Special Paper 466
THE GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF AMERICA®
THE ORDOVICIAN EARTH SYSTEM
EDITED BY STANLEY C. FINNEY AND WILLIAM B.N. BERRY
The Ordovician Earth System
edited by
Stanley C. Finney Department of Geological Sciences California State University at Long Beach Long Beach, California 90840 USA William B.N. Berry Department of Earth and Planetary Science University of California, Berkeley Berkeley, California 94720 USA
Special Paper 466 3300 Penrose Place, P.O. Box 9140
Boulder, Colorado 80301-9140, USA
2010
Copyright © 2010, The Geological Society of America (GSA), Inc. All rights reserved. GSA grants permission to individual scientists to make unlimited photocopies of one or more items from this volume for noncommercial purposes advancing science or education, including classroom use. For permission to make photocopies of any item in this volume for other noncommercial, nonprofit purposes, contact The Geological Society of America. Written permission is required from GSA for all other forms of capture or reproduction of any item in the volume including, but not limited to, all types of electronic or digital scanning or other digital or manual transformation of articles or any portion thereof, such as abstracts, into computer-readable and/or transmittable form for personal or corporate use, either noncommercial or commercial, for-profit or otherwise. Send permission requests to GSA Copyright Permissions, 3300 Penrose Place, P.O. Box 9140, Boulder, Colorado 80301-9140, USA. GSA provides this and other forums for the presentation of diverse opinions and positions by scientists worldwide, regardless of their race, citizenship, gender, religion, or political viewpoint. Opinions presented in this publication do not reflect official positions of the Society. Copyright is not claimed on any material prepared wholly by government employees within the scope of their employment. Published by The Geological Society of America, Inc. 3300 Penrose Place, P.O. Box 9140, Boulder, Colorado 80301-9140, USA www.geosociety.org Printed in U.S.A. GSA Books Science Editors: Marion E. Bickford and Donald I. Siegel Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data The Ordovician earth system / edited by Stanley C. Finney, William B.N. Berry. p. cm. — (Special paper ; 466) Includes bibliographical references. ISBN 978-0-8137-2466-9 (pbk. : alk. paper) 1. Paleobiogeography—Ordovician. 2. Paleoecology—Ordovician. 3. Biodiversity. I. Finney, Stanley C. (Stanley Charles), 1947–. II. Berry, William B. N. QE721.2.P24O76 2010 560′.45—dc22 2010000939 Front cover: Indian River Falls. Outcrop of uppermost Ordovician strata in the Indian Falls Conservation area 5 km NNW of Owen Sound, Ontario. The basal red mudstones, which are overlain by about 2.5 m of gray siltstones, represent the uppermost portion of the shallow-water, poorly fossiliferous Queenston Formation that consists of clastics transported from eastern highlands formed during the Late Ordovician Taconic orogeny. The Queenston is unconformably overlain by about 7.5 m of shallow-water fossiliferous limestones of the Manitoulin Formation. Traditionally, this unconformity has been taken to represent the Ordovician/Silurian boundary but recent work on conodonts and brachiopods indicates that the Manitoulin Formation is of Hirnantian age. This is consistent with the fact that the Hirnantian Isotope Carbon Excursion (HICE) is present in the upper Queenston and lower Manitoulin formations. The subManitoulin unconformity is now interpreted as reflecting a eustatic regression during a middle Hirnantian Saharan glaciation and the Manitoulin as deposited during the following post-glacial transgression. Photo by Stig M. Bergström. Back cover: Conodont, Pygodus anserinus. The platform element of this species, illustrated by a specimen from the Sops Arm Formation in Newfoundland, is very distinctive. The evolution of P. anserinus from P. serra occurs below and very close to the boundary between the Middle Ordovician and Upper Ordovician Series, and the lowest occurrence of P. anserinus, stratigraphically above occurrences of P. serra, can be used in carbonate successions to locate the series boundary with considerable accuracy. Photo by Godfrey Nowlin. 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Contents
Preface Stanley C. Finney and William B.N. Berry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . v 1. Global setting of Ordovician orogenesis Cees R. van Staal and Robert D. Hatcher, Jr. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 2. Ordovician explosive volcanism Warren D. Huff, Stig M. Bergström, and Dennis R. Kolata . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 3. Toward identifying potential causes for stratigraphic change in subtropical to tropical Laurentia during the Mohawkian (early Late Ordovician) Achim D. Herrmann and Bernd J. Haupt . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 4. The Upper Ordovician Guttenberg δ13C excursion (GICE) in North America and Baltoscandia: Occurrence, chronostratigraphic significance, and paleoenvironmental relationships Stig M. Bergström, Birger Schmitz, Matthew R. Saltzman, and Warren D. Huff . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 5. The Ordovician brachiopod radiation: Roles of alpha, beta, and gamma diversity David A.T. Harper . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 69 6. Ordovician paleogeography and tectonics of the major paleoplates of China Chen Xu, Zhou Zhi-yi, and Fan Jun-xuan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 85 7. Ordovician of the Siberian Platform Alexander V. Kanygin, Tatiana N. Koren, Anastasia G. Yadrenkina, Alexander V. Timokhin, Oleg V. Sychev, and Tatiana Yu. Tolmacheva . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 105 8. Early–Middle Ordovician conodont paleobiogeography with special regard to the geographic origin of the Argentine Precordillera: A multivariate data analysis Guillermo L. Albanesi and Stig M. Bergström . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 119 9. Black shales: An Ordovician perspective William B.N. Berry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 141 10. Paleogeographic, paleoceanographic, and tectonic controls on early Late Ordovician graptolite diversity patterns Daniel Goldman and Wu Shuang-Ye . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 149
iii
iv
Contents 11. Origin of Late Ordovician (mid-Mohawkian) temperate-water conditions on southeastern Laurentia: Glacial or tectonic? Frank R. Ettensohn . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 163 12. Correlations across a facies mosaic within the Lexington Limestone of central Kentucky, USA, using whole-rock stable isotope compositions John W. Coates, Frank R. Ettensohn, and Harold D. Rowe. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 177
Preface
Stanley C. Finney† Department of Geological Sciences, California State University at Long Beach, Long Beach, California 90840, USA William B.N. Berry† Department of Earth and Planetary Science, University of California, Berkeley, Berkeley, California 94720, USA With a duration of 44 million years (488–444 Ma), the Ordovician Period is a most significant chapter in Earth’s history. It includes the great Middle Ordovician biodiversification event, the Hirnantian glaciation, and long-term greenhouse conditions. During the period, many continents were dispersed widely along the equator and in the southern temperate belt (Laurentia, Baltica, Siberia, South China, and Tarim), and large Gondwana (Africa, South America, India, Antarctica, and Australia) occupied much of the Southern Hemisphere from the pole to the equator. Richly fossiliferous carbonate sediments, along with occasional shale facies and quartz sands, were deposited in shallow seas that flooded tropical continents, while siliciclastic sediments, including Hirnantian glacial and glacio-marine sediments, were deposited over large parts of Gondwana and peri-Gondwana terranes. After nearly complete submergence in the Early Ordovician, Laurentia underwent a dramatic, extensive regression and subsequent transgression that produced the continentwide, post-Sauk, pre-Tippecanoe unconformity, which may be expressed to various degrees in stratigraphic successions on most other paleocontinents that lay at low to middle paleolatitudes. The margins of the Ordovician oceanic realm, now preserved in orogenic belts (Antler, Taconic, Ouachita, and Ellesmerian of North America, Caledonides of northwest Europe, Central Asia, and Lachlan in eastern Australia), were sites of deep-marine sedimentation of thick turbiditic sandstone packages, shale, and chert. Magmatic-volcanic arcs along paleo-plate boundaries produced impressive belts of Ordovician granites in northwestern Argentina, and numerous, often thick, geographically widespread K-bentonites that are found today in eastern North America, northwest Europe, China, and the Argentine Precordillera and which represent some of the largest known fallout ash deposits of the Phanerozoic Era. Subduction along the margins of Laurentia, Gondwana, Baltica, and Siberia formed extensive linear orogenic belts. Accordingly, rocks of the Ordovician System are widespread on all continents except Antarctica (where the present ice cover may hide them), and capping Mount Everest they occupy the highest elevation on Earth (Ross, 1984). A 30 yr project of formally defining the Cambrian-Ordovician and Ordovician-Silurian boundaries, and a single set of global series-epochs and stages-ages for the Ordovician System-Period was recently completed by the International Subcommission on Ordovician System when the GSSP (global stratotype section and point) for the base of the Dapingian Stage and the Middle Ordovician Series was approved by the International Commission on Stratigraphy and ratified by the International Union of Geological Sciences in 2007 (Fig. 1). This scientific process was especially difficult and complex for the Ordovician System, because the high degree of biogeographic provincialism and ecologic differentiation of Ordovician faunas greatly limited global correlations (Finney, 2005). British series-epochs were often used as de facto nomenclature on stratigraphic correlation charts and geologic time scales. However, they were not widely adopted outside of the British Isles because they could not be correlated biostratigraphically with precision and high †
E-mails:
[email protected];
[email protected].
v
Preface
GLOBAL SERIES
vi
443.7 Ma 445.6 Ma
GLOBAL STAGES
BRITISH SERIES
NORTH AMERICAN SERIES
HIRNANTIAN ASHGILL
UPPER
CINCINNATIAN
471.8 Ma
478.6 Ma
MIDDLE
468.1 Ma
CARADOC
MOHAWKIAN
SANDBIAN
DARRIWILIAN
LLANVIRN WHITEROCKIAN
DAPINGIAN ARENIG FLOIAN
LOWER
460.9 Ma
ORDOVICIAN
455.8 Ma
KATIAN
IBEXIAN TREMADOCIAN
TREMADOC
488.3 Ma
Figure 1. Chart showing correlation between global series and stages and regional series for Britain and North America. Calibrated ages from Ogg et al. (2008).
resolution. As a result, several independent and very different regional sets of series and constituent stages were established for the Ordovician System, with each generally applicable to a different paleoplate or modern continent, but this greatly confused Ordovician chronostratigraphy-geochronology and often resulted in imprecise correlations of Ordovician stratigraphic successions. The new set of global series and stages, and the precise definitions of their boundaries as well as those of the system, now provide a common language for correlation of Ordovician strata and for expressing geologic time (Fig. 1). During the many years required to establish the complete set of new global units, many Ordovician stratigraphers used the regional classification that they preferred, and some lamented the replacement of the British Series as the standard units of Ordovician stratigraphy (Cope, 2007). Nevertheless, now that the global set of units is complete, they are universally accepted and regularly used in papers on Ordovician stratigraphy. Regional chronostratigraphic classifications can still be used for those regional stratigraphic successions on which they were defined and may offer the most precise local correlation, and the correlation of the varied regional units to the new global series and stages is fully elucidated in Bergström et al. (2009). The process of establishing global chronostratigraphic units for the Ordovician System depended on, and resulted in, extensive, focused, often multidisciplinary studies of stratigraphic successions worldwide by a multitude of specialists. It generated a huge body of stratigraphic information, primarily on biostratigraphy and paleontology, but also on chemostratigraphy, sequence stratigraphy, and magnetostratigraphy as well as sedimentology and geochemistry. In addition it fostered the acquisition of radiometric dates that could be used to calibrate the ages of the chronostratigrapic units, particularly their boundaries, thus refining a significant part of the Geologic Time Scale (Cooper and Sadler, 2004). The primary goal of this long-term project was establishment of a single set of global chronostratigraphic units for precise, high-resolution correlations worldwide. However, it also fostered integrated, multidisciplinary studies that documented the state of, and important changes in, the Earth system during the Ordovician Period (e.g., Huff et al., 1992; Finney et al., 1999). As the chronostratigraphic project neared completion, members of the Ordovician Subcommission redirected their attention toward using the greatly expanded knowledge of Ordovician stratigraphy to address major events of the Ordovician Period. Former subcommission chair Barry Webby organized and led the most
Preface successful International Geological Correlation Programme (IGCP) 410, the Great Ordovician Biodiversification Event, which produced an impressive examination and summary of one of the major biotic events of not only the Ordovician but also the entire Phanerozoic (Webby et al., 2004). Along the same lines, a symposium titled “Global Ordovician Earth System” was organized at the 32nd International Geological Congress in Florence, Italy, in 2004. It was composed largely of contributions that used an Earth systems approach to examine aspects of the Earth’s lithosphere, biosphere, hydrosphere, and atmosphere during the Ordovician and to integrate them where possible. Several of those contributions, further elaborated since the Congress in Florence, form the core of this volume with additional contributions later solicited by the editors. The contributions in this volume range from global to regional in scope. Their focus varies from tectonic to paleogeographic and from sedimentological to paleontological. Yet all provide views of the Ordovician world. They are only a small sample of the diverse current research on the Ordovician System, yet they provide entry into the Ordovician world and in varying degree to interactions among Earth’s systems. Thus, the title of the volume is The Ordovician Earth System. In the lead article, Cees van Staal and Robert Hatcher conclude from their study of early Paleozoic orogenic belts that Ordovician orogenesis was due principally to accretion of arc terranes and ribbon microcontinents. Warren Huff and co-authors review the distribution of Ordovician K-bentonites in eastern North America, northwest Europe, Argentina, and China. Achim Herrmann and Bernd Haupt employ numerical models of the Ordovician ocean-climate system to propose that upwelling cold-water masses that penetrated the epicontinental sea of Laurentia during the early Late Ordovician indicate the onset of cooling conditions that plunged the Earth system toward icehouse conditions that later led to the Hirnantian glaciation as well as produced a regional extinction during the early Late Ordovician (Mohawkian) of eastern Laurentia. Stig Bergström and co-authors demonstrate the powerful correlation potential of the early Katian (early Late Ordovician) Guttenberg carbon isotope excursion, which occurred within the time of massive fallout ash deposits and the Mohawkian extinction, but they consider its cause to be enigmatic. Turning to the biosphere, David Harper’s detailed analysis of brachiopod diversity illustrates well the great Middle Ordovician biodiversification event, the Hirnantian mass extinction, and less dramatic changes and relates them to paleogeographic changes and tectonic events. Contributions by Chen Xu and colleagues on the Ordovician paleoplates of modern China and by Alexander Kanygin and co-authors on the Ordovician of the Siberian platform provide valuable summaries of stratigraphic information that are essential for reconstructing Ordovician paleogeography for significant continents of the Ordovician world. Through statistical analysis of Ordovician conodonts from globally widespread areas, Guillermo Albanesi and Stig Bergström examine paleobiogeographic relationships between Laurentia, Baltica, the Argentine Precordillera, and the proto-Andean margin of Gondwana and find that the evidence does not support a Laurentian origin of the Argentine Precordillera (the Cuyania terrane), a hypothesis that has received much recent attention. Organic-rich black shales are prominent, widespread Ordovician lithofacies and commonly contain abundant graptolites, which are essential for chronostratigraphic correlations. Using modern analogues, William Berry concludes that they accumulated in settings similar to modern hypoxic-anoxic environments. The final three papers in this volume are complementary examinations of the Earth system interactions in eastern Laurentia during the Katian (early Late Ordovician or Mohawkian). Daniel Goldman and Wu Shuang-Ye conclude that a significant episode of graptolite extinction was regional and not global and likely due to cold-water masses that penetrated the epicontinental sea of Laurentia, as proposed by the ocean–climate system model of Herrmann and Haupt (this volume). Frank Ettensohn associates the influx of cold-water masses to regional tectonics that altered regional paleogeography. John Coates and co-authors demonstrate that carbon-isotope stratigraphy provides high-resolution correlation between varied lithofacies within this complex depositional setting. Thorough reviews of manuscripts submitted for this volume were provided by Leho Ainsaar, Peter Cawood, Robin Cocks, Roger Cooper, Olda Fatka, Don Gorsline, Jack Green, Christopher Holmden, Dmitri Kaljo, Thomas Kelty, Dennis Kolata, Ed Landing, Stephen Leslie, Greg Ludvigson, Michael Melchin, Godfrey Nowlan, Mark Patzkowsky, Michael Pope, Leonid Popov, John Repetski, Rong Jiayu, Matthew Saltzman, Hans Peter Schonlaub, Brian Witzke, and Jan Zalaciewicz. Their efforts are very much appreciated.
vii
viii
Preface REFERENCES CITED Bergström, S.M., Chen Xu, Gutiérrez-Marco, J.C., and Dronov, A., 2009, The new chronostratigraphic classification of the Ordovician System and its relations to major regional series and stages and to δ13C chemostratigraphy: Lethaia, v. 42, p. 97–107. Cooper, R.A., and Sadler, P.M., 2004, The Ordovician Period, in Gradstein, F.M., Ogg, J.G., and Smith, A.G., eds., A Geologic Time Scale 2004: Cambridge, UK, Cambridge University Press, p. 165–187. Cope, J.C.W., 2007, What have they done to the Ordovician?: Geoscientist, v. 17, p. 19–21. Finney, S., 2005, Global series and stages for the Ordovician System: A progress report: Geologica Acta, v. 3, p. 309–316. Finney, S.C., Berry, W.B.N., Cooper, J.D., Ripperdan, R.L., Sweet, W.C., Jacobson, S.R., Soufiane, A., Achab, A., and
Noble, P.J., 1999, Late Ordovician mass extinction: New perspective from stratigraphic sections in central Nevada: Geology, v. 27, p. 215–218, doi: 10.1130/0091-7613(1999) 027<0215:LOMEAN>2.3.CO;2. Huff, W.D., Bergström, S.M., and Kolata, D.R., 1992, Gigantic Ordovician volcanic ash fall in North America and Europe: Biological, tectonomagmatic, and event-stratigraphic significance: Geology, v. 20, p. 875–878, doi: 10.1130/0091 -7613(1992)020<0875:GOVAFI>2.3.CO;2. Ogg, J.G., Ogg, G., and Gradstein, F.M., 2008, The Concise Geologic Time Scale: Cambridge, UK, Cambridge University Press, 177 p. Ross, R.J., Jr., 1984, The Ordovician System, progress and problems: Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences, v. 12, p. 307–335, doi: 10.1146/annurev.ea.12.050184.001515. Webby, B.D., Paris, F., Droser, M.L., and Percival, I.G., 2004, The Great Ordovician Biodiversification Event: New York, Columbia University Press, 484 p.
The Geological Society of America Special Paper 466 2010
Global setting of Ordovician orogenesis Cees R. van Staal† Geological Survey of Canada, 625 Robson Street, Vancouver, British Columbia V6B 5J3, Canada Robert D. Hatcher, Jr. Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences and Science Alliance Center of Excellence, University of Tennessee, Knoxville, Tennessee 37996-1410, USA
ABSTRACT The global distribution, setting, and dynamic implications of Ordovician orogenesis are reviewed. Evidence for true Ordovician continent-continent collision is absent. Orogenesis is principally due to accretion of arc terranes and/or ribbon microcontinents. Most arc terranes are ensialic and separated from the adjacent continents by backarc or marginal basins, the episodic closure of which commonly was responsible for orogenesis. Little evidence is preserved for true intra-oceanic juvenile arcs during the Early to Middle Ordovician. Instead, subduction appears to have been localized near the margins of Laurentia, Gondwana, Baltica, and Siberia, forming extensive linear orogenic belts during relatively short periods when the upper plate switched from extension to compression. Such tectonic switching appears to have taken place along the entire length of the Pacific and Iapetan margins of Gondwana (>10,000 km) from Middle–Late Cambrian to Early Ordovician time. The onset of orogenesis along Gondwana’s Pacific margin during the end of the Early Cambrian (ca. 513 Ma) coincided with subduction initiation along both margins of the Iapetus Ocean. Orogenesis and subduction initiation are causally related to a global-scale plate reorganization, probably induced by terminal amalgamation of Gondwana. During the Paleozoic, Laurentia’s Iapetan margin steadily grew in size and expanded southward owing to continuous accretion of suprasubduction zone oceanic crust, peri-Gondwanan arc terranes, and ribbon microcontinents. In contrast, the Pacific, Iapetan, and Rheic margins of Gondwana saw little addition of new, allochthonous crust. Accretion mainly involves reattachment of previously rifted-off arc terranes and small slivers of the intervening marginal basin crust. INTRODUCTION
and Eurasia. There is also minor Ordovician deformation in Africa, but this mainly relates to transpression and basin inversion induced by far-field stresses and is not relevant to this paper. What makes Ordovician orogenesis stand out from all other periods in the Paleozoic is that nowhere it appears to have involved true continent-continent collision. Some workers have invoked a Middle Ordovician collision between Gondwana and Laurentia (e.g., Dalziel et al., 1994), mainly based on orogenesis taking
Orogenic events (orogenesis) affected many parts of the world during the Ordovician, and the remnants of the mountain belts created can be found principally in the present-day continents of North America, South America, Australia, Antarctica, †
E-mail:
[email protected].
Van Staal, C.R., and Hatcher, R.D., Jr., 2010, Global setting of Ordovician orogenesis, in Finney, S.C., and Berry, W.B.N., eds., The Ordovician Earth System: Geological Society of America Special Paper 466, p. 1–11, doi: 10.1130/2010.2466(01). For permission to copy, contact
[email protected]. ©2010 The Geological Society of America. All rights reserved.
1
2
Van Staal and Hatcher
place nearly coevally on both margins of Iapetus (Fig. 1) and involving accretion of Laurentian-derived crust (Precordillera) to Gondwana. However, this model was abandoned by Dalziel (1997) and replaced by a short-lived collision between a large promontory on Laurentia that bulged into the Iapetus Ocean (Texas Plateau) and Gondwana. Most other workers favor collision between a Laurentian-derived microcontinent (Cuyania/ Precordillera) and Gondwana instead (e.g., Ramos et al., 1986; Astini et al., 1995; Thomas and Astini, 1996). Irrespective of whether or not the fleeting promontory-Gondwana collision ever happened, we do not consider it a true continent-continent collision, because the area involved in this putative collision was very small compared with the length of the margins. Instead the four principal continental masses present on Earth at that time (Laurentia, Gondwana, Baltica, and Siberia; see Fig. 1 and also Cocks and Torsvik, 2002; Torsvik and Cocks, 2005) were involved in accretion of peri-cratonic arc terranes and/or ribbon-shaped microcontinents and remained separated by oceans (principally the Iapetus, Aegir, Tornquist-Ran, and Pacific Oceans). These accretionary events were precursors to major continent-continent collisions that occurred during the middle to late Paleozoic. Formation and accretion of ribbon-shaped microcontinents, principally derived from Gondwana and to a lesser extent Laurentia, and the closure of marginal oceanic basins on a global scale
during the Ordovician are important tectonic phenomena that pose important geodynamic questions. The purpose of this paper is to provide a brief review and summary of the data and ideas related to Ordovician orogenic events, mainly concentrating on their tectonic evolution and whether they are kinematically and/or dynamically linked, and if so, how and why, and finally to discuss the implications of these orogenic events. The latter is done to further our understanding of the global tectonic climate and the driving tectonic forces during the Ordovician. In this paper we have adopted the usage of the new Ordovician stage names (Finney, 2005; Bergström et al., 2006). OROGENESIS AND TIME In general, classification and correlation of structures and other evidence of tectonic events were historically (pre–plate tectonics) done on the basis of time alone, which is a hazardous process (although one sometimes has no other choice), because orogenic events are invariably diachronous, and kinematically unrelated tectonic events may take place coevally in different parts of the world (e.g., van Staal, 1994). These, by chance, may have been juxtaposed later as a result of subsequent plate motion(s) and closure of intervening oceans (van Staal et al., 1998).
Figure 1. Distribution of the main continents, oceans, subduction zones and arc-backarc systems, and micro-continents in the Early Ordovician (Tremadocian). The South Pole is situated in North Africa. The Pacific margin of Gondwana with the Ross-Delamerian belt of Australia and Antarctica that is continuous with the active proto-Andean margin, together forming a very long circum-Gondwanan subduction system, is just out of view. The Corel Draw figure originally made by Conall MacNiocaill for van Staal et al. (1998) was modified for this paper. Narrow volcanic arc terranes are indicated by ellipses. Dashed lines are used where the existence of subduction zones and/or transform faults is uncertain or contentious. Stippled structures may not have been active at this time. Arm—Armorica terrane; Aval—Avalonia; Boh—Bohemia terrane; Cadom—Paleozoic Cadomian arc terrane of Stampfli and Borel (2002); Car—Carolinia; Dashw & ND arc— Dashwoods microcontinent and Notre Dame arc; Famat arc—Famatinian arc-backarc system; Finnm arc—Finnmark arc-backarc system; Gan—Ganderia; Høl.—Hølanda terrane; Ib—Iberia terrane; Kip arc—Kipchak arc; M—Meguma terrane; Mu arc—Mugodzhar arc-microcontinent; Pc—Precordillera terrane; Penobs. arc—Penobscot arc-backarc system; S-M—Sakmara-Magnitogorsk marginal basin; Svalb—estimated position of the Svalbard and Pearya terranes.
Global setting of Ordovician orogenesis ORDOVICIAN OROGENESIS Orogenic events discussed in this paper include the Finnmarkian, Penobscottian, Taconian, Grampian, Shelveian, and the early stages of the Salinic and Scandian in the Appalachians and Caledonides of North America, British Isles, and Scandinavia; M’Clintock in Pearya of Arctic Canada and its unnamed equivalent in neigboring Svalbard; Famatinian and/or Ocloyic in South America; Sardic or Eo-Variscan in the Eurasian Variscan orogen; events in the Central Asian orogenic belt (Altaids); and parts of the Ross-Delamerian and Lachlan orogenies in eastern Australia and Antarctica (Fig. 1). Most of these orogenies are restricted to the Ordovician, but some started or mainly took place during the Middle to Late Cambrian (Finnmarkian and Ross-Delamerian), whereas others started during the latest Ordovician and climaxed during the Silurian (Salinic and Scandian). Their inclusion here is either due to diachroneity, such that their orogenesis locally extends into the Ordovician, and/or to their dynamics having had an impact on understanding Ordovician orogenesis in general. Following the definition of McKerrow et al. (2000), we restrict usage of the term Caledonian orogeny to describe all orogenic events involved in closing the Iapetus Ocean. Ordovician Paleogeography Comprehensive reviews of Earth’s geography, position of tectonic elements, and migration of terranes relevant to this paper are presented in van Staal et al. (1998), Cocks and Torsvik (2002), Stampfli and Borel (2002), Torsvik and Cocks (2005), and Cawood (2005). Although these authors do not necessarily agree on the evolution of each element, they broadly agree on the disposition of the main continental landmasses summarized in Figure 1. We adhere to these views, which are significantly different from the one proposed by Dalziel (1997). North American Appalachians and British Caledonides Ordovician orogenesis affected the Appalachians differently in different parts of the mountain chain. These orogenic events generally are diachronous along the length of the mountain chain, and to make matters more confusing, they occurred on both sides of the Iapetus ocean while the ocean was still very wide (Fig. 1), which makes the classification of Ordovician structures difficult without knowing the provenance and tectonic setting of the deformed rocks involved. The oldest orogenic events that affected the Appalachian orogen are represented by the latest Cambrian–Early Ordovician phases of the Taconian on the Laurentian side and the Penobscottian on the Gondwanan side (e.g., Colman Sadd et al., 1992; van Staal et al., 2007). Early phases of both orogenies partly overlap in time, and both involve ophiolite accretion-obduction and arc-continent collision (Fig. 1). The onset of ocean closure along opposite margins of the Iapetus Ocean (Fig. 1) signals a major plate reorganization at the end of the Early Cambrian (van Staal et al., 1998; also see below).
3
The main phase of the Taconian (Figs. 1 and 2) in the northern Appalachians is the collision between magmatic arc(s) and Laurentia, which started during the Early Ordovician (ca. 475 Ma; Humberian in Newfoundland) and lasted until the Late Ordovician. Deformation and accompanying tectonothermal activity are principally related to collision of a magmatic arc (Notre Dame–Shelburne Falls arc) built upon a ribbon-shaped peri-Laurentian microcontinent (Karabinos et al., 1998) named Dashwoods in Newfoundland (Taconic 2 suture in Fig. 1; Waldron and van Staal, 2001; van Staal et al., 2007), rapidly followed by Late Ordovician (ca. 450 Ma) softdocking of the peri-Gondwanan Popelogan–Victoria–Bronson Hill arc (Taconic 3, Fig. 2) built on a sliver of Ganderian crust (van Staal, 1994; Rogers et al., 2006 ; Zagorevski et al., 2007). This phase represents the terminal phase of the Taconian and closed the main oceanic tract of the Iapetus between Laurentia and Ganderia (Fig. 2), although a wide oceanic backarc basin (Tetagouche-Exploits backarc) and seaway (Acadian seaway) remained open, to be closed during the Silurian and Early Devonian, respectively (van Staal et al., 1998, 2007; van Staal, 2005; Valverde-Vaquero et al., 2006). In the southern Appalachians the Taconian is termed Blountian (Kay, 1942; Rodgers, 1971; Drake et al., 1989). Orogenesis here is particularly evident from the accumulation of the substantial Blount-Sevier foredeep clastic wedge on Laurentia’s continental margin near the beginning of the Middle Ordovician (ca. 468 Ma, Darriwilian), but it is also recorded by abundant metamorphic ages, formation of eclogite, and generation of arclike plutons in the internal parts of the mountain chain (central and eastern Blue Ridge and western Inner Piedmont). The most attractive model, which is virtually identical to the northern Appalachians, is one involving formation of a west-facing magmatic arc on a peri-Laurentian microcontinent (Hatcher, 1989; Miller et al., 2006; Hibbard et al., 2007). Metamorphism as high as granulite facies affected the rocks in the internal parts of the southern Appalachians between 455 and 465 Ma (Moecher et al., 2004) as a result of the arc-continent collision and associated obduction. Hibbard (2000) proposed that immediately subsequent to this collision the leading edge of the peri-Gondwanan Carolina terrane docked in the latest Ordovician–Early Silurian. If Hibbard’s model is correct, it indicates a remarkably similar kinematic/dynamic evolution for the entire Appalachian margin of Laurentia (Fig. 2) during the Ordovician (Hibbard et al., 2007), virtually eliminating the possibility of a fleeting Middle– Late Ordovician Gondwana-Laurentia collision as proposed by Dalziel et al. (1994) and Dalziel (1997). Other compelling sedimentologic, geochronologic, and field data from the southern and central Appalachians also support closure of the bulk of the Iapetus Ocean in the Late Ordovician, but these data also indicate that the trailing Rheic Ocean remained open until its late Paleozoic destruction (Bream, 2003; Merschat et al., 2005; Hatcher and Merschat, 2006; Merschat and Hatcher, 2007). Possibly several other, yet to be identified terranes outboard of Carolina were accreted to Laurentia prior to final closure of the Rheic Ocean,
4
Van Staal and Hatcher
Figure 2. Paleogeography of the tectonic elements shown in Figure 1 in the Late Ordovician (450 Ma). Figure modified from van Staal et al. (1998). Abbreviations are the same as in Figure 1. Tac 2 and 3 refer to suture zones formed during the Taconian orogeny (van Staal et al., 2007). ACSW—Acadian seaway between Ganderia and Avalonia, the closure of which caused the Acadian orogeny; Hun—Hun superterrane of Stampfli et al. (2002); PVA— Popelogan-Victoria arc; RILA—Red Indian Lake arc; TEB—Tetagouche-Exploits backarc basin; Thor—Thor suture zone, forming part of the TESZ (Trans-European suture zone).
which caused major underthrusting of the “westerly terranes,” situated near the leading edge of Laurentia beneath Carolina. The Taconian also affected the central Appalachians, but its effects were generally recorded slightly later (Late Ordovician) on the foreland. Here, the Martinsburg (Martinsburg-Juniata) clastic wedge is thicker (~5 km) than the Blount-Sevier wedge (~3 km) farther to the south. Deposition of the Martinsburg in the type area started approximately at the same time as the BlountSevier wedge, but deposition continued into the Late Ordovician. These relationships attest to the diachronous and composite nature of the Taconian orogeny in the Appalachians (Shanmugam and Lash, 1982; Drake et al., 1989; Hatcher, 1989). Several exposures of the angular unconformity from Pennsylvania and New Jersey to eastern New York reveal Early Silurian (Llandovery) molasse overlying tilted Upper Ordovician clastic wedge rocks (Rodgers, 1971). Extensive peri-cratonic island arc systems fringing both the Iapetan margins of Laurentia and Gondwana until the Late Ordovician (van Staal et al., 1998), combined with paleomagnetic and faunal evidence (e.g., Cocks and Torsvik, 2002), require that both continents remained widely separated until at least the Late Devonian. Hence, we conclude that there is no evidence to support collision of Laurentia with any large continental landmass other than ribbon-shaped continental arc terranes during the Ordovician.
The Taconian is kinematically and temporally equivalent to the Grampian in the British Isles (Dewey and Shackleton, 1984). Like the Taconian, the Grampian starts with ophiolite obduction immediately prior to arc-continent collision in the Early Ordovician (Dewey and Mange, 1999). The main Grampian orogenesis is a short-lived ca. 15 Ma event (ca. 475–460 Ma), although it comprises a complex tectonometamorphic cycle involving early blueschist and eclogite facies metamorphism of the subducting Laurentian (Dalradian) margin (Friend et al., 2000; Chew et al., 2003), polyphase deformation, and medium to high grade Barrovian metamorphism of the collision complex concurrent with syntectonic intrusion of plutons (Friedrich et al., 1999; Soper et al., 1999; Dewey and Mange, 1999). In this respect, the Grampian is nearly coeval and kinematically remarkably similar to the main phase of the Taconian in central and western Newfoundland (van Staal et al., 1998, 2007). Grampian orogenesis was rapidly followed by the Late Ordovician–Early Silurian Scandian orogenesis similar in nature to the Salinic in the northern Appalachians. While Grampian orogenesis occurred on the Laurentian side, Early to Middle Ordovician orogenesis also took place on the Gondwanan side in the British Isles (e.g., Max et al., 1990; Todd et al., 2000). This orogenic event, which has no name attached to it as yet in the British Isles, is the equivalent of the Penobscottian in the Appalachians (van Staal et al., 1998).
