1
THE MALE DANCER
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
Reviews of the first edition: ‘The fascination of this book lies in the wa...
27 downloads
1255 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
1
THE MALE DANCER
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
Reviews of the first edition: ‘The fascination of this book lies in the way in which the author is able to locate the male dancer in the broader socio-historic context of the times . . . a vital contribution to the placing of dance and its literature within contemporary cultural debate.’ Dr Alexander Carter, Middlesex University ‘A complex summary of the numerous biases and windows through which we have viewed and continue to view male dancers . . . Burt’s work argues persuasively that theatrical dance is a vital and threatening site for defining masculinity in relation to the culture at large.’ David J. Popalisky, Dance Research Journal The Male Dancer, 2nd Edition updates and enlarges a classic Routledge title that has established itself as the definitive study of the role of men in ballet, modern, and postmodern dance. In this challenging and lively book, Burt examines the representation of masculinity in twentieth- and twenty-first-century dance. Taking issue with formalist and modernist accounts of dance, which dismiss gender and sexuality as irrelevant, he argues that prejudices against male dancers are rooted in our ideas about the male body and male behaviour. Drawing on recent developments in dance and performance theory, Burt provides a provocative theory of spectatorship in dance. He examines the work of choreographers such as Nijinsky, Graham, Bausch, and Bill T. Jones, relating performances of masculinity in their dances to the social, political, and artistic contexts in which these were produced. The Male Dancer has proven to be essential reading for anyone interested in dance and the cultural construction of gender. Ramsay Burt has thoroughly updated this important work to include dance works from the last ten years. Reflecting on the latest studies in theory, performance, and practice, he has renewed its timeliness for the new century. Ramsay Burt is Professor of Dance History at De Montfort University, Leicester, UK. His publications include The Male Dancer, followed by Alien Bodies and Judson Dance Theatre. In 1999 he was Visiting Professor at the Department of Performance Studies, New York University. With Professor Susan Foster, he is founder editor of Discourses in Dance.
1
TH E M ALE DAN CE R 1
Bodies, Spectacle, Sexualities
11
Second Edition
11
Ramsay Burt
1
11
11
11
First edition published 1995 by Routledge Second edition published 2007 by Routledge 2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon OX14 4RN Simultaneously published in the USA and Canada by Routledge 270 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016 Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business
This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2007. “To purchase your own copy of this or any of Taylor & Francis or Routledge’s collection of thousands of eBooks please go to www.eBookstore.tandf.co.uk.” © 2007 Ramsay Burt All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilised in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Burt, Ramsay, 1953– The male dancer: bodies, spectacle, sexualities/Ramsay Burt. – 2nd ed. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. 1. Sex in dance. 2. Male dancers. 3. Dance – Sociological aspects. 4. Dance – Anthropological aspects. 5. Masculinity. I. Title. GV1595.B87 2006 792.8081 – dc22 2006024777
ISBN 0-203-96097-1 Master e-book ISBN
ISBN10: 0–415–97575–1 (hbk) ISBN10: 0–415–97576–X (pbk) ISBN10: 0–203–96097–1 (ebk) ISBN13: 978–0–415–97575–9 (hbk) ISBN13: 978–0–415–97576–6 (pbk) ISBN13: 978–0–203–96097–4 (ebk)
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
For M.K.B. 1915–82
1
CONTENTS
1
List of figures Acknowledgements Preface to revised second edition
11
11
1
2
1
THE TROUBLE WITH THE MALE DANCER . . .
9
LOOKING AT THE MALE
30
The spectator and the gaze 31 Choreographer-centred and spectator-centred dance analysis 35 Performative speech acts and dance performance 38 The male dancer and the gaze 41 Naturalising male violence 46 Black male dancing bodies and whiteness 52 Masculinity and presence 54 Conclusion 56
11
3
11
INTRODUCTION
Gender norms and binary ways of thinking 13 The subject and modern body 15 Degeneracy and masculinity 19 Homophobia and the male dancer 22 The male ballet dancer during the nineteenth century: green box trees 24 Homosexuality and the male dancer: the dance that does not speak its name 28
1
11
ix x xi
NIJINSKY
58
Ballets Russes and homosexuality 60 Male prowess in Nijinsky’s roles 63 Nijinsky as genius 66 Nijinsky’s unorthodox roles in Fokine’s ballets 68 The radicalism of early modernism 72
vii
CONTENTS
Nijinsky’s ballets and gender representation 76 Nijinska and gender representation 79 L’Homme et son désir and Les Biches 81
4
AMERICAN MEN
85
Men in the US 86 Shawn’s men 91 Male dancing after Shawn 97 Graham’s men 98 Limón, modernism, and ethnicity 105 The Moor’s Pavane and the dangers of male intimacy 108
5
DANCING IN THE CITY
111
Alvin Ailey and black masculinity 116 Merce Cunningham’s anti-hierarchical structures 122 Steve Paxton and contact improvisation 130 Conclusion 135
6
MASCULINITY AND LIBERATION
138
Bausch’s Sacre: men and shame 142 Bausch’s Bluebeard and the landscape of men’s souls 146 Changing men: Are You Right There Michael, Are You Right? 148 Jones and Zane dancing together 152 Redistributing male energy in Set and Reset 154
7
IDENTITY POLITICS
159
Clark and betrayal 160 Morris and the instability of sex and gender 164 Goode, ghosts, violence, and the politics of camp 167 DV8 and lonely men 172 Playing down sexuality in Swan Lake 178
8
POST MEN
181
Displacing masculinity 184 Women choreographers, male dancers 185 Refiguring the relationship between performer and spectator 194 Three male–male duets 198 More trouble 207
Notes Bibliography Index
209 214 227 viii
1
FIGURES
1
11
11
1
1.1 2.1 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 4.1 4.2 5.1 5.2 6.1 6.2 7.1 8.1
L’Opéra du XIXeme siecle DV8: My Sex, Our Dance Cocteau: backstage after Le Spectre de la rose The death of Petrouchka Cocteau: Stravinsky playing Sacre Nijinsky as the Faune Ted Shawn: Death of Adonis Appalachian Spring Alvin Ailey and Carmen de Lavallade Steve Paxton Fergus Early Trisha Brown: Set and Reset DV8: Dead Dreams of Monochrome Men Lea Anderson: Smithereens
11
11
11 ix
10 49 65 67 72 77 93 103 119 132 151 155 175 193
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
No doubt everyone who researches a particular subject in order to write a book ends up with a long list of people who have contributed in a variety of ways. I am grateful to my editors at Routledge who suggest I consider revising The Male Dancer for a second edition. I owe much to Valerie Briginshaw who has been casting a sharp eye on my writing for more years than I care to remember; and to the friends and colleagues who have helped me in one way or another with one edition or the other including Christy Adair, Lynn Garafola, Rachel Fensham, and Sarah Rubidge. Thanks also to Lea Anderson, Frank Bock, Jonathan Burrows, Boris Charmatz, Nigel Charnock, Fergus Early, John Jasperse, and Lloyd Newson, who all very generously allowed me to interview them while each was in the middle of a busy working period; also to Richard Dyer, Michael Huxley, Sally Luxton, Maggie Morris, Nick Nuttgens, Philippa Thomas, Jane Pritchard at Rambert Dance Company, Joe Goode Performance Group, Thin Man Productions, and the Hall Carpenter Archives at the British Library of Political Economy and Science. Also to my students, many of whom will recognise discussions of ideas and pieces that I first tried out in lectures, seminars, and tutorials with them. York, May 2006
x
1
PREFACE TO REVISED SECOND EDITION 1
11
11
1
11
11
11
The manuscript of the first edition of The Male Dancer was completed in March 1994. Since then, as I discovered while working on this revised and expanded second edition, new research has been published in some of the areas that my book covered but not in others. For instance, although I’d seen the Alvin Ailey American Dance Theater live in the UK, I could hardly find anything written about Ailey’s work or indeed about African American dance in general in the UK. This has now changed and there is a growing and important body of scholarship addressing both that deals with this from theoretical and historical perspectives. More has now also been written about Shawn and Graham, though there is little significant change to our understanding of Nijinsky, apart from the new translation of his diaries. When I was writing in the early 1990s, I felt I was moving into largely uncharted territory in writing about male dancers and homosexuality. This is no longer the case so that, perhaps, the fact that I have also discussed heterosexual masculinities is now a distinguishing aspect of the book. In preparing the new edition I have added discussions of works created since 1994. Dance studies has also moved on since then and I have added discussions of older works that have been the subject of new research. I have cut all the references to psychoanalysis that were in the first edition, not because I no longer think it offers useful insights but because dance scholars in general have been so resistant to it that I feel this is not the best place to advocate it. I’ve also cut what was the second chapter of the first edition that focused on dance and philosophy through an examination of theories of expression, phenomenology and hermeneutic philosophy, and post-structuralist theory. Most of what I said about dance theory there is now somewhat out of date. Central to The Male Dancer, however, is a theory of spectatorship based on ideas about the male gaze which were adapted from feminist film theory. While these ideas in general have attracted widespread criticism from dance scholars, my own use of them has not attracted much comment. Some of the hostility within dance studies towards these feminist ideas, in my opinion, is due to the fact that xi
PREFACE TO REVISED SECOND EDITION
they propose spectator-oriented approaches to cultural analysis that challenge a choreographer-oriented approach and the canonical account of great masterworks which it underpins. So, although no one in dance studies in recent years seems to have had a good word to say about the gendered gaze, I have revisited and revised my approach to it with the help of recent work in dance history that combines theories of spectatorship and narratology. While revising the book, I have adjusted the coverage of some chapters. Ailey, for example, is now no longer in a chapter with Shawn, Graham, and Limón. Instead he and newly added Pomare are in a chapter with Cunningham and Paxton. Had I been writing an entirely new book, I would have found a way of dealing with more choreographers of colour. As it is, I hope that contrasting black modern dance with white avantgarde dance practice in the 1960s goes some way towards troubling an influential way of telling the story of modern dance in which the work of people of colour occupies a marginal position. I’ve split what in the first edition was a long final chapter into three: one for the late 1970s and early 1980s; one about the work of gay choreographers during the period of the AIDS epidemic; and one for work in the 1990s and 2000s. In 1994, it seemed to me strategically important to write about male dance and its relation to gay culture because there seemed a damaging lack of public discussion of this. In 2006, it no longer seems appropriate to single out male gender and sexuality for special treatment. I hope, instead, that the theoretical approaches and discussions of dance works that I have developed in this revised edition will be of use to others who wish to include issues concerning gender and sexuality as part of a process of locating choreography and performance within its wider social and political contexts.
xii
1
INTRODUCTION
1
11
11
1
11
I hardly knew of the existence of dance or ballet at all until I was 26 years old. By then I had a degree in painting and art history, and had read some feminist film theory. A friend persuaded me to go to a festival of experimental dance at Dartington College in the south west of England, and virtually my first dance class was a workshop in contact improvisation with Steve Paxton. In retrospect, the experience brought about a big change in my life. Had I been younger I might have tried to become a professional dancer; I have ended up writing about dance instead. I was born and brought up in a small town in the north of England far from anywhere that ballet was performed, and at a time when modern dance was virtually unknown in England except among a few people in London. As a boy and young man I was taken to art galleries and to concerts of classical music. I don’t recall any of my family’s acquaintances ever going to see a ballet, nor was I aware of the existence of ballet schools. Ballet was not an area of experience considered appropriate for young men like myself, or even one in which I might be interested. My experience is not untypical of men of my class and background. Professional dance during approximately the last 150 years has not been considered an appropriate activity for white men to engage in. Such is the strength of the prejudice against male dancers that a large proportion of the men who have pursued careers in modern dance and to a lesser extent ballet have often not discovered dancing until they were in their teens or early twenties. Far fewer men go into professional dance training than women, and it is consequently much easier for men to find employment in dance than for women. At the same time, men occupy a disproportionate number of the artistic and administrative positions at the top of the dance profession. As Christy Adair points out:
11
11
Women do have a very strong presence in dance but a good deal of work needs to be put into equal opportunities policies and practices in dance for women to benefit. In order for women’s perspectives to be clearly established and influential, women need to have access 1
INTRODUCTION
to positions of power and decision-making as choreographers, administrators and directors. (1992: 238) It would seem desirable both to improve women’s position in the dance professions and to change negative attitudes towards the male dancer. There shouldn’t necessarily be a conflict between the two, but clearly a big increase in the number of men entering the dance professions could worsen women’s already precarious and sometimes extremely exploited position. This book is not primarily concerned with the structures and politics of the dance professions but with the meanings that come into play when men dance on stage. Theatre dance is dance performed on stage rather than dance activity occurring in social situations. In looking at gender representations, my approach is inspired by the achievements of the women’s movement in redefining images of women. Issues relating to images of men, however, are often different from those which affect images of women. There is a key difference between re-evaluating images of women and doing the same for images of men. Part of the feminist project has been to reclaim and redefine femininity, and to celebrate the achievements of women artists and thus contradict the legacy of centuries of definition and domination by men. To what extent can men’s achievements in dance be celebrated without, at the same time, reasserting male dominance and thus reinforcing the imbalance of power between men and women in our society? In an ideal world, men should be able to find ways of expressing their individual experiences through dance and contribute to nondiscriminatory perceptions of the differences between men and women. The reality is, of course, the reverse: images of men generally reinforce male dominance over women. But, as I argue in the first two chapters of this book, patriarchy is maintained through limiting the ways in which masculinity is represented in cultural forms, including theatre dance. To become aware of the conscious and unconscious ways through which dominant ideas are inscribed in theatre dance is a step towards understanding how to create alternative, non-oppressive representations. The history of theatre dance in the twentieth century has been one of continual reform and innovation, and one in which questions of gender and gender representation have never been far from the surface. ‘Modern’, ‘new’, ‘contemporary’, ‘postmodern’ or ‘post-modern’, ‘new wave’, ‘next wave’ are all terms that have been used by dance critics and scholars to describe particular developments in theatre dance, often to imply that this latest style renders all previous styles outmoded. The label ‘modern dance’ generally refers to the work of the pioneer dance reformers (nearly all of whom were women) who developed styles other than ballet, including Ruth St Denis (1879–1968), Isadora Duncan (1877–1927), Doris Humphrey (1895–1958), Martha Graham (1894–1991), Rudolph Laban (1879–1958), Ted 2
INT RODUCT ION
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
Shawn (1891–1972), and Mary Wigman (1886–1973) during the first half of the twentieth century. It is sometimes used to describe the work produced in the US during the 1950s and 1960s; most of the younger choreographers, such as Merce Cunningham, Paul Taylor, and Alvin Ailey, had started their careers dancing in companies run by the earlier pioneers. These were predominantly men. The label ‘contemporary dance’ was widely adopted in Europe during the 1960s and 1970s to distinguish between the new interest in dance partly inspired by visits from companies and teachers from the US and the older European modern dance that had gone underground since 1945. Throughout this book, however, I am following US usage and use ‘modern’ to cover both the earlier pioneering modern dance and the later work that continues within that tradition. ‘Modern’ dance, in this sense, is the mainstream modernist dance tradition that made up (and still largely constitutes) the repertoires of the larger mainstream European and North American modern dance companies. The pioneers of modern dance were predominantly women. Similarly the development of ballet in Britain in the twentieth century was initiated by two women: Marie Rambert (1888–1982) and Ninette de Valois (1898–2001). To work out why there were so few men involved in these developments one has to look into the social and institutional factors that have until very recently restricted women’s access to the artistic professions. Up until the nineteenth century, most women artists in the male dominated field of painting were only able to gain access to training and to the specialist knowledge of their chosen profession by being ‘under the protection’ of a male artist, often their father. Bronislava Nijinska (1891–1972) is the only female choreographer of the first half of the twentieth century to make work with the resources of a major, already existing ballet company – initially the Ballets Russes. An important factor that enabled her to do this was the knowledge and experience of the sorts of artistic ideas and practices that lay behind the development of the Ballets Russes’ work which she had gained through her involvement in the work of her brother Vaslav Nijinsky (1889–1950). Clearly one reason why women initially developed a new area – modern dance – was because of their restricted access to creative positions in the existing one. Furthermore, the female pioneers of modern dance did not have any vested interests in upholding the specialist traditions of ballet, and were, therefore, freer than men to develop new and alternative forms and representations. In Rambert and de Valois’ case there was no prestigious tradition of ballet dancing in Britain (though there was ballet in music halls), and they were, thus, not competing with men in starting their schools and companies. There were some male choreographers active in American modern dance but their situation was the mirror image of that which had faced earlier women painters. Ted Shawn would surely never have got where he did as a dancer and choreographer without the help of Ruth St Denis. José 3
INTRODUCTION
Limón (1908–72) and Charles Weidman (1901–75), as Marcia Siegel suggests, were both dependent on Doris Humphrey for much longer than they needed to be (Siegel 1987). In Britain, Marie Rambert ‘discovered’ and nurtured the fledgling talents of several male choreographers (and, unlike de Valois, one or two women choreographers) of whom the most celebrated were Frederick Ashton (1904–88) and Antony Tudor (1908–87). According to her autobiography (1972), Rambert was not particularly keen to choreograph work herself and gave up doing so in the early days of her ballet company. De Valois, however, choreographed several substantial ballets, some of which were much admired at the time. She, however, believed that men rather than women should choreograph work, and the principal choreographers and artistic directors of the Royal Ballet which she founded have all been male (see Adair 1992: 111–12). The subsequent history of modern dance in the US has also been one of increasing male influence and subsequent dominance. The leading modern dance artists in the 1930s are generally considered to be Martha Graham, Doris Humphrey, Helen Tamiris, Hanya Holm, and Pauline Koner. By 1960 the leading modern choreographer was unquestionably Martha Graham, but, after her, most of the other important choreographers were men. In the 1970s and 1980s male ballet dancers even eclipsed ballerinas in terms of salary, media attention, and drawing power at the box office. Some illustrated books on the male dancer have celebrated what Judith Lynne Hanna has called the big bucks of modern ballet. Some female dance writers have even expressed dismay at this male resurgence, implying that these men have unfairly taken over ‘areas once securely reserved for women’ (Hanna 1988: 144). Dance is not an exclusively or innately feminine activity, and most people would surely accept that the history of twentieth-century dance would have been poorer without the contribution of male dancers and choreographers. It is surely a mistake to view the resurgence of the male ballet dancer and the entry of male choreographers into the previously feminine realm of modern dance as instances of men waiting until women have put in all the hard work and then taking over. Often what leads a man to start dance training is the discovery of their own unrealised potential; this is frequently brought about by seeing an inspirational performance by another male dancer. Shawn may well have been inspired by seeing the Russian ballet dancer Mikhail Mordkin (who toured the US with Pavlova in 1909 and with his own company in 1911–12 while Shawn took up dancing in 1911). José Limón and Erick Hawkins (1909–94) were both inspired to take up dancing after seeing a performance in New York by the German dancer Harald Kreutzberg (1902–68) in 1929. Furthermore, if one accepts that star male dancers generally attract large audiences, this must be largely because women enjoy watching male dancers. Statistics show that women generally outnumber men in audiences for dance and ballet performances. 4
INT RODUCT ION
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
This book does not present a survey of male dance in the twentieth century, nor does it set out to define or celebrate the achievements of men as professional dancers. Instead it examines a selection of significant developments in the representation of masculinity in Western theatre dance during the twentieth century. A critical reading of these is proposed which grounds them in the social and political contexts within which they were created. A major assumption that underlies this selection is that it is only within work that is progressive, experimental, or avant-garde that staid, old-fashioned images and ideas about gender can be challenged and alternatives imagined. I have never seen a ballet performance that has not disappointed me. Perhaps I have been unlucky in what I have chosen or been able to see, but consequently this is not the book of a ballet lover.1 I have sought instead to characterise the conventions and criteria of mainstream and more conservative dance and ballet in quite general terms, and then to use this as a basis for evaluating the work of reformers and innovators. The bulk of this book, therefore, investigates: the reintroduction of the male dancer to Western theatres by the Ballets Russes; the virile image of the male dancer that developed in American modern dance during the first half of the century; and the ways in which avant-garde and postmodern choreographers have been able to adapt, react against, or reject the legacy of existing ways in which masculinity is conventionally represented in theatre dance. The theoretical framework for looking at representations of gender in theatre dance that is developed in the first two chapters attempts to take into account the social and historical conditions of production and reception of dance, including issues of class, gender, ‘race’, and sexuality. The rest of the book, however, at the risk of being accused of ethnocentrism, only looks at representations of masculinity in the context of Western theatre dance. It is, therefore, only concerned with black dance artists who have worked within or have extended the tradition of Western modernist dance. Regrettably this excludes work derived from the revival of traditional African and Caribbean dance, and revived Indian classical dance, as well as recent modern dance in South America and the Pacific Asian region. A somewhat overused adage has it that dance is a universal language. If this is so, globalisation notwithstanding, one shouldn’t underestimate the differences between its dialects. Representations of gender in the dance and theatre traditions of different parts of the world are each grounded in different, socially constructed ideas about the body. Chapter 1 of this book relates representations of masculinity in Western theatre dance to the development in Europe during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries of scientific ideas about the modern body. To do this for each of these other traditions in the same depth would be a sizeable undertaking, and one that is beyond the scope of this book. What I have tried to do, where appropriate, is to critically interrogate the whiteness of modern dance, and 5
INTRODUCTION
not accept this as a universally transcendent norm. The other area that unfortunately, but unavoidably, receives no attention in this book is representations of masculinity in early modern dance in Germany. There were a number of men working as dancers and choreographers in modern dance styles in Germany in the period immediately following the First World War. However, there is very little evidence or documentation available in English about the choreography and performances of male dancers in European modern dance and it is for this reason that they are missing from the present study. The subtitle of the book – bodies, spectacle, sexualities – indicates key issues in the representation of masculinity in theatre dance. The body is the primary mode of communication in dance, and it is through our bodies that we are allocated our gender. Issues relating to the social construction of the gendered body are central to the way gender is represented in theatre dance. But theatre dance is also a spectacle. Different performances invite the spectator to look at dance in different ways. For example, performances of a classic nineteenth-century ballet present the audience with a clearly focused spectacle while a Cunningham event is more open, leaving it up to the spectator to choose what to watch and for how long. The way spectators derive pleasure from the spectacle of dance is also determined by their gender, social background, ethnicity, age, sexuality, and other components of identity. The question of sexuality is particularly important. I point out in the first two chapters that the traditions and conventions of mainstream theatre dance are formed by, and reinforce, a normative heterosexual, white, male point of view, marginalising and suppressing alternative sexualities. Future historians may look back on the period from around 1830 until around 1980 as a curiously anomalous one during which the male body became a taboo subject for cultural representation. Until comparatively recently, surviving nineteenth-century gender ideologies have denied the possibility that women might find the male body of any interest – erotic or otherwise – while punishing attempts to create a homoerotic view of the male body. At the same time, during the twentieth and twenty-first centuries, gay men, predominantly in the field of ballet, and heterosexual women, in the field of modern dance, have been largely responsible for developing male dancing. But the conventions through which they have done this have dictated, first, that the audience look from a male point of view and are thus uninterested in the spectacle of the male dancing body, and, second, that masculinity is an unproblematic and unquestioned norm. This has resulted in the range of male dancing being largely limited to the expression of male dominance and control over female bodies, and the consequent development of a tough, hard, dance vocabulary. The American postmodern choreographer Mark Morris gave an interviewer an illustration of how limited he found the male dancer to be in comparison with the 6
INT RODUCT ION
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
female performer. A woman in rehearsal, he says, can be asked to act like a 65-year-old man but ‘straight’ (heterosexual) men are too embarrassed to act like 13-year-old girls (Acocella 1993: 92). Morris (whose work is considered in Chapter 7) is one of a comparatively small number of recent choreographers who have set out to challenge and disrupt the ways in which gender is conventionally represented in theatre dance. Since the late 1970s, writers have been asking questions about how gender and sexuality have been represented in dance. In doing so, they have sometimes come into conflict with dance scholars committed to formalist aesthetics and modernist approaches to dance theory. A prevalent, modernist view proposes that dance is not a representational practice, and that modern choreographers are progressively purifying themselves of outmoded and extraneous representational and expressive practices. Thus questions about how gender is represented in theatre dance are irrelevant to what has generally been thought to be the true nature of dance as art. Such a view is based on misunderstandings both about the nature of modernism and about the way dance functions as a signifying practice. The first two chapters of this book locate masculinity and its representation in theatre dance within recent sociological debates, in the area of gender studies and film and cultural studies. Chapter 1 asks the question why the male dancer over the last 150 years has been a source of unease and suspicion, while Chapter 2 is concerned with conventions that determine the way the male body is looked at in cultural forms, examining, in particular, the idea of the gendered gaze and spectatorship. Together these chapters develop the criteria for the analysis of dance work in the rest of the book. Chapter 3 looks at the legacy of Nijinsky, Chapters 4 and 5 discuss modern dance in the US. The rise of second wave feminism, the Black Arts Movement, and Gay Liberation around 1970 brought about a sea change in ideas about the relation between identity and cultural representations. The last three chapters of the book discuss the work of choreographers in Europe and the US who have responded to these developments. Masculinity as a socially constructed identity is not a stable entity, but one made up of conflictual and contradictory aspects. Representations of masculinity in theatre dance over the last 150 years (more so in some ways than other cultural forms) have threatened to disrupt and destabilise masculine identities. This suggests specific questions and issues which underlie the analysis and interpretation in the last six chapters. What makes extreme, almost stereotypical representations of violent, macho masculinity appear to support dominant, conservative norms of masculinity in one ballet or modern dance piece but criticise and threaten these norms in another? Why is it that some choreographers have been able to reject and subvert the conventions and traditions through which masculinity is represented, while others’ attempts have been recuperated within dominant 7
INTRODUCTION
conservative gender ideologies? How is it that some choreographers have succeeded in making visible aspects of masculine experience that are otherwise denied or rendered invisible within mainstream work? Finally, this book is concerned with identifying key issues and strategies that offer the radical dance artist potential sites at which to trouble and subvert the conflictual and contradictory aspects of dominant notions of masculine identity in order to create possibilities for representing new, alternative, non-discriminatory perceptions of the differences between men and women in theatre dance.
