The extracts on pp.91 and 110 from Appian's Roman History, vols. 2 and 3, translated by Horace White, are reprin ted by...
170 downloads
3623 Views
30MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
The extracts on pp.91 and 110 from Appian's Roman History, vols. 2 and 3, translated by Horace White, are reprin ted by kind permission of Harvard University Press.
Contents
IX
List of Illustrations
xv
List of Maps
xvi
Preface
List of Abbreviations Part I 1
XVlll
The Search for Illyrians
1
Rediscovery of Illyrians
3 3 13
IIIyrian studies IIIyrian
2
landscapes
Prehistoric JIIyrians IIlyrian origin s : Stone and .
Iron Age Illyrians
3
Naming Illyrians Illyrian language IIlyrian
Part 11
4
Bronze Ages
67
67 74
names .
89
Greek Illyrians
91
Neighbours of the Greeks
91 104
Adriatic IIIyrians Greeks among
5
IIlyrians
Enemies of Macedonia kings: Philip, Alexander
Conquering
Celts, Autariatae and Dardanians
6
Kingdom of Illyrians
A new power on the Adriatic Roman alliance and conquest
28 28 40
and Pyrrhus
117 117 137 156 156 170
VIII
( :lI/llt·I/I.�
Part III
7
Roman IlIyrians
IIIyricum
Dalmatian amI Pannonian IIIyrians Pax Romana
among Illyrians
IXl ISJ 183
207
8
Life and Death Ways of life Burial and belief
9
Imperial IIIyrians Emperors from Illyricum Medieval and modern lIIyrians
254
Bibliography
281
Index
327
219 2 19 24 1 254 267
Illustrations
Arthur John Evans in 1878 (from Joan Evans,
7
2
Reconstruction of Vucedol Eneolithic settlement (Alexander 1972, 58; after Schmidt 1945, 19)
30
.3
Remains of Neolithic pile-dwellings at Maliq, Albania (reproduced by permission of Verlag Philipp von Zabern, Mainz)
36
4
Tumulus burial with central grave at Pa zho k , Albania (from Shqiperia Arkeologjike, Tirana, 1971)
37
5
(a) Pial) of settlements on the Glasinac plateau (after Covic 1975a) (b) Chieftain bu rial at Glasinac (Ilijak, Tumulus 1I) (after Alexander 1972) (c) Bronze greaves from Glasinac burial (a fte r Fiala 1893) (d) Design of ship incised on bronze greav e s from Glasinac (after Stipcevic 1977a, 1 80)
42
Time and Chance, London, 1943)
43 43 44
6
Tumulus graves at Kenete, A lb an ia (from Shqiperia Arkeolog;;ke, Tirana, 1971)
46
7
Plan of hill-settlement at Pod, Bugoino (later phas e) (after Covic 1975b)
50
8
(a) Plans and sections of houses at Donja Dolina (Alexander 1972) (b) Woman's grave at Donja Dolina, with
52 53
X
"'/IS tl', Ifillll.'
objccts cnlarged (AIl'xander
9
1(72)
(a) Burial tumulus at Sti�na in Slovenia,
exca v ati ons ( Ph oto : Habic Srecko)
1%4
(b) Scenes on Vace situla (Situla Art, B elgra d e, 1965 , pI. 1) (c) Bronze situla-cover from Sticna (Grife), 7th centur y BC ( N ar odn i M u z ej , Ljubljana. Photo: Habic Srecko)
60
61 62
10
Rock-cut tomb at Selce e Po sh tm e, Albania (repr oduced by permission of Verlag Ph ilipp von Zabern, M ainz)
123
11
Silver coin of King Monounius minted at Dyrrhachium; diameter 2 1 mm ( re p rod u ce d by cou rtesy of the Trustees of the British Museum, London)
129
12
(a) Pl an of Gajtan fortr ess, Albania (after Popovic 1 98 4) (b) Gate of Gajtan fortress (from Shqipe"ria Arkeologjike, Tiran a , 197 1)
131
13
(a) Plan of Byllis, Gradesht, Albania ( after Koch
1989, 250) (b) Plan of Byllis, central
14
area (Koch 1989, 251)
(a) Plan of Zgcrdhesh fortress, Albania ( Koch
1989, 135) (b) Zgerdhesh we s t perim eter wall and towers ( fr o m Shqiperia Arkeo/ogjike, Tirana , 1971 ) 15
(a) Plan of Lissus, Lezha, Albania ( Koch 1989,
141) (b) Pl an of southwest gate at Lissus (Koch 1989, 1 42-3) (c) M ain gate in w all of middle town, Lissus (repr o d u ced by permission of Verlag Ph il i pp von Zaber n , Mainz) 16
(a) Plan of burial tumuli at Atenica, Serbia ( D j u k ni c and J ovan ov ic ·1966a, pI. 28) (b) Sto n e tomb in Tu m ulu s I at Atenica
131 132
132 134 134
135 135
135
142 143
If/mlr,IIIII/1,,
(I )jllkllil alld .Iovallovil: Il)(,lla, pI. 1.) (l") Plall of s;Krificial areas ill Tl I llllll l l s 1 1 at Atl'nica (L>jllkllic and .Jovanovi�" 1 Y66a,
17 18 19
20
21
22
pis, 37-H) Bronze helmet inscribed 'Of King Monounios' (Preussische Staatsmuseum, Berlin) Plan of b urials in cemetery at Gostilj, M on renegro (after Basler 19 72) (a) Bronze coin of Lissus: head of Artemis ( obv . ) , thunderbolt and legend LIS SI-TAN ( rev.), 2nd cent u ry BC; diameter 12 mm (Ashmolean Museum, Oxford) (b) Bronze coi n of IIIyrian king Genthios (Genrius): Illyrian deity wea ri ng b road hat ( obv.) , Illyrian ship and legend GENTH (rev.), 180--168nc; di am eter 20 mm (reproduced by courtesy of the Trustees of the Briti s h Museum, London) (c) Bronze coins of Scodra: head of Zeus (obv.), Ill y rian ship with legend SKODRI-NON (rev. ) , 2nd century BC; di a m eter 1 7 m m (E. Thiem/A Peik ( Lotus Film), Kaufbeuren} (d) Bronze coin of King Ballaios; diameter 16 mm ( re prod u ced by courtesy of the Trustees of the British Museum, London) (e) Bronze coin of Labeates : TIIyrian deity wearing broad hat (obv.), IIIyrian ship with dolphin an d legend LABIATAN ( rev.) , 2nd ce n tu ry RC; di ameter 20 mm (E, Thiem/A Peik (Lotus film ), Kaufbeuren) .Fortified places around the poljes of Duvno, Livno and Glamoc with line s of intervisibility (after Benac 1985) (a) Wall m a s onry at OsaniCi, Her cegovina (Maric 19 79b) (b) Gate at OsaniCi (Maric 1979b) Bronze-casting mo ul d from Osanici (Marie 19 78, pI. 13)
XI
143
14 7 169
178
178
1 78
1 79
1 79
19 1
193 193 1 95
XII
23
24
25
26 27
28
fllmlr,/III II/S
Incised scene s of w a r ri o r s drinking and fUl1cral
dancers on a Japodian hurial-l"hcst from Rihi�, Bosnia (after Vasic 1967) Figured tom bstones in the Roman colony at Dyrrhachium, 1 st century AD (Durres Museu m ) : ( a ) Ex-slave Caecilius Laetus ('Happy') (b) Domitius Sarcinator ('Clothes-mender') and his wife Titia The prehistoric v i llage and castelliere in Istria restored by R. F. Burton (Burton 1874, pt. 7) four male figures on a tombstone from Zenica, Bosnia, 4th century AD (Stipcevic 1966) (a) Bronze pectoral from Zaton, near Nin, Lihurnia ( S ime Batovic, 150 Godina Arheoloskoga Muzeia u Zadru, 1982) (b) Jewellery and ornaments worn by IIlyrian women (reproduced by permission of Verlag Philipp von Zabern, Mainz) (a) Anthropomorphic bronze pendant from Loz, Slovenia, 5th century BC (Vida Satre, Pra-
ll)lJ
214 214 226
228 232
232
234
zgodovina S/oveniie, 1971)
29
30
(b) Bronze pendant from Kompolje, Lika, 25 cm long (Archaeological Museum, Zagreb) (c) Bronze temple-band from Gorica, Slovcnia ( Stipcevic 1966, fig. 7) (d) Japodian metal h eadgear from Kompol je, Lika (Archaeological Museum, Zagrcb) (c) Japodian leather helmets with metal studs and mail from Kompolj.e, Lika (after DrechslerBizic 1968) ( f ) Bronze and amber jewellery from burial tumulus at Sticna, 6th century BC (Narodni Muzej , Ljubljana. Photo: Habic Srecko) Silvered bronze belt-plate with scene of combat between warriors and horsemen, from Selce e Poshtme, Albania, 3 rd century BC (Historical Museum, Tirana) Altars with Latin text dedicated by chief of the
234 2 34 234 235
235
236
239
1IIIISIr"'/tllI'
x III
JapOlks al I'rivilicl srrill�, lIl'ar I\iha�\ I\osnia, 1 sI lTIII my All (StipCl'vil: 19(6)
Novo Ml's\o, SJovenia, 7th Muzej, Ljubljana. Photo :
31
Bronzl' cuirass fwm Cl'ntury He (Narodni Hahic Srccko)
32
Bronze helmet from a warrior-burial, Kaptol, Slavonia (Archaeological Museum, Zagreb)
240
33
Decorated clay hearth from Donia Dolina, Bosnia (Stipcevict 966)
242
34
Relief of Diana and other deities at OpaCiCi, near Glamoc, Bosn ia (Stipcevic 1966)
246
35
(a) Tombstone of mother and daughter in native style with Greek epitaph, from near Apollonia (Koch 1 989, pI. 22) (b) fam i l y tombstone with relief portraits, from Kolovrat, near Prijepolje, Serbia, late 2nd century AD (photo: A. Cermanovic-Kuzmanovic) (c) Portrait reliefs on family tombstones from near Glamoc, Bosnia, 2nd century AD (Bojanovski 1978a) (d) Tombstone, with depictions of jewellery (above) and textile motifs (helow), with Latin epitaph from near Sinj, Dalmati a (Gabricevic 198 3 , pI . 1; Archaeological Museum, Split)
248
240
249 25 0 25 1
36
Early medieval stone relief with traditional native ci rcles and Christian cross from near Sinj, Dalmatia (Stipcevic 1 966)
272
37
( a ) Plan o f Sarda fortress, Al bania (after V. Popovic 1984) (b) Gate of Sarda fortress (from Shqiperia Arkeologjikif, Tirana, 1971 )
274
(a) Early medieval cemetery at Komani, near Shkoder, Albania, 7th-9th century Ai) (reproduced by permission of Verlag Phi l ipp von Zabern, Mainz) (b) Ornaments and jewellery from KomaniKruja burials, 7th-8th century AD (reproduced
275
38
274
276
XIV
Illustrations by permission of Verlag Philipp von Zabcrn,
Mainz) (c) Gold jewellery from Komani burials, 6th-9th century AD (from Shqiperia Arkeologjike, Tirana 1971)
Maps
1
Illyrian Lands
2
Prehistoric Illyrians: Sites and Cultures
3
The Kingdom of the Illyrians
4
Roman Illyricum
xx XXI XXll xxii i
Preface
The purpose of this book is to present the current state of knowledge regarding peoples known to the Ancient World as IIIyrians. During the past two decades a l a rge amount of work has taken place on known prehistoric and historic sites in Albani a and Yugoslavia, while many new finds h ave been reported. Here annotation of the text and the accompanying bibliography are intended as a guide only to recent publications. In this respect I acknowledge my debt to the IIIyrian biblio graphies compiled by Aleksandar Stipcevic and his colleagues. Research on the origins and identity of lllyri ans continues to be infected by the politics of today. That is no novel ty for this region of Europe but in recent years m uch has been gained through the open debates in symposia organized by Alojz Benac of Sarajevo and in the IlIyrian congresses in Albania. Moreover, at a time when the political future of the Yugoslav and Albanian peoples seems so uncertain, it is right for the outsider to pay tribute to the scholarly integrity of many col leagues in these lands as they confront the m�ths and falsehoods relating to the remote past which are deployed in modern political contests. I am grateful to the Editors and to the Publishers for their invitation to contribute to this series, and no less for their patience and forbearance in the face of delay and procrasti nation. I am gr ateful also for the help and support of my London colleagues, Mark Hassall and Richard Recce, which allowed me to enjoy the hospitality of the British School at Athens and the use of its excellent library for two months early in 1990. Colleagues in Yugoslavia and Al bania have responded
"/'('/"1 "
XVII
gelll'rollsl y to lily rl'lllll'sts tor illllsl rat ions, ShepparJ herl' kindly rl'ad a part of the tl'xt and oflt-red many h elp ful criti cisms and suggestions, as have also the editorial and production staff a t Blackwcll Publishers. I a m also i n deb ted to my col league
Judith Higgcns for help and advice at the proof-reading stage. My greatest debt, signal led in the dedication, is to my family, for their unfailing encouragement and support.
J ..ist
of Abbreviations
AAnt. Hung. AArch. Hung. AI Al A
Acta Antiqua Academiae Scientiarum Hungaricae, Budapest Acta Archaeologica Academiae Scientiarum HUllgaricae, Budapest Archaeologia Tugoslavica, Bcograd American Journal of Archaeology, New York
BRGK
Bericht der Romisch-Germanischen Kommission des Deutschen Archii% gischen lnstituts, Mainz Buletin i Universiteit Shteteror te Tiranes (Bulletin of the State University Tirana), Tirana Beitrage zur Namenforschung, Heidelberg
Akademija Nauka j Um jetnosti Bosne i Hercegovinc (Academie des Sciences et des Arts de Bosnie-Herzegovine), Sarajevo Arch. Anz. Archaologischer Anzeiger, berlin Arheoloski Vestnik, Ljubljana AV British Archaeological Reports, Oxford BAR ANUBiH
BUST BzN
CBI CRAI FGrHist FHG GCBI GGM
Centar za Balka noloska Ispitivanj a (Centre d' Etudes Balkaniques), Sarajev()
Comptes rendus de I'Academie des inscriptions et Belles Lettres, Paris Fragmente der griechischen Historiker, ed. f.
]acoby, Berl in 1923
Fragmenta Historicorum Graecorum, ed. C.
Miiller, Paris 1841-70
Godisn;ak (Annuaire) CBI, Sarajevo Geographi Graeci Minores, ed. C. Miiller, Paris,
I HSS-6 1 (;ZMS 1111'. ArdJ.
JFA
JHS j()Al jRGZM jRS
LCL LF
MAA MGH PZ Rev. Arch. SA
SAZU Sf SH VAHD VAMZ WMBH WMBHL ZA ZPE
(;I'/�lIik Zt'mtll�k()g MI ( � ( I I I( S,Irtlj('/!o, Sarajevo 11Il't'lIitlri,[ ArdJtI('()I()gictl ( ( ;orplIs des Ensembles A n.:hcologiqucs) "
journal of held Archaeolugy, Boston journal of Hellenic Studies, London jahreshefte des Dsterreichischen Archaeologischen lnstituts, Wien Jahrbuch des R6misch-Germanischen Zentralmuseums Mainz, Bonn journal of Roman Studies, London
Loeb Classical Library Listy filologicke, Praha
Macedoniae Acta Archaeologica, PriJep Monumenta Germaniae Historica, Berlin Prahistorische Zeitschrift, Berlin
Revue Archeologique, Paris
Studia Albanica, Tirana
Slovenska Akadcmija Znanosti in Umetnosti (Slovcne Academy of Sciences and Arts), Ljubljana Studime Filologjike (Philological Studies), Tirana Stuaime Historike (Historical Studies), Tirana Vjesnik za Arheologiju i Historiju Dalmatinsku (Bulletin d'Archeologie et d'Histoire Dalmate),
Split
Vjesnik Arheoloskog Muzeja u Zagrebu (Bulletin of the Archaeological Museum in Zagreb),
Zagrcb
Wissenschaftliche Mitteilungen aus Bosnien und der Hercegovina, Wicn Wissenschaftliche Mitteilungen des Bosnisch herzegowinischen Landesmuseums, Sarajevo Ziva Antika (Antiquite Vivante), Skopje Zeitschrift fur Papyrologie und Epigraphik,
Bonn
Map 1
Illyrian Lands
I K.,b.rid
2 Tolmin
1011 km '-------',
3
51.
Luoa
4 St.n;'1
5 Smihd 6 Skocjan
7 Soc..-b
8 Krif.n. Gola 9 NCS3,'lium
10 Vace
I I M.gda!ensk. Gor. 12 Sti",. 13 Novo Mesto
14 Krapin. IS Ncgov. (Ncgau) 16 Gomj. R,dgon, 17 Krk, i•. 18 er... is. 190"", 20 M.li LoSinj 21 Kompolje 22 Mali Oblj'j 23 Prozor
24 Vn:ba, 25 Nin
26 Zadar 27 Radovin 28 Srnilac 29 Bribir
i? fic� 32
J..erinc 33 Galuhie 34 SansIt.i Most 35 Donj. DoIin. 36 Kaptol 37 Gr.bovei brdo 38 Visoko brdo 39 Duboj
40 Luioo
41 Usav.
42 Kamen
43 Kakanj 44 Pod
45 PrtroviCi·Rakitno 46 Gru'"
47 Posuije 48 Postranje 49 Gorica 50Drinovei
Map 2 Prehistoric Illvrians: Sites and Cultures
n=-, n Danilo
54 Vicj.
Luk.
ss Br.c, is. 56 Hvar, i!ii_ 57 Vis, is. 58 KOrCula
5� Mljct 60 Slon 61 R,dimlj.
62 (}<.ania 63 (;ub.vica 64 Kaeanj 65 Ljubomir 66 M.,sko 67 PI.n. 68 Crven. Stij"".
69 Glogovik 70 Lipo
71 Budv,
72 Gotovusa
73 B.rak.,,",
74 BUlmir
75 Orahovica
76 \.isiaCi 77 De&.1o
107�Rd:a \08 Sapo IO'J Ruat 110 Bubaat 111 V_ 112�113Gonop 114 Soo-. "115 Dub 116V"'11 � 0.- T."... 118� 119o.-�, 120 KanpC 121 Sun IIeb
�
l.u�
123 Sirabo 124 a.-. 125 DIIooaII. 12651<_ 12� K..-. 128 KoIsil
129<,:mama1< 130 Kmn< 780bre 132 Sem \J31kmd 79 GI,.inac 80 Tuzl, 134 z...do.< 81 Dvorovi 135Bd1ooft 136 ..... 82 BoSUI 83 Vuaodol 13- Deboo 84 C;omol.v, Blit.., 85 Sab.c B9h1Aool. 86 Selotie 140s.87 Godljevo 141 (.ob88 Rat.... 142 MaIoq 89 Roianei 1430.--: 90 B.r.jevo 144 ...... 91 Rudovei 145 .... 92 VmC. 146 �I Zi 147 Trm 93 Starccvo 94 l..idovar 148T� 95 Bd. Crkva 149 Obnd 96 Vr.novo 1S0y.... 97 Aljudov M.n ....riea 1S1 Sbp 98 Umeari 152 no. ()pa 99 Mramorac IH KuDun c...o 100 Zirovnica 1S4Radaair 1S5 Gomo�, 101 Zlot 156 Orlon CIIIIoi 102 Balta Verde 103 Basarabi 1S7Demi< � 104 Uti« 1S8� 159a........ 105 AIalica brdo
106 Pilatovia
fl.UTARIATAE
DAOR.Sf
/
Map 3
The
Kingdom of the lIIyrians
Map 4
Roman Illyricum
1
Rediscovery of Illyrians
Illyrian studies
For more than a tho u sand years before the arrival of the Slavs in the sixth century AD, the lands east of the Adriatic were the home of peoples known to the ancient world as I l lyrians. Their te rritory comprised much of what is now occupied by the Y ugoslavs , along with northern and central Albania. They spoke a language of which almost no trace has survived. That it b elonged to the ' family ' of Indo-European languages has been deduced from the many names of Illyrian peoples and places preserved in G reek and Latin records, both literary and epigraph ic . We cannot be sure that any of them a ctually cal led themselves IIIy rians : in th e case of most of them it is near certain that they did not. In general the Il l yrians have te nded to be recognized from a negative stand p oint, in that they were manifestly not Celts , Dacians or Thracians, or G reeks or M ace donians, their neighbours on the north, east and south respectively.· Not merely do all the surviving descripti on s of lllyrians and thei r ways derive from ' exter n al ' sources, but what has made matters much worse, for h istory's verdict upon them , is that many Greek and Roman writers seem to vie with each other in expressing their contempt and detestation for I llyrians. Ev en though they have escaped the sort of lasting infamy attached I
Trbuhovic 1971, Stipcevic 1986.
4 10 thl' Ilallll' of t h e Cnlll;lll VaIHLtll. rlH'Y havl' tarl'd lin k h l' tler in the hi st o r i ( al n·uml. As 'sav;l�l'S' or 'harharians' on thl' I lorthern pcriphery 01 t hl' dassiGl1 world , l'Vl'n today I l I y rians hardy make the lootlloll'S in I l l ost Vl' r s i ons of alKien t histor y , and morc oftl'n than n ot they arc simply ignorcd. Rcadcrs �l'nerally fa lll i l i ar with thl' worlds of alKient G rcece and Rome are likely to SllSpe(t, and rightly so, an attcmpt to adjust this hala nn: of thc historical record, not least hcca usc, as the playwri�ht sai d, it i s the onl y vcrsion they know. There seems little to hl' gained from seeking to create a pictu re of I I l yrians that dOl'S Ilot adopt a persp ective of them as peoples on the pni phery of th e Mediterranean worlds of Greece and Rome. ()n the other hand, it is now less acceptahle to order descrip tions of s uch geographically mar g inal societies according to SUdl (ategories as 'Hellenized', 'part-Hellenized' and 'Romani zed'. These lahels convey simplistic notions of a diffu sion of all mate rial innovation and development from an advanced centre to a more primitive periphery, t hrough varieties of direct or indi rect contact. H ap pily , we can now seek an escape from such narrow confines throu gh the in creasing archaeological
evidence for Illyrians and their way of life. Not that it can be claimed that a rchaeologi s ts and other students of prehistoric societies are free from a liking for tradition al explanations of ch ange and development, among which diffusion and migration continue to enjoy special favour. While we ha v e to accept that an authentic and comprehensive account of Illyrians will remain out of reach for the foreseeable future, the evidence now avail able justifies an interim statement. We may best begin with a reconnaissance of progress in IlIyrian studies.2 For all that William Shakespeare's Twelfth Night was set in a 'city in Illyria', two centuries were to elapse before that name appeared on the map of Europe. By the Treaty of Schonbrunn on 14 October 1809 a l ar ge tract of l and east of the Adriatic, including Carinthia, the Istrian penins u la and the Dalmatian coast, was ceded by Austria to the Napoleon ic kingdom of Italy to be ruled with the ti tle of the l l Iy r ian Provinces. In the 2 Salmon 1986 (Roman image of Classical scholarship).
lIIyrians), Irlllscher
1986
(JIIyrians
in
early ninl'tl'l'llIh u.'ntllry till' slirrin�s of Slav national h.'l'lin� be�an 10 hl' translatl'd into politiGll m;\nikstos more spe�ifi� to the estahlished order of Europe as wnstitlltl'll by the Con gress of Vienna in 1815, Among the Slav subjects of the Austro Hungarian Empire of the Hap s b u r gs the I I lyria n name was invoked by a m ov emen t in Cro a ti a , centred on its capital
Agram , the Zagreb of today. Here the continued dom i nancc of the Hu n garian language set off a movement among thc 'Illyrian Slavs', the Slovenes in the northwest a ro und Laibach (Ljubljana), the Croats and thc indepcnden t Serbs further east. It was from th is feeling of cultural oppression that assertions of close links between the ancicnt IIIyrians and the southern ( ' j ugo -' ) Slavs began to bc vigorou sly promoted, notably by Ljudevit Caj and the IlIyrian Movement. Though their argu ments lacked the support of scientific evidence their widespread currency as political slogans awakened the sense of an IIlyrian heritage from thc remote past. Moreover, it happened that around this period, in thc middle decades of thc nineteenth century, the foundations of the modern historical and archaeol ogical traditions of IlIyrian studies were being laid. J In Dalmatia historians and antiquaries of the Renaissance, notably Marko Marulic (1450-1524), had already begun to observc and rccord the abundant ancient remains. In the scven teenth century Vicko Prodic included an account of the Illyrian burial mounds on Brac in his chroniclc of thc i sland's history. In Croatia and Dalmatia, an Austrian territory after thc defeat of Napoleon , the collection and stu dy of ancient remains began with the foundation of archaeological m useums at Split in 1818-21 , at Zadar in 1830 and in the Croatian capital Zagreb in 1846. The first detailed account of thc ancient I1Iyrians appeared in thc Albanesische Studien of J. C. von Hahn, pub lishcd at Jena in 1854, in which the a uthor advanced the proposition that modern Alban ians were descended from ancicnt IlIyrians. In Austria imperial patronage of archaeology and ancient monuments was formally signalled in 1856 with the establishment in Vienna of the Central Com mission for the .l
Archaeological
Movement).
Museum
Puia
1986a
(exhibition
on
the
I1\yrian
The'
(;
St'are'h (or I/Iyrian$
Study an d Preservation of Artistic and Historical M onu men ts . In Zagreb the Croatian Arch aeol ogica l Soc i e ty was rc-estab lished in 1878. Around this time also some of the pioneers of Illyrian studies in Croatia began long and industrious careers, Frane Bulic in Split and at Zagreb, Sime Ljubic in the Museum and Josip Brunsmid in the University. In the Austrian port of Trieste the British consul Richard Burton contributed a study of ancient hill settlements (gradina) and other p rehisto ric remains in the Istrian peninsula (see figure 25), to be followed 30 years l ater by the major synthesis of Carlo Marchesetti.4 At the Congress of Berlin in the summer of 1878 the Great Powers of Europe sought to resolve the Eastern Question, specifically the wretched co ndi tion of Christian Slavs in the European territories of Ottoman Turkey. By assigning to Aus tria the troubled provinces of Bosnia and Hercegovina, the lot of the Slav population may not have been greatly improved but the heartlands of the ancient I lly rian s were laid open to historical and archaeological exploration. A vivid account of the archaeology of Austria's new territories, interspersed with comments on the political questions of the time, is provided by the works of the young Arthur Evans, later famous for his excavations at Knossos, centre of the Minoan civilization of Bronze Age Crete. In the late summer of 1875 the 25-year old Evans (see figure 1) made a journey across Bosnia and Hercegovina from Zagreb to Ragusa (Dubrovnik) on the Adri atic. As he and his brother Lewis moved south, news reached them of uprisings by Christian peasants in Hercegovina and of the atrocities committed by the irregular troops sent to quell them. Though on a lesser scale than the Bulgarian atrocities of the following year, the sufferings of the South-Slav peasants described in Evans' lurid and frankly sensationalized account produced an outburst of indignation in England. It had been his ambition to discover forgotten and exciting civilizations but his search for Illyrians soon became bound up with the cause of Slav freedom, a movement in which he now began to play a leading part. As a special correspondent of the Manchester Guardian based at Ragusa fr om 1877 he reported in unflatter4
Burton 1874,
Marchesetti 1903.
Figure 1
Arthur E lIQns ;n 1878
ing terms the impositioll ot Austrian ruk aftl'r t ilt' Ikrlin Congress, His intemperatl' assl'rtions t hat t il t' Empl'ror's rl'giml' w as no b ett e r than that of the Moslem Turk, and in some respects was worse, l'vokcd little rl'sponse in England, In 1 HH 1
he pub lished a sympathetic account of the activities of Slav dissidents in the nearby mountains and, a fter a spell in p r is on, he was de p o r ted from A ust ri a n territory in A pril 1882," Though they ended in ignominy, his year s of res idence at Ragusa allowed Ev a ns to travel wi dely th roughout the I l lyri a n lands, to collect and study an ti q u iti e s . His 'Antiquarian Rese a rches in III yricu m ', pu b li shed in four parts by the Soc i ety of Antiquaries of London in i t s Archaeologia (1883-5), still repay st udy for thei r wealth of information and observation of de t a il at first hand. He described a society which had been largely cut off from the rest of Europe during nearly five centuries of Ottoman rule. H i s discursive and e nthu s ia stic accounts of p rehis to ric and classical remains and the an c ient customs of the contemporary Slavs were not composed in a sch ola rly seclusion but amid a career of poli t i ca l journalism and agi tation. The achievements of IIlyrians in the remot e past were de p lo yed in order to em phas ize to his readers how dark and regressive had been the era of Turkish rule. Though castigated for its insensitive ways the Austrian regime in Bosnia and Hercego v in a transformed the archaeological pic tu re of those areas from one of near total darkness after the cen tu rie s of Turkish rule into one of the best observed r egi ons of Europe. The advance began with thc foundation of the provincial mu s e u m in S ar ajev o (Bosnisch-Hercegovinische Landesmuseum). Several major programmes of excavation were soon under way; the Neol ithic settlement at Butmir near Sara jevo; the grea t Bronze and Iron Age burial grounds on the Glasinac p la tea u in eastern Bosnia; in the wcs t the I ro n Age cemetery at Jezerine near Bih ac in the Una val ley and the pile dwellings at Donja Doli na on the river Sava. Thc results and finds werc published in the museum Bulletin (Glasnik) in Serb ian, and in German in the volumcs of Scientific Rcports (Wissenschaftliche
-' Wilkcs
1976.
Mitteilungen
aus
Bosnien
und
der
#,t!isnJ/'/'rv 1I111I"n./IIs Ilt'r;:t'WIl'IIhl) whil·h appl'arcd Iwtwl'l'n I Hl}J and I Y 16 along with sl'vl'ral l11onographs on l11ajor sitl's. In addition to thc .1rdlacologicll papers thesc volumcs also included many pion l'l-ring 'iwdics hy anthropologists and ethnologists wh o seized
known area of Europe.6 of the twe ntieth century has "l'l'n many important discoveries and numerous publications rdating to the lIIyrian pa s t . Most of this work h as been under takcn hy s peciali sts in the u niver siti es and in the national IllUSl'UIl1S of Belgrade, Zagreb, Skopje, Sarajevo and Ljubljana. In addition much important evidence that might have been lost throllgh new building and other d eve lop me nt has been rescued hy the hard-pressed antiquities services of the Republics. Several of the long-established periodicals were reconstituted after the Sl'c(md World War and con tinue to be published, including the Sldrinar of Be lgrad e , the Glasnik of the Sarajevo museum, an d thl' V;esnik of the Zagrcb and Split museums. Some important Ilew periodicals have i ssued from the new statc academies for scientific research at Zagreb, Ljubljana (the Slovenian jou rn al Arheoloski Vestnik) and more recen tly Sarajevo. Herc the Centre for Balkan Studies (Centar za balkanoloska ispitivanja) of the Academy of Sciences in Bosnia and Hercegovina, under the inspiration of Alojz Benac, has published an Annual (Godisnjak), numerous monograph s and a massive synthesis of Yugoslav prehistory in several volumes now nearing completion (Praehistoriia Jugoslavenskih Zemalja). With thc international community in mind, the Archaeological Society of Yugoslavia has since 1 954 published Archaeoiogica lugoslavica containing brief rep orts on major new finds and im porta n t research in English, French or German, followed later by Arheoloski Pre gied (Archaeological Preview) with annual s u mmaries of recent field-work. The same body has als o initiated a series of mono graphs for major excavation reports or archaeological s ynth eses. At the time of writing political ten sions appear to h ave made concerted publication at the feder al level more difficult, but the quality of archaeolo gi cal publication remains high, Ihl' dlanCl' to work in this little In Yugoslavia t h l' sccond half
6 Stipcevic 1977a, 3-13; Munrol900 for a first·hand account of progre s s at these sites and of the Sarajcvo congress of 1894.
work
in
10
i n t h l: tl ow o f V O I I l I l I t'S l rol l l � ; I r ; I I l" V o , w h l l l' t h l" p ro (Materijali) o f t h e ;1 1 1 1 1 1 1 , 1 1 l'O l l k n' l l l'l' o t t h l" Y l l �( )s la v ' A rdl aeological Soci ety co nt i n l l l' t o a ppea r , I n Albania the first systelll ;! t ic rl'cord o f a n ci e n t s i t l' s W ;I S m a d c beforc t h e Fi rst Wo rl d W;\ r hy CH I Pa tsch ( 1 1J ( ) 4 ) a n d subsequentl y by CamiJIo Prasch n i k e r a n d A r n o kl Sch o ber (19 1 9) . Thei r topographical studies rema i n the b a s i s of modern studies of I l I y ri a n s ites, while bctween the wars Italian expeditions tel ded to be focused on cl assical sites o n the coast, notably A po \ l o n i a where m ajor excavations were di rected by 1 .1.'011 Re)" S i n ce the Second World War archaeological explo
Ilot a h l y
n'l'd i n gs
;
ration h as heen i mpelled by a national pol icy to establish the l i n k between modern Al ban i ans and ancient JI Iyrians. The i n v es t i ga tion of both prehistoric and classical si tes, \'v·cll ll n dl:rwa y du ring the fifties and sixties, gained impetus in the seventies through a heightened pol itical interest in the Al banian I I l y ri a n heri tage. Research was centred on the archaeological and ethnographical museum in Tirana from 1 948 until 1 976 v..!hen the Albanian Academy of Sciences created its Centre for Archaeological Research i n Tirana with eight regional offices covering the entire country. In addition to the National Museum in Ti rana, major museums have been organized at Durres, Apollonia, Fieri, Saranda and Butrint. Si ncc 1 97 1 all major archaeological research in Albania, including several con ferences and colloqui a attended by foreign specialists, h as been publishcd in the periodical lliria, wh i le the many activitics of the Monuments Protection Service are recorded in Monu mentet. H
A wel come development has been the publication of general works on Illyrians, notably that by Aleksandar Stipccvic, which first appeared in 1 968 in an Italian edition and subsequently in Yugoslav ( 1 974) and American ( 1 977) versions. A more technical study by the Polish scholar W. Paj akowski is more accessible in a German edition published in Sarajevo (1 980). Several general works on IIIyrians h ave appeared in Albania, 7 N o w registered in the bibliographies of Sti pct'\'ic (1 967, 1 977b, 1 9 7 8 , 1 9 84a) a n d Skegro 1 9 8 8 . M Bibliograph y for 1 945-7 1 in Jubani 1 972a a n d s u rvey fo r 1945-8 6 in
Ca banes
J 9 S Ik.
1 1 a l l l o n g w hil.." h O l l l' I l l a y i l l l" i U l k t il l' IHOl.." l'l'd i l l gs o f t ill' I Y72 I l I y r i a ll I.."O l l gl"ess p u h l i s hed ill v o l u ll ll's 4 -6 of Jliria , A Ill a j or I.."O l l l pi l a t i o l l is / '('S IIIyri!'1ls : , ,/}('r(lts historiq ul's ( 1 9 8 5 ) edited hy Sd i ll l I sla l l l i , w i t h other l"< > I l t ri h u to r s in c l u d i n g S. Anama l i, M. K ork u l i a l l d t h e doyen o f A l ha n i a n a rchaeology f. Prendi. ( ; l'J" l l l a n technology has 110\\/ fu rn i s h ed more than one fine v i ., u a l rl'wrd o f A l b a n i a n a rch aeology : one is the lavi shly i l lus t r.l I ed I.." a t a l o g u e (edited by A. Eggebrecht) produced for an l' x h i h i tion at H i l dcsheim during the summer of 1 98 8 , while the 1 l l 1 1 l1 ll ll1ents of Albanian Illyria arc well presented in a guide hook by Gun tram Koch ( 1 98 9 ) . 9
T h e current version of the Albanian theory o f their TIIyrian
o r i gi n s is centred on the unbroken descent of modern A l banians from an Illyrian people already formed in Bronze Age times a n d in a geographical area that coincided with that occupied t od a y by Albanian speakers, the modern state of Albania and the Yugoslav region of Kosovo. The guiding principles of
a rch aeological research are the following: excavation of prehis t or i c burial tu muli to supplement evidence for prehistoric IIIyri a n s from the Korcc basin and to define more clearly the rl'lati ons with prehistoric cultures of Greece, Italy a nd Yugosl a v i a ; the growth of Il Iyrian urban settlements in the Hellenistic period ( fourth to second centuries BC) and thei r rclations with the Greek colonies on the coast; and studies in the late Roman and early medieval periods to demonstrate the links between l I I y rians under Roman rule and Albanians, who fi rst appear during the second half of the eleventh century. I O The continu ing political collisions between Albanians a n d t h e Yugoslav Serbs have h a d a marked impact on IIIyrian studies. It is no novel ty th at debates over rhe ethnic affinities of ancient peopl es in southeast Europe should be bound up with the antipathies of Serbs, Bulgars, Greeks and Albanians but the question of Kosovo has become more serious than at any time since it was first posed at the break-up of th e Ottoman Empire. After the First World War the area moved between Al bania and Yugosl avia according to the bal ance of Great., Also the
10
1 98 4
Buda "1 9 8 4 ,
Clermont-Ferrand
col l o q u i u m , Ca banes
1 987,
1 2.
, ,,,, S" , I I'I /, /1 1 / ' " \,//, 111.\
PO\.... cr po l i t i cs, t h o u �h to r 1 1 I o s t
01
t h l pni od I t h ;l., H' l l u i l ll' d '
undcr Yugosl av control w h i le t h l' po p u l a t i o n h a s hn:o l l 1 l' 1 1 1 0 n' and morc Al hanian, Fo r th i s rl' ;l SOIl t h l' l' t h n i c a ffi n i t i es ( I f t h e Dardani ans, ancient inha bi ta n ts 0 1 K osovo, 1 l o rt h l' rn J\1a cc donia and south ern Serbia, have att ra,,:ted a t t ent i o n A l ba n i a n s hold them to be Iliyrians, ethnica l l y homogeneoLls w i th the rcst, while a Serbian view argues that D a rd a n i �l Il s represent an intermingl ing of both IIlyrian and Thracian elements, There is l i ttle d anger of lasting damage being cau sed by argu ments being conducted on these lincs when the evidencc is h i storical or epigraph i c and remains in the public domain, but the damage is done when archaeological cvidence is successively deployed to support one hypothesis with another. These reconstructions of prehistory - 'houses of cards' according to one scholar provc suprisingly di fficult to demolish even long after thei r fou ndations have becn shown not to exist. Similar problems arise regarding thc peoples of ancient Epirus, no\\' dividcd betwcen Al hania and Greece, Against a widespread view that they spdke a form of Greek the Albanians argue that the Epi rotes wcre one with the rest of the Illyrians. 1 1 I f wc set aside some of the themes inspired by modern pol itics we arc sti l l left with several worthwhile areas of enquiry for which much new evi dencc i s to hand , Who were the I Ilyrians and how valid a rc suggested definitions of lllyrians on the basis of archaeological and linguistic evidence, taken together or separately ? How werc Illyrians linked with other inhabitants of the Danu be lands, Th racians, Daco-Moesians, Italic peoples, Greeks and Celts, i n their material culture and language ? What happened to the IIIyrians under Roman rulc and how were they affected by the process known as Romanization ? What connection did the 'II Iyrian emperors' of the third and fourth centuries AD have with the pcoples conquered by the first Roman emperor Augustus? Is there evidence for the survival of an IIIyrian native culture during the Roman and early Byzantinc periods ? What traces (')f Illyrians can be detected today in the culture of the South Slav s and Albanian s ? Before we tackle the ,
) 1 For the Albanian vi e w see Hadri 1 976 and for the Serbian response M. Garasa n i n 1 9 80 and the comments of Benac 1 98 7 b on Isla mi et a l . 1 9 8 5 ,
1 I
p n' l l I S I O r l l O rl g l l 1 <, o t I l l y n , l l l s , 1 1 1 1 1 t l l I ' l l' l' v o l l I l l O I I d o w l I 1 0 I h l' t i l t h l l' l l I l I r y 1 \ ( W l' I I l 1 l s l lO I l S l d n I h l' I . l l l d s I 1 I w h ilh I h l' }' l i v l'd , ' 1 1 I l.'l' I I I Y l' i ; 1 1 I L l I l d s C l Pl'S l' x l l l h l l Sl'\" l' r. d d i s l i l l ll i n' tc a t u r es t h a t i l l 1 posl'd ; 1 p a I I 1' rn o t I i le O i l I h l' 1 1 1 h a h i 1 ;l I l t s t h a t w a s very d d t l' l'l' l I l tW i l l l'vell
till'
a d j a l'l' l l I P;l r t s o f E u ro p e ,
IIIyrian TI l l' I I l y ri a n
lands are
landscapes 1 1
dom i n a ted
b y the results o f Europe's
, s I I"l'Cl' n t phase of mountain building. The extensive sedimen l a r y hl'd s of limestone, cl ay and sandstone created in the Pa l aeo 1111
w i l' period \.... ere raised into a series of complex folds to create I hl' A l p i n e systems of rel ief On the east th e main A l pine system d i v i d e s , the northern to form the Carpathians of Czecho S l o v a k i a and Roman i a which then double back as the Stara I ' la l l i n a o f Bulgaria. The southern branch continues sou.
1 1H';lstwards, para l le l with the Adriatic, as the Dinaric system ot Yugoslavia and then into Al ban i a and Greece as the Pindus ra n ge , Bet\vcen the two Alpine systems l ies the great Hungari a n or Pa n nonian plain , divided by the Bakony h i l l s, where the I )a n u be turns sourh at the great bend north of Budapest, into a sma l i er n onhwestern plain (Kiss-Al mld) and the great plain ( Nagy-AW>ld) to the southeast. Drainage of this area i s entirely to the Danube, which exi ts from the plain by the Tron Gates �orge throu gh the Carpathians cast of Belgrade. Europe's great l's t ri ver, navigable from Ulm in southern Germany, flows for I 72S miles from its source in the Black Forest to its delta on thl' Black Sea. Its major tributaries drain most o f the TI lyrian hl nds, from the Julian Alps in the northwest to the Alps of northern Al bania. From this quarter heavy winter rains contri b ute to a sustained £low, partly cancelling out the sum mer m a x i m um from the melting snow of the Alps and the summer ra i n fa ll of the plains. Compared wi th th is vast system the rivers which flow into the Mediterranean arc insignificant. Along the Adriatic onl y the Drin and the Neretva are permanent rivers, Il
Accounts of
TUl"I1ock 1 9 !! !! .
h i stori cal
geography a rc fu rnished by Pounds 1969 and
14 the res t hl' i n g l i t t k m o re t h a n sl'a son a l t o r n: n l'i , a l l d l' V l' 1 l t h osl'
are navigable for l igh t na ft oll l y i n t ll l' i r lowest m llrses . A t t he same time these lesser Ad r i a t i � r i vers are i m po rt a l l t lw� a l l se they offer a means of passage through i n tra�table co u n t r y , a n d the most notable in this regard is the Vardar o f Ma�l'don i a for passage between the Aegean and the Danube basin . The route along the Neretva between the Adriatic and central Bosnia is not easy but was evidently used al ready in preh i storic times. In Albania the Mediterranean rivers are al together more sign i fi cant. Flowing mainly in a northwesterly direction between paral lel ranges, some of the larger streams, including the Drin , Mat and Shkumbin, cut through some hills to reach the sea by meandering courses across the coastal plain. The largest system is that of the Drin, which as the Black Drin (Drin i Zi ) fl ows through a deep vall ey northwards to Kukcs, where it is joined by the White Drin (Beli Drin) from the Metohij a basi n. The united stream flows west through the mountai n s for 25 m i l es in a deep gorge but at the edge of the plain divides between a westward course into the Lake o f Sh kodcr a n d a tortuous southern course t o the sea a t the ancient and m odern port of Lezha . With in the bend of the Drin the river Mat flows northwestwards through l ower hills before turning west to cut through the last range of hills bordering the plain. In central Albania the Shkumbin rises close to Lake Ohrid and then turns wcst towards the sea, while the Devoll, which once draincd Lake Prespa and the Oh rid basin, takes a zig-zag course following and crossing several mountain ranges. In contrast the more southerly Osum and Vijose flow northwestwards in their main courses parallel with the ranges. Throughout this area there occur abrupt changes in rivcr character at the meeting of moun tain and plain. The flows become slower and great q uantities of alluvium bring braided streams, flood plains and frequent changes of course among the malarial marshlands th at dry out in the hot summers. The Cretaceous limestones of the Dinaric ranges arc not acutely folded and present a uniquely dry surface devoi d of vegetation over large areas; they comprise the most cxtensive and spectacular example of the karst land-formation. Threc regions can be distingui shed : the J ul ian Alps and Karawanken in the northwest; the western Dinara 40 to 70 milcs broad,
I� t 't ft."
