Greenstone Belt, Southern West Greenland: Implications for Mantle Composition and Geodynamic Processes . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Polat, A.W. Hofmann and P. W. U. Appel Abitibi Greenstone Belt Plate Tectonics: The Diachrononous History of Arc Development, Accretion and Collision . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . R. Daigneault, W.U. Mueller and E.H. Chown Granite Formation and Emplacement as Indicators of Archaean Tectonic Processes . . . . . . . . . . T.E. Zegers Diapiric Processes in the Formation of Archaean Continental Crust, East Pilbara Granite-Greenstone Terrane, Australia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.H. Hickman and M.J. Van Kranendonk Early Archaean Crustal Collapse Structures and Sedimentary Basin Dynamics . . . . . . . . . . . . W. Nijman and S.T. de Vries Crustal Growth Rates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . N. T. Arndt
v xvii
1
1 3 27 45 62
65 65
66
74
88 103
118 139 155
xii
Contents
2.9. C o m m e n t a r y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D.R. Nelson and W.U. Mueller
158
Chapter 3.
161
TECTONISM AND MANTLE PLUMES THROUGH TIME . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Editors: P.G. Eriksson and O. Catuneanu
3.1.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P.G. Eriksson and O. Catuneanu 3.2. Precambrian Superplume Events . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . K. C. Condie .3. Large Igneous Province Record through Time . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . R.E. Ernst, K.L. Buchan and A. Prokoph 3.4. Episodic Crustal Growth During Catastrophic Global-Scale Mantle Overturn Events . . . . . . . . . D.R. Nelson 3.5. An Unusual Palaeoproterozoic Magmatic Event, the Ultrapotassic Christopher Island Formation, Baker Lake Group, Nunavut, Canada: Archaean Mantle Metasomatism and Palaeoproterozoic Mantle Reactivation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B.L. Cousens, J.R. Chiarenzelli and L.B. Aspler 3.6. A Commentary on Precambrian Plate Tectonics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P, G. Eriksson and O. Catuneanu 3.7. Precambrian Ophiolites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . J.R. Chiarenzelli and E.M. Moores 3.8. The Limpopo Belt of Southern Africa: A Neoarchaean to Palaeoproterozoic Orogen . . . . . . . . . A.J. Bumby and R. van der Merwe 3.9. Geodynamic Crustal Evolution and Long-Lived Supercontinents During the Palaeoproterozoic: Evidence from Granulite-Gneiss Belts, Collisional and Accretionary Orogens . . . . . . . . . . . . . M. V. Mints and A.N. Konilov 3.10. Formation of a Late Mesoproterozoic Supercontinent: The South Africa-East Antarctica Connection H.E. Frimmel 3.11. A Mechanism for Explaining Rapid Continental Motion in the Late Neoproterozoic . . . . . . . . . J.G. Meert and E. Tamrat 3.12. Commentary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P.G. Eriksson and O. Catuneanu
Chapter 4. 4.1. 4.2. 4.3.
4.4.
PRECAMBRIAN VOLCANISM: AN INDEPENDENT VARIABLE THROUGH T I M E . . . Editor: W.U. Mueller
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . W. U. Mueller and P. C. Thurston Terminology of Volcaniclastic and Volcanic Rocks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . W.U. Mueller and J.D.L White Komatiites: Volcanology, Geochemistry and Textures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3.1. Physical Volcano!ogy of Komatiites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . W. U. MuelIer 4.3.2. Komatiite Geochemistry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . J. Dostal and W. U. Mueller 4.3.3. Textures in Komatiites and Variolitic Basalts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . N.T. Arndt and A.D. Fowler Archaean and Proterozoic Greenstone Belts: Setting and Evolution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P.C. Thurston and L.D. Ayres
161 163 173 180
183 201 213 217
223 240 255 267
271 271 273 277 277 290 298 311
Contents
4.5. 4.6. 4.7.
xiii
Explosive Subaqueous Volcanism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . J.D.L. White Archaean Calderas . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . W.U. Mueller, J. Stix, J.D.L. White and G.J. Hudak Commentary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . W. U. Mueller
Chapter 5.
THE EVOLUTION OF THE PRECAMBRIAN ATMOSPHERE: CARBON ISOTOPIC EVIDENCE FROM THE AUSTRALIAN CONTINENT . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Editors: P.G. Eriksson and W. Altermann
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P.G. Eriksson and W. Altermann 5.2. Archaean Atmosphere, Hydrosphere and Biosphere . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . H. Ohmoto 5.3. Evolution of the Precambrian Atmosphere: Carbon Isotopic Evidence from the Australian Continent J.E Lindsay and M.D. Brasier 5.4. Precambrian Iron-Formation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.F. Trendall and J.G. Blockley 5.5. The Precambrian Sulphur Isotope Record of Evolving Atmospheric Oxygen . . . . . . . . . . . . . . T.W. Lyons, L.C. Kah and A.M. Gellatly 5.6. Earth's Two Great Precambrian Glaciations: Aftermath of the "Snowball Earth" Hypothesis . . . . . G.M. Young 5.7. The Paradox of Proterozoic Glaciomarine Deposition, Open Seas and Strong Seasonality Near the Palaeo-Equator: Global Implications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . G.E. Williams 5.8. Neoproterozoic Sedimentation Rates and Timing of Glaciations--A Southern African Perspective . H.E. Frimmel 5.9. Earth's Precambrian Rotation and the Evolving Lunar Orbit: Implications of Tidal Rhythmite Data for Palaeogeophysics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . G.E. Williams 5.10. Ancient Climatic and Tectonic Settings Inferred from Palaeosols Developed on Igneous Rocks . . . H.W. Nesbitt and G.M. Young 5.11. Aggressive Archaean Weathering . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P.L. Corcoran and W. U. Mueller 5.12. Commentary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P.G. Eriksson and W Altermann 5.1.
Chapter 6. 6.1. 6.2. 6.3. 6.4. 6.5.
EVOLUTION OF LIFE AND PRECAMBRIAN BIO-GEOLOGY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Editor: W. Altermann
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . W. Altermann Earth's Earliest Biosphere: Status of the Hunt . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . J.W. Schopf Evolving Life and Its Effect on Precambrian Sedimentation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . W. Altermann Microbial Origin of Precambrian Carbonates: Lessons from Modern Analogues . . . . . . . . . . . . J. Kazmierczak, S. Kempe and W. Altermann Precambrian Stromatolites: Problems in Definition, Classification, Morphology and Stratigraphy . . W. Altermann
334 345 356
359 359 361 388 403 421 440
448 459
473 482 494 505
513 513 516 539 545 564
xiv
6.6. 6.7.
Contents
Precambrian Geology and Exobiology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E Westall Commentary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . W. Altermann
Chapter 7.
SEDIMENTATION THROUGH TIME Editor: P.G. Eriksson
575 587
..............................
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P.G. Eriksson, A.J. Bumby and M. Popa 7.2. Sedimentary Structures: An Essential Key for Interpreting the Precambrian Rock Record . . . . . . J.A. Donaldson, L.B. Aspler and J.R. Chiarenzelli 7.3. Archaean Sedimentary Sequences . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P.L. Corcoran and W. U. Mueller 7.4. Discussion of Selected Techniques and Problems in the Field Mapping and Interpretation of Archaean Clastic Metasedimentary Rocks of the Superior Province, Canada . . . . . . . . . . . . . . J.R. Devaney 7.5. Precambrian Tidalites: Recognition and Significance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . K.A. Eriksson and E.L. Simpson 7.6. Sedimentary Dynamics of Precambrian Aeolianites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E.L. Simpson, F.E Alkmim, P.K. Bose, A.J. Bumby, K.A. Eriksson, P.G. Eriksson, M.A. Martins-Nero, L.T. Middleton and R.H. Rainbird 7.7. Early Precambrian Epeiric Seas . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P.G. Eriksson, A.J. Bumby and P. Mostert 7.8. Precambrian Rivers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. G.E Long 7.9. Microbial Mats in the Siliciclastic Rock Record: A Summary of Diagnostic Features . . . . . . . . . J. Schieber 7.10. Microbial Mat Features in Sandstones Illustrated . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . S. Sarkar, S. Banerjee and P.G. Eriksson 7.11. Sedimentation Rates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P.G. Eriksson, P.K. Bose, S. Sarkar and S. Banerjee 7.12. Commentary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P.G. Eriksson and M.A. Martins-Nero 7.1.
Chapter 8.
SEQUENCE STRATIGRAPHY AND THE PRECAMBRIAN Editor: O. Catuneanu
.................
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A.E Embry, O. Catuneanu and P.G. Eriksson 8.2. Concepts of Sequence Stratigraphy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . O. Catuneanu, A.E Embry and P.G. Eriksson 8.3. Development and Sequences of the Athabasca Basin, Early Proterozoic, Saskatchewan and Alberta, Canada . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P. Ramaekers and O. Catuneanu 8.4. Third-Order Sequence Stratigraphy in the Palaeoproterozoic Daspoort Formation (Pretoria Group, Transvaal Supergroup), Kaapvaal Craton . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P.G. Eriksson and O. Catuneanu 8.5. Commentary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . O. Catuneanu and P.G. Eriksson
8.1.
593 593 602 613
625 631 642
657 660 663 673 675 677
681 681 685
705
724 735
Contents
Chapter 9. 9.1. 9.2. 9.3. 9.4. 9.5. 9.6. 9.7. 9.8. 9.9.
xv
TOWARDS A SYNTHESIS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P.G. Eriksson, O. Catuneanu, D.R. Nelson, W.U. Mueller and W. Altermann
Evolution of the Solar System and the Early Earth . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Generation of Continental Crust . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Tectonism and Mantle Plumes through Time . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Precambrian Volcanism, an Independent Variable . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Evolution of the Hydrosphere and Atmosphere . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Evolution of Precambrian Life and Bio-Geology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sedimentation Regimes through Time . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sequence Stratigraphy through Time . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Tempos and Events in Precambrian Time . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
References
.....................................................
Subject Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
739 739 743 747 749 751 755 758 761 762 771 923
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
xvii
PREFACE
Many facets of Earth's evolution are intriguing, yet most of our attention is drawn to the more recent phases, as from the Cambrian epoch (c. < 540 Ma). The Precambrian Era, from 4.5 to 0.54 Ga, covers almost 90% of this planet's history but our knowledge of this segment of time remains elusive, save for selective aspects. Even though extensive research has been conducted on some topics, a significant diversity of opinions amongst researchers is evident and generally concerns the origin, the mechanism or the process inherent to a specific criterion. For example, did the atmosphere change with time? Are palaeoweathering surfaces or regoliths indicative of anoxic or oxygenated climatic conditions? Many other unresolved questions remain. What were the prevalent large-scale driving forces during continent or greenstone belt formation? Have sedimentary patterns evolved with time, or is there just a shift in the prevalent transport process? Can sequence stratigraphy be applied to Archaean sequences, or is better temporal resolution required? Can tidal sequences be identified and characterised in 3.2 Ga sedimentary rocks? Can we reconstruct celestial mechanics within the solar system using modern tidal models and calculations? Have volcanic processes changed over geological time? Why are komatiites largely constrained to the Archaean era? Have supercontinents driven global glaciation periods? The dictum "the present is key to the past" was borne out of the necessity that specific geological problems or features in the past can not be adequately explained or addressed due to limited information or outcrop exposure; there is also a large measure of truth inthe reverse axiom. Ancient surface-forming sedimentary structures (i.e., bedforms and macroforms) can be compared to present-day structures because we assume processes operative on land and sea that produced this structure were comparable and independent of the era. Actualism is a non-gradualistic uniformitarian approach advocating that similar (the same?) processes and invariant natural physical, chemical and biological laws were operative, and hence applicable to both the Precambrian and present. Relative rates of processes or events, such as mid-ocean ridge spreading and subduction, weathering, genesis of continental crust, the rotation of Earth, and the atmospheric evolution probably contrasted with those of Phanerozoic successions, but the large and small scale, surface-forming processes or mechanisms are certainly comparable. For specific aspects, the Precambrian rock record is more useful in explaining processes or mechanisms (of early Earth) than observation and reading of recent processes which are difficult to access. For example, ancient subaqueous volcanic sequences can often be better loci for identifying and quantifying volcanic eruption mechanisms or depositional processes of the early Earth than modern ocean floor settings. This is simply because we cannot access the ocean floor without expensive high technology machinery (i.e., submersibles and ROVs), or map the ocean floor systematically, but extensive subaqueous
xviii
Preface
volcanic sequences are exposed on land. Despite being highly deformed and metamorphosed, ancient Precambrian rocks do offer advantages. For example, mountain-building phases regularly expose thick ancient sequences of oceanic crust, and the nuclei of most continents have well-exposed remnants of Archaean crust (e.g., Superior Province, Canada and Kaapvaal craton, South Africa). These extensive Archaean cratons, present on all major continents, permit us to evaluate how the mechanisms and processes of crustal evolution changed over time. The details of the mechanisms driving the Earth and its development inevitably changed with time. Interaction between erosional and depositional surface processes, mantle dynamics and large-scale horizontal plate motions, mantle- and crust-derived igneous rocks, as well as the complex interplay between atmosphere, climate and biodiversity, reveal the hallmarks of evolution through time, hence the title of this book "The Preeambrian Earth: Tempos and Events". The title conveys the notion that nothing remains completely the same through time and each of the chapters focuses on how this change came about and how it can be explained. It is the latter that arouses geologists' interest. Geologists are renowned for their divergent opinions, and this book adheres to this tradition. Controversy often drives research, and in all chapters there is never one unique solution, opinion, or view but rather a representative cross-section of possible explanations. The editors have sought to synthesise each chapter so that the reader can assimilate more easily all this new and highly condensed information. Throughout the book a diversity of opinion was encouraged and supported. So what are "tempos and events"? Continents have been formed, accreted and dismembered regularly throughout Earth's 4.5 Ga history. The conditions and parameters driving such continental evolutionary events will have changed. This book attempts to place change in an overall context. A continent is an amalgamation of accreted material including volcanic ocean floor and arcs, sedimentary trench deposits, continental platform deposits, but also abundant plutonic material. In the Precambrian, supercontinents formed at various times, with the best known being: (1) a Neoarchaean "northern" (present-day frame of reference) "Kenorland"; (2) a "southern" continent at c. 2.2-1.8 Ga, with (3) the approximately coeval, "northern" Laurentia at c. 2.0-1.7 Ga, to be followed (4) by Columbia in the Mesoproterozoic, (5) the Neoproterozoic had a succession of supercontinents (e.g., Rodinia), ending with the Phanerozoic Gondwana landmasses. The term tempos refers to the rate over a time span at which a certain event (i.e., formation of a supercontinent) or process (i.e., alluvial fan or volcanic edifice construction) occurred. Significant events include superplume volcanism, palaeo-atmospheric changes, advances or retreats of living organisms, orogenic mountain-building phases, continental breakup, as well as global sedimentation patterns (glaciogenic deposits, iron-formations or giant carbonate platforms) and associated sea level changes. Intuitively with the changing dynamics of large-scale endogenous and exogenous processes, the time scale of events and processes must have changed, but some processes or mechanisms responsible for a temporal change of events are difficult to quantify. Each chapter is a reflection of specific events, and the term evolution includes the notion of a temporal change. Not all authors agree on how and over what time scale specific events have occurred, but we are all of the opinion that Earth has evolved. Many
Preface
xix
roads lead to Rome, with some being more direct and evident than others. This book is the outgrowth of numerous research avenues documenting change with time, or as the rifle indicates, tempos and events. The book is a comprehensive entity, but each chapter and individual paper is designed so that it can be read and understood in isolation. The first chapter examines the celestial origins of our planet and solar system and the early differentiation into core, mantle, crust and primitive atmospheres. Chapter 2 is devoted to understanding the formation of granitegreenstone crust. Plate tectonics (and any possible forebear mechanisms) and mantle superplumes surely are related to continental (and oceanic) crustal growth, but are treated separately in chapter 3, as these concepts are both complex and contentious. Chapter 4 considers Precambrian volcanism as an independent variable through time; again, there are strong relationships with the preceding two chapters. Overlap and common themes naturally abound for the successive chapters 5 (evolution of the atmosphere-hydrosphere), 6 (life and bio-geology), 7 (sedimentation through time) and 8 (Precambrian sequence stratigraphy). We are the first to admit that many different structures and chapter outlays could have been adopted, but they grew naturally as the book developed and helped modify some of the prejudices the editors had, as the data set enlarged and new viewpoints were presented. Every chapter has an introduction by one or two editors to the relevant theme(s) being covered, followed by a succession of differently-authored papers, arranged in a specific order chosen by the editorial team. An editorial commentary terminates the chapter incorporating and discussing the views presented. The final chapter synthesises an enormous range of geological "events" occurring at different time periods ("tempos") over c. 4 Ga of Precambrian Earth evolution. The introduction, the various papers, and the closing commentary are termed "sections". The sections have a different authorship team, and are numbered for ease of cross-referencing between sections and chapters. Figures and tables are similarly numbered, based on the adopted section system. Throughout the book we have adopted a few conventions, quite apart from an "English" spelling system that may be strange to some North AmeriCan readers. Terms "Ma" and "Ga" represent millions and billions (10 9) of years before Present, with "My" being used to denote a time period unrelated to any datum. Emphasised text has been underlined and italics are used for non-English terms of common usage. We have found the editing and writing of this book to be an extremely rewarding and educational exercise, and hope the reader will also find it beneficial. We owe our large community of authors from all over the world our gratitude for their tolerance of our numerous requests and changes.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Firstly, Friso Veenstra of Elsevier who approved this book on the recommendation of Kent Condie, the series editor for Elsevier's book-series "Developments in Precambrian Geology". Kent Condie has trodden deep steps within Precambrian geological thought and
xx
Preface
literature, and we have all learnt much from him over the years; we also acknowledge his great encouragement of the book as a whole and for advice on the theme chosen. Patricia Massar of Elsevier was of great assistance in explaining the technical details of manuscript preparation. Without the skills, patience and infinite capacity of Magda Geringer (Department of Geography, University of Pretoria), this book would not have seen the light of day. She did most of the drafting and upgraded all figures, quite apart from dealing with a large array of different software packagesmwe are in her debt. Financially, the University of Pretoria, the University of Alberta and the University of Quebec at Chicoutimi supported drafting costs generously. Wulf Mueller would like to thank LITHOPROBE for its significant contributions in the last 10 years because much of our (my) knowledge concerning Canadian Precambrian craton evolution and characteristics stems from this pan-Canadian research project. Apart from myself, numerous authors in this book were supported by LITHOPROBE. Wlady Altermann is indebted to LE STUDIUM and the CNRS, Orl6ans, and to the GeoBioCenter LMU for support during the major phase of preparing this book. Pat Eriksson acknowledges generous financial support from the University of Pretoria towards this book. No endeavour of this magnitude is possible without a very large team of qualified and willing reviewers. They are gratefully acknowledged and listed below: A. Altenbach (Ludwig-Maximilians University, Munich) W. Altermann (Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Orl6ans) A.D. Anbar (Univ. of Rochester, New York) L.B. Aspler (Consultant, Ottawa) S.-J. Barnes (Univ. of Quebec, Chicoutimi) R.S. Blewett (Geoscience Australia, Canberra) A. Brack (Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Orl6ans) G. Brandl (Council for Geoscience, South Africa) A.J. Bumby (Univ. of Pretoria, South Africa) D. Champion (Geoscience Australia, Canberra) J.R. Chiarenzelli (State Univ. of New York, Potsdam) RL. Corcoran (Univ. of Western Ontario) E. Cotter (Bucknell Univ., USA) R Cousineau (Univ. of Quebec, Chicoutimi) J. Dann (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) J.R. de Laeter (Curtin Univ., Australia) M. de Wit (Univ. of Cape Town, South Africa) J.A. Donaldson (Carleton Univ., Ottawa) B.G. Els (Univ. of Pretoria, South Africa) K.A. Eriksson (Virgina Polytechnic, USA) R G. Eriksson (Univ. of Pretoria, South Africa) R.E. Ernst (Geological Survey of Canada, Ottawa) D.A.D. Evans (Yale Univ.) C.M. Fedo (George Washington Univ.) R Fralick (Lakehead Univ.)
Preface
T. Frisch (Geological Survey of Canada, Ottawa) W.E. Galloway (Univ. of Texas at Austin) A. Gaucher (Univ. of Montevideo) G. Gerdes (Universit~t Oldenburg, Wilhelmshaven) G.J.B. Germs (Rand Afrikaans Univ., Johannesburg, South Africa) B.E Glass (Univ. of Delaware) C. Glatz (Univ. of Maine) R. Gorbatschev (Lund Univ., Sweden) J.W. Hagedorn (Amherst College, USA) R.E. Hanson (Univ. of Fort Worth, Texas) S. Hassler (California State Univ., Hayward) B.M. Jakosky (Univ. of Colorado, Boulder) C.W. Jefferson (Geological Survey of Canada, Ottawa) B.S. Kamber (Univ. of Queensland, Australia) E King (Univ. of Western Ontario) C. Klein (Univ. of New Mexico, Albuquerque) B. Lafrance (Laurentian Univ., Ontario) D. Lescinsky (Univ. of Western Ontario) J.H. Lipps (Univ. of California, Berkeley) D.G.E Long (Laurentian Univ., Ontario) M.A. Martins-Neto (Univ. of Ouro Preto, Brazil) J. McPhie (Univ. of Tasmania, Australia) J. Menzies (Brock Univ., Ontario) A.D. Miall (Univ. of Toronto) R. Morris (CSIRO, Australia) W.U. Mueller (Univ. of Quebec; Chicoutimi) D.R. Nelson (Geol. Surv. Western Australia and Curtin Univ., Australia) A.A. Nemchin (Curtin Univ., Australia) A. Nunes (Barnard College, New York) C.D. Ollier (Univ. of Western Australia) R.T. Pidgeon (Curtin Univ., Australia) M. Popa (Univ. of Bucharest) H.W. Posamentier (Anadarko Canada Corporation, Calgary) D. Powars (US Geological Survey, Stephens City, Virginia) R.H. Rainbird (Geol. Survey of Canada, Ottawa) K.J.R. Rosman (Curtin Univ., Australia) D. Schmidt (Ludwig-Maximilians Univ., Munich) C.A. Smit (Rand Afrikaans Univ., Johannesburg, South Africa) R.H. Smithies (Geol. Surv. Western Australia) G.M. Stott (Ontario Geol. Survey, Sudbury) H. Strauss (Westf~lische Wilhelms-Universit~t, MUnster) L. Tack (Royal Museum for Central Africa, Belgium) H. Tirsgaard (Maersk Oil, Copenhagen)
xxi
xxii
Preface
T. Torsvik (Norwegian Geological Survey, Trondheim) A.E Trendall (Curtin Univ., Australia) D.W. Valentino (State Univ. of New York, Oswego) R. van der Voo (Univ. of Michigan) A.J. van Loon (Benitachell Univ., Spain) M.R. Walter (Macquarie Univ., Australia) R. Weinberg (Monash Univ., Australia) G. Whitmore (Univ. of Natal, Durban, South Africa) M.C. Wizevich (Southern Connecticut State Univ.) Additional acknowledgements are listed below, related to specific sections of the book. D.R. Nelson (section 1.2) dedicates this section to Emeritus Professor John R. de Laeter, A.O., Cit (WA), B.Ed. (Hons), B.Sc. (Hons), Ph.D.D.Sc. (W. Aust.), Hon Tech (Curtin), FTSE, FInstP, FAIP, whose inspiration, leadership and example over the last 15 years constitutes an incalculable personal, professional and scientific contribution. The Perth Sensitive High-Resolution Ion MicroProbe is operated by a consortium consisting of Curtin University, the Geological Survey of Western Australia and the University of Western Australia with the support of the Australian Research Council. Published with permission of the Director, GSWA. D.H. Abbott and J.T. Hagstrum (section 1.4) thank S. Hoffman for editing and D. Breger for her help and expertise on the SEM. A. Polat, A.W. Hoffmann and P.W.U. Appel (section 2.3) thank S. Moorbath, J.S. Myers, S. Hanmer, M. Rosing, R. Frei and H. Rollinson for scientific discussion on the Isua greenstone belt. R. Kerrich and A. Trenhaile are acknowledged for their comprehensive critique of the initial draft of the manuscript. A. Polat is: grateful to the Max-Planck-Institut (Mainz) and the Alexander yon Humboldt Foundation for financial and logistic support. NSERC Grant #250926-02 to A. Polat is acknowledged. This is a contribution of the Isua Multi-disciplinary Research Project. R. Daigneault, W.U. Mueller and E.H. Chown (section 2.4) note that this Abitibi synthesis study was the outgrowth of 20 years mapping by the three of us and many students that paved the way with their data and theses. The Quebec Ministbre des Richesses naturelles (MRNQ) is thanked for constant support, as are the exploration companies. NSERC, FUQUAC, and LITHOPROBE funding (LITHOPROBE contribution no. 1325) are gratefully acknowledged. A.H. Hickman and M.J. van Kranendonk (section 2.6) note that thiscontribution uses information from numerous sources, but particularly from colleagues at the Geological Survey of Western Australia (GSWA), Geo5 science Australia, the University of Newcastle (W.J. Collins and M. Pawley), and Sipa Resources Ltd., Perth (E Morant and C. Brauhart). Their interpretations have benefited from discussions with all these people, but especially with R.H. Smithies, D.R. Nelson, L. Bagas, I.R. Williams, T. Farrell, and E Pirajno. Both authors publish with permission of the Director, Geological Survey of Western Australia. W. Nijman and S.T. de Vries (section 2.7) note that some of the observations and conclusions form part of a Ph.D. study of the second author, to be published in 2003. Gratefully we acknowledge the financial support of the project on Earth's Earliest Sedimentary Basins by the Foundation Dr. Schtirmannfonds in the Netherlands and the cooperation with Maarten de Wit, Frances Westall, Manfred van Bergen, Hanan Kisch, Dave Nelson, and Richard Armstrong. The manu-
Preface
xxiii
script benefited much from comments from Poppe de Boer. Last but not least, we thank the many former Utrecht M.Sc. students for their contributions to the project. R.E. Ernst, K.L. Buehan and A. Prokoph (section 3.3) note that this is Geological Survey of Canada publication 2002188. B.L. Cousens, J.R. Chiarenzdli and L.B. Aspler (section 3.5) acknowledge funding provided through contracts with the Yellowknife Geology Division, Indian and Northern Affairs Canada, facilitated by Bill Padgham and Carolyn Relf, as part of the Western Churchill NATMAP project. Rex Brommecker of WMC originally suggested we examine the Rack Lake drill core. Thanks to A1 Donaldson, Hamish Sandeman, Tony Peterson, Tony LeCheminant, Eva Zaleski, Rob Rainbird, Thomas Hadlari, Derek Smith, Yannick Beaudoin, Ken Ashton, Russell Hartlaub, and Simon Hanmer for providing samples. A1 Armitage and Ryan Morelli kindly provided unpublished analyses from MacQuoid-Gibson dykes and Martin Formation volcanic rocks, respectively. Thanks to the XRF facility at the University of Ottawa and the Ontario Geological Survey laboratories for major and trace element analyses. Donna Switzer, Julie Thompson, Muy Ngo, Brenda Obina and Samantha Seigel performed much of the isotopic lab work. We benefited from discussions with Hamish Sandeman, Tony Peterson, Tony LeCheminant, Rob Rainbird, A1 Donaldson and A1 Miller. M.V. Mints and A.N. Konilov (section 3.9) point out that their paper developed from discussions at workshops sponsored by the COPENA IGCP Project 371 and SVEKALAPKO, a EUROPROBE project during recent years. The work was supported by the Russian Foundation for Basic Research, Projects No. 00-0564241 and No. 01-05-64373. The authors are very grateful to colleagues who have been participating in ongoing studies of the Early Precambrian in the Kola Peninsula and Karelia. H.E. Frimmel (section 3.10) thanks S. Perrit and S. Helferich for providing zircon separates from samples collected in the Borgmassivet area and southern Kirwanveggen, respectively. G. Doyle and A. Bisnath are thanked for the companionship during the 2001/02 Antarctic field season. Both analytical and field work in Antarctica were funded by the Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism within the framework of the South African National Antarctic Programme. J.G. Meert and E. Tamrat (section 3.11) wish to thank Monika Lipinski for an early review of the manuscript. H. Ohmoto (section 5.2) thanks the following persons for providing stimulating discussions, over years, on the various topics related to this paper: Dick Holland, Jim Kasting, Lee Kump, Mike Arthur, Chris House, Kate Freeman, Tony Lasaga, Nic Beukes, Jenz Gutzmer, Lawry Minter, Mike Kimberley, Ken Towe, Yumiko Watanabe, Kosei Yamaguchi, Takeshi Kakegawa, Ken Hayashi, Hiroshi Naraoka, Munetomo and Yoko Nedachi, and Yasu Kato. Financial support from NASA Astrobiology Program (NCC2-1057), NASA Exobiology Program (NAG5-9089) and NSF (EAR-9706279) is gratefully acknowledged. T.W. Lyons, L.C. Kah and A.M. Gellafly (section 5.5) acknowledge financial support by NSF awards EAR-9596079 and EAR-9725538. The Indiana University Stable Isotope Facility, and in particular Jon Fong and Steve Studley, assisted with many of the isotopic analyses. The authors also benefited from many fruitful conversations with Don Canfield, Mike Formolo, Tracy Frank, Matt Hurtgen, Jim Luepke, and Don Winston. G.M. Young (section 5.6) is grateful to the National Scientific and Engineering Research Council of Canada for generous support of investigation of Precambrian glaciogenic rocks over the years and to indi-
xxiv
Preface
viduals too numerous to mention for discussions and field trips related to glaciogenic rocks. H.E. Frilnmel (section 5.8) acknowledges research funding by the South African National Research Foundation. W.J. Sehopf (section 6.2) notes that this research was supported by NASA, though Grant NAG 5-12357 and the Astrobiology Institute. J. Kazmierezak, S. Kempe and W. Altermann (section 6.4) acknowledge financial support from the Foundation for Polish Science (Scholar Grant 2000 to J.K.) and from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (to S.K.). W.A. is grateful to the University of Pretoria, the GeoBio-Center LMU Germany and to the Centre Biophysique Moleculaire, CNRS, Orleans, France for technical support. J.R. Devaney (section 7.4): aside from a thesis completed at Lakehead University and supervised by Phil Fralick, my sedimentologically-oriented studies of Archaean greenstone belts were done while employed by the Ontario Geological Survey. J. Sehieber (section 7.9) is grateful to Wolfgang Krumbein for his enthusiastic encouragement of microbial mat research in the early stages of his career, as well as for his sustained motivation and advice since then. Support for research on sediments that yielded microbial mat features was provided by the National Science Foundation (Grants #EAR-9117701 and EAR,9706178) and the Donors of the Petroleum Research Fund, administered by the American Chemical Society (Grants #25134-AC2 and 33941-AC8). A. Embry, O. Catuneanu and P.G. Eriksson (sections 8.1 and 8.2) acknowledge financial support from the University of Alberta and NSERC Canada (OC); AFE thanks the Geological Survey of Canada for encouraging the research on sequence stratigraphy and for allowing the publication of this paper. PGE acknowledges research support from the University of Pretoria. E Ramaekers and O. Catuneanu (section 8.3): this study benefited from work carried out by P.R. at the Saskatchewan and Alberta Geological Surveys, the Saskatchewan Mining Development Corporation (now Cameco), ongoing work in the Athabasca Basin as a consultant, discussion with industry staff, especially those of Cameco and Cogema, and coworkers of the Extech IV Research project (Jefferson et al., 2002), especially Charlie Jefferson, Gary Yeo, and Darrel Long. O.C. acknowledges research support from the University of Alberta and NSERC Canada. Last, and by no means least, we thank our long-suffering partners, whose support and understanding during preparation of this book, and at all times, remain very important to us: Patricia, Renate, Gabriela, Mari~inne and Janet. June 2003
Wulf U. Mueller (Chicoutimi) Wladyslaw Altermann (Orldans) Octavian Catuneanu (Edmonton) Patrick G. Eriksson (Pretoria) David R. Nelson (Perth)
The Precambrian Earth: Tempos and Events Edited by EG. Eriksson, W. Altermann, D.R. Nelson, W.U. Mueller and O. Catuneanu Developments in Precambrian Geology, Vol. 12 (K.C. Condie, Series Editor) Published by Elsevier B.V.
