The Human Bone Manual

I]Z =jbVc7dcZ BVcjVa

This Page Intentionally Left Blank

I]Z =jbVc7dcZ BVcjVa I^b9#L]^iZ E^ZiZg6#;da`Zch

6bhiZgYVb™7dhidc™=Z^YZaWZg\™AdcYdc CZlNdg`™Dm[dgY™EVg^h™HVc9^Z\d HVc;gVcX^hXd™H^c\VedgZ™HnYcZn™Id`nd

6Xfj^h^i^dc:Y^idg/CVcXnBVgV\^d\a^d Egd_ZXiBVcV\Zg/7gVcYnA^aan 6hhdX^ViZ6Xfj^h^i^dc:Y^idg/@ZaanHdccVX` BVg`Zi^c\BVcV\Zg/A^cYV7ZVii^Z 8dbedh^i^dc/6=^\]ZgEdged^hZ9Zh^\cciZg^dgEg^ciZg/I]ZBVeaZ"KV^a7dd`BVcj[VXijg^c\cX# IZmiVcY^bV\Zh/'%%*!I^b9#L]^iZE^ZiZg6gZcY;da`Zch ;gdciXdkZge]did\gVe]n/'%%*!E^ZiZg6gZcY;da`ZchI^b9#L]^iZ! 6aag^\]ihgZhZgkZY# CdeVgid[i]^hejWa^XVi^dcbVnWZgZegdYjXZYdgigVchb^iiZY^cVcn[dgbdgWnVcnbZVch!ZaZXigdc^X dgbZX]Vc^XVa!^cXajY^c\e]didXden!gZXdgY^c\!dgVcn^c[dgbVi^dchidgV\ZVcYgZig^ZkVahnhiZb!l^i]dji eZgb^hh^dc^clg^i^c\[gdbi]ZejWa^h]ZgdgVji]dgh# EZgb^hh^dchbVnWZhdj\]iY^gZXian[gdb:ahZk^Zg¼hHX^ZcXZIZX]cdad\nG^\]ih9ZeVgibZci^cDm[dgY! J@/e]dcZ/ ))&-+*-)(-(%![Vm/ ))&-+*-*((((!Z"bV^a/eZgb^hh^dch5ZahZk^Zg#Xd#j`#NdjbVnVahd XdbeaZiZndjggZfjZhidc"a^cZk^Vi]Z:ahZk^Zg]dbZeV\Z]iie/$$ZahZk^Zg#Xdb!WnhZaZXi^c\¹8jhidbZg HjeedgiºVcYi]Zc¹DWiV^c^c\EZgb^hh^dch#º H7C%"&'"%--)+,")XVhZWdjcY/Va`#eVeZg&#=jbVch`ZaZidc¸>YZci^ÄXVi^dc¸ =VcYWdd`h!bVcjVah!ZiX#'#=jbVch`ZaZidc¸6cVanh^h¸=VcYWdd`h!bVcjVah!ZiX# (#=jbVch`ZaZidc¸ 8aVhh^ÄXVi^dc¸=VcYWdd`h!bVcjVah!ZiX#)#=jbVcgZbV^ch 6gX]VZdad\n ¸=VcYWdd`h!bVcjVah!ZiX#*#;dgZch^XdhiZdad\n¸=VcYWdd`h!bVcjVah!ZiX# +#;dgZch^XVci]gdedad\n¸=VcYWdd`h!bVcjVah!ZiX#># ;da`Zch!E^ZiZg6#>>#I^iaZ# H7C/%"&'"%--)+,") ;dgVaa^c[dgbVi^dcdcVaa:ahZk^Zg6XVYZb^XEgZhhEjWa^XVi^dch k^h^idjgLZWh^iZVilll#Wdd`h#ZahZk^Zg#Xdb Eg^ciZY^ci]ZJc^iZYHiViZhd[6bZg^XV %*%+%,%-%.&%.-,+*)('& 

8dciZcih @bUVQSU #HAPTER

9^db_TeSdY_^ &#& &#' &#( &#)

!

=jbVcDhiZdad\n 6<j^YZidi]ZBVcjVa GZhdjgXZh[dgi]ZDhiZdad\^hi >YZci^[n^c\7dcZh

& ' * *

#HAPTER

6YU\T@b_SUTebUcV_bC[U\UdQ\BU]QY^c

'

'#& '#' '#( '#)

. '%

HZVgX] 9^hXdkZgn :mXVkVi^dcVcYGZig^ZkVa IgVchedgi

#HAPTER

5dXYScY^?cdU_\_Wi (#&

:i]^Xh^c;dgZch^XDhiZdad\n

 

(#&#& (#&#'

7djcYVg^Zhd[:k^YZcXZ I]Z:meZgiL^icZhh

(#'

:i]^Xh^c6gX]Zdad\^XVaDhiZdad\n

  

(#'#& (#'#' (#'#(

:i]^Xh^c8daa^h^dc C6<EG6VcY>ih:[[ZXih I]Z;jijgZ

"! '& '' '(

') '* '- '-

k

#HAPTER

2_^U2Y_\_WiFQbYQdY_^ )#& )#' )#( )#) )#* )#+ )#, )#-

#!

KVg^Vi^dc 6;Zl;VXihVWdji7dcZ 7dcZhVh:aZbZcihd[i]ZBjhXjadh`ZaZiVaHnhiZb
(& (( (( )% )' )' )+ )-

#HAPTER

@_cd]_bdU]C[U\UdQ\=_TYÍSQdY_^ *#& *#'

7dcZ;gVXijgZ 7dcZBdY^ÄXVi^dcWnE]nh^XVa6\Zcih

   

*#'#& *#'#' *#'#( *#'#)

*#(  

*#)   

8]Zb^hign GdX`!:Vgi]!VcY>XZ 6WgVh^dc ;^gZ

$) *% *' *' *) *) *)

7dcZBdY^ÄXVi^dcWnCdc]jbVc7^dad\^XVa6\Zcih *#(#& *#(#'

Cdc]jbVc6c^bVa EaVci

** ** *,

7dcZBdY^ÄXVi^dcWn=jbVch *#)#& *#)#' *#)#(

8jibVg`h!8]debVg`h!VcYHXgVeZbVg`h EZgXjhh^dcBVg`h Egd_ZXi^aZh

*, +% +' +'

#HAPTER

1^Qd_]YSQ\DUb]Y^_\_Wi +#& EaVcZhd[GZ[ZgZcXZ +#' 9^gZXi^dcVaIZgbh  +#'#&
+#'#' +#'#(

IZZi] =VcYhVcY;ZZi

+#( Bdi^dchd[i]Z7dYn  +#(#&
+#(#'

=VcYhVcY;ZZi

&' +, +++. +.

+. ,& ,'

+#)
k^

+#)#& Egd_ZXi^dchVcYEVgih +#)#' 9ZegZhh^dch

,' ,( ,)

#HAPTER

C[e\\  ,#& ,#' ,#( ,#) ,#* ,#+    

,#,    

,#-    

=VcYa^c\i]ZH`jaa :aZbZcihd[i]ZH`jaa
6cVidbn
,#,#& ,#,#' ,#,#( ,#,#)

6cVidbn
,#-#& ,#-#' ,#-#( ,#-#)

6cVidbn
,#&%#'
,#&&#'
,#&' EVaVi^cZh  ,#&'#& 6cVidbn   

,#&'#'
,#&( KdbZg  ,#&(#& 6cVidbn   

-, .& .& .&

.' .' .) .) .)

IZbedgVah

,#&& BVm^aaVZ  ,#&&#& 6cVidbn   

,* ,, -) -+ -, -,

EVg^ZiVah

,#. 6jY^idgnDhh^XaZh ,#&% DXX^e^iVa  ,#&%#& 6cVidbn   

'%

,#&(#'
,#&) >c[Zg^dgCVhVa8dcX]VZ  ,#&)#& 6cVidbn

.* .* ... ..

&%% &%% &%% &%( &%) &%)

&%) &%) &%+ &%, &%,

&%, &%, &%. &%. &%.

&%. &%. &&% &&% &&%

&&& &&&

k^^

  

,#&)#'
,#&* :i]bd^Y  ,#&*#& 6cVidbn   

,#&*#'
,#&+ AVXg^bVah  ,#&+#& 6cVidbn   

,#&+#'
,#&, CVhVah   ,#&,#& 6cVidbn   

,#&,#'
,#&- On\dbVi^Xh  ,#&-#& 6cVidbn   

,#&-#'
,#&. He]Zcd^Y  ,#&.#& 6cVidbn   

,#&.#'
,#'% BVcY^WaZ  ,#'%#& 6cVidbn   

,#'%#'
&&& &&& &&&

&&' &&' &&( &&( &&(

&&( &&( &&) &&) &&)

&&) &&) &&* &&* &&*

&&* &&* &&+ &&+ &&+

&&, &&, &'& &'& &'&

&'' &'' &'+ &'+ &'+

#HAPTER

4U^dYdY_^ -#& -#' -#( -#) -#*  

k^^^

!"'

9ZciVa;dgbVcY;jcXi^dc 9ZciVaIZgb^cdad\n 6cVidbnd[VIddi] Iddi]>YZci^ÄXVi^dc IdL]^X]8ViZ\dgn8aVhh9dZhi]ZIddi]7Zadc\4 -#*#& -#*#'

>cX^hdgh 8Vc^cZh

&', &'&(% &(& &() &() &()

 

-#*#( -#*#)

EgZbdaVgh BdaVgh

-#+ >hi]ZIddi]EZgbVcZcidg9ZX^Yjdjh4  -#+#& 9^V\cdhi^X8g^iZg^V 

-#+#'

HeZX^Va8VhZh

-#, >hi]ZIddi]VcJeeZgdgVAdlZg4  -#,#& JeeZgkZghjhAdlZg>cX^hdgh   

-#,#' -#,#( -#,#)

JeeZgkZghjhAdlZg8Vc^cZh JeeZgkZghjhAdlZgEgZbdaVgh JeeZgkZghjhAdlZgBdaVgh

-#- L]ZgZ^ci]Z6gX]>hi]ZIddi]AdXViZY4  -#-#& JeeZg>cX^hdgh/>&kZghjh>'     

-#-#' -#-#( -#-#) -#-#* -#-#+

-#. 

>hi]ZIddi][gdbi]ZG^\]idgi]ZAZ[iH^YZ4

      

-#.#& -#.#' -#.#( -#.#) -#.#* -#.#+ -#.#, -#.#-

AdlZg>cX^hdgh/>&kZghjh>' JeeZgEgZbdaVgh/E(kZghjhE ) AdlZgEgZbdaVgh/E(kZghjhE) JeeZgBdaVgh/B&kZghjhB'kZghjhB( AdlZgBdaVgh/B&kZghjhB'kZghjhB( JeeZg>cX^hdgh AdlZg>cX^hdgh JeeZg8Vc^cZh AdlZg8Vc^cZh JeeZgEgZbdaVgh AdlZgEgZbdaVgh JeeZgBdaVgh AdlZgBdaVgh

&(+ &(+

&(+ &(+ &(+

&(&(. &(. &)% &)&

&)' &)' &)' &)) &)) &)+ &), &)&)&)&)&). &). &*% &*' &*'

#HAPTER

8i_YTFUbdURbQU .#&    

.#'  

.#(   

.#) 

!%%

=nd^Y  .#&#& .#&#' .#&#( .#&#)

6cVidbn
&** &** &*+ &*+ &*+


6cVidbn
&*+ &*, &+'

8Zgk^XVaKZgiZWgVZ .#(#& .#(#' .#(#(

>YZci^ÄXVi^dc HeZX^Va8Zgk^XVaKZgiZWgVZ H^Y^c\

&+( &+( &+( &+.

I]dgVX^XKZgiZWgVZ .#)#&

>YZci^ÄXVi^dc

&,% &,%

^m

 

.#)#' .#)#(

.#* 

AjbWVgKZgiZWgVZ

 

.#*#& .#*#' .#*#(

HeZX^VaI]dgVX^XKZgiZWgVZ H^Y^c\ >YZci^ÄXVi^dc >YZci^[n^c\AjbWVgEdh^i^dc H^Y^c\

&,% &,+

&,+ &,+ &-% &-%

 #HAPTER

DX_bQh*CdUb^e]BYRc &%#& HiZgcjb  &%#&#& 6cVidbn   

&%#&#'
&%#' G^Wh   &%#'#& 6cVidbn    

&%#'#' &%#'#( &%#'#) &%#'#*

HeZX^VaG^Wh
!(! &-& &-& &-) &-) &-*

&-* &-* &-, &-, &-, &.'

#HAPTER

CX_e\TUb7YbT\U*3\QfYS\UCSQ`e\Q &&#& 8aVk^XaZ  &&#&#& 6cVidbn   

&&#&#'
&&#' HXVejaV  &&#'#& 6cVidbn   

&&#'#'
!)# &.( &.( &.* &.* &.*

&.* &.* '%& '%& '%'

#HAPTER

1b]*8e]UbecBQTYecE\^Q &'#& =jbZgjh  &'#&#& 6cVidbn

m

" # '%'%-

  

&'#&#'
&'#' GVY^jh  &'#'#& 6cVidbn   

&'#'#'
&'#( JacV   &'#(#& 6cVidbn   

&'#(#'
'&' '&) '&)

'&) '&) '&* '&* '&+

'&. '&. ''% ''% '''

#HAPTER

8Q^T*3Qb`Q\c=UdQSQb`Q\c@XQ\Q^WUc ""% &(#& 8VgeVah  &(#&#& HXVe]d^Y         

&(#&#' AjcViZ &(#&#( Ig^fjZigVa &(#&#) E^h^[dgb &(#&#* IgVeZo^jb
&(#' BZiVXVgeVah  &(#'#& ;^ghiBZiVXVgeVaI]jbW       

&(#'#' &(#'#( &(#'#) &(#'#* &(#'#+ &(#'#, &(#'#-

HZXdcYBZiVXVgeVa I]^gYBZiVXVgeVa ;djgi]BZiVXVgeVa ;^[i]BZiVXVgeVa
&(#( =VcYE]VaVc\Zh  &(#(#& Egdm^bVa=VcYE]VaVc\Zh     

&(#(#' &(#(#( &(#(#) &(#(#* &(#(#+

>ciZgbZY^ViZ=VcYE]VaVc\Zh 9^hiVa=VcYE]VaVc\Zh
''''. ''. '(% '(% '(& '(& '(' '(' '(( '((

'(( '(+ '(+ '(+ '(+ '('('(. '(.

'(. ')% ')% ')% ')% ')% ')%

m^

#HAPTER

@U\fYS7YbT\U*CQSbe]3_SSih?c3_hQU "$! &)#& HVXgjb  &)#&#& 6cVidbn   

&)#&#'
&)#' 8dXXnm &)#( Dh8dmVZ &)#(#& 6cVidbn    

&)#(#'
')& ')& ')) ')) ')*

')* ')+ ')+ '*' '*' '*'

#HAPTER


&*#&#'
&*#' EViZaaV  &*#'#& 6cVidbn   

&*#'#'
&*#( I^W^V   &*#(#& 6cVidbn   

&*#(#'
&*#) ;^WjaV   &*#)#& 6cVidbn   

&*#)#'
"%% '** '** '+, '+, '+,

',% ',% ',% ',% ',&

',& ',& ',. ',. ',.

'-% '-% '-& '-& '-&

 #HAPTER

6__d*DQbcQ\c=UdQdQbcQ\c@XQ\Q^WUc &+#& IVghVah

m^^

"(' '.'

     

  

&+#&#& &+#&#' &+#&#( &+#&#) &+#&#* &+#&#+ &+#&#, &+#&#- &+#&#.

IVajh 8VaXVcZjh 8jWd^Y CVk^XjaVg BZY^Va;^ghi8jcZ^[dgb >ciZgbZY^ViZHZXdcY8jcZ^[dgb AViZgVaI]^gY8jcZ^[dgb
&+#' BZiViVghVah  &+#'#& ;^ghiBZiViVghVa       

&+#'#' &+#'#( &+#'#) &+#'#* &+#'#+ &+#'#, &+#'#-

HZXdcYBZiViVghVa I]^gYBZiViVghVa ;djgi]BZiViVghVa ;^[i]BZiViVghVa
&+#( ;ddiE]VaVc\Zh  &+#(#& Egdm^bVa;ddiE]VaVc\Zh     

&+#(#' &+#(#( &+#(#) &+#(#* &+#(#+

>ciZgbZY^ViZ;ddiE]VaVc\Zh 9^hiVa;ddiE]VaVc\Zh
'.' '.) '.+ '., '.'.'.(%% (%%

(%% (%% (%* (%* (%* (%* (%+ (%+ (%+

(%+ (%+ (%+ (%+ (%, (%, (%-

#HAPTER

?cdU_\_WYSQ\4U^dQ\@QdX_\_Wi &,#& IgVjbV  &,#&#& ;gVXijgZ   

&,#&#' 9^hadXVi^dc &,#&#( 6gi^ÄX^Va9Z[dgbVi^dc &,#&#) IgZe]^cVi^dcVcY6bejiVi^dc

&,#' >c[ZXi^djh9^hZVhZhVcY6hhdX^ViZYBVc^[ZhiVi^dch  &,#'#& DhiZdbnZa^i^h   

&,#'#' EZg^dhi^i^h &,#'#( IjWZgXjadh^h &,#'#) IgZedcZbVa>c[ZXi^dch

&,#( 8^gXjaVidgn9^hijgWVcXZhVcY=ZbVided^Zi^X9^hdgYZgh &,#) BZiVWda^XVcY=dgbdcVa>bWVaVcXZ  &,#)#& HXjgkn   

&,#)#' G^X`Zih &,#)#( DhiZdedgdh^h &,#)#) :cYdXg^cZ9^hijgWVcXZhVcY9nheaVh^Vh

# ) (&' (&' (&) (&) (&*

(&, (&(&(&('%

('% ('( ('( ('( ('( (')

m^^^

&,#* Ijbdgh &,#+ 6gi]g^i^h  &,#+#& DhiZdVgi]g^i^h  

&,#+#' G]ZjbVid^Y6gi]g^i^h &,#+#( 6c`nadh^c\HedcYna^i^h

&,#, 9ZciVaEVi]dad\n  &,#,#& 8Vg^Zh  

 

&,#,#' &,#,#( &,#,#) &,#,#*

9ZciVa=nedeaVh^V EZg^dYdciVa9^hZVhZ 9ZciVa8VaXjajh 6gi^ÄX^Va9ZciVaBdY^ÄXVi^dc

('* ('* ('* (', ('-

('('. ('. ((% ((% ((&

&,#- DXXjeVi^dc

((&

#HAPTER


HZii^c\ EgZhZgkVi^dc EgZeVgVi^dc GZhidgVi^dc Hdgi^c\ BZig^X6Xfj^h^i^dcVcY6cVanh^h BdaZXjaVgDhiZdad\n &-#,#& &-#,#' &-#,#( &-#,#)

HVbea^c\ 9C6VcYE8G 8dciVb^cVi^dc IVe]dcdbnd[9C6

&-#- BdaY^c\VcY8Vhi^c\ &-#. E]did\gVe]n  &-#.#& :fj^ebZci   

###

&-#.#' :medhjgZVcY;^abdgdi]ZggZXdgY^c\bZY^V &-#.#( A^\]i^c\VcYHZije &-#.#) AZ\Va8dch^YZgVi^dch

&-#&%GVY^d\gVe]n &-#&&B^XgdhXden &-#&'8dbeji^c\ &-#&(GZedgi^c\ &-#&)8jgVi^dc

((( (() ((* ((((. ()% ()) ()* ()+ (), (),

()()(). (*% (*& (*'

(*( (*( (*) (** (*-

#HAPTER

DXUC[U\UdQ\2Y_\_Wi_V9^TYfYTeQ\c@_`e\QdY_^c &.#& 6XXjgVXnVcYEgZX^h^dcd[:hi^bVi^dc

m^k

(+%

&.#' ;gdb@cdlcidJc`cdlc &.#( :hi^bVi^dcd[6\Z            

&.#(#& :hi^bVi^c\HjWVYjai6\Z[gdb9Zci^i^dc &.#(#' :hi^bVi^c\6Yjai6\Z[gdb9Zci^i^dc &.#(#( :hi^bVi^c\6Yjai6\Z[gdb8gVc^VaHjijgZ8adhjgZ &.#(#) :hi^bVi^c\HjWVYjai6\Z[gdbAdc\"7dcZAZc\i] &.#(#* :hi^bVi^c\HjWVYjai6\Z[gdb:e^e]nhZVa8adhjgZ &.#(#+ :hi^bVi^c\6Yjai6\Z[gdbi]ZEjW^XHnbe]nh^hHjg[VXZ &.#(#, EVgijg^i^dc8]Vc\ZhVii]ZEjW^XHnbe]nh^h &.#(#- :hi^bVi^c\6Yjai6\Z[gdbi]Z6jg^XjaVgHjg[VXZd[i]Z>a^jb &.#(#. :hi^bVi^c\6Yjai6\Z[gdbi]ZHiZgcVaG^W:cY &.#(#&% :hi^bVi^c\6Yjai6\ZWnGVY^d\gVe]^X6cVanh^h &.#(#&& :hi^bVi^c\6Yjai6\Z[gdb7dcZB^XgdhigjXijgZ &.#(#&' Bjai^[VXidg^Va6\Z:hi^bVi^dc

(+' (+( (+) (+* (+. (,( (,( (,) (-% (-% (-& (-& (-& (-)

&.#) 9ZiZgb^cVi^dcd[HZm  

&.#)#& HZm^c\i]ZH`jaaVcY9Zci^i^dc &.#)#' HZm^c\i]ZEdhiXgVc^VaH`ZaZidc

&.#* &.#+ &.#, &.#- 

:hi^bVi^dcd[HiVijgZ :hi^bVi^dcd[6cXZhign >YZci^[n^c\i]Z>cY^k^YjVa 9^hXgZiZIgV^ih

 

&.#-#& 9ZciVaCdcbZig^XKVg^Vi^dc &.#-#' 8gVc^VaCdcbZig^XKVg^Vi^dc &.#-#( EdhiXgVc^VaCdcbZig^XKVg^Vi^dc

(-* (-+ (-,

(.)%% )%) )%+ )%, )%, )&%

&.#. :hi^bVi^c\7^dad\^XVa9^hiVcXZ &.#&%9^Zi  &.#&&9^hZVhZVcY9Zbd\gVe]n

)&% )&& )&)

'LOSSARY

)&.



!PPENDIX LZWGZk^Zl

)',

"IBLIOGRAPHY

)'.

)NDEX

)*(



mk

This Page Intentionally Left Blank

mk^

EgZ[VXZ ;

dgZch^XhX^Zci^hih!aVlZc[dgXZbZcieZghdccZa!dhiZdad\^hih!eVaZdcidad\^hih!VcY VgX]Zdad\^hih[gZfjZcianZcXdjciZg]jbVcgZbV^ch^ci]Z^gldg`#I]ZhZgZhZVgX]" ZghXVcjhZh`ZaZiVagZbV^chid^ckZhi^\ViZWdi]i]ZgZXZciVcYi]ZVcX^ZcieVhi#;dg i]Zb!Vc^aajhigViZY]jbVcdhiZdad\nbVcjVagZegZhZcihVc^bedgiVciidda[dg^YZci^" ÄXVi^dcVcYVcVanh^h!Wdi]^ci]ZÄZaYVcY^ci]ZaVWdgVidgn# >ci]ZÄZaYhZii^c\!egd[Zhh^dcVahVcYhijYZcihVgZd[iZcgZfj^gZYidYd[Vhi!VXXjgViZ ^YZci^ÄXVi^dcl^i]djiaVWdgVidgngZhdjgXZh#I]^hWdd`^hYZh^\cZYidWZi]Zeg^bVgn gZhdjgXZ^ci]ZÄZaYhZii^c\/VhbVaaZg!a^\]iZg!VcYbdgZYjgVWaZWdd`[dg[dgZch^XhX^" Zci^hih! aVl Zc[dgXZbZci eZghdccZa! VgX]Zdad\^hih! dhiZdad\^hih! oddVgX]Zdad\^hih! VcY eVaZdVci]gdedad\^hih# I]Z ild"Y^bZch^dcVa ^bV\Zh ^c i]^h bVcjVa VgZ kVajVWaZ iddah ^c ÄZaY ^YZci^Ä" XVi^dc!^chigjXi^dc!VcYaZVgc^c\^ckdak^c\]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#I]Zn]VkZWZZc XVgZ[jaanXgV[iZYidh]dlVbVm^bjbVbdjcid[VcVidb^XVa^c[dgbVi^dc!VcYhXVaZY idegdk^YZZVhnXdbeVg^hdc#Dg\Vc^oZY[dgZVhZd[jhZVhVbVcjVa!i]^hWdd`Zbe]V" h^oZhi]ZWVh^Xhl]^aZegdk^Y^c\Vc^cigdYjXi^dcidi]Z]jbVch`ZaZidcVcYVXXZhhidV l^YZgVc\Zd[bdYZgcldg`^c]jbVcdhiZdad\n# L]ViZkZghjXXZhhlZ]VkZVX]^ZkZY^cYZkZade^c\VjhZ[jabVcjValZdlZaVg\Zan idi]ZhijYZcihVcYXdaaZV\jZhl]d]VkZY^a^\ZcianjhZYi]ZÄghiVcYhZXdcYZY^i^dchd[ djgiZmiWdd`!=jbVcDhiZdad\n¸i]ZY^gZXiegZYZXZhhdgd[I]Z=jbVc7dcZBVcjVa# BVcnXdaaZV\jZhbVYZi]dhZkdajbZhedhh^WaZ#7^aaLddYXdX`Vi6XVYZb^XEgZhhÄghi hj\\ZhiZY i]Z iZmi# 7gjXZ AVi^bZg VcY AnbVc ?ZaaZbV d[ i]Z 8aZkZaVcY BjhZjb d[ CVijgVa=^hidgn]ZaeZYjhiddWiV^ci]Z=VbVcc"IdYYedhiXgVc^Vah`ZaZidc^aajhigVi" ZY]ZgZ#B^iX]Zaa9VnVhh^hiZY^cegdk^Y^c\heZX^bZch[dg^aajhigVi^dch[gdbi]ZJc^" kZgh^ind[i]ZEVX^ÄXHX]ddad[9Zci^hign¼h6i`^chdc8gVc^d"DhiZdad\^XVa8daaZXi^dcd[ i]Z6#L#LVgYBjhZjb#I]Vc`h\did7dW?dcZhd[7Zg`ZaZn¼hBjhZjbd[KZgiZWgViZ Oddad\n[dggZbdk^c\i]Z\gZVhZ[gdbi]Z^aajhigViZYh`ZaZidc#;dg[dgZch^XVYk^XZVcY XdchjaiVi^dclZi]Vc`G^X]VgYI]dbVhVcY:aaZcBddgZ# I]ZbVcjVa^aajhigViZh]jbVcWdcZh[gdbVYY^i^dcVa^chi^iji^dchi]ViVgZ\gViZ" [jaanVX`cdlaZY\ZY]ZgZ!eVgi^XjaVgani]ZE]dZWZ6eeZghdc=ZVghiBjhZjbd[6c" i]gdedad\nViJ#8#7Zg`ZaZnl]ZgZIL^hV;VXjain8jgVidg#LZ\gViZ[jaanVX`cdla" ZY\Zi]ZVhh^hiVcXZd[i]ZJ#H#6gbn8ZcigVa>YZci^ÄXVi^dcAVWdgVidgn!=VlV^^0i]Z;7> AVWdgVidgn9^k^h^dc0VcYi]Z6gbZY;dgXZh>chi^ijiZd[EVi]dad\n# I]Z[daadl^c\XdaaZV\jZh]VkZ\gVX^djhanegdk^YZYVXXZhhid^aajhigVi^kZbViZg^Va ^ci]ZbVcjVa/HjoVccZHjcY]dabVcY@ZciA^\]i[ddid[i]ZJc^kZgh^ind[8Va^[dgc^V 6gX]VZdad\^XVaGZhZVgX];VX^a^in!AVggnO^bbZgbVcd[i]ZJc^kZgh^ind[Hdji]9V" mk^^

`diV!9dj\JWZaV`Zgd[i]ZHb^i]hdc^Vc>chi^iji^dc!?Zggn;ZiiZgbVcd[LddYh8Vc" ndc 6gX]VZdad\^XVa 8dchjaiVcih!
mk^^^

This Page Intentionally Left Blank

m^m

This Page Intentionally Left Blank

mm

#HAPTER

>cigdYjXi^dc 7

dcZh]VkZWZZcZcidbWZY[dgb^aa^dchd[nZVgh^chZY^bZcihaZ[iWnVcX^Zci aV`Zh!hlVbeh!VcYg^kZghi]VidcXZYdiiZY:i]^de^V¼h6[Vg9ZegZhh^dc#IdYVn!Vh Zgdh^dcXjih^cidi]ZhZVcX^ZciaVnZgh!i]Z[dhh^ahgZVX]i]ZWVggZc6[Vghjg[VXZ!d[iZc h]ViiZg^c\ ^cid hbVaa! \a^hiZc^c\! bjai^XdadgZY [gV\bZcih d[ WdcZ VcY iZZi]# I]^can hXViiZgZYVbdc\i]ZdhhZdjhVcYYZciVagZbV^chd[i]djhVcYhd[XgdXdY^aZ!ijgiaZ!]^e" edediVbjh!\^gV[[Z!XVgc^kdgZ!WVWddc!e^\!]dghZ!VciZadeZ!VcYdi]ZgVc^bVah[djcY ^ci]Zhjg[VXZ[dhh^aVhhZbWaV\ZhVgZi]ZgZbV^chd[eg^b^i^kZ]jbVcVcXZhidgh#L]^aZ eVaZdcidad\^hihhZVgX]6[VgdjiXgdeh[dgdhiZdad\^XVaXajZhVWdjiegZ]^hidg^X]jbVc [dgb! VgX]Zdad\^hih jcXdkZg i]Z dhiZdad\^XVa gZbV^ch d[ i]Z ^c]VW^iVcih d[ =ZgXjaV" cZjbl]deZg^h]ZYVhBdjciKZhjk^jhZgjeiZY!Wjgn^c\i]Zbl^i]i]Z^gedhhZhh^dch# Dci]Zdi]Zgh^YZd[i]Z\adWZ!Vci]gdedad\^hihegdWZ^cidVgZXZci\gVkZXdciV^c^c\ h`ZaZiVaeVgihi]VibVnWZi]dhZd[VCVo^lVgXg^b^cVa#

(UMAN/STEOLOGY 6i]gZVYi]ViW^cYhi]ZhZVcYi]djhVcYhd[di]Zg^ckZhi^\Vi^dch^hXe]Q^_cdU_\_Wi! i]ZhijYnd[]jbVcWdcZh#I]ZhX^Zci^hiheZg[dgb^c\i]Z^ckZhi^\Vi^dchZbeadni]Z^g `cdlaZY\Zd[i]Z]jbVch`ZaZidc^cgZXdkZg^c\VcY^ciZgegZi^c\i]ZWdcZh#Djih^YZ d[ VcVidb^XVa VcY bZY^XVa hX^ZcXZ! i]ZgZ VgZ i]gZZ bV^c VgZVh ^c l]^X] `cdlaZY\Z d[]jbVcdhiZdad\n^hd[iZcVeea^ZY#;^ghi!dhiZdad\^XValdg`^hd[iZcV^bZYVi^YZc" i^ÄXVi^dc d[ i]Z gZaVi^kZan gZXZcian YZXZVhZY VcY ^h jhjVaan YdcZ ^c V aZ\Va XdciZmi# I]^h ldg`! l]^X] eZgiV^ch id i]Z ejWa^X [dgjb! bdhi d[iZc V Xdjgi d[ aVl! ^h XVaaZY V_bU^cYS _cdU_\_Wi! V Y^k^h^dc d[ [dgZch^X Vci]gdedad\n# I]Z di]Zg ild XdciZmih ^c l]^X]]jbVcdhiZdad\^XVa`cdlaZY\Z^hXdbbdcanVeea^ZYVgZ]^hidg^XVa#I]ZXdciZmi XVcWZVcX^ZciVcYejgZan`Q\U_^d_\_WYSQ\!Vh[dgi]ZEa^dXZcZegZ"XjaijgVa]db^c^Yh d[ 6[g^XV# 6aiZgcVi^kZan! i]Z XdciZmi XVc WZ gZaVi^kZan gZXZci! eVgi d[ Vc QbSXU_\_WY SQ\ gZXdgY# ;dg ZmVbeaZ! ]jbVc WdcZh gZXdkZgZY [gdb i]Z 6oiZX XZciZgh ^c BZm^Xd lZgZX]gdc^XaZY_jhiV[Zl]jcYgZYnZVghV\dWni]ZHeVc^h]Yjg^c\i]Z¹XdcfjZhiº d[BZm^Xd#DhiZdad\^XVaVcVanh^hd[bViZg^Vah[gdbhjX]XjaijgVaXdciZmih^hgdji^cZan jcYZgiV`Zc Vh eVgi d[ VgX]Zdad\^XVa gZhZVgX]# 6gX]Zdad\^hih XdcXZcigViZ dc XjaijgVa gZh^YjZhd[[dgbZg]jbVcdXXjeVi^dch!Wjii]ZnhiVcYid\V^cV\gZViYZVad[kVajVWaZ ^c[dgbVi^dc[gdbi]Zh`ZaZiVagZbV^chd[i]ZVcX^Zci^c]VW^iVcih#>i]VhgZXZcianWZ" XdbZ[Vh]^dcVWaZidgZ[Zgidi]ZhijYnd[]jbVcgZbV^ch[gdbVgX]Zdad\^XVaXdciZmih VhRY_QbSXU_\_Wi#=dlZkZg!]jbVch`ZaZiVaeVgihVgZdcanVhbVaaeVgid[i]ZW^dad\^" &

&IGUREDhiZdad\nVcYVhhdX^ViZYhX^Zci^ÄXY^hX^ea^cZh#

XVagZbV^chX]VgVXiZg^o^c\bdhiVgX]Zdad\^XVah^iZh¸^cYZZY!bdhiVgX]Zdad\^XVah^iZh aVX`]jbVcgZbV^chVaid\Zi]Zg I]Z ^c[dgbVi^dc i]Vi ]jbVc dg egdid]jbVc WdcZh XVc egdk^YZ bV`Zh i]Z gZ" XdkZgn d[ WdcZh V Xg^i^XVaan ^bedgiVci VXi^k^in# H`ZaZiVa VcVidbn ^cXajY^c\ iZZi] gZÅZXih i]Z XdbW^cZY VXi^dc d[ \ZcZh VcY Zck^gdcbZci# I]Z h`ZaZidc [dgbh i]Z [gVbZldg` [dg i]Z WdYn! l]ZgZVh i]Z iZZi] [dgb V Y^gZXi ^ciZg[VXZ WZilZZc i]Z dg" \Vc^hb VcY ^ih Zck^gdcbZci# 7dcZh XVggn ^c i]Z^g h]VeZ! dg ]_b`X_\_Wi! i]Z h^\" cVijgZ d[ hd[i i^hhjZh l^i] l]^X] i]Zn lZgZ ZbWZYYZY Yjg^c\ a^[Z¸i^hhjZh ^cXajY" ^c\ bjhXaZh! a^\VbZcih! iZcYdch! VgiZg^Zh! cZgkZh! kZ^ch! VcY dg\Vch# I]ZhZ hd[i i^h" hjZh jhjVaan Y^hVeeZVg hddc V[iZg YZVi]# I]Z h`ZaZidc! ]dlZkZg! d[iZc egZhZgkZh Zk^YZcXZ d[ i]Z [dgbZg Zm^hiZcXZ VcY cVijgZ d[ bVcn d[ i]ZhZ di]Zg WdYn eVgih# 7ZXVjhZi]ZWdcZhVcYiZZi]d[i]Zh`ZaZidcVgZgZh^hiVciidbVcn`^cYhd[YZXVn! i]Znd[iZc[dgbi]ZbdhiaVhi^c\gZXdgYd[Vc^cY^k^YjVa¼hZm^hiZcXZ#>i^hedhh^WaZid Zhi^bViZVc^cY^k^YjVa¼hV\Z!hZm!VcYhiVijgZ[gdbi]ZWdcZhVcYiZZi]#HijYnd[i]Z h`ZaZidc d[iZc bV`Zh ^i edhh^WaZ id Y^hXZgc V kVg^Zin d[ eVi]dad\^Zh [gdb l]^X] i]Z ^cY^k^YjVabVn]VkZhj[[ZgZY#6cVanh^hd[\gdjehd[^cY^k^YjVahbVnd[[Zg^ch^\]ih^cid egZ]^hidg^XedejaVi^dchigjXijgZ!W^dad\^XVaV[Äc^i^Zh!XjaijgVaWZ]Vk^dgh!VcYeViiZgch d[Y^hZVhZ#I]ZZkdaji^dcVgn]^hidgnd[]jbVc^in^ihZa[bVnWZ gZVY[gdbi]Z[dhh^a gZXdgY¸VgZXdgYXdbeg^h^c\bdhianiZZi]VcYWdcZh#;^\jgZ&#&^aajhigViZhi]ZeaVXZ d[dhiZdad\n^cgZaVi^dciddi]ZghX^Zci^ÄXY^hX^ea^cZh#

!'UIDETOTHE-ANUAL I]Z\dVad[[dgZch^XdhiZdad\nd[iZc^ckdakZh^YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[Vcjc`cdlc^cY^k^YjVa# I]ZegdXZhhd[eZghdcVaan^YZci^[n^c\i]ZgZbV^chd[i]ZgZXZcianYZVY^cY^k^YjVa^h XVaaZY Y^TYfYTeQdY_^# Id cVggdl i]Z edhh^W^a^i^Zh! i]Z [dgZch^X dhiZdad\^hi Äghi Vh" XZgiV^chl]Zi]Zgi]ZgZbV^chVgZ]jbVcVcYi]ZcWZ\^chidZmeadgZi]Z^cY^k^YjVa X]VgVXiZg^hi^Xh!hjX]VhV\Z!hZm!VcYhiVijgZ!XdbeVg^c\i]ZhZkVg^VWaZh^ci]Z]deZhd[ dWiV^c^c\VcZmXajh^kZbViX]l^i]l]Vi^h`cdlcVWdjii]Zb^hh^c\^cY^k^YjVa#I]Z 

8]VeiZg&>cigdYjXi^dc

]jbVcdhiZdad\^hildg`^c\^cVcVgX]Zdad\^XVaXdciZmijhjVaanXVccdieZg[dgbhjX] eZghdcVa^YZci^ÄXVi^dc#GVi]Zg!XdcXZgchVgZl^i]X]VgVXiZg^hi^Xhd[i]Z^cY^k^YjVaVcY l^i]i]Z^ch^\]ihi]Vih`ZaZiVagZbV^chd[bVcn^cY^k^YjVah!gZegZhZci^c\W^dad\^XVa edejaVi^dch!b^\]iegdk^YZdcY^Zi!]ZVai]!W^dad\^XVaV[Äc^in!VcYedejaVi^dc]^hidgn# I]Z dhiZdad\^hi ldg`^c\ ^c V eVaZdcidad\^XVa XdciZmi VcY cdiZ i]Vi bVcn [dhh^ah d[ Ea^dXZcZVcYEaZ^hidXZcZV\ZVgZ[djcY^cVgX]Zdad\^XVaXdciZmih^hVahd^ciZgZhiZY^c jh^c\i]ZcdgbVaangVgZ[dhh^agZbV^chd[]jbVcVcXZhidghVcYdi]ZggZaVi^kZhidaZVgc Vaai]ZhZi]^c\hVcYVahdidY^hXZgcZkdaji^dcVgngZaVi^dch]^eh# H`ZaZiVagZbV^chXVcegdk^YZbZVc^c\[jaXajZhVWdjii]ZgZXZciVcYi]ZVcX^Zci eVhiidVaai]ZhZ^ckZhi^\Vidgh#IdjhZi]ZhZXajZh!dcZbjhibVhiZghdbZ[jcYVbZciVah# I]ZÄghiildWVh^XfjZhi^dchi]ViVcn]jbVcdhiZdad\^hibjhiVchlZgVWdjiVWdcZ dgXdaaZXi^dcd[WdcZhl]Zi]Zg^cV[dgZch^X!VgX]Zdad\^XVa!dgeVaZdcidad\^XVaXdciZmi VgZ/  ™ 6gZi]ZWdcZh]jbVc4  ™ =dlbVcn^cY^k^YjVahVgZegZhZci4 L]Zi]Zgi]ZXdciZmi^h[dgZch^X!VgX]Zdad\^XVa!dgeVaZdcidad\^XVa!i]ZhZfjZhi^dch jhjVaan bjhi WZ VchlZgZY WZ[dgZ [jgi]Zg VcVanh^h ^h edhh^WaZ# I]^h bVcjVa! V \j^YZ id ]jbVc dhiZdad\n! Zbe]Vh^oZh i]Z VcVidbn d[ i]Z ]jbVc h`ZaZidc# I]Z h`ZaZiVa gZbV^chd[hdbZdi]ZgVc^bVah!eVgi^XjaVganl]Zc[gV\bZciVgn!VgZd[iZcY^[ÄXjaiid Y^hi^c\j^h][gdb]jbVcWdcZhVcYiZZi]#6ai]dj\]i]ZgZVgZcd\ZcZgVaY^[[ZgZcXZh i]ViZchjgZZ[[ZXi^kZhdgi^c\WZilZZc]jbVcVcYcdc]jbVcWdcZh!i]ZÄghihiZe^c VchlZg^c\i]ZfjZhi^dcd[l]Zi]Zgi]ZWdcZhVgZ]jbVc^hidWZXdbZ[Vb^a^Vgl^i] i]Z]jbVch`ZaZidc^cVaad[^ihbVcnkVg^Vi^dch^ch]VeZVcYh^oZ#JWZaV`Zg&.-.!;^\# +(^aajhigViZhl]daZWdcZhd[bVbbVahbdhid[iZcXdc[jhZYl^i]]jbVch!Wjii]^h Xdc[jh^dc gVgZan ^ckdakZh l]daZ WdcZh# ;gV\bZciVgn cdc]jbVc gZbV^ch VgZ bdgZ egdWaZbVi^XVcYVgZZcXdjciZgZYbdgZ[gZfjZcian#DcXZV[Vb^a^Vg^inl^i]i]ZgVc\Z! dgZckZadeZ!d[kVg^Vi^dcX]VgVXiZg^o^c\i]ZbdYZgc]jbVcheZX^Zh^hVX]^ZkZY![jgi]Zg ldg`^cXdbeVgVi^kZdhiZdad\nd[Wdi]Zmi^cXiVcYZmiVcibVbbVahWZXdbZhVbjX] ZVh^ZgiVh`#L^i][jgi]ZgXdbeVgVi^kZldg`XdbZhbdgZZmeZg^ZcXZ!VcYl^i]i]ViZm" eZg^ZcXZi]ZdhiZdad\^hi^hWZiiZgVWaZidbV`Zi]ZWVh^X^YZci^ÄXVi^dchgZfj^gZY# >c[dgbVi^dcdcYZiZgb^c^c\i]ZV\Z!hZm!hiVijgZ!VcY^YZci^ind[h`ZaZidc^oZY^c" Y^k^YjVah ^h egdk^YZY ^c aViZg X]VeiZgh d[ i]Z bVcjVa# I]ZhZ hZXdcY"aZkZa fjZhi^dch VcY bVcn di]Zgh! ^cXajY^c\ i]dhZ VWdji W^dbZX]Vc^XVa XVeVW^a^in! e]nad\ZcZi^X gZ" aVi^dch]^eh!VcY\Zd\gVe]^XV[Äc^i^Zh!]dlZkZg!XVcWZVchlZgZYVXXjgViZandcanV[iZg i]ZZaZbZcihVcY^cY^k^YjVah]VkZWZZc^YZci^ÄZYXdggZXian#Iddd[iZci]ZÄghi!WVh^X ^YZci^ÄXVi^dchVgZdkZgadd`ZYdg]Vhi^aneZg[dgbZY!VcYi]jhVcnhjXXZZY^c\VcVanhZh VgZWj^aidclZV`[djcYVi^dch# 8]VeiZgh,·&+[dgbi]ZXdgZd[i]ZWdd`#>ci]ZhZX]VeiZghlZXdch^YZgdcZVcV" idb^XVagZ\^dcViVi^bZ!WZ\^cc^c\l^i]i]ZWdcZhd[i]Zh`jaa#6hZeVgViZX]VeiZg VcY[dgbViVgZZbeadnZY[dgi]ZYZci^i^dc#LZ^cigdYjXZ8]VeiZgh,·&+l^i]Wg^Z[ VXXdjcihd[i]Ze]nad\ZcZi^X]^hidgnd[i]ZWdYnhZ\bZcihVcYdhiZdad\^XVaZaZbZcih YZhXg^WZY^ci]ZX]VeiZg#I]^hVeegdVX]hZihi]ZdhiZdad\^XVaZaZbZcih^cVWgdVYZkdaj" i^dcVgn[gVbZldg`#I]ZhZ^cigdYjXidgnhiViZbZcihVgZbdhianYgVlc[gdbi]ZZmXZa" aZci[jcXi^dcVa]jbVcVcVidbniZmiWn8Vgib^aa!=naVcYZg!VcYH]VÅVcY&.-,!VcY i]Z^ciZgZhiZYgZVYZgbVnejghjZ[jgi]ZgYZiV^ahi]ZgZVcY^cdi]ZgXdbeVgVi^kZiZmih &#'<j^YZidi]ZBVcjVa

(

hjX]Vh?Vgk^`&.-%# >c i]Z YZhXg^ei^kZ 8]VeiZgh ,·&+! ZVX] WdcZ ^h h]dlc ^cY^k^YjVaan! ^c kVg^djh k^Zlh!WnbZVchd[e]did\gVe]h#;dgZVhZd[XdbeVg^hdc!i]ZhXVaZ[dgVaa^cY^k^YjVa WdcZh^hcVijgVah^oZ!l]^aZiZZi]VgZh]dlcil^XZcVijgVah^oZ#;dgeV^gZYWdcZh!dcan i]Z g^\]i h^YZ ^h h]dlc jcaZhh di]Zgl^hZ ^cY^XViZY# Dg^ZciVi^dch [dg i]Z Vgi^XjaViZY XgVc^VVgZhiVcYVgY!VcYdi]ZgWdcZhVgZ^aajhigViZY^cdg^ZciVi^dchh]dl^c\i]Zbdhi VcVidbn#;dgZmVbeaZ!i]Z¹VciZg^dgk^Zlºd[i]Z[gdciVa^hVe]did\gVe]d[i]ZVciZg^dg hjg[VXZd[i]ViWdcZ#9ZiV^ahd[i]ZegZeVgVi^dcVcYe]did\gVe]nd[i]ZhZheZX^bZch VgZ\^kZc^cL]^iZVcY;da`Zch'%%%# =jbVcdhiZdad\niZmihd[iZcYZe^Xi]jbVch`ZaZidchVcYi]Z^gZaZbZcihVh^[i]Zn lZgZ^ciZgX]Vc\ZVWaZ#HZihd[^aajhigVi^dchi]Viegdk^YZa^iiaZdgcdk^hjVa^c[dgbV" i^dcdci]ZgZaVi^kZh^oZhd[Y^[[ZgZcieVgihd[i]Zh`ZaZidcVgZhiVcYVgY#;jgi]ZgbdgZ! WdcZh VgZ d[iZc jchXVaZY VcY$dg YZg^kZY [gdb hZkZgVa ^cY^k^YjVah ^c hjX] ^aajhigV" i^dch#I]^hhVXg^ÄXZhVYY^i^dcVa^c[dgbVi^dcdcegdedgi^dcVa^inVcY[dhiZghinedad\^" XVai]dj\]i#IdgZbZYni]^hh^ijVi^dc!lZX]dhZi]Zh`ZaZidcd[Vh^c\aZ^cY^k^YjVa id ^aajhigViZ Vaa i]Z ZaZbZcih d[ i]Z edhiXgVc^Va h`ZaZidc# 6aa edhiXgVc^Va ZaZbZcih h]dlc^ci]ZYZhXg^ei^kZX]VeiZghd[i]^hbVcjVaVgZ[gdbVh^c\aZbdYZgc]jbVc ^cY^k^YjVa!=VbVcc"IdYYheZX^bZccjbWZg-*,!VilZcin[djg"nZVg"daYWaVX`bVaZ l]dhiddY* ,iVaa&,%XbVcYlZ^\]ZY&(-aW+'#+`\#I]^hh`ZaZidclVhX]dhZc [dg^ihgZaVi^kZan[ZljcjhjVa[ZVijgZhcdiZY^ci]ZXVei^dch[dgZVX]ZaZbZci!Xdb" eaZiZcZhh! VcY ZmXZaaZci egZhZgkVi^dc# 6gi^XjaViZY XgVc^Va VcY Vaa YZciVa heZX^bZch ^aajhigViZY^c8]VeiZgh,VcY-VgZd[gZXZciBZhdVbZg^XVcdg^\^c!VcYi]ZY^hVgi^Xj" aViZYWdcZhd[i]ZXgVc^jbVgZVaa[gdbVh^c\aZbdYZgc^cY^k^YjVa[gdbHdji]Zgc 6h^V#CdiZi]Vii]ZhZY^hVgi^XjaViZYXgVc^VaWdcZhVgZ[gdbV&+"nZVg"daY^cY^k^YjVa ^cl]^X]i]ZWdcnZaZbZcihXdjaYWZY^hVgi^XjaViZYVcYh]dlc^ciVXi#I]^hndjc\ ^cY^k^YjVa]VYcdi[jaanYZkZadeZYVaai]ZbVg`Zghd[XgVc^VagdWjhi^X^in^aajhigViZY Wni]ZVgi^XjaViZYh`jaa# :VX]YZhXg^ei^kZX]VeiZg^hdg\Vc^oZYhnhiZbVi^XVaan#I]ZZaZbZci^hÄghicVbZY VcY ^ih Vgi^XjaVi^dch ^YZci^ÄZY# JcYZg i]Z ¹6cVidbnº hZXi^dc [dg ZVX] ZaZbZci! i]Z bV_dg eVgih VcY dhiZdad\^XVaan h^\c^ÄXVci [ZVijgZh d[ ZVX] ZaZbZci VgZ ^YZci^ÄZY ^c R_\TineZ[VXZVcYYZhXg^WZY# I]Z [jcXi^dc VcY hd[i i^hhjZ gZaVi^dch [dg bdhi higjXijgZh VgZ ^YZci^ÄZY ^c^iVa^X ineZ[VXZ#>i^hcdidjg^ciZci^dcid\^kZVXdbeaZiZa^hi^c\d[bjhXaZdg^\^chVcY^chZg" i^dch#>chiZVY!lZegdk^YZYViVdchd[ii^hhjZidbV`Z[jcXi^dcVahZchZd[Wdcn[ZVijgZh l]^aZXdchiVciangZ^c[dgX^c\i]ZgZVa^ind[WdcZVhVc^ciZ\gVaeVgid[i]ZbjhXjad" h`ZaZiVahnhiZb# Dhh^ÄXVi^dcd[ZVX]ZaZbZci^hWg^ZÅnXdch^YZgZY^ci]ZYZhXg^ei^kZX]VeiZghjcYZg VhZXi^dcXVaaZY7b_gdX#;jgi]ZgYZiV^ahdcYZkZadebZcid[kVg^djhZaZbZcihVgZegZ" hZciZY^c8]VeiZg&.#I]Z@_ccYR\U3_^VecY_^VcYCYTY^WhZXi^dchegdk^YZ^c[dgbV" i^dcidXdbeaZbZcii]Z^aajhigVi^dchVcYVaadlZ[[ZXi^kZ^YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[^hdaViZYVcY [gV\bZciVgnh`ZaZiVaZaZbZcih# BZVhjgZbZcih^ci]^hbVcjVaVgZZmegZhhZY^ci]ZbZig^XhnhiZbVh^hhiVcYVgY^c dhiZdad\n#8VgiZg&.-%egdk^YZhV\ddY]^hidgnd[i]Z:c\a^h]VcYbZig^XhnhiZbh[dg hijYZcihjc[Vb^a^Vgl^i]bZig^XiZgbhdg[dgi]dhZl]dgZbV^cjcXdck^cXZYd[i]Z bZig^XhnhiZb¼hji^a^in^cbdYZgchX^Zci^ÄX^ckZhi^\Vi^dc#



8]VeiZg&>cigdYjXi^dc

2ESOURCESFORTHE/STEOLOGIST I]Zbdhi^bedgiVcih^c\aZgZhdjgXZ[dgi]ZdhiZdad\^hi^hVXdaaZXi^dcd[h`ZaZiVagZ" bV^ch#>YZVaan!i]ZaVWdgVidgnh]djaY]VkZV\gdli]hZg^Zhd[h`ZaZidchd[^cY^k^YjVahd[ `cdlcV\ZidVXXdbeVcnbdjciZYh`ZaZidchd[hZkZgVa^cY^k^YjVah!VhlZaaVhZaZbZci XdaaZXi^dch^cl]^X]bVcn^cY^k^YjVahd[`cdlchZm!V\Z!dXXjeVi^dc!VcYeVi]dad\n VgZgZegZhZciZY#6XdaaZXi^dcd[h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch[gdbVkVg^Zind[bdYZgccdc]jbVc Vc^bVah^hVahdkZgn^bedgiVci#HX]ZjZgVcY7aVX`¼h'%%%VcY'%%)kdajbZhVgZZm" XZaaZciXdbeVc^dchidi]^hbVcjVa#I]ZnegZhZciZmiZch^kZ^aajhigVi^dchd[^bbVijgZ ]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch# 6hndjldg`l^i]]jbVcWdcZhVcYiZZi]!ValVnhgZheZXii]ZbVhdW_ZXihd[hX^" Zci^ÄX^cfj^gn#>chdbZlVnh!h`ZaZiVagZhdjgXZhVgZa^`ZWdd`h^cVa^WgVgn#7dcZhVcY iZZi]]VkZi]ZediZci^Va!^[gZVYXdggZXian!id^c[dgbVWdjii]Za^k^c\!WgZVi]^c\eZdeaZ idl]dbi]ZndcXZWZadc\ZY#IgZVii]ZhZgZbV^chl^i]XVgZ0hdbZd[i]ZbVgZ[gV\^aZ VcYVaad[i]ZbVgZ^ggZeaVXZVWaZ# GZheZXiVcnhnhiZbd[dg\Vc^oVi^dc^cl]^X]ndjÄcYh`ZaZiVabViZg^Va#CZkZgb^m WdcZhVcYiZZi]d[Y^[[ZgZci^cY^k^YjVah!ZkZc[dgVh]dgii^bZdgl^i]i]ZWZhid[^ciZc" i^dch#GZbZbWZgi]Vib^m^c\d[WdcZhgZhjaih^cVadhhd[XdciZmijVa^c[dgbVi^dc¸Vc VXi^dci]Vi^hediZci^VaanZkZcbdgZYZkVhiVi^c\i]Vce]nh^XVaWgZV`V\Zd[VcZaZbZci# >ci]Za^WgVgn!]^hidgnWdd`hh]ZakZY^cXdggZXian^ci]ZW^dad\nhZXi^dcWZXdbZjc" VkV^aVWaZidVcn]^hidg^Vcl]dl^h]ZhidXdchjaii]Zb#7dcZhgZh]ZakZY^ci]Zlgdc\ eaVXZVgZVabdhi^bedhh^WaZidgZig^ZkZ# ;^cVaan!gZheZXii]ZeZdeaZl]dXVbZWZ[dgZndjWnigZVi^c\i]Z^gWdcZhl^i]XVgZ# GZheZXii]Z\ZcZgVi^dchd[hijYZcihVcYegd[Zhh^dcVahl]dl^aa[daadlndjWn`ZZe^c\ i]ZWdcZhVcYi]Z^gegdkZc^ZcXZ^ciVXi# 7ZndcY i]Z e]nh^XVa eaVci d[ i]Z aVWdgVidgn! `Zn gZhdjgXZh [dg i]Z ]jbVc dhiZ" dad\^hi]VkZigVY^i^dcVaanWZZcZfj^ebZci!heZX^bZch!VcYejWa^XVi^dch#I]ZVYkZci d[ZaZXigdc^XejWa^h]^c\VcYZYjXVi^dcVahd[ilVgZVcYi]ZZmeadh^dcd[gZhdjgXZhdc i]ZLdgaYL^YZLZW]VhYgVbVi^XVaanZmiZcYZYgZhdjgXZhVkV^aVWaZidi]ZdhiZdad\^hi# I]ZhZbZY^VVgZgVe^Yan\gdl^c\!Zkdak^c\!VcYkdaVi^aZ!Wji^i^h^bedgiVcii]Vii]Zdh" iZdad\^hiWZVlVgZd[i]Zb#I]Z6eeZcY^mgZegZhZcihVcViiZbeiid^YZci^[nVcYVhhZhh i]ZbdhihiVWaZ!^bedgiVci!VcYjhZ[jalZWh^iZheZgiV^c^c\id]jbVcdhiZdad\n#

)DENTIFYING"ONES >cWdcZ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc^ieVnhidgZbZbWZgi]Vii]ZdhiZdad\^hiValVnh]VhVc^ciVXi XdbeVgVi^kZh`ZaZidcXadhZVi]VcY!ZkZc^cgZbdiZÄZaYh^ijVi^dch#I]Vih`ZaZidc^h ZbWZYYZY ^c ]^h dg ]Zg dlc WdYn#  >i ^h jhZ[ja id k^hjVa^oZ VcY ZkZc `Q\`QdU [ZZa ndjgdlcWdcZhi]gdj\]i]Zh`^ci]ZlVn^cl]^X]Vc^hdaViZYh`ZaZiVaZaZbZcib^\]i ¹eaj\^cidºndjgdlcWdYn#I]^h^heVgi^XjaVganigjZ[dg^YZci^[n^c\VcYh^Y^c\iZZi]! l]^X]VgZXdckZc^ZcianZmedhZY^ci]ZdhiZdad\^hi¼hbdji]#CZkZgg^Y^XjaZVcdhiZdad" \^hil]d]daYhVgVY^jhV\V^chii]Zg^\]i[dgZVgbVcYi]Zch]^[ih^iidi]ZaZ[i[dgZ" VgbWZ[dgZ^YZci^[n^c\^i0i]VidhiZdad\^hil^aaegdWVWanh^YZi]ZWdcZXdggZXian#L]Zc ^YZci^[n^c\i]Zh^YZd[Vcn^YZci^ÄZYh`ZaZiVaZaZbZci!Vaai]ZdhiZdad\^hi]VhidYd^h

&#(GZhdjgXZh[dgi]ZDhiZdad\^hi

*

ZhiVWa^h]i]gZZVmZh^cheVXZ/ideidWdiidb!h^YZidh^YZ!VcY[gdciidWVX`#6cVidb^XVa [ZVijgZhd[i]ZWdcZl^aaVhh^hi^ci]^h!i]ZgZWnegdk^Y^c\i]ZXajZhcZXZhhVgn[dgXdggZXi ^YZci^ÄXVi^dcVcYdg^ZciVi^dc# 6hZXdcYi^e[dg^YZci^[n^c\h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch^ckdakZh]^ZgVgX]^Zhd[YZX^h^dch#7Z" \^c^YZci^[n^c\VWdcZWnYZX^Y^c\l]^X]ZaZbZcih^iXVccdiWZ#;dgZmVbeaZ!VgVY^jh [gV\bZciXVccdiWZVXgVc^VaWdcZdgiddi]l]^X]ZmXajYZh]jcYgZYhd[edhh^W^a^i^Zh! Vi^W^Vdg]jbZgjhiddhbVaa!VbZiViVghVaiddW^\!dgZkZcVÄWjaVlgdc\h]VeZ#Ndj l^aaWZhjgeg^hZY]dlhddcndjXVcZmXajYZVaaWjii]ZXdggZXiX]d^XZ^[ndjVeegdVX] ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc^ci]^hlVn# CdbViiZg]dld[iZcndjb^h^YZci^[nVWdcZdgiddi]!`ZZeign^c\#9dcdiXdc" hiVcianjhZi]ZVgi^XjaViZYh`ZaZidcdg^ciVXih`jaaVhVXgjiX]#I]ZgZ^h\gZVidhiZdad\^" XVaigji]idi]Z^YZVi]Vi¹l^i]ZkZgnb^hiV`ZlZbjhihjgZanWZaZVgc^c\#ºIgnidaZVgc [gdbndjgb^hiV`Zh#Ignid^YZci^[ni]Z`^cYhd[b^hiV`ZhndjVgZbV`^c\#6gZndj bdhid[iZcb^h^YZci^[n^c\^bbVijgZheZX^bZch4>[hd!hZidjiV\gdli]hZg^Zh[dgZVX] h`ZaZiVaZaZbZciVcYhZZ]dli]Zh]VeZd[i]ZWdcZX]Vc\Zhl^i]\gdli]#6gZndj]Vk" ^c\igdjWaZl^i]cdc]jbVch`ZaZiVaeVgih4>[hd!add`ViVgVc\Zd[]jbVckVg^Vi^dc id\ZiV\ddY^YZVd[]dlbjX]kVg^Vi^dcidZmeZXi#6gZndjh^beanXdc[jh^c\dcZeVgi d[i]Zh`ZaZidc[dgVcdi]Zg4>[hd!add`ViVaai]ZZaZbZcih^ci]Zh`ZaZidci]Vib^\]i b^b^XZVX]di]Zgl]Zc[gV\bZciVgnVcYX]ZX`i]Z¹Edhh^WaZ8dc[jh^dcºhZXi^dch^c i]ZYZhXg^ei^kZX]VeiZghd[i]^hbVcjVa#@ZZei]^hbVcjVacZVgWn#>i^hbjX]ZVh^Zgid XVggni]VcVh`ZaZidc!VcYi]Za^[Z"h^oZe]did\gVe]h^cbVcnk^Zlhh]djaY[VX^a^iViZ XdbeVg^hdchVcY^YZci^ÄXVi^dch#



8]VeiZg&>cigdYjXi^dc

#HAPTER

;^ZaYEgdXZYjgZh[dg H`ZaZiVaGZbV^ch =

jcYgZYhd[hijY^ZhVWdji]jbVcdhiZdad\nVgZejWa^h]ZYZVX]nZVg!gVc\^c\ [gdb^c^i^VaVccdjcXZbZcihd[[dhh^aY^hXdkZg^ZhL]^iZZiVa#!'%%(idXdbegZ" ]Zch^kZigZVibZcih^ckdak^c\bjai^eaZedejaVi^dchAVghZc!'%%&#6aai]ZhZhijY^Zh WZ\^cl^i]ÄZaYldg`#I]^hX]VeiZg^cigdYjXZhegdXZYjgZhjhZ[ja^cgZXdkZg^c\h`ZaZiVa bViZg^Va#I]ZX]VeiZg^hdg\Vc^oZY^cVcVeegdm^bViZanX]gdcdad\^XVabVccZg#LZÄghi gZk^ZlVheZXihd[Y^hXdkZgnVcYiZX]c^fjZhd[gZig^ZkVaVcYZmXVkVi^dc#I]ZclZY^h" XjhhigVchedgid[h`ZaZiVabViZg^Va#AVWdgVidgnegdXZYjgZhVcYgZedgi^c\VgZXdkZgZY ^c8]VeiZg&-# >cZkZgnVheZXid[dhiZdad\^XVaVcVanh^h¸l]Zi]Zg^ci]ZÄZaYdg^ci]ZaVWdgVid" gn¸XdbbdchZchZ^hXg^i^XVa#>[i]ZgZ^hVcndcZdkZgg^Y^c\gjaZ!^i^hidi]^c`WZ[dgZ ndjVXi#I]ZgZ^hcdh^c\aZ[dgbjaV!gZX^eZ!dgegdXZYjgZidVeean^cZkZgnÄZaYh^ijV" i^dc#I]ZgZVgZh^beaniddbVcnY^[[ZgZciY^hXdkZgnXdciZmihVcYiddbjX]egZhZgkV" i^dcVakVg^Vi^dc^ckdak^c\dhiZdad\^XVagZbV^ch#8ZbZiZgnZmXVkVi^dc^hY^[[ZgZci[gdb ^hdaViZYh`ZaZidcZmXVkVi^dc![dhh^aWdcZhVgZY^[[ZgZci[gdbbdYZgcdcZh![dgZch^XXVhZh VgZY^[[ZgZci[gdbVgX]Zdad\^XVaegd_ZXih!VcYlViZgad\\ZYWjg^VaXdcY^i^dchVgZY^[[Zg" Zci[gdbbjbb^ÄZYgZbV^ch^ci]ZYg^ZhiYZhZgih#I]ZgZVgZ!]dlZkZg!hdbZ\ZcZgVa eg^cX^eaZhi]ViVeean^cbdhi^chiVcXZhl]ZgZh`ZaZiVagZbV^chVgZXdcXZgcZY# >c bdhi [dgZch^X ^ckZhi^\Vi^dch ^ckdak^c\ dhiZdad\^XVa gZbV^ch! i]ZgZ VgZ d[ÄX^Va \dkZgcbZciegdidXdahidWZ[daadlZY#;dgZmVbeaZ!i]Z8ZcigVa>YZci^ÄXVi^dcAVWdgV" idgn=VlV^^J#H#6gbZY;dgXZh08>A=>!i]Z6gbZY;dgXZhBZY^XVa:mVb^cZg6gbZY ;dgXZh>chi^ijiZd[EVi]dad\n06;>E!VcYi]Z;ZYZgVa7jgZVjd[>ckZhi^\Vi^dcVaa]VkZ lg^iiZc\j^YZh[dgi]Z]VcYa^c\d[]jbVcgZbV^ch#D[iZciZgbZY¹HDEh!ºi]ZhZVgZ hiVcYVgYdeZgVi^c\egdXZYjgZhi]Vi\dkZgc]dldhiZdad\^XVabViZg^VahVgZigZViZYWn eZghdccZa#JhjVaani]ZhZgZbV^chd[iZcYZÄcZYVh]jbVcW^dad\^XVai^hhjZXdchi^ijiZ Zk^YZcXZ!VcYi]ZejgedhZd[bVcnd[i]ZegdXZYjgZh^hidZchjgZi]Z^ciZ\g^in!bV^c" iZcVcXZ!VcYhZXjg^ind[i]ViZk^YZcXZ#HDEhd[iZc^cXajYZhXZcZegdXZYjgZh!hVbea^c\ egdXZYjgZh! aVWdgVidgn egdXZYjgZh! gZedgi^c\ egdXZYjgZh! hidgV\Z egdXZYjgZh! Zfj^e" bZciegdXZYjgZh!VcYhV[ZinegdXZYjgZh#I]ZdhiZdad\^hih]djaYWZXdbZ[Vb^a^Vgl^i] i]ZhZd[ÄX^VaegdidXdahVcYegdXZYjgZhl]ZcZkZg^ckdakZY^cV[dgZch^X^ckZhi^\Vi^dc# H`^ccZg VcY XdaaZV\jZh '%%( egdk^YZ kZgn jhZ[ja VcY XdbegZ]Zch^kZ \j^YZa^cZh [dgdhiZdad\^XValdg`^cbdYZgc[dgZch^XhZii^c\h!eVgi^XjaVgani]dhZ^ckdak^c\bVhh \gVkZh#

,

3EARCH DhiZdad\^XVagZbV^chbVnWZY^hXdkZgZY^c[dgZch^X!VgX]Zdad\^XVa!dgeVaZdcidad\^XVa XdciZmihZ^i]ZgVhVgZhjaid[^ciZci^dcVaegd[Zhh^dcVadgVbViZjghjgkZndgVhVgZhjaid[ VcVXX^YZci#>ciZci^dcVahZVgX]bZi]dYdad\^ZhkVgnl^YZan![gdbeVaZdcidad\^XVaZmeZ" Y^i^dchidbjgYZgdgY^hVeeZVgVcXZ^ckZhi^\Vi^dch#HdbZi^bZhi]ZhZVgX]^haVg\Z"hXVaZ! V^bZYVigZXdkZgnd[hXViiZgZY]db^c^YgZbV^ch^caVg\Z[dhh^aÄZaYh#Di]Zgi^bZh!i]Z hZVgX]XVcWZkZgnadXVa^oZY!Vh^ci]ZX]VggZYgjWWaZd[i]Z7gVcX]9Vk^Y^Vc8db" edjcY^cIZmVhDlhaZnZiVa#!&..*!dgdcVaVg\ZghXVaZ!Vh^ci]ZhZVgX][dgb^a^iVgn B>6h l^i]^c YZXVYZh"daYXgViZghXgZViZYWn]^\]"heZZYb^a^iVgn ^beVXi=dh]dlZg! &..-#I]ZkVg^Zind[gZbdiZ"hZch^c\Veea^XVi^dchid[dgZch^X^ckZhi^\Vi^dch^hgZk^ZlZY Wn9VkZcedgi'%%&VcY7jX`'%%(!VgX]Zdad\^XVahjgkZnbZi]dYhVgZgZk^ZlZYWn 7Vcc^c\'%%'!VcYEZVghdc'%%&\^kZhVXgdhh"XjaijgVadkZgk^Zld[i]ZVgX]Zdad\n d[YZVi]VcYWjg^Va# HdbZi^bZh gZbV^ch [gdb VgX]Zdad\^XVa dg ]^hidg^XVa XZbZiZgn XdciZmih bVn WZ Wgdj\]iidi]ZViiZci^dcd[aVlZc[dgXZbZciV\ZcihdgbZY^XVaZmVb^cZghVhVgZhjai d[kVcYVa^hbdgcVijgVaXVjhZh7ZggnbVcZiVa#!&..&#Di]Zgi^bZh![dgZch^XdhiZdad" \^hih VgZ ^ckdakZY ^c i]Z hZVgX] [dg XaVcYZhi^cZ \gVkZh jh^c\ bZi]dYh gVc\^c\ [gdb VZg^Vae]did\gVe]hidigV^cZYhXZci"YZiZXi^dcYd\h;gVcXZZiVa#!&..'!@dbVg!&...# D[ XdjghZ! cdi Vaa hZVgX]Zh gZhjai ^c Y^hXdkZgn! VcY bVcn V eVaZdcidad\^hi gZijgch Zbein"]VcYZY#
$ISCOVERY H`ZaZiVagZbV^chVgZd[iZc[djcYWnVXX^YZci#;dgZmVbeaZ!]^`ZghVcYXdchigjXi^dc XgZlhd[iZcÄcYdhiZdad\^XVabViZg^Va#L]Zci]ZnYd!i]ZnjhjVaangZedgi^iidadXVa aVl"Zc[dgXZbZciVji]dg^i^Zh#7ZXVjhZi]ZgZVgZbVcnbdgZYd\!]dghZ!Xdl!VcY\dVi WdcZhi]Vc]jbVcWdcZhdci]Zhjg[VXZd[bdhiaVcYhXVeZh!i]ZhZVgZd[iZcb^hiV`Zc [dg]jbVcWdcZhWnaVneZghdchVcYVbViZjgh#6\ZcZgVagjaZ[dgi]ZegVXi^X^c\]j" bVcdhiZdad\^hi^hidVhhjbZi]ViaVl"Zc[dgXZbZcieZghdccZal]dd[iZcÄghiZcXdjciZg hjX]gZbV^ch^cXajY^c\!^chdbZXVhZh!XdgdcZghVgZcdifjVa^ÄZYidgZcYZgVXXjgViZ de^c^dchdc^hdaViZY![gV\bZciVgnh`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#;dgZmVbeaZ!eZigVWW^ihi]VieZg" ^h]ZY^cigV^aZg]dbZÄgZh]VkZWZZc^YZci^ÄZYWnd[ÄX^VaXdgdcZghVh]jbVc^c[Vcih# ;dgZch^X ]jbVc dhiZdad\^hih jhjVaan ZcXdjciZg h^ijVi^dch ^c l]^X] bdge]dad\^XVa ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc^hZVh^anVXXdbea^h]ZYWjihZZJWZaV`ZgZiVa#!&..&#=dlZkZg!VXddg" Y^cViZYZ[[dgiWZilZZce]nh^XVaVci]gdedad\^hihVcYaVl"Zc[dgXZbZciheZX^Va^hihViV Xg^bZhXZcZ^hVWhdajiZanZhhZci^Va[dgi]ZgZXdkZgnd[VaaVkV^aVWaZXajZhLda[!&.-+0 BVeaZhVcY7gdlc^c\!&..)09^g`bVViVcY6YdkVh^d!&..,# DcWZ^c\^cigdYjXZYidh`ZaZiVabViZg^Va!i]Z]jbVcdhiZdad\^hi^h[VXZYl^i]i]gZZ Xg^i^XVafjZhi^dch/ 

8]VeiZg';^ZaYEgdXZYjgZh

 ™ >hi]ZbViZg^Va]jbVc4  ™ =dlbVcn^cY^k^YjVahVgZgZegZhZciZY4  ™ D[l]ViVci^fj^in^hi]ZbViZg^Va4 :meZg^ZcXZ^hi]ZbdhikVajVWaZXdbbdY^in^cVchlZg^c\i]ZÄghiildfjZhi^dch# L]Zc^cVcnYdjWi!XdchjaiXdbeVgVi^kZh`ZaZiVabViZg^Vadgi]Z^aajhigVi^dch^ci]^h bVcjVa# I]Zi]^gYfjZhi^dc^hjhjVaanbdgZY^[ÄXjaiidVchlZgVXXjgViZan!eVgi^XjaVgan^[ XdciZmijVa^c[dgbVi^dc^hcdiVkV^aVWaZ#Id\^kZVcVXXjgViZVchlZg^i^hcZXZhhVgnid Zc\V\Z^cVa^iiaZYZiZXi^kZldg`#I]ZXdcY^i^dcd[WdcZhi]ZbhZakZhYdZhcdiiZaakZgn bjX]WZXVjhZi]Ze]nh^XVaXdcY^i^dcd[i]ZWdcZh^haVg\ZanXdcigdaaZYWni]Ze]nh^" XVa Zck^gdcbZci ^c l]^X] i]Zn lZgZ YZedh^iZY# 7dcZ lZVi]Zg^c\ VcY YZiZg^dgVi^dc VgZVXXZaZgViZYWnY^gZXihjca^\]i!]^\]]ZVi!ÅjXijVi^c\iZbeZgVijgZVcY]jb^Y^in! W^di^X^cÅjZcXZh!VcYhd^aVX^Y^in#L]Zci]ZhZkVg^VWaZhVgZ]ZaYidVb^c^bjb!WdcZ YZiZg^dgVi^dcXVcegd\gZhhkZgnhadlan#IdVhhZhhi]ZVci^fj^ind[h`ZaZiVagZbV^chcdi ^cY^k^YjVaV\ZViYZVi]!^i^hcZXZhhVgnid\^kZeg^bVgnXdch^YZgVi^dcidi]Z^gXdciZmi# =Vhi]Zh`ZaZidcWZZcgZXZcianY^hijgWZY4L]Vi`^cYhd[Vgi^[VXihVeeZVgl^i]i]ZgZ" bV^ch4;VahZiZZi]!YZciVaÄaa^c\h!Xd^ch!WZVYh!ediiZgn!Xd[ÄccV^ah!VcYdi]ZgZk^YZcXZ d[bViZg^VaXjaijgZ^[gZVaVhhdX^Vi^dcXVcWZZhiVWa^h]ZYl^i]i]Zh`ZaZiVagZbV^ch bVnWZXg^i^XVa^cYZiZgb^c^c\i]ZVci^fj^ind[i]ZWdcZh#LZVgd[i]ZiZZi]XVchdbZ" i^bZhegdk^YZXajZhidi]Zdg^\^cd[i]Zh`ZaZiVabViZg^Va0^cbVcneaVXZh!i]ZiZZi]d[ gZXZcianYZVY^cY^k^YjVahjhjVaanh]dl[VgaZhhlZVgi]Vci]VihZZcjcYZgVWdg^\^cVa XdcY^i^dch#7ZXVjhZXdciZmijVa^c[dgbVi^dc^hhdXg^i^XVaidi]ZVXXjgViZYZiZgb^cVi^dc d[i]ZVci^fj^inVcYdg^\^cd[h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch!i]ZdhiZdad\^hih]djaYValVnhbV`ZZk" ZgnZ[[dgiidk^h^ii]ZY^hXdkZgnh^iZVcYbV`ZVÄghi]VcYVhhZhhbZciVcYgZXdgYd[i]Z YZedh^i^dcVa]^hidgnVcYVhhdX^Vi^dchd[dhiZdad\^XVabViZg^Va#

%XCAVATIONAND2ETRIEVAL EgdeZgZkVajVi^dcd[Vcnh`ZaZiVagZbV^chcdgbVaangZfj^gZhXdaaZXi^dcd[i]ZWdcZh VcYhjWhZfjZciaVWdgVidgnVcVanh^h#JedcY^hXdkZgn!i]ZdhiZdad\^hi¼hcVijgVa^cXa^cV" i^dceVgi^XjaVganl]Zci]ZgZbV^chlZgZi]ZdW_ZXid[VhZVgX]VcYZheZX^Vaan^[i]Zn VgZ]db^c^Y[dhh^ah^hid\Zii]ZWdcZhdji¸idXdaaZXii]Zb#I]^h^bbZY^ViZhZeVgV" i^dcd[i]ZheZX^bZc[gdb^ihXdciZmi^hi]ZldghihigViZ\n#I]ZWdcZhXVccdadc\Zg ¹lVa`VlVnºdci]Z^gdlc#7Z[dgZY^hijgW^c\i]ZXdciZmi!bdkZVlVn[gdbi]Zh^iZVcY XVgZ[jaanYZkZadeVhigViZ\n[dggZXdgY^c\VcYgZXdkZgn#>[XZaZWgVi^dcd[VeVaZdcid" ad\^XVaY^hXdkZgn^hXVaaZY[dg!]daY^id[["h^iZ#@ZZecdcZhhZci^VaeZghdccZad[["h^iZ#Dc i]Zh^iZ!^i^hVYk^hVWaZidh]dleVi^ZcXZVcYgZhigV^ci!l]^aZi]dj\]i[jaanYZk^h^c\Vc Veegdeg^ViZ higViZ\n id ZmigVXi i]Z gZbV^ch VcY Vaa XdciZmijVa ^c[dgbVi^dc# Lg^i^c\ ^begZhh^dchYdlc^ci]Z[dgbd[ÄZaYcdiZh^hcZXZhhVgnVcY]Zaeh^ci]^heaVcc^c\# 6[iZgi]Zi]g^aaVcYZmX^iZbZcid[Y^hXdkZgn]VkZVWViZY!^i^hi^bZ[dghZg^djh!dW" _ZXi^kZVhhZhhbZcid[i]Zh^ijVi^dc#I]Z[daadl^c\fjZhi^dchh]djaYWZXVgZ[jaanXdc" h^YZgZY/  ™ L]ViVgZi]Zeda^i^XVaVcYaZ\VaXdchigV^cihjcYZgl]^X]gZXdkZgnbjhiegdXZZY4
.

h]djaYXdc[Zgl^i]egd_ZXibVcV\ZbZciidZchjgZi]ViVaaVeea^XVWaZaVlhVgZ[da" adlZYVcYVaaXdcXZgcZYeVgi^ZhVgZ^c[dgbZY#>chdbZVgX]Zdad\^XVaVcYhdbZ [dgZch^X^ckZhi^\Vi^dchXZcZh!]VoVgYdjhbViZg^Vahl^aaeaVnVgdaZ^cXdcY^i^dc^c\ ]dli]ZZmXVkVi^dcVcYgZig^ZkVaegdXZZYh#  ™ >cl]ViXdcY^i^dc^hi]ZWdcZ4  ™ L]Vi]Vh]VeeZcZYidi]ZWdcZVh^i]VhWZZcZmedhZY4=dl]VhcVijgVadg]j" bVc"^cYjXZYZgdh^dcjcXdkZgZYVcYhXViiZgZYi]ZWdcZVXgdhhi]ZaVcYhXVeZ4  ™ L]ViXdciZmijVa^c[dgbVi^dc^hVkV^aVWaZ4  ™ L]Videi^dchVgZi]ZgZ[dggZXdkZg^c\i]ZWdcZ48dch^YZgi]ZVkV^aVWaZi^bZ! aVWdg!VcYZfj^ebZci#6h=dh]dlZg&..-cdiZh!ÅZm^WaZZmXVkVi^dchigViZ\n^hV `ZnXdbedcZcid[hjXXZhh[jagZXdkZgn# ;^\jgZh'#&i]gdj\]'#&'^aajhigViZhdbZVheZXihd[h`ZaZiVagZXdkZgn^cVgX]Zdad\^" XVah^ijVi^dch#BVnh&..-!JWZaV`Zg&.-.!VcYL]^iZVcY;da`Zch'%%%VgZhdjgXZh d[VYY^i^dcVa^aajhigVi^dch#8]VeiZg&-gZk^ZlhheZX^VaXdch^YZgVi^dch^ckdak^c\egZhZg"

&IGURE6e^dcZZgWjg^Va[gdbcZVgi]Z]^hidg^X7dgYZVjmIgVY^c\Edhi!hdji]ZVhiZgc Lndb^c\#I]Z\gVkZ!l]^X]hZZbZYidWZVhhdX^ViZYl^i]i]ZigVY^c\edhidgi]ZcZVgWn DgZ\dcIgV^a!lVh[djcY^c&.-%WnVÄZaYVgX]Zdad\nXgZljcYZgi]ZY^gZXi^dcd[


8]VeiZg';^ZaYEgdXZYjgZh

&IGURE;gdciVak^Zld[i]Z [gdci^ZghbVc¼hh`jaaZmXVkViZY [gdbi]Z\gVkZh]dlc^c;^\jgZ '#&#CdiZi]ZXgVc^Va\jch]di ldjcYXVjhZYWnV#))"dg)*"XVa^" WZglZVedc#6hZXdcYeZg^bdgiZb \jch]dildjcYidi]Z]^eVcYVi aZVhii]gZZ]ZVa^c\g^W[gVXijgZh lZgZcdiZYWni]Z^ckZhi^\Vidgh# I]^h^cY^k^YjVa!VbVaZl]degdW" VWanadhi]^hl^[Zeg^dgid]^hdlc YZVi]^cY^XViZYWni]ZWaVX`g^c\ cZmiidi]ZlZYY^c\WVcY!bdhi a^`ZanlVhh]di^c&-+.dg&-,% [gdb<^aaZiVa#!&.-)#

kVi^kZh!W^dbdaZXjaVghVbea^c\!VcYegZXVji^dch# I]Z[daadl^c\\ZcZgVahiZehh]djaYWZiV`Zc^ci]ZgZXdkZgnd[h`ZaZiVabViZg^Va/  ™ >[h`ZaZiVaeVgih]VkZWZZchXViiZgZYWnZgdh^dc!bVg`ZVX]l^i]Ve^cÅV\VcYVh" hZhhi]ZY^hig^Wji^dcidegZY^Xil]ZgZbdgZe^ZXZhb^\]iWZ[djcY#  ™ I]ZdkZgg^Y^c\XdcXZgc^cVaaldg`hjWhZfjZciidi]ZY^hXdkZgnd[i]ZheZX^bZc! ^ci]ZÄZaYdgi]ZaVWdgVidgn!^hidVaadlcd[jgi]ZgYVbV\ZiddXXjg#:mXVkVi^dc VcYZmigVXi^dcYVbV\ZiddhiZdad\^XVagZbV^ch^hXdbbdcWjijccZXZhhVgn#HiZeh h]djaYWZiV`ZcidXdchda^YViZ[gV\^aZWdcZ^ch^ij^ceaVXZl^i]egZhZgkVi^kZh!^[ egVXi^XVa#  ™ AdhZVha^iiaZ^c[dgbVi^dcVhedhh^WaZ!ZheZX^VaanXdcXZgc^c\S_^dUhd#I]ZgZbV^ch! l]Zi]Zg^cV[dgZch^XdgVcVgX]Zdad\^XVaXdciZmi!VgZdcZ"d["V"`^cY#I]ZnVgZ cdcgZcZlVWaZgZhdjgXZh#I]ZgZ^hdcandcZhjX]WdcZ!^cY^k^YjVa!Wjg^Va!dgXZbZ" iZgn!l]^X]bZVchi]Vii]ZgZ^hdcandcZX]VcXZidZmigVXii]ZgZbV^chXdbeaZiZan VcYXdggZXian#6Xi^dchiV`ZcYjg^c\gZXdkZgn]VkZXdchZfjZcXZhi]Viadc\djia^kZ Vcn^ckZhi^\Vidg!gZcYZg^c\i]ZdhiZdad\^hi¼hgZhedch^W^a^inVlZ^\]indcZ#  ™ DWiV^cegdeZgZfj^ebZci[dggZXdkZgn#IVWaZ'#&^hVhjeeanVcYZfj^ebZci X]ZX`a^hii]VidhiZdad\^hihbVnÄcYjhZ[jaidXdchjaiWZ[dgZ]ZVY^c\^cidi]ZÄZaY# Egdk^YZYi]Vii]ZWdcZhVcYi]Z^gXdciZmiVgZcdi^bbZY^ViZan_ZdeVgY^oZY!gZXdk" Zgnh]djaYWZYZaVnZYjci^ai]ZegdeZgiddahVgZVkV^aVWaZ#JhZndjg_jY\ZbZcidc ]dlegZXVg^djhi]Zh^ijVi^dc^h#  ™ 7Z[dgZY^hijgW^c\i]ZhXZcZbV`Zlg^iiZcVcYe]did\gVe]^XgZXdgYhd[ZkZgni]^c\ ^bedgiVci#CZkZggZandcbZbdgn#>i^hd[iZcjhZ[jaidZhiVWa^h]VYVijbed^ci '#(:mXVkVi^dcVcYGZig^ZkVa

&&

4ABLE:fj^ebZciVcYHjeea^Zh[dgDhiZdad\^XVa;^ZaYldg` I:6B:FJ>EB:CI 8dbeVhh IVeZbZVhjgZh =VbbZghXVgeZciZg¼hVcY\Zdad\^XVa CV^ahdghiV`Zh Il^cZnZaadldgl]^iZ A^cZaZkZah H]dkZahVcYe^X`h!VmZhVcYhVlh IgdlZah!WjX`Zih 9^\\^c\egdWZhYZciVaVcYWVbWdd 7gjh]ZhkVg^djhh^oZhVcYhi^[[cZhhZh HXgZZch BZiVaYZiZXidg[dgZch^XXVhZh HiZeaVYYZg 8VbZgVig^edY 8VbZgVhk^YZd!Y^\^iVa!EdaVgd^Yœ!Äab 8VbZgVÅVh]ViiVX]bZciVcYXVWaZgZaZVhZ E]didhXVaZ!&-\gVnXVgY!Y^gZXi^dcVaVggdl E]did^c[dgbVi^dcWdVgYYgnZgVhZWdVgY Ea^Zgh!lgZcX]Zh!XjiiZgh!ÄaZh GdeZh!iVgeVja^ch!ÄZaYjbWgZaaVh 6Zg^Vae]did\gVe]h!hiZgZde]didk^ZlZg IgVkZaVcYZmXVkVi^dceZgb^ih IVeZgZXdgYZg EdgiVWaZiVWaZhVcYX]V^gh 7jh]Xa^eeZgh
I:6BHJEEA>:H ;^abVcYegdiZXi^kZÄabWV\h 8dbeVXiÅVh]XVgYhY^\^iVabZY^V K^YZdiVeZh 6jY^diVeZh
E:GHDC6A:FJ>EB:CI 9^\\^c\^chigjbZcih EdX`Zi`c^[Z!hX^hhdgh GVY^d =VcYaZch ;aVh]a^\]i!ZmigVWjaWhVcYWViiZg^Zh 8VbZgV!Äab!WViiZg^Zh!ÅVh]!aZchZh BZVhjg^c\iVeZ!XVa^eZgh E]didWVX`\gdjcY!XVWaZgZaZVhZ!hXVaZ!higVe HbVaae]didb^ggdgh IgVkZaYdXjbZciheVhhedgi!i^X`Zih!]ZVai] XZgi^ÄXViZ!^chjgVcXZ[dgbh!eZgb^hh^dc aZiiZgh =ViVcYWVcYVcVh!\adkZh IZci Hjch]dlZg!idlZa EaViZ!Xje!jiZch^ah!XVciZZc HaZZe^c\WV\VcYeVY CZZYaZVcYi]gZVY HbVaaegZeVgVi^dc`^i Hjc\aVhhZh!ZmigV\aVhhZhdgaZchZh

E:GHDC6AHJEEA>:H BdcZn Lg^i^c\jiZch^ah!cdiZWdd`!XVaXjaVidg AZchXaZVc^c\Åj^YVcYeVeZgh ;^ab >chi^iji^dcVaaZiiZg]ZVYVcYZckZadeZh chZXigZeZaaZci



8]VeiZg';^ZaYEgdXZYjgZh

&IGUREEgZ]^hidg^X VgX]Zdad\^XVah^iZ^c cdgi]Zgc8Va^[dgc^V! WZ[dgZVcYV[iZgZmXVkV" i^dc#IdeI]Zdjia^cZh VcYYVg`Zg^cÄaa^c\h d[X^gXjaVg\gVkZe^ih XVcWZhZZcdci]Z Åddgd[i]ZZmXVkVi^dc igZcX]#I]ZhXVaZhVgZ ^c^cX]Zh#AZ[i;aZmZY Wjg^VahlZgZgZkZVaZY l^i]^ci]Zha^\]ian hjeZg^bedhZY\gVkZ e^ihd[Wjg^Va'#=ZgZ! i]Zild^cY^k^YjVah^c i]^hWjg^VaVgZh]dlc! Wdi]ÅZmZY#I]ZhVbZ aVg\ZhidcZVeeZVgh^c i]ZadlZgaZ[iXdgcZgh d[i]Zilde]did\gVe]h#

'#(:mXVkVi^dcVcYGZig^ZkVa

&(

&IGURE;aZmZYWjg^Vad[VcVYjaiVXXdbeVc^ZYWn\gVkZ\ddYh#H]ZaaWZVYhVY]ZgZidi]Z XgVc^jb!hidcZhVgZ^ci]Zbdji]!VcYdi]ZgWZVYhVcYeZcYVcihVgZhZZcVgdjcYi]ZedhiXgV" c^Vah`ZaZidc#EgZ]^hidg^X!cdgi]Zgc8Va^[dgc^V#I]ZhXVaZ^h^c^cX]Zh#

dci]Zh^iZidXdcigdaV\g^YaV^Ydjil^i]hiV`ZhVcYXdgYVXgdhhi]Zhjg[VXZ#6aa gZXdkZgZYdW_ZXihXVcWZgZaViZYidi]Z\g^Y#Lda[¼h&.-+VYk^XZdcVeegdVX]^c\ VXg^bZhXZcZl^i]hXViiZgZYbViZg^VaVh^[ndjlZgZXaZVg^c\Vb^cZÄZaY^hVeegd" eg^ViZ^ci]^hgZ\VgY#>ci]ZeVhi!VEdaVgd^YœXVbZgVVcY(*"bbWaVX`"VcY"l]^iZ ÄablZgZegVXi^XVaVcYXdbbdchdaji^dch#=dlZkZg!Y^\^iVa^bV\^c\]VhaVg\Zan gZeaVXZYÄab^chjX]h^ijVi^dchhZZHZXi^dc&-#.#L]Zi]Zgjh^c\ÄabdgY^\^iVa e]did\gVe]n!dgiVeZdgY^\^iVagZXdgY^c\!ValVnhXgZViZVWVX`je^cXVhZd[Zfj^e" bZci[V^ajgZdgdeZgVidgb^hiV`Z#6hXVaZVcYY^gZXi^dcVaVggdlh]djaYWZ^cXajY" ZY^cVaaYgVl^c\hVcYe]did\gVe]h#HjWhZfjZcihiV\Zhd[i]ZZmXVkVi^dch]djaY WZe]did\gVe]ZY[gdbVhbVcnVc\aZhVhVeegdeg^ViZ#GZbdkZVaaiddah!dWhXjg^c\ gddih!VcYajbehd[ZVgi]WZ[dgZe]did\gVe]^c\#>[a^\]i^c\^hVegdWaZb!eVgi^Xj" aVgan^cVcZmXVkVi^dc!jhZVl]^iZh]ZZidgVajb^cjb[d^adcXVgYWdVgY!dgVÅVh] ViiVX]bZci!id^aajb^cViZi]ZheZX^bZc#I]Z`ZnidhjXXZhh[jae]did\gVe]n^hi]Z Xdcigdad[a^\]i#>[VheZX^bZc^hd[Xg^i^XVa^bedgiVcXZ!^i^h\ddYidbV`ZVk^YZd gZXdgYd[^i[dgiZVX]^c\!aZXijg^c\!XjgVidg^Va!VcY[dgZch^XejgedhZh#  ™ 7Z\^cegZhZgkVi^dcbZVhjgZh^[cZXZhhVgn[dg]VgYZcZghVcYdi]ZgegZhZgkVi^kZh! hZZ8]VeiZg&-# 

8]VeiZg';^ZaYEgdXZYjgZh

&IGUREEgZ]^hidg^XXgZbVi^dcZmedhZYWnVcVgX]Zdad\^XVaZmXVkVi^dc#6hhdX^ViZYl^i]i]Z XgZbVi^dcVgZdWh^Y^VcVgi^[VXih#I]ZXgZbViZYWdcZ[gV\bZcihVgZhZZc^ci]ZVgZVVWdkZi]Z A6H#,^cY^XVidg#EgZ]^hidg^X!cdgi]Zgc8Va^[dgc^V#I]ZhXVaZ^h^c^cX]Zh#

 ™ 8daaZXiVaaWdcZZmedhZYdci]Zhjg[VXZ!ZkZc[gV\bZcihi]ViYdcdihZZbidWZ ]db^c^Y#GZbdkZndjgh]dZh^[cZXZhhVgnVcY\ZiYdlcdcndjgWZaan[dgVXadhZ add`#BV`ZhjgZi]Za^\]i^hVYZfjViZWZ[dgZYd^c\i]^h#>i^hidndjgVYkVciV\Zi]Vi gV^ch]VkZlVh]ZYi]ZWdcZhjg[VXZXaZVc0VhndjY^hijgWi]Zhd^a^iWZXdbZhbdgZ Y^[ÄXjaiidgZXd\c^oZhbVaaWdcZ[gV\bZcih#BdkZhadlanVcYXVgZ[jaan!cdiigVb" ea^c\gZbV^chdgVgi^[VXihjcYZg[ddi#  ™ HXgZZcZVgi][gdbi]ZVWYdb^cVagZ\^dcd[Vaah`ZaZidchidgZXdkZgY^ZiVgndg[ZiVa h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#HXgZZcVaad[i]ZaddhZhjg[VXZZVgi]aZ[idkZg[gdbZVX]h`ZaZidc# 6&#%"bbbZh]h^oZl^cYdlhXgZZcl^aagZXdkZgbdhi^bedgiVci[gV\bZcih#   LViZglVh]ZmXVkViZYbViZg^Vai]gdj\]VhXgZZcidbV`Zi]ZhbVaa[gV\bZcih bdgZk^h^WaZVcYZVhnidgZXdkZg#  ™ ;dgWjg^Vah!dgdi]ZgVgi^XjaViZY^ch^ijbViZg^Va!ZmedhZi]ZWdcZhdcZViVi^bZ# >cVcVgX]Zdad\^XVaXdciZmi^i^h^bedgiVciidgZXd\c^oZi]Vii]ZgZ^hVkZgnaVg\Z XjaijgVaanYZiZgb^cZYVcYZi]cd\gVe]^XVaandWhZgkZYgVc\Zd[kVg^Vi^dc^c]j" bVcbdgijVgnegVXi^XZ#;dgbdhiVeea^XVi^dch!]dlZkZg!i]ZgZVgZhdbZ\ZcZgVa `^cYhd[Wjg^Vahidl]^X]i]ZdhiZdad\^hih]djaYWZVaZgi/6`bY]QbiY^dUb]U^d^h VWjg^Va^cl]^X]Vaad[i]ZWdcZhVgZ^cVcVcVidb^XVaan¹cVijgVaºVggVc\ZbZci# HjX]Wjg^VahVgZhdbZi^bZhXaVhh^ÄZYVXXdgY^c\idl]Zi]Zgi]ZZmigZb^i^ZhVgZ ZmiZcYZYdgÅZmZY#I]ZgZVgZcdcZViXViZ\dg^oVi^dch]ZgZ!VcYdcZe]did\gVe]^h '#(:mXVkVi^dcVcYGZig^ZkVa

&*

ldgi]bVcnldgYhd[YZhXg^ei^dc#6cUS_^TQbiY^dUb]U^d^hVWjg^Va^cl]^X] i]ZWdcZhd[Vh`ZaZidcVgZcdi^cV¹cVijgVaºVcVidb^XVagZaVi^dch]^eWji]VkZ WZZc\Vi]ZgZYid\Zi]ZghdbZi^bZV[iZgXdbeaZiZdgeVgi^VaY^hVgi^XjaVi^dcd[i]Z h`ZaZidcVcYi]ZcWjg^ZY#HdbZi^bZhi]^hWjg^VaXdbeg^hZhVWjcYaZd[WdcZh#6 ]e\dY`\UY^dUb]U^d^hVWjg^Va^cl]^X]bdgZi]VcdcZ^cY^k^YjVa^hegZhZci# I]ZhZWjg^Vah^cXajYZdhhjVg^Zh!Wjg^VajgchXdciV^c^c\bdgZi]VcdcZ^cY^k^YjVa! VcYVkVg^Zind[di]Zgedhh^W^a^i^Zh#3bU]QdY_^^hVbdgijVgnegVXi^XZ^ckdak^c\ i]Z^ciZci^dcVaWjgc^c\d[i]ZWdYn#8gZbVi^dchXVcd[iZcWZ^c[dgbVi^kZ¸i]Z aZhhZ[ÄX^Zcii]ZÄgZ!i]ZbdgZ^c[dgbVi^kZi]ZheZX^bZc#B^Xdoo^&..&gZk^Zlh bdgijVgnegVXi^XZhldgaYl^YZ#  ™ >cZmedh^c\Wjg^Vah!jhZVeegdeg^ViZiddahVcYjhZi]ZbXVgZ[jaan#9ZciVae^X`h VgZh]VgeVcYZ[ÄX^Zci!Wjii]ZnXVcZVh^anYVbV\Zi]ZWdcZ#LddYZcdgWVbWdd iddahbVnhdbZi^bZhWZhj^iVWaZ!VcYVgVc\Zd[Wgjh]Zhd[kVg^djhh^oZhVcYhi^[[" cZhh^h^cY^heZchVWaZ#Ldg`[gdbi]Zg^WXV\ZdjilVgYl]ZgZedhh^WaZ#9dcdijhZ i]ZigdlZa^cVhlZZe^c\bdi^dcjcaZhhndjVgZYd^c\ZmeadgVidgnldg`#Ignid aZVkZWdcZhhjeedgiZYVhndjXaZVc!Zmedh^c\i]Z[ddiVcY]VcYWdcZhaVhi#LViX] [dghd^aXdadgVcYiZmijgZX]Vc\Zh!gdYZciVcYgddiY^hijgWVcXZ!bVi^begZhh^dch! gdiiZYkZ\ZiVi^dc!lddY!^chZXigZbV^ch!X]VgXdVa!VcYVhhdX^ViZYVgi^[VXihhjX] Vha^eeaj\hdgWZVYh#7ZVaZgiidVaahd[ii^hhjZi]Vib^\]igZbV^c!^cXajY^c\]V^g! h`^c!Äc\Zgeg^cih!VcYa^\VbZcih#Lg^iZdgdi]Zgl^hZgZXdgYndjgcdiZh0bZbdgn l^aacdihj[ÄXZ#GZXdgYVc\aZhd[ÅZm^dc!i]Zdg^ZciVi^dcd[i]ZWdYnVcY]ZVY! i]ZYZei]d[i]ZWdcZh[gdbi]Zhjg[VXZdgi]ZYVijb!VcYVcndi]ZgXdciZmijVa YZiV^ah#IV`Zhd^ahVbeaZhl]ZgZVeegdeg^ViZ#GZbZbWZgi]ViVaaYZiV^ahd[XdciZmi h]djaYWZgZiV^cZY^cVcVgX]Zdad\^XVadg[dgZch^XZmXVkVi^dc#>cVgX]Zdad\^XVa h^ijVi^dch!XdciZmid[iZcn^ZaYhi]Z\gZViZhiVbdjcid[WZ]Vk^dgVa^c[dgbVi^dc# :mXVkVi^dcd[Vh^iZYZhigdnh^i!VcYXdciZmijVaYViVaZ[ijcgZXdgYZYVgZadhi[dgZkZg#

&IGURE8ZgZbdc^VaWZVgWjg^Va#I]gZZaVg\ZVWVadcZh]ZaahXdkZgi]Zh`jaad[i]ZWZVg# 7ZXVjhZi]ZWdcZhd[aVg\ZbVbbVahlZgZjhjVaanZmead^iZY[dgi]Z^gcjig^i^kZkVajZ!aVg\Z bVbbVaWdcZh[gdbVgX]Zdad\^XVagZ[jhZYZedh^ihVgZjhjVaankZgn[gV\bZciVgn0i]^hXVhZ^hVc dWk^djhZmXZei^dc#EgZ]^hidg^X!cdgi]Zgc8Va^[dgc^V#



8]VeiZg';^ZaYEgdXZYjgZh

&IGUREAND6cZmiZcYZYWjg^Va[gdbi]Z egZ]^hidg^XA^WWZch^iZ^cD]^d#I]ZZmXVkVidg aZ[i!]Vk^c\XaZVgZYi]ZXZcigVaeVgid[i]^hWjg^Va! XVgZ[jaanZmedhZhi]Z]VcYe]VaVc\Zhl^i]VYZciVa egdWZ#6[iZg[jaagZXdgY^c\!i]ZVgX]Zdad\^hiVWdkZ XVgZ[jaangZbdkZhi]ZjacVVcY]jbZgjh#I]Zg^Wh ]VkZWZZcZmedhZY[dge]did\gVe]^XgZXdgY^c\VcY YgVl^c\!Wjii]ZnlZgZcdiZcYVc\ZgZYWnjcYZgXji" i^c\Yjg^c\ZmXVkVi^dc#

 ™ HVbeaZh[dgW^dX]Zb^XVaVcVanhZhVcY]^hidad\nhZZ8]VeiZg&-h]djaYWZiV`Zc Vii]ZZVga^Zhii^bZ!l^i]XaZVciddahVcY\adkZh!^chiZg^aZXdciV^cZgh!idVkd^Y XdciVb^cVi^dc#HZZC^ZahZc"BVgh]ZiVa#'%%%[dgVgZk^Zld[]dlWdcZYZ\gVYZh X]Zb^XVaan# I]ZVXijVagZbdkVad[i]ZWdcZhi]ZbhZakZh^hdcZd[i]ZaVhihiZehd[gZXdkZgn!V[iZg ZmedhjgZ!e]did\gVe]n!VcYYgVl^c\#IdV^Y^ci]Z^g]VgYZc^c\!aZii]ZZmedhZYWdcZh YgnXdbeaZiZan^cVcVgZVh]VYZY[gdbi]Zhjc#;gZZZVX]WdcZ\Zcian¸YdcdijhZ [dgXZ#:Vgi]bVig^mbVnWZaZ[idci]Zi]^ceVgihhXVejaV!eZak^hidVkd^YYVbV\Z Yjg^c\igVchedgi#9dcdiViiZbeiÄcZXaZVc^c\^ci]ZÄZaY0i]^hh]djaYWZeZg[dgbZY ^ch^ijVi^dchl]ZgZa^\]i!iddah!lViZg!Xdb[dgi!VYk^XZ!XdbeVgVi^kZbViZg^Va!VcYi^bZ VgZ^c\gZViZghjeean¸^cdi]ZgldgYh!^ci]ZaVWdgVidgn#IV`ZZVX]WdcZdji^cY^k^Yj" VaanVcYaVWZaVhndj\dVadc\!eVgi^XjaVgani]Zg^WhVcYkZgiZWgVZ#@ZZeg^\]iVcYaZ[i ]VcYh![ZZi!VcYg^WWdcZh^chZeVgViZXdciV^cZgh#@ZZejc[jhZYZe^e]nhZhl^i]i]Z^g VhhdX^ViZYWdcZh#7ZdWhZgkVciVhndjgZbdkZi]ZZaZbZcih!lViX]^c\[dg[ZiVaWdcZh! hZhVbd^Yh!`^YcZnVcY\VaaWaVYYZghidcZh!VcYhbVaaVgi^[VXih#HVkZZkZgni]^c\!ZkZc^[ ndji]^c`i]Vi^ib^\]icdiWZ]jbVc#>i^hZVh^ZgidYdVXXjgViZ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc^ci]Z aVWdgVidgn#9dcdiY^hgZ\VgY^bbVijgZh`ZaZiVaeVgihdgY^hijgWZYWjg^Vah0hjX]Y^hgZ" \VgYl^aah`Zli]ZXZbZiZgngZegZhZciVi^dchVcYjai^bViZan]VkZVcVYkZghZZ[[ZXidc VcnYZbd\gVe]^XgZXdchigjXi^dc# 6[iZggZbdkVa!^[i]ZWdcZ^hhi^aalZi!aZi^iYgnXdbeaZiZan^ci]Zh]VYZ#CZkZgb^m i]ZheZX^bZchYjg^c\lVh]^c\dgeVX`^c\Vii]Zh^iZ#HXgZZcVaaZVgi]i]VigZbV^chVi i]Zhedid[i]ZWjg^Va!lViX]^c\[dgWZVYh!iZZi]!VcYdi]Zg^iZbhi]VibVn]VkZWZZc b^hhZYVhi]ZaVg\ZgWdcZhlZgZgZbdkZY# 9ZX^h^dchVWdjilVh]^c\d[bViZg^VaVii]ZgZXdkZgnh^iZVgZWZhiaZ[iidi]Z_jY\Z" '#(:mXVkVi^dcVcYGZig^ZkVa

&,

bZcid[i]Z^ckZhi^\Vidg#6h7gdi]lZaa&.-&cdiZh!i]ZgZ^h\ZcZgVaancdegdWaZb^c YZX^Y^c\VWdjiWdcZhigZc\i]0WdcZhVgZcdi\ZcZgVaanYZXZei^kZ^ci]^hgZ\VgY#>i^h jhjVaanZk^YZciYjg^c\gZXdkZgnl]Zi]Zgi]ZnVgZa^`ZanidY^h^ciZ\gViZl]Zc]VcYaZY# >[lViZg^hVkV^aVWaZVcYi]ZWdcZ^hlZaaegZhZgkZY!^ibVnWZXdckZc^ZciidlVh]eVgih d[ZVX]h`ZaZidc^ci]ZÄZaYXVbe#>i^hd[iZcWZhiidgZbdkZi]ZZVgi][gdbi]ZXgVc^Va XVk^inVcYdgW^ihl]^aZi]Zhd^a^hhi^aaYVbe#9dcdiignidgZXdchigjXiWdcZh^ci]Z ÄZaY¸_jhi`ZZei]Zbid\Zi]Zg# 9ZX^h^dchVWdjii]ZVeea^XVi^dcd[egZhZgkVi^kZhHZXi^dc&-#'bjhiWZbVYZYjg" ^c\ZmedhjgZ!VcYi]^hVeea^XVi^dcl^aad[iZcWZcZXZhhVgnWZ[dgZgZbdkVa^hedhh^WaZ# 6ajb^cjb[d^a^hVc^cZmeZch^kZWjikZgnZ[[ZXi^kZbViZg^Vai]ViXVcWZjhZYid hiVW^a^oZ!egdiZXi!VcY`ZZeWdcZhVcYi]Z^geVgih^ceaVXZYjg^c\a^[i^c\VcYigVchedgi# EgZhhi]Z[d^aÄgbanVgdjcYVaai]ZWdcZVcYbVig^m^ggZ\jaVg^i^Zh# HdbZ^ckZhi^\VidghjhZWjg^VagZXdgY^c\[dgbh#I]ZhZXVcWZjhZ[ja!egdk^YZYi]Vi XVji^dc ^h jhZY ^c YZiZgb^c^c\ hZm! V\Z! VcY di]Zg [ZVijgZh d[iZc egdbeiZY Wn hjX] [dgbh#7ZhjgZidbVg`i]ZhZYZiZgb^cVi^dchd[^YZci^inVhegZa^b^cVgnl]Zci]ZnVgZ bVYZjcYZgÄZaYXdcY^i^dch#

&IGUREBVhh\gVkZVii]ZegZ]^hidg^XA^WWZch^iZXdciV^c^c\i]Zh`ZaZiVagZbV^chd[[djg X]^aYgZcVcYVcVYjai#I]ZaZ\hVcY[ZZid[VaViZgZmiZcYZYVYjaiWjg^VaegdigjYZ^cidi]Z ZmXVkVi^dc[gdbi]ZWdiidbd[i]Ze]did\gVe]#HjX]hjeZg^bedh^i^dcd[Y^[[ZgZciWjg^VaZkZcih ^hXdbbdcanZcXdjciZgZY^cVWdg^\^cVaXZbZiZg^Zh!jhjVaanWZXVjhZ\gVkZhlZgZcdibVg`ZY l^i]eZgbVcZcihjg[VXZbdcjbZcih#



8]VeiZg';^ZaYEgdXZYjgZh

&IGURE:miZcYZYWjg^Vad[Vc^bbVijgZ^cY^k^YjVa[gdbi]ZegZ]^hidg^XA^WWZch^iZ#
&IGURE7dcZhd[V[ZijhlZgZ[djcYl^i]^ci]ZeZak^XXVk^ind[i]^h[ZbVaZh`ZaZidc[gdb i]ZegZ]^hidg^XA^WWZch^iZ#I]Z]jbZgjh!g^Wh!VcYhXVejaVd[i]Z[ZijhVgZ_jhiVciZg^dgidi]Z hVXgd^a^VXVgi^XjaVi^dc#

'#(:mXVkVi^dcVcYGZig^ZkVa

&.

4RANSPORT L]ZcZmedhjgZ!e]did\gVe]n!VcYYgVl^c\VgZXdbeaZiZ!i]Zh`ZaZiVagZbV^chXVcWZ gZbdkZY[gdbi]ZVgX]Zdad\^XVaXdciZmi#>ci]Z[dgZch^XXdciZmii]ZYZX^h^dcidgZbdkZ ^hbVYZWni]ZX]^Z[d[i]ZXg^bZhXZcZ#I]^hWZ\^chV¹X]V^cd[XjhidYnº^cl]^X]i]Z dhiZdad\^hibjhieVgi^X^eViZVcYYdXjbZci^clg^i^c\BZaWnZVcY?^bZcZo!&..,#>[ i]ZWdcZ^hlZaa"egZhZgkZY!i]ZZaZbZcihXVcWZa^[iZY^cY^k^YjVaan#DcXZWdcZh]VkZ WZZcZmigVXiZYVcYÄZaY"XaZVcZY!i]ZnVgZgZVYn[dgeVX`^c\VcYigVchedgiidi]ZaVWd" gVidgn#6kV^aVWaZkZ]^XaZhVcYeVX`^c\bViZg^Vah[dgigVchedgikVgn\gZVian#IgVchedgi i]jhYZeZcYhdcl]Vi^hVkV^aVWaZ#=dlZkZg!jcYZgVaaXdcY^i^dch!dcZeg^bVgngjaZ h]djaYValVnhWZdWhZgkZY/9dcdiaZiVcnbdgZYVbV\Z!XdciVb^cVi^dc!dgb^m^c\dXXjg# DXXVh^dcVaan^i^hcZXZhhVgnidgZbdkZi]ZWjg^Vadg^iheVgihVhVjc^i!^cVhjeedgi" ^c\WadX`d[bVig^m![dghijYndgY^heaVn#IdgZbdkZVcZci^gZWjg^Va!Zbeadni]ZeVaZ" dcidad\^XVaiZX]c^fjZd[_VX`Zi^c\#IdYdi]^h!Äghi^hdaViZi]ZheZX^bZcdcVeZYZhiVad[ ZVgi]#8dkZg^il^i]hZkZgVaaVnZghd[lZii^hhjZeVeZgl]ZgZi]ZWdcZ^hZmedhZY#CZmi! jhZWjgaVeWVcYV\ZhhdV`ZY^ceaVhiZgid[dgbVXVhidg_VX`ZiVgdjcYi]ZheZX^bZc# GZ^c[dgXZ i]^h _VX`Zi Vh cZXZhhVgn l^i] higZc\i]Zc^c\ gdYh d[ bZiVa dg lddY# 6[iZg i]ZeaVhiZg]Vh]VgYZcZY!jcYZgXjii]ZheZX^bZcVcYa^[i^idji#I]^h^hVcZmeZch^kZ deZgVi^dc^ciZgbhd[bViZg^Va!i^bZ!VcYeZghdccZa#>igZfj^gZhZmeZg^ZcXZVcYh]djaY WZjhZYdcanl]ZccZXZhhVgn# DcXZ i]Z Wjg^Va ]Vh WZZc gZbdkZY! lVh]ZY! VcY Yg^ZY! i]Z ]VcYh! [ZZi! VcY g^Wh h]djaYWZWV\\ZYWnh^YZVcYi]ZkZgiZWgVZWnineZ#AVWZa^c\i]ZhZZaZbZcihVii]Z i^bZd[gZbdkVa\gZVian[VX^a^iViZhaViZghdgi^c\^ci]ZaVWdgVidgn#;^cZXaZVc^c\VcY \aj^c\h]djaYWZaZ[i[dgi]ZaVWdgVidgn#AVWZaVaaWV\hVcYWdmZhjhZY[dgXdaaZXi^dc l^i]lViZgegdd[^c`#EVeZgWV\hVgZegdcZidYZiZg^dgVi^dc^[jhZY[dgadc\"iZgbhidg" V\Z!Wjii]ZnWgZVi]Zbd^hijgZVcYVgZi]ZgZ[dgZWZiiZgi]VceaVhi^XWV\h[dgedhi"Zm" XVkVi^dc hdgi^c\ VcY igVchedgi d[ h`ZaZiVa bViZg^Va i]Vi gZiV^c gZh^YjVa bd^hijgZ# >c igVchedgi!`ZZei]ZWdcZhVlVn[gdblViZg#>i^hkZgn^bedgiVciidXVgZ[jaanaVWZaVcY bV^ciV^cdg\Vc^oVi^dcl]Zci]ZWdcZhVgZZmigVXiZY[gdbi]Z^gXdciZmiVcYbdkZYid i]ZaVWdgVidgn# L]ZceVX`^c\WdcZh!eVX`i^\]ianl^i]adihd[eVYY^c\eaVhi^XWV\hdgcZlheV" eZgidVkd^YbdkZbZci^ci]ZXdciV^cZg#EVX`]ZVk^Zg!YZchZgWdcZhVii]ZWdiidbd[ XdciV^cZghVcYi]ZbdgZ[gV\^aZWdcZhhjX]VhhXVejaV!eZak^h!VcYXgVc^VVii]Zide#7Z hjgZi]ViVaaWdcZhhiVn^ci]Z^gVhh^\cZYXdciV^cZghYjg^c\i]Z_dhia^c\i]Vi^cZk^iVWan VXXdbeVc^ZhigVchedgi#7ZeVgi^XjaVganXVgZ[jal^i]i]ZXgVc^jb!l]dhZ[VXZ^h[gV\^aZ# I]ZXgVc^jbVcYbVcY^WaZh]djaYZVX]WZeVX`ZYhZeVgViZan!VcYXVgZh]djaYWZiV`Zc idZchjgZi]ViiZZi]YdcdiY^hadY\Z[gdbi]Z^ghdX`ZihYjg^c\igVchedgi#

&IGUREI]^h[ZiVah`ZaZiVabViZg^Va[gdb i]ZegZ]^hidg^XA^WWZch^iZgZegZhZcihdcZ d[i]ZhbVaaZhiWjg^VahZkZggZXdkZgZY#


8]VeiZg';^ZaYEgdXZYjgZh

#HAPTER

:i]^Xh^cDhiZdad\n :

i]^Xh ^h i]Z hijYn d[ hiVcYVgYh d[ XdcYjXi VcY bdgVa _jY\bZci# :i]^Xh XVc WZ hZZcVhVhnhiZbd[kVajZhi]ViheZX^[nVXdYZd[XdcYjXi#I]ZgZVgZbjai^eaZkVajZ hnhiZbh!ZVX]l^i]YZÄc^i^dchd[l]Vi^hXdch^YZgZYg^\]iVcYlgdc\#I]ZhZYZÄc^i^dch VgZXjaijgVa!hdl]Vib^\]iWZZi]^XVa[dgdcZhX^Zci^hi![dgZmVbeaZ!b^\]iWZjcZi]^XVa [dgVgZa^\^djhaZVYZg#9^[[ZgZciZi]^XVahnhiZbhXdaa^YZVXgdhhi]ZheZXigjbd[dhiZdad\^" XVaZcYZVkdgh¸[gdbi]Z[dgZch^X!idi]ZVgX]Zdad\^XVa!idi]ZeVaZdcidad\^XVa#:mXZa" aZci]^hidg^XVaeZgheZXi^kZhdci]ZhjW_ZXid[Zi]^Xh^c]jbVcdhiZdad\nVgZegdk^YZY WnLVa`Zg'%%%VcYJWZaV`Zg'%%%# Egd[Zhh^dcVahl]dhijYn]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^chVgZ[gZfjZcianXVaaZYdcidbV`Z Zi]^XVa_jY\ZbZcih#I]^hX]VeiZgZmVb^cZhhdbZd[i]ZZi]^XVahiVcYVgYheZXja^Vgid dhiZdad\nVcYjc^kZghVaanegVXi^XZYWndhiZdad\^hih#;dghdbZdhiZdad\^XVa^hhjZhi]ZgZ VgZcdZVhnVchlZghVcYcdegZhXg^WZYXdYZhd[XdcYjXiid\j^YZi]ZegVXi^i^dcZg;^\" jgZ(#&# =jbVcdhiZdad\^hihVgZgdji^cZanXVaaZYdcidegVXi^XZ^ci]Z\aVgZd[i]ZbZY^V hedia^\]iVcYl^i]^caZ\Va!eda^i^XVa!hdX^Va!VcYZXdcdb^XVgZcVhl]ZgZhX^ZcXZbVn WZ b^hXdchigjZY VcY b^hgZegZhZciZY# L]Zi]Zg i]Z ^hhjZ ^h i]Z cjbWZg d[ eZg^h]ZY ^cY^k^YjVah^ci]Z7gVcX]9Vk^Y^VcXdbedjcYViLVXdDlhaZnZiVa#!&..*!i]ZcV" ijgZd[igVjbVidi]ZhdaY^Zghl]dY^ZYl^i]8jhiZgVii]ZA^iiaZ7^\=dgcHXdiiZiVa#! '%%'!dgi]ZV[Äc^i^Zhd[Vc^cY^k^YjVal]dY^ZYi]djhVcYhd[nZVghV\dVi@ZccZl^X` BdgZaa!&..-!i]Z]jbVcdhiZdad\^hi^hdWa^\ZYidWZ\j^YZYWn[VXihVcYi]ZhX^Zci^ÄX VeegdVX]gVi]Zgi]VcWnheZXjaVi^dc!hjeZghi^i^dc!ZXdcdb^Xh!egZXdcXZei^dc!dgeda^i^" XVaZmeZY^ZcXn#

%THICSIN&ORENSIC/STEOLOGY =jbVc h`ZaZiVa gZbV^ch d[iZc Ä\jgZ egdb^cZcian ^c aZ\Va bViiZgh# DhiZdad\^hih VgZ gdji^cZanVh`ZYid^YZci^[nh`ZaZiVagZbV^ch¸idYZiZgb^cZl]Zi]Zgi]ZnVgZ]jbVc VcY!^[i]ZnVgZ!idYZiZgb^cZi]ZV\Z!hZm!^YZci^in!VcYVci^fj^ind[i]ZgZbV^ch#>c[dg" bVi^dc^hegdk^YZYdc]dli]ZhZYZiZgb^cVi^dchbVnWZbVYZ[dgWdcngZbV^ch^c 8]VeiZg&.#HdbZi^bZhi]ZdhiZdad\^hi^hVh`ZYWnaVl"Zc[dgXZbZcigZegZhZciVi^kZhid bV`Z^YZci^ÄXVi^dch!VgZedgi^hÄaZYhZZ8]VeiZg&-!VcYi]ZbViiZgZcYhi]ZgZ#Dc dXXVh^dc!]dlZkZg!i]ZdhiZdad\^hiWZXdbZhbdgZYZZeanZcbZh]ZY^ci]ZaZ\VahnhiZb# >cbVcnXdjcig^Zh!aVl^hegVXi^XZY^cVcVYkZghVg^VahnhiZb^cl]^X]egdhZXji^c\ VcYYZ[ZchZViidgcZnhVcYi]Z^giZVbhhfjVgZd[[^cXdjgihd[aVl#I]ZgZVgZd[iZchZg^" '&

&IGURE1Xe]Q^VUdQ\ c[e\\>h^ig^\]idglgdc\ [dgi]^hjcWdgc^cY^k^YjVa¼h gZbV^chidWZXjgViZY^cV bjhZjb49^[[ZgZcieZdeaZ \^kZY^[[ZgZciVchlZghidi]^h fjZhi^dcYZeZcY^c\dcl]Vi Zi]^XVaeZgheZXi^kZi]ZnWg^c\ idi]Z^hhjZ#

djhfjZhi^dchd[Xg^b^cVa^indg^c]Zg^iVcXZ^ckdak^c\^YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[i]ZYZXZVhZY# I]ZhiV`ZhbVnWZ]^\]#>chjX]aZ\VaV[[V^gh!dhiZdad\^hihbVnWZgZiV^cZY[dgi]Z^gZm" eZgi^hZVcYiZhi^bdcnWnZ^i]Zgh^YZ#;dgi]ZhZVcYdi]ZggZVhdch!i]Z6bZg^XVc6XVY" Zbnd[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh]Vh[dgbVaan^cXdgedgViZYe]nh^XVaVci]gdedad\nVhdcZd[ ^ihY^hX^ea^cZh#

"OUNDARIESOF%VIDENCE >cVaadhiZdad\^XValdg`!WjieVgi^XjaVgan^c[dgZch^XdhiZdad\n!^i^h^bedgiVci[dgi]Z VcVanhiid`ZZeildi]^c\hXaZVgan^cb^cYViVaai^bZh#;^ghi!VcnXdcXajh^dcYgVlc^c VcdhiZdad\^XVagZedgibjhiWZYZ[Zch^WaZ#>cdi]ZgldgYh!i]ZdhiZdad\^hibjhiegZeVgZ [dgVX]VaaZc\ZWnZbeadn^c\i]ZbdhihdjcYVcYje"id"YViZVcVani^XVabZi]dYhVkV^a" VWaZ#HZXdcY!i]ZdhiZdad\^hih]djaYValVnhVkd^YhiZee^c\WZndcYi]ZWdjcYVg^ZhhZi Wni]ZdhiZdad\^XVaZk^YZcXZ^ihZa[#>cdi]ZgldgYh!]Zdgh]Z^hVcZmeZgi^cdhiZdad\n VcYcdicZXZhhVg^anVcZmeZgi^cXg^b^cVa^hi^Xh!eVi]dad\n!idm^Xdad\n!Zc\^cZZg^c\!dg YZiZXi^kZldg`# I]Z[dgZch^XdhiZdad\^hibjhiValVnhgZedgiVcYiZhi^[nl^i]^ci]ZWdjcYhd[i]Z WdcnZk^YZcXZVcYVXXdgY^c\idi]Zeg^cX^eaZhd[i]ZhX^Zci^ÄXY^hX^ea^cZi]Vi]Zdg h]ZgZegZhZcih#I]ZdhiZdad\^hih]djaYZmea^X^ianYgVli]ZViiZci^dcd[VaaXdcXZgcZY eVgi^Zh id a^b^iVi^dch d[ i]Z Zk^YZcXZ ^ihZa[ VcY id jcXZgiV^ci^Zh VhhdX^ViZY l^i] i]Z ^YZci^ÄXVi^dchi]Vi]VkZWZZceZg[dgbZY# DcZZmVbeaZhj[ÄXZhidh]dli]ZigV\^Xidaai]ViXVcWZiV`ZcWnV[V^ajgZiddW" hZgkZi]ZhZWVh^XgjaZh#I]ZK^ZicVbLVgVcYVhhdX^ViZYXdcÅ^Xi^cHdji]ZVhi6h^VgZ" hjaiZY^ci]ZYZVi]hd[]jcYgZYhd[i]djhVcYhd[eZdeaZ!Vbdc\l]dblZgZ6bZg^XVc 

8]VeiZg(:i]^Xh

b^a^iVgneZghdccZa#I]Z6bZg^XVchl]dcZkZggZijgcZY!VcYl]dhZWdY^ZhlZgZcdiVX" XdjciZY[dg!lZgZa^hiZYVhB>6b^hh^c\^cVXi^dc#I]^giZZcbZcVWdVgYVc6bZg^XVc 68"&(%\jch]^eh]diYdlcdkZgAVdh^c&.,'lZgZXdjciZYVbdc\i]ZB>6h#DkZg iZcnZVghaViZgVcZmXVkVi^dcVii]ZXgVh]h^iZgZXdkZgZY*%!%%%e^ZXZhd[WdcZ0i]ZaVg\" ZhiWdcZlVh&(Xbadc\!VcYbdhi[gV\bZcih]VYVbVm^bjbY^bZch^dcd[VgdjcY &Xb#6[iZgVcVanh^hWni]ZJ#H#6gbn!^ilVhVccdjcXZYi]Viedh^i^kZ^YZci^ÄXVi^dch ]VYWZZcbVYZdcVcVidbnVadcZ!VcYi]ViVaai]^giZZcbZc]VYWZZcVXXdjciZY[dg Wn i]ZhZ WdcZ [gV\bZcih# I]Z h`ZaZiVa gZbV^ch lZgZ i]Zc [dglVgYZY id i]Z [Vb^a^Zh [dgWjg^Va#GZaVi^kZhd[i]ZXgZlbZbWZghegZhhZYi]Z^hhjZd[^YZci^ÄXVi^dc!VcYVc ^cYZeZcYZci^ckZhi^\Vi^dcd[i]ZhZWdcZhlVhbVYZ#>iWZXVbZXaZVgi]Vii]ZVcVanh^h! Vai]dj\]YdcZWnegd[Zhh^dcVadhiZdad\^hih!]VYbVYZXdcXajh^dchVWdjiV\Z!hZm!gVXZ! VcY^cY^k^YjVi^dci]VilZci[VgWZndcYi]ZZk^YZcXZc XVhZh a^`Z i]^h dcZ i]Z Zk^YZcXZ XVc WZ ZmVb^cZYWnhZkZgVa^ckZhi^\VidghVcY[VjainVcVanh^h^hi]ZgZWnZmedhZY#>ci]ZbZVc" i^bZ!]dlZkZg!i]Za^kZhd[bVcneZdeaZXVcWZYZZeanV[[ZXiZYWni]ZXdcXajh^dchd[i]Z dhiZdad\^hi!l]dXaZVgan]VhVgZhedch^W^a^inidgZheZXii]Za^b^ihd[i]Z]VgYZk^YZcXZ#

4HE%XPERT7ITNESS L^icZhhZh^cXdjgiegdXZZY^c\hVgZhldgcidiZaai]Zigji]!i]Zl]daZigji]!VcYcdi]" ^c\Wjii]Zigji]#I]ZZmeZgil^icZhh^c[dgZch^XdhiZdad\nbjhiVahd!d[XdjghZ!VY]ZgZ idi]ZhZgjaZh#HZZ@d\Vc&.,-!HiZlVgi&.,.!;ZYZg&..&!VcYHiZVYbVc'%%(0 HZXi^dc >! EZghdcVa >YZci^ÄXVi^dc VcY AZ\Va 8dch^YZgVi^dch d[ ;dgZch^X 6ci]gdeda" d\n8VhZldg`^ci]ZJc^iZYHiViZh[dg[jgi]ZgYZiV^ahdcZmeZgiiZhi^bdcn!VcY=VVX` '%%([dgVcdkZgk^Zld[hX^ZcXZ^ci]ZXdjgih#IZhi^bdcnWnZmeZgil^icZhhhX^Zci^hih ^hdci]Z^cXgZVhZ^cXdjgihd[aVli]gdj\]djii]ZldgaY!Vai]dj\]Y^[[ZgZci_jY^X^Va hnhiZbh ]VcYaZ ZmeZgih ^c Y^[[ZgZci lVnh# ;dg ZmVbeaZ! ^c
'(

Xdch^YZgVgZl]Zi]ZgVbZi]dYdgiZX]c^fjZXVcWZVcY]VhWZZciZhiZY!l]Zi]Zg^i ]VhWZZchjW_ZXiZYideZZggZk^ZlVcYejWa^XVi^dc!VcYl]Vii]ZZggdggViZhVgZ# I]ZaViZ6bZg^XVce]nh^XVaVci]gdedad\^hiVcY¹ZmeZgil^icZhhº9g#Adj^hZGdW" W^ch=VchZc!&..(bVnhZgkZVhVcZmVbeaZ#GdWW^chlVhVhZa["Veed^ciZYZmeZgi^c [ddieg^ci ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc l]d iZhi^ÄZY Vi cjbZgdjh ig^Vah VWdji ]Zg VW^a^i^Zh id ^cY^" k^YjViZeZdeaZWVhZYdc^begZhh^dchaZ[iWni]Z^gh]dZh!hdX`h!dgWVgZ[ZZi#H]ZXaV^bZY i]Vi]ZgiZX]c^fjZhVaadlZY]ZgidiZaal]Zi]ZgVeZghdcbVYZVeVgi^XjaVgeg^ciWn ZmVb^c^c\ Vcn di]Zg h]dZh WZadc\^c\ id i]Vi ^cY^k^YjVa# H]Z hiViZY i]Vi [ddieg^cih lZgZWZiiZg^cY^XVidgh[dg^YZci^[n^c\eZdeaZi]VcÄc\Zgeg^cih#Di]ZgZmeZgil^icZhhZh iZhi^ÄZYdc]ZgWZ]Va[!VcYV\V^chi]Zg!Yjg^c\V[dgZch^XXVgZZgi]ViheVccZYVYZXVYZ VcYhVlbVcnXdck^Xi^dch#DcannZVghaViZg!V[iZg]ZgYZVi]!lZgZ]ZgiZX]c^fjZhVcY XdcXajh^dchZmedhZY#E]nh^XVaVci]gdedad\^hiDlZcAdkZ_dnd[@ZciHiViZJc^kZgh^in cdiZY!¹H]ZbVnlZaa]VkZWZa^ZkZYl]Vih]ZlVhhVn^c\!Wjii]ZhX^Zci^ÄXWVh^hd[]Zg XdcXajh^dchlVhXdbeaZiZan[gVjYjaZciºe#++^c=VchZc!&..(# Id]ZgdlcZnZh!VcYidi]ZZnZhd[i]ZViidgcZnhl]dgZiV^cZY]Zg!9g#GdWW^ch lVhVXi^c\^cVegd[Zhh^dcVaVcYZi]^XVabVccZg#>ci]ZZnZhd[di]ZghX^Zci^hih!h]ZlVh jcZi]^XVa#>ci]ZZcY!]ZgXdcXajh^dchlZgZh]dlcidWZjcgZa^VWaZ!WjinZVghd[a^i^\V" i^dclZgZ^ckdakZY!VcYnZVghd[^cXVgXZgVi^dcgZhjaiZY[gdbXdck^Xi^dchV^YZYWn]Zg ^ciZgegZiVi^dch# ;dgZch^XZmeZgihd[iZcY^hV\gZZ!VcYcdiValVnhWZXVjhZdcZd[i]Zb^hjcZi]^XVa dgjcigV^cZY#CdgYWn&..'!e#&&&+Vh`h!¹=dlXVclZjcYZghiVcYi]Z\gdjcYh[dg \Zcj^cZY^hV\gZZbZciWZilZZcild]dcZhi!fjVa^ÄZY[dgZch^XZmeZgih4º=ZVg\jZhi]Vi lZbjhiY^hi^c\j^h]WZilZZchZZ^c\VcYdWhZgk^c\#LZVaahZZ!WjilZdWhZgkZY^[[ZgZci i]^c\hWVhZYdci]ZXdciZmihd[djg`cdlaZY\Z!WZa^Z[h!kVajZh!VcY\dVah#CdgYWnVg\jZh Xdck^cX^c\ani]Vi^i^hi]ZgdaZd[i]ZZmeZgil^icZhhidgZÄcZi]ZXdciZmid[dWhZgkVi^dc WVhZYdcZmeZgijcYZghiVcY^c\!ValVnhZmVb^c^c\]^YYZcdWhZgkVi^dcVaZmeZXiVi^dch i]Vi bVn ^cÅjZcXZhjeea^ZY^ciZgegZiVi^dch#I]ZZmeZgibjhiValVnhWZhZa["Xg^i^XVa VcYValVnhgZVYnidYZ[ZcYl]VibVnijgcdjiidWZi]ZdcanhjeedgiVWaZXdcXajh^dc ¸i]ZXdcXajh^dcd[¹>Ydc¼i`cdl#ºI]ZZmeZgihjeea^Zh\ddYgZVhdchidhjeedgii]Vi de^c^dc#CdgYWne#&&')XdcXajYZh/¹7di]`cdl^c\VcYcdi`cdl^c\VgZ^c[dgbZY edh^i^dchgZVX]ZYWnXVgZ[jaVeea^XVi^dcd[hX^Zci^ÄXVaanYZ[Zch^WaZbZi]dYh#L]Zc i]ZgZhjaihd[i]dhZbZi]dYhYdcdiVaadljhidgVi^dcVaanegZ[ZgdcZXdcXajh^dcdkZg VcVaiZgcVi^kZ!lZbjhihZiiaZ[dg`cdl^c\l]nlZYdcdi`cdl#º

%THICSIN!RCHEOLOGICAL/STEOLOGY I]ZgZ ^h V hiVg` XdcigVhi WZilZZc i]Z l^YZan VXXZeiZY VcY ZVh^an YZa^cZViZY Zi]^XVa VcYaZ\Va\j^YZa^cZh[dgi]ZdhiZdad\^hildg`^c\^cV[dgZch^XhZii^c\VcYi]ZVbW^\j^" i^Zhd[Zi]^XhVcYaVli]Vi]Vjcii]ZdhiZdad\^hildg`^c\^cVcVgX]Zdad\^XVahZii^c\# :k^YZcXZ!ad\^X!gZVhdc!VcYi]ZhX^Zci^ÄXbZi]dYVgZVaa]ZaY^c]^\]ZhiZZb^ci]Z [dgZch^XgZVab#L]ZcXaV^bhd[Zci^iaZbZciZciZgi]ZaZ\VahnhiZb![dgZmVbeaZ!i]ZgZ ^hgVgZanVcViiZbeiid¹WVaVcXZºhX^Zci^ÄXVcYhe^g^ijVaZk^YZcXZ¸i]Z[dgbZgiV`Zh egZXZYZcXZ#I]^hlVhigVY^i^dcVaani]ZXVhZ^ci]ZgZVabd[hX^Zci^ÄXVgX]Zdad\n#Cdl! ]dlZkZg! i]Z h^ijVi^dc ^ckdak^c\ WdcZh [gdb VgX]Zdad\^XVa XdciZmih i]gdj\]dji i]Z ldgaY ]Vh WZXdbZ XdbeaZm! Åj^Y! VbW^\jdjh! eda^i^X^oZY! VcY Xdc[jh^c\ YjZ id i]Z egdbja\Vi^dcd[aVlhi]ViV^bidgZYgZhhl]ViVgZhZZcVhgZa^\^djh^c_jhi^XZhjcYZgiV`" 

8]VeiZg(:i]^Xh

Zc^ci]ZcVbZd[hX^ZcXZ#>i^hcZXZhhVgnidZmVb^cZi]ZXVjhZh[dgi]^hh^ijVi^dcVcYid Xdch^YZghdbZd[^ih^bea^XVi^dch[dgdhiZdad\^XVagZhZVgX]^ckdak^c\]jbVcgZbV^ch#