1 1 / ', " \'
"/ 1 1 / \' 1 / , " "
l' X I l' l l d i l l g f ro l l l I s I I" ! ; 1 1 0 C n'l'll' , l l l d
l a l l l l lg s l n'p l y
l 'i
i l l I l Ll n y
1 0 1 1 l l' A d r i a l i l' w l l l'rl' 1 1 I ' Sl' I"l'l' I l l'l1 h y I O l l g a l l d I l a r ro w I s l . u l l l ... I w l o l l g i l l g 1 0 I h l' fol d l i l i es o f I h l' D i n a r i l' s y s t c ll l ; and I h l' l';l s t l' !' 1 l D i n ar a , lowl'!' a n d d i s se ct ed h y v a l l cy s of rivers
pl;ln's
flow l I l g
t h e S a v a a l l d D a l l ll hl" where the h ills fal l Pa n no n i a n p l a i n , S O ll t h of this plain and to 1 1 1 1' C;l s I o f t h e D i n a ril' s y stc lll l ies an area dissected by two I l l , q o r r i v e rs a n d thci r tri butaries, the !",lorava flowing north to 1 I 11 ' I >a 1 1 1 1 hc and th e Vardar (Axios) south to the Aegean . This I'l'gi o l l l'< m ta i n s many plains and basins, usually with l acustrine dl' J lO s i t s, separated by hi g,h but generally isolated mountain I l l a SSl' S , notably the great Sar planina (2702 m ) . Through the v ,l I ll'Ys ;l Ild basins of this region pass several major routes I ll'l ""'l'l' l l the Danube and the Mediterrancan, the so-called Mor ,\ V ;I - Vardar corridor. 1 1 1 A l ha n i a a coastal plain, north of the Shkumbin the Kavaje, ,o l l l h of i t the Myzeqej a, extends north from Cape Linguetta ( K l'pi Gj uhezcs) for more than 1 00 miles unti l the border with M o ntenegro, a fter which the coastline turns northwestwards OI l I d t h e Dinaric ranges approach the sea. In placcs the plain is I lVl.'r 30 m iles wide but e1sewhcre is interrupted as the hill s rOl11 e within a few miles of the sea. Flat and only a few metres a hove sea-level, the surface consists mainly of layers of sand i l l l d a l l uvium deposited by the rivers in the manncr descri bed Il hove. As a whole the l i ne of thc coast is advancing and has moved more th an th ree miles since classical times. The area has always provided excellent winter grazing but is now extensively l'xploitcd for the irrigated cultivation of rice and cotton. Major set tlements have developed either as coastal ports (Durres and Vlor a ) or important towns on thc inland margins (Shkoder, Ti rana, El basan and Berat) but rarely in betwcen. I n Yugoslavia the karst is everywhere dose to the coast, most dramatically in the Vclebit range in the north which falls al most sheer into the sea. Except for the central stretch between Zadar and Split there are no significant areas of l owland adjoining the sea north of the plain of the Bojana which drains the Lake of Sh koder. From here to the Neretva some small and isolated a reas of flat land h ave supported the settlemen ts of Dubrovnik, Herl'cg-Novi, Kotor, Budva and Uicinj . Beh i n d the last l i es the hasin of the Lake of Shkoder, into which the Montenegrin a l' ross it
to
,I W ,I Y ge l l t l y 1 0 l h c
16
ri vers Leta a n d !\1 o ra �',1 I l o w I h ro l l gh a n a l l l l v l , d p l a i n . T h l' coastal ranges arc n e x t i nt e r r l l pll'd hy I I l l' hasi n o f I I l l' N l' I"l'1 v a , the only ri ver to cross t h e karsl from a so u r ce w h ich l i l's to the north of i t. After fl owing t h ro u gh several ba s i n s l i n ked by narrows the stream reaches the sea th rough a s m a l l del ta. At Makarska south of Split the high ranges retreat i nland and the high ly i ndented coast as far as the Zrmanja estuary beyond Zadar has always been i n tensively settled, notably a round the Bay of Castles ( Kastelanski zali) on which l ay Salona, the largest ancient settlement of the area and prccursor of medieval and modern Split (Spalato). North of the Krka estuary at S i bellik the limestonc plateau rises towards the interior but contains several bands of alluvial basins which h ave long been settlcd and cul tivated. B etwcen the Zrmanja and the h ead of the Qu arnero ( Kvarner) gulf the coast is barred by the Velebit range, and cven the great port of Rijeka at i ts northern extremity is con fincd to a narrow shel f bctween mountains and sea . The Istrian pen insula i s formcd of a low limestone platform linked to thc higher J ulia n karst along a l inc roughl y bctween Tricste and Rijcka. On thc west and a part of the east coast areas of lowland border the sca . Though karst features pre domi nate, and there arc few rivcrs, the l owcr altitudc and a higher watcr-ta ble has inhibited thc more sevcre conditions of thc Dinaric rcgion. Bchind the coastal plain of Alba n i a lics a bel t of hills formcd for the most part by the fol ding of sedimcntary sandstone, shale and limestone. Thc greater rcsistance of the l ast to surface crosion has rcsulted i n steep ridges separated by softer, more eroded hil ls. In the north this zone confines the river Mat but furthcr south thc Shkumbin cuts thro u gh several ridge s in gorges. Further south again this zone o f h i l ls broadens to more than 5 0 miles to reach thc coast and contains u p to eight stccp sidcd ridges running parallel with thc coast, most rising to arou nd 1 5 00 metrcs, although the Nemcrcke rangc beh'Veen the Vijose and the Drino attains 2486 metrcs. On the north the valleys open to the coastal plain and thei r courses al ternatc between narrows and wide basins containing the major settle mcnts such as Gjirokastra, Tepeleni and Berat. These valleys offer several rOlltes to thc south, in m arked contrast with northern Albania whcre the mountains risc steeply from the
/� " . t/" , 1 1 / " ' / I' "l //11' ' '0/'' \
p L 1 I 1 l I I I h ; l r P; I " ,l ge I I I I h l' i l l l n i m . TI l l '. d i q i l l ll i o l l h a s rl'S l I i t ed 1 1 1 1 1 1 , 1 1 0 1' d i Hl' !'l' l l l'es 0 1 h i s l o r i l ,d d n' l' l l I p I I H' 1 l 1 he l w l'l' l l I l o rt h e rn , \ l i d Sl I l I l h l' l' l l A l ha l l i a , a d i v i dl' w h i d l , a s w e s h a l l sce l at e r l l I a r k ed a i so a s O l l l h e rn l i m i t 0 1 I l I y r i a l l p e op l e s
,
.
highlands steep-si ded and narrow p , I ., S , I !!.l'S of t i l l' D r i n S h k ll m b i ll , l kvol l and Osu m . In the north , I grea l a rc of A l h a n i a n A l ps rises to around 25 0 0 metres, .l I l 1 l l 1 l g .,... h i d1 a rc a reas of summer pasture and near inaccess t h l t-, I h o u gh i n h a bi ted v a l l eys, To the east of the upper Drin t i l l' I l I g h I l l a ss o f Korab (2764 m) is no less rugged, Between I I l l'sl' l I l a SSl'S t h e altern ating gorges and small basins of the B l . l l- k I h i l l ] , ;l v e never been a route in modern times. South of I h e S h k u l l l h i n the h i l l s a re l ess rugged and there occur several I I p l a n d p l a i n s w h e re cultivation is possible. Here the existence 0 1 I h e I ra nSVl'rsc valleys has allowed the passage between e a s t , l l l d wesl a n d fo r that reason has al w a ys been the h i ghly .. I L l I l'gic a rea of the southern Balkans. The l ake region which .. l l'add l es the A l ba n i all- Yugosl a v border consists of several .I l I l I v i a l h a s i n s formed by north-south fa ulti n g, containing l ,a kL's ( ) h ri d , Prespa and Li ttle Prespa, all once much l arger t h a n t h ey a rc today. South of Ohrid the extensive Korcc basin i s dOl t l'd ...... i th m a rshes and rdict lakes, and a si milar, smaller hasi n L'x ists a round Bilisht south o f Lake Prespa . E a s l a n d northeast of the Al banian highlands there lies a 111i1 Zl' of river v a l l e y s and alluvial basins, drained by rivers l I o w i n g in a l l di rections, Th i s region , comprising sOll thern Ser hl,I a n d Y u gosl a v Macedonia, i ncludes in the valleys of the Mor;l va, Y a r d a r and I bar some of the major rOlltes between t i lt' M ed i terranean and central Europe used since Neolithic l i l l ll'S. To the west there is no way across the Dinaric region u ll t i l t h l' .I u l i a n karst plateau at the head of the Adriatic. The Mca hl' l ongs to the Pcl agonian m assif that remained unaffected hy t ill' l a te r A l pine folding which produced the high mountain dw i n s t o the cast and west, a l though it is extens ively faulted 11 IId h a s Iwl'll a ffected by volcanic activity, The lakes which C I I I (t' fi l kd t h l' h a s i n s h a v e l o n g s i n ce d ra i n e d away a nd narrow " h a l l n d s t h a t O I I lT j o i ned l a k e w i t h l a k e form the modern pil l l L' m of d ra i n age. Thl' Tnl i a rv hasi ns of t i l l' V . m ! .l r v a l le v a ro u n d Ti ro\' Yeles I k l l l l l d t h i s i l l l l' rn l l'd i ;l t l' LI I I !!.l' o f m o u n t a i ns, the
I I I l'; I S I l' l' n A l h;l ll i a a rc d i v i d ed hy t h e ,
IX
and
'/ I,, ,. S" < I " " /"1' II/ \'n< lll., S k o p j c a re I h t, l a rge s l a n d m os l i n l po rl a n l o f r i l l' reg i o n .
The former is m o re h i l l y ;ln d l:oll1 p r i ses t reekss r i d gl's w h i dl
ri se to around 700 metres, sett l e m e n ts a n d I:u l t i v ;u i o l l hei n g for the most part confined to the river val ley. Between t h e t wo basins the river flows i n a gorge that is fol lowed by the rai l way but not by the modern road. Above this the tri angu lar Skopje basin is bounded by steep-sided faulted mountains but is a ccess ible by routes from th ree directions, from the northwest by the Vardar flowing from the Tetovo basin (sce below), from the north where a route enters from Kosovo via the Kacanik gorge and the tributary Lepenac between the massifs of th e S ar and the Skopska Crna Gora and from the northeast along the river PCinj a and the Kumanovo b a si n to the Morava system, The upper course of the Vardar forms an arc that encl oses the Jakupnica massif (2540 m), from wh ich the ridges of Nidze and Kozuf extend southwards to enclose the Bitola-Prilep basin . Th is extends from north to south more than 6 0 m i les and i s drained by the C rn a Reka (Black River) which , after exiting from the southern limi t of the plain, doubles back to a north ea stward course th ro u gh an area of mountains to join the Vardar bel O\.... Titov Veles near the ancient P aeonia n capital of Stobi (Gradsko) . Though marshy in some areas th is plain - the ancien t Pel a gonia - has supported a l a rge popu l ation from preh i storic ti mes and contains two of the major cities of Yugos lav Macedonia, Pri l ep and Bitola (formerly Monastir). West and northwest of this area th e di stricts of Ohrid and Tetovo arc dominated by the n o rth-sou th ranges of the Pindus system, nota bly the S ar planina and i ts s o u thward contin uation formed by the Korab, Bistra (2 1 63 m) and Karaorman (2242 m). Togcther they form a barrier t<] cast-west movement morc th an 1 00 miles long. East of thc Sar lies the roughly parallel Suva Gora to the sout h west of Skopje which is co ntin u ed south wards as the ranges of Plaken ska and Pclister, between wh ich lie ( from south to north) the ba s ins of Prespa , Oh rid, Debar (on thc Black Drin between thc J abl anica and Stogovo ranges), Kicevo and Gostivar-Tetovo, the last drained to the north by the upper Vardar. M uch of thc Ohrid and Prespa basins are covered by lakes that sti l l in p l a ces rcach to the foot of s teep mountains. Ohrid, drained n orthwards by the Drin , has contracted and is now bordered with mar shes, notably
U , ', I, �,
" " , ' 1\ '
"l 11/\' 1 / 1 1 1 1 \
;1 1'0 1 1 I l l l S t r l l �a i n t h e n o rt h , I ' n'!'o, p , l
I'>
1 '1
I (l U n l l' t n's h i � l l l' r d Ll n
o h r i d , fro l l l w h i l"l l i t i s d i v i l k d h y t i l l' ( ; 'l l i l' i t' a r;1 I 1 �l" a l l d w a s o n n' d ra i ned w es t w a rd s v i 'l I . i t t le I ' rl'spa .l I l d t h e A l b a n i a n I )l'Vo l l , h i l t i t s l e v el h a s l o n � s i n Cl' s l i n k a n d t h ere i s n o w n o d i sl" h a r�c to t h e sea . A l t h e sa m c t i l 1 1 l' i t s reco rded tl uctuations I I I levcl a re ca u sed by d ra i n a ge i nt o u n derground passages d i w ) l v e d in t h e l i mestone of thc h ; I S i l l 'i to t h e n o rth th e Ohrid
Pindus. Unlike the i sol ated basin has ahvays been an i m p or t a n t ccntre of th e southern Bal kans. Oncc the domain of I he E n ch c 1 e i and c r os s ed by the Roman Via Egnatia, it w a s the .. i t l' o f o n e of the early Slav settl ements and then for a ti me h l';l r t l a n d of the First B u l garian Empi re. The ge n t l y rolling terrain of the l i n ked basins of Kosovo and Mctoh i j a is bo u n ded by steep-sided moun ta i ns formed along fa u l t-li ncs. On the southwe s t lie relatively low ranges (c. I S 00 I l l ) n o rtheast of the united Drin, on the northwest Koprivnik ( .?SW m) and Mokra Gora ( 2 1 S S m), wh i le to the so u thea s t l i e t h e northern heigh ts of the S ar massif. Thc Meto h i ja basin in t he west is drained by the Whi te Drin whi ch exits through a gorge to meet the Black Drin at Kukes i n northern A l bania. Th l' two h i l l s which defi ne the Metoh ij a on the east, Crnoljeva a n d C icevica, are no barrier to communication with the Kosovo hasin around Pristina, wh ich is sma l l er and morc elongated, This i s dra i ned by the northwards-flowing Sitnica which joins the IbaI', itsel f a tributary to thc Morava, at Kosovska Mitrovica a t the n orthern edge of the basin, where the united stream fol l ows a gorge between t h e massifs of Rogozna (1 5 04 m ) and Kopaoni k ( 20 1 7 m ) . Towards t h e south of the pl ain, a round the town of Urosevac, thcre l ies a n area between the dra inage of the Sitn i ca/lbar system and th at of the Nerod i m ka, which feeds the Varda r via thc Lepenac at Kaea n i k . T h i s i s the crucial area of a major north-south passagc between the upper Vardar and thc Morava basin around Nis. I t was in Kosovo th at the advancing Turks destroyed the for ces o f Serbia i n 1 3 8 9, a n d i n more recent times, as a part of th e Sanj ak of Novi Pazar, thc regi on was a subject of dispute bctween Austria and Turkey. North of thc Kumanovo basin rises the Morava, w hose northward cou rse l i nks a string of small basins that once con tai ned lakes. As the South ern 0 uzna) Morava thc stream crosscs
the R h odope p la t e a l l hy a I O l l g go rge , l i l l k l l l )!, V r . I I l J l' . l l l d P r i h o J to the m a j o r b a s i n o f Ll':'i k o v a l: ; 1 ro l l l i d 2. S m i le s I O l l g. F ro m there i t passes into a more d ra m a t i c go rge t o rea dl t h e grl';l t basin of Nis, cross-roads of th e ccntral Ba l k a n s . A fter v e l another defile at Stalac comes the mecting with the
Wcst�rn
(Zapadna ) Morava, which has also flowed th rough several gorges l i nking the basins of Pozega, C acak, Kraljevo and Kruse vac. The u n i ted river then passes through a final defile in th e Rhodope system at Bagrdan to the final broad valley where the now puny rel ic of a great river gently meanders through marshes to the Danube. In spite of the gorgcs and defiles that had to be by-passed through the surrounding hills, the Morava up to Leskovac has been the favoured route for passage towards the Aegean . Thc rai lway and the m a i n modern road now continue along the river via Vranje and Priboj and cross by a dry valley into the KUl11anovo basin and from therc reach the Vardar. An alternative route, avoi ding the detour of the gorge at Grdelica, follows the Jablani ca from the Leskovac basin into the Kosovo basin. A longer but easier detour, avoiding the SOllthcrn Morava altogether, follows the Western Morava up to Kra ljevo and then the Ibar to Kosovo, a l i n e now also taken by railway and modern road. The area east of the Ibar around the massi f of Kopaonik is sti l l covered with dense forests of oak and becch . Several of the smaller basins within th is area con tained cultivablc l and, incl uding Proku plje drained by the Toplica into the Southern Morava, Gnjilane, where rises the Southern Morava, and, further north, the Malo (Little) Kosovo basin. For a distance of around 45 0 miles an uninterrupted system of mountains, high pl ateaus, deep vallcys and gorges extends from northern Albani a to the head of the Adriatic. Becoming steadily broader towards the south , this Dinaric system consti tutcs a near-impassable barrier between the Adriatic and the Pannonian plain. Most of the rock is l i mestone of the Trias and Cretaceous ages and has no surface drainage except for thc streams that cross the clay floor of a basin (polje) before vanish ing underground. The surface of the l i mestone plateau in the karst is quite dry and there is no accumulation of red soil to sustain even a covcr of scrub vegetation . Cultivation is i mpossi ble, while travel i n the region is made difficult by ser-
2. 1 1',l I l·d r i dgl"
l'. l l i 'l·d h >' 1 I 1 1 1 ' \' l' l I l ' I ' l I ' l l I l l . T i l l' 1 1 1 1 )'. 1 \,'O I l S P I U I O I l 'o
s l I r L l u' I O I' l l I . l I i o l l '" a n' t i ll' d e p re s s l o l I , ( d o l i l l a ) , w h lTl' a h e a v y I'l· ... i d l l a l
day
CI I I
reLJ r d
dll' d r. l l l l a ge o f Ll i n w,l I l· r . T h e s e
d e p res, i o l l s Ll n I I l 1 i l e to ' 1 , 1' 1 1 1 d r y v ; r l k y s , hut t h e
most sign i fi level a rea of . 1 1 1 11\ ' 1 1 1 1 1 1 IWt \v l'L'n r i dges 0 1 1 w h i c h ra i n water can seasonally a n' l I l 1 l l l l a t e to form a l a ke. Some of the higher pol je remain d r y h i l t t h os e nca rer the coast at a lower level usually have "I h·s for sOl11 e Illonths of the year, while the Lake of Sh kodCr is i n fact a polje whose sur face lies below sea-level and i s P lT l I I ;I l1L'n t l y i n undated. These areas afford the on l y place for pl' \' l 1 \ a l l e n t sett l e m e n t i n the karst, with most of the villages he i n g spread around the margins. Towards the northeast of the I ) i n a r i c system the karst becomes discontinuous, interrupted hv heds of sandstone and s h ale. Wh ile the l i nes of relief follow d;L' sa m e northwest to southeast axis, the ridges are broader a nd less rugged and the surface greener with more extensive forL·sts. There is also more surface drainage to the few major ri v e r s which cut across the lines o f rdief th rough deep valleys a n d gorges to l ink narrow basins of cultivated land. The Dinaric rq�ion of Yugoslavia compri ses some of the most impenetrahle (OLl ntry anywhere in E urope. Its inhahitants h ave never submit lL·L1 to a central authority, as local loyalties prevail and the fragmented terrain hinders contact even between adjacent com Ill u n i ties. By the same token, resistance to the would-be conqu t'ror has always been determ ined ; the struggles of the Pan nonian I l I yrians against the Romans and those of the Montenegrins agai nst the Turks were emulated by Yugos l avs during the Sewnd World War. Beyond th e h igh karst plateaus and the adjacent high moun tai ns lies a mountainous region where heights rise to bet\lveen 1 3 00 and 1 600 metres. Here the valleys are broader and offer easier passage, while there are long-estahlished major centres in Sarajevo, Visegrad and Novi Pazar. East of the Drina an area of broad valleys and rounded hills ends at the Golija planina ( 1 833 m) and the Ibar valley. On the west lie several platea u s, i ncluding the great prehistoric centre of Glasinac, that reach to the basin of Sarajevo, once a great lake and hordered o n the southwest by the fa ult-l ine of the Vranica (2 1 1 2 m) and Bj elasn i ca (2067 m ) ranges. This area is the physical centre of LI I I I fo r l l 1 a t i o n s
a rc
t h e k a rs t h a s i n s o r
pol je,
a
) )
/ l l , · .'\" , / 1 , " /1 1 1 1 1 1 \,/,/, 1 1 1 ,\
Bosn i a a n d t h e sou rl'l' 0 1 t h e r i v l'r B md l ,1 W l l l l' l l l o r l l\', t i l l' a x i "
of the bas i n as fa r a s Ze n i Gl , \v l ll' rc t h e r i v l 'r l' l l t l'rS a t o rt u o u s defile between t h e v o ka n i l' m a ssi fs ( I f n o r t h e rn Bosll i a , T h e next river to the west is the Vrbas, w h i d, rises ( I l l t h e west slopes of Vranica. After the broad h i gh basin o f Bugojllo the rivcr enters a gorge, with dramatic fal l s at J ajcc, until Banj a l u k a . This dcnsely forested area i n the Middle Ages formed a nucleus of the short-lived independent state of Bos n i a and later of Serbia. In addition to the ti m ber that away from the gorges can be floated down the major rivers, the area has rich m i neral deposits, including lead, silver and i ron ore, most of wh ich have been worked since Roman times, The main eastward continuation of the Alpine system is the Karawanken, a steep-sided ridge that reaches over 2000 metrcs and separates the upper Drau (Drava) basin around Klagen furt from that of the upper Sava around Ljubljana. This range, which is crossed by several passes, notably the Wurzen and Lu belj (Loibl), termi nates in the high Savi nski mountains, but the l i n e of relief is continued into the Pannonian plain with some lower h ills above Maribor on the Drava. The u pper cou rse of the Sava foll ows a valley that has continued eashvard from Friul i , wh ere it is drained by the Tagliamento, and then turns southeastwards into the Lju bl jana basin, around 3 0 miles long. Several smal l but steep-sided h i l l s rise from this plain, around one of which is situated the city of Ljublj ana, founded as the Roman colony Emona although an inhabited area from at least the Late Bronze Age. On the east a limestone plateau rises in pl aces to above 1 000 metrcs but has been dissccted by the Sava, Krka and their tributaries. Only in modern timcs has thc gorge of the Sava across this area become a route, for all of i ts lcngth by the rai lway and in part by a modern road. North of the Karawanken the river Drau rises in the High Tauern of Austria and at Maribor emerges from a gorge through the Pohorje plateau into the broad basin around Ptuj, sitc of a Roman fortress and veteran colony. Later i t is joined by the Mur, flowing from thc area of Prekomurjc, some way below Varazdin. With i ts gentle relief and broad alluvial valleys this region marks the transition from thc high Alpine mountains to the flat Pannonian plain, which l i cs mostly below the 1 50 metrc contour and is draincd by the Danubc and its two
U , 'd,s,
"" " 1\'
"/ ""'1/ , /11.\
21
p r i l l l' i p'l l t r i h l l l .l r i l''i T i s a c ris/a ) a l l d Sa v a , T I l l' pa r t o f t h e p l a i l l w h i l' h l i l's 'io u t h o f t i l l' I h,I V .l i s t h l' h i s to r i l: region S l a v o l l i a , t h ro l lgh w h i l' h a do u h k l i l l l' o f h i l l s passes from I l o r t ln.... esl to sO l l t h ea st. The sOl l t h lT l I r a n ge cO lll m e n ces with t il l' h i l l s l I o r t h o f Z a grch 'N h i d 1 r i S l' Iwrl' a l l d there a bove 1 000 II ll't H'S, w h i l e fu r t h e r c a st the l i nc is w ntin ued by the slightly l o w l T M o s l a v acka a n d Ps u n j h i l l s , Th e northern ra nge com I I l l' l l l'l'S w i t h thc K a l n i k b i l l s (643 111 ) and broadens eastwards to fo rm thc Pa p u k and Ravna Gora which partly enclose the h'l s i n of S l a vo n s k a Pozega, Around 70 miles east of th i s area t il l' I l a rrow ra nge o f the fru ska Go ra (53 9 111 ) is forested on t l1l' l I o r t h face and falls steeply to the Danube, but the gentler sOl l t h e rn slopes h a v e long been cul tivated and support large v i l l a ge s w i th v i n eyards, The locss p l a teaus w hich rise from th e plains ben'Veen the l l I a j o r ri v e r s to heights of more than 60 metres appear to be I O r l l l cd of w i n d - blown deposi ts from the northeast, There is l i l l k s u rfa ce d ra i n age and wells must be d u g deep . Al though l l o W fe r t i l e a n d i n tensively cultivated in some areas, for example a ro u n d V u kovar, in th e Backa and Banat pl ains the settlements (l' n t! to be l oca ted a round th e margins. The old Tertiary basins Mou nd the D rava and Sava have been overlaid with masses of sl'd i m c n t borne down from the A l p s . Now both rivers meander H l l I ggi s h ly, with many cut-offs and occasional cha n ges of �:oll rse , Both have tl ood-pl a i n s u p to five m i l es across, bordered hy ri s i n g terraces to the respective plains of Podravina and Posa v i n a . Here settlements were set well back fro m the river w i t h m eadows rea ch i n g to the bank and fields extending across I h l' v a l l ey floor. The I I l y ri a n lands experience a wide range of cl i m ate. The nort h e rn plains a n d the mountains have the cold winters and Hhort hot s u m m ers of the continental climate, wh i l e the coast t' n joys the more amenable regi m e o f hot summers and mild Wl't w i n ters . D uring w i n ter m u ch of the plain and moun tains h a v l' frel'Z i n g te mperatures, a l th o u gh snowfa l l i s comparatively l i gh t . l' xcept tow a rds the A d riatic. Snow i s rarely seen on I hl' coast except on h i gh gro u n d . S u mmer tempera tures are t'vl' r y w h ere h i g h , e sp e c i a l l y i l l t h e k a rst hol lows near the Adri "til: a n d in t h e a l l u v i a l b a s i n s of M a l'l'do n i a , though even here n i gh t - t i m l' coo l i n g is s i g n i l i l' ;l l l l . R a i n is hornc to the a rea on
weste rl y w i n d s a l l d i s U ) I l Sl'q l l l' l l l l y I l I g h n i l l l i H' 1 l 1 0 I l I l I . 1 1 l 1 l 1 l 1 S west a n d so u t h w est , w i t h tro l l l .l ro l l l l d 1 2. ( )( ) 10 2. ( )( )( ) 1 1 1 1 1 1 , I h a n a rea s fu rther east s u ch a s t h e �il ( ) ra v a - V a rda r co r r i d or w i t h around 75 0 m m . The M ed i te r ra n e a n recei ves t h e h u l k o f its rainfa l l during a utumn a n d early spring, the pl a i n s in late s p r i n g and ea rly autu m n . In the ma tter of w i n ds the IIlyrian l an ds experience th e consequences of l y i n g astrid e th e bou n dary between the Mediterranean a n d continental syste m s , High pressure in central Europe and IO'wer pressu re in the Mediter ranean prod u ces the n otorious winter bura ( bora ) , a cold dry wind which sears down the Adri atic from Istria to A l b a n i a . Loca l l y i t can become a great danger to sh i pping at anchor an d i s totally destructive of any tree- or vegeta tion-growth , especially i n the northern Adriatic. Similar conditions p roduce the Va rda ra c which b l ows down the Vardar during winter, cold and d ry l i ke the bura b u t m uch less violent. Except on the dry karst towa rds the Ad riati c and the locss pl atforms a ro u n d th e Danube the IlI yrian l a n ds tend to be tree covered, though a good deal o f th i s has been removed th rough h u m a n activity since p reh i storic times. Towards the Mediter ranean the ch aracteristic cover is the maquis, a combination of drough t-resistant shrubs wh ich i s widespread between the mount a i n s and the coast. At h igher levels th i s can turn into l i gh t deciduous wood l a n d . Where some soil is retained in th e l i m estone karst an open woodland of b road-leaved trees, including horn beam and varieties o f oak, can develop, and towards the n orth the karst a reas tend to bc m ore densely wooded with oak and beech . The interior mou ntains of Bosnia and Old Serbia arc densely forested with oak and beech, a h uge natural resource for long barel y expl oited. In Macedo n i a woodland i s n o w confined t o th e h igher ridges a n d pl ateaus but evidently never extended to the allu vial p l ai n s . Towards the north, a reas such as S u m adija, whose name means 'wood land', have now largely been cleared for cul tivation . In th e plains few trees a re to be sccn , except for the stands o f will ow and pop l a r which cover the wetlands near the rivers. On thc whole the Illyrian lands are a m ong the least favoured areas of Mediterranean Europe in the matter o f soils. Thesc, when prcscnt, originate fro m thc rock and a re generally sh a l l ow with l i ttle formation of humus. The karst limeston e i s b a re save for
Ik, II."
1 1/ " '/
\' "l 1 11 \'/ / , 1 1 1 ,\
kw pml e t ,> l i t d a y , h i l t a l l l l v l l I l I l , , l l l ll' l ! h ; l d l y d ra i l l e d , l'O V l'r" t il l' ha " i m , I I I t h e pLl i l l s I I I A l h , l I l l , l t h e l u i t l v a l i o l l l i t a l l u v i a l dq)os i t 'o req u i res i r r i ga t i o l l d l l rl l l g t h e h i l I '> U l l l l l l l'l" S , SOllle v ,l l l e y s l'O l l t ;l i l l C l l i t i v ;l h l c soi l .. h i l I l \ l a l l Y a re n a r ro w a n d the ,.,o i l s h a v e heen co v e re d w i t h s to l l Y d e p 0 'i i t i o n . I I I some u pland ha s i n 'i o f t h e ll1ou n t a i n o u s a l l d l a k e regi o n the al luvial and o l h e r d e p os i ts o f d ri e d - o u t l a k es h a v e p roduced soils of a high q l l a l i t y , t h o u gh o ften amoll nt i ng to only a small proportion of I I I l' O h r i d , Korcc, D e b a r and Kukcs basi n s . The forest soils of I I l l· hc l r o f l ower hills to the north of the high mountains offer a h e t te r re w a rd for cu ltivation, while the most recent l oess and a
alluvial
deposits
of
the plains are now ful l y cultivated.
u n i ted state of the South Slavs proclaimed on 1 I kl'clllber 1 9 1 8 comprised all the llIyrian lands except for A l h a n i a , v.... here a boundary l i ne defined with Montenegro in 1 9 1 J was reta i ned. Th e predominantly Albanian Kosovo region was a l so assigned to Yugosl av i a . At the ti me Albania was in 1 1 0 p o s i ti on to p ress her clai m , while the Yugoslavs were eager to gai n northern Alban i a itself for i ts easier passage to the A d riatic. In the northwest the border ,.... ith Italy was no less a problem, in a manner which m i rrored the con fl icting needs of t hose who inhabited the ll Iyrian karst plateaus and the popu hnion of the plains in n o r the ast Italy i n ancien t times. The l'a s t coast of the Adriatic had for centuries been under Ita l i an i n fl uence. Until Napoleon most of it had belonged to the RqJUblic of Venice and in 1 8 1 5 it passed under Austrian rule. A n u ndisclo sed pact in 1 9 1 5 promised m o s t of the coast and islands to Italy but in the final treaty Italy was con fi ned to the I stri a n peni nsula, including the ports of Trieste and Pula, and further south Zadar and some minor islands. The Itali an griev a n ce focused on Fiume ( Rijeka ) , an Italian port i n a Cro atian h i n terland, which in 1 9 1 9 was siezed by an expedition of Italian patriots. After the Treaty of Rapallo ( 1 92 0 ) had proclai med it a free city Fiume was eventual ly annexed to Italy under Mussolini ( 1 924), leaving merely the eastern suburb of Susak as the The
wholely inadequate Adriatic harbour for northwest Yugoslavia. A fter the Second World War the Yugoslav need for a n adequate Adriatic port was acknowledged with the award of al most all Istria, along with the J ulian Alps. Un fo rtunately, Trieste was denied and a wholely a rtificial frontier line from Gorizia on
' 1' /,,'
'i, ', I / ,
/' /",. 11/\'1'1.111 '
t h e I SO I l /.O t o I\. o p er ( Ca pod i ... l r i a ) 1 l' 1 l I l I i ll's I ll'h l l l d t h l' l:oa s t
left the OIKe- g rea t po rt o f T r i l' s l l' herd I o f i t s n a l ura l h i n t e r land. Along t h e Dal m a t i ;l ll t:oasl a l l I t a l i a l l possl'" ., i o l l s \\' C I"l' assigncd to Yugosla via, the fi rst on:a s i o n s i l l n' the end o f t h e Roman Empire whcn the enti re a re a was pol itit:a l l y integrated with the interior. The stirring of Alban ian nationalism in the l ate nineteenth century was prompted less by a desi re for freedom than by the fear of being partitioned between an enlarged Greece and Ser bia. They resisted the encroachments of the Montenegrins sanc tioned by the Congress of Berl in in 1 8 78, wh i le thei r hostility to an i ncreasingly opprcssive Turkish regi me cul m i nated i n the rebellion of 1 9 1 2 which brought a declaration of AI banian i ndependence before the end of thc year. The Grceks and Sl avs objected to the new state, the latter eager to join Serbia with the Adriatic via the route from Ohrid. The M ontenegrins had designs on the north, while the Grceks were more than willing to tak e over southern Albania with its large Orthodox popu lation . Across thc Adriatic, Italy \\'as a supporter of the new state, confidently anticipating the prospect of increased influ ence across the strait. Though the G reat Powers consented, Al ban ian independence rem ained precarious until 1 92 0 when it was formal l y accepted by Italy, which retained possessi on of th e sm a l l island Sazan i (Saseno) in the Bay of Vlora (Valon a ) . Kosovo and the Metoh i ja, whi ch in 19 12 the Turks had been prepared to i nclu de w ith their offer of an a u ton omous Alban i a n provincc, was in 1 920 finally ceded to Yugoslavia. During the Second World War the Alban i ans gained temporary control of the area while under Italian rule but gave it up in 1 945 without protest, in spite of its Al banian majority. Th e ruptu re of relations between Yugosl avia and th e rest of the communist bloc i n 1 948 was marked by a ren ewed h ostility towards the Yugoslav s, a change wh ich, in the eyes of most Albanians, was a satisfactory retu rn to th e natural state of affairs. At the tim e of wri ting the old di spute h as once morc reached a state of crisis. Federal Yugoslavia faces disintegration while a bid for autonomy, or even inde pcndence, by Kosovo has been suppressed by an increasi ngl y n ational istic Serbian Republic. The battleground of th is con flict h as now been extended to the arca of preh i story. The
l u n g - s t a n d i n g A l h a n i a n \.ll i l l 1 l or , I \.'o l l l i n l l i l y 0 1 d l' 'i \.'l' n l frc l I l l t i l l' ;1 I H : i l' l l I I l I y r i a n 'i i 'i n o w a n'( ) l l l pa n i cd h >' a rg l l l l l l' n t s t h a t K o s o v o a n d T\-h o to h i j a fm l l l p a r i s o t a n ;l I l ( i l'll t I I l y r i a n h o me l a n d t h a t s h o l l l d n a t l l ra l l y Ill' j o i lH'd w i t h t h e rest o f 11l00k rn A l h a n i a ,
2 Preh istoric Illyrians
Illyrian origins : Stone and Bronze Ages I The earliest testimony of man's presence in the IlIyrian lands arc stone hand-axes and pebbles broken for use as chopping tools. El sewhere in Eu rope these are dated to 200,000- 1 0 0,000 H C , i n the Lower Palaeolith i c era. These, however, are merely scat tered finds and the earl iest traces of occupation come from severa l caves u sed at intervals over many thousands of years. I n Montenegro, Crvena Stijena, at Petrovici near Niksic, was found to contain 9 metres of debris in wh i ch were 3 1 levels of deposition with 1 5 'cultural horizons'. More th an 23 ,000 stone objects were found bearing signs of having been struck or worked. In Level 24 (counti ng from the top where the latest deposit belonged to the Bronze Age) there was a thick inter gl acial deposit which could be dated to the Last Interglaci al period, that is before the advances of the great Al pine ice caps dated 200,000 to 1 00,000 BC. from the levels beneath came the flint-making flakes of the Levalloisian technique, industries of the Proto-Mousteria n and Mousterian types. from the cnd of the Last Interglacial ( 6 5 , 000 BC) a rock shelter in a sandstone hluff a bove a trib u tary of the river Drava at Krapina, not far from Zagreh, has an accumulation of 8 metres, with the lower 6 m etres bei ng sealed by a later stalagm ite deposit. Around I Pre h i story of Al ban i a : Prendi 1 9 82, 1 9 8 1\ , Korkuti 1 9! U b a n d C.abanes 1 9 8 6 ; of Yugoslavia : Novak el al. 1 9 71 , A l exander 1 972, Ben ac et al. 1 979a-c, 1 9 8 3 .
fl O O 1 r; l g l I l l' I I I '" I I I h l l l l L 1 I 1 hl l l ll· ... I l l l l l l l l n l d l l' 1'l· 1 I 1 . 1 l 1 l '" I I I ; 1 1 l e a " l
I ,�
I l l l' l l , W l I l l l e l l .l I l t ! l' h i l d rl' l l . T h e i r I n· d l I l l l l i cl l l'l1 . 1 ... i lll i l a r i l y
N ca l l l !c n h a l I'v la l l h i l t i l l I I t l l n 1'l· ... l wl' l ... t h c }' n'sc l l l h kd I l l o d e rn I l l a l l ( h o lllo s,/ / I/('//s ) . T h l' l r 1 1 10 1 ... Wl Te f 1 a k cs o f H i n t
10
;1 1 1 <.1 0 1 h er I oca I ro c k s .
.
'
(c.40,()( )()-lW( )() 1\( .) no hones h i s presence is a l l csted in sev e r a l pla ces by blade i n d ustri es. The knO\vn sites h a v e been i d e n t i fi ed with the princi pal divisions of the West Europe a n Palaeolith i c, Aurignadan, Gravettian and Magdalen s i a n , but so fa r fev"" sdentific dates have been obtained through Ll rbo n 1 4 . The general character of these industries has sug �l'sted links v.,ith the northeast, namely Hungary and western Romania . In C rvena Sti jena the most \videspread and oldest A u rignacian had been found along with the remains of red deer, wild cattle and goats. The Aurignacian and G ravettian i ndustries which occur on the plains and in northern Bosnia ( Kamcn, Doboj , Grahovca brdo, LuikiCi, Usova and Visoko hrdo) are generally l i nked \...·i th hunting of the mammoth. The G1VeS used by e a rl y man in these l ands arc devoid of paintings or carvi ngs, though there may well be some in areas yet to be fu l l y explored. This prospect is encouraged hy finds of carvings on a rock face at Lipci, near Risan and Morinj on the Gulf of Kotor in Montenegro. The subjects include deer and some geometric (sub-rectangular) shapes. The l.ipd c arving s are so far unique in the Bal kan region and their date is unknown. ' The Mesolithic or Middle Stone Age ( c . R O OO-c.6000 BC) continued the traditions of h unting, food-gathering and fish ing wh ich had developed in the Palaeolithic, and changes in style of livi ng began only with the appearance of farming and settle ments which distinguish the Ncoli thic or New Stone Age. Dur ing post-glacial ti mes the lands east of the Adriatic began to take on the cha racter and appearance they possess today. As the ice caps along the Adriatic-Danu be watershed starte d to m e l t decid uous trees began to cover the plains and hills, while I : ru m t h e U p p e r Pa l a eo l i t h i c
of Illodern l 1 1 a n h a ve yet cOllle t o l i gh t , hllt
1
Crvena
1 972.
Stijcn a :
Baslcr 1 97/
and
Basler
et
al. 1 975 ; Kra p i n a : Alexander
\ Adriatic region : Hasler "1 9 8 3 ; Lipci : Pusic 1 9 7 1 , also B rod ar 1 9 ! U (Aurignacian h unrcr c o m p l ex i n S loven i a ) .
and Brod a r
l a n d s i n t h e D a n l l he h;l s i n s a v", t i l l' s p re;l d ( I f �r;l ... ... l a n d s where flo u ri shed �ere a l p l a n t s, i l h.: l l I d i n � w h ea t , ha rky , o a t s a n d rye, l a ter domesticated hy m a n . [ n t h e w o o d s a n d m O l l n tai ns there dwelt anim als that are sti ll ty p i c a l o f the region,
open
deer, w i l d cattle, pigs and goats.4 Farm i ng com muniti es first appear in the lands bet\\'een t h e Adriatic an d the Danube i n the context of the Sta rcevo Cul ture (c.6000- 4500 BC) , named a fter a site on the Dan ube a l ittle below Belgrade. These a rc at presen t the earl iest farming groups known north of the Vardar valley, and did not gener ally s pr e a d beyond the plains around Belgrade, that is n orth ern Serbia, the Banat an d Yojvodin a . Some settlements of this culture have been found i n eastern Bosn i a at Gorn j a Tu zla, Obre north of Sarajevo, Y aros , a n d also at V u ce d ol in Croatia (see figure 2). In northern Al bania the Early Neolithic h as been i de n ti fie d along the middle course of the Black Drin at Buri m, farther upstream at Rajce and, in a later phase, at Kolsh near Kukes at the Drin confluence. In Central Albania the sites at Blaz in the Mat valley and in the Korce
Figure 2 Reconstruction 4
Malez and Osole 1 97 1 .
of
Vucedo[ Eneolithic settlement
/ ,,.,·,,,," /1 1/'/,
111 " """,\
\I
ha s i l l .I n' a k i l l 1 0 ! I l l' A d r i a l i l N l'ol l l h l l , I l il- l I l i f i l'd .1 1 � l I l l k i l' I l l'M /, a d a r . T h l' s i l l'S W lTl' n' i d l'l l I l y w l' l I l'hOSl' 1 I a l l d l'< > l l I i l l l l l'd i l l Ol' l'I l p a l i o l l SO l l l l' l i l l l l'S to r ! l 10 1 I ." l I l d s o f Y l' a rs , A s o l'l: u pa t i o l l
o r ' t e l l " the to construct l' I a ho r a te dH< > I l o l ogies, nor o l l l y to r i n d i v i d u a l sites but also rela t i v e to m a n y others, from t hese h a s been deduced a 'spread' or 'ad vance' of fa r m i ng methods, in the form of a slow north ward movement towards the Middle Danube, that brought an i n Cl'l';l Se i n popu lation and which either eliminated or integrated o l d e r co m m unities of hunters and gatherers.5 The econom y of th ese Neolithic farm ing 'tef l '-si tes was a m i x of cereal farm ing, animal domestication and hunting a n d fishing. C rops included wheat, barley, m i l let and bea n s ; I i v cs tock incl uded cattle, pigs, sheep a n d goats. Implements i ncl uded ground stone tool s, axes and adzes, w i th large flaked tools a s scrapers and sickle blades. Obsidian, a n atural vol ca nic form of glass obtained from Hungary, was a l so used for tools. Bone p rovided the material for needles, spoons and spatulas, and clay was baked for loom-weigh ts and spindle whorls. Huma n and an i mal figurines made of clay resemble those found i n G reece and Asia M inor. They have a cylindri cal shape, with no l imbs and the head indi cated only by i ncisions for the detail o f features. The principal evidence for recogni zing the successive phases and associations of these early farm i ng communities consists of hand-made pottery of fi red clay in a variety of forms, decorated with finger i m p ressions, appl ied cordon s and inci sed l i nes. South of the watershed farm i ng m ethods had reached the southern Adri a t i c coast by the mi ddle of the sixth mifleniu m . Pottery with i ncised and i mpressed ornament associated with ground stone i m plements has been found in many sites on the Dalma tian coast and islands. The large di tched enclosure at SmilCic near Zadar prod uced impressed pottery vessels si m i lar to those of southern Italy, and the same pottery has been found on the llt' h r i s ;1l'l' l I l l l l l l a l l'd 1 0 to r l l l a l l a rl i l i l' i ; 1 1 I l l O U I Il. 1 l l I a l l Y s t ra t i fi e d l a y e rs ha ve l' l l a h l e d ;Hl' h a l'( ) l og i s t s
' Serbian
Srcjovic 1 98 8 ; Cornja Tuzl a : Covic 1 97 1 a ; Ohre: Varos: Bcnae 1 971 e ; Vucedol : Schmidt 1 945 ; a lso Di vosti n : and S rejovic 1 9 8 8 . Albanian sites: Korkuti 1 9 8 7.
Ncol ithic:
B e n ;} c 1973 ;
McPh erron
1 h/, '\/ '. 1 / . /' I. " 1111'11, 111.\ n o r t h e r n A d r i a l i �' i s la l l d ... ( : !"l' s . I\. r k a l l d 1\1 . 1 1 1 1 .l l s l I l 1 I I I t i l l' K v a rn c r G u l f a l l d 0 1 1 I h l' 1 1 I ;l i n l a l l d i n �' a V l'" I I I t h l' V d c h i t m ou n ta i n s . 1> Th e next p h as e of the N col ith i e fa rm i n g e ra i n t h e J\t i d d k Dan ube is n a m e d fro m the s i t e o f V i n Ca , ",· h i eh i s a l so o n th e Danube below Bel grade. T h e V i n C a Cul tu re (£:.45 00-4000 BC) a ro u n d the southern edge o f the Dan ube bas i n m a r k s th e s prea d o f far m i ng i nt o th e h i l l s and va l l eys on th e sou th and \vest towards the mountains a n d the Adri atic. The m i xed eco n o m y ba s ed on cere a l s and li v e s to c k of th i s culture was similar to Starcevo b u t it is di s t i n gu ished b y its pottery which exh i b i ts a grea te r va r i e ty of for m and ornamen t. The s h a pe s i nclude carinated and straight-sided bowls w i th th ree - o r fo u r foo t e d p e d e s tal s , 'altars', o r ta bles, -
with hollow feet and pots decorated with animal features. The decoration cons i sts o f burnishing in patterns and incised ri bbon and maean der d e s i g n s For all t h e impression o f i n no v a ti o n which this material conveys there is n o evi dence that th e Vin c a settlements represent any l a rge-sca l e i m m i gr a t i on i n to the l a n d s west and sou th of the M i ddle D a n u b e . Along the Adri atic coast the newer fa rmi n g commu nities are dis tingu i shed by thei r painte d pottery. This shows simil ariti es wi th the p o tte r y of Greece a n d I t al y and also w i t h the T r i e s te reg i o n (Vl a sko Culture ) . I t is n a m e d Danilo Cul tu re from the l o n g occupied hill scttl ement o f D a n i lo Gornje near S i b e n i k , wherc the rema i n s incl ude 24 huts with floors partly paved with stone. There w a s a n a cti v e stone-working t ra di t i o n , wh ile the pottery falls into h.... O types, a p a i n ted ware wi th Ita l ian connections and a burnished w a re with s p i ra l a n d ma cander patterns. D a n i l n settlements a rc numerous al o ng the co a s t and on the islands, in p a rt ic u lar Hvar, but di d not spread i n l a n d . There arc no traces of earl y fa r min g in the mountains and h igh val leys of Bosnia or Montenegro. In Albania the m i ddle Neolithic has been identified at the s e ttle m ents of Cak ran on thc lower Vijose and at Dunarec i n the K orcc basin. .
, \ Adriatic Keolithic: Batovic 1 971 a ( SmiICic) , (eres), Rapan i c 1 984 (Cetina v a lley ) ,
1 9 76a, Mirosa vljcvic 1 9 7 1
\ \
T I l l' d osl' s t t i e ... a p lw;H t o I ll' w l I l l t i l l' I > .l I l i l o ( : u l t u rl' o t t h e l > a l l l l a t i ;l n i\ d r i ;l I i �' a l l d t i l l' l'. l r l y p h .I Sl' o t " a ka n j ( O h re ) i l l I\m n i a , a n d a l so w i t h SO I l l l' g ro u p ., i l l so u t h e rn I ! a l y , � o h j cc t s do ; I P Pl'; t r s p or a d i ca l l y among N col i t h i c fa r l l l i l l g 1.:O l l l l l l ll l l i t i es, especially in I\os l l i a a n d o n the A d r i a t i c, I h e k n o w l ed ge of metal -working a nd t h l' use o f i m plements of mcta l ca m e late to the western I \a l ka n s , Thl' spread of copper and b ro n z e was a slow p r o ce s s : i t w a s ba rel y complete by around 2000 BC and even then for l'l' l l I u r i es a fter the use of metal ,..'as confined to a few si mple fo r l l l s o f i mplement. Tho ug h it continues much debated, it Sl'e I l l S to bc still the view of some archaeol ogi sts that the spread of l l I e t a l i n the Danube lands was marked by a l a rge - scale I l l i wa t i on o f new people into the area from steppes o f western A s i a and the Black Sea region . Moreover, many believe that t h i s was the on l y major movement o f population in the area, t ill' l a ter Aegean m igrati on s that marked the end of the Bronze A gl' ( 1 200 HC) be i ng merely a southward sh i ft of Balkan and l o w e r Danube communitics towards the Aegean and the Nea r East , The th ree phases of the Bron ze Age in the western Balkans, Early Bronze 1 9 0 01 1 8 00- 1 6 00n 5 0 0 BC, Middle Bronze 1 6001t 5 00-c. 13 00 HC and Late Bronze to c. 1 2 0 0 BC, appear to be later and less sophisticated versions of those in the Danube ha s i n , the eastcrn Balkans and thc Carpath i an s, all of which fl'ached full development by th e end of the third m i l l en i u lll . A rchaeologi sts currently bel i eve that a grad ual formation of loca l cultures and the e th n ic groups thcy are j u dged to represcnt took place du ring the l atest phase of the Stone Age (Eneolithic), .lnd that thcse were consolidated rather th an curtailcd by th e arrival of newcomers from the east. It is also suggested, though not unco ntested, that these newcomers were Indo-European sp e a ker s . A symbiosis between these and the existi ng communi t i es resulted in the for m ati o n of the pr i n cipal tribal groups of what a re now cal led the Palaeo-Balkan peoples. On this, it is suggested, the r e is warrant to base the hypo thes is of an unbroken continuity in popu l ation from the Early Bronze Age T h o l lgh
1 1 1 l' 1 ;1 1
I l I I p i l' n H .' I I t S o f
7
Vlasko: Barficld l 971 , . 53- 4 ; Danilo: K o rosec l 9S 8 ; Hvar: I"ovak Cakran : Korkuti a n d And rca l 9 7 S ; D unavec: Kork u ti 1 9 75.