Chapter 1
THE EARLY E A R T H
1.1. INTRODUCTION D.R. NELSON Inferences about the pre-4.0 Ga geological history of the Earth have been based traditionally either on the study of the oldest identified remnants on the Earth's surface (e.g., Maas et al., 1992; Nutman et al., 1996; Amelin et al., 1999; Nelson et al., 2000; Ryder et al., 2000; Wilde et al., 2001; Mojzsis et al., 2001), or on modelling of the differentiation of global chemical reservoirs (e.g., Arndt and Chauvel, 1990; Bennett et al., 1993; Bowring and Housh, 1995; Kramers and Tolstikhin, 1997; Snow and Schmidt, 1998; Albarbde et al., 2000; Canfield et al., 2000; Nutman et al., 2001). A major limitation of these approaches arises from the limited tangible evidence available for study of early Earth--the preserved rock record commences at 4030 Ma (Stern and Bleeker, 1998; Bowring and Williams, 1999), more than 500 My after the Earth's formation. As a consequence, these approaches have so far provided only broad constraints on the mechanisms and time scales of accretion and early differentiation of the Earth, and of physicochemical conditions on the Earth's surface during this time. In section 1.2 of this chapter, a new approach to the study of the early Earth, based on detailed chemical and isotopic studies of meteorites in combination with advances in our understanding of nucleosynthesis, has been investigated. In 1960, the remarkable discovery by J.H. Reynolds of the isotope xenon-129 (129Xe) within the earliest-forming phase of a primitive meteorite (Reynolds, 1960; see also Jeffery and Reynolds, 1961) was eventually to lead to a breakthrough in our understanding of the timing of accretion and differentiation of the Earth. The 129Xe detected by Reynolds had accumulated in situ from the radiogenic decay of the long-extinct nuclide iodine- 129 (129I), which has a half-life of only c. 16 My. The daughter products of a number of other extinct nuclides have since been identified within primitive meteorites, and it is now generally accepted that their short-lived radioactive parent nuclides were synthesised during supernova explosions in the vicinity and shortly before the formation of our solar system. These catastrophic nucleosynthesis events mark the time at which the radioactive isotopes that are widely used for geochronology were formed. As they are now long extinct, short-lived nuclides cannot be used directly to obtain absolute dates relative to the present-day, but their short half-lives have been used to constrain precisely the relative chronologies of planetary formation milestones for the early solar system (see Fig. 1.1-1). The Earth and other terrestrial planets formed by the collision and amalgamation of smaller rocky planetesimals within the early solar system's protoplanetary disk. During the later stages of this accretion process, progressively larger planetary embryos were formed
2
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
Type II supernova event (4571 Ma) 4600 triggered collapse of precursor interstellar molecular cloud
4500 4540
4400
formation of CAI's (4570 Ma) first chondrules (4565 Ma) first planetesimals (c. 4565-4550 Ma)
4300
proto-Earth accretion, core formation
4200
?Mars-sized impactor, formation of Moon o
4100 4000
I
detrital zircons (ZrSiO4) from the Yilgam Craton Acasta orthogneisses
3900 ~ 3800
"
Mt Sones, Enderby Land
3700
Isua greenstone belt, Greenland Manfred Complex, NarryerTerrane
3600
Ancient Gneiss Complex, Kaapvaal Craton orthogneiss in Warrawagine Complex, Pilbara Craton
3500
Coonterunah Formation, Pilbara Craton
3400
granite-greenstonecrust, Pilbara and Kaapvaalcratons
Fig. 1.1-1. Chronology of major events during formation of the solar system and the early Earth (see section 1.2 for further details).
and collided. These violent collisions resulted in the episodic reforming of the growing proto-Earth, along with the destruction of much of the evidence of the extent of earlier differentiation. The Earth's Moon also probably formed as a result of such a catastrophic collision during the later stages of Earth accretion. As the planetary embryos grew, the impact rate decreased and the chances of survival of these early-formed fragments of the Earth's surface increased. In section 1.3 of this chapter, Simonson et al. argue that terrestrial impact structures predating the Proterozoic era (> 2.5 Ga) are unlikely to have survived, due to the fragmentary state of preservation of the Earth's rock record from this time. Fortunately, evidence of such early impact events may be preserved in the Earth's stratigraphic archive, as thin layers rich in distinctive sand-sized spherules. In section 1.4, Abbott and Hagstrum estimate that in the time interval between 3.8 and 2.5 Ga, there were more than 350 impact events large enough to produce an impact layer of global extent. It has also been proposed (section 1.4) that major magmatic and (by implication) crustformation events during the Archaean could have been related to major impact episodes. Although it is widely acknowledged that major impacts must have played an important role in the formation of the Earth's early continental crust, this "extraterrestrial" influence has largely been overlooked in most previous studies of the Earth's Archaean terranes. Recognition and detailed investigation of impact-related sedimentary rocks preserved in the Earth's stratigraphic record currently is still in its infancy, but the way ahead is clearer from studies such as those documented in sections 1.3 and 1.4 of this chapter.
1.2. E a r t h ' s k b r m a t i o n a n d First Billion Years
3
1.2. EARTH'S FORMATION AND FIRST BILLION YEARS D.R. NELSON Introduction
In this section, a new approach to the study of the early Earth, commencing before the time of formation of our solar system at 4571 Ma and working forward in time towards 3500 Ma, has been investigated. This approach explores recent insights into the processes active during formation of the early Earth arising from detailed chemical and isotopic studies of meteorites, combined with advances in our understanding of nucleosynthesis. Many meteorites are fragments of asteroids formed early in the evolutionary history of the solar system, that were too small to have undergone much internal heating (see Hutchison et al., 2001). Some contain refractory calcium- and aluminium-rich inclusions that condensed from the nebula when temperatures were so high that other elements were volatile, shortly after formation of the Sun and during dissipation of the nebula. Others represent disrupted fragments of planetesimals and differentiated planetary bodies, including the Moon and Mars, formed later in the accretion history of the solar system. Some meteorite classes are samples of the interiors of disrupted planetary bodies, and have formed prior to, during and after active differentiation of these bodies. They may therefore provide unique information about the processes operating during the early differentiation of the Earth into silicate crust and mantle, and metallic core. The identification of short-lived (with half-lives less than 100 My) radioactive, now extinct, nuclides within some classes of meteorites has imposed important new constraints on the early evolution of the solar system and on accretion and differentiation rates for planetary bodies such as the Earth. Short-lived nuclides potentially offer the means to precisely constrain early solar system chronology, and of planetary accretion and differentiation processes, in relation to the time of nucleosynthesis. To fully appreciate the insights offered by extinct nuclides into the chronology of the early solar system and formation and differentiation its planets including the Earth, an understanding of the processes involved in the synthesis of the elements prior to the formation of our solar system is required. Details of nucleosynthesis within stars were formulated by the pioneering work of E.M. Burbidge, G.R. Burbidge, Fowler, Hoyle and co-workers (Burbidge et al., 1957) and independently, by Cameron (1957). With the exception of the element hydrogen (H) and possibly some of the helium (He), lithium (Li), beryllium (Be) and boron (B) which may have been synthesised during the Big Bang or by spallation reactions, elements lighter than iron (Fe) now present in our solar system were created primarily by fusion reactions within the interiors of stars. Elements heavier than Fe were mostly synthesised by two major neutron-capture processes; the "slow" or s-process, which refers to the slow capture, relative to the rate of fl-decay, of neutrons within stars, and by the "rapid" or r-process, mostly in catastrophic supernovae events during which unstable intermediate isotopes form by the capture of neutrons in a neutron-dense environment and so rapidly that they do not have time to decay. (Some less abundant neutron-deficient, proton-rich The Precambrian Earth: Tempos and Events Edited by P.G. Eriksson, W. Altermann. D.R. Nelson, W.U. Mueller and O. Catuneanu
4
Chapter 1: 7"he Early Earth
nuclei were synthesised by a third px:ocess, the "proton" or p-process.) In this section, the processes by which short-lived nuclides were synthesised and implications of their identification within early-formed solar system materials for the mechanisms and time scales of formation of the solar system and its planets will be reviewed briefly. Additional important areas of investigation of the early Earth have recently arisen largely as a result of advances in experimental techniques. These include the recent development and application of methods for the isotopic analysis of elements with high ionisation potentials using multicollector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (MC-ICP-MS). In addition, geochemical and isotopic studies of the noble gases have provided constraints on the evolution of the atmosphere (see chapter 5) and history of degassing of the Earth's mantle. The ion microprobe has also recently been applied to the investigation of the only remnants of the pre-4000 Ma Earth available for study, the few small (c. 200 ~tm long) 4400 to 4000 Ma grains of the common accessory mineral zircon (ZrSiO4) found in sedimentary and granitic rocks in Western Australia. It is the purpose of this contribution to provide an overview of these new areas of investigation and to summarise their implications for the pre-3500 Ma history of the Earth.
Synthesis of the Heavy Elements and Short-Lived Nuclides Many heavier nuclides, including unstable nuclides with short lifetimes and that are now extinct, are synthesised by the r-process during core-collapse supernova events. In this section, the stellar environments in which these radionuclides are synthesised and the evidence for and some implications of the presence of extinct nuclides within early-formed materials of our solar system are outlined. Star formation commences with the fragmentation and collapse of the denser parts of interstellar dust and gas within so-called "dark nebula" regions into "proto-stars" of typically 10 to 50 solar masses and 0.1 parsecs ( p a r s e c - 3.09 • 1013 km or 3.26 light-years) in diameter. The proto-star mass continues to increase by the accretion of in-falling material until the increasing density and temperature within its core triggers thermonuclear fusion. Strong stellar winds may then reduce the in-fall and inhibit further growth of the star. An isolated star more massive than about 10 solar masses will evolve very rapidly and have a very short pre- "main sequence" (pre- hydrogen-burning) history of ~< 105 years. Once formed, it may consume all of its available hydrogen fuel within 10 My. Its core will contract progressively until the temperature becomes high enough for He burning to commence. As the core temperature continues to increase, He will be able to combine by the triple-or reaction to build carbon (lZc), and (by or-capture) oxygen (160), with all the He consumed after about 1 My. The core progressively contracts until "carbon-burning" can commence. Carbon nuclei then react with one another to form neon (Ne), sodium (23Na) and magnesium (about 10,000 years; 25Mg is the essential "seed" required for production of the short-lived nuclide 26A1, mainly via the reaction 25Mg(p, y)26A1; see Table 1.2-1), then Ne to O and Mg (about 12 years), O to silicon (Si) and sulphur (S; about 4 years) and finally, burning of Si to 54Fe and a variety of other neutron-rich nuclides with masses near 50 or 60 (about 1 week). Because Fe will not fuse to produce more energy, the star's
1.2. Earth's bbrmation and kirst Billion Years
5
available nuclear fuel nears exhaustion and the radiation pressure generated via fusion is not sufficient to counterbalance the compressive forces of gravitation. The core contracts and its temperature increases until, by highly endoergic reactions, Fe-group nuclei photodisintegrate into c~-particles and neutrons. The star will then collapse catastrophically (see Meyer, 1997, for a recent review), generating a shock wave in the star's outer layers (a socalled Type II supernova event; see Fig. 1.2-1-Type II supernovae are distinguished from those of Type I by the presence of H-emission lines in their spectra), during which r-process nucleosynthesis reactions generate the heavier neutron-rich nuclides (see Table 1.2-1). The discovery in some meteorites of the radioactive decay products of short-lived nuclides synthesised during supernovae events has placed important constraints on the mechanisms and timing of formation of our solar system. The first report of the presence of 129Xe from the radiogenic decay of the short-lived, now extinct, nuclide 129I was made by Reynolds (1960; see also Jeffery and Reynolds, 1961). The presence of a num-
Table 1.2-1. Short-lived radioactive parent-daughter decay systems that may be detected in early solar system materials, and their stellar production sites (adapted from the Chart of the Nuclides, Goswami (2000) and references cited therein) Half-life Radioactive Synthesis Stellar Decay Daughter nuclide
processes
production site
processes
nuclide(s)
26A1 36C1 41Ca 44Ti 53Mn 60Fe 92Nb 99Tc 107pd 129I 135Cs 146Sm 182Hf 205pb 244pu 247Cm
p, EC s EC EC, p r, EC r p s s, r r r p, EC, o~ r, EC, ~ s r,c~ r, ot
SN, N, AGB, W-R SN, AGB, W-R SN, AGB, W-R SN SN SN, AGB SN SN, W-R, RG SN, AGB, W-R SN AGB, W-R SN SN AGB, W-R, RG SN SN
EC /4EC EC,/3 + EC 2/3EC /3/-3/4,6~ 2/-3EC SF 3o~, 2/3-
26Mg 36Ar* 41K 44Ca 53Cr 60Ni 92Zr 99Ru* 107Ag 129Xe 135Ba 142Nd 182W 205T1" 132,4,6Xe (238U) 235U*
0.717 My 0.301 My 0.103 My 59 yr 3.74 My 1.50 My 34.7 My 0.21 1 My 6.50 My 15.7 My 2.30 My 103 My 9.0 My 1.5.3 My 81 My 15.6 My
Nuclide synthesis and decay processes: EC = electron capture, s = slow neutron capture, r = rapid neutron capture, p = "p-process'; photodisintegration of the products of the s-process and proton capture, fl- = electron emission,/3 + = positron emission, SF = spontaneous fission, ~ = alpha capture/decay. Stellar production sites: SN = Types Ib, Ic and II (core-collapse) supernova, N = nova, AGB = asymptotic giant branch star, W-R = "Wolf-Rayet" star, RG = Red Giant star. *Evidence of radioactive decay from short-lived parent radionuclide in presolar or early solar system materials as yet unconfirmed.
6
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
Fig. 1.2-1. SN1987A in the Large Magellanic Cloud 170,000 light-years away, imaged using the Wide Field and Planetary Camera 2 (WFPC2) aboard the Earth-orbiting Hubble Space Telescope. The remains of the supernova star and the material thrown off when the star exploded are visible as the bright object in the centre of the inner ring. The three rings in this false-colour image are illuminated by emissions from atomic H (red) and doubly-ionised O (yellow). The rings have been interpreted to lie on the surface of an hourglass-shaped bubble of gas, created by the interaction of stellar winds from the star as it evolved from a red to a blue supergiant, long before the supernova event. The bright central ring, with a diameter of 1.5 light-years, represents the waist of the hourglass, made to glow by radiation from the supernova explosion. The origin of the rings is uncertain; one theory suggests that the outer rings were formed by a pair of wobbling, narrowly directed jets emerging from the vicinity of the central star and slamming into the hourglass walls. Nebular structures found around other dying stars indicate that such jets and the death of stars are intimately associated. Courtesy of Chris Burrows (Space Telescope Science Institute), the WFPC2 Science Team, and NASA.
1.2. Earth's Formation and Fir~t Billion Years
7
ber of other short-lived nuclides within the earliest-forming phases of primitive meteorites has since been confirmed (Table 1.2-1; see also Podosek and Nichols, 1997). The inventory of the short-lived nuclides calcium-41 (41Ca), 26A1,6~ and palladium-107 (107pd) could have been generated within a nearby Asymptotic Giant Branch (AGB) s t a r u a star of up to c. 8 solar masses with an inert C- and O-rich core, He-burning inner shell and an outer H-burning shell from which most of the star's energy will be derived (Busso et al., 1999). However, others such as manganese-53 (53Mn) and 1291, could not have been produced within AGB stars, but can only be created within massive, short-lived stars by the r-process during supernovae events. Their presence within the earliest-formed materials of our solar system requires that a Type II supernova explosion occurred in the vicinity and within 2 My of solar system formation (Cameron and Truman, 1977). Alternative explanations, that the short-lived nuclides were produced by spallation interactions between suitable target nuclei and high-energy cosmic rays, are not consistent with the abundances of these nuclides (particularly the observed relative abundances of and correlations between the nuclides 41Ca and 26A1) found in early-formed materials (e.g., Wasserburg and Arnould, 1987; Cameron, 1995; Wasserburg et al., 1996; Sajipal et al., 1998; Lee and Halliday, 2000a). Nor does the evidence favour the interpretation (Clayton, 1982, 1986) that the decay products of these nuclides were carried by microscopic (or "fossil") phases formed in the interstellar medium long before formation of the meteorite inclusions (see MacPherson et al., 1995). Current evidence favours the synthesis of the short-lived nuclides with atomic masses > 140, along with a proportion of the heavy elements within our solar system, during a core-collapse supernova event c. 4571 Ma ago (Lugmair and Shukolyukov, 2001; Gilmour and Saxton, 2001). Some short-lived nuclides with atomic masses < 140 (such as l~ and 1291) were present in early-formed solar system materials in much lower abundance than anticipated by this scenario, and it has been proposed that these radionuclides were mostly synthesised during earlier supernovae events (Wasserburg et at., 1996; Cameron, 1998) or by a second r-process mechanism (Qian and Wasserburg, 2000). Nevertheless, these nucleosynthesis events mark the time at which a proportion of the unstable isotopes that are widely used for geochronology were newly synthesised and commenced their radioactive decay. The shock waves that originated from the last supernova explosion to occur in the vicinity could have triggered the rapid collapse of a more slowly evolving molecular cloud of interstellar dust and gas nearby (Cameron and Truman, 1977; Foster and Boss, 1996), thus initiating the formation of our own Sun and solar system. Based on the relative abundance of the short-lived nuclides found within the earliest preserved remnants ot" our solar system, a 10-solar-mass supernova located between 2 to 10 parsecs distant, may have generated the newly-synthesised heavy elements within, and probably also triggered formation of, our solar system (Cameron et at., 1995, 1997).
Formation of Our Solar System Due at least in part to the lower mass of its precursor molecular cloud, the development of our solar system was fortunately very different from that outlined above for supernovae.
8
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
Smaller stars of up to a few solar masses have longer pre-main sequence histories, and substantially longer lifetimes, than more massive stars. The interstellar cloud from which our solar system formed was derived from the ejecta of a range of stellar sources, including red giants and supergiants, AGB, nova, supernova and possibly also Wolf-Rayet stars (massive, high-temperature stars with extremely high mass-loss rates). A nearby supernova event injected newly synthesised, short-lived nuclides into the interstellar cloud and triggered its collapse to form a proto-Sun with radius about 5 times that of the present Sun over a period of < 105 years (see Cameron, 1995). Collapse will have occurred progressively from the inner to the outer part of the cloud, with conservation of angular momentum causing the collapsing cloud to spin faster. Collisions of dust and gas particles orbiting the proto-Sun in the same direction caused the loss of their energy, resulting in the flattening of the cloud, particularly near the centre where the densities are highest. Rotation of both the disk and the proto-Sun around a common centre of mass generated spiral density waves in the surrounding nebula. Within the evolving nebula, gravitational energy can be converted to heat during collapse and can initially be radiated away, so temperatures initially decrease with increasing distance from the cloud core. However, as the density of the cloud increased, heat could not be lost efficiently. At some time within 105 years from the onset of collapse of the cloud core, the proto-Sun commenced the violent early H-burning (or T-Tauri) phase of its evolution (Cameron, 1995). The infall rate of material from the rotating accretion disk increased episodically during this phase, although a significant proportion of the mass of the Sun was lost or recycled back into the disk via energetic bipolar outflows emitted along the axis of rotation. Magnetic field instabilities emanating from the Sun and vigorous flares, violent eruptions and strong stellar winds will have caused turbulence and mixing of ionised gas and dust within the accretion disk. Temperatures within the accretion disk will have changed dynamically as the disk evolved, with parts shielded from the increasing temperatures of the inner nebula by the increasing density of the accumulating dust and gas closer to the cloud core and near the midplane of the disk (see Meibom et al., 2000). Where temperatures dropped below 1500 K, high-temperature refractory elements, such as Ca, Ti (titanium) and A1, condensed to form fragile "fluffy" sub-micron sized grains. These dust grains collided and accreted to form precursors of the Ca- and Al-rich inclusions (CAIs) of primitive meteorites. These inclusions are composed of a variety of high condensation temperature minerals, such as corundum (A1203), perovskite ([Ca, Na, Fe, Ce]TiO3), melilite ([Ca, Na]z[Mg, Fe, AI, Si]307), hibonite ([Ca, Ce][AI, Ti, Mg]12019) and spinel ([Mg, Fe, Ni, Cr]A1204). The more abundant Fe, Ni (nickel), and silicate-rich components condensed within parts of the nebula at lower temperatures, whereas volatile components such as water, ammonia, and methane ices, condensed only in the cold outer regions of the accretion disk. Volatile components in the inner solar system may have been carried to the outer regions of the solar system as ionised gas and dust by the solar wind (Shu et al., 1994). The Sun would have settled into the hydrogen-burning "main sequence" phase within 3-30 My of the onset of collapse of the cloud core (Strom et al., 1993; Cameron, 1995).
1.2. Earth's Formation and First Billion Years
9
Mechanisms and Ttime Scales o f Early Condensation
Spectroscopic observations suggest that, for those young solar-type T-Tauri stars that have accretion disks (so-called "classical" T-Tauri stars), such disks persist for only a few million years from the time of star formation (Podosek and Cassen, 1994; Bertout and M6nard, 2001; Briceno et al., 2001; Throop et al., 2001). Such brief time scales for planetary formation are also suggested by mathematical simulations (Wetherill and Stewart, 1993), which indicate that progressive aggregation of non-volatile components into planetary-sized bodies will occur within <~ 105 years. Simulations also indicate that gas drag would cause planetesimals smaller than about 1 km in diameter formed before the nebula had dissipated to lose angular momentum and spiral into the Sun in time frames of 105 years (Weidenschilling, 1977). Only larger planetesimals would avoid this fate. Because coagulation arising from collision between icy particles is more efficient than that between metal or silicate particles, coagulation of icy interstellar grains within an ice sublimation belt in the cold outer parts of the nebula led to the early formation of large gas-rich giant proto-planets, the precursors to Jupiter and Saturn, before the nebula gas had dissipated (Cameron, 1995). Evidence of hypervelocity impacts preserved within chondrites has also been interpreted to indicate formation of massive planets within ~< 2 My of solar system formation (Hutchison et al., 2001). The rapid formation and large mass of Jupiter was to have a profound influence on the subsequent evolution of the terrestrial planets within the inner accretion disk (cf. Chambers and Wetherill, 1998). Planetesimals in the inner part of the disk formed at a slower rate than those within the ice sublimation belt, by the collision and amalgamation of chemically refractory dust particles. As the planetesimals became progressively larger, the random component of their heliocentric velocities progressively decreased. Their lower relative velocities further enhanced their rapid growth by collision and accretion (see Wetherill, 1994). Such collisions resulted in shock melting, brecciation and accretion of part of the masses of smaller planetesimals to the larger bodies. These collisions also triggered large-scale melting and magmatic differentiation within the silicate components of the larger planetesimals. Although planetary-sized bodies had formed in the inner part of the accretion disk within <~ 2 My of the onset of collapse of the precursor molecular cloud (see below), these probably continued to be extensively reworked by late-stage collisions for at least a further 100 My. The presence of decay products from the short-lived nuclides, particularly 26A1, 41Ca, 53Mn, 6~ 107pd, 1291and hafnium-182 (182Hf; see Table 1.2-1), within primitive meteorites affirms that these meteorites must have formed within a few million years of the synthesis of these unstable radionuclides in the supernova event. The abundances of the decay products of many short-lived nuclides have been shown to be correlated commonly with the abundances of their parent elements (see, e.g., MacPherson et al., 1995, for the case of 26A1), confirming that the daughter products were not inherited as "fossil" components from interstellar dust but rather, that the radioactive decay of their parent nuclides occurred within the mineral phases in which the daughter products reside (see Fig. 1.2-2). Because they are now extinct, short-lived nuclides cannot be used directly to obtain absolute dates relative to the present-day, but their short half-lives allow their use to investi-
10
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
0.160| /
I
p
I
I
I
I
I
I~1
150
S,ine. ree.s.anO,
F
+ ano hi,e
~ 0.150~
+ ,assaite
me,i,te
~0"~~0.145It
00~
.~
.~}4~ 0.13950.1t.40 , , ' , T , T ,i ,
,~,.~
.
I
0135 I 0
I
.
...........
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
I 100
I
. . . . .
_
.