8
1
1 THE TROUBLE WITH THE MALE DANCER . . .
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
‘The unpleasant thing about a danseuse is that she sometimes brings along a male dancer.’1 This is the title of one of the satirical lithographs which Charles Edouard de Beaumont (1812–88) published in 1860 of scenes at the Paris Opéra (Figure 1.1). It shows a male figure dancing, while behind him slightly to one side is a ballerina with little sylph wings who turns her head deferentially towards him. He wears tights and has an ugly face, solid thighs, and big hands. The artist, however, has not made him look grotesque, just less attractive than the ballerina. The implication is that the viewer would rather look at her, but the male dancer wants you to look at him, and anyway he is in the way. The joke is that the normal roles in the supported adagio are reversed so that he is on pointe while she is supporting him. But not only is he not in need of any support but the energy of the turn he is preparing to take and the amount of space it needs will cause a collision. The title appeals to a shared prejudice about these ‘unpleasant things’. At the start of the twenty-first century, it is tempting to read into the scene more recent prejudices against the male dancer. Nevertheless, the print captures a particular historical moment with its associated attitudes towards class, gender, and aesthetics, all of which have had a strong influence on the development of later attitudes. Up until the nineteenth century in Europe, prejudices against the male dancer did not exist. By the start of the twenty-first century these have developed and changed in response to a variety of social and historical factors. The print takes for granted that everyone knows what is wrong with the male dancer, but more or less leaves it unstated. That which is unstated, and by implication should not be stated in polite company, can be a powerful incitement to prejudice. So what then is the trouble with the male dancer? Today one might answer this question in a number of ways, depending upon point of view and the sort of dance with which one is familiar. One might feel distaste at macho displays of male energy on the dance stage – what are they trying to prove? and so on. Or one might feel that male dancers are generally a disappointment – they just don’t look very masculine. Or, again, one might feel that the ways in which one has seen 9
THE MAL E DANCER
Figure 1.1 ’The unpleasant thing about a danseuse is that she sometimes brings along a male dancer’. Plate from Charles Edouard de Beaumont’s 1860 Album Comique, L’Opéra du XIXeme siecle. Courtesy of Jerome Robbins Dance Division, The New York Public Library for the Performing Arts, Astor, Lenox, and Tilden Foundations.
10
THE TROUBLE WITH THE MALE DANCER . . .
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
masculinity represented in dance do not seem very relevant to one’s own experience of class, ethnicity, gender, sexuality, and so on. Then there are those who do enjoy watching male dance, and wish there were more male dancers around to watch. In the area of modern and experimental dance during the twentieth century, a large number of male dancers did not actually discover dancing until their late teens or early twenties. This is undoubtedly largely the result of prejudices against the male dancer. For much of the twentieth century, the dance world tended to appear to be predominantly a feminine realm in terms of audiences, dancers, and teachers. The fact that, for example, in Britain and the US ballet and modern dance teachers have been predominantly women has been cited as one reason for male dancer’s ‘effeminacy’ (e.g. Manchester 1950). But for many people, a key source of contemporary prejudice is the association between male dancers and homosexuality. It is certainly true that there are a lot of gay men involved in the dance world. Although by no means all male dancers are gay, this is what prejudice suggests. One consequence of this, I suggest, is a particular form of hyper-masculine display which sometimes naturalises aggression and violence as dancers try to show that they are not effeminate, where ‘effeminate’ is a code word for homosexual. Until comparatively recently there has been a profound silence in the dance world on the subject of male dance and homosexuality. Commenting on the fact that the early American modern dancer Ted Shawn was gay, Judith Lynn Hanna in her book Dance, Sex and Gender points to the irony in the time and effort he and his company of male dancers ‘spent trying to prove that they were not what Shawn and many of the company were’ (1988: 141). What she fails to recognise is that for gay men in the US at that time, ‘coming out’ was not an option. With the trial of Oscar Wilde as a terrible example, and with fear of blackmail, it is not surprising that so many in the dance world have, in order to protect individuals, taken the line of denying any knowledge of homosexuality among dancers. By no means all male dancers are gay, and the belief that they are is not in itself an entirely satisfactory explanation of the prejudice. If one takes a historical perspective, I have not seen any firm evidence that the general public were aware of and concerned about gay involvement in ballet before the time of Diaghilev and Nijinsky at the beginning of the twentieth century. The prejudice against the male dancer, however, developed during the flowering of the Romantic ballet, in the middle of the nineteenth century, when de Beaumont drew this lithograph. Examination of attitudes towards the male dancer during this earlier period (considered below) suggests that what is at stake is the development of modern, middle class attitudes towards the male body and expressive aspects of male social behaviour. I am not arguing that, prior to Nijinsky, all male dancers were heterosexual, merely that their sexuality was not an explicit issue. Gender representations in cultural forms, including theatre 11
THE MAL E DANCER
dance, do not merely reflect changing social definitions of femininity and masculinity, but are actively involved in the processes through which gender is constructed and norms reinforced. What concerns us here is the way that the socially produced parameters of, and limits on, male behaviour are expressed in representations of masculinity in theatre dance. At stake is the appearance of the dancing male body as spectacle. What Rosalind Coward has commented on, in relation to contemporary film, in many ways sums up a modern attitude to the gendered body: Under the sheer weight of attention to women’s bodies we seem to have become blind to something. Nobody seems to have noticed that men’s bodies have quietly absented themselves. Somewhere along the line, men have managed to keep out of the glare, escaping from the relentless activity of sexual definitions. (Coward 1984: 227) Over the last two centuries, however, it is not that male dancers have quietly absented themselves, but that, in many instances, they have been nervously dismissed. When the male dancer gradually disappeared from the stages of western European theatres during the period of the Romantic ballet, his place, in some cases, was taken by the female dancer dressed ‘en travestie’ (Garafola 1985). There is a similar disappearance of the male nude as a subject for painting and sculpture (Walters 1979), and male forms of dress underwent what J.C. Flugel (1930) has brilliantly characterised as ‘the great male renunciation’ – the abandonment of the more flamboyant styles that the aristocracy had popularised in favour of the plain, black, bourgeois suit. What became conflictual and, consequently, repressed was anything that might draw attention to the spectacle of the male body. What one should, therefore, be looking for to explain the mid-nineteenthcentury prejudice against the male dancer, is the development, during this period, of modern attitudes to the body and gender, at a time when bodies in general were a source of anxiety. It is these attitudes that brought about a situation in which it seemed ‘natural’ not to look at the male body, and, therefore, problematic and conflictual for men to enjoy looking at men dancing. Masculinity, as a socially constructed identity, was rarely stable. Rather than enjoying a secure autonomy, men have continually needed to adjust and redefine the meanings attributed to sexual difference in order to maintain dominance in the face of changing social circumstances. Because the body is the primary means of expression in dance, and because gender is an attribute of the body, dance is a key area through which gendered identities are revealed. The kinds of gender representation that choreographers and dancers create and perform are partly determined by their individual histories and experiences. History and experience also effect the kinds of interpretation that audience members make of the dance work 12
THE TROUBLE WITH THE MALE DANCER . . .
1
1
11
11
1
11
they see performed. How they see it is also, however, conditioned by the way in which the work is framed and presented to them – the way the work negotiates the traditions and conventions of theatre dance. Dominant gender ideologies are not, therefore, imposed without resistance through dance. The moment of live performance is a privileged one in which these ideologies are represented and contested. Indeed dancing bodies can become sites of resistance against them. The spectacle of men dancing on stage can, therefore, sometimes expose some of the tensions and contradictions within masculine subjectivities. The unease that sometimes accompanies the idea of the male dancer is, I suggest, produced by structures which defend and police dominant male norms. This chapter therefore aims to reveal some of the conflictual and contradictory aspects of the construction of modern masculine identities, while Chapter 2 discusses how these determine and are determined by the way masculinity is represented in theatre dance. The fact of the male dancer’s decline in the nineteenth century is the context for his subsequent revival. It was the prudishness of Victorian gender ideologies that initially condemned male dancers to the problematic status they have spent much of the last 100 years trying to overcome. ‘Modern’ ideas about masculine social behaviour and the male body, which developed during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, have exerted a residual influence on more recent social attitudes towards the creativity and expressiveness of male artists as a whole up to the present. This chapter, therefore, looks first at the ways in which the development of ideas about the modern male body have influenced attitudes towards male behaviour that themselves can account for prejudices against men dancing on stage. It then looks at some of the earliest manifestations of these prejudices in the writings of ballet critics in the nineteenth century. What emerges from the latter is that these writers did not criticise, or were not primarily worried by, any signs of effeminacy in the male dancer; what concerned them chiefly were questions of male bourgeois identity. It was not until the early years of the twentieth century that a connection was made between male dance and homosexuality, and the chapter concludes with a discussion of this. GENDER NORMS AND BINARY WAYS OF THINKING
11
11
I have suggested that the joke behind de Beaumont’s lithograph is the incongruousness of male and female dancers exchanging roles in a supported adagio. The lithograph exemplifies a binary way of thinking in which positive masculine characteristics and attributes are valued to the detriment of feminine ones. As feminists have pointed out, this way of thinking has reduced richly diversified qualities into narrowly defined 13
THE MAL E DANCER
polar opposites such as culture and nature, mind and body, intellect and feeling. In this lithograph, the male dancer’s ugliness contrasts with his partner’s beauty, his vigour and need for space with her intimacy and delicacy. Comparing their legs reveals a more complex polarity. Whereas his head and hands are slightly out of proportion with his body, his legs are not, and their silhouette is somewhat similar to hers. The difference is that de Beaumont has used shading to indicate the muscles in his legs while leaving hers flat and insubstantial. There is an undeniably realistic materiality to his body while hers is drawn in a way which suggests that her beauty offers her the magical possibility of transcending the body and thus evoking a Romantic ideal. Watching her permits an escape from an ugly reality into beauty and romance, but his energy and material presence pull the spectator back to the here and now. The lithograph, therefore, reinforces a binary where male dancing bodies promise action while female dancing bodies invite contemplation and fascination. Writing about visual art, John Berger observed that: ‘Men act and women appear. Men look at women. Women watch themselves being looked at’ (1972: 47). Berger, thus, argued that the gendered look informs the criteria and conventions which govern the way women and men are depicted in the tradition of European visual art within which de Beaumont worked. Lorraine Gamman and Margaret Marshment began their book on the female gaze by revising Berger’s observation: ‘Men act, women appear. That’s patriarchy’ (1988: 1). I take this to mean that male dominance over women remains a constant, although the particular social groups exercising that dominance change over time. While binary modes of thinking assure that masculinity seems to be universal, there is, of course, a history of changing masculinities. In this example, the male dancer disappeared from western European theatres around the time that the nobility, with its landed estates, were handing on political power and patronage of the arts to the bourgeoisie with its capital investments. At a time of historical change, the visibility of the male dancing body became problematic. If nineteenth-century bourgeois men feared visible, male bodies, this is because, as Peggy Phelan has observed, visibility is a trap which ‘summons surveillance and the law; it provokes voyeurism, fetishism, the colonial/ imperial appetite for possession’ (1993: 6). Victorian men, therefore, wished to be spectators who were not, themselves, objects of investigation for another’s gaze. Film theorist Steve Neale proposes that mainstream narrative cinema assumes the spectator’s look is an investigative one. Whereas women are constantly under investigation, men, he suggests, rarely are: ‘Women are a problem, a source of anxiety, of obsessive enquiry; men are not. Whereas women are investigated, men are tested. Masculinity, as an ideal, at least, is implicitly known. Femininity is, by contrast, a mystery’ (1983: 15–16). What Neale neatly sums up here has been the norm for gender representations in Western cultural forms. But what if one could dismantle 14
THE TROUBLE WITH THE MALE DANCER . . .
1
1
11
11
1
the binary system on which this depends? What if the spectator were not white, male, heterosexual, and middle class? Neale evokes one of Freud’s most quoted remarks: what do women want? But there may be women who find men a mystery and puzzle over what they want; and it is not impossible that white men may be a source of fear and fascination for some African and Asian men. Rather than assuming ‘man’ is the universal norm against which all others are measured, this is to pose the question how white, middle class, heterosexual men might appear as one part of a range of different identities that are marked in terms of ethnicity, race, class, sexuality, age, and other social categories. Indeed we should not assume to know what this range may, in the future, include. To dance on stage for an audience is to make oneself visible in what may, sometimes, seem a naked exposure. It is, thus, to have to take into consideration how one might appear from points of view other than one’s own and thus to experience one’s being through others. Cultural anxiety about men dancing on stage, therefore, helps protect those men who don’t want to consider the effects that male dominance have on others. The idea that masculinity, as Neale puts it, is an ideal that is implicitly known, stops people realising that there is an open-ended range of evolving identities. Many of the dance pieces that I discuss later in this book have not only troubled normative definitions of masculinity, but, in doing so, have made space for imagining ways of embodying other possibilities. In order to appreciate the value of such alternative ways of performing masculinities, it is necessary to investigate the development of modern ideas about embodied subjectivity. THE SUBJECT AND MODERN BODY
11
11
11
The relation between subjectivity and embodiment is central both to a sense of gendered identity and to the way dance functions as a signifying practice. To be a subject is to have a conception of oneself as an independent and responsible member of society. The body, as anthropologist Mary Douglas has argued, is a symbol of society. The idea of society, she wrote, is a powerful image. ‘It has form; it has external boundaries, margins, internal structure’ (1966: 114). Gender and sexuality are key elements within the internal structure while sexual dissidents and the otherwise gendered are either marginal or a threat to boundaries. These boundaries, Douglas has argued, can represent any boundaries that are threatened or precarious. If they, therefore, ‘contain power to reward conformity and repulse attack’ (ibid.), it is this which is at work producing anxieties about the male dancer. Modern ideas about the body, and about the biology of gender difference, developed as a result of the breakdown of older notions of the body in Greek thought and their assimilation within medieval and renaissance Christian thought. As the authority of the Church declined, the older 15
THE MAL E DANCER
Christian model of the sinful flesh became recast with new, scientific features by both the enlightened, rational bourgeoisie and their evangelical protestant counterparts. By the nineteenth century, the idea that the body, as an entity, is execrable not only persisted but became increasingly important in new and more anxious forms. The body itself was no longer admired, but became, as Michel Foucault has shown in his books on the asylum, the clinic, prisons, and sexuality, the object of classification and regulation through scientific, medical, and juridical processes (Foucault 1971, 1973, 1977, 1979). As Leo Bersani has pointed out, ‘Foucault wrote so brilliantly of the body as an object of the exercise of power, that we may fail to note how little he spoke of the body as an agent of power’ (1995: 102). Judith Butler has criticised Foucault for only recognising the way power inscribes the body. The problem with this, she points out, is that on a theoretical level it presupposes a pure, unmarked body prior to the moment of inscription (1990a: 130). What is needed, she argues, is to recognise that gender and sexuality are attributes of one’s body which seem to be fundamental to one’s sense of self but whose meanings are determined by norms that come from outside oneself. Dance is an area where, as embodied beings, we negotiate the social and cultural discourses through which gender and sexuality are maintained. She points out: the body has its invariably public dimension: constituted as a social phenomenon in the public sphere, my body is and is not mine. Given over from the start to the world of others, bearing their imprint, formed within the crucible of social life, the body is only later, and with some uncertainty, that to which I lay claim as my own. (2004: 21) There are a number of different practices through which one can lay claim to one’s body, but, because dance is a performing art, it is a particularly useful area in which to consider the ways in which gender is performed. Performing one’s gender, Butler argues, is like performing a play: ‘gender is an act which has been rehearsed, much as a script survives the particular actors who make use of it, but which requires individual actors in order to be actualised and reproduced as reality once again’ (1990b: 277). One cannot refuse to perform the gender that is ascribed to one, but as one lays claim to one’s body, one lays claim to the means through which one responds to and interprets this demand. The possibilities for interpretation are nevertheless circumscribed: Just as a script may be enacted in various ways, and just as the play requires both text and interpretation, so the gendered body acts its part in a culturally constricted corporeal space and enacts interpretations within the confines of already existing directives. (Ibid.) 16
THE TROUBLE WITH THE MALE DANCER . . .
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
Ideas about the nature of gendered bodies are one area in which the kinds of interpretation that Butler identifies have taken place. Although these ideas claim to be universal, they nevertheless change and develop. Butler has put this in a way that seems particularly apt for the way masculinity is performed in dance. These ideas, she argues, are: ‘a sedimentation that over time has produced a set of corporeal styles which, in reified form, appear as the natural configuration of bodies into sexes which exist in a binary relation to one another’ (ibid.: 275). If the traditions and conventions, through which gender is represented in dance, are a set of corporeal styles that have sedimented over time, it is possible to correlate changing ideas about the nature of gendered bodies with ideas about theatre dance. With the increasing acceptance of a rational and scientific approach to the body, Aristotelian ideas about the metaphysical inferiority of women gradually became untenable. The eighteenth-century idea that men and women have the same potential to be free, reasoning subjects implicitly threatened male power. Christine Battersby (1989) has shown the conflicting nature of the arguments which were put forward, by philosophers in the nineteenth century, to maintain male dominance. Scientists and commentators sought to prove that women were physically and temperamentally unsuited to serious thinking (Jacobus et al. 1990). If the male body was the norm, against which female anatomical and temperamental traits were judged, men, by default and by implication, were considered to be less capable of transcending their natural lusts and desires, and thus morally inferior. If women had some grounds for claiming to be purer and more disembodied than men, it became more appropriate, therefore, for female dancers to evoke the ballet ideal than for male dancers. This definition of gendered difference is part of the larger separation of the middle class (male) public world of work and politics from the (female) private world of the home and family, which has been called the culture of separate spheres (Davidoff and Hall 1987; Wolff and Seed 1987). Artistic expression, itself, became gendered so that, as Paul Hoch has suggested: ‘Art, as an emotional (and therefore feminine) representation of the inner life became even further estranged from science, the representative mode of thought in the cruel, emotionless masculine world “outside” ’ (1979: 140). Much of the literature about gender ideologies in the nineteenth century contrasts stoic, taciturn masculinity with feminine sensitivity and emotionality. In Greek antiquity, stoic philosophy encouraged men to use reason to achieve moderation and avoid being carried away by their passions. Feelings are experienced through one’s body. Richard Rorty (1980) has shown that, whereas reason for Greek philosophers was located neither ‘inside’ nor ‘outside’ the human being, seventeenth-century scepticism located a newly discovered consciousness as an interiority. For Descartes, all bodily perceptions were fallible so that consciousness became dis17
THE MAL E DANCER
embodied. Whereas Greek philosophers, therefore, advocated an embodied moderation, Descartes proposed a rational ideal that could only be achieved through transcending the body. For nineteenth-century bourgeois men within the culture of separate spheres, what was important was not the achievement of moderation but the performance of masculinity in as unemotional a manner as possible. This particular mode of performance has persisted into recent times. Steve Neale has identified male heroes in Hollywood films whose behaviour is ‘marked not only be emotional reticence but also by silence, a reticence in language’ (1983: 12). In dance terms, this translates into a reticence with gesture and bodily expression, and I shall identify in later chapters similar masculine traits in some theatre dance work. This is a reactive mode of male performance. It is not one that actively represents positive aspects of experience but one which passively avoids association with femininity or effeminacy. This reactive masculinity is one which suggests anxiety about the limits and boundaries of masculine identities. The Romantic notion of the artist as inspired genius is the obvious exception to the rule that men should appear unemotional and inexpressive. Christine Battersby points out that the (male) Romantic artist was excepted from gendered divisions of social behaviour through being allowed to have ‘feminine’ qualities such as sensitivity, passivity, emotionality, and introspective self-consciousness. Battersby argues that artists could appropriate these ‘feminine’ characteristics by evoking the notion of genius, and thus without suffering the lower social status of being female. When the Romantic artist expresses the underlying forces of sublime nature, this is a male creative energy responding to the male energy of nature: according to Edmund Burke (1729–97), the grandeur of an avalanche in the Alps is sublime, as are also ‘kings and commanders discharging their terrible strength and destroying all obstacles in their path’ (Battersby 1989: 74). The new notion of male artistic self-expression was linked to the body and physicality. A sublime, muscular dynamism was identified in Michaelangelo’s art. On another level, creativity was linked to virility and male sexuality. Battersby calls this the ‘virility school of creativity’. The Romantic idea of male artistic self-expression clearly underlies much of the hype that has surrounded the recent popularity of the male dancer. It is paradoxical, however, that these notions should initially have been developed at the time when the male dancer was disappearing in western Europe as a result of strong social disapproval. The Romantic genius was allowed a wide range of self-expression that would have been considered unacceptable in men not considered to be gifted. The way in which the Romantic composer might pound his piano while performing his own work, or the emotionalism of the Romantic poet, or the way the brush strokes betray the painter’s emotions: the implicit or explicit physicality of all these seems to have been acceptable for male artists in the nineteenth 18
THE TROUBLE WITH THE MALE DANCER . . .
1
century. As far as theatre dance is concerned, during the nineteenth century the dancing of ballet movements was not recognised as a reputable means of artistic self-expression, let alone a means through which male genius manifests itself. There were significant differences between the performance of the male dancer and forms of self-expression in music, literature, and the visual arts. The general low status of the performing arts, and of dance as a non-verbal form within them, contributed to the exclusion of the male dancer from the realm of genius.
1
DEGENERACY AND MASCULINITY A variety of anxieties about the weakness and insecurity of the boundaries defining masculinity clustered around the nineteenth-century idea of degeneracy. In the 1870s the Italian criminologist Cesare Lombroso (1835–1909) believed he had proved that criminals and prostitutes were throwbacks to humanity’s savage past. (He also proposed that genius was a productive form of degeneracy.) Fear of genetic regression was also anxiously identified in other areas. In Europe’s colonies, African ‘savages’ seemed in danger of regressing to brute animality while contemporary Asians were believed to be degenerate descendants of once great civilisations. If the health and vitality of Western culture supposedly justified colonial rule, Europeans needed to guard against becoming degenerate themselves. For the middle classes, the surviving aristocracy exhibited worrying signs of degeneracy through its moral decadence, while the urban poor were in danger, through ill health and vulnerability, to epidemics. The migration from the country to the city to form the new proletariat, necessary for large scale industrial expansion, produced an urban population in danger of losing its health and becoming soft within the unhygienic and immoral environment of the city. Catherine Gallagher has suggested that for the Victorian middle classes, the social body, far from representing a perfectible ideal, was imagined to be ‘a chronically and incurably ill organism that could only be kept alive by constant flushing, draining, and excising of various deleterious elements. These dangerous elements, moreover, were often not themselves unhealthy but rather were overly vigorous and fecund individuals’ (1987: 90). These overly vigorous and fecund individuals were, of course, members of the working classes. For the bourgeoisie, the body, with everything it implied, became a problem and a threat. J.S. Bratton, discussing the hornpipe within the context of nineteenth-century British working class entertainment, suggests that it was the sort of act through which a performer could exhibit admired qualities of dexterity, physical prowess, inventiveness, and pluck, within a dance which would be familiar as ‘working or holiday accomplishments of the audience, carried to a pitch they had not the leisure to attain’ (1990: 68). Bratton suggests that, underlying middle-class distaste for this sort of performance, was a real or imagined
11
11
1
11
11
11
19
THE MAL E DANCER
fear of the mass of working-class people going out in the street, getting together, and being induced to drunken disorder by the physical excitement of singing and dancing, and, ultimately, incited to riot by shows and plays which might have radical tendencies. (Ibid.: 74) Towards the end of the nineteenth century, the existence of a newly defined category, homosexuality, became a source of anxiety, particularly through its association with fin-de-siècle decadent art. And if all this wasn’t bad enough, middle class male prerogatives were also being increasingly challenged by women’s education, their developing economic role as consumers, and by calls for women’s suffrage. One response to anxiety about the limits and boundaries of masculine identities was to identify an external cause for this contemporary crisis rather than acknowledging any internal contradictions from which it might derive. As Michael S. Kimmel has shown, the late nineteenth and early twentieth century was a time of widespread debate about fears that this ‘super-civilisation’ was causing modern European men to lose touch with their ‘essential’, ‘natural’ masculinity (1987). One participant in this debate was Lord Baden-Powell. In his book Rovering To Success: A Guide For Young Manhood, he states: God made men to be men. On the other hand civilisation, with its town life, buses, hot-and-cold water laid on, everything done for you, tends to make men soft and feckless beings. That is what we want to get out of. (1930: 24) He goes on to praise English public schools for forming character and ‘licking’ upper and upper-middle class boys into shape, and compares this with the manhood initiation rites of Zulus, Swazis, and Matabeles: Unfortunately, for the ordinary boy in civilised countries there is nothing of this kind. We badly need some such training for our lads if we are to keep up manliness in our race, instead of lapsing into a nation of soft, sloppy, cigarette suckers. (Ibid.: 25) It was these ‘ordinary’ boys lower down the social scale who were attracted to the boy scout movement. Baden-Powell connected traditional male values with notions of nation and race, proposing that, by preparing for success ‘“you’ll be a MAN, my son” and you will thus be making one more man for the nation’ (ibid., his emphasis, and the reference is to Kipling’s poem If ). Lord Baden-Powell’s ideas about the need to stay in touch with ‘essential’ masculinity begs comparison with that of Theodore Roosevelt (1858–1919), US President (1901–09). Both shared what might be called a pro-male attitude towards masculinity, as did the writer Edgar Rice Burroughs 20
THE TROUBLE WITH THE MALE DANCER . . .