Global setting of Ordovician orogenesis Scandinavian, Greenland, and Svalbard Caledonides Ordovician orogenesis in the Scandinavian Caledonides was, until recently, mainly thought to be represented by an early event that principally took place in the Late Cambrian along the Baltic margin (Finnmarkian; Andréasson et al., 1998; Sturt and Ramsay, 1999; Grenne et al., 1999; Roberts, 2003). However, the structurally highest allochthons, in the Scandinavian Caledonides, which have a Laurentian provenance, have preserved ample evidence for a major Ordovician tectonic event that took place prior to their Silurian (Scandian) docking with the Baltic margin (Yoshinobu et al., 2002; Roberts, 2003). The Ordovician event is kinematically equivalent to the Taconian–Grampian orogeny in the Appalachians and British Caledonides. Surprisingly, no evidence for this event has been preserved in the East Greenland Caledonides, the area from which these rocks presumably were derived. However, the presence of Middle Ordovician blueschist, eclogite, and other evidence of major tectonism in western Svalbard (Dallmeyer et al., 1990; Gee and Page, 1994) and Pearya (M’Clintock orogeny; Trettin, 1987) leave little doubt that the Taconian–Grampian was probably continuous along the entire length of Laurentia’s Iapetan margin north of the Appalachians. The lack of evidence of this event in East Greenland suggests that most Ordovician tectonism was restricted to the peri-Laurentian arc terrane preserved in the Caledonides upper allochthon (Hølanda terrane of Grenne et al., 1999), which is thought to have been present directly outboard of Laurentia at the latitude of Greenland (Fig. 1) during the Ordovician (Grenne et al., 1999). A similar relationship has been observed in Newfoundland, where most Taconian tectonothermal activity was restricted to the peri-Laurentian Notre Dame arc and its basement (the Dashwoods microcontinent of Waldron and van Staal, 2001) and largely absent in the exposed parts of the adjacent passive margin, because most of the underthrusted margin rocks were never fully exhumed (van Staal et al., 2007). The Finnmarkian event is generally thought to be mainly restricted to the latest Cambrian, but age dating revealed that orogenesis continued into the Early–Middle Ordovician in Finnmark in northern Norway (e.g., Rice and Frank, 2003). The Finnmarkian involved arc development, ophiolite obduction, arc accretion, and metamorphism to eclogite facies conditions that principally affected rocks that now reside in the middle and upper allochthons in Norway and Sweden (Gee et al., 1985). The main Finnmarkian event is thought to have been the result of collision of a peri-cratonic arc terrane with the adjacent Baltic margin (Sturt and Roberts, 1991; Grenne et al., 1999; Roberts, 2003). Holtedahl (1920) recognized a slightly younger Early Ordovician event in central Norway and called it the Trondheim event, which probably is related tectonically to Finnmarkian orogenesis. It includes ophiolite emplacement and blueschist and eclogite facies metamorphism (Eide and Lardeaux, 2002; Roberts, 2003). Ophiolites have yielded uranium lead ages of 497–482 Ma (Dunning and Pedersen, 1988; Roberts, 2003), which are similar in age to the Penobscot ophiolites preserved in Newfoundland.
5
In general, the close similarities in age and style of orogenesis between the Penobscottian and Finnmarkian, both positioned on the southern side of Iapetus, invite correlation. If correct, Baltica and adjacent Gondwana (Ganderia and parts of Avalonia; Rogers et al., 2006) may have been characterized by a more or less continuous (excluding transform faults) peri-cratonic arc terrane with a length on the order of thousands of kilometers. Thus consistent to what has been observed in the British Caledonides and the northern Appalachians, Ordovician orogenesis also appears to have taken place on both sides of the Iapetus Ocean in the Scandinavian Caledonides. The Baltic–East European craton (Baltica) also converged with Ganderia and Avalonia during closure of the Tornquist Ocean, which separated Baltica from Gondwana, along the former’s southern margin (Valverde-Vaquero et al., 2006) and which led to formation of the Thor suture. The Tornquist closure was completed by the end of the Ordovician (454–443 Ma) and caused the Shelveian orogeny, whose effects on the exposed parts of Baltica (lower plate) appear to be minor (Torsvik and Rehnstrom, 2003). In general, this collision appears to have been relatively soft, with deformation and metamorphism (low grade) mainly restricted to the collsion zone (Trans-European suture zone [TESZ]; see below). Scandian orogenesis in the Scandinavian Caledonides mainly took place during Silurian times. The Scandian was principally caused by the main collision between Laurentia (Greenland) and the Baltic craton. It is coeval and is correlated with the Salinic orogeny (Laurentia-Ganderia collision) in the northern Appalachians (van Staal, 2005; van Staal et al., 2008). Since Baltica and Ganderia were already together by Late Ordovician times as a result of the Shelveian orogeny (see above and Valverde-Vaquero et al., 2006), the Salinic and Scandian orogenies are both dynamically related to collision of Laurentia (upper plate) and the composite craton comprising Baltica and Ganderia (lower plate). Early Paleozoic Orogenic Events in Eurasian Gondwana The orogenic events that involved the assembly of Paleozoic Europe comprised kinematically and temporally diverse, and in part, unrelated events that were scattered throughout the Paleozoic, culminating in the collision that formed Pangea at the end of the Paleozoic. Orogenic events that took place during the Ordovician include the Shelveian orogeny, which formed as a product of convergence among Baltica, Ganderia, and Avalonia (McKerrow et al., 1991; Pharaoh et al., 1993; van Staal et al., 1998; Torsvik and Rehnstrom, 2003; Valverde-Vaquero et al., 2006). The structures related to the Shelveian orogeny are mainly present in the unexposed basement beneath the North Sea and Denmark. Shelveian structures near the Thor suture were incorporated in a poorly understood but complex, long-lived deformation zone that characterizes the TESZ. The TESZ separates the Baltic–East European craton from younger accreted lithosphere of western Europe over a strike length exceeding 2000 km. Accretion-related deformation in the TESZ possibly had already started during the
6
Van Staal and Hatcher
Late Cambrian–Early Ordovician (Sandomierz orogenic phase of Belka et al., 2000) owing to accretion of a small peri-Gondwanan crustal block to Baltica. Evidence for Early to Late Ordovician orogenic events (referred to as the Sardic or Eo-Variscan) is also preserved farther west in Europe (e.g., Armorican terrane assemblage) from the Alps to Spain and Portugal (von Raumer, 1998; Handy et al., 1999; Martínez Catalán et al., 2002; Matte, 2002; Robardet, 2002; and references therein). This evidence includes arc magmatism, ophiolite generation, polyphase deformation, and eclogite and high-grade metamorphism, which are generally thought to be related to formation of a short-lived volcanicmagmatic arc terrane(s) and backarc basin(s) fringing the Eurasian margin (Fig. 1) of the Gondwanan supercontinent (Paleozoic Cadomia of Stampfli et al., 2002) and an accretionary event. Ordovician orogenesis here does not represent a major collisional event but more of an amalgamation and/or reattachment of the peri-Gondwanan, ribbon-like arc terrane(s) to the Eurasian margin of Gondwana. According to Stampfli and Borel (2002), the reattached arc terranes were assembled into the long Hun superterrane (Fig. 2), which became the leading edge of the Eurasian margin until it rifted off Gondwana as a coherent ribbon continent during the latest Silurian and started to move north, opening part of the Paleotethys in its wake. Reattachment of the Paleozoic Cadomian arc terrane and closure of the intervening marginal basin during the Early to Middle Ordovician took place after departure of Avalonia and concomitant eastward migration of the trailing Rheic Ocean spreading center to the north of the Cadomian arc terrane. The eastward migration of the Rheic spreading center may have put the arc terrane into compression (Stampfli and Borel, 2002) and caused it to re-accrete. Final accretion of the Hun superterrane to Laurussia took place later during the Variscan (Martínez Catalán et al., 1997, 2007; Matte, 2002). The ribbon terranes fringing the Eurasian margin extended at least as far east as the Himalayan margin of India (Stampfli and Borel, 2002; Cocks and Torsvik, 2002). The latter also preserved evidence for extensive Cambrian–Ordovician orogenesis (e.g., Gehrels et al., 2006). Accretion-reattachment of a peri-Gondwanan ribbon-like terrane to the Himalayan margin of India, possibly kinematically related to coeval events along the European segment of this Gondwanan margin, is also an attractive mechanism for explaining Ordovician orogenesis here. Central Asia Orogenic Belt (Altaids) and the Urals The notion that the Ordovician globally was a time of development of a series of rapidly evolving and amalgamating pericratonic arc terranes, which, when built on continental crust commonly formed ribbon continents, may also be valid for the Central Asia orogenic belt of central Asia and the Uralides. The central Asia orogenic belt and narrow Uralides formed mainly during closing of the Aegir Ocean (Fig. 1) and separated the Siberian (Angara) craton from the Baltic–East European craton to the east and the accreted terranes of the Tethysides to the south. Ordovician orogenesis in the Central Asia orogenic belt
mainly involved closure of marginal basins and assembly of separated fragments of the ribbon-shaped Kipchak arc, according to S¸engör and Natal’in (1996). In addition, collision of part of the Kipchak arc with the Mugodzhar arc-microcontinent, which was positioned outboard off the Baltic–East European craton’s eastern margin and separated from it by the Sakmara-Magnitogorsk marginal basin (Fig. 1), may have induced oroclinal bending and strike-slip imbrication of the Kipchak arc. The Mugodzhar arcmicrocontinent was later re-accreted to the East European craton during the middle–late Paleozoic Variscan orogeny (Puchkov, 1997). Kröner et al. (2007), on the other hand, suggested that the central Asia orogenic belt is an accretionary orogen that formed by across-strike rather than by highly oblique accretionary processes, and the precursor of the Kipchak arc was not a ribbon continent. In addition, detailed structural, petrologic, geochemical, and geochronologic studies in the Ol’khon (Baikal) region in southern Siberia by Fedorovsky et al. (2005) suggest that the central Asia orogenic belt includes an Early Ordovician orogenic event. This event is represented by a polydeformed tectonic collage of ophiolite, arc volcanic, plutonic, and sedimentary rocks, produced during its accretion to the southern margin of the Siberian craton. Accretion was oblique, with strike-slip dominating over dip-slip tectonics. Metamorphic grade ranges from granulite facies against the Siberian craton, with little or no metamorphic overprint on the craton itself, to amphibolite facies to the south. Shortening is indicated by craton-vergent, ductile-brittle Paleozoic folds and thrusts in the adjacent Siberian craton, which formed during accretion of the tectonic collage to the craton. An intriguing element of this part of the orogen consists of linear to blocky bodies of marble associated with metasiliciclastic and volcanic rocks to the northwest that give way to dominance of less deformed and metamorphosed volcanic and plutonic rocks to the south. Famatinian Belt in South America Ordovician orogenesis was mainly localized along the protoAndean margin, and is particularly well preserved in north-central Argentina, adjacent Chile and southern Peru, and Bolivia. This belt probably extends through Ecuador into Colombia. Orogenesis comprises subduction-related magmatism, metamorphism, deformation, and foreland basin development, which are variably referred to as the Famatinian and/or Ocloyic orogenic cycle (Ramos, 1988). During the early Paleozoic the Famatinian belt was an active margin with development of a magmatic arc, which appears to have switched on several occasions from a compressional to an extensional state (e.g., Rapela et al., 1998). Transient compression of the magmatic arc caused localized deformation of arc plutons, which started during the latest Cambrian and/or earliest Ordovician (Pankhurst et al., 1998). Middle Ordovician compression of the Puna’s Famatinian arc-backarc basin system closed the backarc basin and led to concomitant deformation, retroarc–foreland basin development (Bahlburg and Hervé, 1997), and metamorphism in the underlying Mesoproterozoic
Global setting of Ordovician orogenesis crust of the Arequipa-Antefolla terrane (Loewy et al., 2004). Farther south, orogenesis mainly involves accretion of the ribbonlike Precordillera-Cuyania microcontinent, whose provenance remains conjectural, although it is generally regarded as having been derived from Laurentia (Ramos et al., 1986; Astini et al., 1995; Thomas and Astini, 1996). Terra Australis Orogen in Australia and Antarctica Early Paleozoic orogenesis is also evident along the eastern margin of Australia, Tasmania, and the Transantarctic Mountains of Antarctica, which were positioned directly along strike of the proto-Andean margin of South America during that time. All three continents formed part of a very extensive convergentaccretionary margin that nearly circumnavigated the entire length of the Pacific margin of the Gondwana supercontinent (Terra Australis orogen of Cawood, 2005). The first phase of Ordovician orogenesis was represented by the waning stages of the predominantly Cambrian Ross-Delamerian orogen (Foden et al., 2006). However, age dating of the slaty cleavage of the most outboard Robertson Bay terrane (northern Victoria Land) suggests that deformation, at least locally, continued well into the Early Ordovician (Dallmeyer and Wright, 1992). This event was followed by the first phase of the Lachlan orogeny during the Late Ordovician (Foster et al., 1999; Foster and Gray, 2000; Collins, 2002). Both the Ross-Delamerian and Lachlan orogenies involve accretion of peri-cratonic volcanic arcs to the AustralianAntarctic cratons related to closure of the intervening marginal basins. The Ross-Delamerian orogeny may have involved more than one subduction zone (see reviews by Boger and Miller, 2004, and Cawood, 2005, and references therein) and was a tectonically complex event. Ophiolite obduction locally accompanied closure of the marginal basins. The passive margin of the Lachlan backarc basin was built partly on the foundered Delamerian Mountains and hence was filled by a large volume of clastic detritus from this orogen. This clastic wedge was incorporated into a thick accretionary wedge during Late Ordovician–Silurian backarc basin closure. The latter was achieved by subduction of marginal basin crust beneath both the passive and active sides of the basin. The Lachlan orogenic events continued into the middle Paleozoic, around the Devonian-Carboniferous boundary, which led to full development of the Lachlan segment (Foster and Gray, 2000) of the Terra Australis orogen. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS The evidence for worldwide Ordovician orogenesis clearly indicates that it was a global phenomenon, but in contrast to the Proterozoic Grenvillian, late Paleozoic Appalachian, or Tertiary Alpine-Himalayan orogenic cycles, it did not involve true continent-continent collision(s), and the major continents remained separated by wide oceans. Instead the Ordovician is marked by formation of peri-cratonic arcs of great strike-length along the margins of Laurentia, Baltica, Siberia, and Gondwana;
7
linear orogenic belts, several characterized by low-grade metamorphism; marginal basins; suprasubduction ophiolites; ribbon microcontinents; global high-water stands; and black shale deposition. Evidence for formation of true intra-oceanic juvenile arcs starved of continental-derived sediment (such as found in the Pacific today) is rare or absent. The latter is significant because it indicates that subduction was localized along continental margins. In addition, prior to the start of the Ordovician, during the Middle and Late Cambrian (513–490 Ma), the margins of virtually all continental cratons underwent either the onset of orogenesis or initiation of subduction. The latter commonly led to generation of large tracts of suprasubduction zone ophiolite and associated boninite. For example, subduction had initiated between 515 and 510 Ma directly outboard of the Ganderian, Baltic, and Laurentian margins (van Staal et al., 1998, 2007) at a time when the Pacific margins of Antarctica and eastern Australia saw the onset of Ross-Delamerian orogenesis. Early Cambrian Pampean orogenesis along the West Gondwanan margin had started slightly earlier (ca. 530 Ma; e.g., Rapela et al., 1998), but may also have been causally related. Combined, these phenomena suggest a causal link to a global-scale plate reorganization. An attractive mechanism was the Early Cambrian terminal suturing between East and West Gondwana (Boger and Miller, 2004; Cawood, 2005) and final assembly of Gondwana, which undoubtedly must have had a major impact on the Early–Middle Cambrian global plate motion budget. The rapid volume increase of oceanic spreading ridges that probably accompanied the global-scale plate reorganization may also be responsible for the eustatic rise in sea level during the Cambrian. Surprisingly, subduction initiation in the Iapetus appears to have taken place near the passive margins of Laurentia, Ganderia, and Baltica. In the Phanerozoic geological record there are no obvious examples in which passive margins were directly transformed into long-lived, active margins. Margins are generally characterized by old, strong oceanic lithosphere and hence are not favorable sites for subduction initiation (Cloetingh et al., 1982). The locations of nascent subduction zones are generally thought to be controlled by the presence of a zone of weakness, buoyancy, and compressive forces, the latter related to convergence (Mueller and Phillips, 1991, and references therein). The presence of compressive forces is critical, because no combination of a lithosphere-penetrating fault and negative buoyancy forces alone would produce a subduction zone (Hall et al., 2003). For this reason, van Staal et al. (2007) proposed that subduction had nucleated on old transform faults and/or abandoned spreading centers near the Laurentian margin of the Iapetus Ocean, created by an Early Cambrian inboard ridge jump(s), whereas on the opposite side of the Iapetus, near Avalonia and Ganderia, an extensive transform fault system had been created by late ridge-trench collisions during the late Neoproterozoic and Early Cambrian, respectively (Rogers et al., 2006). However, in light of the evidence discussed above and elsewhere (Cawood and Buchan, 2007), the possibility that subduction can initiate along a passive margin should not be ruled out. Erickson (1993)
8
Van Staal and Hatcher
suggested that subduction could start near a passive margin, provided that the continent-oceanic interface becomes decoupled as a result of reactivation of old, rifting-related faults during strikeslip or extension. Rollback of downgoing slabs probably was mainly responsible for the great tract of Early Ordovician peri-cratonic arcs and associated marginal basins that were present in the Iapetus, Aegir, and Pacific Oceans. In particular, the propagation of the peri-cratonic arc-backarc systems that were present along the entire length of the Pacific and Iapetan margins of Gondwana (Australia, Antarctica, proto-Andean margin of South America, Ganderia, and Avalonia) and probably also Baltica was very impressive and comparable in scale to the active margins that surrounded the Pacific Ocean during the Mesozoic and Cenozoic. Tensional forces induced by slab rollback probably were also responsible for the terrane dispersal (Avalonia and Ganderia) along Gondwana’s Iapetan margin (e.g. Schultz et al., 2008) and their subsequent motion toward Laurentia (van Staal et al., 1998). Terrane dispersal along the Laurentian margin—e.g., Precordillera (Astini et al., 1995; Thomas and Astini, 1996), several internal southern Appalachian terranes (Merschat et al., 2005; Hatcher and Merschat, 2006), and Dashwoods (Waldron and van Staal, 2001; Cawood et al., 2001)—on the other hand was probably due to an inboard ridge jump from a spreading center positioned close to the Laurentian margin. It calved off ribbonshaped slivers of continental crust from adjacent promontories (van Staal et al., 2007). During the Ordovician, peri-cratonic terranes along the Gondwanan margin underwent several short-lived periods (10– 20 Ma) during which large arc segments switched from extension to compression, commonly leading to closure of the trailing marginal basins or narrow seaways (Zagorevski et al., 2007). The latter appears to be the main cause of Ordovician orogenesis along large segments of the Gondwanan margin (Penobscottian, Famatinian-Ocloyic, Sardic, late Ross-Delamerian, and early Lachlan) and probably also the margin of Baltica (Finnmarkian). Why the stresses along these margins switched from extension to transient compression is poorly constrained and not well understood at present. Collins (2002) proposed that compression was due to short-lived periods of flattening of the downgoing oceanic slab as a result of the entrance of relatively buoyant lithosphere, such as oceanic plateaus, into the subduction zone. Although this model is at first sight appealing and may be applicable to some events, it is difficult to accept that flattening of the circum-Gondwanan subduction zones more or less happened coevally (within a period of 20 m.y.) over a strike length exceeding 10,000 km simply because of arrival of buoyant oceanic crust; neither is there much evidence preserved for accretion of oceanic plateaus during the Early Ordovician along the Pacific and Iapetan margins of Gondwana. Perhaps the switch from extension to compression along the Pacific and Iapetan margins was due to far-field stresses generated by Gondwana’s drift and/ or associated rotation during the Ordovician.
While the Ordovician mobile belts along the Gondwanan margins were dominantly non-accretionary orogens sensu stricto (i.e., little or no accretion of truly exotic terranes, but rather re-accretion of rifted-off arc terranes: the extensional accretionary orogens of Collins, 2002), the Iapetan margin of Laurentia was the recipient of intra-Iapetan and/or Gondwana-derived arc terranes and/or microcontinents (van Staal et al., 1998, 2007; Hibbard, 2000; Hibbard et al., 2007; Merschat et al., 2005; Zagorevski et al., 2006, 2007) and hence was steadily growing in size. This process continued throughout the Paleozoic and basically ended with the formation of Pangea during the Permian. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We thank Jim Hibbard and Monica Escayola for discussions on aspects of Cambrian–Ordovician orogenesis in the Appalachians and the Famatinian and Pampean mountain belts, respectively. Conall MacNiocaill provided us with the original paleomagnetic diagrams published in van Staal et al. (1998), which became the starting points for Figures 1 and 2. Jim Monger, Peter Cawood, and an anonymous reviewer provided insightful comments, all of which improved the manuscript. RDH acknowledges U.S. National Science Foundation grants EAR-8305832, EAR8417894, EAR-8816343, and EAR-9814800. This is Geological Survey of Canada publication 2006371. REFERENCES CITED Andréasson, P.G., Svenningsen, O.M., and Albrecht, L., 1998, Dawn of Phanerozoic orogeny in the North Atlantic tract: Evidence from the Seve-Kalak superterrane, Scandinavian Caledonides: GFF, v. 120, p. 159–172, doi: 10.1080/11035899801202159. Astini, R.A., Benedetto, J.L., and Vaccari, N.E., 1995, The Early Paleozoic evolution of the Argentine Precordillera as a Laurentian rifted, drifted and collided terrane: A geodynamic model: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 107, p. 253–273, doi: 10.1130/0016-7606(1995)107<0253: TEPEOT>2.3.CO;2. Bahlburg, H., and Hervé, F., 1997, Geodynamic evolution and tectonostratigraphic terranes of northwestern Argentina and northern Chile: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 109, p. 869–884, doi: 10.1130/0016 -7606(1997)109<0869:GEATTO>2.3.CO;2. Belka, Z., Ahrendt, H., Franke, W., and Wemmer, K., 2000, The BalticaGondwana suture in central Europe: Evidence from K-Ar ages of detrital muscovites and biogeographical data, in Franke, W., Haak, V., Oncken, O., and Tanner, D., eds., Orogenic Processes: Quantification and Modelling in the Variscan Belt: Geological Society [London] Special Publication 179, p. 87–102. Bergström, S.M., Finney, S.C., Chen, X., Goldman, D., and Leslie, S.A., 2006, Three new Ordovician global stage names: Lethaia, v. 39, p. 287–288, doi: 10.1080/00241160600847439. Boger, S.D., and Miller, J.McL., 2004, Terminal suturing of Gondwana and the onset of the Ross-Delamerian orogeny: The cause and effect of an Early Cambrian reconfiguration of plate motions: Earth and Planetary Science Letters, v. 219, p. 35–48, doi: 10.1016/S0012-821X(03)00692-7. Bream, B.R., 2003, Tectonic implications of geochronology and geochemistry of para- and orthogneisses from the southern Appalachians crystalline core [Ph.D. thesis]: Knoxville, University of Tennessee, 296 p. Cawood, P., 2005, Terra Australis Orogen: Rodinia breakup and development of the Pacific and Iapetus margins of Gondwana during the Neoproterozoic and Paleozoic: Earth-Science Reviews, v. 69, p. 249–279, doi: 10.1016/ j.earscirev.2004.09.001.
Global setting of Ordovician orogenesis Cawood, P.A., and Buchan, C., 2007, Linking accretionary orogenesis with supercontinent assembly: Earth-Science Reviews, v. 82, p. 217–256, doi: 10.1016/j.earscirev.2007.03.003. Cawood, P.A., McCausland, P.J.A., and Dunning, G.R., 2001, Opening Iapetus: Constraints from the Laurentian margin in Newfoundland: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 113, p. 443–453, doi: 10.1130/0016-7606 (2001)113<0443:OICFTL>2.0.CO;2. Chew, D.M., Daly, J.S., Page, L.M., and Kennedy, M.J., 2003, Grampian orogenesis and the development of blueschist-facies metamorphism in western Ireland: Journal of the Geological Society [London], v. 160, p. 911– 924, doi: 10.1144/0016-764903-012. Cloetingh, S.A.P.L., Wortel, M.J.R., and Vlaar, N.J., 1982, Evolution of passive continental margins and initiation of subduction zones: Nature, v. 297, p. 139–142, doi: 10.1038/297139a0. Cocks, L.R.M., and Torsvik, T.H., 2002, Earth geography from 500 to 400 million years ago: A faunal and palaeomagnetic review: Journal of the Geological Society [London], v. 159, p. 631–644, doi: 10.1144/0016 -764901-118. Collins, W.J., 2002, Nature of extensional accretionary orogens: Tectonics, v. 21, p. 6-1–6-12. Colman-Sadd, S.P., Dunning, G.R., and Dec, T., 1992, Dunnage-Gander relationships and Ordovician orogeny in central Newfoundland: A sediment provenance and U/Pb study: American Journal of Science, v. 292, p. 317–355. Dallmeyer, R.D., and Wright, T.O., 1992, Diachronous cleavage development in the Robertson Bay terrane, northern Victoria Land, Antarctica: Tectonic implications: Tectonics, v. 11, p. 437–448, doi: 10.1029/91TC02891. Dallmeyer, R.D., Peucat, J.J., Hirajima, T., and Ohta, Y., 1990, Tectonothermal chronology within a blueschist-eclogite complex, west-central Spitsbergen, Svalbard: Evidence from 40Ar/39Ar and Rb-Sr mineral ages: Lithos, v. 24, p. 291–304, doi: 10.1016/0024-4937(89)90049-2. Dalziel, I.W.D., 1997, Overview: Neoproterozoic-Paleozoic geography and tectonics: Review, hypothesis, environmental speculation: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 109, p. 16–42, doi: 10.1130/0016-7606(1997) 109<0016:ONPGAT>2.3.CO;2. Dalziel, I.W.D., Dalla Salda, L.H., and Gahagan, L.M., 1994, Paleozoic Laurentia-Gondwana interaction and the origin of the AppalachianAndean mountain system: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 106, p. 243–252, doi: 10.1130/0016-7606(1994)106<0243:PLGIAT> 2.3.CO;2. Dewey, J.F., and Mange, M., 1999, Petrography of Ordovician and Silurian sediments in the western Irish Caledonides: Tracers of a short-lived Ordovician continent-arc collision orogeny and the evolution of the Laurentian Appalachian-Caledonian margin, in MacNiocaill, C., and Ryan, P.D., eds., Continental Tectonics: Geological Society [London] Special Publication 164, p. 55–107. Dewey, J.F., and Shackleton, R.M., 1984, A model for the evolution of the Grampian tract in the early Caledonides and Appalachians: Nature, v. 312, p. 115–120, doi: 10.1038/312115a0. Drake, A.A., Jr., Sinha, A.K., Laird, J., and Guy, R.E., 1989, The Taconic orogen, Chapter 3, in Hatcher, R.D., Jr., Thomas, W.A., and Viele, G.W., eds., The Appalachian-Ouachita Orogen in the United States: Boulder, Colorado, Geological Society of America, Geology of North America, v. F-2, p. 101–177. Dunning, G.R., and Pedersen, R.B., 1988, U-Pb ages of ophiolites and arcrelated plutons of the Norwegian Caledonides: Implications for the development of Iapetus: Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology, v. 98, p. 13–23, doi: 10.1007/BF00371904. Eide, E.A., and Lardeaux, J.M., 2002, A relict blueschist in meta-ophiolite from the central Norwegian Caledonides—Discovery and consequences: Lithos, v. 60, p. 1–19, doi: 10.1016/S0024-4937(01)00074-3. Erickson, S.G., 1993, Sedimentary loading, lithospheric flexure, and subduction initiation at passive margins: Geology, v. 21, p. 125–128, doi: 10.1130/ 0091-7613(1993)021<0125:SLLFAS>2.3.CO;2. Fedorovsky, V.S., Donokaya, T.V., Gladkochub, D.P., Khromykh, V.P., Mazukabzov, A.M., Mekhonoshin, A.S., Sklyarov, E.V., Sukhorukov, V., Vladimirov, A.G., Volkova, N.I., and Yudin, D.S., 2005, The Ol’khon collision system (Baikal region), in Sklyarov, E.V., ed., Structural and Tectonic Correlation across the Central Asia Orogenic Collage: Northeastern Segment: Irkutsk, Russia, Russian Academy of Sciences, IGCP 480 Workshop Guidebook, p. 5–31.