0
y-i~ercept= -1.0 _. 1.2 %~
I
.l.,.ji"
50~
I 200
.5
I
I 300
.0
I
1.5
I 400
2.o
1
-25 500
27AI/24Mg Fig. 1.2-2. 26AI-26Mg isochron diagram (from Hsua et al., 2000) for a spinel-free island (SFI#3) within CAI 5421 from the Allende chondrite meteorite. Spinel-free islands are the earliest recognisable phases in CAIs and may represent clasts that were entrapped in a liquid of CA/composition that crystallised around them. Melilite-rich mantles were commonly formed around these phases, which are the principal phases that condensed early from the solar nebula. This diagram is like a conventional isochron diagram except 27A1 is used on the X-axis instead of the parent isotope 26A1, because all 26A1 is now extinct, having been converted to 26Mg. The slope of array has no age significance, but can provide the initial 26A1/27A1 ratio at the time the sub-system was isolated from a common reservoir. Six anorthite measurements were taken from a single SFI exhibiting a moderate range of A1/Mg ratios (200-300) and excesses that are well correlated with its AI/Mg. A range of initial 26A1/27A1compositions have been determined for Allende CAIs, indicating that the meteorite consists of an aggregation of material formed over a range of times early in the history of the solar system.
gate the relative chronology of the earliest history of the solar system. The abundance ratio of a short-lived parent nuclide relative to a stable nuclide of the same element (for instance, 26A1/27A1) in a chemically undisturbed mineral phase is a function of both the abundance of the parent nuclide in the starting material (which will have been the solar nebula for the most refractory and therefore earliest condensing phases of meteorites) and the time at which the mineral formed. This ratio can be calculated from the slope of the correlation between the measured daughter nuclide/daughter element abundance ratio (i.e., 26Mg/24Mg) and the measured parent/daughter element ratio (27Al]24Mg). An absolute time scale for the radioactive decay of the parent nuclide can be obtained by the determination of the absolute age of formation of a host mineral phase that has a well-constrained parent nuclide
1.2. Earth's Formation and bTrst Billion Years
11
abundance. The uranium-lead (U-Pb) radiogenic decay schemes have been most successfully applied to the precise determination of the absolute chronologies of mineral phases bearing daughter products of extinct nuclides (see below). Provided an absolute time scale for the radioactive decay of the parent nuclide can be established, absolute chronologies for other host phases can be obtained by comparison of their initial 26AI/Z7AI ratios with that calculated for the dated host phase. Chronologies determined using such initial ratio comparisons are, however, based on the assumption that both parent and daughter nuclides were distributed homogeneously, both throughout the regions in which the phases were formed and for the duration over which the comparison is made. If some or all of the inventory of short-lived nuclides was introduced from a nearby supernova, which also triggered the rapid collapse of the precursor molecular cloud, complete mixing of the solar nebula prior to the onset of condensation seems unlikely. The preservation of "presolar" isotopic anomalies in sub-micron sized corundum (A1203), diamond, graphite, silicon carbide (SC) and silicon nitride (Si3N4) grains (see Zinner, 1997; Ott, 2001, for recent reviews) and of 160 heterogeneities in CAIs (Young and Russell, 1998; Yurimoto et al., 1998; however, see Thiemens, 1999, for an explanation invoking mass-independent chemical fractionation for such O isotopic variation) also indicates that the nebula did not reach complete chemical homogeneity before planetesimals started to condense. Moreover, although the manganese-53-chromium-53 (53Mn-53Cr) chronologies determined for many meteorite classes are consistent with other evidence (see Carlson and Lugmair, 2000), 53Mn-53Cr isotopic trends between meteorite classes suggest that the 53Mn/54Mn ratio within the inner solar nebula may have varied radially with distance from the Sun (Lugmair and Shukolyukov, 1998). Violation of the assumption of initial chemical homogeneity throughout the entire solar nebula prior to and during early condensation may introduce significant but unquantifiable uncertainties into chronologies based on initial ratio comparisons and such chronologies should be treated as indicative only, unless supported by additional evidence. The radioactive nuclide 26A1 decays to 26Mg with a half-life (tl/2) of 0.730 My (see Table 1.2-1). The presence of live 26A1 in the early solar system was first demonstrated by Gray and Compston (1974) and Lee and Papanastassiou (1974) for refractory CAIs of the Allende carbonaceous chondrite. Lee et al. (1976) reported a range of 26Mg/Z4Mg values for minerals from Allende CAIs that were correlated with AI/Mg. Recent studies (for a summary, see Podosek and Cassen, 1994) have confirmed that many CAIs had similar initial 26AI/27A1 ratios (c. 5 x 105) and can be inferred to have formed within a short interval of < 105 yrs duration (see Fig. 1.2-2). The identification of excess potassium-41 (41K) from the in situ decay of the parent nuclide 41Ca (tl/2 c. 0.1 My) within high Ca/K phases in CAIs from the Efremovka carbonaceous chondrite (Srinivasan et al., 1996) also requires that some CAIs formed within <~ 1 My of the supernova event. An absolute age of 4571 Ma has been determined for CAI formation (see Lugmair and Shukolyukov, 2001 ). This date therefore corresponds both to the time of the supernova event and also formation of the earliest preserved millimetre- to centimetre-scale materials formed within our solar system.
12
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
Chondrules are millimetre-sized spherical objects found in chondritic meteorites, that were formed by flash heating to 1700-2100 K within the solar nebula (see, for example, Shu et al., 1996; Alexander et al., 2001, for recent reviews). The majority of chondrules examined lack any evidence of live 26A1, implying that the oldest chondrules formed at least several million years later than the time of CAI formation (Carlson and Lugmair, 2000). Evidence of live 26A1, but with generally lower initial 26A1/Z7A1 ratios than in CAIs, has been found in only a few chondrules (Hutcheon and Hutchison, 1989; Zinner and G6pel, 1992; Russell et al., 1996; Galy et al., 2000). Comparison of the initial 53Mn/55Mn ratios of chondrules from the Chainpur and Bishunpur chondrites (Nyquist et al., 1997, 1999) with those of CAIs (Birck and All6gre, 1988) is also consistent with a time of formation of the oldest chondrules 2-6 My later than CAI formation (see Carlson and Lugmair, 2000). Similar comparisons using initial 53Mn/55Mn ratios indicate that enstatite chondrites formed between 9 and 24 My later than CAIs (Birck and All6gre, 1988; Shukolyukov and Lugmair, 1999; see Carlson and Lugmair, 2000).
Mechanisms and Time Scales of Planetary Differentiation For planetesimals larger than a few tens of kilometres in diameter, internal gravitational pressure and heating from radioactive decay may be sufficient to cause partial melting within their interiors, resulting in melt segregation and igneous differentiation. The eucrite and augite meteorite classes are remnants of such differentiated planetary bodies. A Pb-Pb isochron date of 4557.8 -+- 0.5 Ma was determined by Lugmair and Galer (1992) for the time of igneous differentiation processes occurring within the angrite parent body. The difference in the initial 53Mn/55Mn ratio determined for the eucrite parent body compared to that of the angrite parent body indicates that the former differentiated 5.8 4-0.8 My prior to that of angrites (Lugmair and Shukolyukov, 2001 ). A date of 4564.8 • 0.9 Ma is therefore indicated for the time of igneous differentiation within the eucrite parent body (see Lugmair and Shukolyukov, 2001). These dates indicate that planetesimals at least several tens to hundreds of kilometres in diameter (the probable howardite-eucrite-diogenite parent body, the asteroid 4 Vesta, is thought to have had a radius of c. 250 km) had formed and had undergone internal magmatic differentiation less than c. 10 My after the supernova event and formation of CAIs. A time difference of ~< 10 My between formation of CAIs and igneous differentiation within the eucrite and angrite parent bodies is also consistent with the initial 26A1, 53Mn and 182Hf abundances calculated for eucrites (Lugmair et al., 1995; Srinivasan et al., 1999; Quitte et al., 2000; Kline et al., 2002) and the higher initial 87 Sr/86Sr ratios of eucrites and angrites compared to CAIs (see Podosek and Cassen, 1994; Halliday and Porcelli, 2001). Early differentiation of metallic cores and silicate mantles within planetary bodies is also indicated by rhenium- 187-osmium- 187 (187Re-187Os), hafnium- 182-tungsten- 182 (ISZHf-182W) and palladium- 107-silver- 107 (l~176 isotopic data from the iron and enstatite meteorites. Formation of metallic cores within ~< 50 My of formation of the solar system is suggested by 187Re-187Os isotopic data from pallasites and iron meteorites (Morgan et al., 1995; Shen et al., 1998; Horan et al., 1998), although a large uncertainty
1.2. Earth's Formation and First Billion Years
13
of -+-3% in the half-life of 187Re renders absolute chronologies determined by this method imprecise. The short-lived nuclide 182Hf decays to 182W with a half-life (tl/2) of 9 My (see Table 1.2-1 ). Hf is a refractory lithophile element and will preferentially partition into silicates during metal-silicate melt segregation, whereas W is moderately siderophile and will be concentrated into metal phases. Depletions in l S2W relative to that within terrestrial silicates have been detected in iron meteorites and the metal fractions of ordinary chondrites (Harper and Jacobsen, 1996a; Horan et al., 1998; Lee and Halliday, 2000a, b), indicating segregation of low Hf/W metal phases early in solar system history and prior to complete decay of 182Hf. No differences in W isotopic compositions amongst the different iron meteorite groups have yet been resolved; calculated initial 182Hf/18~ ratios for metal phases within enstatite chondrites are also comparable with those determined for carbonaceous chondrites (Kline et al., 2002; Schoenberg et al., 2002a; Yin et al., 2002), indicating that the metal phases of differentiated meteorites segregated within <~ 2 My of the formation of the solar system. This is in general terms consistent with the l~176 evidence, which indicates a formation interval of < 9 My for most of the iron meteorites (Carlson and Lugmair, 2000). This interval corresponds to the time at which the temperatures of the parent bodies of the iron meteorites fell below the diffusional blocking temperature for Pd, Ag, Hf and W, and so corresponds to the time at which these planetesimals had either ceased to differentiate or were disrupted by impacts (Carlson and Lugmair, 2000). Intriguing evidence of early differentiation involving hydrous fluids within planetesimals is provided by the identification of monoisotopic 129Xe, from the radiogenic decay of the extinct parent nuclide 129I, within halide crystals in the chondritic meteorite Zag (Whitby et al., 2000). These findings indicate that aqueous fluids circulated, presumably as part of hydrothermal systems, within planetesimals <~ 2 My after solar system formation. Further evidence in support of the operation of early aqueous alteration processes in planetesimals has been provided by 53Mn-53Cr isotopic investigations of carbonate (CaMg[CO3]2) fragments from the carbonaceous (CI) chondrites Orgueil and Ivuna (Endress et al., 1996) and of fayalite from the altered (CV3) chondrite Mokoia (Hutcheon et al., 1998), which indicate pervasive aqueous alteration within 20 My of the time of solar system formation. Other studies (Young et al., 1999) have recently argued that the mineralogical and O isotopic variability observed within the carbonaceous chondrites is attributable to fluid-rock interaction within their parent body (or bodies) shortly after CAI and chondrule formation. Earth Accretion, Formation of the Moon and the Magma Ocean
It is apparent from the above discussion that planetary embryos (Mercury or lunar size, c. 1026 g) that were to eventually collide and combine in the final stages of formation of the Earth had themselves formed within <~ 5 My of the supernova event that triggered formation of the solar system. This short time scale for formation of planetary embryos indicates that some of the short-lived nuclides, particularly 26A1, were still present in sufficient abundance to provide an internal heat source, enabling planetary embryos to form and differentiate extensively into silicate mantle and metallic core components within this
14
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
time interval. The terrestrial planets were mainly derived by the collision and accretion of planetary embryos that formed within a c. 0.5-2.5 AU range of the Sun (Wetherill, 1994), but major contributions of the more volatile components could have been sourced from the more volatile-rich asteroid belt and outer parts of the solar system during the later stages of accretion of the terrestrial planets. It is also apparent that liquid water was present during accretion of the terrestrial planets and would almost certainly have played a major part in the early differentiation of the planetary embryos that ultimately were to become part of the Earth. Provided accretion was rapid, the earliest atmospheres of these planetary embryos would have been acquired from the solar nebula before its dissipation and may have been close to solar in composition. Atmospheres of those planetary embryos formed closer to the Sun were probably more depleted in volatile components such as water, ammonia, and methane ices compared to those formed more distant from the Sun. However, the final chemical compositions and internal structures of the terrestrial planets would have been determined largely by the last major collisions that occurred between planetary embryos. Statistical simulations of the final stages of planetary accretion in the terrestrial zone (Chambers and Wetherill, 1998; Agnor et al., 1999) predict the formation and eventual collision of a small number of massive planetary bodies. Whatever the chemical nature or degree of differentiation of the last major planetary bodies that were to collide and ultimately form the Earth, there is little doubt that they were to be transformed irreversibly by the process that was to bring about their amalgamation. Although not universally accepted (see, e.g., Jones and Palme, 2000; Ruzicka et al., 2001; Dreibus and W/~nke, 2002, for recent critical analyses), the most widely accepted current hypothesis for the origin of the Earth's Moon argues that it originated from the impact of a planetary embryo ("Theia") of at least the mass of Mars (Mars mass is c. 11% of present-day mass of the Earth) with the proto-Earth, after the latter had accreted to about 50-90% of its present mass (Giant Impact Hypothesis; see Stewart, 2000, and references therein) (see also, section 5.9). This model is generally consistent with the angular momentum of the Earth-Moon system, with stochastic planetary accretion models (Canup and Angor, 2000, and references therein), with the extreme depletion in volatile elements found in the Moon and with the alignment of the O isotopic compositions of lunar samples along the terrestrial O isotope fractionation line (Weichert et al., 2001). The best available estimate of the time of this possible collision, between 25 and 35 My after solar system formation (i.e., between about 4550 and 4540 Ma ago), has been provided by 182Hf-182W model dates obtained on lunar rocks interpreted to be derived from different sources within an isotopically stratified lunar mantle (Kline et al., 2002; Yin et al., 2002). This estimate is unaffected by the recent recognition (Lee et al., 2002) that ISZw in some lunar samples is of cosmogenic origin, and is consistent with the oldest dates obtained from lunar samples (Swindle et al., 1986; Snyder et al., 2000). Determination of the exact time of impact is dependent on poorly-constrained variables such as accretion rates, the possible secular variation in the oxidation state (as pointed out by Ringwood, 1966, the presentday silicate mantle is too oxidised to be in equilibrium with its metallic iron core) and W metal-silicate partition coefficient within the bulk silicate Earth, and the ratio of the masses of the proto-Earth and impactor. But the W and Pb isotopic evidence is consistent
1.2. Earth's Formation and First Billion Years
15
with collision between the proto-Earth and an impactor 30 My after formation of the solar system, with a proto-Earth to impactor mass ratio of 7:3 and with between 65 to 90% of the current mass of the Earth-Moon system having been accreted at the time of impact (Halliday, 2000; Kline et al., 2002; Yin et al., 2002). This formation time for the Moon is generally consistent with (comparatively imprecise) estimates based on 1291-244pu-Xe (Pu, plutonium) isotopic constraints (reviewed by Swindle et al., 1986). A wide range of other plausible scenarios is also consistent with the 1291-244pu-Xe, 182Hf/182W, O and U-Pb isotopic constraints, however. An initial 182W/184W ratio of the bulk Moon within uncertainty of the bulk silicate Earth, inferred from the least radiogenic 182W/184W value measured so far for lunar samples (D.-C. Lee et al., 1997), is consistent with its derivation from the silicate portion of the proto-Earth and the impactor. Collision of a Mars-sized body with the proto-Earth will have caused shock melting of a significant part of the mass of at least one hemisphere of the proto-Earth. Rapid isostatic readjustment of the remaining mass of the proto-Earth mantle will have occurred immediately after impact, followed over the next c. 103 years by the propagation of a solidification front towards the surface (Solomatov, 2000). A low-viscosity, turbulently-convecting shallow magma ocean formed rapidly over a probably subsolidus (depending on presently poorly-constrained initial conditions) lower mantle, but the magma ocean will have cooled rapidly to a more viscous, low melt fraction magma ocean consisting of 20 to 30% partial melt within c. 1 My of the impact (Abe, 1993). Segregation of metal from silicate phases would have been facilitated by formation of a magma ocean, promoting the release of gravitational energy associated with further growth of the metallic core. The proto-Earth atmosphere was probably severely depleted as a consequence of the impact (Chen and Ahrens, 1997). Silicate vapour and steam released into the atmosphere by the impact may have slowed the rate of heat loss by surface radiation, but solidification of a thin surface layer overlying the magma ocean will have occurred rapidly, possibly over a period of tens of years (Mukhin and Pinenov, 2002). A partially molten magma ocean in the upper part of the Earth's mantle may have persisted for up to 200 My after the impact (Abe, 1997).
Latter Stages of Earth Accretion and Early Earth Differentiation Two main areas of direct investigation have provided significant insights into the early differentiation history of the Earth; 182Hf-182W isotopic systematics, which have facilitated our understanding of the formation of the Earth's metallic core, and the noble gases, which have provided constraints on the evolution of the atmosphere and history of degassing of the Earth's mantle. Theoretical and experimental studies of the Earth's Moon and detailed investigations of the oldest preserved remnants of the Earth's surface crust are additional important areas of investigation. During large-scale differentiation of the Earth into silicate mantle and metallic core, W is expected to be partitioned preferentially into the metallic core, whereas Hf should be concentrated into the silicate mantle. As anticipated, the silicate component of the Earth has a Hf/W ratio of c. 15, substantially higher than the chondritic value of c. 1 (cf. Harper and Jacobsen, 1996a; Halliday and Lee, 1999). As outlined earlier, remnants of the early-
16
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
formed metallic cores of other planetary bodies, such as the iron meteorites and the metal fractions of ordinary chondrites, have low Hf/W ratios and are depleted in l sew relative to carbonaceous chondrites (Lee and Halliday, 1995; Harper and Jacobsen, 1996a; Lee and Halliday, 2000a, b; Halliday et al., 2000; Kline et al., 2002; Schoenberg et al., 2002a; Yin et al., 2002), indicating that these metal phases segregated within ~< 2 My of the formation of the solar system. If the Earth's core also formed rapidly when live 182Hf was present, it might be anticipated that the core would also be depleted in 1sew, in common with the iron meteorites. Provided that differentiation of the Earth into metallic core and silicate mantle components occurred rapidly and within a closed system, the high Hf/W of the silicate mantle resulting from preferential incorporation of W relative to Hf into the core should have resulted in the Earth's silicate mantle having a radiogenic W isotopic composition relative to the chondritic value. Measurement of the W isotopic compositions of terrestrial silicates (Lee and Halliday, 1996; see Halliday et al., 2000) initially suggested that the silicate mantle component of the Earth had a 182W/184Wvalue indistinguishable from the chondritic value. However, recent investigations (Kline et al., 2002; Schoenberg et al., 2002a; Yin et al., 2002) indicate that there were analytical problems with earlier measurements of 182w[lS4w for carbonaceous chondrites and have confirmed that terrestrial silicates have significantly more radiogenic W isotopic ratios than carbonaceous chondrites. Based on the difference in W isotopic compositions of terrestrial silicates and carbonaceous chondrites, these studies have argued that the Earth's metallic core must have formed within 35 My of formation of the solar system. However, metal-silicate segregation within planetesimals may have occurred significantly more rapidly than the rate of planetary accretion. The rate of terrestrial core growth was therefore probably largely limited by the rate of planetary accretion, rather than the rate of planetary differentiation and metal-silicate segregation. If this was the case, 182w/lS4w values in terrestrial metal and silicate components will largely be a function of the degree of mixing of metal and silicate components derived from the impactors and proto-Earth, following partial rehomogenisation of these components as a result of late impact events and prior to metal-silicate resegregation. As a consequence, 182Hf_182W model ages are unlikely to represent meaningful estimates of the time of terrestrial core formation. If the terrestrial planets were accreted rapidly enough to have captured atmospheres derived from the nebula, it is likely that these early atmospheres were subsequently removed by intense ultraviolet luminosity and solar winds generated during the Sun's T-Tauri phase. However, such early solar atmospheric gases may have been trapped by dissolution in extensive magma oceans if these existed on the surfaces of the terrestrial planets prior to nebula dissipation. The relative abundances and isotopic compositions of the noble gases have been applied successfully to investigate this possibility. The element helium (He) consists of two isotopes, 3He and 4He, of which 4He is the by-product of c~-decay. Neon (Ne) consists of three isotopes, ZONe, 21Ne and 22Ne, of which 21Ne and 22Ne are produced principally by nucleogenic (n, or) reactions on 180 and 24Mg, and 25Mg respectively, from local decay of U and thorium (Th; although 21Ne may also be generated by spallation reactions on Mg, Na, Si and A1). Because both 4He and 21Ne are generated by the radioactive decay of U and Th, variations in 21Ne arising from nucleogenesis within a closed system
1.2. Earth's Formation and First Billion Years"
17
will be correlated with 4He. Based on the relative elemental abundances of the noble gases and isotopic compositions of He and Ne, three principal componentsmsolar (inferred from the solar wind as measured in lunar surface materials), primitive meteoritic (or "planetary") and atmospheric--can be distinguished. Isotopic compositions of the noble gases He and Ne within fresh basaltic glasses from Hawaii have been interpreted as resulting from mixing of nucleogenic and atmospheric components with a solar component having high 2~ (c. 13.6; Honda et al., 1991). Solar-like Ne isotopic ratios have also recently been detected in basaltic glasses from Iceland (Dixon et al., 2000). The existence of solar-like Ne within the Earth requires preservation since the time of Earth's formation of source regions that have retained high [Ne]/[U+Th], so that the isotopic composition of trapped initial solar Ne is not modified by the addition of nucleogenic 21Ne generated by in situ decay of U and Th. The high 2~ values of some mid-ocean ridge basalt samples are also accompanied by low 38Ar/36Ar (argon) ratios (Pepin, 1998), consistent with the presence of a low 38Ar/36Ar, "solar wind"-like component. The identification of high 3He and "solar" Ne (high 2~ and Ar (low 38Ar/36Ar) components within the Earth supports the proto-Earth's early capture and dissolution within a magma ocean of a solar atmosphere prior to nebula dissipation. Basalts derived from the Earth's upper mantle, well gases and the present-day atmosphere contain excesses of 129Xe from the radiogenic decay of the extinct parent nuclide 129I, and of the heavier isotopes of Xe (particularly 136Xe) from fission of 238U and of the extinct nuclide 244pu (Kunz et al., 1998; see Table 1.2-1). The presence of these excesses provides further confirmation of the rapid accretion of much of the mass of the Earth before the complete decay of the short-lived parents 129I and 244pu. Excesses of 129Xe in midoceanic ridge basaltic glasses are correlated with 4~ (Staudacher, 1987). As 4~ is generated by radiogenic decay of 4~ the observed correlation of 129Xe with 4~ in ridge basalt glasses is consistent with the rapid early depletion of incompatible elements (including K) and the degassing of the noble gases in the Earth's upper mantle during the decay of 129I. Rapid degassing and early depletion of the noble gases within the upper mantle led to high K/Ar and I/Xe ratios and to correlated enhancement in 4~ and 129Xe. Estimates of the terrestrial 129Iand atmospheric 129Xe inventories indicate that the initial terrestrial 1291/127Iratio was more than 2 orders of magnitude lower than that of the prevailing solar system ratio and indicate a 129Xe retention formation interval for the Earth of between 60 to 110 My after formation of the solar system (Swindle et al., 1986; Kunz et al., 1998; Podosek and Ozima, 2000; Porcelli et al., 2001). This Earth formation 1291-129Xe date has generally been interpreted as the average time of closure of the Earth to Xe loss (Swindle et al., 1986), although its exact chronological significance is unclear. Jephcoat (1998) suggested that 129I,and its "missing" daughter 129Xe, may have been occluded into the Earth's deep mantle and core during the early stages of accretion, whereas Podosek and Ozima (2000) speculated that 129Xe is missing because of the loss of volatiles during violent impact degassing late in the accretion history of the Earth. On the basis of the Earth's noble gas characteristics, Harper and Jacobsen (1996) argued that the Earth accreted in two stages. During the first stage, solar He and Ne (and also solar Ar) were incorporated into a magma ocean blanketed under a massive proto-atmosphere
18
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
of molecular hydrogen and helium prior to dissipation of the solar nebula. The "planetary" (i.e. meteoritic) compositions of the heavier noble gases were subsequently acquired by the late accretion of planetesimals after dissipation of the solar nebula during the second phase. This two-stage model also accounts for the oxidised state of the Earth's silicate mantle relative to the core. This interpretation was, however, disputed by Trieloff et al. (2000), who argued that the Hawaiian and Icelandic plume (see also, sections 3.2 and 3.3) components have 2~ ratios more consistent with a meteoritic solar (Ne-B) component with 12.52 • 0.18 rather than a solar component with present-day solar wind ratio of 13.80 -+-0.10. These authors argued that the Earth's solar-type rare gas inventory was inherited from the small planetesimals that accreted to form the Earth, following their irradiation by solar wind after the nebula had dissipated. From the above discussion, it is clear that the processes responsible for the early differentiation of the Earth into metallic core, silicate mantle, chemically differentiated crust and atmosphere overlapped in time and operated in unison with, and were even closely linked to, the progressive accretion of the planet. Earth's Earliest Crust
Given the rapid time scales of formation of the Earth, its later-stage accretion by the collision of a small number of massive planetesimals, and its internal heating by radioactive decay and release of gravitational energy associated with core formation, there seems little doubt (regardless of the applicability of the Giant Impact Hypothesis) that the Earth passed through a "magma ocean" stage in its accretion history. Insight into the nature of the first surface crusts formed under such conditions may be inferred from observations of the crusts of the Earth's Moon and other terrestrial planets. Because of its lower mass, the Moon lost its internal heat rapidly, so its earliest crust is relatively well preserved. The oldest recognised lunar crust is preserved as 4530 Ma ferronian anorthosites that are generally considered to represent flotation cumulates derived from a differentiated residual global lunar magma ocean (see Snyder et al., 2000; Shearer and Floss, 2000; see also O'Hara, 2000, for an alternative view). Between about 4200 and 2500 Ma, lunar mare basalts were episodically erupted with very high effusion rates, filling multi-ring and irregular-shaped depressions on the Earth-facing hemisphere of the Moon up to a thickness of 4.5 km (see Shearer and Floss, 2000). These melts are considered to have been derived by decompression melting of mafic cumulate sources, with the depth of source melting becoming progressively deeper in the lunar mantle with time (Nyquist et al., 1995; see Snyder et al., 2000). The masses, cooling rates and the time scales of crust formation of Venus, the Earth and the Moon were very different, yet there are similarities in their major physiographic features. Based on counts and sizes of impact craters, Venus was completely resurfaced comparatively late in its historymthe average surface age of Venus is estimated to be about 750 Ma (McKinnon et al., 1997). Three major physiographic features---crustal plateaus, volcanic plains and volcanic risesmmay be distinguished over > 80% of the surface area of Venus (Phillips and Hansen, 1998). Crustal plateaus are postulated to have formed by large degrees of plume melting beneath thin lithosphere, followed by lithospheric thick-
1.2. Earth's Formation and First Billion Years
19
ening by magmatic intrusion and underplating. The widespread volcanic plains may have formed over broad areas of mantle upwelling associated with mantle convection. Although volcanic plains probably formed throughout the time of crustal plateau formation, Phillips and Hansen (1998) proposed that Venusian plains volcanism culminated at about 700 Ma, when the stress state of the lithosphere switched from a "mobile-lid" state, during which some form of plate-tectonic crustal recycling may have operated, to a rigid lithosphere "thick-lid" state. Volcanic rises are considered to be younger features formed over a thicker lithosphere by lower degrees of plume melting (Phillips and Hansen, 1998). A partially molten magma ocean may have persisted in the upper part of the early Earth's mantle for several hundred million years. Surface temperatures were probably so high at this time that water resided mostly in the atmosphere as steam rather than in the oceans, with about 1 wt.% H20 dissolved in the magma ocean (Abe, 1993). Much of the Earth's accreted volatile inventory residing in the early atmosphere may have been lost by impact erosion and hydrodynamic escape, whereas a substantial proportion of the presentday atmosphere and oceans may have been reacquired from comets following accretion (cf. Delsemme, 1995). There are few reliable constraints on the magnitudes and rates of these competing processes. Depending on the effectiveness of the atmosphere's blanketing on the rate of heat loss from the Earth's surface, a thin solid surface layer could have formed over the magma ocean within a period of tens of years (Mukhin and Pinenov, 2002). As was the case for the Moon and the other terrestrial planets, volcanic plains are inferred to have been a dominant physiographic feature of the earliest surface crusts of the Earth. Plagioclase is stable only at depths less than about 40 km and will sink in wet terrestrial magmas (Taylor and McLennan, 1985), so early terrestrial crusts are likely to have been largely komatiitic and/or high-Mg basaltic, rather than anorthositic as on the Moon. Thin, transitory high-Mg basaltic and komatiitic crusts derived by very large degrees of partial melting of both shallow and deeper upwelling mantle sources may have been melted, fragmented and reformed many times over the surface of a chaotically convecting, partially molten mantle (see also, section 3.6). On cooling and solidification, such early crusts were probably rapidly resurfaced by continuous, voluminous sheet-like volcanic flows triggered by new upwelling events. Such early Earth crusts would have had short lifetimes and were brecciated by meteorite impacts and rapidly recycled back into the mantle. Early terrestrial crusts were probably periodically recycled on a global scale, as a consequence of both major impacts and of convective mantle overturn (Nelson, 1998a; see section 3.4). The nature of the recycling mechanisms for the earliest mafic "thin-lid" plates back into the Earth's mantle is unknown (a speculative hypothesis is discussed in section 3.6). Mismatches between the rate at which new crust was created and its surface distribution over convective mantle upwellings, and the rate at which crust could be destroyed via an orderly process of recycling into the mantle, probably meant that crust recycling initially did not operate by one orderly mechanism as it apparently does on the Earth today. Because they were zones in which water and other volatiles were recycled into the mantle and the adjacent crust could be magmatically reworked by remelting, intrusion and differentiation, siliceous high metamorphic grade continental crust buoyant enough to resist recycling into the mantle probably formed within these recycling zones (cf. "plughole"
20
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
model in section 3.6). As cooling of the planet proceeded, the prevailing chaotic mantle convection regime probably gave way to transitory stable convective regimes during which stable spreading-ridge systems could form over regions of mantle upwelling for increasingly longer durations. Because of the higher mantle temperatures, the solidus of upwelling mantle was intersected at greater depths than is the case for the present-day Earth, resulting in the formation of substantially thicker and more magnesian oceanic crust during these early stable convective periods compared to that which was to be formed on a younger, cooler Earth (see Arndt and Chauvel, 1990). Crustal thickening by flood-basalt resurfacing also operated throughout the Archaean; the more than 15 km thick, predominantly high-Mg basaltic sequences of the c. 3480-3410 Ma Warrawoona Group of the Pilbara craton, Western Australia, represents one of the best preserved early Archaean examples. Tonalite, trondhjemite and granodorite melts were generated by partial melting within this early, hydrothermally altered mafic crust. The oldest identified terrestrial zircons could have crystallised within such felsic differentiates. Earth's Oldest Preserved Crustal Remnants
The oldest identified remnants of the Earth's early crust are 4400 to 4000 Ma grains of the common accessory mineral zircon (ZrSiO4), found both as detrital grains within c. 3050 Ma metasedimentary rocks (Froude et al., 1983; Compston and Pidgeon, 1986; Wilde et al., 2001; Wyche et al., in press) and as xenocrysts in c. 2700 Ma gneissic monzogranites (Nelson et al., 2000) of the Yilgarn craton, Western Australia. Major- and traceelement distribution patterns and the presence of fine euhedral growth zoning and siliceous inclusions within these ancient zircons suggest that they crystallised within moderately to highly silicic (i.e., granitic sensu lato) melts. They were probably derived from a 4400 to 3874 Ma composite terrane comprised of igneous and high-grade metamorphic rocks (see Nelson et al., 2000). Their ancient source rocks may survive in the northwest Yilgarn but have not been identified. Zircon will accommodate U but not Pb within its mineral structure and is thus suitable for U-Pb dating. Furthermore, zircon is highly resilient and can survive high-grade metamorphism, intensive detrital reworking and incorporation into silicic melts. As a consequence, the chemical, microstructural and U-Pb isotopic characteristics of individual zircon crystals may preserve a record of complex geological histories. Such histories have been investigated for several >/4000 Ma zircon grains by combined in situ U-Th-Pb isotopic microanalysis using the SHRIMP (Sensitive High-Resolution Ion MicroProbe), back-scattered electron and cathodoluminescence imaging and trace-element microanalytical methods (Nelson et al., 2000; Wilde et al., 2001; Nelson, 2002). Due at least in part to the higher abundance of the parent isotope 235U (tl/2 c. 700 My) prior to 4000 Ma and consequent higher accumulated abundance of the daughter isotope 2~ ion-microprobe analyses of typically 25 ~tm diameter sites on sectioned and polished surfaces of these ancient zircons can yield very precise 2~176 dates, with typical 95% confidence uncertainties of less than a few million years. Ion-microprobe analyses indicating recent loss of radiogenic Pb from the analysis sites are commonly obtained from sites with U greater
1.2. Earth's Formation and First Billion Years
21
than c. 400 ppm, consistent with analyses obtained on younger zircons from samples taken elsewhere throughout the Yilgarn craton (cf. Nelson, 1997). An unusual feature of the ~> 4000 Ma zircons so far examined in detail is the wide range of e~176 dates found within each grain. Some, but not all, of the range in e~176 dates obtained from individual grains is attributable to the overlap of the ion-microprobe analysis sites onto younger rim zircon (cf. Nelson et al., 2000). The oldest e~176 date obtained from each crystal has usually been interpreted as a minimum estimate of the time of igneous crystallisation of the zircon, with any younger dates not accounted for by the presence of younger rim zircon instead attributed to loss of radiogenic-Pb from micronscale domains within each grain (Nelson et al., 2000). Diffuse euhedral primary igneous zoning is evident in the cathodoluminescence and back-scattered electron images obtained for most/> 4000 Ma zircons so far examined in detail (see Figs. 1.2-3 and 1.2-4), indicating that the e~176 variation cannot be attributed to patchy recrystallisation of the zircon microstructure. Nor can the 2~176 variation be related to the network of fractures, which are later features (see Figs. 1.2-3 and 1.2-4). Such radiogenic-Pb loss could have occurred episodically, during a series of thermal events occurring in the interval 4405 to 3750 Ma, or during one or a few younger events occurring before c. 3750 Ma. Maas et al. (1992) subdivided the older U-Pb zircon analyses from the Mount Narryer quartzites into c. 4190 Ma and 4150 Ma sub-populations; both ages are represented within grain 11 from the Churla Well granitic gneiss examined by Nelson et al. (2000; see Fig. 1.2-3). In addition, e~176 dates of 4360, 4340 and 4318 Ma obtained from grain 10 from a sample (169075) of quartzite from the Southern Cross granite-greenstone terrane, central Yilgarn, closely match the dates of 4363, 4340 and 4320 Ma indicated by analyses obtained by Wilde et al. (2001) from their 4404 Ma grain W74/2-36 from the Jack Hills, northwest Yilgarn (see Figs. 1.2-4 and 1.2-5). This concurrence between e~176 dates obtained from within and between zircon grains favours the episodic loss of radiogenic Pb during a series of thermal events between 4360 and 3750 Ma. Significant Pb diffusion from the structure of zircon will occur during metamorphism when temperatures exceed 850~ (J.K.W. Lee et al., 1997; see Fig. 1.2-6), so the events recorded within these ancient zircons: may correspond to high-grade thermal episodes during which accumulated radiogenic Pb was lost from susceptible domains within these grains. It is conceivable that at least some of the concordant e~176 dates at c. 4360, 4340, 4320, 4185, 4150, 4005, 3978, 3945 and 3874 Ma recorded within these ancient zircons (see Fig. 1.2-7) correspond to events during which temperatures of their host rocks exceeded 850~ perhaps during episodic mantle upwelling or overturn episodes. Although it is not certain how representative their thermal histories are of the early Earth's near-surface environment, evidence of ancient radiogenicPb loss by diffusion from micron-scale domains preserved within these t> 4000 Ma zircons is consistent with near-surface temperatures exceeding 850~ as late as 4000 Ma. Wilde et al. (2001) and Mojzsis et al. (2001) reported 6180 values significantly higher than the value of c. 5.3%o expected for mantle-derived zircons for > 3900 Ma detrital zircons from the Jack Hills metasedimentary belt. It was argued that their high 6180 values indicated that these ancient zircons crystallised within granitic melts derived from the partial melting of high-180/160 sedimentary or low-temperature hydrothermally-altered
22
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
Fig. 1.2-3. Back-scattered electron (BSE) and cathodoluminescence (CL) images (adapted from Nelson et al., 2000) of grain 11 extracted from a leucocratic granitic gneiss (sample 105007: Churla Well), Yilgarn craton. The surface microstructure and SHRIMP analysis sites are visible on the BSE image. Note that because the zircon structure and composition has been modified by high-intensity electron bombardment during chemical analysis along linear traverses, these can be seen on the CL images as bright lines. Diffuse primary igneous zonation is evident in the CL image. Inset show zones within the grain which are distinbuishable on the basis of the BSE and CL images and petrographic investigation. An interpretive schematic structural diagram sununarising SHRIMP U-Pb dates, with + 1o" uncertainties, obtained for this grain is also shown.
