M
rial 0
uto
The Jewish Trinity
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Matenal com direlbs autorars
The Jewish Trinity Wh...
242 downloads
3138 Views
53MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
M
rial 0
uto
The Jewish Trinity
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Matenal com direlbs autorars
The Jewish Trinity When Rabbis Believed in the Father, Son and Holy Spirit
By Yoel Natan
cP Aventine Press LLC
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Look for other books by Yael Natan coming soon! Web site: www.yoel.info
Copyright © Octo ber, 200 3 by Yoel Natan Ediuon 1,0.1
Without limit ing the rights unde r copyr ight rese rve d above. no pan of this publication may be reprod uced. store d in or introd uced into a retr ieva l sys tem , or transmitted, in any form o r by any means (electron ic. mec hanical. photocopyin g. recordin g. or otherwise ). without the pr ior wr itte n permiss ion o f both the copyright owne r and the pub lisher of thi s book. Pu blished by Avent ine Press, LLC 2208 Cabo Bah ia Chula Vista, CA 9 19 14. USA www.a veminepre ss.com ISB N: 1-59330- H)(I-6 Printed in the United Stales of A merica ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Table of Contents
Foreword
1
Glossa
3
a nd Abbreviations
Syno psis of The Jewish Trinity
9
Chap ter 01 : The Syntax War Between Trinitaria ns 15
and U n it a ria n s
Chap ter 02: Proto-Sinaitic Trinitarianism
67
Cha pter 03: The Presences of Elyon
79
Chap ter 04: The Shema
l1 3
Chap ter 05: The Trini ty in Dani el 01-05
127
Chapter 06: The Prophet Behind the Prophets
141
Chap ter 07: Various OT Presentations of the Trinitv
159
Chapter 08: The NT Use of aT Yahveh Texts
163
Cha ter 09: The "1 AM" Stateme nts
199
Chap ter 10: The Song of Moses (Deu 32)
213
Appen d ix A: MT Plurals Referring to Yahveh
249
Ap pend ix B: OT Texts That Sugges t or Speak of the Deity of the Mess iah ~cndix
265
C: Trinita rian Proofs
269
Appendix D: A Sampling of the NT Use of OT Yahveh Texts
323
En d notes
34 1
Ind ex .."
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
,.. ,., 357
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Matenal com direlbs autorars
Foreword T , ..dit;u lI
~ "Y ~
tl' i>L
MlO ~C ~
a ud the Ic st o f the OT ", l ite I" sc kll" " ' ,illte d a t tile
ex istence of the Trin ity. Th is book. ho weve r, shows that the NT writers knew that Mose s and the other OT writer s wrote strik ingly and o ften abo ut the Trinity and about the de ity' of C hrist. T he or and NT write rs both wrote abo ut Ihe Trinity and the g lory and grace of the Me ssia h so that their readers co uld he saved. The aim of this book is 10 d isperse Ihe smog o f those who wo uld ob fusca te the witnes s o f the Ot' and NT to the Tnnuy and to the dei ty of Ch r ist. so that the O'I' and NT will continue to save as many ax poxvible through the ir witness to the trut h. Th is boo k ought to accomplish this aim, God willing. beca use eve n if someone werc to arbitrarily reject the majority o f the Trinitarian proofs men tioned in this book, the mino rity of O'F and NT proo fs that remained wou ld still to tal mo re than the number of proofs kno w n before the publica tion of this book . By Goo 's grace. many readers of this book will co nclude thar: • Many of the c ults and wor ld reli gio ns frn m which people need to esc ape are based on the mistak en idea tha t Moses was unitaria n rather than Trinitarian, and • If Mo ses. Yesh/lu. and all the OT and NT writers were through and throug h Trinitarian, the n the read e r shou ld fo rsake all an ti-Tr ini tarian religions. c ults, and churches, as well as thei r leade rs, te ache rs, theologians and philosopher s, and quickly join a Trinitarian church.
'reel Natan Ma}' 2003
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Matenal com direlbs autorars
Glossary and Abbreviations N o ll' .
Wl " lh d lld
d hloH; v i dt il" ' ~
<,;;ill be lo oke d u p 0 11 Web
~ i Lc~ ~ ..,,;h d ~ .
Britannica.com H'. l nfoplease .com H' and Gu ruNet .n mr " . Intern et searc h e ngines such as Goo gle.co ni' v are also helpful. Mo st of the Bible te xts and reference works listed below ca n be fo und in sc hol arly Bible soft ware prod ucts such as HibldVorks T " or Logos T" . Some hook s, such as the KOrl1 l1 . can be found in the public dom a in on the Web. T
Transliterated Aramaic: Translation and Int erpretation Ila yah : Most High. Strong's Concordance has 'iltav with a pron unciation of i/-Iah'·ee.
/lyonin : Most High. Strong 's Concordance has
'1'1.\'111'1;11
with a pronuncia tion of
e1-\'IJIlI." ,
Translitera ted Greek : Translation and Interpretation egw eim i: " I am" or " I AM " no 14'/1 : " who is" o r "WHO IS" kunos: " lord" or "Lord"
Translit erated Heb rew: Translation a nd Interpretation Note 1: Capitalization co nvention: There is no ca pitalization in Hebrew. T his makes it a matter of interpretation whether the English translations and translitcratio ns read, for instance, "lord" o r "Lord" tadon o r Adon ), "god" or "God" teiohim or tJ ohim). "face" or " Face" tpan im or PUllim ). or spirit or Spirit (ruill'h or Rual'lI). The lac k of capitalization. or any co nventio n. for differentiating the Hebre w for "god" from "God" telohim from E/ohim ) can he co nfusing. Per instance, it has led to two translations of Exo 22:2K: "Do not re vile the gods" (KJV, LXE), and "Do not blasphe me God " (NIV, RSV. YL I). Not e 2: Ita lici zatio n con vention : Boo k titles and words that have no t yet beco me a part of the English language belo w are italic ized. MT, LXX, DSS, TR and s imilar works are not italic ized since. though they seem to I'll ' titles, they are used as proper nouns to denote families of manusc ripts. Note 3: Many of the follo wing no uns are discussed in the collective plurals chapter, adon : " master" Adon : "Lord." Capitalized when used to refer to Yahveh, adonai: " my maste rts)." adonai, like adonim, is a plural form of
l I J OII I'f' .
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
4
Yael Natan
adonai is a plural of delegation. a type of co llective noun, when used to refer to a s ing le master who has dele gated authority to anothe r master or slave dri ver. A donai: " my Lo rdt s)." Adenai is c ap italized whe n used to refer to Ytlhl'ell. AdO/wi is a plural o f delegation. a type of co llective noun , whe n used to refer to a s ingle me mber of the Trinity. but a q ua ntitat ive plural or a plu ral collec tive noun whe n used 10 refer to two or the three persons of the Trinity. adonee : " my master" A do llee: " my Mas ter." Ca pitalized when used to refer to the Son o r Spiri t. No instances of Adoncc happe n to refer to the Fath er. A ta 1l-hu: " You-he" are pa ired pro noun s. ecn aa . "o ne:' or " united one" whe n referring 10 a group. echadim: " united ones" o r " a fe w." ehyeh asher ehyeh: "I AM who I AM" el: "god" El: "God:' Capitalized when refer ring to Yahveh, The Hebrew root means "mighty one : ' The plural is elohim. El S hadda i: "God of Mig hty Ones:' Shadd(/i is a " masc uline plural" accord ing to the Westmi nster Morphology a nd Lemma Data base (WTM ), Rele ase 3,5, Westmin ster T heo logica l Scrninary.Hjtjl. elah im : "god(s ): ' "etohi m" is a plura l of delegalion , a type o f collect ive nou n, when re ferring to a single false god among his cohorts, "e lo him" is a plural collec tive no un or a quantitative plural when referring 10 angels or human judges. Elo h im : "(Iodt s}." "Elohim" is c apitalized when used 10 refer to Yahl'eh . " E/o llim" is a plural of delegation , a type of collective nou n, when used to refer to a single member of the Trinuy. " tJolr im" is a quantitative plural or a plural collective no un when used to refer to two or three persons o f the Trinity. Elyon : "ElyrJl! " literally means " high," hUI is commonly imerpreted 10 mean "Most High" or "Highesl." haElohim : " [All) the God s" khayyim : Adjective meaning, "li ving." m alek : " messenger:' ofte n interpreted to mean "angel." Malek Yah veh : " Angel of Yahveh." Capitalized whe n used to refer to the Son. panim : "facers)," "pcrso nrs)," or " prese nee(s)." "panim" is a Hebrew dua l Iorm that ca n he singular or plural, depending on the co ntext. Panim : "Face ts)." " Pe rso n(s )" or "Pre se ncer sr" (o f Yu/ll'e"l. Pan im is capitalized whe n used 10 re fe r 10 the Son or Sp irit (E xo 33 :14- 15 ). Panim is a plural of delegation, a type of co llective no un, when used to refe r to a s ing le member of the Trinity. Pan im is a quan titative plural or a plural collective noun when used 10 refer to two or three persons of the Trinity. ru aeh : "spirit," " mind," or "w ind" Ruach : "Spim." Ruach is capitalized when used to refer 10 the Spirit. S hek inah, Tile: The Son or Sp irit who are the Pamm. In rabb inic theolo gy, however, the Shekm ah is a vis ible, imperson al manifestati on of the di vine presence . Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
5
Shema, The: SIU'Ina mean s, "Hear!" in Hebrew. T he Shema refers to Moses' stateme nt. "Hear. 0 Israel : Y ahveh [the Father] land] our Elohim [the So n), Yahveh [the Spirit] [are ) a united one [echadl" ( Deu 06:04). yachid: "sole : ' "a lo ne," " unique" Yahveh : " vahveh" is the per sonal na me of th e Heb rew God. rah veh is co mmo nly tran slated as " LORD" in English Bib les, and as Kurios, mean ing. " Lord," in the G reek LXX (the Se ptuagint). Yeshua: "Jesus" in English, or tesous in Koine Greek . Yes lrua is the Aramaic derivatio n of the Hebrew name Joshua. Aramaic and other languages were spoken in Palestine in Ye,~ h lla' s day. Bihle Book Name Ahbreviations Conventions All Bible book name abbreviations are three-lettered . This citation method has advantages o ver other abbreviatio n systems . T he thrr..re-let ter abbreviations arc the same as the first three letters of the English Bible book name, except in a few cases: • J udges (Jdg j a nd Phil e mo n (Phm) arc diffe rentiated f ro m J ude (J ud ) and Philippians (Phi), and • Song of Solomon is abbreviated "S ol" 10 avoid con fusion with the word "So n" For the most part, all three-lettered book name abbreviatio ns sort just as their corresponding book names would in searc h e ngines and indexes. T he e xceptions are Jud ges (1dg) and Jude (1ud). Jude, howe ver, is only one chapter in leng th, so this is not a major concern. Old Testament I. Gen: Genesis: 2. Exc: Exodus; 3. Lev: Le viticus; 4. Num: Numbers; 5. Deu: Deuteronomy; 6. Jcsr Joshua: 7. Jdg: Judges; 8. Rut: Ruth; 9. 15a: 1 Samuel; 10, 2Sa: 2 Samuel: 11. IKi: 1 Kings; 12. 2Ki: 2 Kings; 13. leh: 1 Chronicles; 14. 2eh: 2 Chronicles; 15. Ear: Ezra; 16. Nch: Nehem iah; 17. Est: Esther; l R. Job: Job: 19. Psa: Psalm; 20. Pro: Proverbs; 2 1. Eel': Ecclesiastes; 22. Sol: Song of Solomon ; 23. Isa: Isaiah; 24. Jer: Jeremiah ; 25. Lam: Larnemation s: 26. Eze: Ezekiel; 27. Dan : Darnel; 28. Hos : Hosea; 21). Joe: Joe l: 30. Amo: Amos; 3 1. Oba: Obadiah; 32. Jon: Jonah; 33. Mtc: Micah ; 34. Nah: Nahum: 35. lIab: Hab akkuk; 36. Zep: Zephaniah; 3 7 . lI a ~ : Haggai ; 38, Zec : Zechariah; 39. ~lal : Malachi . Ne w Testament
40. Mat : Matt he w; 41. Mar: Mark: 42. Luk: Luke: 43. Joh: John: 44. Act: Acts: 45. Rom : Rom ans; 46. I Co : 1 Cor inthians; 47. 2eo: 2 Corin thians; 48.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
6
Yael Na ta n
Gal: Galatians; 49. Eph: Ephes ians; 50. Phi: Philippians; 51. Col: Co lossians: 52. lTh: 1 Thessa lonians: 53. 2Th: 2 Thessalonian s: 54. lTi: I Timothy; 55. 2Ti: 2 Timothy: 56. Tit: Titus; 57. Phm: Philemon; SR. Heb: Hebrews; 59. Jam: James; 60 . IPe: I Pete r; 61. 2Pc: 2 Pete r; 62. Ijn: I Jo hn; 63. 2Jo: 2 John: 64. 3Jo: 3 Jo hn; 65 . Jud: Jude; 66. Rev: Revelat ion.
Citation Convention for the Bible and Koran All the chapter and verse Bible c itations arc two-digit, for e xa mple. Mat 0 1: 01. exce pt fo r Psalms. which has three-d igit c hapter refere nces. Lead ing zeroes are used when necessary. for e xample. Psa 00 1:01. This method of c itatio n me ans that the chapter and verse c itations sort nume rically in search e ng ines and indexes. All the chapter and verse c itations for the Koran are three-digit [Koran 009:(05 ). "Sura(h)" is Arabic and re fers to the 114 chapte rs of the Kora n.
Other Books, References and Abbreviations 11\1a: First Macca bees (lnrertesrame ntal apoc ryphal book] 2~la : Seco nd Macca bees (lnrcrtcsturncntal apocryphal book) a.k.a.: A bbreviation for "abo kno wn as" BlJB: Brown, Driver; Bri,;,;.\ : Hebrew-A ramaic and English texicon of the or BHS: Bibtia Hehraica Stung ortensia (an annotated MT rece nsion) DSS : T he Dead Sea Scrolls and fragme nts fo und in the twen tie th ce ntury at Qu mran and its environs near the Dead Sea . Most of the scrolls that survived were stored in day jan; in ca ves. Hadith: A repo rt o f the sayings o r actions of Muh ammad or his co mpanio ns, toge ther with the tradit ion o f its chain o f tra nsmissio n {isnad j. T he plural is Hadith or Hadiths. ISBE : lntemannnat Standard Bible Encyclopedia, 19 34 (Public Domain) Jdt: Judith (Intertestamental apoc ry phal book) KJV: King Ja mes Version of the Bible (English) Koran : Th e s ac red tex t of Islam , c ons ide red by M us li ms to co ntai n the re ve lations of Allah 10 M uham mad . Koran is a lso spelled Qu r 'all. Quran and Alcorcm , LXE: The English Tran slation of The SepWlIKint Ve n ;oll of the OM Tes tament (LXE), by Sir Lance lot C. L. Brenton. 1844, 1851, published by Sa muel Begsrer and Son s, London. LXX: T he Septuagint is a second and third ce ntury B.C. G reek translation of the OT a nd so me apocryphal boo ks. 1\IT: The Masoret ic Te xt (OT He bre w and Ara ma ic) is a rec en s ion. A de fi nitio n o f a recensio n is: A critical revision of a te xt incorporating the eleme nts deemed most plausible from varying sources.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
7
The MT recension was compiled from vario us Hebrew manuscripts by Talmudic acade mies in Babyloni a and Pa lesti ne du ring the 6th to 10t h cen turies AD. The name of the te xt comes from Ta lmu dic academy of the Masore tes. meaning. "Traditionalists." that flouri shed in Tiberias o n the Sea of Galilee between the 7th ami 9th ce nturies AD. The oldest surviving MT recensio n manu script is the "Cairo Prophets" (895 AD), which was prod uced by Moses ben Asher in 'l'iberias. Galilee. The second oldest MT recen sio n manuscript is the Lenin grad Codex of the Latter Prophets (916 AI)). which has Babylonian vowel pointing. T his book so me times uses the ter m MT as an inc lusive te rm for the MT recensio n and the family of manu scripts that served as the bas is fo r the MT recens ion. This fa mily of manusc ripts no longer exists except fo r scrolls found a mong the Dead Sea Scro lls. NIV: New international Ver.l'itJII , 19&4 (US English Bible) NT : New Testament (the origin al was written in Kaine G reek) D'T: Old Testament (Jewish Tanakh) (the original is in Hebrew, but parts are in Aramaic). RSV: Revised Standa rd Ven 'iml (1952 ) (English Bible) Sir: Wisdom of S ir uch (a n Intertestam en ta l apocryphal book, u.k .a., Ecclesiastic us) Sanna: The way of life prescribed as no rmative in Islam, based bo th on t he teachin gs and practices of Muhammad , and on exegesis of the Koran, TR: Textus Receptus. from the Latin mean ing, " Received Te xt," This is t he Greek text of the New Testame nt that was standard in printed editio ns from the 16th to the end of the 19th century. TWOT: The Theological Wordbook of IIII' OT Yl.T: The EnXIi.\'h Young \ Literal Transiution of the Holy Bible 18621 181171 189&(YL 1) by J N. Young WEB : The WorM English Bible is o ne of the public dom ain versions of the OT and NT in modern Eng lish that is downloadab le from ebible.org. The WER NT consistently follows the Greek Majority Text, but provides footnot es noting any significant variant readings listed in these Greek NT recensions: Textus Recep tus (TR), Nestle- Aland (NA) , and United Bibl e Societv (UBS).
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Matenal com direlbs autorars
Synopsis of the Jewish Trinity A oe; u~t i llc ~ .. iJ
Ll,.. t
C lll i ~ t\,I U e;) i~
la tent ill tl,,: OT. d lld p..tc lIL ill th e NT. '
Christian s have app lied Augustine's analysis to oth er d istin ctively Christian doctr ine s. Fo r instan ce. co nvent io nal wisdom says tha t wh ile the d oc tri ne of the Trinity was implic it in the OT. it is exp lic it in the NT.1 s This book shows that if on e reads the or without wear ing unitarian blinder s. the or is as e xplici t abo ut the Trinit y as the NT. The reade r of this book will co me to know the OT as ancient Trinitarian Yahvists knew the OT -a book replete with Trinitaria n proof's ,
Synopsis of Cha pter 01: The Syntax War Between Trinitarian s and Unitarians Th is chapter deals with the main d ifference between the ancien! read ing and the modem reading of the O'I; The ancients read the several thousand plurals that refer to }(Ih ~'eh as collective nouns with different nuance s. Collective no uns that refer to }(,hre!l are pote nt Trinitarian proofs, espec ially co nsidering the sheer number o f instances. During Inrertestame nta l times. unitar ian reade rs argued thaI all plurals referring to Yo hreh were maje stic plurals. The majestic plural propon ents said that plurals referri ng to Yahl'eh indicate majesty, but do not hin t at the e xistence of persons ca lled Yalll'ell. T his c hapter shows that the majestic plural usage is a n incorrect rea din g o f thousand s of plurals referr ing to vahven. and that the se plurals, in fact, consuu ne Trinitarian proo fs.
Synopsis of Chapter 02: Proto-Slnaluc Trinitarianism At Mount Sina i, the So n revealed that h is name was Yahveh. Previously, o nly the Fath er was known as Yah vch, So Gene sis contai ns both the Proto-Gospel (Ge n 0 3: 15) and Pro to-Sinairic Trinitarianism. In Ge nesis. the Fa ther was kno wn as Yahveh and the Most High ( /:'/yon) . the Son was known bo th as God of Mighty On es (EI Shaddai) a nd as the Ma lek }(111I'eh. and the Spirit was know n as the Spirit (RIUK h). The Trinity was know n as hatilohim, literally. "[All] the Gods." This analysis of Gene sis is co nfirmed by ex amining the Genesis na rrat ive. as well as other sect io ns of the OT that refer back to Gene sis. T he Trinitarian interp retatio n of Gene sis debu nks the J ED P theor y. Also, the theories that say the Masek Ya lll'en was a mere creature. or was imperso na l. are refuted.
Synopsis of C ha pter 03: The Presences of Elyon T his c hapte r di sc usses the Presen ce s of Etvon. Im por tant passages incl ude how the Israeli te s saw the " Living G ods" tkhuvvim E/on;m) (De u 0 5:26) d uring Matenal com direlbs autcrars
10
Yael Natan
the giving of the law. Moses said that at the giving of the law. "[ AllJ the Gods" (haElohim) stood on three mountains: This is the blessing that Moses the man of [Ali i the Gods [IIlIEfoh im] pronounced on the Israe lite s before his death. Yah vrh [the Father] came from Sinai. and Ithe Sonl dawn ed over them from Sc tr: he [the Spirit] shone forth from Mount Paran. He [the Father] came with myriads of holy noes from the so uth. from his [the "ather 's) mountain slopes (Deu 33:01-02) . La ter, the Father sent his Presence s, the Son and Sp irit, to Canaan. The Father said: 'My Presences (plural noun). they will go [plural verb] with you, and I will g ive you rest. ' Then Moses said to him, ' Your Presences [plural noun I, if they do not go [plural verb] with us. do not send us up from here' (Exo 33:14-15). T he Pre sence s' o the r appearances in the OT are al so discussed.
Synopsis of C hapte r
()~:
The Shema
The Shema is a simple Tr initarian form ula: Hear. 0 Israel : rah veh [the Fathe r] lan d ] o ur Elohim [the Son], Yahveh [the S piritllarc] 11 united o ne k d wdl (Dc u 06:04). The correct interpretation and import of the Shl'lna ca n he inferred from OT Sht'nw- Iike statements (Hos 11:06; I'-Cc 14:0lJ). Ye.l,hail's short vers io n of the Shem« is, " 1 and the Father are one" (Joh 10:30). When ever Ye,~ hlla d iscussed the Snema, he a lwa ys mentions two or three o f the divine persons of the Trinity, fo r instance: • After quoting the Shema (M at 22:36-40 ), veshua said that David was inspired by the Spirit when David sa id that the Fathe r and So n we re his Lord (Psa 110: 01. OS: Mat 22 :43-45; Mar 12:36-37: Luk 20:42, 44 ),and • After speaking a Shema·like statement, "I and the Fat her are one" (Joh 10:30), Ye.I'hail said that the jud ges to who m the word of God ca me were called "gods" (Psa Ol'l2:06: Joh 10:35 ). YeS/lUG adde d: What about the o ne whom the Father set apa l1 as his very own and sent into the world? (psa 0&2:0& ; Joh 10: 36a). Yeshua here alluded to Yahveh the Fat her 's state ment to the Son in the same Psalm : Rise up, 0 God [the Son] and judge the eart h, for all the nations are your [the Son' s] inheritance (Psa 082:08: Joh 1O: 36a)!
Synopsis of C ha pter 05: The Trinity in Daniel 01·05 Da niel infonned Ncb uchadnczzur that the go lde n head of his d rcnmscapc stat ue re pre se nted Ne buch adn e zxar's kingd om, the Bab ylon ian Empire, T he statue's other body parts represen t succeed ing ki ngdom s down to the e nd of time as we kno w it.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
11
The gold head showed that 11 disti ng uishing characteristic of Ncbuchadnczzar's kingdom was wea lth. The other body parts were made of inferior me tals and clay to show that the distingu ishing characteristics of subseq uent kingdoms would not be wealth. Th e gold head also reve aled that a d isti ngui shing c ha racteristic of Neb uchad nezz ats kingdom was ho mogene ity. Hi s was a un if ied kin gdom. The Modo-Pe rsian that followed was bifurcated as shown in the arms unite d to the torso. Alexander's kingdom bifurcated into the Sclcucid and Ptolemaic dynasties, as was shown hy the bronze thig hs. Rome was divided into the Western Latin-speaking and Eastern G reek-speaking parts, as was shown by the two iron calves. T he Rom an Empire dissolved leaving nations of iron to exis t in the midst of nations of d ay. In the end the Son wou ld establish a kingdom not built o n the fou ndations of the old kingdom s represe nted in the statue. The Son's kingdom would last fo rever. Ncbuchadnczznr saw the Son in Da n 03:25, and Daniel saw the Son in the Dan 07 So n of Man vision. T here is a relati onship between the statue of Nebuch adnezzars dream (Dan 02) and the golden statue that Neb uchad nezzar built (Dan 03 ). Nebuchadnezzar'v landscape statue of Dan 03 was like the drcamscapc statue of Dan 02, but was golde n from head to toe (Da n 03). Ncb ucha d nczzur's stat ue represented Ncb ucha d nczzurs prayer to his gods. Nebuchadnezz ar wanted his gods to veto Y(/h ~'eh 's plan to cut Nebuchadnezzars gol den kingdom off at the neck -hen ce, the gold frnm head to toe. Nebuchad nezzur wanted the Babylonian Empire to be the sole empire until the end of the world, and not ju st until the Medo -Persian Empire was formed. Danie l inst r uc ted Nebuc ha dnezza r about vahveh, the " Most High ," just as Jo se ph had instructed Egy ptia n roy a lty (Gen 45: 08; Psa 105 : 17-22 ). Ncbuchadnczz ur used OT Trinitarian rcr rninology that Moses, Josh ua. ami others had used. Neb uchadnezzar's Trinitarian speec h is recorded in Dan 02 -03. By Dan 04, it seems Nebuchadnezzar ma tured into a full-fledged Trinitarian, as his letter to his subjects shows (Dan 04).
Synopsis of Chapter 06: The Prophet Behind the Prophets The OT prophetic books should be read as the words of the prcmcur natc So n rather than as the word s of the prophets. The few phrases and sections that are ob vious words of the prophets shou ld he considered mere inspired interjectio ns. That the OT prophetic books can. for the most part. be understood as the wo rds of the Son impl ies Trinitarianism. In OT prophetic boo ks, first pe rson speech (for example . " I: ' "me," " my") sho uld gene rally be read as the words of the So n. Q uotations are most often the words of the Father as q uoted b)! the Son. Third person speec h (for exa mple. "he ,' "h im," "his") referring to Yaln'eh generally is the Son speak ing abou t the Fathe r or the Spirit. Matenal com direlbs autcrars
12
Yael Na ta n Synopsis of Chapter 07: Various OT Presentations of the Trinity
Ezekiel, Jo nah and Zecha riah g ive interest ing pre se ntat ions o f th e T rin ity. Jo nah di sti ngui shed between Yahveh t he father and the Presences of Yahveh, who are the So n and Spirit. Jonah' s Trinita rian lan gu age includes me nt ion of "[All] the Gods" (htlEloh im) and " Yf/hreh Elohim." In Eze kiel and Zec hariah. both the Spirit and Son take on vari ous roles, call each othe r Yahveh, and refer to the Father and quote the Father.
Synopsis of Chapter 08: The NT Use of OT Yahveh Texts Th e fir st part of this cha pter concerns NT q uotation s and allus ions to O'T Yl/hl'eh texts. Man y exam ples are give n in the append ix that com plements this chapter. Th e list o f NT a llus ions and q uotat ions to O'T Yahveh text is meant to be representative rather th an ex haus tive. The second part of th is chap ter concerns whether reshua pr imarily spo ke Gree k or Ara maic. T his has some bearing on whet her Yeshua ident ified h imself as: • Yahveh the Son hy his applying O'T Yahveh tex ts to himsel f, • Th e d ivine Son of Ma n described in the Dan 07 vision (as is d iscu ssed in the Song of Mo ses c hap ter), • The -t AM" (as is disc ussed in the " I AM" and the Song of Moses chapt ers), and • The subjec t o f the Shema along wi th the Father a nd the Spirit (as is di scu ssed in the Silemil c hapter). The evidence will show that Yes/ilia spoke both Ara ma ic and Gree k. Gal ilee , where YO'hua grew, was hom e to many ge ntiles who tended to spea k Gree k. W hile Aramaic was mo re prevalent in Judea , inscri ptions an d literary evidence show that Greek was common the re , too. G iven Yeshua 's lang uage ab ilities, it is implaus ible that he inadve rtently gave the impression that he was, for instance, the "I AM." His audie nces were ast ute enoug h to kno w what Yeshua was say ing, and they eve n tried to sto ne Yes/ilia mo re tha n o nce for blasphemy. Not once d id Yl'shua say he was m isundcrstood . T he NT writ ers kne w both Arama ic and Gree k, and the)' were fam iliar with the O'T He bre w. Th is me ans tha t th e NT wr ite rs conscio us ly ap plied O'I " I A M" sta tements and Yahveh texts to YeS/ilia. G iven the ir language abi lities. they faithfu lly recorde d Yeshua 's stateme nts, ami no meaning was inadve rten tly added or lost during tra nslatio n or tra nscription.
Synopsis of Chapter 09: The "I Alit-I" Statements Ya/weh the Son was the d ivine spea ker of Exo 03 - 06, as was d iscussed in the cha pter on Proto-S ina itic Trinitarian ism. Yahl'eh the Son said in Hebrew: I AM who I A M [Hebrew: "ehveh asher ellyell"1. Th is is wha t yo u are to say to the Israeli tes: ' I AM fellyell1 has sent me to you' (Exo 0 3:14 ). The Greek LXX version reads: Matenal com direlbs autcrars
13
The Jewi sh Trinity
I AM [Greek: eRII' dmi ) WHO IS [ho II'n). ..WH O IS [ho wn].. .(LXX Exo 0 3; 14). No te thai the Hebre w wo rd etryeh mentioned three times in Exo 03;14 is translated as "(',IIw eimi" and wn." T his c hapte r disc usses the occ urrences where Yeshua and thc NT writers applied "e,tiw eimi" and "ho wn" to Ycshua . In this way. the NT writers show that Yes/lifo is Yuhl'ell the So n- the divine spea ker in Exo 03.
'"'/0
Synopsis of Chapter 10: The Song of Moses (Deu 32) The So ng of Mo.'iCS shows God's stra tegy for sav ing Jews and gentiles. The Father's slrategy is to try to save errant Israel by every means possible. lastly by se nding his Son. The So n is far superio r to Moses. After being rejected by the Je wish leaders. the Son turns to save the gen tiles. This has the effect of making Israel jealous enoug h to come back into the Trinity's fold. O ne sect ion in th is chapter presents a So n of Man theo logy where the Dan 07 So n of Man is linked to the Proto-Gospel (Gen 03; 15). The cha pter ends with a discussion on how the Son is far superior to Moses in that the Son is: • The '" AM," • The Son of Man (Dan 07), and • God the So n. Synopsts of Appendix A: J\.fT Plurals Referring to Yahveh This ap pendix disc usses plurals referrin g to Yahn,h tha t are fo und In 3K chapters of IK MT books. The se arc plural verbs. adjectives and noun s other than the comm on plural noun Elohim (literally, "Gods"). All plurals referring to Yahveh sho uld be considered Trinit arian proo fs. Synopsts of Appendix B: OT Texts That Suggest or Speak of the Deity of the Messiah This appendi~ lists the texts. provides a short summary statement of each text, and directs the reader to where there is further discussion of eac h text. Synopsis of Appendix C: Trinitarian Proofs Thi s appendix first summarizes fo ur categories of Trinitarian proo fs. Fo ur categorie.s of Trinitarian proofs are : I, Many passages thai are prima facie evidence for the doctrin e of Trinity co ntain MT o r LXX plurals referring to Yahveh, Examples include the " us" in Gen 0 1: 26: 03:22: II :07 and lsa 06:0K. More examples are found in the M Y plurals appendix.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
14
Yael Na ta n
2. OT Yahrch texts applied to ind ividual pe rsons o f the Tr inity in the OT and NT arc prima facie evidence for the do ct rine o f Trinity. The se arc di scu ssed in the "I AM" and Song of Moses chapters. as well as in the NT use of OT Yah veh texts c hapter and its co mplementary ap pendi x thai goes by the same name. J. Texis that suggest o r speak to the de ity of the Messiah shou ld be cons idered indire ct proofs o f the Trinity. T hese proo fs are su mmarized in a table in a separate append ix, and 4. Gen eral Trinitari an proofs are listed with an e xplanation in this Trinitarian proofs ap pendi x. Synopsis of Appendix D: A Sampling oflhe NT US(' nfOT Yahveh Texts A list o f OT Yahveh text-, quo ted or al luded 10 in the NT is pro vided with an ex planation of their s ignificance . The pa~~ age~ are grouped according to the person or persons of (he Trinity to w hom the OT Yanl'en (e xt is applied.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Chapter 1 The Syntax War Between Trinitarians and Unita rians
The or Battleground T he task of a uansl ator a nd interpreter is 10 e xpress the sutho rs intended meaning in another language . Th e qu andary is thaI the intended meaning of the or a uthors is in d ispute. We re the or a uthors unitarian as is supposed by the rabb inic unitaria ns. Prote stant Unitarians , Jehovah 's Witne sse s, O nene ss Pe ntecostal s and othe rs'! Did the aut ho rs of the or j ust hint o f the Trinity as main stream Ch ristian sc holars co ntend"? O r were the authors of the or full-fledged Trin itarian s? O ne m ight as k. " Just ho w d id such diverge nt vie ws o f the OT de velop?" T his is surprising ly simp le to explain. Many layme n will be surprised to know that, with ju st a few e xce pt ions. thousand s o f O'T He brew plural s re ferring to Yalll,,'h a re translated a s singulars. Th ese plurals are tran slated as singulars because rabb inic an d Christ ian sc holars are tau ght that all plurals referring to Ya hveh are maje stic pl ura ls. The majestic plura l sy ntax is counter intuitive in thaI the plural for m supposed ly doe s not ind icate an y so rt of plurality in the god head . A majestic plural. as the name indi cate s. supposed ly speaks o nly of ¥llhl'eh's majesty. Mo st C hrist ian sc ho lars grudg ing ly accept the e xiste nce of majest ic plurals. Th ey quickl y point o ut. ho we ver. that maje stic plurals accommoda te the doctrine of the Trini ty. and e ven hint that Yahl'eh is the Trin ity. Christian scholars bolster these asse rtions by referring to the OT and NT Trinitarian proofs. By contrast , thi s boo k contend s that the OT wr iters would find the majesti c pl ural rationa lization to he a fore ign co ncept. Like wi se. the OT pro phets wo uld assert that the unitarian misi r ne rpr eta no n of t he OT was adopted first d urin g Intertestamemel tunes. They wou ld assert th at the real reason why people do not believe in the Trinity is the y do not want to listen to Moses (Joh 05:47 ; Luk 16 :3 1). A casual read ing of the NT reve als that Yeshua and the NT w riters wou ld not agree with the assertio n th at the OT merel y hint s at the Trinity. T he NT w riters speak of the Fathe r. Son and Spirit w itho ut an introd uct ion . without apo logy, and without any sense of no ve lty. Th e NT writers knew the Trinity to he read ily apparent in the OT. That many Jew s read ily became Christians sho ws that the y too Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Yael Natan
16
had a Trinitarian o utlook on the OT. The apostles sa id that the NT merely made the word s o f the prophet s abo ut the de ity o f the Me ssiah mo re certain (2Pc 01 : 16, 19). So to summar ize. thi s c hapte r de als with a princip le di ffere nce bet ween the ancien! read ing and the modern reading of the OT. The ancients read the seve ral tho usand pl ural no un s referring to Ya hve h as co llec tive no uns wi th differ e nt
nuances. These collective nouns are potent Trinitarian proofs. especiall y cons ide ring how often they occ ur in the OT. Mode rns. howe ver, read thes e sam e plural nouns as majestic plurals. Supposed maje stic plurals indic ate majesty, but in no way hint that there arc person s ca lled ranven.
Hebrew Couec nve Noun s Be fore t he di sc ussion of Hebrew co llec tive nou ns heg ins in ea rne st. it is wort hw hile to note that Hebre w is like other lan guages in that it has its ow n d istinctive sy ntax. For insta nce. an American English speaker migh t think it odd that in Hebrew: • Coll ectiv e noun s. wheth er s ingular or plural . can lake plural verb s and pred icates. and • Plura l collect ive nou ns can refer to a single gro up. and can take s ingular verbs and modifiers. Hebrew collective noun us.age is not entirel y di fferent from that o f other languages . A case in point is that British Eng lish uses collective nou ns muc h like a ncie nt Hebrew. bu t A merica n Engli sh docs less so . The Am ah-a n Her itage Dictionarv of the Eng lish ulIlglw ge states: In Amer ican usage. a co llec tive nou n ta kes a s ingular verb when it refers to the co llectio n cons idered as a whole. as in Tilt' fwnily was united on this question. The enemy is s ui/lg for peace. It take s a plu ral verb when it refers to the members of the group considered as individua ls. as in My f am il), are alW(/.I'.I' fi ghting among themse lves. The enemy were showing ul' in groups of th ree o r fo ur to fil m in their wea"OIIS. In British usage. ho we ver. co llective nouns are more oft en treat ed as plura ls: The government have 1I0t announce d a nell' policy. The tea m a re pl(lyillK ill the test matches next week. A co llective noun should no t be treated as both singular and plural in the same co nstruction: thus The family is de termined 10 p re.I'.\' its (not the ir) claim ... •
Singular Collective Nouns with Plural Predicates The famo us Hebraist. H. W. F. Gesenius (1 7R6-1842 AD) wrote thai Hebre w s ing ular coll ec tive nou ns " read ily" have plural predic ate s.' He re arc a fe w examples: • Joseph sa id. "T he whole eart h [singular] came [plural verb]" (Gen 41:57). so persons are indicated by the s ingular "earth,"
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
17
The Jewish Trinity
• " Each man IHebrew singular is cn'''1threw down [plural verb) his staff" (Exo 07:12). • " Each man [singular ct'sh] gat her [plural impe rative] as much as he needs" (Bxo 16:l(i), • "So man (sin gular CCJh ] lies dow n [s ingu lar verb] and rises [s ing ular verb] not aga in: till the hea vens are no more they will not aw ake [plural verb). or be roused Iplural verb) o ut o f thei r sleep" (Job 14:12), • "Surely ma n [singular cnh ] walks abou t [sing ular verb] as a shadow ! Surely. for nothing they strive [plural verb] : man acc umulates [singular verb] and doe s not know [sing ular verb]" (Psa 0 39:06 (Bl/S 0 39:07)). • "They o pen [plura l verb] their mo uth [singular noun]" (Jnh 16: Ill), and • "The ev il man [singu lar cesh )" (Pro 0 2:1 2) is the subject o f the plural ve rbs " leaves," "ex ults" and "are devious" (Pro 02: 13- 15).
Plural Collecttvc Nouns with
Si ll~ u la r
Predicates
Hebrew co llec tive nou ns tha t refer to a gro up may be plural, ye t can take s ing ular pred icates . Here are some ex amples: • " Luminaries" takes a singular ve rb (vter be " ) in Gen 0 1:14a. but plural verbs in GenO I: 14b-16, • "Nations and a gro up o f nations" take a sing ular verb (Gcn 35: I I). • "Childre n" takes a sing ular verb (Exo 10 :24), • " People" takes sing ular ve rbs (E xo 20 :18: Jo s 24: 16 , 2 1), but ca n also take plural verbs (Jc s 24: 16. 2 1, 24), • "A nima ls" takes a singular verb (Job 12:07 ), and • " Wo rthless ido ls" take s the singular verb " pass away" (Isa 02: 18).
The Hebrew Plural Collective Noun Hlohim. lite rallJ "Gods" The Athanasian Creed speaks ag ainst the here sy of Trirheism. and warn s aga inst speaking o f the Tr inity as "Gods" or "Lords." T he Athnnasian Creed was written in the wester n churc h in the sixth ce ntury by an un kno wn author who may have had no famil iarity with the Bible in the origina l langua ges." The Athanasian Creed co ncerns doctrine, and sho uld not necessar ily be interpre ted as an exegetical ga g rule. Exegetes can disc uss the fact that the literal translations of plural form s referring 10 Yahveh are plural. What to make of that fact. and how to express it doctrina lly, is where the Athanasian C reed becomes helpfu l. The Hebrew plural co llective no un Elo him/elohim (lite rally, "Gods" o r "gods") occ urs 2,600 times in 2,247 MT verse s. Most instances refe r to Yohveh, but d ohim is also used to refer to angels (Psa 008:005 [BHS 008:006]), judges (Exo 2 1:06: 22: 08 -09 (BHS 22:07·08); los 24:0 1), rulers (Psa 082:01 , 06), as well as fal se gods and idols . The a ncient Hebrews co nsidered Elo him 10 be a plural co llec tive nou n. or a nuanced co llective no un, denoting the persons of the Trinity. Elohim was no t used to re fe r to Yahreh in any polythei stic se nse. Like other Hebrew plura l collecti ve Matenal com direlbs autcrars
18
Yae l Na tan
no uns. Elohim/elohim co uld ta ke sing ula r o r pl ural ve rbs a nd mo difie rs. Fo r e xample . E/ohimlelohim co ukl ta kc: • S ingu lar mod ifiers. for exam ple, " The ir gods Id ohim) will be [p lural ve rb] a snare [singular noun I" (Exo 23 :33; Jdg 0 2:03), • Si ngular verbs , fo r instance, "The God /gods IE lohim/eiohim] who a nswe rs [s ing u lar ve rb ] hy fir e -he is Elol!im " ( I Ki IR:24 ). No te tha t e it her the ha ttaaltm (" the Baals" ) ( I Ki l X: JK). who are 8(.w{ an d Ashcrah ( IKi 18: 19), or " the Word" (the Son ) (I Ki 18 :01 , 3 1) and the Sp irit (I Ki 18 : 12). are the co llccuvc subjec t of the cond itional sente nce (I Ki 18 :24 ), • P lural verbs and modifiers such as: o "... gods [c!olrim] are near [plura l modi fier ].. .' (De u 04:07). o ... ..make us gods Id ohim! who will go [plural verb ) before us ..." (Exo 32: 01 ,23), o ... ..gods [d ohim ) ne ither see.. . hear.. .ear... smell. .. .. (plural verbs ] (Deu 04: 28 ), and o The plu ral verbs and modi fier referring to Yah" ch (Ge n 20: 13: 35:07 ; Exo 32: 04, 08; Jo s 24: 19 and the like) thai are me ntioned in the MT plura ls appendix. Sometimes Hebrew speakers used s ing ular and plural verbs with Elohim in the same convers ation. This tend s to pro ve that Etohim was inde ed con side red a co llective noun. Por instance , Sennachenb 's o ffice rs asked in He bre w (2K i 1R:2R): Ho w can yo ur Flohim [God s) deliver [singular verb] you o ut of m ine hand (2C h 32 : 14)? .. How m uch le ss sha ll yo ur Elohim [pl ural no un] del iver (plural ve rn ] )'O U out of my hand (2C h 32: I S)! T he chro n icler wrote , "Se unacher tb's offi ce rs spo ke further ag a ins t Yah veh Hlohim" (2Ch 32: 16). Other passage s w ith singular and plural ver bs refe rring to Elohim can be fo und in the MT plura ls append ix. Plural co llective nouns used with singular verbs sugges t that then: are the plu ral mem bers of " a united" (ed1at£) group. So the plural Elohim (literally. "Gods") used w ith a singu lar verb is meant to emphas ize that then: an: three perso ns of the Trinity. Like wise. the plural form "gods" (e1ohim) is used with sing ular verbs to refer to a false god and his goddess eon sort or progeny. Other plural coll ective nouns that an: s im ilar to Etohim an: hllt.:lohim (" (A ll J the Gods" ), Adontli (" my Lord s" ) and adonai ("my masters" ). T hese word s an: d iscussed in depth later in this chapter. A form s im ilar to the collectiv e noun Etotsim is the p lura l co llect ive no un Mitsrayim. M it.l m yim can be tran slated as a sing ular co llec tive noun " Egy pt" (Gen 13:10 ; 15: 18), or as a plural collect ive noun " Egy ptians," according to contextua l clues. For ex ample : • In Exo 14:25 Mitsravim is used w ith two singular verbs (" he sa id" and "let me ge t away" ), but bot h times M il.l-ray im shou ld be translated in the plura l as " T he Egy ptians sa id , ' Let us ge t away," . and • In Exo 14:1 8 a plural verb is used with Mitsrayim; so Mo ses must have meant the plural Mitsravim to be translated in the plura l as " the Egyptian s will know," rather th an in the singular as " Egypt wi ll know ." Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
19
So the plural form Mitsrayim can bc tra nslated as a singu lar collective noun, "Egypt," or as a plural co llective noun, " Eg)'ptians." T his suggests that the p lura l form Elohim sho uld, depend ing on the context. be tre ated as a sing ular collecti ve nou n (God ), or as a p lural cotlecuve no un re ferr ing to the persons o f l'c!hw-I,. For example. Yahl'eh is a " God IE/ohi",! o f God s IE/ohi", !, and Lord IAdonail of Lo rds [AdO/llIi]" (com pare l os 22:22; Psa 050:01; Isa 26: 13; Dan 0 2:47; 11;36; m 06 :15; Rev 17:14; 19:1 6) . Etohim , a plura l to rm, can be trans lated as "God" o r " Gods." Th e plural form Adonai can he translated as " Lord" o r " Lords." In the above-listed pass.age s. the first Elohim and Adonai o f eac h phrase shou ld be tra nslated as a sing ular collecti ve nou n. w hile the second Eloh im and Adona; of eac h ph rase shou ld be con side red a pl ural collective no un: "God of God s" and " Lord of Lo rds." The sing ular co llective no un emphas izes YalH'eh 's unity, while the plura l co ltccnve no un emphas izes that the re are persons called Yahveh, Tha t one phrase ha s both singu lar and plura l collective nouns referr ing to Yahl'e!l indicates that Yllhrt'h is the Trinity: o ne God. yet three person s. Th e " God of Gods and Lord of Lord s" passages are similar to the Shema in that they are Trinitar ian express ions. The Shemo is men tioned late r in th is c hapter, and in the chapte r o n the Sncma .
Weaknesses of th e Majestic Plur al Hypothesis Grammar issues c an rest for a moment as other issues with broad imp lications are here d isc ussed. A bird's eye v iew of the deb ate reve als that there are so me obv ious weak nesses in the majestic plu ral hypothe sis.
Exceptions Become the R" le Rath er Tha ll Lsest "Proving fin the sense of "Testing "j the R ute .. A we akness o f the maj est ic plural hy pothes is is th at the proo fs co ns ist of except io na l examples where pl ural no u ns see m ing ly refer to s ing le perso ns or objec ts. In the majestic p lural schem a. the lesso ns dr awn from e xcept ional examp les de termin e the tr an sl at ion and in te rp re tati o n of tho usan ds of wo rds. Rather than letti ng "the exceptions pro ve [in othe r words, "test"] the rule"-as th e proverb says,' majestic plura l proponcn ts say, "Tbc e xcept ions are thc ru le ." The re are at least two pitfall s involved when us ing e xce pt ions to e xp lain the majority o f insta nces. Firs\, exce ptions hy de fin ition are always fe w, and th us are easie r to misconstrue. The misinterpretation is then used to d isto rt the meaning of man) words. Second, even if exce ptional data were inte rpreted co rrectly, the connection between the exceptions and thc mass of da ta that thc exceptions supposed ly ex plain may be ten uo us. What this mcans is th at eve n if a few exce ptions arc prove n to be majes tic p lura ls, this doe s not necessarily me an there are thou sands o f majestic plurals in the OT. Matenal com direlbs autcrars
20
Yael Natan
Analogous s ituations where erroneo us e xtrapolations could be drawn from sca nt data include: • If o ne dete rmi ned what Eng lish gra mmar rules are by anal yzing the e xce ptional for ms " its" and "u's." o ne would mistake co ntractio ns for possessives. and abbre viation s for possessives. "Its" looks plural, but is really a possessive prono un, and "u'svlooks like a possessive prono un. but is really the abbreviated fo rm of "it is." • A planet might be mistaken for a star, or vice versa , but this does not mean all luminaries are planets, and • A Tom Clancy fiction novel might be mistaken for history. but this doe s not mean that Tom Clanc y is a historian rather than a novelist. Stat istically speaking, it is unwise to suppose that thousands of OT majestic plurals exist based on the ana lysis of a few examples. Per haps the majestic plural rationalization e xists merely because no one has bothered to offe r viab le alte rnativ e explanatio ns. I use the word "viable" because theol ogical liberals have offered altcmativc explanations. Liberal s commonly believe that the majestic plura l rationali zatio n was unknown in the patr iarchal and Mosaic periods. Man y liberals believ e that the Hebrew plurals refe rring to Yahl'e11 act ua lly are vestiges of mcnolatry (hcnothcismj. binitarianism, or pol ythe ism." Mon ol atr) is the belief tha t the re art: many gods worth y of wor ship, but th at eac h person o ught to choose o ne god to worsh ip and ig no re the o t he rs. Binitananism is the worship of two divine persons who arc worshipped as one god. Of course. these theories are flawed in that they do not satisfactor ily e xplain all the data. The ev idence calls out for a Trinitarian ex planatio n, but the call has falle n o n deaf cars until now. Som eone migh t ask , "Wh y must anyon e t hin k up e xplanatio ns for pl ural forms?" The answer is that there is no surviving ancie nt Hebrew grammar book that states how the He brew Scripture should be translated. So a Hebrew grammar must be based on the study of the language itself. This is problcm anc al becau se languages tend to becom e regular and less complicated o ver time. Inscriptions and archaic word form s may be the only evidence that certain words. usages, cases and conjuga tions e ve r exi sted. Unfortunately. there are fe w undis puted sa mples of e xtra- Biblica l, anci ent Hebrew. These are mainly found on walls and porshard s. Unlike some ancie nt Innguages, ancient Hebrew seems to have been written almost ent irely on perishable materials. Whole libraries went up in smoke or disintegrated to d ust in a process that began already in OT times (2K i 22:08). There are only a fe w samples of e xtra-Biblical, OT-era Hebre w. Thi s mean s that OT Hebrew grumrnurs and lexi co ns canno t be cross checked and verified aga inst no n- Biblica l so urces from the same per iod. By contrast, the NT Greek gra mmars and lexicon s can be c rossc hecked again st Nf-era, extra-Bib lical G reek so urces to ex pose built-in bias .
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
21
Certain ways to read the OT cun be tau g ht thro ug h Hebre w gram mars and lexicons. The dange r o f Hebre w gram mars douhling as de facto do ctrinal honks is that any reading besides the "official" rendering is co nsidered a gramm ar mistake. T he reader who is non chalant ab out the po wer o f gra m mars 10 c hange pe rccprio n and influence doctrine sho uld consider how some gra mmar issues arc not just ac ade mic issues. Indeed. ove r the cen turies, a stude nt who wished to read Trinitarian texts as they we re inten dcd to be read ran the risk o f being ch arged with false doct rine or blasphemy. The se charges e ntailed various consequences de pending nn the ce ntury and cultura l se tting. Exa mples could be multiplied abo ut how far dog ma and rules c an remo ve the pious interpretatio n o f a text from its literal read ing, but here are two examples that may give pa use. One exa mple is from Judai sm and other fro m Islam: • In He bre w grammars it was ta ug ht that in orde r to av o id t he c ha rge o f blas phemy, it was best to read o ut loud "Lord" (Adonai ), or another wo rd, instead o f saying the name Yo/well. Th e gra mmar books referred to "what is read" as qcre, and "w hat is writte n" as kethih . Just how effective this qerekelllih syste m was is shown by the facr that after awh ile. the ex act pro nunciatio n o f the name rahveh became a matter for debate. Th is is the case eve n tho ugh Ya/weh occ urs about 6,828 time s in 5,790 OT verses, and • In early Islamic times, in o rder 10 show the sup pose d su periority o f Islam , Musli ms devised the d ogma that the Koran wa s both ete rna l, and the very words of Allah." So, to trans form Mu hammad 's discou rse into wo rds that Allah cornrn anded Muhammad tn repeat , com pilers inserted the imperative for m "say" 350 times into the Koran ic text. '" 11 Many scholars, unlike most Muslims. se nse the man}' ab surdi ties that the "sa}'!" inte rpolat ions create." The qere-kethib and "Say!" rules affec ted h und reds or thousands of pass ages, an d thus cha nged ho w an entire book was read. Si milar ly, the majest ic plural rule affec ted the inter pretatio n o f thousands o f passages with the result that many read the Trinitari an Bible as thoug h it taught unitarianism. The majestic plural rule is nnt hing hut a veil (2Co 03: 13- 16; 2Co 04:03 ). So it behooves the reade r to suspect any qere inter pretative translat ion that is unitarian when the kethih literal reading of the text is Tri nitarian. f-or instance , the many plu ral and d ual form s that arc translated as majest ic pl ural s oug ht to be trans lated as co llec tive plurals. Exa mp les incl ude Elohim (God) and Panim (meaning, "facets)." or "presence," or "Prese nce s"]. The I\-Iajestic Plural Rationalization Has Not Been Seriously C r os s Examined Due to a Sanitized History Another weak ness of the majestic plural rati onali zatio n is that this gram matical construction has not been ser io usly analyzed in the past. The maje stic plural usage has been acce pted uncri tically based on its long rabbimcaltraditiou. Howe ve r, the majestic pl ural trad itio n may not he very ancie nt.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
22
Yael Na ta n
T he success of the early Trinitaria n c hurch among Je ws suggests tha t the Inle rte s ta me nlal Je ws int e rpre te d OT maj e stic plu ral s as be ing Tr in itarian. Cu ltures, however, are notorio us for presenting idealized, san itized pictures of the past. Cullural me mory selectively preserves che ris hed idea s while suppressing and forgett ing d isse nt. As the saying goes, "The victors write h istory." II is a mailer of histo ry that unitarians managed to ostracize Trinnanans fro m Je wish soc iety. Th e Jewish Trinitarian uad iuon was deem ed hereti ca l and was forgotten. Records nOI deemed ca nonica l were burned or allowed 10 di sin tegrate into ob livion , unless. of course , Ihey we re fortunate e nough to be left in pots in caves. The idea that classical J udaism had unan imous agree ment o n unitarianism and the majestic plura l syntax may soon fall o n hard limes . Other cherished ide as abo ut classical J udais m have been discarded in the twe ntieth ce ntury d ue to archeology finds, namely, t hat: • The lang uage o f Palestine was wholly A ramaic and Hebrew. Th is issue will be discussed in the chapte r on Ihe NT Use of OT Yahl'eh TeXiS, and • Cla ssic alJudai sm was untainted by astrology and human figural art. Jewish traditio n had prese nted cl assical Judaism as be ing untainted by astrology an d human figura l art. So me rab bis wrote that astrology applied 10 gent iles. hut not to JeWS. 'l As trology. ho we ve r, ap pears in Jew ish apocaly ptic writings." and as trology eve n made a n inc ursion into the Herodian temple i tself! ' ~ I. Les ter Ness wro te: [F lav ius] Jo sep hus [37 A D-?] " and Philo [Judaeus (c. 20 BC--c. AD 40)] 1'".1.10 not hesita te to ide ntify the twelve signs wuh the twelve loave s of [show] bread offered eac h d ay in the temple o r the seven pla nets wit h the seve n branches o f the me norah." T he Arc h o f T it us in Ro me that co mme mo rates the 70 AD co nques t o f Je rusalem co nfirms Jose phus and Philo's assertion that the te mple meno rah had astral connotations. Erwin Goode nough wrote: From these indepe nde nt sources. then . we have ev idence that Je ws actually made their te mple c ultus, made Judaism itself, into an astral relig ion.'"
Figure t.
What remains of the Jerusalem
temple menorah rt'lid on the Arch of Titus,
DO DO Matenal com direlbs autcrars
23
The Jewi sh Trinity
Addi tio nal examples of as t ral art inf iltration could be ci ted to s how that ast ro log y made major in roads in to J ud a ism from the Ma cc a be a n thro ug h the Byzantine pe riod . Be rnard Go ldm an notes tha t in the Macca bean period "the star o f the Maccabees" was place d over the temple facade.'?' Popular M uccabca n and Herodian coins loo k suspic iously li ke a c resce nt and Venus orb co uplet on a po le or f inia l. The coi n purpo rted to port ray a do uble co rnucopia wit h a po me g ra na te o rb on a stem between the horns o f ple n ty. Ya'u kov Mcsh o rer wrote : It is log ic a l to ass ume that the symbo l fi lte red into J uda is m as a n o bj ect re la te d to fe rti li ty, and th e n acq ui red addi tio na l Je wi s h con no-
tenons."
FiAure 2. Popular xta ccabean a nd Herudlun coin.
Classical J uda ism abso rbed astrolog ica l art and concepts , and this ca used friction wit h the C hristian c hurch. Ste phen's speech re fe rs to the astra l worship of the fore fathers. the implic atio n being that the NT Jewish leaders whom Stephen addressed had erred in the same way (Act 07:43 ). It was not the as trology so much as the cree ping homegrow n heresy called unitarianism that did the most to squeeze OT T rinitarianism entirely OUI of Judaism. Astrology in the tem ple, of co urse, was one o f the factors that led to the rejectio n of Trinitarianism, to the destr uction of the temple, and to the further dispersal of the Jews. Th e Maj esti c Plural Has Been Accepted Uncr-ltlcally on an A d Hom inem Basis T he re are other re ason s the majestic p lu ra l has no t und e rg o ne se rio us cros s -exa mination. Man y ho ld to the ad hominem assum pt ion t ha t uni taria ns are especial ly q ua lifi ed to read He bre w. This is no t rig ht since Ye shu{/, the a po st les, an d many early Trinitaria ns were fl uen t in Hebre w a nd A ram a ic.
M
rial 0
uto
24
Yael Na tan
Th e NT shows that Yeshua , the a po stles and early Ch ristian s considered the OT to be thoroughl y Trinitari an. Since the NT was not as ye t written. the y s urel y did not de rive the ir Trini tarian beliefs fro m the NT. T he NT shows that the peo ple were not be holden to every official do gma (Mat 01: 29; Mar 01 :22). So the maj estic plural ration ali zation ma y ha ve ca used f ric tion bet wee n the people and the religiou s authoritie s. What e ver the case. the fact that so man y lnte rtestarne ntal Je ws held Trinitaria n beliefs suggests the y did not belie ve the or was awash in majestic plurals refer ring to YlIIIl' eh as tho ugh he were a single majestic perso n. Desp ite convent ional wisdo m, unitarians arc not es pecially q ualified to rule o n OT Hebrew, FiNt of all , the Bible is not hk e o ther doc ume nts that are doctrinall y neutral , so the translatio n and interpre tation is not purel y acade mic. Human s, being what the y are, find it a ll too ea sy to give in to sectarian bias. Co ntrary to what so me might believe, no one spea ks Biblical Hebre w. The fir st language of grammarians like Gese nius and other Ashke nazi Jews of Ce ntral and Eastern Europ e was Yiddish. Yiddish is a blend of medieval Ge rman, S la vic, Old Fre nch, Old Italian , Ara maic and He brew. Sephardic Je ws, who lived in the Iberian Pe ninsula. wrote mainly in Arabic. Fo r instan ce, Moses be n Ma imo n, a.k .a. Ma imoni des ( 1135- 1204 AD), wrote in Arabic , but did incorpo rate so me non-Biblical Hebrew. S. D. Goitein wrote abo ut the Arabic influence on medie val Hebre w: The Jews too k their full share in this g reat Middle-Eastern mercantile c ivilizatio n, in partic ular from the te nth to the thirteenth centuries, and it was at that time and in that part of the wo rld that Judaism itsel f received its final shape. T here, under Arab-Muslim influe nce. Jewi sh t hought a nd philosophy and eve n Je wish law and religious prac tice were sys tematized a nd fin a lly fo rmula ted . Even the He br ew la ng ua ge de ve lo pe d its grammar and voca bulary on the model of the Arab language . T he re vival of He bre w in o ur own times would be entirely unthink able witho ut the se rvices rendered to it by Arabic in va rious ways a thousand years ago. Arabic itsel f beca me a Jewish la ngua ge and. unli ke Latin in Europe, was e mployed by Jews for all secular and religio us purposes, with the so le e xception of the synagogue se rvice ." The He brew that Je ws spea k toda y is Modern Hebrew. T he syntax of Modern Hebrew is qui te remo ved from that of the OT. In fac t. the Hebre w lang uage is usually divided into fo ur developme ntal stages: Biblical. Mishnaie (also ca lled "Rabbinic "]. Medie val and Modern Hebrew. T he syntax of Modern Hebre w is Mish uuic, a nd M ishna ic has different rules fro m Biblical sy ntax!)' Th e vocabu lar y of Mode rn He bre w also is ve ry' differe nt rrom Biblica l He brew. Elieze r Ben-Yehuda ( 1858- 1922 AD), the fat her of Mode rn He brew, s pe a rhe aded t he re vi val of He bre w as a li ving, s po ke n la ngu age . Be nYehuda began with the 7 ,704 Hebrew words of the Tora h, but proceeded to
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
25
The Jewi sh Trinity
co !n an d borrow other words. Mod e rn Heb re w acq uired 100.000 words by 19 78 A D.~~ By so me est imates . in 2000 AD Heb re w had 120.0nO words. Spea kers of non- Hebre w lang uages pe rhaps could tak e a fresh appr oach to Biblica l Hebrew. Modern Hebre w speakers. howe ver. are burdened by more tha n two millennia's wo rth of linguistic baggage. So it may be e asier to reach a level of objectivity co ncern ing He brew when one has no preconceived notions, and no habits that need to be unlcarned . All these facts take n together suggest that di sagreement s about majestic plurals may be dr iven by sect ar ian bias rath er tha n a lack of relevant OT data. T here is no hint that Yesh ,w and the apos tles or any early Christians deferred to the establishment for aut horitati ve gramma tical rulings (Mat 0 7:29; Mar 0 1:22). Likewise, C hristians should learn fro m the da ta rathe r than accept ad hominem argurnc nration. even if the authorities sco ff (Jo h 0 7:49). OT Data Inconsistent With the Existence of the :\Iajestic Plural Syntax Josh ua and me tsraetues In a speec h aga inst poly theism, Joshua referred to Yahreh as the " hoI) [plura l adjective] Go ds [E/ohi/lll" (Jos 24: 19). Unless Joshua was teac hing Trinita rianism, it wo uld have bee n counterproduc tive to refer to God usin g a plura l in a speec h ag ains t polythei sm. So the ph rase "h oly' [plural adjec tive I Gods IE/ohim]" is a plural co llective noun rath er tha n a majestic plural.
l ehoiakim ll,I' Al/OII Yi:,h ,'('h sa id that when Jehoiakim d ied, no one would lament his dea th as tho ugh he were a bro the r, nor wou ld any one say: Alas, [what a ] master [tIJon] ! Alas, [what] majesty! (Jer 22: 18). The Hebrew translated "m aster" is the singular form adon. If the re we re such a thi ng as a n OT majestic pl ural. one wou ld think that the pl ura l fnrm adonai wn uld ha ve bee n used before the phrase. "Alas. [w hat] majes ty." If the plura l at/ollai meant " majestic master" j ust by itself. the n the sec ond phrase "A las. lw hatl majesty!" wo uld have been red undant. The Majestic Plural Construction is at Odds with the Shema Trini tarianism is based on the Biblical version of the Shenw that read s Etahim (Go ds ) is "a united o ne" (echad). Unitaria nism. ho we ve r, c urrent ly is based o n an a ltered vers ion of the Shema introd uced by Maimon ide s. Maimomdes ch anged the Shcma from Elohim (God s) is "a united one " (('eheld) to Elohim (Gods) is "a unique one " (yae"i(/) . T ho ugh the OT neve r used vachid to refer to Yahvrh ; Maimonides" altered vachid vers ion o f the Shema has beco me a pivotal article of the modern Jewish fai th.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
26
Yae l Na tan The Majestic Plural Concept is at Odds with Unitaria nism
The maje stic pl ural conce pt sugge sts that the quality o f majesty is so me how related to the co nce pt o f plurality. This assoc iat ion betwee n majesty and plurality see m's artificia l and con trived. For the sake of argument. however, it is worth while to thin k the associ ation is hypot het icall y valid. For instance. if the association betwee n pluralit y and majesty were valid. the pe rso ns of the Trinity wou ld necessarily' be more majesti c than the lo ne div mc f igurc to uted by maje stic pl ural propone nts. The Majestic Plural is at Odds with the OT Use of the Plural for God If the OT taught unitar ianism. one would expect that the s ingular Hebrew for ms for God. £ / (Ge n 14: 18) and Elo( w)uh (D eu 32: 15. 17; Hab 0 3:0 3) wo uld have bee n used thro ugho ut thc OT. Furthcrmo re, the singular for m El wo uld have bee n use ful to counter the pre va iling poly theistic notions. Ove rall, the O T looks ve ry Trinitar ian. T he singular for ms £ / a nd £ /o(w}uh are used mainly in poet ic sec tions . As WHS noted above , there are 2.600 occ urrences of the plural for m Eiohim in 2,247 OT verses. The sing ular form D , howe ver, occ urs 2 19 times in 2 12 verses, wh ile the singular for m Elo( w)uh occ urs 58 times in 57 ve rses. The prevale nce of the plural Elohim suggcs ts that the plural form Elohim wou ld have been used in poe try. too. e xce pt that the forms EI and Elo(w)uh were eas ier to work with given the constraints o f Heb rew poet ry.