9
Finney, S., 2005, Global series and stages for the Ordovician System: A progress report: Geologica Acta, v. 3, p. 309–316. Foden, J., Elburg, M.A., Dougherty-Page, J., and Burtt, A., 2006, The timing and duration of the Delamerian orogeny and implication for Gondwana Assembly: Journal of Geology, v. 114, p. 189–210, doi: 10.1086/ 499570. Foster, D.A., and Gray, D.R., 2000, Evolution and structure of the Lachlan fold belt (orogen) of eastern Australia: Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences, v. 28, p. 47–80, doi: 10.1146/annurev.earth.28.1.47. Foster, D.A., Gray, D.R., and Bucher, M., 1999, Chronology of deformation within the turbidite-dominated, Lachlan orogen: Implications for the tectonic evolution of eastern Australia and Gondwana: Tectonics, v. 18, p. 452–485, doi: 10.1029/1998TC900031. Friedrich, A.M., Bowring, S.A., Martin, M.W., and Hodges, K., 1999, Shortlived continental magmatic arc at Connemara, western Irish Caledonides: Implications for the age of the Grampian orogeny: Geology, v. 27, p. 27–30, doi: 10.1130/0091-7613(1999)027<0027:SLCMAA> 2.3.CO;2. Friend, C.R.L., Jones, K.A., and Burns, I.M., 2000, New high-pressure granulite event in the Moine Supergroup, northern Scotland: Implications for Taconic (early Caledonian) crustal evolution: Geology, v. 28, p. 543–546, doi: 10.1130/0091-7613(2000)28<543:NHGEIT>2.0.CO;2. Gee, D.G., and Page, L.M., 1994, Caledonian terrane assembly on Svalbard: New evidence from 40Ar/39Ar dating in Ny Friesland: American Journal of Science, v. 294, p. 1166–1186. Gee, D.G., Kumpulainen, R., Roberts, D., Stephens, M.B., Thon, A., and Zachrisson, E., 1985, Scandinavian Caledonides tectonostratigraphic map: Geological Survey of Sweden, 1 sheet, scale 1:2,000,000. Gehrels, G.E., DeCelles, P.G., Ojha, T.P., and Upreti, B.N., 2006, Geologic and U-Th-Pb geochronologic evidence for early Paleozoic tectonism in the Kathmandu thrust sheet, central Nepal Himalaya: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 118, p. 185–198, doi: 10.1130/B25753.1. Grenne, T., Ihlen, P.M., and Vokes, F.M., 1999, Scandinavian Caledonide metallogeny in a plate tectonic perspective: Mineralium Deposita, v. 34, p. 422–471, doi: 10.1007/s001260050215. Hall, C.E., Gurnis, M., Sdrolias, M., Lavier, L.L., and Muller, R.D., 2003, Catastrophic initiation of subduction following forced convergence across fracture zones: Earth and Planetary Science Letters, v. 212, p. 15–30, doi: 10.1016/S0012-821X(03)00242-5. Handy, M.R., Franz, L., Heller, F., Janott, B., and Zurbriggen, R., 1999, Multistage accretion and exhumation of continental crust (Ivrea crustal section, Italy and Switzerland): Tectonics, v. 18, p. 1154–1177, doi: 10.1029/1999TC900034. Hatcher, R.D., Jr., 1989, Tectonic synthesis of the US Appalachians, Chapter 14, in Hatcher, R.D., Jr., Thomas, W.A., and Viele, G.W., eds., The Appalachian-Ouachita Orogen in the United States: Boulder, Colorado, Geological Society of America, Geology of North America, v. F-2, p. 511–535. Hatcher, R.D., Jr., and Merschat, A.H., 2006, The Appalachian Inner Piedmont: An exhumed strike-parallel, tectonically forced orogenic channel, in Law, R.D., Searle, M., and Godin, L., eds., Channel Flow, Ductile Extrusion, and Exhumation of Lower-Mid Crust in Continental Collision Zones: Geological Society [London] Special Publication 268, p. 517–540. Hibbard, J.P., 2000, Docking Carolina: Mid-Paleozoic accretion in the southern Appalachians: Geology, v. 28, p. 127–130, doi: 10.1130/0091-7613(2000) 28<127:DCMAIT>2.0.CO;2. Hibbard, J.P., van Staal, C.R., and Rankin, D.W., 2007, A comparative analysis of pre-Silurian building blocks of the northern and southern Appalachians: American Journal of Science, v. 307, p. 23–45, doi: 10.2475/01.2007.02. Holtedahl, O., 1920, Palaeogeography and diastrophism in the Atlantic-Arctic region during Palaeozoic time: American Journal of Science, v. 49, p. 1–25. Karabinos, P., Samson, S.D., Hepburn, J.C., and Stoll, H., 1998, Taconian orogeny in the New England Appalachians: Collision between Laurentia and the Shelburne Falls arc: Geology, v. 26, p. 215–218, doi: 10.1130/0091 -7613(1998)026<0215:TOITNE>2.3.CO;2. Kay, G.M., 1942, Development of the northern Alleghany synclinorium and adjoining region: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 53, p. 1601– 1658. Kröner, A., Windley, B.F., Badarch, G., Tomurtogoo, O., Hegner, E., Jahn, B.M., Gruschka, S., Khain, E.V., Demoux, A., and Wingate, M.T.D.,
10
Van Staal and Hatcher
2007, Accretionary growth and crust formation in the Central Asian orogenic belt and comparison with the Arabian–Nubian Shield, in Hatcher, R.D., Jr., Carlson, M.P., McBride, J.H., and Martínez Catalán, J.R., eds., The 4-D Framework of Continental Crust: Geological Society of America Memoir 200, p. 181–209, doi: 10.1130/2007.1200(11). Loewy, S.L., Connelly, J.N., and Dalziel, I.W.D., 2004, An orphaned basement block: The Arequipa-Antofalla basement of the central Andean margin of South America: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 116, p. 171– 187, doi: 10.1130/B25226.1. Martínez Catalán, J.R., Arenas, R., and Díaz Garcia, F., and Abati, J., 1997, Variscan accretionary complex of northwest Iberia: Terrane correlation and succesion of tectonothermal events: Geology, v. 25, p. 1103–1106. Martínez Catalán, J.R., Díaz García, F., Arenas, R., Abati, J., Castiñeiras, P., González Cuadra, P., Gómez Barreiro, J., and Rubio Pascual, F.J., 2002, Thrust and detachment systems in the Ordenes complex (northwestern Spain): Implications for the Variscan-Appalachian geodynamics, in Martínez Catalán, J.R., Hatcher, R.D., Jr., Arenas, R., and Díaz García, F., eds., Variscan-Appalachian Dynamics: The Building of the Late Paleozoic Basement: Geological Society of America Special Paper 364, p. 163–182. Martínez Catalan, J.R., Arenas, R., Díaz García, F., Gómez Barreiro, J., González Cuadra, P., Abati, J., Castiñeiras, P., Fernández-Suárez, J., Sánchez Martínez, S., Andonaegui, P., González Clavijo, E., Díez Montes, A., Rubio Pascual, F.J., and Valle Aguado, B., 2007, Space and time in the tectonic evolution of the northwestern Iberian Massif: Implications for the comprehension of the Variscan belt, in Hatcher, R.D., Jr., Carlson, M.P., McBride, J.H., and Martínez Catalán, J.R., eds., The 4-D Framework of Continental Crust: Geological Society of America Memoir 200, p. 403–423, doi: 10.1130/2007.1200(21). Matte, Ph., 2002, Variscides between the Appalachians and the Urals: Similarities and differences between Paleozoic subduction and collision belts, in Martínez Catalán, J.R., Hatcher, R.D., Jr., Arenas, R., and Díaz García, F., eds., Variscan-Appalachian dynamics: The Building of the Late Paleozoic Basement: Geological Society of America Special Paper 364, p. 239–251. Max, M.D., Barber, A.J., and Martinez, J., 1990, Terrane assemblage of the Leinster massif, SE Ireland, during the lower Paleozoic: Journal of the Geological Society [London], v. 147, p. 1035–1050, doi: 10.1144/ gsjgs.147.6.1035. McKerrow, W.S., Dewey, J.F., and Scotese, C.R., 1991, The Ordovician and Silurian development of the Iapetus ocean, in Bassett, M.G., Lane, P., and Edwards, D., eds., The Murchison Symposium: Special Paper in Paleontology, v. 44, p. 165–178. McKerrow, W.S., MacNiocaill, C., and Dewey, J.F., 2000, The Caledonian orogeny redefined: Journal of the Geological Society [London], v. 157, p. 1149–1154. Merschat, A.J., and Hatcher, R.D., Jr., 2007, The Cat Square terrane: Possible Siluro-Devonian remnant ocean basin in the Inner Piedmont, southern Appalachians, in Hatcher, R.D., Jr., Carlson, M.P., McBride, J.H., and Martínez Catalán, J.R., eds., The 4-D Framework of Continental Crust: Geological Society of America Memoir 200, p. 553–565, doi: 10.1130/2007.1200(27). Merschat, A.J., Hatcher, R.D., Jr., and Davis, T.L., 2005, 3-D deformation, kinematics, and crustal flow in the northern Inner Piedmont, southern Appalachians, USA: Journal of Structural Geology, v. 27, p. 1252–1281, doi: 10.1016/j.jsg.2004.08.005. Miller, B.V., Fetter, A.H., and Stewart, K.G., 2006, Plutonism in three orogenic pulses, eastern Blue Ridge Province, southern Appalachians: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 118, p. 171–184, doi: 10.1130/B25580.1. Moecher, D.P., Samson, S.D., and Miller, C.F., 2004, Precise time and conditions of peak Taconian granulite facies metamorphism in the southern Appalachian orogen, USA, with implications for zircon behavior during crustal melting events: Journal of Geology, v. 112, p. 289–304, doi: 10.1086/382760. Mueller, S., and Phillips, R.J., 1991, On the initiation of subduction: Journal of Geophysical Research, v. 96, p. 651–665, doi: 10.1029/90JB02237. Pankhurst, R.J., Rapela, C.W., Saavedra, J., Baldo, E., Dahlquist, J., Pascua, I., and Fanning, C.M., 1998, The Famatinian magmatic arc in the central Sierras Pampeanas, an Early to Middle Ordovician continental arc on the Gondwana margin, in Pankhurst, R.J., and Rapela, C.W., eds., The ProtoAndean Margin of Gondwana: Geological Society [London] Special Publication 142, p. 343–367.
Pharaoh, T.C., Brewer, T.S., and Webb, P.C., 1993, Subduction-related magmatism of Late Ordovician age in eastern England: Geological Magazine, v. 130, p. 647–656, doi: 10.1017/S0016756800020951. Puchkov, V.N., 1997, Structure and geodynamics of the Uralian orogen, in Burg, J.-P., and Ford, M., eds., Orogeny through Time: Geological Society [London] Special Publication 121, p. 201–236. Ramos, V.A., 1988, Late Proterozoic–early Paleozoic of South America—A collisional history: Episodes, v. 11, p. 168–174. Ramos, V.A., Jordan, T.E., Allmendinger, R.W., Mpodozis, C., Kay, S.M., Cortes, J.M., and Palma, M., 1986, Paleozoic terranes of the central ArgentinaChilean Andes: Tectonics, v. 5, p. 855–880. Rapela, C.W., Pankhurst, R.J., Casquet, C., Baldo, E., Saavedra, J., and Galindo, C., 1998, Early evolution of the proto-Andean margin of South America: Geology, v. 26, p. 707–710, doi: 10.1130/0091-7613(1998)026 <0707:EEOTPA>2.3.CO;2. Rice, A.H.N., and Frank, W., 2003, The early Caledonian (Finnmarkian) event reassessed in Finnmark: 40Ar/39Ar cleavage age data from the NW Varangerhalvoya, N. Norway: Tectonophysics, v. 374, p. 219–236, doi: 10.1016/ S0040-1951(03)00240-3. Robardet, M., 2002, Alternative approach to the Variscan Belt in southwestern Europe: Preorogenic paleobiogeographical constraints, in Martínez Catalán, J.R., Hatcher, R.D., Jr., Arenas, R., and Díaz García, F., eds., Variscan-Appalachian Dynamics: The Building of the Late Paleozoic Basement: Geological Society of America Special Paper 364, p. 1–15. Roberts, D., 2003, The Scandinavian Caledonides: Event chronology, palaeogeographic settings and likely modern analogues: Tectonophysics, v. 365, p. 283–299, doi: 10.1016/S0040-1951(03)00026-X. Rodgers, J., 1971, The Taconic orogeny: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 82, p. 1141–1177, doi: 10.1130/0016-7606(1971)82[1141:TTO] 2.0.CO;2. Rogers, N., van Staal, C.R., McNicoll, V., Pollock, J., Zagorevski, A., and Whalen, J., 2006, Neoproterozoic and Cambrian arc magmatism along the eastern margin of the Victoria Lake Supergroup: A remnant of Ganderian basement in central Newfoundland?: Precambrian Research, v. 147, p. 320–341, doi: 10.1016/j.precamres.2006.01.025. Schultz, K.J., Stewart, D.B., Tucker, R.D., Pollock, J., and Ayuso, R.A., 2008, The Ellsworth Terrane, coastal Maine: Geochronology, geochemistry, and Nd-Pb isotopic composition—Implications for the rifting of Ganderia: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 120, p. 1134–1158. S¸engör, A.M.C., and Natal’in, B.A., 1996, Paleotectonics of Asia: Fragments of a synthesis, in Yin, A., and Harrison, T.M., eds., The Tectonic Evolution of Asia: Cambridge, UK, Cambridge University Press, p. 486–640. Shanmugam, G., and Lash, G.C., 1982, Analogous tectonic evolution of the Ordovician foredeeps, southern and central Appalachians: Geology, v. 10, p. 562–566, doi: 10.1130/0091-7613(1982)10<562:ATEOTO> 2.0.CO;2. Soper, N.J., Ryan, P.D., and Dewey, J.F., 1999, Age of the Grampian orogeny in Scotland and Ireland: Journal of the Geological Society [London], v. 156, p. 1231–1236, doi: 10.1144/gsjgs.156.6.1231. Stampfli, G.M., and Borel, G.D., 2002, A plate tectonic model for the Paleozoic and Mesozoic constrained by dynamic plate boundaries and restored synthetic oceanic isochrones: Earth and Planetary Science Letters, v. 196, p. 17–33, doi: 10.1016/S0012-821X(01)00588-X. Stampfli, G.M., von Raumer, J.F., and Borel, G.D., 2002, Paleozoic evolution of pre-Variscan terranes: From Gondwana to the Variscan collision, in Martínez Catalán, J.R., Hatcher, R.D., Jr., Arenas, R., and Díaz García, F., eds., Variscan-Appalachian Dynamics: The Building of the Late Paleozoic Basement: Geological Society of America Special Paper 364, p. 263–280. Sturt, B.A., and Ramsay, D.M., 1999, Early Ordovician terrane-linkages between oceanic and continental terranes in the central Norwegian Caledonides: Terra Nova, v. 11, p. 79–85, doi: 10.1046/j.1365-3121.1999.00228.x. Sturt, B.A., and Roberts, D., 1991, Tectonostratigraphic relationships and obduction histories of Scandinavian ophiolitic terranes, in Peters, T., ed., Ophiolite Genesis and Evolution of the Ocean Lithosphere: Ministry of Petroleum and Minerals, Sultanate of Oman, p. 745–769. Thomas, W.A., and Astini, R.A., 1996, The Argentine Precordillera: A traveler from the Ouachita embayment of North American Laurentia: Science, v. 273, p. 752–757, doi: 10.1126/science.273.5276.752. Todd, S.P., Connery, C., Higgs, K.T., and Murphy, F.C., 2000, An Early Ordovician age for the Annascaul Formation of the SE Dingle Peninsula, SW Ireland: Journal of the Geological Society [London], v. 157, p. 823–833.
Global setting of Ordovician orogenesis Torsvik, T.H., and Cocks, R.M., 2005, Norway in space and time: A centennial cavalcade: Norwegian Journal of Geology, v. 85, p. 91–104. Torsvik, T.H., and Rehnstrom, E.F., 2003, The Tornquist Sea and BalticaAvalonia docking: Tectonophysics, v. 362, p. 67–82, doi: 10.1016/S0040 -1951(02)00631-5. Trettin, H.P., 1987, Pearya: A composite terrane with Caledonian affinities in northern Ellesmere Island: Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences, v. 24, p. 224–245. Valverde-Vaquero, P., van Staal, C.R., McNicoll, V., and Dunning, G., 2006, Middle Ordovician magmatism and metamorphism along the Gander margin in Central Newfoundland: Journal of the Geological Society [London], v. 163, p. 347–362, doi: 10.1144/0016-764904-130. van Staal, C.R., 1994, The Brunswick subduction complex in the Canadian Appalachians: Record of the Late Ordovician to Late Silurian collision between Laurentia and the Gander margin of Avalon: Tectonics, v. 13, p. 946–962, doi: 10.1029/93TC03604. van Staal, C.R., 2005, The northern Appalachians, in Selley, R.C., Cocks, R.L.M., and Plimer, I.R., eds., Encyclopedia of Geology: Oxford, UK, Elsevier, v. 4, p. 81–91. van Staal, C.R., Dewey, J.F., MacNiocaill, C., and McKerrow, W.S., 1998, The Cambrian–Silurian tectonic evolution of the northern Appalachians and British Caledonides: History of a complex, west and southwest Pacifictype segment of Iapetus, in Blundell, D.J., and Scott, A.C., eds., Lyell: The Past Is the Key to the Present: Geological Society [London] Special Publication 143, p. 199–242. van Staal, C.R., Whalen, J.B., McNicoll, V.J., Pehrsson, S., Lissenberg, C.J., Zagorevski, A., van Breemen, O., and Jenner, G.A., 2007, The Notre Dame Arc and the Taconic orogeny in Newfoundland, in Hatcher, R.D., Jr., Carlson, M.P., McBride, J.H., and Martínez Catalán, J.R., eds., The 4-D Framework of Continental Crust: Geological Society of America Memoir 200, p. 511–552, doi: 10.1130/2007.1200(26).
11
van Staal, C.R., Currie, K.L., Rowbotham, G., Goodfellow, W., and Rogers, N., 2008, Pressure-temperature paths and exhumation of Late Ordovician-Early Silurian blueschist and associated metamorphic nappes of the Salinic Brunswick subduction complex, northern Appalachians: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 120, p. 1455–1477, doi: 10.1130/B26324.1. von Raumer, J.F., 1998, The Palaeozoic evolution in the Alps: From Gondwana to Pangea: Geologische Rundschau, v. 87, p. 407–435, doi: 10.1007/ s005310050219. Waldron, J.W.F., and van Staal, C.R., 2001, Taconian orogeny and the accretion of the Dashwoods Block; a peri-Laurentian microcontinent in the Iapetus ocean: Geology, v. 29, p. 811–814, doi: 10.1130/0091-7613(2001)029 <0811:TOATAO>2.0.CO;2. Yoshinobu, A.S., Barnes, C.G., Nordgulen, O., Prestvik, T., Fanning, M., and Pedersen, R.B., 2002, Ordovician magmatism, deformation and exhumation in the Caledonides of central Norway: An orphan of the Taconic orogeny: Geology, v. 30, p. 883–886, doi: 10.1130/0091-7613(2002)030 <0883:OMDAEI>2.0.CO;2. Zagorevski, A., Rogers, N., van Staal, C.R., McNicoll, V., Lissenberg, C.J., and Valverde-Vaquero, P., 2006, Lower to Middle Ordovician evolution of peri-Laurentian arc and back-arc complexes in the Iapetus: Constraints from the Annieopsquotch accretionary tract, Central Newfoundland: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 118, p. 324–342, doi: 10.1130/ B25775.1. Zagorevski, A., van Staal, C.R., McNicoll, V.C., and Rogers, N., 2007, Upper Cambrian to Upper Ordovician peri-Gondwanan island arc activity in the Victoria Lake Supergroup, Central Newfoundland: Tectonic development of the northern Ganderian margin: American Journal of Science, v. 307, p. 339–370, doi: 10.2475/02.2007.02. MANUSCRIPT ACCEPTED BY THE SOCIETY 6 OCTOBER 2009
Printed in the USA
The Geological Society of America Special Paper 466 2010
Ordovician explosive volcanism Warren D. Huff† Department of Geology, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, Ohio 45221, USA Stig M. Bergström School of Earth Sciences, Ohio State University, 155 South Oval Mall, Columbus, Ohio 43210, USA Dennis R. Kolata Illinois State Geological Survey, 615 East Peabody Drive, Champaign, Illinois 61820, USA
ABSTRACT Explosive eruptions from volcanoes are recorded in the stratigraphic record throughout the Phanerozoic, but evidence of these eruptions in the form of preserved tephra layers appears to be concentrated at times of active plate collision and concomitant high stands of sea level. The products of volcanic eruptions are lavas, tephra, and gases. Basaltic magmas (low-silica content) are usually erupted in the form of lava flows, whereas rhyolitic magmas (high-silica content) are commonly explosively erupted as plinian and ultraplinian plumes, and associated pyroclastic flows. Fallout tephras are preserved in ancient sedimentary sequences as tonsteins, bentonites, and K-bentonites. Middle Ordovician K-bentonites represent some of the largest known fallout ash deposits in the Phanerozoic Era. They cover minimally 2.2 × 106 km2 in eastern North America and 6.9 × 105 km2 in central and northwestern Europe as a result of explosive volcanism, which affected both Laurentia and Baltica during the closure of the Iapetus Ocean. The three most widespread beds are the Deicke and Millbrig K-bentonites in North America and the Kinnekulle K-bentonite in northwestern Europe. Similar successions are well known in South America and China. Sedimentation rates of volcanic ejecta range from meters per year locally to ~1 mm/1000 yr in the deep sea. Volcanogenic sediments react with seawater to produce secondary phases such as zeolites and clay minerals. Studies of recent ashfall behavior suggest that the preservation potential in the stratigraphic record can be viewed as somewhat remarkable in that such sudden events are preserved at all, much less produce such a wealth of valuable geologic information. OVERVIEW
perturb the Earth’s climate on time scales of one to five years, generally resulting in net global surface cooling. Historically documented eruptions do not, however, represent the full range of intensity and magnitude of all explosive eruptions in geologic history. Deposits in the geologic record provide compelling evidence for eruptions that have been orders of magnitude larger than ones witnessed by mankind. Modern studies have shown
Explosive volcanism plays a fundamental role in the exchange of material and energy from the Earth’s interior to the hydrosphere and atmosphere, and major explosive events can †
E-mail:
[email protected].
Huff, W.D., Bergström, S.M., and Kolata, D.R., 2010, Ordovician explosive volcanism, in Finney, S.C., and Berry, W.B.N., eds., The Ordovician Earth System: Geological Society of America Special Paper 466, p. 13–28, doi: 10.1130/2010.2466(02). For permission to copy, contact
[email protected]. ©2010 The Geological Society of America. All rights reserved.
13
14
Huff et al.
that lithofacies associations of near-vent subaerial phenomena typically include pyroclastic surge deposits, thin welded tuff beds, various lava flow morphologies, abundant erosional unconformities, and fluvial and laharic facies. While volcano-tectonic subsidence might aid in the preservation of such deposits, they generally are not well known in the geologic record. Ash layers in marine sediments, on the other hand, are the best geologic record of explosive volcanism, and many of the Phanerozoic volcanic ash layers represent enormous explosive eruptions that dispersed fine ash and aerosols through the atmosphere over tens of thousands of square kilometers. Most of the world’s southern landmasses were assembled in the supercontinent of Gondwana at the beginning of the Ordovician (Scotese and McKerrow, 1990). As Gondwana drifted gradually toward the South Pole, fragments separated and moved toward the equator (Cocks and Torsvik, 2005). These included Baltica, Siberia, Avalonia, and Laurentia, and much smaller terranes such as the Precordillera of western Argentina and several blocks in south China (Fig. 1). Laurentia and Baltica are estimated to have moved at rates up to 23 cm/yr (Gurnis and Torsvik, 1994). Much of Ordovician explosive volcanism during this time was associated with closure between these various tectonic units. In the Northern Appalachians the timing of the emplacement of the Taconian allochthons and related low-grade metamorphism is constrained by faunal control and isotopic dating, which suggests emplacement ages of latest Middle Ordovician to Late Ordovician (Sasseville et al., 2003). In the southern and central Appalachians the Taconic terrane collided in a non-orthogonal fashion, first in southwest Virginia and then later in southeast Pennsylvania, and consisted of several discrete terranes (Bronson
Hill, etc.) that collided at different times in the Middle Ordovician (Aleinikoff et al., 2003). The northward drift of the Baltoscandian plate and similar activity along the Asian margin of Gondwana produced similar collisions and resulted in dramatic changes in sea level and related climatic and biological changes (Chen and John, 1998; Nordgulen et al., 2003). Each of these tectonic events included subduction-related explosive volcanism, and each has left a record of these eruptions in the form of K-bentonite beds. The Ordovician Period was not necessarily unusual in this respect. Collision-related volcanic ash beds can be found in all periods of the Phanerozoic and well back into Precambrian time. But some of the Ordovician eruptions were exceptionally large and produced massive amounts of fallout ash that, in a contemporary setting, would have been considered disastrous. A major episode of glaciation was centered in Africa during the Late Ordovician that contributed to ecological disruption and mass extinction. Although explosive volcanism was probably not a major contributor to these events, as the extinction events occurred nearly 10 Ma following the largest eruptive events, it no doubt exacerbated already fragile atmospheric conditions and might well have been a minor factor in driving environmental shifts (Rampino and Self, 1992). Miller (1997) examined faunal diversity patterns for the Ordovician and concluded that, while it is tempting to correlate global patterns of biodiversity with global-scale environmental processes, a careful examination of the data argues more strongly for a signal that is, in reality, “an aggregation of patterns and processes that are unique to particular regions or scales” (p. 100). The closing of the Iapetus Ocean, separating Baltica, Avalonia, and Laurentia, occurred by means of the subduction of
4 6 0 Ma 120°W
80°
40°
0°
40°
80°
120°
90°N
60°
30°
Siberia
Laurentia Ia O pet ce u an s
0°
30°
60°
S. America (Gondwana)
Avalonia
Baltica European Massifs
Tornquist Sea
Gondwana 90°S
Figure 1. Paleogeographic map for the Late Ordovician (Tychsen and Harper, 2004).
160°E
Ordovician explosive volcanism oceanic crust beneath, and the consequent collision of, volcanically active island arcs or microplates against the southeastern margin of Laurentia (Scotese and McKerrow, 1991). These collisions were associated with the Taconic orogeny, which began during the Middle Ordovician and produced a complex deformational and sedimentological record that has been extensively documented (Rowley and Kidd, 1981; Stanley and Ratcliffe, 1985; Tucker and Robinson, 1990) and which includes numerous K-bentonite beds in both the eastern North American, British, and Baltoscandian successions. Baltica was surrounded by a passive margin during the Middle Ordovician, but it apparently was in close proximity to Laurentia (Cocks and Torsvik, 2005; Huff et al., 1992; McKerrow et al., 1991). Consequently we attribute the origin of the ~150 Middle Ordovician ash beds in southern Sweden, including the Kinnekulle K-bentonite, to be the explosive volcanic activity in the magmatic arcs associated with the Taconic orogeny. The Ordovician record of explosive volcanism consists of examples of both near-vent pyroclastic flows and ignimbrites and distal sequences of altered fallout tephras known as K-bentonites. Middle Ordovician K-bentonites represent some of the largest known fallout ash deposits in the Phanerozoic Era (Huff et al., 1996). They cover minimally 2.2 × 106 km2 in eastern North America and 6.9 × 10 5 km2 in northwestern Europe as a result of explosive volcanism that affected both Laurentia and Baltica during the closure of the Iapetus Ocean. The three most widespread beds are the Deicke and Millbrig K-bentonites in North America and the Kinnekulle K-bentonite in northwestern Europe. The source vents are thought to have been near the Laurentian margin of Iapetus on an arc or microplate undergoing collision with Laurentia. The volume of ash preserved in the stratigraphic record, converted to dense rock equivalent (DRE) of silicic magma, is minimally estimated to be 943 km3 for the Deicke, 1509 km3 for the Millbrig, and 972 km3 for the Kinnekulle (Huff et al., 1996). One means of expressing the magnitude of an eruption is by use of the volcanic explosivity index (VEI). The VEI was proposed in 1982 as a way to describe the relative size or magnitude of explosive volcanic eruptions (Newhall and Self, 1982). It is a 0-to-8 index of increasing explosivity, and each successive increase in number represents an increase of about a factor of ten. In terms of the VEI these eruptions would probably be ranked between 7 and 8. The Millbrig and Kinnekulle beds are coeval and possibly equivalent, yielding a combined DRE volume of nearly 2500 km3. Some unknown but probably large amount of additional ash fell into oceanic regions of the Iapetus, but these areas became subducted, and the ash is not preserved in the geologic record. The symmetry of the thickness contours (Huff et al., 1992) is suggestive that one or more ash clouds interacting with equatorial stratospheric and tropospheric wind patterns dispersed pyroclastic material to both the northwest and southeast, in terms of Ordovician paleogeography. Well-documented examples of near-vent facies are relatively few, however, and are briefly summarized below. Therefore, the primary focus here will be on the
15
stratigraphic record of distal ashes and their application to stratigraphic, tectonic, and paleogeographic reconstructions. PROXIMAL FACIES Some of the most carefully documented examples of Ordovician near-vent facies have been described in North Wales (Branney and Kokelaar, 1992; Kokelaar et al., 1984; Kokelaar and Königer, 2000), where units such as the Caradocian Pitts Head Tuff represent episodes of felsic arc magmatism. An Early Ordovician episode of subaerial arc magmatism was, in turn, succeeded by extension-related marine-marginal-basin magmatism that produced thick intercalations of volcanic rocks and coeval intrusions (Kokelaar, 1986). Two main subsequent cycles of Ordovician volcanism are distinguished within the Late Ordovician successions, the Llewelyn Volcanic Group and the Snowdon Volcanic Group. In the English Lake District the onset of volcanism occurred in the Late Ordovician and produced the Eycott and Borrowdale Volcanic Groups (Fitton et al., 1982). The Borrowdale Volcanic Group of northwest England represents part of a Late Ordovician ensialic arc related to subduction beneath the Avalonian margin of the Iapetus Ocean during late stages of closure between the continents of Laurentia and Avalonia (Branney, 1991; Millward and Evans, 2003; Millward et al., 1978). The volcanic succession includes subaerially erupted calc-alkaline basaltic, andesitic, and rhyolitic lavas, and pyroclastics with continental margin, subduction-related geochemical affinities. A similar succession known as the Komarov Volcanic Complex (Darriwilian) occurs in the Prague Basin (Chlupácˇ et al., 1998). In the eastern Lachlan Fold Belt in New South Wales, mantlederived shoshonitic magmatism commenced in the Early Ordovician and was replaced by tholeiitic magmatism by Late Ordovician time (Wyborn, 1992). The favored model for the development of the shoshonites is from melting of subcontinental lithosphere that was previously enriched in incompatible elements (notably Ba, K, Sr, and P). The prior enrichment is thought to have taken place by subduction processes in the Cambrian, when basement blocks defined by granite studies were being assembled (Gray and Foster, 2004; Keay et al., 1997). In this scenario, melting in the Ordovician subcontinental lithosphere was triggered by overturning associated with asthenospheric upwelling. Subsequent Silurian and Early Devonian volcanism became strongly felsic as a consequence of the increasing involvement of crustal melting in magma generation. In North America the Late Ordovician Ammonoosuc Volcanics and overlying Partridge Formation have been interpreted to be Ordovician island arc volcanics formed during the Taconic orogeny and emplaced as part of the Bronson Hill Anticlinorium (Hollocher, 1993; Karabinos et al., 1998; Leo, 1985; Schumacher, 1988). These units contain substantial quantities of metamorphosed bimodal mafic and felsic volcanics, including an array of pyroclastics, that have been dated at 453–449 Ma (Tucker and Robinson, 1990). They are thought to have been built on a
16
Huff et al.
margin of Avalonia that collided with the Laurentian margin in Late Ordovician or Early Silurian time (McKerrow et al., 1991). Although these rocks are of the same general age as several widespread distal airfall tephras, now altered to K-bentonites, in the eastern Midcontinent, no correlations have been made that would suggest that the Bronson Hill was a source area for these ashes. DISTAL FACIES Explosive eruptions, particularly those involving magmawater interaction and/or production of large ignimbrites, can generate huge volumes of mostly ash-grade tephra that is widely transported in the atmosphere (Walker, 1981). This material eventually settles out to form distinctive layers that can be correlated across thousands to millions of square kilometers and spanning different depositional environments to form chronostratigraphic markers (Bergström et al., 1995; Drexler et al., 1980; Huff et al., 1996; Rose and Chesner, 1987). Such tephra layers provide information on source magma composition, eruption dynamics, and chronology as deduced from mineral chemistry, granulometric properties, and thickness and distribution patterns (Fredlund et al., 2000; Ninkovich et al., 1978). Finer material (ash <2 mm and lapilli 2–64 mm) is convected upward in an eruption column (Self and Walker, 1994) before settling out downwind to form pyroclastic fall deposits. These deposits are composed of various proportions of vitric, crystal, or lithic particles. Vitric particles are glass shards or pumice derived from magma, whereas crystals are minerals derived from phenocrysts or microlites developed in the magma. Different minerals reflect the composition of different magmas. The most common minerals are shown in Table 1. Thickness and median grain size of ash deposits generally decrease exponentially with distance from a volcano (Walker, 1971). The distribution of ash will depend on the initial grainsize distribution of the ejecta (reflecting fragmentation during the eruption), dynamics of the eruption column, and the column’s interaction with wind (Carey and Sparks, 1986; Sparks et al., 1992). The glass component of the deposited tephra is unstable in most sedimentary environments, and within a relatively short
time following fallout it will begin to devitrify. For example, Hodder et al. (1993) and Naish et al. (1993) reported on studies from North Island, New Zealand, that showed that a downcore decrease in the abundance of volcanic glass is matched by a downcore increase in the abundance of smectite, supporting an early diagenetic origin for the smectite from glass. The transformation is described by a two-stage model involving a combination of parabolic and linear kinetics, reflecting both the hydration of glass and the formation of smectite. Their model indicates that the half-life for volcanic glass is only 1500 yr. Alteration products will depend upon the geochemical nature of the depositional environment, but generally they are zeolites and clay minerals (Hay and Guldman, 1987). Altered ash falls are known in the stratigraphic record as bentonites and K-bentonites. The latter most commonly occur in pre-Mesozoic strata and reflect a more advanced state of diagenetic alteration in which smectite has been metasomatized partially or completely to illite. Paleozoic K-bentonites consist predominantly of clay minerals, dominantly illite and smectite, derived from the breakdown of vitric pumice fragments. However, a small proportion of the beds consists of unaltered primary phenocrystic mineral grains whose morphology, composition, and mineral character retain information generated by the magmatic and tectonic origins of the source volcanoes. FIELD IDENTIFICATION OF K-BENTONITES K-bentonites in unmetamorphosed stratigraphic sections are characterized by a soapy to waxy texture when wet and display a range of colors including light to dark shades of gray, buff, orange, red, and green, depending upon the composition, the activity of circulating groundwater and the extent of local weathering reactions. In cores and subsurface exposures in which there has been less oxidation, K-bentonites are more commonly green to greenish gray to bluish gray (Fig. 2A). Some K-bentonites contain conspicuous and abundant euhedral to anhedral biotite flakes along with quartz, feldspar, amphibole, zircon, and apatite. The typical appearance of a K-bentonite bed in outcrop is that of a fine-grained clay-rich band ranging between 1 mm and 2m in
TABLE 1. COMPOSITION OF MAJOR PHENOCRYST PHASES IN MAGMA Basalt Basaltic Andesite Dacite Rhyolite andesite Plagioclase ** *** *** *** ** Olivine ** ** * Pyroxene ** ** ** * Hornblende * * ** ** * Biotite * ** ** Alkali feldspar * ** *** Quartz ** *** Zircon * ** *** Apatite * ** *** Fe-Ti oxide ** ** * Note: This table is adapted from Schmincke (2004). Mineral occurrences: abundant—***; common—**; rare—*; absent to rare— -.
Ordovician explosive volcanism
17
M D
B
A
M
D C
D
Figure 2. (A) Core from northern Estonia, showing a K-bentonite in an Ordovician carbonate section. (B) Road cut at Gladeville, Tennessee, with Deicke (D) and Millbrig (M) K-bentonites. (C) Deicke and Millbrig at Minke Hollow, Missouri. (D) Deicke at Carthage, Tennessee.
thickness that has been deformed by static load from the enclosing siliciclastic or carbonate sequence (Fig. 2B–2D). Accelerated weathering of K-bentonites causes them to be recessed into the outcrop face. The clay minerals tend to be primarily mixed-layer illite-smectite with lesser amounts of kaolinite (Fig. 3). With increasing burial metamorphism, corrensite (chlorite-smectite)
becomes common. For thicker K-bentonites there is often a zone of nodular or bedded chert in the adjacent strata at both the base and the top of the bed. Although cherts associated with K-bentonites are generally considered to reflect the destiny of silica released during ash devitrification, this relationship has not been thoroughly documented.
18
Huff et al.
33.3Å 9.9Å
7.14Å
3.33Å 3.58Å
5.25Å
12.9Å
5.02Å ARG_22
ARG_23
ARG_47
ARG_50
Figure 3. Sequence of X-ray-diffraction tracings of oriented, glycol-saturated K-bentonite clays from Argentina. Typical of many K-bentonites, these samples range from R0 ordered (ARG_6) to R3 ordered (ARG_22) illite-smectite. Kaolinite is also present in some samples, with peaks at 7.14Å and 3.58Å.
ARG_52 ARG_32
ARG_5B
ARG_6
5
10
15
°2Θ
20
25
30
ORDOVICIAN K-BENTONITES
North America
As with every Phanerozoic System, many Ordovician successions contain a number of K-bentonites representing episodes of explosive volcanism, most commonly associated with collisional tectonic events. Figure 4 shows the global stratigraphic and geographic distribution of K-bentonite beds that have been reported in the literature. Numerous beds have been reported from North and South America, Asia, and Europe. A brief review will summarize some of the pertinent literature for each region.
The Ordovician successions of North America are known to contain nearly 100 K-bentonite beds, one or more of which are distributed over 1.5 × 106 km2 (Kolata et al., 1996). The first report of an Ordovician K-bentonite in North America was made by Ulrich (1888), who described a thick bed of clay in the upper part of what is now known as the Tyrone Limestone, near High Bridge, Kentucky. The Tyrone Limestone, along with the Camp Nelson Limestone and the Oregon Formation, constitute the
UK GLOB. STAGE SER. SER.