1.2. Earth's Formation and First Billion Years
23
Fig. 1.2-4. Back-scattered electron (BSE) and cathodoluminescence (CL) images of grain 10 extracted from a quartzite from the Southern Cross Province of the Yilgarn craton (sample 169075: Kohler Bore). The surface microstructure and SHRIMP analysis sites are visible on the BSE image. Faint igneous zoning is apparent in the CL image and indicates that the grain is an end-fragment of a larger euhedrally zoned crystal. An interpretive schematic structural diagram summarising SHRIMP U-Pb dates, with -+-1cr uncertainties, obtained for this grain is also shown.
source rocks. Wilde et al. (2001) reported a 3180 value of 7.4 + 0.7%0 (2a uncertainty) obtained on an area of grain W74/2-36 from which they obtained the oldest 2~176 date of 4404 + 8 Ma (20- uncertainty). These authors argued that this required the presence of liquid water on the Earth's surface at 4404 Ma. A lower ~180 value of 5.0-+-0.7%0, indistinguishable from values obtained from mantle-derived zircons, was obtained from part of this grain which gave a younger 2~176 date of 4364 + 6 Ma (2a uncertainty).
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
24
(a) W74, grain 2-36
((n r "1o
_Z
o~ o~
.
0
.~_
4300
4320
4340 2~176
4360 4380 Age (Ma)
4400
4420
Fig. 1.2-5. Gaussian Summation probability density plots for >/-t-95% concordant SHRIMP U-Pb analyses older than 4.0 Ga obtained from (a) zircon W74/2-36 from a sample of conglomerate from the Jack Hills, Narryer Gneiss Complex (data from Wilde et al., 2001 ); (b) grain 10, quartzite sample 169075 from the Southern Cross Province of the central Yilgarn craton (data from Nelson, 2002).
Wilde et al. (2001) interpreted this apparently younger area as a magmatic overgrowth on a 4404 -t- 8 Ma, high 6180 core. However, from the images and maps shown in Wilde et al. (2001) and Peck et al. (2001), grain W74/2-36 is a grain fragment that crystallised during a single episode. The range in 2~176 dates obtained for this zircon is therefore likely to be due to episodic loss of radiogenic-Pb from micron-scale domains (cf. Nelson et al., 2000). A more detailed schematic diagram of grain W74/2-36 presented in Peck et al. (2001) shows that the high 6180 value of 7.4 was obtained from a site that gave a younger 2~176 date (4284 + 6 Ma) than the site from which the lower 6180 value of 5.0 was obtained (4364 + 6 Ma). This raises the possibility that the high 3180 value is of secondary origin and therefore does not provide evidence of the presence of liquid water on the Earth's surface at 4404 Ma. Experimental studies (Watson and Cherniak, 1997) indicate that oxygen diffusion in zircon occurs at a significantly higher rate and at lower temperatures than does Pb diffusion (see Fig. 1.2-6). If the observed variation in 2~176 ratios within individual/> 4000 Ma zircons is due to Pb diffusion at high temperatures, it is unlikely that magmatic oxygen isotopic compositions in these zircons would remain unaffected. In a morphological study of > 3900 Ma zircons from the Jack Hills, Pidgeon et al. (2001)
1.2. Earth's Formation and First Billion Years
25
Fig. 1.2-6. Diagram showing curves of diffusion radius (lxm) versus closure temperature (T~ for different cooling rates for Pb (from J.K.W. Lee et al., 1997) and O diffusion (Watson and Cherniak, 1997) in zircon. The observed 207pb/206pb variation within individual ~>4.0 Ga zircons may be attributed to Pb diffusion at a ~m-scale at T c. 850-950~ between 4405-3750 Ma. The shaded area corresponds to the estimated diffusion radius, based on a SHRIMP ion probe spot size of c. 25 ~m diameter, required to account for the observed 207pb/2~ variation in the ~>4.0 Ga zircons that have so far been examined in detail (Nelson et al., 2000; Wilde et al., 2001 ; Nelson, 2002). Oxygen diffusion in zircon under high temperatures and in the presence of H20 will occur far more rapidly than Pb diffusion in zircon. The observed 207pb/206pb (and ~;180) variation within individual >~4.0 Ga zircons is consistent with Earth's surface temperatures of c. 850-950~ at > 3.75 Ga.
also pointed out that most of these ancient grains lack morphological features, such as large central cores surrounded by strongly magmatically-zoned rims, consistent with their crystallisation within peraluminous melts derived from sedimentary precursors. The oldest rocks so far identified on the Earth's surface are 4030 Ma granitic gneisses of the Acasta Gneiss Complex of the Northwest Territories, Canada (Stern and Bleeker, 1998; Bowring and Williams, 1999). Granite-greenstone crust, consisting of thick (~> 10 km) arcuate or linear, synclinal sequences of predominantly mafic volcanic rocks (greenstones) that have been intruded by antiformal tonalite, trondhjemite, granodiorite and monzogranite complexes, is largely unique to the Archaean era (see also, chapters 2 and 4). Early Archaean examples include the 3800-3700 Ma Itsaq gneiss terrane of west Greenland and the 3600-3000 Ma Pilbara and Kaapvaal cratons of Western Australia and South Africa, respectively. Pillow lavas preserved within Isua greenstones (section 2.2) provide clear evidence for the presence of submarine magmatism and of oceans at c. 3700 Ma (Myers, 2001a). Amphibolite-facies rocks from the Isua greenstone belt and from related rocks
26
Chapter 1" The Early Earth
._,g, I/1 t,"1o om
o L Q,.
t~ t'r
3600
3700
3800
3900
4000
4100
20r Pbl 2o6Pb Age
4200
4300
4400
4500
(Ma)
Fig. 1.2-7. Gaussian Summation probability density plot for ~> -t-95% concordant SHRIMP U-Pb analyses older than 4.0 Ga obtained on zircons from the Narryer Gneiss Complex, Murchison granite-greenstone terrane and Southern Cross quartzites of the Yilgarn craton. Data sources: Froude et al. (1983), Compston and Pidgeon (1986), Maas et al. (1992), Nelson et al. (2000), Wilde et al. (2001), Nelson (2002). from Labrador have unradiogenic W isotopic compositions compared to terrestrial values (Schoenberg et al., 2002b), indicating that their 3800 to 3700 Ma sedimentary precursors contained a detrital component derived from meteorite debris. Granite-greenstone crust formation within the Pilbara and Kaapvaal cratons was episodic, with major episodes of c. 10 to 100 My duration resulting in contemporaneous greenstone volcanism on, and granitic intrusion into, pre-existing granite-greenstone crust, separated by periods of magmatic quiescence during which clastic and chemical sedimentary rocks were deposited (Nelson et al., 1999). Although there is evidence suggesting that increased magmatic activity within the Kaapvaal craton may have occurred simultaneously with that in the Pilbara craton, the overall chronological patterns of granite-greenstone crust growth evident for the two cratons are not similar (Nelson et al., 1999), suggesting that by the early Archaean, crust formation was mostly associated with localised processes rather than global-scale convective overturn (cf. Nelson, 1998a; see section 3.4). The greenstone sequences consist of basalt, high-Mg basalt and komatiite with interlayered minor felsic volcanic, chemical and clastic sedimentary rocks. Field and chemical characteristics of greenstone ultramafic and mafic lavas are consistent with their eruption as highly voluminous "flood basalt"-like flows derived by large degrees of partial melting of both shallow and deeper upwelling
1.3. Early P r e c a m b r i a n Stratigraphic R e c o r d
27
mantle sources (see detailed discussions in chapter 4). They are probably therefore the Earth's equivalents of the volcanic plains of the crusts identified on the other terrestrial planets.
1.3.
THE EARLY PRECAMBRIAN STRATIGRAPHIC RECORD OF LARGE EXTRATERRESTRIAL IMPACTS
B.M. SIMONSON, G.R. BYERLY AND D.R. LOWE Introduction
Supracrustal rocks whose features are sufficiently well preserved to enable detailed inferences about Earth's surface environments date back to at least 3470 Ma (e.g., Byerly et al., 2002). The primary features of older supracrustal rocks can be so obscured by deformation and metamorphism that their very origin as sediments is in dispute (e.g., Fedo and Whitehouse, 2002). Based on the lunar record, Ryder (2003) inferred that the impact rate in the Earth-Moon system exceeded c. 15 times the present rate at 3800 Ma but had declined to about 2 times the present rate by 3000 Ma. The oldest impact structure yet found on Earth is the Vredefort structure of South Africa, at 2020 Ma (Grieve, 1998). This means that no impact structures have been identified in terrestrial rocks representing close to 1.5 billion years of geologic history during which a multitude of extraterrestrial objects must have struck the Earth. It is highly unlikely that many impact structures will ever be identified in Archaean and Palaeoproterozoic rocks, given the fragmentary state of their preservation. There is, however, another record of large impacts preserved in the Earth's stratigraphic archive. This record consists of thin layers rich in distinctive sand-size spherules representing silicate droplets formed by the melting and vapourisation of terrestrial target rocks during impacts by large extraterrestrial bodies such as asteroids and comets. At least 11 layers rich in spherules representing a minimum of 7 different impacts have been documented in Archaean to early Palaeoproterozoic successions (Table 1.3-1). All but one of these layers have been found in two relatively small areas with rocks of roughly equivalent ages in South Africa and Australia (Figs. 1.3-1 and 1.3-2). The spherule-bearing layers are generally thin, but they are dispersed over very large areas, so they are unlikely to be erased by regional erosion or tectonism. The spherule-bearing layers will be preserved readily if they were deposited below wave base in continental shelf to slope environments. This means that successions deposited on continental margins can preserve a cosmopolitan record of large impacts, even those which took place in oceanic crust that has since been resorbed into the mantle. Spherule layers may ultimately prove to be our best source of information on the timing and nature of impacts in the early Precambrian. There may also be differences between the impact spherule layers formed in early Earth history versus those formed in more recent times, which could reflect secular changes in Earth's lithosphere and hydrosphere (Simonson and Harnik, 2000). However, we still have much to learn about the known spherule layers, and more examples are needed in order to test the validity of any The Precambrian Earth: Tempos and Events Edited by P.G. Eriksson, W. Altermann, t).R. Nelson, W.U. Mueller and O. Catuncanu
Table 1.3-1 (part 1). Comparative data on Precambrian spherule-rich layers Name Host formation of of spherule layer layer
Group to which formation belongs
Geographic location of layer
N/A
Graensesci
Vallen
Ketilidian orogen, South Greenland
NIA
Dales Gorge Member Hamersley of Brockman
Hamersley basin, Western Australia
N/A
Wittenoom
Hamersley
Hamersley basin, Western Australia
N/A
Carawine*
Hamersley
Hamersley basin, Western Australia
NIA
Jeerinah*
Fortescue
Hamersley basin, Western Australia
N/A
Monteville
Ghaap
Griqualand West basin, South Africa
S4
Mapepe
Fig Tree
Barberton Greenstone Belt, South Africa
S3
Mapepe
Fig Tree
S3
Ulundi
Fig Tree
Barberton Greenstone Belt, South Africa Barberton Greenstone Belt, South Africa
S2
Mapepe
Fig Tree
S1
Hooggenoeg
Onverwacht Barberton Greenstone Belt, South Africa
S1
Apex Basalt
Warrawoona Pilbara Craton, Western Australia
Barberton Greenstone Belt, South Africa
Approximate Minimum geologic age lateral (in Ga) persistence (in km) z 1.85,
26
Approximate thickness of spherule layer (in cm) 100
Approximate content of spherules in layer by volume 20%
Approximate aggregate thickness of spherules (in cm) 20 - -
N M
Table 1.3-2 (part 2). Comparative data on Precambrian spherule-rich layers Name of layer
Host formation of spherule layer
N/A
Grrensesa
N/ A N/ A
Dales Gorge Wittenoom Carawine* Jeerinah* Monteville Mapepe Ma~e~e Ulundi Mapepe Hooggenoeg Apex Basalt
N/A N/A N/A S4 S3 S3 S2 S1 S1
Diameter of largest spherules observed (in mm) 1.4 2.1 1.1 2.3? 2.0' 1.6 1.6 4.0 2.0 2.5 1 .O 0.8
Grain size of coarsest clastic detritus in layer
Highest Ir concentration reported (ppb)
Most anomalous E ( ~ ~reported c ~ )
References from which data are derived
?J
3
2 P 8' 5
fine sand none? fine sand coarse sand coarse sand coarse sand coarse sand coarse sand coarse sand coarse sand coarse sand coarse sand
0.02 17.9 0.43 1.54 11.4 6.4 450 519 725 3.9 3.0 N.D.
N.D. N.D. N.D. +O. 16 f0.03 +O. 12 f0.03 -0.04 f0.04 -0.32 f0.06 -0.41 f0.08 -0.41 f0.10 -0.09 h 0.03 N.D. N.D.
@.
1
7
2,3,4 2,3,5,6,7 3, 5, 6, 8, 9, 10 4, 10, 11, 12, 13 10, 14, 15 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 16, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23 16, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23 16, 19, 20, 23 19.24 19, 21, 24
4s 6'
Data sources are unpublished data and ( I ) Chadwick el al.. 2001; (2) Simonson, 1992; (3) Hassler and Simonson, 2001; (4) McDonald and Simonson, 2002; (5) Simonson et al., 1998; (6) Simonson et al., 1993b; (7) Woodhead et al., 1998; (8) Simonson and Hassler, 1997; (9) Simonson et al., 2000a; (10) Shukolyukov et al., 2002; (I 1) Simonson et al., 2000b; (12) Simonson et a]., 2001; (13) Simonson et al., 2002; (14) Simonson et al., 1999; (15) Simonson et al., 2000c; (16) Lowe et al., 1989; (17) Kyte et al., 1992; (18) Shukolyukov et al., 2000; (19) Lowe et al., 2003; (20) Kyte et al., 2003; (21) Lowe and Byerly, 1986; (22) Byerly and Lowe, 1994; (23) Byerly et al., 1996; and (24) Byerly et al., 2002. N/A = not applicable. N.D. = no data reported. *= layers in two different formations and groups that nevertheless were probably formed by a single impact (Simonson et al., 2002) ?these layers also contain more irregular, flow-banded particles of former melt up to 2 cm across.
3 c;
3 I;
30
Fig. 1.3-1.
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
1.3. Early Precambrian Stratigraphic Record
31
Fig. 1.3-1. Geographic locations of early Precambrian spherule layers. (a) Representative locations (largely surface exposures) throughout known areas of occurrence of the Carawine and Wittenoom spherule layers (map (2)) and the Dales Gorge and Jeerinah spherule layers (map (3)) in the Hamersley basin (map (1)), Western Australia. (b) The four known locations of the Monteville spherule layer (map (2)) in the Griqualand West basin (map (1)), South Africa; location next to question mark (?) on southwestern edge of basin is a possible fifth occurrence. (c) Geologic map of western part of the Barberton greenstone belt, where spherule layers occur; the stratigraphic units hosting spherule layers are indicated in Figure 1.3-2b and c. Maps in (a) and (b) are adapted from Hassler and Simonson (2001); map in (c) is adapted from Lowe and Byerly (1999a).
32
Chapter 1." The Early Earth
HAMERSLEY BASIN
(a)
Main
outcrop
TRANSVAAL BASIN
area Kuruman
l
Brockman
Iron Fm ~
=,. F,, - 2470+4 F,, F -,, F,, rp
~"Fm v-
Dales Gorge
Mt. McRae . . . . . . + Mt. " . . . . . .
Shale Sylvia
Fm.
Iron Fm. 2521_+3
,~,
S undifferentiated
"22222-
450
m _.%
units b
om/tted
cl. oL.
Wittenoom S
--------
>, m L
"_-----_" (2541+18/-15) :--.-_'---_-'.- 2561_+8
E ,~ ""
Wittenoom
m
Formation
1 Marra
_
_
_ _
_ _
_
!
m M a m b a
Iron Fro.
t
~
!
E~
Iron-Formation
~
_
Fe g m 2597_+5
"--ZZZZ"-'---~;
- Jeerinah S
"---------"-
\ 2 6 2 9 _+ 5 2557+_.49
Revilio _
_
. Fm.
_
_
.
_
_ .
.
_
_
_ .
_
_
oe,"D
.
.
Fm.
Maddina
SL ages
= 6")
_ i i_
Jeerinah
i,o
All radiometric
3
lOOmI
Basalt Layer
_
ell _
Carbonate
Spherule
.
i - l - l i _ _
~
!
Q.
o" Argillite
l - i - l i _ _
i - i_-
m m
_ .
l - i_- l i _ _
are
in Ma.
Basalt
-----------':- 2690 + 16 *VTV~UT UuUvVvU
~.u.u.u,u.v u. continues
down
Monteville S ~ 2650 _+ 8
......
continues
Lokammona
Fm. down
Fig. 1.3-2. Stratigraphic contexts of early Precambrian spherule layers. (a) Stratigraphic columns for main outcrop area of Hamersley basin (left) and Griqualand West basin (right); stratigraphic positions of spherule layers are indicated in space between columns by tick marks adjacent to names of layers (as listed in Table 1); also indicated are available age determinations (in millions of years) and their stratigraphic positions. Columns in (a) adapted from figure 3 of Hassler and Simonson (2001), with new dates cited from Simonson et al. (2000b).
generalisations made about them. In this section, we summarise briefly what is known about early Precambrian spherule layers, discuss the significance of their characteristics for interpreting early Earth history, and speculate about what future studies of these layers might ultimately tell us.
Distinctive Characteristics of Spherule Layers Spherules What sets all of the layers apart are an abundance of spheroidal particles whose distinctive external shapes and internal textures suggest an origin by quenching of silicate melt droplets (Lowe et al., 2003; Simonson, 2003). These particles are referred to collectively as spherules. Most are truly spherical in three dimensions (Fig. 1.3-3), but a substantial minority of spherules depart from a spherical shape. After spheres, ovoids are the commonest shape but lesser numbers of spherules have non-spherical shapes such as teardrops, dumb-
1.3. Early Precambrian Stratigraphic Record
(b)
33
SOUTHERN BGB
4oo
2001~[~ i
~
NORTHERN BGB (lower (Iowe plate)
.....: <---S3, S4
lOO1 .1, ,I
NORTHERN BGB
(upper plate)
i 9
~
!
i 9
:
2
>rv
:-1(3
i
~
" !
:~'.--
uJ ~,~ rr ~ o " ~.
1
. ....................~...
<--Sl
~:c-
: ~.
i
(.9
=-
,z,-~
~=~-J''~ e~- i P.t-,-~l.k "~ '~ ~'C2 ~_.
~o =- ~
-r
IIIII
N
Fault
km
"' z o o -To
Iny0ka Fault Spherule Layer
= S
Fig. 1.3-2 (continued). (b) Stratigraphic column for southern part of western Barberton greenstone belt with stratigraphic levels of spherule layers indicated on right sides of column as S 1, $2, etc. (c) Stratigraphic columns for northern part of western Barberton greenstone belt with stratigraphic levels of spherule layers indicated on fight sides of columns by arrows labeled $3. Stratigraphic columns in (b) and (c) adapted from Lowe et al. (2003).
bells (Fig. 1.3-3c), and fused spheres (Fig. 1.3-3d). The latter represent pairs of droplets that became joined because they collided in flight while still hot (referred to as agglutinated spherules). Together, spherical and non-spherical spherules form a continuum that is analogous to the fluidal shapes of the variety of tektites and microtektites referred to as splash forms (Glass, 1990). Spherules range in size up to 5 mm in diameter, but those less than a millimetre or two across tend to be the most highly spherical. Related melt particles that range up to at least 2 cm long occur in the Late Archaean Carawine layer (Table 1.3-1), but they have more angular shapes and show different textures internally. These angular particles have more in common with Muong Nong-type tektites than splash forms and may represent the most proximal impact ejecta yet found in Archaean strata (Simonson et al., 2000a). Although they are found in the same layer as spherules, the more angular particles are not considered further here.
34
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
Internally, spherules show a variety of textures indicative of their initial molten state. These include infilled bubble cavities, microlitic textures, radial or spherulitic aggregates of fibrous crystals grown during quenching and/or devitrification (Figs. 1.3-3d, e), and skeletal spinel crystals (Fig. 1.3-3f). With the exception of the spinel crystals, the minerals and glass originally present in the spherules have all been replaced by secondary phases ranging from diagenetic to metamorphic in origin. Some spherules do not show any internal textures diagnostic of their formerly molten state (Figs. 1.3-3a, c). Spherules lacking diagnostic textures could either have consisted originally entirely of glass (like microtektites) or had any such textures obliterated by wholesale replacement. Mineralogically, spherules most commonly consist of quartz, sericite, chlorite, and/or K-feldspar, all of which are secondary in origin. The authigenic origin of the K-feldspar is based on the fact that it replaces entire spherules, has a low sodium content, and commonly occurs in crystals whose shapes are typical of plagioclase microlites (Simonson, 2003). Primary textures are best preserved in spherules that consist of K-feldspar, whereas textures are less likely to be preserved as well in spherules that currently consist of quartz, sericite, and chlorite. Where textures are preserved in the latter, they tend to be outlined by fine inclusions of rutile. In general, Early Archaean spherules have been metamorphosed and deformed to a higher degree than those of the Late Archaean and Palaeoproterozoic. However, textures in the latter spherules can also be obliterated via diagenetic replacement with coarse carbonate crystals (calcite, ankerite, and/or dolomite) and/or pyrite. The textures in spherules are also obscured commonly by surface alteration in outcrops of layers. This takes the form of impregnation by caliche carbonate and oxidation of ferrous iron in minerals such as pyrite and ankerite. Nevertheless, spherules in carbonate-rich layers typically stand out in high relief on weathered surfaces (Fig. 1.3-4a).
Fig. 1.3-3. Photomicrographs of impact spherules in plane polarised light. Long axes of fields of view are 1.85 mm in (a) and (b), 460 ~tm in (c) and (d), 2.5 mm in (e), and 600 ~m in (f). (a) Well-sorted spherules from Dales Gorge layer. The spherules consist of K-feldspar (grey, primarily rims) and weathered (oxidised) stilpnomelane (dark). A cement consisting of stilpnomelane filled the interstitial pores early enough to prevent significant compaction of spherules. Carbonate rhombs (white) cut across both cement and spherules. (b) Well-sorted spherules from Wittenoom layer. These spherules consist of K-feldspar (grey and white) plus some calcite (also white); spherules show more textural heterogeneity and are more compacted than those in a. (c) Dumbbell-shaped spherule from Dales Gorge layer, with a thin rim of K-feldspar and massive core of felted stilpnomelane. (d) Particle from Wittenoom layer, consisting of two K-feldspar spherules that fused in flight; the one with circular cross-section was stronger, and therefore cooler and/or more crystalline at the time of collision; whereas the other spherule contains a teardrop-shaped bubble cavity. (e) Well-sorted spherules with bubble cavities, from an unweathered core sample of Monteville layer. The spherules and most of interstitial material consists of K-feldspar, variably darkened with impurities. Finely felted sericite is also present, especially filling bubble cavities. The small clear crystals between spherules are fine quartzose sand. (f) Chlorite-chert spherule from impact layer $3 in the Barberton greenstone belt, with an abundance of Ni-rich spinel octahedra (black), many hollow.
1.3. Early Precambrian Stratigraphic Record
35
Spherule-rich layers
Spherules occur in discrete layers that form regionally persistent markers beds. For example, the S 1 layer in the Hooggenoeg Formation of the Onverwacht Group persists along strike for tens of kilometres around folds in the Barberton greenstone belt (Lowe et al., 2003) and the Wittenoom layer is preserved over tens of thousands of square kilometres in the relatively undeformed strata of the Hamersley basin (Simonson, 1992). The areas
Fig. 1.3-3.