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
(1875–1950) whose great fictional character Tarzan presents an exemplary image of masculinity conceived of as ‘natural’ and innate. Tarzan’s civilised behaviour is a thin veneer which is learned because of women. This is in line with the pro-male, misogynistic view that, while it is women’s function to uphold and maintain the values of civilisation, the consequent feminisation of culture leads to the weakening of manhood. Tarzan, thus, recuperated for men the feminine qualities of being closer to nature and the emotions without becoming feminine. In his first Tarzan novel Tarzan and the Apes (1912), it is only through contact with Jane Porter that the eponymous ape man decides to enter into civilised society. As Joseph Bristow points out: Tarzan obviously bears the traces of earlier varieties of man – the gentleman of Victorian fiction; the imperial soldier on the battle-front; the Scout making himself at home out of doors – but he is, for all to see [when he first kisses Jane], a belatedly Darwinian being whose sexual passion knows no reason. The political imperative to survive has here been transformed into a sexual imperative to be a man. (1991: 217) This political and sexual imperative is a homophobic one. The idea of a ‘natural’ and instinctive masculinity evoked by Tarzan, and asserted by figures such as Roosevelt and Baden-Powell, was a reassuring myth to hold onto during a period in which traditional gender norms were perceived to be under threat. This myth is, of course, largely a product of white, Anglo-Saxon social forces, but one which draws on an ideologically distorted view of non-Western masculinity. Tarzan can be seen as a hero who directs his violence against an externalisation of a contemporary crisis rather than facing up to the possibility that it may have internal causes. Tarzan is a useful reference point for Ted Shawn’s early male solos, since his first performance as a dancer was the year before the publication of the first Tarzan novel. I discuss Shawn’s choreography in Chapter 4, but it is useful here to note how Shawn, who initially trained to become a Methodist minister just before the First World War, developed ideas about dance and masculinity that were formed by Victorian gender ideologies. Writing in 1946 when he had retired from an active career as dancer and choreographer, he defined essential, binary differences between male and female ways of moving that are clearly informed by heterosexual, Christian, family values. He wrote: In watching movements of men in manual labour all over the world, continuously and carefully, I have come to the conclusion that most of them are big movements of the whole body and the arm movement is a continuation of the body movement, as for example the movement of a man using a scythe. (1946: 104) 21
THE MAL E DANCER
By contrast, women’s movements, according to Shawn, are small, delicate, and confined. He was, thus, arguing that men’s work is totally different from women’s work, and that it is neither right nor natural for women to do male work. ‘We felt that it was best when woman was working in the home, taking care of the needs of her husband and children, and so most religious and moral education has come from mother to children’ (ibid.: 105). This provided Shawn with a seemingly ‘natural’ basis for making prescriptions about male and female movements in dance and a retrospective justification for the kinds of male dances he had choreographed in the 1920s and 1930s. He thus used positive examples of men from ‘all over the world’ to confirm what ‘we’ already know about white masculinity. By polarising differences between men and women, Shawn blurred and erased other kinds of difference, particularly in relation to ‘race’ and ethnicity. His account of manual labour is one in which he presumptuously located himself in a field of others in which he was the supposed centre. The violence of this presumption is that those men whose work effort did not fit in with Shawn’s particular need are in danger of not being considered men, or perhaps even human, at all. Shawn, in many ways, set an unfortunate precedent for men entering what had, by the twentieth century, become, in effect, the feminised field of theatre dance. As I shall show in Chapter 4, Shawn created a hard, muscular, male dancing body, through his attempts to distance male dancing from the fearful spectacle of effeminacy and homosexuality. The point I am making here, however, is that this way of performing masculinity through dance also ran the danger of naturalising whiteness and male violence. HOMOPHOBIA AND THE MALE DANCER What I have proposed, so far, is that, increasingly since the nineteenth century, it has been considered appropriate for men not to appear soft and not to appear emotionally expressive. An individual who does not conform to these behavioural norms, and cannot claim to be a genius, has been in danger of being considered ‘not to be a proper man’, a euphemistic phrase that generally means homosexual. The cluster of fears associated with homosexuality is sometimes called homophobia. Homophobia is the social mechanism which prohibits, or makes fearful, the idea of intimate contact or communication with members of the same sex. It is generally argued that homophobia is a mechanism for regulating the behaviour of all men rather than just self-identified homosexuals. Much queer theory assumes that homophobia is an essential characteristic of patriarchal society. Joseph Bristow puts it thus: ‘homophobia comes into operation so that men can be as close as possible – to work powerfully together in the interests of men – without ever being too (sexually) close to one another. . . . homophobia actually brings men into a close homosocial 22
THE TROUBLE WITH THE MALE DANCER . . .
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
relation’ (1988: 128). The mechanisms (including disapproval of male dance) which limit the subversive potential of some representations of masculinity can be seen to serve the purpose of keeping out of sight anything which might disrupt the relations within which men work powerfully together in the interests of men. Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick argues that, in men’s relationships with other men in contemporary Western society, emotional and sexual expression is necessarily suppressed in the interests of maintaining male power. In a broader historical and anthropological perspective, she argues, this sort of male bonding is atypical: a similar suppression does not occur in female bonding in modern Western society, nor did it exist, for example, for Greek men at the time of Socrates. In the latter examples, there is a continuum between social, political, and sexual expression. Sedgwick argues that male, homosocial relationships in our society are characterised by intense homophobia, fear, and hatred of homosexuality. This repressed homosexual component of male sexuality accounts for ‘correspondences and similarities between the most sanctioned forms of male homosocial bonding and the most reprobate expressions of male homosexuality’ (Sedgwick 1985: 89). Men are in a double bind in that they are drawn to other men, but this acceptable attraction is not clearly distinguishable from forbidden homosexual interest: ‘For a man to be a man’s man is separated only by an invisible, carefully blurred, always-already crossed line from being “interested in men”’ (ibid.: 89). What was at stake in Sedgwick’s account is the limit of normative heterosexual masculine identity. Heterosexuality depends on homosexuality in order to define its own limits. There would be nothing straight about heterosexual men if there weren’t homosexual men to define the limit beyond which heterosexuals cannot go. Homosexuals are, thus, essential to the continuation of heterosexuality; as Leo Bersani has put it, homosexuals are ‘the internally excluded difference that cements heterosexual identity’ (1995: 36). Homophobia doesn’t actually offer an explanation of why modern Western society is prejudiced and discriminates against homosexuals. Homosexual men were subject to sometimes violent discrimination prior to the nineteenth century, at times when performances by leading male ballet dancers were greeted with considerable approval. There is no simple linkage between homosexuality, homophobia, and uneasiness at professional male dancers. The usefulness of the concept of homophobia is, perhaps, strategic. By giving a name to the way social restrictions function that maintain certain norms of masculine behaviour, it is possible to make visible aspects of male experience that are otherwise hidden. It, then, also becomes possible to discuss the way male–male social relations have been represented in theatre dance in terms of homophobia. My argument is that it is these social restrictions that, since the mid-nineteenth century, have caused the display of male dancing to become a source of anxiety. 23
THE MAL E DANCER
Male appearance signifies power and success: as John Berger has put it, a man’s appearance tells you what he can do to you or for you. If, however, his appearance is also desirable, he is, from the point of view of a male spectator, drawing attention to the always-already crossed line between homosocial bonding and homosexual sexuality. His appearance, therefore, carries with it, for the male spectator, the threat of revealing the suppressed homosexual component within the links he has with other men and through which he maintains his power and status in patriarchal society. It is the inability of the male ballet dancer to represent the power and status of men in bourgeois society which was proposed by one nineteenth-century writer as being the trouble with the male dancer. THE MALE BALLET DANCER DURING THE NINETEENTH CENTURY: GREEN BOX TREES In London, Paris, and most other European cities during the first half of the nineteenth century, as ballet came to be defined as an idealised feminine world, there was, on a material level, a decline in demand for male dancers. The fashion for the all-white, female corps de ballet must have contributed to the disappearance of men from the corps de ballet in most of Europe. There were still male dancers around who were valued for their technical ability as dancers. Peter Brinson has suggested: The more the employment, and so the technical standards of male dancers as regular members of ballet companies declined throughout the second half of the nineteenth century, the more the practice grew of employing for particular occasions the few who could display any sort of technical brilliance. These men moved from company to company like a circus act. (1966: 72) One example of professional male dancers in Italy were the Fighting Dancers or Tramagnini who performed speciality danced combats as part of theatrical spectacles in Florence during the second half of the nineteenth century (Poesio 1990). This, however, seems to have been an isolated phenomenon. Elsewhere, after the 1850s, male dancers increasingly performed roles that demanded acting skills and mime, such as Dr Coppelius in Coppélia (Saint-Léon 1870) or Drosselmeyer in The Nutcracker (Petipa/ Ivanov 1892), parts that could be performed by dancers past their prime. It was, therefore, in countries such as Britain and France where the ballet was under bourgeois rather than royal and aristocratic patronage that the career structure for male dancers collapsed, while it was at the courts in Copenhagen, Stockholm, and St Petersburg that the career structure of male ballet dancing survived. 24
THE TROUBLE WITH THE MALE DANCER . . .
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
While the ballet La Sylphide (1832) is hailed as the first Romantic ballet with its star role for Marie Taglioni and its all-white corps de ballet, the neo-classical ballet d’action with its (male) danseur noble, that it superseded, did not disappear overnight. Instead, there was a transitional period in which older and newer style ballets appeared in the same season, together with older style ballet interludes in operas. There were also, as John Chapman points out, ballet critics such as Hipployte Prévost who went on writing appreciatively about neo-classical ballets into the 1850s. But, for Romantic critics such as Jules Janin (1807–74), performances by danseurs noble were an excuse for scurrilous criticism. Concluding a merciless attack in 1832 on the danseur noble Monsieur Albert (François Decombe 1787–1865), Janin observed: People say ‘He is so noble! He is so noble! What deportment! What looks! What deportment!’ It is truer to say ‘He is so stiff!’ I abhor the danse noble just as I detest the noble style of declamation and all the routines, reflections, and genuflections of the Conservatory. (Quoted in Chapman 1997: 213) This did not, however, mean that Janin and Théophile Gautier (1811–72), the other great critic of the Romantic ballet, necessarily disliked male dancers as such. But the fact that, for them, ballet was a pleasing but undemanding display of feminine grace made it increasingly difficult for them to find a way of admitting to any pleasure in watching male dancers. In an 1837 review of Fanny Elssler, for example, Gautier announced that ‘an actress is a statue or a picture which is exhibited to you and can be freely criticised’ (1947: 20) and then went on to give an extraordinarily detailed description of her physical appearance, especially her legs, as if she were indeed an object rather than a person. This concludes: ‘We shall be pardoned, we hope, for having discoursed at such length on legs, but we are speaking of a dancer’ (ibid.: 21). Writing about La Volière (1838), a ballet choreographed by Therese Elssler in which, dressed ‘en travestie’, she partnered her sister Fanny, Gautier denounced the male ballet dancer, paying his usual attention to legs: ‘Nothing is more distasteful than a man who shows his red neck, his big muscular arms, his legs with the calves of a parish beadle, and all his strong massive frame shaken by leaps and pirouettes’ (ibid.: 24). Gautier was not, however, writing about an actual male dancer, since the male role was performed by a woman. It is, however, significant that the thought of a male dancer seemed to conjure up for him associations with working class masculinity. His distaste recalls the distaste that, as J.S. Bratton has shown, middle class Englishmen felt about working class male performers in English music halls. As I have shown, Janin objected to the danseur noble’s aristocratic manners. If aristocratic and working class masculinity were equally distasteful for the middle class spectator, was there any a positive image available for middle class men? This is the problem that 25
THE MAL E DANCER
Gautier and Janin both faced when they came to write about Jules Perrot (1810–92) in his highly acclaimed performance in Le Zingaro (1840). When Gautier came to write about Le Zingaro, his obsession with dancers’ legs came back, as it were, to haunt him. Reporting that: ‘the spectators clapped their hands, stamped, and even threw bouquets on their own account’, Gautier observed that this had nothing to do with either the music or the story: ‘Perrot’s legs did it all. But what legs!’ (ibid.: 43). It is surely the prohibition on homosexual attachment that prompted Gautier to immediately qualify his enthusiasm: ‘Perrot is not handsome, he is extraordinarily ugly. From the waist upwards, he has the proportions of a tenor, there is no need to say more; but from the waist downwards, he is a delight to look at’ (ibid.). Having got that out of the way, Gautier went on to compare Perrot’s legs with classical sculptures and Raphael paintings before describing his pas de deux with Carlotta Grisi. Gautier’s conclusion was that: ‘Perrot displays a perfect grace, purity, and lightness: it is visible music, and, if the comparison be permitted, his legs sing very agreeably to the eye’ (ibid.: 44). Janin had a very similar problem. After outlining the plot of Le Zingaro, he went off on a long digression. Ballet, for him, was a feminine spectacle: ‘Speak to us of a pretty dancing girl who displays the grace of her features and the elegance of her figure, who reveals so fleetingly all the treasures of her beauty. Thank God, I understand that perfectly’ (Janin in Chapman 1997: 232). What he couldn’t understand was, of course, the male dancer. In giving reasons why men do not look right on the ballet stage, he referred to the social position of middle class men: That this bewhiskered individual who is a pillar of the community, an elector, a municipal councillor, a man whose business is to make and above all unmake laws, should come before us in a tunic of skyblue satin, his head covered with a hat with a waving plume amorously caressing his cheek . . . this was surely impossible and we have done well to remove such great artists from our pleasures. (Ibid.) The male dancer, dressed in sky-blue satin and wearing a feathered hat, was undoubtedly a (male) danseur noble of the neo-classical ballet. In this latest diatribe against him, Janin was perhaps suggesting that the aristocratic manners he exemplified were degeneracy and effeminacy, as he goes on to object to woman as queen of the ballet being ‘forced to cut off half her silk petticoat to dress her partner with it’ (ibid.). He concluded that ballet was a feminine sphere within which men either did not appear manly, or if they looked too manly did not appear ideal: ‘Today the dancing man is no longer tolerated except as a useful accessory. He is the shading of the picture, the green box trees surrounding the garden flowers, the necessary foil’ (ibid.). After this long and richly evocative denunciation 26
THE TROUBLE WITH THE MALE DANCER . . .
1
of the male dancer, Janin, like Gautier, then did a complete volte-face, simply saying: So then, the more I am convinced of this truth, the more you can believe me when I say that Perrot is the most admirable danseur that can be seen! He seems incredibly light, even to those who have seen Taglioni’s exceptional lightness up close. (Ibid.)
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
Gautier and Janin both seemed to struggle to find a language with which to describe what they liked about male dancers. The ones they disliked recalled for them decadent aristocrats, parish beadles, and green box trees. Perrot, however, was not an old fashioned danseur noble but a new male Romantic lead. When it came to finding a way to praise Perrot, it is surely significant that both compare him with Taglioni. This is surely proof that Romantic ballet had become a feminine realm. The problem was that there was no acknowledged distinction between ballet as aesthetic experience and ballet as erotic spectacle. To enjoy the spectacle of men dancing was, therefore, to be interested in men, but that was socially proscribed. The male ballet dancer, therefore, came too close for comfort to the blurred and problematic line that separates, or, as Sedgwick implies, fails to separate, necessary and approved homosocial male bonding from forbidden homosexual sexuality. Gautier and Janin made a melancholy, double disavowal: they had to deny themselves in advance the possibility of enjoying watching a male dancer; having done so, they were, therefore, unable to grieve this male dancer’s loss so that he lingered on as a melancholy ghost. Confronted with a performance by a male dancer who was clearly exceptional, they had to invent an absent male dancer (the melancholy ghost) to criticise and thus prove that they took no pleasure in watching male dancing. Then, they finally evoked another ghostly dancer, this time the first great Romantic ballerina, Taglioni. Lynn Garafola (1985) has pointed out that men were freer to enjoy the feminine spectacle of ballet when male dancers were eliminated and their roles performed by women dancers ‘en travestie’. The male dancer not only became out of place on the newly feminine ballet stage, but, because male appreciation of the spectacle of the ballerina took on sexual aspects, the ways that male dancers appeared on stage became a source of anxiety to bourgeois male spectators. The contradiction which led to the decline of the male ballet dancer under bourgeois patronage during the nineteenth century was this: on the one hand, the male dancer was required as a necessary foil to dance with the ballerina; but, on the other hand, his presence provoked anxiety, not only in relation to class position, but also in relation to the difference between homosocial and homosexual relations. The prejudice did not, therefore, arise because of any actual belief that male dancers were homosexual. The lengths to which Gautier and Janin 27
THE MAL E DANCER
went to prove that they didn’t like male dancing, surely, demonstrate their own fear of being thought to be interested in men. When, however, gay men did become involved in dance and ballet, with Börlin, Nijinsky, and Shawn, the homophobic structures were already there to police any infringement of heterosexual norms. HOMOSEXUALITY AND THE MALE DANCER: THE DANCE THAT DOES NOT SPEAK ITS NAME There is a widespread reluctance to talk about dance and homosexuality, surely making it the dance that does not speak its name. The reference here is to Oscar Wilde who, during his trial in 1895 for homosexual offences, made a celebrated speech in defence of the love that dared not speak its name in his century. Over the years since then, a homosexual culture or subcultures have developed with diverse, shifting memberships and significant inputs from artists and intellectuals. In recent years, partly as a result of the gay rights movement, theoretical work has been done on the way homosexuality has been and is represented in the arts and mass media, and research has been done into the work of gay and lesbian artists. While Melanie Weeks (1987), Christy Adair (1992), and Valerie Briginshaw (2001) have written about lesbianism and dance, until recently surprisingly little attention has been given to gay men and dance. One of the first scholarly books that considered homosexuality and dance was Judith Lynne Hanna’s Dance, Sex and Gender (1988). Although the sections on gay men reflect the large amount of material Hanna researched for the book, they show little sympathy, or understanding, of the situation in which gay people live in our society and Hanna seems to be unaware of the underlying sexual politics. She saw homosexuality as a problem for gay people, which of course it is; but she didn’t consider what sort of a problem. There is a difference between thinking of homosexuality as a psychopathology, and seeing any neurosis suffered by a homosexual as a result of internalising society’s negative image of homosexuality. The latter way of defining the problem opens up a fruitful avenue for examining gay art, but one which Hanna did not explore. Instead her concern was with ‘why male homosexuals are disproportionally attracted to dance’ (1988: 130), and she suggested ways in which, for gay people, an involvement in the dance world can alleviate or be an escape from their ‘problem’. The problem, however, is not just the result of internalising society’s negative image of homosexuality, but the fact that Western society is, and has been for hundreds of years, profoundly homophobic. The source of much of Hanna’s material on gay men in ballet was the essay ‘Toeing the line: in search of the gay male image in classical ballet’ written in 1976 by the Canadian writer Graham Jackson. This considered the institutional structures and pressures that influence and limit the 28
THE TROUBLE WITH THE MALE DANCER . . .