%THICSIN#OLLISION GZhZVgX]^c]jbVcdhiZdad\ncZXZhhVg^an^ckdakZhi]ZhijYnd[]VgYi^hhjZhi]VigZe" gZhZcieZdeaZ#6kVg^Zind[a^k^c\eZdeaZ]VkZdW_ZXiZYiddhiZdad\^XVaZmXVkVi^dcVcY gZhZVgX]#6cVidb^XVahijYnd[i]ZYZXZVhZY]VhWZZcXdcigdkZgh^Va[gdb^ihkZgn^cXZe" i^dc#:VganVcVidb^hihlZgZ[dgXZYidgZig^ZkZVcYY^hhZXii]Z^gXVYVkZgh^chZXgZXn#Id" YVn!VhZkZgnÄghi"nZVgbZY^XVahijYZci`cdlh!gZbV^chd[i]ZYZVYVgZk^iVagZhdjgXZh [dgiZVX]^c\i]Za^k^c\#Hd^i^h^cdhiZdad\n# 9ZVi]]VhV]^\]Zbdi^dcVakVajZ!Vh^cY^XViZYWni]Z[VXii]ViWdi]bdYZgcVcY egZ]^hidg^X]jbVch]VkZYZkZadeZYVl^YZgVc\Zd[XjhidbhVcYg^ijVah[dgYZVa^c\ l^i] ^i¸Xjhidbh VcY g^ijVah i]Vi X]Vc\Z i]gdj\] i^bZ# 6gX]Zdad\^hih VcY e]nh^" XVaVci]gdedad\^hih]VkZaZVgcZY!VcYXdci^cjZidaZVgc!VWdjieVhi]jbVcbdgijVgn egVXi^XZhWnZmXVkVi^c\h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#6hdjia^cZYZahZl]ZgZ^ci]^hWdd`!XVgZ[ja VcVanh^hd[i]ZWdcZhi]ZbhZakZh]VhaZYid^ch^\]ih^cidi]ZY^Zi!a^k^c\XdcY^i^dch! edejaVi^dchigjXijgZ!\ZcZi^XgZaVi^dch]^eh!]ZVai]!VcYZkdaji^dcd[]db^c^Yh^cWdi] i]ZgZXZciVcYgZbdiZeVhi#I]ZZbdi^kZkVajZd[YZVi]]VhXdbW^cZYl^i]i]Z^c[dg" bVi^dcXdciZcid[]jbVcWdcZhid[dgbVXdbWjhi^WaZb^m^ci]ZbdYZgcldgaY#I]Z YZWViZdkZg]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^chedhZhZi]^XVaY^aZbbVh[dgegVXi^X^c\dhiZdad\^hih VcYVgX]Zdad\^hih# >cCdgi]6bZg^XVVcY6jhigVa^V!aVg\ZedejaVi^dchd[^cY^\ZcdjheZdeaZbZi:jgd" eZVcZmeadgZghhZkZgVa]jcYgZYnZVghV\d#HjWhZfjZciidi]^hXdciVXiWdi]Xdci^cZcih hVli]ZYZXa^cZVcYhdbZi^bZhi]ZZmi^cXi^dcd[cVi^kZeZdeaZhVcYi]Z^gXjaijgVa]Zg^" iV\ZVh:jgdeZVcXdadc^oVi^dcegdXZZYZY#CVi^kZ6jhigVa^VcVcY6bZg^XVchjgk^kdgh d[i]ZhZ^ckVh^dchhj[[ZgZYVcYXdci^cjZidhj[[Zg\gZVi^c_jhi^XZh#6XVaadjhY^hgZ\VgY [dghjgk^k^c\cVi^kZeZdeaZ]VhhdbZi^bZhWZZcYZbdchigViZYWnYZkZadeZgh!bjhZdad" \^hih!\dkZgcbZcih!VcYVci]gdedad\^hih^ci]ZgZXdkZgnVcYY^hedh^i^dcd[VWdg^\^cVa h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#6YdjWaZhiVcYVgY]VhhdbZi^bZhWZZcVeea^ZY^ci]ZY^hijgWVcXZ VcYhjWhZfjZciigZVibZciVcYY^hedh^i^dcd[:jgdeZVckZghjh^cY^\Zcdjhh`ZaZiVagZ" bV^chBX<j^gZ!&.-.0=jWZgi!&.-.# >c>hgVZa!jaigVdgi]dYdm?Zlh]VkZhdj\]iidgZhig^XiVgX]Zdad\^XVagZhZVgX]#>cCZl Ndg`!6[g^XVc"6bZg^XVch]VkZ^ch^hiZYi]Vih`ZaZiVagZbV^chd[haVkZhdcanWZhijY^ZY Wn 6[g^XVc"6bZg^XVc dhiZdad\^hih# 6gX]Zdad\^XVa ZmXVkVi^dc VcY VcVanh^h d[ h`ZaZiVa gZbV^ch]VkZWZZchZg^djhanXjgiV^aZYVcYZkZchideeZYVii]Z^ch^hiZcXZd[hdbZcV" i^kZCdgi]6bZg^XVcVcY6jhigVa^Vc\gdjehl]d]VkZjhZYi]Z^hhjZVhV[dgjb[gdb l]^X] id ZmegZhh i]Z^g \g^ZkVcXZh# I]Z fjZhi^dc d[ ZmXVkVi^dc VcY edhi"ZmXVkVi^dc ]VcYa^c\ VcY Y^hedh^i^dc d[ dhiZdad\^XVa gZbV^ch ]Vh gVe^Yan \Vi]ZgZY Xdch^YZgVWaZ hnbWda^X^bedgiVcXZidbVcneZdeaZ#>chdbZgZ\^dch!gZhZVgX]^cidegZ]^hidgn]Vh hj[[ZgZYhZiWVX`h!l^i]ZmXVkVi^dchWZ^c\]VaiZYl]^aZXjaijgVaVcYh`ZaZiVabViZg^Va^h gZWjg^ZY#I]ZgZ^hcdWZiiZglVnid^aajhigViZVcYZmeadgZi]ZZi]^XVa^hhjZhd[ZmXVkV" i^dc!VcVanh^h!VcYgZWjg^Vad[]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^chi]VcidegZhZciVXVhZ]^hidgn [dgVYY^i^dcVak^Zlh!hZZBZ^\]Vc!&..'0@aZhZgiVcYEdlZaa!&..(0
'*

?jhidkZgh^m]jcYgZYnZVghV\d!adc\WZ[dgZ8dajbWjhZmeadgZYi]Z¹CZlLdgaY!º V[dgi^ÄZYk^aaV\Zh^iZVi8gdl8gZZ`!dcl]Vi^hcdli]ZH^djm>cY^VcGZhZgkVi^dc^c Hdji]9V`diV!lVh^c]VW^iZYWncZVgandcZi]djhVcYCVi^kZ6bZg^XVch#I]^hegZ]^h" idg^X!egdWVWan6g^`VgV!k^aaV\ZlVhViiVX`ZYVcYcZVganÄkZ]jcYgZYd[i]Z^c]VW^i" Vcih`^aaZY#6ai]dj\]i]ZgZ^hcd]^hidg^XgZXdgYd[i]^hZkZci!]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch YdXjbZci^c\ i]Z bVhhVXgZ lZgZ Y^hXdkZgZY ZgdY^c\ dji d[ i]Z h^iZ ^c &.,- ;^\jgZ (#'L^aaZnVcY:bZghdc!&..(#6cV\gZZbZcilVhgZVX]ZYVbdc\i]ZH^djmAV`diV! 9V`diV!VcYCV`diVIg^WZhdcl]dhZaVcYi]Zh^iZlVhadXViZY!i]ZJ#H#6gbn8dgehd[ :c\^cZZgh!VcYi]Zegd_ZXiVgX]Zdad\^hih# 6cVanh^hd[i]Z]j\Zh`ZaZiVahVbeaZZmXVkViZYVi8gdl8gZZ`lVha^b^iZYWni]Z Vbdjci d[ i^bZ VkV^aVWaZ WZ[dgZ ^i lVh eaVXZY ^c \daY"eV^ciZY! XdcXgZiZ Xd[Äch VcY gZWjg^ZY#I]ZVaiZgcVi^kZidhijYnVcYgZWjg^ValVhcdZmXVkVi^dcViVaa#I]Zegd_ZXi dhiZdad\^hi!E#L^aaZnd[i]ZJc^kZgh^ind[IZccZhhZZ!hjbbVg^oZYi]Zh^ijVi^dcVh[daadlh/ DcanÄkZbdci]hlZgZeZgb^iiZY[dgi]ZVcVanh^h!VcY>VcYi]Zdi]Zg e]nh^XVaVci]gdedad\^hihY^YVhXdbeaZiZV_dWVhlZXdjaY#6hi]ZVcVanh^h egdXZZYZY!]dlZkZg!gZhZVgX]fjZhi^dchXVbZjel]^X]lZXdjaYcdiejg" hjZVchlZghidl^i]^ci]ZeZg^dYd[i^bZYZh^\cViZY###>cY^Vcha^k^c\id" YVnhiVcYidWZcZÄi[gdbdjgXdcXajh^dch#6YY^i^dcVahijYnd[i]ZgZbV^ch b^\]iV^YCVi^kZ6bZg^XVch[jgi]Zg#:mVbeaZhd[i]ZVeea^XVi^dchd[djg VcVanhZh^cXajYZYZiZgb^cVi^dchd[W^dad\^XVagZaVi^dch]^ehl]^X]hjeedgi >cY^VcaVcYXaV^bhVcYjcYZghiVcY^c\hd[egZ]^hidg^XY^hZVhZl]^X]XdjaY VaaZk^ViZhj[[Zg^c\Vbdc\egZhZci"YVnCVi^kZ6bZg^XVch#>[djghijY^Zhd[ Y^hZVhZ XdjaY gZhjai ^c jcYZghiVcY^c\h l]^X] hVkZY _jhi dcZ X]^aY¼h a^[Z! i]ZchjgZangZiV^c^c\h`ZaZidch[dgXdbeaZiZhijYn^hlVggVciZY#L]ZclZ

&IGUREI]Z8gdl8gZZ`bVhhVXgZWdcZWZY#



8]VeiZg(:i]^Xh

VaahiVcYidWZcZÄi!i]Z^ciZgZhihd[dcZZi]c^X\gdjeh]djaYcdiWZeZgb^i" iZYidhiVcY^ci]ZlVn#LZbjhiWZVWaZidYdi]ZbdhiXdbeaZiZVcYXdb" egZ]Zch^kZhijYnd[Vaa]jbVch`ZaZidchd[Vaa]jbVc\gdjeh# L^aaZn!&.-&!e#'+ I]Z^hhjZd[ZmXVkVi^dc!VcVanh^h!VcYgZWjg^VahiVcYhdjiXaZVganVi8gdl8gZZ`!Wji ^i\dZh[VgWZndcYi]^hdcZdXXjggZcXZ#HdbZCVi^kZ6bZg^XVch]VkZXaV^bZYi]ViVaa VgX]Zdad\^XVagZhZVgX]^hgVX^hiVcY^ck^daVi^dcd[i]ZhVXgZYcVijgZd[egZ]^hidg^Xh^iZh# HdbZVgX]Zdad\^hih]VkZgZhedcYZYWngZWjgn^c\ZmXVkViZYgZbV^ch!dgcdiZmXVkVi^c\ ViVaa!VhVbZVchd[aZhhZc^c\iZch^dchdghZXjg^c\XdcigVXih#HZkZgVaVgX]Zdad\^hihVcY e]nh^XVaVci]gdedad\^hih]VkZ\dcZhd[VgVhidh^\cW^cY^c\aZ\VaV\gZZbZcihidgZWjgn VcnWdcZbViZg^Va^cXajY^c\cdc]jbVcWdcZdci]Zhedil^i]djiVcVanh^h!idWjgn Vaae]did\gVe]hVcYcZ\Vi^kZhbVYZYjg^c\i]ZgZhZVgX]!VcYidgZWjgnVcnVgi^[VXih [djcY^ci]Zk^X^c^ind[i]Zh`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#H`ZaZiVahVbeaZh]VkZWZZciV`Zc[gdb bjhZjbXdaaZXi^dchVcYgZWjg^ZY!Ve]ZcdbZcdchdbZe]nh^XVaVci]gdedad\^hih]VkZ a^`ZcZYidi]ZYZhigjXi^dcd[h^c\aZ"XdenbVcjhXg^eih# I]Z6bZg^XVc8dbb^iiZZ[dgEgZhZgkVi^dcd[6gX]Zdad\^XVa8daaZXi^dchXdch^YZgh i]ZbV^ciZcVcXZd[VgX]Zdad\^XVaXdaaZXi^dch!^cXajY^c\h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch!idWZeVgid[ i]Zegd[Zhh^dcVaVcYZi]^XVaYjind[hX]daVgh^cVgX]Zdad\n#I]^h\gdjejg\ZhVgX]Zdad" \^hihidVWhiV^c[gdbeVgi^X^eVi^dc^cVcnÄZaYegd_ZXi!XdcigVXi!dgdi]Zgegd\gVb^c l]^X]XdaaZXi^dchdWiV^cZY[gdbgZhZVgX]l^aaWZ\^kZcje[dgYZhigjXi^dc#I]ZngZX" dbbZcYi]VihX]daVgandg\Vc^oVi^dch^cVgX]Zdad\nigZVi`cdl^c\VXihd[YZhigjXi^dc d[VgX]Zdad\^XVabViZg^Vah!dgXdbea^X^in^chjX]VXih!Vh\gdjcYh[dgZmejah^dc[gdb i]Zegd[Zhh^dcd[VgX]Zdad\n# BVcne]nh^XVaVci]gdedad\^hih]VkZVXi^kZandeedhZYZ[[dgihidgZWjgnh`ZaZiVabV" iZg^Va!egdWVWanWZXVjhZi]ZhZhX^Zci^hihVgZbdhiVlVgZd[i]ZediZci^Va^c[dgbVi^dc^c i]ZhZgZbV^chVcYVgZbdhihZch^i^kZid]dli]^h^c[dgbVi^dc^hadhii]gdj\]gZWjg^Va# ?VcZ 7j^`higV! V e]nh^XVa Vci]gdedad\^hi! ]Vh VYYgZhhZY hZkZgVa b^hXdcXZei^dch i]Vi ]VkZX]VgVXiZg^oZYi]Z^hhjZ7j^`higV!&.-&V!&.-(#L]^iZVgX]Zdad\^hih]VkZWZZc VXXjhZYd[¹cZkZgY^\\^c\jei]Z^gdlcVcXZhidgh!º^cZ[[ZXiegVXi^X^c\V`^cYd[Vg" X]Zdad\^XVaVeVgi]Z^Y#6h7j^`higVcdiZh!i]Z[VXii]ViVbdhianl]^iZhZid[egd[Zhh^dcVa VgX]Zdad\^hihhijYnVhZid[bdhianVWdg^\^cVaWdcZh^cCdgi]6bZg^XVVcY6jhigVa^V^h cdiVbVc^[ZhiVi^dcd[gVX^hb#;gdbi]ZZmXVkVi^dcd[gZbV^chd[l]^iZ[gdci^ZghbZc ^cLndb^c\<^aaZiVa#!&.-)0hZZ8]VeiZg'idVcVanh^hd[gZbV^ch[gdb&,i]"VcY &-i]"XZcijgn\gVkZhd[:jgdeZVcl]VaZghdcHe^ihWZg\ZcBVVi!&.-&!&.-,!VgX]Z" dad\^hihVcYe]nh^XVaVci]gdedad\^hihgdji^cZanldg`dch`ZaZiVagZbV^chVhhdX^ViZY l^i]gZXZciLZhiZgcXjaijgZ#>c[VXi!i]ZaVg\ZhiVcYWZhi"hijY^ZYh`ZaZiVahZg^Zh^cjhZ Wne]nh^XVaVci]gdedad\^hih^hXdbedhZYd[bdhianl]^iZVcYWaVX`^cY^k^YjVah[gdb bZY^XVa hX]dda Y^hhZXi^dch Vi 8VhZ LZhiZgc GZhZgkZ Jc^kZgh^in# BVcn d[ i]ZhZ h`Za" ZidchXdbZ[gdb`cdlc!cVbZY!heZX^ÄX^cY^k^YjVahl]dhZgZa^\^dc^hd[iZcgZXdgYZY# ;jgi]ZgbdgZ!hdbZd[i]Zh`ZaZiVahZm^c\VcYV\^c\iZX]c^fjZhjhZYbdhil^YZanWn dhiZdad\^hihlZgZYZkZadeZY!^ceVgi![gdbVcVanh^hd[i]ZgZbV^chd[l]^iZ6bZg^XVch `^aaZY^ci]Z@dgZVcLVghZZ8]VeiZg&.#I]Zb^hXdcXZei^dci]ViXdci^cjZYXjgVi^dc d[ gZbV^ch YdZh cdi ]Zae a^k^c\ eZdeaZ ]Vh WZZc VYYgZhhZY gZeZViZYan# ;dg ZmVbeaZ! JWZaV`Zg¼h&..%hjXXZhh^cedh^i^kZan^YZci^[n^c\CVi^kZ6bZg^XVcbjgYZgk^Xi^bh [gdbi]ZE^cZG^Y\ZGZhZgkVi^dclVhVY^gZXigZhjaid[]^hjhZd[XdbeVgVi^kZXdaaZX" i^dchd[CVi^kZ6bZg^XVch# (#':i]^Xh^c6gX]Zdad\^XVaDhiZdad\n

',

.!'02!AND)TS%FFECTS >cCdgi]6bZg^XV!hdbZCVi^kZ6bZg^XVchVg\jZYYjg^c\i]Z&.,%hVcY&.-%hi]Vi WZXVjhZ hdbZ XdciZbedgVgn >cY^Vc eZdeaZ ]VkZ YZhXZcYVci gZaVi^dch]^eh id hdbZ h`ZaZiVa gZbV^ch ]djhZY ^c bjhZjb XdaaZXi^dch! i]Z Y^hedh^i^dc d[ i]ZhZ gZbV^ch h]djaYWZXdcigdaaZYZmXajh^kZanWnbdYZgcCVi^kZ6bZg^XVch#CjbZgdjhhiViZaVlh VYYgZhhZYi]Z^hhjZ!VcYdcCdkZbWZg&+!&..%!EgZh^YZci7jh]VeegdkZYEjWa^XAVl &%&·+%&!i]ZCVi^kZ6bZg^XVccYZZY! hdbZ Vci]gdedad\^hih VgZ hnbeVi]Zi^X id i]Zcdi^dci]Vii]ZgZ^hcddW_ZXi^kZgZVa^inViVaa#I]ZC6<EG6hiVijiZ^hWVhZYdc hdbZi]^c\`cdlcVh¹XjaijgVaV[Äa^Vi^dc#ºI]ZaVl^chigjXih^chi^iji^dchVcYediZci^Va XaV^bVcih[dg¹gZeVig^Vi^dcºidVhhZhh¹XjaijgVaV[Äa^Vi^dcºWnV¹egZedcYZgVcXZd[i]Z Zk^YZcXZ!º Zk^YZcXZ i]Vi ^cXajYZh ZkZgni]^c\ [gdb W^dad\n id \Zd\gVe]n id [da`adgZ VcYdgVaigVY^i^dc#=dlVgZi]ZhZlZ^\]ZY4GZbV^chbVndcanWZgZijgcZYV[iZghjX] ¹XjaijgVaV[Äa^Vi^dcº^hZhiVWa^h]ZY#I]jh!i]ZC6<EG6aZ\^haVi^dc]VhdeZcZY^chi^" iji^dcVah`ZaZiVaXdaaZXi^dchjeidediZci^VaXaV^bhWn^cY^k^YjVahl]d[ZZahe^g^ijVa XdccZXi^dchidi]ZgZbV^ch^cfjZhi^dc# I]ZYZWViZXdcXZgc^c\ZmXVkVi^dc!hijYn!VcYgZWjg^Vad[]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch l^aaXdci^cjZidWZ]ZVgY^ci]ZXdjgih!VhlVhi]Z@ZccZl^X`XVhZ
4HE&UTURE 6cn\gdjed[eZdeaZ![gdbi]ZhbVaaZhi[Vb^anidi]Z]jbVcheZX^Zh!^hWZhiZfj^eeZY 

8]VeiZg(:i]^Xh

idYZVal^i]^ihegZhZciVcY[jijgZl]Zc^ibdhi[jaanjcYZghiVcYhVcYVeegZX^ViZh ^ih ]Zg^iV\Z# EgZ]^hidg^X gZhZVgX]! ^cXajY^c\ dhiZdad\^XVa hijYn! ^h dcZ lVn i]Vi ]Zg^" iV\ZXVcWZ[jaangZkZVaZY#I]Z\gZViigV\ZYn^ci]ZYZWViZdkZgh`ZaZiVagZbV^ch[gdb VgX]Zdad\^XVaXdciZmih^hi]Vii]Z^hhjZ]VhhdbZi^bZhe^iiZYVgX]Zdad\^hihV\V^chiYZ" hXZcYVcihVcYgZaVi^kZhd[i]ZeZdeaZi]Znl^h]idhijYn#I]^h]VhdXXjggZYViVi^bZ l]Zci]ZkZgnVgX]Zdad\^XVagZhdjgXZh^cCdgi]6bZg^XVVcY6jhigVa^Vl]^X]Wdi] eVgi^ZhhZZ`idegZhZgkZVgZY^hVeeZVg^c\ViVcjcegZXZYZciZYgViZVii]Z]VcYhd[i]Z YZkZadeZgVcYi]ZaddiZg;^\jgZ(#(#>ci]Z[VXZd[i]^hXViVhigde]^XVcY^ggZkZgh^WaZ YZhigjXi^dcd[i]ZeVhi¼hdcangZXdgY!i]ZgZWjg^Va^hhjZXdchi^ijiZhVXdhianY^kZgh^dc[dg VaaeVgi^Zh#I]ZhX^Zci^ÄXXdbbjc^inVcYcVi^kZ\gdjehcZZYidgZY^gZXii]Z^gZcZg\^Zh ^cVXdcXZgiZYZ[[dgiidhVkZVcYegdiZXii]Z]Zg^iV\Zd[i]ZeVhiWZ[dgZ^iY^hVeeZVgh# L]Vi^higjZ[dgjeeZgEaZ^hidXZcZVcY=dadXZcZdhiZdad\^XVagZbV^ch^hVahdigjZ [dg]db^c^Y[dhh^ah#>cbVcneVgihd[i]ZldgaYl]ZgZi]Zbdhi^bedgiVci]db^c^Y [dhh^ahVgZWZ^c\[djcY!i]ZVXVYZb^XVcYhX^Zci^ÄX^c[gVhigjXijgZhgZbV^ca^iiaZYZkZa" deZY#6hVgZhjai![dhh^ah]VkZd[iZcWZZcZmedgiZYidi]ZcVi^dchi]Vi]VY¹Xdadc^oZYº i]ZhZaVcYh!idWZhijY^ZYWn[dgZ^\cZmeZgih!VcYd[iZcY^heaVnZYVcYXjgViZY^cYZÄ" c^iZan^c[dgZ^\cbjhZjbhVcYjc^kZgh^i^Zh#I]ZYZb^hZd[Xdadc^VagjaZVXgdhh6[g^XV VcY6h^VZcYZYi]^hh^ijVi^dc!WjiViiZci^dcidi]ZYZkZadebZcid[[VX^a^i^ZhVcYeZg" hdccZaidhjeedgidc\d^c\]jbVceVaZdcidad\^XVagZhZVgX]^ci]ZhZVgZVhlVhhadl^c Xdb^c\#IdYVn!eVgi^XjaVgan^c6[g^XV!VÄghi\ZcZgVi^dcd[hX]daVgh^hiV`^c\^bedgiVci

&IGUREVWdkZVcY[daadl^c\eV\ZKVcYVa^hbd[dhiZdad\^XVagZbV^ch^cVcVgX]Zdad\^XVa XdciZmi#:k^YZcXZd[addi^c\^hhZZc^ci]ZhZilde]did\gVe]hiV`ZcVii]Zh^iZd[CjkV`lZliVfV! VaVg\Z&%%% gddbejZWad^cXZcigVa6g^odcVdXXje^ZYWZilZZcVY&'-%VcY&)'*#KVcYVah ]VkZ]Ve]VoVgYanY^hXVgYZYi]Z]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^chZcXdjciZgZY^ci]Z^ghZVgX][dg\gVkZ \ddYh!YVbV\^c\i]ZWdcZhVcY[dgZkZgadh^c\i]Z^gXdciZmi#I]ZcdcgZcZlVWaZVgX]Zdad\^XVa gZXdgY^hgVe^YanY^hVeeZVg^c\YjZidhjX]eajcYZg#E]didhXdjgiZhnd[EZiZgE^aaZhVcYi]Z 8dXdc^cdCVi^dcVa;dgZhi#

(#':i]^Xh^c6gX]Zdad\^XVaDhiZdad\n

'.

&IGUREXdci^cjZY

hiZeh idlVgY YZkZade^c\ i]Z cZXZhhVgn eaVi[dgb [gdb l]^X] id XdcYjXi ldgaY"XaVhh gZhZVgX]^cid]jbVceVaZdcidad\n#I]ZgZVgZXdci^cjZY^chiVcXZhd[Zmead^iVi^kZgZaV" i^dch]^ehVcY]^i"VcY"gjc[dhh^a]jci^c\Wn[dgZ^\cZgh[gdbi]ZYZkZadeZYldgaY!Wji i]ZgZVgZVahdhZkZgVabdYZahd[^ciZgcVi^dcVaXdaaVWdgVi^dcWZilZZcadXVaVcY[dgZ^\c hX]daVgh!^cWdi]6[g^XVVcY6h^V# >i^hZhhZci^Va[dgdhiZdad\^hih^ciZgZhiZY^cXdcYjXi^c\aVWdgVidgnVcYÄZaYgZhZVgX] ^c[dgZ^\cXdjcig^ZhidbV`ZZVganVcYdeZcXdciVXil^i]i]Z\dkZgcbZciVaVYb^c^h" igVidghVcYadXVahX]daVgh^cVcnXdjcign^cl]^X]i]Zn^ciZcYidldg`#GZhZVgX]bjhi \d]VcY"^c"]VcYl^i]YZkZadebZci^ci]ZhZh^ijVi^dch!Zchjg^c\bZVc^c\[ja!jc^ciZg" gjeiZYegd\gZhhVcYegdYjXi^kZhX^ZcXZ# 

8]VeiZg(:i]^Xh

#HAPTER

7dcZ7^dad\n  KVg^Vi^dc 7

dcZVhVXdccZXi^kZi^hhjZVcYWdcZhVhZaZbZcihbVnWZhijY^ZYdchZkZgVa ]^ZgVgX]^XVaaZkZah#>c[dgbVi^dcYZg^kZY[gdbbVcnh`ZaZidchbVnWZjhZY^cgZ" XdchigjXi^c\ `_`e\QdY_^ RY_\_Wi 8]VeiZg &.# HijYn d[ i]Z kVg^djh ZaZbZcih d[ V h^c\aZh`ZaZidcbVnWZjhZYidZajX^YViZi]ZW^dad\^XVaVheZXihd[Vc^cY^k^YjVa8]Ve" iZgh&,VcY&.#HjX]VhhZhhbZcihVgZWj^aidcV[djcYVi^dci]ViZbe]Vh^oZhi]Z^YZc" i^ÄXVi^dcd[i]ZWdcnU\U]U^dci]ViXdchi^ijiZZVX]]jbVch`ZaZidc8]VeiZgh,·&+# 7Z[dgZZbWVg`^c\dcVhnhiZbVi^XXdch^YZgVi^dcd[]jbVch`ZaZiVaZaZbZcih!^i^hjhZ" [jaidXdch^YZgWdcZW^dad\n#I]^hX]VeiZgh]djaYi]ZgZ[dgZWZXdch^YZgZYVcZhhZci^Va hiZee^c\hidcZidi]ZYZhXg^ei^kZVcY^ciZgegZi^kZX]VeiZghid[daadl# >i^h^bedgiVciidcdiZi]Zbjai^eaZ[jcXi^dchd[WdcZVhVi^hhjZVcYd[WdcZhVhdg" \Vch#7dcZhVXiVhZhhZci^VabZX]Vc^XVaXdbedcZcihd[i]Z]ecSe\_c[U\UdQ\cicdU]# I]ZnhZgkZidegdiZXiVcYhjeedgihd[ii^hhjZh0idVcX]dgbjhXaZh!iZcYdch!VcYa^\V" bZcih0VcYVhi]Zg^\^YaZkZghi]VibjhXaZhdeZgViZidegdYjXZbdkZbZci#7dcZhVahd [jcXi^dcVhe]nh^dad\^XVaanXg^i^XVaXZciZgh[dgi]ZegdYjXi^dcd[WaddYXZaah!VhhidgV\Z [VX^a^i^Zh[dg[Vi!VcYVhgZhZgkd^ghd[^bedgiVciZaZbZcihhjX]VhXVaX^jbZhhZci^Va[dg WaddYXadii^c\VcYbjhXaZXdcigVXi^dc#7dcZVhVi^hhjZ^hVYVeiZYidi]ZhZ[jcXi^dch# I]ZkVg^ZYbZX]Vc^XVaVcYe]nh^dad\^XVa[jcXi^dchd[WdcZhVhdg\VchVgZ^ci^bViZan gZaViZYidi]Z\gdhhVcYb^XgdhXde^X ^cXajY^c\bdaZXjaVghigjXijgZd[WdcZi^hhjZ! l]^X]lZgZk^Zl^ci]^hX]VeiZg# 7dcZ^hVYncVb^Xi^hhjZi]ViVaadlh[dg\gdli]Yjg^c\dcid\ZcnYZkZadebZcid[ i]Z^cY^k^YjVa#>i^hh]VeZYVcYgZh]VeZYWnXZaahi]VigZh^YZl^i]^c^i#7ZXVjhZd[i]^h! i]Z\gdhhh]VeZ!dg]_b`X_\_Wi!d[WdcZhXVcWZVaiZgZYYjg^c\a^[Z#I]Zh]VeZVcYh^oZ d[WdcZhVcYiZZi]XVcVahdkVgnYgVbVi^XVaanWZilZZc^cY^k^YjVah#7Z[dgZ^cigdYjX^c\ WdcZW^dad\nVii]ZaZkZad[i]ZbdaZXjaZ!i]ZXZaa!VcYi]Z\gdhhZaZbZci!^i^hXg^i^XVa i]VilZZmVb^cZVegdeZgind[VaaW^dad\^XVahigjXijgZh!i]ZegdeZgind[kVg^Vi^dc#Jc" YZghiVcY^c\VcYVeegZX^Vi^c\kVg^Vi^dc^cWdcnVcYYZciVa\gdhhVcVidbn^hXg^i^XVaan ^bedgiVci^cVcnldg`l^i]i]Z]jbVch`ZaZidc#

6ARIATION ;dgVgVcYdba^k^c\hVbeaZd[Ä[inbVaZVcYÄ[in[ZbVaZ^cY^k^YjVah[gdbkVg^djh ]jbVcedejaVi^dch!^ildjaYWZZVhnidZhiVWa^h]e]nh^XVaX]VgVXiZg^hi^Xhi]VildjaY (&

VaadlZVX]eZghdcidWZgZXd\c^oZY^cY^k^YjVaan#KVg^Vi^dcldjaYWZZbeadnZY^chdgi" ^c\i]ZedejaVi^dc!VcYdcan^ci]ZgVgZ^chiVcXZd[^YZci^XVail^chldjaYi]ZgZWZ bjX]Y^[ÄXjain^cY^hi^c\j^h]^c\Y^[[ZgZcieZdeaZ#I]^h^hWZXVjhZi]Z]jbVcheZX^Zh! a^`Zdi]ZgheZX^Zh!Zm]^W^ihkVg^Vi^dc#I]^hkVg^Vi^dcZmiZcYhidi]ZiZZi]VcYWdcZhd[ i]Zh`ZaZidc# >c^YZci^[n^c\djg[g^ZcYhVcYVXfjV^ciVcXZh!lZbV`ZjhZd[djgVW^a^inidgZXd\" c^oZkVg^Vi^dc#L^i]djikVg^Vi^dc^ce]nh^XVa[ZVijgZh^ildjaYWZ^bedhh^WaZ[dgjhid ^YZci^[ndcZVcdi]ZgVii]Z\gdjeVcY^cY^k^YjVaaZkZah#>c[VXi!djgjhZd[hd[ii^hhjZ kVg^Vi^dc hZZbh hd cVijgVa i]Vi lZ iV`Z ^i [dg \gVciZY# DYYan Zcdj\]! ]dlZkZg! i]Z Vbdjcid[kVg^Vi^dc^ci]Z]VgYi^hhjZhd[i]ZWdYn^hd[iZccdiVci^X^eViZYWnhijYZcih d[dhiZdad\n#H]VeZVcYh^oZ^c]jbVcWdcZhVcYiZZi]kVgnl^YZan!VcYVcVanh^hd[i]^h kVg^Vi^dcbV`Zh]jbVcdhiZdad\nh^bjaiVcZdjhanX]VaaZc\^c\[dgi]ZWZ\^ccZgVcY jhZ[ja[dgi]Zegd[Zhh^dcVa# I]ZgZVgZ[djgbV_dg[VXidghaZVY^c\idkVg^Vi^dc^c]jbVch`ZaZiVaVcVidbn#DcZ hdjgXZd[i]^hkVg^Vi^dc^h_^d_WU^i!dg\gdli]#6\gZViYZVad[h`ZaZiVakVg^Vi^dc^ch^oZ VcYh]VeZ^hdWhZgkZYVadc\i]ZXdci^cjjbd[\gdli]WZilZZc[ZijhVcYVYjai#I]^h kVg^Vi^dcXVcWZjhZYWni]ZdhiZdad\^hi^cYZiZgb^c^c\i]ZV\ZViYZVi][gdbh`ZaZiVa gZbV^ch# 6hZXdcYhdjgXZd[h`ZaZiVakVg^Vi^dc^c]jbVch^hi]ZhZmd[i]Z^cY^k^YjVa#=j" bVchVgZbdYZgViZancUheQ\\iTY]_b`XYS^cWdYnh^oZ!VcY^cVcn\^kZch`ZaZiVaede" jaVi^dci]^hY^bdge]^hb^hbVc^[ZhiZY^ci]ZgZaVi^kZanhbVaaZgh^oZd[[ZbVaZWdcZh VcYiZZi]#I]^hh^oZkVg^Vi^dc^hVXXdbeVc^ZYWnh]VeZkVg^Vi^dc!l]^X]VaadlhXZgiV^c h`ZaZiVaZaZbZcihidWZjhZY^cYZiZgb^c^c\i]ZhZmjVa^YZci^ind[egZ]^hidg^XgZbV^ch 8]VeiZg&.# 6i]^gYineZd[kVg^Vi^dc^hWU_WbQ`XYS!dg`_`e\QdY_^RQcUT#9^[[ZgZci]jbVc \gdjehkVgn^cbVcnh`ZaZiVaVcYYZciVaX]VgVXiZg^hi^Xh#I]^h\Zd\gVe]^XkVg^Vi^dcXVc WZZbeadnZYidVhhZhhi]Z\Zd\gVe]^XhdbZi^bZhXVaaZYgVX^VaV[Äc^ind[h`ZaZiVagZ" bV^ch8]VeiZg&.# ;^cVaan!ZkZc^cY^k^YjVahd[i]ZhVbZV\Z!hZm!VcYedejaVi^dcY^[[Zg^cVcVidbn0 VeVgi[gdbbdhi^YZci^XVail^ch!cdildeZdeaZVgZ^YZci^XVa^ci]Z^gZmiZgcVah^oZVcY h]VeZ#H`ZaZiVaZaZbZcihVgZcdiZmXZei^dchidi]^hgjaZ#CdgbVakVg^Vi^dcWZilZZcY^[" [ZgZci^cY^k^YjVahd[i]ZhVbZV\Z!hZm!VcYedejaVi^dc^hXVaaZYY^TYfYTeQ\!dgYTY_ ci^SbQdYS!fQbYQdY_^#I]^hkVg^Vi^dcXVcWZhjWhiVci^Va!Wji^i^hiddd[iZcdkZgadd`ZY# ;^\jgZ)#&^aajhigViZhi]Z^cÅjZcXZhd[dcid\Zcn!hZm!VcY^Y^dhncXgVhndckVg^Vi^dc^c i]ZiVajh!dcZd[i]ZWdcZhd[i]ZVc`aZ# 6egd[jh^dcd[XaVhh^ÄXVi^dchd[[dhh^ah]VhWZZcXgZViZYWni]Z[V^ajgZidVeegZX^ViZ cdgbVah`ZaZiVakVg^Vi^dc^cbdYZgcheZX^ZhVcYi]Z[V^ajgZidjcYZghiVcYi]Zeg^cX^" eaZhVcY\dVahd[iVmdcdbn#>ci]ZgZhjai^c\[dgZhid[[Vb^anigZZh!^aa"XdcXZ^kZYheZX^Zh VcY\ZcZgVVgZ]jc\a^`ZdgcVbZcih#CdgbVakVg^Vi^dcl^i]^cXadhZangZaViZYUhdQ^d bdYZgcheZX^Zhbjhi\j^YZdjgZmeZXiVi^dchd[kVg^Vi^dc^cheZX^Zhl]dhZbZbWZgh a^kZY^ci]ZeVhi#;dgi]^hgZVhdc!dhiZdad\^hihjc[Vb^a^Vgl^i]cdgbVakVg^Vi^dc^ci]Z egZhZciVgZ^cXa^cZYidb^h^ciZgegZih^b^aVgkVg^Vi^dc^ci]ZeVhiVh^cY^XVi^c\bja" i^eaZ heZX^Zh# Id ]Zae Vkd^Y hjX] b^h^ciZgegZiVi^dc! i]Z eVaZdcidad\^hi bjhi WZXdbZ [Vb^a^Vgl^i]kVg^Vi^dc^cbdYZgc]jbVchVcYi]Z^gXadhZhigZaVi^kZh!i]Z\gZViVeZh! WnhijYn^c\aVg\Zh`ZaZiVaXdaaZXi^dch#>cVhhZhh^c\Vcnh`ZaZiVaZaZbZci!cdiZdcid\Z" cZi^XX]Vc\Zh^ch]VeZVcYh^oZWnhijYn^c\Y^[[ZgZci^cY^k^YjVahl]dY^ZYViY^[[ZgZci V\Zh#IdVhhZhhcdgbVakVg^Vi^dc^ci]ZVYjaih`ZaZidcVg^h^c\[gdbi]Zdi]ZghdjgXZh 

8]VeiZg)7dcZ7^dad\nKVg^Vi^dc

^YZci^ÄZYegZk^djhan!ignidZmVb^cZVaVg\Z!b^mZY"hZmhVbeaZd[^cY^k^YjVah#;^\jgZh )#&!)#'!)#(!VcY)#)^aajhigViZkVg^Vi^dc^ch^oZVcYh]VeZ^cVh^c\aZ"h^iZ!WVaVcXZY"hZm hVbeaZ[gdbVegZ]^hidg^X8Va^[dgc^Vch`ZaZiVaedejaVi^dc# I]ZgZVa^ind[Y^bZch^dcVaVcYbdge]dad\^XVakVg^Vi^dc^ci]Z]VgYi^hhjZhd[^c" Y^k^YjVahbV`Zhdi`_\_Wi!i]ZegVXi^XZd[X]ddh^c\dcZ^cY^k^YjVaidX]VgVXiZg^oZV heZX^Zh!VeVgi^XjaVganjchj^iVWaZVeegdVX]idi]ZhijYnVcYjcYZghiVcY^c\d[]jbVc dhiZdad\nVcYZkdaji^dc#NZi!id^aajhigViZWVh^Xed^cihd[VcVidbnVcY^YZci^ÄXVi^dc^i ^hcZXZhhVgnidWZ\^chdbZl]ZgZ#>cjh^c\i]^hWdd`¼hX]VeiZghdc^YZci^ÄXVi^dc8]Ve" iZgh ,·&+! i]Z gZVYZg h]djaY i]^c` d[ i]Z h`ZaZiVa ZaZbZcih X]dhZc [dg ^aajhigVi^dc VhgZegZhZciVi^kZ!WjicZkZgVhine^XVa#I]ZgZ^hcd¹ine^XVaº^cY^k^YjVa#LZ^aajhigViZ kVg^Vi^dc^ch`ZaZiVah^oZVcYh]VeZ^ci]^hWdd`idgZ^c[dgXZi]Z[VXii]VihjX]kVg^V" i^dc^cW^dad\^XVahigjXijgZh^hcdgbVaVcYidWZZmeZXiZY#

!&EW&ACTSABOUT"ONE 7dcZ¸dcZd[i]Zhigdc\ZhiW^dad\^XVabViZg^Vah^cZm^hiZcXZ!eVgi^XjaVgan^ciZgbhd[ WZVg^c\ lZ^\]i¸^h i]Z bV^c hjeedgi^c\ i^hhjZ d[ i]Z WdYn# 9jg^c\ gjcc^c\! V ]j" bVcadVYhi]ZWdcZhVii]Z`cZZ_d^cil^i]V[dgXZ^cZmXZhhd[ÄkZi^bZhi]ZlZ^\]i d[i]ZZci^gZWdYn#NZi!YZhe^iZ^ih\gZVihigZc\i]!WdcZ^hVkZgna^\]ilZ^\]ibViZg^Va# I]Zh`ZaZidc^ihZa[Xdchi^ijiZhaZhhi]Vc'%d[i]ZlZ^\]id[i]ZZci^gZWdYn!l]ZgZVh V[gVbZldg`d[hiZZaWVgheZg[dgb^c\i]ZhVbZbZX]Vc^XVa[jcXi^dchVhi]Z]jbVc h`ZaZidcldjaYlZ^\][djgidÄkZi^bZhbdgZ#Jca^`ZhiZZa!WdcZ^hVS_]`_cYdUbViZ" g^Va![dgbZYd[egdiZ^cXdaaV\ZcVcYb^cZgVa]nYgdmnVeVi^iZ#7dcZY^[[Zgh[gdbhiZZa ^cnZiVcdi]ZghZchZ/^i^hVa^k^c\i^hhjZi]ViXVcgZeV^gVcYgZh]VeZ^ihZa[^cgZhedchZ idZmiZgcVahigZhhZh#BdgZYZiV^aZYgZk^Zlhd[i]Ze]nh^XVa!\ZdbZig^X!VcYbZX]Vc^XVa egdeZgi^Zhd[WdcZVhVi^hhjZ!VcYWdcZhVhdg\Vch!VgZegdk^YZYWn7jgg&.-%VcY 8jggZn&.-)!'%%'#

"ONESAS%LEMENTSOFTHE-USCULOSKELETAL3YSTEM >ci]ZbdhiWVh^XiZgbh!i]ZbjhXjadh`ZaZiVahnhiZb^hVhnhiZbd[WdcnaZkZghdeZg" ViZYWn]ecS\Uc#6cnXdccZXi^dcWZilZZcY^[[ZgZcih`ZaZiVaZaZbZcih^hXVaaZYV_d^ci# 7dcZh^ci]Zh`ZaZidcQbdYSe\QdUVi_d^cihVcYVgZXdccZXiZYiddcZVcdi]ZgWnbZVch d[\YWQ]U^dcVcYSQbdY\QWU#8Vgi^aV\Z^hVidj\]VcYYZchZWjiZaVhi^XVcYXdbegZhh" ^WaZXdccZXi^kZi^hhjZ#7dcZhVgZbdkZYWnbjhXaZhVXi^c\Y^gZXiandci]ZWdcZhdgk^V dU^T_^c!XadhZaneVX`ZYeVgVaaZaWjcYaZhd[XdaaV\ZcÄWZgh#BdkZbZciVii]Z_d^cih^h XdcigdaaZYVcYa^b^iZYWni]Zh]VeZhd[i]ZVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZhVcYWna^\VbZcihi]Vi W^cYi]Z_d^cihid\Zi]ZgVcYegZkZciY^hadXVi^dc;^\jgZ)#*# I]Z]^e!ZaWdl!`cZZ!VcYi]jbW_d^cihVgZVaaZmVbeaZhd[[gZZanbdk^c\_d^cih XVaaZYci^_fYQ\Z_Y^dc#I]Zhjg[VXZhd[i]ZWdcZheVgi^X^eVi^c\^chncdk^Va_d^cihVgZ XdViZYl^i]Vi]^cjhjVaan&·*bbaVnZgd[ha^X`!Vgi^XjaVgXVgi^aV\ZXVaaZYXiQ\Y^U SQbdY\QWU#I]ZVgZVWZilZZci]ZVY_VXZciWdcZh^hi]ZZ_Y^dSQfYdi!VheVXZa^cZYWnV bZbWgVcZi]VihZXgZiZhVajWg^XVciXVaaZYci^_fYQ\ÎeYT!l]^X]gZhZbWaZhZ\\l]^iZ ^cXdch^hiZcXn#I]^hÅj^Ycdjg^h]ZhXVgi^aV\ZXZaahd[i]Z_d^ciVcY^hXdcÄcZYidi]Z _d^ciWni]ZÄWgdjhZ_Y^dSQ`ce\U!VhVXbVYZd[XdccZXi^kZi^hhjZVcYgZ^c[dgXZYWn )#'6;Zl;VXihVWdji7dcZ

((

a^\VbZcihXdccZXi^c\idi]ZeZg^dhiZjbd[i]ZVgi^XjaVi^c\WdcZhhZZHZXi^dc)#)#I]Z XdbW^cVi^dcd[]nVa^cZXVgi^aV\ZXdVi^c\i]ZWdcZhjg[VXZhVcYhncdk^VaÅj^YajWg^XVi" ^c\ i]ZhZ hjg[VXZh \^kZh hncdk^Va _d^cih YjgVW^a^in l^i] hbddi] bdkZbZci VcY adl [g^Xi^dc# Hncdk^Va _d^cih VgZ d[iZc XaVhh^ÄZY VXXdgY^c\ id i]Z \ZdbZig^X egdeZgi^Zh d[ i]Z Vgi^XjaVi^dc#I]Z]^e_d^ci^hVc`XUb_YTQ\!dgRQ\\Q^Tc_S[Ud_d^ci!l^i]i]Z]Zb^" he]Zg^XVa [Zbjg ]ZVY Äii^c\ ^cid i]Z VXZiVWjajb! V XVk^in ^c i]Z eZak^h# I]^h _d^ci higjXijgZVaadlhbdkZbZci^cbVcnY^gZXi^dch#I]ZZaWdlVcY`cZZ_d^cihVgZXVaaZY XY^WU_d^cihWZXVjhZi]ZnVaadlV]^c\Z"a^`ZbdkZbZcia^b^iZYbdhianiddcZeaVcZ# I]Z_d^ciVii]ZWVhZd[i]Zi]jbW^hXVaaZYVcQTT\UcXQ`UT!dgcU\\Qb!_d^ciWZXVjhZ

&IGUREWZadlVcYdeedh^iZCdgbVakVg^Vi^dc^cVWdcZd[i]ZVc`aZ!i]ZiVajhk^ZlZY[gdb i]Z^c[Zg^dg!dgadlZg!VheZXi0i]ZVciZg^dg!dg[gdci!hjg[VXZd[ZVX]WdcZ^hidlVgYi]Zided[i]Z eV\Z#6aad[i]ZiVa^h]dlc]ZgZlZgZhZaZXiZY[gdbVh^c\aZ"h^iZh`ZaZiVahVbeaZd[egZ]^hidg^X 8Va^[dgc^Vchid^aajhigViZh`ZaZiVakVg^Vi^dcViig^WjiVWaZidV\Z!hZm!VcY^Y^dhncXgVhn#6aaheZX^" bZchVgZ[gdbi]ZaZ[ih^YZZmXZei[dgi]ZheZX^bZc^ci]ZjeeZgg^\]iXdgcZg#DcZ"]Va[cVijgVa h^oZ# Ide9TY_ci^SbQdYSfQbYQdY_^H^m VYjaibVaZiVa^X]dhZc[gdbVhZm"WVa" VcXZYhVbeaZd[Ä[inVYjai^cY^k^YjVah# KVg^Vi^dc^ci]^hhZg^Zh^hhZZc^ci]Z h^oZVcYh]VeZd[i]ZdkZgVaaWdcZ djia^cZVhlZaaVh^ci]Zegdedgi^dch d[i]ZeVgihd[i]ZWdcZVcY^ci]Z ided\gVe]nd[i]ZkVg^djhhjg[VXZh# HjX]kVg^Vi^dc^hXdbbdc^c]jbVc h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch# B^YYaZCUhfQbYQdY_^I]gZZVYjai [ZbVaZaZ[iVcYi]gZZVYjaibVaZ g^\]iheZX^bZchX]dhZcVigVc" Ydb[gdbVhZm"WVaVcXZYhVbeaZd[ Ä[inVYjaih`ZaZidch#=dbdhVe^Zch ^hVeg^bViZheZX^Zhl]dhZhZmjVa Y^bdge]^hb^cWdYnh^oZ^hbdYZgViZ Wneg^bViZhiVcYVgYh!aZhhi]Vci]Z \dg^aaV!WjibdgZi]Vci]ZXdbbdc X]^beVcoZZ#8]VeiZg&.Xdch^YZgh hZmjVaY^bdge]^hb^ci]Z]jbVc h`ZaZidc# 7diidb?^d_WU^UdYSfQbYQdY_^I]Z heZX^bZcVii]Z[VgaZ[i^hViVajh[gdb VcZlWdgcX]^aY#IVa^[gdb^cY^k^YjVah ViV\Zh&#*!+!&%!&'!VcY&-nZVghh]dl dcid\ZcZi^XX]Vc\Zh^ch^oZVcYh]VeZ d[i]^hh`ZaZiVaZaZbZci#



8]VeiZg)7dcZ7^dad\nKVg^Vi^dc

d[^ihh]VeZ#>iVaadlhbdkZbZci^cildWVh^XY^gZXi^dch#@\Q^Qb_d^cihVaadlildWdcZh idha^YZVXgdhhdcZVcdi]Zg!ZmVbeaZhd[l]^X]XVcWZ[djcY^ci]Zlg^hiVcYi]ZVgX] d[i]Z[ddi# 7ZXVjhZd[i]Z^gbdW^a^in!hncdk^Va_d^cihVgZi]ZbdhidWk^djh_d^cih^ci]ZbjhXj" adh`ZaZiVahnhiZb!Wjii]ZgZVgZilddi]Zg^bedgiVci_d^ciineZh^ci]ZWdYn/XVgi^aV\^" cdjh_d^cihVcYÄWgdjh_d^cih#>cSQbdY\QWY^_ecZ_Y^dcci^SX_^Tb_cUci]ZVgi^XjaVi" ^c\WdcZhVgZjc^iZYWnbZVchd[XVgi^aV\Z!VcYkZgna^iiaZbdkZbZci^hVaadlZY#I]Z iZbedgVgn _d^cih WZilZZc \gdli] XZciZgh YZhXg^WZY aViZg ^c V h^c\aZ \gdl^c\ WdcZ VgZXVgi^aV\^cdjh#HdbZd[i]ZhZ_d^ciheZgh^hi^cVYjai]ddY!hjX]Vhi]ZXVgi^aV\^cdjh XdccZXi^dchWZilZZci]Zg^WhVcYi]ZWgZVhiWdcZhiZgcjb#6ci]`XicYc^hVkVg^Zin d[XVgi^aV\^cdjh_d^cih^cl]^X]i]ZÄWgdXVgi^aV\ZWZilZZci]ZWdcZhjg[VXZh^hXdkZgZY WnVi]^caVnZgd[]nVa^cZXVgi^aV\Z#Ci^TUc]_cUcVgZi^\]i!^cÅZm^WaZÄWgdjh_d^cihWZ" ilZZcWdcZhi]ViVgZjc^iZYWnWVcYhd[YZchZÄWgdjhi^hhjZ^ci]Z[dgbd[bZbWgVcZh dga^\VbZcih0VcZmVbeaZ^hi]Z_d^ciVil]^X]i]ZildadlZgaZ\WdcZhi^W^VVcYÄWjaV Vgi^XjaViZVWdkZi]ZVc`aZi]ZY^hiVai^W^dÄWjaVgVgi^XjaVi^dc#3bQ^YQ\cedebUcVgZ ÄWgdjh_d^cihd[i]Zh`jaa0i]ZhZVgZ^ciZgadX`^c\!jhjVaanidgijdjh_d^cih^cl]^X]i]Z

)#(7dcZhVh:aZbZcihd[i]ZBjhXjadh`ZaZiVaHnhiZb

(*

&IGURE6Yjai]jbVcXaVk^XaZhXdaaVgWdcZhhZaZXiZYid^aajhigViZi]ZidiVagVc\Zd[kVg^V" i^dc^ch^oZ!djia^cZ!VcYided\gVe]n^cVh^c\aZ"h^iZ!hZm"WVaVcXZYhVbeaZd[Z^\]incdgbVa egZ]^hidg^X8Va^[dgc^Vch#CdiZi]ZkVg^Vi^dc^cdkZgVaah^oZ!^ci]Zh]VeZd[i]ZWdcZ!VcY^c i]Zided\gVe]nd[i]Zhjg[VXZ#I]^h`^cYVcYVbdjcid[kVg^Vi^dch]djaYWZZmeZXiZY^cVcn cdgbVahVbeaZd[h^b^aVgV\ZVcYhZmXdbedh^i^dc#I]ZhZg^\]i"h^YZheZX^bZchVgZh]dlc^c ^c[Zg^dgk^Zl!l^i]i]ZaViZgVaVgbZcYidlVgYi]Zg^\]ih^YZd[i]ZeV\Z#DcZ"]Va[cVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg)7dcZ7^dad\nKVg^Vi^dc

WdcZhVgZXadhZid\Zi]ZgVcYi]ZÄWgdjhi^hhjZWZilZZci]Zb^hi]^c#6W_]`X_cYc^h i]Z_d^ciWZilZZci]Zgddihd[i]ZiZZi]VcYi]ZWdcZd[i]Z_Vlh#L]ZcVcnildWdcn ZaZbZcih[jhZid\Zi]Zg!i]ZgZhjai^hXVaaZYVci^_cd_cYc# BdkZbZcid[i]Zh`ZaZidciV`ZheaVXZ![dgi]ZbdhieVgi!Vihncdk^Va_d^cih#I]^h bdkZbZci^hXVjhZYWni]ZbjhXaZh!l]^X]ldg`WnXdcigVXi^c\VXgdhh_d^cihWZilZZc WdcZh#BjhXaZhjhjVaanViiVX]idildY^[[ZgZciWdcZh!Wjii]ZnbVnViiVX]idhZkZgVa# Bdhi bjhXaZh VgZ XdccZXiZY id WdcZh k^V dU^T_^c#
&IGURE6Yjai]jbVc[ZbdgVjeeZgaZ\WdcZhhZaZXiZYid^aajhigViZi]Zh^oZVcYh]VeZ kVg^Vi^dcZcXdjciZgZY^cVh^c\aZ"h^iZ!hZm"WVaVcXZYhVbeaZd[&%%cdgbVaegZ]^hidg^X8Va^[dg" c^Vch#I]ZgZ^hXdch^YZgVWaZkVg^Vi^dcWZilZZcheZX^bZchh]dlc]ZgZ^ch^oZ!gdWjhi^X^in!bVg`" ^c\hd[bjhXaZViiVX]bZcih!VcYegdedgi^dchVcYVc\aZhd[i]ZY^[[ZgZcieVgihd[ZVX][Zbjg# I]ZhZaZ[i"h^YZheZX^bZchVgZh]dlc^cedhiZg^dgk^Zl!l^i]i]ZhjeZg^dgideZcYd[i]ZWdcZ idlVgYi]Zided[i]ZeV\Z#DcZ"i]^gYcVijgVah^oZ#

)#(7dcZhVh:aZbZcihd[i]ZBjhXjadh`ZaZiVaHnhiZb

(,

bZcihgZh^hiiZch^dc!i]ZgZWnhigZc\i]Zc^c\i]Z_d^ciVcYeZgb^ii^c\dcanbdkZbZcih XdbeVi^WaZl^i]i]Z[jcXi^dcd[i]Z_d^ci# BjhXaZViiVX]bZcih^iZhVgZXdckZci^dcVaan^YZci^ÄZY^cgZaVi^kZiZgbh#I]Zh^iZ i]VihiVnhgZaVi^kZanhiVWaZYjg^c\XdcigVXi^dcd[i]ZbjhXaZ^hXVaaZYi]Z_bYWY^#;dg i]ZVeeZcYV\Zh!i]^h^hjhjVaani]ZViiVX]bZcih^iZXadhZhiidi]Zigjc`#I]Zh^iZi]Vi ^h bdkZY Wn i]Z XdcigVXi^dc d[ V bjhXaZ ^h iZgbZY i]Z Y^cUbdY_^# ;dg ZmVbeaZ! i]Z bjhXaZh i]Vi ÅZm i]Z Äc\Zgh dg^\^cViZ ^c i]Z VciZg^dg XdbeVgibZci d[ i]Z [dgZVgb VcY^chZgidci]ZÄc\Zgeg^cih^YZd[i]ZÄc\ZgWdcZhe]VaVc\Zh#6Xi^dchXVjhZYWn

&IGURE9ZciVakVg^Vi^dcYjZidV\ZgZÅZXiZY^clZVg!hZm!VcY^Y^dhncXgVhn#I]Ziddi] gdlhh]dlc]ZgZlZgZhZaZXiZY[gdbVh^c\aZ"h^iZ!hZm"WVaVcXZYh`ZaZiVahVbeaZd[h^minegZ]^h" idg^XAViZ=dg^odc8Va^[dgc^Vch#CdiZi]ZY^[[ZgZcXZh^clZVg!h^oZ!VcYh]VeZd[i]ZiZZi]Vh lZaaVhi]ZkVg^Vi^dc^ciddi]gdlXjgkVijgZVcYaZc\i]#



8]VeiZg)7dcZ7^dad\nKVg^Vi^dc

X

"ONE #OLLATERAL ,IGAMENTS *OINT#AVITY !RTICULAR #ARTILAGE

&IGURE9dghVak^Zld[V]jbVcg^\]ilg^hiVcY]VcY#I]^hXdbedh^iZ^aajhigVi^dcXdb" W^cZhi]ZiZX]c^fjZhd[Xgdhh"hZXi^dc^c\a^iiaZÄc\Zg!Y^hhZXi^dcg^c\VcYb^YYaZÄc\Zgh!VcY gVY^d\gVe]ni]jbW#I]ZWdcZhVgZZbWZYYZY^cVbVig^md[hd[ii^hhjZh^cXajY^c\h`^c!cZgkZh! VgiZg^Zh!kZ^ch!bjhXaZh!a^\VbZcih!iZcYdch!VcY_d^ciXVgi^aV\Z#>ci]ZVhhZhhbZcid[ZmiZgcVa WdcZbdge]dad\n!cZ^i]Zgi]Zhd[ii^hhjZbVig^mcdgi]Z^ciZgcVahigjXijgZh]djaYWZ[dg\diiZc#

)#(7dcZhVh:aZbZcihd[i]ZBjhXjadh`ZaZiVaHnhiZb

(.

bjhXaZh VgZ jhjVaan gZX^egdXVa# 6i i]Z ZaWdl _d^ci! Y^[[ZgZci bjhXaZh XVjhZ deedh^iZ bdi^dch hjX] Vh UhdU^cY_^ higV^\]iZc^c\ i]Z Vgb VcY ÎUhY_^ WZcY^c\ i]Z Vgb# HjX]bjhXaZhVgZXVaaZYQ^dQW_^Ycdc#BjhXaZhVgZd[iZc^YZci^ÄZYWni]Zeg^bVgnVX" i^dci]Vii]Z^gXdcigVXi^dcXVjhZh#8]VeiZgh,·&+^cigdYjXZhdbZd[i]ZbV_dgbjhXaZh i]VibdkZi]Z]jbVch`ZaZidcVcYaZVkZigVXZhd[i]Z^gdg^\^chVcY^chZgi^dchdci]Z WdcZh#;dgcdl!lZXVcZVh^an^aajhigViZhZkZgVaWVh^Xhd[i]ZbjhXjadh`ZaZiVahnhiZb l^i]i]Z]jbVc]VcYVcYVgb#BjhXaZh^ci]Z[dgZVgbVgZZVh^aneVaeViZYVhi]Z]VcY ^h XaZcX]ZY VcY deZcZY# I]ZhZ bjhXaZh VXi k^V iZcYdch! l]^X] WZXdbZ kZgn k^h^WaZ VXgdhhi]Z[gdciVcYWVX`d[i]Zlg^hil]Zc^i^hÅZmZYVcYZmiZcYZY#;dgZmVbeaZ!i]Z ZmiZchdgY^\^idgjbbjhXaZ!VgZh^YZcid[i]Z[dgZVgb![jcXi^dch^cZmiZcY^c\i]Z[djg Äc\ZghVh^ideZgViZhk^V[djgiZcYdchi]ViXgdhhi]Zlg^hi#

'ROSS!NATOMYOF"ONES I]Zl^YZgVc\Zd[ZaZbZcih]VeZh^ci]Z]jbVch`ZaZidcbVnhZZbidYZ[nXaVhh^ÄXV" i^dc#I]ZWdcZh^ci]ZWdYnbVn!]dlZkZg!WZeVgi^i^dcZY^cidV[ZlWVh^XWjidkZgaVe" e^c\h]VeZh#I]Za^bWWdcZhVcYbVcnd[i]Z]VcYVcY[ddiWdcZh!jhjVaanXVaaZYadc\ WdcZh!VgZijWjaVg^ch]VeZ!l^i]ZmeVcYZYZcYh;^\jgZ)#+#I]ZWdcZhd[i]ZXgVc^Va kVjai!h]djaYZg!eZak^h!VcYg^WXV\ZiZcYidWZÅViVcYiVWjaVg#I]ZWdcZhd[i]ZVc`aZ! lg^hi! VcY he^cZ VgZ WadX`n VcY ^ggZ\jaVg# 9Zhe^iZ i]^h kVg^Zin d[ ZmiZgcVa [dgb! i]Z bV`Zjed[WdcZhViWdi]i]Z\gdhhVcYb^XgdhXde^XaZkZah^hgZbVg`VWanXdchiVci# 6ii]Z\gdhhaZkZa!Vaad[i]ZWdcZh^ci]ZVYjaih`ZaZidc]VkZildWVh^XhigjXijgVa XdbedcZcih/S_]`QSdVcYc`_^WiWdcZ#I]Zhda^Y!YZchZWdcZi]Vi^h[djcY^ci]Z lVaahd[WdcZh]V[ihVcYdcZmiZgcVaWdcZhjg[VXZh^hXVaaZYXdbeVXi!dgS_bdYSQ\!WdcZ# 6i_d^cih!XdbeVXiWdcZXdkZgZYWnXVgi^aV\ZYjg^c\a^[Z^hXVaaZYceRSX_^TbQ\R_^U# I]^h^hgZXd\c^oZYVhhbddi]ZgVcYh]^c^Zgi]VccdcVgi^XjaVgXdbeVXiWdcZVcYaVX`h i]Z]VkZgh^VchnhiZbhYZhXg^WZYaViZg# I]ZhZXdcY`^cYd[WdcZ]VhVbdgZhedc\n!edgdjh!a^\]ilZ^\]i!]dcZnXdbWhigjX" ijgZ#I]^hWdcZ^h[djcYjcYZgegdijWZgVcXZhl]ZgZiZcYdchViiVX]!^ci]ZkZgiZWgVa WdY^Zh!^ci]ZZcYhd[adc\WdcZh!^ch]dgiWdcZh!VcYhVcYl^X]ZYl^i]^cÅViWdcZh# I]^hSQ^SU\\_ec!dgdbQRUSe\Qb!WdcZ^hcVbZYV[iZgi]Zi]^cWdcnhe^XjaZhdbQRUSe \QUi]Vi[dgb^i#I]ZbdaZXjaVgVcYXZaajaVgXdbedh^i^dchd[XdbeVXiVcYigVWZXjaVg WdcZi^hhjZVgZ^YZci^XVa0^i^hdcani]ZY^[[ZgZcXZ^cedgdh^ini]VihZeVgViZhi]ZhZ\gdhh VcVidb^XVaWdcZineZh# 6gZVhd[igVWZXjaVgWdcZ^ci]Z\gdl^c\h`ZaZidcXdchi^ijiZh^iZhd[i]ZbUT]Qb b_g! V WaddY"[dgb^c\! dg XU]Qd_`_YUdYS! i^hhjZ i]Vi egdYjXZh gZY VcY l]^iZ WaddY XZaahVcYeaViZaZih#I]ZiU\\_g]Qbb_g!bV^canVgZhZgkZd[[ViXZaah[djcY^ci]Z]UT e\\QbiSQfYdi]daadl^ch^YZi]Zh]V[id[ijWjaVgWdcZh!^hhjggdjcYZYWnXdbeVXi WdcZ#9jg^c\\gdli]!i]ZgZYbVggdl^hegd\gZhh^kZangZeaVXZYWnnZaadlbVggdl^c bdhi d[ i]Z adc\ WdcZh# 6h cdiZY egZk^djhan! ^c VYY^i^dc id i]Z^g gdaZ ^c WaddY XZaa egdYjXi^dcVcY[VihidgV\Z!WdcZh[jcXi^dcVhdg\Vch^cnZiVcdi]ZglVn/WdcZi^hhjZ gZegZhZcihVXVaX^jbgZhZgkd^g[dgi]ZWdYn# EVgihd[ijWjaVg!dgadc\!WdcZhVgZd[iZcYZhXg^WZYVXXdgY^c\idi]ZXZciZghd[dhh^" ÄXVi^dchZZHZXi^dc)#,i]ViVeeZVgYjg^c\i]Z\gdli]egdXZhh#I]ZZcYhd[adc\WdcZh VgZXVaaZYi]ZU`Y`XicUcWZXVjhZi]ZnYZkZade[gdbhZXdcYVgndhh^ÄXVi^dcXZciZghd[ i]ZWdcZi]ZVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZhd[i]ZZe^e]nhZhVgZeVgihd[_d^cih#I]Zh]V[id[Vadc\ 

8]VeiZg)7dcZ7^dad\nKVg^Vi^dc

,INEOF0ROXIMAL %PIPHYSEAL&USION 3PONGYTRABECULAR "ONE

#ORTICAL"ONE SUBCHONDRAL 0ROXIMAL %PIPHYSIS -ETAPHYSIS PROXIMAL

#ORTICAL"ONE .UTRIENT&ORAMEN

-EDULLARY #AVITY

$IAPHYSIS

-ETAPHYSISDISTAL ,INEOF$ISTAL %PIPHYSEAL&USION

$ISTAL%PIPHYSIS

&IGURE6aZ[ii^W^Vh]^cWdcZhZXi^dcZYXjiidh]dl`ZnZaZbZcihd[i]Z\gdhhVcVidbn d[V]jbVcadc\WdcZ#CdiZi]ZY^hedh^i^dcd[i]ZXdbeVXiVcYhedc\nWdcZ#DcZ"]Va[cVijgVa h^oZ#

)#)
)&

WdcZ^hXVaaZY^ihTYQ`XicYcWZXVjhZ^i^hi]ZgZhjaid[i]Zeg^bVgndhh^ÄXVi^dcXZciZg d[i]ZWdcZ#I]ZZmeVcYZY!ÅVgZYZcYhd[i]Zh]V[iVgZXVaaZY]UdQ`XicUc#6\ddYZm" VbeaZd[i]ZhZeVgih^hi]Z`cZZ!l]ZgZi]ZZe^e]nh^hVii]Z`cZZZcYd[i]Z[Zbjg[jhZh idi]ZbZiVe]nh^hd[i]Zh]V[il]Zc\gdli]^hXdbeaZiZ# 9jg^c\a^[Z!i]ZdjiZghjg[VXZd[WdcZh^hjhjVaanXdkZgZYl^i]Vi]^ci^hhjZXVaaZY i]Z`UbY_cdUe]#I]^hi^hhjZ^hb^hh^c\^cYgnWdcZh!Wji^ca^[Z^iXdVihVaaWdcZhjg" [VXZhcdiXdkZgZYWnXVgi^aV\Z#I]ZeZg^dhiZjb^hVidj\]!kVhXjaVg^oZYbZbWgVcZi]Vi cdjg^h]ZhWdcZ#HdbZd[i]Zi]^cÄWZghd[i]ZeZg^dhiZjbeZcZigViZi]Zhjg[VXZd[WdcZ! l]ZgZVhdi]Zgh^ciZgil^cZl^i]iZcYdchidVcX]dgbjhXaZhidi]ZWdcZ#I]Z^ccZghjg" [VXZ d[ WdcZh ^h a^cZY l^i] Vc ^aa"YZÄcZY VcY aVg\Zan XZaajaVg bZbWgVcZ XVaaZY i]Z U^T_cdUe]#7di]eZg^dhiZjbVcYZcYdhiZjbVgZ_cdU_WU^YSi^hhjZh¸i]ZnXdciV^c WdcZ"[dgb^c\XZaahi]ViVgZcjbZgdjhVcYVXi^kZYjg^c\ndji]#I]ZhZXZaahVgZgZYjXZY ^c cjbWZg! Wji gZbV^c ediZci^Vaan VXi^kZ ^c VYjai]ddY# I]Zn bVn WZ hi^bjaViZY id YZedh^iWdcZl]Zci]ZeZg^dhiZjb^higVjbVi^oZY#

-OLECULAR3TRUCTUREOF"ONE LZcdlijgcidVcVhhZhhbZcid[WdcZhVibdgZWVh^XbdaZXjaVgVcYXZaajaVgaZkZah#Cd bViiZgl]Vih]VeZVWdcZiV`ZhVii]ZbdaZXjaVgaZkZa!^ihi^hhjZ^hWVh^XVaani]ZhVbZ ^cVaabVbbVah#7dcZi^hhjZ!a^`ZÄWZg\aVhh!^hVXdbedh^iZd[ild`^cYhd[bViZg^Vah# I]ZÄghiXdbedcZci^hVaVg\ZegdiZ^cbdaZXjaZ`cdlcVhS_\\QWU^!l]^X]Xdchi^ijiZh VWdji.%d[i]Zdg\Vc^XXdciZcid[WdcZ#8daaV\Zc^hi]ZbdhiXdbbdcegdiZ^c^ci]Z WdYn#8daaV\ZcbdaZXjaZh^ciZgil^cZid[dgbÅZm^WaZ!ha^\]ianZaVhi^XÄWZgh^cWdcZ# I]ZXdaaV\Zcd[bVijgZWdcZh^hhi^[[ZcZYWnVYZchZ^cdg\Vc^XÄaa^c\d[i]ZhZXdcY XdbedcZci!XiTb_hiQ`QdYdU#>cWdcZ!XgnhiVahd[i]^hb^cZgVa!V[dgbd[XVaX^jbe]dh" e]ViZ!^begZ\cViZi]ZXdaaV\ZcbVig^m#I]^hlZVkZd[egdiZ^cVcYb^cZgVah\^kZhWdcZ ^ihVbVo^c\egdeZgi^Zh#I]ZXdbW^cVi^dcd[bViZg^Vah^h^aajhigViZYWnildh^beaZZm" eZg^bZcih#I]Zb^cZgVaXdbedcZci\^kZhWdcZ^ih]VgYcZhhVcYg^\^Y^in#L]ZchdV`ZY ^c VX^Y id Y^hhdakZ i]ZhZ b^cZgVah! V WdcZ WZXdbZh V gjWWZg"a^`Z! ÅZm^WaZ higjXijgZ# =dlZkZg!l]ZcVWdcZ^h]ZViZYidXdbWjhii]Zdg\Vc^XXdaaV\Zc!dgaZVX]ZYdji^c hdbZVgX]Zdad\^XVaXdciZmih!^iWZXdbZhZmigZbZanWg^iiaZVcYXgjbWaZh# 8]VgVXiZg^oVi^dchd[WdcZVii]ZbdaZXjaVgaZkZa\^kZhdbZXajZhVWdji^ihe]nh^XVa egdeZgi^Zh!Wji^i^h^bedgiVciidXdch^YZgi]ViWdcZVhVi^hhjZbjhiWZbVYZVcYbV^c" iV^cZYWnXZaah!^ibjhiWZgZhedch^kZidhigZhh!VcY^ibjhiWZXVeVWaZd[\gdli]#6add` Vii]ZhigjXijgZd[WdcZVWdkZi]ZaZkZad[i]ZXdaaV\ZcÄWg^aVcYVhhdX^ViZYb^cZgVa egdk^YZh^ch^\]i^cidi]ZhZY^bZch^dchd[WdcZ[jcXi^dc#

(ISTOLOGYAND-ETABOLISMOF"ONE 8Ycd_\_Wi^hi]ZhijYnd[i^hhjZh!jhjVaanVii]Zb^XgdhXde^XaZkZa#I]ZgZVgZild]^hid" ad\^XVaineZhd[bVbbVa^VcWdcZ/Y]]QdebUVcY]QdebU#>bbVijgZWdcZS_QbcU\i Re^T\UTR_^UVcYg_fU^R_^U^hi]ZÄghi`^cYd[WdcZidYZkZade^cegZcViVaa^[Z#>ih Zm^hiZcXZ^hjhjVaaniZbedgVgn!Vh^i^hgZeaVXZYl^i]bVijgZWdcZVh\gdli]Xdci^cjZh# >bbVijgZWdcZ^hjhjVaan[dgbZYgVe^YanVcYX]VgVXiZg^oZhi]ZZbWgndc^Xh`ZaZidc! h^iZhd[[gVXijgZgZeV^g!VcYVkVg^Zind[WdcZijbdgh#>i]VhVgZaVi^kZan]^\]Zgegdedg" 

8]VeiZg)7dcZ7^dad\nKVg^Vi^dc

i^dcd[dhiZdXniZhhZZaViZgi]VcbVijgZWdcZ#LdkZcWdcZ^hi]ZbdgZe]nad\ZcZi^" XVaaneg^b^i^kZWdcZineZ^cZkdaji^dcVgniZgbh#>i^hXdVghZVcYÄWgdjh^cb^XgdhXde^X VeeZVgVcXZ!l^i]WjcYaZhd[XdaaV\ZcÄWZghVggVc\ZY^cVcdcdg^ZciZY!gVcYdbeViiZgc# 7di]XdbeVXiVcYigVWZXjaVgedgi^dchd[VYjaiWdcZhVgZbVYZd[bVijgZ!dg\Q]U\ \Qb!WdcZi^hhjZ!cVbZY[dgi]ZdgYZgan!dg\Vc^oZYhigjXijgZegdYjXZYWni]ZgZeZViZY VYY^i^dcd[jc^[dgbaVbZaaVZidWdcZhjg[VXZhYjg^c\Veedh^i^dcVa\gdli]#8dbeVXi WdcZ^hXdbedhZYd[YZchZWdcZi]ViXVccdiWZcdjg^h]ZYWnY^[[jh^dc[gdbhjg[VXZ WaddYkZhhZah#8QfUbcYQ^cicdU]c!l^i]i]Z^gXVcVahVcYXVcVa^Xja^YZhXg^WZY^ci]^h hZXi^dc!VgZi]Zhdaji^dcidi]^hegdWaZb#>cXdcigVhi!i]ZbdgZedgdjhigVWZXjaVgWdcZ gZXZ^kZhcjig^i^dc[gdbWaddYkZhhZah^chjggdjcY^c\bVggdlheVXZhVcYaVX`h]VkZg" h^VchnhiZbh#CdgbVaVYjaiWdcZ!Wdi]XdbeVXiVcYigVWZXjaVg!^h]^hidad\^XVaanaVbZa" aVgWdcZ#AVbZaaVgWdcZ^hjhjVaanaV^YYdlcbdgZhadlani]VcldkZcWdcZ!l]^X]^i jhjVaangZeaVXZh# B^XgdhXde^XZmVb^cVi^dcd[VigVchkZghZhZXi^dcd[XdbeVXiWdcZ^c![dgZmVbeaZ! i]Z i^W^Va h]V[i gZkZVah i]Z ^ciZgcVa higjXijgZ d[ ]VkZgh^Vc WdcZ ;^\jgZ )#-# HjX] V hZXi^dcgZhZbWaZhVcZcYk^Zld[Ve^aZd[hVlZY"d[[igZZigjc`h#I]ZXgdhhhZXi^dcd[ ZVX]¹igjc`ºd[iZch]dlhVeegdm^bViZan[djgidZ^\]iXdcXZcig^Xg^c\h!`cdlcVhXQ fUbcYQ^\Q]U\\QU#6XadhZZmVb^cVi^dcd[ZVX]aVbZaaVldjaYgZkZVaVWZYd[eVgVaaZa XdaaV\ZcÄWZgh#;^WZgh^chjXXZhh^kZaVbZaaVZ!]dlZkZg!VgZdg^ZciZY^cY^[[ZgZciY^gZX" i^dch#I]^hVaiZgcVi^dcd[ÄWZgY^gZXi^dcVYYhhigZc\i]idi]ZhigjXijgZ# :VX]¹igjc`º^ci]ZXgdhhhZXi^dcd[XdbeVXiaVbZaaVgWdcZ^h`cdlcVhVXQfUb cYQ^cicdU]!dgcUS_^TQbi_cdU_^#HZZ;^\jgZ)#,V·)#,X[dg^aajhigVi^dchVcYYZhXg^e" i^dchd[dhiZdch#I]ZhZ]VkZgh^VchnhiZbhbZVhjgZVWdji(%%¥b%#(bb^cY^VbZiZg VcYVgZVWdji(·*bb^caZc\i]#I]ZngZegZhZcii]ZWVh^XhigjXijgVajc^id[XdbeVXi WdcZ!VcYi]Z^gadc\VmZheVgVaaZai]Vid[i]Zadc\WdcZd[l]^X]i]ZnVgZeVgi#EVhh" ^c\i]gdj\]i]ZXdgZd[ZVX]]VkZgh^VchnhiZb^hV]daadlXQfUbcYQ^SQ^Q\!i]gdj\] l]^X]WaddY!anbe]!VcYcZgkZÄWZgheVhh#6YY^i^dcVahbVaaZgXVcVah!i]ZF_\[]Q^^Äc SQ^Q\c!e^ZgXZi]ZWdcZi^hhjZdWa^fjZanVcYVig^\]iVc\aZh[gdbi]ZeZg^dhiZVaVcY ZcYdhiZVahjg[VXZhida^c`i]Z]VkZgh^VcXVcVah!XgZVi^c\VcZildg`i]Vihjeea^ZhWaddY VcYanbe]idi]ZXZaahd[adc\WdcZh# HbVaaXVk^i^Zh[djcYl^i]^cZVX]aVbZaaVVgZXVaaZY\QSe^QU#:VX]aVXjcV]VgWdgh Vc_cdU_SidU!Va^k^c\WdcZXZaa#Cjig^ZcihVgZigVchedgiZYidi]ZhZXZaahi]gdj\]SQ^Q \YSe\Y!b^cjiZÅj^Y"ÄaaZYX]VccZahi]VigVY^ViZ[gdbi]ZXZcigVaaneaVXZY]VkZgh^Vc XVcVaidaVXjcVZ^chjXXZZY^c\aVbZaaVZdg[gdbdcZaVXjcViddi]Zgh#I]ZhZX]VccZah ^cWdcZi^hhjZZcVWaZi]Za^k^c\XZaahidhjgk^kZ^cV]ZVk^anb^cZgVa^oZYZck^gdcbZci# I]gZZ eg^bVgn XZaa ineZh VgZ ^ckdakZY ^c [dgb^c\ VcY bV^ciV^c^c\ WdcZ i^hhjZ# ?cdU_R\QcdcVgZWdcZ"[dgb^c\XZaahgZhedch^WaZ[dghnci]Zh^o^c\VcYYZedh^i^c\WdcZ bViZg^Va#DhiZdWaVhihVgZd[iZcXdcXZcigViZY_jhiWZcZVi]i]ZeZg^dhiZjb#I]ZnbV`Z aVg\ZfjVci^i^Zhd[VbViZg^Va`cdlcVh_cdU_YTegZWdcZi^hhjZ!VcjcXVaX^ÄZYdg\Vc^X bVig^mg^X]^cXdaaV\Zc#8VaX^ÄXVi^dcd[WdcZiV`ZheaVXZVhXgnhiVahd[]nYgdmnVeVi^iZ! i]Z ^cdg\Vc^X XdbedcZci d[ WdcZ! VgZ YZedh^iZY ^cid i]Z dhiZd^Y bVig^m# DcXZ hjg" gdjcYZYWnWdcnbVig^m!i]ZdhiZdWaVhihVgZXVaaZYdhiZdXniZh!XZaahi]VigZh^YZ^caV" XjcVZVcYVgZgZhedch^WaZ[dgbV^ciV^c^c\WdcZi^hhjZ#?cdU_S\QcdcVgZgZhedch^WaZ [dgi]ZbUc_b`dY_^gZbdkVad[WdcZi^hhjZ#6aah`ZaZiVaZaZbZcihX]Vc\ZYgVbVi^XVaan Yjg^c\ dcid\Zcn VcY Xdci^cjZ id WZ XVeVWaZ d[ X]Vc\Z ^c VYjai]ddY# 7dcZ [dgbV" i^dciV`ZheaVXZi]gdj\]djia^[Z#I]ZgZh]Ve^c\!dgbU]_TU\Y^W!d[WdcZiV`ZheaVXZVi i]ZXZaajaVgaZkZaVhdhiZdXaVhihgZbdkZWdcZi^hhjZVcYdhiZdWaVhihWj^aYWdcZi^hhjZ# )#*BdaZXjaVgHigjXijgZd[7dcZ

)(

&IGUREA7dcZ]^hidad\n#6XdbeVg^hdcd[eg^bVgnVcYhZXdcYVgndhiZdch[gdbEV^cZVcY
&IGUREB7dcZ]^hidad\n#6c^ciVXihZXdcYVgndhiZdcl^i]hZkZgVa[gV\bZciVgndhiZdch# HZXdcYVgndhiZdchVgZegdYjXihd[WdcZgZbdYZa^c\#EdaVg^oZYa^\]i^c\!'%%M#



8]VeiZg)7dcZ7^dad\nKVg^Vi^dc

&IGUREC7dcZ]^hidad\n#6XgdlYZYÄZaYd[hZXdcYVgndhiZdch#I]ZaVg\Z]VkZgh^VcXVcVah ^cY^XViZ^cXdbeaZiZ[dgbVi^dcd[hZkZgVadhiZdch#EdaVg^oZYa^\]i^c\!&%%M#HZZ8]VeiZg&.[dg VY^hXjhh^dcd[]dlVcVanhZhd[i]ZhZb^XgdhXde^X]^hidad\^XVahigjXijgZh^cWdcZ]VkZWZZc ZbeadnZY^c^cY^k^YjVaV\ZVhhZhhbZci#8djgiZhnd[GdWZgiEV^cZ#

3ECONDARY/STEON OR(AVERSIAN3YSTEM

]

X BLOOD VESSELS LACUNAE OSTEOCYTES WITHIN

X

HAVERSIANCANALS PERIOSTEUM CANALICULI

0ROXIMAL 4IBIA

LAMELLAE

&IGURE
)#+=^hidad\nVcYBZiVWda^hbd[7dcZ

)*

I]Z deedh^c\ egdXZhhZh d[ WdcZ [dgbVi^dc VcY gZhdgei^dc Vaadl WdcZh id bV^ciV^c dgX]Vc\Zi]Z^gh]VeZVcYh^oZYjg^c\\gdli]#HdbZdhiZdad\^hihY^hi^c\j^h]WZilZZc ¹bdYZa^c\ºVhWdcZhXjaei^c\Yjg^c\\gdli]VcY¹gZbdYZa^c\ºVhi]ZegdXZhhd[Xdc" i^cjdjhgZbdkVaVcYgZeaVXZbZcid[WdcZYjg^c\a^[Z#

"ONE'ROWTH I]Z]^hidad\^XVah^ijVi^dcYZhXg^WZY^cHZXi^dc)#+VXXdjcih[dgi]ZbZiVWda^hbd[WdcZ VcYi]ZeaVhi^X^ind[WdcZ^ci]ZVYjai#9jg^c\dcid\Zcn!]dlZkZg!i]Zh`ZaZidcjcYZg" \dZhigZbZcYdjh\gdli]#DhiZdXniZhYdcdiY^k^YZ!VcY!WZXVjhZWdcZbVig^mXVaX^ÄZh hddcV[iZgWZ^c\egdYjXZY!i]Zi^hhjZXVccdijcYZg\d[jgi]ZgZmeVch^dc[gdbl^i]^c# 6hVXdchZfjZcXZ!VaaWdcZ\gdli]^hi]ZgZhjaid[WdcZYZedh^i^dcdcVegZZm^hi^c\ hjg[VXZ#>cYZZY!WdcZValVnhYZkZadehWngZeaVXZbZcid[VegZZm^hi^c\XdccZXi^kZi^h" hjZ#:bWgndad\^XVaan!WdcZYZkZadebZci_cdU_WU^UcYc!dgdhh^ÄXVi^dcdXXjgh^cild \ZcZgVah^iZh#>cY^dbQ]U]RbQ^_ec_ccYÍSQdY_^!WdcZh!eVgi^XjaVgani]Z[gdciVaVcY eVg^ZiVaWdcZhd[i]ZXgVc^VakVjai!dhh^[nWnVeedh^i^dcdci^hhjZl^i]^cVcZbWgndc^X XdccZXi^kZi^hhjZbZbWgVcZ#BdhiWdcZh^ci]Zh`ZaZidc!]dlZkZg!\gdli]gdj\]Vegd" XZhh`cdlcVhU^T_SX_^TbQ\_ccYÍSQdY_^!^cl]^X]WdcZhVgZegZXZYZYWnXVgi^aV\Z egZXjghdghXVaaZYXVgi^aV\ZbdYZah#:Vgan^c^ihYZkZadebZci!^cjiZgd!i]Zh`ZaZidc^h ÅZm^WaZ!Wjidhh^ÄXVi^dc^h^c^i^ViZYWZ[dgZW^gi]#K^h^WaZZaZbZcihd[i]ZZVganh`ZaZidc VgZbdhianXdbedhZYd[XVgi^aV\Z!VbViZg^Vai]Vi^h\ddY[dggVe^Y\gdli]^cVbZY^jb l]ZgZi]Z[jcXi^dchd[hjeedgiVgZcdinZicZXZhhVgn#8Vgi^aV\Z^hXdbedhZYbdhiand[ XdaaV\ZcVcY!jca^`ZWdcZ!^i^hÅZm^WaZVcYVkVhXjaVg^ci]ZVYjai#I]ZdcanY^[[ZgZcXZ WZilZZci]ZildY^hi^cXibZX]Vc^hbhd[dhh^ÄXVi^dc^hi]ZZck^gdcbZci^cl]^X]dh" h^ÄXVi^dcdXXjgh#I]ZgZ^hcdY^[[ZgZcXZWZilZZci]Z`^cYd[WdcZegdYjXZY# ;ZiVag^Wh!kZgiZWgVZ!WVh^XgVc^jb!VcYa^bWWdcZhWZ\^cVhXVgi^aV\ZbdYZah#Dhh^" ÄXVi^dcdXXjghl^i]^ci]ZXVgi^aV\ZbdYZaVh^i^heZcZigViZYWnWaddYkZhhZah#


8]VeiZg)7dcZ7^dad\nKVg^Vi^dc

&IGURE
aVnZgd[XVgi^aV\Z!¹\gdlhºVlVn[gdbi]Zh]V[iXZciZg#I]Z\gdl^c\XVgi^aV\Z^hgZeaVXZY WnWdcZdci]ZY^Ve]nhZVah^YZd[i]ZeaViZ#6hi]Z^cY^k^YjVa\gdlh!i]ZZe^e]nhZVa eaViZ^hejh]ZY[Vgi]Zg[gdbi]Zeg^bVgn\gdli]XZciZgd[i]ZWdcZi]Zh]V[i!aZc\i]" Zc^c\i]ZWdcZ#Dhh^ÄXVi^dcVcY\gdli]d[i]ZWdcZXdbZidV]Vail]ZcXZaahVii]Z \gdli]eaViZhideY^k^Y^c\!VcYi]ZZe^e]nh^h[jhZhl^i]i]ZbZiVe]nh^hd[i]Zh]V[i# 7ZXVjhZ i]Z ZcYh d[ i]Z adc\ WdcZ ÅVgZ! hjWhiVci^Va gZbdYZa^c\ dXXjgh Vh i]Z WdcZ aZc\i]ZchYjg^c\i]^hegdXZhh;^\jgZ)#.# 6iZaZkZclZZ`hWZ[dgZW^gi]i]ZgZVgZjhjVaanVWdji-%%dhh^ÄXVi^dcXZciZgh!i]Z ¹Wdcne^ZXZhºd[i]Zh`ZaZidc#6iW^gi]i]ZgZVgZVWdji)*%XZciZgh#6hVgjaZ!¹eg^bVgnº XZciZghVeeZVgWZ[dgZW^gi]!VcY¹hZXdcYVgnºXZciZghVeeZVgV[iZgW^gi]#I]ZhZXdcYVgn XZciZgVii]ZadlZgZcYd[i]Z[ZbjgjeeZgaZ\WdcZVcYi]ZdcZVidei]Zi^W^VadlZg

)#,7dcZ
),

aZ\WdcZWZ\^cidVeeZVg_jhieg^dgidW^gi]#Bdhiadc\WdcZhYZkZadeildhZXdcYVgn XZciZgh^cVYY^i^dcidi]Zeg^bVgnXZciZghd[dhh^ÄXVi^dc#6[Zladc\WdcZhYZkZade VhZXdcYVgnXZciZgVidcZZcYdcan!VcYine^XValg^hiVcYVc`aZWdcZhdhh^[nZci^gZan [gdbi]Z^geg^bVgnXZciZgh#7nVYjai]ddY!Vaad[i]Zeg^bVgnVcYhZXdcYVgnXZciZgh ]VkZ[jhZYidn^ZaYi]ZVkZgV\ZVYjai]jbVcXdbeaZbZcid['%+ZaZbZcih!i]ZWdcZh d[i]ZVYjai]jbVch`ZaZidc#I]ZhZWdcZhVgZa^hiZY^c8]VeiZg+!;^\jgZ+#'#

"ONE2EPAIR 7dcZhdXXVh^dcVaanWgZV`!dgVbQSdebU!l]ZchjW_ZXiZYidVWcdgbVahigZhhZhdgl]Zc WdcZ^hlZV`ZcZYeVi]dad\^XVaan#I]ZegdXZhhd[gZeV^gWZ\^chVhhddcVhi]Z[gVXijgZ dXXjgh#7addYkZhhZah^ci]Z]VkZgh^VcXVcVah!i]ZeZg^dhiZjb!VcYi]ZbVggdlVgZjhj" VaangjeijgZYWnV[gVXijgZ#7addYÅdlh^cidi]Z[gVXijgZodcZVcYcdgbVaan[dgbhV XU]Qd_]QWaddYnbVhhi]ViXdV\jaViZhVhi]ZWaddYkZhhZahVgZhZVaZYd[[#I]ZeZg^" dhiZjb^hjhjVaanidgcVii]Z[gVXijgZh^iZVcYejaaZYVlVn[gdbZcYhd[i]ZWgd`Zc WdcZh#I]^hhi^bjaViZhi]ZdhiZd\Zc^XaVnZgd[i]ZeZg^dhiZjbidWZ\^c[dgb^c\VSQ\ \ec![gVXijgZgZeV^gi^hhjZi]Vi[dgbhVhdgid[cVijgVahea^ci#I]ZXVaajhÄghiXdch^hihd[ ÄWgdjhXdccZXi^kZi^hhjZi]ViWg^Y\Zhi]ZWgd`ZcWdcZhjg[VXZh!in^c\i]Zbid\Zi]Zg# L^i]^cildYVnhi]ZdhiZdWaVhihgZhedcY!VcYi]ZXVaajh^hhjWhZfjZcianb^cZgVa^oZY id[dgbldkZcWdcZ!i]Z`bY]QbiR_^iSQ\\ecI]Zeg^bVgnWdcnXVaajhiV`ZhVWdji h^mlZZ`hidYZkZade#AViZg!i]^hldkZcWdcZXVaajh^hXdckZgiZYidaVbZaaVgWdcZ#>[dg^" ZciVi^dcd[i]ZWgd`ZcWdcZZcYh^hXadhZidi]Zdg^\^cVa!VcY^[hjWhZfjZcibdkZbZci Vii]Z[gVXijgZh^iZ^ha^b^iZYZheZX^VaanWn^bbdW^a^o^c\i]ZWdcZ!i]ZXVaajhbVnWZ" XdbZhdgZbdYZaZYi]ViZk^YZcXZd[[gVXijgZ^hZkZcijVaanegZhZcidcan^cgVY^d\gVe]h# ;jgi]ZggZbdYZa^c\bVnXdbeaZiZanZa^b^cViZVcnZk^YZcXZd[i]Z[gVXijgZ#8]VeiZg &,^aajhigViZhhdbZZ[[ZXihd[[gVXijgZ^cWdcZ#



8]VeiZg)7dcZ7^dad\nKVg^Vi^dc

#HAPTER

EdhibdgiZbH`ZaZiVa BdY^[^XVi^dc 7

dcZhX]Vc\ZVhi]Z^cY^k^YjVa\gdlh#I]^hegdXZhh!_^d_WU^i!Xdci^cjZhjci^a aViZ^cVYjai]ddY^chdbZgZ\^dchhjX]Vhi]ZejW^Xhnbe]nh^hhZZ8]VeiZg&.# 7ZXVjhZWdcZ^ha^k^c\i^hhjZ!^iXVcgZhedcYide]nh^XVahi^bja^ViVcni^bZYjg^c\Vc ^cY^k^YjVa¼ha^[Z#>cY^k^YjVakVg^Vi^dc^cVcn]jbVch`ZaZiVaZaZbZci!i]ZgZ[dgZ!XVc WZi]ZgZhjaid[i]ZWdcZgZhedcY^c\id\ZcZi^XXdcigda!idZck^gdcbZciVa[VXidgh!dg id Wdi]# I]Z bdge]dad\^XVa X]Vc\Zh Y^hXjhhZY ^c 8]VeiZg &, VgZ Q^dU]_bdU] Z[" [ZXih#I]Zn^cXajYZX]Vc\ZhWgdj\]iVWdjiWneVi]dad\n#6[iZgYZVi]!]dlZkZg![jgi]Zg bdge]dad\^XVaX]Vc\ZhXVcdXXjg^cWdcZ!Wgdj\]iVWdjiWnW^dad\^XVa!X]Zb^XVa!VcY e]nh^XVaV\ZcX^ZhdeZgVi^c\dc^i#@_cd]_bdU]]_TYÍSQdY_^VaiZghWdi]i]ZXdcY^" i^dcd[i]Z^cY^k^YjVaWdcZhVcYi]ZXdbeaZiZcZhhd[i]Zh`ZaZidcVhVl]daZ# I]ZhijYnd[i]ZegdXZhhZhi]VideZgViZWZilZZci]Zi^bZd[YZVi]d[i]Zdg\Vc^hb VcYi]Zi^bZd[hijYnWni]ZdhiZdad\^hi^hXVaaZYdQ`X_^_]i#IVe]dcdbn![gdbi]Z i^hZhhZci^Vai]Vii]ZhZegdXZhhZhVcYi]Z^gZ[[ZXih WZ jcYZghiddY ^c dgYZg id Vkd^Y i]Z b^hiV`Zc Viig^Wji^dc d[ edhibdgiZb bdY^ÄXV" i^dcidVciZbdgiZbeVi]dad\^XVaegdXZhhZhhZZ8]VeiZg&,#>cVYY^i^dcidbdY^[n^c\ i]ZWdcZhi]ZbhZakZh!edhibdgiZbegdXZhhZhXVcYgVbVi^XVaanVaiZgi]ZXdbedh^i^dc

).

d[h`ZaZiVaedejaVi^dch#HZkZgVae^i[Vaahd[YZbd\gVe]^XgZXdchigjXi^dc^ckdakZi]ZY^[" [ZgZci^VaYZhigjXi^dcd[h`ZaZiVagZbV^chYjZidedhibdgiZbegdXZhhZh# I]Z[dgZch^XdhiZdad\^hildg`^c\^cVXg^bZhXZcZXdciZmiVXihVhVbZbWZgd[Vc^c" kZhi^\Vi^kZiZVbhZVgX]^c\[dgVaaVkV^aVWaZXajZh#=dlZkZg!hdbZe]nh^XVaVci]gdedad" \^hihldg`^c\^cVgX]Zdad\^XVadgeVaZdcidad\^XVaXdciZmih]VkZ[dXjhZYZmXajh^kZandc i]ZgZig^ZkVad[WdcZhVcYi]ZgZWn]VkZb^hhZY^bedgiVciXdciZmijVaXajZhVWdjieVhi WZ]Vk^dg#I]^hZmXajh^kZ[dXjhdci]ZgZig^ZkVad[WdcnheZX^bZch]Vhi]ZediZci^Vaid hVXg^ÄXZbjX]Xg^i^XVa^c[dgbVi^dcVWdjii]ZeVhi#6gX]Zdad\^hihd[iZchijYnWjg^Vah idjcYZghiVcYeVhiXjaijgVaVXi^k^i^Zh!eVgi^XjaVganbdgijVgnegVXi^XZh#9jYVn&.,-0 9jYVnVcYBVhhZi!&.-,]VhXdch^hiZcianXVaaZYViiZci^dcidi]ZcZZY[dgXdbbjc^XV" i^dcWZilZZcVgX]Zdad\^hiVcYdhiZdad\^hiYjg^c\ZkZgne]VhZd[i]ZgZXdkZgnd[h`Za" ZiVagZbV^ch#CVlgdX`^&..*ZkZchj\\Zhihi]Vii]^hheZX^Va^oZY!\Ve"Wg^Y\^c\ÄZaY d[hijYnh]djaYWZXVaaZY]jbVciVe]dcdbn#>i^h^bedgiVciidgZbZbWZgi]ViWdY^Zh VgZjhjVaanWjg^ZY!cdi_jhih`ZaZidch#I]ZY^hedh^i^dcd[i]Zh`ZaZidci]ZgZ[dgZegd" k^YZhXg^i^XVa^c[dgbVi^dcdc]dli]ZWdYnlVhWjg^ZY#I]ZXjaijgVaVcYiVe]dcdb^X X^gXjbhiVcXZhhjggdjcY^c\YZVi]VcYi]Zeg^bVgnWjg^Vad[i]Z^cY^k^YjVa^cÅjZcXZ i]Zh`ZaZidcgZXdkZgZYWni]ZVgX]Zdad\^hi#7njh^c\VaaVkV^aVWaZXajZhZmedhZYYjg" ^c\ZmXVkVi^dc!i]ZXjaijgVaVggVc\ZbZcid[i]ZXVYVkZgVcYi]Z^cÄaa^c\d[i]ZWjg^Va heVXZbVnWZ^c[ZggZY# >i^hbdhiXdckZc^ZciidY^k^YZiVe]dcdb^XV\Zcih^cidildbV_dgXaVhhZh¸W^dad\^" XVaVcYe]nh^XVa¸VcYidXdch^YZg]jbVc"^cYjXZYbdY^ÄXVi^dchhZeVgViZan#>ih]djaY WZgZVa^oZY!]dlZkZg!i]ViW^dad\^XVaV\ZcihVXii]gdj\]Wdi]e]nh^XVaVcYX]Zb^XVa eVi]lVnhidVaiZgWdcZh#I]^hX]VeiZgYZhXg^WZhVcY^aajhigViZhi]ZZ[[ZXihd[i]Zbdhi XdbbdcanZcXdjciZgZYedhibdgiZbVaiZgVi^dchd[]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#I]Zhij" YZci^hgZ[ZggZYidAnbVc¼h&..)kdajbZKZgiZWgViZIVe]dcdbnVhVcZmXZaaZciZmiZc" h^dcd[bjX]d[i]ZhjW_ZXibViiZgd[i]^hX]VeiZg![gdbVcVgX]Zdad\^XVaeZgheZXi^kZ# =V\ajcYVcYHdg\¼h&..,ZmXZaaZciZY^iZYkdajbZ;dgZch^XIVe]dcdbn^hVcdi]ZgkVaj" VWaZgZhdjgXZ!Vh^hHZXi^dc>>>>ciZgegZiVi^dcd[IgVjbVVcYIVe]dcdbnd[HiZVYbVc '%%(#

"ONE&RACTURE >cdhiZdad\^XVaVcVanh^h!^i^hXg^i^XVaid^YZci^[nYZk^Vi^dchd[WdcZh[gdbi]ZcdgbVa XdcY^i^dc VcY id Y^hi^c\j^h] WZilZZc YZk^Vi^dch XVjhZY Wn eVi]dad\^XVa V\Zcih VcY i]dhZWgdj\]iVWdjiWniVe]dcdb^XV\Zcih#6hhZhh^c\WdcZ[gVXijgZ^cVcVgX]Zdad\^" XVaXdciZmi^hVcZmVbeaZd[i]ZY^[ÄXjai^Zhd[hjX]ldg`#;gVXijgZd[VgVY^jh![dgZm" VbeaZ!XVcdXXjgVnZVgWZ[dgZYZVi]!Vc]djgWZ[dgZYZVi]!^bbZY^ViZanV[iZgYZVi]!dg Yjg^c\ZmXVkVi^dc#I]ZXVjhZhd[hjX][gVXijgZkVgn#6ciZbdgiZb[gVXijgZXVcdXXjgVh i]Z^cY^k^YjVa[Vaah[gdbVigZZ#EdhibdgiZb[gVXijgZXVcWZXVjhZYWni]ZXdgehZWZ^c\ [dgXZY^cidVhbVaaWjg^VaXgneidgWnV]nZcVhXVkZc\^c\i]ZWdYn#>beVi^ZciVgX]Z" dad\^hihVahd]VkZWZZc`cdlcid[gVXijgZWdcZhi]gdj\]XVgZaZhhcZhh#H^\chd[Wdcn ]ZVa^c\VgdjcYi]Z[gVXijgZXdjaY^YZci^[ni]Z[gVXijgZVhVciZbdgiZb#L^i]djii]^h ]ZVa^c\!]dlZkZg!i]ZdhiZdad\^hibVnWZ[dgXZYid^YZci^[ni]Z[gVXijgZVh`UbY]_bdU] VgdjcYi]Zi^bZd[YZVi]!^bean^c\i]Vi^i^hcdiedhh^WaZidVhXZgiV^cl]Zi]Zgi]Z [gVXijgZdXXjggZY_jhiWZ[dgZ!Yjg^c\!dgV[iZgYZVi]#JWZaV`Zg&..'WcdiZhi]Zh^\" c^ÄXVcXZd[[gVXijgZd[i]Z]nd^Y^cV[dgZch^XXdciZmi#9ZVi]WnhigVc\jaVi^dchdbZ" 

8]VeiZg*EdhibdgiZbH`ZaZiVaBdY^ÄXVi^dc

" $ !

#

&IGUREGZXZcidgbdYZgc!7VcY9VcYVcX^Zci6VcY8[gVXijgZhd[]jbVc[ZbdgVa h]V[ih#HeZX^bZch6VcY8VgZ[gdbVcVgX]Zdad\^XVaXdciZmi^cl]^X]i]ZWdcZlVh[gV\bZci" ZYl]Zc[gZh]!l]ZgZVhheZX^bZch7VcY9lZgZ[gVXijgZYYjg^c\gZig^ZkVad[i]ZZaZbZcih [gdbi]Z\gdjcY#CdiZi]ZXdcX]d^YVa^beVXihXVgdci]Z^ciZgcVahjg[VXZd[heZX^bZc8#DcZ" ]Va[cVijgVah^oZ#

i^bZh ^ckdakZh ]nd^Y [gVXijgZ# =dlZkZg! Y^hhZXi^dc Yjg^c\ Vjidehn XVc Vahd [gVXijgZ i]Z]nd^Y#>cXdbeaZiZVc`nadh^hd[i]Z]dgchidi]ZWdYnd[i]Z]nd^Y^hhdbZi^bZh b^hiV`Zc[dg[gVXijgZ#I]Z]nd^YXVcWZ[gVXijgZYeg^dgidYZVi]VcYcdih]dlh^\c^Ä" XVcigZbdYZa^c\Vii]Zi^bZd[YZVi]#I]ZdhiZdad\^hi¼hbdhi^bedgiVciXdcig^Wji^dc idV[dgZch^X^ckZhi^\Vi^dcbVnWZidWg^c\Vaai]ZhZedhh^W^a^i^Zhidi]ZViiZci^dcd[i]Z ^ckZhi^\Vi^kZiZVb# I]ZgViZVil]^X]VWdcZadhZh^ihdg\Vc^XXdbedcZciVcYWZXdbZh¹YgnºVhde" edhZYid¹\gZZcºdg¹[gZh]ºkVg^Zhl^YZan!YZeZcY^c\dci]ZZck^gdcbZcid[YZedh^i^dc# B^cZgVa^oVi^dcdg¹[dhh^a^oVi^dcºd[i]ZWdcZVahdYZeZcYhbdgZdcXdciZmii]Vcdc ZaVehZYi^bZ#9Zhe^iZi]ZkVg^Vi^dch^cgViZd[X]Vc\Z!^i^hd[iZcedhh^WaZidY^hi^c\j^h] WZilZZcVcX^ZcieZg^bdgiZb[gVXijgZd[WdcZhi]Vihi^aagZiV^cZYbjX]dg\Vc^XXdb" edcZcil]ZcWgd`Zc!VcYgZXZci[gVXijgZhd[YgnWdcZhi]VidXXjggZYYjg^c\ZmXVkV" i^dcVcYigVchedgi#9^hXg^b^cVi^dc^hd[iZc[VX^a^iViZYWngZ[ZgZcXZidi]Zhjg[VXZXdadg VcYZY\ZX]VgVXiZg^hi^Xhd[i]ZWgd`Zchjg[VXZh;^\jgZ*#&#6cX^Zciadc\^ijY^cVadg he^gVa[gVXijgZhd[i]Zh]V[iVgZjhjVaanhigV^\]i!l^i]h]Vge!a^cZVgZY\Zh#7ZXVjhZi]Z [gVXijgZhjg[VXZ]VYVagZVYn[dgbZYVii]Zi^bZd[Wjg^Va!i]^hhjg[VXZ^hjhjVaani]Z hVbZXdadgVhi]ZgZhid[i]ZWdcZhjg[VXZ#=dlZkZg!Ygndg[dhh^a^oZYWdcZhi]Vi]VkZ WZZc gZXZcian Wgd`Zc jhjVaan ]VkZ gdj\]Zg! bdgZ _V\\ZY [gVXijgZh! VcY i]Z [gVXijgZ hjg[VXZ^hjhjVaanVY^[[ZgZciXdadga^\]iZg^cbdhijc[dhh^a^oZYWdcZi]Vci]ZVY_VXZci jcWgd`Zchjg[VXZh# *#&7dcZ;gVXijgZ

*&

6h YZhXg^WZY ^c 8]VeiZgh ,·&+! ^cY^k^YjVa WdcZh eZg[dgb Y^[[ZgZci bZX]Vc^XVa VcYe]nh^dad\^XVa[jcXi^dch#I]ZhZ[jcXi^dchVgZgZÅZXiZY^ci]Zl^YZkVg^Vi^dc^ch^oZ! h]VeZ!YZch^in!VcY^ciZgcVahigjXijgZd[i]ZWdcZh#I]ZhZX]VgVXiZg^hi^Xh!^cijgc!V[[ZXi i]ZediZci^Va[dgedhibdgiZb[gVXijgZd[ZVX]ZaZbZciVcYZkZceVgihd[ZaZbZcih#;dg ZmVbeaZ!]jbVc[ZbdgVah]V[ih[gdbVgX]Zdad\^XVaXdaaZXi^dchVgZ[VgbdgZa^`Zanid ZhXVeZi]ZgVkV\Zhd[W^dad\^XVaVcYe]nh^XVaYZhigjXi^dci]Vci]ZhbVaaZg!bdgZ[gV\^aZ hiZgcjb# :aZbZci gZegZhZciVi^dc ^c ZmXVkViZY h`ZaZiVa VhhZbWaV\Zh XVc i]ZgZ[dgZ WZ VaiZgZYh^\c^ÄXVcian[gdbi]ViegZY^XiZYWnZaZbZcigVi^dh^ci]Z^ciVXih`ZaZidc#I]Z VWhZcXZd[]VcYe]VaVc\Zh^cVcZmXVkViZYXZbZiZgnVhhZbWaV\ZjhjVaanYdZhcdibZVc i]ViWdY^ZhlZgZWjg^ZYl^i]djiÄc\Zgh#>chiZVY!hjX]VWhZcXZbdgZd[iZc^cY^XViZhi]Vi nZVghd[edhiWjg^VagdYZciijccZa^c\i]gdj\]i]Zh^iZY^heaVXZYi]ZhZhbVaaZaZbZcihdg i]VigZXdkZgniZX]c^fjZhlZgZcdiVYZfjViZ#6iig^Wji^dcd[i]ZY^hegdedgi^dcidhdbZ g^ijVaVXi^k^in^ckdak^c\gZbdkVad[i]ZÄc\ZghldjaYWZjclVggVciZY^chjX]VXVhZ# I]ZVeegZX^Vi^dci]VieViiZgchd[ZaZbZciY^hegdedgi^dch^ci]ZVgX]Zdad\^XVagZ" XdgYVgZcdiVaaViig^WjiVWaZid]jbVc^ciZgkZci^dc]VhXVjhZYVgX]Zdad\^hihidadd` XadhZanVicVijgVaWdcZbdY^ÄXVi^dc^ci]ZbdYZgcldgaY#I]ZhZQSdeQ\YcdYShijY^Zh ]VkZh]dlcgZeZViZYani]Vii]ZhigjXijgZd[i]ZWdcZhi]ZbhZakZh^hd[iZcVbV_dgYZ" iZgb^cVcid[eViiZgc^c\^ci]ZVgX]Zdad\^XVagZXdgY#;dgZmVbeaZ!i]ZZY\Zd[i]Zi^W^Va eaViZVj^hd[iZcZgdYZYh^beanWZXVjhZd[^ihegdb^cZcXZVcYi]^cXdgiZm!l]ZgZVhi]Z h]V[id[i]^hZaZbZci^hgVgZanYVbV\ZY#

"ONE-ODIlCATIONBY0HYSICAL!GENTS #HEMISTRY EdhibdgiZbX]Vc\Zh^cWdcZgVc\Z[gdbb^cdgVaiZgVi^dchd[WdcZegdiZ^chidXdb" eaZiZhigjXijgVaVcYX]Zb^XVaWgZV`Ydlc#6hdjia^cZY^c8]VeiZg)!i]ZbV_dgXdc" hi^ijZcihd[WdcZVgZegdiZ^cbdhianXdaaV\ZcVcYb^cZgVah#I]ZgZaVi^dch]^eWZilZZc i]ZhZ Xdchi^ijZcih ^ckdakZh XdbeaZm higjXijgVa [ZVijgZh VcY X]Zb^XVa WdcYh l]dhZ cVijgZ^hcdi[jaanjcYZghiddYKdc:cYiVcYDgicZg!&.-)#L]Zci]Zdg\Vc^hbY^Zh! i]ZdcXZ"YncVb^XWdcZi^hhjZWZ\^chidY^h^ciZ\gViZ#Hd^aVX^Y^ine=VcYeZgbZVW^a" ^in!bd^hijgZ!iZbeZgVijgZ!VcYb^Xgddg\Vc^hbhXVcVaaYgVbVi^XVaanV[[ZXii]ZgViZd[ h`ZaZiVaYZiZg^dgVi^dc#9Zedh^i^dcVaZck^gdcbZcih^cXajYZXdcY^i^dchhjX]Vhi]ZYgn :\nei^Vc dg EZgjk^Vc YZhZgih VcY i]Z XdaY! Ygn VgXi^X¸Zck^gdcbZcih i]Vi egZhZgkZ ZkZchd[ii^hhjZh#Di]ZgYZedh^i^dcVaXdcY^i^dchZchjgZYZhigjXi^dcd[ZkZci]ZiZZi]# 9^[[ZgZcXZh^chd^aXdcY^i^dch!ZkZcl^i]^cVh^c\aZWjg^Va!XVcgZhjai^cY^[[ZgZci^Va YZhigjXi^dc#>c\ZcZgVa!WZiiZgWdcZegZhZgkVi^dc^hegZhZci^clZaa"YgV^cZYVgZVhl^i] adllViZgiVWaZh!^chd^ahl^i]VcZjigVadgha^\]ianVa`Va^cZe=!VcY^ciZbeZgViZVgZVh =ZcYZghdc!&.-,#I]ZhZ\ZcZgVa^oVi^dchVgZd[iZck^daViZY!]dlZkZg!WZXVjhZegZhZgkV" i^dc^hhdYZeZcYZcidcjc^fjZXdbW^cVi^dchd[i]ZhZkVg^VWaZh^cadXVaYZedh^i^dcVa hZii^c\h#I]ZXdadgVcYYZ\gZZd[[dhh^a^oVi^dcVgZVahdXdcigdaaZYWni]ZZck^gdcbZci d[YZedh^i^dc#JcYZgi]Zg^\]iXdcY^i^dch!VWdcZXVcWZXdbZXdbeaZiZan[dhh^a^oZY^c V[Zli]djhVcYnZVgh# L]Zcjc[dhh^a^oZYWdcZ^hZmedhZYidi]ZZaZbZcih!eVgi^XjaVgangV^cVcYhjc!^ih hjg[VXZYZiZg^dgViZhVii]ZhVbZi^bZi]Vi^ihdg\Vc^XXdciZci^hadhi#LZVi]Zg^c\WdcZh ÄghiY^heaVnVcZildg`d[ÄcZ!jhjVaaneVgVaaZahjg[VXZXgVX`h#I]ZhZXgVX`hegd\gZhh^kZ" 

8]VeiZg*EdhibdgiZbH`ZaZiVaBdY^ÄXVi^dc

&IGURE7jgc^c\VcYlZVi]Zg^c\d[WdcZ#I]Zh]V[i[gV\bZcihVcYe]VaVcmdci]Zg^\]i h]dlX]VgVXiZg^hi^XXgVX`^c\!YZ\gZVh^c\!VcYZm[da^Vi^dcVhhdX^ViZYl^i]lZVi]Zg^c\#I]ZhZ ]jbVcWdcZhaVnZmedhZYdcVcjcegdiZXiZYhjg[VXZ^c8dadgVYd[dgVWdji&*nZVgh#I]Z [ZbdgVah]V[i[gV\bZciVcYe]VaVcm^ci]Zb^YYaZh]dlWdcZYZiZg^dgVi^dc!Y^hXdadgVi^dc! VcYZm[da^Vi^dc^cY^XVi^kZd[YVbV\ZWnWjgc^c\#CdiZi]Vii]ZXdciVXiWZilZZcYVbV\ZYVcY jcYVbV\ZYhjg[VXZh^hVWgjei#Hd[ii^hhjZegdiZXihi]ZYZZeZgWdcZh!l]ZgZVhhjWXjiVcZdjh WdcZhdgWdcZedgi^dch^hbdgZhjhXZei^WaZidhjX]YVbV\Zl]ZcÅZh]ZYWdcZhVgZWjgcZY!hd i]ZeViiZgcd[YVbV\Zegdk^YZhXajZhidi]ZVbdjcid[hd[ii^hhjZdci]ZWdYnl]ZcWjgc^c\ dXXjgh#I]Za^bW"WdcZh]V[ihea^ciZgVcYe]VaVcmdci]ZaZ[iVgZjcVaiZgZY#7Vg/&Xb#

*#'7dcZBdY^ÄXVi^dcWnE]nh^XVa6\Zcih

*(

anYZZeZcVcYl^YZcVhi]ZWdcZhjg[VXZWZ\^chidYZiZg^dgViZ;^\jgZ*#'#I]ZgViZd[ lZVi]Zg^c\YZeZcYhdciZbeZgVijgZVcY]jb^Y^in!WjiVgX]Zdad\^hih]VkZViiZbeiZY idjhZWdcZlZVi]Zg^c\idZhi^bViZ]dlbjX]i^bZhdbZWdcZVhhZbWaV\Zhidd`id VXXjbjaViZdc[dgbZgaVcYhjg[VXZh!VcY[dgZch^XdhiZdad\^hihjhZh^b^aVgdWhZgkVi^dch# AnbVcVcY;dm&..,Y^hXjhhi]ZegdhVcYXdchd[lZVi]Zg^c\YViV^cWdi]gZVabh#

2OCK %ARTH AND)CE 7dcZhdci]Zhjg[VXZd[XVkZhXVcWZWgd`ZcVcYhXgViX]ZYWngdX`[Vaa#7jg^ZYWdcZh XVcWZ[gVXijgZYWnZVgi]bdkZbZci#>cXdaYZgXa^bViZh!i]Z[gZZoZ"i]VlXnXaZXVcgZ" hjai^cYVbV\ZidWdcZh#I]ZedhibdgiZbVaiZgVi^dcXVjhZYWni]ZhZcdc]jbVce]nh^" XVaV\ZcX^ZhbVn^cXajYZhig^Vi^dchVcYeda^h]^c\i]Vib^\]iWZViig^WjiZYid]jbVc ^ciZgkZci^dc#=dlZkZg!^chjX]X^gXjbhiVcXZhi]ZYZedh^i^dcVaXdciZmiVcYXdcÄ\jgV" i^dcd[YVbV\ZXVcegdk^YZ^bedgiVciXajZh[dgi]ZVXXjgViZ^ciZgegZiVi^dcd[i]ZWdcZ bdY^ÄXVi^dch#

!BRASION EVgi^XaZhd[\g^ihjheZcYZY^cVZg^VadgVfjZdjhZck^gdcbZcihXVcVWgVYZWdcZh!gZYjX" ^c\hjg[VXZgZa^Z[#HjX]hVcYWaVhi^c\Z[[ZXihVgZXdbbdcandWhZgkZY^cWdcZhZmedhZY dci]Zhjg[VXZ^cYZhZgiXdcY^i^dchdgigVchedgiZY^cVg^kZg#BVcn[dhh^aVhhZbWaV\ZhVgZ gZXdkZgZY[gdbÅjk^Vi^aZZck^gdcbZcihVcYi]Z^gZaZbZcihd[iZch]dlVWgVh^dcYVbV\Z#

&IRE >i^hedhh^WaZ[dgWdcZhidWZXdbZX]VggZYWncVijgVaandXXjgg^c\ÄgZh!Wjii]ZZ[[ZXih VgZjhjVaancdiVhhZkZgZVhYVbV\ZXVjhZYWnbdgijVgnXgZbVi^dcdgY^ZiVgngdVhi" ^c\egVXi^XZh;^\jgZh*#'VcY*#(#;dgbVcnVgX]Zdad\^hihVcYdhiZdad\^hih!Vc^cigd" YjXi^dc id XgZbViZY ]jbVc WdcZ ^h i]Z Äghi ZcXdjciZg l^i] WjgcZY WdcZh# I]^h ^h jc[dgijcViZWZXVjhZi]ZdW_ZXi^kZd[XgZbVi^dcVhVbdgijVgnegVXi^XZ^hi]ZYZhigjX" i^dcd[i]ZWdYn#8gZbViZYWdcZhVgZine^XVaan]ZViZYidkZgn]^\]iZbeZgVijgZhVcY X]VgVXiZg^hi^XXdadgX]Vc\ZhVcYXgVX`^c\VXXdbeVc^Zhi]Zadhhd[i]Zdg\Vc^Xedgi^dc d[i]ZWdcZi^hhjZ#>i^hcZXZhhVgnidgZXd\c^oZ!]dlZkZg!i]ViWdcZhjW_ZXiZYidadlZg iZbeZgVijgZh[dgh]dgiZgeZg^dYhd[i^bZ^hcdihdXdche^XjdjhanVaiZgZY#>c[VXi!Wjgc" ^c\d[WdcZi^hhjZbVnhdXadhZanb^b^XcdgbVaWdcZ"lZVi]Zg^c\egdXZhhZhi]Vib^" XgdhXde^XdgX]Zb^XVaVcVanh^h^hcZXZhhVgnidY^hi^c\j^h]i]ZildIVnadgZiVa#!&..*# 7jgc^c\X]Vgg^c\d[WdcZi^hhjZ^hVahdhdbZi^bZhXdc[jhZYl^i]hiV^c^c\eVgi^Xj" aVganbVc\VcZhZhiV^c^c\d[WdcZh^chdbZYZedh^i^dcVaXdciZmihH]V]VX`"
8]VeiZg*EdhibdgiZbH`ZaZiVaBdY^ÄXVi^dc

&IGURE7jgcZY]jbVcWdcZ#7jgc^c\]ZgZ]VhgZhjaiZY^chea^ii^c\!XgVX`^c\!VcYY^hXda" dgVi^dcd[i]ZheZX^bZch!Zm[da^Vi^dcd[i]ZXgVc^VakVjaiWdcZjeeZgg^\]iXdgcZg!VcYYZhigjX" i^dcd[i]ZhjWXjiVcZdjhhjg[VXZd[i]Zi^W^Vah]V[i[gV\bZciWdiidb#DcZ"]Va[cVijgVah^oZ#

"ONE-ODIlCATIONBY.ONHUMAN"IOLOGICAL!GENTS .ONHUMAN!NIMAL 8Vgc^kdgZhhjX]Vh]nZcVh!ldakZh!Yd\h!aZdeVgYh!VcYZkZcXgdXdY^aZhVcY^chZXihXVc ]VkZVYgVbVi^X^beVXidcWdcZhVcYWdcZVhhZbWaV\Zh#I]ZhZVc^bVah!eVgi^XjaVgan i]ZXVc^YhVcY]nZc^Yh!VgZV\Zcihd[WdcZYZhigjXi^dcWZXVjhZi]ZnWgZV`WdcZhWZ" ilZZci]Z^giZZi]^cVcZ[[dgiidgZig^ZkZi]Z[ViVcYbVggdll^i]^c#I]Zhd[i!igVWZXjaVg edgi^dchd[WdcZhVgZ[VkdgZYWni]ZhZVc^bVah!VcYZkZcVhbVaa]nZcV^h[jaanXVeVWaZ d[hea^ciZg^c\i]Zh]V[id[VcVYjai]jbVc[Zbjg#8Vgc^kdgZYVbV\ZidWdcZh^hgZX" d\c^oZYWni]Zh^\cVijgZd[i]ZiZZi]¸e^ii^c\!hXdg^c\!VcYejcXijg^c\d[i]ZWdcZ hjg[VXZ;^\jgZ*#)#=V\ajcYZiVa#&.--egdk^YZVWg^Z[VXXdjcid[[dgZch^XXVhZh^c l]^X]]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^chlZgZgVkV\ZYWnXVgc^kdgZh!l]ZgZVh=V\ajcY&.., gZk^ZlhXVc^YYViV#=V\ajcY&..'XdcigVhihgdYZciVcYXVgc^kdgZYVbV\Z# *#(7dcZBdY^ÄXVi^dcWnCdc]jbVc7^dad\^XVa6\Zcih

**

&IGURE8Vgc^kdgZ"\cVl^c\bVg`hdcegZ]^hidg^X]jbVch`ZaZiVaZaZbZcih#I]Z[Zbjgide aZ[ih]dlhYZhigjXi^dcd[i]Zhedc\nWdcZd[i]Z\gZViZgigdX]VciZgVcYVhhdX^ViZYWgdVY]dg^" odciVa\gddkZhbVYZWnXVgc^kdgZiZZi]_jhiWZadli]ZigdX]VciZgedh^i^dc#I]Z]jbZgjhide g^\]ih]dlhh^b^aVgYZhigjXi^dcd[igVWZXjaVgWdcZVadc\l^i]hbVaaejcXijgZhaZ[iWn\cVl^c\ dci]ZVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZd[i]Z]ZVY#I]ZdhXdmVZWdiidbh]dlhYZhigjXi^dcd[i]Z^a^VXXgZhi VcYVY_VXZcieZg[dgVi^dchXVjhZYWn\cVl^c\#8Va^[dgc^V#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg*EdhibdgiZbH`ZaZiVaBdY^ÄXVi^dc

6ai]dj\]gdYZcihVgZ\ZcZgVaanhbVaaZgi]VcXVgc^kdgZh!i]Z^g\cVl^c\XVcWZ_jhi VhYZhigjXi^kZ#GdYZcihgVc\^c\^ch^oZ[gdbb^XZidaVg\ZedgXje^cZhX]ZldcWdcZh# A^`ZXVgc^kdgZh!aVg\ZgdYZcihXVcbdkZWdcZhVgdjcYdci]ZaVcYhXVeZ!d[iZcXVggn^c\ i]ZbdkZgaVg\ZY^hiVcXZhidi]Z^gYZch!l]ZgZi]ZnVXXjbjaViZVcYbdY^[ni]ZbWn X]Zl^c\#I]ZX]^hZaZY\Zd[i]ZgdYZci^cX^hdg^hjhZYidh]VkZVlVni]Zhjg[VXZWdcZ! egdYjX^c\ V Y^hi^cXi^kZ! [Vc"h]VeZY eViiZgc d[ gZ\jaVg! h]Vaadl! eVgVaaZa dg hjWeVgVa" aZa!ÅVi"WdiidbZY\gddkZhi]ViVgZjhjVaanXdcXZcigViZYdci]Zegd_ZXi^c\hjg[VXZhd[ WdcZh#I]ZhZigVXZhXVcWZeViiZgcZYVcYgZ\jaVg!Wjii]Znh]djaYcdiWZXdc[jhZYl^i] bdY^ÄXVi^dchidWdcZbVYZWn]jbVch;^\jgZ*#*# >cVYY^i^dcidY^heaVn^c\igVXZhd[X]Zl^c\WnbVbbVah!WdcZhXVcWZhXVggZYWn i]ZVXi^dcd[bVbbVa^Vc[ZZi#IgVbea^c\Wnjc\jaViZhVcYeda^h]^c\WnXdchiVcieVh" hV\Zd[XVgc^kdgZh^cVaV^gbVnhXgViX]VcYeda^h]WdcZhjg[VXZh#I]ZhjeZgÄX^Vahig^V" i^dchi]VigZhjai[gdbigVbea^c\b^\]iWZb^hiV`Zc[dgXjibVg`hjci^a^i^hVeegZX^ViZY i]Vii]ZhZbVg`h!jca^`ZXjibVg`h!VgZjhjVaangVcYdbandg^ZciZYVcYXdcXZcigViZY^c ÄZaYhd[eVgVaaZahig^VZVXgdhhi]Zbdhiegdb^cZcieVgihd[i]ZWdcZ#

0LANT EaVcihhZcYi]Z^ggddih^cidi]Z\gdjcY^chZVgX]d[lViZgVcYcjig^Zcih#I]ZhZgddih hZXgZiZ VX^Yh i]Vi XVc WZ kZgn Z[[ZXi^kZ Vi ZiX]^c\ i]Z hjg[VXZh d[ Wjg^ZY WdcZh# I]Z ^c^i^VaeViiZgcd[gddiYVbV\Z^hjhjVaanVgZi^XjaViZcZildg`d[h]Vaadl\gddkZhi]Vi h]djaYcdiWZb^hiV`Zc[dgi]Zldg`d[egZ]^hidg^XZc\gVkZgh;^\jgZ*#+#I]^hgddi" ZiX]ZYcZildg`XVcWZXdbZhdYZchZi]Vii]ZZci^gZdjiZghjg[VXZd[VWdcZ^hZiX]ZY VlVn# >cY^k^YjVa gddi"bVg` \gddkZh VgZ d[iZc l]^iZg ^c Xdadg i]Vc i]Z hjggdjcY^c\ WdcZWZXVjhZd[YZXVaX^ÄXVi^dcWgdj\]iVWdjiWni]ZVX^Y#

"ONE-ODIlCATIONBY(UMANS 9^hi^c\j^h]^c\]jbVc[gdbcdc]jbVcV\Zcih^ci]ZbdY^ÄXVi^dcd[h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch Xdci^cjZh id egZdXXjen Vci]gdedad\^hih hijYn^c\ ]jbVc dg^\^ch ^c 6[g^XV! i]Z eZd" ea^c\d[i]ZCZlLdgaY!VcYbVcndi]ZgegdWaZbhd[egZ]^hidgn#6hcdiZYegZk^djhan! bVcnVXijVa^hi^XhijY^Zh]VkZWZZcXdcYjXiZYl^i]i]Z\dVad[Y^hXdkZg^c\Y^V\cdhi^X Viig^WjiZhd[]jbVcWdcZbdY^ÄXVi^dc^cVgX]Zdad\^XVaXdciZmih#Bdhid[i]ZhZhijY^Zh [dXjhdccdc]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^chVcYVgZgZ[ZggZYidVhj__QbSXU_\_Wi#I]Z^ggZ" hjaihVahdVeean^cXVhZhl]ZgZ]jbVcgZbV^chVgZi]ZdW_ZXihd[]jbVcbdY^ÄXVi^dc# =jbVcbdgijVgnegVXi^XZhbVn]VkZegd[djcYZ[[ZXihdci]ZY^hedh^i^dcd[Vh`Za" Zidc#;dgZmVbeaZ!i]Z[dgX^c\d[i]ZXdgehZ^cidVhbVaaheVXZXVcXVjhZhigVc\ZVcV" idb^XVa_jmiVedh^i^dchVcYZkZc[gVXijgZh#>chZXdcYVgnWjg^Vah!i]ZgZVgZd[iZcigVXZh d[]jbVcVXi^k^inaZ[idci]ZWdcZh0YZÅZh]^c\XVcaZVkZXjibVg`hVcYhXgVe^c\bVg`h dci]ZWdcZh!VcYXgZbVi^dcjhjVaanXVjhZhX]Vgg^c\gZhjai^c\^cl]^iZ!\gVn!WaVX`! VcYWajZ]jZhVcYigVchkZghZXgVX`^c\d[i]ZWdcZh#;dgijcViZan[dgi]ZdhiZdad\^hi! VWdg^\^cVa XgZbVi^dc bVn WZ ^cZ[ÄX^Zci! aZVk^c\ ^YZci^ÄVWaZ [gV\bZcih VkV^aVWaZ [dg gZXdkZgnVcYVcVanh^h# 8Vcc^WVa^hb^cVcVgX]Zdad\^XVaXdciZmi^hVide^Xd[Xdch^YZgVWaZVci]gdedad\^" XVa^ciZgZhi#=jbVchXVc[gVXijgZadc\"WdcZh]V[ihl^i]]VbbZghidcZhVcYejakZg^oZ *#)7dcZBdY^ÄXVi^dcWn=jbVch

*,

&IGURE=^\]aneViiZgcZYgdYZci\cVl" ^c\bVg`hdc]jbVch`ZaZiVaZaZbZcih#I]Z i^W^VaZ[i![gdbegZ]^hidg^X8Va^[dgc^V!h]dlh \cVl^c\WnVkZgnhbVaagdYZci#I]ZXgV" c^jbWZadl![gdbVegZ]^hidg^X6[g^XVch^iZ! h]dlh]ZVkn\cVl^c\!l^i]WgdVYZg\dj\Zh aZ[iWni]Z^cX^hdghd[Vc6[g^XVcedgXje^cZ# CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg*EdhibdgiZbH`ZaZiVaBdY^ÄXVi^dc

&IGUREGddibVg`^c\dcV]jbVcXgVc^jb[gdbVegZ]^hidg^X8Va^[dgc^Vh^iZ#HjX]YZa^" XViZ!^cig^XViZZiX]^c\d[\gddkZhh]djaYcdiWZb^hiV`Zc[dgXjaijgVaVXi^k^i^Zh#CVijgVah^oZ#

*#)7dcZBdY^ÄXVi^dcWn=jbVch

*.

adc\"WdcZ ZcYh id ZmigVXi cjig^i^djh [Vi# EZgXjhh^dc e^ih VcY Vck^a hXVgh VgZ jhjVaan hZZcjcYZgi]ZhZXdcY^i^dchL]^iZ!&..'#8jibVg`hbVYZWnhidcZdgbZiVaiddah bVnVahdVeeZVgdch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch^cVXVcc^WVa^oZYVhhZbWaV\Z#7jgc^c\d[i]ZWdcZ VhhdX^ViZYl^i]gdVhi^c\^hd[iZcXdcXZcigViZYdci]ZhjWXjiVcZdjhhjg[VXZhd[WdcZh hjX]Vhi]ZXgVc^jb!bVcY^WaZ!VcYi^W^V#HijYnd[i]ZeViiZgchd[WdcZYZhigjXi^dc i]gdj\]WdcZVhhZbWaV\ZXdbedh^i^dcVcYi]ZVXijVae]nh^XVaigVXZhaZ[idc^cY^k^YjVa WdcZhd[iZcbV`Zh^iedhh^WaZidY^hi^c\j^h]WZilZZc]jbVcVcYcdc]jbVcYVbV\Z idWdcZh# 6hcdiZY^c8]VeiZg'!^begdeZgZmXVkVi^dc!igVchedgi!VcYXaZVc^c\d[WdcZh^c i]ZÄZaYdgaVWdgVidgnXVcgZhjai^cYVbV\Zidh`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#I]^h¹egZeVgVi^dc!ºdg XaZVc^c\!YVbV\Z^hjhjVaanZVh^anY^hXZgc^WaZ[gdbeZg^bdgiZbYVbV\Zdci]ZWVh^hd[ ^ihY^hig^Wji^dcVcYhjg[VXZX]VgVXiZg^hi^Xh#BVcnd[i]ZldgaY¼hbdhi[Vbdjh]db^c^Y [dhh^ah]VkZWZZcYVbV\ZY^ci]^hbVccZg#BZiVa^chigjbZcih!^cXajY^c\YZciVae^X`h! ZaZXig^XYg^aah!VcYZkZcl^gZWgjh]Zh!XVcVaaaZVkZigVXZhdcdhiZdad\^XVaheZX^bZch! Wjii]^hYVbV\Zh]djaYcZkZgWZb^hiV`ZcVhZk^YZcXZ[dgegZ]^hidg^X]jbVcWZ]Vk^dg# I]ZdhiZdad\^hih]djaYiV`ZegZXVji^dchidVkd^Y^cÅ^Xi^c\hjX]YVbV\Zdch`ZaZiVa gZbV^ch#I]ZhZZmXVkVi^dc"VcYegZeVgVi^dc"gZaViZYYZ[ZXihVgZd[iZcZVh^anY^V\cdhZY WVhZYdci]Z^gXdadg#6cX^ZcihjgÄX^VaYZ[ZXih^cVWdcZjhjVaanVXXjbjaViZhd^a!bV" ig^m!hiV^ch!dgdi]ZggZh^YjZhi]ViYVg`Zci]ZbgZaVi^kZidi]ZVY_VXZciWdcZ#GZXZcian bVYZYZ[ZXihVgZjhjVaana^\]iZg^cXdadgVcY[gZZd[hiV^c^c\VcYb^XgdhXde^XVcYbVX" gdhXde^X[dgZ^\cYZWg^h# 9^hXg^b^cVi^dcWZilZZciVe]dcdb^XV\Zcihdg¹VXidghºi]ViVcX^ZcianXVjhZYhjg" [VXZbdY^ÄXVi^dchidWdcZh^hd[iZci]dj\]iidWZVbdgZY^[ÄXjaiiVh`#;dgZmVbeaZ! hdbZ]VkZVYkdXViZYi]ZjhZd[hXVcc^c\ZaZXigdcb^XgdhXdenidX]ddhZWZilZZcY^" V\cdhZhd[XVgc^kdgZX]Zl^c\bVg`hdg]jbVcan^cYjXZYXjibVg`h#7a^cYiZhih^cV hijYnWn7ajbZchX]^cZZiVa#&..+YZbdchigViZYZmXZaaZci^ciZg"VcVanhiV\gZZbZci VcYVXXjgVXn^c^YZci^[n^c\XjibVg`h!eZgXjhh^dcbVg`h!VcYXVgc^kdgZiddi]bVg`h lVh ZmXZaaZci! VeegdVX]^c\ &%% [dg ZmeZgih# BV_dg ]jbVc"bVYZ bdY^ÄXVi^dch id WdcZhjg[VXZhVgZdjia^cZY^ci]Z[daadl^c\hZXi^dchVcYVgZ^aajhigViZYVcYY^hXjhhZY [jaan^cL]^iZ&..'#