UPPER ORDOVICIAN
MIDDLE ORDOVICIAN
LOWER ORDOVICIAN
HIRNANTIAN
KATIAN
SANDBIAN
DAPINGIAN DARRIWILIAN
FLOIAN
TREMADOCIAN
ASHGILL
CARADOC
LLANVIRN
ARENIG
North America
England Wales Norway
Sweden
East
Baltic
Poland
Figure 4. Global stratigraphic distribution of Ordovician K-bentonites.
N. Ireland Scotland China Argentina
Carnic Alps
20
Huff et al.
High Bridge Group of Late Ordovician age. Subsequent work by Nelson (1921, 1922) showed that the bed was volcanogenic in origin and that it could be correlated into Tennessee and Alabama. From the 1930s on, K-bentonite beds of Ordovician age began to be reported from localities throughout eastern North America (Brun and Chagnon, 1979; Huff and Kolata, 1990; Kay, 1935; Kolata et al., 1996; Weaver, 1953). Their clay mineralogy is typically dominated by a regularly interstratified illite-smectite in which the swelling component accounts for 20–40% of the total structure. Two prominent K-bentonites occur within the Tyrone Limestone of central Kentucky (Fig. 5). The Millbrig or “Mud Cave” K-bentonite of local drillers is found at or near the contact between the Tyrone Limestone and the overlying Curdsville Limestone Member of the Lexington Limestone. In parts of the region the Millbrig has been removed along the preLexington disconformity (Cressman, 1973) and hence has somewhat restricted usefulness in regional correlation. The equivalent bed in the Carters Limestone of central Tennessee is the T-4 bed of Wilson (1949). The Deicke or “Pencil Cave” K-bentonite of local usage occurs ~4–6 m below the top of the Tyrone Limestone and varies in thickness from a few centimeters to 1.5 m. Some reworking of the original ash by waves and bottom currents undoubtedly occurred. However, the influx of terrestrial clastics was so minimal as to preclude contamination of the K-bentonite by anything other than carbonate mud. The Deicke is the most persistent K-bentonite marker in the area. Its equivalent in central Tennessee is the T-3 bed (Wilson, 1949). The chemical characteristics of the K-bentonite beds along the Cincinnati Arch were reported by Huff and Türkmenoglu (1981). Using immobile trace elements, the Deicke and Millbrig have been correlated by chemical fingerprinting from southeastern Minnesota to southeastern Missouri (Kolata et al., 1987) and by wireline logs from Missouri to the southern Appalachians and into the Michigan Basin and southern Ontario (Huff and Kolata, 1990; Kolata et al., 1996). Both beds range from 1.5 m or more in thickness in the southern Appalachians (Haynes, 1994) to 3 cm or less in western Iowa. Unpublished data from wireline logs and recent studies of the Bromide Formation in southern Oklahoma suggest that both beds extend farther to the southwest than has previously been mapped. K-bentonites include a thin (5–6 cm) widespread but locally absent bed ~24 m below the top of the Tyrone Limestone, another thin bed between the Deicke and Millbrig, and a bed in the Curdsville Member of the Lexington Limestone that Conkin and Conkin (1992) labeled the Capitol Metabentonite. Huff et al. (1996) calculated the DRE values to be 943 km3 for the Deicke and 1509 km3 for the Millbrig. Kolata et al. (1996) documented the stratigraphic distribution of at least seven named K-bentonite beds traceable throughout the mid-Mohawkian of the upper Mississippi Valley region and subsequently named them the Hagan K-bentonite complex (Kolata et al., 1998). The youngest of the series, the House Springs K-bentonite, can be correlated as far as the southern Appalachians on the basis of both distinctive outcrop and wireline log characteristics. The Hagan complex is a sequence of altered fall-
out ashes that originated from one or more volcanic centers in the southern Appalachian Mountains. The Deicke and Millbrig beds are part of the complex and, to date, have the widest known distribution. Recent discoveries in the Bromide Formation of Oklahoma suggest that both the Deicke and Millbrig are continuous into that area (Leslie et al., 2006). A unique feature of the Hagan complex is that it straddles the Black River–Trenton unconformity, generally believed to be a significant stratigraphic sequence boundary in the eastern United States (Holland and Patzkowsky, 1996) and is traceable throughout much of the southern and central Appalachians. South America Ordovician K-bentonites have been recognized since 1994 in the upper San Juan Limestone and overlying clastic strata of the Gualcamayo and Los Azules Formations in the Argentine Precordillera (Huff et al., 1998). They have been recorded from more than 20 localities, mainly in the eastern thrust belts, in the San Juan Limestone and the overlying Gualcamayo Formation (Fig. 6), but a few ash beds are known also from the central thrust belts. The oldest occur in the upper Lower Ordovician Oepikodus evae conodont Zone and the youngest in the middle Darriwilian Pterograptus elegans Zone. The older beds are in the topmost part of the Lower Ordovician San Juan Limestone in outcrops along the Gualcamayo River in the Guandacol region. In the overlying, ~200 m thick Gualcamayo Formation are numerous ash beds, especially along a small tributary to the Guandacol River where more than 170 separate ash beds have been observed (Huff et al., 1998). The K-bentonite interval contains graptolites of the Isograptus victoriae maximus Zone (Ortega et al., 1993) and is of early Middle Ordovician age (Dapingian and Darriwilian/Global Stages). The top part of the underlying San Juan Limestone contains conodonts of the Oepikodus evae Zone (Hünicken and Pensa, 1989). Because the latter zone is elsewhere no younger than the Isograptus victoriae lunatus Zone, the contact between the San Juan Limestone and the Gualcamayo Formation at this locality may be unconformable, and the succession may have a stratigraphic gap corresponding to the Isograptus victoriae victoriae Zone (Bergström et al., 1996). The widespread occurrence of K-bentonite beds in the Argentine Precordillera constitutes one of the most extensive suites of such beds known anywhere in the Ordovician System of the world and serves as testimony to the high intensity of explosive volcanism along this margin of Gondwana during the early and middle parts of that period. Previous and ongoing studies of the sedimentology, mineralogy, and geochemistry of these beds provide both insight and constraints concerning the magmatic, tectonic, and paleogeographical settings under which the explosive volcanism was generated, and also permit comparisons with lower Paleozoic K-bentonites on other continents. Although recent field work has revealed an extensive succession of K-bentonite beds in the exposures along the Gualcamayo River and its tributaries in western La Rioja Province, most of
Oregon Limestone
40 m
K-b 60 m
20 m
K-b
40 m
K-b
Oregon Limestone
GROU P BRI D GE
50 m
10 m
HI GH
Tyrone Limes tone
Deicke
Camp Nelson Limestone
Millbrig
BRIDGE
GROU P
30 m
H IGH
70 m
LEXINGTON LIMESTONE
Logana Mbr. Capitol
C urd s v ille L im es ton e M em b er
80 m
0m
Figure 5. Stratigraphic column of a portion of the upper Ordovician High Bridge Group and Lexington Limestone in central Kentucky, showing K-bentonite zones, either named or indicated by the K-b symbol. The sequence consists mainly of micritic and heavily burrowed limestone and dolomite.
22
Huff et al.
Figure 6. Stratigraphic sections from the eastern thrust belts of the Precordillera, showing the distribution of K-bentonite (K-b) beds.
our detailed particle-size, mineralogical and geochemical studies to date have been of samples from the extensive sections at Cerro Viejo, near Jáchal, and at Talacasto, north of San Juan, in San Juan Province. Further, whereas most known evidence for pre-Andean explosive volcanism on the Gondwana margin is preserved in the Ordovician sections of the Argentine Precordillera, additional beds of pyroclastic origin have also been reported from the Balcarce Formation of the Tandilia region, south of Buenos Aires (Dristas and Frisicale, 1987). Trace fossils have traditionally been used to assign the Balcarce Formation to the
Lower Ordovician, owing to the presence of Cruziana furcifera (Poiré et al., 2003). At least one, and perhaps as many as four, altered pyroclastic beds occur in the white quartzite sequence that ranges from 18 to 500 m in thickness and unconformably overlies Precambrian basement (Dalla Salda et al., 1988). In contrast to the illite-smectite-rich beds of the Precordillera, the Balcarce beds consist mainly of well-crystallized kaolinite with scattered crystals of altered ilmenite, and are considered to be tonsteins that are the product of altered mafic ashes (Dristas and Frisicale, 1987).
Ordovician explosive volcanism The Argentine sequence is nearly unique in both the number and lateral distribution of K-bentonite beds, and geochemical and grain-size data are consistent with a source area along the Gondwana margin, such as the Puna-Famatina arc (Huff et al., 1998). They provide no supporting evidence of a close association between the Precordillera and Laurentian sedimentary basins at that time, as has been proposed by Thomas and Astini (1996).
23
suggesting a possible link with exotic units of the Scandinavian Caledonides. In the Late Ordovician to Early Silurian (ca. 450–430 Ma) gabbroic to granitic plutons were emplaced into the earlier assembled oceanic and continental rock units. The plutons show evidence of mixed crust and mantle sources and probably represent continued magmatism along the Laurentian margin. These collisions were associated with the Taconic orogeny, which began during the Middle Ordovician and produced a complex deformational and sedimentological record that has been extensively documented (Rowley and Kidd, 1981; Stanley and Ratcliffe, 1985; Tucker and Robinson, 1990) and which includes numerous K-bentonite beds in both the eastern North American, British, and Baltoscandian successions. Baltica was surrounded by a passive margin during the Middle Ordovician, but it apparently was in close proximity to Laurentia (Cocks and Torsvik, 2005; Huff et al., 1992; McKerrow et al., 1991). Consequently we attribute the origin of the ~150 Middle-Upper Ordovician ash beds in southern Sweden, including the Kinnekulle K-bentonite, to be the explosive volcanic activity in the magmatic arcs associated with the Taconian orogeny. Figure 8 shows the comparative stratigraphic distribution of K-bentonites in Baltoscandia and in North America. Many beds are coeval, most notably the Viruan Kinnekulle bed in Baltoscandia and the Mohawkian Millbrig bed in North America. The possibility of a common source for the Millbrig and Kinnekulle giant ash beds was suggested by Huff et al. (1992), but subsequently
Northern and Central Europe The closing of the Iapetus Ocean separating Baltica, Avalonia, and Laurentia (Fig. 7) occurred by means of the subduction of oceanic crust beneath, and the consequent collision of, volcanically active island arcs or microplates against the southeastern margin of Laurentia (Scotese and McKerrow, 1991). An Early to Middle Ordovician (ca. 480–465 Ma) magmatic and tectonometamorphic event is well documented in the Karmøy-Bergen area (southern Norway) and in the Helgeland Nappe Complex (Uppermost Allochthon, north-central Norway) (Nordgulen et al., 2003). Granitoids related to this event are peraluminous and were essentially produced during high-grade metamorphism and anatexis of crustal protoliths during collision and amalgamation of continental fragments above an east-dipping (present coordinates) subducting slab near the Laurentian margin. The northwestern parts of the Scottish and Irish Caledonides, which were derived from the Laurentian margin, underwent time-equivalent deformation, metamorphism, and magmatism,
o
0
Equator
Baltica
Figure 7. Closing of the Iapetus Ocean during the Late Ordovician initiated a line of volcanic arcs parallel to the margins of Laurentia, Avalonia, and Baltica. Yellow areas represent the sites of the most active explosive volcanism, and arrows indicate the direction of ash transport (Bergström et al., 1997a).
Scotland
Laurentia
N. Ireland nt n na cea UK m Re tus O e S. Ireland n Iap ea ia Oc n c ei lo Rh va
A
Nova Scotia
0
o
30 S 1000 km
H. teretiusculus
N. gracilis
C. bicornis
C. americanus
ab. 10 beds
ab. 9 beds
ab. 13 beds K
Darriwilian
Sandbian
D
M
Katian
H. teretiusculus
N. gracilis
Many thin beds
D. foliaceus
D. clingani
P. linearis
P. serra
P. anserinus
A. tvaerensis
A. superbus
Figure 8. Stratigraphic distribution of Ordovician K-bentonites in North America and Europe. Symbols indicate Millbrig (M), Deicke (D), and Kinnekulle (K) K-bentonites. Pertinent graptolite and conodont zones are also shown.
friendvillensis
“sweeti”
aculeata
quadridactylus
compressa
undatus
tenuis
C. spiniferus
confluens O. ruedemanni
G. pygmaeus
velicuspis
robustus
grandis
complanatus ordovicicus
HARJUAN VIRUAN
A. manitoulinensis
BALTOSCANDIC NORTH AMERICAN NORTH MIDCONTINENT ATLANTIC BALTIC BRITISH GLOBAL AMERICAN CONODONT GRAPTOLITE CONODONT GRAPTOLITE STAGES K-BENTONITE SERIES SERIES K-BENTONITE SERIES ZONES ZONES ZONES ZONES Hirnantian shatzeri D. D. D. complanatus divergens
C I N C I N N AT I A N
MOHAWKIAN
WHITEROCKIAN
ASHGILL
CARADOC LLANVIRN
Ordovician explosive volcanism questioned by Haynes et al. (1995). Close examination in the field shows that both beds consist of several internally graded units, suggesting that each bed represents the cumulative deposition of multiple ashfalls in environments characterized by low background sedimentation rates. This aspect was examined in some detail by Kolata et al. (1998) and Haynes (1994) for the Millbrig and by Huff et al. (1999) for the Kinnekulle, all of whom showed systematic mineralogical and grain size variation within individual subunits. Given higher rates of sediment accumulation, it is conceivable that these units could be preserved as a series of closely spaced coeval beds (Bergström et al., 1997b; Huff et al., 1999). The stratigraphic position of these beds in England and Wales is essentially occupied by the massive Snowdon and Borrowdale volcanics of north Wales and the English Lake District, as described above, although a possible occurrence of the Kinnekulle K-bentonite in central Wales was reported by Bergström et al. (1995). The Middle Ordovician section at Röstånga in Scania (southern Sweden) contains 18 K-bentonite beds ranging from 1 to 67 cm in thickness, and all occur within the D. foliaceus (formerly multidens) graptolite Biozone. At Kinnekulle, 290 km to the north, this interval includes the type section of the Kinnekulle K-bentonite, which is widespread and has been correlated throughout northern Europe (Bergström et al., 1995). In most sections the Kinnekulle K-bentonite can be recognized by distinctive geochemical fingerprints, its prominent thickness, and its biostratigraphic and lithostratigraphic position (Bergström et al., 1995). However, at Röstånga, whole rock chemistry is inconclusive at identifying which of the 18 beds is the Kinnekulle K-bentonite. Several beds at Röstånga correlate equally well with the Kinnekulle bed (Bergström et al., 1997b) and thus argue strongly for the composite nature of what is called the Kinnekulle K-bentonite. The Deicke, on the other hand, appears to be a single event deposit, but it has not been recognized in Europe. The regional aspects of ash accumulation on submarine surfaces was discussed by Kolata et al. (1998) and Ver Straeten (2004). The Millbrig in eastern North America and the Kinnekulle in northern Europe both display macroscopic and microscopic evidence of multiple event histories, a characteristic that is explainable only by invoking a history of closely spaced episodic ash accumulations in areas with essentially no background sedimentation (Kolata et al., 1998; Ver Straeten, 2004). Parts of the Millbrig and Kinnekulle beds contain biotite grains that are compositionally indistinguishable from one another, although the majority of samples analyzed show a clear distinction between the two beds on the basis of Fe, Mg, and Ti ratios. Tectonomagmatic discrimination diagrams, combined with Mg number data, indicate that the Deicke-Millbrig-Kinnekulle sequence represents the transformation from calc-alkaline to peraluminous magmatic sources, consistent with a model of progressively evolving magmatism during the closure of the Iapetus Ocean (Huff et al., 2004). Published isotopic age dates are inconclusive as to the precise
25
age of each bed. Thus, it appears that the Millbrig and Kinnekulle beds are coeval and represent separate but simultaneous episodes of explosive volcanism, although it cannot be excluded that parts of these beds were derived from the same eruption(s). Similar intercontinental correlations elsewhere in Europe or China have not yet been attempted. Although most Ordovician K-bentonites reported in Europe are from the British Isles (Fortey et al., 1996; Huff et al., 1993) and Baltoscandia (Bergström et al., 1995; Bergström et al., 1997b), there are also occurrences in Poland (Tomczyk, 1970), the Carnic Alps (Histon et al., 2003), and Lithuania (Sliaupa, 2000). The Alpine orogen represents a collage of Alpine and preAlpine crustal fragments. Schönlaub (1992, 1993) showed that some fragments reflect a true odyssey of near global wandering. These segments have been dated as ranging from Late Ordovician to the Permian on the basis of various rather well-known climate-sensitive biofacies and lithofacies markers, thus adding further to the controversy with regard to the paleogeography and the relationship of the Paleozoic proto-Alps and the coeval neighboring areas such as Baltica, the British Isles, the Prague Basin (Barrandian), Sardinia, Southern France and Spain, and North Africa. Ninety-five K-bentonite levels have been recorded to date from the Upper Ordovician (Ashgill) to Lower Devonian (Lochkov) sequences of the Carnic Alps (Histon et al., 2003). These bentonites occur in shallow- to deep-water fossiliferous marine sediments, suggesting a constant movement from a moderately cold climate of ~50° south latitude in the Late Ordovician to the Devonian reef belt of some 30° south. China The first Ordovician K-bentonite recognized in China (Ross and Naeser, 1984) was a single bed in the Upper Ordovician Wufeng Shale. Subsequently, Huff and Bergström (1995) reported two beds in the Lower Ordovician Ningkuo Formation at Hentang in the Jiangshan Province, southeastern China. More recently, a number of K-bentonite beds have been recognized in the Ordovician–Silurian transition (Ashgill–early Llandovery) in the Yangtze Block, south China (Su et al., 2004). A preliminary analysis of the geochemical composition of the K-bentonites has suggested a parental magma origin of trachyandesite to rhyodacite with some rhyolite in general, which came from volcanic-arc and syn-collision to intra-plate tectonic settings. Regional correlation of these K-bentonite beds indicates that they clearly have the potential of increasing southeastward, both in thickness and grain size. These features suggest that the original volcanic ash may have come from the southeastern part of present-day south China. In addition, along the southeast margin of the Yangtze Block, typical flysch successions have also been identified both from the Zhoujiaxi Group (early Llandovery) and Tianmashan Formation (Ashgillian) in the southern part of Hunan Province, south China. Geochemical analysis of the silicate minerals has
26
Huff et al.
suggested that the flysch successions were deposited in the basin on a passive continental margin (Fletcher et al., 2004). Field observations of the paleocurrents, cross-bedding, ripple marks, and flute marks all suggest that the detrital components must have been transferred from the southeast part of present south China, in good agreement with the conclusion drawn from the analysis of the K-bentonites as mentioned above. Furthermore, the flysch successions both in the Tianmashan Formation and the Zhoujiaxi Group clearly show a northwestward progradation in space and time during the Ordovician–Silurian transition. Both the K-bentonites and flysch successions could be regarded as the products from responding distantly of the area to the continuous northwestward collision and accretion process of the Cathaysia Block to the Yangtze Block (Su et al., 2004). DISCUSSION AND SUMMARY One of the important findings made by the Deep Sea Drilling Project and the Ocean Drilling Program is the discovery that the frequency of ash layers in the sedimentary record at sites close to volcanic arcs is not uniform but highly episodic (Cawood and Leitch, 1997; Pletsch and Reicherter, 2001). Volcanic ash in deepsea sediments may be in discrete layers or dispersed throughout other sediments. Size sorting by the wind may occur with distance from the source. Eruptions into the troposphere (5–12 km altitude) are the most common, with residence times of the ash measured in hours or days. Global ashfalls occur after extremely explosive eruptions inject ash into the stratosphere. Extremely fine-grained ash may remain in the atmosphere for a year or more, and often, prevailing wind patterns will distribute the ash over glacial and arid regions or in the deep ocean. Sedimentation rates of volcanic ejecta range from meters per year locally to ~1 mm/1000 yr in the deep sea. Volcanogenic sediments react with seawater to produce clay minerals. Against this backdrop of the studies of recent ashfall behavior the preservation potential in the stratigraphic record can be viewed as somewhat remarkable in that such sudden events are preserved at all, much less produce such a wealth of valuable geologic information. Burial compaction and devitrification of airfall tephra will typically reduce the thickness of an ash bed by a factor of 3–4× (Huff et al., 1996). Thus, many K-bentonites whose stratigraphic thicknesses are measured in millimeters and yet can be traced for tens or even hundreds of kilometers clearly represent the remains of what, by contemporary standards, would be considered large-magnitude eruptions. What is most remarkable about many Phanerozoic K-bentonites in general, and Ordovician beds in particular, is that their preservation could only occur with relative highstands of sea level and widespread epicontinental flooding. Kolata et al. (1998), and more recently Ver Straeten (2004), have provided compelling arguments for the selective preservation of fallout ash in marine sequences during flooding and highstand intervals. Thus, many of the stratigraphic characteristics of K-bentonites that we see in Ordovician sequences likely represent more general features of ash beds throughout the Phanerozoic.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We are indebted to numerous colleagues and students whose efforts and insights have stimulated much discussion and influenced our thinking about Ordovician volcanism over the years. We particularly wish to acknowledge funding support for various aspects of this work from U.S. National Science Foundation grants EAR-9204893, EAR-9005333, and INT-9513128. REFERENCES CITED Aleinikoff, J.N., Wintsch, R.P., Scott, R.B., Walsh, G.J., and Yacob, E.Y., 2003, New Shrimp U-Pb ages for late Proterozoic and Paleozoic igneous rocks in the Avalon and Bronson Hill terranes of south-central Connecticut: Confirmations and surprises: Geological Society of America Abstracts with Programs, v. 35, no. 3, p. 24. Bergström, S.M., Huff, W.D., Kolata, D.R., and Bauert, H., 1995, Nomenclature, stratigraphy, chemical fingerprinting, and areal distribution of some Middle Ordovician K-bentonites in Baltoscandia: Geologiska Föreningens i Stockholm Förhandlingar, v. 117, p. 1–13. Bergström, S.M., Huff, W.D., Kolata, D.R., Krekeler, M.P.S., Cingolani, C., and Astini, R.A., 1996, Lower and Middle Ordovician K-bentonites in the Precordillera of Argentina: A progress report: XIII Congreso Geológico Argentino y II Congreso de Exploración de Hidrocarburos, v. 5, p. 481–490. Bergström, S.M., Huff, W.D., Kolata, D.R., and Melchin, M.J., 1997a, Occurrence and significance of Silurian K-bentonite beds at Arisaig, Nova Scotia, eastern Canada: Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences, v. 34, p. 1630– 1643, doi: 10.1139/e17-131. Bergström, S.M., Huff, W.D., Kolata, D.R., Yost, D.A., and Hart, C., 1997b, A unique Middle Ordovician K-bentonite bed succession at Röstånga, S. Sweden: Geologiska Föreningens i Stockholm Förhandlingar, v. 119, p. 231–244. Branney, M.J., 1991, Eruption and depositional facies of the Whorneyside Tuff Formation, English Lake District: An exceptionally largemagnitude phreatoplinian eruption: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 103, p. 886–897, doi: 10.1130/0016-7606(1991)103<0886: EADFOT>2.3.CO;2. Branney, M.J., and Kokelaar, P., 1992, A reappraisal of ignimbrite emplacement: Progressive aggradation and changes from particulate to nonparticulate flow during emplacement of high-grade ignimbrite: Bulletin of Volcanology, v. 54, p. 504–520, doi: 10.1007/BF00301396. Brun, J., and Chagnon, A., 1979, Rock stratigraphy and clay mineralogy of volcanic ash beds from the Black River and Trenton Groups (Middle Ordovician) of southern Quebec: Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences, v. 16, p. 1499–1507. Carey, S., and Sparks, R.S.J., 1986, Quantitative models of the fallout and dispersal of tephra from volcanic eruption columns: Bulletin of Volcanology, v. 48, p. 109–125, doi: 10.1007/BF01046546. Cawood, P.A., and Leitch, E.C., 1997, Data report: Phase chemistry of volcanic ash from Site 9491, in Shipley, T.H., Ogawa, Y., Blum, P., and Bahr, J.M., eds., Proceedings of the Ocean Drilling Program, Scientific Results, Volume 156: College Station, Texas, Ocean Drilling Program, p. 343–351. Chen, J.F., and John, B.M., 1998, Crustal evolution of southeastern China: Nd and Sr isotopic evidence: Tectonophysics, v. 284, p. 101–133, doi: 10.1016/S0040-1951(97)00186-8. Chlupácˇ, I., Havlícˇ ek, V., Krˇ íž, J., Kukal, Z., and Štorch, P., 1998, Palaeozoic of the Barrandian (Cambrian to Devonian): Prague, Czech Geological Survey, 183 p. Cocks, L.R.M., and Torsvik, T., 2005, Baltica from the late Precambrian to midPaleozoic times: The gain and loss of a terrane’s identity: Earth-Science Reviews, v. 72, p. 39–66, doi: 10.1016/j.earscirev.2005.04.001. Conkin, J.E., and Conkin, B.M., 1992, Paleozoic metabentonites of North America: Part 3—New Ordovician metabentonites from Kentucky and Tennessee: University of Louisville Studies in Paleontology and Stratigraphy, v. 20, p. 1–30. Cressman, E.R., 1973, Lithostratigraphy and Depositional Environments of the Lexington Limestone (Ordovician) of Central Kentucky: U.S. Geological Survey Professional Paper 768, 61 p.
Ordovician explosive volcanism Dalla Salda, L., Bossi, J., and Cingolani, C., 1988, The Rio de la Plata cratonic region of southwestern Gondwanaland: Episodes, v. 11, p. 263–269. Drexler, J.W., Rose, W.I., Sparks, R.S.J., and Ledbetter, M.T., 1980, The Los Chocoyos Ash, Guatemala: A major stratigraphic marker in Middle America and in three ocean basins: Quaternary Research, v. 13, p. 327–345, doi: 10.1016/0033-5894(80)90061-7. Dristas, J.A., and Frisicale, M.C., 1987, Rocas piroclasticas en el sector suroeste de las sierras septentrionales de la Provincia de Buenos Aires: Revista de la Asociación Argentina de Mineralogia: Petrologia y Sedimentologia, v. 18, p. 33–45. Fitton, J.G., Thirwall, M.F., and Hughes, D.J., 1982, Volcanism in the Caledonian orogenic belt of Britain, in Thorpe, R.S., ed., Andesites: New York, Wiley & Sons, p. 611–636. Fletcher, C.J.N., Chan, L.S., Sewell, R.J., Campbell, S.D.G., and Davis, D.W., 2004, Basement heterogeneity in the Cathaysia crustal block, southeast China, in Malpas, J., Fletcher, C.J.N., Ali, J.R., and Aitchison, J.C., eds., Aspects of the Tectonic Evolution of China: Geological Society [London] Special Publication 226, p. 145–155. Fortey, N.J., Merriman, R.J., and Huff, W.D., 1996, Silurian and Late Ordovician K-bentonites as a record of late Caledonian volcanism in the British Isles: Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, Earth Sciences, v. 86, p. 167–180. Fredlund, M.D., Fredlund, D.G., and Wilson, G.W., 2000, An equation to represent grain-size distribution: Canadian Geotechnical Journal (Revue Canadienne de Géotechnique), v. 37, p. 817–827. Gray, D.R., and Foster, D.A., 2004, Tectonic evolution of the Lachlan Orogen, southeast Australia: Historical review, data synthesis and modern perspectives: Australian Journal of Earth Sciences, v. 51, p. 773–817, doi: 10.1111/j.1400-0952.2004.01092.x. Gurnis, M., and Torsvik, T., 1994, Rapid drift of large continents during the late Precambrian and Paleozoic: Paleomagnetic constraints and dynamic models: Geology, v. 22, p. 1023–1026, doi: 10.1130/0091-7613(1994) 022<1023:RDOLCD>2.3.CO;2. Hay, R.L., and Guldman, S.G., 1987, Diagenetic alteration of silicic ash in Searles Lake, California: Clays and Clay Minerals, v. 35, p. 449–457, doi: 10.1346/CCMN.1987.0350605. Haynes, J.T., 1994, The Ordovician Deicke and Millbrig K-bentonite beds of the Cincinnati Arch and the southern Valley and Ridge Province: Geological Society of America Special Paper 290, p. 1–80. Haynes, J.T., Melson, W.G., and Kunk, M.J., 1995, Composition of biotite phenocrysts in Ordovician tephras casts doubt on the proposed trans-Atlantic correlation of the Millbrig K-bentonite (United States) and the Kinnekulle K-bentonite (Sweden): Geology, v. 23, p. 847–850, doi: 10.1130/0091-7613 (1995)023<0847:COBPIO>2.3.CO;2. Histon, K., Klein, P., Schönlaub, H.P., and Huff, W.D., 2003, Ordovician and Silurian K-bentonites from the Carnic Alps (Austria): Geological Society of America Abstracts with Programs, v. 35, no. 7, p. 174. Hodder, A.P.W., Naish, T.R., and Nelson, C.S., 1993, A two-stage model for the formation of smectite from detrital volcanic glass under shallow-marine conditions: Marine Geology, v. 109, p. 279–285, doi: 10.1016/0025-3227 (93)90066-5. Holland, S.M., and Patzkowsky, M.E., 1996, Sequence stratigraphy and long-term paleoceanographic change in the Middle and Upper Ordovician of the eastern United States, in Witzke, B.J., Ludvigsen, G.A., and Day, J.E., eds., Paleozoic Sequence Stratigraphy: Views from the North American Craton: Geological Society of America Special Paper 306, p. 117–130. Hollocher, K., 1993, Geochemistry and origin of volcanics in the Ordovician Partridge Formation, Bronson Hill anticlinorium, west-central Massachusetts: American Journal of Science, v. 293, p. 671–721. Huff, W.D., and Bergström, S.M., 1995, Castlemainian K-bentonite beds in the Ningkuo Formation of the Jiangshan Province—The first Lower Ordovician K-bentonites found in China: Palaeoworld, v. 5, p. 101–105. Huff, W.D., and Kolata, D.R., 1990, Correlation of the Ordovician Deicke and Millbrig K-bentonites between the Mississippi Valley and the southern Appalachians: American Association of Petroleum Geologists Bulletin, v. 74, p. 1736–1747. Huff, W.D., and Türkmenoglu, A.G., 1981, Chemical characteristics and origin of Ordovician K-bentonites along the Cincinnati arch: Clays and Clay Minerals, v. 29, p. 113–123, doi: 10.1346/CCMN.1981.0290205. Huff, W.D., Bergström, S.M., and Kolata, D.R., 1992, Gigantic Ordovician volcanic ash fall in North America and Europe: Biological, tectonomagmatic, and
27
event-stratigraphic significance: Geology, v. 20, p. 875–878, doi: 10.1130/ 0091-7613(1992)020<0875:GOVAFI>2.3.CO;2. Huff, W.D., Merriman, R.J., Morgan, D.J., and Roberts, B., 1993, Distribution and tectonic setting of Ordovician K-bentonites in the United Kingdom: Geological Magazine, v. 130, p. 93–100, doi: 10.1017/S001675680002375X. Huff, W.D., Kolata, D.R., Bergström, S.M., and Zhang, Y.-S., 1996, Largemagnitude Middle Ordovician volcanic ash falls in North America and Europe: Dimensions, emplacement and post-emplacement characteristics: Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research, v. 73, p. 285–301, doi: 10.1016/0377-0273(96)00025-X. Huff, W.D., Bergström, S.M., Kolata, D.R., Cingolani, C., and Astini, R.A., 1998, Ordovician K-bentonites in the Argentine Precordillera: Relations to Gondwana margin evolution, in Pankhurst, R.J., and Rapela, C.W., eds., The Proto-Andean Margin of Gondwana: Geological Society [London] Special Publication 142, p. 107–126. Huff, W.D., Müftüoglu, E., Kolata, D.R., and Bergström, S.M., 1999, Kbentonite bed preservation and its event stratigraphic significance: Acta Universitatis Carolinae—Geologica, v. 43, p. 491–493. Huff, W.D., Müftüoglu, E., Bergström, S.M., and Kolata, D.R., 2004, Resolving questions of consanguinity between the late Ordovician Deicke, Millbrig and Kinnekulle K-bentonites in North America and Baltoscandia: Geological Society of America Abstracts with Programs, v. 36, no. 5, p. 246. Hünicken, M.A., and Pensa, M.V., 1989, Stratigraphical significance of conodonts in two Middle Ordovician olistoliths, Guandacol River, La Rioja Province, Argentina: Courier Forschungsinstitut Senckenberg, v. 117, p. 51–54. Karabinos, P., Samson, S.D., Hepburn, J.C., and Stoll, H.M., 1998, Taconian orogeny in the New England Appalachians: Collision between Laurentia and the Shelburne Falls arc: Geology, v. 26, p. 215–218, doi: 10.1130/ 0091-7613(1998)026<0215:TOITNE>2.3.CO;2. Kay, G.M., 1935, Distribution of Ordovician altered volcanic materials and related clays: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 46, p. 225–244. Keay, S., Collins, W.J., and McCulloch, M.T., 1997, A three-component Sr-Nd isotopic mixing model for granitoid genesis, Lachlan fold belt, eastern Australia: Geology, v. 25, p. 307–310, doi: 10.1130/0091-7613(1997)025 <0307:ATCSNI>2.3.CO;2. Kokelaar, P., 1986, Petrology and geochemistry of the Rhobell Volcanic Complex; amphibole-dominated fractionation at an early Ordovician arc volcano in North Wales: Journal of Petrology, v. 27, p. 887–914. Kokelaar, P., and Königer, S., 2000, Marine emplacement of welded ignimbrite: The Ordovician Pitts Head Tuff, North Wales: Journal of the Geological Society [London], v. 157, p. 517–536. Kokelaar, B.P., Howells, M.F., Bevins, R.E., Roach, R.A., and Dunkley, P.N., 1984, The Ordovician marginal basin of Wales, in Kokelaar, B.P., and Howells, M.F., eds., Marginal Basin Geology: Volcanic and Associated Sedimentary and Tectonic Processes in Modern and Ancient Marginal Basins: Geological Society [London] Special Publication 16, p. 245–269. Kolata, D.R., Frost, J.K., and Huff, W.D., 1987, Chemical correlation of Kbentonites in the Middle Ordovician Decorah Subgroup, upper Mississippi Valley: Geology, v. 15, p. 208–211, doi: 10.1130/0091-7613(1987) 15<208:CCOKBI>2.0.CO;2. Kolata, D.R., Huff, W.D., and Bergström, S.M., 1996, Ordovician K-bentonites of Eastern North America: Geological Society of America Special Paper 313, p. 1–84. Kolata, D.R., Huff, W.D., and Bergström, S.M., 1998, Nature and regional significance of unconformities associated with the Middle Ordovician Hagan K-bentonite complex in the North American midcontinent: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 110, p. 723–739, doi: 10.1130/0016-7606 (1998)110<0723:NARSOU>2.3.CO;2. Leo, G.W., 1985, Trondhjemite and metamorphosed quartz keratophyre tuff of the Ammonoosuc volcanics (Ordovician), western New Hampshire and adjacent Vermont and Massachusetts: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 96, p. 1493–1507, doi: 10.1130/0016-7606(1985)96<1493: TAMQKT>2.0.CO;2. Leslie, S.A., Bergström, S.M., and Huff, W.D., 2006, Volcanic ash beds discovered in the Upper Bromide Formation and Womble Shale (Ordovician) in Oklahoma: The westernmost occurrences of the Millbrig and Deicke K-bentonites?: Geological Society of America Abstracts with Programs, v. 38, no. 1, p. 31. McKerrow, W.S., Dewey, J.F., and Scotese, C.R., 1991, The Ordovician and Silurian development of the Iapetus Ocean: Special Papers in Palaeontology, v. 44, p. 165–178.