I l.I 7 1 ;
1 95 5 ,
I hl ' SI '. I / I " Il l / 1 11 "' / . 1 1/, d O W I l to t h e f i r s t h i s t o r i Ld l"l'u I l"l l s 0 1 Ib l k ,1 1 l p l'o p k s , 1 1 1 t h i s e q u a ti o l l t h e p r ilK i pa l regi o l l a l gro l l ps d d i l l l'd h y d u r a l" t l' J" i s t i l"s
of their m a te r i a l cu l t u r e a re t h l' l l i d l'll t i l i ed \v i I h h i s to ri l"a I groups th u s : East Bal k a n B ro n ze A ge n:p resl' l l ts Thral"i a n s, t h e Balkano-Danubian the 'proto D"Ko-�loesi a n s ' , a n d t h e West Balkan the III yrians. x In the western Bal kans there arc few remains to connect with these bronze-using 'proto-Illyrians', except in western Serbia and eastern Bosnia. Moreover, w i th the notable exception of Pod near Bugoj no in the upper valley of the Vrbas, noth ing i s known o f their settlements. Some hill settlements h ave been i dentified in western Serbia but the main evidence comes from cemeteries, consisting usually of a small number of burial mounds (tumu l i ) . In eastern Bosnia at th e cemeteries of BcIotic and Bela Crkva the rites of inhumation and cremation are found, with skeletons in stone cists and cremations in urns. Metal implements appear here side by side with those of stone. Most of the remai ns belong to the fully developed Middle Bronze Age. Similar burials have been discovercd on the Glas i n a c plateau east of Sarajevo ; several mounds arc known to have remaincd in u se from the beginning of the Bronzc Age. Here i nhumation is the dominant rite. The metal obj ects found at thcse sites tend to be of Ccntral European origin and rcmain in use down to Iron Age times. It is these Bronzc Age comm un i ties which havc been identified as anccstors of the historical IIIyrians.9 Outside western Serbia and eastern Bosnia not a lot is known of early metal-using communities. Objects of metal occur i n the established Neol i th ic settlements a t Butmir and LisiciCi and in some of the caves on Hvar (Grabak and Zelena Petina) , where bronzc axc-picks, axe-hammers, chisels and A a t axes were in use by around 2000 BC. Thc impress i o n o f continuity from the age of stonc to that of metal comes also from the cave dwelling at Hrustovaea Petina in thc Sana val ley and the Dcbclo Brdo h i l l-settlemcnt overlooki ng Sarajevo, which acquired defences around this time. The pottery in u se here �
M, G a rasa n i n 1 9 82a, 1 9 !! !! a , Bugoj no: Covic 1 9 71 b, 1 975b ;
.. Pod,
Belotic and Bcl a
Crkva: D , a n d
c, arasan in 1 9 7 1 b ; G l a s l nae: Benae and Covic 1 95 6 , Covi': 1 9!W- 1 .
M,
1 '''''''i�/l I lI ( 1 11"",/11,\ N h o w s si m i l a l' i t i l's w i t h t h a t o l n l l't a l - l I s l n g l'on l l 1 1 l l n i t i es i n t h l' Sa va ;l n d I > l'a " ;1 v a l l e y s ( V l Il\' d o l a n d S Ll V o n i a n n d t l l res) a n d a l so, t h ol l gh i n n l l l l' h s m a l l e r q l l a nt i t ies, w i t h p o t t e r y i n the Hvar CWt' S , A d i s t i n g l l i s h i n g k,l I l1 re o f the Bronze Age i s the p r a t, t i l'e o f ra i s i n g m O ll nd s of so i l o r stone a bove the burials of i n d i v i d u a l s . T h i s was acco m p a n ied by an elaborate ritual, i n d i ca ted by enci rcl ing r i n gs of stones and the deposition of prel'iolls objects as grave goods, i ncluding battle axes and
daggers. I n Albania the first metal-using culture (Chalcolithic, 2600-2 1 00 KC) is represen ted in the first and second levels at M a l i q in the Korce basin (see figure 3). The early houses were (' rn"tcd on oak p i l es , then l ater ones directly on the ground w i t h walls of bundled reeds. Implcmcnts were of flint, polished stone, bone, horn and day (weigh ts for fishing nets) and i n d u dcd also copper axes, spearheads, necdles and fish-hooks. There are links with other Balkan sitcs of th is p eriod , notably I�u hanj in southern Serbia and Krivodol in Bulgaria, as well as somc correspondenccs wi th Macedonian s i te s . Albanian i Hchaeologists stress the essentially local character o f this cul l U rc, wherc the earl ier traditions have heen detcctcd as per s i sti ng cven i n newer phases that have been associated with a new i mmigrant ruling class. I Cl This rather tidy portrayal of a succcssion of early farming (ultures using ground and flaked stone tools and thcn some largely importcd metal implements comes to an end with the m iddle phasc of the Bronze Age ( 1 6001 1 5 00-c. 1300 BC) . The (hange is sign i fied by thc m an i fest a bility of the people some identify as 'proto-IIIyrians' to exploit the rich mineral deposits ()f Bosni a and Slovenia, notably copper, tin and gold. The techniques of u sing two- and threc-piece moulds, casting-on, hammering and annealing bccome commonplace. The hoards o f working tools and ingots testify to the speci al ist smith, and those of finished metal goods to thc activity of the travclling merchant. Hithcrto the Adriatic coast and hinterland were remotc from the main centres of stone-using farmers and the first spread of metal. The balance now shifts i n the sense that III Butmir: Munro 1 900, 1 8 9-2 1 7 ; Li siciCi : 1 976a, 1 9 8 1 ; Maliq: Prendi 1 9 77-8 .
Benac 1 971 <1 ; Dal mati a : Marovic
Figure 3
Remains of Neolithic pile-dwellings at Maliq, Albania
the Dal matian coast is j oi n e d by sea routes with Italy a n d the Aegean. Bronze ob j ec ts reflecting contacts with the latter incl ude double axes, daggers, rapiers and ingots in the form of miniature ox-hides, while l inks with the north are to be seen in the trapeze-hilted dirk from the island of Osor and brooches from Unesic near Siben ik. A few imports from the Mycen aean Bronze Age of southern Greece, including a sword and some
h�ure 4 Tumulus burial with central grave at l'azhok . Alban ia
pottery on Hvar, may represen t seaborne trade. The middle of the second millennium may have seen the beginnings of the trade in a mber objects down the Adriatic, from the sou th shore of the Baltic via the Vistula, Slovakia and around th e eastern Alps to the h ead of the Adriatic. A relatively sudden expansion of external con tacts may be reflected in an increased occurrence of weapons around the Adriatic. " In Alb ania evidence for the Middle and Later Bronze Ages (c.2000-1 200 BC) comes mainly from Maliq and from other si tes in the Korce basin and from the Mat valley in the north west. At Maliq there is a break in continuity with earlier cultures, which some have lin ked with the arrival of Indo European speakers in the Korce basin. Their appearance is signified by pottery with corded decoration, and was fol lowed by a process of fusion with existing communities. This period sees the beginning of the tumulus burials at Pazhok in the Devoll valley (see figure 4) and, sl ightly later, at Ban; in the Korce basin. The Middle Bronze Age (identified with Maliq phase Hie) is held to represent a period of 'consolidation ' and is also represented at the Nezir cave in the Mat valley. In this era the external links are predominantly with the Aegean cultures, from which imported objects include swords, daggers, 1 1
Batovi c 1 980a.
/I,, ' S" I m 1, /"r 1II"" t. lIIS spea rhea ds, k l l i n's a n d s i lo' k ks . Thl' v a ril'd a n d l' I q�a l l l fo r m s of Late Brollze A g e pottc ry ( M a l i q I l I d ; t i ft l'l' ll l h - l \w l tt h lo'l'l l l l l l' ies RC) are decorated i ll red and OdHl' in gl'o ll1�.'l ric p a tte rn s , identified by Albanian archaeologi sts a s ' De v o l \ i a n w a re' a l l d believed to have remained in use unaltered unti l the end of t h e Iron Age. A wider distribution in Macedonia and Epirus is t h e
basis for suggestions of a southward and eastward movement of IlIyrian peoples. The large haul of bronze objects from burial tumuli, some of wh ich continued in use for several centuries, include some local types, notably 'Skodran ' axes found in northern Albania along with imported double axes and swords. Later these Aegean forms were to be replaced by northern types, among them socketed axes and tongue-grip s'.... ords. 12 J ust as ancient writers could discover no satisfactory general explanation for the origin of IIIyrians, so most modern scholars, even though now possessed of a mass of archa eological and l inguistic evidence, can assert with confidence only that Illyrians were not an homogeneous ethnic entity, though even that is today challenged with vigour by historians and archaeologists working with in the perspective of modern Albania. Notions once widely canvassed of a 'proto-IIIyrian' people of Indo European origin once widespread across Europe were always at best unproven and have now been generally discarded. In the twenties and thirties of the twentieth century, belief in the existence of a European s u b -stratum of now vanished IIlyrians was an attractive idea to those bent on emphasizing the pure Aryan origin of the nordic peoples of Europe. In the other di rection there seems now to be increasing scepticism towards theories of direct IlIyrian involvement in the movement of new peoples into Greece at the end of the second millennium BC. Similarly, many have now discarded the si mple i dentification of European Illyri ans with the Urnfield Culture of Late Bro nze Age Central Europe. This particular equation stemmed from the 'pan -IlIyrian' theories propounded early th is century by philologists who could d i scover traces of Illyrians scattered across the linguistic map of Europe. 1 3 12
Mat
val ley (Burrel ) :
Kurti 1 98 3 ;
Pazhok: Bodi naku 1 9 R 2 ; Bar,: And rea
1 9 76b, 1 977-8 ; Nezir: Andcca 1 9 8 5 , Prendi 1 984 ( axes) . Jl IIIyrian cth nogencsis : Korkuti 1 9 82, Pren di 1 985b.
A I lI o n' Ll I l l i o ll ' n'l"O I P , 1 r t l l" l 1 0 1 1 u l 1 1 1 ).' 1' 1 . 1 1 1 O l'igl l l ' o r \' d l l log �' I I �', i s ' ha, l' l l Il' I"gl'l1 I ru l\l a I'l"iLl l'u l ogl \ 1 s ;1 1 S;l I";\ jl' V O , 1 1 0 1 a h i v A , I k l l a l" ;\ l I d B , ()v i c WO l' k i l l g t ro l l l ! Il l' n' Ll l i v l' a h u l l d a n c�' 0 1 p l'l'il i s l O l'ic I'e l ll a i n s i n Bos n i ;l a l l d a d j a n'llI a reas, t h e y s u gge s t ! l L l I d u r i n g t h l' Iho l l l.e Age t h ere took pl ace a p ro gressive ' 1 l I y r i ;lII i l.a t i o l l ' o f peoples d wel l i ng in t h c l a nds betwecn the S;\ V ;\ a n d the A d r i a t i c . Sincc their homel and lay aside from the l l I a i n ro u te of m igration across so utheast Europe the movement I I I peo ples at the cnd of the B ronze Age had relatively little i l l l p a c t on them , On the other h and, the beginnings of the Iron A ge a ro ll n d 1 000 ne is held to coincide with the formation of
I he h i storical Illyrian peoples. This hypothesis, based on a large l l I a ss of evidence, well excavated and fully analysed, has an i n t e rn a l consistency that is impressive and appears now to l' Omm and the field. On thc other hand, its value for Illyrian origins as a whole is limited, not l east because it largely ignores t h l' many contacts and presumed interactions between IHyrians ,, " d other cultures, notably those of the Mediterranean. More I IVl'r, the 'Bosnia-centred' theory offers no explanation for the origi ns of differences between peoples historically designated as J I I yrian, such as those between the Liburni in the north west il lld the 'real Illyrians' of the southeast, in what is now Mon tenegro and northern Albania . It is, however, equally difficult to accept the view that such differences are due principally to the survival of populations with older culturcs later subsumed into the family of thc Indo-European-spcaking IIlyrians. Cur rent thcories of Illyrian ethnogenesis cannot fail to impress through thei r weight of archaeological evidence; but material remains alone can nevcr tel l the whole story and can m islead. Also, while i t is tru e that Pan-IIIyrian theories have been set aside, the questions which prompted their formu lation stil l remain: there are traces o f JIIyrian names, and some historical t radition, for the prcsence of Illyria n peoples in parts of Europe heyond the l i mits of their historical homelands, and also in Asia Minor. What one i s to make of these remains a problem. I n general the linguistic evidence for IIIyrians in Greece, Asia M i nor and Italy i s yet to be interpreted. In the case of Italy there is not only the testi mony of names from l iterary sources and inscriptions but also indications in the archaeological evi dence that there was a movement of p e op l es across the Adriatic
4()
I ta l y d ur i n g the f i rs t centu r y o f t h l' f i rst millellll i u m ( 1000-9 0 0 lI< : ) . NOIll, t h eiL-ss t he t heory o f an I l I y riall migration across the Adriatic h a s heen cha llenged hy A . lkn;l c, w h o argues that the I I Iyrian lingu istic a n d m a terial rem a ins i n I ta l y
into
need amount to no more th an t h e result of several centu ries o f commercial intercourse. I n s u m , the destructive i mpact o f later research on the earlier generalizations regarding IlIyrian s sho u l d b e regarded a s a step forward. The prohlem remains for prehis toria ns h ow to construct a valid scheme of analysis with wh ich to tackle the formation of Illyrians. 1 4 Iron Age IlIyrians 1 5
The five centuries between the Late Bronze Age ( 13001 1 200 Bc) and the middle of the eighth century witnessed not onl y the spread o f iron use a n d iron-working but mark for Greece and neigh bouring lands the beginning of recordcd history, when names and events are preserved and descriptions of peoples and pl aces were first written down. The same period saw m ovements of people southwards to Macedonia, Greece and Asia Minor from the direction of the Danube and the southern Bal kans. The years 1 200- 1 05 0 BC, during which there took place in Greece the decline of Mycenaean fortresses and the beginning of the classical city-states, arc m arked among IlIyri ans by a rich material cul ture and contacts with the Aegean world . These links were then broken and were not to be re created unti l around 8 00 BC. During the Early or HaJ lstatt (named from thc site near Salzburg in Austria ) Iron Age (mid eighth to mid-fourth century BC) , the first phase of IIIyrian history, the principal external influences were the Greek Aegean and northern Italy (Bologna and Este). Though widespread from the seventh century onwards thc Greeks had relatively 14
JIIyrian
formation : Bellac 1 9 64, 1 9 76 M . G a rasanin 1 9 8 8 a ;
S. lta l v : Benac 1 98 8 . 11 Ea�ly Iron Age i n Yugoslavia :
,
IIIyrians
in
Covic and Gabrovcc 1 97 1 , �1. Garasanill 1 9 82b, Vasic 1 973 , Benac ct a 1 . 1 9 8 7, Gabrovcc 1 9 64-5 , 1 966a (Slovcll i a ) , Vasic 1 977 (chronology), Jevtic 1 98 3 ( pottcry). In Albania : Prclldi 1 9 75a, 1 9 8 5a, Hammond 1 982a.
,1 1 I l I t k i l l l P , K t 0 1 1 t h e I I I .J l l' I" i a l l l l l t l l lT 0 1 t h e ... I H l l h n l l I l I y r i a l l '" ( I \o" l I l a , S n h i a , �t o l l l l' l I l'gro a l l d A l h a l l i a ) u l l t i l t h e e x p a l l ... i o n o t M 'I l"l'll o n i a i n t i l l' fo u rt h n' l I t u ry . B y w a y o f co n t rast t h e l O l l l n l l l l l i t i l· ... i n C ro a t i a , S l o v l' l I i a a n d western Bos n i a were dl'l' p l y i l l t l u l' l I cl'd hy t h e I ta l i c c u l t u res, espec i a l l y in
parts of
S l o v l'l I i 'l ( I .ower Ca rn i o l a ) . An i n v asion of horse-riding and l , l rI - d r i v i n g 'Th raco-Ci m merians' from the direction of the I \ L l l" k Sea was ollce tho ught to h a v e infl uenced th e western I \ , d ka n s ;I t t h e st a r t
of
Iron Age but this is now doubtcd. ( ) n t h e ot he r h al1ll , thc cxpansion of Ach a e m enid Persia into t h e so u t h e rn Balkans is b elie v ed to be the like l y cx pl a nat i on t or ... i g l l i hCvorovi near Bjelina), in Serbia ( S abac, Mramorac, Umcari, Nov i )lazar and ot h ers), in nor th crn Albania (Mat, Burrel, (,:ina mak, Kushi and others) and the a d j acent southern Adriatic ( ;lI bavica near Mostar, Radi m l j a, Plana, Kacanj , Mosko, Lj u hO lll i r, Glogovik and others). The typical G l as i nac settlement i s a fortified h il l top (see figurc Sa), of which not one h as yet hl'l'n fully examined. B u rials consist of skeletons benea t h carth t ll lll u l i dcfined by stonc ci rcles of around ten metres diamcter and oft en contain two to four graves (see figure 5 b ) . Down to t h e si xth centu ry tumuli oc c u r in groups of around ten but l a ter t h e number i ncreases. Major tombs contain a centr al h u r i a l surrou n ded by r o ugh ston e s, wi th sec ondary burials a round, outsi de thc stone enc l osu rc and generally orientated l'ast-west. The gr aves are often rich in finds but the con t e n t s vary. The presence of qu anti ties of w c apons indicate a the
.
-
1 1,
Etruscan infl uences : Sta re 1 975 .
IS 11 __1=::::1.._' III () 50 1w .... .. .... 1ww 1 1l1
,
() 1oiLW . loo!
o 51) : _...L---.JIw_' I I I __I:::=
SO
!wI !oooI I III
figure
a) Plall of settlemellts
01/
.s-
the Glasinac plateau
(b}
(c) b)
Figu re 5 Continued Chie{tain burial at Glasinac (Ili;ak . Tumulus c) Bronze greaves {rom Glasinac burial
Il)
1 11 1 ' .'\/ '1 1 ,., I, I"" 1 1/ " " 1 1 1 / \
Figure 5 Continued on bronze great'es from G/asinac
d) Design of ship incised
dominant warrior class (see figures 5c and 5d). An increase in cremation graves during the l ate sixth and early fifth centuries may reflect a collapse of the tribal structure and change in prevailing religious belief, I 7 Settlements and associated burials persisted a t Glasinac unti l the l ate fourth century, having continued without significant interruption from the developed ( Middle) Bronze Age. It has been estimated that at the height of its prosperity from the eighth to sixth centuries the population of the area had increased by a factor of seven. The emergence of a local ruling elite suggested by tom bs containing prestigious i mports marks a concentration of power in eastern Bosnia comparable with that which appeared around a century l ater in Slovenia. During the sixth century the rulers of Glasinac may h ave been expanding thei r power in several directions. Nevertheless Glasi nac i tself remained out of di rect contact with the Greek world, an isolation that may h ave accelerated a decline after the early fifth century. The rapid falling-away in the nu mber of burials before the end of the fourth century seems to i ndicate a general desolation, probably marked by the departure of whole groups towards the expanding world of Greece and Macedonia. Excavations of tumuli i n northern and central Albania have 17
Glasinac cu ltu re :
Benac and Covic
1 95 7 ,
(;ovic
1 979,
Govcdarica 1 978.
l 'I'I '''i� / f l n , 1 IIvll. I 11 ,\ t'u rn i s l l l'd s i g n i l i Ll l l 1 l' v i dl' l l l'l' l or t i l l' SOl i t l l l' r I l I I I 0-; t I l I y ri a n s , TIll' a rl';l k n o w l l 1 0 I h l' ( ; n'l' b , ; t -; I l I y r i s l a y lll' t w t't' l l I h c La k cs .l I I d t i l l' A d r i a l i l", a n d i l l d u d ed I h e v a l l e y s o f t h t' Bl a c k a n d the I I l l i l l'd D r i l l , M a t , Sh k u ll l h i n a l l d SC I l l ;l Il , a n d the coastal p l ain i l '" tar s O l l t h a s t h e ri vcr V i josi.; , In t h c Za dr i m e plain aro u n d t i ll' l ow n Lw a nd Mat most to m b s co nta in s i n g l e warrior w a V l'S w i t h n u m ero u s weapons, In the ce m etery at Burrel there il l'l' XO l l l lll u l i of th i s type, In character and content these gra vcs 1 I I ,l I d, those of G lasinac an d thcre can be no do u bt tha t there w a -; somc con n ection betwecn the two grou p s though the nature l i t' t h ;1 I l i n k rcmains a sub j e ct of debate betwee n Yu goslav and A l ha n i a n a rch aeologists, Burials continued down to the fourth l'l' l l t ur y , though in decreasing numbers , Down to the end of t h l' s i x th cent u ry an ab u nd a n ce of weapons, i n cludi n g spears, l'u rvcd s w ords, knives, battle-axes a n d , i n a few cases, bronze l'u i rasses, helme ts and greaves, is testi mony to the powcr of a w a r ri o r class. Their jewcllery and bronze brooches are also ... illl i l a r to t h ose found in Glasinac b urials. Cemeteries of tu m u l i h i l v c been e x p l ore d in the Drin v a l ley between Debar and " li kes, n o tab l y at G inama k (67 tu mu li ) , K e n e te (see figu re 6) _I l I d Kruma. S ev e r al features of the ir construction, including l.' IKlosing the b u r i a l with i n stone slabs, of ritual, such a s smash i ng p ots on the surface of the rising t u m u l u s , and content, i n d u ding a ta st e for amber ornamcnts, link these com m un i ties w i th t h os e of thc Mat v al l ey to the west. The earliest tumuli d at e from thc La te Bronz e Age and some continued in use as l a tc as the fo u rth century. Linked with these grou p s arc those w h ose t u m u l i cemeteries w i th cremations lic acro ss the Yugos lav border in s o u thern Kosovo (Dibicak near Suva Reka and Romaj a n ear Prizren) , w ho s e iron w ea p on s , two-ha ndled cups a n d poor- q u a l i ty ornaments match those from graves at Kcnete and Kruma. At the same time the burials in Zadrime and th e Mat d i ffer from those of the Drin va lley , which a l s o continued down to the fourth ccnt u r y , in the use of i ron for weapons but bronze for ornament. In the latter iron is cmployed for both , w h i l e silver pins occur in burials of the late sixth cen tury. I H
I H Prehistoric tumuli in N, Albania : Ku rti 1 98 5 , 1 9 87 (Hurrel ) , 1 97 1 , 1 976 a (Mat), Hoti 1 98 2 (Bardhoc) , Jubani 1 982 (Kruma ) , 1 9 8 3 (Kcnctc) ; in Kos()vo: Jubani 1 9 85, 1 9 8 6a, Slav kovic-Djuri 1 964 (Suva Reka), Djuric
Figure 6 Tumulus graves at Ki/nete, Alhania
In ce n tral Albania the cemetery of 25 tumuli at Pazhok com menced in the Late Bronze Age (c. 1 300 BC) but would ap pe a r to h av e gon e out of use by 700 fiC, though many of its tum u l i have y e t to be explored. Further east in the Korce basin, wh ich lies south of the Lakes, the great tu m ulus at Bar� (4 1 m diameter) contained a pri m ary burial of the Late Bronze Age. After a considerable interva l burials began to be i nserted into the mound and continued for a rou nd three centuries unti l around 8 5 0 fi e. S o far nearly 200 graves have been reco ve re d, representing a l a rge ruling elite rather than the succession of a single dynasty . The earl ier bu rials contained jewellery a n d o rn a m e nt s o f gol d and bronze, an early variety of the ' s p ec tacle' - b rooc h , a n d pottery decorated w i th knobs and n ipples, the so-ca l kd Devo l l wa re. The burials at Bar� contain sign i fi ( ; I i , i ,: 0 1 1 1 . 1 I 'odorov i l 1 '1 7 ) ( Rol1la j a ) ; in (I\ I or ) . 1 ' 1 I " l 1 '1 7 6 ( I\otor), I .ckovic
..
( ' " i j,'vo poI Jl' ) .
Montencgro: Parovic-Pdi k a n 1 976 l 9 8 0 (Njcgosi), Srejovic 1 9 8 0- 1
'"" l I l 1 l y flo wl' r wl'a p O l I s t h a l l t h oM' i l l t i l l' M a t a n d D r i l l v a l k y s , A 'ft a w h o k t h l'Y a p pl'a r t o n' l a t l' I I 1 0 0 0l' dml' l y w i t h a g ro u p of h ur i a l s a k w m i l l''ft t o t i l l' sou t h . 1 1 K u ,\ i I.i, a l so i ll t h l' Kor,"'l; h a s i n , w h i c h so fa r rl' p n'Sl' 1 1 t t il l' most s o u t h n l y e x t c n s i o n o f t il l' ( ; l a s i n Ol c- M a t l l I a tl' r i a l c u l t u r l' . T I ll' t'a rl i c r o f t w o t U l11 u l i ( 1. 9 I I I d i a lllctn) c o n ta i n l'll h v c cr c m a t i o n s i n u rn s a n d many � k t' k t on h u r i a l s i n trcnchcs, SO Ill C o f ,.... h i ch were stone-l ined. M a n y wcapons wcrc rcco verc d , a mong them swords, spears, a r ro w s , k n i ves and choppers, w h i le ornaments include bronze hracclets, beads and pendants, wh ich m a tch closel y those from so u t h e rn Koso vo and Glasi nac. Onc s uggestion is that these h u ri a l s bel ong to a rul i n g dy n asty of the e igh th century that h a d moved to the area from somewhere in the Glasinac region to t h e n o r th . Also connected with th is regi m e may be the l'o m p l exes of fortifications gu a rdi n g entry to the Korce plain , w h i c h A l banian arch aeologi sts have dated to the ninth and l'i g h t h c enturi es . These include Sy m ize and Bellovode on the west, Bi l isht in the sou th, and the group around Tren on t h e cast, co ntroll ing the 'Wol f's pas s ' ( Gryke e Ujkut) leadi n g to l .i tt l e Prespa Lake. The 1 8 burials in the second tumulus at K ill; i Zi, begi nning aro u nd the middle of the seventh centu ry, OUt' skeleton graves w i th few weapons and no ' G lasinac' j ewel l e r y . Some of the pottery is hand-made in local forms but mo st i s wheel-made and imi ta tes Greek forms . G reek im ported pottery was also found and there were two exa m ples of mouth pi ece s of sheet gol d tied across the faces of the deceased . The m a rked differcnc es bctween th e burials in the two tu m u li at Ku� i Zi m ay rcp resen t the differcnce in materi al c u l turc bctween a ru l i ng dynasty of northern ( Glasi n ac ) origins and onc with sou thern connections that ruled until some time after the m i dd l e of the sixth centu r y . According to o n c reconstruction ( Ha mmond) wc h ave the evidence for an IlIyria n dyn asty bcing rcp laced by a Chaonian regimc from northern Epirus. 1 9 The co mmunities o n the east and southeast borders of thc G l asinac p rovi nce remai n l ittle known . In southcrn Serbia and Kosovo the Early Iron - Age co m munities are represented by Si tes in central Albania: Bodinaku ] 975, ] 9 8 2 1 9 77-8 (Ku� i Zi ), 1 97601 ( Korcc I � 7 1 , 1 973, 1 9 76 (Trcn forti fication s ) , " /
(Ban;), 1 976b,
(Pazhok); Andrea 1 975 basin culture) ; Korkuti
4X cClll l' t l' r i l'S o f ' I LI I ' I I r 1l - h l l r i a l .. d a l l'd I I l a i l l l y t o t h e e i gh t h n' l l tury. ThoSl' a t DO l l j a B m j i cl , ( ; o m j a St r a z ;l v a , D O l l j a TOPO l l i cl (which cont i ll llL'S i nt o t he Sl' V l' 1 1 I 1 I cl' n t ury ) , K a rag;l l " a n d others, represent a d i s t i n ct l ocl l g ro u p ( Don j a B rn j i ca ) , The burial urns were covered with sto n e s l a hs, abovc w h ich , in the
case of later burials, a mou nd of carth was raised. These cemcteries appear to represent communities which h ad developed from earlier local groups and exhib i t few signs of outside contacts. Further south another local group h as been identificd in southcrn Kosovo around Suva Reka in the Topluga basin north of Prizren, where sitcs incl ude the hill-forts Belace vac and Hisar and cremation graves at S iroko. The scttlements and cemeteries of this group, which has similarities with those in the Black Dri n valley, were in use betwccn the eighth and fifth centuries.20 In northern Serbia the hilly country south of Belgrade has p roduced sevcral hoards and tombs of the late eighth and seventh centuries ( Rudovci, Barajevo, Rodisic, Z i rovnica, Roz anci, Rtanj , Alj udov Manastirica, etc. ). Their contents have been compared with those from burials across the Danube in southwest Transylvania (Bilvane§ti-VinI), Wal lachia (Balta Verdc and Gura Padinei) and also in Bulgaria (Drzhanica). East of the river Morava tumulus burials containing both skeletons and cremations of the late sevcnth and sixth centuries have been identified as a group from the metal -working centre at Zlot, a cave-sitc in eastern Serbia (Vrtiste, Vranovo, Dub, Konopnica ) . The associated black-burn ished pottery appears to belong to the Basarabi tradi tion of southwest Romania, wh ich extends into northwest Serbia and Slavonia. Pins characteristic of the Zlot group occur at several sites in northwest Bulgaria, mainly west of the river Iskar. The presence of both burial rites beneath tumuli has been interp reted as the result of thc local tradition (crcmation) bcing mixcd with burial customs origi nat ing from thc area of Glasinac and also from the south.2 1 Largc quantities of material have been recovered from burials 10 Srejovic 1 97 1 (Donj a Brnjica), 1 973 ( Karagac), Trbuhovic and Trbuhovic 1 970 (Donja Topoll i ca), Ercegovi c-Pavlovic and K o s t i c 1 98 8 (S. Serbia) 21 Vasic 1 972, Dumitrcscu 1 976 (Basarabi ) , Kosoric 1 976 (Drina basin), Stojic 1 9 86 (Morava basin ) .
f 'r" hlS / O Il I
f t/VIII /lIS
I I I a n' a s hordl' r i n � I l I y r i a n Lmds 1 1 1 1 t h l' Sl I l I t l l l" l s t , t h l' h i st or i �'a l I'l'gi o l l s o l l 'l' l a gl l l l i a a ro u n d H i l l l l a , P,Il'O l l i a a ro u n d S l i p , a l o n � w i l h t h l' l 1 l i d d l l' Sl'l't i o n o f t h l' V a rda r ( A x i os ) v a l l e y , n o r t h of I hl' I k l ll i r K a p i j a go rge, h i s\l I r i l' L y eh n i t i s a ro u n d O h r i d and in I la rda n i a a ro u n d S kopje in t h e u p per Va rd a r basin . Among I h l' l 1 l a n y t U ll1 u l i s ur vi v i n g in Pc i a gon i a on l y Visoi has so far lll'l' I l fu l l y i n v e s t i gated. A ce n t r a l grave a l i gned west-cast, l ined .I nd cov e red w i th stones, ,"vas su rrounded by d o z ens of radiall y l oca t�'d skeleton burials i n si m i l a r graves. There are other t U ll 1 u l i dated to the eighth ce ntu ry whose contents indicate an origi n in the Glasinac provi nce. In the fertile region of Paeonia a ro u n d S tip tum ul us cemeteries of the Early Iron Age ( OrI o v i (;u k i , Gorno Pole near Star Karaorman, Radanje, Kunovi Cuki , Don je Orizare and other s ) h ave a central stone-lined grave su rrounded by others in a ra dial formation, wh ile the pot t e r y forms also suggest links with the north and the north Wl'St. ll The appearance in Pelagonia and Paeonia of these t U lll u l i burials apparently closely connected with the Glasinac provi nce ha s been i n terp r ete d as evidence for a temporary l I I y ri an domination of these regions. Us ing a fr a gme nt from Stra bo's a cco unt of M acedon i a (now missing from his Geography) , Hammo n d has identi fi ed the evidence for an l' ph emera l JIIyrian domination o f th at country. Eighth-century h u rials in the great ce m etery at Vergi n a on the river Haliacmon
ill the coa s tal plain of Macedonia which contain 'spectacle' h ro o che s , diadems, bronze bel t- p l a tes and, do w n to the mid seventh century, numerous spears ( o ften in pai rs ) and bronze pendants, arc te s ti m ony for the presence of lllyrians. Marking a relative decl ine i n material wealth these newcomers from the north may represent an abru p t change of ruling class. An I l Iyrian presence has also been detected in the tu mul i of Pela gonia (Visoi and Pri lep), in Eordaea (Pateli), along the course of the lower Vardar ( Ax i u polis, G evgh eli and Chauchitsa) and in Paeonia. Here the bronze p e ndan ts, beads and buttons from Radanje and Orlovi C uki and the burial arrangements match those at Visoi, and the IlIyrian presence here may h ave pe r sis ted II
Vasic 1 976, MikulCi c 1 966, 1 97 1 (Pelagollia ) , Simoska and Sanev 1 9 76 (central Pel agonia), Pasic-VillCic 1 970 ( O rlova Cub), D, Garasallin 1 9 76 (Radanje) , Kitalloski 1 9 83 (burial rites in Pdagonia ) .
n". s/', I I'I f, I/ / /' IlIv/'i, /II.�
(i O
u nt i l the e n d o f t i l l' sc v l' n t h n' n t ur y . Th i s I l I y r i a n d O l 1 1 i n a lKl' lasti ng o v e ra l l fro m a ro u n d H 5 0 t o a ro u n d 65 0 III a t v a r i o u s ti mes encompassed m o s t of the northern a n d \vestern a re a s o f ancient Macedon ia.n Evidence for the Early I ron Age i n regions to the west o f Glasinac is both small in q uanti ty and uneven in distri bution . In central and western Bosnia, Hercegovina and Central Dal ma tia no major settlement of the period has yet been investigated, with the exception of Pod near Bugojno in the Vrbas valley (see figure 7). This hill-top settlement was o ccupied from the Middle Bronze to the Late Iron Age and has yielded exceptional evidence for a regular arrangement of streets and houses as early as the period from the tenth to the eighth centu ry. In western Hercegovina there is sufficient in common in the material from the period of the sixth to fourth centuries from a n u m ber of sites to i dentify a local group (Gorica, Crvenica, Posusje, Postran je, Zagvozd, Crude, Drinovci , PctroviCi-
" "
"
I'
Figure 7 2.1
,
"
.-
,
1'
Plan of hill-settlement at Pod, Bugojno (later phase)
Ham mond l 970, 1 972 ch . 1 4, 1 982a; Georgi cv l 978 (Ku manovo grave).
1 '" ,/" ,\ /. " ,.
1 1/ 1'/ 1,, ,/ \
IC, k I l I l O ) .! I o l l g w i t h S t O I l .I t t i l l' h . l �l' 0 1 t i l l' 1 't· I f l' s . l l P l' l l l 1 l � l I l a
.l I I d t i l 1 d � 0 1 1 t i l l' i � L l l l d � B r . l l ( V I q. 1 I , l i b ) .I l l d K o r l' l I l a ( B l .l I o ) . T h o l lgh t h e . I rl'.1 i , d o m i l l a t l' d h y 1 1 1 1 1 1 Il'I'O m fo rt i fi l'd h i l l - s l, t t k
rel'overed l'om es often l'I l I l t a i n m o rl' t h a n o l l e i l l h l l l l l ;l l i o n t hey w e re evid ently family t o m hs . C re m a t i o n Ol'l'l I rS a t C o r i ca (a fter which this group is n . l I l 1 n l ) n e a r t h e northeastern edge o f the Imotsko polje. The l \ 1 o st d i sti n ct i v e fe a tu re of the Corica group i s the large number o f wea pons, i n cl ud i n g iron spears, curved, short swords and k n i v es , m a n y later vers i on s of the ' C reco-II l yria n ' h el met and "l' V l' f;1 1 i m ported greaves (Ston, Zagvozd and Vicja Lub). Ikfore the si xth century this was a group of predominantly IOl'a l ch a racter which then evidently increased its power and prosperi ty through contacts wi th the Greek Adriatic and sou t h e rn Italy, enabling a southward expansion towards thc coast I l I l' l I 1<; ( g r; l d i l \ ;l ) , l I l o s t o f t h l' l'V i d l' l I l'l' so Ll r
t ro l l l ' I I a t ' " k L' k t o l l -gra v l's h u i l t o f s t O l l l' s l a hs . Si nl'e th ese
.1 I 1 d i s l a nds.24
The m iddle
material record in northwest Bosnia, incl uding the Sava and thc lower courses of its principal tributaries (Sa n a-Una, Vrbas and Bosna) is dom i nated in the Early I r o n A ge by thc major settlcments and accompanying cemetcries at l >ol1 j a Dol i n a on the Sava near Bosanska Gradiska, and by S a n ski Most amid the rich iron-ore deposits around the lower Sa n a . Donj a Dol ina began as a settlement of pile-dwellings on the ri ver, but by thc Late I ron Age the river deposits and occupation debris had raised the site above water level and the p i l e-dwel l i ngs were replaced. The settlement was enclosed with a wooden palisade plastered with mud. The rectangular houses generally contained three rooms, onc with a hearth of fired day (sce figure 8 a ) . The houses were linked by raised wooden walkways in a regular arrangemcnt so as to form narrow streets. The flat cemetery alongside the pile-dwellings contained skeletons laid in wooden coffins or directly on the earth (see figure 8b). The occupation of Donja Dolina lasted from the seventh to ! 4 We stc r n Bosni a : Covic 1 971 h (Pod , Bugojno), Bellae 1 97 1 cl (Zecovi, Prij edor), Covic 1 9 6 1-2 (Crveniea, Duvno) ; Goriea group: Covic 1 975 e ( Vi ti n a ) , Marovic I 96 t -2, 1 963-5 (Brac), 1 979 (Ccti n a valley), 1 9 8 1 (Brat), Protic 1 9 8 5 (Vis), Radmilli l 970 (Lastovo).
1 '/ 1/ , S/ ', /I , /, // 1 / 1 11\'1 /0 111 '
• •
•
.
: :�
.
!\
::
'l.': : : : :;i,.": =,,,.-.-.;,:: .::: . .::;: ,,",,,�-"--"" , .... o,
.-. .. : : "
. : :- :- -..._.
.
2!
4:
Figure 8 a) Plans alld
6,
8,
10 '
. ..
:r.:4t· ·
+-I...._....�...3E ��---�-........ . ��: .. -· : !:·-·· ,�---·..
:
.
j:
•
•
, , : : ::; =
m
sectiolls of houses
at
[)on;a Dolinll
the first century fl C , and indeed longer i f it was a di rect continu ation of the c10seby Gorn j a Dolina of the Pa nnonian Urnfield Culture occupied from the twel fth century, Climatic ch ange may have caused the abandon ment of th i s settlement and some of the inhabitants may have moved to occupy a pi le-settlement at the river's edge. But it was only towards the end of the seventh century that this fairly i nsignificant riverside settlement was transformed into a major centre of exchange for the northwest Bal kans, signal led by the appearance of exotic objects from cultures as remote as Greece and northern Italy , Dou btless its position on a major naviga ble river contributed to th is advance but the rise to com mercial prominence is prob ably to be explained by the emergence of greatly enriched ruling groups on the west in Slovenia and to the east and southeast in the Glasin ac complex. Whether or not Donja Dolina was itsel f the centre for one of these new powers is hard to tell, if only because of its relative isolation. On the other h and, the presence of well-armed warriors in its com m unity may indicate some degree of local independence. Though not deserted u n til Roman times the commercia l prominence of Donja Dolina
(7 �u !� ()J O· 0"
@
�/
Figure R Continued b) Woman 's grave at Donja Dolina, with
objects
enlarged
I ", ' .\, ', 1 1 , 1 , /' "
1 111'11 . 1 " \
a p pca rs 1 0 I L I Vl' v ;l I l i s l H'd . I '> r.l p i d l �' ;l s i l h a d ;l IT i v l' l l , d ur i l l � t h e fo urth Cl' l l l l l ry w h c l l l l l a l l Y d l ;\ l l �l'S . i l l d l l d i l l � I h l' C C l t i l' m igrations, d i s r u ptcd l o ng-d i s l a lKc t ra d c p a t tcrns w h i ch h a d been estab l ish e d fo r a ro u n d two cCllt u rics . .! \ At Sanski Most houses \vith h ea rt h s ",'ere fO ll n d a l ongsi d e t h e ri ver San a . Th ere were also round forging-furnaces togeth er with implements for s m e l t i n g a n d fo rg i n g iron, which was evidently the principal activity carried on i n the settl e m e n t . N o t fa r away a ' fl at' cemetery contained skeleton buri a l s a n d c remati o n urns, the latter probably of l ater date, with a few g rave s l i ned and covered with sto nes. Pottery similar to that o f Donja Dolina includes single- or dou bl e-handled c up s and bowls, but the later crcmation urns, large a n d b i co n i cal , arc s i m i l ar to those in th e ce m e te ries further to the west around Bihac i n the Una val l ey. Jewel l ery in the graves at Sanski Most appcars to bc a mixture of Sl ove n i a n ( hrooch es, b el t- b u ckl cs and b ra c el e ts ) and western Bosnian Uapodian) types (pi n s, bronze di scs , temple bands and d eco rated bronze buttons ) . Weapons foun d a t San ski Most i n cl u d e iron spears an d sing l e edged short swo rds . A dou bl e-edged G reek sword and two pairs of greavcs, also imports, were recovered. Most of the graves date to the fifth and fourth ccnturies and, taken as a wh ole, th e m a terial culture a pp e ars to rcflect a group of local origin, though i m i tating some Sl oven ian forms. What appcars to ha v e been a shift in burial ri te fro m i n h um a ti on to cre mation, similar to th at o bs e r v ed at Gla s inac and elsewhere h a s been ta ken as evi den ce for th e arrival of new p eo ple from the northY' In the regi o n of Sl avon i a l y i n g between the middle and lowcr courses of the Drava and Sava a sign i ficant d isc ov e ry has been th e cemetery near the hill-fort at Kaptol near Pozega, in a val l ey enclosed hy low h i l l s . Tu mul i of th e Early Iron Agc wcrc fo un d to inco rp o ra tc a stone-built cham her con taining u p to five cremations, b o th with and without urns. The pol ished bl ack pottery, m a i n ly in bicon i cal forms, has incised geo metri c decor ation and moulded additions such as ani m a l s ' heads. In addi ti on to i ron spears and b a ttl e - a xe s there wcre i mp o rtc d helmets, a
2..<
2 f,
Do n j a Dol i na : Truhclka 1 904 and 1 909, l\.laric 1 964a, Fia la 1 8 99 (Sanski Most ) , Maric 1 97 1 b (Vis, Drvcnta) ,
( :o r i l l l h i ;l l l I y pe ;l l I d ;I l l e;l r l v V (' I' ... l o l I 0 1 I h e ' ( ; reco - I l l y r i a l l ' 1 l l' 1 1 I l l' 1 , ;l I I d ; 1 p;l i r 0 1 g rea v l· ... I h ;1 1 I \ I ,I Y Ill' p l'l's u l I l ed t o h a n' rca l.: l l l'd t h i s s i t l' v i ;1 DO l l j a D o l i l l ;l , s i l l n' t l l l' rl' a rl' d ose resem h L l l l n' " hl'I V.' l·l· 1 I I h e m a t e r i ;1 1 f l'O l I l I h l' I w o s i tes.
The K aptol
h l l ri a l ... he l o l l g to a l l esta h l i s h ed l oca l w a r r i o r elite of the si xth n' l I t ur y s i m i la r to t h ose i n the ( ; la s i n a c regi on, a l though here
j udge from the presence of tackle in the tom bs. D To t h e east of the Kaptol group a major community of the F ;l rl y I ro n Age has been identified in the region around the m o u t h s of the Drava and Sava, including the district of Srem, n o rthern Serbia and the Banat plain across the Danube in the reg i on o f Voj v o d i n a . Th is group appears to be linked with that of Basarabi, n amed after a sitc on the D anube near Calafat in so u t h west Romania, whose disti nctive pottery appears in many settlements with i n the a bove area. Thc most sign ificant finds come from two major hill-forts wh ich have been exca vatcd, Bosut near the Sava west of Sremska Mitrovica, near the mouth of the river Bosut, and Gomolova, a m ajor 'tel l ' - l i ke settlement a l so on the l e ft bank of thc Sava, a few miles d o w ns tream from M itrovica. Excavation here on a large scal e revealed long established settlements commencing around the middle of the eighth century with large houses containing altars of fired cl ay. The connection between Bosut-Gomolova a n d the Basarabi group may h ave once been dose, but by the si xth century these l i n ks appear to havc diminished, when local characteri stics in the pottery become more evident. Thc ma teria l cu l ture of these settlements was altogether di fferent from those of the communi ties represented by the several large urn cemeteries a round Dalj, near the mouth of thc Drava, which are a later conti n u ation o f the Urnfield Culture in the transition from Bron ze to Iron, al though no settlement has yet been investigated. It is in this a rea that an appare n tly sudden and widespread di stri bution of bronzc horse-ha rness of the late eighth and seventh centurics has been i n terpreted as the evidence for an invasion of horse rid i ng groups from the di rection of the Black Sea and South Russia, thc so-called Th raco-Cimmerians. There appears to be h or ses were l I 1 0 re i m porta n t to h o rsl'- h i ts a n d
!7
o
ther
Vey voda and Mirnik 1 9 7 1 , 1 9 73 ( Kapto l ) , Vinski-Gaspa r i n i 1 9 7R .
I h" S, ', ,,., " /"1' IlIyn.II/., a gro w i n g s�:l' p t i l' i s l l l t o w a rds t h l' reali t y o t t h i s i n v a s i o n , a l l d some s p ecialis ts now p r e fe r t h l' s i lllpkr l' x p l a n a t i o n t h a t w i t h the spread of i ron u se ca m e all increase i n t h l' lIse o f t h l' h o rsl' in the plains.2.8 By far the largest quantity of m ate r i a l evi dence fo r t h e Earl y I ron Age in the I llyrian lands comes from the n orth w es t, west ern C roa tia includ i n g the northern Adri atic and the Istrian peninsula, and Slovenia in the sou th ea s tern Alps. I n the 'Level Corner' (Ravni Kotari) around Zadar on the A d riati c, between the rivers Krka and Zrmanja the material culture of the histo ri cal Liburni ans has been recovered in abundance from th e ir cemeteries and their settlements . The latter i ncl ude hill -top si tes such as Radovin and Bribir which, like others yet to be i n vest i gated, were later forti fi ed with walls of dressed stone and in the Roman era were formally constituted as self-govern ing citie s . O th e r, low-lying sites on the coast such as Zadar and Nin were also to be de v eloped later as Roman cities. Th e settlements at Radovi n and Nin have furnished ev i dence fo r s tone defen ces a n d stone houses, arran ged in row s parallel with the ramparts and wi th a central open space. Inhumation appears to have been the prefe rre d burial rite, with skeletons pla ced in a crouched p o s iti o n in graves that are sometimes lined with stone slabs. Large clay vess e ls were often used for the burial of ch i l dren. Most graves were in 'flat' cemeteries but a few tumuli, so me containing several graves, are recorded. By compari so n with that of oth e r groups the p ottery of the Liburnians is relatively little known as it rarely occurs in grav es . There are quantities of imp o r ted wares, i n cluding Daunian from south Italy, some Hellenistic and a small quant i ty of classical Greek. T h e ma i n finds consist of jewellery, on the basis of w hich Batovic has been able to suggest an elaborate chro n ology for Li b urni an material culture. In contrast, weapons arc almost unknown, save for some eighth-century bronze two-
28 Brukner 1 97 1 , Tasic 1 972 (Gomola va), Medovic 1 978 (chronology), Tasic 1 98 8 (ethnic identiti es), Vasic 1 9 8 9 (Banostor graves).