#UTMARKS #HOPMARKS AND3CRAPEMARKS L]Zci]Zh]Vge!d[iZc^ggZ\jaVgZY\Zd[VhidcZiddaXdciVXihi]Zhjg[VXZd[VWdcZYjg^c\ YZÅZh]^c\dgY^hVgi^XjaVi^dcVXi^k^i^Zh!VSed]Qb[;^\jgZ*#,^h[dgbZY#I]ZhZbVg`h VgZjhjVaanbjX]cVggdlZg!ÄcZg!VcYbdgZK"h]VeZYi]VcXVgc^kdgZiddi]bVg`h#Jc" a^`Zi]Zh^c\aZgdj\][jggdld[VXVgc^kdgZbVg`dgi]ZÅVi"WdiidbZYigdj\]d[Vgd" YZci^cX^hdgbVg`!XjibVg`hjhjVaanY^heaVnhig^VZl^i]^ci]ZbVg`VcYd[iZch]dl ¹h]djaYZgbVg`hºdg¹WVgWhºl]ZgZY^[[ZgZcieVgihd[i]ZiddaZY\ZXdciVXii]ZWdcZVcY i]ZgZWnXjii]Z^gdlceVgVaaZadghjWeVgVaaZabVg`h#8jibVg`hVgZjhjVaani]ZgZhjaid[ ha^X^c\VXi^k^i^Zh^cl]^X]i]ZWaVYZd[i]Zidda^hjhZYeZgeZcY^XjaVgidi]Z\gV^cd[i]Z i^hhjZWZ^c\ha^XZY#3X_`]Qb[c;^\jgZ*#-VgZh^b^aVgidXjibVg`h!WjigZhjai[gdb [dgXZ[jaVcYVWgjeiXdciVXiWZilZZciddaZY\ZVcYWdcZgVi]Zgi]Vc[gdbha^X^c\VXi^k^" i^Zh#8]debVg`hVgZaZhh[gZfjZci^cVgX]Zdad\^XVaWdcZVhhZbWaV\ZhbdY^ÄZYWnhidcZ iddahl^i][gV\^aZZY\ZhVcYVgZbdgZ[gZfjZci^c[dgZch^XXVhZhl]ZgZbZiVa^beaZbZcih Vaadli]ZX]dee^c\d[i^hhjZh#CSbQ`U]Qb[c!bVYZl]Zci]ZZY\Zd[i]Zidda^hhXgVeZY 

8]VeiZg*EdhibdgiZbH`ZaZiVaBdY^ÄXVi^dc

&IGURE8jibVg`hbVYZWnhidcZiddahdcild[ZbdgVah]V[i[gV\bZcihVcYVXaVk^XaZ# 8jibVg`hVgZjhjVaaneViiZgcZYl^i]gZheZXiidi]Zhd[ii^hhjZi]VilVhWZ^c\Xji[gdbi]Z WdYn¸]ZgZ!YZÅZh]^c\XjibVg`hidgZbdkZaZ\bjhXjaVijgZ!VcYbVg`hbVYZ^ci]ZegdXZhh d[YZXVe^iVi^dc#7Vg/&Xb#;gdbL]^iZ&..'#

&IGURE8]debVg`hbVYZWnhidcZiddahdci]ZedhiZg^dghjg[VXZd[Vegdm^bVai^W^Va[gV\" bZci#7Vg/&Xb#;gdbL]^iZ&..'#

*#)7dcZBdY^ÄXVi^dcWn=jbVch

+&

VXgdhhi]Zhjg[VXZd[i]ZWdcZ!Vahdh]dladlZg[gZfjZcX^Zh^cVgX]Zdad\^XVaVhhZbWaV\Zh [dgi]ZhVbZgZVhdc#I]ZhZVgZjhjVaanh]VaadlZgi]VcZ^i]ZgXjibVg`hdgX]debVg`h! Wjii]ZnXdkZgl^YZgVgZVhl^i]bVcneVgVaaZadghjWeVgVaaZahig^Vi^dch#

0ERCUSSION-ARKS 8jibVg`hVcYX]debVg`hVgZ[gZfjZcianZcXdjciZgZY^cWdi][dgZch^XVcYVgX]Zd" ad\^XVaXdciZmih#>ci]Z[dgZch^XXdciZmi!hjX]bVg`hXVc^cY^XViZVciZbdgiZbigVjbV dgedhibdgiZbViiZbeihidY^hVgi^XjaViZWdYnhZ\bZcih#DcXZY^hVgi^XjaViZYVcYaZhh [gZfjZcianYZÅZh]ZY!i]ZZaZbZcihd[i]Zh`ZaZidcXVcWZgZYjXZY[jgi]ZgWnY^gZXi eZgXjhh^dcl^i]V]ZVkndW_ZXi#I]^h^hgVgZanhZZc^c[dgZch^XXdciZmih!Wji^i^hk^gij" Vaanjc^kZghVa^coddVgX]Zdad\^XVaXdciZmih#;Vi^h]^\]aneg^oZYWnbVcneZdeaZ!VcY WdcZhXdciV^c[ViinbVggdl^cWdi]i]Z^gbZYjaaVgnXVk^i^ZhVcYi]Z^gigVWZXjaVggZ" \^dch#IddWiV^c[Vi[gdbi]ZÄghiadXVi^dc!i]Zh]V[ihVgZXgVX`ZYVcYejaaZYVeVgi#;Vi ^ci]Zhedc\nWdcZXVcWZZmigVXiZYWnZVi^c\i]ZXgjh]ZYigVWZXjaVgedgi^dchdgWn Wd^a^c\i]ZbidgZcYZgi]Z[Vi^cXdd`^c\kZhhZah#6aad[i]ZhZXjaijgVaVXi^k^i^Zh]VkZ i]ZediZci^VaidaZVkZigVXZhdci]ZWdcZh# L]Zc[gVXijgZd[i]ZWdcZ^hZ[[ZXiZYl^i]VhidcZ]VbbZghidcZ!^ggZ\jaVg!gdj\]" ZcZY`UbSeccY_^`Ydc;^\jgZ*#.i]ViXdggZhedcYidi]Zi^ed[i]ZeZgXjhhdgbVnWZ aZ[i dc i]Z WdcZ eVgi^XjaVgan ^[ Vaa hd[i i^hhjZ ]Vh WZZc gZbdkZY# >[ i]^h VXi^k^in ^h jcYZgiV`ZcdcVcVck^adg^[i]ZeZgXjhhdgbdkZhha^\]ianVh^i^beVXihi]ZWdcZ!`Ub SeccY_^dgQ^fY\cdbYQU;^\jgZ*#&%bVngZhjai#I]^hVXi^k^ind[iZcegdYjXZhY^^Ub S_^SX_YTQ\cSQbc;^\jgZ*#&&dci]ZbZYjaaVgnXVk^inhjg[VXZd[i]ZWdcZh]V[iVcY QTXUbY^WÎQ[Ucdci]Zh]V[ilVaa#L]Zci]ZiVg\ZibVggdl^h^ci]ZigVWZXjaVgedg" i^dchd[i]ZWdcZ!i]ZeZgXjhh^dcidi]^hVgZVhdbZi^bZhXgZViZhXgjh]^c\;^\jgZ*#&'! VcY l]Zc [gZh] WdcZ [gV\bZcih VgZ ejaaZY VeVgi [dgXZ[jaan! i]Z gZhjai ^h hdbZi^bZh eZZa^c\!eVgi^XjaVgandc^bbVijgZWdcZhVcYg^Wh;^\jgZ*#&(#L]Zci]Z[gV\bZciZY WdcZhVgZWd^aZY^cXZgVb^XkZhhZah^cVcViiZbeiidgZcYZg\gZVhZ!hdbZd[i]Zh]V[i [gV\bZcih bVn VXfj^gZ V eZXja^Vg [dgb d[ VWgVh^dc dc i]Z^g i^eh XVaaZY `_d `_\YcX L]^iZ!&..'#

0ROJECTILES

I

]ZegZk^djhZmVbeaZhd[WdcZbdY^ÄXVi^dc]VkZWZZchZaZXiZY[gdbVgX]Zdad\^" XVa XdciZmih! Wji WZXVjhZ [gZh] WdcZ ^ciZgVXih l^i] [dgZ^\c dW_ZXih ^c i]Z hVbZ lVn!i]ZWZ]Vk^dgVaYZYjXi^dchWVhZYdchjX]bdY^ÄXVi^dchVahdaVg\ZanVeean^ci]Z bdYZgc[dgZch^XgZVab#>ci]^hgZVab!bViX]^c\WdcZbdY^ÄXVi^dch[djcYdck^Xi^bh d[`c^kZhVcYdi]Zgiddahidi]Ziddahi]ZbhZakZh^hhdbZi^bZhedhh^WaZVcY^bedgiVci# =^\]"heZZYegd_ZXi^aZhhjX]VhVggdlh]VkZWZZcbdY^[n^c\]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch [dg i]djhVcYh d[ nZVgh ;^\jgZ *#&)# >c i]Z bdYZgc [dgZch^X XdciZmi! egd_ZXi^aZh VgZ bdhid[iZcbZiVa!^ci]Z[dgbd[WjaaZihd[kVg^djhXVa^WZg!dgh]gVecZa;^\jgZ*#&*# I]ZVcVanh^hd[ZcignkZghjhZm^iYVbV\ZiddhiZdad\^XVagZbV^ch^hd[iZcXg^i^XVa^c[d" gZch^X^ckZhi^\Vi^dch#>cVYY^i^dcidi]^hWdcZbdY^ÄXVi^dcZk^YZcXZ!i]ZgVY^d\gVe]^X Y^hXdkZgnd[[dgZ^\cbZiVadgdi]ZgdW_ZXih^ch`ZaZiVagZbV^chd[iZcXdchi^ijiZhVcVY" Y^i^dcVaXg^i^XVaY^bZch^dcd[[dgZch^XVcVanh^h# 

8]VeiZg*EdhibdgiZbH`ZaZiVaBdY^ÄXVi^dc

&IGUREEZgXjhh^dce^ihbVYZWnhidcZ]VbbZghidcZh#7Vg/&Xb#;gdbL]^iZ&..'#

*#)7dcZBdY^ÄXVi^dcWn=jbVch

+(

&IGUREEZgXjhh^dce^ihVhhdX^ViZYl^i]eZgXjhh^dchig^VZdcadc\WdcZh]V[i[gV\bZcih# I]ZXd"dXXjggZcXZd[]VbbZghidcZVcYVck^ahig^VZl^i]i]ZhZe^ih^h\ddYZk^YZcXZd[]jbVc ^ckdakZbZci^ci]ZegdXZhh^c\d[i]ZhZWdcZh#7Vg/&Xb#;gdbL]^iZ&..'#

&IGURE>ccZgXdcX]d^YVahXVgh[dgbZYl]Zci]ZhZ[ZbdgVaheZX^bZchlZgZ[gVXijgZY[dg i]Z^gbVggdl#7Vg/&Xb#;gdbL]^iZ&..'#



8]VeiZg*EdhibdgiZbH`ZaZiVaBdY^ÄXVi^dc

&IGUREL]Zchedc\nWdcZ^hXgjh]ZYWn[dgXZ!XdgiZmdci]ZVY_VXZciVgZVh^hejh]ZY^cid i]ZXgjh]ZYVgZV!Vh^ci]ZhZ[ZbdgVaheZX^bZch#CdiZVahdi]ZY^hVgi^XjaVi^dcXjibVg`hdci]Z [ZbdgVacZX`#7Vg/&Xb#;gdbL]^iZ&..'#

&IGUREEZZa^c\dcV_jkZc^aZ¼hegdm^bVajacVideVcYVcVYjai¼hg^WWdiidb#7Vg/&Xb# ;gdbL]^iZ&..'#

*#)7dcZBdY^ÄXVi^dcWn=jbVch

+*

&IGUREEgd_ZXi^aZed^ciZbWZYYZY^ci]ZkZcigVahjg[VXZd[V]jbVchiZgcjb#CdWdcn gZVXi^dc^hhZZc!^cY^XVi^c\i]Vii]ZZkZcilVheZg^bdgiZb!XVjhZd[YZVi]jc`cdlc#EgZ]^hidg^X 8Va^[dgc^V#

&IGURE7jaaZiZcignVcYZm^ildjcY!bdYZgc]jbVc]db^X^YZk^Xi^b#8VjhZd[YZVi] `cdlc[gdbVjidehngZXdgYh#BdYZgc8aZkZaVcY#



8]VeiZg*EdhibdgiZbH`ZaZiVaBdY^ÄXVi^dc

#HAPTER

6cVidb^XVaIZgb^cdad\n =

jbVc VcVidb^hih VcY Vci]gdedad\^hih i]gdj\]dji i]Z ldgaY jhZ V heZ" X^ÄXkdXVWjaVgnidYZhXg^WZi]Z]jbVcWdYn#6cVidb^XVacdbZcXaVijgZ^hWdi] XdcX^hZ VcY egZX^hZ! Vaadl^c\ jcVbW^\jdjh Xdbbjc^XVi^dc Vbdc\ Vaa gZhZVgX]Zgh l]dhijYnh`ZaZiVabViZg^Va#>cYZZY!^i^hk^gijVaan^bedhh^WaZid[daadlZkZcWVh^XYZ" hXg^ei^dchdg^ciZgegZiVi^dch^ceVaZdcidad\n!e]nh^XVaVci]gdedad\n!bZY^X^cZ!]jbVc VcVidbn!VcYVkVg^Zind[Vaa^ZYY^hX^ea^cZhl^i]djiVXdbbVcYd[i]ZWVh^X!\ZcZgVa VcVidb^XVa iZgbh ^cigdYjXZY ^c i]^h X]VeiZg# =ZgZ lZ YZÄcZ i]Z ZhhZci^Va eaVcZh d[ gZ[ZgZcXZ!Y^gZXi^dcVaiZgbh!WdYnbdi^dch!VcYWdcn[dgbVi^dchcZXZhhVgn[dgi]ZYZ" iV^aZYhijYnd[]jbVcdhiZdad\n#6cVidb^XVacdbZcXaVijgZ]VhZkdakZY[gdbVXaVh" h^XVa[djcYVi^dc!VcYbVcnd[i]ZcVbZhjhZYidYZhXg^WZWdcZhVcYi]Z^geVgihVgZ YZg^kZY[gdbAVi^cVcY
0LANESOF2EFERENCE I]gZZWVh^XgZ[ZgZcXZeaVcZhVgZjhZY^c]jbVcdhiZdad\n#I]ZcQWYddQ\]YTcQWYddQ\! ]UTYQ^!dg]YT\Y^UeaVcZY^k^YZhi]ZWdYn^cidhnbbZig^XVag^\]iVcYaZ[i]VakZh# 6cneaVcVgha^XZi]gdj\]i]ZWdYni]VieVgVaaZahi]ZhV\^iiVaeaVcZ^hXVaaZYV`QbQcQW YddQ\cUSdY_^#6S_b_^Q\Vb_^dQ\eaVcZY^k^YZhi]ZWdYn^cidVciZg^dgVcYedhiZg^dg ]VakZhVcY^heaVXZYVig^\]iVc\aZhidi]ZhV\^iiVaeaVcZ#6dbQ^cfUbcUX_bYj_^dQ\ eaVcZ ha^XZh i]gdj\] i]Z WdYn Vi Vcn ]Z^\]i Wji ValVnh eVhhZh eZgeZcY^XjaVg id i]Z hV\^iiVaVcY[gdciVaeaVcZh#

+,

$IRECTIONAL4ERMS >c dhiZdad\n ^i ^h jhZ[ja id gZ[Zg id Y^gZXi^dch d[ bdi^dc dg i]Z gZaVi^kZ adXVi^dch d[ kVg^djhh`ZaZiVaeVgih#6aad[i]ZY^gZXi^dcVaiZgbhjhZY]ZgZgZ[Zgidi]Z]jbVcWdYn ^chiVcYVgYVcVidb^XVaedh^i^dc!Wji^i^h^bedgiVciidcdiZi]Vibdhid[i]ZhZiZgbh VgZVeea^XVWaZidVaabVbbVah#6[ZliZgbhbVndXXVh^dcVaanXVjhZXdc[jh^dcl]Zc ]db^c^Y i]Z oddad\^XVa [Vb^an d[ eg^bViZh id l]^X] ]jbVch VcY i]Z^g ^bbZY^ViZ VcXZhidghVcYcZVg"gZaVi^kZhWZadc\VcYcdc]db^c^YWdcZhVgZWZ^c\XdbeVgZYWZ" XVjhZ]jbVchVgZ_bdX_WbQTUigjc`jeg^\]iW^eZYhVcYbdhidi]ZgbVbbVahVgZ `b_^_WbQTUigjc`]dg^odciVafjVYgjeZYh#

'ENERAL V# Ce`UbY_b/idlVgYi]Z]ZVYZcYd[i]Z]db^c^YWdYn#I]ZhjeZg^dgWdjcYVgnd[ i]Z]jbVceVg^ZiVaWdcZ^hi]ZhV\^iiVahjijgZ#3U`XQ\YSVcYSbQ^YQ\VgZhnc" dcnbdjhiZgbhi]VibVnWZjhZY]dbdad\djhan[dgW^eZYhVcYfjVYgjeZYh# W# 9^VUbY_b/deedh^iZd[hjeZg^dg0[dg]db^c^Yh!WdYneVgihVlVn[gdbi]Z]ZVY#I]Z ^c[Zg^dghjg[VXZd[i]ZXVaXVcZjh!dg]ZZaWdcZ!^hi]ZeVgid[i]ZWdcZi]VigZhih cZVgZhiid!dga^Zh^cXdciVXil^i]!i]Z\gdjcY#3QeTQ\!idlVgYi]ZiV^a!^hd[iZc jhZY^ci]ZYZhXg^ei^dcd[fjVYgjeZYVaVcVidbn# X# 1^dUbY_b/idlVgYi]Z[gdcid[i]Z]db^c^YWdYn#I]ZWgZVhiWdcZ!dghiZgcjb!^h adXViZYVciZg^dgidi]ZWVX`WdcZ!dgkZgiZWgVaXdajbc#FU^dbQ\!idlVgYi]ZWZaan! bVnWZjhZY]dbdad\djhan[dgW^eZYhVcYfjVYgjeZYh# Y# @_cdUbY_b/deedh^iZd[VciZg^dg0[dg]db^c^Yh!idlVgYi]ZWVX`d[i]Z^cY^k^YjVa# I]ZdXX^e^iVaWdcZ^hdci]ZedhiZg^dgVcY^c[Zg^dgZcYd[i]Zh`jaa#4_bcQ\^hd[" iZcjhZY[dg]dbdad\djheVgihd[i]ZfjVYgjeZYVcVidbn#  Z# =UTYQ\/idlVgYi]Zb^Ya^cZ#I]ZaZ[ih^YZd[i]Zidc\jZ^hbZY^Vaidi]ZaZ[i]Va[ d[i]ZbVcY^WaZ#  [#
8]VeiZg+6cVidb^XVaIZgb^cdad\n

4EETH V# =UcYQ\/idlVgYi]Zb^Ya^cZed^cid[i]ZYZciVaVgX]l]ZgZi]ZXZcigVa^cX^hdgh XdciVXiZVX]di]Zg#I]ZVciZg^dgedgi^dcd[bdaVgVcYegZbdaVgXgdlchVcYi]Z bZY^VaeVgihd[XVc^cZhVcY^cX^hdghVgZXVaaZYi]ZbZh^VaeVgihd[i]ZhZiZZi]# I]ZbZh^Vahjg[VXZd[i]ZXVc^cZidjX]Zhi]Z^cX^hdgcZmiid^i!VcYi]ZbZh^Vahjg" [VXZd[i]ZÄghibdaVgidjX]Zhi]ZegZbdaVgcZmiid^i# W# 4YcdQ\/deedh^iZd[bZh^Va#I]ZY^hiVa]Va[d[VegZbdaVg^hi]ZedhiZg^dg]Va[d[ i]Ziddi]# X#
(ANDSAND&EET V# @Q\]Qb/eVabh^YZd[i]Z]VcY#I]ZeVabVghjg[VXZd[i]ZY^\^ihWZVghÄc\Zg" eg^cih# W# @\Q^dQb/hdaZd[i]Z[ddi#I]ZeaVciVghjg[VXZd[i]Z[ddiXdciVXihi]Z\gdjcYYjg" ^c\cdgbValVa`^c\# X# 4_bcQ\/ided[i]Z[ddidgi]ZWVX`d[i]Z]VcY#I]ZYdghVahjg[VXZhd[]VcYhVcY [ZZid[iZcWZVg]V^g!l]ZgZVhi]ZeVabVgVcYeaVciVghjg[VXZhYdcdi#

-OTIONSOFTHE"ODY BdkZbZcid[i]ZWdYn^hVXXdbea^h]ZYWnbjhXaZhVXi^c\Y^gZXiandgk^ViZcYdchdc WdcZh#I]ZaZhhbdW^aZViiVX]bZcied^cii]ViVcX]dghVbjhXaZ^hXVaaZYi]Zdg^\^cd[ i]ZbjhXaZ!VcYi]Z^chZgi^dc^hi]Zh^iZd[bjhXaZViiVX]bZcil^i]gZaVi^kZanbdgZ bdkZbZcii]Vci]Zdg^\^c#

+#'9^gZXi^dcVaIZgbh

+.

LATERALMEDIAL LATERAL

SUPERIO

RIGHT ANTER IOR

R

POSTER

IOR LEFT

INFERI

OR PROXIMAL

AL AGITT S TRANSVER SE C ORONA

DISTAL

DO RS

PAL M

DORSAL

CRANIAL ANTERIOR

L

CAUDAL POSTERIOR

VENTRAL

DORS A L

AL

AR

PROXI

MAL

DISTAL

PLA NTA R &IGURE9^gZXi^dcVaiZgbhVcYeaVcZh[dgV]jbVcVcYVfjVYgjeZYVabVbbVa#@cdlaZY\Z d[i]ZY^gZXi^dcVaiZgbhVcYeaVcZhd[gZ[ZgZcXZ^hcZXZhhVgn[dgVcnldg`^c]jbVcVcVidbn# >c]jbVcdhiZdad\n!i]ZhZiZgbhVgZZhhZci^Va[dgi]ZhijYnVcYXdbeVg^hdcd[h`ZaZiVaZaZbZcih#



8]VeiZg+6cVidb^XVaIZgb^cdad\n

                    



  

  0AIREDCRANIALELEMENTS  3INGLECRANIALELEMENTS  -ANDIBLE  (YOID  #ERVICALVERTEBRAE  #LAVICLE  3CAPULA  3TERNUM  4HORACICVERTEBRAEVAR  (UMERUS  2IBSVAR  5LNA  2ADIUS  ,UMBARVERTEBRAEVAR  3ACRUM  /SCOXAE  #ARPALS  -ETACARPALS  0ROXIMALHANDPHALANGES  )NTERMEDIATEHANDPHALANGES  $ISTALHANDPHALANGES  &EMUR  0ATELLA  &IBULA  4IBIA  4ALUS  #ALCANEUS  /THERTARSALS  -ETATARSALS  0ROXIMALFOOTPHALANGES  )NTERMEDIATEFOOTPHALANGES  $ISTALFOOTPHALANGES #OCCYXNOTVISIBLE 4/4!,!DULT

     



#OMMONLYVARIABLEELEMENTS INDICATEDBYVAR

&IGUREH`ZaZiVaZaZbZcih#

'ENERAL V# 6\UhY_^/\ZcZgVaan!VWZcY^c\bdkZbZcii]ViYZXgZVhZhi]ZVc\aZWZilZZcWdYn eVgih#L]ZcV]VcY^hXaZcX]ZY^cidVÄhii]ZgZ^hhigdc\ÊZm^dcd[i]Ze]VaVc\Zh dci]ZbZiVXVgeVa]ZVYh#7nXdckZci^dc!ÅZm^dcVii]Zh]djaYZgdg]^e_d^cigZ" [ZghidVkZcigVa[dglVgYbdkZbZcid[i]Za^bW# +#(Bdi^dchd[i]Z7dYn

,&

W# 5hdU^cY_^/deedh^iZd[ÅZm^dc0VhigV^\]iZc^c\bdkZbZcii]Vi^cXgZVhZhi]ZVc" \aZWZilZZcWdYneVgih#I]ZXaVhh^X`VgViZX]de^hbVYZWnVg^\^Y]VcY^cl]^X] i]ZÄc\ZghVgZZmiZcYZY#7nXdckZci^dc!ZmiZch^dcVii]Zh]djaYZgdg]^e_d^ci^hV YdghVaWVX`lVgYhl^c\d[i]Za^bW# X# 1RTeSdY_^/bdkZbZcid[VWdYneVgi!jhjVaanVa^bW!VlVn[gdbi]ZhV\^iiVa eaVcZ#L]Zci]ZVgb^hgV^hZYidi]Zh^YZ[gdbhiVcYVgYVcVidb^XVaedh^i^dc! VWYjXi^dcd[i]ZVgbdXXjgh#;dgi]ZheZX^VaXVhZd[Äc\ZghVcYidZh!VWYjXi^dc^h bdkZbZcid[i]ZY^\^iVlVn[gdbi]Zb^Ya^cZd[i]Z]VcYdg[ddihegZVY^c\i]Z Y^\^ih# Y# 1TTeSdY_^/deedh^iZd[VWYjXi^dc0bdkZbZcid[VWdYneVgi!jhjVaanVa^bW! idlVgYi]ZhV\^iiVaeaVcZ#7g^c\^c\i]ZVgbYdlcidhaVei]Zh^YZd[i]Zi]^\]^h VYYjXi^dc#;dgi]ZheZX^VaXVhZd[Äc\ZghVcYidZh!VYYjXi^dc^hbdkZbZcid[i]Z Y^\^iidlVgYi]Zb^Ya^cZd[i]Z]VcYdg[ddiXadh^c\i]ZY^\^ih#  Z# 3YbSe]TeSdY_^/VXdbW^cVi^dcd[VWYjXi^dcVcYVYYjXi^dc!VhlZaaVhÅZm^dc VcYZmiZch^dc!i]VigZhjaih^cVcVeeZcYV\ZWZ^c\bdkZY^cVXdcZ"h]VeZYeVi]# L]Zci]ZYg^kZgd[VhadlkZ]^XaZh^\cVahhdbZdcZWZ]^cY]^bideVhh!i]^h ¹lVk^c\dcº^hd[iZcYdcZWnX^gXjbYjXi^c\i]ZVgb#  [# B_dQdY_^/bdi^dci]VidXXjghVhdcZWdYneVgiijgchdcVcVm^h#I]Z]ZVYd[i]Z gVY^jhgdiViZhdci]ZY^hiVa]jbZgjh# \# ?``_cYdY_^/bdi^dc^cl]^X]WdYneVgihVgZWgdj\]iid\Zi]Zg#Deedh^i^dcd[i]Z i]jbWVcYÄc\Zgi^ehVaadlhjhid\gVhehbVaadW_ZXih#

(ANDSAND&EET V# @b_^QdY_^/gdiVgnbdi^dcd[i]Z[dgZVgbi]Viijgchi]ZeVab[gdbVciZg^dgan [VX^c\i]jbWaViZgVaidedhiZg^dgan[VX^c\i]jbWbZY^Va#IneZlg^iZghVgZjhZY l^i]i]Z]VcY^cegdcVi^dc# W# Ce`Y^QdY_^/deedh^iZd[egdcVi^dc0gdiVgnbdi^dcd[i]Z[dgZVgbi]VigZijgch i]ZeVabidVedh^i^dc^cl]^X]i]Zi]jbW^haViZgVa#L]ZcX]^beVcoZZhWZ\[dg [ddYi]Z]VcY^hd[iZc]ZaY^chje^cVi^dc# X# 4_bcYÎUhY_^/ÅZm^dcd[i]ZZci^gZ[ddiVlVn[gdbi]Z\gdjcY#L]ZcVb^bZ lVa`hdc]Zg]ZZah!]Zg[ZZiVgZYdgh^ÊZmZY# Y# @\Q^dQbÎUhY_^f_\QbÎUhY_^/deedh^iZd[Ydgh^ÅZm^dc0ÅZm^c\d[i]ZZci^gZ[ddi ^c[Zg^dgan!idlVgYi]Z\gdjcYVii]ZVc`aZ#6Xi^dc^cWdi]Ydgh^ÅZm^dcVcYeaVc" iVgÅZm^dcdXXjghVii]ZVc`aZ#L]ZcVWVaaZg^cVlVa`hdc]ZgidZh!]Zg[ZZiVgZ higdc\aneaVciVgÊZmZY#  Z# 5fUbcY_^/ijgc^c\i]ZhdaZd[i]Z[ddidjilVgYhdi]Vi^i[VXZhVlVn[gdbi]Z b^Ya^cZd[i]ZWdYn#6ahd`cdlcVh`b_^QdY_^d[i]Z[ddi#  [# 9^fUbcY_^/ijgc^c\i]ZhdaZd[i]Z[ddi^clVgYhdi]Vi^i[VXZhidlVgYi]Zb^Ya^cZ d[i]ZWdYn#6ahd`cdlcVhce`Y^QdY_^d[i]Z[ddi#

'ENERAL"ONE&EATURES L]ZgZVhi]ZY^gZXi^dchVcYbdi^dchYZhXg^WZY^cHZXi^dch+#'VcY+#(]VkZkZgnegZ" X^hZbZVc^c\h!i]ZhZg^Zhd[\ZcZgVaiZgbhVeea^ZYidWdcn[ZVijgZh^hbdgZVbW^\jdjh 

8]VeiZg+6cVidb^XVaIZgb^cdad\n

VcY Xgdhh"Xjii^c\# ;dg ZmVbeaZ/ i]Z fjZhi^dc¸l]Zc ^h V ijWZgXaZ W^\ Zcdj\] id WZ XVaaZYVijWZgdh^indgVigdX]VciZg¸^hgVgZan[VXZYWni]ZdhiZdad\^hi#I]^h^hWZXVjhZ i]Z XdckZci^dcVa aVWZah [dg kVg^djh WdcZh VcY WdcZ eVgih VgZ ValVnh VYdeiZY id Zc" hjgZhiVW^a^ind[cdbZcXaVijgZVcYZ[[ZXi^kZcZhhd[Xdbbjc^XVi^dc#HeZX^ÄXiZgbh[dg cZVganVaaWdcZhVcYi]Z^geVgihVgZVagZVYnZhiVWa^h]ZY!VcY]VkZWZZc[dgVadc\i^bZ# I]Z¹\gZViZgigdX]VciZgºd[V[Zbjg![dgZmVbeaZ!^YZci^ÄZhVeVgi^XjaVg!jc^fjZhigjX" ijgZ[dgVaa]jbVcdhiZdad\^hih#GZXd\c^oZi]Vii]Z[daadl^c\iZgbhVgZd[iZckV\jZWn i]ZbhZakZh!WjiVgZjcVbW^\jdjhl]ZcXdjeaZYl^i]ZaZbZci"heZX^ÄXcVbZh^cigd" YjXZY^c8]VeiZgh,·&+#

0ROJECTIONSAND0ARTS V# @b_SUcc/VWdcnegdb^cZcXZ#I]ZbVhid^YegdXZhh[dgbhi]Zegdb^cZcXZWZ]^cY i]ZZVg# W# 5]Y^U^SU/VWdcnegd_ZXi^dc0jhjVaancdiVhegdb^cZciVhVegdXZhh#I]ZVgi^Xj" aVgZb^cZcXZd[i]ZiZbedgVaWdcZ^hi]ZgdjcYZYVgZVl^i]l]^X]i]ZbVcY^Wj" aVgXdcYnaZVgi^XjaViZhYjg^c\X]Zl^c\# X# C`Y^U/\ZcZgVaanVadc\Zg!i]^ccZg!h]VgeZgegdXZhhi]VcVcZb^cZcXZ#KZgiZWgVa he^cZhVgZjhZY^ci]Z^YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[kVg^djhkZgiZWgVZ# Y# DeRUb_cYdi/VaVg\Z!jhjVaangj\dhZgdj\]ZcZYZb^cZcXZd[kVg^VWaZh]VeZ0 d[iZcVh^iZd[iZcYdcdga^\VbZciViiVX]bZci#I]ZYZaid^YijWZgdh^inbVg`hi]Z h]V[id[i]Z]jbZgjh#  Z# DeRUbS\U/VhbVaa!jhjVaangj\dhZZb^cZcXZ0d[iZcVh^iZd[iZcYdcdga^\VbZci ViiVX]bZci#I]ZXdcd^YijWZgXaZ^h[djcYVadc\i]Z^c[Zg^dgZY\Zd[i]ZXaVk^XaZ#  [# Db_SXQ^dUbc/ildaVg\Z!egdb^cZci!Wajci!gj\dhZegdXZhhZh[djcYdci]Z[Zbjg# I]ZaVg\Zgd[i]ZhZ^hXVaaZYi]Z\gZViZgigdX]VciZg!i]ZhbVaaZg^hi]ZaZhhZgigd" X]VciZg# \# =Q\\U_\ec/VgdjcYZYegdijWZgVcXZVY_VXZciidi]ZVc`aZ_d^ci#>i^hZVhnideVa" eViZZmVb^cZWnidjX]Wdi]aViZgVaVcYbZY^VabVaaZda^# ]# 2_cc/Vhbddi]!gdjcY!WgdVYZb^cZcXZ#;ZbVaZh`jaahiZcYidh]dlbdgZWdhh^c\ d[i]Z[gdciVaWdcZi]Vci]dhZd[bVaZh#  ^# 1bdYSe\QdY_^/VcVgZVl]ZgZVY_VXZciWdcZhVgZ^cXdciVXik^VXVgi^aV\ZdgÄ" Wgdjhi^hhjZViV_d^ci#I]Zbdhiegdm^bVahjg[VXZd[i]Zi^W^V^hhV^YidVgi^XjaViZ l^i]i]ZY^hiVaZcYd[i]Z[Zbjg#  _# 3_^Ti\U/VgdjcYZYVgi^XjaVgegdXZhh#I]ZdXX^e^iVaXdcYnaZha^Zdci]ZWVhZd[ i]ZXgVc^jbVcYVgi^XjaViZl^i]i]ZjeeZgbdhikZgiZWgV!i]ZViaVh# `# 5`YS_^Ti\U/VcdcVgi^XjaVgegd_ZXi^dcVY_VXZciidVXdcYnaZ#I]ZaViZgVaZe^Xdc" YnaZd[i]Z]jbZgjh^hadXViZY_jhiegdm^bVaidi]ZZaWdl!VY_VXZciidi]ZaViZgVa XdcYnaVghjg[VXZ#  a# 8UQT/VaVg\Z!gdjcYZY!jhjVaanVgi^XjaVgZcYd[VWdcZ#I]Z]ZVYd[i]Z]jbZgjh ^hi]ZhjeZg^dgegdm^bVaZcYd[i]ZWdcZ# b# CXQVd!dgTYQ`XicYc/i]Zadc\!higV^\]ihZXi^dcWZilZZci]ZZcYhd[Vadc\WdcZ# I]Z[ZbdgVah]V[i^hgdj\]anX^gXjaVg^cXgdhhhZXi^dc# c# 5`Y`XicYc/^c\ZcZgVajhV\Z!jhjVaani]ZZcYedgi^dcdgZmigZb^ind[Vadc\WdcZ i]Vi^hZmeVcYZY[dgVgi^XjaVi^dc#I]Zegdm^bVaZe^e]nh^hd[i]Zi^W^V^hi]ZZm" eVcYZYZcYd[i]ZWdcZi]ViVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]Z[Zbjg#HZZ8]VeiZg)[dgbdgZ +#)
,(

egZX^hZYZÄc^i^dchd[i]ZY^Ve]nh^h!Ze^e]nh^h!VcYbZiVe]nh^h# d# >US[/i]ZhZXi^dcd[VWdcZWZilZZci]Z]ZVYVcYi]Zh]V[i#I]ZcZX`d[i]Z[Z" bjg^hadc\gZaVi^kZidi]Zh^oZd[i]Z[ZbdgVa]ZVY^chdbZZVgan]db^c^Yh# e# D_bec/VWdcni]^X`Zc^c\#I]ZhjegVdgW^iVaidgjhdchdbZ=dbdZgZXijh[gdciVa WdcZh^hkZgni]^X`# f# BYTWU/Va^cZVgWdcnZaZkVi^dc!d[iZcgdj\]ZcZY#I]ZaViZgVahjegVXdcYnaVgg^Y\Z d[i]Z]jbZgjhWdgYZghi]ZWdcZVWdkZi]ZaViZgVaZe^XdcYnaZ#  g# 3bUcd/Vegdb^cZci!jhjVaanh]VgeVcYi]^cg^Y\Zd[WdcZ0d[iZc[dgbZYWZilZZc VY_VXZcibjhXaZbVhhZh#I]ZhV\^iiVaXgZhi^hVhigjXijgZi]Vi[dgbhYjg^c\i]Z YZkZadebZcid[aVg\ZiZbedgVa^hbjhXaZh^ci]Z\dg^aaV#  h#
$EPRESSIONS V# 6_ccQ/VYZegZhhZYVgZV0jhjVaanWgdVYVcYh]Vaadl#I]ZdaZXgVcdc[dhhV^hadXViZY dci]ZedhiZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]ZY^hiVa]jbZgjh!l]ZgZ^igZXZ^kZhi]Zegdm^bVa jacVYjg^c\[jaaZmiZch^dcd[i]ZVgb# W# 6_fUQ/Ve^i"a^`Z!YZegZhhZYVgZV0jhjVaanhbVaaZgi]VcV[dhhV#I]ZVciZg^dg[dkZV d[VcjcldgcbdaVg^hhZZc^cdXXajhVak^Zl# X# 7b__fU/Vadc\e^idg[jggdl#I]Z^ciZgijWZgXjaVg\gddkZeVhhZhWZilZZcildij" WZgXaZhdci]Z]jbZgjh# Y# Ce\Sec/Vadc\!l^YZ\gddkZ#6higdc\hjegVidgVahjaXjh^hegZhZcidc6[g^XVcVeZ XgVc^VWji^hlZV`dgVWhZcidc6jhigVade^i]ZXjhXgVc^V#  Z# 6_^dQ^U\\U/VheVXZWZilZZcXgVc^VaWdcZhd[Vc^c[Vci#I]Zhd[ihediVideV WVWn¼h]ZVY^cY^XViZhi]ZegZhZcXZd[V[dciVcZaaZ#  [# CedebU/l]ZgZVY_VXZciWdcZhd[i]Zh`jaabZZiVgi^XjaViZ#I]ZaVbWYd^YVahj" ijgZ^hWZilZZcdXX^e^iVaVcYeVg^ZiVaWdcZh# \# 6_bQ]U^/VcdeZc^c\i]gdj\]VWdcZ!jhjVaanVeVhhV\Z[dgWaddYkZhhZahVcY cZgkZh#I]ZbZciVa[dgVbZc^hVcdeZc^c\dci]ZaViZgVahjg[VXZd[i]ZbVcY^WaZ# ]# 3Q^Q\/VijccZa"a^`Z!ZmiZcYZY[dgVbZc#I]ZXVgdi^YXVcVa^h[djcYVii]ZWVhZd[ i]Zh`jaa#  ^# =UQdec/Vh]dgiXVcVa#I]ZZmiZgcVaVjY^idgnbZVijh^hi]ZXVcVai]ViXdccZXih i]Zb^YYaZVcYdjiZgZVg#  _# CY^ec/VXVk^inl^i]^cVXgVc^VaWdcZ#I]Z[gdciVah^cjh^hlZaaYZkZadeZY^chdbZ ZVgan]db^c^YXgVc^V# `# 1\fU_\ec/Viddi]hdX`Zi#I]ZXVc^cZVakZdajh^ci]ZbVcY^WaZ^hYZZeZgi]Vci]Z ^cX^hdgVakZdajh#



8]VeiZg+6cVidb^XVaIZgb^cdad\n

3+5,,

#HAPTER

H`jaa I

]Zh`jaa^hi]ZbdhiXdbeaZmedgi^dcd[i]Zh`ZaZidcVcY^hd[bV_dg^bedgiVcXZ [dg]jbVcdhiZdad\n#>i^hdcZd[i]Z`ZnhidV\^c\!hZm^c\!VcYjcYZghiVcY^c\i]Z Zkdaji^dcVgn ]^hidgn d[ ]db^c^Yh# I]Z XdbeaZm^in d[ i]Z ]jbVc h`jaa XVc WZhi WZ jcYZghiddY Wn gZXd\c^o^c\ i]Z l^YZan Y^[[Zg^c\ [jcXi^dch ^i eZg[dgbh# >i [dgbh i]Z Wdcn[djcYVi^dc[dgi]ZhZchZhd[h^\]i!hbZaa!iVhiZ!VcY]ZVg^c\#>i]djhZhVcYegdiZXih i]ZWgV^c#>cVYY^i^dc!i]Zh`jaa[dgbhi]Z[gVbZldg`d[i]ZX]Zl^c\VeeVgVijh#<^kZc i]ZhZkVg^ZY[jcXi^dch!^i^hcdldcYZgi]Vii]Zh`jaa^hVXdbeaZmhigjXijgZ# 7Z[dgZbdk^c\idVYZiV^aZYXdch^YZgVi^dcd[i]Z^cY^k^YjVaWdcZhd[i]Zh`jaa!^i ^hjhZ[jaidXdch^YZgi]^heVgid[i]ZVcVidbnVhVjc^i;^\jgZh,#&·,#+W#6[ZlXdc" kZc^ZciaVcYbVg`hVgZjhZ[ja^ci]^hVcVanh^h#I]ZZnZhdX`ZihVgZi]Z_bRYdc#I]Z]daZ WZilZZcVcYWZadli]ZdgW^ih!i]ZcdhZ]daZ!^hi]ZQ^dUbY_b^QcQ\Q`UbdebU!dg`YbY V_b]Q`UbdebU#I]ZZVg]daZhVgZUhdUb^Q\QeTYd_bi]UQdYi]Zh^c\jaVg^h]UQdec! VcYi]ZaVg\ZdkVa]daZ^ci]ZWVhZd[i]Zh`jaa^hi]ZV_bQ]U^]QW^e]#I]Zi]^c WdcnWg^Y\ZhVii]Zh^YZhd[i]Zh`jaaVgZi]ZjiW_]QdYSQbSXUc#I]ZiZZi]VgZeVgid[ i]Zh`jaa!WjiWZXVjhZd[i]Z^g^bedgiVcXZVcYeZXja^VgVcVidbnVcZci^gZX]VeiZg^h YZkdiZYidi]ZbhZZ8]VeiZg-#

(ANDLINGTHE3KULL >cVYY^i^dcidWZ^c\dcZd[i]ZbdhiXdbeaZmeVgihd[i]Zh`ZaZidc!hdbZd[i]ZZaZbZcih d[i]Zh`jaaVgZVahdi]ZbdhiYZa^XViZ#9jg^c\hijYn!i]Zh`jaah]djaYWZ]VcYaZYVWdkZ VeVYYZYhjg[VXZVcYhiVW^a^oZYV\V^chigdaa^c\dci]Zhjg[VXZWnbZVchd[hVcYWV\hdg Xadi]g^c\hYZh^\cZY[dgi]^hejgedhZ#>i^hgVgZancZXZhhVgnidhidgZdgbVc^ejaViZi]Z adlZg_Vl^c^ihcVijgVaVcVidb^XVaedh^i^dcgZaVi^kZidi]ZjeeZg_Vl#L]Zci]^hedh^" i^dc^hXVaaZY[dg!]dlZkZg!cdiZi]Vii]ZXdaa^Y^c\jeeZgVcYadlZgiZZi]VgZ[gV\^aZVcY hjhXZei^WaZidX]^ee^c\#8VgZh]djaYWZZmZgX^hZYl]ZcdXXajY^c\i]ZjeeZgVcYadlZg _Vlh^ci]^h[Vh]^dc!VcYeVYY^c\h]djaYValVnhWZeaVXZYWZilZZci]ZiZZi]^[i]Zh`jaa ^hhidgZY^ci]^hedh^i^dc# >c ]VcYa^c\ i]Z h`jaa! ValVnh jhZ Xdbbdc hZchZ VcY Wdi] ]VcYh# 6 Äc\Zg dg i]jbWeaVXZY^cVcYWZ]^cYi]Z[dgVbZcbV\cjbl^aacdiYVbV\Zi]ZWdcZ!Wjidi]" ZgdeZc^c\h!hjX]Vhi]ZdgW^ihdgon\dbVi^XVgX]Zh!VgZbdgZ[gV\^aZVcYh]djaYcZkZg WZ jhZY Vh \g^ee^c\ hjg[VXZh# >c VYY^i^dc id i]Z i]^c WdcZh l^i]^c i]Z dgW^ih! i]dhZ YZa^XViZeVgihi]ViVgZhjhXZei^WaZidYVbV\ZYjg^c\XgVc^VabVc^ejaVi^dc^cXajYZi]Z ZY\ZhVcY^ch^YZhd[i]ZcVhVaVeZgijgZVcYi]Zi]^c!egd_ZXi^c\eiZgn\d^YeaViZhVcY ,*

&IGURE1Te\d]Q\Uc[e\\\QdUbQ\CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg,H`jaa

%LEMENTSOFTHE3KULL I]ZiZgb¹h`jaaºhj[[Zgh[gdbXdbbdcb^hjhZ#>i^hldgi]" l]^aZidgZk^Zli]ZegdeZgjhZd[XgVc^VaiZgb^cdad\n#

 ™  ™  ™  ™  ™  ™  ™

I]Zc[e\\^hi]ZZci^gZWdcn[gVbZldg`d[i]Z]ZVY! ^cXajY^c\i]ZadlZg_Vl# I]Z]Q^TYR\U^hi]ZadlZg_Vl# I]ZSbQ^Ye]^hi]Zh`jaal^i]djii]ZbVcY^WaZ# I]ZSQ\fQbYQ^hi]ZXgVc^jbl^i]djii]Z[VXZ# I]ZSQ\_ddU^hi]ZXVakVg^Vl^i]djii]ZWVhZ# I]Zc`\Q^SX^_SbQ^Ye]^hi]Z[VX^Vah`ZaZidc# I]Z^Ueb_SbQ^Ye]^hi]ZWgV^cXVhZ#

I]Z i]gZZ WVh^X Y^k^h^dch d[ i]Z ZcYdXgVc^Va hjg[VXZ Vi i]Z WVhZ d[ i]Z cZjgdXgVc^jb XdggZhedcY id i]Z id" ed\gVe]nd[i]ZWVhZd[i]ZWgV^c#I]ZhZVciZg^dg!b^YYaZ! VcYedhiZg^dgXgVc^Va[dhhVZVgZgZheZXi^kZandXXje^ZYWn i]Z [gdciVa adWZh! iZbedgVa adWZh! VcY XZgZWZaajb d[ i]Z WgV^c# L]Zci]ZZVgdhh^XaZhi]gZZeV^ghd[i^cnWdcZhVhhdX^" ViZYl^i]]ZVg^c\VgZ^cXajYZYVcYi]Z]nd^YZmXajYZY! i]ZgZVgZjhjVaanilZcin"Z^\]iWdcZh^ci]ZVYjai]jbVc h`jaa# 9^hi^c\j^h]^c\ i]ZhZ WdcZh ^h dXXVh^dcVaan bVYZ Y^[ÄXjaiWZXVjhZhdbZd[i]Zb[jhZid\Zi]ZgYjg^c\VYjai a^[Z# ;dg i]^h gZVhdc! ^i ^h VYk^hVWaZ id WZ\^c hijYn l^i] ndjc\VYjaiheZX^bZch!^cl]^X]i]ZWdcZhVgZbdhigZVY" ^angZXd\c^oVWaZ#7dcZhd[i]Zh`jaaVgZa^hiZY^c;^\jgZ,#- VXXdgY^c\idl]Zi]Zgi]ZnVgZh^c\aZjceV^gZYdgeV^gZY ^ci]ZVYjaih`jaa#>cVYY^i^dcidi]ZWdcZha^hiZY^c;^\jgZ ,#-! i]ZgZ VgZ d[iZc hjijgVa WdcZh Vahd XVaaZY G_b]YQ^ R_^Uc!dgUhdbQcedebQ\R_^Uc!^ggZ\jaVgdhh^XaZhdXXjg" g^c\Vadc\hjijgZh#6aVg\Z!ig^Vc\jaVgY^SQR_^U^hdXXV" h^dcVaan[djcYVii]ZgZVgd[]jbVcXgVc^V# ,#':aZbZcihd[i]ZH`jaa

,,

3+5,,

hinad^YegdXZhhZhVii]ZWVhZd[i]Zh`jaa#>[iZZi]WZXdbZ Y^hadY\ZYYjg^c\hijYn!gZeaVXZi]Zb^bbZY^ViZan^ci]Z XdggZXihdX`Zih# I]Z iZbeiVi^dc id iZhi i]Z bZX]Vc^XVa egdeZgi^Zh d[ Ygn WdcZ Wn egdW^c\! il^hi^c\! ed`^c\! hiVWW^c\! VcY hXgVe^c\h]djaYValVnhWZgZh^hiZY#=dlZkZg!^ci]ZXdjghZ d[ ]VcYa^c\ dhiZdad\^XVa bViZg^Va! WgZV`V\Z YdZh dXXjg# ;dgijcViZan! ^i ^h cdgbVaan V h^beaZ bViiZg id \ajZ i]Z WdcZWVX`id\Zi]Zg#I]^hh]djaYWZYdcZegdbeianWni]Z aVWdgVidgn hjeZgk^hdg hd i]Vi i]Z Wgd`Zc e^ZXZh VgZ cdi adhieZgbVcZcianhZZ8]VeiZg&-#

&IGURE1Te\d]Q\Uc[e\\Q^dUbY_bCVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg,H`jaa

3+5,,

&IGURE1Te\d]Q\Uc[e\\`_cdUbY_bCVijgVah^oZ#

,#':aZbZcihd[i]ZH`jaa

,.

&IGURE1Te\d]Q\USbQ^Ye]ce`UbY_bCVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg,H`jaa

3+5,,

&IGURE1Te\d]Q\USbQ^Ye]Y^VUbY_bCVijgVah^oZ#

,#':aZbZcihd[i]ZH`jaa

-&

&IGUREA1Te\d]Q\USbQ^Ye]U^T_SbQ^YQ\hjeZg^dgeVgi#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg,H`jaa

3+5,,

&IGUREB1Te\d]Q\USbQ^Ye]U^T_SbQ^YQ\^c[Zg^dgeVgi#CVijgVah^oZ#

,#':aZbZcihd[i]ZH`jaa

-(

'ROWTHAND!RCHITECTURE 3UTURESAND3INUSES 6iW^gi]i]Zh`jaa^hbVYZjed[[dgin"ÄkZhZeVgViZZaZbZcihVcY^haVg\ZgZaVi^kZid di]Zg eVgih d[ i]Z WdYn# I]Z [VX^Va eVgi d[ i]Z cZlWdgc h`jaa! ]dlZkZg! ^h gZaVi^kZan hbVaa!gZÅZXi^c\i]ZYdb^cVcXZd[WgV^cYZkZadebZciVii]^hhiV\Zd[bVijgVi^dc#I]Z [VXZ¹XViX]Zhjeºidi]ZcZjgdXgVc^jbVhYZkZadebZci!eVgi^XjaVgan^ci]ZbVcY^WaZ VcYbVm^aaV!egdXZZYh#>bedgiVcihiV\Zh^ci]ZYZkZadebZcid[i]Zh`jaa^cXajYZZbZg" \ZcXZd[i]ZÄghihZid[iZZi]WZilZZci]ZV\Zhd[+VcY')bdci]h!i]ZZbZg\ZcXZd[

NEWBORN

&IGURE
THREEYEARS

SIXYEARS



8]VeiZg,H`jaa

YOUNGADULT

ELDERLYADULT

,#(
-*

3+5,,

i]ZeZgbVcZciiZZi]WZ\^cc^c\ViVWdji+nZVgh!VcYejWZgin#;^\jgZ,#,^aajhigViZh \gdli]d[i]Zh`jaa# 6iW^gi]i]Zh`jaaXdciV^ch^ciZgkVahd[YZchZXdccZXi^kZi^hhjZWZilZZceaViZhd[ WdcZ#I]ZhZ¹hd[ihedih!ºdgV_^dQ^U\\Uc!VgZXVgi^aV\^cdjhbZbWgVcZhi]ViZkZcijVaan ]VgYZcVcYijgcidWdcZ#>ci]ZVYjaii]Zh`jaaWdcZhXdciVXiVadc\_d^cihl^i]^ciZg" adX`^c\!hVliddi]!dgo^eeZg"a^`ZVgi^XjaVi^dchXVaaZYcedebUc#8gVc^VaVgi^XjaVi^dch^c i]ZVYjai]jbVch`jaaVgZhjbbVg^oZY^c;^\jgZ,#-#BVcnd[i]ZhZhjijgZhYZg^kZi]Z^g cVbZY^gZXian[gdbi]ZildWdcZhi]ViXdciVXiVXgdhhi]Zb#;dgZmVbeaZ!jiW_]QdYS_ ]QhY\\QbicedebUcVgZhjijgZhWZilZZci]Zon\dbVi^XhVcYbVm^aaVZ!VcYVb_^d_^QcQ\ cedebUcVgZh]dgihjijgZhWZilZZci]Z[gdciVaVcYcVhVah#HdbZhjijgZh]VkZheZX^Va cVbZh#I]ZcQWYddQ\cedebUeVhhZhYdlci]Zb^Ya^cZWZilZZci]ZeVg^ZiVaWdcZh#I]Z ]Ud_`YScedebUeVhhZhWZilZZcjc[jhZY[gdciVa]VakZhVcYdcangVgZaneZgh^hih^cid

/. 4! 0! , 2)% 4 4% !, -0 /2 /# !, #)0 )4! -! , 8), ,! 0! ,! 4). 6/ % -% 2 ). &% 2)/ %4 2. (!3 / ,! !, ) $ #2 #/ ) -! .! .# , 3! (! , :9 '/ -! 30 4)# (% . -! /) $ .$ )", %

&2

&2/.4!, 0!2)%4!, 4%-0/2!, /##)0)4!, -!8),,! 0!,!4).% 6/-%2 ).&.!3!,#/.#(! %4(-/)$ ,!#2)-!, .!3!, :9'/-!4)# 30(%./)$ -!.$)",%

ARTICULATION SOMETIMESARTICULATES ARTICULATINGPAIR UNPAIREDELEMENT

&IGURE6gi^XjaVi^dcd[WdcZh^ci]Z]jbVch`jaa#

VYjai]ddY#I]ZS_b_^Q\cedebUa^ZhWZilZZci]Z[gdciVaVcYeVg^ZiVah#I]Z\Q]RT_Y TQ\cedebUeVhhZhWZilZZci]ZildeVg^ZiVahVcYi]ZdXX^e^iVa#CaeQ]_cQ\cedebUcVgZ jcjhjVa!hXVaZ"a^`Z!WZkZaZYhjijgZhWZilZZciZbedgVaVcYeVg^ZiVaWdcZh#I]Zc`XU^_ _SSY`YdQ\!dgRQcY\QbcedebUVXijVaanVhncX]dcYgdh^ha^ZhWZilZZci]Zhe]Zcd^YVcY i]ZdXX^e^iVa#@QbYUd_]Qcd_YTcedebUceVhhWZilZZci]ZeVg^ZiVahVcYi]ZiZbedgVah! Xdchi^iji^c\edhiZg^dgZmiZch^dchd[i]ZhfjVbdhVahjijgZ#?SSY`Yd_]Qcd_YTcedebUc eVhhWZilZZci]ZdXX^e^iVaVcYiZbedgVahdcZ^i]Zgh^YZd[i]ZkVjai# CY^ecUcVgZkd^YX]VbWZgh^ci]ZXgVc^VaWdcZhi]ViZcaVg\Zl^i]i]Z\gdli]d[ i]Z[VXZ#I]ZgZVgZ[djgWVh^XhZihd[h^cjhZh!dcZZVX]^ci]ZbVm^aaVZ![gdciVa!Zi]bd^Y! VcYhe]Zcd^Y#I]ZhZh^cjhZhVgZa^c`ZYidi]ZcVhVaXVk^inVcY!^ca^[Z!^gg^iVi^dcd[i]Z^g bjXdjhbZbWgVcZhbVnXVjhZhlZaa^c\!YgV^c^c\!VcY]ZVYVX]Z"gZaViZYY^hXdb[dgi#

3KULL/RIENTATION I]ZbdhijhZ[jaVcY^c[dgbVi^kZXdbeVg^hdchWZilZZch`jaahd[Y^[[ZgZci^cY^k^Yj" VahVgZjhjVaanXdbeVg^hdchbVYZl]ZcWdi]h`jaahVgZ^ci]ZhVbZdg^ZciVi^dc#I]Z XdckZci^dcjhZY^cdg^Zci^c\i]Zh`jaa^hi]Z6bQ^[Vebd8_bYj_^dQ\68!cVbZY[dg i]ZX^in^cl]^X]i]ZXdckZci^dclVhZhiVWa^h]ZY^c&--)#I]Z;gVc`[jgi=dg^odciVa^h VeaVcZYZÄcZYWni]gZZed^cih/i]Zg^\]iVcYaZ[i`_bY_^ed^cihVcYi]ZaZ[i_bRYdQ\U# I]ZhZdhiZdbZig^Xed^cihVgZVii]Zided[ZVX]ZmiZgcVaVjY^idgnbZVijhVcYi]ZWdi" idbd[i]ZaZ[idgW^i# H`jaahVgZcdgbVaank^ZlZY[gdbh^mhiVcYVgYeZgheZXi^kZh!Vaa^c;gVc`[jgi=dg^" odciVaVh^aajhigViZY^c;^\jgZh,#&·,#*#K^ZlZY[gdbVWdkZ!i]Zh`jaa^hhZZc^c^_b]Q fUbdYSQ\Yc#L]Zck^ZlZY[gdbZ^i]Zgh^YZ!i]Zh`jaa^hhZZc^c^_b]Q\QdUbQ\Yc#>_b]Q _SSY`YdQ\Yc^hi]ZedhiZg^dgk^Zld[i]Zh`jaa#K^ZlZY[gdbi]Z[gdcii]Zh`jaa^hhZZc ^c^_b]QVb_^dQ\Yc0k^ZlZY[gdbi]ZWVhZ^i^hhZZc^c^_b]QRQcY\QbYc#6aad[i]ZhZ k^Zlh VgZ eZgeZcY^XjaVg dg eVgVaaZa id i]Z ;gVc`[jgi =dg^odciVa# 6 XdchiZaaVi^dc d[ _cdU_]UdbYS`_Y^dc^hjhZYidgZedgiVcYXdbeVgZh`jaah]VeZhVcYh^oZh#HZZBVgi^c VcYHVaaZg&.*,VcYL]^iZVcY;da`Zch'%%%[dgi]Z^gYZÄc^i^dch# 

8]VeiZg,H`jaa

3+5,,

,EARNING#RANIAL3KELETAL!NATOMY IdaZVgcXgVc^Vah`ZaZiVaVcVidbn!VeegdVX]i]Zh`jaahnhiZbVi^XVaan#;^ghi!hijYni]Z h`jaad[Vndjc\VYjai!dWhZgk^c\VaahjijgZhWZilZZci]ZWdcZh#I]Zc!hijYnV\gdli] hZg^Zh!cdi^c\]dlZVX]WdcZVcYhjijgZX]Vc\ZhYjg^c\dcid\Zcn#;^cVaan!jhZi]ZYZ" hXg^ei^dch^cHZXi^dch,#+·,#'%idaZVgci]Z[ZVijgZhd[ZVX]WdcZd[i]Zh`jaa#I]ZhZ [ZVijgZh VgZ i]Z `Znh id Y^V\cdh^c\ kVg^djh WdcZh d[ i]Z h`jaa Wn ZaZbZci VcY h^YZ# >ciVXiXgVc^VaWdcZh]VkZgVi]Zgjc^fjZbdge]dad\^Zh#Ndjl^aagVgZan]VkZY^[ÄXjain ^YZci^[n^c\i]Zb# 7ZXVjhZi]ZkVg^djhWdcZhd[i]Zh`jaaVgZd[iZc[djcY^cVY^hVgi^XjaViZYdg[gV\" bZciVgnhiViZ!ZVX]WdcZdgeV^gd[WdcZhbjhiWZ\^kZc^cY^k^YjVaXdch^YZgVi^dc#Id ^YZci^[nVcYh^YZ[gV\bZcihd[i]ZXgVc^jb![daadli]ZhZhiZeh/9ZiZgb^cZl]Zi]Zgi]Z e^ZXZ^hXgVc^VakVjaidg[VXZ#CdiZVcnWaddYkZhhZa^begZhh^dch!hjijgZh![dgVb^cV!hjg" [VXZiZmijgZh!WdcZi]^X`cZhhX]Vc\Zh!bjhXaZViiVX]bZcih!h^cjhlVaah!dgiddi]gddih dghdX`Zih#CdiZi]Zi]^X`cZhhd[i]Ze^ZXZVcY^ihXgdhh"hZXi^dcVaVcVidbnVii]ZWgZV`! ^cXajY^c\h^cjhYZkZadebZci#8VgZ[jaancdiZi]Zbdge]dad\nd[Vcnk^h^WaZhjijgZh#

&RONTAL&IGURES n !NATOMY I]Z[gdciVa^hadXViZYVii]Z[gdcid[i]ZcZjgdXgVc^jb#>iVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]ZeVg^ZiVah! cVhVah!bVm^aaVZ!he]Zcd^Y!Zi]bd^Y!aVXg^bVah!VcYon\dbVi^Xh#I]Z[gdciVa^hdcZd[ i]ZaVg\ZhiVcYbdhigdWjhiXgVc^VaWdcZh#>iXdch^hihd[ild\ZcZgVaeVgih!dcZkZgi^XVa VcYdcZ]dg^odciVa# V# I]ZkZgi^XVaVb_^dQ\caeQ]Q[dgbhi]Z[dgZ]ZVY# W# I]ZX_bYj_^dQ\`_bdY_^VXihidgdd[i]ZdgW^ihVcYidÅddgi]Z[gdciVaadWZhd[ i]ZWgV^c# X# 6b_^dQ\U]Y^U^SUcVb_^dQ\deRUbc!dgR_ccUcYdb^cViZi]ZZXidXgVc^Vahjg[VXZ# I]ZhZeV^gZY[gdciVaWdhhZhbVg`i]ZadXVi^dcd[i]Zdg^\^cVaXZciZghd[dhh^ÄXV" i^dcd[i]^hWdcZ# Y# DU]`_bQ\\Y^Ucdci]ZaViZgVaZXidXgVc^Vahjg[VXZbVg`i]ZViiVX]bZcid[i]Z iZbedgVa^hbjhXaZ!VbV_dgZaZkVidgd[i]ZbVcY^WaZ!VcY^ihXdkZg^c\!i]ZiZbedgVa [VhX^V!V[VhX^Vah]ZZii]ViXdkZghi]ZiZbedgVa^h#I]ZiZbedgVaa^cZYZÄcZhi]Z hjeZg^dgZY\Zd[i]ZiZbedgVahjg[VXZVcY[dhhV#I]^ha^cZWZXdbZhVXgZhi^c^ih ,#+;gdciVa

-,

FRONTAL SQUAMA FRONTAL EMINENCE

SUPERCILIARY ARCH SUPRAORBITAL MARGIN SUPRAORBITAL NOTCH

METOPICSUTURE FRONTALSUTURE

&IGURE6b_^dQ\Q^dUbY_bZXidXgVc^Va#CVijgVah^oZ#

VciZg^dg!aViZgVaZmiZcidci]Zon\dbVi^XegdXZhhd[i]Z[gdciVa#>id[iZcY^k^YZh ^cidhjeZg^dgVcY^c[Zg^dga^cZhVh^ihlZZehedhiZg^dgan#  Z# JiW_]QdYS`b_SUccUc[dgbi]ZbdhiaViZgVaVcYVciZg^dgXdgcZghd[i]Z[gdciVa#  [# Ce`UbSY\YQbiQbSXUcWgdlg^Y\ZhVgZi]ZWdcnidg^dkZgi]ZdgW^ih#I]ZnVgZ bdhiegdb^cZci^cbVaZhVcYVgZhdbZi^bZh_d^cZYWnVegdb^cZci\aVWZaaVggZ" \^dc# \# Ce`bQ_bRYdQ\]QbWY^cVgZi]ZjeeZgdgW^iVaZY\Zh#I]ZhZVgZcdiX]ZYdge^ZgXZY Wni]ZhjegVdgW^iVacdiX]dg[dgVbZc# ]# Ce`bQ_bRYdQ\^_dSXUcdgV_bQ]Y^Q!^[i]ZcdiX]ZhVgZWg^Y\ZYVgZhZiVadc\i]Z bZY^Va]Va[d[i]ZhjeZg^dgdgW^iVag^b#I]ZnigVchb^ii]ZhjegVdgW^iVakZhhZahVcY hjegVdgW^iVacZgkZVhi]ZneVhhhjeZg^dganidi]Z[dgZ]ZVYgZ\^dc#  ^# I]Z]Ud_`YScedebUVb_^dQ\cedebU^hVkZgi^XVahjijgZWZilZZcg^\]iVcYaZ[i [gdciVa]VakZh#>iheZgh^hiZcXZ^hkVg^VWaZ!WjidcandXXVh^dcVaanYdZh^iaVhi^cid VYjai]ddY#IgVXZhd[^iVgZdWhZgkZYbdhid[iZc^ci]Z\aVWZaaVggZ\^dc^cVYjaih#  _# =U^Y^WUQ\Wb__fUc[dgi]Zb^YYaZbZc^c\ZVaVgiZg^ZhVgZegZhZcidcWdi]h^YZhd[ i]ZXdcXVkZZcYdXgVc^Vahjg[VXZd[i]Z[gdciVahfjVbV#I]ZWgV^c^hXdkZgZYl^i] 

8]VeiZg,H`jaa

3+5,,

TEMPORALLINE

&IGURE6b_^dQ\\UVd\QdUbQ\ZXidXgVc^Va#CVijgVah^oZ#

Vidj\]djiZgegdiZXi^kZbZbWgVcZ!i]ZYjgVbViZg!l]dhZWaddYhjeeanXdbZh [gdbi]ZbZc^c\ZVaVgiZg^Zh# `# I]ZcQWYddQ\ce\Sec^hVkZgi^XVa\gddkZi]VigjchYdlci]Zb^Ya^cZd[i]ZZcYd" XgVc^Vahjg[VXZ#>iadY\Zhi]ZhjeZg^dghV\^iiVah^cjh!VaVg\ZkZhhZai]ViYgV^chWaddY [gdbi]ZWgV^c#  a# I]ZVb_^dQ\SbUcd^hVb^Ya^cZXgZhiXdcÅjZcil^i]i]ZVciZg^dgZcYd[i]ZhV\^iiVa hjaXjh#I]^hXgZhi\^kZhViiVX]bZciidi]Z[VamXZgZWg^!Vhigdc\bZbWgVcZWZilZZc i]ZildXZgZWgVa]Zb^he]ZgZhd[i]ZWgV^c# b# I]ZV_bQ]U^SUSe]!V[dgVbZcd[kVgn^c\h^oZ!^h[djcYVii]Zgddi!dgWVhZ!d[ i]Z[gdciVaXgZhiVcYigVchb^ihVhbVaakZ^c[gdbi]Z[gdciVah^cjhidi]ZhjeZg^dg hV\^iiVah^cjh# c# 1bQSX^_YTV_fUQUWbQ^e\QbV_fUQUVgZZheZX^VaanVeeVgZcicZVgi]ZXdgdcVa hjijgZVadc\i]ZZcYdXgVc^Vab^Ya^cZ#I]ZnVgZ[ZVijgZhVhhdX^ViZYl^i]Vcdi]Zg XdkZg^c\aVnZgd[i]ZWgV^c!i]ZVgVX]cd^Y!l]^X]^hVYZa^XViZ!VkVhXjaVgbZbWgVcZ an^c\WZcZVi]i]ZYjgVbViZg#Ij[ihd[VgVX]cd^Y!i]ZVgVX]cd^Y\gVcjaVi^dch!ejh] djilVgYV\V^chii]ZYjgV!XVjh^c\gZhdgei^dcd[i]ZWdcZVcYi]Z[dgbVi^dcd[ ,#+;gdciVa

-.

ARACHNOIDFOVEAE

SAGITTAL SULCUS

MENINGEAL GROOVES FRONTALCREST HORIZONTAL PORTION ZYGOMATIC PROCESS FORAMENCECUM &IGURE6b_^dQ\`_cdUbY_bZcYdXgVc^Va#CVijgVah^oZ#

LACRIMALFOSSA FRONTALSINUS PARSORBITALIS ETHMOIDAL NOTCH

&IGURE6b_^dQ\Y^VUbY_bZXidXgVc^Va#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg,H`jaa

e# f#  g#

'ROWTH I]Z[gdciVadhh^ÄZh^cbZbWgVcZ[gdbildeg^bVgnXZciZgh#6iW^gi]i]ZhZXZciZghVgZ hZeVgViZ#I]Zn[jhZVadc\i]ZbZide^XhjijgZb^Ya^cZ!jhjVaanYjg^c\VX]^aY¼hhZXdcY nZVg#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION

 ™

L]Zc[gV\bZciVgn!i]Z[gdciVa^hXdc[jhZYbdhid[iZcl^i]i]ZeVg^ZiVah#I]Z bZc^c\ZVa^begZhh^dchVgZaVg\ZgVcYbdgZYZchZdci]ZeVg^ZiVah!VcYi]ZZcYd" XgVc^Vahjg[VXZhd[i]ZeVg^ZiVahVgZaZhhjcYjaVi^c\i]Vci]dhZd[i]Z[gdciVa#  ™ I]Z[gdciVa^hi]ZdcanbV_dgkVjaiWdcZl^i]VhjWhiVci^Vah^cjhVcYVY_VXZcidg" W^iVag^bh#

3IDING >hdaViZY[gV\bZcihd[[gdciVahfjVbVbVnWZY^[ÄXjaiidh^YZ#H^Y^c\i]Z[gdciVadgVcn di]ZgWdcZdgiddi]!l]Zi]Zg[gV\bZciVgndg^ciVXi!^hd[iZch^bea^ÄZYWn]daY^c\i]Z ZaZbZci^c^ihXdggZXidg^ZciVi^dcVY_VXZciidi]VigZ\^dcd[ndjgdlch`jaa#>cdi]Zg ldgYh!ViiZbeiid^bV\^cZi]Z[gV\bZciÄii^c\^cidndjgdlcVcVidbn#I]ZXdgdcVa hjijgZ^hedhiZg^dgVcYXdjghZhVciZgdaViZgVaan!idlVgYi]Z[VXZ![gdbWgZ\bV^ciZghZX" i^dcd[XdgdcVaVcYhV\^iiVahjijgZh#I]^hbZVchi]Vii]ZhV\^iiVaVcYXdgdcVahjijgZh YdcdibZZiVig^\]iVc\aZh#I]^h[VXiXVcWZkZgnjhZ[ja^ch^Y^c\[gV\bZcihd[[gdciVa hfjVbV#

 ™ I]ZVciZgdbZY^VaaneaVXZY[gdciVah^cjh^hd[iZcZmedhZY^cWgd`Zce^ZXZh#  ™ I]ZZXidXgVc^VaaneaVXZYiZbedgVaa^cZhhl^c\bZY^VaanVcYlZV`ZcedhiZg^dgan#

,#+;gdciVa

.&

3+5,,

d#

[dkZVZdci]ZZcYdXgVc^Vahjg[VXZ#DcWdi]h^YZhd[i]Zb^Ya^cZi]ZZcYdXgVc^Va hjg[VXZd[i]Z[gdciVaWZVghYZegZhh^dch[dgXdckdaji^dchd[i]Z[gdciVaadWZhd[i]Z WgV^c# I]Z`Qbc_bRYdQ\Yc!dg_bRYdQ\`\QdU!^hi]Z]dg^odciVaedgi^dchd[i]Z[gdciVa#>ih ZcYdXgVc^Vahjg[VXZh^hjcYjaVi^c\Wjben!Xdc[dgb^c\idi]Z^c[Zg^dghjg[VXZd[ i]Z[gdciVaadWZ#>ih^c[Zg^dghjg[VXZdgW^iVahjg[VXZ^hhbddi]ZgVcYXdcXVkZ#
0ARIETALS&IGURESn !NATOMY I]ZeVg^ZiVah[dgbi]Zh^YZhVcYgdd[d[i]ZXgVc^VakVjai#:VX]eVg^ZiVaVgi^XjaViZhl^i] i]Zdeedh^iZeVg^ZiVaVcYl^i]i]Z[gdciVa!iZbedgVa!dXX^e^iVa!VcYhe]Zcd^Y#EVg^ZiVahVgZ WVh^XVaanhfjVgZVcYVgZi]ZaVg\ZhiWdcZhd[i]ZkVjai!l^i]V[V^ganjc^[dgbi]^X`cZhh# V# I]ZVb_^dQ\Q^W\U^hadXViZYViWgZ\bV# W# I]Zc`XU^_YTQ\Q^W\U^hadXViZYVieiZg^dcl]ZgZi]Zhe]Zcd^Y!eVg^ZiVa!iZbed" gVa!VcY[gdciVaWdcZhXdckZg\Z#

PARIETAL FORAMEN FRONTAL ANGLE OCCIPITAL ANGLE

PARIETAL TUBER SUPERIOR TEMPORAL LINE INFERIOR TEMPORAL LINE

PARIETAL STRIAE

MASTOID ANGLE

SPHENOIDAL ANGLE

&IGUREBYWXd`QbYUdQ\\QdUbQ\ZXidXgVc^Va#6ciZg^dg^hidlVgYi]Zg^\]i!hjeZg^dg^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg,H`jaa

SAGITTALSULCUS ARACHNOID FOVEAE

MENINGEAL GROOVES

,#,EVg^ZiVah SIGMOID TRANSVERSE SULCUS

&IGUREBYWXd`QbYUdQ\]UTYQ\ZcYdXgVc^Va#6ciZg^dg^hidlVgYi]ZaZ[i!hjeZg^dg^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

,#,EVg^ZiVah

.(

3+5,,

X# I]Z_SSY`YdQ\Q^W\U^hadXViZYViaVbWYV^ciZghZXi^dcd[hV\^iiVaVcYaVbWYd^YVa hjijgZh# Y# I]Z]Qcd_YTQ^W\U^hadXViZYViVhiZg^dcl]ZgZi]ZaVbWYd^YVahjijgZXdciVXih i]ZiZbedgVa#  Z# I]Z`QbYUdQ\deRUbR_ccU]Y^U^SU^hi]ZaVg\Z!gdjcYZYZb^cZcXZXZciZgZYdc i]ZZXidXgVc^Vahjg[VXZd[i]ZeVg^ZiVa#>ibVg`hi]ZXZciZgd[dhh^ÄXVi^dcd[i]ZWdcZ#  [# DU]`_bQ\\Y^UcYdb^cViZi]ZZXidXgVc^Vahjg[VXZ!VgX]^c\VciZgdedhiZg^dgan# \# I]Zce`UbY_bdU]`_bQ\\Y^UVcX]dghi]ZiZbedgVa[VhX^V# ]# I]ZY^VUbY_bdU]`_bQ\\Y^U^cY^XViZhi]ZbdhihjeZg^dgZmiZcid[i]ZiZbedgVa^h bjhXaZ#  ^# L]ZcegZhZci!i]Z`QbYUdQ\V_bQ]U^^hadXViZYXadhZidi]ZhV\^iiVahjijgZcZVg aVbWYV#>iigVchb^ihVhbVaakZ^ci]gdj\]i]ZeVg^ZiVaidi]ZhjeZg^dghV\^iiVah^cjh#  _# I]Z`QbYUdQ\cdbYQUVgZhig^Vi^dch!dg¹gVnh!ºi]VieVhhedhiZgdhjeZg^dgan[dghdbZ Y^hiVcXZdci]ZZXidXgVc^Vahjg[VXZd[i]ZeVg^ZiVa[gdbi]Z^gdg^\^cdc^ihWZkZaZY hfjVbdhVaZY\Z# `# =U^Y^WUQ\Wb__fUc[dgb^YYaZbZc^c\ZVaVgiZg^ZhYdb^cViZi]ZZcYdXgVc^Va hjg[VXZd[i]ZeVg^ZiVa#I]ZhZVgiZg^Zhhjeeani]ZYjgVbViZg#I]ZbdhiVciZg^dg WgVcX]eVgVaaZahi]ZXdgdcVaZY\Zd[i]ZeVg^ZiVa!VcYbdhid[i]ZWgVcX]ZhigV"

kZghZi]ZWdcZidlVgY^ihdXX^e^iVaVc\aZ#  a# I]ZcQWYddQ\ce\Sec^hbVYZl]Zci]ZeVg^ZiVahVgZVgi^XjaViZYVcYi]Zh]Vaadl \gddkZhVadc\i]ZhV\^iiVaZY\Zd[ZVX]eVg^ZiVaXdbW^cZVadc\i]ZZcYdXgVc^Va b^Ya^cZ#I]^hhjaXjh^hVedhiZg^dgXdci^cjVi^dcd[i]ZhVbZ[ZVijgZdci]Z[gdciVa# b# 1bQSX^_YTV_fUQUWbQ^e\QbV_fUQUVgZXdcXZcigViZYZcYdXgVc^VaanVadc\i]Z VciZg^dgZmiZcid[i]ZhV\^iiVaZY\Zd[ZVX]eVg^ZiVa#I]ZnVgZ[jcXi^dcVaanZfj^kV" aZciidhigjXijgZhd[i]ZhVbZcVbZYZhXg^WZY[dgi]Z[gdciVa# c# I]ZcYW]_YTce\SecdXUce\SecV_bdXUcYW]_YTQ^T_bdbQ^cfUbcUcY^ec XgdhhZhi]ZbVhid^YVc\aZd[i]ZeVg^ZiVa!Xjii^c\V\gddkZdci]ZZcYdXgVc^Va hjg[VXZ#>ibVg`hi]ZXdjghZd[i]ZigVchkZghZdgh^\bd^Yh^cjh!VkZhhZai]ViYgV^ch WaddY[gdbi]ZWgV^c#

'ROWTH I]ZeVg^ZiVaWdcZdhh^ÄZh^cbZbWgVcZ!l^i]dhh^ÄXVi^dcZmiZcY^c\gVY^Vaan[gdbV XdbW^cZYXZciZgcZVgi]ZeVg^ZiVaWdhh#I]Z[djgXdgcZghd[i]ZWdcZVgZcdidhh^ÄZYVi W^gi]!VcYi]ZgZbV^c^c\heVXZhVgZi]Z[dciVcZaaZh#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION L]Zc[gV\bZciVgn!i]ZeVg^ZiVa^hXdc[jhZYbdhid[iZcl^i]i]Z[gdciVa!dXX^e^iVa!dg iZbedgVa#I]Z[gdciVa!dXX^e^iVa!VcYiZbedgVaYdcdi]VkZeVg^ZiVa[dgVb^cV!VhbVcn bZc^c\ZVa\gddkZh!dgZXidXgVc^Vahig^VZVhhdX^ViZYl^i]VcZmiZgcVaan[VX^c\WZkZaZY hjijgZi]ZhfjVbdhVa#

™

I]ZXgdhhhZXi^dcd[VeVg^ZiVa^hbdgZgZ\jaVgi]^X`cZhhYdZhcdikVgnVhbjX] i]Vci]dhZd[i]Zdi]ZgkVjaiWdcZh# ™ I]ZiZbedgVaa^cZ^hVXdchiVci[ZVijgZVXgdhhi]ZaZc\i]d[i]ZeVg^ZiVa# ™ I]ZZcYdXgVc^Vahjg[VXZd[i]^hWdcZ^hcdiVhjcYjaVi^c\VcY^ggZ\jaVgVhi]Vid[ i]Z[gdciVadgi]ZdXX^e^iVa#

3IDING H^Y^c\^hY^[ÄXjaidcanl]Zci]ZeVg^ZiVaWdcZ^hkZgn[gV\bZciVgn#I]ZbZc^c\ZVa \gddkZhVgZdg^ZciZYkZgi^XVaanVadc\i]ZXdgdcVahjijgZVcYbdgZ]dg^odciVaancZVg i]ZhfjVbdhVahjijgZ#

™ I]ZXdgdcVahjijgZ!jca^`Zi]ZhV\^iiVahjijgZ!^hVc^ciZgÄc\Zg^c\gVi]Zgi]Vc Vc^ciZgadX`^c\!o^eeZg"a^`Z!dg_^\hVl"a^`ZVgi^XjaVi^dc#I]ZaVg\ZVciZg^dgb^YYaZ bZc^c\ZVakZhhZabV`ZhVc^begZhh^dcVadc\i]^hhjijgZZcYdXgVc^Vaan# ™ I]Zi]^X`ZhiXdgcZghVgZi]ZdXX^e^iVaVcYbVhid^YVc\aZh# ™ I]ZbVhid^YVc\aZWZVghVhjaXjhZcYdXgVc^Vaan# ™ I]ZhfjVbdhVahjijgZ^haViZgVaVcY^c[Zg^dg!VcYi]ZeVg^ZiVahig^VZVc\aZedhiZgd" hjeZg^dgan# 

8]VeiZg,H`jaa

3+5,,

4EMPORALS&IGURES n !NATOMY IZbedgVah[dgbi]ZigVch^i^dcWZilZZcXgVc^ValVaaVcYWVhZ!]djhZi]ZYZa^XViZdg\Vch d[]ZVg^c\!VcY[dgbi]ZjeeZghjg[VXZd[i]Z_Vl_d^cih#I]Z]^\]an^ggZ\jaVgh]VeZd[ i]ZiZbedgVa^hgZaViZYidi]ZkVgn^c\[jcXi^dchd[i]ZWdcZ#I]ZiZbedgVaVgi^XjaViZh l^i]i]ZeVg^ZiVa!dXX^e^iVa!he]Zcd^Y!on\dbVi^X!VcYbVcY^WaZ#I]Z_Vl_d^ci!dgiZb" edgdbVcY^WjaVg_d^ci!^hd[iZcVWWgZk^ViZYIB?#EVgihd[i]ZiZbedgVaWdcZVgZkZgn gdWjhiVcY![dgi]^hgZVhdc!VgZd[iZcbdgZgZh^hiVciidYZhigjXi^dci]Vcdi]ZgeVgihd[ i]ZXgVc^VakVjai# V# I]Zi]^c!eaViZ"a^`ZcaeQ]Qg^hZhVabdhikZgi^XVaanid[dgbi]ZXgVc^ValVaahVcY Vgi^XjaViZl^i]i]ZeVg^ZiVahVadc\i]ZhfjVbdhVahjijgZ# W# I]Z`Udb_ec`ibQ]YT^hi]ZbVhh^kZ!YZchZWdcneVgii]ViYdb^cViZhi]ZZcYd" XgVc^VaVheZXid[i]ZiZbedgVa#I]Zh]VgehjeZg^dgZY\Zd[i]ZZcYdXgVc^VaeZigdjh hjg[VXZVc\aZhVciZgdbZY^Vaan!hZeVgVi^c\i]ZiZbedgVaVcYdXX^e^iVaadWZhd[i]Z WgV^cVcY]djh^c\i]Z^ciZgcVaZVg#I]ZeZigdjh^hlZY\ZYWZilZZci]ZdXX^e^iVa VcYi]Zhe]Zcd^Y#I]ZZcY"dck^Zlk^Zl[gdbVciZgdbZY^Va^h^cidi]ZXVgdi^Y XVcVa#I]^heZigdjheVgid[i]ZWdcZ]djhZhi]ZYZa^XViZdg\Vchd[]ZVg^c\VcY Zfj^a^Wg^jb!^cXajY^c\i]Zi^cnbdkVWaZbVaaZjh!^cXjh!VcYhiVeZhWdcZh# X# I]ZUhdUb^Q\QS_ecdYSQeTYd_bi]UQdec51=^hi]ZZmiZgcVadeZc^c\d[i]Z ZVgXVcVa!l]^X]eVhhZhVciZgdbZY^Vaan[dgVWdji'Xb#I]Z^ccZgZcYd[i]ZXVcVa ^hXadhZYWni]ZinbeVc^XbZbWgVcZZVgYgjb^ci]Za^k^c\^cY^k^YjVa# Y# I]ZjiW_]QdYS`b_SUccd[i]ZiZbedgVa^hVi]^cegd_ZXi^dcd[WdcZi]Vi[dgbh i]ZedhiZg^dg]Va[d[i]Zon\dbVi^XVgX]#>ihVciZg^dgZY\Z^hi]ZhZggViZYon\dbVi" ^XdiZbedgVahjijgZ!^ihhjeZg^dgZY\Z^hVcViiVX]bZci[dgi]ZiZbedgVa[VhX^V!VcY ^ih^c[Zg^dgZY\ZVcX]dghÄWZghd[i]ZbVhhZiZgbjhXaZ#  Z# I]Zce`bQ]UQdQ\SbUcd^hi]ZhjeZg^dggddid[i]Zon\dbVi^XegdXZhh#>igjch]dg^" odciVaanVWdkZi]Z:6Bl]ZgZi]ZdhiZdbZig^Xed^ciVjg^XjaVgZ^hadXViZY#  [# I]Zce`bQ]Qcd_YTSbUcd^hi]ZedhiZg^dgZmiZch^dcd[i]ZhjegVbZViVaXgZhi#I]Z Xdci^cjdjhgV^hZYZY\Zd[i]ZhZXgZhihbVg`hi]Za^b^id[i]ZiZbedgVa^hbjhXaZVcY iZbedgVa[VhX^VViiVX]bZci# \# I]Z`QbYUdQ\^_dSX^h[dgbZYWni]ZedhiZgdhjeZg^dgWdgYZgd[i]ZiZbedgVa l]ZgZi]ZhfjVbdhVaVcYeVg^ZidbVhid^YhjijgZhbZZi# ]# I]Z]Qcd_YT`b_SUccWZVghVcZmiZgcVahjg[VXZi]Vi^hgdj\]ZcZY[dgi]ZViiVX]" bZcid[hZkZgVabjhXaZh^cXajY^c\i]Z[daadl^c\/hiZgcdXaZ^YdbVhid^YZjh!heaZc^jh XVe^i^h!VcYadc\^hh^bjhXVe^i^h#I]ZhZbjhXaZh[jcXi^dc^cZmiZch^dc!ÅZm^dc!VcY gdiVi^dcd[i]Z]ZVY#I]ZiZbedgVa^hbjhXaZbVnVahdViiVX]^ci]^hgZ\^dcl]Zc i]ZhjegVbVhid^YXgZhi^hegZhZcidci]ZbVhid^YVgZV!Vh^chdbZ]jbVchVcY ,#-IZbedgVah

.*

bVcn[dhh^a]db^c^Yh#>ciZgcVaan!i]Zi]^c"lVaaZYbVhid^YegdXZhh^hdXXje^ZYWn VcjbWZgd[kVg^VWanYZkZadeZYkd^Yh`cdlcVh]Qcd_YTSU\\c#  ^# I]Z]Qcd_YTV_bQ]U^dXXVh^dcVaanbjai^eaZ^hadXViZYcZVgi]ZedhiZg^dgZY\Z d[i]ZbVhid^YegdXZhhVadc\i]ZdXX^e^idbVhid^YhjijgZ#>iigVchb^ihVhbVaa WgVcX]d[i]ZdXX^e^iVaVgiZgn!l]^X]hjeea^Zhi]ZYjgVbViZg!i]ZY^ead…hedc\n WdcZhVcYl^X]ZYWZilZZc^ccZgVcYdjiZgWdcZiVWaZhd[XgVc^VakVjaiWdcZh!VcY i]ZbVhid^YV^gXZaah#  _# I]Z]Qcd_YT^_dSXTYWQcdbYSWb__fU[dgViiVX]bZcid[i]ZY^\Vhig^XbjhXaZ^h i]ZkZgi^XVaandg^ZciZY[jggdlbZY^Vaidi]ZbVhid^YegdXZhh# `# I]Z_SSY`YdQ\Wb__fUce\Seca^Zh_jhibZY^Vaidi]ZbVhid^YcdiX]#>i^hVh]Va" adl[jggdli]ViadY\Zhi]ZdXX^e^iVaVgiZgn#  a# I]ZdU]`_b_]Q^TYRe\QbQbdYSe\QbcebVQSU^hi]Zhbddi]!Vgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ ^c[Zg^dgidi]Zgddid[i]Zon\dbVi^XegdXZhh#I]ZgZ^hXdch^YZgVWaZided\gVe]^X gZa^Z[idi]^h^c[Zg^dgan[VX^c\hjg[VXZ# b  # I]ZQbdYSe\QbU]Y^U^SU[dgbhi]ZVciZg^dgedgi^dcd[i]ZiZbedgdbVcY^WjaVg Vgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ# c# I]Z]Q^TYRe\QbV_ccQW\U^_YTV_ccQa^ZhedhiZgdhjeZg^dgidi]ZVgi^XjaVg Zb^cZcXZ#I]ZZb^cZcXZVcYi]Z[dhhV^ihZa[VgZWdjcYZYbZY^VaanWni]Zhe]Zcd" hfjVbdhVahjijgZ#>cX]Zl^c\!i]ZXdcYnaZd[i]ZbVcY^WaZbdkZhVciZg^dgandcid i]ZZb^cZcXZVcYedhiZg^dgan^cidi]Z[dhhVVhlZaaVh[gdbh^YZidh^YZ^cVXi^dchVi i]ZIB?#>ca^[Zi]ZgZ^hVÄWgdXVgi^aV\^cdjhVgi^XjaVgY^h`^ciZgedhZYWZilZZci]Z bVcY^WjaVgXdcYnaZVcYi]Z[dhhV# d# I]Z`_cdW\U^_YT`b_SUcc^hVegd_ZXi^dci]Via^Zh_jhiVciZgdhjeZg^dgidi]Z:6B! ^ciZgedhZYWZilZZci]Zdi]`Q^YS`Qbdd[i]ZWdcZl]^X][dgbhbdhid[i]Zg^b

SQUAMA SUPRAMEATAL CREST

SUPRAMASTOID CREST

POSTGLENOID PROCESS



EXTERNAL ACOUSTIC AUDITORY MEATUS MASTOID PROCESS

ENTOGLENOID PROCESS

&IGUREBYWXddU]`_bQ\\QdUbQ\ZXidXgVc^Va#6ciZg^dg^hidlVgYi]Zg^\]i!hjeZg^dg^hje# CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg,H`jaa



MIDDLEMENINGEAL GROOVE

PARIETALNOTCH



INTERNAL ACOUSTIC AUDITORY MEATUS

SIGMOID SULCUS

&IGUREBYWXddU]`_bQ\]UTYQ\ZcYdXgVc^Va#6ciZg^dg^hidlVgYi]ZaZ[i!hjeZg^dg^hje# CVijgVah^oZ#

,#-IZbedgVah

.,

3+5,,

d[i]Z:6BVcYi]ZbVcY^WjaVg[dhhV#I]^hg^b^hgdj\]ZcZY[dgi]ZViiVX]bZci d[i]ZXVgi^aV\^cdjheVgid[i]Z:6B# e# I]ZU^d_W\U^_YT`b_SUcc^hi]Z^c[Zg^dgegd_ZXi^dcd[i]ZVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZVii]Z bZY^VaZY\Zd[i]ZVgi^XjaVgZb^cZcXZ# f# I]Zdi]`Q^YSeVgid[i]ZiZbedgVaa^ZhedhiZg^dgidi]ZIB?#>ihVciZg^dghjg[VXZ! [dgb^c\i]ZgZVglVaad[i]ZbVcY^WjaVg[dhhV!^hcdcVgi^XjaVg#  g# I]Zcdi\_YT`b_SUcc^hVi]^c!ed^ciZYWdcngdYi]Vied^cihVciZgd^c[Zg^dgan[gdb i]ZWVhZd[i]ZiZbedgVaWdcZ#>i^hVhaZcYZgegd_ZXi^dcd[kVg^VWaZaZc\i]VcY^h [gV\^aZVcYd[iZcWgd`Zcdgb^hh^c\Vhdci]Z^aajhigViZYheZX^bZc!l]ZgZ^ihY^h" iVaZcY]VhhcVeeZYd[[#>iVcX]dghi]Zhinad]nd^YhdbZi^bZheVgiandhh^ÄZYa^\V" bZciVcYhZkZgVahbVaabjhXaZh#  h# I]Zcdi\_]Qcd_YTV_bQ]U^!adXViZY^bbZY^ViZanedhiZg^dgidi]ZWVhZd[i]Zhin" ad^YegdXZhh!^h[dgi]ZZm^id[i]Z[VX^VacZgkZXgVc^VacZgkZ,VcYi]ZZcigVcXZd[ i]ZhinadbVhid^YVgiZgn#  i# I]ZfQWY^Q\`b_SUccZch]ZVi]hi]ZWVhZd[i]Zhinad^YegdXZhh# j# I]ZZeWe\QbV_ccQ^hadXViZY_jhibZY^Vaidi]ZWVhZd[i]Zhinad^YegdXZhh#I]^h YZZe[dhhV]djhZhi]ZWjaWd[i]Z^ciZgcVa_j\jaVgkZ^c!VkZhhZai]ViYgV^chWaddY [gdbi]Z]ZVYVcYcZX`# k# I]ZSQb_dYTSQ^Q\^hVaVg\ZX^gXjaVgXVcVai]ViigVchb^ihi]Z^ciZgcVaXVgdi^YVg" iZgn!VbV_dghdjgXZd[WaddY[dgi]Z]ZVY!VcYi]ZXVgdi^YeaZmjhd[cZgkZh#>i^hh^ij" ViZYbZY^Vaidi]Zhinad^YegdXZhhVii]ZaZkZad[i]Zhe]ZcdhfjVbdhVahjijgZ!_jhi VciZg^dgidi]Z_j\jaVg[dhhV# l# =YTT\U]U^Y^WUQ\Wb__fUcVgZcVggdl!lZaa"YZÄcZYX]VccZahl]^X]bVg`i]Z ZcYdXgVc^Vahjg[VXZd[i]ZiZbedgVa#I]ZaVg\Zg!bdgZY^[[jhZjcYjaVi^dchdci]^h

ARTICULAREMINENCE MANDIBULARFOSSA TYMPANICPART VAGINALPROCESS STYLOMASTOID FORAMEN

CAROTIDCANAL STYLOIDPROCESS JUGULARFOSSA

MASTOIDNOTCH DIGASTRICGROOVE OCCIPITALGROOVESULCUS MASTOIDFORAMEN

&IGUREBYWXddU]`_bQ\Y^VUbY_b6ciZg^dg^hje!bZY^Va^hidlVgYi]Zg^\]i#CVijgVah^oZ#

hjg[VXZVgZgZaViZYidXdckdaji^dchd[i]ZiZbedgVaadWZd[i]ZWgV^c# m# I]ZY^dUb^Q\QS_ecdYSQeTYd_bi]UQdec^hadXViZYVWdjib^YlVnVadc\i]Z edhiZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]ZeZigdjhengVb^YVcYigVchb^ihi]Z[VX^VaVcYVXdjhi^X cZgkZhXgVc^VacZgkZh,VcY-!gZheZXi^kZanVhlZaaVhi]Z^ciZgcVaVjY^idgnVgiZgn# n# I]ZcYW]_YTce\Sec^hi]ZaVg\Z!Xjgk^c\\gddkZhZiVii]ZedhiZg^dgWVhZd[i]Z eZigdjhengVb^Ydci]ZZcYdXgVc^Vahjg[VXZd[i]ZbVhid^YeVgid[i]ZiZbedgVa WdcZ#I]^hhjaXjh]djhZhi]Zh^\bd^Yh^cjh!VcVciZgd^c[Zg^dgZmiZch^dcd[i]ZigVch" kZghZh^cjh!l]^X]^hVbV_dgkZhhZaYgV^c^c\WaddY[gdbi]ZWgV^c^cidi]Z^ciZgcVa _j\jaVgkZ^c#CdiZi]Vii]^hhjaXjh^hVXdci^cjVi^dcd[i]ZhjaXjhdci]ZedhiZgd^c" [Zg^dgXdgcZgd[i]ZeVg^ZiVa#

'ROWTH idhh^ÄZh[gdbZ^\]iXZciZghYjg^c\[ZiVaYZkZadebZci!cdiXdjci^c\i]dhZd[ i]Zb^YYaZZVgdginbeVc^Xg^c\#6hW^gi]VeegdVX]Zh!dcani]gZZbV^cXZciZghgZbV^c/ i]ZhfjVbV!i]ZeZigdjheVgi!VcYi]ZinbeVc^Xg^c\# 

8]VeiZg,H`jaa

3+5,,

ZYGOMATICPROCESS

PETROUS PYRAMID

&IGUREBYWXddU]`_bQ\ce`UbY_b6ciZg^dg^hje!bZY^Va^hidlVgYi]ZaZ[i#CVijgVah^oZ#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION :kZcl]Zc[gV\bZciVgn!^i^hY^[ÄXjaiidXdc[jhZi]ZiZbedgVal^i]di]ZgWdcZhWZ" XVjhZd[^ihjc^fjZbdge]dad\n#I]ZWgd`ZcZaZbZcihi]VibVnegZhZcihdbZigdjWaZ VgZi]ZhfjVbVVcYon\dbVi^XegdXZhh#

 ™  ™

I]ZiZbedgVahfjVbVdkZgaVehi]ZeVg^ZiVa#>i^hi]^ccZgi]Vci]ZeVg^ZiVadg[gdciVa# ;gV\bZciVgniZbedgVaegdXZhhZhd[i]Zon\dbVi^XWdcZVgZcdiVhi]^cVcYadc\ Vhi]Zon\dbVi^XegdXZhhd[i]ZiZbedgVa#

3IDING

 ™

;dg^hdaViZYbVhid^YhZXi^dch!i]ZbVhid^Yi^eed^cih^c[Zg^dganVcYi]ZZci^gZ bVhid^YVc\aZhVciZg^dgan#  ™ I]ZY^\Vhig^X\gddkZ^hedhiZg^dgVcYbZY^Va#  ™ ;dg^hdaViZYeZigdjhengVb^Yh!i]Z^ciZgcVaVXdjhi^X[dgVbZc^hedhiZg^dgVcYi]Z engVb^YiVeZghVciZgdbZY^Vaan#

,#-IZbedgVah

..

 ™

;dg^hdaViZY[gV\bZcihd[hfjVbV!i]ZhfjVbdhVahjijgZhjg[VXZdkZgaVehi]ZZXid" XgVc^Vahjg[VXZd[i]ZeVg^ZiVa#
!UDITORY/SSICLES&IGURE STAPES

I]Z i^cn ZVg dhh^XaZh P]Q\\Uec ]VbbZg! Y^Sec Vck^a! VcY cdQ`Uc hi^ggjeR VgZ ]djhZY ^c i]Z inbeVc^X XVk^in d[ i]Z iZbedgVa# I]Z Äghi ^h XdccZXiZY id i]Z inbeVc^X bZbWgVcZ! dg ZVgYgjb! VcY i]Z di]Zgh VgZ adXViZY bdgZ bZY^Vaan# I]ZhZ WdcZhVgZhdhbVaai]Vii]ZnVgZWZhidWhZgkZYjcYZg bV\c^ÄXVi^dc# I]Zn VgZ d[iZc adhi Yjg^c\ h`ZaZiVa gZXdkZgnVcYVgZhZaYdbhijY^ZY#

INCUS MALLEUS

&IGURE1eTYd_bi_ccYS\Uc k^ZlZY[gdbWdi]h^YZh#CVijgVa h^oZ#

/CCIPITAL&IGURES n !NATOMY I]ZdXX^e^iVaWdcZ^hhZiVii]ZgZVgd[i]ZXgVc^jbVcYVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]ZiZbedgVah! he]Zcd^Y!eVg^ZiVah!VcYi]ZjeeZgbdhikZgiZWgV!i]ZViaVh# V# I]ZV_bQ]U^]QW^e]^hi]ZaVg\Z]daZ^ci]ZdXX^e^iVai]gdj\]l]^X]i]ZWgV^c" hiZbeVhhZh^c[Zg^dgan^cidi]ZkZgiZWgVaXVcVa# W# I]ZcaeQ]_ecedgi^dcd[i]ZdXX^e^iVaWdcZ^hWn[Vgi]ZaVg\Zhi!Xdchi^iji^c\i]Z aVg\ZeaViZd[WdcZedhiZg^dgVcYhjeZg^dgidi]Z[dgVbZcbV\cjb# X# I]Z_SSY`YdQ\`\Q^e]^hi]VieVgid[i]ZdXX^e^iVahfjVbVi]Via^ZhVWdkZi]Z hjeZg^dgcjX]Vaa^cZh#I]ZhZXi^dcd[hfjVbV^c[Zg^dgidi]Za^cZh^hi]Z^eSXQ\ `\Q^e]# Y# I]ZUhdUb^Q\_SSY`YdQ\`b_deRUbQ^SUa^Zhdci]ZZXidXgVc^Vab^Ya^cZl]ZgZi]Z dXX^e^iVaVcYcjX]VaeaVcZhbZZi#>i^h]^\]ankVg^VWaZ^cVeeZVgVcXZVcY]ZVk^Zg VcYbdgZegdb^cZci^cbVaZ^cY^k^YjVah#  Z# Ce`UbY_b^eSXQ\\Y^Uca^ZidZ^i]Zgh^YZd[i]Zb^Ya^cZdci]ZZXidXgVc^Vahjg[VXZ 

8]VeiZg,H`jaa

,#&%DXX^e^iVa

&%&

3+5,,

d[i]ZhfjVbdjhedgi^dc#I]ZcjX]VaeaVcZVcYdXX^e^iVaeaVcZhbZg\ZVii]ZhZ hjeZg^dganXdckZma^cZh#HZkZgVacjX]VabjhXaZhViiVX]idVcYWZadli]ZhZa^cZhVcY [jcXi^dcidZmiZcYVcYgdiViZi]Z]ZVY#  [# 9^VUbY_b^eSXQ\\Y^UceVgVaaZai]ZhjeZg^dga^cZhWjiVgZadXViZYVWdjib^YlVn dci]ZZXidXgVc^VacjX]VaeaVcZ#;VhX^VhZeVgVi^c\cjX]VabjhXaZhViiVX]idi]Z a^cZ!l]ZgZVhVYY^i^dcVacjX]VabjhXaZhViiVX]^c[Zg^dgidi]^ha^cZ# \# I]ZUhdUb^Q\_SSY`YdQ\SbUcd]UTYQ^^eSXQ\\Y^U^hV]^\]ankVg^VWaZbZ" Y^Vca^cZdgXgZhii]VieVhhZhWZilZZci]Zg^\]iVcYi]ZaZ[icjX]VabjhXjaVijgZ# >ihigZiX]Zh[gdbi]ZZmiZgcVadXX^e^iVaegdijWZgVcXZidi]ZgZVgd[i]Z[dgVbZc bV\cjb!VcX]dg^c\i]ZcjX]Vaa^\VbZci# ]# I]ZRQcY\Qb`Qbd^hi]Zi]^X`!hfjVgZegd_ZXi^dcVciZg^dgidi]Z[dgVbZcbV\cjb# I]^heVgiVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]ZeZigdjhedgi^dchd[Wdi]iZbedgVahVcYl^i]i]Z he]Zcd^Yk^Vi]Zhe]ZcddXX^e^iVahjijgZ#  ^# I]Z\QdUbQ\!dgS_^Ti\Qb!`Qbdcd[i]ZdXX^e^iVaa^ZidZ^i]Zgh^YZd[i]Z[dgVbZc bV\cjb!Vgi^XjaVi^c\l^i]i]ZiZbedgVah#  _# ?SSY`YdQ\S_^Ti\UcVgZgV^hZYdkVahigjXijgZhdcZ^i]Zgh^YZd[i]Z[dgVbZcbV\" cjb#I]Z^g^c[Zg^dghjg[VXZhVgZXdckZm#I]ZVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZhd[i]ZhZXdcYnaZh Äi^cidi]ZXdcXVkZ[VXZihd[i]ZViaVhkZgiZWgV# `# 3_^Ti\QbV_ccQUVgZZXidXgVc^VaYZegZhh^dch^bbZY^ViZanedhiZg^dgidi]ZXdc" YnaZh#I]ZhZ[dhhVZgZXZ^kZi]ZedhiZg^dgbVg\^cd[i]ZhjeZg^dg[VXZid[i]ZViaVh kZgiZWgVl]Zci]Z]ZVY^hZmiZcYZYWVX`lVgY#  a# 3_^Ti\QbV_bQ]Y^QSQ^Q\ceZg[dgViZi]ZdXX^e^iVaVii]ZYZei]d[i]ZXdcYnaVg [dhhVZ!l]ZgZZVX]igVchb^ihVcZb^hhVgnkZ^c# b# 8i`_W\_ccQ\SQ^Q\cVgZijccZahi]gdj\]i]ZVciZg^dgeVgid[i]ZWVhZi]ZgZ[dgZ hjeZg^dg^ceaVXZbZcid[ZVX]XdcYnaZ#I]ZhZXVcVah\^kZZm^iid]ned\adhhVacZgkZh XgVc^VacZgkZ&'VcYZcigVcXZidVgiZg^Zh# c# :eWe\Qb`b_SUccUcVgZaViZgVaanY^gZXiZYXdgcZghd[i]ZWdcZeaVXZYaViZgVaidi]Z XdcYnaZh#I]Zi^ehd[i]ZhZegdXZhhZha^ZVii]ZVciZg^dgbdhied^ciVadc\i]ZdX" X^e^idbVhid^YhjijgZ# d# I]ZZeWe\Qb^_dSX^hZmXVkViZY^cidi]ZVciZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]Z_j\jaVgegdXZhh# I]^hcdiX][dgbhi]ZedhiZg^dg]Va[d[i]Z_j\jaVg[dgVbZc^ci]ZVgi^XjaViZYXgV" c^jb!l^i]i]ZVciZg^dg]Va[WZ^c\Xdcig^WjiZYWni]ZiZbedgVaWdcZ# e# I]ZSbeSYV_b]U]Y^U^SUY^k^YZhi]ZZcYdXgVc^Vahjg[VXZd[i]ZdXX^e^iVahfjVbV ^cid[djg[dhhVZ#>i^hhdcVbZYWZXVjhZ^i^hXgdhh"h]VeZY# f# 3UbURbQ\V_ccQUVgZig^Vc\jaVgYZegZhh^dchWZadli]ZaVbWYd^YVahjijgZdci]Z ZcYdXgVc^Vahjg[VXZd[i]ZdXX^e^iVa#I]Zn]djhZi]ZdXX^e^iVaadWZhd[i]ZWgV^c¼h XZgZWgjb#  g# I]ZSUbURU\\QbV_ccQUdXXjeni]Z^c[Zg^dgeVgid[i]ZZcYdXgVc^Vahjg[VXZd[i]Z dXX^e^iVahfjVbV#I]ZgZ^cgZhii]ZXZgZWZaaVgadWZhd[i]ZWgV^c#  h# I]ZY^dUb^Q\_SSY`YdQ\`b_deRUbQ^SUa^ZhVii]ZXZciZgd[i]ZXgjX^[dgbZb^cZcXZ#  i# I]Z_SSY`YdQ\cQWYddQ\ce\SeceVhhZhhjeZg^dgan[gdbi]Z^ciZgcVadXX^e^iVaegd" ijWZgVcXZ#>i^hVYZZeZcYdXgVc^Va\gddkZbVg`^c\i]ZedhiZg^dgZmiZch^dcd[i]Z hV\^iiVah^cjh!VbV_dgWaddYYgV^cV\ZeVi]lVn[gdbi]ZWgV^c# j# I]ZY^dUb^Q\_SSY`YdQ\SbUcd^hi]Z^c[Zg^dgVgbd[i]ZXgjX^[dgbZb^cZcXZ# HdbZi^bZh^iWZVghVhjaXjhi]ViXdci^cjZhdcdcZdgWdi]h^YZhd[i]Z[dgVbZc bV\cjb#HjX]VhjaXjh!XVaaZYVc_SSY`Yd_]QbWY^Q\ce\Sec!gZegZhZcihVcVaiZg" cVi^kZeVi]lVn[dgWaddYidYgV^c[gdbi]ZWgV^c#

OCCIPITALPLANUM

EXTERNAL OCCIPITAL PROTUBERANCE SUPERIOR NUCHAL LINE NUCHAL PLANUM INFERIOR NUCHAL LINE EXTERNAL OCCIPITAL CREST FORAMEN MAGNUM CONDYLAR FORAMEN CONDYLARFOSSA HYPOGLOSSALCANAL OCCIPITALCONDYLE GROOVEFORTHEMEDULLAOBLONGATA &IGURE?SSY`YdQ\`_cdUb_Y^VUbY_bZXidXgVc^Va#HjeZg^dg^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

k# DbQ^cfUbcUce\SY[dgbi]ZigVchkZghZVgbhd[i]ZXgjX^[dgbZb^cZcXZ#I]Zn ]djhZi]ZigVchkZghZh^cjhZh#I]ZdcZdci]Zg^\]i^hjhjVaanaVg\ZgVcYXdbbjc^" XViZhY^gZXianl^i]i]ZhV\^iiVahjaXjh#=dlZkZg!kVg^Vi^dch^ci]Zhd[ii^hhjZVcY WdcnbVc^[ZhiVi^dchd[i]^hXgVc^VakZcdjhYgV^cV\ZhnhiZbVgZXdbbdcVcY hdbZi^bZhegdcdjcXZY#I]ZigVchkZghZhjaXjhd[i]ZdXX^e^iVaXdccZXihl^i]i]Z h^\bd^YhjaXjhd[i]ZiZbedgVaVcYZcYdXgVc^Va_j\jaVgegdXZhh!d[iZck^Vi]Z igVchkZghZdgh^\bd^YhjaXjhdci]ZbVhid^YXdgcZgd[i]ZeVg^ZiVa# l# I]ZWb__fUV_bdXU]UTe\\Q_R\_^WQdQ^hi]Z]daadl^c\dci]ZZcYdXgVc^Vahjg" [VXZd[i]ZWVh^aVgeVgid[i]ZdXX^e^iVa!i]ZXa^kjh# 

8]VeiZg,H`jaa

3+5,,

CRUCIFORMEMINENCE INTERNAL OCCIPITAL PROTUBERANCE

OCCIPITALSULCUS CEREBRALFOSSA

TRANSVERSE SULCUS

INTERNAL OCCIPITAL CREST

CEREBELLAR FOSSA

JUGULARPROCESS JUGULARNOTCH HYPOGLOSSALCANAL

&IGURE?SSY`YdQ\Q^dUbY_bZcYdXgVc^Va#HjeZg^dg^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

'ROWTH I]ZdXX^e^iVa^hVcdi]ZgWdcZl^i]Wdi]bZbWgVcdjhVcYZcYdX]dcYgVadhh^ÄXVi^dc# 6iW^gi]i]ZdXX^e^iVaXdch^hihd[[djgeVgih/i]ZhfjVbV!i]ZaViZgVaeVgihi]ViWZVgi]Z XdcYnaZh!VcYi]ZWVh^aVgeVgi#I]ZhfjVbVVcYaViZgVaedgi^dchjc^iZViVWdjiV\Z)! VcYWnV\Z+i]ZWVh^aVgeVgiViiVX]Zhidi]ZhZ#I]Zhncdhidh^h[jh^dcWZilZZci]ZdX" X^e^iVa VcY i]Z he]Zcd^Y VXgdhh i]Z he]ZcddXX^e^iVa hncX]dcYgdh^h cdgbVaan iV`Zh eaVXZWZilZZc&-VcY'*nZVghd[V\Z#

,#&%DXX^e^iVa

&%(

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION :kZcl]Zc[gV\bZciVgn!i]ZdXX^e^iVa^hY^[ÄXjaiidXdc[jhZl^i]di]ZgWdcZhd[i]Z kVjai#  ™ I]ZgZ^hl^YZkVg^Vi^dc^ci]^X`cZhhVXgdhhi]ZdXX^e^iVahfjVbVi]Vi^hcdi[djcY ^ci]ZeVg^ZiVahdgi]Z[gdciVa#  ™ I]ZdXX^e^iVaaVX`hbZc^c\ZVa\gddkZhZcYdXgVc^VaanVcY]VhbjX]bdgZZXidXgV" c^Vagj\dh^ini]VchZZcdci]ZeVg^ZiVadg[gdciVa# Di]Zg edhh^WaZ Xdc[jh^dc bVn XdbZ l]Zc ZmigVhjijgVa WdcZh VgZ ZcXdjciZgZY# I]ZhZWdcZhVgZhdbZi^bZhfj^iZaVg\Z!eVgi^XjaVganVadc\i]ZaVbWYd^YVahjijgZ#DcZ ZkZc]VhVcVbZ!i]ZY^SQR_^U#I]^h^hVaVg\Z!ig^Vc\jaVg!hnbbZig^XVaWdcZeaVXZYVi i]Zided[i]ZdXX^e^iVa!_jhiWZadlaVbWYV#

3IDING >hdaViZY[gV\bZcihd[dXX^e^iVaVgZZVh^anh^YZYWnadXVi^c\i]ZaVbWYd^YVahjijgZ#

 ™ ;dg^hdaViZYXdcYnaZh!i]ZZY\Zd[i]Z[dgVbZcbV\cjb^hbZY^VaVcYhdbZl]Vi edhiZg^dgidi]ZXdcYnaVgWdYnXZciZgh#

 ™ I]ZXdcYnaVg[dhhV^hedhiZg^dg!VcYi]Z]ned\adhhVaXVcVahijccZa[gdbVciZgdaVi" ZgVaidedhiZgdbZY^Va# 

-AXILLAE&IGURE !NATOMY BVm^aaVZVgZVeV^gd[WdcZhi]Vi[dgbi]ZYdb^cVciedgi^dcd[i]Z[VXZ#;jcXi^dcVaan! i]ZbVm^aaVZ]daYi]Ziddi]gddihVcY[dgbbdhid[i]ZcVhVaVeZgijgZVcYÅddg!bdhi d[i]Z]VgYeVaViZ!VcYi]ZÅddghd[i]ZdgW^ih#Bdhid[i]ZbVm^aaVgnWdcZ^ha^\]iVcY [gV\^aZ!i]ZZmXZei^dcWZ^c\i]Zedgi^dci]Vi]daYhi]ZiZZi]#BVm^aaVZXdbeg^hZ[djg WVh^XegdXZhhZhVcYi]ZnVgi^XjaViZl^i]ZVX]di]ZgVcYl^i]i]Z[gdciVa!cVhVah!aVXg^" bVah!Zi]bd^Y!^c[Zg^dgcVhVaXdcX]VZ!eVaVi^cZh!kdbZg!on\dbVi^Xh!VcYhe]Zcd^Y# V# I]ZQ\fU_\Qb`b_SUcc^hi]Z]dg^odciVaedgi^dcd[i]ZbVm^aaVi]Vi]daYhi]Z 

8]VeiZg,H`jaa

ZYGOMATIC PROCESS

0/34%2)/2 FRONTAL PROCESS

INFRAORBITAL FORAMEN CANINE FOSSA PALATINE PROCESS

NASO ALVEOLAR CLIVUS

,!4%2!,

-%$)!, MAXILLARY SINUS

ANTERIOR LACRIMAL CREST

ANTERIOR NASAL SPINE CANINE JUGUM ALVEOLAR PROCESS

350%2)/2

).&%2)/2 INFRAORBITAL SULCUS

GREATERPALATINE GROOVE

INCISIVEFORAMEN ALVEOLI

&IGUREBYWXd]QhY\\QCVijgVah^oZ#

,#&&BVm^aaVZ

&%*

3+5,,

!.4%2)/2

iddi]gddih# W# 1\fU_\Y[dgi]Ziddi]gddihVgZegZhZciVaaVadc\i]ZVakZdaVgegdXZhh!ZmXZeil]ZgZ i]ZhZ]VkZWZZcgZhdgWZY[daadl^c\i]Zadhhd[iZZi]# X# I]ZSQ^Y^UZeWe]^hVWdcnZb^cZcXZdkZgi]ZbVm^aaVgnXVc^cZgddidci]Z[V" X^Vahjg[VXZd[i]ZbVm^aaV# Y# I]ZjiW_]QdYS`b_SUcc[dgbhbjX]d[i]ZX]ZZ`#  Z# I]ZY^VbQ_bRYdQ\V_bQ]U^^hadXViZYWZadli]Z^c[Zg^dgdgW^iVag^bdci]Z[VX^Va hjg[VXZVcYigVchb^ihi]Z^c[gVdgW^iVacZgkZVY^k^h^dcd[XgVc^VacZgkZ*VcYkZh" hZahidi]Z[VXZ#  [# I]ZSQ^Y^UV_ccQ^hV]daadld[kVg^VWaZZmiZciadXViZYdci]Z[VX^Vahjg[VXZ_jhi WZadli]Z^c[gVdgW^iVa[dgVbZc!l]ZgZi]Zon\dbVi^X![gdciVa!VcYVakZdaVgegd" XZhhZhd[i]ZbVm^aaVXdbZid\Zi]Zg# \# I]ZQ^dUbY_b^QcQ\c`Y^U^hi]Zi]^cegd_ZXi^dcd[WdcZdci]Zb^Ya^cZVii]Z ^c[Zg^dgbVg\^cd[i]ZcVhVaVeZgijgZ# ]# I]ZY^VbQ_bRYdQ\ce\SecWb__fU^hXZciZgZYdci]ZedhiZg^dg]Va[d[i]ZdgW^iVa ÅddgVcYdeZchedhiZgdhjeZg^dgan#>iXdccZXihVciZgd^c[Zg^dganl^i]i]Z^c[gVdg" W^iVa[dgVbZck^Vi]ZY^VbQ_bRYdQ\SQ^Q\#  ^# I]Z]QhY\\QbicY^ec^hi]ZaVg\Zkd^Y^ci]ZWdYnd[i]ZbVm^aaVhjeZg^dgidi]Z VakZdaVgegdXZhhVcY^c[Zg^dgidi]ZdgW^iVaÅddg#  _# I]ZVb_^dQ\`b_SUccg^hZhidVgi^XjaViZl^i]i]Z[gdciVa!cVhVah!aVXg^bVa!VcYZi]" bd^Y# `# I]ZQ^dUbY_b\QSbY]Q\SbUcd^hVkZgi^XVaXgZhiadXViZYdci]ZaViZgVaVheZXid[ i]Z[gdciVaegdXZhhd[i]ZbVm^aaV#I]ZbVm^aaVXdbW^cZhl^i]i]ZaVXg^bVaWdcZ id[dgbi]Z\QSbY]Q\Wb__fUVcYSQ^Q\#I]^hXVcVa]djhZhi]ZcVhdaVXg^bVaYjXi! l]^X]YgV^chiZVgh^c[Zg^dgan^cidi]ZcVhVaXVk^in#  a# I]Z`Q\QdY^U`b_SUcc[dgbhi]ZVciZg^dgild"i]^gYhd[i]Z]VgYeVaViZVcYÅddg d[i]ZcVhVaXVk^in# b# I]ZY^SYcYfUV_bQ]U^eZg[dgViZhi]ZVciZg^dg]VgYeVaViZVii]Zb^Ya^cZ# c# I]ZY^SYcYfUSQ^Q\^hW^adWViZ!deZc^c\k^Vi]Z^cX^h^kZ[dgVbZc!l^i]ZVX]adWZ ZcXadhZYWndcZd[i]ZbVm^aaVZ#:VX]adWZd[i]ZXVcVaigVchb^ihi]ZiZgb^cVa WgVcX]d[i]Z\gZViZgeVaVi^cZVgiZgnVcYi]ZcVhdeVaVi^cZcZgkZ# d# I]Z`bU]QhY\\QbicedebU^hhdbZi^bZhhZZc^ci]ZlVaad[i]Z^cX^h^kZXVcVaVcY dci]ZVY_VXZcieVaViVahjg[VXZ!eVgi^XjaVgan^cndjc\^cY^k^YjVah# e# I]ZWbUQdUb`Q\QdY^UWb__fUVii]ZgZVgd[i]Z]VgYeVaViZbVg`hi]Z_jcXi^dcd[ i]ZeVaVi^cZVcYVakZdaVgegdXZhhZh#I]^h\gddkZ^h[dgi]Z\gZViZgeVaVi^cZkZhhZah VcYcZgkZ# f# I]Z]QhY\\QbideRUb^hi]Zgj\dhZhjg[VXZVii]ZedhiZg^dgZcYd[i]ZVakZdaVg egdXZhh#>i^hkVg^VWaZ^cZmegZhh^dc!Vgi^XjaVi^c\l^i]i]ZengVb^YVaegdXZhhd[i]Z eVaVi^cZVcYhdbZi^bZhl^i]i]ZaViZgVaeiZgn\d^YeaViZd[i]Zhe]Zcd^Y#  g# I]Z^Qc_Q\fU_\QbS\Yfec^hi]Zhjg[VXZWZilZZci]ZXVc^cZ_j\VZ!i]ZWVhZd[i]Z e^g^[dgbVeZgijgZ!VcYi]ZVakZdaVgbVg\^c#

 'ROWTH :VX]bVm^aaVdhh^ÄZh[gdbildbV^cXdbW^cZYXZciZgh!dcZ[dgi]ZbVm^aaVegdeZgVcY dcZ[dgi]ZegZbVm^aaV#I]ZhZ[jhZZVgan^c]jbVcYZkZadebZci!VWdjii]Zc^ci]lZZ` 

8]VeiZg,H`jaa

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION HbVaa[gV\bZcihd[bVm^aaVb^\]iWZXdc[jhZYl^i]di]ZgXgVc^VaWdcZh#7ZXVjhZi]Z WdcZ^hXdbeaZm!^i^h]Zae[jaidcdiZi]ZY^V\cdhi^X[ZVijgZhjhZ[ja^c^YZci^[n^c\^i# I]ZhZ^cXajYZi]ZVakZdaVggZ\^dc!i]Zh]VgeZY\Zhd[i]ZcVhVaVeZgijgZ!i]ZZY\Zd[ i]ZaVXg^bVaXVcVa!i]ZaVg\ZbVm^aaVgnh^cjh!VcYi]Zjc^fjZ!hZggViZY^ciZgbVm^aaVgn hjijgZ#

3IDING ;gV\bZcihd[bVm^aaVbVnegdkZY^[ÄXjaiidh^YZ!VcYi]ZjhZd[XdbeVgVi^kZheZX^bZch bVnegdkZcZXZhhVgn#

 ™

;dgVWgd`Zc[gdciVaegdXZhh!i]Zi]^ccZgZY\Z^hVciZg^dgVcYbZY^Va!i]ZbZY^Va hjg[VXZ^hkVhXjaVg^oZYeZg[dgViZYWnWaddYkZhhZah!VcYi]ZVciZg^dgaVXg^bVa XgZhi^haViZgVa#  ™ ;dgVcnhZ\bZcil^i]VakZdaVgWdcZegZhZgkZY!iddi]gddihdghdX`ZihXVcWZjhZY VhV\j^YZidbZY^Va!aViZgVa!VciZg^dg!VcYedhiZg^dg#

0ALATINES&IGURESn !NATOMY I]ZhbVaa!YZa^XViZ!A"h]VeZYeVaVi^cZWdcZh[dgbi]ZgZVgd[i]Z]VgYeVaViZVcYeVgi d[i]ZlVaaVcYÅddgd[i]ZcVhVaXVk^in#>cY^k^YjVaeVaVi^cZWdcZhVgZVabdhicZkZg [djcY^cVc^hdaViZY!^ciVXihiViZ0i]Zn\ZcZgVaanVXXdbeVcni]ZbVm^aaVZVcYhe]Zcd^Y! idl]^X]i]ZnVgZi^\]ianWdjcY#>cVYY^i^dcidi]ZhZild!eVaVi^cZhVgi^XjaViZl^i]i]Z kdbZg!^c[Zg^dgcVhVaXdcX]VZ!Zi]bd^Y!VcYl^i]ZVX]di]Zg# V# I]ZX_bYj_^dQ\`\QdUd[i]ZeVaVi^cZ[dgbhi]ZedhiZg^dgi]^gYd[i]Z]VgYeVaViZ# W# I]ZWbUQdUb`Q\QdY^UV_bQ]U^SQ^Q\eZg[dgViZhi]ZgZVgXdgcZgd[i]Z]VgYeVa" ViZVcY^h[dgbZYVhi]ZVakZdaVgegdXZhhd[i]ZbVm^aaVbZZihi]Z]dg^odciVaeaViZ ,#&'EVaVi^cZh

&%,

3+5,,

^cjiZgd!Wjii]ZhjijgZWZilZZci]ZbbVneZgh^hi^cidVYjai]ddY^ci]ZgZ\^dcVY_VXZci idi]Z^cX^h^kZXVcVa#

d[i]ZeVaVi^cZ#I]^hXVcVaigVchb^ihi]Z\gZViZgeVaVi^cZkZhhZahVcYcZgkZ# X# I]Zild]VakZhd[i]Z`dUbiW_`Q\QdY^USQ^Q\WZXdbZk^h^WaZ!hlZZe^c\edhiZgd" hjeZg^dgan!l]Zci]ZbVm^aaVVcYeZgeZcY^XjaVgeaViZd[i]ZeVaVi^cZVgZY^hVg" i^XjaViZY# Y# I]Z`_cdUbY_b^QcQ\c`Y^U^hadXViZYdci]ZhjeZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]Z]dg^odciVa eaViZ#I]ZhjeZg^dg!dgcVhVaXVk^in!hjg[VXZd[i]ZeaViZ^hhbddi]ZgVcYbdgZgZ\j" aVgi]Vci]ZeVaViVahjg[VXZ# Z#
PERPENDICULAR PLATE

PTERYGOPALATINE CANAL

,!4%2!, ANTERIORISTOTHERIGHT

350%2)/2 LATERALISTOTHERIGHT

HORIZONTAL PLATE POSTERIOR NASALSPINE PYRAMIDAL PROCESS

GREATER PALATINE FORAMEN LESSERPALATINE FORAMINA

0/34%2)/2 LATERALISTOTHERIGHT

).&%2)/2 LATERALISTOTHELEFT

&IGUREBYWXd`Q\QdY^UHjeZg^dg^hje# CVijgVah^oZ#

&IGUREBYWXd`Q\QdY^U6ciZg^dg^hje# CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg,H`jaa

'ROWTH EVaVi^cZWdcZhdhh^[n^cbZbWgVcZ[gdbh^c\aZXZciZgh#

 0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION 7ZXVjhZi]ZeVaVi^cZhVgZVabdhiValVnhViiVX]ZYidi]ZbVm^aaVZVcYhe]Zcd^Y!^YZc" i^ÄXVi^dc^hcdijhjVaanY^[ÄXjai#L]ZchbVaa!^hdaViZY[gV\bZcihd[eVaVi^cZVgZZc" XdjciZgZY!cdiZi]Z[gZZedhiZg^dgZY\Zd[i]Z]dg^odciVaeaViZVcYi]Zhbddi]!ZkZc XdcXVk^indci]ZcVhVahjg[VXZd[i]^heaViZ#

3IDING 7ZXVjhZ^hdaViZY[gV\bZcihd[eVaVi^cZbdhid[iZcegZhZgkZi]Z]dg^odciVaeaViZ!cdiZ i]Vi i]Z hjeZg^dg hjg[VXZ ^h hbddi]! i]Vi i]Z ^c[Zg^dg eVaViVa hjg[VXZ ^h gdj\]! i]Vi i]Z edhiZg^dg ZY\Z ^h cdcVgi^XjaVg! VcY i]Vi \gZViZg VcY aZhhZg eVaVi^cZ [dgVb^cV VgZ edhiZgdaViZgVa#

6OMER&IGURE !NATOMY I]ZkdbZg^hVhbVaa!i]^c!eadl"h]VeZY!b^Ya^cZWdcZi]VidXXje^ZhVcYY^k^YZhi]Z cVhVaXVk^in#>iVgi^XjaViZh^c[Zg^dgandci]Zb^Ya^cZl^i]i]ZbVm^aaVZVcYi]ZeVaV" i^cZh!hjeZg^dganl^i]i]Zhe]Zcd^Yk^V^ihl^c\h!VcYVciZgdhjeZg^dganl^i]i]ZZi]" bd^Y#I]jh!i]ZWdcZ[dgbhi]ZedhiZgd^c[Zg^dgeVgid[i]ZcVhVahZeijb!l]^X]Y^k^YZh i]ZcVhVaXVk^in# ,#&(KdbZg

&%.