28
Huff et al.
Miller, A.I., 1997, Dissecting global diversity patterns: Examples from the Ordovician radiation: Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, v. 28, p. 85–104, doi: 10.1146/annurev.ecolsys.28.1.85. Millward, D., and Evans, J.A., 2003, U-Pb chronology and duration of late Ordovician magmatism in the English Lake District: Journal of the Geological Society [London], v. 160, p. 773–781, doi: 10.1144/0016-764902-160. Millward, D., Moseley, F., and Soper, N.J., 1978, The Eycott and Borrowdale volcanic rocks, in Moseley, F., ed., The Geology of the Lake District: Yorkshire Geological Society Occasional Publication no. 3, p. 99–120. Naish, T.R., Nelson, C.S., and Hodder, A.P.W., 1993, Evolution of Holocene sedimentary bentonite in a shallow-marine embayment, Firth of Thames, New Zealand: Marine Geology, v. 109, p. 267–278, doi: 10.1016/0025 -3227(93)90065-4. Nelson, W.A., 1921, Notes on a volcanic ash bed in the Ordovician of Middle Tennessee: Tennessee Division of Geology Bulletin 25, p. 46–48. Nelson, W.A., 1922, Volcanic ash beds in the Ordovician of Tennessee, Kentucky and Alabama: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 33, p. 605–615. Newhall, C.G., and Self, S., 1982, The volcanic explosivity index (VEI): An estimate of explosive magnitude for historical volcanism: Journal of Geophysical Research (Oceans & Atmospheres), v. 87, p. 1231–1238. Ninkovich, D., Sparks, R.S.J., and Ledbetter, M.T., 1978, The exceptional magnitude and intensity of the Toba eruption, Sumatra: An example of the use of deep-sea tephra layers as a geological tool: Bulletin of Volcanology, v. 41, p. 286–298, doi: 10.1007/BF02597228. Nordgulen, Ø., Barnes, C.G., Pedersen, R.B., Skår, Ø., and Yoshinobu, A.S., 2003, Mid-Ordovician to Early Silurian granitoid plutonism in the Scandinavian Caledonides: Geological Society of America Abstracts with Programs, v. 35, no. 7, p. 346. Ortega, G., Toro, B., and Brussa, E., 1993, Las zonas de graptolitos de la Formación Gualcamayo (Arenigiano tardío-Llanvirniano temprano) en el norte de la Precordillera (Provincias de La Rioja y San Juan), Argentina: Revista Espanola de Paleontologia, v. 8, p. 207–219. Pletsch, T., and Reicherter, K., 2001, Hole-to-hole correlation of Eocene volcanic ash layers from the Blake Nose depth transect, Leg 171b1, in Kroon, D., Norris, R.D., and Klaus, A., eds., Proceedings of the Ocean Drilling Program, Scientific Results, Volume 171B: College Station, Texas, Ocean Drilling Program, p. 1–10. Poiré, D.G., Spalletti, L.A., and Del Valle, A., 2003, The Cambrian-Ordovician siliciclastic platform of the Balcarce Formation (Tandilia System, Argentina): Facies, trace fossils, palaeoenvironments and sequence stratigraphy: Geologica Acta, v. 1, p. 41–60. Rampino, M.R., and Self, S., 1992, Volcanic winter and accelerated glaciation following the Toba super-eruption: Nature, v. 359, p. 50–52, doi: 10.1038/359050a0. Rose, W.I., and Chesner, C.A., 1987, Dispersal of ash in the great Toba eruption, 75 ka: Geology, v. 15, p. 913–917, doi: 10.1130/0091-7613(1987) 15<913:DOAITG>2.0.CO;2. Ross, R.J., Jr., and Naeser, C.W., 1984, The Ordovician time scale—New refinements, in Bruton, D., ed., Aspects of the Ordovician System: Palaeontological contributions from the University of Oslo, v. 295, p. 5–10. Rowley, D.B., and Kidd, W.S.F., 1981, Stratigraphic relationships and detrital composition of the medial Ordovician flysch of western New England: Implications for the tectonic evolution of the Taconic orogeny: Journal of Geology, v. 89, p. 199–218, doi: 10.1086/628580. Sasseville, C., Tremblay, A., and Clauer, N., 2003, Structural characterization and preliminary K-Ar dating constraints for the Taconian allochthons, Quebec Appalachians: Geological Society of America Abstracts with Programs, v. 35, no. 7, p. 345. Schmincke, H.-U., 2004, Volcanism: New York, Springer-Verlag, 324 p. Schönlaub, H.P., 1992, Stratigraphy, biogeography and paleoclimatology of the Alpine Palaeozoic and its implications for plate movements: Jahrbuch Geologische Bundesanstalt, v. 135, p. 381–418. Schönlaub, H.P., 1993, Stratigraphy, biogeography and climatic relationships of the Alpine Palaeozoic, in von Raumer, J.F., and Neubauer, F., eds., PreMesozoic Geology in the Alps: New York, Springer-Verlag, p. 65–91.
Schumacher, J.C., 1988, Stratigraphy and geochemistry of the Ammonoosuc volcanics, central Massachusetts and southwestern New Hampshire: American Journal of Science, v. 288, p. 619–663. Scotese, C.R., and McKerrow, W.S., 1990, Revised world maps and introduction, in McKerrow, W.S., and Scotese, C.R., eds., Palaeozoic Palaeogeography and Biogeography: Geological Society [London] Memoir 12, p. 1–21. Scotese, C.R., and McKerrow, W.S., 1991, Ordovician plate tectonic reconstructions, in Barnes, C.R., and Williams, S.H., eds., Advances in Ordovician Geology: Geological Survey of Canada Paper 90-9, p. 271–282. Self, S., and Walker, G.P.L., 1994, Ash clouds: Characteristics of eruption columns: U.S. Geological Survey Bulletin 2047, p. 65–74. Sliaupa, S., 2000, Ordovician-Silurian metabentonites in the Baltic basin: A record of surrounding Caledonian volcanic activity: Geophysical Journal, v. 22, p. 128–129. Sparks, R.S.J., Bursik, M.I., Ablay, G.J., Thomas, R.M.E., and Carey, S.N., 1992, Sedimentation of tephra by volcanic plumes: Part 2: Controls on thickness and grain-size variations of tephra fall deposits: Bulletin of Volcanology, v. 54, p. 685–695, doi: 10.1007/BF00430779. Stanley, R.S., and Ratcliffe, N.M., 1985, Tectonic synthesis of the Taconian orogeny in western New England: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 96, p. 1227–1250, doi: 10.1130/0016-7606(1985)96<1227: TSOTTO>2.0.CO;2. Su, W.-B., He, L.-Q., Baum, G.R., Huff, W.D., and Li, Z.-M., 2004, Kbentonites near the Ordovician-Silurian boundary in South China: Contributing factors to the terminal Ordovician multiple-sphere crises?: Florence, Italy, International Geological Congress, 32nd, Abstracts Volume, p. 989. Thomas, W.A., and Astini, R.A., 1996, The Argentine Precordillera: A traveler from the Ouachita embayment of North American Laurentia: Science, v. 273, p. 752–757, doi: 10.1126/science.273.5276.752. Tomczyk, H., 1970, The Silurian, in Sokolowski, S., ed., The Geology of Poland, Volume 1: Warsaw, Wydawnictwa Geologiczne, p. 237–320. Tucker, R.D., and Robinson, P., 1990, Age and setting of the Bronson Hill magmatic arc: A re-evaluation based on U-Pb zircon ages in southern New England: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 102, p. 1404–1419, doi: 10.1130/0016-7606(1990)102<1404:AASOTB>2.3.CO;2. Tychsen, A., and Harper, D.A.T., 2004, Ordovician-Silurian Distribution of Orthida (Palaeozoic Brachiopoda) in the Greater Iapetus Ocean Region: Palaeontologia Electronica, v. 7, http://palaeo-electronica.org/2004_1/ toc.htm. Ulrich, E.O., 1888, Correlation of the Lower Silurian horizons of Tennessee and of the Ohio and Mississippi valleys with those of New York and Canada: American Geologist, v. 1, p. 100–110. Ver Straeten, C.A., 2004, K-bentonites, volcanic ash preservation, and implications for Early to Middle Devonian volcanism in the Acadian orogen, eastern North America: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 116, p. 474–489, doi: 10.1130/B25244.1. Walker, G.P.L., 1971, Grain size characteristics of pyroclastic deposits: Journal of Geology, v. 79, p. 696–714, doi: 10.1086/627699. Walker, G.P.L., 1981, Plinian eruptions and their products: Bulletin of Volcanology, v. 44, p. 223–240, doi: 10.1007/BF02600561. Weaver, C.E., 1953, Mineralogy and petrology of some Ordovician Kbentonites and related limestones: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 64, p. 921–943, doi: 10.1130/0016-7606(1953)64[921:MAPOSO] 2.0.CO;2. Wilson, C.W., Jr., 1949, Pre-Chattanooga Stratigraphy in Central Tennessee: Tennessee Division of Geology Bulletin 56, 407 p. Wyborn, D., 1992, The tectonic significance of Ordovician magmatism in the eastern Lachlan Fold Belt: Tectonophysics, v. 214, p. 177–192, doi: 10.1016/0040-1951(92)90196-D.
MANUSCRIPT ACCEPTED BY THE SOCIETY 6 OCTOBER 2009
Printed in the USA
The Geological Society of America Special Paper 466 2010
Toward identifying potential causes for stratigraphic change in subtropical to tropical Laurentia during the Mohawkian (early Late Ordovician) Achim D. Herrmann† Barrett Honors College, Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona 85287, USA Bernd J. Haupt Earth and Environmental Systems Institute, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, Pennsylvania 16802, USA
ABSTRACT Numerical models of the ocean-climate system indicate that during the early Late Ordovician, water from the higher southern latitudes flowed north toward the equator. The cold-water masses welled up into and penetrated the epicontinental sea of Laurentia. The “cold-water conditions” existed despite high levels of pCO2 (~15× preindustrial atmospheric levels) and did not necessarily indicate the onset of glaciation during the early Late Ordovician; rather the cold-water conditions may indicate the onset of a cooling event that plunged the Ordovician Earth system toward icehouse conditions that would lead later to the end-Ordovician (Hirnantian) glaciation. Furthermore, the observed distribution of cold-water masses across the southeastern margin of Laurentia is consistent with the interpretation that a cold-water event caused a regional extinction in the Mohawkian of eastern Laurentia.
margin of Laurentia indicate upwelling and initiation of glaciation prior to the Hirnantian (ca. 445–443 Ma; Webby et al., 2004). Furthermore, a prolonged glacial episode was suggested based on glaciogenic sediments (Hamoumi, 1999), and early Late Ordovician carbonates from the Baltic platform suggest a temperature drop of as much as 15 °C (Tobin et al., 2005). Identifying the timing of the onset of the Late Ordovician glaciation and the dynamics of the Ordovician climate system leading up to the glaciation is important, because the glaciation coincided with the second largest mass extinction during the Phanerozoic (Sepkoski, 1996). Sedimentological and faunal changes indicate a transition from warm-water to cool-water conditions within the shallow epicontinental sea of Laurentia during the early Late Ordovician (Brookfield and Brett, 1988; Brookfield and Elgadi, 1998;
INTRODUCTION It is generally thought that the Ordovician was characterized by high pCO2 levels (14–16 times preindustrial levels: e.g., Berner and Kothavala, 2001; Crowley and Baum, 1995; Yapp and Poths, 1992) and a warm, greenhouse climate (Barnes, 2004). However, a very short-lived glaciation (~1 m.y.) was proposed based on oxygen and carbon isotope stratigraphy and eustatic sea-level changes during the latest stage of the Ordovician (Brenchley et al., 1995, 2003). The proposed short duration of the glaciation was challenged based on stratigraphic evidence from Late Ordovician deposits. For example, Pope and Steffen (2003) suggested that deposits along the southern †
E-mail:
[email protected].
Herrmann, A.D., and Haupt, B.J., 2010, Toward identifying potential causes for stratigraphic change in subtropical to tropical Laurentia during the Mohawkian (early Late Ordovician), in Finney, S.C., and Berry, W.B.N., eds., The Ordovician Earth System: Geological Society of America Special Paper 466, p. 29–35, doi: 10.1130/2010.2466(03). For permission to copy, contact
[email protected]. ©2010 The Geological Society of America. All rights reserved.
29
30
Herrmann and Haupt
N. Am. series N. Am. stages
Global stages
Katian Sandbian Mohawkian Turinian Chat.
Global series
Upper
Ordovician
System
Holland and Patzkowsky, 1996; Lavoie and Asselin, 1998; Patzkowsky and Holland, 1996; Pope and Read, 1997). This transition occurs across the M4-M5 sequence boundary (Fig. 1), which is part of 14 sequences that are identified in the Mohawkian strata of eastern North America (Holland and Patzkowsky, 1996). In particular the change to a skeletal association that is reminiscent of brynoderm and bryomol associations of modern and ancient temperate water settings supports the notion that cool-water conditions existed in the epicontinental sea. Changes in lithofacies were accompanied by a regional extinction event that occurred over the eastern United States (Patzkowsky and Holland, 1999) and affected articulate brachiopods (Patzkowsky and Holland, 1993, 1996; Patzkowsky et al., 1997), cephalopods (Frey, 1995), corals (Patzkowsky and Holland, 1996), and crinoids (Eckert, 1988). However, this transition from tropical to cold-water carbonates is problematic because paleogeographic reconstructions and paleoclimatic indicators place eastern North America in a tropical to subtropical region during this time (Scotese and McKerrow, 1990, 1991). Nevertheless, based on sequence stratigraphic evidence and carbon isotope data, Saltzman and Young (2005) suggested that the transition to Late Ordovician icehouse conditions occurred during this time. Therefore, global cooling could have led to cool-water conditions in equatorial regions, similar to other icehouse conditions in the Paleozoic (Beauchamp and Desrochers, 1997; Samankassou, 2002). Alternatively, it has also been proposed by several workers that these linked paleontologic and lithologic changes were caused by changing basin bathymetry owing to the Taconic orogeny, changing ocean circulation, and increased siliciclastic detritus from the Taconic highlands that enhanced water turbidity, thereby potentially suppressing and hampering tropical carbonate production (Holland and Patzkowsky, 1996; Patzkowsky and Holland, 1996). The purpose of this paper is to discuss results of numerical model simulations of
Seque.
Age (Ma)
M6
the global ocean-climate systems in the early Late Ordovician and to address the hypothesis of whether global cooling could have led to a substantial decrease in surface temperature in a shallow ocean that was located in tropical to subtropical regions during this period. Our results indicate lower surface temperatures along the eastern and southern margins of Laurentia, places where cool-water conditions were postulated (e.g., Pope and Steffen, 2003). This supports the idea that global cooling contributed to the observed turnover event in the Mohawkian of eastern North America. METHODS The numerical simulations were performed with the Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory Modular Ocean Model (MOM) version 2.2 with a horizontal global resolution of 4° (zonal) by 4° (meridional) and 16 vertical, unevenly spaced levels that gradually widen with depth (50 m for the surface layer, 850 m for the bottommost layer). This grid is fine enough to represent the main ocean circulation features, including vertical thermohaline structure (Haupt and Seidov, 2001), necessary for use of a realistic paleogeography and paleobathymetry (Fig. 2). The Gent and McWilliams parameterization (Gent and McWilliams, 1990) for improved mixing along isopycnal surfaces (rather than across isopycnals to fixed-depth averages) associated with mesoscale eddies (50–100 km scales) was used (Pacanowski, 1996). The use of the Gent-McWilliams mixing improves the ability of coarse-resolution ocean circulation models to simulate large-scale aspects of general circulation. The ocean model is driven at the sea surface by annual mean atmospheric boundary conditions (momentum [wind stress], sea surface temperature, and freshwater flux) derived from the output of the atmospheric general circulation model GENESIS, a three-dimensional
Lithologic changes Cool-water carbonates
Abundant phosphate
High terrigenous influx
Tropical carbonates
Rare phosphate
Low terrigenous influx
M5
Genus extinction (Gma) 0.00
0.40
0.80
1.20
1.60
M4 M3 M2
455
M1
Figure 1. Summary of long-term lithologic changes and biotic turnover for Middle and Upper Ordovician strata of North America. Abrupt shifts in lithofacies occur in the lower Chatfieldian (Chat.) across the M4-M5 sequence boundary. Biotic turnover is shown for articulate brachiopod genera in the eastern United States (Patzkowsky and Holland, 1997). Similar patterns of turnover are known among other benthic invertebrates. Pulses of extinction and migration are coincident with the lithologic changes. Global stages and series are from Finney (2005) and Bergström et al. (2006).
Stratigraphic change in subtropical to tropical Laurentia 0
60 E
120 E
180
120 W
31
60 W
90 N
90 N
35 34 33
60 N
60 N
32 31 30 28
30 N
30 N
26
SI
AU
24
20 0
0
LA
30 S
SA
18
CH I
16 14
BA Gond
temperature [oC]
22
12
30 S
10 8
< 5 cms-1 > 5 cms-1
6 4
60 S
60 S
SCE 90 S
90 S 0
60 E
120 E
180
120 W
2 0 -2
60 W
Figure 2. Paleogeography of the early Late Ordovician (after Scotese and McKerrow, 1990, 1991). Light gray indicates permanently exposed land areas, and flooded areas are outlined with black lines. LA—Laurentia; BA—Baltica; SA—South America; SCE—South Central Europe; SI—Siberia; CH—China; AU—Australia; I—Iapetus; Gond—Gondwana. Note incursion of colder water masses from higher southern latitudes deflected northward toward the southern margin of Laurentia. Simulation was performed with pCO2 level of 15× preindustrial atmospheric levels (PAL) of 280 ppm. Note that 15× PAL is within the proposed range of atmospheric pCO2 during the Late Ordovician (Berner, 1994; Berner and Kothavala, 2001; Yapp and Poths, 1992). Surface ocean circulation patterns of Herrmann et al. (2004a) are indicated by arrows.
atmospheric general circulation model coupled to a 50 m thick slab ocean (Herrmann et al., 2004b). The GENESIS output is averaged (weighted average for monthly output) over the last ten years of model simulation. These surface boundary conditions, which are a function of longitude and latitude, but independent of time, are interpolated from the GENESIS model grid to the MOM grid. The model is run without flux corrections—there are no direct (paleo) observations available—from a state of rest, and no separate spin-up of the ocean is required. Using given prescribed boundary conditions, the three-dimensional (3-D) model ocean adjusts to this particular forcing and produces a unique distribution of salinity, temperature, and velocity. The model is run for an integration period of 10,000 yr. We use built-in model diagnostics, which are large-scale integral quantities like the global energy cycle, gyre components, meridional overturning, and tracer budgets and fluxes to ensure that a steady-state solution is reached. Table 1 shows main surface boundary conditions for the numerical model. Additional details of both model setups and experiments are described in greater detail in Herrmann et al.
(2004a, 2004b). The model results presented here focus on the regional conditions across Laurentia. RESULTS Our numerical model experiments indicate that the Late Ordovician surface ocean was characterized predominantly by zonal circulation patterns in the Northern Hemisphere as a result of zonal wind patterns and a lack of continental barriers. The location of most continents in the Southern Hemisphere obstructed zonal currents and led to the development of large gyre systems in the southern ocean basins between the continents. The gyre system between the eastern margin of Gondwana and Laurentia was characterized by a strong western boundary current along the eastern margin of Gondwana, which transported warm equatorial water masses southward toward higher southern latitudes. Furthermore, surface water masses with lower temperatures from the high latitudes reached subtropical latitudes in the Iapetus region along the southeastern margin of Laurentia (Fig. 2).
32
Herrmann and Haupt TABLE 1. SURFACE BOUNDARY CONDITIONS FOR NUMERICAL MODEL Boundar y conditions Atmospheric CO2 4200 ppm (15× preindustrial level) Other trace gas concentrations Methane: 0.65 ppm; N2O: 0.275 ppm; CFCs: 0 ppm Land-sea distribution Paleogeography of Scotese and McKerrow (1991) Orbital parameters Eccentricity: 0.06; obliquity: 22.0; precession 270, perihelion to N.H. vernal equinox Solar luminosity 95.5% of present-day value Note: For additional details on model setup and boundary conditions, see Herrmann et al. (2004a, 2004b).
The global ocean of the early Late Ordovician is typified by warm surface waters and cold bottom waters (Fig. 3A and 3B). The thermal structure is caused by strong vertical downwelling of water masses in the higher southern latitudes (Fig. 4). A less significant downwelling occurs in the high latitudes of the Northern Hemisphere because of fresher (less saline) and thus less dense waters compared with the high latitudes in the Southern Hemisphere. The strong deepwater formation in the Southern Hemisphere led to a predominantly zonal distribution of temperature and salinity, especially in the Northern Hemisphere. Deepwater masses below 2000 m had a temperature range of ~4–5 °C (Fig. 3A). On the shallow epicontinental sea of Laurentia, temperatures were above 20 °C (Fig. 3B). The water temperatures in the deeper ocean basins surrounding Laurentia decreased with depth to ~10 °C at a depth of ~1000 m. DISCUSSION The lithological and geochemical changes in the Mohawkian of Laurentia include (1) a shift from tropical-type to temperatetype carbonates, (2) an increase in fine-grained siliciclastics, (3) an increase in the amount and distribution of phosphatic sediments, and (4) a positive shift in the δ13C of carbonates and organics (Lavoie and Asselin, 1998; Patzkowsky and Holland, 1996; Patzkowsky et al., 1997; Pope and Read, 1997; Saylor et al., 1997). Global interpretations for this transition suggest that the lithologic and oceanographic changes in North America are the result of the onset of icehouse conditions that eventually led to a glaciation in the latest Ordovician (Lavoie and Asselin, 1998; Pope and Read, 1997). Kolata et al. (2001) identified the Sebree Trough as a potential passageway through which cold water from the southern (margin) opening could penetrate deeply into the shallow epicontinental sea of Laurentia. The presence of cold, open-ocean water masses close to the vicinity of the Sebree Trough was subsequently demonstrated by Pope and Steffen (2003). Pope and Read (1997) had speculated previously about the presence of cold-water masses along the southern margin of Laurentia that were carried into lower latitudes. Our simulations of the global ocean circulation support the hypothesis that cold ocean-water masses must have reached the southern margin of Laurentia during the Late Ordovician (Fig. 2). Using pCO2 values as high as 15× the preindustrial level, our modeled climate scenario indicates that the southern part of
the epicontinental sea, where the cooling event of the TurinianChatfieldian has been identified, had surface waters with temperatures below 28 °C. Temperatures above 28 °C occur only much farther north, closer to the equator. The average marine tropical seawater temperature required for precipitation of most carbonate particles ranges from 28 °C to 30 °C (James, 1997; Lees, 1975; Lees and Buller, 1972). At these temperatures, abiotic precipitation of carbonate is possible, and both pellets and ooid/aggregate grains can form. At the lower temperatures predicted by our modeling, carbonate precipitation rates would have been greatly reduced, consistent with the observed lithological and faunal changes in the Late Ordovician. These changes therefore could have been the result of the onset of the global cooling trend. Our numerical model results show that the global ocean was characterized by cold, deep ocean-water masses of 4 °C, with warmer water near the surface. This is in contrast to geochemical data from the Taconic foreland basin, which suggest that the epicontinental ocean was inversely stratified (Railsback et al., 1990). Based on paleoecological studies (Cisne et al., 1982; Cisne and Rabe, 1978), Railsback et al. (1990) suggested that along a depth transect across the eastern margin of Laurentia, warmer, saline bottom waters underlay colder, brackish surface waters. Two alternative explanations can be used to resolve this disagreement. First, the observed geochemical signal from the Taconic foredeep might be related to the outflow of saline waters from the extensive epicontinental shelf of Laurentia, similar to present-day outflow of warm saline waters from the Mediterranean Sea into the Atlantic Ocean (e.g., Johnson, 1997) and from the Persian Gulf into the Indian Ocean (e.g., Pratt et al., 1999). Second, studies by Railsback et al. (1990) and Ackerly et al. (1993) focused on the brachiopod genus Paucicrura. Ackerly et al. (1993) correlate the number of punctae in Paucicrura rogata with water depth and temperature, and showed that water temperature increased with depth. However, dysoxic conditions within the foreland basin may have contributed to reduced growth rates of brachiopods. Dysoxic conditions would have increased the packing density of punctae per unit area, and therefore packing densities would not have been a good predictor for any depthdependent temperature variations. The cold-water conditions would have existed in the epicontinental sea of Laurentia despite high pCO2 values of 15× preindustrial levels. Using an atmospheric general circulation model, Herrmann et al. (2003) showed that at those pCO2 levels,
12 0
60 E
120 E
180
120 W
60 N
60 N
A
30 N
0
0
16
120 E
12
8
1000
8
8
8
3000 60 S
4000
section at 60.00 oE
90 S 60 E
16
12
12
30 S
90 S 0
20
16
2000
B
60 S
depth [m]
90 N
30 S
20
60 W
90 N
30 N
24
24 20
8
16
12
8
A
0
180
120 W
60 W
5000 -80 -70 -60 -50 -40 -30 -20 -10
S
B
10
Latitude
0
20
40
50
60
70
80
N 24 20
24 20
24 20 16
30
[ o] 24 20 16
12
12
depth [m]
temperature [oC]
28 26 24 22 20 18 16 14 12 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 -1 -2
0
1000 8
8 2000 3000 4000
section at 24.00 oS
5000 80
100
120
140
160
Longitude [o]
W
E
Figure 3. Thermal structure of the (A) global ocean and (B) Laurentian epicontinental sea. Note cold bottom waters and warm shallow water. Locations of cross sections marked on small globe.
8 -15 4 -25
-10 -4
-25
-15
50
60
-4
-4
0 --18
0
0
-20
-4 5
0
-45 -5 0 -4
-25 -30-20 -35 -25 -40
0 -8
depth [m]
-15 -20
-20
-180 0
0
5000 -80 -70 -60 -50 -40 -30 -20 -10
S
0
10
Latitude [o]
20
30
40
70
stream function [Sv]
30 25 20 15 10 8 6 4 2 0 -2 -4 -6 -8 -10 -15 -20 -25 -30
4 0 -8-4 -10
-25 -20 --180 -15 -4
0
-25 5 -1
4000
-40 -3530 - 5 -2-20 -15 0 --18 -4
0 -3
-2-015
3000
-40 -35 -30 -25 0 -2 -15 -10 -8 -4 0
-20
-45
2000
-50 -45 -40 -35 -30 -25 -20 -15 0 -1-8 -4 0
0 -15 -10-8-4
-20 -25 -30 -35 -35
1000
-35
-1 -80-04 108420 -15 -04 4 --180 0--804 -25 -1-52 -1 -15 0 0 1510 -2 -30 5 -30 -2 0 -30 -25 --2105-1-8 0-4 5 4 0 -3
0
80
N
Figure 4. Meridional overturning in the global ocean. The stream function is shown in Sv (1 Sv = 106 m3/s). Areas with negative values are shown with dashed lines.
34
Herrmann and Haupt
accompanied by a high sea level, no ice sheets will form. This indicates that despite the predominance of cold-water masses within the low-latitude shallow epicontinental sea and global cooling, high-latitudinal ice sheets are not necessary (Tobin et al., 2005). Until unambiguous glacial deposits are found, the early Late Ordovician should be referred to as a transition from hothouse to icehouse, rather than the onset of glaciation. CONCLUSIONS Although Laurentia was situated in tropical to subtropical latitudes during the Late Ordovician, lithological evidence indicates that part of this time period was characterized by deposition under cool-water conditions. Whereas Turinian strata of eastern North America contain abundant warm-water carbonates, the Lower Chatfieldian marks a shift to cool-water carbonates, an increase in siliciclastic influx, and phosphatic sediments. Numerical modeling results show that global cooling had a major impact on sea surface temperatures in the shallow epicontinental sea of Laurentia during the Late Ordovician. The presence of cold-water masses that originated in the higher latitudes and were brought toward the southern and eastern margins of Laurentia could have led to the observed stratigraphic changes. Our current global climate model does not include a turbidity function, and this alternative hypothesis cannot be directly tested with our model setup. Future modeling studies therefore need to extend the modeling approach by using high-resolution regional sediment-transport models that include turbidity functions. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This paper was much improved thanks to the careful reviews by M. Saltzman and M. Pope, and to the editorial work of S. Finney. L. Wasylenki provided useful comments that greatly improved this manuscript. ADH expresses his gratitude for financial support from The Sol and Esther Drescher Faculty Development Grant. REFERENCES CITED Ackerly, S.C., Cisne, J.L., Railsback, L.B., and Anderson, T.L., 1993, Punctal density in the Ordovician orthide brachiopod Paucicrura rogata: Anatomical and paleoenvironmental variation: Lethaia, v. 26, p. 17–24, doi: 10.1111/j.1502-3931.1993.tb01506.x. Barnes, C.R., 2004, Ordovician oceans and climate, in Webby, B.D., Paris, F., Droser, M.L., and Percival, I.G., eds., The Great Ordovician Biodiversification Event: New York, Columbia University Press, p. 72–76. Beauchamp, B., and Desrochers, A., 1997, Permian warm- to very cold-water carbonates and cherts in northwest Pangea, in James, N.P., and Clarke, J.A.D., eds., Cool-Water Carbonates, v. 56: Tulsa, SEPM (Society for Sedimentary Geology), p. 327–347. Bergström, S.M., Finney, S.C., Xu, C., Goldman, D., and Leslie, S.A., 2006, Three new Ordovician global stage names: Lethaia, v. 39, p. 287–288, doi: 10.1080/00241160600847439. Berner, R.A., 1994, GEOCARB II: A revised model of atmospheric CO2 over Phanerozoic time: American Journal of Science, v. 294, p. 56–91. Berner, R.A., and Kothavala, Z., 2001, Geocarb III: A revised model of atmospheric CO2 over Phanerozoic time: American Journal of Science, v. 301, p. 182–204, doi: 10.2475/ajs.301.2.182.