The Form HoElollim is Not C ons iste nt With the Existence of the Majesti c Plural Syntax The Hcb rew de fin ite article no (the) prefix implie s "all the ... ," but doc s not explic itly stale "all the ..... Massey g ives the ex ample that havam [hu + yam ] litera lly mea ns " the peop le:' but "all the peop le" is implied." Th e definite art icle " the" (ha) prefixed to Elohim (haElohim) suggests the Trinity: " [AlII the Gods." So when t he arncle I", is prefixed 10 Flohim (or do/rim). thl: form should be taken to mean: • " [All) the Gods" whe n referring 10 the Trini ty. • " [Ali i the gods" when referring to false gods (Exo 18: II ; Jdg 10: 14; 2Ch 0 2:04; Jer 11 :1 2), and • " [AlII the judge s" whe n referring to humans (Exo 2 1:06: 22:08- 09 (BIIS 22:0708); Jos 24:0 1). The reade r o f mod ern translat ions, o f co urse, will not find ha F.lohim tra nslated as a plural co llective no un whe n referri ng to Yahveh , e xce pt in ISa 04 :08 (as is no ted in the MT plur als appe ndi x ). Lik e tho usan d s o f o ther pl ura ls th at refer to YCl hw h. tran slato rs co nside r the fo rm hClElohilll to be a maje stic pl ural. Accordingly. when refe rring to rahveh; /w EIt/him is translated in the s ing ular as Matenal com direlbs
autcrars
The Jewish Trinity
27
"God " (Gcn 05:22, 24; 06:02, 04, 09 , I I; 17:1S; 20 :0 6, 17; 22:03, 09; 27:28: 31: I I; 35:07 , etc.) Onl y when the translators figured, wrongly or rightly, that haetohim referred to false gods was hoctohim translated in the plura l as "gods" (Exo llU I; Deu 10:17; Jdg 10:14: ISa 04:08 : 2Ch 0 2:04: Psa 136:02; Jer II :12). It goes without sayillg that translating a plural form as a singular sometim es and as a plural other times is inconsisten t. This treatment of haEJohim is also inconsistent with the translat ion of o ther plurals prefixed by the defi nite article. Exa mples incl ude: " ... the Baets [huHau lim ] and the Asherahw IhuA.I"herrl l J" (NI V Jdg tl3:07) , If Ya hreh were a s ingular perso n, it is c urio us that God is culled IIlIElo him (" [Ali I the Gods") , H aE lo h im occurs 366 timex ill 337 OT verses, and nearl y a lways refers to Yahwh (Gcn 05:22, 24: 06 :02, 04 , 09, I I, etc .. but not in Exo 2 1: 06; 22:0&,09). However, when "a ll" [Hebre w is cowl] is explicitly prefixed to "the god s" (co wl elohimr. the phrase refers to: • Angels (Psa 097:07, 09), o r • Pagan gods (fnr instance, Gen 35:04; Exu 12:12; 1&:1 1; 2 Ki 1&:35; ICh 16:2526: 2Ch 02:05 (BHS 2Ch 02:04); 32:14; Psu 09 5:03 : 096:04-05; 135:05; Isa 36: 20; Zep 02: 11). At least three inc idents show that the form haElohim (" [All] the Gods") refers to persons ca lled Yahvr h ; and so implicitly spea ks of the Trinity: • In Dcu 33 :0 1 Moses is called " the man of [AlII the God s," and the n in the nex t verse Yllh ~Th was said to have appeared on three mountains during the gi ving of the law [Exo 20). Deu 33:01-0 2 is d iscussed in the chapter nn the Presences of Elvon, • In a sec tion where rahveh is twice ca lled "[ AII] the Gods" (Jos 22:34: 24:( 1), the Transjordan tribes called upon Yahveh to be the Mosaic minimum of two concurring witnesses , saying: God of Gods, Yah l'ell [the Fathe r]! God of God s, ranvcn [the So n]! He know s (Jos 22:2 2), and • S imilarly, Elijah ca lled Yohvch '"[All] the God s" (1 Ki I R:2 1, 24, 37). Later, the people twice said: Yehvch , he is [Al ii the God s: Yuh w'h , he is [AlII the Gods (I Ki 18:39 ). The ex tensive use o f the form haElohim suggests that "[All] the Gods" implic itly speaks of rhe Trin ity: • The se people saw or talked to haE/ollim: Enoch (Gen 05:22, 24), Noah (Gc n 06:(9), Ahraham (Cen 17:1 &; 20: 17; 22:03, 09 ), Abimelech (Cen 20:06), Jacob (Gen 27:2&; 35:(17: 4& :15), Moses (E xo 03:06, I I. 12, 13; 19:0 3), the Israelites (Exo 18: 12; 19 :17; 20:20, 2 1; 24: I I ), Buleam {Num 22: 10; 23:27) and G ideon (Jdg 06: 36, 39), • Moses is called "the man ofl AllI the Gods" (Dcu 33:0 1: Jos 14:06 ; 2Ch 30:16: Ezr 0 3:02; Psa 090:0 I), Moses is called the "servant of [AII] lhe Cods " ( Ie h 06:34 : 2Ch 24:09 : Neh 10:29 (BHS 10:30); Dan 09: I I), and Moses received the "Law of [All] the Gods (Exo 18:16; Neh 08:08 ; 10:291 BHS 1O:301l on the "Mount of [All] the Gods" (Exo 03:01 : 04 :27: IR:05; 24;13; I Ki 19:08; 2Ki 04:2"j), Matenal com direlbs autcrars
28
Yael Na tan
• The Ark o f t he Cove nant was later called the " Ark of [Alii the Go ds" 35 times in 3 1 verses (Jdg 20:27 ; 1Sa 04 :04, 13. 18. 19, 2 1, 22; 05:0 I, 02. 10 (twice); 14: 18 (twice ); 2Sa 06 :0 2, 0 3, 04. 0 6, 07. 12 (twice); 15: 24 (twice), 25. 29; lCh 13: 0 5. 06, 07. 12, 14 ; 15:02, 15 ,24 ; 16:01 , 06 ; and 2C h OI:(4), and • T he ark res ided in the " Ho use of IA lIl the Gods," The " House of IAllI the Gods" is mentioned 55 time s in 54 verses (l dg IlL 'll ; ICh 06 :33; 09 : 11, 13.26. 27 ; 22:0 2; 23:28; 25:06; 26:20; 28: 12, 2 1; 29:07; 2Ch 03 :03 ; 04: 11 ,1 9;05:01. 14; 07 :05 ; 15:18 ; 22:12 ; 23:03, OlJ; 24:07 , 13,27; 25:24; 28:24 (tw ice) , 3 1: 13, 2 1; 33:07; 35:08; 36:18. 19; Ezr 0 1:04; 0 2:68; 0 3:08, 09; 06:22; 08 :36; 10:0 1. 06, 0 9; Neh 06 : 10; 08: 16; 11 :11, 16, 22; 12:40 ; 13:0 7,09, II ; Bee 04 :17; and Dan 0 1:02 ). The AffinitJ Between Hebrew Plurals That Refer to Yahveh Massey w rote : The only way to exp lici tly excl ude the implicit 'all ' from ' the people ' is to mark it with a q ualifica tion. e.g. . 'so me of the peop le ,' 71 So in the ca se of haElohim. the on ly way to re mo ve the implicit "all" is to usc a qu alifi er like "some ," No qualif ier is eve r used when hatilohim refer s to the Trinity, Besides. a "some" q ualifie r wo uld still refer to more than one perso n, not just a singular majest ic person, So w hen I/(/ £Io llim refers to Yalll'ell. the plural Iorm sugges ts that there a re pe rsons who are called Yah",'h both indi viduall ) and co llec tively, Far fro m us in g qu al if iers to exc lude the implic it "a ll" und erst a ndin g of halilohim (" [Ali i the God s" ), ha Elohim is used in conj unct ion with other MT elem ents that refer to the perso ns of rahveh , Of co urse. the plural fo rm Etahim (lite rall y. "Go ds") occurs so oft e n that its proximi ty to ot her Trin itarian proofs is stat ist ically insig nificant. Howe ver, there are othe r Trinitarian proofs be sides Elohim scattered througho ut the OT. For e xample, the affinity between h(lElohim ("[A ll] the God s" ) and these ot her Trinitarian proofs is statistically significant. To ap prec iate the sta tistical s ig nifica nce of ha Eloh im 's p ro xim it y to O T Trinitari an proo fs, note that the re are only 336 ve rses with an instance o r two of ha lilohim out of 23,2 13 verse s in the Heb rew OT, Furthermore. the distri bution of haElollim throu ghou t the OT is no t e ven. Mo st instan ces of IIII E/ohim (9 1.5 percent or 335 instances of 366 total instance s) occ ur in just twe lve OT books." Also , most instances o f IwElohim (80.6 perce nt or 2lJ5 mstances of 366 total instances) are c lustered in just 83 ch apters." So ch a nce wou ld only acco unt for a few instan ce s o f p ro ximity be twee n IwElohim and Trinita rian proofs. Furth ermore. the fact that hablohim is cluste red see ms significa nt- as thou gh these cha pters were mean t to teach the Trinity, Th e affinity between IIaElohim and plurals referring to Yallvd , is dem onstrated in the fo llowin g table :
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
29
The Affinity Between Elements (Besides the Common Plural Form Elohim) That Indicate Yahven is Plural Persons T he ele ments conce rned are: • " rAIII the Gods" (haEIohim) occurs 366 time s in 33 7 OT verses. ha E/a him is d iscussed above, • "You-he" tatah-hu ] paired pronouns occ ur nine times in n ine OT vers es . Atah-hu is di scussed later in the chapter, • "Yahveh Elohim" (Yahveh Gods) occur 37 times in 35 O'I' verses . ·' Y(.IJII'I:1i Elohim" is di sc ussed later in the cha pter. and • MT plural verbs and modifiers rererrin~ to Y(.Ihveh occ ur once o r more in 38 MT Ch apters. MT plura ls referring to Yahveh a rc d isc ussed in Co llect ive Plurals chapter and in the MT plurals app e ndix. Groupings of Trinitarian cle men ts (beside s the co mmon plura l for m Elollim ) arc found at: • The Creation Account: o Yahveh Etohim: Gen 02:04h- -03 :23 o MT Plural s: Ge n 01:26; 03 :22; and I.XX Gen 02:18; I.XX Cen 03:05b • Gen 20 and Neh 9: c hllElohim : Ge n 20:06, 17: Neh 09:07 o Ata n-hu: Neh 09 :06a, 07 o MTPl urals: Ge n 20:13; LX X Neh 09: IR
•
•
•
•
•
•
Cen 35: o hllElohim: Gen 35:07 o MT Plural: Gen 35:0 7 Deu 04 and Jer 2..1: c hllElohim : Deu 04 :35, 39: Jer 23:23 o MT Plurals: Dc u 04:07 ; Jer 23:36 jos 22, 24: o halilohim: Jos 22:34 ; 24:0 1 o MTPlural: Jos 24:19 (Sa 04 : o ho EJohim: ISa 04 :04 , 08 (twice). 13. 17, 18, 19, 2 1, 22; 05:01, 02, 10 (twice), II o MT Plurals: lSa 04: 07-08 2Sa 07: o halilohim: 2Sa 07:02 , 2R o A teh -hu: 2Sa 0 7:28 o Yohveh Elohim : 2Sa 07 :25 o MT Plural: 2Sa 0 7:23 2Ki 19: o hoEloh im: 2Ki 19:1 5 c A II/Ii- /m : 2Ki 19:15 o Yohw' h Elohim : 2Ki 19:19 Matenal com direlbs
autcrars
Yael N ata n
30 •
IChl 7 and2Sa07; c Jw E/oll im: ICh 17:0 2. 2 1, 26 o A la h· h,,: l Ch 17:26 o fa/w ell Elohim: t Ch 17:16- 17 o MT Plural: 2S a 07 :23 • t ell 28:
o hIlE/ohilll: ICf 28: 12. 2 1 o Yohveh Eloh im: lCf 28:20 •
•
•
•
•
• •
•
•
•
l ehO! : o IwE/ohim : 2eh 0 1:03-04 o Yahveh Elohim: 2e h 0 I :09 2eh 07; o hllE/ohim: 2e h 07:05 o Yahveh Etohim: 2eh 06:4 1-42 2eh 19: o Iw E/oll im: 2eh 19:03 o A/ali-hit: 2e h 20:06 2eh 32: o halilohim; 2eh 32: 16, 3 1 o MTPl umls: 2Ch32 :14. 15 Isa 37: o J",[lohim: lsa 37: 16 o A ltl h·h,,: Isa 37 : 16
Isa 41: o MTPl urals: lsa41:04.21 -23. 26 Dan 04 : o MTPlura]s: DaI104:08.09, 17. 18, 25, 26, 3 1, 32; 05: 11 , 20, 21 ; 07:18, 22, 25b, 26 . 27 Jon 04 : o Iw E/oll im: Jon 04 :07 o Yahve h Elohi m: Jun 04:06
Ecc 12: o halilohim; Ecc 12:07 , 13-14 o MT Plural: Ecc 12:01 H os 11-12: o MT Plurals : Hos 11:02, 12 (8HS 12:0 1);Hos 12:04 (8 11S 12:( 5 )
Th e Pai red Words vah veh Blohlm Yah veh HIt/him are the Father ( Ya lll'eh) and the So n (H{t/him ). Yahveh Etah im are the " us" mentioned severa l ti me s in Genesis (GCIl 0 1:26. 0 3:22 ; 11:07 and LXX Gen rJ2 : IR). Yahreh f it/him are men tioned twen ty times in Ge n rJZ -rJl The nou ns Yahveh F.lohim are d iscussed in the MT plurals append ix, as are all the plural elem ents mentioned in the " Affinity" table, above. Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
31
The Paired Pronouns "You-he" (Atah-hu) The paired pronou ns atah-hu ("you-he") occ ur nine times in the MT (2Sa 07: 28; 2Ki 19:15; ICh 17:26; 2Ch 20:06; Neh 09 :06a, 07; Psa 044:05a ; Isa 37:16; Jer 14:22). Five times all.lh·/Ill is assoc iated with the form haE/ohim ([A ll] the Gods). This sugges ts atah-hu refers to the persons called Yahveh. He re arc literal translations of all nine occurrences of paired pronouns "you-he": • Y(,h",'h, y ou -he [are] [All] the Gods [JwElohim ) (2Sa 07:28), • Yahl'eh, Gods [E/ohim] of Israel who dwell [betwee n] the che rubim . yo u-he [are] [Alii the Gods [huElohim ) (2Ki 19 :15), • Now Yuhl'eh, you- he [are] [Ali i the Gods [haElohim] (tCh 17:26) , • Yahveh Gods [EJoMm] of o ur fat hers. [are] yo u- he not Gods It'Jo him ] in heaven'! (2Ch 20:06), • You -he [are ) Yohvch alone... you -he [are] fuhl'eh . [All I the Gods [hllEJohim] (Neh 09:06-{l7), • You-he [are] my king, 0 Gods [E/ohim] (Psa 044:(4). • Yahvch of hosts, Gods IEJohim ] of Israel who d well [between] the che rubi m, you-he [arc] [Alii the God s [haElohim l (!sa 37: 16), and • [Are I not you-he. Ya /w eh, our Gods [Elohenu I? (Je r 14:22). The Presences of Elyon chapter discusses ho w the Father dwc lt in heave n, while the Son and Spirit as Prese nces of Yohveh d wel t first in the tabernacle and the n t he temple. T he "you" of the pained "yo u-he' pronou ns rna) have been mean t as a collective prono un referring to the Presences in the temple. T he mem bers of the Trinity were ofte n addressed wuh singular collective noun s. The "he" of the paired "you-be" pronouns may have been mea nt as a singular pronoun refe rring to the Father in heaven. "You" natura lly refers to a person or persons who are ncar- such as the Presences in the te mple. "He" naturally refe rs to a person more distant such as the Father in heaven. "You" is a singular collective noun referring to the Son and Spirit.
The Lack of Evidence for the Majestic Plural Syntax in Any Language Since Biblical He brew is a Semit ic lang uage, one wou ld expect to find copious examples of majes tic plurals in other contemporary Se mitic languages. T ho ugh large ancient Near East Iibruries have been unearthed, o nly a few dubious exam ples have been offered as proof t hai othe r Se mitic languages used majestic plurals. Instead , what one finds is, as the Encyclopaedia Britannica stales: So me rulers speak of their own dynastic dei ty. A king who owes his position to the Assyrian emperor refers to the latter and the dynastic deity equally as ' my master.,_v, Notice the king and god arc referred to by the s ingular "my master," not by a majest ic plural "my masters."
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
32
Yael Na tan Case Studies on Supposed Majestic Plurals Supp osed Arab ic M aj e,I'Iit." I' hirals
Majest ic plural proponents say that the Koran co ntains many majestic plum b. Muhammad has Allah say ing, "we ," " us" and "our" often, Many plural pronouns that are best unde rstood as refe rring to angels are instead inter preted as referring to Allah.'! Th e Kora n. howe ver, is nOI of any great a nnquity, btl! is merely medie val-era Iitcrururc written betwee n 6 10 and 6 32 AD. Furthermo re, pre- Islamic doc ume nts yie ld sca nt ev ide nce for the ex iste nce of majesti c pl ural s in Arabia. James Hastings wrote: C urio usly eno ugh, the two oldest doc umen ts which mention he r [the goddess M m taf ]. 11 Nabataea n and a La tin inscr iption , use the plural form Ma na wtl/ (spell Mal1l11't// in Latin), ju st as the plural M1II1tI.I't/ is used for Mt/lliya rmeaning, "do om to death" or "destruction"]," and It may be added that the di vine name tval , which occurs once in an ancient verse, is possibly a plural of majest y fo rmed from D .'-' Latin had no majestic plural rarionalizauon . so the abo ve Lat in tra nsliterations cited by Hast ings may have reflec ted a plural in e ither Aramaic or Arabic. T he se few pre -Islamic pl ural s could be explained without resorting 10 the majest ic plural rationalizat ion. Later in th is cha pte r. for e xample. the plurals referring to Ba al and Astnora h are explained without referring to the majestic plural rationalizat ion. T hese Arabian doc ume nts we re pro bably based o n Arabic langu age so urces. The Arabic langu age was first writte n down with a crude alphabet a few ce nturies before the Islamic er a. It would seem, the refore, that no ne of the ex amples fro m Arab ia are o f great antiquity. Thus, it cannot be pro ven that the majestic plural concep t was fo und in Arabia be fo re Je wish influe nces infiltrated the pen insu la. If the pre -I sla mic writers meant the se plu rals to be unde rstood as maje st ic pl urals , they probably wer e ju st copying Je wish custo m. There is, ho wever. no do ubt that Ko ran ic maje stic plurals re flect Jewish teach ing. Ibn Warraq w rote about the Jewish influen ce: Cook pctuts out the si milarity of certain Muslim beliefs and practices to those of the Sa maritans .. .He also points OUI that the fundamental idea o f Muham mad develo ped of the reli gion o f Abraham was already presen t in the Jewish apocryphal work (dated to circa 140-100 BC ) ca lled the Book of Ju bilees and may well have influenced the forma tion of Islamic ideas.. .. Sozornc nus [a fifth ce ntury AD historian I goes on to describe how certain Ara b tri bes that learn ed of the ir Ishmaehte o rigins from Jews adopted Jewish observances [c ircumcision. abs tai ning from canng pork, ctc.} '' J. Wansbrough wrote about the Jewish inl1 uenee on the Ko ral/ ' S development: Quranic all usio n presuppose s familiarity with the narrativ e material o f Judaeo -Christian scripture, w hich was not so much reformulated as merel y referred to.. ..Take n together. the q uantity of reference. the mecha nically re pe t it io us e m ploy me nt of rhe to rical conve nt ion, and the st ride ntly po lemica l style. all sugges t a stro ngly sec tarian atmosphere in which a Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewish Trinity
33
corpus of familiar scripture was being pressed into the service of as yet unramiIiar doc trine ." The Kora n repeatedly notes how c ritics acc used Muhammad of having no new stories (Koran 006:025; 008:03 1; 0 16:024; 023:083; 02 5:005; 027:068; 0 46:01 7; 068:0 15; 083:0 1J ). The detractors sa id the o ld info rmatio n was pieced togethe r with the he lp o f others (Koran 016: I03; 044:0 14). Koran 025:004-005 reads: Those who di sbelie ve say : Thi s is no thin g bu t a lie t hat he [Muhammad ] has forged, and other peop le have helped him at it; so indeed the y ha ve done inju stice and (uttered) a fa lsehood. And they [critics] say: The sto ries of the ancients-he [Muhammad] has go t them written, and the se are read out to him morn ing and evening. One heckle r vexed the apostle by saying: Muhammad is only an ea r. If anyone te lls him a thing he believes it.-'" The Koran ev e n rec o rd s t ha t a non - indigen o us Ara bic spe aker he lped Muham mad formulate Islam: We [Alla h ] know indeed tha t the y s ay, is a man tha t teach e s him [Muhammad]. ' The to ng ue o f him [Muhamm ad's tuto r) they [the Mekkans] wicked ly poin t to is o utlandish. while this [the Ko mnJ is Arabic , pure and clear ( Koran 0 16: I03; compare 026: 1( 5). The language and cultural identity of Muhammad's tutor is suggested else where in the Koran, Allah to ld Muhammad to go to the Peo ple of the Boo k, mea ning the Jews. to verify that the KOf(1I1 was co nsistent with Heb rew sc ripture (Koran 010: 0(4). Muhammad's biographer, Ibn lshuq. men tion s there be ing ma ny rabbi s at Medina. Med ina is Arabic mea ning, 'T he City [of the Prophet Muhammad]." Several rabbis converted to Islam. including Muk hayriq" and Husayn ibn Salta m." One of the most learned rabbi s in the area lived at Medina. Ibn lxhaq wrote: 'A bdull ah b. Suriya the one-eyed who was the most learned man of his time in the Hijaz in Torah studies ... J" History records that the Jews in Arabia d id not spea k pure Ara bic, at leas t to ex press their religion. S. D. Goitein wrote that e ven d uring medieval times, the Jews around the Mediterranea n did not use Arabic d uring synagog ue services. " In Ambia up to M uhammad 's time . the Je ws had a spec ialized vocabulary that was unfam iliar to the Arabs. The diffe re nce het wee n the J udea -Arabic dia lec t and Arabic was much less than the d iffere nce betwee n German and Yiddish. Gordo n Newby wrote: Muhammad 's aman uensis, Zayd b. Thabir. is said to have learned alyohudivvah in seventeen d ays in order to be able to understand what the Jews were writing. an indication that the diffe rence betwee n Arabic and atyah udiyyah we re mutters of vocabulary and sc ript; they were no t differen t languages." So in the Koran Muhammad con trasted the Judeo-Arab ic d ialect with Arab ic. Thi s e xplains why Muhammad had to e mphasize that the Kora n was written in "pure" Arabic nathe r than just saying the Kora n was written in Ara bic ( Koran 12:
-u
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
34
Yael Na ta n
002 ; 0 13:037; 0 16: 103; 0 20: 11 3; 0 26: 195; 039:028; 04 1:00 3; 04 2:007; 043:003; 0 46:0 12). M uham mad arg ued that the different dialec t proved that his mater ia l was nOI ju st a rehash of ra bbinic materia l. but was o riginal re ve lat ion. Histor y also points 10 the Jews being Muhammad 's source of inspiration. as Gord on Ne wby wrote: The c irc ulat ion of non -Is lam ic materi als for usc as the basis for Qur 'an co m me ntary was p resent dur ing Muhammad 's lifeti me a nd saw a conside rable increase in the two gene ratio ns after his dea th. The Co mpani on. Abu Hurayruh, althu ugh illiterate, had extensive knowle dge of the Torah. a s did ' Ali, Sa lma n al-Farivi. and, of co urse. the 'Ocea n of Tafsir.' Ibn ' A bba s. who is ofle n c alled the 'hih r (l1·'ummll,' or ' Rabbi o f the [Mus lim] Co mmunity,' on accou nt of his extensive knowledge o f Ju deo-C hrjstum as well as M uslim Scripture and co mme ntary acqu ired in Arab ia. Muhammad, Abu Bakr, and 'U mar are repo rted to have made several trips to the Bet M id rash [vHo use of S tudy"] in Med in a, and Muhammad 's aman uensis, Zayd b. Thabit, who was so ce ntral in matte rs Q ur' anie, is repo ned to have go ne so far as to learn a!-Yllhudiy."a" [JudeoArabic ] in a Bet Mid rash at Muhammad 's behest in ord er to read Je wish ma ter ial,' : So it see ms that the unly plausible e xplanat ion, give n all the data , is: • Muhamm ad 's tuto r me ntioned in Kora n 0 16:103 was a Jew ish Arab , and • Muha mmad learned the majestic plural rationalizat ion from the Jews. Logic also suggests that Muhamm ad lea rned the majestic plural rationalization from the Jewish sources rather than Arabie sources. If Allah was eve r made to say "we" or "our" or " us" in pre -Islamic lime s, the Mekkans surely wo uld have meant the plural pron ouns to refer to Allah and his goddess d aughte rs Allar. Mana! and U :.;:a ( Kortlll 0 53:0 19 -020 ). In fact, the K ora n may record the Mekkan objec tion 10 Muham mad 's mer ging A/hlh and his dau ghters into one god by interpre ting phu nls as maje stic plurals: So they [Me k kun cri tics] won de r t hat a Warn e r [M uham mad ] ha s come to them from amo ng the mselves! and the unbelievers say, 'This is a sorce rer telling lies ! Has he made the gods into a single Allah? Truly this is a strange thing!' And the leader among them goes aw ay (imputiently), (saying), ' Walk ye away. and remain co ns tant to yo ur gods! T his is most sure ly a thing sought after ' ( Komll 0 38:004-IXI6). It see ms e vide nt that the so urce o f maje stic plurals in the Koran trace s bac k partly to rabb inic pse udo-scholarsh ip and pa rtly to OT Trinitarian ism. Muhamm ad purpose ly made Allah speak oft en like Yallreh occa sionally spo ke - using plural pronouns like " we" and " us" (Ge n 0 1:26; 0 3:22: 11 :0 7; Isa 06 :0R). So it wou ld see m that majest ic plurals both in the Koran and in ex tr a-biblical Je wish literatu re are an unwitting or 11 grudging imitation o f OT Trinitarian ism.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
35
Supposed M' lj l'I1ic Ptura!s in First Man'flbl't's
So me maje st ic plural pro ponents sa)' that Ihe OT apocry phal boo k o f Fi rst Maccabe e s co nta ins majestic plural s. Of course. this is Interrestamemalliterature, so il probabl y refl ects newfangled rab binic teaching on the majestic plural. Intert eslamental t imes. of course. were more than a thousand years after Moses pe nned the Pent ateu ch (Exo 34:27; D eu 3 1:19). Grammar rules are introduced and arc dis carded all the lime. A thousand years is mo re than e nough time for the majestic plural inno vation 10 be conceptualized, be introduced. and beco me koshe r gr amma r. Th en maje stic plura l propone nts mo nopohzed Jew ish scholars hi p by fo reing out traditional Tri nitari an scholars. In First Macca bee s various kings wrote messages using the pronouns "we" and " us" ( I Ma 10: 19-20.26-28,53-54.56.70-72; 11:31 , 33-35). The " we" and the " us" of the lener s refer not to a single king, but 10 IWO petty kings, or the king and his co urt. For instance: Demetrius sen t Jo nathan a letter in peacea ble words to honor him ; fo r he sa id, 'Let us [Demetrius and his co urt] act firs t to make peace with him (Jonat han] before he mak es peace with Alexande r again st us. for [ot herwise ] he will rem em be r all the wrongs whic h we did to him a nd 10 his bro ther s and his nation ' ( I Ma 10:03-05), So he said, 'S hall we [Alexander and his cou rt] find another such man? Come now, we will ma ke him ou r friend and ally.' And he wrote a letter and sent it to him... in the fo llo wing wonk ' King Alexander to his brother Jo nathan, greeting. We [Alex ander and his court] have heard about ) 'OU, that you are a mig hty warrior and worthy to be ou r friend' (I Ma 10: 16-19 ), and When Deme trius heard of these things he was grieve d and said. ' Whal is this that we I Deme trius and his co urt] have done '! Alexander has gotte n ahead of us in forming a frie ndship wit h the Jews 10 stre ngthe n himsel f ' (lMa 10:22-23 ). It see ms incon cei vable that the above state ments would be the kmg's self-deli berat ive thou ghts. II would be unnatu ra l for a king 10 think 10 himself us ing majestic plural pro nouns such " us" and "we." Hexides , a k ing us ing majesuc pl ural s puhlid y wo uld surely ha ve ca used en dless con fusion. When the king used a plural prono un. eve ryone wou ld wonder whe the r the king was referri ng just to his majestic self. Perha ps he mea nt h imself and his co urt, or qu een. or all ies, or what not. Th at kings ever uscd majestic plurals so unds as fic titio us as Hans Ch ris tian Ande rsen 's ta le "T he Em pe ror 's New Clot hes" (I R37 AD).
Supposed Majestic Plurals in the ArHicryplral and PwudcpiXTaplral Books Man y pse udepigr ap hal book s and apocry pha l boo ks lik e Fi rsl Macc ab ee s surv ive on ly in Greek o r Coptic ve rsions. Many suc h books may have bee n written o rigi nally in G reek. Since there is no majestic plural construction in Gree k grammar, one can assume the re are no majestic plurals in any apocry phal and pse udep igrap hal hoo k that or iginally was wnuen in Greek . Matenal com direlbs autcrars
36
Yael Na ta n
Supposed M uj e.I'f;c Plural.I' ill the Septuagint (LXXj T here is no maje stic plural construc tio n in G ree k gra m mar. So no o ne ca n automatically assume the re are no majestic plurals in the Septuag int. the G ree k Tranvluno n of rhe He bre w OT. Someone migh t ask: Did the LXX translators recognize many Hebrew no uns 10 be majest ic plurals, and then tran sla te them as s ingulars'! It is possible tha t the LXX translators mistook He bre w plurals to be maje stic plurals. II see ms mo re plausible that the LXX translat ors understood ma ny Hebrew pl urals were plural collective nOIl IlS. T he G reek may have used sing ular co llective nouns more freque ntly than plural co llec tive nou ns , so Hebre w plura l collective nouns we re translated as singu lar co llect ive nou ns. T he situat io n is ana lo go us to a Br it ish Eng lis h boo k be ing tra ns late d into A merica n English. The plura l co llective nouns wo uld he changed to s ingular co llective nouns to con form 10 the sensibilities of Amer ican English reader s." Supposed Maj estic Plurals ill Ezra Majest ic plura l propo nent s offer an exa mple fro m the Aram aic book o f Ezra: The letter yo u sen t us has bee n read and trans lated in my presence " (Ezr 04 : l 8). King Anaxerxes" use of a sing ular prono un (my') wo uld he inconsiste nt with his ha ving used a majestic plural (us) e arlier in the verse. Anaxer xes ' leiter me ntions a translator and a reader bein g in his pre sence , and that the letter was writte n out of loyalty 10 "th e palace" and king (Ezr 04 :14). So A rtaxerxes ' use o f " us" is best interpreted as the king spea king for him self and his court. or pe rhaps the trans lator. the reader and himself. King Artnxc rxcs' response must have been trans lated from the k ing 's Per sian lan gu age. a n lu do- Euro pean lang uage s imila r to Vedic Sa nskrit ( Ezr 04 : 18 )..... S urely. the king a nd trans lato r d id not use majestic plurals since. apparently. neither the Ara maic nor Indo-Euro pean langu ages had a majestic plural usage. Nkodenltfs ' S"PfX1.1'ed Maj estic Plural Nicode mus came stealthily to Ye.l lw l! at night and sa id, "Rabbi. we kno w... .. (J oh 0 3:02). Some ha ve s upposed that s inee Nicodem us was a Pha risee and a " ruler o f the Je ws" (Joh 0 3:( 1), he was e ntitled to use majest ic plurals when refe rring to himse lf. That Nicode mus wa s refe rring to hi mself and his co lleagues see ms appare nt when Ye.lhlw add ressed Nicodemus a nd sa id, "yo u peop le" (Joh 0 3: 11 ). Supposed Maj estic Plurais in the Apastte Paul '.1' Writings Paul said " us" and "we" ofte n in Co loss ians. in First and Second Thessalon ians, and in other ep istles. S ince G ree k has no majestic plura l sy ntax , it is unlikely that Paul wou ld write using majest ic plurals. Historic ally. Paul's plural prono uns have been unde rsto od 10 refe r to himse lf and his coworke rt s j, f rie nd (s) o r co ngregation(s). Malenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
37
Suppo.l'ed M aj en k Plural Usage in viaonan Engtond
Alexa ndrma Victoria , Queen of England from IR37- 1901 AD, reportedly said, "We are not amused." T his has been offered as support for the majestic plural rationalization. Every o ne in co urt, howeve r, su rely unders tood the queen 10 be speaking for herself and the royal fa mily, or herself and the court. If Q ueen Victoria really had used a majestic plural, there ought to be tho usands of o the r examples of majest ic plurals in the English royal archives. Apparently, none arc to be found since only this one exa mple has been offered. Because this isolated example is of late da te, it says nothing abou t whe ther the majestic plural can be traced back to antiquity in any language. The example proves, if anyth ing, that English royalty had read a rabbini c grammar book abo ut majest ic plurals. In rea lity, ho we ve r. this example proves absol utely nothing abou t the majestic plural since it represen ts a typical use of the plural prono un "we." Sup/H).\'ed M aj en k Plural Referring 10 Kemosh
T he Ammo nites had not integr ated into Israe lite society as had o ther e thnic gro ups like the Ken ites (Jdg 05:24; ISa 15:06) and the Hitt ites (I Sa 26:06; 2Sa I I: I I ). The lack of integ ratio n was due to Ammonite reliance on sorcery and their false god, Kemosh (Dcu 23:03- 06). T he segregation a lso was a result of the Ammonit es and Moabues, the desce ndants of Lot, living o n buffer stale "reservations" (Gc n 19:38: Dcu 02:09- 11. 19-21) . T he)' shared th is status with the Edomite s, the descendants of Esa u (Deu 02:04-06; Jos 24:04). T he marginalized Ammonites wa ited three ce nturies until the Israelites were weak, and then they de manded land back that WlIS not theirs in the first place. The Ammonite rationale was not that they we re the majority occ upants or " the powers that be" over the disputed land (Jdg 11 :26: Ro m 13:0 I ). Instead, a corrupted oral history, or a misreading of Israelite history, informed the Ammonites that the Israelites had take n the ir land (Jdg I I:13). Neve rtheless. the Am monites wanted to undo three hundred years of history (Jdg 11:26). The Israelites operated o n the manifest destiny principle that Y(lJm :h had give n certain lands to the Israelites and ce rtain lands to the gentiles (Dell 02:05-24; Act 17:26), Jephth ah no ted that YaJ"":,,, himself had driven out the pre vious occ upants. and that Yahvch had given Israel thrce hund red years of uncontested occ upancy in the contested land (Jdg 11:23). Jephthah set the record straight by pointing out that Israel had take n the contested land from the Amorites ( Num 21 :21-24; Jdg II : 19-23). not from the Ammon ites (Deu 02: 19-21, 37). So in rea lity. the Ammonites were attempting a naked land grab of territory that belonged first to the Amori tes and then to the Israelites. Jephthah argued that if the Ammonites had bee n given an opportunity, they wou ld have confiscated land given to the m by "your clohim [literally. "gods"), Kemesh: (Jdg 11 :24). Je ph rhah's argu me nt was not so hypot het ical, fo r the Ammonites had driven out tribes to take their land (Dcu 0 2:19-23). Mo reo ve r. the Ammo nites were about to do so again by dislodg ing Israe l.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
38
Yael Natan
The s ituat io n be twee n t he Ammo nites and I sr ael oc c urred because t he Ammonite s relied on the ir sanitized and corrupted oral history, This h istory left them fee ling both self-rig hteous and wronged. Their history was as e ffective as a myth since it pro vided the pretext for group actio n and co hes io n. The Am monites could selectivel y misrea d Israel's written history to make land claims and construct moral superiority arguments. Jephtha h, how e ver, could not "fi ght fin: w ith fire" by reading the Ammon ite 's d isin fected histo ry. Jephthah co uld onl y co unter with the correct reading of Israelit e history. The correct reading probably sounded like only so much pro paganda to the Ammonites OJg 11:2 ~). So why did Je phthah ca ll K/'/Il (!.I'h "f'loh im," literally, "god s"? Using a maje stic pl ural to honor an e nemy's god does not motivate on e 's troops, nor does it make for effective psycholog ical warfare. Furthermore , it wo uld be incon s iste nt fo r Jephthah first to ho nor Kcmosh b)' using a majest ic plural (Jdg I I:24 ), and the n be little the Ammonite king, sayin g: Are you better tha n Balak son of Zippor. king of Moa b"? Did he ev er q uarrel with Israel or fight with them? (Jdg 11:25). Archaeol ogy see ms to pro vide an an swe r for wh y I ep ht hah ca lled Kemosh plura l "gods." Centurie s afte r the Je phrhah inc ide nt in Judges , Mes ha had the Moabite Stone made to bOlISI abou t his rebellion aga inst Israel. Me sha happens 10 be menuon ed in the Bible (2Ki rJ3:(4). Though Jep hthuh fo ug ht an Am monite king , and Mesh a was Moabire. both kings referred 10 the same god(s) Kemosh, Th e Ammon ites and Moabi tes and their gods arc mentioned togethe r in the OT ofte n. for instance, in Deu 23:03 -tl4. The A mmonites and Moabites were related (Gen 19:37-38). Their god s Molech and Kemosh are noted for having territorial ambit ions (Jer 49:01 -0 3). William Fox well Albright wrote: As a male, Athturt was kno w n a s Athta r and co rres po nde d 10 the Moabite god Kemosh , as well as the Am mon ite god Milco m, o r Molech ( I Ki 11:33)." Mcsha the n built a tem ple to Kemosh and Ashlar that showc ased the Moabitc Stone. The 34-line inscription c hise led aro und 850 BC is ca lled the Mesha inscnpnon." T he sto ne was redisco ver ed in 1868 AD. The stele (a lso spel led "s tela" ) boa sted of Mcsha's dastard ly deeds and mundane ads. In lines 14-18 of the inscr iption. Mesha calls his gods hy the co mpound name Astnar-Kemosh: .. .Now Kemosh said to me , 'Go se ize Nebo fro m Israel.' So I wen t at night and fo ugh t against it fro m the break of dawn until noon. I seized it and killed everyo ne of [irl-c-seve n thous and native men, fore ign men . nat ive wome n, forjeig n] women. and conc ubines- for I dev oted it to Ashtar-Kemosh. I took fro m there rh] e ves ]se ls of ruh veh and dra gged the m before Krmosh , Now the king o f Israel had built.. ." Another Moahite stone. the Balun Ste le , shows a king flan ked hy two fig ures. Archa eo lo gis ts sus pect that the fi gures are Kemosn wi th a sun d isk , and the goddes s A.\h/llr with a crescent moon." The Mesne inscription men tio ns K emosh
Malenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
39
ofte n (lines 0 3. OS, 09, 13, 14, IS, 19.33), but there is one me ntion o f AshtarKemosh (see quote abo ve). The mentio n of Astnar-Kcmosn on the Moabite Sto ne and the figure s on the Balua Ste le suggest that Kemosh was an mclusive ter m meaning Ashtar-Kemosh, That Kcmosh is a collective no un ex plains why Jcp hthah spo ke of Kcmosh using a sing ular ver b "causes to possess" with the pluralvgod s" (c1ohim) : That which Kemos h your gods causes you to possess-will yo u nol possess it'! (Jdg I I :24) . Tho ugh the Moa bite lan guage was closely related to He bre w,'" no Moa bite stde spo rts a majestic plural. Apparently. the Moebites d id not assimilate the majestic pl ural rationa lization from the Israe lites . though there is ev idence tha t Moabite s an d Israeli tes intc rrmnglcd : • The Moa bites were desce ndants of Lot (Gen 19:37). Lot undou bted ly kne w and spo ke Ihe same Hebrew that his uncle Abraham spoke (Gcn 12:0 5; 14:12), • The Jewish Tr ansjo rda n tr ibes mingled with the Moabites. Mcsha's inscription e ven ment ions a sanc tuary of Yahveh at Nebo at the edge o f Moabue terr itory (see lines 14 a nd 18 quoted above ), • A man of Judean desce nt wa s once a Moabite king (l Ch 04 : 22 ) .-~ ' • The book of Ruth reveals that the tribes west of the Jordan River als o m ixed with the Moabites. a nd • T he Moa bite god Kemosn was wors hipped in Jeru sale m fo r Iwo centuries betwee n the reigns o f Sol omon and Josiah ( I Ki I I :07.33; 2Ki 23: 13). T his data suggests that the maje stic plura l usage was unkno wn in ancient ti mes, an d was devised o nly in lnte rtestame ntal times.
The Supposed Majestic Plural Baalim (Lords) I n many ancient Near East language s, the word baahm (lo rds) was a near sy nony m fo r elohim (gods). If elohim we re used as a majestic pl ural. o ne wou ld ex pect that healim and other etohim synonyms would have been used as maje stic plurals, too. Howe ver. ancient Near Eas t libraries re veals that haalim re ferred to persons or things rather than to single. majestic persons. A study of the B iblica l data also sho ws that haalim always re fers to persons or things. Here is a study o f how the wor d boat was used in the OT, When refe rring to the god Ba(/I, the He brew word baal is made definite by: • Prefixing the definite art icle "t he" (ha ) as in ha8aal (the 8001) ami ha800lim ("t he Haal.\"), • Putting haal in a Heb re w construct make s heal 11 possessive (" H(wl's ," or "of Baar). o r • Pre fixing a prepo sition to boat suc h as "by" (beth) (Jer 02:0 8; 12;16: 23:13) or the pre posi tion " to" tlamadtn (Jdg 0 2:13; 06:3 1: IKi 16:32; 19: 18). Ot herwise. the He brew for m baal is used as: • A title meaning. "masters" or " husba nds" (Gcn 20:03), • A personal name ( IC h 05:05; 08: 30; 09 :36), or as • A syllahle in com pound: Matenal com direlbs autcrars
40
Yael Na ta n
o Place names (Exo 14:02), and o Personal names (Gcn 36:J~-39). The acco unt of E lijah on Mount Ca nnel shows that the word haBlIalim ("'the Hlwh'" refers ( 0 both HIllIl and Ashtorah , Elija h uses the singu lar leon hl/Baal (IK i 18: 19.21 ,22.25 ,26, 40) and the plural hatsoatim (I Ki \lUH) inte rch angeably in the account of Elijah a nd the Prophets of Baat. Elijah reve aled who the hattaatim were by say ing: .. . bri ng the fo ur hu nd red and fi tly prophe ts of Blilil an d the four hundred prophets of Astuorati (1 Ki 18: 19). So Elijah used the plural fo rm flllHal/lim (vthe 8(/(/1.\") as a pl ural collective noun referring to the god Baul and h is god dess consort Ashtoratr. In the acco unt of the Prophets of 8 /10/, both the singular form !w Raat and the pl ural haHlll/lim likely were co llective nouns referring to Baal and Ashtoroh, It is easy to understand ho w in patriarchal soc ieties the singular term haR(wl carne to be an inclu sive. co llective noun referr ing to the god Baal and his goddess consort. Many gods were assu med to have goddess consorts. thou gh the names of the goddesses may have never been invo ked in literature. The names o f the goddesses were often the fem inine form o f a god 's name. for examp le, Batl!"s goddess consort in Byblos was Baalat of Byblos." Similarly. Alla h's goddess consort or daughte r. de pending nn the locu tion and period. was Al/m [ Koran 053 :( 19). Somet imes the goddess consort was a goddess wi th all entirely d iffer ent name than the god. but their spheres of infl uence we re related. For ex am ple, Baurs goddess consort Asmorah has a name with no etymological connection to Baal, but Baat-Shamash was " Lord of Heave n" a nd Ashtorah happened to be the "Q ueen of Hea ven" (Jer 07: 18: 44: 17, 19). Baars symbol so metimes was the sun. As!llOrah's astral association was Venus. The sun and Ven us o ften rise and set together. T hat Raul and A\/rwmh's spheres of infl uence are related help to acco unt for their being know n as Ill/Baalim (I Ki 18: 18). Ca lling Baal and Asntorah Baalim is similar to calling a husband and wife by the plural " the Joncscs." The word IwBaalim als o was used as a co llect ive no un referring to a pantheon. Hosea , ev idently spea king of a pantheon, said the hu baalim have a " their name [singular]" (Hos 02 :17). That haBaalim (vthc Baal.{·) became synony mo us with "pantheon" is because the gnd Buul wa s a ruin god , amo ng oth er things. In t he parched environme nt of the ancie nt Near East. his rain and fert ility roles mea nt Bact was the de [acto top god in most C anaanite pantheons . So thc term habaatim was used as a collective plural to refer to many gods (Jdg 0 2:1 1; 03 :07: 08:33; 10:06. 10; ISa 07:04; 12: 10: IKi 18:1 8; 2Ch 17:0 3; 24:07; 28: 0 2: 33:03 ; 34:04 ; Jer 02:23; 0 9:14; II :13; Hos 02: 13). Ce rtain verses provide esped ally stro ng evidence that haBaalim referred to seve ral deities (Jdg 02: 11 -12: 03:07; 08:33; 10:(6). Tbe fll/ :vdolJlledia Britwlllic(I slates that there were many Hoo ts: It is clear that severa l different deities arc referred to by the form Baa/·X r''Lord of X"). Hudad is probably represented by !Ju{/i-Shilmt'll (t'Lord of the Heavens"). F.l appeared under the title BU{"-Hulllm(JIl :'~ Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
41
Suppo.l'ed Maj en k P/urals Ref errinf( to Goaaess Consorts Asheroh (hilA.I'hert/h) was the Canaanite gnddess of fo rtune and happi ness. Asherah is only referred 10 as 11 perso nal goddess a fe w times (lKi 18:19; 2Ki 23: 0 4, ( 7). Most translations only ha ve the plural form of Ash;'rah's name once in the phrase: "the Boats and the Asturans" (N fV Jdg 03:07, but RSV transliterates the plural as A.l hl'mth) . Otherwise, "groves" or "Asherah poles" is the standard translation of the Hebre w plural forms lIaAsherorh (Jdg 03:07; 2Ch 19:03; 33:03) and haA.~hl.'filII (2Ki 23:14: 2Ch 14;02; 17:06; 24:18; 3 1:0 1. 19; 34:07; Isa 27:09: Bzc 27:06). T his leaves o nly o ne plural form of Asherah in the whole OT that might be classified as a plura l of majesty - "the A.I'hemhs" in Jdg 03:07. T here are a few al te rnative ex ptananons for the plural fo rm "Asherahs" or " Ashcrorh" in Jdg 03:07, oth er than that Asheratxs is a majestic plural. Perhaps the plural fon n !UlA,I'hl.'mth should be trans lated as "groves" ( KJ V. LXE Jdg 03 : 07) or "sh rines" ( YLT Jdg 03:07). If "the Baals' are understood to mean the male population of the pantheon, than "the A~hemhs" may stand for the goddesses of the pantheon. T he plura l A.I'hem!l.l' may also stand for Baal's three goddess co nsorts who, according to certain Ugaritic myths. were jea lous riva ls: A.I'hrorah , Astarte, and A na /h . The jea lous, love- hate rcla nons hip of Baal and Asntorah was the explanation provided for the cold and hot seaso ns ex perie nced eac h year in many Mcdircrraucan regions.
Israel's Neigh bors Kn ew No Majestic Plural Sl nta x The following examples show that in Palestine collective no uns, but no t majestic plurals , were used to refer to gods and even to Yahveh, Abraham and rhe Three Men Three heave nly men came to visit Abra ham. These me n d id no t pose as Israelites s ince Israel did not ex ist at the time. Abraham must have assumed at first that they were Arnrneans. perhaps from Hara n, Abraham addressed the three men ax "01) Lord s" (AdO/wi). The plura l form Adona ; literally means "my Lords," but modern translations read " Lord." Thai "they answered Abraham" (Ge n 18:05) shows that the Father was Lord, the So n was Lord. and the Sp irit was Lord, as the Athanasian C reed teaches. Abraha m said, " If now I have found favor in your [singular) sighr..." (Gen 18:03). T hat Abraham used a singular "sight" shows that Abraham meant "Lords" as a plural collective no un. If the three visito rs had unde rstood AdO/wi ax a majestic plural, then they wou ld have understood Abraham to say "m ajestic lo rd [singu lar )" rathe r th an "lords [plural]." If the three men were familiar with majestic plurals, they wou ld have thoug ht that Abraham had addressed only o ne majestic lo rd of the three. Thai all three visitors replied (Gen 18:05) shows that the three visitors thought Abraham had addressed them co llectively as a group of lo rds. T his shows that the Matenal com direlbs autcrars
42
Yael Natan
majest ic plura l was nol known in the Near East (palestine or Me sopo tam ia). Since the three visitors we re from hea ven. evide ntl y the majestic plural was unkno wn eve n in hea ven during Abraham 's da y.
LOI and the Two Mt'n S imilar 10 the situat ion with Abraham and the three visitors (Oen I ll), Lo t addres sed the two visitors as "my Lords" (AdO/w i ). They both ans we red (Ge n 19: 02 ). If the two visitors we re familiar with the majest ic plural. they wou ld have tho ught Lot addre ssed only one majes tic lord, but not both. That the Son and Spirit an swered Lot suggests that the two visitors knew of no majestic plural syntax (G en 19:02).
Ahraham and Ahimelech tire Fhitistinc Ru ler The Philistines called Dagon clohim (gods) OJg 16:23-24; IS a 05:07 ). T he Philistines also used sin gu lar verbs with the plura l form elohim (ld g 16:23-24 ). The plural elohim used with a s ing ular verb indicates that when the Philistines refer red to Dago n as "gods," they used etotnm as a pl ural co llect ive no un. The Phil istines co uld have used the plural collect ive no un clohim to refer to both Dagon and h is goddess consents)." T he plural fo rm d ohim may have bee n used to ind icate that Dago n was a pluri form god. Dago n may ha ve been plurifm m meaning tha t Dagon had a: • Dual nature. s ince Dagon was supposed ly part fish an d pan man, or an • Androgyno us nature. Dagon wo uld have been like Astarte , who o rig inally was thought to be androgy nous." Abraham told Abirnelech: God s (£ {oll illl ], they c aused [plural verb] me to wander. .. (Ge n 20:13). Abime jech must have understoo d Abraham to he using a plural co llec tive noun with a plural verb to speak of perso ns comprising one god. If Abimelec h had not bee n fam iliar with plural collective noun s, the n Abimelech would have as sumed Abraham was using quantitative plum Is. If Abimclcch only knew of quantitative pl urals, than Abimelech wo uld have understood Abraha m to be speaking as a polythe ist-as thou gh Abraham had se veral gods. Abraha m co uld speak to Abim e1cch using plurals no uns and verbs referring to the person s o f Yoh vch, O ther pagan s, ho we ve r, wou ld have under stood such talk to be polythe istic. The difference between Ab ime lech a nd othe r pagans is that " (All] the God s [ht/£/ohilll )"' (the Tri nity) had appeared to Ab imelech (Ge n 20 :0 6). Beca use Abimc1ech had seen the three persons know n as vahveh, Abime1cch knew that Abraham was speak ing as a Trini tarian rather than as a poly theist. Later in the acco unt, Abraham prayed to " [All ] the Gods [hat.;/ohim)" (the Trinity ) to heal Abimcl cch (Gc n 20: 17). T he Phil ist ine s ca me to know the Tr inity frnm an c ie nt Yahvis ts who we re Abraham's co ntemporar ie s , Yahv ist s suc h a s Melchized ek (G e n 14: 18-20). Yahvists subseq uently ke pt the Philistines informed of Yahven-: Ynhvists such as
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
43
Jaco b (Gen 26:28), Salaa m (N um 22 -24) and the Israeli te s duri ng the Exod us ( Exo 13: 17; Num 14:14: Deu 32:31 : Jos tl,'Hll). Du ring the time of the Judges, the Philistines see m to have known that YlIhreh was the Tri ni ty. The Philisune s used sing ular verbs to refer to Dagon (1dg 16: 23), but some times spoke of Yahl'eh using plural nou ns and plura l ve rbs. T he Philist ines said: God s [plural noun] have co me [singular verb ].. .who can de liver us fro m the hand [singular noun] of the mighty [pluraludjccrivc ] God s [pluralnoun]? T hey [plu ral pro noun] ale the same [plural pronoun) Gods [plural no un] who struck [plural ver b) the Egyptians with all kinds of plagues (I Sa 04:07-(8). Jacob and His Familr Since Laban of Haran was considered an Aramea n (Gen 28:05: 3 1:20 : 3 1:24), and Jacob was conside red a "wander ing Ara mea n" (Dc u 26:05), one co uld say that Jacob 's fam ily was as much Ar umcan as Israe lite (Gc n 32:28: 35:10). Th e langua ge of Arumeans was Aramaic or a sister lang uage, As wa s disc ussed before. the Ara maic langu age apparen tly d id not use majestic plural s. Jacob told h i.s fam ily to bury all their foreig n gods (Gen 35:02). It is interesting that just afte r Jaco b and h is clan made a cle an break with po lythei sm. the na rrator used a plural noun and verb to refer 10 Y ahveh: "Gods [E/ohiml. they had re vealed [plural verb ] himself to him" (Gc n 35:07 ). If the narrator were not Trinitarian. it wou ld ha ve made better se nse to use singu lars in this si tuation. Sennacherlh :1' Offkia/.I' Se nnachenh's o fficers as ked in Hebrew (2 Ki 18:28): Ho w can your Elohim [God s) de liver [singular verb] you o ut of mine hand (2C h 32: 14)? . .Ho w m uch le ss sha ll your Elohim [pl ural no un] del iver [plural verb] )'O U out of my hand (2C h 32: 15)! T he Ch ro niele r wrote, "Se nnac he rih's office rs spoke fu rt her against Yohvch Eloh im" (2C h 32:1 6). The Chro nicler also wrote : T hey spoke about the E/ohim of Je rusalem as they did abou tthe £/ohim of the othe r peoples of the wo rld (2C h 32: 19), The offi cer s referred to Yo/we" using the pl ural fo rm £ /o h;m with both singular an d plura l verbs. S ince the ot he r nations d id not use a majestic plural syn tax. and since the officers spo ke o f Yahreh as the)' did o f oth er gods, Scnnachcnb's officials must not have used majestic plurals to refe r to Yahvch, Anot her ind ication that majestic plurals were not used is that the o ffice r was waging psycho logica l warfare. He wo uld want to d iminish the glory of ranven (2C h 32: 15), All thi s suggests that Se nnac henb's officers knew o f no majestic pl ural synta x, but they d id know there were persons called Ya hl'e h - the Tr inity.
Dodd's Psalm Da vid co mplained about fo reign rulers. and prayed that G od wou ld judge the earth so the nation s wo uld say: Matenal com direlbs autcrars
44
Yael N ata n
Most assuredly. God s [plural noun], they j udge [plural part iciple] the e arth (Psa 05&: I I ). Surely. the ge ntiles did not usc majestic plurals. so Dav id 's phra se wou ld so und a wfully polytheistic nil ge ntile lips. T he plural s suggest that David ho ped the gent iles wou ld one da y come to know the Trinity (,1I1/1lI.I'H'.
Indeclin able Nouns as Ccllecuve Nouns As wa s mentioned at the start of thi s chapte r, Hebre w speak er s so metimes paired s ingular collective nou ns with plural predicates. On e ex ample is that the seemingly s ingular form Yohvch is so metimes paired with plura l verbs. plural mod if iers. and plural no uns such as E/o him (God s ). Ap paren tly. }{,h l'eh is an indecl inable noun. Ind ecli nable no uns arc no t all tha t unc o m mon , pe rhaps in any langu age. Engli sh has indecli nabl e no uns (so metimes ca lled "in varian t no uns" ) wher e the singular and plural form s are iden tical. The pluralized for m of any of these nou ns see ms forced and unnatural, for instance, " proge nies:' Examples incl ude: aircraft, appa ratus, biso n, darkness. dee r, fi sh, gro use, hardware. hiatus. home work . informat ion. lo gistics, migh t, offspring. progen y, prospectus. scissors. series. sheep. silverware, software, species, status. thunder and woo l. Hebrew also has indeclinable no uns such as owph ("bird" or " birds"). Fo r exa mple, in lob 12:0 7, owph shou ld be translated " birds" rather than " bird," s ince in the preceding parallel co ns truc tion in lob 12:0 7, the noun "animals" is pl ural. yet take s a s ingular verb. He brew sing ulars may he used to denote singular persons or things, or a co llection of persons or things, e ven when there is a perfec tly valid plural fonn that co uld ha ve been e mployed. For instance: • adam (an mcan Adam (Gc n 05 :(1 ), both Adam and Eve together (Gc n 01: 2628), a man. or humanit y, • eyr; ca n mean a tree , grov e or forest. or a Slick or sticks (E ze 37: 17 is di scussed later in thc chapte r). Note that the plural eytsim is a lso used , • bahemah can mean an ox or ca ule (Gen 0 1:24 ), • di mah ca n mea n a tea r or tea rs (P sa 006:07; 042: (4). The plura l form of dimah is fo und once in the OT (La m 02: I l]. • ROy ( an mean a ge ntile or a nation (Gen 18: 18). T hc pl ural fo rm Roy im is also used, • yond (an mean a hand or hands (G cn 19: [0 , 16). The Hebrew singular " hand" (Psa 0 3 1:05 ; BIIS Psa 03 1:06) is translated into the Greek as " hands" (LXX Psa 03 1:06 ; Luk 23:46), and • zerah can mean a seed or seeds (compare Gal 0 3: 16). The co nte xt and the subject-ve rb agree me nt indic ate wheth er indeclin able nou ns are to be understood as sing ulars or as co llect ive nouns. Som et imes s ing ular nou ns are used, see mingly to emphasize that person s or thing s are a co llect ive entity. For instance : Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
45
• The peo ple [sing ular noun] journeyed [plura l ver b] from Hazero th (Num 12: 16), • T he Amale k ite [in ot her words, " the Arna le kues"] and Ca naa nite lin o ther words, "the Canaanites "] that lived on that mountain came [sing ular ver b] down (Num 14:45), and • Lcr l sractlsingular noun] rejoice [sing ular verb] in his Make rs [plural noun) , let the peo ple (plural noun] o f Zion be glad [plural verb] in their King (Psa 149:02). Case Studies on Hebrew Collective Nouns Ya/weh as an Indeclinable Cotteaive NO/III
Most OT translat ions never mention the He bre w word Yaln'eh, thou gh so me mention the pse udon ym Jeh o vah. To ind ica te tha t Yahl'eh is the undc rlying Hebr ew word, translators ca pitalize the entire word as " LORD" or as "GOD:' Yah veh occurs 6,R2R times in 5,790 OT verses. Tho ugh Ylih yeh occ urs so o ften, Yahl'eh is not declined o nce." eve n when paired with pl ural verbs and modifie rs (as is noted in the MT plurals appen dix }. YlIllI'eh is not declined eve n when used as a possessive Hebrew "co nstruct." In English translations, ho weve r, the possessive YiIIIl'eh is tra nslated as LORD's . That Yahreh is an indeclinable noun is made conspicuo us by: • The shee r number of occ urrences of the Name, Yahveh, in the OT,
,"d • The fact thai Hebrew is an inflected lang uage, Ho w did Yohvch beco me an indeclinable noun? Eve knew the Farber hy the Name, vonven (Ge n 04 :0 1). Peo ple spoke or heard Ihe Name, Yahveh, in 52 Genesis verses.> Th at Moses knew of the Name, Yahveh. is ev ide nced by the fact that the sho rtened form of Yahveh (Ya) is embedded in the nantes o f persons born before the events of Exo 03 and 06, for instance : • Jochebed (me aning, "Yahveh is glory") was the mother of Moses, Aaron and Miriam (Exo 06:20; Num 26:59), and • Joshua (mea ning, "Yalil'ch saves") was born be fo re the Exodus fro m Egy pt (Nurn 32: 11- 12), and was a leader as early as Exo 17:09 . The Name, Yahveh, was likel y deri ved fro m a form (Qa{ imperfec t, I st perso n singular) of the verb " I am" tha t was c urrent at the Creation (Gcn 0 2:04b; 04 :26 ). The Name, Yahveh, ossified while the conjugation for " I am" grad ually changed. This is not unlike how ma ny archaic forms co me into existence. A certain fo rm ossifies while the rest of the co njugation o r decle nsion mor phs aro und it, or the form fos silizes whi le the rest of the conj ugation or de cle nsio n becomes exunct. Language students k now that entire lan guage s ff ux ove r time. Heavily used conj ugations like the '" am" conj ugation often acqu ire so many irregular to nus that se para te conjugation tab les are necessitated. The breakdown of irregular co njugations sometimes de fies explanation. so rote memorization is necessitated. The abo ve was a gene ral ex planat ion of the Name, Yahreh. however, here is a mo re det ailed analys is. At the burning bush, the Son told Moses thai his name Malenal com direlbs
autcrars
46
Yael Natan
was Yahveh (Exo 03: 15-16. 18).11 The Son pointed OUi that the Nam e. Yohveh, had been derived fro m ehyeh, Ehyeh is the Qaf impe rfec t first per son form o f the verb "1 am: ' The BHS He brew of Exo 03: 14 has the form ehyeh three times: God said 10 Moses, 'I AM k hye hl who I AM [ehyeh l.' And he said , 'Say this to the people of Israel, 'I AM Iehreh l has se nt me to you" (Exo 0 3: 14). The grammatical and etymological specifics on the form Yah veh are disputed. but the meaning, '"I AM ," is what is mo st important. In NT times, for instance , the Son po inted OUi to Septuagint (LXX) readers thai he was the "1 AM" (" C811' eillli'). Thi s is the same Greek phrase used to translate the Hebrew for " I AM " phr ase s in LX X Exo 03: 14 and elsew here. The fonn Yah ~'f'h is not a form in any conjugat ion table, and there is no con se nsus on the exact etymology of Yah l'eh. These facts give the author license to propose an e xplanation . In the Ga rden o f Eden , the Fathe r said his name was " I AM: ' This existential-sounding name was told Adam and Eve [Gen ()4; 0 1,26). Reve aling th is name was appropriate since Adam and Eve surely were thinking cosmological and existential tho ughts. In the proto-Hebrew that Adam and Eve spoke, the Qui imperfect of the verb "I am" likely was vahveh , There was the da nger thai Adam a nd Eve might think the Name, vahven. was just a homon ym of the "I am" verb form vahveh , So the Fathe r likely indicated this name actually mea nt, " I AM," Moses met the Son at Mount Sinai many centuries after the Creation. Moses kne w thm the Father's name was Yah veh; but did nOI know the Mu lek Yah ~'eh' s name. The Son said his name was Yahl'eh , too. The So n referred to the Hebrew ve rb form rhyeh ("I am") to e xplain the name Yi,h l'eh's meaning of "I AM ," Of course, the fo rms ehveh and Yu /n'eh no longer were ide ntical beca use the ancient proto- Hebre w fo rm yahveh had softe ned to e!lyeh in He brew. The proc ess of so fte ning hard words occurred with grea ter freq ue ncy before the ad vent of dictionaries. Dictionaries have the affect of standa rdizing spelling and pronuncia tion. For instance, the harder sound ing "annoy" and softer so und ing "ennui' a re derived from the same French word. The reason for the d ifferen t pronunciation is thai "annoy" was borrow ed in the 1275 AD from Old French, while "e nnui" was borro wed in 1732 AD from Middl e French. Thi s example of a word softening occurred before dictiona ries became ubiq uitous in Europe . Etymological studies shnw that soft leiters go silent, es pec ially soft letters that begin words. Deep, harsh gutturals have all but d isappeared from most langua ges, and hard phon emes le nd to softe n. This wo uld explain why in Mose s' day the Name , Yahveh, no lo nger matched the Qaf imperfect ti na person of the verb "I am" (ehyeh ). Apparently, the initial soft sound ing " y" of Yahveh had dropped, and the hard "v" sound had changed to the so ft vy" sound. leaving the form ehveh , Fac tors that led to the ossification of the Name, Yah veh, incl ude; • Respect for the d ivine name, and • There was no need fo r a plural form of YlIhl'eh from the time o f Eve until the time of Moses. Onl y on Mount Sinai did Moses find o ut that the Son as well as the Father was named Yahw h. Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewish Trinity
47
Thi s book 's chapte r on Proro-Stnalnc Trinitarianism e xplains that the patriarchs kne w only the father as vah veh, Of course, the post-Smauic narra tor of Gene sis knew that the Father, So n and Spirit were all named Ya hl'eh, but the patriarchs did not kno w the Spiril as rahveh, The patriarc hs kne w the Son only as EI Shaddoi and as the M alek Yallwh (the Angel of Yah l'eh). After meetin g Yahveh on Mount Sinai. Moses co ntinued to use the form Yah veh as an indecli nabl e no un. Moses did not upda te the Name , Yo h l'eh. to chych s ince Moses knew that the unde rlying meaning was what was really important. Moreove r, the ancie nt Name, tchveh, surely was dear In many Near East Yahvists. Moses did not also contrive a plura l for Yohveh, Moses knew that Yahveh cou ld be unde rstood as a singular or as a collective noun. thereby obv iating the r eed for a plural. Furthermore. 10 say that there were three Yahvehwrnighrlead to polytheistic notions about Yuh veh, but God is one (De u 06:04). Us ing the conte xt as a guide, Hebre w speakers used other indec linable no uns without co nfusion, for instance, OWl'h ("bird" or " birds"). He brew speakers cou ld differe ntiate when Yah l'eh was used as a s ingular to refer to o ne perso n. or as a collective noun to refer to the Trinity. That is, of course . as long as the re were no ingra ined. preconceived no tions to obfuscate matters, The fact that Yah l'eh is an indeclinable noun has never been the real problem. From ln tertestamenra l times to the present. however. the failure or refusal to recognize that Yahveh is an indeclinable noun has led man)' dow n the rocky road from Trinitarian ism to unitarianism. Many e xegetes have failed to see that vah veh can be used as a singular or as a co llective noun e ven though vahveh is associated with: • Singular as well as plural verbs. pronoun s and modifiers (as is noted in the MT plurals appendix), • The plural fo rm ha Eloh im , meaning. "[ All] the Gods.'?" HaElohim , of course, was discussed previously in this chapter. and • Most of the 2,600 instances of the plural form Efohim (literally, "Gods"] fo und in 2,247 verses. Translators always treat Yah veh and Elohim as singulars, hut ne ve r as co llective nouns referring to Yah reh. T he upshot of this practice is that reade rs of translations mista ke nly assu me that thousands of occurrences of YuJII'eh and God are prima f acie ev idence that God is a single person. Most translation reade rs would be surprised to learn that plural form s for God such as Elohim vastly outnumb er sing ular forms suc h as El and Elo(w)ah . That trans lations ne ver treat YU /II' eh and Elohim as collective noun s is es pecia lly insidious whe n coupled with Mairnomdes ' non -bihhcal vach id vers ion of the Shema . The yochi d versio n says 't(lh l'eh is "a unique o ne" while the Biblica l edllld version says Yohveh is "a united one," While the majestic plural may have been introd uced to combat polyrhcisnc notions pre valent during Intertestamental times, Maimo nides ' non- biblical vochid ver sion of the Sh cma was introd uced to combat Trini ta rianis m. Ma imo nides (11 3&-1 204) lived in southern Spa in d uring the Islamic occ upatio n where no polytheism existed. Thu s. Maimonides" Shell/a , along the majestic plural usage and Matenal com direlbs autcrars
48
Yael Natan
other arguments , are taught 10 ensure that stude nts read the Trinitarian Bible as tho ugh it were a unit arian book. T he Bi ble in the o riginal langu age s co ntains overw he lming evidence of th e Trinity. and tranvlationv wo uld too if the He bre w and Ara maic pl ural collective nou ns, plural verbs and plural mod ifie rs we re tran slated as plu ral s. Th is wou ld con stitu te ov er whelm ing ev iden ce that Yah vch is the Tr inity. Ho we ver . du e to the policy of tra nslating nearly all plurals referring 10 Yohvch as sing ulars. man y Trinitari an proofs are lost in tr anslation. Trinitarians are left ta lking abo ut ho w the OT "h ints" o f the Trinity. This, of co urse. undcrwhclms oppon ents and skeptics . A s translatio ns now read: • Provin g monothei sm to be bibl ica l is an overly e asy. downh ill bailie again st wou ld-be pol ytheists, but • Pro ving Trini tari ani sm 10 be b iblical is an un nece ssarily hard, upb ill battle against wou ld-be uni tarian s.
Echad Gi rd Echadim Used as Co lleclil'e Noun s St ud ying the use of /'dwd(im) (vuni ted one (s)" ) is info rm ati ve for the study of other co llective nouns such rah voh , t ;/ and Elohim. Furt hermore . the words Yahl'eh. £ /oh ill/ and echad all happen to be fou nd in the Shema (D cu 06 :04): Hear. 0 Israel : Yohveh [the r ather] [and] our E/ohilll [the Son]. Yah l'cn [the Spirit] [are ] a uni ted o ne k d ra(J] lDeu 06:04). Yahveh; Elohim and edwd's use as collec tive nou ns indicates that the Sh ema speaks o f Yahl'eh as be ing person s who are " a unite d on e" (ech o(/). For instance , the narrator of Judges uses echod as a collec tive noun to refer to per sons: All the men o f Israel were gathe red [singular verb ] to the city as one [et'hdd ] man [singular noun ], com pan ions (Jdg 20 : II ).'" Note tha t pl ural "companions" are called " o ne (r('hadJ ma n." and a singular verb is used . T here are many more passages whe re echad is used similarly. for instanc e: • Eve ning and mo rning were one da y (Gcn 0 1:0 5), • Man and woman becom e one fle sh (Oen 02 :24 ; Ma l 02: 15; co mpare ICo 06: 16). • Asse mblies. soldiers and nations were con sidered one (Gen 11 :0 6 ; Num 14: 15 ; Jns 0 9:tl2; Itl:42; Jdg 06 : 16 ; zorn. OR, 11; 2S a 02 :25 ; 07:23: 19 : 14: Ezr tl2:64: 03 :0 1; Neh 0 8:01), • Two gro ups plan ning to intermarry wo uld have bee n one peop le (Gen 34: 16 ). • Th e two dreams that the pharaoh dreamt (G en 4 1:32) had one interpret atio n (Ge n 41 :25-26), • The people answered with o ne vo ice (Exo 24:03 ), • C urtain s we re strung together so the tabe rnacle became one (Exo 26 :06 . II ; 36 : 131, • A q uan tity of gra pes wa s cons idered one clu ster tho ugh the cluster wa s so large that two men had to carry it on a pole (N um 13:23 ). and • Trum peters and s inge rs made o ne vo ice (2Ch 05: 13). Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
49
Two OT ve rses have the singular form cchad and the plural form echadim in the same verse. Th e narrator, Moses, wrote : T he who le earth had o ne (ed uu/] lan guage of a few k chadim ) d ialect s [lueralty, "words" ) (Gen II :01), The plural form echadim ( an mea n "one" (E ze 37 :17), bu t cchadi m likel y sho uld be tra nslated as "a few " w he n modifying plural nou ns." For exa mple. echadim paired with the plural word "d ays" should be translated as "a few days" (Ge n 27:44; 29:20; Dan I I : 20) . ~ 1 The plural form cchadim ("'united o nes") is meant 10 em phasize -s-even more tha n the sing ular torm echnd r- e united one"). that a who le is co mprised of paris. In ot her wo rds. seve ral da ys eq uals a few kdradim) days, a few (('c1wdim ) d ialect s comprise a langu age . and the like. T he author labe ls this usc of the plural a plural of dtstrt buuon -,.a type of pl ural co llective noun. A plural of di stributio n is meant to sho w that a whole is di st ributed over pa rts. The othe r instance o f echad and erh aaim being used in the same verse oc curs when roh veh told Ezekiel: Join them one to the othe r, so that to you the stick will be one , and they will beco me a uni ted one in you r hand (E/.e 37:1 7). Ezc 37: 17 di ffere ntiate s three use s o f cchad ("a uni ted one " ) and echadim (vunited one s"): Join them [two stic ks I one [echad (sing ular noun j] to the othe r [cchad (sing ular noun )]. so that 10 you the stick Ieyl; (co llect ive noun )] will he one [edwd (coll ecti ve noun)], and they will become a united o ne In 'had im (plural of distribu tion l] in yo ur hand (Eze 37:17). Here is a more detai led look at t he three uses of cctioa and echadim found in Ezc 37: 17; I. Ezekiel used echad as a reg ular singular for m to refer to the indi vid ual sticks befo re they we re assem bled. Ezek iel called the part s "one" (cch ad) and the "other" (echad), 2. Ezek ie l used the singular form cchad (" a united nne") as a co llect ive nou n to under sco re the aspect of union. Similarly, anothe r pro phet. Zecharia h. ca lled h is shep herd's staff "Un ion" kdrad) to emphasize the union of brot he rhood be tween J udah and Israel (Zec 11 :07, 14). Zechariah then bro ke the stick into two to stress how there once had been a unio n (Zec I I: 14), and 3. Ezekiel used the pl ural echadim (" unitcd ones") to (all atten tio n to ho w the stic k was assem bled from co mponent parts ca lled: • "The m" and "they," as we ll as • "One (c('had) a nd the other (ech ad) ." So in Eze 37; 17 echadim is a plural of d istri bution-a ty pe o f plura l collec tive noun . In Eze 37:17. rchad is paired with the sing ular for m e.l'l: meaning , "stic k": Jo in the m o ne [e('ha d (singular nounj ] to the o the r [et'had (sing ular nou nj], so thai 10 yo u the stick Iey/ ;;: (co llect ive nou n)! will be one lee/wd (co llective no unI]. Malenal com direlbs autcrars
50
Yael Na tan
Not e that two uni ted st icks we re conside red on e (I;'("hl.l d) st ick (Eze 37: 17). The singular form eyt: (Gcn 02:17 ) is used o ften as a collective noun meaning, "s ticks" and " trees" (Ge n 0 I: II ). thou gh the plural for m eyl,I';1II (trees ) is used ofte n elsew here (Le v 01 :07). Evt; in Ezc 37:17 and Yahl'eh in the Shema (Dell 06 :04 ) arc co m parable in that
they are both paired with the word erhad. rahvch; as we have seen. can be a collective no un just as "yf::. is com monly used as a colle ctive nou n. So just as Exe 37: 17 says th m sticks (eyl:) are a united one (edllld) . the Shem« co uld vel)' well indic atc that fa /well arc perso ns who arc a united one (edwd ). t :ehlld im is No la Plum l of tntensitv So me majestic plural propo nen ts might venture thai edwdim is a plural of inte nsity, a var iation on the so-called majestic plura l rationaliza tion. T hey wo uld say a plural o f inten sity is like a majestic plura l in that the plural form fa ils to ind icate an y so rt of plurality. The plural suppose d ly gives a s uperlat ive me aning to the s ing ular- like " h ighes t" rath er than just "h igh." Majestic plural proponen ts thi nk that the e xiste nce o f the plural of inte nsity te nds to prove the ex istence o f the plural of majest y, since born usages are similar. Mo reo ve r, prov ing that both grarnmutical con struction s ex ist wo uld buttre ss the unitarian interp retation o f the OT. If echudim (literally, "ones" ) were tra nslated a.s a plural o f intensity, the superlative meaning wou ld be " very one" or "abso lute o ne" o r "alone." If. ho we ver. cchadim is a type o f pl ural collec tive noun, than cchadim wo uld mean "a few." Not ice that the d iffe rent defi nitions the plural of intensity and the co llective noun produce are near ly antonyms: "absolutely one" vers us -a fe w," We ' ve alread y see n that echadim is usually trans lated "a few" (Ge n 11:0 I; 27: 44 ; 29:20; Da n I I:20 ). Moreo ve r. the "alone" l)Yll,'hill ) interpre tation o f the Shcma is not he lped by an "alone" translatio n of echadim. T he rea son is that the Shema has the sing ular fo rm ech ad and not the plural for m ech adim. So it would see m that echadim is a pl ural collective noun ("united one") rather than a plural o f inten sity (uniquely one ). The re are other exa mples of the supposed plural of inten sity. For instance. it is said that the s ingular for m olam means "old," so the plural fo nn o!amim in Ecc 0 I: 10 must mean "ancien t." Th is definition might be correct. however. the pro pone nts for the plural of inten sity arri ved at the co rrect defini tio n th rough the wrong methodology. After all, a broken cl ock is still acc urate twice eac h d ay! The English equivale nt o f what the Heb rew author had in mind by the plural otamim perhaps was not so much "o ldest" or "ancient," but rat her "o ld, old, old. " The plural form otamim, therefore. stood for multi ple uses o f the s ing ular otam. Th is is similar to how: • The plural ectmdim (vunited o nes" ) stoo d for two uses o f the sing ular in Eze 37: 17: echad (o ne) and echad (the other ). ££'ha and echodim we re di scussed above.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
51
Eloh im (" G od ~" ) may he a plural standing for "God, God , God" (t.:l, 1::1, El )three persons who arc one God. or in other words. the Trin ity. Perh aps consjderanou of Hebrew dual form s would he instructive. Whet her dual forms are translated as singulars or plurals is depen dent on the context. Either way, dual forms are not translated as plurals of intensity. However. eve n whe n dual form s a rc translated as sing ulars, therc is so me sense of plurality: • "Heave m sj ' (.\hu I/Il/yim) refe rs to the severa l "sphe res ." T he clouds were kno wn to he closer s ince they covered the moon. Occultatio n and the varying swiftness of the heave nly bod ies suggested that certa in regions we re fa rther than others, • "Pacer's]" (/Hmim ) may refer to ho w the face has bilateral sy mme try: two ears, two eyes, two nostrils. and so forth, and • "Water(s )" ( may i m ) may refer to ho w many dewdrops form a droplet, ho w many drops fonn a unit of water, and how a unit of water can form rivu lets (Ge n 0 2:10). Majestic plural propone nts offer more exa mples in thei r attempt to prove plurals of intensity' e xist. These examples, ho we ver, indicate plurality rathe r than intensity. The plural fonn may be used to indicate repeated behavior. o r abstractness. Abstract ideas are plural in the sense thai they are abstracted from the study of many e xamples or lessons. and then the abstract idea is in tum applied to many situations or dimensions. Here are some exa mples supposed to be plurals of inten sity that perhaps are better interpreted in a plural sense: • "Wisdoms" docs not necessarily mean "great wisdo m," but merely that a person is wise about a number of subjects (Psa 049 :04 ), • "Dark nesses" does not necessarily mean "great darkness," but rather "da rk places" (KJV, YLT Lam 03 :06). Ano ther inte rpretation is that a deep shadow is usua lly comprised of both a partial (penumbra) and full (umbra) shadow, • "Co mpass ions" does not necessarily mean one has "great co mpass io n," but merel y indicates many acts of co mpass ion (Lam 03:22), • "H arlotries" docs not necessarily mean "g reat harlot ries," but mcrely that many acts of fo rnication is tantamoun t to harlot ry ( Hos 0 1:02), • "Btnemesses' does not necessarily mean "great bittern ess," but mere ly indicates thaI there are multiple bitter situanon s (Hos 12:14 (BHS 12:1 5). and • "Blood s" docs no t mea n " very blood y: ' but merel y indica tes multiple stab wounds (Exo 22:02 -03; Hos 04 :02). •
Summa rv Findings 0 11 Edwdim Moses showed that things called echad ("a united one"] could he comprised of echodim ("united one s"), for example: • O ne (et'hl./tl) language could be co mprised of "a few" (ed w dim ) dia lects (Ge n I l :OI ), and • O ne (et 'hl./t/im) period of time is "a few" days (Gen 27:44; 29:20; see also Dan 11 :20 ).