3+5,,

d[i]ZVakZdaVgegdXZhhd[i]ZbVm^aaV# \#I]ZedhiZg^dgWdgYZgd[i]ZeZgeZcY^XjaVgeaViZ^hi]Zi]^X`ZhiWdgYZg#>iWZVghV hZggViZY\gddkZi]ViVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]ZbZY^VaeiZgn\d^YeaViZd[i]Zhe]Zcd^Y# I]^hVgZVd[i]ZWdcZ^hXVaaZYi]Z`ibQ]YTQ\`b_SUcc# ]# I]ZS_^SXQ\SbUcd^hVhjW]dg^odciVaandg^ZciZYXgZhieaVXZYcdifj^iZ]Va[lVnje i]ZeZgeZcY^XjaVgeaViZdci]ZbZY^Vahjg[VXZd[i]ZeaViZ#I]^hXgZhi^h[dgVgi^Xj" aVi^dcl^i]i]Z^c[Zg^dgcVhVaXdcX]V#

ALAOR WING PERPENDICULAR PLATE

POSTERIOR BORDER

NASOPALATINE GROOVE

2)'(4,!4%2!, ANTERIORISTOTHERIGHT &IGUREF_]UbHjeZg^dg^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

0/34%2)/2

V# 1\QU!dggY^Wc!d[i]ZkdbZgVgZadXViZYdcZ^i]Zgh^YZd[VYZZeb^Ya^cZ[jggdl dci]ZhjeZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]ZkdbZg#I]^heVgid[i]ZWdcZ^hi]Zi]^X`ZhiVcY hijgY^ZhiVcY^hi^\]ianVeegZhhZYidi]Zhe]Zcd^Y# W# I]Z`Ub`U^TYSe\Qb`\QdUd[i]ZkdbZg^hVi]^ckZgi^XVah]ZZid[WdcZdci]Z b^Ya^cZWZadli]Zl^c\h# X# I]ZcdcVgi^XjaVg`_cdUbY_bR_bTUbd[i]ZkdbZgY^k^YZhi]ZedhiZg^dgcVhVaVeZg" ijgZ^cidild]VakZh# Y# >Qc_`Q\QdY^UWb__fUcadY\ZcVhdeVaVi^cZcZgkZhVcYkZhhZah!bVg`^c\Wdi]h^YZhd[ i]ZeZgeZcY^XjaVgeaViZ!l]ZgZi]ZngjcVciZgd^c[Zg^dgan[gdbi]ZVaVZ#

'ROWTH 6cdi]ZgWdcZl^i]Wdi]ZcYdX]dcYgVaVcYbZbWgVcdjhdhh^ÄXVi^dc!i]ZkdbZgdhh^" ÄZh[gdbildeaViZhaVb^cVZdcZ^i]Zgh^YZd[VbZY^VceaViZd[XVgi^aV\Z#7nejWZgin! i]ZaVbZaaVZVgZk^gijVaanjc^iZY!Wjii]ZW^aVb^cVgdg^\^cd[i]ZWdcZ^hY^hXZgc^WaZ^c i]ZXaZ[iWZilZZci]ZVaVZ#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION 7ZXVjhZd[i]Zb^Ya^cZeaVXZbZcid[i]ZkdbZg!hnbbZign^hi]ZWZhi\j^YZid^YZci^" ÄXVi^dc#>hdaViZYkdbZghVgZgVgZan[djcYVcYVabdhicZkZggZXdkZgZY^ciVXi#IdVkd^Y Xdc[jh^dcl^i]di]Zgi]^cWdcZh!hjX]Vhi]Zhe]Zcd^Y!cdiZi]Vii]ZkdbZg]VhVaVZ VcYi]Vii]ZeZgeZcY^XjaVgeaViZ^hhnbbZig^XVa!l^i]V[gZZedhiZg^dgZY\Z#

3IDING I]Zcdcb^Ya^cZedgi^dchd[i]ZkdbZgVgZhdhbVaai]Vih^Y^c\Xg^iZg^VVgZjccZXZhhVgn [dgi]^hWdcZ# 

8]VeiZg,H`jaa

3+5,,

)NFERIOR.ASAL#ONCHAE&IGURE !NATOMY >c[Zg^dgcVhVaXdcX]VZZmiZcY]dg^odciVaanVadc\i]ZaViZgValVaahd[i]ZcVhVaXVk^in! Vgi^XjaVi^c\l^i]i]ZbZY^ValVaad[i]ZbVm^aaVZVcYl^i]i]ZeVaVi^cZh#I]ZnVahdVg" i^XjaViZl^i]i]ZZi]bd^YVcYaVXg^bVahhjeZg^dgan#I]ZWdcZhVgZgVgZan[djcY^hdaViZY WZXVjhZi]ZnVgZhd[gV\^aZ#I]Z^gh]VeZ^hkVg^VWaZ!l^i]i]ZVciZg^dgVcYedhiZg^dgZm" igZb^i^ZhiVeZgZYidVed^ci!VcYi]Z^c[Zg^dghjg[VXZ[gZZ!i]^X`ZcZY!VcYkVhXjaVg^oZY# >c[Zg^dgcVhVaXdcX]VZ[jcXi^dc^cda[VXi^dcVcY^cbd^hiZc^c\^c]VaZYV^g#

'ROWTH I]Z^c[Zg^dgcVhVaXdcX]VZdhh^[n[gdbh^c\aZXZciZgh#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION 7ZXVjhZ^c[Zg^dgcVhVaXdcX]VZVgZhd[gV\^aZ!i]ZnVgZk^gijVaancZkZg[djcY^ciVXiVh ^hdaViZYheZX^bZch#HbVaa[gV\bZcihb^\]iWZb^hiV`Zc[dgZi]bd^Y!he]Zcd^Y!dgaVX" g^bVa#CdiZ!]dlZkZg!i]Vii]Zhjg[VXZiZmijgZd[i]Z^c[Zg^dgcVhVaXdcX]VZ^h]^\]an eZg[dgViZYWncjbZgdjhi^cnVeZgijgZh!\^k^c\i]ZbV[gV\^aZVcYa^\]ilZ^\]iVheZXi#

3IDING I]ZgZ^ha^iiaZjhZ[dg`cdlaZY\Zd[h^Y^c\^c[Zg^dgcVhVaXdcX]VZ#

,!4%2!, ANTERIORISTOTHERIGHT

!.4%2)/2 LATERALISTOTHELEFT

-%$)!, ANTERIORISTOTHELEFT

&IGUREBYWXdY^VUbY_b^QcQ\S_^SXQHjeZg^dg^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

,#&)>c[Zg^dgCVhVa8dcX]VZ

&&&

%THMOID&IGURE !NATOMY I]ZZi]bd^YWdcZ^hZmXZZY^c\ana^\]iVcY hedc\n#>i^hgdj\]ani]Zh^oZVcYh]VeZd[ Vc^XZXjWZ!Wji^hdcanV[gVXi^dcVh]ZVkn# >i^hadXViZYWZilZZci]ZdgW^ih!XZciZgZY dc i]Z b^Ya^cZ# >i Vgi^XjaViZh l^i] i]^g" iZZc WdcZh/ i]Z [gdciVa! he]Zcd^Y! cVhVah! bVm^aaVZ! aVXg^bVah! eVaVi^cZh! ^c[Zg^dg cVhVaXdcX]VZ!VcYkdbZg#I]ZZi]bd^Y^h k^gijVaancZkZg[djcYVhVjc^iWZXVjhZd[ ^ih[gV\^a^in#>i^hWZhik^ZlZY^cVheZX^Vaan Y^hVgi^XjaViZYh`jaa!l]ZgZ^ihXdbeaZm^in XVcWZVeegZX^ViZY# V# I]ZSbYRbYV_b]`\QdU^hWZhidW" hZgkZYZcYdXgVc^Vaan!l]ZgZi]ZZi]" bd^YXVcWZhZZcidÄaai]ZZi]bd^Y cdiX]d[i]Z[gdciVa#I]ZXg^Wg^[dgb eaViZgdd[hi]ZcVhVaXVk^i^Zh!VcY WZXVjhZ^i^heZg[dgViZYWnbVcni^cn [dgVb^cV^iadd`ha^`ZVh^ZkZ#Da[VX" idgncZgkZhXgVc^VacZgkZ&eZg[dgViZ i]^heaViZVhi]ZneVhhjeidi]ZWgV^c [gdbi]ZbjXdjha^c^c\d[i]ZcdhZ# W# I]ZSbYcdQWQ\\Y^hVeZgeZcY^XjaVg egd_ZXi^dcd[i]ZXg^Wg^[dgbeaViZd[ i]ZZi]bd^Y^cidi]ZZcYdXgVc^Va XVk^in#>i^h^ciZgedhZYWZilZZcda[VX" idgnWjaWh!VcY^ihedhiZg^dghjg[VXZ VcX]dghi]Z[VamXZgZWg^!V[daYd[i]Z YjgVbViZgZmiZcY^c\^cidi]Zadc\^" ijY^cVaÄhhjgZd[i]ZWgV^cWZilZZc i]ZildXZgZWgVa]Zb^he]ZgZh# X# I]Z\QRibY^dXc!dg\QdUbQ\]QccUc! d[i]ZZi]bd^Ya^ZidZ^i]Zgh^YZd[i]Z b^Ya^cZVcYXdch^hid[VhZg^Zhd[i]^c" lVaaZYZi]bd^YVaXZaah#I]ZaViZgVa 

8]VeiZg,H`jaa

CRIBRIFORM PLATE

350%2)/2 ANTERIORISUP

,%&4,!4%2!, ANTERIORISTOTHELEFT

CRISTAGALLI

LABYRINTH

PERPENDICULARPLATE

!.4%2)/2 SUPERIORISUP &IGURE5dX]_YTCVijgVah^oZ#

'ROWTH I]ZZi]bd^Y^hi]ZdcanWVh^XgVc^VaWdcZi]Vi^hZci^gZanegZ[dgbZY^cXVgi^aV\Z#>i dhh^ÄZh[gdbi]gZZXZciZgh!dcZ[dgZVX]aVWng^ci]VcYdcZ[dgi]ZeZgeZcY^XjaVgeaViZ# 9jg^c\i]ZÄghinZVgV[iZgW^gi]!i]ZeZgeZcY^XjaVgeaViZVcYXg^hiV\Vaa^WZ\^ciddh" h^[n#I]ZnVgZ_d^cZY^ci]ZhZXdcYnZVgidi]ZaVWng^ci]h#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION I]Zi]^ceaViZhd[i]ZZi]bd^Yb^\]iWZY^[ÄXjaiid^YZci^[nl]Zc[djcY^hdaViZY!Wji i]^hWdcZ^hgVgZan[djcYWn^ihZa[#BdgZd[iZc!e^ZXZhd[^iVY]ZgZidi]Zdi]ZgWdcZh ^iVgi^XjaViZhl^i]!bdhiXdbbdcani]Z[gdciVadghe]Zcd^Y#I]ZeZgeZcY^XjaVgeaViZ b^\]iWZXdc[jhZYl^i]i]ZkdbZg!Wjii]ZkdbZg]VhVcdcVgi^XjaVgedhiZg^dgZY\Z VcYVi]^X`ZcZYZY\Zl]ZgZi]ZVaVZ_d^c#

3IDING I]Zedgi^dchd[Zi]bd^Yi]ViVgZjhjVaan[djcY^hdaViZYVgZWdi]b^Ya^cZhigjXijgZh ¸i]ZXg^hiV\Vaa^VcYi]ZeZgeZcY^XjaVgeaViZ#

,ACRIMALS&IGURE !NATOMY I]ZaVXg^bVahVgZkZgnhbVaa!i]^c![gV\^aZWdcZhd[gZXiVc\jaVgh]VeZ#I]ZaVXg^bVah bV`ZjeeVgid[i]ZbZY^ValVaahd[i]ZdgW^ihVciZg^dgidi]ZZi]bd^Y#I]ZnVgi^XjaViZ l^i] i]Z [gdciVa! bVm^aaVZ! Zi]bd^Y! VcY ^c[Zg^dg cVhVa XdcX]VZ# I]Zn VgZ k^gijVaan cZkZg[djcYVadcZWjiVgZd[iZcViiVX]ZYid[VX^Va[gV\bZcih#I]ZaVXg^bVah]VkZdg" W^iVaVcYcVhVaaViZgVaVcYbZY^Vahjg[VXZhVcY[djgWdgYZgh# ,#&+AVXg^bVah

&&(

3+5,,

eaViZhd[i]ZZi]bd^YVaaVWng^ci]h[dgbbdhid[i]ZbZY^VadgW^iValVaah!VcYi]Z bZY^VaeaViZh[dgbi]ZjeeZglVaahd[i]ZcVhVaXVk^in# Y# I]Z`Ub`U^TYSe\Qb`\QdUd[i]ZZi]bd^Y^hVÅViiZcZYaVb^cVeaVXZYVii]Zb^Y" a^cZWZilZZci]ZaViZgVabVhhZh#>i[dgbheVgid[i]ZcVhVahZeijbVcYVgi^XjaViZh ^c[Zg^dganl^i]i]ZkdbZg#

V# I]Z`_cdUbY_b\QSbY]Q\SbUcd^hVkZgi^XVaXgZhidc i]ZbZY^VadgW^iValVaai]ViWdjcYhi]ZedhiZg^dg ]Va[d[i]ZaVXg^bVa\gddkZ#

POSTERIOR LACRIMAL CREST

'ROWTH I]ZaVXg^bVadhh^ÄZh^cbZbWgVcZ[gdbVh^c\aZXZciZg#

,!4%2!, ANTERIORISTOTHERIGHT

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION I]ZaVXg^bVaXgZhi^hY^V\cdhi^X!VcYVai]dj\]i]ZaVXg^" bVa^hk^gijVaancZkZg[djcYVadcZ!^iXVcd[iZc]Zaeid ^YZci^[nVY_VXZciWdcZh#

3IDING

-%$)!, ANTERIORISTOTHELEFT &IGUREBYWXd\QSbY]Q\ HjeZg^dg^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

I]ZaVXg^bVaXgZhi^hdg^ZciZYkZgi^XVaan!VcYi]ZaVXg^bVa\gddkZ^hVciZg^dgidi]ZXgZhi# I]ZWVhZd[i]ZXgZhihlZZehVciZg^dganidWZXdbZVbVg\^c[dgi]ZaVXg^bVaXVcVa#

NASAL FORAMEN

.ASALS&IGURE !NATOMY I]ZcVhVahVgZhbVaa!i]^c!gZXiVc\jaVgWdcZheaVXZY dc Z^i]Zg h^YZ d[ i]Z b^Ya^cZ WZadl i]Z \aVWZaaVg gZ\^dcd[i]Z[gdciVa#I]Z^g[gZZ^c[Zg^dgZcYh[dgb i]ZidebVg\^cd[i]ZcVhVaVeZgijgZ#I]ZcVhVahVg" i^XjaViZl^i]i]Z[gdciVahjeZg^dgan!l^i]ZVX]di]Zg bZY^Vaan!VcYl^i]i]Z[gdciVaegdXZhhZhd[i]ZbVm" ^aaVZ aViZgVaan# I]Zn Vgi^XjaViZ edhiZg^dgan l^i] i]Z Zi]bd^Y# V# I]Z^QcQ\V_bQ]U^eZg[dgViZhi]Z[VX^Vahjg[VXZ VcYigVchb^ihVkZ^c# 

8]VeiZg,H`jaa

,!4%2!, ANTERIORISTOTHERIGHT SCALE

-%$)!, ANTERIORISTOTHELEFT &IGUREBYWXd^QcQ\ HjeZg^dg^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

3+5,,

'ROWTH :VX]cVhVadhh^ÄZh^cbZbWgVcZ[gdbVh^c\aZXZciZg#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION >i^hY^[ÄXjaiidXdc[jhZi]ZcVhVal^i]di]ZgWdcZhWZXVjhZd[^ihY^V\cdhi^X^ciZgcVhVa hjijgZ!i]ZZmiZgcVa[dgVbZcVcY^ciZgcVa\gddkZ!i]Zhbddi]djiZgVcYgdj\]^ccZg hjg[VXZ!VcYi]ZcdcVgi^XjaVg![gZZ^c[Zg^dgZY\Z#

3IDING JhZi]ZXg^iZg^VbZci^dcZY^cHZXi^dc,#&,#&idh^YZcVhVaWdcZh#

 ™

I]Z[gZZZY\Z^h^c[Zg^dg!i]Zi]^X`ZhiVgi^XjaVgZY\Z^hbZY^Va!VcYi]Z[gdciVahj" ijgZ^h^ciZgY^\^iVi^c\VcYhjeZg^dg#

:YGOMATICS&IGURE !NATOMY On\dbVi^Xh[dgbi]Zegdb^cZciXdgcZghX]ZZ`hd[i]Z[VXZ#I]ZZY\ZhVgZZVh^an^YZc" i^ÄVWaZ! l^i] i]Z gdjcYZY dgW^iVa g^b! i]Z h]Vge VgZV VgdjcY _j\VaZ VY_VXZci id i]Z iZbedgVa[dhhV!VcYi]Zgdj\]ZcZY^c[Zg^dgWdgYZg#:VX]on\dbVi^XWdcZVgi^XjaViZh! k^V^ihi]gZZbV^cegdXZhhZh!l^i]i]Z[gdciVa!he]Zcd^Y!iZbedgVa!VcYbVm^aaV# V# I]ZVb_^dQ\`b_SUccg^hZhkZgi^XVaanVcYhZeVgViZhi]ZdgW^i[gdbi]ZiZbedgVa[dhhV# W# I]ZdU]`_bQ\`b_SUccZmiZcYhedhiZg^dgan!_d^c^c\i]Zon\dbVi^XegdXZhhd[i]Z iZbedgVaWdcZid[dgbi]Zon\dbVi^XVgX]# X# I]Z]QhY\\Qbi`b_SUccZmiZcYhidlVgYi]Zb^Ya^cZ![dgb^c\i]Z^c[ZgdaViZgVa dgW^iVabVg\^c# Y# I]ZjiW_]QdYS_VQSYQ\V_bQ]U^eZg[dgViZhi]ZXdckZmaViZgVahjg[VXZd[i]Zon" \dbVi^X#>i^hd[iZcbjai^eaZ!Vaadl^c\i]ZeVhhV\Zd[i]Zon\dbVi^Xd[VX^VacZgkZV Y^k^h^dcd[XgVc^VacZgkZ*VcYkZhhZah#  Z# I]Z]QccUdUbYS_bYWY^!i]Zgdj\]ZcZY!ZmeVcYZY^c[Zg^dgZY\Zd[i]ZWdcZ!ZmiZcYh [gdbi]Zon\dbVi^XdbVm^aaVgnidi]ZiZbedgdon\dbVi^XhjijgZVcYdcidi]Z ,#&-On\dbVi^Xh

&&*

iZbedgVa#I]^h^hi]ZbV^cViiVX]bZcied^ci[dgi]ZbVhhZiZgbjhXaZ!VbV_dgZa" ZkVidgd[i]ZbVcY^WaZ#  [# JiW_]QdYS__bRYdQ\V_bQ]Y^QeZg[dgViZi]Z^c[ZgdaViZgVaXdgcZgd[i]ZdgW^iVa XVk^in[dgi]ZeVhhV\Zd[i]Zon\dbVi^XdiZbedgVaVcYon\dbVi^Xd[VX^VacZgkZh/Vahd Y^k^h^dchd[XgVc^VacZgkZ*# \# I]ZjiW_]QdYS_dU]`_bQ\V_bQ]U^^hXZciZgZY^ci]ZiZbedgVahjg[VXZd[i]Z on\dbVi^X#>iigVchb^ihi]Zon\dbVi^XdiZbedgVacZgkZ#

'ROWTH I]Zon\dbVi^XWdcZdhh^ÄZh[gdbi]gZZXZciZghi]Vi[jhZ^cidVh^c\aZXdbW^cZYXZciZg Yjg^c\[ZiVaYZkZadebZci#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION I]Zi]gZZY^V\cdhi^XWdgYZghd[i]Zon\dbVi^XWdcZbV`Z^YZci^ÄXVi^dcZVhn#I]Zbdhi [gZfjZciXdc[jh^dcXdbZh^cb^hiV`^c\i]Zon\dbVi^XegdXZhhd[i]ZiZbedgVa[dgi]Z on\dbVi^XWdcZ#CdcZd[i]ZegdXZhhZhd[i]Zon\dbVi^XWdcZegdeZgVgZVhi]^cdg ZmiZcYZYVhi]Zon\dbVi^XegdXZhhd[i]ZiZbedgVa#

3IDING Idh^YZ^hdaViZYdg[gV\bZciVgnon\dbVi^XWdcZh!gZbZbWZgi]ZgZaVi^dchd[i]^hWdcZ idi]ZdgW^i!i]ZbVhhZiZgbjhXaZ!VcYi]ZiZbedgVa[dhhV#

 ™

I]ZbVhhZiZg^XViiVX]bZci^h^c[Zg^dg!VcYi]ZXdckZmhjg[VXZ^hVciZg^dgVcYaVi" ZgVa!VcY^heZg[dgViZYWn[dgVb^cV#  ™ I]ZdgW^iVag^b^hWajciZgi]Vci]Z_j\VabVg\^cedhiZg^dgid^i# ZYGOMATICOORBITALFORAMINA FRONTALPROCESS ZYGOMATICOFACIAL FORAMEN MAXILLARY PROCESS

TEMPORALPROCESS

MASSETERIC ORIGIN

,!4%2!, ANTERIORISTOTHERIGHT

ZYGOMATICOTEMPORALFORAMEN -%$)!, ANTERIORISTOTHELEFT

&IGUREBYWXdjiW_]QdYSHjeZg^dg^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg,H`jaa

3+5,,

3PHENOID&IGURESn !NATOMY I]Z he]Zcd^Y ^h i]Z bdhi XdbeaZm WdcZ d[ i]Z XgVc^jb# 6ai]dj\] ^ih cVbZ bZVch ¹lZY\Za^`Z!º^ihh]VeZ^h[VgbdgZZaVWdgViZ#>i^hkZgnY^[ÄXjaiidk^hjVa^oZi]^hWdcZ l]Zcldg`^c\l^i]VcVgi^XjaViZYXgVc^jbWZXVjhZ^i]Vhhjg[VXZhi]Vi[VXZbVcnY^" gZXi^dch¸ZcYdXgVc^Vaan!^c[Zg^dgan!aViZgVaan!VcYVciZg^dgan#I]Zhe]Zcd^Y^hh^ijViZY WZilZZci]ZWdcZhd[i]ZXgVc^VakVjaiVcYi]dhZd[i]Z[VXZ#;dgi]^hgZVhdc!VcYWZ" XVjhZbVcneVgihd[i]ZWdcZVgZi]^c!i]Zhe]Zcd^Y^hk^gijVaancZkZg[djcY^ciVXi^c Wgd`ZcXgVc^V#>chiZVY!edgi^dchd[^iVY]ZgZiddi]ZgXgVc^Vae^ZXZh# I]Z bVcn Vgi^XjaVi^dch d[ i]Z he]Zcd^Y lZgZ cdiZY VWdkZ Vh ZVX] d[ i]Z ilZakZ WdcZh^iidjX]ZhlZgZ^cigdYjXZY#I]ZhZVgZgZk^ZlZY^ci]ZYZhXg^ei^dch\^kZc]ZgZ# I]Z Vgi^XjaVi^c\ b^Ya^cZ WdcZh VgZ i]Z kdbZg! Zi]bd^Y! [gdciVa! VcY dXX^e^iVa# I]Z he]Zcd^YVahdVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]ZeV^gZYeVg^ZiVah!iZbedgVah!on\dbVi^Xh!VcYeVaV" i^cZhVcYhdbZi^bZh!i]ZbVm^aaVZaViZgVaidi]Zb^Ya^cZ#:mVb^cVi^dcd[i]Zhe]Z" cd^Y^hh^bea^ÄZYWnYZVa^c\l^i][djgWVh^XeVgihd[i]ZWdcZ!i]ZWdYn!\gZViZgVcY aZhhZgl^c\h!VcYi]ZeiZgn\d^YeaViZh#;dgVcdkZgVaaeZgheZXi^kZ!k^Zli]Zhe]Zcd^Y [gdbWZ]^cY!k^hjVa^o^c\^iVhVÅn^c\Vc^bVal^i]VXZcigVaWdYn!ildeV^ghd[l^c\h! VcYYVc\a^c\iVadchi]ZeiZgn\d^YeaViZh# V# I]ZR_Ti^hi]ZdcaneVgid[i]Zhe]Zcd^Yi]Via^ZhdcVcY^bbZY^ViZanVY_VXZci idi]Zb^Ya^cZ#I]^h^hi]ZbdhihjWhiVci^VaeVgid[i]ZWdcZ#>ihVciZg^dghjg[VXZ [dgbhi]ZhjeZgdedhiZg^dglVaad[i]ZcVhVaXVk^inVcYVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]ZXg^W" g^[dgbVcYeZgeZcY^XjaVgeaViZhd[i]ZZi]bd^Y#EdhiZg^dgan!i]ZWdYnVgi^XjaViZh l^i]i]ZdXX^e^iVaVXgdhhi]Zhe]ZcddXX^e^iVadgWVh^aVghjijgZ0VciZgd^c[Zg^dgan ^iVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]ZkdbZg# W# ?`dYSSQ^Q\cVgZhZZcidZ^i]Zgh^YZd[i]ZWdYn#I]ZneVhhVciZgd^c[Zg^dgidi]Z aZhhZgl^c\h!_jhibZY^VaVcYhjeZg^dgidi]ZhjeZg^dgdgW^iVaÄhhjgZ#I]Zdei^X cZgkZXgVc^VacZgkZ'VcYde]i]Vab^XVgiZgneVhhi]gdj\]i]ZhZXVcVahdci]Z^g lVnidi]ZZnZWVaah# X# I]ZcU\\QdebSYSQ¹Ijg`^h]hVYYaZº^hVhVYYaZ"h]VeZYYZegZhh^dcdci]ZZcYd" XgVc^Vahjg[VXZd[i]Zhe]Zcd^Y#>i^hadXViZYZcYdXgVc^Vaan!edhiZg^dgVcY^c[Zg^dg idi]Zdei^XXVcVah!Videi]ZWdYnd[i]Zhe]Zcd^Y!YZXdgViZYWni]Z[djgXa^cd^Y egdXZhhZh# Y# I]ZXi`_`XicUQ\`YdeYdQbiV_ccQ^hi]ZYZZeZhiYZegZhh^dcd[i]ZhZaaV#>i]daYh i]Ze^ij^iVgn\aVcY!i]ZbVcj[VXijgZgd[\gdli]]dgbdcZh#  Z# I]ZT_bce]cU\\QU^hi]ZhfjVgZeaViZd[WdcZi]Vi[dgbhi]ZedhiZg^dgWdjcYVgn d[i]ZhZaaVijgX^XV# ,#&.He]Zcd^Y

&&,

SUPERIOR ORBITAL lSSURE

GREATERWING

ORBITAL SURFACE SPHENOIDAL SINUS SPHENOIDAL CREST

PTERYGOIDCANAL PTERYGOID PROCESS

&IGUREC`XU^_YTQ^dUbY_bHjeZg^dg^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

ANTERIORCLINOID PROCESS HYPOPHYSEAL FOSSA POSTERIORCLINOIDPROCESS &IGUREC`XU^_YTce`UbY_b6ciZg^dg^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

 [# I]Z`_cdUbY_bS\Y^_YT`b_SUccUcVgZi]Zild]^\]ankVg^VWaZijWZgXaZhadXViZYVi i]ZhjeZgdaViZgVaXdgcZghd[i]ZYdghjbhZaaVZ# \# I]ZS\Yfec^hi]Zha^\]iZcYdXgVc^Va]daadli]VihadeZhedhiZg^dgan[gdbi]ZYdg" hjbhZaaVZidlVgYi]Zhe]ZcddXX^e^iVahjijgZ# ]# I]Zc`XU^_YTQ\cY^ecUcVgZaVg\Z!eV^gZY]daadlhl^i]^ci]ZWdYnd[i]Zhe]Z" cd^Y# 

8]VeiZg,H`jaa

3+5,,

LESSERWING OPTIC CANAL

DORSUM SELLAE CLIVUS FORAMEN ROTUNDUM BODY PTERYGOID FOSSA LATERAL PTERYGOID PLATE

MEDIAL PTERYGOID PLATE

PTERYGOID HAMULUS

&IGUREC`XU^_YT`_cdUbY_bHjeZg^dg^hje#CVijgVah^oZ# SPHENOIDAL ROSTRUM

INFRATEMPORAL CREST FORAMENOVALE FORAMEN SPINOSUM

&IGUREC`XU^_YTY^VUbY_b6ciZg^dg^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

 ^# I]Zc`XU^_YTQ\b_cdbe]^hVb^Ya^cZWdcnegd_ZXi^dcdci]ZVciZgd^c[Zg^dghjg[VXZ d[i]ZWdYnd[i]Zhe]Zcd^Y#>iÄih^cidi]ZÄhhjgZWZilZZci]ZVaVZd[i]ZkdbZg#  _# I]Zc`XU^_YTQ\SbUcd^hXdci^cjdjhl^i]i]Zgdhigjb!ZmiZcY^c\hjeZg^dgan[gdb ^idci]ZVciZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]ZWdYnd[i]Zhe]Zcd^Y#I]^hb^Ya^cZhe]Zcd^YVa XgZhiVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]ZeZgeZcY^XjaVgeaViZd[i]ZZi]bd^YVcY[dgbheVgid[ i]ZhZeijbd[i]ZcdhZ# ,#&.He]Zcd^Y

&&.

`# I]ZWbUQdUbgY^Wcd[i]Zhe]Zcd^Yg^\]iVcYaZ[iVgZViiVX]ZYidi]ZWdYn#I]Zn VgZi]ZhZ\bZcihi]ViZmiZcYi]Z[Vgi]ZhiaViZgVaan[gdbi]ZWdYn![dgb^c\bdhi d[i]Zb^YYaZXgVc^Va[dhhVZZcYdXgVc^VaanVcYbjX]d[i]ZiZbedgVa[dhhVZZXid" XgVc^Vaan#I]Z\gZViZgl^c\hVgi^XjaViZl^i]i]ZiZbedgVah!eVg^ZiVah![gdciVa!on\d" bVi^Xh!VcYbVm^aaVZ#  a# I]Zce`UbY_b_bRYdQ\ÍccebUcVgZi]ZdeZcheVXZh\VehWZilZZci]Z^c[Zg^dg hjg[VXZhd[i]ZaZhhZgl^c\hVcYi]ZVciZg^dghjg[VXZhd[i]Z\gZViZgl^c\h#I]ZÄh" hjgZhVgZk^h^WaZVii]ZWVX`d[i]ZdgW^ih^cVcVciZg^dgk^Zld[i]ZXgVc^jb#I]Z hjeZg^dgdgW^iVaÄhhjgZVcYi]gZZ[dgVb^cV^YZci^ÄZYaViZgVgZWZhihZZcdci]Z ZcYdXgVc^Vahjg[VXZd[i]Zhe]Zcd^Y#I]ZhZdeZc^c\hVgZVggVc\ZY^ci]Z[dgbd[ VcVgXi]VihlZZehedhiZgdaViZgVaan[gdbi]Zb^Ya^cZ^ci]ZVgZVl]ZgZi]Z\gZViZg l^c\VcYWdYnbZg\Z#I]ZVgX^hhdbZi^bZhXVaaZYi]Z¹XgZhXZcid[[dgVb^cV#º b# I]ZV_bQ]U^b_de^Te]^hh^ijViZY^ci]ZbdhiVciZg^dgVcYbZY^VaeVgid[i]Z b^YYaZXgVc^Va[dhhVZVii]Z_jcXi^dcd[i]Z\gZViZgl^c\hVcYi]ZWdYn#I]ZhZ[d" gVb^cVigVchb^ii]ZbVm^aaVgncZgkZhVcdi]ZgY^k^h^dcd[XgVc^VacZgkZ*i]Vigjc _jhi^c[Zg^dgidi]ZhjeZg^dgdgW^iVaÄhhjgZh# c# I]ZV_bQ]U^_fQ\U^hadXViZYedhiZg^dgidi]Z[dgVbZcgdijcYjbdcZVX]h^YZ! Veegdm^bViZan^ca^cZl^i]i]ZYdghjbhZaaVZ^cZcYdXgVc^Vak^Zl#I]ZhZ[dgVb" ^cVigVchb^ii]ZbVcY^WjaVgcZgkZhVcYVXXZhhdgnbZc^c\ZVaVgiZg^Zh# d# I]ZV_bQ]U^c`Y^_ce]^hadXViZYdcZVX]\gZViZgl^c\_jhiedhiZgdaViZgVaidi]Z [dgVbZcdkVaZ#I]Z[dgVb^cVhe^cdhVVgZhZi^ci]ZedhiZgd^c[Zg^dghe^cZhd[i]Z he]Zcd^Y!kZgnXadhZidi]ZiZbedgVaWdcZh#I]ZnigVchb^ii]Zb^YYaZbZc^c\ZVa kZhhZahVcYWgVcX]Zh[gdbi]ZbVcY^WjaVgcZgkZh# e# I]ZY^VbQdU]`_bQ\SbUcdcbVg`i]ZZXidXgVc^Vahjg[VXZhd[i]Z\gZViZgl^c\h# I]Zn[dgbi]ZWVhZd[i]ZiZbedgVa[dhhVZViVWdjii]ZaZkZad[i]Zon\dbVi^X VgX]Zh# f# I]Z_bRYdQ\cebVQSUcd[i]Z\gZViZgl^c\hd[i]Zhe]Zcd^Y!l]^X][dgbi]ZaViZgVa lVaad[ZVX]dgW^i!VgZkZgnhbddi]VcYÅVi^cXdbeVg^hdcidi]ZZcYdXgVc^Vahjg" [VXZh#  g# I]Z\UccUbgY^Wc!l]^X]VgZbjX]hbVaaZgi]Vci]Z\gZViZg!VgZi]^c!l^c\" h]VeZYedhiZg^dgegd_ZXi^dchd[i]ZZcYdXgVc^Vahjg[VXZ#I]ZhZeVgi^VaanÅddgi]Z g^\]iVcYaZ[i[gdciVaadWZhd[i]ZWgV^c#I]ZnVg^hZ[gdbi]ZhjeZg^dghjg[VXZd[ i]ZWdYnVcYVgi^XjaViZl^i]i]Z]dg^odciVadgW^iVaeaViZhd[i]Z[gdciVa#  h# I]ZQ^dUbY_bS\Y^_YT`b_SUccUcVgZi]ZedhiZg^dgbdhiegd_ZXi^dchd[i]ZaZhhZg l^c\h#I]ZhZ\^kZViiVX]bZciidi]ZiZcidg^jbXZgZWZaa^!VhZ\bZcid[YjgVbViZg i]VihZeVgViZhi]ZXZgZWZaajb[gdbi]ZdXX^e^iVaeVgid[i]ZXZgZWgVa]Zb^he]ZgZhd[ i]ZWgV^c#  i# I]Z`dUbiW_YT`b_SUccUcd[i]Zhe]Zcd^YVgZk^h^WaZdcan[gdbWZadldgidi]Z h^YZd[i]ZXgVc^jb#I]ZeiZgn\d^YegdXZhhZhVgZZVX]Y^k^YZY^cidildi]^ceaViZh# j# I]Z\QdUbQ\`dUbiW_YT`\QdU\Q]Y^Q^hVi]^ckZgi^XVaeaViZd[WdcZhZZc^caVi" ZgVak^Zld[i]ZXgVc^jb# k# I]Z]UTYQ\`dUbiW_YT`\QdU\Q]Y^Q^hVi]^ckZgi^XVaeaViZd[WdcZi]Vigdj\]" aneVgVaaZahi]ZaViZgVaeaViZ^cdg^ZciVi^dcWji^hhZiXadhZgidi]Zb^Ya^cZ#:VX] eV^gd[eiZgn\d^YeaViZhVgi^XjaViZhVciZg^dganl^i]i]ZeVaVi^cZh#I]ZhZ[djgi]^c egd_ZXi^dchegdk^YZViiVX]bZci[dgi]ZbZY^VaeiZgn\d^YbjhXaZh!bVcY^WjaVgZaZkV" idgh# l# @dUbiW_YTV_ccQUVgZgdj\]"ÅddgZY]daadlhWZilZZci]ZbZY^VaVcYaViZgVa 

8]VeiZg,H`jaa

'ROWTH I]Zhe]Zcd^Y^hbdhian[dgbZY^cXVgi^aV\Z0dcani]ZeiZgn\d^YeaViZh[dgbYZgbVaan#
0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION 7ZXVjhZ^i]VhhdbVcneVgih!Wgd`Zc[gV\bZcihd[he]Zcd^YVgZd[iZcY^[ÄXjaiid^YZc" i^[n#DcanVc^ciZch^kZhijYnd[i]ZkVg^djhVcVidb^XVaeVgih^cigdYjXZYVWdkZl^aaVa" adlXdcÄYZci^YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[^hdaViZY[gV\bZcih#;dgijcViZan![gV\bZcihd[he]Zcd^Y VgZjhjVaanViiVX]ZYiddi]ZgXgVc^VaWdcZh!VcY^YZci^ÄXVi^dc^hV^YZYWni]^h[VXi#I]Z eVgihbdhid[iZc[djcY^hdaViZYVgZi]Z\gZViZgl^c\hVcYi]ZWdYn# I]ZcVijgZd[i]ZhjijgZWZilZZci]ZiZbedgVa!eVg^ZiVa!VcYhe]Zcd^Y]Zaeh^ci]Z ^YZci^ÄXVi^dcVcYh^Y^c\d[he]Zcd^Y[gV\bZcih#I]Zhe]Zcd^YdkZgaVehi]ZeVg^ZiVa hjeZg^dganVcYjcYZgaVehi]ZiZbedgVaedhiZg^dgan#>iVWjihi]ZiZbedgVa^cWVh^XgVc^Va VheZXi#

3IDING

 ™

;dgeiZgn\d^YeaViZh!i]ZeiZgn\d^Y[dhhV[VXZhedhiZg^dgan!VcYi]ZeaViZh]VkZcdc" Vgi^XjaVg!h]VgeedhiZg^dgVcY^c[Zg^dgZY\Zh#  ™ ;dgi]Z\gZViZgl^c\!i]Zhbddi]!ÅVidgW^iVahjg[VXZh[VXZVciZg^dgan!VcYi]ZXdc" XVkZiZbedgVahjg[VXZh[VXZaViZgVaan#  ™ I]ZZcYdXgVc^Vahjg[VXZ^hedhiZgdhjeZg^dg!VcY^ihWVhZ^hbVg`ZYWni]Z[dgVb^cV gdijcYV!dkVaZ!VcYhe^cdhV#I]ZaViiZg[dgVbZc^hVii]Zhe^cZd[i]Z\gZViZgl^c\! i]ZbdhiedhiZgdaViZgVaZmiZcid[i]Zl^c\!d[iZcdci]Zhe]ZcdhfjVbdhVahjijgZ#  ™ ;dgV[gV\bZciVgnaZhhZgl^c\!i]Z[gZZ!cdcVgi^XjaVgZcY^hedhiZg^dg!i]Zl^c\i^eh [VXZaViZgVaan!VcYeVgihd[i]Z[gdciVad[iZcVY]ZgZVciZg^dgan#I]ZVciZg^dgXa^cd^Y egdXZhhed^cihedhiZg^dgan#

,#&.He]Zcd^Y

&'&

3+5,,

eiZgn\d^YeaViZh# m# I]Z`dUbiW_YTXQ]e\ec^hi]Z]dd`"a^`ZegdXZhh[dgb^c\i]ZedhiZgdaViZgVa! WVhVaXdgcZgd[ZVX]bZY^VaeiZgn\d^YeaViZ# n# @dUbiW_YTSQ^Q\ceZg[dgViZi]ZWdcZVWdkZi]ZeiZgn\d^YeaViZhVcYgjcVadc\i]Z WVhZd[i]ZhZeaViZh#

-ANDIBLE&IGURESn !NATOMY I]ZbVcY^WaZ!dgadlZg_Vl!Vgi^XjaViZhi]gdj\]^ihXdcYnaZhk^VVcVgi^XjaVgY^h`l^i] i]Z iZbedgVa WdcZh Vi i]Z iZbedgdbVcY^WjaVg _d^ci# I]Z eg^bVgn [jcXi^dc d[ i]^h WdcZ^h^c]QcdYSQdY_^X]Zl^c\#I]ZbVcY^WaZ]daYhi]ZadlZgiZZi]VcYegdk^YZh ^chZgi^dchjg[VXZh[dgi]ZbjhXaZhd[bVhi^XVi^dc#I]ZhZild[jcXi^dchVgZeZg[dgbZY Wni]ZildWVh^XeVgihd[i]ZbVcY^WaZ/i]ZWdYnXdgejhVcYi]ZVhXZcY^c\gVbjh# V# I]ZR_TiS_b`ec!dgX_bYj_^dQ\bQ]ec^hi]Zi]^X`!WdcneVgid[i]ZbVcY^WaZ i]ViVcX]dghi]ZiZZi]#L^i]^ih^beaVciZYiZZi]!i]ZXdgejhd[i]ZbVcY^WaZ^h kZgn]VgY!YZchZ!VcYgZh^hiVciidYZhigjXi^dc#;dgi]^hgZVhdc!bVcY^WjaVgXdgedgV djiaVhidi]ZgWdYneVgih^cWdcZVhhZbWaV\Zhi]Vi]VkZWZZcgVkV\ZYWnXVgc^"

CORPUS

EXTRAMOLARSULCUS ENDOCORONOIDRIDGE

MANDIBULARCONDYLE

&IGURE=Q^TYR\Uce`UbY_bCVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg,H`jaa

,#'%BVcY^WaZ

&'(

3+5,,

kdgZhdghjW_ZXiZYide]nh^XVaYZ\gVYVi^dc# W# I]Z]U^dQ\V_bQ]U^^hi]ZaVg\Z!hdbZi^bZhbjai^eaZ[dgVbZcadXViZYdci]Z aViZgVaXdgejhhjg[VXZ!cZVgb^YXdgejh!WZadli]ZegZbdaVggZ\^dc#I]^h[dgVbZc igVchb^ihi]ZbZciVakZhhZahVcYcZgkZVcdi]ZgY^k^h^dcd[XgVc^VacZgkZ*# X# I]Z_R\YaeU\Y^U^hVlZV`Zb^cZcXZi]VieVhhZh[gdbi]Zgddid[i]ZgVbjhidi]Z VgZVVii]ZgZVgd[i]ZbZciVa[dgVbZc# Y# I]ZUhdbQ]_\Qbce\Sec^hi]Z\jiiZgWZilZZci]Zgddid[i]ZVciZg^dgZY\Zd[i]Z gVbjhVcYi]ZaViZgVaVakZdaVgbVg\^cd[i]ZaVhibdaVg#I]^hVgZV\^kZhg^hZidi]Z WjXX^cVidgbjhXaZ!i]ZbjhXaZd[i]ZX]ZZ`#  Z# I]Z]i\_Xi_YT\Y^UdWa^fjZanXgdhhZhi]ZbZY^Vahjg[VXZd[i]ZXdgejh!WZ\^c" c^c\cZVgi]ZVakZdaVgbVg\^cVii]ZaVhibdaVgedh^i^dcVcYY^b^c^h]^c\Vh^i gjchVciZgd^c[Zg^dgan#>ibVg`hVcViiVX]bZcih^iZ[dgi]Zbnad]nd^YbjhXaZ!Vbjh" XaZi]Vi[dgbhi]ZbjhXjaVgÅddgd[i]ZdgVaXVk^inVcYVXihidZaZkViZi]Zidc\jZ VcY]nd^YWdcZ#  [# I]ZceR]Q^TYRe\QbV_ccQ^hi]Z]daadlWZcZVi]i]ZVakZdaVgedgi^dci]Vigjch Vadc\i]ZbZY^VaXdgejh!^c[Zg^dgidi]Zbnad]nd^Ya^cZ#>ca^[Z!i]ZhjWbVcY^WjaVg \aVcY!dcZd[i]ZhVa^kVgn\aVcYh!gZhih^ci]^h[dhhV# \# I]ZceR\Y^WeQ\V_ccQ^hi]Z]daadl^c\WZcZVi]i]ZVakZdaVggZ\^dc!hjeZg^dgid i]Zbnad]nd^Ya^cZ^ci]ZegZbdaVggZ\^dc#I]ZhjWa^c\jVa\aVcY!Vcdi]ZghVa^kVgn \aVcY!gZhih^ci]^h[dhhV# ]# 6]Q^TYRe\Qbd_bec^hi]ZkVg^VWanYZkZadeZYi]^X`Zc^c\d[i]ZVakZdaVgbVg\^c _jhia^c\jVaidi]ZX]ZZ`iZZi]#I]^h[ZVijgZiV`ZhdcVW^aadlZYVeeZVgVcXZ^c^ih bdhiZmigZbZbVc^[ZhiVi^dchWji^hd[iZc^beZgXZei^WaZ#  ^# I]Z]Q^TYRe\Qbci]`XicYciZX]c^XVaangZ[Zghdcanidi]Zb^Ya^cZhjg[VXZhd[ jc[jhZYg^\]iVcYaZ[ibVcY^WjaVg]VakZh^c^cY^k^YjVahaZhhi]Vc&nZVgd[V\Z#>i ^hd[iZcjhZYVhVbdgZ\ZcZgVaiZgbgZ[Zgg^c\idi]ZVciZg^dggZ\^dcd[i]ZbVc" Y^WaZWZilZZci]ZXVc^cZh#  _# I]Z]U^dQ\c`Y^Uca^ZcZVgi]Z^c[Zg^dgbVg\^cd[i]Z^ccZgedhiZg^dghjg[VXZd[ i]ZVciZg^dgXdgejh#I]ZnVgZkVg^VWaZ^cegdb^cZcXZVcYVcX]dgi]Z\Zc^d\adhhVa VcY\Zc^d]nd^YbjhXaZh!bjhXaZhd[i]Zidc\jZ# `# I]ZTYWQcdbYSV_ccQUVgZi]ZeV^gd[gdj\]ZcZYYZegZhh^dchdci]ZedhiZgd^c[Zg^dg VheZXid[i]ZXdgejhVY_VXZciidi]Zb^Ya^cZ#I]Zn[VXZedhiZgd^c[Zg^dganVcYVgZ ViiVX]bZcih^iZh[dgi]ZY^\Vhig^XbjhXaZh!YZegZhhdghd[i]ZbVcY^WaZ#  a# I]Z]U^dQ\`b_deRUbQ^SU]U^dQ\U]Y^U^SU^hi]Zig^Vc\jaVgZb^cZcXZ!dg WdcnX]^c!Vii]ZWVhZd[i]ZXdgejh^ci]ZVciZg^dghnbe]nhZVagZ\^dc#>i^hhZeV" gViZY[gdbi]ZVakZdaVgbVg\^chd[i]Z^cX^hdghWnVegdcdjcXZY^cXjgkVi^dcdg ¹bZciVahjaXjhºdgi]Z¹aVW^dbZciVahjaXjhº^[ÅZh]^hhi^aaViiVX]ZYidi]ZYZegZh" h^dc^cbdYZgc]jbVch# b# I]ZbQ]ecdgQcSU^TY^WbQ]ec^hXdch^YZgVWani]^ccZgi]Vci]ZXdgejh#I]^h kZgi^XVaeVgid[i]ZbVcY^WaZg^hZhVWdkZi]ZaZkZad[i]ZiZZi]VcYVgi^XjaViZhl^i] i]ZXgVc^VaWVhZ# c# I]Z]Q^TYRe\QbS_^Ti\U^hi]ZaVg\Z!gdjcYZY!Vgi^XjaVgegdb^cZcXZdci]Zedh" iZgdhjeZg^dgXdgcZgd[i]ZgVbjh#>iVgi^XjaViZhVii]ZiZbedgdbVcY^WjaVg_d^ci# d# I]ZS_^Ti\Qb^US[^hi]ZVgZV_jhiVciZgd^c[Zg^dgidi]ZXdcYnaZ#6]ZVYd[i]Z aViZgVaeiZgn\d^YbjhXaZViiVX]Zhidi]ZVciZgdbZY^Vahjg[VXZd[i]ZcZX`_jhiWZadl i]ZVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZd[i]ZXdcYnaZ!^ci]Z`dUbiW_YTV_fUQ#I]^hbjhXaZVXihid YZegZhhVcYhiVW^a^oZi]ZbVcY^WjaVgXdcYnaZYjg^c\X]Zl^c\#

CONDYLARNECK

MANDIBULAR FORAMEN

LINGULA MYLOHYOIDGROOVE PTERYGOIDTUBEROSITIES

MENTALSPINES DIGASTRICFOSSA

MYLOHYOID LINE SUBMANDIBULAR FOSSA SUBLINGUALFOSSA

&IGURE=Q^TYR\U`_cdUbY_bCVijgVah^oZ#

e# I]ZS_b_^_YT`b_SUccd[i]ZgVbjh^hi]^cVcYig^Vc\jaVg!kVgn^c\l^YZan^c h]VeZVcYgdWjhi^X^in#>ihVciZg^dgWdgYZg^hi]^X`ZcZYVcYXdckZm!VcY^ihedhiZ" g^dgZY\Z^hXdcXVkZVcYi]^ccZg#7di]bZY^VaVcYaViZgVahjg[VXZhd[i]^hegdXZhh gZXZ^kZi]Z^chZgi^dcd[i]ZiZbedgVa^hbjhXaZ# f# I]Z]Q^TYRe\Qb^_dSXY^SYcebQ^hi]ZcdiX]WZilZZci]ZXdcYnaZVcYi]ZXdgd" cd^YegdXZhh#  g# I]ZQ^W\UdgW_^YQ\Q^W\U^hi]ZgdjcYZYedhiZgd^c[Zg^dgXdgcZgd[i]ZbVcY^" WaZ#I]ZbVhhZiZgbjhXaZViiVX]bZci^hXZciZgZYdci]ZaViZgVahjg[VXZd[i]ZgVbjh! VaaVadc\i]ZVc\aZ#  h# I]Z]QccUdUbYSdeRUb_cYdi^hi]ZgV^hZY!gdj\]ZcZYVgZVVii]ZaViZgVaZY\Zd[ i]Z\dc^VaVc\aZVil]^X]i]ZbVhhZiZgbjhXaZViiVX]Zh#I]^hVgZV^hd[iZc_d^cZY WndWa^fjZg^Y\ZhgV^hZYWnbVhhZiZgViiVX]bZci#L]Zci]ZZY\Zd[i]Z\dc^Va Vc\aZegd_ZXih[VgaViZgVaan[gdbi]ZgZhid[i]ZgVbjh!i]Z\dc^VaVgZV^hhV^YidWZ higdc\anUfUbdUT#



8]VeiZg,H`jaa

3+5,,

CORONOIDPROCESS MANDIBULARNOTCH RAMUSASCENDINGRAMUS

MASSETERIC TUBEROSITY

MASSETERIC FOSSA OBLIQUELINE MENTALFORAMEN MENTALPROTUBERANCE

&IGURE=Q^TYR\U\QdUbQ\CVijgVah^oZ#

 i# I]Z]QccUdUbYSV_ccQ^hVkVg^VWanZmegZhhZY]daadl^c\dci]ZaViZgVahjg[VXZd[ i]Z\dc^VaVc\aZ# j# I]ZU^T_S_b_^_YTbYTWU!dgReddbUcc!^hi]ZkZgi^XVag^Y\ZZmiZcY^c\^c[Zg^dgan [gdbi]ZXdgdcd^Yi^edci]Z^ccZgbZY^VaVheZXid[i]ZgVbjh# k# I]Z]Q^TYRe\QbV_bQ]U^ZciZghi]ZWdcZdWa^fjZan!XZciZgZY^ci]ZbZY^Vahjg" [VXZd[i]ZgVbjh#I]ZVakZdaVgkZhhZahVcY^c[Zg^dgVakZdaVgcZgkZVY^k^h^dcd[XgV" c^VacZgkZ*ZciZgi]ZWdcZi]gdj\]i]^hdeZc^c\!gjcc^c\i]gdj\]i]ZbVcY^WaZ k^Vi]Z]Q^TYRe\QbSQ^Q\# l# I]Z\Y^We\Q^hVh]Vge!kVg^VWanh]VeZYegd_ZXi^dcVii]ZZY\Zd[i]ZbVcY^WjaVg [dgVbZc#>i^hi]ZViiVX]bZcied^ci[dgi]Zhe]ZcdbVcY^WjaVga^\VbZci# m# I]Z]i\_Xi_YTWb__fUce\SecXgdhhZhi]ZbZY^Vahjg[VXZd[i]ZgVbjh!gjcc^c\ VciZgd^c[Zg^dgan[gdbi]ZZY\Zd[i]ZbVcY^WjaVg[dgVbZc#>iadY\Zhi]Zbnad]nd^Y kZhhZahVcYcZgkZ# n# @dUbiW_YTdeRUb_cYdYUc^ciZggjeii]ZbZY^Vahjg[VXZd[i]Z\dc^VaVc\aZedhiZgd"

,#'%BVcY^WaZ

&'*

^c[Zg^dgidi]Zbnad]nd^Y\gddkZ#I]ZnbVg`i]Z^chZgi^dcd[i]ZbZY^VaeiZgn\d^Y bjhXaZ!VcZaZkVidgd[i]ZbVcY^WaZ#

'ROWTH I]ZbVcY^WjaVg]VakZhVgZhZeVgViZViW^gi]0i]Zn_d^cYjg^c\i]ZÄghinZVgVii]Zhnb" e]nh^h#6iW^gi]i]ZbVcY^WaZ]daYhjcZgjeiZYYZX^YjdjhiZZi]^cXgneihWZadli]Z hjg[VXZ#I]ZZgjei^dcd[i]ZhZiZZi]VcYi]Z^geZgbVcZciXdjciZgeVgihZ[[ZXihYgVbVi^X X]Vc\Zhdci]ZbVcY^WaZYjg^c\dcid\Zcn#Adhhd[eZgbVcZciiZZi]gZhjaih^cgZhdge" i^dcd[i]ZVakZdaVgedgi^dcd[i]ZbVcY^WaZ#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION DcanhbVaa[gV\bZcihd[bVcY^WaZXVcWZXdc[jhZYl^i]di]ZgWdcZh#L]ZgZiddi] hdX`Zih VgZ egZhZci! i]Z WdcZ bjhi WZ bVm^aaV dg bVcY^WaZ# I]Z [dgbZg ]Vh V h^cjh VWdkZi]ZbdaVggddih#

 ™

I]ZbVcY^WjaVgXdgejh]VhVbjX]i]^X`ZgXdgiZmi]Vci]ZbVm^aaV!VhlZaaVhV WVhVaXdcidjg#  ™ I]ZXdgdcd^YegdXZhhb^\]iWZb^hiV`Zc[dgi]^cXgVc^VaWdcZh!hjX]Vhi]Zhe]Z" cd^Ydgon\dbVi^X#CdiZ!]dlZkZg!i]Vii]ZXdgdcd^YYdZhcdiVgi^XjaViZVcY^ih ZY\ZhVgZi]ZgZ[dgZcdchjijgVa#

3IDING Idh^YZ[gV\bZcihd[bVcY^WaZ!gZbZbWZgi]Vii]Z^cX^hdghVgZVciZg^dgVcYXadhZgid i]Zb^Ya^cZi]Vci]ZbdaVgh!VcYi]Vii]ZgVbjh^hedhiZg^dg!l^i]\gZViZggZa^Z[dc^ih bZY^Vahjg[VXZ#

 ™

;dg^hdaViZYXdcYnaZh!i]ZWdgYZgd[i]ZbVcY^WjaVgcdiX]^hXdci^cjdjhl^i]i]Z aViZgVah^YZd[i]ZXdcYnaZbdhid[i]ZXdcYnaZ^ihZa[a^ZhbZY^Vaidi]ZeaVcZd[ i]ZgVbjh#  ™ ;dg^hdaViZYXdgdcd^Yh!i]ZcdiX]^hedhiZg^dg!i]Zi^ehjeZg^dg!VcYi]ZZcYdXdgd" cd^YWjiigZhhbZY^Va#  ™ ;dg^hdaViZY\dc^VaVc\aZh!ijWZgdh^i^Zh[dgi]ZbZY^VaeiZgn\d^YVgZbZY^VaVcYVgZ VciZgdhjeZg^dganY^gZXiZY#



8]VeiZg,H`jaa

#HAPTER $%.4)4)/.

9Zci^i^dc I

]Z jeeZg VcY adlZg _Vlh VgZ YZgbVa WdcZh l^i] V [VhX^cVi^c\ Zkdaji^dcVgn ]^hidgn#IZZi]^ci]ZjeeZgVcYadlZg_VlhhZZbid]VkZZkdakZY[gdbÄh]hXVaZh# I]Za^k^c\XdgZd[VbVbbVa^Vciddi]^hVYZchZWdcZa^`ZbViZg^VaXVaaZYTU^dY^!dg TU^dY^U!VheZX^VaineZd[XVaX^ÄZYWjiha^\]iangZh^a^ZciXdccZXi^kZi^hhjZi]ViZmiZcYh ^cidVhdX`Zi^ci]Z_Vl#I]ZXgdlcd[i]Ziddi]^hXdkZgZYl^i]VaVnZgd[ZmigZbZan ]VgY!Wg^iiaZbViZg^Va`cdlcVhU^Q]U\#I]ZhZWVh^Xi^hhjZh]VkZWZZcbdaYZYWnZkd" aji^dc^cidVc^begZhh^kZkVg^Zind[h]VeZhVcYh^oZhVbdc\i]ZkZgiZWgViZh# I]ZYZci^i^dc^hdcZd[i]Zbdhi^bedgiVcieVgihd[]jbVcVcVidbn[dgi]ZdhiZ" dad\^hi#IZZi]dlZi]Z^g^bedgiVcXZ^ceVaZdcidad\nVcYVci]gdedad\nidVkVg^Zind[ [VXidgh#D[Vaai]Zh`ZaZiVaZaZbZcih!iZZi]VgZi]ZbdhigZh^hiVciidX]Zb^XVaVcYe]nh^" XVaYZhigjXi^dc#I]ZnVgZ!i]ZgZ[dgZ!dkZggZegZhZciZYgZaVi^kZiddi]ZgeVgihd[i]Zh`Za" Zidc^cVabdhiVaaVgX]Zdad\^XVaVcYeVaZdcidad\^XVaVhhZbWaV\Zh#>cVYY^i^dcidWZ^c\ VWjcYVci!iZZi]Xdchi^ijiZV[dXjhd[Vci]gdedad\^XVaVcYeVaZdcidad\^XVa^ciZgZhiWZ" XVjhZi]ZnVgZhd^c[dgbVi^kZVWdjii]Z^cY^k^YjVal]dedhhZhhZYi]Zb#IZZi]egdk^YZ ^c[dgbVi^dcdci]ZV\Z!hZm!]ZVai]!Y^Zi!VcYZkdaji^dcVgngZaVi^dch]^ehd[ZmiVciVcY Zmi^cXibVbbVah!]db^c^Yh^cXajYZY# IZZi]VgZ[dgbZYYZZel^i]^ci]Z_VlhVcYi]ZcZgjeii]gdj\]i]Z\jbi^hhjZdcXZ cZVganXdbeaZiZ#Jca^`Zi]ZX]Vc\^c\h]VeZhd[di]Zgh`ZaZiVaZaZbZcih!iddi]Xgdlc bdge]dad\nXVcdcanWZVaiZgZYWnQddbYdY_^iddi]lZVg!WgZV`V\Z!dgYZb^cZgVa^oV" i^dcdcXZi]ZXgdlcZgjeih#Iddi]bdge]dad\nXVcWZjhZYidZ[[ZXi^kZanY^[[ZgZci^ViZ WZilZZcedejaVi^dchl^i]^cVheZX^Zh!heZX^Zhl^i]^cV\Zcjh!VcYhd[dgi]#I]ZhiVW^a" ^inVcYVYVei^kZh^\c^ÄXVcXZd[iddi][dgbZhiVWa^h]i]ZYZci^i^dcVhVXZciZge^ZXZ^c bVcnXdbeVgVi^kZedejaVi^dcVaVcYZkdaji^dcVgnhijY^Zh#;^cVaan!iZZi]VgZi]Zdcan ]VgYi^hhjZhd[i]ZWdYni]ViVgZY^gZXiandWhZgkVWaZl^i]djiY^hhZXi^dcdggVY^d\gVe]n# 9ZciVabZVhjgZbZciVcYiZgb^cdad\nVgZY^hXjhhZY^c8]VeiZg+#9ZciVaeVi]da" d\n^hgZk^ZlZY^c8]VeiZg&,#I]ZjhZd[YZci^i^dc^chZm^c\VcYV\^c\VcY^cZhi^" bVi^c\edejaVi^dcY^hiVcXZ^hXdkZgZY^c8]VeiZg&.#I]Zeg^cX^eaZhd[^YZci^ÄXVi^dc Y^hXjhhZY^ci]^hX]VeiZg[dgbi]ZkZgn[djcYVi^dcdcl]^X]Vaadi]ZgVheZXihd[YZciVa hijY^ZhVgZWVhZY#

$ENTAL&ORMAND&UNCTION IZZi]Xdchi^ijiZi]ZeVgid[i]Zh`ZaZidci]Vi^ciZgVXihY^gZXianl^i]i]ZZck^gdcbZci! hZgk^c\idhZ^oZVcYbVhi^XViZX]Zl[ddYbViZg^Va!l]^X]^hhjWhZfjZcianeVhhZY[Vg" &',

i]ZgVadc\i]ZY^\Zhi^kZhnhiZb#7di]i]Z^ciZgcVaXdbedh^i^dcVcYi]ZZmiZgcVabdg" e]dad\nd[iZZi]VgZVYVeiZYidi]^h[jcXi^dc^cXdch^YZgVWaZYZiV^aVbdc\bVbbVah# >cVYjai]db^c^Yh;^\jgZ-#&!Y^SYc_bcVgZi]ZZ^\]iheVijaViZiZZi]^ci]Z[gdcid[i]Z jeeZgVcYadlZg_Vlh[djg^cZVX]_Vl!ilddci]Zg^\]iVcYilddci]ZaZ[i#Jcldgc ^cX^hdghY^heaVnh]Vge!i]^cXjii^c\ZY\Zh#BdYZgc]jbVcSQ^Y^Uc[jcXi^dceg^bVg^an VhedhiZg^dgZmiZch^dchd[i]Z^cX^hdggdlh!Wjii]ZngZiV^cVbdgZXdc^XVah]VeZi]Vc i]Z^cX^hdgh#=jbVc`bU]_\QbcVgZiZgbZY¹W^Xjhe^YhºWnYZci^hih#>c]jbVchi]ZgZ VgZ[djgegZbdaVghildeV^gh^ci]ZjeeZg_VlVcY[djg^ci]ZadlZg_Vl#>ceg^b^i^kZ bVbbVahi]ZgZlZgZZ^\]i^cZVX]_Vl!Wjii]ZbZh^VaVciZg^dgildeV^ghd[egZbdaVgh ]VkZWZZcadhiYjg^c\i]ZXdjghZd[eg^bViZZkdaji^dc#;dgi]VigZVhdc!i]ZÄghiegZbd" aVgWZ]^cYi]ZXVc^cZ^ci]Z]jbVcYZci^i^dc^h^YZci^ÄZYVhi]Zi]^gYegZbdaVgWZ" XVjhZ^idXXje^Zhi]Zi]^gYd[i]Z[djgdg^\^cVaegZbdaVgedh^i^dch#=_\QbcbV`Zjei]Z gZhid[]jbVcYZci^i^dc#I]ZhZVgZi]ZaVg\ZhiiZZi]0i]Z^gZmiZch^kZX]Zl^c\hjg[VXZh Zbe]Vh^oZXgjh]^c\VcY\g^cY^c\gVi]Zgi]Vch]ZVg^c\d[[ddYbViZg^Va#I]ZgZVgZjhj" Vaanh^mbdaVghildhZihd[i]gZZiZZi]^cWdi]jeeZgVcYadlZgVYjai]jbVc_Vlh# 4USYTe_ec`bY]Qbidg]Y\[iZZi]VgZi]ZÄghiid[dgb!Zgjei!VcY[jcXi^dc^c i]ZÄghinZVghd[a^[Z#I]ZhZiZZi]VgZhnhiZbVi^XVaanh]ZYVcYgZeaVXZYWni]Z^g`Ub]Q ^U^dcUS_^TQbiXdjciZgeVgihi]gdj\]djiX]^aY]ddYVcYVYdaZhXZcXZ#

$ENTAL4ERMINOLOGY HZXi^dc+#'#'^YZci^ÄZhhdbZY^gZXi^dcVaiZgbhheZX^ÄXidYZci^i^dc#7ZXVjhZldg`dc YZciVaVcVidbnbV`ZhZmiZch^kZjhZd[i]ZhZiZgbh!VWg^Z[gZk^Zl^hZhhZci^Va]ZgZ#>c YZciVaVcVidbn!i]Z]UcYQ\edgi^dcd[i]Ziddi]^hXadhZhiidi]Zed^cil]ZgZi]ZXZc" igVa^cX^hdghXdciVXiZVX]di]Zg!VcYTYcdQ\^hi]Zdeedh^iZd[bZh^Va#I]Z\Y^WeQ\eVgi d[i]Ziddi]Xgdlc^hidlVgYi]Zidc\jZ#ci]^hh]dgi]VcY!i]ZXVe^iVaaZiiZgh9!3!@! VcY=^YZci^[ni]ZeZgbVcZci^cX^hdgh!XVc^cZh!egZbdaVgh!VcYbdaVgh!gZheZXi^kZan# L]Zci]ZhZVgZh]dlc^cadlZgXVhZ!egZXZYZYWni]ZaZiiZgT!i]ZY!S!VcY]YZcdiZ YZX^Yjdjh ^cX^hdgh! XVc^cZh! VcY bdaVgh# 7ZXVjhZ i]Z YZX^Yjdjh bdaVgh VgZ gZeaVXZY WneZgbVcZciegZbdaVgh!eVaZdcidad\^hihhdbZi^bZhgZ[Zgidi]ZhZiZZi]VhYZX^Yjdjh egZbdaVgh#I]jhi]ZeVaZdcidad\^XVaVWWgZk^Vi^dcT`^hi]ZZfj^kVaZcid[i]ZVci]gd" edad\^XVaT]# I]Zedh^i^dchd[VaaiZZi]VgZ^cY^XViZYWncjbWZgh!gZ[Zgg^c\idi]Zedh^i^dci]Vi i]Ziddi]]daYh^ci]Ziddi]gdl#I]jh^cX^hdghXVcWZ!hdg"hXZcigVahdgaViZgVah#=j" bVcXVc^cZhVgZVaa!h#EgZbdaVghXVcWZ#hdg$hdg!hdg"h[dgi]Zcdc"eVaZdcidad\^" XVaan^cXa^cZY!VcYbdaVghXVcWZ!h!"h!dg#h#G^\]iVcYaZ[iiZZi]VgZYZh^\cViZYWn i]ZaZiiZghBVcY
8]VeiZg-9Zci^i^dc

2DM

2)  2)  2# 20 20 2- 2- 2-

2) 2) 2# 20 20 2- 2- 2-

&IGURE9ZX^YjdjhideVcYeZgbVcZcib^YYaZVcYWdiidbYZci^i^dc#CVijgVah^oZ#

-#'9ZciVaIZgb^cdad\n

&'.

$%.4)4)/.

2DI  2DI  2DC 2DM

2DI  2DI  2DC 2DM 2DM

^cX^hdg^hYZh^\cViZYcVcVaiZgcVi^kZhnhiZbd[cdbZcXaVijgZ!]jbVcXVc^cZedh^i^dc^h^cY^" XViZYWnVWVggZegZhZci^c\i]ZdXXajhVaeaVcZ!^#Z#!8[dgadlZgXVc^cZ!8[dgjeeZg#

!NATOMYOFA4OOTH ;^\jgZ-#'h]dlhi]ZkVg^djhZaZbZcihd[V]jbVciddi]#I]ZgZVgZZ^\]iZZc[ZVijgZhhd Xdbbdcan[djcY^ciZZi]d[Vaa`^cYhi]Vii]ZnVgZldgi]a^hi^c\hZeVgViZan#  &# I]ZSb_g^^hi]ZeVgid[i]Ziddi]XdkZgZYWnZcVbZa#  '# I]Zb__d^hi]ZeVgid[i]Ziddi]i]ViVcX]dghi]Ziddi]^ci]ZVakZdajhd[i]ZbVc" Y^WaZdgbVm^aaV#  (# I]Z^US[SUbfYh^hi]ZXdchig^XiZYeVgid[i]Ziddi]Vii]Z_jcXi^dcd[i]ZXgdlc VcYgddi#  )# 5^Q]U\!i]ZheZX^Va^oZY]VgYi^hhjZi]ViXdkZghi]ZXgdlc!^hWdi]VkVhXjaVgVcY VXZaajaVg#>i^hVWdji.,b^cZgVa^oZY!ZhhZci^Vaan[dhh^a^oZYdcXZ^i^h[dgbZY#  *# I]ZSUbfYS_U^Q]U\\Y^UdgZe^SdY_^!35:^hi]Za^cZZcX^gXa^c\i]ZXgdlc!l]^X] ^hi]ZbdhigddilVgYZmiZcid[i]ZZcVbZa#  +# I]ZTU^dY^_U^Q]U\Ze^SdY_^45:^hi]ZWdjcYVgnWZilZZci]ZZcVbZaXVeVcY i]ZjcYZgan^c\YZci^c#  ,# 4U^dY^dgTU^dY^U^hi]Zi^hhjZi]Vi[dgbhi]ZXdgZd[i]Ziddi]#I]^hi^hhjZ]Vh cdkVhXjaVghjeeanWji^hhjeedgiZYWni]ZkVhXjaVghnhiZb^ci]ZejaeVcY^ha^cZY dci]Z^ccZghjg[VXZi]ZlVaahd[i]ZejaeXVk^inWndYdcidWaVhih!YZci^c"egdYjX" ^c\XZaah#I]ZhZXZaah]VkZi]ZhVbZgZaVi^dch]^eidYZci^ci]VidhiZdWaVhih]VkZid WdcZ#9Zci^cjcYZga^Zhi]ZZcVbZad[i]ZXgdlcVcYZcXVehjaViZhi]ZejaeXVk^in! i]ZXZcigVahd[ii^hhjZheVXZl^i]^cViddi]#DXXajhValZVgbVnZmedhZYZci^c!VcY WZXVjhZYZci^c^hhd[iZgi]VcZcVbZa!i]ZgZhjai^c\ZmedhjgZhVgZjhjVaandXXajh" VaanXdcXVkZ#  -# I]Z`e\`SXQ]RUb^hi]ZZmeVcYZYeVgid[i]ZejaeXVk^inVii]ZXgdlcZcYd[i]Z iddi]#

%NAMEL

O C C LU S A

O C C LU S A

L

L

$ENTINE 0ULP#HAMBER

L AI S E

M

L IN G U

L AI B A

AL

L

L DISTA

D LATSI

LAU G

LABIA L

#EMENTUM 2OOT#ANAL "ONE !PICAL&ORAMEN

&IGURE6cVidbnd[Viddi]#



8]VeiZg-9Zci^i^dc

A PI C A L

A PI C A L

NI L

AL MESI

-#(6cVidbnd[VIddi]

&(&

$%.4)4)/.

 .# I]Zb__dSQ^Q\^hi]ZcVggdlZcYd[i]ZejaeXVk^inVii]ZgddiZcYd[i]Ziddi]# &%# 3U]U^de]^hVWdcZ"a^`Zi^hhjZi]ViXdkZghi]ZZmiZgcVahjg[VXZd[iddi]gddih# &&# 3Q\Se\ec ^h V XVaX^ÄZY YZedh^i Xdbbdcan [djcY dc i]Z h^YZh d[ iddi] Xgdlch# I]Zdg^\^chd[XVaXjajha^Zl^i]eaVfjZ!Xdadc^Zhd[b^Xgddg\Vc^hbhi]ViZhiVWa^h] i]ZbhZakZhdci]ZiZZi]# &'# I]Z `e\` ^h i]Z hd[i i^hhjZ l^i]^c i]Z ejae X]VbWZg# I]^h ^cXajYZh cZgkZh VcY WaddYkZhhZah# &(# I]ZQ`YSQ\V_bQ]U^^hi]ZdeZc^c\ViZVX]gddii^e!dgQ`Uh!i]gdj\]l]^X]cZgkZ ÄWZghVcYkZhhZaheVhh[gdbi]ZVakZdaVggZ\^dcidi]ZejaeXVk^in# &)# 6Sec`^hVcdXXajhVaegd_ZXi^dcd[i]ZXgdlc#BV_dgXjhehdc]db^c^YbdaVghVgZ cVbZY^cY^k^YjVaan;^\jgZ-#(#@cdlaZY\Zd[i]ZhZXjheh!^cXajY^c\i]Z^ggZaV" i^kZh^oZhVcYi]Z^glZVg!^hd[iZckVajVWaZ^c^YZci^[n^c\^hdaViZYiZZi]#8jhehd[ i]ZjeeZgiZZi]ZcYl^i]i]Zhj[ÄmS_^U!l]ZgZVhXjhehdci]ZadlZgiZZi]ZcY l^i]i]Zhj[ÄmS_^YT#I]Zi^ed[VXjhe^hi]ZQ`Uh#G^Y\Zhi]ViYZhXZcY[gdbXjhe Ve^XZhVgZSbUcdc#   V# I]Z`b_d_S_^U^hi]ZbZh^da^c\jVaXjhedcVcjeeZgbdaVg#8jheaZih!\gddkZh! dgdi]Zgided\gVe]^X[ZVijgZhdc^ihbZh^da^c\jVahjg[VXZVgZXVaaZY3QbQRU\\YÄc UVVUSdc#   W# I]ZXi`_S_^U^hi]ZY^hida^c\jVaXjhedcVcjeeZgbdaVg#   X# I]Z`QbQS_^U^hi]ZbZh^dWjXXVaXjhedcVcjeeZgbdaVg#   Y# I]Z]UdQS_^U^hi]ZY^hidWjXXVaXjhedcVcjeeZgbdaVg#   Z# I]Z`b_d_S_^YT^hi]ZbZh^dWjXXVaXjhedcVadlZgbdaVg#8jheaZih!\gddkZh! dgdi]Zg[dgbhdci]ZbZh^dWjXXVahjg[VXZd[i]ZegdidXdc^YVgZXVaaZY`b_d_ cdi\YTUVVUSdc#   [# I]ZXi`_S_^YT^hi]ZY^hidWjXXVaXjhedcVadlZgbdaVg#   \# I]Z]UdQS_^YT^hi]ZbZh^da^c\jVaXjhedcVadlZgbdaVg#   ]# I]ZU^d_S_^YT^hi]ZY^hida^c\jVaXjhedcVadlZgbdaVg#   ^# I]ZXi`_S_^e\YT^hi]ZÄ[i]!Y^hiVa"bdhiXjhedcVadlZgbdaVg#   _# 8jheaZihdci]Z^cX^hVaZY\Zhd[jcldgc^cX^hdghVgZXVaaZY]Q]]U\_^c# &*# 6ÍccebU^hVXaZ[idci]ZdXXajhVahjg[VXZWZilZZcXjheh#;^hhjgZhY^k^YZi]ZXjheh ^cideViiZgch#I]Zbdhil^YZanVX`cdlaZY\ZYd[i]ZhZ^hi]ZI%`QddUb^!VeViiZgc ^cl]^X]i]ZÄkZadlZgbdaVgXjhehVgZVggVc\ZY^cVNeViiZgc[dgVgZk^Zl!hZZ ?d]Vchdc!&.,.# &+# I]Zeg^b^i^kZbVbbVa^VcXjheeViiZgclVhVig^Vc\aZd[Xjheh^cWdi]jeeZgVcY adlZgbdaVgh#;gdbi]^heViiZgcVgZbVg`VWaZkVg^Zind[[dgbh]VhVg^hZci]gdj\] Zkdaji^dc!gVc\^c\[gdbi]ZiVaaXdajbcVgbdaVghd[lVgi]d\hidi]ZWaVYZ"a^`Z bdaVghd[hdbZXVgc^kdgZh#>c]jbVch!Vh^cbdhidi]Zgeg^bViZh!i]ZbZh^VaVc" iZg^dgeVgid[i]ZbdaVg^hgZ[ZggZYidVhi]ZdbYW_^dbYW_^YT^cadlZgbdaVgh# I]ZY^hiVaedhiZg^dgeVgid[i]Zeg^bViZbdaVg!VYYZYdcidi]ZbdY^ÄZYdg^\^cVa ig^Vc\aZd[Xjheh!^hXVaaZYi]ZdQ\_^dgdQ\_^YT^cadlZgbdaVgh# &,# 9^dUb`b_hY]Q\S_^dQSdVQSUdc9@36cVgZ[VXZih[dgbZYWZilZZcVY_VXZciiZZi] ^ci]ZhVbZ_Vl0_SS\ecQ\S_^dQSdVQSUdcgZhjai[gdbXdciVXid[bVcY^WjaVgVcY bVm^aaVgniZZi]Yjg^c\X]Zl^c\# &-# 6SY^We\e]^hVg^Y\Zd[ZcVbZai]VieVgiandgXdbeaZiZanZcX^gXaZhi]Zh^YZhd[V iddi]XgdlcVcY^hjhjVaancdiegZhZcidc]jbVcbdaVghVcYegZbdaVgh#

0ARACONE

0ROTOCONE

IAL

-E

SIA

L

,AB

GUAL

$ISTA

CAL

L

"UC

,IN

-ETACONE (YPOCONE

-ETACONID

0ROTOCONID

%NTOCONID

(YPOCONID

(YPOCONULID

&IGURE6cVidbnVcYY^gZXi^dcVaiZgbh[dgYZci^i^dc#6gXVYZhh]dlccVijgVah^oZ0^chZi ÄghibdaVghh]dlcil^XZcVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg-9Zci^i^dc

4OOTH)DENTIlCATION 7ZXVjhZY^hVhhdX^ViZYiZZi]VgZgZaVi^kZanVWjcYVciVcYWZXVjhZd[i]Z^g^bedgiVcXZ^c dhiZdad\^XValdg`^c[dgZch^Xh!VgX]Zdad\n!VcYeVaZdcidad\n!^i^hcZXZhhVgnidWZVWaZ id^YZci^[n^hdaViZYiZZi][jaanVcYVXXjgViZan#6[jaaVcYZmVXi^YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[ZVX]d[ i]ZilZcinYZX^YjdjhVcYi]^gin"ildeZgbVcZci]jbVciZZi]hZZbha^`ZV[dgb^YVWaZ iVh`!WjiVa^iiaZdg\Vc^oVi^dcVcYhdbZ]Zae[gdbdjgXadhZhigZaVi^kZh!i]Z\gZViVeZh! h^bea^ÄZhi]Z_dWXdch^YZgVWan# 6cnbdYZgcYZci^i^dcgZÅZXihb^aa^dchd[nZVghd[Zkdaji^dc#6hV\ZcZgVagjaZ!i]Z kVg^Vi^dcWZilZZcY^[[ZgZciiZZi]d[]jbVcYZci^i^dc]VhgZYjXZY!dgWZXdbZ¹]dbd\" Zc^oZY!ºl]ZgZVhbdge]dad\^XVakVg^Vi^dcViZVX]iddi]edh^i^dc]VhiZcYZYid^cXgZVhZ# I]jh!XdbeVgZYidVeZYZci^i^dc!]jbVciZZi]VgZbdgZY^[ÄXjaiid^YZci^[n#;dgi]dhZ ^ciZgZhiZY^ci]ZgVc\Zd[kVg^Vi^dcXdbbdcanZcXdjciZgZY^c]jbVciZZi]!lZgZXdb" bZcYIVnadg&.,-VcYLdZa[ZaVcYHX]Z^Y&..,# >cWdi]VeZhVcY]jbVch!^i^h[V^ganZVhnidYZiZgb^cZl]Zi]ZgiZZi]VgZ^cX^hdgh! XVc^cZh!egZbdaVgh!dgbdaVgh#BdhiegdWaZbhd[^YZci^ÄXVi^dcXdbZ^cY^hi^c\j^h]^c\ WZilZZcaZ[iVcYg^\]i!VcYWZilZZcY^[[ZgZci^cX^hdg!egZbdaVg!VcYbdaVgedh^i^dch^c i]ZjeeZgVcYadlZg_Vlh#6[Zl]^cihVcYVcdg\Vc^oVi^dcVahigjXijgZ\gZVian[VX^a^iViZ i]ZhijYnVcYgZXd\c^i^dcd[^cY^k^YjVaiZZi]#L]ZcaZVgc^c\idY^hi^c\j^h]WZilZZc iZZi]!^i^hZVh^ZhiidWZ\^cl^i]i]ZVeZh0Xg^iZg^VjhZYidY^hXg^b^cViZWZilZZcVeZ iZZi]VgZ![dgi]ZbdhieVgi!i]ZhVbZdcZhjhZYid^YZci^[n]jbVciZZi]# I]ZhiZehidlVgY^YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[^hdaViZYiZZi]VgZdjia^cZY]ZgZ^cVad\^XVadgYZg# >ih]djaYegdkZedhh^WaZid^YZci^[nk^gijVaanVaajcldgcVcYbdhildgc]jbVciZZi] Wn[daadl^c\i]^hdgYZg#>cjh^c\i]ZhZ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc\j^YZa^cZh!ZkZc[dgjcldgciZZi]! ValVnh`ZZekVg^Vi^dc^cb^cY#8g^iZg^Vdjia^cZY]ZgZVgZi]ZaZVhikVg^VWaZ#>YZci^[n ZVX]iddi]dci]ZWVh^hd[^ihXgdlcbdge]dad\n!X]ZX`^YZci^ÄXVi^dcdci]ZWVh^hd[ gddicjbWZgVcYh]VeZ!VcYi]ZcYdjWaZ"X]ZX`i]Z^YZci^ÄXVi^dcWndWhZgk^c\lZVg! ^cXajY^c\i]ZegZhZcXZ!eaVXZbZci!VcYh]VeZd[^ciZgegdm^bVaXdciVXi[VXZih#>i^hWZhi idjhZbjai^eaZXg^iZg^V[dgZVX]^YZci^ÄXVi^dc!X]ZX`^c\ZVX]dcZ^cYZeZcYZcianVcY bV`^c\VYZX^h^dcWVhZYdci]ZbV_dg^inl]Zci]ZgZ^hXdcÅ^Xi# 6aad[i]Z^YZci^ÄXVi^dchiZehdjia^cZY]ZgZVhhjbZi]Vii]Ziddi]^hV]jbVciddi] -#)Iddi]>YZci^ÄXVi^dc

&((

$%.4)4)/.

>cVYY^i^dcidi]ZhZVcVidb^XVaeVgihd[iZZi]!V[ZlVYY^i^dcVaiZgbhjhZYidYZ" hXg^WZVcY^ciZgegZiiZZi]VgZVahdjhZ[ja#Ce`Ub^e]UbQbiiZZi]VgZZmigViZZi]i]ViZm" XZZYi]ZZmeZXiZYcjbWZgd[iZZi]^cVcn\^kZcXViZ\dgn#;dgZmVbeaZ!hjeZgcjbZgVgn bdaVgh[djgi]bdaVghVgZkZgngVgZ^c]jbVchWjibdgZXdbbdc^cVeZh#1WU^UcYc ^hi]ZaVX`d[iddi][dgbVi^dcViV\^kZcedh^i^dc#8i`_`\QcYQ]nedb^cZgVa^oVi^dc ^h V Y^hijgWVcXZ d[ ZcVbZa [dgbVi^dc i]Vi d[iZc bVc^[Zhih ^ihZa[ ^c igVchkZghZ a^cZh! e^ih!dgdi]Zg^ggZ\jaVg^i^Zhdci]ZZcVbZahjg[VXZ#8i`UbSU]U^d_cYc^hVXdcY^i^dc^c l]^X]VcZmXZhhd[XZbZcijb[dgbhdci]Zgddi#DQeb_T_^dYc]gZ[Zghidi]ZXdcY^" i^dc^cl]^X]i]ZejaeX]VbWZg^hZmeVcYZYgZaVi^kZidi]ZcdgbVaXdcY^i^dc#3QbYUc ^hVY^hZVhZegdXZhhgZhjai^c\^ci]ZYZb^cZgVa^oVi^dcd[YZciVai^hhjZh#CX_fU\cXQ`UT ^cX^hdgh]VkZhigdc\anYZkZadeZYbZh^VaVcYY^hiVaa^c\jVabVg\^cVag^Y\Zh!^beVgi^c\ V¹h]dkZaºVeeZVgVcXZidi]Ziddi]#HZkZgVad[i]ZhZ[ZVijgZhVgZ\^kZc[jgi]ZgXdch^YZg" Vi^dc^c8]VeiZgh&,VcY&.!l]ZgZi]ZjhZhd[iZZi]^ceVaZdeVi]dad\nVcYi]ZhijYn d[edejaVi^dcVaV[Äa^Vi^dcVgZY^hXjhhZY#

l^i]a^iiaZdgcdlZVg#L]Zc^YZci^[n^c\ldgciZZi]!ViiZbeiidbZciVaangZXdchigjXi i]Z dg^\^cVa! jcldgc Xgdlc bdge]dad\n# Dcan i]gdj\] ZmeZg^ZcXZ l^i] V gVc\Z d[ ]jbVciZZi]l^aai]ZgZhZVgX]ZgWZXdbZ[Vb^a^Vgl^i]i]ZcdgbVa!ZmeZXiZYkVg^Vi^dc l^i]^ci]Z]jbVcheZX^Zh#I]jh!l]Zc^i^hcdi^c^i^VaandWk^djhl]Zi]Zgi]Ziddi] ^h]jbVc!ldg`^c\i]gdj\]i]ZhiZeh^cYZiV^abVnbV`Z^iedhh^WaZid^YZci^[nVcY Za^b^cViZcdc]jbVciZZi]#LdgcWZVgVcYe^\iZZi]gZhZbWaZ]jbVciZZi]hjeZgÄ" X^Vaan!WjibdYZgViZZmeZg^ZcXZl^i]hbVaahVbeaZhd[ldgcVcYjcldgc]jbVciZZi] l^aaVabdhiValVnhWZVYZfjViZidVaadlVcVXXjgViZY^V\cdh^h# GZbZbWZgi]Vibdhid[i]ZXg^iZg^VegZhZciZY]ZgZ[dgY^V\cdh^c\bdYZgc]jbVc iZZi]idhZi!VgX]!XaVhh!dgineZVgZgZaVi^kZ!VcY]ZcXZYZeZcYZcidcXdbeVg^c\dcZ dWhZgkVi^dc!^cYZm!dgh^oZV\V^chiVcdi]Zg#6ahd!cdiZi]Vii]ZdhiZdad\^hiXdckZc^Zcian XVgg^ZhV[jaadgeVgi^VaXdbeVgVi^kZYZci^i^dcVgdjcYViVaai^bZh#;dg^YZci^ÄXVi^dc d[iddi]XViZ\dgn!VgX]!VcYh^YZ!i]ZdhiZdad\^hibVnÄcY^ijhZ[jaid^bV\^cZegdeZgan eaVX^c\i]Zjc^YZci^ÄZYiddi]^cid]^hdg]ZgdlcYZci^i^dc#>c^YZci^[n^c\^hdaViZY iZZi]!dgeVgihd[iZZi]!egdXZZYVXXdgY^c\idi]ZhZfjZcXZdjia^cZY^cHZXi^dch-#*·-#.! l^i]gZ[ZgZcXZid;^\jgZ-#(# I]ZiZZi]^c;^\jgZh-#)·-#&.VgZVaagZegdYjXZYViil^XZcVijgVah^oZ#Gddidg^Zc" iVi^dc^cbZh^VaVcYWjXXVa!aVW^Va!VcYa^c\jVak^Zlh^hVcVidb^XVabVm^aaVgngddih ed^cije!idlVgYi]Zided[i]ZeV\Z#DXXajhVak^ZlhVgZh]dlcl^i]i]ZbZh^VaXgdlc ZY\ZidlVgYi]Zided[i]ZeV\Z#6aa¹aZ[iºh^YZiZZi]VgZe]did\gVe]^XcZ\Vi^kZgZkZg" hVahd[VXijVag^\]ih^YZiZZi]#CdiZi]Vii]ZZcVbZad[i]Z^aajhigViZYiZZi]^hcdih]^cn# :cVbZa^higVchajXZciVcYh]^cn!Wjii]ZhZX]VgVXiZg^hi^XhXdbW^cZiddWhXjgZided\" gVe]nYjg^c\e]did\gVe]n#IdhdakZi]^hegdWaZb!lZXdViZYi]ZiZZi]^aajhigViZY]ZgZ l^i]deVfjZ!i]^ce^\bZcieg^dgide]did\gVe]n#

4O7HICH#ATEGORY#LASS $OESTHE4OOTH"ELONG &IGURESn )NCISORS  ™ >cX^hdgXgdlchVgZÅViVcYWaVYZ"a^`Z#  ™ I]Zdjia^cZd[i]ZdXXajhVaYZci^cZeViX]d[i]Z^cX^hdgZmedhZYWnlZVg^hgZXiVc" \jaVgdghfjVgZ#

#ANINES ™ 8Vc^cZXgdlchVgZXdc^XVaVcYijh`a^`Z# ™ I]Zdjia^cZd[i]ZdXXajhVaYZci^cZeViX]d[i]ZXVc^cZZmedhZYWnlZVg^hY^V" bdcY"h]VeZY# ™ 8Vc^cZgddihVgZadc\Zgi]Vcdi]Zggddih^ci]ZhVbZYZci^i^dc# ™ HdbZXVc^cZhbVnWZXdc[jhZY[dg^cX^hdgh#CdiZ!]dlZkZg!i]Zadc\Zg!aVg\ZgXV" c^cZgddigZaVi^kZidXgdlc]Z^\]iVcYi]ZdkVaXVc^cZXgdlcXgdhhhZXi^dc#



8]VeiZg-9Zci^i^dc

-AXILLA

-ANDIBLE $%.4)4)/.

-AXILLA

-ANDIBLE

&IGURE6XdbeVg^hdcd[bVm^aaVgnVcYbVcY^WjaVg]Va[VgX]Zh[dgeZgbVcZciideVcY YZX^YjdjhWdiidbYZci^i^dch#DXXajhVa!g^\]ih^YZ!il^XZcVijgVah^oZ#

-#*IdL]^X]8ViZ\dgn9dZhi]ZIddi]7Zadc\4

&(*

0REMOLARS  ™ EgZbdaVgXgdlchVgZgdjcY!h]dgiZgi]VcXVc^cZXgdlchVcYhbVaaZgi]VcbdaVg Xgdlch#I]ZnjhjVaan]VkZildXjheh#  ™ EgZbdaVghVgZjhjVaanh^c\aZgddiZY#  ™ HdbZadlZgi]^gYegZbdaVghbVnWZb^hiV`Zc[dgXVc^cZh#CdiZ!]dlZkZg!i]Z hbVaaZgXgdlc]Z^\]iVcYh]dgiZggddid[i]ZegZbdaVg#

-OLARS  ™ BdaVgXgdlchVgZaVg\Zg!hfjVgZg!VcYWZVgbdgZXjhehi]Vcdi]ZgiZZi]#  ™ BdaVghjhjVaan]VkZbjai^eaZgddih#  ™ GZYjXZYi]^gYbdaVghVgZhdbZi^bZhb^hiV`Zc[dgegZbdaVgh#IdVkd^Yi]^h!cdiZ i]ZgZaVi^dch]^ed[gddiaZc\i]idXgdlc]Z^\]i!i]ZgdjcYdgdkVadjia^cZd[i]Z egZbdaVgh^cdXXajhVaVheZXi!VcYi]ZXdbeVgVi^kZangZ\jaVgXjheeViiZgcdci]Z egZbdaVgXgdlch#

)STHE4OOTH0ERMANENTOR$ECIDUOUS&IGURESn $IAGNOSTIC#RITERIA  ™ Id^YZci^[nYZX^YjdjhiZZi]!VYjaiXg^iZg^Vdjia^cZYWdi]VWdkZVcYWZadlVgZVe" ea^XVWaZZmXZeil]ZgZ^cY^XViZY^cHeZX^Va8VhZh!HZXi^dc-#+#'!WZadl#  ™ 9ZX^YjdjhXgdlch]VkZZcVbZai]Vi^hi]^ccZggZaVi^kZidXgdlch^oZ#  ™ 9ZX^Yjdjhiddi]XgdlchVgZbdgZWjaWdjh^ch]VeZ!l^i]i]ZZcVbZaVadc\i]Z XgdlclVaahd[iZcWja\^c\djiVWdkZi]ZXZgk^XdZcVbZaa^cZbdgZegdb^cZcian i]Vc^ceZgbVcZciiZZi]#  ™ 9ZX^Yjdjhiddi]gddihVgZi]^ccZgVcYh]dgiZg#I]ZYZX^YjdjhbdaVggddihVgZ bdgZY^kZg\Zci#  ™ 9ZX^Yjdjhiddi]gddihVgZd[iZceVgiangZhdgWZY!eVgi^XjaVganWZadli]ZXgdlc XZciZgd[YZX^YjdjhbdaVgh#

3PECIAL#ASES  ™ 9ZX^YjdjhÄghijeeZgVcYadlZgbdaVgXgdlch]VkZeZXja^Vgh]VeZh#I]ZjeeZg ^hig^Vc\jaVg^cdjia^cZ!l^i]Vhigdc\anegd_ZXi^c\WjXXVaeVgVXdcZhjg[VXZ#I]Z adlZg]VhVadliVadc^YVcYVcZmiZch^kZWjXXVaegdidXdc^Yhjg[VXZ#  ™ 9ZX^YjdjhjeeZgXVc^cZhY^[[Zg[gdbVYjaijeeZgXVc^cZh^ci]Vii]ZbZh^VadX" XajhVaZY\Z^h\ZcZgVaanadc\Zgi]Vci]ZY^hiVadXXajhVaZY\Z#



8]VeiZg-9Zci^i^dc

2) 

2DI 

2) 

2DC 

2# 

2DI 

2)

2DI 

2)

2DC

2#

$%.4)4)/.

2DI 

2DM 

2-

2DM

2-

2DM 

2-

2DM

2-

&IGURE9ZX^YjdjhVcYeZgbVcZciiZZi]XdbeVgZY#>cX^hdghVcYXVc^cZh^ca^c\jVak^Zl0 bdaVgh^cWjXXVaVcYdXXajhVak^Zlh#G^\]ih^YZ!il^XZcVijgVah^oZ#

-#+>hi]ZIddi]EZgbVcZcidg9ZX^Yjdjh4

&(,

)STHE4OOTHAN5PPERORA,OWER Id ^YZci^[n YZX^Yjdjh iZZi]! VYjai Xg^iZg^V djia^cZY Wdi] VWdkZ VcY WZadl VgZ Veea^XVWaZ# ;dg^cX^hdghVcYXVc^cZh!k^Zli]ZXgdlca^c\jVaan#E8;h!l]^X]bjhiWZbZh^VaVcYY^hiVa#

2DI 

2) 

2DI 

2) 

2DI 

2)

2DI 

2)

&IGUREJeeZgVcYadlZgYZX^YjdjhVcYeZgbVcZci^cX^hdghXdbeVgZY#G^\]ih^YZ! a^c\jVak^Zl!il^XZcVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg-9Zci^i^dc

5PPERVERSUS,OWER)NCISORS&IGURE

5PPERVERSUS,OWER#ANINES&IGURE  ™ JeeZgXVc^cZXgdlchVgZWgdVYbZh^dY^hiVaanZadc\ViZgZaVi^kZidi]Z^g]Z^\]i# AdlZgXVc^cZXgdlchVgZcVggdlgZaVi^kZidi]Z^g]Z^\]i#  ™ JeeZgXVc^cZXgdlch]VkZbjX]a^c\jVagZa^Z[#AdlZgXVc^cZh]VkZXdbeVgVi^kZan a^iiaZa^c\jVagZa^Z[#  ™ JeeZgXVc^cZXgdlch]VkZVe^XVadXXajhValZVgi]Vi^hbdhiana^c\jVa#AdlZgXV" c^cZh]VkZVe^XVadXXajhValZVgi]Vi^hbdhianaVW^Va#

&IGUREJeeZgVcYadlZgYZX^YjdjhVcY eZgbVcZciXVc^cZhXdbeVgZY#G^\]ih^YZ! a^c\jVak^Zl!il^XZcVijgVah^oZ#

2DC

2#

2DC

2#

-#,>hi]ZIddi]VcJeeZgdgVAdlZg4

&(.

$%.4)4)/.

 ™ JeeZg^cX^hdgXgdlchVgZWgdVYbZh^dY^hiVaanZadc\ViZgZaVi^kZidi]Z^g]Z^\]i# AdlZg^cX^hdgXgdlchVgZcVggdlXdbeVgZYidi]Z^g]Z^\]i#  ™ JeeZg^cX^hdgXgdlch]VkZbjX]a^c\jVagZa^Z[#AdlZg^cX^hdgXgdlch]VkZXdb" eVgVi^kZana^iiaZa^c\jVaided\gVe]n#  ™ JeeZg^cX^hdggddihVgZjhjVaanbdgZX^gXjaVg^cXgdhhhZXi^dc#AdlZg^cX^hdggddih VgZjhjVaanbdgZbZh^dY^hiVaanXdbegZhhZY^cXgdhhhZXi^dc#

5PPERVERSUS,OWER0REMOLARS&IGURE  ™ JeeZgegZbdaVgXgdlch]VkZildXjhehd[cZVganZfjVah^oZ#AdlZgegZbdaVg Xgdlchh]dlXdbeVgVi^kZan]^\]Y^heVg^in^cWjXXVaVcYa^c\jVaXjheh^oZ!l^i] i]ZWjXXVaXjheYdb^cVi^c\i]Za^c\jVaXjhe^c]Z^\]iVcYVgZV#  ™ JeeZgegZbdaVgXgdlch]VkZhigdc\dXXajhVa\gddkZhdg^ZciZYbZh^dY^hiVaanbZ" Y^Vc\gddkZhWZilZZci]ZbV_dgXjheh#AdlZgegZbdaVgXgdlch]VkZXdbeVgV" i^kZanlZV`bZY^Vc\gddkZh#  ™ JeeZgegZbdaVgXgdlchVgZbdgZdkVa^cdXXajhVadjia^cZ#AdlZgegZbdaVgXgdlch VgZbdgZX^gXjaVg^cdXXajhVadjia^cZ#

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

20

&IGUREJeeZgVcYadlZgeZgbVcZciegZbdaVghXdbeVgZY#G^\]ih^YZ!WjXXVa!bZh^Va!VcY dXXajhVak^Zlh!il^XZcVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg-9Zci^i^dc

5PPERVERSUS,OWER-OLARS&IGURE

2DM 

2DM

2-

2DM 

2-

2DM

2-

2-

&IGUREJeeZgVcYadlZgYZX^YjdjhVcYeZgbVcZcibdaVghXdbeVgZY#G^\]ih^YZ!WjXXVa VcYdXXajhVak^Zlh!il^XZcVijgVah^oZ#

-#,#)JeeZgkZghjhAdlZgBdaVgh

&)&

$%.4)4)/.

 ™ JeeZgbdaVgXgdlchjhjVaan]VkZi]gZZdg[djgbV_dgXjheh#AdlZgbdaVgXgdlch jhjVaan]VkZ[djgdgÄkZbV_dgXjheh#  ™ JeeZgbdaVgXgdlch]VkZdjia^cZh^ci]Zh]VeZd[Vg]dbWjhh`ZlZYgZXiVc\aZ ^cdXXajhVak^Zl#AdlZgbdaVgXgdlch]VkZhfjVgZ!gZXiVc\jaVg!dgdWadc\djia^cZh#  ™ JeeZgbdaVgXgdlch]VkZXjheheaVXZYVhnbbZig^XVaangZaVi^kZidi]ZbZh^dY^h" iVaXgdlcVm^h#AdlZgbdaVgXgdlch]VkZXjheheaVXZYhnbbZig^XVaanVWdjii]Z Xgdlcb^Ya^cZ#  ™ JeeZgbdaVghjhjVaan]VkZi]gZZbV_dggddihi]ViVgZkVg^VWan[jhZY#AdlZgbd" aVghjhjVaan]VkZildbV_dggddih!WjidXXVh^dcVaan]VkZi]gZZ#

7HEREINTHE!RCH)STHE4OOTH,OCATED 5PPER)NCISORS)VERSUS)&IGURE ™ JeeZgXZcigVa^cX^hdg>&XgdlchVgZaVg\Zgi]Vci]dhZd[i]ZjeeZgaViZgVa^cX^hdg >'Xgdlch# ™ JeeZgXZcigVa^cX^hdg>&Xgdlch]VkZV\gZViZgbZh^dY^hiVaaZc\i]/]Z^\]igVi^d i]VcjeeZgaViZgVa^cX^hdg>'Xgdlch^caVW^Vak^Zl# ™ JeeZgXZcigVa^cX^hdg>&XgdlchVgZbdgZhnbbZig^XVa^caVW^Vak^Zli]VcjeeZg aViZgVa^cX^hdg>'Xgdlch# ™ JeeZgXZcigVa^cX^hdg>&gddihVgZh]dgiZgVcYhidjiZggZaVi^kZidXgdlch^oZi]Vc jeeZgaViZgVa^cX^hdg>'gddih#

,OWER)NCISORS)VERSUS)&IGURE ™ AdlZgXZcigVa^cX^hdg>&XgdlchVgZha^\]ianhbVaaZgi]VcadlZgaViZgVa^cX^hdg >'Xgdlch# ™ AdlZgXZcigVa^cX^hdg>&Xgdlch]VkZVhbVaaZgbZh^dY^hiVaaZc\i]/]Z^\]igVi^d i]VcadlZgaViZgVa^cX^hdg>'Xgdlch^caVW^Vak^Zl# ™ AdlZgXZcigVa^cX^hdg>&XgdlchVgZha^\]ianbdgZhnbbZig^XVa^caVW^Vak^Zl i]VcadlZgaViZgVa^cX^hdg>'Xgdlch0i]ZY^hiVa>'XgdlcZY\ZhÅVgZY^hiVaan^c i]^hk^Zl# ™ AdlZgXZcigVa^cX^hdg>&gddihVgZh]dgiZg!Wdi]gZaVi^kZidXgdlc]Z^\]iVcYVW" hdajiZan!i]Vc>'gddih#



8]VeiZg-9Zci^i^dc

2DI 

2) 

2DI 

2) 

$%.4)4)/.

&IGUREJeeZgYZX^YjdjhVcYeZgbVcZci^cX^hdghXdbeVgZY#G^\]ih^YZ!a^c\jVa k^Zl!il^XZcVijgVah^oZ#

2DI 

2)

2DI 

2)

&IGUREAdlZgYZX^YjdjhVcYeZgbVcZci^cX^hdghXdbeVgZY#G^\]ih^YZ!a^c\jVa k^Zl!il^XZcVijgVah^oZ#

-#-L]ZgZ^ci]Z6gX]>hi]ZIddi]AdXViZY4

&)(

5PPER0REMOLARS0VERSUS0 &IGURE  ™ JeeZgi]^gYegZbdaVgE(Xgdlch]VkZbV_dga^c\jVaXjhehi]ViVgZhbVaaXdb" eVgZYidbV_dgWjXXVaXjheh#JeeZg[djgi]egZbdaVgE)Xgdlch]VkZbV_dgWjX" XVaVcYa^c\jVaXjhehd[bdgZZfj^kVaZcih^oZ^cdXXajhVak^Zl#  ™ JeeZgi]^gYegZbdaVgE(Xgdlch]VkZaZhhhnbbZig^X!bdgZig^Vc\jaVgdjia^cZh ^cdXXajhVak^Zli]VcjeeZg[djgi]egZbdaVgE)Xgdlch#I]ZaViiZgVgZgdjcYZg WZXVjhZi]ZgZaVi^kZbZh^dY^hiVaaZc\i]d[i]ZbV_dgWjXXVaXjhe^hcdiVh\gZVi Vh^ci]ZE(Xgdlci]Za^c\jVaXjhed[i]ZE)Xgdlc^hgZaVi^kZanaVg\Zg^cWdi] aZc\i]VcYVgZV#  ™ JeeZgi]^gYegZbdaVgE(Xgdlch]VkZbdgZXdcXVkZbZh^Vahjg[VXZhVcYbdgZ YZZean^cYZciZYbZh^VadXXajhVadjia^cZhi]VcjeeZg[djgi]egZbdaVgE)Xgdlch#  ™ JeeZgi]^gYegZbdaVgE(Xgdlchh]dlbdgZbZh^dWjXXVaegd_ZXi^dcd[i]ZXZgk^" XdZcVbZaa^cZi]VcjeeZg[djgi]egZbdaVgE)Xgdlch#  ™ JeeZgi]^gYegZbdaVgE(XgdlchXdciVXibZh^Vaanl^i]i]ZXVc^cZ#I]ZgZhjai^c\ hbVaabZh^Va>E8;^hY^hi^cXi^kZ!jhjVaanXjgk^a^cZVgVcYXjeeZY!VcYkZgi^XVaan Zadc\ViZY#I]ZbZh^Va>E8;dci]ZjeeZg[djgi]egZbdaVgE)^hjhjVaanbdgZ hnbbZig^XVaVcYWjXXda^c\jVaanZadc\ViZY#  ™ JeeZgi]^gYegZbdaVgE(gddihVgZjhjVaanYdjWaZ!W^adWViZ!dgVe^XVaanW^[jg" XViZY#JeeZg[djgi]egZbdaVgE)gddihVgZjhjVaanh^c\aZ#

,OWER0REMOLARS0VERSUS0&IGURE  ™ AdlZgi]^gYegZbdaVgE(Xgdlch]VkZVbV_dga^c\jVaXjhei]Vi^hhbVaa!gZaVi^kZ idi]ZYdb^cVcibV_dgWjXXVaXjhe!^cWdi]dXXajhVaVgZVVcY]Z^\]i#I]ZbV_dg a^c\jVaXjhe^hd[iZcZmegZhhZYbZgZanVhVhbVaaa^c\jVag^Y\Z#AdlZg[djgi]egZ" bdaVgE) Xgdlch]VkZbV_dgWjXXVaVcYa^c\jVaXjhehd[bdgZZfj^kVaZcih^oZ! VcYi]ZbV_dgWjXXVaXjhe^haZhhed^ciZYi]VcdcVE(Xgdlc#  ™ AdlZgi]^gYegZbdaVgE(Xgdlch]VkZVbZh^Va[dkZVeaVXZYkZgnbZh^Vaan!XadhZ idi]ZbZh^VadXXajhVaZY\Z^cdXXajhVak^Zl#AdlZg[djgi]egZbdaVgXgdlch]VkZ bdgZY^hiVaaneaVXZYbZh^Va[dkZVZ#  ™ AdlZgi]^gYegZbdaVgE(Xgdlch]VkZaZhhhnbbZignd[dXXajhVadjia^cZi]Vc adlZg[djgi]egZbdaVgE) Xgdlch#  ™ AdlZgi]^gYegZbdaVgE(Xgdlch]VkZbjX]hbVaaZgiVadc^Yhi]VcadlZg[djgi] egZbdaVgE) Xgdlch#  ™ AdlZgi]^gYegZbdaVgE(XgdlchWZVgbZh^VaXVc^cZ>E8;hVcVad\djhidi]dhZ Y^hXjhhZYZVga^Zg[dgi]ZjeeZgXdjciZgeVgih#



8]VeiZg-9Zci^i^dc

20

20

20

20

20

$%.4)4)/.

20

&IGUREJeeZgeZgbVcZciegZbdaVghXdbeVgZY#G^\]ih^YZ!WjXXVa!bZh^Va!VcYdXXajhVa k^Zlh!il^XZcVijgVah^oZ#

20

20

20

20

20

20

&IGURE   AdlZg eZgbVcZci egZbdaVgh XdbeVgZY# G^\]i h^YZ! WjXXVa! bZh^Va! VcY dXXajhVa k^Zlh!il^XZcVijgVah^oZ#

-#-L]ZgZ^ci]Z6gX]>hi]ZIddi]AdXViZY4

&)*

5PPER-OLARS-VERSUS-VERSUS-&IGURE  ™ JeeZgÄghibdaVgB&Xgdlch]VkZ[djglZaa"YZkZadeZYXjhehVggVc\ZY^cV g]dbW^Xh]VeZ#JeeZgi]^gYbdaVghB(iZcYidWZhbVaaZgVcYbdgZXgZcjaViZ [jggdlZYdci]ZdXXajhVahjg[VXZi]VcÄghibdaVgh!l^i]bdgZ^ggZ\jaVgXjhe edh^i^dc^c\gZaVi^kZidi]ZbV_dgXgdlcVmZh#JeeZgi]^gYbdaVghB(jhjVaanaVX` V]nedXdcZ^c]jbVch#JeeZghZXdcYbdaVgB'XgdlchVgZ^ciZgbZY^ViZidi]Z ÄghiVcYi]^gYbdaVgXgdlch^cbdge]dad\^XVaViig^WjiZh#  ™ JeeZgÄghibdaVghB&]VkZi]gZZadc\!Y^hi^cXi!VcYY^kZg\Zcigddih#JeeZgi]^gY bdaVghB(iZcYid]VkZ[jhZYgddihVcYaVX`Y^hiVa>E8;h#JeeZghZXdcYbdaVg B'gddihVgZ^ciZgbZY^ViZ#

2-

2-

2-

&IGUREJeeZgeZgbVcZcibdaVghXdbeVgZY#G^\]ih^YZ!WjXXVa!bZh^Va!VcY dXXajhVak^Zlh!il^XZcVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg-9Zci^i^dc

,OWER-OLARS-VERSUS-VERSUS-&IGURE

2-

2-

2-

&IGUREAdlZgeZgbVcZcibdaVghXdbeVgZY#G^\]ih^YZ!dXXajhVa!bZh^Va!VcY WjXXVak^Zlh!il^XZcVijgVah^oZ#

-#-L]ZgZ^ci]Z6gX]>hi]ZIddi]AdXViZY4

&),

$%.4)4)/.

 ™ AdlZgÄghibdaVgB&Xgdlch]VkZÄkZlZaa"YZkZadeZYXjheh!jhjVaanVggVc\ZY^c i]ZXaVhh^XN"*eViiZgc#AdlZgi]^gYbdaVghB(jhjVaan]VkZ[djgdg[ZlZgXjheh l^i]VbdgZkVg^VWaZVggVc\ZbZci#AdlZgi]^gYbdaVghB(iZcYidWZhbVaaZg VcYbdgZXgZcjaViZi]VcÄghibdaVgh!l^i]bdgZ^ggZ\jaVgXjheedh^i^dc^c\gZaV" i^kZidi]ZbV_dgXgdlcVmZh#AdlZghZXdcYbdaVgB'XgdlchVgZ^ciZgbZY^ViZid i]ZÄghiVcYi]^gYbdaVgXgdlch^cbdge]dad\^XVaViig^WjiZh#  ™ AdlZgÄghibdaVghB&]VkZildadc\!hZeVgViZ!VcYY^kZg\Zcigddih#AdlZgi]^gY bdaVghB(iZcYid]VkZ[jhZYgddihVcYi]ZnaVX`Y^hiVa>E8;h#L]Zci]ZbZh^Va VcYY^hiVagddihgZbV^chZeVgViZ!i]ZY^hiVadcZ^hXdajbcVg!hZiWZadlVgdjcYZY edhiZg^dgXgdlcegdÄaZ#AdlZghZXdcYbdaVgB'gddihVgZ^ciZgbZY^ViZ#

)STHE4OOTHFROMTHE2IGHTORTHE,EFT3IDE 5PPER)NCISORS&IGURE BV`Zi]ZÄghiilddWhZgkVi^dch^caVW^Vak^Zl!dg^Zci^c\i]ZheZX^bZcVh^ildjaYgZhi ^ci]ZYZci^i^dc!l^i]i]ZdXXajhVahjg[VXZ]dg^odciVa#I]ZgddiVm^hVc\aZhedhiZgdaViZg" Vaan^ci]ZbVm^aaV#  ™ I]ZY^hiVadXXajhVaXdgcZg^hbdgZgdjcYZYi]Vci]ZbZh^Va#  ™ I]Zadc\Vm^hd[i]ZgddiVc\aZhY^hiVaangZaVi^kZidi]ZkZgi^XVaXZgk^Xd^cX^hVa Vm^hd[i]ZXgdlc!l^i]i]Zgddii^ejhjVaanaZVc^c\Y^hiVaan#  ™ I]Z>&$>&>E8;^hbdgZeaVcVgÅViiZg!l^YZg!VcYbdgZhnbbZig^XVaaneaVXZY i]Vci]ZbdgZ^ggZ\jaVg!kZgi^XVaanZadc\ViZ>&$>'>E8;#  ™ I]ZY^hiVagddihjg[VXZ^hbdgZYZZean\gddkZYi]Vci]ZbZh^Vagddihjg[VXZ#

,OWER)NCISORS&IGURE BV`Zi]ZÄghi!i]^gY!VcY[djgi]dWhZgkVi^dch^caVW^Vak^Zl!dg^Zci^c\i]ZheZX^bZcVh ^ildjaYgZhi^ci]ZYZci^i^dc!l^i]i]ZdXXajhVahjg[VXZ]dg^odciVa#  ™  ™  ™  ™

I]ZgddiVm^hVc\aZhedhiZgdaViZgVaan# I]ZY^hiVadXXajhVaXdgcZg^hbdgZgdjcYZYi]Vci]ZbZh^Va# I]Z>&$>&>E8;^hbdgZeaVcVgÅViiZgVcYhnbbZig^XVaaneaVXZYi]Vci]Z>&$>'>E8;# I]ZdXXajhValZVgbdhid[iZcVc\aZhY^hiVaanVcY^c[Zg^dgangZaVi^kZidi]ZkZgi^XVa XZgk^Xd^cX^hVaVm^hd[i]ZXgdlc#  ™ I]Zadc\Vm^hd[i]ZgddiVc\aZhY^hiVaangZaVi^kZidi]ZkZgi^XVaXZgk^Xd^cX^hVa Vm^hd[i]ZXgdlc!l^i]i]Zgddii^ejhjVaanaZVc^c\Y^hiVaan#

5PPER#ANINES&IGURE BV`Zi]ZÄghiilddWhZgkVi^dch^caVW^Vak^Zll^i]i]Ziddi]dg^ZciZYVh^ildjaYgZhi ^ci]ZYZci^i^dc#  ™ I]ZbZh^VadXXajhVaZY\Zg^Y\Z_d^c^c\Xgdlch]djaYZgl^i]VeZm^hjhjVaan h]dgiZgi]Vci]ZY^hiVadXXajhVaZY\Z#  ™ I]Zadc\Vm^hd[i]ZgddiVc\aZhY^hiVaangZaVi^kZidi]ZkZgi^XVaXZgk^Xd^cX^hVa Vm^hd[i]ZXgdlc#  ™ I]ZY^hiVa>E8;[dgE(^hjhjVaanaVg\ZgVcYZheZX^VaanWgdVYZgi]Vci]ZbZh^Va aViZgVa^cX^hdg>E8;#  ™ I]ZY^hiVagddihjg[VXZ^hbdgZYZZean\gddkZYi]Vci]ZbZh^Vagddihjg[VXZ#  ™ I]ZbZh^VaZcVbZaa^cZ]VhV]^\]ZgXgdlclVgYVgX]#



8]VeiZg-9Zci^i^dc

2) 

,) 

,) 

2)

2)

,)

,)

$%.4)4)/.

2) 

&IGUREG^\]iVcYaZ[ijeeZgVcYadlZgeZgbVcZci^cX^hdgh#AVW^Vak^Zl!il^XZ cVijgVah^oZ#

,OWER#ANINES&IGURE 6aad[i]ZXg^iZg^VjhZYidh^YZjeeZgXVc^cZhVgZVeea^XVWaZidadlZgXVc^cZh#

5PPER0REMOLARS&IGURE  ™ >E8;hl]ZcegZhZciVgZbZh^VaVcYY^hiVa!VcYi]ZbV_dgbZY^Vc\gddkZWZilZZc Xjheh^hdg^ZciZYbZh^dY^hiVaan#  ™ I]ZbV_dga^c\jVaXjhe^hXZciZgZYbZh^VaangZaVi^kZidi]ZbV_dgWjXXVaXjhe# CdiZi]Vi[dgldgciZZi]i]Vii]ZXZciZgd[i]ZYZci^cZZmedhjgZjhjVaanXdggZ" hedcYhidi]ZeaVXZbZcid[i]Zdg^\^cVaXjheVeZm#  ™ I]ZbV_dga^c\jVaXjhe^hhbVaaZg!aZhhdXXajhVaanegdb^cZci!VcYjhjVaanbdgZ ]ZVk^anldgci]Vci]ZbV_dgWjXXVaXjhe#  ™ I]Zadc\Vm^hVmZhd[i]ZgddihVc\aZhY^hiVaangZaVi^kZidi]ZkZgi^XVaXZgk^Xd" ^cX^hVaVm^hd[i]ZXgdlc# -#.>hi]ZIddi][gdbi]ZG^\]idgi]ZAZ[iH^YZ4

&).

2# 

2# 

,# 

,# 

2#

2#

,#

,#

&IGUREG^\]iVcYaZ[ijeeZgVcYadlZgeZgbVcZciXVc^cZh#A^c\jVaVcYaVW^Va k^Zlh!il^XZcVijgVah^oZ#

,OWER0REMOLARS&IGURE  ™ I]Z>E8;hl]ZcegZhZciVgZbZh^VaVcYY^hiVa#  ™ I]ZbV_dgWjXXVaXjhe^haVg\Zg!bdgZdXXajhVaanegdb^cZci!VcYjhjVaanbdgZ ]ZVk^anldgci]Vci]ZbV_dga^c\jVaXjhe#  ™ I]ZbV_dga^c\jVaXjhe^hY^heaVXZYbZh^VaangZaVi^kZidi]ZbV^cWjXXda^c\jVa Vm^hd[i]ZXgdlc^cdXXajhVak^Zl#  ™ I]ZiVadc^Y!^[egZhZci!^hY^hiVa#  ™ I]Zadc\Vm^hVmZhd[i]ZgddihVc\aZhY^hiVaangZaVi^kZidi]ZkZgi^XVaXZgk^Xd" ^cX^hVaVm^hd[i]ZXgdlc# 

8]VeiZg-9Zci^i^dc

,0 

20 

,0 

20 

,0 

20 

,0 

20

,0

20

,0

20

,0

20

,0

$%.4)4)/.

20 

&IGUREG^\]iVcYaZ[ijeeZgVcYadlZgeZgbVcZciegZbdaVgh#7jXXVaVcY dXXajhVak^Zlh!il^XZcVijgVah^oZ#

-#.>hi]ZIddi][gdbi]ZG^\]idgi]ZAZ[iH^YZ4

&*&

5PPER-OLARS&IGURE  ™ >E8;hl]ZcegZhZciVgZadXViZYdci]ZbZh^VaVcYY^hiVaXgdlc[VXZh#  ™ I]ZegdidXdcZ^hi]ZaVg\Zhi!bdhi]ZVk^anldgcXjhe#>idXXje^Zhi]ZbZh^da^c\jVa XgdlcXdgcZg#  ™ I]Z]nedXdcZ^hi]ZhbVaaZhiXjhe!VcY^hhdbZi^bZhVWhZci#>idXXje^Zhi]ZY^hid" a^c\jVaXgdlcXdgcZg#  ™ A^c\jVaXjhehVgZdXXajhVaanaZhhegdb^cZcii]VcWjXXVaXjhehVcY]VkZ]ZVk^Zg lZVg#  ™ >cdXXajhVak^Zl!i]Za^c\jVaXgdlchjg[VXZ^hbdgZk^h^WaZi]Vci]ZWjXXVaXgdlc hjg[VXZ#  ™ I]ZaVg\Zhid[i]Zi]gZZgddih^hd[iZcXdbegZhhZYWjXXda^c\jVaanVcYhZiWZcZVi] i]ZegdidXdcZVcY]nedXdcZ#  ™ I]ZildhbVaaZggddihVgZgdjcYZgVcYhZiWjXXVaandcZbZh^VaVcYdcZY^hiVa! VcYi]ZbZh^dWjXXVagddi^hjhjVaani]ZaVg\Zgd[i]Zild#  ™ 6aagddihVc\aZY^hiVaanl^i]gZheZXiidi]ZbV_dgXgdlcVmZh# 

,OWER-OLARS&IGURE  ™ >E8;hl]ZcegZhZciVgZadXViZYdci]ZbZh^VaVcYY^hiVaXgdlc[VXZh#  ™ I]ZaVg\ZhiXgdlcY^bZch^dc^hjhjVaanbZh^dY^hiVa#  ™ I]ZegdidXdc^Y^hi]ZaVg\Zhi!bdhi]ZVk^anldgcXjhe#>idXXje^Zhi]ZbZh^dWjXXVa XgdlcXdgcZg#  ™ I]Z]nedXdcja^Y^hi]ZhbVaaZhiXjhejcaZhhi]ZgZVgZVYY^i^dcVa!hbVaaZgXjheh! aVWZaZY8"+!8",!VcYhddc#>i^heaVXZYY^hiVaanVcYXZciZgZYdci]ZbZh^dY^hiVa XgdlcVm^h#  ™ I]ZWjXXVaXjhehVgZdXXajhVaanaZhhegdb^cZcii]Vci]Za^c\jVaXjhehVcY]VkZ ]ZVk^ZglZVg#  ™ I]ZildbV_dggddihVgZXdbegZhhZYbZh^dY^hiVaanVcYhZijcYZgi]ZbZh^VaVcY Y^hiVaXgdlc]VakZh#  ™ 6aagddihVc\aZY^hiVaanl^i]gZheZXiidi]ZbV_dgXgdlcVmZh#



8]VeiZg-9Zci^i^dc

2-

,-

2-

,-

2-

,-

2-

,-

,-

$%.4)4)/.

2-

2-

,-

&IGUREG^\]iVcYaZ[ijeeZgVcYadlZgeZgbVcZcibdaVgh#BZh^Va!WjXXVa!VcYdXXajhVa k^Zlh!il^XZcVijgVah^oZ#

-#.#,JeeZgBdaVgh

&*(

This Page Intentionally Left Blank



8]VeiZg-9Zci^i^dc

#HAPTER

=nd^YKZgiZWgVZ c ZVgan kZgiZWgViZh! V X]V^c d[ XVgi^aV\Z"gZeaVXZbZci WdcZh [dgbZY VgdjcY i]ZcdidX]dgYid\^kZ^ihi^[[cZhh#DkZgi^bZ!i]ZhZWdcZhYZkZadeZYegdXZhhZhi]Vi lgVeeZYVgdjcYi]ZYdghVah^YZd[i]ZcZgkZXdgY#IdYVnlZ`cdli]ZhZWdcZhVhkZgiZ" WgVZ!ZaZbZcih[gdbl]^X]i]ZZci^gZVc^bVahjWe]najbKZgiZWgViVYZg^kZh^ihcVbZ# >cbdhibdYZgckZgiZWgViZh!i]ZkZgiZWgVZ]VkZgZeaVXZYi]ZcdidX]dgYVhi]Zeg^cX^" eVabZVchd[hjeedgi[dgi]ZXZcigVaeVgid[i]ZWdYn#I]ZhVXgjbVcYXdXXnmVgZkZg" iZWgVZ!Wjii]Zn[jcXi^dcVheVgihd[i]ZWdcneZak^h#I]Z]nd^YWdcZ!Vc^ciZgbZY^Vgn WZilZZci]Zh`jaaVcYedhiXgVc^Vah`ZaZidc!XdbW^cZhh`ZaZiVaZaZbZcihd[i]ZhZXdcY VcYi]^gYe]Vgnc\ZVaVgX]ZhVhhdX^ViZYl^i]i]Z\^aahd[eg^b^i^kZÄh]#

(YOID&IGURESn !NATOMY I]Z]nd^YWdcZ^hadXViZY^ci]ZcZX`VcYXVcWZeVaeViZY^bbZY^ViZanVWdkZi]Zi]n" gd^YXVgi^aV\Zi]ZegdijWZgVcXZdci]ZVciZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]ZcZX`#>i^hi]ZdcanWdcZ ^ci]ZWdYni]ViYdZhcdiVgi^XjaViZl^i]Vcdi]ZgWdcZ#>chiZVY!^i^hhjheZcYZY[gdb i]Zi^ehd[i]Zhinad^YegdXZhhZhd[i]ZiZbedgVaWdcZhWni]Zhinad]nd^Ya^\VbZcih#I]Z ]nd^Y\^kZhViiVX]bZciidVkVg^Zind[bjhXaZhVcYa^\VbZcihi]ViXdccZXi^iidi]Z XgVc^jb!bVcY^WaZ!idc\jZ!aVgncm!e]Vgncm!hiZgcjb!VcYh]djaYZg\^gYaZ#>ihh]VeZ ^h]^\]an kVg^VWaZ VcY^i^hd[iZc[gVXijgZY^c[dgZch^XXVhZh^ckdak^c\higVc\jaVi^dc EdaaVcZcVcYJWZaV`Zg!&..,#I]ZJ"h]VeZY]nd^YXdch^hihd[i]gZZbV_dgeVgihi]Vi VgZkVg^VWan[jhZY/ V# I]ZR_TihigVYYaZhi]Zb^Ya^cZ#>i^hVi]^c!edhiZgdhjeZg^dganXdcXVkZ!XjgkZY WdcZi]ViVgi^XjaViZhl^i]!dg^h[jhZYaViZgVaanid!i]Z]nd^Y]dgch# W# I]ZWbUQdUbX_b^cVgZadc\!i]^chigjXijgZhi]Vi[dgbi]ZedhiZg^dgh^YZhd[i]Z ]nd^YWdcZVcYegd_ZXiedhiZgdaViZgVaan[gdbi]ZWdYndcZ^i]Zgh^YZ#I]Zi^ed[ ZVX]]dgc^hVha^\]ianZmeVcYZYijWZgXaZi]VihZgkZhVhi]ZViiVX]bZci[dgi]Z aViZgVai]ngd]nd^Ya^\VbZci# X# I]Z\UccUbX_b^cVgZhbVaa!Xdc^XVaZb^cZcXZhdci]ZhjeZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]Z WdcZ^ci]ZVgZVl]ZgZi]ZWdYnVcY\gZViZg]dgch_d^c#I]Z^gkVg^VWandhh^ÄZY Ve^XZh\^kZViiVX]bZciidi]Zhinad]nd^Ya^\VbZcih#

&**

6%24%"2!%

>

GREATERHORNS LESSERHORNS

BODY &IGURE8i_YTce`UbY_b EdhiZg^dg^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

&IGURE8i_YT\QdUbQ\ 6ciZg^dg^hidlVgYi]ZaZ[i! hjeZg^dg^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

&IGURE8i_YTY^VUbY_b EdhiZg^dg^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

'ROWTH I]Z]nd^Ydhh^ÄZh[gdbh^mXZciZgh/ild[dgi]ZWdYnVcYdcZ[dgZVX]d[i]Z\gZViZg VcYaZhhZg]dgch#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION =nd^YhVgZb^hiV`Zcbdhi[gZfjZcian[dg^bbVijgZkZgiZWgVahZXi^dch#  ™ I]ZWdYn^h[Vgi]^ccZgVcYbdgZeaViZ"a^`Zi]VcVkZgiZWgVaXZcigjb!dgZkZcVcn eVgid[VkZgiZWgVaVgX]#  ™ I]Z]dgchVgZadc\ZgVcYi]^ccZgi]Vci]Zhe^cdjhegdXZhhZhd[VcnkZgiZWgVa ZaZbZci#

3IDING  ™ I]Zl^YZhieVgid[i]Z\gZViZg]dgc^hVciZg^dg!VcYi]Z]dgci]^chVh^ihlZZeh edhiZg^dgan!hjeZg^dgan!VcYaViZgVaanidZcY^ci]ZijWZgXaZ#  ™ I]ZhjeZg^dghjg[VXZWZVghi]ZaZhhZg]dgch#

'ENERAL#HARACTERISTICSOF6ERTEBRAE 7ZXVjhZi]Z[jhZYkZgiZWgVZd[i]ZhVXgjbVcYXdXXnm[dgbeVgid[i]ZWdcneZak^h! i]ZnVgZYZhXg^WZY^c8]VeiZg&)#I]^hX]VeiZgYZhXg^WZhi]ZilZcin"[djgbdkVWaZkZg" iZWgVZ¸i]ZhZkZcXZgk^XVa!ilZakZi]dgVX^X!VcYÄkZajbWVgkZgiZWgVZ#>ci]^hhZXi^dc lZ^cigdYjXZeVgihXdbbdcidbdhikZgiZWgVZ0^ci]Z[daadl^c\hZXi^dchlZXdcXZc" igViZdcZVX]XaVhhd[kZgiZWgV# 

8]VeiZg.=nd^YKZgiZWgVZ

!NATOMY&IGURESn

SPINOUS PROCESS

LAMINA

VERTEBRAL FORAMEN

SUPERIORARTICULARFACET PEDICLE TRANSVERSEFORAMEN TRANSVERSEPROCESS VERTEBRALBODY

350%2)/2

INFERIORARTICULARFACET

).&%2)/2

!.4%2)/2

,!4%2!,

&IGURE6YVdXSUbfYSQ\fUbdURbQ6¹ine^XVaºXZgk^XVakZgiZWgV#EdhiZg^dg^hje^chjeZg^dg VcY^c[Zg^dgk^Zlh0hjeZg^dg^hje^cVciZg^dgVcYaViZgVak^Zlh#CVijgVah^oZ#

.#'
&*,

6%24%"2!%

I]ZkZgiZWgVaXdajbc^hbdhid[iZcXdbedhZYd[i]^gin"i]gZZZaZbZcih^ci]ZVYjai]j" bVc#D[i]ZhZ!ilZcin"[djgVgZhZeVgViZbdkVWaZkZgiZWgVZ!VcYi]Zdi]ZghVgZkVg^VWan [jhZYl^i]^ci]ZWdcneZak^h#>ih]djaYValVnhWZedhh^WaZid^YZci^[n^hdaViZY!ZkZc [gV\bZciVgn^cY^k^YjVakZgiZWgVZWnineZ¸ XZgk^XVa!i]dgVX^X!VcYajbWVg#8Zgk^XVa kZgiZWgVZVgZ^ci]ZcZX`!i]dgVX^XkZgiZWgVZ^ci]Zi]dgVm!VcYajbWVgkZgiZWgVZ_jhi hjeZg^dgidi]ZWdcneZak^h#L^i]^ci]ZhZjc^ih!^cY^k^YjVakZgiZWgVZVgZYZh^\cViZYWn aZiiZgA!ajbWVg0I!i]dgVX^X08!XZgk^XVaVcY^YZci^ÄZYWncjbWZg[gdbhjeZg^dgid ^c[Zg^dg#;dgZmVbeaZ!i]ZbdhihjeZg^dgi]dgVX^XkZgiZWgV^hYZh^\cViZYI"&#

SPINOUS PROCESS LAMINA

SUPERIOR ARTICULARFACET VERTEBRAL FORAMEN

TRANSVERSE PROCESS PEDICLE

VERTEBRALBODY

350%2)/2

0/34%2)/2

COSTALFOVEAE

,!4%2!, &IGURECUfU^dXdX_bQSYSfUbdURbQVWdkZVcYdeedh^iZ6¹ine^XVaºi]dgVX^XkZgiZWgV# EdhiZg^dg^hje^chjeZg^dgVcY^c[Zg^dgk^Zlh0hjeZg^dg^hje^cedhiZg^dg!aViZgVa!VcYVciZg^dg k^Zlh#AViZgVa^ha^i[gdbi]ZadlZgaZ[iidVXXZcijViZXdhiVaVgi^XjaVi^dch#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg.=nd^YKZgiZWgVZ

).&%2)/2

&IGUREXdci^cjZY

!.4%2)/2

HjXXZhh^kZkZgiZWgVZVgi^XjaViZY^gZXianl^i]dcZVcdi]ZgVXgdhhhncdk^Va_d^cih#6aa bdkZVWaZkZgiZWgVZ]VkZildhjeZg^dgVcYild^c[Zg^dgVgi^XjaVg[VXZih#I]ZhZ[djg[VX" ZihXdcigdabdkZbZciWZilZZcVY_VXZcikZgiZWgVZ0i]Z^gh]VeZhVgZi]Z`Znidi]Z[jcX" i^dcVcY^YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[Y^[[ZgZcikZgiZWgVZ#>cY^k^YjVakZgiZWgVZVgZjc^iZYl^i]^c i]ZkZgiZWgVaXdajbcWna^\VbZcihVcYbjhXaZhi]Vi]daYi]Zbid\Zi]Zg^cVÅZm^WaZ jc^i#I]Zi]gZZeg^bVgn[jcXi^dchd[ZVX]kZgiZWgVVgZidWZVgWdYnlZ^\]i!idVcX]dg bjhXaZhVcYa^\VbZcih!VcYidegdiZXii]Zhe^cVaXdgY#L]Zci]ZZci^gZXdajbcdgaVg\Z hZ\bZcihd[i]ZXdajbcVgZVkV^aVWaZ!^i^hZVhnid^YZci^[nZVX]kZgiZWgVWnineZVcY cjbWZg#HjXXZhh^kZkZgiZWgVaWdY^ZhXZcigVVgZaVg\ZgXVjYVaanWZXVjhZd[hjXXZhh^kZan \gZViZglZ^\]i"WZVg^c\gZhedch^W^a^i^Zh#HdbZ^cY^k^YjVakZgiZWgVZ!a^`Zi]ZViaVh8"&! VgZY^V\cdhZYZVh^an!ZkZc^[^hdaViZY!WZXVjhZd[i]Z^gjc^fjZbdge]dad\n#Di]Zgh!eVg" i^XjaVganb^Y"XZgk^XVahVcYb^Y"i]dgVX^Xh!VgZ[VgbdgZY^[ÄXjaiid^YZci^[nWncjbWZg l]Zc[djcYY^hVhhdX^ViZY[gdbi]Zdi]ZgkZgiZWgVZ# .#'
&*.

6%24%"2!%

INFERIOR ARTICULAR FACET

>ca^[Z!i]Z^ciZgkZgiZWgVaY^h`hVgZbVYZjed[XdcXZcig^Xg^c\hd[heZX^Va^oZYÄWgd" XVgi^aV\ZVcYa^ZWZilZZcVY_VXZcikZgiZWgVZ#:VX]Y^h`^hXdbedhZYd[VX^gXjb[ZgZci^Va WVcYd[ÄWgdjhi^hhjZVcYÄWgdXVgi^aV\Z`cdlcVhi]ZVccjajhÉWgdhjh#6ii]ZXZciZgd[ i]ZY^h`^hVhd[ihjWhiVcXZ`cdlcVhi]ZcjXaZjhejaedhjh#I]ZhZi^hhjZhVgZhjggdjcYZY WnVÉWgdjhXVehjaZ!l]^X]W^cYhid\Zi]ZgVY_VXZcikZgiZWgVaWdY^ZhVcYZcXVehjaViZhi]Z Y^h`h#I]ZhZhd[ii^hhjZXdbedcZcihVgZXg^i^XVa[dgbdkZbZci^ci]ZkZgiZWgVaXdajbc# I]Z^ciZgkZgiZWgVaY^h`hbV`ZjebdgZi]VcdcZ"Ä[i]d[i]ZXdajbc¼hidiVa]Z^\]i^ca^[Z VcYXdcig^WjiZid^ihY^hi^cXi^kZadc\^ijY^cVaXjgkVijgZ#9^h`hVgZi]^X`Zhi^ci]Zajb" WVgVcYXZgk^XVagZ\^dchl]ZgZi]ZkZgiZWgVaXdajbc^hbdhi[gZZanbdkVWaZ#

SPINOUS PROCESS LAMINA SUPERIOR ARTICULAR FACET

VERTEBRAL FORAMEN

TRANSVERSE PROCESS

PEDICLE

VERTEBRALBODY

350%2)/2

0/34%2)/2 &IGUREDXYbT\e]RQbfUbdURbQVWdkZVcYdeedh^iZ6¹ine^XVaºajbWVgkZgiZWgV#EdhiZg^dg ^hje^chjeZg^dgVcY^c[Zg^dgk^Zlh0hjeZg^dg^hje^cedhiZg^dg!aViZgVa!VcYVciZg^dgk^Zlh#AVi" ZgVa^ha^i[gdbi]ZjeeZgg^\]iidVXXZcijViZi]Zhe^cZVcY^c[Zg^dgVgi^XjaVg[VXZi#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg.=nd^YKZgiZWgVZ

INFERIOR ARTICULAR FACET 6%24%"2!%

).&%2)/2

INFERIORARTICULARFACET ,!4%2!,

&IGURE Xdci^cjZY

!.4%2)/2

.#'
&+&

>cY^k^YjVahXVckVgn^ci]ZcjbWZgd[kZgiZWgVZi]Zn]VkZ^cZVX]XViZ\dgn#I]^h kVg^Vi^dcbVndXXjg^cdkZg&%d[Vaa^cY^k^YjVah^cVh`ZaZiVaedejaVi^dc#KVg^Vi^dc [gdbi]ZjhjVaXdcY^i^dcbdhid[iZc^ckdakZhi]ZVYY^i^dcdghjWigVXi^dcd[dcZkZg" iZWgVahZ\bZci#I]Zbdhi[gZfjZciYZk^Vi^dc[gdbi]ZjhjVaeViiZgcd[,XZgk^XVa!&' i]dgVX^X!VcY*ajbWVgkZgiZWgVZ^hi]ZXVhZd[VcZmigVi]dgVX^XdgajbWVgkZgiZWgV l^i]VcVhhdX^ViZYh]^[i!Vhl^i]&(i]dgVX^XVcY)ajbWVgkZgiZWgVZ# LZÄghiYZhXg^WZi]ZWVh^XXdbedcZcihd[VcnkZgiZWgVWZ[dgZYZhXg^W^c\eVgi^XjaVg kZgiZWgVaXViZ\dg^Zh/ V# I]ZfUbdURbQ\V_bQ]U^^hi]Z]daZ^cZVX]kZgiZWgVi]gdj\]l]^X]i]Zhe^cVaXdgY eVhhZh#:VX]kZgiZWgVi]jh[dgbhVhZ\bZcid[i]ZkZgiZWgVaXVcVaeVhh^c\Ydlc i]ZkZgiZWgVaXdajbc# W# I]ZfUbdURbQ\R_Ti^hVhedda"h]VeZYhigjXijgZi]ViXdchi^ijiZhi]ZbV^clZ^\]i" WZVg^c\edgi^dcd[VkZgiZWgVZmXZei^ci]ZXVhZhd[i]ZViaVhVcYVm^h#I]ZWdYn^h kZgni]^c"lVaaZY!XdbedhZYbdhiand[a^\]ilZ^\]i![gV\^aZ!hedc\nWdcZ!VcY^i^h i]ZgZ[dgZkZgnhjhXZei^WaZidedhibdgiZbYVbV\Z#>i^hVahdVXZciZg[dgWaddYegd" YjXi^dc#I]ZaVg\Z[dgVbZcVii]Zb^Ya^cZdc^ihedhiZg^dghjg[VXZ^h[dgi]ZZm^id[ i]ZWVh^kZgiZWgVakZ^c# X# I]ZfUbdURbQ\QbSXZcXadhZhi]Zhe^cVaXdgYedhiZg^dgidi]ZkZgiZWgVaWdYn# Y# I]Z`UTYS\U^hi]Zh]dgihZ\bZcid[i]ZVgX]XadhZidi]ZkZgiZWgVaWdYn!ViiVX]ZY bdgZhjeZg^dganidi]ZWdYni]Vc^c[Zg^dgan#>ihhjeZg^dgVcY^c[Zg^dghjg[VXZhVgZ cdiX]ZY[dgi]Zhe^cVacZgkZhi]ViZbZg\Z[gdbi]Zhe^cVaXdgYid^ccZgkViZXdg" gZhedcY^c\WdYnhZ\bZcih#I]ZhZcZgkZheVhhi]gdj\]i]Z\VehWZilZZcVY_VXZci Vgi^XjaVi^c\kZgiZWgVZ!i]ZY^dUbfUbdURbQ\V_bQ]Y^Q#  Z# EdhiZg^dgidZVX]eZY^XaZ^hi]Z\Q]Y^Q!i]ZeaViZ"a^`ZeVgid[i]ZVgX]i]ViVi" iVX]Zhi]ZeZY^XaZidi]Zhe^cdjhegdXZhh#  [# I]Zc`Y^_ec`b_SUccegd_ZXihedhiZg^dgandci]Zb^Ya^cZVcYhZgkZhidVcX]dg i]Z^ciZghe^cdjhVcYhjegVhe^cdjha^\VbZcihVcYhZkZgVabjhXaZh#I]ZhZa^\VbZcih a^b^iÅZm^dcd[i]ZkZgiZWgVaXdajbc#7ZXVjhZi]Zhe^cdjhegdXZhhZhVXiVhaZkZgh [dgbjhXjaVgVXi^dc!i]ZaZc\i]!h^oZ!VcYhadeZd[^cY^k^YjVahe^cZhYZeZcYdci]Z [jcXi^dcVagdaZl]^X]kVg^djhWVX`bjhXaZheaVn# \# DcZdbQ^cfUbcU`b_SUcc^h[djcYdcZVX]h^YZd[ZVX]kZgiZWgV#A^`Zhe^cdjh egdXZhhZh!i]ZigVchkZghZegdXZhhZhVXiVhaZkZgh[dgi]ZbjhXaZhViiVX]ZYidi]Zb# BdkZbZcihd[i]ZVm^Vah`ZaZidcVgZbVYZedhh^WaZWni]ZbjhXaZhVXi^c\dci]ZhZ aZkZgh#BdkZbZci^hgZhig^XiZYWni]Za^\VbZcihi]Vi]daYi]Z^cY^k^YjVakZgiZWgVZ id\Zi]Zg#I]ZigVchkZghZegdXZhhZhd[i]dgVX^XkZgiZWgVZVgi^XjaViZl^i]i]Zg^Wh# ]# Ce`UbY_bQbdYSe\QbVQSUdc[VXZedhiZgdhjeZg^dgan^cbdhiXZgk^XVakZgiZWgVZ!edh" iZg^dgan^ci]Zi]dgVX^XkZgiZWgVZ!VcYedhiZgdbZY^Vaan^ci]ZajbWVgkZgiZWgVZ#  ^# 9^VUbY_bQbdYSe\QbVQSUdc[VXZ^ci]Zdeedh^iZY^gZXi^dchd[i]ZhjeZg^dg[VXZih[dg ZVX]kZgiZWgVaXaVhh#  _# I]Zi]dgVX^XkZgiZWgVZWZVgS_cdQ\V_fUQU!Vgi^XjaVg[VXZih[dgi]Zg^Wh!dci]Z h^YZhd[i]ZWdYnVcYdci]ZigVchkZghZegdXZhhZh#

'ROWTH&IGURE Bdhi kZgiZWgVZ dhh^[n [gdb i]gZZ eg^bVgn VcY ÄkZ hZXdcYVgn XZciZgh# >c ^bbVijgZ 

8]VeiZg.=nd^YKZgiZWgVZ

kZgiZWgVZ!i]Zi]gZZeg^bVgnXZciZghVgZi]ZXZcigjbVcYi]Zild]VakZhd[i]ZcZjgVa VgX]i]ZWdYn^hXdbedhZYd[i]^hXZcigjbeajhVhbVaahZ\bZcid[ZVX]cZjgVaVgX]# HZXdcYVgnXZciZghVgZ[djcYVii]Zi^ehd[ZVX]igVchkZghZegdXZhhVcYd[i]Zhe^cZ#;aVi" iZcZY!g^c\"a^`ZVede]nhZhhjggdjcYi]ZeZg^e]Zgnd[i]ZhjeZg^dgVcY^c[Zg^dghjg[VXZh d[ZVX]WdYn#I]ZhjeZg^dgVcY^c[Zg^dghjg[VXZhd[^bbVijgZkZgiZWgVaWdY^Zh]VkZV ¹W^aadlZYºVeeZVgVcXZ!l^i]Vi]^cWdcng^c\^chiZVYd[VgdjcYeaViZd[WdcZeaViZh VgZ[djcY^cbVcndi]ZgbVbbVah#I]^h[jhZhidi]ZWdYnjedch`ZaZiVabVijgVi^dc#

8Zgk^XVakZgiZWgVZi]Vih]VgZi]ZX]VgVXiZg^hi^XXZgk^XVaeViiZgcVgZ8"(i]gdj\]8"+# LZÄghiYZhXg^WZi]^heViiZgcVcYi]ZcVhhZhhi]Zi]gZZgZbV^c^c\XZgk^XVakZgiZWgVZ#

)DENTIlCATION  ™ KZgiZWgVaWdYn#8Zgk^XVaWdY^ZhVgZ^ciZgadX`^c\!l^i]hVYYaZ"h]VeZYhjeZg^dgVcY ^c[Zg^dghjg[VXZh#8Zgk^XVaWdY^ZhVgZhbVaaZgi]Vci]dhZd[i]dgVX^XdgajbWVg kZgiZWgVZ#  ™ 6gX]#6ii]Zgddid[i]ZXZgk^XVaVgX]VcYidZ^i]Zgh^YZd[i]ZXZgk^XVakZgiZWgVa WdYnVgZigVchkZghZ[dgVb^cV;^\jgZ.#)bZY^Vaidi]ZigVchkZghZegdXZhhZh# I]ZhZ[dgVb^cV]djhZi]ZkZgiZWgVaVgiZg^Zh!l]^X]eVhhjelVgYidi]ZedhiZg^dg eVgid[i]ZWgV^c#8Zgk^XVaVgX]ZhYZa^b^iig^Vc\jaVgkZgiZWgVa[dgVb^cV!l]^X] VgZaVg\ZVcYl^YZgZaVi^kZidi]Zh^oZd[i]ZkZgiZWgVaWdYn#  ™ He^cdjhegdXZhh#8Zgk^XVahe^cdjhegdXZhhZhegd_ZXi[V^gan]dg^odciVaanWZ]^cYi]Z kZgiZWgVaWdYnbdhianedhiZg^dgan!eVgian^c[Zg^dgan#I]ZnVgZjhjVaanW^[jgXViZY W^ÄYVcYd[iZcVhnbbZig^XVaVii]Z^gedhiZg^dgi^eh!h]dgiZgi]Vci]dgVX^Xhe^" cdjhegdXZhhZh!VcYcdiVhbVhh^kZVhajbWVghe^cdjhegdXZhhZh#  ™ IgVchkZghZegdXZhhZh#8Zgk^XVaigVchkZghZegdXZhhZhVgZkZgnhbVaa!h^c\aZdgeV^gZY ijWZgXaZhi]Viegd_ZXiaViZgVaanWZndcYi]ZigVchkZghZ[dgVb^cV#  ™ HjeZg^dgVcY^c[Zg^dgVgi^XjaVg[VXZih#8Zgk^XVaVgi^XjaVg[VXZihVgZXje"h]VeZYdg eaVcVg#I]ZhjeZg^dgVcY^c[Zg^dg[VXZihVgZeVgVaaZa0Wdi]eVhh[gdbVciZgdhjeZg^" dgidedhiZgd^c[Zg^dg#I]Z^c[Zg^dg[VXZi^hh^ijViZYbdgZedhiZg^dgidi]ZkZgiZWgVa WdYni]Vci]ZhjeZg^dg[VXZi#

3PECIAL#ERVICAL6ERTEBRAE&IGURESn  ™ I]ZQd\Qc8"&a^ZhWZilZZci]ZXgVc^jbVcYi]ZVm^h#HjeZg^dgVgi^XjaVg[VXZih d[i]ZViaVhVgZXdcXVkZVcYZadc\ViZVcYgZXZ^kZi]ZXdcYnaZhd[i]ZdXX^e^iVa WdcZ#I]ZViaVhkZgiZWgV]VhcdkZgiZWgVaWdYn!aVX`hVhe^cdjhegdXZhh!VcY]Vhcd Vgi^XjaVgY^h`hhjeZg^dgdg^c[Zg^dgid^i#Dci]ZedhiZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]ZVciZg^dg Wdcng^bd[i]^hkZgiZWgVi]ZVciZg^dgZY\Zd[i]ZkZgiZWgVa[dgVbZci]ZgZ^hVc dkVaVgi^XjaVi^dc[dgi]ZYZchhZZaViZgd[i]ZVm^h#  ™ I]ZQhYc8"'VahdaVX`hVine^XVakZgiZWgVaWdYnWji]VhVegd_ZXi^c\egdXZhhi]Vi [dgbhVe^kdi[dgi]ZViaVh#I]^hegd_ZXi^dc^hXVaaZYi]ZTU^cdg_T_^d_YT`b_SUcc .#(8Zgk^XVaKZgiZWgVZ

&+(

6%24%"2!%

#ERVICAL6ERTEBRAEN &IGURESAND

&IGUREFUbdURbQ\Wb_gdXVWdkZVcYdeedh^iZI]ZeV^ghd[^bbVijgZkZgiZWgVZ^chjeZg^dg k^ZlXdcigVhiVdcZ"nZVg"daYl^i]Vh^m"nZVg"daY^cZVX]XVhZ#Idegdl/ViaVhaZ[i!Vm^hg^\]i# B^YYaZgdl/Ä[i]XZgk^XVakZgiZWgVaZ[i!Ä[i]i]dgVX^XkZgiZWgVg^\]i#7diidbgdl/hZXdcY ajbWVgkZgiZWgVaZ[i!ÄghihVXgVakZgiZWgVg^\]i#6ciZg^dg^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg.=nd^YKZgiZWgVZ

6%24%"2!%

&IGUREXdci^cjZY

.#(8Zgk^XVaKZgiZWgVZ

&+*

#n

#n

#n

#n



8]VeiZg.=nd^YKZgiZWgVZ

&IGURE3UbfYSQ\ fUbdURbQUce`UbY_b aZ[iVcYdeedh^iZ EdhiZg^dg^hje# CVijgVah^oZ#

6%24%"2!%

#n

#n

#n &IGUREXdci^cjZY

.#(8Zgk^XVaKZgiZWgVZ

&+,

&IGURE1d\Qc fUbdURbQce`UbY_b EdhiZg^dg^hje# CVijgVah^oZ#

&IGURE1d\Qc fUbdURbQY^VUbY_b EdhiZg^dg^hje# CVijgVah^oZ#

&IGURE1hYc fUbdURbQce`UbY_b EdhiZg^dg^hje# CVijgVah^oZ# DENSOR ODONTOIDPROCESS

&IGURE1hYc fUbdURbQQ^dUbY_b HjeZg^dg^hje# CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg.=nd^YKZgiZWgVZ

&IGURE1d\Qc Q^TQhYcfUbdURbQU QbdYSe\QdUTQ^dUbY_b HjeZg^dg^hje# CVijgVah^oZ#

;^\jgZ.#&'#I]jh!l]Zci]Z]ZVY^hcdYYZYjeVcYYdlc!bdkZbZci^hbdhianVi i]Z_d^ciWZilZZci]ZdXX^e^iVaXdcYnaZVcY8"&#L]Zci]Z]ZVYijgch[gdbh^YZ idh^YZ!i]ZViaVhgdiViZhVWdjii]ZYZchd[i]ZVm^h#  ™ I]ZcUfU^dXSUbfYSQ\fUbdURbQ8",^higVch^i^dcVaWZilZZcVine^XVaXZgk^XVa VcYVine^XVai]dgVX^XkZgiZWgV#>ihkZgiZWgVaWdYn^hi]ZaVg\Zhid[i]ZXZgk^XVah VcY]VhVÅVi^c[Zg^dghjg[VXZ#>ihhe^cZbdhiXadhZangZhZbWaZhVi]dgVX^Xhe^cZ VcY^hjhjVaani]ZjeeZgbdhikZgiZWgVahe^cZeVaeVWaZ^ci]Zb^Ya^cZd[i]ZWVX` ^cVa^k^c\^cY^k^YjVa#

3IDING  ™ I]Zadc\Vm^hd[i]Zhe^cdjhegdXZhh^hY^gZXiZYedhiZgd^c[Zg^dgan#  ™ I]ZhjeZg^dgVgi^XjaVg[VXZi[VXZhedhiZgdhjeZg^dgan!VcYi]Z^c[Zg^dgdcZ[VXZhi]Z deedh^iZY^gZXi^dc#  ™ I]ZgV^hZYVgi^XjaVgh^YZhd[i]ZkZgiZWgVaWdYnVgZhjeZg^dg# .#)I]dgVX^XKZgiZWgVZ

&+.