['" " Im l l l l'l, 1 1 1 \" 1. 1 , , ,\
'i 7
l'dgl'd s w o rd s fro l l l N i l l , ( > V rr t i l l' ' I X 1 1 1 ;1 1 1 1 p h a ses o t dl' v l' l o p I I I l' l I t t h l' re a p p eal's t o Iw a (ol l t i l l l l l t y f ro l l l t h l' n i n t h (l' l l t ll ry down to t h e R O l 1 l a n e ra , '' '' Beh i n d t ill' Vl'kh i t m o u n t a i l l s a l o n g t h e (O;) st hetween Li bur n i a a n d I s t ri a t h e h i gh pl a i n o f Li b h a s p ro v ed exceptionally r i d 1 i n I ro n A g e fi n ds that m a y h e taken to represent the m a t l' ri a l l'l1 l turc of th c h istorical J a podcs. Several major cem l't n i cs, notably Prozor and Kompolje, have yieldcd many arte la dS, w h i l e several settlements (Vrcbac and Mal i Oblj aj ), i n d u d i ng cavc-si tes, h ave been idcntified and partly invcsti ga t l'd . Thc hill-forts were protccted by ramparts of stone blocks and earth and contained rectangular houses. Both 'flat' and t u m u l us cemeteri es occur, thc former being more common with s k eleto n s laid in stonc-lined graves. Crcmation was already s p reading into thc area in the eighth century and by the fourth h a d become the dominant ritc, both with and without urns. As i n thc case of that of their Li burnian neighbours on the south, t h e chronology of Japodian materi al culture is based upon jewellery rather than pottery. Contacts of the Lika communities
wi th the Adriatic appcar to h ave passed via the Li burnians but the power of the latter declined contact with northcrn Italy may have become closcr. By th is time the Lika J apodes had evidcntly moved across the Velebit to control the coast betwecn the Zrmanja and Istria. In the fourth century they also evidently expandcd northwards to dominate the Vin ica area of Lower Carniola. To the east the Una valley around Bihac appears to have come under japodian control by the fi fth century. Some early graves of the eighth and seven th centuries arc seen to exhibit closer parallels with groups further east in Bosnia and Hcrccgovina but by thc end of the fifth ccntury graves in the major cemeterics at Jezerine, Golubic and Ri bic, in use continuously down to the Roman period, exhibit a cultural unity with the Lika. By thc middle of the fourth ccntury what can bc identified with rcasonable certainty as thc material culture of the historical japodes had becomc one of the major when
l�
Libu rnians: Batovic 1 965, 1 976b, 1 970 (Nin), 1 968, 1 97 1 b (Radovin),
1 980b (Bribir), 1 9 76c (Adriatic connections), Cus-Rukonic 1 9 8 0- 1 (Oso r) ,
nil' St', I /"( I, /1 1 1 111"1'10 111.\ g ro u p s i l l t h e wes t e rn I b l k a l l s , n';Kh i l l g f ro l l l t h e r i v l' l" I. r l l l a l l j a
i n t h l' south to t h t, I\. U P;l i l l t he l I o rt h a l l d f ro l l l t h t' A d ri a t i ( t o In th e U n a v a l l e y . A n area where the m a te r i a l ( u l t u r e o f t h e Ea rl y I ro n A ge h a s an exceptional richness a n d d i stincti ve c h a ra ctl' r i s t h e v a l l e y of t h e Krka around Novo Mesto, the a rea of S l ovenia known a s Dol ensko ( fo r m erly Lower Carn iola ) . Later the Dolensko a pp e a r to have expanded westwards into the a rea of Upper Carniola a r o u n d Lj ubljana. A m a j o r settlement of t h i s region, the o n l y one so far exca va t e d , l ay at Sticna in the hill s between Novo M cs to and Lj u b l j ana and was occu pied continuously from the end of th e ci ght h century to the Roman period, An area of around 800 by 400 metres i s encl o s e d by a wall of several ph a s e s built of l arge undressed l i m esto n e blocks ( u p to 3 by 1 . 5 m) and with e a r th and s mall stones p a c k e d between, which was backed with an earth rampart. A fter the original constru ction the defen ces of S ti cn a were remode l l ed in the fifth and sixth centu ries , Aroun d the ti me that the Sticna settlement was bccoming established thcre appear in thc area tumul i buri a l s that rep la c e the cemeterics of the Urnfidd Culture d a ti n g from the tenth to eighth centuries. What this changc rep resents is to d a y much debate d , By the late sevcnth and sixth ccnturies l a r ge tumuli appcar w i th skel eton burial s in a radial a rra ngeme nt around a n un o c cu p i ed ccntre, enclosed by stonc slabs or wooden coffins or si mply laid in the earth. The sim i l ar i tie s betwcen these bur i a l s a n d those of Bosn i a a n d M acc don i a has suppo rted a hy p oth e s i s of a m i g r a tion into C a r n i o l a fro m the south east that was a s s o ci a t ed with an expl o i tati on of the m i nerals i n which th e region is rich. The skelcton bu rials are for th e most part co n fi n ed to th e D o l en sko a rea. Certa i n l y the case for these bei n g i m migra n ts from Bo sni a appears to be strong, bu t unfortunately there are too m a ny gaps in the archaeological record of the i n tervening areas for there to be any certainty i n thc m atter:H 10 J apodes : Drechsler-Biiic 1 9 75 b, 1 95 8 ( V rebac) , 1 96 1 , 1 966, 1 9 7 1 (Kompo lje), 1 972-3 (Prozor), 1 9 75 a ( Osi k, Gospic), M a ric 1 97 1 a (Una �'a l ley) , 1 975 a (eastern frontier), Radimsky 1 8 95 Uezeri ne) , Radi msky et at . 1 8 97 (R ipac), Rau nig 1 97 t a (Golubic), 1 9 8 0- 1 ( Ripac) . .H Dolensko (Lower Ca rnio la) group: Archeoloska Naj disca Sl oven i j e
I '/'I 'h,stu/'/, 111" "",,,\
TIll' l'a rly pOl tl'ry o f t l1l' Do I l' I 1 S k o �"O I l P soon hre;l k s away from t ill' U rn /ield t ra d i t ions a s Ill'W pl'dl'st a l forms hegi n to a ppea r. Nl' x t t hl' rl' fol l m.... s a fa ... h ion ( I f i l1 \ i t a t i n� nll'ta l vessels, wit h vl' rt i cl l ;\ I \ d hori zoll tal r i h h i l l �. I m ported pottery from Vl'Ill'l i l' Ilorthcast I t a l y a l so rca dll'd t h c a n.'a, a long with wares frol1\ A p ll l i a a n d ( ; n:ece (Attica ) . From the late seventh century t ill' I ) o k l l s k o l'u ItUrl.' is distinguished by an abundance of metal vessc l s, i ncl u d i ng buckets, situ lac (water-buckets for the ritual of w i n c-dri n k i ng), cau ldrons, tankards, etc. Much of this metal work w a s l'v i d e ntl y produced locally, satisfying a great demand Oil t he pa rt o f the ru ling elite, The decoration of metal vessels a nd ot her objects evolved into the remarkable collection of st y les k nown today as Situla Art, which reached its fullest dl'Vl'lopment in Dolcnsko only in the fifth century, when numer OilS l'x a m ples of situlae with figural decoration occur in tombs. Thl' origins of the crafts m an sh ip and of the style of Situla Art wou l d a ppear to lie further west among the Veneti, where the ('a rl i l'st examples arc dated to the late seventh century. Possibly t ll l' rl' was a transfer of workshops from that area to Dolensko hrough t a bout by cha n ges u nderway in northeast Italy. Here t h (' a ppetite for traditional fashions in metal ornament was �iving way to a taste for the finer and more elegant productio n s of the Greeks and Etruscans. The old style may have suited t hl' ru lers in Dol ensko, direct, uncomplicated and explicit in rdlecting their own ways of l i fe. If the w o rkshops identified in s lll: h p l aces as Vace, Magdalenska Gora and Novo Mesto were those of craftsmen trained among the Veneti then what may havl' been a speculative venture turned out to be a great success. ( )I\ a la rge variety of metal ware, including a l so belt-buckles, sca bbards, b rooches and pendants , the Situla style becomes the disti ngu i shing feature of the Dolensko Culture (see figure 9 ) . La rge q u anti ties of weapons and some armour are also a feature o f the Dolensko Culture. The most common arc spears and sockt'hl xes and there are some bows and a rrows. Helmets (IIlVl'lItory and Ill a p of s i tes), hey 1 966, Gabrovec 1 964-5, 1 96 6 a , Dular I 'J H l (pottl'ry ) , 1 9 !U (Crnomei j ) , Frey and Gabrovcc 1 969, Gabrovec, hey ;lI1d Fl I l t i n y I ':I 7 D , Ga hrovrc 1 ':175 ( Sticn a ) , Wel l s 1 978 ( Sticna), 1 9 8 0 ( M "�lb kmka �ora ) , Kncz 1 ':I7 H , I ':I HOb ( Novo Mcsto), Pus 1 911 l-3 ( Ll l l h l j a n a ) , I'" h il: 1 ':1 7.' ( S lovl'n i a n D ra v a ) .
Figure 9a) Burial tumulus at Sticna, 1 964 excavations
occur i n tombs over the period from the eigh th to the fourth
centuries. In the seventh century there appears a local variety of helmet, bowl-shaped and made of l eathe r stre n gth en ed with bronze studs. This was re pla ce d later by a n Italic d esign made o f b ron z e piec es fo rged toge th er, rep la c e d in turn by a d o u b le crested type. In the fifth century there appears a much more durable type of Italic he lm e t named a fter the find at Negau ( n o w Negov a ) , on the river Mur near Gornja Radgona in north-cast Slovenia, whi ch had a lo n g p eri o d of use over a wide area. The examples of bronze body-armour found in tom bs a t Sticna a n d Novo Mesto we re i m po rted and have been dated to the late seventh century. The trapp ings for horse harness are also common in D o len sko , with ex amples of spurs appearing in the fifth century.-u .1 2
Situ l a art: Knez 1 976, 1 9 ! Wa, 1 98 3 .
I'rl'/Jistori, I /lv,." ilK
61
Figure 9b) Scenes on Vale situia The cu r ren t chronology and analy s i s of the Dolensko Cu l turel and i t s outliers is based largely on the work of Gabrovec. According to th is scheme t he fi rst ph as e , wh ich la sts from the m id - e igh th to the mid-seventh century, is m arked by the co incid ence of iron- w orki n g and tumuli burials with pottery and j ewell ery made in local sh apes . From the seventh to the
Figu re 9c) Bronze situ/a-cover from Sticna
fourth centuries Italic influences increase and the l ocal warrior eli te di splays a steadily increasing material pro s p e ri ty , reflecti n g an expan sion of th eir power over neigh bouring com m u n ities. At the height of their prosperity in the fifth century the m i l i ta ry role b ec o m e s less p ro m i n e n t in favour of i ma ge s of a n elite ta king the i r pl easu res aga i nst the background of a sta b l e pol iti cal ascendancy. This has been inferred specifically from the changing repertoire of Situla An, where the b attle themes a n d warriors appea r to give way to the pleasures of the h u n t, and s u ch agreeable pastimes as banqueting and m usical and athletic festiva l s . The gol den age soon pa ss ed a n d du ring the e arly
fo u r t h lT l l I u r y t l l l' rl' hl'g i n l a r gl ' n' I 1 I l' t l' l' I l'" o t w a r r i o r w a v l'S, hilt it has IWl' 1 l co n d l l d l'd t h ;1 I h}, t i l l' l' nd ot t h l' fo u r t h cl' n t l l ry t h i s a rl' a h a d hl'l'n t a h'n o v er a n d 'il' t 1 kd h y Cl' l t S . 1 1 TIll' t ra c t o f h i l l y (oll n t ry e x t e n d i ng sOll t h w e s t from Lower ( :a rn i o l a tow a rd s I s t r i a , knowll a s N o t ra n j s k a ( I n ner Carn iola),
h a s p ro d l l cl'd seve ra l i m porta n t Sitl'S o f the I ron Age, notably t h e ca v e sh ri ne o f S k o cjan (St Kanzi a n ) , though no single place
has yet fu rnished evidence for a continuous occupation from H a l l s ta tt (Early I ron Age) to La Tcne J Late Iron Age) ti mes The meta l hoard and flat cemetery at Skocjan have produced h rooches, bowls, helmets and spears that in some respects resem b l e those from the Dolensko area and from St Lucia. Si m i l a r material has also been found in the cemeteries at Socerb a n d S tanjel. The hill-top settlement at S mihel has th ree associ ated flat cemeteries, one of the eighth-seventh centuries, the others contai ning mainly fourth-century graves. The material from the cemetery at Kriina gora of the eighth-sixth centuries is di fferent from that in the rest of Notranjska and has similarit ies with the Lika group, while the fact that a thi rd of the graves contain skeletons seems another indication of links with communities further south . It has been suggested that th e inter ruption of cemeteries i n this area after the seventh century was caused by the dom ination of the Dolensko group. Similarly a recovery of local independence, following decl ine of the latter's power, may be signified by the reappearance of major cem eteries in the fourth century.>4 The Iron Age communities of the lstrian peninsula at the head of the Adriatic are known from several sites, where the finds suggest that a si ngle cultural group had formed by the eighth century. Their typical forti fied settlements on hill-tops had begun to be occupied al ready in Bronze Age times. These castellieri, as they arc known in Istria, often enclose two or th ree crests, with single or multiple ramparts on the naturally unprotected sides. They vary greatly in situation and in physical character, from just above sea-level to around 700 metres, and from an area of a few hundred square metres to vast complexes .
hi�tory:
11
Dolensko
l4
Notranj ska group: Gustin 1 973
Frey
and
Gahrovec 1 97 1 (ch ronology ) ,
Petru 1 973, Mason 1 98 8 , Terian 1 9 8 5 ,
(chronology),
Urleh
Gabrovec l 973 ,
1 973 (Krizna
gora ) .
/'I". .'\/',m " /"/' I lIvri'lII� o f sl'v e ra l sq u a re k i l o l l l t't res . Tht'y l'o l l t a i l l e d rt'ct a ll gl l / ;n l i ll1 h e r
and clay housl's. B u r i a l w a s i ll fl a t lTt'll 1 a t i ol l l't'Ill l' t l' r i l' s , S O I l 1 l' times without but m a i n l y with u rn s , i n a stone- l i nl'd gravl' that was sometimes covered. Bou n d a ry walls of a d ry - s to n e construction defined family burial plots. The dead were crem ated wearing their clothes and their jewel lery. Skeleton burials arc rare. A particular feature of the lstrian material culture a rc the carved stones from Nesactiu m on the cast coast. Here a princely tom b suggests that predecessors of the kings who reigned there in the third and second centuries were already wielding power in the fi fth. There is much yet to be understood about the Istrian culture of the Iron Age, and publication of some o f the major collections of evidence will assist in thi s regard. There seems little doubt that what was basically the prod uct of local evolution over several centuries was from the sixth to fou rth centuries much altered by Italic influences. The origins of some elements may lie in the i mpact of the Pannonian Urnfield Culture on local Bronze Age groups, from which several traits, including grave-construction, pottery ornament and the lack of brooches, continued down to the fi rst appear ance of Ita l i c influences. As a result of these, lstria became part of a more uni form, Italic-dominated complex around the Adriatic, which included Liburnia and the Lika:!5 In the Alpine valley of the river Soca or lsonzo several large cemeteries, including 5t Lucia containing more than 7000 graves, together form a distinct group. They belong to the inhabitants of hill-fort settlements of which as yet l i ttle is known. The graves were lined and covered with stone slabs and contained the cremated remains of the deceased wearing clothes and jewellery. The graves contain pottery, metal vessels and jewellery but are devoid of weapons. The Soca group seems to have consisted of a local culture, somewhat isolated in the southeast Alps, which was radically altered by Italic influences in the course of the seventh century. Thi s development appears to have been connected with the establishment of long-distance trade routes between the Mediterranean and the Balkans. 5t 35 Istri a : BaCic 1 9 70 (fortifications), Kucar 1 979 (Beram cemetery ) , Mladin 1 974 ( b ronze vessels and helmets) .
I 'rl,h,,,lonc
I I I V I I' /II \
I .l I l' i a l a y a l .1 I l l a l o r lTos s ro a d s o f t l l l'st' ro l l l l'S, a ll d i t i s I h l' n' I h .1 I OlU l rs hy fa r t il l' gn'a l l'sl l'C ) l I ll' l l I ra l i o l l of h u r i a l s . I ta l i c w a n's Wl' re l I o t o l l l y fo r w a rded e a s l w a rds h u t Wl're a l so very I i k l' l y m a ll u fa c t u red I h e re . A I l l' W el'<>Ilomy grew u p with a n (' I l l ph a s i s Oil co m m e rce a n d ua fts a s t h e pop u l a t i o n appears to h a v e con centra ted more and m o re i n a few large centres such as St Lucia and Kobarid, while other places, such as Tolm i n w h e re recta n g u l a r houses o n stone foundations have been fo u n d , we r e a bandoned. D u ring the l ate sixth and fifth centur ies, the p e r iod to which the richest graves in the region belong, I h l' role of St Luci a a pp ears to have increased as a cent re for
p rosperous traders. At the same time the wide range of objects fo u n d in graves of a similar period in the cemetery suggests perhaps an i ncreasing economic stratification with i n the popu l a t i o n , with a wealthy minority among a multitude of the poor. Pol itical changes in the fourth century evidently dis rupted the pattern of commerce on which the settlement had depended and its prosperity dwindled rapidly.36 This section has described in outline the 20 or so g ro ups defined by material remains who o c cupied the IIIyrian territor i es du ring the Early Iron Age (eighth to fo u rth centuries) . horn this there e merges no supp ort for dear-cut definitions of I l I y r ians, either through a compact unity in the archaeological e vidence or through any apparent consistency in habit s of ritual or daily life across the different cultural gro u p s. At the same t i me some conclusions rega rding origins and development can be drawn. Several groups, notably those in lstria, Lihurnia, northern and southern Serbia, central Bosnia and Dal matia, had already been fo r m ed before the start of th is peri o d, but an Early Iron Age prosperity brought i ns t abi li ty to their traditional pattern of social relations and a decline had already set in before the cnd of the seventh century. New groups emerged, notably those of Glasinac and Dolensko (Lower Carniola), through ex p l oiting the qualities of i ron to amass a wealth of cattle and create fortified settlements. Their el ites are dis tinguished by gra ves that arc rich in weapons and jewellery .lh
Soca (lsonw) group : Gabrovcc and Svolsjak 1 983, Tedan, Lo Schiavo and Trampuz-Orel 1 984-5 ( St Lucia), Svolsj ak 1 976 (Most n a Soci ) , 1 973 (Tolmin), Ba rtosiwicz 1 9 85 (faunal cvidcnce).
hh
a n d �o n l ;\ i n i l l l po r t s t ro l l l I t a l y a n d C rn'n' , T h l' m'w r u i n s s u p po rted l o n g-d i s t a lKl' �( ) Il l l l l l' r�l' n' n t rcd on s lJl: h p l a n's ;\ s Donja Dol ina and St Lu� i a . I n t h e b ur i a l m o u n d s w c GI ll 1 1 0 \\'
recognizc the increasing dominance of powerfu l c h i e fs w i t h their armed followers, such as th o s c a t G l a s i nac ( I 1 i j a k and Osovo) and Dolcnsko (Sticna and Novo M e s t o ) . By thc fi fth century the p o wer of these chiefs, based in tri bal alliances, h a d reached a peak, but in the foll o w i n g century thcrc was a decl ine as the tribal structures began to b e challcngcd by new forms of central authority developing in a d j a c ent lands.
J
Naming Illyrians
Illyrian l anguage !
Though almost nothing of it survives, except for names, the I l lyrian language has figured promi nently in several theories regarding the spread of Indo-European languages into Europe. In the late nineteenth century the names of persons and places recorded by a ncient written sources and on inscriptions con vi nced some schol ars that Illyrian-speakers had once been wide spread across Central and Eastern Europe, the Balkan penin sula, Asia M i nor and southeast Italy. In the early twentieth century there was a confident identification of IIIyrian as a pri mary sub-stratum of Indo-European from w hich whole families of European l anguages later developed. Theories of this kind flourished in a time when there was also a greater confidence on the part of archaeologists. Most were willing to accept that the appearance of a new language was somehow connected with the movement of whole com munities, best illustrated by the h istoricall y documented migrations of the Celts between the fifth and third centuries BC and also by the barbarian invasions of the Roman Empire between the third and the sixth centuries AD. Many still hold to the view that it is possible to detect traces of invasions by Indo-Europeans in the material culture of this or that region. I On
I l Iyrian
langua.se,
names
and etymology : Crossland 1 982, Rendic-M ioccvic 1 9 5 6 , Katicic
1 9 82, Russu 1 969, Sasd 1 9 77a, 1 9 76b, 1 9 8 0, 1 9 8 4 .
Pol ome 1 976a,
' h, ' .\, ',1/, /, t",. 'I/\'n. III.\ As rega rds t h e Ba l k ;I l l s , t h c r c h " ... h c c l l I I I l' X I S l c l l l l' t o r sl' v l' I'a l del:a des a theory t h a t I I l O V l' l I 1 l' l \ I S o f I l l' W p l' o p k ... i l l t o E u ro pe from the d i rection o f A s i a a ro u l l d t h e hegi n n i n g o f the B ro n ze Age ( before 2 000 IIc) m a rked t h e a r ri v a l a n d d is persa l o f I n do European speakcrs. Serious pro blems arise w i th this and s i m i la r .
theories when onc comes to exa mine thc p rocesses of evol u tion and fragmentation that produced the historically attested langu ages of the Balkans within barely a thousand years. This ques tion has most recently been taken up i n a stimulating a n d provocative book by Colin Renfrew (1 987) . While it is hard to avoid notions of invasions and m igrations in a discussion of the Illyrian language and its origins, there arc clear signs th at the old famil i ar landscape of European l inguistic and arch aeol ogical cvolution is becoming a desol ation of vanished certainties in both disciplines. At th i s stage it may be useful to outline the limits of IlIyrian territory as indicated in the onomastic evidence, that is, names of persons, peoples and pl aces recorded in the Greek and Roman sources, as set out by I. I. Russu ( 1 969). The southern limit starts on the coast of central Albania and passes i nland to Yugoslavia to include the Lakcland, the Skopje basin and the Kosovo-Metoh ija region. Then it turns north to follow a line west of the river Morava to the vicinity of Belgrade on the Danube. On the north the Sava and Drava valleys are included along with an area north of the latter extending i n the direction of Lakc Balaton in western Hungary. From there the limit passcs southwestwards, skirting the southeast Alps, to meet the Adriatic in Istria. Finally the ancien t districts of Calabria and Apulia in southeast Italy arc included. In addition to a distri bution of lI Iyrian personal and place-names the Messapian language recorded on more than 300 inscriptions is i n some respects similar to Balkan II Iyrian. This link is also reflected in the materia l culture of both shores of the southern Adriatic. Archaeologists have conclu ded that there was a phase of II Iyrian migration into Italy early i n the first millennium B C , not only in the south but also further north from Li burnia to Picenum. A more cautious view suggests that while Messapian may have developed as a branch of Illyrian, or rather 'pre-Illyrian', a substantial di fference between the two had developed by h is torical times. For this reason the problem of Messapian is better
N,IIII1/Ig 111 ,,", 1 1 1 .\
CI I l I s i d lTl'd ;1 '.. ,I d i s t l l l d l' l l I i t y w l I l l I l l t i l l' ('.I d y l a l l �l l a �l'S I I I I t a l y
ra t h lT t l U I l a s a l l l' x t l' n s i l l l l I I I t i l l' I b l k a l l I I l y r i a l l p ro v i ncl' , ' T h l' ( ; rl'l' k s h a d a w l lrd lor t h l' ' I)('a k i l l � I I f I l I y r i a n ( iJltlrjzeill)
a n d rl'cI I�n i l.l'l1 a l a n � L l a �l' d i s t i l l d tro l l l ( ; rl'l'k . As p rese rved
in S t ra h o ' s ( ; ('ogr,l/,hy t h e G rcl' k t ra d i t i o n i d e n t i fied
I 1 l yrians
a s a p e o p l e (l'tlJllos) d i ffl' rl'nt fro m M a ccdon i a n s and Thracians a -.. wdl a s fro m the Greeks. On th e other hand, Greek sources ;I lT fa r fro m clea r over any distinction between IIIyrian and the
i n h a h i ta n t s of Epirus: 'Epirote' as a political or ethnic term w a s evi den t l y not cu rrent before the fourth century BC, and the ph rase 'epirote peoples' means no more than 'peoples of the m a i n l a n d ' , th at is, seen from the island of Corcyra where the ( ; rl'e k s first settled in the region. It cannot yet be establ ished
that there were peoples in the northwest of mainland Greece who spoke a language that was neither IIlyrian nor Greek. When Strabo refers to 'bi l ingual' people beyond the mountains west of Macedonia, the presumption is that the languages spoken were Greek and Illyrian. Ancient writers tell us almost noth i ng of the IIIyrian language, although there is no doubt th at it continued to be spoken wel l into the Roman period. They furnish a h andful of authentic Illyri an words, including ' rh inos' for 'fog', 'sabaius' or 'sabaia', a local variety of beer, and 'sybina' for a lance or hunting-spear. Studies of the llIyri an language must continue to depend on the large n u m ber of attri butable names, tribal, personal and geographical, p reserved in a ncien t literary and epigraphic sources.] Modern study of Illyrian names began with the catal ogues of geographi cal ( 1 925 ) and person al ( 1 92 9 ) names compiled by H. Krahe, modelled on the dictio nary of Cel tic names co m piled by Alfred Holder ( 1 8 9 6-1 9 1 4 ) . These were followed by studies of the II Iyrian language by Krahe ( 1 955-8 ) , Anton Mayer ( 1 95 7-59) and I. I. Russu ( 1 969). A new era began with jiirgen Untermann's analysis of Venetic names ( 1 9 6 1 ) which defined the separate l inguistic identity of the Venetic peoples. l
On
limits of IlIyrians: Maric 1 964b, Degmedzic 1 967 (archeological and
l i tera ry evidence ) , Katicic 1 977a (Paeonians), I1ievski 1 967a (Istria), Si mone 1 972, 1 976 (Messapian), 1 986,
1 977 (JIIyrians .1
in Italy) . Crossland 1 982.
1 975
(Greece), Suic
Pisani 1 976, Ma rin
I I'i'
St', l/t " /"1' 111"1'/0 / 1 1 .\
Th i 'i p i O l l l'lT i l 1 g w o r k o t l o( , d d d i l 1 i l l O I 1 h a \ h(,(, 1 1 i l 1 l i l a l l'll , t o r t h e l 1 l os t p a rt s l l �n's s fl l l l y , i ll l a t e r s t l l d i e s 0 1 t h e l 1 a l l 1 (,S o t oth e r I1 l y r i a n grou ps. C l- z a A l fi i l d y 's ca l a l ( )gll�' a n d a n a l y ses o f
per s o n a l n a m es from t h e R o m a n p ro v i n cc o f Da l m a t i a ( 1 964, 1 965 a n d 1 96 9 ) rema i n fu ndamental a n d a rc m a tched b y t h e works of And ras M6csy o n Pannonia ( 1 95 9 ) and M oes i a Superior ( 1 9 70 ) . Duj e Rendic-Miocevic h a s p u b l ished severa l studies of names from the territory of th e Dcl matae, on t h e m i d d l e Adriatic arou n d Split, notably from th e n a t i v e centre a t Rider ( Danilo) n e a r S i benik, and we owe t o fanoula Papa zogl u ( 1 978) a valuable examination of the eth ni c affin iti es of th e Darda n ians from the evidence of n a mes. Perhaps the most significant contribution has been the work o f Radoslav Katicic. Following the lines of Untermann's study of Ven eti c names, KatiCic ( 1 962, 1 963 ) has defined two 'onomastic provinces' among the Illyrians. The southern provi nce i ncludes the ancient regi on of Ulyris in central and southern Alban ia, the h eart of the IlIyrian k i ngdom around th e Lake of Scodra, and the Adri atic coast and h i ntcrland up to and beyon d the Neretva v alley . The Middle Dal mati an-Pa nnon ian province l i cs fu rther north and is con siderably greater in area . In the northwest l ies the Venetic province, including the Liburn i , th e lstrian pen in sula and the region o f Lj u b l j ana in Slovenia beyond the Julian A lps. These two IIlyrian onomastic provinccs are dcfined by th c near excl usive distri bution of some personal n ames. Among the southern ' real ' Illyrians these include Epicadus, Tem us (a female name), Genti us (in Grcek Gen th ios), Pinnes (or Pinnius), Mon ounios ( recorded on coins) , Gra baei (a tri bal name), Vcrzo and Zanatis. The mid dle Dal matian -Pannon ian provin ce exh ibits a l a rger variety of names, o f which those cha racteristic of th e a rea in clude Andes ( m . )/Andia (f. ) , Baezus/Baezo, Bubant-, Iettus, Paio, Panes, Pan to (m. }/Pantia ( f. ) , Pinsus, Plares, Sinus, Stataria , Stennas, Suttis and Vendo . The province defined by these includes the Adriatic coast between the rivers Titus (Krka) and Hippius ( Cetina) , western, central and southern Bosnia, the middle and upper Una va l ley and the Li ka plain . On the cast the district (Sanj a k ) of Novi Pazar and western Serbia a rc also i ncluded. There is a measure of overlap between the three p rovinces (Venetic and the two I llyri an ) . Thus Bato occurs both among
N,II/III/,I; 1 1/ 1'1 /, 1/1 ,
1 Ill' sO l l l h c l' l l I I l y r i a l l s .1 I I d .t l so 0 1 1 t i l l' l >;t l l I l a l i a l l I.'oasl , i ll Wl'sl l' l' I I a l l d l'l' l I l ra l Bos l l i a .1 I I d I l I rl h n l I o r t h i ll Pa n ll o n i a , Vl'r/,o Ol'I'I I rS i l l S a l o l l a a n d a l so i l l W l's l lT l l Bos l l i a . A n e l e m en t o f I h l' I l I y r i a l l roy a l 1 1 a I I l l' S k nd i l a i d a s a p pca rs i n eastern B o s n i a . I S 1 l i d l l s a n d ;I I l l O l l g t h c I k l l l l a t ;1e a t R i d e r as Laedica l i us and I , ( a ) nl i l' l i s . S i l l l i l a r l y t he m i d d l e p ro v i n ce i n c l u d e s na mes w i th ;1 w i d l 'r d i s pe rsa l : t h c root of A p l i s/A p l o occ u rs a l so i n Liburn i a , l I 1 d I S l r i a , w h e re i t i s a n element in M a ga p lin us. Th e name I k u S ; 1 S , ge n i t i v e Beusamis, which is found among th e Delm a tae, h a s hecn w m p a re d with the Messapic Bosat, with Bu zetius a m o n g t h c J a po des and with the Pan non ian Busio. The n ames l >a l.;1 , D a s i u s a n d Dazomenus have been connected with Das I I l l' l l l l S in Pa n n on i a and D azos in southern Italy. The meaning o f I h esl' p l a u s i b l e correspondences is hard to determine: neither 1 I l l' i n t ern a l l i n k s between the three pri ncipal lllyrian onomastic p rov i n Cl's n o r those between them and other a reas indicate more t h a n th a t the l a ngu ages spoken by peoples in the Illyrian I l' rr i l o rics were som ehow rel a ted i f not altogether common, T h o u g h they are separatel y iden tified i n the h istorical sources t h l' rl' was u n d o u btedly a close associ ati on between Liburni and Vl' n l,t i , fro m the distr i b u ti on of disti nctive names with the S l l' I l l S hosti in Hostiducis (gen itive), or vols-Ivolt- in Vol setis (�l'n, ) , Volso, Volsonus, Voltimesis (gen . ) and Voltis( s )a. Place-n a mes fro m the IlIyrian territories add l i ttle to our k n ow l edge o f the ll1yrian l anguage. The recurrent e lement -Ulla, fo r example, Aenona (Ni n ) , B l a ndona (south Li burnia), E m o n a ( L j u b l j a l1a), Narol1a ( Vid) , Sca rdona (Skradin near � i hl' n i k ) , Salona (Solil1 near Split) , does n o more than i ndicate t h a t I 1 l yrian place n a mes followed a basic Indo-European (o n ti gu ra tion . Indo-European characteristics i n the formation of pl' rson a l n a mes i nclude the der i vatio n of fem i n i nes in -Oil, for e x a m ple, the masculine Apl is/Aplinis with feminine A p l o/A p l o n i s , or thc use of the prefix epi- in Epicadus, the d i fferent deri va tion s i n -nt- and -menos in Dasan t-, Dasmenos, a n d the use of numbers as personal na mes, Tritonusffritano, Sl's t u S/Scxtus/Sesto. Finally the i mpact of Celtic on I l lyrian n o m c n c l a t u rc has been m u ch discussed but attributions of indi v i d u a l n a mcs a rc fa r from certa i n . A mo ng the japodes the n a llll'S J a ri tlls, M a tcra, N o n nt i o a n d S i n lls, a re ascri bed to Cl'i t i c i n fl u en ce, as a r c Sa rn u s, S i n u s a n d V e p u s a m ong t h e ..
71.
' 1 1'1' .'11 ,, ,,.t /., fO,. 1 11)'1';. 111.,
Dc l m a ta e . P l a ce n a ml'S con t a i n i n g t il l' l' k m l' 1 l I -d'f11 UI1I
,
fo r
example, Nov i o d u l 1 U Ill o n t h e Sa v a , C a r ro tl u l1 l1 l ll O i l t h e Dra v a a n d Singidunum (Belgrade) on t h e Da n u he re p resen t e v i del1 ce for Cel tic penetration of the a rea.4 A notable addition to the repertory of IIIyrian names has come from the cemeteries in the vicini ty of the Greek colony Dyrrhachium (Durres) . Many hundreds of graves had their inscribed tombstones still in place, simple cylindrical stelai, decorated, if at all , with a simple band of l au rel and inscri bed, mostly in Greek, with the single name and patronymic of the deceased. The names so far reported include Andena (f.), Antis (f., two examples), Batina, Batouna, Boiken, Breigos, Brykos, Gen th ios, DazaiosfDazos ( two examples) , Epe(n)tinus (from the place Epetium, Stobrec on the coast south of Split), Epicadus (ten examples) , Epidamnos, Zaimina, Isnthena, Koreta, Lydra, Mallika, Monounios, Pladomenus, Plator (five examples), I'la toura, Scodrina, Strabainos, Syrmas, Syra, Sychos, Tadus, Tata, Teutaia (four examples)ffemiteuta. New additions to the list of south-II Iyrian names include Andena (Andia), Plaios/Plai anus/Plaia, and also Scodrina from the myrian capital Scodra, an adjectival form that appears on local coins. Known south JIIyrian names include Genthios, Cillanus, Epicadus, Laidas, Laidon, and Teutaia, and those new to the list include Billena, Isnthena, Mallika and Strabainos.s With such a large repertoire of myrian names it is possible to consider etymologies and links with other Indo-European languages of wh ich a fuller record survives. Thus it seems generally agreed that the name of the IIlyrian queen Teuta of the third century BC derives from teutana, which means 'queen'. Si milarly, Gentius, the last o f the lllyrian kings, defeated by the Rom ans in 168 BC, has been connected with a noun, in its Latin form gens, gentis, meaning 'class' or 'kin' and appropriate for the leader of such a group. These are exceptions and no satisfactory etymologies have yet been produced even for some of the most distinctive myrian names. A more difficult question is how myrian fits within the family 4 s
Polomc 1 982. To<;i 1 96.5, 1 970, 1 976, 1 9 86,
Simone
1 977.
N.",I/I/g III \'I "'I/.�
o f I l I d o - I ': m o pl'OI n l a n g l l age s A s .1 w h o k t i l l s has hn' l I d i v i dl'd i nto a Wl'stl' rn grou p ( ; l'r l l 1 a n i c,: , Vl'l I e t i r , IlIy rian, C l'i til', I talic a n d ( ; n'l'k ) and an eas tern gro u p ( Ba l t i lo, Slav ic, A l hani an, Th racian Phry gian, Armenian , I ranian and I n d i an ) . The disti n c t ion t l l rn s on the con sona n t ' s ' in the l att e r and 'ch ' , 'h ' or 'k' .
i n t hl' for lller, a n d the two groups a rc identified by the words fo r the n u mber 1 00, centum in Latin and satem in Old Iranian, alth o u gh s u bseq uent d i s cover i es have led to a questioning of t his t i d y geograp h i ca l separation. One explanation attributes the d i fferen ce not to separation within some linguistic family t ree hut to a mechanism of change from 'ks' to 's' in the cen tral area while l e a ving the older forms untouched at the periphery. I n the case of Illyrian the problems appear to be mu l tiply in g : i f, as some have argued, II Iyrian belongs not to the centum
grou p but to the satem, the common etymology of Gentius and ),!t'I1S must be d iscarded. There is no evidence that IIlyrian in fact bel o n gs to the satem group, but the argument that it does
crucial to the case that modern Albanian is descended from So far no satisfactory scheme for the analysis of I l l y rian names has been proposed. The com mon name Bato may derive from the same root as the Latin battuere meaning ' to strike', or is j ust as likely to derive from the root * bha 'say' or 'tell', the Latin fari. A connection of the common I I l y rian name Epicadus and the stem * kad, me a n i ng 'out st a ndi n g' or 'flourishing' in Sanskrit and Greek, is denied by those who argue for the satem attribution of lllyrian, prefer ri ng words meaning 'destruction', 'deprived of', 'quick, ardent' and 'sh arp , bold', It i s hard to see any way forward in a rguments of this kind. While some scholars appear entirely engaged with placing Illyrian in this or that group, there are i ndications that some of the divergences once regarded as definitive of the two Indo-European groups in fact arose at a much l ater stage of the development of language. In the end the strongest evidence for the connection between Illyrian and Al ban i an must be the few direct correspondences of vocabulary often cited.6 is
l I I y ri a n .
" Polomc 1 9 82, Cimochowski 1 976. Fo r 1 98 7a-b, 1 98 8a-b, 1 98 9 .
some
IIlyrian
etymologies,
Stanko
74 l I I y ri a n names
The further refi nements of I 1 l y ri a n 011ol1l a s t i l: p ro v i lKl's p ro posed by Geza A l foldy fo r the a rea i n cl uded i n the l a ter R o m a n province of Dalmatia comprise m o s t of t h e h istoril: I I I y ri a n territories. Five principal groups arc identi fied: ( t ) ' re a l IlIyrians' south o f the river Neretva and extending sou th of the provincial boundary with Macedonia at the river Dri n to include IIIyris of north and central Albania; (2) the populous Dclmatae after whom the province was named, who occupied the middle Adriatic coast between 'real IlIyrians' and Liburn i ; ( 3 ) the Venetic Liburni o n the northeast Adriatic; (4) the Japodes who dwel t north of the DeImatae and behind the Liburn i, where names revea l a mingling of Venetic, Celtic and IlIyrian elements; and (5) the Pannonian peoples in the north of the province, in Bosnia, northern Montenegro and western Serbia . Alfoldy's identifications of names with these groups, some known only from around the ti me of the Roman conquest, have been chal lenged by R. KatiCic. He rejects a Pannon ian onomastic province distinct from that of the Del matae because the number of names on which it is based is too small, while there is too much that is common in the distri bution of names between them. Similarly, Alf6ldy 's identifications and interpret ation of Celtic names among the Japodes and in the east of the Pannonia n onomastic province have also been queried. For KatiCic the occurrence of Celtic personal names in these areas is less likely to be evidence for a mixed 'IlIyrian-Celtic' native population, or a Celtic element surviving from the migrations of the fourth century BC, than the consequence of movement in the Roman period associated with military service and the processes of Romanization.7 Typical names among the ( 1 ) 'real IIIyrians' according to AIWldy arc: Ann aeuslAnnaius, Epicadus, Epidius, Pinnes, Plare(n )s, Tatta, Temeia, Zanatis and Ziraeus. Other names less well known but which may also originate in the area include Agirrus, Blodus, Boria, Clavus, Laedio, Laiscus, Mad7
AlfOldy
1 964a, Katicic
1 964,
N.lI/lIl1g 1 11 "" , , " .\
7 'i
l'lta, Posa 1 1 1 io, P ra v a i l l S , Sn'rd i ." ' l 'l'lId,l, l.oraLI . A slIIal ler � ro l l P f O l l l t d ill I h l' a rea a p pea r 10 u r i � l l I a l l' f ro l l l t h e centra l Da l lll a l i ;1 I 1 prov i llcl' : ga l o, l )a s i IlS, l )a z a s , D i t ll s, Messor and Vl'rl'.o, A fn\! l I a m l'S \,.... h i dl occll r i n I h l' II pper Ncretva valley a ro u n d K O l l j i l' a ppea r to be o f Cel t i c origi n : Boio, Bricussa, !a n l s , M a l l a i lls alld M asccl i o - a suggestion which seems to Ill' cO l l fi r lllcd by Celti c styles of d ress on figured tom bstones. A l li i l d y suggcsts th at this Celtic component may derive from I Ill' i m pact of the migrating Celts on the IIlyrian Autariatae, h U I il 1I0W scems that they dwelt not there but further south 1ll'I Ween the ' rca l IIIyrians' around the Lake of Shkoder and I hl' 1 >a rd a n i a n s of Kosovo. Throughout this area the formula 0 1 1 I 0 l l l cn c l a t ure is that of the single personal name with the fa l her's namc ( patronymic) in the genitive.i! Ikl weCII the 'real lIlyrians' and the Liburni the (2) Delmatae appl'a r to cxh i bi t a similarly characteristic group of names. Thei r territory is exceptionally rich in onomastic evidence, w i l h h u ndreds of native names recorded at Rider (Danilo near S i he n i k ) and with several smaller concentrations at several o t h l' r ce n t res , Characteristic names include Aplis/Apludus/Apu rusl Apl usl Apl i us, Baezo, Beusas/Beuzas, Curbania, Cursulavia, 1 ,\ 1 0, Lav i ncia, Ledrus, Messor, Paio/Paiio, Panes/Panias/Panius ( pa ntus ?)/Panentius, Pant(h )ia/Panto ( f. ) , Pinsus, Pladomenus, Pia I i ItO, Sa m untio, Seio/Sei io, Statanius/Staticus/Stato/Status, Sl'st u s/Sextus/Sexto, Tito, Tizius, Tritus, Var(r)o. Other names a ppea r a mong the Delmatae whose origins lie outside their tl'rritory, A Libu rnian element is suggested by Accnica, Cb'ata, ( )a rlllocus, Germanicus (the native stem Germanus/Germus, with t h e charactistic Venetic ending -icus), Labrico, Lunnicus, Mel a ndri ca, Turus. A second group of names is common with t lH.' Pa nnonians and, though some are found also i n the southern l I I y rian p rovince, their origins seem to lie among the former: Ba rd u r i u s, Hato, Carrius, Dasantilla, Dasas/Dazas, Dam), Pl a tor/Pla tino, Scenobarus, VerzoNerzulus. Several of these arc a l so to be fou n d a mong IIlyrians settled far away i n the mining a n'a of the p rovi nce Dacia at Alburnus Maior. From the sou t lH.'rn I I lyrians the names Boria, Epicadus, Laedicalius, LoisclIs,
'I b,' S, ',III " /"1' 1 11),,,,111,\ Pi 1 1 i l l'S
Ve( n )do,
of nomenclature among the Dclmatae a re more varied t h a n among the southern II Iyrians, although the single n a m e with patronymic is widespread, In the western distri cts of the Del ma tae ( some of which still belongcd to the Liburnians until not long before the Roman conquest) a two-name formula appears to have spread from thc Liburni, in the same areas whcrc Liburnian names are also found. The commonest form is pcr sonal name plus family name plus patronymic, for example, Plator Carvius Batonis (filius) or Aplis Lunnicus Triti f(ili us) . A local variation appears to have the family name included in the patronymic formul a, Platino Platoris Tizi filia, 'Platino, daughter of Plator Tizus'.9 The language of the (3) Veneti is better documented than others in or nea r the lllyrian territories. The evidcncc includes morc than 3 00 inscriptions, most from the major scttlements of Ateste and Patavium ( Padua), along with a shrine near Lagole di Ca l alzo on the upper Piave and another at Gurina Alpe near Kotschach, on the far sidc of the Plocken pass in the Gail valley. Finds of individual inscriptions extend to Istria and across the Julian Alps. The texts are brief and follow a similar pattern of dedications to various deities and epitaphs on tom bstones and cremation urns. Enough of the language and vocabulary survives to indicate that Venetic was a northwest Indo-European dialect with several poin ts of corre s pondence with Latin. The distribution area of Venetic inscriptions is concentrated in the western part of th at area where Venetic names occur on inscriptions of the Roman period. Th is includes lstria, the Emona ( Lj ubljana) region and the Liburnian coast and islands down to the river Titus (Krka) . The repertoire of Venetic personal names include several Roman family (gens) names ending in -icus, - ocus , -inus, -iacus, -arius, -anius and -anus, also family and per sonal names ending with -avus. Individual names include Accius/Axius, Cantius, Carminius, Appuleius, Avitus, Tutor, 'J
Rendic-Miocevic 1 94 8 , 1 956, 1 976a,
NlulIlI/g 1 1/ \'//1 /11,\
77
Ba r h i l l s , H o n i a l ll s , ( :l' r v i l l S , ( : I I S0 1 1 1 I l S , I > a s i l l l i ll s , l > a S
region of the Roman per i od are pre do m i n a n t l y Ccitic, and it s ee m s that th i s s t a t e of a ffairs came about w i t h the C e lti c movements into the area after 400 HC. The i d e nt i ty o f the pre - Celtic inhabitants of th is large a rea , which i n d udes mo st of the Danube basin a b ove the Dan u be b e nd , re m a i n s a probl e m . What li ttle evidence there is i ndicates that t h e y may, in the southern area at lea s t , have been Vencti and l I I y r i a n s of the Pannonian-Dalmatian g ro u p . Venetic inscrip I ions h ave been discovered ca rved on rock faces and on p ortable h ro n ze d e dica ti ons, p roba b ly da ti n g to the second century B C . Latin in s crip tions of the Ro m an period indicate the survival of a Vene ti c clement in the upper D r a u, the lower Isel and u p per M i)1I valleys. M oreover some tr ibal and geographical na m es in the same re gio n , Laianci, Aguntum , Saevates and Sebatum, a re patently not of Celtic origin. The material evidence is not conclusive but d oe s not conflict with the notion of a Venetic s u rvival . They may indeed be the Carn i , in Roman times a peop l e confined to northeast Italy , but who in e arl ier times extended far into the eastern Alps . In the Roman pe riod the Venetic component was still strong in the area of Ljub l j ana (lg) where, in addition to some names of Celtic origin, the followi n g Venetic-Istrian names occur: Ampo, Fronto, Lucius, Pletor , Plotius, Pl unco, Rega and names formed from the root Volt-. Possibly a p eople named by the elder Pliny as Catali somewhere in this area may be connected with the lstrian Catari of the Tergeste (Trieste) region and may represent a survival of Veneti around Lj ubljana. The name of the Carn i has s u r vived in Carniola, a later name for part of wha t is now Slovcnia, the Austrian province Carinthia (Karnten), Mons Carantanus (U1 richsberg near Virunum) a n d the earl y med i eval centre Carl i o n s i n t h e Norican
10
Untcrmann 1 96 1 .
nil' .'\" , 1 1'1 " fi ll' IlIv",, ,"s
7X
a n t ll m ( K a rn h l l rg ) , a l l d possi h l y i l l t h e 1 J ;l l l ll' ot t he N o r i cl I I
settl ement a n d l a ter R O l l l a ll fo rt ress Ca rn ll lH l I l I I O i l t h e m i d d l e Danu be below Vien n a . I I The names of the (3 ) Li burn i demon s t rate th e i r Ve netic character, with such roots as Vols-I Volt - and the en dings -icus and -ocus, and set them apart from the rest o f the A d r i a t i c IIIyrians: Acaica, Actor, Boninus, Cliticus, Colatina, Curticus, Darmo, Dumma, Hosp(olis) , Hostiducis (gen.), Hostiices, Lam bieu s, Malavicus, Marica, Menda, Moicus, Oclatinus, Oeplus, Opia, Opiavus, Oplica, Oplus, Plaetor, Patalius, Recus, Suioca, Tarnis, Toruca, Trosius, Vadica, Velsounus, Verica, Viniocus, Volaesa, Volscus, Volsetis, Volso, Volsonus, Volsounus, Volsus, Volti mesis, Vol (l)tis(s)a, Zupricus. Also the name Turus, common among the Li burni but fou n d as well among the Delmatae and the j apodes, is of Liburnian Venetic origin. The majority of these names are unknown among the eastern and southern neighbours of the Li burni, except in a few border districts. In addition a smaller group of names appear to be of exclusively Li burnian rather than general Venetic origin, since they do not occur in other Venetic or llIyrian districts: Aeia, Barcinus, Buzetius, Caminis (gen.), Ceunus, Clausus, Granp( . . . ), Iaefus, Lastimeis, Mamaester, Pasinus, Picusus, Tetenus, Vesclevesis (gen .) and Virno. The separate i dentity of the Liburnians is also i ndicated by formulae of nomenclature. The single name plus patronymic common among IIIyrians is rare. In a region where the Roman three-name formula (praenomen, nomen gentile and cognomen, for example, Caius julius Caesar) spread at an early date, a native two-name formula appears in several variants. That with personal name plus fam ily name is found in southern Li burnia ( Ravni Kotari), wh ile that with personal name plus family name plus patro nymic is found throughout the Liburnian area, for example, Avita Suioca Vesclevesis, Vclsouna Suioca Vesclevesis f(ilia); Avita Aqllillia L(uci) f(ilia) , Volsouna Oplica PI (a)etoris f(ilia) and Vendo Verica Triti f(ilius). 1 2 The (4) japodes dwelt beh ind the Liburnians i n the hills 1 1 12
Alfoldy
1 974 (Vcnetic in Noricum ) .