Brenchley, P.J., Carden, G.A.F., and Marshall, J.D., 1995, Environmental changes associated with the ‘first strike’ of the Late Ordovician mass extinction: Modern Geology, v. 22, p. 69–82. Brenchley, P.J., Carden, G.A., Hints, L., Kaljo, D., Marshall, J.D., Martma, T., Meidla, T., and Nõlvak, J., 2003, High-resolution isotope stratigraphy of Late Ordovician sequences: Constraints on the timing of bio-events and environmental changes associated with mass extinction and glaciation: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 115, p. 89–104, doi: 10.1130/ 0016-7606(2003)115<0089:HRSISO>2.0.CO;2. Brookfield, M.E., and Brett, C.E., 1988, Paleoenvironments of the MidOrdovician (Upper Caradocian) Trenton limestones of southern Ontario, Canada: Storm sedimentation on a shoal-basin shelf model: Sedimentary Geology, v. 57, p. 75–105, doi: 10.1016/0037-0738(88)90019-X. Brookfield, M.E., and Elgadi, M., 1998, Sedimentology and paleocommunities of the Black River and Trenton Limestone groups (Ordovician), Lake Simcoe area, Ontario: Geological Society of America Annual Meeting, Field Trip Guidebook 6, 35 p. Cisne, J.L., and Rabe, B.D., 1978, Coenocorrelation: Gradient analysis of fossil communities and its applications in stratigraphy: Lethaia, v. 11, p. 341– 364, doi: 10.1111/j.1502-3931.1978.tb01893.x. Cisne, J.L., Karig, D.E., Rabe, B.D., and Hay, B.J., 1982, Topography and tectonics of the Taconic outer trench slope as revealed through gradient analysis of fossil assemblages: Lethaia, v. 15, p. 229–246, doi: 10.1111/ j.1502-3931.1982.tb00647.x. Crowley, T.J., and Baum, S.K., 1995, Reconciling Late Ordovician (440 Ma) glaciation with very high CO2 levels: Journal of Geophysical Research, v. 100, p. 1093–1101, doi: 10.1029/94JD02521. Eckert, J.D., 1988, Late Ordovician extinction of North American and British crinoids: Lethaia, v. 21, p. 147–167, doi: 10.1111/j.1502-3931.1988 .tb00805.x. Finney, S.C., 2005, Global series and stages for the Ordovician System: A progress report: Geologica Acta, v. 3, p. 309–316. Frey, R.C., 1995, Middle and Upper Ordovician Nautiloid Cephalopods of the Cincinnati Arch Region of Kentucky, Indiana, and Ohio, USA: U.S. Geological Survey Professional Paper 1066, 126 p. Gent, P.R., and McWilliams, J.C., 1990, Isopycnal mixing in ocean circulation models: Journal of Physical Oceanography, v. 20, p. 150–155, doi: 10.1175/ 1520-0485(1990)020<0150:IMIOCM>2.0.CO;2. Hamoumi, N., 1999, Upper Ordovician glaciation spreading and its sedimentary record in Moroccan North Gondwana margin, in Kraft, P., and Fatka, O., eds., Quo Vadis Ordovician?: Short papers of the 8th International Symposium on the Ordovician System: Acta Universitatis Carolinae, Geologica, v. 43, p. 111–114. Haupt, B.J., and Seidov, D., 2001, Warm deep-water ocean conveyor during Cretaceous time: Geology, v. 29, p. 295–298, doi: 10.1130/0091-7613 (2001)029<0295:WDWOCD>2.0.CO;2. Herrmann, A.D., Patzkowsky, M.E., and Pollard, D., 2003, Obliquity forcing with 8–12 times pre-industrial levels of atmospheric pCO2 during the Late Ordovician glaciation: Geology, v. 31, p. 485–488, doi: 10.1130/0091 -7613(2003)031<0485:OFWTPL>2.0.CO;2. Herrmann, A.D., Haupt, B.J., Patzkowsky, M.E., Seidov, D., and Slingerland, R.L., 2004a, Response of Late Ordovician paleoceanography to changes in sea level, continental drift, and atmospheric pCO2: Potential causes for long-term cooling and glaciation: Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, v. 210, p. 385–410, doi: 10.1016/j.palaeo.2004.02.034. Herrmann, A.D., Patzkowsky, M.E., and Pollard, D., 2004b, The impact of paleogeography, pCO2, poleward ocean heat transport and sea level change on global cooling during the Late Ordovician: Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, v. 206, p. 59–74, doi: 10.1016/ j.palaeo.2003.12.019. Holland, S.M., and Patzkowsky, M.E., 1996, Sequence stratigraphy and longterm paleoceanographic change in the Middle and Upper Ordovician of the Eastern United States, in Witzke, B.J., Ludvigson, G.A., and Day, J., eds., Paleozoic Sequence Stratigraphy: Views from the North American Craton: Geological Society of America Special Paper 306, p. 117–129. James, N.P., 1997, The cool-water carbonate depositional realm, in James, N.P., and Clarke, J.A.D., eds., Cool-Water Carbonates: SEPM (Society for Sedimentary Geology) Special Publication 56, p. 1–20. Johnson, R.G., 1997, Climate control requires a dam at the Strait of Gibraltar: Eos (Transactions, American Geophysical Union), v. 78, p. 280–281. Kolata, D.R., Huff, W.D., and Bergström, S.M., 2001, The Ordovician Sebree Trough: An oceanic passage to the Midcontinent United States: Geological
Stratigraphic change in subtropical to tropical Laurentia Society of America Bulletin, v. 113, p. 1067–1078, doi: 10.1130/0016 -7606(2001)113<1067:TOSTAO>2.0.CO;2. Lavoie, D., and Asselin, E., 1998, Upper Ordovician facies in the Lac SaintJean outlier, Québec (eastern Canada): Palaeoenvironmental significance for Late Ordovician oceanography: Sedimentology, v. 45, p. 817–832, doi: 10.1046/j.1365-3091.1998.00170.x. Lees, A., 1975, Possible influence of salinity and temperature on modern shelf carbonate sedimentation: Marine Geology, v. 19, p. 159–198, doi: 10.1016/ 0025-3227(75)90067-5. Lees, A., and Buller, A.T., 1972, Modern temperate-water and warm-water shelf carbonate sediments contrasted: Marine Geology, no. 13, p. M67–M73, doi: 10.1016/0025-3227(72)90011-4. Pacanowski, R.C., 1996, MOM 2. Documentation, User’s Guide and Reference Manual, GFDL Ocean Technical Report #3.2: Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory/NOAA, 329 p. Patzkowsky, M.E., and Holland, S.M., 1993, Biotic response to a Middle Ordovician paleoceanographic event in eastern North America: Geology, v. 21, p. 619–622, doi: 10.1130/0091-7613(1993)021<0619:BRTAMO> 2.3.CO;2. Patzkowsky, M.E., and Holland, S.M., 1996, Extinction, invasion and sequence stratigraphy: Patterns of faunal change in the Middle and Upper Ordovician of the eastern United States, in Witzke, B.J., Ludvigson, G.A., and Day, J., eds., Paleozoic Sequence Stratigraphy: Views from the North American Craton: Geological Society of America Special Paper 306, p. 131–142. Patzkowsky, M.E., and Holland, S.M., 1997, Patterns of turnover in Middle and Upper Ordovician brachiopods of the eastern United States: A test of coordinated stasis: Paleobiology, v. 23, p. 420–443. Patzkowsky, M.E., and Holland, S.M., 1999, Biofacies replacement in a sequence stratigraphic framework: Middle and Upper Ordovician of the Nashville Dome, Tennessee, USA: Palaios, v. 14, p. 301–323, doi: 10.2307/ 3515459. Patzkowsky, M.E., Slupik, L.M., Arthur, M.A., Pancost, R.D., and Freeman, K.H., 1997, Late Middle Ordovician environmental change and extinction: Harbinger of the end-Ordovician or continuation of Cambrian patterns?: Geology, v. 25, p. 911–914, doi: 10.1130/0091-7613(1997)025 <0911:LMOECA>2.3.CO;2. Pope, M.C., and Read, J.F., 1997, High-resolution stratigraphy of the Lexington Limestone (late Middle Ordovician), Kentucky, U.S.A.: A cool-water carbonate-clastic ramp in a tectonically active foreland basin, in Noel, P., and Clarke, J.A.D., eds., Cool-Water Carbonates: SEPM (Society for Sedimentary Geology) Special Publication 56, p. 410–429. Pope, M.C., and Steffen, J.B., 2003, Widespread, prolonged late Middle to Late Ordovician upwelling in North America: A proxy record of glacia-
35
tion?: Geology, v. 31, p. 63–66, doi: 10.1130/0091-7613(2003)031<0063: WPLMTL>2.0.CO;2. Pratt, L.J., Johns, W., Murray, S.P., and Katsumata, K., 1999, Hydraulic interpretation of direct measurements in the Bab el Mandab Strait: Journal of Physical Oceanography, v. 29, p. 2769–2784, doi: 10.1175/1520-0485 (1999)029<2769:HIODVM>2.0.CO;2. Railsback, L.B., Ackerly, S.C., Anderson, T.F., and Cisne, J.L., 1990, Palaeontological and isotope evidence for warm saline deep waters in Ordovician oceans: Nature, v. 343, p. 156–159, doi: 10.1038/343156a0. Saltzman, M.R., and Young, S.A., 2005, Long-lived glaciation in the Late Ordovician? Isotopic and sequence-stratigraphic evidence from western Laurentia: Geology, v. 33, p. 109–112, doi: 10.1130/G21219.1. Samankassou, E., 2002, Cool-water carbonates in a paleoequatorial shallowwater environment: The paradox of the Auernig cyclic sediments (Upper Pennsylvanian, Carnic Alps, Austria-Italy) and its implications: Geology, v. 30, p. 655–658, doi: 10.1130/0091-7613(2002)030<0655:CWCIAP> 2.0.CO;2. Saylor, B.Z., Byers, C.W., Choi, Y.S., and Simo, J.A., 1997, Paleoceanography and paleoclimate of the Middle and Upper Ordovician Sinnipee Group: Geological Society of America Abstracts with Programs, v. 29, no. 4, p. 70. Scotese, C.R., and McKerrow, W.S., 1990, Revised world maps and introduction, in McKerrow, W.S., and Scotese, C.R., eds., Palaeozoic palaeogeography and biogeography: Oxford, UK, Geological Society [London] Memoir 12, p. 1–21. Scotese, C.R., and McKerrow, W.S., 1991, Ordovician plate tectonic reconstructions, in Barnes, C.R., and Williams, S.H., eds., Advances in Ordovician Geology: Geological Survey of Canada Paper 90-9, p. 225–234. Sepkoski, J.J., Jr., 1996, Patterns of Phanerozoic extinction: A perspective from global data bases, in Walliser, O.H., ed., Global Events and Event Stratigraphy in the Phanerozoic: Heidelberg, Springer-Verlag, p. 35–51. Tobin, K.J., Bergström, S.M., and De La Garza, P., 2005, A mid-Caradocian (453 Ma) drawdown in atmospheric pCO2 without ice sheet development?: Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, v. 226, no. 3–4, p. 187–204. Webby, B.D., Cooper, R.A., Bergström, S.M., and Paris, F., 2004, Stratigraphic framework and time slices, in Webby, B.D., Paris, F., Droser, M.L., and Percival, I.G., eds., The Great Ordovician Biodiversification Event: New York, Columbia University Press, p. 41–47. Yapp, C.H., and Poths, H., 1992, Ancient atmospheric CO2 inferred from natural goethites: Nature, v. 355, p. 342–344, doi: 10.1038/355342a0. MANUSCRIPT ACCEPTED BY THE SOCIETY 6 OCTOBER 2009
Printed in the USA
The Geological Society of America Special Paper 466 2010
The Upper Ordovician Guttenberg δ 13C excursion (GICE) in North America and Baltoscandia: Occurrence, chronostratigraphic significance, and paleoenvironmental relationships Stig M. Bergström† School of Earth Sciences, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio 43210, USA Birger Schmitz Department of Geology, GeoBiosphere Science Centre, Lund University, Sölvegatan 12, SE-223 62 Lund, Sweden Matthew R. Saltzman School of Earth Sciences, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio 43210, USA Warren D. Huff Department of Geology, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, Ohio 45221, USA
ABSTRACT Two prominent, and apparently globally distributed, δ13C excursions have been documented from the Upper Ordovician, namely the early Katian Guttenberg isotope carbon excursion (GICE) and the latest Ordovician Hirnantian isotope carbon excursion (HICE). The former excursion, which has lower δ13C values than the HICE, is now recorded from dozens of localities in North America and Baltoscandia, and it appears to be present also in China. In North America the GICE ranges from the uppermost Phragmodus undatus Midcontinent Conodont Zone to near the top of the Plectodina tenuis Midcontinent Conodont Zone, an interval corresponding to the lower part of the Diplacanthograptus caudatus Global Graptolite Zone. The base of the GICE lies somewhat above the Millbrig K-bentonite. In Baltoscandia the GICE occurs in the upper Diplograptus foliaceus through the lower Dicranograptus clingani Graptolite Zones, and in the upper Amorphognathus tvaerensis Conodont Zone. Its base is a few meters above the widespread Kinnekulle K-bentonite. In Baltoscandia and in Oklahoma the GICE ranges through a part of the Spinachitina cervicornis Chitinozoan Zone. In North America the GICE is regionally in a transgressive-regressive succession. The bathymetric conditions in the GICE interval in Baltoscandia were somewhat complex and have been the subject of different interpretations, but there is no obvious correlation between the GICE and apparent sea level changes. A review of the relations between the GICE and potential climatic and water temperature
†
E-mail:
[email protected].
Bergström, S.M., Schmitz, B., Saltzman, M.R., and Huff, W.D., 2010, The Upper Ordovician Guttenberg δ13C excursion (GICE) in North America and Baltoscandia: Occurrence, chronostratigraphic significance, and paleoenvironmental relationships, in Finney, S.C., and Berry, W.B.N., eds., The Ordovician Earth System: Geological Society of America Special Paper 466, p. 37–67, doi: 10.1130/2010.2466(04). For permission to copy, contact
[email protected]. ©2010 The Geological Society of America. All rights reserved.
37
38
Bergström et al. indicators, such as lithofacies, faunas, and 18O geochemistry, does not suggest a close correlation to specific environmental conditions. The cause of formation of the GICE is enigmatic, but there is no direct evidence that it was coeval with a period of extensive glaciation in the Gondwana. The GICE is a powerful chemostratigraphic tool that is useful for detailed local and even transatlantic correlations.
INTRODUCTION Conspicuous, geographically widespread variations of δ13C values in the stratigraphic record have in recent years proved to have great utility as tools in chemostratigraphic research. Such changes, known as excursions, frequently provide new insights into stratigraphic relationships at both the local and regional scales. In the case of the Ordovician, two major, apparently global, positive δ13C excursions are currently recognized, namely the early Late Ordovician Guttenberg isotope carbon excursion (GICE) and the latest Late Ordovician Hirnantian isotope carbon excursion (HICE). Although additional Katian excursions have been recognized in both North America (Ludvigson et al., 2004) and Europe (Kaljo et al., 2004), these are mostly of smaller magnitude and are as yet not documented outside these regions. The HICE, which is a prominent positive excursion, has been studied more intensely than the GICE and is documented from North America, the British Isles, China, South America, and Baltoscandia (Bergström et al., 2006). It has been widely employed in Hirnantian chronostratigraphy. The GICE, which is a somewhat less conspicuous, but still prominent, excursion in the Ordovician δ13C curve, has so far been recorded from a substantial number of sites in North America and northern Europe, and it also occurs in China (Bergström et al., 2009). The literature on the HICE has expanded rapidly during the last decade and is considerably more extensive than that dealing with the GICE. A recent paper (Bergström et al., 2006) reviewed several aspects of the HICE, especially its global chemostratigraphic significance and its putative relations to the Gondwana glaciation. The purpose of the present paper is to summarize pertinent data on the GICE from North America and Europe, including new information from sections in Sweden, and assess its local and transatlantic chemostratigraphic significance. This review, the first to deal in some detail with both North American and European records of the GICE, also includes brief discussions of its relations to depositional environments (especially bathymetric conditions) and possible glacial periods as well as proposed hypotheses to explain its formation. DISCOVERY AND CONCEPT OF THE GICE The discovery of the GICE dates back to the mid-1980s, when Hatch et al. (1987) found elevated δ13C values in oils and rock samples from nine drill cores from Iowa and Kansas. Samples from the Guttenberg Member of the Decorah Formation (Fig. 1) showed heavy δ13C values of up to +4‰ from baseline values
ranging from –3‰ to +0.5‰. This isotope excursion was in an interval a few meters thick well above the Millbrig K-bentonite in a highly condensed section. Ludvigson et al. (1996) presented a large amount of information in a comprehensive sedimentological, chemical, and petrographic study. Later, Ludvigson et al. (2000a) published additional important δ13C data based on rock samples from three outcrops through the same stratigraphic interval in Iowa, Wisconsin, and Missouri. Further information was provided by Ludvigson et al. (1990, 2000b, 2001a, 2001b) and Smith et al. (2000). Finally, Ludvigson et al. (2004) published a comprehensive chemostratigraphic and lithologic investigation of the excursion interval in which they formally labeled the positive excursion just above the Elkport K-bentonite within the Guttenberg Member of the Chatfieldian Decorah Formation as the Guttenberg excursion. This concept of the Guttenberg excursion (GICE) has been followed herein and is the same as that used by several other authors such as Saltzman et al. (2001, 2003a, 2003b), Bergström et al. (2001, 2004), Young et al. (2003a, 2003b, 2004a, 2004b, 2005) and Barta et al. (2003, 2004). It is important to recognize this concept of the GICE because Ludvigson et al. (2004) distinguished and named four older, apparently not global and hence regionally less significant, excursions in the succession just below the GICE in eastern Iowa. These should not be confused with the GICE, and they are apparently more local in their distribution than the GICE, as will be discussed below. Likewise, Kaljo et al. (2004) and Bergström et al. (2007) recently named several excursions above the GICE in the Estonian and North American successions, respectively. GICE IN NORTH AMERICA Since the initial discovery of the GICE, this excursion has been recorded at many localities in more than a dozen states and provinces in North America (Fig. 2). It has been particularly intensely studied in the Upper Mississippi Valley, but its currently known distribution area includes a large part of the North American Midcontinent as well as the Appalachians and the Great Basin in Nevada. In all probability, future work will show that it is present in all parts of the continent where rocks of suitable age and facies are present. Format restrictions of the present paper do not permit discussion of all North American GICE records, and we have therefore selected for review only particularly important occurrences, generally 1–3 for each outcrop region. Each of these records is discussed separately below and illustrated by the pertinent δ13C curve. For a general classification of the North American stratigraphic units discussed, see Figure 3. It should be noted
Upper Ordovician Guttenberg δ13C excursion (GICE) in North America and Baltoscandia
Figure 1. GICE curve in the Guttenberg Member of the Decorah Formation in the Cominco Millbrook Farms SS-9 drill core from eastern Iowa, one of the sections in which the GICE was first recorded (Hatch et al., 1987). The δ13C curve is based on Pancost et al. (1999), as interpreted by Ludvigson et al. (2004). Note the GICE peak of ~+1.5‰ in the Guttenberg Member as compared with δ13C baseline values of ~ –1‰ to 0‰ in the Platteville and Dunleith Formations. Also note that the Deicke and Millbrig K-bentonites are not present in this core, apparently because this interval is not preserved at the PlattevilleDecorah unconformity of Ludvigson et al. (2004, Fig. 5).
that for series classification we use the recently approved global standard series in which the provincial North American Mohawkian Series is referred to the global Upper Ordovician Series. Upper Mississippi Valley To date, the GICE has been most intensely studied in the Upper Mississippi Valley, a region that includes the important Upper Ordovician outcrop areas in Iowa, Wisconsin, Illinois, Minnesota, and Missouri. More than a dozen GICE sites have been recorded, and major references include Hatch et al. (1987), Hasiuk et al. (2001), Ludvigson et al. (1996, 2000a, 2000b, 2001a,
39
2001b, 2004), Smith et al. (2000), Patzkowsky et al. (1997), Pancost et al. (1998, 1999), Simo et al. (2003), Saltzman et al. (2003a, 2003b), and Witzke et al. (2000). A typical GICE curve from this region is illustrated in Figure 4. As recently described in detail by Ludvigson et al. (2004), the GICE occurs in a stratigraphic interval characterized by much condensation and the presence of significant stratigraphic gaps that locally may include the excursion interval. When present, the GICE interval is generally <5 m thick and hence is considerable thinner than in the successions in Kentucky, Pennsylvania, Virginia, and West Virginia (see below). Stratigraphically, this excursion is within the Guttenberg sequence of Ludvigson et al. (2004) and well above the level of the widespread Millbrig K-bentonite (Kolata et al., 1996). In several sections the δ13C values increase near the level of the Elkport K-bentonite (Ludvigson et al., 2000a), and the curve returns to baseline values near the level of the Dickeyville K-bentonite. Typically, the excursion is within the Guttenberg Member of the Decorah Shale, which, according to Sweet (1987), belongs to the lower part of his P. tenuis Conodont Zone. δ13C baseline values are ~ –1‰ to –2‰, and the GICE values range up to ~+3‰ but are in most cases between +1‰ and +2‰; hence the magnitude of the excursion is ~3‰. The δ13C curve returns to baseline values of about –1‰ to 0‰ in the uppermost part of the Guttenberg Member, and there are no obvious excursions in the overlying Ion Member of the Decorah Formation and the Beecher and Eagle Point Members of the Dunleith Formation. The Decorah Formation clearly represents a deepening episode in the environment of deposition of the Upper Mississippi Valley succession, and according to Ludvigson et al. (1996) and Witzke and Bunker (1996) the Guttenberg Member represents the peak of the transgression. Estimates of water depth during deposition of this member are somewhat controversial, but according to Ludvigson et al. (1996) the water depth is likely to have been several tens of meters. Hence, it appears that the excursion occurs during a marked highstand episode. Kentucky The particularly important outcrop area of Upper Ordovician rocks in north-central Kentucky and adjacent parts of Indiana and Ohio (Fig. 2) includes the reference area of the Cincinnati Series, the Upper Ordovician in the standard North American chronostratigraphic classification (Ross et al., 1982). The outcrops in Indiana and Ohio do not expose strata as old as the GICE interval, but that part of the Upper Ordovician succession is very well exhibited at many sections in Kentucky. Drill cores penetrating the GICE interval are also available, such as the stratigraphically important Minerva core from a site near Maysville in northern Kentucky (Sweet et al., 1974). Thus far, the GICE has been studied in sections near Frankfort, Franklin County (Saltzman et al., 2003a; Bergström et al., 2004), at Boonesborough, Madison County (Young et al., 2005), and in the Minerva drill core, Mason County (Saltzman et al., 2003a). Data from these sections were
40
Bergström et al.
Figure 2. Sketch map of parts of the USA and adjacent Canada, showing Upper Ordovician outcrop areas (gray) and geographic location of study sections. 1—SW Wisconsin; 2—eastern Iowa; 3—NE Missouri; 4—north-central Kentucky; 5—SW Virginia; 6—eastern West Virginia; 7—central Tennessee; 8—Arbuckle Mountains, Oklahoma; 9—central Pennsylvania; 10—northern New York State; 11—Manitoulin Island, Ontario; 12—Minerva drill core; 13 (inset map)—central Nevada. No GICE has yet been recorded from Alabama, Georgia, or Arkansas, but Hatch et al. (1987) reported elevated isotope values from Kansas drill cores, indicating the presence of the GICE. Early Chatfieldian rocks are missing in the Ordovician outcrop areas in Texas.
summarized in a composite δ13C curve for Kentucky in Young et al. (2005). The conodont biostratigraphy of these sections is well established on the basis of conodont studies (Bergström and Sweet, 1966; Sweet et al., 1974; Sweet, 1979; Richardson and Bergström, 2003). Detailed sequence-stratigraphic and lithostratigraphic investigations were carried out by Holland and Patzkowsky (1996), Pope and Read (1997, 1998), and Brett et al. (2004). K-bentonites and their event-stratigraphic significance have been studied by Conkin (1991), Conkin and Conkin (1992), and Kolata et al. (1996, 1998). The lower part of our δ13C curve (Fig. 5) is based on samples from the Turinian Tyrone Limestone in the Dead Horse
Quarry near Highway 627 in the northeastern part of Frankfort, Franklin County (Conkin and Conkin, 1992). As shown in Figure 5, the δ13C values range between 0‰ and about +1‰ through the upper Tyrone Limestone, and these are interpreted to represent local baseline values for this interval. The values from more than 20 samples from the Curdsville Member of the Lexington Limestone are based on samples collected from outcrops near and along Highway 627 in the northeastern part of Frankfort (Conkin and Conkin, 1992). The δ13C values through this part of the Kentucky succession differ little from each other and average about +1‰ and do not differ substantially from the Turinian baseline values. The sudden increase to +2.5‰ a little
F O R M A T I O N
CHATFIELDIAN TURINIAN
MOHAWKIAN
KATIAN SANDBIAN
UPPER ORDOVICIAN
GLOBAL N.AM. CONODONT ZONE SER. ST. SER. ST. MIDCONT. ATL.
GRAPTOLITE ZONE U. MISS VALL. TENNESSEE OKLAHOMA KENTUCKY
B. confluens A. superbus Plectodina tenuis
Diplacanthograptus caudatus
Phragmodus Amorphognathus undatus tvaerensis Belodina compressa
Decorah
Hermitage
Viola Springs
Lexington
VIRGINIA
W. VIRGINIA
PENNSYLV.
Reedsville
Reedsville
Antes
Trenton
Dolly Ridge
Coburn Salona
NEVADA
Kings Falls
Eureka
Napanee Selby
M D
Climacograptus bicornis
NEW YORK
Platteville
Carters
Bromide
Tyrone
Eggleston
Nealmont
Nealmont
Copenhagen
Watertown
Figure 3. Stratigraphic chart showing relations between formations studied, global and North American stages, and conodont and graptolite zones. Note the position of the Millbrig (M) and Deicke (D) K-bentonites in the uppermost Climacograptus bicornis Zone.
McGREGOR QUARRY, CLAYTON CO. IOWA
ION MBR. GUTTENBERG MBR.
10
PLATTEVILLE SPECHTS FM. FERRY MBR.
? Dickeyville K-bentonite
5
GICE
DECORAH FORMATION
m 15
Elkport K-bentonite
Millbrig K-bentonite Deicke K-bentonite
0 -4
-3
-2
-1
0
1
13
C
carb.
Figure 4. GICE curve in the Guttenberg Member of the Decorah Formation at the McGregor Quarry, Clayton County, eastern Iowa (after Ludvigson et al., 2000a). Note the 2-peak appearance of the δ13C curve, the peak values of ~+1‰, and the baseline values of ~ –1‰. The GICE is within the Guttenberg Member, which represents a highstand interval.
Figure 5. GICE curve in a composite section through the Lexington Limestone, based on outcrops near and along Highway 627 at Frankfort and the Minerva drill core in northern Kentucky. Note δ13C curve baseline values of 0‰ to +1‰, and the 2-peak appearance of the δ13C curve. Also note that the excursion is within the Logana Member of the Lexington Limestone, which represents a highstand interval.
42
Bergström et al.
above the base of the Logana Member is quite conspicuous and represents the beginning of the GICE. The post-Curdsville part of the δ13C curve is based on samples from the Minerva drill core. Most of the δ13C values fluctuate between +1‰ and +2‰ through the Logana Member. Slightly higher, near the top of the Logana Member, the δ13C values drop to between 0‰ and +1‰ and are considered baseline values, indicating the end of the GICE. The total thickness of the GICE is 10–15 m in Kentucky, hence more than twice as much as in the Upper Mississippi Valley. Interestingly, in both the Frankfort section and the Minerva drill core, the GICE has a two-peak appearance, as is the case for several other sections in both North America and Baltoscandia. In terms of conodont biostratigraphy, the basal Lexington Limestone clearly represents the Phragmodus undatus Zone, but the base of the superjacent Plectodina tenuis Zone is currently poorly controlled in the Lexington Limestone. In the Minerva drill core the index of the zone appears ~15 m above the base of the Lexington Limestone, which is near the middle of the GICE interval. However, indeterminate Plectodina fragments occur in slightly older strata, and it is quite possible that most of, or the entire, GICE is present in the latter zone, as is the case in other sections. In terms of sequence stratigraphy, the GICE occurs in the highstand interval in the lower half of the M5 sequence of Holland and Patzkowsky (1996) in a sequence referred to as M5A by Brett et al. (2004) and McLaughlin and Brett (2004). On the basis of chemostratigraphy, the Logana Member correlates closely with the Guttenberg Member of the Decorah Formation in the Upper Mississippi Valley, which also represents a marked highstand in sea level. Virginia The only published GICE section in Virginia is the long railroad cut at Hagan, Lee County, which is the reference profile of Cooper’s (1956) North American Wildernessian Stage (Bergström et al., 1988). It is one of the most important sections through this stratigraphic interval in the southern and central Appalachians and has been dealt with in numerous publications (see, e.g., Miller and Fuller, 1954; Miller and Brosgé, 1954; Bergström et al., 1988; Haynes, 1992, 1994; Kolata et al., 1996, 1998, 2001; Leslie and Bergström, 1997; Mitchell et al., 2004). A δ13C curve through the upper Eggleston Formation and Trenton Limestone was recently published by Young et al. (2005), and it is shown, slightly modified, in Figure 6. Apart from an ~70-m-thick interval in the upper part of the Trenton Limestone, the study interval is excellently exposed and includes the Deicke and Millbrig K-bentonites. The Hagan δ13C curve (Fig. 6) shows more fluctuations than the curves from the Upper Mississippi Valley and Kentucky but compares well in major features with the curves from these areas, although the GICE is much thicker (~120 m). The δ13C curve shows baseline values between 0‰ and +1‰ in the lower-
most 30 m of the Trenton Limestone before a conspicuous rise to >+2‰. In the next 50 m there are numerous fluctuations in δ13C values between +1‰ and near +3‰, with average values of ~+2‰. The curve, based on samples from the uppermost Trenton Limestone, above the covered interval, shows a notable decline down to values of <–1‰, which is interpreted as the end of the GICE. Although several workers (see, e.g., Bergström et al., 1988; Leslie, 1995) have investigated the conodont biostratigraphy of the Hagan section, the precise position of conodont zone boundaries remains incompletely known. However, the relations between the GICE, the Millbrig K-bentonite, and conodont zones are closely similar to those in other sections in the eastern Midcontinent. As in these sections, the M5 sequence boundary is above the Millbrig K-bentonite, and evidently the GICE is in the transgressive sequence of the Trenton Limestone. West Virginia The only current record of the GICE in West Virginia is from a relatively little known section at Dolly Ridge, Pendleton County, which was recently described by Young et al. (2005). The outcrop is along a dirt road along the slope of Dolly Ridge ~1.3 km southwest of Riverton. An ~180-m-thick succession of the Nealmont and Dolly Ridge Formations, first described by Perry (1972), consists of lime mudstones, wackestones, shales, and some beds of skeletal packstones. As many as 14 K-bentonites have been recorded from this section, including two beds in the upper Nealmont Formation, tentatively identified as the Deicke and Millbrig K-bentonites (Young et al., 2005). For further details about this section, see Perry (1972). The Dolly Ridge succession provides an excellent, and apparently complete, GICE curve (Fig. 6) in a succession representing a relatively high sedimentation rate and without recognized stratigraphic gaps. Along with the Hagan section, it is currently the stratigraphically thickest (~130 m) representation of the GICE known not only in North America but globally. The δ13C curve is based on 30 samples, but despite a rather thick average sample interval of 6 m, we expect the excursion curve to be fully representative of the GICE in this succession. As described by Young et al. (2005), the top 40 m of the Nealmont Formation, which contains the Deicke and Millbrig K-bentonites and is referable to the Phragmodus undatus Zone, has baseline δ13C values of between +1.2‰ and +0.5‰. From about the base of the Dolly Ridge Formation, there is a gradual but rapid rise in the δ13C values to about +3‰ at ~100 m above the base of the sampled interval. Values between +2.5‰ and +3‰ are present through a thickness of nearly 50 m until the curve drops conspicuously to below 0‰ in the topmost part of the Dolly Ridge Formation, just below the overlying Reedsville Formation. This indicates the end of the GICE. Although the biostratigraphic control of this section is not yet as precise as in some other North American successions, the current, largely unpublished, information at hand is in good agreement with
Upper Ordovician Guttenberg δ13C excursion (GICE) in North America and Baltoscandia
43
Figure 6. GICE curve in the Trenton Limestone at Hagan, Virginia, and the Dolly Ridge Formation at Dolly Ridge,West Virginia (after Young et al., 2005). Despite the considerable stratigraphic range of the excursion, it has the same relations to the Midcontinent conodont zones at these sections as in other successions. Note the δ13C baseline values of ~+1‰ and the peak values of ~+3‰.
the biostratigraphic range of the GICE in other successions. As shown in Figure 6, the Dolly Ridge curve shows close resemblance to the less complete Hagan curve in general shape, thickness, and relations to the Millbrig K-bentonite, and the base of the Reedsville Formation. However, it is a great deal smoother than the fluctuating Hagan curve, but the reason for this requires further study. Tennessee A classical Ordovician outcrop area in Tennessee is around the City of Nashville in the central part of the state, where there are numerous exposures of Upper Ordovician strata (Wilson, 1949; Holland and Patzkowsky, 1997, 1998). The late TurinianChatfieldian succession consists of carbonates and calcareous shales referred to the Carters and Hermitage Formations. The Carters Formation includes shallow-water lime mudstones and packstones that locally contain bird’s-eye structures. The Hermitage Formation apparently was deposited in deeper water than the Carters Formation and consists mainly of wackestones and calcareous shales, mudstones, and siltstones. Lithologically, it is similar to the Logana Member of the Lexington Limestone in Kentucky. The Deicke K-bentonite is present in the upper Carters Formation, and the Millbrig K-bentonite, where present, occurs
at the top of the same formation (Haynes, 1994; Kolata et al., 1996). The upper Carters Formation contains conodonts of the Phragmodus undatus Zone, and Plectodina tenuis, the index of the P. tenuis Zone, appears near the base of the overlying Hermitage Formation (Leslie, 1995). The Carters-Hermitage formation contact is an unconformity that has been taken as the M4-M5 sequence boundary (Holland and Patzkowsky, 1998). The δ13C studies by Railsback et al. (2003) and Young (2003) showed the presence of the GICE in the Hermitage Formation. Based on three sections, Young (2003) presented a composite GICE curve (Fig. 7). The baseline δ13C values in the upper Carters Formation are between 0‰ and +1‰. At the base of the Hermitage Formation the values rise conspicuously from ~+1‰ to ~+3‰. The abruptness of this increase supports the idea of a stratigraphic gap at the top of the Carters Formation. The high δ13C values are present in only a relatively thin interval (~3 m), and the upper part of the Hermitage Formation is characterized by values in the +1‰ to +2‰ range. Owing to the shape of the δ13C curve, it is difficult to define the precise level of the end of the GICE. However, this horizon is likely to be in the upper part of the Hermitage Formation somewhat below the base of the Belodina confluens Zone. As in Kentucky and other regions of the Midcontinent, the GICE occurs in a part of the succession characterized by a flooding event.
Bergström et al.