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
production of ballets that deal with gay themes or subject matter and some of the ways in which a gay sensibility is expressed in or can be read into ballet. This essay has, until recently, stood out as one of the very few pieces to consider this subject. Written in the mid 1970s it had a very optimistic tone – coming out seemed for Jackson the solution for most gay men’s problems. Thus his central concern was with the fact that although a large proportion of gay men are dancers, choreographers, or hold administrative positions in the dance world, and there is a large gay audience for dance, ballet companies rarely if ever produce work that directly addresses the experiences and sensibilities of gay people. They don’t rock the boat. There are obvious reasons why there has been a silence on the subject of gay male dancers and choreographers. Arnold Haskell writing in 1934 is doubtless protecting individuals when he states: ‘of the outstanding male dancers that I know, and I know them all, not one is effeminate in manner, and very few indeed are not thoroughly normal’ (1934: 299). But he is surely also protecting the institution of ballet itself. With the liberalisation of laws about homosexuality and substantial changes in social attitudes, the continuation of the taboo on discussions of dance and homosexuality is surely both unnecessary and unhelpful. One possible reason why the taboo still persists is the need for dance and ballet companies to raise funding and attract sponsorship from private individuals and businesses. If this is the case, it is not a very good one, whereas the arguments for greater openness are surely compelling. Not talking about something doesn’t make it go away, and may, insidiously, make it take on greater significance than it really deserves. All male dancers are placed under suspicion with the result that, as is widely recognised, far fewer boys and men are involved in the dance world than girls and women. Moreover, homophobic prejudice can, as Jackson observes: ‘paralyse talented dancers from developing a personal dancing style reflective of their characters [and] limit the range of male dancing severely’ (Jackson 1978: 41). This holds true for gay and heterosexual dancers. The initial reasons for keeping quiet about gay male dancers are surely no longer valid, and silences now do more harm than good. Perhaps there are now more choreographers dealing with homosexual themes than there were when Jackson wrote ‘Toeing the line’, but only in the marginalised, underfunded, experimental fringes. In the mainstream, fear, prejudice, and the old boy network still ensure the status quo. The case of Matthew Bourne’s 1995 version of Swan Lake, which I discuss in Chapter 7, exemplifies this. It is a truism that fear and prejudice breed on ignorance. Homophobic mechanisms channel and block our understanding and appreciation of representations of masculinity that are made by both gay and straight dance artists. It is through understanding the ways in which these mechanisms work that their effectiveness is undermined, and the possibility of positive change is brought about. 29
2 LOOKING AT THE MALE
When we go to see a dance concert and watch male dancers performing, we each bring along our own miscellaneous bundles of ideas and experiences concerning masculinity. The ideological nature of these, their contradictions and limitations, were the subject of the first chapter. The dancers, choreographers, rehearsal directors, and others involved in producing the performance also bring with them their ideas and experiences, and these are present for the dancers as they perform on stage. Given the ways in which people are connected with one another through the society they live in, there is, of course, a considerable overlap between these ideas and experiences. They constitute a common discourse through which we are able to communicate with one another. Reading representations of masculinity in theatre dance does not, merely, mean recognising similarities between performances of masculinity in daily life and the way in which masculinity is embodied and represented by dancers on stage. It involves interpretation of information that is not a translation of a prior verbal text but the result of processes of corporeal investigation. Apprehension of the significance of a dance piece gradually accumulates over the duration of the performance. The time and space in which live dance performance takes place is a privileged one in which experience is intensified. What is represented through dancing can sometimes suggest an ideal not accessible in everyday life, and representation is, therefore, accorded particular cultural significance. Representations of masculinity in theatre dance are mediated through signifying systems; some of these are shared with other cultural forms while others are specific to dance. In the last chapter, I introduced Judith Butler’s idea that gender is ‘a sedimentation that, over time, has produced a set of corporeal styles’ (1990b: 275). Theatre dance forms have their own conventions and traditions. Sometimes we may see dancers perform canonical repertoire so beautifully or intensely that we can momentarily forget that what they are doing is constructed out of conventions. By making us believe that what they are performing is real for them, the dancers hide the work of representation. Or sometimes we may see a performance whose 30
LOOKING AT THE MALE
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
originality necessitates an unavoidable discontinuity with cultural traditions: indeed the signs that make up such a performance may not yet be readily assimilated and conventionalised. Or the performance may bring together sign systems to create juxtapositions or experiences that were previously inconceivable. Different kinds of dance performance may attract or absorb our attention in different ways. This chapter is concerned with the ways in which performances draw us in and represent masculinities for us to interpret. It investigates the sexual politics underlying the way theatre dance situates us as viewers in relation to the material it presents. An understanding of this can open up possibilities for reading these representations differently. This chapter is about the power relations that come into play when we see dance performed. In much Western theatre dance, male dancing bodies are supposed to be seen and read in a particular way. This is because of dominant ideas about gender, sexuality, class, ethnicity, religion, and other components of identity. It is also because of the predominantly hierarchical and male-dominated structures of the Western dance world, and the kinds of cultural and aesthetic values which these produce and reinforce. This chapter, therefore, investigates what kinds of possibility exist for choreographers, spectators, and dancers to negotiate their own ways through the processes of making, performing, and viewing dance. It is concerned with the processes that limit spectators as they read dance, and considers how effective these limitations are. It investigates the signifying structures through which dancers and choreographers make representations of masculinities. It thus identifies, in broad terms, some of the main ways in which representations are supposed to conform to dominant gender ideologies, and indicates the kinds of strategy which artists sometimes adopt to trouble and subvert these. THE SPECTATOR AND THE GAZE The art historian John Berger, whose ideas I introduced in the first chapter, observed that in Western visual culture: ‘Women are depicted in a quite different way from men – not because the feminine is different from the masculine – but because the “ideal” spectator is always assumed to be male and the image of woman is designed to flatter him’ (1972: 64). The connection which Berger made between gender representation and an assumed male spectator is one which has subsequently been widely developed. The male gaze, first theorised by feminist film scholar Laura Mulvey in 1975, had, in its time, a revolutionary effect on feminist scholarship in many fields, including dance studies. She identified two different ways of looking at narrative film: a way in which the spectator, caught up in the story, identifies with the protagonist, and a more detached look of pleasure at visual display. 31
THE MAL E DANCER
Film scholar Steve Neale, whose ideas were also cited in the first chapter, applied Mulvey’s thesis to the spectacle of masculinity in mainstream Hollywood film. ‘In a heterosexual and patriarchal society,’ he wrote, ‘the male body cannot be marked explicitly as the erotic object of another male look: that look must be motivated in some way, its erotic component repressed’ (Neale 1983: 14). In their determination to enlighten people about the way gender ideologies are inscribed in cultural forms, Mulvey and Neale described the process of inscription without acknowledging any possibility that spectators might exercise any agency in the way they watch work. They did not, however, actually say that spectators have no freedom in the way they respond to films, or that female spectators have no point of entry to them. So, while Neale argued that the male body could not be the erotic subject of another male look, he, nevertheless, qualified this by proposing that male dancers in Hollywood musicals were feminised because, for this film genre, the viewing subject was presumed to be female. What seemed most important to Mulvey and Neale was to recognise the extent to which the conventions underlying mainstream Hollywood films limited the possibilities for the viewing subject by assuming that the spectator was white, heterosexual, and male. Both the film screen and the stage are spaces where spectators are encouraged to make identifications with the subject positions which performers embody. Developing a feminist account of spectatorship in theatre, Jill Dolan pointed out that: ‘the male spectator’s position is the point from which the text is most intelligible’ and that if a female spectator ‘identifies with the male hero, she becomes implicit with her own indirect objectification’ (1991: 13). If she admires ‘the represented female body as a consumable object, she participates in her own commodification’ (ibid.). Nevertheless, as Sue-Ellen Case has cautioned, there are problems in applying film theory uncritically to live performance. Case noted that, initially, feminist theatre scholars thought that ‘the power relations of the Gaze in narrative cinema seemed homologous to operations of spectatorship in the theatre’ (1995: 330). However, as she pointed out, photographic technology focuses the gaze in a particular way which should not be conflated with the kinds of focusing structures through which spectatorship is constructed during live performance. Case warned that when one understands the gaze as something constituted through technical apparatus of perception, such as those used in the cinema, there is a danger of excluding from one’s account of spectatorship ‘any account of the “live”, and by extension, the “body” outside of the apparatus’ (ibid.). At issue are the structures through which looks and gazes operate within theatre dance and how these situate the spectator in a normative, habitual way as a passive and uncritical consumer of ideologically determined representations. 32
LOOKING AT THE MALE
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
It is not just norms of gender and sexuality that are reinforced through these habitual structures of looking and gazing. Writing in the 1950s, Frantz Fanon discussed the problems of black spectatorship. When a young black man sees a Tarzan film at a cinema in the Caribbean, Fanon suggested, he automatically identifies with the hero, Tarzan, against the savages in the film who are black. If, however, he views the same film in a European cinema, it is more difficult for him to identify with Tarzan ‘for the rest of the audience, being white, automatically identify him with the savages on the screen’ (1967: 153). For Fanon’s black male spectator, awareness of his blackness within a context of white racism makes identification with this ideal, white, male hero problematic and conflictual. As Brenda Dixon Gottschild has shown, watching African American dancers performing in blackface was uncomfortable and ambivalent for African American audiences (1996: 112–13). Ideals are aspirational rather than attainable and, as I showed in Chapter 1, white masculinity is itself conflictual. Richard Dyer has pointed out that, for the white, male spectator, Tarzan represents an unattainable ideal who uses his ‘white man’s muscles’ to defend nature against injustice and exploitation, sometimes defending the natives against whites whose actions would destroy their way of life (1997: 157). (I return to this in my discussion of US modern dance in Chapter 4.) Later feminist writers have suggested the situation for female spectators is also complicated. Angela McRobbie has pointed out that girl spectators can interpret the idealised image of the ballerina in ways that affirm and empower them as young women (1984). What Fanon, Gottschild, McRobbie, and, to a certain extent Dyer, are suggesting are restricted possibilities for reading ideologically loaded representations against the grain of their universalising intentions. At issue is the way white, heterosexual, male interests are disguised as universal and ahistorical ideals. These become a problem when enforced in violent ways in order to cover up and disavow conflicts within the construction of masculine identities. While my central concern is with masculinity, it is worth remembering that individuals are always complex and multifaceted, finding their identities within a wide range of economic, cultural, and political determinations. It is, therefore, necessary to expand the principle that spectators make identifications with performers through networks of gazes by including a wider range of potential viewing positions. Two further accounts of looking, which the art historian Michael Fried and feminist film theorist Kaja Silverman have proposed, offer ways of doing this. Michael Fried (1980) has distinguished between paintings that exemplify absorption and ones which project what he called theatricality. A ‘theatrical’ painting, in Fried’s terms, is one that makes a claim on spectators, causing them to want to see what the figures in the painting are engaged in seeing or doing. The figures themselves achieve this by drawing attention to themselves so as to make the spectator want to be like them or to experience 33
THE MAL E DANCER
what spectators imagine the figures are experiencing. The kinds of paintings in which Fried detected absorption are ones in which the figures have an inward focus. Because the figures are so absorbed in what they are doing, they allow the spectator a certain freedom to take in the piece as a whole, and become absorbed in it in their own way. Fried’s thesis suggests ways of theorising dance spectatorship.1 Some dancers and dance pieces reach out to, attract, appeal to, or claim the spectator’s attention. Some performances, thus, invite the spectator to identify with a dancer in her or his charismatic interactions with another dancer (for example during a duet); or alternatively the spectator can be drawn in by the intensity of the dancer’s performance (for example during a solo); or the performer may behave in a seductive or a dominating way. These are all instances in which the spectator’s gaze is focused in a way determined by the dancer or the performance. In Fried’s terms, these are ‘theatrical’. Fried’s notion of absorption correlates with Susan Foster’s description of what she calls reflective dance: Dances operating in this mode elaborate their own world of references by focusing on their own movement. Just as they reflect themselves, however, they also inevitably reflect the viewers in the process of searching for and producing meaning for the dances. (1986: 76) So, in this kind of spectatorship, the dancer’s sense of absorption can draw the spectator into the dance, not through a point of identification with the dancer but through involvement and fascination with the formal and aesthetic qualities of the choreography which he or she is performing. Abstract, storyless dance pieces generally position the spectator so that he or she looks in an absorbed way, while dancers in works which explore narrative situations or present interactions between individuals generally claim the spectator’s attention in what Fried called a ‘theatrical’ way. Where a male dancer claims attention in a ‘theatrical’ way, his active, dominating performance can have the effect of reinforcing norms of masculine behaviour. If he tries too hard, however, or seems too emotional, he may fail to appear sufficiently in control of himself or sufficiently detached and distant. A male dancer who is absorbed in the enveloping atmosphere which the performance of a piece generates, so that he barely acknowledges the spectator, conforms with norms of male detachment and self-sufficiency. But, by not being in control of the spectator’s gaze, he may not have any defence against being looked at in an erotic way. Both absorption and ‘theatricality’, as I shall show in subsequent chapters, are more likely to reinforce dominant gender ideologies than they are to open up alternative ways of watching and interpreting dance. Kaja Silverman has distinguished between the look and the gaze. By the gaze, she means the sets of structures initially described by Mulvey which 34
LOOKING AT THE MALE
1
1
influence ‘what we see when we apprehend the world not only through a particular image repertoire, but from the position which is assigned to us in advance’ by ideologically determined focusing structures (Silverman 1996: 182). Silverman suggests, however, that there can be ways of looking which acknowledge that the viewer actively initiates his or her own involvement within what they are watching. Some dance works, which I discuss in later chapters of this book, deliberately disrupt habitual patterns of spectatorship, and force audience members to become aware of their related situatedness as observers. This can lead them to develop more active and creative approaches to interpretation. Such works, which are generally associated with the tradition of avant-garde performance, often challenge and subvert the representation of normative gender ideologies.
11 CHOREOGRAPHER-CENTRED AND SPECTATOR-CENTRED DANCE ANALYSIS
11
1
11
11
11
Critical investigations of spectatorship can have comparably disruptive effects. Some dance scholars, in the 1980s and 1990s, began to ask questions about the ways in which gender, ‘race’, sexuality, and other components of identity are represented in theatre dance, pointing out the ways in which much dance has failed to address them as female, black, or gay spectators. Two of the most controversial essays that did this concerned the ballets of George Balanchine (1904–83). Writing in 1987 about one of the pas de deux in Balanchine’s The Four Temperaments (1946), Ann Daly pointed out that, while this duet might be an archetypal courtship, ‘the desire expressed by their relationship belongs only to the man. About her own desire, the compliant ballerina remains silent’ (17). In a 1996 book, Brenda Dixon Gottschild pointed out that, in a culture that considers classical ballet to be high culture but sees jazz dance as merely popular entertainment, ‘it will not suffice to say that jazz dance influenced [Balanchine’s] work. That term serves to misname the Africanist legacy that, buried under layers of deceit, has been invisibilized’ (78). Balanchine has achieved institutional status. His citation as one of the Dance Heritage Coalition’s Irreplaceable American Dance Treasures states that he ‘was the foremost choreographer of the twentieth century and the architect of classical ballet in America’ (DHC 2000). Claims, particularly in the US, that theatre dance is a serious art form (that can take its place alongside visual art, music, and literature) in effect depend upon an acknowledgement of the excellence of Balanchine’s ballets. To have chosen work by Jerome Robbins (1918–98) to mount a claim for recognition of the validity of African American or feminist spectatorship would have been less threatening, since he is less central to the canon. If the issues that Daly and Gottschild raised are controversial, and their conclusions for some unacceptable (see Copeland 1993; Jordan and Thomas 1994; Banes 1998; 35
THE MAL E DANCER
Gottschild 2005), this raises questions about whose interests are served through maintaining the particular universal values which modernist choreography is supposed to exemplify. By demonstrating that, although pure abstract choreography such as Balanchine’s may not tell stories, it still mediates ideas about gender and race, Daly and Gottschild in effect challenged widely held beliefs about modernist choreography. These are that pure, abstract dance has progressed beyond representation (understood in the limited sense of imitation). Thus, for much of the twentieth century, the value of dance as art was widely believed to lie in formal, aesthetic properties that were timeless and universal (e.g. Banes 1980; Cohen 1981; Levin 1983; Levinson 1991). In this view its aesthetic value has nothing to do with gender, ‘race’, and sexuality. This means seeing an individual work solely as an instance of its choreographer’s style. This formalist way of reading dance focuses on the choreographer as author and origin of a work’s value. Both the author-centred and spectator-centred approaches to dance analysis can generate useful and informative insights, although questions about gender representation generally only arise within spectatorcentred approaches. As in other fields of cultural analysis, the birth of the reader should not necessarily bring about the death of the author. Cultural theorist Mieke Bal, explaining her semiological approach to analysing visual images, has suggested that neither an approach which is purely concerned with authorial intention nor one which focuses exclusively on spectatorship can provide a satisfactory account of the process of visual analysis. She points out that each model ‘can only account for ideal, totally successful communication’ whereas the artist (as sender) does more than transmit a clear message: ‘the package contains other, subliminal and unconscious messages’ (1995: 148). In turn, the spectator (as receiver) approaches the work within her or his own preoccupations. Bal, therefore, argues that: the receiver manipulates the sender, by being whom she or he is and by the affective, political and intellectual relationship between receiver and sender. Manipulation is not only an instance of (ideological) agency, but also of the historical embeddedness of that agency. Rather than the assumed (but in fact projected), authorial intention, the interaction between work and audience should be the object of a genuine historical inquiry. (Ibid.) By calling this process manipulation, Bal conveys the idea that the artist’s work is not complete without a spectator, but the spectator does not actually add anything to it by interpreting it. Where dance analysis is concerned, this situation is further complicated by the fact that dancers perform an intermediary role between choreographer and spectator. Where Bal proposes that the receiver manipulates the sender in the way they interpret 36
LOOKING AT THE MALE
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
their messages, I suggest that, in live performance, because the performer senses the audience’s response, dancer and spectator both interact through manipulating the message. The spectator responds to the performance itself while the performer frames the material in ways that may modify, limit, or direct the kinds of interpretative manipulation the spectator can make. Bal’s proposition that one takes the interaction between work and audience as the object of enquiry has important implications for dance studies. It means focusing on the dancer–spectator relationship during the moment of live performance and not treating the performance as merely a projection of the choreographer’s intentions. This means analysing not only the choreography which the choreographer as author sets, but also those aspects that only come into play during the live moment of performance itself. As Susan Foster puts it: ‘The dance itself rather than the choreographer suggests an interpretative itinerary for the viewer’ (1986: 242). This is to attribute agency to the dance itself in that both the choreographer and the dance give opportunities to the dancer and spectator. This shift, I suggest, is a prerequisite for an understanding of the way dancing bodies perform gender. Who is performing and what kind of affective, political, and intellectual relationship is created between dancer and spectator is crucial to the ideas about gender that are brought into play during a performance. In theorising the political component of the performer–spectator relationship, I am accepting Stuart Hall’s account of hegemony which underlies the British approach to cultural studies. Hall argued that, although dominant ideologies seem to be uniform and consistent, they only represent the world view of a dominant group. Majority audiences realise this and negotiate their own versions within them (just as McRobbie suggests girls negotiate their own version of the ballerina ideal). Hall suggests the negotiated version ‘contains a mixture of adaptive and oppositional elements . . . it accords the privileged position to the dominant definitions of events while reserving the right to make a more negotiated application of “local conditions” ’ (1993: 102). It is, therefore, composite, conflictual, diverse, and ‘shot through with contradictions, though these are only in certain circumstances brought to full visibility’ (ibid.). In the moment of live performance, therefore, the relationship between the spectator and the male dancer is one in which dominant, supposedly natural and common sense definitions of normative masculinity may be acknowledged, but only through negotiation and adaptation; as a result, their conflictual and contradictory nature may, sometimes, become visible. This suggests that it is no longer possible to see a dance work as the expression, solely, of aesthetic values which transcend the circumstances of their creation. Rather than seeing the choreographer as a unified and universal subject who evokes timeless truths, it is necessary to see him or her as a complex and potentially conflictual subject, someone in touch with, and formed by, the 37
THE MAL E DANCER
circumstances of their time and place. Feminist art historian Griselda Pollock proposes we need to analyse any cultural text ‘for its complex inscriptions of historically specific and non-cogent, non-unified processes of subjectivity which are gendered, and classed and culturally defined’ (1995: 50). Many of the works that I discuss in the following chapters are powerful and fascinating because of the richness and depth with which their choreographers and dancers work through the complex and contradictory effects of gender ideologies. Whereas a dance ethnography might prioritise establishing the views of particular spectators at a particular performance, dance historians generally infer the spectator’s position from available evidence. Because of dance’s ephemerality, particular attention, therefore, necessarily falls on the primary sources that are available, including contemporary reviews. Dance critics negotiate their own versions of dominant ideologies and their writings are never value free. It is precisely because of this that their prejudices can provide valuable information about contemporaneous attitudes towards the male dancer, as I showed in the first chapter when discussing reviews by Gautier and Janin. Every company director since Diaghilev has paid close attention to the press. The Western dance world is one in which performances not only generate writing but writing in turn has an effect on the future development of dance. Some experimental dance works, during the last two decades, need to be seen as responses to articulate black, gay, and feminist writing, including writing about dance. Understanding how dominant ideologies work can enable the formulation of subtle and effective forms of resistance that can, in turn, lead to the stagings of alternatives. The significance of Hall’s account of hegemony is that dominant ideas mediated through cultural forms only remain dominant while the broader majority are prepared to accept them and, therefore, these need to be responsive, in a democratic and consensual way, to pressure for change. PERFORMATIVE SPEECH ACTS AND DANCE PERFORMANCE When Bal proposes that the artist as sender does more than transmit a clear message, she is using the deconstructive idea that there is no oneto-one relationship between a sign and what it signifies. Jacques Derrida used the idea that a sign always exceeds its literal meaning to critique J.L. Austin’s theory of performative speech acts. Since a deconstructive approach to speech act theory underpins the idea of the performance of gender that I have been using, it is necessary to explain what this is and clarify the relationship between performative speech acts and dance performance. Austin noticed that, whereas most statements use words to communicate meanings, there are special circumstances in which we use words to do 38
LOOKING AT THE MALE
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
things, such as promising, apologising, asking, or thanking. He called these performative speech acts because ‘the issuing of the utterance is the performing of an action – it is not normally thought of as just saying something’ (1962: 6–7). Whereas one can use logic to check whether most statements are true or false, this is not the case with performatives. The most cited example which Austin gives is the act of saying ‘I do’ during a marriage ceremony (ibid.: 10). The actual statement itself cannot be checked logically without reference to the context in which it is uttered: for example, is the person already married to someone else? Austin, therefore, created a logical system of rules for establishing what he called the ‘felicity’ or ‘infelicity’ of promises and other performatives. Crucially for subsequent uses of the theory of performative speech acts within performance studies, he debarred from his system a few situations, including the use of speech acts by actors on stage. ‘Language in such circumstances’, Austin claimed, ‘is in special ways – intelligibly – not used seriously but in ways parasitic upon its normal use – ways which fall under the doctrine of etiolations of language’ (ibid.: 23, emphasis in the original). Derrida took up this passage and questioned whether speech acts ever only actually behave in what Austin describes as a normal way. Speakers never know exactly how their statements will be understood, and may not understand all the implications of what they say. According to Derrida, the speech act always, therefore, exceeds its literal meaning. Whereas Austin insisted that speech acts are dependent on their context, Derrida argued that any statement, including a speech act, ‘can be cited, put between quotation marks; in doing so it can break with every context, engendering an infinity of new contexts in a manner which is absolutely illimitable’ (1977: 185, emphasis in the original). It is this citationality or iterability of the speech act which underlies Butler’s description of gender as a performative act. Butler, as I showed in the first chapter, argued that individuals perform their gender through the repetition of socially mandated discourses of stylised bodily acts. Individuals, she argues, are compelled to repeat acts which can neither be refused nor followed in strict obedience. Butler explains this as an instance of what Louis Althusser called interpellation (1995: 121–4). In Althusser’s well-known example, the policeman calls out to someone on the street ‘hey you!’ and the person turns round to face him. The policeman’s call, Althusser proposes, interpellates them into the discourse of the law, and their response to his call is an admission of their obligations as subjects (Althusser 1984: 47–8). Similarly, individuals are called upon to perform their gender and, as they do so, they acknowledge that they are subject to normative gender ideologies. Although individuals have no choice but to comply with the interpellating demand, these performative acts, following Derrida, nevertheless always exceed their literal meaning. The example of subversive gender 39
THE MAL E DANCER