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
52
Yael Natan
The writer of Jud ges wrote that people can be co nsidered in a singular or plural se nse - bo th echad ("a united one" ) and "compan ions" (Jdg 20: 11). Ezekiel referred 10 an unassem bled part (a st ick) as echad (o ne). Ezek iel showed thai the asse mbled parts (two sticks put e nd 10 end) co uld be referred to both as ech od C'a united one") and echadim t''untrcd ones"). T hat Mo ses and Ezek iel used bo th the singular (crill/d ) and plural (eduulim) as co llec tive noun s to describe the same things is no wonder, Echad comes from a Hebrew root that means "10 uni fy" or " 10 co llect together." So ech ad was used to e mphasi ze unity. while echadim highlighted the ind ividual part s o f the collect ion. The Hebrew use of singular and plural co llective nouns is similar to the co llecnve noun usage in many language s. A singular co llect ive noun and pred icate em phas ize the co llec tion as a who le, while a plural co llective no un and plu ra l pred icate emphasize (he compo nents o f the co llection. The n, of CO UThl:, the re is t he hybrid version when: a singular co llective no un is paired with a plural predica te, or a plura l co llective noun is paired with a singular predic ate. Zec hariah called his shepherd's staff " Union" (ec had) to indicate the brothe rhoo d be tween J ud ah and Isr ae l (Zec 11:07, 14). T he echod surely d id no t emphas ize any assembly of Zechariah's Slick s ince the Slic k was still in one piece until Zechar iah broke it in two (Zcc 11 : 14). Beca use echad and ectmdim can both ser ve as collective nouns. the echad that ends the SJU'ma co uld be a co llect ive no un. We ' ve a lread y see n that Yahreh can be a co llective nou n. and Elohirn, o f co urse, is a plural form . So grammatica lly speaking, the Sne ma is decidedly Trinitarian: He ar, 0 Israel: Yohveh [the Father] [and ) our Elohim [the Son], Yah l·eh [the Spirit] [are] a united one Iet.·had ] (Deu 06:04 ).
The Plural of Distribution In Languages Other Than Hebrew The Ararneans appare ntly used plura l co llective nouns as plurals o f distri bution just as the Hebrews d id. In Dan 05:25 the handwriting o n the wall included the Aramaic plural word parsin (d ivided ). When Daniel spoke of the writing on the wall, howe ver, he used the s ingular fo rm o f parsin (pines) (Dan 05: 2&). T his see ms to ind ica te that Da niel co ns ide red Belsha zzar's kin gdo m to be a whole com posed of parts. Two reaso ns for this might he : • The Babylonia n kingdom was already split adm inistrative ly. Belshazzar was the coregent who ruled from Babylon . while the corege nt Nabo nidus ruled from the north Arabian oasis c ity of Tcrna, and • T hat very night Be lshazzar 's kingdom was abou t to be div ided between the Medes and Persians (Dan 05:2&). yet the di vided kingdom was ruled by one top leader (Dan 05:30).
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
53
Repetition of Elohim as t he S ubject of a Singular Verb Indicates Elohim is
Persons Somet imes Elo},im is repeated as the subject o f a singular verb. Sometimes a fe w d iffe rent names for God , suc h as Yah l'eh , Hohisn. ha Elohim and Snoddai. a re given as the co llective subject o f a s ingular verb. Jacob provides conte nt fo r the study of see mingly redundant subjec ts. Jaco b used multiple name s for God as Ihe subject of the same singula r verb on at least five occa sions (Gcn 28:20- 22,3 1:42, 32:0 9, 41\ : 15-16 ; 49:24 -25 ). T he narrator of Gene sis wrote: He [Jacob] .. .said . '[A ll] the Go ds (lIlIElo h im ) .. .[A lI] th e Gods (haEloh im) .. .the Malek.. .bless [singular ve rb] the lads [two of Joseph's sons ]' (Gen 48: 15-16). Here Jacob used Iwo instances of " [All] the God s" (haElohim) and the M aId as subjec ts o f the same singular verb " to bless." T his shows that Jacob knew Ihe Malek 10 be o ne of "[All) the Gods" (haElohim) . Other wise, if Jaco b had net co ns ide red the Ma lek to he God , Jaco b wo uld have used a plural verb to say that both God and an ange l, " .. .they bless."?' That t he Maid Yah""h is one of J",Elohi m (" [All] the Gods") is verified by t he fac t that Jaco b els ewhere used a plu ral ver b with ha Elohim (" [AlIl lhe God s" ). Jaco b sa id. "Gods [Eloh im]. they had reve aled [plural verb] himself to him" at Bethel in Ge n 28 (Gcn 35:0 7). Note that Jacob spoke of God as " they" (Gen 35: 07 ) right after the Father spoke of the So n in the third person: Then God [the Father) said to Jacob. "Go up til Bethel a nd settle there , and build an altar the re to God [the So n]. who appeared to yo u when yo u were Ileem g from your brother Esau (Ge n 35:01). The Ma lek of I Ali i the Gods (ilaEloh im ) (Ge n 3 1: II ) said that he was God (E/) who appeared to Jaco b at Bethe l (Ge n 3 1: 13). So Gen 3 1: 11, 13 show that the Ma lek Yahwh was one of the Elohim who appeared at Bethel in Gen 28 (Gcn 35: 07 ). That the Ma jek me ntioned in Ge n 4 R: 16 is o ne o f [All] the God s (ha fillhim) can also be ascertained from Moses ' word s: ... and with the best gifts of the earth and its fullness, and the favor o f him [the Malek Yah!'ehJ who dwe lt in the b urning bush [Exo 03:02J . Let all these rest on the head of Joseph [Jose ph's sons' de scendant s), o n the brow of the prince among his brothers (Dcu 33: 16). In Deu 33: 16 Moses co nnected Jacob's blessing and the burning hush accounts where the Ma jek is mentioned eac h time: • Jacob 's bless ing as ked that God and the Malek bless Ephraim and Manasseh's descendants (Gen 4 K: 15-16 ), and • The Malek Yo/we }, was at the burning bush (E xo 0 3:02: Act 0 7:30 . 35). Note that the narrator of Exodu s places the Ma lek Ya hl'eh (Exo 0 3:02) right in the same b ush as God and Yahveh (Bxo 0 3:04) . mcaning that the M alek Yahveh was Yah veh the Son.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
54
Yael Na tan
The re is plenty o f proof that the Malek Y ahveh was one of 111.1E/ohim ("[All] the Gods" ) me ntioned in the account of the burning bush (EI\o 03:0 1. 06, 11 . 12, 13 ). The Mu /eli. Yahveh (Exo 0 3:0 2) said: " am the Hohin! of yo ur father-s-the Etahim of Abraham. the t'/ohim o f Isaac and the Elohim of Jaco b: At this, Mose s hid his face. because he was a fraid to look at '[ All] the God s' (ha Ell/him) ( Exo 03 :(6). That the Maid rahveh was o ne o f IwElohim (" [AliI the God s" ) ca n also be infe rred from ho w. in connection with the burning bush acco unt. the Malek Yahveh is ca lled: • Yahveh (Exo 03 :0 4. 07, 15, 16, 18 (twicej). and • God (E xo 0 3:0 4. 0 5. 06 (five times) , II , 12 (twice ), 13 (twice ), 14, 15 (fi ve times), 16 (twice) , J g (twlccu. Ano ther passa ge similar to Gen 48: 15 - 16 is Gen 3 1:4 2 whe re Ja co b used a s ing ular verb with the collective subjec ts: God , God , and the r ea r o f Isaac. The parallel struc ture betwee n Ge n 48:15-16 (11t1 Eloh im . halitohim, Malek ) and Gen 3 1:42 (£/ohim , E/oh im. Fear) sugges ts that "tbc Fear" is the Malek . That Jacob co nside red the Ma /ek to be God (Ge n 31:42) and o ne of "[ All] the Gods" (h(lt '/ollim) (Ge n 48: 15- 16) is consistent with how e lsew here: • The Malek Yahl'eh re fe rred to h imself as £ Iohilll (Ge n 3 1: II , 13; Exo 0 3:02, 061. and • The Maid Yohveh was called E!o /rim o ften (Cen 16; 21 - 22; 3 1-32; Exo 0 3; 14; 23; Num 22 - 24; Jdg 0 2; Jdg 06; 13; I Ki 19; 2Ki 19; and Zec 02 - 0 3). The Plural of Dcleganon-,,a Plural Couccuvc Noun Variant T he proofs usu all y o ffe red for the maje stic plural co nstructio n arc OT text s where a creature is ca lled clohim (gods ) and adonai (m asters ). Maje stic plural proponents cre me a false dilemma by say ing that the speaker must have used the plura l to indicate the person is majestic. They say. "Surely the plural form cannot me an a s ingle person is plur al pe rso ns!" Passage s referring to a single pe rson using a plural are offe red as proof that pl urals referring to Yahw,h are mere maj esti c plurals. The case for majest ic plurals unravel s. howe ver. whe n other grarnmaric al poss ibilities arc e xplored. The plural in que stion may ha ve bee n intended as a quant itati ve plural, a plural co llec tive nou n. a plura l o f de legation. a plural of d istrib ution. or anot her type of plural. The plural of de legatio n by itself ex plai ns mo st o f the ex amples offe red as majest ic pl ural proofs. For instance. a se rvant wo uld normally refer to his master using the s ing ula r «donee, mea ning, " my mas ter." Some times. ho we ve r. the se rvant would refer to his master using the pl ural m lOl rai. meaning. " my masters." The se rvant used the plural form to ac kno wledge that a master had de legated manage na l re spn nsibifities to : • Another master. • A slave driver. or eve n to • The servant himself. Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
55
So plurals were somet imes mea nt to ackno wledge the multi tie r co mmand structure.
Discussion of Majestic Plural Proof Texts The study of majestic plural proo f texts shows that supposed majestic plurals are really plurals of deleg ation. o r another construction that expresses plura lity. M osrers
( I.\"
Adonai"-'
T he Genesis narrator said that Abraham was masters (adO/Ill;) to his servant Ehe zer (Gen 24:09- 10). Laban a lso said that Abraham was masters (odmlll;) to Eliezer (Ge n 24:5 1). Plurals of delegation arc applied to Abraham because he had delegated authority to his servant Eliezer (Gen 24:02). Abraham also had delegated a uthor ity to Isaac , whom Eliczer considered his mas ter (adonee) (Gen 24:65). Eliezer referred to Isaac using the sing ular (/(/0111'1' ("my master" ) rather than using a plural of delegatinn ((/(Iono;). Th is was likely because Isaac had not yet delegated authority to any person who m Eliezer recogn ized as an eq ual or superior. Pouphar is ca lled (ldO/ra; (masters ) (Gen 3l,l:02 , 03, 07, 08,1 6. 19.20) because Potiphar had deleg ated much authority to Joseph (Gen 39:04-06, 08-09, I I). Joseph 's warden is called adO/III; (masters) (Gen 39:20; 40 :07 ) because he had delegated authority to Joseph (Gcn 39:21-23). Joseph was called Egypt's adO/III; (masters) (Gen 42:30. 33). and Jose ph was adonai {masters) tn his servan ts (Gen 44:08). Josep h was called adona; because Pharao h had delega ted authority to Joseph (Ge n 4 1:40 . 44, 55; 44:08. 18; 45 :08). Those who were not Joseph's servants seemed to not have used plurals of delcganon referring to Jose ph. For instance , Jacob and Joseph 's brothers referred to Joseph as "dOlI (maste r) (Gen 45:08-09) and as "donee (my master) (Gen 44;16, 18 (twice), 19) . Ano ther example is the Egyptian populace calling Jose ph adonee (my master) (Gen 47: 18 (twice), 25). Joseph was ca lled adonce for the same reaso n that Eliezer referred to Isaac as adonee (Gen 24 :65). Isaac was adonee to Eliezer since Isaac had not delegated a uthority to anyone that Ehe zer recognized as an equa l or superior. Jose ph was odonce because Joseph had not delegated a uthor ity to any subordinate that Jacob, Joseph 's brothers, o r the Egyptian populace recognized as their superior. Thur tbc Egyp tians populace dealt direct ly with Joseph rathe r than his delegate can be inferred from: • The detail of Joseph 's cnmmiss ioning (Gen 4 1:40-45). • From the Egyptians' stateme nt: You have saved o ur lives. May we find favor in the eyes of my lord (adonee) [Joseph]. Our land and we will be in bondage 10 Pharaoh (Ge n 47:1 9.25). In Mosaic Law , a master was simply an adonee ( mas ter) (Exo 2 1:05 ). If, howe ve r, a servant had decl ined his chance to be a freeman in order to serve a master for life. then the master ((Ido/leel became masters ((Idolla;) (b.n 2 1:(6). Matenal com direlbs autcrars
56
Yael Na tan
Th e sw itch fm m adona to aclOlwi occurred becau se the master del egated authority. The servant may have become a manager or supe rvisor. or eve n an inheritor (Gcn 15 :0 2) and adopted son-in- law (Ge n 29 : 1&: 3 1:3 1; Exo 2 1:04-05). An altern ativ e ex planatio n of the use of the plural (adonai) take s into account the ce re mony that made the servant into a servant fo r life . T he ceremon y invo lved pie rc ing the servant 's ear with an a wl before the elders [Exo 2 1:(6). So the adonai (m asters) may ind icate that the se rvant was now beho lden 10 the elders and his mas ter who together were called "masters" «(/(1011(/;). Da vid was called adonai ( I Ki 01 : 11 , 4 3) bCl:i.\USC he had delegated kingship to Solom on on o ath. The agreed upon delegation of kin gship we nt into effec t w hen David ruled with Solomon . Thi s co- rege ncy began at the lime Adonija h failed to usurp the thro ne and la sted until the timc of Da vid 's dea th (l Ki 01 : 13, 30; 0 2:0 1; ICh 22 : 17 ). Job sa id : C aptive s a lso enjoy their ease [in Sheol where the souls of the damned await Judgment Day ); they no lon ger hea r the slave dri ver 's sho ut. The small and the great are the re . a nd th e slave is fr eed from h is ma sters [adona ; I" (Joh 03 : 18-19 ). He re " masters" is plural because the se rvant's master had de legated autho rity to a s lave dr iver. So the slave had two masters (ado na;): the master and the sla ve driver. I sa ia h prop he si ed tha t an A ssyrian ki ng wo u ld rul e E gyp t ( Isa 20 :04 ). Else where, th is kin g is called " a crue l [sing ular ] adonim [masters ] and a fie rce [si ngu lar] kin g [singu lar]" (Isa 19 :0 4). The " k ing " was Esarhaddo n w ho co nquered Egypt in 670 Be. "Masters" (m/onim ) is a plura l of delegation thai refers to the king and his commande rs. Thi s is con sistent w ith how an Assy rian king once boas ted , "Are not my commanders all kings?" (1 Ki 20 :24 : lsa 10:08). Isa iah called a donke y' s ow ner " maste rs" ( Isa 0 1:03). O ne might wonder, " Why wo uld a donke y's o wner necessarily be majestic ?" M aje stic plural propo nents provide no overriding reason Wh y the plural form "masters" must be translated as a sing ular, especially con siderin g how : • The w it thai Ye.l h ,w rode into Jerusalem had "owne rs" (Lu k 19: 33), and • Eliczcr had two maste rs , Ab raha m ( ado na i) (Ge n 15 :0 2) and Isaac (adoll e!') (O en 24 : 12, 65). The Trinitarian interpretatio n of Isa 0 I:0 3 is revealed whe n one co ns ide rs how: • Elsewhere Yahveh sa id the y (meaning the Trin ity) are " maste rs" (Al/ollim ) (Ma l 01 :06), and that • Isa 0 I:0 3 is a parallel construction . The para llel co nstructio n sho ws tha i there are two ellipse s in the trai n of thou ght. Isa 0 I:03 should be unde rstood as: The 0 )1, know s its owner [qantlh (masculine sing ular»), t he donkey its ma sters' manger, but Israel does not kno w . .. [. .. its owner, in other words, God [Exo 06:07 ; 19 :05-06)), my people do not perce ive . .. [. .. its ma sters, in other words, the Trinity {Mal U1:06) ] (Isa 0 I:03). Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
57
MOSt'S lind Aaron as £ Iohim Yah veh sa id to Moses, "Behold . I have made yo u god ~ [d ohim] to pharaoh .. ... (Exo 0 7:0I a ). T he plural form etohim is a plural of de legation that denotes how Mose s del egated authority to Aaro n. Pharaoh obviouxly knew that Aaron was speaking on behalf of Moses. A plural o f delegatio n is a collec tive noun variant, so o ne cou ld say thai pharaoh knew Moses and Aaron co llectivel y as "gods." The delegat ion of authority from Moses to Aaron can be seen when the whole verse is considered: Behold, I have made yo u gods [elohim] to pharao h, and you r brother Aaron will be your [Mose s'] prophet (Exo 0 7:0Ib). God had delegated au thority to Moses ( Exo 0 3: 10; 04:12), and then from Moses to Aaro n saying: He [Aaron] will speak to the people for you [Moses]. and it will be as ifh e [Aaron I were yo ur [Mose s"] mo uth, and 11S if )' OU [Moses ] were like [/amed h preposition] God to him [Aaron] (E xc 04: 16).
Ang els and Judg es as Etohim As was ju st disc ussed, Moses and Aa ro n we re ca lled "god s" (dohim) . Angels a lso we re called "gods" (e1ohiln) (Psa 097:07). J udges were also called: • "gods" (dohim ) (Psa 082:01 ,06), and • " [a ll] the gods" (haefoh im) (Exo 2 1:0 6; 22:08-0 9 (BHS 22:07 -08) ; Jos 24:0 1). Hum ans and angels were o nly ca lled etotnm co llec tive ly. The re is no oc c urre nce in the 0 '1' of a mere angel nr human working alone heing ca lled "god" ( eI ) or "gods" (e/oh im) . Thus, elohim sho uld be conside red a plural co llective noun when referring to mere angels or human s. God had delegated autho rity fro m himself to angels and human s to rule and to judge. This delegation explains the plural since the plural recogn izes that two or mo re perso ns are, by definition. involved in any delegatio n of authority. God's de legation of author ity also e xplains why the judges or ange ls were ca lled "gods" (elohim ). They were God's dele gates who represented God . The uotacn Calfas Eloh im Some say that thc golde n calf tha t Aaron made (Exo 32:20. 24 : De u 09 :21) was called "gods" (d ohim ). so this elohim must be a majestic plural. One might wonde r. " Why would a c111f image be so majcsuc?" Why the plural form etohim was used in co nnection with a lone calf is d iscussed under Exo 32 in the Trinitarian proofs appendi x.
Sam uel a,\ D o /rim Saul asked a spiritist what she saw: The wo man a nswered Saul, ' I see elohim [gods ] coming up [plural pa rticiple] ou t of the earth' (I Sa 28:13). Maje st ic plura l propone nts arg ue that bec ause the ne croma ncer refe rred to Sam uel as clohim (gods). etohim must de note maje sty rather than plura lity. Matenal com direlbs autcrars
58
Yael Na ta n
Majestic plural pro pc nenrs. however, have nor accou nted for all the partici pants at the sp iri tist 's dwe lling. whether real o r im pe rso na ted . T he plu ra l participle "corning up" me an s thai the spi ritis t saw IWO sp ir its who m she ca lled etohim (gods). The Septuagint translators reta ined the plural partici ple : ." see gods. the y arc co ming up. .." (LXX 153 28: I J). T he plural partsciple in ISa 28:13. mention ed above , is perhaps why the KJV and RSV ( hose to use the p hrase "by the famil ia r spir it" in ISa 2IH17-08. T he Hebr ew word translated "familiar sp irit" is owh. " Having a famili ar spmt" is a dctinition g iven for (lll'b in the Thayer/BDB le xicon and the nVOT,"" Owb is mentioned five times in the spir itist of Endor account ( ISa 28:03, 07 (twice), OR, 09 ).'" When Sa ul heard the spiritist say that she saw etohim. Sa ul asked what "he :' meaning Samuel. looked like, After all, Saul had requested that tbc spiritisl bring up Samuel ([Sa 2R:II ). Th e spiritisl used singulars 10 sa)' thai an old man rose fro m the ea rth ( ISa 28:14 ), II wo uld see m the plural s in ISa 2R: 13 referred to both Samue l and Ihe fam iliar spirit. while the singu lars in ISa 28: 14 refer to Samuel on ly, So the spiritist cal led Samuel a nd the fa miliar sp irit "god s" ( ISa 28 :13 ), but d id 1101 refer to Sam uel a lone as "gods." So Ihe "god s" (elollim ) ( ISa 28 : 13) is a plu ral co llective noun referri ng 10 Samuel and the fam iliar spiril. Th is is sim ilar to how the angels and judges were only calle d elohim (god s) couecuvety. but no t individ ually, T his fact wa s mentioned above in this sec tion. Two DemOlIS ax Etatnm W he the r the d emons were rea l or impersonated by the s pirinst is inconsequent ial to our study of gra mmar. Whether real or not , the spiritis t would have used the sa me gram mar e ither way so as ne t to give herself a way, II is wel l known that spiritists impersonate de mo ns, for instance. Sam uel Zwemer w rote: The ex pectant moth er, in fear of the qurina [an "e viltwin" spirit] visits the sheikha (le arned woma n) three mo nths before the birth o f the child. and does whateve r she indicates as a re medy. These sheikhas exercise g reat mnuen ce over the wo men. and batte n on their superstinous beliefs, o flen impe rso nat ing the qarina and frightening the igno rant.... The case can be made that Sam uel's s pirit was ne t presen t at the spiritist of Endo r"s dwe lling. This wo uld mea n that two demons were cu lled etohim, o r at least IWO impersonated dem ons. The demo ns were called elohim bec ause demons liked to pose as pagan gods (clohim). T his is what Mo ses sa id on the subject: T hey sacrificed 10 dem on s, w hic h are not God - god s (efohim) the y had nOI known. gods (e/ohim ) that recentl y appeared, gods (e/ohim ) your fathe rs did not fear (Deu 32: 17; sec also Psa 106: 37). Saul sa id, " Please d ivine by the fam iliar spirit" (I Sa 2R:OR ). so o ne sp irit was a demo n for sure. The other entity likely was a second demon posin g as Samuel. Everythin g the dem on told Saul see med to ha ve been pari of a ca lcu lated plan to
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
59
extingu ish Sau l's hope and destroy Saul spiritually and physic ally. This would lead one to conclude that a demon had indeed posed as Samuel, The demon perhaps had 11 plan of attac k since there was forewarnin g of Sa ul's visit 10 the spiritist of Ende r (ISa 28:(7). Saul's occ ult experience began with the cla irvoyant saying that Sam uel came up out of the ground rather than from heaven (I Sa 28: 13. 15). T his was calculated to destroy any hope thai Saul may have had abou t the afterlife. Now the best that Saul could ho pe for wou ld be to d well in nether regions with Samuel. T hat Samuel's spirit came out of the gro und sugges ts a demon was pnsing as Samuel. Sa muel's body but not spirit wou ld be residing underground awaiting j udg me nt (D eu 32:22: Jo b 03:1 8-1 1); Psa 0(1):1 7 ; 016 :10 ; 055:1 5; 086:13). Sam uel's spirit would instea d be residing in heave n with Enoch, and later with Elijah (2Ki 0 2: II ; Luk 08:55; 16:26; 20:37-38; 24:05; Rev 07 :09). If the real Sam uel had talked to Sau l the day before Sau l was abou t to die, Sam uel would have given Saul an uplifting law and gospel sermon. Samue l wou ld have presen ted the way of salvation throug h faith in the promised Messiah (Gen 03: 15; 49: 10-11; Num 24:17). The demon posing a.s Samuel. however, o nly spoke of law and wrath. In this way, the demon presen ted a mere caricature of Sa muel and, indirectly, of Yahl'eh. Sam uel's impostor gruffly asked Saul, "Why have you disturbed me by bringing me up'!" (I Sa 28: 15). T he true Sa muel, who grieved for Saul until Sa muel 's dying day (lSa 15:35), wo uld not have been so gruff. The o nly reason Samuel did not minister to Saul mo re when Samuel was alive was Samuel feared for his life. as did David ( ISa 0 2:34 ; 16:02; 19:15; Psa 059:0 I). Sa muel's satanic impostor s a id that rah veh had tu rned away from Sa ul beca use Sau l had no t destroyed t he Amalck ites (lSa 28: 16-18). Sa ul, ho we ve r, was the prodi ga l son who had turned away from Yohv rh, Yahveh had no t t urned away from Sa ul (I S a 15: 11). That Yahveh had not harde ne d S a ul in his s in is evident from how, afte r Sau l admi tte d tha t he had s inned , S amuel we nt to wo rsh ip Yahl'cn with Sau l li Sa 15:31). Sa muel's demonic imposto r said that Yahveh had become Saul's e nemy ( ISa 28 :16). It is true that the spec ial measure of t he Spirit had left Saul and rested on David (I Sa 16:1 3-1 4). It is also true that Yo/weh allo wed a "spirit of sadness " ( YLn or an "evil spirit" (N/ V, LXE, KJV) to torment Sau l (lSa 16:1 4.23; 18:10; 19:0IJ). Ho we ve r, the last spirit ment ioned as possessing Sau l was the "S pirit of God" ( ISa 19:23-24). Inte restingly. Saul prophes ied ( ISa 10:11- 13: 18;10; 19:2 1, 23-24; 28;15) eve n whi le being tormented (I Sa 18: 10). So if the "evil spirit" was more than just a bad mood, it may have been a "lying spirit" utteri ng false prophes ies (I Ki 22:22-23; 2Ch 18:2 1-22). If the spirit that afflic ted Sa ul was a de mon. the n Da vid 's songs and har p play ing were a form of exorc ism (1Sa 16:23; 18:10; 19:(9 ). David was a prophet (Act 0 2;30 ) who spoke by the S pirit ( ISa 16:13; Act 04:25). David sang inspired
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
60
Yael Natan
psa lms that had the power 10 dri ve out e vil spirits. The de mon. ho wever, wo uld return after each e xorcism becau se Sa ul did not repent (L uk II :24-26). Tha i Samu el grieved for Saul until Samuel 's dyin g da y suggests that Ytlhl't'h did not e nd Sau l's time of grace before Saul d ied (I Sa 15:35; He b 09: 27). The only reason Samuel did not preach to Saul was Sam uel feared for his life (ISa 16: 02 ). So ev ide ntly the evi l spirit was sent not 10 harden Sa ul's heart ( Ro m 09: 18 ). Rat her. itseernx, the spirit was se nt to de stroy Saul's sinful nature so his so ul might be saved (lCo05:04-05). It seems unl ikely that the name Saul wo uld have remained a popular name among the Jews if God had hardened Saul's heart ( ISa 06:06; Act 07:58). A demo n. howe ver. wanted Saul 10 think that Ya lll'eh was his pennanent e nemy. Then the prodigal SOil would never think of returning home (Luk 15:24. 32; ColO I:2 1-22 ). G ive n Israel 's military sit uat ion a nd Saul 's lo ss of heart (lSa 2R:04-0 5) , the prophecy that Samu e l's impostor gave was a pro phecy any prescient demon cou ld proffer ( ISa 28; 19). Th e demo n knew that self-fulfilli ng proph ecies have the best chance of s uccess, so the dem on grap hically pred ica ted tha t Saul and his so ns wo uld be in hell the next day. Th e fear the prophecy instilled in Sau l (I Sa 28; 1520) became a co ntributing facto r in Saul's battlefield defeat ( ISa 3 1:02-(6). The prophecy the demon gave abo ut Sa ul and his sons being with Sa muel the next day probab ly co ntributed to Saul's c hoice to commit suic ide ( IS a 3 1:04-(5). T he sense o f fata lism the prop hec y introd uced mean t that Sau l d id not e xplo re any op tio ns 10 avoid death. Op tions could have included tactic al retreat, mustering additi onal force s agains t the Philistines ( ISa 11:0 7), pa ying tribute, or abdicating in favor of Jonathan or Dav id. The fal se prophecy thai Saul and his sons wou ld be with Samuel undergro und (ISa 28:19) likely helped Sa ul resign to his fate a nd co mmit suicide (Job 03: 1719 ). After a ll, co uld Saul hope for anything better in the after life than to be where Samuel was? A good law and gos pel sermon. however, wo uld ha ve produced d iffere nt results in Saul. The rea l Samuel would ha ve told Saul o f God's grace and the gift of paradise {Lu k 23:43), while at the same time warning of hell fo r rejec ting God's graci ous offers. The fatal error that caused Saul's de mise was his attendance at a "synagog ue o f Satan" (Rev 02:09; 0 3:tl9). Saul heard a se rrnone ne from a demon (2Co I I; 14). Sau l was beat up spirit ually an d emotionally by the demon posing as Sam uel. Saul's ex perience is so mewhat analogous 10 how a dem o n beat up the seve n sons ofSce va (Ac I 17: 14-16). Per haps God allowed this demon to further destroy Saul's sinful natu re so his so ul migh t be saved (ICh 10:13- 14; ICo 05:04-05). Scr ipture, however, does not hold out much hope thai Sau l e ver repented and went to heave n ( IC h 10: 13- 14). So the case has here been made that two de mons were ca lled etoh im, and that the real Sa mue l wa s never culled etahim. So demons are called elohim co llective ly, just as earlier we learned thm humans and ange ls were o nly called elohim collec tively and not indi vid ua lly. Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
61
A Grave as "Grare I " T he prophe tess Huldah referred to King Josia h's "graves " (2 Ki 22:20 : 2Ch 34:28) . Luter, howe ver, Josia h was buried in a si ngula r "grave" (2 Ki 23 :30). Majestic plura l proponents be lieve the plura l indicates a royal grave as o pposed to a com mon grave. If there were an occasion to refer In a grave using a majestic plural , it wou ld have been when Abraham. the " prince of God ," was offered any of the Hittit es' "choicest graves" (Gen 23:06). Notice that "grave" is in the singular as would be expected. T he Hittites said: You are a mighty prince a mong us. Bury yo ur dead in the choicest [singular I of our graves. None of us will refuse you his grave [sing ular] for burying your dead (Gen 23:06). Here is a n a lte rna tive inte rpretatio n of Jo siah 's plu ral "g ra ves." Huldah began the prophecy by saying Josiah wo uld be gathered to his "fathers." So the plural " graves" may refer to a grave complex such as a mausoleum, family plot, or catacomb where his "fathers" are buried . So the mention of "graves" may be si milar to ho w English speakers ofte n use the plura l "cataco mbs" evert when referring to a single catacomb. Anoth er inte rpretation of the plural "graves" is that the prop hetess Huldah kne w Josiah would first be laid in one tomb, and then in a nother. Joseph, for e xample. was placed in o ne tomb and then anothe r (Gcn 50:24-25; Exo 13:19: Jos 24:32) . The re was another way that bodies came to be laid in two to mbs. Betwee n 20 Be and 70 AD'" a Je wish practice involved hurying a person in a ca ve or a tomh. Then after the soft tissues had turn ed to d ust, the bones were collected and put in an ossuary in a family tomb. The person whose body was so handled could be said to have "graves." The most likel y interpre tatio n of "graves," howe ver, can be found in Ezekiel. In Eze kiel 's "Dirge fo r Egypt" (Ezc 32: 17-32), Ezekiel intersperses the singular word "grave" ( ql' ber ) (Eze 32:23, 24) with the plural "graves" (Eze 32:22, 23. 25, 26). In the same c hapter, Ezekie l mentions the singular "S heol" (Etc 32:2 1, 271. T he NIV most ofte n translates "Sheol" as "grave." Once, ho we ver. the N IV translates Sheol as "realm of death" (Deu 32 :22). Twice the NfV tran slates Sbeo! as "death" in the phrase "gates of death" (Job 17:16: Isa 38:10). So it seems that the plural "graves" refers to first the physical grave, and then secondly to the metaphysic al place ca lled Shcol. Based o n the informatio n from Ezekiel. one can say the prophecy about Josiah going to his "graves" in peace (2Ki 22:20 ; 2Ch 34:28) dea ls with more than JU SI temporal death. The prophecy must also mean that Josiah would find peace with God in the afterlife. Huldah's prophecy mean t Jo siah cou ld look fo rward to a bodily resurre ction ju st as Job had (Job 19:27). Huklah's prophecy assured Josiah of heaven ju st as the thief on the cross was assured of heaven (Luk 23:43). Josiah was buried in his own singular grave (2Ki 23:30 ). Perhaps Josiah 's body was left undisturbed until the body turned to tally to dust. Surely. Josiah's grave was not desecrated along with the graves of the o ther kings who had worshipped Matenal com direlbs autcrars
62
Yael Na ta n
false gods (Jer 08 :01-02). Perhaps Josiah's grave lasted as long as David's grave (Act U2:29). Sennacherib
CI.\
"King,\ "
Hezckiah's men sa id. "Why shou ld the kings of Assyria come and find plenty of water?" (2Ch 32:04 ). Majestic plural proponems say that "kings" is a majestic plural that refers to Sennacherib. since other OCl:UITl:nCl:S of "king" are singular in the same chapter (2C h 32:0 I. 07) . Majestic plural proponents say that early translato rs must have thought "kings" was a majestic plural, since the LXX, Syriac, and Arab ic translatio ns of 2Co 32:04 have "king" rather than "kings:' One explana tion of the plural "k ings" is tha t the Assyrians boasted about thei r armies being so large that each co mmander was like a king (lsa 10:08). Interestingly. in the NT the Corinthians were eo proud that Paul said they thou ght of the mselves as hl:ing kings (I Co 04 :08 ). Th e early Musli ms had sim ilar thoug hts: We were kings of men befo re Muhammad. And when Islam came we had the superiority." So the "kings" in 2Ch 32:04 may he a plural collective noun referr ing to the Assyrian king and his commanders . The tircydopal'(lia Rrltannica provides information that supports the idea that there were in fact mo re than one Assyrian king: Some rulers speak of their own dynastic deity. A king who owes his position to the Assyria n emperor refers to the latte r and the dynast ic deity equally as 'my master:.... If the Assyrian king is co nsidered an "e mperor:' then his regional admin istrators could be considered "kings." After all. by definitio n lin emperor is 11 king of kings. The com manders of the Assy rian armies may have a lready been regio nal kings, or soon wo uld be, After each successful campa ign. the new ly conquered land likel y was div ided into fiefdoms for commanders to rule. T he si ngu lar instances of "king " may refer to the Assyrian emperor. or the singular "king" may be a co llective noun referring to the king and his king-like com manders. Translat ions such as the LXX, Sy riac and Arabic translate "kings" in the singu lar. T he trans lators likel y thoug ht it more sensible that collective nou ns be s ingular in fonn rathe r than plural. T here is another explanation of the plural "kings" in 2C h 32:04. Stopping up all the wells througho ut Israel was a large public works project. This may have requ ired more j ustification than the threat of invasion by one Assyrian king. Sto pping up wells was a draconian policy that incon ve nie nced the population by interferin g with the water supply. Stopping up all the wells may have been implemented only whe n there was a threat of repeated invasion by two o r mo re kings-hence the plura l "k ings: ' At an earlier time the Phil istines had implemented a policy of stopping up wells (Gen 26: 15. 18). Archaeo logy shows that Palestine was rife with invas ions durin g patriarchal times, and that all of Palestine was an armed ca mp. Genesis mentions Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewish Trinity
63
how even Abra ham had 3 18 ser vants who cou ld bear arms (Ge n 14:14 ), and Esau had 400 serv an t so ld iers (Gen 32:( 6). Genesis eve n no tes how Abraham's cla n (Gen 14:0 2 ) and Jacob's clan (Gen 34: 26; 48:22) we re involved in armed confl icts. So Hevek iah 's me n we re sa ying that stopping up t he wells wa s impo rtan t because of the lo ng-term threa t o f invasion by Assyrian kings. Indeed, Hczckiah's me n were presci ent. In the fo urt h year of He zekia h's reig n. Shalmaneser came th reat eningly dose to Ju dea (2K i 18:09 ). In the fou rtee nth yea r of Hczckiah's reign, Scnnac hcnb threatened to invade (2K i 18:13). That plural kings were involved can he see n fro m Hezekiah's prayer : o Yanveh ; the kings of Assyria have laid waste [plural ve rb] the nations and the ir lands (2 Ki 19:17). A Possessor a.\ ..P O.I'.I"I'.\.\"or.\ " For the protec tio n of wisd om is like the protection of mon e y: the advantage of knowledge is that wisdom preser ves the life of its possessors (Ecc 07: 12). Majestic plural proponen ts so metimes offer Ecc 07: 12 as proof of the maje stic plural , s ince the wo rd " possessor s" is plura l. Since more than one person ca n possess wisdom , the plu ral "posse ssors" shou ld be understood as a plural collect ive noun.
TheMalek Ya hveh as Elohim Maje stic pl ural proponents say that the Malek Yahvcb be ing called Elolrim is proof of the majestic plural, for the Ma lek Yahveh is one person but Etohim is a pl ural noun: • The Malek Yahl'eh referred to himself as Elohim (Oc n 3 1: II , 13; Exo 0 3:02, 06), and • The Malek Yahl'eh was called Etoh im often (Ge n 16: 2 1- 22; 3 1-32; Exo 0 3; 14; 23; Num 22 - 24; Jdg 0 2; 06 ; 13; IKi 19; 2Ki 19: and Zec 0 2-03). Elohim is used as a plural co llective nou n when refe rring to the Tr inity, but as a plura l of de lega tio n when referr ing to indi vidua l membe rs of the Trinity. The pl ural o f del egat ion, Elohim, is used to note that the Malek Yt,h l't'h's is a member of the Trinity. Since ma lek mean s " messenger" in Hebrew, the Malek Yahveh definitel y is both a mem ber of the Trin ity. and a delegate of the Trinity, Th e conte xt and ot her cl ue s help the reader to de ter mine whet her Elohini is being used as a plural collective no un, or as a plural of del egat ion. Som etimes. the plain se nse of the vers e te lls the rea der that first one and then another perso n is culled Elo him. For instance , in Psa 045:06-0 7 and Psa 082:01, 08, Elo him is used as a plural o f dele gatio n twice. Each time D olrim refers to a di ffere nt ind ividua l of tbe Trinity, the Father and then the Son . The se ve rses arc d isc ussed in the Trinitarian proo fs append ix.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Yae l Na tan
64 How the
~T
Writers Understood MT Hebrew Plurals
The re are many quotatio ns of the or in the NT. Many of these q uotations incl uded the plural form t 'loilim in origi nal Hebrew. The NT application of these quotatio ns shows that NT writers : • Knew whom the OT passage a pplied to, and • Distinguished whet her the plura l wax a pl ural co llect ive noun or a plura l o f delega tion. For instance: • The writer of He brews knows that the Father called the Son Elohim in Psa 045: 0 6-07 (Heb 0 1:08 ),
• Joh n knows that the Father calle d hu man judges etohim in Psa 082:01 (Joh 10: 34-35), and
• Jo hn kno ws that the Fathe r called the Son, who wo uld be the Messiah, Elohim in Psa 082:0 8 (Joh 10:36). Psa 045 and 082 are di scussed in the Trinitarian proofs ap pend ix. Many NT quotatio ns of the OT are discu ssed further in the cha pter and ap pe ndix on the NT use of OT Yah veh te xts . The NT was writte n in 11 way co nsiste nt with the gra mmar and meaning of the OT. For insta nce, take the Heb rew form f:lohim, meanin g, "God." f:/ohim was ap plied to the Trin ity as a co llective noun , and F./ohim was applied to indi vidu a l perso ns of the Trinity as a plural of de legat ion. Gree k words fo r God like theos were also applied to indi vidua l persons o f the Trinity, and some times to the Trin ity co llectively. The NT writers kne w tha t the OT somet imes ap plied t '/ohim to the Trinity, and so met imes to the indiv idual mem bers of the Tr inity. Thi s is e viden ced not o nly in quo tations of the OT, hut also in doctrine. For insta nce , the NT writers kne w they could ascr ibe NT ac tivity to the Trin ity (Go d), or they co uld d istrib ute the cre d it to one or two membe rs. For exa mple, the Trinity (God ) was cred ited with a ll the fo llow ing act ivities, b ut indi vidu al membe rs of the Trin ity were also given separate cred it: • The Fathe r (Ac t 02:32; 13:30: Rom 06:04 ; G al 0 1:0 1; Eph 0 1:19-20), the Son (Joh 0 2:19-22; 10:1 7- 18), and the Spirit (Rom 0 1:04; 08:09- 11) raised Yes/ilia from the dead, • The Father (Jo h 05 :2 1), the Son (Joh 06 :39-40. 44 . 54) . and the Spirit (Rom 08 : 09- 11) will raise the dead, • The Father (Joh 15:16: 16;23), the Son (Jo h 14:13-14 ). and the Sp irit (Rom 08: 26) answe r prayer, • The Fat her (Gen 02:07 ; Psa 102:25; He h 01: 0 2), the So n (Joh 0 1:03; Co l 0 1: 16: Heb 0 1:02), and the Sp irit (Ge n 0 1:02; Job 33:0 4; Psa 104 :30) c reated the world , and • The Fath er ("Most High" ) and the Spirit (Luk 01: 35), and the So n (Heb 02: 14) we re involved in the incarn ation.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
65
The NT writers not only saw the Trinity in the OT. but also occasionally expressed the Trinity using the same gra mmar. For instance. there are so lecisms in the Gree k that could be thought of as He braisms in ITh 03: I I and Rev 2 1:22-23; 22 :0 1,lB-()4. These verses are discussed in the Trinitarian proofs appendix. Concluding Remark As was stated in the introducto ry remarks to this c hapter. o ne can see that the OT is thorou ghly Trinitarian when o ne has a co rrect understanding of OT Hebre w gra mmar.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Matenal com direlbs autorars
Chapter 2 Proto-Sinaitic Trinitarianism Who the Ma lek Yahveh Was
T he title MlIlek Yahve h literally me ans " Me ssenge r o f Ya h l'eh ," bUI is oflen translated as " Angel of the Lord. " Unlike o ther me ssen ge rs (maleks), the Malek Yohl'eh was the prcincarnatc Son of God. Proofs o f the Malek Yah veh' s div inity are ma n)', a nd are di scu ssed in the Tr initar ian proofs app endix. Corrobora ting passages incl ude those w here the Malek Yllhw'h: • Spo ke as o nly 1'(,1/1'<'" ca n spea k (for instance , Ge l! 16:11; 2 1:17; 22;15- 1K, Num 22 :35; Jdg U2:0 1, 06:14. 16 ), • Called h imself God (EI) (Gen 31: II , 13; Exo 0 3:06) , • Was ca lled God (Elohim ) o r Yah re h in mo st Malek. Yah veh accounts (Gcn 16; 2 1-22; 3 1-32; Exo03; 14; 23; Num 22 -24; Jdg 02; 06; 13; lKi 19; 2Ki 19; andac02 - 03), • Was located in the sa me bush as God (Elollim) and Yahveh (Exo 0 3:02, 04), and • Instructe d Moses 10 say that Yohvch had appe ared and met him (E xo 0 3:16. 18). Note that in the Burning Bush account, Mose s was "afraid 10 look at God [Elohim ]" (Exo 0 3:06). The Malek Yanveh directly quoted the Father once (Gcn 22: 15- 18). Mo sl ofte n, the Ma lek Ya lH'l,h spoke o f the Father in the third person as "Goo" (Gen 2 1:17 ) or as Ya lll'(,h (Gen 22:16 ). T he Malek Ya hveh o ften spo ke in his c apac ity as God, and eve n culled h imself God. for instance. Jaco b said : The Angel (Maid) o f [All ] the Gods f /uiElo him ] sa id to me [Jacob] in the dream, ' ...f um the God (E/) of Bet hel' (Gen 3 1: I I, 13). The Malek Yaln-e h acco unts mention the Trin ity. haElohim , literally, "[ All] the Gods" (Gcn 22 :03 , 09; Num 22: 10; 23:27 ). T he accounts also refer to the Son as the Ma lek of herlohim ([All] the Gods)" (Gen 3 ];] 1: Exo 14 :19 ; Jdg 06: 20; 13: 0 6, 09 ). As was noted abov e. d ur ing many of the MCllek Yohvch appearances . the Malek Yllh ~'e h was culled Y(/h ~'e h and God. This indic ates that the Malek Ya hrch was both God and YCI/II'd ,. and a member of the Trinu y, the IraF.lohim ([ Ali i the Gods). A para llel exists between the Malek Yahveh and the Messi ah, Yeshua. The OT prese nts the Ma lek Yah reh both as a messenger and as Yahveh the Son. L ikewise , Matenal com direlbs autcrars
68
Yael Na tan
the NT presents Yes/lila as both messen ger (Joh 08:28 ; 12:49) and God (1oh 20:28 ; Hcb 0 I:08). This led or readers to conclude that Yeshlla was the Malek Yah"eh in the fle sh, and that Ye.\h,w was both God a nd vah veh the Son . Acti ng as a messeng er , the Ma lek Ya treeh demo nstrated (he prein camate Son's love for fallen humanity. The prcinca rnatc Son was not too proud 10 beco me a messenger. Likewise. the Son was not too proud to become the Messiah (Mat 20: 28; Mar 10:45 ; Ro m 15:08-09 ; 2Co 08:09; Heb 12:0 2). In teresting ly, the Malek Yahveh demonstrated the pre incamate So n's lo ve for fallen humanity when he took o n the form of a man. He tempo rarily appeared in the for m of a man when he made preincamate appearances as the: • Malek Yah veh (Gen 18-19, 32; Jos 05; Jdg 0 6,1 3), • Son of Man (Eze 0 1:26; Dan 07: 13), and as the • Son ofGod (Dan 03 :25 ). The se te xts led tmene stamema l readers like S imeon (Luk 02:25 -34 ) to ex pect the Son's appearance as the God -man Messiah (Isa 0 7: 14: 09:06: Mic 0 5:02 : Mat 01 :23; Joh 0 1:14: Ro m 09 :05 ; Phi 02 :06-07 : Heb 0 2:09- 18).
Jacob and Hi Shaddai (Gcn 32 and 35) We ca n knnw with ce rtai nty that the "man' with whom Jaco b wre stled wa s HI Shaddoi and no t a mere c reature. T he wrestler called h imsel f "God' (Ge n 32:28), Jacob ca lled the wrestler Elol1im (Oen 32:30 ), and Jacob c alled the place whe re they wres tled Peniel ("Fal:e o f G oo" ) (Gcn 32:30-3 1). The wrestler gave Jacob the epo nym Israel. and the narrator of Kings said it was Ya hveh who gave Jacob the name Israe l ( IKi lR:31: 2Ki 17:34). The div ine w restler (Gc n 32) ap peared agai n to Jacob as £/ Shad(lai at Bethel (Gen 35 ). T his appearance occurred after the Father spoke o f the Son in the third person: Then Go d [the Father) said to Jacob, 'G o up to Bethel and settle there , and build an altar the re to God [the Son]. who appeared to yo u whe n yo u were fleein g from you r brother Esau' (Ge n 35:01), The wres tle r (Ge n 32) appeared aga in to Jaco b afte r the narrator, Moses. spoke of God using plural s: [All) the God s [h{l1::lohim ]. they appeared [plural verb) to him [Jaco b] [at Bethel in Gen 28 J (Ge n 35:(7). Then. by way o f introd uction. the narrator. Moses . reca lled ho w the wres tler (Ge n 32:28) had give n Jacob the name Israe l (Gen 35:0 9- 10). This was Moses" way of tell ing the reader that EI Shaddlli. who was abou t to ap pear to Jacob aga in (Oe n 35: 11-13), had pre vio usly wres tled with Jacob (Gen 32). So. based entirel y on evidence internal to Ge nesis. the wrestler ca n be ide ntified bnth as £ / Shoddai and as God the Son. We ca n a lso kno w. based nn the Malek Yahl'cl1's directio ns conce rning Gene sis {Exo 06:0 3). that God the Son was both the Ma lek: YlIIH'ch and EI Sh atlc/ai.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewish Trinity
69
£ 1 Sh adllai mea ns "G od of Migh ty One s." The £ 1 is s ingular and refer s to the Son, Shadda i is a plural co llect ive noun referrin g to the Tr inity, So El Shaddai could be tran slated as "God of Migh ty On es: ' a nd £ 1 Shadllai could be interpreted as "Divine member o f the Trinity." S ince Elo him and El Stmddoi arc titles ami not names , Jacob req uested to know the name of the Ma lek Yclh reh . Th e Ma lek vah veh den ied Jacob 's req uest say ing that Jacob did not have a suffic ient necd 10 know (Gcn 32:29). Th is is not unexpected since God has many sec rets (Dcu 29:29; Ma t 0 7:06 : n :1 7, 35; Joh 15:15).
!\loses and El S haddai (E xo 03 and 06) Mose s learned from Gene sis thai the Father was Yahveh, As was mentioned in the chapter on colle cnve plurals. Eve knew the Fath er was Ya h eh (Gen 04:0 1). The Name . fa hre h. is found 124 time s in Genesi s. Fu rther mo re. the shortened fonn o f Yahreh (Ya) is em bedde d in the names of perso ns born before Exo 0 3 and 0 6, fo r instanc e: Joc he bed (Exo 06 :20 ; Num 26 :S9) and Joshua (E xo 17:09 ). Jacob 's ex perience with the di vine wrestler informed Moses that he needed to presen t a need 10 know the Malek Yahw'h 's name, Mose s sa id that the Israe lites would not bel icve the Malek fahreh had sent h im if Mose s d id not know the Malek Yuhl'eh's name (Exo n:02. 13). Jacob. Mose s and the Hebrew elde rs did not kno w the Malek Yah ~'eh ' s name. T hro ughout the book of Genes is and 10 Exodu s 0 3: 13. o nly the post-Smairic Yah vixt narrator, Mo ses, kne w the Ma lek Yuhl'"h as Ya ln'eh (Gen 16:13; b tl 0 3:04. 0 7). The patriar ch s only knew the Son as: • F.lohim(Gen 16:13; 22:12; 31:13; Exo 03 :06 . 13,I S, 16;04:(5), and as • El Shmlda i (Gen 17:01 ; 35: II ; Exo06:03). Mose s undoubtedly kne w from study ing Gene sis and extra-biblical sources that the man with whom Jac ob wrestled was the Ma lek rah veh, The Hebre ws knew the de tails of Jacob 's enco unter with the d ivine wres tler Stl well that it affec ted their eating habits (Ge n 32:32). T his same Ma lek Yc,hl'eh now met Mose s on Mount Sinai (E xo 03:(2 ). T he Ma id Yahveh thought Moses and the Israeli tes had been in a state of suspe nse lo ng enou gh. and had suffic ient reason to know his Name , Yahveh (Exo 0 3: 14- 16). The Ma lek fa lwe h's (E xo 0 3:02) revealing that he was fahl'eh allowed Hosea to wrue thai the wrestler was both the Ma lek fa ln'eh (Hov 12:04 IBHS 12:0 5 ]) and Yuh l'"h (Hns 12 :0 SI HHS 12 :0 6 ]) : In the wo mb he [Jaco b) took his brother [Esau] by the heel; and in his manhood he [Jacob ] had power with God [i.e.. with the Peniei , literally "Th e Fal.:e( s) of God " (Gen 32:30 -3 1»). 04 Indeed, he [Jacob] had power ov er the Millek [the Son] an d prevailed [Gen 32:24-321; He [Ja cob ) wept. and made suppl ica tion to him [the Son I, He [Ja cob] found him [the Son] at Bethe l [Gen 35 :09- 15]. and there he [Jaco bi spoke with us [the Trinity].
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Yael Natan
70
05 even Yahvch [the Fath er], Goo [the Son] of hosts; Yah veh is his [the Tr inily 'sJ name of reno wn ( Hos 12:03·0 5 [BH S 12:04·06 ]). Since Jacob e nco untered God twic e ar Bet hel (Gc n 28 lind 35), so meo ne might as k. " Which appearance of God at Bethel was Hosea refe rr ing to?" Hosea sa id that after God wrestled with Jacob at the Jabbok ford (ll eb 12:04 : Ge n 32), God ta lked to Jacob al Bethel (Hos 12:04; Gen 35). Th is means that Ho sea had the Oen 35 Bethel meeting in mind - the encounter between Jacob and £ 1 Shaddai (Oc n 35: I I).
Moses Received th e T rinita r ia n Interpretation of Genesis on vtount S inai The Ma lek Yllhw'h re veale d to Mo ses that he was " I AM" and Yah reh (Exo 03 : 14- 15; 06:03). After Mo ses returne d 10 Mo unt Sinai from Egypt. the Ma lek Yah veh further clarified the prope r interpretation of Gen esis. The Mo lek Yah l'eh said the pa tria rchs had know n him as El Shadda i, but not as Yahveh (Exo 06:03). True to the Malek Yah ~'eh ' s word s. only the Gene sis post-Sinainc Yahvist narra tor, Mo ses. kne w that EI Shllddo i wa s al so Yahveh. There is o nly o ne mentio n in Ge nesis o f El Shoddu i be ing fa hreh , and that is hy the narrator. Mo ses: When Abram was ninety-nine years old , Ytlhl'ell appeared to him and sa id. ' I am God Alm ight y lEI Sllluhla;j; wa lk before me and be blameless' (Gen 17:01) . Th e Ma lek Yah veh tho ught it was important to reaffi rm tha i in th e book of Gene sis. the Mo lek Yohreh was the same pe rson as Ef Shaddai. EI Shaddoi had appear ed to the pat riarch s and made prom ise s conce rning Israel (Gen 17:01 ; 35:11), The patriarch s also men tioned /;'1 Shoddui in hlessin gs and prayer s (Gen 21\:03; 43: 14; 48:03; 49:25). Furth e rmor e. the Malek Yu hl'ell did not want Mo ses to th ink that £ 1 Shmltlu ; was a fourth person of the God hea d. Kno wing that EI Shadda i wa s the Mo lek Yahl'ell would help Moses con vince the Hebrew eld ers that Genesis was Tr initarian. A lre ady at th at time the He brew e lders may have leaned tow ard a unit ari an interpretation o f Ge ne sis. The Hebrew ci de rs may have entertained the thou ght that: • /;'1 Shaddai wa s roh veh (the Fathe r), • The Spirit wa s an imp ersonal fo rce. and • The Malek Ya hveh was a created ange l or an impersonal Sl1ekil1ah apparition of Yalweh, Tha i the Malek Yahveh wa s Yah veh mea ns that Exo 0 3-06 is very similar to the Jo s 05: 13-06:05 account. Jo shua doc s not specifically ment ion the Malek Yohreh, but calls the Son Ya h l'eh (los 06:02, 0 6), T he same Malek Yohl'eh to ld bot h Mo ses and Josh ua to take off the ir sanda ls bec au se his prese nce made place s ho ly (Exo 03:05; Jos 05 :1 5 ). Note that , thou gh the Mu le/.: Yalll'eh was Yah veh (Bxo 03:04, 0 7, 14- 16. 18: Jos 06:02, 08), the Mlilek Yahveh dist ingui shed himself from Yfl hl'eh the Father (Exo 06:03; Jos 05:14-15). Clearly, Jo s 06:01-05 is a cont inuation of the conv ersati on belween Jo shua and the Malek Yahre h (los 05:13-15). Th e chapter d ivision betwee n Jo s 05-06 is Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewish Trinity
71
d early misplaced. Othe rwise. the commander of Yah re h's armi es appeared in Jos 05 witho ut having any substantive message for Joshua. So it would seem the Jos 05: 13-06:05 account buttresses the Trinitarian interpre tation of both Exo 03-06 and Genesis, Dtsttngutshing the Trinity in Genesis Specific persons of the Trinity can be distinguished easily in some verses of Genesis: • Ya/weh's saying, " us" (Ge n 01 : 2 6 ~ 03:22; 11:07), • HaE/o/lim is a Hebre w form mean ing, "[All] the Gods," When referring to vahveh, Iw£lo him denotes the persons of the Trinity. The OT menti ons that these people sa w o r talked to hll£/oll i/ll (the Trini ty): Enoch (Oe n 05:22. 24), Noah (Gcn 06:09). Abraham (Oe n 17: 18; 20: 17; 22:03, (9) , Abimc lcch (Oe n 20:06), Jacob (Gen 27:28 ; 35:07; 48: 15), Moses (Exo 03:06, II , 12. 13; 19:03), the Israelites (Exo 18: 1 2~ 19:17; 20:20 , 21 : 24: II). Balaam (Num 22:10: 23:27 ) and Gideon (Jdg 06 :36. 39), • Abraham said , "Gods [Elohinl] . they caused me to wander [plural verb ] fro m my father's hous e ... " (Gen 20 :13). Based o n Ocn 20 :13, we should e xpect to find ar least two persons of the Trini ty in Gen 12:01 ·07. Indeed . God did appea r to Abraham twice to tell Abraham to leave his father 's hou sehold (Oe n 12:0 1. 07). One person appearing twice to promise essentially the same thing makes less sense than an alternative explanation. A plausible interpretation is that two persons of the Trinity appeared consecutively to tell Abraha m to leave Hara n. This allowed two persons of the Trinity to extend promi ses of re ward fo r Abraham acting on his faith by jo urneying to the Promised Land . • The narrator, Moses, recoun ted ho w " fAlI] the God s [h(/£ /olli/ll ), they had appeared [plural verb] to him (Jaco b) when he was fleeing from his brother [Bsuu] [at Bethel in Gen 28]" (Ge n 35:07) . The Ma lek of [Alii the Gods (h(/t'lohim) (Gen 3 1: I I ) said that I'll' was God (HI who appeared to Jacob at Be thel (Ge n 3 1: 13). So Gen 3 1: II , 13 show thai the Mu/ek Yull l'eh was one of the persons of haElollim (" [AliI the Gods") who appeared at Bethel in Gen 28 (Ge n 35:( 7), and • The Mu /ek Yilll l'eh (Exo 03:02) said I'll' was the £ 1Shm ldai (Exo 06:03) who appeared to the patriarchs (Gcn 17:01; 35: II ). One need not distinguish the persons of the Trin ity througho ut Genesi s to see that the Malek Yahreh's Exo 06 :03 interpretatio n of Genesis is a major Trinitarian proof te xt. People are free, however. to attempt to distinguish the perso ns of the Trinity throu ghout Ge nesis, Deduct io ns and infere nce s can be made fro m the data in Genesis as well as from other books of the Bible that touch on subjects in Genesis. We have seen, for instance. that the book s Exodu s, King s and Hosea refer to Genesis. According to the Ma lek Yah w.'h ·s directions, noting whom the patriarc hs kne w as roh veh helps to identify the Father in Genesis. On ly the post-Sinaitic Yahvist Matenal com direlbs autcrars
72
Yael N ata n
narrator, Mo ses. knew that the Son and Spirit were Yah I'!'''. The Name , Ytl hreh, occ urs 165 lime s in 143 Ge nesis verses. The peop le spoke or heard the Name , Yahvrh, in on ly 52 ve rses." so most occurrences o f vah veh in Genes is occu r in the narration . T he NT writers men tio n "God" and " Lo rd" often. The se likel y refer to the Father or to the Tr inity-provided there is no me ntion o f the Son or the Sp irit nea rby. Likew ise. in Genesis, Rlohim and Adona; likely refer 10 the Fathe r or the Trinity when there is no nearby men uon of the Ma lek Yahveh. £ 1 Sh ade/IIi or the Spirit. When the con te xt mentions a spec ific person o f the Tri nit y, then Eloh im an d Adon(/ ; like ly are plurals of delegat ion. A plural of del egation is a Iype of co llective noun that refers to rne Father, the Son or the Spirit's me mbership in the Trinity. Iden tify ing the d ivine perso ns in Genes is by the Ma lek Y{l h ~'eh 's criterion in Exo 06:03 yield s doct rinal d ividends, It becomes clear that the patriarch s referred to the Trinity by the form ha£loh im (" (A ll ] the Gods" ). Ha£lolli m is found 23 lime s in 2 1 verses of Genesis," and, in total. 337 OT verses. The pat riarc hs referred to the indi vidual person s of the Tnn ity by additional names and title s: • In patriarchal times the Father was know n as: o Yahveh, o £ lol1im ("God" ), o £ 1£ Iyo/l ("God Most High" (Ge n 14:1 8, 19, 20 , 22» , o £ 1 Olum ("Ood Eternal" (Ge n 2 1:33». and o Adonai Yahveh (vl.ord Yaill-eh" (Gen 15 :0 2, 08 )), • In patriarc hal times the Son was known as: o EI SJllllldai ("Ood of Mighl)' Ones" (Gen 17:0 1; 28:03; 35: II ; 43:14; 4&:03; 49 :25)). o £ Iohim (" God " (Gcn 16 : 13 ; 22 : 12; 31 ;13; Exo 03:06»), o The Ma lek. I:'lohim ("the Messe nger of God" (Ge n 21 : 17; 3 1: I I ) , and o T he Mulck Yuhl'Ch (Gen 16 :0 7, 09, I I: 22: II , 15), and • The Spirit was known to the patriarchs a s the: o T he "Ruach o f Elohim' ("Spirit o f God" (Gc n 01 :02)). and o The "Ruach o f Yo hveh" (Gen 06:03). T h ree "Cu n t r ols" that Ver ify the Trinitarian Interpretation of Ge nesis: Num 22-24, Job, a nd Rooks I a nd II of the Psalms
The Trinitv ill Nu m 22- 24 Salaam provided sorc e ry services to anyone will ing to pa y the fcc , whether that person happened to be idolatro us or not. Salaam. howe ve r. co nsidered himse lf a Yahvist since he sa id that Yah vch was his God (N um 22: 18, 38 ). Balaam was fro m the "o ld" Yahvist school, as was Mclchizcd ck (Ge n 14:1 8). T he proto -patriar c hal Yahvists wo uld hav e co ns id e red Balaam an erring sou l. Not on ly was sorce ry wrong, but also Balaam hired himself out to anyo ne regard less of his religious persuasion. Salaa m wo uld ha ve been 10 the an cie nt Yahvists what these men were to ear ly C hrist ians; Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
73
• S imon of Samar ia (Act 08:(9). • Bar-Jesus Elymas, the Jew ish sorcere r (Act 13:06-11). and • T he seve n sons o f Sceva . a Je wish chief priest, who likely syncretized pagan and Jewish beliefs (Ac t 19:1 4). E ventually. the Isr ae lite s killed Balaam for pract ic ing sorcery against Israe l (Num 3 1:08). S ince Balaa m lived near the river in "Aram" (Nu m 23 :05, 0 7: Deu 23 :04), he was unaware of doctr inal develo pme nts in vo lvi ng the patri arc hs or Mose s. Balaum's Yahvis m. therefore. was proto-St mnnc and even proto-pat riarch al. The name "J acob" is found nn Balaam 's lips (N um 23:10 , 2 1, e tc.j, hut on ly beca use Hnlak a nd h is pr ince s infor med Balaam abou t Ja co b {N um 23 :07). Sorce re rs a lways needed de tails supplied to the m to develop a: • Rele vant curse or interpretation, • Plausible communication from the "other" side, or a • Self- fulfilling prophecy (Da n 0 2:07 -09). S ince Bnlaum's Yahvism was proto-patriarc hal an d proto-Sinuitic. Num 22-24 is a benchm ark for the Tri nitarian inte rpretatio n o f Genesis. We can ex pect that B alaam wou ld not kno w facts first revealed 10 the patriarc hs o r 10 Mose s on Mo unt S inai. For instance , Balaa m would no t have known that the Malek Yahveh was " I AM" and Yahl'ch the Son (E xo 0 3:13-15 : 0 6:(3). The several Cre ation, Fall and Flood sto ries of the ancient Near East suggest that the Yahvists possessed atteasr Ge n 0 1- 11 as Sc ripture. Gi lga mesh , for instance , is ju st a sp in o lT from the Ge nesis Flood account. Liberal theologians. of course. asse rt ju st the nppos ite. T hey' maintain that the Gen esis Flood acco unt ste ms from the Gi lgamesh acco unt. but without ev ide nce and ju stifica tion. Balaa m wo uld have know n all the na mes of God found in Ihe first part of Gene sis. In Gcn 0 I - II the Trinity is ca lled haElohim ("[AliI the G ods"), As was the case with Jaco b (O en 32:29 ), the patr iar chs had no need 10 know addi tional names for God. Thus. even a proto-patriarchal Yahvist suc h as Balaam would have kno wn all the names of Yahwh that Mclc hizcdck and the patriarchs knew. Bulaam would ha ve know n, for insta nce , that: • The Trin ity was ca lled haElohim ("[All] the Gods") (Gen 05:22, 24: 06 :02, 04 , 09, 11.. .), • The title Elyon, "the Most High: ' was un iquel y the Father's (Gen 14 :18, 19, 20 , 22), • The title (EI) Shaddai, "God of Mighty Ones" was uniquely the Son's (Gcn 17: 01; 28:03: 35: I I: 43 :14: 48:03; 49 :25) , • The Spirit was culled the Ruech, meaning, "S pirit" (G en 0 1:02: 06:03: 41:3R), and • The Son was ca lled the Malek Ya!1l'I;,h (Ge n 16:0 7, 09, 10, I I: 22: 11. 15: Exo 03:(2) and El Snaddai (E xo 06:(3). Indeed , we find that Balaam referred 10 the persons of the Trinity just as the patriarchs had (Nurn 22 -24). As was the case in Gene sis, only the pro ro-Sm uinc narrato r of Num 22 -24 knew that the Malek Yllhl'ch's name was Yll hl'd l (N um 22: Matenal com direlbs autcrars
74
Yael Na ta n
28 .3 1). Balaam often spo ke of the Fat her as Ytlhreh, and S alaam knew the Tri nity as IwE/ohim ("[AliI the God s" ) (N um 22:10. 23:27). Balaam referred to the Fathe r as £lyon (" Mosi lligh") {Num 24:16). Balaam refe rred to the Spirit both as "God" (N um 24:04, 16 ) and as "rhe Sp irit of G od" (N um 24:02). S alaam referred 10 the Malek Yahl'eh as Shadd/Ii (N um 24:04 , 16 ). Snaaaai is short for /;'1 Shlllldlli . mea ning, "God of Mighty One s: ' The Son was called HI Shuddai often during the patriarchal pe riod (Gen 17:01 ; 28:03; 35: 11: 43:14; 48 : 03 ; 49:25). Shl./tMai by itself co uld be understood as a plural of de legatio n, a type of collective noun. Shaddoi wou ld the n ind icate that the Malek Ya hveh is one of the "Mights" (Shaddui ), o r in oth er words, a mem ber of the Trinity. S ince Balaam said he saw a vision of S/wddai and fell down prostrate (Num 24: 16), Balaam must have bee n referring to the Mille/.: YCl hreh by the title Shatldai. The M{l1l.'k Yahveh is the on ly heavenl y' person who appeared to Balaa m [N um 22:22-35 ). The So n is often c alled (El ) SJwddai (Gen 17:0 1; 2K:03; 35: 11 ; 43:1 4: 48:03; 49:25; Exo 06:0 3; Num 24:0 4, 16, and the like). Th at Balaam knew the M ale/.: Yahwh to be £1Shaddai e xplains why Salaam fell dow n prostrate befo re the Malek Yahreh (N um 22:31). That Balaam bowed to the Malek Yahveh may itself suggest that the Malek Yah veh was d ivine (N um 22:3 1). Bowing to angels was not necessa ry (Luk 0 I: 11- 12; Rev 22:08-09). Balaam sa id he saw a vision o f " him" (N um 24:17), mea ning Shaddai (Num 24: 16 ), as the future Messiah (N urn 24:0 7b-0 8, 17): • His [Israel's ) King [The So n a s Mess iah] shall be higher than Agag. His [the Messiah's ] k ingdom sh all be exalted (Nurn 24:07b). £1 [the Fa ther] brings him [The So n as Messiah] fort h out of Egy pt (N um 24:0R), • He [Balaam ] sa id, who he ars the words of t.;J [the Spirit mentioned earlier in N um 24:02 , 04 .]. who kno ws the knowledge of the Mosl High [the r athe r], whn sees the vision of Shaddai [the Son as Malek Yahreh and Shaddai], fa lling dow n, and having h is eyes o pe n [see Num 22:3 1] (Num 24: 16), and • I see him (The Son a s Messiah], but not now; I see h im [T he So n as Me ssiah], but not ncar: T here shallco me fo rth a Star [T he Son as Messiah ] out of Jacob, a scepter [The So n as Messiah ) shal l rise out of Israel [The sce pter or " branch" is associated with the Messiah in Gen 49 :10-1 J. Num 24: 17; Isa 04:02. I I :0 1; 53: 0 2; Je r 2] :05; 33: 15; Zcc 03:08; 06:12, and elsewhere ) (Num 24:17). Shadda i in N um 24:16 is the o nly plau sible re fere nt for the pronou n " hi m" fo und in Num 24:17, So Bulnam saw the M(lIck Yahl'eh who wa s Shaddai. and the n Balaam saw " him: ' mea ning Shadda i, as the future Messiah. T his ag rees with ho w Salaam later called the Messiah "God": He to ok up his pa ra ble. and sa id. ' Alas , w ho s hall li ve whe n E l [meaning Shaddui as Messiah ] does this?' (Nu m 24:2 3). S alaam's passage: El [the Fa ther) hrings him [The So n as Messiah] forth o ut o f Egypt (Num 24:08) . a llowed Ma tt he w to ap ply a simila r passage fro m Ho sea to Ycshua's ch ildhood round trip to Egypt an d back (Mat 0 2:15): Matenal comdirelbs autcrars
The Jewish Trinity
75
When Israel was a c hild, I [the Father] loved him [the Son]. and OUi of Egypt I called my so n (Hos II :01 ). Balaam's messianic prophecy is similar to other messiani c prophec ies in that Balaam spoke of the Messiah as king (Ge n 49: 10; Eze 2 1:26·27; Mic 05:02 [BHS 05:01 ]). Buluam's prophecy in Numbe rs is similar to Psa 091 in that both speak of the Messiah being 1:.:1 S/wdJa i. The Psalmist wrote that the Messiah wou ld be Shaddai , and the Messiah would la ke refuge in £ /)'0 11 (the Most Highl . meaning the Father (Psa 09 1:0 I. 09 ). The Trinity ill Jo b Job lived between 2.000 and 1.500 Be. Job's Yahvism wo uld have been proto patriarchal s ince Job most likely did not know of the patriarchs. Though Job mennonv /Ill/ leks (ange ls). Jo b makes no mention of the Ma lek Yah veh, Job does. however, mention Slwddai twenty-three times. The book of Job can serve as another benchmark that verifies the Trinitarian interpretation of Genesis. As a proto-patriarc hal Yahvi-a, Job would have kno wn the Son as Shaddai and as Etohim , but not as Yahveh (Exo 0 3:13-15 ; 06:03). Therefore, it is nOI surprising that the Nam e, Ya hl'ell. does not appear in the same chapter as the name Shadda i -cxcept in Job 40. 71 Yah l'eh and Shaddai we re both kno wn as God since Job's friend Elihu said: BUI no o ne says, ' Where is God s [p lura l no un), my Make rs [plural noun] ...?' (Job 35: HI). In Job 40 , the informed , post-Sinauic Yahvist na rrator mentions Yahveh three time s (lob 40 :0 1, 03 , 06 ). while God mention s the nam e Shadda i (Job 40:(2). So Job had a proto -patriarchal theology. while a later narrat or o r redactor had a post-Sinuitic theo logy. Job knew thc Fathe r as Yahw h and Job knew the Son as Shlllldai, hut Job did not know the So n as Yah vch , The Trinity in Books l and 1I 1!{ the P.W/ lm ,I' The usage of divine names in Hooks I and 11 of the Psalms is somewhat akin to Job's alternating use of Ya hreh and Shaddl/; in different chapters. In the Psalms: • To honor the Father and the Trinity, Yahveh is the predominant name for God in 8 00k I (Psa 00 I - 04 1), and • To honor rne Son , Ell/him is the predominant name for God in Book II (Psa 042 -072). Also, to honor the So n, the first mention in the Psa lms of the name Shlldda; occurs in Book II (Psa 068: 14 [BHS 068: 15]). The arrangement of Book I and II was intended to honor the Fathe r and the Son individually. It was appropriate for the Psalm s to hono r the Son since the So n wo uld one day become the God-man offsprin g of David (2Sa 07:12). David was respon sible for writing many psalms. Appropriately, in 2Sa 07 and in the Psalms there are many proofs both of the divinity of the Messiah , and of the Trinity. T hese proofs are discussed in the MT plurals appendix. What better way was there to ho nor the Father and the Son individually than to recall Proto-Sinaiuc theology in poe tic verse? Book I recalls how only the Fa ther Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Yael N ata n
76
was kno wn as Yahveh during Genes is. Boo k II recall s how the Son was know n as £1Shaddai and Elohim, but not as Yahwh (E xo 06:03), Thu s. Books I ami II of the Psalms help to verify the Trin itarian interpretation of Genesi s. The Impact of the Trinitarian Interpretation of Genesis on I<:xegesis The JED P theo ry is buttressed mainly 0 11 the assumption that diffe rent writer s an d redac tors preferred the title Elohim over the Name , Yahveh, or vice versa. The Ma lek Yuh l'eh's instruct jon abou t Gene sis (Exo 06:03), howe ver, sho ws that the different names len d to indicate di fferent perso ns of the Trinity. Thi s mean s that the JED P theo ry is merely eis egevis passed off as ex egevis." II is interesting to notc that if the same JEDP assumpt ions were app lied to othe r text s know n to ha ve on ly one aut hor, the pr ocess wo uld resul t in man)' wild con cl usions. For insta nce. Norman Ge isler make s this interest note about the Koran : . ..the same a nti-supernaturalism that led liberal critics of the B ible to de ny that Moses wrote the Pentateuch. noting the d iffere nt words for God used in different passages, wo uld like wise arg ue that the QlIr 'lIf1 did nOI co me from Muhammad. For the Qur 'ull also use s different names for God in di fferen t place s. AI/uh is used for Goo in suras 4, 9, 24, 33, but Rub is used in suras IR, 23 and 25." Th e Impact of the Trinitarian Interpretation of Genesis on A ngel of the
Lord Theories The Malek Yahveh (Exo 0 3:02) said that the patriarchs knew him as HI Slwdl/ai, bUI nol as Yahveh (Exo 06:03). T his mean s thc Malek Yll hr eh was known 10 be a divine person separate and distinc t fm m Yoh veh the father. The e vidence simply do e s not support any theory that says the Malek Yuhreh wa s a mere s pirit cr eature, much less an impe rso nal Shekil1(( h or apparition of Yah w h. The se theories post ulate that thc Malek Yahve h was "Goo" and '"Yah,'ch" onl y by association with the Father, OUI of deference to the Father, or by derivation from the Father. If the Ma lek vah veh wer e impersonal, this wo uld te nd to ma ke God into a puppe lccr or ventriloq uist. On ene ss Iheo lo gy is pop ular in man y Pemecostal ci rcles. O nene ss is just a warmed -over , repackaged version of the ancient he resy called Mod alism. Onene ss adhere nts believ e tha t there is onl y one person c alled YaJII·eh. lie play-ac ted the part of Father, So n and Spirit-as the occasion required . One ne ss e nth usia sts believe that, among other things, the Son: • Q uoted himself (Ge n 22: 15- 16; Joh 14 :10 , 24), • Spok c of him self as being the Father ot tcu. • Play-act ed two (Joh 12:2R-30 ) or three (Mat 0 3: 16- 17 ) divine persons at a lime, and • Pra yed to the Father often (1oh 17:01 -26 ).