TURINIAN Clim. bicornis Phragmodus undatus BROMIDE
HIGHWAY 99, FITTSTOWN, OKLAHOMA
GICE
C H AT F I E L D I A N
One of the economically most important outcrop areas of Ordovician rocks in North America is in and around the Arbuckle Mountains in southern Oklahoma. Because of their importance as hydrocarbon producers, Ordovician strata in this region have been the subject of intense study for more than a century, resulting in a voluminous literature. Of particular interest in the present study is the Viola Springs Formation, which includes the GICE interval (Young et al., 2005). For information about various aspects of this formation, see Alberstadt (1973), Amsden and Sweet (1983), Finney (1986), and Goldman and Bergström (1997). Gao et al. (1996) carried out a pioneer δ13C study of the Viola Springs Formation, but unfortunately they studied a stratigraphically incomplete section along Interstate 35 in which most, if not all, of the GICE interval is cut out by an unconformity. One of the stratigraphically most complete and best exposed sections of the Viola Springs Formation is along Hwy 99 ~3.3 miles south of Fittstown in Pontotoc County. This section, which
was described by Decker (1933), is a classical field trip stop. Its conodont biostratigraphy was decribed by Sweet (1983), and the graptolite biostratigraphy was dealt with by Finney (1986) and Goldman et al. (2005). A δ13C curve through the upper 10 m of the Bromide Formation and the lower 46 m of the overlying Viola Springs Formation was published by Young et al. (2005). The δ13C values from the upper 10 m of the Bromide Formation are ~0‰ (Fig. 8), whereas those from the lower 20 m of the Viola Springs Formation are between –1‰ and +1‰ with notable fluctuations. The values in the middle part of the study section reach nearly +1.5‰ before dropping to <0‰ in the upper 6 m of the sample interval. This drop, which represents the end of the GICE, is just below the base of the Belodina confluens Zone and below the first record of the important graptolite Diplacanthograptus spiniferus.
Plectodina tenuis VIOLA SPRINGS
Oklahoma
STAGE GRAPTOD. spiniferus LITE ZONE CONODONT Bel. confluens ZONE FM.
44
Millbrig K-bentonite?
Deicke -2 K-bentonite?
M5 M4
-1
0
1
2
13
C
carb.
Figure 7. Composite δ13C curve through the Hermitage Formation in central Tennessee, based on outcrops at Nashville Airport, and road cuts at Gladesville and Tanglewood (after Young et al., 2005). The M4-M5 sequence boundary is associated with a prominent gap that includes the uppermost Carters and lowermost Hermitage Formations. This results in an abrupt beginning of the GICE at the base of the Hermitage Formation, which is a highstand unit that is lithologically reminiscent of the Logana Member of the Lexington Limestone in Kentucky. Note that the δ13C curve has baseline values of ~+1‰ and peak values of ~+3‰.
Figure 8. GICE in the Viola Springs Formation at the Highway 99 road cut south of Fittstown, Oklahoma (after Young et al., 2005), where the sampled interval is 73 m thick. The excursion occurs in an ~30-mthick interval. The curve baseline values are ~0‰, and the peak values ~+1.5‰. Note that the lowermost Viola Springs Formation, below the GICE, has yielded chitinozoans of the Spinachitina cervicornis Zone (Goldman et al., 2005), which are also present below the GICE in Baltoscandia. For information about the recently discovered K-bentonites in the Bromide Formation in this section, see Leslie et al. (2006). As in the other figures, the lithologic patterns in the stratigraphic column follow those used in Bergström et al. (2006; Fig. 4).
One of the early Ordovician δ C investigations in North America was carried out by Patzkowsky et al. (1997) on the upper Nealmont, Salona, and Coburn Formations at a highway cut near Reedsville, which occupy a stratigraphic position similar to that of the Decorah Formation in the Upper Mississippi Valley on the basis of conodont biostratigraphy (Sweet, 1984) and the presence of the Deicke and Millbrig K-bentonites in the lower part of the Salona Formation (Kolata et al., 1996). Among the two sections studied by these workers, the most informative one is the Highway 144 cut just south of Reedsville, Mifflin County. Their investigated interval is ~150 m thick and ranges to near the top of the Coburn Formation. This unit is overlain by the Antes Shale, the lower part of which contains graptolites of the Corynoides americanus and Orthograptus ruedemanni Zones (Mitchell et al., 2004). The Nealmont, Salona, and Coburn formations belong to the Atlantic Amorphognathus tvaerensis Conodont Zone, and the index of the Midcontinent Belodina confluens Conodont Zone appears in the topmost part of the Coburn Formation (Richardson and Bergström, 2003). The baseline δ13C values in the Turinian Nealmont Formation are difficult to establish because values are currently available from only the topmost 18 m of the formation, but comparison with the Hagan and Dolly Ridge successions suggests that the baseline value may be ~1‰. Assuming this is correct, there is a rather distinct negative δ13C excursion in the topmost part of the Nealmont Formation, a few meters below the Deicke K-bentonite (Fig. 9). The curve from the lower 10 m of the Salona Formation shows a gradual increase in δ13C values up to ~+2‰. This is an unusual feature because in most studied sections in North America the stratigraphic interval just above the Millbrig K-bentonite has typically rather uniform, or even decreasing, δ13C values. If this is due to the fact that the Reedsville section is unusually complete stratigraphically—there appears to be no gap in the projected position of the M4-M5 sequence boundary—or due
FM.
CONODONT ZONE
B. confluens
m 150
140
120
110
L
D I A N COBURN
REEDSVILLE, MIFFLIN COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA ANTES SHALE
130
GICE
Plectodina tenuis
I E TURINIAN
NEALMONT
13
90
80
70
60
50
Phragmodus undatus
Pennsylvania
45
100
C H A T F SALONA
This section is particularly important biostratigraphically in that it provides information about the relations between the GICE and conodont, graptolite, and chitinozoan zones. The interval beneath the GICE represents the Phragmodus undatus Conodont Zone (Sweet, 1984), the Climacograptus bicornis Graptolite Zone (Finney, 1986; Goldman et al., 2005), and the Spinachitina cervicornis Chitinozoan Zone (Goldman et al., 2005). The GICE falls largely, if not entirely, within the Plectodina tenuis Zone, which overlies the Phragmodus undatus Zone. It is also of interest to note that the M4-M5 sequence boundary of Holland and Patzkowsky (1996) is at the unconformity at the base of the Viola Springs Formation; a K-bentonite at that stratigraphic level was recently interpreted to be the Millbrig K-bentonite (Leslie et al., 2006). Hence, the relations between the GICE and various stratigraphic indicators in the Fittstown section agree well with the conditions at other Midcontinent sections.
STAGE
Upper Ordovician Guttenberg δ13C excursion (GICE) in North America and Baltoscandia
40
30
Millbrig K-bentonite Deicke K-bentonite
20
10
0
0
1
2
3
4
13
C
carb.
Figure 9. GICE in the Salona and Coburn Formations in the highway cut at Reedsville, Pennsylvania (after Patzkowsky et al., 1997). The δ13C curve baseline values appear to be ~+1‰, and the peak values ~+3‰. Note that the thickness of the GICE is of the same order (~100 m) as at Hagan and Dolly Ridge, and hence many times greater than in the Upper Mississippi Valley sections.
to some other, still unidentified reason, requires further study. The gradual increase in δ13C values continues upward in the succession to reach maximum values of somewhat more than +3‰ in the upper half of the Salona Formation and through much of the overlying Coburn Limestone. There is a gradual decline in values in the upper 15 m of the Coburn Limestone below the base of the Belodina confluens Zone, but a sudden decline to baseline values is not very obvious. However, it is important to note that there is severe tectonic deformation in the upper part of the Coburn Formation at Reedsville, and there may be even a significant gap between this formation and the overlying Antes Shale, as recently illustrated by Mitchell et al. (2004, Fig. 7). Hence, the uppermost part of the Reedsville curve may be considered problematic. At any rate, the thickness of the GICE in the Reedsville section (~100 m) appears to be comparable to that of the Dolly Ridge and Hagan sections and more than
New York State Another classical area of Ordovician rocks is around the Adirondack Mountains in northern New York State (Fig. 2). This is the type area of the Trenton Group (Kay, 1937) and of the Mohawkian Series, the upper Middle Ordovician in the standard North American Series classification. Studies since the mid-nineteenth century have resulted not only in numerous publications but also in a complex, and in some cases controversial, stratigraphic nomenclature (for recent discussions, see Goldman et al., 1994; Brett and Baird, 2002; Mitchell et al., 2004; Brett et al., 2004). Recent δ13C work in the Trenton Group (Barta, 2004; Barta et al., 2007) has shown the presence of a distinct excursion, identified as the GICE, which starts in the mid-Napanee Formation a few meters above a K-bentonite identified as the Millbrig K-bentonite (Mitchell et al., 2004; Fig. 3) and ends in the middle of the overlying Kings Fall Formation (Fig. 10). Full details of this excursion have been published by Barta et al. (2007). It should be noted that the typical two-peak GICE reaches maximum δ13C values of ~+3‰ in the upper Napanee Formation and lower Kings Fall Limestone (Barta, 2004). Slightly higher stratigraphically, in the middle Kings Fall Limestone, the isotope curve drops to baseline values of +1‰ to +2‰. Barta (2004) and Barta et al. (2007) also recorded the GICE above the Deicke K-bentonite in the Bobcaygeon Formation on Manitoulin Island, Ontario, and in the reference section of the Rocklandian Stage (or Substage) at Stewart Quarry at Rockland, Québec. The discovery of the GICE in the lower part of the Trenton Group has important implications for the regional correlation of the Rocklandian Stage (or Substage) in North America. The fact that the GICE starts about midway through the Rocklandian shows that this level correlates closely with the base of the Logana Member of the Lexington Limestone, the base of the Hermitage Formation in central Tennessee, and the base of the Guttenberg Member of the Decorah Formation in the Upper Mississippi Valley. Also, the chemostratigraphy suggests that the Selby Formation, the basal unit in the Trenton Group, correlates with the Curdsville Member of the Lexington Limestone in Kentucky. These correlations at about the base of the Rocklandian differ substantially from those recently advocated by Brett et al. (2004, Fig. 6), who considered the Curdsville Member a correlative of the Watertown Formation of the Black River Group in New York.
DEXTER QUARRY, NEW YORK
GICE
FM.
STAGE
C H AT F I E L D I A N ROCKLAND N A PA N E E
20 times as large as in the epicontinental platform successions in the Upper Mississippi Valley, illustrating the much higher rate of deposition in the Appalachian Foreland Basin compared with that in the continental interior. It should be noted also that in Pennsylvania the GICE occurs in a highstand succession. The Salona Formation was clearly deposited in deeper water than the underlying shallow-water Nealmont Formation, whereas the Coburn Limestone might represent a renewed shallowing of the depositional environment.
HULL KAY ‘37
Bergström et al.
TURINIAN WATERTOWN WATERTOWN SELBY
46
10
Not exposed
m
no data
0 Millbrig (Hounsfield) K-bentonite Pond level
0
1
2
3
13
C
carb.
Figure 10. GICE in the Napanee Limestone at the Dexter Quarry, Jefferson County, New York (after Barta, 2004). For a composite New York State δ13C curve, see Barta et al. (2007, Fig. 10). Base line δ13C values are ~+1‰ in the early Chatfieldian Selby Limestone, and excursion peak values approach 3‰ in the Napanee Limestone in the highway road cut. Although no δ13C values are available from the ~6-m-thick covered interval, it is likely that baseline values continue through that portion of the succession. Based on unpublished recent studies of other sections in this region (Barta, 2004), the excursion extends upward to the middle portion of the Kings Fall Limestone, which overlies the Napanee Limestone. The Dexter Quarry is the reference section of the well-known Hounsfield K-bentonite, which, based on recent geochemical fingerprinting (Mitchell et al., 2004), is identical with the Millbrig K-bentonite.
Nevada Until recently the GICE had not been recorded in the vast region west of the Rocky Mountains. A pioneer δ13C study on samples from the Chatfieldian interval in the Vinini Shale (Jacobson et al., 1995) failed to provide evidence of the presence of the GICE. One major reason for the lack of GICE records is undoubtedly the fact that in most regions this stratigraphic interval is missing or is represented only by clastic sediments, such as the prominent Eureka Quartzite, which are less useful for chemostratigraphic work. One of the very few, if not the only, carbonate formation that holds some promise for a δ13C study of the GICE interval is the Copenhagen Formation of central Nevada, which is considered a local carbonate facies of the lower part of the Eureka Quartzite (Harris et al., 1979). The suitability of the Copenhagen Formation for chemostratigraphic study is also enhanced by the fact that it has well-established conodont
Upper Ordovician Guttenberg δ13C excursion (GICE) in North America and Baltoscandia
ing its identification as the GICE. Interestingly, the values (~+1) of the samples from the top of the Copenhagen Formation are heavier than the baseline values in the lower part of the formation (between –1‰ and –2‰). This could be interpreted as indicating that the complete GICE excursion is not represented (Saltzman and Young, 2005), its top segment either being present in the basal part of the overlying Eureka Quartzite or cut out by the possible unconformity at the Copenhagen-Eureka contact. The GICE occurs in an interval of the Copenhagen Formation that based on conodonts (Phragmodus biofacies of Sweet, 1988) and lithology (much increased amount of shale in Member C) represents a deeper-water environment. Shallow-water hyaline conodonts of the types characteristic of the Turinian successions in the eastern Midcontinent are completely absent. This suggests that in central Nevada the GICE is coeval with a highstand event, as is generally the case in Midcontinent successions such as that in Kentucky, where the GICE appears at the base of the shaly, deeper-water Logana Member of the Lexington Limestone (see above). On the other hand, the Eureka Quartzite, with a sequence boundary at its base, is usually interpreted as a regressive deposit and appears to represent the post-GICE shallowing event. The identity and distribution of the distinctive positive δ13C excursion beneath the GICE in the lower part of Member C of the Copenhagen Formation are currently unclear. This excursion is firmly dated as representing the Baltoniodus gerdae Subzone of the Amorphognathus tvaerensis Zone by the occurrence of the subzonal index, B. gerdae, which is restricted to this subzone
ANTELOPE VALLEY, NEVADA m
Eureka Qtz.
50
B
A 0
Antelope Valley Ls.
Pl. aculeata-E. quadr. B. variabilis ? B.g.
C
100
B. com ?
P. undatus ?
GICE
137
C. sweeti P. anserinus
CHAZYAN
? TURINIAN COPENHAGEN
CHATFIELDIAN
STAGE FM.
biostratigraphy (Ethington and Schumacher, 1969; Harris et al., 1979; Sweet et al., 2005). The first δ13C curve from the Copenhagen Formation was recently published by Saltzman and Young (2005). Their data were based on samples from two sections of the Copenhagen in the Monitor and Antelope Ranges, where the unit has a total thickness of ~140 m. Most of the δ13C values from the lower 50 m of the formation are between –1‰ and –2‰ (Fig. 11). These are regarded as baseline values and are comparable to those from the underlying Antelope Valley Limestone (Saltzman and Young, 2005). Based on conodonts, this part of the Copenhagen Formation ranges through the uppermost Whiterockian Series (upper Chazyan Subseries). At about the 55-m level, near the contact between Members B and C, the δ13C values increase conspicuously to ~+1‰. High values are maintained to about the 80-m level, where the curve drops down markedly to ~ −1‰, indicating the end of this excursion. This value drop is followed by another, even more drastic, positive δ13C increase, with maximum curve values of ~+3.5‰. The values decrease again through the uppermost 25 m of the formation and are ~+1‰ at the top of the formation. The top 30–35 m of the Copenhagen Formation contains Phragmodus undatus, Polyplacognathus ramosus, and other conodonts present in the Phragmodus undatus Zone elsewhere, and this interval is referable to the Phragmodus undatus Zone that straddles the Turinian-Chatfieldian Stage boundary. These biostratigraphic data indicate that the prominent excursion in the upper 35 m of the formation occupies the same stratigraphic interval as the GICE in the eastern Midcontinent, thus confirm-
47
-2
-1
0
1 13
C
carb.
2
3
4
Figure 11. GICE in the Copenhagen Formation in the Antelope Valley area, central Nevada (after Saltzman and Young, 2005). GICE peak values approach 4‰. Note that conodont biostratigraphy (Harris et al., 1979) shows that the interval of the apparent δ13C excursion between 55 and 85 m is of Turinian age and hence significantly older than the GICE. The top of the Copenhagen Formation is a prominent sequence boundary, and it is possibly associated with a stratigraphic gap that may cut out the topmost part of the excursion. B.g.—B. gerdae.
48
Bergström et al.
(Bergström, 1971) in an interval corresponding to the upper half of this excursion. The base of this subzone has been taken as the base of the North American Turinian Stage (Ross et al., 1982), and hence the excursion is of early Turinian age and clearly older than the GICE and the late Turinian pre-GICE excursions recognized in the Upper Mississippi Valley. No obvious excursion has yet been recorded from coeval strata in the eastern Midcontinent or in the stratigraphically more condensed but well-studied successions in Estonia (Ainsaar et al., 2004a; Meidla et al., 2004; Kaljo et al., 2004; Martma, 2005). In fact, in the Estonian and Swedish successions the δ13C curve shows a dip from ~+1‰ to ~0‰ in the B. gerdae Subzone. This suggests that the apparent excursion in central Nevada may be a local anomaly and not a global feature in the δ13C curve. However, if decisive biostratigraphic data were not available, this excursion, together with the “real” GICE, could readily be incorrectly interpreted as a 2-peak GICE similar to that in many North American and European sections. This underscores the necessity of having adequate chronostratigraphic control for reliable identification of the GICE and other isotope excursions. TRANSATLANTIC CORRELATION OF THE GICE The fact that the GICE is recognizable across much of the North American continent suggests that it is a globally distributed excursion. If so, it should be present in coeval successions on other continents such as Baltica. High-resolution biostratigraphy is probably the only reliable means of establishing correlation of an excursion between continents, although its position in a global eustatic curve, and relation to widespread event–stratigraphic markers such as major K-bentonite beds, may provide supporting evidence for consanguinity. On the basis of recent investigations the biostratigraphic position of the GICE is well established in North America. As recently shown (Bergström et al., 2004; Young et al., 2005), this excursion starts near the boundary between the Phragmodus undatus and Plectodina tenuis Midcontinent Conodont Zones, and ends in the upper part of the latter zone, based on sections in the Upper Mississippi Valley, Kentucky, Tennessee, Oklahoma, New York State, and the Appalachians (Fig. 12). There is also evidence from these sections, especially those in New York State, Kentucky, and Oklahoma, that the GICE interval is in the upper part of the Amorphognathus tvaerensis Atlantic Conodont Zone and ends well below the base of the overlying Amorphognathus superbus Conodont Zone. In terms of graptolite biostratigraphy, the GICE begins near the base of the global Diplacanthograptus caudatus Zone and ends below the base of the North American Diplacanthograptus spiniferus Zone. Recent work (Goldman et al., 2005) has also shown that the beginning of the GICE at the Fittstown section in Oklahoma is just above an interval containing chitinozoans of the Baltic Spinachitina cervicornis Zone. This zone occurs in the upper Haljala and Keila Stages in Baltoscandia (Nõlvak and Grahn, 1993). Finally, depending on the local net depositional rate, the GICE starts a few decimeters to a
few meters above the Millbrig K-bentonite, which is an excellent regional marker bed in the sections in eastern North America. In Baltoscandia, a prominent δ13C excursion (the mid-Caradoc excursion of Kaljo et al., 2004) is present in the upper part of the Amorphognathus tvaerensis Zone in strata representing the Keila and Oandu Stages (Fig. 12). The graptolite correlation of the beginning of this excursion is not yet firmly established in Baltoscandia, but on the basis of sections in southern Sweden it is likely to be in the uppermost part of the Diplograptus foliaceus (formerly D. multidens) Zone. Diplacanthograptus spiniferus, the index of the North American D. spiniferus Zone, is present in the post-GICE Rakvere and Nabala Stages in Estonia (Bergström et al., 2004). In Baltoscandia, and especially in the many studied sections in Estonia, the beginning of the excursion has been recorded from the upper part of the Spinachitina cervicornis Chitinozoan Zone of the middle-upper part of the Keila Stage. Finally, in the Baltoscandian sections the excursion starts a few meters above the Kinnekulle K-bentonite, which has been correlated with the North American Millbrig K-bentonite on the basis of a variety of evidence (Huff et al., 1992; Bergström et al., 2004). Hence, the GICE and the Baltoscandian “mid-Caradoc” excursion occupy precisely the same stratigraphic interval. The possible transatlantic equivalence of this interval was first suggested by Huff et al. (1992) and has also been discussed by, among others, Ainsaar et al. (1999) and Bergström et al. (2001, 2004). Based on all the evidence at hand, it seems clear that these excursions are the same, and so it is appropriate to use the GICE designation also for the Baltoscandian excursion (see Bergström et al., 2004). For a diagrammatic illustration of the biostratigraphic relations of the GICE in North America and northern Europe, see Saltzman et al. (2003a) and Bergström et al. (2004, 2007). GICE IN SWEDEN Lower Upper Ordovician strata that represent the global Sandbian and Katian stages are present in several areas in southern and central Sweden (Fig. 13), especially in the provinces of Scania, Västergötland, Östergötland, and Dalarna. As shown in Figure 14, the GICE interval is in the Skagen and Moldå Formations and in equivalent strata in carbonate mound facies, the Kullsberg Limestone. Apart from a thin development of the Skagen Limestone, most of the excursion interval is in shaly facies in Scania (Nilsson, 1977; Bergström et al., 1999; Pålsson, 2002), and no GICE data are currently available from that region. The GICE interval is not present on the Island of Öland, and it is poorly developed, if present at all, in the subsurface of the island of Gotland in the Baltic (Nõlvak and Grahn, 1993). The only GICE data published from Västergötland (Meidla et al., 2004) are based on a few samples collected from the Skagen Limestone at the famous Gullhögen Quarry. Because their recorded stratigraphic succession of the interval just above the Skagen Limestone differs significantly from that presented from the site by Holmer (1986), further studies are needed to establish
0
1
2
13
C
carb.
3
B. compressa
C. bicornis
0
1 13
C
carb.
2
C. bicornis
C. spiniferus
GRAPTOLITE ZONE
D. clingani
RAKVERE KEILA
Kinnekulle K-b.
RANGES CHITINOOF KEY ZOAN GRAPTOZONE LITES
F. fungiformis
S. cervicornis
D. foliaceus
Deicke K-b.
S. cervicornis
A. tvaerensis
TURINIAN
A. tvaerensis
OANDU
HALJALA
GICE
P. undatus
Millbrig K-b.
C. americanus
P. tenuis
C. caudatus
C. B. A. spiniconflu- superbus ferus ens
CHATFIELDIAN
STAGE
K-BENTONITES CONODONT ZONE GRAP- CHITINOK-BENTONITES STAGES & TOLITE ZOAN & C EXCURSION C EXCURSION MIDCONT. ATL. ZONE ZONE
A. CONODONT superbus ZONE
BALTOSCANDIA
NORTH AMERICA
B. hirsuta L. dalbyensis
Figure 12. Transatlantic correlation diagram, showing the relations between conodont, graptolite, and chitinozoan biostratigraphy, K-bentonite event stratigraphy, and the early Chatfieldian δ13C excursion in North America and Baltoscandia. On the basis of these relations, the GICE is considered the same δ13C excursion as the “middle Caradocian” excursion of Kaljo et al. (2004). The δ13C curves in the North American and Baltocandian parts of the diagram are based on parts of the Kentucky composite curve and the Fjäcka curve, respectively. For C. spiniferus read D. spiniferus.
Figure 13. Sketch map of the southern part of Baltoscandia, showing study localities. For the location of other δ13C sites in Estonia and Latvia, see Kaljo et al. (2004, Fig. 1B). Black denotes Ordovician outcrop areas.
50
Bergström et al.
SERIES
S TA G E
GLOBAL BRITISH N. AM. BALTOS. GLOBAL BALTOS. N. AMER. ASHGILLIAN
CONODONT SWEDISH LITHOZONES STRATIGRAPHIC UNITS
RICHMONDIAN
CINCINN- HARJUAN ATIAN
NABALA
MAYSVILLIAN EDENIAN
A. ordovicicus
SLANDROM Amorphognathus superbus
SKÅLBERG
RAKVERE
CARADOCIAN
OANDU CHATFIELDIAN
VIRUAN KEILA
Amorphognathus tvaerensis
FREBERGA
KATIAN UPPER ORDOVICIAN
C
MOLDÅ
KULLSBERG
GICE
SKAGEN
SANDBIAN
HALJALA
Millbrig K-bent. TURINIAN
Kinnekulle K-bent. DALBY
Figure 14. Stratigraphic diagram showing series, stages, conodont zones, and Swedish formations discussed in the text.
the relations between the GICE and the Gullhögen succession. No well-exposed outcrop of the GICE interval is known from Östergötland, but it is completely penetrated by core drilling at Smedsby Gård in the northwestern part of the province (Fig. 13), which has been investigated in the present study. The best GICE sections in Sweden are in the Siljan area in Dalarna (Fig. 15), where the excursion interval is developed in carbonate facies and is well exposed at several localities. In the present study we describe new δ13C studies of three localities in the Siljan area and of the Smedsby Gård drill core. These sites were selected for study because they represent different depositional facies (inner shelf, mound, and outer shelf, respectively), and it would be of interest to determine if the GICE was environmentally controlled. Siljan Area, Dalarna A pioneer study of δ13C and δ18O in Upper Ordovician rocks of this region, and in entire Baltoscandia, was carried out by Jux and Manze (1979). This interesting but widely overlooked report was based on numerous samples through both the GICE and the HICE intervals, but the authors did not recognize any excursions. Subsequently, some δ13C data from the Siljan area were reported by Tobin and Walker (1996, 1997), Bergström et al. (2001, 2004), Saltzman et al. (2003a), Ainsaar et al. (2000, 2004a), and Tobin et al. (2005), but the only GICE curves published previously are from the Fjäcka section. Below we present new δ13C data from sections at Fjäcka, Skålberget, and Amtjärn (Fig. 15). These δ13C data, as well as those from the Smedsby Gård drill core, were obtained from limestone samples using the same standard laboratory procedures as described in Bergström et al. (2006).
Fjäcka This outcrop, which is one of the best known and most studied Ordovician sections in Sweden (see, e.g., Jaanusson and Martna, 1948; Jaanusson, 1963, 1976, 1982; Laufeld, 1967; Bergström, 1971; Holmer, 1989; Nõlvak and Grahn, 1993; Nõlvak et al., 1999), lies along the Fjäckan rivulet (Fig. 16). It provides a continuous exposure of the Skagen and Moldå Formations, as well as overlying and underlying units, in a stratigraphically condensed succession. Our new sampling started in the upper part of the Dalby Formation and ranged through the Skagen and Moldå Formations into the lowermost part of the Slandrom Limestone (Fig. 17). The δ13C values from the stratigraphically lowest 14 samples, which are from the upper Dalby Formation and the lower Skagen Formation, range from ~+0.5‰ to +1‰, which we consider to be pre-GICE baseline values. At ~2.5 m above the Kinnekulle K-bentonite, there is a marked but gradual increase in values to near +2‰. These heavy values last for several meters before dropping to baseline values ~4 m below the top of the Moldå Formation. Of note is a dip in the δ13C curve near the base of the Moldå Formation that gives the curve a 2-peak appearance similar to that in the GICE curve from some localities in North America. We consider the GICE to end ~2 m above the base of the Moldå Formation, where the values are ~+1, hence the same as the pre-GICE baseline values. The total thickness of the GICE at Fjäcka amounts to ~5 m. This is slightly larger than the thickness of the GICE interval in the cratonic sections in the Upper Mississippi Valley, but only a fraction of its thickness at Dolly Ridge, Hagan, and Reedsville. Conodonts (Bergström, 1971, 2007) as well as chitinozoans provide the best biostratigraphic control of the excursion interval. The uppermost Dalby Formation contains conodonts of the
Upper Ordovician Guttenberg δ13C excursion (GICE) in North America and Baltoscandia
51
Figure 15. Sketch map of the Siljan area, showing location of our studied GICE sections. Inset map illustrates the position of the carbonate mounds at Amtjärn, Skålberget, Kullsberg, and Unkarsheden.
Baltoniodus alobatus Subzone of the Amorphognathus tvaerensis Zone. Two important conodont species, Hamarodus europaeus and Amorphognathus complicatus, which probably represent the Amorphognathus superbus Zone, appear ~1 m above the end of the GICE (Fig. 17). Diagnostic conodont taxa have not been found in the Skagen Formation, and its conodont zone assignment remains uncertain, although it is likely to represent the upper part of the A. tvaerensis Zone on the basis of chemostratigraphy. In terms of Baltoscandic chitinozoan zones, the GICE lies in the middle-upper part of the Spinachitina cervicornis Zone (Nõlvak and Grahn, 1993; also see Laufeld, 1967), which has its reference section in the Fjäcka outcrop. Skålberget Skålberget is a relatively small, now disused and partly waterfilled, quarry in the southeastern part of the Siljan area (Fig. 15). It was quarried for the Kullsberg and Boda Limestones in the 1930s and 1940s (Thorslund, l935, l936). Although abandoned
for more than half a century, it still provides an excellent section through the Kullsberg Limestone and the overlying Skålberg and Slandrom Limestones, the Fjäcka Shale, and the Jonstorp Formation. A quarry pit formerly exposing the Boda Limestone and the overlying Llandovery shales has now been filled in, so that exposure is completely destroyed. A thickness of ~50 m of the Kullsberg Limestone is now exposed along the southern rim of the quarry (Fig. 18). The Kullsberg Limestone is a carbonate mound deposit that forms a >200-m-long elongated lens of in part poorly stratified limestone. The dip of the beds varies from very steep to vertical. Because the basalmost part of the Kullsberg Limestone is covered by Pleistocene till, its total thickness at this locality is unknown. In view of the fact that the quarrying operations at other Kullsberg sites included virtually the entire formation, it appears likely that its total thickness at Skålberget does not substantially exceed 50 m. The record of “Macrourus-Kalk und Mergel” (= Moldå Formation in current terminology) by Jux and Manze (1979, Fig. 3) beneath the Kullsberg Limestone at Skålberget is most unlikely
52
Bergström et al. rate, our Kullsberg values compare well, and in most cases they exceed the GICE values from the non-mound facies at Fjäcka, and we interpret them as indicating that the GICE ranges through the entire thickness of the Kullsberg Limestone.
Slandrom Lst.
N
sampled interval mill -ra
ce
Moldå Fm.
Ki
Skagen Fm.
nn
0
ite on nt le be ul K-
K-be nton ite
ek
Dalby Fm.
5m
Figure 16. Detailed sketch map of part of the Fjäcka outcrop and our sampled interval (marked by thick black line) in the Skagen and Moldå Formations. Note the Kinnekulle K-bentonite at the base of the Skagen Formation.
to be correct in view of the fact that the equivalent of the Moldå Formation (Skålberg Limestone) overlies rather than underlies the Kullsberg Limestone (Jaanusson, 1982). For details about the Kullsberg lithology and geochemistry, see Jaanusson (1982), Tobin and Walker (1997), and Tobin et al. (2005). Some δ13C data from Skålberget were previously published by Jux and Manze (1979), Tobin and Walker (1997), and Tobin et al. (2005). Our new data are from a series of samples collected through a 50-m-thick section along the southern rim of the quarry (Fig. 18). The sampled Kullsberg section illustrated by Jux and Manze (1979, Fig. 3) is only ~25 m thick. This small figure suggests that their samples came from the northern end of the Kullsberg lens, where the thickness is markedly smaller. The δ13C values from our sampled profile are extraordinarily uniform, being about +2‰ all through the succession. The values presented by Jux and Manze (1979) are also uniform, but strangely they are lighter, mostly ranging from 0‰ to +1‰. We have no explanation for this consistent difference, and Jux and Manze (1979) did not indicate what standard they used. At any
Amtjärn Another mound of the Kullsberg Limestone is ~1 km SW of Skålberget (Fig. 15). It is of slightly smaller dimensions than that at Skålberget, and the quarry exposing it is known as the Amtjärn Quarry (Thorslund, 1935, 1936). In the vicinity of this quarry there are outcrops, now mostly overgrown and covered, of both underlying and overlying units (Laufeld, 1967; Thorslund and Jaanusson, 1960; Jaanusson, 1982). Of special interest for the present study is a section a few meters thick of the uppermost Dalby Formation just below the Kullsberg mound near the south entrance to the quarry (Thorslund and Jaanusson, 1960, Fig. 12). This may be the only locality in the region that currently exposes the base of the Kullsberg Limestone as well as subjacent strata. Condonts from the Dalby Formation at this site show that the exposed beds represent the topmost part of the unit and the Baltoniodus alobataus Subzone of the Amorphognathus tvaerensis Zone (Tobin et al., 2005). The δ13C data from the Dalby Formation show baseline values of ~1‰ (Fig. 19), but they get heavier upward, and this increase continues into the lowermost part of the overlying Kullsberg Limestone to reach values of +1.7‰ at the end of the outcrop. We interpret this increase as marking the beginning of the GICE. Further sampling at Amtjärn may help bridge the gap in the δ13C curve between the Amtjärn and Skålberget successions, but we believe this gap to be relatively insignificant. The importance of the Amtjärn succession is that it shows that the GICE is present also in the lowermost part of the Kullsberg Limestone mound. It should be noted that the GICE interval is >50 m thick in the Kullsberg mound facies, hence some 10 times as thick as at Fjäcka that represents the inter-mound facies. However, the end of the excursion is currently poorly established in the mound facies, because at Skålberget there is a stratigraphic gap at the top of the mound lens. However, based on conodonts, and especially the important species Hamarodus europaeus, the Skålberg Limestone that overlies the Kullsberg Limestone correlates with the post-GICE part of the Moldå Formation at Fjäcka, and the end of the GICE therefore may be at the top of the Kullsberg Limestone. Smedsby Gård, Östergötland The well drilled by the Geological Survey of Sweden in 1946 at Smedsby Gård near the town of Motala (Fig. 13) penetrated the GICE interval as well as older and younger strata (Jaanusson, 1962; Wikman et al., 1982). Because the succession corresponding to the Skagen and Moldå Formations is uniform lithologically in this region, Jaanusson (1982) introduced the
Kinnekulle K-bentonite
-6
-8
0
1
2
13
C
carb.