performance that Butler discussed in several of her works is a drag queen. Gay Morris argues that, although Butler has not considered dance, the work of the US contemporary choreographer Mark Morris demonstrates that ‘dance, which can incorporate drag, offers far more subtle and wide ranging possibilities for attacking rigid gender categories than does drag alone’ (1996: 142). She supports this by focusing, in particular, on his performance of dual female roles as Dido and the Sorceress in his 1989 work Dido and Aeneas (which I discuss in more detail in Chapter 7). She points out that: the size, muscularity, and substance of his body considered ‘masculine’, [are] combined with an extreme flexibility and soft, fatty quality that is read as stereotypically ‘feminine’. Morris consciously emphasizes and uses these differing aspects of his body as an element to upset dichotomous gender categories. (Ibid.: 145–6) In Austin’s terms, one could say that Morris’s performance of femininity was not used seriously but in ways parasitic upon its normal use. He performed as a woman in the performance although spectators knew his biological gender. He was citing the behaviour, and gestural signs and conventions through which femininity is performed and in doing so is, in Derrida’s phrase, putting these between quotation marks. Commenting on the use of this deconstructive theory of performativity in theatre and performance studies during the 1990s, Susan Foster was wary of its usefulness for dance studies. ‘The vast majority of studies implementing the notion of performance,’ she observed, ‘neglect the body and at the same time use body to inflect textuality with a new vitality’ (1998: 22). Thus Shoshana Felman (2002), in her reading of Austin, points out that the physicality of speech production can scandalously eroticise, exceed, and thus undermine the literal meaning of a speech act. Butler, herself, seemed to confirm the danger to which Foster refers when she recently admitted that ‘Every time I try to write about the body, the writing ends up being about language. This is not because I think that the body is reducible to language; it is not’ (2004: 198). Foster’s concern is that, because of its roots in language and linguistics, this notion of performance is only concerned with the conceptual strategies of signification, and lacks ‘attention to repertoires of behavior other than those of the text’ (1998: 27). The signs and traces of embodied behaviour, which inform the conventions of theatre dance, may not be reducible to language, but they only signify meanings because they constitute a non-verbal discourse. The theory of performative speech acts, particularly as it has been taken up by queer scholars, can help elucidate some of the ways in which this discourse creates meanings. Indeed, there are correlations between Derrida’s critique of the attempt by Austin to exclude parasitic citations of speech acts, and 40
LOOKING AT THE MALE
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
the problematic exclusion of queer identities from normative masculinity (which I discussed in the first chapter). Derrida accused Austin of trying to surround felicitous performatives with a ‘kind of ditch or extended place of perdition which speech could never hope to leave’ (1977: 190). Isn’t the risk of parasitic citations, Derrida rhetorically asks, ‘its internal and positive condition of possibility? Is that outside its inside, the very force and law of its emergence?’ (ibid.). Foucault, Bersani, and others, as I noted in the first chapter, argued that homosexual men are essential to the maintenance of heterosexual norms because they are ‘the internally excluded difference that cements heterosexual identity’ (Bersani 1995: 36). Alan Parker and Eve Sedgwick have proposed a queer reading of one of Austin’s speech acts which fits the normative, coercive model I have been describing where the male dancer is supposed to appear active under the (male) spectator’s gaze. The speech act they cite is ‘I dare you’ which, in their example, becomes ‘I dare you to prove you are not a “wuss”’. Parker and Sedwick’s ‘wussiness’ is clearly a rhetorical trope into which readers can insert any queer identity. For my purposes, it fits the situation of professional male dancers in the West over the last century who, regardless of their sexual orientation, find themselves dared to prove that they are not effeminate, or unmanly, or gay. Parker and Sedgwick point out that the structure of the speech act ‘I dare you’ not only involves an ‘I’ and a ‘you’ but also tacitly implies a ‘they’ who will witness the dare: In daring you to perform some foolhardy act, ‘I’ necessarily invoke a consensus of the eyes of others. It is these eyes through which you risk being seen as a wuss [unmanly], it is as people who share with me a contempt for wussiness [unmanliness] that these others are interpellated. (1995: 8) They point out that the witness may not in fact share the prejudice and indeed the ‘I’ may only be issuing the dare out of fear that they themselves might not pass the test. For Parker and Sedgwick, the role of witness constitutes the space of the speech act in which is staged ‘a spectacle that denies its audience the ability either to look away from it or to intervene in it’ (ibid.: 10). This is surely a revealing way of understanding the roles of male performer and spectator as they negotiate dominant ideologies and manipulate the choreographer’s ‘message’ for the duration of a dance performance. THE MALE DANCER AND THE GAZE If for most of the last 100 years, the construction of male roles in dance and ballet has too often been overshadowed by the need to respond to the prejudice that dancing is not a masculine activity, choreographers and 41
THE MAL E DANCER
dancers have responded to this in different ways. It sometimes results in a ‘macho’ overcompensation – of trying to prove that ballet is, in fact, tough, or that modern dance is not soft like ballet. But there have also been instances where dancers have, seemingly, been unaware of, or ignored the prejudice, or found relatively acceptable ways of side-stepping it. Alternatively, as in the case of some of the gay choreographers whose work I discuss in Chapter 7, some dancers and choreographers have deliberately set out to undermine and attack restricted ideas about masculine identities. At issue is how the male dancer presents himself to the spectator’s gaze. Laura Mulvey (1975), as I noted earlier, first coined the term ‘the male gaze’, and proposed that cinema audiences have two different types of way of looking at narrative film: a look with which the spectator, caught up in the story, identifies with the protagonist, and a more detached look of pleasure at visual display. This latter is directed by the way characters within the narrative look at each other. As I have shown, Jill Dolan and Ann Daly both argued that this network of intersecting looks and gazes operates in theatre and dance to invite spectators to make identifications with some dancers on stage or to contemplate the visual spectacle which dance sometimes presents. Dance scholars have, of course, made revisions and objections to these arguments, some of which I shall consider later. The looks and gazes that make up spectatorship in theatre dance can result in dancers of both sexes becoming the subject of both male and female spectators’ gazes and thus permit cross-gender identifications (which may not necessarily be motivated by gender issues). In order to explore what happens in situations where the male dancer may be the subject of both male and female gazes, I turn to a discussion of the duet since this is a key signifying structure through which gender and sexuality is represented in theatre dance. Revising his 1949 book on the pas de deux for a new edition in 1969, Anton Dolin reflected with regret on what he saw as a move away from the gallant and chivalrous tradition of male partnering which his own dancing exemplified. Within the ballet tradition introduced to western Europe by the Ballets Russes and continued in particular in Britain by dance artists such as Dolin, the male role in the pas de deux tended to be inconspicuous and uncontroversial. Writing in 1969, Dolin regretfully acknowledged that, since the first European performances by the Bolshoi Ballet in 1956, a new style of partnering had come into fashion: ‘It is of no use to be, and remain, old fashioned, but I shall never reconcile myself to the current vogue of executing the lovely classical adagios (pas de deux) of Swan Lake and The Sleeping Beauty as if they were weight-lifting contests’ (1969: 12). In Dolin’s view ‘the good (male) partner will always try to avoid any appearance of hard work, however difficult it may be, and believe me, often is’ (ibid.). Whereas masculinity is normally signified through action, it is, therefore, hidden within this gallant tradition. 42
LOOKING AT THE MALE
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
The male partner’s gaze is crucial in signifying his masculinity. He never acknowledges the spectator’s gaze, and his own gaze is directed towards the ballerina. As Adrian Stokes put it: Her partner guides and holds her. And he – he then watches her pas with upraised hand, he shows her off. He has the air of perpetual triumph, and when the time comes for his own variation he bounds, leaps, bounces and rejoins the ballerina in the wings amid applause. Such is the abstract of the pas de deux, the crux of ballet. (1942: 81) Anton Dolin gives a similar account: ‘He is there to focus attention upon her from their first entrance until the last call is finished’ (1969: 12). This applies even when he is applauded: following the adagio the true ballerina expects her partner to lead her on. [ . . . he] should keep his whole attention on her and with obvious admiration at what she has accomplished. He knows that without him she could not have achieved such perfection, but it is gentlemanly not to show it! (Ibid.) By himself gazing at the ballerina, he identifies himself with the males in the audience and is, in turn, available to be the bearer of their looks. Here, the complex interplay of the spectator’s and male dancer’s gazes and projected identifications does not just determine how the spectacle is interpreted, but creates a sense of narrative. At the same time, this gentlemanly consideration for his female partner could also be attractive to a female spectator, a fantasy dancing partner who combines strength with tenderness, male authority with refined grace. So, while the conventional use of the dancer’s gaze signifies a degree of manliness, the gallant partner is, nevertheless, relatively inconspicuous, and gentlemanly rather than dominating. His behaviour, therefore, indicates a tacit acknowledgement of female spectatorship. Any consequent eroticisation of the male dancing body, however, would be a source of homophobic panic for an (assumed) heterosexual male viewer. The gallant pas de deux, therefore, attempts uneasily to balance the interests of actual female and largely imagined male spectators. The pas de deux between Apollo and Terpsichore in Balanchine’s 1928 ballet Apollon Musagète (Apollo and the muses) exemplifies this balancing act. In classical Greek mythology, the muses are minor deities who each preside over one of the arts or sciences, and their role is to inspire mortals. In Balanchine’s ballet, three of them danced solos for the adolescent Apollo, initially Serge Lifar, who then danced for them before choosing Terpsichore, the muse of dance, initially Alice Nikitina, as his dancing partner. This was the first of Balanchine’s extremely productive collaborations with the 43
THE MAL E DANCER
composer Stravinsky. At the time of its first performance, its ‘neo-classical’ combination of the clear, precise conventions of Marius Petipa’s late nineteenth-century pas de deux with modernist fragmentation was controversial. For much of the ballet, Apollo was the bearer of the male spectator’s look as he watched the three ballerinas’ solos. His interest in them, however, was seriously impersonal and artistic and, when he danced with Terpsichore, there was no sense that any personal relationship was involved. He almost never seemed to look directly at her, often facing in the opposite direction from her or looking past her, upwards. This began with a tableau that cited Michaelangelo’s painting of God’s creation of Adam on the Sistine Chapel ceiling. Apollo, like Michaelangelo’s Adam, lay on his side on the floor, resting on one leg and pushing his torso up with one arm, his free arm raised in mid air with one finger pointing. Terpsichore sidled across the floor towards him on pointe, both looking away from each other. With her right arm she pointed up to the heavens, while her left arm reached down, towards his pointing hand, and their two fingers touched. Just as Michaelangelo’s God imparts the divine spark of life to his Adam by touching his finger, so Terpsichore, the muse of dance, with the same gesture, gave Apollo divine inspiration. The fragmentation, and the two dancers’ sense of detachment and absorption in what they were doing, had the effect of directing the spectators’ attention towards the unfolding sequence of shapes that the two dancers made together. This, as Peter Brinson and Clement Crisp have described it, culminated in a ‘“swimming lesson” with [Terpsichore] stretched in a beautiful proud curve on [Apollo’s] back as they move their arms in swimming motion’ (Brinson and Crisp 1970: 208). As the US dance critic Edwin Denby put it: ‘When the score and the choreography now and then exchange a smile, the dancers don’t presume to be in on the joke, they are attending to the powerful dance forces present’ (1965: 256). Apollon Musagète presented both male and female dancing bodies as absorbing, aesthetic spectacle. It, therefore, reached out to the spectator to claim ‘his’ attention, inviting ‘him’ to identify with the male partner and enjoy what he is seeing and doing: in Fried’s terms, this is theatrical. But the ballet also created an effect of absorption by drawing spectators in through their fascination with its formal and aesthetic qualities. Its modernist fragmentation may, at the time, have disrupted habitual habits of spectatorship and encouraged what Silverman called active looking: the female roles might therefore have appeared more self-sufficient and autonomous than ones in traditional ballets. Apollo’s role, however, conformed with norms of masculine behaviour. Dolin and Stokes, in effect, describe a situation where male dominance was breaking down. From a historical perspective, the disappearance of the male ballet dancer from nineteenth-century ballet companies came at a time when ballet was becoming a performance genre in which male 44
LOOKING AT THE MALE
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
patrons watched women dancing: in other words it became a feminine realm. When the male ballet dancer made his comeback with the Ballets Russes, for which Balanchine and Dolin both worked at the start of their professional careers, theatre dance was an area in which female and gay male patronage were becoming increasingly significant (as I show in the next chapter). Whereas film scholar Steve Neale said that male dancers were feminised through being the subject of a female gaze, I suggest it is more useful to say that the institution of Western theatre dance had become doubly feminised by these two significant shifts in patronage. The word ‘feminised’ is emotive. In ordinary life, people often sense when they are being looked at since this can sometimes be an uncomfortable experience. For some male spectators, an involuntary identification with the male performer might have a worrying potential to arouse shame and embarrassment for this man whose body is offered as sexual spectacle. Film scholar Richard Dyer points this out in his discussion of film star publicity photos, male pin ups, and paintings and drawings of the male nude. ‘On the one hand,’ he observes, ‘these men are there to be looked at by women. On the other hand, this does violence to the codes of who looks and who is looked at, and some attempt is instinctively made to counteract this violation’ (1982: 63). Dyer argues that images of men must appear active in some way in order to appear in line with dominant ideas of masculinity. Women in pin ups (and in nude paintings) almost always avert their eyes from their viewers and acknowledge them, thus allowing themselves to be surveyed as erotic objects. Men in pin ups, and much dance photography, look out actively, often upwards, barely acknowledging the viewer and thus resisting the attempt of the viewer’s gaze to objectify them. Both male and female pin ups are, therefore, in Fried’s terms absorbed, but their absorption signifies differently through gender conventions. Looking upwards, Dyer suggests, can signify masculine subjectivity: ‘In the case where the model is looking up, this always suggests spirituality: he might be there for his face and body to be gazed at, but his mind is on higher things, and it is this upwards striving that is most supposed to please’ (ibid.). As I have noted, Apollo looked upwards as if his mind was on higher things. Whereas women are usually shown in passive poses, men are generally shown caught in some sort of activity. Even if men are not in action, ‘the male image still promises actively by the way the body is posed. Even in an apparently supine pose, the model tightens and taughtens his body so that the muscles are emphasised, hence drawing attention to the body’s potential for action’ (ibid.: 67). At the start of his pas de deux, Apollo lay stretched on the stage floor looking up in a characteristic pose of masculine striving. He was posed with his body turning, resting on his arms, like David in the Sistine Chapel, caught in action with his body tensed, and his eyes, looking up in what Dyer would 45
THE MAL E DANCER
call a pose of masculine striving (1987: 118). These conventions of striving and active looking make images of men look masculine. Where men are presented in images without these conventions, their masculinity appears unstable. Apollo and Terpsichore’s ‘swimming lesson’ lift is one in which the male partner’s masculine strength and stability are signified. In other kinds of duet that do not conform to the gallant conventions, male strength can be shown within more exciting and dangerous lifts, and the male partner may also signify his masculinity through his ability to control his female partner. Ann Daly’s objections to one duet in Balanchine’s The Four Temperaments was that the ballerina appeared helpless and passive through being displayed in a vulnerable and sexually demeaning way towards the audience (1987). It would be simplistic to dismiss ballet pas de deux in general as no more than an exhibition in which the female dancer is an object to be manipulated. Duets signify social relations. The actual practice of partnering and lifting is one which requires a high degree of skill and co-operation between the male and female dancer, but the extent to which the spectator is made aware of this varies between one duet and another, and between different styles and traditions. Some signify hierarchies of dominance and subordination, others suggest more egalitarian relations. Sarah Rubidge suggests that there are certain questions that one can ask about the relationship implied in a duet: How often does the male initiate the lifts? How often is the woman used as a passive object? How often does the male dancer, by touching a part of his partner’s body, cause her to move? Does the female dancer initiate movement in the male in a similar way? How often do the partners bear each other’s weight equally in a duet – or trust their weight to their partner? (1989: 5) Rubidge’s observations suggest a way to compare male and female agency within a duet, but a balanced, ‘politically correct’ duet may not be very exciting. In narrative ballets such as Kenneth Macmillan’s Romeo and Juliet (1965) or Birgit Culberg’s Miss Julie (1950), love duets express a passionate struggle. The central duet in Balanchine’s Agon (1957), which is a storyless ballet, uses tensions between a resistant ballerina and a sometimes forceful partner to suggest an abstracted struggle. The male dancer’s active roles in such ballets can compensate for, or repress, the way in which he is the erotic object of either a spectator’s or another dancer’s gaze. NATURALISING MALE VIOLENCE The way in which the male pin up and the male partner in a duet are presented to the spectator – in Mulvey’s useful term, their to-be-looked46
LOOKING AT THE MALE
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
at-ness – is contradictory. As Dyer has pointed out, where the conventions are adhered to, the image resists being objectified and appreciated from an erotic point of view; yet it is only through appearing masculine that the pin up seems desirable. Any female or gay male spectatorship is, therefore, achieved through breaking the laws governing normative gender ideologies, and law breakers are liable to punishment. As I noted earlier in this chapter, Steve Neale has suggested that ‘in a heterosexual and patriarchal society, the male body cannot be marked explicitly as the erotic object of another male look: that look must be motivated in some way, its erotic component repressed’ (1983: 14). Neale argues that the problem lies within, and must be resolved through, the narrative, usually through some sort of punishment. Punishment generally must be seen to follow in narratives where the central character goes against social convention, and this applies also in theatre dance. Neither women nor men are supposed to look erotically at men. Jocasta, in Graham’s Night Journey (1947), comes to a bad end for having desired Oedipus, as does he himself for having been the erotic subject of her gaze (see Burt 1997). As Graham Jackson (1978: 38–9) points out, gay ballets (in which men are the erotic object of the male gaze) such as Undertow (Tudor 1945) and Monument For A Dead Boy (Rudi van Dantzig 1965) are only acceptable if they end tragically. One of the most extreme forms of testing masculinity within a narrative is a fight. Neale points out that one moment when the film audience are allowed to look at men – and specifically at male bodies – as spectacle, is in the shoot-out of a Western film. These are ‘moments of spectacle, points at which the narrative hesitates, comes to a momentary halt, but they are also points at which the drama is finally resolved, a suspense in the culmination of the narrative drive’ (ibid.: 8). Male sexuality is commonly associated with aggression and violence, and Neale suggests that, within the shoot-out, there are structures that stop or punish erotic display. He argues that, in some Westerns, erotic looks by a male protagonist at another man result in sadomasochistic narratives (ibid.: 12). Sadism, as Laura Mulvey has pointed out: ‘demands a story, depends on making something happen, forcing a change in another person, a battle of will and strength, victory and defeat, all occurring in a linear time with a beginning and an end’ (1975: 14). What Mulvey describes here can, with a little adaptation, be applied to some male–female and male–male duets. Neale suggests that in Serge Leone’s Spaghetti Westerns the erotic component of the way the protagonists exchange aggressive looks during gun duels is also repressed and recuperated. This convention of exchanged looks is parodied through the use of extreme and repetitive close-ups, and thus the way that the film is edited makes the narrative start to freeze, and spectacle take over. As Mulvey observes, spectacle consists of: ‘stopping the narrative in order to recognise the pleasure of display, but displacing it from the male body as such and locating it more generally in the overall 47
THE MAL E DANCER
components of a highly ritualised scene’ (ibid.: 8). The dance example that most directly and knowingly draws on these filmic conventions is the knife fight between the two male rivals at the end of Carlos Saura’s dance film Blood Wedding (1981). This was, in effect, a male–male duet. Through a combination of mime and flamenco movement, the dancers alternated between a chilly male reserve, in which they managed to generate suspense around their latent, masculine potential for violence, and abrupt, carefully calculated, devastatingly brutal, rhythmic eruptions. The homoerotic component of their gaze, as they eyed one another, led to ritualised, slow motion penetration as, climactically, they knife each other. As Leo Bersani (1988) and others have argued, within Western culture, penetration signifies masculinity while being penetrated is a feminine position. Killing one another might be a tragic, no win situation, but it provides a powerful spectacle that seems to evoke natural, essential virility in a way that reinforces normative gender ideologies. Such male violence maintains a fantasy of men’s mastery and inviolability at the cost of denying their own vulnerability and ignoring that of others. The exchanges of looks between male protagonists in some of José Limón’s work, as I show in Chapter 4, seems to lead inevitably to fights between them. There were choreographed fights in many twentieth-century ballets and in US modern dance, and hard, warrior figures occurred in several of Ted Shawn’s works, also discussed in Chapter 4. The theme of male violence has been used as a guise for presenting a spectacle of the male dancer’s body because displays of fighting movement clearly use dancerly qualities which are appropriately masculine and thus unproblematic for the male dancer. DV8’s piece My Sex, Our Dance (1987) offers a useful counter example to this. Superficially, it seemed to present violent masculine struggle in a way that conformed to normative expectations but, in fact, subverted them by making visible and contesting the ‘naturalness’ of violent behaviour. It was performed in a high energy, risky dance style which conveyed the fraught and dangerous nature of male–male relationships. It started with Newson shaking hands with Charnock and then reaching out to touch him. Charnock flinched away from him and their interactions developed into a fight followed by a brooding truce and then more combat. Their interactions, therefore, explored the precarious line dividing, on the one hand, male bonding and trust and, on the other, fear and homophobia. The consequent tension erupted in violent sequences: one dancer hurled himself through the air backwards, sometimes to be caught but sometimes not; or they tripped one another up; or one hurled himself onto a mattress where the other was lying so that the latter had to roll out of the way. My Sex, Our Dance had no narrative closure. The dancers seemed trapped in endless cycles of struggle and truce. There was, however, one significant event in it. Newson has spoken of an incident, while making the piece, when he and Charnock had collapsed, worn out, lying one on top of the 48
LOOKING AT THE MALE
1
1
11
11
1
11
11 Figure 2.1 Lloyd Newson and Nigel Charnock in DV8’s My Sex, Our Dance, 1986. Photo © Eleni Leoussi.
11 49
THE MAL E DANCER
other on the mattress (Newson 1987). At this moment someone came into the rehearsal room and, seeing them lying there, was very embarrassed, excused themselves, and quickly left. This moment was worked into the finished piece. As it was performed in Britain, a heterosexual couple sat throughout the piece at a table in the far left, front corner of the performance space. They chatted quietly, sipping wine, and were apparently oblivious to the performance behind them. Stephanie Jordan describes them as: ‘the man and woman who canoodle and giggle at the café table on the stage’s edge and openly express their lighter attachment’ (1987: 23). At the moment when Newson collapsed exhausted on top of Charnock lying on the mattress, the woman at the table laughed. Although she was apparently laughing at something unrelated to what Charnock and Newson were doing, it exacerbated unease at their physical contact. The piece, therefore, maintained its excruciating tension throughout. It made the spectator long for a resolution: why couldn’t the two men develop an emotional intimacy? Why did they keep fighting one another when they both seemed to want the same things? But the only options for narrative resolution are tragic ones, as in Blood Wedding and Monument For A Dead Boy. Just at the moment when a temporary resolution seemed possible, as Charnock and Newson lay together exhausted on the mattress, the couple’s laughter intervened, breaking the men’s intimacy and reminding spectators how straight society views behaviour such as this. So, a lack of narrative resolution, on one level, produces critical awareness on another one. To see the piece as a whole as a plea for greater tolerance towards sexual minorities is, I think, to miss the point. Like much of DV8’s work, which I discuss in more detail in Chapter 7, it was a critique of masculinity as such, of men’s institutionalised fear of emotional intimacy, of the maintenance of tight physical boundaries around male bodies. My Sex, Our Dance revealed what the German writer Klaus Theweleit, in another context, called men’s ‘protective psychological body armour which functions as a dam to stop the flow of pleasurable sensation’ (1987: 434). Much of the literature about DV8 praises the company for their brave expression of the ‘truth’ about gender and sexuality (e.g. Winter 1989, Mackrell 1992). I would like to suggest, instead, that My Sex, Our Dance exemplified queer performativity, both in its citation of the trope of choreographed male fighting, and by putting in quotation marks the straight behaviour of its extras. What was, therefore, significant about this piece was its use of these performative citations to make visible the way normative gender ideologies are naturalised. Like other works I will discuss in later chapters, it denaturalised what might ordinarily appear normal male behaviour by making it appear problematic and extreme. The moment in My Sex, Our Dance when Charnock flinched as Newson attempted to touch him generated an affective sense of shame. Like other
50
LOOKING AT THE MALE
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
male–male duets that I discuss in later chapters, it transgressed the blurred and ambiguous line between appropriate and inappropriate male relationships. The danced relationship between Charnock and Newson seemed shameful because it revealed a failure to maintain tight physical boundaries around male bodies. As in other pieces I discuss in later chapters, My Sex, Our Dance showed men performing roles that appeared hysterical and ecstatic, and were haunted by the spectre of male failure. Failure to appear a proper man can be caused by failure to appear in control of oneself, or to seem overwhelmed by the tensions and contradictions within socially constructed male norms. The performance of failure neither reaches out to spectators to claim their attention nor leaves them to become absorbed in the piece in their own individual way. What is disconcerting is that, in effect, it fails to attain either state. Such ambiguous performances, nevertheless, have the potential to challenge the idea that masculinity is an unproblematic, unquestioned norm by their refusal to assert male mastery. In My Sex, Our Dance, this refusal operated both at the level of individual performances and within the choreographic structure as a whole which lacked narrative closure. Where choreographers refuse conventional narrative closure, as in My Sex, Our Dance, this can be seen as a deliberate rejection of a certain kind of Romantic pose which, as I noted in the first chapter, is associated with the notion of male genius. Christine Battersby (1989) has described the Romantic (male) genius battling against nature and engaging in an organic struggle to create a whole, a oneness, through his mastery of a sublime and terrifying (male) nature. Following Battersby, a male choreographer, during the rehearsal period, might be said to master his material by pulling it together into a coherent whole, while a male dancer can do the same through a masterful interpretation of awkward, difficult material in performance. If he can achieve this, he will seem to affirm his masculinity, whereas the same achievement for a female choreographer or dancer would not have the same positive connotations. A male genius, as Battersby has pointed out, is allowed to have feminine characteristics of sensitivity and emotionality, and his special status allows him to risk being considered slightly mad: ‘but a female viewed as hysterical and ecstatic has to fight off a much more mundane kind of cultural nonentity’ (1989: 145). It is in this context that the abstract structures of some experimental dances, that I discuss in later chapters, can challenge gender norms. Choreographers such as Cunningham and Paxton have investigated neutral, fragmented structures, while others, such as Brown and de Keersmaeker, have explored minimalist ones. The use of such structures constitutes a refusal to impose control in a masterful way and create an organic, unified whole. Alternative, anti-hierarchical choreographic structures open up new, egalitarian ways of thinking about social relations.