36
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
Fig. 1.3-4. Surface exposures and hand sample of impact spherule layers. (a) Caliche-coated surface normal to bedding on Monteville spherule layer type locality, with numerous white spherules standing out in relief; coin is 16 mm in diameter. (b) Weathered surface of Wittenoom layer at the type locality of the Bee Gorge Member. Light resistant beds at the top and bottom are ambient carbonate lutite layers; intervening darker strata make up the spherule layer. Note the imbricated stack of rip-up slabs of limestone in centre and current-ripple crests climbing obliquely to right above them. The coin is 21 mm in diameter. (c) Sawn slab from impact layer $2 from the Barberton greenstone belt, with a mixture of numerous large siliceous rip-up clasts plus spherules and other finer debris. Major divisions on the scale at bottom are in cm. (d) Wittenoom layer from near Mt. Farquhar in the western part of the Hamersley basin. The spherules occur in cm-thick, discontinuous lenses at level of head of rock hammer (centre). Resistant, dm-scale bed just above the hammer head is dolomite, probably a distal carbonate turbidite. Enclosing both are evenly layered, shaly strata typical of the basinal lutites of the Bee Gorge Member of the Wittenoom Formation.
over which the spherule layers were originally deposited were presumably much larger. The global extent of the Cretaceous-Tertiary (K/T) boundary layer proves that spherules generated by one large impact can carpet the surface of the entire planet (Smit, 1999). It has already been suggested that individual impacts in both the Early and Late Archaean may have each generated contemporaneous spherule layers in South Africa and Australia (Simonson et al., 1999; Byerly et al., 2002). Confirmation that one or both of these layers were dispersed globally must await detailed scrutiny of contemporaneous strata at localities scattered widely around the Earth.
1.3. Early Precambrian Stratigraphic Record
37
Most of the spherule layers recognised so far are anomalously coarse sand-rich beds within mud-dominated successions. Based on sedimentary structures displayed in both the mud- and sand-rich layers, most of these successions were deposited below wave base in deeper water environments. The spherule layers per se commonly display large rip-up clasts from subjacent strata (Figs. 1.3-4b, c), normal grading, and/or cross-stratification (Fig. 1.3-4b). The Late Archaean to Palaeoproterozoic spherule layers are enclosed in muddy strata which are thinly laminated and show few or no signs of deposition from currents or waves (Fig. 1.3-4d; Hassler and Simonson, 2001). The Early to Middle Archaean spherule layers were deposited in a broader spectrum of environments involving a mix of shallower to deeper water and even subaerially emergent environments such as fan-deltas (Lowe et al., 2003). In all settings, the spherule layers are products of anomalously high-energy events. At least in some cases, the source of the high energy appears to have been tsunami waves and attendant currents induced by the impacts that created the spherules themselves (Hassler et al., 2001; Lowe et al., 2003). In other cases, they formed thick layers with coarse clasts deposited by mass movements (Simonson, 1992; Hassler and Simonson, 2001). Regardless of how and where they were deposited, spherule layers are highly distinctive. Under optimal conditions, they can be recognised confidently on the basis of a single exposure one metre wide (e.g., the early Archaean $4 layer; Lowe et al., 2003) or by examination of a single sample from a drill core with a hand lens (e.g., the Late Archaean Jeerinah layer; Simonson et al., 2000b). Evidence f o r an impact origin The study of impact spherule layers is a relatively new development in the field of Precambrian geology, essentially dating from the publication of Lowe and Byerly (1986). Most Precambrian impact structures are Meso- to Neoproterozoic in age, and even these are not very numerous (Shoemaker and Shoemaker, 1996). Given their lower abundance and higher degree of deformation compared to younger rocks, it is unlikely that a record of impact structures as rich as that of the Phanerozoic will ever be found in Archaean to Palaeoproterozoic rocks. However, there is no reason why additional spherule layers could not be preserved in many Precambrian successions. The interpretation of these spherules as products of impacts by large extraterrestrial bodies initially met with widespread scepticism and has been challenged on a number of counts. Most troubling among the arguments raised against the impact interpretation is the failure to isolate any shock-metamorphosed minerals from the spherule layers, a deficiency which is still not fully understood. However, a number of arguments have been marshaled in support of the interpretation of these spherules as impact products. These arguments, recently summarised in Lowe et al. (2003) and Simonson (2003), are recapitulated below. Perhaps the most obvious argument has to do with the textural characteristics of the spherules themselves. It is now well documented that a number of Phanerozoic impacts produced ejecta layers that consist predominantly of highly spherical grains of former melt, generally known as microtektites (if they consist entirely of glass) or microkrystites (if they display primary crystallisation textures). In addition, a minority of the particles in Phanerozoic microtektite layers display distinctive shapes such as teardrops and highly
38
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
elongated dumbbells. These are a close match for the shapes and sizes of particles found in many of the Precambrian spherule layers, whereas there is no close match amongst layers formed by volcanic eruptions. The only volcaniclastic layers in which spheroidal particles dominate are those rich in accretionary and armoured lapilli (Reimer, 1983), which are very different from impact spherules. Accretionary and armoured lapilli are typically larger than impact spherules, and if they are the same size, accretionary lapilli typically show crude concentric growth bands internally (e.g., Lowe, 1999b) rather than the bubble cavities and crystallisation textures of impact spherules. Even where internal textures are altered beyond recognition, the presence of unusual shapes such as dumbbells and teardrops can be used to distinguish impact spherules from accretionary lapilli. Accretionary lapilli formed during impacts have textural characteristics identical to those of volcanic accretionary lapilli (e.g., Warme et al., 2002), but no accretionary lapilli have been reported from any spherule-rich layer in either the Precambrian or Phanerozoic. Spherules of silicate melt are of course widespread in volcanic deposits (e.g., Heiken and Lofgren, 1971; Hay et al., 1979). The key difference between the spherule layers described here and the melt spherules formed by terrestrial volcanic processes such as lava fountaining is that volcanic spherules are always highly subordinate to non-spherical particles such as bits of scoria or Pele's hair. In contrast, the majority of the initially molten particles in impact spherule layers are spherical. This can be determined readily in Precambrian spherule layers, provided they are not too severely affected by tectonic deformation or diagenetic processes such as replacement and compaction. In rare instances, a high proportion of the melt particles in a volcaniclastic layer have spheroidal shapes (e.g., G61inas et al., 1977a), but only in layers close to their point of origin and intimately associated with volcanic flow rocks. This is clearly different from impact spherules, which occur in thin layers that persist regionally to perhaps globally. More direct evidence that extraterrestrial bodies were involved in forming the spherules comes from the geochemistry of spherule-rich samples. A chondritic component was first recognised in spherule layers on the basis of iridium anomalies, enrichments in siderophile elements, and platinum group elements (PGEs) with inter-elemental ratios approaching chondritic values (Lowe et al., 1989; Kyte et al., 1992; Simonson et al., 1998, 2000c). Objections were raised to some of these interpretations, in part because of the extremely high values of PGEs in some samples (Reimold, 2000). However, given the great age of these layers, some blurring of the extraterrestrial signal is to be expected. In the case of some of the late Archaean layers, the departures from chondritic ratios closely match those in a layer of known impact ejecta from the late Precambrian Acraman impact structure of South Australia (Simonson et al., 1998). Another line of evidence pointing to an extraterrestrial origin for the spherule layers are nickel-rich chrome spinels in some of the older Archaean layers (Fig. 1.3-3f; Byerly and Lowe, 1994; Lowe et al., 2003). Although they differ in composition from those associated with K/T and Eocene impact spherules, the spinels in the Archaean spherules are clearly enriched in extraterrestrial components and differ in composition from spinels found in closely associated komatiites. Most recently, extraterrestrial chromium has been detected in Precambrian spherule layers (Table 1.3-1) via the isotopic technique of Shukolyukov and Lugmair (1998).
1.3. EarlyPrecambrian Stratigraphic Record
39
Timing of Impacts
The ages of the older Archaean spherule layers are well constrained by U-Pb zircon dates from both the layers and associated rocks. Identical zircon populations were reported from the oldest spherule layers in both the Barberton greenstone belt of South Africa and the Pilbara craton of Western Australia, indicating their depositional ages are indistinguishable at 3470-t-2 Ma (Byerly et al., 2002). Similar analyses have been done on two of the younger layers in the Barberton greenstone belt and place their depositional ages at c. 3260 Ma (Byerly et al., 1996) for $2 and 3243 -t- 4 Ma for $3. Layer $4 is believed to be very close in age to $3 because it is only 6.5 m stratigraphically above $4 (Lowe et al., 2002). Taking the total span of time represented by these four layers and simply dividing it into equal increments yields a recurrence interval (RI) of roughly 77 My between spheruleforming impacts in the Barberton greenstone belt. Focusing solely on the three youngest layers yields a significantly shorter RI of roughly 10 My between spherule-forming impacts (Lowe et al., 2003). The ages of the Late Archaean to Early Palaeoproterozoic spherule layers are not as well constrained. A minimum of three impacts is required to create the spherule layers in the Hamersley basin (Table 1.3-1). Direct dating has only been attempted on the Wittenoom layer. Pb-Pb analysis of carbonates in and around this layer yielded a date of 2541 + 11~Ma (Woodhead et al., 1998), which is consistent with other dates from surrounding strata (Trendall et al., 1998). The age of the spherule layer in the Jeerinah Formation is probably the best known as it lies within a few meters stratigraphically of a 2629 + 5 Ma tuff dated via the SHRIMP U-Pb zircon method (reference number 139 in Table 1 of Nelson et al., 1999). The age of the Dales Gorge spherule layer, the youngest of the Hamersley layers, can only be approximated as roughly 2490 Ma by interpolating between widely spaced zircon-dated tuff layers (summarised in Nelson et al., 1999). New SHRIMP U-Pb analyses of zircons from tufts in overlying formations (Pickard, 2002) suggest the Dales Gorge layer may be slightly older than this. The age of the spherule layer in the Monteville Formation (Table 1.3-1) is not well constrained either. It is bracketed between tufts whose zircons yielded SHRIMP U-Pb dates of 2650 -4- 8 Ma and 2602 -t- 14 Ma (Gutzmer and Beukes, 1997) and is stratigraphically closer to the older one. Taking outer age limits of 2630 and 2490 Ma for the three spherule-forming impacts in the Hamersley basin yields a RI of c. 70 My for the younger cluster of early Precambrian layers. This value is surprisingly close to the initial estimate from the Barberton greenstone belt. The existence of the Monteville spherule layer is not a factor because it may have been formed by the same impact that produced the spherule layers in the Jeerinah Formation (Simonson et al., 1999, 2002). In addition to the spherule layers in Western Australia and South Africa, one possible spherule layer has been reported from the Ketilidian orogen of South Greenland (Chadwick et al., 2001; Table 1.3-1). This layer has not been studied in the field since the 1960s, and the succession in which it occurs is not well dated. Chadwick et al. (2001) summarised the age constraints and indicated that the maximum and minimum depositional ages for this spherule layer were c. 2130 and 1848 Ma respectively. That places it firmly in the Palaeo-
40
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
proterozoic and significantly younger than all of the other known Precambrian spherule layers. Implications for Earth History
The characteristics of impact ejecta are determined by the properties of two things: the impactor and the target area. Impactor properties that can affect the nature of the ejecta include its composition, velocity, and angle of impact. Properties of the geologic deposits in the target area that can affect the nature of the ejecta include their chemical composition, their state of induration, the existence of any anisotropy, and whether or not they are covered by water. Simonson and Harnik (2000) noted that the handful of early Precambrian impact spherule layers found so far appear to differ in some ways from their Phanerozoic counterparts. If indeed they do, this could reflect secular changes in either the nature of impactors or Earth's surface environments and rocks, or both, through time. The characteristics of early Precambrian spherule layers that may differ from Phanerozoic examples are outlined next, followed by a discussion of the possible implications for early Earth history. The most striking difference between early Precambrian and Phanerozoic spherule layers is the fact that spherules are simply much more abundant in the older layers. Spherules constitute the vast majority of impact-generated material in all of the early Precambrian layers, so the aggregate thickness of spherules calculated independently of other types of detritus is a reasonable proxy for impact size. Precambrian spherule layers vary greatly in thickness (Table 1.3-1), but most of this variation reflects dilution by non-impact detritus entrained and redeposited by waves and/or currents. Even though the average aggregate thickness of spherules is often very difficult to estimate, it appears to be measured in tens to hundreds of millimetres in many Precambrian spherule layers (Table 1.3-1). In contrast, the aggregate thickness of spherules in the distal parts of the KfI' boundary layer averages 2 to 3 mm and never exceeds 100 mm (Smit, 1999). The aggregate thickness of impact ejecta can be much greater at more proximal sites, but such locations are not good analogues for Precambrian spherule layers because the ejecta is not dominated by spherules. For example, spherules are found in an Eocene ejecta layer 80 mm thick on the continental slope off New Jersey at DSDP site 612, but they are outnumbered by shock-metamorphosed solid ejecta and non-spheroidal impact glass particles (Glass, 1989). The great thickness of spherules strongly suggests that early Precambrian spherule layers were created by objects at least as large as the K/T boundary projectile, whose diameter is estimated at 10 km (e.g., Shukolyukov et al., 2000). However, equating layer thickness with projectile size has its pitfalls. The total mass of spherules in the K/T boundary layer can be estimated with confidence because its thickness has been determined all over the world (Smit, 1999). In contrast, early Precambrian layers are only preserved over a small fraction of the Earth's surface, and even within these areas they vary dramatically in thickness. For example, the Jeerinah and Carawine layers were probably formed by the same impact (Simonson et al., 2002), yet the entire Jeerinah layer consists of c. 3 mm of nearly pure spherules at one site whereas the Carawine layer c. 200 km away has an aggregate spherule content of roughly 250 mm (Table 1.3-1). There is as yet no data whatsoever con-
1.3. Early Precambrian Stratigraphic Record
41
cerning Precambrian spherule layers from most of the Earth's surface. Therefore, extreme caution is advisable in estimating the total mass of spherules from a given impact in the face of such extreme variations in thickness. The lateral extent of the spherule layers is also something of an open question. The furthest any early Precambrian spherule layer has been traced continuously is a few hundred kilometres (Table 1.3-1). The 3470 Ma layers in South Africa and Western Australia are most likely products of a single impact (Byerly et al., 2002), and the Late Archaean Monteville and Jeerinah spherule layers in South Africa and Western Australia, respectively (Table 1.3-1), could also have formed from a single impact (Simonson et al., 1999). These correlations, plus the great thickness of spherules noted above, clearly indicate the spherules were dispersed laterally for thousands of kilometres. However, striking geological similarities between these two cratons suggest they were in close proximity to one another at times (see, however, review in Nelson et al., 1999, for a contrasting viewpoint), in which case the observed thicknesses might be typical for part, but not all, of the Earth's surface. On the other hand, geochemical evidence suggests the Precambrian spherule layers represent ejecta dispersed globally. By analogy with compositional contrasts between microtektites and microkrystites in the K/T boundary layer (J. Smit et al., 1992), the high Ir and Cr contents of the Precambrian layers are more typical of distal than proximal spherules, although it is difficult to generalise given the small number of Precambrian spherule layers so far identified. It is still not understood why some Phanerozoic impacts produced spherules in abundance and dispersed them over wider areas whereas others apparently did not. Most early Precambrian spherule layers were probably produced by objects at least as massive as the K/T boundary impactor. Such major early Precambrian impacts were probably more closely spaced in time than was the case for their Phanerozoic counterparts. The recurrence interval (RI) of spherule-forming impacts recorded in both the Barberton greenstone belt and the Hamersley basin is roughly 70 My, which is virtually identical to the Phanerozoic RI of an impactor ~> 10 km in diameter (Chapman and Morrison, 1994). One would expect the RI to be even shorter in the early Precambrian from Ryder's (2003) reading of the lunar impact record, and the early Archaean spherule layers coincide with evidence of a higher rate of impacts from lunar impact spherules (Culler et al., 2000). In fact, the RI of large impacts in the late Archaean to Palaeoproterozoic is likely to become shorter via the discovery of additional spherule layers. Almost all of the Precambrian spherule layers found so far are in two relatively small areas (Fig. 1.3-1) that represent a fraction of early Precambrian time. Other spherule layers are likely to be found as the search spreads to strata in new geographic areas and of different ages. If the Precambrian spherule layers found so far represent thicker accumulations in relatively close proximity to the points of impacts rather than global blankets, even the layers found to date are not representative of all of the large impacts during their respective time windows. This too would mean the RI of large impacts in the early Precambrian was significantly shorter than the inferred maximum of 70 My. Differences in the Earth's hydrosphere could also contribute to contrasts in thickness and frequency of early Precambrian versus Phanerozoic spherule layers. The modern ocean
42
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
shields the deep sea floor from all but the largest impactors because the diameter of a projectile has to roughly equal the water depth before rocks on the seafloor can be excavated and dispersed as vapour or melt droplets (Gersonde et al., 1997). What if Archaean oceans were shallower (see discussion, section 3.6) on average than those of the Phanerozoic? Then smaller projectiles could have produced spherules from oceanic crust in the Archaean. This in turn would mean that a greater number of spherule layers would be produced, even if the flux of impactors were the same then as it was in the Phanerozoic. A higher abundance of impact spherules from mafic target rocks in the early Precambrian could therefore signal shallower oceans as opposed to a greater rate of impacts when compared to the Phanerozoic. The chemistry of Archaean seawater (sections 5.2-5.5) could have also played an important role. Silica concentrations were much higher in Precambrian oceans than they are today (Siever, 1992), so Precambrian seafloor environments may have been more amenable to the preservation of impact spherules. This is particularly true of those with low silica contents, as they are the most vulnerable to dissolution in modern seawater (Glass, 1984). In fact, the two basins where most of the spherule layers have been found are known for their silica-rich deposits. The Hamersley basin is well known for the size and extent of its banded iron formations (Trendall, 1983b) (section 5.4), and early silicification is very pervasive in the Barberton greenstone belt (Duchac and Hanor, 1987; Lowe, 1999a). Perhaps unusually high levels of silica played a role in the preferential preservation of spherules layers in these two basins, as did the fact that they contain some of the least altered and deformed supracrustal rocks on Earth in their respective time windows. The internal textures of early Precambrian spherules also appear to differ from those of Phanerozoic impact spherules. Most of the mass in distal impact ejecta is derived from target materials (Koeberl, 1998), so any systematic change in the primary composition of impact spherules over geological time probably reflects changes in the average composition of Earth's lithosphere. Simonson and Harnik (2000) proposed that early Precambrian spherules were more basaltic on average than Phanerozoic spherules. This is consistent with a smaller volume of continental crust in the early Precambrian (e.g., Eriksson, 1995) (chapter 2, section 3.6), which would statistically produce a lower percentage of ejecta from high-silica continental rocks and a correspondingly higher incidence of impacts into oceanic crust. A predominance of impacts into mafic target materials could also help account for the paucity of shock-metamorphosed grains from continental source rocks such as quartz and zircon in early Precambrian layers (Simonson et al., 1998). This is not to say that continental impacts did not produce ejecta in the Archaean. The Late Archaean Carawine layer contains melt particles that resemble Muong Nong-type tektites (Simonson et al., 2000a, 2002). The latter are larger and more layered than normal tektites and formed during a continental impact in Indochina (Glass, 1990). The melt material in the Carawine layer therefore represents a good candidate for early Precambrian continental impact ejecta. Whatever their size, frequency, and target materials, there is clear evidence that the impactors responsible for the Precambrian spherule layers had chondritic compositions. The relative abundances of siderophile elements, particularly PGEs, support this interpretation (Lowe et al., 1989; Kyte et al., 1992; Simonson et al., 1998, 2000c). Even among
1.3. Early Precambrian Stratigraphic Record
43
the few spherule layers known, variations in the relative abundances of chromium isotopes (Table 1.3-1) indicate several different types of impactors were responsible. Meteoritic materials consistently have excess 53Cr relative to terrestrial materials; additionally, carbonaceous chondrites have excess 54Cr relative to other terrestrial and extraterrestrial materials (Kyte et al., 2003). In the convention proposed by Shukolyukov et al. (2000), both of these indicators are combined into a normalised E53 value in which terrestrial materials have a value of zero, whereas ordinary and carbonaceous chondrites depart from zero in positive and negative directions respectively. Most of the older Archaean layers show negative e53 anomalies, indicating they were produced by impactors with compositions like carbonaceous chondrites (Lowe et al., 2003; Kyte et al., 2003). In contrast, some of the late Archaean spherule layers show positive anomalies, indicating they were produced by impactors with compositions like ordinary or perhaps enstatite chondrites (Shukolyukov et al., 2002; McDonald and Simonson, 2002). Data are still scarce and more work is clearly needed to constrain the compositions of the impactors which produced the Precambrian spherule layers.
Scientific Value of Spherule Layers Research on spherule layers by a handful of scientists has already yielded a wealth of tantalising information about impacts in early Earth history, but it has generated even more questions about how and why they form. Only now are earth scientists at large starting to search systematically for these layers, and already they are being discovered in strata that have been examined by geologists many times in the past (e.g., Walkden et al., 2002). Given the large number of impacts that must have happened in early Earth history (Glikson, 1999), it is likely that many additional Precambrian spherule layers will be discovered. In closing, we will speculate a little about what we stand to learn about impacts and their role in early Earth history via the discovery of additional spherule layers and their characterisation. Precambrian spherule layers can provide important insights into the dynamics and environmental effects of large impacts. Craters and related structures provide the best evidence of the location and size of an impact, but they are commonly poor recorders of an impact's environmental effects. In contrast, spherule layers are ideal for assessing environmental effects because each one is found enclosed within sediments deposited immediately before and after the impact. Moreover, Precambrian layers are superior to most Phanerozoic layers for studies of the processes which happen during spherule deposition because physical sedimentary structures are never obscured by burrowing organisms, although they can be deformed tectonically or otherwise altered just as easily as Phanerozoic strata. Most Precambrian spherule layers found so far show evidence of reworking, very possibly by processes induced by the impacts themselves (Hassler and Simonson, 2001), although a minority appear to be direct fallout deposits (Lowe et al., 2003). This persistent evidence of reworking may indicate that the thick spherule accumulations found to date were mostly deposited in the same region as the impact that generated them, rather than on a distant part of the Earth's surface. Lastly, studies of the textures and compositions of the spherules may
44
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
shed light on processes in large ejecta clouds. It is unclear at present exactly what type(s) of impact spherules form as ballistic droplets of impact melt versus condensates from rock vapour. Much of what we infer about this topic is based on studies of the K/T boundary layer, which has been examined in great detail but, in the final analysis, is still the product of a single impact. Studies of spherules from numerous impacts are needed to delineate the full range of possibilities, so contrasts between spherules formed by different Precambrian impacts may shed new light on this question. They may also help answer the question of why only certain impacts produce spherule layers. Even if we don't fully understand how they form, impact spherule layers may provide excellent tools for stratigraphic correlation. All of the spherule layers found so far are "marker beds" that were deposited rapidly by anomalously high-energy events, probably in time periods ranging from a few hours to perhaps a few days. Combined with their dispersal over very large areas, this means spherule layers are excellent time-stratigraphic markers. Byerly et al. (2002) have already made a convincing case for the correlation of Early Archaean spherule layers from South Africa to Western Australia, and further work may establish similar correlations among Late Archaean spherule layers. If these and other layers can be identified successfully and correlated on other continental shields as well, they could form the basis for a framework of intercontinental stratigraphic correlation among early Precambrian successions whose time resolution could be on the order of centuries, decades, or even years in strata that are billions of years old. Studies of spherule layers may allow us to detect changes in both impactors and target rocks through geologic time. Spherule layers have already extended the record of terrestrial impacts back in time by almost 1.5 billion years. Provided enough can be found to assemble a database comparable to that of impact structures (Grieve, 1998), spherule layers could be used to test for variations in the rate of large terrestrial impacts through geologic time, for example, via comet showers (Shoemaker, 1998). The fact that spherule layers always occur in stratigraphic context means they could also be used to test for correlations between large impacts and turning points in the history of life (see chapter 6). Even in the absence of skeletal fossils, recent advances in the study of biomarkers might make it feasible to do this in some early Precambrian successions. While the number of spherule layers known to date is clearly too small for a statistical approach to secular variations, some tantalising coincidences have already been documented. For example, spherule layers in the Barberton greenstone belt coincide with critical transitions from volcanic to sediment-dominated successions marked by major unconformities, suggesting that the impacts that generated them induced major lithospheric changes (Lowe et al., 2003). The oldest spherule layer in the Hamersley basin occurs just a few metres stratigraphically beneath what is perhaps the oldest major BIF on Earth. Large iron-formations require large-scale hydrothermal systems in the deep ocean (Jacobsen and Pimentel-Klose, 1988) (various genetic models are discussed by Trendall and Blockley, section 5.4), so the onset of BIF deposition could reflect hydrothermal activity initiated or enhanced by a large oceanic impact. Late Archaean spherule layers in the Hamersley and Griqualand West basins (quite possibly products of the same impact) are also stratigraphically close to the base of the first large carbonate plat-
1.4. Early Precambrian Impact Events
45
forms (Grotzinger, 1989). Perhaps the appearance of the first carbonate platforms reflects an adaptive radiation of new microbial life forms in the wake of a large impact? In summary, the study of impact spherule layers, particularly those of the Precambrian, currently stands in a position analogous to studies of impact craters near the start of the 20th century. There have been relatively few discoveries and detailed studies made so far, but the pace should accelerate dramatically in the decades to come. As it does, we stand to learn a great deal about both projectiles from space and the surface of the Earth they hit.
1.4.
STRATEGIES FOR FINDING THE RECORD OF EARLY PRECAMBRIAN IMPACT EVENTS
D.H. ABBOTT AND J.T. HAGSTRUM Introduction
Recent work has shown that there is a high degree of correlation between the timing of impact events and of strong plumes (e.g., komatiites; Abbott and Isley, 2002a) (see also section 4.3 on komatiites, and sections 3.2 and 3.3 on plumes). There is also a c. 26 My periodicity in komatiite activity at about 2.7 Ga (Isley and Abbott, 2002). This is the same periodicity (26-36 My) as is observed in the Phanerozoic record of large impacts (Stothers and Rampino, 1990; Rampino and Stothers, 1999). These correlations suggest that mantle plumes were strengthened by large impact events. If this is true, the ideal part of geological time to test this idea is within the Archaean rock record. During the Archaean, large impacts were more abundant than in the Phanerozoic (section 1.3), and the strongest mantle plumes were at least 10 times stronger than the strongest Phanerozoic plumes (Abbott and Isley, 2002b) (sections 3.2 and 3.3). The Archaean rock record also contains most of the documented komatiites (section 4.3). So far, only about 7 Archaean impact debris layers have been identified (Lowe et al., 1989; Simonson et al., 1999) (see section 1.3). As we will show, there should have been at least 350 impact events that produced global impact layers during the period from 2.5 to 3.8 Ga. Because continents covered about 27% of the Earth's surface by the late Archaean, most of these impacts would have been within the Archaean ocean basins. In this section, our knowledge of Phanerozoic oceanic and terrestrial impact events has been applied to formulate a search strategy for Precambrian distal impact layers. The search strategy incorporates: (1) characteristic sedimentary facies of distal impact layers, (2) geophysical methods of finding distal impact layers, (3) distinctive spherule and rock types in impact layers, and (4) distinctive minerals in impact layers. Some possible stratigraphic associations that have not yet been found, but that might be characteristic of some distal impact layers, are also proposed. The Precambrian Farth: Tempos and Events Edited by EG. Eriksson. W. Altermann, D.R. Nelson, W.U. Mueller and O. Catuneanu
46
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
Calculating Crater Size Necessary to Produce a Global Impact Layer The rate of formation of impact craters on the Earth's surface can be estimated by tabulating the abundance of impact craters on cratons, and by measuring the abundance and size distributions of asteroids and comets with Earth-crossing orbits. The estimated cratering rate for the last 120 My is about 516 impact craters over 10 km in diameter (Shoemaker, 1983; Shoemaker et al., 1990; Shaw, 1994). Because the recent cratering rate is higher than in the rest of the Phanerozoic, we assume that the recent cratering rate sets a lower bound on the background-cratering rate for Archaean time. Using this cratering rate, at least 5,500 craters over 10 km in diameter must have formed between 3.8 and 2.5 Ga. Because an 11 km diameter crater is required to put material into the stratosphere and to make microtektites (Glass et al., 1979), most Archaean cratering events should have produced regional tektite-bearing impact layers that covered minimum surface areas of c. 7.1 • 105 km 2. Because most of the Archaean Earth's surface was ocean basin, most of the resulting impact layers would have been deposited within the deep ocean basins and subsequently destroyed by subduction (section 3.6 debates the age of the onset of plate tectonics). To ensure that a layer was deposited on the continents and preserved, we must estimate the minimum crater size producing a global impact sedimentary layer. A global impact layer is distinguished by the presence of impact spherules, nearperfectly round spheres of quenched impact melt (Harnik and Simonson, 2000; Simonson et al., 1999). Some impact spherules are crystalline and are called microkrystites (see section 1.3). Other impact spherules are pure glass, and are microtektites (McCall, 2001). Tektites are generally deposited asymmetrically and close to the source crater, whereas microkrystites are generally more widely distributed. Both the Popigai impact event (crater diameter 100 km) and the Chesapeake Bay impact event (crater diameter 80 km) produced global microkrystite-bearing layers of late Eocene age (Whitehead et al., 2000). The ages of the two impact layers are nearly identical and the layers are intermixed in deep-sea cores. The combined impact layer is typically several centimetres thick. In the Phanerozoic, ash layers this thick are usually bioturbated into the surrounding sediments. A minimum layer thickness of c. 5-10 cm is required to prevent dispersal of a rapidly deposited layer by bioturbation. Thus, the presence of two closely spaced impacts increases the possibility that a global layer will be preserved and it is probable that an even larger minimum size for an impact crater might be required to produce a global layer in the Phanerozoic. However, in the Archaean, bioturbating organisms were not present (e.g., section 6.2). Global impact layers only a few millimetres thick should be preserved as intact layers and the layers should have sharp upper and lower contacts. Therefore, we assume that during the Archaean a minimum crater size of c. 80 km would have produced a global impact layer. The cratering rate decreases by about a factor of two for each doubling in crater size (Hughes, 1998). Thus, the cratering rate for 80-kin diameter impact craters is 1/24 or about 1/16th the rate of creation of 10-km impact craters. This predicts that 32 impact craters over 80 km in diameter formed during the last 120 My. For the entire Archaean, there should have been about 350 impact events that produced global layers a millimetre
1.4. Early Precambrian Impact Events
47
or more in thickness. So far, we know of only about 7 Archaean impact layers (Lowe et al., 1989; Simonson et al., 1999) and no Archaean impact craters have been identified. Even with very poor stratigraphic preservation, there must be many more impact layers within Archaean sedimentary rocks.