Untermann 1 9 70.
a n d fO l"l' s t s o f sO l l t l H' r I l ( : I'O , l t l , 1 ,l I ld w l' .. I C I" I l l\os l l i Ol , Thci r ( ) n ( ) I 1 1 Ol S l i l' l' v i d c l l l'l' a p pca rs to Ill' ,I m i x t l l rc , w i t h S O l 1 1 l' l 1 a l ll CS I y p i cl l l y I l l y r i a l l : D i l i l l S , D i t l l l' i o , D i I l l S , Pa l l t a d i e n us, P l a to r , P l a t ur i l l s , Sestell i l l s , Scstlls, ' L l I ol l i a , Tc u d a , Tri tus and Vendes, M os t Ol'l:ur i ll the eastern pa rts of thei r te rritory, nota bly a ro u n d Bi hac in the Una v a l l e y . Names of likely Li burnian o r i �i l l i ncl ude Tu r ra n i u s , Turrini lls and Turu s, which may i n d i c a t e , a l ong with the evidence of name formulae, a Venetic l'Il'l1ll'nt among the Ja p o des . A group of names identi fied by
of Cel tic origin : Ammida, Andes, Iaritus, Matera, Mllntanus, Nantia, Nonntio, Parmanicus, Poia, Sa ri us, Scneca, Sicu, Sil us and Sinus are distri buted throughout .I a podian terri tory. A smal ler group confined to thei r territory a rc to be regarded as typically Japodian: Anadrus, Dcidmu, Dennaia, Loantius, Rufantills, Stennas/Stennato and Vandano. A l f( i l d y ' s list of Celtic names has been queried by KatiCic, with l' i � h t of the 1 6 (Andes, Iaritus, Maxa, Muntanus, Parmanicus, Sari us, Sinus and Silus) being discarded. Four names arc a n:c ptc d as definitely Celtic: Nantia, N o nntio, Poia and Sicu . M c l l i to has a Greek and Celtic element, wh ile the Ccltic associ ations of Ammida, Matera and Seneca rcmain questionable. Rather than constituting evidence for the surviving Celtic clement in the ethnically mixed Japod ia n s described by ancicnt writers, KataCic argues that the Cel tic names are the result of outside contacts and thc immigration of Romanized Celts dur i ng the first two ccnturies AD. The formulae of Japodian names a rc the si n g l e name or singlc name plus patronymic. A two name native formula of Venetic type is found where the first of the names appears to serve as a praenomen in the Roman fashion, occurring mainly around Bihac and in the Lika, for exa m p le , Secund us Turrinius Muntani filius, Sestus Platorius Triti f(i lius) . 1 3 The (5) Pannonian p eoples occu p icd a large tract of ter r i to ry north of the Delmatac, extending across the Roman provinces of Dalmatia and Pannonia, comprising the Bosnian va l l eys , parts of the Sava and Drava (Drau) valleys, and from the Japodes in the northwcst to Macedonia in the southeast. Names A l f(ildy
as
M a x a , M e l l ito,
1 .1
KatiCic 1 965, Rendic-Miocevic 1 975a,
HO
ty p i c a l o f t il l' Pa l l l l o l l i a l l I I l y r i a n s a n:or d i n g t o A l t i i l d y a rt' com mon a l so a m o n g t h t' l k l m a t ;ll' : HalO, D a s a s , l . i n'a i u s a n d Sceno b ar b u s , N a mes origi na ti n g from t h e Del m a t a c or so u t h e rn IIIyrians include Carvus, Laidus, Piaror, Tem a n s , Teuta, V a r ro and Verzo. A smalle r group i s con fi ned to the no rtheast Pa n nonians : Arbo, Arsa (possibly Th r a cian) , Callo, Dactor, lauletis (ge n . ) , Proradus and Vietis (gen. ) . AlfOl dy's Pannonian ono m a s tic p ro vince has been ch a ll enged by KatiCic on the ground s that the evidence of four di s ti n gu is hi ng names is insufficient. Bato is no t confined significantly to the Pannonians and seems to be no less attach e d to the Dclmatae and to the southern IIIyrians.
Similarly Dasas/Dasius and Scenobarbus also occur among the Delmatae, and only the confi ned distribution of Li cca i us indi cates a distinctive Pannonian-Illyrian name. In argu i ng for the unity of the Dalmatian-Pannonian onomastic p ro vin ce , Katicic observes that AlfO ldy lists four Pannonian names, seven of the Delmatae and five so u th I/Iyrian. But on l y one of these is fairly certainly Pannonian, two of th e Delmatae and three south lllyrian, indicating that that the propos ed division between DeJmatae and Pannonian is not valid. The two-name formula is found among Pa nnon i ans, and the few known examples around Plj evlja in northern Monten e gro may not be of local origin ( see below). Most are styled with the singl e name plus patronymic, for example, Te uta Vietis and Bato Liccai f(ilius). Among the Pannonians wi th in Roman Dalmatia the western groups, i ncluding the Maezaei and Daesitiates, exhibit few outside connections, and those are w i th Del m ata e i m me diate ly to the south, though in Al foldy's view the two groups arc quite distinct, w i th many of the latter's names unknown among Pannonians. This is in marked contrast to the more varied pi cture among the southeast Pannonians, notably the territory of th e Pirustae, where in addition to Pannonian names, includ ing the ethnic Pirusta and Scirto, a significant group of names of external origin is on re cord. 1 4 The p resence o f Illyrians i n the Celtic pro vin ce of Noricum Pan nonia is for the most part marginal. There is no base for the
14
M6csy 1 967.
N . l lll il/g 111,,1 1.111 \
H I
s i l l l p k l'll u a t i o l l , O IKl' w i lk l y l' ll t n t a i l l l' d , t h a t t il l' popu l a t i o n o f t ill' p r l' - Cl' i t i c I Lt l l s t a l l l ro l l A �l' i l l a n d n o r t h o f t h e e a s t e rn A l ps we rl' I I l y r i a n -spea kns, a rdi l 1 l' I 1 1 1' l l t o f ea r l i l' r 'pa n - I l l y r i a n ' t h l'o r i es n o w d i sca rded. I t i s d o u h t fu l i f the s m a l l n u mber of I I l y r i a n perso n a l n a m es i n the sou th and southeast of the Cel tic p ro v i n ce represen ts any k i n d o f eth n i c s urvi v al from before the l a l tn's migration in the fourth ce n t ury BC. At the same time, it h a s been observed t h a t it i s in the sa m e areas th a t the t ra d i ti o n s of the m ateri al culture of the earlier Hal lstatt I ron Age p e rs i s te d with the least change down to the Roman period . M ost of the III y r ia n personal names and the few pl ace - names occ u r on the sparsely populated margins of Carinthia. They m a y represent remnants of an IIIyri a n population expelled from t h i s ferti le region southwards into the Pannonian-Dalmatian region, with which the JIlyrian na m es of Noricum are co n n ec ted . On the other hand, movements of p e op le during the Roman l' ra can account for a dispersal of Pannoni ans and D e l m atae , especially i n such a productive mining region as the eastern A l ps. " In Roman Pannonia the Lato bi c i and Varciani who dwelt
cast of the Venctic Catari in the upper Sava valley were Celtic hut the Colapiani of the Co l api s (Kulpa) valley were IHyr i a n s (north Pannonian), exh i b i t ing names such as Li cca i u s , Bato, Cralus, Lirus and Plassarus. The few names on record for other groups in the Savq valley belong to a more southerly Pannonian Dalmatian group, the Illyrian Jasi with S cen u s , the Brcuci with Scilus Bat9, Blacdarus, D asm en u s , Dasius, S urco, S a s s a i u s , Liccaius and Lensus, and the Amantini and S co rd i sci around Sirm ium with Ter c o and Precio, Dases and Dasmcnus. It seems that at the time of the Roman conquest Illyrian p e op l e s were not to be found north of th e river Drava. Most of the people in northern Pannonia have Celtic names, except for a group of Pannonian ' JIlyrians, Bato, Breucus, Dases, D a s m en us , Licco, Liccaius, etc . , in the north e as t around Brigetio. These are likely to represent ' a people called the Azali, IIIyrians tr an s ported there from southern Pannonia during the wars of conquest
L�
Alfoldy
1 974
(IIIyrian in Noricum).
'/ '' '1' S, '"r, " /"r I U"n./II,"
u nder A l I gl l s t ll s
a n d St' 1 \ kd I l l';l r t il l' \ );1 I l 1 l ht' hl· t ...... t·t· 1 l t w o
Celtic groups, Boi i i n t h e west a n d E ra v i sc i i n t h e c a s ! . l h
Around t h e m i d d l e Dri n a a n d t h e Wt'stl' r l l M o ra v a t h t' OIlO mastic evidence suggests a s i gn i fica n t Ce l ti c e l e m e n t among t h e populat i o n, confirmed also by tomb s to n es w i t h Ce l ti c sym bol s and fashions of dress. A l f()ldy has detected descen d a nts of the Celtic Scordisci once d omina n t in th e central Balkans. Th e nu mb er of II I y r i an names in that a rea, Genthena, Tatta, Dasius and Thana i s small compared with the Celtic: A i o i a , Andeti a , Baeta, Bidna, Catta, Du ss o n a, Enena, laca, M adu s a, Matisa, Nindia, Sarnus, Seius, Totia and perhaps Pinenta. If the Scord i sci did reta i n their Celtic character into the Roman era the Illyrian element m ay represent an assimilation of gro up s from the ex i sting native population. Alfoldy's i nventory of 15 Celtic names among the Scordisci has been severely pruned by Kati Ci c . Only th ree, Catta, Iaca and "fo tia are j u d ged to be certa i nly Celtic, with another four, A i oia, Bidna, Matisa and Nindia, possible. Six, Andetia, Baeta, Dussona, Enena, Madusa and Pinenta, are not, while Sarnus and Seius arc either Celtic or north IIIyrian . This Cel tic presence a round the middle Drina and M orav a does not, in th e view of K ati Cic , represent a Celtic s urvi v al of the Scordisci but was rather a consequence of co ntacts with the Celtic world follo w i n g the Roman conquest. Whether the Sco rdisci were a Ce l tic or an Illyrian people h a s been co n si d ered by Fanoul a P apa z oglu ( 1 978 ) . Th e enquiry is at the outset confronted with con fusion among the ancient writer s . A tradition pre s erved b y Strabo cal l s th em Celti c, referring to their i nvasion of Greece and the southern Balkans in the third century BC. Others descri be them as lllyrians and one has them as Thraci an s . Appian includes the Scordisci in what must be a l a t e version of the Greek myth of lllyria n gene s is. Moreover, to make the matter more uncertain, th ere seems to be real doubt as to w het h er th e S cordis ci , whose name appears to be of lllyrian origin, were ever really a separate peop l e rather than a m ixed group of Celts and IIIyrians formed duri ng and after the third-century m i grations. This would explain their frequent and sudden c h ange s of territory dur i n g 16
Katicic
1 96 6 b
(Critic in Sl oven ia).
N.'IIIIII.I.! 1111'11.111,\
lU
til l' thn'l' lTlltmil'!'. of tlll'ir 11I!'.tOl'y, till' Il'!'.uh of t1uClIIOltioll!'. ill t lll' i r politicll relati o n s with Ill'ighhoming pl'opks of I h c ( c n l r a l I\alkall. .... Cl'rI'linly .lIll'IllI11S to rl'l'IlIlstrtKI a l'(lhcrent h i story 01' idl'llIity for t h i s pcopk th r o u gh (o l l l h i n i ng and rcconc i l ing the writtl'n sOllrn's h a vc rarely sel'llll'd t o re pay the cffort,I7 Thc a p p l i cltion of ol1omastic evidl'nce to th i s matter seem s 1 0 givl' rise to further problems, As we have seen , Katicic has qlll'sti o l1ed Alf(jl dy's identi fication of Celtic names, mainly fel11ak, from the western Dri na, the western Morava and M o u n t Koslllaj south of Belgrade, and also the same scholar's sllggcstion that male children received Roman names, with
I l I yrian and Celtic traditional names being reserved for females. the opinion of Papazoglu the material evidence is decisive for the existence of a pre-Roman Celtic population along the south bank of the Danube between the m outh of the Drava at M ursa and t hat of the Timok in eastern Serbia, and th is rep resen ts the historical Scordisci. Also there are a number of Cdtic place n ames i n this area: Cornacum , Cuccium, Bononia, Ma l ata, Cusum, Acumincum, Rittium, Burgenae, Taurunum, Si ngidunum, Tricornium, Vinceia, Viminacium, Lederata, Pin Cll m, Taliatac and Egeta. Even here the picture is far from clear: for example the name Pi ncum ( Veli ka Gradiste near the entrance to the Danube gorge) is claimed as a Celtic, TI Iyrian or Thracian name in each of the principal works of reference for these l anguages, and several others on the l i st have been c l a i med for more than one l anguage. We may perhaps l eave the difficult problem of Scordiscan iden tity with a summary of Pa pazoglu's reconstruction based on the historical, linguistic and material evidence. The Scordisci were a warrior-dominated Celtic group whose numerical strength did not increase even in the period when they dominated the central Bal kans. Their heartland was the Danube bank between the Drava and the Danube gorge, an area they continued to i n h a bit after major defeats at the hands of Romans and Dacians. Even here they were intermi xed with older strata of I I I yrians, Dacians and Thracians, and the onl y part of their territory where a settled Celtic population was probably i n the majority was the lower In
17
Alfoldy 1964b, KatiCic 1 965, Papazoglu 1978.
H4
.,.",- S'-,III"
/111 IIlVI;,ms
va l l ey of t h l' M or;wa. TIll' surv i v a l of ( : l' l I i r Swrdisri aW;l Y from thc river Danuhl' i s imposs i b l l' to gallgl' from any v a ril' t y
of evidence currently availahle, though imm i grati oll i n the Roma n era is a more l i k ely cxplanation for the few Celtic n am es on record . The e v i dence of p erson al names indicates an intrusive element in the p opu l ati on among the Pann on ia n IIlyrians of northern Montenegro a round Pl j ev lja a nd Prijcpolj e . Apa rt fr om some names of Thra cia n origin, B essus and Teres, and some Celtic nam e s , Arvus, Bclzeius, Cambrius, Taritus, Lautus, Madussa and Ar gur i a n u s ( e ith er Thracian or Celtic) , the on l y namc of south T\lyrian origi n is Plarcs. On the other h a nd , there are many that arc characteristic of th e Del matae, for example, Carvanius, Germanus, Lavianus, Panto, Pinsus, Pladomenus, S ta ta ri a, Testo, Tritto, Vendo and Verza i iu s . The l ink with the Delmatac app e ars to be confirmed b y the presence o f the two-name fo rm ula, adopted by some wcstcrn groups of the Delm a tae from the Liburnians, for example, Cam Sta t ari a , Tu(r)i f(ilia) . This formula survived into the Roman era when some enfranch ised n atives exh i bit two cogno mi na : P. AeI(ius) Pladome[nus] Carvanius, Au rel ia Ti tu l l a Arguriana, Aurelia Titulla Cambria and Ti tus Aurelius Severus Cclsianus. The area is remote from the homeland of th e DcJmatae and the i r presence may be explained as the result of m ass eviction from near the Adriatic in o r der to accommodate new R oman settlers. The arcas to which t hey were trans p o rted may well h ave been chosen b eca us e of the severe depopulation tha t had occurred during th e final stage s of the Roman co n quest ." 1 Along the eastern margins of the JIIyr ians there is a broad a rea of in ter mingling or ' co n ta c t zone' bet ween namcs of Illyr i a n and Thracia n o rig i n , running from th c Danube below Bel grade down the west o f the Morava valley t o th e Vardar and the northern border of M a ccdonia , The n u mber of recorded n ative names in this area is not l a rge . Those of Ill y rian and Thracian ori gins o ccu r together in the mining a r ea of Mount Kosmaj south of Belgrade and therc is another group of n a mes from the Metohija area of Dardania. Native names of Roman IH
Alfoldy 1964a (Delmatae
in northern Montenegro).
so l d i l' rs n'l'ru i t l'd i n till' Sl'CO l lll n'lIt my 1\1) /ro l l l S�:u p i (Sk o p j e) i ll Ihe soulh a n d R a t i a ri a ( A n:har) on til l' Da ll u he i n cl u lk a few n a l l 1 l'S o f Pa n ll o n i a n '''yri a n origi n , for e x a m ple, Dassi us and A n d i o, hut fa m i l iar Th ra�:i a ll n a mes, Hi t us, S i nn a , Dolens, Ilrigissa , Mucco, AlIllIzon, Mucatra l and Da izo, arc in the lIlajority. The I I I y r ian component is markedly stronger in Dard a n i a , i ncl u d i n g Das(s) ills, Scerviaedlls and Andia, but Thracian na mes arc also found, Sita and Nanea. Whether the Dardanians were an lI I yrian or a Thracian people has been much debated ,l lld onc view suggests that the area was originally populated w i t h Th racians who were then exposed to direct contact with '''yrians over a long period. 19 The eth n i c a ffinities of the Dardan ians, from whose n ame is sa i d to derive the modern Al banian word for 'pear' (dardhc), as revealed in the evidence of names from their terri tory have
Iwen examined by Papazoglu. Literary sources record Dardan i a n names for three medicinal plants. From the Materia Medica of Pedan i us Dioscurides, a Roman military doctor from Anazarhus in Ci l icia who l ived in the time of Nero, we learn that gentiana was called aloitis and aristolocheia makra or kll'matitis (wormwood or birthwort, a herb promoting ch i ldbirth ) was cal led sopitis. From another writer we learn that caca lia was the Dardanian name for Mercurialis tomentosa ('hai ry' Mercury) ; this also occurs as a personal name on an i m perial rescript issued at Viminacium on the Danube in AD 294. The recorded na mes of Dard anian leaders during the Macedonian and Roman wars, Longarus, Bato and Monunius, whose daughter Etuta was married to the IIIyrian king Gentius, arc all Illyrian. Native names on Roman tombstones of the second to third centuries are unevenl y distributed in Dardanian territory, with several areas enti rely devoid of evidence. llIyrian names in Dardanian territory inclu de Andio, Andinus, Ann us, Anna, Catulla (?), Cinna, Citto, Dasius (four exa mples)lDassius (seven examples) , Dicco, Epicadus, Epicaris, Messius/Messa, Plannius, Scerviaedus, Tataffatta, Times (three examples), Tur ranis, Turelius (two examples) , Vanno (two exa mples ) , Varanus
I�
Dardanian names: Mocs}' 1974, Papazoglu 1978. Also Mirdita 1981,
Petrova 1 983-4.
(two examples), Varallilla alld Varidill'i. Thl" Th"'ll'i;lll ll;lI111·S include: AlIllIporis, AlIlllZOIl, Bithlls (three l'xampks), CclslIs (two e xa m p l e s ) , Celsinus, Cocaills, Daizo, (killS, Dida, Dinl'n
t i l l a, Dizas, Dizo (two examples), Dolens, Ept;likcllthos, Ettcla, Mania, Murco (th re e examples)/Moca, Mucatralis, ivluc;ltus, Teres (th ree examples), Torcula and Tzitzis. In the matter of d istribution the Thra ci an names arc found ma in l y in eas tern Dardan i a, from S c u p i to Naissus (Nis) and Remesiana, although some IIIyrian na mes do occur. The latter are entirely dom inant i n the western areas, Pristina-Mitrovica (Kosovo ) and Prizren-Pec, while Thra cian names are absent. The m ea n i ng of this state of affairs has been variously inter preted, ran g i ng from notions of 'Thracianization' (in part) of an existing lllyrian popu lati on to the preci se opposi te. In fav ou r of the latt er may be the close cor re sp o n d e nce of Ill yria n names i n Dardania with those of the so u thern 'real ' lll yrian s to th ei r west, i n c l u d i ng the names of Dardanian rulers, Longarus, Bato, Mon u n i us and Etuta, and those on later epitaphs, Epicadus,
Scerviaedus, Tuta , Times and Cinna. Other Dardanian names arc linked with the central Dalmatian group as defined by R. K ati C i c , for example, Andius/Andia, Andinus, Annus/Anna, Dasi us and Pl annius. Yet this leaves a n um ber of Dardanian names with no parallel outside the area, in cl uding Ambia, Blicities, Bubita, Cocaius, Ettela, Maema, Mescena, Mesta, Momonia, Nanea ( four examples), Ninis, Pasades, Pi tta, Rom ma, Sausa and Utinadius. These make any neat apportion in g of the Dardanian onomastic material less pl au sibl e and suggests that t he Dardan ia ns are be tter regarded as a sepa rate onomastic provincc. The pro bl e m s are no less i n r egard to the p l a ce - n ames i n the re gi o n, where claims of Illyr i a n or Thrac i an origi ns have been similarly advanced . Out of a to t al of 20, only fou r , Naissus, Rcm csiana, Scupi and Margu s, are defin i tel y Thracian a n d eight Il l y ria n , Anausaro, Arri bantion, Drauda cu m , Gabulellm, Creven i , Scardlls, Sarnuntu m and Ulcinillm (?). The two groups arc distributcd in a pattern similar to the person al names, Th ra ci a n onl y in the east and IIIyrian main ly, but not en t i rel y , in the west. As modern s cholarsh i p bccomes morc sceptical of si mple theories of h ow ch a nge occurred in the remote pas t, so the homo geneities of p re historic and historic formations havc been
N./lII/I/,� 11/,,11.111.\
H7
I'l'vea lnl as L1 1 ..l' or il l u sory, The Idl',' of 11I;lJor ullll ifkrelll ia l l'd IwoPil-'i such a'i «l'II'i, I>;ll" iall'i, Thr.lCi,lIl'i alld IIlyrian'i slill l't'Ill;lill'i u'idul a'i a gcneral COIlCl'pt hut ;l\tl'lllpt'i to define more pl'l'l' iwl}, sllch group'i k;ld to l'tlllhl'i ioll alld disintegrationo This ,t;l\lO ot affairs has hecome Illore marked as Ilew methods and tedlllilJlIcs cllable archaeologists to pay greater attcntion to locally dcfinahle groups within thc increasing mass of material l'VidlolKCo In the case of the llIyrians the tcndency of modern histor ical and l i nguistic researches has bccn to define IIlyrians .Is a Ilame a pplicd by G reeks to a group of Indo-Europcan slwaking peoplcs in A l bania and Montenegro. To the north of I hesc were other peoples, dwelling between the Adri atic and the Drava val l ey, who spoke a l anguage akin to that of these 'rl";ll' IIlyrians, to whom the Illyrian name was applied, along w i th the Roman geograph ical tcrm llIyri cum in thc years pre cnling thc conquest, but who were generally identified as Ddm
groupso
Part 11 Greek Illyrians
•
4
Neighbours of the Greeks
Adriatic IIIyrians
During the reign of the emperor Antoninus Pius (AD 1 3 8-1 6 1 ), that h igh s ummer of the Roman Empire, a senior administrator, reti red from the imperial service , devoted his leisure to compos ing an account in Greek of Rome's rise to world empi re. The work was a rranged according to the di fferent nation s and peoples Rome had de fea t ed and incorporated, and one chapter, titled Illyrike, d ealt with Illyrians. Appianus of Alexandria was an adm ire r of the Roman Empire and he was most at e ase when recounting the wars and victories which led to its cre ation. Social and p ol i ti c a l themes he found generally less con genial or more difficult to record and his short section on Illyrians bears th is out . Nevertheless, the works of Appian are a valuable sourc e for the formative years of the Rom an Empire, though this status is due in part to their survival ne a rly intact while the works of better info r m ed historians h ave perished. The Illyrike opens with an a cco u nt of the lands and the origins of Illyrians: The Greeks cal l those peopl e lIlyrian wh o dwell beyond Macedoni a and Thrace, from Chaonia and Thesprotia to the river Danube. That is the length of the country, while i ts breadth is from Macedonia and the mountains of Thrace to Pannonia and the Adriatic and the foothills of the Alps. It is five days' journey in breadth and th irty across, say the Greeks. The Romans measured the country as above six thousand stades in l ength (7S0 Roman miles) and about twelve hundred stades (ISO Roman miles) in width. (lllyrike 1)
<)2.
(;"'I'/': 1111'''''''.\
They say that the c.:oUlllry was Ilallll'tl after IIIYl"lus, �()II of Poly phemus; for the Cyclops Polyphelllus and his wift' (;alall'a had dul'l' sons, Celtus, IIIyrius and G a l as , who a ll migrated from Sic.:ily and rule d over peop les named after them, Celts, lIIyrians and Galatians, This seems to me to he the most acceptable of the numerous myth ologies am ong the many peoples, IIIy ri u s had six so n s , Enchcleus, Autarieus, D a rdanus, Maedus, Taulas and Perrhaebus, also daught ers, Partho, Dao r th o, Dassaro, and others. From these sp ran g the Taulantii, the Perrhaebi, Enchelees, Autaries, Dardani, Pa rthe n i, 1)as saretii and the Daorsii. A u tarieus had a son Pannonius, or Paeon, an d the latter had sons, Scordiscus and Triballus, from whom also n at ion s be a ri ng si m i lar names originated. But these matters I shall set on onc side for those who study the distant past. (lll)'rike 2)
How th e name Illyrian c a m e to be a pplied to m any diffe re n t peopl e s, as indicated here by Appian and also hy si m i l ar a ccou n ts in th e works of other writers, is still debated . A widely a cce pt ed explanat i on is that II Iyrii was once no more than th e name of a single people known to ha v e oc c u pied a small and wel l defined part of the south Adriatic coast, around the Lake of ShkodCr astride the modern fronti e r between Albania and Yu goslav Montenegro. Appian's mythological ge n eal ogy of IIIyrians reflects the us e of the name as a generic term for di ffe ren t peoples within a reaso n a b ly well defined but much greater area, the western Balkans between the Middle Danube and the Adriatic. The key evidence for IIIyri ans as the na me of an individu al people i n the so uth comes in the Natural History of t h e Elder Pl iny, compo s ed in the m id dl e decades of the first century AD. This names ' ll lyri a n s properly so-called' (Illyrii proprie dieti) among the native communities in Roman Dalma tia (NH 3.144). Ev i de n tl y these were th e fi rst people of this area to become known to the Greeks, causing their name to be appli ed to other peoples with similar language and customs.' Ap p i an' s des criptio n of the Illyrian te r rito ri es records a s ou thern b ou n da ry with Chaonia an d Th e sprot i a , where ancient Epirus began south of the rive r Aous (Vijose). The country
I
Pajakowski 1980.
N,'/g"'lt I/In 0/ ,h,' ( .. "",�.,
ill1l111'diately to till' north, hetwlTn till' roast and the high I1HlIlIltains, was krlown to the dassil',ll (;reeks as IlIyris and was inhahited hy several peoples whose eponymous allcestors ,1!,pear in A p pia l l s IlIyrian gl'rll'alogy quoted a ho v e . The Taul antii desl:ended from Tall las dwelt in the M a t valley and in the hinterland of the Greek colony Epidamnlls, the later Dyrrhach "Ull (modern DlIrrcs) . Beh ind these dwelt the Encheleae around the upper Drin and Lake Ohrid, while in the m iddle and upper valley of th e river Genusus (Shkumbin ) dwelt the Parthini, d e sce n ded from Partho, daughter of IlIyrius. From th i s it has lll'l'Il inferred that if the first Greek contacts with a people railed I l I y ri ans took place when the latter dwel t around the Lake of Scodra, that is, north of the Taulan tii and Parthin i , thne m u st have occurred later a southward movcment o f IIIyr i'1I1 people i n to an area once inhabited hy Greek speakers. There may he some coincidence hetwcen this n otional IIIyrian '
l' x pansion with a so uth ward movcment of i ron-using peoples in the first millenium nc. 2 the sou thern Bal kans the tcrritorial definition of ancient pt'oples is no less di fficult than has proved to be the case with modern nation states formed out of the Ottoman Empire, and fo r similar reasons. In areas where a large proportion of the population was accustomed to scasonal movement i nnovation in thei r material culture derived mainly from their conta ct with itinerants, and notions of a frontier can often have little mcaning, either in political or material terms. This state of affairs is evident not only in thc vaguc descriptions of IIIyrian pcoples by Greck writers but even in the frontiers between Greeks and non-Grecks in that direction. Thus Herodotus (4.49), writing in Athens around thc middle of the fi fth century, seems to imply a greatcr II Iyria, extendi ng from Epirus to the Veneti and inland to the Serbian Morava (his Angros in the land of the Autariatae) . This acco unt fits fairly well with the onom astic evidence and may have heen based on the evidence of traders familiar with Illyrian territory. Yet the Greek world t'a r1 y In
1
Hammond 1 982a.
lJ4
(;'I'I'�' IIIY/'/tllls
as a wh ok knew Iiuk of th l'sl' 1 l 1O f l' rl'lllOtl' IlIyri;lI)s and frolll around the middle of till' fourth lTlltUry 1\( a Illud) narrowl'r definition appears to have prevailed. I The ea rlies t surviving accoun t of the IIlyrian peoples is to he found in the Periplus or Coastal Passage, a clockwise account of the sailor's route around the A d ria tic composed probably a round the middle of the fou rth ce n tu ry RC. The name and origin of its author are not known, although a mis ta k e n tra ditio n has attributed the work to Scylax of Caryanda, a famous m a ri ner who na vi ga ted the Indian Ocean and the river Indus on behalf of the Persian king Darius at the end of the sixth ce n tury. The Adriatic v o ya ge is described in 1 4 ch apte rs , start ing from southern Italy: 14 After L u ca nia t he p eop le of the J apyges extend as far as mount Orion, wh ic h lies in the Adriatic. The v oy a ge alon g the coast of J apy gia lasts six da y s and six night s. Then.' are in fact Greeks dwelling in Ja pygi a and the i r cities are Heraclea, Metapontum, Tarent u m and th e port Hydrumum on the coast within the Ionian or Adriatic sea . 15 Next a ft e r mount Orion and the ] a p y ges co m es the people of the Samnites, who extend from the Tyrrhenian sea to the Adri atic. The voy age along the Samnite country lasts two da y s and onc night . 16 After the Samnites comes the peo ple of the Umbri, where lies th e city of An c o na . This p eople worship s Diomede, as a result of the benefits r e ceiv e d from him , and they maintain a sh rine of Diomede . 'Ine voyage along Umbria lasts two days and one ni ght. 17 After the Umbrian peo ple come the T yrrheni: they cxwnd from the Tyrrhenian sea on the far s i de to the Adriatic. In their country lies the Greek city Spina and the river Spines, and the voyage upstream to the city is arou nd twenty stades . The j o urney from the city of Pisa to t h a t same place lasts three da ys. 18 Next after the Tyrrheni is the Celtic p eople, who were left behind from th e Celtic expedition and who occ upy a small terri t ory extending to the Adriatic. At this point comes the inne rmost recess of the Adriatic. 19 After the Celts come the people of the Veneti , in whose land is the river E ridan us. Here the passage lasts one day,
1
Cabanes 198 8a.
lO
Aiel'!' till' Vl'Ill'11 till' rlVl'!' I'll'!', Tills 11\,('1' !Iow, al,o 11110 till' 1'011111'> Fllxinlls, lal'in� in till' dll'l'l110n 01 Fgypl . Thl' n'aslal voyagl' .. Ion� Ihl' ISl1'ian 1'l'�ion la s ls ;1 day ,1I1d .1 ni�hl. 1..1 Aher till' I'lri is till' pl'opk 01 Ihe I.ihurni, In t he lerritory of th,lI Iwoplt' are thl' follo ...... ing (oastal citil's: I.ias, IthIssa, A t t ie ni tes ,
Ilyyrta, Ampsi, Osi, Petll'tae, H e m ion i I - Alos, Tarsatica, Sen ites , I >yyrta, l.opsi, Ortopdl't:le, Hegini]. Thl'sl' people are ruled by Wlll11l'l1 , who arc the wives of freeborn men, but they c o hab i t with their own slaves and with the men of the neigh bouring regio ns. Before thl' (oast lie islands, of which I can record the following names (for therl' arc many othe rs which have no name): the island Istris 310 statll's long and 120 stades wide, the Elektrides, and the Mentorides art' the large islands. Then comes the (river) Catarbates. The voyage along the coast of the Liburni lasts two days. l.l After the Li burni there come the lIlyrian people. The II Iyri i dwel l by the sea as fa r as Chaonia, which lies opposite Co rcyra, the island of Akinous, There is si tuated the Greek city cal led Heraclea, with a harbour. There dwell the Lotus-eaters, barbarian peoples with the names Hierastamnae, Bulini, and Hylli who are neighbours of the Hulini. Th is people tell that Hyllus the son of Hercules had his dwdling among them, They are a barbarian people occupying a
penin sula a little smaller than the Peloponnese, The Bulini are also an I I I yr i an peopl e. The voyage along the land of the Bulini as far as the river Nestu s takes one day, 23 The Nesti, A fte r the river Nestus the voyage follows a course aro und a bay which is called the Manius bay and which takes onc day. With i n the bay lie the i slands Proteriu s, Cratiae and Olynta. The distance between them is [?8 or 12] stades or less and they lie in the direction of Pharos and Issa. The former is now Pharos the Greek island and the latter Issa, on both of which there are Greek cities, Before one reaches the river Naron a broad s t r ip of land extends far into the sea. There is an i s land close to the coastal region named Melite, and another close to it is named Black Corcy ra, where the land extends out from the coast in a second promontory but the other faces in the direction of the river Naron. Corcyra lies twenty stades from Melite and eight from the mainla n d coast. 14 Manii . After the Nesti is the river Naron. The passage into the narrows of the river is unimpeded, Indeed triremes and cargo vessels sail as far as the trading settlement which lies upwards of eighty stades from the sea. The people living there a re the Man ii, who are by race Illyrians. Beyond, there is a huge lake, extending from the in land side of the
trading St'Uil-l11l'Ilt as far as tht' Autariatat', an IlIyrian Pt'opll-, In the lake is an island of onc h u ndrt' d and twcnty st,llb" that is t' spn' iall y favourable for agriculturt" The rivl'f Naro flows Oil out of this I,lkl', From the Naron to the river Arion is a day's voyagt', Then from the river A r io n (to the river Rhizon) the voyage is a half-day . There are the rocks of Cadmlls a nd Harmonia and a shrine no t far from the river Rhizon. From the river R hizon to Bouthoe is (a half-day voyage, as it is also to the Rhizon ) trading settlement. 25 Enchelei . The Enchclei are an IIIyrian people, who inh ab it the land after Rhizon. From Bouthoe to Epidamn us, a Greek city , the voyage takes a day and a n ight , by land three days. 26 Taulantii. The Taulantii are an IIIyrian people, in whos e land is the cit y Epidamnus. A river flows by the city, by name the Palamnus. Then from Epidamnus to Apollonia, a Greek city, the j o urne y on foot takes two days. Apollonia lies fifty stades from the sea and the river Aias flows by the city, From Apollonia to Amantia the distance is 320 stades . From Amantia more within the Ionian Gulf is the city Oricus. The j ou rney to the sea of Oricus is ei gh ty stades, of Amantia sixty. Bou nding all these on the south are the Atintanes, below Oricus a n d Chaonia as far a s Dodona. Around this area are the Ceraunia n mountains in Epirus , and nearby is a small island, named Sason. From there to Oricus the voyage is one thi rd of a day. 27 These arc the IIIyrian peoples , extendin g from the Bulini up to this point . The opening of the Ionian g ulf extends between the Ceraunian mountains and the Japygian peninsula. And to the city of Hydru ntu m from th e Ceraunian mountains the cro s sing is around five hundred stades. This is the entrance to the gulf, and that which lies within is called the Ionian gulf, There a re many h arbours in the Adriati c : the Adriatic and Ionian gulf are one and the samc.4
In this surviving version the Coastal Passage attributed to Scylax contains confusions, later interpolations and plain errors. Yet this first authentic account of the Adriatic lists the names of several IIlyrian peoples on the east coast down as far as the river Aous (Vijose). Their northern limit was the river Catarbates, beyond which dwelt the Liburni, Istri and (V)eneti who are not included among the IIIyrian peoples. From the 4 Scylacis Caryandel1sis Pe ripIus maris ad Utora habitata f.uropae et Asiae et Libyae, GGM vol. 1, pp. 15-96 (Greek text with Latin version),
lJ7
hasis of this donlllll'llI. alollg with illtOl'lIIatioll trolll other writl'rs. it is possihle to fl'l"Ollstrlll't a politicll geography of the l'astl'rIl Adriatic.: as it was knowll to the (;rcl' k world around the middle of the fourth century Ill. III a latl'r w or k of the same l·harac.:tl'r, the
Coastal Voyage (/'aiegesis) attributed to
Sl'YIllIHIS and c.:ompilcd at the cnd of the sec.:ond century BC, a
narrower definition of IIIyrians excludes the Bulini and Hylli to ma ke lIIyrian territory commence on the coast around Sibenik, Ilorth of Split, In the previous century the geographer Eratosth l'nl'S had moved the limit of the Illyrians northwards to the Neretva but excluded the Nestoi who dwelt around the river Nestos (Cetina). These definitions of Illyrians may have been academic until around 200 BC when Illyria meant the kingdom
on the south Adriatic. The later extension of lllyria/lllyricum to all the lands between Adriatic and Danube came only in the Roman era . .) Beginning in the south the first IIIyrians near the coast were
the Bylliones beyond the river Aous in the hinterland of Apol IOl1ia. Their hill-settlement developed later into the town of Byllis, at Gradisht on the right bank of the Aous. The identity and location of thc Atintani/Antintancs remain a problem. One recent solution is that there were in fact two groups of this name, the Atintanes in Epirus and the Illyrian Atintani in the region Germenike north of Elbasan. Another view locates Atin tancs among the hills on the right bank of the Aous i n the Mallakastra north of Tepelen and perhaps as far as the area of Skrapar. This places them in a key strategic situation on the route between the Adriatic and Thessaly via the Metsovo pass or to Macedonia via the Korce basin. Whether or not the commonwcalth (koinon) of thc Illyrian Bylliones attested after 232 BC belonged to these Atintanes, who according to Thucyd ides were connected with the Molossians, is not clear. Thcir chief settlement at Gradisht had acquired an urban character
by the middlc of the third century.6 The Taulantii werc a group who at various times dominated .� Anonymi rScymni Chii ut fertur] Orbis Descriptio, GGM vo!. 1 pp. 196-237 (on Adriatic, l i nes 369-443). 6 Atintani/es: Hammond 1967b, 1 9 89 (two peoples), Papazoglu 1970c (against division); Bylliones: N. Ceka 1984, 1987a, 1987b.
( ; ,." " /.: lII)'1i,/II.� m llch o f t h e p l a i n bet w een t h e A O I l 'i a n d t h e D r i l l . It w a 'i I l I yri a n Ta u l a n t i i from E p i d a l1l llll'i wh o m:n l p il'd t h e 'i itl' o f Apol lonia befo re th e arri va l o f th e C reek co l o n i s ts a ro l l n d (' 0 0 B C. Oncc thcy wcrc callcd i n by the Greek sett l e rs t o Sl'i Zl' Epidamnus, a fter they had been ejected hy the Lihu rni. A mo n g group s who may have belonged to the T aulantii, kno\\'n to Greeks for thcir m cthod of prepa ri n g mcad fro m h oncy, w e re the Ab r i , named by the sixth-century writer Hecataeus as neigh bours of the Chelidones, thc ' snai l -m en ', who may have lived on thcir n orthcrn borders to w ards the Mat o r Drin vaIJ eys . 7 Bchind the co a s t II1 y ri an s bordered the C haone s , the Ep i rote people of whom the Dexari or Dassaretae werc the mos t n orth erly and bor dcrcd thc Illyrian Enchelei , the 'eel-men ' , w h os e n a mc poin ts to a location near Lake Oh ri d . According to Polyb i u s (5 . 1 08 ) , the Dassaretae possessed several towns, though none has yet been defini tel y located, including Pclion, A nti patr ci a (probably Berat), Chrysondym, Ge no u s or Gerous and Creonion. Livy's reference to ' P iru s ta e of th e Dassareti' (45 .26) in t he s eco n d ce ntu ry BC may be an error of the manuscript: Pi rustae dwelt some way to the north in Bosnia and northcrn Montenegro and were a mong the last of the Illyrians to surrender to the R o m a ns . North of Dassareti s i n
the middle and upper valley of the Genusus w a s the territory of the Il \yrian Parthin i , likely to have been part of the Taulantii until they firs t appear as Roman allics l ate in the thi rd century BC.8 The region of Lake Lych n i ti s (Ohrid ) , which abounds in fish, l ies at a narrow p oint of the A driatic-Acgcan watcrshcd and th ro ugh it passcs not only thc main east-west route but also one between north and south . This was the territory of the Enchelei, whose rulers cla ime d descent from thc h ero Cadm us . S aid to h a v e come from Phoe n icia, h e arrived in G ree ce and,
after many adventures, founded and ruled over Thebes along w i th his wi fe Harmonia . Later thc y movcd to thc Enchclei, then at war with J I I y ri a n s, but who had received an oracle that 7 Hammond 1966. A bri and Chelidones: Hecataeus, FGrHist vol. 1, Fl OO- l ; Taulantian honey : Aristotle, On Marz!ellous Things Heard 22 ( Le!. vol . 1 4, p. 246) . H
Hammond 1 966, 1 96 7 b, 606-7.
N,';ghhf llll ... "l ,f,,' ( " ' I'I'�"
vid ory wo uld I ll' t1ll'i rs if t111'Y !"l'n' l ved ( :adl1l lls ;I s k i llg, A f ter ;\ S fo retold, ( : .. dl1ll l s alld l larll lonia r llled over thelll alld fOllu d cd t h e tOW II' ot HO llthoc ( Hu dv a ) and I .yrh llid u s (Ohrid ) . III t h e end king and q l l een wt.'re trans fo rmed hy l.l' I I S into d r a gons and rem o v ed to Elysilllll, w h i l e his son
t h i 'i had co 1 1 H .' a hollt
I l Iy rills or Polydorlls succeed ed to h i s t h ron e . The Periplus p l a n's the Enchelci on the coast north of the T au lantii and attrih lltes to them B o u th oe, on the coast near the Gulf of Koto r , w h i ch also figures in the Cadmus legend. If the Taulanti i l' x «.'nded north to the Mat valley the Enchelei may have con tl'Ol kd the l ow e r Drin and the plain around Shkoder. At this point the Periplus, as we h ave it, is muddled over the river N a ron, the modern Neretva, a nd the Arion, wh i ch must be the allcient D ri l on, the Al banian Drin. It seem s best in th is matter to fo l l ow the sol ution of M. Suic that the lake is in fact the La ke of Shkoder, i nto and out of which the Drin has flowed a t va rious times in its history. Accepting th is makes it possible to p l a ce the Autariatae beyond the l ake and north of the lower D rin, wh ich makes better sense than much further north in the
mountains around the upper Neretva. 'J Wi th the Enchelei on the lower Drin and the Black Drin up to the source at Ohrid, their northern neighbours will have heen the Autariatae, dwel l i ng beyond the mou ntains wh ich now divide northern Albania from Yugosl avia. What Greek sources tel l of this remote people amounts to h a rdly more than a necdote. Whether or not the Ardaei already occupied the coast between the Lake of Shkoder and the Neretva rema i ns in do u bt. The rise to power on the Adri ati c during the third cen tury of these neigh bours of the Autariatae will have involved the absorption of several smaller groups recorded for th at area, i ncluding the . Labeates, who appear to have retained their separate identity into the early Roman period. The Illyrian Manii dwelt on th e lower Neretva on the long narrow bay formed by the northwards-projecting peninsula Pcl j eSac, and n am�d Manius Bay after them. To their north the Nesti occupied the coast and hinterland around the Nestus (Cetina ). This region was later occupied by the Dclmatae but �
Katicic
1 977b,
Suic
1 95 3 , PapazogJu 1 96 3 , 1 9 7 8 , Martinovic 1 966.
1 00
thei r n a m e does n o t a p pea r 1 1 1 1 1 i I l h l' sl'(o l l d (l' l l l l I ry 1\( , Oppo s i te t h e Nesti O i l l h e m a i n l a n d w e re I h l' b rgl 'r D a l l l l a t i ;l I1 isl a nds, Mclite ( M l jct), Black C orc y r a ( Ko rt': u l a ) , w h i dl l i es dose to the tip of PcljcS a c, and then Pha ros ( H v a r) and [ s s a (Vis). In Crateia wc m a y discern the name B ratti a (Brat':) and i n Olunta that of Solentia (50Ita ) , which l ie nearer to t h e ma i nland opposite Split. If the river Catarbates which marks the so u th ern boundary of the Liburni is the Krk a , thc ancien t Ti tus, which flows in t o the Adri atic through Lake Pr oklj an near 5 ibenik, then on thc short stretch of coast betwecn t h a t and the Nestus (Cet ina ) arc to be l o cated some lesser llly ria n
groups, the Bul i n i , Hierastamnae and Hyll i, There seems to bc no connection between these and the Dclmatae l ater so domi nant in this region, nor is there yet any refercnce to Salon a a t the head of its great b a y or to Traguri um (Trogir ) and Epetiu m (Stob r ec) which were once possessions o f the Greek colony on Issa. The Hyll i take their name from Hyl lus, a mythical son of Heracles, and the n ame persisted into Roman times as that of the headland on the coast south of 5ibenik, the p eni n s u la Hyllica, a p lace connected also with the cult of the hero Diomede. The name of the Bulini may be recalled by Bulinia, a place somewhere in this area on the Peu ti n ge r Map, a late Roman road map which surviv es in a medieval copy discovered in the sixteenth century by Co n r ad Pell ti nger . There seems little doubt that these smaller Il I yr i an com m unities known individu ally in th e fourth century were later absorbed by the Delmatae. This is the case with the Caul ici , Mentores, Syopii and Hyth mi tae l i s ted i n the region by Hecataeus of Mi letus of the sixth century and with the Ismeni and Mentores n amed in the sccond c ent u ry BC by the Periegesis. lO The Liburni arc placed by Hecataeus on the inncrmost part of th e Adriatic gul f. In the Periplus they dwell on the northcast Adriatic between I I Iy r i a n s and lstri , where m uch of the coast is closed off from the inte rio r by the VeJebit mountains and screened by the islands of t h e Dalmatian archipelago. The Liburnian n a me seems to have passed into ge n e r al use from thc time when t hey dominated not only the enti r e Dal matian 10
Suit 1 95 5 . Hecataeus, FGrHist
vol . l ,
p. 20, F93-6.