11 51
THE MAL E DANCER
BLACK MALE DANCING BODIES AND WHITENESS During a particularly interesting and revealing roundtable discussion about dance and gender in 1988, the African American choreographer Bill T. Jones presented a black artist’s perspective on the relation between performer and spectator. The other participants in the discussion were the choreographer Johanna Boyce and performance scholars Ann Daly and Carol Martin. While articulating perceptions about the experience of dancing which influenced her work, Boyce told Jones she imagined that being on display is a fearful thing for a man because it is a situation in which he doesn’t ‘have total control or empowerment’ over the people watching him (Boyce et al. 1988: 89). Jones said that, as a black man on stage being watched primarily by white spectators he felt that his state in the world was that of being ‘such a marginal, “special black” ’. He felt that he was a ‘commodity’ and that this ‘must be a feeling that women have’ (ibid.: 90–1). For Jones: There is something about the spectators saying, in effect ‘Perform for us. Show us your body’. So it made me extremely aggressive, and maybe that was my desire to impose masculine control – I also assume it was racial . . . It was a cruel and ironic way that I saw myself. You know: you’re a black man – take off your shirt. You’re allowed to wiggle your hips in public. You know what they’re all thinking, ‘Oh, I bet you have a dick down to your knees’. (Ibid.: 89–90) Some of the pressures which Jones identifies in this quotation about the need to be aggressive and impose masculine control concur with the general experience of male dancers as I have been discussing it in this chapter. But some of what he is saying, as Jones himself points out, is specifically concerned with black male experience. It reinforces the stereotype of the over-sexed black stud, and it also relates to African American history: Jones has often spoken about black slaves as commodities being forced to dance on the auction block (e.g. 1995: 73–4). What he was telling the other participants in the discussion was that, in a similar way to the black film spectator that Fanon discussed, he felt interpellated into performing a narrowly defined role that was not of his own making. Jones’s observations about being a marginal ‘special black’ recall Isaac Julien and Kobena Mercer’s discussion the same year about the peculiar restrictions that black film directors and casts face. Because so few black films are made compared with films by white directors: each film is burdened with an inordinate pressure to be ‘representative’ and to act, like a delegate does, as a statement that ‘speaks’ for the 52
LOOKING AT THE MALE
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
black communities as a whole (. . .) This of course underlines the problem of tokenism: the very idea that a single film could ‘speak for’ an entire community of interests reinforces the perceived secondariness of that community. (1988: 4) The work of black artists such as Bill T. Jones and Alvin Ailey can often seem to be caught in this trap of tokenist representativeness. As Susan Manning has noted, black and white critics have interpreted Ailey’s flagship work Revelations (1960) – which I discuss in Chapter 5 – in different ways: ‘Whereas many white critics emphasize the universality of the frame of mythic abstraction, many black critics emphasize the frame of historical and cultural specificity’ (Manning 2004: 219). Performance scholar Peggy Phelan’s notion of the unmarked is relevant here. Commenting on the agenda adopted by some artists and performers to generate increased visibility for minorities and marginalised groups, Phelan has drawn attention to certain dangers this might bring. Visibility, she observes, is a trap: ‘it summons surveillance and the law; it provokes voyeurism, fetishism, the colonial/imperial appetite for possession’ (1993: 6). Although underrepresented communities can be empowered by an enhanced visibility, Phelan points out ‘there is real power in remaining unmarked’ (ibid.). Clearly white, male, heterosexual men generally enjoy the privilege of being unmarked; but at the same time to be unmarked is to be without properties. Where white masculinity as a universal, is sometimes associated with blankness and can seem lacking in character, white ideas about the black, male, dancing body can sometimes hint at envy. As Richard Dyer has pointed out in his discussion of Paul Robeson: Black and white discourses on blackness seem to be valuing the same things – spontaneity, emotion, naturalness – yet giving them a different implication. Black discourses see them as contributions to the development of society, white as enviable qualities that only blacks have. (1987: 79) I discuss how Jones has dealt with this through his own work in Chapters 6 and 8. Just as I argued in the first chapter that homosexuality is fundamental to the construction of masculinity as the internally excluded difference, so black masculinity occupies an equally central position in relation to the construction of an unmarked, white, universal notion of masculinity. It is not just necessary to be aware of the kinds of factor that Jones raised during the roundtable discussion when considering performances by black male dancing bodies, but that there is also a need to analyse critically the whiteness of white, male, dancing bodies. 53
THE MAL E DANCER
MASCULINITY AND PRESENCE The theoretical framework I have been developing for analysing relations between male dancers and spectators has taken as its starting point ideas about the male gaze. I have examined what happens when some of the questions asked about the objectification of the female body are applied to the male dancing body. Some dance scholars, in the late 1980s and early 1990s, applied feminist ideas about the male gaze to dance analysis (Alderson 1987; Goldberg 1987–8; Dempster 1988; Daly 1989; Adair 1992). Subsequent scholarship has adopted a more critical or sceptical attitude (Jordan and Thomas 1994; Manning 1997; Thomas 2003), while Ann Daly’s gradual move away from feminist theory and ideas about the male gaze can be followed in her retrospective collection (2002). Rather than rejecting these ideas altogether, as many dance scholars seem to have done, my approach in this chapter has been to modify them in order to revise feminist accounts of spectatorship in dance. In doing so, I have focused on the way the spectacular aspects of men’s dancing generally reinforce conservative norms of masculine behaviour. I have, therefore, concentrated on the visual aspects of the process of perceiving dance. These ideas about spectacle and spectatorship form the basis for most of the discussions in the rest of this book. Spectators, nevertheless, interpret many aspects of dance performance through relating what dancers are doing to their own embodied experience. Some dance scholars, in writing about recent experimental dance performances, have theorised the presence rather than the visual appearance of the dancing body. For Ann Daly, presence is the core of the pleasure of watching dance: ‘Presence is the silent yet screeching excitement of physical vibrancy, of “being there”. It is one of the thrills of watching dance, to see someone radiate pure energy, whether it is in stillness or in flight’ (1989: 25). Experimental works in which dancers’ physical presence overrides the spectacular aspects of dance performance, as I show in later chapters, can sometimes trouble and subvert dominant gender ideologies to stage alternative ways of performing masculinities. Susan Manning, in her review of dance scholarship which uses ideas about the male gaze, argues that modern dance (though not ballet) has ‘projected a kinaesthetic power that challenged male viewers to see the female dancer as an expressive subject rather than as an erotic object’ (1997: 163). Along similar lines, Ann Cooper Albright has argued that it is through creating a powerful physical presence that dancers such as Isadora Duncan and Yvonne Rainer were able to resist being objectified as women by a voyeuristic male gaze. Duncan’s charismatic dancing made her audience share her experience of dancing, thus stopping them objectifying it as erotic spectacle. The clarity of Rainer’s radical analysis of ordinary movement in her Trio A had a similar effect by bringing her audience’s attention to the process of ‘making and remaking the self through movement’ (Albright 1997: 19). 54
LOOKING AT THE MALE
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
It is, of course, not Albright’s aim to consider how the male dancing body can resist being eroticised by a viewer’s gaze, but it is revealing to apply her observations about female dancers to the situation of male dancers. The kind of female presence that Albright believes is empowering for women has very different effects when exercised by male dancers. Where a male dancer creates a powerful physical presence he dominates and masters the audience in a way that, I have argued, may escape an eroticising gaze but does so by conforming to conservative norms of masculine behaviour. Trio A, which was first performed in 1966 at Judson Memorial Church by Rainer, Steve Paxton, and David Gordon, is an avant-garde work which, in my opinion, distances audiences by challenging and disrupting normal habits of watching dance. Paxton’s Flat (1964), which I discuss in Chapter 5, involved a radical examination of ordinary movement that paralleled Rainer’s investigations. Rather than creating a strong presence by bringing his audience’s attention to the process of making and remaking a masculine subjectivity through movement, which is what Albright said Rainer’s dancing achieved, Paxton’s work was marked by troubling absences – and I would argue Rainer’s work was similarly troubling. The lack of a reassuring presence in such work made audience members become aware of their own activities as observers. This is a necessary precondition for developing ways of seeing masculinity and femininity differently. Both Albright and Daly (1989) see presence as an affective relation between dancer and spectator, and view strong presence as more desirable and valuable than weak presence because the former can affirm gendered identity. This, however, doesn’t address Phelan’s point that ‘there is real power in remaining unmarked’ (1993: 6). In Phelan’s view, performance’s ontology is its disappearance, which teaches us ‘to learn to value what is lost, to learn not the meaning but the value of what cannot be reproduced or seen (again)’ (ibid.: 152). She points out that it is the presence of the living bodies of the performers that cannot be saved or recorded. The specificity of performance, she has reminded us, is its liveness: ‘Performance’s only life is in the present. Performance cannot be saved, recorded, or otherwise participate in the circulation of representations of representations’ (ibid.: 146). Presence and absence are not binary opposites. In Phelan’s account there are always presences and absences in operation during performance. The implications of this become clear when Phelan applies it to the work of feminist performance artists such as Adrian Piper, Sophie Calle, and Angelica Festa. All these artists have used absence and disappearance to create a space for the performance of aspects of women’s experience that cannot be represented within cultural representation because this only permits the reproduction of male sex and gender. Some female choreographers, as I show in subsequent chapters, have also used absences as a way of representing aspects of their perceptions of masculinity that 55
THE MAL E DANCER
cannot be represented within the norms and conventions of mainstream theatre dance. This is also the case where some men’s experiences, both straight- and gay-identified, cannot be represented. Absence and disappearance can, therefore, be powerful, in troubling or uncanny ways, where they draw attention to gaps and limitations within normative cultural representation. André Lepecki proposes that: ‘critical theories of dancing practices must consider how it is that “presence” challenges the very stability of “the body” ’ (2004: 6). I take this to mean that, by troubling and undoing the simple binary of presence or absence in order to realise a multiplicity of presences, dance performance can challenge the processes of social and cultural construction that render some bodies marked and others unmarked. The kinds of presence that dancers project and the absences they call to mind determine the ideological positions that spectators can take up in relation to the performance. They, therefore, both enable and restrict the ways in which embodied memories and histories, that are shared by performer and spectator, are evoked during performance. The kinds of memory and history that are evoked have the potential to either reinforce or destabilise constricting cultural discourse that only permit the reproduction of male sex and gender. For example, Martin Hargreaves (2000) has argued that the male swans in Matthew Bourne’s version of Swan Lake (1995) are haunted by the absence of the bodies of the female swans in the classic, late nineteenth-century ballet. Casting male dancers in these roles would not be significant if the swans in Swan Lake had not up until then been feminine. (I discuss Bourne’s Swan Lake in Chapter 7.) Hargreaves (2000, 2004) suggests that ghosts (emanations that are simultaneously both present and absent) from past performances and of past performers are often a factor brought into play as spectators watch and interpret live performance. These ghosts create a dialectic of difference between present and past that impacts on the performance of gender. In this way both male and female dancing bodies have the potential to destabilise norms. I have been arguing that the potential for male dancing bodies to do this underlies anxieties about the male dancer, but, as I show in later chapters, the trouble that he sometimes causes can also have positive consequences. CONCLUSION I have outlined in these first two chapters a general framework for analysing theatre dance as a signifying practice which mediates hegemonic gender ideologies. The constraints and restrictions placed on male dancing bodies, which I have identified in this chapter, correspond with the problematic and conflictual elements within the construction of masculine subjectivities that I outlined in the first chapter. In theatre dance, therefore, the acceptable 56
LOOKING AT THE MALE
1
1
11
male dancer is one who, when looked at by the audience, proves that he measures up to supposedly unproblematic male ideals: he looks actively at his female partner or upwards in an uplifting way; he appears powerful, uses large, expansive movements, but is stoical rather than emotionally expressive; he controls, displays, and forces changes in women dancers in duets. Some choreographers, however, have been able to problematise and disrupt normative conventions to produce works which challenge dominant norms of gendered behaviour. The qualities that make a male dancer appear acceptable can sometimes be used in a denaturalising and destabilising way. To dismantle the concept of the dominant male point of view, and to consider how representations of masculinity in theatre dance appear to spectators who look from other points of view, is to read dance against the grain of the generally accepted account of dance history. It is this revisionist view of dance history that underpins the analyses offered in the rest of this book.
11
1
11
11
11 57
3 NIJINSKY
Vaslav Nijinsky (1889–1950) is a key figure in the reintroduction of the male ballet dancer to the stages of European theatres at the beginning of the twentieth century, and for initiating and developing representations of masculinity that have dominated ballet and even, to some extent, modern dance throughout the century. From reminiscences of the first performance of Diaghilev’s Ballets Russes in Paris in 1909, it is clear that Nijinsky became a star over night, and he went on to become probably the most famous dancer of the twentieth century. Nijinsky was the first international superstar of the globalised media, and then became the first superstar to find the pressures so unbearable that he suffered a breakdown. He was the first male dancer to challenge conservative nineteenth-century gender ideologies, becoming retrospectively a gay icon. For the twentyfirst-century reader, Nijinsky indeed has become what Marcia Siegel calls ‘an unknowable, infinitely manipulable presence in the dance universe’ (2002: 3). This chapter considers the legacy which has come down to us in the name of ‘Nijinsky’. Nijinsky the man and dance artist played the key role in transforming ideas about the male dancer, but it is also necessary to acknowledge the parts that other individuals, organisations, audiences, and writers have played in this transformation. What the Ballets Russes contributed to the development of representations of masculinity in theatre dance is easier to map out. The tradition of male partnering in the pas de deux was reintroduced to the West. The company’s first programme in Paris in 1909 included the Blue Bird pas de deux from Sleeping Beauty, showing Petipa’s development of the supported adagio (i.e. a duet with lifts).1 In 1910 Diaghilev included Giselle (in the Moscow version) in his programme of ballets. European ballet audiences realised that the pas de deux had not looked right without a good male partner, and Nijinsky was certainly that, though some might have argued that Mikhail Mordkin (1880–1944), also with the Ballets Russes that season, was as good. In addition, the Polovtsian Dances in the opera Prince Igor similarly showed Western audiences what they had been missing since the male corps de ballets in western European theatres had been disbanded in the mid-nineteenth century. 58
NIJINSK Y
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
All this is probably not what comes to mind when the pre-1914 Ballets Russes is mentioned. This is the period of exotic ballets, with the ‘new’ choreography by Fokine (1880–1942) and costumes and sets by Bakst (1866–1924) and Benois (1870–1960), that showcased Nijinsky’s talents. Lynn Garafola has argued that Diaghilev in effect dethroned the ballerina in his desire to create works that celebrated the masculine body beautiful (1999: 248). There was no precedent in European theatre dance history for a piece such as Fokine’s Le Spectre de la rose in which the male role (Nijinsky’s) is clearly the central one and the female dancer (initially Karsavina) plays a fantasising spectator’s role. These roles extended ideas about male dancing in daring ways. Clearly Diaghilev (1872–1929) brought about the creation of these ballets to show off his lover’s talents. While Diaghilev’s pleasure at the spectacle of male dancing bodies was a factor in developing male dance, Nijinsky’s dancing didn’t just appeal to female and homosexual male spectators. He was a star; and performers, as Richard Dyer (1979, 1987) has pointed out, only become stars because their persona appeals to broad cross-sections of the general public. Nijinsky’s persona was a construction that helped towards the success of the Ballets Russes project as a whole. Diaghilev, as Garafola (1989) points out, was a brilliant publicist. What the public took to be ‘Nijinsky’ should therefore be thought of as a continuum between his onstage roles and his interpretation of them, the style of the pieces he himself choreographed, and the image of him generated for publicity purposes. Fokine, who choreographed most of Nijinsky’s new roles, appears to have left dancers a very free hand in interpreting and fleshing out the bare skeleton of the choreography that he had indicated to them.2 While Fokine enjoyed a certain autonomy, he would have been working to a scenario and within the constraints of commissioned or arranged music. Diaghilev and his associates would already have indicated very specific ideas about the piece before Fokine actually got to the rehearsal room, and they would have taken an active interest in the ballet’s progress. The visual artists themselves contributed to the way Nijinsky’s roles mediated his gender. The posters and deluxe souvenir programmes moulded his image as did the costumes they created for him. There is the jewelled male brassiere designed by Bakst which Nijinsky wore in Schéhérazade (1910), or the Bakst costumes in Narcisse and Le Dieu bleu, which, as Garafola suggests, with their: ‘abbreviated skirt, sharply demarcated waist, exposed collarbones and shoulders teased conventions of masculinity’ (1989: 39). Nijinsky did more than just create the central roles in these exotic ballets. His own choreography contributed towards the development of modernism and neo-classicism in ballet. Through the choreographic innovations that he introduced and his sister Bronislava Nijinska (1891–1972) developed, ways of representing gender were developed which were much more radical and critical than those of Fokine. While the roles he created within Fokine’s 59
THE MAL E DANCER
choreography challenged existing gender ideologies, the avant-garde modernism of his own and his sister’s choreography constituted a more radical assault on normative gender ideologies. Part of what is so interesting about Nijinsky is that he did things in dance that no one had, up until then, considered possible. I noted in Chapter 2 Steve Neale’s thesis that the male body cannot be marked explicitly as the erotic object of another male look and is feminised if it is the erotic object of a female look. But can this idea be applied to the comparatively innocent pre-1914 audiences who watched Nijinsky dance? There is some evidence in Ballets Russes’ critical reception of unease at some of Nijinsky’s performances but there is scant evidence from that decade which suggests critics or commentators were aware of the possibility that women or gay men could look at his dancing body in an eroticised way. As I will show, it is only in the 1920s that gender and sexuality started to become a focused issue in discussions of his sister’s and Jean Börlin’s ballets. This chapter, therefore, examines representations of masculinity in Fokine’s ballets and in Nijinsky’s own choreography, then ends with a briefer discussion of how things changed in the 1920s. BALLETS RUSSES AND HOMOSEXUALITY The reintroduction of the male dancer to the European theatre stage in 1909 in new and sometimes unorthodox images came at a time when there was much discussion and widespread insecurity about the nature of male identity. As Amy Koritz notes: ‘That this shift occurred despite the homosexual orientation of the Diaghilev circle, and after the Wilde trials increased the danger for homosexuals, makes it all the more extraordinary’ (Koritz 1995: 131). It was a time when the feminist movement was emerging and middle class women were becoming powerful in their roles as consumers and as patrons of the arts. It was also a time when, as Jeffrey Weeks has shown (1977, 1985), men who were sexually attracted to other men were thinking about themselves using the newly defined category of homosexual, a term that was first used in English in 1892. In this context, the project of the Ballets Russes spanned contradictory extremes, as Diaghilev and his choreographers struggled to discover whether the codes of conventional masculine behaviour would encourage or suppress their artistic expression. Paradoxically, it was at this time of complex and somewhat contradictory changes that it became possible, within the field of ballet, to create these new, unorthodox representations of masculinity. The audiences who saw the Ballets Russes in those years were very different from those who in the middle years of the nineteenth century had rejected the male dancer. The latter were almost exclusively male. In nineteenth-century Paris, these were the young men about town, members of the Paris Jockey Club, for whom an entré to the loges and meeting 60
NIJINSK Y
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
spaces at the Opera House was a means of meeting available females (Guest 1966: 28; Garafola 1985: 36; see also Nochlin 1991: 75–94). Diaghilev’s audiences up until 1914, as Lynn Garafola (1989) points out, were the élite of society, artists, and those who, by supporting his enterprise, gained entry to that élite.3 Chief among his supporters were women: Misia Edwards (later Sert), the Marchioness of Ripon, Lady Ottoline Morrell, Lady Juliet Duff, Margot Asquith, Lady Cunard, and later Coco Chanel. The very high quality of the Ballets Russes productions and the technical accomplishments of individual dancers, together with Diaghilev’s legendary skills as publicist, lent respectability to his company’s challenging, new representations of masculinity. In addition to this, the increasingly significant female constituency in the audience clearly enjoyed watching male dancers and Nijinsky in particular.4 Suzanne Moore has argued in relation to the female gaze that ‘the codification of men via gay discourse enables a female erotic gaze’ (1988: 53), and Nijinsky’s dancing would seem a clear example of this. The many prominent figures in the audience who were homosexual would also have been appreciative of Nijinsky’s performance: for example Cocteau, Compte Robert de Montesquiou, Proust, Lytton Strachey, and Maynard Keynes. A second factor that permitted the creation by the Ballets Russes of challenging, new representations of masculinity, was the Russian-ness of those involved. In Britain, prevalent concerns about the decline in masculine norms focused on the frailty of English or Western men. Nijinsky and the male dancers in the Ballets Russes were neither. One English magazine commented thus on the popularity in London society of the Ballets Russes: We want to know the truth about these semi-Asiatic and semiEuropean people . . . Of this [Victorian] disease of super-civilisation these Russians are emphatically free . . . they are pagan with the pure untroubled paganism of the healthy child. (Quoted in Chadd and Gage 1979: 22)5 The Victorian disease was degeneracy and decadence. As I discussed in the first chapter, there was, at the time, a widespread debate about the way this ‘super-civilisation’ was causing modern European men to lose touch with their ‘essential’, ‘natural’ masculinity (Kimmell 1987). As some scholars have noted, contemporary writing about the Ballets Russes suggests that semiAsiatic and semi-European Russians were considered to be closer to an essential, ‘primitive’ virility than the average English man, and thus male Russian dancers were, to western European eyes at least, partly exempted from some of the restrictions of Victorian gender norms. One great, but largely unmentioned, source of fear about masculinity during this period was homosexuality. Jeffrey Weeks has argued that the strong homosocial relationships between men during the nineteenth century were deeply ambivalent and became increasingly dangerous for the 61
THE MAL E DANCER
respectable as awareness of homosexuality grew (Weeks 1977; Richards 1987). The Oscar Wilde trials had brought about a new and widespread public awareness of homosexuality, and between the 1890s and the end of the First World War extensive legislative and medical attempts were made to define and control homosexuality (Foucault 1979; Weeks 1986). This brought about a new awareness among men who were homosexual of a sense of identity arising from their sexual preferences, and of the existence and vulnerability of other homosexual men with whom they might have something in common (Weeks 1977). It was on the strength of their reception in Paris that the Ballets Russes’ reputation was founded. Under the Code Napoleon, sex between men was not illegal in France from 1792 until 1942. Many literary figures in France during the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries were homosexual and the Arts generally enjoyed a greater prestige in France than in Britain. Attitudes towards sexual mores were more relaxed in France than in England at the time, and there was a little more tolerance of homosexuality – it was, for instance, to France that Oscar Wilde went for refuge after his release from Reading Gaol. Many French doctors, like their colleagues in other Western countries, nevertheless considered homosexuality to be an illness. There is no particular association of homosexuality with ballet prior to the time of the Ballets Russes. It was only with Diaghilev that ballet became an area in which homosexual men became involved as artists and as audiences, and that a homosexual approach developed to the appreciation and interpretation of ballet. Diaghilev’s artistic affiliations (prior to his adoption of a more avant-garde approach on the eve of the First World War) were with the fin de siècle aesthetic and art nouveau movements in the Arts, and with an ideology of art for art’s sake. He seems to have gone out of his way to meet Oscar Wilde and Beardsley (Buckle 1975: 65), publishing one of the latter’s drawings in his magazine Mir Ikusstva (‘The World of Art’). How much he consciously acknowledged a specifically homosexual contribution to these artistic movements is not known. No one writing about the development of homosexual identity in the early years of the twentieth century has yet considered the role played by ballet, but the promotion of the male ballet dancer by Diaghilev and the development of new unorthodox images by Nijinsky must have had some impact on this development. Nijinsky’s homosexuality is sometimes played down or discounted. His sister Nijinska, in her Early Memoirs (1981), mentions a few of Nijinsky’s infatuations with young girls in St Petersburg while he was a student. In the diaries which Nijinsky wrote in 1919, while becoming increasingly unstable, there are accounts of meetings with female prostitutes in Paris and St Petersburg. He also hinted at his initial reluctance to give himself sexually to Diaghilev (Acocella 1999: 104); but he nevertheless noted: ‘I 62
NIJINSK Y
1
1
11
11
1
11
loved [Diaghilev] sincerely, and when he used to tell me that love for women was a terrible thing, I believed him’ (ibid.: 111). According to Anton Dolin, Diaghilev disliked obvious homosexuality and hated any signs of effeminacy (Dolin 1985: 50). Kevin Kopelson begins his book, The Queer Afterlife of Vaslav Nijinsky, by acknowledging that Nijinsky didn’t consider himself homosexual (1997: 2). Nevertheless, during the period 1909–13 Diaghilev’s artist collaborators and his close associates, who helped with the creation of Fokine and Nijinsky’s ballets, knew that Nijinsky was Diaghilev’s sexual partner. It therefore seems reasonable to take this into consideration where it is relevant and useful in looking at his work. The vast majority of those who saw Nijinsky would have had no idea of his relationship with Diaghilev. Nijinsky’s roles in Fokine’s ballets, despite their unorthodox representations of masculinity, could have been interpreted from a normative point of view. From this point of view, their male prowess, Nijinsky’s male ‘genius’, and his ballets’ archaic, exotic, or ‘oriental’ distance would have appeared acceptable. At the same time men who were homosexual and some heterosexual women watched Nijinsky dancing and appreciated the spectacle of male sexuality this presented. This was, I suggest, an example of what Stuart Hall has called a negotiated reading (see Chapter 2) that ‘accords the privileged position to the dominant definitions of events while reserving the right to make a more negotiated application of “local conditions”’ (1993: 102). Local conditions, here, were the tastes and interests of a minority group of rich, cultured, and educated men who were attracted to good-looking men. These conditions enabled female spectatorship. In my view, Nijinsky’s L’Après midi d’un faune and Le Sacre du printemps, and, following the First World War, his sister Nijinska’s Les Noces, rather than negotiating a subversive definition of normative gender ideologies, presented a more direct challenge to them because of their avant-garde nature. To demonstrate this, I will therefore consider differences between representations of masculinity in Fokine and Nijinsky’s ballets, and then examine representations of masculinity in modernist ballets from the early 1920s. MALE PROWESS IN NIJINSKY’S ROLES
11
11
A much reproduced drawing by Jean Cocteau shows Nijinsky in the wings after Le Spectre de la rose (Figure 3.1). Like a boxer between bouts, he lies back exhausted on a chair holding a glass of water while Vassili, Diaghilev’s valet, fans him with a towel. In the background, looking concerned, are Diaghilev, Bakst, and Misia Edwards (later Sert) and her husband. Part of the mythology about Nijinsky concerns his incredible leap out through the window at the end of this piece, and, in general, the extraordinary agility and elevation of his jumps. It would appear that Cocteau’s drawing is not a total invention, as Marie Rambert describes the scene in her 63
THE MAL E DANCER
autobiography.6 Fokine, however, talked down Nijinsky’s leap (1961: 180–1). Anton Dolin claims that he had danced most of Nijinsky’s roles, either with the Ballets Russes or subsequently, and with many dancers from the original casts. In his opinion Nijinsky’s roles were not that demanding technically. This is perhaps to miss a crucial point about the attitude towards technical feats shared by Nijinsky, Pavlova, Fokine, and other dancers of their generation from the Imperial Theatres. They disliked the tours de forces performed by the older generation of ballerinas and male dancers, feeling that these looked mechanical and were unsympathetic to the creation of an artistic feeling in performance. (But the younger dancers had all been trained to perform and all did perform the virtuoso roles in the Petipa repertoire.) Bronislava Nijinska, in her Early Memoirs, gives us several very detailed accounts of her brother’s performances and how he prepared for them. She tells how his daily practice was geared towards developing his strength and that he would practise much more difficult feats than were needed for his roles. She also says that he would practise to minimise the preparations for jumps, and that he worked at finding how to land softly afterwards, so that, when he was on stage, his performance would appear effortless and flowing. The description that Rebecca West gives us of the effect is echoed in many other accounts: The climax of his art was his jump. He leaped high into the air, and there stayed for what seemed several seconds. Face and body suggested that he was to mount still further, do the Indian rope trick with himself as rope, hurl himself up into space through an invisible ceiling and disappear. But then he came down – and here was the second miracle – more slowly than he had gone up, landing as softly as a deer clearing a hedge of snow. (Quoted in Buckle 1975: 390) It would seem that Nijinsky did possess extraordinary strength and agility but that this was accompanied by hard work at creating an illusion of effortlessness. As Nijinska remarked: ‘Do you remember how many transitions, how many nuances there were during the course of his leap? These transitions and nuances created the illusion that he never touched the ground’ (1986: 86). What all this amounts to is that whatever Dolin may have believed, Nijinsky did produce a spectacle of famed and mythologised strength and agility on stage. While it was Diaghilev who commissioned these roles, it was Fokine who came up with the steps. As Garafola (1989) points out, Fokine is a transitional figure between the nineteenth-century ballet tradition and twentieth-century modernism. Judging by survivals such as Le Spectre de la rose (1911), or from descriptions of ballets such as Narcisse (1911), as far as the steps of Nijinsky’s solos are concerned, these were fairly traditional. Compared with Nijinsky’s subsequent innovations, Fokine’s 64
NIJINSK Y
1
1
11
11
1
11
11 Figure 3.1 ’Memories of the Ballets Russes: backstage after Le Spectre de la rose’. From Jean Cocteau, Dessins, 1923. © ADAGP, Paris, and DACS, London 2006.
11 65
THE MAL E DANCER
choreography is conventional, in phrasing and use of space. Aided by Fokine and Nijinsky’s musicality, jumps and effects co-ordinate with appropriate musical climaxes, while, spatially, there are circles that boldly encompass the stage, and strong diagonals to give Nijinsky the appearance of mastering the space, and, by doing so, dominating the audience. These are devices for displaying traditional male virtuosity. Steve Neale, as I observed in Chapter 1, proposed that whereas women are a mystery to be investigated and exposed, men are tested. The evidence suggests that in these virtuosic roles, Nijinsky passed the test. Fokine himself was keen to dance Nijinsky’s roles in 1914 after the latter’s break with Diaghilev and the company. Fokine’s male solos clearly conformed to conventional expectations of male strength and prowess, and supported the notion that the Russian male dancers were less tainted by civilisation and more in touch with ‘natural’ masculinity than their Western contemporaries. In Michael Fried’s terms these were ‘theatrical’ ballets (see Chapter 2): Fokine was an extraordinarily skilled and innovative storyteller, and the roles he created for Nijinsky invited spectators to identify with him. Nijinsky’s own ballets, as I shall show, exemplified what Fried called absorption. NIJINSKY AS GENIUS Nijinsky was not just famous for his strength, agility, and for his exceptional skill in partnering a ballerina. He was also hailed for his extraordinary expressiveness and the uncanny way he ‘got into’ his roles. His performance as Petrouchka is the prime example of this. The action of the ballet Petrouchka (1911) was set during a Lenten carnival fair in St Petersburg during the 1840s. The opening section was a big crowd scene full of incidental events leading up to the performance of three magic puppets – Petrouchka, the Doll (initially Karsavina) and the Moor (Orlov in blackface) – all controlled by the menacing Magician (initially Cecchetti). The second scene showed Petrouchka thrown by the Magician into his celllike box, miming his hatred for the Magician, and getting over-excited when the latter brings his love, the Doll, into his room. His innocence, Garafola suggests, contrasted with her knowledge. Disappointed or frightened by Petrouchka’s antics, she hastily retreated. The next scene showed the Moor to be equally incapable of responding to the Doll when she came into his cell. But, when Petrouchka came in after her, the Moor, enraged, gave chase. The final scene showed the fair ground, this time in full swing at night. Eventually the carousing of the crowd was interrupted by Petrouchka emerging from the Magician’s booth chased by the Moor who, in turn, is followed by the Doll. Before a stunned crowd, the Moor killed Petrouchka (Figure 3.2). When a merchant called a Guardian of the Peace, the Magician showed that Petrouchka was just an inanimate puppet and all dispersed except for the Magician. As the music ended, Petrouchka’s 66
NIJINSK Y
1
1
11
11 Figure 3.2 The death of Petrouchka: Adolf Bolm as the Moor, Tamara Karsavina as the Doll, and Nijinsky as Petrouchka in costume as the Faune. Photo Karl Struss, New York 1916. Courtesy of Jerome Robbins Dance Division, The New York Public Library for the Performing Arts, Astor, Lenox, and Tilden Foundations.