Important Differences: Submarine, Abyssal and Continental Impacts Impact events that are large enough to produce global layers will have characteristic features that depend on the environment of the impact. If the impact is submarine, it will produce characteristic sedimentary structures over a broad region. If the impact occurs on continental crust, either the continental shelf or subaerial continental crust, it is likely to hit either quartz-rich sedimentary rocks or quartz-bearing igneous and metamorphic rocks. These rocks are all potential sources of shocked quartz. In contrast, an impact into the abyssal ocean will strike a thin cover of pelagic sediment overlying oceanic crust (depending on water depth; section 1.3). The rock types that make up the oceanic crust, MORB (mid-ocean ridge basalt), OIB (ocean island basalt) and oceanic plateau basalt are not quartz normative. These rocks do not contain quartz grains that form shocked quartz. Only oceanic fracture zones or sheeted dykes may contain small amounts of a quartz normative rock type, such as plagiogranite. Typical pelagic sediment has only a small component of wind-blown quartz from the continents. This wind-blown quartz is very fine grained (i.e., < 63 ~m in diameter). The shocked quartz that is unique to impacts has at least two directions of planar deformation features (PDFs) within a single grain (Short and Bunch, 1966). Because multiple directions of PDFs are easier to find within large grains of quartz, these small grains make it difficult to find shocked quartz within abyssal impact layers. Thus, shocked quartz grains are not expected to be characteristic of abyssal impact layers and cannot be relied upon to verify an impact event in the abyssal ocean. Prior to 3.0 Ga, the continental crust had about 20% of its present day volume (Taylor and McLennan, 1985). Typical Archaean continental crust was thicker (c. 49 km) than Phanerozoic crust (c. 40 km; Mooney et al., 1998; Abbott et al., 2000), so the continents covered about 7% of the Earth. By the end of the Archaean, continental crust had about 80% of its present day volume (Taylor and McLennan, 1985) (see also, section 2.8). Including their greater crustal thickness, Late Archaean continents covered about 27% of the Earth, compared to 41% at present (Cogley, 1984). Particularly in the Early Archaean, it is likely that there was significantly less wind-blown quartz in abyssal sediments (section 7.6 discusses temporal control on aeolian deposits). Therefore, it is most probable that Archaean-age impact layers do not contain shocked quartz.
Differentiating Cometary and Asteroid Impacts Anomalies in the amount of Ir and other PGEs are widely used as evidence for impact events (Schmidt et al., 1993; Smit et al., 1997; Chadwick et al., 2001) (see also section 1.3).
48
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
However, the concentration of iridium in an impact layer depends on the nature of the impactor. Most comets contain about 33-50% volatile material that contains almost no Ir. The non-volatile remainder is not as high in Ir as a typical asteroid. Furthermore, typical Earth-encounter velocities for asteroids are 15-25 km/s whereas the velocities of comets are typically between 40 and 70 km/s (French, 1998). Therefore, the dilution of the impactor in the ejecta blanket differs greatly between asteroids and comets. Because comets produce larger craters for a given size of impactor, cometary material constitutes a smaller proportion of the ejecta layer. Because the size of an Ir anomaly is related to the dilution of the impactor within the ejecta layer, this further reduces the average Ir anomaly from cometary impact events. Van den Bergh (1994) estimated that the typical Ir anomaly from a cometary impact would be about 1% of the size of the Ir anomaly from an asteroid impact of similar mass. Because the Ir anomalies from asteroid impacts are difficult to measure, the Ir anomalies from cometary impacts would usually be below background levels and hence undetectable. We do know of impact events that have no discernable Ir anomaly. Only one of the five known strewn fields of tektites has a significant Ir anomaly (Glass, 1980; Koeberl, 1993). Because tektites form during impacts, this may indicate that the majority of impact layers do not have significant Ir anomalies. Another important difference between cometary and asteroid impactors is their crater size distribution. As impact craters become larger, the relative proportion of those produced by cometary impactors increases. Hughes (1998) suggested that around 95 % of the impactors producing craters between 20 and 100 km in diameter are comets. For craters over 100 km in diameter, the proportion of comets should be even higher. This means that comets, not asteroids, produce most global impact layers and that most global impact layers will not have detectable Ir anomalies. Characteristics of Submarine Global Impact Layers: Sedimentary Structures The most important immediate effect of a submarine impact would be the generation of tsunami waves whose size would be directly dependent on the size of the impactor. An impact that could produce a global impact layer from an 80 km diameter impact crater would require an impactor of c. 4 km in diameter (Melosh, 1989). The tsunamis produced in this event would have local heights on continental shelves of 1 km or greater (Artemieva and Shuvalov, 2002). The erosive power of such tsunamis would generate large ripped up blocks, cross-beds, profound disconformities, regional redeposition, and reworked sediments (Hassler et al., 2000; Hassler and Simonson, 2001). Hassler and Simonson (2001) described ripped up blocks of iron-formation that are > 2 m across. These large blocks are inferred to result from an impact that produced a crater c. 210 km in diameter (impactor c. 10 km in diameter). Massive rip-up blocks that are many metres in length are often misidentified as intact outcrops; this initially occurred with the Alamo impact breccia (J. Warme, 2003, pers. comm.). The problem would be even greater in deformed Archaean terranes. Careful structural measurements are required to identify massive rip-up blocks in poorly exposed Archaean cratons with highly metamorphosed
1.4. Early Precambrian Impact Events
49
strata. In addition, geologists should check carefully to see if smaller fragments surround the large blocks. An intact, well-bedded sedimentary formation that suddenly becomes part of an apparently conformable shear zone or a melange could actually be rip-up blocks from an impact event. If the shear zone or melange does not appear to have a higher metamorphic grade or to be more altered than the well-bedded sediments, then it could be an impact layer. In sand-sized sediments at continental shelf depths, tsunamis can produce antidunes. Antidunes are found today in the outflow zones from areas where large lakes of glacial meltwater were impounded (Waitt, 1985). Antidunes migrate upstream against the current, so their apparent downstream edges will be on the opposite side of the structure from the palaeocurrent direction. Antidunes are also extremely large, with 3-15 m heights and 100-325 m wavelengths (Bretz, 1969). Thus, any cross-beds in Archaean continental shelf sequences with amplitudes more than 3 m could be part of an antidune sequence. The erosive power of a 1 km amplitude tsunami is profound. As a result, the underlying sediments will be eroded. At large distances from the impact or in deeper water, the impact will produce a disconformity with a broad age gap in the sediments. In the Phanerozoic rock record, such disconformities can be identified using micropalaeontology. In the Archaean, these disconformities can only be identified if the geochronology is good enough and deposition was rapid. Although disconformities are difficult to identify in the Archaean rock record, erosion from tsunamis produces other features that might be preserved. Tsunamis often redeposit marine sediments within terrestrial sequences that are tens of meters above sea level and tens of kilometres inland (Bourgeois et al., 1993). The easiest tsunami deposits to identify are thin, graded layers of coarse clastic rocks that occur within otherwise continuous sequences of carbonate, chert, or iron-formation. Carbonate, chert, and iron-formation require depositional environments nearly free of terrestrial detritus. Therefore, the sudden appearance of coarse clastic lithologies within fine-grained sedimentary sequences could have resulted from strong wave action that moved distal clastic sediments into the area. During the Phanerozoic, some of these deposits may have been the result of large earthquakes. However, most tsunami deposits from large earthquakes are only a few centimetres in thickness and are typically gravel-sized or finer (Bourgeois and Johnson, 2001; Bourgeois et al., 2001). In contrast, impact tsunami deposits can be metres to tens of metres thick with a basal conglomerate containing rip-up clasts from the underlying beds (Takayama et al., 2000). Thus, any >~ 1 m thick coarse clastic layer within an Archaean carbonate, chert, or iron-formation sequence should be studied to see if it came from an impact-generated tsunami. The uppermost layer of most impact deposits should be an air-fall deposit. If this is the case, the layer will contain a few parts per thousand of impact spherules, characteristic impact minerals (discussed later), and microtektites. Impacts onto sedimentary substrates produce a smaller amount of impact melt (Pierazzo et al., 1997). From our own observations and those of others (Hassler et al., 2000), we infer that spherules resulting from impacts onto (marine) sediments are smaller than spherules resulting from impacts onto bare rock. We calculate that the impact spherules and microtektites from abyssal craters
50
Chapter 1: The EarlyEarth
over 80 km in diameter should only be about 130 ~m in diameter. The few Archaean deposits that have been found contain medium to coarse sand-sized (250-1000 l.tm) impact spherules (Simonson et al., 1999) (section 1.3). These spherules can be seen with a hand lens, but they are not typical. An impact crater about 300 km in diameter is the minimum size needed to produce spherules that are visible with a hand lens (c. 250 ~tm particles). Therefore, only about 92 of the estimated 350 Archaean global impact layers should contain spherules that are visible using a hand lens. Thus, a careful consideration of sedimentary structures and how they make sense in their stratigraphic setting could produce an abundant return in newly identified impact layers within rock sequences. Unless new methods are developed to quickly magnify and image small grains in rocks, verifying these impact layers will require intensive petrographic investigation.
Geophysical Methods for Finding Impact Layers and Impact Craters During a large impact, the country rock is melted to produce an impact melt body that is usually quite magnetic. All impact craters larger than 40 km in diameter have large central magnetic anomalies (Pilkington and Grieve, 1992). Impact debris layers have high magnetic susceptibilities, due to their high magnetic mineral contents. For example, Worm and Banerjee (1987) found that the K/T impact layer has about 8-15 times higher magnetic susceptibility than the surrounding sediments. In our own studies, the contrast in magnetic susceptibility between impact layers and the surrounding sediment depends upon the magnetic susceptibility of the surrounding sediment. In red clay sediments, we find that the upper contact of the impact layer with the overlying sediment occurs at magnetic susceptibility values of about 40 • 10 -6 cgs (Fig. 1.4-1). The magnetic susceptibility within the impact layer is at least 40 • 10 -6 cgs and can be as high as 200 • 10 -6 cgs. If the sediment is a carbonate rather than red clay, the susceptibilities of impact layers will be somewhat lower. Because carbonates have a negative magnetic susceptibility, carbonate rocks and fossils dilute the high magnetic susceptibility of impact layers. In high carbonate sediments, the upper contacts of impact layers occur at susceptibility values of about 20 • 10 -6 cgs, with increases to values as high as 100 • 10 -6 cgs within the impact layer. Ash layers also have magnetic susceptibilities above 40 x 10 -6 cgs. Careful inspection of the coarse fractions (> 63 and > 125 ~tm) of a high susceptibility layer will show if the layer is an ash layer or an impact layer. Ash layers
Opposite: Fig. 1.4-1. Left: Magnetic susceptibility versus depth, core RC11-200. Note the increase in susceptibility to values above 40 • 10-6 cgs between 56 and 62 cm. The background magnetic susceptibility is about 10 • 10-6 cgs. Right: Photo of abyssal impact layer in split core. Abyssal impact layer containing several hundred impact spherules is between 56 and 62 cm. Abyssal impact layer is darker than most of the core. Note soft sediment deformation at 65-98 cm depth. This soft sediment deformation could be due to rapid deposition of the impact layer or to impact-related seismic activity.
1.4. Early Precambrian Impact Events
51
RCl1-200
Mag Sus, cgs (1.0E-6) 0 0
0
0
E 'r 0
Q. 4) r
0
0 0
50
100
52
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
often contain biotite or pumice, both of which are typically absent from abyssal impact layers. Preservation of high magnetic susceptibilities for Archaean sedimentary rocks depends on the degree of alteration. Because high magnetic susceptibility is primarily due to the occurrence of magnetite in the impact layer, high-grade sediments containing diagenetic magnetite might be mistaken for impact layers. If the magnetite in impact layers is removed or altered by weathering or metamorphism, the impact layers might lose their high susceptibility signature. Although the high magnetic susceptibility of impact layers might disappear if the sediment was to be metamorphosed or altered, study of drill-core samples of Archaean low metamorphic grade sedimentary rocks could yield new discoveries of impact layers. If the sedimentary facies and structures suggest possible impact events (as discussed earlier), scientists should measure magnetic susceptibility. A 30 m long core can be measured at 2 cm intervals easily in one day, whereas petrographic examination of the same core would constitute a more substantial project. Examining a 30 m core with a hand lens would take many hours and might miss dispersed layers of impact spherules and impact minerals. For this reason, the magnetic susceptibilities of Archaean sedimentary rocks from low-grade sequences that might contain impact layers should be measured.
Characteristic Rock Types and Features: Microtektites, Pseudotachylites, and Spherules Tektites consist of impact melt that may have travelled between 20 and 80 km into the stratosphere (Koeberl, 1992). Larger tektites have aerodynamic forms including teardrop shapes, flattened concave disks, and dumbbells (Fig. 1.4-2). The microtektite in Figure 1.4-2d is teardrop-shaped and shows surface ablation that is characteristic of tektites. However, most tektites from abyssal impacts are spherical microtektites (McCall, 2001; Figs. 1.4-2b, c). Some of the abyssal microtektites may be transitional forms from microfossils to true microtektites (Fig. 1.4-2a). Some microfossils have shapes that approximate teardrops and may be mistaken for tektites. Some weathering of volcanic glass can produce spalling of glass that resembles the sculpturing of microtektites by atmospheric erosion. Thus, microtektites such as that in Figure 1.4-2a often require further verification by thin section work. In contrast, round microtektites (e.g., Figs. 1.4-2b, c) are much easier to verify. Most abyssal microtektites are composed of perfectly clear, nearly pure silicate glass. They are much richer in SiO2 than microtektites from on-land craters (Taylor and Levinson, 1970). Their compositions mean that microtektites will resist alteration and are likely to survive in the geological record. A logical source for SiO2 in abyssal microtektites is silica-rich material such as chert or biogenic silica. Archaean cherts are relatively common, although they have somewhat higher Mn and Fe contents than Phanerozoic chert layers (Veizer et al., 1989). These Archaean cherts are a potential source of silica-rich microtektites in Archaean impact deposits. Simonson has found tektite-like objects in some Proterozoic and Archaean impact layers (Simonson et al., 2000a) (section 1.3). Their microtektites have classic teardrop shapes and dumbbell forms. They occur along with much more abundant microkrystites.
1.4. Early Precambrian Impact Events
53
Fig. 1.4-2. SEM secondary-electron images of microtektites. (a) Transitional club-shaped tektite. RC12-49 704-706 cm. Scale bar is 50 ~tm. (b) Round microtektite with craters. RC11-205 0-4 cm. Scale bar is 50 ~tm. (c) Round microtektite with ablation. MSN151P 0-5 cm. Scale bar is 50 ~m. (d) Teardrop-shaped tektite with ablation. RC 11.-205 0--4 cm. Scale bar is 100 ~tm.
We have documented four different morphological and compositional types of impact spherules from our abyssal impact layers. Depending on the spherule composition, the outer surfaces of these spherules have various sorts of quench textures. The microtektites discussed above are spherules with high silica contents (> 95% SIO2). These spherules are about half the size of the other spherules in our impact layers. We have also found spherules with quench textures that resemble miniature columnar jointing (Fig. 1.4-3). In visible light at 50 times magnification, the spherules are shiny, yellow, and round. In images taken with a scanning electron microscope (SEM), spherules etched in KOH to remove the outer layer show quench textures that resemble columnar jointing. Like columnar joints, the best-developed and most symmetrical features are beneath the surface. Also like columnar joints, the joints do not continue to the bottom of the rock layer (Fig. 1.4-3a). Furthermore, the quench textures of these spherules resemble the quench textures on the surfaces of spherules produced during experimental impacts (Evans et al., 1994). These columnar-textured spherules have an overall composition that resembles a highFe red clay. The high K contents of these rocks indicate that they are terrestrial in origin
54
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
Fig. 1.4-3. Spherules with miniature columnar jointing. All spherules are from RCI 1-200, 55-62 cm. Note that the size of the jointing varies across individual spherules. This variation is inconsistent with a biogenic origin for the jointing. (a) Cross-section of polished spherule. Note that jointing occurs only on the edge and does not extend to the middle of the spherule. (b) and (d) SEM secondary-electron images of columnar spherules. Scale bar is 50 ~m. Spherules in b and d were treated with KOH to remove the outer coating and exposed the jointing. On upper left centre of d, some of shiny outer coating still remains. Note that d has a tektite-like shape. (c) SEM backscattered-electron image. Scale bar is 50 ~tm. Spherule c has cocoliths on its surface that partially obscure the jointing.
(Taylor et al., 2000) and are not cosmic spherules. Due to their high Fe contents, these spherules weather readily, and they would be less likely to be preserved in Archaean sediments than more silica-rich impact spherules. However, in an Archaean chert layer, they might be the most readily identifiable impact spherules. We also have found white spherules with quench textures that resemble miniature spinifex textures in SEM images (Fig. 1.4-4). These spinifex microkrystites have a terrestrial origin, with K contents of a few percent and an overall composition similar to that of a high-K amphibole or pyroxene. For comparison, Figure 1.4-4d shows a thin section of Archaean spinifex texture. The enlargement (Fig. 1.4-4b) of a small part of the spherule
1.4. Early Precambrian Impact Events
55
Fig. 1.4-4. Spinifex textured spherules. (a) SEM backscattered-electron image of spherule from ODP41-1R3W, 145-147 cm. Scale bar is 100 gm. (b) Enlarged backscattered-electron image of radiating aggregate in left centre of (a). Scale bar is 10 gm. (c) Backscattered-electron image of spherule from RC11-203, 1294-1296 cm. Scale bar is 50 ~tm. (d) Spinifex texture in thin section of V-8 komatiite from the Barberton greenstone belt.
in Figure 1.4-4a shows a strikingly similar texture. A major difference is the size, with komatiite-spinifex textures (see also, section 4.3) being typically much larger. However, microspinifex texture has also been found in some komatiites (Puchtel and Humayun, 2001). Therefore, there is no impediment to a wide range of sizes of spinifex texture. Furthermore, spinifex texture is not confined to komatiites, but has been documented in harzburgites, impact carbonates, and in native sulphur (Imai and Geshi, 1998; Nixon et al., 1999; Jones et al., 2000). Thus, spinifex texture is more indicative of rapid cooling and crystallisation than it is of a specific rock composition. The last type of impact spherules we have found contains randomly oriented crystal aggregates (Fig. 1.4-5). The crystals are most likely to be plagioclase feldspar. The microkrystites have a few percent K, which precludes an extraterrestrial origin. Some of the spherules appear to be hollow (Fig. 1.4-5b). Such spherules might be analogues of the originally hollow Archaean spherules with outer crystal layers (Fig. 1.4-5d) found by Simonson and Hassler (2001). One of our crystal aggregates has some large crystals that jut out of the
56
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
Fig. 1.4-5. Crystal aggregate spherules. All but (d) are SEM backscattered-electron images; (b), (c), (e) and (f) are spherules from ODP 41-1R3W, 145-147 cm. (a) Scale bar is 50 ~tm. Spherule from PLDSII1P, 0-2 cm. (b) Scale bar is 35 ~tm. Note that this spherule appears to be hollow. (c) Scale bar is 50 ~m. (d) Thin section of Archaean spherule (after Simonson and Hassler, 2001). The centre of this spherule may originally have been hollow and the cavity in-filled later. (e) Transitional spherule with small crystals and some columnar jointing. Scale bar is 50 ~m. (f) SEM backscattered-electron image of spherule with protruding crystals. Scale bar is 35 ~m.
1.4. Early Precambrian Impact Events
57
Fig. 1.4-6. Colours and surface textures of impact spherules. All photographed in visible light at 50x magnification. (a) Silver coloured metal spherule from V20-36, 61 cm. Spherule is hollow. (b) Yellow and white spherules from JYN5-46P, 14-16 cm. (c) All from ODP 41-1R3W, 145-147 cm. (cl) White spherule (has random crystals in SEM image). (c2) Yellow to white spherule (SEM images in Figures 4a and b). (c3) Black spherule (has columnar texture in SEM image). (c4) White spherule (SEM image in Figure 5b). (d) Red spherule. (e) Clear spherule (microtektite). RC12-228, 153 cm. (f) Green spherule. V29-66, 0-4 cm (columnar texture in SEM image).
spherule (Fig. 1.4-5f). Another crystal aggregate has a texture that is transitional between random crystal aggregates and columnar jointing (Fig. 1.4-5e). In visible light at 50 times magnification, both the spinifex and random types of microkrystites appear white and perfectly round (Figs. 1.4-6b, c4). Because they are similar in size and colour to marine microfossils, these white impact spherules are easy to miss in Phanerozoic sediments. There are two key tests that can be performed using a microscope. Microfossils are hollow and easily crushed, whereas impact spherules are usually solid. If the impact spherules are not solid, the hole in the centre has a diameter that is less than half the overall diameter of the spherule. In contrast, microfossils have a very thin outer layer. Impact spherules can be crushed, but they are usually slightly magnetic; when compressed
58
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
with a metal pick, they either stick to the pick or jump away. As there are no microfossils in Archaean sedimentary rocks, these impact spherules should be readily identifiable. We have found many colours of impact spherules: white, yellow, green, brown, orange, black, and metallic silver (Fig. 1.4-6). Each impact layer seems to have characteristic spherule compositions and morphologies. Thus, the four types of abyssal impact spherules outlined above are unlikely to represent an exhaustive compilation of impact spherule morphologies. For example, some impact spherules resulting from the Eltanin abyssal impact contain vesicles and others have included spinel grains (Gersonde et al., 1997; Kyte, 2002), whereas others appear to be pure metal (Fig. 1.4-6a). Although most spherules are yellow or white in colour, some are black, brown, orange or green (see Fig. 1.4-6). As more abyssal impact layers are identified, the range of documented spherule morphologies and colours is likely to grow. Impact events may also produce widespread melting of the country rock (Dressier and Reimold, 2001). The distribution of melting is very heterogeneous, and may produce pseudotachylites. Pseudotachylites are veined rocks resulting from impacts in which all of the veins have exactly the same composition as the surrounding matrix. The darker colour of pseudotachylite veins is due to the finer grain size of the glass that makes up the veins. Pseudotachylites have been recognised and described at the c. 2 Ga Vredefort impact crater, Kaapvaal craton (Colliston et al., 1999; Reimold and Colliston, 1994).
Characteristic Impact Minerals Diamond and shocked minerals Once a probable impact layer has been identified, it must be verified as a bona fide impact layer. To do this, one must find minerals that can only form at impact sites (Dressier and Reimold, 2001). There are three such minerals, each has a characteristic form: shocked quartz, shocked zircon, and impact diamond (Miura, 1994). Shocked quartz and shocked zircon show planar deformation features (section 1.3) that are the result of deformation along crystal planes during impact. The result is absolutely parallel planes that cut across the crystal and occur in characteristic crystallographic directions. The two most common directions are co{1013 } and Jr {1012} (Bohor et al., 1987). To qualify as shocked quartz, the parallel planes should occur in at least two different directions. Diamond resulting from shock metamorphism is very different from the diamond found in kimberlite pipes (Shelkov et al., 1998; Masaitis et al., 1999). Impact diamond is not always white; it can be black and have a metallic lustre under reflected light. Impact diamonds are usually only a few microns in size and have a characteristic hexagonal or cubic crystal form. The hexagonal form of impact diamond, or lonsdaleite, has characteristic convex crystal faces. Impact diamonds have a grain density of about 3.5 g/cm 3, higher than that of graphite, which has a grain density of about 2.23 g/cm 3. Impact diamond is very hard and will scratch all other minerals. Diamond is also nearly insoluble and can be separated out by dissolving the rest of the rock-forming minerals. Raman spectroscopy is most effective for distinguishing black-coloured impact diamond from graphite.
59
1.4. Early Precambrian Impact Events
Typical abyssal sediments have about 0.5-1% organic carbon, sufficient to provide the C for impact diamond. Because most of the larger impactors are comets, the abundant C from comets can also be a precursor to impact diamond. Some segregations of nearly pure C occur in our identified abyssal impact layers, but we have not yet located impact diamond. Nevertheless, impact diamond is more likely to form in abyssal impacts than is either shocked quartz or shocked zircon. Native elements
Impact events are extremely reducing (Yakovlev and Basilevsky, 1994). This may be due to the formation of plasma in the impact vapour cloud. Plasmas strip all the electrons from atoms, thus reducing them to their lowest charge state. This means that impact layers could contain reduced mineral forms and native elements. Because they usually have a metallic lustre and no oxygen, native elements can be readily identified. Of the native elements, native carbon (diamond and graphite) has been found at most impact sites (Table 1.4-1). Native S, Fe, Pt and Ni have also been found. Experimental results predict that native A1, Ca, K, Co, Mn and Mg should also form during impacts (Yakovlev and Basilevsky, 1994) but none have yet been found. The most durable and the most abundant of these native elements are native Fe, C, and Ni. Placer diamonds have been found in the Archaean Witwatersrand Supergroup (Nisbet, 1987). Thus, impact diamonds should be preserved within low-grade Archaean sequences, even if those sequences are not reducing. In low-grade black and brown shale sequences, it is likely that native Fe and Ni would also be preserved.
Table 1.4-1. Native elements found in impact layers Element Pt Fe C C C C C C C C C C C S S Ni
Source Crater Morokweng Popigai Popigai Ries Sudbury Chixulub Kara Puchezh-Katunki Zapadnaya Ternovka Boltysh Ilintsky Lappajarvi Sudbury Chixulub Popigai
Forms Globules and segregations Globules and segregations Diamond Diamond Diamond Diamond Diamond Diamond Diamond Diamond Diamond Diamond Diamond Massive or granular Massive or granular Globules and segregations
References Andreoli et al., 1999 Vishnevsky, 1975 Visknevsky et al., 1975 Hough et al., 1995; Rost et al., 1978 Masaitis et al., 1997 Carlisle and Braman, 1991 Masaitis et al., 1999 Khakhaev et al., 1994 Gurov et al., 1996 Gurov et al., 1995 Gurov et al., 1995 Gurov et al., 1995 Langenhorst and Masaitis, 1996 Heymann et al., 1997a Heymann et al., 1997b Masaitis and Sysoev, 1975
60
Chapter 1: The Early Earth
Fig. 1.4-7. Platy magnetite grains, feldspar crystals and impact spherules. (a) and (b): SEM secondary electron images. (c) and (d): Photographs in visible light at 50x magnification. (a) Entire magnetite grain. RC 11-205, 0-5 cm. Scale bar is 300 l~m. (b) Surface detail of magnetite grain in a. Scale bar is 10 ~m. (c) Magnetite grains lined up on-end by a magnet beneath the slide. White circles are radiolaria and sponge spicules. V20-36, 362 cm. (d) Clear feldspar crystal (right) next to two impact spherules on a 63 I~m sieve. Spherules are left bottom and left centre. RC11-200, 59 cm. Abyssal impacts We have found extremely large quantities of platy magnetite in ejecta layers from abyssal impacts (Figs. 1.4-7a, b, c). Although magnetite can be an important component of heavy mineral sands, impact-generated magnetite is different in form. Because impact magnetite is deposited from the air, it is extremely platy, with an aspect ratio of about 15:1 (Fig. 1.4-7c). In contrast, detrital magnetite is rounded and abraded during sedimentary transport and will as a result commonly have a 1 : 1 aspect ratio. In addition to its differing morphology, detrital magnetite is concentrated in heavy mineral sands with other heavy minerals such as zircon, sphene, ilmenite, and garnet. It does not occur generally in silty or clay-rich sediments. Abyssal impact layers we have investigated are dominated by clay- and silt-sized grains. In most abyssal impact layers, magnetite grains are the coarsest component (typically 63-500 ~m in width) and there are very few quartz grains. Most of these quartz grains are very small, typically just over 40 I~m in diameter. In contrast, detrital quartz and heavy minerals found with detrital magnetites are typically sand-sized with no clay matrix.