6%24%"2!%

&IGURE1d\Qc Q^TQhYcfUbdURbQU QbdYSe\QdUTce`UbY_b EdhiZg^dg^hje# CVijgVah^oZ#

4HORACIC6ERTEBRAEN &IGURESAND I]dgVX^XkZgiZWgVZi]Vih]VgZi]ZX]VgVXiZg^hi^Xi]dgVX^XeViiZgcVgZI"'i]gdj\]I".# LZÄghiYZhXg^WZi]^heViiZgc!i]ZcVhhZhhi]Z[djggZbV^c^c\i]dgVX^XkZgiZWgVZ#:VX] i]dgVX^XkZgiZWgVVgi^XjaViZhl^i]VeV^gd[g^Wh#

)DENTIlCATION  ™ KZgiZWgVaWdYn#JeeZgi]dgVX^XWdY^ZhVgZgdj\]anig^Vc\jaVg^chjeZg^dgdjia^cZ! l]ZgZVhadlZgi]dgVX^XkZgiZWgVaWdY^ZhVgZbdgZX^gXjaVg#I]dgVX^XhVgZ^ciZg" bZY^ViZ^ch^oZWZilZZcXZgk^XVaVcYajbWVgkZgiZWgVZ#I]dgVX^XkZgiZWgVZ]VkZ Vgi^XjaVg[VXZihdci]Z^gaViZgVah^YZh!l]^X]hjeedgii]Zg^Wh#:VX]ine^XVag^W]Vh ildVgi^XjaVi^dchl^i]kZgiZWgVZ/dcZdci]Zh^YZd[VY_VXZcii]dgVX^XWdY^ZhVcY dcZVii]ZZcYd[i]Zi]dgVX^XigVchkZghZegdXZhh#KZgiZWgVZI"'i]gdj\]I".WZVg hjeZg^dgVcY^c[Zg^dg]Va[[VXZih!XVaaZYTU]YVQSUdc!dci]ZhjeZg^dgVcY^c[Zg^dg ZY\Zhd[i]ZaViZgVah^YZhd[i]Z^gWdY^Zh#I]jh!i]ZkZgiZWgVaWdYnd[Vcnine^XVa i]dgVX^XkZgiZWgVVgi^XjaViZhl^i][djgg^W]ZVYh!dcZhjeZgdaViZgVaanVcYdcZ ^c[ZgdaViZgVaandcZVX]h^YZ#L]Zcg^WVgi^XjaVi^dc^hcdih]VgZYWZilZZcVY_VXZci WdY^Zh!¹l]daZºXdhiVaVgi^XjaVi^dch!dgVQSUdc!gZhjai#  ™ 6gX]#I]ZkZgiZWgVaXVcVahVgZhbVaagZaVi^kZidi]ZWdY^ZhVcYVgZbdgZX^gXjaVg ^cdjia^cZi]Vc^cXZgk^XVakZgiZWgVZ#I]dgVX^XkZgiZWgVZaVX`igVchkZghZ[dgVb^cV#  ™ He^cdjhegdXZhh#I]dgVX^Xhe^cdjhegdXZhhZhVgZadc\!higV^\]i!VcYcVggdl XdbeVgZYidi]Zh]dgi!W^ÄYXZgk^XVahe^cdjhegdXZhhZhVcYi]Z]ViX]Zi"h]VeZY ajbWVghe^cdjhegdXZhhZh#I]ZVc\aZWZilZZci]ZWdYnVcYi]Zhe^cdjhegdXZhh WZXdbZhbdgZVXjiZVcY^hY^gZXiZYbdgZ^c[Zg^dgan^ckZgiZWgVZb^YlVnWZilZZc I"'VcYI"-#  ™ IgVchkZghZegdXZhhZh#I]dgVX^XigVchkZghZegdXZhhZhVgZegdb^cZciaViZgVaegd_ZX" i^dch[gdbi]ZVgX]#I]ZnWZVgVgi^XjaVgVQSUdcV_fUQUdci]Z^gVciZgdaViZgVa XdgcZgh[dgVgi^XjaVi^dcl^i]i]ZijWZgXaZhd[i]Zg^Wh#  ™ HjeZg^dgVcY^c[Zg^dgVgi^XjaVg[VXZih#I]dgVX^XhjeZg^dgVcY^c[Zg^dgVgi^XjaVg[VX" ZihVgZkZgnÅVieaVcVgVcYVgZhZikZgi^XVaan![VX^c\Y^gZXianVciZg^dgi]Z^c[Zg^dg [VXZidgedhiZg^dgi]ZhjeZg^dg[VXZi#

3PECIAL4HORACIC6ERTEBRAE&IGURESn  ™ I]ZÍbcddX_bQSYSfUbdURbQI"&]VhVl]daZXdhiVa[VXZihjeZg^dganVcYV]Va[ XdhiVa[VXZi^c[Zg^dgan#>igZiV^chbdgZXZgk^XVa"a^`ZX]VgVXiZg^hi^Xhd[^ihhe^cZVcY WdYni]VcVcndi]Zgi]dgVX^XkZgiZWgV#  ™ I]ZdU^dXdX_bQSYSfUbdURbQI"&%jhjVaan]VhVXdbeaZiZ!hjeZg^dganeaVXZYXdh" iVa[VXZidcZVX]h^YZd[i]ZkZgiZWgVaWdYnVcYXdhiVaVgi^XjaVi^dchdci]ZigVch" kZghZegdXZhhZh#  ™ I]ZU\UfU^dXdX_bQSYSfUbdURbQI"&&]VhVc^ciVXi!hjeZg^dganeaVXZYXdhiVa[VXZidc ZVX]h^YZd[i]ZkZgiZWgVaWdYnWjicdXdhiVaVgi^XjaVi^dcdci]ZigVchkZghZegdXZhhZh#  ™ I]ZdgU\VdXdX_bQSYSfUbdURbQI"&'gZhZbWaZhI"&&!Wjii]Z^c[Zg^dgVgi^XjaVg [VXZihVhhjbZi]ZajbWVgeViiZgc# 

8]VeiZg.=nd^YKZgiZWgVZ

6%24%"2!%

4n

4n

&IGURE DX_bQSYSfUbdURbQU ce`UbY_bi]^heV\Z! VcY[daadl^c\i]gZZ eV\ZhEdhiZg^dg^hje# CVijgVah^oZ#

4n

.#)I]dgVX^XKZgiZWgVZ

&,&

4n

4n

4n



8]VeiZg.=nd^YKZgiZWgVZ

&IGURE Xdci^cjZY

6%24%"2!%

4n

4n

&IGURE Xdci^cjZY

4n

.#)I]dgVX^XKZgiZWgVZ

&,(

4n

4n

4n



8]VeiZg.=nd^YKZgiZWgVZ

&IGURE Xdci^cjZY

&IGURE6Ybcd dX_bQSYSfUbdURbQ \QdUbQ\HjeZg^dg^hje# CVijgVah^oZ#

4n 6%24%"2!%

&IGUREDU^dX dX_bQSYSfUbdURbQ \QdUbQ\HjeZg^dg^hje# CVijgVah^oZ#

4n

&IGURE5\UfU^dX dX_bQSYSfUbdURbQ \QdUbQ\HjeZg^dg^hje# 4n CVijgVah^oZ#

&IGUREDgU\VdX dX_bQSYSfUbdURbQ \QdUbQ\HjeZg^dg^hje# CVijgVah^oZ#

4n

.#)I]dgVX^XKZgiZWgVZ

&,*

3IDING  ™ I]Zadc\Vm^hd[i]Zhe^cdjhegdXZhh^hedhiZg^dgVcY^hVc\aZYh]Vgean^c[Zg^dgan! eVgi^XjaVgan^ci]Zb^Y"i]dgVX^XgZ\^dc#  ™ I]ZhjeZg^dgVgi^XjaVg[VXZi[VXZhedhiZg^dgan!VcYi]Z^c[Zg^dgdcZ[VXZhVciZg^dgan#  ™ I]ZXdhiVaVgi^XjaVi^dcdci]ZigVchkZghZegdXZhhZh[VXZhVciZgdaViZgVaan#  ™ >caViZgVaVheZXii]Z^c[Zg^dgVgi^XjaVg[VXZihVgZhZeVgViZY[gdbi]ZgZVg]Va[d[ i]ZkZgiZWgVaWdYnWnVXdch^YZgVWaZ\Ve#  ™ I]Z^c[Zg^dgY^bZch^dchd[i]ZWdYnVgZ\gZViZgi]Vc^ihhjeZg^dgY^bZch^dch#

,UMBAR6ERTEBRAEN &IGURES  AND >i^hXdbeVgVi^kZanZVhnid^YZci^[n^cY^k^YjVaedh^i^dchd[^hdaViZYajbWVgkZgiZWgVZ# A^`Z i]Z i]dgVX^X VcY XZgk^XVa kZgiZWgVZ! i]Z ajbWVgh ^cXgZVhZ egd\gZhh^kZan ^c h^oZ [gdbhjeZg^dgid^c[Zg^dgA"&idA"*#AjbWVghVgZi]ZaVg\Zhid[Vaai]Zjc[jhZYkZg" iZWgVZ#CdiZi]Vii]Z^cY^k^YjVa^aajhigViZY^ci]^hbVcjVa]VhVhVXgVa^oZYA"*l^i]V eV^gd[ZmigVhVXgVaVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZh#

)DENTIlCATION  ™ KZgiZWgVaWdYn#AjbWVgWdY^ZhaVX`XdhiVae^ihVcYigVchkZghZ[dgVb^cV#

,n &IGURE<e]RQbfUbdURbQUce`UbY_bVWdkZ!deedh^iZ!VcY[daadl^c\eV\ZEdhiZg^dg^h je#CdiZi]Vii]ZA"*d[i]^h^cY^k^YjVa^h¹hVXgVa^oZYºVcYVgi^XjaViZh^cÄkZeaVXZhl^i]i]Z hVXgjb#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg.=nd^YKZgiZWgVZ

6%24%"2!%

,n

,n &IGUREXdci^cjZY

.#*AjbWVgKZgiZWgVZ

&,,

 ™ 6gX]#AjbWVgVgX]ZhVgZkZgnhbVaagZaVi^kZidi]Zh^oZd[i]ZWdY^Zh#  ™ He^cdjhegdXZhh#AjbWVghe^cdjhegdXZhhZhVgZ]ViX]Zi"h]VeZY!aVg\Z!Wajci!VcY bdgZ]dg^odciVaandg^ZciZYi]Vcdi]ZgkZgiZWgVahe^cdjhegdXZhhZhi]ZnVgZdg" i]d\dcVaidi]ZXdgdcVaeaVcZ#  ™ IgVchkZghZegdXZhhZh#AjbWVgigVchkZghZegdXZhhZhVgZgZaVi^kZanhbVaaZgVcYi]^c" cZgi]Vci]dgVX^XigVchkZghZegdXZhhZhVcYaVX`VcnVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZh#I]ZnVgZ

,n

,n &IGUREXdci^cjZY



8]VeiZg.=nd^YKZgiZWgVZ

gjY^bZciVgndgVWhZcidcA"&VcY^cXgZVhZ^ch^oZVcYegd_ZXi^dc^c[Zg^dgan#  ™ HjeZg^dgVcY^c[Zg^dgVgi^XjaVg[VXZih#I]ZhjeZg^dgVcY^c[Zg^dgajbWVgVgi^XjaVg [VXZihVgZcdieVgVaaZa#>chiZVY!i]ZhjeZg^dgVgi^XjaVg[VXZihVgZXdcXVkZVcY[VXZ edhiZgdbZY^Vaan#I]Z^c[Zg^dgVgi^XjaVg[VXZihVgZXdckZmVcY[VXZVciZgdaViZgVaan#

6%24%"2!%

,n

,n

,n &IGURE<e]RQbfUbdURbQU`_cdUbY_bVWdkZVcY[daadl^c\eV\ZK^Zl^c\i]ZWdcZh^c i]^hVheZXiVaadlhi]Z^g^cY^k^YjVa^YZci^ÄXVi^dc#HjeZg^dg^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

.#*AjbWVgKZgiZWgVZ

&,.

,n

,n &IGUREXdci^cjZY

)DENTIFYING,UMBAR0OSITION I]ZA"&^hi]ZhbVaaZhid[i]ZhZg^Zh#L]Zck^Zl^c\i]ZedhiZg^dghjg[VXZd[VajbWVg kZgiZWgVhZZ;^\jgZ.#'&!^bV\^cZVfjVYgVc\aZXdccZXi^c\i]ZXZciZghd[[djghjeZ" g^dgVcY^c[Zg^dgVgi^XjaVg[VXZih#>cA"&VcYA"'!i]^hdjia^cZ^hVkZgi^XVaanZadc\ViZ gZXiVc\aZ#>cA"(VcYA")i]Zdjia^cZgZhZbWaZhVhfjVgZ#>cA"*i]Zdjia^cZ^hV]dg^" odciVaanZadc\ViZgZXiVc\aZ#

3IDING  ™ I]Zadc\Vm^hd[ZVX]igVchkZghZegdXZhheVhhZh[gdbi]ZkZgiZWgVaWdYnVcYaVb^" cVhjeZgdaViZgVaan#  ™ I]ZhjeZg^dgVgi^XjaVg[VXZihVgZXdcXVkZVcY[VXZedhiZgdbZY^Vaan!l]ZgZVhi]Z ^c[Zg^dg[VXZihVgZXdckZmVcY[VXZVciZgdaViZgVaan#  ™ CdiZi]ZaVg\Z\VeWZilZZci]Z^c[Zg^dgVgi^XjaVg[VXZihVcYi]ZedhiZg^dghjg[VXZ d[i]ZkZgiZWgVaWdYn^caViZgVaVheZXi#I]ZVgX]dg^\^cViZh[gdbi]ZhjeZg^dg]Va[ d[i]ZkZgiZWgVaWdYn# 

8]VeiZg.=nd^YKZgiZWgVZ

#HAPTER

I]dgVm/HiZgcjbG^Wh >

3TERNUM&IGURESn !NATOMY I]ZhiZgcjb!dgWgZVhiWdcZ![jcXi^dchVi^ihjeeZgZcYidXdccZXii]Zh]djaYZg\^gYaZ XaVk^XaZVcYhXVejaVidi]Zi]dgVm#>cVYY^i^dc!^iVcX]dghi]ZVciZg^dgZcYhd[eV^gZY g^Wh &·, k^V XVgi^aV\Z# I]Z WdcZ ^h XdbedhZY d[ i]gZZ bV^c eVgih ^c VYjai]ddY Wji YZkZadeh[gdbh^mhZ\bZcih#I]ZhZ\bZci_d^cihbVnVaa[jhZ^cVYjai]ddY!Wjii]Z^g adXVi^dc^h^cY^XViZYWnXdhiVacdiX]ZhVadc\ZVX]h^YZd[i]ZhiZgcjb# V# I]Z]Q^eRbYe]^hi]ZbdhibVhh^kZ!i]^X`Zhi!VcYhfjVgZhid[i]gZZbV^chiZgcVa ZaZbZcih#>i^hi]ZhjeZg^dg"bdhiZaZbZcid[i]ZhiZgcjbVcY^hi]Zl^YZhieVgid[ i]^hWdcZ# W# 3\QfYSe\Qb^_dSXUcdXXjeni]ZhjeZg^dgXdgcZghd[i]ZhiZgcjb#>i^h]ZgZi]Vi i]ZbVcjWg^jbVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]Zg^\]iVcYaZ[iXaVk^XaZh# X# I]ZZeWe\Qbce`bQcdUb^Q\^_dSX^hi]Zb^Ya^cZcdiX]dci]ZhjeZg^dgWdgYZgd[ i]ZbVcjWg^jb# &-&

4(/2!8

ceg^b^i^kZ!V^g"WgZVi]^c\[^h]Zh!WgZVi]^c\lVhVXXdbea^h]ZYWnhlVaadl^c\ bdkZbZcih^cl]^X]V^glVh\jaeZY^cidi]Zajc\h#:VgangZei^aZh^begdkZYdci]^h hnhiZbl]Zci]ZnZkdakZYVbZVchidgZhe^gZk^Vi]ZbjhXjadh`ZaZiVabZX]Vc^Xhd[i]Z i]dgVX^Xh`ZaZidc#I]^hlVhbVYZedhh^WaZVhi]Zi]dgVX^Xg^WhZmiZcYZYkZcigVaan[gdb i]Z kZgiZWgVa Xdajbc id gZVX] i]Z hiZgcjb# I]Z hiZgcjb [dgbZY V `^cY d[ kZcigVa WdcnXdajbci]Vi[jhZY^cidVWdcnWVgVcYVcX]dgZYi]ZY^hiVaZcYhd[i]Zg^Wh#;jg" i]Zghd[ii^hhjZheZX^Va^oVi^dchaZYidbdgZhde]^hi^XViZYWgZVi]^c\[jcXi^dch# I]Zh`ZaZidcd[i]Z]jbVci]dgVm!dgX]Zhi!^ha^`ZVWVh`ZidgXV\ZXdbedhZYd[XVg" i^aV\ZVcYWdcZ#>i^hViiVX]ZYYdghVaanidi]ZkZgiZWgVaXdajbc#I]^hhigjXijgZZcXadhZh VcYegdiZXihi]Zeg^cX^eVadg\Vchd[X^gXjaVi^dcVcYgZhe^gVi^dc!i]Z]ZVgiVcYajc\h! VcY^hi]ZWVhZidl]^X]i]ZjeeZga^bWhVgZViiVX]ZY#I]ZbV_dgWdcZh[dgb^c\i]Z i]dgVmVgZi]ZhiZgcjbVcYi]ZilZakZg^WhdcZVX]h^YZ#I]ZjeeZghZkZcg^WhdcZVX] h^YZXdccZXi!k^VXVgi^aV\Z!Y^gZXianl^i]i]ZhiZgcjbVcYVgZhdbZi^bZhXVaaZY¹igjZ!º dg¹hiZgcVa!ºg^Wh#G^Wh-·&%ViiVX]idi]ZhiZgcjb^cY^gZXian!Vahdk^VXVgi^aV\Z!VcY VgZhdbZi^bZhXVaaZY¹[VahZ!ºdg¹VhiZgcVa!ºg^Wh#I]ZaVhiildg^Wh¹ÅdVi^c\ºg^Wh]VkZ h]dgiXVgi^aV\^cdjhZcYhi]Via^Z[gZZ^ci]Zh^YZhd[i]ZWdYnlVaa#

JUGULARSUPRASTERNAL NOTCH

CLAVICULAR NOTCH

MANUBRIUM

CORPUSSTERNI

&IGURECdUb^e]Q^dUbY_bI]Zm^e]d^YegdXZhhdci]^hhiZgcjb]VYcdi dhh^ÄZYVcY^hcdih]dlc#HjeZg^dg^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&%I]dgVm/HiZgcjbG^Wh

lRST COSTAL NOTCH 4(/2!8

COSTAL NOTCHES

&IGURECdUb^e]\UVd\QdUbQ\ HjeZg^dg^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

&IGURECdUb^e]`_cdUbY_bHjeZg^dg^hje# CVijgVah^oZ#

&%#&HiZgcjb

&-(

Y# 3_cdQ\^_dSXUcdXXjenWdi]h^YZhd[i]ZbVcjWg^jb^c[Zg^dgidi]ZXaVk^XjaVg cdiX]Zh#I]ZhZcdiX]ZhgZegZhZciVgi^XjaVi^dchl^i]i]ZXdhiVaXVgi^aV\Zhd[i]Z Äghig^Wh#I]ZbVcjWg^jbh]VgZhVgi^XjaVi^dc[dgi]ZhZXdcYg^Whl^i]i]ZXdgejh hiZgc^#  Z# I]ZS_b`eccdUb^Y^hi]ZXZcigVaeVgi!i]ZWdYn!dgWaVYZ!d[i]ZhiZgcjb#>i^h [dgbZYYjg^c\dcid\Zcn[gdbi]Z[jh^dcd[hiZgcVahZ\bZcihhiZgcZWgVZ'·*# I]ZXdgejhhiZgc^bVn[jhZ!eVgi^Vaan[jhZ!dggZbV^cjc[jhZYl^i]i]ZbVcj" Wg^jb^cVYjai]ddY#  [# I]ZcdUb^Q\Q^W\U^hi]ZVc\aZ[dgbZYWZilZZci]Z[jhZYbVcjWg^jbVcYi]Z XdgejhhiZgc^# \# I]ZS_cdQ\^_dSXUcVadc\Z^i]Zgh^YZd[i]ZXdgejhhiZgc^VgZ[dgVgi^XjaVi^dcl^i] i]ZXdhiVaXVgi^aV\Zhd[g^Wh'·,# ]# c*·&%d[VYjaiXdgedgVhiZgcdgjbVb^Ya^cZ[dgVbZc!i]ZcdUb^Q\V_bQ]U^! eZg[dgViZhi]ZhiZgcVaWdYn#  _# I]ZhY`X_YT`b_SUcc^hi]ZkVg^VWandhh^ÄZY^c[Zg^dgi^ed[i]ZhiZgcjb#>id[iZc [jhZhl^i]i]ZXdgejhhiZgc^^cdaYZgVYjaih#>ih]VgZhi]ZhZkZci]XdhiVacdiX] l^i]i]ZWdYn#I]^hegdXZhhXVcWZeVgi^Vaandhh^ÄZYVcYbVndhh^[n^cidW^oVggZ VhnbbZig^XVah]VeZhl^i]dYYeZg[dgVi^dch#>ch]dgi!i]Zm^e]d^Y^hV]^\]ankVg^" VWaZZaZbZci#I]Zm^e]d^YegdXZhhd[i]Z^cY^k^YjVaX]dhZcid^aajhigViZi]^hiZmi! [dgZmVbeaZ!lVhcdidhh^ÄZYVii]Zi^bZd[YZVi]#

'ROWTH I]Z[djghjeZg^dgXZciZghd[dhh^[^XVi^dcbVcjWg^jbVcYXdgejhhiZgc^hZ\bZcih '·)VeeZVg^c[ZiVaa^[Z#I]Zi^b^c\d[[jh^dcWZilZZchiZgcVahZ\bZcih^hd[iZc^g" gZ\jaVg! Wji [jh^dc WZilZZc i]Z adlZg ild XZciZgh ^c i]Z Xdgejh hiZgc^ hZ\bZcih ) VcY*dXXjghhddcV[iZgejWZgin#;jh^dcdXXjghWZilZZchZ\bZcih'!(!VcY)WnZVgan VYjai]ddY#6hbZci^dcZYZVga^Zg!i]ZbVcjWg^jbVcYXdgejhhiZgc^hdbZi^bZh[V^aid jc^iZ!ZkZc^cVYjai]ddY#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION ;gV\bZcihd[i]ZhiZgcjbb^\]iWZb^hiV`Zc[dg[gV\bZcihd[eZak^hdg^bbVijgZkZg" iZWgVZ#  ™ I]ZXdhiVaVcYXaVk^XjaVgcdiX]Zh!VcYi]Za^cZhd[[jh^dcWZilZZchiZgcVahZ\" bZcih!h]djaYWZhj[ÄX^ZciidZchjgZXdggZXi^YZci^ÄXVi^dc#  ™ I]ZhiZgcjb^hVWdcZl^i]kZgnadlYZch^in#>ihXdgiZm^heVeZg"i]^c!eZg[dgViZY WncjbZgdjhb^Xgd[dgVb^cV#I]^hbV`ZhZkZc[gV\bZciVgnhiZgcVZVhnidhdgi [gdbdi]ZgZaZbZcih!hjX]Vhi]ZeZak^h#  ™ >c[VcihiZgcZWgVZVgZd[iZcXdc[jhZYl^i]kZgiZWgVaXZcigV#>c[VciXZcigV]VkZ gdj\]Zg!aZhhbVijgZ^#Z#!bdgZW^aadlZY!\gVcjaVgXdgi^XVahjg[VXZh#



8]VeiZg&%I]dgVm/HiZgcjbG^Wh

3IDING  ™ ;gV\bZcihd[bVcjWg^jbVcYXdgejhhiZgc^XVcWZh^YZYWncdi^c\i]Vii]ZVc" iZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]^hWdcZ^hgdj\]ZgVcYbdgZXdckZmi]Vci]Zhbddi]!\Zcian XdcXVkZedhiZg^dghjg[VXZ#  ™ I]Za^cZhd[[jh^dceVhh]dg^odciVaan!VcYi]ZbZY^daViZgVaanl^YZhied^cidci]Z XdgejhhiZgc^^hVii]Zi]^gYhZ\bZci^c[Zg^dgidi]ZbVcjWg^jb#

2IBS&IGURESn !NATOMY

V# I]ZXUQTd[Vg^W^hi]ZhldaaZcegdm^bVaeVgid[i]Zg^W#>iWZVghildVgi^XjaVg hjg[VXZhYZb^[VXZih[dgXdciVXil^i]i]ZWdY^Zhd[hjXXZhh^kZi]dgVX^XkZgiZWgVZ# I]ZÄghig^WVcYg^Wh&%·&'VgZjc^[VXZiZY# W# I]Z^US[d[Vg^W^hi]Zh]dgihZ\bZciWZilZZci]Z]ZVYVcYi]Zg^W¼hVgi^XjaVi^dc l^i]i]ZigVchkZghZegdXZhhd[i]Zi]dgVX^XkZgiZWgV# X# I]ZdeRUbS\U^hadXViZYdci]ZedhiZgd^c[Zg^dgXdgcZgd[ZVX]g^W#>iVgi^XjaViZh l^i]i]ZigVchkZghZegdXZhhd[i]Zi]dgVX^XkZgiZWgV!egZhZci^c\VbZY^VaVgi^XjaVg [VXZi[dgVgi^XjaVi^dcl^i]i]ZigVchkZghZegdXZhhd[i]Zi]dgVX^XkZgiZWgV!VcYV cdcVgi^XjaVgeVgi[dga^\VbZcidjhViiVX]bZci# Y# I]ZQ^W\U^hi]Zh]VgeXjgkZ^ci]ZWdcZaViZgVaidi]ZijWZgXaZ#>i^hbVg`ZYWn Vegdb^cZcia^cZdci]ZZmiZgcVahjg[VXZd[i]Zh]V[i^bbZY^ViZanY^hiVaaViZgVa idi]ZijWZgXaZ#I]^ha^cZbVg`hi]ZViiVX]bZcid[i]ZYZZebjhXaZhd[i]ZWVX`# >iVahdbVg`hi]Zh]^[i[gdbi]ZXVjYVaan[VX^c\ZmiZgcVag^Whjg[VXZidi]ZbdgZ XgVc^Vaandg^ZciZYZmiZgcVahjg[VXZ#I]ZijWZgXaZ"id"Vc\aZY^hiVcXZ^cXgZVhZh[gdb g^W)idg^W&&#  Z# I]ZcXQVdd[Vg^W^hi]ZXjgkZY!iVeZg^c\hZ\bZciWZilZZci]ZijWZgXaZVcYi]Z g^W¼hY^hiVakZcigVa!VciZg^dgZcY#H]V[ihd[g^Wh(·+VgZi]^X`ZgVcYgdjcYZY^c hZXi^dcXdbeVgZYidi]dhZd[g^Wh,·&'#  [# I]ZS_cdQ\Wb__fUd[Vg^W^hi]Z\gddkZVadc\i]ZbZY^Vah^YZd[i]Z^c[Zg^dgZY\Z d[i]Zg^Wh]V[i#>ca^[Zi]^h\gddkZ]djhZhVc^ciZgXdhiVaVgiZgn!kZ^c!VcYcZgkZ#>i^h bdhiegdb^cZcidcg^Wh*·,# &%#'G^Wh

&-*

4(/2!8

I]ZgZVgZjhjVaanilZakZg^WhdcZVX]h^YZd[i]Zi]dgVm![dgVidiVad[ilZcin"[djg^c i]ZVYjaibVaZVcY[ZbVaZ]jbVcWdYn#I]ZcjbWZgd[g^Wh^hkVg^VWaZ0i]ZgZbVnWZ ZaZkZc dg i]^giZZc g^Wh dc V h^YZ! l^i] hjeZgcjbZgVgn g^Wh ^c Z^i]Zg i]Z XZgk^XVa dg ajbWVghZ\bZci7aVX`VcYHX]ZjZg!&..,#I]ZjeeZghZkZcg^WhcjbWZgh&·,Vgi^Xj" aViZY^gZXianl^i]i]Zh^YZhd[i]ZhiZgcjbk^VXVgi^aV\Z#G^Wh-!.!VcY&%VgZ^ciZgXdc" cZXiZYbZY^VaanWnXdbbdcXVgi^aV\Zhi]ViViiVX]idi]ZhiZgcjb#I]ZaVhiildg^Wh!&& VcY&'!]VkZ[gZZ"ÅdVi^c\Y^hiVaZcYh#6aag^WhVgi^XjaViZk^Vi]Z^gegdm^bVaZcYhl^i] i]dgVX^XkZgiZWgVZ#I]Zg^WhjhjVaan^cXgZVhZ^caZc\i][gdbg^W&idg^W,!VcYYZXgZVhZ [gdbg^W,idg^W&'#8dcXZgcl^i]i]ZjhZd[i]ZhiZgcVag^WZcYidZhi^bViZVYjai V\ZViYZVi]8]VeiZg&.]VhaZYhZkZgVa^ckZhi^\VidghidgZÄcZbZi]dYhd[h^Y^c\VcY hZfjZcX^c\]jbVcg^WhBVcc!&..(0=deeVVcYHVjcYZgh!&..-#I]ZhZVeeanidg^Wh `cdlcidWZ[gdbVh^c\aZ^cY^k^YjVa#

350%2)/2

&IGUREBYWXdbYRcDcZ"i]^gYcVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&%I]dgVm/HiZgcjbG^Wh

).&%2)/2

\# I]ZcdUb^Q\U^Td[Vg^W^hi]ZVciZg^dgkZcigVaZcYd[i]Zh]V[i#I]^hZcY^hV gdj\]ZcZY!edgdjh!XjeeZYdkVahjg[VXZ[dgi]ZViiVX]bZcid[XVgi^aV\Z#>ihhjg[VXZ X]Vc\ZhhjWhiVci^Vaanl^i]^cXgZVh^c\V\Z#I]ZhiZgcVaZcYhd[g^Wh&&VcY&'iV" eZgidVed^ci# ]# I]ZSbQ^YQ\e``UbUTWUd[bdhig^Wh^hWajci!hbddi]!VcYXdckZm#  ^# I]ZSQeTQ\\_gUbUTWUd[bdhig^Wh^hh]Vge!l^i]VXdhiVa\gddkZdci]ZbZY^Va hjg[VXZ#I]^h\gddkZ\^kZhi]Zhjg[VXZd[i]Zg^Wi]Vi[VXZhi]ZWdYnXVk^inVXdc" XVkZVeeZVgVcXZ#

3PECIAL2IBS&IGURE

'ROWTH G^Wh!ZmXZei[dgi]ZZaZkZci]VcYilZa[i]!dhh^[n[gdb[djgXZciZgh#:e^e]nhZh[dgi]Z ]ZVYVcY[dgi]ZVgi^XjaVgVcYcdcVgi^XjaVgeVgihd[i]ZijWZgXaZVeeZVg^ci]ZiZZch# I]Zn[jhZidi]Zg^WWdYn^cZVganVYjai]ddY#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION  ™ 6[gV\bZciVgnÄghig^Wb^\]iWZb^hiV`Zc[dgVc^c[Zg^dggVbjhd[i]ZdhXdmVZ# I]ZXdgiZmd[i]Zg^W!]dlZkZg!^hcdiVhi]^X`!i]Zhjg[VXZ^hbdgZ^ggZ\jaVg!VcY i]ZXgdhhhZXi^dc^hbjX]i]^ccZgi]Vc^ci]ZdhXdmVZ#  ™ Egdm^bVaZcYhd[di]Zgg^Wh!l]ZcWgd`Zc^cidh]dgihZ\bZcih!XdjaYWZb^hiV`Zc [dgbZiViVghVadgbZiVXVgeVah]V[ih#=dlZkZg!i]ZXgdhhhZXi^dcd[Vg^W^hbdgZ &%#'G^Wh

&-,

4(/2!8

 ™ I]ZÍbcdbYR^hi]ZbdhijcjhjVaVcYi]ZgZ[dgZbdhiZVh^anY^V\cdhZYg^W#>i^h VWgdVY!hjeZgd^c[Zg^dganÅViiZcZY!h]dgi!i^\]ianXjgkZYWdcZl^i]dcandcZVg" i^XjaVg[VXZidc^ihhbVaagdjcYZY]ZVY#>ihhjeZg^dgXgVc^Vahjg[VXZ^hgdj\]ZcZY WnbjhXaZViiVX]bZcih#I]^hhjg[VXZVahdWZVghildh]Vaadl\gddkZh/i]ZVciZg^dg dcZ[dgi]ZhjWXaVk^VckZ^c;^\jgZ&%#,VcYi]Zdi]Zg[dgi]ZhjWXaVk^VcVgiZgnVcY ^c[Zg^dgigjc`d[i]ZWgVX]^VaeaZmjhbZY^Va;^\jgZ&%#,#I]Zg^Y\ZWZilZZci]ZhZ \gddkZh^hegdadc\ZYkZcigVaan^cidi]ZcSQ\U^UdeRUbS\U[dgi]ZViiVX]bZcid[ i]ZVciZg^dghXVaZcZbjhXaZ;^\jgZ&%#,#I]ZgZ^hcdigjZ^c[Zg^dgXdhiVa\gddkZ#  ™ I]ZcUS_^TbYR^h^ciZgbZY^ViZWZilZZci]ZjcjhjVaÄghig^WVcYi]ZbdgZine^" XVag^Wh(·.#>i]VhVaVg\ZijWZgdh^in[dgi]ZhZggVijhVciZg^dgbjhXaZcZVgi]ZZmiZg" cVab^Yh]V[iedh^i^dc;^\jgZ&%#,#  ™ I]ZdU^dXbYR^ha^`Zg^Wh(·.WjijhjVaan]VhdcanVh^c\aZVgi^XjaVg[VXZidci]Z ]ZVY#  ™ I]ZU\UfU^dXbYR]VhVh^c\aZVgi^XjaVg[VXZidci]Z]ZVYVcYaVX`hVijWZgXaZ#>ih hiZgcVaZcY^hcVggdlVcYd[iZced^ciZY#>ihh]V[i]VhVha^\]iVc\aZVcYVh]Vaadl XdhiVa\gddkZ#  ™ I]ZdgU\VdXbYR^hh]dgiZgi]Vci]ZZaZkZci]VcYbVnZkZcWZh]dgiZgi]Vci]Z Äghi#I]^hg^W^hh^b^aVgidi]ZZaZkZci]^cbdge]dad\nVcYVahdaVX`hi]ZVc\aZ VcYi]ZXdhiVa\gddkZ#

350%2)/2

ANGLE

CRANIALUPPER EDGE

&IGUREBYWXdUYWXdXbYR V¹ine^XVaºg^W#]ZgZVcYdeedh^iZ CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&%I]dgVm/HiZgcjbG^Wh

TUBERCLE

).&%2)/2

4(/2!8

COSTALGROOVE CAUDALLOWER EDGE

STERNALEND

&IGUREXdci^cjZY

&%#'G^Wh

&-.

&IGURE BYWXdUYWXdXbYR `_cdUb_Y^VUbY_b CVijgVah^oZ#

HEAD NECK

SHAFT

TUBEROSITYFORSERRATUS ANTERIORMUSCLE GROOVEFOR SUBCLAVIANARTERYAND BRACHIALPLEXUS SCALENE TUBERCLE GROOVEFOR SUBCLAVIAN VEIN

350%2)/2 

8]VeiZg&%I]dgVm/HiZgcjbG^Wh

&IGURE BYWXdÍbcdQ^T cUS_^TbYRc aZ[iVcYdeedh^iZ CVijgVah^oZ#

4(/2!8

&IGURE Xdci^cjZY

).&%2)/2 &%#'G^Wh

&.&

^ggZ\jaVg!l^i]dcZh]VgeZY\Z#JhjVaani]ZijWZgXaZ!]ZVY!dgeVgid[i]ZXdhiVa \gddkZ^hZcdj\]idY^V\cdhZVWgd`ZcheZX^bZcVhVg^W#  ™ I]Z]ZVYVcYcZX`d[i]ZÄghig^WVgZÅViiZgVcYhbVaaZg!gZheZXi^kZan!i]VcV igVchkZghZegdXZhh[gdbVi]dgVX^XkZgiZWgV#  ™ I]Z]ZVYd[Vg^Wb^\]iWZXdc[jhZYl^i]VWgd`Zc^c[VcijacV!WjiViiZci^dcid WdcZbVijg^inXVcV^Y^ci]ZY^V\cdh^hd[i]ZhZeVgih#

3IDING  ™ ;dgi]ZÄghig^W!i]Z]ZVYVcYcZX`ed^ci^c[Zg^dgan!VcYi]ZhjeZg^dghjg[VXZWZVgh \gddkZhl]Zc^cXdggZXiVcVidb^XVaedh^i^dc#  ™ ;dgVaadi]Zgg^Wh!i]Z]ZVYhed^ciidlVgYi]Zb^Ya^cZ!VcYi]ZijWZgXaZhVgZ^c[Z" g^dg#  ™ I]ZXgVc^VaZY\Z^hi]^X`ZgVcYWajciZgi]Vci]Z\gddkZY!h]Vge^c[Zg^dgZY\Z#  ™ I]Z^ccZghjg[VXZd[i]ZilZa[i]g^W[VXZhhjeZg^dgan#



8]VeiZg&%I]dgVm/HiZgcjbG^Wh

#HAPTER

H]djaYZg<^gYaZ/ 8aVk^XaZHXVejaV I

#LAVICLE&IGURESn !NATOMY I]ZXaVk^XaZ^hVijWjaVg!hdbZl]ViH"h]VeZYWdcZ#>ihbZY^VaZcYhiZgcVaZmigZb^in Vgi^XjaViZh!k^VVhncdk^Va_d^ci!l^i]i]ZXaVk^XjaVgcdiX]d[i]ZbVcjWg^jb#>ihaVi" ZgVaZcYVXgdb^VaZmigZb^inVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]ZVXgdb^VaegdXZhhd[i]ZhXVejaV#I]Z XaVk^XaZ^hdkVa"id"X^gXjaVg^cXgdhhhZXi^dc#I]ZbZY^VaZcY^hgdjcYZYVcYÅVgZYa^`Z VigjbeZi!VcYi]ZaViZgVaZcY^hÅViiZcZYhjeZgd^c[Zg^dgan#I]^hZaZbZci^hZVh^aneVa" eViZYVadc\^ihaZc\i]^cVa^k^c\eZghdc# V# I]ZS_cdQ\Y]`bUccY_^deRUb_cYdia^Zhdci]ZbZY^VaZcYhiZgcVaZmigZb^in d[i]Z^c[Zg^dghjg[VXZd[i]ZXaVk^XaZ#>i^hVWgdVY!gdj\]hjg[VXZi]ViVcX]dghi]Z XdhidXaVk^XjaVga^\VbZci!l]^X]higZc\i]Zchi]ZhiZgcdXaVk^XjaVg_d^ci# W# I]ZceRS\QfYQ^ce\SecWb__fUgjchVadc\i]ZedhiZgd^c[Zg^dgfjVYgVcid[i]Z b^Yh]V[i!egdk^Y^c\Vgdd[dkZgi]Z\gZVikZhhZahd[i]ZcZX`VcYVc^chZgi^dc[dg i]ZhjWXaVk^jhbjhXaZWZilZZci]ZXaVk^XaZVcYi]Zg^WXV\Z#>ci]ZXVhZd[V[gVXijgZ! i]ZhjWXaVk^jhegdiZXihi]ZhZkZhhZahWnegZkZci^c\bdi^dc^ci]Z[gZZZcYd[i]Z _V\\ZY[gVXijgZYWdcZ#

&.(

3(/5,$%2

]ZYZeVgijgZd[[^h]Zh[gdbi]Z^gVfjVi^X]VW^iViWgdj\]iegd[djcYX]Vc\Zh ^cadXdbdi^dc#I]Z[dgZa^bW\^gYaZh]djaYZg\^gYaZ!dg^\^cVaanViiVX]ZYidi]Z gZVgd[i]Z]ZVY!YZiVX]ZYVcYbdkZYiV^alVgY!aZVk^c\VÅZm^WaZcZX`#6hi]^h\^gYaZ bdkZYXVjYVaan!hdbZd[i]Z]ZVY¼hYZgbVaVgbdgVcY\^aabjhXaZhgZbV^cZYViiVX]ZY id^i!VcYVhVgZhjaidjgdlch]djaYZg\^gYaZ^hhi^aaViiVX]ZYidi]Zh`jaaWnYZg^kVi^kZh d[hdbZd[i]ZhZeg^b^i^kZ\^aabjhXaZh#I]ZgZbV^c^c\YZgbVaWdcZZaZbZciXdchi^" ijiZheVgid[djgXaVk^XaZ#I]Z]jbVch]djaYZg\^gYaZegdk^YZhhjeedgiVcYVgi^XjaV" i^dc[dgi]Z]jbZgjhVcYVcX]dghVkVg^Zind[bjhXaZh#I]Z[jcXi^dcd[i]ZXaVk^XaZVhV higji[dgi]Zh]djaYZg^hbVYZdWk^djhl]Zc[gVXijgZd[i]^hWdcZ^hVXXdbeVc^ZYWnVc VciZgdbZY^VaXdaaVehZd[i]Zh]djaYZg#I]Zh]djaYZg\^gYaZZbWgVXZhi]Zi]dgVmedhiZ" g^dgan!aViZgVaan!VcYVciZg^dgan!egdk^Y^c\VeaVi[dgb[dgbdkZbZcihd[i]Z[dgZa^bW#

TRAPEZOIDLINE OBLIQUERIDGE SUBCLAVIANSULCUS GROOVE COSTALIMPRESSION TUBEROSITY CONOIDTUBERCLE &IGUREBYWXdS\QfYS\UY^VUbY_b6ciZg^dg^hje!aViZgVa^hidlVgYi]ZaZ[i#CVijgVah^oZ#

ATTACHMENTSITEFORTRAPEZIUSMUSCLE

ATTACHMENTSITEFORDELTOIDEUSMUSCLE

ATTACHMENTSITEFORPECTORALISMAJORMUSCLE

&IGUREBYWXdS\QfYS\Uce`UbY_b6ciZg^dg^hYdlc!aViZgVa^hidlVgYi]ZaZ[i#CVijgVah^oZ#

&IGUREBYWXdS\QfYS\UQ^dUbY_bHjeZg^dg^hje!aViZgVa^hidlVgYi]ZaZ[i#CVijgVah^oZ#

X# I]ZS_^_YTdeRUbS\U^h[djcYdci]ZaViZgVaZcYVXgdb^VaZmigZb^ind[i]Z XaVk^XaZ!VcY^hadXViZYedhiZg^dgan#>i^hi]ZViiVX]bZcied^ci[dgi]ZXdcd^Ya^\V" bZci!l]^X]ViiVX]Zhidi]ZXdgVXd^YegdXZhhd[i]ZhXVejaVVcYgZ^c[dgXZhi]Z_d^ci WZilZZci]ZhZildWdcZh# Y# I]ZdbQ`Uj_YT\Y^U_R\YaeUbYTWUaZVYhaViZgVaan[gdbi]ZXdcd^YijWZgXaZ#>i^h i]ZViiVX]bZcih^iZ[dgi]ZigVeZod^Ya^\VbZci!l]^X][jcXi^dcha^`Zi]ZXdcd^Ya^\V" bZci#  Z# I]Zce`UbY_bcebVQSUd[i]ZXaVk^XaZWZVghaZhhgZa^Z[i]Vci]Z^c[Zg^dghjg[VXZ# 

8]VeiZg&&H]djaYZg<^gYaZ/8aVk^XaZHXVejaV

I]Zgj\dh^i^Zhdci]ZedhiZgdaViZgVahjg[VXZd[i]ZWdcZbVg`i]ZViiVX]bZcih^iZ [dgi]ZigVeZo^jhbjhXaZ!VcYgj\dh^indci]ZVciZgdaViZgVahjg[VXZd[i]ZXaVk^XaZ^h [dgi]ZYZaid^YZjhbjhXaZ#I]Zgj\dh^indci]ZVciZgdbZY^Vahjg[VXZVcX]dgheVgid[ i]ZeZXidgVa^hbV_dgbjhXaZ#

'ROWTH&IGURE I]ZXaVk^XaZdhh^ÄZh^cbZbWgVcZVcYhZXdcYVgnXVgi^aV\Z[gdbildeg^bVgnXZciZgh ^ci]Zh]V[iVcYVhZXdcYVgnXZciZgVii]ZhiZgcVaZcY#I]ZWdcZ^hd[YZkZadebZciVa ^ciZgZhiWZXVjhZ^i^hi]ZÄghiiddhh^[n^cjiZgdVilZZ`*#>i^hVahdi]ZaVhiWdcZid[jhZ! dci]ZhiZgcVaZcY!Vi'%·'*nZVghd[V\Z#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION I]ZaViZgVaZcYd[i]ZXaVk^XaZ^hbdhid[iZcb^hiV`Zc[dgi]ZVXgdb^dcegdXZhhd[i]Z hXVejaV^c[gV\bZciVgnheZX^bZch#

3IDING I]Z[daadl^c\Xg^iZg^Vh]djaYWZhj[ÄX^ZciidXdggZXianh^YZ[gV\bZcihd[XaVk^XaZ/  ™ I]ZbZY^VaZcY^hgdjcY0i]ZaViZgVaZcY^hÅViiZcZY#  ™ I]ZWdcZWdlhVciZg^dgan[gdbi]ZbZY^VaZcY!XjgkZhedhiZg^dganVib^Yh]V[i! VcYi]ZchlZZehVciZg^dganV\V^cVh^igZVX]Zhi]ZaViZgVa!ÅViiZcZYZcY#I]jh!i]Z VeZmd[i]ZÄghid[i]ZildXjgkZhl]^X]\^kZi]ZXaVk^XaZ^ihH"h]VeZ^hbZY^Va! VcYi]ZVeZmd[i]ZhZXdcYXjgkZ^haViZgVa#  ™ Bdhi^ggZ\jaVg^i^ZhVcYgdj\]Zc^c\hVgZdci]Z^c[Zg^dghjg[VXZ#  ™ I]Z[VXZi[dgi]ZÄghiXdhiVaXVgi^aV\Z^hdci]Z^c[Zg^dgZY\Zd[i]ZbZY^VaXaVk^XaZ! VcYi]ZXdhiVaijWZgdh^in^hVahd^c[Zg^dg#

3CAPULA&IGURESn !NATOMY I]ZhXVejaV^hVaVg\Z!ÅVi!ig^Vc\jaVgWdcZl^i]ildWVh^Xhjg[VXZh/edhiZg^dgYdghVa VcYXdhiVaVciZg^dg!dgkZcigVa#I]ZgZVgZi]gZZWdgYZghi]VibZZi^ci]gZZVc\aZh#I]Z hXVejaVVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]ZXaVk^XaZVcYi]Z]jbZgjh# &&#&8aVk^XaZ

&.*

3(/5,$%2

 ™ I]ZVXgdb^dcd[i]ZhXVejaVXdci^cjZhbZY^VaanidWZXdbZi]ZhXVejaVghe^cZ! l]ZgZVhi]ZaViZgVaZcYd[i]ZXaVk^XaZWZXdbZh^cXgZVh^c\anXna^cYg^XVaVhi]Z h]V[ihigZiX]ZhbZY^Vaan#  ™ >cXdbeVg^hdchd[i]Zi^ehd[ZVX]WdcZ!i]Z[VXZid[i]ZXaVk^XaZ^haViZgVaVcYi]Z [VXZid[i]ZVXgdb^dc^hVciZgdbZY^Va#

CORACOIDPROCESS

SUPERIOR ANGLE SUPERIOR CRANIAL BORDER SCAPULARNOTCH ORFORAMEN

MEDIAL VERTEBRAL BORDER SUBSCAPULAR FOSSA

OBLIQUERIDGES

&IGUREBYWXdcSQ`e\QQ^dUbY_bHjeZg^dg^hje!aViZgVa^hidlVgYi]ZaZ[i#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&&H]djaYZg<^gYaZ/8aVk^XaZHXVejaV

ACROMIONACROMIONPROCESS SCAPULAR SPINE SUPRASPINOUS FOSSA

LATERAL AXILLARY BORDER

INFERIOR ANGLE

&IGUREBYWXdcSQ`e\Q`_cdUbY_bHjeZg^dg^hje!aViZgVa^hidlVgYi]Zg^\]i#CVijgVah^oZ#

&&#'HXVejaV

&.,

3(/5,$%2

INFRASPINOUS FOSSA

SUPRAGLENOID TUBERCLE

GLENOIDCAVITY GLENOIDFOSSA

INFRAGLENOID TUBERCLE

&IGURE BYWXdcSQ`e\Q \QdUbQ\HjeZg^dg ^hje!VciZg^dg^h idlVgYi]Zg^\]i# CVijgVah^oZ#

V# I]Zce`UbY_bSbQ^YQ\R_bTUb^hi]Zh]dgiZhiVcYbdhi^ggZ\jaVgWdgYZg# W# I]ZcSQ`e\Qb^_dSXdgV_bQ]U^^hVkVg^VWaZ[ZVijgZdci]ZhjeZg^dgWdgYZg# I]^hhZb^X^gXjaVgcdiX]^h[dgbZYeVgianWni]ZWVhZd[i]ZXdgVXd^YegdXZhh# >iigVchb^ihi]ZhjegVhXVejaVgcZgkZVcYbVnWZXdbZV[dgVbZc^[i]Za^\VbZci VXgdhh^ihXgVc^VaZY\Zdhh^ÄZh# X# I]ZS_bQS_YT`b_SUcc_jihVciZg^dganVcYhjeZgdaViZgVaan[gdbi]ZhjeZg^dgWdg" YZgd[i]ZhXVejaV#I]^hÄc\Zg"a^`Z!Wajci!gj\dhZegd_ZXi^dcVcX]dghVkVg^Zind[ bjhXaZh!a^\VbZcih!VcY[VhX^Vah]ZZih^bedgiVci^ci]Z[jcXi^dcd[i]Zh]djaYZg _d^ci# 

8]VeiZg&&H]djaYZg<^gYaZ/8aVk^XaZHXVejaV

3(/5,$%2

SCAPULARNECK

&IGUREBYWXdcSQ`e\Qce`UbY_b6ciZg^dg^hidlVgYi]ZaZ[i!aViZgVa^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

&&#'HXVejaV

&..

Y# I]ZceRcSQ`e\QbV_ccQ^hi]Zh]VaadlXdcXVk^ini]ViYdb^cViZhi]ZVciZg^dgXdh" iVahjg[VXZd[i]ZhXVejaV#  Z#I]Z_R\YaeUbYTWUci]ViXgdhhi]ZhjWhXVejaVg[dhhV[gdbhjeZgdaViZgVaid^c[Zgd" bZY^VaVgZ[dgbZYWn^cigVbjhXjaVgiZcYdchd[i]ZhjWhXVejaVg^hbjhXaZ!VbV_dg bjhXaZi]Vi[jcXi^dch^cbZY^VagdiVi^dcVcYVYYjXi^dcd[i]Z]jbZgjhVcYVh" h^hih^cdi]ZgbdkZbZcihd[i]ZVgbVii]Zh]djaYZg#  [# I]Z\QdUbQ\QhY\\QbiR_bTUb^hi]ZVciZgdedhiZg^dgani]^X`ZhiWdgYZg#>i^hjhjVaan ha^\]ianXdcXVkZ# \# I]ZW\U^_YTSQfYdiW\U^_YTV_ccQ^hVh]Vaadl!kZgi^XVaanZadc\ViZXdcXVk^in i]VigZXZ^kZhi]Z]ZVYd[i]Z]jbZgjh#I]Zh]VaadlcZhhd[i]^h_d^ciVaadlh\gZVi bdW^a^ind[i]Z]jbZgjhX^gXjbYjXi^dcXdbZhZVh^an!Wjii]Zh]djaYZg_d^ci^h XdchZfjZcianbdgZegdcZidY^hadXVi^dci]Vci]Z]^e_d^ci# ]# I]Zce`bQW\U^_YTdeRUbS\Uh^ihVY_VXZciidi]ZhjeZg^dgZY\Zd[i]Z\aZcd^YXVk^" in!Vii]ZWVhZd[i]ZXdgVXd^Y#I]^hVcX]dghi]Zadc\]ZVYd[i]ZW^XZehWgVX]^^bjhXaZ! VÅZmdgd[i]ZVgbVcY[dgZVgb#  ^ I]ZY^VbQW\U^_YTdeRUbS\Uh^ih_jhiVY_VXZciidi]Z^c[Zg^dgZY\Zd[i]Z\aZcd^Y XVk^in#>i\^kZhdg^\^cidi]Zadc\]ZVYd[i]Zig^XZehWgVX]^^bjhXaZ!VcZmiZchdgd[ i]Z[dgZVgbVcYVcZmiZchdgVcYVYYjXidgd[i]ZVgbVii]Zh]djaYZg#  _# I]ZcSQ`e\Qb^US[^hi]Zha^\]ianXdchig^XiZYgZ\^dc_jhibZY^Vaidi]Z\aZcd^Y [dhhV# `# I]Z]UTYQ\fUbdURbQ\R_bTUb^hi]ZhigV^\]iZhi!adc\Zhi!VcYi]^ccZhiWdgYZg#  a# I]ZcSQ`e\Qbc`Y^UYdb^cViZhi]ZedhiZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]ZhXVejaV#>ieVhhZhbZ" Y^daViZgVaanVXgdhhi]^hhjg[VXZ!bZg\^c\bZY^Vaanl^i]i]ZkZgiZWgVaWdgYZgVcY egd_ZXi^c\aViZgVaanVhi]ZVXgdb^dcegdXZhh# b# I]ZQSb_]Y_^QSb_]Y_^`b_SUcc^hi]ZaViZgVaegd_ZXi^dcd[i]ZhXVejaVghe^cZ# >ihXgVc^Vahjg[VXZ^hkZgngdj\]!egdk^Y^c\ViiVX]bZci[dgVedgi^dcd[i]ZYZa" id^YZjhbjhXaZ!VbV_dgVgbVWYjXidgl]dhZdg^\^chXdci^cjZVadc\i]Z^c[Zg^dg ZY\Zd[i]ZhXVejaVghe^cZ#I]ZjeeZgÄWZghd[i]ZigVeZo^jhbjhXaZ!l]^X]VXiVh hXVejaVggdiVidgh!Vahd^chZgi]ZgZ#I]ZVciZgdbZY^VaXdgcZgd[i]ZVXgdb^dcWZVgh VhbVaaVgi^XjaVg[VXZi[dgi]ZY^hiVaZcYd[i]ZXaVk^XaZ# c# I]Zce`bQc`Y^_ecV_ccQ^hi]ZaVg\Z!bZY^daViZgVaanZadc\ViZ]daadl^c\hjeZg^dg idi]ZWVhZd[i]Zhe^cZ#>i^hi]Zh^iZd[dg^\^cd[i]ZhjegVhe^cVijhbjhXaZ!VbV_dg VWYjXidgd[i]ZVgb# d# I]ZY^VbQc`Y^_ecV_ccQ^hi]Z]daadl^c\^c[Zg^dgidi]ZhXVejaVghe^cZ#I]^h ZmiZch^kZ!lZV`anXdcXVkZVgZV^hi]Zh^iZd[dg^\^cd[i]Z^c[gVhe^cVijhbjhXaZ!V aViZgVagdiVidgd[i]ZVgb#I]Z^cigVbjhXjaVgiZcYdchd[i]^hbjhXaZViiVX]idi]Z g^Y\Zhdci]Zhjg[VXZd[i]Z[dhhV# e# I]Zce`UbY_bQ^W\Ud[i]ZhXVejaV^hl]ZgZi]ZhjeZg^dgVcYbZY^VakZgiZWgVa WdgYZgh^ciZghZXi#I]ZaZkVidghXVejaVZbjhXaZViiVX]Zhidi]ZYdghVahjg[VXZd[i]Z hXVejaV^ci]^hgZ\^dc# f# I]ZY^VUbY_bQ^W\Ud[i]ZhXVejaV^hl]ZgZi]ZkZgiZWgVabZY^VaVcYVm^aaVgn aViZgVaWdgYZgh^ciZghZXi#Gj\dh^i^Zhdci]ZXdhiVaVcYYdghVahjg[VXZh^ci]^hVgZV bVg`i]Z^chZgi^dchd[i]ZhZggVijhVciZg^dgbjhXaZhVcYdg^\^cd[i]ZiZgZhbV_dg bjhXaZ[gdbi]ZbZY^VaVcYaViZgVaWdgYZgh!gZheZXi^kZan#



8]VeiZg&&H]djaYZg<^gYaZ/8aVk^XaZHXVejaV

'ROWTH&IGURE I]ZhXVejaVdhh^ÄZh[gdbhZkZcdgbdgZXZciZgh#DcZd[i]ZhZ^h[dgi]ZWdYn!ildZVX] [dgi]ZXdgVXd^YVcYVXgdb^dc!VcYdcZZVX][dgi]ZkZgiZWgVaWdgYZgVcY^c[Zg^dgVc" \aZ#Dhh^ÄXVi^dcd[i]ZWdgYZgh^hkVg^VWaZ!l^i]Zadc\ViZYeaViZhVeeZVg^c\VcY[jh^c\ Yjg^c\VYdaZhXZcXZ#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION  ™ L]Zc[gV\bZciVgn!i]ZhXVejaVb^\]iWZb^hiV`Zc[dgi]ZeZak^h#>cVaad[^ihÅVi eVgih!]dlZkZg!i]ZhXVejaV^hi]^ccZgi]Vci]ZeZak^h#>cYZZY!i]ZhXVejaVgWaVYZ ^hbdhianVh^c\aZ!i]^caVnZgd[WdcZ^chiZVYd[hedc\nWdcZhVcYl^X]ZYWZilZZc Xdgi^XZhVh^ci]ZeZak^h#

3(/5,$%2

&IGURE8aVk^XjaVgVcYhXVejaVg\gdli]# IdeHjeZg^dgk^Zld[VdcZ"nZVg"daYaZ[iVcYVh^m"nZVg"daYXaVk^XaZg^\]i# 7diidb9dghVak^Zld[VdcZ"nZVg"daYaZ[iVcYVh^m"nZVg"daYg^\]ihXVejaV#CVijgVah^oZ#

&&#'HXVejaV

'%&

 ™ 6Wgd`Zc[gV\bZcid[\aZcd^YXdjaYWZb^hiV`Zc[dgi]Z]^e_d^ci#I]Z\aZcd^Y^h bjX]h]VaadlZgVcYhbVaaZgi]Vci]ZVXZiVWjajb#  ™ I]ZXdgVXd^YXdjaYWZb^hiV`Zc[dgi]ZigVchkZghZegdXZhhd[Vi]dgVX^XkZgiZWgV! Wjii]ZXdgVXd^Y^hcdcVgi^XjaVg#  ™ I]ZaViZgVaeVgid[i]ZVXgdb^dc^hhdbZi^bZhb^hiV`Zc[dgV[gV\bZcid[aViZgVa XaVk^XaZ#=dlZkZg!WZXVjhZi]ZVXgdb^dc^hXdci^cjdjhl^i]i]Zi]^c!eaViZ"a^`Z he^cZ!gVi]Zgi]VcVXna^cYg^XVah]V[i!i]^hb^hViig^Wji^dcXVcWZVkd^YZY#I]Z^c" [Zg^dgVXgdb^Vahjg[VXZ^hVahdhbddi]VcYXdcXVkZ0i]ZY^hiVaXaVk^XaZ^hcdi#  ™ I^cn[gV\bZcihd[hXVejaVgWaVYZdg^c[VcihXVejaVhXdjaYWZb^hiV`Zc[dgl^c\h d[i]Zhe]Zcd^Y!Wjii]Zi]^cWdcZd[i]ZhXVejaVl^aaWZWdjcYZYWnWgd`Zc hjg[VXZh!l]ZgZVhWgd`Zce^ZXZhd[he]Zcd^Ye^ZXZhcdgbVaan]VkZ[gZZdghjijgVa ZY\Zh#

3IDING L]Zc^ciVXi!i]Z\aZcd^Y^haViZgVaVcYi]Zhe^cZ^hedhiZg^dg#L]Zc[gV\bZciVgn!jhZ i]Z[daadl^c\Xg^iZg^V/  ™ ;dgVc^hdaViZY\aZcd^Y!i]Z[dhhV^hiZVgYgde"h]VeZY!l^i]^ihWajciZcY^c[Zg^dg# L]Zcadd`^c\Y^gZXian^cidi]ZXdggZXiandg^ZciZY\aZcd^Y[dhhV!cdiZi]Vii]Z VciZg^dgZY\Zd[i]Z[dhhV]VhVWgdVYcdiX]^c^i#I]ZhjegV\aZcd^YijWZgXaZVii]Z hjeZg^dgZY\Zd[i]Z\aZcd^Y^hY^heaVXZYVciZg^dgan#EdhiZg^dgan!i]ZWdgYZgd[i]Z \aZcd^Y^hlV^hiZY!VcYi]ZZY\Z^hgV^hZYVcYgdj\]ZcZY#I]ZVciZg^dgWdgYZg^h cdiVhgV^hZY0^i\ZcianhadeZh^cidi]ZgZhid[i]ZhXVejaV#  ™ ;dgVc^hdaViZYVXgdb^dc!i]Z^c[Zg^dghjg[VXZd[i]ZVXgdb^dc^hXdcXVkZVcY^h hbddi]Zgi]Vci]ZhjeZg^dg#I]ZXaVk^XjaVg[VXZi^heaVXZYVciZg^dgbZY^VaangZaV" i^kZidi]Zi^e#  ™ ;dgVc^hdaViZYkZgiZWgVaWdgYZg!i]ZVciZg^dghjg[VXZ^hXdcXVkZVcYi]ZedhiZg^dg ^hXdckZm#I]ZdWa^fjZg^Y\Zhgjc[gdbhjeZgdaViZgVaid^c[ZgdbZY^VaeVgVaaZaid i]ZhXVejaVghe^cZ#  ™ ;dgVc^hdaViZY^c[Zg^dgVc\aZ!i]ZVciZg^dghjg[VXZ^hXdcXVkZ!l]^aZi]ZedhiZg^dg ^hXdckZm#I]Zi]^X`ZhiWdgYZg^haViZgVaVm^aaVgn#  ™ ;dgVc^hdaViZYVm^aaVgnWdgYZg!i]ZWgdVYhjaXjh^c[Zg^dgidi]Z\aZcd^YeVgVaaZah i]ZWdgYZgVcY^hY^heaVXZYVciZg^dgan#I]ZWdgYZg^ihZa[i]^ch^c[Zg^dgan#I]ZWdcn i]^X`Zc^c\^h\gZViZhi[dgb^c\V¹WVgºdci]ZVciZg^dghjg[VXZ#I]^X`cZhhd[i]Z XdgiZm^cXgZVhZhVhi]Z\aZcd^Y^hVeegdVX]ZYVadc\i]^hWdgYZg#  ™ ;dgVc^hdaViZYXdgVXd^Y!i]Zhbddi]hjg[VXZ^h^c[Zg^dg!i]Zgdj\]hjeZg^dg#I]Z VciZg^dgWdgYZg^hadc\Zg#I]Z]daadldci]Z^c[Zg^dghjg[VXZ[VXZhi]Z\aZcd^YVgZV edhiZgd^c[Zg^dgan#  ™ ;dgVc^hdaViZYhe^cZ!i]Zhe^cZi]^chbZY^VaankZgiZWgVaanVcYi]^X`ZchidlVgYh i]ZVXgdb^dc#I]Z^c[Zg^dgWdgYZg]VhVijWZgXaZi]Vied^cih^c[Zg^dgan#6Y_VXZci idi]Zhe^cZ!i]Z^c[gVhe^cdjh[dhhV^hbdhiYZZeanZmXVkViZYbZY^Vaan#I]ZhjegV" he^cdjh[dhhV^hbdhiYZZeanZmXVkViZYaViZgVaan#6kVg^VWanegZhZci[dgVbZcdg [dgVb^cVeZg[dgViZhi]ZhXVejaVVii]ZhjeZgdaViZgVaWVhZd[i]Zhe^cZ!Vii]ZYZei] d[i]ZhjegVhe^cdjh[dhhV#



8]VeiZg&&H]djaYZg<^gYaZ/8aVk^XaZHXVejaV

#HAPTER

6gb/=jbZgjh! GVY^jh!JacV I

(UMERUS&IGURESn !NATOMY I]ZjeeZgVgbWdcZ!dg]jbZgjh!^hi]ZaVg\ZhiWdcZ^ci]ZjeeZga^bWVgb#>iXdb" eg^hZhVegdm^bVaZcYl^i]VgdjcYVgi^XjaVg]ZVY!Vh]V[i!VcYVc^ggZ\jaVgY^hiVaZcY# I]Z]jbZgjhVgi^XjaViZhegdm^bVaanl^i]i]Z\aZcd^Y[dhhVd[i]ZhXVejaVVcYY^hiVaan l^i]Wdi]i]ZgVY^jhVcYi]ZjacV# V# I]ZXUQT^hV]Zb^he]ZgZdci]Zegdm^bVaZcYd[i]Z]jbZgjhi]Vi[VXZhbZY^" VaanVcYVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]Z\aZcd^Y[dhhVd[i]ZhXVejaV# W# I]ZQ^Qd_]YSQ\^US[^hi]Z\gddkZi]ViZcX^gXaZhi]ZVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZd[i]Z]ZVY [dgi]ZViiVX]bZcid[i]Z_d^ciXVehjaZ#

'%(

!2-

]Z[^ghikZgiZWgViZhaVX`ZY_Vlh#I]ZhZVc^bVah!h^b^aVgidbdYZgcaVbegZnh VcY]V\Äh]!VahdaVX`ZYeV^gZYÄch#?VlhVcYÄchZkdakZY)%%b^aa^dcnZVghV\d! Vaadl^c\Äh]idadXdbdiZVcY[ZZYbdgZZ[[ZXi^kZan#?VlZYÄh]]VkZeV^gZYÄchhZidc ÅVieaViZhd[WdcZi]ViVgZViiVX]ZYidi]ZbjhXaZhd[i]Z^gWdYnlVaah#I]ZhZeV^gZY Äch!ÅZm^WaZ[Vchd[hbVaaWdcZh!VgZjhZYeg^bVg^anVhV^Yh^chiVW^a^o^c\VcYhiZZg" ^c\#I]Za^bWhd[iZggZhig^VaVc^bVahZkdakZY[gdbi]^hhigjXijgVaVggVc\ZbZciVhÄch lZgZigVch[dgbZY^cidgdY"WZVg^c\hZ\bZcih#6ai]dj\]i]Za^bWhd[aVcYkZgiZWgViZh hZZbkZgnY^[[ZgZci[gdbÄh]Äch!i]Zild]dbdad\djhhigjXijgZhVgZVXijVaan]^\]an XdbeVgVWaZ# :VX]kZgiZWgViZa^bW]VhVWVhZVcYi]gZZhZ\bZcih#I]ZWVhZhi]Za^bW\^gYaZh VgZi]ZdaYWVhVaÄceaViZhd[Äh]!l]^X]ZkdakZYidiV`Zdci]Z[jcXi^dcd[igVch[Zgg^c\ i]ZlZ^\]id[i]ZWdYnidi]Za^bWhd[i]ZiZggZhig^VaiZigVedY#I]Zegdm^bVakZgiZWgViZ a^bWhZ\bZcihXdchi^ijiZi]ZjeeZgVgbVcYi]^\]#I]Z^ciZgbZY^ViZa^bWhZ\bZcih! i]Z[dgZVgbVcY[dgZaZ\!ZVX]WZVgildWdcZh^c]jbVch!i]ZgVY^jhVcYjacV^ci]Z Vgb!VcYi]Z^ghZg^Va]dbdad\h!i]Zi^W^VVcYÄWjaV!^ci]ZaZ\#I]^hX]VeiZgXdch^YZgh i]Zi]gZZWdcZhd[i]ZildjeeZgbdhihZ\bZcihd[i]Z[dgZa^bW/i]Z]jbZgjh!gVY^jh! VcYjacV#

HEAD GREATERTUBERCLE LESSERTUBERCLE INTERTUBERCULAR SULCUS BICIPITALGROOVE CRESTOFTHE LESSERTUBERCLE CRESTOFTHE GREATERTUBERCLE

&IGUREABYWXd Xe]UbecQ^dUbY_b Egdm^bVaZcY# CVijgVah^oZ#

X# I]ZcebWYSQ\^US[^hi]Zh]dgihZ\bZci^c[Zg^dgidi]Z]ZVY#>ia^c`h]ZVYVcYh]V[i# Y# I]Z\UccUbdeRUbS\U^hVhbVaa!WajciZb^cZcXZVciZgdaViZgVaidi]Z]ZVYdci]Z egdm^bVah]V[i#I]ZaZhhZgijWZgXaZbVg`hi]Z^chZgi^dcd[i]ZhjWhXVejaVg^hbjhXaZ! l]^X]dg^\^cViZhdci]ZXdhiVahjg[VXZd[i]ZhXVejaVVcYgdiViZhi]Z]jbZgjhbZ" Y^Vaan#  Z# I]ZWbUQdUbdeRUbS\U^haVg\Zg!bdgZedhiZg^dg!VcYegd_ZXihbdgZaViZgVaani]Vc i]ZaZhhZgijWZgXaZ#I]Z\gZViZgijWZgXaZWZVghgj\dh^i^Zh[dgi]Z^chZgi^dcd[i]Zhj" 

8]VeiZg&'6gb/=jbZgjh!GVY^jh!JacV

NUTRIENTFORAMEN

LATERAL SUPRACONDYLAR CRESTRIDGE

CORONOID FOSSA

&IGUREBBYWXd Xe]UbecQ^dUbY_b 9^hiVaZcY# CVijgVah^oZ#

TROCHLEA CAPITULUM

egVhe^cVijh!^c[gVhe^cVijh!VcYiZgZhb^cdgbjhXaZh#I]ZhZbjhXaZh!id\Zi]Zgl^i]i]Z hjWhXVejaVg^hbjhXaZ!Xdchi^ijiZi]ZgdiVidgXj[[bjhXaZh#>cVYY^i^dcidbZY^VaVcY aViZgVagdiVi^dc!i]ZhZbjhXaZhVahdV^Y^cVYYjXi^dcVcYVWYjXi^dcd[i]ZVgb#  [# I]ZY^dUbdeRUbSe\Qbce\SecRYSY`YdQ\Wb__fUZmiZcYhadc\^ijY^cVaanYdlci]Z egdm^bVah]V[i#>iWZ\^chWZilZZci]ZildijWZgXaZhVcY]djhZhi]ZiZcYdcd[i]Z adc\]ZVYd[i]ZW^XZehWgVX]^^bjhXaZ#>ca^[Z!i]ZigVchkZghZ]jbZgVaa^\VbZciXdccZXih i]ZildijWZgXaZhidWg^Y\Zi]Z\gddkZVcY[dgbVXVcVa# &'#&=jbZgjh

'%*

!2-

MEDIAL SUPRACONDYLAR CRESTRIDGE RADIALFOSSA

&IGUREABYWXd Xe]Ubec`_cdUbY_b Egdm^bVaZcY# CVijgVah^oZ#

\# I]ZSbUcd_VdXUWbUQdUbdeRUbS\U[dgbhi]ZaViZgVaa^ed[i]Z^ciZgijWZgXjaVg \gddkZ#>i^hi]Z^chZgi^dch^iZ[dgi]ZeZXidgVa^hbV_dgbjhXaZ!VbjhXaZi]Vidg^\^" cViZhdci]ZVciZgdbZY^VaXaVk^XaZ!i]ZhiZgcjb!VcYi]ZXVgi^aV\Zd[i]ZigjZg^Wh# I]^hbjhXaZVXihidÅZm!VYYjXi!VcYbZY^VaangdiViZi]ZVgb# ]# I]ZSbUcd_VdXU\UccUbdeRUbS\U[dgbhi]ZbZY^Vaa^ed[i]Z^ciZgijWZgXjaVg \gddkZ#>i^hi]Z^chZgi^dch^iZ[dgi]ZiZgZhbV_dgVcYaVi^hh^bjhYdgh^bjhXaZh!bZY^Va gdiVidghVcYVWYjXidghd[i]ZVgb# 

8]VeiZg&'6gb/=jbZgjh!GVY^jh!JacV

!2-

OLECRANON FOSSA

&IGUREBBYWXd Xe]Ubec`_cdUbY_b 9^hiVaZcY# CVijgVah^oZ#

MEDIAL EPICONDYLE

LATERAL EPICONDYLE

 ^# I]Z]jbZgVacXQVd^hkVg^VWanig^Vc\jaVg!gVc\^c\[gdbbdgZXna^cYg^XVa^c^ih egdm^bVahZXi^dcidVcVciZgdedhiZg^dganXdbegZhhZY!gdjcYZYig^Vc\aZY^hiVaan#  _# I]ZTU\d_YTdeRUb_cYdi^hdci]ZaViZgVahjg[VXZd[i]Zh]V[i#>i^hi]Z^chZgi^dch^iZ d[i]ZYZaid^YZjhbjhXaZ!VbV_dgVWYjXidgVbdc\di]Zg[jcXi^dchd[i]ZVgbi]Vi dg^\^cViZh[gdbi]ZVciZg^dgWdgYZgVcYhjeZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]ZXaVk^XaZ!i]ZaViZgVa bVg\^cVcYhjeZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]ZVXgdb^dc!VcYi]ZhXVejaVghe^cZ#I]ZYZaid^Y ijWZgdh^in^hgZXd\c^oZYWn^ihgdj\]ZcZYhjg[VXZ#>iiVeZghidVK"h]VeZdci]Z &'#&=jbZgjh

'%,

&IGUREABYWXd Xe]Ubec]UTYQ\ Egdm^bVaZcY# CVijgVah^oZ#

aViZgVa]jbZgjh# `# I]ZbQTYQ\ce\Secc`YbQ\Wb__fU^h[djcYdci]ZedhiZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]Zh]V[i#>i ^hVh]Vaadl!dWa^fjZ\gddkZ[dgi]ZgVY^VacZgkZVcYYZZekZhhZahi]VieVhheVgVaaZa VcY^bbZY^ViZanedhiZgd^c[Zg^dgidi]ZYZaid^YijWZgdh^in#>ih^c[Zg^dgWdjcYVgn^h Xdci^cjdjhY^hiVaanl^i]i]ZaViZgVaWdgYZgd[i]Zh]V[i#  a# I]Z^edbYU^dV_bQ]U^^hadXViZYVciZgdbZY^VaanVcYZm^ihi]Zh]V[i[gdbY^hiVa idegdm^bVa#6\ddYlVnidgZbZbWZgi]ZY^gZXi^dcd[Zcignd[cjig^Zci[dgVb^cV 

8]VeiZg&'6gb/=jbZgjh!GVY^jh!JacV

!2-

&IGUREBBYWXd Xe]Ubec]UTYQ\ 9^hiVaZcY# CVijgVah^oZ#

^cidVaad[i]Zadc\WdcZh^hid^bV\^cZi^\]ianÅZm^c\ndjgdlcVgbhVii]ZZa" WdlhVcYaZ\hVii]Z`cZZh^c[gdcid[ndj#>ci]^hedh^i^dcndjXVcadd`^cidi]Z WdcZhk^Vi]Z[dgVb^cV#>cadc\WdcZh!i]ZhZ[dgVb^cVXVggni]Zcjig^ZciVgiZg^Zh# b# I]Z_\USbQ^_^V_ccQ^hi]ZaVg\Zhid[i]gZZ]daadlhdci]ZY^hiVa]jbZgjh#>i^h edhiZg^dg!VXXdbbdYVi^c\i]ZdaZXgVcdcegdXZhhd[i]ZjacVYjg^c\[dgZVgbZm" iZch^dc#I]ZYZZeZhiVgZVd[i]^h[dhhVbVnWZeZg[dgViZY![dgb^c\V[dgVbZc!dg cU`dQ\Q`UbdebU# &'#&=jbZgjh

'%.

ANATOMICAL NECK

SURGICAL NECK

DELTOID TUBEROSITY

&IGUREABYWXd Xe]Ubec\QdUbQ\ Egdm^bVaZcY# CVijgVah^oZ#

c# I]ZS_b_^_YTV_ccQ^hi]ZaVg\Zg!bZY^VaaneaVXZY]daadldci]ZVciZg^dghjg[VXZ d[i]ZY^hiVa]jbZgjh#>igZXZ^kZhi]ZXdgdcd^YegdXZhhd[i]ZjacVYjg^c\bVm^" bjbÅZm^dcd[i]Z[dgZVgb# d# I]ZbQTYQ\V_ccQ^hi]ZhbVaaZg!aViZgVaaneaVXZY]daadldci]ZVciZg^dghjg[VXZd[ i]ZY^hiVa]jbZgjh#>igZXZ^kZhi]Z]ZVYd[i]ZgVY^jhYjg^c\bVm^bjbÅZm^dcd[ i]Z[dgZVgb# e# I]ZSQ`Yde\e]^hi]ZgdjcYZYZb^cZcXZi]Vi[dgbhi]ZaViZgVaedgi^dcd[i]Z 

8]VeiZg&'6gb/=jbZgjh!GVY^jh!JacV

RADIALSULCUS SPIRALGROOVE

!2-

&IGUREBBYWXd Xe]Ubec\QdUbQ\ 9^hiVaZcY# CVijgVah^oZ#

Y^hiVa]jbZgVahjg[VXZ#>iVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]Z]ZVYd[i]ZgVY^jh# f# I]Zdb_SX\UQ^hi]ZcdiX]"dghedda"h]VeZYbZY^Vaedgi^dcd[i]ZY^hiVa]jbZgVa hjg[VXZ#>iVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]ZjacV#  g# I]Z\QdUbQ\U`YS_^Ti\U^hi]ZhbVaa!cdcVgi^XjaVgaViZgVaWja\Zd[WdcZhjeZgdaVi" ZgVaidi]ZXVe^ijajb#>ihZgkZhVhVh^iZd[ViiVX]bZci[dgi]ZgVY^VaXdaaViZgVaa^\V" bZcid[i]ZZaWdlVcY[dgi]ZXdbbdciZcYdcd[dg^\^cd[i]Zhje^cVidgVcYi]Z ZmiZchdgbjhXaZh^ci]Z[dgZVgb# &'#&=jbZgjh

'&&

&IGUREBYWXdXe]Ubec`b_hY]Q\ 6ciZg^dg^hje!aViZgVa^hidlVgYi]Zg^\]i# CVijgVah^oZ#

&IGUREBYWXdXe]Ubec TYcdQ\6ciZg^dg^hje!aViZgVa^h idlVgYi]ZaZ[i#CVijgVah^oZ#

 h# I]Z]UTYQ\U`YS_^Ti\U^hi]ZcdcVgi^XjaVg!bZY^Vaegd_ZXi^dcd[WdcZhjeZgdbZ" Y^Vaidi]ZigdX]aZV#>i^hbdgZegdb^cZcii]Vci]ZaViZgVaZe^XdcYnaZ#>iegdk^YZh Vh^iZd[ViiVX]bZciidi]ZjacVgXdaaViZgVaa^\VbZci!idbVcnd[i]ZÊZmdgbjhXaZh^c i]Z[dgZVgb!VcYidi]ZegdcVidgiZgZhbjhXaZ#  i# I]Z]UTYQ\ce`bQS_^Ti\QbSbUcdbYTWU^hhjeZg^dgidi]ZbZY^VaZe^XdcYnaZ VcY[dgbhi]Zh]VgebZY^VaWdgYZgd[i]ZY^hiVa]jbZgjh# j# I]Z\QdUbQ\ce`bQS_^Ti\QbSbUcdbYTWU^hhjeZg^dgidi]ZaViZgVaZe^XdcYnaZVcY [dgbhi]Zh]VgeaViZgVaWdgYZgd[i]ZY^hiVa]jbZgjh#

'ROWTH&IGURE I]Z]jbZgjhdhh^ÄZh[gdbZ^\]iXZciZgh/i]Zh]V[i!i]Z]ZVY!VcYWdi]ijWZgXaZhVXdb" edh^iZd[hZkZgVaZVganXZciZgh^cXajY^c\i]Z]ZVY^ihZa[VcYZVX]ijWZgXaZ0V¹Xdc_d^ciº! i]ZXVe^ijajbVcYigdX]aZVi]ZXVe^ijajb[jhZhidi]ZigdX]aZVWZ[dgZZ^i]Zg[jhZhid i]Zh]V[i!VcYZVX]Ze^XdcYnaZ# 

8]VeiZg&'6gb/=jbZgjh!GVY^jh!JacV

!2-

&IGURE8e]UbQ\e\^QbQ^TbQTYQ\Wb_gdX I]ZeV^ghd[^bbVijgZ]jbZg^aZ[i!gVY^^XZciZg! VcYjacVZg^\]i!h]dlc]ZgZ^cVciZg^dgk^Zl!VgZ [gdbVdcZ"nZVg"daYVcYVh^m"nZVg"daY#CVijgVah^oZ#

&'#&=jbZgjh

'&(

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION I]Z]jbZgVa]ZVYXVccdiWZb^hiV`Zc[dgV[ZbdgVa]ZVYWZXVjhZi]Z[dgbZg^hdcan ]Va[d[Vhe]ZgZ!l]ZgZVhi]ZaViiZg^hhjWhiVci^VaanbdgZi]Vc]Va[#  ™ I]Z[ZbdgVa]ZVY]VhVY^hi^cXiYZegZhh^dc!dgV_fUQSQ`YdYc!l]^X]i]Z]jbZgjh aVX`h#  ™ I]Z]jbZgVah]V[i^haVg\ZgVcYbdgZX^gXjaVg^chZXi^dci]Vci]ZgVY^Va!jacVg!dg ÄWjaVgh]V[ih#  ™ I]Z]jbZgVah]V[i^hhbVaaZgVcYbdgZ^ggZ\jaVg^chZXi^dci]Vci]Z[ZbdgVa h]V[i#  ™ I]Z]jbZgVah]V[i^hhbVaaZgVcYaZhhig^Vc\jaVgi]Vci]Zi^W^Vah]V[i#

3IDING  ™ ;dgVc^ciVXiWdcZ!i]Z]ZVY[VXZhbZY^Vaan!i]ZXVe^ijajb^haViZgVa!VcYi]ZdaZX" gVcdc[dhhV^hedhiZg^dg#  ™ ;dgVc^hdaViZYegdm^bVaZcY!i]Z]ZVY^hbZY^Va!VcYi]ZaZhhZgijWZgXaZVcY^ciZg" ijWZgXjaVg\gddkZVgZVciZg^dg#  ™ ;dgVc^hdaViZYY^hiVaZcY!i]ZdaZXgVcdc[dhhV^hedhiZg^dg!i]ZbZY^VaZe^XdcYnaZ ^haVg\Zg!VcYi]ZXVe^ijajb^haViZgVaVcYdg^ZciZYVciZg^dgan#>[i]ZVgi^XjaVgZcY ^hb^hh^c\!i]ZXdgdcd^Y[dhhV^haVg\ZgVcYbdgZbZY^Vai]Vci]ZgVY^Va[dhhV#  ™ ;dgVc^hdaViZYh]V[i[gV\bZci!i]ZYZaid^YijWZgdh^in^haViZgVa!l^i]^ihedhiZg^dg VgbeVhh^c\[gdbedhiZgdhjeZg^dgidVciZgd^c[Zg^dg!VcYi]Zcjig^Zci[dgVbZc Zm^ihi]ZWdcZidlVgY^ihegdm^bVaZcY#6hbVaa!i]^cg^Y\ZgjchVadc\i]ZZci^gZ bZY^VaZY\Zd[i]Zh]V[i!VcYi]Zcjig^Zci[dgVbZc^h[djcYdci]^hZY\Z#I]ZaVi" ZgVaa^ed[i]Z^ciZgijWZgXjaVg\gddkZ^hhigdc\ZgVcYadc\Zg#

2ADIUS&IGURESn !NATOMY I]ZgVY^jh^hi]Zh]dgiZhid[i]Zi]gZZVgbWdcZh#>i^hcVbZY[dg^ihVXi^dc!Vijgc^c\ bdkZbZciVWdjii]ZXVe^ijajbd[i]Z]jbZgjh!l]^X]Vaadlhi]ZWdcZidgdiViZgZaV" i^kZidi]ZbdgZÄmZYjacV#I]ZgVY^jhVgi^XjaViZhegdm^bVaanl^i]i]Z]jbZgjhVii]Z XVe^ijajbVcYbZY^Vaanl^i]i]ZjacVdcWdi]egdm^bVaVcYY^hiVaZcYh#9^hiVaan!i]Z gVY^jhVgi^XjaViZhl^i]ildXVgeVaWdcZhd[i]Zlg^hi# V# I]ZXUQT^hVgdjcYVgi^XjaVghigjXijgZdci]Zegdm^bVaZcYd[i]ZgVY^jh#>iVgi^X" jaViZh!k^V^ihXjeeZYegdm^bVahjg[VXZVgi^XjaVg[dkZV!l^i]i]Z]jbZgVaXVe^ij" ajb!l]ZgZVhi]ZZY\Zd[i]ZgVY^Va]ZVYX^gXjb[ZgZci^VaVgi^XjaVi^dcVgi^XjaViZh l^i]i]ZgVY^VacdiX]d[i]ZjacV# W# I]Z^US[^hi]ZhaZcYZghZ\bZcid[i]ZgVY^jhWZilZZci]Z]ZVYVcYi]ZgVY^Va ijWZgdh^in# X# I]ZbQTYQ\deRUb_cYdiRYSY`YdQ\deRUb_cYdi^hVWajci!gj\dhZ!kVg^VWanh]VeZY 

8]VeiZg&'6gb/=jbZgjh!GVY^jh!JacV

higjXijgZdci]ZVciZgdbZY^Vah^YZd[i]Zegdm^bVagVY^jh#>ibVg`hi]Z^chZgi^dc d[i]ZW^XZehWgVX]^^bjhXaZ!VÅZmdgVcYlZV`bZY^VagdiVidgd[i]Z[dgZVgb!VcYV aVg\ZW^XZehWjghVi]VijcYZga^Zhi]^hbjhXaZ# Y# I]ZcXQVdd[i]ZgVY^jh^hi]Zadc\!i]^chZXi^dcWZilZZci]ZgVY^VaijWZgdh^inVcY i]ZZmeVcYZYY^hiVaZcY#  Z# I]Z^edbYU^dV_bQ]U^Zm^ihi]ZWdcZidlVgY^ihY^hiVaZcYVcY^hadXViZYdci]Z VciZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]Zegdm^bVa]Va[d[i]ZgVY^jh#  [# I]ZY^dUb_ccU_ecSbUcd^hi]Zh]VgebZY^VaZY\Zd[i]ZgVY^Vah]V[i#>ihZgkZhVh i]ZViiVX]bZcih^iZ[dgVÄWgdjhbZbWgVcZ!i]Z^ciZgdhhZdjhbZbWgVcZ!l]^X]Y^" k^YZhi]Z[dgZVgb^cidildXdbeVgibZcih!VciZg^dgVcYedhiZg^dg#I]ZhZ]djhZi]Z ÅZmdgVcYZmiZchdg\gdjehd[bjhXaZhi]ViVXiVXgdhhi]Zlg^hi# \# I]Z_R\YaeU\Y^U^hdci]ZVciZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]Zh]V[i#>ihe^gVah^c[ZgdaViZgVaan [gdb^ihdg^\^cVii]ZWVhZd[i]ZgVY^VaijWZgdh^in#I]^ha^cZ\^kZhdg^\^cidZmig^c" h^XbjhXaZhd[i]Z]VcY# ]# I]Z`b_^Qd_bdUbUcY^cUbdY_^^hVb^Yh]V[igdj\]Zc^c\dci]ZaViZgVahjg[VXZ#  ^# I]Ze\^Qb^_dSX^hVXdcXVkZVgi^XjaVg]daadldci]ZbZY^VaXdgcZgd[i]ZY^hiVa gVY^jh#>iVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]ZY^hiVaZcYd[i]ZjacV#  _# I]ZTYcdQ\bQTYQ\QbdYSe\QbcebVQSUVgi^XjaViZhl^i]XVgeVaWdcZh¸i]ZajcViZ dci]ZbZY^Vah^YZ!VcYi]ZhXVe]d^Ydci]ZaViZgVah^YZ# `# I]Zcdi\_YT`b_SUcc^hVh]Vgeegd_ZXi^dcdci]ZaViZgVah^YZd[i]ZY^hiVagVY^jh#  a# I]ZT_bcQ\deRUbS\U
!2-

'ROWTH&IGURE I]ZgVY^jhdhh^ÄZh[gdbi]gZZXZciZgh/i]Zh]V[i!i]Z]ZVY!VcYi]ZY^hiVaZcY#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION GVY^Vah]V[ihZ\bZcihb^\]iWZb^hiV`Zc[dgi]ZjacVdgÄWjaV!VcYY^hiVaZcYhb^\]i WZ b^hiV`Zc [dg i]Z XaVk^XjaVg cdiX] d[ i]Z bVcjWg^jb! Wji i]Z [daadl^c\ [ZVijgZh ]Zae^YZci^[n[gV\bZcihd[i]ZgVY^jh#  ™ I]ZjacVgh]V[iiVeZghXdci^cjdjhani]ZX^gXjb[ZgZcXZYZXgZVhZh[gdbegdm^bVa idY^hiVa!l]ZgZVhi]ZgVY^jhYdZhcdi#  ™ I]ZjacVgh]V[i]VhVh]Vge^ciZgdhhZdjhXgZhi!Wjii]Zilddi]ZgXdgcZghVgZcdiVh ZkZcangdjcYZYVhi]ZnVgZ^ci]ZgVY^jh!l]^X]]VhViZVgYgdeh]VeZ^cXgdhhhZX" i^dcVcYVhbddi]Zg!bdgZjc^[dgbXgZhi#  ™ Bdhid[i]ZjacVgh]V[i^hig^Vc\jaVg#I]ZjacVgh]V[idcanWZXdbZhgdjcY^cXgdhh hZXi^dcVi^ihY^hiVaZcY#>cXdcigVhi!i]ZgVY^Vah]V[i^hX^gXjaVgegdm^bVaanVcY^h VgdjcYZYig^Vc\aZVib^Yh]V[i#>i^hVWgdVY!VciZgdedhiZg^dganXdbegZhhZYdkVa l^i]XdgiZmi]Vii]^chVibdgZY^hiVaXgdhhhZXi^dch#  ™ I]ZÄWjaV!VahdVadc\haZcYZgWdcZl^i]XgZhih!^hbjX]bdgZ^ggZ\jaVg^cXgdhh &'#'GVY^jh

'&*

HEAD

NECK

OBLIQUE LINE

&IGUREBYWXdbQTYecQ^dUbY_bAZ[i!egdm^bVaZcY0g^\]i!Y^hiVaZcY#CVijgVah^oZ#

hZXi^dcVcYbjX]adc\Zgi]Vci]ZgVY^jh#  ™ I]ZY^hiVagVY^VaVgi^XjaVi^dc]VhildY^hXZgcVWaZVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZhºdg¹[VXZih!º hZZ;^\jgZ&'#&'!l]ZgZVhi]ZXaVk^XjaVgcdiX]d[i]ZbVcjWg^jb^hh^c\jaVg#

3IDING  ™ ;dgVc^ciVXigVY^jh!i]ZjacVgcdiX]^hbZY^Va!i]ZgVY^VaijWZgdh^inVcY^ciZgdh" hZdjhXgZhiVgZbZY^Va!i]ZYdghVaijWZgXaZhVgZedhiZg^dg!VcYi]Zhinad^YegdXZhh^h aViZgVa#  ™ ;dgVc^hdaViZYegdm^bVaZcY!i]ZijWZgdh^in[VXZhVciZgdbZY^Vaan#I]ZbZY^Va 

8]VeiZg&'6gb/=jbZgjh!GVY^jh!JacV

DORSAL TUBERCLE STYLOID PROCESS

&IGUREBYWXdbQTYec`_cdUbY_bAZ[i!egdm^bVaZcY0g^\]i!Y^hiVaZcY#CVijgVah^oZ#

edgi^dcd[i]Zegdm^bVajacVgVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ]Vhi]Z\gZViZhiegdm^bdY^hiVa Y^bZch^dc#  ™ I]ZgZ^hVhbVaag^Y\Zdci]ZedhiZgdbZY^VaVheZXid[i]ZcZX`!Xdc\gjZcil^i]i]Z hjeZg^dgVheZXid[i]ZbZY^VaZY\Zd[i]ZgVY^VaijWZgdh^in#  ™ ;dgVc^hdaViZYhZ\bZcid[h]V[i!i]Z^ciZgdhhZdjhXgZhi^hbZY^Va!VcYi]ZdWa^fjZ a^cZ^hVciZg^dg#I]Zcjig^Zci[dgVbZcZm^ihi]ZWdcZY^hiVaanVcY^hh^ijViZYVc" iZg^dgandci]Zh]V[i#I]ZedhiZgdaViZgVahjg[VXZ]Vhi]Z\gZViZhigj\dh^inViVWdji b^Yh]V[i#  ™ ;dgVc^hdaViZYY^hiVaZcY!i]ZVciZg^dghjg[VXZ^hhbddi]VcYÅVi!i]ZedhiZg^dg hjg[VXZ]VhZmiZchdg\gddkZh!i]ZjacVgcdiX]^hbZY^Va!VcYi]Zhinad^YegdXZhh^h aViZgVa#I]Zhinad^YegdXZhh^hhbddi]dc^ihVciZg^dghjg[VXZ# &'#'GVY^jh

'&,

!2-

PRONATOR TERES INSERTION

RADIAL TUBEROSITY BICIPITAL TUBEROSITY

NUTRIENT FORAMEN

INTEROSSEOUS CREST ULNAR NOTCH DISTALRADIAL ARTICULAR SURFACE &IGUREBYWXdbQTYec]UTYQ\AZ[i!egdm^bVaZcY0g^\]i!Y^hiVaZcY#CVijgVah^oZ#

&IGUREBYWXdbQTYec`b_hY]Q\AViZg" &IGUREBYWXdbQTYecTYcdQ\9dghVa^h Va^hje!VciZg^dg^hidlVgYi]ZaZ[i#CVijgVah^oZ# je!aViZgVa^hidlVgYi]Zg^\]i#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&'6gb/=jbZgjh!GVY^jh!JacV

5LNA&IGURESn !NATOMY I]ZjacV^hi]Zadc\Zhi!i]^ccZhiWdcZd[i]Z[dgZVgb#>iVgi^XjaViZhegdm^bVaanl^i] i]ZigdX]aZVd[i]Z]jbZgjhVcY]ZVYd[i]ZgVY^jh#9^hiVaan^iVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]Z jacVgcdiX]d[i]ZgVY^jhVcYl^i]VcVgi^XjaVgY^h`i]VihZeVgViZh^i[gdbi]ZXVgeVa WdcZhVcYegdk^YZh[gZZggdiVi^dcd[i]Z]VcYVcYgVY^jhVgdjcYi]ZjacVi]Vc^hhZZc ^cbVcndi]ZgbVbbVah#

&'#(JacV

'&.

!2-

V# I]Z_\USbQ^_^_\USbQ^_^`b_SUccd[i]ZjacV^hi]Zbdhiegdm^bVaeVgid[i]Z WdcZ#>i^hVbVhh^kZ!WajciegdXZhh#I]Zig^XZehWgVX]^^bjhXaZ!i]Zeg^bVgnZmiZchdg d[i]Z[dgZVgb!^chZgihdci]ZijWZgdh^ind[i]ZegdXZhh# W# I]Zdb_SX\UQb^_dSXcU]Y\e^Qb^_dSXd[i]ZjacVVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]ZigdX]" aZVgVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZd[i]ZY^hiVa]jbZgjh#>cXdcigVhiidi]ZbdgZbdW^aZgVY^jh! gdiVgnbdi^dc^hkZgngZhig^XiZYVii]ZjacVgeVgid[i]ZZaWdl_d^ci!h]Vgeana^b^i" ^c\i]ZjacV^c^ihVW^a^inidgdiViZVgdjcY^ihadc\Vm^h# X# I]ZkZgi^XVaWeYTY^WbYTWUhZeVgViZhi]ZigdX]aZVgcdiX]^cidbZY^VaVcYaViZgVa edgi^dch# Y# I]ZS_b_^_YT`b_SUcc^hi]ZVciZg^dg!WZV`"h]VeZYegd_ZXi^dcVii]ZWVhZd[i]Z hZb^ajcVgcdiX]#  Z# >bbZY^ViZan^c[Zg^dgidi]ZXdgdcd^YegdXZhh^hVgdj\]ZcZYYZegZhh^dcXVaaZYi]Z e\^QbRbQSXYQ\deRUb_cYdi[dgi]Z^chZgi^dcd[i]ZWgVX]^Va^hbjhXaZ!VÅZmdgd[ i]ZZaWdli]Vidg^\^cViZh[gdbi]ZVciZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]Z]jbZgjh#  [# I]ZbQTYQ\^_dSX^hi]ZhbVaaVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ[dgi]ZgVY^jh#>i^hadXViZYVadc\ i]ZaViZgVabVg\^cd[i]ZXdgdcd^YegdXZhh# \# I]ZcXQVd^hi]Zadc\hZ\bZcid[WdcZWZilZZci]ZWgVX]^VaijWZgdh^inVcYi]Z ^cÅViZYY^hiVaZcYd[i]ZjacV# ]# I]Z^edbYU^dV_bQ]U^Zm^ihi]ZWdcZ^cVY^hiVaY^gZXi^dcVcY^h[djcYdci]Z VciZgdbZY^VajacVgh]V[i#  ^# I]ZY^dUb_ccU_ecSbUcda^Zhdeedh^iZi]ZgVY^jh!dci]ZaViZgVahjg[VXZd[i]ZjacVg h]V[i#  _# I]Z`b_^Qd_bbYTWU^hVh]dgi!kVg^VWanZmegZhhZYg^Y\Zdci]ZY^hiVafjVgiZgd[ i]Zh]V[i#>i^hadXViZYVciZgdbZY^VaanVcY^hi]Zdg^\^c[dgi]ZegdcVidgfjVYgVijh bjhXaZ# `# I]Zcdi\_YT`b_SUcc^hi]Zh]Vge!Y^hiVa"bdhiegd_ZXi^dcd[i]ZjacV#>i^hhZidc i]ZedhiZgdbZY^VaXdgcZgd[i]ZWdcZ#>ihZcY\^kZhViiVX]bZciidi]ZjacVgXdaaVi" ZgVaa^\VbZcid[i]Zlg^hi#>i^hhZeVgViZY[gdbi]ZgZbV^cYZgd[i]Z]ZVYWnVYZZe \gddkZdge^i!i]Z[dkZV#  a# I]ZUhdU^c_bSQb`Ye\^QbYcWb__fU^hVY_VXZciidi]Zhinad^YegdXZhh!adXViZY egdm^bdaViZgVaanid^i#>i]djhZhi]ZiZcYdcd[i]ZZmiZchdgXVge^jacVg^hbjhXaZ!VYdg" h^ÅZmdgVcYVYYjXidgd[i]Z]VcYVii]Zlg^hi# b# I]ZbQTYQ\SYbSe]VUbU^dYQ\QbdYSe\QdY_^^hi]ZY^hiVa!aViZgVa!gdjcYVgi^XjaV" i^dci]ViXdc[dgbhidi]ZjacVgcdiX]d[i]ZgVY^jh^ci]ZhVbZlVni]Vii]ZgV" Y^Va]ZVYXdc[dgbhidi]ZgVY^VacdiX]d[i]Zegdm^bVajacV#

INTEROSSEOUS CREST

GUIDING RIDGE

ULNAR BRACHIAL TUBEROSITY

NUTRIENT FORAMEN TWO

RADIAL CIRCUMFERENTIAL ARTICULATION &IGUREBYWXde\^QQ^dUbY_b#AZ[i!egdm^bVaZcY0g^\]i!Y^hiVaZcY#CVijgVah^oZ#

'ROWTH&IGURE I]ZjacVdhh^ÄZh[gdbi]gZZXZciZgh/i]Zh]V[i!i]ZdaZXgVcdcegdXZhh!VcYi]ZY^hiVaZcY#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION I]ZjacVgegdm^bVaVcYY^hiVaZcYhVgZY^V\cdhi^X!Wji^hdaViZYh]V[ihXdjaYWZb^h" 

8]VeiZg&'6gb/=jbZgjh!GVY^jh!JacV

!2-

STYLOIDPROCESS &IGUREBYWXde\^Q`_cdUbY_bAZ[i!egdm^bVaZcY0g^\]i!Y^hiVaZcY#CVijgVah^oZ#

iV`Zc[dggVY^VadgÄWjaVgh]V[ih#  ™ I]ZgVY^Vah]V[i^hbdgZig^Vc\jaVg!dgiZVgYgde"h]VeZY!^cXgdhhhZXi^dcl^i]ild gdjcYZYXdgcZghVcYdcZh]VgeXdgcZg#GVY^Vah]V[ihYdcdiiVeZgY^hiVaanVhi]Z aZhhgZ\jaVgjacVgh]V[iYdZh#  ™ I]ZÄWjaVgh]V[i^hbjX]bdgZ^ggZ\jaVg^cXgdhhhZXi^dc!l^i]bjai^eaZh]Vge XdgcZgh#  ™ HZZi]ZYZhXg^ei^dcd[i]ZgVY^jhh]V[i[dg[jgi]ZgYZiV^ah# &'#(JacV

''&

OLECRANON OLECRANON PROCESS CORONOID PROCESS

TROCHLEAR NOTCH SEMILUNAR NOTCH

PRONATOR RIDGE

&IGUREBYWXde\^Q]UTYQ\AZ[i!egdm^bVaZcY0g^\]i!Y^hiVaZcY#CVijgVah^oZ#

3IDING  ™ ;dgVc^ciVXijacV!i]ZdaZXgVcdcegdXZhh^hegdm^bVaVcYedhiZg^dg!i]ZgVY^Va cdiX]^haViZgVa!VcYi]Z^ciZgdhhZdjhXgZhi^haViZgVa#  ™ ;dgVc^hdaViZYegdm^bVaZcY!jhZi]ZhVbZXg^iZg^V\^kZcZVga^Zg[dgVc^ciVXijacV# CdiZVahdi]Vii]ZWgVX]^VaijWZgdh^in^hbZY^VaanY^heaVXZY#  ™ ;dgVc^hdaViZYh]V[ihZ\bZci!i]Zh]V[iiVeZghY^hiVaan!VcYi]Zcjig^Zci[dgVbZc Zm^ihi]ZWdcZY^hiVaanVcY^hadXViZYdci]ZVciZg^dgh]V[ihjg[VXZ#I]Z^ciZgdhhZ" 

8]VeiZg&'6gb/=jbZgjh!GVY^jh!JacV

RADIAL NOTCH

!2-

EXTENSOR CARPI ULNARIS GROOVE

&IGUREBYWXde\^Q\QdUbQ\AZ[i!egdm^bVaZcY0g^\]i!Y^hiVaZcY#CVijgVah^oZ#

&IGUREBYWXde\^Q`b_hY]Q\AViZgVa ^hje!VciZg^dg^hidlVgYi]ZaZ[i#CVijgVah^oZ#

&IGUREBYWXde\^QTYcdQ\#6ciZg^dg^h Ydlc!aViZgVa^hidlVgYi]Zg^\]i#CVijgVah^oZ#

&'#(JacV

''(

djhXgZhi^haViZgVa#I]Zh]V[ihjg[VXZVciZg^dgidi]ZXgZhi^hbdgZ]daadlZYegdm^" bVaanWjii]^hbVnÅViiZcY^hiVaan#6ib^Yh]V[iVcYY^hiVaan!i]Zhjg[VXZedhiZg^dg idi]Z^ciZgdhhZdjhXgZhibVnY^heaVnVcVggdl\gddkZi]Vi^hkVg^VWaZ^cZmegZh" h^dc#  ™ ;dgVc^hdaViZYY^hiVaZcY!i]Zhinad^YegdXZhh^hedhiZg^dg!VcYi]Z\gddkZ[dgi]Z ZmiZchdgXVge^jacVg^h^haViZgVaidi]ZegdXZhh#



8]VeiZg&'6gb/=jbZgjh!GVY^jh!JacV

#HAPTER

=VcY/8VgeVah! BZiVXVgeVah! E]VaVc\Zh I

]Z ]VcY ^h V XdbeaZm higjXijgZ i]Vi gZegZhZcih i]Z iZigVedY¼h Y^hiVa a^bW hZ\" bZci#>i^hi]ZbdY^ÄZYZcYd[i]ZVcXZhigVaÄh]Äc!VhigjXijgZWVhZYdc_d^ciZY WdcngVnh#>ci]Z\ZcZgVa^oZYgZei^a^Vc]VcY!VhZid[hbVaalg^hiWdcZhXVgeVah[dgbh i]Z[djcYVi^dc[dgÄkZY^\^ih#:VX]Y^\^i^hXdbedhZYd[dcZaVg\Zegdm^bVahZ\bZci VbZiVXVgeVaVcYVX]V^cd[VYY^i^dcVaWdcZhi]Ze]VaVc\Zh#9^\^iVagZYjXi^dcVcY bdY^ÄXVi^dc]VkZdXXjggZY^cV\gZVikVg^Zind[bVbbVah![gdbi]Zl^c\hd[WVihid i]Zh^c\aZidZhd[bdYZgc]dghZh#=jbVch]VkZgZiV^cZYi]Z\ZcZgVa^oZYeViiZgcd[ÄkZ Y^\^ih#I]ZgZVgZVidiVad[ilZcin"hZkZcWdcZh^cZVX]]jbVc]VcY!Z^\]iXVgeVaWdcZh VggVc\ZY^cildgdlh![daadlZYY^hiVaanWnVh^c\aZgdld[ÄkZbZiVXVgeVah#;Vgi]ZgY^h" iVaan!i]ZgZ^hVh^c\aZgdld[ÄkZegdm^bVae]VaVc\Zh!Vh^c\aZgdld[[djg^ciZgbZY^ViZ e]VaVc\Zh!VcYVh^c\aZgdld[ÄkZY^hiVa!dgiZgb^cVa!e]VaVc\Zh# >cVYY^i^dcidi]ZilZcin"hZkZcbV_dg]VcYWdcZh!i]ZgZVgZhbVaaWdcZhXVaaZY cUcQ]_YT R_^Uc i]Vi a^Z l^i]^c iZcYdch d[ i]Z ]VcY# I]ZhZ VgZ cdi jhjVaan gZXdk" ZgZYVcYVgZgVgZanhijY^ZYWndhiZdad\^hih!l]dh]djaYcZkZgi]ZaZhhValVnhWZVaZgiid

)$ (/

!,

ARTICULATION SOMETIMESARTICULATES

$



20 !,  20 !,  4! #!

-%

-%

4! #!

4! #!

20 !,



20 !,



20 !, -%

4! #!

-%

-! 4%

4! #!

-%

(!

#!

0)4 !4 %

%: /)

!0 42

42

!0

%:

)5

-

2&/

0)3 )

42

)1

5%

42

!4 %

3#

,5 .

!0

.! 5,

2!

$)

53

(!.$

2!$)53 5,.! 3#!0(/)$ ,5.!4% 42)15%42!, 0)3)&/242!0%:)542!0%:/)$ #!0)4!4% (!-!4% -%4!#!20!, -%4!#!20!, -%4!#!20!, -%4!#!20!, -%4!#!20!,

&IGURE6gi^XjaVi^dcd[WdcZh^ci]ZVYjai]jbVclg^hiVcY]VcY#

''*

-ETACARPAL -ETACARPAL -ETACARPAL -ETACARPAL -ETACARPAL

(AMATE #APITATE 0ISIFORM ,UNATE

4RAPEZOID 4RAPEZIUM 4RIQUETRAL 3CAPHOID

&IGUREBYWXdXQ^T`Q\]QbVciZg^dg#HbVaahZhVbd^YWdcZhcdi^cXajYZY#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&(=VcY/8VgeVah!BZiVXVgeVah!E]VaVc\Zh

(!.$

&IGUREBYWXdXQ^TT_bcQ\edhiZg^dg#HbVaahZhVbd^YWdcZhcdi^cXajYZY#CVijgVah^oZ#

&(=VcY

'',

i]Z^gegZhZcXZVhi]ZnVgZd[Xdch^YZgVWaZ[jcXi^dcVah^\c^ÄXVcXZ#>ci]Z]VcY!VeV^gd[ hZhVbd^Yh^hjhjVaan[djcYdci]ZeVabVgVheZXid[i]ZÄghibZiVXVgeVa]ZVY#;^\jgZh &(#&·&(#(hjbbVg^oZVcY^aajhigViZVgi^XjaVi^dchl^i]^ci]Z]VcY# :aZbZcihd[i]Z]VcYh`ZaZidcVgZYZhXg^WZY^ci]gZZXViZ\dg^Zh/i]ZSQb`Q\c!i]Z ]UdQSQb`Q\c! VcY i]Z XQ^T `XQ\Q^WUc# >c i]Z XVgeVa gZ\^dc d[ i]Z ]VcY! Vh ^c i]Z iVghVagZ\^dcd[i]Z[ddi!VkVg^Zind[Y^[[ZgZcicVbZh]VkZWZZcVeea^ZYidZVX]WdcZ VhVcVidb^XVacdbZcXaVijgZ]VhZkdakZYi]gdj\]i]ZnZVgh#;dggZVYZghXjg^djhVWdji i]^h]^hidgn!D¼GV]^aan&.-.egdk^YZhV\ddYhjbbVgn# 7Z[dgZVcVano^c\i]ZkVg^djhZaZbZcihi]VibV`Zjei]Z]VcY!^i^hjhZ[jaidcdiZ i]Z^bedgiVcXZd[VcVidb^XVacdbZcXaVijgZ^ci]ZhijYnd[i]Z]VcY#>cYZVa^c\l^i] ZaZbZcihd[i]Z]VcY!^i^hZVhnidWZXdbZXdc[jhZYWni]ZiZgbh¹VciZg^dg!º¹edhiZg^dg!º ¹bZY^Va!ºVcY¹aViZgVaºWZXVjhZi]ZhZiZgbhXVcdcanWZVeea^ZYl]Zci]ZheZX^bZc ^h^cegdeZgVcVidb^XVaedh^i^dc#;dgi]^hgZVhdc!^i^hjhZ[jaidhjeeaZbZcii]ZY^gZX" i^dcVaiZgbhl]Zcedhh^WaZ!jh^c\i]Z[daadl^c\hZihd[hncdcnbh/  ™  ™  ™  ™

VciZg^dg2eVabVg edhiZg^dg2YdghVa bZY^Va2jacVg2a^iiaZÄc\Zgh^YZ aViZgVa2gVY^Va2i]jbWh^YZ

I]ZiZgbbQi^hd[iZcVeea^ZYidZVX]Äc\Zg!dgidZ!^cXajY^c\i]Ze]VaVc\ZhVcY bZiVXVgeVad[i]ZY^\^i#7nXdckZci^dc!i]Zi]jbWgVn!dg`_\\Uh!^h^YZci^ÄZYVhgVn cjbWZg&#I]Z^cYZmÄc\Zg^hgVn'!i]Zb^YYaZÄc\Zg^hgVn(!i]Zg^c\Äc\Zg^hgVn)! VcYi]Za^iiaZÄc\Zg^hgVn*# ;dg]VcYVcY[ddiZaZbZcih!^i^hd[iZcZVh^ZhiidjhZbZbdgn"WVhZY!dgedh^i^dcVa! ¹iddahº^cdgYZgidh^YZi]ZWdcZfj^X`an#I]ZiZmiegdk^YZhVhZid[i]ZhZiddahWjiVahd Zbeadnh hiVcYVgY VcVidb^XVa iZX]c^fjZh id h^YZ ZVX] WdcZ# BVcn d[ i]Z edh^i^dcVa iZX]c^fjZhYZiV^aZY]ZgZVgZVYdeiZY[gdb7Vhh&..*#

#ARPALS&IGURESn I]Z Z^\]i WdcZh d[ i]Z VYjai lg^hi VgZ d[iZc YZhXg^WZY Vh XjW^XVa ^c h]VeZ l^i] h^m hjg[VXZh!Wjii]^h^hVb^haZVY^c\X]VgVXiZg^oVi^dc#:VX]WdcZ]VhVjc^fjZ!Y^V\cdhi^X h]VeZ#;dgi]^hgZVhdc!^YZci^ÄXVi^dc^hhigV^\]i[dglVgY#6c^cigdYjXi^dcidi]Z[jcX" i^dcVaVcVidbnd[i]Zlg^hi[VX^a^iViZhhijYnd[i]Z^cY^k^YjValg^hiZaZbZcih#I]ZeVa" bVghjg[VXZd[i]ZXVgejh!dglg^hi!WZVgh[djgbV_dgegd_ZXi^dch#I]Z]dd`d[i]Z]V" bViZVcYi]Ze^h^[dgbjcYZga^Zi]ZbZY^VaZY\Zd[i]ZeVabVii]ZWVhZd[bZiVXVgeVa *B8*#I]ZhXVe]d^YijWZgXaZVcYXgZhid[i]ZigVeZo^jbjcYZga^Zi]ZaViZgVaZY\Z d[i]ZeVab!Vii]ZWVhZd[i]Zi]jbWbZiVXVgeVaB8&#>ca^[Zi]ZgZ^hVÄWgdjhWVcY higZiX]ZYigVchkZghZanWZilZZci]ZhZXVgeVaZaZkVi^dch#I]^hWVcY!i]ZÊZmdggZi^cVXj" ajb!XgZViZhVSQb`Q\de^^U\i]gdj\]l]^X]ÊZmdgiZcYdchd[i]Zlg^hieVhh# I]ZXVgeVahVgZY^k^YZY^cidVegdm^bVagdl^cXdgedgVi^c\[gdbgVY^VaidjacVg i]ZcSQ`X_YT!i]Z\e^QdU!i]ZdbYaeUdbQ\!VcYi]Z`YcYV_b]#I]ZhXVe]d^YVcYajcViZ Wdi]Vgi^XjaViZl^i]i]ZgVY^jh#I]ZY^hiVagdld[XVgeVah!V\V^c[gdbgVY^VaidjacVg!^h XdbedhZYd[i]ZdbQ`UjYe]WbUQdUb]e\dQ^We\Qb!i]ZdbQ`Uj_YT\UccUb]e\dQ^We \Qb!i]ZSQ`YdQdU!VcYi]ZXQ]QdU# 

8]VeiZg&(=VcY/8VgeVah!BZiVXVgeVah!E]VaVc\Zh

3CAPHOID&IGURE I]ZhXVe]d^YWdcZVahd`cdlcVhi]Z]VcYcVk^XjaVg^hh]VeZYa^`ZVWdVi!l^i]V bV_dg XdcXVkZ hjg[VXZ [dg i]Z ]ZVY d[ i]Z XVe^iViZ VcY V bV_dg XdckZm hjg[VXZ i]Vi Vgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]ZY^hiVagVY^jh#DcZd[i]ZaVg\ZhiXVgeVaWdcZh!^i^hi]ZbdhiaViZgVa VcYegdm^bVaXVgeVa!^ciZgedhZYWZilZZci]ZgVY^jhVcYi]ZigVeZo^jb!Vii]ZWVhZd[ i]Zi]jbW#I]ZdeRUbS\U^hVWajci!cdcVgi^XjaVgegd_ZXi^dcVY_VXZciidi]Z]daadlZY XVe^iViZ[VXZi#>i^hdcZd[[djgViiVX]bZcih[dgi]Z ÊZmdggZi^cVXjajb!VÄWgdjhWVcY VXgdhhi]Zlg^hi#  ™ 1^Qd_]YSQ\cYTY^W#I]ZXdcXVkZVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ]djhZhi]ZXVe^iViZ]ZVYVcY ^hi]ZgZ[dgZY^hiVa#I]ZijWZgXaZ^hdci]ZeVabVghjg[VXZVcY^haViZgVaidlVgYi]Z i]jbW#  ™ @_cYdY_^Q\cYTY^W#=daYi]ZXdcXVkZXVe^iViZ[VXZiidlVgYndjVcYi]ZijWZgXaZ je#I]ZijWZgXaZaZVchidlVgYi]Zh^YZ[gdbl]^X]i]ZWdcZXdbZh#

TUBERCLE

&IGUREBYWXdcSQ`X_YTEVabVg^hje#K^Zl[gdbi]ZXVe^iViZaZ[i0k^Zl[gdbi]ZgVY^jh g^\]i#CVijgVah^oZ#

,UNATE&IGURESn

 ™ 1^Qd_]YSQ\cYTY^W#I]ZgVY^Va[VXZi^hegdm^bVa!VcYi]ZXVe^iViZ[VXZi^hY^hiVa# I]Zadc\!cVggdl!XgZhXZci"h]VeZY[VXZidci]ZÅVihjg[VXZd[i]ZWdcZVgi^XjaViZh

&IGUREBYWXd\e^QdU 9dghVa^hje#K^Zl[gdbi]Z XVe^iViZ#CVijgVah^oZ#

&IGUREBYWXd\e^QdUEVabVg^hje#K^Zl [gdbi]ZhXVe]d^YaZ[i0k^Zl[gdbi]Zig^fjZigVa g^\]i#CVijgVah^oZ#

&(#&8VgeVah

''.