I() I
\,'O;lst h u t C Vl' 1l f or " tillll' held ( :o rl y r.1 ( : 0 1' 1 1 1 ) f ro lll whil.'ll t lll'Y Wl'lT l' jl'\.'I l'l1 hy Corillthl;1I1 '>l' \ tl e r s ill till' l'ighth l:l'lltury , A I . i h ur ll i a ll m a r i t i llH' s u prl'llIacy , or thala sson;l l' Y , rl'l:alls a h i stor i cll tra d i t i oll fro m a t i m l' whl'n Pl'OP I l' S were poss i b l y
Li burnia i nto P i C l' 1H 1 1n and from I I I y ri a i n to Mcss a p i a a n d J apygi a , The ga r h l nl l i st o f p l a ces on the Li b u rn ian coast in thc Periplus h a s hl'l'n reco n structcd to n ame Ta rsatica (Trsat ncar Rijeka ), I .ops i ca (Sv J u raj ) , Scn ia ( Senj ) and Ortopula (Stinica), all in t h l' n o rthern part of h istorical Liburnia. The difficul ty here is t h a t this i nt erprctation necessitates the identification of the river Catarbatcs with the Zrmanj a (the ancient Tedan ius) north of Zadar, placing the southern limit of thc Liburni farther to t h e north than was evcr later the casc. Another, and more p l a u s i b le, rcconstruction lists Apsyrtae, the modern islands Cres and Mali Losin j in thc Kvarner, Alypsoi of the later Lopsica a m ong the northern Liburn i, and some of the major settlements on the pl a i n bchind Zadar, including Nedinum (Nadi n ) , Acn ona (Nin ) a n d Jader (Zadar) . In th at case thc Catarbates, l i terally the 'stecply-fall ing', is the Krka, which marked the bou ndary bctween Li burnians and Dalmatians in Hel lenistic and Roman times. Finally, a long-standing associ ation betwecn the head of the Adriatic and the amber tradc explains the namc Elcktrides (from elektron, the Greek word for am ber) fo r somc islands of the Kvarncr gul f, i ncluding eres, Krk and Mali Losinj . The Mentores named by Hccataeus and othcr writcrs may denote othcr islands, such as Rab (ancient Arba ) or Pag (Gissa). The reference to the Istrian pen insula as an island of around 40 by 1 5 miles is a not uncharacteristic error of the . Periplus. 1 1 For all its con fusions thc Periplus leaves no doubt that the i nland peoples between thc Adri atic and Sava were, if not al together unknown, at lcast not in regular contact with the Greek world of the fourth centu ry BC. A possible reference by Hecataeus to the Japodcs, who occupied the Lika plain behind the Vclebit, - 'Japygia a town in Italy and in JIIyria' - docs not alter th is picture. Aside from amber there may h ave been l I Ioving a c ro s s t h l' A d r i a t i c fro m c a s t t o Wl'st, from
1 1
Suic
1 955,
I f)!
( ; ,." " k III\'rI, /II�
l i tt l e to a l l ra d ( ; n'l' k s t o wa rds t i l l' I . i h l l rn i a l l s h orl' ( I f t h l' I I p pl' r
Ad riatic, l' Vl'1l i f W l' t rl'a t a s l' x a ��l' ra t i ( l l l t h l' rl' l l l a r k ( I f ;t "' i t i Zl'l 1 of cl assical A t h e n s tlu t sl'n d i n � a s h i p i nt o t h l' A d r i a t i c a t a l l was a n act o f madn ess. A n u n fa m i l i a r i ty w i t h the u pper A d r i a t i c is implied by the wide currency of the story that a branch of the Danube flowed into it, by which it w a s possible t o sa i l bctwccn the Black Sea and the Adriatic. Thc fa ble was somehow bound up with a similarity in name between th e Adriatic Istri and Ister, the Greek name for thc (lower) Danube, as they camc to know it from the di rection of thc Black Sea . Also connected with this was a bel ief th at there existcd an isthmus between the h ead of the Ad riatic and the Black Sea, repeatcd by Theo pompus, a h istorian of the fourth-century BC, from whom it was copied by the Coastal Voyage attributed to Scymnus of Chios, by which time the story had becomc cmbedded in myth s of the h eroes. This vcrsion actually has a branch of thc Danube cntcring the Adriatic. Th i s is the background to one version of the retu rn voyagc of the Argonauts, up the Danube and Sava to enter the Adriatic by the Po, which appears in thc poem o f the third-century Apol lonius of Rhodes. Absyrtus, the slaugh tered half-brother of Medea, was com m emoratcd by an island in the northern Adriatic, whilc another story has it that Olcin ium ( Vicini) on the coast of Montcncgro near the Lake of Sh koder was a foundation of the pursuing Colchians. 1 2 The fantastic story o f thc rcturn voyage o f the Argo ma y echo voyages by Greeks i n the remotc past, venturing far beyond the known limits of thei r world. That they shoul d return v i a the distant Adriatic m a y derive from the routc of a known trade link with Central Europc. A similar basis may bc suggcstcd for Herodotus' story (4. 3 2 ) of thc Hyperborean offerings : 'According to the Delians, certain sacrcd offerings wrapped up in wheat-straw comc from the Hyperboreans into Scythia, whence they are taken ovcr by the neigh bou ring pcoplcs in succession until they get as far wcst as the Adri atic; from therc thcy are sent south, and the first Grecks to rcceive
1 1 Beaumont 1 93 6 , KatiCic t 970, 1 976c, Hcca taeus, FGrHist F97 Uapygi a ) .
vul .
1 , p. 20,
N,'/ghhl ll l l ... I II ,h" ( ; "" ,h
101
t h t' m a re d l l' J ) o d o l l 'll'a I l S ' ( 0 1 I )Od O I l , I , t i l t' f a l l1 0 l l s O LH : k 0 1 Zl' l I S i l l I :. p i rll s ) , SOl l1l, t h i l lg o f t h l' I I l l'C h a l l l l's o f p rl' h i s t or i c t r.Hk i s n' v l',l l l'd h y t h t' m a l l l l l' r i l l w h I c h t h ese g i fts, vv h idl m a y h a v e ht'l'1l p i el'l's o f a m be r d esti l l t'd l o r t h e A po l l o o f Ddos, Wl' rl' pa ssed from onc gro u p to a n o t h e r o n thei r j o u rn e y . A no t h er v o y age o n this scale m a y l i e beh i nd th e story of the t rl'ach ero ll s Tro j a n A ntellor who trav elled to the Adri atic after t h e fa l l of Tro y , w h ere he i s sa id to have founded several towns. O n c t rad itio n con nects him with Black Corcyra (Korcula ) . A n other, a l ready c u rre nt i n the ti me of the fifth-cen tury drama t i st S op ho c les , tells of a descent of the (V)eneti fro m the (H)eneti of Asia Minor which was the background to y e t another tale that An te no r , who had led them to Thrace, then journeyed to t he head of the Adriatic and founded the town of Patavium (p a du a ). U
The cl assical Greeks had only to travel a short distance to north or th e northwest to find themselves in a l and that was remote and strange. Soon after the sailor turned north out o f the Gulf of Corinth a short voyage brou gh t h i m to the river Achelous, where the Greek wo rld ended . Beyond this the Greek com m un i ties of Acarnania and around the Ambracian gul f were outposts in a barbarian world. Futher north again Thesprotia was a remote land at the cnd of the world, and even the fa mou s oracle of Zeus at Dodona among the Molossians w a s not e asily accessible. Greek writers such as Th ucydides viewed the ' mainland' (epeiros) from the perspective of Corcyra with its Corinthian colony facing across the strait. For the educated Athenian, people of th i s land lived in the old primitive ways, though this view was also taken of the Aetolians who, though Greek, had not yet advanced to the civilized urban l i fe. Beyond Corcyra there were no city-states (po/eis) bur only tribes (ethne) , such as the belligerent Chaon i ans. Few comprehended their languages, they dwelt in un fortified villages, ate their food uncooked and knew l ittle of the vine. Though more accurate information must have become available over the centuries the
I.l
Katicic
1 988
(An tcnor),
1989
(Diomcdes).
1 04 m a n y lat e r w r i ters Sl'l' l l l c d l"I l I l t c n t t o pass on t h i s p o r t ra y a l h y Th ucydidcs, Fo r E p h or u s , wri t i n g i n t h e fo u rt h Cl' l l t ll ry 1\( , Acarnania was th e cnd of ( ; rl'CCl' i n th a t d i rcct i o ll . 1 4
A s wc have already seen, the Periplus sets the sout h c rn l i m i t of Illyrians around Apol lonia, whcrc Chaonia began, but offers no eth nic defini tion for scvcral groups between I I I yrians and Greeks, including Chaonians, Thesprotians, Cassopaean s and Molossians, Though Polybius' doubts as to whether the Aetoli ans werc really Greeks ( 1 8 , 1 , 5 ) may be di scarded as the partial view o f an upper-class Achacan towards a rival power, there docs appear to have been a consisten t tradition from the time of Homer that Greeks end cd with Acarnanians and barbarians bcgan with Thesproti ans. To Pl utarch , who camc from Chaeronea in Boeotia, Greeks living north of Acrocera unia (Cape Linguetta/Kep i Gjuhezes) wcre exiles. Nevertheless thcre does seem to be evidence that these pcoples of Epirus between Acharnania and Illyria spoke a l anguage akin to Greek, though this is contested by Al banians who would have them to be JI Iyrians. From th is point of view the use of Greek by these peoples by the middle of the fourth century must bc reckoned as an al ien official l anguage, employed by a king (3 70-3 68 BC) of thc Molossians for two decrees at Dodon a. Perhaps more tel l i ng in favour of their non-IIlyrian character is that well born Molossians were admitted to the m ajor ath letic festivals of Greeks, an i nvitation never extended to Illyrians, ' 5 Greeks
among Illyrians
The fuI J development of an iron-using material culture among IlIyrian peoples by the eigh th century BC coincides with the start of l asting contacts with the Aegean civilizations of archaic and classical Greece. The intensive use of iron ore and the mastery of iron-working techniques led to economic and social change. 'Ibe exchange of commodities between different groups increased in volume and was a catalyst in the formation of
14 1\
Cabanes 1 9 8 8 a . Ca banes 1 98 8a,
.H (Molossian decrees).
N" /gh 'lI IlIn 1 1/ ,1" , ( ; / I'I,h
t r i h a l � ro l l ps , w i t h a l l i l l lTl'a S I l l � l O I l Sl..' i o l l s m'ss o f col l ec t i v l' i d cl l t i t y u ml t- r i l l d i v i d u a l r u i ns . T h l' L l l l' r s t a �l'S o f t h i s nl l t LJ r c a rI..' m a r k cd by p r i n n' l y b ur i a l s w i t h r i l.. h gra v c goods. I n "
a d d i t i o l l t o t h e I t a l i a n con ncl.." t i ol l s i t h a s bccn suggested that t ra ccs o f a rch a i c Grcck i n fl ucncc ca n be seen in some of the o rn .1 I11 c n t , nota b l y in the wa rrior frieze on the from Vacc, I n the western and cen tral Balkans
famous situla the devel oped I ro n Age a mong the lIlyrians is still viewed principally through t h e contents of tu muli burials on the Glasinac pl atea u, wherc t h e persisting conservatism of II Iyrian burial traditions has long been recogni zed. The distinguish i ng objects of this culture are double-arched fi bulae, bracelets and iron weapons, notably swords, axes, sh ields, etc. A love of amber, for beads, necklaces and cha rms, was evidently common among the Illyrians and is often cited as a distinguish ing feature of their burial groups. The cli max of this culture is evident in rich burials of the sixth and fi fth centuries, when the princes and princesses of the warrior elites were buried clad in all their finery, with gold and sil ver belts and girdles, bracelets, spears, varieties of pottery, j ewellery, hairpins and pendants. A featurc of some of these burials i s the presence o f high-quality pottery, metal ware and jewellery of Greek origi n . In addi tion there are other obj ects of similar character which may be the work of Greek craftsmen b ut whose design and ornament suggcst that they were created speci fically for IIIyrian and othcr 'barbarian' tastes . Th i s group of objects h as been much discussed over thc yea rs. Some schol ars have a rgued that they are the work of Illyrian craftsmen imitating Greek fashions and from this notion has stem med the concept of a 'Greco-Illyrian' matcrial cul turc of the sixth to fi fth centuries nc. 1 6 The principal finds-spots o f Greek imports i n the IIIyrian territories include the following: Atenica (princely tombs of thc late sixth/early fifth centuries BC with Ionian glass, glass-paste and amber beads and an Attic plaquc depicting a wil d boar) ; Glasinac (South Italian archaic objects, bronze vessels, Ionian pottery, classical (proba bly Attic) metalwork, armour and 16
Mano-Zissi 1 973 , Popovic 1 975, Pa rovic-Pesi kan 1 9 85, 198 6 ,
( ; " " 'k 1 11"/,/, /11,,
o rn a l l l l'l l \ s ) ; N o v i I 'a /.a r ( I a r).:l' Lll" i l l' ot IT).:a l i a , ).:o l d a l l d s i l v er
jewel lery, hl'a d s , a n d A t l i ( pol l ny ) ; " a �a n i ( \v a r r i or W;l V l'S o f the late sixth t o e a rl y fi ft h Cl' l l \ u ry w i t h A r t i r pot t e r y , ( ; !"l'l'( ) T 1 l yrian hel mets a n d s i l ver jc\w l l c ry ) ; Lj u bo m i r ( v,'a r r i o r h u r i a l s with fi fth cent u ry Atti c pottery , p i n s a n d b roochcs ) ; M ra ll l o ra c ( bu r i a l s with silver belts and bracel ets with orna m e nt i n a Greek style, p ossibl y l a te sixth cen tury) ; Umeari ( burials w i th sil v er belts, pins, brooches, etc. w i th Greek o rn a m e nt ) ; Rahna (cemetery of a round 5 0 0 BC containing G re c o - Il l y ria n hel met) ; Bel a Crkva (burial with miniature pots im i tati n g Greek forms of the l ate fi fth century ) ; Sremska Mitrovica (' boat'-e �rri ngs and go ld neck l ace, possibly Ionian of aroun d 5 00 ne) ; Siroko (settlement remains w i th Greek pottery and jewel lery) ; Batinci (silver belts with Greek-style ornam ent) ; Tuzla (tombs with ' Greco-Illyrian' obje c ts, glass - p aste beads and pins) ; J osainicka Banj a ( Hellenistic pottery, including Megarian bowls, i n settlement) . Among the southern most l llyrian communities sev eral cemeteries have p roduce d some of the best-known evidence for this Greco-TIIyrian cul ture. Easily the most famous arc the burials at Trebeniste near Lake Ohrid, where the contents of p rincely burials have been much d iscussed s ince the first finds were m ade during the First World War, particularly th e gold face-masks and sandals. Greek i m p orts i n the tom bs, which con sist of relatively modest burials of around the mid - si x th century, princ e ly burials of the earl y fifth century and some later b u rials, incl u de Ionian and other bronze tripo d s , b ronze crater, h ydria , a candelabrum base, lekythoi, kylices, filigree jewel lery, silve r brooches, glass amphorae and m i n iat u re s . Other sites i n the same area incl ude Saraj, Brod near Bitolj (Greek p ottery or local imitation s in p oss i b l e seventh century Cori n thian form), Visoi near Bitolj (two g roups of bu r ials, Visoi I with Gree k p o ttery and j ewel l ery, Visoi 11 l ater crem ations with finds sim i l a r to Trebeniste) ; Radol iste near Lake Ohrid (tombs w i th Gree k i m p o rt s of late si xth or early fi fth cent u ry, pins, brooches, bronze vessels, earrings and Greco Illyrian hel met dated to the second half of the sixth century ) ; Karaorman i n Paeonia near S tip (six tombs with Greek painted pottery and j ewellery , with a Greek coin of around 4 8 0 BC) ; Treben i sko Kale (tombs dated to the fo u rth to se c ond centuries
1 111
w i l h pOI l l' r y i l l I k l l l' l l i s l i l' t O rl l l S ,1 1 1 1 1 I " wl' l I l' 1" Y ) ; a l l d I k l l l i r i( ;l p i j a , a I O I l � l's l ;l h l i s h nl sl' l I k l l l l' l l l O i l I I I l' V a rd a r sOl l l h o t S l o h i i l l P a l'o l l i a a l 1 I 1 1' l' l I l ra l l l'l' 1 0 1 l 1 1' �or�l' ( ; rl'l' k pot t e ry o f t i h h 10 tO l l rl h Cl' nt ur y i n Sl'I I l l' n l l' l I l o t Macedo n i a n s a n d
( ; n'l'k s ) . 1 "
Hy w h a l m e a n s a n d by wh a t ro u tes these G reek ohj ects ca m e 1 0 l i e a m ong t he treasuries of l I I y r i a n tombs remains l a rge ly a 1 1 I ;l I l e r o f specu l a tion. It m ay be that for a p e r i od an o v e rl a nd I ra n si t e x i s te d from the di r ec ti o n of A sia Minor and th e Bl ack Sl';I , an d it has been su gge s te d that Herodotus' acco u n t o f th e Da n ll be basi n may h ave been b a s ed on i n form ation of Ion i an I ra d e rs s ta rt i n g inland from I st r os near the Danube d e lt a . Another matter of debate h as be e n the extent of c o m merc i al i d i n k s befo re th e e n d of the fifth century from the d i rection o f 1 1l l' Adriatic a n d southern Italy , C er t ainl y th e re ce p tion o f ( ; reek p restige go o d s b y the T I I y ri a n elite a p p e a r s confined to I h e s i xth and fi fth centuries, m a i nl y from the second h a l f o f 1 Il l' fo r m e r a n d from the early years o f t h e l a tte r After the m i d d l e o f the fi fth cen tury Greek i m p orts a rc, with a few l' x ceptions, absent fro m I1 \yrian tombs, and on l y the Gl asi nac tu lll u l i fu rn i s h evidence for a con ti n ui ng reception of Greek i m ports. Hellenistic pr o d u c ts of the fourth to s e cond centu ri e s .lrl: con fi ne d m a i n ly to regions b ord e ring Macedon i a , and th e r e i s a l m o st nothing from a r ea s fu rth e r n or th The brief duration o f t h i s Greco-IlIyrian con n e cti o n m a y be ex p la i n e d by t w o fa ctors, a col l apse o f th e power of native ru lers a m on g th e I l Iyrians a n d the s h i fting balance of pol i tical powe r i n Greece. T h e fact that a significant p ropo rtion of the i m ports ha ve a n Attic or Ion ian origin sugges ts th at t h e cessation of commerce w i th the lI I yri ans was li nked with a decline in Athen ian power a fter th e middle of the fifth century and the l a ter outbreak of the Pel o p onnesian War with S par ta a n d h e r allies . In a l ate r period the mai n d irection of Greek p e netra ti on w a s from the d i re cti on of the Adri ati c and southern Italy. 1 8 .
,
1 7 Parovic-l'dikan 1 964; Tr�heniste : Fi lm... 1 927, VlIlic 1 93 3 , Popovic l 95 6 , Lahtov 1 95 5 ; Novi Paza r : Mano-Zissi a n d l'opovic l 9 6 9 . I H I .isicar 1 973 , Batovic 1 9 84 ( Corinrhian pottery) , P� tric 1 980 (Aplllian imports), Glogovic 1 979 (5. Italian i n I stria), Mano 1 976b, 1 9 8 6 {trade ·
I OX If one Ill a y ao.:ept t h i s rl" ,:O l 1 s t r m: t i o l 1 t h e re H' I I l ;l i l l '> t h e p ro b
lem of what is t e r llled the ' ( ; rel:o - I l l y r i a l l nd t u re ' . Severa l t y pes of object which occur i n si m i l a r wlltexts to t h ose o f t h l' G reek imports listed above have been classi fied e i th e r as Greek p ro d ucts created specifically for an IIlyrian taste or a s t h e p rod ucts of Illyrian workshops working in close imitation of Greek model s. Perhaps the most ·discussed example is the open -faced bronze 'Greco-Illyrian' h elmet. Dated to the late sixth and fifth centuries, these have been found down the Adriatic coast as far as Al bania and i n the Ohrid region. Their origin has been sought in an early Peloponnesian, probably Corinthian, type recorded at Olympia and dated to 700-640 BC. A hel met from Canosa in southern Italy has suggested to some that the traffic in these helmets may have been l i n ked with th is area. It seems unlikely this very distinctive helmet was a l ocal prod uct of scattered workshops but, as seems to be i ndicated by its distri bution, was a type produced specifically for the northern war riors and possibly may be related to somc form of merccnary service by Illyrians. The same uncertainty persists regarding the few isolatcd finds of early Greek objects from the western Balkans, such as bronze running figures from Prizren and from Albania, a macnad from Tetovo on the upper Vardar and the finc bronze-working smith, probably Peloponnesian work, from Vran iste near Bela Palanka in Serbia, all of which arc dated to the same era of prestigious i mports, the late sixth and early fifth centuries. t 9 Several other varieties of jewell ery and ornament are thought likely to be local production in imitation of Grcck models, notably double 'omega'-pins, arched brooches and silver brace lets with snake's head terminals. These were pl aced alongside Greek imports in princely burials and are generally identified from an i n feriority in production technique, notably in thc large variety of obj ects at Trebeniste; but they are also found rou tes in S. lIIyria), Parovic-Pesikan 1 98 5-6 (pottery i mports in Bosnia), Vuckovic-Todorovic 1973 (E. Yugoslavia), Bousquet 1974 (Tetovo epitaph), Parovi c-PeSi kan 1 978 (sixth century inscription at Liplj an). l � Greco-lIlyrian hel mets : Marovic 1 9 76b, Vasic 1 9 8 2-1 , Andreou 1 9 8 5 , Os mani 1 98 8 ; weapons: Vasic 1 9 82a, Parovic-PeSikan 1 98 2 (Greek mach ai ra), Vasic 1 98 3 (bronze vessels), Vasi liev 1 9 8 3 (transport of bronzes).
Nt '/gh/Jo/l /'.- "I ,h,' ( ; " " ,h
1 0 l)
l a t l' r i l l t he l a rge l'l' l l l l' t lT Y a t I \ l Id v , l 0 1 1 1 I l l' A d r i ;l I i l' a ll d a m o l l g t h l' .I a pmks a t K O l l l po l j e i l l t i ll' I . i k .t , I t l I I a y wl' l I hl' t h a t thl' go l d lII a s k s , ga l l l 1 l il' t a n d sa n d a l s i l l Trl'lK' n i s t l', a n d t h e gold and s il ver a nd s il ver belt a ppl ilJ lIl's w i th repo ussc o r n a m e n t i n d l l d i ng G reek moti fs s u c h a s p a l m et tes, a rc loca l , i f Greek i nsp i red crea tions for 1I 1yrian t aste, What appears to have been a s llccess fu l s y m hiosis in material culture between Greeks and the III y r i a n rulers can be comparcd with a similar relationship a l ready i dentified for thc same period in other areas of Europe, n o ta bly thc Celtic northwest, which bordered the highly pro ducti vc Mediterranean cul tures of Greece and south Italy. Dis p l a y of exotic ornamcnt and gorgeous apparel will have served
to undt:rwritc the status of a n ative el i te, who controlled the sou rces of wealth, exportable raw materials including metal ores, t i m b er , hides and cereals along with slaves and mercenar i es, t hat brought such prestigious goods to a chief's stronghold and i n d u e course to his family burials in rcmote lIlyria. The pr eci o u s imports includcd fine dress ornaments and the utensils fo r banq uets and wine-drinking in the grand manner, m a n y o f wh i ch were desti ned for the oblivion of the tomb. How mu ch the IIIyrian princcs had in common with their co n temp o rarie s i n wcstern Europe is hard to j udge but their common taste for objects garishly ornamen ted i n the Greek style appears beyond doubt.·w Greeks were generally reluctant to risk life among lIIyrians and, with two notable exceptions, their settlements ca me late and never amounted to much . North of the Gulf of Corinth they appear to have made l i ttle i mp act on territories west of t h e Pindus. As one travels westwards across the mountainous spine of mainland Greece there arc marked changes in cl imate and vegetation : temperatures are generally lower and the winter rainfall is heavy and prolonged, forming real rivers with a permanent flow. Forests are more widespread and there is excellent pasturage . The movement of flocks revolves around the great seasonal festivals of St George (23 April) and St. Demetrius (23 October) . In this world meat and milk arc
20
Parovic-Pesikan
hinterla nd ) ,
1983
(Apulian
and
Etru scan
imports
to
Adriatic
1 10
( ; ,/,/,k 1 11 ",.,. 111 ...
i m po rtant for t h e d i e t . W O I l 1 l' 1 l h a v e ;\ l l 1 0 re s i gn i t i Gl I l t ro l l' than i n the w o r l d o f t h e d a ss i G1 1 lw/is fl l r t l l l' r ca s t , a l l d t h e extended family rema i n s t h e ba s i l: u n i t o f sOl:i l' t y . A t t h e pol i t i cal level there i s nothing t o (o l l l pare w i t h t h e d o sed all d integrated po/is but a looser and more di spersed federati o n o f groups belonging t o a si ngle tri be. Confron ted with th is s()(iety and its different ways Greek writers soon resort to l a bels such as 'brigan ds' or 'pi rates'. Even a fter centuries of relatively stable contact the Greeks took l i ttle account of changes which had occurred among these peoples, where even the urban settl e men ts that had grown up under their i n fluence still retai ned the character of mountain strongholds.21 If we omit such tales as the settl emen t of Oricu s on the Bay of Valon a by Euboeans fol low i ng the Trojan War, the first recorded advance by Greeks i n the direction of the I1 Iyria n s was m ade by Corinthian s. I n 733 BC Chersi crates, a member of the Ba cch i a d clan rul i ng a t Corinth, esta blished a settlemen t on Corcyra (Corfu ) that served as the principal staging-po i n t on the voyage between Greece and the west. Having ejected some Eretri ans fro m Euboea and some Libur nian s from the northern Adri a tic, the Corinthians soon pro spered . The next expansion of the Corinthian empire came a ro u n d a century later when a joi nt expedition from Corinth and Corcyra founded on th e I1 lyria n ma inlan d the colony Epi d a m n us on the headl a n d D yrrh ach i u m , the name by which the c i ty was l a ter known.22 A long with Apollon i a further south, the new settl e ment brought the short sea crossing to southern Italy under Greek control and was for centu ries a terminus of th e principal highway across the southern Balk ans, l a ter engineered by th e Romans as th e Vi a Egna ti a . These settlements will a l so h a v e secured con t rol of th at rou te to the interior and access to th e sil ver deposits of the region . The foundation myth of the col ony is offered by the historian Appian as a digression from the Roman civil war between Pompey and Caesar in 48 BC
21 12
Cabanes 1 9 8 8 a .
Hamll10nd 1 982b,
(currency ) .
Myrto
1 98 6 , N . Ceka 1972, ]976, Petrova
1980
I I I
I > y rr h a dl l l l l l l s O l l l e Iwhl' v l' 1 0 Ill' r l u' S , I I I I I ' , 1 \ I -'. p l d ,I I 1 1 I 1l I S , O i l a �'(O I l I I l of I h l' f o l l o w i l l g n r o r . i\ ha r h , l I ' I ; 1 1 I k l l l g 0 1 r ill' reg i o l l , h y l l a l l l C I :. p i d a ll l l l l l s , h u i l l a ( i l y 0 1 1 I hl'
(O,lsl
, l I ld 1 l .1 I 1 1 �·d 1 1 a fr n h i l l l se l f.
I >y rr h a d l l l s , r ill' S O i l o f h i s d a u g h l n ,l I l d , ;I S i l w a s b d i l'\'' l' d , o f I 'os c i d o l l , a d ded a h a r b o u r to I h l' c i l Y w h i c h Ill' I l a med lJyrrhach i u m , W h l' l l D y r r h ;l l' h w. w a s attackl'll b y h i s h ro t h c rs, Heracies, retu rn ing
fmlll E ry t h ral' ( w h l'nu' he had ca rried o ff the oxen of k i n g Geryon) l I I a d l' an a l l i a n cl' w i t h h i m in return fo r a share o f his territory. From
I h i s t h e citi zl'llS of Dy rrh a ch i u m
cl a i m
Herades as onc of the ir
fOll lldns beca u se he had a s ha re of their l and, n ot dishonou ring I >y rrhach u s b u t because th ey took even greater pride in Heracles as
m i st a k e n ly killed l on i us , the son of Dyrrhachus, and, hav i n g r ai se d a burial mound,
bl'ing a god . They say tha t in a battle Hera d es
t h rew the body i n to the sea s o that i t wo u l d be named a fte r him, In J a tl'r period t he Bryges, retu rning from Ph rygi a, se i zed the ci t y a n d
a
s u r rou n d i ng t e rri t o r y , th en th e Ta ulantii, an JI I y r i a n peop le , took i t from them a n d th e Liburni, another JII y ria n people, took i t from the la u l.1 nti i . They w e re in the h abit of ma ki ng plundering exped itions a ga i n st th eir ne i gh bo u rs i n v e r y fast s h i p s . And beca use th ese were I he fi rs t the Rom ans c ame up against they bestow the name L i b u r nae Oil very fast ships. Tho s e expell ed from D y rrh ac h iu m by the Lib u rn i
a n s obtai ned help from the C orcy ra e a ns then masters of the sea a n d d rove o u t the Li burn i . The Corc yra e ans mix e d in t h ei r own settlers with them and for this reason it came to be regard ed as a Greek port. But bel ieving it s name to be ill-sta rred , the Corcyraeans c h a nged the name an d called i t Epidamnus from the upper city, and Th ucydi dl's a l so c al ls it by that name, b u t in the en d the old n a me t r i u m p hed and it is now ca ll ed Dyrrhachium. ( Civil War 2 3 9 )
The Illyrian el ement in the Greek colony appears to b e borne out by the con tents of early cemeteries, in wh ich Corinthian grave-pottery of the seventh and sixth centuries is found along s i de cremation urns of the local type. The successive rule of Taulantii and Liburni in the historical tradition may represent the southward movement of Illyrian peoples during the early I ron Age from around 1 000 BC into the area known as IIlyris. The presence of Bryges at Epidamnus in the account of Appian seems to be confirmed by other sources, including the Coastal Voyage attributed to Scymnus of Chios and Strabo's Geogra phy. No l ater record of their presence in th e area survives and nor can any link be established with the Bryges of Thrace, supposedly descended from the soldiers of Xerxes' army, who
I II
a ppea r fo ur n' n t l l r i l's l a t l' !" I n t h l' a r m y o t M , B r t l t l l s d ur i n g
the P h i l i p p i
ca m p a i gn , T h l' sl' t t l l' l I l l' n t a t E p i d a m n l l s hl'C\ m l' a flo u ri sh i ng cen trc fo r COJ\ l I \ W rt.T a n d rcm a i n s tod a y t he p r i n c i pal port (Durres) for the reg i o n , We l ea rn t h a t i t s con sti t u t i o n was o l i garchic and th at many of the inh a b i t a n t s w e r e n o t citize n s , By the sixth cen tury the city h ad erected i ts o w n treasury for dedications at Olymp i a . Thucydides' a cco u n t of
the internal conflicts (stasis) d u ring th e 43 0s BC makes clea r that this was not the first trouble of thi s kind in the col ony. In the st r uggle for power betwee n democrats and aristocrats, the latter supported by Corcyra , the Taulantii con tinued to play a major role in t h e affairs of the city. Wh e n the dem ocra ts gained the upper hand their opponents turned for h elp to the IIIyr i ans, They app eared in strength to besiege the city in 435, in the proccss cau si ng m uch damagc to the city' s econ o my thro u gh their occupat i o n of the surrounding cou n try. H The se cond Greek settlement on thc lIlyrian mainland was Apollonia, traditional ly found ed in 5 8 8 BC on a headland over looking the mo u th of the river Ao u s (Vijose) , ten st ade s from the r i ve r and 5 0 from the sea, It lay d ose to the frontier b etwc e n lllyr i s and Epirus and may have been established to make secure the form e r' s control o f that area, Around 600 RC Corin th is sai d to h ave re s ponded to an lllyrian invitation and contributed 200 settl ers to an alre ady e x i s tin g trading post. Others, especially from Corcyra, fol l owed these. The colony w a s said to have been named Gyl aceia aftcr its founder the Corinthian Gylax, but l ater took thc name from A poll o . For severa l ccnturies Greek and IlIyrian communities appear to have m ainta i ned a separate existence. That is the impre ss ion from cemete r ie s with contents that are quite differcnt, one with imported pottery, the other e x h ibiting the older tradi tion of b u r i al mounds and the rite of i n h umation. Apollonia's pros per i ty during the sixth and fifth centurie s BC was based on herds, well nourished i n the surro u n d ing pastures. The excepl.l Anamali 1 970, Bakhuizen 1 9 8 6 ; cemeteries : Dhima 1 985a, Myrto 1 98 4, Ta tari 1 9 8 7, Hidri 1 9 83 ; pottery production : H idri 1 986, 1 9 8 8 , Tatari 1 9 77-8 (local), D'Andrea 1 98 6 (export ) ; also Ta tari 1 98 5 (building construction), 1 98 8 (Hellenistic house), Zeqo 1 98 6 (stone and terracotta
figures).
I I I l i o n a l r i c h n l'ss o f A po l l o n i a n I n l'l I or y s l I sl a i l 1 l'd a n ot a h l y n a r row o l iga rch i c H'gi m e , deslTi hl'l1 h y A r i s l o t k, w h o cou l d d i s COVl'r n o t ra ce o f d e m ocracy i n a c i t y w h l' re a m i nori ty o f freemcn cont ro l l ed a m a j o r i t y t h a t were n o t free born , The p ri v i l eged w e re e v i d en tl y descend a n t s of the original coloni st s w h i l e t h e i r s u b j ects w ere not c ap t u red or purchased slaves but r a t h e r the native population of the a rea with the sta tu s of serfs i nt egrated i n to the h i ghl y successful e conomy of thc city.24 Epidamnus and Apol l onia were for centuries the principal ports for tra ffic between G reece , the w estern Balkans and thc m i d d l e Danube. In thc H ellenistic period they were first stra tegi c bases fo r the military am bitions of kings of Epirus and M ace d onia and then, especially Apollonia , the principal ports of d isemba rca tion for Roman armies, Apollonia also acquired
a mong Romans the reputation of a centre of higher l earning, a nd may h ave been the ori ginal terminus of the V ia Egnatia. ny the s e co nd and carly first centuries BC the coins of thc two cities were circ u lating w idely in the middle Danube basin, e v idently servi ng as a conven ien t silver currency for merchants and s l ave-traders. Most of the rema i ns of Epida m nus/Dyrrhach ium lie beneath the modern city Durres, Albania ' s prin cipal port, testi fyi ng to i ts continued prosperi ty. Apollonia, by way of con trast, had lost i ts harbour as the course o f th e river altered , and thc ruins of the Hcl lenistic and Roman city sta nd forlo rn on the h i l l of Pojan i . N o Greek settlements are known to have becn established on the mainland north of Epidamnus/Dyrrhachi um. North of the river Drin neither coast nor hinterland invited perm anent settlement and, although Grccks un d o ubted l y lived and tr a ded in several pl aces, the th ree formally constituted colon ies were all on islands, Black Coreyra (Korcula) , Issa (Vis) an d Pharos (Hvar). On the oppositc coast the Po vallcy scttlcmcnts of Spi na and Adri a , wh i ch fl ourished during the fi fth and fourth centuries as the destinations of l ong - di s ta nc e sea trade from Phocaea and Aegina, acquired somet h in g of the ch aracter of 24
Bcau mont 1 952, Bl avatsky 1 966 (fou ndation ), °1 97 1 , Anamali 1 970, Bak 1 9 8 6 ; cemeteries: Mano l 976a, 1 977-8 , Korkuti 1 98 1 (pre-colonial tumul i ) , Nemeskeri a nd Dhima 1 9 8 8 (racial mixture in cemetery), Bereti 1 977-8 , 1 9 8 8 (Triport occupation), Vreka 1 9 8 8 (Hellen istic black-glaze) , huizen
1 14
i.:o l o n i a l Sl' t t k l l l l' l l t s . I I I I l l a l l' r i ;l l I l' r l l l S t h e l"O I l l I l l l' IU' IWI WCl' I l
Greei.:e a n d t h e u pp e r A d r i a t i l" w a s t h e p ro l: u r l' l l l l' l I t o t sa l t , corn a n d cattle, fo r w h i dl t h e ( ; rl'l' k s o ffl'red "v i ne, pottery a n d metal wares.25 Early in the sixth cen tury settlers from Cn i d us i n A s i a M i nor settled on the Dal m atian islan d. Black Corcyra ( Korcul a ) , so named from its dense vegetation to disti nguish it from its la rger namesake further sou th . Thc citizens of thc latter assistcd th e venture after the Cn idians had rescucd 300 boys from thc hosti l e Periander, tyrant of Corinth . The settlers n a med thcir colony after the land of thcir benefactors. The sitc of th e settlcment has not been located but lay either in the west or in the n orthcast at the narrow passage with the pcninsula Pcljdac, wherc the modcrn city Korcula enjoys two excellent harbours. Somc coi n s with a Corcyraean legend may b el o ng to the settlc men t but the venturc appears to have failcd, and the island i s known to ha vc received at least onc other ncw settlement, pro b ab l y in the th ird ccntury BC. Native IIIyrians do not figu re in the story of thc colony on Bl ack Corcyra but they are certainly promincnt i n the carly h istory of the colony settl ed in 3 8 5 BC on thc island Pha ros (Hvar) from the Aegean island Paros, famcd for its marble. In tradition a l fashion they acccpted the guidancc of an oracle, but thc settlers reccived more tangible assistance from Dionysius, thc a m b i ti ous ruler o f Syracuse, who had around thc same timc cngineered an Illyrian attack on thc Molossians in Epirus. The account of Diodorus says that h e h a d a l ready sent a colony to the Adri atic a n d fou n ded 'the city na med Lissus' . The Pari a n s on Ph aros were soon in d ifficul ties with the n atives and needed help from the tyrant. Th i s year the Pari ans who had settled on Pha ros allowed the prev i ous b a rb a r i a n i n h a biLants to remain u n h a rmed in a wdl fortified place,
wh ile they themsel ves b u il t th ci r city by thc sea and encl osed it with
a
w a l l . Later the earlier i nha bitants took offence at the presence of the Greeks and called in the l I I y rians dwel l i ng on the mainland opposite. These crossed to Pha ros in a l a rge n umber of small boats and, m ore than ten thousand strong, killed many G reeks and did
2S
Nikolam.:i 1 97601, Braccesi of Syracllse).
(Oion y s i ll s
1 977,
Bakhu izcn
1 9 87,
Woodhead
1 970
N" lg/'/'"II I ' 1 1/ I I I l I d l d . " " ; I gl' , I l o w l' V l' I' I > I O l l �' � I I ' "
'''I' ( " I'I'�"
I I�
l C l l l l l I l . 1 l 1 d l'l .1 1 1 1 " 1 , , , . " led l i p
w i l h a I . I l'gl' 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 11(' 1' o f t l' l IT l l ll'� . l g. I I I I ' t t h l' I I l y n .1 1 l I l g h l ( r a i l ;l l l d ,
h ;l V l l lg ' 1 1 I l k " l l l l l' ;l l l d Cl p l l l rl'd o l h l T � , k d l n l l l Hl l'l' I h a l l f i v l' I h o l l s a l l d o f I hl' ha rh;I I'I ;II1S .l I I d l o o k ;l ro l l l l l l t w o t l lO l I '; J l l d p r i s o l l l' r . ( l >iotiol'lls 1 ), 1 4)
The t h i rd G reek colony k n O \\' n i n th i s central sector of the I h l l1 l a ti a n coa st was Issa on the north si de o f the island Vis. N o t h i n g is recorded o f its found ation , but coins and internal
orga n i za tion ( recorded on inscripti ons) suggest that it was a Sy raclI s a n settl ement. It has been p roposed th at it was this p l a ce and not L issus far to the south at the mouth of the Drin from ..vhich help came to the Greeks on Pharos, since Issa l ies on l y 25 miles away. The voyage from Lissus was more than t e n ti mes as long, but a garrison at the latter would fit better with Dionysius' schemes involving Illyrians and Molossians. A more sta ble relation sh i p with native l I Iyrians is implied by the decree recordi ng the details of a settlement from Issa on Black Corcyra. On the document, wh ich has been dated to the third century BC, arc named the Illyrians Pul l us and Dazus, w h i l e most of the text specifies the allotment of lands t o individual fa milies, both within and without the walls of the settlement, grouped by the tradi tion al Dorian 'tribes' of Dymanes, Hylleis and Pamphylo i . 2(, A handful of inscriptions and some locally struck coins with a l i m i ted circulation testify to a survival of the Greek settle ments on Pharos a n d Issa, though only the latter appears to have maintained its independence until the Romans appeared i n 229 B C . Pharos was subject to the IIIyrian dynasty of Agron, albeit under the rule of the native Demetrius of Pharos. The site of the colony was Starigrad, a sheltered harbour in the northeast of the island. The near square enclosure of the wal ls lies beneath the modern town, close to the fertile plain of Jelsa . 26 D . Rendic-Mioccvic
1980
(Corcyra Nigra ) , Cambi, Kirigi n and M arin
1 9 8 1 , Kirigin and M a rin 1 98 5 ( Issa necropolis), Zaninovic l 97 8 , 1 9 84b
(hill -forts o n Hvar), 1 98 0- 1 ( l a n d division o n Hvar), Sl apsak 1 9 8 8 , S t anC i c and Sl apsak 1 98 8 , Bintl i ff and Gaffncy 1 98 8 ( l a n d division and su rvey on Hvar), K irigin and Popovic 1 9 8 8 ( G reek '.... atchtowcr), Migotti 1 9 8 6 ( Hellenistic pottery in Hvar), Margetic 1 9 7 1 , D . Rendic-Miocevic 1 970a
(col ony of Issa on Korcu l a ) ,
I 1 (' Th i s h a d hel'll on:up i cd d i v i ded i n t o a rec t a ngu l a r gr i d o f roa d s and p ath s a t t h e t i m e o f t h e ori g i lu l col o n i z a t i o n , a n d i t m a y h ave been th i s w h i c h ca u sed t h e i n i t i a l ;Kco m lllod a t i o n w i t h the II Iyrians to decline in t o h osti l i ty . Thc nca r rectangu l a r walled area o f Issa containe d a p l a n n ed city with p a ra l l el stre ets . Recent di s coveries here i nc l u d e a rem a rk able series o f burials da ti ng to the Hellenistic period, containing Greek p o t tery a nd with some of the inscribed tombstones still in th ei r
original positions. A round thi s period, the first h a l f of the second century BC, Issa appears to have pro sp ered under Roman influence an d posses s ed at l east two settlements o n the nearby mainland, at Tra guri um ( Tr ogir ) and Epetium (Stobrec) , both of wh ich have produced Greek re m ains. When these place s were th reatened by the l oca l Delmatae it was Issa's app ea l to R o me which brough t the first con frontation between the l a tte r and this p o werfu l p e o p l e. The s urv iv al of Issa and Ph aros was owed to their own resources. Perha p s Issa may h ave gained some p ro fi t from l ong-distance commerce, th ough more as a port of call than a s a centre for trad in g with the natives of the m a i nl and.27 Tho u gh far fr om their Greek o ri gin s the two col onies maintained links with their homeland, Ph ar o s on o n e o cca s i on a p p eal i n g to its metro p o lis for ' rep ai r a n d s u pport' . Nevertheless, an i mpression of i s ol ati on a n d gr ad u a l decline is suggested by Pl i n y's reference to 'the fading memory of many Greek town s a nd strong cities' (N H 3 . 1 44) in IIlyria.
27 Nikolanci 1 968-9 (Corinthian pottery on lssa) , 1 9 76a, 1 976b (Asia Minor imports), 1 9 8 0 (inscription ), D. Rendic-Mioccvic 1 970b, 1 976 b (coinage).
5
Enemies of Macedonia
Conquering kings: Philip, Alexander and Pyrrhus 1
I l I yrians first appear in the record of Greek a ffai rs not long hefore the Peace of Nicias ended the first phase of the Pelopon ncsi an War in 42 1 BC. Before Athens suffered defeat at Delium in 424 BC, Sparta had sent an expedition under Brasidas to assist King Perdiccas of Macedonia and other opponents of Athens. At first the Spartans avoided involvement in Macedon's war with Arrha baeus the son of Bromerus, rul er of Lyncus ( Lyncestis), but in 423 they joined an expedition which ended with ignominious retreat by the Macedonians and a bri l l iantly contrived escape of the Spartans. After an i nitial success against Arrh abaeus, Perdiccas persuaded his all ies to await thc arrival of IIIyrian mercenaries. The latter opted instead to join the army of Arrhabaeus and, as the historian Th ucydides observes, 'the fear inspired by their warl ike character made both parties now think it best to retreat.' When the Spartans fina l l y reached safety they proceeded to loot suppl ies from the Macedonian army, causing a rupture of the pact between the king and the Spartans. The historian attributes to the Spartan commander a morale-raising h arangue to his men, clearly shaken by the fea rsome appearance of a new enemy:
1
For accounts
of the fourth and
1 9 8 8 a , Hammond Ham mond and Wal bank 1 98 8 .
th i rd centuries, Cabanes
1 96 6 , Hammond and Gri ffith 1 979,
I IX t h e y Ill a y t n n f y d l l '''l' w l l h ;1 1 1 ; l l I I V l' 1 1 1 I ; l g l l I .1 I 10 1 l . d ll' )' . . .. l' f O l' l l l l d a h k i n o u t w a rd h u l k . dll'i r l o u d y cl i l l l � I .. l l l l hl'.l r.l h k .l l I d t i ll' b r; \ l I d i , h i l l �
o f thei r we a p o n s i n t h e ;\ i r h a s ; \ t h rea t e n i n g a p pea ra n c e . B u t w h e n i t comes to rea l figh t i n g w i t h a n oppone n t w h o s t a n d " h i" gro u n d they are not wh at th ey se(.'med ; thl'y h ave n o rl'gu tl r ord e r I h a t w o u l d m ake t h em ashamed of deserting their positions w h e n h a rd p ressed ; wit h them fligh t and attack a re equ ally h o n ourahle, and afford no test of cou rage; thci r i n d e p e nd e nt mode of fighting never leaving an y one who wants t o r u n a w a y withou t a fa i r excu se fo r so doi n g. (4 . 1 26)l
In the troubled reign of A m yn ta s III ( 3 93-3 70/3 6 9 BC) , father of Philip 11, a powerfu l and appa rently stable regime among the southern I ll y ri a n s first emerges. This marks the begi n n i n g of a succession o f w a r s which were t q end on l y wi th Rom a n in te r vention and the end of the Macedonian monarchy two centu ries l ater. The surviving a cco u n t s are both incomplete and in pl aces contra dictory, although the general cou rse of events seems clear. Diodorus the Sici l i an (c.30 nc) , who probably followed the fourth-century Greek writer Ephorus, d e s cri bes a catastrophic attack by IIIyrians in 3 93/2 BC A m y ntas the father of Philip was driven fro m h i s coun try hy l II yrians who a ttacked M acedo n i a . G ivi n g up hop(.' for his crown, he made a prcsen t to the people of O lyn th us of his terri to r y which bordered on theirs. For a time he lost his k i ngdom hut hc wa s soon rcsto red by thc Thessal ians, regaining his crown and ruling for twenty-four years , Some say th a t after the expu lsion of A m y n tas th e M acedon ians \.... ere r u led fo r two years by Arga c u s and that it was a fter this interval tha t Amyntas recovered the kingship. ( 1 4. 92, 3 )
D i odorus' a ccount of a near identical Illyrian raid ten years l ater is ge ne ra l l y taken to be an erroneous duplication but this i s fa r fro m defi nite. Ce rta inly it would not have been at all u ntypical of the Illyrians to repeat a raid and expl oit thei r victory in the same manner after an interval of a few years. Between the two i nva s i ons of M a ce do n i a , Illyri ans arc said to have l aunched an attack on Epirus in 3 84/5 BC. The instigator is said t o have been Dionysius of Syracuse, eager to interfere 1
Hammond
1 972, 1 04 -7.