1 ghost appeared on top of the booth to frighten the Magician by frantically waving his arms. Nijinsky’s role contained both dynamic dancing and demanding mime. His sister, Nijinska, records: 11
11
11
When Petrouchka dances, his body remains the body of a doll; only the tragic eyes reflect his emotions, burning with passion or dimming with pain. . . . Petrouchka dances as if he is using only the heavy wooden parts of his body. Only the swinging, mechanical, soul-less motions jerk the sawdust-filled arms or legs upwards in extravagant movements to indicate transports of joy or despair. . . . Vaslav is astonishing in the unusual technique of his dance, and in the expressiveness of his body. In Petrouchka, Vaslav jumps as high as ever and executes as many pirouettes and tours en l’air as he usually does, even though his petrouchkian wooden feet do not have the flexibility of a dancer’s feet. (1981: 373–4) It was for his dramatic expressiveness in roles such as Petrouchka and the sensuality of his performance of roles such as the Golden Slave in Schéhérazade 67
THE MAL E DANCER
(1910), as well as for his technical abilities, that Nijinsky was acclaimed as a genius. As Christine Battersby has argued (see Chapter 1), the idea of genius has, sometimes, been invoked to allow male artists to give expression to emotions that, over the last two centuries, have been characterised as feminine. But genius is also close to madness. In Nijinsky’s case, it becomes, in the hands of some writers, a back-handed compliment. Prince Peter Lieven, for example, suggested: I think the neatest and at the same time the truest estimate of Nijinsky’s intellect was given me by Misia Sert, one of Diaghilev’s best friends. She called him an ‘idiot of genius’. This is no paradox. In our enthusiasm over the ‘entity of genius’ our admiration goes to the dancer’s creative instincts and not to the conception of his brain, as for example, his role in Petrouchka. (1980: 89) In 1941, Alexandre Benois was even more dismissive of Nijinsky’s intelligence. For him Nijinsky was someone who only came alive for the stage: ‘Having put on his costume, he gradually began to change into another being, the one he saw in the mirror. . . . The fact that Nijinsky’s metamorphosis was predominantly subconscious is in my opinion, the very proof of his genius’ (1941: 289). But wasn’t he really saying, in the knowledge of Nijinsky’s subsequent psychological breakdown, that his subconscious metamorphosis was proof of his incipient madness? Writing at a time when Diaghilev’s short-lived association with the avant-garde was largely forgotten, Benois and Lieven disapproved of the radicalism of Nijinsky’s choreography. Both, therefore, helped create the negative, dismissive view of Nijinsky’s work that survived until the publication of Buckle’s biography and Nijinska’s memoirs. But from the point of view of hegemonic norms, the idea that Nijinsky was a genius in his dancing, and in his onstage creation of roles such as Petrouchka, is a comparatively safe and unthreatening one. It could easily be recuperated within conservative ideas about masculinity. NIJINSKY’S UNORTHODOX ROLES IN FOKINE’S BALLETS For those who knew to look for it, Nijinsky’s roles were nevertheless transgressive, presenting a spectacle of male sexuality. This raises the question how far his roles in ballets such as Narcisse, Schéhérazade, Le Spectre de la rose, and in his own L’Après midi d’un faune (1912) broke with the nineteenthcentury tradition, and in what ways did they still appear to be acceptable interpretation of classical or ‘oriental’ themes? 68
NIJINSK Y
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
Many contemporary descriptions of Nijinsky ascribe androgynous qualities to his dancing, stressing its male power and strength but female sensuousness. Richard Buckle quotes several descriptions of Nijinsky’s performance of the Golden Slave in Schéhérazade (1910), including Fokine’s comment that ‘The lack of masculinity which was peculiar to this remarkable dancer . . . suited very well the role of the Negro slave’ (1961: 155). The ambiguity of Nijinsky’s masculinity and sexuality in Schéhérazade would also be read in relation to a similar ambiguity about the role played by Ida Rubinstein as Zodeida, the Sultan’s favourite (Wollen 1987: 5–33; see also Batson 2005). Fokine then likened Nijinsky to a ‘half-feline animal’ but also to a stallion ‘overflowing with an abundant power, his feet impatiently pawing the floor’ (1961: 155). Alexandre Benois, who wrote the libretto for this ballet, described Nijinsky’s performance as ‘half-cat, half-snake, fiendishly agile, feminine and yet wholly terrifying’ (quoted in Buckle 1975: 160). Amy Koritz has noted that the London critics often used the same vocabulary when writing about qualities in Nijinsky’s dancing that they used to describe that of the two female ballet stars Karsavina and Pavlova (1995: 132). In her view, the Ballets Russes raised the status of ballet to high art through the presence of good male dancers; but this new status was legitimated by a shift from an emphasis on star performers to an emphasis on ‘the “masculine” role of choreographer as creator’ (ibid.: 133). The power of the male choreographer as author, she argues, had the effect of desexualising the male dancer. In the pre-war period, the person who came closest to publicly naming Nijinsky as a homosexual was C.W. Beaumont in a foreword to a deluxe limited edition of George Barbier’s drawings of the dancer. These, Garafola suggests, ‘borrowed the iconography of “decadence” and art nouveau to “homoeroticize” the body of the Ballets Russes star’ (2000: 71). In his foreword, Beaumont asserted that ‘Nijinsky is not a man in the true, robust sense of the word’ and suggested that roles such as Le Spectre de la rose ‘are not parts for the descendants of Mars and Hercules’ (1913: n.p.). The word homosexual was implied but not actually stated (as it would be about Börlin), and the book would only have been seen by a small readership, most of whom, Garafola suggests, were probably themselves homosexual. Garafola argues that the androgynous quality of Nijinsky’s dancing may have related to the image of the androgyne in the work of many homosexual visual artists of the Aesthetic movement at the end of the nineteenth century (1989: 56). The androgyne presented the image of a graceful, innocent, often languid youth, unspoilt by the world. Emmanuel Cooper (1986) has suggested that many homosexual artists of the Aesthetic movement saw in the androgynous male a positive image of the homosexual as a third sex. According to the ‘scientific’ explanation of homosexuality initially proposed by Karl Ulrichs, homosexual men were women born in men’s bodies, and constituted a third sex. Those homosexuals who subscribed 69
THE MAL E DANCER
to the notion of a third sex saw this as a slightly effeminate ‘in-between’ man or woman.7 The role of Narcisse which Nijinsky created in Fokine’s Narcisse (1911), can be interpreted as a straight piece of classical mythology, but is also open to interpretation as an image of the third sex. The figure of Narcissus has a history of use by homosexual artists that goes back to Caravaggio. Nijinska’s description of Narcisse exemplifies all the qualities associated with the Aesthetic androgyne – grace, innocence, and unspoiltness: His body of the youth in love with his own image emanated health and the athletic prowess of the ancient Greek Games. It could have been dangerous to portray in a dance the sensual and erotic Narcisse, driven to ecstasy by his own reflection in the water. Vaslav had so interpreted this scene that all such implications disappeared, dissolved in the beauty of his dance. Each pose on the ground, each movement in the air was a masterpiece. (1981: 366–7) Alternatively, the vigorous classicism of Nijinsky’s presentation of the role might be interpreted from another, different homosexual perspective that looked back to Classical Greece as an example of a robust, manly culture in which male homosexuality was normal (see Dyer 1990: 22–5). What made Narcisse acceptable to straight audiences, apart from its classical origins, was the fact that it was a moral fable that warns against the dangers of self obsession.8 For transgressing social norms, Narcissus is punished. On another level (following the argument in Chapter 2) Narcissus also has to be punished for being the erotic subject of the (male) spectator’s gaze, as must the Golden Slave in Schéhérazade who was the object of Zodeida’s desiring gaze. In the Slave’s case, the discourse through which Nijinsky’s highly ambiguous and exotic roles might nevertheless have appeared acceptable was that of Orientalism. As Edward Said (1978) has pointed out, for the nineteenth-century European (and by implication for the Ballets Russes’ audiences) the Orient was associated with the freedom of licentious sex (see also Aldrich 1994). In the Romantic imagination, Mario Praz (1967) identifies a literary and artistic tradition which combined the imagery of exotic places, the cultivation of sadomasochistic tastes, and a fascination with the macabre (see also Nochlin 1991: 41–3). Schéhérazade, with its orgy and subsequent execution, is clearly an example of this. Kevin Kopelson also points out that Russians of Diaghilev’s class had owned slaves (serfs) until 1861 (1997: 15). For Russian viewers, the Golden Slave was oriental, but, for Western viewers such as Proust, he was also Negro (ibid.: 64). Peter Wollen points to the ambiguous nature of the identity of the Russian ballet as both of the East and the West. It was a fusion of French ballet traditions and indigenous Russian Orientalist traditions, in for instance Pushkin and Rimsky-Korsakov. Drawing on dancers and visual 70
NIJINSK Y
1
1
11
11
1
11
artists from St Petersburg, it was part of European Russia in contrast to more ‘Eastern’ Moscow. ‘Yet by a strange reversal the trend was turned around and, in the form of the Ballets Russes, Paris (cultural capital of Europe, the “west”) began to import Russia, the “east”, in a deluge of exaggerated Orientalism’ (Wollen 1987: 21). The Ballets Russes never performed in Russia and both Diaghilev and Nijinsky were dismissed from the service of the Imperial Theatres.9 Bakst, Benois, and Roerich (who designed set and costumes for Polovtsian Dances and Le Sacre du printemps and worked with Stravinsky on the libretto for the latter) never worked for the Imperial Theatres after 1909, Fokine leaving in 1918. After 1911, Nijinsky was unable (or Diaghilev may have encouraged him to believe he was unable) to return to Russia because he had defaulted from his military service. Yet these artists claimed, as Benois put it, to be presenting Russian ballet to Europe, making new works that would embody ‘all the beloved old with a fresh and stimulating manner of presentation’ (Benois 1936: 194). One can, therefore, conclude that the project of the artists and intellectuals in Diaghilev’s circle was to negotiate through the ballet their identity as Russians, in ways that significantly contradicted and opposed hegemonic Russian definitions. For Diaghilev and Nijinsky as homosexual men, this marginal position also enabled a limited, but contained, expression of homosexual experience. Nijinsky’s homosexuality was signified primarily through ambiguities within the stories, and through qualities of costume and decor. It was not signified by the virtuosic solos for which he became famous. In the case of the Golden Slave, Fokine’s innovative methods of combining mime and dance into expressive movement was a vehicle for expressing a transgressively sensual and eroticised male image, but in a context within which transgression was seen to be punished. The violent deaths at the end of Schéhérazade might have been appreciated as an erotic spectacle, but this was in an acceptable form that could be displaced from ‘normal’ Europeans onto oriental (or Negro) ‘Others’. Richard Dyer’s comments on the Rudolph Valentino film The Son of the Sheik (1926) could equally be applied to Schéhérazade:
11
The audience could take it two ways. Shocked by the sexual explicitness, it could dismiss the depicted events ‘anthropologically’ as foreign behaviour. Drawn to the characters, however, it could welcome the film as a sunlit dream of sexuality. In a period not yet saturated in Freudian ideas, such dreams were still possible. (1992: 101)
11
The status quo of conservative gender ideologies thus remained intact. It is only through the modernism of his own choreography that Nijinsky directly confronted norms of masculine behaviour. 71
THE MAL E DANCER
THE RADICALISM OF EARLY MODERNISM A useful starting point for characterising the modernism of Nijinsky’s ballets is another of Cocteau’s drawings, showing Stravinsky playing Le Sacre du printemps (Figure 3.3). Growing out of the composer’s shoulders, as he sits hunched over the piano, are closely packed rows of geometrically distorted figures. The word ‘angular’ has been used to describe both Stravinsky’s music and the movements in Nijinsky’s choreography. It conjures up both their modern feeling and their primitivism, as does Cocteau’s drawing through its light-hearted, but knowing, references to the new, fragmented vocabularies of cubist and futurist painting, as well as its reference to ‘primitive’ African sculptures. Here is a seeming paradox that Nijinsky and Stravinsky, when producing their most ‘advanced’ works, were both involved in manipulating material gleaned from Russian academic research into archaic and defunct folkloric artefacts and traditions. Simon Karlinsky has given us a useful account of the way Stravinsky used such material in his early ballets for Diaghilev. The Firebird, Karlinsky
Figure 3.3 ’Stravinsky playing Le Sacre du printemps’. From Jean Cocteau, Dessins, 1923. © ADAGP, Paris and DACS, London 2006.
72
NIJINSK Y
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
argues, is still a product of the nineteenth-century aesthetic. It mingles themes from Russian folklore with melodies from a reputable folk song collection, and couches them in ‘the most advanced and elegant musical idiom of the time, French Impressionism’ (1983: 234). In Petrouchka Stravinsky turned his back on both ‘the ethnographic approach and the western-style sugar-coating of folklore implicit in the Russian nineteenthcentury aesthetic’ (ibid.), and went even further along this road in Sacre in which ‘Lithuanian and Slavic materials were deformed . . . with a sovereign freedom that may be termed cubistic’ (ibid.). When one examines contemporary accounts of Nijinsky’s work, a similar pattern emerges. First, these suggest that Nijinsky was reacting against the nineteenth-century tradition, and against the impressionistic vagueness of Fokine. When working secretly with her brother on L’Après midi d’un faune, Nijinska wrote in her diary in 1911: ‘Not long ago Fokine freed himself from the old classical school and the captivity of Petipa’s choreography, and now Vaslav is freeing himself from the captivity of Fokine’s choreography so that, again, we enter a new phase in our art’ (1981: 328). Writing to his mother in 1912, Stravinsky also felt Fokine only went half way: ‘At the beginnings of his career he appeared to be extraordinarily progressive. But the more I knew of his work, the more I saw that in essence he was not new at all. . . . New forms must be created, and the evil, the gifted, the greedy Fokine has not even dreamed of them’ (quoted in Buckle 1975: 269–70). In 1913, the composer told Henry Postel du Mas: ‘Nijinsky is capable of giving life to the whole art of ballet. Not for a moment have we ceased to think along the same lines. Later you will see what he can do . . . he is capable of innovation and creation’ (quoted in Craft 1976: 37).10 Jacques Rivière also saw the general move towards modernism in dance as a reaction against the nineteenth century, characterised by the artificiality of Debussy. He detected in Fokine’s work ‘a certain artfulness, a certain vacillation, some sort of inner vagueness’ (1983: 117) and felt that the innovation of Nijinsky’s choreography for Sacre lay ‘in doing away with dynamic artificiality, in the return to the body, in the effort to adhere more closely to its natural movements, in lending an ear only to its most immediate, most radical, most etymological expressions’ (ibid.). Just as Stravinsky exercised a sovereign freedom in deforming folk idioms, Nijinsky took a high-handed approach towards his source material. Fokine had been highly critical of the inauthentic nature of the danses de caractère (folk-derived dances that occur as divertisements) and period dances of the Maryinsky repertoire of the early 1900s. When he, himself, choreographed such dances, he was proud of their imaginative realism. In his memoirs he speaks of learning folk dances on his travels in Russia and later in western Europe, and of his efforts to research the dances of classical Greece from sculptures and artefacts in museums and libraries (Fokine 73
THE MAL E DANCER
1961). Nijinsky, however, wasn’t interested in authenticity for its own sake. There is a story of how Bakst took him to the Louvre to look at Greek sculptural reliefs when Nijinsky was working on Faune; Nijinsky became far more interested in the galleries of Egyptian reliefs (Buckle 1975: 188). When Nijinsky was making Sacre, he used the geometric patterns that Roerich had devised for the costumes as inspiration for choreographing circle dances (traditional Russian khovorods) and groups (Hodson 1986: 71). Nijinsky’s interest in Gauguin’s paintings (Buckle 1975: 107, 331) is surely significant here. Linda Nochlin has argued that Gauguin: [rejected] what he conceived of as the lies of illusionism and the ideology of progress – in resorting to flatness, decorative simplification, and references to ‘primitive’ art – that is to say, by rejecting the signifiers of western rationalism, progress, and objectivity in toto. (1991: 51) Faune also resorted to flatness. All the movement material was based on a severely horizontal, frieze-like flattening of walking. The floor patterns of the movement were straight, parallel lines in a narrow track right at the front of the stage; the back cloth for the ballet in the Théâtre du Chatellet in May 1912 was placed only 2 metres behind the proscenium arch (Schouvaloff 1993: 99). What was important for Nijinsky and Stravinsky was not the authenticity of the source material but the meanings that, in its fragmented form, it evoked in a dislocated, modern context, and the affective impact they could achieve through its use. To some Russian audiences at the time, Stravinsky’s progressive use of folk sources would have been interpreted as an expression of the Russian soul, achieved through rejection and purification of extraneous western European cultural influences. But Stravinsky was an immigrant, having more or less left Russia after 1909. The ballet scores that he wrote for Diaghilev, written in western Europe, are often best known by their French titles, and were premiered in Paris, the most advanced cultural metropolis of the day. Nijinsky also was in exile. Raymond Williams has suggested that the experience of exile, and of migrating to a foreign metropolis, was central to the creation of the formal innovations made by the early modernists. Williams argues the experience of being an immigrant is a theme that: underlies in an obvious way, the elements of strangeness and distance, indeed of alienation, which so regularly form part of the repertory. But the decisive aesthetic effect is at a deeper level. Liberated or breaking from their national or provincial cultures, placed in quite new relations to those other native languages or visual traditions, encountering meanwhile a novel and dynamic common environment from which many of the older forms were obviously distant, 74
NIJINSK Y
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
the artists and writers and thinkers of this phase found the only community available to them: a community of the medium; of their own practices. (1989: 45) It is this concentration on the medium itself that is, of course, the hallmark of modernist work, but it is also the key to understanding the revolution in representational practices. Nijinsky was, undoubtedly, a modernist in Williams’s terms. As a choreographer, he purged the ballet vocabulary of outmoded representational forms and conventions. It took him numerous rehearsals to prepare L’Après midi d’un faune (some accounts say 90, some 120), although the piece only takes eleven minutes to perform. This was because of his revolutionary approach to interpretation. As Nijinska explains: the number of rehearsals was not excessive if one takes into account the ballet’s completely new technique of presentation, and if one also remembers the marvellous level of execution finally achieved by the artists. Up to then the ballet artist had been free to project his own individuality as he felt . . . Nijinsky was the first to demand that his whole choreographic material should be executed not only as he saw it but also according to his artistic interpretation. (1981: 427) The key to his new approach is the idea that expression came through the movement material itself and not through mime or acting. Marie Rambert tells a story about Nijinsky rehearsing a new dancer in the role of one of the nymphs. He told her off for acting out a moment when the Faune frightens her. He wasn’t interested in facial mannerisms. All she had to do was get the movements right (1972: 62). Nijinsky wanted dancers to focus in on the performance of the movement itself. In Michael Fried’s terms, he wanted them to be absorbed in it, rather than to use it as a platform for ‘theatrical’ projection. It is the movement material on its own that is expressive. Jacques Rivière makes the same point while discussing Sacre. In Nijinsky’s dance, he argues: the face no longer plays a part of importance; it is merely an extension of the body – its flower. It is above all the body that speaks. . . . By breaking up movement and bringing it back to the simple gesture, Nijinsky causes expression to return to the dance. All the angles, all the breaks in his choreography, are aimed only at preventing the escape of emotion. (1983: 120) Rivière’s emphasis on feeling corresponds with a trend among a young generation of French intellectuals. In 1911, under the joint pseudonymn 75
THE MAL E DANCER
Agathon, two young writers, Henri Massis and Alfred de Tarde, produced two influential newspaper surveys or ‘enquêtes’: L’Esprit de la nouvelle Sorbonne (‘Spirit of the New Sorbonne’) and Les Jeunes gens d’aujourd’hui (‘The Young People Today’) in which they attacked the scientific rationalism of late nineteenth-century French intellectual culture. In its place they proposed a non-rationalised, non-scientific, and non-utilitarian, masculine morality, which valued the spiritual over the material, the moral over the artificial. As Joan Acocella has observed in her introduction to Kyril FitzLyon’s recent translation of Nijinsky’s diaries, Nijinsky himself wanted its publication ‘to right the balance of power in the world, to wrest authority from the thinkers, return it to the feelers’ (1999: xxiv). These, then, are the aspirations and the new means at Nijinsky’s and subsequently at Nijinska’s disposal. What difference could a less rational, more affective performance make where gender representations are concerned? NIJINSKY’S BALLETS AND GENDER REPRESENTATION Nijinsky’s first ballet, L’Après midi d’un faune (1912) is set to Debussy’s Prelude à l’après midi d’un faune of 1894 that was itself inspired by Mallarmé’s poem of 1876. The poem presents the reveries of a young Faune. These include an encounter with two beautiful nymphs which may be recollected from a dream, a fantasy, or a real event. Mallarmé was one of the poets that Verlaine dubbed Les poètes maudites, pure of heart but despised and rejected by both mother and society, and accursed (‘maudites’) by God. Nijinsky’s amoral interpretation of the poem is surely within this tradition.11 The ballet’s first performance provoked heated debate in the French press, and charges of indecency (Buckle 1975: 284–9). These largely concern the ballet’s ending. The Faune, having surprised a group of nymphs, carries back to his rock a veil that one of them has dropped, and rubs it against his crotch. As it is usually performed now, the Faune stretches out on top of the veil while making a couple of pelvic thrusts, jerks his head back in pleasure, and then lies still. Richard Buckle suggests that when Nijinsky first performed this he actually mimed masturbation (ibid.: 284). Whether or not this was the case, the ballet’s ending focused the audience’s attention towards his penis and thus suggested male sexual excitement. As a classical male role, the Faune superficially resembles the title role of Fokine’s Narcisse. The difference, however, is in its attitude towards morality. Underlying the myth of Narcissus is a warning about unnatural behaviour – being unmoved by the love of Echo, being obsessed with personal appearance. The Faune, however, is ‘pure’, ‘natural’, and innocent. The movement style of the ballet was simple walking steps and jumps, dance stripped of every vestige of balletic style and performed with an absorbed focus.12 This exquisite surface, by being outside balletic convention, 76
NIJINSK Y
1
created an ideological space for the ballet that was outside social norms. The Faune, as Nijinsky shows him, is amoral, and the piece a deliberate provocation to society to condemn such spontaneous sexual behaviour, as if he were saying only a depraved mind could see anything depraved in this (Figure 3.4). It was surely Nijinsky’s marginal position – as Russian immigrant, as someone from a poor, one-parent family in Diaghilev’s privileged bourgeois and aristocratic circles, as someone in a sexual relation-
1
11
11
1
11
11 Figure 3.4 Vaslav Nijinsky in costume as the Faune.
11
Photo Karl Struss, New York 1916. Courtesy of Jerome Robbins Dance Division, The New York Public Library for the Performing Arts, Astor, Lenox, and Tilden Foundations.