(!.$

I]ZajcViZ^hh]VeZY^ci]Z[dgbd[VXgZhXZcibddc#I]ZYZZeanXdcXVkZhjg[VXZVgi^Xj" aViZhl^i]i]ZXVe^iViZ!VcYi]ZaVg\Z!WgdVYVgi^XjaVi^dcdeedh^iZi]^hh]VgZhi]ZY^hiVa gVY^VaVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZl^i]i]ZhXVe]d^Y#

aViZgVaandci]Zi]jbWh^YZl^i]i]ZhXVe]d^Y#I]ZgZbV^c^c\[VXZi![dgi]Zig^" fjZigVa!^hY^heaVXZYYdghVaan#I]ZaVg\ZhicdcVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ^heVabVg#  ™ @_cYdY_^Q\cYTY^W#EaVXZi]ZÅVih^YZdci]ZiVWaZVcYi]ZbdhiXdcXVkZ[VXZiid" lVgYndj#I]ZgZbV^c^c\[VXZig^hZhjeVcYidlVgYi]Zh^YZ[gdbl]^X]i]ZWdcZ XdbZh#

4RIQUETRAL&IGURESn I]Zig^fjZigVa^hi]Zi]^gYWdcZ[gdbi]Zi]jbWh^YZ^ci]Zegdm^bVaXVgeVagdl#>i ]Vhi]gZZbV^cVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZh]ZcXZ^ihcVbZ#I]ZWdcZ^hY^hi^c\j^h]ZY[gdbi]Z igVeZod^YWn^ihe^h^[dgbVgi^XjaVi^dc!Vh^c\aZ!X^gXjaVg!^hdaViZY!VcYZaZkViZY[VXZi#  ™ 1^Qd_]YSQ\cYTY^WI]ZhbVaaZhid[i]Zi]gZZbV_dgVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZh^h[dgi]Z e^h^[dgb!dci]ZeVabVg!bZY^Vahjg" [VXZd[i]ZWdcZ#I]ZaVg\Zhi[VXZi^h &IGUREBYWXd [dgi]Z]VbViZVcY^hY^hiVa#I]Zaj" dbYaeUdbQ\AViZgVa cViZ[VXZi^haViZgVaid!WjiXdci^cjdjh ^hje#EVabVgk^Zl# l^i]!i]^h[VXZi# CVijgVah^oZ#  ™ @_cYdY_^Q\cYTY^W=daYi]ZXdbbdc ZY\ZWZilZZci]ZildaVg\Zhi[VXZih idlVgYndjVcYkZgi^XVaan#L]Zci]Z &IGUREBYWXd i]^gY[VXZi[dgi]Ze^h^[dgb^hje! dbYaeUdbQ\EVabVg i]^h[VXZied^cihidlVgYi]Zh^YZ[gdb ^hje#K^Zl[gdbi]Z l]^X]i]ZWdcZXdbZh# ]VbViZ#CVijgVah^oZ#

0ISIFORM&IGURESn I]Ze^h^[dgbWdcZ^heZV"h]VeZY!l^i]dcZh^YZÅViiZcZYWni]Zig^fjZigVaVgi^XjaVg [VXZi#I]ZcdcVgi^XjaVgWdYn^hVcViiVX]bZcied^ci[dgi]ZÊZmdggZi^cVXjajb#I]Ze^" h^[dgb^hi]ZhbVaaZhid[i]ZXVgeVah#7ZXVjhZ^iYZkZadehl^i]^cViZcYdc!^i^hVXijVaan VhZhVbd^YWdcZ#I]ZgZVgZdi]Zg!bjX]hbVaaZghZhVbd^YWdcZh[djcYZbWZYYZY^c ÅZmdgiZcYdch![dgZmVbeaZ!VihdbZbZiVXVgede]VaVc\ZVaVcY^ciZge]VaVc\ZVa_d^cih#  ™ 1^Qd_]YSQ\cYTY^WI]ZcdcVgi^XjaVgWdYnd[i]Ze^h^[dgbjcYZga^Zhi]ZjacVg XdgcZgd[i]ZWVhZd[i]ZeVab#I]Zbdge]dad\^XVakVg^Vi^dcd[i]ZWdcZbV`Zh h^Y^c\VXXjgViZ^cdcanVWdji &IGUREBYWXd`YcYV_b] -*·.%d[VaaXVhZh# 9^hiVa^hidlVgYi]ZaZ[i#K^Zl  ™ @_cYdY_^Q\cYTY^W=daYi]Z [gdbi]Zig^fjZigVa# [VXZiidlVgYndjVcYijgci]Z CVijgVah^oZ# WdcZjci^ai]ZWja`d[i]Zcdc" Vgi^XjaVghjg[VXZi]Vi^hk^h^WaZ &IGUREBYWXd`YcYV_b] ^ci]^hk^Zl^hje#I]Z\gddkZ I]Zig^fjZigVa[VXZi^hjeVcY VcYi]ZWja`d[i]^hk^h^WaZhjg" [VXZhi]ZaZ[iYdghVa#K^Zl[gdb [VXZ^hY^heaVXZYidlVgYi]Zh^YZ i]Zegdm^bVa!eVabVg]VbViZ [gdbl]^X]i]ZWdcZXdbZh# ZcYaViZgVa#CVijgVah^oZ# 

8]VeiZg&(=VcY/8VgeVah!BZiVXVgeVah!E]VaVc\Zh

4RAPEZIUM'REATER-ULTANGULAR &IGURE I]ZigVeZo^jb^hVc^ggZ\jaVganh^YZYWdcZd[bZY^jbh^oZ#>i^hY^hi^c\j^h]ZYWn^ih aVg\Zhi[VXZi!VhVYYaZ"h]VeZYVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ[dgi]ZWVhZd[B8&i]jbW!VcYWnV adc\!gV^hZY!cVggdlijWZgXaZ!dgXgZhi#  ™ 1^Qd_]YSQ\cYTY^WI]ZWdcZ]VhVcZadc\ViZ!egdm^bdY^hiVaandg^ZciZYXgZhi!dg ijWZgXaZ!dc^iheVabVghjg[VXZ#I]^h^hVcViiVX]bZcied^ci[dgi]ZÊZmdggZi^cVXj" ajb#I]Z\gddkZVY_VXZciidi]^hijWZgXaZ^hbZY^VaidlVgYi]ZXZciZgd[i]Z]VcY# I]Zi]jbWVgi^XjaVi^dc^hY^hiVaVcY[VXZhaViZgVaan#  ™ @_cYdY_^Q\cYTY^WEaVXZi]ZWdcZdcVÅVihjg[VXZl^i]i]ZijWZgXaZdcideVcY VlVn[gdbndj!VcYi]ZXdcXVkZ[VXZihdcZ^i]Zgh^YZ#I]Z\gddkZVY_VXZciidi]Z ijWZgXaZ^hdci]Zh^YZ[gdbl]^X]i]ZWdcZXdbZh#

&IGUREBYWXddbQ`UjYe]EVabVg^hje#K^Zl[gdbi]ZB8'WVhZaZ[i0k^Zl[gdbi]Z aViZgVahXVe]d^YZcYXZciZg0k^Zl[gdbi]ZhXVe]d^Y"igVeZod^YWdjcYVgn[gdbbZY^Vag^\]i# CVijgVah^oZ#

4RAPEZOID,ESSER-ULTANGULAR &IG I]ZigVeZod^Y^hWddi"h]VeZY#>i^hi]ZhbVaaZhiXVgeVaWdcZ^ci]ZY^hiVagdl#>iVgi^Xj" aViZhY^hiVaanl^i]i]ZWVhZd[B8'#

&IGUREBYWXddbQ`Uj_YTEVabVg^hje# K^Zl[gdbi]ZY^hiVa"bdhiigVeZo^jbaZ[i0 k^Zl[gdbi]ZXVe^iViZ"hXVe]d^YWdjcYVgn [gdbegdm^bVag^\]i#CVijgVah^oZ#

&(#&#+IgVeZod^Y

'(&

(!.$

 ™ 1^Qd_]YSQ\cYTY^WI]ZaVg\ZhicdcVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ^hYdghVa!VcY^ihbdhi ed^ciZYXdgcZg^hegdm^bVaVcYaViZgVadci]Zi]jbWh^YZ#?jhieVabVgidi]^h XdgcZgi]ZgZ^hVh]Vgeg^Y\Zl]ZgZi]ZaViZgVa!bdgZXdckZmVgi^XjaVg[VXZi[dgi]Z igVeZo^jbbZZihi]Zegdm^bVa!bdgZXdcXVkZVgi^XjaVg[VXZi[dgi]ZhXVe]d^Y#  ™ @_cYdY_^Q\cYTY^WEaVXZi]Z¹hdaZºd[i]ZWddidci]ZiVWaZ!l^i]i]ZcVggdl!K" h]VeZYheVXZWZilZZci]ZVgi^XjaVg[VXZihdgi]ZaVg\ZhiVgi^XjaVgYdjWaZ[VXZi idlVgYndj#I]ZidZd[i]ZWddii]Zced^cihidlVgYi]Zh^YZ[gdbl]^X]i]ZWdcZ XdbZh#

#APITATE&IGURESn I]ZXVe^iViZ^hVaVg\ZXVgeVaWdcZi]ViVgi^XjaViZhY^hiVaanl^i]i]ZWVhZhd[B8(!B8 '!VcYhdbZi^bZhB8)#>ihY^hiVaZcY^hi]ZgZ[dgZhfjVgZYd[[!l]^aZi]Zegdm^bVaZcY ^hgdjcYZY#I]ZXUQT;^\jgZ&(#&(d[i]ZXVe^iViZ^hi]ZgdjcYZYZcYd[i]ZWdcZi]Vi Vgi^XjaViZhegdm^bVaanl^i]i]Z]daadl[dgbZYWni]ZajcViZVcYhXVe]d^Y#I]ZRQcU ;^\jgZ&(#&(d[i]ZXVe^iViZ^hi]ZbdgZhfjVgZY"d[[ZcYi]ViVgi^XjaViZhY^hiVaanbdhi Y^gZXianl^i]i]ZWVhZd[B8(#  ™ 1^Qd_]YSQ\cYTY^WEgdm^bVaani]Z]ZVYVgi^XjaViZh^ci]Z]daadl[dgbZYWni]Z ajcViZVcYhXVe]d^Y#I]ZaVg\Zhi!ÅViiZhicdcVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ^hYdghVa#I]ZbdgZ XdcXVkZhjg[VXZd[i]Z]ZVY^h[dgi]Z]VbViZVcY^hi]jhbZY^Vadci]Za^iiaZÄc" \Zgh^YZ#  ™ @_cYdY_^Q\cYTY^WL]Zci]Z]ZVY^hjeVcYi]ZWVhZgZhihdci]ZiVWaZ!eaVXZi]Z adc\!cVggdlVgi^XjaVi^dci]VigjchjedcZh^YZd[i]ZWdcZ[gdbi]ZWVhZidi]Z ]ZVYidlVgYndj#I]^hVgi^XjaVi^dc^hdci]Zh^YZ[gdbl]^X]i]ZWdcZXdbZh#

HEAD

BASE

&IGUREBYWXdSQ`YdQdUEgdm^bVa^hje#K^Zl[gdb]VbViZaZ[i0k^Zl[gdbi]ZhXVe]d^Y VcYigVeZod^Y[gdbaViZgVab^YYaZaZ[i0eVabVgk^Zlb^YYaZg^\]i0YdghVak^Zlg^\]i#CVijgVa h^oZ#

&IGUREBYWXdSQ`YdQdUEVabVg^hje#K^Zl[gdbi]ZB8(WVhZ# CVijgVah^oZ#

(AMATE&IGURE I]Z]VbViZ^hi]ZXVgeVaWdcZl^i]i]ZXQ]e\ec;^\jgZ&(#&*dg]dd`"h]VeZY!cdc" Vgi^XjaVgegd_ZXi^dcdci]ZeVabVghjg[VXZ#I]^hegd_ZXi^dc^hi]Z[djgi]ViiVX]bZci ed^ci[dgi]ZÊZmdggZi^cVXjajb#  ™ 1^Qd_]YSQ\cYTY^WI]ZWdcZVgi^XjaViZhY^hiVaanl^i]i]ZWVhZhd[B8)VcY B8*k^VVYdjWaZ[VXZiVii]ZWVhZd[i]Z]Vbjajh#I]Z]Vbjajh^heaVXZYdci]Z Y^hiVa!eVabVghjg[VXZd[i]ZWdcZVcY^hbZY^Va!]dd`^c\dkZgi]ZZY\Zd[i]ZXVg" 

8]VeiZg&(=VcY/8VgeVah!BZiVXVgeVah!E]VaVc\Zh

eVaijccZa^ci]^hedh^i^dc#  ™ @_cYdY_^Q\cYTY^WEaVXZi]ZÅVicdcVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZYdlcl^i]i]Z]dd`VcY i]ZildVY_VXZcibZiVXVgeVa[VXZihVlVn[gdbndj#I]Z]dd`aZVchidlVgYi]Zh^YZ [gdbl]^X]i]ZWdcZXdbZh#

'ROWTH I]ZXVgeVaWdcZhZVX]dhh^[n[gdbVh^c\aZXZciZg#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION 7ZXVjhZd[i]Z^ghbVaah^oZVcYXdbeVXiXdchigjXi^dc!i]Z^YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[[gV\bZc" iVgnXVgeVaWdcZh^hcdijhjVaanXVaaZY[dg#>[i]Z]VcY]VhWZZcXVgZ[jaanXdaaZXiZY!^c" iVXiWdcZhVgZjhjVaanVkV^aVWaZ#:VX]d[i]ZXVgeVaWdcZh^hY^hi^cXi^kZVcY^bedhh^WaZ

HAMULUS

&IGUREBYWXdXQ]QdUEVabVg^hje#K^Zl[gdbi]ZB8)VcYB8*WVhZhaZ[i0k^Zl [gdbi]ZXVe^iViZb^YYaZaZ[i0k^Zl[gdbi]Zig^fjZigVab^YYaZg^\]i0k^Zl[gdbi]ZajcViZ g^\]i#CVijgVah^oZ#

-ETACARPALS&IGURESn I]ZbZiVXVgeVahVgZcjbWZgZYB8&i]Zi]jbWi]gdj\]B8*i]Za^iiaZÄc\Zg! VXXdgY^c\idi]ZÄkZgVnhd[i]Z]VcY#I]ZnVgZVaaijWjaVgWdcZh!l^i]gdjcYY^hiVa Vgi^XjaVghjg[VXZhXUQTcVcYbdgZgZXiVc\jaVgegdm^bVaZcYhRQcUc#I]ZnVgZ^YZc" &(#'BZiVXVgeVah

'((

(!.$

idXdc[jhZl^i]Vcdi]Zg#8dc[jh^dcd[i]ZVYjaiXVgeVaWdcZhl^i]i]ZiVghVaWdcZh^h ^begdWVWaZWZXVjhZi]Z[dgbZgVgZVaahbVaaZgi]Vci]ZaViiZgVcYi]Zh]VeZhVgZVaa Y^hi^cXi^kZ# BVcn h`ZaZidch! ZheZX^Vaan i]dhZ [gdb VgX]Zdad\^XVa XdciZmih! ]VkZ ^cXdbeaZiZ ]VcYhWZXVjhZd[edhibdgiZbY^hijgWVcXZd[i]Zh`ZaZidc[dg^chiVcXZ!Wjggdl^c\gd" YZcihWZ[dgZZmXVkVi^dc#I]ZhZVc^bVahd[iZcbdkZhbVaaZgh`ZaZiVaZaZbZcihYjg^c\ i]Z^gWjggdl^c\VXi^k^i^Zh#9jg^c\VgX]Zdad\^XVaZmXVkVi^dc!kZgnhbVaaWdcZh!hjX]Vh i]ZhZhVbd^Yh!e^h^[dgb!VcYiZgb^cVae]VaVc\Zh!VgZhdbZi^bZhadhi^[XVgZVcYÄcZ hXgZZc^c\VgZcdiZbeadnZY^cgZXdkZgn#













&IGUREBYWXdXQ^TT_bcQ\edhiZg^dg#GVnh&·*!h]dl^c\i]ZbZiVXVgeVahVcYi]Z egdm^bVa!^ciZgbZY^ViZ!VcYY^hiVa]VcYe]VaVc\Zh#9^hiVa^hje!aViZgVa^hidlVgYi]ZaZ[i# CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&(=VcY/8VgeVah!BZiVXVgeVah!E]VaVc\Zh

(!.$













&IGUREBYWXdXQ^T`Q\]QbVciZg^dg#GVnh&·*!h]dl^c\i]ZbZiVXVgeVahVcYi]Z egdm^bVa!^ciZgbZY^ViZ!VcYY^hiVa]VcYe]VaVc\Zh#9^hiVa^hje!aViZgVa^hidlVgYi]Zg^\]i# CVijgVah^oZ#

&(#'BZiVXVgeVah

'(*

i^ÄZYVcYh^YZYbdhiZ[[ZXi^kZanVXXdgY^c\idi]Zbdge]dad\nd[i]ZWVhZh# I]ZWVhZhd[i]ZbZiVXVgeVahVgi^XjaViZl^i]i]Z^gcZ^\]Wdgh^cedh^i^dch'·*#6aa [djgd[i]ZXVgeVah^ci]ZY^hiVagdlVgi^XjaViZl^i]dcZdgbdgZbZiVXVgeVaWVhZh/i]Z igVeZo^jbl^i]B8&VcYB8'!i]ZigVeZod^Yl^i]B8'!i]ZXVe^iViZl^i]B8'VcY B8(VcYhdbZi^bZhB8)!VcYi]Z]VbViZl^i]B8)VcYB8*#

&IRST-ETACARPAL4HUMB I]ZÄghibZiVXVgeVa^hi]Zh]dgiZhibZiVXVgeVa!WgdVYZgVcYbdgZgdWjhi^c^ihh]V[i i]Vci]Zdi]Zgh#>ihh^c\aZegdm^bVaVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ^hhVYYaZ"h]VeZY!XdggZhedcY^c\ idi]Z[VXZidci]ZigVeZo^jb#  ™ CYTY^WI]ZbVm^bjbeVabVgegd_ZXi^dcd[i]ZWdcZVii]ZWVhZ^hValVnhidlVgY i]ZbZY^Vah^YZ#I]ZgZ[dgZ!^cVegdm^bVak^Zl!^bV\^cZY^k^Y^c\i]ZhVYYaZ" h]VeZYegdm^bVa[VXZi^cidbZY^VaVcYaViZgVaedgi^dch#I]ZbZY^Vaedgi^dcd[i]Z Vgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ^hValVnhhbVaaZg#I]ZaViZgVaeVabVghjg[VXZd[i]Zh]V[i^haVg\Zg VcYbdgZZmXVkViZYi]Vci]ZbZY^VaeVabVghjg[VXZ#K^ZlZYYdghVaan!l^i]i]ZY^h" iVaZcYje!i]ZVm^hd[bVm^bjbaZc\i]^hh`ZlZYWVhVaanidlVgYi]Zh^YZi]ZWdcZ ^h[gdb#

3ECOND-ETACARPAL I]ZhZXdcYbZiVXVgeVa^hcdgbVaani]Zadc\ZhibZiVXVgeVa!Vii]ZWVhZd[i]Z^cYZm Äc\Zg#I]ZWVhZegZhZcihVadc\!XjgkZY!WaVYZ"a^`ZlZY\Zi]ViVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]ZigVe" Zod^Y!XVe^iViZ!igVeZo^jb!VcYB8(#  ™ CYTY^WI]Zbdhiegdm^bVaeVgid[i]ZWVhZ^hVWgdVY!WaVYZ"a^`Z!bZY^Vaan edh^i^dcZYlZY\Zi]ViWZVghi]ZVgi^XjaVi^dc[dgB8(#

4HIRD-ETACARPAL I]Zi]^gYbZiVXVgeVaa^ZhVii]ZWVhZd[i]Zb^YYaZÄc\Zg#>i^hi]ZdcanbZiVXVgeVa l^i]Vh]Vgeegd_ZXi^dc!i]Zcdi\_YT`b_SUcc!Vi^ihWVhZ#>iVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]ZXVe^iViZ VcYB8'VcYB8)Vii]ZWVhZ#  ™ CYTY^WI]Zhinad^YegdXZhh^hdci]ZaViZgVa!dgB8'!h^YZd[i]ZWdcZ#

&OURTH-ETACARPAL I]Z[djgi]bZiVXVgeVaa^ZhVii]ZWVhZd[i]Zg^c\Äc\ZgVcY^hh]dgiZgVcYbdgZ\gVX^aZ i]VcB8'dgB8(#>i]VhV[V^ganhfjVgZWVhZl^i]i]gZZdg[djgVgi^XjaVg[VXZih#>i Vgi^XjaViZhVi^ihWVhZl^i]i]ZXVe^iViZhdbZi^bZh!]VbViZ!B8(!VcYB8*#



8]VeiZg&(=VcY/8VgeVah!BZiVXVgeVah!E]VaVc\Zh

(!.$













&IGUREBYWXdXQ^T\QdUbQ\#GVnh&·*!h]dl^c\i]ZbZiVXVgeVahVcYi]Zegdm^bVa! ^ciZgbZY^ViZ!VcYY^hiVa]VcYe]VaVc\Zh#CVijgVah^oZ#

&(#'BZiVXVgeVah

'(,













&IGUREBYWXd]UdQSQb`Q\c]UTYQ\CVijgVah^oZ#













&IGUREBYWXd]UdQSQb`Q\RQcUc`b_hY]Q\9dghVa^hje!aViZgVa^hidlVgYi]ZaZ[i# CVijgVah^oZ#

 ™ CYTY^WI]Zegdm^bVaVcYbZY^VaWVhVa[VXZihh]VgZVXdbbdc!g^\]i"Vc\aZ Vgi^XjaVgZY\Z#

&IFTH-ETACARPAL 6ii]ZWVhZd[i]Za^iiaZÄc\Zg!i]ZÄ[i]bZiVXVgeVa^hi]Zi]^ccZhiVcYh]dgiZhid[i]Z cdcedaa^XVabZiVXVgeVah#>iWZVghdcanildWVhVa[VXZih/dcZ[dgi]Z]VbViZVcYdcZ[dg B8)#  ™ CYTY^WI]ZcdcVgi^XjaVgh^YZd[i]ZWVhZ[VXZhbZY^Vaan!VlVn[gdbB8)#

'ROWTH&IGURE :VX]bZiVXVgeVaZmXZeiB8&dhh^ÄZh[gdbildXZciZgh/Veg^bVgndcZ[dgi]Zh]V[i 

8]VeiZg&(=VcY/8VgeVah!BZiVXVgeVah!E]VaVc\Zh

&IGUREBZiVXVgeVa\gdli]#I]ZeV^ghd[^bbVijgZbZiVXVgeVahVgZh]dlc]ZgZ^cVciZ" g^dgeVabVgk^Zl!l^i]gVn&dci]ZaZ[iVcYgVn*dci]Zg^\]i#I]ZnVgZ[gdbdcZ"nZVg"daYVcY h^m"nZVg"daY^cY^k^YjVah#CVijgVah^oZ#

VcYi]ZWVhZ!VcYVhZXdcYVgndcZ[dgi]ZY^hiVaZmigZb^ini]Z]ZVY#I]Zi]jbWbZiV" XVgeVa]VhVhZeVgViZXZciZg[dg^ihWVhZWjicdcZ[dg^ihY^hiVaZmigZb^in#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION BZiVXVgeVah'·*VgZhidjiZgi]VcbZiViVghVah'·*#BZiVXVgeVah]V[ihVgZaVg\Zg^cY^" VbZiZggZaVi^kZidaZc\i]VcYVgZcdiVhhigV^\]iVcYhaZcYZgVhbZiViVghVah]V[ih#BZiV" XVgeVa]ZVYhVgZbdgZgdjcYZYi]Vci]ZbZY^daViZgVaanXdbegZhhZYbZiViVghVa]ZVYh#

>ch^Y^c\i]ZbZiVXVgeVah!i]ZWVhZhVgZValVnhegdm^bVa!VcYi]ZeVabVgh]V[ihjg[VXZh VgZValVnhbdgZXdcXVkZi]Vci]ZYdghVahjg[VXZh^caViZgVak^Zl#;ZVijgZhd[i]ZWVhZ VgZjhZYidh^YZbZiVXVgeVahVhdjia^cZY^ci]ZegZXZY^c\hZXi^dch#

(AND0HALANGES&IGURESn I]Ze]VaVc\ZhVgZVaah]dgiZgi]VcbZiVXVgeVah!aVX`gdjcYZY]ZVYh!VcYVgZVciZgdedh" iZg^dganÅViiZcZY^ci]Z^gh]V[ih#I]Zi]jbWe]VaVc\ZhVgZh]dgiZgVcYhfjViiZgi]Vc i]Zdi]Zgh!VcYi]Zi]jbWaVX`hVc^ciZgbZY^ViZe]VaVcm#I]ZZmeVcYZYegdm^bVa ZcYd[ZVX]e]VaVcm^hi]ZRQcU#I]ZY^hiVaZcY^hi]ZXUQTegdm^bVadg^ciZgbZY^ViZ e]VaVc\Zhdgi]ZTYcdQ\dY`ij[i0Y^hiVae]VaVc\Zhdcan#I]ZcdcVgi^XjaVgijWZgXaZh VY_VXZciidi]ZbZiVXVgeVa]ZVYhVcYi]Ze]VaVc\ZVa_d^cihVgZViiVX]bZcied^cih[dg i]ZXdaaViZgVaa^\VbZcih# &(#(=VcYE]VaVc\Zh

'(.

(!.$

3IDING

9dghVahjg[VXZhd[i]Z]VcYe]VaVc\ZhVgZhbddi]VcYgdjcYZY#I]ZeVabVghjg" [VXZh!^cXdcigVhi!VgZÅViVcYbdgZgdj\]ZcZY!ZheZX^VaanVadc\Z^i]Zgh^YZd[i]ZcXQVd! l]ZgZgV^hZYg^Y\ZhbVg`ViiVX]bZcih^iZh[dgi]ZÉWgdjhÊZmdgh]ZVi]h!i^hhjZhi]ViegZ" kZcii]ZÊZmdgiZcYdch[gdb¹Wdlhig^c\^c\ºVlVn[gdbi]ZWdcZhVhi]ZÄc\ZghVgZ ÅZmZY#

0ROXIMAL(AND0HALANGES :VX]egdm^bVa]VcYe]VaVcmY^heaVnhVh^c\aZ!XdcXVkZegdm^bVaWVhVaVgi^XjaVg[VXZi [dgi]ZbZiVXVgeVa]ZVY#I]Zegdm^bVai]jbWe]VaVcm^hgZVY^angZXd\c^oVWaZWn^ih h]dgi!hidjiVeeZVgVcXZ#

)NTERMEDIATE(AND0HALANGES :VX] ^ciZgbZY^ViZ ]VcY e]VaVcm Y^heaVnh V YdjWaZ egdm^bVa Vgi^XjaVg [VXZi [dg i]Z ]ZVYd[i]Zegdm^bVae]VaVcm!VcYZVX]Vahd]VhVY^hiVaVgi^XjaVg[VXZi#I]Zi]jbWgVn WZVghdcanilde]VaVc\Zh!aVX`^c\Vbdge]dad\^XVaan^ciZgbZY^ViZe]VaVcm#

$ISTAL(AND0HALANGES :VX]Y^hiVa]VcYe]VaVcmY^heaVnhVYdjWaZegdm^bVaVgi^XjaVg[VXZi[dgi]Z]ZVYd[ i]Z^ciZgbZY^ViZe]VaVcm#I]ZiZgb^cVaZcYd[ZVX]]VhVcdcVgi^XjaVgeVY!i]ZTYc dQ\`XQ\Q^WUQ\deRUb_cYdi#I]Zi]jbWe]VaVcm^hgZVY^angZXd\c^oVWaZWZXVjhZd[^ih h]dgi!hidjiVeeZVgVcXZ#I]ZYdghVahjg[VXZhd[i]ZhZe]VaVc\ZhVgZbdgZgdjcYZY!VcY i]ZeVabVghjg[VXZhVgZbdgZgj\dhZ#

'ROWTH =VcYe]VaVc\ZhZVX]dhh^[n[gdbildXZciZgh/Veg^bVgndcZ[dgi]Zh]V[iVcYY^hiVa ZcY!VcYVhZXdcYVgndcZ[dgi]ZWVhZ#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION =VcYe]VaVc\Zh]VkZh]V[ihl]dhZeVabVghjg[VXZhVgZÅViiZcZY![dgb^c\V]Va["X^gXaZ ^cXgdhhhZXi^dc#;ddie]VaVcmh]V[ihVgZX^gXjaVg^cXgdhhhZXi^dc#

3IDING ;dgh^Y^c\]VcYVcY[ddie]VaVc\Zh^i^hWZhiidldg`l^i]l]daZheZX^bZchVcYXdb" eVgVi^kZbViZg^Vah!eVgi^XjaVgan^ck^kdgVY^d\gVe]h#



8]VeiZg&(=VcY/8VgeVah!BZiVXVgeVah!E]VaVc\Zh

#HAPTER

EZak^X<^gYaZ/HVXgjb! 8dXXnm!Dh8dmVZ I

]ZWdcnhigjXijgZVii]ZWVhZd[i]Z[gdcia^bWh^hi]Zh]djaYZg\^gYaZVcYi]Z dcZVii]ZWVhZd[i]Z]^cYa^bWh^hi]ZeZak^X\^gYaZ#I]ZeZak^X\^gYaZhd[iZg" gZhig^VakZgiZWgViZhVgZXdccZXiZYidi]ZkZgiZWgVaXdajbcVcYVgZbjX]aVg\Zgi]Vc i]Z^g]dbdad\h^cÄh]#I]ZhZVYVeiVi^dchVgZgZfj^gZY[dglZ^\]i"WZVg^c\VcYbjhXaZ ViiVX]bZci^ci]ZiZggZhig^Va[dgbh#>cZVganaVcY"YlZaa^c\kZgiZWgViZh!i]Zg^\]iVcY aZ[ia^bW\^gYaZh_d^cZYYdghVaanl^i]i]ZhVXgVakZgiZWgVZid[dgbVWdcng^c\VgdjcY i]ZgZVgd[i]Zigjc`#I]^h^hhi^aai]ZWVh^X[dgb^ci]ZiZigVedYeZak^h# I]ZVYjai]jbVcWdcneZak^h^hXdbedhZYd[[djgbV^cZaZbZcih/i]Zg^\]iVcY aZ[i _c S_hQU VcY i]Z cQSbe] VcY S_SSih# I]Z hVXgjb VcY XdXXnm VgZ eVgi d[ i]Z Vm^Vah`ZaZidcVcYVgZVXijVaankVg^VWan[jhZYkZgiZWgVZ#I]ZWdcneZak^h[jcXi^dchid hjeedgiVcYegdiZXii]ZVWYdb^cVaVcYeZak^Xdg\Vch#>cVYY^i^dc!^iVcX]dghbjhXaZh d[i]ZVWYdbZcVcYaZ\#Jca^`Zi]Zh]djaYZg\^gYaZ!l]^X]^hVbdkVWaZeaVi[dgb!i]Z eZak^X\^gYaZ^hÄgbanÄmZYidi]ZVm^Vah`ZaZidck^V^ihkZgiZWgVaZaZbZci!i]ZhVXgjb#

3ACRUM&IGURESn !NATOMY

V# I]Z`b_]_^d_bi^hi]ZVciZg^dgb^Ya^cZegd_ZXi^dcd[i]ZhVXgVaeaViZVj#I]Z hVXgVaeaViZVj^hi]ZÅVi!VciZgdhjeZg^dgan^cXa^cZYhjg[VXZd[i]ZhVXgjbi]ViVg" i^XjaViZhl^i]i]ZiZgb^cVa!dgbdhi^c[Zg^dg!ajbWVgkZgiZWgV# W# I]ZQ\QU!dg¹l^c\h!ºhlZZeaViZgVaan[gdbi]ZÄghihVXgVaZaZbZci#I]ZnVgi^XjaViZ l^i]i]ZedhiZgdbZY^Vahjg[VXZd[i]ZdhXdmVZ# X# I]ZcQSb_Y\YQSZ_Y^dQebYSe\QbcebVQSU^hi]ZVgi^XjaVi^dcWZilZZci]ZhVXgjb VcYi]ZdhXdmVZ#I]^hVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ^hWZhihZZc^caViZgVaVheZXi#I]ZVgi^XjaV" i^dc^hi]Zbdhi^bbdW^aZhncdk^Va_d^ci^ci]ZWdYn#I]Z¹ZVg"h]VeZYºhjg[VXZ

')&

0%,6)#')2$,%

I]ZhVXgVakZgiZWgVZ[jhZYjg^c\VYdaZhXZcXZ^ciddcZ^bbdW^aZ!lZY\Z"h]VeZYWdcZ! i]ZhVXgjb#I]^hWdcZ^hine^XVaan[dgbZY[gdbÄkZhZ\bZcih!WjibVn]VkZVh[ZlVh [djgdgVhbVcnVhh^m#I]ZhVXgjb^hadXViZYVii]ZWVhZd[i]ZkZgiZWgVaXdajbc#>i Vgi^XjaViZhW^aViZgVaanl^i]i]ZilddhhVXdmVVcY^c[Zg^dganl^i]i]ZhbVaaXdXXnm#

ALA

TRANSVERSE LINES

ANTERIORPELVIC SACRALFORAMINA

&IGURECQSbe]Q^dUb_Y^VUbY_bfYUgCVijgVah^oZ#

Vgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]ZVjg^XjaVghjg[VXZd[i]ZdhXdmVZ# Y# I]ZQ^dUbY_b`U\fYScQSbQ\V_bQ]Y^QVgZdeZc^c\h^ci]ZXdcXVkZVciZg^dghjg" [VXZd[i]ZhVXgjbi]gdj\]l]^X]i]ZhVXgVacZgkZheVhh#  Z# I]ZdbQ^cfUbcU\Y^UcVgZ]dg^odciVag^Y\Zhdci]ZXdcXVkZVciZg^dghVXgVahjg[VXZ i]VibVg`i]ZZY\Zhd[i]Z[jhZYhVXgVakZgiZWgVZ#  [# I]Zce`UbY_bQbdYSe\QbVQSUdcd[i]ZhVXgjbVgi^XjaViZl^i][VXZihdci]Z^c[Zg^dg Vgi^XjaVgegdXZhhZhd[i]Zbdhi^c[Zg^dgajbWVgkZgiZWgV# \# I]ZT_bcQ\gQ\\d[i]ZhVXgjb^hVgdj\]!^ggZ\jaVg!kVg^VWaZeaViZd[WdcZbVYZ jed[i]Zdhh^ÄZYaVb^cVZVcYVgi^XjaVgegdXZhhZhd[i]Z[jhZYhVXgVakZgiZWgVZ# ]# I]Z]UTYQ^SbUcdc`Y^U^hi]Z]^\]ankVg^VWaZb^Ya^cZegd_ZXi^dcd[i]ZYdghVa lVaaXdbedhZYd[[jhZYhe^cZhd[i]ZhVXgVakZgiZWgVZ# 

8]VeiZg&)EZak^X<^gYaZ

SUPERIOR ARTICULARFACET

MEDIANCREST SPINE

DORSALWALL

&IGURECQSbe]`_cdUb_ce`UbY_bfYUgCVijgVah^oZ#

0%,6)#')2$,%

&IGURECQSbe]Q^dUb_ce`UbY_bfYUgEdhiZg^dg^hje#CdiZi]ZaViZgVaaneaVXZY[VXZih[dg i]ZhVXgVa^oZYA"*d[i]^h^cY^k^YjVa#CVijgVah^oZ#

&)#&HVXgjb

')(

PROMONTORY

SACROILIACJOINT AURICULARSURFACE

&IGURECQSbe]\UVd\QdUbQ\6ciZg^dg^hidlVgYi]ZaZ[i#CVijgVah^oZ#

'ROWTH I]Z hVXgjb dhh^ÄZh [gdb bVcn hZeVgViZ XZciZgh ^c ^cY^k^YjVah l^i] ÄkZ hVXgVa kZg" iZWgVZ#:VX]hVXgVaWdYnYZkZadeh[gdbVeg^bVgnXZciZgl^i]ildZe^e]nhZVaeaViZh# 8dggZhedcY^c\VgX]Zhdhh^[n[gdbildXZciZghZVX]!VcYVcVYY^i^dcVaeV^gd[XdhiVa ZaZbZcih [dgb i]Z VciZgdaViZgVa egd_ZXi^dch d[ ZVX] hVXgVa kZgiZWgV# Ild Ze^e]nhZVa eaViZh[dgbViZVX]hVXgd^a^VXVgi^XjaVggZ\^dc!dcZ[dgb^c\i]ZVjg^XjaVghjg[VXZVcY dcZ[dgb^c\i]ZaViZgVabVg\^c^c[Zg^dgidi]^h#HZZ;^\jgZ.#,#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION  ™ I]ZegdbdcidgngZ\^dcb^\]iWZb^hiV`Zc[dgVajbWVgkZgiZWgVl]Zc[gV\bZci" ZY#AjbWVgh!]dlZkZg!aVX`ViiVX]ZYVaVZ# 

8]VeiZg&)EZak^X<^gYaZ

 ™ I]ZVjg^XjaVghjg[VXZb^\]iWZb^hiV`Zc[dgV[gV\bZcid[dhXdmVZl]ZcWgd`Zc# =dlZkZg!i]ZhVXgVaVjg^XjaVghjg[VXZ]Vhk^gijVaancdVY_VXZcidjiZgWdcZhjg[VXZ hjggdjcY^c\^iVhi]ZdhXdmVZYdZh#

3IDING L]Zc[gV\bZciVgn!eVgihd[i]ZhVXgjbXVcWZh^YZYVh[daadlh/  ™ I]ZVciZg^dghVXgVahjg[VXZ^hhbddi]VcYXdcXVkZ!l^i]igVchkZghZa^cZh#  ™ I]Zh^oZd[hVXgVakZgiZWgVZY^b^c^h]Zh^c[Zg^dgan#  ™ I]ZVjg^XjaVghVXgd^a^VXhjg[VXZ^haViZgVa!VcYi]ZVeZmd[i]^hK"h]VeZY[ZVijgZ^h VciZg^dg#

#OCCYX&IGURESn I]ZXdXXnm!i]ZkZhi^\^VaiV^a!^h]^\]ankVg^VWaZ^ch]VeZ!l^i]i]gZZidÄkZbdhid[iZc [djgkVg^VWan[jhZYhZ\bZcih#I]ZgjY^bZciVgnkZgiZWgVZd[i]ZXdXXnm]VkZVgi^XjaVg VcYigVchkZghZegdXZhhZhhjeZg^dgan!Wjii]ZnaVX`eZY^XaZh!aVb^cVZ!VcYhe^cdjhegd" XZhhZh#I]ZhVXgVaVgi^XjaVi^dc^hk^Vi]ZhjeZg^dgXdXXn\ZVaWdYnVhlZaaVhVgZaVi^kZan aVg\ZeV^gd[ijWZgXaZhXVaaZYi]ZS_b^eQ;^\jgZ&)#+#I]ZaViiZgVgZgjY^bZciVgnVg" i^XjaVgegdXZhhZhi]ViXdciVXii]ZhVXgjb#I]ZXdXXnmbVn[jhZl^i]i]ZhVXgjbaViZ ^ca^[Z# 6hl^i]i]ZhVXgjb!i]Z^cY^k^YjVakZgiZWgVaZaZbZcihd[i]ZXdXXnmYZXgZVhZ^c h^oZ^c[Zg^dgan!VcY]dg^odciVaa^cZhd[[jh^dcXVcWZhZZcWZilZZcVY_VXZciXdXXn\ZVa kZgiZWgVZ#I]ZXdXXnmhZgkZhidVcX]dgeZak^XbjhXaZhVcYa^\VbZcih#

CORNUA 0%,6)#')2$,%

&IGURE3_SSihQ^dUbY_bHjeZg^dg^hje# &IGURE3_SSih`_cdUbY_bHjeZg^dg^h CVijgVah^oZ# je#CVijgVah^oZ#

&)#'8dXXnm

')*

/S#OXAE&IGURESn !NATOMY Jca^`ZbVcnWdcZhi]Vi\V^ci]Z^gcVbZhWZXVjhZd[eZgXZ^kZYh^b^aVg^i^ZhidXdb" bdcdW_ZXih!i]ZdhXdmVZgZhZbWaZhcdXdbbdcdW_ZXiVcYi]jh]VhZVgcZYi]Z^c" [dgbVacVbZY^^_]Y^QdU ¸i]Z¹WdcZl^i]cdcVbZ#ºI]ZdhXdmVZY^[[Zgh^cbVaZh VcY [ZbVaZh! l^i] ^ih VcVidbn gZegZhZci^c\ V Xdbegdb^hZ WZilZZc i]Z YZbVcYh d[ adXdbdi^dcVcYW^gi]^c\#I]ZdhXdmVZ^hVeVgid[i]ZWdcneZak^hVcY^h[dgbZYdcid" \ZcZi^XVaan[gdbi]gZZY^[[ZgZcieVgih!i]ZY\Ye]!YcSXYe]!VcY`eRYc!l]^X][jhZ^c ZVganVYdaZhXZcXZ#6cVidb^XVadg^ZciVi^dcd[i]ZdhXdmVZ^hVXXdbea^h]ZYWneaVX^c\ i]Z]^ehdX`ZiaViZgVaanVcYi]Z^a^jbhjeZg^dgan0i]^hVaadlhi]ZeaVcZd[i]Z`eRYS ci]`XicYci]ZdcaneaVXZl]ZgZg^\]iVcYaZ[idhXdmVZcZVganbZZiidYZÄcZi]Z hV\^iiVaeaVcZ# I]Z[ZVijgZh^YZci^ÄZY]ZgZdXXjgdcWdi]i]Zhjg[VXZhVcYi]ZZY\Zhd[i]ZdhXdm" VZ#BVcnd[i]Z[ZVijgZhVgZk^h^WaZ[gdbY^[[ZgZcik^Zlhd[i]ZWdcZ#L]ZcXdggZXian dg^ZciZY!i]ZVciZg^dghjeZg^dg^a^VXhe^cZh]djaYWZ^ci]ZhVbZeVgVXdgdcVaeaVcZVh i]ZbdhiVciZg^dged^cidci]ZejW^h# V# I]ZY\Ye]^hi]Zi]^c!WaVYZ"a^`Zedgi^dchjeZg^dgidi]Z]^ehdX`Zi# W# I]ZYcSXYe]^hi]ZbVhh^kZ!Wajci!edhiZgd^c[Zg^dgeVgid[i]ZWdcZi]VidcZh^ihdc# X# I]Z`eRYc^hi]ZVciZgd^c[Zg^dgeVgid[i]ZWdcZi]ViVeegdVX]Zhi]Zdeedh^iZdh XdmVZVii]Zb^Ya^cZ# Y# I]ZQSUdQRe\e]^hi]ZaViZgVaan[VX^c\!]Zb^he]Zg^XVa]daadli]Vi[dgbhi]Z hdX`Zid[i]Z]^e!l]^X]Vgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]Z]ZVYd[i]Z[Zbjg#  Z# I]ZQSUdQRe\QbV_ccQ!dgcdiX]!^hi]ZcdcVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZl^i]^ci]ZVXZiVWjajb# >i^hi]ZViiVX]bZcied^ci[dgi]Za^\VbZcijbiZgZh!Va^\VbZcii]Via^b^ih[ZbdgVa bdW^a^inVcYVXXdbeVc^Zhi]ZkZhhZai]Vihjeea^ZhWaddYidi]Z[ZbdgVa]ZVY#  [# I]Z\e^QdUcebVQSU^hi]ZXgZhXZci"h]VeZYVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZl^i]^ci]ZVXZiVWj" ajbl]ZgZi]Z[ZbdgVa]ZVYVXijVaanVgi^XjaViZh# \# I]ZY\YQS`Y\\QbQSUdQRe\_SbYcdQ\ReddbUcc^hi]ZWdcni]^X`Zc^c\!dgWjiigZhh! adXViZYkZgi^XVaanVWdkZi]ZVXZiVWjajbdci]ZaViZgVa^a^VXhjg[VXZ#I]^he^aaVg ZmiZcYhidi]ZhjeZg^dgbVg\^cd[i]Z^a^jb# ]# I]ZY\YQSSbYcdQ\deRUbS\U^hi]Zi]^X`Zc^c\Vii]ZhjeZg^dgiZgb^cjhd[i]Z^a^VX e^aaVg#  ^# I]ZY\YQSSbUcd^hi]ZhjeZg^dgWdgYZgd[i]Z^a^jb#>i^hH"h]VeZYl]Zck^ZlZY hjeZg^dgan#BVcnd[i]ZVWYdb^cVabjhXaZhdg^\^cViZdci]ZXgZhi#  _# 7\edUQ\\Y^UcVgZgdj\]!^ggZ\jaVga^cZhi]ViYZbVgXViZi]ZViiVX]bZcid[i]Z \ajiZVabjhXaZhdci]ZaViZgVahjg[VXZd[i]Z^a^jb#I]ZnkVgn[gdbegdb^cZciid ^beZgXZei^WaZWZilZZc^cY^k^YjVahVcYVXgdhhi]Z^geVi]h#I]Z^c[Zg^dg\ajiZVaa^cZ ^hV]dg^odciVaa^cZ_jhihjeZg^dgidi]ZVXZiVWjajb#I]ZQ^dUbY_bW\edUQ\\Y^U^h Va^cZi]ViXjgkZhedhiZgd^c[Zg^dgani]gdj\]i]Z[dhhVedhiZg^dgidi]Z^a^VXe^aaVg# I]Z`_cdUbY_bW\edUQ\\Y^U^hbdgZkZgi^XVaaneaVXZY!cZVgi]ZedhiZg^dgZY\Zd[ i]Z^a^jb#I]Z\ajiZjhb^c^bjhbjhXaZdg^\^cViZhWZilZZci]Z^c[Zg^dgVcYVciZg^dg a^cZh!VcYi]Z\ajiZjhbZY^jhbjhXaZVg^hZhWZilZZci]ZVciZg^dgVcYedhiZg^dga^cZh# I]Z\ajiZjhbVm^bjhbjhXaZdg^\^cViZhedhiZg^dgidi]ZedhiZg^dg\ajiZVaa^cZ#I]Z Äghiild\ajiZVabjhXaZh!b^c^bjhVcYbZY^jh!VgZVWYjXidghVcYbZY^VagdiVidghd[ 

8]VeiZg&)EZak^X<^gYaZ

&)#(Dh8dmVZ

'),

0%,6)#')2$,%

i]Z[ZbjgVii]Z]^e!VcYi]Z\ajiZjhbVm^bjh^hVaViZgVagdiVidg!VcZmiZchdg!VcY VcVWYjXidgd[i]Z[ZbjgVii]Z]^e# `# I]ZQ^dUbY_bce`UbY_bY\YQSc`Y^U^hadXViZY!VXXdgY^c\id^ihcVbZ!Vii]ZVciZ" g^dgZcYd[i]Z^a^VXXgZhi#>iVcX]dghi]ZhVgidg^jhbjhXaZVcYi]Z^c\j^cVaa^\VbZci#  a# I]ZQ^dUbY_bY^VUbY_bY\YQSc`Y^U^hVWajciegd_ZXi^dcdci]ZVciZg^dgWdgYZgd[ i]ZdhXdmVZ!_jhihjeZg^dgidi]ZVXZiVWjajb#>i^hi]Zdg^\^cd[i]ZhigV^\]i]ZVY d[i]ZgZXijh[Zbdg^hbjhXaZ!VÅZmdgd[i]Zi]^\]Vii]Z]^e!VcYVcZmiZchdgd[i]Z `cZZ#>ihadlZgZmiZcihZgkZhVhi]ZViiVX]bZcih^iZ[dgi]Z^a^d[ZbdgVaa^\VbZci# b# I]Z`_cdUbY_bce`UbY_bY\YQSc`Y^U^hi]ZedhiZg^dgiZgb^cjhd[i]Z^a^VXXgZhi#>i ^hVcViiVX]bZci[dgeVgid[i]Z\ajiZjhbVm^bjhbjhXaZ!VcZmiZchdg!aViZgVagdiVidg! VcYVWYjXidgd[i]Z[ZbjgVii]Z]^e# c# I]Z`_cdUbY_bY^VUbY_bY\YQSc`Y^U^hVh]Vgeegd_ZXi^dc_jhiedhiZgd^c[Zg^dgid i]ZVjg^XjaVghjg[VXZ#>ieVgi^VaanVcX]dghi]ZhVXgdijWZgjha^\VbZci!l]^X]hZgkZhid W^cYi]ZhVXgjbidi]ZdhXdmVZ# d# I]ZWbUQdUbcSYQdYS^_dSX^hi]Zl^YZcdiX]_jhi^c[Zg^dgidi]ZedhiZg^dg^c[Zg^dg ^a^VXhe^cZ#I]Ze^g^[dgb^hbjhXaZ!VaViZgVagdiVidgd[i]Zi]^\]Vii]Z]^e!VcYi]Z cZgkZhaZVk^c\i]ZeZak^h[dgi]ZadlZga^bWeVhhi]gdj\]i]^hcdiX]#8dgi^XVa WdcZ^ci]ZdhXdmVZ^hi]^X`Zhi^ci]^hVgZV# e# I]ZYcSXYQ\c`Y^U[dgViiVX]bZcid[i]ZhVXgdhe^cdjha^\VbZci^hadXViZY_jhi^c[Z" g^dgidi]Z\gZViZghX^Vi^XcdiX]# f# I]Z\UccUbcSYQdYS^_dSX^hi]ZcdiX]WZilZZci]Z^hX]^Vahe^cZhjeZg^dganVcY i]ZgZhid[i]Z^hX]^jb^c[Zg^dgan#I]ZdWijgVidg^ciZgcjhbjhXaZ!VaViZgVagdiVidg VcYhdbZi^bZhVWYjXidgd[i]Z[ZbjgVii]Z]^e!eVhhZhi]gdj\]i]^hcdiX]#  g# I]ZYcSXYQ\deRUb_cYdi^hi]ZWajci!gdj\]!bVhh^kZedhiZgd^c[Zg^dgXdgcZgd[i]Z dhXdmVZ#>iVcX]dghi]ZZmiZchdgbjhXaZhd[i]Zi]^\]Vii]Z]^e!^cXajY^c\i]Z hZb^iZcY^cdhjh!hZb^bZbWgVcdhjh!W^XZeh[Zbdg^hadc\]ZVY!VcYfjVYgVijh[Zbdg^h#  h# I]ZQebYSe\QbcebVQSU^hi]ZZVg"h]VeZYhVXgVaVgi^XjaVi^dcdci]ZbZY^Vahjg[VXZ d[i]Z^a^jb#  i# I]ZY\YQSdeRUb_cYdi^hi]Zgdj\]ZcZYhjg[VXZ_jhiedhiZgdhjeZg^dgidi]ZVjg^Xj" aVghjg[VXZ#>i^hi]ZViiVX]bZcih^iZ[dghVXgd^a^VXa^\VbZcih# j# I]Z`bUQebYSe\Qbce\Sec^hVkVg^VWaZ\gddkZVadc\i]ZVciZgd^c[Zg^dgZY\Zd[i]Z Vjg^XjaVghjg[VXZ# k# I]ZY\YQSV_ccQ^hi]Zhbddi]]daadldci]ZbZY^Vahjg[VXZd[i]Z^a^VXWaVYZ# l# I]ZQbSeQdU\Y^U^hVcZaZkVi^dci]VihlZZehVciZgd^c[Zg^dganVXgdhhi]ZbZY^Va hjg[VXZd[i]ZdhXdmVZ[gdbi]ZVeZmd[i]ZVjg^XjaVghjg[VXZidlVgYi]ZejW^h# m# I]ZY\Y_`eRYSY\Y_`USdY^UQ\U]Y^U^SUbVg`hi]Zed^cid[jc^dcd[i]Z^a^jb VcYi]ZejW^h_jhiaViZgVaidi]ZVgXjViZa^cZ# n# I]ZY\Y_`eRYSce`UbY_b`eRYSbQ]ecXdccZXihi]ZejW^hidi]Z^a^jbVii]Z VXZiVWjajb# o# I]ZYcSXY_`eRYSY^VUbY_b`eRYSbQ]ec^hi]Zi]^c!ÅVihig^ed[WdcZXdccZXi^c\ i]ZejW^hidi]Z^hX]^jb# VV# I]Z`eRYSci]`XicYc^hi]ZcZVg"b^Ya^cZhjg[VXZd[i]ZejW^hl]ZgZi]Zild dhhVXdmVbdhiXadhZanVeegdVX]#>ca^[Z^i^hcZVgandXXajYZYWni]ZdWijgVidgbZb" WgVcZ# WW#I]Z_RdebQd_bV_bQ]U^^hi]ZaVg\Z[dgVbZcZcX^gXaZYWni]ZildejW^XgVb^ VcYi]Z^hX]^jb#>ca^[Z^i^hbdhianXadhZYWnVbZbWgVcZVXgdhh^i# XX# I]Z_RdebQd_bWb__fUce\Sec^hi]Zl^YZ\gddkZdci]ZbZY^Vahjg[VXZd[i]Z

ILIACPILLAR

ILIACCREST ILIACCRISTAL TUBERCLE

ANTERIOR GLUTEAL LINE POSTERIOR GLUTEAL LINE

INFERIOR GLUTEAL LINE

LUNATE SURFACE ACETABULAR FOSSA ORNOTCH

ILIOPUBIC SUPERIOR PUBIC RAMUS ISCHIAL TUBEROSITY

ISCHIOPUBIC INFERIORPUBIC RAMUS

&IGUREBYWXd_cS_hQU\QdUbQ\CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&)EZak^X<^gYaZ

ILIAC TUBEROSITY

POSTERIOR SUPERIOR ILIACSPINE

POSTERIOR INFERIOR ILIACSPINE GREATER SCIATIC NOTCH

PREAURICULAR SULCUS AURICULAR SURFACE OBTURATORGROOVE

ISCHIALSPINE LESSERSCIATIC NOTCH

PUBIC SYMPHYSIS &IGUREBYWXd_cS_hQU]UTYQ\CVijgVah^oZ#

&)#(Dh8dmVZ

').

0%,6)#')2$,%

OBTURATOR FORAMEN

ILIACFOSSA

ARCUATELINE

ILIOPUBIC ILIOPECTINEAL EMINENCE

&IGUREBYWXd_cS_hQUQ^dUb_ce`UbY_bfYUg6ciZg^dg^hYdlc#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&)EZak^X<^gYaZ

ILIUM

ANTERIORSUPERIOR ILIACSPINE

ANTERIOR INFERIOR ILIACSPINE

ACETABULUM

PUBIS

0%,6)#')2$,%

ISCHIUM

&IGUREBYWXd_cS_hQUQ^dUbY_bCVijgVah^oZ#

&)#(Dh8dmVZ

'*&

^a^dejW^XgVbjh!Vii]ZhjeZgdaViZgVaXdgcZgd[i]ZdWijgVidg[dgVbZc#I]ZdWijgV" idgkZhhZahVcYcZgkZeVhhi]gdj\]i]^h\gddkZ#

'ROWTH&IGURE I]ZgZVgZi]gZZeg^bVgnVcYÄkZhZXdcYVgnXZciZghd[dhh^ÄXVi^dc^cZVX]dhXdmVZ#I]Z ^a^jb!^hX]^jb!VcYejW^h[dgbi]Zeg^bVgnXZciZgh![jh^c\VgdjcYi]ZVXZiVWjajb# I]Z^a^jb]VhdcZhZXdcYVgnXZciZgVii]ZVciZg^dg^c[Zg^dghe^cZVcYdcZVXgdhhi]Z ^a^VXXgZhi#I]ZejW^h]VhdcZXZciZgVii]Zhnbe]nh^hi]Z¹kZcigVagVbeVgiº!VcYi]Z ^hX]^jb]VhdcZVii]ZijWZgdh^ini]ViZmiZcYhVadc\i]Z^c[Zg^dgejW^XgVbjh#I]Z Z^\]i]XZciZg¹dhXdinaZYdcº^hadXViZY^ci]ZYZei]d[i]ZVXZiVWjajb#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION  ™ ;gV\bZciVgn^a^VXWaVYZhb^\]iWZb^hiV`Zc[dgXgVc^VadghXVejaVg[gV\bZcih# I]ZXgVc^VaWdcZhVgZ!]dlZkZg!d[bdgZjc^[dgbi]^X`cZhh#I]Zn]VkZXdgi^XZhd[ VWdjiZfjVai]^X`cZhhVgdjcYi]ZY^ead…#  ™ HXVejaVgWaVYZhVgZi]^ccZgi]Vc^a^VXWaVYZhVcYY^heaVnhjWhXVejaVgg^Y\Zh#  ™ ;gV\bZciVgnVjg^XjaVgVgZVhXdjaYWZb^hiV`Zc[dghVXgV!Wji^ci]ZaViiZgWdcZ i]ZgZVgZViiVX]ZYVaVZ!VcYi]ZVY_VXZcihjg[VXZh]VkZcdZk^YZcXZd[hVXgd^a^VX gdj\]Zc^c\dghX^Vi^XcdiX]Zh#

3IDING L]Zc^ciVXi!i]ZdhXdmVZ^hZVh^anh^YZYWZXVjhZi]ZejW^h^hVciZg^dg!i]Z^a^VXXgZhi ^hhjeZg^dg!VcYi]ZVXZiVWjajb^haViZgVa#L]Zc[gV\bZciVgn!kVg^djheVgihd[i]Zdh XdmVZXVcWZh^YZYVh[daadlh/  ™ ;dg^hdaViZYejW^XgZ\^dch!i]ZkZcigVahjg[VXZ^hgdj\]!i]ZYdghVahjg[VXZ^h hbddi]VcYXdckZm!i]Zhnbe]nh^h[VXZhi]Zb^Ya^cZ!VcYi]ZhjeZg^dgejW^XgV" bjh^hbdgZgdWjhii]Vci]Z^c[Zg^dgejW^XgVbjh#  ™ ;dg^hdaViZY^hX]^VagZ\^dch!i]Zi]^X`ZggVbjh[VXZhi]ZVXZiVWjajb#I]Zi]^ccZg gVbjh^hi]ZgZ[dgZVciZgd^c[Zg^dg#I]Zhjg[VXZd[i]Z^hX]^VaijWZgdh^in[VXZhedh" iZgdaViZgVaan#  ™ ;dg^hdaViZY^a^VXWaVYZh!i]Z^a^VXe^aaVg^haViZgVaVcY^hVciZg^dganY^heaVXZY#I]Z Vjg^XjaVghjg[VXZVcYgZaViZYhigjXijgZhVgZedhiZg^dgVcYbZY^Va#  ™ ;dg^hdaViZY^a^VXXgZhih!i]Z^a^VXijWZgXaZ^hVciZg^dgVcYaViZgVa!VcYi]ZaViZgVa hjg[VXZVciZg^dgid^i^hbdgZXdcXVkZi]Vci]Zhjg[VXZedhiZg^dgid^i#I]ZXgZhi hlZZehedhiZgdbZY^Vaan[gdbi]^hed^cijci^a^igZVX]Zhi]ZaZkZad[i]ZVciZg^dg ZY\Zd[i]ZVjg^XjaVghjg[VXZVcYijgchaViZgVaan#  ™ ;dg^hdaViZYVXZiVWjaV!i]ZVXZiVWjaVgcdiX]^h^c[Zg^dgVcY[VXZhha^\]ianVciZg^" dgan#I]Z^c[Zg^dgZcYd[i]Z¹XºbVYZWni]ZajcViZhjg[VXZ^hWgdVYZgVcYbdgZ Wajcii]Vci]ZhjeZg^dgZcY#I]Z^hX]^VagVbjh^hedhiZg^dg!VcYi]ZhjeZg^dgej"



8]VeiZg&)EZak^X<^gYaZ

&IGURE?cS_hQUWb_gdXI]Zi]gZZZaZbZcihd[i]ZdhXdmVZ!h]dlc]ZgZ^caViZgVa k^Zl!VgZ[gdbVdcZ"nZVg"daYaZ[iVcYVh^m"nZVg"daYg^\]i#CVijgVah^oZ#

&)#(Dh8dmVZ

'*(

0%,6)#')2$,%

W^XgVbjh^hVciZg^dg#I]Z^a^jb^hhjeZg^dg#  ™ ;dg^hdaViZYVjg^XjaVghjg[VXZh!i]ZVjg^XjaVghjg[VXZ^hedhiZg^dgdci]Z^a^jb VcY[VXZhbZY^Vaan#>ihVeZmed^cihVciZg^dgan!VcYi]Zgdj\]ZcZYhjg[VXZ[dgi]Z hVXgd^a^VXa^\VbZcih^hedhiZgdhjeZg^dg#I]Z\gZViZgVcYaZhhZghX^Vi^XcdiX]ZhVgZ edhiZgd^c[Zg^dg#

This Page Intentionally Left Blank



8]VeiZg&)EZak^X<^gYaZ

#HAPTER

AZ\/;Zbjg!EViZaaV! I^W^V!;^WjaV I

]ZZkdaji^dcd[i]ZaZ\b^ggdghi]Vid[i]ZVgbVhYZhXg^WZY^c8]VeiZg&'# I]Zh^c\aZi]^\]WdcZ!i]ZVU]eb!^hi]ZhZg^Va]dbdad\d[i]ZjeeZgVgbWdcZ!i]Z ]jbZgjh#A^`Zl^hZ!i]ZadlZgWdcZhd[i]ZaZ\!i]ZdYRYQVcYÍRe\Q!VgZhZg^Va]dbdad\h d[i]ZgVY^jhVcYjacV#I]ZaVg\ZhihZhVbd^YWdcZ^ci]ZWdYn!i]Z`QdU\\Q!a^ZhVii]Z `cZZ_d^ci#I]ZW^eZYVaadXdbdidgbdYZegVXi^XZYWn]db^c^Yh]VhgZhjaiZY^cbV_dg heZX^Va^oVi^dchd[i]ZaZ\WdcZh#

&EMUR&IGURESn !NATOMY I]Z[Zbjg^hi]Zadc\Zhi!]ZVk^Zhi!VcYhigdc\ZhiWdcZ^ci]ZWdYn#>ihjeedgihVaad[i]Z WdYn¼hlZ^\]iYjg^c\hiVcY^c\!lVa`^c\!VcYgjcc^c\#7ZXVjhZd[^ihhigZc\i]VcYYZc" h^in!^i^h[gZfjZciangZXdkZgZY^c[dgZch^X!VgX]Zdad\^XVa!VcYeVaZdcidad\^XVaXdciZmih# I]Z[Zbjg^hVeVgi^XjaVgankVajVWaZWdcZWZXVjhZd[i]Z^c[dgbVi^dc^iXVcegdk^YZdc i]ZhiVijgZd[Vc^cY^k^YjVahZZ8]VeiZg&.# I]Z[ZbjgVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]ZVXZiVWjajbd[i]ZdhXdmVZ#9^hiVaan!^iVgi^XjaViZh l^i]i]ZeViZaaVVcYi]Zegdm^bVai^W^V#I]ZaZ\¼hVXi^dchVii]Z]^e^cXajYZbZY^VaVcY aViZgVagdiVi^dc!VWYjXi^dc!VYYjXi^dc!ÅZm^dc!VcYZmiZch^dc#6ii]Z`cZZ!bdi^dc^h [VgbdgZgZhig^XiZY!XdcÄcZYbdhianidÅZm^dcVcYZmiZch^dc#6ai]dj\]i]ZbV^c`cZZ VXi^dc^hi]Vid[Vha^Y^c\]^c\Z!i]^h_d^ci^hdcZd[i]ZbdhiXdbeaZm^ci]ZWdYn#

'**

,%'

V# I]ZXUQT^hi]ZgdjcYZYegdm^bVaeVgid[i]ZWdcZi]ViÄih^cidi]ZVXZiVWjajb# >iXdchi^ijiZhbdgZd[Vhe]ZgZi]Vci]Z]Zb^he]Zg^XVa]jbZgVa]ZVY# W# I]ZV_fUQSQ`YdYc^hi]ZhbVaa!cdcVgi^XjaVgYZegZhh^dccZVgi]ZXZciZgd[i]Z ]ZVYd[i]Z[Zbjg#>igZXZ^kZhi]Za^\VbZcijbiZgZh[gdbi]ZVXZiVWjaVgcdiX]d[i]Z dhXdmVZ# X# I]Z^US[d[i]Z[ZbjgXdccZXihi]Z]ZVYl^i]i]Zh]V[i# Y# I]ZWbUQdUbdb_SXQ^dUb^hi]ZaVg\Z!Wajci!cdcVgi^XjaVgegdb^cZcXZdci]ZaVi" ZgVa!egdm^bVaeVgid[i]Z[Zbjg#>i^hi]Z^chZgi^dch^iZ[dgi]Z\ajiZjhb^c^bjhVc"

 Z#

 [#

\#

]#

 ^#

 _#

`#

 a#

iZg^dgVheZXid[i]ZigdX]VciZgVcY\ajiZjhbZY^jhbjhXaZhedhiZg^dgVheZXi!Wdi] bV_dgVWYjXidghd[i]Zi]^\]VcYhiVW^a^oZghd[i]Z]^e#I]Z^gdg^\^chVgZdci]Z WgdVY!ÅVg^c\^a^VXWaVYZd[i]ZdhXdmVZ#I]ZhZbjhXaZhVgZXgjX^Va^chiVW^a^o^c\ i]Zigjc`l]ZcdcZaZ\^ha^[iZY[gdbi]Z\gdjcYYjg^c\W^eZYVaadXdbdi^dc# I]ZY^dUbdb_SXQ^dUbYS\Y^U^hVkVg^VWaZ![V^gankZgi^XVa!gdj\]ZcZYa^cZi]VieVhh" ZhWZilZZci]ZaZhhZgVcY\gZViZgigdX]VciZghdci]ZVciZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]ZWVhZd[ i]ZcZX`d[i]Z[Zbjg#HjeZg^dgan!i]^ha^cZVcX]dghi]Z^a^d[ZbdgVaa^\VbZci!l]^X] ^hi]ZaVg\Zhia^\VbZci^ci]Z]jbVc[gVbZ#>iVXihidhigZc\i]Zci]Z_d^ciXVehjaZd[ i]Z]^e# I]Zdb_SXQ^dUbYSV_ccQ^hi]Ze^iZmXVkViZY^cidi]ZedhiZgdbZY^ValVaad[i]Z \gZViZgigdX]VciZg#I]^he^i^h[dg^chZgi^dcd[i]ZiZcYdcd[dWijgVidgZmiZgcjh!V bjhXaZi]Vidg^\^cViZhVgdjcYVcYVXgdhhi]ZbZbWgVcZi]VihigZiX]ZhVXgdhhi]Z dWijgVidg[dgVbZcd[i]ZdhXdmVZ#I]^hbjhXaZVXihidgdiViZi]Zi]^\]aViZgVaanVi i]Z]^e#?jhiVWdkZ^ih^chZgi^dc!i]ZbZY^Vai^ed[i]Z\gZViZgigdX]VciZggZXZ^kZh hZkZgVa]^ebjhXaZh/i]ZhjeZg^dgVcY^c[Zg^dg\ZbZaa^!i]ZdWijgVidg^ciZgcjh!VcYi]Z e^g^[dgb^h#I]ZaViiZgildVgZ^bedgiVciVWYjXidgh!VcYVaad[i]ZhZbjhXaZhXVc gdiViZi]Z[ZbjgaViZgVaan# I]Z_RdebQd_bUhdUb^ecWb__fU^hVh]VaadlYZegZhh^dcVa^\cZYaViZgVaanVcY hjeZg^dganVXgdhhi]ZedhiZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]Z[ZbdgVacZX`#>c]db^c^Yh!ZgZXi edhijgZWg^c\hi]ZiZcYdcd[i]ZdWijgVidgZmiZgcjhbjhXaZ^cidXdciVXil^i]i]Zedh" iZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]Z[ZbdgVacZX`!XgZVi^c\i]Z\gddkZ# I]Z\UccUbdb_SXQ^dUb^hi]ZWajci!egdb^cZciijWZgXaZdci]ZedhiZg^dg[ZbdgVa hjg[VXZ_jhi^c[Zg^dgidi]Zed^cil]ZgZi]ZcZX`_d^chi]Zh]V[i#I]^h^hi]Zed^ci d[^chZgi^dcd[i]Z^a^dehdVhiZcYdci]ZXdbbdciZcYdcd[i]Z^a^VXjhbjhXaZ!dg^\^" cVi^c\^ci]Z^a^VX[dhhV!VcYi]ZehdVhbV_dgbjhXaZ!dg^\^cVi^c\[gdbi]ZajbWVg kZgiZWgVZVcYi]Z^gY^h`h#I]ZhZbjhXaZhVgZbV_dgÅZmdghd[i]Zi]^\]Vii]Z]^e# I]ZY^dUbdb_SXQ^dUbYSSbUcd^hi]ZZaZkViZYa^cZdci]ZedhiZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]Z egdm^bVa[ZbjgWZilZZci]Z\gZViZgVcYaZhhZgigdX]VciZgh#>ieVhhZh[gdbhjeZgd" aViZgVaid^c[ZgdbZY^Va#?jhiVWdkZ^ihb^Yed^ci^hVhbVaaijWZgXaZi]ZaeQTbQdU deRUbS\U!l]^X]^hi]Zh^iZd[^chZgi^dcd[i]ZfjVYgVijh[Zbdg^hbjhXaZ!VaViZgVa gdiVidgd[i]Z[Zbjg# I]ZW\edUQ\\Y^U!dgdeRUb_cYdi!^hVadc\!l^YZ!gdj\]ZcZY!edhiZgdaViZgVaaneaVXZY [ZVijgZi]ViZmiZcYh[gdbi]ZWVhZd[i]Z\gZViZgigdX]VciZgidi]Za^ed[i]Za^cZV VheZgVhZZaViZg#>iXVcWZVYZegZhh^dcdg^iXVcVhhjbZi]Z[dgbd[VigjZijWZg" dh^in#>[i]ZaViiZg^hegZhZci!^i^hd[iZcgZ[ZggZYidVhi]ZdXYbTdb_SXQ^dUb#>i^hi]Z ^chZgi^dc[dgeVgid[i]Z\ajiZjhbVm^bjhbjhXaZ!VcZmiZchdg!VWYjXidg!VcYaViZgVa gdiVidgd[i]Zi]^\]Vii]Z]^ei]Vidg^\^cViZhdci]ZedhiZg^dg]Va[d[i]ZdhXdmVZ! i]ZhVXgjb!VcYi]ZXdXXnm# I]Zc`YbQ\\Y^U!he^gVa^c\^c[Zg^dgidi]ZaZhhZgigdX]VciZg!XdccZXihi]Z^c[Zg^dg ZcYd[i]Z^ciZgigdX]VciZg^Xa^cZl^i]i]ZbZY^Vaa^ed[i]Za^cZVVheZgV#>i^hi]Z dg^\^cd[i]ZkVhijhbZY^Va^hbjhXaZ!VeVgid[i]ZfjVYg^XZeh[Zbdg^hbjhXaZ!V`cZZ ZmiZchdgi]Vi^chZgihdci]ZVciZg^dgi^W^Vk^Vi]ZeViZaaV# I]Z`USdY^UQ\\Y^U^hVh]dgi!XjgkZYa^cZi]VieVhhZh^c[ZgdaViZgVaan[gdbi]ZWVhZ d[i]ZaZhhZgigdX]VciZg!WZilZZci]Zhe^gVaa^cZVcY\ajiZVaijWZgdh^in#>i^hi]Z ^chZgi^dcd[i]ZeZXi^cZjhbjhXaZ!l]^X]dg^\^cViZh[gdbi]ZejW^XeVgid[i]Zdh XdmVZVcYVXihidVYYjXi!aViZgVaangdiViZ!VcYÅZmi]Zi]^\]Vii]Z]^e#



8]VeiZg&*AZ\/;Zbjg!EViZaaV!I^W^V!;^WjaV

&*#&;Zbjg

'*,

,%'

b# I]ZVU]_bQ\cXQVd^hi]Zadc\hZXi^dcWZilZZci]ZZmeVcYZYegdm^bVaVcYY^hiVa ZcYhd[i]ZWdcZ# c# I]Z\Y^UQQc`UbQ^hi]Zadc\!l^YZ!gdj\]ZcZY!VcYZaZkViZYg^Y\Zi]VigjchVadc\ i]ZedhiZg^dgh]V[ihjg[VXZ#>iXdaaZXihi]Zhe^gVa!eZXi^cZVa!VcY\ajiZVaa^cZhegdm^" bVaanVcYY^k^YZh^cidi]ZhjegVXdcYnad^Yg^Y\ZhY^hiVaan#I]Za^cZVVheZgV^hV eg^bVgndg^\^ch^iZ[dgi]ZkVhijhbjhXaZhVcYi]Zeg^bVgn^chZgi^dch^iZd[i]ZVY" YjXidghadc\^h!WgZk^h!VcYbV\cjhd[i]Z]^e# d# I]Z^edbYU^dV_bQ]U^^hadXViZYVWdjib^Yh]V[iaZkZadci]ZedhiZg^dghjg[VXZd[ i]ZWdcZ!VY_VXZciiddgdci]Za^cZVVheZgV#I]^h[dgVbZcZm^ihi]ZWdcZY^hiVaan# e# I]Z]UTYQ\ce`bQS_^Ti\Qb\Y^UbYTWU^hi]Z^c[Zg^dg!bZY^VaZmiZch^dcd[i]Z a^cZVVheZgV!bVg`^c\i]ZY^hiVa!bZY^VaXdgcZgd[i]Zh]V[i#>i^h[V^ciZgi]Vci]Z aViZgVahjegVXdcYnaVgg^Y\Z# f# I]Z\QdUbQ\ce`bQS_^Ti\Qb\Y^UbYTWU^hi]Z^c[Zg^dgY^hiVa!aViZgVaZmiZch^dcd[ i]Za^cZVVheZgV#>i^hbdgZegdcdjcXZYi]Vci]ZbZY^VahjegVXdcYnaVgg^Y\Z#  g# I]Z`_`\YdUQ\cebVQSU^hi]Zl^YZ!ÅVi!ig^Vc\jaVgVgZVd[i]ZedhiZg^dg!Y^hiVa [Zbjg#>i^hWdjcYZYWni]ZXdcYnaZh^c[Zg^dganVcYWni]ZhjegVXdcYnaVga^cZh bZY^VaanVcYaViZgVaan#  h# I]Z\QdUbQ\S_^Ti\U^hi]ZaVg\Z!egdigjY^c\!Vgi^XjaVg`cdWdci]ZaViZgVah^YZd[ i]ZY^hiVa[Zbjg#  i# I]Z\QdUbQ\U`YS_^Ti\U^hi]ZXdckZm^indci]ZaViZgVah^YZd[i]ZaViZgVaXdcYnaZ# >i^hVcViiVX]bZcied^ci[dgi]ZaViZgVaXdaaViZgVaa^\VbZcid[i]Z`cZZ#>ihjeeZg hjg[VXZWZVghV[VXZii]Vi^hVcViiVX]bZcied^ci[dgdcZ]ZVYd[i]Z\VhigdXcZb^jh bjhXaZ!VÅZmdgd[i]Z`cZZVcYeaVciVgÅZmdgd[i]Z[ddiVii]ZVc`aZ# j# I]Z`_`\YdUQ\Wb__fU!Vhbddi]]daadldci]ZedhiZgdaViZgVah^YZd[i]ZaViZgVa XdcYnaZ!^hV\gddkZ[dgi]ZiZcYdcd[i]Zedea^iZjhbjhXaZ#I]^hbjhXaZ^chZgihdci]Z edhiZg^dgi^W^Vahjg[VXZVcY^hVbZY^VagdiVidgd[i]Zi^W^VVii]Z`cZZ# k#I]Z]UTYQ\S_^Ti\U^hi]ZaVg\Z!Vgi^XjaVg`cdWdci]ZbZY^Vah^YZd[i]ZY^hiVa [Zbjg#>ihbZY^Vahjg[VXZWja\ZhVlVn[gdbi]ZVm^hd[i]Zh]V[i#I]ZbZY^VaXdc" YnaZZmiZcYhbdgZY^hiVaani]Vci]ZaViZgVaXdcYnaZ# l# I]Z]UTYQ\U`YS_^Ti\U^hi]ZXdckZm^indci]ZbZY^Vah^YZd[i]ZbZY^VaXdc" YnaZ#>i^hVed^cid[ViiVX]bZci[dgi]ZbZY^VaXdaaViZgVaa^\VbZcid[i]Z`cZZ# m# I]ZQTTeSd_bdeRUbS\U^hVkVg^VWaZ!gV^hZYijWZgXaZdci]ZbZY^VahjegVXdcYnaVg g^Y\Z_jhihjeZg^dgidi]ZbZY^VaZe^XdcYnaZ#>i^hVcViiVX]bZcied^ci[dgi]ZVY" YjXidgbV\cjh!VbjhXaZdg^\^cVi^c\dci]ZadlZgZY\Zd[i]Z^hX]^dejW^XgVbjh VcY^hX]^VaijWZgdh^in#I]^hbjhXaZVYYjXihi]Zi]^\]Vii]Z]^e# n# I]ZY^dUbS_^Ti\QbV_ccQ!dg^_dSX!^hi]ZcdcVgi^XjaVg!ZmXVkViZYhjg[VXZWZilZZc i]ZY^hiVaVcYedhiZg^dgVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZhd[i]ZXdcYnaZh#L^i]^ci]Z[dhhVVgZ ild[VXZihi]ViVgZi]Z[ZbdgVaViiVX]bZcih^iZhd[i]ZVciZg^dgVcYedhiZg^dgXgjX^" ViZa^\VbZcih!VeV^gd[XgdhhZYa^\VbZciha^c`^c\i]Z[ZbjgVcYi^W^V#I]ZhZa^\V" bZcihhigZc\i]Zci]Z`cZZ_d^ci# o# I]Z`QdU\\QbcebVQSU^hVcdiX]ZY!Vgi^XjaVgVgZVdci]ZVciZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]Z Y^hiVa[Zbjg!dkZgl]^X]i]ZeViZaaV\a^YZhYjg^c\ÅZm^dcVcYZmiZch^dcd[i]Z `cZZ#I]ZaViZgVahjg[VXZd[i]^hcdiX]^hZaZkViZY!egd_ZXi^c\bdgZVciZg^dgani]Vc i]ZbZY^VaWdjcYVgnd[i]ZcdiX]#I]^h]ZaehegZkZciaViZgVaY^hadXVi^dcd[i]Z eViZaaVYjg^c\[jaaZmiZch^dcd[i]Z`cZZ#

HEAD

NECK INTERTROCHANTERICLINE

&IGUREABYWXdVU]ebQ^dUbY_b6WdkZ!egdm^bVaZcY0deedh^iZ!Y^hiVa ZcY0b^YYaZ!b^Y"h]V[i#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&*AZ\/;Zbjg!EViZaaV!I^W^V!;^WjaV

,%'

&IGUREB

&*#&;Zbjg

'*.

GREATER TROCHANTER

OBTURATOREXTERNUS GROOVE INTERTROCHANTERICCREST

LESSERTROCHANTER

PECTINEALLINE

GLUTEALLINEORTUBEROSITY

NUTRIENTFORAMEN

LINEAASPERA

&IGUREABYWXdVU]eb`_cdUbY_b6WdkZ!egdm^bVaZcY0deedh^iZ!Y^hiVa ZcY0b^YYaZ!b^Y"h]V[i#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&*AZ\/;Zbjg!EViZaaV!I^W^V!;^WjaV

NUTRIENT FORAMEN

MEDIAL SUPRACONDYLAR LINERIDGE

LATERAL SUPRACONDYLAR LINERIDGE

POPLITEAL SURFACE

,%'

&IGUREB

&*#&;Zbjg

'+&

FOVEACAPITIS

TROCHANTERIC FOSSA QUADRATE TUBERCLE

SPIRALLINE

&IGUREABYWXdVU]eb]UTYQ\6WdkZ!egdm^bVaZcY0deedh^iZ!Y^hiVa ZcY0b^YYaZ!b^Y"h]V[i#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&*AZ\/;Zbjg!EViZaaV!I^W^V!;^WjaV

ADDUCTOR TUBERCLE MEDIAL EPICONDYLE

,%'

&IGUREB

&*#&;Zbjg

'+(

&IGUREABYWXdVU]eb\QdUbQ\6WdkZ!egdm^bVaZcY0deedh^iZ!Y^hiVaZcY0 b^YYaZ!b^Y"h]V[i#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&*AZ\/;Zbjg!EViZaaV!I^W^V!;^WjaV

LATERAL EPICONDYLE POPLITEAL GROOVE

,%'

&IGUREB

&*#&;Zbjg

'+*

&IGUREBYWXdVU]eb`b_hY]Q\#EdhiZg^dg^hje!aViZgVa^hidlVgYi]ZaZ[i#CVijgVah^oZ#

PATELLARSURFACE

LATERAL CONDYLE

MEDIAL CONDYLE

INTERCONDYLARFOSSA ORNOTCH &IGUREBYWXdVU]ebTYcdQ\6ciZg^dg^hje!aViZgVa^hidlVgYi]ZaZ[i#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&*AZ\/;Zbjg!EViZaaV!I^W^V!;^WjaV

'ROWTH&IGURE I]Z[Zbjgdhh^ÄZh[gdbÄkZXZciZgh/dcZ[dgi]Zh]V[i!dcZ[dgi]Z]ZVY!dcZ[dgi]Z Y^hiVaZcY!VcYdcZ[dgZVX]igdX]VciZg#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION CZ^i]Zg ^ciVXi [ZbdgV cdg [ZbdgVa [gV\bZcih VgZ ZVh^an Xdc[jhZY l^i] di]Zg WdcZh#  ™ I]Z[ZbdgVa]ZVY]VhV[dkZVVcY^hVbdgZXdbeaZiZhe]ZgZi]Vci]Z]jbZgVa ]ZVY#  ™ I]Z[ZbdgVah]V[i^haVg\Zg!]VhVi]^X`ZgXdgiZm!VcY^hgdjcYZg^cXgdhhhZXi^dc i]VcVcndi]Zgh]V[i#>i]VhdcandcZh]VgeXdgcZg!i]Za^cZVVheZgV#

3IDING  ™ ;dg^ciVXi[ZbdgVdgegdm^bVaZcYh!i]Z]ZVY^hegdm^bVaVcY[VXZhbZY^Vaan#I]Z aZhhZgigdX]VciZgVcYa^cZVVheZgVVgZedhiZg^dg#  ™ ;dg^hdaViZY[ZbdgVa]ZVYh!i]Z[dkZV^hbZY^VaVcYY^heaVXZYedhiZg^dganVcY^c[Z" g^dgan#I]ZedhiZgd^c[Zg^dg]ZVY·cZX`_jcXi^dc^hbdgZYZZeanZmXVkViZYi]Vci]Z VciZgdhjeZg^dg_jcXi^dc#  ™ ;dgegdm^bVa[ZbdgVah]V[ih!i]Zcjig^Zci[dgVbZcdeZchY^hiVaan!VcYi]Za^cZV VheZgV^hedhiZg^dgVcYi]^ch^c[Zg^dgan#I]Z\ajiZVaijWZgdh^in^hhjeZg^dgVcY [VXZhedhiZgdaViZgVaan#  ™ ;dg[ZbdgVab^Yh]V[ih!i]Zcjig^Zci[dgVbZcdeZchY^hiVaan!i]ZWdcZl^YZch Y^hiVaan!VcYi]ZaViZgVaedhiZg^dghjg[VXZ^hjhjVaanbdgZXdcXVkZi]Vci]ZbZY^Va edhiZg^dghjg[VXZ#  ™ ;dgY^hiVa[ZbdgVah]V[ih!i]Zh]V[il^YZchY^hiVaanVcYi]ZaViZgVahjegVXdcYnaVg g^Y\Z^hbdgZegdb^cZcii]Vci]ZbZY^Va#I]ZbZY^VaXdcYnaZZmiZcYhbdgZY^h" iVaani]Vci]ZaViZgVa#  ™ ;dg[ZbdgVaY^hiVaZcYh!i]Z^ciZgXdcYnaVgcdiX]^hedhiZg^dgVcYY^hiVa!VcYi]Z aViZgVaWdgYZgd[i]ZeViZaaVgcdiX]^hbdgZZaZkViZY#I]ZaViZgVaXdcYnaZWZVghi]Z edea^iZVa\gddkZ!VcYi]ZbZY^VaXdcYnaZWja\ZhVlVn[gdbi]Za^cZd[i]Zh]V[i# GZaVi^kZidi]Zh]V[iVm^h!i]ZaViZgVaXdcYnaZZmiZcYhbdgZedhiZg^dgani]Vci]Z bZY^Va#I]ZbZY^VaXdcYnaZZmiZcYhbdgZY^hiVaani]Vci]ZaViZgVaWZXVjhZ^cVcV" idb^XVaedh^i^dci]Z[ZbjgVc\aZhWZcZVi]i]ZWdYn#

,%'

&*#&;Zbjg

'+,

&IGURE6U]_bQ\dYRYQ\Q^TÍRe\QbWb_gdXI]ZeV^ghd[^bbVijgZ[ZbdgVide!i^W^VZ b^YYaZ!VcYÄWjaVZWdiidb!h]dlc]ZgZ^cedhiZg^dgk^Zl!VgZ[gdbVdcZ"nZVgdaYVcYVh^m" nZVg"daY#9^hiVaZcYhVgZidi]ZaZ[i#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&*AZ\/;Zbjg!EViZaaV!I^W^V!;^WjaV

,%'

&*#&;Zbjg

'+.

MEDIAL ARTICULAR FACET

APEX &IGUREBYWXd`QdU\\QQ^dUbY_b HjeZg^dg^hje0aViZgVa^hidlVgYi]ZaZ[i# CVijgVah^oZ#

LATERAL ARTICULAR FACET

&IGUREBYWXd`QdU\\Q`_cdUbY_b HjeZg^dg^hje0aViZgVa^hidlVgYi]Zg^\]i# CVijgVah^oZ#

0ATELLA&IGURESn !NATOMY I]ZeViZaaV!i]ZaVg\ZhihZhVbd^YWdcZ^ci]ZWdYn!Vgi^XjaViZhdcanl^i]i]ZeViZaaVg hjg[VXZd[i]ZY^hiVa[ZbjgeViZaaVgcdiX]#I]ZeViZaaVg^YZh^ci]ZiZcYdcd[i]ZfjVYg^" XZeh[Zbdg^h¸i]ZaVg\ZhibjhXaZd[i]Zi]^\]VcYi]Zeg^bVgnZmiZchdgd[i]Z`cZZ#I]Z eViZaaV[jcXi^dchidegdiZXii]Z`cZZ_d^ci!idaZc\i]Zci]ZaZkZgVgbd[i]ZfjVYg^XZeh! VcYid^cXgZVhZi]ZVgZVd[XdciVXiWZilZZci]ZeViZaaVga^\VbZciVcYi]Z[Zbjg# V# I]ZQ`Uhd[i]ZeViZaaV^hi]ZcdcVgi^XjaVged^cidci]ZWdcZ#>ied^cihY^hiVaan# W# I]Z\QdUbQ\QbdYSe\QbVQSUd[dgi]ZY^hiVa[Zbjg[VXZhedhiZg^dganVcY^hi]ZaVg\" ZhieVgid[i]ZaVg\ZVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZd[i]ZeViZaaV# X# I]Z]UTYQ\QbdYSe\QbVQSUd[dgi]ZY^hiVa[Zbjg[VXZhedhiZg^dganVcY^hhbVaaZg i]Vci]ZaViZgVaVgi^XjaVg[VXZi#

'ROWTH I]ZeViZaaVdhh^ÄZh[gdbVh^c\aZXZciZg#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION I]^hWdcZb^\]iWZb^hiV`Zc[dgVcdhXdmVZ[gV\bZci!Wjidcan^cVkZgn[gV\bZciVgn hiViZ#I]ZVXZiVWjajbd[i]ZdhXdmVZ^hhigdc\an]daadlZY!VhdeedhZYidi]ZbjX] ÅViiZgVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZd[i]ZeViZaaV# 

8]VeiZg&*AZ\/;Zbjg!EViZaaV!I^W^V!;^WjaV

3IDING  ™ 1^Qd_]YSQ\cYTY^W#I]ZeViZaaV^hig^Vc\jaVg^ch]VeZ#>ihi]^c!ed^ciZYVeZm^h Y^hiVa!VcYi]Zi]^X`Zg!WajciZgZcY^hegdm^bVa#I]ZaViZgVaVgi^XjaVg[VXZi!l]^X] Vgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]ZaViZgVaXdcYnaZd[i]Z[Zbjg!^hi]ZaVg\Zgd[i]Zild[VXZih#  ™ @_cYdY_^Q\cYTY^W#EaVXZi]ZVeZmVlVn[gdbndjVcYi]ZVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZdci]Z iVWaZ#I]ZWdcZ[VaahidlVgYi]Zh^YZ[gdbl]^X]^iXdbZh#

4IBIA&IGURESn !NATOMY I]Zi^W^V^hi]ZbV_dglZ^\]i"WZVg^c\WdcZd[i]ZadlZgaZ\#>iVgi^XjaViZhegdm^bVaan l^i]i]ZY^hiVa[Zbjg!il^XZaViZgVaanl^i]i]ZÄWjaVdcXZegdm^bVaanVcYdcXZY^h" iVaan!VcYY^hiVaanl^i]i]ZiVajh#

&*#(I^W^V

',&

,%'

V# I]ZdYRYQ\`\QdUQe^hi]Zegdm^bVai^W^Vahjg[VXZdcl]^X]i]Z[ZbjggZhih#>i^h Y^k^YZY^cidildVgi^XjaVghZXi^dch!dcZ[dgZVX][ZbdgVaXdcYnaZ#>ca^[Zi]ZgZVgZ ÄWgdXVgi^aV\Zcdjhg^c\hVgdjcYi]ZeZg^e]Zgnd[i]ZhZVgi^XjaVg[VXZih!i]ZbZY^Va VcYaViZgVabZc^hX^# W# I]Z]UTYQ\S_^Ti\U^hi]ZbZY^VaeVgid[i]Zi^W^VaeaViZVj#>ih[ZbdgVaVgi^Xj" aVi^dc^hdkVa!l^i]i]Zadc\Vm^hdg^ZciZYVciZgdedhiZg^dgan#>ihaViZgVaZY\Z^h higV^\]i# X# I]Z\QdUbQ\S_^Ti\U^hi]ZaViZgVaeVgid[i]Zi^W^VaeaViZVj#>ih[ZbdgVaVgi^XjaV" i^dc^hhbVaaZgVcYgdjcYZgi]Vci]ZbZY^VaVgi^XjaVi^dc# Y# I]ZY^dUbS_^Ti\QbU]Y^U^SU^hi]ZgV^hZYVgZVdci]Zegdm^bVai^W^Vahjg[VXZ WZilZZcVgi^XjaVg[VXZih#  Z# I]Z]UTYQ\Y^dUbS_^Ti\QbdeRUbS\U[dgbhi]ZbZY^VaeVgid[i]Z^ciZgXdcYnaVg Zb^cZcXZ#  [# I]Z\QdUbQ\Y^dUbS_^Ti\QbdeRUbS\U[dgbhi]ZaViZgVaeVgid[i]Z^ciZgXdcYnaVg Zb^cZcXZ#I]ZVciZg^dgVcYedhiZg^dgXgjX^ViZa^\VbZcihVcYi]ZVciZg^dgVcYedh" iZg^dgZmigZb^i^Zhd[i]ZbZc^hX^^chZgi^cidi]ZcdcVgi^XjaVgVgZVhWZilZZci]Z XdcYnaZh!l]^X]VgZ_jhiVciZg^dgVcYedhiZg^dgidi]ZbZY^VaVcYaViZgVa^ciZgXdc" YnaVgijWZgXaZh!gZheZXi^kZan# \# I]Zce`UbY_bÍRe\QbQbdYSe\QbVQSUd^hadXViZYdci]ZedhiZgd^c[Zg^dgZY\Zd[i]Z aViZgVaXdcYnaZ# ]# I]ZdYRYQ\deRUb_cYdi^hi]Zgj\dhZVgZVdci]ZVciZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]Zegdm^bVa i^W^V#>ihhjeZg^dgeVgi^hhbddi]ZhiVcYl^YZhi#I]ZeViZaaVga^\VbZcid[i]ZfjVY" g^XZeh[Zbdg^hbjhXaZ!VbV_dgadlZgaZ\ZmiZchdgVii]Z`cZZ!^chZgih]ZgZ#  ^# I]Zi^W^VacXQVd^hi]Z[V^ganhigV^\]ihZ\bZcid[i]Zi^W^VWZilZZci]ZZmeVcYZY egdm^bVaVcYY^hiVaZcYh#  _# I]Zc_\UQ\`_`\YdUQ\\Y^UXgdhhZhi]Zegdm^bVa]Va[d[i]ZedhiZg^dgi^W^Vahjg" [VXZ[gdbhjeZgdaViZgVaid^c[ZgdbZY^Va#I]Za^cZYZbVgXViZhi]Z^c[Zg^dgWdjcY" Vgnd[i]Zedea^iZjhbjhXaZ^chZgi^dc#I]^hbjhXaZ^hVÅZmdgVcYbZY^VagdiVidgd[ i]Zi^W^VVcYdg^\^cViZh[gdbi]Zedea^iZVa\gddkZdci]ZaViZgVa[ZbdgVaXdcYnaZ# I]Za^cZ^ihZa[\^kZhg^hZidi]Zedea^iZjh[VhX^VVcYhdaZjhbjhXaZ!VeaVciVgÅZmdgd[

LATERALINTERCONDYLARTUBERCLE

MEDIALINTERCONDYLARTUBERCLE

TIBIALTUBEROSITY

ANTERIORSURFACE ANTERIORCREST

MEDIALSURFACE

&IGUREABYWXddYRYQQ^dUbY_b6WdkZ!egdm^bVaZcY0deedh^iZ!Y^hiVaZcY#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&*AZ\/;Zbjg!EViZaaV!I^W^V!;^WjaV

,%'

MEDIALMALLEOLUS &IGUREB

&*#(I^W^V

',(

TIBIALPLATEAU

SOLEALPOPLITEAL LINE

NUTRIENTFORAMEN

&IGUREABYWXddYRYQ`_cdUbY_b6WdkZ!egdm^bVaZcY0deedh^iZ!Y^hiVaZcY#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&*AZ\/;Zbjg!EViZaaV!I^W^V!;^WjaV

,%'

MALLEOLARGROOVE &IGUREB

&*#(I^W^V

',*

&IGUREBYWXddYRYQ]UTYQ\#AZ[i!egdm^bVaZcY0g^\]i!Y^hiVaZcY#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&*AZ\/;Zbjg!EViZaaV!I^W^V!;^WjaV

INTERCONDYLAREMINENCE

SUPERIOR lBULAR ARTICULAR FACET

INTEROSSEOUS CREST

lBULAR NOTCH

INTEROSSEOUSSURFACE

,%'

INFERIORlBULARARTICULARSURFACE &IGUREBYWXddYRYQ\QdUbQ\AZ[i!Y^hiVaZcY0g^\]i!egdm^bVaZcY#CVijgVah^oZ#

&*#(I^W^V

',,

LATERAL CONDYLE

MEDIAL CONDYLE

LATERALINTERCONDYLARTUBERCLE MEDIALINTERCONDYLARTUBERCLE

&IGUREBYWXddYRYQ`b_hY]Q\6ciZg^dg^hje!aViZgVa^hidlVgYi]Zg^\]i#CVijgVah^oZ#

&IGUREBYWXddYRYQTYcdQ\ 6ciZg^dg^hje!aViZgVa^hidlVgYi]ZaZ[i# CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&*AZ\/;Zbjg!EViZaaV!I^W^V!;^WjaV

i]Z[ddiVii]ZVc`aZ# `# I]Z^edbYU^dV_bQ]U^^h_jhi^c[ZgdaViZgVaidi]Zedea^iZVaa^cZ#>i^hVaVg\Z[dgV" bZci]ViZm^ihi]ZWdcZegdm^bVaan#  a# I]ZQ^dUbY_bcebVQSUQ^dUbY_bSbUcdd[i]Zh]V[i[dgbhi]ZVciZg^dgZY\Zd[i]Z ¹h]^c#º b# I]Z]UTYQ\cebVQSUd[i]Zh]V[i[dgbhi]ZbZY^VaZY\Zd[i]Z¹h]^cºd[i]ZadlZg aZ\#I]^hhjWXjiVcZdjhWdgYZg^hi]Zl^YZhii^W^Vah]V[ihjg[VXZ# c# I]ZY^dUb_ccU_eccebVQSUd[i]Zh]V[i^haViZgVa!deedh^iZi]ZÄWjaV#>i^hi]Zbdhi XdcXVkZd[i]Zi]gZZi^W^Vahjg[VXZh# d# I]ZY^dUb_ccU_ecSbUcd^hi]ZaViZgVaXgZhid[i]Zh]V[i!l]^X][VXZhi]ZÄWjaV#>i^h i]ZViiVX]bZciVgZV[dgi]Z^ciZgdhhZdjhbZbWgVcZ!Vh]ZZid[i^hhjZi]Vi[jcXi^dch idW^cYi]Zi^W^VVcYÄWjaVid\Zi]ZgVcYidXdbeVgibZciVa^oZadlZgaZ\bjhXaZh ^cidVciZg^dgVcYedhiZg^dg\gdjeh!_jhiVh^ihhZg^Va]dbdad\YdZh^ci]Z[dgZVgb# e# I]Z]UTYQ\]Q\\U_\ec^hi]Zegd_ZXi^dcdci]ZbZY^Vah^YZd[i]ZY^hiVai^W^Vi]Vi [dgbhi]ZhjWXjiVcZdjhbZY^Va`cdWVii]ZVc`aZ#>ihaViZgVahjg[VXZ^hVgi^XjaVg! [dgi]ZiVaVgWdYn# f# I]ZÍRe\Qb^_dSX^hi]ZY^hidaViZgVaXdgcZgd[i]Zi^W^V#>i^hVig^Vc\jaVgcdcVg" i^XjaVgVgZV[dgi]Zi]^X`!h]dgi^ciZgdhhZdjhi^W^dÉWjaVga^\VbZci#I]^ha^\VbZci W^cYhi]ZY^hiVai^W^VVcYÄWjaVid\Zi]ZgVhVjc^iVii]^hhncYZhbdh^h#I]Zegdm^" bVaVc`aZ!dgdQ\_SbebQ\!_d^ci^h[dgbZYWni]Zi^\]ianWdjcYY^hiVai^W^VVcY ÄWjaV!l]^X]Vgi^XjaViZl^i]i]ZhjeZg^dg!bZY^Va!VcYaViZgVaiVaVghjg[VXZh#  g# I]ZY^VUbY_bÍRe\QbQbdYSe\QbcebVQSU^hVi]^cVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ[dgi]ZÄWjaV! l]^X][VXZhaViZgVaanVii]ZWVhZd[i]ZÄWjaVgcdiX]#  h# I]Z]Q\\U_\QbWb__fUdci]ZedhiZg^dgVheZXid[i]ZbZY^VabVaaZdajhigVchb^ih i]ZiZcYdchd[i]Zi^W^Va^hedhiZg^dgVcYÊZmdgY^\^idgjbadc\jhbjhXaZh!eaVciVgÅZmdgh#

'ROWTH&IGURE I]Zi^W^Vdhh^ÄZh[gdbi]gZZXZciZgh/dcZ[dgi]Zh]V[iVcYdcZ[dgZVX]ZcYd[i]ZWdcZ# HZeVgViZXZciZgh[dgi]Zi^W^VaijWZgdh^inhdbZi^bZhdXXjg#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION ™ I]Zig^Vc\jaVgi^W^VaXgdhhhZXi^dcY^[[ZgZci^ViZh[gV\bZcihd[i]^hWdcZ[gdbi]Z [Zbjgdgi]ZbjX]hbVaaZg]jbZgjh#I]Zi^W^Vah]V[i^hbjX]aVg\Zgi]VcgVY^Va dgjacVgh]V[ih# ™ Egdm^bVaVcYY^hiVaZcYhd[i]Zi^W^VVgZY^V\cdhi^X!VcYi]Zdcanedhh^W^a^ind[ Xdc[jh^dcVg^hZh^cb^hiV`^c\VhZ\bZcid[i]Zegdm^bVaVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ[dgi]Z WdYnd[VkZgiZWgV#I]ZVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZd[i]Zi^W^V^hbjX]YZchZgVcYhbddi]Zg i]Vci]ZVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZd[VkZgiZWgVaWdYn# ,%'

3IDING ™ ;dgVc^ciVXii^W^V!i]Zi^W^VaijWZgdh^in^hegdm^bVaVcYVciZg^dg#I]ZbZY^VabVa" &*#(I^W^V

',.

aZdajh^hdci]ZY^hiVaZcYVcY^hbZY^Va#  ™ ;dgi]Zegdm^bVai^W^V!i]Zi^W^VaijWZgdh^in^hVciZgdaViZgVa!i]ZÄWjaVgVgi^XjaV" i^dc^heaVXZYedhiZgdaViZgVaan!VcYi]ZaViZgVa[ZbdgVaVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ^hhbVaaZg! gdjcYZg!VcYhZiaViZgVaan#I]Z^ciZgXdcYnaVgZb^cZcXZ^hhZiedhiZg^dgan!VcYi]Z Vm^hd[i]ZcdcVgi^XjaVghig^edci]ZeaViZVjgjch[gdbVciZgdaViZgVaidedhiZgdbZ" Y^Va#I]^hhig^e^hl^YZgVciZg^dgani]VcedhiZg^dgan#I]Z^ciZgXdcYnaVgZb^cZcXZ ]VhVbdgZXdcXVkZbZY^VaWdgYZgVcYVbdgZZkZcanhade^c\aViZgVaWdgYZg#  ™ ;dg[gV\bZcihd[h]V[i!i]ZZci^gZh]V[iiVeZghY^hiVaan!VcYi]Z^ciZgdhhZdjhXgZhi ^haViZgVaVcYedhiZg^dg#I]ZbZY^Vahjg[VXZ^hi]Zl^YZhiVcY[VXZhVciZg^dgan#I]Z cjig^Zci[dgVbZc^hedhiZg^dgVcYZm^ihegdm^bVaan#I]ZXdgiZm^hi]^X`ZhiVib^Y" h]V[i#  ™ ;dgi]ZY^hiVaZcY!i]ZbVaaZdajh^hbZY^VaVcY^ihY^hiVa"bdhiegd_ZXi^dc^hVciZ" g^dg#
&IBULA&IGURESn !NATOMY I]ZÄWjaV^hVadc\!i]^cWdcZi]Via^ZhaViZgVaidi]Zi^W^V!Vgi^XjaVi^c\il^XZl^i]^i VcYdcXZl^i]i]ZiVajh#6ai]dj\]i]^hWdcZeaVnhdcanVc^cY^gZXigdaZ^ci]Z`cZZ _d^ci!hZgk^c\idVcX]dga^\VbZcih!^ieaVnhV`ZngdaZ^c[dgb^c\i]ZaViZgVaWdgYZgd[ i]ZVc`aZ_d^ci#I]ZÄWjaVWZVghkZgna^iiaZlZ^\]i!cdiZkZcidjX]^c\i]Z[ZbjgVi^ih hjeZg^dgZcY# V# I]ZXUQT^hi]ZhldaaZcegdm^bVaZcYd[i]ZÄWjaV!bdgZbVhh^kZVcYaZhhbZ" Y^daViZgVaanÅViiZcZYi]Vci]ZY^hiVaZcY#>i^hi]ZViiVX]bZcied^ci[dgi]ZW^XZeh [Zbdg^hbjhXaZVÅZmdgVcYaViZgVagdiVidgVii]Z`cZZVcYi]ZaViZgVaXdaaViZgVaa^\V" bZcid[i]Z`cZZ# W# I]Zcdi\_YT`b_SUcc^hi]Zbdhiegdm^bVaegd_ZXi^dcd[i]ZWdcZ![dgb^c\i]Z edhiZg^dgeVgid[i]Z]ZVY# X# I]Z`b_hY]Q\ÍRe\QbQbdYSe\QbcebVQSU^hVgdjcY!ÅVi!bZY^Vaandg^ZciZYhjg" [VXZi]ViXdggZhedcYhidVh^b^aVghjg[VXZdci]ZaViZgVaegdm^bVai^W^V# Y# I]ZÄWjaVgcXQVd^hi]Zadc\!i]^c![V^ganhigV^\]ihZ\bZcid[i]ZWdcZWZilZZci]Z ZmeVcYZYegdm^bVaVcYY^hiVaZcYh#  Z# I]ZY^dUb_ccU_ecSbUcd^hVcZaZkViZYXgZhii]VigjchYdlci]ZbZY^Va!ha^\]ian VciZg^dgan[VX^c\hjg[VXZd[i]Zh]V[i#6iiVX]ZYid^i^hi]Z^ciZgdhhZdjhbZbWgVcZ!V ÄWgdjhh]ZZii]ViW^cYhi]ZÄWjaVVcYi^W^VVcYY^k^YZhi]ZadlZgaZ\bjhXjaVijgZ ^cidVciZg^dgVcYedhiZg^dgXdbeVgibZcih#  [# I]Z^edbYU^dV_bQ]U^deZchegdm^bVaandci]ZedhiZgdbZY^Vahjg[VXZ!ViVWdji b^Yh]V[iaZkZa#I]ZXgdhhhZXi^dcd[i]ZÄWjaVgh]V[iXVcWZZmigZbZankVg^VWaZ^c i]^hgZ\^dc# \# I]Z\QdUbQ\]Q\\U_\ec^hi]Z^c[Zg^dgbdhiY^hiVabdhiegd_ZXi^dcd[i]ZÄWjaV# >ihaViZgVa!cdcVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ^hhjWXjiVcZdjh![dgb^c\i]ZaViZgVa`cdWd[i]Z 

8]VeiZg&*AZ\/;Zbjg!EViZaaV!I^W^V!;^WjaV

Vc`aZ# ]# I]Z]Q\\U_\QbTYcdQ\QbdYSe\QbcebVQSU^hVÅVi!bZY^Vaan[VX^c\!ig^Vc\jaVghjg" [VXZl]dhZVeZm[VXZh^c[Zg^dgan#I]Zhjg[VXZVgi^XjaViZhl^i]i]ZaViZgVahjg[VXZd[ i]ZiVajh#  ^# I]Z]Q\\U_\QbV_ccQ^hadXViZY_jhiedhiZg^dgidi]ZY^hiVaVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ#>i^h i]ZViiVX]bZcih^iZd[i]ZigVchkZghZi^W^dÉWjaVgVcYedhiZg^dgiVadÉWjaVga^\VbZcih! l]^X]higZc\i]Zci]ZVc`aZ_d^ci#  _# I]ZÍRe\Qb`Ub_^UQ\Wb__fU![dgiZcYdchd[i]ZÉWjaVg^heZgdcZjhadc\jhVcYÉWj" aVg^heZgdcZjhWgZk^hbjhXaZh!bVg`hi]ZedhiZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]ZY^hiVaÄWjaV#I]ZhZ bjhXaZheaVciVgÅZmVcYZkZgii]Z[ddiVii]ZVc`aZ!dg^\^cVi^c\^ci]ZaZ\VcY^c" hZgi^c\Vii]ZWVhZhd[i]ZÄghiadc\jhVcYÄ[i]WgZk^hbZiViVghVah#

'ROWTH&IGURE I]ZÄWjaV!a^`Zi]Zi^W^V!dhh^ÄZh[gdbi]gZZXZciZgh/dcZ[dgi]Zh]V[iVcYdcZ[dgZVX] ZcY#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION I]Zegdm^bVaVcYY^hiVaÄWjaVgZcYhVgZY^hi^cXi^kZVcYVgZgVgZanXdc[jhZYl^i]di]Zg WdcZh#  ™ I]ZY^hiVaZcY^hÅViiZcZYVadc\i]ZeaVcZd[i]ZVgi^XjaVg[VXZi!l]ZgZVhi]Zegdm" ^bVaZcYd[i]ZÄ[i]bZiViVghVa![dgl]^X]VY^hiVaÄWjaVgZcYb^\]iWZb^hiV`Zc! ]Vhild[VXZihVcY^hÅViiZcZYeZgeZcY^XjaVgidi]ZeaVcZhd[ZVX]#  ™ ;^WjaVgh]V[ihVgZi]^c!higV^\]i!VcYjhjVaanfjVYg^aViZgVahdbZi^bZhig^Vc\jaVg! l^i]h]VgeXgZhihVcYXdgcZgh#I]jh!i]ZnVgZi]jhbdgZ^ggZ\jaVg^cXgdhhhZXi^dc i]VcZ^i]ZggVY^VadgjacVgh]V[ih#

3IDING

&*#);^WjaV

'-&

,%'

 ™ ;dgVc^ciVXiÄWjaV!i]ZVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZh[dgi]Zi^W^VVgZbZY^Va!i]Z]ZVY^h egdm^bVa!i]ZÅViiZcZYZcY^hY^hiVa!VcYi]ZbVaaZdaVg[dhhV^hedhiZg^dg#  ™ ;dgi]Zegdm^bVaZcY!i]Zhinad^YegdXZhh^haViZgVa!egdm^bVa!VcYY^heaVXZYedh" iZg^dgan#I]ZVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ[VXZhbZY^VaanVcY^hVahdY^heaVXZYedhiZg^dgan#I]Z cZX`^hgdj\]ZhiaViZgVaan#  ™ ;dgi]Zh]V[i!ignidjhZ^ciVXiheZX^bZch[dgXdbeVg^hdc#I]Zcjig^Zci[dgVbZc deZchegdm^bVaan#I]Zh]VgeZhiXgZhidci]Zig^Vc\jaVgegdm^bVaZcY^hi]Z^c" iZgdhhZdjhXgZhi#I]^hZmeVcYhYdlch]V[iidVgdj\]!ÅViiZcZYhjg[VXZ#I]ZY^hiVa VheZXid[i]Zh]V[i^hbVg`ZYWnVa^cZY^kZg\^c\[gdbi]ZigZcYd[i]Z^ciZgdhhZ" djhXgZhi^ci]ZY^gZXi^dcd[i]Zh^YZ[gdbl]^X]i]ZWdcZXdbZh#  ™ ;dgi]ZY^hiVaZcY!i]ZbVaaZdaVg[dhhV^hValVnhedhiZg^dg!VcYi]ZVgi^XjaVg[VXZi^h ValVnhbZY^Va!l^i]^ihVeZmed^ciZY^c[Zg^dgan#

STYLOID PROCESS

INTEROSSEOUS CREST

&IGUREBYWXdÍRe\QQ^dUbY_bAZ[i!egdm^bVaZcY0g^\]i!Y^hiVaZcY#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&*AZ\/;Zbjg!EViZaaV!I^W^V!;^WjaV

lBULAR GROOVE

,%'

&IGUREBYWXdÍRe\Q`_cdUbY_bAZ[i!egdm^bVaZcY0g^\]i!Y^hiVaZcY#CVijgVah^oZ#

&*#);^WjaV

'-(

PROXIMAL lBULAR ARTICULAR SURFACE

MALLEOLAR DISTAL ARTICULAR SURFACE NUTRIENT FORAMEN

MALLEOLAR FOSSA

&IGUREBYWXdÍRe\Q]UTYQ\AZ[i!egdm^bVaZcY0g^\]i!Y^hiVaZcY#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&*AZ\/;Zbjg!EViZaaV!I^W^V!;^WjaV

HEAD

LATERAL MALLEOLUS ,%'

&IGUREBYWXdÍRe\Q\QdUbQ\AZ[i!egdm^bVaZcY0g^\]i!Y^hiVaZcY#CVijgVah^oZ#

&*#);^WjaV

'-*

&IGUREBYWXdÍRe\Q`b_hY]Q\ 6ciZg^dg^hje0aViZgVa^hidlVgYi]Zg^\]i# CVijgVah^oZ#



&IGUREBYWXdÍRe\QTYcdQ\EdhiZg^dg ^hje0aViZgVa^hidlVgYi]Zg^\]i#CVijgVah^oZ#

8]VeiZg&*AZ\/;Zbjg!EViZaaV!I^W^V!;^WjaV

#HAPTER

;ddi/IVghVah! BZiViVghVah! E]VaVc\Zh I

53

). 4

ARTICULATION SOMETIMESARTICULATES

,! 4%

!2 5,

$) !,

-%

.! 6)#

 ST

.% /) $

,# !

#!

#5 "

%2 #5 -% .% $ )&/ N 2! D 2, -% #  5. 4! RD 4! # % ) &/ -% 23 5. !, 24! %)&  4! /2 -% 23 !, 4!  4! -% 23 !, 4!  4! -% 23 !, 4!  4! 23 !, 

! 5, 4! ,5 3

&)"

4)")! &)"5,! 4!,53 #!,#!.%53 #5"/)$ .!6)#5,!2 ST#5.%)&/2ND#5.%)&/2RD#5.%)&/2-%4!4!23!, -%4!4!23!, -%4!4!23!, -%4!4!23!, -%4!4!23!,

4)"

)!

]ZWdcZhd[i]Z[ddiVgZdWk^djhhZg^Va]dbdad\hd[i]Z]VcYWdcZh#I]ZYZZe Zkdaji^dcVgn]^hidgnd[[ddiZaZbZcih^hh^b^aVgidi]ViYZhXg^WZY[dgi]dhZd[i]Z ]VcY^c8]VeiZg&(#I]ZgZVgZVidiVad[ilZcin"h^mWdcZh^cZVX]]jbVc[ddi!dcZaZhh i]Vc^cZVX]]VcY#D[i]ZhZkZciVghVaWdcZh!ilddXXjenVegdm^bVagdl![djgdXXjen VY^hiVagdl!VcYdcZ^hXZciZgZYWZilZZcgdlh#I]ZiVghVahVgZ[daadlZYY^hiVaanWnV h^c\aZgdld[ÄkZbZiViVghVah#;Vgi]ZgY^hiVaan!i]ZgZ^hVh^c\aZgdld[ÄkZegdm^bVa e]VaVc\Zh!Vh^c\aZgdld[[djg^ciZgbZY^ViZe]VaVc\Zh!VcYVh^c\aZgdld[ÄkZY^hiVa! dgiZgb^cVa!e]VaVc\Zh# >cVYY^i^dcidi]ZhZilZcin"h^m!Vhl^i]i]Z]VcY!i]ZgZVgZhbVaahZhVbd^YWdcZh i]Via^Zl^i]^ciZcYdchd[i]Z[ddi#>ci]Z[ddi!VeV^gd[hZhVbd^Yh^hjhjVaan[djcY WZadl i]Z ]ZVY d[ i]Z Äghi bZiViVghVa# ;^\jgZh &+#&·&+#) hjbbVg^oZ VcY ^aajhigViZ Vgi^XjaVi^dchl^i]^ci]Z[ddi#:aZbZcihd[i]Z[ddih`ZaZidcXVcWZY^k^YZY^cidi]gZZ hZ\bZcih/i]ZdQbcQ\c!]UdQdQbcQ\c!VcY`XQ\Q^WUc# >i^hXdckZc^ZciidVeeanheZX^ÄXY^gZXi^dcVaiZgbhidi]Z[ddi#@\Q^dQbgZ[Zghid i]ZhdaZd[i]Z[ddi!^ih^c[Zg^dghjg[VXZ^chiVcYVgYVcVidb^XVaedh^i^dc#4_bcQ\^hi]Z

&IGURE6gi^XjaVi^dcd[WdcZh^ci]ZVYjai]jbVcVc`aZVcY[ddi# &//4

'-,

-ETATARSAL-ETATARSAL

-ETATARSAL -ETATARSAL

-ETATARSAL

&IGUREBYWXdV__dT_bcQ\ce`UbY_b#HZhVbd^YWdcZhcdi^cXajYZY#CVijgVah^oZ#

&IGUREBYWXdV__d`\Q^dQbY^VUbY_b#HZhVbd^YWdcZhcdi^cXajYZY#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&+;ddi/IVghVah!BZiViVghVah!E]VaVc\Zh

#UBOID ,ATERAL#UNEIFORM )NTERMEDIATE#UNEIFORM -EDIAL#UNEIFORM

#ALCANEUS

.AVICULAR

4ALUS

'-.

&//4

&+;ddi

&IGUREABYWXdV__d\QdUbQ\HZhVbd^YWdcZhcdi^cXajYZY#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&+;ddi/IVghVah!BZiViVghVah!E]VaVc\Zh

&IGUREBBYWXdV__d]UTYQ\HZhVbd^YWdcZhcdi^cXajYZY#CVijgVah^oZ#

'.&

&//4

&+;ddi

deedh^iZ!hjeZg^dghjg[VXZ#@b_hY]Q\edhiZg^dg^hidlVgYi]Zi^W^V!TYcdQ\VciZg^dg^h idlVgYi]ZidZi^eh!VcYi]ZY^hiVa"bdhie]VaVc\ZhVgZgZ[ZggZYidVh¹iZgb^cVa#º>cVYY^" i^dc!i]ZW^\idZ^hhdbZi^bZhXVaaZYi]ZXQ\\eh!VcY^ihgVn^h^YZci^ÄZYVhgVn&#Di]Zg gVnhVgZcjbWZgZYVh^ci]Z]VcY# I]Z]jbVc[ddi]VhX]Vc\ZYYgVbVi^XVaanYjg^c\^ihZkdaji^dc[gdbV\gVhe^c\ dg\VcidVhigjXijgZVYVeiZYidW^eZYVaadXdbdi^dc#Bdhid[i]ZbdW^a^in!ÅZm^W^a^in! VcY\gVhe^c\VW^a^i^Zhd[i]Z[ddi]VkZWZZcadhi^c]jbVchVhi]Z[ddiVYVeiZYidh]dX` VWhdgei^dcVcYegdejah^dc#

4ARSALS I]Z hZkZc iVghVah XdbW^cZ l^i] i]Z ÄkZ bZiViVghVah id [dgb i]Z adc\^ijY^cVa VcY igVchkZghZVgX]Zhd[i]Z[ddi#I]ZdQ\ecVgi^XjaViZhhjeZg^dganl^i]i]ZY^hiVai^W^VVcY ÄWjaVVii]ZVc`aZ_d^ci#I]ZSQ\SQ^Uec[dgbhi]Z]ZZad[i]Z[ddi!hjeedgihi]ZiVajh! VcYVgi^XjaViZhVciZg^dganl^i]i]ZSeR_YT!i]Zi]^gYaVg\ZhiiVghVaWdcZ#I]ZbZiViVg" hVahVgi^XjaViZegdm^bVaanl^i]i]ZXjWd^YVcYi]gZZSe^UYV_b]c#I]ZhZkZci]iVghVa! i]Z^QfYSe\Qb!^h^ciZgedhZYWZilZZci]Z]ZVYd[i]ZiVajhVcYi]ZhZXjcZ^[dgbh#

4ALUS&IGURESn I]ZiVajh^hXVaaZYi]ZQcdbQWQ\ec^cdi]ZgVc^bVah#>i^hi]ZhZXdcYaVg\Zhid[i]ZiVghVah VcY^hh^ijViZYWZilZZci]Zi^W^VVcYÄWjaVhjeZg^dganVcYi]ZXVaXVcZjh^c[Zg^dgan#Cd bjhXaZhViiVX]idi]^hWdcZ#>igZhihVidei]ZXVaXVcZjhVcYVgi^XjaViZhY^hiVaanl^i] i]ZcVk^XjaVg#>i[dgbhi]ZadlZgbZbWZgd[i]ZdQ\_SbebQ\Z_Y^d#IVaVgkVg^Vi^dc^h ^aajhigViZY^c;^\jgZ)#&#

HEAD NECK

TROCHLEA

SULCUS TALI

GROOVEFOR mEXORHALLUCIS LONGUS

CALCANEAL ORSUBTALAR ARTICULAR SURFACES 0,!.4!2).&%2)/2

$/23!,350%2)/2 &IGUREBYWXddQ\ec9^hiVa^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&+;ddi/IVghVah!BZiViVghVah!E]VaVc\Zh

V# I]ZXUQT^hi]ZgdjcYZY!XdckZm!Y^hiVaVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZd[i]ZiVajh#>iÄih^cid i]Z]daadld[i]ZcVk^XjaVg# W# I]ZR_Ti^hi]ZhfjVg^h]Wja`d[i]ZWdcZedhiZg^dgidi]ZiVaVgcZX`# X# I]Zdb_SX\UQ^hi]ZhVYYaZ"h]VeZYVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZd[i]ZWdYn#>ihh^YZhVgZi]Z aViZgVaVcYbZY^Va]Q\\U_\QbcebVQSUc!l]^X]Vgi^XjaViZl^i]i]ZÄWjaVVcYi^W^V! gZheZXi^kZan# Y# I]Z^US[XdccZXihi]Z]ZVYd[i]ZiVajhidi]ZWdYn#DXXVh^dcVaani]ZgZVgZhbVaa Vgi^XjaVg[VXZihdci]ZcZX`![dgbZYWnXdciVXil^i]i]ZVciZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]Z Y^hiVai^W^VYjg^c\higdc\Ydgh^ÅZm^dcd[i]Z[ddiVii]ZVc`aZdgiVadXjgVa_d^ci# I]ZhZ[VXZihVgZXVaaZYhfjViiZgh¼[VXZih#  Z# I]ZWb__fUV_bÎUh_bXQ\\eSYc\_^Wec^hi]Zh]dgi!cZVgankZgi^XVa\gddkZdci]Z edhiZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]ZiVaVgWdYn#>i^hhdcVbZYWZXVjhZ^iigVchb^ihi]ZiZcYdc d[i]^hbjhXaZ!VXVa[bjhXaZi]VieaVciVgÅZmZhi]Z[ddiVcY]Vaajm#  [# I]ZSQ\SQ^UQ\dgceRdQ\QbQbdYSe\QbcebVQSUcdci]Z^c[Zg^dgVheZXid[i]ZiVajh VgZjhjVaani]gZZ^ccjbWZgVcYkVg^VWaZ^ch]VeZ# \#I]Zce\SecdQ\Y^hVYZZe\gddkZWZilZZci]ZedhiZg^dgVcYi]Zb^YYaZXVaXVcZVa Vgi^XjaVghjg[VXZh#  ™ 1^Qd_]YSQ\cYTY^WI]ZhVYYaZ"h]VeZYVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ[dgi]ZY^hiVai^W^V^hhj" eZg^dg!VcYi]ZiVaVg]ZVY^hVciZg^dg#I]ZaVg\ZgbVaaZdaVghjg[VXZ[dgi]ZÄWjaV ^haViZgVa#  ™ @_cYdY_^Q\cYTY^WI]Z]ZVY^hbZY^Val]Zck^ZlZY[gdbVWdkZVcYVa^\chl^i] i]Z]Vaajm#

BODY

-%$)!,

&IGUREBYWXddQ\ec 9dghVa^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

,!4%2!,

'.(

&//4

&+#&IVghVah

#ALCANEUS&IGURESn I]ZXVaXVcZjh!dg¹]ZZaWdcZ!º^hi]ZaVg\Zhid[i]ZiVghVaWdcZhVcYi]ZaVg\ZhiWdcZd[ i]Z[ddi#>i^hadXViZY^c[Zg^dgidi]ZiVajhVcYVgi^XjaViZhVciZg^dganY^hiVaanl^i]i]Z XjWd^Y# V# I]ZSQ\SQ^UQ\deRUb^hi]ZaVg\Z!Wajci!cdcVgi^XjaVg!edhiZg^dgegdXZhhd[i]Z]ZZa# >i^hi]Z^chZgi^dced^cid[i]ZXVaXVcZVa!dg6X]^aaZhÀ!iZcYdc#8dcigVXi^dcd[i]Z \VhigdXcZb^jhVcYhdaZjhXVa[bjhXaZhXVjhZheaVciVgÅZm^dcd[i]Z[ddi!l^i]i]Z XVaXVcZVaijWZghZgk^c\VhVaZkZgVgbi]VijhZhi]ZiVaVgWdYnVh^ih[jaXgjb# W# I]Z\QdUbQ\VcY]UTYQ\`b_SUccUc!dci]ZeaVciVgedgi^dcd[i]ZXVaXVcZVa ijWZgdh^in!hZgkZidVcX]dghZkZgVa^cig^ch^XbjhXaZhd[i]Z[ddi#I]ZaViZgVaegdXZhh ^hbjX]hbVaaZgi]Vci]ZbZY^Va# X# I]ZcecdU^dQSe\e]dQ\Y^hi]Zh]Za[dci]ZbZY^Vah^YZd[i]ZXVaXVcZjh#>i hjeedgihi]ZiVaVg]ZVY# Y# I]ZcecdU^dQSe\Qbce\SecWb__fU!_jhi^c[Zg^dgidi]ZhjhiZciVXjajb!^hV egdcdjcXZY\gddkZ#I]ZiZcYdcd[i]ZÊZmdg]VaajX^hadc\jhbjhXaZ!VeaVciVgÅZmdg d[i]ZW^\idZ!igVkZahi]gdj\]i]^h\gddkZ#>i^hXdci^cjdjhedhiZgdhjeZg^dganl^i] i]Z\gddkZdci]ZedhiZg^dgZmigZb^ind[i]ZiVajh#  Z# I]ZÍRe\Qb`Ub_^UQ\deRUbS\U^hVgdjcYZYegd_ZXi^dcadldci]ZaViZgVa hjg[VXZd[i]ZXVaXVcZVaWdYn#>i^hXadhZanVhhdX^ViZYl^i]iZcYdchd[i]ZÉWjaVg^h eZgdcZjhadc\jhVcYWgZk^hbjhXaZh#I]ZhZbjhXaZheaVciVgÅZmVcYZkZgii]Z[ddi!

SUSTENTACULAR SULCUS GROOVE

LATERAL ANDMEDIAL PROCESSES

CALCANEAL TUBER $/23!,350%2)/2 &IGUREBYWXdSQ\SQ^Uec9^hiVa^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#



0,!.4!2).&%2)/2

8]VeiZg&+;ddi/IVghVah!BZiViVghVah!E]VaVc\Zh

-%$)!, &IGUREBYWXdSQ\SQ^UecVWdkZVcYg^\]i 9dghVa^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

SUSTENTACULUM TALI

0/34%2)/2

!.4%2)/2

&IGUREBYWXdSQ\SQ^UecaZ[iVcYWZadl 9dghVa^hje#CVijgVah^oZ# lBULARPERONEAL TUBERCLE

,!4%2!,

'.*

&//4

&+#&IVghVah

^chZgi^c\dci]ZWVhZd[i]ZÄghiVcYÄ[i]bZiViVghVah!gZheZXi^kZan#  ™ @_ccYR\US_^VecY_^>i^hcdiedhh^WaZidXdc[jhZVc^ciVXiXVaXVcZjhl^i]Vcdi]Zg WdcZ#6Wgd`ZcXVaXVcZVaWdYnb^\]ihdbZi^bZhWZb^hiV`Zc[dgVhZXi^dcd[ [ZbdgVa\gZViZgigdX]VciZg!Wjii]ZdcanVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZdci]Zegdm^bVa[Zbjg ^hi]Zhe]Zg^XVa]ZVY#  ™ 1^Qd_]YSQ\cYTY^WI]ZijWZgdh^in^hedhiZg^dgVcYi]Z^c[Zg^dghjg[VXZ^h cdcVgi^XjaVg#I]ZhjhiZciVXjajbiVa^egd_ZXihbZY^Vaan!^c[Zg^dgidi]ZiVaVg]ZVY#  ™ @_cYdY_^Q\cYTY^WL^i]i]Z]ZZaVlVn[gdbndjVcYi]ZVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZhje!i]Z h]Za[egd_ZXihidi]Zh^YZ[gdbl]^X]i]ZWdcZXdbZh#

#UBOID&IGURESn I]Z XjWd^Y WdcZ h^ih dc i]Z aViZgVa h^YZ d[ i]Z [ddi! hVcYl^X]ZY WZilZZc i]Z XVaXV" cZjhVcYi]Z[djgi]VcYÄ[i]bZiViVghVah!Vgi^XjaVi^c\l^i]i]ZcVk^XjaVgVcYi]^gY XjcZ^[dgb#>i^hgZXd\c^oZYWn^ihaVg\Zh^oZVcYegd_ZXi^c\!ed^ciZY!egdm^bVaVgi^XjaVg hjg[VXZ#>i^hi]ZbdhiXjWd^YVa!dgXjWZ"h]VeZY!d[i]ZiVghVaWdcZh#I]ZSeR_YTdeRUb _cYdi;^\jgZ&+#&%^hVaVg\ZijWZgdh^indci]Z^c[ZgdaViZgVahjg[VXZd[i]ZWdcZ#I]Z

CUBOID TUBEROSITY

).&%2)/20,!.4!2

350%2)/2$/23!,

&IGUREBYWXdSeR_YT9^hiVa^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

6IEWFROMTHE LATERALCUNEIFORM

6IEWFROMTHE CALCANEUS

&IGUREBYWXdSeR_YT9dghVa^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&+;ddi/IVghVah!BZiViVghVah!E]VaVc\Zh

6IEWFROMTHE -4AND-4BASES

iZcYdc[dgi]ZÉWjaVg^heZgdcZjhadc\jhbjhXaZZciZghi]Z[ddik^Vi]Z\gddkZVY_VXZciid i]^hijWZgdh^in#  ™ 1^Qd_]YSQ\cYTY^WI]Zl^YZ!ÅVicdcVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ^hhjeZgdaViZgVa!VcYi]Z ed^ciZYXVaXVcZVa[VXZi^hegdm^bVa#I]ZijWZgdh^in^h^c[ZgdaViZgVa#I]ZgZ^hVc Vgi^XjaVi^dcdci]ZbZY^Va!Wjicdidci]ZaViZgVahjg[VXZ#  ™ @_cYdY_^Q\cYTY^WAdd`Y^gZXianVii]ZÅVicdcVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ#L^i]i]ZXVaXV" cZVa[VXZiidlVgYndj!i]ZijWZgdh^inegd_ZXihaViZgVaandci]Zh^YZ[gdbl]^X]i]Z WdcZXdbZh#

.AVICULAR&IGURESn I]ZcVk^XjaVg^hcVbZY[dgi]Zhigdc\anXdcXVkZegdm^bVahjg[VXZi]ViVgi^XjaViZhl^i] i]Z]ZVYd[i]ZiVajh#Dci]ZY^hiVahjg[VXZ!i]ZcVk^XjaVg]VhVaVg\Z[VXZiY^k^YZYWn ildg^Y\Zh#I]ZhZYZbVg`i]ZVgi^XjaVgeaVcZhd[i]Zi]gZZXjcZ^[dgbh#>cVYY^i^dc!i]Z cVk^XjaVgd[iZcVgi^XjaViZhl^i]VXdgcZgd[i]ZXjWd^Y#I]ZdeRUbS\U;^\jgZ&+#&'d[ i]ZcVk^XjaVg^hVaVg\Z!Wajciegd_ZXi^dcdci]ZbZY^Vah^YZd[i]ZWdcZ#I]^hijWZgXaZ^h i]ZbV^c^chZgi^dcd[i]Zi^W^Va^hedhiZg^dgbjhXaZ!VeaVciVgÅZmdgd[i]Z[ddiVcYidZh#

TUBERCLE 6IEWFROMTHETALUS02/8)-!,

6IEWFROMTHECUNEIFORMS$)34!,

&IGUREBYWXdV__d^QfYSe\Qb9dghVa^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

&IGUREBYWXdV__d^QfYSe\Qb9^hiVa^hidlVgYi]Z aZ[i#CVijgVah^oZ#

350%2/-%$)!,

'.,

&//4

&+#&IVghVah

 ™ @_ccYR\US_^VecY_^6ai]dj\]\ZcZgVaanh^b^aVg^c\gdhhh]VeZ!i]^hWdcZ^h bjX]aVg\Zgi]Vci]ZhXVe]d^YVcY]VhVÅVih^YZl^i]i]gZZ[VXZih#  ™ 1^Qd_]YSQ\cYTY^WI]ZXdcXVkZiVaVg[VXZi^hegdm^bVa#I]ZaVg\Z!ÅVicdcVg" i^XjaVghjg[VXZ^hYdghVa!VcYi]ZijWZgXaZ^hbZY^Va#  ™ @_cYdY_^Q\cYTY^W=daYi]ZWdcZWni]ZWVhZd[i]ZijWZgXaZ!l^i]i]ZXdcXVkZVg" i^XjaVghjg[VXZ[VX^c\ndjVcYi]ZÅVicdcVgi^XjaVgh^YZje#I]Zi^ed[i]ZijWZgXaZ ed^cihidlVgYi]Zh^YZ[gdbl]^X]i]ZWdcZXdbZh#

-EDIAL&IRST #UNEIFORM&IGURE I]Z Äghi XjcZ^[dgb ^h i]Z aVg\Zhi d[ i]gZZ XjcZ^[dgbh# >i h^ih WZilZZc i]Z cVk^XjaVg VcYi]ZWVhZd[i]ZÄghibZiViVghVa!Vgi^XjaVi^c\l^i]i]ZhZVhlZaaVhl^i]i]ZhZXdcY XjcZ^[dgbVcYi]ZWVhZd[i]ZhZXdcYbZiViVghVaBI'#>i^haZhhlZY\Z"h]VeZYi]Vc i]Zdi]ZgXjcZ^[dgbhVcY^hY^hi^c\j^h]ZYWni]Z`^YcZn"h]VeZY[VXZi[dgi]ZWVhZd[ i]ZÄghibZiViVghVa#  ™ 1^Qd_]YSQ\cYTY^WI]Zadc\Zhi!`^YcZn"h]VeZYVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ^hY^hiVa!^ih adc\Vm^hkZgi^XVa#I]ZWgdVY!gdj\]!cdcVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ^hbZY^Va!VcYi]ZaViZgVa [VXZi[dgi]Z^ciZgbZY^ViZXjcZ^[dgb^hhjeZg^dg#I]Zegdm^bVa[VXZi[dgi]ZcV" k^XjaVg^hXdcXVkZ#  ™ @_cYdY_^Q\cYTY^WEaVXZi]ZaVg\Z!`^YcZn"h]VeZYVgi^XjaVg[VXZiVlVn[gdbndj VcYdg^Zci^ihadc\Vm^hkZgi^XVaan!l^i]i]ZhbVaaZg!bdgZXdcXVkZcVk^XjaVg[VXZi idlVgYndj#L^i]i]ZWdcZgZhi^c\dc^ihWajciZgZcY!i]Zdcandi]Zg[VXZi^hcZVg i]ZidehjeZgdaViZgVaVcY[VXZhidlVgYi]Zh^YZ[gdbl]^X]i]ZWdcZXdbZh#

)NTERMEDIATE3ECOND #UNEIFORM&IGURE I]Z^ciZgbZY^ViZXjcZ^[dgb^hi]ZhbVaaZhid[i]gZZXjcZ^[dgbh#>i^hadXViZYWZilZZc i]ZcVk^XjaVgVcYi]ZhZXdcYbZiViVghVa#>cVYY^i^dc!^iVgi^XjaViZhdcZ^i]Zgh^YZl^i] i]ZÄghiVcYi]^gYXjcZ^[dgbh#  ™ 1^Qd_]YSQ\cYTY^WI]ZcdcVgi^XjaVgYdghVahjg[VXZd[i]ZWdcZ^hWgdVYZhi!VcY i]ZWdcZlZY\Zh^c[Zg^dgan!eVgi^X^eVi^c\^ci]ZigVchkZghZVgX]d[i]Z[ddi#I]Z egdm^bVaVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZ^hjhjVaani]ZbdhiXdcXVkZ[dgi]ZcVk^XjaVg#I]Z aViZgVaZY\Zd[i]^h[VXZiegdm^bVa!aViZgVaXdgcZgd[i]ZWdcZ^hXdcXVkZ^cegdÄaZ# I]ZaViZgVa[VXZi^hW^adWViZ#  ™ @_cYdY_^Q\cYTY^WEaVXZi]ZÅVi!cdcVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZjeVcYi]ZXdcXVkZ[VXZi VlVn[gdbndj#I]Zdjia^cZd[i]ZhjeZg^dgYdghVahjg[VXZ^hVhfjVgZl]dhZbdhi egd_ZXi^c\XdgcZged^cihidlVgYhi]Zh^YZ[gdbl]^X]i]ZWdcZXdbZh#

,ATERAL4HIRD #UNEIFORM&IGURE I]ZaViZgVaXjcZ^[dgb^h^ciZgbZY^ViZ^ch^oZWZilZZci]Zdi]ZgXjcZ^[dgbh#>i^had" XViZY^ci]ZXZciZgd[i]Z[ddi!Vgi^XjaVi^c\Y^hiVaanl^i]i]ZhZXdcY!i]^gY!VcY[djgi] 

8]VeiZg&+;ddi/IVghVah!BZiViVghVah!E]VaVc\Zh

-%$)!,

6IEWFROMTHE INTERMEDIATECUNEIFORM

6IEWFROMTHE FOOTNAVICULAR

&IGUREBYWXd]UTYQ\ÍbcdSe^UYV_b]9dghVa^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

6IEWFROMTHE MEDIALCUNEIFORM

6IEWFROMTHE LATERALCUNEIFORM

6IEWFROMTHE FOOTNAVICULAR

&IGUREBYWXdY^dUb]UTYQdUcUS_^TSe^UYV_b]9dghVa^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

6IEWFROMTHE INTERMEDIATECUNEIFORM

6IEWFROMTHE CUBOID

6IEWFROMTHE FOOTNAVICULAR

&IGUREBYWXd\QdUbQ\dXYbTSe^UYV_b]9dghVa^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#

'..