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
77
O nly the Ma lek Yllh veh's being a d ivine person disti nct from the Father wou ld a llow the Malek rahveh 10 state that: • He was E/ Shaddai, and • T he patriarchs d id not know him by the Name, Yallreh (Exo 0 6:0 3). Both the Prcdc luvian s and patriarc hs knew at least one perso n to be Yahveh (Ge n 04 :01 , 26). If the Father, the Male/.:. Yahveh and the Spirit were all the same pe rso n, as Medalists asse rt, there is no sideste pp ing the fac t that that pe rson definitel y was k now n as Ytl/ll'eh. On ly di stinct persons of the Trini ty co uld, without co ntriva nce, claim that the Patriarchs d id not know him as rahveh (Exo 06: 03 ). Beside s Exo 06:03, there are many indicat ions that the Father and Son are two distinct persons in both testaments. Examples include: • T he MlIle/.:. Yahveh quoting the Father (G en 22: 15- 1R). and • The prophet)' that the kings o f the earth wo uld speak against YClhl'eli and his Me ssiah (Psa 002 :02) saying: Le t us break their [plural] chains... a nd throw off their [plural I fetters (Psa 002 :03). NT examples that show the Father and Son are distinct persons include Yf'.I'hulI ' s baptis m. At YeJ/llw ' s baptism, the Father spoke fro m hea ven while the Spirit al ighted on veshua in the form of a do ve (Mat 03:16-1 7). Another NT example occ urred when Ye,~JItfII was in the temple a nd the Father spo ke from hea ven (Jo h 12:28-30 ). It would see m that either the Trinity is three distinct persons, or e lse we must believe that God is a ventriloqu ist or a puppe teer. That God is a ventriloquist or puppeteer is a doctrine unwort hy of belief ( ICo 15: 19).
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Matenal com direlbs autorars
Chapter 3 The Presences of Elyon
Background The Hebrew wo rd Elvon is ofte n translated as " Mos t High: ' Elyoll is the Fathe r. The Hebrew word panim is translated as "presencets)." "facetx)," or "personts)." Panim looks like a Hebrew plural. bUI is in fact a d ual form. The singular form I/(Im,h we nt unuse d in Hebrew Sc rip ture. Whet her dual forms are Iranxlated as singulars or plurals depends on the co ntext. Dual forms such as panim arc discu ssed in the chapter o n Heb rew co llective nouns. Since mo st trans luncns arc no r literal, Ihc ph rase " before my face [paniml" become s "before me" (Gc n 17:01 ; 33:14). Some times the word panim is igno red altogether. Por instance. Jonah ran aW11) " "from the Presences [PllI/im ] of Yah ,'e" " is so metimes trans lated as "from the LORD" (NIV Jon Ol:()] (twice), 10). The phrase Panim Yahveh: • Preceded by the prepositio n " befo re" ("/" = lamedh) lite rally means " before Yah ~'eh 's pre sence: ' or " before Ya/n>eh," o r wo rds to that effe ct. • Precede d by the pre pos ition " fro m" (m in ) lite rall y mea ns " fro m Ya hl'eh' s presenc e ,'" anu • Witho ut a prepositional ph rase literally mean s " Presences of Yah l'eh .'''' There are two e xce pt ions di scussed later in this ch ap ter (Psa 0 34 :15- 16; Lam 04 :16). As wa s sta ted before , whether Pan im is transla ted as a s ing ular o r plura l depends on the co ntext. This mean s the dual for m Panim can refer to the Son or Spi rit. or both. For insta nce , here the pl ural ve rbs ind icate that Punim refers to the Son and Spirit, and therefo re sho uld be translated in the plura l as "Presences": ra hve h I t " y on the Fa ther] rep lied , ' My Pre se nc es [Heb re w plu ral " ani"' J, the y will go [pl ura l verh] with yo u. and I will gi ve yo u re st.' T hen Mo ses said to him [Efyoll the Father]. ' Your Presences. if they [the Son and Spirit] do not go [plura l ve rb] with us [to the Promised Land i, do not se nd us up from here [Mount Sin ai]' (Exo 33:1 4- 15 ).
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Yael Na tan
80 Who Arc Elyon 's Presences?
The Son as E/\'IJIl :~ Presence The existence of God 's omnipresence can be inferred by observing the world an d universe (Act 17:27-28; Rom 0 1:19- 20). Just as no mer e spirit cre ature can con vey God's o mnipresence. ne ither can a mere creature conve y God 's e specia l. pe rsonal presence. It is the refore no sur prise that Script ure associ ates Yalwell's Presence o nly with the So n a nd Spiru." The Son is called a Prese nce o f Y ah veh in these instances: • T he Malek Yah reh (E xo 0 3:02 ; 23 :20 , 23; 33:02) is ca lled the Presence o f vah veh (h o 06 :12. ) 0; 23:1 7; 34: 14. 15. 23. 24,34,35 ; Dell 16:16; 3 1: 11). Note that these passage s are found in, or refe r back to. sections where the Son is sai d to have d ivine names: o Yahveh and the " I AM" (Exo 0 3: 14- 15), o £ 1 Shadda; (Exo 06: 03). and o T he Mu lek with Yah w' h ' s Name in Him (Exo 23:2 1; 33:02) , • The Male/.: Yahl'e1l 's presen ce made the surro undings so holy that Moses and Joshu a were obliged to take off the ir sanda ls [Exo 0 3:05; Jo s 0 5: 15). and • The narrator of the book of Jo shua wrote : Seve n prie sts c arried sev en trum pets before the Prese nce [Pal/im] o f Yuh l'eh (Jos 06:0&). The " Presence o f Ya hl'eh" refers bac k to the co mmande r of Yah l'l' h ' s armies-the M (li ek Yah ~'eh (Jos 0 5:14- 15). Ev iden tly, the Malek Yahveh ma rch ed ahead o f the Israe lites arou nd Jericho j ust as the Malek Yahl 'ch had marched ahead of the Israelit es during the Exod us (Exo 14: 19). Isa iah said that the Messiah wo uld be "Imma nuel." meaning, "God (pre sent ] with us" ( lsa 0 7:14; Mat 1JI :23). T he wo rd " Immanuel" was Isaiah's wa y o f say ing that the co ming Messiah wou ld be a Pre sence of Yah veh, Luke wro te about Y('.I'hul/ as a Presence , .. . .. when time s of spiri tual refreshm ent ma y come fro m the Presence [the So n) of the Lord [the f ather ]. and that he [the Fathe r] may send him [the Son as a Pre sen ce ) who has been appoin ted fo r you-s-eve n Ch rist Ye.l'/ullI (Act 03:19 -20 (Gree k 03:20»). Isaiah also wro te abou t the Messiah bein g the Fat her's Presen ce on the Last Day: Enter into the rock , and hide in the dust, from before the Presence of the Fear [the So n) of Yah l'e1l [the Father ], an d from the g lory [the Son] of his [the Fat her'x ] majesty (I sa 02 :10). Speaking about the Son 's return on the Last Day (2 Th 0 1:07 ), Paul alluded to Isa 0 2: 10 10 say that the Messiah was the Presence and the g lory of the Father: Who shall be punished with eve rlasting destru ction fro m the Presence [the Son] of the Lord [the Father], and fro m the glory [the Son) of his [the Fathe r's ] power (2Th 0 1:09 ). Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
81
Speaking of t he New Hea ven and New Ea rth, the A pos tle John wro te in Revelati on of the Son 's pre sence with the Father. Joh n wrote that the Lord God an d the Lamb "is" a tem ple (Rev 21:22). Jo hn also wrote o f the Son's prese nce with the Fathe r as thoug h the So n were a lamp and as though the Fath er were the emitted light rgc v 2 1:23): I saw no temp le in it. for the Lord Go d, the Almighty, and the La mb, is (sin gu lar verb) its temp le. T he c ity has no need for the sun or moon to shine, for the ve ry glory of God illuminated it, and its lamp is the Lamb (Rev 2 1:22-23). The Apostle John wrote that the Father and Son had one throne , one fuce, and one name. That the Father and Son have a sing ular throne agrees with YlIhl'eh's OT state ment: A glorious th rone , ex alte d from the begi nni ng. is the place o f our sanctuary tJe r 17: 12). Note that there was one thro ne in "o ur sanctuary," Jer 17:12 is me ntioned in the MT plurals appendix . John eve n addressed both the Fathe r and So n together using the singular pro nouns "h is" and " him" (Rev 22:0 1, 03-(4): He showed me a river of water of life. cle ar as crys tal. proceeding o ut of the th ro ne [sin gula r] of God [the Father ] an d of the Lam b [the Son] ... The throne [singular] of God and of the Lam b will be in it, and his [singular pronoun] serva nts serve him [singular prono un]. Th ey will see his [singular pronoun) face, and his [singular pronou n] name will be o n their fore heads ( Rev 22:0 I, 03-(4). The Son is said to be present at the Eucharist. Surely, on ly a Presence of ranven co uld acco mplish suc h a d iv ine feat! T he Euc harist is a meal commemorating Ye.~hIUJ's sacrifice for s ins (Rom OS:0 3; Bph 0 5:02; He b 09: 14; 10:12). Th e wine is ca lled the blond of the covenant (M at 26:26-29; Mar 14:22-25; Luk 22: 17-20: ICo I I:23- 29). To avoid misunde rstandin gs, it would be beneficia l to set ou t the Lutheran posit ion on the Lord 's Supper he re. Koehler wrote: ' ... we he reby utte rly con de mn the Ca pernait ic eat ing of the bod y of Ch rist, as though His body were rent with the teeth, an d d igested like othe r food' (F. C. Epit., A rt. VIII, 42, Trig/or, p. 1317). We do not ' hold that the body and blood of Ch rist are included in the bread loc all y, or are other wise permane ntly united therew ith apart from the use of the Sacrament ' (E C. Th . D., An. VII, 14. Trigtot, p. 977). The Lut heran Churc h does not tea ch 'con substantiatum ,' which means that bread and body form one substance, or that the body is present, like the bread. in a nomralmenner; nor does it teac h "irnpananon.' which mea ns that the body is locally encl ose d in thc bread... Th e bo dy and blood of C hrist arc really, but supematuratty prese nt in the Sacrament, an d all co mmu nicants rece ive them orally, with their mou ths, toge ther with the bread and wine." T he So n's supe rnat ural, met aphysic al prese nce in the bread an d wine is expressed by: Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Yael Natan
82
• The Son ~ ay i n g . "T his is my body" (Mat 26:26; Mar 14:22: Luk 22 :19) , • The Son say ing, "T his is my blood" (Mal 26:28: Mar 14:24: Luk 22:20) . and by • Paul say ing thai the ce lebrants and co mmunicants must recognize the bod y of the Lord ( l e o 10: 16 ; 11 :27). Yeshua:w s upe rna tu ra l. met a phys ica l pre sen ce with the bre ad a nd wine is prefig ured by: • The supernatural be nefits that acco mpan ied the eat ing of manna (Deu 08:0304 ; 29:05-06; Neh Ol}:10 -11 ; Joh 06:4 1, 5 1). Moses said that Yuhw:,h wal ked through Ihe midst o f Israeli te c amp. so the ca mp had 10 remain hol y so Yah veh wo uld not tum away ( De ll 23: 14), • Mclchizcd ck, an ancie nt Yah vist priest- king of Jeru sa lem, came out to meet A hrah am wi th bread and wine (Ge11 14 :18 ). Melc hizedek was great er than Abraham ( Hcb 0 7:0 7). Th e Son bec a me a k ingly prie st in t he order o f Mele hizedek after his dea th a nd res urrect io n (Psa 110:04; Heb 05: 06). T hat the Son is a prie st-k ing in the orde r of Melc hizedek e xpla ins why Yi:',, /wa said that he would not dr ink wine until "it find s fulfill ment in the kingdom of God" (Isa 25:06 -0 7; Ma t 26:29; Mar 14:25; Luk 22: 16, 18). Yeshua the n appeared on the firs t d ay of the week (M at 28:0 1, 09-10; Luk 24:2 1, 33-35; Joh 20:19 , 26) and bro ke bread and dran k wine with the d isc iples (Act 10:41). Th us, wine "found its fulfillment' (its highest use ) whe n it became cus tomary to meet and have the Lord 's Supper on the first day of the week (Ac t 20:07; ICo 16:0 2; Rev 0 1: 10). True comm unio n, of co urse, occ urs only in the kingdom of the priest -kin g Ye.I'hu iI .
• w hen the Tr inity appeared to Abraham. he told Sarah 10 make bread from th ree seahs o f flou r (Gcn 18:06 ). The n Abraham ate with the Tr inity, • Mose s, his father-in-law. and the Israel ite elders ate in the prese nce of Yah veh (E xo 18:12; 24:11), • Mo ses instr uct ed the Israel ites to b uild a n altar and eat and rejoic e in the prese nce of YaJm:,h once they had entered the Promised Land ( Deu 12:07 , 18; 14:23, 26; 15:20 ; 27:07; Eze 44:03). • Dur ing the time of the Judges. Sam uel told Sau l abo ut three men making what seems to be a Trinitarian offe ring to [All] the God s (haEfohim ) at Bethel (I Sa 10:03-04 ): three loaves of bread and three goat s, }'et o ne sk in of wine. T he Trin ity may have posed as three men in ISa JO as they did in Gen 18. Instead of bread made with three seahs of flour (Gen 18:06), the three me n had three loave s ( ISa 10:0 3). One of the me n. perhaps the Son, shared t wo lo ave s of o ffer ing bread with Saul. This see ms to prefi gure the Lord 's Sup per, • The ISa JO inc iden t with Saul has similarities to Da vid and h is men ea ting the Bread of the Presen ces (Exo 25:30 ) at Ihe tabe rnacle ( ISa 2 1:04·06; Mat 12:03(4). Paul sa id a person partaking of the Lord 's Supper should ex amine himself before eating and drinking (I Co 11:28). Before g iving David the Bread of the Presen ce s, the priests as ked Da vid whether his men had kept them selve s fro m wome n. To men on the march, this is likel y a e uphe mistic wa}' o f sa) ing "fo rm-
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
83
cat io n" ( ISa 2 1:04-06; co mpare Rev 14:04). Co nsidered togeth e r, the incidents co nce rning Sau l and Da vid ce rta inly seem 10 fore shadow t he Lord 's Supper, • The So n's d isappearance s durin g Munoah and Gi deo n's blood and grain offer ings (Jdg 06: 19-2 1: 13: 15-20 ), and • The Son 's co ntinuing the co n versatio n with Gi deon even after he d isappeared in the smoke of G ideon's grain offe ring (Jdg 06:23), T he narrator sa id that after the Malek Yahl'eh di sappeared, ¥ll hn 'h said to him: ' Peace be to yo u; do not fea r, yo u shall 110t die " (1d g 06 :23). Ye S/lilli' S su perna tural, met a phys ica l pre sen ce with the bread a nd wine is underscored by: • The Son's say ing h is flesh was bread (1oh 06 :50-58), and " I AM the bread of life" (1oh 06: 35 is discus sed in the "1 AM" chapte r), • T he So n's reappeara nce in Je rusa lem during the disciples' di scu ssion of thc Son's prev ious d isappea rance during thc bre aki ng of bread with the Em maus d isciples ( Luk 24:31. 35-36). The Son said upon his reappearance to the d isci ple s. " Peace be to you" (Lu k 24 :36). This brings to mind how. after the M alek Yah l,t'h had d isappeared : ra hveh said to him [Gideon). 'Peace be 10 yo u; do no t fear. you shall not die ' (1dg 06:23 is noted just abov e ), • The Son say ing: For w here two or three co me together in my name , there am I with the m (Ma t 1&: 20 ), and • The supernatur al be nefit s that accom pany the celebration of the Lord 's Supper nco 10:16-17; 11:29-30). The Spi ,-il ll.\ Elvon \' P resence Scrip ture associates Yahveh'v Prese nce with the Sp irit. The narrator wrote that the Spirit of Yahveh stirred within Samson (Jd g 13:24 ), but tha t Yahveh eve ntually left Samso n (ldg 16:20 ), T his sho ws that the Spirit is more than an impe rsonal fo rce , for Yahveh wo uld need 10 be perso nally present in ord er to lea ve. Ezekie l wro te about the Spirit being t(,h""h's Pre sence: 'N either will I hide my Pre sence IPanilll ) any mo re from them; for I have pour ed OUI my Spirit on the house of Israel.' says the Lo rd Yah l'eh [the Father] (Ezc 39 :29 ). HI/th the SI/II lind Spirit as flyo/l:~ Prese nces Severa l passages show that both the Son and the Sp irit are Elyoll's Presences: • Da vid wrote: o Whc re could I go fro m yo ur [the Father 's] Spirit'! Or whc re co uld I fl ee from yo ur [the Father's] Prese nce [Pll nim] [the So n]"? (Psa 139:0 7), and o Hide you r [the Fathe r's] face from my sins. .. b ut do not ban ish mc from your [the Father 's ] Prese nce [the Son]. nor ta ke your Holy Spint fro m me (Psa rJ5 1:09-11). Matenal com direlbs autcrars
84
Yael Na ta n
•
Isai ah wrote : In their entire affliction he [the Father] wa s afll icted, and the Malek [the Son] , hi s [the Father's] Presence [Pllllim (the Sc m ]. saved them .. .BUI they rebel led. and gr ieved his Hol y Spirit.. . his Holy Sp irit in the midst o f the m r"in the midst" is tantamoun t to say ing the Spirit is a Presence! (Isa 63:09- 11 ). • Th e Son said that the Fat her wou ld send the Messiah and the Sp irit 10 be prese nt with believers. The Son said: Now the Lord Yahveh (the Fat her) has sent me [the Son) and his [the Father's ] Sp irit (lsa 48 : 16 ). • During h is earthly min istry. Ye.~hIUJ said that he (Mat 28 :20) and the Spirit (1oh 16:07) wou ld be present for be lievers. Joh n recorded how Ye.I'lwll said the Spirit is "another Counselor," mea ning tha t both the Sp irit lind Son were Counselors . Ye.~ h u(1 the n sa id th at the Spirit and Yesh ,w would be presen t with Christ ians : I will pray to the Fa ther, and he will give yo u a no ther Counselor, that he may be w ith you forever-c-the Spi rit of truth, w hom the world can not receive; for the world does no t see him or kno w him . You kno w him, fo r he lives w ith yo u. and will be in you. I w ill not leave you o rphans. I wi ll co me ro you rlo h 14:1 6- 1&). • Luke wrote that parents brought infant s to YeIhUil for his blessing {Luk 18: 1517). Thi s incident correlates we ll with what Jere miah wrote abou t the Prese nces of rahvch : Pou r out yo ur heart before the Prese nces [the Son and Spirit) of the Lord [the Father] . Lift up your ha nds to him [the Trini ty ] fo r the li ve s o f you r infants (Lam 0 2: 19). • Isa iah records Ytlh l'eh' s words about the Prese nces after the Last Day: As the ne w hea ve ns and new earth that I make will endure before my Prese nces [the So n an d Spirit).. Prom one Ne w Moon to anot her and from on e Sabbath to a nother, all mank ind will come and bo w down before my Presences [the Son and Spirit) (l sa 66 :22-23). The next section disc usses more events where the Son and Spirit appear as the Presence s of £1)"01/.
Some Encounters with Elyon 's Presences Abraham and /11" Trinitv Ge n 1&- 19 com prise the lo ngest Trinitarian proof text in the Bible . Gen 19 me ntions Ya hl'e ll\ Pre sence s (Ge n 19 :1 3, 27 ). fa/well appeared as three me n to Abraha m (Gc n 18 :0 1·02). Moses. the narrator of Genes is, wrote: ranveh [the Son ] sai d ... ' I will go dow n now, and see if what they ha ve done is as bad as the outcry about it that has come to me [the Son). If not, I wi ll know.' T he men [the Son and Spirit ) turned and wen t toward Sodom. but Abrah am re mained stand ing be fore Yohveh [the Fath er) (Ge n 1&:20-22). Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Th e Jewish Trin ity
85
Yahveh the Father rema ined behind to talk to Abraham, but the n ret urned to heaven without go ing to Sodom (Gen 18:33) . The Son and Spirit we nt to Sodom and Gornorrah because the inhabitants had been s inning aga inst Yahvch for so me time (Gen 13: 13). Still. they were presumed innocent until proven guilty. After dul y invcs ng uring the situation, Yahreh the Son and Spirit called dow n sulfur upon Sodo m from Yah veh the Father in hea ven: Then Yahveh [the Son and Spi rit] rained on Sodom and o n Gomorrah sulfur and ti re from Yll1Il'f'Il [the Fat her) out of the sky (Ge n 19:24). The Son may have called do wn su lfur spec ifica lly on Sodom, while the Spirit may ha ve called down sulfur specifically on Gomorrah.
Lor and the Two "Presences" (Gen / 9: 13, 2 7) The narrator wrote: Then Yllhl'eh [the Son ] said, 'T he o utcry agai nst Sodom a nd Gomorrah is so great and the ir sin so grievo us that I [the Son] will go do wn and see if what the y ha ve done is as bad as the ou tcry tha t has reached me [the Son]. If ne t. I will know,' Th e men [the Son a nd Spirit l turned away and went toward Sodom. but Abraham remained standing befor e Yilh"eh [the Father] (Gcn IIUO-22 ). The above Trinitari an interpreta tion o f Oe n 18:20-22 fits wel l with wha t the two me n to ld Lot in Sodom : We [the So n and Spirit ) will destro y this place [Sodom ), becau se the cry about them has grown great before the Presences [the Son and Spirit] of Yahveh [the Fa ther] . Ya/II'ell [the Father) has se nt us [the So n and Spirit ) to destro y it (Ge n 19: 13). The Son had told Abraham that the outcry had reached him (Gc n 18:2 1). The Father se nt the Son and Spirit to Sodom (Oe n 18:22). O nce in Sod om the Son and Spi rit identified the mselves to Lot as the Presen ces o f Yahvch who had heard the outcry aga inst Sodom (Gen 19: 13). Later the narrator wrote: Abraham got up early in the morn ing to the place where he had stoo d befor e the Presence s [the Son and Spirit) of YuJII'eh [the Father]. He [A braham] looked down tow ard Sod om and Gomorrah. toward all the land of the pla in, and he saw dense smoke rising from the land, like smoke from a furnace (Gen 19:27-28 ). The place with an o ve rlook o f Sod om (Cen 19:27-28) where Ab rah am saw Sodom with the me n is menti o ned in Gen 18:16: The men [the Son and Spirit] RISe up from there, and koked toward Sod om. Abraham went with them to see them on their [the Son and Spirit's) way. The " men" ment ioned in C ell 18: 16 are the Son and Spir it since they we re the only two perso ns heade d toward Sodom (Gc n 18:22 ). The Fathe r remained behind 10 talk to Ahraham , and then the Father returned to heaven to rain dow n sulfur o n Sodom (Gen 18:22, 33; 19:24 ). So a nalys is of Gen 18-1 9 reveals: • The ch apter is thorou ghly Trinitarian, and Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Yael Na tan
86 • The Presence s o f Spirit.
rahveh
who are ment ioned in Ge n 19:13 .27 an: the Son and
Jacob a/ the Jabbok Jacob wres tled with a Pre sence at the ford of the Ja bbok River (Gen 32:28). Jacob named the ford Peniet tPanim + Ef), mean ing, " r ace of God" or " P resence of Go d." Jaco b sa id he saw God " Face 10 face" [Pantm to p al/1m) (Gen 32:30). Yah w,h and the Maid, Yah re h o ften mel peop le "Pace to face" (Exo 33: I I; Num 12:08 ; 14:14 ; Deu 05 :04 ; 34:10 : Jdg 06: 22 ). The G en 32:28 incident is di scu ssed in the Proro-Sinaiuc Trinitarianism chapter. The lsroclites end the Prese nces The Presences of Yahreh we re present at the g iving o f the law (E xc 20) . Moses recou nted the eve nt: This is the blessing that Moses the man of [Ali i the Gods [haE/ohim ] pronounced on the Israeli tes before his death. Yil/well [the Father] ca me from Sinai, and [the Son] dawned over them from Seir; he (the Spirit I shone forth from Mount Pawn. He [the Father] ca me with my riads of holy ones from the sout h, from his [the Father'x] mountain slopes [Deu 33:0 1-02). The N /V Study Bib/t' says S ina i, Se ir and Mou nt Paran (Dc u 33:02) are three mou nta ins assoc iated with the giving of the law. G. R. Hawt ing wrote: In Jewish a nd C hrist ian el aboration s the biblica l sto ry o f Ha gar 's e xpulsion by Abraham (Gene sis 21:14-2 1) had deve loped strong Arabian associa tions. Paran. the place whe re Ishmael grew up and lived (Gene sis 2 1:2 1), wa s idcntified as a re gi on of no rthwest Arab ia, an d in Pau l 's allegorical develo pmen t o f the story Hagar was iden tified with Mou nt Sin ai 'w hic h is a mo untain in Arabia: '" Mark Co he n wrote abou t med ieval Je ws: Ibn Ezra knew the o ld rabbinic midrosh on the Sinai-Se ir-Para n vers e. For De uteronom y 33:2-3 , he quoted Saad ya's apparentl y apologetic treatme nt of the passa ge. "The Gaon of blessed mem ory slate d that Moun t Sinai, Sc ir, and Paran in the biblical verse arc near one another and that this ve rse tells abo ut the revelano n at Mo unt Sm at.'" Mark Co he n add s an ex planato ry note that the Heb rew form translated ... . ..' fro m Sina i' is e xactly like 'at Sinai," as is [the case with the form com monly translated ] ' from Se ir.' "" So Deu 33:02 co uld be tra nslated e ithe r "from S inai. .. from Se ir. ,.from Par an," or "at Sin ai...at Se ir.. .at Paran." The Muslim misinterp retat io n of Deu 33:02- 03 sho uld be noted. Sam uel M. Z wemer wrote: Muslims ha ve always been eage r to find furthe r proof o f the corning of Mu ham mad in the O ld and New Testament Script ures in add itio n 10 their miai nte rpreta tion o f Joh n 16:7 , re gard ing the Pa racle te [Hel per]. T hey ther efore not on ly q uote the wo rds of the Koran but al so refe r to Matenal com direlbs autcrars
87
The Jewi sh Trinity
Deute ro nom y 33:2 ,...The passage in Deuteronom y states that Jeho vah [Ya l/vell ] came fro m Sina i and ro se fro m Se ir unto the m; he s hined forth from Muunt Paran Sinai is a Jew ish mo untain ; Seir, they say, is a mountain in Galilee where Christ died. Paran . however, is a mou ntai n ncar Mecca ami signifies the Muslim religion." O bviously, the Muslim interpretati on is contradicted not only by geography, but also b)' the OT and NT narratives. That YlIhvl'lI appeared o n three mountains in the same region during the giving of the law is confirmed by Moses' later q uotation of a statement the Israelites made during the giving of the law: For what mortal man has ever heard the voice of the Ji ving Gods [plumIs: khavvim E/ohim ] speaking out of fire, as wc have, and survived? (Deu 05:26)."1 That the Israeli tes were spea king ahout the giving of the law (Exn 20 ) is evident from the context of Deu 115 :26. T hat God spoke out of fire (Deu 05:26) at the giving of t he law is well attested ( Exo 19:1 8; 20:19; Deu 05:24-28; 09: 10; 18:1617 ), The Israelites' mention of the "living Gods" (Deu 05:26) is anothe r indicator that the perso ns of the Trinity appeared simultaneo usly: a person on Mount Seir. a person on Mo unt Parun, and the Fathe r on Mount Sinai (Dc u 33:(2). There is anot her indication that Deu 33:02 speaks of the Trinity appea ring on three mounta ins: the previo us verse says Moses was "the man of [All] the Gods " (/IIIE/ohim) (De u 33:( 1). Durin g the giving of the law (Exo 20) as well as at other times, Moses (Exo 03:06, I I, 12, 13; 19:(3) a nd the Israelites (Exo 18:12; 19;17; 20:20, 2 1; 24: II ) saw [All] the Gods (haElohim). Related poin ts disc ussed in the chapter o n He bre w collective nouns include ho w: • lIa Efohim refers to the Trinity, and • Moses is elsewhere called "the man of [All] the Gods" and the "servant of [All ] the God s: ' That chapters Deu 32-33 contain other Trin itarian proo f passages fu rther supports the Trinitarian interpretation of Deu 33:0 1-02, See the Trinitari an proofs appendix for a discussion of these texts: Deu 32:08-09; LXX Deu 32 :43; and Deu 33:27. Furthermore. Deu 33: 16 refers to a divine person in the "burning bush" of Exo 03:02 (sec also Act 117:3(1). This would seem to indicate that the Ma lek Yahveh was one of the persons of the Trinity who appeared o n one of the three mounta ins (Sinai , Seir, or Paran ) d uring the giving of the law (Deu 33:02). Moses and the Presences Awhile after the giving of the law, Moses spoke to the Father at Mount S ina i: Yll /n'e ll I E/yoll the Fath er) rep lied , 'My Prese nces [Hebrew plural Panim ], they will go [plural verb] with you, and I will give you rest.' Then Moses said to him [t 'lyon the Father]. ' Your Presences, if they [the Son and Spirit] do not go [plura l verb] with us [to the Promised Land] , do not se nd us up fro m here [Mount Sinai]' (Exo 33: 14-15).
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
88
Yael Na ta n
Many passages discussed in this chapter note ho w the Son and Spirit were sent as Presences 10 ca rry out so me divine purpose." Moses wanted the three members of the Trinit y to go to Canaan for a variety of reasons, the fo remo st reason being de fense (Psa 041\ :0 1-03: 132:13- 14. 18; ba ][:09; Jer 49:01-02: EI.e 35: 10; 36:05; Zec 112:( 5). Moses knew that the Son and Spiri t, the Presences of YiJl1l'ell (Ge n 19: 13, 27), had bee n se nt ( 0 Sod om. Moses knew tha t the) had raine d dow n sulfur from Yanl'f:h the Father in heave n (Gen 19 :24 is disc ussed above). Mose s also saw fir sthand ho w vahveh had brought Israel "OUI of Egypt by his Pre sence s and his grea t stre ngth" (Dell 04: 37: NU Ill 20: 16) . Moses spo ke of how the Prese nces would accom pany Israel into the Prom ised Land: The ete rnal God [the Father] is [Israel's) d welli ng-pla ce. unde rneath are the eve rlasting ar ms [the Son and Sp ir it]. He [the Father] will drive ou t the ene my fro m before you . saying Ito the Son and Spirit]. ' Destroy ! [the enemy]' (Deu 33:27). The Judges Deborah and Barak celebrated how. earlier during the Exodus. the r ather had directed the Son and Spirit to go with Israel toward the Promi sed Lund: o rahveh [the Trinity], when you [the Son ) went ou t from Se ir, when you [the Sp irit] marc hed fro m the land of Edom, the earth shook, the heavens poured, the clo uds poured down water. The mountains q uaked before Yahveh, the One of Sinai [the Father ]. before Yahveh, the E/ohim o f Israel [the Trinity] (ldg 05:04-05). David also wrote abo ut how the Son and Spirit helped con quer the Promised Land: It was not by their sword that they won the land, nor di d their ar m bring the m victory; it was you r right hand [the Son], your [the Fathe r's ) arm [the Spirit ], and the ligh t of you r [the Father's ] Presen ce s (the Son and Spirit], for you [the Fathe r] loved them. You-He (a fah·hu ] lthe Trini ty] are r uy King, 0 God . w ho decrees vic tories for Jaco b (P sa 04 4:03·04 fBHS 04 4 : 04-05[). Mose s wanted the Son and Spirit 10 tra vel to the Promi sed Lund (Exo 33: 14-15) . Mose s kne w that Yohl'l'h was God of both the Jews a nd ge ntiles. but Moses wa nted Yahveh the Son and Spirit 10 functi on as Israel's nation al God for the time being. Mo ses knew that most of Israel wou ld eve ntually fall into un belief (De u 3 1: 16·1 8) . If Yahl'eh the Son and Spirit look up residence in Ca naan, the Promi sed Land wou ld become Ya/ll'ell's land (los 22:19; Isa 14:02; Hos 09 :03). It is not hard to figure ou t ho w Moses got this idea s ince Mose s was at Mount S inai in the Wildern ess of Sin. The names Sin and Sinai likely refe r to Sin the moon god-as j udged from the ety mology and archeologica l ev idence. Mose s knew that if Yllhvell ' s Pre sen ces we re in Ca naa n, it would be harder for Yalll'ell to ab ando n Ytllll'eh's land and Ycl/ll'eh's temp le (Ez e 08 :06) . Th en all three persons rathe r tha n j ust one person of the Trini ty would need to rejec t lsraet if the occasion called for it, as Jeremi ah wrote:
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewish Trinity
89
The Word (the Son] of Ya lll'eh [the Father] came 10 Jeremiah. saying, ' Ha ve yo u [Je re mia h] not no ticed wha t t his people ha ve spo ke n? Spec ifically : 'The two kingdom s that Yahveh chose [Israel & Jud ah], he [Ytl/n'd l] has rejected them. and they [YtI" l'ch ] spurn my peopl e [Judah] so that the)' are no longer a nation before them [Yoh l'eh r 'Oer 33:24). Hosea wrote similarl y: As the y [the Trinity] ca lled [plural verb] the m [Is rael ), so they [the Trinity] went [plural verb) from them [Israe l] (Hos 11:(2 ). With Yahveh in the Promised Land, the separation of Yoh veh fro m Israel wou ld be like: • A divorce (Jer03:08), • Disowning a so n (Hos 11:(1 ), or • Traveling co mpanions parting ways (Amo 03 :02-(3). With Yllh"eh in res idence in Canaa n, it would he surrea l if Yahveh we re to become a stranger in his ow n la nd IJer 14:08-(9). It would be noticeable if Ytlh l'eh retreate d bac k 10 the Mou nt of [All] the Gods (lraF:lohim) (E xo 03:0 1; I Ki 19:08). Ya hveh' w last resort was abando nin g the te mple whe re his Name and Presences re sided (Bxo 25:30 ; 28: 30 ; I Ki 08 :29; 09:03; 2Ki 23 :27; Eze 08:(6 ). Yah l'eh preferred to el im inate (E zc 33 :24- 29) o r bani sh idolaters and ca ree r sin ners from his Presen ces,"' often by e xil ing them to o t her coumnes." In this regard, the prophe ts ta ug ht not hin g ne w. Th e prophets merely rem inded Israel of Yah,'eh' s me thods of dealing with fla gra nt sinners, a po lic y know n 10 Moses ( D eu 30:02-06 ) a nd to Solo mo n (2Ch 06 :24 -39). At first the Father was just plann ing to send the Ma lek with Ya h l'ell' s Name in him to Canaan with the Israelites (Exo 23:20-23). The Father called the Ma lek , "sah veh, your God" (Exo 23:19 ). The Father sa id. "T hree time s a year all your males shall appear before the Presence [the Son] of the Lord Yahveh [the Fathe r]" (Exo 23: 17: repeated in Deu 16:16; 3 1: II ). The Father said that the M alek was "my (the Fathe r's) Presence" ( YL T Exo 23: 15 ), T he Father a lso said : Be watchful because of his [the Son's) Presence [pilll ;m] (YLT Exo 23:21). The Ma lek se nt 10 the Prom ised Land is "the Ml dek , His [the Father 's] Presence [Panim 1" ( IS11 63:(9). So the Malek was the Father's Presence , yet the Ma lek had "his [own ] presence." That the Ma lek had his ow n presence mean s the Ma lek was no mere Shekillllh- the impe rsonal apparition posited hy rabbinic theologians. The early NT C hurch understood Ye.lhl/o to be Yahveh the Son and the Ma lek Yahl't'h with YahH'h's Name "in him" (Exo 23:2 1). Many mentions are made in the NT of " the Name of Yc.I'huiI." "" In Act 05 :40-4 1 the Name of Ye.lh/Ill is called "the Name" (see also 3Jo 0 1:07). Yf'.\'IlUl/ mean s, " YlIhl'ch saves" (Mat 0 1:21; ITi 0 1:15), so the name Yah veh is " in" the name Yeshua as well as "in" Yeshua. A para llel to the Mil /ek's heing se nt with the authority to retain sins (Exo 23:2 1) occ urred whe n Yeshua com missioned the ten disciples in fulfillment of his prom ise; '" will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven" (Mat 16:19). Ye.l'llua breathed
Matenal com direlbs
autcrars
90
Yae l Na tan
the Spirit o n the disc iples, and then sa id that they co uld forg ive or retain sins (Joh 20 :21-23), No tice thai the disci ples were only ab le to forgive o r reta in sins after they rece ived the Spint rhat proceeded from the Father through the Son. Note that it was the OT Maid Ya hveh who became the Messiah and then breathed o ut the Sp irit o n the disciples (Joh 20:21-13). Ultimately only God can forgive or retain sins (Mar 0 2 :07: Luk 05:2 1). The se facts lead \0 the concl usion that the Ma lek Yah I" '" was a perso n of the Trinity. Immediately after the golde n calf inc ident . the Fathe r said that he was still p lan n ing to se nd " m y Malek " to the P ro mi sed La nd ahe ad o f th e Israelite s (compare Exo 32:34 to Exo 23:23). A little later, ho wever, the Father dec ided to se nd 1I creatu re spirit -"an angel" (Exo 33 :02) . The golde n calf incident caused the Father to reconsider se nd ing the Malek with his name "in h im" - as had been planned (Exo 23:20 -23 ). The Father co ncl uded that if he traveled in the mids t of the Israeli tes, he might destro y the Israe lites (Ex o 33: 03 ). T hat the Father d id not want to " go in th e mids t" of Israel also e xplains why the Father d id not want to send his Pre sence . the Ma lek Yah veh ( YLT Exo 23: 15; Isa 6 3:09). The proxi mity to o pe n re bell ion wo uld cause the Malek Yah veh to refuse for giveness (Exo 23 :21; Heb 12: 17 ). The Israelites mo urned ov er the ne ws that t he Father was plan n ing to send a me re angel (Ex o 33:04 ). T hat the Israeli te s mo urned con firms th at the Father de ci ded to se nd a me re spir it c reature {Exo 33 :02) rather th an the div ine " my Malek ," the Malek Ya/weh (Exo 23:20 -23; 32 :34). Another co nfirm ation that the Father was plann ing to se nd " an angel" rather tha n the Ma lek Yah veh is Moses sa id : You have not let me know whom yo u will send with me (Exo 33 : 12). Appare ntly, the l-ather had no t mentioned whether the spirit c reature no w tasked w ith go ing to Canaan would be Mich ael. Gabrie l. or another ange l. There were development s th at c hanged the un fortunate situat io n in which the Israeli tes fou nd them sel ves. The plagues (E xo 32 :35) that resulted fro m the golde n calf in cident we re no t indisc ri mi nate. but affec ted tho se who had e ngaged in "pagan revel ry" (Exo 32 :06; ICo 10 :07 ). Pagan worsh ip often invo lved org ies and othe r behaviors that sociolog ists term "h igh risk beh aviors ." T he d anger, o f course, is the spread o f S·ITIs (Se xually Tran smiued Disease s). That plagues mainly affec ted gross sinners ca n be see n from Num 25 :05- 18 and ot her passages." After the plagues took thei r toll on the hardened sinners, Yahl'el1' s Presence could aga in go with the survivors wi tho ut inflict ing further j udg ment o n the nation as a whole (Exo 33 :0 3-05; Jer 3 1:02; Eze 20 : 18). The Israeli tes who were spared either did not participate in the sin, or had mourned ov er the golden calf incident and were forg ive n (Exo 33 :04) . After the hard hearted were gone and the sur vivors were forgive n, the Fat her said . " My Presences, they w ill go" to C anaa n (Exo 33: 14 ). T he plura l verb " they w ill go " indicates that Panim sho uld be tra nslated in the plural as " Presences," mcaning the Son and Spirit. Before the golde n ca lf inc ide nt. the Father was ju st Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
91
pla nning to se nd Ihe Son, bUI no w the Father was planning 10 send both the Son an d Spiru. Th is is de finitely a n insta nce of grace abo unding more than s in: The law was added so thai the offe nse migh t increase. Bu t whe re s in abou nded , grace increa sed all the more. (Ro m 05 :20) , Mose s liked Ihe Father's idea o f sending both the Son and Sp ir it so much that Mo ses asked the Father not to reconside r this decision (Exo 33:15) . Moses then as ked the Fathe r 10 go to Ca naan wi th the Israeli te s eve n Ihough the Father earl ier had said: I will not go with yo u. because yo u are a stiff-necked peo ple and migh t de stroy you on the way (Exo 34:03 J. Later in the conversation. Moses said : Ye t. how wo uld an yone know that I have found favor in yo ur sight, I an d you r people. unless yo u [the Fath er) go with us, so that we are dist inguished. I and yo ur people, from all Ihe peopl e who arc o n the surface of the eart h'! (Exo 33:16). Moses here argued that the Fathe r's not traveling In the Promised Land wou ld [eave the wrong imp ression-that the Father was still too ang ry 10 be amon g the Israel ites ( Exo 33:05). Mose s and Aaro n had a hard enough t ime holdi ng sway ove r the Israeli te s. Mo ses did not want the Israelit es to think Israel or its leaders were o ut of favo r with Yah reh the Fathe r. Th ey had already rebelled once when they doubted ranveh was with them : And he [Moses] called the place Ma ssah and Meribah because the Israelites qu arre led and becau se they te sted Ytlh l'eh saying. ' Is Yahveh amo ng us or not'?' (Ex o 17:07). The Fathe r's send ing the So n and the Sp irit would parallel how the Fathe r se nt the Son and the Spirit d uring NT ti mes (Isa II :02: 4 2:0 I; 48: 16; Luk 04 :18- 19; l oll 03:3 4). The NT Jews d id not recognize that the Messiah had the Father 's favo r (Psa 022:08 ; Mat 27;43), thoug h the Father voiced fro m he aven that he was pleased with the Son (Mat 03:17; 17:05 : Mar 01: 11: Luk 03 :22; Joh 12:28; 2 Pe 0 1:17 ). So Mo ses was wise in a skin g thai the Father co me to Palest ine, too (E xo 33:16). Moses was not onl y concerned abou t t he Fathe r go ing to the Promi sed Land because o f ho w the Israelit es might act, b ut also o n account of the ge ntiles. The Israe lites had beco me a laughingstoc k to their ene mies on account of the golde n calf incid ent (Exo 32:25). The ge ntiles co uld sense a people 's weakness when that people did not have a good rela tions hip with their grM:1(s) (Num 21:29: Deu 32:27; 2Ch 28:23: 32: 15- 16; Psa 042: 10; 079: 10; 11 5:0 2; l oe 0 2: 17b). Withou t the Father go ing 10 Ca naan, Israel's enemies would not be ab le to d iscern (Isa 10;09 -11; 36: 18-20; Jer 50:07; Eze 25:08 ) that Israel was the apple (pupil) o f the Father's eye ( Deu 32: 10; Zec 0 2:08). O ne of the words for pupil in the O T is 'ivshnwn, me aning. "the little man" (Dcu 32:10; Psa 0 17:08 ). If one loo ks real close al the pupil, onc sees a reflection of one's self. That Israel was the "little man" reflec ted in Yu/n'eh's eyes me ant the Fa ther was lookin g at Israel , bless ing and be ing grac ious to ward and giv ing Malenal com direlbs
autcrars
92
Yael Na tan
Israel peace (Nurn 06: 25-26). Any believ er who has the Aaronic Ble ssing named over them similarly becomes the apple o f the Father 's eye. Moreo ver, a clo se relationsh ip between Yahveh and Israel is implied. On e o nly gels so clo se so as to see the reflection in ano ther 's eye when there is an intimate , personal. affect ionate relation ship. Based o n his ex perie nce in Egypt. Mose s k new that God hel ped nation s in ord inary ways (Psa 145:09 ; Amo 09 :07 ; Mat 05:45: Act 14: 17; 17:27). Moses th ere fore wa nted the Father 10 he lp Israel in an e xtrao rd ina ry way. Mose s con vinced the Fat her 10 go to the Promi sed Land so that the nations wou ld see that the Father favored Israel e nough to dwell with Israel (Exo 19:05-06; Deu 10:1 5; 23: 14; 26: 19; 28:0 I; Hos II :08 ; MalO) : 14- 18). The Father told Moses: I will do a lso this thing that you ha ve spoken [acco mpany Isr ael to the Promi sed Land (Exo 33: 16)J: for yo u ha ve found fa vor in my sight. and I know yo u by name (1-::1:0 33: 17). Tha i the Father we nt to the Promi sed Land was how Jeremiah co uld say that Israellived under the shado w of Yahw h (Lam 04:20). Bec ause of the golden calf incident. the cove nants between Yahveh and Israel had 10 he fonnall y reinstated . The cove nants had bee n annulled whe n Yah veh was abo ut to de stroy Israel. Yahveh co nsidered fult1l1ing his prom ises to the patriarchs thm ugh a nat ion pop ulated by Mo ses' own descendants: Le ave rnc alone now so my ange r ma y burn aga inst them 10 destroy them . The n I will make yo u into a great nation (Exo 32: 10: De u 09: 25 -26). Mose s. how eve r. co nvinced Yahveh to reconsider Ihis course of action. and the n to renew the cove nants. Israel had a co venantal re lationsh ip with the Father that was first es tablished in Gen IS, and a covenantal relanonvhip with the So n that was fir st es tablished in Gen 17. Yanveh the Son referred to his Gen 17 covenant when he sa id: I also established my cove nant with the patriarchs (Exo 116:( 4 ). Yalll'eh invited Moses back up the mountain the ne xt da y to see Ytlh w:h's glory (Exo 34: 0 1-(3). Pre viously, Yahveh was invisible and his presence was kno wn on ly from a voic e, so metimes accompan ied by fire or so me other phenomenon (Deu 04: 12.1 5 ). After Moses saw Yalll'ch's g lo ry, Israel wo uld see Mose s' face glowing with Yohl' eh 's glory. T he n they wou ld know with cert aint y that Israel was once aga in in God 's good graces . The y wo uld a lso kno w the cove nants had been renewed. and Yahreh wo uld again be go ing 10 Pale stine with Israel . The next day the Father stood near to Moses in a nimbus cloud (Exo 34:(15). The Father proclaimed his Name. Yahl'eh - ju sl as he said he would (E xo 33: 19; 34:(15). Th e cl oud was the Spir u who served as a co ver ing " hand" that shielded Moses from see ing the Father's own fac e (Bxo 33:22-23). The Sp irit some times appeared a s a cloud. For instance , as was noted abov e, Barak and Deborah described the Spirn se nt in Exo 33 :1 4- 15 as a clo ud (Jdg 05: 04 -(15). Also, the Trin itar ian proofs appe ndix d isc usses ho w the Sp irit was the pil1arof clo ud in Exo 14:1 9-24.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
93
Acco rding to Pau l, the nimbus cloud at Sinai in Exo 34 e mitted the Sp irit's glory. Paul wrote that the Spirit is the glnry of the Lord that shines on our faces just as the Spirit's light shone on Moses: But we a ll, with unveiled face behold the glory of the Lord. and are trans formed into the sa me image with eve r-incre asing glory that comes from the Lord. the Spirit (2Co 03: 18). Paul mentions Moses and the veil that covered his glowing face starting in lCo 03: 13. so lCo 03: 18 surely alludes to Moses' Mount Sinai experience (Exo 34:33-35). After the rather descended in the nimbus cloud of the Spirit and proclaimed his name (Exo 34:05), YlIheh the So n passed by and procla imed the Name. YlIhreh ( Exo 34:(6). The actio ns of the Fathe r and Son distingu ish the Father and Sonthe Father stood a nd proclaimed while the Son passed by Moses. The wording also revea ls that the subjec t of Exo 34:05 is the Father. while the subjec t of Bxo 34:06 is the Son. The prev ious day the Father said that he wou ld say: I will be grac ious In whom I will be grac ious, and will show mercy to whom I wiII show mercy (Exo 33:19). The Father's stateme nt is in the first person ("I "), while the Son talked of t he Father in the third person ("he"): Yahveh [the Son ) passed in front of Moses, proclai ming, •Yahveh [the Parhcr ]. Yahve h, the compass ionate and gracious God ... Yet he ... he .. . ' (Ew 34:06-07). T he Parher spoke from within a bright nimbus cloud. but the So n showed his face. How the So n appeared in Exo 34 can be asce rtained fro m Eze kiel's So n of Man vision and the Transfiguration accounts. During the Transfiguration. t he Messiah appeared to be as brig ht as the sun (Mat 17:0 2) and his clo thes were as bright as lightning (Luk 09 :29). Ezekiel described the Son of Man: .. .o n the likeness of the throne was a likeness as the appearance of a man. I saw that from what appeared to he his waist lip he looked like glowing metal, as if full of fire, and that from there down he looked like tire, and there was brightness round about him. As the appearance of the bow that is in the cloud in the day of rain. so was the appearance of the brightness round abou t. Thi s was the appearance of the likeness [the Son] of the glory of Y ahveh [the Father] (Eze 0 I:26-28). Even though YeI/llla is now incarnate, Paul wrote that he stilI shows the "glory of God": Even if o ur gospe l is veiled, it is veiled in those who peris h: in whom the god of this world has blinded the minds of the unbelieving, that the light of the gospe l of the glory of Christ, who is the image of God, should not dawn on them . Fo r we do not preach ourselves, but C hrist Ye.~hlla as Lord. a nd ourselves as your servants for YeS/lilli'S sa ke; seeing it is God who said, 'Light wiI1 shine out of darkness,' who has sho ne in our hearts , to give the light of the knowledge of the glory of God in the face of Christ (lCo 04:03-06 ). Matenal com direlbs autcrars
94
Yae l Na tan
Scriptural para llels 10 Moses' e xperience on the moun! {Exo 33 -34) include how the Father spoke to Elijah in a "wh ispe r of a gen tle breeze" (LXX I Ki 19:12; compare Oen 0 3:08. 10; loh 0 3:0R). Just as the nimbus clo ud was the Spirit (Exn 34:05 ), the breeze was the Spirit (LXX lKi 19:12 ). Just as Mose s was protected in the cle ft of a rock on Mo unl Sin ai. Elijah was protected in 11 l:lIVC entra nce o n M o unt Sinai .
Ano ther para llel to Hxo 33 -34 occu rred at the T ransfig uration. T hen: the Father spoke to the disci ples from within a bright nimb us clo ud thai was the Spirit (M at 17:05 ). The Transfiguration and 1Ki 19 arc di scussed late r in this chapter. After Yahveh the Son ap peared to Moses on Mount Sinai (Exo 34:06 ). Moses made this req ue st of the Son: If now I have fou nd favor in yo ur sight, Lord, please let the Lord [the So n) go in the mid st of us la s a Presence ), al tho ugh it is a stiff-nec ked peop le; and pa rdo n o ur iniqui ty and our sin, and take us for thy inheri tance (Exo 34:09 ). That the Prom ised Land was Yahl'eh's "inheritance" is another ind ication that Mo ses here talked to Yu llreh the So n. Moses said elsew he re that Yohvrh the Son had rece ived Israel as an inheri ta nce from Etvon. the Father (Den 32:08-09 ). The r athe r can receive an inheritance fro m ne ither h imse lf nor his SOil. but the So n can rec eive an inheritance fro m the Fathe r. O the r indicators that t he di vine pe rso n to whom Moses spoke in EMI 34 was t he Son are : • Mose s already had the Father's favo r. and • The Father had already agreed to go to C anaan (Exo 33:12, 16-17). Mose s was not askin g the Father a seco nd time for something the Fath er had a lready gra nted . Rathe r, Moses requested the Son's favo r, and that the So n rene w his Ge n 17 covenant. O ut o f courtesy Moses asked the So n to agree to go to t he Pro mised Land as a Presence (Bxo 34 :09 ). The So n wo uld nat urally ag ree to do this last favor. since the Father had alread y ag reed to send the Son and Spirit (Exo 34: 14-15). In re spon se 10 Mo se s' request , Yeh veh the Son made a c o ve nant to go to Ca naan. Pre vio usly, the Father had stated what his intennedi ary, the Ma lek wit h Yahreh 's Na me , wo uld do ( Exo 23 :20-33). No w, ho we ver, the inter medi ary himself, the M o tel: with Yah n ,II 's Na me, stated what he wo uld do in Ca naa n (EJw 34: 10- 26 ). Th ai the Mu lek Yahveh TOughl y restate d in Exo 34:10- 16 wha t the Father had promised the Ma/ek would do in Exo 23:20-33 c an be see n fro m the s imilar clements in each sect ion: • A command to appear before Yuhl'ell the Son three time s a year (Exo 23: 14, 17: 34:23-24), • A proh ibition aga inst coo king a goat in its mother's milk (E xo 23:19; 34:26), • A co mmand to smash sacred sto nes (ido ls and be ryls) (E xn 23:24: 34: U ), and • A prom ise that Yahveh the So n wou ld drive out Ca naani te tribes suc h as the Penzztte s (Exo 23:23; 34: I I).
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewish Trinity
95
Tha i both Exo 23 and 34 were all about what the Malek Ya hreh wo uld do is con firmed hy seve ral facts. The promises in Exo 23 and 34 co inc ide with the covenant thnt the Son , £ 1 Sh adllai, made in Gen 17. £ 1 Shaddai, who was the Mo ld Yo hve h (E xo 0 3:02 ; 06:03 ), re ferred to his Gen 17 cove nant when he said: 1 also es tablis hed my cove nant with the patriarchs (E xo 06:04). The Ma lek. Yahveh was involved with the co nquest of the Prom ised Land (Jos 05:13-06:(8). Conque ring Palestine was cond ucted in fulfillmenl of what the So n sa id he would do (Ge n 17; Exo 34) and what Ihe Father sa id the Malek Yllhrt'h would do [Exo 23). The Malek. Yahreh e ven me ntioned his Gen 17 cove nant with the patriarchs, the covenant that was renewed in Exo 23 and 34: The Malek Yah veh went up from Gilgal to Bukim and said, ' I bro ugh t you up o ut of Egypt and led you into the la nd that 1 swore to give to your forefathers [Gen 17].' I said, 'I will ne ver break my [Exo 34 ) co venant with you, and you shall no t make a co ven ant with the peop le of this land, but you shall break down the ir altars [ Exo 34 : I3 J.' Yet you have disobeyed me, Why have you do ne this?' (Jdg 02:01 -02). The Malek Ya hreh sa id that Israel fa iled 10 break down the pagan altars (Jdg 0 2:02). The only covenant in which this was a provision was the Exo 34 covenant between the Son and Israel (E xo 34: 13). Therefore , the Malek Yahveh claimed the Exo 34 co venant was his (Jd g 0 2:02), and this mean s the Ma lek. Yahveh is the Yahwh of Exo 34 :06-29. Mo .\·/.'.\·' Encounte rs with the Presences at the Hoeki' That Hrno ght Forth Watcr O r en'if'lI'
Muse s' other e nco unters with the Presences include the times Mose s struc k rock s that then prod uced a flow of water. One rock was at a place near Sinai c alled Mussah and Meribah (Bxo 17 :( 7). The other ruck was at a place called Meribah Kade sh in the Desert of Zin (Num 27: 14 ). Yah veh stoo d hy the roc k at Mou nt Sinai to show Israelthat Ya lll,/.' h was prese nt in Israel desp ite the ir previous doubts: Ya lll'f,h a nswered Moses, 'Wa lk o n ahead of the people , Take with yo u some of the elders of Israel and take in yo ur hand the staff with which yo u struck the Nile. and go. I will sta nd there before you by the rock at Horeb. Strike the rock, and water will come o ut of it for the people to drink.' So Mose s did this in the sight of the elde rs of Israel. And he called the place Massah and Mer ibah becau se the Israe lites quarreled and becau se rbey tested Yahveh saying, ' Is Yahveh among us or not?' (Exo 17:115-(7). At Mounl Sinai Moses struck the watering rock once (Exu 17 :{)fi), perhaps to indicate that there was one spiritual Presence at the rock: . .. our forefathers were a ll under the clo ud and they all passed through the sea. They were all baptized into Mose s in the cloud and in the se a. They a ll ate the same spiritua l food and drank the same spiritua l drink;
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
96
Yae l Na tan
for they drank from the supe rnatural roc k thai acco mpan ied the m, and that roc k was Christ ( ICo 10 :0 1-04). T hat th e "supc muturul rock . ..accom panied th em " suggests tha t Chr ist was Pre sent both at the rock at Sin ai (Ex:o 17) and at the rock at Kadesh (N um 20 ). David assoc iated the Spirit w ith the rock at Kadesh inci dent: By the waters of Me ribah they angered Yahve h, and tro uble came ( 0 Moses bec ause of them ; for they rebe lled ag ainst the Spirit of God, and rash words came from Moses' lips (Psa 106: 32-33). Da vid also wrote : Tre mble, you earth, at the Prese nce [the Sp irit ] of the Lord (the rathe r]. at the Pre sence [the Son] ofthe God [the Father ] o f Jacob. w ho turned the rock into a pool of water, the Flint into a spring of waters (Psa 114:07.( 8). Co mparing what David and Paul wrote , there see ms to have been two Pre sences at the rock at Kadcsn Prev iously, Mo ses struck the rock at Sina i once - perh aps to indicate that one Pre sence stood by the rock . namely. Ch rist (Exo 17:06; ICo 10:
04 ' . At the roc k of Kudcsh, however. Mose s left the Prese nces (Pallim) of Yahreh. and then returned and struck " that rock" tw ice (Num 20 :07-(9). Also, it is interes ting that the roc k at Kad esh is called " the rock" and Pau l refers 10 C hrist as "the rock" (Num 20:0 8, 10- 11; ICo 10 :04). The two knoc ks see ms to indicate th at the two Presence s mention ed in Exo 33:1 4- 15. the Son and Spirit. were bo th at the rock at Kade sh . At the ro ck o f Kad esh. Yo hvch sa id that Mo se s fa iled to keep rah veh hol y before the peo ple (N um 20: 12 ; Dcu 32:51). T he basic mean ing of " holy" is " to se parate" or to " set apart," So it see ms Moses failed to keep Yahveh " ho ly" by' al[o wing the Israeli tes to make an unaut horized near appro ach to the Presen ce s of Yilhw;,h. B ringin g the e lders of Israel close to Yah veh wa s nOI a co nce rn, but the rebe ls we re : Mo ses and Aaron gathered the assembly to gether in trent of the rock and Mo ses sa id to them . ' Listen, you re bel s, must we bring you water OUi o f thi s roc k'?' (Nu m 20: 10). So Mose s' "rash words " (Ps u 106:3 2-33) were his anno unc ing before Yohveh that some o f th e Israelites we re re be ls . II is one th ing to bri ng peo ple be fore Yahveh, bur it is another thing to decl are them rebe ls eve n if it were true . This decl aration unnece ssa rily rai sed matters of co nscience tlCo 10:25-29 ). Moreo ver, call ing pe ople " re be ls" while the y a re stand ing r ight in front of Yahveh is tant amount 10 calling down judgment before thc rebels' ti me of grace had exp ired (Exo 33 :03). Mose s' rash words were similar to the ra sh words Ye,I'/llla warned agai nst-even if the words could be construed as being true : Anyone who says, ' You foo l!' will be in da nger of the fire of hell (M al 05:22), Yeshua 's words are es pec ially poi gnan t conside ring ho w God calle d the rich ma n who ente rtained Epicu rean thoughts a "fool" :
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
97
The Jewish Trinity Fool ! T his n ight yo ur so ul is required of yo u; the thin gs yo u ha ve prep ared . whose wil l the y be'! (Luk 12;20 ).