1.4. Early Precambrian Impact Events
61
Large, clear feldspar crystals also appear in some impact layers. The feldspar crystals, typically plagioclase, are generally a few millimetres in length, dwarfing the c. 180 ~tm impact spherules (Fig. 1.4-7d). Some of the feldspar grains are zoned. The feldspar grains are very fragile and often fall apart if touched. Both the magnetite and feldspar grains we have found are often significantly larger than the impact spherules. Thus, they may be the first minerals to be recognised in thin sections of abyssal impact layers. Sedimentary layers with abundant platy magnetite and perfectly crystalline feldspar grains should be checked carefully for impact spherules and microtektites.
Stratigraphic Associations that May Be Characteristic of Impacts The science of finding impact deposits in Archaean sediments is extremely new and we have yet to find all of the possible types of deposit that might be characteristic of Archaean impact events. It is justified therefore to speculate about other sedimentary and volcanic associations that could be characteristic of impact events. If impact sediments are characteristically reduced and contain reduced compounds, distal airfall deposits may often appear as brown to black shale layers. We have also postulated that large impacts may increase the intensity of existing mantle plume volcanism (Abbott and Isley, 2002a). If an increase in melting occurred, the resulting rocks would be komatiites and basaltic komatiites (see also section 4.3). Thus, if a black shale layer is overlain by extrusive komatiitic to basaltic komatiitic rocks, the shale should be examined for impact debris. The reduction produced by impacts will also affect the degree of reduction of ironformations. Iron-formations commonly show lateral changes in oxidation state that have previously been attributed to a change from more oxidising shallow water to reducing deep water conditions (James, 1954) (see section 5.4 for full discussion). However, it is possible that this lateral change in the oxidation state actually reflects the distance of iron-formation deposition from an oceanic impact crater. Sulphide-facies iron-formation could form closest to the crater, and the oxide-facies iron-formation furthest away. If sulphide facies ironformation reflects proximity to an impact event, it is the most likely of all the types of iron-formation to contain relatively large clasts of impact breccia and concentrations of impact spherules. In addition, jadeite has been found in at least one impact layer (Odette, 1969). Jadeite and omphacite form when basalt is metamorphosed under high pressure to form eclogite. Most impacts onto continental crust may not have hit basaltic targets, but abyssal impacts will almost invariably have done so. If the impactor had a high enough energy, it would have penetrated through the pelagic sediment cover and into basaltic basement. Thus, the largest abyssal impacts could produce both jadeite and omphacite from the high-pressure breakdown of basaltic oceanic crust. If these minerals are present in any quantity, they will be quite distinct visually. Jadeite is bright green, and omphacite is pink. Consequently, there is a distinct possibility that Archaean impact layers might sometimes have prominent pink and green minerals within them. Because jadeite and omphacite are not common as detrital minerals, they could possibly serve as markers for impact horizons.
62
Chapter l: 7"he Early Earth
Summary Impact debris layers should be common in early Precambrian sedimentary rocks. We estimate that there should be at least 350 global-scale layers that range in age from 3.8-2.5 Ga. Most of these layers would be from impacts into the abyssal ocean. We have studied Phanerozoic abyssal impact ejecta in deep-sea sediment layers in order to identify their distinguishing characteristics. These layers usually contain: (1) platy magnetite, (2) microtektites, and (3) microkrystites. The most common high-pressure mineral from abyssal impacts would be impact diamond rather than shocked quartz or shocked zircon. Distal abyssal impact layers often have sharp contacts, internal laminations, dark colours, and high magnetic susceptibility. The uppermost 10 cm of unusual sedimentary layers with high magnetic susceptibility values should be examined for impact spherules, exotic minerals, and other debris that characterise Phanerozoic sediment layers resulting from abyssal impacts. A set of features within Archaean rock suites that is characteristic of impacts has been delineated. These impact characteristics range from small-scale features like impact spherules, shocked quartz, and impact diamonds to large-scale rip-up blocks and sedimentary structures from tsunami waves. We have also described characteristic mineral associations, rock types, and textural features that should be examined carefully for impact debris and impact spherules. These suggestions result from our studies of Phanerozoic impact events and in particular of Phanerozoic impact events within the ocean basins.
1.5. COMMENTARY D.R. NELSON The short-lived nuclides have provided remarkably detailed chronologies of the formation and differentiation of the planets, as was outlined in section 1.2. They indicate that the Earth's accretion, and large-scale differentiation into metallic core and silicate mantle, was largely completed within c. 20 My of the time of formation of our solar system. However, during the latter stages of the Earth's accretion and probably for at least a further 100 My, it is likely that the planet was reworked on a global scale many times, by collisions with substantial (Moon- and Mars-sized) impactors. Late-accretion collision was the dominant process determining the state of the early Earth and conditions on its surface for it's first 100 My or more, with major collision events destroying or partially resetting any evidence of earlier differentiation processes. The accretionary flux decreased rapidly during the first few hundred million years, with possible short-lived spikes in the flux (i.e., the late heavy bombardment at c. 3.85 Ga) due to the deflection of asteroids or comets from the outer Solar System into geocentric orbit (see Hartmann et al., 2001). The physical state of the Earth and the physicochemical conditions on its surface during the lengthy time interval prior to c. 3.8 Ga largely belong within the realm of speculation. Despite the almost complete absence of any firm constraints, there is little doubt The Pmcambrian Earth: Temposand Events Edited by P.G. Eriksson, W. Altermann, D.R. Nelson, W.U. Mueller and O. Catuneanu
1.5. Commentary
63
that physicochemical conditions on the Earth's surface changed more dramatically during this c. 770 My time interval than during any other time. It would, however, be an oversimplification to assume that the Earth evolved in a regular and orderly fashion in one direction towards conditions resembling those of today--from hot to cool surface temperatures, for example--during this interval. In section 1.2 it was argued that, during at least the first hundred million years following the Earth's accretion, its surface temperatures were probably so high that water resided mostly in the atmosphere as steam, rather than in the oceans. An alternative view, based on elevated g 180 values obtained for > 4.0 Ga detrital zircons from the Yilgarn craton of Western Australia, has been advanced by Wilde et al. (2001), Mojzsis et al. (2001), Peck et al. (2001) and Valley et al. (2002). These authors argued that high g180 values determined for some of these ancient zircons indicated that they crystallised from melts derived from high-180/160 sedimentary or low-temperature hydrothermally-altered source rocks. Based on one elevated ~ 180 value (7.4 + 0.7%0, 20" uncertainty) obtained from grain W74/2-36, from which the oldest 2~176 date of 4404 + 8 Ma (20" uncertainty) was also obtained, Wilde et al. (2001), Peck et al. (2001) and Valley et al. (2002) surmised that the Earth must have been cool enough for liquid water to exist on the Earth's surface by c. 4.4 Ga. Some inconsistencies in these arguments were pointed out in section 1.2; it was argued that the high 6180 values of these ancient zircons were of secondary origin and therefore unrelated to the 180/160 characteristics of the melts from which the zircons crystallised. What is currently known of the influence of major impact events on the Earth during the Precambrian was summarised in section 1.3. Although progress has been rapid, section 1.3 reveals that this field of investigation is in its infancy and there is still much to learn. There are no known terrestrial impact structures older than c. 2.0 Ga, so any future assessment of the direct influence of extraterrestrial impacts on the Earth's early evolution and on physicochemical conditions on its surface will be largely dependent on the recognition and examination of impact-related horizons within the Archaean sedimentary rock record. Since the pioneering study of Lowe and Byerly (1986), comparatively few impactrelated sedimentary layers from within Archaean to early Palaeoproterozoic successions have been identified (see Table 1.3-1). As pointed out in Section 1.3, the earliest interpretation of spherules as resulting from meteorite impacts was initially regarded skeptically, although this is now more widely accepted. Such acceptance has arisen largely because of the improved characterisation of the diagnostic features of impact-related sedimentary horizons. Section 1.4 outlined the diagnostic sedimentary, mineralogical and geophysical features of distal impact layers and proposed an improved strategy for their recognition. Armed with this new set of diagnostic criteria, it is hoped that a better appreciation of the important but commonly ignored role of meteorite impacts on the Earth's early geological development can be attained.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
The Precambrian Earth: Tempos and Events Edited by P.G. Eriksson, W. Altermann, D.R. Nelson, W.U. Mueller and O. Catuneanu Developments in Precambrian Geology; Vol. 12 (K.C. Condie, Series Editor) Published by Elsevier B.V.
65
Chapter 2
GENERATION
2.1.
OF CONTINENTAL
CRUST
INTRODUCTION
W.U. MUELLER AND D.R. NELSON As with many aspects of tracing and documenting Earth's evolution, controversy arises, and the generation of the continental crust is no exception. Implicit in the formation of continental crust, is the development and formation of granite-greenstone terranes because they generally constitute nuclei of most modern-day continents. Many studies favour an episodic increase in the volume of continental crust from the Early Archaean (Taylor and McLennan, 1985; McLennan and Taylor, 1991; Condie, 1998), whereas Armstrong (1991) advocated that most of the continental crust had been generated prior to 3 Ga, but was lost from the geological record due to recycling into the mantle (section 2.8). The latter point had not gone unnoticed by Dimroth (1985), who demonstrated from mass balance calculations that magma emplacement into Archaean and modern arcs exceeded the growth of continental crust by a factor of two, therefore implying that significant recycling of continental crust back into the mantle must have occurred. Evidently, the results from geochemical studies of sedimentary rocks and from the stratigraphy of Precambrian volcano-sedimentary sequences of preserved but fragmented terranes, still demand a verdict, yet new geochemical studies of a 3.4 Ga norite dyke from the Isua area shows that crustal recycling was a viable process (Nielsen et al., 2002). By what process or processes are large amounts of continental crust produced? This contentious issue revolves around the concepts of mantle plumes (sections 3.2 and 3.3) and subduction. Most of the focus of this chapter deals with the mechanisms or large-scale geodynamic structures that may have contributed to the formation of continental crust during the Archaean. Evidently, depending on the study area, different models are favoured. Mantle plumes may dismember continents efficiently but can also accrete material to the crust by producing volcanic flood provinces. In contrast, horizontal plate movements related to subduction, which include the various phases of the Wilson cycle, generate most of the volcano-plutonic material at active margins and mid-oceanic rifts (Fisher and Schmincke, 1984). Subsequent subduction-related tectonics may accrete newly formed crust onto continental margins, but was this the prevalent mechanism during the Precambrian and especially during the Archaean? Superplume events, advocated to have had major influence on pre-1.9 Ga Earth evolutionary events (Condie, 1998, 2002; Nelson, 1998a), primarily record continental breakup and can be monitored partially by using major magmatic episodes (Nelson, 1998a), black shales (Condie et al., 2001) and banded iron-formations (Isley and Abbott, 1999)
Chapter 2: Generation o f Continental Crust
66
as tracers (Condie, section 3.2). Major upwelling due to plumes contains the notion of large-scale diapirism, yet in many greenstone belts, unequivocal structural evidence for all-encompassing vertical tectonics controlling the belt's evolution remains elusive. A revival of vertical-dominated tectonics, a modification of the "sagduction theme", has been considered for parts of the Pilbara (see section 2.6) and Indian cratons (Chardon et al., 1998). In contrast, the Late Archaean cratons of North America show a new wrinkle with the coeval evolution of plume-generated komatiites and subduction-related arc volcanism. Evidence for plume-arc interaction occurring over a protracted period of c. 30 My is best recorded in the Abitibi greenstone belt (Dostal and Mueller, 1997; Mueller and Mortensen, 2002; Daigneault et al., section 2.4), and Polat and Kerrich (2001) support the concept of subduction-accretion complexes with intervening komatiite plume volcanism for the southern Superior Province. The Yilgarn craton reveals a similar history. In the eastern part of the Yilgarn craton, an elongate rift formed at c. 2705 Ma, and was filled rapidly with komatiitic and basaltic lavas. By c. 2670 Ma, subduction and continent-continent collision had closed the rift and initiated regional deformation. This was followed by widespread granitoid plutonism and metamorphism. Thus, the regional deformation episodes preserved in many Late Archaean granite-greenstone terranes were apparently not due to the ascent and lateral movement of the granitic plutons resulting from melting of older crust by a mantle plume, as argued by Campbell and Hill (1998) for greenstones of the Yilgarn craton, but reflect tectonic plate interactions. Evidently, geodynamic plume-arc events played an important role in the Late Archaean. This does not, however, preclude the possibility that diapirism played a more significant role in the formation of granite-greenstone terranes during the Early Archaean, and that its significance may have diminished with time. The contributions in this chapter display the diversity of opinions on crust formation, granite-greenstone belt evolution and its possible controls.
2.2.
ISUA ENIGMAS: ILLUSIVE TECTONIC, SEDIMENTARY, VOLCANIC AND ORGANIC FEATURES OF THE > 3.7 GA ISUA GREENSTONE BELT, SOUTHWEST GREENLAND
J.S. MYERS Introduction
The Isua greenstone belt is located within a part of the Archaean gneiss complex of West Greenland (Bridgwater et al., 1976) that contains remnants of early Archaean tonalitic gneisses (Fig. 2.2-1). Some rocks within the belt are considered to provide evidence for the existence of life before 3.7 Ga (Rosing, 1999; Pflug, 2001). Early interpretations of the geology concluded that "the sequence exposed in the Isua greenstone belt is essentially of sedimentary origin" (Dimroth, 1982) and that it contains substantial amounts of shallow marine carbonates, clastic quartzites and felsic volcanic rocks (Nutman et al., 1984). More recently it was found that the carbonates are metasomatic in origin (Rose et al., 1996; The Precambrian Earth: 7k'mposand Events Edited by P.G. Eriksson, W. Altennann, D.R. Nelson, W.U. Mueller and O. Catuneanu
2.2. Isua Greenstone Belt: Features
67
Fig. 2.2-1. Simplified map of the Godthfibst]ord region of southwest Greenland showing the main geological units and the location of the Isua greenstone belt. Numbers indicate ages in Ga. Geology from Allaart (1982) and Myers and Crowley (2000).
Rosing et al., 1996), "felsic volcanics" reflect mylonitised tonalite and altered pillow lava, and the chloritic and amphibolitic schists that make up most of the greenstone belt were derived from basaltic pillow lava (Myers, 2001 a). These schists were isoclinally folded and refolded, tectonically interleaved, refolded into open folds, and then cut by dolerite dykes at c. 3.5 Ga. Nevertheless, several recent studies continue to underestimate substantially the amount of deformation and distortion. Primary features continue to be described that are in stark contrast to detailed recent structural and lithological re-interpretations of the relevant outcrops (e.g., Myers, 2001b for a summary). Recently described examples of
68
Chapter 2: Generation of Continental Crust
Fig. 2.2-2. (a) Basaltic dyke, interpreted as pillow lava, and dyke contact interpreted as a thrust by Komiya et al. (1999), located on Fig. 2.2-2b. (b) Geological map of the northeastern part of the Isua greenstone belt and cross-section, from Komiya et al. (1999, their Fig. 9a).
2.2. Isua Greenstone Belt: Features
69
Fig. 2.2-2 (continued). (c) Geological map of the same area as Fig. 2.2-2b, by Myers (1998, unpublished). these controversial interpretations are briefly discussed below in the light of the significant new field evidence.
1998-2002 Interpretations Reconsidered Intra-oceanic accretionary complex Based on repetition of inferred oceanic plate stratigraphy, the northeast part of the Isua belt was interpreted by Komiya et al. (1999) as an intra-oceanic accretionary complex. Unfortunately, the origin of many rocks that are key elements of the model were misinterpreted and the effects of multiple episodes of intense deformation were not recognised. Intensely deformed rocks that were derived from basaltic pillow lava were misinterpreted as hyaloclastite and mafic turbidite. Some dykes were mistakenly interpreted as pillow lava and the sharp boundaries of some dykes were inferred to be thrusts (Fig. 2.2-2).
Pillow breccia A small outcrop of basaltic pillow fragments enclosed by quartz (located at 1 on Fig. 2.2-3) was interpreted as a well-preserved pillow breccia by Appel et al. (1998) and Fedo et al. (2001 ). The sides of the outcrop indicate substantial extension of the fragments and quartzfilled vesicles into rods. Fluid inclusions in unstrained quartz from the vesicles were interpreted as remnants of early Archaean seawater (Appel et al., 2001). However, the quartz in these vesicles must have recrystallised during and after repeated episodes of deformation. Therefore the fluid inclusions cannot be primary undeformed features and are probably of metamorphic or metasomatic origin. The inferred breccia may also be of tectonic origin. The outcrop does not appear to be located in a zone of low strain. On the contrary, it is situated adjacent to a zone of
70
Chapter 2: Generation of Continental Crust
Fig. 2.2-3. New simplified geological map of a northeastern part of the Isua greenstone belt showing the locations of deformed pillow breccia (1) and polymictic conglomerate (2) in relation to fault zones of chloritic schist. intense late Archaean or early Proterozoic ductile deformation. The fragments are of early Archaean pillow lava, but the brecciation may be a result of deformation that post-dates the episodes of intense early Archaean ductile deformation.
Polymictic conglomerate Deformed fragments of quartz, metachert and amphibolitic schist enclosed in chloritic schist (located at 2 on Fig. 2.2-3) were interpreted as deformed polymictic conglomerate
2.2. Isua Greenstone Belt: Features
71
Fig. 2.2-4. New simplified geological map of a northeastern part of the Isua greenstone belt showing the extent of a narrow belt of complex schist and the location within it, at point denoted as 3, of "graded turbidite", shown in photograph. (Appel et al., 1998; Fedo, 2000; Fedo et al., 2001). This rock lies within a Late Archaean or Early Proterozoic shear zone where this zone crosses a unit of metachert and amphibolitic schist derived from pillow lava. Therefore the polymictic conglomerate appears to be tectonic in origin. Graded turbidite A complex layer of heterogeneous schist, interpreted as metasedimentary rocks (Nutman et al., 1984; Nutman, 1986; Rosing et al., 1996), lies within amphibolitic schist mainly derived from pillow lava. At one locality (3 on Fig. 2.2-4) the layer contains two thin layers of quartz-mica-chlorite-graphite schist that appear to have well preserved depositional grading (Fig. 2.2-4), and they have been interpreted as graded turbidite (Nutman et al.,
72
Chapter 2: Generation of Continental Crust
Fig. 2.2-5. Quartz mylonite, previotsly interpreted as clastic quartzite, along an early Archaean fault zone in the southeastern part of the Isua greenstone belt.
1984" Nutman, 1986" Fedo et al., 2001). 13C-depleted carbon in graphite was interpreted as being of biogenic origin by Rosing (1999) and the best oldest evidence of life. Recent mapping (Fig. 2.2-4) indicates that this composite layer is not isoclinally folded and refolded like most nearby layers of chert, BIF and pillow lava. It appears to be an early Archaean fault zone associated with tectonic interleaving after episodes of isoclinal folding and refolding. The layers interpreted as graded turbidite contain rootless isoclinal folds and mylonitic fabrics (Constantinou, 2001) and are highly deformed rocks. The apparent sedimentary structures are thus misinterpretations. Clastic quartzite
A number of thin layers of quartzite were interpreted as deposits of clastic sedimentary origin (Nutman, 1986; Rosing et al., 1996; Fedo, 2000; Fedo et al., 2001). Recent mapping indicates that most of these layers are quartz mylonites in repeatedly deformed fault zones (Fig. 2.2-5). The quartz and quartz-fuchsite rocks probably originated as vein quartz. These fault zones post-date isoclinal folding and refolding of the greenstones and were related to tectonic disruption and intercalation of rock units that predated intrusion of c. 3.5 Ga dykes.
2.2. Isua Greenstone Belt: Features
73
Fig. 2.2-6. Mylonite derived from early Archaean tonalitic gneiss and amphibolite, located at position 4 on Fig. 2.2-4.
Microfossils Microfossils called Isuasphaera isua were described (Pflug, 1978; Pflug and JaeschkeBoyer, 1979) from the greenstone belt, as well as morphologies resembling capsules of iron bacteria called Appelella ferrifera (Robbins, 1987). Although substantially discredited by Bridgwater et al. (1981) and Roedder (1981) (see also section 6.2), these spherical siliceous microstructures were recently reiterated as "cellular structures of the Huroniospora-type (cyanobacteria)" by Pflug (2001). The samples came from metachert in a thick metachert and BIF unit at the northeastern end of the greenstone belt. The rocks were repeatedly deformed during the Early Archaean and then enormously constricted and rodded. Any primary spherical objects must now be extremely elongated, and so these circular microstructures cannot be original. They have recently been interpreted by Appel et al. (2003) as products of pre-Quaternary weathering.
c. 3.64 Ga mylonites Mylonites (Fig. 2.2-6; located at 4 on Fig. 2.2-4) in the northwest part of the greenstone belt were interpreted by Hanmer and Greene (2002) and Hanmer et al. (2002) as a c. 3.64 Ga thrust-nappe stack, and the oldest known evidence of"a modern structural regime .... similar to those of modern mountain belts". More detailed mapping indicates that the mylonites
Chapter 2: Generation of Continental Crust
74
post-date the c. 3.5 Ga dykes. These dykes cut across the adjacent greenstones but are cut by the mylonite stack and are transposed into the mylonitic fabric. Conclusions
New field investigations indicate that what were thought to be the best preserved examples of sedimentary, volcanic and biogenic structures, and an intra-oceanic accretionary complex, may not be of primary, Early Archaean origin. The Isua greenstone belt contains schists and mylonites derived from pillow lava and a small amount of chert and BIE All primary structures and textures are distorted. Understanding the original nature and significance of the components of the greenstone belt requires an understanding of the effects of deformation. In greenstone belts, as in gneiss terranes, superficial simplicity may be caused by multiple episodes of intense ductile deformation (see also section 7.4).
2.3.
GEOCHEMICAL DIVERSITY IN VOLCANIC ROCKS OF THE > 3.7 GA ISUA GREENSTONE BELT, SOUTHERN WEST GREENLAND: IMPLICATIONS FOR MANTLE COMPOSITION AND GEODYNAMIC PROCESSES
A. POLAT, A.W. HOFMANN AND EW.U. APPEL Introduction
Geochemical signatures in Archaean mafic to ultramafic volcanic rocks can provide important constraints on the thermal and chemical characteristics of their mantle source regions (Sun, 1984; Xie et al., 1993; Arndt, 1994; Condie, 1994a; McCulloch and Bennett, 1998; Jochum et al., 2001). Recent geochemical investigations of Archaean greenstone belts have documented a great compositional diversity in volcanic rocks, reflecting diverse source characteristics, petrogenetic processes, and tectonic settings in the early Earth (Arndt, 1994; Polat and Kerrich, 2001b; Wyman et al., 2002a; Polat et al., 2002). However, preservation of these mantle-derived mafic to ultramafic volcanic rocks diminishes from the Neo- to the Palaeoarchaean. They become extremely rare in terranes older than 3.6 Ga (Nutman et al., 1996). Preservation of primary volcanic features, including pillow basalts (see, however, section 2.2), in the oldest known, well-exposed > 3.7 Ga Isua greenstone belt, West Greenland (Fig. 2.3-1), provides an excellent opportunity to study the geochemical characteristics of Palaeoarchaean mafic to ultramafic volcanic rocks. In this study, for descriptive purposes, the western part of the Isua greenstone belt has been divided informally into three litho-tectonic sequences: outer arc, central arc, and inner arc (Fig. 2.3-2). In this contribution, we compare the geochemical characteristics of metamorphosed pillow basalts and associated flows from these three litho-tectonic sequences. Samples of the inner and outer arcs are from only the western part of the belt, and samples of the central arc are from both eastern and western segments of the belt. The objective of this study is to evaluate the significance of the geochemistry of the Isua volcanic rocks in The Precambrian Earth: Tempos and Events Fxtited by P.G. Eriksson, W. Aitcrmann, D.R. Nelson, W.U. Mueller and O. Catuneanu
2.3. Isua Greenstone Belt: Geodynamic Processes
75
Fig. 2.3-1. Simplified geological map of the Godthfibsfjord region, adapted from Myers and Crowley (2000).
76
Chapter 2: Generation of Continental Crust
Fig. 2.3-2. Simplified geological map of the western part of the Isua greenstone belt (IGB), showing the location of samples, modified from Nutman (1986). The western part of the belt has been informally divided into three lithotectonic sequences: outer arc, central arc, and inner arc. The Isua greenstone belt has been remapped by Myers (2001a, b); however, a complete map of the belt has not been published yet. Inset shows the location of the Isua greenstone belt in southern Greenland.
terms of Palaeoarchaean petrogenetic processes, mantle source characteristics, and geodynamic setting. According to Nutman et al. (2002), the outer arc sequence is composed of c. 3800 Ma volcano-sedimentary rocks, whereas the central arc sequence is characterised by c. 3700 Ma supracrustal rocks. These dates were obtained from felsic rocks, the origin of which (felsic volcanic versus felsic intrusive) is a matter of debate (Myers, 2002; see also section 2.2); therefore, they may not be directly relevant to the formation of volcanic rocks discussed in this study. No age has been assigned to the inner arc sequence. Geochemical signatures in many Neoarchaean volcanic suites have been attributed to Phanerozoic-style volcanism, such as mantle plume, island arc, mid-ocean ridge, and back-arc volcanisms (Arndt et al., 1994; Condie, 1994b; Dostal and Mueller, 1997; Cousens, 2000; Corcoran and Dostal, 2001). Accordingly, in this study we assumed, in a broad sense, that the geochemical characteristics of the > 3.7 Ga Isua volcanic rocks have similar geodynamic significance to their Phanerozoic counterparts. This reasoning is based on the assumption
2.3. Isua Greenstone Belt: Geodynamic Processes
77
that certain groups of elements (e.g., HFSE, REE) will behave consistently for a particular petrogenetic process throughout the Earth's history.
Geological setting The 3.7-3.8 Ga Isua greenstone belt is located in the Godth~,bsfjord region of southern West Greenland (Fig. 2.3-1; Nutman, 1986). The region contains extensive, well-exposed Palaeo- to Neoarchaean intrusive and supracrustal rocks (Nutman et al., 1996; Myers and Crowley, 2000). The Palaeoarchaean intrusive rocks are dominated by the 3.65-3.80 Ga Itsaq Gneiss Complex derived mainly from tonalities and granodiorites (Fig. 2.3-1). In addition, there are numerous Palaeoarchaean ultramafic intrusions within the Itsaq Gneiss Complex (Friend et al., 2002). Most of the Palaeoarchaean rocks were intensively deformed and metamorphosed during a Neoarchaean tectonothermal event, resulting in widespread modification of Palaeoarchaean structures and stratigraphic relationships. Palaeoarchaean volcanic and sedimentary rocks are best exposed in the Isua greenstone belt in the Isukasia area (Fig. 2.3-2). On the basis of U-Pb ages and field relationships, Nutman et al. (2002) and Hanmer et al. (2002) proposed modem plate tectonic-like models for the Palaeoarchaean evolution of the Isukasia area. Friend et al. (1996) showed that the Godth~bsfjord region is composed of Palaeo- to Neoarchaean terranes assembled at about 2720 Ma (Fig. 2.3-1). These terranes are: (1) the Akulleq terrane composed of the Palaeoto Mesoarchaean (3800-3600 Ma) granitoids and supracrustal rocks within the Itsaq Gneiss Complex, and Neoarchaean supracrustal and intrusive rocks; (2) the Akia terrane consisting mainly of Mesoarchaean (3220-3000 Ma) orthogneisses; and (3) the Tasiusarsuaq terrane including Neoarchaean (2920-2800 Ma) granitoids and older supracrustal rocks (Fig. 2.3-1). Neoarchaean intrusive rocks include variably deformed and metamorphosed granites, tonalities, gabbros, and anorthosites. The Ivis~.rtoq greenstone belt contains the largest, well-preserved Neoarchaean volcanic and sedimentary rocks in the region (Fig. 2.3-1). The Isua greenstone belt is about 35 km long and up to 4 km wide. The belt contains the oldest known, relatively well-preserved metavolcanic and metasedimentary rocks on Earth (Rosing et al., 1996; Appel et al., 1998; Fedo, 2000; Myers, 2001a, b). Recent detailed mapping suggests that the belt is composed of several fault-bounded litho-tectonic sequences, including basaltic and high-MgO basaltic pillow lavas, ultramafic intrusions, chert-banded iron-formation (BIF), and a minor component of clastic sedimentary rocks (Myers, 200 l a, b). The thickness and lithological characteristics of these supracrustal sequences vary along the belt. All lithologic units are variably metamorphosed, metasomatised, and deformed (Myers, 2001b). Geochemical studies suggest that the belt experienced several tectonothermal events in the Palaeoarchaean, Neoarchaean, and Proterozoic (Blichert-Toft and Frei, 2001 ; Frei et al., 2002; Polat et al., 2003), resulting in widespread modification of chemical and isotopic compositions. The most pervasive metasomatism occurs in the outer arc sequence of the belt (Fig. 2.3-2; Nutman, 1986; Rose et al., 1996). According to Rose et al. (1996), this calc-silicate-carbonate metasomatism is closely associated with early Archaean ultramafic intrusions.