77
THE MAL E DANCER
ship with another man – that allowed him to produce a representation of ‘natural’ masculinity that ran so strongly against convention. He was also a Russian artist, forceful, earthy, intensely idealistic, and innocent, yet without illusions, like a character in one of the novels by Dostoyevsky and Tolstoy that he wrote about in his diaries. As Sokolova, who danced in the ballet with Nijinsky, recalls: Nijinsky as the Faune was thrilling. Although his movements were absolutely restrained, they were virile and powerful, and the manner in which he caressed and carried the nymph’s veil was so animal that one expected to see him run up the side of the hill with it in his mouth. (1960: 41) By animal, I take Sokolova to mean the animality of virile sexuality. Nijinska’s description of his later ballet for Diaghilev, Sacre, stressed the animality of the male dancers in a more shameful and abject way: The men in Sacre are primitive. There is something almost bestial in their appearance. Their legs and feet are turned inwards, their fists clenched, their heads held down between hunched shoulders; their walk, on slightly bent knees, is heavy as they laboriously straggle up a winding trail, stamping in the rough, hilly terrain. (1981: 459) In the reconstruction of Sacre that Millicent Hodson produced for the Joffrey Ballet, the men look bestial. They characteristically make their entrances leaning forward as Nijinska describes above. Their postures are like those of the figures in the famous nineteenth-century Russian painting of The Volga Boatmen by I. Repin (1844–1930). The angle at which the men in Sacre lean, and the slightly pointed hats they wear, make them look as if they are about to jump forwards and upwards, and penetrate into one of the massed groups of women. In the first act, men fight each other in the ‘Games of the rival clans’. The Ancients, in the second act, wear bear skins with the animals’ heads fitting on their own like hoods. As Roerich noted, this was ‘to show that the bear was man’s ancestor’ (quoted in MacDonald 1975: 89). Grouped with other men round the circle, in which the Chosen One is trapped and will dance herself to death, they perform a dance sequence which includes a movement where they drag their left foot across the floor like an animal pawing the ground. Throughout the Chosen One’s sacrificial solo, they wait for her death spasm, the signal for them to rush in and grab her, hoisting her high in the air. All these are instances of the bestial quality in Sacre’s male roles.13 Sokolova recalls the heat on stage every time Sacre was performed (1960: 44). Millicent Hodson suggests this may have been partly due to the ritualistic nature of the movement – circle dances that generated altered 78
NIJINSK Y
1
1
11
11
mental states (1985: 41). It must also have come from the effort expended by both sexes in jumping, throwing themselves on the ground and straight away springing back up again, running and stamping. Although the actual movement material was very different from Faune, the emphasis on its ritualistic quality resulted in a performance that had an absorbed rather than ‘theatrical’ focus. The male dancers had more dynamic leaps and jumps than the female ones; these were the sorts of movement for which Nijinsky himself was famous in his roles in other men’s ballets; however, in Sacre, rather than hiding effort and exhaustion, these were if anything exaggerated. There was no way that the male dancers in Sacre could have been thought of as effeminate. If Faune presented a pure, ‘natural’ masculinity, in Sacre Nijinsky had stripped this of both its acceptable classical setting and its sexiness, to produce a more extreme representation of ‘natural’, uncivilised masculinity. The men in Sacre may have been unattractive but the affects that their performance produced were intense. Their physical presence was, perhaps, more significant than their appearance. The first performance of Sacre on 29 May 1913 at the Théâtre des Champs-Elysées has gone down in history for the disturbance that split the audience. That it was the revolutionary character of the choreography, and not the music, that split the audience was proved by the fact that the latter was ecstatically received when performed on its own in a concert in Paris early in 1914. It was the unrelieved intensity of the dancers’ ritualistic performance and the ways in which male dancing bodies were presented that audiences had found most difficult to accept.
1 NIJINSKA AND GENDER REPRESENTATION
11
11
11
Nijinska’s ballet Les Noces (1923) is a clear descendant of Sacre: in the sequence of Stravinsky’s output the score immediately follows Sacre (though it took him years to finish) and shares with it a similar rhythmic complexity and melodic harshness. Thematically both refer to Russian folk melodies and practices. Nijinska saw her work as the further development of the choreographic advances initiated by her brother. At the end of her life she wrote: When the critics indicated the influence of Faune in my choreography of Les Noces, they were wrong. I was formed as a choreographer more by Jeux and Le Sacre du printemps. The unconscious art of those ballets inspired my initial work. From them, I sought to realise the potential of my brother’s creativity in terms of neo-classical ballet and modern dance. (1981: 469) The music for Les Noces is sometimes said to be the piece of Stravinsky’s which Europeans find most inaccessible. It takes as its starting point texts 79
THE MAL E DANCER
that record rituals and superstitions surrounding Russian peasant wedding celebrations. The Russian peasant world view remained a mixture of Christian and pagan superstitions much longer than it did in most Western countries. There was never a period of religious reform such as the Reformation and Counter-Reformation in Europe. Simon Karlinsky suggests that in Les Noces some of the invocations sung by the wedding guests are thinly disguised pagan survivals (1983: 236). Boris Asaf’yev (1982), writing in Russia in 1929, proposed that two conflicting themes are bound together in Stravinsky’s music for Les Noces: the women’s grim, downtrodden threnody (lament), and the men’s grotesque, drunken buffoonery. The first and third sections – blessing the bride, departure of the bride – are strident laments, while the second and last sections – blessing the groom, the wedding feast – are bawdy and grotesque. Key to the work’s affective impact was Nijinska’s modernist use of pointe work. Pointe has been, since its development in the early 1800s, the prime signifier of femininity in ballet. But, rather than using it to create the atmosphere of delicate ethereality that one finds in the all-white acts of so many nineteenth-century ballets, Nijinska used pointe to emphasise the brittle nervousness of the Bride and her female companions at what is for them the dreadful prospect of marriage. The traditional Russian wedding, Asaf’yev wrote, is virtually a funeral rite. He did not imply that Les Noces divides simply into feminine and masculine sections, but argued that these themes are inexorably but conflictually connected: The authority of tradition speaks to women: life is a burden, bear it come what may, bury your maidenhead, and with it your will. The buffoon says: life is mime, the rite of the family is theatrical farce. . . . The laughter of buffoonery . . . serves to assuage the bitterness of female grief and blunt the wild impulsiveness of the male procreative energy. (1982: 130) The ballet, like the music, is the battle between these two powerful old themes. Asaf’yev, cut off from the West in post-revolutionary Russia, would not have seen the ballet performed. In Nijinska’s choreography the themes of the piece divide clearly along gendered lines, and there is never any compromise or let up in the bitterness of female grief. The Bride remains totally frigid and slightly turned away from her husband all through the final wedding feast. This is more obvious in the British Royal Ballet’s version (1966) than in the Paris Opéra version (1976). In the feast, the two families are seated on a platform, back stage, while the guests dance in front of them side by side in segregated blocks and wedges. The music here is at its rowdiest, with sometimes two or three different things being sung at once. The male and female dancers never completely come together; sometimes the men are jumping up at the moment that the women are 80
NIJINSK Y
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
landing from their own jump, which is following a different rhythm in the music. It is in the earlier scenes that the differences between the material given to the male and female dancers is most apparent. The groups formed by the women are generally in lines, strung out on either side of the bride as they weave patterns holding the yards of rope-like hair that are being ceremonially braided. This linearity matches the accompanying thin, strident lament of the soprano who sings the part of the Bride. The men’s groups have more depth, just as the male voices that accompany them are more resonant. The men form a semi-circle behind the Groom at the beginning of the second scene, form up in little walls of dancers two or three deep, and, at the end of the scene, perform a vigorous circle dance that could almost be straight out of Sacre (see Garafola 1992: 66–7). One of the most striking aspects of Nijinska’s choreography is the extraordinary, pyramidal tableaux in the first two scenes. At the end of the blessing of the Bride, the women guests, one after the other on alternate sides, lay their heads one on top of the other in a vertical line. The last two each lay a rope-like hair braid on their side which emphasises the triangular shape of the group. Finally the Bride takes her place, putting her elbows on top of the pile and propping her head on her hands, while her mother and father stand symmetrically at either side blessing her with raised arms. There is a similar group in Blessing the Groom, but here four men kneel forwards at the front, three men then lie backwards on top of them with their arms spread wide, two more men do the same on top of them, and then the Groom walks easily into position behind so that his head is at the apex. The energy in the women’s pyramid is downwards with the weight of all those heads precariously held in line. In the men’s group the energy is upwards: it is like a football scrum, and the way they support one another is much easier, recalling the ease with which men sometimes touch one another in all-male situations. In another, similar motif, each man in a group lays his head on his forearm and walks sideways in an awkward crouch. This unnatural pose, moving sideways across the stage while facing front, recalls typical Nijinsky poses in Sacre and Faune. A block of men form up in this position and move sideways across the stage like a screen behind the Groom. Here and elsewhere, this motif is surely a reference to lying in bed, and thus to the bedding of the couple at the end of the feast. Both this and the pyramid speak of these men’s almost insolent, masculine ease in their bodies, and happiness at their status in patriarchal society: this contrasts with the female lack of ease about the power men express through their bodies. Nijinska’s fragmented modernism made the audience aware of the men’s physical ease by stressing the women’s lack of it. This was unprecedented and would not occur again at this scale until Pina Bausch began to make work in Wuppertal in the 1970s (see Chapter 6). 81
THE MAL E DANCER
L’HOMME ET SON DESIR AND LES BICHES I have argued that, before the war, the homosexual sensibility which informed the creation of Nijinsky’s eroticised roles enabled a female spectatorship. Nijinska’s post-war ballets created possibilities for female spectators to look at the male dancing body in a different way from gay male spectators. After the war, public awareness of homosexuality had increased and the connection between ballet and homosexuality was beginning to be mentioned in French dance criticism. Two ballets from the early 1920s exemplify different aspects of this. L’Homme et son désir, made in 1921 by Jean Börlin (1893–1930), the choreographer and leading dancer in Rolf de Maré’s Ballets Suédois, wasn’t intended to be a homosexual ballet but Börlin’s nakedness, nevertheless, inspired homophobic comments. By contrast, Les Biches, choreographed by Nijinska for the Ballets Russes in 1924, exemplified a calculated and knowing exposition of sexual ambiguity without, however, attracting any adverse criticism. L’Homme et son désir, a Brazilian-themed ballet, was initially conceived by the poet and diplomat Paul Claudel (1868–1955) as a project for Nijinsky. While French ambassador in Rio de Janeiro, he had met Nijinsky there in 1917 where Claudel saw one of his last performances with the Ballets Russes. Having developed his initial concept with the young composer Darius Milhaud (1892–1974), who was working at the embassy, and Andrée Parr, artist wife of a British diplomat, Claudel only found out about Nijinsky’s mental breakdown on his return to Paris. After Diaghilev had turned the project down, Rolf de Maré (1898–1964) agreed to take it on. Claudel, who had been fascinated by Dalcroze’s innovative stagings of theatre work on a visit to Hellerau before the war, had come up with the idea of staging his ballet on four narrow tiers of an almost vertical stage set. As Claudel explained, on the top tier: the hours of the night file past, dressed all in black and wearing golden head-dresses. Below is the Moon, led across the sky by a cloud, like a servant walking ahead of a great lady. Right at the bottom, in the waters of the vast primeval swamp, the reflection of the Moon and of her servants follows the regular march of the celestial couple. (Cited in Häger 1990: 126) In the middle platform, the main action took place performed by Man – an everyman – who danced out his passions and desires, pacing along his narrow strip like a tiger in a cage. As Man, Börlin wore almost invisible, tight briefs that matched the shiny, yellow makeup with which the rest of his body was covered. While Bengt Häger (1990) has suggested that the ballet was an unqualified success, Charles Batson (2005) has translated French reviews that demon82
NIJINSK Y
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
strate that the ballet had a more mixed reception. Milhaud’s music – for five strings, four woodwinds, seventeen percussion instruments, and vocal quartet – was progressive but difficult, with allusions to indigenous Brazilian music. Though Claudel, an eminent figure, wrote serious pieces explaining his intentions, Batson notes that many reviewers adopted an ironic tone (2005: 198). Almost all the references to Börlin’s performance, Batson suggests, either attacked or made a joke about his being naked on stage. Tellingly, one review spelled out the recent change in attitudes towards male dancing. Le Petit Bleu noted: ‘Nijinsky’s legs started ToutParis’s fad for masculine thighs . . . Aesthetic and predictable manifestation of a homosexuality already daring and become predictable since’ (quoted in Batson 2005: 202). The positive qualities of open, passionate expressiveness, that Claudel and Rivière had admired in Nijinsky’s performance, and the moral masculinity, that Agathon advocated in the ‘enquêtes’, had now become suspect in a more anxious, post-war climate. A large proportion of the younger generation of French men having died in the trenches, the post-war French government actively adopted pronatalist policies. In this climate, Börlin’s naked and expressive Man did not seem the sort of man who would father the sons to replace those so traumatically lost in the war. Diaghilev, as I have already noted, did not appreciate effeminacy or obvious homosexuality, and clearly appreciated the manly spectacles Nijinsky and Nijinska choreographed for him. This is evident in a letter he wrote in 1923 to his friend and secretary Boris Kochno while Les Biches was being made: Here everything is going along better than I expected. Poulenc [who Diaghilev had commissioned to compose the music for Les Biches] is enthusiastic about Bronia’s choreography, and they get along excellently together. The choreography has delighted and astonished me. But then, this good woman, intemperate and anti-social as she is, does belong to the Nijinsky family. Here and there her choreography is a bit too ordinary, a bit too feminine, but on the whole it is very good. (Quoted in Buckle 1979: 418) Having said he felt Nijinska’s work was sometimes feminine, Diaghilev went on to talk about the entrance of the three young men (who have been described as sportsmen, bicyclists, or Olympic athletes): ‘The dance for the three young men has come out extremely well, and they perform it with bravura – weightily, like a cannon. It doesn’t at all resemble Les Noces, any more than Tchaikovsky’s Eugene Onegin resembles his Queen of Spades’ (ibid.). One gets the impression it is the male dancers that Diaghilev is most interested in, and likening them to a cannon is a most revealing simile. 83
THE MAL E DANCER
The men’s entrance is an ostentatious one. They are out to show off before the women, as Haskell puts it, ‘like bucks before a groups of does (biches)’ (1928: 148). Despite this dazzling entrance, the women, however, behave as if unimpressed – two women ignoring the men altogether. This had the effect of making the audience see the men, and this sort of macho display, from a more complex point of view, and thus with a detachment which, as with Les Noces, was surely a consequence of Nijinska’s modernism. A reviewer in The Times described Les Biches as an ‘atmospheric and allusive’ ballet which followed the course of a group of young people’s ‘amorous adventures centring round a pale blue sofa, which is sat upon, jumped on, peeped over, or pushed about by everyone concerned from one end of the ballet to the other’ (Anon. 1924: 12). One shouldn’t overestimate the extent to which Nijinska had artistic control over this or indeed any of the ballets she made for Diaghilev. Although, like Fokine, she would have enjoyed relative autonomy over the actual process of choreography, decisions about music, design, and libretto were Diaghilev’s prerogative, and he and his circle also made contributions during rehearsals. In Les Biches, he suggested that she play with an extravagantly long cigarette holder as she danced the Rag Mazurka, having seen her constantly smoking on stage while running rehearsals. Diaghilev, the ballet’s designer Marie Laurencin, and Misia Sert were all apparently involved in making changes to the Girl in Blue’s costume, progressively shortening it and making her look more boyish (Buckle 1979: 420; Baer 1986: 40). It is never entirely clear what gender she was supposed to be. Batson observes: ‘When the men choose to continue their duets together, ridiculing the advances of one particularly flirtatious woman, no voice is raised to proclaim that these are not truly manly men’ (2005: 207). Because their entrance had gone off like a cannon, nothing else seemed to matter. Whereas Parisian critics had criticised Börlin’s Man for his mannered grace and unfettered emotions, they approved the muscular displays of the men in Les Biches. Börlin’s ‘theatrical’ expressivity (in Fried’s sense) contrasted with the more absorbed and atmospheric performance qualities in Les Biches. Through absorption and modernist fragmentation, Nijinska’s choreography, like that of her brother before her, created an ideological space that enabled heterosexual female and gay male spectators to negotiate their own ‘local’ readings of male dancing bodies, even when these only superficially conformed to hegemonic norms. The cool, sophisticated quality of Les Biches and of Nijinska’s next two ‘modern’ ballets for Diaghilev – Le Train Bleu (1925) and Romeo and Juliet (1926) – was very different from the hot, intense atmosphere her brother had created in Faune and Sacre. Homophobic ballet criticism was already beginning to limit the range of male dancing to harder, more manly types of muscular display. But at least, for those who knew to look, Nijinska showed that this wasn’t necessarily the kind of masculinity that women wanted. 84
1
4 AMERICAN MEN
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
Men don’t dance. This, according to Walter Terry, was the message that one of Ted Shawn’s fellow divinity students had for Shawn, after the latter’s first public dance performance in Denver in 1911. When Shawn cited as examples the men of the Russian ballet, and the dances of men in almost every culture, the reply came ‘that’s all right for Russians and pagans but not for Americans’ (Terry 1976: 41). This is a witty anecdote but also a telling one, in that it brings together key issues facing white men in the US who go into serious theatre dance. First, ‘Men don’t dance’ is not far from ‘ “real” men don’t dance’, that is, there must be something wrong with those who do. With this go all the homophobic anxieties that remind white men of the need to conform to prevalent and culturally specific heterosexual norms of masculine behaviour. Second, what is or is not right for US citizens is a question of US cultural identity. At the start of the twenty-first century, while Russian men have continued to have a high profile on the international ballet scene, US men are now dancing on stage and have played a large part in the development of US modern dance. Shawn did a great deal to enable this. It must to some extent be as a result of Cold War rhetoric (Gilbaut 1985; Prevots 1998) that there has been and still is among some critics and commentators a deep-rooted belief that the US leads the world in the modern arts. A perceived link between aesthetic modernism, scientific, technological, and democratic progress, and national identity has informed the way US modern dancers have understood their role. Third, there is the comment about pagans. Cotton Mather (1663–1728), the influential Puritan minister in Boston at the time of the Salem witch trials, referred to ‘pagans’ in some of his sermons against dancing. Christian ideas had a much greater impact on dance in the US than in Europe during the first half of the twentieth century. Shawn and his fellow student were studying for the Methodist ministry. Christian beliefs were sufficiently important for him and for the other two choreographers whose work is discussed in this chapter – Martha Graham and José Limón – to create a number of dance pieces that referred to biblical themes and Christian subjects (see Manor 1980, 1992).1 Graham herself was simultaneously 85
THE MAL E DANCER
attracted and repelled by the idea of Puritanism while there is an almost baroque, Catholic fervour in some of Limón’s work. Shawn, Graham, and to a lesser extent Limón, each in their own way, developed in dance the image of a heroic masculinity which is valorised with reference to nature, heterosexuality, and religion, and presented in a style and vocabulary that looks muscular and hard. The masculine ideal which their work evokes is entirely a product of white, Western social forces and depends upon an ideologically distorted view of non-Western masculinity. There are now many excellent histories of US modern dance. This chapter does not set out to retell this story or recount the development of roles for men in modern dance in the US. Instead it presents readings of a few well-known pieces. What emerges from these is a recurring theme of ‘natural’, essential masculinity as signified through dance. I argue that these pieces, and the masculine ideal which they reinforce, can be seen as conservative and defensive responses to challenges to white, male hegemony. The resulting way of performing masculinity has persisted on the dance stage for a large part of the last 100 years, and has developed an autonomy of its own. Choreographers have not been able to ignore it: they have had to take it on board, adapt it, reject it, or react against it. It has become an immediately recognisable norm or positive stereotype, through or against which choreographers have tried to map out different positions in relation to the problems surrounding masculine identities. What, therefore, are these problems, and what are the threads that bind modern dance in the US to essentialist ideals of American manhood? MEN IN THE US The US association of masculinity with toughness renders male dance problematic, dancing still being, in many people’s minds, a feminine realm. Marcia Siegel sums this up thus: Dancing is an equivocal activity in any society that places a low value on the arts in general, but it becomes even more dubious where men have been celebrated as kings of the frontier, masters of the gun, the ax, and the plow. (1981: 305) This may be how men in the US have been celebrated, but the reality has, of course, been somewhat different. Throughout the period which this chapter covers, there have been continual conflicts and sources of insecurity about the nature of masculine identity as various, sometimes contradictory factors have seemingly threatened to weaken or undermine it. A heavyhanded return to ideals of ‘natural’, essential, instinctive, and ‘traditional’ masculinity is, of course, only one of many differing responses to such insecurities: but it is this sort of response that underpins the representations 86
AME RICAN MEN
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
of masculinity one finds in the choreography of Shawn and Graham. Why, then, has this idea of American man as a gun-slinging, axe and plough wielding frontiersman developed? By the beginning of the twentieth century, the prairie was increasingly being ploughed up and the expansion westwards into unsettled land was ended. While men in the US might still dream of the frontier life that Siegel invokes as a viable avenue through which to establish their identity as men, the frontier had effectively ceased to exist. In general, modern civilised lifestyles and values were widely perceived to be having a harmful and deleterious influence on the effete, educated, Eastern male elite. There was widespread concern about the feminisation of US culture (see Douglas 1977) which had a softening and degenerating influence on traditional male lifestyles and ideals. Other factors, also, were affecting men, and white-collar male workers in particular. The rise of women’s suffrage and changes in the world of work, with women increasingly entering the job market, meant that jobs which up until then had been the preserve of white-collar male workers were now being done by women. Women were becoming powerful as consumers and as patrons of the Arts. It was, for example, women who, in the early 1900s, generated a fashion for the tango and foxtrot and the new ragtime dances. This, as Belinda Quirey observed: left many middle-aged men in the world of the waltz, and unwilling to learn new tricks. Many of their middle-aged wives, on the other hand, had taken to the new style. There was therefore a demand for good partners and this was supplied by many professionals. (1976: 87) Professional male dancing partners, sometimes called gigolos, were often regarded by husbands with scorn and suspicion. When Shawn first became interested in dancing around 1910, dance in the US was almost exclusively a female preserve. Loie Fuller, Isadora Duncan, and Ruth St Denis are often described as the founding mothers of modern dance. Ted Shawn first came to public prominence as St Denis’s dancing partner, but quickly turned this questionable role into the more respectable one of co-director, with St Denis, of the Denishawn School and Dance Company. He, then, worked hard for the rest of his life to overcome US suspicions about professional male dancing and, as I noted in Chapter 1, the arguments he used were formed in the climate of nineteenthcentury gender ideologies.2 What was distinctively American within Shawn’s concerns about degeneracy was the evangelical, Protestant, ‘muscular’ Christian approach he derived from his religious training (Putney 2003). Just as Protestant churches used sport as a ‘net’ to catch young men and drawn them into the fold, Shawn used athletic, masculine movements to attract men to dance. 87
THE MAL E DANCER
Shawn’s choreography and his later writings can be seen as part of a widespread reassertion of ‘natural’ male energy that, as I pointed out in Chapter 1, informed the writings of Lord Baden-Powell, Theodore Roosevelt, and Edgar Rice Burroughs. This amounted to a reassuring rebuttal of the charge that men are growing soft. Michael S. Kimmell (1987) has called this sort of conservative reaction to changing masculine norms of identity a ‘pro-male’ response. For Shawn, the rebuttal took on a literally muscular form. For much of the nineteenth century, there had been no premium on fitness among middle class males. As Susan Bordo has put it, the bulging stomachs of successful businessmen and politicians ‘were a symbol of bourgeois success, an outward manifestation of their accumulated wealth’ (1990: 94). At the end of the century, however, Bordo suggests that: social power had come to be less dependent on the sheer accumulation of material wealth and more connected to the ability to control and manage the labor and resources of others. At the same time, excess body weight came to be seen as reflecting moral and personal inadequacy or lack of will. (Ibid.) The underlying morality here was, of course, Christian. There was a racial dimension to this new concern with masculine fitness. I pointed out, in the first chapter, that Shawn’s first performance as a dancer was the year before the publication of the first Tarzan novel. The whiteness of the pro-male reaction against the perceived threat of feminisation and degeneracy needs to be seen in the context of imperialism and white supremacy. Whiteness is a social construction. As James Baldwin, in fiercely ironic mode, argued: ‘No one was white before he/she came to America. It took generations, and a vast amount of coercion, before this became a white country’ (1998: 178). Richard Dyer has pointed out that white masculinity, as a social ideal, draws on notions of purity that derive from Christianity. An aspiration to maintain physical self control that is central to white masculinity can take on Christian spiritual attributes. ‘The white spirit,’ Dyer suggests, ‘could master and transcend the white body, while the non-white soul was a prey to the promptings and fallibilities of the body’ (1997: 23–4). To carry the white man’s burden meant cultivating ‘a hard, lean body, a dieted or trained one, an upright, shoulders back, unrelaxed posture, tight rather than loose movement, tidiness in domestic arrangement and eating manners’. These are all ways in which ‘the white body and its handling display the fact of the spirit within’ (ibid.). Just as Christian teaching urges eternal vigilance against sin, so whiteness requires constant maintenance to defend it against degeneracy. For Shawn, white people who danced to jazz music were endangering themselves. Writing in 1946, he said he was: 88
AME RICAN MEN
1
1
11
11
1
11
11
11
sick at heart that we, this whole vast country of millions of white people, still kept on dancing dances of Negro derivation. Have we lost completely the qualities that made us a great nation? We were capable in the past of creating our own dances. Why is it in this last period that we have let this Negroid influence so completely obliterate everything else? (84) Martha Graham held more integrationist views of US dance than Shawn, but comments she made in 1932 nevertheless betray her underlying commitment to the virtues of white, Christian self-control. ‘The Negro dance’, she wrote, ‘is a dance towards freedom, a dance to forgetfullness, often Dionysiac in its abandon and the raw splendor of its rhythm – it is a rhythm of disintegration’ (1978: 99). The white ideal is one that does not disintegrate. Shawn did, however, approve of Negro spirituals which he said were ‘the highest form of art that has emanated from the Negro people’ (1946: 99), presumably because of their Christian message. Indeed, along with other white US choreographers in the 1930s, Shawn found spirituals ‘a rich source of material’ for making dances (ibid.). As Susan Manning (2004) has recently pointed out, in the 1930s these choreographers and many white critics saw no discontinuity when white bodies danced black subject matter – a practice she calls ‘metaphorical minstrelsy’. At the same time these critics, Manning also notes, were reluctant to accord the same value and significance to similar dances created and performed by African American choreographers. Whiteness depends on the maintenance of difference. As a European writing about modern dance in the US, I am often struck by its optimism. US dancers seem to dance bigger, harder, and with more positive intensity than most Europeans. Critics in the US, for their part, have sometimes found the pessimism of some European choreographers problematic. Their initial reaction, for example, to Pina Bausch’s work showed this (see Daly 1986), as did Mark Morris when he jokingly renamed Anne Teresa de Keersmaeker ‘de Tearjerker’ (Acocella 1993: 220). Almost all the dance works discussed in this chapter were popular and outgoing in a characteristically American way. However, in order to gain a better understanding of the way these works represented masculinity, it is necessary to take note of a few underlying and sometimes anxious negatives within the rhetoric