A More Dellliled Look Let us. howe ver. tak e a clo ser look at the accounts of Ihe rocks at Ma ssuhMeribah (Exo 17:07 ). and Menbah-K adesh (Num 20). When Israel was in Kadesh. the " glnry of Yahveh" appeared (Num 20:(6). Th e '"glory" is likel y a reference to the Son (ICo 10:04). Yah reh to ld Mo ses 10 gather the people logether and then brin g water out o f "that rock" "before their eyes" (NIV Num 20:0 7-(19). Mos es then too k a staff from Yahl'eh's Prese nce s (Num 20:09), and gathe red Israel to the face (pan;m ) of " tha t" ce rta in rock (Num 20: 10 ). Yalw eh, how e ver. d id not le ll Mo se s to bring the people up to the rock face (panim). vah veh just told Mo ses to bring Israel "w ithin sigh t" of the rock , litera lly " befo re their ey e s" (Num 20 :0R ). "Within sig hl" co uld have mean t a hundred meters or more , not right up to the rock face. Pre viously, the people viewed eve nts fro m "th e foo l o f the moun tain" (E xo 19:1 7 ), and " the people stood at a dist ance " (Exo 20:21). Since the people we re at the rock face (pan im ), th is mean t the people we re in the presence (panim) o f Yohvrh stand ing there (N Ull 20: 10; Deu 32:5 1). No one was suppos ed to com e nca r Yalwell unl ess Yalw eh aut ho rized an ap proach (Exo 19: 12- 13, 21 -25; 24:0 1-02; Lev 10:01-03). Yah vch then told Mo ses that he had fa iled to keep vahveh ho ly be fore the people (Num 20 : 12; De u 325 1). The basic me ani ng of "holy" is " to se parate" or to "set apart." So Mose s fai led to keep Yahveh " ho ly" by allowi ng the Israelites. especiall y the "rebels," to ma ke an unauthorized ncar approac h to Yanven. Also. there is no ment ion of anyo ne removin g his or her sanda ls in rec ogn ition of the hol y pre sence of Yohveh (Exo 0 3: 0 5 ; los 05 : 15). Previ ou sly, the people were always kept separate, and on ly Moses, Aaron , the priests and sometimes elders were allowed to approach roh veh (E xo 19:12 -13,2 125 ; 34:03) . Those few who d id approach Ya hveh remo ved the ir sandals (Bxo 03 : 0 5 ; los 0 5: 15). For insta nce , the first time water gushed from a rock at Sina i, on ly Mo ses and the elde rs we re in Y{/ h ~'eh' s presen ce (pul1 im) (Exo 17:06). Th e people we re nOI in Yahveh's pre sence , since Mo ses and so me elders had wa lked ahead of the people to the rock (Bxo 17:0 5). At Kadcsh, howe ve r, even the assembly came to the face (panim) of the rock were Yaln'eh was standing (Num 20: 10 ). [t is true that Moses also failed to ho no r Yohveh b)' spea king rash words to the reb e llious Israelites in Ya hl'ch's presence (P sa 10 6:32-33). Deu 32:5 1 does see m to mention that Mo ses d id two things wron g at the Kade sh rock : Thi s is becau se [ I] bot h of you brok e fa ith w ith me in the presence of the Israelites at the waters of Me ribah Kadesh in the Wilderness of Zin, and bec ause 121 yo u did not up hold my hol iness [separatene ss] among the Israelites (Deu 32:5 1). Mose s, how e ve r, later said it was the Israel ites ' fa ult that he was no t ahle to enler the Promised Land (Deu 0 1:37; 0 3:26). So me ha ve said th is was bec ause, instead of speak ing to the rock , Mo ses struc k the rock with his sta ff. Yah veh sa id Matenal com direlbs autcrars
98
Yael Na tan
that both Moses and Aaro n committed thai same sin (Num 27:12- 14: De u 32:5052). It wo uld see m hard to believe that Aa ron or any of the peo ple ca used Moses to strike the roc k twice rather than speak to it. T he o nl y sing le s in thai Mo se s. Aaron an d the people co m mitted was no t keep ing the peo ple separate from Yahre h. It seems that allow ing the peo ple to approac h Yohvcb without authorization was the o nly sin that Mose s and Aaron committed tha t wax ser io us enough to : •
Ot he rwise be a stoning offense (Exo 19: 12-1 3. 22 ; 24 :02; Num 16 : 17), and
•
Kee p Mo ses and Aaro n out of the Prom ised Land {Num 20:12, 24: Dell 32:5 152). Exe getes may posit or ded uce ma ny things about Sc ripture. but this doe s not chan ge Script ure. Sc ripture docs nol e xplicit ly state that Moses was in t ro uble with Yohveh over striking the rock twice rather than speak ing to it. The same cou ld be said for Mose s' rash words . In fact, Yahw'h \ g iving Moses a sta ff at Kadexh suggests that Moses was supposed to strike the rock at Kadesh. Striking the reck at Kadesh wo uld bc con sistent wit h Yahrch 's command to strike the rock at MO Un! S inai (Nu m 20:08 ; co mpare Exo 17:06). So it wo uld see m that the s in that kep t Moses and Aaron o ut of the Prom ised Land was the fail ure to kee p the Israe lites sepa rate from Yahreh' s Presenc es . Elijah and the Presences on the Mount of [All) the Gods The account of Elijah confron ting the prophets of Baa l and As hto rah at Mo unt Ca rmel co ntains several Trinitarian ele me nts. The Word of vah veh (I Ki 18:0 I. 3 1) and the Spirit ( IKi 18:12 ) are me ntioned. The Israel ites seem to have all uded to the Wo rd and Spirit whe n the y sa id: Yalwell- he [the Son] is God ! Yllln'('/l- he [the Spirit) is God ( I Ki 18:39)! In the next ch apter, Elijah we nt to Mou nt Horeb . oth erwise called Mo unt Sinai an d the " Mo unt of [All] the Gods" (haElohim) (I Ki 19:08; also Exo 03:01 ; 04:27; 18:0 5 ; 24:13; 2Ki 04 :25). Thc form HaElohim refers to the Trinity, as was d iscussed in the c hapter on Hebre w coll ective nouns. Elijah went to the Mo unt of [Ali i the God s at the invitation of the Malek Yah veh (I K i 19:05-08). Pre viously, the Trinity issued invitations for visi ts on hills and mo unta ins. v ah veh e ven had a rep utation amon g the pagan s for he ing a god of the hills (l Ki 20: 28). Exa mple o f Yahreh's Trinitar ian invitations to mo untai ns includ e: • " [AIlI the G ods" invited Ab rah am to Mount Moriah by (Ocn 22:03, 09) where he met the Malek Ya llreh (Ge n 22:0 2-03, 09. 11-12). T he Malek vahveh also quo ted the Father (Gen 22:16 ). • Jacob mel " [All) the G ods" al Bethel (Gc n 3 1: II , 13; 35 :07). Jacob we nt back to Bethel at the invitauon o f the Father (Ge n 35:(1) where he met El Shaddai, the So n (Ge n 35: I I). Bethel was know n as hill country (Oen 12:08 : lo s 16:0 I; ISa 13:0 2),
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewish Trinity
99
•
Mose s was drawn to the " Mount of [All] the Gods" (Exo 0 3:01 ) by the spectacle of the burni ng bush. Moses ret urned to the " Mo unt of [All] the God s" at the invitation (Ex o 03:12 ) o f the Malek Yohvch (Exu 0 3:02 ; Act 07 :30. 35). During the Exod us, Mose s was invited up the mountain often, for instance, Exo 34:0 2. There Moses met "[ All ) the God s" (Exo 03:06, I I , 12, 13: 18: 12: 19 :03 . 17: 20: 20,2 1:24: I I), and • Aaro n was invited to meet Moses at the " Mount of [All ) the God s" (Exo 04:27). The Malek Yahveh invited Elijah to Mount S inai, and aided Elijah 's trip there (IKi 19:0 5. 0 7). The narrator referred to this Malek Yal/ reh as the Word of Yllhrt 'h (1K i 19:( 9) and as Yoh veh (IKi 19:11). The Word o f Yah re h to ld Elijah to stand before the Presence o f Ya hveh (the Son ) at the mouth of the cave. beca use Ya hl'eh the Father was abo ut to " pass by" ( IKi 19: I I). A wind . an ea rthq uake and a fi re pas sed "before the Pre sence [the Son] of Yahreh (the Father)" (I Ki 19: I I ). Yah l'eh the Fat her. howe ver. was not in the wind. the e art hq uake nor the fire ( I Ki 19 :11 - 12). The n Ya h ~'eh the Fathe r spo ke in a whispe r ( IKi 19:12- 13). T he LXX has " the vo ice of a gentle bree ze" (LXE I Ki 19: 12 ). The whisper was the Fathe r, while the breeze was the Spirit. This is similar to how ea rlier in Exo 34 the Father was in the cloud o f the Spir it. The Hebrew word Ruach mea ns "Spmt." " breeze" or " wind." T he Sp ir it is els ewhe re com pared to the wind (Joh 0 3:01'0. T he statement that "th e Sp ir it of God moved ov er the water" (Ge n 01 :02 ) suggests a breeze. "The vo ice of a gentle breeze" would e xpla in how the Fat her 's whisper co uld " pass by" ( I Ki 19 :11 ). That the whisper was in a breeze explai ns wh y EI ijah proce eded to the mo uth of the cave upo n hea ring the wh isper ( I Ki 19: 13). Elijah had retrea ted into the safet y of the c ave to avoi d the wind. the fire, and the tu mbling rocks d islod ged by the earthquake (IKi 19: 11 -1 2). Tha t the Fathe r would spe ak from within a breez e is not un usua l since: • Yahveh spoke from within a bush (Exo 03:02, 04 ), • Yah veh spok e fro m within clouds (Exo 16:10 : 24:16: 34:05: 40:38: Lev 16:2: Num 11:25:Deu OI :33: Mat 17:05). • The Father's voice once eve n so unded like thunder (Joh 12:28-30 ), and • Yah rch apparently also appea red in a ge nt le bree ze in the Ga rden of Eden. " In the cool of the da y" likely refe rs to the cooli ng breezes that occ ur aro und sunse t: The y [Adam and Eve ] heard the sou nd of Yahl'eh God walk ing in the garde n in the cool o f the day, and the man and his wife hill them sel ves fro m the presences of v ah veh (Fathe r] God [So n] a mong the trees of the garden (Ge n 03 :( 8) . Note that Adam and Eve hid among the trees upon hea ring God in the breeze . Likewise , Elijah pulled his cloak o ve r his face (IKi 19: 13) upon he aring " the vo ice of a gent le breeze" (LXE I K i 19: 12). So it would see m that the LXX tra nslation of " the voice of a gent le bree ze" likely refl ects the or iginal Hebre w text. T he Son being the Word. and the Fathe r Matenal com direlbs autcrars
100
Yael Na ta n
be ing the w hisper in the breeze of the Spirit. makes IKi 19 a thorou ghly Tri nitarian cha pter. i K i 19 will be discussed aga in later in this chapter. Thai the Father mel E lij ah last fits the story line. Elijah left Isra el to meet the Trinity o n the Mou nt o f [Alii the Gods. Sinai. Israel's prob lems cou ld o nly he so lved by foreig n intervention. The Son was Ihe nalio nal God of Israel, while the Father ruled all the nations. as is discussed in chapter un the Song of Moses. The " athe r told Elijah to anoin t Hazael king liver Arum. and Jehu son o f Nimshi king ove r Israel. They we re to dea l wit h God 's enem ies in Israel (I Ki 19: 15- 17). The P revencrs in Jill" Temple
Scripture ofte n ment ions the Presences in the tem ple (I Sa 0 I:22: 02: 17, 18: 26: 20; 2Sa 2 UlI : IKi 13:06; 2 Ki I J:(M; 2C h 33: 12; Joh 0 I: 12; 02 :07; Jer 26:19; Zec 07 :02 : 08:21, 22). Ezekie l me ntioned the two Presences in the tem ple ex tensively. Eze kie l referred 10 the Son as "the G lory," and to the Spirit as "t he man." The narrator referre d to " the man" as Yahveh (Ezc 44:02, 0 5), and "the man" refers to the Glory (Eze 43:0 1) as Yahl'eh (E ze 44:02). So one ca n ded uce thai the two Presences in the temple are the Son and Sp irit. Ezek iel is di scussed further in the chapter o n the Va rious Presentatio ns of the Trini ty. The Name , Ylilw/'h, was horne h)' his Presences (l'anim) in the tem ple (2Ch 20: 0 9; see also Deu 14:23; 18:07; IKi 08:29; 09 :03; 2Ki 23:27 ; Jer 0 7;]() ; 34: 15). The M alek with Yilhw;,h's Name in him wa s one of God's Presences who bore the Name, Yahveh, in the te mple (Exo 13:2 1; Exo 34:20; Luk 13:35). The Father sa id: Put the bread of the Pre sence s o n the ta ble to be before my Pre sence s IP tmim l at a ll times (Exn ')5:30). So it see ms the Son and Spirit were associ ated with the Bread of the Presences. Yah veh sat betwee n the wings of the cher ubim [Ex o 25:2 2; Lev 16:02; Num 07 : 89; ISa 04 :04; 2Sa 06 :02; 2K i 19:1 5; ICh 13:06; Psa 080:01; 0 99:01 ; Isa 37: 16) of the " Ark of [A ll] the Gods" thaI was placed in the " House of [A ll] the Gods." The name "IA II I the God s" (ha Elohim) implies that mem be rs of the Trinity were associa ted with the Ark and the Temple. T he Heb rew collective nouns c hapter d isc usses the: • Thirt y-fi ve me ntio ns of the "Ark of [All] the Gods," and • Fifty-five ment ions nf the "House of IAII I the Go ds." Eve n before the tem ple was built , David we nt before the Prese nces of YlIhl'eh (2Sa 07: 18; ICh 16:0 1; 17: 16) in the ta bernacle that con tained the Ark of [All] the Gods (2Sa 06:1 6-17), T he Spirit in the form of a d our.! o f glory was associated with the: • Ark (Lev 16:02). • Tabernacle (Exo 40:34-38; NU Ill 09 :15-22; 10: II ), and • Solo mon's temple (I Ki 8: 10- 12; 2C h 5: 13-14). Luke wrote co ncern ing Isa 06 that Isaiah ta lked to the Spirit in the te mple (Act 28:25-26: Isa 06:08- 13). The Spirit was sometimes associated with a clo ud, as was d iscussed abo ve concerning Exo 34:05. Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
101
The SOil was also present in the te mple. The Apostle Jo hn wrote co ncerning the Isa 06 te mple vis ion that lsaiah saw and spoke "ahuut" the glo ry of YCShUlI (1 nh 12: 41). The Apostle Paul also knew the So n was an O'T Presence or Face of Yahreh . Paul wrote that }('I'/wa is the "i mage of God," and that the light of the knowledge of the glory of God shows in the face of Yesh ua (2Co U4:04-06 : com pare 2 Co 03: 14- 18 and Rev 0 1:16). The Presences of Elyon in the te mple were the Son and Spi rit, and they allowed the Fathe r to speak as thou gh he we re es pecially present in the temple ( IKi U9:U3; I I:36: Jer 07 :10: 34: 15; EI.e 44:15 and Hag 0 2:14). T hat the Presences dwelt in the templ e is how the Father: • Could he present in heave n (Dan 07:13: Psa 011 :04 ), and • Hear from hea ven (2Ch 07; 14b). while his Faces (2C h 07 :1 4a ) and his eyes, ears and heart were present at the temple ( IKi 09:03 ; 2Ch 07: 15-16 ). Stephen taught that the Fathc r dwe lt in heaven rather than the te mple: The Most High [E1.w lI] doc s not live in houses made by men. As the prophet says: ' Heaven is my throne. a nd the earth is my footstoo l. What kind of house will yo u build for me ?' says the Lord [the Father]. 'O r where will my resting place be? ' (Ac t 07;48-49 ). The Fathe r sent his Presences. the Son and Spirit. to be es pecially present in the temple. T he Most High (E lyon ), ho wever, determined that he wo uld dwe ll in the heave ns and not be es pec ially present else whe re (I Ki 08 :27; 2C h 02 :06 ; 06 :18; Act 07:48-50; Isa 66 :0 1-0 2; Jo h 14:02). This arrangeme nt was mea nt to emphas ize how there were individua l person s of the Trinity, ye t the)' were a united o ne - as the Stoma pointed out. This Trinitarian e xplanatio n solves the apparent contradiction of ho w Ya/n 'dl was sa id to dwell in the tabernacle and temple (25 a 07:05-(7). yet not in the tem ple (Isa 66:0 1-02). T his Trinitarian e xplanation also explains why the Psalmists cou ld speak of ranven having "tabernac les" - one be ing in hea ve n and the other on earth (Psa 043:03; 046:04; 084:0 1; 132:07: Heh 08:05; 09 :24). That the Father d we lt in heaven uve r the Promised Land is ho w Jeremi ah could say that Israel lived under the shado w of Yahveh (Lam 04 :20 ). That Israellived unde r the shadow of Elyon , and the Presences of lh hW'h were in the temple, e xplains why Jonah thought he co uld run from the Presences (Panim) of Y ah veh in the temp le (Jon 0 I:03, 10). The account of Jonah is discussed in the chapter on T he Various Prese ntations of the Trinity. Thai the Father dwe lt in heave n a nd rne Presences d wel t in the temple is why Hezekiah co uld use the paired pronouns " you-he" (atah -hu ) to pray; a Yllh l'eh , God of Israel. e nthro ned between the cherubim, you-he are Goo over allthe kingdoms of the earth (2Ki 19: IS: Isa 37; 16). The other se ven occurrences of the "you-he" (a rah·h u) paired pronouns also were likel y spoken in the vicini ty of the first and second te mples (2Sa 07:28; tCh 17:26: 2C h 20 :06: Neh 09:06a. 07 ; Psa 0 44 :05a: Jer 14:22). II was noted in the chapter on He bre w collective nouns that the "yo u-he" paired pronoun s occur with orher plural eleme nts indicating plural persons. T he members Matenal com direlbs autcrars
102
Yael Na tan
of the Trinity were ofte n addressed with singu lar collective nouns and prono uns as well as pfural collecuvc nouns and prono uns. The "you" of the paired "you-he" pro nouns lIlay have been meant as a co llective pro noun referrin g to the Presences in the te mple. T he " he" of the paired "yo u-he" pronouns may have been mea nt as a sing ular pro no un refer ri ng 10 the Father in heaven. "You" naturally refers to a person or persons who are near- such as the Presence s in the temple. " He" na turally refers to a more d istant person such as the Father in heaven . The Presences Bid Not Always Inhabit th e Temple T he Prese nces who bo re the Name of Yahveh d id not always dwe ll in the temple. T he Presences did no t d well in the first temple until it was dedica ted ( I Ki 08:10- 11 ; 2C h 05:13-14). Like wise, the Prese nces d id no t d well in the ruin s of Solomon's temple (2 Ki 23:27; Lam 05 : I8; Dan 09 :17; Zec 08:03). Apparently. the Presences who bore thc Name. Yahl'eh, never inhabited Herod 's tem ple, apal1 from the time that Ye.I'huiI was there. Ye.lh,w considered the temple a de n of thie ves d ue to the prese nce of crooked moneychangers. Also. the high priestly positio ns routinely went to the shrewdest sc hemers. T he highest bidde rs usually were the He llenistic Sadd ucees who did not eve n belie ve in the resurrect ion or sp irits (Al;t 23:08). Herod the Gre at initiated the co nstruction of the temple in 19 Be. This is the same Herod who tried to kill Ye,llma in Bethlehe m when Yeshua was abo ut two years o ld (Mat 02:07_ 16). When Ye.lh,w came to the tem ple du ring his ministry, it had been under co nstructio n for forty-s ix years (J oh 0 2:20 ). Peo ple picked up stones. perhaps fro m the te mp le co nstr uc tio n projec t, and twice tried to sto ne Ye.I'illfil in the te mple co urts (Joh 08 :59: 10 :31-32; 11:(8). Herod 's tem ple likely would not have been inhabited by the Presence s only after its completion and ded icatio n, if at all. This was the case with Solomon's temple {lKi 08:06- 13; 2Ch 05:13- 14). Herod the Grcat had the temple that Zcrubbabct built destroyed. Herod 's temple was not completed until 62 o r 64 AD - long after Ye.lh"iI declared it deso late (Mat 23:38; Luk 13:35). Then in 70 AD the Ro mans destroyed Herod 's temple. That God 's Presences no lo nge r dwe lt in the temple le ft open the possibility that a Presence might visit the temple. T he Jewish leadership, howe ver, "d id not recognize Ihe time of God's com ing to you" (NI V Luk 19:44), e ven though l ohn Ihe Baptist had cried out: Prepare in the wilderness the way of Yohveh [the So n]; make level in the desert a highway for o ur God [the So n] {lxa 40:03; compare Mat 03: 0 3; Mar 0 1:02-0 3; Luk 03:04 -06; l oh 0 1:23). The Fat he r also said: ' Beho ld, I se nd my messenge r [Joh n Ihe Bap tist] to prepare the way before my Presence [Yaln'ell Ihe Son], and the Lord [Ye.IJuw ] who m yo u see k will sudden ly come to his te mple: the Malek of the covenant in whom Malenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
103
yo u d elight, beho ld. he is coming,' says Yahveh o f angelic arm ies [the l-ather ] (Mal 03:0 1). Ycshua confirmed that the Father spoke of send ing a messenger ahead of his Presence. Yahveh the So n. Yeshull quoted what the Father had told him: I [the Fathe r] will send my messenger ahead of yo u [the Son ]. who will prepare your [the Son \] way before yo u [the So n] (Mat 11 :10: Mar OI:02 ; Luk 07:27 ). what the Father said to the Son is reflected in Isa 40:03 and Mal 0 3:01. lsa 40:0 3 predicted the message of John the Baptist, so naturally, lsa 40:03 reads as tho ugh John the Baptist were speaking. Mal 03:01, ho we ve r. reads as though the Father were speaking to the Judeans. So e ither the Father spoke three times o n the subjec t. o r the So n ada pted the Father's con ve rsation for Isaiah and Malac hi's messag e. YC,I'I" W'S version nf Ma l 0 3:01 sho ws ho w to translate and interp ret Ma l 03:0 1. The phrase co mmonl y translated as .. ... befo re me" sho uld be translated as .. ... send m}' messenger before my [the Fa ther's ] Pre sence [the Son ]." T he rest o f Mal 0 3:01 confirms the " my Presence" translat ion of Pai wn. The Presence is described as " the Mu lek of the co ve nant" who would co me to his temple (Mal 0 3:0 1b). The wo rd Ma lek de scribe s the Son . who is elsew he re called the " Malek. his Presence" (l sa 63 :09). T he Presences were members of the Tri nity, and they dwe lt in the OT temples. So it is natural that the te mple would be called " his te mple" (Mal 0 3:01 ). Yah""h the Son also prophesied abou t his [the Messiah 's ] min istry, "Now the Lord Yahveh has sent me and his Spirit" (Isa 48: 16). Of course, if the Son and Spiri t were alread y in the te mple d uring NT time s, they wo uld not need 10 be "se nt" to the Promised Land. So Herod 's tem ple was no t inhabited by the Prese nces - the Son and Spirit. The So n was sent bac k to the Promi sed Land when Yes/llI{/ was co nceived . lind the Sp irit was sent at Yeshutt' s ba ptism in the form o f a do ve. Mal 03:01 says that the Malek of his Presence would "co mevro the temple, but there is no mention of the Presence dwell ing in the tem ple. The Pharisees made sure Ye,I'hu{/ 's com ing wou ld remain a shon visit. Since Yes/llw was reb uffed at the tem ple, he sa id : Look. your house is left to you [as1 d eso late Ius it was already]. I tell you, you will not see me again until yo u say, ' Blessed is he who co mes in the Na me of t he Lord ' (Mat 23:31':-39 ; Luk 13:35). Yahveh said that he watched his tem ple being turned into a den of thieve s (Jer 07: II ), Yahvch said that he wo uld thrust the e vildoers from the temple and from his Presences (Jer 0 7:15 ). Interestingl y. the evening before Ye,I'IllItI cleansed the te mple, Mark recorded: Yeshua ente red Jer usalem and went to the temple. He loo ked aro und at e verything (Mar 11 : 11 ). YC,I'I"w took note o f the e vil occ urring at the templ e ju st as Yulll'eh had (Jer 07: 11). T hen . the next da y. Yeshua thrust the ev ildoe rs from tem ple and from his prese nce (Mar II : 15; see also Mat 2 1:12 and Joh 0 2:15) ju st as YU //I'('h had (Jer 0 7: Matenal com direlbs autcrars
104
Yael Natan
15). This suggests thai Ye.\h tw was the Prese nce who was pro phesied to ret urn to the tem ple (Isa 40:03 ; Mal O3:Ul ). Later. Yeshua told the parable of the vineyard to say thai he was Yah veh the Son, show ing that he was author ized to cleanse the temple (L uk 19:47 - 20:20). Inte rest ingly, only when he was present in the temple did Yes/ilia ca ll the te mple " his Father's hou se" (Luk 02:49; Jo h 02 :16). T he tem ple that con cern ed Yeshua was hi.s ow n body (Jo h 0 2:21) and the body o f the Chu rch ( ICo 06 :19). T hese bodi es were mystically linked (Jo h 02 :19-2 1; 06:51 -58 ; ICo 06: 19; Eph 0 3:06; 0 5: 30-32; Col 01 :24). Ye.\'huil and his di sciples on ly paid tem ple lax so as not to ca use unnece ssary
offens e. Th e tax was paid fro m mone y found in a fish rather than fro m earned mone y (Mat 17:24 -27 ). This seems as tho ugh Yes/ilia tho ugh t the te mple was a mere building left unoc cupied by rah veh , When Y{',\ hua was in Samaria, he did not affirm the assertion of the Jews that YiI/II'eh had to be worshipped in Jerusale m. Ye.\ h tw in fact said thm the "time. . .has now come' that the tem ple was irrelev ant (Joh 04:20-24). Yeshua also sa id that heav en is his Fath ers house and omitted any refe re nce to the temple (Jo h 14 :0 2). To ward the end of h is mini stry. Ye.\ h tw co nsigned the temple 10 desola non and destruction (Mat 24 :02; Ma r 13:0 2; Luk 2 1:06). YeI hull also sa id that the te mple was " yo ur ho use" rather tha n "m y Parhers ho use" (M at 2 3:3R-39 ; L uk 13:35 ). So YC'I JIlW wax uncon cer ned about the temple except when h i.s life and ministry unav oidably brought him to the tem ple . Thi s see ms to show that Ye.\1I1w had bee n Yah w h's Prese nce in the temple, and that the templ e was de solate whe neve r Yeshua was nOI there. Ye.\'hlUl\ example of foll owi ng ce rta in token Jew ish cu stoms. as well as paying the te mple tax so as not to otfend, ev ide ntly intl uenced the e arly Church (Mat 17: 24-2 7). Th at is why Pau l a nd the Jewish d isciples followed a mod icum of Mosa ic custom s co ncern ing the temple (Act 2 1:20-29). The early C hurch other wise taught that the te m ple was irre levant. The e arly Church did not ope nly teach aga inst the temple. despi te what their detractors claimed (Act 06: 13- 14 : 21 :28). T here was no point in pressing the issue that the temple was desolate s ince the e arly Church knew thai the temple wo uld be destro yed shortly (Mat 24 :02; Mar 13:02: Luk 2 1:06). With the te mple gone, the y co uld stop pract icing ce rtain Mosaic c ustoms without causing un necessary offe nse (Mat 17:27 ). The Con nec t io n Between Exo 33- 34 and t he Aa roni c Hlesslng (Bened iction) Yahveh told Moses: Th is is ho w ) 'OU sho uld bless the childre n of Israe l: you shall te ll them: 'Yil hl'eh bless you, and kee p yo u; Ya hve h make his Face [Panim ) shine on you, and be gracio us to yo u; Yahwh tum his Face [Panim ) tow ard yo u. and give you peace.' Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
105
So shall they [the priests] put my Name [sing ular] on the chi ldre n o f Israel; and I will bless them (N um 06:22-27) . In the Aaronic Bles sing . the Name, Yatweh. is me ntioned three rimes. Onl y after the second and third mentio n of Yahl'eh is there a mention of " Presences" or "Faces." T he Faces refe r to the Spir it an d Son. Th e reason the face of Ya/weh the Father is not mentioned in the Aaronic bless ing is found in Exo 33-34 . Moses as ked 10 see Yahl'('h th e Fath er"s glory (Exo 33:1 R). T he Father said that see ing the Father 's ow n face wou ld prove fatal for Moses {Exo 33:20; co mpare Rl:V 06: 16 ). T he reas on was MOSl:S was a sin ful mortal. since sinkss an ge ls con tinually Sl:l: the Father 's ow n face and survive (Ma t 18: 10). The Fat her invited Mose s up the m ount the nex t day so that Moses co uld see the Son and the Spirit's glory. Moses would a lso sec the Father 's glory, albei t partially sh ielded fro m view. T he glory of the Son and Spirit is nOI necessarily letha l to sin ners. T his is due hoth 10 the concept of grace and the princ iple Ihal the Son is the "form" (Num 12:08: Phi 0 2:0 6 ), "image" (Gen 0 1:26-27: 09 :06; 2eo 04 : 04; Co l 0 1:15), and "lik eness" ( Ell: 0I :26-2X; Heb 01: 03) of rahveh the Father, Likewise , the Sp irit's glo ry is not necessarily lethal du e 10 grace and to the fac t that the Spiru proceeds fro m the Fat her and throug h the So n. Instead of show ing his full glory, the Fathcr said that he would me rely procla im his pre sence. The Fathe r would proclaim his presence by saying his Name, Yalll'eh, and by proclaiming his goodness, grace and mercy {Exo 33:19). The l-ather sa id that when his glory was about to pass by, he wo uld cover Moses with his hand. Upon passing by, the Fat her said he wo uld remo ve his hand so Moses co uld see the Father 's back (E xo 33:22-23). Placin g Moses in the deft of a roc k and covering Moses with his hand was the Father 's way of "blessing and keeping" Moses ali ve . T his parallels the first pari of the Aa ro nic Blessing (Num 06:24). The Father 's hand. meaning the brigh t doud, was the Spirit {Exo 34:05 ; Mat 17:05). In this way the Fath er " made his Face [Pt/llim] shine upon .. .and be grac ious" to Moses (Num 116: 25). Moses also saw the So n both as he passed by (Exo 34:06), and during the Ieeeto-face, forty-day discuss ion that followed (Exo 34:07-28). Th is was part of the Father "t urning his Face fPan im] toward" Mose s an d giving Mo ses peace" [Num 06:26). The prcincurnutc Son turne d his face toward Moses as he passed by Moses, an d talked to Moses face to face d uring the fort y days (E xo 34:06). So Moses saw the back of the Fa ther and the races o f the Son and Sp ir it. who are called the " Presences" or " Faces" of the Fathe r in Exo 33:14- 15. Just as the Aaronic B kssing artic ulates, Mose s was kept safe and was blessed by rbe Father (N um 06: 24). and he saw the Faces of the Son and Sp ir it. Otherwise, Moses wo uld ha ve been o ne of the di sfavored. for according 10 Jere miah, the di sfavored see the back of ranvon b ut not Yahreh's Faces: I [the Father ] will show the m the back, but not the Faces [the Son and Spirit) in the day of their calamity (Jer nU 7). So it becomes ap paren t why in the Aaronic Blessin g, the Name, YlIIIl 'ell . is men tioned three times , but on ly a fter the second and third mentions of Yah l'e ll Matenal com direlbs
autcrars
10 6
Yael Na ta n
are the " Faces" ment ion ed. In the Aaronic Blessing the Fathe r is me ntioned as bless ing and keeping, hut not a s lookin g at the Israelit es. Seeing the Father 's ow n face wou ld prove leth al for the sinners (Exo 33:20). In the Aam nic Blessing, the Fath er is me ntion ed firsl since the Father was t he first to ap pear before Moses (E xo 34:05). T he Spirit is me ntioned second since he, in the fonn of a cloud , shie lded Moses from seeing the Father's own face (Ex o 34: 05 ). The So n is menti o ned third since he appeared last (Exo 34:06). "T um .. .Face" ap plies to the Son since the phrase is anthropo morphic a nd is mo st characteristic of the preincamate Son (Eze 0 I:26; Dan 07; 13). So Ihc Aaron ic Blessing shou ld be unde rstood as being thorou ghly Trin itarian: Th is is ho w ) 'OU sho uld bless the children of Israe l: you shall tell them : 'Y ahveh [the Father] bless you, and keep yo u; Yahveh [the Fathe r] ma ke his [the Father's] Face [Pal1;m, meaning the Spir it I shine on yo u, and be gr acious to you; Yahveh [the Fathe r] turn his [the Father's) Face fPan;m, mea ning the Son] to ward you, and give yo u peace.' So shall they [the priests ] put Illy [the Farhcrs] Name [Yah ,'eh ] on the chil dre n of Israel; a nd I [the Fat her) will bless them (Nu m 06:22-27). Passages with Similarities to Exo 34 and the Aaronic Blessing: (NUll! 06:23-27) There are seve ral passages that spea k of Yahw:h loo king on the favored, but not on the d isfavored. If the OT were unitari an, ho we ve r, the situatio n ou gh t to he reversed. For, if Yahven were on ly o ne perso n and no o ne can see Yllhrt'h's face and live (boo 33: 20 ), the n ¥ahl'('h should look on the d isfavo red and look away from the favor ed ! The above- ment ioned seem ing co ntradiction ca n be reconciled impleme nting a Trinitari an interpretation of the passage s concerned: • Exa mples of the Son and Spirit look ing on the favore d incl ude: o When you [the Falhe r) sa id, 'Seek my Face s' [(l Ch 16:11 ; Psa 105:04) ], my heart sa id to yo u [the Fathe r], ' I will sec k your [the Father's ] Faces [the Son and S pirit] , ¥ahl'/.'h [the Father]. On not hide yo ur [the Fa ther's) Face s [the Son and Sp ir it] from me' (P sa 027:08-09), o Let your [the Fathe r's ) Faces [the So n and Spirit] shine on your ser vant: sa ve me in yo ur unfailing lo ve (Psa U3 1: 16 IBHS 03 I: I 71), o May God [the Father] be me rc iful 10 us. bless us, and ca use his Faces [the Son and Spirit] to shine o n us (Psa U67:0 1), o Restore us, 0 God [the Fath er]: make yo ur Faces [Son and Spirit] sh ine upon us, that we may be saved (Psa ORO:03 [HHS ORO:04] ); also Psa ORO:07 [HHS 080:0 81), and o ' In a surge of anger I [the Father] hid my Faces [So n and S pirit] from you fo r a mome nt, but with everlasting kindness I will ha ve com pass ion on )'OU,' says yahveh [the Father] your Redeemer (Isa 54:08).
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
107
•
Examples of the Father lookin g on the d isfavored incl ude : o Ya!ll'eh:~ [the Father 's own] face has d ivided them (Lam 04 :16a ). • Exam ples of the Father looking o n the di sfa vored while the Son and Spirit look on the favored include: o YalH'eh's eyes [the Son and Spirit) are toward the righteous. His ears [the Son an d Spiri t] listen to their cry. Yaln'eh's [the Father 's) face is aga inst tho se who do ev il, to cut off the memory of them from the earth (Psa 034: 15- 16 1BHS 0 34:16-17 ]). • E xamples of the Father not loo ki ng o n the favored, but the Son and Spirit looking o n the favored include: o Hide your [the Fathe r's] face fro m my sins ... (but] do not cast me away fro m your Face [the Son ), or take your Holy Sp irit from me (Psa 051 :09 -11 [BHS 051:11-13 ]). Peter quotes the above passage and said God's face is o n (Gree k: epi), meaning, "toward." bo th the favored and the ev il: The eyes [the Son and Spirit I of the Lord (the Father] arc on [Greck: epi] t he rig hteous. and His [the ~ath er' s) ears [the Son and Spirit's] hea r their sup plic atio n, but the face of the Lord (the Father) is upon [Gree k: epi] those doi ng ev il ( IPe 03 :12). Incidents with Similarities to Exo 34 and the Aarontc Blessing (Num 06:23-27) Elijah at M Ollnt Sinai I Ki 18-1 9 was discussed ea rlier in this c hapter. T his sec tion discusses the co nnectio n be tween IK i 19 an d the Aa ro nic Blessing , Elij ah wen t to Mo unt Hore b. otherwise known as Mount Sinai and the " Mount of [All] the Gods" ( I Ki 19:08: also Bxc 03 :0 I: 04:27: 18:05: 24: 13; 2Ki 04 :25 ). Th e Word of YlIII ~'eh ( I Ki 19 :(9), who was previously called the MlI lek ¥tllll-eh (I Ki 19 :05-07 ), told Elijah to stand before the Face of Yahveh the Son at the mo uth of the cave. From this vantage point Elijah wo uld sec the process ion o f the Fathe r and the Spirit C1 Ki 19: II , 13). Notice that Elijah did not cover his face before standing beside the Presence of Yahveh the Son at the mouth of the cave. Elijah only retreated into the safety of the cave to avoid the wind. the fire, and the rock slides from the earthquake. Only when Elijah heard the Father whisper in a gentle breeze did Elijah cover his face with his cloak. Elijah then proceeded to the mouth of the cuvc a second time ( I Ki 19:13). Elija h knew that El.ro n' s Presence s, the Son a nd the Spir it, would have a gracio us d ispos ition due to Exo 33-34, the Aa ronic Blessin g and other Scriptures. The se passages we re disc ussed abo ve. Elija h, howeve r, kne w fro m the sa me Scriptures that for a sinful per son to see the Father's ow n face wou ld prove lethal. Thi s is why Elijah covered h is face with his cloak on ly upon hearing Yahwh the Father, but not whe n spea king with the M lIl ek and Word of YlIhn,II . Elijah 's covering his face with his clo ak (1 Ki 19: 13) is similar to ho w at a later time the prophet Isaiah saw the face of Yll hr eh in the te mple (Isa 06:01) . Isaiah Matenal com direlbs autcrars
10 8
Yael Na tan
thou ght that becau se of his sinfulness, he might d ie on account of see ing Yah veh {lxa 06 :05 1. Isaiah o nly saw the gracio us face of the Son, perhaps o n account of the train that fil led the te mple (Isa 06:0 1). Yahveh the Son was gracious and had Isaia h's sin blotted o ut (Isa 06 :07 ).
The Transfiguration At the Tran sfigu ration, the Trini ty bes towed the sa me hono r and favor on the three disciples that was prev iously bestowed on Moses and Elijah. T hat honor was heari ng the Father and see ing his Faces, the Son and Spin t. The Transfi guration was a literal act ing out of the Aaronic Blessing and a reenac tment of Exo 33-34. The Father passed by Moses in a cloud that shielded Moses frnm the Father 's g lor y (E xo 34:05 ). So 10 0 , a bright clo ud envelo ped the disci ples and shielded them fro m the g lo ry o f the Father. The br ight cloud in E xo 34 an d at the Transfigurat ion was the Spirit. T he br ight clo ud was the Spirit sh ining his fa ce o n the d isciple s, as the Aaronic Blessing describes (Num 06: 25). T he voice wit hin the clo ud in Exo 34:05 and at the Transfi gu rati on was the r ather kee ping the d iscip les safe (Num 06: 24). The Father ke pt the m safe by adv ising the m to listen to the Son (Mat 17:0S: Mar 09 :07; Luk 09:35) rather than listen to Peter's m mblings (Ma t 17:04-0 5: Mar 09:05-06 ; Luk 09:32-3 4). At the Transfig uratio n, Ye.lhrw's face and clo thes shone brightly (Mal 17:02 ). Ye,lhrla turned from talking to Moses and Elijah to tell the di sciple s, "Do no t be afraid" (M at 17:07 ). This was a real life e xample of the Aaron k Ble ssin gs: Yan veh [the Father] turn his [the Father's ] Face [the Son] to ward yo u and g ive yo u peace (Num 06:26). T hat fe.I'h ull ' S face shone on the di sciples on the Mount o f the Transfigurati on is si milar to Mose s' fort y-da y and night stay o n Mount Sinai: Mo ses did not kno w that the skin of h is fa ce sho ne bec ause of his speaking with him [Yahreh the Son ] (Exo 34:29).
Yeshua's Baptism Anothe r incident with si mi la rit ies to the Tr a nsfi gurati on an d the Aaro nic Ble ssin g is YC.I"hUll ' S baptism (Mat 03:13- 17). A do ve a lig hted on Ye,l /uw 's sho ulde r afte r Ye.l"htw was bapt ized . Then, Matthew said. " the heave n was o pened," and a voice said: Th is is my belo ved Son with whom I am well pleased (Mat 03:17). It see ms clo uds hid the Fa the r's own face du ring Ye.l'hm/ s baptism. Ezeki el, Matthe w and Luke ev en usc the sa me Greek words "anoigw ouranos ' for "h ea ven ope ned" (LXX Ezc 0 1:0 1; Mat 0 3:16; Luk 0 3:2 1). Eze kiel mentions clo uds (Ezc 01 :04. 28 ) after saying the heaven s open ed (Eze 01 :0 I). An interestin g paralle l is when Ye,I'h/1lI was in the tem ple co urts, the Fat her's voic e spoke from heav en say ing: I have glor ified it [his Name]. and will glorify it ag ain, John wrote that some peopl e thought the voice was thunder. This may ind icate that the re were clo uds obsc uring the Fathe r's ow n Face (Joh 12:29 ). So in respect Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
109
to the Father 's voice com ing from within o r be hind clouds, Yeshua ' s bapt ism was similar to Exo 34 and the 'l'ra nsfiguranon. Now returning to Ye.l'/lUl/'s baptism. the Father " kept" John the Ba ptist (Nu m 06:24), The Father told Joh n that the one on whom he saw the Sp irit alight wou ld be the on e who would bapt ize with the Sp irit (Joh 0 1:33), T he Father also "kept" Jo hn by say ing from hea ven that Yes/1lI1I was his beloved so n (Mal 03:17). John did not think it was right fo r him to baptize Yeshua , but Yeshua graciously assured Joh n tha t it was the right thing to do (Mat 0 3:1 5). Thi s was )I(,1II'e1l the Son tu rning his face to ward Jo hn and giv ing him peace (N um 06:26). Afte r Ye,~ h lw 's baptism the Spirit ca me do wn in the form of a dove and alighted on Ye,\ hua' s shoulder (Mat 03 :16). T he clou ds that ope ned and shown light, and the dove that aligh ted are both e xamples of the Father having the Spirit shine his face on Joh n the Baptist and Ye,\hUlI (N um 06 :25). Since the Aaronic Blessing was acte d ou t during Yeshua's bapt ism, one co uld say that the Name of ranvcn was put on Yes/llw d uri ng h is ba ptism (N urn 06: 27; Mat 28 : 19 ). Stephen ',\' Stoning Another in cid en t with si milarities to the Tr ansfig uration an d to the Aaronic Bless ing occu rred a t Stephe n's stoning. Stephe n's face shone like an angel's (Act 06 :15) because Ste phen was full of the Spirit (Ac t 06 :05: 07:55). T hen Ste phen looked to heav e n and saw the glory of God the Spirit. The g lory may ha ve look ed like a halo or sunb urst in the clouds. Stephe n also saw the face of Ye,\ /uw as he stood at the right ha nd of the l-uther (Act 07:55-56). Notice, however, that Step hen did not say he saw the Fat her's own face, which was likel y obscured by the clou ds and the sunb urst of g lory. The First Commandment The first co mmand ment is oflen translated as: " You shall have no othe r gods before me" [Exo 20:03). T he first commandment literally reads : Let there be [singu lar ve rb] to you no oth er s [plural adjecti ve (/('herim] gods [plu ral nou n e/"him] before my Presences [plural noun Pal/im ] (E:w 20:03; Deu 05:07 ). Understanding the First Commandment in Terms of Space O ne mu st think in sp at ial and Trinitaria n te rm s to u nderstan d the fi rst co mmand ment pro perly. As was noted previou sly concerning Deu 05:26 and Deu 33:0 1-02, durin g the g iving of the Ten Command ments. the " Ji ving Gods" appeared on t hree moun tains: the Father on Moun t Sin ai, the Son on Mount Seir, and t he Spirit on Mou nt Paran. During the Exod us, the clouds ge nerally were posi tioned between Israe l and Israel's ene mies for tactica l reasons (Exo 14:20; Num 10: 12). Late r, when the Father sen t the So n and Spirit 10 the Promi sed Land ( Exn 33: 14-15 ). the Father happe ned III he o n Moun t S ina i, the Son was on Mo unt Seir, an d the Spir it Matenal com direlbs autcrars
110
Yael Na ta n
happen ed to be in Edom (Jd g 05: 04- 05 ). Thi s may ha ve bee n meant 10 de te r enemies and 10 g ive Israel a measure of comfort. if Israel was positioned between the three mountains.
Co mpar ing Deu 33 and Jdg 05 revea ls that at the giving of the Ten Commnndrne nrs, the Son was o n Mo unt Se ir and Spirit was on Mount Paran. They were " before" the Father who was on MOUn! Sinai (Exo 20:03; Dell 0 5:07 ). Conce rning the prepositio n "before ," note that the Fathe r el sew here spoke of the Spirit bein g "be fore" him. The Farber said, " . ..the Spirit fro m before me will gro w faint" (lsa57: 16 )."' The fint Commandment l.cgistates Agaillst Pseudo- Trinities T he Fat her used the wo rd "other," lite rall y, "o the rs" (m,'heri m ), in the first command ment to make both a di stinction and an allowance: • T he di sti nc tio n is bet ween the di vine Son and Spiri t who we re "before" the Father. and the so-called gods that the Israeli te s would be tempted 10 pUi before the Father. and • The allowance is that while the so-c alled gods put before the rather arc not worthy of wors hip. the Son and Spiru who happen to he before the Fath er are di vine persons wo rthy of wo rship. By say ing. " You shall have no other gods before my Presen ces:' the Father was warning against a type of syncretism where the lxruelites would swap the Sun or Spirit with false gods to create a pseudo-trin ity. Ge nesis provide s an ex ample of such a pseudo-trinity. As was seen in the cha pter on Hebrew co llect ive plurals. the He brews liked to address the mem bers of the Tri nity as, for instance. the God o f Abraha m. the God of Isa ac, and the God of Ja cob. Laban, however, swore by a pseud o-rnnuy w hen he said : Ma y the God of Ab raham, the god of Nahor. and the god of their father [Teruh]. j udge [plural verb] between us (Ge n 3 1:53). The plura l verb "j udge " shows that Lab an may have been referring 10 th ree de ities me rged into a pse udo- trinity. Scripture docs not say whethe r Abraha m's brother, Nahor, wors hipped false gods, hut Scripmre does reveal that Laba n (G en 3 1:19) and Terah (lo s 24 :02) we re both pagans. Interestingly, Laban was from Haran (Gen 27:43; 29:04). and Sinasi Gund uz wrote: The chil dre n of Sin. l shtar. his dau gh ter. and Sh am as h. his son. are menti on ed with him in on e of the Nabo nidus inscription s from Harran [Arubic spelling of Huran]. It see ms there was a trinity of gods, b ut this ma y be due to the custo m of ment ion ing gods in threes." J. Spence r Tri ming ha m wrote similarly: Mesopotamian cults in particular we re based o n the triad, 'Our Lord. o ur Lad y. a nd the Son of o ur I W O Lord s. with Beet-Shamim: whic h correspon d to the great Syrien de ities . Hadad, Atagali s. Simius. and the Sky-god. BlI 'al SIWIII;III.""
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
111
The comma ndme nt against pseudo-trinities was necessary because sy ncret ism was rampa nt in the ancient world . Several ancient rd igions even had pseudotrinities or triads. Pse udo -tr initi es an d triads may have resulted fro m corru pte d mem ories of Yahvism's Trinity. This situation is parallel to ho w many ancient c ultures have worldwide flood stories that are distant echoes of the Ge nesis flood acco unt (Oen 00-09). Many c ultures knew of the Ge nesis flood upon being dispersed from the Tower of Babel (Gen II :1l8-09). Similarly, many post -Babel cultures remembered that Yohveh was the Trinit y. They especially remembered that Yahl'ch referred 10 himself as "us" (Ge n OJ :26; 03:22; II :1l7). Perhaps, if it were not fo r the fragmented memories of the true Trinity, many cu ltures migh t have lapsed into diffe re nt brands of unit a riani sm rathe r tha n variegated polytheism. Another factor that gave rise to paga n pse udo-trinities is the De vil humors him self by creating religion s that mimic the true faith. In fact, the Apos tle John prophesied how the Devil wou ld create a pse udo-trini ty. Joh n wrote that a second beast that spoke like a dragon appeared (Rev 13;11). T he dragon controlled the first beast whose fatal wound has healed (Rev 13;12). The dragon had an image of the first beast created and caused the deceived people 10 worship the fi rst and seco nd bea st, and the image of the first beast (Rev 13:15). So in esse nce John described Sa tan creating a pseudo-trinity. The First Commandment l.egiskncs Against Unitarianism If the Father had just said, "You shall have no gods befo re me," there wo uld have been serious theological consequences. Without the word "o thers" (acherim), hearers might assume that the fi rst com mand men t taught unitarianism . An omission of the word "others" from the First Co mmandment would he taken 10 mean that the So n on Mount Seir and the Spirit on Mount Pa r,111 were not divine persons of Yahveh, With the word "ot hers," however, the Israelites knew the Father meant "others" besides the Sun and Spirit. It sho uld be noted that the Father elsewhere refe rred to the Son as God . For instance, the Father called the Malek w ith his Na me "God" (Exo 23: 19, 25) . The Father twice ca lled the Son "God" in the Psa lms (Psa 045: 06-07; 082:08 ). Furthermore. the Father sa id his Prese nces always existed with him and were uncreated: Before my Presences [Pallim] there was no God created, and after me there is none [created] (Isa 43: 10). That the Fathe r. Son and Spirit are to be co nsidered divine can be ascerta ined even from the Trinitarian title of MoursItoreb (hllE/olli",) . Horeb is the mountain where the first command ment was given. Moun t Horeb is sometimes called Mount S inai or the "Mount of [A ll] the Gods" (hatJt/ll im) (Exo 03:01 ; 04:27; lR:05; 24: 13; IKi 19:0R; 2Ki 04 :25). The name Sinai has pagan o rigins and refers to the moon god Sin. The name haf/"him, howe ver, refers to the Trini ty, since haf/t/him is repeatedly associ ated Matenal com direlbs autcrars
11 2
Yael Na tan
with the Trinity, Moses. the Ark of the Covenant and the templ e. Huhloh im was d isc ussed in the ch ap ter on Heb rew co llec tive no uns. Further proof that "the Mou nl of [All] the Gods" refers to the Trinity cernes from Sa muel's time. A mu sica l group of Yalll'eh's prophe ts manned a high place on a hill c alled "Gibeah of [All] the God s" (l Sa 10:05). "G ibeah" means " hill" in Hebrew. The hill had different names just as Moun t Sinai was known by different name s. The hill was kno wn as Gibeah of Benjamin ( I Sam 13:2, 15; 14:16 ), G ibeah o f the children of Benjamin (2 Sam 23:29), and G ibeah of Saul ( I Sam I I:04; Iva 10:29). That the hill had d ifferent names does not detract from the fact that the hill was a lso known as " [AIl ) Ihe Gods IIIl1E/ohim]" because the hill was associated with Yahreh , the Trinity. In Deu 13:0 2. Moses showed that in the first co mmandme nt (Exo 20:(3) the plural word "others " (ad lerim) distinguishes between the persons of the Trini ty and so-called god s. Moses wrote that false prophets would sa y: Let us fo llo w others [t/cherim ) gods. gods you have not known, and let us wors hip them (Deu 13:0 2). Notice that Moses dcti ned "o thers [acherim ] gods" as gods "that you have not known." Moses, however, knew that the Israelites already knew "the living God s,' since they had appeared on three mountains during the gh'ing of the law (Deu 05:26; 33:(2 ). By defini ng "othe rs [al'herim ] gods" as bei ng "gods yo u have not known." Moses meant to ensure that the Israel ite s wo uld never come to thin k o f Ya ll l'ell the Son a nd Ya hl'eh the Sp irit as being "other" gods. Like wise, Moses spoke the Shenw to e nsure that Israel would ne ve r co me to think of Trinitarianism as a form of polytheism. T he Shema 's messa ge is that the Fa the r, So n and S piri t are "a united o ne" (ed uIlI). in other word s, that they are the Trinity {Deu 06:04 ). As was d iscussed in the cha pter on Hebrew co llective nouns, theo log ians actually had to change Moses' wordin g from echad to vachid to interpret the Stoma in a non-Trinitarian way.
The First Co mmandment Legislates AKainsr Bini/arianism T he r athe r's usc of the plura l, lite rall y. "o thers" (a cherim ) . instead of the s ing ular "ot he r" ((ldl('r), is impo rta nt. If the Fat her were Hinitariun and no t Trinitarian. he wo uld think that the Son was a d ivine person, but that the Spirit was an impersonal force. Then, in the f irst command ment. the Father wo uld have used the singular word "o ther" and not "others" (acher instead of the plural achcrirm. The singular word "other" would indicate that Israe l s hould worship none other than the Father and Son. To recap-if the Father were a Binitarian. Yahl'e1, co uld have said : Yo u shall ha ve no other [sing ular adjective (It'lIer ] God [singular noun E/] before my Face. T he singular "other" wo uld sig nal to the Isr ae lites that the y were to have no other god before the Father besides the So n. The same cou ld be said if the Binitariani sm were reverse d- if the Father conside red the Spirit. but not the Son, to be God. Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Chapter 4 The Shema
Introduction During the Exodus, Mo ses made many stateme nts that. w hen cons idered toge the r. fo rm a doctrine of God, For instance , Moses' doct rine o f God was bounded at the top by statements that ranventhe Fa ther was the Most High (Elyon) (Gc n 14: 18. 19, 20 , 22; N urn 24: 16; Dell 32:0&). This mean t there was no god greater tha n Yahveh, During the g iving of the Ten Com ma ndments , the Israe lites saw the persons of ¥tlhreh on three mo untains. Thi s was discussed in the chapter o n the Presence s conce rning Dell 0 5:26 and 33:02 . Du ring the giving of the first co mmandment. the " athe r told the Israe lites not \0 ha ve an y other god.s be fore him. So the do ctrine of God was boun ded on the botto m. The Israelites kne w there we re on ly three persons ca lled Yohvr h, Still, the re was one pol yt he ist ic no tion tha t had to be nipped in the bud trithe ism. Trithei sm is the idea thai Israel had three gods rather than o ne God. So Moses spoke the Shcmll to e xpress the unity o f the three person s called ¥lIhr eh : He ar, 0 Israel: YlI hveh [the Father] [and ) our Elohim [the Son], YI.I/H'ch [the Spirit] [are ] a united o ne Iec had 1 (Dec 06 :04 ). The co ncept of unity e xpressed by the Shema was necessary to counte rbalance the man y eleme nts in the Pentateu ch that speak abo ut the pe rsons of the Trinity. These include : • The Trinitar ian proofs suc h as Deu 33:02 that are me ntioned in the pre vious chapters . as well as the Trin itarian proofs mentioned in the Trinitarian proofs append ix, • Most o f the 8 12 instances o f the plural form El ohim (Go ds) fo und in 683 verses of the Pentate uch. So me instances of etohim, of co urse, refe r to false gods . and • 56 of the 57 instances of the form " [Ali i the Gods" (haElohim ) fo und in 54 ve rses o f the Pentateuch. In Exo 18: I I , ho we vcr, haetohim refer s to false gods. So the Shema stresses that the three person s ca lled Yohvch were the Trinity (also called the Triu nity ). O ne can bypass the Trmitanan message of the Shema onl y by Matenal com direlbs autcrars
11 4
Yael Natan
changing the wording, such as by changing echud to .l'l.I chi d. So one co uld say that the Shema is a Trinitarian cre ed. All subseq uent data about the Trinity mere ly adds preci sion 10 the Shema. An analogy wo uld be ho w the value of pi (3. 14 ) has beco me increasing clear-cut o ver ti me (3.1 4 1592653589793 23846 ...). Precision was added to p; and accepted as factua l hy the sc ientific co m mun ity only when such preci sion become mea ningful. use ful or nece ssary. The Shema had been an adeq uate c reed th roughout OT limes as is evidenced by the fact that the or reads Trinitarian thro ugho ut By the time the Son came as the Me ssiah, the Trinitarian Sh/'ll lll had. since Inrertesta me malnmes, been reinterpreted as being unitarian. Beca use their hearts we re harden ed to what the OT actually said, thc motley c rew of Pharisee s, Sadducees, Esscncs and other co uld all cla im to be true OT belie vers along with Trinitarian Yahvis rs. So Y/',\ hu(/ made the Trini tarianism me ssage more explicit by talking o ften about the Father. Son and Spirit. At the end of his earthly caree r, Yeslllm ga ve a 5111'111(/like form ula ju st as Moses had given Snema at the e nd of his caree r. Ye,5huQ gave the command to baptize in the name of the Fathe r, Son and Sp irit. Th is Trinitarian formula was meant to drive a wed ge between true belie vers and unitarian heretics. The NT along with explici t doct rinal state ments arc the sword that YI'shua said would divide families alon g orthodox and hereti ca l fa ult line s (Mat 1034-36; Luk 12:5 1-53). Paul sa id true believers would work toward doct rinal uni ty by a mo re detailed st udy of God's word (Ro m 16: 17; l Co 0 1: 10: 2Ti 02 :15- 16). Paul said d ivisions caused by statements o f fa ith help to dis tinguish those who m God appro ves (I Co 11 :1 8-19). After awhile. " hy poc ritica l liars , whose co nsciences have been seare d as with a hot iron " (l Ti 04:02) we rc able to re inter pret the NT to acco mmodate thc ir unbelief. Joh n had 10 re mind bel iev er s who were confronted wit h sed uc tive teac hings that both the Fathe r and Son were indispen sable to the faith (2Jo 01 :0811). In fact. the NT is fu ll of reminders abo ut correct doctrine (Jo h 14:26: Ro m 15: 15: ICu 04: 17: 15:0 1: 2Ti 01 :06: 2Pe 0 I: 12: Jud 0 I :05 J. After awhile mo re mnemonics such a s the Apostles, the Nicene and Athanasian Creed s were nece ssitated. C hristians have fou nd o ut that other doc trinal statem ents have been and will cont inue to bc necessary so that the Church docs not deg enerate into unendin g don nybrook br aw l until the Last Day. l\-Iaimonides (1135-1204 AD ) Maimonides is the mos t fa mo us med ie val rab binic sch o lar. Maimonides ' nick na me, Ramba m. is an acronym der ived from his title and name: Rab bi Moses Ben Maimo n. Rambum codified the Tal mud. He also wrote the GuidI' for me Perplexed (I 190 A D), an atte mpt In reconc ile Aristo telian philosophy with rabbinic theolog y. Rambam formulated the Thi rteen Ankles of Faith that still serve as a fund amenta l creed of Orthodox Judaism.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
115
Moses used the word edultl in the Shema to desc ribe Yehveh as a " united one ," Rambam, however. substituted yachid for echad to describe God as "alone," "an absolu te one," or "a n only one." The OT neve r refers to Yahveh as being voctud (alone) . By substituting the word ."lIdl id. Rambam though t he could sidestep the Trinitari an implications of the Shema. Rambam's substitution. ho we ve r, does not make the e ntire Shema read unitarian. Ra mbum's vers ion of the Shcma is here trans lated: ·'Yah "eh. our God [Elohellu] [are] Yahveh alone lradlid)." Notice that o ne Trinitarian ele ment is still left intact, literally. "our Gods" (flohr/til). ffohn/U is the plural construct form of Etohim. So eve n Ramb am's modi fied Shema still teac hes that there are divine persons named Yahl'eh! Moses had expressed the un ique ness of Yah l'eh , yet witho ut co mprom ising his Trinitarian beliefs. Moses' .%ema- like state ment uses the plural form Efohim (Gods ) to say that the plural persons of Yllhl'eh are God a lone: Yahveh: he is [All] the Gods [/ltIEfohim], there is none bes ide (Deu 04:
35,39). Note that these passages in Deu 04 are foun d o nly two chapters away from the Shema (Deu 06:04). Solo mon ( IKi 08:60) and Isaiah (Isa 45:05) also echo Moses' stateme nt Ihat there is no God besides the Trinity. Jere miah provided a fifth "alone: ' Slrema- like passage when he said there was none like Yahl'('h who could send rain . Jerem iah wro te: [Are] not you- he [tl/ah -hll] YlI hl'eh, Etohenu (literally, "o ur Gods"]? (Jer 14:22). The reader will recognize thaI Jeremiah used the same phrase, Yahveh Honen u. that is fo und in the Shema. The plural form Elohenu and the "yo u-he" paired pronouns ind icate thaI Jeremi ah knew perso ns named Yahl'eh. So Je remiah expressed Yah ~'f'h 's uniq ueness without comprom ising his Trinitarian beliefs. would God he hono red hy Ramh am's attempt to trans form the Shcma into a unitar ian statement of faith? Perh aps looking at the theological implications of unitaria nism will help decide. A recurring rabbinic theological theme is that since God is a single person. he became lone ly. Loneliness is supposedly why God decide d to create angels and humans. Christians, howeve r, do not posit that God was lonely. bUI say that God created angels and humans for his glory. In rabbinic theo logy. God was like the lone (e('hl ld ) man of whn m Solo mon spoke (Ecc 04:rJR). Solo mon said two persons together were better than one forlorn person (Bee 04:09-1 2a). but a co rd of three strands was best of all (Eee 04 : 1 2b) ~ Surely, Solomon's had the Tnn uy in mind when he said this, In Pro 09 :10 and 30:03. Solomon spoke of Yahveh the Fathe r and Yahveh the So n. In Ecc 12:0 I and Sol 0 I: I I. Solo mon spoke of the Trinity as plural perso ns. These passages arc disc ussed in the MT plurals appendix. Solomon would likel y say that Rambam's yachid versio n of the SlIemll promotes a "dejected loner" interpretati on of God.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
116
Yael N ata n
United in Essence The Shema should he understood til mean foremost that the three persons a re a united in the ir name-Ytlhl'eh. T he Trinity's union in name arises from the fact that three person s are united in esse nce . In fact, all e xpression s o f the Trinit y's unity suc h as being united in action and purpose arise from the Trinit y's underl ying union in ess ence . S ince a single person cannot have the quality of being united, the Trinity is the most powe rful example of the Gesta lt theory: "the whole is greater tha n the sum o f us parts: ' The chapter on Hebrew collective nouns gives many examples of things said ttl be a " united one" (edwJ), such as grapes, day s, slicks, and sol diers . Not once was there any diffe renuuuon as to the si/,e or the importance o f the objects comprising the united one (edull/). The co nsec utive da ys said to be echudim (t'united one s" or "a few" ) were equal. since days mea sured by the sundial are alwa ys twel ve hours long (j oh II :(9). The Shema's insis tence that persons of Ya hveh are on e (('('hm / ) therefore see ms to suggest that the pe rso ns co mprising the whole sho uld he viewed as eq uals-c-at le ast accord ing to essence . Being united in essence means that the Trinity ca n be addressed as: • God of Gods ( Eloll im) and Lord of Lord s (Adonai ) (1os 22:22; Psa 050:0 I : Isa 26; 13; Dan 02:47; I I :36: I Ti 06 :15: Rev 17:14; 19:16). • Lord o f [Alll thc Lords ( haAdonim ) (Dcu 10:17; Psa 136:03) , • God of IAIII the God s (ha t'loh im) (Psa 136:02 ), • Lords (Allon ai ). s ince Ahraham addre ssed three pe rsons as "Lords' (A dona i ). and all three replied (Gen 18:0 3-05) . Also, Lot addre ssed IWO perso ns as "Lords" (AtIO/wi), and they both answered (Gen 19:0 2). Further, Ya/II 'dl ca lled himself " Lords" (Adonim) in MaiO I :06. • Yahveh, since the narrator. Moses. indic ates that there was a Yahveh in heave n and a Yanven on earth (Gcn 19:24 ). Also. Ya/w ell o ftcn spoke in the third person of a nother person named Yah veh , as ts discu ssed in the Tr initarian proofs appe nd ix, • God (El or Eiohim i, since the autho r of Heb rews sa id that the Fat her add ressed the Son as "Cod" in Psa 04 5:06 -07 (Heb 01 :OX), and Ye.l"hua sa id that the " a ther add ressed him as "God" (Psa 082:08; Joh 1O:36a). and • Most High (A ramaic is ltyonin J. since a hea venly dwell er called both the Father and the Son the Most Highs (Dan 07: 18 , 22. 25b. 27). Uni ted in Na me Zecharia h interpreted and ex panded on the Shema saying that the members of the Trinity are united both in esse nce and in name to rule Israel . Zecha riah said: Yoh veh [the Trinity] has become king over all the land, in that day there shan be a united one [echad]. Yahl'e1l [the Trinity]. und his [the Trinity's ] name is a united one [echad ] (Zec 14 :(9). Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
117
The three me mbers of the Trinity each have the Name, Yah reh, and this meant they are united in the pursuit o f ma king the mselves a name ( Exo 09 :16; 2Sa 0 7:23; leh 17:2 1; IS1l 63:1 2, 14; Eze 20:09) . A passage sim ilar to Zec 14:09 shows that Yahvchss n: perso ns united to make themselves a name (Hos 12:04-05). The Son referred to the Fathe r and him self as " us" (Hos 12:04) ,"' and then made the Shema- Ii ke stateme nt: ranven [the Father ]. God [the Son ] of hosts , Yuhl'eh is his [the Trinity] name of renown (Hos 12:051BHS 12:06]). The He brew word that the NI V ua nslares as " name of re no wn" is zeker (Hos 12: 05). Zeker usu ally mea ns " me mory" or " me morial," but here it ma kes better se nse to say that Yahveh is the Trinity's " na me o f renown" Elsewhe re. tekcr is associatcd with the Hebrew word for " name" (sheim) (Exo 0 3: 15 ; Job lit 17; Psa 009: 0 5-06 ; 135:13; Pro 10:07; Isa 26:0&. 13- 14). So 1I0s 12:04 is Trinitarian ("us") and is paired wit h a passage (Hos 12:05) tha t is similar to the Shema- Iike state ment in Zee 14:09. T he concept o f being a united one «('("had) 10 make oneself a name was nOI novel. Perhaps the Tower of Babel builders were ins pired by the concept of the Tri nity when they united to make themselves a name, The y said: Let us build a city and a tower .. ,let us make a nam e fo r o urselves (Ge n 11:(4). God said that the people had become a " united one" techadv who spoke a "u nited o ne" «'rill/d) language (Gen I I :(6). T he rea so n the builders' lan g uage was a "united o ne" (el'had) was that the language as 11 whole co nsisted of a "few d ialects" techadim (J(/l'lIrim) (Ge n 11:0 1). Yahw,h said : If as a unite d one [ec had ] peo ple speaking a un ited o ne [ec had] lan guage-e-lf they have begun 10 do this. then not hing they plan to do will be impossible for them (G en II :06). So God, united in resol ve , sa id, " Let us..." (Gen 11:07). and then proceeded to dis ru pt the plans of the united one people who set o ut to do the impossible, T he Towe r o f Babel account gave co mfort to the Israeli te s who were faci ng man) e nemies. T hough the To wer of Habel builders were united as one, they were sca ttered to the fo ur winds by the united one ranven. So it seems Moses meant the Shema to communicate that the united persons of Yohwh co uld choose to sca tter all lsracl's ene mies -no matter ho w united they appeared (Ge n 34:30; Em 0 1:10; Psa 0&3:04; Est 0 3:(9). ln this way. Yah veh wou ld ma ke a name for himsel f just as he defe ated the Egyptians to make a na me for hi mself ( ICh 17:21; Dan 09 :15: Jer 32:20-21 ).
United in Action Notice that the narrator of J udges referred to people as echad (a united one) and used singu lar verbs with echad:
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
11 8
Yael Natan
• The assem bly is gat hered [singular verb] as lim: [ec bud ] ma n [sing ular no un] (Jdg 20:01),
• All the people rose [singular verb) as o ne [ec had] man (1dg 20:08 ), and • All the me n of Israel were gathered [sjn gular verb ] to the c ity as one [cc had] man , companions Odg: 20: 11 l. In the last verse, Jd g 20 : II . not ice thai the plural nou n "co mpanio ns" is used as an appositive modifying the singular forms echad and " man." This shows that in the Shomo , the fo rm cchad could re fer to united persons : He ar, 0 Isr ael: Ya hveh [the Father] [and ) our £lol1il/l [the Son]. Yahveh [the Spirit! [are] a united on e Iechad] (Dell 06:04). The plural fo rm E/ohim (Gods) is used over 2.000 t imes in the o t with sing ular verbs and other mod ifier s. Oc casio nally. plural ver bs and ot her mod ifiers are used with E/ohim. These sho w tha t three person s united in esse nce arc also united in action. as is d iscussed in the chapter on Hebrew co llective nouns. Simi lar ly, sing ular verbs are used wit h o ve r 300 instances of the plura l fo rm haF./ollim (fAil] the God s) referring to Yah reh. T he many occurrences o f the co llective no uns Eloh im and huE/ollim used with sing ular ver bs a re hel pful in under stan di ng the Shema. Indeed . any collec t ive no un referring to Yahveh used with a s ing ular ve rb ca n be co ns ide red an informal version of the Shema. The coll ec tive noun refers to perso ns ca lled Yahveh; and the s ingular verb sho ws that Yehveh is. and ac ts as. a uni ted on e.
United in Determination and Purpose Echad is often used to show the united determination of a gro up of persons.
For e xample, the Chro nicle r wrote , "The hand o f God gave them one [ee had ] mind" (2C h 30; 12). Joseph lold Phara oh that his IWO dreams (Gen 4 1:32) had o ne ( ed uuf) interpretation (Ge n 4 1:25-26). Josep h ex plained that IWO dreams with o ne t echads uuerpretanon meanl that "the matter has been firml y decided by God , and God will do it soo n" (Gen 4 1:32). The Sncma show s that the persons of the Trin ity arc united [echud ]. The Shema was spoken in c ircumsta nces whe n Israel needed to k now Ihat the Tri ni ty was united in their determination to: • Relocate Israel out of the dese rt and into Palestine , and • Establi sh a theocrac y. The Scrip tures show that the persons of the Tr init y are united in their deter minatio n to make perso ns and peo ples. T he " us" made Adam and Eve (Ge n 01:26; LXX Gen 0 2:18). Peop le have "c reators" (Bee 12:( 1) and "makers" (lob 35: 10), and the nat ion Israel has " makers" (Psa 149:02 ; Isu 54:05 ). These MT plurals are discussed in the MT pl urals appe ndix . S imilarly, per sons of the Trin ity arc united in Ihei r determination as to whe re people and nations live [Jos 24: 18 ; Act 17:26 ): • God sa id, " Let us" when God determined that Adam and Eve wou ld live in Ede n (Ge n 01:26). Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
11 9
• The " us" de termined that it was best that Adam and Eve live ou tside the Garden of Eden (Ge n 0 3:22), • When God determined that the population should he dis trib uted across the ea rth, God said, "Let us" (Ge n II :0 7), • A braham literally said . "Gods [E/ohim] . they ca used me to wander" (Ge n 20: 13) to the Promised Land (Gcn 12:(1), • Jacob lite rally sa id, "Gods [E/ohim], they reve aled himse lf' (Gen 35:07) whe n they promised to bring Jaco b hack to the Promi sed Land (G en 28: 12- 15). • Aaro n sa id that Yahr eh (E xo 32:05). " they brought" Israel out of Egypt (Exo 32: 04, OR),
•
Ya/weh sa id. " My Presen ce s. they will go with you" to con que r the Pro mised
Land (Ex o 33: 14-15). • Mose s. short ly before sayi ng the Snema. sa id that the gods arc not as ncar the natio ns as Yohveh our God fare ne ar]" (De u 04 :07). • Joshua recalled how "the Ho ly Ones" had brought Israel ou t of Egypt to the Prom ised Land (Jos 24:19), • The Philistine s, who were fig hting to kee p land taken fro m Israel, said about
Yahven: These are the Gods. they who struc k the Egyptians wit h a ll kinds of plag ues ( ISa 04: 07-08) , and • David said. "G ods . they we nt to red ee m to himself a peo ple .. .from Egypt" (2Sa 07:23). The MT plur als mentioned above arc d isc ussed furth er in the MT plurals appe ndix.
The Shema as Ancient Israel's National Motto The "uni ted one" inter pretatio n of the Shema is appropriate to the co ntex t of the Shcma. Moses was g iving a motivational speec h to the Israel ites to conq uer the Promised Lund and set up a theocratic state. The Israel ites needed to kno w that the Trinity was united for Israel aga inst Israel's foe s. l-or this reas on. the Shcma became a nation al motto for ancient Israel. To show that the Shel/la is an ent ire ly appropriate mou e for natio nal Israel. one can compare the Sncma to a very si milar national motto o f the Unucd States: e pllf,-ibu.I' unum, Th is is a Lat in phrase me aning. "o ut of many. o ne." Since Moses was the founde r of a Trinitarian theoc racy. he wou ld natu rally speak of the Fathe r, Son and the Spirit as being united for the nation. Like wise. the founders of a rcpublic natu rally would spea k of the mse lves and thei r colonies being united as o ne nation against the nation's foe. That Yahveh were one and the United States were one wou ld not rule OUI the usc of plural verbs and mod ifier s with e ither Ya hveh or the United States. For exa mple. Moses used both singular and plural verbs to refer to Yuhl'ell. Likewise. the founders of the United States co uld say:
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
120
Yael Na tan
The United States is [singular verb] no longer at war with Britain. and mor e tha n two- thirds o f the United States ha ve ratified the Co nstitution. To pro ve that the unify ing moti vatio n and logic was the same in the elise of Israel a nd the United States. co ns ide r this; Benjamin Fra nkli n ap tly said at the s igning of the Decl aration of Independence. " We must all ha ng to gether, or a ssured ly we shall all hang se parately" (l uly 4. 1776). That same day the Co ntinenta l Co ngress appo inted the G reat Seal co mmittee: Benjam in Franklin, John Adams, an d Thoma s Jeffe rson. Interesting ly, it was this trio w ho c hose the mott o: "e pluribus ull um ." Du ring the United St ates C ivil War (186 1-1865 AD ), the wo rds and acti on s o f the Co nfede racy bel ied the moun "c pluribus IIl1l1m: ' So a second mo tto was needed to express unity du ring ci vil war, The argume nt for the second motto ran th us: in a nation with Ju deo-Ch ristian values. "The re is but o ne God." So " In God We Trust" was chose n. Th is sentime nt is the same unifying sentime nt ex pressed by the vochid version of the Shema. From IS64 A D o nward. the United States retained both the echad and vochidtype motto s. In thc hcat of the Cold War that pitted natio ns with Judco -Christian va lues against at heistic communism. President Eisenhowe r signed Public La w 140. This law stated that all Un ited Stale s coinage and paper c urre ncy m ust di splay the mott o " In God We Trust." T his is how the "In God We Trust'· motto became the pro minen t motto of the United States. The histor y of United State s mo tto s par allels the histor y of the Shema. T he echad motto of the fo undi ng fathers , "I.' plurihus tm tlm," ex presses the unity of ma ny, while the yachid mono introduced later, " In God Wc Trust." ex presses the ge neric belief in one God. The echad vers ion o f the Shc ma wa s a motto o f Israe l's fo unding fathe r. Moses. The echad version of the Shemu e xpresses the unity o f the Trinity. while the yochid ve rsion of the Shema, introduced long a fter, merely ex presses the bel ief that there is onl y one God. Both .w lt·h ill monos were introduced because some people rej ected the e ar lier echad mottos , so a compromised yochid mo tto was adopted instead. The NT and the Snema' " Zechariah alluded to the She ma and the n e xpa nded on the Shema : In that day Yahl'eh [the Trinity] will be one (Hebrew mascu line edlllJ]. and His [the Trinity J name will be one [Hebrew masculine echad [ (ill 14:(9). The LXX translat ors tra nslated the He brew mascul ine echad in Dcu 06:04 and Zec 14:09 a with the Greek masculine heis. In zecn l 4:09 b, howe ver, the same Hebrew masculine word echad is translated with the Gree k ne uter hell. T he reason for the dis crepancy is that in De u 06:04 and Zee 14:09 a, echod stands by itse lf and is usually translated as "one." Th e reader must co mplete the thou ght by supplying a word suc h a s " united one ... in name ." So in Deu 06:04 and
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
121
Zee 14:09a, the LXX translators used the G ree k equivalent of erhad with the same mascul ine gender: heis. In Zee 14:09b, however, Zecha riah expa nded and inte rpreted the Shema and supp lied the implied noun : "name." Zechariah therefore understoo d the Snema to mean: He ar, 0 Israel: Yohveh [the Father] [and ) our Elohim [the Son]. Yahw:h [the Spirit] [are] a united one IechaJ ] [in name (Yahl'eh)] (Dcu 06:(4). Because " united one" must now agree in gende r with the neu ter Greek word for "n ame" (onoma). the LX X trans lators used the Greek ne uter word hen to translate the masc uline echad. Evide ntly. the LXX translato rs did not realize that Zec haria h ex panded and interpre ted the SI,t'IIUI and supplied the impl ied word "united o ne. .. . ,. III name. If the translators were not Trinitarian, there would be no sense or purpose in declaring that a single d ivine perso n is "one in name." Ho we ve r. if the LXX translators had been Tr initarian. they wou ld have co nsisten tly used the Greek neuter word hen rather than heis (Deu 06 :04 . Zec 14:09a and 14:09 h ) when translat ing ShcIna-like stateme nts. The Greek NT sometimes fo llows the Gree k LXX tnanslation o f the He bre w Snem«: , .. the Lord is one [masculine hei.lr' (De u 06 :04; Zee 14:09a ; Ma r 02: 07 ; IO: I K; 12:29; Luk IK: 19; Rom 0 3:30; leo OK:04. 06: Gal 03:20; Jam 02:19). At oth e r t imes t he NT follows the LXX trans lat ion of Zech aria h's e xpa nded version of the Shema: "the Lord .. .is one [neuter he n)" (Zec 14:09b; Joh I I:52; 17: 11, 23). Anothe r Sht'lna-li ke state men t thai uses both heis and "':'11 is di scussed in the Trinilarian proofs appe ndix at 11005:07-08The NT use of hen a nd heis in ShwllI-like state me nts is eas ily ju stified. T he NT writers were correct in follow ing either the LXX of the Shema (Dcu 06:04). or the LXX of Zec hariah's ex panded version of the Shema (Zec 14:09). Also. the Hebre w word for "name" (.\"heim) is masc uline. whi le the Greek word for " name" (onoma) is ne uter, So whether the NT writers q uoted or alluded to the Shema usin g the mascu line heis or neuter hen, they likel y understood the Sncma 10 mea n: " united one in name." So nets is correct. while hell is tec hnically correct. When the NT writers used the mascul ine heis in their quotations and a llusions to the Snema, this was probably to accom modate reade rs and listeners familiar with the LXX. For example, Yeslllla likel y was acco mmod ating the teacher o f the law when he quoted the LXX of the Shcma using heis (M ar 12:29, 32). That Ye.lh l/a actually understoo d the Shema as: Ya lm:-h [the Father ]. o ur God [the Son I, YaJm:-II [the Spirit] [are] one [hell ) [in name) (De u 06: 04), can be inferred from Yf .I'hua' s Shfllll/-like state ment, "I and the Father are o ne [hen 1" (Joh 10:30). Here, Yeshlil/'s usc of hell agrees with the LXX of Zec ha riah's ex panded version of the Shema (Zec 14:09). T he neuter hell agrees with the neuter word III/Omil meaning , " name." Matenal com direlbs autcrars
122
Yael Natan
High Priest ly Prayer also has a state ment very simi lar 10 Zechariah's expanded versio n of the Shema (Zec 14:09 ). Ye s/ilia said : Father. keep in your name [onoma is neute r] those you have gi ven me, that they may be one [hen is neuter suggest ing ono ma (name) is meant] as weare [onc llin namc l tIoh 17: 11, scc also Joh 11 :52: 17:23). Ye.I'llIw ' S pra yer was fulf illed be cau se Christi a ns are ke pt by the Name . Christians become "one' b) virt ue how the Name is named over C hrist ians in baptism. Also. the Name is named over Ch ristians d uring blessings such as the Aaronic Blessing (Num 06:27). Thai Yr.I'hu(/ understood the Shl'nlll and the Aaronic Blessing to be Trinitarian can be surm ised from Ye.l,nua 's co mmand that the disciples baptize " in the name [neu ter singular onoma] of the Father and the Son and the Hol y Sp irit" (Mat 28: 19 ). This baptis mal co mmand is similar to the Aaronic Blessing in Ihal the Name is p ut on the Israelites by men tioning the Name, Ya h\'f'h . three times [Nu m 06: 22Yt'.~hU(I's
27 ).