78
Chapter 2: Generation of Continental Crust
On the basis of recent detailed mapping, Myers (2001 b) has recognised low- to highstrain litho-tectonic domains in the belt. This study also revealed a complex history of polyphase deformation and high grade metamorphism. The domains of least strain contain well-preserved volcanic and sedimentary features, including pillow basalts, pillow breccia, heterogeneous volcanic breccia, and polymictic conglomerates (Komiya et al., 1999; Myers, 2001b; Appel et al., 2001; see also section 2.2). The variably deformed pillow basalts are intercalated with ultramafic units. In contrast, primary volcanic and sedimentary structures in the highly strained domains are intensely deformed and metasomatised. The original stratigraphic relations between mafic (pillow basalts) and ultramafic units have been disrupted and complicated throughout the belt. Most supracrustal units have been recrystallised under upper greenschist to amphibolite facies metamorphism. Mafic dykes cut the early schistosity and lineation (Appel et al., 1998). There are a number of lines of evidence suggesting an intra-oceanic origin for the Isua volcanic rocks. These are: (1) stratigraphic association of chert layers, banded ironformations, and pillow basalts (Rosing et al., 1996; Myers, 2001b); (2) the absence of xenocrystic zircons in mafic-ultramafic volcanic rocks; (3) granitoids and felsic dykes in the region are younger than the volcanic rocks of the belt (Moorbath et al., 1977; Nutman and Bridgwater, 1986); and (4) conglomerates contain no continental detritus (e.g., granitic and gneissic pebbles; Fedo, 2000). Mineralogically, volcanic rocks from the central arc sequence are amphibolites, consisting predominantly of tremolite-actinolite-hornblende-chlorite-talc schist (Rosing et al., 1996; Gruau et al., 1996; Myers, 2001b). Myers (2001b) showed that these amphibolites were derived from pillow basalts. Volcanic rocks from the outer arc sequence are composed mainly of hornblende-garnet-biotite-dolomite-ankerite schist and amphibolites, whereas volcanic rocks of the inner arc sequence consist primarily of amphibolites and chlorite-talc schist (Rose et al., 1996; Gruau et al., 1996; Myers, 2001 b). Like those in the central arc sequence, amphibolites and chlorite schists in the outer and inner arc sequences were derived from pillow basalts (Myers, 2001b). Given the fact that all supracrustal rocks in the Isua greenstone belt have been metamorphosed, the prefix "meta" will be taken as implicit throughout the remainder of this section. Geochemistry Central tectonic unit
Detailed major and trace element characteristics of volcanic rocks of the central lithotectonic sequence have been discussed in Polat et al. (2002). Accordingly, only a summary of these compositional features is presented here (Table 2.3-1). The least altered volcanic rocks are characterised by high Mg-numbers (0.60-0.80), MgO (7-16 wt.%), A1203 (14-20 wt.%), Ni (60-645 ppm), and Cr (60-1920 ppm) contents, but low TiO2 (0.20-0.40 wt.%), Zr (12-30 ppm), Y (6-14 ppm), and rare earth elements (REE) concentrations (Table 2.3-1). AlzO3/TiO2 (45-94) ratios are super-chondritic whereas Zr/Y (1.3-2.5) ratios tend to be sub-chondritic. Collectively, these compositional features represent a coherent mafic to ultramafic suite.
Table 2.3-1. Summary of the ranges of the significant compositional and element ratios for mafic to ultramafic volcanic rocks in the > 3.7 Ga Isua greenstone belt*
Si02 (wt.%) MgO Ti02 A1203 Fe203 Mg# Cr ( P P ~ ) Ni Zr Nb Th La Y Yb (La/Sm)cn (LdYb)cn (Gd/Yb)cn ZrN (ZrISm),, A1203/Ti02 (NbILa),, (ThILa),, (Nb/Th)p
Outer arc sequence least altered 48-53 8.9-19.6 0.50-1.05 6.5-1 1.9 12.0-17.7 0.58-0.77 1 94-29 16 88-952 34-7 1 1.46-2.46 0.25-2.12 1.80-3.95 12.3-21.7 1.042.01 0.7-1.1 1.2-2.1 1.4- 1.7 2.6-3.3 0.7-1.1 1 1.3-1 3.5 0.37-0.82 0.78-5.81 0.14-0.80
Outer arc sequence variably altered 45-6 1 4.8-19.4 0.4W.84 5.9-15.8 9.4-15.4 0.440.78 144-3 170 42-1 157 29-64 0.75-2.16 0.1 1-2.24 0.82-9.77 9.421.2 0.88-2.02 0.41.7 0.40-4.3 0.7-1.9 2.M.6 0.67-1.6 11.4-27.8 0.17-0.97 0.36-6.88 0.12-1.70
Central arc sequence least altered 47-54 6.8-16.1 0.17-0.40 13.9-20.2 8.2-1 1.9 0.61-0.77 60- 1920 60-645 12.1-29.5 0.13-0.80 0.04-0.29 0.31-1.83 6.0-13.7 0.94-1.84 0.56-1.39 0.16-0.79 0.2W.61 1.3-2.5 1.1-1.6 45-94 0.23-0.77 0.57-2.07 0.3 1-0.76
Central arc sequence variably altered 40-54 11.7-24.5 0.15-0.26 12.7-19.2 7.9-14.5 0.77-0.85 277-3452 163-863 7.5-19.1 0.02-0.35 0.01-0.06 0.1W . 6 2 5.4-1 1.O 0.84-1.86 0.30-1.0 0.10-0.35 0.38-0.47 1.2-2.2 1.1-2.0 55-80 0.08-2.57 0.28-1.29 0.1 1-3.34
Inner arc sequence least altered 48-53 4.5-21 .O 0.52-1.14 7.9-14.1 12.2-15.0 0.40.77 33-2268 3 1-826 46-77 1.21-2.75 0.40.79 2.44.3 10.9-27.6 1.1-2.7 1.0-1.7 1.3-3.0 1.4-1.9 2.8-5.1 0.8-1.4 12.5-15.0 0.29-0.60 0.8-1.9 0.22-0.57
Inner arc sequence variably altered 51-53 4.3-21.9 0.32-1.18 5.5-14.6 11.3-15.0 0.39-0.81 3 1-2040 31-1 100 25-8 1 0.67-2.83 0.27-0.62 0.4W.52 8.9-27.5 0.90-2.7 0.3-0.8 0.3-1.2 1.1-1.4 2.8-3.1 0.91-1.32 12.5-16.9 0.6-1.7 1.O-5.6 0.3-0.6
*Data for the central arc sequence from Polat et al. (2002). and data for the inner and outer arc sequences from unpublished data of Polat and Hofmann.
Q
2
2
S
",
B
9 ?
z
p 2. "u 3 Z
80
Chapter 2: Generation of Continental Crust
Chondrite-normalised REE patterns are concave upwards (La/Smcn = 0.56-1.39; Gd/Ybcn = 0.26-0.61). On primitive mantle-normalised trace element diagrams, they are characterised by relative depletion of Nb (Nb/Thpm ----0.31-0.76; Nb/Lapm -- 0.23-0.77), but enrichment of Zr (Zr/Smpm -- 1.1-1.6), relative to neighbouring REE (Table 2.3-1). Inner and outer arcs
Volcanic rocks of the inner and outer arc sequences are chemically similar (Table 2.3-1); therefore, their geochemical features are described together. These are compositionally variable at 4-22 wt.% MgO, 31-1157 ppm Ni, 31-3170 ppm Cr, and Mg-numbers of 0.39 to 0.81 (Table 2.3-1). These compositional features are consistent with mafic to ultramafic compositions. They possess variable SiO2 (45-61 wt.%), TiO2 (0.3-1.2 wt.%), and A1203 (6-16 wt.%) abundances (Table 2.3-1). AlzO3/TiO2 (11-28) ratios range from sub-chondritic to super-chondritic, and Zr/Y (2.0-5.1) ratios are mostly super-chondritic. In addition, they have the following geochemical features: (1) depleted to enriched REE ((La/Sm)cn = 0.3-1.7; (Gd/Yb)cn = 0.7-1.9)patterns; (2) low (Nb/Th)pm (0.12-1.70)and (Nb/La)pm (0.17-1.7) ratios, generating negative Nb anomalies (Table 2.3-1). Discussion Element mobility
Element mobility is a major problem for studying the > 3.7 Ga Isua volcanic rocks, which have undergone sea floor hydrothermal alteration, greenschist to amphibolite facies metamorphism, metasomatism, and polyphase deformation destroying primary textures and minerals (Gruau et al., 1996; Frei and Rosing, 2001; Frei et al., 2002; Polat et al., 2002; 2003). It is important therefore to understand and take account of the effects of alteration on the geochemistry of the Isua volcanic rocks before considering any petrogenetic interpretation. Accordingly, in this section we briefly discuss the possible effects of alteration on the geochemical composition of the Isua volcanic rocks in an attempt to assess the least altered samples for near-primary geochemical signatures, particularly those for HFSE and REE. The effects of metamorphic alteration on the central arc volcanic sequence were evaluated by Polat et al. (2002). Therefore, in this contribution we evaluate the effects of alteration on the volcanic rocks from only the inner and outer arc sequences. Following Polat et al. (2002), several criteria were adopted to assess the effects of alteration on the inner and outer arc volcanic rocks. These are: (1) the magnitude of correlations with the least mobile element, Zr, on binary diagrams; elements having a correlation coefficient (R) < 0.75 were considered as mobile; (2) the presence of significant Ce anomalies on primitive mantle-normalised diagrams; samples possessing Ce/Ce* (asterisk denotes the concentration interpolated from that of adjacent elements on the primitive mantlenormalised diagram) ratios greater than 1.1 and less than 0.9 were designated as variably altered; and (3) the existence of significant carbonate or silica alteration ( > 2 wt.%). Given the fact that all Isua volcanic rocks have been altered to some extent, samples were divided into least altered and variably altered groups (Table 2.3-1). Only the former group was used for petrogenetic interpretation.
2.3. Isua Greenstone Belt: Geodynamic Processes
81
Fig. 2.3-3. (a-d) Zr versus selected element variation diagrams to highlight the effects of alteration on Si, Na, K, and Sr. Most altered samples are located in the outer arc sequence, where carbonate alteration is the most pervasive. (e-h) Zr versus selected element variation diagrams to highlight the limited effects of alteration on Ti, Nb, and REE. Strong correlations indicate that these elements were not disturbed significantly by post-emplacement alteration.
Chapter 2: Generation of Continental Crust
82
Outer arc sequence 100
(a) O 462901 Minor alteration 9462915 Minor alteration [] 462912 Strong alteration <> 462916 Strong alteration
3E 13.. r
10
o iv,
1 II
I I I I I 1 1 1 I I I I I I 1 I I Th Nb La Ce Pr Nd Zr Sm Eu Ti Gd Tb Dy Y Ho Er Trn Yb
Inner arc sequence 100 (b)
O 2000-27 Minor alteration 9 2000-15 Strong alteration
3E a.
"~ 10 o
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
Th Nb La Ce Pr Nd Zr Sm Eu Ti Gd Tb Dy Y Ho Er Tm Yb
Fig. 2.3-4. Primitive mantle-normalised trace element diagrams of variably altered samples to highlight the effects post-emplacement carbonate alteration. Primitive mantle normalisation values from Hofmann (1988). The mobility of Si, Na, Ca, Rb, K, Sr, Ba, Ca, Fe, P, and Pb in volcanic rocks of the central litho-tectonic sequence is well documented (Polat et al., 2002). There are extreme variations in these elements in the inner and outer arc volcanic rocks (e.g., Rb = 0.2-98 ppm; Ba = 1..1-258 ppm; K20 = 0.04-3.92 wt.%; Na20 = 0.01-4.25 wt.%), which do not correlate well with Zr abundance, and show very weak correlations with MgO content (Fig. 2.3-3). This variability is reflected in significant enrichments or depletions on primitive mantle-normalised diagrams (not shown). Collectively, the large concentration
2.3. lsua Greenstone Belt: Geodynamic Processes
83
range of these elements at a given Zr value signifies loss or gain of these elements during post-emplacement hydrothermal alteration, metamorphism, or metasomatism. Accordingly, these elements designated as mobile were screened out, and were not used for petrogenetic interpretation. In contrast to these mobile elements, a number of studies (Arndt, 1994; and references therein) have found that in many Archaean volcanic rocks the effects of alteration on REE, high field-strength elements (HFSE), A1, Cr, Ni are minor. Thus, these latter elements are widely considered to be immobile. However, some studies suggest that these elements can also be mobile during intense carbonate or silica alteration, and metamorphism, resulting in non-coherent patterns on normalised trace element diagrams (Kerrich and Fryer, 1979; Arndt et al., 1989; Gruau et al., 1992; Lahaye et al., 1995). Therefore, we have assessed the effect of alteration on these elements in the severely altered Isua volcanic rocks. On diagrams of Zr versus Nb, Nd, Sm, Ti, Y, and heavy rare earth elements (HREE) most samples display systematic correlations, consistent with the relatively low mobility of these elements (Fig. 2.3-3). In contrast, there is a large scatter of Th and light rare earth elements (LREE) (La, Ce), particularly in the outer arc volcanic rocks, consistent with mobility of these elements during post-magmatic alteration processes. The effects of carbonate alteration on the mobility of these elements are well illustrated by the primitive mantle-normalised diagrams where samples with minor (< 2 wt.%) carbonate alteration have coherent REE and HFSE (Nb, Zr, Ti, Y) patterns, consistent with the limited mobility of these elements (Fig. 2.3-4). However, samples with moderate to strong (2-20 wt.%) carbonate alteration display depleted LREE patterns and minor positive Zr and Nb anomalies, suggesting the loss of LREE, and that Nb and Zr were less mobile than REE (Fig. 2.3-4). The behaviour of Th is rather variable. Frei et al. (2002) suggested that the Isua volcanic rocks gained LREE during post-magmatic alteration, but the results of this study indicate that LREE were lost during intense carbonate alteration. The loss of LREE is further endorsed by Sm-Nd isotope systematics of altered samples (Albar~de et al., 2000; Polat et al., 2003). However, our study supports the conclusions of Frei et al. (2002) on the gain of Th and LILE (large-ion lithophile elements; K, Rb, Ba, etc.) in many samples of the outer arc volcanic sequences. Samples which gained significant amounts of silica (4-10 wt.%) in the outer arc sequence are enriched in A1203 and Na20, but depleted in CaO and LREE. It appears that variably altered samples are closely associated with high-strain domains, whereas the least altered samples tend to occur in low-strain domains (Myers, 2001b). In addition, the variably altered samples tend to occur in the vicinity of ultramafic intrusions, which may have played an important role in the generation of some metasomatic fluids in the outer arc volcanic sequence (Rose et al., 1996; Rosing et al., 1996). Crustal contamination Negative Nb and Ti anomalies in the Isua volcanic rocks could possibly reflect some crustal contamination (Fig. 2.3-5). However, SiO2, MgO, Ni, Cr, Co, Th, Ti, and LREE contents in these rocks do not correlate with the magnitude of negative Nb and Ti anomalies. High AlzO3/TiO2 (45-90) ratios and positive Zr (Zr/Zr* = 1.1-2.1) anomalies in the volcanic rocks of the central tectonic sequence could not have resulted from crustal contamination,
84
Chapter 2: Generation of Continental Crust
given that the continental crust has lower values (18 and 0.94, respectively) of these ratios. There is no evidence from the published initial Sr, Nd, Hf, and Pb isotope composition for any crustal contamination by significantly older rocks in the Isua greenstone belt (see Albar~de et al., 2000; Kamber et al., 2001). In conclusion, negative Nb and Ti anomalies and other geochemical features of the least altered Isua volcanic rocks appear to reflect the mantle source characteristics and petrogenetic processes in the Palaeoarchaean, rather than continental contamination.
Petrogenetic interpretation As shown above, alteration, deformation, and crustal assimilation can all be ruled out as the cause of the specific geochemical characteristics of the Isua volcanic rocks. The high MgO, Ni and Cr contents indicate high temperature partial melting. Continuous compositional range (MgO = 7-16 wt.%, Ni = 60-645 ppm in central tectonic unit; MgO = 5-21 wt.%, Ni = 31-952 ppm in outer and inner arc units) is consistent with olivine-controlled fractionation processes. Negative Nb and Ti anomalies on primitive mantle-normalised diagrams of the Isua volcanic rocks are consistent with a subduction zone petrogenetic origin (Fig. 2.3-5; cf. Pearce and Peate, 1995). The geochemical characteristics of the least altered volcanic rocks are consistent with the presence of two geochemically distinct volcanic associations in the Isua greenstone belt. These are (1) a low-HFSE association (e.g., TiO2 = 0.20-0.40 wt.%; Zr = 12-30 ppm; Nb = 0.13-0.80 ppm; Y = 6-14 ppm) in the central arc litho-tectonic sequence, and (2) a high-HFSE association (TiO2 = 0.50-1.14 wt.%; Zr = 34-77 ppm; Nb = 1.2-2.7 ppm; Y = 11-28 ppm) in the inner and outer arc litho-tectonic sequences (Fig. 2.3-2). These two suites have distinct trace element patterns on primitive mantlenormalised diagrams (Fig. 2.3-5). In addition, volcanic rocks from the central arc sequence have consistently lower Zr/Y and (Gd/Yb)pm ratios than those from the inner and outer arc sequences at a given Mg-number value, and MgO and Ni contents (Fig. 2.3-6; Table 2.3-1). Collectively, geochemical differences between the two suites cannot be attributed to metamorphic alteration, fractional crystallisation, degree of partial melting, or crustal contamination processes but could be explained by two geochemically-distinct mantle sources. Primitive mantle-normalised REE patterns suggest that the low-HFSE association was derived from an LREE depleted mantle source, whereas the high-HFSE association was derived from a fiat to LREE enriched mantle source. The depletion of the source of the lowHFSE association may have resulted from a previous melt extraction event(s). The LREE enriched characteristic of the high-HFSE suite can be attributed to the enrichment of their source by subduction zone metasomatism (cf. Pearce and Peate, 1995). Super-chondritic Zr/Sm ratios in the low-HFSE association may reflect the metasomatism of their sources by slab-derived melts (cf. Pearce et al., 1999). Positively fractionated HREE patterns in the high-HFSE association (Fig. 2.3-5) are consistent with melt generation in the field of garnet stability (cf. Sun and Nesbitt, 1978), whereas negatively fractionated HREE patterns in the low-HFSE association suggest that garnet was not a stable phase in the source. The low-HFSE association was referred to as "boninitic" by Polat et al. (2002) because it has many geochemical characteristics similar to those of Tertiary boninites from the west-
2.3. Isua Greenstone Belt: Geodynamic Processes
100 (a)
==
Central
85
9N-MORB
sequence
arc
10
0.1 100
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
Th Nb La Ce Pr Nd Zr Sm Eu Ti Gd Tb Dy Y Ho Er Tm Yb
(b)
Inner arc sequence
10 3E
13. t~ 0
iv.
1
0.1
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
1
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
Th Nb La Ce Pr Nd Zr Sm Eu Ti Gd Tb Dy Y Ho Er Tm Yb
100 (c)
10 3E
13.
Outer
arc
sequence
!
t~ 0
n,
1
0.1
i
i
I
I
I
J
I
J
I
I
I
J
I
I
I
i
i
i
Th Nb La Ce Pr Nd Zr Sm Eu Ti Gd Tb Dy Y Ho Er Tm YI
Fig. 2.3-5. Primitive mantle-normalised trace element patterns for the least altered samples from different lithotectonic sequences. Primitive mantle normalisation values from Hofmann (1988).
86
Chapter 2: Generation of Continental Crust
Fig. 2.3-6. (a--c) Ti versus Nb and Zr, and Zr/Y versus Gd/Yb variation diagrams, indicating that samples from the central arc sequence (low-HFSE association) and from the inner and outer arc sequences (high-HFSE association) plot separately, consistent with the presence of two geochemically distinct mafic-ultramafic rock associations in the Palaeoarchaean Isua greenstone belt. These two volcanic associations are likely to reflect distinct tectonic segments of a Palaeoarchaean intra-oceanic arc(s).
2.3. Isua Greenstone Belt: Geodynamic Processes
87
ern Pacific Ocean. The primary melts of the boninitic association require high temperature (c. 1300~ low pressure (< 10 kbar) melting of an extremely depleted clinopyroxenepoor harzburgitic mantle source (cf. Crawford et al., 1989; Taylor et al., 1994). According to Polat et al. (2002), the melts of this association resulted from an interaction between an extremely depleted subarc mantle source and slab-derived adakitic melts. The volcanic rocks of the high-HFSE association can be defined as "picrites" given that they have geochemical features similar to those of Phanerozoic picrites (cf. Ramsay et al., 1984; Eggins, 1993; Kamenetsky et al., 1995). Generation of the primary melts of the picritic association requires high temperature (c. 1300~ and high pressure (c. 30 kbar) melting of refractory peridotitic mantle source (cf. Eggins, 1993). In conclusion, the low-HFSE association was derived from a shallower and more depleted mantle source than the high-HFSE association. Conclusions
On the basis of the least mobile elements in samples screened for minimum alteration, two distinct types of mafic to ultramafic volcanic associations have been recognised in structurally separated sequences of the > 3.7 Ga Isua greenstone belt. These are (1) a lowHFSE association in the central litho-tectonic sequence, and (2) a high-HFSE association in the outer and inner arc litho-tectonic sequences. The former association was referred to as "boninitic" by Polat et al. (2002) because it has many geochemical characteristics similar to those of Tertiary boninites from the western Pacific Ocean. The latter association has geochemical features similar to those of Phanerozoic island arc picrites (cf. Ramsay et al., 1984; Eggins, 1993; Kamenetsky et al., 1995). Volcanic rocks with boninitic affinity have recently been reported from the Neoarchaean Abitibi and Frotet-Evans greenstone belts of the Superior Province, suggesting that boninitic volcanism in the Archaean may have been more widespread than is currently recognised (Kerrich et al., 1998; Boliy and Dion, 2002). Studies of Tertiary boninitic rocks suggest that they are the products of high temperature, low pressure partial melting of a hydrous, refractory mantle source above a subducted oceanic lithosphere at intra-oceanic convergent plate boundaries, such as the Izu-BoninMariana subduction zones of the western Pacific (Taylor et al., 1994). Similarly, Phanerozoic island arc picrites are the products of high temperature, high pressure melting of refractory peridotitic subarc mantle sources (Eggins, 1993). If the geochemical characteristics of the Palaeoarchaean lsua boninites and picrites have the same geodynamic significance as their Phanerozoic counterparts, then they likely originated in an intraoceanic subduction zone-like tectonic setting, suggesting that Phanerozoic-like plate tectonic processes were operating as early as 3.8 Ga (Fig. 2.3-7). On the basis of combined structural and geochronological studies, Nutman et al. (2002) suggested that the c. 3800 Ma outer arc sequence and the c. 3700 Ma central arc sequence were probably juxtaposed by Phanerozoic-like plate tectonic processes operating in the Palaeoarchaean. The geochemical characteristics of the low-HFSE and high-HFSE associations are comparable to those in the Tertiary Mariana forearc, and in the Vanuatu and Solomon island arcs, respectively (Ramsay et al., 1984; Eggins, 1993; Taylor et al., 1994). The occurrence of boninites and picrites have been described from certain Phanerozoic subduction zones featuring high
Chapter 2: Generation o f Continental Crust
88
Fig. 2.3-7. Interpreted geodynamic settings for the Isua boninites and picrites. Given the fact that the original temporal and spatial relationships between the boninites and picrites are unknown, it is not necessary to assume that they erupted above the same subduction zone. It is equally possible that they erupted in different oceanic arcs and were juxtaposed by subsequent tectonic processes. geothermal gradients, suggesting that high geothermal gradients in Palaeoarchaean subduction zones may have played an important role in the production of the Isua boninites and picrites. It should be emphasised that analogies with modem geodynamic settings should be used with great caution as templates for geodynamic interpretation, but such comparisons may help in understanding the processes by which Archaean greenstone belts originated. Similarly, it should also be emphasised that the Isua greenstone belt represents only a tiny fraction of the surviving Palaeoarchaean crust; therefore, the geochemical characteristics of the Isua volcanic rocks may not offer a complete picture of the petrogenetic and geodynamic processes operating in the Palaeoarchaean.
2.4.
ABITIBI GREENSTONE BELT PLATE TECTONICS: THE DIACHRONONOUS HISTORY OF ARC DEVELOPMENT, ACCRETION AND COLLISION
R. DAIGNEAULT, W.U. MUELLER AND E.H. CHOWN Introduction
Comparing the tectonic evolution of Archaean greenstone belts with Phanerozoic counterparts has long been a contentious issue (e.g., Hamilton, 1998), yet thrust structures, inferred from inverted sequences, recumbent folds and subhorizontal high strain zones, have been identified on numerous Archaean cratons (Stowe, 1974, 1984; Poulsen et al., 1980; de Wit, 1982; Jirsa et al., 1992; Mueller et al., 1996; Kusky and Polat, 1999) (see also discussion in section 3.6). Similarly, shallow-dipping seismic reflections, interpreted as a remnant subduction zone, have been recognised at depth, north of the Abitibi greenstone belt (Calvert et al., 1995). The combination of outcrop- and crustal-scale shallow dipping The Precambrian Earth: Temposand Events Edited by EG. Eriksson, W. Altermann, D.R. Nelson, W.U. Mucller and O. Catuneanu
2.4. Abitibi Greenstone Belt Plate Tectonics
89
structures and thrusts is consistent with shortening via horizontal plate motions generated by subduction. However, the amount of tectonic transport is difficult to assess and defining allochthonous or autochthonous terranes remains a problem (Thurston, 2002). Large-scale processes become complex if plume-generated komatiites are involved. Mantle plumes (sections 3.2 and 3.3) impinging on Archaean subduction zones are a particularly appealing geodynamic process used to explain komatiites associated with arc volcanic rocks (Dostal and Mueller, 1997; Hollings et al., 1999; Wyman, 1999a; Polat and Kerrich, 2000a). Plate tectonics are accepted as the principal mechanism for Archaean greenstone belt formation and deformation (Langford and Morin, 1976; De Wit, 1998) (see, however, section 3.6), but plume activity for komatiite-tholeiitic basalt sequences remains an important process (Tomlinson and Condie, 2001). The resurgence of the "sagduction" concept for greenstone belts of the Dharwar Craton (Chardon et al., 1998), shows that vertical tectonics are important, but may be explained readily by oblique convergence (Chadwick et al., 2000). Kloppenburg et al. (2001) explained gravitational forces in the 3.5-3.4 Ga Warrawoona Group and associated granitoid complexes of the Pilbara Craton as the product of an extensional core complex deformational event linked to plate tectonics. Whilst komatiites are considered plume derivatives, their structural signature imposed on Archaean arc and ocean floor terranes remains elusive. Physical features of plumes such as radiating dyke swarms, selective changes in sedimentary thickness, or domal upwelling are excellent criteria in continental break-up settings but are unlikely to be recognised in the arc and ocean plateau environment. In the arc setting with plume impingement, subduction-generated structures are therefore dominant. Focus is placed here on the structural evolution of the 2735-2670 Ma Abitibi greenstone belt, the largest coherent greenstone belt in the world (Card, 1990). The 300 x 700 km Abitibi greenstone belt is a prime example of subduction-dominated processes even though mantle plumes constantly affected Abitibi evolution. The Abitibi greenstone belt is a linear east-trending volcano-sedimentary sequence pierced by plutonic suites, that displays arc formation, arc evolution, arc-arc collision and arc fragmentation (Mueller et al., 1996) and is therefore strikingly similar to modern collisional orogenies. It is the best belt in the world to decipher Archaean arc time-space variations and the deformation geometry produced by Archaean plate tectonics (Daigneault et al., 2002) because of precise U-Pb zircon age determinations (Mortensen, 1993a, b; Ayer et al., 2002), volcanic facies analysis (Dimroth et al., 1982, 1985), sedimentary facies analyses (Mueller and Donaldson, 1992a) as well as a well constrained emplacement history of plutons (Chown et al., 1992, 2002) and detailed geochemistry (Goodwin, 1982). Divisions of the Abitibi Greenstone Belt The Abitibi greenstone belt (Fig. 2.4-1), divided into Southern (SVZ) and Northern Volcanic Zones (NVZ; Chown et al., 1992) represents a collage of two arcs, delineated by the Destor-Porcupine Manneville Fault Zone (DPMFZ; Mueller et al., 1996). The SVZ is separated from the Pontiac sedimentary rocks, an accretionary prism (Calvert and Ludden, 1999) to the south, by the Cadillac-Larder Lake Fault Zone (CLLFZ). The fault zones are
~ ~ l t r a r n a f i c - m a fvolcanic ic r a d t s Mafc ~ lntrus~on
I
Fig. 2.4-1. Division of the Abitibi greenstone belt into southern (SVZ) and northern volcanic zones (NVZ) with external and internal segments in the NVZ. BRS = Black River segment; MS = Malartic segment. Plutons cited in text: Cb = Chibougamau; Fv = Flavrien; Fr = Franquet; La = Lacorne; Lm = Lamotte; Lp = Lapparent; Ma = Marest; Mi = Mistaouac; Mu = Muscocho; Op = Opemisca, Pr = Preissac; Re = Renaud; Wa = Waswanipi. DLC = Dore Lake Complex, BRC = Bell River Complex. Sedimentary basins: Ch = Chicobi, Tb = Taibi, K = Kewagama, Po = Pontiac, Du = Duparquet, Cs = Caste, Om = Opemisca, Ca = Caopatina. Pie diagrams show distribution of prominent rock types. Modified from Chown et al. (1992) and Daigneault et al. (2002).
2.4. Abitibi Greenstone Belt Plate Tectonics
91
terrane zippers that show the change from thrusting to transcurrent motion as documented in the turbiditic flysch basins overlain unconformably by, or in structural contact with, coarse clastic deposits in strike-slip basins (Mueller et al., 1991, 1994a