&//4

&+#&IVghVah

bZiViVghVah#BZY^Vaan^iXdciVXihi]Z^ciZgbZY^ViZXjcZ^[dgb!aViZgVaani]ZXjWd^Y!VcY egdm^bVaani]ZcVk^XjaVg#  ™ 1^Qd_]YSQ\cYTY^WI]ZYdghVahjg[VXZ^hVgZXiVc\jaVg!cdcVgi^XjaVgeaVi[dgb! VcYi]ZWdcZlZY\Zh^c[Zg^dganidi]^h#I]Zegdm^bVacVk^XjaVgVgi^XjaVi^dc^h l^YZgWjihbVaaZgi]Vci]ZZadc\ViZ!lZY\Z"h]VeZYY^hiVaBI([VXZi#I]ZWdgYZg WZilZZci]ZcVk^XjaVgVcYi]ZXjWd^Y[VXZihegd_ZXih^cVK"h]VeZVhi]ZWVhZd[ i]Zi]^gYXjcZ^[dgblZY\ZhWZilZZci]ZhZildWdcZh#  ™ @_cYdY_^Q\cYTY^WEaVXZi]ZÅVi!cdcVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZjelZY\ZYdlc!l^i]i]Z   hbVaaZgZcY[VXZiidlVgYndj#I]Z6[g^XV"h]VeZY[VXZi^hVlVn[gdbndj#I]Z adc\ZhiWdjcYVgnd[i]ZjeeZghjg[VXZ^hdci]Zh^YZ[gdbl]^X]i]ZWdcZXdbZh#

'ROWTH I]ZiVghVahZVX]dhh^[n[gdbVh^c\aZXZciZg!l^i]i]ZZmXZei^dcd[i]ZXVaXVcZjh!l]^X] ]VhVcZe^e]nh^hVi^ihedhiZg^dgZcY#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION 6hl^i]i]ZXVgeVah!bdhid[i]ZiVghVahVgZXdbeVXiVcYgdWjhihigjXijgZh#>YZci^ÄXV" i^dcd[[gV\bZciVgniVghVah^hi]ZgZ[dgZcdijhjVaangZfj^gZY#I]ZZmXZei^dcidi]^h^h i]ZXVaXVcZjh!l]^X]^haZhhYZchZVcY^hd[iZcWgd`Zc^c^ihcdcVgi^XjaVgVgZVh#7ZXVjhZ bdhid[i]ZiVghVahVgZaVg\Zgi]VcXVgeVah!i]ZnVgZbdgZd[iZcgZXdkZgZY[gdbVgX]Zd" ad\^XVaXdciZmih#H^Y^c\d[iVghVah!Vhl^i]XVgeVah!^h[VX^a^iViZYWnedh^i^dcVaiZX]c^fjZh# HdbZd[i]ZiZX]c^fjZhegZhZciZY]ZgZVgZVYdeiZY[gdb7Vhh&..*#

-ETATARSALS&IGURESn I]ZbZiViVghVah!a^`Zi]ZbZiVXVgeVah!VgZcjbWZgZY[gdbBI&i]Z]Vaajm!dgW^\idZ i]gdj\]BI*!VXXdgY^c\idi]ZÄkZgVnhd[i]Z[ddi#I]ZnVgZVaaijWjaVgWdcZhl^i] gdjcYY^hiVaVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZhXUQTcVcYbdgZhfjVg^h]egdm^bVaZcYhRQcUc#6h l^i]bZiVXVgeVah!bZiViVghVahVgZ^YZci^ÄZYVcYh^YZYbdhiZ[[ZXi^kZanVXXdgY^c\idi]Z bdge]dad\nd[i]Z^gWVhZh# I]Z eaVciVg bZiViVghVa cXQVd WdYn hjg[VXZh VgZ ValVnh bdgZ XdcXVkZ ^c aViZgVa k^Zli]Vci]Z^gYdghVah]V[ihjg[VXZh#I]ZWVhZhd[cdc]VaajX^VabZiViVghVaVaaVgi^Xj" aViZl^i]ZVX]di]Zg#:VX]d[i]ZiVghVah^ci]ZY^hiVagdlVgi^XjaViZl^i]ViaZVhidcZ bZiViVghVaWVhZ#

&IRST-ETATARSAL I]Z Äghi bZiViVghVa ^h i]Z h]dgiZhi Wji bdhi bVhh^kZ bZiViVghVa# >i Vgi^XjaViZh Vi ^ih WVhZl^i]i]ZbZY^VaXjcZ^[dgb#I]ZcUcQ]_YTWb__fUcVii]ZWVhZd[i]Z]ZVYXdg" gZhedcYidhZhVbd^YWdcZh;^\jgZ&+#'(^ci]ZiZcYdchd[ÊZmdg]VaajX^hWgZk^h!Vh]dgi 

8]VeiZg&+;ddi/IVghVah!BZiViVghVah!E]VaVc\Zh











&IGUREBYWXdV__dT_bcQ\hjeZg^dg#GVnh& ·*!h]dl^c\i]ZbZiViVghVahVcYi]Z egdm^bVa!^ciZgbZY^ViZ!VcYY^hiVa[ddie]VaVc\Zh#9^hiVa^hje0aViZgVa^hidlVgYi]Zg^\]i# CVijgVah^oZ#

(%&

&//4

&+#'BZiViVghVah











&IGUREBYWXdV__d`\Q^dQb^c[Zg^dg#GVnh&·*!h]dl^c\i]ZbZiViVghVahVcYi]Zegdm^" bVa!^ciZgbZY^ViZ!VcYY^hiVa[ddie]VaVc\Zh#9^hiVa^hje0aViZgVa^hidlVgYi]ZaZ[i#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&+;ddi/IVghVah!BZiViVghVah!E]VaVc\Zh











&IGUREBYWXdV__d\QdUbQ\GVnh&·*!h]dl^c\i]ZbZiViVghVahVcYi]Zegdm^bVa!^ciZg" bZY^ViZ!VcYY^hiVa[ddie]VaVc\Zh#CVijgVah^oZ#

(%(

&//4

&+#'BZiViVghVah











&IGUREBYWXd]UdQdQbcQ\c]UTYQ\9^hiVa^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#









&IGUREBYWXd]UdQdQbcQ\RQcUc`b_hY]Q\9dghVa^hje#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&+;ddi/IVghVah!BZiViVghVah!E]VaVc\Zh



eaVciVgÅZmdgd[i]ZW^\idZ#  ™ CYTY^WI]ZWVhVa[VXZi]VhVXdckZmbZY^VaegdÄaZVcYVhigV^\]iaViZgVaegdÄaZ#

3ECOND-ETATARSAL I]ZhZXdcYbZiViVghVa^hi]Zadc\ZhiVcYcVggdlZhibZiViVghVa#>i]VhildaViZgVa[VXZih Vii]ZWVhZ!ZVX]Vgi^XjaVg^c\l^i]i]ZaViZgVaXjcZ^[dgbVcYBI(#>iVgi^XjaViZhegdm^" bVaanl^i]i]Z^ciZgbZY^ViZXjcZ^[dgbVcYbZY^Vaanl^i]i]ZbZY^VaXjcZ^[dgb#>ih WVhZ]Vhha^\]ianbdgZd[V¹hinad^YºVeeZVgVcXZi]Vci]ZWVhZd[BI(#  ™ CYTY^WI]Zbdhiegdm^bVaed^cidci]ZWVhZ^haViZgVaidi]ZbV^ch]V[iVm^h#

4HIRD-ETATARSAL I]Zi]^gYbZiViVghVa^hkZgnh^b^aVgidBI'!Wji^ihWVhZ]VhildbZY^VaWVhVa[VXZih i]ViVgZhbVaaZgi]VcBI'aViZgVa[VXZih#I]ZaViZgVaWVhVa[VXZi^hh^c\aZVcYaVg\Z#I]Z WVhZ^hhfjVgZgi]Vci]ZBI'WVhZ!VcYi]ZgZ^hVaVg\Z!Wja\^c\ijWZgXaZY^hiVaidi]Z aViZgVaVgi^XjaVg[VXZi#I]ZWVhZVgi^XjaViZhl^i]BI'VcYBI)VcYl^i]i]ZaViZgVa XjcZ^[dgb#  ™ CYTY^WI]Zbdhiegdm^bVaed^cidci]ZWVhZ^haViZgVaidi]ZbV^ch]V[iVm^h#

&OURTH-ETATARSAL I]Z[djgi]bZiViVghVa^hh]dgiZgi]VcBI'dgBI(#>i]Vhh^c\aZbZY^VaVcYaViZgVa WVhVa[VXZih[dgVgi^XjaVi^dcl^i]BI(VcYBI*#I]Zegdm^bVa[VXZi[dgi]ZXjWd^Y ^h[V^gandkVa#  ™ CYTY^WI]Zbdhiegdm^bVaed^cidci]ZWVhZ^haViZgVaidi]ZbV^ch]V[iVm^h#

&IFTH-ETATARSAL I]ZÄ[i]bZiViVghVaWZVghVcdi\_YT`b_SUcc!VY^hi^cXi^kZ!Wajci!cdcVgi^XjaVgWVhVa egd_ZXi^dc#>i^haViZgVa!deedh^iZi]ZBI)[VXZi!VcYegd_ZXihegdm^bVaan#>i^hi]Z^chZg" i^dced^ci[dgi]ZiZcYdcd[i]ZeZgdcZjhWgZk^hbjhXaZ!VXVa[bjhXaZi]ViVXihideaVciVgÅZm VcYZkZgii]Z[ddiVii]ZVc`aZ#I]Zegdm^bVaWVhVaVgi^XjaVi^dc^h[dgi]ZXjWd^Y#  ™ CYTY^WI]Zhinad^YegdXZhh^haViZgVa#
(%*

&//4

&+#'BZiViVghVah

'ROWTH&IGURE BZiViVghVahZVX]dhh^[n[gdbildXZciZgh#;dgBI'!BI(!BI)!VcYBI*!i]ZgZ^h dcZXZciZg[dgWdi]i]ZWVhZVcYh]V[iVcYVhZXdcY[dgi]ZY^hiVaZcY#;dgi]ZBI&! i]ZgZ^hdcZXZciZg[dgi]ZWdYnVcYdcZ[dgi]Zegdm^bVaZcY#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION BZiViVghVahVcYbZiVXVgeVahVgZh^b^aVg^c\gdhhh^oZVcYh]VeZWjiVgZZVh^anY^hi^c" \j^h]ZY[gdbZVX]di]Zg#BZiViVghVa'!BI(!BI)!VcYBI*VgZadc\Zgi]VcB8 '!B8(!B8)!VcYB8*!l^i]higV^\]iZgVcYcVggdlZgh]V[ih#BZiViVghVa]ZVYhVgZ XdbegZhhZYbdgZbZY^daViZgVaanVcYVgZhbVaaZggZaVi^kZidi]Z^gWVhZhi]VcbZiVXVg" eVa]ZVYh#

3IDING BZiViVghVaWVhZhVgZValVnhegdm^bVa!VcYi]Zbdhiegdm^bVaeVgid[i]ZWVhZ^hValVnh aViZgVadcBI'!BI(!BI)!VcYBI*#

&OOT0HALANGES&IGURESn ;ddie]VaVc\Zhh]VgZVXdbbdcWVh^XYZh^\c]ZVYh!WVhZh!VcYh]V[ihl^i]]VcYe]V" aVc\ZhhZZHZXi^dc&(#(#

0ROXIMAL&OOT0HALANGES :VX] egdm^bVa [ddi e]VaVcm Y^heaVnh V h^c\aZ! XdcXVkZ egdm^bVa [VXZi [dg i]Z bZiV" iVghVa]ZVY!VcYVhedda"h]VeZY!dgigdX]aZVg!hjg[VXZY^hiVaan#I]Z]VaajX^Vaegdm^bVa e]VaVcm^haVg\ZgVcYhidjiZgi]Vci]Zdi]Zgh#

)NTERMEDIATE&OOT0HALANGES :VX]^ciZgbZY^ViZ[ddie]VaVcmY^heaVnhVYdjWaZegdm^bVaVgi^XjaVg[VXZi[dgi]Z]ZVY d[i]Zegdm^bVae]VaVcm#:VX]Vahd]VhVigdX]aZV"h]VeZYY^hiVaVgi^XjaVg[VXZi#I]ZhZ e]VaVc\ZhVgZ¹hijciZY!ºhfjVikZgh^dchd[i]Z^gVcVad\h^ci]Z]VcY#

$ISTAL&OOT0HALANGES :VX]Y^hiVa[ddie]VaVcmY^heaVnhVYdjWaZegdm^bVaVgi^XjaVg[VXZi[dgi]Z]ZVYd[i]Z ^ciZgbZY^ViZe]VaVcm!Wjii]ZiZgb^cVai^ed[i]ZWdcZ^hVcdcVgi^XjaVgeVY!i]ZTYcdQ\



8]VeiZg&+;ddi/IVghVah!BZiViVghVah!E]VaVc\Zh

&IGUREBZiViVghVa\gdli]#I]ZeV^ghd[^bbVijgZbZiViVghVahVgZh]dlc]ZgZ^ceaVciVg k^Zl!l^i]gVn&dci]ZaZ[iVcYgVn*dci]Zg^\]i#I]ZnVgZ[gdbdcZ"nZVg"daYVcYh^m"nZVg"daY ^cY^k^YjVah#CVijgVah^oZ#

&IGURECUcQ]_YTc_VdXUbYWXdV__d hjeZg^dgYdghVak^ZlaZ[i0aViZgVak^Zl g^\]i#

`XQ\Q^WUQ\deRUbS\UdeVd#I]ZhZe]VaVc\ZhVgZkZgnhbVaaVcYhijWWnXdbeVgZYid Y^hiVa]VcYe]VaVc\Zh#

'ROWTH ;ddie]VaVc\ZhZVX]dhh^[n[gdbildXZciZgh!dcZ[dgi]Zh]V[iVcYY^hiVaZcYVcYdcZ [dgi]ZWVhZ#

0OSSIBLE#ONFUSION =VcYVcY[ddie]VaVc\ZhVgZZVh^anY^hi^c\j^h]ZY!ZkZcl]Zc^hdaViZY#;ddie]VaVc\Zh VgZVaabjX]h]dgiZgi]Vci]Z^gVcVad\h^ci]Z]VcY#

(%,

&//4

&+#(;ddiE]VaVc\Zh

 ™ Egdm^bVa[ddie]VaVc\ZhVgZi]ZdcandcZhi]Vib^\]iWZb^hiV`Zc[dg]VcYe]V" aVc\Zh#  ™ E]VaVc\ZVah]V[ih^ci]Z]VcYVgZXdbegZhhZYYdghdkZcigVaan![dgb^c\V9"h]VeZ ^cXgdhhhZXi^dc!l]^aZi]dhZ^ci]Z[ddiVgZbdgZX^gXjaVg^cXgdhhhZXi^dc#  ™ ;ddie]VaVc\ZhY^heaVnbdgZXdchig^Xi^dcVib^Yh]V[ii]Vc]VcYe]VaVc\Zh#  ™ I]Z]Vaajm]VhdcanVegdm^bVaVcYVbdge]dad\^XVaanY^hiVae]VaVcm!VcYi]ZhZ hfjVi!bVhh^kZWdcZhVgZkZgnY^hi^cXi^kZ#

3IDING ;dgh^Y^c\]VcYVcY[ddie]VaVc\Zh^i^hWZhiidldg`l^i]l]daZheZX^bZchVcYXdb" eVgVi^kZbViZg^Vah#I]Z]ZVY^hY^hiVa!VcYi]ZWVhZ^hegdm^bVa#I]ZYdghVae]VaVc\ZVa h]V[ihjg[VXZhVgZhbddi]VcYhigV^\]i!l]ZgZVhi]ZeaVciVghjg[VXZhVgZbdgZ^ggZ\jaVg VcYXjgkZY#



8]VeiZg&+;ddi/IVghVah!BZiViVghVah!E]VaVc\Zh

#HAPTER

DhiZdad\^XVa 9ZciVaEVi]dad\n >

c8]VeiZg)!dcWdcZW^dad\n!lZ^cigdYjXZYi]ZXdcXZeid[kVg^Vi^dcVcY^ih^b" edgiVcXZ id ldg` ^c ]jbVc dhiZdad\n# LZ YZhXg^WZY i]^h kVg^Vi^dc Vh hiZbb^c\ [gdb[djgbV^chdjgXZh/V\Z!hZm!VcXZhign!VcY^Y^dhncXgVhn#BVcn[VXZihd[]jbVcdh" iZdad\^XVakVg^Vi^dcVgZ^aajhigViZYWni]ZYZhXg^ei^dchd[i]ZkVg^djhh`ZaZiVaZaZbZcih ^c 8]VeiZgh ,·&+! VcY Wn i]Z VcVanh^h d[ V\Z! hZm! VcXZhign! VcY hiVijgZ egZhZciZY ^c 8]VeiZg&.#I]^hX]VeiZgXdci^cjZhidXdch^YZgkVg^Vi^dc!XdcXZcigVi^c\dckVg^Vi^dc YjZideVi]dad\n#CdcbZig^X!cdceVi]dad\^XVakVg^Vi^dchY^hXgZiZigV^ihVgZZhhZci^Va ^cgZXdchigjXi^c\kVg^djhW^dad\^XVaY^bZch^dchd[[dgbZg]jbVcedejaVi^dch#I]ZhZ VgZgZk^ZlZY^c8]VeiZg&.# I]^hX]VeiZg^cigdYjXZhVkVg^Zind[W^dad\^XVaegdXZhhZhi]ViXVcgZhjai^ch`Za" ZiVabdY^ÄXVi^dchWZ[dgZYZVi]Q^dU]_bdU]#8jaijgVaegVXi^XZhi]ViiV`ZeaVXZ_jhi WZ[dgZdgV[iZgYZVi]`UbY]_bdU]VgZVahdZmVb^cZY#=ZgZ!i]ZY^hXjhh^dcd[h`Za" ZiVabdY^ÄXVi^dch[dXjhZhdceVi]dad\^XVaXdcY^i^dch#8]VeiZg*ZmVb^cZYhdbZVY" Y^i^dcVaeZg^bdgiZbbdY^ÄXVi^dch!Wjii]ZgZlZXdcXZcigViZYdcX]Vc\Zhidi]ZWdcZ i]VidXXjgVidgV[iZgi]ZYZVi]d[i]Z^cY^k^YjVa`_cd]_bdU]SXQ^WUc#I]ZgZVYZg h]djaYcdiZi]Vii]ZbdhiXg^i^XVahiZe^cgZXdgY^c\eVaZdeVi]dad\^XVaXdcY^i^dch^hi]Z gZXd\c^i^dcd[igjZWdcZVWcdgbVa^i^Zh!VhdeedhZYidi]dhZl^i]^ci]ZcdgbVagVc\Z d[kVg^Vi^dc^c^bbVijgZVcYVYjai]ZVai]n^cY^k^YjVah# @Q\U_U`YTU]Y_\_Wi^hi]ZhijYnd[Y^hZVhZ^cVeVhiXdbbjc^in#@Q\U_`QdX_\_Wi ^hi]ZhijYnd[Y^hZVhZh^cVcX^ZciedejaVi^dchVhgZkZVaZYWnh`ZaZiVagZbV^chVcYegZ" hZgkZYhd[ii^hhjZh#7dcZhVcYiZZi]XVcWZgZXdgYhd[ZkZcih^ci]Za^[Zd[Vc^cY^k^YjVa! ^cXajY^c\igVjbVVcYY^hZVhZ#>cYZZY!YgVbVi^X^ch^\]ih^cidi]Z]ZVai]d[^cY^k^YjVah! VcYd[edejaVi^dch!bVnWZ\V^cZY[gdbhijY^Zh^cdhiZdad\^XVaeVi]dad\n#6hB^aaZg VcYXdaaZV\jZh&..+cdiZ!i]ZdW_ZXi^kZhd[eVaZdeVi]dad\^XVagZhZVgX]^cXajYZY^V\" cdh^c\heZX^ÄXY^hZVhZh^c^cY^k^YjVah`ZaZiVagZbV^chVcYZmVb^c^c\i]ZedejaVi^dcVa VcYZkdaji^dcVgnZ[[ZXihd[i]ZhZ^ciZgVXi^dchWZilZZc]jbVchVcYi]ZY^hZVhZhi]Vi V[Å^Xii]Zb# EVi]dad\^XVaX]Vc\ZhdWhZgkVWaZ^cdhiZdad\^XVabViZg^VahgZhjai[gdbVc^bWVaVcXZ ^ci]ZcdgbVaZfj^a^Wg^jbd[WdcZgZhdgei^dcVcY[dgbVi^dc!dg\gdli]"gZaViZYY^hdg" YZgh#I]^h^bWVaVcXZXVcVg^hZVhVgZhjaid[bVcn[VXidgh!^cXajY^c\bZX]Vc^XVahigZhh! X]Vc\Zh^cWaddYhjeean!^cÅVbbVi^dcd[hd[ii^hhjZh!X]Vc\ZhWgdj\]iVWdjiWn^c[ZX"

(%.

i^djhY^hZVhZh!]dgbdcVa!cjig^i^dcVaVcYbZiVWda^XjehZih!VcYijbdghBZch[dgi]Zi Va#!&.,-#9^V\cdh^c\i]ZZmVXiXVjhZd[VcdWhZgkZYh`ZaZiVaeVi]dad\n^h!]dlZkZg! cdiValVnhedhh^WaZ#;dgZmVbeaZ!Vc^cY^k^YjVa¼h\gdli]bVnWZ^ciZggjeiZYWnVgVc\Z d[[VXidghi]Vi^cXajYZ^c[ZXi^djhY^hZVhZ!hiVgkVi^dc!dgigVjbV#I]^h\gdli]VggZhibVn aZVYidi]Z[dgbVi^dcd[8QbbYc\Y^Uc^ci]Zadc\WdcZh!a^cZhd[^cXgZVhZYWdcZYZch^in i]VigZegZhZcii]Zedh^i^dcd[i]Z\gdli]eaViZVii]Zi^bZd[^chjaiidi]Zdg\Vc^hb# I]Za^cZhVgZk^h^WaZgVY^d\gVe]^XVaan!dg^cXgdhhhZXi^dc!VcYbVnWZjhZYidZhi^bViZ i]ZV\ZVil]^X]i]Z^cY^k^YjValVhhigZhhZY# GVY^d\gVe]^XVhhZhhbZci^hVcZhhZci^VaXdbedcZcid[YZhXg^W^c\VcYY^V\cdh^c\ Y^hZVhZ^ch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#DWhZgkVi^dchdcY^[[ZgZci^cY^k^YjVahbVnWZXdbW^cZY id Zhi^bViZ i]Z YZ\gZZ id l]^X] i]Z edejaVi^dc lVh higZhhZY# ;gdb i]Z =Vgg^h a^cZh i]ZbhZakZh! ]dlZkZg! dcan \ZcZgVa hiViZbZcih VWdji i]Z kVg^Zin d[ edhh^WaZ higZhhdgh ^cXajY^c\ Y^hZVhZ VcY Y^Zi bVn WZ bVYZ BVVi! &.-)0 =jbbZgi VcY KVc cXdcigVhi!i]ZXa^c^X^VcY^V\cdh^c\Y^hZVhZ^cVa^k^c\ eVi^ZciXVcVhhZhheVi^Zci]^hidgn!hd[ii^hhjZ!X]Zb^hign!eVi]d\Zch!VcYeV^c#>i[daadlh i]VieVaZdeVi]dad\^XVaY^V\cdhZhWVhZYdch`ZaZiVaaZh^dchl^aagVgZan]VkZi]ZegZX^" h^dcgdji^cZanZcXdjciZgZY^cXa^c^XVahZii^c\h#9ZkZadebZcih^cbdaZXjaVgW^dad\n! ]dlZkZg!VgZdeZc^c\cZlYddgh[dgi]ZeVaZdeVi]dad\^hi# 6cjbWZgd[Y^hZVhZhVgZ\ZcZi^X^ccVijgZVcYXdjaYediZci^VaanWZYZiZXiZY^c eVhi edejaVi^dch jh^c\ 9C6 VcVanh^h# 9^hZVhZ egdXZhhZh X]VgVXiZg^oZY Wn adc\"iZgb ^c[ZXi^dcWnhjWhiVci^VaYZch^i^Zhd[k^gVadgWVXiZg^VaeVi]d\Zchb^\]iVahdWZYZiZXiZY i]gdj\]gZXdkZgnd[i]Z9C6d[i]ZeVi]d\Zc#6hnZi!kZgn[ZlhijY^Zhd[eVaZdeV" i]dad\n]VkZji^a^oZY9C6bZi]dYh#6cZVganVeea^XVi^dclVhVbea^ÄXVi^dcd[i]Z BnXdWVXiZg^jbijWZgXjadh^h9C6[gdbVEZgjk^VcbjbbnidkZg^[nVegZ"8dajbW^Vc dXXjggZcXZd[ijWZgXjadh^h^ci]ZCZlLdgaYHVadZiVa#!&..)# Jc[dgijcViZan![ZlY^hZVhZhaZVkZh^\cVijgZhd[Vcn`^cYdci]Z]jbVch`ZaZidc! VcYi]dhZi]ViYdbVnXVjhZkZgnh^b^aVgh`ZaZiVagZVXi^dch#I]ZdcangZVaVYkVciV\Z i]Vii]ZdhiZdad\^hi]Vh^chijYn^c\eVi]dad\n^hi]ZVW^a^inidhijYni]ZZci^gZh`ZaZidc VidcXZ!l^i]djihd[ii^hhjZXdkZg#;dgi]ZhZgZVhdch!HiZ^cWdX`&.,+hj\\ZhiZYi]Vi i]ZbdhigVi^dcVaVeegdVX]idY^[[ZgZci^VaY^V\cdh^h^c]jbVch`ZaZiVaeVi]dad\n^h idhiViZi]Zbdhia^`ZanY^V\cdh^h[daadlZYWnVa^hid[edhh^WaZVaiZgcVi^kZh^cdgYZgd[ YZXgZVh^c\a^`Za^]ddY# 6hB^aaZgZiVa#&..+cdiZ!i]ZgZVgZildbV_dg^beZY^bZcihideVaZdeVi]dad\^XVa ldg`#;^ghi!i]ZgZ^hVeVjX^ind[lZaa"YdXjbZciZY!Xa^c^XVaanY^V\cdhZYh`ZaZiVahVb" eaZhidjhZVhXdcigdahV\V^chil]^X]jc`cdlch`ZaZiVahVbeaZh[dgZch^X!VgX]Zdad\^XVa!



8]VeiZg&,DhiZdad\^XVa9ZciVaEVi]dad\n

dgeVaZdcidad\^XVabVnWZXdbeVgZY#I]ZhZXdcYegdWaZba^Zhl^i]i]ZY^[ÄXjain^c ÄcY^c\h`ZaZiVaVWcdgbVa^i^Zh!dgeViiZgchd[VWcdgbVa^i^Zh!i]ViVgZjc^fjZid^cY^" k^YjVaY^hZVhZXViZ\dg^Zh#B^aaZgVcYXdaaZV\jZh&..+hj\\Zhii]VieVaZdeVi]dad\^Zh WZY^V\cdhZYVcYXaVhh^ÄZY^cdcZd[hZkZcXViZ\dg^Zh/&VcdbVan!'igVjbVgZeV^g! (^cÅVbbVidgn$^bbjcZ!)X^gXjaVidgnkVhXjaVg!*bZiVWda^X!+cZjgdbZX]Vc^" XVa!dg,cZdeaVhi^XXVcXZgh#>cVhZg^Zhd[Wa^cYiZhih!i]ZhZVji]dgh[djcYi]ViZkZc igV^cZYheZX^Va^hihldg`^c\dch`ZaZiVagZbV^chdcanVX]^ZkZYVXXjgVX^Zhd[VWdji)( Vii]^hWgdVYY^V\cdhi^XaZkZa!l]^aZdcanVWdji(%d[bdgZheZX^ÄXY^V\cdhZhlZgZ VXXjgViZ#7j^`higVVcYJWZaV`Zg¼hHiVcYVgYhkdajbZ&..)VYkdXViZhi]ZY^k^h^dcd[ eVaZdeVi]dad\^XVaX]Vc\Zh^cidc^cZXViZ\dg^Zh/&VWcdgbVa^i^Zhd[h]VeZ!'VWcdg" bVa^i^Zhd[h^oZ!(WdcZadhh!)VWcdgbVaWdcZ[dgbVi^dc!*[gVXijgZhVcYY^hadXV" i^dch!+edgdi^X]neZgdhidh^h$Xg^WgVdgW^iVa^V!,kZgiZWgVaeVi]dad\n!-Vgi]g^i^h!VcY .b^hXZaaVcZdjhXdcY^i^dch# I]ZÄghihiZe^cVcneVaZdeVi]dad\^XVaVcVanh^h^hidZhiVWa^h]i]ZZckZadeZd[l]Vi ^hcdgbVa^ch^oZ!h]VeZ!VcYided\gVe]n[dgV]ZVai]n]jbVc¼hh`ZaZidc#L]Zch`ZaZiVa gZbV^ch[Vaadjih^YZi]ViZckZadeZ!eVi]dad\n^hdcZedhh^WaZZmeaVcVi^dc#I]ZgZVgZ ildWVh^XhiZehideVaZdeVi]dad\^XValdg`#I]ZÄghi^hYZhXg^ei^dcVcYi]ZhZXdcY^h Y^V\cdh^h#9^V\cdh^hl^aagVgZanVeegdVX]l]Vi^hedhh^WaZ^ci]ZXa^c^XVahZii^c\WZ" XVjhZWdcZjhjVaangZhedcYhid^chjaihWnZ^i]ZggZhdgW^c\dgYZedh^i^c\!VcY^ibVn i]ZgZ[dgZZVh^angZhedcYidY^[[ZgZciY^hZVhZh^ckZgnh^b^aVglVnh#9ZhXg^ei^dc^hi]Z bdhi^bedgiVcihiZe^ceVaZdeVi]dad\^XValdg`WZXVjhZZkZc^[i]Z[daadl^c\Y^V\cdh^h ^h^cXdggZXi!di]Zgldg`ZghXVcXdbZVadc\aViZgVcYVbZcYdgbdY^[ni]ZY^V\cdh^h# >c Vcn YZhXg^ei^dc! ^YZci^[n i]Z cVijgZ VcY Y^hig^Wji^dc d[ VcdbVa^Zh VXgdhh i]Z h`ZaZidcVcYdWhZgkZi]ZeViiZgcd[Y^hig^Wji^dcd[i]ZhZVcdbVa^ZhVXgdhhi]Zedej" aVi^dc# I]ZhZ VcdbVa^ZhXVciV`Zi]Z[dgbd[aZh^dchdgd[X]Vc\Zh^ch^oZdgh]VeZ# CdiZi]ZY^hig^Wji^dcd[VaaaZh^dch!l]Zi]Zgh^c\aZ!bjai^eaZ!Y^[[jhZ!dgXdcXZcigViZY# CdiZ^[WdcZ^hZViZcVlVnani^XdgYZedh^iZYWaVhi^X#8]ZX`VaaWdcZhd[i]Zh`ZaZidc [dg [jgi]Zg Zk^YZcXZ# IZX]c^fjZh VcY bZi]dYh [dg eVaZdeVi]dad\^XVa Y^V\cdh^h bVn ^cXajYZ!^cVYY^i^dcid\gdhhVcVidbn!gVY^d\gVe]h!]^hidad\n!b^XgdgVY^d\gVe]h!hXVc" c^c\ZaZXigdcb^Xgd\gVe]h!X]Zb^XVaVcVanh^h!hZgdad\n!VcY9C6iZX]c^fjZh# 7dd`hWnGdWZgihVcYBVcX]ZhiZg&..*!HiZ^cWdX`&.,+!DgicZgVcYEjihX]Vg &.-&! DgicZg '%%(! VcY Vc ZcXnXadeZY^V Wn 6j[YZg]Z^YZ VcY GdYg^\jZo"BVgi^c &..-egdk^YZZmXZaaZci\j^YZhiddhiZdad\^XVaeVi]dad\nVcYAZl^h'%%%egdk^YZh VhiVijh gZedgi dceVaZdeVi]dad\n[dgcdc"VYjaih#6YY^i^dcVa^aajhigVi^dchVcYiZX]" c^fjZh VgZ [djcY ^c 7j^`higV VcY JWZaV`Zg &..) VcY AdkZaa '%%%# I]Z gZVYZg ^h jg\ZY id Xdchjai i]ZhZ hdjgXZh l]Zc ldg`^c\ l^i] ediZci^Vaan eVi]dad\^XVa ]jbVc h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#I]^hX]VeiZg^h^ciZcYZYidhjeeaZbZcii]ZhZiZmihVcY^hdg\Vc^oZY VXXdgY^c\an#>i^hYZh^\cZYidegdk^YZi]ZgZVYZgl^i]Vc^cigdYjXi^dcidi]Z`^cYhd[ YZciVaVcYdhiZdad\^XVaeVi]dad\nZcXdjciZgZYbdhiXdbbdcan^cldg`l^i]egZ]^h" idg^X h`ZaZiVa gZbV^ch# 6aa ^aajhigViZY ZmVbeaZh d[ dhiZdad\^XVa eVi]dad\n VgZ YgVlc [gdb i]Z 7Zg`ZaZn Eg^bViZ H`ZaZiVa 8daaZXi^dc! bdhi d[ i]Zb [gdb VgX]Zdad\^XVa XdciZmih#>chjbbVg^o^c\ldg`dci]^hXdaaZXi^dc!G^X]VgYhVcY6ci‹c&.-,cdiZ i]Vi^ci]ZÄkZi]djhVcY^cY^k^YjVahZmVb^cZY!dkZgdcZ"Ä[i]h]dlZYVcdbVadjhYZ" kZadebZcidgi]ZZ[[ZXihd[eVi]dad\^XVaegdXZhhZh#I]Z^gYViVh]dli]ViYZ\ZcZgVi^kZ _d^ciY^hZVhZ!eZg^dYdciVaY^hZVhZ![gVXijgZ!VcYdhiZdbnZa^i^hVgZi]ZaZVY^c\X]Vc\Zh dWhZgkZY^ci]^hbdhianegZ]^hidg^X8Va^[dgc^VcXdaaZXi^dc#

&,DhiZdad\^XVa9ZciVaEVi]dad\n

(&&

&IGURE=ZVaZY[gVXijgZ# I]^haZ[iXaVk^XaZh]dlhV edhibdgiZb[gVXijgZi]Z a^\]i"XdadgZYWdcZVgdjcY i]ZXgVX`k^h^WaZ^ci]^h ^c[Zg^dgk^ZlVcYVbdgZ bZY^VaVciZbdgiZb[gVXijgZ i]Vi]Vh]ZVaZY#I]Zdg^\^cVa h]V[ihjg[VXZhVgZ_d^cZYWnV WdcnXVaajh#I]ZgVY^d\gVe] h]dlhi]Vii]ZbZY^VaZcY d[i]^hXaVk^XaZgdiViZY XdjciZgXadX`l^hZgZaVi^kZid ^ihaViZgVaZcY!gZhjai^c\^c VYgVbVi^Xb^hVa^\cbZcid[ i]Z[gVXijgZYe^ZXZhYjg^c\ VcYV[iZg]ZVa^c\#EgZ]^hidg^X! 8Va^[dgc^V#DcZ"]Va[cVijgVa h^oZ#

4RAUMA I]ZbdhiXdbbdceVi]dad\nV[[ZXi^c\i]Zh`ZaZidc^hYZ\ZcZgVi^kZX]Vc\Z#IgVjbV dXXje^ZhhZXdcYeaVXZVcYV[[ZXihi]Zh`ZaZidc^chZkZgValVnh¸ [gVXijg^c\dgY^had" XVi^c\i]ZWdcZ!Y^hgjei^c\^ihWaddYdgcZgkZhjeean!dgVgi^ÄX^VaanYZ[dgb^c\^i#HZZ BVgi^cVcY;gVnZg&..,[dg]dlhijY^Zhd[dhiZdad\^XVaigVjbV]VkZWZZcZbeadnZY id^ckZhi^\ViZk^daZcXZVcYlVg[VgZ^ci]ZeVhi#

&RACTURE ;gVXijgZ^cVWdcZdXXjghVhVgZhjaid[VWcdgbVa[dgXZhd[iZch^dc!XdbegZhh^dc!idg" h^dc! WZcY^c\! dg h]ZVg Veea^ZY id i]Z WdcZ# HZkZgVa edhh^WaZ ineZh d[ \gdhh [gVXijgZ ^cVWdcZbVngZhjai[gdbi]^hVWcdgbVahigZhh;^\jgZh&,#&VcY&,#'#6S_]`\UdU VbQSdebU^hdcZ^cl]^X]Wgd`ZcZcYhd[VWdcZWZXdbZhZeVgViZY#6cY^S_]`\UdU! dg¹WbUU^cdYS[!º[gVXijgZ^c[gVXi^dc^hdcZ^cl]^X]WgZV`V\ZVcYWZcY^c\d[VWdcZ VgZXdbW^cZY#6S_]]Y^edUTVbQSdebU^hdcZ^cl]^X]i]ZWdcZhea^ciZgh!l]ZgZVhV S_]`_e^TVbQSdebU^hV[gVXijgZ^cl]^X]i]ZWgd`ZcWdcZeZg[dgViZhi]Zh`^c#HdbZ [gVXijgZh d[ WdcZ VgZ Viig^WjiVWaZ id di]Zg eVi]dad\^XVa XVjhZh¸`QdX_\_WYSQ\ VbQS debUdXXjghVhVgZhjaid[WdcZhVagZVYn]Vk^c\WZZclZV`ZcZYWndi]ZgeVi]dad\^XVa dgbZiVWda^XXdcY^i^dchhjX]VhdhiZdedgdh^h# ;gVXijgZhd[WdcZhVgZd[iZcYZhXg^WZYWni]Z[ZVijgZhd[i]ZWgZV`^ihZa[/Xdbb^" cjiZYl]Zci]ZgZ^hh]ViiZg^c\d[WdcZ!XdbegZhhZYl]Zci]ZWdcZ^hhfjZZoZY!dgYZ" egZhhZYl]ZcWdcZ[gV\bZcihVgZYZegZhhZYWZadli]ZVY_VXZcihjg[VXZ# 

8]VeiZg&,DhiZdad\^XVa9ZciVaEVi]dad\n

&IGURE=ZVaZY[gVXijgZ#6WdkZI]^h aZ[igVY^jh]VhV]ZVaZYb^Yh]V[i[gVXijgZ# I]ZgVY^d\gVe]h]dlhi]Vii]Z[gVXijgZd[[hZi ^hVWdjiZfjVaidi]Zl^Yi]d[i]ZWdcZ#I]Z egdm^bVaeVgid[i]ZWdcZ^hd[[hZiedhiZg^dgan# EgZ]^hidg^X!8Va^[dgc^V#DcZ"]Va[cVijgVah^oZ#

&IGUREEhZjYVgi]gdh^h#G^\]iI]^haZ[i]jbZgjhlVhWgd`Zc_jhiVWdkZi]Zb^Yh]V[i# I]Z[gVXijgZ[V^aZYid]ZVaVcdcjc^dc!gZhjai^c\^cXdci^cjZYbdkZbZci!l]^X][dgbZYi]Z [VahZ_d^ci#EgZ]^hidg^X!8Va^[dgc^V#DcZ"]Va[cVijgVah^oZ#

&,#&IgVjbV

(&(

;gVXijgZ]ZVa^c\^hYZhXg^WZY^c8]VeiZg)#6ciZbdgiZb[gVXijgZbVnWZY^[[Zg" Zci^ViZY[gdbedhibdgiZb[gVXijgZdcanl]ZcVXVaajh!i]Z]VgYi^hhjZ[dgbZYVii]Z h^iZd[VWgd`ZcWdcZYjg^c\i]Z]ZVa^c\egdXZhh!^hegZhZci#6aadi]Zg[gVXijgZhi]Vi dXXjgVidgVgdjcYi]Zi^bZd[YZVi]h]djaYWZY^V\cdhZYVheZg^bdgiZb#;jaa[gVXijgZ ]ZVa^c\XVcXdbeaZiZangZbdkZVcn\gdhhh^\chd[[gVXijgZ!ZkZc^cVgVY^d\gVe]#I]Z gViZd[[gVXijgZgZeV^gYZeZcYhdc[gV\bZciVa^\cbZci!i]ZVbdjcid[bdkZbZciVi i]Zh^iZd[[gVXijgZ!VcYi]Z]ZVai]!V\Z!Y^Zi!VcYWaddYhjeeand[i]Z^cY^k^YjVa#HdbZ [gVXijgZhcZkZg]ZVaWZXVjhZd[Xdci^cjZYbdkZbZciVii]ZWgd`Zchjg[VXZ#Cdcjc^dch YZkZadebdhi[gZfjZcian^ci]ZVeeZcY^XjaVgh`ZaZidc#>i^hedhh^WaZi]ViVcZl¹_d^ci!º dg`cUeTQbdXb_cYc!l^aa[dgbVii]Z[gVXijgZh^iZ;^\jgZ&,#(# IgVjbVhjX]VhhldgYXjihdgVggdleZg[dgVi^dchidWdcZhXdchi^ijiZheZX^Va`^cYh d[[gVXijgZh#HjX]ldjcYhVgZXVeVWaZd[]ZVa^c\i]gdj\]i]ZhVbZegdXZhhZhYZhXg^WZY ^c8]VeiZg)#>cVcn`^cYd[[gVXijgZ!VY_VXZciWdcZ^hhjhXZei^WaZidhjWhZfjZcieVi]d" ad\^XVaXdbea^XVi^dchhjX]Vh^c[ZXi^dc!i^hhjZYZVi]!YZ[dgb^in!VcYVgi]g^i^hWgdj\]i dcWni]Z^c^i^VaigVjbV# I]ZVcVanh^hd[[gVXijgZhVii]ZedejaVi^dcVaaZkZaXVcWZkZgn^c[dgbVi^kZ^cVY" YgZhh^c\ fjZhi^dch d[ egZ]^hidg^X WZ]Vk^dg# ;dg ZmVbeaZ! AdkZ_dn VcY =Z^eaZ &.-& VhhZhhZYi]ZA^WWZcedejaVi^dcVcY[djcYi]Vii]ZdkZgVaa[gVXijgZgViZlVh]^\]#I]Z adl^cX^YZcXZd[[gVXijgZh^cX]^aYgZchj\\ZhiZYi]ViigVjbVi^XX]^aYVWjhZlVhcdi egVXi^XZY#I]ZgZhjaihd[i]Z^gVcVanh^hVahdhj\\ZhiZYi]Vi[gVXijgZg^h`lVh]^\]Zhi^c i]Z&%·'*VcY)* V\ZXViZ\dg^ZhVcYi]Vii]ZXVgZd[eVi^ZcihlVhZca^\]iZcZYVcY h`^aa[jaVbdc\i]^hCVi^kZ6bZg^XVc\gdje#

$ISLOCATION >cVYY^i^dcidXVjh^c\WdcZ[gVXijgZ!igVjbVidi]Zh`ZaZidcXVcVahd^ckdakZbdkZ" bZcid[_d^cieVgi^X^eVcihdjid[XdciVXil^i]i]Zh^bjaiVcZdjhY^hgjei^dcd[i]Z_d^ci XVehjaZ# >[ i]Z WdcZh eVgi^X^eVi^c\ ^c i]Z _d^ci gZbV^c Y^hadXViZY! i]Z gZhjai bVn WZ Y^V\cdhZYdhiZdad\^XVaan;^\jgZ&,#)#L]Zci]Z_d^ci^hY^hadXViZY!i]ZVgi^XjaVgXVg" i^aV\ZXVccdidWiV^ccdjg^h]bZci[gdbi]Zhncdk^VaÅj^Y!i]ZXVgi^aV\ZY^h^ciZ\gViZh! VcY Vgi]g^i^X X]Vc\Zh dXXjg# DhiZdad\^XVa bVc^[ZhiVi^dch d[ Y^hadXVi^dc VgZ jhjVaan XdcÄcZYidVYjaih#I]Zk^daZciigVjbVcZXZhhVgn[dgY^hadXVi^dcjhjVaanhZeVgViZhi]Z Ze^e]nhZh ^c hjWVYjaih! VcY ha^eeZY [ZbdgVa Ze^e]nhZh VgZ Xdbbdc ^c _jkZc^aZh# >c i]Z ZaYZgan! i]Z bdgZ Wg^iiaZ WdcZ jhjVaan \^kZh lVn! [gVXijg^c\ eg^dg id Y^hadXVi^dc# I]Zild_d^cihbdhid[iZcY^heaVn^c\dhiZdad\^XVabVc^[ZhiVi^dchd[Y^hadXVi^dcVgZi]Z h]djaYZgVcY]^e_d^cih# 

!RTIlCIAL$EFORMATION ;gVXijgZVcYY^hadXVi^dcYZhXg^WZYZVga^ZggZhjai[gdbhjYYZcigVjbVidi]Zh`ZaZidc! Wjiadc\"iZgbigVjbVXVcVahdbdY^[ni]Zh]VeZd[VWdcZ#9Z[dgb^i^Zhd[i]^h`^cY VgZ^cYjXZYbdhid[iZcVhVgZhjaid[XjaijgVaegVXi^XZhhjX]VhXgVYaZWdVgY^c\!bVhhV\" ^c\!dgW^cY^c\i]ZXgVc^Vd[^c[Vcih#6cdi]ZgZmVbeaZ^hi]Z[ddi"W^cY^c\egVXi^XZYWn 8]^cZhZldbZcd[]^\]hiVijh#I]ZbdhiXdbbdcbVc^[ZhiVi^dchd[Vgi^ÄX^VaYZ[dg" bVi^dcd[i]Zh`ZaZidcVgZi]dhZd[i]ZXgVc^jb#8jaijgZhVgdjcYi]ZldgaY]VkZ![dg 

8]VeiZg&,DhiZdad\^XVa9ZciVaEVi]dad\n

&IGURE9^hadXVi^dc# I]^haZ[i]^e_d^cih]dlh i]Vii]Z[ZbdgVa]ZVY Y^hadXViZYVciZgdhjeZg^dgan [gdb^ihdg^\^cVaeaVXZ l^i]^ci]ZVXZiVWjajb# I]ZXgdhhhZXi^dcd[i]Z [ZbdgVacZX`^hhZZc^c i]ZedhiZmXVkVi^dcWgZV`! l]^X][VXZhi]Zk^ZlZg# DhiZdVgi]g^i^hhZXdcYVgn idi]ZigVjbV^hZk^YZci# EgZ]^hidg^X!8Va^[dgc^V# DcZ"]Va[cVijgVah^oZ#

XdhbZi^XgZVhdch!VaiZgZYi]Zh]VeZd[i]ZVYjai]ZVYWneaVX^c\VWcdgbVaegZhhjgZh dci]ZYZkZade^c\h`jaa#DgicZgVcYEjihX]Vg&.-&YZhXg^WZi]^hegVXi^XZWneZdeaZ dcZkZgnXdci^cZciZmXZei6jhigVa^V!Wji7gdlc¼h&.-&ldg`i]ZgZhj\\Zhihi]Vii]Z egVXi^XZlVhXdci^cZciVaanjW^fj^idjh#7di]XjaijgVaVcYW^dad\^XVa^c[dgbVi^dcXVc XdbZ[gdbi]ZVcVanh^hd[^ciZci^dcVaanYZ[dgbZYXgVc^V#;dgZmVbeaZ!6ci‹c&.-. ]Vh jhZY ^ciZci^dcVa VciZgdedhiZg^dg VcY X^gXjb[ZgZci^Va XgVc^Va kVjai YZ[dgbVi^dc ^cVEZgjk^VchVbeaZidhijYni]ZgZaVi^dch]^eWZilZZci]ZXgVc^VakVjaiVcYi]ZWVhZ ^ci]ZYZkZadebZcid[i]ZXgVc^d[VX^VaXdbeaZm#D¼Adj\]a^c'%%)cdiZhi]ZZ[[ZXi d[XgVc^VaYZ[dgbVi^dc^cXgZVh^c\ldgb^VcWdcZcjbWZg#HdbZZmVbeaZhd[Vgi^ÄX^Va XgVc^VaYZ[dgbVi^dcVgZ^aajhigViZY^c;^\jgZh&,#*VcY&,#+# 

4REPHINATIONAND!MPUTATION DgicZg VcY EjihX]Vg &.-& YZhXg^WZ dbU`XY^QdY_^! dg dbU`Q^QdY_^! Vh eZg]Veh i]Z bdhigZbVg`VWaZigVjbVhZZcWni]ZeVaZdeVi]dad\^hi;^\jgZ&,#,#Lg^iiZcVXXdjcih YdXjbZci^c\i]^hegVXi^XZZmiZcYidi]ZVcX^Zci
(&*

&IGURE6gi^ÄX^VaXgVc^VaYZ[dgbVi^dc#8^gXjb[ZgZci^VaYZ[dgbVi^dc^hegdYjXZYWn lgVee^c\i]ZgZVgd[i]ZXgVc^VakVjai#EgZ]^hidg^X!EZgj#DcZ"]Va[cVijgVah^oZ#

&IGURE 6gi^ÄX^VaXgVc^Va YZ[dgbVi^dc# 6ciZgdedhiZg^dg YZ[dgbVi^dc^h XVjhZYWni]Z Veea^XVi^dcd[ egZhhjgZ[gdb WZ]^cY#EgZ]^hidg^X! EZgj#DcZ"]Va[ cVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&,DhiZdad\^XVa9ZciVaEVi]dad\n

hjgeg^h^c\an]^\]#HdbZedhibdgiZbigZe]^cVi^dclVhYdcZid[Vh]^dcVbjaZih[dgi]Z VYdgcbZcid[hjgk^kdgh#6gcdiiZiVa#'%%(egdk^YZVcdkZgk^Zld[igZe]^cVi^dc# :k^YZcXZd[VbejiVi^dcbVnWZdWhZgkZYdci]Zh`ZaZidc^ci]Z[dgbd[b^hh^c\ VeeZcYV\ZhdgeVgihd[VeeZcYV\Zh#9^V\cdh^c\VciZbdgiZb[gdbeZg^bdgiZbVbej" iVi^dc!V\V^c!YZeZcYhdci]ZegZhZcXZd[]ZVa^c\dg^c[ZXi^dcd[i]ZWdcZi^hhjZVii]Z ed^cid[igVjbV#

)NFECTIOUS$ISEASESAND!SSOCIATED-ANIFESTATIONS >c[ZXi^djhY^hZVhZ]Vhadc\WZZcVbV_dgXVjhZd[YZVi]^c]jbVcedejaVi^dch#Jc" [dgijcViZan!YZVa^c\l^i]dhiZdad\^XVaZk^YZcXZd[^c[ZXi^djhY^hZVhZXVcWZ[gjhigVi^c\ WZXVjhZ[Zl^c[ZXi^djhY^hZVhZhaZVkZVcnY^gZXiZk^YZcXZd[i]Z^gZm^hiZcXZ^ci]Zh`Za" Zidc#BVcnd[i]ZX]gdc^X^c[ZXi^djhY^hZVhZhi]ViYdaZVkZdhiZdad\^XVah^\chegdYjXZ bdge]dad\^XVaandkZgaVee^c\gZhedchZh!bV`^c\Y^[[ZgZci^VaY^V\cdh^h^bedhh^WaZ# ?cdUYdYc^hV\ZcZgVaiZgb[dgVc^cÅVbbVi^dcd[WdcZi^hhjZXVjhZYWn^c[ZXi^dc dg^c_jgnVcY^hcdiheZX^ÄXVhidXVjhZ#I]ZiZgbh_cdU_]iU\YdYcVcY`UbY_cdYdYcVgZ ha^\]ianbdgZXdc[jh^c\WZXVjhZi]ZnhZgkZid\ZcZgVaanYZhXg^WZdhiZdad\^XVaXdcY^" i^dchVhlZaaVhid^YZci^[nheZX^ÄXY^hZVhZh0eZg^dhi^i^h^hVhnbeidb^cVY^hZVhZhnc" YgdbZ hjX] Vh hne]^a^h! Wji ^i ^h Vahd Xdbbdc ^c bVcn di]Zg Y^hZVhZh DgicZg VcY EjihX]Vg!&.-&#

&IGUREIgZe]^cVi^dc#I]gZZVgi^ÄX^VaanegdYjXZY]daZhVgZZk^YZcidci]^hi]gZZ"fjVgiZg k^Zld[VXgVc^jb#I]Z]daZXadhZhiidi]ZeVg^ZiVaWdhh^hcZVganXdbeaZiZandWa^iZgViZYWn ]ZVa^c\#I]Zdi]Zg]daZhVahdh]dlhjWhiVci^VaWdcn]ZVa^c\!^cY^XVi^c\i]Vii]Z^cY^k^YjVa hjgk^kZYi]ZdeZgVi^dch#EgZ]^hidg^X!EZgj#DcZ"]Va[cVijgVah^oZ#

&,#'>c[ZXi^djh9^hZVhZh

(&,

/STEOMYELITIS ?cdU_]iU\YdYc^hWdcZ^cÅVbbVi^dcXVjhZYWnWVXiZg^Vi]VijhjVaan^c^i^VaanZciZg i]ZWdcZk^VVldjcY#I]^hY^hZVhZbV^canV[[ZXihi]Zadc\WdcZh;^\jgZ&,#-VcY^h YZÄcZYVhVc^c[ZXi^dci]Vi^ckdakZhi]ZbZYjaaVgnXVk^in#=dlZkZg!jhV\Z^ci]ZeVaZd" eVi]dad\na^iZgVijgZ]Vhd[iZcWZZc^begZX^hZ#DhiZdbnZa^i^h^hVabdhiValVnhXVjhZY Wn ejh"egdYjX^c\ b^Xgddg\Vc^hbh .% d[ i]Z i^bZ Wn HiVe]nadXdXXjh VjgZjh VcY ^h i]jhXVaaZYce``ebQdYfU!dg`i_WU^YS_cdU_]iU\YdYc#I]Zb^Xgddg\Vc^hbhXVcgZVX] i]ZWdcZY^gZXian!VhVgZhjaid[^c_jgnViVcnV\Z!dgk^Vi]ZWaddYhigZVb]ZbVid\Zcdjh dhiZdbnZa^i^h!bdhid[iZc[djcY^cX]^aYgZc#8]VgVXiZg^hi^X]VgYi^hhjZbVc^[ZhiVi^dch ^cXajYZVcY^f_\eSbe]d[XdVghZanldkZcWdcZVgdjcYi]Zdg^\^cVaadc\WdcZXdgiZm VcYdcZdgbdgZdeZc^c\h[dgejhYgV^cV\ZXVaaZYS\_QSQUÍcde\QU#I]ZaViiZgdeZc i]gdj\]i]Z^ckdajXgjb#

0ERIOSTITIS EZg^dhi^i^h^hVXdcY^i^dcd[^cÅVbbVi^dcd[i]ZeZg^dhiZjbXVjhZYWnigVjbVdg^c[ZX" i^dc#>i^hcdiVY^hZVhZ#HZZBZch[dgi]ZiVa#&.,-[dgVXdbeaZiZgZk^Zld[^ihkVg^djh Zi^dad\^Zh#I]ZhZVji]dghYZbdchigViZVcV\Z"heZX^ÄXY^hig^Wji^dcd[eZg^dhiZVagZVX" i^dchi]VihZZbhidXd^cX^YZl^i]¸VcYWZVgZhedchZid¸^c[ZXi^djhY^hZVhZ^c^c[Vcih VcYX]^aYgZc^ci]ZegZ]^hidg^XA^WWZcedejaVi^dc#EZg^dhi^i^h^ckdakZhdcani]ZdjiZg Xdgi^XVaWdcZ!l^i]dji^ckdakZbZcid[i]ZbVggdlXVk^inVh^cdhiZdbnZa^i^h#>iXVc WZVXjiZdgX]gdc^XVcY^idXXjghVcni^bZi]Z^ccZghjg[VXZd[i]ZeZg^dhiZjbgZVXihid ^chjaiWn[dgb^c\ldkZcWdcZi]VihaZZkZhi]ZjcYZgan^c\Xdgi^XVaWdcZ;^\jgZ&,#.#

4UBERCULOSIS IjWZgXjadh^h^hVX]gdc^X^c[ZXi^djhY^hZVhZi]VigZhjaih[gdbVWVXiZg^jb!BnXdWVXiZ" g^jbijWZgXjadh^h#>c[ZXi^dc^hjhjVaank^Vi]ZgZhe^gVidgnhnhiZb!Wjidi]ZgWdYneVgih! ^cXajY^c\WdcZh!XVcVahdWZV[[ZXiZY#7dcZVcY_d^ciYZhigjXi^dcXVcgZhjai[gdbi]Z ^c[ZXi^dc#I]ZegZhZcXZd[egZ"8dajbW^VcijWZgXjadh^h^ci]ZCZlLdgaY^hVhhZhhZY Wn7j^`higV&.-&WVcYGdWZgihVcY7j^`higV'%%(#BdaZXjaVgldg`WnHVadVcY XdaaZV\jZhXdcÄgbZYdhiZdad\^XVadWhZgkVi^dch^c&..)#6kVg^Zind[WdcZhXVcWZV[" [ZXiZYWnijWZgXjadh^h!Wjii]ZkZgiZWgVaXdajbc^hi]ZbdhiXdbbdceg^bVgn[dXjh# I]ZbdhiXdbbdcbVc^[ZhiVi^dcl]Zck^ZlZY[gdbi]Zh^YZ^hi]ZXdaaVehZd[dcZ dghZkZgVakZgiZWgVaWdY^ZhXVjh^c\Vh]VgeVc\aZ^ci]Zhe^cZ[i`X_cYc#9^[[ZgZci^Va Y^V\cdhZh[gdbdhiZdbnZa^i^hVcYhZei^XVgi]g^i^hVgZd[iZcedhh^WaZWZXVjhZijWZgXjad" h^hh]dlhYZhigjXi^dcVcYXVk^iVi^dc^cXVcXZaadjhWdcZ!l^i]djiZmiZch^kZVhhdX^ViZY gZVXi^kZWdcZ#I]ZeViiZgcd[ZaZbZci^ckdakZbZci!l^i]i]ZkZgiZWgVZVcYdhXdmVZVh [dX^!bVg`hijWZgXjadh^h#>cVYY^i^dc!i]ZgZ^hcdZk^YZcXZd[hZfjZhigVi^dc!Vc^ckdaj" Xgjb!dg[jh^dcd[i]Z_d^cih#DgicZgVcYEjihX]Vg&.-&Y^hXjhhVcY^aajhigViZi]Z h`ZaZiVaZ[[ZXihd[ijWZgXjadh^h#



8]VeiZg&,DhiZdad\^XVa9ZciVaEVi]dad\n

&IGUREDhiZdbnZa^i^h#I]Zi^W^Vdc i]ZaZ[ih]dlhadXVa^oZYgZVXi^kZWdcZVcY VXadVXV!l]ZgZVhi]Vidci]Zg^\]ih]dlh i]ZgZhjaid[VbdgZZmiZch^kZgZVXi^dc idi]Z^c[ZXi^dc#GVY^d\gVe]hd[i]Zild WdcZhh]dlXaZVg^ckdakZbZcid[i]Z bZYjaaVgnXVk^in#EgZ]^hidg^X!8Va^[dgc^V# DcZ"]Va[cVijgVah^oZ#

&,#'>c[ZXi^djh9^hZVhZh

(&.

4REPONEMAL)NFECTIONS H`ZaZiVaanh^\c^ÄXVciY^hZVhZhXVjhZYWnVb^Xgddg\Vc^hb`cdlcVhVhe^gdX]VZiZ^c i]Z\ZcjhIgZedcZbVVgZnVlhVcYZcYZb^XVcYkZcZgZVahne]^a^h#I]ZhZY^hZVhZh]VkZ VldgaYl^YZY^hig^Wji^dcidYVn!WjiXdch^YZgVWaZXdcigdkZghnZm^hihdkZgi]Z^gdg^\^ch VcYY^hig^Wji^dchZkZgVa]jcYgZYnZVghV\d#9ZWViZXZciZghdcl]Zi]Zghne]^a^hb^h" Y^V\cdhZYVhaZegdhnlVhegZhZci^ci]ZDaYLdgaYWZ[dgZ8dajbWjhgZijgcZY[gdb i]ZCZlLdgaY#I]ZXdcigdkZghn^hlZaa"gZk^ZlZYWnWdi]HiZ^cWdX`&.,+VcYDgi" cZgVcYEjihX]Vg&.-&!l^i]VbdgZgZXZcijeYViZWn7V`ZgVcY6gbZaV\dh&.--# >chne]^a^h!i]Zb^Xgddg\Vc^hbhZciZgi]ZWdYni]gdj\]i]Zh`^cdgbjXdjhbZb" WgVcZh^iZh#IZgi^Vgnhne]^a^i^Xh`ZaZiVaaZh^dchdXXjgegd\gZhh^kZan!jhjVaanWZ\^cc^c\ WZilZZc'VcY&%nZVghV[iZg^c[ZXi^dc#I]ZhZXVcWZXdbeaZm!Wjii]ZgZ^hjhjVaanVc dhiZdad\^XVa[dXjhd[i]ZY^hZVhZ^ci]Z[gdciVaVcYeVg^ZiVah!i]Z[VX^Vah`ZaZidc!VcYi]Z i^W^V#>cY^k^YjVaaZh^dchbVncdiWZY^hi^c\j^h]VWaZ[gdbhdbZXVcXZgh!ijWZgXjadh^h! dgdi]Zg^c[ZXi^djhX]Vc\Zh#HiZ^cWdX`&.,+!DgicZgVcYEjihX]Vg&.-&!VcY7jX`" aZnVcY9^Vh'%%'egdk^YZ[jgi]ZgYZiV^ah#

#IRCULATORY$ISTURBANCESAND(EMATOPOIETIC$ISORDERS L]ZcWaddYhjeeanidWdcZhhZZ8]VeiZg)^hjehZiWnigVjbVdgdi]ZgY^hZVhZh!V kVg^Zin d[ Wdcn bVc^[ZhiVi^dch XVc dXXjg! ^cXajY^c\ YZVi] d[ WdcZ i^hhjZ# 6cZb^Vh XVcVahdV[[ZXii]Z\gdhhVeeZVgVcXZd[WdcZh#>gdcYZÄX^ZcX^Zh!h^X`aZXZaaVcZb^V!VcY i]VaVhhZb^VVaagZhjai^ci]ZZmeVch^dcd[heVXZhdXXje^ZYWn]ZbVided^Zi^XbVggdl l^i]^ci]ZWdcZh#I]ZgZhjai^hd[iZck^h^WaZ^ci]Zh`jaa!l^i]Vl^YZc^c\d[i]ZY^ead… aZVY^c\idVi]^X`Zc^c\d[i]ZXgVc^VakVjai#O^bbZgbVcVcY@ZaaZn&.-'ViiZbeiV Y^[[ZgZci^VaY^V\cdh^hd[Y^[[ZgZciineZhd[VcZb^Vh# @_b_dYSXi`Ub_cd_cYc!dgc`_^WiXi`Ub_cd_cYc!^hVXdcY^i^dcZm]^W^i^c\aZh^dch! jhjVaand[i]ZXgVc^VakVjai#I]ZhZgZegZhZciVi]^cc^c\VcYd[iZcXdbeaZiZYZhigjXi^dc d[i]ZdjiZgiVWaZd[i]ZXgVc^VakVjaii]VigZhjaih^cVh^ZkZ"a^`Zdg¹XdgVa"a^`ZºVeeZVg" VcXZd[i]ZZXidXgVc^Vahjg[VXZ#I]ZaZh^dchhZZb idWZXVjhZYWnVcZb^V"VhhdX^ViZY ]neZgigde]nd[i]ZY^ead…WZilZZci]Z^ccZgVcYi]ZdjiZgiVWaZh#Edgdi^X]neZgdh" idh^h^hbdhid[iZchZZc^c^bbVijgZ^cY^k^YjVahVcY^hgZXd\c^oVWaZVhVedgdh^ind[ i]Z XgVc^Va kVjai# >i ^h jhjVaan W^aViZgVaan hnbbZig^XVa! [dXjhZY dc i]Z eVg^ZiVah VcY i]ZVciZgdaViZgVafjVYgVcid[i]ZdgW^iVagdd[h#I]ZdgW^iVaaZh^dchVgZXVaaZYSbYRbQ _bRYdQ\YQ!VcYVh^b^aVgY^hijgWVcXZd[i]ZZcYdXgVc^Vahjg[VXZ^hXVaaZYSbYRbQSbQ^YY ;^\jgZ&,#&%# 8VjhZhd[i]^hWdcngZVXi^dc]VkZWZZcZmiZch^kZanheZXjaViZY#>ih]^\][gZfjZcXn ^ci]Zhdji]lZhid[Cdgi]6bZg^XVlVhdcXZi]dj\]iidWZWZXVjhZd[VbV^oZ"WVhZY! ^gdc"YZÄX^ZciY^Zi#=dlZkZg!ldg`dci]Ze]ZcdbZcdc^cVaVg\ZhVbeaZd[8Va^[dgc^V h`ZaZidch cdcV\g^XjaijgVa! Äh]"YZeZcYZci Wn LVa`Zg &.-+ hj\\ZhiZY i]Vi edgdi^X ]neZgdhidh^h ^h hdbZi^bZh YjZ id cjig^Zci adhhZh VhhdX^ViZY l^i] Y^Vgg]ZVa Y^hZVhZh gVi]Zgi]VcidY^ZieZghZ!Vedh^i^dchjeedgiZYWn@Zci&.-,#>cVhijYnd[h`ZaZiVa gZbV^ch[gdbi]ZegZ]^hidg^Xhdji]lZhi!EVa`dk^X]&.-,hj\\Zhihi]ViZcYZb^XVaan ^cVYZfjViZbViZgcVaY^ZiXVcXdbW^cZl^i]^c[ZXi^dcidegdYjXZkZgnZVgandchZid[ ^gdc"YZÄX^ZciVcZb^Vl^i]gZhjaiVciedgdi^X]neZgdhidh^h#GZhZVgX]WnHijVgi"BVXVY" Vb&.-,V!WhigZhhZhi]ZVhhdX^Vi^dcWZilZZcdhiZdad\^XVabVc^[ZhiVi^dchVcYVcZb^V! 

8]VeiZg&,DhiZdad\^XVa9ZciVaEVi]dad\n

&IGUREEZg^dhi^i^h#aZ[iI]Zg^\]ii^W^VVcYaZ[ijacVd[i]ZhVbZ^cY^k^YjVah]dl gZVXi^kZWdcZi]VidkZga^Zhi]ZXdgiZm#>c\gdhhVheZXii]ZedhibdgiZbZm[da^Vi^dcd[gZVXi^kZ WdcZ]VhZmedhZYi]ZjcYZgan^c\XdgiZmdci]ZedhiZg^dgjacVgZY\Z#EgZ]^hidg^X!8Va^[dgc^V# DcZ"]Va[cVijgVah^oZ#g^\]iI]ZhXVcc^c\ZaZXigdcb^Xgd\gVe]h]dlhVXgdhhhZXi^dci]gdj\] i]Zhjg[VXZd[Vh^b^aVganV[[ZXiZY^cY^k^YjVa#HXVaZ/Veegdm^bViZan'%#

VhjW_ZXi[jgi]ZggZk^ZlZYWnLVeaZgZiVa#'%%)#Jh^c\i]ZegZ]^hidg^XA^WWZchVbeaZ! BZch[dgi]ZiVa#&.,-YZbdchigViZi]Viedgdi^X]neZgdhidh^h^hXdbbdcanXVjhZYWn i]Z cdgbVa hZfjZaVZ d[ ^c[ZXi^dc# 6h cdiZY ZVga^Zg! i]Zn [djcY V Y^gZXi gZaVi^dch]^e WZilZZceZg^dhi^i^h^c[ZXi^dcVcYedgdi^X]neZgdhi^i^h^gdcYZÄX^ZcXn^chjWVYjaih# I]^h^hXdch^hiZcil^i]Xa^c^XVaYViVi]Vihj\\Zhii]Vi^gdcbVnWZhZfjZhiZgZYl^i]^c i]ZWdYnVhVYZ[ZchZV\V^chi^c[ZXi^dc#I]jh!bjX]egZ]^hidg^Xedgdi^X]neZgdhidh^h &,#(8^gXjaVidgn9^hijgWVcXZhVcY=ZbVided^Zi^X9^hdgYZgh

('&

bVnWZi]ZhZXdcYVgnXdchZfjZcXZd[^c[ZXi^djhY^hZVhZ!cdid[Y^Zi#>cYZZY!HijVgi" BVXVYVb&..&edh^ihi]Viedgdi^X]neZgdhidh^h^hi]ZgZhjaid[Vc^ciZgVXi^dcVbdc\ Xjhidbh!Y^Zi!]n\^ZcZ!eVgVh^iZh!VcY^c[ZXi^djhY^hZVhZh#H]Z[ZZahZk^YZcXZ[dgX]gdc^X Y^hZVhZ^ch`ZaZiVabViZg^Vah]djaYcdiWZ^ciZgegZiZYVhVc^cY^k^YjVa¼h^cVW^a^inid VYVeiidi]ZZck^gdcbZciWjigVi]ZgVhZk^YZcXZd[i]Z^cY^k^YjVa¼hÄ\]i[dg]ZVai] V\V^chii]ZeVi]d\Zc#

&IGURE8g^WgV dgW^iVa^V!edgdi^X ]neZgdhidh^h#I]Zh`jaad[V *"nZVg"daYX]^aY^hh]dlc^c VciZgd^c[Zg^dgVcYedhiZg^dg k^ZlhidY^heaVni]ZXg^WgV dgW^iVa^Vd[i]Z[gdciVa^c i]Zgdd[hd[i]ZdgW^ihVcY hedc\n]neZgdhidh^hd[ i]ZeVg^ZiVahVcYdXX^e^iVa# EgZ]^hidg^X!EZgj#DcZ"]Va[ cVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&,DhiZdad\^XVa9ZciVaEVi]dad\n

-ETABOLICAND(ORMONAL)MBALANCE CVggdlanYZÄcZY!bZiVWda^XY^hdgYZghd[WdcZVgZY^hdgYZgh^cl]^X]VgZYjXi^dc^c WdcZbVhh^hi]ZgZhjaid[^cVYZfjViZdhiZd^YegdYjXi^dc!dgb^cZgVa^oVi^dcdgZmXZh" h^kZYZdhh^ÄXVi^dcd[WdcZ#Cjig^i^dcVaYZÄX^ZcX^ZhVgZjhjVaanXaVhh^ÄZYjcYZgbZiV" Wda^XY^hdgYZgh#=dgbdcVaY^hijgWVcXZhXVcVahdaZVYidYgVbVi^XX]Vc\Zh^ccdgbVa h`ZaZiVaVcVidbn#

3CURVY HXjgkn^hVbZiVWda^XY^hZVhZXVjhZYWnVadc\"iZgb^chj[ÄX^Zci^ciV`Zd[k^iVb^c8! l]^X]^hZhhZci^Va[dgi]ZegdYjXi^dcd[XdaaV\ZcVcY!i]ZgZ[dgZ!dhiZd^Y#H`ZaZiVabVc^" [ZhiVi^dchVgZbdhiVeeVgZci^c^c[Vcih!jhjVaan^ci]Z[dgbd[Xdgi^XVai]^cc^c\VcY eVi]dad\^XVa[gVXijgZh^cgVe^Yan\gdl^c\WdcZVgZVh#BVVi'%%)egdk^YZhVjhZ[ja gZk^ZlVcYXVhZhijYn#

2ICKETS G^X`Zih^hbdhid[iZcVcjig^i^dcVaY^hZVhZgZhjai^c\[gdbVc^chj[ÄX^ZciVbdjcid[ k^iVb^c9^ci]ZY^Zii]ViXVjhZhV[V^ajgZd[b^cZgVaYZedh^i^dc^ci]ZWdcZi^hhjZ#6h VgZhjai!ZmXZhh^kZjcXVaX^ÄZYdhiZd^YVXXjbjaViZh!VcYi]ZWdcZi^hhjZgZbV^chhd[i VcYÅZm^WaZ#I]ZY^hZVhZlVhYZhXg^WZY^ci]Z&+%%h!Wji^ihcjig^i^dcVahdjgXZlVhcdi Y^hXdkZgZYjci^ai]Z&.'%h#I]ZdhiZdad\^XVaZ[[ZXihd[g^X`ZihVgZegZhZcii]gdj\]dji i]Zh`ZaZidc!Wjii]ZnVgZbdhiegdcdjcXZY^ci]Za^bWh!l]^X]VgZjhjVaanWZciVcY Y^hidgiZY#I]ZaZ\hVgZX]VgVXiZg^hi^XVaanWdlZYdjilVgYdg^clVgY#>cVYjaih!i]ZhVbZ Y^ZiVgnYZÄX^ZcXn^hXVaaZYdhiZdbVaVX^V!VY^hZVhZjhjVaana^c`ZYid\ZcZgVabVacjig^" i^dc!eVgi^XjaVganidYZÄX^ZcX^Zh^cegdiZ^c![Vi!XVaX^jb!VcYe]dhe]dgjh#>ih\gZViZhi Z[[ZXi^hdcWdcZh^cl]^X]gZbdYZa^c\^h]^\]Zhig^Wh!hiZgcjb!kZgiZWgVZ!VcYeZak^h! bV`^c\i]ZbhjW_ZXiideVi]dad\^XVa[gVXijgZ#

/STEOPOROSIS ?cdU_`_b_cYc!dg_cdU_`U^YQ^ci]ZcdcXa^c^XVah^ijVi^dc!gZ[Zghidi]Z^cXgZVhZYed" gdh^ingZYjXZYYZch^ind[WdcZi]Vi^hbdhid[iZceVgid[i]ZV\^c\egdXZhh#>i^hVXdc" hZfjZcXZd[i]Z[V^ajgZd[i]Zdg\Vc^hbidbV^ciV^ci]ZWVaVcXZWZilZZcWdcZgZhdge" i^dcVcY[dgbVi^dc#EdhibZcdeVjhValdbZcVgZbdhiVig^h`[dgdhiZdedgdh^hWZXVjhZ d[i]ZXZhhVi^dcd[Zhigd\ZcegdYjXi^dc#BVaZhVgZZcYdlZY^c^i^Vaanl^i]bdgZWdcZ bVhhi]Vc[ZbVaZhVcYhdYdcdiWZXdbZkjacZgVWaZiddhiZdedgdh^hjci^aaViZg^ca^[Z ^ci]Z^g,%hVcY-%h#>i^hZhi^bViZYi]ViVccjVaXdhihVhhdX^ViZYl^i]dhiZdedgdh^h^c i]ZJc^iZYHiViZhVadcZ^ckdakZ,W^aa^dc#DhiZdedgdh^h^hVhhdX^ViZYl^i]&#'b^aa^dc WdcZ[gVXijgZh^ci]ZZaYZganZVX]nZVg#GZhZVgX]^cidWVh^XWdcZW^dad\n!eVgi^XjaVgan ^cidi]Z[VXidghi]ViVXi^kViZVcY^cVXi^kViZdhiZdXaVhih!]VhWZZchejggZYdcWni]ZhZ hiVi^hi^Xh#6\VglVaVcYHidji'%%(egdk^YZVcVci]gdedad\^XVaeZgheZXi^kZdcdhiZd" edgdh^h# &,#)BZiVWda^XVcY=dgbdcVa>bWVaVcXZ

('(

%NDOCRINE$ISTURBANCESAND$YSPLASIAS I]Z\gdli]d[i]Zh`ZaZidc^hXdcigdaaZY!^caVg\ZeVgi!Wni]ZhZXgZi^dcd[]dgbdcZh ^ci]Ze^ij^iVgnVcYi]ngd^Y#EVi]dad\n^ci]ZhZ\aVcYhXVcaZVYidZmigZbZh`ZaZiVa X]Vc\Zh# 7YWQ^dYc] gZhjaih [gdb ZmXZhh^kZ egdYjXi^dc d[ hdbVidigde]^X ]dgbdcZ VcYXdchZfjZcidkZghi^bjaVi^dcd[\gdli]XVgi^aV\ZhVcY\^\Vci^Xegdedgi^dchd[i]Z h`ZaZidc#1Sb_]UWQ\i^hh^b^aVganXVjhZYWnVcdkZganegdYjXi^kZe^ij^iVgn!WjiV[iZg i]ZZe^e]nhZhVgZ[jhZY#I]ZbdhiYgVbVi^XdhiZdad\^XVabVc^[ZhiVi^dcd[VXgdbZ\Van ^h\gdli]Vii]ZbVcY^WjaVgXdcYnaZVcYVgZhjai^c\Zadc\Vi^dcVcYY^hidgi^dcd[i]Z adlZg_Vl#4gQbÍc]^hXVjhZYWnVkVg^Zind[XdcY^i^dch#1SX_^Tb_`\QcYQ^hV]ZgZY^" iVgn[dgbd[YlVgÄhbl^i]a^bWh]dgiZc^c\!VabdhicdgbVaigjc`VcYkVjaiYZkZade" bZci!VcYVhbVaa[VXZ;^\jgZ&,#&&#>i^hV]ZgZY^iVgnY^hZVhZXVjhZYWni]ZXdc\Zc^iVa Y^hijgWVcXZd[XVgi^aV\Z[dgbVi^dcVii]ZZe^e]nhZh!Vh`ZaZiVaYnheaVh^VgVi]Zgi]VcVc ZcYdXg^cZY^hijgWVcXZ#

&IGURE6X]dcYgdeaVh^V#I]ZaZ[i]jbZgjhVcYaZ[i[Zbjgd[VcVX]dcYgdeaVhi^XYlVg[ [VgaZ[iVcY[Vgg^\]iVgZXdbeVgZYl^i]VcdgbVa]jbVc]jbZgjhVcY[Zbjg[gdbVh^c\aZ ^cY^k^YjVaXZciZg#CdiZi]ZY^hegdedgi^dchVcY[jaanVYjaihiVijhd[i]ZVX]dcYgdeaVhi^X ^cY^k^YjVa#EgZ]^hidg^X!8Va^[dgc^V#DcZ"[djgi]cVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&,DhiZdad\^XVa9ZciVaEVi]dad\n

4UMORS DhiZd\Zc^X cQbS_]Q ^h bdgZ Xdbbdc i]Vc Wdcn XVcXZg gZhjai^c\ [gdb bZiVhiVh^h# H`ZaZiVaijbdghjhjVaanhiZb[gdbdi]Zgi^hhjZhdjgXZh!VcYi]Z^gVeeZVgVcXZXVcWZ kZgnYgVbVi^X#BdYZgcXaVhh^ÄXVi^dchd[h`ZaZiVaijbdghcVbZdkZg[dginY^[[ZgZciij" bdgineZh^cWdcZVcYVhhdX^ViZYXVgi^aV\ZVcYÄWgdjhXdccZXi^kZi^hhjZ#=^hidad\^XVa heZX^bZchVcYW^dX]Zb^XVaYViVVgZjhjVaancZZYZYidhdgii]ZhZdji#IjbdghVgZY^" k^YZYhdbZl]ViVgW^igVg^an^cidWZc^\cdgbVa^\cVciVcYVgZXaVhh^ÄZYVXXdgY^c\id i]Zi^hhjZh^cl]^X]i]Zndg^\^cViZ#=e\dY`\U]iU\_]Q![dgZmVbeaZ!^hVgVgZeg^bVgn bVa^\cVciijbdgd[]ZbVided^Zi^Xi^hhjZ#>ihZ[[ZXidcWdcZi^hhjZh^hVl^YZhegZVYeVi" iZgcd[ani^XaZh^dchdckVg^djhh`ZaZiVaZaZbZcih# I]ZbdhiXdbbdcijbdgd[WdcZ^hVc_cdU_SX_^Tb_]Q#I]ZhZVgZWZc^\cij" bdgh! jhjVaan VhnbeidbVi^X# I]Zn ValVnh Vg^hZ Vi Ze^e]nhZVa a^cZh VcY egdigjYZ Vi g^\]iVc\aZhidi]Zadc\Vm^hd[VWdcZ#I]ZngZhZbWaZdhh^ÄZYiZcYdch^cbVcnXVhZh# 6c_cdU_]Q^hVbdjcYd[XdbeVXiWdcZ!jhjVaandci]ZZXidXgVc^Vahjg[VXZ0i]ZhZVgZ d[iZcXVaaZY¹WjiidcºdhiZdbViV:h]ZYZiVa#!'%%'#I]ZnVgZ]VgY!YZchZ!VcY^kdgn" a^`Z^cVeeZVgVcXZVcYdXXjg^cVWdji&d[VaaeZdeaZ#5QbUh_cd_cUcVgZ¹dhiZdbViVº d[i]Z^ccZgVheZXid[i]ZZmiZgcVaVjY^idgnbZVijh# I]ZbdhiXdbbdcan[dgbZYdhiZd\Zc^XhVgXdbVhdXXjgYjg^c\i]Z\gdli]eZg^dY# I]ZhZ^cXajYZ_cdU_cQbS_]QdQ!SX_^Tb_cQbS_]QdQ!VcY5gY^WÄccQbS_]QdQ#7di] HiZ^cWdX`&.,+VcYDgicZgVcYEjihX]Vg&.-&egdk^YZ\ddY^c[dgbVi^dcdci]ZhZ gVgZXVcXZgh#

!RTHRITIS 1bdXbYdYc^hi]Z^cÅVbbVi^dcd[V_d^ci¸V\ZcZgVa^cÅVbbVi^dci]Vi^cXajYZhhd[i i^hhjZZ[[ZXih#I]Z^cÅVbbVi^dcXVcXdbZVhVgZhjaid[igVjbVVhlZaaVhd[WdcZVcY _d^ci^c[ZXi^dchhZZGd\ZghZiVa#!&.-,![dgVhjbbVgnVcYXaVhh^ÄXVi^dc#

/STEOARTHRITIS ?cdU_QbdXbYdYc!i]ZbdhiXdbbdc[dgbd[Vgi]g^i^h!^hX]VgVXiZg^oZYWnYZhigjXi^dc d[i]ZVgi^XjaVgXVgi^aV\Z^cV_d^ciVcY[dgbVi^dcd[VY_VXZciWdcZ!^ci]Z[dgbd[Wdcn a^ee^c\VcYhejg[dgbVi^dc_cdU_`XidUc!VgdjcYi]ZZY\Zhd[i]Z_d^ci#6WZiiZgiZgb [dgi]^he]ZcdbZcdc^hTUWU^UbQdYfUZ_Y^dTYcUQcU;^\jgZh&,#&'·&,#&)#I]ZXVjhZh d[i]^hY^hZVhZVgZ![dgi]ZbdhieVgi!bZX]Vc^XVa#I]ZY^hZVhZdXXjghbdhian^cadVY" WZVg^c\_d^cih!eVgi^XjaVgan^ci]Zhe^cZ!i]Z]^e!VcYi]Z`cZZh#DhiZdVgi]g^i^h^hVc ^c]ZgZcieVgid[i]ZV\^c\egdXZhh#;dgVgZk^Zld[XjggZci`cdlaZY\ZVWdjidhiZdVg" i]g^i^h!Xdchjai:ehiZ^c&.-.!VcY[dgVgZk^Zld[egZ]^hidg^XVgi]g^i^h^ci]Z6bZg^XVh! hZZ7g^Y\Zh&..'# DhiZdVgi]g^i^h^hjhjVaanXaVhh^ÄZYVhZ^i]Zgeg^bVgn!gZhjai^c\[gdbVXdbW^cVi^dc d[[VXidghi]Vi^cXajYZV\Z!hZm!]dgbdcZh!bZX]Vc^XVahigZhh!VcY\ZcZi^XegZY^hedh^" i^dc!dghZXdcYVgn!^c^i^ViZYWnigVjbVdgVcdi]ZgXVjhZhjX]Vhi]Z^ckVh^dcd[i]Z _d^ciWnWVXiZg^VcU`dYS!dg`i_WU^YSQbdXbYdYc¸d[iZcVXdbea^XVi^dcd[dhiZdbnZa^" i^h#HijY^Zhd[i]ZeViiZgc^c\d[dhiZdVgi]g^i^XaZh^dchd[i]Zh`ZaZidcVii]Z^cY^k^YjVa &,#*Ijbdgh

('*

&IGUREDhiZdVgi]g^i^h#I]ZcdgbVaajbWVgkZgiZWgVaZ[iaVX`hi]ZdhiZde]niZ YZkZadebZcihZZcdci]ZVciZg^dgVcYaViZgVaZY\Zhd[i]ZkZgiZWgVl^i]YZ\ZcZgVi^kZVgi]g^i^h g^\]i#EgZ]^hidg^X!8Va^[dgc^V#DcZ"]Va[cVijgVah^oZ#

&IGUREDhiZdVgi]g^i^h#:WjgcVi^dcVcYbVg\^cVaa^ee^c\VgZZk^YZcidci]^haZ[i `cZZ_d^ci!hZZc]ZgZ^cedhiZgdaViZgVak^ZlVcYa^i[gdbi]ZadlZgg^\]iidh]dlYZiV^a#I]Z ZWjgcVi^dc^hi]Z^kdgn"a^`Z!h]^cneViX]dci]ZbZY^Va[ZbdgVaVcYi^W^VaXdcYnaZh#EgZ]^hidg^X! 8Va^[dgc^V#DcZ"]Va[cVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&,DhiZdad\^XVa9ZciVaEVi]dad\n

&IGURE DhiZdVgi]g^i^h#IgVjbVid i]^haZ[i[ZbjgegdYjXZY hZXdcYVgndhiZdVgi]g^i^X X]Vc\Zhidi]Z_d^ci!hZZc ]ZgZ^ci]Z[dgbd[VWdcn ZmiZch^dcVcYYZ[dgbVi^dc d[i]Z[ZbdgVa]ZVYVcY VWj^aYjed[dhiZde]niZh VgdjcYi]ZeZg^bZiZg d[i]ZVXZiVWjajb# EgZ]^hidg^X!8Va^[dgc^V# DcZ"i]^gYcVijgVah^oZ#

VcYVii]ZedejaVi^dcaZkZaXVch]ZYa^\]idcegZ]^hidg^XVXi^k^ineViiZgch#;dgZmVbeaZ! BZgWh&.-(lVhVWaZidh]dli]VidhiZdVgi]g^i^XX]Vc\ZhhZZc^c[ZbVaZ=jYhdc7Vn >cj^ih`ZaZidchXdggZaViZYl^i]Zi]cd\gVe]^XVXXdjcihVcYVgX]Zdad\^XVaZk^YZcXZ[dg hXgVe^c\VcYXjii^c\Vc^bVa]^YZhVcYhZl^c\!l]ZgZVhaZh^dchhZZc^cbVaZhXdggZaViZY l^i]]Vgeddci]gdl^c\VcY`VnV`eVYYa^c\# 6e]ZcdbZcdcd[iZc[djcYVhhdX^ViZYl^i]dhiZdVgi]g^i^h^hUReb^QdY_^!i]ZgZ" hjaid[hjWX]dcYgVaWdcZWZ^c\ZmedhZYl]ZcXVgi^aV\Z^hYZhigdnZY#7dcZV[[ZXiZYi]^h lVniV`ZhdcVeda^h]ZY!^kdgn"a^`ZVeeZVgVcXZ;^\jgZ&,#&(#I]Zegd_ZXi^c\he^XjaZh d[ WdcZ VhhdX^ViZY l^i] dhiZdVgi]g^i^h VgZ XVaaZY dhiZde]niZh# CZVgan Vaa ^cY^k^YjVah daYZgi]Vc+%nZVghZm]^W^ii]ZhZVgi]g^i^X[ZVijgZh!ZheZX^Vaan^ci]ZadlZgi]dgVX^XVcY ajbWVggZ\^dch#Gd\ZghZiVa#&.-,!&.-.VhhZhhXaVhh^ÄXVi^dchd[dhiZdVgi]g^i^h!VcY 7g^Y\Zh&..(cdiZhi]Vii]ZhXdg^c\egdXZYjgZhjhZYidgZXdgYi]ZY^hZVhZhZg^djhan V[[ZXii]ZgZhjaihd[VcnXdbeVgVi^kZhijYn#

2HEUMATOID!RTHRITIS B^YYaZ"V\ZYldbZc]VkZVegZY^hedh^i^dc[dgi]^hVgi]g^i^h#>ihZmVXiXVjhZgZbV^ch jc`cdlcWjiVabdhiXZgiV^cankVg^Zhl^i]\ZcZi^XWVX`\gdjcY#>cg]ZjbVid^YVgi]g^" i^h!i]Z^bbjcZhnhiZbd[i]ZWdYnViiVX`h^ihdlcXVgi^aV\Z#7dcZX]Vc\ZhVgZVigde]^X VcYVgZZheZX^Vaan[dXjhZY^ci]Z]VcYhVcY[ZZi#I]ZaZh^dchVgZjhjVaanW^aViZgVaan hnbbZig^XVa# G]ZjbVid^Y Vgi]g^i^h ^h i]Z aZVhi Xdbbdc Vgi]gdeVi]n ^c VgX]Zdad\^" XVah`ZaZiVabViZg^Va#LddYhVcYGdi]hX]^aY&.--Vg\jZi]Vi^i^hZk^YZcXZY^cCZl LdgaYh`ZaZiVagZbV^ch!VcYGdi]hX]^aYZiVa#&..%egdedhZgZXd\c^i^dcXg^iZg^V[dg h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch# &,#+6gi]g^i^h

(',

!NKYLOSING3PONDYLITIS 6cQ^[i\_cYc^hVcVWcdgbVa^bbdW^a^indgÄmVi^dcd[V_d^cigZhjai^c\[gdbeVi]d" ad\^XVaX]Vc\Zh^ci]Z_d^ci#1^[i\_cY^Wc`_^Ti\YdYc^hVX]gdc^XVcYjhjVaanegd\gZh" h^kZY^hZVhZi]ViV[[ZXihi]ZkZgiZWgVaXdajbc#I]ZVhhdX^ViZY a^\VbZcihd[i]Zhe^cZ dhh^[n!VcYi]Z^ciZgkZgiZWgVa_d^cihWZXdbZ^bbdW^a^oZY#

$ENTAL0ATHOLOGY 7ZXVjhZi]ZiZZi]^ciZgVXiY^gZXianl^i]i]ZZck^gdcbZci!i]ZnVgZhjhXZei^WaZidYVb" V\Z[gdbe]nh^XVaVcYW^dad\^XVa^cÅjZcXZhcdideZgVi^c\dcdi]Zgh`ZaZiVaZaZbZcih# 6hijYnd[YZciVaeVi]dad\nXVcWZjhZ[ja[dg^ckZhi^\Vi^c\i]Z]ZVai]VcYY^Zihd[^cY^" k^YjVahVcYedejaVi^dch#:kZci]dj\]iddi]lZVgi]Vi^hZmXZhh^kZWnidYVn¼hhiVcYVgYh ]VhX]VgVXiZg^oZY]jbVchVcYi]Z^gVcXZhidgh[dgb^aa^dchd[nZVgh!^ih]djaYWZcdiZY i]Viiddi]lZVgVcYVgi^ÄX^Vaiddi]bdY^ÄXVi^dc]VkZWZZc^cXajYZY^ci]^hX]VeiZg dcan[dgXdckZc^ZcXZ#Aj`VXh&.-.Y^k^YZhYZciVaY^hZVhZh^cid[djgXViZ\dg^Zh/^c[ZX" i^djh!YZ\ZcZgVi^kZ!YZkZadebZciVa!VcY\ZcZi^X#6aad[i]ZhZ!d[XdjghZ!VgZ^ciZggZaViZY ^ci]ZYZciVa]ZVai]d[i]Z^cY^k^YjVa#Iddi]lZVgh]djaYWZi]dj\]id[VhVeVi]da"

&IGUREIddi]lZVg#=ZVknViig^i^dcdcYZci^i^dcd[i]^hVYjaibVaZ]VhZa^b^cViZYVaa Wjii]Zi]^gYbdaVgXgdlch#I]Z^cY^k^YjVaXdci^cjZYidX]Zldci]ZhijWhd[]^h^cX^hdgh! XVc^cZh!egZbdaVgh!VcYhZXdcYbdaVgV[iZgi]Ziddi]Xgdlch]VYldgcVlVn#HjX]lZVg^hV cdgbVae]ZcdbZcdc^cdaYZg^cY^k^YjVah[gdbVWdg^\^cVaedejaVi^dchl^i]\g^i^ci]ZY^Zi# EgZ]^hidg^X!8Va^[dgc^V#CVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&,DhiZdad\^XVa9ZciVaEVi]dad\n

d\ndcanl]Zc^i^hhdZmigZbZi]Vii]ZVhhdX^ViZYWdcZ^hV[[ZXiZYcZ\Vi^kZan#=^aahdc '%%'egdk^YZhVjhZ[jagZk^Zld[YZciVaeVi]dad\n!l^i]\j^YZa^cZh[dgVhhZhh^c\VcY hXdg^c\XVg^ZhVcYeZg^dYdciVaY^hZVhZ[daadl^c\]^h'%%&gZXdbbZcYVi^dch#8]Ve" iZg&.Xdch^YZgh]dliddi]lZVgbVnWZjhZYidV\Zh`ZaZiVabViZg^VaVcYY^hXjhhZh ]dlhjX]lZVgXVcWZjhZYidVhhZhhegZ]^hidg^XY^Zih#;^\jgZ&,#&*h]dlh]dlZmigZbZ iddi]lZVglVhjcYZgbVcnegZ]^hidg^XXdcY^i^dch#

#ARIES 9ZciVaSQbYUc^hVY^hZVhZegdXZhhX]VgVXiZg^oZYWni]Zegd\gZhh^kZYZXVaX^ÄXVi^dcd[ ZcVbZadgYZci^cZ#I]ZbVXgdhXde^XVeeZVgVcXZd[XVg^ZhXVckVgn[gdbdeVfjZhedih dci]ZXgdlcid\Ve^c\XVk^i^Zh^ci]Ziddi]#6egZgZfj^h^iZ[dgi]Z[dgbVi^dcd[YZciVa XVg^Zh^hTU^dQ\`\QaeUVcYVY^Zii]Vi^cXajYZh[ZgbZciVWaZXVgWd]nYgViZh#EaVfjZ^h i]ZbVig^mVcY^ih^c]VW^i^c\Xdbbjc^ind[WVXiZg^Vi]Vi[dgbhdci]Ziddi]#8Vg^djh aZh^dchXVcWZ\^cVcnl]ZgZi]VieaVfjZVXXjbjaViZh!bdhid[iZc^ci]ZÄhhjgZhd[iddi] XgdlchVcY^ci]Z^ciZgegdm^bVaVgZVh#;^\jgZ&,#&+h]dlhVaVg\ZXVg^djhaZh^dc# AVghZc &.-( dWhZgkZY i]Vi i]Z egZ]^hidg^X h]^[i id V\g^XjaijgZ dc i]Z
$ENTAL(YPOPLASIA 4U^dQ\Xi`_`\QcYQ^hVXdcY^i^dcX]VgVXiZg^oZYWnigVchkZghZa^cZh!e^ih!VcY\gddkZh dci]Zhjg[VXZd[iddi]Xgdlch#I]ZhZY^hijgWVcXZhVgZYZ[ZXih^cZcVbZaYZkZadebZci# 6bZad\ZcZh^h!dgZcVbZa[dgbVi^dc!WZ\^chVii]ZdXXajhVaVeZmd[ZVX]iddi]Xgdlc VcYegdXZZYhgddilVgY!ZcY^c\l]ZgZi]ZXgdlcbZZihi]ZgddiVii]ZXZgk^XdZcVbZa a^cZ#9jg^c\i]^hegdXZhh!higZhhidi]Zdg\Vc^hbbVngZhjai^cViZbedgVgnjehZid[ VbZadWaVhi^X VXi^k^in VcY V XdchZfjZci ZcVbZa YZ[ZXi bVg`^c\ i]Z ^ciZggjei^dc d[ YZkZadebZci#I]ZhZZcVbZa]nedeaVhi^XYZ[ZXihXVciV`ZbVcn[dgbh!gVc\^c\[gdb h^c\aZe^ihida^cZhid\gddkZh#6h9Vc[dgi]ZiVa#&..(cdiZ!WZXVjhZhXdg^c\d[i]ZhZ [ZVijgZhkVg^Zh\gZVianWZilZZcdWhZgkZgh!^ciZgdWhZgkZgVcY^cigVdWhZgkZgW^VhbjhiWZ Xdch^YZgZY^cVcnXdbeVg^hdcd[gZhjaih[gdbY^[[ZgZcihijY^Zh# HZkZgVaY^[[ZgZci[VXidghXVcXVjhZYZciVa]nedeaVh^VhhZZ
('.

&IGURE8Vg^Zh#7^aViZgVaXVg^djhaZh^dchd[i]ZÄghibdaVghVgZZk^YZcidci]^h ^cY^k^YjVa#6gZaViZYVWhXZhhVgdjcYi]ZY^hiVaÄghibdaVggddi^hhZZcedhiZgdhjeZg^dgidi]Z g^\]ibZciVa[dgVbZc#EgZ]^hidg^X!8Va^[dgc^V#CVijgVah^oZ#

0ERIODONTAL$ISEASE @UbY_T_^dYdYc^hi]Z^cÅVbbVi^dcd[i^hhjZhVgdjcYViddi]#>iXVc^ckdakZWdi]hd[i i^hhjZhVcYi]ZWdcZ^ihZa[#EZg^dYdciVaY^hZVhZ^ch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch^hgZXd\c^oZYVhV gZhjaid[^c[ZXi^dcd[i]ZVakZdaVgWdcZVcYVY_VXZcii^hhjZh#>iXVjhZhgZXZhh^dcd[i]ZVa" kZdaVgWdcZ!VhZ^i]ZgV]dg^odciVaadlZg^c\d[i]ZXgZhid[i]ZVakZdaVgegdXZhhdgVhVc ^ggZ\jaVgadlZg^c\d[i]ZegdXZhh!l^i]edX`ZihdglZaahZmeVcY^c\^cidi]ZXVcXZaadjh WdcZd[i]Z_Vlh#I]ZV\Zcihd[^c[ZXi^dcVgZb^Xgddg\Vc^hbh!VcYi]ZY^hZVhZ^hjhjVaan YjZidi]ZXdbW^cZYZ[[ZXihd[aVg\Z!b^mZYXdbbjc^i^Zhd[WVXiZg^V#6cQRcSUcc^hV adXVa^oZYXdaaZXi^dcd[ejh^cVXVk^in[dgbZYWni^hhjZY^h^ciZ\gVi^dc#6WhXZhhZhVgZ d[iZc[djcYVhXVk^i^Zhl^i]^cVakZdaVgWdcZcZVgi]Ziddi]gddiVe^XZh#;^\jgZ&,#&+ ^aajhigViZhi]ZhZ[ZVijgZh#8aVg`ZVcY=^ghX]&..&egdk^YZVi]dgdj\]VXXdjcid[[VX" idgh^cÅjZcX^c\VakZdaVgWdcZ#

$ENTAL#ALCULUS 9ZciVaXVaXjajh^hb^cZgVa^oZYeaVfjZdcViddi]hjg[VXZ#I]Z[VXii]ViXVaXjajhXVc igVe[ddYYZWg^h]VhWZZcjhZYWn9dWcZnVcY7gdi]lZaa&.-+VhVcVeegdVX][dg VhXZgiV^c^c\VheZXihd[egZ]^hidg^XY^Zi#;^\jgZ&,#&,h]dlhgZbcVcihd[XVaXjajhWj^aY" je# 

8]VeiZg&,DhiZdad\^XVa9ZciVaEVi]dad\n

&IGURE9ZciVa ]nedeaVh^V#I]^h&'" nZVg"daYX]^aYhj[[ZgZYV bZiVWda^XjehZiYjg^c\i]Z [dgbVi^dcd[]^hXVc^cZh idhZZl]Zci]^hdXXjggZY! Xdchjai;^\jgZ&.#&#I]^h jehZigZXdgYZY^ihZa[^c i]Za^cZVg]nedeaVh^VhZZc W^aViZgVaandci]ZaVW^Va hjg[VXZd[i]ZXVc^cZXgdlch# 8VaXjajh^hVahdhZZcdc i]ZaVW^Vahjg[VXZd[i]Z ^cX^hdgXgdlch#EgZ]^hidg^X! 8Va^[dgc^V#CVijgVah^oZ#

!RTIlCIAL$ENTAL-ODIlCATION 6kVg^Zind[XjaijgVaegVXi^XZhiZX]c^XVaan![dgbhd[igVjbV^beVXihYZci^i^dc#EZdeaZ Zc\gVkZ!Xdadg!VcYZkZc^ciZci^dcVaanejaadjiUfe\cUiZZi][dgXdhbZi^XejgedhZh# 7gdi]lZaa&.-&^aajhigViZhi]ZkVg^Zind[YZXdgVi^dchZcXdjciZgZYdcYZciVagZbV^ch! eg^bVg^andci]ZVciZg^dgiZZi]#I]ZhZVgi^ÄX^Va^cX^h^dchh]djaYcdiWZXdc[jhZYl^i] ]nedeaVh^Vh#B^acZgVcYAVghZc&..&gZk^ZlÄa^c\!X]^ee^c\!^caVnh!VcYdi]ZgVaiZgV" i^dch!gZ[Zgg^c\idi]ZhZVhTU^dQ\]edY\QdY_^c!l]ZgZVhejgedhZ[jagZbdkVad[jhjVaan VciZg^dgiZZi]^hiZgbZYQR\QdY_^# ;gVnZg&..&VcYbVcndi]Zgh]VkZ^ciZgegZiZYi]Z^ciZgegdm^bVa\gddkZhhdbZ" i^bZhegZhZciWZilZZcVY_VXZciiZZi]Vh\gddkZhaZ[iWni]ZjhZd[iddi]e^X`h!VcYhjX] [ZVijgZhVgZZkZc`cdlc[gdb[dhh^a]db^c^YiZZi]d[bdgZi]Vcildb^aa^dcnZVgh^c V\Z#=ajh`d'%%(^c[Zghi]Vii]ZhZ\gddkZhlZgZbVYZWn\gVhhhiVa`hjhZYVhiddi]" e^X`h#;dm&..'gZk^Zlha^iZgVijgZdcXjaijgVahig^Vi^dch^ci]Z]jbVcYZci^i^dc!cdi" ^c\hZkZgVahijY^Zhi]Vi]VkZh]dlc]VcYZYcZhhWVhZYdci]ZY^gZXi^dcVa^ind[dWa^fjZ hXgViX]bVg`hdci]ZaVW^Vahjg[VXZhd[jeeZg^cX^hdgh!eVgi^XjaVganVbdc\eVaZda^i]^X ]db^c^Yh#I]ZhZbVg`hlZgZegZhjbVWanbVYZWZXVjhZ[ddYlVhhZXjgZYWnjh^c\i]Z [gdciiZZi]VhVk^hZl]^aZe^ZXZhlZgZXjiVlVnl^i]VhidcZ^beaZbZcii]ViXVbZ^cid XdciVXil^i]i]ZiZZi]#

/CCUPATION >cWdi][dgZch^XVcYeVgi^XjaVgan^cVgX]Zdad\^XVaXdciZmih!^i^h^bedgiVciidYZiZg" b^cZi]ZdXXjeVi^dcVaVcYhdX^VahiVijhd[^cY^k^YjVahcdlgZegZhZciZYWnh`ZaZidch# HiZZaZ'%%%gZk^Zlhi]Zh`ZaZiVa^cY^XVidghd[]VcYZYcZhh!Wji]VcYZYcZhh^h]VgYan dXXjeVi^dc#@ZccZYn&.-.igVXZhi]Z]^hidgnd[dXXjeVi^dcVahijY^Zh^cVci]gdeda" d\nVcYbZY^X^cZ#LVaYgdc¼h&..)XVaa[dgXg^i^XVaZkVajVi^dcd[XaV^bh^hVeiVcY Zca^\]iZc^c\#=ZcdiZhi]Vi^ci]Z^g[ZgkdgidYZYjXZVhbjX]Vhedhh^WaZVWdjii]Z &,#,9ZciVaeVi]dad\n

((&

a^kZhd[VcX^Zci^cY^k^YjVah!dhiZdad\^hih]VkZbVYZhdbZZmigVkV\VciXaV^bhVWdjiZc" k^gdcbZciVahigZhhZh!eVg^in!hdX^VahiVijh!VcYdXXjeVi^dc#6h]ZcdiZh!hdbZVji]dgh ]VkZWZZcjcVWaZidgZh^hii]ZiZbeiVi^dcidYZYjXZVcjcYZgan^c\XVjhZ[dgZkZgnWdcn aZh^dc!^YZci^[n^c\^cY^k^YjVahVh]dghZbZc!ha^c\i]gdlZgh!lZVkZgh!VcYXdgc\g^cYZgh WVhZYdci]ZegZhZcXZd[WdlZYa^bWWdcZh!he^cVaYZ[dgb^i^Zh!VcYdhiZdVgi]g^i^hVi kVg^djh_d^cih# EZg]VehWZXVjhZ^c[dgbVi^dcgZ\VgY^c\dXXjeVi^dcVcYhiVijh^hhdkVajVWaZ^cVc VgX]Zdad\^XVaXdciZmi!cdiZcdj\]ViiZci^dc^heV^Yidi]ZegZb^hZhi]VijcYZga^ZhjX] ^YZci^ÄXVi^dch#LVaYgdc¼h&..)ZmVb^cVi^dcd[l]Zi]ZgeViiZgchd[dhiZdVgi]g^i^h XVcWZjhZYid^YZci^[ndXXjeVi^dc^hVjhZ[jaYZeVgijgZ#EgdXZZY^c\[gdb`cdlcid jc`cdlc!]ZcdiZhi]Vii]ZgZ^hVlZVai]d[bdYZgcXa^c^XVaYViVdcdhiZdVgi]g^i^hVcY dXXjeVi^dc#=ZÄcYhcdXdck^cX^c\Ze^YZb^dad\^XVaZk^YZcXZd[VXdch^hiZci!Xd]ZgZci gZaVi^dch]^eWZilZZcVeVgi^XjaVgdXXjeVi^dcVcYVeVgi^XjaVg[dgbd[dhiZdVgi]g^i^h# >cYZZY! \^kZc i]Z [VXi i]Vi hZm! gVXZ! lZ^\]i! bdkZbZci! VcY \ZcZi^X egZY^hedh^i^dc VgZVaa`cdlc[VXidghi]Vi^cÅjZcXZYZkZadebZcid[i]ZY^hZVhZ!i]^h^hcdihjgeg^h^c\# LVaYgdc&..)XdcXajYZhi]ViWZXVjhZlZ`cdli]VidXXjeVi^dc^hcdii]ZhdaZXVjhZ d[dhiZdVgi]g^i^h!i]ZgZXVccdiWZVcna^`Za^]ddYd[WZ^c\VWaZidYZYjXZi]Z[dgbZg [gdbi]ZaViiZg#;jgi]ZgbdgZ!ZkZc^cXVhZh^cl]^X]dXXjeVi^dcVaangZaViZYVXi^k^in YdZh hZZb id WZ ^bedgiVci ^c YZiZgb^c^c\ i]Z ZmegZhh^dc d[ Vgi]g^i^h! i]ZgZ VgZ cd jc^fjZ[ZVijgZhVWdjii]^hZmegZhh^dc¸bdhieZdeaZl]dYZkZadeVgi]g^i^hVii]ZÄc" \Zg_d^cihVgZcdib^aaldg`Zgh!ZkZci]dj\]b^aaldg`ZghYdYZkZadeVgi]g^i^hVii]ZhZ _d^cih#;dgh^c\aZh`ZaZidch!i]ZgZ[dgZ!i]ZegdheZXihhZZbWaZV`# DcVedejaVi^dcVaWVh^h!]dlZkZg!i]ZegdheZXihVgZWZiiZg#=ZgZ!WnZmVb^c^c\ i]ZeViiZgchd[dhiZdVgi]g^i^h^cZVX]h`ZaZidc!VcYVbdc\Vaah`ZaZidch!^ib^\]iWZ edhh^WaZidYgVlXdcXajh^dchVWdjiVXi^k^ineViiZgcY^[[ZgZcXZhdcV\gdje!dgedejaV" i^dcaZkZa#I]^h^hi]ZjcYZgan^c\WVh^hd[i]ZdcanXdbegZ]Zch^kZh`ZaZiVahijYnd[ VXi^k^in"^cYjXZYeVi]dad\n!VhbVaaedejaVi^dcVahijYnd[8VcVY^Vc>cj^ih^cl]^X] VXi^k^ineViiZgchhjX]Vh`VnV`^c\!]Vgeddci]gdl^c\!VcYhZl^c\lZgZgZaViZYiddh" iZdVgi]g^i^XeViiZgchdcVedejaVi^dcVaWVh^hBZgWh!&.-(#6hijYnWnHi^gaVcY&..' dchV^adgh[gdb@^c\=ZcgnK>>>¼hV#Y#&*)*ÅV\h]^e!BVgnGdhZ!^hVcdi]Zg!hbVaaZg! VcYbdgZa^b^iZYhVbeaZ^cl]^X]VcViiZbeiidgZaViZdXXjeVi^dcideVaZdeVi]dad\n ^hbVYZ#:kZc^ci]ZWZhid[XVhZh!]dlZkZg!^igZbV^ch^bedhh^WaZidYZÄc^i^kZanXdc" XajYZi]ViVcnh^c\aZ^cY^k^YjVa]VYVeVgi^XjaVgdXXjeVi^dcWVhZYdcVcneVgi^XjaVg Vgi]g^i^X_d^ci^c]^hdg]Zgh`ZaZidc#6hLVaYgdc&..)!e#.-XVji^dch!¹I]ZgZ^hV eZg[ZXianjcYZghiVcYVWaZYg^kZidbV`Zi]Zbdhid[l]Via^iiaZZk^YZcXZhjgk^kZh^c i]Zh`ZaZidcVcYi]^hhdbZi^bZh]Vhi]ZZ[[ZXid[dkZgl]Zab^c\i]ZXg^i^XVa[VXjai^Zh#º I]ZdhiZdad\^hih]djaYWZlVgnd[eddganhjeedgiZYXaV^bhVWdjiY^Zi!Y^hZVhZ!YZbd\" gVe]n!VcYdXXjeVi^dcViWdi]i]ZaZkZad[i]Z^cY^k^YjVah`ZaZidcVcYi]ZaZkZad[i]Z edejaVi^dchVbeaZ#



8]VeiZg&,DhiZdad\^XVa9ZciVaEVi]dad\n

#HAPTER

AVWdgVidgnEgdXZYjgZh GZedgi^c\ 6

cVanh^hWZ\^ch^ci]Z[^ZaYVcYZmiZcYhidi]ZaVWdgVidgn#I]ZegdXZYjgZhY^h" XjhhZY^c8]VeiZg'VgZgZaViZYeg^bVg^anidi]ZZmedhjgZVcYgZXdkZgnd[h`ZaZiVa gZbV^ch#I]ZgZ!lZigVXZYgZbV^ch[gdbi]Z^ged^cid[Y^hXdkZgn^cidi]ZaVWdgVidgn# CdllZ^cigdYjXZaVWdgVidgnegdXZYjgZhXdbbdcanVeea^ZYid]jbVcdhiZdad\^XVa bViZg^Va VcY Xdch^YZg i]Z ZaZbZcih d[ Z[[ZXi^kZ gZedgi^c\ d[ VcVani^XVa gZhjaih# >i ^h ^bedgiVciidcdiZ!eVgi^XjaVgan[dg[dgZch^XhZii^c\h!i]ViHiVcYVgYDeZgVi^c\EgdXZ" YjgZhHDEh[dgV\ZcX^Zh^ckdakZY^cXVhZhl^i]Zk^YZci^Vgn]jbVcgZbV^chbjhiWZ [daadlZY kZgn XadhZan hZZ 8]VeiZg '# I]Z X]V^c d[ XjhidYn bjhi ValVnh WZ g^\^Yan gZheZXiZYVcYYdXjbZciZY!VcYhZXjg^ind[i]ZgZbV^chgZheZXiZY#

3ETTING HdjcY egdXZYjgZh! Vc Veegdeg^ViZ hZii^c\! VcY XVgZ[ja jhZ d[ i]Z egdeZg Zfj^ebZci VgZ ZhhZci^Va ^c dhiZdad\^XVa VcVanh^h! cdi dcan id ZchjgZ VXXjgViZ gZhjaih Wji Vahd id hV[Z\jVgYi]Zh`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#D[eg^bVgn^bedgiVcXZ^hi]Vildg`WZXdcYjXiZYdkZg VeVYYZYhjg[VXZ#8VgZh]djaYWZiV`ZcidegZkZciheZX^bZch[gdbXdciVXi^c\]VgY hjg[VXZhdggdaa^c\dcidi]ZÅddg#:kZclZaa"egZhZgkZYWdcZhi]VihZZbhijgYnbVnWZ [gV\^aZl]ZcXdbeVgZYidi]Z^chigjbZcihjhZYidbZVhjgZi]Zb#I]ZdhiZdad\^hibjhi i]ZgZ[dgZWZXVgZ[jacdiidXgjh]!e^ZgXZ!hXgViX]!dgdi]Zgl^hZYVbV\Zi]ZheZX^bZc l^i]i]Z^chigjbZcih#Ed`^c\dgegdYY^c\i]Zh`ZaZiVabViZg^Val^i]i]ZÄc\ZghXVc VahdZVh^anYVbV\Zi]ZWdcZ!ZheZX^Vaani]ZbdgZ[gV\^aZeVgihd[i]ZXgVc^jb# I]ZhijYnd[WdcZh^hWZhiYdcZ^cVlZaa"a^iaVWdgVidgn;^\jgZ&-#&#A^\]i^c\^h Xg^i^XVa#DkZg]ZVYÅjdgZhXZcia^\]ihVgZeddg[dgdhiZdad\^XValdg`WZXVjhZi]ZniZcYid Äaai]Zgddbl^i]Y^[[jhZa^\]i#DWhZgkVi^dcd[dhiZdad\^XVaYZiV^aYZeZcYhdci]ZXdc" igdad[^cX^YZcia^\]idci]ZheZX^bZc!VcY[dgi]^hgZVhdcVhl^c\"Vgb!^cXVcYZhXZci a^\]ihdjgXZ^hgZXdbbZcYZY[dgdhiZdad\^XVaVcVanh^h#6jc^Y^gZXi^dcVaa^\]ihdjgXZ bV`Zh^iedhh^WaZ[dgi]ZgZhZVgX]Zgid]^\]a^\]ihjWiaZWdcn[ZVijgZhdgbdY^ÄXVi^dch WnVc\a^c\i]Za^\]iidZc]VcXZi]Zk^h^W^a^ind[hjg[VXZYZiV^a# >i bjhi WZ cdiZY i]Vi i]ZgZ bVn WZ hZkZgVa W^dad\^XVa VcY X]Zb^XVa ]VoVgYh ^c" kdakZYl^i]gZXdkZgnVcYVcVanh^hd[h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch!eVgi^XjaVgan^c[dgZch^XXdciZmih 
(((

&IGURE>ci]ZaVWdgVidgn!dhiZdad\^XVaheZX^bZchVgZ[jaanaVWZaZYVcYgZhidgZY#=ZgZi]Z dhiZdad\^hiX]ZX`h[dg_d^ch#L]Zc_d^chVgZ[djcY!i]ZWdcZhVgZ\ajZYid\Zi]ZgVcYiZbedgVg" ^anhjeedgiZY^cVhVcYWdml]^aZi]Z\ajZhZih#8dbeVgVi^kZbViZg^Vah]djaYWZVXXZhh^WaZ Yjg^c\i]ZhZdeZgVi^dch#I]ZlVh]^c\VcYYgn^c\d[VYY^i^dcVaheZX^bZchegdXZZYh^ci]Z WVX`\gdjcY#

0RESERVATION I]Z higZc\i]Zc^c\ d[ WdcZh XVc WZ VXXdbea^h]ZY ^c hZkZgVa lVnh Yjg^c\ VcY V[iZg gZXdkZgn# KVg^djh ]VgYZcZgh! dg egZhZgkVi^kZh! VgZ VkV^aVWaZ# I]ZhZ VgZ jhjVaan Z^i]Zg lViZg"dgVXZidcZ"hdajWaZ0i]Zn^cXajYZedank^cnaVXZiViZEK6!dgK^cVX!VeaVhi^XY^h" hdakZY^cVXZidcZ!EVgVad^Y7,'!7ZYVXgnal]^X]XVcWZejgX]VhZY^c]VgYX]jc`h l]^X]VgZi]ZcY^hhdakZY^cVcdg\Vc^XhdakZci!7jikVgVedlYZgb^mZY^chdakZci! VcYbVcndi]Zgh#8nVcdVXgnaViZ\ajZhd[kVg^djhk^hXdh^i^ZhVgZ^ggZkZgh^WaZWjibVn WZcZXZhhVgnidVeeanWZ[dgZi]ZgZbdkVad[gZbV^ch!eVgi^XjaVgan]ZVk^anWjgcZYdg Vh]ZYiddi]Xgdlch^c[dgZch^XXdciZmihB^cXZgZiVa#!&..%#?d]chdc'%%&gZk^Zlh bdYZgcXdchda^YVcihjhZY^cdhiZdad\^XValdg`VcYGdhh^ZiVa#'%%)Xdch^YZgi]ZhZ^c gZaVi^dcid[gV\^aZXgZbViZYgZbV^chVcYi]^chZXi^dc^c\#8dchjail^i]i]ZXdchZgkVidg d[i]Z^chi^iji^dci]Vil^aa]djhZi]ZdhiZdad\^XVabViZg^VaVWdjii]Z`^cYd[egZhZgkV" i^kZegZ[ZggZY# 

8]VeiZg&-AVWdgVidgnEgdXZYjgZhGZedgi^c\

I]Z`Znidjh^c\VcnegZhZgkVi^kZ^hXdggZXiY^aji^dc#I]Zbdhi[gZfjZci[V^ajgZ^c egZhZgkVi^kZjhZ^hi]Z[V^ajgZidY^ajiZi]Zhdaji^dcZcdj\]!l]^X]gZhjaih^ceddgeZc" ZigVi^dcVcYi]Z[dgbVi^dcd[V]VgYdjiZgh`^cdci]ZheZX^bZcWjiVaVX`d[^ciZgcVa ]VgYZc^c\#>begZ\cVi^dcl^i]VegZhZgkVi^kZ]Vk^c\i]ZXdch^hiZcXnd[lViZg^hgZX" dbbZcYZY!jhjVaanVWdjiV*·&%hdaji^dc#>i^hjhjVaanWZhiidY^el]daZheZX^bZch ^cidi]Zhdaji^dcVcYi]ZcaZii]ZbYgndcVl^gZhXgZZc#>ci]ZXVhZd[bdgZ[gV\^aZ gZbV^chi]Vil^aacdihiVcYjeid^bbZgh^dc!Yg^ei]Zhdaji^dcdcidi]ZheZX^bZc#JhZ dg\Vc^XhdakZcihi]^ccZghl^i]ZmigZbZXVji^dc#BVcnd[i]ZhZX]Zb^XVahVgZYVc\Zg" djh0Vkd^YWgZVi]^c\i]Z^g[jbZhVcYgZbZbWZgi]Vii]ZnVgZd[iZcZmigZbZanYVc\Zg" djhWZXVjhZd[i]Z^gÅVbbVW^a^in#

0REPARATION IZX]c^fjZhjhZY^ch`ZaZiVaegZeVgVi^dcXaZVc^c\kVgnVXXdgY^c\idi]ZXdcY^i^dcd[ i]Z WdcZ VcY i]Z XdciZmi d[ ^ih Y^hXdkZgn# ;dgZch^X dhiZdad\n gZfj^gZh heZX^Va igZVi" bZcihZZaViZg#8dci^cjZidjhZXdbbdchZchZ#>[i]ZWdcZ^hlZaaegZhZgkZY!^iXVcWZ lVh]ZY^caj`ZlVgblViZgl^i]djiYZiZg\ZcihdgVcndi]ZgVYY^i^kZhjh^c\Wgjh]Zh! lddYZcegdWZh!VcYhegVnWdiiaZh#CZkZglVh]bdgZi]VcdcZh`ZaZidcViVi^bZ#JhZV hXgZZc^cVaalVh]^c\!ÄZaYVcYaVWdgVidgn!id`ZZehbVaaWdcZh[gdbWZ^c\adhi#6hi]Z lVh]^c\lViZgWZXdbZhbjYYn!hbVaa[gV\bZcihbVnYZiVX]VcYWZXdbZadhi^ci]Z hZY^bZciVii]ZWdiidbd[i]ZWVh^cdgY^hVeeZVgYdlci]ZYgV^c#8aZVci]ZWVh^cVcY hXgZZc[gZfjZcian!bV`^c\hjgZi]ViWdi]VgZX]ZX`ZYWZilZZcegdXZhh^c\ZVX]Wjg^Va# 9ZeZcY^c\dc]jb^Y^in!i]ZlVh]ZYWdcZhYgn^c')id)-]djghdcl^gZgVX`h^ci]Z h]VYZ#>ci]ZaVWdgVidgn!ndjXVcheZZYi]^hjeWnjh^c\V[VcidWadlV^gVXgdhhgVX`hd[ Ygn^c\WdcZh#CZkZgjhZV]ZVihdjgXZYjZidi]ZYVc\Zgd[WdcZhjg[VXZZm[da^Vi^dc# ;dg[dhh^ah!bdgZhde]^hi^XViZYegZeVgVi^dciZX]c^fjZhVgZd[iZcXVaaZY[dg#;dhh^ah VgZhdbZi^bZhZcXVhZY^cVkZgn]VgYbVig^mi]VibVnWZZkZc]VgYZgi]Vci]ZWdcZ ^ihZa[#HdbZi^bZhi]ZbVig^mXVcWZhd[iZcZYl^i]VXZidcZ!eV^cii]^ccZg!dgZkZclViZg# KZgn^bedgiVci[dhh^aheZX^bZchh]djaYWZbdaYZYhZZhZXi^dc&-#-WZ[dgZXaZVc^c\id bV`ZVgZXdgYd[egZegZeVgVi^dchiVijh#L]ZcXaZVc^c\!bVig^mhVbeaZhh]djaYWZ`Zei hdi]Vi[jijgZ^ckZhi^\Vidghb^\]iWZVWaZidZhiVWa^h]`b_fU^YU^SU!i]ZhigVi^\gVe]^X VcYheVi^Vaedh^i^dcd[i]ZheZX^bZc# HdbZXdbbdcanjhZYeVaZdcidad\^XVaegZeVgVi^dciddahVcYiZX]c^fjZh^cXajYZ i]Z[daadl^c\/  ™ =VbbZgVcYX]^hZa#I]^hiZX]c^fjZ]VhVadc\]^hidgn!VcYbVcn[dhh^ah]VkZi]Z hXVghidegdkZ^i#HeZZY^hVcVhhZi!Wjii]Zh]dX`^bedhZYdci]ZheZX^bZcVcYi]Z aVX`d[ÄcZXdcigdaVgZcZ\Vi^kZed^cih#  ™ 9ZciVaYg^aa#I]^h[VhiWjiYVc\ZgdjhiZX]c^fjZ]VhWZZcjhZY[dgbVcnnZVgh# Edh^i^kZed^cih^cXajYZ\ddYXjii^c\edlZg!bdgZXdcigdai]VcV]VbbZgVcY X]^hZa!VcYaVX`d[h]dX`idi]ZheZX^bZc#=dlZkZg!ZmigZbZXVgZbjhiWZiV`Zcid `ZZei]Zhjg[VXZd[i]Z\g^cYZg[gdbYg^aa^c\^cidi]Zhjg[VXZd[i]ZdW_ZXiWZ^c\ XaZVcZY#  ™ 9ZciVae^X`dgcZZYaZ]ZaY^ck^hZjcYZgW^cdXjaVgb^XgdhXdeZ#I]^h^hd[iZc i]ZbdhiZ[[ZXi^kZlVnidXaZVcV[dhh^a0^i\^kZhi]ZegZeVgVidgbjX]XdcigdaVcY a^b^ihediZci^VaYVbV\Zidi^cnVgZVh#=dlZkZg!i]^hldg`gZfj^gZhVcZcdgbdjh &-#(EgZeVgVi^dc

((*

&IGUREAVWdgVidgn" ^cYjXZYYVbV\Zdci]Z EaZ^hidXZcZ[dhh^a=dbd XgVc^jb[gdbEZigVadcV!
Vbdjcid[i^bZVcYeVi^ZcXZ#  ™ 6X^YigZVibZci#9^ajiZVXZi^X![dgb^X!dg]nYgdX]adg^XVX^YhXVcWZjhZYidY^h" hdakZbVig^m]daY^c\hdbZ[dhh^ah#:mXZaaZciYZiV^abVnWZdWiV^cZYWni]^hiZX]" c^fjZ!Wji^iXVaah[dgeVi^Zci!ZmiZcYZYbdc^idg^c\id`ZZei]ZVX^Y[gdbViiVX`" ^c\i]ZheZX^bZc^ihZa[!ZiX]^c\^ihhjg[VXZ!dglZV`Zc^c\^ihhigjXijgVa^ciZ\g^in# IV`ZVaahiVcYVgYaVWdgVidgnegZXVji^dchl]Zcjh^c\VX^Yh#  ™ 6^gVWgVh^dc#I]^hegZeVgVi^dciZX]c^fjZjhZhViddai]Vih]ddihVhigZVbd[eVg" i^XaZhVii]ZbVig^ma^`ZVb^c^VijgZhVcYWaVhiZg#I]^hegdk^YZhheZZYVcYXdcigda l^i]djih]dX`#=dlZkZg!i]ZVWgVh^kZeVgi^XaZhbVndWhXjgZYZiV^aVcY[gdhii]Z WdcZVcYiddi]hjg[VXZh#>cVYY^i^dc!^i^hY^[ÄXjaiidXdcigdai]ZVWgVh^kZhigZVb Vh^igVb^ÄZhi]gdj\]XgVX`hWZadli]Zhjg[VXZd[VheZX^bZc# I]Z bdhi ZhhZci^Va ^c\gZY^Zcih ^c hjXXZhh[ja [dhh^a egZeVgVi^dc VgZ eVi^ZcXZ VcY ZmeZg^ZcXZ!Wji]ZaeVcYVYk^XZ[gdbh`^aaZYegZeVgVidghVgZXgjX^Va#CdiZi]ViVaad[ i]ZiZX]c^fjZhY^hXjhhZY]ZgZXVggnl^i]i]Zb]VoVgYh[dgi]Z[dhh^ah#>i^hWZiiZgidWZ hV[Zi]Vchdggn^cegZeVg^c\^bedgiVci[dhh^ah#EgZeVgVi^dcigVjbVi]Vi^hgZVY^andW" hZgkVWaZdcegZk^djhanXaZVcZY[dhh^ahh]dlhi]VibVcneVhildg`ZghlZgZcdiXVgZ[ja Zcdj\];^\jgZh&-#' ·&-#(# Di]Zg heZX^Va^oZY egZeVgVi^dc iZX]c^fjZh ^c dhiZdad\n ^ckdakZ [dgZch^X bViZg^Va 

8]VeiZg&-AVWdgVidgnEgdXZYjgZhGZedgi^c\

&IGURE;gdciVak^Zld[Vc^bbVijgZCZVcYZgi]VaXgVc^jb[gdb:c\^h!7Za\^jb6# I]ZhjeZgÄX^VahXgViX]ZhVadc\i]Zb^Ya^cZlZgZbVYZWnVY^V\gVe]^chigjbZcicZZYaZ!VcY i]dhZVadc\i]ZWgd`ZcZY\Zd[i]ZaZ[i[gdciValZgZbVYZWnhVcYeVeZgjhZYidhbddi]i]Z egZk^djhaneaVhiZg"gZXdchigjXiZYVgZVWZ]^cY#I]ZhZbVg`hlZgZ^ciZgegZiZYVhZk^YZcXZd[ CZVcYZgi]VabdgijVgnegVXi^XZGjhhZaaVcYAZBdgi!&.-+#I]^h^ciZgegZiVi^dclVhh]dlcid WZb^hiV`ZcWnL]^iZVcYIdi]&.-.#HXVcc^c\ZaZXigdcb^Xgd\gVe]h7·9h]dli]ZhVcY" eVeZghig^Vi^dch#CdiZi]Z¹YdjWa^c\WVX`ºVii]ZZcYd[ZVX]hVcYeVeZg\gV^c¼heVi]Vhi]ZZcY d[i]ZhVcY^c\higd`ZlVhgZVX]ZY#I]ZhZÄ\jgZh^aajhigViZi]Zji^a^ind[i]ZhXVcc^c\ZaZXigdc b^XgdhXdeZ^c^ckZhi^\Vi^c\WdcZbdY^ÄXVi^dcVibV\c^ÄXVi^dc#

l^i] VY]Zg^c\ ÅZh]# =ZgZ! bdhi d[ i]Z ÅZh] XVc WZ gZbdkZY XVgZ[jaan l^i] Xjii^c\ iddah#I]ZheZX^bZcXVci]ZcWZWd^aZYl^i]dgl^i]djiX]Zb^XVahhjX]VhZconbZ" WVhZYYZiZg\Zcih#;dgVY^hXjhh^dcd[VkVg^Zind[YZÅZh]^c\iZX]c^fjZhjhZ[ja^cWj^aY" ^c\XdbeVgVi^kZbVbbVa^Vch`ZaZiVaXdaaZXi^dch!Xdchjai=^aYZWgVcY&.+-VcYBdg^ &.,%!VhlZaaVh;ZcidcZiVa#'%%(#7ZhjgZidXdchjaiVhd[ii^hhjZeVi]dad\^hiWZ[dgZ gZbdk^c\hd[ii^hhjZh¸cZkZgYZhigdnZk^YZcXZd[Vcn`^cY#:kZc ^chZXiaVgkVZXdc" iV^cZY^ci]ZhZi^hhjZhbVnegdk^YZ^bedgiVciXajZh^cV[dgZch^XXVhZ# &-#(EgZeVgVi^dc

((,

2ESTORATION GZhidgVi^dc^ckdakZhejii^c\e^ZXZhd[Wgd`ZcWdcZhWVX`id\Zi]Zg#6YZiV^aZY`cdla" ZY\Zd[dhiZdad\n\gZVianh^bea^ÄZhi]^hegdXZhh0i]ZVW^a^inid^YZci^[ni]Zh^YZVcY edh^i^dcd[[gV\bZcihVaadlhi]Zfj^X`^YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[_d^ch#I]ZgZhidgVi^dcd[[gV\" bZciVgnWdcZh^hd[iZcYZhXg^WZYVhbdgZY^[ÄXjaii]VcYd^c\V_^\hVlejooaZ#I]^h^h VcZmV\\ZgVi^dc#6Wgd`Zch`ZaZidc]VhdcZbdgZY^bZch^dcVcY[VgbdgZ^c[dgbVi^dc i]VcVe^XijgZejooaZd[VedaVgWZVg^cVhcdlhidgb#GZhidgVi^dc^hd[iZcfj^X`VcY ZVhn[dgi]ZXdbeZiZcidhiZdad\^hihZZ;^\jgZ&-#&[dgVc^aajhigVi^dcd[gZhidgVi^dc^c egd\gZhh#I]Z[daadl^c\VgZkVajVWaZ\j^YZa^cZh[dggZhidgVi^dc/  ™ JhZV\ajZi]VibVnWZY^hhdakZYaViZg#I]^hZchjgZh[jijgZldg`Zghi]ZVW^a^inid XdggZXiVcnjc^ciZci^dcVab^hiV`Zhd[gZhidgVi^dc#  ™ 9dcdi]jggn#6h^cegZeVgVi^dc!eVi^ZcXZVcYZmeZg^ZcXZVgZZhhZci^Va^c\ddY h`ZaZiVagZhidgVi^dc#  ™ GZhidgZi]Z[VXZVcYkVjaihZeVgViZanWZ[dgZ_d^c^c\i]Zb#JhZi]ZbVcY^WjaVg XdcYnaZhVhV\j^YZidgZhidg^c\i]ZXdggZXiXgVc^VaWgZVYi]l]Zci]^h^h^cYdjWi#  ™ 7ZhjgZi]ZWdcZhidWZ\ajZYid\Zi]ZgVgZYgn!jcaZhhVlViZg"hdajWaZ\ajZ^hWZ^c\ jhZY#  ™ 9dcdi\ajZjci^andjVgZedh^i^kZd[V\ddY_d^c#8]ZX`jcYZgi]Zb^XgdhXdeZ^[ cZXZhhVgn#  ™ BV`ZhjgZi]Z_d^c^c\hjg[VXZhVgZXaZVcd[YZWg^h#6Y]Zg^c\\g^i!egZhZgkVi^kZ!VcY ÅV`Zhd[WdcZXVcgZhjai^cb^hVa^\cbZcid[Wgd`Zce^ZXZh#  ™ JhZXdadg!iZmijgZ!VcY¸bdhi^bedgiVcian¸VcVidbnidbViX]i]Ze^ZXZh#  ™ CZkZg\ajZiZZi]^cidi]Z^ghdX`Zihjci^andjVgZVWhdajiZanedh^i^kZi]Vii]ZnWZ" adc\i]ZgZ#>ciZgegdm^bVaXdciVXi[VXZihegdk^YZVc^ckVajVWaZ\j^YZidVXXjgViZ iddi]eaVXZbZci#  ™ 9dcdi\ajZndjghZa[^cidVXdgcZgWnaZVk^c\jcÄaaZY\VehWZilZZcWdcZh#>c" hiZVY!jhZbVh`^c\iVeZidbV`ZiZbedgVgn_d^ch#9dcdiaZVkZi]ZbVh`^c\iVeZ dc[dgbdgZi]VcVXdjeaZd[bdci]hVcYWZXVgZ[jai]Vii]ZWdcZhjg[VXZXVc gZaZVhZi]ZiVeZl^i]djiZm[da^Vi^c\#L]ZchVi^hÄZYi]Vii]Z_d^chVgZXdggZXi!egd" \gZhh^kZangZbdkZi]ZiVeZVcY\ajZi]ZWgd`Zchjg[VXZhid\Zi]Zg#  ™ GZXdchigjXidcanl]ZgZcZXZhhVgn#JhZhd[ieaVhiZgdgV*%/*%b^mijgZd[eVgV[Äc lVmVcYYgneaVhiZg]ZViZYidVa^fj^Y^cVhVjXZeVcdcV]dieaViZcdiVcdeZc ÅVbZ#9dcdi^\c^iZi]ZeVgV[Äc#I]^hgZhidgVi^dcbViZg^Va^hZVhnidldg`l^i] VcYgZbdkZ#>cXdcigVhi!bdYZa^c\XaVnheaVhi^X^cZiZcYidWZbdgZ\gZVhnVcY h]djaY\ZcZgVaancdiWZjhZYZmXZeiVhiZbedgVgnegdeh#6[iZgi]ZgZhidgVi^dc^h XdbeaZiZ!WZhjgZidYZbVgXViZi]ZgZXdchigjXiZY[gdbi]ZgZVahjg[VXZh#GZXdc" higjXi^dcVhdeedhZYidgZhidgVi^dc^hgVgZan_jhi^ÄVWaZ[dgVcdg^\^cVaheZX^bZc WZXVjhZ^i^hhjW_ZXi^kZVcY^idWhXjgZhkVajVWaZXgdhh"hZXi^dcVa^c[dgbVi^dc#  ™ JhZVhVcYWdmVcY\gVk^inidedh^i^dce^ZXZhl]^aZgZWj^aY^c\i]Zb#6cX]dgdcZ e^ZXZ^ci]ZhVcYVcYWVaVcXZi]Zdi]Zge^ZXZdcided[^i!eZg]VehiZbedgVg^an hjeedgi^c\i]Z\ajZ_d^cl^i]bVh`^c\iVeZ;^\jgZ&-#&#7ZhjgZidaZii]Z\ajZ XdbeaZiZan]VgYZcWZ[dgZgZbdk^c\i]Ze^ZXZ[gdbi]ZhVcYWdm#  ™ L]ZgZXdciVXihVgZa^b^iZYVcYlZV`!WgVXZi]ZeVgihWnjh^c\higjihbVYZd[ lddYZcdg\aVhhgdYh#  ™ 9dcdijhZ\ajZh!egZhZgkVi^kZh!dggZXdchigjXi^dcbViZg^Vai]Vil^aa^c]^W^ibdaY" 

8]VeiZg&-AVWdgVidgnEgdXZYjgZhGZedgi^c\

^c\gjWWZghi]VibVnWZjhZYdci]ZheZX^bZcViVaViZgi^bZ#8]ZX`VcnhjX] hjWhiVcXZh[dgXdbeVi^W^a^inl^i]bdaY^c\gjWWZgWZ[dgZVeean^c\i]Zbidi]Z heZX^bZc#  ™ ;dghdbZheZX^bZch!XdbeaZiZgZhidgVi^dc^hZmigZbZanY^[ÄXjai0hdbZY^hidgi^dc^h i]ZgZhjaid[lVge^c\gVi]Zgi]Vc[gVXijgZ#HjX]lVge^c\^h^bedhh^WaZidXdggZXi#

3ORTING I]Z dhiZdad\^hi ^h d[iZc [VXZY l^i] i]Z X]VaaZc\Z d[ hdgi^c\ V XdaaZXi^dc XdciV^c^c\ bdgZ i]Vc dcZ h`ZaZiVa ^cY^k^YjVa# D[ eg^bVgn ^bedgiVcXZ ^c i]^h hdgi^c\ VgZ V\Z! h^oZ!VcYhZmY^[[ZgZcXZhVhlZaaVhW^aViZgVa!cdcbZig^XigV^ih#BViX]^c\Vgi^XjaVgdg ^ciZgegdm^bVa[VXZihd[iZcegdk^YZhXajZhVWdjiVhhdX^Vi^dc#EgZhZgkVi^dcVa[VXidghhjX] VhWdcZXdadg!lZVi]Zg^c\!dg^ciZ\g^inVgZd[hZXdcYVgn^bedgiVcXZ!WjiVgZhdbZi^bZh jhZ[ja^chdgi^c\^cY^k^YjVah# I]Z]Y^Y]e]^e]RUb_VY^TYfYTeQ\c=>9^cVcnVhhZbWaV\Zd[WdcZh^hi]Z b^c^bjbcjbWZgd[^cY^k^YjVahcZXZhhVgnidVXXdjci[dgVaad[i]ZZaZbZcih^ci]Z VhhZbWaV\Z#6kZgnh^beaZZmVbeaZb^\]iWZVcVhhZbWaV\ZXdch^hi^c\d[ildheZX^" bZch!V[gV\bZcid[aZ[i]jbZgVa]ZVYVcYV[gV\bZcid[aZ[iY^hiVa]jbZgjh#I]ZhZ ildheZX^bZch!ZkZci]dj\]i]Z^ciZgkZc^c\h]V[i^hb^hh^c\!XdjaYgZegZhZcii]ZhVbZ ^cY^k^YjVajcaZhhi]ZnVgZd[eViZcianY^[[ZgZci^cY^k^YjVaV\Zh#:kZci]dj\]i]ZgZ b^\]iWZild^cY^k^YjVah^ckdakZY!i]ZBC>kVajZldjaY!^ci]^hXVhZ!WZ&# I]^hWVh^Xad\^X^hjhZYidYZiZgb^cZi]ZBC>kVajZ[dgVcnVhhZbWaV\Zd[]jbVc gZbV^chWn[daadl^c\i]ZhZegdXZYjgZh/  ™ ;^ghi!gZbdkZVaacdc]jbVcZaZbZcih#  ™ CZmi!hZeVgViZi]ZWdcZhVXXdgY^c\idZaZbZciVcYh^YZ#  ™ L^i]^cZVX]g^\]i"h^YZZaZbZciXViZ\dgn!Xdjcii]Zb^c^bjbcjbWZgd[^cY^k^Yj" Vah!cdie^ZXZh!gZegZhZciZY#8dch^YZgVaaedhh^WaZ_d^chWZilZZc[gV\bZcihVcYVh" hZhhi]ZV\Zd[ZVX][gV\bZci#  ™ EZg[dgb i]Z hVbZ b^c^bjb cjbWZg Xdjci [dg aZ[i"h^YZ WdcZh l^i]^c ZVX] ZaZ" bZciXViZ\dgnVcYi]ZcX]ZX`[dg^cY^k^YjVahgZegZhZciZYWnaZ[i"h^YZWdcZhi]Vi Z^i]ZgYdbViX]!dgedhh^WanWZadc\!idi]dhZ[gdbi]Zg^\]i#I]ZhZYdcdi^cXgZVhZ i]ZXdjci#  ™ AZ[i"h^YZWdcZhi]ViYdcdibViX]XdggZhedcY^c\g^\]i"h^YZdcZh^cV\Zdgbdg" e]dad\nVgZVYYZYidi]Zb^c^bjbcjbWZgXdjci# 6[iZg i]^h ^h YdcZ [dg Vaa eV^gZY VcY jceV^gZY ZaZbZcih! i]Z \gZViZhi b^c^bjb cjbWZgd[^cY^k^YjVah]VhWZZcYZiZgb^cZY# 8dch^YZg! [dg ZmVbeaZ! Vc VhhZbWaV\Z Xdch^hi^c\ d[ ild g^\]i bVm^aaVZ l^i] [jaa VYjaiYZci^i^dch!i]gZZaZ[i[ZbdgVd[VYjaih!dcZg^\]i[Zbjgd[Vc^c[Vci!ildhVXgV![djg VYjaig^\]iXVaXVcZ^!VcYi]gZZeZgbVcZcig^\]ijeeZgXZcigVa^cX^hdgh#I]ZBC>^ci]^h VhhZbWaV\Z^hh^m¸i]Z^c[VcieajhÄkZVYjaihYZiZgb^cZYWnildg^\]iXZcigVa^cX^hdgh ^cbVm^aaVZ!VcYi]gZZ^hdaViZYjeeZgg^\]iXZcigVa^cX^hdgh#I]ZbVm^bjbcjbWZg d[^cY^k^YjVah^hYZiZgb^cZYWnXdjci^c\Vaacdc_d^c^c\!cdcbViX]^c\ZaZbZcih¸^c i]^hXVhZ!VidiVad[Ä[iZZc#;dgVcdi]ZgZmVbeaZ!hZZ;^\jgZ&-#)#CdiZi]Vii]ZBC>^h cdiZfjVaidi]Z¹bdhia^`ZancjbWZgd[^cY^k^YjVahº6YVbhVcY@dc^\hWZg\!'%%)#

&-#*Hdgi^c\

((.

-ETRIC!CQUISITIONAND!NALYSIS 7ZXVjhZdhiZdad\^XValdg`^heVgid[i]ZhX^Zci^ÄXZciZgeg^hZ!^i^hcZXZhhVgnidXdb" bjc^XViZgZhjaihiddi]ZggZhZVgX]Zgh^cVcjcVbW^\jdjhVcYegZX^hZbVccZg#DcZd[ i]ZbdhiXdckZc^ZciVcYZ[[ZXi^kZlVnhidXdbbjc^XViZdhiZdad\^XVadWhZgkVi^dch^hid fjVci^[ni]Zb¸ idZmegZhhi]Zb^ccjbWZgh#I]jh!id^c[dgbXdaaZV\jZhVcYdi]Zgh VWdjiVeVgi^XjaVgiddi]!^i^hVh^beaZbViiZgidbZVhjgZVcYXdjciX]VgVXiZg^hi^Xhd[ i]Viiddi]# GZXZciVYkVcXZh^cXdbejiZg^oZYidbd\gVe]^X8IVcYaVhZghXVcc^c\iZX]cdad" \^Zh]VkZbVYZ^iedhh^WaZ[dgdhiZdad\^hihidVXfj^gZbZig^XhY^\^iVaan!VcYidY^heaVn i]Zb k^V V XdbejiZg hXgZZc gZbdiZ id i]Z heZX^bZch jcYZg hijYn# 6i Äghi \aVcXZ!