In both the Aaro nie Ble ssing ( Num 06:27 ; LXX 06:23) and in Zechariah 's expanded ve rsio n of the Shemu (Zec 14:09 ). the He bre w word " name" (.I'heim) is translated into Gree k as OIlOm(/ (s ing ular, neuter). Unoma is the Greek word translated as " name" in the Great Co mm ission (Mat 28: 19). So in bapt ism the Name o f the Trinity is pUI on the baptized just as the Name o f the Trin ity was pUI on the Israelites during the Aaron ic Benedictio n.
What Yeshua Said About the Snemo Yt' .I'h,w was in the temple area in Decem ber d uring the Feast of Dedication -
Hanukkah. When Yesnllll walked along Solomon's Colonnade, the Jews dem anded, " If you are the Chri st, tell us plainl y" (Joh 10:24). Yeshull answered , " I d id tell you, but you do not believe" (Joh 10:25). The n Ye.l h,w spoke of how he was the Son 10 the Father, and he said. "I and the Fathe r arc o ne" (Joh 10:30). The Je ws then pic ked up sto nes, likely from the temp le co nstruction sue. The Jews wanted to stone Yes/lIll1. beca use they undersrood thai Ye,I'hua was cla iming to be God (Jo h 10:34). Yeshua purposely foiled the ir " Kangaroo Co urt" con victio n of blasphemy by re ferring to two verse s fro m Psa OR2. Ye.\ hua sa id that the judges 10 whnm the Word of God (the So n) came were called "gods" (Psa 082:06; Joh 10:35), so " what about the one [the Son] whom the Father set apart as his very own and sen t into the world'!" (Psa 082:08 ; Jon 1O: 36a) . This last statement is Yeshua's all usion to Yahveh the Fathe r's statement: Rise up, 0 God [the So n] and judge the earth, for all the nations are your [the Son 's] inheritance (Psa 082:08; Joh 1O: 36a)! Thai Psa OR2:08 is the Father speak ing 10 the So n c an be ascertained hy the fact that the Father cannot have the earth as an inheritance. but only as a possessio n. The Father. however. c an g tve the ea rth 10 the Son as a n inhe ritance. Also. it sho uld be noted that the Fa ther 's ca ning the Son "God" (Psa 082:08 ; Joh 1O:36a ) is Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewish Trinity
123
not a unique occurrence. since the writer of Hebrews said thaI the Father ca lls the Son "Gnd" (psa 045 :06 -07 [8HS045:01-0R J; Heb OI:OR). After defea ting this would-be lynch mob. Ye,I'h /1lI reiterated the cha llenge that if the Jews co uld not rightly con vict him of sin. then they sho uld believe his word s (Joh Ol'l:46-47 ; 10:37- 38: 18:21-23). Per haps the wo rds that YeshliG had in mind that the Jews should believe were: • The Father and he were one (Joh 10:30) . and • The Fathe r is in rnc , and 1 am in the Fathe r" (Joh 10:38). When Yeshlla mentioned tbat be was the Son o f the Fathe r. and that he and the Father were one (Joh 10:30). the Jews understood Yes/ilia to be making an allusion to the Shcma (Deu 06:04 ; Zec 14 :( 9 ). The fact that: • Yeshlla was walking along So lo mo n's Col onnade at the temple when YeshliG said. "00 not belie ve me unless I do what my Father does" (Joh 10:37). and that • Yes nua sa id he wa s God 's SOil who was se nt into the wo rld (J oh 10: 36), se e ms to ind ic ate that Yesllu{! wa s all uding to Sol omon's bonk of Pro verbs (Pro 30:03-04). Ag ur me ntioned that Yalln'h, who ca me to e arth and ascended to hea ven, also had a Son ( Pro 30 :( 4 ). T he implic ation of Yeshlla's allu sion was that the Son does what the Father doe s (Joh 06:62; 10:36-37). namel y, desc end to earth from heaven and ascend buck to hea ven (Pro 30:04). Indeed , Yeshlla said earlier that the discip les wo uld bel ieve once they saw "the Son of Man asce nd to where he was before" (Job 06:(2 ). Agur culled the Father and Son the " Holy One s" (Pro 30:03 ). and the " Ho ly One s" (plural) are previously called rohveh (Pro 09: 10). That thl: Hol y One s are Yah w h show s tha t the Father and Son are one in the Name , Yah veh, Tha t persons are one in name me ans that an informal version of the Shema is found in Prove rbs. The abo ve inte rp ret at io n a nd othe r OT Tri ni tar ia nism is bch ind Yeshua 's stateme nt, " I and the Father are one" (Joh 10:30). Th e anti-Trinitarian Jews kne w this was the case , and were sure eno ugh of Ye,I'Illla's inte nded meaning to pick up stones to sto ne him. Severa l month s after the inc ident recorded in Joh 10, Y/,,\ hua was again at the te mple du ring the Passo ver Week , Yeshua remi nded the audience that Moses had called the Malek Yahveh at the burning bush both: • "God" (Mat 22:31-32; Ma r 12:26-27; Luk 20 :37-38), and • " Lord" [ Luk 20 :37). Thes e state ments di sturbed one scr ibe. The scribe may have also beard Yn hull's Tri n itar ian state me nts spoke n dur in g Ha nukkah (Joh 10). The sc ribe wanted YC'I/IlW to affirm unitarianism and back off his Trinitarian-sound ing statements. The sc ribe asked Yes/ilia what was the greates t commandment, kno wing that Yeshua wo uld say the Shema (Mat 22 :35-36; Mar 12:2R). Y('.\'hlla acco mmodated the scribe (Dcu 06:04-05 ; Mar 12:29-30; Mat 22:36-38). The sc ribe then tried to pUi words into Yeshua's mouth and said:
Malenal com direlbs autcrars
124
Yael Natan
Well said. teac her. You are right in say ing thai God is one [hcis] and there is no other but him (Mar 12:32 ). The teac her of the law's state me nt shows thaI the unita rian misinterpretation of the She ma, which would later culminate in Ramba m's yachid version o f the Shemo, was al ready curre nt in Ye.\,hua's da y. Ye.I'huiI took exc eptio n 10 the teac her of the law's unitari an rmsmterpretauon of the Shema. Yeshuo told the sc ribe that he was only ncar, but not in, Ihc k ingdom of God (M ar 12:34 ). Ye,I' luw 's stateme nt was c alculated to pique the inter est of the sc ribe in the Jewish Trin ity. The Jewish Trinity was a belief that those "in" the kingdom kne w. Tho se on ly " ncar" the kingdom did no t know the Trinity, or refu sed to believe in the Tr inity (Deu 29:29; Mat 13: I I: ICo 02:07 ). Ye.~h Ul/ then proceeded to teac h the scribe about the Trin ity, and he co untered the sc ribe's unitarian yochid interpreta tion of the Shema. Ye.\ h tw said that Da vid spoke by the Spirit when David spo ke of the Fathe r and Son as Lord (Ps a 110: 0 1, 05: Mat 22:4 3-4 5: Mar 12:36-37; Luk 20:42, 44). Note the mentio n of three pe rso ns: the Spirit was the witness to a co nversat ion between David's Lord, the r athe r and Son. In t his wa y Ye,I' lw cI hi nted at the inte nded Trin itaria n interpretat ion of t he Shema. Ye.l hl lll'S statements. of co urse. were guarded and subtle since he was teac hing in the temple (Mat 22:31-4 5: Mar 12:26-37; Luk 20:37-4 7). Onl y a few mon ths carlier Ye.\ lula was nearly stoned at the temple (Jo h 07:06-08, 30; 08:20). Paul was beaten in the temple area (Act 2 1:27-32). James. the brother of Ye.l'hulI, was th rown off the tem ple moun t into the roc ky Kidron Va lley, and then pelted with sto nes." So Trinitarian Yahvtst "rabbis" such as John the Baptist and Yesl llla reso rted to hin ting abo ut the Trinity in pu blic (Mat 26:21, 49: Mar 09:05; W:5 1: I I:2 1; 14: 45: Joh 0 I:38, 49; 03:02. 26; 04 :31 : 06:25 ; 09:02; 11:08 ). Thou gh Ye.l'hull wa s forced to s pea k- and the d isciple s wr ite, in guar de d te rms abo ut the de ity of Christ and the doctrine of the Trinity. thi s is a ble ssing in d isguise. If Ye.l'IlIllI had staled that he was di vine. or if he had coined the word "Trinity," he would ha ve been branded a doctr inal innovator as surely a s he was fa lsel y branded a g lutto n and a dr unkard (M at 11 :19: Luk 07: 34). Besides. the re is no lack of proo f fo r the Trinity in the OT. Anyone who deni es that the deit y' of Christ or the Trinit y is bibli cal merely ex poses his or her willful ignorance of the OT Trinitarianism.
YeIhl/a's Other C omments on the Yach id Interpretation of the Shema H ealing Iht' Pa r atvtic Ye,I'Jlllll fo rgave a man his sins. So me teachers o f the law wer e thinking a long
the lines of the yachid (alone) interpretation of the Stoma when they thou ght: Wh y doe s th is fell ow ta lk like that? lie 's blasp hem ing! Who can forgive sins b ut God alon e 1111';,\ 110 theos [r?" (Ma r 02 :07; Luk 05:21), The thought that the re migh t be a second or third divine perso n who cou ld forg ive s ins was anathem a to these teacher s of the law. Yeshua challe nged their Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
125
vachid interpretation of the Shema by allud ing to the Olin 07 SOil of Man visio n
with these word s: •BUI so thai yo u may know that the So n of Man has author ity on earth to forgive sins·....Then he said to the paralytic , 'Get up. take your mat and go horne.' And the man got up and went home (Mar 09:06-07; Mar 02:10- 12; Luk 05 :24-25). The M
U ll
Who Culled YeI/1I1li "Good"
Ye,I'Illlll also challenged the yachid interpretation of the Shcma when he said :
Why do you call me good? .. No one is good -e-exce pt God 1I10ne [the G reek is h";I'] ( Mat 19:17; Mar 10: 18; Luk 18:19). YCIhua was alluding to Psa 0 14:03: 053: 03 where it says no mere man is good, bill yahveh is good. Nearby is penned: "God is prese nt in the company of the righteous" (Psa 0 14:05). So Yn hua meant that he is Imma nuel (mcunmg. "God with us") who imputes righteo usness 10 sinners (Isa 07:14; Ma t 01 :23 ). The bouom line is that Yeshull said the man's calling him "good" was tanta mount to ca lling Ye.l'hull God - bec ause who co uld plausi bly and co nvinci ngly deny that Yc'.I'/uw was good? Yeshull said Ihal Ihe rich man lacked perfection only because he had not yet give n away his ea rthly possession s 10 follow Ye.l'hua (Mat 19:21; Mar 10:21 : Luk 18:22). Thu s, YeIhuCl implied that the man did not perfectly kee p the commandment attached to the Shema (De u 06:04 ): You shall love Yahveh [the Father] [and ) o ur fit/h ill/ [the Son] with all your hear t. with all your soul, and with all your might (Deu 06 :( 5). The rich man did not ho nor and love God the So n with all his heart, sou l and mind {Joh 05 :23, 36-37). In th is way, Yeshua pointed out the Trinitarian interpretation of the Shell/a. Ye,I'hua also showed thar one can not keep the Shema, the Greatest Commandme nt. withou t honoring God the Son. Parenthet ically. the command to give away riches was not give n to everyone for a ll time, but was meant for this partic ular rich man. T he co mmand was meant to: • Reveal the co nditio n of the rich man's heart . and • Show that Ynhull was Yalll·"h the Son . who was within his rights to make such dema nds. In Psalm 014, two verses after the verse that YeslullI alluded to (Psa 014:03), is the statement "for God is present in the cornpuny of the righteous" (Psa 014:05). The answer to the conu ndru m that there is no one good (Psa 0 14:03), yet "God is prese nt in the company of the righteo us." is that Gnd imputes righteou sness to his followers j ust as God c redited Abraham with righteousness (Gen 15:06). Righteousness was credited to Abraham eve n before the rite of circumc ision was given (Gen 17), and centu ries before the Mosaic Law was handed down. So Yeshua inferred that he is Immanuel ("God with us") (l sa 07:14; Mat 01 :23), and that he impu tes righteou sness to sinners. O n the Last Day, those who think that Yeshull is a mere angel or a human. but not God . will co me before the throne. YO'h,W will then ask, " Why do you call Matenal com direlbs autcrars
126
Yael Na tan
me go od"?" (M at 19:1 7; Mar 10:1 8 ; Luk 18:19 ). The correct answer is. " Because Ye.~ " lIa is God." Man y. ho wever, will respond that Yeshuo is good because he is a great teacher. Yes/lila will ask them : If you beli eve tha t I a m good, the n why did you not beli eve that I am God the SOil as I cla im to be'? Ye,I'Illlll will re spon d to those who thin k him a mere man or an an gel that the y are accuxing him o f not bl:ing good. O nly God is good. and God eve n c harges an gel s w ith erro r (lob 04: 18; 15: 15- 16). Furt her mor e , as C. S. Le wis pointed out co nce rning Yeshua's clai med of deit y, e ither Yeshua was a lunatic, a liar, or Lord. On ly God ca n claim 10 be God and st ill be ca lled sane, truthful, and go od. Ye ,I'n ua 's op inion of those w ho say he is a mere angel is that they are bo ld a nd during. Thcy dare to dc motc YeIhUil do wn to thc le vel of an archangel like Mich ael. who is ca lled "one of the ch ief princes" (Dan ]0: 13). If the archange l Mich ael hesitated to rebuke Satan (2 Pe 0 2:1 1; Jud 01 :(9) . they should defi nitel y not accuse a person greater than M ichael of having erred (Job 04: I R; 15: 15-1 6). Peter's wo rds apply to those who think YCIhua is an e rring angel: Dar ing. se lf-wil led , the y are not afraid 10 speak ev il of dig nitari es ; wherea s angel s . tho ug h grea te r in migh t and po wer. d o nOI bnng a raili ng judg ment against them befo re thc Lord. BUI these, as un reaso ning cre atures. ho rn nat ural animal s to he taken and destroyed. spea king ev il in matters about which they are igno rant, will in their destro ying surel y be destroyed , receiving the wages of unrighteousness (2Pe 02: 10· 13 ). For the impert inence o f ca lling Ye.~ "lIa "good" as thou gh he were j ust another human, Y('.I'huli cou ld re spond: You [mista kenly ] thought the " AM' was like yo u, but I will rebu ke you and accuse yo u to your face (Psa 050 :2 1).
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Chapter 5 The Trinity in Daniel 01-05 Introduction Many Christians have a general bias aga inst the spiritual aptitude of pagans. The bias is especially strong ag ainst Neb uc hadnezzar II (re igned 605 to 56 1 B e ) because he set up a gia nt id o l ( Dan ( 3 ). How e ve r. Dan ie l. Shadr ac h. Me shac h a nd A bed neg o informed Neb uc hadnezzar abo u t Yahveh over a period of time. So there is no reaso n for Bi ble reade rs 10 automatically give Ncbuchadnczzar's Trinitari an-so und ing lette r about Yahl'eh (Dan 04) short shrift. This c hapter will show that Nebuc hadnezzar prog ressed in his understand ing of ¥tlhreh , and that Dan 04 has a Trinitarian rat her than a pagan message . Of co urse. it wo uld be anachronistic 10 think that Nebuchadnezzar's understanding of the Trinity was as refined as the Athanasian Creed. One can hold to a simple Trinitarian creed like the Shema and still be considered a Trinitarian. The False Bias A~ainst the Religious Aptitude of Pagans Many people think that pagans had reams of gods with a high god at the top of the heap. Many pagan s, ho we ver , had sophistica ted pa ntheo ns and eve n pseudotrinities . The reaso n paga n c ultures have pseudo- trinities is the same rea son pagan cu ltures have Flood myths. a.s wel l as o ther sem blances and imi tations o f Yahvism or Ch ristiani ty. The awareness of the Trinity was passed down fro m the age between Noah's Flood and the Tower of Babel debacle . Also. just as syncretism OCCUlTed betwee n pagan c ultures, syncre tism occurred betwee n Yahvists and pagans. Pagan c ultures a lso gle a ned some knn wled ge ab ou t God d ire ctl y from nat ure (Rnm 0 I:20 ). The bias against the religious apt itude of pagans is not bo rne ou t by history or Scripture (be 0 3:05-0 7: Mat 11 :23 ). For instance , when the Philistine Abi melec h (Gen 20 :06) and the Ara mean Salaam (Num 22:10: 23:27) saw t he Tr init y (lwElohim), they were not baffled that three persons were one God. In fact. the high gods of the Mesopot am ia, the heart land of Ncbuchadnczzar 's kingdom , were pse udo- trini ties. J. Spencer Tr imingham wrote:
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
128
Yael Na tan
Mesopotamian cults in particular we re based on the triad, 'Our Lord, o ur Lady. and the Son o f o ur IWO Lord s. with Be 'et -Shamim.: whic h correspo nd to the great Syri an deit ies, Hadad. Atagatis, Simios. and the Sky-god. Hll'tll Shmnim ."" Sinas! G unduz wrote: The c h ild re n o f Sin [mo o n ), Ishta r [Ve n us ), his dau ghte r, a nd Shamash [sun]. his son. are me ntion ed with him in one of the Nabonidus inscriptio ns from lIarran [Arabic spelling o f Haran ]. II see ms there was a trinity of gods. but this ma y be d ue to the c ustom of men uouin g gods in threes." The Dreamscape Statile Ncb uchadnczzar d reamt o f a sta tue repre senting the kingd o ms o f the world down to the end of lime (Dan 0 2): • The hea d of go ld rep re sen te d Neb uchad ne zzarv ru le o ver the Ba bylo nian Empire (60 5-562 Be). • The c hest and arms of silver were the two branches o f the Medo-Persian Empire (546-33 I BC ). • The bro nze abdo men was the Macedonian Empire (331-323 BC). • The bron ze thighs were the Ptole maic (323-030 BC ) and Scl cucid (3 12-064 BC) branc hes. • The legs o f iron were the Rom an (27 BC -476 AD) and Byzantine (395-1453 AD) Empires, and • The feet and toes o f c ia)' and iron are natio ns tha t ha ve ar isen since the full of the Ro man Em pire (476 AD). The nations comprising the iron o f the feet are tho se that model them selve s o n the Rom an Emp ire (th e iron ca lves). Th e co pied fea tures tend to perpet uat e and stre ngthe n gove rnment institutions. These features include an offic ia l lang uage , a legal tradition, a senate (leg islative branch], a stro ng e xec utive. a mass ive public wo rks infrastructure, and the like. C lay na tions are those that do not mode l them se lves o n t he Ro man mod el. What kee ps iron and cl ay natio ns ap art are the d iffe rent cu ltures and religion. and the realization that trad ing make s better econo mic sense tha n co nq uest an d occ upation (Dan 0 2:43). The roc k that Nebuchadnezzar saw smas h the statue was cUI out of a mount ain, but not by h uman hand s (Dan 0 2:34, 45 ). The mo untain refers to the mass of huma nity. a nd the rock c ut ou t from the mo untain is Ch rist. the living sto ne (ICo 10: 04: I Pe 02 :04-OR) and Chri stians ( ICO0 3: I6-17; 06 :19; 2Co 06 :16; Eph 02 :20-2 2: lI eb 03 :06 ). The spread o f C hristianity (the rock tumbling do wn the moun tain) se nds se ismic shoc kwaves through the pagan kingdo ms represe nted by the statue, T he tumbling rock represe nts Ye.I'hulI ruling the Ch rist ian C hurc h in the mids t of his ene mies (Psa 110:02: co mpare Psa 106:47: Rom OS:3? : zcc 0 2:14-16 ). The las t day will co me Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
129
when the rock finall y co llides with and smashes the statue represent ing earth ly kingdom s. After the Last Day, Yesh ,w will rule on the mountain that grew from the rock that finally smashed the statue, T he mountain gll.lwing from the rock represe nts the resurrected believers from all ages jo ining the believers who happened to be living when the Last Day occ urred. T hen the re will be a New Heaven, New Earth and New Jerusalem that will last forever (Isa 65:17; 66:22; Joh 18:36; Jam 02:05; 2Pe 03 :13; Rev 03: 12; I I: 15; 2 1:0 1-(2). Nehuchadnezzar's Reaction to the Statue Daniel told Ncbuchadnczz ar that he was the golden head. T here is no mention, howe ver. thai the dream statue even had a golden neck . So Nebuchadnezza r kne w that if Yahwh had his way, Nebuchad nczzar would not have a dynastic successor worthy of a prophetic mention (Dan 02:38). Nebuc hadnezzar was not satisfied being j ust the golde n head , the first of several kingdom s. He either wanted his d ynasty to last forever, or he wanted to be the ete rnal king that Dan iel mentio ned in interpretatio n. Per haps Neb uch adnezzar started to believe the tlallering salute given to him eve rywhere: "0 king, live fo re ver!" (Dan 0 2:04; 03:09). T hat the statue relates to Ncb uchadnczzur or his dyn ast y sugges ts tha t the statue may have been made to look either like Nebuchadnezzar. or a stereoty pical Babylon monarch.
Neb uchadnezzar was not a perso n to sit aro und and ju st hope for fa vo rable change ( Dan 0 2:0 9 ). Ne buc hadnezzar mused abou t how Yoh veh ha d commun icatcd his intcntion abou t the kingdoms of histo ry through a d ream scap c statue. So Neb uchadnezzar dec ided to signal what he wante d the kingdo ms of history to look like us ing a 27- meter high, 2.7- meter wide gold leaf sraruc." The statue was placed in the plain of Dura in the prov ince of Baby lon (Dan 03 :01). T hat the statue was cove red entirely with gold. rat her tban being partl y gold. silver. bronze. iron and clay. had meaning. Nebuchadnezzar wanted to communicate that he wanted his golden kingdom to last to the end of the world. He did not want his kingdom cut off at the neck . The astrologers must have reasoned that Nebuc hadnezzar's gods of the plain wou ld be more acco mmodating than vanven, especially s ince Ncb uchadnczzar had conquered "Yalll'eh 's land" (los 22:19; Isa 14:02; Hos 09:03 ). Sinee Babylon was in the heart of the relatively na t river va lle)' of Mesopotam ia. foreig n gods were like ly often viewed to be mountain gods . T he astrologers per haps co nsidered Yahn,h a "god of hills" ( I Ki 20:23-28 ). and reasoned that is why: • The statue was destroyed by a rock cut out of a mountain ( Dan 02:34, 45), and • The rock subsequently grew into a mounta in that filled the earth (Dan 0 2:35). Th a t ranvcn was co ns idered a mo unta in god is l ikel y the reason why Neb uc hadnezzar si tu ated his statue on the pla in of Du ra in the prov ince o f Ba bylon (D an 03 :0 1), Th ere the gods of the pla in co uld view t he Malenal com direlbs autcrars
130
Yael Na tan
s tat ue, and no ne o f the f avor it e as tra l d eitie s wo uld be hidde n be hi nd hi lls ami rnou nrai ns, Mo reover, the st al ue wo uld be o ut of the vie w of mo unta in gods. T he sta t ue wo uld be we ll a wa y fro m a ny mo u nta in whe re the "g od o f h ills " mig ht smas h the st at ue wit h a t um blin g stone . Thai Ncb uchad nc zznr was ap pealing to the god s of the plain is why the astrologers and Nebuchadnezzar de manded everyone pay ho mage to the statue. Th e gods of the pla in wo uld then 1(M)k favo rab ly on Nehuchadaezzar's pro posed versio n of the future as com municated by the statue . Ce rtain Je ws co nt inued to worsh ip Yohveh de sp ite Nebuchadnezzar 's orde rs. Nebuchad nezzur became infuriated bec ause wors hipping Yahveh was tantamo unt to as king that his go lden dy nasty be c ut off at the neck . After all, it was Yah vch who had se nt Ncb uchadnczzar the statue dr ea m say ing that h is k ingdo m wo uld pretty much end with him (Dan 0 3:0R- 1R; also aga in in 06:07 -13). A :\lisintl'rprl'talion Leads to Mi stranslation That in Turn Reinforces the Misinterpretation Eve ry Bi ble reader is famil iar with Dan 06 acco unt o f Daniel in the lions ' den. Daniel was se nt to the lions' de n becau se he pet itio ned Yll hl'e1l during a ce rtain thirty-day period. Daniel broke a law tha t said d uring a certa in mo nth, everyone was to pe tition King Darius instead o f /hei r gods. It is not clea r w hether the people we re to pennon the king as thou gh he we re a goo , or ju st petition by co urier or through a pe rso nal aud ience. The ratio nale for the co mma nd may have been that Darius wa nted to magnify him self by gra nting pe titions d irec tly. Per haps Dar ius wanted 10 act as high priest and pe tition the gods fo r his peop le. Perhaps Darius j ust wanted the und ivided attention of the gods for his o wn petitions. T he Da n 06 int e rpre ta t ion may hav e influ e nc ed the inte r pretanon and tr anslat io n o f Dan 02 -0 3. D an 06 ma y ha ve led transl at o rs 10 t hi nk that Nebuehad nezz ar ordere d people to wors hip a statue rep rese nting eit her a god or King Nebueh ad ne zzar himse lf. The interpret ers figured that if the peo ple were to pray to a K ing Darius in Dan 06. Dan 0 2 - 0 3 m ust invol ve pray ing to King Neb uchadne zza r o r an idol. So inte rpre te rs appare ntly made Dan 02 - 0 3 co nform to the ir preconce ived no tion s. Th at is w hy a few A ra maic wo rds are no t tra nslat ed cons isten tly througho ut Daniel 02 and 0 3. If the wo rds we re translated co nsistently, one wou ld read that the people were 10 " pay ho mage" to the statue rathe r than " worship" the statue. Furtherm ore, the statue would be ca lled a "statue" or an " icon" rather than an " ido l." Here are the details : • In Dan 0 2:46 , the Aramaic word rcgid is usually translated as "pay homage," but in Dan 0 3 the ten occ urre nces of ccgid are a ll translated as " wors hip" ( Dan 0 3:05,06.07.10, 11 , 12.1 4. 15 , 18, 28) . and
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
131
•
In Dan 0 2, the Aramaic word Helem is translated "statue" four times (Dan 02 : 31, 32. 34, 35). Howe ver, in Dan 03, the same word uetem is trans lated "idot" eleven times (Dan 03:tll , 02 , OJ; 05, 07 , 10, 12, 14, 15, IR , 19). Faulty trans lations ca use readers to miss the intended meaning of the golde n statue. Also lost in trans lation is the tra nsition between the d rearnscape statue in Dan 02 a nd the golden statue of Dan 03. A consistent trans lation . however, re veals that ju st as Nebuchadnezzar had fallen down and paid homage to Danie l. the people were to fall do wn and pay ho mage to the statue. The stat ue was not meant as an idol to be worshipped since it me rely represe nted Ncbuchadnczzur 's ambitious ho pes for the future of his kingdom. The statue that Nebuchadnezzar set up was no more an idol than Daniel was an idol to Nebuchadnezzar. T he Dan 03 landscape statue that Nebuchadnezzar made was no more an idol than the Dan 02 drcam scapc statue that Ncbuc hadnczzar mimic ked. Note that the astrologers a nd Shadrac h. Meshach and Abednego all made a distinction betwee n: • Ncbuchaduczzur's gods [Arama ic is t'lah1l] and the golden image [Aramaic is l.I'dem], and • Worship [Aramaic is pt'lochl and paying homage [Aramaic is ced(I;' J. The pertinent te xts read: They neither worship IAramaic is petach J your gods [Aramaic is dahh] nor pay homage to [Aramaic is celJig] the image [Aramaic is 1.I'e/em] of gold you ha ve set up... we will not worship [Aramaic is pdl/ch l your gods [Aramaic is t'lllhh] or pay homage to [Aramaic is ad;'!;'] the image [Arama ic is 1.I"e/l.'m] of gold you have set up (Dan 03:12, IR). So all the princip le characters in the accou nt knew exactly why Nebuc hadnezza r had set up the golden statue (Dan 0 2:49), They knew Nebuchadnezznr built the statue not as an idol per sc, but to indicate thc altcmanvc future hc wanted the gods to bring about. It shou ld a lso be noted that Neb uchad nezz ar was not pract ic ing sy mpathetic mag ic because he was not trying to manipulate nature or impersonal metaphys ical forces. The gods he was trying to com municate with were perso ns, just as the God who se nt Ne buchad nezzar t he statue d ream was a person (Deu 04: 07). Pagans usually barter with the gods. and some times vowed that if a god fulfilled a prayer req uest. he or she would worship that god forever. Ncbuc hadnczzar may have reasoned that the gods would grant his wish because, unlike Yahvrh, his gods of gold (Da n 05:04, 23) would be happiest with his golden kingdom. Ncbuc hudnczznr perhaps reasoned: Why would my gods want kingdom s made of inferior metals , clay and stone (Dan 02 :39)? Nebuc hadnezzar. of course. unwittingly set himself up against the Son of God and his eternal kingdom as pred icted in the Dan 02 statue dream (Dan 04:03. 34; compare also Dan 06:26). Neb uchad nczzur apparently did not learn from the fiery furnace incident that pagan gods cannot overrule what Ya1l r e1l has dete rmined. O nly after anothe r Matenal com direlbs autcrars
132
Yael Na tan
dr eam follo wed by a se ven-year bou t o f ment a l illness wo uld Neb uchadnez zar ac cept tha t Yaln'ch was the Mo st High God who d o le d o ut the k ingdom s to an yo ne he ple a sed ( Dan 04:1 7. 25. 32, 34 ; see a lso Da n 02 :21 ; 0 5: 18-23 ). So the rea der ca n see that the dreamscape statue and the landscape statue ar c no t t wo isolated a nd d isconnect ed ev e nts . T he y a rc ind ivid ual lesso ns in Nebuchadnezzars spiritual schoo ling lead ing up to Nebuchadnexzar beco ming a Tri nitaria n Yahvist, Trinitarian Proof Texts in Dan 01-05 Ki ngs tho ug ht it wise to know ab ou t the god s of the ir kingd om s (2 K i 17: 26). Kno wing the e nemy's gods hel ped whe n cond ucting psychological warfare (2Ki IR:251. Some kings e ven ado pted the gnds o f the ir e nem ies (2C h 2R:23 ). Nebuchad nezz ar paid homage to Daniel because he to ld Nebuch adne zzar bo th t he dream an d the interpr etation (Da n 0 2:46). Surely, this incide nt must have made Ncbuchadn czzar cu riou s abou t rahven. (AliI the Gods (haE lohim)
Dan iel
undoubte dly to ld Neb uc had nezza r a bo ut "[ All] th e Go d s" ( JwF.{oh im ) ( Dan 0 1:0 2, 09 , 17 ), es pe c ially s ince Neb uc hadn e zzar had ro b be d t he tem ple o f " [A ll ) the G od s" (1w EJoh im) in Je r usa le m (Da n 01: 0 2 ). In 604 Be. Neb uch ad nc zza r may ha ve e ven sto lc n o r de st ro yed the A rk of the Co ven an t. Th e A rk was often ca lle d the " A rk of [All ) the God s" ( hat'{oh im ). The last me ntion o f the e xiste nce of the Ark (Jer 0 3:1 6 ) precedes th e fi rst mcnti o n o f Ne buc had ncz zar by o nly e ig htce n c hapte rs (Jc r 21 : 02 ). T he te mple was d est roy ed afte r 586 Be , the a rk's terminus ad (/"e m . If Daniel tol d Neb uchadnezzur an ythi ng abou t the OT, it wo uld have bee n hard not to ment io n the Tr inity. There are so many Trinita rian proo fs in the O T, Moreo ve r, a former po lytheist likc Ncb uchad ncz za r would na tu rally interpret the thou sands o f plur al no uns, ve rbs a nd mod ifiers referring to Yahveh as refere nces to plura l persons. Da n 0 4, the c hap te r th at Ne buch ad ne zz ar wro te , se e ms to indic ate tha t Ne buc had ncz znr k ne w a lo t abo ut Yah l'eh . ~' Re me mber that Ne buc had ne zzar lived in an age that p red ated transla tions suc h as the LX X. Translatio ns tran sformed nea rly all the Hebrew plurals referring to Yahveh into s ingulars. In fact, it see ms it was not until the ad vent of Trinityadverse translat ions that peop le carne to think of Yahvc h in unitari an terms. Initially. when Neb ueh adnezzar was still a paga n, he to ld Daniel : Truly. yo ur god is a god of gods [a triad ], and the lord of kings [three d ivine per sons]. and a rcvcalc r of sec rets. see ing that yo u have bee n able to revea l this sec ret ( Dan 02:47 ). The pagan triad s we re thou gh! to be the more po werful gods. Pagans may have add ressed their pse udo-trinities as "a god of gods ." Th e phrase "God of Gods" is used elsewhere in the OT to desc ribe the Trinity [Dc u 10:17; Jos 22:22; Psa 0 50: Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
133
01 ; Dan II :36). Ncbuchadn czzar's phrase " lo rd of kings" (Dan 0 2:47) is s imilar to the phrase "Lord of Lords" that is else where used to descnbe the Trinity (Deu 10: 17; Jos 22:22; Psa 050 :0 I; 136:03; Isa 26:13; Dan 02:47; II :36; ITi 06 :15; Rev 17: 14; 19 :16). Nebec bad nezxar told Danie l that y" hl'('h was "your god" (Dan 0 2: 47). Nebuehadnezzar said of Shadrach, Mcshuch and Abednego that Yahveh was "their ow n God" (Dan 03:28). NOIe that Nebuehadnezzar did not say "m y God " or "o ur God." Th is meant that when Ncbuchad nczzar sa id Yelhwh was a "god of gods:' he had a standard Se mitic triad of gods in mind. Neb uchad ne xzar did not mea n the phrase ·'god of gods" to he und erstood as though Yllh l'eh were the head of his pantheon. Ot herwise, Nebuchudnez zar wou ld have said that Yah veh was "his God" and "our Cod: ' So initially. it seems. Nebuch adne zzar merely repeated Tr initari a n ph rases tha t Danie l spo ke abo ut Yahveh, Nebuehadne zzar initially understood these phrases in terms of his Semitic pagan religion . not in terms of Trinitarian Yahvism . The fact that Nc buchadncz zar used Trinitarian language about Yahveh reveals th at Daniel tau g ht tha t rahveh was t he Tr init y. Evide ntly, Da nie l instr ucted Nebuehadnezzar abo ut Yllh l'eh ju st as Joseph instructed Eg yptian roya lty about Yahn'h (Gen 45:08; Psa 105:17-22). Later, Neb uchad ne zzar said that Daniel had "the Spirit of the Holy [plural] Gods [plural I in him " (Dan 04 :08 . 09 . Iln This is similar to Pharaoh's statement about Joseph: Can we find such a one as this, a man in whom is the Spirit of God'! (Gen 4 1:38). It was o nly afte r Neb uc hadnezxar witnessed Shad rach , Meshach and Ahednego be ing saved from the fiery furnace that Nebuchadnezznr started to take Yahveh seriou sly. Onl y then did Ne buchadnezzar ca ll Ya hl'eh the Most High Cod (Dan 03: 26). Yet. Ncbuchadnezzar later had to write that he learned Yel hl'ell was his God the hard way- after another d ream a nd a seven-year bout of me ntal illness. O nly then did Ncbuc hadnczzar accept that Yallreh was the Most High God who doled out the kingdom s to anyo ne he pleased (Dan 04: 17,25, 32. 34; see also Dan 0 2:2 1; 05:18-13) .
One Like the Son of the Gods is Also Called Malek Aft e r Nebuc hadn e zzar had the statue dream (Da n 0 2) e xpla ined to hi m. Nebuchadne zzar undo ubtedly wanted to know more abo ut Ya h re h and the last kingdom 's ete rnal ruler, Daniel told Nehuchadnezzar that the eternal ruler wou ld he the So n of Yahl'eh (Pro 30:03-( 4). Daniel must have told Nebuchadnezzar that the Son had appea red many times ax the Maid Yahveh, Daniel pro bably mentioned that the So n made so me preincamatc appea rances (Ge n 18-1 9 : 32: Jos 05: Jdg 06 , 13)."" T hat Ncbuchadnezzar knew the Son appe ared some times as a man and so metimes as the Angel of Yah veh e xplains why Ncb uchad nczzur said the fourth person in the furnace was a "So n of God" (LXX Da n 03:25) and a malek (vmevse nger'') sent by God (Dan 03:28 ). Acco rdi ng to t he MT re cen sio n reading fo r Dan 0 3:25, how ev e r, Malenal com direlbs autcrars
Yael Na tan
134
Nebuc had nezzar said the Ma lek. (Da n 03:28 ) was " like a so n of God." T his is similar to how Job called the angels "so ns of God" (Job 01 :06; 02:0 1; 38:07). T his does. not contradict the LXX rendering, as though the LXX spoke of the divine Son while the MT recension spoke of a mere angel. The versio ns arc eas ily reconciled if one understand s that the So n appeared in the fiery furnace as a man (Da n 03:25 ), and then Nebuchad nezza r was told he was the divine Malek Yahw'h (Dan 03:28) . In fact. twice d uring the time of the J udges. the So n appeared as a man and the n as the Malek. Y ahveh in fire to Manoah and Gideon (Jdg 06 :21 : 13:20), T he Ma lek. Yahl'ell's appearance in the fiery furnace must have bee n like "a man of fAll) the God s" (Jdg 13:06 ,08) and " like the Ma id of [All ] the God s" (Jdg 13:06 ). Manoah knew the Ma lek. Yuln'en to be God (Jdg 13:22), and Manoah 's wife knew the Ma lt'/.:. Yah reh to be Yilhl'e h (Jdg 13:23). Nebuchad nezzar's spiritua l instincts perhaps taught him that the "one like the Son of God" was God and YuJm :,h. With his interest piqued . Nebuchadnezzar surely searched the Scriptures with Daniel and found OUI more about the Son of God and the Trinity. The S pir it of th e
H ol~'
fl'lural) Gods fPluralJ
Neb uch adne zzar sa id that Daniel had "the Spirit o f the Hoi)' [plural ] Gods [plura lI in him" ( Dan ()4:08, 09 , 18), This is similar 10 Pharaoh 's statement abo ut Joseph: Can we find such a one as this, a man in whom is the Spirit of God '! (Gen 4 1:38). Moreove r, Nebuchadnezzars phrasing is similar to Joshua's statement about Yahl'eh be ing " the Holy [plura l] God s [plural]" (los 24: 19). " Holy" means "separate." The phrase " Holy Gods" means that Yalll'e h was in a separate category from other gods. The characteristics of that category would be that: • Yah l'eh is. the Trinity whereas no pagan gods are true trin ities. So me gods and thei r consorts might be consid ered triads or pseudo-trinities. and • The Trinity is rea lly God while pagan gods are merely demons in disguise. The de mons co mpos ing pagan pseudo-tr inities, of co urse, are not three perso ns united in nature. That Neb uchadne zzar spoke of "t he Spirit of the Holy Gods" who dwe lt in Daniel means that Nebuchad nezzar was rea lly referring to the Trinity. Otherwise, Daniel wo uld have protested and said that he was not possessed by demons (Den 32: 17; Sl.-'C also Psa 106:37), Belshazzar's Impertinence Be lshazza r, the so n of Ne huc had nezz ar, succe eded Nebuc hadn e zzar 10 the thro ne. Be lshazzar threw a party during which the Hand of Yahl'e h wrote o n a wall. The partygoe rs happe ned to be imb ibing from vesse ls from Ya hl'eh' s te mple.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
135
Perh aps the q ueen noticed that the sc ript on the wall was like the Hebr ew script inscnbed o n the vessels. Thi s in turn reminded the queen of ho w Daniel was a lI ebr ew and wo rsh ipped the Hebr ew's Trinity. Of course. the queen knew all abou t Ne buc hadnezzars letter pro m ulg ated thro ugho ut the k ing do m (Dan 04). Th e queen al so remembered that Daniel had succee de d at rendering an interprelation after the oth er wise men had fai led. The q ueen then told Be lshazzar th at Daniel .. . .. .has the Spir it of the Holy [plural] God s [plu ra l] in him . In the time o f your ta rhcr he was fo und to ha ve ins ight and intelli ge nce and wisdo m like thut o f the gods (Dan 05 :1 I) . When Daniel arrived, Belshazzar told Demel mar he had " the spirit of the gods in him" (Dan 05:14). Thi s con trasts with how Nebuchadnezza r had written that Daniel had the "Sp irit o f the Holy (plural] Gods" in him (D an 04:08. 09, 18). Belshazzar's wife had used the same wor ding that Neb uchadnezzar used (Dan 05: I I). No te tha t Belshazza r o mitted the plura l adjec tive " ho ly" before Ihe word " Gods." Bec ause Belshazzar did not ho nor God as " ho ly," a si m ilar fate befell Belshazzar as befell Moses. Yohveh too k a way leade rship from Bel sh azzar j ust as Y{/IIl'el1 had taken away leadership fro m Mo ses w hen Mose s did not hono r Ytll1l'eh as being "ho ly" (N um 20 : 12 ). Befo re Belshazza r rec ei ved his puni shment. he recei ved a good tongue-la shin g fro m D aniel . Be lshazzar's slate ment, me ntioned above. was am big uo us as 10 whethe r the Spir it of the Tnniry indwelt Dan iel , o r whet her a spirit of a pagan god ind well Dan iel. Danie l, of co urse, knew that pag an gods we re really dem ons (Deu 32: 17 ; see also Psa 106:37 ). Th erefore, Daniel to ld Belshazzar that he had fa iled to honor the "G od who holds in his hand you r life and all you r ways" (Dan 05:23). Dani el' s mention of God's " hand" was apt. not on ly because God's finger had j ust writte n o n the wall, bu t bec ause the Spirit of Yahve h is called the ha nd and fin ger of God several lime s in the Bible . Belshazzar 's fail ure 10 call God " holy" mea nt he failed to specify whethe r Daniel was indwelt by the Sp irit or by a demon . Thi s indeed was a sin agains t the Spiril (Mar 03:29-30 ). The wrtttng on the Wall Dunielthen interpreted the wr iting on the wall whic h read: M ell e [numbe red ), mene [numbered]. tekel [we ighed], parsin [divided ] (Dan 05:25). Dani el sa id: T his is wh at these words mean : Mene : God has numbe red the da ys o f you r re ign an d brou ght it to an end . Teket: You ha ve been we ighed on the scales and found wan ting. PI/WI' [sing ular form of plIninJ : Your kin gdom is d ivided and given to the Medes and Pe rsians (Dan 05:27-28). Dan iel's readersh ip no dou bt kne w this passage all uded 10 ho w ancie nt tran sac tions were co nducte d. Ex actly how this passage rela ted to anc ient co mmerce ta kes a lot of ex pla ining to uninitiated modems. Understand ing the hand writing o n the wa ll is of some importa nce. since it was Matenal com direlbs autcrars
136
Yae l Na tan
meant 10 make unfavo rable compariso ns betwee n the polytheistic Belshazzar and the Trimrana n Ncbuc hudnczzar, The dreamscape statue and the golden statue also deserve a lengjhy treatment since they conce rn the history of the world, and the future kingdom of Yclhl'eh the Son.
How the WritinA on the Wall and Nebuchadnezzae's Statue Are Related An cie nts often we ig he d and co unted co ins. whi le mod e rn s ju st co unt co ins. O ne mig ht be surprised to lea rn tha t many muse ums have large collec tion s of co in weights." Wei gh ing coins was impo rtant s ince eac h co in's va lue was, to so me e xtent. based on its met al conte nt. Trea suries and mints d id no t bac k t he face val ue of co ins. whe the r th e y were aut hent ic o r not. O fte n, ancient coinage systems were not we ll standardized, so s ilver and gold coins had to be we ighed. Co ins meant to be weighed wen: ca lled at marco in Arabic.'?' One benefit of empires was a standardized co inage so merchants and taxmcn could forego weighing coins durin g each transacuon at the ir own risk. Co ins standardized for counting were called li t p e:::,o in Arabic. However. eve n a] p l.',;:o coins sometimes were not worth their face value: • Many mints had little quality control. • T he re were many imitat ion and counterfe it coins, • Peo ple would crop (meaning, "d ip" o r " trim") coins. since anc ient coins did not have raised margins or reeded edges where groo ved lines run vertica lly around the w in's perimeter, • Often coins were holed 10 make jewelry, and • Alloy coins would lose precious metal due to wear and co rrosion. Corrosion wears off q uickly. To com plicate matte rs, coins were made of alkiys beca use alloy s resist wear better than pure gold, silver and copper. Alloys do not corrode as quickly as pure silver and copper. Mirus and eve n counterfe iters knew that the face value of coins was greater than the bullion from which the coins were made. IU' SO an ancie nt mint on ly issued a coin with a high gold or silver content until that mint's co in became acce pted. "The coin of the realm" often was debased due to gree d, or the kingdo m experienced financia l distress. Ya'ako v Meshorcr wrote: O f co urse, it was impossible in those days to gauge the s ilve r co ntent of coins .. .whe n, in the co urse of tim e, it became an accepted c urrency. the Nabateans could permit them se lves to red uce the weight of the cotns.v" Interestingly, during Belsh azzar's feast. the Modes and Persians were abo ut to take ove r Babylon. So perh aps Babylo nian coinage was already deba sed at the time of the handwriting on the wall incident. Perhaps the debasing used one of the following me thod s. or a co mbination of the follow ing: • Inflating the face value, • Using less precious and mo re base metal in the alloy , and • Shrinking the size or thickness of the co in flan. c-
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewish Trinity
137
Collectors have many name s for the material s in de based coin s incl uding billon, efectrum. pa le -go ld, go ld- was hed, go ld- plated, gol d-c oat ed. cl ad, and copper core. Color alo ne can not be used to accurate ly peg a co in's go ld or silver content because: • Many ancie nt co ins co nsisted of base metals coated in gold o r silver, • Different co lo red met als could be alloyed with go ld and silver, and • Gold-silver alloys have subtle tones of yellow. The gold -silver alloy only turn s white when the silver content approac hes seventy percent." Gold , howe ver , has a spec ific gravity (de nsene ss) o f 19.3, which make s go ld nearly twice as heavy by volume a s lead (1 1.34), silve r (10.5 ), copper (8.92 ) and iron (7.i'~6 ) . This s izea ble d iffere nce in density mea nt ancient balance scal es cou ld readi ly ferret out coi ns with a lower than e xpec ted gold con tent. The reaso n mene (count ed ) is repealed twice in Dan 0 5:25 is that coins represe nting the day s o f Belsha zzar's reign were co unted. T hen an eq ual numbe r of known good co ins or co in weigh ts we re co unted and lidded to the other s ide of the balance sca le. In order for Be lshazzar's "c o ins " to be acc eptable , they wo uld need to be gold, s ince in Neh uchadne zzars dr eam the statue's go lde n head represen ted the Babylonian kin gdom (Dan 02 :32, 31l ). In fact. the mention o f go ld, silve r and bronze describing Belsh azzar's fea st (Dan 05:02 . 04. 23) see ms to be an allusion to Ncbu chadncz za r's statue of Dan 02 . The go ld co ins o r co in weight s against w h ich Belshazzar 's "coins" we re wei gh ed perha ps represe nted the da ys of Nebuchadnezzar's re ign . Consider how Da niel mad e comparisons betwee n Bel shazzar and Be ls hazza r 's fath e r Nebu chadne zzar (Da n 05:18-22). The sca le tipped in favor o f the coi n weights (or Ncbuchadncz za r's gold coin s) which meant Belshazzar's reign was found wanti ng ( Id el).
Belshazzar 's rei gn was supposed to be more gold than silve r, but we ighin g pro ved h is reign wa s more silver than go ld. The read er will reca ll that the chest a nd arm s o f the statue were s ilver (Dan 02:32), which character ized the ne xt kingdom of the Medes and Per sians. So appropriately, Belshazzar's co ins, whic h were more s ilver than go ld, were div ided (pa {'\') among the Mede s and Pers ians (Dan 05 :21l). Sil ver was the eleme nt that comprised the statue's c hest and arms. Si lver was commonty alloyed with gold to make billon lind elect rum co ins. Gold co mprised the statue's head. Co pper was commonly allo yed with silver to make silver co ins. Copper a nd tin make the allo y bron ze. The statue's be lly and thighs ha ppe n to be made of bronze. Besid es bron ze's use in wea pons and too ls, bron ze was wide ly used in co inage . Most "cop per" co ins are, in fact, bronze, since copper in its pure form is soft. Copper is also susce ptible to tarnishing and wea r. So one c an see that fro m top to bottom. the baser metal in the alloy of one kingdo m becomes the domina nt metal of the next. The statue went from a goldsilv er alloy for the bead , to a silver-co pper for the che st and arms. to co pper-tin (hro n/.e) alloy for the belly and thigbs. Matenal com direlbs autcrars
138
Yael Na ta n
Just as adding too much silver de based gold coins, add ing too much co pper readily de based silver coins. Silve r has nea rly the same de nsity as copper ami other base metals, while gold is nearly twice as de nse silver and othe r base metals. Therefore, debased silver coins are harder to ferret out by use of sc ales than are debased gold coins. This fad meant ancient mints cou ld debase silver co ins with near impunity. Using modern, non-destructi ve techniq ues. numi smat ists commonly find that many ancient silver coins contain twen ty-five perce nt or less silve r! Some ancient co ins even have copper cores and arc ca lled "clad," "silver-was hed," "s ilvercoated" or "stfver-plate d." Such coins are "co mmo nly encountered and are know n co llectively as .w/merutll." "''' The Romans provide an example of how ingen ious debasing techniques became: In the later Roman Empire (3nl cen tury AD) silver issues were hea vily debased with copper; prior to st riki ng, the blanks were immersed in a n acid bath that leaehed out the surface copper to expose more silver. giving a muc h mo re acce ptable ap pe arance to the co ins when they were firs t issued ." IUl That a kingdom or co unterfei ter co uld profit imme nsel y by d eba sing silver re veals why medieval alc hem ists tried hard to produce a secret alloy of base metals that had the same properties as gold . The re also is a con nection between the bronte belly, the bronte thighs and t he iron calves: Bronze is harder than copper as a result of alloying that metal with tin or other metals. Bronze is also more fusible (i.e., more readilv melted) and is he nce easier to cast. It is also harder than pure iron and far more resistant to corrosio n. The s ubstitut ion of iron for bron ze in tools and weapons from aho ut 1000 BC was the result o f iron's ab undance compared to copper a nd tin rathe r than any inheren t advantages of [pure] iron .!" Wh m made bronze more expensive than iron was the scarci ty of tin . Thoug h co pper was plentiful, in ancient times the know n de pos its of tin were small, and these were found in remote locat ions such as Britain and Afghanistan. The scarcity of tin would have led to the ex tens ive use of iron at an earlier time if it were not for the fad that iron's high melting poin t ( 1,535 degrees Celsius) requ ired the development of techniques not nece ssary for copper and tin prod uction. Co pper and t in, when smelted toge ther, have a lo w melt ing po int of 950 de grees Cels ius. Sin" bronze is an alloy, different proportions of copper and tin have different properties : A low propor tion of fro m 2-9% tin to circa 90-9&% co pper produces a 'soft' bronze. T his is the a lloy usually used for casting coin Ilans and most other decorative , voti ve or practical artifacts .,.[co inJ d ies [for example] .. , co ntain variously from 18-22% tin resulting in a very hard cast object."" If enough tin is used. bronze is even harde r than pure iron. Weaponry. howe ver. was one appticerion where "carbunzcd' iron (" iron carbide' or "steel"] was better Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
139
tha n bronze. Iron became im pregn ated with ca rbo n by repeatedly being heated in ch arcoal fires durin g the smelting, forging and que nch ing (tem pering) processes. The hammering process d ro ve slag ou t o f Ihe iro n. and Ihe qu en ching process invol ved plun ging red-hot iron into water to turn the iron brittle . Upon reheatin g the brittle iron forms a crystalline mat rix that makes the iron du rable and springy. So Nebuchadnezzars sta tue's legs o f steel are a prophecy of the militarist ic ch arac ter of the Rom an Empire."" That the statue's legs were made of steel and its feet partly of iron shows tha t the real ce nters of power wou ld move our of the ironpoor Middle East to iron-rich Europe; Indian steel blades were still sought afte r. though by the ninth ce ntury they seem to have taken a back place to tho se from the Rhin eland .. . Bro nze was used to a much grea ter ex tent [in the Midea st] tha n in Europe pres umably because of the shortage of iro n in the Islamic world."'" Inte restingly, bronze was in short supp ly and ex pensive in Medi eval Europe with the res ult thai anc ient Rom an bronze stat uary was melted dow n while mar ble statuary was [eft intact. On ly nne Roman bronze statue has remained above gro und in Ita ly si nce it was made - Ihe equestrian Marcus Au relius in Rome. Th is fact once led a rch t::i.llogists to ass ume that Roma n statuary was made most ly of marble ra the r than bronze. "whic h is not nece ssarily true."!" That Europe had iron , and enough wood and coal to fire the iron , help ed propel Ch ristian Europe and Ihe Bible into Ihe world. Thus. at the very time the gospel and the Bible los t influence in the Middle Eas t, Europe was transformed fro m a bac kwater into an ex pans jomst power with g[nha[ reac h. The ne wly found lands also tended to have iron. limber a nd co al. This mea nt Noah's prophesy abo ut Japheth was fulfilled (Gen 09 ;27). Japheth's te rritory was e nlarged. espec ially whe n Euro peans se ttled ev erywhere land was sparsely po pulated - rel atively spea king. Christianity and the Bible spread glo bally. Truly, God d id determine when and where nations migrate and settle "so that men wou ld see k h im a nd pe rhaps reac h o ut for h im a nd fin d him " (Act 17:26-27). T here a b o was a con nectio n between the statue's feet that are a mi xture of iro n and clay. an d the statue's iron ca lves . Mo lten iron an d oth er me tals were com mon ly poured into d ay molds, Th e mold s we re formed usi ng the "lost beeswa x" meth od . Th e da y mold was not used again . bUI was bro ken up 10 uncove r the cast iron. C lay was used as a mold for iro n for Ihe very reason c ited in Dan 02: 43 - day and iron do not mix. Since the statue" feet were co nst ituted of iron st ill in the d ay mold, this meant the iron was not formed into weapons. T he irnn in the d ay was weaker. 10 0. since il was nol "carburized" into steel by going through the forging and que nching (te mper ing) proc esses. Iron, not steel, de scribes how the western a nd easter n Ro man Empires dis integrated into smalle r co untries that copied the Roman Republic and Em pires in many re spects . The co pycat states. ho we ve r. are nol tempered by cent ury after ce nt ury of warfare. Th ey are not as militaris tic as the Ro man Empire, at [east o n a long-term
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
' 40
Yael Na tan
basis on the order of ce nturies. Weak co untries o f cla y ofte n surro und the Roman copycat sta tes and shape the iron as tho ugh they were a mold or cast. In te restingly, during this last period of the wor ld, coinage of iron-lik e met als such as low-grade stee l and nicke l have nearly replaced go ld. s ilver. bronze and copper co inage. T his is e speci ally the ca se d uring ti mes of war. Furthermore , co ins made of a luminum circulate side by side with iron-like co inage. Because a luminum is reactive c hemically. it IICYer naturall y occurs as nugge ts or in veins. Aluminum , however, is abundant in rocks, vegetation, and animals. No nfer rou s metals like a luminum sho uld be considered pari o f the day of the statue 's feet along with the other components of cl ay: silicon (sand a nd q uartz). potassium oxide, calcium oxide, nitrogen and wha tnot.'!' So it see ms that iro n and day feet foreshadow the coin age of modern nation sta tes.
More on th e Trinity in Daniel The chapter on Hebrew collective no uns and the MT plurals appendix discuss the Trinitarian proof texts in Dan 04 -05 and 07 that involve plura ls nouns and pl ural verbs. T he Trinitarian proofs appendix di scusses Dan 09: 19. The So ng of Moses c hapter discusses the impl icutions of the Trinitarian texts in Dan 0 7.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Chapter 6 The Prophet Behind the Prophets
Introduction The purpose of this chapter is 10 show that the or prop hetic books should be read as the word s o f the prcincurnatc SOil. That the OT prophetic books can , for the most part. he unde rstood as the words of the Son implies Trinitarianism. The first person speech (fo r e xample. " I," " me," "my") that are not q uotations sho uld ge nera lly be co nsidered the words o f the Son. The SOil o ften refers 10 the Father and Spirit in the third person (for e xample. " he," "him," " his") . Quota tions mos t often are the words of the Father as quoted by the Son. T he few phrases and sect io ns that arc ob vious wo rds o f the prophe ts sho uld be con sidered mere interjections interspe rsed in what is otherw ise the Son's narrative. Isaiah Wa s a Proxy for the Prophetic Role of Yah veh th e Son Some have taught that Yahveh did not verbally inspire the OT prophets. So me say the OT prophet s only had a "feel" for what Yahveh migh t have sa id in a gi ven s ituatio n, T he prophets the n ga ve ve rbal message s, some o f whic h were collected a nd written do wn in a nthologies. These antholog ies survived on ly if reade rs of subseq uent generations thou ght the material wa s applicable to the ir times. T his [ow view of the canon and inspira tion invites critici sm . Cr itics might say the prophet and his listeoers mistook a prophet 's sanc tified sentime nts for the words of Yahveh (Ez c 13:02 -07 , 17; 22:2 8 ; see also Jc r 05:1 3: 18: 18: Hos 09:07 ). Yahveh, ho wever, wa rned the Israeli te s that they must di sce rn between sanc tified se ntiments and the inspired word of God: You m ust no t me ntion ' the oracl e o f rah veh : ag a in, because eve ry ma n's ow n word becomes his ora cle tJer 23:36a). vonven d id not ask the prophet s to be h is ghos tw rite rs or his ed ito ria l co lumn ists, God's idea of a prophet is ex pressed alread y in Exod us. God sa id: • ' He will speak to the people fo r yo u, and it will be as if he were yo ur mouth and as if yo u we re G od to him ' (Ex o 04 : 16 ), and
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
142
Yael Natan
• Then Yahvch sa id 10 Mose s. 'See, I have made )'011 like God 10 Pha rao h. and yo ur brothe r Aaron will be your prophet' (Exo 07:0 1). Yahveh said tha t he spo ke " by the hands" of the prophet s. The phrase " by the hand" po ints to " verbal inspira tion" rat her tha n an y wishy -washy, to uchy-feci )' type of insp iration . Unfo rtunate ly, mo st translations do not let Scripture clai m verbal inspiration for itself. f or instanc e, the phrase " by the hand" is co mmon ly mistranslated as " by." T he MT recen sion, however. litera lly say s " by the ha nd of' in dozens of passages. li Z One of Ihe " by the ha nd of' passages reads: By YOUT Spirit you adm onished them by the ha nd of your prophets (Neh 09:30). Another read s: I spoke 10 the prophets, ga ve the m man y visio ns and told pa rables by the hand of the prophets (Hos 12:1 0 ). The prophet's hand was a hand once removed from the anthropomo rphic hand of the Spi rit. who is som eti mes c alled the " hand of Yflh r eh." For instan ce, the ch ronicle r wrote: He [David ] gave him [Solomon] the plan s o f allthat the Spirit hall put in his mind for the courts of the temple of Yllhl'eh ( ICh 2&: 12). Theil David told Solomon: I have in writ ing from the hand of YlI hl'eh upon me. and he gave me unde rstanding in all the de tails of the plan (I Ch 28:19). So David ide ntif ied the ' hand of Yahveh ' (ICh 2& :19) as the Sp irit ( IC h 28:12). Ezek iel also ide ntified the " hand of YoIII'eh" that was upon him (Ez c 1JI :03; 03: 22) as the Spirit (Ezc 0 3: 14 ). So it see ms the phrase " by the hand" indi cates that the prophets' main co ntributio n to the Bible was taking dictation throug h the Spir it from the prcincarnate Son (Eze 43:10). The prophetic boo ks are not ju st the product of a co mmittee o n which God is a membe r. In fact, the pro phets o ften say that God is the rea l a uthor, for insta nce: • David : The Spir it of Yahvch spoke through me; his word was o n my tongue (2Sa 23:02 ), • Elijah : This is the Word of Yatreeh that he [the Word] spoke through his serv a nt Elijah (2K i 09:36), • Isaiah: T he visio n concerning Judah and Jerusale m that Isaiah so n of Amoz saw (l sa 01 :( 1). Al that time 1'(,/1\ ,(,h spoke throu gh Isaia h (tsa 20:( 2), • Jeremiah: The Word of Yahveh came to him [Jeremiah] .. .The Word of Yahveh ca me to me [Jere miah ) say ing (Je rOI:02 , ( 4 ). You [Yahl'eh] know I [Jeremiah] ha ve not desired the da y o f despai r. Wha t passes my lips is on behal f of your Presence s (Jer 17:1 6 ). Th e word tha t Yah veh spo ke con cerning Babylon,.. by Jere miah the prophet (Jc r 50:0 1). • Ezekiel : The hea ven s were ope ned and 1 saw visio ns o f God ... the Word of YlI hl'f'h came e xpresvly to Ezek iel the priest (Eze 01 :0 1. ( 3 ). YlI hl'(,h told
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewish Trinity
143
Ezekiel . ' So n of man. go 10 the house of Israel and speak my words to them' (be OH I4), • Hosea: The Word of Yilhreh who c ame to Ho sea .. .When Yah veh be gan to spea k thro ugh Hosea. Ya/lI'eh said to him." (Hos 0 1:01 -(2 ), • Joel: Th e Word of Yah l'eh who came to Joel (Joe 0 1:( 1), • Amos: Th e words of Amos ...[concerning] what he saw co nce rning Israel (Amo 01:(1). • Obadiah: The vis io n o f Obadiah. This is what the Lo rd Yahveh says abo ut Edom - we have heard news from Yohveh (Oha 0 1:(1 ), • Jonah : The Word of Yahveh came to Jonah (Jon 0 1:0I) , • Micah : The Word o f YaJII'd, who came to Micah...the vision he saw [ Mic 01 : 01) . • Nahum: The book of the vis ion of Nahum (Nah 0 1:0 I), • Habakkuk: T he o racle thai Habakk uk the prophet sa w (Hab 0 1:( 1), • Zephaniah: The Word of Yahw' h who c ame to Zep haniah (Zcp 01 :0 1). • H aggai : The Word o f Yoh veh came through the pro phe t Haggai ,. ,sllying (H ag 0 1:0 1). T hen the Word of Yilh ~'e h ca me through Haggai. the prop het. say ing (Hag 01 :(3), • Zechariah : The Word of Yah veh came 10 the pro phet Zechariah (Zcc 0 1:0 I), • Malachi ; An oracle of the Word of YaJm ;,II to Israel through the hand of my angel [malat'hi] (Mai O1:0 I), and • E lsew here: Do ze ns of o the r passag e s say that Ya hvc h spo ke t hrou gh the prophet s. lll Som eo ne might ask. " If Ya hl-ell is speak ing thro ugh the prophets. w ho is the spec ific pe rson o f the Trinity doi ng the speaking?" Som e Chris tians might say, "The Fa ther," s ince the y re member Yes/lila say ing tha t the Father tau ght Pete r ce rtain truths (Mat 16 :1 6- 17). Ynhul/ also sa id the Father gave him the words that he spoke (Jch 14:10, 24 ). Most Christ ians, howe ver, wou ld automatically think , " the Spirit." beca use: • The Spirit and the prophets are o ften associated (Num II :29 ; ISa 10:10; 19:20: Neh 09: 30 ; Zee 07: 12: Act 28:25; Eph 03:05), • Passages associ ate Dav id 's word s, espec ially h is Psa lms. wit h the Spi rit (I Sa 16: I 3; Mat 22: 43; Ma r 12:36 ; Act 0 I: 16; 04:25- 26 ), • Paul's stateme nt, ' Th is is what we spea k. no t in wo rds taught us by huma n wisdom . but in words taught by the Sp irit. e xpressing spiritual truth s in spi ritual words' ( ICo 02: 13). and • The wr iter o f Hebrews quote s Jer 3 1:33-34 and sa id that the Spirit was q uoting the Father ): The Ho ly Spi ri t a lso te sti fies to us , fo r aft er sayi ng , 'This is the cove nant that 1 [the Father] will make with them: ' After those days,' says the Lo rd [the Father). ' 1 will put my laws on their he art. I will al so write them on thei r mind;" the n he says [the Spirit q uotes the Father]. ' I will remember their sins and their iniq uities no mo re' (Heb 10: 15- 17 ).
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
144
Yael Natan
Peter. howe ver, wrote that the spirit of Christ spoke through the OT prophet s. especially of the Son be ing the future Messiah : Co ncern ing this salva tion. the prop hets so ught and sea rched d ilige ntly, who prophesied of the grace that would com e to you. sea rching for who or what kind o f lime the spirit of Ch rist, whic h was in them. pointed to. when he predicted the s ufferings of Christ, and the g lories that would fo llow them . To them it was revealed thaI they were sen . ing yo u and not them selve s whe n the y reve aled the things now announced 10 you thro ugh those who pre ached the gos pel to you by the Holy Spirit se nt out from heaven; whic h things angels desire to look into (I Pe 0 I:10-11). Re velation is the on ly NT hook tha t resembles the OT prop hetic hooks. The Apostle John wrote concerning Re velation that the r ather del ivered the revelation to Yn 'hua , and Yeshua de livered the re vel atio n to Jo hn thou gh the age ncy o f an angel: The apoc alypse of Ye.I'Illiti Christ that God [the Father] gave him [ Ye.~ IJua ] to show his [YesIJ ua's l ser vants what must soo n take place. li e [Yn hull ] made it known by send ing his [Yeslulll's l angel to his IYn hulI' s] servant. John (Rev 0 1:0 I j . In Revelation, Yt·.fIJua is identified as " the spirit of the prophet s." Yeshna said, " I, Yn·hua . ha ve se nt my angel" (Rev 22:16). Thi s meant Yn'hua was the " Lord, the God of the spi rits of the pro phets" w ho had "sent his angel" (Rev 2 2:06). Besides del ivering a me ssage through an angel. Yeshua also delivere d his message through the Spir it. Yeshua said: " have yet many thin gs 10 te ll you . but yo u c annot bear them now. Ho wever when he. the Spirit of tru th. has co me. he will guide yo u into all trut h, fo r he will not speak fro m himself; but whate ver he hears, he will speak. He will decla re to yo u things that are co ming. He will g lorify me, for he will take fro m wha t is mine , and will declare it to you. All things whatev er the Father has are mine; there fore I sa id that he takes of mine , and will declare it to you (Joh 16:1 2-15). Rev OJ and 22 and Joh 16 adeq uately explain ho w the writer of Hebrews co uld say the Sp irit rather tha n the Son quoted the Father in Jer 3 1::B-34 (He b 10:1 5-17, quoted abo ve). The cha in of transrnissiou for insp ired me ssage s we nt thus: Thro ughou t the OT prophet ic honks, gene ra lly the prein ca ma te Son spoke, or he quoted the Father. The Son then gave h is compiled message to the proph ets dir ectly, or through the agenc y of the Sp irit or an angel. In te re stingl y. sometime s a pro phe t ev e n spo ke as thou gh he were him self Yahl'eh the Son, and not just as a prophet inspired by the So n. The Son could have the prophet speak for him and as h im becau se the prophet had the " mind of C hrist" (ICo 02: 16 allu de s to Isa 40: 13). T he prophet s a lso had the spirit of Christ and the Hol y Spirit dwe lling in them (Rom 08 :09-1 1). An ex ample of a prophet speaking as the Son is when Jerem iah told his assistant to say over the Euphrates: Thu s shall Babylon s ink. and s hall not rise aga in becau se of the ev il that I will bring on he r (Jer 5 1:64) . Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
145
Though there is no q uotation formula, this is an ob vious qu ote of Yahreh. A pro phet's spiritual make up was the same as other believers throug h who m God c hose to speak (Mat 10:20; Rom 08: 15 , 26; G al 04 :06; Eph 06:18) . Paul helps el uc ida te the prophe tic phe nom e no n w hen he d e lved into what make s ge nuine to ngues-spe ake rs tick. Pau l sa id tha t tongu es-speake rs were no di fferen t fro m ot her Christians, e xce pt in on e point. Th ey had the gift of being able to verbalize. but not nece ssaril y unde rstand. so me o f what the Spiri t teaches huma n spirits to pray and prophesy. A tongues-spea ker ca n never ve rbalize or understand the to tality o f what the Spirit himself says wh ile plead ing a believer 's cause. Words can only express so much (Rom 08 :26 ). Paul said a person who spoke in tongu es utters mysteries with his spirit ( ICo 14:0 2, 14- 16, 32). Paul said that unless a to ngues-speak er ca n interpret what his spirit says, his mind is uninvo lved in the tong ue speak ing process (leo 14 :14, 20 ). Glossolalia witho ut inter pre tat io n is s imilar to mindlessly rec iting a so ng with ly rics in a fore ign lang uage. O f co urse , if someo ne is mista ken abo ut ha ving the g ift of tongues in the first place, he or she ju st mindle ssly babbles . The human spirit can pra y, sing and spea k in a mean ing ful foreign language inde penden t of Ihe mind . T he mind c an simultaneously carry out independent menta l proces se s such as prayin g. s ing ing and spea king in a mean ingful lang uage ( ICo 14: 10, 14, 15). Most bel ieve rs arc obliv ious to both the co mmunicat ions o f the Spirit within the m, and the prayers of their own human vpuit. Moreover, behevers ca n blurt o ut d ivinel y inspired speec h without know ing it [Luk 2 1:13- 15 l - j ust as t he unbel iever Caiaphas did (Joh I I :50-52). T he prop he ts we re co nsci o us o f, and wro te dow n, w ha t the Spi rit and the spirit o f C hrist taugh t thei r h uman spirit and mind to sa}'. T he prophets we re like tong ues-speaker s in that the words they jolted dow n ca me from the Son. The y d id not rumin ate on a subject and then write an es say in the ir ow n word s. As ranven said, the pro phet s spo ke visions "from the mo uth of Yclhr eh" (Jer 23: 16). The y did no t "follow their o wn spirit" (EJ.e 13:(13) and the " the delu sions o f the ir own minds" (Je T 14:1 4). The NT speakers and writers knew that some of the prophets' writing.s that do not look pro phetic at first glance arc indeed pro phet ic. The Psa lms, for example. do nOI loo k prophenc . however, some events described in the Psalms did not literall y happen to the Psalmists. Many of the e ven ts desc ribed in the Psalms d id , howe ver. happe n to the Mess iah . For instance: • The d isciples (Joh 02 :17 ) and Paul (Rom 15:02-03) applied Psa 069:09 to Ye,I'Il/IlI, • Peter also applied a verse from the same Psal m (Psa 069 :25 ) and a ver se from anothe r Psalm (Psa 109:08 ) to e vent s in Yeshua's life , and • Ye,I' llUli applied Psa 035:19 to himself (Joh 15:25). The Psalm s o ften read in the firs t person (I , me , my). and some Psal ms arc messiani c. T hese facts tend 10 show that reshua was the real Psalmist (Ac t 01 :20 ).