"'/1/'/111/ ',\ 1 1/ " , , /, " . /"1110 1
I I 'J
i l l t h l' A d r i a l i l' , O i l I h i s ( l l' l' a S I O I I I I I ' 1 I l ' l 'orl 0 1 A kl' l i a s I h l' k i l l � o t I h l' M o l os s i a l l s . T I l l' S i l i I i , l I l I Y r,l I l 1 (.:0 1 1 1 ri hll l nl .woo l roops ,l I l d S OO Sl'ts o f a rl l 1 O l l f' , i l l w h i l..' h I h l' I I l y r i a l l s set a ho l l l t h l' J\t o l os s i a l l s i l l ha l t l l' .l l l d , il is d a i l l l l' d , k i l l ed more I h a l l I S , O( ) O , w i t h d r a w i ng o n l y w h c l l a S p a r t a n a rm y came to I h l' rl'SClIl' o f t h e Epi rotes. T h e e p i sode m a de plain the rise of I l I y r i a l l power 0 1 1 the n or t h w e s t fri nges of the Greek world, I h O l l gh w h e n they l a u nched a similar attack 25 years l ater t h e M o l oss i a n king H a rr ybas evacuated his non -combatant pop ll l a tion to Aeto l i a and gave the Iilyrians to understand that
t' " i kd
were open to them. The strategy worked and th e M o lossians fel l upon the Iilyrians l aden with booty, and robbed a l l d e x p e l l ed them. l In 3 70 BC t h e worthy Amyntas died fu l l o f years, h aving res to red the fortunes of his kingdom after lllyrian disasters. I l i s marriage to Eurydice of the Lyncestae had produced three SO i l S and a daughter. His eldest son su cceeded through el ection hut t h e rei gn of Alexan der, who was said to have bought off I he l I I yrians and del ivered his brother Philip to them as a hostage, was brief. During a ca mpaign in 3 6 8 or 3 6 7 he was m urdered by h i s kinsman Ptolemy who was h i mself suppressed i n 3 65 by the king's younger brother Perdiccas. The latter died early in 3 5 9 in a shattering defeat at the h ands of the IIIyri ans, not th e first occasion he had fought against them . More than 4000 Macedon ians were killed 'and the remai nder, panic stricken, havi ng become exceedingly afraid of Illyrian arm ies, had lost heart for con ti nui ng the war' ( D iod o ru s 1 6 . 2 , 8-9 ) . The scale o f this disaster may later h ave been exaggerated in order to magnify the achievement of Philip, b u t it seems that once again IIIyrians had brought Macedoni a close to collapse, when the kingdom was also threatened by Paeonians, Th raci ans, Chalcidi ans a n d Athenians.4 The Illyrian victory of Philip early in his reign was to prove decisive for the security of Macedonia in that quarter. Having struck a treaty with Athens late in 359 and dealt with the h i s l a nds
\ Hammond and G ri ffi th 1 979 , 1 7 2-5 (no dupl i cation), Di odo rus SiClllus 1 4 . 92 (3 93/2 tic) , 1 5 . 2 (3 8312 lie), 1 6 .2 (3 60/3 5 9 lIC) . 4 Justinus 7.5 (Alexa n der), Diodorus S iculus 1 6 .2, H a m m o n d and G riffith
1 9 79, 1 8 8 .
I.W
( ,' r," '/': III)'r",/s
Paeo n i a ns l';l r l y i l l t i l l' t o l l o W l l l g Y l';1 1' t h l' n l' W k i n g l'OI H :l' l l t ra t l,d
all h is pOWl' r a ga i l l s t t h l' I l l y r i a n s . W i t h 600 ca v a l r y a n d 1 0 ,000 i n fant r y h e a d v a n cl'd i nt o t h ei r tl' r r i to ry a n d n' j l'ctnl an offe r by the I I I y ri a n r u l e r Ba rd y l i s o f a treaty on till' b a s i s of the status quo, dem a n di ng instead su rrend e r o f a l l the M a ce donian towns they held. Bardyl i s gave battle with a force wh ich matched that of Philip. The Illyrians formed a defensive s q u are and there was a long fight with heavy casualties until the Macedon ian caval ry broke through , and II Iyrian l osses were said to be 7,000. Macedonia now controlled all t h e terri tory as far as Lake Lychn iti s (Oh rid) and was now as wel l pl aced to attack the lllyrians as they had once been to raid Macedonia. It was a famous victory. Though some information abo u t Bardylis is provided by the contemporary historian Theo pompus and by other writers, none i dentifies his regime with any people or tribe other than Illyrian s In the great battle with Philip he is said to have fought on horseback at the age of 90, and there is no suggestion that he did not s urvive the encounter. He was, it is said, by origin a charcoal-burner who amassed a fortune and founded a dynasty by sharing out the booty gained in raids he h ad directed. Nothing stan ds on the record to locate the centre of his power, save for the fact that Ph il ip's victory in 35 8 BC gained control of Lyncestis. A later victory by Ph i l ip over Cleitus the son of Bardylis a pparently reduced the latter to the status of a client, and this may have been ach ieved by operations against Dardanians. In th at case the power of Bard ylis may have been centred among the southern Dardanians of Kosovo and Metohija, from which it expanded to the southwest as far as th e Molossians, south to Lyncestis and, for short periods, southeast to include Macedonia.s Ph ilip 11 w a s soon again at war with IIIyrians, though evi dently not those ruled by Bardylis. Diodorus i n forms us that i n 356 BC k i ngs of the Thracians, Paeonians an d JI Iyrians combi ned to resist th e rising power of Macedonia, by whom each had already been defeated. Ph i l i p moved before the allies .
' Papa7.0glu 1 96 1 Griffith 1 979 ,
and
(Hcraclca Lyncestis) , Diouorus 2 1 3- 1 4 .
Siculus
1 6 .4, Ha mmond
hll'I1l/t"
01
M , 'I I '' /Ol/l, '
III
(m i l d I I n i t l' t l l l' i r fo r-n's, a n d ' s t n l l' k 1 1' 1' 1' 0 1' i n t o t h l' l l ! a n d (Oll l pl' l l ed t h l' l l I t o j o i n t l l l' i r for n's w i t h t i l l' M a n·d o n i a n s ' , The l,'o;l l i t i o n had e v i d e n t l y hl'l' ll (o l l l l' i V l'd hy t il l' A t h e n i a n s , and t h l' n a llll'S o f the rll l ers i n v o l v e d , ( ; ra h l l s o f the I I l y r i a n s , Ly ppe i l l S of t h e Pal'on i a n s a n d Cl't r i p o r i s o f Th ra(e, a rc preserved in a n A t h en i a n dcaee r a t i fy in g t h e a l l i a lKe. The victory ovcr the I I l y r i a n s i n 356 HC, ach ieved by Pannen i o in a major battle, a l ong w i t h th e victory of the royal chariot at the Olympic
Ga mes, were l ater recalled as propitious coi nci dences with the d a y on which Alexander the Great was born. The IlIyrians of Grabus are unli kely to have been the subjects of Bardylis defeated only two years earl ier, though some have suggested ( ; rabus was his son and successor. His name suggests some l'onnection with the Grabaei, a mi nor people of the II Iyrians who l i ved on the southern Adriati c near the Lake of Shkodcr. In 344/3 BC, according to D i odorus: 'Ph i l ip had inherited from his father a q uarrel with the lllyrians and found no means o f reconci ling his disagreement. He therefore invaded Il lyria w i th a large force, devastated th e countryside, captured many towns and returned to Macedonia laden with booty ' ( 1 6.69, 7 ) . Some detai l is furnished by Didym us, an Alcxandrian com mentator on the Phil ippics of Demosthenes of thc fi rst century HC, who records th at among the many wounds sustained by Ph ilip, one came from the Tri balli (in 3 3 9 R c) and another during an earl ier campaign against lllyri ans. On this occasion the king was pu rsu ing the lllyrian Pleuratus, whcn Hippostratus the son of Amyntas and 150 of the elitc corps of the Com panions were casualties. Next the historian Justinus compresses into a single sentence the reference to an Illyria n war wh i ch he p l a ces between 3 4 6 and the end of 343 B C . The enemy are named as 'the Dardani and other neigh bouring peoples', whom Philip defeatcd and took prisoner 'by a deceit'. Finally, under the year 3 3 6/5 RC, in the context of incidents leading up to the murder of Philip by Pausan i as, Diodorus records that, 'as Ph i lip was engagcd in battle with Pleurias, king of the IIIyrians, Pau s anias, one of the royal bodyguard, stepped in front of h i m and, receiving on his body all the blows directed at the king, so met his death' ( 1 6 . 9 3 , 6). From these scraps of evidence onc may reconstruct a series of cal culated forays i ntended to secure the
( ; II 'I '�' 111" 110/11.\
I I l y r i a l l rc a r ot �b l'l'd o l l i . l , p r i or to t i l l' p Ll I l I I l'd l' x pl'd i t i o ll
a ga i n s t t h e Pers i a n k i n � t h a t wou l d rC I I 1 O V l' I h l' hl'sl o f t h e a r m y to A s i a . h The fi rst de monstration of t h e e x cc pt i on a l m i l i ta ry tail- n t of Alexander, son o f Ph i l ip 1 1 , took the form o f a spect
Danube. After a battle in wh ich 3 00 of the Triballi were killed, Al e x and e r crossed the river and defeated th e Getae. The Triballi now formally su rrendered, and among others who came to pay their respects were ' Cel ts from the Ionian gulf' who dwelt 'in a d i stant country that was hard to penetrate', pre s umably the l ands between the head of the Adriatic and the mid d le Dan u be . Expressions of frien dsh ip were reciprocated, th ough the Celts made it clear they were far from being i n awe of the Macedoni ans. Next ca me trouble with the IlIyrians. When the returning army had rea c he d Paeonia, A l e x and e r received news th at Clc itus the son of Bardylis had taken up a r m s and that he was supported by Glaucia s of the Taulantii over towards th e Adri a t ic, and also that the Autariatae were pla n ning to ambush h i s army on the march . Al e x ander knew l i ttle o r nothing o f this peo p l e but he was assured by his ally king Langarus of the Agrianes that th e re was little to fear from th em . With Alex and er's appro v a l he attacked the m and i n flicted severe damage but died before he coul d e n j oy th e pro m i se d reward. At this poi n t the lIlyrians decided t o launch an a ttac k o n Mac ed onia, before Alexander a nd his army returned from the Danube. It was the h DioJorus Sicul us 1 6.22 ( 3 5 6 BC), Plu tarch, Alexander 3, J ustinus 1 2. 1 6 ( birth of Alexander), Isocrates, Phili/JI}, 2 1 , Demosthencs Philippic. 1 .4 8 ( .H O KC), Olynth iac L 1 3 (349 B C ) DiodorLIS S i c u l u s 1 6 .69, . � (344/3 lie), Didym lls Comm. 011 Demosthenes Ph ilippic. col . 1 2 , 64, J lI stinus 8 . 6, DioJorL1s Sicu l us 1 6 .93 (33 6/5 LIe) . Hammond 1 9 66, 245-6, H a m m o n d and Griffith 1 9 79 , 469-74, Hammond l 9 8 1 , Hatzopo u los 1 9 8 7, Tronson 1 911 4 (ma rriage o f Philip I l with lIlyrian Audata) .
Fi�lIre 1 () R ock -cu t tomb at Se/cif
e
Poshtme, A lbania
I l e w s o f Philip's d e a th \vh ich had stirred the n o r th e rn peoples t o action : ' I 1 1 y r i a ns , Th racians, D a rd a n i a n s a n d o th e r barbarian t ri hes of d u b io u s a n d u nt r u stwo r th y nature, who cou l d never he held i n ch eck by any means i f th ey were a l l to revolt a t the s a m e time' U u s tin u s l 1. 1 , 6 ) . A l exander a d va n ce d h i s fo rces li p the river Erigon (Crna Reka) to Pelion, where Cleitus had m oved t o a '.... a i t Gla ucias and t h e Ta ula ntii. Th e site w a s wel l protected a n d was r i n ged by c o m m a n d i n g h e i gh t s , hel d by th e t roops of Clcitll s . One possible location is the i s o l a te d h i l l settlement at Gorier in the plain of Poloske n e a r the river Devo l l , which h a s Hel lenistic and l a ter forti fications, and was clearly a ce ntr a l place i n this part of D a s s a reti s , th e Korce basin sOllth o f Oh ri d. More recently Albanian arch aeologi sts h a v e i d e n ti fied P e l i o n with t h e rem ai n s a t Selce e Posh tme on the u pper cou rse of the Shkumbi n . Here th e most nota b l e rema i n s a rc a group of tom bs, w i t h c h a m b ers and a rch i tectural fa<; ad es carved out of a rock face (see figu re t 0 ) . The i r p r i n ce l y charac tcr h a s suggested a com p a ris o n with the fam ou s royal tombs at Vergin a i n Macedonia, and this has been p a r t l y bornc out by thc con tents o f one of th em. Alcx ander's lllyrian ca m p a i gn is dcscri bed by A rr ia n . Th e Ma ce do n i a n s arrived before G l auc ias and the Taulantii but the I I I yrians, h a v i n g sacri ficed three boys, three gi rls and thrcc black ram s, m a d e as i f to attack.
1 24
( ;f't't'�' lIIynjllls
W h e n t h e M a n'do n i a n s a l so hega n to m o v l' tl1l'Y a h a n donl'd
t h e i r d e fen s i v e pos i t i o n s a n d fl ed i n t o Pl' l i o n , ka v i n g t lw s a c r i ficial vict i m s w h e re t h e y h a d fa l lell . The d a y a fter A l e x a nder began his b l ock a d e Glaucias and h i s l a rge a r m y a r r i ve d , p roh ab l y from the west via the Tsan go n pass, Alex a n d e r now extricated his outnumbered forces from a d a ngerous position and, using fully the disci p l i n e and trai n ing impose d by h i s fath e r on the M ace do n i a n army, succeeded in de feating both Cleitus and Glaucias. Alexander's campaign was fough t not in IIlyris but in Dassaretis, the plains south of Lake Ohrid, though the area had long been under Illyrian control, b e ing open to attack both from the no rth and from the west. The whole episod e is recounted by Arrian as a demonstration of Alexand e r's brilliance as a general, in wh i ch the lllyrians were overawed, outw i tted and humiliated by a trained army, a com bination of the w edge of arm oured i n fa n try (the ph alanx) and h eavy cav a l ry whos e ch a rge , given the right ground, was unstoppable. Yet against the highly mobile l ight i n fant ry a n d ca v alry of the I I I y r i ans a co mm a n der who lost his n e rve could easily lose his w h o l e army, The escape and v icto ry of Alexander and his army brought home to the l l lyrians, or at least some of them, how much had cha n ge d since they had brought Macedonia to i ts knees barely 5 0 years b e fore . 7 Glaucias of the Ta ulantii, though de fe ated by Ale x a nde r in 335 B C , survi v e d for more than a generation and was still ruling in 3 02 B C . In 3 1 7 B C , six years a fter the death of Ale x an der and with power in M aced on i a in the ha n ds of the ruthless Cassander, Glauci as offered asy l um to the infant Py rrhus after the expulsion of his father Aeacides from his k i ngd om among the Molossians. The infant prince was placed i n the care of Gl aucias' wife Beroea, who was herse l f a Molossian princess , Cassander, eager to gain Epirus , took o ffen ce at th is action and offered to pay 200 t a le nts for Pyrrhus but the offer was d ec l ined. Three ye a rs later Cassander came west, de fe ate d Glau ci a s and seized Dyrrhachium and Apo l l onia on the borders of his territory. After another three years, in 3 1 2 BC, Cor cyr a 7 Arrian Ana basis 1 . 1-6. Ham mond l 9 74a, 1 977, Bosworth 1 98 1 (d isputi ng location of Pe(l)lion), Hammond and Walbank 1 9 8 8 , 3 9- 4 9 . Selcc e Poshtme : N. Ceka 1 976, Manastirli 1 976.
1 '.III 'mit'S
11/
M o l , " ' /1 11 / 1 ' /
rl'l"ove rl'd t h e t wo l' i t ies and h ;l I 1 d (' ( 1 l > y r r h a dl i u l 1 1 over to ( ; I a u l" i a s , even tho ugh h e w a s n o w hou n d hy t re a t y not to a n a l" k a l l ies o f M a l"cdon i a . Py rr h u s wew to m a n h ood safe a l1long t h e Ta u la nt i i a n d a ro u n d fi v l' Y l';HS l a te r, 0 11 the death of A ketas the k i n g of Epi ru s , G l a u(' i a s m a r c he d south and l'sta h l i shcd 011 the th rone the 1 2-yea r-old P y rrh u s . In 3 03/2 BC Py rrh ll s ca me to the court of Gla llcias, presumably by now his a doptive fath er, to atte n d the marriage of o n e of h is sons.8 for th e first 20 y ears of his reign the restless and energetic young r u l er of E pirus was m u ch involved in the struggles of A l exa nder's s uccessors . In 3 0 1 BC he fought with distinction in the great b a t tle at Ipsus in Asia Minor on the side of Antigonus, when the ca u se of a c entral power in the empi re of Alexander was finally defeated by a coalition of ri v als . Later he tried to sei ze control of Ma c edoni a itself, where many of the soldiers saw in h i m a new Alexander. Once he fough t h i s brother-in law Demet r ius , th e son of Antigo n u s , in single co m hat. When he finally gain e d Macedonia his regime is said to have l a s ted o n l y seven months ( 2 8 7 BC ) , as the Macedon ians preferred their old ge n era l Lysimachus . Back in Epirus he turned h is a m b ition s to the west, which was to bring him into a m e mora b le con flict with the rising power of Rome in the I t a l ia n peninsula . The reign of Pyrrhus, who died i n 272 BC, for a l l h is adventures d sewhere, saw his kingdom in Epirus rise to a pos i tion of power on the west of Greece and Mace do n i a . Links w i th h i s n eigh b o u rs were strengthened by marriage al l iances. O n c o f his wives was Birkenna, daug h ter of Ba rd yl i s , s o n o f t h e Cleitu s (of the Dardani ?) defeated b y A l ex a n de r . This all iance may h a ve secured the inland Dardani to the north , while his l i nks w i th th e Ta ulantii may h ave assisted his enterprises. It seems dear th a t at some time Pyrrhus was able to annexe the lands of the Tau l antii in the northern coastal plain of A l bania, as wel l as the key port of Dyrrhachiu m ; and the adv a n ce may l'ven have con ti n ued farther north to i n cl ude the area around the Lake of Shkoder, heart of the later Illyrian k i n gdom . 9 Mo re than a century of warfare with M acedoni a and Epir u s H D iodortJs Siculus 1 9 .67, Pol yaenus 4. 1 1 (3 1 4 BC ) , Diodorus a n d 71l ( 3 1 3 (lc), Hammond and W a l bank 1 9 11 1l , 1 54 -5 . 'I
C a h a n e,� 1 976, fra nk!.' 195 5 ,
Hammond
1 96 6 .
Sicul us 1 9 .74
l 2. h
h a d h ro u g h t t h l' A d r i .l l i l.' I I I Y I' I '1 I 1 S hl't W l'l' l l F p i r u s a l l d t h l' r i v l r Nere t v ,l i l l to d i rect a l l d l a s t i l l g cO l l t a c t w i t h t h l' ( ; rl'l' k w o r l d . They were t o l e a d t o m a j o r c h a n gl's i n t h e sm:i a l ,l I l d l'�:o l l o m i c life o f this region, som e o f w h i ch ( a n n o w h e more cl ea rl y observed thanks to the material evi dence gathered by Y u goslav and Albanian archaeologists . Changes in the pastoral econ o m y '
of a population dwell ing i n v i l l ages brought an increase in population and m ore settlements based on a l a n d economy, aiding the growth of central authori ty , at first that of the king. The growth of towns will also have engendered a demand for greater pol itical auton omy th at placed strains on th e traditi onal tri bal structures. To some the evidence suggests a spiritual and mental acculturation to an urban life on the Hellenistic pattern . At the same time there is little sign, even when Roman conquest brought an end to this era of lllyrian development, that genuine urban societes had developed : IIIyrian loyal ties lay with th e traditional figures of chief and tribe (ethnos) . There is a gen eral i mpression from the historical sources that this was a period of growth in the Illyrian population . Attacks by them came frequently and in great strength. The pressu re of such growth on a pastoral economy will have seen a move to agriculture as a means o f increasing the sources o f subsist ence. In the case of upper Macedonia , where con d itio n s were sim i l ar, Philip forced whole co mmunities to leavc the hills for the pl ain, thus increasing his own authority as well as the cconomic base of h is kingdom. In some IIIyrian areas it is possiblc to trace the growth of certai n villages into major local centres for defence, markets and religion, in fact a small local town. Thc spread of agriculturc a mong the southern IIIyrians, inevita bly con fined to the small areas of cultivable land, is hard to measure. Perhaps the abil ity of Illyrians to fight as hopl itc infantry, as against the Molossians in 3 8 5/4 nc, i ndicates an increase of myrian peasantry. 1 0 We know little of Illyrian society i n the fourth and third cen turies BC. Thcy appeared in war as free warriors u nder their chiefs or some overlord such as Bardylis or Glaucias. A t home there is no sign of chattel slavcry on the d assical model. Refer10
Ca banes 1 988a, 1 8 S-90.
"'1//'/11;/ '.\
I I1
I II
M . / I I '. !" /II,I
' I w l o t s ' 0 1 t h e A rd i a �' i h a v �' l x p 0 l \ e d fo r sa l e i n t h e s l a v e l I l a rkl' t s o f t h e I k l k n i st i c ,.... o r l d h u t r a t h e r depc n d e l l t CO III III U l l i t i l' S w h o frolll t i I I l l' to t i lIle cven pa rtict pa t ed i l l c x ped i t i o l 1 s . The s u bject po p u l a t i ol1 a t A pol l on i a w e r e e v i dcn t l y n a t i v e w m m u nities who worked the fiel ds belonging to t h c co l o ny s oligarch y. An au thentic traffic in slaves may h a v c devel oped l a te r th rough the co l onies of Apollonia an d E p i d a m ll u s and may be the explanation for the sprcad of thei r �' I l l'l'S
t o s l a V l's o f t i l l' I > a rda n i a m
or
h e �' n 1 I 1 1ll'h d i sc u ssed . T l l l'sl' W l' n' n o t p r i so n c r s
'
'
,
'
w i n s across th e Balkans in the second and first centuries
BC.
D u ri n g the third century records of the freeing (manumission) o f slaves began to be i nscri bed on stone at Apollonia, Klos, B y l l i s a nd Buth rotu m . As in other societies thc status of a leader was determined by the nu mber of warriors who followed. Obedience to a higher authority such as a king was channelled th rough the collective loyalty of a tribe to the chief. In retu rn he acknowledged the source of his power by offering securi ty a n d protection when needed. Polybius presents us with a n i m age of society i n the Illyrian kingdom as pcasant infa ntry fighting un d cr a ristocratic proprictors (polydynastae), each on e of whom controlled a town with i n the kingdom . The persistcnce of thc old tri bal ties appears to be reflccted by the use of tra d itional tumulus burial as late as the Christian e ra He re thc chief still lay at the cen tre with his compan ions at rest around him. We can imagine th is order of society bei ng based on the many hill-settlements which had acqu irc d defences by the end of the fourth century BC. At Gajtan near ShkodCr an a r ea of nearly five hectares was enclosed by a rampart of u n w or k ed stones but the structures within were merely sh acks of tim ber and clay. Such a pl ace was evidentl y created by a local ruler mainly a s a place of refuge, and there seems little warrant to suggest that it was the first stage of a genuine urbanization, cut short later by foreign conquest. I 1 Livestock remained the principal pro d uct of IIIyrians. Their mutton soon gained a reputation among the Romans, wh ile King Pyrrh us had already gained a place in the reference books for his methods of cattle-breeding. Quantities of cereal were .
1 1
Ca banes 1 9 8 8 a, 1 90-7.
I 2. X
( .. rt't'/..'
Ill",.,,,,, s
prod lll:c d , I h o ugh t ll l' rl' i s 1 1 0 l l l l'a l l S o f I l l l'a S I lr l' l l l l' l l l l' X I..'l' p l fo r req u i s i tions i n t i m e o f w a r, n o ta h l y I h l' l > y r r h .K h i u l l l cl l11 pa i g n during the civil w a r between Ca e s a r a n d POl11 pey . I I l y r i a n vineyards enjoyed n o great rep u tation a ll l o n g G reeks J n d Rom ans, though there is an intrigu i ng po s s ibi l i ty tha t the v i t i c u l tu re
of the Bordeaux region derived from Illyri an Dyrrhach i u m . The background to Roman intervention in Illyri a in 229 BC was i n part com mercial. Italian traders were active along the Illyrian coast at the time, while the founda tio n of a Roman colony at B rindisi in 244 BC indicates an interest in the short crossing of the Adriati c . Tim ber from the IlIyrian hinterland was val ued down to medieval and modern times, notably for sh ips but a l so as a source of fuel . Except for such basic items as cloth or Alpi n e cheese, both val ued abroad, little or nothing was made among the southern I1 lyrians until the growth of towns sti mu lated the in troduction of n ew techniques, masonry construction, brick, tile and pottery manufacture and metal-working. Nothing is so far known of the extraction of silver, a n d the location of Damastion, with its remarkable si lver coinage, remains a mystery. Somewhere to the north or northeast of Ohrid seems l ikely. No r is there yet any evidence for working of the copper deposits in the Shkumbin valley. The deposits of asphalt (Ad Picarias on ancient road maps) inland from Apol lonia were exploited during th e Greek and Roman periods though remains of the working are yet to be found. Speci alized production of pottery in Illyria commences with imitation of south Italian forms at Dyrrhachium, where in the second century BC 'Megarian' bowls with moulded decoration were also produced . There local production and stamping of tiles in k i l ns spreads as far north as the Shku m b i n . The chief centre of production was Apollonia but other centres includ e Gurezeze, Dimale (Krotine) , Klos, Byllis and Margelli<;, but the nam es on stamps are Greek rather than IlI yr ian . In the Korce basin and on the island St Ach il leus in Lake Little Prespa stamped storage jars have been discovered. Stamped amphorae of Rhodian origin (220- 1 8 0 BC) may be significant evidence for long-distance commerce but who were the consumers at this period remains unc1ear. 1 2 1 2 Cabanes 1 9 8 8 a, 1 9 7-204, D i b ra 1 98 1 (hoard near Shkoder) .
of
axes, hoes
and
scythes
/ ',1/1'111/1 ',0; "/ M . / I ,,' /f ll/I./
I ll}
N o I I l y r i a n p ro d u l'I i o n o f l'o i l l S i s k n o w l l hdo rl' K i n g MOl l ll l l i ll s st f l ll' k h i s co i l l s at I > y rr h a dl i ll l l l (sl'e figure I I ) , fo l lownl h y M y t i l ll s a ro l l n d tell Yl'a rs Ja l l' r, A n l'a rl y dating of t h l' fi rst Scod ra co i n s, gener,l l l y l i n h'd w i th the Macedon ian occu p a t i o n a ro u n o 2 U n e , to the m i ddle of the th i r d cen tury is hett e r d i sca roeo, mainly beca use no coi ns are known to have heen i ssll ed hy III y rian rulers of a later period su ch as Agron, Tellta, Scerdilaidas, etc. By around 230 BC, wh en Epirote do mi na tion had waned, coins were circulating around the l ower Aous v a l l e y , from Byllis, A m anti a , Olympe and other places, though never in quantities to m atch those from the two coastal col oni es . The e a r l y Scodra coins are small bronze issues intended for local c i rc u l ation, but the m a i n l ocal currency was based on silver i ssues from the major centres, Dyrrhachium, Apollonia and Epi rus, In the kingdo m of Illyri a an authentic lo c al co i n age a ppears only in th e second century BC under King Gentius. 1 3 Th e 'Illyrian tow n ' has been a m a j o r theme o f research in modern Albania, involving study of the origins, growth, politi cal and social organization and relations with the surrounding
territory, including the establish ment of outlying satellite forti fications in th e border districts of Illyris and Epi ru s . The first construction of fortifications is dated now to the fi fth century
Figure 1 1 Silver coin of 'King Monunius' minted at Dyrrhachium : diameter 2 1 mm
U
Cabanes
t 988a,
204-7, Coin circu l ation: Gjonccgaj
1 984b (Epirus), 1 98 6 (others), 1 976b (Byllis circulation ) .
t 984a
(Corcyra) ,
1 .1 0 lie,
a n d designa tt'd as a ' p rt'-' or ' prow-' u rb a n ph ase defi ned
t h ro u gh i n vestigations at G a j ta n a ro u n d th ree m i l es southeast of Shkodcr. A n a rea of a ro ll n d fou r to fi ve hecta res was en cl osed by a ston e rampart about 3.5 metres wide of u n w or k e d blocks but with two fa ce s of closely fitting stones en c l o s i n g a core of smaller stones. There were no to w e r s in this p h as e and at the most one or two ga tes (see figures 1 2a a n d 1 2b). More th an two dozen sites w ith defences erected i n t h i s manner have been identified, i n cl u ding simple refuges such as Tr e n an d Ventrok in th e Korce b a s i n , G a n jo l le n e a r G a j ta n , and el a bo r a te defensive comp l ex es such a s G a jta n , Sh koder , Marshej, Lissus phases I and 11, Zgerdh esh ph a se I a nd OsaniCi I and 11. 1 4 The forma ti on of proper urban centres takes place in the southernmost districts of I l l y ri s , a dj oining Chaonia and th e Aous (Vijose) valley, before the end of the fifth century BC b u t that stage is not reach e d in the no r th , th at i s, in the Mat valley a nd th e S h k oder b a sin, until around a century later. After 3 5 0 BC I l l yri an towns are believed to have become es ta bl i she d at Lissus (Lezha) and Shkoder and in the interior at An tip a tr eia (Berat) and also at Selce e Poshtme in th e Shkumbin valley, a s uggested location for Pelion. Perh aps the most re m a rkabl e d evelopment took place at Byllis of the Byll iones (see figures B a and 1 3b), w he re the earlier settlement at Klos on its co n fi n ed h i I l - top w a s r ep laced by a new settlement on th e adjoining h i l l that developed the i mposing character of a Hell enistic and later Roman city. The defended area of some of the new I l lyri a n towns reached 30-40 hectares, with p e rimeter walls fortified with strai gh t- si d ed or sometimes round towers, such as survive at Lissus (see bel ow) . The gates were li kewis e well protecte d in a fashion a p propri a te to resisting Hel l eni sti c techniques in s iege warfare employing a rtill ery . This e ra of
1 4 Early fortifications : Prendi 1 976a, N. Cek a 1 977-8, 1 983, 1 985a, 1 986, Karaiskaj 1 976, 1 9 77, 1 977-8 b ( M a rshej near Shkoder) ; typology: Zheku 1 977-8 , 1 9 8 0, Korkuti 1 973 , 1 976, Isl ami 1 976b, 1 9 84, J ubani 1 9 72b ( G ajta n i}m Ju bani and N . Ceka 1 9 7 1 ( Rosuje), 1 986b (Kodra e Pazarit), Fistani 1 9 83 (Kratue near Sh koder), Lera 1 975 (Symize near Ko rce ) . Mon tenegro: Mijovic and Kov a cev i c 1 975 ( ch a llen g i ng Albanian ch ron ology ) , Parovic-Pesikan 1 98 0 (Risan hinterl and), 1 977-8 (Gulf of Kotor) . On A d ri atic settlements, Suic 1 975 .
Fi}:tlre 1 J a) I'lal1 of Hyllis. G radesht. b) Plan of Hyllis. central area
Albania
L,,/ '/II1/'S
I II i\I " 1 /'dOlI l"
I I r ha n dl' V l' l o p n l l' l l I i s " , a r k ed h y t i l l' f i r ... '
U
I ,1 1
In ... , n I l' ! i o n o f p l l h l i l"
h u i l d i ngs, w h i c h a t B y l l i .. W l' l"l' l' v l' n t l l a l l y t o i n (\ l I d l' a t 1l l' a t l"l' , st a d i u ll l a n d d o u h l e port i o ) , a l \ l' X l'I.: l I t l'l1 i n cOllrsl'l1 h l o c k s o f
d ressed stone. B u i l d i n gs o f a d i st i n c.: t 1 y u r ba n c.:h a ra c.:t l' r h a ve rec.:en t l y been revealed in several major sett l em e n t s . The u rban c.:ha rac.:ter of B y l l i s is ev ident by the m i ddle of the third century BC, sur ro u n ded by a cordon of strongholds p rotecting the territories of the commonweal th (koi11011) of the Bylliones, at Gurzeze, M a rgellic;, Rabie, Matohasanaj . These are constructcd in reg u l a r dresscd masonry, with defenccs dated to the late fourth or early third century BC similar to those further south in Epi rus. further north the massive defcnces at Bcrat (Antipatreia or Barguli um) may belong to th e era of direct Epirote rule beforc 23 0 B C . The l ocation of Dimalc (or Dimallum), a scttle mcnt in the territory of the Parthini, at Kroti nc wcst of Berat, depends on tiles stamped DIMALLITAN (in Grcek) . Though thc enclosed area is less than 1 5 hectarcs, there was at least one building of a publ ic character - a portico ovcr 30 metres long with seven niches which appears to imitate si milar build ings at Apol 1onia. At Zgerdhesh (sec figures 1 4 a and 1 4b), southwcst of Kruja, there are defenccs similar to those at Gajtan, dated locally to the sixth to fifth centu ry B C. Imported Apul ian pottery appears at the end of thc fourth centu ry but thc wal ls of coursed masonry bel ong to a later period . Except for a semicircu lar structure in the lower part of the town no pu blic buildings are known in the ten-hectare settlcment, which has been identified as the A1banopolis of Ptolemy's Geography. Studies of the well-preserved fortifications at Acroli ssus and Lissus suggest that the formcr came first and was built in thc l ate fourth century. There was a major reconstruction of the latter in the first century BC, when the more roughly dressed blocks were replaced by smooth, dose-fitting masonry. No intcrior structures have yet been located. The function of Lissus (sce figures 1 5a, i S b and l Sc) near thc mouth of the Dri n was to gua rd the route inland and to furnish a secure anchorage for IlIyrian shipping. Little is known of Il Iyrian Scodra, mainly because the Rozafat fortress has remained in u se until modern times. Similarly few traces arc now to be seen of myrian defences at Meteon (Medu n ) , Olcinium (Ulcini ) and Rh izon
( R i sa l l ) . I I I t l H' Sl'l'O l l d l' l' l l t u ry A l l a I l a t i v {' o f R O l l l a l l R i s i ll i u l l l , w h o h a d r i s{' 1 l t o l'olll m a ml t h {' a r m y o f A fr i l' a rl'l'a l l nl t hl' 'Aeacian w a l l s ' o f h i s I l I y r i a n h Olm" perh a p s a l l u d i n g to Al'anls of Aegina who ass i s te d Apol l o and Poseidoll in b u i l d i ng thl' ,
walls of Troy . Nothing has yet been repo rted o n the sett l e m e n t at Selce e Poshtme, a candidate for the location of Pclion, and there is so far no certain location for Uscan a, the strategical ly pl aced chief settlement of the Illyrian Penestae. 1 5 The rapid move to a fo rm o f urban i zation among the sou thern Illyrians, during the late fourth and early th i rd centuries BC, m atches the rather better observed developments to the south in Epi rus. For the IIIyrians a question remains as to the extent th at this development was a di rect consequence of exter nal sti m ulus, notably Molossian Epi rus in the time of Pyrrh us, and whether there is any genuine evol ution from the earl ier period that warrants the use of such descriptions as 'pre-' or 'proto-' urban. The matter will be resolved only by systematic excavation in the i nterior of these settlements, which so far has not been attempted. What evidence there is at present tends towards a negative conclusion, and it seems likely that many of the roughl y fortified h ill-sites were more likely refuges for herdsmen and flocks on the move or for the inhabitants o f local v i llages i n level country, a n d therefore arc unlikely to produce evidence for permanent occupation.
I � Urban development: N. Ceka 1 98 5b, Cabanes 1 9 8 8b, Anamali 1 976b. Lissu s: Prendi and Zheku 1 9 7 1 , 1 9 72, 1 9 8 6 , Zheku 1 974, 1 976, Prendi 1 98 1 (inscriptions); Shkodcr : Hoxha 1 9 8 7 (B ronze Age remai ns); Berat: Ba�e 1 9 7 1 , Spahiu 1 975 , 1 9 8 3 ; Selce : N. Ceka 1 972 ; ByIlis/Klos: Papaj ani 1 976a, 1 979 (the.atre), Vreka 1 98 7 (Gurzeze near Cakran); Dimale: Hammond 1 968, Dautaj 1 9 72 (brick stamps), 1 976a, 1 9 76 b (economy) , 1 9 84a (coins), 1 9 84b (stoas), 1 9 86 (political organization) ; Zgerdhesh: Islami 1 972b, 1 975 , Papa jani 1 9 77. Also Lahi 1 9 8 8 (Beltoje near Shkoder), N . Ceka 1 975 b (fortifications of Amantini), Anamali 1 972, Prendi and Budina 1 972 (Irmaj , Gramsh), Isl ami 1 970 (Xibri, Mat district), Anamali 1 975 (Podgradec), Bud ina 1 9 8 5 (Antigoneia). Ba�e 1 974 (Kanine), 1 975 (Gulf of Vlora), 1 979, Bereti 1 985 (Tri port), N . Ceka 1 98 7c (Margel li<;), Jubani and N. Ceka 1 97 ] (Rosuje).
" , II, 'I/Ii,',.. 1 1/ 1\ 1 , ,/ /,, /1 1'11, '
1 17
Cel ts, A u t a ri a t a e and I >a rd a n i a ns TIl l' \:o l 1 l i n g o f t h l' Cd t s ' h a s l o n g hccl l a l l a n:epta h l c h y poth l's i s for a n:h a co l ogi sts gra pp l i n g w i t h t h e h u ge q u a n t i t i es of l l I a t c ri a l from t h i s cra, a n d i ts wide a ppli cat io n i n Cen tral and Southeast E u rope has h a d a di rect b e a r i n g on defin i n g the limits a l l d i d e n t i ties of the IIIyr i an pe op le s , n o t a bly in the regi on of t h e m i dd l e Danube and i ts major tri butaries. That in parts of t h i s a rca, incl uding the eas t ern Alps, M iddle Danube and Sava a n d Drava valley, the majority of the settled populati on were ( :c l t i c-spea k i n g is g enera l l y ac cepted from h istor i cal and ono m a st i c evidence . Yet how they came to be there and what, if a n y t h i ng, ha p pened to a n 'existing popu l ati on ' a re quest io n s awaiti ng answers. One central and long- l a s tin g hypothe s i s a mong arch aeologi sts i s that the arri v al of Celtic-speakers in sl.'veral a r ea s north of the A l p s co i n c i des wi th , and indeed is, t h l' po i n t of transition from the earl ier to the later ph ase of the E u ro p ean Iron Age. That named after Ha l l s ta tt in the ea s ter n A l ps not far from Salzb u r g came to an end around 400 BC a n d
was rep l a ced by that of La Tene, after a lake side settlement in Swi tzerland, famous for its e l eg ant style of curv i linear non figural ornament often referred to as 'Celti c ' art. By the l ate second and early first cen t u r i e s BC the two cul t ures had fused i n to a un i form version of La Tene across most of Europe nor t h of the Alps. 1 6 Pto lemy ' s h istor y o f Alexander's campaigns recorded that, fo llo wi ng his brilliant victory on the Danube in 335 BC, an emb a ssy came from the Celts to seek the alliance and fr i end sh i p of the young king. The p oint of the anecdote, as re tol d by Arrian and the geographer Strab o , was to show how t h i s peo ple 'who l i ved a long way off in a coun try n ot ea sy to p e n etrate ' told Alexander that their greate s t fear was n ot him but the sky fal l i ng upon their heads. Alexander, thou gh not a little insulted, granted the alliance and sent the envoys home. They had come from the far west, 'around the Adriati c ' in the version of I h Gustin 1 984, J ovanovic and Popovic 1 9!1 1 , Todorovic 1 96 8 (biblio graphy), Majnaric-Pandiic 1 978 (N. Croatia), P. Popov i c 1 978 ( co i n use), Knez 1 98 3 (Novo Mesto ) . Bolta 1 96 6 ( eelje).
I \X l'to l clll Y p reserved h y S l ra ho ( 7 . . \ , X ) or ' d w e l l i n g O i l I h e I o n i a n gu l f' i n Arri a n ( 1 0 4 , 6 ) . Though i t i s t ru l' t h a t t h e Pe r i p l l l s locates some Celts 011 t h e n o r t h A d r i at i � �oa s t o f I t a l y , i t i s more l i kely that these came from the north "vcst Ba l k a n s or even the ea stern Alps and the m iddle Danu he. The a rr i v al of Cel ts in this area by the early fourth century i s indicated hy the accoun t of Justin us, based on Cel tic tradition in th e work of Pompeius Trogus (Book 24) . Around the end of the fifth century some of the 3 00,000 m igrating Celts crossed the Alps and sacked Rome but the rest, by a progress which caused great devastation, reached the lllyrian coast and made their homes in Pannon ia. They mastered the Pan nonians and for many years continued warring with neigh bouring peoples. 1 7 Thc fourth-century h istorian Theopompus m ay b e the source of an account of fighti ng between Cel ts and Illyrians, hoth equ ally detested by the average Greek, where the one achieved victory by i n fl icting on the other the agonies of severe diarrhoea : When the Cel ts attacked, with a knowledge of (lIlyrian) intem pcrance, they o rdcred their soldicrs to prepa re food in their tents as s umptuous as possible, and thcn to add to i t a type of medi cinal herb wh ich had the effect of emptying and purging the bowel s . When this took effect many werc c a u gh t by the Celts and kille d, while other s cast themselves into thc river from the unbearahlc pain. (Th eopompus, q uoted by Athenaeus 1 0.60)
In a version of the story included by Polyaenus in a collection of Stratagems (7.42), the Illyri ans involved were the Autariatae, whom the Celts lured by feigned flight to consumc the doctored food left in their tents. Yet the story is a commonplacc and m ay have been judged by Theopompus as appropriate to the IIIyrians, fam ed for their l ove of food and drink, perhaps as background material to his account of Ph ilip II's lllyrian victory in 35 9/8 BC. If it ever happened, the likely date for the episode is early in the fourth century. 1 8 Thc Auta riatae were the most rcmote o f the lllyrian peoples 17 IR
M. Garasanin 1 970, Gavela 1 975a. Papa7.ogl u 1 9 7 8 .
b'I'II//" .\ "/ M " , " , 1"1//, ,
1 .\9
k n o w l I 1 0 t il l' ( ; n'l' k w o r l d i l l t i l l' C r. I o t Pl l I l i p a n d A l e x a n d e r , a n d a f!,oOlf dea l o f w h a l i s rn:l l nkd o f I h c l I I i s l H.'a r fa l l l a s y . Pe r h a p s I h l' o l l l y re l i a h l e e v i dl' l h ."l' i s t i l l' n' p o r l i ll A r r i a n ( fr o m I h l' e Y l'- w i t nl'ss Pto l e lll Y ) that t h l' A l I t a r i a t a e h a d plan n ed a n a t t a c k o n A l e x a nd e r ' s a rm y d ur i n f!, t h e i r homew a rd m a rch in U S 11( . Th i s wou l d a l so ta ll y with the tradition repe a ted by S t ra ho that t h e y wcrc ' once thc g r e a test and most pow c r fu l of 1 Ill' f 1 l y r i a n s ' . Another anecdote, wh i ch probably also or i ginatcd i l l ( ; reece in the fourth century BC, de s c ri b e s a long - r unni ng klld between the Au ta ri a t a c and the Ardiaei over the p o s se ss io n o f a sal t-sou rce near their common bo rd c r. Watcr which flowed out e a ch spring from the foot of a great m ounta i n p ro d u ced l' x cd l en t s alt thr o u gh evaporation within five d a y s , which was t h ell fed to livestock. Thc sitc, not namcd in the sources a n d n o w not easily located ( p oss i bly at O raho v i c a in thc uppcr N c rctva valley) , was far inland and e n a b l ed the Ardiaei to avoid h aving to import salt and thus to have few contacts with other peopl es. Th ere was an arra ngeme nt bctween thc two peoples to extract the s a lt in alternate yea r s but when this h roke down war ensued. The p i ctu re of the Ardi aei remote from the sea and from other p eo p l e does not match thcir later reput a tion for s e a b orne activity and may rel ate to a pe r iod
beforc thcy had movcd to occupy at least part of the c o a s t between the Neretva and the Drin. Evcn so, Appian o b serves t h a t though po w er fu l on the s ea , the Ardiaei were dest r oye d in the end by the Autariatac 'who wcrc bcst on l a nd ' , though th ey too s us tai n ed h eavy losses. I '} Taken together, the intell igi ble sou rces locate the Au tari atae inl and from the Ardiaei and the Lake of S h k oder, e xtend i n g cast to the Dardan i and north , or rather n orth e a s t, to thc Tri ba l l i . In modern terms their territory will h ave i ncl uded the va l l eys of the Lim and the T ara ( perh a p s somehow connected with thcir namc) bcyo nd thc mou n tai n s of n orther n Alb a n i a , and a l so the western Morava, an arca of thc Balkans barely known to the ancient geogra ph ers . It is te m p ting to i dent i fy I � Aristotle, Oil Marvellous Things Heard 1 3 8 (LeL 1 4 . 3 0 8- t O ) , Strabo 7.5, 1 1 , Appian, ll/yrike 3, Perhaps the salt source was 'Stane Vode' (salt water) near Orahovica , a few miles north of Konjic in the upper Neretva valley, Patsch 1 922, 43 note 4.