Amorphognathus complicatus Hamarodus europaeus
80
85
Kinnekulle K-benonite
Baltoniodus alobatus
-4
SLANDROM LS.
?
Amorphognathus tvaerensis B. alobatus not named
-2
Amorphognathus tvaerensis
Baltoniodus alobatus
SKAGEN FM.
Core missing
2
0
DALBY FM.
75
GICE
?
m
74
FREBERGA FM.
4
53
SMEDSBY GÅRD CORE
DALBY FM.
6
Am. superbus
Amorphognathus complicatus Hamarodus europaeus
Depth m
GICE
MOLDÅ FM.
SLANDROM LS.
FJÄCKA
CONODONT ZONE CONODONT SUBZONE
Upper Ordovician Guttenberg δ13C excursion (GICE) in North America and Baltoscandia
90
0
1
2
13
C
carb.
Figure 17. Comparison of the GICE in the Fjäcka and Smedsby Gård sections, based on data from the present study. Note that the baseline value of the δ13C curve is ~+1‰, and the GICE peak value approaches +2‰ in both successions.
term Freberga Formation for this interval, and this designation is used herein. Although Wikman et al. (1982) briefly referred to the Freberga Formation portion of the core, this interval has not yet been described in any detail. In the lower 5 m of the Freberga Formation the δ13C values are between 0‰ and +1‰ (Fig. 20), which are considered baseline values. At about the 83 m core depth, the values show a distinct increase to nearly +2‰, and we regard this as the beginning of the GICE. For a stratigraphic thickness of ~5 m, the δ13C values range between +1‰ and +2‰ before decreasing to baseline values of ~1‰ at 78–79 m core depth, which marks the end of the GICE. As seen in Figure 17, the GICE curve is closely similar to the Fjäcka curve, and the excursion has a similar thickness. Also the biostratigraphy of the Freberga Formation resembles closely that of the Skagen and Moldå Formations at Fjäcka. The uppermost part of the Dalby Formation contains conodonts of the Baltoniodus alobatus Subzone of the Amorphognathus tvaerensis Zone. As in the Fjäcka section, the conodonts Hamarodus europaeus and Amorphognathus complicatus appear just after
the end of the GICE in the upper part of the Freberga Formation at virtually the same level as in the Fjäcka section. The Freberga Formation is slightly thicker (~13.3 m) compared with ~10 m of the combined thickness of the Skagen and Moldå Formations at Fjäcka, but the δ13C chemostratigraphy and biostratigraphy are remarkably similar. GICE IN ESTONIA AND LATVIA An exceptionally large amount of δ13C work has been carried out in recent years in the Ordovician of eastern Baltoscandia, and especially in Estonia (Ainsaar et al., 2004a, 2004b; Kaljo et al., 1999, 2004). In fact, the stratigraphical and regional δ13C variations in that system are better known in Estonia that in any other region of similar size in the world. Furthermore, biostratigraphy, lithofacies, faunas, and lithostratigraphy have been investigated in great detail in both outcrops and many drill cores. For a useful general summary of non-isotopic information, see Raukas and Teedumäe (1997).
54
Bergström et al.
N. ENTRANCE
SKÅLBERGET & AMTJÄRN
N
m SKÅLB. KULLS
50
Fjäcka Sh.
Boda Lst. Tunnel section
30 25 20 15 10 5 0
S. entrance section 0
covered
30
AMTJÄRN SOUTH
sampled section
5
DALBY FM.
m
Figure 18. Sketch map of the Skålberget locality (after Jaanusson, 1982), which is now a nature preserve. Our sampled section through the 50+-m-thick Kullsberg Limestone at the south margin of the quarry is marked by a thick black line.
GICE
Sla nd rom
Kullsberg Lst.
N. entrance section
35
SKÅLBERGET SOUTH
water-filled pit
KULLSBERG LIMESTONE
40
Skålberg Lst. Lst .
no ou tcr op s
45
0
covered
0
1
2
3
13
C
carb.
The Upper Ordovician succession in eastern Baltoscandia includes mostly calcareous epicontinental rocks deposited in shallow-water environments at temperate to subtropical latitudes. By and large, water depth increased in a southern direction in terms of present latitudes, with the shallowest environments being in northern Estonia and somewhat deeper waters in southern Estonia and Latvia. Although the Upper Ordovician succession in both northern and southern Estonia has several stratigraphic gaps (Nõlvak and Grahn, 1993; Ainsaar et al., 2004a; Kaljo et al., 2004, Fig. 2), these tend to be relatively minor, and as a whole the portion of the succession pertinent to the present study is remarkably complete stratigraphically. A significant δ13C excursion in the upper Keila and Oandu Stages, referred to as the mid-Caradoc excursion by Kaljo et al. (2004), is here identified as the GICE on the basis of biostratigraphic and other evidence. The report by Ainsaar et al. (1999) is apparently the first to compare this Estonian excursion with the Guttenberg excursion (GICE) in North America. As indicated by drill core investigations, the excursion is best developed in southern Estonia and Latvia. This may at least partly
Figure 19. Composite δ13C curve, based on our Skålberget and Amtjärn sections. The baseline δ13C values are likely to be ~+1‰, and the GICE peak values through the Kullsberg Limestone are extraordinarily uniform, being mostly between +2‰ and +2.5‰. Note that the top of the GICE is not yet well established at Skålberget, but the topmost part of the GICE curve may well be cut out by the unconformity at the top surface of the Kullsberg Limestone mound.
reflect the widespread stratigraphic gap at the Keila-Oandu contact that may cut out parts or all of the upper Keila GICE interval in many sections in northern Estonia. For southern Estonia, instructive excursion curves have been published from, for instance, the Ristiküla-174 (Meidla et al., 1999; Ainsaar et al., 2004a), Viljandi (Kaljo et al., 2004), Männamaa F-367 (Ainsaar et al., 2004a), Mehikoorma-421 (Martma, 2005), and Valga–10 (Ainsaar et al., 2004a) drill cores. In Latvia, the excursion is present in the Kandava (Brenchley et al., 1996) and Jurmala (Ainsaar et al., 2004a) drill cores. Because of its stratigraphic completeness and informative δ13C curve, we select the
Upper Ordovician Guttenberg δ13C excursion (GICE) in North America and Baltoscandia
74 75 Core missing
406.7
KEILA
80
GICE
402.5
GICE
FREBERGA FM.
401.1
85
90
0
1 C
13
2
carb.
424.6
Kinnekulle K-b.
0
HALJALA
Kinnekulle K-benonite
Baltoniodus alobatus
DALBY FM.
RAKVERE
Depth m
OANDU
m
NABALA ESTONIAN STAGES
RISTIKÜLA 174 CORE, SOUTHERN ESTONIA Amorphognathus complicatus Hamarodus europaeus
SLANDROM LS.
SMEDSBY GÅRD CORE
55
1 C
2
13
carb.
Figure 20. Comparison between the GICE in the Smedsby Gård, Sweden, and the Ristiküla, southern Estonia (Ainsaar et al., 1999), drill cores. Note the close similarity of the δ13C curves, despite the fact that these sites are more than 600 km apart. In both successions the baseline values are between 0‰ and 1‰, and the GICE curve peak values are near 2‰. Based on chemostratigraphic correlation, the base of the Oandu Stage would correspond to a level at ~79 m in the Smedsby Gård drill core.
Ristiküla-174 drill core as an instructive illustration of the GICE in eastern Baltoscandia. Ristiküla-174 This core was drilled by the Estonian Geological Survey and was studied by Ainsaar et al. (1996, 1999), who provided extensive faunal and lithologic data. In this drill core an 8–9-m-thick interval above the Kinnekulle K-bentonite, which represents the lower half of the Keila Stage, shows baseline δ13C values between 0‰ and +1‰, with most values being ~+0.5‰ (Fig. 20). Slightly higher stratigraphically there is a conspicuous rise in the δ13C curve to values near +2‰, which mark the beginning of the GICE. These high values persist for the next few meters before the δ13C curve drops to values between +1‰
and +1.5‰; these are followed, slightly higher up, by even lighter values of ~0‰, which are taken as marking the end of the GICE. As a whole, the Ristiküla δ13C curve shows a remarkably close similarity to that of the Smedsby Gård, allowing a close correlation between these successions (Fig. 20). There is also an obvious similarity between the Estonian curve and the Fjäcka one (Fig. 17). This close chemostratigraphic correlation is of special stratigraphic interest, because in this stratigraphic interval the precise relations between the Estonian standard regional stages and the Scandinavian succession have long been uncertain and even controversial (see, e.g., Jaanusson, 1976). Assuming that no significant gaps occur in the Keila-Rakvere succession in the Ristiküla drill core, the chemostratigraphic data suggest that the base of the Oandu Stage corresponds to a level 1–2 m above the base
56
Bergström et al.
of the Moldå Formation in its type section at Fjäcka, and that the top of the Oandu Stage is coeval with a level in the middle part of the Moldå Formation. As noted by several authors, for instance, Ainsaar et al. (1996), the boundary between the Keila and Oandu Stages is in large parts of eastern Baltoscandia marked by a stratigraphic gap that reflects a widespread regression. In the Fjäcka succession there is no obvious lithologic evidence of such a gap, although the more common occurrence of limestone beds with a higher carbonate content in the Moldå Formation compared with those of the Skagen Formation perhaps may be interpreted as indicating a shallowing in the depositional environment. We attribute the apparent lack of the Keila-Oandu boundary gap in the Fjäcka succession as due to the fact that the latter was deposited at a water depth large enough to prevent minor regressions to leave a recognizable imprint in the geological record. δ13C EXCURSIONS ABOVE AND BELOW THE GICE INTERVAL Several, in most cases relatively small, positive shifts in the δ13C curve above and below the GICE interval have been distinguished and named in both North America and northern Europe. However, the question as to whether or not these are local or global excursions has not been adequately addressed in the literature by regional comparisons. The detailed δ13C curves now available from a considerable number of sections provide a timely opportunity to assess the regional distribution and stratigraphic significance of these δ13C perturbations. In their detailed study of the δ13C chemostratigraphy of the Decorah Formation and associated strata in the Upper Mississippi Valley, Ludvigson et al. (2004) recognized four positive pre-GICE δ13C excursions in the late Turinian Stage, namely, in descending order, the Spechts Ferry, Quimby’s Mill, Grand Detour, and Mifflin excursions; three of these are shown in Figure 21. Presumably, owing to the existence of stratigraphic gaps in the succession, not all of these excursions are recognized in the δ13C curve of each locality, but they are best displayed at their localities 2–4 (Ludvigson et al., 2004, Figs. 7–9). The Spechts Ferry excursion, which lies typically between the Deicke and Elkport K-bentonites, is characterized by a positive shift in the δ13C curve just below a negative shift beneath the point of the beginning of the GICE (Fig. 21). However, in most sections the excursion curve differs little in this interval from the baseline values above and below the GICE. The stratigraphic position of the Spechts Ferry excursion just above the Deicke K-bentonite facilitates direct comparison with North American sections outside the Upper Mississippi Valley. For instance, the Tyrone Limestone at Boonesborough, Kentucky (Fig. 21), the Nealmont Limestone of Dolly Ridge, West Virginia (Fig. 6), and Reedsville, Pennsylvania (Fig. 9), and the Carters Formation of central Tennessee (Fig. 7) do not show a significant excursion between the two major K-bentonites. On the other hand, there is a positive shift of ~+1.5‰ between these K-bentonites at Hagan,
Virginia (Fig. 6). In Baltoscandia there is no notable positive excursion directly below the Kinnekulle K-bentonite that could be interpreted as the Spechts Ferry excursion. Hence, based on the evidence at hand, it appears that this excursion is a local, rather than global, shift in the δ13C curve. The stratigraphically next lower excursion recognized by Ludvigson et al. (2004, Figs. 9 and 10), the Quimby’s Mill excursion, was described from the uppermost part of the Platteville Formation just below the Deicke K-bentonite. This excursion is identified in only a few drill cores, but its absence in other sections in the Upper Mississippi Valley may be due to the absence of the excursion interval at the very prominent unconformity at the top of the Platteville Formation. In the Boonesborough, Kentucky, succession (Conkin and Conkin, 1983), there is a minor positive shift in the δ13C values from 0‰ to ~+1‰ within an interval a few meters thick beneath the Deicke K-bentonite (Fig. 21) that might correspond to the Quimby’s Mill excursion in eastern Iowa. However, in the coeval interval in other studied sections outside the Upper Mississippi Valley there appears to be little deviation from the δ13C baseline values, and we consider this excursion to be a local, rather than regional, feature. The lowest two excursions recognized by Ludvigson et al. (2004), the Grand Detour and Mifflin excursions, are characterized by shifts of up to ~2‰ from the baseline values in the δ13C curve (Fig. 21), and we are uncertain about their regional significance. If regionally distributed, they ought to be present in the interval of the Tyrone-Oregon Formations in Kentucky, but the biostratigraphic resolution currently available is insufficient to establish their precise positions within this interval in which there appears to be no significant shift from the baseline values (Fig. 21). At Hagan, there is a minor positive shift (up to ~+1.5 ‰) in the δ13C curve ~30–50 m below the Deicke K-bentonite that might represent one of these excursions, but further studies are needed to confirm this. The contact between the Platteville and the Decorah Formations marks a prominent gap of regionally variable magnitude in the Upper Mississippi Valley succession (Ludvigson et al., 2004, Fig. 3). In some areas, for instance, in northern Illinois, the entire GICE interval is missing. There is no evidence of the corresponding unconformity in the upper Turinian interval below the Deicke K-bentonite in Kentucky. In Baltoscandia, equivalents to the North American Turinian Stage ought to be present in the middle and upper Dalby Formation in Sweden, and in the lower Adze and Dreimani Formations in Estonia, which represent an interval referred to the Baltoniodus alobatus Subzone, and possibly the B. gerdae Subzone, of the Amorphognathus tvaerensis Zone (Bergström, 1971). This interval, below the Kinnekulle K-bentonite, is characterized by a prominent negative δ13C shift in some published δ13C curves from Sweden, Latvia, and Estonia (Ainsaar et al., 2004b, Fig. 1; Meidla et al., 2004, Fig. 1). In the recent description of the Kergula (565) drill core from northern Estonia, Martma (2006, Fig. 4) showed this interval as representing the upper part of the
Upper Ordovician Guttenberg δ13C excursion (GICE) in North America and Baltoscandia
57
Figure 21. Comparison of the Turinian δ13C excursions recognized in eastern Iowa (Ludvigson et al., 2004) and the δ13C curve from the coeval interval in the thicker, and presumably stratigraphically more complete, succession through the upper High Bridge Group at Boonesborough, Kentucky. Whereas the Iowa succession shows δ13C value fluctuations from near –3‰ to ~+0.5‰, most Kentucky values are between 0‰ and ~+1‰. This makes safe comparison of the Iowa δ13C excursions with the Kentucky succession difficult. Interestingly, correlation between the two curves is improved if one assumes that the prominent gap between the Platteville and the Decorah Formations in Iowa corresponds to ~6 m of section represented just below the Deicke K-bentonite in the Kentucky section, where there is no evidence of an unconformity.
“Upper Kukruse low” in the δ13C curve. Hence, in Baltoscandia there is currently no obvious evidence of the existence of the three Turinian positive δ13C excursions recognized in the Upper Mississippi Valley. Investigations after the initial submission of the present study (Bergström et al., 2007, 2009) have shown that the several positive δ13C excursions recognized between the GICE and HICE in Estonia (Kaljo et al., 2004) have their counterparts in the Cincinnati region reference successions of the Cincinnatian Series, the Upper Ordovician in the North American classification. These interesting results, which will be published in some detail elsewhere, indicate that not only GICE and HICE, but these excursions also, are of a global nature.
GICE RELATIONSHIP TO EUSTASY It is generally agreed that the latest Ordovician Hirnantian δ13C excursion (HICE) was associated with a eustatic regression caused by the lodging of very large amounts of water in the continental ice sheets on the Gondwana continents. Although recent studies (Bergström et al., 2006) suggest that this event might have involved more than a single glacial period, the correlation between the positive δ13C excursion and regression(s) appears well established, as it is based on investigation of a considerable number of successions on several continents. The possible relation between GICE and a Gondwana glaciation is more controversial and has been discussed in several
58
Bergström et al.
recent papers (see, e.g., Kaljo et al., 2004; Tobin et al., 2005; Young et al., 2005), but finding a conclusive relationship between GICE, glaciation, and eustatic regression has been elusive. It can be assumed that the development during GICE time of a significant continental glaciation with large ice sheets would result in a glacio-eustatic regression that is likely to have left a recognizable record, especially in the shallow-water cratonic sedimentary successions. Unfortunately, most Late Ordovician sea level curves are based only on a particular region (see, e.g., Ross and Ross, 1992; Nielsen, 2004), and published global sea level curves tend to have limited stratigraphic resolution. Furthermore, it is often difficult to separate regressive events caused by more or less local epeirogeny from those resulting from eustasy. As noted by Tobin et al. (2005), in order to separate epeirogenic effects from eustasy, it is useful, if not necessary, to examine coeval sea level events on several continents. Despite these problems, in a regional study like the present one it is of interest to examine the relations between the GICE and bathymetric indications in the rock record. If it could be shown that this excursion was globally associated with a eustatic regression similar to the regression present in the HICE interval, it would strongly suggest the existence of an ice age during GICE time. Unfortunately, the evidence used in support of the existence of such a glacial period during GICE time in northern Africa is highly controversial (Hamoumi, 1999, 2003) and is not considered conclusive by most workers. Abundant evidence indicates that in the North American Midcontinent, late Turonian strata, such as the Tyrone Formation of Kentucky (Cressman and Noger, 1976), the Bromide Formation of Oklahoma (Amsden and Sweet, 1983), the Platteville Formation and coeval formations of the Upper Mississippi Valley (Witzke and Bunker, 1996), the Carters Formation of central Tennessee (Holland and Patzkowsky, 1998), the Eggleston Formation of Virginia, the Nealmont Formation of central Pennsylvania, and the Black River Group of New York–Ontario (Brett et al., 2004), represent very shallow-water (mostly peritidal) facies that has been described as having “layer-cake” stratigraphy. The upper part of this succession represents the M4 sequence of Holland and Patzkowsky (1996, 1998). Commonly, the top of this sequence is an omission surface (Kolata et al., 1998) that locally, as in Kentucky, has a relief of several meters (Cressman, 1973). The strata overlying this unconformity, which were regarded as the lower part of their M5 sequence by Holland and Patzkowsky (1996, 1998), are known by different formation names in different states, such as the Lexington Limestone in Kentucky, the Viola Springs Formation in Oklahoma, the Decorah Formation in the Upper Mississippi Valley, the Dolly Ridge Formation in West Virginia, and the Hermitage Formation in central Tennessee. All these units show evidence of having been formed in deeper water than the underlying Turinian peritidal carbonates, and clearly they represent sediments deposited during a sea level rise. The GICE starts in the Logana Member of the Lexington Limestone in Kentucky and in a coeval position in other sections near, or at, what has been described as a maximum flooding surface (Brett
et al., 2004). Hence, the major part of the GICE occurs in a highstand systems tract in Kentucky, and the same is the case in the other regions just listed. The upper part of the GICE is present in strata laid down in a shallowing depositional environment characterized by the occurrence of grainstones, etc. A similar trend can be recognized in the central Nevada succession, where the moderately deep-water Copenhagen Formation with the GICE is overlain by the very shallow-water Eureka Quartzite (Saltzman and Young, 2005). To summarize, in North America at least a significant part of the GICE appears to be present in a transgressive, rather than regressive, part of the Ordovician sedimentary record. In this respect it would seem to differ from the HICE. The bathymetric conditions in Baltoscandia were less uniform than in North America during the GICE interval, and two recently proposed interpretations of water depth are partly contradictory. Kaljo et al. (2004, Fig. 5) described the initial part of the GICE succession in the upper Keila stages of Estonia as having been deposited during a regression that culminated at the end of Keila time as shown by the unconformable Keila-Oandu contact, which is associated with a stratigraphic gap, especially in northern Estonia (Nõlvak and Grahn, 1993). The upper part of the GICE interval was interpreted as representing a minor transgression in early-middle Oandu time. Hence, in this bathymetric interpretation, assuming that the transatlantic correlation of the GICE is correct, the Estonian sea level changes would be opposite to those displayed in the North American Midcontinent. Nielsen (2004) proposed a partly different interpretation of the sea level history in Baltoscandia during this particular time interval. Based primarily on the Caledonian foreland basin succession in the Oslo region of southeastern Norway, his Keila Drowning Event in the lower-middle Keila Stage was followed by a lowstand in the upper Keila and Oandu Stages, the Frognerkilen Lowstand Event. On the other hand, Kaljo et al. (2004) interpreted most of the Oandu deposits as representing a deepening event. Most of the following, post-GICE, Rakvere Stage was shown by Nielsen (2004) to represent his Nakkholmen Deepening Event, whereas Kaljo et al. (2004) showed this as a lowstand episode. Hence the interpretations by Kaljo et al. (2004) and Nielsen (2004) are in conflict with each other in the GICE interval, and neither of these alternatives fits very well with the sea level history of the North American Midcontinent, although Nielsen’s (2004) interpretation would appear to be closest to the bathymetry of the latter region. Nielsen and Meidla (2004) tried to resolve some of the problems in the correlation of sea level curves between Norway and Estonia, but there are still differences in interpretation. In Sweden the GICE starts in the upper part of the Skagen Formation and in the coeval basal part of the Kullsberg Limestone. For a recent discussion of the general bathymetric conditions in the Siljan region, see Tobin et al. (2005). The strata of the GICE interval were deposited in substantially deeper water than coeval rocks in Estonia and hence were less affected by relatively minor bathymetric changes. Although estimating the
Upper Ordovician Guttenberg δ13C excursion (GICE) in North America and Baltoscandia precise water depth is difficult, the topographic relations between the Kullsberg mounds and the surrounding level bottom where the Fjäcka succession was deposited may provide a minimum local depth figure. As shown above, the GICE occurs through the >50-m-thick Kullsberg Limestone and through ~5 m of the non-mound Fjäcka succession. According to Tobin et al. (2005), the depth in the Kullsberg depositional environment was likely to have been several tens of meters. Assuming a relatively constant rate of deposition in both mound and non-mound facies during the GICE interval, it would seem that during at least late GICE time, the water depth at Fjäcka must have been >50 m and perhaps as much as 75–100 m, based on the elevation of the mound above the surrounding sea bottom on which the non-mound Skagen and Moldå Formations were deposited. In Scania, southernmost Sweden, the Skagen Formation with the GICE appears to have been deposited during a brief shallowing episode, as shown by the change from dark shale to limestone facies, and in some other areas there is a significant stratigraphic gap at the top of the Skagen Limestone (see Nõlvak and Grahn, 1993) that may mark the peak of the regression. Whether this gap cuts out the upper part of the GICE, as one would expect on the basis of the stratigraphically more complete succession in the Siljan area, is not yet known and requires further study. In view of these problems the only conclusion that can be drawn is that at least at the present time there is no very convincing regional evidence from Baltoscandia and North America that overall the GICE was closely correlated with a eustatic regression. This would make it unlikely that the GICE was somehow related to a significant glaciation episode in the Gondwana region. If there was a glaciation at that time, it would appear unlikely that it involved the formation of large continental ice sheets that trapped substantial amounts of seawater (Tobin et al., 2005). GICE AND CLIMATIC INDICATORS It is a widely held view that overall, the Ordovician Period, except its latest part (Hirnantian Stage), was characterized by a greenhouse-state climate with high CO2 and relatively low O2 (see, e.g., Barnes, 2004). Although this may be true as a generalization, it may not necessarily be valid for relatively short time periods such as the GICE interval. The possible presence of continental ice sheets in the Gondwana region in the Late Ordovician prior to the Hirnantian has been discussed by several authors (see, e.g., Hamoumi, 1999, 2003; Pope and Steffen, 2003; Saltzman and Young, 2005), but the supporting evidence for a glaciation has been equivocal. The apparent absence of undisputed glacial deposits in the well-exposed successions of early Katian age in the Gondwana region has been taken by some authors as important negative evidence for the existence of such a glacial period. Recently, Tobin et al. (2005), on the basis of geochemical evidence, suggested that the GICE was associated with a cooling event without formation of a continental ice sheet. In the following section we will briefly discuss some lithologic, faunal, and geochemical indications from North America and Baltoscandia that
59
may have potential for interpretation of the climate, as reflected by the seawater temperature, during the GICE interval. This in turn may help clarify whether or not it is likely that the GICE was associated with a glacial period, as was the case with HICE. Lithofacies During the early part of the Katian Stage, which corresponds approximately with the beginning of the GICE, shallow seas with dominating carbonate deposition covered most of the North American Midcontinent from the Mississippi Valley region to the Appalachian foreland basin. Paleomagnetic data indicate that, for instance, Kentucky lay at ~10°S latitude (Bergström and Noltimier, 1982), and the data at hand suggest that the entire Midcontinent apparently was in the tropical zone. Many limestones are bahamitic, indicating deposition at water temperatures of >22–25 °C (Jaanusson, 1973). Evaporites are uncommon in these strata, and the diverse and abundant benthic faunas suggest normal seawater salinities and good water circulation. In central Kentucky the lithofacies of the GICE interval (essentially the Logana Member of the Lexington Limestone) has been described as being a cool-water type with phosphaterich limestones that differ in some respects from the underlying peritidal bahamitic limestones in the Tyrone Formation (Holland and Patzkowsky, 1996). It has also been proposed that the lithofacies of these carbonate sediments was affected by upwelling from the nearby Sebree Trough (Kolata et al., 1998, 2001), which was an elongate basinal structure that is thought to have had an oceanic connection to the south. But the carbonates of the GICE interval in Kentucky, as well as elsewhere in the Midcontinent, are of a tropical type and differ substantially from the subtropical-temperate cold-water limestones in Baltoscandia. Thus we conclude that the lithofacies of the Laurentian carbonates does not provide evidence of a marked lowering of the seawater temperature that could be used as evidence for the presence of a glaciation. It is also significant that, as noted above, the GICE is in that part of the Katian succession that represents a flooding event in both the Mississippi Valley and in the eastern Midcontinent, which is opposite to what would be expected from a glacioeustatic regression. The lithofacies of the sediments in Baltoscandia corresponding to the early Katian Stage in North America, especially those in Sweden and the Baltic States, have been investigated extensively, and a large amount of information has been published. During GICE time, Baltoscandia occupied a subtropical-temperate position (Spjeldnaes, 1961; Bergström and Noltimier, 1982; Cocks and Torsvik, 2005) at a latitude of 30–35°S. Jaanusson (1973) and Lindström (1984), among others, discussed various environmental parameters bearing on the deposition of the Ordovician limestones in Baltoscandia. Although these authors differed in their interpretation of the water depth in the depositional environment, they agreed that most pre-Hirnantian Ordovician limestones in Baltoscandia were deposited in relatively cold water. Bahamitic carbonates are unknown in the GICE interval in
60
Bergström et al.
Sweden but are present locally in the Oandu Stage in Estonia (Vasalemma Formation) and particularly in coeval shallow-water strata (Mjøsa Limestone) in the Mjøsa region in southeastern Norway (Jaanusson, 1976). These unique successions, which include reef-like structures, were interpreted by Jaanusson (1973) as representing a brief invasion of warm waters into parts of the Baltoscandic depositional basin. Judging from the Estonian succession, this warm-water invasion occurred during the final phase of the GICE. The absence of coeval bahamitic strata in Sweden has been attributed to the fact that the depositional environment was too deep and too cold at the bottom for deposition of such carbonates. The local presence at relatively low latitudes in Baltoscandia of warm-water carbonates in the GICE interval, in a succession otherwise characterized by cold-water limestones, is not what would be expected if the GICE was associated with a cold climate and a glaciation. Hence, the lithofacies evidence from North America and Baltoscandia is not very indicative of a substantial climatic cooling. A general conclusion emerges: namely that the GICE is not restricted to a particular carbonate lithofacies but is present in a spectrum of carbonate rock types representing a variety of depositional environments from warm, tropical, shallow-water seas to subtropicaltemperate, relatively deep and cool epicontinental sites. Faunas It is a well-established fact that the Ordovician is one of the Phanerozoic periods with the most conspicuous biogeographic differentiation in the faunas (Jaanusson, 1976; Jaanusson and Bergström, 1980; McKerrow and Scotese, 1990; Webby et al., 2004). A primary reason for this is clearly the vast latitudinal spacing of the continents during this time period, with large regions at different latitudes with different climates from the equator to the poles. The GICE interval provides an instructive illustration of the faunal differentiation at different latitudes with associated differences in climate and seawater temperatures. The Midcontinent megafossil faunas in the North American GICE interval are of tropical types and are dominated by brachiopods and bryozoans and with relatively less abundant occurrences of other shelly fossils such as trilobites, pelecypods, and corals. For useful reviews of the megafossil faunas in the Upper Mississipi Valley, see Sloan (2005), and for those in Kentucky and nearby states, see Pojeta (1979, and the several other U.S. Geological Survey monographs in the series “Contributions to the Ordovician Paleontology of Kentucky and Nearby States”). Useful information is also available in Feldmann and Hackathorn (1996). These faunas have very little in common, even at the generic level, with most coeval megafossil faunas in Baltoscandia. For extensive information about the latter faunas, especially the diverse ones in Estonia, see Rõõmusoks (1970). Also the Baltoscandian microfossil faunas in the GICE interval differ strikingly from those from the North American Midcontinent (Bergström, 1990) apart from the presence of a few pandemic and in most cases long-ranging taxa. However, there is
one important exception to this statement—the conodont fauna of the Mjøsa and Svartsaetra Limestones in Norway and, to a lesser extent, that of the Saku Member of the Vasalemma Formation of Estonia (Bergström, 1997; Bergström et al., 1998). The conodont fauna of the Mjøsa Limestone is of a unique type in Europe and is closely similar to the tropical one from the Lexington Limestone in Kentucky (Bergström et al., 1998); but it is strikingly different from those of the coeval Skagen and Moldå Formations in Sweden and corresponding strata in Norway (Hamar, 1966). Interestingly, these condont faunas are associated with some shelly fossils of Laurentian type and occur in shallow-water bahamitic limestones (see above). There is no significant faunal change that correlates closely with the GICE interval. In the North American Midcontinent succession, the Turinian very shallow-water shelly and conodont faunas differ in several respects from the Chatfieldian ones, but this change occurs in the uppermost Turinian, hence well below the beginning of the GICE. For instance, in the well-known succession in the Upper Mississippi Valley, the faunal change is near the Deicke K-bentonite (Sloan, 2005), and it might be at a corresponding interval in Kentucky and adjacent states (Patzkowsky and Holland, 1996, 1997), although the paucity of fossils in the uppermost Tyrone Limestone and coeval strata makes it difficult to recognize details in the faunal succession. At any rate, this faunal change is attributed to the marked environmental change from peritidal to deeper, although not very deep, conditions at the beginning of the M5 sequence. In an informative review, Ainsaar et al. (2004a) summarized various faunal changes in the Keila-Oandu succession in northern Estonia. The most significant is that at the top of the Keila Stage, which is commonly an unconformity and a stratigraphic gap of regionally variable magnitude, not only in northern Estonia but also in parts of eastern and south-central Sweden (Nõlvak and Grahn, 1993). It is important to note that this gap, which was caused by a regression in the latest Keila sea, is in the middle to upper part of the GICE curve (Fig. 20). If one assumes that the GICE curve covers the same chronostratigraphic interval in Baltoscandia and in North America, as suggested by a variety of evidence presented above, the faunal change in Estonia occurred substantially later than the one near the top of the Turinian Stage in North America, and the North American M4-M5 sequence boundary is clearly older than the latest Keila regression in northern Estonia. Hence, these faunal and depositional changes are not coeval, as suggested by Ainsaar et al. (2004a, p. 128), but diachronous. Accordingly, they are not very useful evidence for a possible global oceanographic change in the GICE interval, or for a contemporaneous eustatic sea level change, in Baltoscandia and in North America. 18
O Geochemistry
Important information about seawater temperature in ancient environments can be obtained by investigations of the δ18O isotope in well-preserved calcareous fossils and carbonate
Upper Ordovician Guttenberg δ13C excursion (GICE) in North America and Baltoscandia sediments. This method is based on the fact that the difference in δ18O/δ16O ratios between the CaCO3 and the seawater from which the calcium carbonate is precipitated is related to the temperature, with a decrease in temperature of the water leading to an increase in the calcite δ18O value. This paleothermometer is widely used in geologically relatively young (Cenozoic and Cretaceous) deposits, and it has often proved to produce valuable, and seemingly reliable, data on past seawater temperatures (Anderson and Arthur, 1983). However, many attempts to use this technique on Paleozoic marine limestones and fossils have been unsuccessful, because the δ18O values have been reset owing to diagenesis (Marshall, 1992) and do not represent the original δ18O signature. The idea that in general, Paleozoic δ18O values are unreliable (see, e.g., Kaljo et al., 2004), if not entirely useless, has resulted from the unfortunate practice of leaving out δ18O values in many 13 C publications. Most δ18O values through the GICE interval in Kentucky are between –4.8‰ and −6‰, in the Hagan (Virginia) and Dolly Ridge (West Virginia) successions between –5.7‰ and –6.5‰, and in the Fittstown (Oklahoma) section between –4.5‰ and −5.2‰ (Young et al., 2005). Shields et al. (2003) reported similar v