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
146
Yael Na ta n
Early on in Ye.\1Il1a's ministry. the d isciple s thought of the Psalms in me ssianic ter ms (Joh 0 2: 17 ). Yeshu a ma y have remind ed the Emma us disciples ( Luk 24: 27) a nd the twel ve d isci ples (L uk 24 :45 -47) that the Psal ms were me ssia nic. Perhap s this is why Pete r applied Psa 0 16: 10 to YesllU(/ at Pentecost (Act 02:29] 1). Matthew sa id Ye.\'hua fulfilled a Psal m's pro phecy by his activity of tell ing parables: I will open my mo uth in parab les; I will utter things hidden Si lK C the c reatio n of the wo rld (Psa 078 :02: Mat 13:33 ). That the Psalms were part of the Me ssiah's scri pt is co nsiste nt with Yes/ilia 's asse rtion that he did not spea k o r act extempora neously, btl! accord ing 10: • Scripture (Luk 04:2 1: Joh 13:18; 17;12; 19:24, 28; 19:36; AcI 0 1:16 ). and • What the Fathe r wanted (Jch 14:10 ). In the Psalm s. David ofte n spo ke in the fiN person (for ex ample , " I," " me: ' " my" ). Da vid d id not o ften use q uota tion form ulas. Us ually this wo uld ind ic ate that the au thor is speak ing his o wn words of h imsel f. Peter. however. said that what David described in the Psalms did not happen to Da vid. For ins tance , there was no O T application of Dav id 's wo rds: You will nOI ahando n me to the grave. nor will you lei ynu r Holy One see dec ay (Psa 0 16: I0). The OT writers, YC.I'hua , Peter and the NT C hurch. belie ved Ihal the Spiril spoke th rough Da vid (1Sa 16:13; Mat 22:43; Mar 12:36; Act 01 :1 6; 04: 25 ). Peter eve n ca lled David a prophet: Brothers, I ca n ten yo u confide ntly that the palriarc h Da vid died and was buried. and his tom b is here to this d ay. But he was a prophet [2Sa 23: 02 1and knew that God had promised him o n oat h that he would place one o f his desce ndants on his throne 12Sa 07:11-16 1. See ing what was ahead. he spoke of the res urrectio n of the C hri-a, that he was not aban do ned to the grave. nor did his body see deca y (Act 0 2:29-30). So Da vid se rved as a pro xy a nd as a type fo r the Messiah who is the antit ype. Isai ah also se rved as a prophetic pro xy j ust as David had. In the same chapter w here Paul sai d that Psa 0 16: 10 was me ssianic (Act 13:35-38), Paul sa id that Ye.lh,w is the Suffer ing Servant (Act 13:34 qu otes tsa 55:03lcom pare 2Sa 07: 15]l. Paul was merely agreei ng with Pete r who sa id the same thing cnruc r-c uuu Psu 0 16:10 was messiani c (Act 02:27-3 1). Another ex ample of where the NT writers read Isaiah as tho ugh the So n were speaking and quotin g the Father is where Matthew quotes Isa 0 7: 14: An this took place to ful fill what the Lord had said throu gh the prophet : 'The virgin will be with ehild and will give birth to a son. and the y will ca ll him Immanuel: which mea ns, 'God with us" (Mat 01:22-231. Another ex am ple whe re Mat thew knew Yahveh was speak ing is his q uote of H o~a 11:0 1: And so was fulfilled what the Lord had said th rou gh the pro phet: 'Out of Egypl I called my son' (Mal 02: 15),
Malenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewish Trinity
147
Anothcr instance is Paul's allusion to l sa 26:19. Isaiah sa id on be half of the future Messiah: Your dead sha ll live [just as] my dead body, they shall arise . Paul wrote : Christ has indeed been raised from the dead , the first frui ts of those who have fallen asleep . For since death came throu gh a man, the res urrection o f the dead co mes also through a man. For as in Adam all d ie , so in Chri st all will be mad e ali ve ( ICo 15: 20-22). Ano ther instance of a n Isaiah e xce rpt he ing read as tho ugh C hrist were the speaker is provided by Joh n (loh 12:38) and Paul (Rom 10: 16- 17).' ]4 The eve nt described by Isaiah occ urred during the life of Ch rist: Who has belie ved our message'! And to whom has the arm o f Yahvc h been re vealed? ( lsa 53:0 1). Pau l wrote: And Isaiah boldly says . ' 1 was fou nd by those who d id not see k me; I revealed mysel f to those who did not ask for me.' But co nce rning Israel he says, 'All day long I have held out my ha nds 10 a disobedient and obstin ate people ' (Ro m 10:20-2 1). Pau l sure ly understood that Isaiah was q uoting Ya/weh"s wo rds. s ince Isaia h wo uld not talk as thou gh he we re God. Also , Yes/lila said that Isa 06:09-10 was fulfilled in Mat 13:14-[5: In them the prophecy of Isaiah is fulfilled, which says, ' By hearing yo u will hear, and will in no wa y understand; see ing you will see , and will in no wa y percei ve; for this peo ple 's heart has grown callo us, their ears are d ull of hearing , they have closed their eyes; or else perhaps they might perceive with thei r eyes, hear with their ears, understand with the ir heart, and sho uld turn again; and I would heal them' (Mat 13: 14-15). The writer of Heb rews a lso read Isa iah as though the Messiah were the speake r. The au thor of Hebre ws said that Isa OR: 17-1 R appl ied to Yeshua: Again, ' I [the Messiah ) will put m)' trust in him.' Again. "Beho ld, here am I and the children [believers (Joh 17: 12)] whom God [the Father] has give n me ' ( Heb 02:(3). The writer o f Hebrews knew it wa s not unusua l for God to say that he had childre n (l sa 45: I I: Jer 10 :20 ; Lam 01: 16; Eze 16:21 ). so Christ eo uld say he had children. too, Another instance of Isa iah bein g read as though Chr ist were the speaker is Yex /llIa ' s saying he was the speaker of Isa 29: 13 (Ma t 15:07 -0 R): You hypocrit es! Well d id Isaiah prophesy of you. say ing. "T hese people dra w near to me with thei r mout h, and honor me with their lips; bu t their heart is far fro m me ' (Mat 15:07-(8 ). Ye,511uQ also said that Isa 61:0I-02a was fulfilled in Luk 04:17-19 (compare lI eb 10:07. 09): The book o f the p rophet Isa iah was handed to hi m, He o pe ned the book. and fo und the place where it was writte n: ' The Spirit of the Lord is
Matenal com direlbs
autcrars
148
Yae l Na tan
on me. becau se he has anointed me to preach good news to the poor. He has sent me 10 healthe brokenhearted. to proclai m rel ease (0 the captives, recovering of sight 10 the blind, to del iver those who arc crushed, and 10 proc laim the acce pta ble year o f the Lord ' (Luk 04:17- 19). Other sec tio ns in the prophetic books that sho uld be considered me ss ianic incl ude Jer 11 :18- 12:17. 15: 10-21 and 17:14-18. Al so messia nic are those sections that disc uss the Shephe rd in Zechariah . s ince Yes/ili a sa id he was the S hep herd of Zec 13:07 (Mar 14:27). Eve n the ea rly Ch urc h fathers knew that the prop he ts we re prop he ts on ce re moved from the real prophet. Thai is why the c urly Ch urch fathe rs interpreted so me phrases and sec tio ns as pro phecies thai a quick perusal migh t not reve a l In he prop hecie s, for instance, Psa 02 2: 16. So meti mes the assessment that the Son is speaking d irect ly thro ugh the OT prophe ts is not borne o ut by the punctuation mark s. Th is is because the original Heb rew text d id not have punctuation marks. T he Masoretes first add ed di acritical marks and punctuation to the Hebre w tex t in the s ixth through n inth ce nturies AD. The result was the Masoretic Text (MT l recensio n. Unfo rt una tely, the int e nded se nse o f t he o rigin al ma y not have bee n as imponant as what appealed to the Masorete s' unitari an se nsibilities. That the MT is a recen sion mean s the com pilers were free to c hoose what read ing to fo llow and what rea ding to discard or footnote. T he e xact crite ria that the Masoretes used to determ ine the co rrect readin g are sketchy. Tran slators also feel the y have a lice nse to force passages to read as though the prophe t were the o ne spea king or quoting. Texts that do not confo nn to translato r e xpectatio ns regularly have their pronouns a nd punct uation adju sted. In this way. the Son is excised out of Scripture . and most o f the Trinitarian Scripture is made into unitarian literature. Ma ny e xamples of te xtual change s will be g ive n lat e r. Here , ho we ver, is an example of a Trini ta rian passage bein g changed to conform to the unitarian se nsibilit ies of the translators . The Son quoted the Father who said: I [the Father] ov e rth re w some of you as Go d [the Son] overthrew Sodom and Gomorrah (Amo 04: I Ia). Though the MT and LXX both have "G od: ' the NI V translators thought that ch anging "Goo" to the pronoun 'T' would ma ke better sense. Whene ver third person speec h-a-where God speaks o f God, is changed to first person spee ch, another Trinitarian proof text is lost in translation. A similar change is made in Hos 12:U4 where the last wo rd in the Hebrew, " us," is re ndered as "hi m" in the NIV. Still. eve n in translation so me passages are best understood as tho ugh the Son we re speaking or qu ot ing the Father. For instan ce , whe n Isa iah talked to King Ahaz, the narrator wrote the very telli ng phrase , "Again Yahveh spoke 10 Ahaz" (lsa 07: I 0). ELsewhere , the narrator said: At that time Ya hn "h spok e by Isaiah the son of Amoz, saying... (Isa 20:02).
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewish Trinity
149
Yahveh eve n told Isaiah 10 take OUI a " large" scroll and a pen to take dow n dictation (lsa 08:0 1)! Isaiah so me times menti oned Yahveh spea king words 10 him directly (lsa 0 I:02: 08:05, II : 20:02 ; 29:11-12, 18; 30:08; 34 :16). Examples where the prophetic ex pe rie nce in vol ved minimal in put by the prophe ts include Eze kiel's saying tha t he saw "God's visio ns" (Ezc 0 1:0 1; 08: 08-04 ; 11 :24: 40:02). Ezekie l said that the "vision I had seen went up from me" tE ze 11:24 ). That Ezekiel wrote dow n what God was seeing and saying about the visio n becomes e vident when Ezek ie l wrote, "l destroyed the city" (Eze 43 : ( 3 ). Unfort una tely, the "I" in the MT rece nsion is often translated as "he ." This masks the fa ct that Ezek iel is recording Yahl'eh's words d irectl y. It was God who envisioned destroying the city. as Ezekiel wrote: It was acc ording to the appearance of the vision that I saw, even according to the vision that I saw when I came to destroy the city ( Eze 43:03). Anot her e xa mple where the prophe tic e xper ie nce in vo lved minimal inpu t by the prophets comes from the NT. Paul said that everyone prese nt co uld hea r what the Son had said to him, but o nly Paul actually saw the Son (Act 09:(7 ). So so metimes bein g a pro phet req uired no special prophet ic insigh t o r presci ence, b ut mere ly the ability to ta ke dictation. Malachi is the best e xample of a prophet who is a mouthpiece. In fact, it is no t known whether there really was an ac tual prophet named "Malac hi." Malachi is discussed further at the e nd o f this c hapte r. When a prophet spo ke in the fiN person (I , me, my) withou t an)' q uo tation for mulas, such as "thus says Yah l'h:' this is likely the word s of YlI hreh the Son. When the So n spoke of, but does not quote, the Father or the Spirit. he uses third person speec h (for exa mple, " he: ' " him: ' " his"). For instance, in the following sec tio n, Ya h eh the Son refers to the Father, the Mo st High, using the pronoun " he": My [t he So n' s ] people are det erm ined to turn from me [the So n ]. Though they cal l to the Most High [the Father] , He [the Father] certainly will not e xalt them. How ca n I [the So n] give yo u up, Ephra im? How ca n I [th e So n] hand yo u o ve r, Isr ae l? 1I0 w can I [the Son ) ma ke yo u like Admah? How can I [the Son] make you like Zebo iim? My [the Son's] he art is turned within me [the So n]. My [the So n's] co mpassion is aroused. I [t he Son] will not e xec ute the f ierc e ness of my (t he So n's ] an ger. I [the Son ) wil l not retu rn to destroy Ephraim: ~or I [the Son ] am God [the So n], and not man [this is the premcamate So n spea king ): the Ho ly One [th e Son] in t he midst o f you: And I [the Son1 will not come in wrath (Hos 11:07-09). Peter mdicated that the perso n of Ya /H 'ell speaking using fir-s t pe rso n speec h througho ut Isa iah is spec ifically t he So n ( I Pe 0 1:10 -1 1). Thi s assertion is co nsistent with the pronou n usage in Isaiah. T here are eve n passages whe re God uses direct speec h and mention s both the Father and Sp irit in the third pe rson, fo r instance, see Isa 34:16 and 48:12- 16 in the Trinitarian proofs appendix. By Matenal com direlbs autcrars
150
Yael Na ta n
the process of elimina tion. one can determine that the person of Yclhl'l.'h who is speaking in Isa 34:16 and 4R:12- 16 is the Son. Double Quotation Formulas When there is a dou ble q uotatio n form ula such as: lIear you the Wo rd [the Son! of Yahve h [the Father]. 'Thus says the Lord Yahw;,h (the Father]' (Eze 13:02b-03a), the prop het is te lling his liste ne rs to hear the words of the Son who then q uotes the Father. So the first phrase is spoken by the prophet, a nd the second phrase is spo ken by the Son. Double quota tion form ulas are found ofte n in the OT. lJ ~ Furthe rmore. the phrase "the Word came" followed by the words "Thus says .. ." sho uld also be cons idered a dou ble q uotatio n formula. T his formula is used to indicate that the prophe t quoted the Son's q uotatio n of the Father 's direct speech Ocr 2 1:01. 04; 25:01-05; 26:0 1-02; 27:01-02; 34:0 1-02; 34:0&. 12-1 3; 44:01-02. The Prophets were Sometimes 11 Proxy for the Priestly Role of Yahveh the Son When Isaiah pleaded with God concerning the sinfu lness of his people and eve n of himself. this is the Spirit and the So n in action working through Isaiah. Il~ As Paul said: The Spirit he lps us in our weakness. We do not know what we oug ht 10 pray for. but the Spirit himself intercedes for us with g roans that words cannot express. And he [the Father] who searches our hearts knows the mind of the Spirit. because the Spirit intercedes for the saints in accor dance with God's [the Father's ) will (Rom 08 :26-27; see also 10h 03 :06; Rom OR :16 ). Here Paul is saying that since the Father knows every thought of the Spirit. the Spirit's intercessi on need not be audible. Paul a b o said the spirit of the Son intercedes for believers : God sen t o ut the spirit of his Son into yo ur hearts, crying. ' Abba, Father !' (Gal 04:06; sec a lso Rom 08 :15- 16). So when Isaiah seems to co nfess the si ns of himself and of the nation Israe l (for instance, Isa 06 :05), that really is Yahreh the So n act ing as the ultimate priest thro ugh his proxies - the prophe ts. Isaiah wrote: Thus says your Lord Yahveh [the Father], and your God [the Son], who pleads the cause of his [the Son's] people (Isa 51:22; see also Jdg 10:16; Psa 043:0 I; Mic 07:09; Heb 02: 18; 04: 15). The re arc instances, howe ver, where the MT recension has the Son confess ing sin where the LXX does not , for exa mple. Jet 04:0&: • LXX: For these things gird yourselves with sack clothes. and lament, and howl : for the anger of the Lord is not turned away from you. • MT: For this, gird on sackcloth, lament and howl. for the fierce anger of ranven hath not turned back from us [Son and Israeli .
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
151
So meone might think it unsee mly fo r the So n to be confessing the sins of the people as thnu gh they we re his ow n sins -i-us he doe s in Psa 069 :05. The alternative. however. is that the prophet co nfessed the sins of others as though the y were h i ~ ow n. The OT prophets were not the ones co mmitt ing g ro~~ sin and idolatry, however. So the issue is a non- issue. a non starter. Besides, the So n is not o nly a prophet, but also a priest and king and even a sacrif ice for sin. So who better than the Son could con fess the s ins of others as though the y were his own '! The Priest in Isaiah Was Also the Sacrifice The Son is not o nly the ultimate priest. hut also the sacrifice (Heb 07:27; 09: 14. 28; Act 08:32-33). T hat Isa 53 spoke of the So n as a sacrifice was con firmed when the eunuch asked Philip about Isa 53:07-08: Tell me. please. who is the prophet talking about. himself or someone e lse? (Act 08:34). Luke wrote: Philip then began with that very pass age of Scri pture [Isa 53:07-08] and told him the good news ahout Ye l'huo (Act 08 :35). The Son confessed the sins of the people. This is si milar to how the OT priests confesse d the sins of the people o ver the sacr ificia l lamb and o ver the scapegoat (Lev 16:21 ; Isu 53: 10; I Pc 03: 18). Since the Spirit and the So n dwell in Chris tians. and the Son takes huma nity's sins on himself, God him self becomes afflicted when his peop le are afflicted (Isa 63:09 ; Act 09:(4). In this way, God thnmu ghl)' identifies himself with his people (Mat 10:40; 18:05: 25:40.45. and the like). Since the So n became the scapegoat, he was afflicted for the sins of hi.s people ( Isa 53:04 : Jer 15:10-21; Mat 08:17; 2Co 05:2 1; Hcb 09 :26. 28; 10:10: I Pc 0 2:24). So he can associate with sinners (Mat 27:43; Luk 07 :39; 19:07 ). and allow himself to be thought of as a sinner (Psa 069:04; 10h 09 :24), and even as a criminal (Isa 53: 12; Mar 15:28; Luk 22:31). Whe n we read Isaiah saying that he is sinful (l sa 06: 05 ), it really was YollI,,,h the So n talking through Is.aiah -talki ng as a scapegoat wou ld. The Son shou ld be seen as the ultimate speaker behind the statement: We [the Son and belie vers ] all , like sheep, have gone astray, each of us has turned to his own way; and Ya/weh [the Father) has laid on him [the Mess iah] the iniqu ity of us all (the Son and belie vers] (lsa 53:06: see also Heb 10:10-12). Interestingly, there are instances, such as Jer 10:18-20, where the MT rece nsion has the So n suffering punis hment for sin where the LXX does not. T he LXX translators merely translated the first perso n pronouns in the MT as third person pronouns 10 keep the prophet from suffering punishment for sin. The trans lators evidently did not realize that the Son wo uld suffer as a scapegoat.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
15 2 Yah~'eh
Yael Natan the Son Can Properly Call
Yah~eh
the Father " My Goo" and "Ou r Goo"
Though the Servant of Yah veh ca lled himse lf Yohveh (Isa 6 1:0&), the Se rvant of Yaln'eh also calls the Fathe r " my God" (l sa 07: 13; 25:0 1: 49:04: 6 1:10) and "our God" (Isa 01 : 10: 40:08 ; 57:0 7; 6 1:06). A critic migh t say thai this di sproves the Trinity, or at least it di sprove s that a ll three mem bers are eq ual. Thi s criuc ism. howeve r. can be countered j ust like all) ot her straw arg ument. Trinita rians do no t try to prove thai the three persons o f the Trinity are the sa me - j ust equal. There arc not three Fathers. but rather the Fathe r. SOli and Spirit! Moreo ver , Scripture ex plicit ly slates that the Son humbled hi mse lf and took on the form o f a man (Phi 02:08). So a passage showing that the Son submits to the Father do cs 1I0t prove the So n's substance is infe rior 10 that of the Fathe r's. S ubord ina te does no t nece ssar ily mean in fe rio r- as an y prince studying with a tutor realizes soone r o r later. A cr itic might also say that the phrase " my God" sho ws the speake r must hav e bee n the prop he t, or an yone other than the SOli. There arc sev eral poss ible respo nses 10 this c rit icism. To start. the issue is not as important as il migh t see m stanstically. The LXX often does not has the " my God" and "o ur" God" reading when the MT recen sion doc s. This is significant beca use , though the NT write rs has: • Yex/ma say ing, " my God ," a few times (fo r instance , Mat 27:46: Joh 20: 17; Rev 03:12), and • The Father be ing " his IYe.~"lIa 's l God" (Re v 01:(6), the number o f these occurre nces is not so great that it suggests Yr.I'hul/ was on ly a man and not the God -man . So the book of Isaiah can still be viewed as though the Son were the author. just as so me Psa lms arc viewed a s messiani c. though David used wo rds such as "my God" (for ex ample. Psa 0 22:0 I (LX X 02 1J JI Apparently. jhe scribes, espe c ially Ihe Soferim. "e mended" Ihe MT rece nsio n to ma ke the prophet s sound more human. humble and polite. Ho we ver. they did not gi ve due consideration to the d ivine orig in o f the prophets ' words (JeT 08:08-09: Hos 08:12 : Mal 15:06 ). T he Soferim were like the Israel ite s who did not want to hear the direct speec h of Yah veh , bUI onl y wa nted 10 hear Mose s' rendition of what Yahl'eh told him: Speak to us yo urse lf and we will listen. But do nOI have GrM:I speak 10 us or we will d ie (Exo 20:19: see also Dell 04: 33: 0 5:24-28 ; 18:16- 17; Jer 20:09; 36:32; Heb 12: 19 ). The sc ribes wou ld not be the las t people to mistake the humannes s of God 's se rvants as ev ide nce for the human origin of the ir: • Words (Joh 14:10, 24 ), • Dccd s tMar 11:27.29-33; Jo h05: 19).or • Perso n (Luk 0 3:23). For instance , thou gh many wo uld think that Ya hl'eh is talking to Jeremiah in Jer 25:15- 16 , a c areful reading suggests that the Father is talk ing to the Son .
n.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
153
The LXX (second or third century BC) is much older tha n the MT recension (tenth ce ntury AD), a nd t he LXX predates the Trinitarianism vers us unitarianism debates on reco rd. So o ne can assume tha t at lea st in areas affect ing the doct rine of God , the LXX would mort; o ften re flect the original te xt. What one finds is that in one area where the LXX hints of the Trinity, the MT was changed so the autho r of prop hetic books became merel y human. For instance: • The prop het sa id "o ur God" in the MT recensio n. but not in the LXX (Isa 0 I:10; 35:02 : 55:07; 6 1:02. 06 ; Je r 08:1 4 : 14: 22: 23:36: 3 1:06; 37:03; 42: 20: 43:0 2; Hos ORJJ2; Joe OI:16; Zec 13:0 9 ), • The prophet sa id " my Go d" in the MT rece nsion. but not in the LXX (lsa 0 7:1 3; 25:0 1; 57:2 1; 6 1: 10: Hos 09:08, 17; Joe 0 1:13; Hab 01 :12; Zec II :0 4 ), and • The prop het sa id " my Lo rd" in the MT recen sion, but not in the LXX (ls a 2 1: 08). A search sho ws that the LXX has: • Fewe r instan ces of the prophet say ing, " my God : ' tha n in the MT recensio n (lsa 12:0 2; 33: 22: M ic rJ6:rJ6; Hah o I: II ), • Fewer instances of the prop het saying, "o ur God," than in the MT rece nsion (I sa 26: 12; 35:04: Jer 23:3 8; 4 2:04; 46:10), and • No instan ce s of " my Lo rd," o r "our Lord" when the MT rece nsion docs not say the same . Here arc so me e xa mples o f ho w the c hanges in the MT recensio n tend to de mote the au thor fro m being the creator to being a crea ture: • lsa tll : ](J: o LXX : Listen to the law of God o MT: Listen to the law o f ou r God • Isa 07 : JO,13: o LXX: T he Lord again spoke to Ahaz .. .will yo u also co nte nd against the Lord '! o MT: Again Yahveh spo ke to Ahaz ... will yo u also weary my God ? • Isa 25:01 : o LXX : 0 Lord G od, I will glor ify you o MT: Yahveh: yo u are my God • Isa 32:15 o LXX : until the Sp irit sha ll come upon you o MT: until the Spirit is po ured o ut on us • Isa 33:14 o LXX: W ho will tell yo u that a fire is kindled? Who will tel l yo u o f the eterna l place? o MT: Who o f us can d well with the con suming fire? Who o f us can d well with e verlasting burning'! • Isa 35:02 : o LX X: ,. . the maje sty of G od o MT: ... the e xcellency o f o ur God
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
154 •
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Yael N ata n
lsa 47:04: o LXX : Yo ur deli ve rer is Yahveh o MT: Our Redeemer, vah veh lsa52:1O: o LXX : sa lvatio n o f God o MT: salvatio n of our God Isa 55:07: a LXX: Let him ret urn to the Lord. and he shall find mercy: fo r he shall ab unda ntly pardon your sins. a MT: LeI him tum to Yahveh .. .and to o ur God, fo r he will frecly pardon. Isa57 :2 1: o LXX : 'T here is no joy 10 the ungodl y: sa id God o MT: ' The re is no peace,' says my God. 'for the wicked.' Isa 6 1:0 2: a LXX: .. .rhe day o f recompense, to com fort all that mourn o MT: . ,.the day of vengeance of our God. to co mfo rt al l who mourn lsa 6 1:06: o LXX: You shall be called .. .ministers o f God o MT: You will be named miniererv o f ou r God Isa 6 1: 1O: o LXX : lei my so ul rejoice in the Lord a MT: My soul rejo ice s in m}' God Joe OI :1 3 a LXX: .. .yo u who minister to God a MT: ... you who minister befo re my God Joe OI:16 a LXX: Yo ur meat has bee n destroyed before your eyes, joy and g lad ness from out of the house of yo ur God. a MT: Is not the food c ui offbefore our I:YI: _~, joy and gladness from the house of our God? Mic 05:05-o6 1BHS 05:04-051 : o LXX: When Ashur shall co me into you r land, and when he shall co me up upon yo ur co untry. .. .and the re s hall be rai sed up aga inst him seven shepherds .. .a nd He [the Messiah] shall deli ver you from the Assyrian. when he shall co me upon your land. and when he shall invade your coasts. a MT: When the Assy rian in vade's our land and marc hes through o ur fortresses, we will raise against him seve n shepherds... He [the Messiah] will deliv er us fro m the Assyrian when he invades o ur land and marc hes into our borders. Ha b OI :1 2: o LXX : 0 Lord God, my Holy One a MT: My God , my Ho ly One Z I:C II :04 o LXX : Thus says the Lord Almighty Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
155
o MT: This is what Yah ~'l'h, my God, says • Mal 02;10 o LXX : Did not one God create yo u? o MT; Did no t o ne Go d crea te us'! Many manuscripts, e ven a mong the Dead Sea Scrolls. e stablish ho w the LXX read a century or mo re before Ch rist's time. The LXX. generally speaking, was trans lated from o ne family o f Heb rew manu script s wh ile the MT rece nsion was compiled from anothe r famil y. A co mpar ison of the MT recension with the famil y of Heb re w man uscripts that led to the LX X helps to sho w whe re the co pyists and scribes (e specia lly the Sojerim ) made inad verten t o r inten tional c hanges in the MT recensio n. Here a re two mor e e xamples of where the MT and LXX differ. and where the Soferim ma y ha ve made the changes: • Gen 0 2:1 8: o LXX : " And the Lord God sa id, ' It is not good tha t the man should be a lone , let us make [plural verb] fo r h im a help suitable to hirn.?' o MT: " I will make ...·• rather than " Le t us make .. .,'" • Neh 09 :18: o LX X: Nehe miah recou nted the golde n ca lf incide nt using plural no uns and plural verbs: .. .the y even made to them sel ve s a moll en calf, and said, "These are the Gods that bro ught [plura l] us up o ut of Egypt' (LX X Ne h 09:1 R), a nd o MT: The HH S ha s the s ingular form " bro ught." hut the HHS cr itical apparatu s says that the LX X and many Hebre w manuscripts have the plural fo rm "brought." Co mparison of sections of the OT sho ws how changes were made fro m time to time. For instance, the poetry sec tio ns were ha rder to edi t, and so they te nd to have more archai c Hebrew, By cont rast. prose sections ha ve less archaic He brew. That changes wer e made ex pla ins why: ,. ,few traces of dia lects e xist in Biblical Hebre w,., scho lars belie ve this to be the res ult of Masoretic edit ing of the text. l IT Syste matic ed iting resu lted in the bifurcatio n o f the Hebre w into families that led to the MT recension and the family on whic h the LXX was based. If ed its were rarely made. there wou ld only be o ne fam ily with variant readings. Comprehensive ch ange s are only possible when a fam ily of manuscripts is in the hand s o f a few peop le. Then all co pies not ma rked "offic ial" can eventually be d iscarded or destroyed. Wh ile co mprehensive c hanges in the LX X we re not possible afte r the third century Be due 10 the popularity of the LXX, pornons of the MT may ha ve been cha nged up to the ti me of the Masore tes (6th to 10th ce nturies AD), It was the n that the Masoretes standardized the text to c reate the MT rece nsion (lob 05: 12). During the recen sion proce ss. the MT fa mily' likel y underwent the most radica l changes. Th e reaso n is that a unitar ian bia s rather than statist ica l analysis dererrnined what read ings become the standa rd. Matenal com direlbs autcrars
156
Yael Na tan
Hu manizing the prophets, as was d iscuss ed ab o ve, co uld not und o a ll the Trinitarian ism inhcrent in the MT. T hc Gr eck LXX and MT recension still agree co nce rning most Trinitarian proo f tex ts. For instance , the " us" referring 10 Yah veh still survives in both the MT recens ion and the LXX in several places (Ge n 01 : 26; 03 :22; I I:07; Isa 06:08). However, only the LXX retains the " us" referring to Yuhl'eh in Gen 02 : IR. Por ce ntunes the LXX was held in h igh regard. T he Je wish establishme nt d id not consider the LXX translators suspect until afte r Christianity adopted the LXX as its de facto official translation . Even then, the LXX remai ned in usc in the sy na go gues unti l at lea st 130 AD when Aqu ila's Greek translatio n was first introd uced. Aqui la's trans latio n was produc ed under rabbinic supervisio n. The histor y of the LXX shows that we can be sure the LXX tra nslators d id not insert Tr initarian lang uage based on a whim or here tical noti ons. Trinitarian pfl)o fs that survived in the MT recension arc no t necessaril y more legit ima te than those found in the LXX. Th ey were ju st so well kno wn that MT editors co uld not ax the m. MT ed its tend ed to make the MT more unitarian and less Trinitaria n. Trinitarian proo fs had to surv ive the anti-Trini tari an bias of unitarian Sofe rim scnbes. and the unitarian bias o f the Masore tes who com piled the MT rece nsio n. T he provenance !" o f surviving Tr initarian tex ts must have been so und. or e lse the y would not ha ve esca ped the e raser and sc issors century a fter cen tur y. Less known Trini tarian proofs such as the " us" in Gen 02: 18 were not safe from tampering hands. T bcsc passa ges tende d to acc umulate variant readings, becau se unitaria n copyists would assume a plural referr ing to Yi/hl'eh was a mistake. Then whe n it carne time to co mpile a recen sion , the manu scripts with the uni tar ian reading wo uld outnumber manusc ripts with the orig ina l Tr initarian read ing. So o ne ca n be sure that any Tri nitarianism remaining in e ither the MT rece nsion or the Gre e k LXX was a pa n o f the inspired or iginal. Th is wou ld be in accordance with the exege tica l principle: durior tecno praefe ratur, meaning, " the harsher read ing is to be prefe rred."!" In this case . the "harsher' read ing wo uld be the Trinitarian reading, and the mo re palatable read ing wo uld be the unitarian reading. Another response concerning the Son say ing. " my God: ' and "our God" is that cnncs read more into the " my God " and "our God " stateme nts than is warranted. The Son ca n still be d ivine and refer tn the Father as " his God." ju st a s: • The writer of Hebrews says that the Fathe r addre ssed the Son as "God " in Psa 04 5:06-07 (Heb 01 :08), • Ycshua said that the Father addressed him a s "G od" (Ps a 01l2:011 ; Joh 10: 36a). • The Fathe r ca lled the Son " my King" (Psa 00 2:07 ), and • The Me ssiah is the Father's (vyo ur") " Holy On e" (Psa 0 16: 10). So the Son's calling the r athe r " my God " doc s not necessarily prove an involun tary sub ordination on the pan o f the Son Be sides. Paul e xplained why the Son called the Fath er his God. Paul said that thou gh the So n is equal to the Father, w hen the Son becam e the God -m an, he voluntaril y subord inated himse lf so that the Father 's wish became his command (Mat 06 : W ; 26:42; Hcb 10:07, 09 ). Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
157
In Paul's words. Yes/ilia is "in very nature God, [but) d id not conside r equality with God so me th ing to he hel d de arly" ( Phi 0 2:(6). After the res urrect ion. however, Yesh ,w was exalted to be Most High along with the Father (Phi 02:09I I ). Ye,~llUa 's exaltatio n is d iscussed further in the Song o f Moses c hapter. Who is th e Aut hor Behind t he Aut hor in l\Iala chi? The Tt/le Mu ltlt'hi " Malach i" means " my messenger" in Hebre w. Nothing is kno wn abou t a man named Malach i who might be the author of Malachi. The title may refer to the Son , who was o fte n called the Maid YahH,II in the OT. T he So n was a lso the Malek with the Father 's Name. rahveh , "in him" (Exo 23:2 1). The Fa ther even referred to the So n as "Malach i" (Exo 23:23; 32:34). The name Malachi could refer to an angel that Yahl'eh the Son had sent. For instance. Yes hua refe rred to a cre ature a ngel (Rev 22:08-09) who m he had sent as " my a ngel" ( Rev 22 :16). Ma lachi could refe r to a prophet or prie st s ince prophets (Hag 0 I: 13) and priests (Mal 0 2:07) were called matcks. However. eve n if the re were a person named Malachi, the name ultimately refers to the Son in the amitypc-typal sense . This wou ld be similar to how a priest-k ing was named Melch izedek, bur the name is a theophoric name referring to Melc hizedek's God , Yahveh, "Mclchizcdc k" means " My King is Righteou sness" (Ge n 14: I8), The Gree k LXX lists the book's title as "His Malek," rather than " My Malek." Thi s is s ignific ant because it ind icates the LXX trans lators tho ught " Malach i" was not a proper name. Otherw ise. they might have transliterated the Heb rew name directly into Greek. Th is rna}' indir.:ate that the LXX translators thought "M alachi" referred to the Malek Yanveh, who is called " his Ma lek" (Dan 03:28; Oc n 24:07, 40 ; Dan 06:22). Of course. " his angel" may refer to an angel sent by the So n (Act 12:1 1.1 5; Rev 0 1:0 1; 22:06), In any eve nt. as with the name Mek hizedc k, the LXX name " His Mu lek" ultimate ly points to the Malek vah veh who ins pired the whole 0'1' (I Pe 0 I: I0-1 1 was d iscussed ab ove ). The Rook. of Malachi Itself Provides (11/ Il/siMh f Whether an angel o r a prophet named Malachi del ivered the words of the Son, ultimately the Malach i behind the Malachi is the Son . T his is co nsistent with the opening line of the book : The oracle of the Word [the So nI o f Yahveh [the Fat her] to Israe l hy the ha nd of my [the Son's] angel [nwlcwhi] (Ma l 01 :0 1). If the "my nwlek" (malachi) in the ope ning line refers to a pro phet. this shows the prophet's con tribution to the book was merely taking dictat ion. If the Son were the Malachi. this would be es pecially ap prop riate. Then the Son would begin the OT by creating the universe (Ge n 0 1:0 1-0 3; 10h 01: 0 1-(3). and end the OT as the last prophet. Malachi. Sim ilarly, Yeshua bega n the NT as the subject of four biographies called the Gospels, and ended the NT as the main d ivine speaker of
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
158
Yael Na ta n
Revelation (Rev 22: 16. 20). By bookending both the Old and New Testaments. the Son truly is the Alpha and O mega, the Beginning and the End (Rev 21 :06: 22: 13). A n Issue
O ne passage in Malach i that may have been changed in the MT recens ion reads in the LXX as: Have you not all one father? Did not one God create you'? Why have you fo rsaken every ma n his brothe r. 10 profane the covenant of your fathers'? (LXX Mal 02: 10). The MT reads: Do we [the LXX reads "you"] not all have o ne Father'? Has not one God created us [the LXX reads "you"]? Why do we [the LXX reads "you"] dea l treache rously every man against his brothe r. profaning the covenant of our (the LXX reads "your"] fathers? (Mal 02: 10). That the LXX has Malachi saying "you" Israelites were created. but appare ntly docs not include himself as being created, shows that the ultimate author of the book Malachi is the Son. T he LXX was trans lated from the Hebre w sometime betwee n the second or third century BC and 70 BC. Apparently. some time after the LXX was translated but before the tenth century AD, a copyist c hanged a verse in the MT rece nsion. The c hange demoted Malac hi fro m being God to being a creature (Mal 02: 10). That "yo ur God " was change d to "my God" and "o ur God" in many prophetic books apparently was an attempt to demote the author from creator to creature. Th is reflected the general trend in Juda ic thou ght. As Jud aism became increasingly unitar ian. it was tho ught that no malek: not even the Ma lek Yah veh : could be d ivine.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
Chapter 7 Various OT Presentations of the Trinity
The Trinity in Ezekiel The 50/1
The Word (Eze 0 1:03). w ho is also called the G lory (Eze 0 1:28) , is Ya llr eh the Son. T he Glory has the appearance of a ma n (E zc 0 1:26-2 8). T he NT refer s to the Son as the G lory a nd as the Word (Joh 0 I:14; Heh 0 I:03). Ezek iel sa id the G lor y by the rive r (E zc OL0 3, 28) was the same G lory me ntioned thro ughout Eze kiel (E ze 03 :22-23; 10:18-20; 43:03). The S"irit "The man" is first mentioned in Eze 08:0 ] -0 ] and is again introduced in Eze 40: 0 3. "T he man" is an anthropomo rphic rep rese ntation of the Spirit (E zc 08:0 2-0 3; 43:05.(}(j). The " Hand of Yllh l'ch" is also the Spirit (Eze 0 3: 14: 08:03; 37:0 I) . Bot h " the man" and the Glory arc ass oci ated with Yanveh oft en. In on e instance. " the man" brought Eze kiel " bac k" to the eas t ga te (Eze 4 4:0 1). Ezekie l had been by the eas t gate with " the man" in the pre vious c hapter [Eze 43:01). Th e rea son they had to go " back" to the gate is. appa rently. the man and Eze kie l had fo llowed the Gl ory (th e Son) from the east gate to the temple whe re the Son had talked to Ezek iel (Ezc 43:0 6-27). S ince the Glory (the So n) was in the te mple and on ly Ezek iel a nd the man were back at the cast gate, the narrato r must have been refe rring to "the man" (Ezc 44: 0 1) as }{,hl'el1 the Spirit (Eze 44 :02 . 0 5 ). The Trinitv The Spirit and the Gl or y are some times mentioned together, but at the same time they are disting uished from eac h other (Ezc 01 :28 - 0 2:0 2; 03:1 2-14. 23-24; 08:0 3-04: 10:18 -11 :01 , 22-23: 43:0 1-0 5). Nei ther the Glory nor " the man" is Yahl'el1 the Father. since: • "The man" quoted the Fat her (Eze 44 :06: 45:09. 18:46:01. 16; 47 :13), and • The G lory quoted the Father (Eze 03: 11 -12; 11 :0 5; 43: 18, II), 27) , The man (Eze 44:0 I ) referred to the G lory who went thro ugh the eas t gate into the temple (Ezc 43 :0 2..()5) as Ya hreh (Ezc 44 :( 2). T herefo re, the Gl ory (also c alled Matenal com direlbs autcrars
160
Yael Na tan
" the Word") is Yil hreh the Son, "the man" (also called " the hand of Yah l'ell" ) is Ya/w eh the Spirit. and the Ya/w eh that is o ften quoted in Ezekiel is vanvcn the Father.
The Trinity in Jonah The Pre'\'("Ke.~ of Yahl'eh In the boo k of Jo nah. the Presences of Y ahveh are mentioned four times (Jon 0 I: 02 ,0] (twice], If)) . The sailors kne w that Jonah was running from the Presences (the Son an d Spirit ) of Yahveh (Jon 0 1: 10). Jo nah wa s not necessarily runnin g from the Father, s ince it was the Word (the So n) who gave Jonah the assignment to go to N ineve h (Jon 0 1:0 I; 0 3:0 I, 0 3).
That Jonah was running from the Prese nces in the tem ple rather than fro m Ya hw'h the rat her in hea r te n make s se nse. Otherwise. the sa ilo rs wo uld har t: thoug ht Jo nah was making a mistake. The sailo rs like ly were we ll versed in astrolog y, espec ially since thcy used thc stars for navigation . The basic co nvictio n of ancient astrologist s was thai de itie s who co ntrolled lives and e ve nts on earth popu lated the heave nly bodie s. Jonah m ust have 1011.1 the sailors that the Presences were es pecially present in the te mple at Jerusalem. Ot herwise, the sa ilors would think il impossible to run frnm astral de ities. If Jo nah did not lell the sa ilors the Presence s were in the te mple . the sailors would have figured it impo ssible to avo id any god. unless the god's star rose and se t with the seasons. If that we re the ca se, Jonah would have had to travel north or south 10 a latitude where the star never clears the horizon. Jonah's destination, however. was Tarshish (Spain ) (Jon 01 :03). which is rough ly west of Pale-nne. Thc re is , ho we ver. no indication in thc book of Jo nah that the sailo rs thought Jonah's itinerary was ill co nceived. So Jnnah must have ment ioned the Presences in the templ e. The Trinitv as [All J the Gods (ho Elolli"') When the storm brewed. the ship's captain told Jo nah : Ge l lip and ca ll o n yo ur Gods [E lohim] ! Maybe [All ] the God s [/IlI Elohim ] will take notice [singular verb] of us, and we will not perish" (Jon 01 :(6) . T hat the ca ptai n used a s ingular ve rb with haElohim may ind ic ate that the capt ain knew Jonah's "own god" to be the Trinity (11t1Elohim). How the captain kne w the Tnnity to be "[A ll] the Gods" (hoElo him) is Jonah had 1011.1 the sailors that he was running from the Presences of Yahveh, Jonah must have then collectively referred 10 Yah veh the Father and his Presences as " [All] the Gods. " Jonah's terminology would have been normal Trinitar ian theology, since, in the OT. the Trinity often is ca lled "[All] the God s [haf:lohim]. " T his was discussed in the chapter on Hebrew co llec tive nouns. Of co urse. if the captain had any familiarity with the Hebrew relig ion, he wou ld have oflen heard the Hebrews using plural nouns and singular ve rbs in refe rence to Yahl'ch. Moreover. the pagans had Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
161
their pseudo-trinities. T he Trinity is called "[All] the Gods" four times in the book o f Jo nah (Jon tH : 0 6; 03:09, 10 : 04:0 7 ). Anothe r indicator of the perso ns of the T rinity, the dua l name "Yahveh Elohim ," is found in Jon 04 :06. T he paired names rohvch Elohim are discussed in the chaprcr o n Hebrew collective nou ns.
The Tr inity in Zechariah The $11/1 The Malek Yahveh is called Yah l'f'll (Zec 03:0 1-02). The Malek Yllh ~'eh spoke as only Yahreh co uld [Zec 0 2:0K- I I: 03:0 2-04 ). The personified " Word o f Yahreh" is Yahwh the So n. The phrase " this is the word of Yah~'eh" (Zcc 04 :0 6). ho wever, is nOI perso nified, and so here the "word" does not refer to the So n. The personified "Word [the Son] of ranven [the Fathe r]" (Zcc 07 :08) spoke of the Spirit and the Father as se parate persons (Zcc 0 7: 12-13). The Malek Yllhrt'h is shown to he dis tinct from Yohvch the Father by the Malek Yahreh's saying that Yahveh the Father "sent me" (Zee 0 2:08-09, II; 04:09; 06 : 15). T he Matek: rohvch has a sp irit that e xtends t hro ughout the earth, Zech ariah mentioned that the " Interpret ing" Malek's spirit extends to a north country (Zec 06 : 08). Com bining these insights with fac ts about previou s encounters with the M alek Yahwll indicates that the Ma lek Yahveh in Zechariah is the Word o f Yahwh, who is Yaln'ell the Son. Ill ' The SI,ir;1 The "Interpreting" Malek who talked to Zechariah is identified as Yahreh (Zec 0 1:20). T he "Imcrpreting " Malek is shown to be a separate person from the Malek Yallreh (Zee 0 I:09- 13; 02:03-04; 0 3:0 I and elsewhere). The "Interpreting" M alek is ment ioned in zcc 0 1:09. 13- 14, 19; 0 2:03; 04 :0 1, 04-05; 05:05, 10; and 06:04OS. Based on the fact that the " Interpreting" Malek is not the M« ld : vahvch , and based on the other facts given by Zechariah , the "Interpreting" Malek in Zechariah is Yahw'h the Spirit. The Father In Zec hariah, Yah~'eh o f hosts refers to a perso n d istinc t from the Word of Yaln'eh (Zec 07:08 ) and the Spir it (lee 07: 12-13). By proce ss o f eli minat ion, o ne can say the "Yahreh o f hosts" mentioned in Zec hariah is vahveh the Father.
Malenal com direlbs autcrars
Matenal com direlbs autorars
Chapter 8 The NT Use of OT Yahveh Texts
Background
The grea ter part of th is chapter co ncerns wheth er Ye.I'hu(I pr imarily spoke Gree k or Aramaic. Th e langu age issue has some bea ring on whe ther Yeshua ident ified himself a s: • Ya/weh the Son b)! apply ing O'I' Ya hreh texts to him self (sec Isa 35:0 2-05; 40: 03. 08 , 09 ; Dan 07: 14 and oth er instances in the NT Use of O'T Yah veh Texts append ix), • The d ivine Son of Ma n o f the Dan 07 vis ion (as is d iscussed in the So ng of Mose s chapter), • The " I A M" (as is d iscussed in the "I AM" and the Son g of Moses chapters) , and
• The subject of the Shema along with the Father (as is dis cussed in the Shema chapter). T he ev ide nce will sho w tha t Yes/ilia spoke both A ramai c and Greek . S ince Ye.l h ,w preac hed in Hellenized area s and his fo llowers and aud ience tended to be Helle nized. Ycshua likel y spo ke as much Greek as Aramaic while in Ga lilee. Aram a ic was prevale nt in Judea. but inscri ption s and ot her literar y evide nce sho w tha t Gree k was co mmon . too. Th is sugges ts that Ye.l'hua may ha ve spoken more Aramaic than Greek in J udea, b ut there too his audie nce te nded to be mo re Hell enized than Judean s taken as a whole. The se above e stimates. o f co urse. are predica ted on the assu mptio n that Yes/ilia drew an aud ience rep re sentative of the po pulation ce nters he visited. In a ll likelihood , ho we ve r, Ye.l hull ap pealed more to He lle nized Jew s and ge nti les, Th is helps ex plain why the NT is written in Gre ek, and why Pilate had the sig n posted on tht:: cruc ifix in three langu age s: Ara ma ic. Uree k and Lati n. Wherever Yeshua wen t, he could count on the majority knowing G reek, at least as a second langu age. Ye,I'hulI. ho wever, v isited areas where he could not ass ume the cro wds kne w A ramaic . Except in spec ial circ umstance s that will be d iscu ssed, Matenal com direlbs autcrars
164
Yael Natan
Ye.~hlw
spoke Gree k whe n the crowd mostly spo ke G reek. and Ara maic when the crowd mos tly spo ke Aramaic. Yes/lila and the Father spoke for the benefit of their heare rs, whether Jew or Genti le (loh 12:30 ). So appare ntly veshua spoke Greek to Gree ks, even when the Gr eek s happen ed to be in Aramaic-speaking Judea (lo h 0 7:35 ; 12:20 -30). On ly later. after the Je ws had rejec ted the gos pe l, did God speak \0 Jews thmug h fo reign tong ul:s(lsa 2K:ll ; leo 14:21). The ev idence will show that Ye.\ htw and the NT writers knew both Aramaic and G reek , and were fam iliar with the in both lang uages. Th is meant that Yeshua an d the NT writers co nscio usly applied OT " I AM" statem ents and Yohvr h text s to reshua . Since the NT writers were fam iliar with the OT in IW O or three languages. no mea ning was inadvertentl y adde d or lo sl in translation fro m the OT to the NT.
or
The Impact of Wh ether the Bible Personages Immediately Recognized Allusions or Quotations The d isciples kep i the OT in mind during Yeshu(/ ' s ministry (Joh 01 :45: 02 :1 7: Mar 09: II ). The dis ciples d id not catch e very subtle allus ion 10 th e OT. but the y did d utifull y teach and record what they heard. For example , when the ow ners as ked why the d isciples were unt ying the ir don ke y, the d iscip les did not say. ' T his is 10 fulfill what was writte n in Zechar iah.,." (M at 2 1:04-05 ). T he disciplex sa id what the y were instructed to say. "T he Lord need s if' (Zee 09:09: M ar 11:04-06 ; Luk 19:32-34 ). In the es tim ation of Yeshua, it made lillie d ifference wheth er the di scip les and other NT characters recogn ized a quote or allusio n as such (Jo h 0 2: 17). He kne w the y wou ld event ually recogni ze h is quotations and all usions becau se he wo uld ma ke thai happe n. Ye.~hu(1 infonned the Emmaus d isc iples that their training an d O T knowledge were sufficie nt 10 understan d the OT. but their attitude needed adjust men t (Luk 24: 25 -32 ). Yeshuo also said "the Counse lor. the Hol y Spiri t. whom the Fat her will se nd in my nam e. he wil l leac h yo u all th ings. and w ill remind you of all th at I said to you" (Joh 14:26 ). Apparent ly. the Spi rit d id co me beca use the inspired NT writers proceeded to refere nce the OT hundred s of times. The NT reader can also mak e va lid as sociations and co ncl usions not alread y s pelled out in the OT or NT. Th is is similar to how prophecies are val id eve n thou gh the prophecies may have been unin telligible 10 the pro phet (Dan 08 :27). Mos t propheci es. in fact, were mea nt to be undcrstood only by later generatio ns. an d the Bi ble does not interpret mos t of us pro phecie s. Future gen erations ha ve mo re informal ion and c an "c onnec t all the dots" ( IPe 0 1:10-1 2; Dan 12:04). Later gene rations are situated in a better position to de rermme ho w literal or fig urat ive a prop hecy was by lonk ing at its fulfillment ( I Ki 2 1:23: 2Ki 09:36) . As the say ing goes , " Hinds ight is 20/20."
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
165
Th e Jewi sh Trinity The NT Writers Distinguished the Persons of the Trinity in th e OT
Th e NT wr ite rs applied O T Ya hl'f'h texts to the T rinity and to ind ivid ua l members of the Trinity. For e xam ples. see the NT use o f OT Yah I"'" Texts appe ndix . The NT wr ite rs were aware tha t ce rtain OT Yahveti texts we re o nly ap plicable to one person of the Trinity. That this is the case sugges ts that the NT writers were able 10 d iscern the persons of the Trinity in the OT Yu/lUa' s Quotations of, and Allusions to, Yahveh's " I AM" Statements and th e Shema
Background T ho ug h e rudite theolo gical books on the OT elucidate plent y of Trinita rian proofs, many people fixate on Yllhrt'h' s usc o f the pronoun " us" in Gen 0 1:26. 0 3: 22 , 11 :07 and lsa Ot):OR . These people usua ll y think that: • The OT o nly "hints" of the e xistence of the Trinity, and • Theologians barel y eke the doc trme of the Trinity c ut of the OT (I Co 0 3:02 ; Heb 05:1 2- 13), Theo log ical liberals often hold the opinion that the OT was e ither unitarian or was adapted fro m poly theistic te xts. Nat urally, they miss or gloss over the fores t of OT Trinitarian proofs. Libera ls also miss or misread the many OT indicators that the Ma lek. Ya hveh was d ivine, and that the co ming Messiah wo uld he divine. Of course . a d ivine Malek. Yahveh and Me ssiah would be an unexpected development if one viewed the OT 10 be unitarian . Liberals who hold that the OT is unitarian often co nclude that Paul and the ea rly Ch urch were myrhmakers. Paul supposed ly transformed three Bible characters into the Tnmty : • The itinerate preacher, Yeshua , into the Messiah. • T he Messiah into the so n o f God, • The son of God into Ihe Son of God. • The Son of God into God the Son . • Yalweh into God the Fa ther, and • The spirit of Yah veh into God the Spirit. The re just, howeve r, was nor e nough lime between the C rucifixion and Paul's death for mythmakin g of this magnitude. Furthermore. this view does not ex plain why the OT has so much mate rial that lends itself 10 a Trinitarian inrerpretauo n. What is more likely the case is that the NT accurately report ed the fact that Y'·.I'Juw iden tified himself as God the Son ,just as the Jews said Yeshua d id (Ju h 05: 18; 10:33). Yeslllla was killed by the Jews because he identified himsel f as thc"] AM" (Exo 03) and as the Son o f Man (Dan 07). The Jews also d id not like how Ye.~hIUJ see med 10 identify the Father and himself as subjects of the 511(1110. The abo ve sce nario is more like ly than any sp in a liberal has tried to put o n the NT and earl)' Church history. Pre vio usly, liberals sa id that Ye.~ Jllfa was killed Matenal com direlbs autcrars
166
Yael Na tan
because he was a messianic " freedo m fighter," Tha i is because liberals wanted to suppo rt socialistic and communist ic guerr illa leade rs. Th en liber als tr ied to say Ye.\hlw was a tra veling rabbi. Then some one rea lized that there would be no reason to kill a traveling rabbi. Lately, liberals have bee n saying that Yt'IhuQ was a v ictim of a dis pute abo ut: • Ceremonia l washings at the tem ple (Jo h 0 3:25 ), and • Whether it was proper fo r priests to e xclude the b lind, lame and lepers from th e temple (M at 2 1:14; Luk 17: 14). Th is inter pret ive shift seems to match the shift in libe ral po litics and ch urc h fu ndr aising effo rts. Liberals church co ngregations are gray ing, and there is a need to raise mon ey for elevators and wheelchair acce ss ramps. Libe ral s know tha t "god- man" my ths ta ke a lo ng w h ile to de ve lop and propagate . Since the NT was wri tten o nly dec ade s after the cr ucifix ion. libera ls would rather not belie ve that the NT calls Yel'lw(l "God" at al l. Liberals say that the NT w riters " application ofOT YI./h ~,t'h text s to Ye.\ h tlll was not me ant to say that Ye.\ lula was Ya/weh the Son incarnate. Libera ls also sa y it is onl y a fl uke that the ·'1 AM : ' Shema, and "Son of Ma n" stateme nts app lied to Ye.I'hua appear to be allus ions to, or quotations of, the LXX a nd MT. How liberals attempt to disco unt the idea th at the " I AM:' Snema , and "So n of Man" statements are allu sion s 10, or quotat io ns of, the OT is hy say ing: • The NT is Gre ek , • The OT is Hebrew, and • Yeshua on ly spoke Aramaic If Yes/lila spoke Aramaic. liberals thin k this wo uld di stance Ye,I'hul/ 's '·1 AM" and Shema stateme nts fro m those found in the Greek LXX and the Hebre w OT. T he libe ra l argu me nt is thwarted , ho we ve r, wh en o ne rea li ze s th at the popular 'l'ar gum s we re writte n in Ar am a ic. A lso, if Ye .I'hul./ s po ke Aramaic , this wo u ld stre ng t he n th e t ie bet ween Ye.l'h lw' s man y Son of Ma n stat em ent s and the D an 07 Son of M an vis io n. D an 02:04b -07 is w ri tte n in Aramaic . while the re st o f Dan iel is written in H ebrew. Per haps it is counterint uitive, but if ¥n hllll spoke in Ar am aic , the tie between the Greek LXX and He bre w Scripture s wou ld still be stro ng. The reason is that translators would be extra carefu l to choose thei r words we ll so as not to givc any false impre ssion s. Por ins tanc e , if Ye.I'II/1lI were not God , the NT writers wo uld ha ve made d isclaimer s wh en writ ing abo ut ¥t'.I'hua 's '" AM" a nd Son of Ma n statements. Whatever view one tak e s, log ic s uggests t ha t ¥esh ll a really d id ap ply ·'1 AM : · "S on of Man : ' and Shema state me nts to hi mse lf. Be sid es, w hate ve r language veshua used . th is fact is dear: the Jews undo ubted ly unde rstood Ye.l'hllll to be claiming to be God the Son. ¥t' shua nev er told the Jews that there was a misunderstand ing. He on ly co mplained o f their stubborn disbe lief (j oh 05:' R: 10:33).
or
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
167
Whether Yeshlla Spoke Predominantly Aramaic or Greek Background The conservat ive scholar Alfred Edc rshcim wrote: f Ye,\'/wlI ) spo ke Heb re w, a nd used and q uoted the Sc np tures in the o riginal ... althoug h, no doubt, He unde rstood Greek, poss ibly a lso Lann.!" Edcrshci m furthe r wrote abou t the language sit uation in first century Palestine: If Greek was the lang uage of the co urt and [military] camp. and indeed [G ree k] mu st have been und erstood and spo ken by mos t in the la nd [Palestine ].. ."" The mantra es poused by liberals such as those in the "Jes us Seminar" has been : the NT contains ~'ery few words actually spoken by Ye.l'huli. Libera l analysis of the literary ev idence had deter mined that Arama ic was the dom inant. if not the excl usive language of the Jews in Palestine. Liberals ta ught that the G reek NT was, at best. a translation of Ye.\"hua' s words. and, at worst. a to tal fraud. Lockstep ping liberals did not question these assertions, evert though Josephus, an eye witness of fiNt century Patesune spoke of the pre valence of G reek . Now. ho we ver, the cherished idea tha t Palestine was who lly Ara maic and Hebre w speaking has been discarded due to archeological evidence. T he ev idence will be discussed shortly. The reader will reca ll from the He brew collective nouns chapter that other cherished ideas have fallen by the ways ide in the last ce ntury. T hese include t he idea s that classical J udaism was anicon ic. devoid of figural art. and free of astrology. Interpolatlng Anachrontstlc Ideas into the Past It is unlikely that Yes/ilia wou ld have been monoling ual in the multilingua l envi-
ronment of the first century Pales tine. Palestine then was a part of the multilingua l Roman Empire. The ancien ts became co nversant or fl uent in o ther langu ages more readily than moderns today'. The reason is that the vocabulary of many ancient languages amounted to me rely several thousand words each. Th e vocab ularies of many mode rn lang uages tot al seventy-f ive thou sa nd words. English runs into more than ten times thaI, according to the Oxford English Dic tionary! By con tras t, the Torah contains 1,104 words .'>' What makes for speedy vocabulary growth is move able type prin ters (circa 1455 AD). cheap wnnd pulp paper ( 1800's AD). and affordable person al co mputers connected to the Web (I 1,l1,l3 A D).
To complicate matte rs, some modern languages are no t spelled phonet ically. Some languages have so many exceptional spellings that teachers are tempted to give up teac hing a plethora of spell ing rules. T he task of teac hing spel ling has fallen to word processing software where the users learn by trial and e rror. In ancient times, howe ve r, spel ling often did not matter since words were spe lled Malenal com direlbs autcrars
168
Yael Na ta n
phonetically, or spelling was not standard ized. or a language was not eve n written down due to the lack of an alp habet. Thai vocabulary and spelling were not major obstacle s to learn ing ancient languages meant people could more readily become conversant or fl uent in: • A seco nd or thirdlanguage. • A hybrid lang uage (lin";IUl/rwl/"(l or 'wine), or • A language with a red uced voca bula ry (creole or pidgin ),
The Langu age Situation in First Century Judea Josep h Ben Mat thias (late r Josephu s Flavius) was a Je wish prie st. Pharisee. gen eral a nd histor ian . Jo se phu s lived from 37/3 8 AD to 100 AD. He wro te , betwee n the ye ars 7 5 and 7 9 A D. Th e Histo ry of th e Jewish Wa r . T hi s boo k is a history o f the Je wish Re volt (6 6 -70 AD) a nd the siege of Masuda (72 - 73 AD) . Jo se phu s fini sh ed writ ing The Antiqu ities of the l e ws in 93 AD. T h is is a hi story o f the Je wi sh peo ple fro m the C reat io n to 66 A D. Joseph us grew up in an aristocratic, priestly fa mily in Jerusalem. Jose phus' nati ve lang uage wa s Aram aic. Undou btedly. Joseph us was tau gh t Gree k because ma ny o f the prie sts were Hellen ists . The G ree k inlluen ce in Judea g rew ncar ly unbounded Irom the days o f Alexander the Gre at (circa 330 Be). Hy 165 He, during the re ign of Antioch us (Epiphanes) IV, Helle nism had made enou gh inroad s into Ju daism to beco me a major cause of the Maccabean revolt. During the Macc abe an pe riod a nd subseq uen t Roma n per iod, the in flu e nce of Gree k ne ver abated. Gree k wa s ubiqu itous in Pa lestine e ve n afte r the se vent h century Muslim conquests. That Greek had made inroads into Judea since 330 Be cx plains why prior to 70 A D, ma ny re lig ionists in J udea read the Greek LXX . Thi s is ev idenced hy the prese nce of Greek scrolls and fragments among the Dead Sea scrolls. These Gr eek fra gments were one or two hund red years old by the time they were left fo r pos terity in 70 AD!I ~4 G ree k LXX fra gmen ts we re even found at Masada. the Jewish fortress besieged by the Romans from 72-73 AD. Tho ugh Eders heim wrote long before these archeo log ical di sco veries, he was on target about the LXX be ing... .. .the people's Bible . not merel y among the Helleni sts. but in Ga lilee, and e ven in Judea.'> Joseph us, a former priest, needed to know Greek for co mmerce, and to talk to the Romans and the Greek- spea king Jews of the diaspore . The Roman aristocrats spoke G reek. so knowing Gree k he lped Jose ph us as a negotiator in Rome from 64 to 66 AD. Edersheim wrote abo ut a nothe r Jewish official: Yet eve n the Je wish patriarch, Gamahcl Il, who may have sat wi th Saul o f Tars us at the fee t of his grandfather, was said to ha ve busied himsel f with Greek, as he certainly he ld liberal views on many points co nnected with Grecianism, To be sure, trad itio n ju stified him on the ground that his position bro ught him into co ntact with the ruling powe rs... 11<> Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
169
Josephus wrote The History of the Jewish I*lr in Aramaic, a version now lost to history, The Greek translation, which was prepare d under Josephus' personal supervisio n by fluent G reek speakers. survives . Josephus wrote his later works in Greek rather than Aram aic. Linguists have concluded that Josephus' later works show that he had a good grasp of Greek, but he used some clumsy idioms. This is what o ne would expect if Greek were Jose phus' seco nd langu age. G ree k was t he native lan gua ge of many peo ple in first ce ntury Palestine. Jose phus, howeve r, likely wrote of the language situation speci fic to Jeru sa lem and Judea. Josephus wrote that there was no incentive for J udeans to learn Greek perfect ly as a mark of educational distinctio n. because e ven se rvants commonly kne w Greek! It seems what Josephus was hinting at was that Greek was used for com merce and government functio ns. Scholars attempting to write great literary works naturall y thought it best to write works in their native language. What was considered an accomp lishment was to lea rn Hebrew a nd Aramaic, and then to beco me famili ar with the Jewish law! Thi s explains why the crowd at the temple became quiet when Paul started to speak in Aramaic. Perhaps t he crowd tho ught Paul , who hailed from the Greek colony of Tars us. would on ly kno w Greek. T hey were surprised when Paul started speaking the lang uage of the learned Jew (Act 21 :40; 22:02). That Aram aic was the langu age of the learned is why Paul bothe red to mention that Y/;'.I'hUl/ spoke some Aramaic (Act 26: 14). Paul ment ioned that Y/;'.I'hUl/ spoke Aramaic while making his defen se before King Agrippa. who was "well acquainted with a ll the Jewish custo ms and controversies" (Act 26:03). Thi s would show that Ye,~hlla had been familiar with rabb inic writings and the law as King Agr ippa was. Otherwi se, King Agrippa might think C hristianity centered o n an unlearned. Greekspeaking Galilean (Luk 23:05- 07). Josephus wrote about the Greek-speaking situation in Judea: I ha ve also taken a great deal of pains to obtain the learning of the G reeks, and understand the e lemen ts of the Greek language, although I ha ve so long accustomed myself to speak o ur ow n tongue that I can not prono unce G ree k wit h sufficie nt ex actness: for o ur natio n does not encourage those that learn the languages of many nations, and so adorn their discourses with the smoot hness of their periods; because they look upon this sort of accompli shment as commo n, not on ly to all sorts of freeme n. but to as many of the servants as please to learn them . But they give him the testimony of being a wise man who is fully acquainted with our laws , and is able to interpret their meanin g; on which account, as there have been many who have done thei r endeavors with great patience 10 obtain this learn ing, there have yet hardly bee n so many as two or three that have succeeded therein who were immediately well rewarded for their pains. III G reek was more prevalent in Pa lesti ne north of Judea and Jerusalem , but Pierer W. Van Del' Horst wrote that even:
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
170
Yael Natan
One of the most surprising fac ts about these fun erary inscription s is thai mo st of them are in Greek- approx imately 70 percent ; about 12 percen t arc in Lat in : and o nly 18 percent arc in Hebrew or Aramaic. These figure s are e ven more instructive if we break t hem down between Palestine and the diaspora . Na turally in Pale sti ne we wou ld expect more Hebre w and Aramaic and le ss Greek. Thi s is true , but nor 10 any great ex tent. Even in Palestine approx imately two-thirds of these inscriptions are in Greek . Apparent ly fo r a great part of th e Je wish popula tion the daily language was Gree k, even in Palestine. Th is is impressive te stimony 10 the impact of Hel leni stic culture 0 11 Jews in their mo the r country, to say nothin g of the d iaspora. In Je rusalem itself about forty pe rcen t o f the Jew ish inscription s from the first century period (before 70 AD) are in Greek. We may assume that most Jewi sh Jerusalenmes who saw the inscription s ill situ (Latin for "on site "! were able to read them .. ..Th is is not to sa y IIebrew and Aramaic ever died out complete ly as lan g uage s fo r the Jews. Especially in the e astern diaspora, Je ws continued to speak a Semitic language . But in the firs t five centuries of the Common Em. e xactly the period when rabbinic lite rat ure was bein g wri tten in Hebrew and Arama ic, a majority of the Jews in Pale stine a nd the western diaspora spo ke Greek. '1' The recently di scov ered ossuary purported to be that of " James, son of Joseph , brother of Ye5hl/a" is inscribed in Aramaic.':" James was ma rtyred in Je rusalem in 6 3 AD. so Jeru salem wa s likel y whe re the ossuary was inscribed . This ossuary inscript ion wou ld be part of the sixty percen t of Jeru salem inscriptions wri tten in a lang uag e other than Greek. So it would seem that the idea that " Ye,l/uUl o nly spo ke Arama ic" is j ust liberal non sense that is needed to make liberal argumentation work . The idea th at Ye.l'hul/ w as mo nolingual is not gro unde d on the literary and archeological data.
8iblical Data on th e Lan guage Sit uation in Judea The Jews were e xposed to Aramaic mainly in the synago gues . while Greek wa s increasingly pre vale nt e veryw here el se . Thi s he lps e xplain why Paul' s speaking in Aram aic silenced the thron g at the temple (A ct 22:02) , The crow d may have qui eted down out of hab it because they heard Aramaic mainly in the synagog ue. As Jo sephu s said above, the popu lace respected most those who took the time to learn Je wish law wel l. This purs uit required an advanced knowledge of Aramaic. Another incident that sug gests not all Judeans were conversant in Aramaic was Yt'.l hIW's appea rance 10 Paul o n the road to Damascus. Ye.lh lW said in Aramaic, "Saul, Saul , why do yo u pe rsec ute me?" (Act 09 :04 ; 26 : 14 ). Pau l should have kno wn who the person was right away since Paul wa s persecuting C hristians. Previo usl y, Paul even he ard Stephen say Ye,I11l1ll was stan ding in g lo ry at the righ t hand of the Father (Ac t 07:55-56, 58). Paul did nut imm ediately recogni ze Yeshna, like ly because Paul figured Ye,lh/1lI was a Greek -speaking Galilean (Joh 07: 35,4 1, 52 ), wh ile the man in the vision spoke Arama ic (Ac t 26: 14- 15a). Matenal com direlbs autcrars
171
The Jewish Trinity
Notably, Pau l' s co mpanio ns heard the voice. but the y did not " unde rstand" the voice (Act 09 :07 ; 22:09) . Th is suggests that Pau l's com panions were no t con versant in Arama ic. Of course, this might be the very reaso n why Yeshua spoke in Aramaic since he wanted to have a private co nversation with Paul. Paul's companions may have been Greek-speaking diaspora Jews who attended the Sy nagogue of the Freed men in Jerusalem (Act 06:(9 ). What ever the case, the accou nt seems til show that not e very resident in Judea spoke Aramaic. Of course, it was for this very reason that Pilate posted his sign on the cross in three languages: Aramaic, Greek and Latin. That no t e veryo ne in Pale sti ne, including Paul's peers, spoke Aramai c sheds light on some of Paul's statements. Paul said he was "a Je w to the Jews" (ICo 09: 20), and "a Hebrew of Hebre ws" (Phi 03:05). Paul said he surpassed his peers in a ll things Jewish CGal 01 :13- 14). Paul may have meant he was a Pharisee while most of his peers were not (Act 23:06 ; Phi m:( 5 ). Paul may also have meant that he kne w both He brew and Aramaic better than his peers. As Josephus said, the populace respec ted those most who rook the time 10 learn Jewi sh law well. This pursuit . of course, required an advanced knowledge of Aram aic. The Fir st Cent ury Language Sit ua tio n in Galilee of the Gentiles Before 70 AD, Galilee was not known fo r being especially Jewish, After the Fjrxt Jewish Re volt and the destruction of Herod's Temple by the Romans (70 AD). Galilee became a center of Jewish learni ng. Rabbi Yohanan ben Zak kai. a lead ing Jew ish rabbi. formed a cente r for Jewish learn ing at Yavneh (Jabnah or Ja mnia) by 'I'ibcnas on the Sea of Galilee. The Romans cru shed the final Je wish rebellion (132-135 AD ) led by the false messia nic figure S imeo n Bar Ko khba (or Bar Ko/.iha). Jew is h scholars then moved fro m the Sea of Ga lilee to Usha near mod ern Ha ifa. Haif a is located straight west of the Sea of Galilee in a nook of Israel 's Mediterranean seacoas t. So Gal ilee became a center of Jewish learnin g after 70 AD, but was a Je wish hinterl and previously. This fact may ha ve led to some anachronistic think ing abo ut the Jcwishncss of Galile e. In the seventh century BC, Galilee was called "the Gali lee of the Gen tiles" ( Isa 09:01 -02). 'Ib is still was a fitting name in Ye.\'/uw 's time (Mat 04 :1 5- 16). T here were many reaso ns thnt the majority of Galileans were gentile: • The Israel ires failed to drive the Canaanite s out of Gal ilee Odg (I I:30-36), • The so uthern border of Ga lilee was seventy miles distant from Jerusale m. T his meant that Ga lilee was far away from where the bulk of the Jewish population res ided. Moreover, gent ile territories bounded Ga lilee on all sides, • T he Assyrian king Tiglathpileser III (P ul] e xpel led so me Jew s and deponed others o ut of Ga lilee in 734 or 732 BC (2K i 15: 19, 29) , • In 165 BC , S imon Mac cabeus evacuated many Jewish Ga lilean s 10 safety in J udea ( IMa 05:23), and Matenal com direlbs autcrars
172
Yael Na tan
• Sama ria served som ew hat a s a barrier that h indered Je ws from spreading into Gali lee. The Assy rian king. Sargon II, de ported ma ny Je ws out of Sa ma ria. The Jew s that re mained intermarried with gentiles that Sargo n II settled in Samaria. Th e Pto lemaic and Se leucid Empires alte rnately ruled Ga lilee from 324 10 166 BC Hel lenistic rulers proselytized thei r subjects 10 adopt G reek c ulture and la ng uage. Th at ge ntiles popu lated G alil ee mean t Gali lee wa s mo re recept ive to Hellen ization than J udea . During this per iod ma ny Greeks immig rate d. and twen ty-nine Greek cities spru ng lip in Palestin e. Helleni zed cit ies inclu de Hippu s, Julius. Gude ra, Scythopolis, Caesa rea and Cae sarea Phili ppi. Helle nistic towns ncar Nazareth inclu ded Scp phoris and Tibe rias . That ge ntile s wer e the majority populat ion in Galilee meant the proc e ss of Hcltcntzanon went fa irly smoothly. Sc r upulo us Je ws in Judea, howe ve r, had qualms over Helle nization, as the lntertestarnental literature points out. T hough the Jewish Maccabees (164 HC-6 3 AD ) ruled Galilee for a lime , they co uld not reverse or eve n ste m the tide of Helle nization. He llenizatio n co ntinued in Gal ilee until Galilee became impover ished and depopulated after the Arab conquest (63 6 AD). Galilee never d id reco ver unlil modern times. Joseph . Ma ry and YI'.11w ll we re Ga lileans who resid ed in Nazareth most of their live s (L uk 01 :04 ; Mat 02 :22-23). Th e small tow n of Nazareth ma y ha ve been e ntire ly lewish, bUI Nazaret h was near Hellen istic tow ns. T his suggests that Y('.~ luw , like most ot her Gali leans, was al least conversa nt with , if not Fl uent, in Greek. Ye.I'!wiI'S upbri nging in the l ew ish town of Nazareth allowed him 10 learn Aramaic well. Th is meant thai al age twelve he co uld con ver se well with the temple teache rs for whom G ree k was 11 seco nd language (Luk 02:46-47). Moreo ver. eve n if res huu wo uld have bee n more co mfo rtable prea c hing in Arama ic, this do cs no t necessarily mea n he used Aramaic much in his ministr y. Ye.l huil may have felt the need to use the langua ge of the peop le in Gal ilee and Syrian Phoe nicia, amo ng whom he lived out most of his ministry yea rs. Yes hua wo uld ha ve been like most missionari es do wn to the pres ent who speak in one language to their con gre gat ion, and in their native lan guage to their co llea gues. So Yeshua likely pre ached in Greek , the lan guage of co mmerce and the arts, rather than in Hebrew and Arama ic, the tradi tionallanguages of his rel igion . That Yeshlw's ministry was co nd ucted in a language for ei gn to Judc an s wo uld be a partial fulfi llment o f Isaiah's prophecy (Isa 28:11; 1Co 14:21). Later, man y nations wo uld evangelize Israel using foreign tongues.