1 40
( ; rl'I,k IIIY"'III�
these A u ta ri a tae, p ro ha h l y a gl' l l l'ra l l l a l 1 l l' to r a w h o l l' g ro u p
o f smaller peoples k n o w n l a t e r h y t h l' i r i n d i v i d u a l n a l 1 lCS, w i t h the people of the Glasinac c u l tu rl i n e a s t e rn Bosn i a , w h e rc a tradition of tumulus buri a l h a d conti n ued a l most without interruption from Bronzc Age times. I n the early ( H a l lstatt) phasc o f the I ron Age a si milar l ocal tu mul us culture between the D rina and the Morava appears to have spread cast into Serbia by the end of the fifth century sc . This may represen t the expansion of the Autariatae at the expense of th e Triballi until , as Strabo remarks, thcy in thei r turn werc overcome by the Celtic Scordisci in the early third century BC. Similarly the decline or fragmentation of the Autariatae is m atched by a rise to prominence of the Ardiaei on the coast and of the Dardani inlan d. In the matter of m aterial remain s the p rincely burials of the early fi fth century BC containcd in two tumu l i (35 and around 70 metres i n diameter) at Atenica near C acak in western Serbia might wel l belong to the lIIyrian Autariatae in a time of pros perity before the Cel tic migrations (sce fi gurcs 1 6a and 1 6 b ) . The smallcr mound contained a central burial bencath a tru nc ated cone of chopped stones and a secondary interment near the perimeter beneath a similar construction of stones. The l arger mound contai ned on ly a central burial in a tom b con structed of rectangular slabs. All three bodies had been crem atcd outside the tum ulus before bu ri al, and the remains dis persed in the grave. Before thc burial platform of the larger tumu l us was constructed a sacrifice of young animals including a dog, a wil d boar and a wild sow and three oxen (see figure 1 6c ) . Th at the smaller tumulus contained a female burial is i nferred from the m any beads and pendants of gl ass and amber, with birds' and rams' heads, gold and silver appliques, buttons and a silver brooch. The bu rial contained the iron tyres of a chariot or burial cart, wh ich had been cons u med along with the corpse. Thc contents of the second burial were si milar but included also weapons, a spear, bronze arrows and an Attic gold p l aque decorated with the figure of a boar, and undoubt edly was that of a male child. Both burials included pottery and metalwork of Greek (probably Ionian ) origin. The larger tumulus contained a male burial with similar conten ts but included al so a sword, bronze arrows, h arness and the remains '
/ ', 1 / ( '11//( ',\ "/ M,,. /,. 1",/ /,/
14 1
of a l' h a r i o l . A l l l o n g ( ; rn' k i l l l po rt , W(' I'l' a n I o n i a n W I l l C l u g a n d s(' v e r .. 1 b ro n zl' d n.'ss p Lhl l l l's 0 1 s i l l l i l a r o r i g i n a n d a bon(' d a ggl' r h a n d l c . Th i s i so l a t cd h ur i a l o f w h a t w a s p ro b a b l y a si ngk fa m i l y p l a l'cd p ro m i n c n t l y i n t h c broad v a l l ey of the Wl'stnn M o r a v a i m p l ies an esta b l i s hed a u t h o rity that fel t able t o l'onsign h i gh -va l u e p r e s ti g e goods i nto their burial mounds.20 In 1 9 5 7, the yea r before the Atenica burials were d iscovered , a s pcl'tacu l a r find of obj ects dating to the same period was l I l ;l d c b e n ea t h a medieval ch urch near the town of Novi Pazar, w h i dl l i es on a tributary of the Ibar on the borders of Bosnia and Serbia. An iron-bound oak chest ( 1 .85 m by 0 . 8 5 m) l'on cealed in a pit more than two metres deep contained a fine wl l ection of j ewel lery and dress ornaments. No trace of a c rc m a t i o n or skeletal remains were found and i t is possible that t h i s i s an ex ampl e of hidden treasure rather than d e posited grave goods, although on balance a contex t of burial appears
t h c more p robable. In addition to i mported Greek pottery, b ronze
vessels and jewellery described above, the contents of
t h c chest included what some archaeologists regard as typical 1 0(;1 1 productions, among them a gold belt, earrings, gol d, silver and b r o n z e brooches and carved pieces of am ber. O bje ct s that tcn d to be labelled 'Greco-II lyrian' included a bronze wine
strai ner, gold pectorals, aprons an d pla q ues (pteryges) a n d more than 1 000 atta c hm ents of sheet gold in va riou s sha pes. The character of the ornaments and the absence of weapons s u ggests the robes and regalia of several IlIyrian princesses, b u t t h e belts, pectorals and some of the brooches were worn b y males. What the Novi Pa z a r hoard represents remains a puzzle b u t most likely it was the fam i l y treasure of an JI I y rian ruler w i th a marked taste fo r Greek imports of th e highest quality.2 1 The Autariatae had the misfortun e to be driven from thei r homel ands by a plague of frogs which fel l half-formed from the sky, a story which attracted the curiosity of several ancient w riters. This is the version of Heraclides, an Egyptia n civil servant of around 1 70 BC: I" Djuknic and Jovanovic 1 966a, 1 966b ( A tenica), Zotovic 1 972 (Krcmni, l I I yrian cemetery near Uzicc), 1 9 84 (Pi l atoviCi near Pozega ), 1 98 7 (bu ri a l n e a r Priboj i n Li m val ley). I l Mano-Zissi and Popovic 1 969 (Novi Pazar).
1 42 Somewhere in Pa eon ia and Dardania frogs fell from the sky like rain and there were so many that the houses and streets were ful l of them . Du ri ng the first days the people somehow bore it by destroying them and shutting up the houses. But as this achieved n othi n g, and their very cooking pots got filled with frogs which got boiled and baked with the food, and neither could the water be d ru n k, nor could men put foot to the ground for the multitude of them, and as the stink from the dead creatures was odious, the people a bandoned their ho m eland (Heraclides, frag. 3, FHG vol. 3 p. 168) .
No sense can be made of this horror story but it is reliably reported that the people were migrating from their homeland late in the fourth century BC. In 3 1 0 BC they were in Paeonia, where they were on the point of achieving a victory over king
I O I l.14S
10
(a) Figure 1 6 a) Plan of burial tumuli at Atenica, Serbia
1 43
(b)
; !: " �; " ' ! " ' --�' - :: )! . .
: :
il
n
U
••
\::::.:: - ..... .. . .. - --
(c)
•
� .... •
! "
. ' "
o �:
�:
. b !i
.. .. ..
.-:;: ':
-._ . - - . - - . -------- - -. - -- - - -
Figure 1 6 Continued b) Stone tomb in Tumulus I at Atenica c) Plan of sacrificial areas in Tumulus 11 at Atenica
1 44 A u do kon w h e n Ca ssa l l lk r Cl l 1 1 l' to t h l' rl'Sl' l I l' a n d I h l' I l I y ri a n s ,
a l o n g w i t h the i r fa m i l il's t o t a l l i n g i n a l l 20,000, were sl,tt l ed on M ou nt O rbcl us in ea ste rn Pal'oll i a on the fro n t i e r o f M a ce donia and Thrace, Thcir m igrat i o n w a s attri b u tcd to the plague of fro g s (along with mice or rats ) b u t they were t re ated realisti cally by thc s ini ste r Cassander, who in ty p ical Macedonian fa s hi on sought to e xpl o it thcm as an al l y against the n o rth e rn nei gh bours of his territory , Behind th e th reat of the fro gs and other creatu res may have been the real th r eat from the Celts now p res sin g into the southern Balkans. It is rep o rted tha t Cassander d i d fight with Ce lts in Thracc, p e rha p s to d r iv e off an atte m pt ed raid on M a cedonia . Th e sto ry that the su fferings of the Il lyri an Autariatac was retribution by thc divine A p o l lo o f D elph i for th eir having j o ined i n the atta ck o n his sanctuary in 279 BC is un do ubt ed l y a fi ction by those eager to c l a i m the cred i t for any misfortune s u ffe rc d by the Ill yri an s d u ri ng that perio d . Celtic pressure may have been the rcason for the disper sal of oth e r groups of Autariatae, such as the 2,000 se r vi n g in the army of Ly s i ma ch u s d uring the w i n te r of 3 02/ 1 BC w h o wcnt over to ' O ne - ey ed ' Anti go n u s. Perhaps their mercenary service commenced when Lysi m a chus made expeditions against the Ge tae on the lower Danubc. Whatever the background to th e se incidents it is around the end of the fourth centu ry that the name of the Autariatae vanishes from the h istori cal record, alt h o ugh thcrc is n o th in g in the matcrial evidence from thcir homeland th at indicates any su dden o r d r a m at i c ch a nge .22 Wc are i nde b ted to th c geograp h e r Stbo for a s in gularl y ambiguous portrayal of the Dardanians: 'they are so utte r l y wild that they dig caves beneath their dung-hills and live th e re; but still they have a ta s te for music and are al w ays p la ying m usical instruments, both flutes and st r i n gs ' (7. 5 , 7). Th o ugh their territory and eth n i c associations remain in doubt, the Dardani were for several centuries an end u r ing presence among thc peoples of th e central B a l k an s, 'the most stable and con se rvati ve ethnic element in an a r c a where everyth ing was e xp ose d t o con stan t chan ge ' as the Yugosl av scholar Fanoul a .1.2 Papazogl u 1 970a, 1.978, Cassander and the Auta riatae: Diodorus Siculus 20. 1 9 ; Justi nus 1.5.2; Orosius, Historia 3 . 2 3 , 26; Delphi : Appian, lllyrike 4; Antigonus : Diodorus Sicu l us 20. 1 1 .3 .
1 ', I/ I '/11II ',� "l '1'1 . 11 " . 11 1 1/1. 1
1 4 .'1
Pa p a zog l ll P ll t s i t . Wh i l l' t h e o n u' f O l' l l 1 l d a h l l' A l I t a r i a t a l' h a d v a n i s h l'<.1 l o n g hdo rl' t h e R O l l l a n l o n l j l l l'st . a n d t h e Tr i ha l l i . Sl'ord i sl' i a n d M Ol's i a l l d l'l: l i nl'd t o i n s i g n i f i l'a n t relll n a nts, t h e Da rda n i l' n d l l rl'd . I n t h e ( ; rl'ek a n d R o m a n w o r l d s t h e h u m b l e I 1 1 l 1 s i l- l ov i n g Da rda n i i n th e i r rl' l11ote va lleys beyond Mace don i a Gl l1l e to he l i n ked with a people of the s a me name who d w e l t i n north west Asia M i nor , and who gavc the i r name to t h l' d i strict of Dardan i a from which the modern name Dard a m'l les is derived . Other coincidcnces of ethnic names supported n o t i o n s of a co n n ection between the Balkans and Asia Minor, t he Mysians in the latter match i n g the Balkan Moesians and the P hry gia n s correspondi ng to the Bryges. A curren t cxpla n a t ion cites as a like l y context the large-scale m o v cment of peoples at the end of the Bronze Age (around 1 200 BC) , w hen some of the established powers around the castern Mediter ra nean were a fflicted by the attacks of ·sea-pcoples'. By Roman
t i mes the nature of the connection between Balkan and Asian Da rdani had become altogcther a m ore de li cate matter. Then t he co n nec tion was explained by a m o ve ment in the opposit e d i rection : a certain Dardanus who ruled ovcr many tri b e s in Asia Minor was responsible for settl in g the Dardani west of the Thracians. Tradition had it that th is Dardanus was founder o f thc Trojan ruling housc , a matter of some importance when t h e rulers of so m e of the great powers of antiquity, i n cluding Epirus, M acedonia and Rome, claimed a Trojan ancestry . But if Dardanus a nd his people w ere descended from the Bal kan pcople the lattcr ' s notoriously uncouth ways wil l have been an embarrassment. The a cce pted vcrsion was that the Dardani were a kindred people of the Trojans who had degcncrated in thei r new ho m e to a state of barbarism.23 Though for a time probably subordinate to the powcr of Epirus, the Dardani maintained an i ndependence that was later eroded by Maccdonia and finall y extinguished by the Romans. It s ee ms likely that the IIl yria n Clcitus defeated by Alexander was probably a r uler of the Dardani. After 3 3 5 BC nothing is reported of th em , not even when the neighbouring Paeonians
H On Dardan ians: Papazoglu 1 978, 1 3 1 ff., Srejovic 1 973 (formation ) ; settlements: Mikulcic 1 973, Mirdita 1 975 , M . Garasanin 1 975 a .
1 46
( ; ,." ,,/.: I IIVI'I,ms
J l l \H ;, ft l' r t ill' lka t h o f i\ it- x a n dl' \" u n t i l lH4 II( whcn Lysi m adl ll s SCi l.l'd l:on t ro l of M a l:cdon i a a n d Pal'o n i a , wherc a dcceit ca u s c d A ri s to n , thl' son o f k i n g A u d o it- o n , to take refuge among the Da rd a n i . N o t long a fter the death o f Lysimachus i n 28 1 B C a large force of Celts moved sou th th ro ugh thc central Bal kans and, l ate in 280 or carly in 279, overwhelmed the army of Macedonia under Ptolemy Cera u n u s . During his brief reign the latter h a d faced opposition from Ptolemy thc son of L ys im ach us, who was aidcd by Monunius king of the IIlyrians. A n inscribed bronze helmet found near Ohrid m ay have be l onged to a soldier of th i s ruler (see figure 1 7) . He may have belonged to the Dardani s i ncc a la ter ruler of that p eople bore the same name, tho ugh it also occurs i n the old Thracian territories o f Lysimach us. I t is not certain that he is the samc Monunius who offered help against thc Celts to Ptolemy Ceraunus. The gesture was rejccted with contempt, as if the sons of Alexander's all-conquering soldiers needed help from thc likes of Dardan ians, even when they came as 20,000 men in arms. The Dardanian king's response was to forecast the down fa l l of Macedonia. A co i n of Macedonian type b ea ring the name of Monunius m ay be evidence for thc aspirations of the Dardanian ruler in the kingdom, perhap s in the ti m e of confu sion fol l owing the Celtic invasion. Nor is i t certain if this was the same ruler who ga i ned power over the Taula ntii and struck a coin of Dyrrhach ium with the l egend King Monunius. 2 4 Thc ra pi d decline of Epirus following thc dea th of Pyrrhus in 272 BC may h ave been hasten ed by atta cks from o n ce obedient northern neigh bours. Alexander 11 is kno w n to have fought an l I I yrian war against Myti l u s whose Dyrrhachium coins bear thc royal title. Conceivably the latter was a successor to M on u n ius and ruler of th e increasingly powcrful Dardani, rather than merely a local dynast. While Dardanians may have taken con trol of the Tau l a n ti i , it seems that the principal directions of thcir expansion were now towards the cast and north, agai ns t Paconia and into the Morava and Nisava val leys against the rc bd l nl in
24
24
Polyaenus 4, 1 2, .3
(Monllnius) .
(Audol�on); Justinus 24.
9-1 1 , Pompci us
Trogus
Pro \ .
1 47
Figure 1 7 B ronze helmet inscribed ' Of King Monun ios '
Triballi. Unlike Macedonia, the Dardanians had apparently suffered l ittle from the passage of the Celts throu gh their lan d s , though i t was in th e i r territory that Lonovius and Lutarius deta ch e d them selves from the main force to mo ve ag a i n st
1 4H
( ; rl'I'�' IIIvrj, IIH
Th race, w h i k t h l' rt'st l'Oll t i l l l l l'l1 sou t h I I lH k r l\ rl'I l I l I l S to M a lT d o n i a a nd G n.'l'l'l'. Th e 1 );) rd a n i a n s w e n : n o t s l o w to ;l t t ;K k w h e n t h ey returned n o r t h a ftt' r defe a t , w a n d e r i n g a b o u t t h e c o u n try s ide exhausted w i t h h u n ge r and col d . ! � Save for a doubtful episode early i n t h e l ong rei gn of A nt i gonu s Gonatas, there is n o record of action b y the Dardani o r any other nor th ern e r s in the direction of Macedonia fo r n ea r l y a generation. From later ev i den ce it see m s that this \\'as a period of recovery and consolidation on the northern fron ti e rs of Macedonia, incl uding the construction of new fortifications, watch-towers and other means of defence that rarely attract the attention of historians. Dardanians were again a th reat i n the re i gn of Demetrius II (240/3 9-229 BC), when they invaded Paeo n i a and wo n a v i cto ry over the Macedonian king not long before his death. Longa ru s , the first to be n a med ruler of th e Dardanians, directed the attack. Events in this a rea now b eco m e m o r e p ro min e n t i n th e affairs of Greece and Macedonia, since a thre at from the north was likely to cause the Antigonids to abandon any enterprise under way in Greece an d hasten
home.26 Antigonus Doson, regent for the first decade of Demetrius' son PhiI i p V, claimed a victory over the Dardanians 'exultant a fter th e de ath of Demetrius'. Part of Paeon ia was annexed to Macedonia and Anti gone i a was founded on the river Axius, the main invasion route from the north. In 222 BC Doson won a famous victory over the Spartans at Sellasia, but hastened back home with in a few d a y s when news came that the Illyrians had i nvaded and were l oo ti n g his k i n g do m . Acc o rd i n g to Pol yh ius he found them still in the country and forced them to a battle which he won but he so over-exerted himself in shouting en cou ragement to his troops that he bu rst a b lo od -v e s s e l and fell fatally ill. I t seems likely that these Illyrians came from Dardania, since it was the Dardani who were again prominent in attacks on Macedonia in the first yea rs of Philip V's sole reign. During the Social War against the Aetolians and Spartans (220-2 1 7 BC), ' th e Dardan ians and a l l the neighbouring peoples 25 Passage of Celts : livy Diodorus Siculus 22.9. 26
J 8 . 1 6, Pausan ias 1 0. 1 9, 7;
Pompeius Trogus 2 8 , livy J 1. 2 8 , J ustinus 2 8 3 , 4 .
retreat:
J ustinus 24 . 8 ,
hll'lIIil'.�
"I
M", l'd"III,'
1 4 lJ
who dll' r i s h l'd l' v c r l a st i l l � h a t red ( I t t he M an'doll i 'l Il lks p i scd t ill' you t h o f Ph i l i p a n d n l l l st a llt l y p ro v o k l'd h i m ' (/ lIst i n ll s 2 1.) . 1 ) . Pol y h i u s lk'sni hl's w h .l I m m t h a v l' hl'l'n a ty p i l:a l cpisodc i ll t h l'sl' Yl·a rs . In 2 1 1.) Ph i l i p was i n AGl rn a n i a i n northwest ( ; rl'l'l'l' whcn news Gl m e that the Da rdanians, assu m i ng that Ill' w a s Oil his way to the Pelopon nese, collected their forces for a r:l i d . When Ph i l i p reached h i s capital Pella he found that the Da rd a n i had learned of his return and cal l ed off the attack, l' n a h l i n g Ph i l i p to send h i s men home early for the autumn fru i t-picking. Two years later Philip decided to strike first and sl·i zcd Byla zora, 'the largest city in Paeonia, very conveniently si tuated on the pass from Dardania to Macedonia ' ( pol ybius S . 1.) 7 ) . The situation, probably the modern Titov Veles on thc river Vardar, commands the upstream entrance to a long defile a n d , no less important, a rou te southwestwards into Pelagonia via the Babuna valley and over the Babuna pass or along the Raec val l ey and over the Pletvar pass to Pril ep. The capture a nd, one assumes, the garrisoning of Bylazora appears to have hrought a swi ft end to Dardanian raids, and may be compared w i th the capture and occupation of Lychnitis a century and a h a l f before by Philip II foll owing his defeat of Bardylis. As Macedonia was finally gaining what passed for peace on i ts northern bordcr, Ph ilip, the IIIyrians and the Grceks were concentrating their attcntion westwards on the great struggle bei ng fought in Italy between the Romans and the Carthagi n i a n s under Hannibal ,27 Even the Roman allies who had felt abandoned when the Romans agreed a peace with Philip in 205 BC will have becn su rprised at the speed with which they returned to the area once the war with Hannibal and Carthage was over. Philip had profited from the armistice and his ambitious schemes in the direction of Asia Minor were evidently no longer hindered by troubles on his northern borders , When the Romans returned to I I I yria in 200 BC undcr the experienced commander P. Sulpiciu s Galba, they expected support fro m their former allies. These began to appear at the Rom an headquarters in Dassaretis,
17 Philip V and DarJallia ns: Hammond a n d Wal bank 1 9 8 8 . Polybius 2.70 (Doson), 4.66 (2 1 9 BC) , 5 .97, Miku)cic l 976 (Bylazora) .
( ; " · f · k "'vrt, III ,
Fro m t h e D a r d a n i Cl l l l l' B a l o , son o f I h l' I .o n �a r l l s w h o h a d once fo ugh t a ga i n s t Ph i l i p ' s Lu l ll' r I k n ll' l ri u s 1 1 . Th l' R o m a n com m a nder to l d t h e m h e wo u l d cl l l o n t h e i r h e l p w h l' n h i s
army had entered M acedon i a . .! s The king an tic i p a t e d that the R o m a n l i n e o f a d v a n ce w o u l d be i n to th e Erigon valley and he w a s determ i ned to p ro te c t h i s fla n k s from raids b y Roman al l ies, the A e toli a n s i n t h e sOllth
and the Dardanians in the north . He ordered his son Perseu s to block the pass (probably th e Deb reste pass via the Treska va l l ey ) l e a ding into Pelagonia , When th e Romans m ade their move P h i l i p recalled the troops under Pe rs e us , and h i s caval ry defeat at Ottolobus on the river Erigon, though not a major reverse, was the ou tc o me of a gamble after learning that Illyri ans and Dardanians had crossed the passes in st rength and were a l re ad y in M a ce d onia . Though the i n v a s io n s were co n ce rted, it was the Dardan i a n s w h o did the most damage, Whe n P h i l i p s commander Athenagoras tri ed to am bush th em on the home ward march they rec ov e red from th e effects of th e surprise attack to form up in regular order and fi gh t a ba t tle in which n eithe r side was able to claim victory. L a t e r some of the Dard anians were killed or wounded by the Macedonian cavalry, but no pri s o n ers were taken b e cause these troops do not leave their ran ks i mp u lsively but keep close order both in co m bat and i n withdrawa l ' ( L i vy 3 1 .43 ) . The episode shows how m uch the Dardanians had been influenced by the m ilitar y traditions of the Hel len i stic world. Two years l a te r a Roma n ge n er a l addressing his troops on the eve of t heir victory over P h ili p at Cynoscephalae reminded th e m that they were not u p aga ins t the M acedon ians of Alexander but merely those who not long before had b een a p re y of the Dardanians. N ew s of the Roman v i ctory drew th e Dardanians once again d ow n the Vardar v a l l ey , b ut P h i l i p caught and defeated them near the Paeonian capital Stobi with an army h e h a d h a s ti l y co n s cripted from the citi es of h i s k i ngdo m . The Macedonians continued to ho l d '
'
2K
Liv y J 1. 1 S
(Bato, son of Longarus) .
/ -'/1/'/111/',\
I II hi " , /'' /",//"
I�I
l\y l .l l.o r a .1 I l d I h ro u g h I h a l P o l l'O l l l , I , w h o'l' H' l u m I h l' J ) a rd ;l I l i a l l s W lTl' sl i l l l k m ; J l l d i l l g W Y l' , I r<, 1 .1 1 l' !" .l ft l' !" a l l o t l l l' r m a j o r R O l l l a l l v i � to r y , ." · I n t il l' l a l l' !" y ea rs o f h i s re i g l l Ph i l i p V l a u n � h ed a ll o ffell sive a g;l i n s t h i s northern n e i gh bours, a ho v e a l l aga i n s t the Dardani a n s , T h c R o m a n version i m p l i cs t h a t beh ind i t there lay a plan fo r r c v c n gc o n the Rom ans, e v e n to the exten t of planning a l l i n l"rcd i b l e ove r l a n d expcdition across the Balkans to Italy, Th ough m o s t of the storics regarding t h e aims of Ph i l ip wcrc
l i kely fictions emanating from his enemies in Greece, it scems Philip had grasp cd h ow Rome might be threatened in the a rea where Italy was weakest, fro m across the Julian A l ps in the northeast. Aga i nst a ba c k g ro u nd of rising distr u s t a n d suspicion, both states may h ave become aware of the long but n ot im po ssi ble routc across the Bal kans, down the Morava to the arca of Belgrad e , th en west u p t h e Sava val ley. It may have been during these ye ar s , betwcen th e second and third wars of Rome and Macedonia, that the eastcrn and northern a pproaches to thc llIyrian lands first became known to th e Greek and Roman world, a l th o ugh morc than one and a hal f centu ries w o u ld elap s e before, in the pri n cipate of Augustlls, a Roman a rmy would cross the Danube basin. While on ca mpaign in Thrace in 01 84 BC Philip sent agcnts to 'stir up the barbari ans along the river Danu be, that they might invade Italy' (Livy 39.35 ) . Two years l ater Philip was p leased to learn th at the Bastarnac had accepted h i s all iance and were offe ring a princess in ma rri a ge for o nc of h i s sons Perseus as i t turned out. This formidable people, evi dently o f German origi n, dwelt beyond the lower Danube but were often willing to j oin in expeditions far from their h o m elan d s . In the fo l l owing year we find Ph i l i p founding a new city on the river Erigon, wh ich was named Perseis in honour of h i s eldest son, and at th e same time ordering m ass deportati ons fro m Paeonia, where he then fi l led the towns with 'Thracians and othcr barharians, as being likely to remai n morc s ec u rely loyal to h i m in the coming hour of d ange r ' ( P olyb i u s 23 . 1 0), th at is, war with Rome. Th ree years l a ter, it is reported, a fter he had poss i b l e that
29
L i v y 3 1 3 8- 4 1 ; 3 3 . 1 9
(after CYlloscephalac) .
( .. " 'I'�' 1IIl''''. /II.� asse m h l ed h i s a r l l l Y a l S l o h , ;l I l d I I lo v l'd aga i n s l t i l l' Th LI l' i a n Maedi, h e hea ded fo r I h l' I Lt l' ' ' ' ' ' S l I l o l l n t a i n s hl'CI I l Sl' h e b e l icvcd thc story t h a t fro l l l t h l' t o p o I l l' « Hl l d sce t h l' B la c k Sea, the Adri atic, t h c Da n u be a n d t h e A l ps : ' to h a v e t h ese spread out before h i s eycs w o u l d h a ve, he thought, Il O s m a l l
weight i n determi n i ng h i s strategy i n a w a r with Rome' ( Li v y 40.2 1 ) .JO
In fact Philip's purpose for the Bastarn ae was more spccific to the secu rity of Macedonia : they were to eject the Dardanians and take over their country . It was a ty p i c a l ly ruthless yet real i stic scheme, and was later imitatcd in the Danube l ands on more than one occasion by the Romans. The Romans, or rather some of them, may have been receptive to stories that the Bastarnae were on their way to Italy accompani ed, i t was predicted, by the kindred Scordisci thro u gh whose lands th ei r route l ay . To get the Bastarn ae to Dardania the king had go n e to great trou ble and expense to arrange sa fe passage through the Th racians. They left home after a good dea l of hesitation but had got as far as Amphipol i s when, in the summer of 1 79 BC, news arrived that King Philip was dead. Soon th e re was trouble with the Th raci ans and the Bastarnae retreated to Donuca (perhaps Rila), a high mountain in western Thrace. After fu rther skirmishes some decided to return home and set off for Apollonia and Mesembria on thc Black Sea coast of Thrace, but the rest, under the leadersh ip of Clondicus, pressed on to Dardan i a and set about ejecting the population in accord ance with their arrangement with the late king. A full-scale wa r now ensued. Thc Dar d anian s , faced at first not only with attacks by the Bastarnac but also the Scordisci and Thracians, bla med the attack on the new King Perseus and asked the R o mans for help. The king den ied any responsibility and the Roma n s were inclincd to believe h i m , well aware that thcrc was anyway little that they could do in the matter. The Dardani were at first penned up in their strongh ol ds but held out until the allies of the Bastarnae h ad left and then attacked. The details arc not recorded but the Dardanians ev idcntly th rew .10 Philip a n d Bastarnae: Hammond and Walbank 1 9 8 8 , 469-70, Livy 39.35 (1 84 BC), 40.5 ( 1 8 2 lie:) , 3 9 ) 3 (Perseis). ..
1 ':/II '/IIII'S 1 1/ "'1 " 1 1,' /1 1111"
I(d
o u t t i ll' i n v ;ldl'l"s, from t l H' s t o r y t h , l t I I I I /� II( t i l l' B a s t a m a c l ost I ll a n y mcn a nd h o rscs w h i le lT o s s i n � t h l' IrOl.l' n l > a n ll hl' a n d t h a t a l l l o n � t h l' s u r v i vors w a s ( : I o n d i u l s w h o h a d l ed the pl'op k i nt o D a r d a n i a four yea rs l'a r l i n a n d who w o u l d a ppca r a�a i n s i x years l a t e r w i th his people i n M a�edonia as a potential a l l y o f Pe rseus aga i nst thc Romans, l ! A��e p t i n g the poss i b i l ity that Macedon ia could mount an i nvasion o f Ita l y by the ovcrl an d route through the IlIyrians, it sce m s that some belicved Rome in its turn cou l d get at Mace d o n i a from thc direction of northcrn Italy. This is thc only reasonablc expl anation for the behaviour of G. Cassius Long i n ll s, the Roman consul of 1 7 1 BC sent to oversee Roman i n terests in northeast Italy. The Scnate received a req ucst from t h e re�cntly fou n ded colony Aquileia for help with its defences a �a i nst the h osti l e Histrians and I1Iyrians. When they suggested t h a t th i s m ight be a suitable matter for thc consul Cassius the scna tors werc astonished to hcar that some ti me beforc hc had ascm bled his army at Aquilcia and, with 3 0 days' rations and �lIi des wh o knew the way, had set off for Macedonia th rough the l a n d of the Illyrians. The senators were indignant that thc mnsul had abandoned his provincc, was i n tending to trcspass on anothcr's, was l eading his army by a dangerous route th rough foreign peoples and had left Italy cxposed to attack from all d i rections. The troubles of Aquileia were forgotten as th ree senators were sen t to tell thc consul that he was not to engage any people unless the Senate had already decl ared war on them. Next year we find the Senate rcceiving furious com plaints against Cassius, from the Gauls, Carni, Histri and J a podes. Apparen tly the consul and h is army had sct out for Macedoni a peacably enough but then came back kill i n g, burn ing and looting in all di rections. The Sen ate disclaimcd any responsibility for this conduct and announced that had they known they would never have approved thc enterprise. But the former consul was now a military tribune with the army in 11 Livy 40.57-8 , 4 1 . 1 9 ( 1 76 BC), Polyhiu s 25.6 ( 1 77/6 nc) . A Macedoni an settlement at Isar-Marvinci ( ? Idomene) may have becn devastated in this w a r , Sokolovska 1 979-8 2, Sokolovska and Mikulcic 1 9 8 5 . An o v e r l a n d assa ult on Italy from the direction of the Balkans was latcr contemplated by Mith ridates of Pontus and, reputedly, by (he Dacian king Burebista in 49 li e. =
1 .'1 ·t
( ; r," '/': "h'"o I",'
M a cc d o l l i a a l l l l , s i l l l..'l' h l' l'I l l d d 1 1 0 1
he l' h a r�l'd w i l h I h cse
com p l a i n ts i l l h i s a hsclKc, I h l' Se l l �l I l' l'I l l d d d o n o m o rc t h a l l promise a fa i r h ea r i n g i f t h e y w i s l1l'd t o p roscclI te h i m 0 1 1 retu rn from active serv i ce. I n th e mea n t i m c t h e Sen a t e paci fied t h c aggrieved peoples with s u i table presents, i ncl uding 2 0 0 0 a sses in cash for each of the envoys and for Cincibi l is, the prince o f the Gau ls, a n d h i s brother w h o had come as an envoy, two five-pound neckl aces of twisted gold, five 20-pound silver ves sels, two horses with h arness trappings for head and chest, along with their grooms, caval ry weapons and m i l i tary cloaks, and cloth ing for thc prince's attendants, both free and slave, The Gauls molested hy Cassi us arc descri hed as dwelling 'across the Alps', and they are likely to havc been Cel tic peoplc across the J ulian Al ps, beyond the Carn i and Histri and north of the Japodes. From this area also may have come thc Gallic ch ief Bal anus who came to Rome in thc following year to offcr help against Macedon ia. He too received presents, a two-pound gol d necklacc, a horse with ornamental trappi ngs and caval ry weapon s.·n During the l ong reign of Phil ip V there arc signs that the Macedonians were creating a scheme of defencc to keep out th e Dardanians and other 'eternal enemies'. It was based on well-chosen forti fied strongholds manned with permanent gar risons : Bylazora on the Vardar/Axius, Si ntia probably some whcre to the west (perhaps around Kicevo or Gostivar) and Perseis on thc river Erigon ( Crna Reka). Beyond these places whole areas werc cleared of population and systematically devastated in order to make invasi on and retreat even more hazardous. In the th ird war between Rome and Macedonia we hea r of an em bassy from Perscus to the IlIyri an Gentius early in 1 69 RC leaving Stuberra on the upper Erigon for Scodra and 'crossing Mount Scardus, journeying through the so-called desert of II lyria, which, some years before, had been de populated by the Macedonians to make it more difficult fo r the Dardanians to raid IlIyria and Macedonia. Their journey through th is region was accompanied by great h ardship' (Polybius 2 8 . 8 ) . Along with these strongholds and cordons of .Il
Livy 4 1. 1 -7, 43 . 1 and S .
i ', " , -III1'-S "l M . I I I-. /I IIII.I
dl'v a s t a t i o l 1 it Sl'l' I I l S d l' a r t h a t t h l' dqlO P l I l .l l i o l 1 0 1 Pal'< lIl i a a n d t h e sl, t t l i n g t h nl' o f Th r;Ki a n s h a d l 1 0 t h i n g t o d o w i t h a n y i l11 pl' I l(,l i n g w a r a ga i n s t R o m e h u t w a s y l' l a n o t h e r e 1 e lllent i n t h e d dl' lKl' o f M a cedon i a , When w a r hega n i n 1 7 1 lie, Perseus s t i l l j u d ged it w o r t h w h i l e to m a ke a pre-e m pti v e stri ke against the D a rd a n i a n s , ' by the way, i n contempt of the Roman power a n d a s a d i version ' (Pl u ta rch, Aemilius Paul/us 9), it was clai med, He reportedly kil led many of them and brought back a great amount of booty, Because of this, and because of the now \'Vell-establ i shed cordon of defence, the Dardanians appear to have taken no part in a war which was to bring to an end t h e r u le o f kings in Macedonia.·H
.1.1
Hammond and Wal hank 1 9 !1 !l , Sokol ovska 1 97!l (Dcm i r Kapi j a ) , MikulCic Papazogl u 1 970b, Hatzopoulos 1 9 8 7 (inscri ption from OJeveni nea r Bitoli, recording Macedonian victory over Dardanians by Phili p 1 I or
1 985 (Stobi ) ,
V),
6
Kingdom of Illyrians
A
new
power on the Adriatic I
From the end of the fifth century we h ave seen how it was possible for regimes among the southern lllyrians to exploit periods of weakness in Macedonia and Epirus, nota bly Bardylis of the Dardan i and Glaucias of the Taulantii. Under a Philip, Alexander or Pyrrhus the tide was reversed and the Illyrians were not only held off but even reduced to subject status. Th e dyn asty of the Antigon i ds in third-century BC Macedon ia was far from weak but was more than once distracted from its effort to retain power in Greece by trouble on the northern fronti er. There is now an impression, although it can be no more than that, of a new and more lasting political order emerging among the IIIyrians, not only among the Dardanians. The most notable example of this was the rise of a new power based on the Ardiaei, an lllyrian people on the south Adriatic coast well placed to profit from the decline of Epirus after th e death of Pyrrh us. Agron , son of Pleuratus, belonged to the ruling house of the Ardiaei : ' Agron was king of that part of IIIyria which borders the Adriatic sea, over which sea Pyrrhus and his successors had held sway. In turn he captured part of Epirus and also Corcyra, Epidamnus and Pharos in succession, and established garrisons in them' (Appi an lllyrike 7) . The new
I Hammond an d Wal bank 1 98 8 , Hammond 1 96 8 (229-205 BC), Wilkes 1 969, May 1 946 (2 1 7- 1 6 7 BC), Isl ami 1 9 74, 1 9 76a, Ca banes 1 986.
power d i sposed of ' I he mosl pl l w n t I I I t o rn" hOI h hy l a n d a n d 'il'a , o f a n y o f I h l' k i ngs w h o h a d rl' i g l l l'd i n I I l y r i a hefore h i m ' , Wl' a re i n formcd h y Po l yhius ( 2 . 2. ) . T h l' I l I y r ians u s e d the k m b u s , a s m a l l and fa st wars h i p w i l h a s i ngle bank of oars w h i ch co u l d carry 50 soldiers i n a d d i t i o n to the rowers. Raids hy sea fro m the A d r i a ti c were probably a familiar threat to the north western Greeks. Wh at was new was the use of a land a rm y to follow up and pro fit from victories gained by the J navy . I n 234 BC the royal succession i n Epirus came to an end and -
a federal republic was instituted. In the south, the western part of Acarnani a seceded from this arrangment. Their independence was soon threatened by the Aetolians who began to occupy territory around the Gulf of Ambracia, including Pyrrhus' old capital Ambraci a, which forced the Epirotes to establish a new centre at Phoenice. Besieged at Medion , the Acarnanians sough t assistance from Demetrius 11 of Macedonia, w h o for most of his reign had been at war with the Aetolian and Achaean Leagues. In response to the request the k i ng brought Agron and his IIIyrians on the scene. The IIIyrian attack mounted in either 232 or 23 1 BC is described by Polybius. One hun dred lembi with 500 men on board sailed up to l and at Medion. Dropping a nchor at daybreak, they disembarked speedily and in secret. They then formed up in the order that was u sual in th e i r own cou n try, and advanced in th eir sev eral companies against the Aetolian l i nes. The latter were overwhelmed with atonishment at the unexpected nature and boldness o f the move; bu t they had long been inspired with overweening self-confidence, and h aving full rel i a n ce on their own forces were fa r from bei ng dismayed. Th ey drew up the greater part of their hoplites a n d cavalry in front of their own l i nes on the l evel ground, and with a portion of their cavalry and their ligh t i n fantry they hastened to occupy some rising ground in front of th eir camp, wh ich nature had m ade easily defensible. A single ch arge, however, of the Iilyrians, whose n umbers and dose o rder gave them i r resistible weigh t, served to dislodge the light-armed troops, and forced the caval ry who were on the ground with them to reti re to the hop lites. But the Illyrians, being on higher ground, and ch arging down from it upon th e Aetolian troops formed up on 2
Hammond 1 96 8 (kingdom of Agro n ) .
( ; 'I'I'�' 111,, 11, 111.\ t h t, p la i n , fO u t ed t lW I I I w i t h o u t d l i l i u d t y , Tht' ,\kd H I I l I , l I l s I O l l l t'd t h t' action by sa l l y i n g O l l t of t h e t o w n a nd ( h a rgi ng t h e A e t o l i a l l s , Th u s , after ki l l i n g a g r e a t n u m be r , a n d t a k i ng a s t i l l g rea t t' r I l l l lll bt' f p r i s oners, a n d beco m i n g masters a l so o f t h e i r a rllls a n d baggagt', t h e
lIIyrians, having carried ou t the orders o f their k i ng, con veyed t h e i r bagga ge a nd the rest of their booty to t h ei r boats and i m med i a t e l y set sail fo r their own cou n rry , (Jlolybius 2.3)
This defeat of the Aetolians, famed for thei r vi ctory over the invadi ng Gau l s a generation before, caused a s e n sation in Greece, Agron was heside h i mse l f with del i ght when his ships returned and he learned of the vi ctory from his commanders. The king then drank so much by way of celehration, it was reported , th at th is, and ' othe r similar indulgences', brought on an atta c k o f ple u ris y which killed him within a few days . ; I1Iyrian succes s contin ued when com mand passed to Agron's widow Teuta, who gran te d individual ships a l i cence to uni v er sal pl unde r . In 23 1 BC the fleet and army at tacked El is and Messen ia in the Pelopon n ese. On the way home they called for supplies at P h oeni ce in Epi rus, which, for a consideration, the garrison of 800 G au l ish mercenaries handed o v e r to them. The Epirotes, who had evi dently not been i nvolved in recent even ts, qui ckly assem bled an army to relieve the town . News that the I1Iyrian Scerdilaidas was march ing south th r o u gh the pass at Antigoneia caused the E p i rote s to send pa r t of their forces north to secure th at town. At Phoenice the Epirote s beca me careless and during the night the Ill y rians were able to leave the town, cross the river - after repl aci ng the wooden b r idge whi ch the besiegers had partly dismantled - and take up a good posi tion to offer battle, which they proceeded to w i n the next day. The scale of the fighting now began to i ncrease. The Epiro tes had al ready begged ass i stance from the Greek Leagues, while the II l yrians , having j oi n ed up with the force under Scerdilaidas, marche d inland to Hal icranum (in the plain of modern I o annina ) . Here they were preparing to do ba ttle with the Leagues, and were choo s ing a good site, when orders to wi thdraw arrived from Queen Teuta , on the grounds that some of the IIIyrians had gone over to the Dardani . A truce was .I
Hammond 1 9 67h,
591
and 595 f.
1\ /IIgdl llll
1 1/
1 1/\,// , / 1 1 ,\
aWl'l' d , Phm' n i n' W;I S re t u rned t l l r , I p r i n. . . d o n g w i t h t rn' horn p r i s o n l' l" s , S l a v l's and t h l' loot W l' I'l' p l l t o n t he s h i p s w h i k I h l' a r m y I I n d e r Sn' rd i l a i d a s m a rl'ill'd n o r t h b y the pass at A n t i go n l' i a , Th e con t i n ued I l l y r i a n S l l l'Cl'SS w a s another shock fo r the G reeks : ' fo r seei n g the m o s t securely placed and power fu l ci ty of Epirus th us unexpected l y r e d uce d to slavery, they onc and all began to feel anxious, not merely as in former t i mes fo r their property in open country, but for the safety of t h e i r own persons and cities' (Polybius 2.6) . The Epi rotes signi
fied their acceptance of the Illyrian victory by sending envoys to Teuta promising cooperation with them and hosti l i ty towards the Leagues. Teuta was del ighted with the profits of the cxpedi tion. Phoenice was the m ost prosperous place in Epirus, and ccntre for thc growi ng commerce with Italy. It was Illyrian interference with that commerce which bro ught Roman forces across thc Adri atic for the first time." Even beforc the first war against Carthage (264 -24 1 RC ) , from which they gaincd control of Sicily, the Romans had bccn aware of the danger to the Adriatic coast of Italy from seaborne attack. In 246 a colony of Roman citizens was scttled at Brundisium to keep a watch on thc Ionian gulf. ' From time im memorial JI lyrians had attacked and robbed ships sailing from Italy' ( Polybi us 2 . 8 , 1 ) . During their occupation of Phoen ice a number of the IlIyrian ships had cngaged in privateeri ng against Italian merchants. So many were now robbed, mu rdered or captured th at the Roman Senatc, after ignoring earl ier com plai nts, realized that something had to be done. Polybius (2. 8 ) furnishes a suspiciously vivid account o f a Roman embassy to Queen Teuta, a version of cvents that was intended to j usti fy the Roman invasion of Illyri a. ' It was l ed by thc brothers L. and Gn. Coruncanius. On a rrival they found Teuta celebrating the end of a rebcllion i n Illyria and engagcd in laying siege to the Greek island city Issa (Vis), 'the last town which held out'. When the ambassadors compl ained of injurics to Romans, Teuta promi sed that no royal forces would harm them but said she was unablc to put an end to thc tradition of private enterprise. One of the ambassadors lost h i s temper an d prom-
4
Dcl l l 967b (IIIyrian
motives in 230
BC),
1 ('( )
( ; 'I'I,k IIlvlic llls
i sed 'to i m p ro v e re l a t i o n s Iwt wl'l' n sov e r e i gn a n d s u h j e c t i n I l I y r i a ' , The q u een hea rd t h i s ' w i t h w O l 11 a n i s h passion a n d u n reasoning ange r ' a n d a r ra n ged fo r th e i n so l e n t en voy t o b e murdered on his homeward voyage. News of th i s caused t h e
Romans to prepare for war: legions were en l isted and the fleet assem bled, and there was general i ndignation at 'the queen's violation of the law of nations'.5 The Roman invasion of IlIyria in 229 B C appears to have caught Teuta and the II lyrians completely off guard. As soon as the weather permi tted, the queen had ordered south a naval expedition even larger than those of previous years, with most of the ships h eading for an attack on Corcyra . Some Landed at Epidamnus, entered the city to procure food and water with weapons concealed and almost captured i t ; but they were thrown out after a fight and the careless citizens thus 'received a useful l esson for the futu re' (Polybius 2.9, 6). These ships now joined the main II Iyrian force in the siege of Corcyra. The Corcyraeans, along with Apollonia and Epidamnus, sought assistance from the Leagues of Greece. Ten Achaean ships were engaged by the Illyrians, reinforced by seven warships of the Acarnani ans, off the island Paxos south of Corcyra. By superior tactics the IIIyrians took four tri remes and sank a quinquereme, while the rest of the Greeks managed to escape. Corcyra was surrendered and was occupied by a garrison under the com mand of Demetrius from the isl and of Ph aros (Hvar) . The main Illyrian force sailed north for another attack on Epidamnus. The IlIyri ans were now on the point of controlling all the coastline north of the Gulf of Corinth, including the sea routes to Sici l y and Italy via Corcyra.6 The Roman consul Gn . Ful vius had planned to sail his 200 sh ips to Corcyra to raise the si ege. Even when he l earned the island had surrendered he still sailed there, having already entered secret negotiations with Demetrius, who had fal len out of favou r with Teuta. Thus Corcyra welcomed the Romans and, with the compliance of Demetrius, surrendered the garri son . The city became a ' friend of Rome' and woul d hencefor ward rely on Roman protection from the I I I yrians. Demetrius ; There a rc discrepancies between t h e pro- Roman versi ons of Appian Polybius, Ham mond 1 9 6 8 , 5-6_ n
Polybius 2 . 9- 1 0.
and
I td
now sl· r v l·d a s ;l d v i sl' r t o t i l l' H 0 I 1 1 . 1 1 1 u l l l l l 1 1 a n d l' r s for t h e rest of t h e w a r . M ea n w h i l e t h l' r o n s l I l A. I 'ost 1 1 1 1 1 i l l S b rough t an a r m y o f 20,000 i n fa n tr y a n d .WOO Ll V a l r y a r ro s s from B ru n d is i 1 l 1l 1 to A po l i o n i a , w h i d1 now joi l 1 l'd the Homan a l l i a n ce. The fkl't I I n der Fu l v i u s reached A p o l i o n i a and the two forces a d v a n ced i n the d i rection of Epidamn us, ca using the Illyrians to a ba ndon the siege and disperse their forces. The city was rl'cei v ed into Roman protection and the army now m oved i n l and among the llIyri an peoples of the hinterland. Here the Romans received delegations from m any peoples, including the Ati ntan i and Parthini, from whom a formal surrender was accepted. At sea the blockade of Issa was raised and the city a l so was received into Roman protection. As the Romans approached the Il Iyrian heartl ands there was more resolute opposi tion. The fleet moved northwards and attacked IIIyrian l'oastal towns, at one of which, the unidentified Noutria, Roman losses included a magistrate of the Republic (quaestor) and some military tri bunes, al though 20 ships laden with plun der were intercepted. The besiegers of Issa fled to Arbo (not identified), and the queen herself retreated to Rhizon (Risan) , i n the Gulf of Kotor. The Romans decided that enough had been ach ieved and hostilities ceased. The consuls handed over IIIyria to Demetrius and withdrew the fleet and army to Epid amnus, from wh ich the greater part returned to Italy under fu lvius. Having assembled 40 ships and some troops from a l l ies in the area the other consul remained across the Adriatic to keep a watch on the Illyrian Ardiaei and the peoples under Roman protection. Before the end of wi nter, envoys of Teuta appeared in Rome and a treaty was concluded. According to its terms the queen would abandon Illyris, except for a few places, and promised not to sail south of Lissus at the mouth of the Drin with more than two ships, even then unarmed vessels. The terms of the settlement