Wh ether Ibh uQ Spoke Predomin an tly Gree k or Ara maic Was Ye sh ua a Hel lenized Je w o r an A ramaic -s peaki ng l ew ? (Act 0 6:0 1). Hellenized Jew s were found all over the ea stern Mediterranean, even in Jer usale m sy nagog ues (Ac t 06 :09 ; Act 09:28-29). Greek -speaking l e wish Christian s we re a lso found in Jerusalem (Mat 27:32; Act 02:10; 09: 29; 11 :19 -20; 2 1:37 ).
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
173
Many Gre ek-speaking Christians were d riven OUi of Jeru salem by persecutions and revolts (Mat 24:16: Mar 13:14; Luk 2 1:21). Many G reek-sfll:aking C hristians voluntarily left Je rusalem betwee n 67 and 70 AD. T hey took Mat 24 :15-20 to be a warning of Jerusalem's impending doo m, and decide d to take refuge in the Greco- Roma n city named Pe lla. Pella was named after the Maccdonjun birth place of Alex ander the Gre at. So it would see m that if Helle nized Jews resided in Jeru sa lem and Pella, surely man)' Galilean Jews were Helle nized. Some Helleni zed Jews knew Hebrew and Ara maic. Paul knew Gree k since his formative years were spent in a form er Greek colony. Tarsus. Paul, howe ver, became familiar with the Hebre w Scriptures and Aramaic (Act 21:40 ; 22:02 : 26: 14). Being a Hellenized Jew did not necessarily detract from his Jewish ness. Even non-Hellenized Jews spo ke Aramaic and languages besides Heb re w (Ac t 02:08I I ). Paul wo uld have brooked no sugges tio n that his being Hellenized mea nt he was any less Jewish than his contemporaries. Paul thought of himse lf as being Jewish (Rom 0 2:29 ), "a Jew to the Jews" (I Co 09:20), and "a Hebre w of Hebrews" (Phi 03:05). Moreover, Paul said that while he was in Jerusa lem. he surpasse d his peers in all things Jewish (Gal 0 1:13-1 4). Paul did not need to sacrifice one culture for the other. For Paul. being a Hellenized Jew was a cultur ult'borh-and" situation, not an "either-or" dilemma.
Yeshua's Parents Matthew related that Joseph, Mary and Ye,5hua stayed in Egypt awhile (Mat 0 2: 13- I5). T he Jewish community in Egypt had trans lated the Hebre w and Aramaic Sc riptures into the G reek LXX. T he LXX and its prec ursor translations had bee n used in Alexandr ian synagogues since the seco nd century Be. or e ven earlier. T hat Mary and Joseph [led In the G reek-speakin g Je wish diaspora in Egypt suggests that they spoke Greek well . If the y did not speak Gree k, they migh t have instead fled 10 Aramaic-speaking Jewi sh communities in Mesopotamia. S urely. as natives of Galilee, Mary and Joseph would have been familiar with the LXX (Luk 0 1:26; 02:04. 39 ). T he least that one cou ld safely conclude is that Mary and Joseph 's stopo ver in Egypt increased their exposure to Greek. Yu/lllQ in the Nazareth Synagogue
Some assert that YI'.I·h l/a actually read a Hebrew Isaiah manu script. and read from an Aramaic commentary in the Nazareth synagogue (Luk 04 : I6-30) . Thi s is based o n the shaky assump tion that what was the norm in Judea was the nonn in Galilee. The norm in Judea was that a reade r wou ld read the Hebrew Scriptures, and then a "translator" t turgeman or meturgemani would comment o n the text in Ara maic, or read an Aramaic 'lurgum.!" The language situations in Galilee and Judea could have been entire ly diffe rent. Just beca use Arama ic was spoken in Judean synagog ues does not prove that Yeshu(I Matenal com direlbs autcrars
174
Yael Na tan
s poke Aram aic in G alil ean synagogues ."! Besides. read ing from Targum commentaries would have been a rathe r safe occu pation. Ycshua 's comments, ho we ver, a lmos t gOI him thrown off a cliff. Ce rtainly his comments did not co me from an Aramaic Targum (Luk 04:2 1-30)! YI'I huII made di sparag ing re marks abou t those rab bin ic tea c hi ng s based o n the errors and nonsen se pro pag ated throug h the 'largurns (Mat 15:05: 22:29; 23: 16; Luk 11 :46: Jo h 12:34). Mo reo ver. the LX X and MT arc qu oted in the NT to the near excl usion of the Targum s. The peo ple recog nized that Ye.\1ulII had new teac hings (Mar 01 :27 ). T his all suggests tha t Yeshua did not read from Targums during his minim)'. The nonns cu rrent in J udea say onl y so m uch about the nonns in Ga lilee of the Ge ntiles. Galilee was seve nty mile s aw ay from Jude a. which was several days' walk in anc ient times . Gali lee and Judea were d istan t e nough to ha ve differing accents. likely in both the Greek and Aramaic lang uages (Mat 26:73 ). Bexidex, the norm of reading Aramaic Targums in Ju dea speaks more about ho w Bab ylon was a center of Je wish learnin g than it docs ab out the language situation in Judea. In Isaiah 's day (8'" ce ntury BC), the people spoke Hebrew but not Aramaic . Otherwi se , it would have been pointless to a sk the Assyrian com mander to spe ak in A ramaic rather than in Heb rew if the peop le under stood both (2Ki 18:26. 28; 2C h 32:18: lsa 36:1I , 13). After the exile ( 6' 0 century HC ). man y Jud ean men interm arried with foreigne rs. Half of their children knew the langu age of Ashdod. A mmon and Moab , but not "t he la nguage of Ju dah ," meaning Hebrew (Neh n :24). So eve n afte r vario us A ram aic -spe ak ing e mpires e xercised their in flue nce in the reg ion for ce nturies, sm all states maintained their o wn lan gu age s. So it see ms we can di spense wi th the notion that em pires imposed their lang uages on the conquered peoples to the ncar ex tinctio n of the nati ve lang uages. That mo st of the OT is wri tten in Heb rew shows that the Judean s co ntinued to speak Hebrew rig ht up to the Intenest amen tal period . Interestingl y, the on ly Aramaic portions of the OT cons ist mainl y of correspondence writte n by ge ntiles, an d chapters that concern gentile s (D an 02:04-07:28; Ezr 04:08-06:18; 0 7:1226 ). Also , it see ms many lnter restamental books were originally written in Greek, an d the Greek co pies are the only remnants to survive. Until the Imenestamemal pe riod, Hebre w was able to co mpete with Aramaic in Judea , espe cially since they are siste r lang uages. Hebrew, howe ver, wen t into steep decli ne when Gree k was introd uced. Most peo ple wo uld have been bilingual, given both the circ umsta nces in an cient times an d als o hu man lim itations. The nor m of read ing A ram aic Targu ms in Judea started after the return from ex ile (6'" century BC ). Aramaic did not supplant He bre w. however. Th en Greek arr ived in Palestine wi th Alex ander the Gre at (332 BC). As Heb rew trailed off, A ramaic and Gree k filled the lang uage vacuum. Thi s see ms to ex plain why forty perc ent of the insc riptions in l erusalem we re Greek while most of the res t were A ramaic.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
175
Th e no r m of rea din g mostl y Aramaic in th e synagog ues o f J udea du ri ng Yl'sh ua's time resu lted fro m Hebre w's slow decline. By con trast, in Galilee of the Gen tiles there were fewer Hebrew speakers even before the exile. Then the Greek settlers came spea king on ly Greek. So the language norms in Judea d uring Ye.~hlw 's day spea k even less abou t co nditions in Galilee than one migh t imagine. Moreo ver. archaeologis ts tell us that Aramaic was not as dee ply e ntrenched in Judea and Gali lee as was co mmonly assumed. Be side s, the norms in Judea could not simp ly be im posed e lsewhere si nce the norm s presuppose certain co nditions . For the norm in Judea to be the norm elsewhere required that the sy nagogue have: • A geni;a (s toreroom) stoc ked with expensive scro lls of the Heb rew Sc riptures as well as Aramaic Targ ums, instead of the less expensive G reek eq uivale nts,
,"d •
A perso n o n hand with the required expertise to read Hebrew and Arumaic. Most synagogues o utside of Judea and Mesopotamia d id not have an aud ience that understood Aramaic. In these places it likely was dee med impractical to incorporate Aramaic into the worship services. The Greek LXX was much eas ier to procure than Hebrew Scriptures d ue to: • Sup ply and de mand efficienc ies. • More slave co pyists knew Gree k than Heb rew, and • " From the ex treme laho r and care bestowed o n them, Hebrew manu scripts of the Bible were e normously dear."!" So the majo rity of e aste rn Medi terrane an sy nagog ues used the LX X. As Ederxhei m wrote: Accordingly, ma nuscripts in Gree k or Lati n, although often incorrect. must ha ve been easily attainable, and t his would ha ve cons ide rab le influence of making the Gree k version of the Old Testame nt the 'people's Bihle: llt T he LX X was most like ly rea d eve n in Jeru sale m sy nagogues such as in the Sy nagog ue of the Freedmen. Thi s synagogue dre w members from Cy rene. Ale xandria. Cilicia and Asia where lI eb rew and Aramaic were conside red foreign languages (Act 06:(9). As was noted prev iously, Paul' s co mpa nions see m not to have known Arama ic (Ac t 09:07; 22:(9)! Luke has Yeshua read ing the LXX word for word (lsa f 1:0 1-02; Luk 04: 1819). So all things co nsidered, the LXX sure ly was a text that Ycshua read from his childhood at Nazareth. Moreove r, Ye,\'1w lI cer tainly used the LXX ex te nsively in his Galilean ministry, if not a lso in his Judea n ministry, YeIhl/a Was Unschooled
Man y nine tee nth a nd twe ntie th ce ntu ry libe ra ls read that Ye,\,lltlll had no t "stud ied" (Joh 07: 15 ), and that Ye.l h ull ' S disciple s were " unschooled" (Act 04: 13). Having been misled that the language of Galilee was almost exclusively Aramaic,
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
176
Yael N ata n
these liberals ass umed that anyone schoo led in Galilee must onl y have kno wn ho w 10 write Ara maic (Jo h 08:(6). Thi s assu mp t ion in t urn led man y 19'" and 20 '" ce ntu ry libera ls to o the r ass umptions. For instance , liberals wrote that ¥e,I'Im u ' s disc iples were not ca pable of writing the good Allie (in ot her wo rds. " Athe nia n") Koi ne Gree k found in the Go spel s . So some li ber al s taug ht that the Go spe ls and the NT ori gin als were written in Aramaic . Other libe rals wrote tha t the NT was conceived and writte n by both the Apostle Pa ul and apocr yphal writers using pseud ony ms. This prej udice ag ainst ho me -schooli ng and synagogue-sc hoo ling is unwarra nted. Even tod ay, home-sch ooled ch ildren ofte n excel be yond the ir peers at cd ucanona l institu tio ns . C hildren in Ga lilee likely we re bilingual or even pol yglot because of the nece ssit ies of Ga lilea n co mmerc ial and c ultural life. The d iverse society served as a lang uage laboratory that reinforced langua ge lessons learned at hom e. Nea rly every Jew ish boy wen t to synagog ue-school. So so me body who was " not stud ied" and " unschoo led" had schooling- just not at a theo logical seminary. Pa ul, by co ntrast. was "s tud ied" and "sc hoo led." He learned fro m the Rab bi Gam aliel, the g randson of Rabbi Hillel , who started a religious se minary of sorts in Je rusalem (Act 05:34; 22:03: 26:24 ). Ye.~ htlll ' s attending se minary wo uld have been a supe rfl uous activity since he had already " amazed" the learned doctors at the te mple at age twel ve (Luk 02 :4247). Besides. the farther the ancie nt Je wish teache rs progr essed beyon d the basics, the mo re e rror cre pt in. When the people said that Ye.l hull and the disciples were unsc hooled , the y we re merely not ing that YeIhuli was unma tch ed in wisdom and authoritativeness (Mat 13:54: Mar 06: 02: Joh 06 :45: OR: 2R). Similarly, the Sanhed rin wondered ho w the disciples had honed their o ratorica l skills without unending seminary (Ac t 04: 13).
The Form of the Gospels Some scho lars assert that Ye,I'hu a spo ke primarily, if not e xclusively, in Aramaic. Thi s asserti o n is made despite the fact that : • T he re are only a few scaue red quo tatio ns o f Ye.I'huli speaking Aramaic, while the vast majorit y of Ye,I'hlla ·s words were recorded in Greek, • T he majori ty of OT qu otations fo und in the NT. incl uding tho se of Yeshua, follow the G reek LXX rathe r than the MT recension . • No Ch urch father uneq uivocally mentioned the e xistence of any Aramaic co llect ion of Ye.l hlw 'S say ings or an Aramaic gos pel, and non e has bee n unearthed. • Archeo logists have di scove red that Greek was quite pre valent in first ce ntury Pa le st ine , ju st as the first cen tur y Je wi s h his tor ian Jo se phu s sa id it was (Antiqui/ies of the Jews, Book 20: 11 :0 I). and • The only incid ents where the NT reade r is sure that Yeshul/ spoke Aramaic are those times that: o Th e ge ne ral pu blic ap pare nt ly d id no t under sta nd wh at Y/,Sh lill sa id in Aramaic , and Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity o YeIhua purposel y downplaycd a miracle to avoid un wan ted publicity, espec ially so the civ il an d religious a utboruies wo uld not feel they had to jailor kill Ye.\'hua just ye l. The above-listed facts suggest that the ge neral publi c unde rstood Gree k. So when Ye5hua k new that only those persons familiar with the OT cou ld possibly kno w about his role as Messiah, he chose 10 speak in Aramaic . This st rategy made sense because. on average, Aramaic speakers knew the O'T better than those who on ly spoke Greek. Yt-.5hua wanted to avo id situations where people wo uld dec lare him their "b rea d king" (Joh 06: 15I, or wo uld offe r sac rifices to him as thou gh he we re Zeus, and to his d isciple s as thou gh they were O lympian gods (Ac ts 14:12), Most ag ree that all the NT book s, except perhaps Matthe w, were first penned in G ree k. T he ea rly Ch urch fat her Papias wrote that Ma tthew's gospe l was wr itte n " in Heb rew." Some have ta ke n " in Hebre w" 10 mea n " in Arama ic ," bu t no t eve n a frag me nt of a n A ra ma ic prot o -M at the w has bee n fo u nd . T here is no indepe ndent co nfirmation hy another C hurc h fathe r or historian that Matthe w's gospel was o rig inally writte n in Aramaic. Matt he w was a tax co llector, so it wo uld see m he wou ld need to know Greek 10 talk 10 the Romans (M at 09: 09; 10:03) . Not surprising ly, scholars co nsider Papias" asse rtion a du bio us tradition. O thers hold the op inion that Papius' words "in Hebrew" should be understood as " in the Jewi sh sty le" or "using Hebraisms." In any eve nt, Matthew still q uoted from the Gree k LX X far more than from the Hebrew, This ind icates that: • Matthew's audience was G ree k-speaking. • Ycx/lIla 's prefe rred OT tex t was the LX X, and • Yn hua 's audie nce was mainly G reek spea king (Joh 0 7:35). Intere sting ly. Matt he w ex plained simple Heb re w and Ara maic te rms in his gos pel (Mat 0 I:23; 27:33, 46). These explana tions suggest that Matthew wrote his gos pel in Greek fo r He llenized Je ws and Greeks rather than for Aramaic speake rs. That Matthe w q uoted from the LXX as well as from the Hebre w or Aramaic sho ws that Matt hew was Iluent in two or three langu ages. O ne can easily assume that Y('.~luw was Fl uent in as many la nguage s as Matt hew was. Perhap s lou king at the big picture wo uld help. 110 1.11 wo uld o ne expect the gospels to re ad if Ye,I'llI/a spoke c hiefly G reek and prima rily quo ted the Gree k LXX'! Ho w might the gospels read if both Aramaic and G reek were wel l kno wn in Palestine? Bilingual peo ple often prod uce biling ual boo ks. Bilingual books usua lly are wriuen in o ne lang uage, but ha ve a smauering of a second language. Like wise. most quotat ions wou ld natu rally be so urced fro m books wri tten in on e lan gu age , and a sma tter ing wo uld be so urced fro m boo ks written in u sec ond language. T hat is exactly what we have in the gos pels . The gospels are G reek with a sma tte ring of Ara maic, an d sim ilarly the qu otations mai nly co me from the Gr eek LXX. In the NT there are scatte red Aramaic place na mes and phrases tra nslite rated into Greek, some times accom panied by an ex planation ( Mat 27:46; Mar 05:4 1: 07: Matenal com direlbs autcrars
178
Yael Na ta n
34; Joh 0 1:38. 4 1). Also, there are a lterna te, no n-transliter ated Gree k names and place names (Jo h 19:13 . 17; 20:24: 2 1:02 ). Natu rally. Aram a ic an d Hebra ic tho ught and cu lture arc reflec ted in both the NT storyline and in occasional Heb raism s. The good Allie Koinc Greek a nd the absence of clumsy, wooden translations suggest that the NT was originally writte n in Greek and not Aramaic. The Aramaic Words and Phrases in the NT Thai Aramaic was fadin g in im portance in Palest ine exp lains why NT Je wish Greek spea kers occasionally used Aramaic words as cognates. Most NT instances of mbbi and ahfxl are indeclin able. which sugges ts they were loa n wo rds. The re are two NT inst anc e s of rtlbbol1; used as an A ramaic wo rd rat he r than as a borrowed word. Inte rest ingl y, bot h occurrences (Mar 10:51 ; Jo h 20: 16) were spoken in Judea near Jeru salem (Mar 10:01 and 11 :01 ). T he Apos tle Jo hn wrote tha t Ma ry addre ssed Ye ,111l1ll with the A ra maic t itle Rabboni. Th is seems to show Mary's su rprise and d isbe lief at Yeshl/a's res urrection (l o h 20: 16).0' Mary had thoug ht she was ta lki ng ttl an Ara maicspeaking gar dener. Mary fa iled to switch fro m Aramaic to Gree k w hen she fou nd o ut she was addressi ng the Gree k-spea king G ali lean. Joh n's Greek -s pe aking gos pel reade rs would have (aught ho w surprised Mary m ust ha ve been 10 address Yeshna in Aram aic rather tha n Gree k. In areas of Palestine populated by Gree ks, natu rally Gree k was spo ken more an d Ara maic less. Lest Ness po ints out: It was almo st unknow n for a G ree k to learn a 'barhariantlang uage. !" This fact exp lains why Yes/lI/11 used Aramaic in these are as the seve ral limes he did not want publicity. Th is is simi lar to how Ye,I/l/1lI spoke Ara maic 10 Paul on the road to Dam ascus. Evide ntly, Yeshl/o wanted a priva te conversa tion with Paul. Paul said his co mpanions heard but did not understand Ye.l'hull' s voice (Act 09 :07; 22 :(9), The sit uation was the same in the Decarolis. Mark wrote: Yt',f hl/a too k a man aside from the crowd ... YeI/llla looked up to heave n and with a deep sigh said to him , I:phphtltha! meaning. ' Be ope ned!' .. , Yes/lI/11 co m manded them not to tell an yone. T he mo re he co mmanded, however, the mo re they kep t talk ing abo ut the miracle (Mar 07:33-36). Ye,5hua's purpose in speaking Aramaic while performing a miracle served the same purpose as taking the ma n aside, o ut of view of the market. The Decapoli s crowd was ge ne rally G ree k speaking, so spea king A ramaic helped to keep the miracle unde r wra ps. Unwan ted pu blicit y had caused Yes/ilia to mo ve out of areas hefore (Ma r 0 I:45 ; Luk 05:16; Jo h 04:0 I-OJ). Ye,I'/wli was sent mainl y to the Jews who o ften ha ppened to know Greek and A ramaic (Ma t 15:24-28). Ye,lhflll was not sent to the G reeks who often happe ned to kno w G reek and Latin (Joh 19:20) . Keeping publicity down mea nt that thoug h the Jewis h leaders might investigate (Joh 09: 08-35). (hey would not con clude that
Malenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
179
they had to kill Yesh lltl just yet (Joh 07:25-26; II :47-51). The same could be said for the civ il authorities [Luk 13:3 1l· Gree ks unfamili ar with the OT would not put Ye,~hlla's miracles in the proper context. Yeshna knew that the Gree ks in the Decapol is naturally spoke more Gree k tha n Aramaic . So the situation at the market was similar to how Ye.~/lIIa quoted Psa 0 22:0 1 in Aramaic fro m the cross (Mat 27:46). The G reek speakers who heard veshua ca ll from the c ross mistake nly thought he called o ut for Elijah. or for so mething to drink (Mat 27 :47-49). Th e discip les understood Ye.~ lw a ' s Aramaic, and eventual ly they carne 10 understand the OT. The NT write rs wrote about the Decapolis miracles in the Greek NT. It is interesting to think that some of the Greek speakers who witnessed the miracle in the Dcc upohs may have later read the acco unt in a Greek Gospel. Then they would have kno wn a Gospel writer 's translat ion of what reshu a spoke in Aramaic. T hey also would have read a prope rly comextuahzed acco unt of the miracle thev had seen earlier (Le k 24:25-27). y,'.I'hUlI crossed the Sea of Galilee from the Deca pohs and went to Capemau m. Ye,~hlla then went to the synagogue ruler 's house and raised Juirus' daughter from the dead. Ye.111UlI attempted to minimi ze the miracle both by te lling the mourners to disperse. and by saying that the daughter had only been sleeping (Mat 09:24; Mar 05:39). Ye.~ lrull then put the crowd out side Jairu s' home so they wou ld not be able to blab the details of the miracle all o ver the countryside (Mat 09 :25; Mar 05:40) . O nly Pe ter, James and John and the girl's parents were present inside the home (M ar 05 :37; Luk 08:5 1), but Ye.I'hulJ spo ke in Aramaic anyway. Undou btedly. people were eavesdrop ping outside the house . Most houses at that rime wert': ope n and airy to take advantage of Pa lestine's temperate climate. Ye.~ h llil said, Tafilllll kOI/In! which meant, " Little girl, I sa)' to you, get up!" (Mar 05:4 1). Just as at the Decapolis, Yeshua gave strict orders that no one speak abou t the miracle at Jairu s' house (Mar 05:43). It is notable that the same three disciples who witnessed the resurrect ion of J uirus" daughter were at the Transfiguration. There, too , they were o rdered not to talk about the Transfiguration until after Yeshua rose from the dead (Mat 17:01,09; Mar 09 :0 2. 09 ), Apparently. Yesh ua spo ke Arama ic among the Greek-s pea king Ga lileans 10 keep the miracle so mewhat hushed up. Thi s wou ld be consistent with his usc of Aramaic while performing a miracle in the Decap oli s to keep the miracle secret. Thi s shows that the Gal ilean Jews tended In speak G reek rather than Aramaic. just as the Decapoli s gentiles tended to speak Greek rather than Aramaic. That Aramaic was used in the Judean sy nagogues, while the Judean populace tended 10 speak Greek outside the synagogues, ex plains why: • The crowd was able to converse with Pilate though Pilate undo ubtedly spoke G reek (Mat 27: 17. 24; Mar 15:08, II . 15; Luk 23:04), and • Pilate posted a sign on the cruc ifix in Aramaic. Greek and Latin (Joh 19:20) . There is another indicatio n that much of the J udean populace spoke the same lan gua ge as the Rom an so ldiers, that bein g G ree k. A Ro man centurio n said that Ye,\hulJ was the So n of God (Mat 27:54; Mar 15:39). He had gained this Matenal com direlbs autcrars
ISO
Yael Na tan
information from passersby who hurled insults (Mat 27:40. 43 ). Pilate 's trili ngua l sign d id nOI men tion the title Son of God . but merel y said, .. Yex/Illa o f Na zareth . the King of the Je ws ." Many o f the passers by undoubtedl y knew Aramaic . hut appare ntly the y chose to cast their insults in Greek. The y knew Ye.l'hua was Ga lilea n, so the y figured his native langua ge was Gree k. Th is can be ascertained fro m the fact that one perso n who mentio ned "Son of God " q uoted Psa 002:08: He tr usts in God. Let God rescue him now if he wa nts him. fo r he said, " a m the Son of God ' (Mat 27:43 ). Yet, when Yes/ilia qu oted Ihe same Psalm in Arama ic (Psa 0 22:00 1; Mat 27:46), the people arou nd the c ross did not understand what he said. T his sho ws that the "So n of God" insults (Mat 27:40 , 43) must have been spoken in Gre ek rath er tha n Aramaic. That many in the c ro wd did no t know Aramaic e xplai ns why' Ye,~ h lla cried o ut from the cross in Aramaic , " £/0 ;, Eloi, lumu sabachthom?" (Mat 27:46; Mar 15: 34; Psa 0 22:0 1 [LX X 0 2 1:0 11) . Ye.~ lmll want ed to make sure his quote of Psa 02 2 [LXX 0 2 1J was understood in its scrip tural co ntex t. Arama ic speake rs tended to kno w the Psal ms bener. Ye.I'!lUu did not want the Roman so ld ier to hear him say in Gre ek, " My God , my God, why have you forsaken me?" Wit hout knowledge of Psa 0 22, the Gr eek spea king Roman cen turiun wo uld have misunde rstood the q uo ta tio n, Then he wo uld have dis counted the idea that Yeshna had a d ivine origin (Mat 27:54 ; Ma r 15:39; Ac t 21:31 ). Those who kne w the Psalms the best in Judea tended to be Arama ic speake rs. The y wo uld have kno wn that Psa 022 starts ou t with the speaker dow ntrodden hy h is e nemies, but ends up on a happy note. The early Ch urch figured it all out and deemed Psa 022 to be messianic. By the way. the fact tha t Yeshlla reci ted Psa 0 22 in Aramaic is no reason to accept the MT Hebre w renderin g of Psa 022 rather than the Greek LXX. Rabb is ha ve lo ng pointed out tha t the MT does not describe a c ruci fixio n since the MT s upplies the nonsensical phrase " like a lion my hand s and my fee t" rat her tha n " they pierced my hands and feet," S ince the MT recension co nve rts "they pie rced" into " like a lio n," the reade r must supply anoth er verb to ma ke sense of the no nsensical phrase " like a lion my hands and my feet," Interest ingly, the rea der does not need to sup ply the ve rb in othe r " like a lion" passages (e .g .. Psa 00 7:02 ; 0 I 0:09 ; 0 17: 12; Isa 38 : 13). The " they pierced" readin g of Psa 022 :16 (BHS 02 2: 17; LXX 021: 17) is mo st likel y the COITCl:t read ing since: • The Hebrew of the DSS (Nul/(// H eW',. (X Hev/Se4 , f,1 1. line 4 ),'-'" as wel l as the Syriac, LXX and other tra nslations, have the verb " pierced," • The BHS critical appara tus says that o ther Hebrew man usc ript s hav e " they pierced."!" and • l sa 53:05 a nd Zec 12:10 also say the Messiah wo uld be pierc ed (loh 19:37; 20: 25 ), Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
181
People who did not know Arama ic thought Ye.I'hua sa id, " He is calling Elijah." The Greek word for Elijah is Elias, so the Gree k speakers fig ured f /; or f lo; must be Aramaic fo r Elija h (Mat 27:46-47. 49; Mar 15 :35-36). Ano ther G reek spea ke r assu med that Ycshua was compla ining about the suo and waoted his thirst q uenched (Mat 27:48). T he Greek speake r arrived at this conclusion becau se he thought thai Ye.I'Il/Ill. instead of saying. "Elias" (Elijah), said "hetio s" (the sun). During the c rucifixion the land was dark from the sixth 10 the ninth hour (Mal 27;45). T he sun may have ju st appeared when Yeshl/a 's said. "f lo;. I-:Ioi...,'· during the ninth hour (Mat 27;46 ). So me of Ihe Greek-speaking Rom an soldiers may have concl uded that Yeshua called out to the ir favorite god . Hetios (the sun), Later the centurion and guards aro und the cross sa id. "S urely he was the Son of God (rhcos)!" (Mal 27:54; Mar 15:39), Unlike the thie ves o n the cross, the soldiers were not Jewi sh. so they drew the ir co nclusions from Ihe earthquake and the abnormal darkness rather than the Torah. So when the soldiers said Ye.l /uflI was t he So n of God (Ihe{/,\). they probably had a son of Hetios (Apollo ) in mind. Th is was s imilar to how Barnabas was mistaken for Zeus, and Paul was mistake n for Hermes at a later date (Acts 14:12). The similarity bet ween the Aramaic for "God" (Eli or Eloiv. "Elijah" (Elias) and "the sun" (helios) continued to play a role in Cbrt snan times. J. S. Trimingham wro te how astral shrines we re converted to C hristian usc: The cult of the prop het Elias [Elijah] is known to ha ve replaced the c ull of the Sun in Heljeni suc places and the similarity between the names Elias and Helios [G reek sun god popular in Late Antiquit y) is adduced .!" The cruc ifixion account sho ws thai YI,.\ hua spoke Ara ma ic on the cross for the same reasons he spo ke Aramaic: • In the Decapolis. • At the quickening of Jairus ' daug hter. and • O n the road 10 Damascus. In certa in peculiar situations. spea king Aramaic was Yeshm!'s way of reac hing out only to those who were most inclined to be spiritually minded (Mat 07:06 ; Gal 06:0 1),
YeIhl/a's Aramaic Phrases The NT record s that Ye.I' lma spo ke a fe w Aramai c phrases. but this does not mean that Yeshua genera lly' spoke Aramaic. The sa me logical leap would pro ve that the Apostle John s poke Aramaic in his ministry amo ng the Greeks, John mentions Ara maic place names such as Bethesda [Io h 05:02 ). Gabbatha {I uh 19: 13 ). Golgo tha (Joh 19:17 ). Abaddon (Rev 09:11) and Arma geddo n (Rev 16:16 ). Joh n ce rta inly wrote hi s go spe l and e p istles in G reek 10 Greeks and to Helle nized Jews. Tradition says that John wrote Rcvclunon on Parmos. o ne of the Dodecanese Islands so utheast of Gre ece in the Aegean Sea . The Apostle Jo hn was
Malenal com direlbs autcrars
182
Yael Na ta n
a flue nt G reek spea ker - as Jo hn's gospel and the boo k of Revelation show. That Jo hn was a fluent Gre ek speaker suggests that Yes/ilia wa s, too . If the use of a fe w Aramaic phrases indica tes that Ye.\ /1II11 mainly spo ke Aram aic, the same leap of logic co uld prove the absurd-that Jo hn and Paul spo ke Aramaic du ring his ministry to the gen tiles. Paul inclu ded a fe w Aram aic phra se s in letters to the Corinthians. Romans and Galatians ("' M{mI1111 ]1Ul" ( ICo 16:22); A hba (Ro m 08: 15 ; G al 04 :06»). Pau l is note d fo r ha ving conversations in Arama ic once 0 11 his way to Damascus and once at the tem ple (Act 2 1:40 ; 22:02; 26:14). Pa ul's native la nguage was Gree k. Paul grew up in Tars us, a fo rmer G ree k co lony on the south co ast of Asia Minor (mode rn Tur key) (Act 21:37-39). Paul kne w Aramaic (Ac t 2 1:40; 22:0 2; 26: 14) because he was an e xceptional stude nt of things Je wish (Ga l 0 1:13-14). Pau l also studied at Jerusalem under e xceptiona l teac hers IAcl 22:03 1. If Pau l learn ed Aramaic in Asia Mino r. it wo uld have been as a fo n: ign language since the seac oast c ities spo ke Gree k. The Asia Minor inte rior spoke Anatolian d ialec ts (Act 14: 11), Paul appended the Aramaic phrase "Mara na Tho" tothe Greek word anathema. The resultant phrase "Anathema. MlIfw l(/ Thu" has the loo k and feel of an a nagra m and palindrome , tho ugh it is neit her. The phrase means, " . ..a c urse be on him . Come, a Lord !" ( ICo 05:05). Apparently, these Ara maic phrase s were part o f the liturgy that the Greeks knew. T h is borrowing is simi lar to ho w nati ve Eng lish speakers may k no w a sm atle ring o f Gree k ("K urie Ele i.I'OII " ) and He brew (Ha llduja!l )Y · Simi lar ly. Paul appe nded the Greek article and no un "ho Pal er, " meaning. "the Father." to the Aramaic noun A hha , meaning, "Fathe r" (R om 08:15 ; Gal 04:06). The G reeks kne w this phrase beca use fe,I'I1/1lI said. "A bba Pate r" (Mar 14 :36 ). T hai feshull mixed Gree k and Ara maic in his speec h sugges ts he was bilingual.
reshu a Talked to G ree k Speakers Ye,5!lUQ held several conversa tions with perso ns whom one would suspect kne w
G reek. but not much. if any. Aramaic . The reason for this is, as u SI Ne ss points OUI:
It was almost unknown for a Gr ee k 10 learn a 'barba rian ' lang uage. '''' I( a lso is reason able to suppose that Latin spe akers suc h as Pilate, o nce having lea rned Greek. wou ld not fee l the need to learn Arama ic. Beside s, a rule o f thumb is there are ma ny mor e mo no lingu al peo ple than bili ngu al peo ple. and mo re biling ual perso ns than polyglots. Ye.l'!lull talked to a Rom an cen turio n (Mat 08:05. II ; com pare ACI 2 1:37 ), and to a G ree k wo man al Tyre who was a nati ve of Syrian Phoenici a (Mar 07:261. Greek was ce rtainly the co mmon lang uage bet ween Yeshull and Pilate (l oh 19:20 -22; Act 02:07-08, 10). Pilate. being an aristoc rat. wo uld have known Gree k, and Pila te had ma ny G reek-speak ing subjects of Jewish and gentile extractio n. Ga lilean Greek (Luk 23:05-06 ) must not have bee n as d istinctive as G alilean Aramaic (M at 26:73 ; Mar 14:70 ). Peter may have spoken Arama ic to the Jews in Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
183
Jeru salem, but he was recognized for having a Galilea n accent. This sugges ts that Aramaic was the second language in Galilee . 1'('.~ luw surely spo ke Greek to Pilate, but Pilate had to be told that YeIhua was a Galilean. Thi s suggests that YeshuG was a fluent Gree k speaker, and that G reek was the indigeno us language of Galilee of the Gentiles. That Ga lileans spoke Greek may he why the J udeans were prej udiced aga inst the idea of there heing a Ga lilean prop het (Io h 07:41, 52) . As Edersheim wrote: A Jewish Messiah who would urge his cla im upon Israel in Greek, seems almost a contradiction in rerms.!" That is apparently what the Jewi sh leade rs mistakenly thought. too, as thoug h being biling ual or trilingual were a handicap ! Edc rshcim's argument . ho we ve r, see ms based o n the false assu mption that reshuu was mo nolingual. and that he either kne w Greek or Aramaic. but not both. Ye,~Jltfa used Aramaic. G reek and Hebrew as approp riate. No o ne should reject the Messiah on account of his use of Greek durin g his eart hly ministry. Wha t helped Y('.I'hua and others speak G reek flu ently withou t a st ro ng, distinctive accent is that Attic Koine G reek was standardized o n Athenian Gree k al ready in Alexande r's time . Moreover, Aristophanes of Byzantium c reate d a system of acce nt and breathing marks that helpe d standardize the pronunc iation of Allie Koine Greek start ing aroun d 200 Be. Later. Peter spoke to Cornelius of the Italian Regime nt as well as to Cornel ius' friends and family (Act HUll ). Cornelius did not learn Aramaic in Italy, but he likely learned G reek there. Learnin g the Greek language and culture was commo n in anc ient hal)'. The Romans were helped in their quest to learn Greek by the fact that ancient Latin and G reek arc relatcd Indo-European languages. Pro ximity helped Rom ans learn G reek, since the Greek main land was not far from Italy. Moreover. in B.C. times the Greeks had colonized the so uthern e nd of Italy and other nearby areas. So the accou nt of Cornelius is further proof that Ye.l'/uUI must have spoken Greek since his disc iples both spo ke and wrote Greek well.
YeIhl/a Taught in Greek-speaking Areas The Gree ks had se ttled ma ny areas in Pa lestine, The Hell enized c ities of Se pphoris and 'Iibenas were near Naza reth. Since Yeshua visited Hellenistic cities durin g his ministry years. it wou ld be co nsistent for Ye.l'hua to have done so also durin g his pre-mini stry years. The disciples seemed to have had no scruples about buying food at Sa maritan towns (Joh 04 :0&). In fact, the disciples were shocked that the Samaritans o nce refused them food. The refusal occu rred only because Yeshua and his disciples were trave ling to Jerusalem for a feast (Luk 09 :53). It seems the rift between the Jews and Sam aritans was kept a live main ly over the dispute about whether the templ e belonged at Mount Ge rizim or Jerusalem (Joh 04 :20-21). It is wel l known that many Jews avoided Samar ia on their way betwee n Matenal com direlbs autcrars
184
Yael Natan
J udea an d Galil ee whe n possible (Joh 04 :04 ). T he Samarita ns wer e not happy a bo ut Galilean Jews bypassing Mount Gerizim to attend feasts at Jeru salem (Luk 09:53). Th e S amarita ns thoug ht that o nly the Penta teu ch was cano nical. Mo unt Ge rizim (Dell II :29; 27: 12; l os 08: 33; Jd g 09 :07 ) figu res more pro minently in the Pentateuch than does Jer usalem (Ge n 14:18). So this may have been a reason why the Samaritans fig ured Ge rizim o ught to be the site of the te mple rather tha n Jeru sa lem. Several of Ye.\ /mll's d isciples gre w up fishin g on the Se a of Gal ilee. Surel y, the ir c ustomers incl uded the inhabi tants of the Hellenized cit ies of Tibe rias and Ga dara. Tibenas was situated on the Sea of Ga lilee. which is also named the Sea of Tibe rias and Luke Kineret. This lake is me ntioned seve ral times in the gospels (Mat 04: 18; 15:29 ; Mar 0 I: 16: 07 :31; Joh 06:0 I, 23 ; 21 :01), G ada ra wa s a fe w mi les so uthea st o f the Sea o f G alilee , in the re g io n ca lled the G adarene s ( Ma t 08 :28 : Mar 0 5:01 ; Luk 08:26 ). Gadara bel o nged to the Decapolis (Mat 04 :25; Mar 0 5:20; 07:31), a co nfederacy of ten Romanco ntro lle d ci tie s in northea st P alestine ori gi nall y se ttle d by G re ek s . The co nfede rac y was formed afte r 6 3 Be a nd wa s do minat ed by Dama scu s . T he Gre ek cyn ic philoso phe r Menipp us an d o the r G ree k thinker s lived in Ga dara . Some liberals have pro posed that Ye,\'1lUtI was a wandering Stoic-C ynic preacher who called on men to repe nt and to be virtuous. To propose that Yeshll o was a G ree k th in ker mu st me an the se li bera ls th ought Yeshua spo ke G re ek . T he Gr eeks mu st ha ve not iced that Yeshna preached in the Gr eek -speaking are as o f Palest ine. That must be why so me Gr eek s c ame to sec Yeshll(/ at the te mple (Joh 12:20-22) . Interestingly, right before the Greeks came In see Yn ·hutl . the Phari see s co mplained that the whole wo rld was fo llo wing Yesh tw (Joh 12: 19). It wo uld see m odd for Gree ks 10 searc h YeS/ilia om at the temp le if YeS/ilia did not speak G reek ~ The Jewish authontie v in Jer usale m also noted that Yeshua taughl Greeks and Greek -speaking Jews in Pale stine. That is why the Je wish author ities at the temple figu red Ye.f hll(/ migh t go teac h the Greek s as well as the diuspora. Gree k-spea king Jew s arou nd the Medi te rranean (Jo h 07 :35. 4 1. 52; also see Act 2 1:28). T he Jewish autho rities' word s we re: W here do es this man inten d 10 go that we will be unable 10 find hi m? Will he go where our people live sca ttered among the Greeks . and teac h the Gr ee ks? (Joh 07:35). That the Je wish author it ies thou ght restwa wo uld teach Gr eek speake rs IS s ignific ant. If Yes/lIIa ' s d iscipl es mainl y spoke A rama ic. the Jewish authori ties wo uld ha ve s upposed Ye.\'/IU(/ would go a mon g the Aramaic -speaking diaspora Je ws in Mesopotamia (Act 02:( 9) . Th at the Jewish authorit ies figured Ye,\'1111l1 had a better chance of elud ing their grasp amo ng the G reek-speakin g diaspora sugges ts that YeshuG was fluen t in Greek. Be side s. the Jewish author ities may have he ard thai Ye.\'/lII a was o nce taken to the G reek -spea king d iaspo ra in Egypt to el ude Herod 's forc es (Mat 0 2:13-15 ). Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
185
Even after his return from Egypt, Joseph was warned in a dream to leave Aramaic s peaking Ju dea I'm G ree k-speakin g Ga lilee ( Mat 0 2:21 -22). So the Je wi sh authorities likely figured o ut that. to avoid arrest (Mal 2 1:46 ; Mar 12:12; 14:0 I; Luk 20: 19), YC.I'J/Uu avoided Judea and traveled in Gree k-spe aking Galilee and Syrian Phoenicia (Mat 15:2 1: Joh 04:03,. The factor that suggested to the Jewish authorities that Yeshua would go to the Greek-speaking diaspora must have been his usc of G reek . It was not as though the Jews had greater access to the Fert ile Crescent than to the Mediter ranean, The NT sho ws that the Jewi sh leadership could send letters and ca use evange lists trouble around the Mediterranean as surely as they co uld chase do wn people in the Fertile Crescent (Mat 23: 15; Al:t 09 :02; 21 :28; 22:05; 28:2 1-23). Ycshua likel y spoke G reek to his arreste rs. The y were a Ro man cohort. officers of the te mple guards, and officials of the chief priests and Pharisees (Luk 22:52; Joh I K:03). Jeru sa le m was an intern ation al c ny where seve ral languages were spoken, and the Jew s and Ro mans who arrested Yt-.shua were likely more so ph!sne ared than most. Apparently, o nly offi cers of the tem ple guards, but not the tem ple g uards themselves, were se nt. The guards were not trusted since they had failed to arrest Ycshua once befo re due to Yeshua's persuasive wo rds {Joh 07 :32, 45- 47). T he commander of the cohort was a trib une (t-h ifitlfrhm') . Tribun es we re usually in charge of Roman troops {Joh l K:12; Act 2 1: 33; 22:24. 27, 2K, 29; 23:10, 19,22; Act 24:22). T he co hort is called a speira (Joh nU B , 121, a Gree k word derived from the Latin word meaning, "coho rt." Spdm is found se ven times in the NT. and each time speira refers to a Ro man cohort (Mat 27:27; Mar 15:16; Joh l K:03, 12; Act 10:0 1: 2 1:3 1; 27:0 1). Unfortunate ly, the word speira is often translated as "soldiers" in Joh 18:03 and 18:1 2. So the reader is given no clue that a Roman cohort assisted with Yes/ilia 's arrest. T hat Rom ans were involved with Ye.l'huu·s arrest wo uld not be a unique occ urre nce in the NT. Roman s arrested Paul and handed him o ver to the Sanhedrin (Act 21 :3 1-41 . 22:24-30). Ycsh/lu like ly spoke Greek to the xpeiro that arrested him, s ince Paul spoke G reek to the commander of the speira that arrested him (Act 2 1:3 1, 37). Likel y the sa me cohort arre sted both Yeshua and Paul. T his cohort was statio ned next to the te mple at fortress Antonia. Of course, the coho rt likely had diffe rent personnel s ince the arrest of Yt'-I'hu{/ and Paul occ urred decades apart. YC,I'JIllU like ly spoke Gree k to his arresters since Greek was the o nly language that the entire arresting party understood. Surely the "off icers" and "o fficials" and Roman soldiers all kne w Greek. So Y/'shuu's "I AM" state ments that cau sed t he so ldiers to fall to thei r knees were quotations of the name " I AM" as given in the LXX (1oh 18:05-08). T he '" AM " and the Song of Moses chapters discu ss the "I AM" statements in Jo h 1Kfurth er.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
186
Yael Na ta n
Whether the Disciples Were Hellenized or Hebraic Jews Background Wheth er the di sc iples we re Helle nized Jews o r Hebraic Je ws speaks volumes about the leader who chose them, es pec ia lly since they c hose to stay' with him (1nh 06:67-7 1).
The Evidence in Names A person' s name lends 10 ind icate the culture into which the pe rso n was bo rn. A ro ll call otrhc d isc iples reveals that : • TWIl di sc iples had Arama ic nick nam es (C ephas and T ho mas), but were abo kno wn by the Greek eq uivalents (Peter and Didym us), • Two d isciples had Gree k names (Andrew and Phili p). • Two disciples we re known by the GrcCiZIXI (Hellen ized) Hebrew na me " Jame s: ' w hic h co mes fro m the name " Jaco b," and • O ne d isci ple. S imon, was kno wn by a Greek title Zelotes, meaning. "Zealot." So s ix of the ele ven discip les fro m Galilee we re known by G reek or Greei zcd names, and a se venth was known by a Greek title. Na mes hel p 10 de termine the degree of Hel leni za tion in firs t century Gali lee. Conside r ho w so me Gr eek s at the tem ple wa nted to see Ye.11ulII (Jo h 12:20-22). Th csc Greek s first approa ched Philip, who in turn approached A ndrew. Then bo th Philip and A ndrew approach ed Ye.I'huiI with the Gree ks' req uest to see him. So it see ms significant that the onl y IWO d isc iples with Gree k g iven name s were involved whe n the G reeks wante d 10 sec Ye.I'hun. T he name s see m to ind icate tha t the d isc iples were more or less Helleni zed Je ws . This is what one would ex pect since all the disciple s but Judas were fro m the Ga lilee o f the Gen tile s (Isa 09 :0 1: Mal 04:15). T his e xpla ins w hy Ye.l h /Ill had to tell h is dis ciples 10 go to the prcdo minantly Aramaic -speaking Ju dcans fir st before go ing 10 the G ree k-spea king gentiles (Mat 10:05; Luk 24:47: Act 0 1: OS). The ele ven Gali le an d isciples wo uld have found il easier to ev ange lize Greek speakers, and the o nly disci ple fro m Judea (Ju das) was no more. Ye,I'Illlll 's Arama ic title MeS,l ill,I' is mentioned o nly twice in the NT (Joh tll A I: 04: 25 ). Messias is Ihe Aram a ic equi valent of the Hebrew Me,I'him'h (Mess iah), mean ing, " A no inted." Ye.I'h/IlI , howe ver, was co m mo nly c alled b y the G reek equivalen t of the Aramaic Messias, namely, Ctvistos (Ma t 0 1:16; 27:17 , 22; Joh 01 :4 1; 04 :25) , Yeshul/'s po pular title Christos wa s used 546 t imes in the NT instead of the Aramaic fonn Messias. If Yesh Uil d id nol spea k G reek , o ne wo uld ex pect thai mo re titles and more words wo uld be rranslue rated rather than transla ted in the NT. These facts suggest that Ye.l hua 's fo llowers were thoro ughl y Helleni zed , and that Yeshlil/ himsel f was a Hellenized Jew. Th is may be one reaso n why Pilate had the sign o ver the cross
Malenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
187
written in Aramaic, Gree k and Latin (Joh 19:20). The Latin , of course, was meant for the Romans from all parts of the emp ire. Ye.\,hua's ministry was mostly carried on in Helleni zed areas. T hus, one cou ld say thai Yi:'shll
188
Yael Na ta n
there were fewer Jews, and the na tive lan gua ge was A nato lian rather th an Greek (Ac t 14: 12). The min istry shift in Act 13 is indicated by a quote of Isa 49 :06 after the con version of some Greek -speakin g ge nt iles: For th is is w hat the Lo rd has co mmanded us: " have made yo u a light for the Gen tiles, that you may bring salvation to the e nds of the earth' (Ac t 13:47) . Paul's turning 10 the ge ntiles eac h time the Jews rejected him (Act 09:29; 13: 46) was a fulfillment of Isaiah's prophec y. This is paralleled in Yeshua's min istry. Yeshua atte mpted to conduct his ear liest minim }' in Jud ea (Joh 0 1:43 ; 04: 0 1-0 3). Wh en Jo hn was put in prison . fe.l l lt/i l withdrew (0 Capema um in the G alilee of the Genti les (Mal 04: 12- 13). Ma tthe w the n quoted Isaiah 's prophecy that said alight came to the gentiles who lived in darkness (Is a 09:0 1-02; Mat 04: 14- 16). Inte restin gly. we find that a Roman ce nturion had the sy nagog ut: in C apernaum b uilt {L uk 07:0 1-06). Since the Rom an centurion sure ly knew Gree k, o ne c an ass ume the synagog ue used the G reek LXX for rea dings . Later. Ycshua aga in retreated to the Galilee of the Genti le s whe n the Ph arisee s plotted 10 take h is life (M al 12 :1 4- 15). Matthe w then qu ote s Isa 42:0 1-04 that spe aks of the Messiah preaching to the ge nt iles (Mal 12: 17-21). So fro m the time o f Isaiah to the tim e C hrist. G alilee was considered the land o f gentiles (Isa 09:0 1). During the Passio n w eek, Y{',\ h u <J sa id: Is il not wriuen: ' My house will be ca lled a hou se of prayer for all nat io ns?' But yo u have mad e it into a den of robbers (Ma r II : 17). So the se fac ts see m to indic ate that Ye,I'hl/lI'S ministry was co nduc ted mainly among Greek-speaking Je ws and ge ntiles (Mat 15 :26-27 ).
Beyond the Evidence of Names Some of Ye.l,hu a 's d isciples we re form erly fo llowe rs of Jo hn the Bapti st (1oh 0 1:37-4 2 ; Act 01 :2 1-26). Joh n ministered in at least two locatio ns. O ne plac e w as "Bethany beyond the Jo rdan" across fro m Jeru salem. and another was at the Samar ita n-Galilean borde r at Ae non by Sa lim. Ae no n is ofte n loc ated ncar the Jord an about fifte en m iles south of the Sea of Galilee . A ndre w and John were o ne-t ime d isciples of Jo hn (1nh 01 :35-40). The Ae no n lo cat io n helps e xp la in w hy so me of Ye.l h /IlI ' S d isciple s we re from the heavi ly Hell enized Galilee of the Gentiles (l sa 09: 0 I; Mat 04: I S). Juda s, howe ver. was from so uthern Judea. John spo ke to Ro man so ld iers, almost certainly in Greek (Luk 0 3:14; Act 2 1: 37 ). Jo hn 's bapt ism made its way 10 Gree k-speakin g areas such as Alexandr ia and A sia M inor (Ac t 11U 4-25; 19 :03-04 ). So it see ms appropriate that Luke's quote o f Isaiah applied 10 Jo hn the Bap tist follow s the Greek LXX. T he phra se " a ll flesh shall see the salva tio n of God" is especi ally apro pos since it refers 10 both Jew and ge nt ile (l sa 40:03-05; Luk 0 3:04-06).
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
189
John bap tized ncar the heavily Helleni zed Gal ilee of the Ge ntiles an d minislered to Hellenized Jews and even 10 Roma n so ldiers. This suggests that Jo hn the Baptist an d his discip les were Helleni zed Je ws. Thm so me of Jo hn 's disc iples became Y(',~Juw 's di s, iples sugges ts that }('I'JW(l wa s a Hellenized Je w, 100 . If Yes/ilia prima rily spoke Ara maic, o ne would e xpect that: • Most of his d iscip les and followers wo uld spea k Ara maic, • G reci an Jews and G reek s would have o nly tric kled inlo the Ch urch while the gospe l ignited the Fertile Cresce nt (Ael 0 6:0 1; 11 :20 ), • All the gos pels wo uld have been wr itte n in Aramaic or iginally, and there wou ld be plent y of ext ant copies even today, and • Th e re wou ld a lso ha ve been severa l e p istles 10 t he Ar amaic Je ws in Mesopo tamia, an Aramaic apoc aly ptic book sim ilar to Re ve lation, and mo re Aram aic apocry phal an d pse udepigra phal boo ks. Compared to the volu me of early C hurch Gree k literature , ne xt to nothing was written in Ara maic Instead. the NT boo ks and early Ch urch literature were writte n in Fl uen t Attic Koin e Greek. C hris tian wr itings in Aram a ic on ly came at a later dale except in far-o ff Mesopotamia . as J. S. Trimi ngham wrote: .v.within a few years o f Jesus' dealh -ri sing". owi ng to the strong hold that Hellenist hum anism had gained in Sy ria. the Go spel ex press ion was almost excl us ive ly thro ugh the medi um o f Greek , though with ou t being ab le 10 d o mo re tha n submerge Ihe Aramea n subst ratum wh ich was find ing mor e direct ex press ion in Mesopotamia."-' Tri min gha m noted the language situation in Palestin ian churches in the fourth century : The worship o f the Ch ris tia ns was cond ucted thro ugh Greek , but the fact that the services. es pec ially the gospel lecnons a nd d iscourses, were trans lated ora lly into Aram a ic, shows that the majorit y of the peop le were Ararnucans. !" Notice that Trim ingham on ly says the majority race was Aramea n. T he fact that the serv ice was conducted in Greek suggests that the majority of Ara means in t he fo urth ce ntury knew G ree k. Here are so me det a ils that Tri min gham provide s to bac k up h is state men t: Buse bius [c irca 264-340 A DJ repo rts that Procopio ». a native o f Ael ia [Aelia Ccpitotina: a Roman name for Jer usalem ]. used to translate for the congrega tion of Scythopolis ( Bcisan in Palestin e II). Ege ria (ci rca 385 AD) writes, ' In this pro vince [Palestine ) there are some people who know both G ree k and Syriac. hut othe rs know on ly one or the other. T he bishop ma y kno w Syriae . bUI neve r use s it. He always speaks in Gree k, and has a presbyte r beside him who translates the Greek into Sy ria" so that eve ryo ne can understand what he means. Sim ilarly, the lesso ns read in chu rch have to be read in Greek. but there is always someone in atte nda nce to transla te into Syria, so that [allJ the peop le can unde rstand.':" Matthe w. Mark. Jo hn. Ja me s, Peter, Jude , an d perhaps even Luk e and the a uthor of Hebre ws , heard YC-\'h IUl speak at so me po int. Th ey ap parent ly kne w Matenal com direlbs autcrars
190
Yael Natan
Greek very well, jud ging from the books rightl y attributed to them. If Ye.\'h ull were challenged by G reek and needed an interpreter. one wo uld e xpec t this to be noted somewhere in the NT. No interpreter is me ntioned eve n when Yeshua visited predominantly Greekspe aking areas of Palestine . Yt'IhUil apparen tly had no difficult y ta lking to people who may have kno wn only Greek and some Lat in, such as the Greek woman fro m
S}Tian Phoenic ia, the Roman so ld iers, and Pon tius Pilate . Pau l also talked to YeI hl/u seve ra l t imes (Act 09 :04-06 ; 23 : II ; leo 12:02). The conve rsa tion may have been in Greek. Paul's nat ive tongue , e xcept for the lime that Pau l was on his way 10 Damascu s (Act 26:14). D uring this incident , Aramaic was spo ken to kee p the co nve rsatio n confidential be twee n Paul and Yes/llIl1. After introducing him se lf in Gree k to the Ro man comm and er (Act 2 1:37), Paul addressed the crowd in Aramaic and recounted how Yeshua me t him on the ro ad to Damascus (Act 22 :(2). Ano the r time Pau l (old the account in Gree k, but me nuoned that Ye sh/lll had spoken in Aramaic (A ct 26: 14). Those who he ard a recounting might have bee n surprise d o n two co unts - that the : • Greek-speaking Galilean , Yeshua, spo ke Ar ama ic , too, and • The apostle who ta ught Greeks and brou ght Greeks to Je rusalem (Act 22:2R-29) spoke Aramaic beside s (Act 2 1:40; 22 :02; 26: 14 ). The crowd (Act 22 :2 1-221 an d Festu s (Act 26 :23-24) both inte rrupted Pau l at the same point in the acco unt. T hey co uld stand to hear no more once Pa ul said Ye,I'hulI to ld him to bring the go spe l to the ge ntiles . Festus said . " Your great learning is dr iving you insan e" (Act 26:24). Evidently, it wa s j ust too incredible that Ye.\ h,1lI and now Paul could evange lize e./fec/il'ely in two lan gua ges (emphasis on "effectively"). The re WlI S no interl ude after the asce nsion whe n the apostle s had an opport unity to learn Greek Ilue ntly fro m scratch . Earl)' o n the C hurc h had to deal with perce ived conflicts between Grecian Jews and Hebraic Jews (Act 06:01 -1 5). In fact, Yeshua had al ready attrac ted Greeks dur ing his ministr y at the temple (Joh 12:202 1). Also , the re mu st have been Gree k speakers in Galilee and in Sy ria Phoe nicia w ho bec ame C hristian ea rly o n due to Yes /ilia ' s ministry there. This all sugges ts that the di sc iples knew Gre ek Fl uently fro m childhoo d . Simila rly, o utreach to fore ign Greek-speaking ge nt iles came very early. Fer instance , Philip spo ke tuthe Ethiopia n e unuch . The language used was likel y Greek, since Philip sure ly did not kno w Coptic or anoth er Ethiop ian language. After bap tizing the eunuc h, Philip preached in the Greek-speak ing coas tal town s includin g Cacsarca (Act 08:27-40). Ano ther instan ce of the evange lizat ion of Greek speakers oc curred whe n Peter ta lked to Co rnel ius of the Italia n Regimen t, as well as to his fam ily and frie nds (Act 10:0 1). Cornelius surely knew Gree k as othe r Ro man comma nders d id (Act 2 1:371, and there is almost no cha nce that Co rne lius learned Aram aic in Ita ly. So anyway , it is signific ant thai after Pentecost, w ith 11 few e xceptions, the rest of the NT records contacts with Greek speakers.
Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
191
The Post-Ascension, Pre-Pentecost Evidence Another incident that shows the disciples were Helleni zed Galileans is Act 0 2. The diaspora Jews were surprised that the tongues-speake rs from Galilee (Act 0 2: 07) could speak the lang uages of many nations - including Judea (Act 02:09). T his shows that the majority of Galileans were percei ved as being Greek speakers. while the majority of J udeans were perceived as being Aramaic speakers. That the Judcans tende d to speak Ara maic while the Ga lileans tended to spea k Greek explains the necessity' of Peter's explanation to his followers. who at the time were mostly Galilea n: Eve ryone in Jeru sal em hea rd a bout t his, so the y [t he Judeans in Jerusalem] called that field in their own [Aramaicllanguage Akeldama, that is. 'Field of Blood ' (Act 0 1: 19). The G reek words translated " in thei r o wn lang uage" arc "iaios aiateaos? It is true that bilingual Galileans, who spoke both Greek and Arama ic, had a diffe rent Ara maic accent than that found in J udea (Mat 26:73 1. The fact that Peter had to give a detinitio n of the word Akeldama shows that Peter was referring to diffe rent languages, not to distinct dialects o r acce nts. This is also consistent with ho w t he Greek phrase "idios diatektos" is used in the rest of the LXX o r NT. All three occurrences refer to distinct lang uages rathe r than dialec ts or accents (Act 01 :19; 02 : 06,08). So me translations put parentheses around Act 01 :111- 19. Thi s is an attempt to construe the " in their own language" verses as Luke's aside to Theophilu s [ Luk 0 1:03; Act 0 1:01). The note would indica te that Akeldama was an Aramaic word transliterated into Greek, The NIV is o ne of the mode m translation s thai treats Act 0 I:18-1 9 as tho ugh it were Luke's rather than Peter's comment. So that the passage still makes se nse in contex t, the NIV inserts the words "said Peter" after the co mment (Act 01 :20). Ho we ver, if Luke mean t Act 01 :111-1 9 as a com ment. it seems he would have inse rted the word "said Peter" himself. So mehow Luke would ha ve indicated that he was making a parenthetical comment. Modern translators e nclose Act 0 1: 18- 19 in parentheses based o n misi nfor mation. Modern exegetes and trans lators were taug ht in school long ago that both Gali lean and Judeans considered Aramaic to be their native language. So it just wo uld not do to have Pete r, a Galilean, say ing that Aramaic was "the ir own language" when Aramaic was Peter's language. too. By contrast. the King James Bible translators apparently had no pr oblem with Act 0 1:111- 19 being part of Peter 's speech. The KJV translators must have thoug h! the Galileans spoke Greek while the Judeans spoke Aramaic. Rec ently, archeologists have changed the ir story and say tha t Greek was prev alent everyw here in first century Palestine. Exegetes and translators, howe ver. have yet to catch up to the new evidence and findings. So Peter, the Greckspeaking Ga lilean. likel y referred to Arama ic as "their own language ," beca use Judeans tende d to speak Aramaic while Ga lilea ns tended to speak Greek. T hus. Matenal com direlbs autcrars
192
Yael Na ta n
Act 0 I: 18- 19 sho uld be interpre ted as an integral part of Peter's speec h, and not just a co mment by the narrator; Luke. The Evidence from the Act 02 Penrecnst At Pentecost, the Jews of the dia spo ra were onl y interes ted in how the Galile ans (Act 0 2:(7 ) could mirac ulously speak in "other lang uages" (Greek: "hcterais ,;/w.\.I'tl i,~") (Ac t 02 :04). So a nation o mitted from the Act 0 2 list of nano ns wo uld be one that spo ke the sa me lang uage that the Ga lilea ns tended to speak. The dom ina nt langu ages of the nations listed in the Act 0 2 were Anato lian, Arabic. Aramaic. Co ptic. Demo tic Egyptian, Doric Gree k. and Latin. The g laring o mission from the Act 0 2 list of nations is the nation where Attic Koine G ree k origi nated: Greece and its environs. T he Jews must ha ve perce ived that both the first ce n tury Ualjleans an d the Greeks tended to speak the sa me language- Attic Ko ine Gree k. Greece is not found in the Act 02 list o f nations for the same rea so n that Ga lilee is not in the list -it would not have been miraculo us for G alilea ns 10 speak their ow n language! By contrast. Judea d id make the Act 02 list of nations because the d iaspora Jews perceived that the tlrst cen tury Judc ans tended to speak Ara maic while Ga lileans tended to speak Greek. Whether the Pentecost Tongues-speakers Were All Galilean The det ails o f Act 0 2 serve to buttress the above interpretatio n of Act 0 2 aga inst possi ble o bjections. For ex ample. so meone might propose that the to ng uesspeakers we re not all G alilea ns. The n no con cl usions could be draw n from what natio ns were included or excl uded frn m t he Act 02 list. Note that the dias pora Jews indicate that all the tongues-speak ers were Ga lilea n (Act 02:07). Be sides. if the tongue s-speake rs were not all fro m Ga lilee. than the miracle o f Pentecost would not be as awe some as was desc r ibed by the dia spo re Je ws (Act 02 :08, 11-12). The re ma y ha ve been twe lve or one hundred twenty to ngues-s peakers (Act 0 1: 15. 26 ). Approximately seven major languages arc represented in the Act 02 list of a doze n or so nations and pro vinces . Thi s suggests that on ly the twelve d isciples were speaking in to ngues. Th e dia spora Jews said: We hear the m de claring the wo nders of God in our own tongues ! (Ac t 0 2: 11 ). This see ms to indicate that on ly about seven lang uages were re prese nted. If there were more langu ages than seven, it wo uld have been a cacophony. The n no one wou ld ha ve been ab le to say they understood a nything (Act 02: 11). T he fact that they all had been in o ne house when the tong ues of name res ted o n their heads suggests that there we re just twelve tongues-speakers. If there were just twelve. the Je ws wo uld have been able to de termine their nationality easi ly. Their Ga lilean accen t and perhaps the ir clothing we re cl ues (Mat 26:73). Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewish Trinity
193
The diaspore Jew s' statement that the tongue s-speake rs were Galilean was con firmed by no less than angels. Shavuot (Pe nteco st, Wh itsund ay) occurred se ven week s after the resurrection. Ye.l'Il ua's ascension occurred forty days after the resurrec tio n (Act 01 :03). This meant that Pentecost occurred on ly ten days after the angels called the ascension watchers "men of Gal ilee" (Act 01 : II), The ascensio n watchers were the sa me Galilean s who spo ke in to ngues on Pen te cost. This analysis further sugges ts that there were on ly twelv e tongue s-speakers. The tongues-speakers likel y were all Galilean for vario us reaso ns: • Ye,I'Illlll 's disciples and follo wers tended 10 he Gali lean because of the language barrier. Whi le many Galilea ns a nd Judeans were biling ual, still. the Galilean's lang ua ge of c hoice was G reek while the Judean's la nguage of c ho ice was Aramaic, • Judea n suppo rters of Ye.IIl/1lI likely we re dis illusion ed when Yesllllu's o nly Judcan disc iple committed suicide after betraying Ye .l h/w (At't 0 I: I1'1 -19). • The disciple s kept a low profile out of fear of J udcan Jew s (Jo h 20:19 ). T his meant J udeans would not as readily be included in their cki se-knu group. a nd • Logistics caused Judea n follo wers to d rift away becau se the disciples had traveled to Galilee and then back to Jerusalem sbortl) befor e Pentecost (Mat 21'1 : 07,16; Mar 16:07).
Analysis of th e Languages oflhe Nations Listed in Act 02 Language purists might cruicize the analysis of what languages were spo ken in the natio ns listed in Act 02 . Further analysis, ho wever. sho uld leave this inference intact: the Galileans and near by Hellenists such as the G reeks in the Decapohs tend ed to spea k an Allie Koinc Greek that so mewhat approximated the Gree k spoken in Greece by commoners. The analysis is s implified in that the diaspora Jews only referr ed to languages they spo ke personally. They said: We hear them decl aring the wonders of Gnd in our own tongues! (Ac t oz. ni. The diaxpora Je ws wen: no t refe rring to minor dialec ts. T hey were referrin g to the languagcs of commerce and government that they, but not Galileans. spoke. Th e diaspora Je ws from the Midea st co unt ries of Parthia. Media, Elam. Mesopotam ia and Judea likely were referrin g to Aramai c. The Arab Jews likel y we re referring to the proto-Arabic spoke in Nab ataea. T he Jews and gentile convert s from Rome referred to Larm. The Jews fro m Asia Minor (modern Turkey ) ca me from the prov inces of Asia, Cappadocia. Pamph ylia, Phrygia and Pomus. They were likely' referri ng to the Anatolian language. the native language of interior Asia Minor. The Jew s who lived in the interio r of Asia Minor were able to speak the language of the indigenous pop ulation. That is why in Lystra . in the interior of Asia Mino r, the Jews were able 10 win over the gentile crowd from Paul and Barnabas. Paul and Barnabas did not speak Lycaonian. an Anatolian dialect (Act 14:11). Matenal com direlbs autcrars
194
Yael Natan
T he reaso n Pau l d id not know A natolian is that Pau l grew up in a southern co astal cit y o f Asia Mino r. Tarsus used to be a Gree k colony, and Greek. was likel y the dominan t langu age there. Paul did not have a chance 10 le arn Anatolian befor e he wa s sent o ff for schoo ling in Jeru sale m. Gr eek is why most of Paul's miss ionary journe ys were spent alo ng the coasts of the Mediterranean. On the coasts that Paul visited, he could count un Attic Greek be ing enher the primary or secondary language o f co mmerce and governme nt. For instance, it wo uld be hard for the Je wish C hristians Aqu ila and Prisci lla nOI 10 kno w Attic Greek wh ile doin g business in Ro me (Ac t 18:02 : Ro m 16:0 3). Cor inth (Act 1&:02). Sy ria (Act 18:18) and Ephesus (Act 18: 19, 26; l eo 16:08. 19). The Je ws in the major c it ies o f Egy pt spo ke Allie Ko ine Gr eek . There rne OT was translated into the All ie Koin e G reek LXX. All ie Ko ine Greek was the lan gu age o f commerce and gove rnment in the Hellenized la nds co nq ue red hy Alexander the O rear (356-323 BC) . and the se lands inclu ded G alilee and Egypt R ichard C avend ish wrote: Afte r the co nq uest of Egypt by Ale xande r the Gre at in 33 1 Be the country was ruled by G reek s for 300 years. and d uring this period the c ull o f Isis beca me co mpletely Helleni zed. When the Rom ans too k over the gove rnme nt in 30 Be the y relied on the suppo rt o f the Greek middle class in Egypt and the lang uage o f ad ministration remain ed Greek .!" So at Pent ecost. the Jews fro m Egypt wo uld not th ink il mirac ulous that the Ga lileans spoke Alli e Koine G reek. es pecia lly since the LXX he lped standa rdize the G reek spoke n and written by the Galilean Jew ry. Th is would be similar to how Martin Lut her 's Bible translation helped to standardize German. The rea der migh t wo nde r w het her Arne Ko ine G ree k re se mbled the G ree k s poke n o n the Greek pe nins ula. The Greek lang uage developed on a nd otf the Gr eece ma inland togethe r. Evident ly. there wa s enou gh sea and o ve rland tra ve l an d trade , and shared literature and gove rnment (empires ), that Allie Ko ine G reek rem ained fairly unifo rm for centuries o ver a wide geog raphica l area. Not until the fiflh cen tury A D was there a split. The influent ial Auicist schoo l co nvince d writers In re turn In wr iting in cl assical Att ic Greek. which bec ame kno wn as Byzantin e Gre ek. Th e co ntinuing deve lopment of spo ken Artie Koine Gr ee k from the fift h 10 the fifteenth cent uries AD ca used an e ver -widening di verge nce be tween Attic Koine and Byzantine Gr eek. Attic Koi ne Gr ee k wa s sta nd ard ized by a sys te m of ac cent an d breathing marks introdu ced aro und 200 BC, repu tedl y by Aristophanes of Byzantium. Arne Koin e Gr eek may have been the only language 10 ha ve dia critical mark s until the Masoretes pointed the Heb rew MT recensio n fro m the sixth to ten th ce nturies AD. O nly in modern limes d id d ictionaries prov ide pronun ciatio n keys that serve the same purpose . T hat At nc Koine wa s stand ardized had its benefits. At lea st d uri ng the NT period . A rtie Koine Greek speakers in Greece and aro und the Med iterr anean found the ir speec h and writing mutually co mprehensible. This e xplains w hy Paul was ab le to ev a ngel ize many place s in Greek. Also, Paul was ab le to walk around Matenal com direlbs autcrars
The Jewi sh Trinity
195
Athe ns reading inscriptions. q uoting Greek poets. and converse with the philosophers at the Areopagus (Act 17). The language situatio n in the interior of Greece , ho wever. is a separate matter fro m the coasts where Attic Greek was the norm . Athe ns was a sea power. and rarel y controlle d the interior main land of Greece. Aristophanes ' pro nuncia tion syste m and other means of standardizatio n did not e xist when differe nt dialects became established in the G recian interio r. The dialect s resulted from geographica l isolation and Dorian immigrat ions. So early Greek colonists spread Doric, Aenlie, lonic-Aui c, and Arcade-Cypriot Gree k around the Mediterranean in the ce nturies prec