&IGUREIdYZiZgb^cZi]Zb^c^bjbcjbWZgd[^cY^k^YjVah[dgi]^hhVbeaZd[iZc heZX^bZchh]dlcdcZ"]Va[cVijgVah^oZ!ÄghicdiZi]Vii]ZgZVgZcdcdc]jbVce^ZXZh#Hdgii]Z e^ZXZhWnh`ZaZiVaZaZbZciVcYh^YZ#I]ZgZVgZildg^\]iiVa^!i]gZZaZ[ibVcY^WaZh!dcZbVm^aaV! VcY[djgg^\]ijacVZ#DcZd[i]ZjacVZ^h^bbVijgZ#I]ZBC>^hi]jhZfjVaidViaZVhi[djg eZdeaZ#7ZXVjhZcde^ZXZh_d^cdgVgZVci^bZgZhdeedh^iZh^YZhd[i]ZhVbZ^cY^k^YjVa!^i^hedh" h^WaZi]ViZVX]e^ZXZgZegZhZcihVY^[[ZgZci^cY^k^YjVa!hdi]ZbVm^bjbcjbWZgd[^cY^k^YjVah ^cY^XViZY[dgi]^hhVbeaZ^hiZc#



8]VeiZg&-AVWdgVidgnEgdXZYjgZhGZedgi^c\

i]^hiZX]cdad\^XVaXVeVW^a^inWg^c\hl^i]^ii]ZegdheZXid[[Vhi!ZVhn!VcYVXXjgViZYViV VXfj^h^i^dcVcYY^hig^Wji^dc#GVgZdgkVajVWaZheZX^bZchXVccdlWZY^\^i^oZYWnaV" hZgdg8IhXVchVcY¹]ZaYº^cXdbejiZgbZbdgnDjhaZnVcYBX@dZlc!'%%&0Oda" a^`d[Zg Zi Va#! &..-0 BV[Vgi VcY 9Za^c\ZiiZ! '%%'# Hd Vaajg^c\ VgZ i]Z h^gZc hdc\h d[ i]ZhZcZlXVeVW^a^i^Zhi]VihdbZ]VkZhj\\ZhiZYi]Vii]ZndWk^ViZi]ZcZZYidXjgViZ dg^\^cVaheZX^bZchhZZVahd8]VeiZg(#I]^h^hVb^hiV`ZcVcYZmigZbZanYVc\Zgdjh e]^adhde]n^cdhiZdad\n# =^hidgn]daYhaZhhdch]ZgZ#L]Zc^iWZXVbZedhh^WaZid¹XVeijgZºbdge]dad\nd[ [dhh^aheZX^bZchk^Vh^a^XdcgjWWZgVcYVXXjgViZeaVhi^Xh!gZea^XVhd[i]Z[dhh^adg^\^" cVah lZgZ Y^hig^WjiZY i]gdj\]dji i]Z ldgaY# I]ZhZ XVhih VgZ ^bbZchZan kVajVWaZ Vh iZVX]^c\VcYegZa^b^cVgngZhZVgX]iddah!WjiZmeZg^ZcXZ]Vhh]dlci]Vii]ZnVgZcd hjWhi^ijiZ[dgi]Zdg^\^cVah#9^hidgi^dc!bVig^mXdkZg!VcY^ciZgcVabdge]dad\nVgZVaa adhi^cVXVhi#Ldg`Zghjc[Vb^a^Vgl^i]dg^\^cVahXVcWZWVYanb^haZYWnhjX][ZVijgZh! [ZVijgZhdcank^h^WaZl^i]gZ[ZgZcXZidi]Zdg^\^cVa#B^h^ciZgegZiVi^dchWVhZYdc^cVX" XjgViZdWhZgkVi^dchVcYbZVhjgZbZcihdce]did\gVe]hVcYXVhihVgZVcZbWVggVhh^c\ eVgid[i]ZejWa^h]ZYa^iZgVijgZd[]jbVceVaZdcidad\n#HZZ8aVg`ZVcY=dlZaa&.,' [dgVcVcVanh^hd[egdWaZbh^c]ZgZci^cdWhZgkVi^dchVcYbZVhjgZbZcih[gdbe]did" \gVe]hVcYXVhih# L^i]Z^i]Zgild"dgi]gZZ"Y^bZch^dcVaY^\^iVa^bV\ZhhXVccZY[gdbdg^\^cVadhiZd" ad\^XVaheZX^bZch!i]ZhZegdWaZbhVgZXdbedjcYZYYgVbVi^XVaanVhi]Z^ckZhi^\Vidg bdkZhVcdi]ZghiZeVlVn[gdbi]Zdg^\^cVa#8dadg!iZmijgZ!^ciZgcVaVcVidbn!bVig^m XdkZg!egZhZgkVi^kZXdkZg!egZeVgVi^dcYVbV\Z!Zgdh^dch!VcYY^hidgi^dchd[Vaa`^cYhbVn WZ[V^i][jaangZXdgYZYWnhjX]^bV\^c\d[i]Zdg^\^cVa!Wji[dgi]ZdhiZdad\^hihZViZYVi VXdbejiZgbdc^idgdci]Zdi]Zgh^YZd[i]ZeaVcZi!i]ZhZ[ZVijgZhVgZd[iZccdiY^\^" iVaan Y^hi^c\j^h]VWaZ [gdb VXijVa Wdcn VcVidbn# =jbVch gdji^cZan bV`Z b^hiV`Zh! VcYi]ZhZiZX]cdad\^ZhhZZbed^hZYid^cXgZVhZYgVbVi^XVaani]ZcjbWZgVcY^beVXi d[i]ZhZb^hiV`Zh^c]jbVcdhiZdad\n#;dgdWk^djhgZVhdch!dhiZdad\^hihh]djaYValVnh gZ[Zgidi]Zdg^\^cVaheZX^bZc!ZkZcl]ZcVXfj^g^c\bZig^XYViV[gdbY^\^iVahdjgXZh# I]ZedejaVg^bV\Zd[VcdhiZdad\^hiVildg`^hdcZd[VeZghdc^cVl]^iZaVWdgVidgn XdVi! bZVhjg^c\ ^chigjbZci ^c ]VcY! bVc^ejaVi^c\ hdbZ WdcZ jhjVaan V XgVc^jb# I]ZgdaZd[i]Zegd[Zhh^dcVadhiZdad\^hi^h[VgWgdVYZgi]Vci]^h#>ci]Z[dgbVi^kZYVnh d[dhiZdad\n!fjVci^ÄXVi^dcd[WdcnVcVidbnlVhi]Z[dXjhd[bdhildg`#:aVWdgViZhZih d[bZVhjg^c\ed^cihlZgZYZÄcZY!VcYkVhifjVci^i^Zhd[bZig^XYViVlZgZXdbe^aZY# ?jhiWZXVjhZVXZgiV^cbZVhjgZbZci]VhWZZcgZedgiZY!]dlZkZg!YdZhcdibZVci]Vi ^i^hZ^i]ZgjhZ[jadgZkZcgZegdYjX^WaZHi^gaVcY!&..)#8dckZghZan!cZlbZig^XhVgZ gdji^cZanYZkZadeZYidfjVci^[nbdge]dad\^XVadWhZgkVi^dch#I]ZigVY^i^dcVaYVnh^c l]^X]bZVhjgZbZcilVhYdcZ[dgbZVhjgZbZci¼hhV`ZVgZi]Vc`[jaandkZgcdl!Wji bZig^X VcVanh^h YdZh Xdci^cjZ id eaVn V eg^bVgn gdaZ ^c dhiZdad\n# =dlZaah &.+.V egdk^YZhVc^ciZgZhi^c\WVX`\gdjcY[dgi]ZhZaZXi^dcd[h`ZaZiVabZig^Xed^cih# 6aahX^Zci^ÄXbZVhjgZbZcih!^cXajY^c\i]dhZ^cdhiZdad\n!h]djaYWZiV`Zc^ci]Z bZig^XhnhiZb#I]^hhnhiZbZmegZhhZha^cZVgdhiZdad\^XVabZVhjgZbZcih^cb^aa^bZiZgh! XZci^bZiZgh!VcYbZiZgh#HdbZdWhZgkVi^dchbVnWZfjVci^ÄZYZkZci]dj\]i]ZnVgZ Y^[ÄXjaidg^cVeegdeg^ViZidgZXdgYVhVXijVabZVhjgZbZcih#;dgZmVbeaZ!igV^ihhjX]Vh i]Z8VgVWZaa^¼hXjhedcjeeZgbdaVghbVnWZgZXdgYZYVhVWhZcidgegZhZci#KVg^VWaZhgZ" XdgYZY^ci]^hlVnVgZXVaaZYTYcSbUdUfQbYQR\Uc!VhdeedhZYidS_^dY^e_ecfQbYQR\Uc hjX]Vha^cZVgbZVhjgZbZcih# BVcnbZVhjg^c\iddah]VkZWZZc^ckZciZYVcYYZkZadeZY[dgdhiZdad\^XVaVcVanh^h# &-#+BZig^X6Xfj^h^i^dcVcY6cVanh^h

()&

;^\jgZ&-#*^aajhigViZhhdbZd[i]Zb#I]Zbdhi[gZfjZcianjhZY^hi]Zha^Y^c\XVa^eZg! l]^X]]VhVeV^gd[_Vlhl]dhZkVg^VWaZ\VeZ^hbZVhjgZYk^VVY^VadghXVaZdci]Z XVa^eZg h]V[i# 6 hegZVY^c\ XVa^eZg ^h jhjVaan jhZY [dg ldg` dc XgVc^Va VcVidbn# Dh" iZdbZig^XWdVgYhVgZjhZ[ja^cbZVhjg^c\aZc\i]hVcYVc\aZhd[edhiXgVc^VaZaZbZcih# 9Zk^XZh[dgdg^Zci^c\XgVc^VVgZVahdVkV^aVWaZ!VcY^chigjbZcihXVaaZYY^V\gVe]hVgZ jhZYidigVXZXZgiV^cegdÄaZhd[XgVc^V]ZaY^ci]ZhZYZk^XZh#Bdhid[i]ZhZegZX^h^dc

&IGUREIddah[dg dhiZdbZig^XbZVhjgZbZci# JeeZgaZ[i!i]ZWVh^Xha^Y^c\ kZgc^ZgXVa^eZg^hjhZYid bZVhjgZi]ZWjXXda^c\jVa WgZVYi]d[i]Zg^\]i bVm^aaVgni]^gYegZbdaVg# CdiZi]ZgVgZcdcbZig^X VcdbVanhZZc^ci]^hYZc" i^i^dc/W^aViZgVaanegZhZci hjeZgcjbZgVgnbdaVgh# JeeZgg^\]i!bZVhjgZbZci d[XgVc^VaaZc\i]l^i]i]Z hegZVY^c\XVa^eZg#AZ[i! bZVhjgZbZcid[[ZbdgVa W^XdcYnaVgaZc\i]l^i] i]ZdhiZdbZig^XWdVgY#



8]VeiZg&-AVWdgVidgnEgdXZYjgZhGZedgi^c\

^chigjbZcihVgZbVYZd[hiZZaVcYVgZZmeZch^kZ#I]ZnVgZVahdh]Vge#8VgZh]djaYWZ ZmZgX^hZYidhZZi]Vii]Z^chigjbZcihVgZcdiYVbV\ZYYjg^c\jhZ#BdgZ^bedgiVcian! WZXVjhZWdcZ^hhd[iZgi]VchiZZa!i]ZhZ^chigjbZcihXVchXgViX]dgeZg[dgViZWdcZhjg" [VXZh!VcYXVgZh]djaYWZiV`ZcidhZZi]VihjX]YVbV\ZYdZhcdidXXjgYjg^c\VcVanh^h# BVcnd[i]ZhZ^chigjbZcih]VkZcdlWZZca^c`ZYidb^XgdXdbejiZgh!Vaadl^c\bZig^X YViVVXXjbjaViZYdcaVg\ZhVbeaZhd[dhiZdad\^XVabViZg^VaidWZZciZgZYVcYbVc^ej" aViZYZaZXigdc^XVaan# BZig^XVcVanh^h^cdhiZdad\ngZfj^gZhbdgZi]Vch^beanbZVhjg^c\V\^kZcZaZbZci# >i^hXg^i^XVaan^bedgiVciidegdk^YZegZX^hZYZÄc^i^dchd[ZVX]bZVhjgZbZci#;jgi]Zg" bdgZ!i]ZYZ\gZZidl]^X]bZVhjgZbZcihXVcWZgZegdYjXZY^h^bedgiVci^cbZig^X VcVanh^h#I]ZZmVbeaZ^cIVWaZ&-#&h]dlhdcZlVnd[XVaXjaVi^c\VcYgZedgi^c\i]Z iZX]c^fjZ"WVhZYbZVhjgZbZciZggdg^cigVdWhZgkZgZggdg#=ZVi]XdiZ&.-&VcY7j^" `higVVcYJWZaV`Zg&..)egdk^YZ[jgi]ZgYZiV^ahdcbZVhjgZbZciZggdg^c]jbVc dhiZdad\n# BZig^XYViV^cdhiZdad\nVgZjhjVaanXdbe^aZYVhVgZhjaid[bZVhjg^c\VgXh!X]dgYh! dg kdajbZh# >cY^XZh VgZ bVYZ Wn XdbW^c^c\ i]ZhZ kVajZh# ;dg ZmVbeaZ! i]Z 8gVc^Va

4ABLE 6JhZ[jaEgdXZYjgZ[dg:hi^bVi^c\BZVhjgZbZci:ggdg 6# 6cdhiZdad\^hibZVhjgZhViddi][dgi]ZÄghii^bZVcY\ZihVgZVY^c\d[&%#-bb# BZVhjgZbZci6&%#-bb 7# I^bZ^hVaadlZYideVhhWZhi^[V[ZlYVnhhdi]Vi`cdlaZY\Zd[i]Zdg^\^cVa bZVhjgZbZciYdZhcdi^cÅjZcXZi]ZgZbZVhjgZbZci#I]ZhVbZ^ckZhi^\Vidgi]Zc gZbZVhjgZhi]ZhVbZiddi]Vi&&#%bb#BZVhjgZbZci7&&#%bb 8# 6[iZgVcdi]Zg]^Vijh!i]ZhVbZ^ckZhi^\VidgbZVhjgZhi]Ziddi]Vi&&#*bb#   BZVhjgZbZci8&&#*bb 9# I]ZgZVgZcdli]gZZbZVhjgZbZcih#IdXVaXjaViZi]ZbZVcVkZgV\Zd[i]ZhZ! VYYi]Zi]gZZbZVhjgZbZcih]UQcebU]U^dc1
2
3###]]VcYY^k^YZ i]ZidiVaWni]ZcjbWZgd[bZVhjgZbZcih(#I]ZgZhjai^hi]ZbZVc!dgVkZgV\Z! ((#((&&#&bb# :# IdYZiZgb^cZi]ZYZ\gZZidl]^X]i]Zdg^\^cVabZVhjgZhYZk^ViZ[gdbi]^hVkZgV\Z! Ä\jgZi]ZY^[[ZgZcXZWZilZZci]ZbZVcVcYZVX]bZVhjgZbZci#6YYi]ZhZY^[[Zg" ZcXZh1*!!!! ( #2*!!!!!  !3*!!%!!! $( (   VcYi]ZcY^k^YZi]ZhjbbZYY^[[ZgZcXZhWni]ZcjbWZgd[bZVhjgZbZcih( iV`Zc (# "&'# I]ZgZhjaigZÅZXihi]ZYZ\gZZidl]^X]i]ZVXijVabZVhjgZbZcihY^[[Zg[gdbi]ZbZVc# 8dckZgii]^hidVeZgXZciV\Zd[i]ZVkZgV\ZkVajZ "&'!!!  "$"$# I]ZVkZgV\ZbZVhjgZbZciZggdg[gdbi]Z&&#&bbbZVc^hVWdji'^ci]^hZmVbeaZ# 7ngZedgi^c\i]^hkVajZ!i]ZdhiZdad\^hi^c[dgbhi]ZVjY^ZcXZVWdji]dlgZeZViVWaZ Vcn\^kZcbZVhjgZbZci^h#

&-#+BZig^X6Xfj^h^i^dcVcY6cVanh^h

()(

>cYZm^hi]ZegdYjXid[i]ZbVm^bjbXgVc^VaWgZVYi]W^"ZjgndcVcY&%%!Y^k^YZYWn i]ZbVm^bjbXgVc^VaaZc\i]\aVWZaaVidde^hi]dXgVc^dc#>cY^XZhVgZXdckZc^ZciWZXVjhZ i]ZnZmegZhhh]VeZVhVh^c\aZkVg^VWaZ#;dgZmVbeaZ!Vh]dgidg¹WgdVYºh`jaa]VhV]^\]" Zg^cYZmi]VcVadc\!cVggdlh`jaa#7Vhh&..*egdk^YZhVXdcX^hZ\j^YZidhiVcYVgY bZVhjgZbZcihVcY^cY^XZhbdhil^YZanjhZY^c]jbVcdhiZdad\n#8gVc^VabZig^XhVcY ^cY^XZhVgZhjbbVg^oZY^cL]^iZVcY;da`Zch'%%%#7j^`higVVcYJWZaV`Zg&..) gZXdbbZcYi]Vi()XgVc^VaVcY))edhiXgVc^VahiVcYVgYbZVhjgZbZcihWZiV`Zcdc ^ciVXih`ZaZidch# :megZhh^dcd[h`ZaZiVaZaZbZcih]VeZ!dgbdge]dad\n!XVcWZZmVb^cZYWnjc^" kVg^ViZh^c\aZbZVhjgZbZcidgW^kVg^ViZildbZVhjgZbZcih!Vh^cVc^cYZmbZVch# I]Z jhZ d[ bjai^eaZ bZVhjgZbZcih id ZmegZhh h`ZaZiVa h]VeZ ]Vh WZZc XVaaZY bjai^" kVg^ViZbdge]dbZig^Xh#I]ZhjXXZhhZhVcY[V^ajgZhd[bjai^kVg^ViZVcVanh^h^c]jbVc dhiZdad\nVcYeVaZdcidad\nVgZZmVb^cZYWnAdkZ_dn&.,-!=dlZaah&.,(!;gVnZg &.-*!GZnbZciZiVa#&.-)!VcY8dggjXX^c^&.,-!&.-,#G^X]ihbZ^ZgZiVa#&..'! '%%'egdk^YZV\ddYgZk^Zld[Vci]gdedad\^XVabdge]dbZig^Xh#GdWW'%%%egdk^YZh V\ddY^cigdYjXi^dcidi]Ziddahi]Vi]jbVcdhiZdad\^hihl^aacZZYidYdbdgZi]Vc VXfj^gZYViV#I]Zi]dj\]i[jaVcYVeegdeg^ViZVcVanh^hd[i]dhZgZhjaih^hcdiVig^k^Va ZcYZVkdg#

-OLECULAR/STEOLOGY =dlZaah&..*!e#'edhZhi]ZfjZhi^dc/¹>hV\^kZcjc`cdlch`jaa!l^i]VbVaZVhh^\c" bZciWVhZYdcbdge]dad\^XVaX]VgVXiZgh8]VeiZg&.!^cYZZYVbVaZgVi]Zgi]VcV hdbZl]ViZmigZbZ[ZbVaZ4I]ZgZ^hcdlVnd[iZaa^c\!VcYi]Vi^hi]ZegdWaZb#ºI]^h ^hcdadc\Zgi]ZXVhZ# IgVY^i^dcVabZi]dYh[dgVcVano^c\h`ZaZiVagZbV^chVgZWVhZYdcZmVb^c^c\i]Z h^oZhVcYh]VeZhd[WdcZh#GZXZciVYkVcXZh^cdi]ZgÄZaYh]VkZ\^kZcg^hZidVcZlhZi d[bZi]dYhi]ViVaadli]ZdhiZdad\^hiidVcVanoZi]ZbdaZXjaVgXdchi^ijZcihd[WdcZ# JcYZgXZgiV^cXdcY^i^dch!h`ZaZiVagZbV^chgZiV^chj[ÄX^ZciYZch^i^Zhd[9C6!Vb^cd VX^Yh!VcYkVg^djh^hdideZhideZgb^ii]Z^ggZXdkZgnVcYVcVanh^h#HZZHX]b^Yi"HX]jaio VcYHX]jaio'%%)[dgVXdch^YZgVi^dcd[egdiZ^cegZhZgkVi^dc^cegZ]^hidg^XWdcZ#I]Z iZX]c^fjZhjhZYVgZd[iZcXdbeaZmVcYgZfj^gZheZX^VaanZfj^eeZYaVWdgVidgn[VX^a^" i^Zh#Edhh^WaZXdciVb^cVi^dc^hValVnhVc^hhjZC^X]dahdcZiVa#'%%'#=dlZkZg!i]ZVX" XjgVXnVcYegZX^h^dcd[i]ZgZhjaihdWiV^cZYbVnWZhjeZg^dgidi]dhZd[igVY^i^dcVa bZi]dYh!YZeZcY^c\dci]ZcVijgZd[i]ZfjZhi^dc#9C6VcVanh^h!^ceVgi^XjaVg!Vaadlh i]Z W^dVgX]Zdad\^hi dg [dgZch^X dhiZdad\^hi id VYYgZhh fjZhi^dch i]Vi VgZ WZndcY i]Z gVc\Zd[bdge]dad\^XVabZi]dYh# 6hbdaZXjaVgW^dad\^hihYZkZadelVnhidZmigVXibdgZ^c[dgbVi^dc[gdbbdYZgc 9C6!i]ZineZhd[fjZhi^dchi]ViXVcWZVYYgZhhZYl^i]VcX^Zci9C6VgZZmeVcY^c\ gVe^Yan#;dggZk^Zlh!hZZ@VZhiaZVcY=dghWjg\]'%%'VcYE~~WdZiVa#'%%)#8jg" gZcian!i]ZgZVgZÄkZbV_dgfjZhi^dchVWdjiVYZXZVhZY^cY^k^YjVai]Vi9C6VcVanh^h d[h`ZaZiVagZbV^chXVcediZci^VaanVYYgZhh/hZm!eVi]dad\n!VcXZhign!^cY^k^YjVi^dc!VcY Y^Zi#BdaZXjaVgiZX]c^fjZhVgZi]jhWZXdb^c\i]ZbZi]dYd[X]d^XZ[dgkVg^djhineZh d[dhiZdad\^XVaVcVanh^h#:kZchd!i]ZhZiZX]c^fjZhVgZWZhiVeea^ZYVheVgid[VcdkZgVaa dhiZdad\^XVaVcVanh^hgVi]Zgi]Vc^c^hdaVi^dc#



8]VeiZg&-AVWdgVidgnEgdXZYjgZhGZedgi^c\

3AMPLING I]ZjhZd[cZl]^\]"iZX]bdaZXjaVgbZi]dYhYdZhcdibZVci]Vii]Z[jcYVbZciVahd[ egdeZggZXdkZgn!egZeVgVi^dc!VcYYdXjbZciVi^dcd[h`ZaZiVagZbV^chXVcWZ^\cdgZY# >cYZZY!b^hiV`ZhbVYZeg^dgid!dgYjg^c\!i]ZhVbea^c\d[bViZg^Va[dgbdaZXjaVgVcVa" nh^hXVchZg^djhanXdbegdb^hZgZhjaih#>cVYY^i^dcidi]ZhiVcYVgYhZid[gZXdbbZcYV" i^dch [dg gZXdkZgn VcY YdXjbZciVi^dc d[ h`ZaZiVa gZbV^ch 8]VeiZg '! ^ckZhi^\Vidgh l^h]^c\iddWiV^c\ddYhVbeaZh[dgbdaZXjaVgVcVanh^hh]djaYXdch^YZgi]Z[daadl^c\/ >[bdaZXjaVgVcVanh^h^hidWZZbeadnZYdccZlangZXdkZgZYh`ZaZiVabViZg^Va!gZXdkZgn egdXZYjgZhh]djaYWZbdY^ÄZYidb^c^b^oZXdciVb^cVi^dcd[i]ZgZbV^chWnbdYZgc XdbedjcYhVcYbdYZgc]jbVch#I]ZheZX^ÄXegdXZYjgZhl^aaYZeZcYdci]ZcVijgZ d[i]Zh^iZ!i]ZVkV^aVWaZi^bZVcYgZhdjgXZh!VcYi]ZineZd[VcVanh^heaVccZY#;dg9C6 VcVanh^h!i]ZhZldjaY^YZVaan^cXajYZjh^c\Y^hedhVWaZaViZm\adkZhVcY]V^gcZih!VcY hiZg^a^o^c\ZmXVkVi^dciddah#>[i]^h^hcdiegVXi^XVa[dgi]ZZci^gZhVbeaZ!VgZVhdcVWaZ Xdbegdb^hZbVnWZidZbeadnhjX]egdXZYjgZhdci]ZheZX^ÄXZaZbZcihYZhi^cZY[dg 9C6VcVanh^h#GZbZbWZgi]ViVaaheZX^bZchh]djaYWZigZViZYVhediZci^Vaan^c[ZX" i^djhVcYegdiZXiZYV\V^chiXdciVb^cVi^dcVcYYZ\gVYVi^dc#I]Z6gbZY;dgXZh9C6 >YZci^ÄXVi^dcAVWdgVidgn6;9>A]VheVgi^XjaVgHDEhhZZ8]VeiZg'i]ViXdkZgi]ZhZ ide^XhVcYbVcndi]Zgh# I]ZZmedhjgZd[h`ZaZiVagZbV^chhjWhiVci^VaanVaiZghi]Z^gZck^gdcbZci#I]^hbVn! ^cijgc!aZVYid[jgi]ZgYZXVnd[i]Z^gbdaZXjaVgXdchi^ijZcih#8jggZcian!a^iiaZ^h`cdlc VWdjii]ZZ[[ZXihd[egZhZgkVi^kZhVcYX]Vc\Zh^ciZbeZgVijgZ!]jb^Y^in!bd^hijgZ!VcY V^gX^gXjaVi^dcdci]ZegZhZgkVi^dcd[kVg^djhW^dbdaZXjaZh#Jci^abdgZ^c[dgbVi^dc^h VkV^aVWaZ!i]Zl^hZhiXdjghZ^hidb^c^b^oZi]ZbV\c^ijYZd[hjX]X]Vc\ZhVhbjX] Vh^hegVXi^XVa#8dchjai^c\l^i]i]ZheZX^Va^hil]dl^aaWZXdcYjXi^c\i]ZbdaZXjaVg VcVanh^h^hVYk^hVWaZ# I]ZZkVajVi^dcd[i]ZVXXjgVXnd[bdaZXjaVgVcVanhZhYZeZcYh^ceVgijedcegdeZg YdXjbZciVi^dcd[i]ZegdkZc^ZcXZd[i]ZhVbeaZh#>[bdaZXjaVgVcVanh^h^hidWZZb" eadnZY dc cZlan gZXdkZgZY h`ZaZiVa bViZg^Va! eVgi^XjaVg ViiZci^dc h]djaY WZ eV^Y id egdeZganYdXjbZci^c\Wdi]i]ZXdciZmid[i]ZgZbV^chVcYi]ZZmXVkVi^dcbZi]dYh ZbeadnZY#9ZeZcY^c\dci]ZineZd[VcVanh^heaVccZY!^ibVnWZVYk^hVWaZiddWiV^c hd^ahVbeaZh[gdbi]ZVgZVhjggdjcY^c\i]ZZaZbZcihidWZVcVanoZY#=ZgZV\V^c!Xdc" hjaiVi^dcl^i]i]ZVeegdeg^ViZheZX^Va^hi^hXgjX^Va# L]Zi]Zgi]ZbdaZXjaVgbZi]dYhVgZidWZVeea^ZYidcZlangZXdkZgZYh`ZaZiVagZ" bV^chdgidbjhZjbXdaaZXi^dch!i]ZX]d^XZd[l]^X]heZX^bZchidhVbeaZbjhiWZ bVYZXVgZ[jaan#7ZXVjhZbdaZXjaVgiZX]c^fjZhVgZine^XVaanYZhigjXi^kZ!heZX^bZch[dg hVbea^c\ h]djaY WZ X]dhZc id b^c^b^oZ i]Z bdge]dad\^XVa ^c[dgbVi^dc adhi l]^aZ bVm^b^o^c\i]ZediZci^Va^c[dgbVi^dc\V^cZY^ci]ZbdaZXjaVgVcVanh^h9Z<jhiVVcY L]^iZ!&..+#>cdgYZgidVYZfjViZanlZ^\]i]ZhZd[iZc"XdbeZi^c\\dVah!^i^h^beZgV" i^kZi]Vii]Zh`ZaZiVagZbV^chÄghiWZZmVb^cZY[dgh^\chd[eVi]dad\n!WdcZbdY^ÄXV" i^dc! VcY di]Zg bdge]dad\^XVa kVg^Vi^dch# Dcan i]Zc XVc Vc VXXjgViZ VhhZhhbZci WZ bVYZd[i]Z¹bdge]dad\^XVakVajZºd[i]Zh`ZaZiVaheZX^bZchVcYd[i]ZkVg^djhedg" i^dchd[^cY^k^YjVaheZX^bZch#>i^hd[iZcjhZ[ja[dgbdaZXjaVgVcVanh^hidWZÄghiVi" iZbeiZYdccdc]jbVcgZbV^chdgdc]jbVcheZX^bZchd[YjW^djhegdkZc^ZcXZid ZhiVWa^h]i]Z[ZVh^W^a^ind[i]ZbZi]dYeg^dgidi]ZYZhigjXi^kZhVbea^c\d[bdgZkVaj" VWaZheZX^bZch#

&-#,BdaZXjaVgDhiZdad\n

()*

GZbdkVad[h`ZaZiVai^hhjZ[dgbdaZXjaVgVcVanh^hYZhigdnh^c[dgbVi^dcVWdjii]Z bdge]dad\nd[i]ZWdcZ!Wjii]^hadhhXVcWZgZYjXZY\gZVianWnegdeZgYdXjbZciV" i^dceg^dgidhVbea^c\#I]ZZmVXibZi]dYhZbeadnZYidgZXdgYi]Zbdge]dad\nl^aa YZeZcYdci]ZVci^X^eViZYYZ\gZZd[YZhigjXi^dcVcYi]Z^bedgiVcXZd[i]ZheZX^bZc# B^c^bVaan! ]^\]"fjVa^in e]did\gVe]h l^i] V hXVaZ WVg VcY gVY^d\gVe]h h]djaY WZ iV`ZcVcYYZkZadeZYeg^dgidhVbea^c\#BdaY^c\VcYXVhi^c\d[heZX^bZchegdk^YZV i]gZZ"Y^bZch^dcVagZXdgYd[i]Zbdge]dad\n#I]^h!^cXdbW^cVi^dcl^i]e]did\gVe]h! b^c^b^oZhi]Zadhhd[^c[dgbVi^dc#9dXjbZciVi^dcdcanegZhZgkZhbdge]dad\^XVa^c" [dgbVi^dc^[^igZbV^cheZgbVcZcianVXXZhh^WaZ!hdXVhihVcYe]did\gVe]hd[i]ZgZa" ZkVciheZX^bZchVadc\l^i]Xde^Zhd[i]ZgZhjaihd[i]ZbdaZXjaVgVcVanh^hh]djaYWZ YZedh^iZYegdeZganVcYegdbeian^ci]ZVeegdeg^ViZVgX]^kZh#

$.!AND0#2 4U_hibYR_^eS\UYSQSYT9C6^hi]ZbdaZXjaZd[]ZgZY^in#I]Z\ZcZi^XXdYZ^c9C6 ^hWVhZYdc[djgX]Zb^XVaWj^aY^c\WadX`hXVaaZYcjXaZdi^YZh/VYZc^cZ!Xnidh^cZ!i]n" b^cZ!VcY\jVc^cZ#I]ZhZcjXaZdi^YZhXVcWZi]dj\]id[Vh[dgb^c\V[djg"aZiiZgVa" e]VWZii]ViheZaahdjii]ZVhhZbWan^chigjXi^dch[dgVaai]ZegdiZ^chi]VibV`ZjeVc dg\Vc^hb#6abdhiZkZgnXZaa^cVeZghdc¼hWdYn]VhVXdbeaZiZXdend[i]Z^g9C6!VcY Vaa i]ZhZ Xde^Zh VgZ ZhhZci^Vaan ^YZci^XVa# I]ZgZ ^h V igZbZcYdjh Vbdjci d[ gZhZVgX] V^bZY Vi ZmigVXi^c\ kVg^djh ineZh d[ ^c[dgbVi^dc [gdb 9C6! ^c eVgi WZXVjhZ bVcn Y^hZVhZh VgZ i]dj\]i id ]VkZ V \ZcZi^X XdbedcZci# >c V W^dbZY^XVa XdciZmi! heZX^ÄX Y^hZVhZh!hjX]Vh=jci^c\idc¼hY^hZVhZVcYh^X`aZXZaaVcZb^V!XVcWZY^V\cdhZYWVhZY [gdb9C6VadcZ#I]ZhZmVcY\ZcZgVaVcXZhignd[Vcjc`cdlc^cY^k^YjVaXVcWZYZ" iZgb^cZY[gdb9C6#8dbeVg^hdchd[9C6hVbeaZhXVcWZjhZYidZhiVWa^h]^YZci^in VcYeViZgc^in#7gdlc'%%%egdk^YZhVcdkZgk^Zld[i]ZVeea^XVi^dcd[VcX^Zci9C6 hijY^Zhid]jbVcdhiZdad\n# I]ZVW^a^inidYZiZgb^cZhZm!VcXZhign!Y^hZVhZhiVijh!VcY^YZci^in[gdb9C6]Vh dWk^djhVeea^XVi^dch^cdhiZdad\n![dgZch^Xh!VgX]Zdad\n!VcYZkZceVaZdcidad\n#I]ZhZ Veea^XVi^dch!i]dj\]!VaaYZeZcYdci]ZVW^a^iniddWiV^c9C6[gdbdg\Vc^XgZbV^chd[ jc`cdlcVci^fj^in#6[iZgVcdg\Vc^hbY^Zh!i]Z]^\]andg\Vc^oZYbdaZXjaZhd[9C6 YZ\gVYZ gVe^Yan# I]Z `Zn XdcXZeijVa WgZV`i]gdj\] i]Vi aZY id i]Z ÄZaY d[ ¹VcX^Zci 9C6ºlVhi]ZgZXd\c^i^dci]ViYZhe^iZi]^hYZXVn![gV\bZcihd[9C6VgZhdbZi^bZh egZhZci ^c gZbV^ch d[ \gZVi Vci^fj^in# L^i] dcan V [Zl bdY^ÄXVi^dch! Zm^hi^c\ iZX]" c^fjZh[dg^hdaVi^c\bdYZgc9C6XVcVahdWZjhZYidgZig^ZkZi]^h9C6=^\jX]^ZiVa#! &.-)0E~~Wd!&.-*#I]ZhZiZX]c^fjZhdg^\^cVaangZfj^gZYVaVg\ZVbdjcid[egZhZgkZY 9C6!VXg^iZg^VbZidcan^cXVhZhd[ZmXZei^dcVaegZhZgkVi^dcZ#\#!bjbb^Zhdg^XZ" ZbWZYYZYVc^bVah# 9ZkZadebZcid[i]Z`_\i]UbQcUSXQY^bUQSdY_^E8GbVYZ^iedhh^WaZidgZig^ZkZ ZmedcZci^VaanhbVaaZgVbdjcihd[9C6Bjaa^hVcY;VaddcV!&.-,#>cdgYZgidVcVanoZ 9C6!^i^hcZXZhhVgnid]VkZVhj[ÄX^ZcifjVci^ind[^i#Jh^c\XdckZci^dcVaiZX]c^fjZh! ZkZcVYdoZcbdaZXjaZhd[9C6VgZZ[[ZXi^kZan^ck^h^WaZ¸i]ZnVgZiddhbVaaidYZiZXi# I]ZE8GVXihVhV¹bdaZXjaVge]didXdenbVX]^cZºWnbV`^c\a^iZgVaanb^aa^dchd[ Xde^Zhd[VhZXi^dcd[9C6#I]^h^hgZ[ZggZYidVhVbea^ÄXVi^dc!VcYE8GXVcVbea^[nV hZXi^dcd[9C6hiVgi^c\[gdbdcanV[Zldg^\^cVabdaZXjaZh#I]ZaVg\ZVbdjcid[9C6 n^ZaYZYWni]ZbZi]dYXVci]ZcWZVcVanoZYfj^iZZVh^anjh^c\VkVg^Zind[hiVcYVgY 

8]VeiZg&-AVWdgVidgnEgdXZYjgZhGZedgi^c\

iZX]c^fjZh#Jh^c\E8G!gZhZVgX]ZghlZgZVWaZidgZig^ZkZ9C6[gdbVcX^Zcih`ZaZiVa gZbV^ch=V\ZaWZg\ZiVa#!&.-.#I]^hVYkVcXZbVYZVcX^Zci9C6bZi]dYdad\nVe" ea^XVWaZidVWgdVYgVc\Zd[fjZhi^dch^cdhiZdad\n# I]Z\ZcZgVabZi]dYdad\n[dgdWiV^c^c\VcYVcVano^c\9C6[gdbVWdcZdgiddi] ^ckdakZhi]gZZ\ZcZgVahiV\Zh#;^ghi!i]Z9C6bjhiWZZmigVXiZYVcY^hdaViZY#I]^h^c" kdakZhgZYjX^c\VWdjiV\gVbd[WdcZdgiddi]idedlYZg#I]ZedlYZg^hi]ZcigZViZY X]Zb^XVaanidgZbdkZegdiZ^chVcYdi]ZgXdbedjcYhVcYidXdcXZcigViZi]Z9C6#HZX" dcY!VegZYZiZgb^cZYhZXi^dcd[i]Z9C6^hVbea^ÄZYjh^c\E8G#;^cVaan!i]ZgZhjai^c\ 9C6hVbeaZ^hVcVanoZY!ine^XVaanWnYZiZgb^c^c\^ihcjXaZdi^YZhZfjZcXZ#HiZVYbVc '%%(egdk^YZhVgZk^Zld[b^idX]dcYg^Va9C6VcVanh^hVcY]^hidbdge]dad\n#6hh]Z cdiZh[dgi]Z[dgZch^XXdciZmi!9C6XVcWj^aYV\ZcZi^XegdÄaZVcYgZhjai^c^cY^k^Yj" Vi^dc!Wji^iXVccdiXdchigjXiVW^dad\^XVaegdÄaZd[i]Z^cY^k^YjVa#

#ONTAMINATION 9Zhe^iZ i]Z ZmX^i^c\ ediZci^Va d[ VcX^Zci 9C6! i]Z Veea^XVi^dch VgZ hi^aa a^b^iZY Wn bZi]dYdad\^XVaY^[ÄXjai^Zh=VcYiZiVa#!&..)0@ZabVcVcY@ZabVc!&...#I]ZbV_dg egdWaZb^hXdciVb^cVi^dcWnZmd\Zcdjh9C69C6cdi[gdbi]ZiVg\ZiZY^cY^k^YjVa# A^k^c\ dg\Vc^hbh VgZ XdchiVcian h]ZYY^c\ 9C6"WZVg^c\ i^hhjZh ^c i]Z [dgb d[ h`^c XZaah!]V^g!hVa^kV!VcYdi]ZghZXgZi^dch#6gX]Zdad\^XVah`ZaZiVagZbV^ch![dgZmVbeaZ!g^h` WZ^c\XdciVb^cViZYWni]Z9C6[gdbdg\Vc^hbh^ci]Zhd^a!b^Xgddg\Vc^hbh\gdl" ^c\l^i]^ci]ZWdcZh!ZmXVkVidgh!XjgVidgh!dgZkZci]Z9C6VcVanhihi]ZbhZakZh#I]Z egdWaZbd[XdciVb^cVi^dc^hldghZcZYWni]ZcVijgZd[E8G#I]ZedanbZgVhZX]V^c gZVXi^dcegZ[ZgZci^VaanVbea^ÄZhlZaa"egZhZgkZY9C6bdaZXjaZh!l]^X]VgZbdgZa^`Z" anidWZbdYZgcXdciVb^cVcihi]VcigjanVcX^Zci9C6#7ZXVjhZE8GegdYjXZhaVg\Z Vbdjcihd[]^\]anXdcXZcigViZY9C6!aVWdgVidg^Zhd[iZcZcXdjciZgegdWaZbhl^i]i]Z egdYjXihd[egZk^djhE8GgZVXi^dchXdciVb^cVi^c\XjggZcildg`#8dciVb^cVi^dc^h d[ZmigZbZXdcXZgcl]ZcViiZbei^c\idgZig^ZkZ9C6[gdbVcX^Zci]jbVcgZbV^ch! Vh]jbVchVgZVahdi]ZbV^chdjgXZd[Zmd\Zcdjh9C6!bV`^c\XdciVb^cVi^dcbdgZ Y^[ÄXjaiidYZiZXi#HZkZgVaejWa^h]ZY9C6hZfjZcXZh[gdbkZgnVcX^ZcigZbV^chVgZ cdll^YZan]ZaYidWZ^cVji]Zci^XA^cYV]a!&..,#7ZXVjhZi]ZbViZg^VahjhZY[dgi]Z ZmigVXi^dcd[9C6VgZd[iZcjc^fjZ!VcYi]ZVcVanh^h^hi^bZXdchjb^c\!^cYZeZcYZci gZea^XVi^dcd[gZhjaih^hcdiValVnhXVgg^ZYdji#6cjbWZgd[iZX]c^fjZh]VkZWZZcYZ" kZadeZYidgZYjXZi]ZX]VcXZhd[XdciVb^cVi^dcdXXjgg^c\!VcYid^cXgZVhZi]Za^`Za^" ]ddYd[i]ZXdciVb^cVi^dcWZ^c\gZXd\c^oZY#I]Z^cYZeZcYZcikZg^ÄXVi^dcd[VcX^Zci 9C6gZhjaih^hVahdWZXdb^c\bdgZXdbbdc#Hd!l]ZgZVhXdciVb^cVi^dcl^aaa^`Zan Xdci^cjZidWZd[XdcXZgc!i]ZWdYnd[gZa^VWaZVcX^Zci9C6ldg`l^aaVahdXdci^cjZ idZmeVcY#

4APHONOMYOF$.! I]ZheZX^ÄXhd[YZVi]!Wjg^Va!VcYTYQWU^UcYcVX]Vc\Z^ci]ZX]Zb^XVa!e]nh^XVa!dg W^dad\^XVaXdbedh^i^dcd[WdcZhjWhZfjZciidYZVi]i]ViXVcgZhjai^ci]ZegZhZgkVi^dc d[9C6^chdbZXVhZh!Wjicdi^cdi]Zgh!VgZjc`cdlc#I]ZegZhZgkVi^dcd[9C6YdZh hZZbidWZ^cÅjZcXZYeg^bVg^anWnZck^gdcbZciVaXdcY^i^dchgVi]Zgi]VcWni^bZ!Vi &-#,BdaZXjaVgDhiZdad\n

(),

aZVhi[dggZbV^chndjc\Zgi]VcVWdji&%!%%%nZVghEVghdchVcYLZZYc!&..,#7dcZh VcY iZZi] i]Vi VgZ lZaa"egZhZgkZY bVXgdhXde^XVaan VcY b^XgdhXde^XVaan hZZb bdgZ a^`Zanidn^ZaY9C6#:be^g^XVaZk^YZcXZVahdhj\\Zhihi]VigZbV^ch[gdbXdaYZggZ" \^dchbVnegZhZgkZ9C6WZiiZgi]VcgZbV^ch[gdblVgbZgVgZVhEd^cVgZiVa#!&..+# >i^hVahdXaZVgi]Vib^idX]dcYg^Va9C6bi9C6¸VhbVaa!cdc"cjXaZVg\ZcdbZi]Vi ^h^c]Zg^iZYdcan[gdbi]Zbdi]Zg¸^hZVh^ZgidgZig^ZkZi]VccjXaZVg9C6EVghdch VcYLZZYc!&..,#I]^h^ha^`ZanYjZidi]Z\gZViZgcjbWZgd[Xde^Zhd[bi9C6VcY eZg]Veh^ihhbVaaZg!X^gXjaVghigjXijgZ# 6b^cdVX^YhVgZi]ZX]Zb^XVaWj^aY^c\WadX`hd[egdiZ^ch^cVaaa^k^c\dg\Vc^hbh# :VX]ineZd[Vb^cdVX^YXdbZh^cildb^ggdg"^bV\Z[dgbh`cdlcVhVci^dbZgh/i]Z 9"[dgbVcYi]ZA"[dgb#6aaVb^cdVX^Yhi]ViVgZ^cXdgedgViZY^cidVegdiZ^cVgZ^c i]ZA"[dgb!WjidkZgi^bZi]Zn\gVYjVaanXdckZgi^cidi]Z9"[dgb!VegdXZhh`cdlcVh gVXZb^oVi^dc#6iiZbeihidjhZi]ZgVi^dd[9"idA"[dgbhVhVcVWhdajiZYVi^c\bZi]dY ]VkZ\ZcZgVaan[V^aZY!Vhi]^hgVi^d^hh^\c^ÄXVcianV[[ZXiZYWnY^V\ZcZh^h!Wjii]ZiZX]" c^fjZ]Vh[djcYildVeea^XVi^dch^cbdYZgcdhiZdad\n# Ed^cVgZiVa#&..+]VkZh]dlci]Vii]ZYZ\gZZd[gVXZb^oVi^dcd[VheVgi^XVX^Y^c h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch^hXdggZaViZYl^i]i]ZegZhZgkVi^dcd[9C6#7ZndcYVXZgiV^cYZ\gZZ d[gVXZb^oVi^dc!cd9C6lVhVWaZidWZVbea^ÄZY#I]^hiZX]c^fjZiV`ZhVYkVciV\Zd[ i]ZhZch^i^k^ind[i]ZgVXZb^oVi^dcegdXZhhidZck^gdcbZciVa[VXidgh!i]ZhVbZ[VXidgh i]ViheZZYi]ZYZXVnd[9C6#I]ZbV^cjhZhd[Vb^cdVX^YgVXZb^oVi^dc^cVcX^Zci 9C6ldg`VgZidVhhZhhi]ZegdheZXihd[gZig^Zk^c\9C6VcYid]ZaeXdcÄgbi]ZVj" i]Zci^X^ind[i]Z9C6dWiV^cZY#

-OLDINGAND#ASTING 8Vhihd[h`ZaZiVabViZg^VaVgZjhZY^cdhiZdad\nVcYeVaZdcidad\n[dghZkZgVaejgedh" Zh#I]Znegdk^YZV\ddYi]gZZ"Y^bZch^dcVaVgX]^kVagZXdgYd[i]ZdW_ZXijcYZghijYn BVccVcYBdc\Z!&.-,0Hb^i]VcYAVi^bZg!&.-.#>cVYY^i^dc!i]ZnVgZjhZ[ja^c Xdbbjc^XVi^c\ÄcY^c\hl^i]XdaaZV\jZhVcY[dgha^X^c\^cidXgdhhhZXi^dch[dgXdb" eVgVi^kZejgedhZh#HeZX^Va^oZYiZX]c^fjZhVcYbViZg^VahjhZY^cbdaY^c\VcYXVhi^c\ iZZi]VgZdjia^cZY^c=^aahdc&..'!&..+#HZkZgVabdaY^c\bZi]dYhbVnWZjhZY[dg WdcZh!YZeZcY^c\dci]ZcZZYhd[i]Z^ckZhi^\Vidg0YZiV^ahVgZegdk^YZYWnL]^iZVcY ;da`Zch'%%%#8dbejiZg^oZYidbd\gVe]^X8IVcYaVhZghXVcc^c\bZi]dYhXdb" W^cZYl^i]hiZgZda^i]d\gVe]^XdjiejiVgZgZaVi^kZancZliZX]cdad\^Zhi]ViVaadldhiZ" dad\^hihideZg[dgb¹Y^\^iVabdaY^c\ºd[]VgYi^hhjZheZX^bZch!l^i]i]ZVYYZYWZcZÄi d[gZkZVa^c\^ciZgcVahigjXijgZBV[VgiVcY9Za^c\ZiiZ!'%%'#

0HOTOGRAPHY DhiZdad\^hihjhZe]did\gVe]nidVgX]^kZgZXdgYWdcnbViZg^VaVcY^ihXdciZmiVhlZaa Vh id Xdbbjc^XViZ ^c[dgbVi^dc ^c ejWa^XVi^dch VcY egZhZciVi^dch# BVm^b^o^c\ i]Z ji^a^in d[ e]did\gVe]n ^c dhiZdad\n VhhjbZh Vc jcYZghiVcY^c\ d[ i]Z bZY^jb i]Vi \dZhWZndcYi]ZVW^a^i^Zhd[i]ZXVhjVae]did\gVe]Zg# I]ZVYkZcid[Y^\^iVae]did\gVe]n]VhX]Vc\ZYi]Z[VXZd[hX^Zci^ÄX^bV\^c\#>i^h gVe^YangZeaVX^c\Äab!Wji^ihWg^c\hVcjbWZgd[^bedgiVciXdch^YZgVi^dchVadc\l^i] 

8]VeiZg&-AVWdgVidgnEgdXZYjgZhGZedgi^c\

i]Z WZcZÄih# JcYZghiVcY^c\i]ZiZX]cdad\nVcYi]ZY^[[ZgZcXZhWZilZZcY^\^iVaVcY Äabe]did\gVe]n^h^bedgiVci#=dlZkZg!VcVYZfjViZY^hXjhh^dcd[i]^h^hWZndcYi]Z hXdeZd[i]^hbVcjVa#;dgVXdcX^hZiZX]c^XVagZk^Zld[Y^\^iVa^bV\^c\[jcYVbZciVah hZZ6cYgZlBjio¼hVgi^XaZdca^cZVi/Xdd`*gggS_TUcdQS_][^_g\UTWUdUSX^Y SQ\TYWYdQ\O`X_d_WbQ`Xi#D[[ZgZY]ZgZVgZdcanV[Zl\ZcZgVaXdch^YZgVi^dchgZ\VgY" ^c\e]did\gVe]n^cdhiZdad\n#

%QUIPMENT Gdji^cZh^ijVi^dch^cdhiZdad\ngZfj^gZjh^c\Vh^c\aZ"aZchgZÅZmXVbZgVHAG#I]^h^h igjZ[dgWdi]ÄabVcYY^\^i^Vae]did\gVe]n#6cdi]Zg[dgbVil^i]Y^hi^cXiVYkVciV\Zh ^cÄZaYldg`^h¹^chiVciºdgEdaVgd^Yœe]did\gVe]n#=dlZkZg!Y^\^iVae]did\gVe]n]Vh bZibVcnd[i]ZVYkVciV\Zhd[^chiVcie]did\gVe]n^bbZY^ViZ[ZZYWVX`!XdckZc^ZcXZ VcY]Vhb^i^\ViZY^ihY^hVYkVciV\ZhXdhi!VkV^aVW^a^in!h^c\aZeg^ci!VcYlVhiZ# I]Zji^a^ind[HAGXVbZgVhVcYi]Ze]nh^Xhd[dei^XhgZbV^cjcX]Vc\ZY[gdbÄab idY^\^iVa#I]Z^YZVaaZchZh[dge]did\gVe]^c\heZX^bZchVgZ¹ÅVi"ÄZaYºaZchZh¸i]dhZ l^i][dXVaaZc\i]hVWdjiil^XZi]Vid[¹cdgbVaº,%·&'%bb^c(*bb[dgbVi#I]Z dei^XVafjVa^i^Zhd[i]ZhZaZchZhegdYjXZVÅViÄZaYd[[dXjhl^i]djii]ZX]VgVXiZg^hi^X a^cZVgY^hidgi^dchd[l^YZ"Vc\aZaZchZhdgi]ZYZei]XdbegZhh^dcd[iZaZe]didaZchZh# HbVaahZchdghVh^cVaa"^c"dcZXdchjbZgY^\^iVaXVbZgVhXVcbViX]i]Zdei^XVaZ[" [ZXi d[ (* bb Äab jh^c\ h]dgiZg [dXVa aZc\i] aZchZh# BVcn Y^\^iVa HAGh ]VkZ hZc" hdghXdbeVi^WaZl^i]aZchZh[gdbÄabHAGh!Wjii]ZZ[[ZXi^kZ[dXVaaZc\i]hbVnY^[[Zg# HdbZbVcj[VXijgZghjhZ¹[jaa"h^oZºhZchdghh^b^aVgidi]Z')(+bbVXi^kZVgZVd[ (*bbÄabi]ViYdcdigZfj^gZ[dXVaaZc\i]XdckZgh^dc#Di]ZgZfjVaan]^\]"fjVa^in XVbZgVh]VkZVhZchdgbZVhjg^c\'(#,&*#,bb!\^k^c\Vc-*bbaZchVcZ[[ZXi^kZ [dXVaaZc\i]d[&(%bb#I]ZaViiZg\ZihbdgZ[dXVaaZc\i]djid[VaZch!nZiegdYjXZh i]ZhVbZfjVa^in^bV\Z# AZchZhl^i]bVXgd"[dXjh^c\XVeVW^a^i^ZhVahdXVaaZY¹XadhZ"jeºaZchZhVgZjhZ[ja ^cYdXjbZci^c\hbVaaheZX^bZch#I]ZhZaZchZhVaadli]Z[dXVaed^cid[VaZchidZm" iZcY[Vgi]Zg[gdbi]ZÄabeaVcZ!Z[[ZXi^kZanZcaVg\^c\i]ZhjW_ZXi#;dgZmVbeaZ!bVXgd aZchZhl^i]V&/&XVeVW^a^inXVcgZXdgYViddi]a^[Z"h^oZdci]ZÄab!i]jhbVm^b^o^c\ YZiV^a#6&%*bbbVXgdaZch^h^YZVa[dg\ZcZgVa"ejgedhZdhiZdad\^XVae]did\gVe]n# 9^\^iVak^YZd^h^cXgZVh^c\anXdbbdc^ci]ZÄZaYVhXVbXdgYZgh\ZihbVaaZgVcY WZiiZg# I]Z B^c^"9K [dgbVi ^h edejaVg# 8dbeVXi =^\]"9ZÄc^i^dc ^h \V^c^c\ ViiZc" i^dc#7di]d[i]ZhZ[dgbVihXgZViZ[ddiV\Zhj^iVWaZ[dgWgdVYXVhi#HdbZXVbXdgYZgh]VkZ i]Zdei^dcd[h]ddi^c\^ciZgaVXZYdgegd\gZhh^kZcdc"^ciZgaVXZYk^YZd#>ciZgaVXZYdaY iZX]cdad\nk^YZdXdbW^cZhildÄZaYhd[VaiZgcVi^c\hXVca^cZhidXgZViZZVX][gVbZ d[k^YZd#Egd\gZhh^kZk^YZdhXVchVc^bV\Z^cdcZeVhhd[hZfjZci^VahXVca^cZh[dgZVX] [gVbZd[k^YZd#I]^hgZhjaih^cVhbddi]ZgVcYh]VgeZge^XijgZl^i]]^\]ZggZhdaji^dc VcYcdbdi^dcVgi^[VXih#8VbXdgYZghl^i]egd\gZhh^kZhXVcXVeVW^a^inVahd]VkZVh^c\aZ" h]dibdYZi]ViXVchZgkZVhVcZbZg\ZcXnWVX`"je[dghi^aah#8Veijg^c\Vh^c\aZk^YZd [gVbZ[dgjhZ^ceg^cidghi^aa"^bV\ZegZhZciVi^dc[gdbegd\gZhh^kZhXVc^hZVh^ZgVcY ViV]^\]ZgfjVa^ini]Vc^hedhh^WaZ[gdb^ciZgaVXZYk^YZd#H^c\aZ[gVbZXVeijgZh[gdb ^ciZgaVXZYk^YZdWZcZÄi[gdbi]ZVeea^XVi^dcd[VheZX^VaÄaiZg^c6YdWZœE]didh]deœ# :fj^ebZci bV^ciZcVcXZ ^h ZmigZbZan ^bedgiVci ^c i]Z ÄZaY# :ck^gdcbZciVa Xdch^YZgVi^dchVgZd[iZccZ\aZXiZYjci^a^i^hiddaViZ#=ZVi!hVcY!XdaY!VcYbd^hijgZ &-#.E]did\gVe]n

().

Vaa lgZV` ]VkdX dc XVbZgV Zfj^ebZci# ;jc\Va \gdli] dc ^ciZgcVa aZch ZaZbZcih ^h Xdbbdc ^c kZgn ]jb^Y Zck^gdcbZcih# 9gn VcY l^cYn XdcY^i^dch gZfj^gZ Y^a^\Zci egdiZXi^dc [gdb Wadl^c\ hVcY VcY i]Z ]Vgh] Z[[ZXih d[ ]ZVi dc Zfj^ebZci VcY bZ" Y^V#:migZbZXdaYXVcYZ[ZViWViiZg^Zhfj^X`an^cZaZXigdc^XXVbZgVh#A^i]^jbWViiZg" ^ZhbVnWZY^[ÄXjaiidÄcYVlVn[gdbX^i^Zh#6aad[i]ZhZXdcXZgchVgZZmVXZgWViZY^c Y^\^iVae]did\gVe]n#I]ZgZ^hcdbZX]Vc^XVaWVX`jehdaji^dc^cY^\^iVae]did\gVe]n# ;dgldg`Zgh^ckdakZYeg^bVg^an^cZmdi^XÄZaYldg`!VbZX]Vc^XVaÄabXVbZgV^hhi^aa cZXZhhVgn!ViaZVhi[dgWVX`je#

%XPOSUREAND&ILMOROTHER2ECORDING-EDIA I]ZhZch^i^k^ind[ÄabVcYY^\^iVahZchdghida^\]i^hgViZYWnVc>HDcjbWZg¸V]^\]" ZgcjbWZgbZVchbdgZa^\]i"hZch^i^kZ#>cÄabe]did\gVe]nndjX]ddhZVÄabl^i] VeVgi^XjaVg>HDVXXdgY^c\idVci^X^eViZYXdcY^i^dchVcYndjVgZXdchigV^cZYWni]Z a^b^ihd[i]ViÄabjci^ai]ZZci^gZgdaa^hZmedhZY#>cY^\^iVae]did\gVe]nndjXVcY^Va ^ci]ZYZh^gZY>HD[dgi]ZXdcY^i^dchVcYXVcVY_jhii]Z>HDViVcni^bZ# I]Z^ciZggZaVi^dch]^ed[>HD!aZchVeZgijgZ!VcYh]jiiZgheZZYbViiZgh^cVXdggZXi ZmedhjgZ#ibZVchi]VidcVXaZVghjccnYVnl^i]VaZchVeZg" ijgZd[[$&+!i]Zh]jiiZgheZZYl^aaZfjVai]Z>HDgVi^c\d[i]ZÄab#  ™ HDÄabhXdciV^cÄcZg\gV^chd[a^\]i"hZch^i^kZ XgnhiVahi]ViegdYjXZh]VgeZge]didhVcY]^\]ZgXdcigVhi!WjigZfj^gZadc\Zgh]ji" iZgi^bZhdgl^YZgVeZgijgZhdgWdi]#=^\]">HDÄabhVgZ[VhiZg!WjiXVcWZ\gV^cn! ÅVi^cXdcigVhi!VcYegZhZgkZaZhhYZiV^a#>cY^\^iVae]did\gVe]n!adlZg">HDhVgZ dei^bVa#=^\]">HDhZii^c\hdcanVbea^[ni]Zh^\cVa[gdbi]ZhZchdg#I]^hXVcegd" YjXZY^\^iVa¹cd^hZº¸jcYZh^gZYgVcYdbe^mZahhXViiZgZYVWdjiVc^bV\Z#  ™ I]ZbVg`ZY[jaahiZehd[VeZgijgZ!h]jiiZgheZZY!VcY>HDdcbdhiXVbZgVhVcY aZchZhYdjWaZdg]VakZi]ZZmedhjgZl^i]ZVX]hiZe#;gdb[$&+id[$&&YdjWaZhi]Z a^\]ii]gdj\]i]ZaZch0[gdb&$&'*hZX#id&$'*%hZX#i]ZYjgVi^dcd[i]ZZmedhjgZ ^hXji^c]Va[0VcYVÄabgViZYVi>HD)%%^hil^XZVhhZch^i^kZida^\]iVh>HD'%%# 

8]VeiZg&-AVWdgVidgnEgdXZYjgZhGZedgi^c\

 ™ JhZd[VWbQiSQbT&-gZÅZXiVcXZ^hi]ZWZhilVnidhZiVegdeZgZmedhjgZ^c bdhiXdcY^i^dch#A^\]ibZiZghVgZXVa^WgViZYidi]^hhiVcYVgY#NdjXVcbZiZg[gdb i]ZXVbZgVÄaa^c\i]Zk^ZlÄcYZgl^i]i]Z\gVnXVgYdgndjXVced^ciV]VcY"]ZaY a^\]ibZiZgViVcZkZcan"^aajb^cViZYXVgYYZkd^Yd[h]VYdlhdg\aVgZ#HD! ZmedhZY dg jcZmedhZY¸h]djaY cZkZg WZ m" gVnZY#:medhjgZidV^gedgim"gVnhVgZXjbjaVi^kZVcYV[[ZXi[VhiZg>HDÄabhi]Zbdhi# 9dcdiaZVkZÄab^cX]ZX`ZYaj\\V\Z#6alVnh]VkZ^i]VcY"X]ZX`ZYVihZXjg^in#M"gVnh YdcdiV[[ZXiY^\^iVa^bV\ZhdghidgV\ZbZY^V!i]dj\]higdc\bV\cZi^XÄZaYhbVn# AdlZg"ZcYY^\^iVaXVbZgVhgZXdgY^bV\Zhdcan^c?E:<[dgbVi!jhjVaanl^i]Vcde" i^dcd[]^\]"!bZY^jb"!dgadl"fjVa^inXdbegZhh^dcgVi^dh#?E:<^hV¹adhhnºVa\dg^i]b i]ViY^hXVgYh^c[dgbVi^dcVh^iXdbegZhhZhÄaZh#>iXVc^cigdYjXZVgi^[VXih^cidVc^bV\Z l]^X]VgZXdbedjcYZYl^i]ZVX]XdbegZhh^dc$YZXdbegZhh^dc#I]dj\]cdibZVc^c\" [ja^chcVeh]dih!i]ZhZXVc]VkZgVb^ÄXVi^dch^cXg^i^XVahX^ZcXZe]did\gVe]n#I]Zjc^" kZghValdg`]dghZI>;;[dgbVi^hVkV^aVWaZdcbVcnXVbZgVh!WjiegdYjXZhaVg\ZgÄaZh# Egd[Zhh^dcVaXVbZgVhXVcgZXdgY^c&'"W^i¹XVbZgVG6Lº[dgbVii]ViegdYjXZh]j\Z ÄaZh#I]^hjcXdbegZhhZY[dgbViXdciV^chVaai]Z^c[dgbVi^dcXVeijgZYWni]ZXVbZgV l^i]dji^c"XVbZgV^bV\ZegdXZhh^c\#>i^cXajYZhi^bZ!YViZ![gVbZcjbWZg!aZch!VcY ZmedhjgZ^c[dgbVi^dc#>iXVcWZXjhidb^oZYid^cXajYZdi]Zg^c[dgbVi^dchjX]VhY^h" iVcXZidi]ZhjW_ZXiVcY<EHaVi^ijYZ$adc\^ijYZYViV#I]Zeg^hi^cZ^bV\ZYViV^cG6L ÄaZhegdk^YZi]ZbdhiÅZm^W^a^in#=dlZkZg!G6LÄaZhgZfj^gZegdXZhh^c\Ydlci]Za^cZ! ^cXajY^c\h]VgeZc^c\VcYVY_jhi^c\aZkZah#>iiV`ZhhdbZegVXi^XZid\Zii]ZiZX]c^fjZ XdggZXi#C^`dcœ!8Vcdcœ!VcYdi]Zgegd[Zhh^dcVaa^cZhd[[Zgegdeg^ZiVgnhd[ilVgZYZ" h^\cZYidh^bea^[negdXZhh^c\G6L^bV\Zh#H^b^aVggZhjaihVgZdWiV^cVWaZjh^c\6YdWZ E]didh]de#iXVeijgZhi]ZbVm^bjb Vbdjcid[^bV\ZYViVl]^aZegdk^Y^c\Vc^bbZY^ViZanjhVWaZ^bV\Z# 6 kVg^Zin d[ XVeijgZ bZY^V Zm^hi ^cXajY^c\ BZbdgn Hi^X`hž! B^XgdYg^kZhœ! VcY l^gZaZhhXdccZXi^dchidXdbejiZg]VgYYg^kZh#8dbeVXi;aVh]œXVgYhV#`#V#8;žXVgYh VgZegdk^c\idWZgdWjhihidgV\ZYZk^XZh#HdbZjaigV"]^\]"XVeVX^in8;XVgYh]VkZWZZc gZedgiZYid]VkZhiVW^a^inegdWaZbh#;djg&<78;XVgYhbVnWZWZiiZgi]VcdcZ)<7 XVgY#>bV\ZhdcbZbdgnYZk^XZh^cVXVbZgVVgZZVh^anYdlcadVYZYidVXdbejiZg]VgY Yg^kZ#>i^h^bedgiVciidVgX]^kZY^\^iVa^bV\Zhdc89hdg9K9hVii]Z^gbVm^bjb fjVa^in# Ha^YZh VcY cZ\Vi^kZh h]djaY WZ hidgZY ^c edanegdenaZcZ haZZkZh# BZiVa WdmZh [dg ha^YZhVcY\aVhh^cZZckZadeZh[dgcZ\Vi^kZhVgZVXXZeiVWaZ#6kd^Yjh^c\k^cnaha^YZh]ZZih Vhi]Zd[["\Vhh^c\d[i]Zk^cnal^aaYZhigdnYnZhdcÄab#GVgZVcYkVajVWaZ^bV\Zh!Wdi] eg^cihVcYha^YZh!h]djaYWZYjea^XViZYl^i]^ciZgcZ\Vi^kZhVcY$dghXVccZYVcYi]Zc adX`ZY VlVn jcYZg VgX]^kVa bjhZjb XdcY^i^dch# GZeZViZY egd_ZXi^dch d[ ha^YZh VcY ZmedhjgZd[VaaÄabVcYeg^cihidi]ZZaZbZcihYZ\gVYZhi]Z^gfjVa^indkZgi^bZ#

,IGHTINGAND3ETUP EgdeZg dg^ZciVi^dc VcY a^\]i^c\ hZeVgViZ i]Z egd[Zhh^dcVa"add`^c\ e]did\gVe] [gdb &-#.E]did\gVe]n

(*&

hcVeh]dih#Ig^edYhVcYheZZYa^\]ihZaZXigdc^XÅVh]ZhVgZ[jcYVbZciVa[dg\ddYe]d" id\gVe]h#;^ZaYe]did\gVe]neg^bVg^angZa^ZhdcVkV^aVWaZcVijgVaa^\]i!Wjii]ZfjVa^in d[a^\]iX]Vc\Zhl^i]lZVi]ZgVcYi^bZd[YVn#E]did\gVe]hiV`ZckZgnZVgandgaViZ ^ci]ZYVnd[iZc^ckdakZh]VYdlhi]ViXVcWZb^i^\ViZYl^i]VcZaZXigdc^XÅVh]#;^aa ÅVh]ZhXVcgZkZVaYZiV^a^cYZZeb^Y"YVnh]VYdlhVcYgZYjXZ]Vgh]^bV\ZXdcigVhi# L]^iZXVgYh!I"h]^gih!VcYXgjbeaZYVajb^cjb[d^aXVcWZjhZYidWdjcXZhd[iZga^\]i ^cidYVg`h]VYdlh#BVc^ejaVi^c\a^\]iidXdbZ[gdbi]Zh^YZd[VhjW_ZXil^aaZbe]V" h^oZYZiV^aVcYiZmijgZ#6cd[["XVbZgVÅVh]hncXXdgY^hXdckZc^Zci[dgi]^hejgedhZ#6 higV^\]i"dcÅVh]l^aa¹ÅViiZcºVc^bV\ZWnZa^b^cVi^c\bdhih]VYdlh#G^c\ÅVh]ZhVgZ jhZY^c[dgZch^XVcYbZY^XVae]did\gVe]n[dgÅVi!ZkZc^aajb^cVi^dc# 6 a^iiaZ i]dj\]i VWdji hZii^c\ je h]dih l^aa ^begdkZ i]Z^g kVajZ# 7VX`\gdjcYh h]djaYXdcigVhil^i]i]ZhjW_ZXi#HegVn^c\lViZga^\]iandci]ZbVig^mVgdjcY[dhh^a WdcZh^ch^ij]ZaehXgZViZXdcigVhi#>ci]ZaVW!WaVX`dg\gVnkZakZidg[ZaiWVX`\gdjcYh ^begdkZXdadgVXXjgVXn#HeZX^bZchXVcWZhiVW^a^oZYVcYegZhZciZY^cVegdeZgeaVcZ d[ gZ[ZgZcXZ l^i] i]^c\h Vh h^beaZ Vh V hZi d[ gjWWZg lVh]Zgh# 6kd^Y d^a"WVhZY XaVnh i]ViXdciVb^cViZheZX^bZch#6gZ[ZgZcXZhXVaZh]djaYVeeZVgl^i]VaaheZX^bZch#GdX` ]VbbZgh!Xd^ch!VcYaZchXVehVgZeddghjWhi^ijiZh[dgVcZVhn"id"gZVYbZig^XhXVaZ#6 hXVaZ^hbdhijhZ[jal]ZcgV^hZYidi]Z[dXVaeaVcZd[i]Z^bedgiVcieVgid[i]ZhjW_ZXi# I]ZiVg\ZihXVaZhdci]ZXdkZgÅVehd[i]^hbVcjValZgZYZh^\cZYid[daYdjiVcYegd" k^YZVc^YZVagZ[ZgZcXZhXVaZ[dgbdhih^ijVi^dch#6X]^cVbVg`ZgdgÄcZ\gZVhZeZcX^a XVcWZjhZYidbV`ZcdiZh^ci]ZheVXZhegdk^YZYVcYl^aal^eZd[[ZVh^an#H]Vge^Zœ eZgbVcZcibVg`ZghVahdldg`VcYXVcWZgZbdkZYjh^c\Vl]^iZeaVhi^XZgVhZg#

,EGAL#ONSIDERATIONS E]did\gVe]nXVcWZVedlZg[jaiddal]ZcVcdhiZdad\^hi^hXVaaZYjedcidhZgkZVhVc ZmeZgil^icZhhhZZ8]VeiZg(#&#6aae]did\gVe]^XZk^YZcXZegZhZciZY^cXdjgi^hhjW" _ZXiidXgdhh"ZmVb^cVi^dc!^cXajY^c\i]ZbVccZg^cl]^X]^ilVhVXfj^gZY!VgX]^kZY! VcYgZegdYjXZY#¹6Yb^hh^W^a^inºd[Zk^YZcXZ^hY^[[ZgZci[gdb¹lZ^\]iºd[i]ZZk^YZcXZ# HdbZ_jg^hY^Xi^dchfjZhi^dci]ZVYb^hh^W^a^ind[Y^\^iVae]did\gVe]nYjZidi]ZZVhZd[ bVc^ejaVi^c\i]Z^bV\Z!egZ[Zgg^c\Äab"WVhZY^bV\Zh^chiZVY#Di]Zghh^beanXdch^YZg i]ViVaae]did\gVe]n\dZhidi]Z¹lZ^\]iºd[i]ZZk^YZcXZ# >[^i^hZmeZXiZYi]Vindjge]did\gVe]nl^aaWZjhZYidhjeedgide^c^dch^cVaZ\Va XdciZmi!i]ZWZhiegVXi^XZ^hidh]ddiÄabidZhiVWa^h]VWVh^XgZXdgYVcYi]ZciV`ZVY" kVciV\Zd[i]ZÅZm^W^a^inVcYXdckZc^ZcXZd[Y^\^iVae]did\gVe]n#6¹i]gdl"VlVnXVb" ZgVº^hd[iZchj[ÄX^Zci^ci]^hgZ\VgY!Xdchi^iji^c\^cZmeZch^kZ^chjgVcXZ#6hViidgcZnh VcYXdjgihWZXdbZbdgZVlVgZi]Vi[dgZch^X^bV\ZVcVanh^hXVc^YZci^[nbVc^ejaViZY Y^\^iVa^bV\Zh!i]ZnVgZaZhha^`ZanidX]VaaZc\ZY^\^iVae^XijgZhl]Zci]ZnVgZ^c^i^Vaan XVeijgZY^cG6L[dgbViVcYWVX`ZYjel^i]XdckZci^dcVaÄab# 8dcXZgchVgZWZ^c\gV^hZY^cVXVYZb^VVWdjiY^\^iVae]did\gVe]nVcY^bV\ZbV" c^ejaVi^dc VcY ]dl i]^h gZaViZh id YViV ^ciZ\g^in# H]VgeZc^c\ d[ V G6L ^bV\Z VcY bV`^c\idcVaVY_jhibZcihVgZ^bedgiVcieVgihd[WVh^X^bV\ZegdXZhh^c\#=dlZkZg!i]Z ZVhZd[Veean^c\Xadc^c\hiVbehVcYXjii^c\VcYeVhi^c\eVgih^c6YdWZE]didh]de ]VhaZY_djgcVaZY^idghidhVni]^h^hfjZhi^dcVWaZVcYhX^ZcXZZi]^X^hihidYZXaVgZi]Z egVXi^XZh^beanlgdc\#HdbZ_djgcVahVgZYZkZade^c\^bV\ZbVc^ejaVi^dc\j^YZa^cZh VcY di]Zgh ZcXdjgV\Z gZhZVgX]Zgh id hjWb^i dg^\^cVah Vadc\ l^i] ZY^iZY ^bV\Zh# 6g" 

8]VeiZg&-AVWdgVidgnEgdXZYjgZhGZedgi^c\

X]^k^c\cVi^kZG6LY^\^iVaÄaZhVcYiV`^c\V[ZlÄabh]dihVgZkVajVWaZh]djaYndj cZZYidYZ[ZcYi]Z^ciZ\g^ind[^bV\ZhjhZYidiZaaVc^bedgiVcihidgn#Hj[ÄXZ^iidhVn! ^bbZchZ XVji^dc ^h lVggVciZY l]Zc dcZ X]ddhZh id bdY^[n Vc ^bV\Z id Zc]VcXZ V hX^Zci^ÄXed^ci#HZZ<^aWZgiVcYG^X]VgYh'%%%[dgVY^hXjhh^dcd[Y^\^iVa^bV\^c\d[ WdcZbdY^ÄXVi^dcVcYi]ZZi]^XVafjZhi^dcd[Y^\^iVaVaiZgVi^dc#

2ADIOGRAPHY 6cVanh^hd[WdcZh^ci]Za^k^c\^cY^k^YjVa^hjhjVaanVXXdbea^h]ZYWnZmedh^c\VÄab idm"gVnheVhhZYi]gdj\]i]ZWdYneVgi#I]ZWdcZi^hhjZWadX`hhdbZm"gVnh!gZhjai^c\ ^cVcZ\Vi^kZ^bV\Zdci]ZÄabXVaaZYVbQTY_WbQ`X#7ZXVjhZWdcZh!^cXajY^c\^ciZgcVa eVgihd[WdcZh!WadX`hdbZd[i]ZgVnh!i]ZgVY^d\gVe]XVcWZVkVajVWaZV^Y^cY^V\cdh" ^c\WdcZXdcY^i^dc^cbZY^X^cZ# GVY^d\gVe]n^hVahdVkVajVWaZidda[dgi]ZdhiZdad\^hi#7ZXVjhZi]ZgZ^hcdg^h`id VYgnWdcZheZX^bZc!kVg^djhZmedhjgZhVcYdg^ZciVi^dchbVnWZbVYZidh]dli]Z ^ciZgcVaVgX]^iZXijgZd[VWdcZdgi]ZYZkZadebZciVahiVijhd[VcjcZgjeiZYYZci^i^dc# DhiZdad\^hih d[iZc jhZ [jaan ZcXadhZY m"gVn YZk^XZh l^i]^c h]^ZaYZY! WZcX]ide XVhZh l^i]ZmiZgcVaXdcigdah;Vm^igdcdgdi]Zg#I]ZheZX^bZch]djaYWZdg^ZciZYhdi]Vi i]Zm"gVnWZVbeVhhZhi]gdj\]i]ZXZciZgd[i]ZVgZVd[^ciZgZhiVcYhdi]Vii]^hVgZV ^heZgeZcY^XjaVgidi]ZWZVbVcYeVgVaaZal^i]i]ZÄabeaVcZ#I]ZheZX^bZcVcYÄab h]djaYWZVh[VgVhegVXi^XVa[gdbi]Zm"gVnhdjgXZVcYVhXadhZiddcZVcdi]ZgVhedh" h^WaZ#8dbejiZg"Vhh^hiZYZc]VcXZbZcid[gVY^d\gVe]hbVnWZjhZ[jaV[iZgegdXZhh^c\ DYlV`VcYHX]jai^c\!&..+#I]ZYZkZadebZcid[XdbejiZYidbd\gVe]nhXVcc^c\ VYYhVediZci!cdcYZhigjXi^kZWdcZ"hZXi^dc^c\iddaidi]ZdhiZdad\^hi¼h`^i#8IhXVccZgh VgZjhjVaandcan[djcY^c]dhe^iVagVY^d\gVe]nYZeVgibZcih!VcYi]Z^gjhZgZfj^gZh XdaaVWdgVi^dcl^i]eZghdccZai]ZgZ^c#HeddgZiVa#&..(Y^hXjhhVeea^XVi^dchVcYegdW" aZbh^ckdakZY^ci]ZYZg^kVi^dcd[dhiZdbZig^XYViV[gdb8IhXVch#L^i]i]ZVYkZcid[ ^cYjhig^Va8IhXVcc^c\!VXXjgVX^Zhd[aZhhi]VcdcZiZci]d[Vb^aa^bZiZgVgZgdji^cZ# L]Zcedhh^WaZ!]dlZkZg!^i^hValVnhWZiiZgidiV`ZbZVhjgZbZcihY^gZXian[gdbi]Z heZX^bZc#I]^h^hWZXVjhZbZVhjg^c\VaVhZgdg8IhXVc\gZVian^cXgZVhZhi]ZX]VcXZ i]VibVig^m!Xadi]^c\!Y^hidgi^dc!dgZgdh^dcl^aaWZdkZgadd`ZYVcY^cVXXjgViZbZV" hjgZbZcih\ZcZgViZY#IdjhZVcnd[i]ZhZiZX]c^fjZh^c^ckZhi^\Vi^c\]jbVch`ZaZiVa bViZg^Va!XdchjaiVheZX^Va^hi^cgVY^d\gVe]n#HZZDgicZgVcYEjihX]Vg&.-&!=^aahdc &..+!VcY7gjlZa]Z^YZ'%%&[dgY^hXjhh^dchd[gVY^d\gVe]n^cdhiZdad\^XVaVcYYZc" iVaVcVanhZh!VcYBV[VgiVcY9Za^c\ZiiZ'%%'[dgVeea^XVi^dchd[i]gZZ"Y^bZch^dcVa ^bV\^c\^ceVaZdVci]gdedad\nVcYegZ]^hidg^XVgX]Zdad\n#

-ICROSCOPY ;^cZYZiV^ahdci]Zhjg[VXZd[VWdcZdgiddi]bVnWZWZhi^ckZhi^\ViZYl^i]VW^cdXjaVg Y^hhZXi^c\b^XgdhXdeZ#>ciZchZ!jc^Y^gZXi^dcVaa^\]ihdjgXZhXVcWZjhZYidZbe]Vh^oZ b^XgdhXde^XYZiV^a#;dgY^hXg^b^cVi^c\WZilZZckVg^djh`^cYhd[hjg[VXZVaiZgVi^dcdc WdcZh gddi bVg`h! Xji bVg`h! eVi]dad\n! i]Z W^cdXjaVg b^XgdhXdeZ ^h V bdhi kVaj" VWaZV^Y#Ide]did\gVe]b^XgdhXde^XhigjXijgZdgigVjbVdci]Zhjg[VXZd[VWdcZ!i]Z hXVcc^c\ZaZXigdcb^XgdhXdeZH:BXVcegdk^YZZmXZaaZci^bV\Zhl^i]\gZViYZei] &-#&&B^XgdhXden

(*(

&IGURE6i]gZZ"Y^bZch^dcVaaVhZg"hXVcc^c\jc^iVii]ZJc^kZgh^ind[8Va^[dgc^V!7Zg`ZaZn# I]ZbVX]^cZVXXjgViZanbZVhjgZhi]gZZ"Y^bZch^dcVahjg[VXZided\gVe]nVcYigVch[Zghi]ZhZ YViVidVXdbejiZgl]ZgZbZVhjgZbZcih!gZhidgVi^dch!VcYdi]ZgbVc^ejaVi^dchVgZedhh^WaZ#

d[ÄZaY#;dgaVg\ZheZX^bZchi]ViYdcdiÄi^ci]ZkVXjjbX]VbWZgd[i]Zb^XgdhXdeZ! dg[dgheZX^bZch]djhZY^c^chi^iji^dchl^i]djiH:B[VX^a^i^Zh!^ibVnWZcZXZhhVgnid gZea^XViZi]Zhjg[VXZd[i]ZdW_ZXiWnbdaY^c\^il^i]YZciVa^begZhh^dcgjWWZghVcY edjg^c\VcZedmnedh^i^kZ[dgjhZ^ci]ZVcVanh^h#;dgldg`dcWdcZhjg[VXZhVi]^\] bV\c^ÄXVi^dc!i]ZH:B]VhWZZci]ZigVY^i^dcVaiddad[X]d^XZVcY!jc[dgijcViZan!Zm" eZchZ!WjicZlY^\^iVa^bV\^c\iZX]cdad\^ZhVgZX]Vc\^c\i]^h<^aWZgiVcYG^X]VgYh! '%%%#HiVcYVgY]^hidad\^XVab^XgdhXde^XiZX]c^fjZhVgZjhZYidhijYni]Zb^XgdhXde^X higjXijgZd[WdcZWZadli]Zhjg[VXZdgi]Z^ciZgcVahigjXijgZd[iZZi]=^aahdc!&..+# HX]jaio&..,egdk^YZhildgZk^Zlhd[]dlb^XgdhXdenXVcWZVeea^ZY^c]jbVcdh" iZdad\^XVahijY^Zh#

#OMPUTING I]ZXdbejiZggZkdaji^dcXdci^cjZhid^beVXiVaaVgZVhd[hX^ZcXZ!^cXajY^c\]jbVc dhiZdad\n# HViZaa^iZh Xdbbjc^XViZ l^i] ]VcY"]ZaY <EH 


8]VeiZg&-AVWdgVidgnEgdXZYjgZhGZedgi^c\

cZXiZYidZaZXigdc^XY^hiVcXZ"bZVhjg^c\YZk^XZhVaadlaVhZg"egZX^h^dc^ceadii^c\heZX^" bZch^ci]ZÄZaY#9Zh`ideXdbejiZghgZXZ^kZ!egdXZhh!VcYdjiejidjgi]dj\]ih!djg YViV!VcYdjg^bV\Zh#AVhZghXVccZghXdccZXiZYidXdbejiZghVaadli]ZZmiZgcVa[dgb d[dW_ZXihidWZ^bV\ZY^ci]gZZY^bZch^dch!^bedgiZYidi]ZXdbejiZg!VcYbVc^ej" aViZYY^\^iVaan^cbVcnlVnh;^\jgZ&-#+#BZY^XVaXdbejiZghVaadljhideZZgYZZe l^i]^cdhhZdjhhigjXijgZhidhZZ[dgbZgan]^YYZcZk^YZcXZd[VcX^ZcieVi]dad\n#I]Z ZmeadY^c\ \adWVa Xdbbjc^XVi^dch cZildg` bV`Zh ^i edhh^WaZ id ZmX]Vc\Z ^YZVh VcY YViVgVe^YanVXgdhh^ciZgcVi^dcVa[gdci^ZghVcYWZilZZcÄZaYVcYaVWdgVidgn#6hVgZhjai d[Vaad[i]ZhZYZkZadebZcih!^i^h^bedhh^WaZidi]^c`d[ldg`^c\^c]jbVcdhiZdad\n l^i]djii]ZV^YVcYldg`^c\`cdlaZY\Zd[XdbejiZgiZX]cdad\^Zh# >cVYY^i^dcidi]ZWVh^XldgY"egdXZhh^c\h`^aahVcYegd\gVbhcZXZhhVgn[dghX]da" VganXdbbjc^XVi^dc!VaadhiZdad\^hihh]djaYaZVgci]ZWVh^Xhd[YViVWVhZVcYhegZVY" h]ZZiegd\gVbhi]ViVaadl[dgi]ZgVe^YVcYZVhnbVc^ejaVi^dcd[aVg\ZdhiZdad\^XVa YViVhZih#8dbejiZghVgZiddahi]Vi]Zaei]Z^bV\^cVi^dc!Wjii]ZnYdcdihjWhi^ijiZ [dg^i#Jc[dgijcViZan!]jbVcdhiZdad\^hih]VkZcdiWZZc^bbjcZidi]Z[VahZ]deZi]Vi XdbejiZghVcYiZX]cdad\nXVcgZeaVXZgZVaheZX^bZchVcYgZVaZmeZgi^hZ#I]ZXjggZci ]^\]"iZX]XgVoZ]VhXgZViZYhdbZ^ciZgZhi^c\ZmZgX^hZh#;dgZmVbeaZ!WdcZh]VkZWZZc ^bV\ZYWn8IVcYaVhZghXVch!^cejiidYZh`ideVcYbV^c[gVbZhnhiZbh!bVc^ejaViZY i]ZgZ^cl^i]ViiZcYVciWZVji^[jaXdadghVcYWdcZhÅdVi^c\VcYgdiVi^c\^cheVXZ!VcY i]ZcXde^ZYWnhXjaei^c\i]ZY^\^i^oZYWdcn[dgb^cideaVhi^X#HdbZhjX]ZmZgX^hZhVgZ jhZ[jaidhjg\ZdchXjhidb^o^c\egdhi]Zi^XYZk^XZhVcYid^ckZhi^\VidghVhhZhh^c\[gV\^aZ gZbV^ch^cbVig^mAnccZgjeZiVa#!&..,#=dlZkZg!hdbZd[i]^h]^\]"iZX]l^oVgYgn Veea^ZYidVgX]Zdad\^XVaVcYeVaZdcidad\^XVaheZX^bZchaZVkZhi]ZdWhZgkZgidXdcXajYZ! ¹I]VilVhgZVaanVlZhdbZ!Wjihdl]Vi4º8dbejiZghXVcYd^cXgZY^WaZi]^c\h!Wjii]Zn VgZiddahi]Vi]Zaejh^ckZhi^\ViZ!dg\Vc^oZ!VcYYdXjbZci#I]ZnYdcdihjWhi^ijiZ[dg djgdlc^bV\^cVi^dcdgXg^i^XVa_jY\ZbZcil]ZcVhhZhh^c\dhiZdad\^XVagZbV^ch#

2EPORTING 6[iZg i]Z jhjVaan jcejWa^h]ZY ^c^i^Va ÄZaY gZedgih id \gVci^c\ V\ZcX^Zh VcY kVg^djh \dkZgcbZciVa gZ\jaVidgn V\ZcX^Zh! ejWa^h]ZY gZedgi^c\ d[ ]db^c^Y dhiZdad\^XVa gZ" bV^ch[gdbeVaZdcidad\^XVaXdciZmihd[iZcdXXjgh^ci]gZZhiV\Zh/Äghi!VccdjcXZbZci ^cVegdb^cZci^ciZgcVi^dcVa_djgcVahjX]VhHX^ZcXZdgCVijgZ![daadlZYWnVcVidb^" XVaYZhXg^ei^dc^cVbdgZheZX^Va^oZY_djgcVahjX]Vhi]Z6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa 6ci]gdedad\n!VcYÄcVaan!jhjVaannZVghaViZg![jaabdcd\gVe]^XigZVibZci#7Vh^XbZi" g^X!egZhZgkVi^dcVa!VcYXdciZmijVaYViVVgZgZedgiZY!Vadc\l^i]^ciZgegZiVi^dch!^cVaa i]gZZejWa^XVi^dckZcjZh# >c[dgZch^X]jbVcdhiZdad\n!i]ZgZedgi^c\d[h`ZaZiVagZbV^chjhjVaan[daadlhVY^[" [ZgZcihZg^Zhd[hiZeh#=ZgZ!WZXVjhZd[i]Zg^\dgdjhegdXZYjgZhVYdeiZYWnaVlZc[dgXZ" bZci V\ZcX^Zh VcY bZY^XVa ZmVb^cZgh 9^BV^d VcY 9^BV^d! &.-.! i]Z dhiZdad\^hi¼h bdhi^bedgiVcigZedgiWZXdbZheVgid[i]ZaZ\VagZXdgY^chiZVYd[bdk^c\higV^\]iid" lVgYejWa^XVi^dc#I]Z[dgbVi[dg[dgZch^XgZedgi^c\^ci]ZJc^iZYHiViZhVcYWZndcY^h hZiWni]ZCVi^dcVa;dgZch^X6ci]gdedad\n9ViV7Vc`Vii]ZJc^kZgh^ind[IZccZhhZZ! @cdmk^aaZBddgZ"?VchZcVcY?Vcio!&.-.#I]Z^ckZcidgnZcXdbeVhhZhi]ZZci^gZh`Za" Zidc!VcYWdcZhVgZhXdgZY[dgegZhZcXZ$VWhZcXZVcYXdcY^i^dc!l^i]cdiZhdci]^c\h

&-#&(GZedgi^c\

(**

a^`ZeVi]dad\n#HjcY^X`&.-)egdk^YZhV\ddYgZk^Zld[i]ZdhiZdad\^hi¼heVgi^X^eVi^dc ^c[dgZch^XXVhZh# >cV[dgZch^XhZii^c\!i]ZegZhhjgZ[dgVXXjgViZVcY^bbZY^ViZgZedgi^c\^hhdbZ" i^bZhkZgn^ciZchZ#DhiZdad\^hihbVnWZ[dgXZYidXdcYjXii]Z^gZmVb^cVi^dch^chjW" dei^bVa XdcY^i^dch¸Vi bdg\jZh! ^c Xg^b^cVa aVWdgVidg^Zh! VcY ZkZc ^c gZ[g^\ZgViZY igjX`hdglVgZ]djhZhVii]ZY^hVhiZghXZcZ#EgZhhjgZbVnXdbZ[gdbi]ZhZch^i^k^ind[ i]ZXVhZ![gdbgZaVi^kZhl^h]^c\idXdcYjXi[jcZgVgng^iZh!dg[gdbaVlZc[dgXZbZci V\ZcihgZfj^g^c\fj^X`VchlZghidejghjZi]Z^g^ckZhi^\Vi^dchdg]daYi]Z^ghjheZXih# JcYZgi]ZhZXdcY^i^dchd[^cVYZfjViZ[VX^a^i^Zh^cXajY^c\^cVYZfjViZXdbeVgVi^kZbV" iZg^VahVcY^ciZchZegZhhjgZ!dhiZdad\^hihVgZbdgZegdcZidbV`Zb^hiV`Zh#Hj[ÄXZ^i idhVni]Vii]ZgZ^hcdidaZgVcXZ[dghjX]b^hiV`Zh^cV[dgZch^XXdciZmi!l]ViZkZgi]Z XdcY^i^dch#I]Z[dgZch^XdhiZdad\^hih]djaYValVnhhiViZl]Vi^hYZ[Zch^WaZ^cVXdjgid[ aVl!`ZZeheZXjaVi^dcidVb^c^bjb!VcYldg`XadhZanl^i]di]Zghdci]Zbjai^Y^hX^" ea^cVgn^ckZhi^\Vi^dciZVb# >cVgX]Zdad\^XVadhiZdad\n!i]ZXdaaVWdgVi^c\VgX]Zdad\^hiVcYdhiZdad\^hijhjVaan ldg`djiVgZedgi^c\egdXZYjgZ^cVYkVcXZd[i]ZZmXVkVi^dchVcYYZiZgb^cZl]Vi^c" [dgbVi^dch]djaYWZbVYZVkV^aVWaZ^cgZedgihdgejWa^XVi^dch#I]ZgZXZciejWa^XVi^dc d[i]ZkdajbZHiVcYVgYh[dg9ViV8daaZXi^dc[gdb=jbVcH`ZaZiVaGZbV^ch^hVb^aZhidcZ ^ci]ZhiVcYVgY^oVi^dcd[YViVXdaaZXi^dc[dgdhiZdad\^XVagZbV^ch[gdbVgX]Zdad\^XVa XdciZmih# I]^h &..) kdajbZ! gZVa^oZY dcan jcYZg i]Z egZhhjgZ d[ [ZYZgVa aZ\^haVi^dc [dgX^c\ ^bb^cZci YZhigjXi^dc d[ dhiZdad\^XVa XdaaZXi^dch hZZ 8]VeiZg (! XdciV^ch V hZg^Zhd[X]VeiZghVcYVeeZcY^XZh^ckZcidgn[dgbh[dgVYjaiVcY^bbVijgZgZbV^ch i]Viegdk^YZV[gVbZldg`[dgi]ZdWhZgkVi^dcVcYgZXdgY^c\d[dhiZdad\^XVaViig^WjiZh# >i^hVc^ckVajVWaZgZhdjgXZ[dgi]ZdhiZdad\^hiegVXi^X^c\^cVcVgX]Zdad\^XVaXdciZmi# I]Z[daadl^c\ed^cihVgZd[[ZgZYVhV\ZcZgVa\j^YZidgZedgi^c\dc]jbVcdhiZd" ad\^XVabViZg^Va#BdhidhiZdad\^XVagZedgih!eVgi^XjaVgan^c[dgZch^XhZii^c\h!XdkZgi]Z ed^cihdjia^cZY]ZgZ#  ™ 9^db_TeSdY_^#I]ZdhiZdad\^hih]djaYcdiZl]ZcVcY]dlÄghiXdciVXilVhbVYZ gZ\VgY^c\ i]Z XVhZ# I]Z cVijgZ d[ i]Z bViZg^Vah gZXZ^kZY dg dWhZgkZY h]djaY WZ cdiZY]ZgZ#6cnhiZehiV`ZcWni]ZdhiZdad\^hiidegZhZgkZdgdi]Zgl^hZVaiZgi]Z bViZg^Vah]djaYWZdjia^cZY#  ™ 2_^Uc`bUcU^dI]^h^hh^beanVa^hi^c\d[l]ViWdcngZbV^chlZgZVcVanoZY!hdbZ" i^bZhl^i]BC>YZiZgb^cVi^dchVcYi]Z^gZmeaVcVi^dch^cXajYZY#  ™ 3_^dUhdQ^TS_^TYdY_^_VdXUbU]QY^cI]^h^heVgi^XjaVgan^bedgiVci^c[dgZch^X VcYVgX]Zdad\^XValdg`#CdiZh]djaYWZbVYZd[i]ZXdciZmi^cl]^X]i]ZWdcZh lZgZ[djcY#GZbZbWZgi]ViVaad[i]ZgZbV^chgZXZ^kZY[dgVcVanh^hXdchi^ijiZZk^" YZcXZ!d[iZcXgjX^VaVcYValVnh^ggZeaVXZVWaZ#>ceVgi^XjaVg!VcnXjaijgVadgW^dad\^" XVagZbV^chVhhdX^ViZYl^i]i]ZWdcZhh]djaYWZcdiZY#Hd[ii^hhjZVY]Zg^c\idi]Z WdcZhh]djaYWZYZhXg^WZY#7Z[dgZgZbdkVad[Vcnhd[ii^hhjZgZbV^ch!X]ZX`l^i]V [dgZch^XeVi]dad\^hiVWdjihVbea^c\d[i]^hbViZg^Va#6cnhd[ii^hhjZegZhZcih]djaY WZgVY^d\gVe]ZYZmiZch^kZanWZ[dgZgZbdkVaidX]ZX`[dgdW_ZXihl^i]^cWjaaZih! Xadi]^c\!ZiX##CZkZgY^hedhZd[VcnVhhdX^ViZYbViZg^Val^i]djiXdchjai^c\i]Zd[" ÄX^Vah^ckdakZY^ci]Z^ckZhi^\Vi^dc#  ™ @QdX_\_Wi6hhZhhbZcih]djaYWZa^b^iZYidi]Z]VgYi^hhjZ#CdiZVcnZk^YZcXZd[ WdcneVi]dad\nVcYaZVkZi]Zhd[ii^hhjZiddi]ZgZmeZgih#CdiZ]ZVaZY[gVXijgZhVcY



8]VeiZg&-AVWdgVidgnEgdXZYjgZhGZedgi^c\

di]ZgdhiZdad\^XVabVc^[ZhiVi^dchd[Y^hZVhZ#  ™ 1^_]Q\YUcGZedgiVcni]^c\jcjhjVaVWdjii]Zh`ZaZiVagZbV^ch!hjX]VhhjeZg" cjbZgVgnY^\^ihdgdi]ZgcdcbZig^XigV^ih#I]ZhZ[VXihbVn]Zae^c^cY^k^YjVi^dc# >cVhhZhh^c\gVY^d\gVe]h!cdiZVcn[ZVijgZhi]Vib^\]iWZXdbeVgZYidVciZbdgiZb ÄabhVcYi]ZgZWnZhiVWa^h]^YZci^in#  ™ DbQe]QGZedgiVcnh^\chd[dhiZdad\^XVaigVjbV!gVc\^c\[gdb]ZVaZY[gVXijgZh idZmXVkVi^dc"gZaViZY[gVXijgZh#IgnidYZiZgb^cZ]dlgZXZcii]Z[gVXijgZhVgZWn cdi^c\Zk^YZcXZd[]ZVa^c\!XdadgY^[[ZgZcXZh!dggddi"bVg`ZiX]^c\dcWgd`Zchjg" [VXZh#:megZhhVcde^c^dcdcl]Zi]Zgi]ZWdcZlVh[gZh]l]ZcWgd`ZceZg^bdgiZb [gVXijgZdgYgncdck^iVa#9^hi^c\j^h]WZilZZcegZ"VcYedhi"YZedh^i^dcVaigVjbV l]Zcedhh^WaZBVeaZh!&.-+#  ™ 1WUcUhbQSUcdQdebUQ^TgUYWXd;dgi]ZhZ!WZVhheZX^ÄXVhedhh^WaZ!WjiYdcdi \^kZZhi^bViZhl]dhZegZX^h^dc^hcdilVggVciZY#<^kZi]ZVeegdeg^ViZa^b^ihd[Xdc" ÄYZcXZ^cVaaYZiZgb^cVi^dch#IZaal]VibZi]dYhlZgZjhZYidbV`Zi]ZZhi^bViZh VcYl]ni]ZhZbZi]dYhlZgZjhZY#  ™ DY]UQ^TSQecU_VTUQdXDhiZdad\^hihVgZVabdhicZkZgVWaZidbV`Zi]ZhZZh" i^bViZhl^i]XZgiV^cin#L]ZgZVhZmeZg^ZcXZY^ckZhi^\VidghbVnheZXjaViZdci^bZ d[YZVi]Wnjh^c\dYdg!\gZVhZ!i^hhjZ!dgWdcZlZVi]Zg^c\!i]ZhZViig^WjiZhVaakVgn VXXdgY^c\ id iZbeZgVijgZ! ]jb^Y^in! VcY XdkZg# 6cY ]dl XVc i]Z dhiZdad\^hi Zm" Vb^c^c\V\jch]dii]gdj\]i]Z]ZVY`cdli]Vii]Zk^Xi^blVhed^hdcZYWZ[dgZ WZ^c\h]di4;dgi]ZhZgZVhdch!i]ZdhiZdad\^hibjhildg`XadhZanl^i]Vegd[Zhh^dcVa [dgZch^XeVi]dad\^hiVcYhig^XianVkd^YheZXjaVi^dchVWdjiYZVi]WVhZYdcWdcnZk^" YZcXZ^c^hdaVi^dc#7nhijYn^c\]ZVaZYaZh^dchi]ZdhiZdad\^hiXVchdbZi^bZhhVn l]Zi]ZgVeZghdchjgk^kZYVh`ZaZiVaigVjbV!Wjijc]ZVaZYaZh^dchd[iZcYdcdi! Wni]ZbhZakZh!^cY^XViZi]ZXVjhZd[YZVi]#I]ZdhiZdad\^hi¼haZ\VaXdcig^Wji^dc^h jhjVaana^b^iZYid^YZci^ÄXVi^dc!hdbZi^bZh^cXajY^c\^cY^k^YjVi^dc#I]Zh`ZaZidc ^ihZa[\^kZha^iiaZZk^YZcXZgZaZkVciidfjZhi^dchVWdjii]Zi^bZVcYXVjhZd[YZVi]#  ™ 9^TYfYTeQdY_^^hhdbZi^bZhgZ[ZggZYidVh¹eZghdcVa^YZci^ÄXVi^dcºGd\Zgh!&.-+# I]^h^hi]ZYZiZgb^cVi^dcd[i]ZeZghdcVa^YZci^ind[i]ZgZbV^ch#I]ZWZhi]deZ [dg^cY^k^YjVi^dc!l^i]djihd[ii^hhjZ^cY^XVidghhjX]VhÄc\Zgeg^cih!^h^cYZciVa gZXdgYh#;dgh`ZaZiVabViZg^VaaVX`^c\YZciVaZk^YZcXZ[dg^cY^k^YjVi^dc!^i^hd[iZc edhh^WaZidbViX]eVi]dad\^XVaaZh^dchdgVciZbdgiZbe]did\gVe]hdggVY^d\gVe]h l^i]edhibdgiZb^bV\Zhd[i]ZWdcZ#Edh^i^kZ^YZci^ÄXVi^dchbVnWZWVhZYdcdaY [gVXijgZhdgY^hXgZiZigVWZXjaVgdgh^cjheViiZgchLZWhiZgZiVa#!&.-+#HZZ8VaYlZaa &.-+[dgVY^hXjhh^dcd[iZX]c^fjZhjhZY^c[VX^VagZegdYjXi^dc[gdbVYgnh`jaa# >cY^k^YjVi^dc^hd[iZc^bedgiVci^caZ\VaVcY^chjgVcXZbViiZgh#  ™ =UdbYScQ^T^_^]UdbYScGZedgihiVcYVgYYZciVa!XgVc^Va!VcYedhiXgVc^VabZV" hjgZbZcih!VhlZaaVhdWhZgkVi^dchdccdcbZig^XigV^ih#  ™ Ce]]Qbi H^bean hjbbVg^oZ i]Z bdhi h^\c^ÄXVci XdcXajh^dch gZVX]ZY [dg i]Z hZXi^dch\^kZc]ZgZ# DhiZdad\^XVaÄcY^c\hd[\ZcZgVa^ciZgZhiVgZjhjVaangZedgiZY^cVhX^Zci^ÄXejWa^" XVi^dci]VibV`ZhYViVVkV^aVWaZidi]ZhX^Zci^ÄXXdbbjc^inVhVeZgbVcZcigZXdgY#>c YZhXg^W^c\i]ZgZhjaihd[dhiZdad\^XVaVcVanh^h!Xdbbjc^XVi^dcbjhiWZjcVbW^\jdjh# I]ZdhiZdad\^hih]djaYheZX^[nZmVXianl]VibViZg^VahlZgZVcVanoZY!l]ViegdXZYjgZh lZgZjhZY^ci]ZVcVanh^h!VcYl]VigZhjaihlZgZVX]^ZkZY#BdhihX^Zci^ÄXejWa^XVi^dch

&-#&)8jgVi^dc

(*,

]VkZWVh^XhZXi^dchd[¹>cigdYjXi^dc!º¹BViZg^VahVcYBZi]dYh!º¹GZhjaih!º¹8dcXaj" h^dch!ºVcY¹7^Wa^d\gVe]n#ºHX^Zci^ÄXeVeZghdc]jbVcdhiZdad\nVgZ[djcY[gZfjZcian ^cWdd`dgbdcd\gVe][dgbVhlZaaVh^c_djgcVahhjX]Vhi]Z6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^" XVa6ci]gdedad\nVcY?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh#

#URATION 9jg^c\i]Z^c^i^VaegdXZhh^c\d[h`ZaZiVabViZg^Va!^i^hVYk^hVWaZidaVWZaVaaWdcZh^c" Y^k^YjVaanl^i]VegZÄmYZh^\cVi^c\i]Zh^iZVcYVcjbWZggZegZhZci^c\i]Zh`ZaZiVa ^cY^k^YjVa#;dgZmVbeaZ!7D9"KE"&$&^hVheZX^bZccjbWZg[dgi]ZÄghikZgiZWgViZ eVaZdcidad\^XVaheZX^bZc[gdbi]ZÄghiadXVa^inXdaaZXiZY^ci]Z7dYdVgZVd[:i]^de^V ^c&.-&#>i^hXgjX^Vai]Vii]^haVWZa^c\WZaZ\^WaZ!l^i]cjbZgVahi]ViVcndcZXVcgZVY# 7ZkZgnXVgZ[jacdiidXdc[jhZ.hl^i]'hdg&hl^i],h#HeZX^bZccjbWZghh]djaY WZlg^iiZc^ceZgbVcZci!lViZgegdd[^c`VcYegdiZXiZYjcYZgcV^aeda^h]#;dghd[iZg WdcZh!^ibVnWZcZXZhhVgnidaZiVYgded[egZhZgkVi^kZYgnVcY]VgYZcdci]ZWdcZ hjg[VXZ WZ[dgZ ejii^c\ i]Z aVWZa dc i]Z WdcZ# I]^h igZVibZci egZkZcih i]Z ^c` [gdb Y^[[jh^c\^cidVc^aaZ\^WaZWadW#HeZX^bZccjbWZghVgZZhhZci^Va0i]ZngZegZhZcii]Z Xg^i^XVaa^c`hWZilZZcWdcZhVcY^c[dgbVi^dcdci]Z^gdg^\^cVaXdciZmi#B^m^c\d[aV" WZaZYbViZg^Va^hkZgnWVYegVXi^XZ^ci]ZaVWdgVidgn!Wjib^m^c\d[jcaVWZaZYbViZg^Va ^hd[iZc^ggZkZgh^WaZ!VcYi]ZgZ[dgZjc[dg\^kVWaZ#AVWZahh]djaYWZejidcWdcZhZVgan ^ci]ZXjgVidg^VaegdXZhh# I]ZgZVgZildbV^cdW_ZXi^kZhd[XjgVi^dc#I]ZÄghi!Vh^cdi]ZghiZehdjia^cZYZVg" a^Zg!^hidegZkZciadhhd[^c[dgbVi^dc#>c[dgbVi^dcadhhXVcXdbZ^ci]Z[dgbd[VXijVa e]nh^XVaYZhigjXi^dcd[i]ZWdcZhVcYiZZi]!^ci]Zb^m^c\d[jcaVWZaZYZaZbZcih^ci]Z XdaaZXi^dc!dg^ci]ZadhhdgYZhigjXi^dcd[i]ZgZXdgYh^cXajY^c\XdbejiZggZXdgYh[dg i]Zh`ZaZiVabViZg^Va#6abdhiVaah^beaZWgZV`V\Zd[WdcZhXVcWZgZeV^gZYl^i]\ajZ# I]ZdW_ZXi^kZd[XjgVi^dc!]dlZkZg!^hidegZkZciWgZV`V\Z^ci]ZÄghieaVXZWn]Vc" Ya^c\ VcY hidg^c\ Wdcn bViZg^Va egdeZgan# JcigV^cZY dg jcfjVa^ÄZY eZghdch h]djaY cdi]VcYaZdhiZdad\^XVabViZg^Val^i]djihjeZgk^h^dc#BZig^Xdge]did\gVe]^XVcVanh^h d[bViZg^Vah]djaYcdiWZVaadlZYidYVbV\Zi]ZheZX^bZch#7dcZhVgZ[V^ganidaZgVcid[ VgVc\Zd[hidgV\ZXdcY^i^dch!Wjii]Z^gXdciV^cZghWdmZh!igVnh!WV\h!eVYY^c\h]djaY WZXdbedhZYd[VcdcYZiZg^dgVi^c\!VX^Y"[gZZbViZg^Va#7dcZhh]djaYWZhidgZY^cVgZVh ^cl]^X]]jb^Y^in!^cX^YZcia^\]i!VcYZmigZbZiZbeZgVijgZhVgZ`ZeiidVb^c^bjb# HiZehh]djaYWZiV`ZcidhZZi]Vi^chZXihVcYgdYZcihVgZ`ZeiVlVn[gdbhidgZYh`ZaZiVa bViZg^VaVcYgZXdgYh#IdegZkZciVXX^YZciVaadhhd[gZXdgYh[gdbÅddY^c\!ÄgZ!dgi]Z[i! ^i^hVYk^hVWaZidbV`ZVXdend[Vaah`ZaZiVagZXdgYhl]Zi]ZgY^\^iVaanidVXdbejiZg Y^h`dgVhV]VgYXdenVcYidhidgZi]^hXden^cVhZeVgViZadXVi^dc# I]ZhZXdcYbV_dggdaZd[XjgVi^dc^hi]Zegdk^h^dcd[gZhZVgX]VXXZhhidi]ZXdaaZX" i^dc#Idegdk^YZi]^hVXXZhh!^i^hcZXZhhVgnid^bedhZVcYbV^ciV^cV]^\]YZ\gZZd[ dg\Vc^oVi^dc^ci]Zh`ZaZiVaXdaaZXi^dc#6gZhZVgX]Zgh]djaYWZVWaZidbdkZfj^X`an VcYZ[ÄX^ZcianWZilZZci]ZWdcngZbV^chVcYi]Z^ggZXdgYh#8dbejiZgYViVWVhZhVgZ ^bedgiVci!cdidcan[dgXdaaZXi^dcdg\Vc^oVi^dc!WjiVahdVhVbZVchd[Zc]VcX^c\gZ" hZVgX]VXXZhh#8V[[ZaaZiVa#'%%&egdk^YZVcdkZgk^Zld[XjgVidg^VaegdXZYjgZhVcY egdWaZbh^c]jbVcdhiZdad\n#



8]VeiZg&-AVWdgVidgnEgdXZYjgZhGZedgi^c\

#HAPTER

I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\n d[>cY^k^YjVah EdejaVi^dch L

]ZcdhiZdad\^XVagZbV^chVgZgZXdkZgZY^c[dgZch^XVcYVgX]Zdad\^XVa h^ijVi^dch!i]ZdhiZdad\^hi^hd[iZcXVaaZYdcidbV`ZbdgZi]VciVmdcdb^X^YZc" i^ÄXVi^dch#=jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^chd[iZcgZVX]i]ZdhiZdad\^hil^i]djiVcnYdXjbZc" iVi^dcVWdjii]Z^g^cY^k^YjVaV\Z!hZm!hiVijgZ!dggVX^VaV[Äc^in#I]ZWja`d[i]Za^iZgV" ijgZdc]jbVcdhiZdad\n^hXdbedhZYd[i]djhVcYhd[Wdd`hVcYVgi^XaZhYZhXg^W^c\ i]ZYZkZadebZcid[bZi]dYhidVaadlVXXjgViZVcYegZX^hZ^YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[^cY^k^YjVa igV^ih^ch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#I]^hgZhZVgX]Xdci^cjZhidYVn!ZkZcV[iZgVXZcijgnd[^c" iZch^kZhijYn#6aad[i]^hgZhZVgX]VcYejWa^XVi^dc]VkZWZZcYg^kZcWni]ZcZZY[dg WVh^XW^dad\^XVa^c[dgbVi^dcVWdjih`ZaZiVabViZg^Va[gdb[dgZch^XVcYVgX]Zdad\^XVa XdciZmih#>cVgX]Zdad\n!^cY^k^YjVaViig^WjiZhd[Vh`ZaZiVa^cY^k^YjVaWZXdbZi]Z[jc" YVbZciVaXdbedcZcihd[ldg`^ci]Z^ckZhi^\Vi^dcd[bdgijVgnegVXi^XZh!eVaZdeVi]da" d\n!VcYeVaZdYZbd\gVe]n#>c[dgZch^XdhiZdad\n!i]ZhZ^cY^k^YjVaW^dad\^XVaViig^WjiZh VgZ^bedgiVci^ccVggdl^c\i]ZÄZaYd[^ckZhi^\Vi^dcidXZgiV^chjWhZihd[eZdeaZVcY ^cZhiVWa^h]^c\i]Z^cY^k^YjVa^YZci^ind[i]ZgZbV^ch#I]^hX]VeiZg^hVc^cigdYjXi^dc idi]Zegd\gZhhi]Vi]VhWZZcbVYZ^cVhhZhh^c\i]ZV\Z!hZm!hiVijgZ!VcXZhign¹gVX^Va!º dg\Zd\gVe]^X!V[Äc^in!VcY^cY^k^YjVi^dcd[]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch# Djg[dXjhdci]Z]jbVch`ZaZiVaZaZbZcih^c8]VeiZgh,·&+lVhV^bZYVigZXd\c^" i^dc!egdk^Y^c\V\j^YZidY^V\cdhi^XVheZXihd[]jbVcWdcZh#H^oZVcYh]VeZX]VgVX" iZg^hi^XhjhjVaanVaadl[dgi]ZjcVbW^\jdjhhdgi^c\d[]jbVc[gdbcdc]jbVcWdcZ! ZkZc^ckZgn[gV\bZciVgnbViZg^Va#6ai]dj\]i]ZYZiZgb^cVi^dcd[hZm[gdbh`ZaZiVa gZbV^chVeeZVghidWZVcVcVad\djhZ^i]Zg$dgYZX^h^dc!dcanV[Zlh`ZaZiVaX]VgVXiZgh Vaadli]ZdhiZdad\^hiidbV`Zi]^hX]d^XZ#;jgi]ZgbdgZ!i]Zdi]ZgX]VgVXiZg^hi^XhY^h" XjhhZY^ci]^hX]VeiZg¸^cY^k^YjVaV\Z!hiVijgZ!VcYVcXZhign¸YdcdiaZcYi]ZbhZakZh idhjX]ZVhnVcYh^beaZY^k^h^dchVh]jbVc$cdc]jbVcdgbVaZ$[ZbVaZ#GVi]Zg!i]Zn \gVYZ Xdci^cjdjhan [gdb egZcViVa id ZaYZgan! [gdb h]dgi id iVaa! VcY [gdb dcZ \Zd" \gVe]^X\gdjeidVcdi]Zg#;dgi]^hgZVhdc!^i^hd[iZcWZhiidXdch^YZgVhhZhhbZcihd[ i]ZhZX]VgVXiZg^hi^XhVhZhi^bVi^dchgVi]Zgi]VcYZiZgb^cVi^dch# Hdgi^c\]jbVc[gdbcdc]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^chVcY^YZci^[n^c\i]ZgZbV^chWn ZaZbZci!h^YZ!V\Z!VcYhZmVgZ\ZcZgVaani]Zbdhi^bedgiVciXdcig^Wji^dchi]ZdhiZdad" \^hiXVcbV`ZidVgX]Zdad\^XVagZhZVgX]#HjX]^YZci^ÄXVi^dch![Vg[gdbWZ^c\ig^k^Va!VgZ (*.

d[iZcXg^i^XVa^cVchlZg^c\VgX]Zdad\^XVafjZhi^dch#6YY^i^dcVa^c[dgbVi^dc!]dlZkZg! XVcd[iZcWZdWiV^cZY[gdbh`ZaZiVaedejaVi^dch#I]^h^c[dgbVi^dcXVcWZXgjX^Va^c gZVX]^c\V[jaaZgjcYZghiVcY^c\d[i]ZeVhi#I]ZgZXdchigjXi^dcd[edejaVi^dcW^dad\n [gdbh`ZaZiVagZbV^ch^hVcVXi^k^ini]Vi^ckdakZhediZci^Vae^i[VaahVhlZaaVhediZci^Va WZcZÄih[dgi]ZdhiZdad\^hi# I]ZV^bhd[eVaZdZe^YZb^dad\ni]ZhijYnd[Y^hZVhZ^cVcX^ZciXdbbjc^i^ZhVcY eVaZdYZbd\gVe]n i]Z hijYn d[ k^iVa hiVi^hi^Xh ^c VcX^Zci Xdbbjc^i^Zh VgZ id bV`Z hiViZbZcihVWdjieVhiedejaVi^dchWVhZYdci]ZX]VgVXiZg^hi^Xhd[hjWhZihd[i]dhZedej" aVi^dch!^cXajY^c\i]dhZ[dgl]dbh`ZaZiVagZbV^chlZgZgZXdkZgZY#6hLVaYgdc&..) cdiZh![djgZmig^ch^X[VXidghVXidcYZVYedejaVi^dch!VaagZYjX^c\i]Zh^oZd[i]ZhjWhZi VkV^aVWaZ[dghijYn#I]ZhZ[djg[VXidghVgZZmig^ch^X^ci]ZhZchZi]Vii]ZnVgZ^cYZeZc" YZcid[i]ZW^dad\^XVa[ZVijgZhd[i]ZedejaVi^dcjcYZghijYn#;^ghi!dcanVedgi^dcd[ i]dhZi]ViY^ZVgZWjg^ZYVii]Zh^iZWZ^c\hijY^ZY#HZXdcY!dcanVedgi^dcd[i]ZWjg^ZY ZkVYZ YZhigjXi^dc# I]^gY! dcan V edgi^dc d[ i]Z jcYZhigdnZY VgZ Y^hXdkZgZY# ;djgi]! dcanVedgi^dcd[i]ZY^hXdkZgZYVgZgZXdkZgZY[dgi]ZdhiZdad\^hiidVcVanoZ#L^i]Vcn d[i]ZhZ[gVXi^dcVi^dch!i]Zh`ZaZiVahjWhZiXVcWZW^VhZYgZaVi^kZidi]ZhVbeaZd[eZdeaZ ^ci]Zdg^\^cVaedejaVi^dcl]dVXijVaanY^ZY#8VgZ[jaZkVajVi^dcd[hjX]ediZci^VaW^Vh ^hXg^i^XVaidVXXjgViZangZXdchigjXi^c\edejaVi^dcVaViig^WjiZhd[VcX^Zci]jbVch# >c i]Z egZXZY^c\ X]VeiZgh! Zbe]Vh^h lVh eaVXZY dc i]Z ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc d[ h`ZaZiVa eVgih Vi i]Z aZkZa d[ i]Z ^cY^k^YjVa# I]Z ^YZci^ÄXVi^dch d[ ^cY^k^YjVah VcY i]Z^g hZm! V\Z!hiVijgZ!eVi]dad\n!VcY^Y^dhncXgVi^Xh`ZaZiVaX]VgVXiZg^hi^XhXVcWZXg^i^XVaan^b" edgiVci ^c [dgZch^X! VgX]Zdad\^XVa! dg eVaZdcidad\^XVa XdciZmih# >c i]Z VgX]Zdad\^XVa XdciZmi! ]dlZkZg! h`ZaZiVa gZbV^ch Vaadl jh id iV`Z [jgi]Zg hiZeh ^c Vci]gdedad\^XVa VcVanh^h#HjX]VcVanh^hV^bhidZajX^YViZW^dad\^XVaeVgVbZiZghd[eVhi]jbVcedejaV" i^dch!^cXajY^c\gZaViZYcZhh!Y^Zi!Y^hZVhZ!VcYYZbd\gVe]n#I]ZhZVgZVgZVhd[]jbVc dhiZdad\n^cl]^X]gZhZVgX]Xdci^cjZhViVgVe^YeVXZ#I]ZgZVYZgXVc`ZZeXjggZci^c iZX]c^fjZh!egdidXdah!VcYÄcY^c\hi]gdj\]gZ[ZgZcXZideg^bVgngZhZVgX]ejWa^h]ZY ^c_djgcVahhjX]VhI]Z6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n!I]Z?djgcVad[;dgZch^X HX^ZcXZh!;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZ>ciZgcVi^dcVa!VcYI]Z>ciZgcVi^dcVa?djgcVad[DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n#

!CCURACYAND0RECISIONOF%STIMATION 6XXjgVXn^hi]ZYZ\gZZidl]^X]VcZhi^bViZXdc[dgbhidgZVa^in#EgZX^h^dc^hi]ZYZ\gZZ d[gZÄcZbZcil^i]l]^X]VcZhi^bViZ^hbVYZ#6\^c\VbVcY^WaZVhhjWVYjaib^\]iWZ VXXjgViZ![dgZmVbeaZ!WjildjaYhi^aaWZ^begZX^hZ#=dlVXXjgViZanVcYegZX^hZanXVc i]ZdhiZdad\^hiZhi^bViZi]ZV\Z!hZm!hiVijgZ!VcYV[Äc^ind[]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch4 I]ZgZ^hcdh^beaZVchlZgidi]ZfjZhi^dc#6cn^YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[VW^dad\^XVaeVgVbZiZg hjX]VhV\Z!hZm!hiVijgZ!dgVcXZhign^h!^cZ[[ZXi!VegdWVW^a^inhiViZbZci#I]Za^`Za^]ddY i]ViV\^kZc^YZci^ÄXVi^dc^hVXXjgViZYZeZcYhdcVcjbWZgd[Y^[[ZgZci[VXidghi]ViVgZ ldgi]\ZcZgVaXdch^YZgVi^dcWZ[dgZlZijgcidi]ZVcVani^XVabZi]dYhi]ZbhZakZh#  ™ 6XXjgVXnVcYegZX^h^dcd[^YZci^ÄXVi^dcYZeZcYdcV\ZXViZ\dg^Zh#7ZXVjhZi]Z \gdl^c\]jbVcjcYZg\dZhVegd\gZhh^kZYZkZadebZcid[i]ZWdcZhVcYiZZi]! ndjc\Zg^cY^k^YjVahXVc!^c\ZcZgVa!WZV\ZYbdgZegZX^hZani]VcdaYZg^cY^k^Yj" Vah#;dgZmVbeaZ!i]ZZcYhd[i]Za^bWWdcZh[dgbVcY[jhZVi`cdlcV\Zh#Iddi] [dgbVi^dcVcYZgjei^dcVgZlZaa"YdXjbZciZY!Vai]dj\]hdbZl]VikVg^VWaZ#6[iZg 

8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

 ™

 ™

 ™

 ™

   ™

i]ZhZ\gdli]egdXZhhZhZcYVibVijg^in!i]ZgZ^ha^iiaZXdci^cj^c\h`ZaZiVaX]Vc\Z idbdc^idg#HjWhZfjZciX]Vc\Zh^ci]ZVYjaih`ZaZidcVgZd[iZcYZ\ZcZgVi^kZVcY iVh`"dg]ZVai]"heZX^ÄX!VcYi]ZgZ[dgZcdihdlZaa"XdggZaViZYl^i]ZaVehZYi^bZ# 6ai]dj\]egZX^hZh`ZaZiVaV\^c\WZXdbZhbdgZY^[ÄXjail^i]VYjaih!ZhiVWa^h]^c\ i]ZhZmd[Vc^cY^k^YjVaWZXdbZhZVh^Zg#I]^h^hWZXVjhZhZmjVaX]VgVXiZg^hi^Xhd[ i]Zh`ZaZidcd[iZcYZkZadedcanl]ZchZmjVabVijg^in^hViiV^cZY#Bdhid[i]Z Xg^iZg^VZhiVWa^h]ZY[dgYZYjX^c\VcXZhignVgZdcanjhZ[ja^cXdbeVg^hdchWZilZZc # VYjaih#@gd\bVcVcY>h¨XVc&.-+egdk^YZVbdgZYZiV^aZYdkZgk^Zld[i]ZhZXdc" XZgch^ci]Z^giZmidc[dgZch^XdhiZdad\n# 6XXjgVXnVcYegZX^h^dcd[^YZci^ÄXVi^dcYZeZcYdcVkV^aVWaZh`ZaZiVaZaZbZcih# 9^[[ZgZciZaZbZcih]VkZY^[[ZgZciYZkZadebZciVahiV\Zh#HdbZ!hjX]Vhiddi]Zgje" i^dc!XdggZhedcYbdgZXadhZanidX]gdcdad\^XVaV\Zi]Vcdi]Zgh!hjX]VhXgVc^Va hjijgZXadhjgZ#HdbZh`ZaZiVaZaZbZcih!hjX]Vhi]ZejW^hd[i]ZdhXdmVZ!Y^heaVn hZmjVaanY^V\cdhi^XX]VgVXiZgh!l]ZgZVhdi]ZghYdcdi#HdbZZaZbZcih!hjX]Vhi]Z [Zbjg!h]dl]^\]XdggZaVi^dchl^i]hiVijgZ!l]ZgZVhdi]ZghYdcdi#HdbZWdcZh d[i]ZXgVc^jbVgZjhZ[ja^cY^hXg^b^cVi^c\WZilZZcbdYZgc]jbVc\gdjeh!VcY di]ZghVgZcdi# 6XXjgVXnVcYegZX^h^dcd[^YZci^ÄXVi^dcYZeZcYdchVbeaZXdbedh^i^dc#6XXjgV" Xnd[^YZci^ÄXVi^dcY^b^c^h]Zhl]Zci]ZdhiZdad\^hi^h[dgXZYid^YZci^[n^hdaViZY ^cY^k^YjVahWnbZVchd[V\ZVcYhZmhiVcYVgYhYZg^kZY[gdbdi]ZgedejaVi^dch# I]ZbdhiVXXjgViZVcYegZX^hZhZm^c\VcYV\^c\VgZdWiV^cZYl]Zc^i^hedhh^WaZid VggVc\ZbVcnh`ZaZiVaheZX^bZch^cVhZg^ZhidcUbYQdUVcYidXdbeVgZl^i]^cV h^c\aZW^dad\^XVaedejaVi^dc#;dgZhi^bVi^c\hZm!V\Z!dggVX^VaV[Äc^in!^i^hValVnh V\gZViVYkVciV\Zidldg`l^i]edejaVi^dchd[h`ZaZidchgVi]Zgi]Vcl^i]^hdaViZY ÄcYh#I]^h^hhdbZi^bZhi]ZXVhZ^cVgX]Zdad\^XVahZii^c\h!Wji[dgZch^XhZii^c\h gVgZanegdk^YZi]Zdeedgijc^inidldg`l^i]aVg\Zjc`cdlchVbeaZh# 6XXjgVXnVcYegZX^h^dcd[^YZci^ÄXVi^dcYZeZcYdcVcVani^XVabZi]dYh#9^[[ZgZci bZi]dYhn^ZaYYZiZgb^cVi^dchd[hZmVcYV\Zi]Vi]VkZY^[[ZgZcigZa^VW^a^in#;dg ZmVbeaZ!hZm^c\VejW^hl^i]i]ZE]Zc^XZiZX]c^fjZhZZHZXi^dc&.#)#'^h]^\]an gZa^VWaZ!l]ZgZVhjhZd[i]ZhX^Vi^XcdiX]^h[VgaZhhgZa^VWaZ# 6XXjgVXnVcYegZX^h^dcd[^YZci^ÄXVi^dcYZeZcYdci]ZVeea^XVW^a^ind[i]ZVcV" ani^XVabZi]dYhidi]Zjc`cdlc^cY^k^YjVadghVbeaZ#BdhihiVcYVgYhjhZY[dg hZm^c\VcYV\^c\h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch]VkZWZZcZhiVWa^h]ZYdci]ZWVh^hd[:jgdeZVc VcY6bZg^XVch`ZaZiVahZg^Zh#I]ZhZhiVcYVgYh]VkZcdiWZZch]dlcidVeean ZfjVaanid]jbVcedejaVi^dch^cdi]ZgeVgihd[i]ZldgaYdg[gdbegZ]^hidg^X XdciZmihhZZBZch[dgi]VcYAdkZ_dn!&.-*0JWZaV`Zg!&.-,0@^c\ZiVa#!&..-!VcY hdbZhijY^Zh]VkZhj\\ZhiZYi]Vi^ciZgedejaVi^dcVaY^[[ZgZcXZha^b^ii]Z^gji^a^in HX]b^ii!'%%)#Cdidcan^hi]ZgZkVg^Vi^dcl^i]^ch^c\aZedejaVi^dch^ci]ZgViZ d[h`ZaZiVabVijgVi^dc!Wjii]ZgZ^hVahdh^\c^ÄXVcikVg^Vi^dcWZilZZcedejaVi^dch AVbeaVcY?d]chdc!&..+#I]^h[VXidg^hh^\c^ÄXVciYjZidi]Za^b^iZYcjbWZgd[ edejaVi^dchdcl]^X]i]ZXjggZcianjhZYbZi]dYh]VkZWZZcWVhZYhZZHZXi^dc&.#'# 6XXjgVXnVcYegZX^h^dcd[^YZci^ÄXVi^dcYZeZcYdcgZhZVgX]XdciZmi#I]ZYZ\gZZ d[VXXjgVXncZZYZY^cVeVgi^XjaVgVcVanh^hYZeZcYhdci]ZfjZhi^dchWZ^c\Vh`ZY VcYi]ZegdWaZbhWZ^c\^ckZhi^\ViZY#>[i]ZegdWaZb^ckdakZhbZgZanhdgi^c\hjW" VYjaibVcY^WaZh[gdbVYjaibVcY^WaZh!VXXjgVXnh]djaYWZ&%%#=dlZkZg!^[i]Z ^ckZhi^\Vi^dccZXZhh^iViZhhZeVgVi^dcd[(*"nZVg"daY[gdb(+"nZVg"daYbVcY^WaZh! cd`cdlcbZi]dYl^aaWZVXXjgViZ# &.#&6XXjgVXnVcYEgZX^h^dcd[:hi^bVi^dc

(+&

&ROM+NOWNTO5NKNOWN I]ZkZgn^hhjZd[V\^c\VcYhZm^c\h`ZaZiVagZbV^chVcYd[YZiZgb^c^c\i]Z^ghiVijgZ VcYV[Äc^in^bea^Zhi]Vii]ZhZW^dad\^XVafjVa^i^ZhVgZjc`cdlc[dgi]ZheZX^bZchjc" YZgVcVanh^h#IdhdakZ[dghjX]jc`cdlch!i]ZdhiZdad\^hibjhiegdXZZYWnXdbeVg^c\ i]Zjc`cdlch`ZaZiVaZaZbZcihidVhiVcYVgYhZg^Zhd[h`ZaZiVa^cY^k^YjVahl]dhZV\Z VcYhZmVgZ`cdlc#L]ZgZYdhjX]hZg^ZhZm^hi4Cdi^cbVcneaVXZh¸XZgiV^cancdi ^cVgX]Zdad\^XVaXZbZiZg^ZhaVX`^c\lg^iiZcgZXdgYh#6\Z!hZm!hiVijgZ!VcYV[Äc^ind[ h`ZaZidch[gdbhjX]XdciZmihbjhii]ZgZ[dgZWZigZViZYVhjc`cdlcfjVa^i^Zh#;dga^k" ^c\^cY^k^YjVah!kVg^VWaZhVgZbdgZd[iZc`cdlc#;dgi]^hgZVhdc!gVY^d\gVe]^XhijYnd[ bdYZgc]jbVcYZkZadebZci]VhegdkZc^bedgiVci^cZhiVWa^h]^c\V\^c\hiVcYVgYh [dgjhZWndhiZdad\^hih#Jc[dgijcViZan!bVcnhjg[VXZ[ZVijgZhd[WdcZh^ci]Za^k^c\]j" bVcVgZcdik^h^WaZWngVY^d\gVe]n# >cViiZbei^c\idhdakZ[dgjc`cdlcW^dad\^XVafjVa^i^Zhd[h`ZaZiVabViZg^Va!dhiZ" dad\^hih]VkZbVYZ^ciZch^kZjhZd[ÄkZbV_dgh`ZaZiVaXdaaZXi^dch^cl]^X]i]ZgZVgZ bdgZ"dg"aZhhVYZfjViZgZXdgYhd[V\Z!hZm!hiVijgZ!VcYV[Äc^in#I]Z=VbVcc"IdYYXda" aZXi^dclVhVXXjbjaViZYWZilZZc&.&'VcY&.(-Vi8VhZLZhiZgcGZhZgkZJc^kZgh^in¼h 9ZeVgibZcid[6cVidbn#=ZgZ!(*.']jbVc^cY^k^YjVah[gdbadlhdX^d"ZXdcdb^XhiV" ijhlZgZXdaaZXiZY[gdbVgZV]dhe^iVah#6XXdgY^c\idVhijYnd[i]ZIdYYbViZg^VaVcY^ih gZXdgYh!dcanVWdji&+d[i]Z^cY^k^YjVah^ci]^hXdaaZXi^dc]VkZhj[ÄX^ZciangZa^VWaZ V\ZhViYZVi]idWZjhZY^ch`ZaZiVaV\^c\hijY^ZhAdkZ_dnZiVa!&.-*#6hZXdcYhVbeaZ i]Vi]VhhZZcl^YZjhZ^cZhi^bVi^c\V\Z[dgWdcngZbV^ch^hVhZid[h`ZaZidchd[6bZg^" XVcb^a^iVgneZghdccZa`^aaZY^ci]Z@dgZVcLVgBX@ZgcVcYHiZlVgi!&.*,#Jc[dgij" cViZan!i]^hhZiXdch^hiZYeg^bVg^and[bVaZ^cY^k^YjVahl^i]Va^b^iZYV\ZY^hig^Wji^dc# 6i]^gYhdjgXZ^hi]ZIZggnXdaaZXi^dc!hdbZ&+%%J#H#l]^iZVcYWaVX`VYjaih`ZaZidch [gdbLVh]^c\idcJc^kZgh^in¼h6cVidbn9ZeVgibZci&.'%·&.+*!cdl]djhZYVii]Z CVi^dcVaBjhZjbd[CVijgVa=^hidgn!Hb^i]hdc^Vc>chi^iji^dc!LVh]^c\idc!98#I]Z [djgi]XdaaZXi^dci]Vi]VhWZ\jcidegdYjXZYViV]Zae[ja^ci]ZVcVanh^hd[h`ZaZiVa gZbV^ch^hXdbedhZYd[h`ZaZiVaeVgih\Vi]ZgZY[gdbVjideh^ZY^cY^k^YjVah^cAdh6c" \ZaZh8djcinHjX]ZnZiVa#!&.-+#I]ZjhZd[XdgdcZg"WVhZYhVbeaZhidiZhiVcYYZkZade V\^c\bZi]dYh^h^cXgZVh^c\E[VjVcYHX^jaa^!&..)#I]ZÄ[i]XdaaZXi^dc^hi]Z8dWW XdaaZXi^dcVi=dlVgYJc^kZgh^in!XdbedhZYd[VWdji+%%h`ZaZidchd[WaVX`h[gdbi]Z LVh]^c\idc!98!VgZV# HiVcYVgYhVcYbZi]dYhYZkZadeZY[gdbi]ZhZXdaaZXi^dchVaahj[[ZghdbZa^b^iV" i^dch# :mXZei [dg hdbZ ^c[Vcih! bdhi d[ i]Z h`ZaZidch VgZ [gdb VYjaih dkZg '* nZVgh d[V\Z#GVX^VaXViZ\dg^ZhVgZ![dgi]ZbdhieVgi!¹WaVX`ºVcY¹l]^iZ!ºl]^X]VgZaZ\Va VcY hdX^Va iZgbh WVhZY dc adXVa Xjhidb gVi]Zg i]Vc W^dad\^XVa VcXZhign# 6Yb^mijgZ ^hjcVXXdjciZY[dg#I]ZhZbdhianY^hhZXi^dc"gddbhVbeaZhVgZd[iZcd[WZadl"VkZgV\Z hdX^dZXdcdb^XhiVijh#BVcni^bZhi]ZV\Zhd[YZVi]gZXdgYZY^ci]ZXdaaZXi^dcgZXdgYh VgZdcanZhi^bViZhbVYZWni]ZXdgdcZg# IdhjbbVg^oZ!i]ZVXXjgVXnVcYegZX^h^dcd[VcdhiZdad\^hi¼hViig^Wji^dchd[VcV\Z! hZm!dghiVijgZidVh`ZaZidc[dgl]^X]i]ZhZkVg^VWaZhVgZjc`cdlcValVnhYZeZcYdc hiVcYVgYhYZg^kZY[gdbVhZg^Zhd[h`ZaZidchdg^\^cVaanVXXdbeVc^ZYWn^cYZeZcYZci gZXdgYh d[ i]ZhZ W^dad\^XVa Viig^WjiZh# I]ZgZ VgZ h^\c^ÄXVci egdWaZbh ^ckdakZY l^i] Xdcigdaa^c\ W^dad\^XVa Viig^WjiZh d[ VgX]Zdad\^XVaan YZg^kZY h`ZaZiVa bViZg^Va l^i] i]ZhZVcYdi]ZgXdaaZXi^dchd[bdYZgc]jbVcWdcZh#Bdhi^bedgiVciVbdc\i]Zb^h



8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

i]VicdcZd[i]ZhZg^ZhXdciV^ceZdeaZl]da^kZYjcYZgVWdg^\^cVa!cdc"LZhiZgchjWh^h" iZcXZXdcY^i^dch#I]ZZ[[ZXihd[Y^[[ZgZcia^[ZhinaZhdc^cY^k^YjVahi]VibV`Zjeh`ZaZiVa hZg^ZhXVcWZYgVbVi^X#;dgZmVbeaZ!i]ZgViZVcYYZ\gZZd[iddi]lZVgVgZ]^\]Zg^c VWdg^\^cVaedejaVi^dch!Vh^hi]ZVbdjcid[bjhXjaVghigZhhVcYdhiZdad\^XVagZVXi^dc idi]VihigZhh#

%STIMATIONOF!GE >cY^k^YjVaV\ZYZiZgb^cVi^dc^ch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch^ckdakZhZhi^bVi^c\i]Z^cY^k^YjVa¼h V\ZVii]Zi^bZd[YZVi]gVi]Zgi]Vci]ZVbdjcid[i^bZi]Vi]VhZaVehZYh^cXZYZVi]# JWZaV`Zg&.-.!e#+(hjXX^cXianZcXVehjaViZhi]ZegdXZYjgZhVcYegdWaZbh^c]ZgZci ^cV\^c\h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch/ :hi^bVi^dcd[V\Z"Vi"YZVi]^ckdakZhdWhZgk^c\bdge]dad\^XVa[ZVijgZh^ci]Zh`Za" ZiVagZbV^ch!XdbeVg^c\i]Z^c[dgbVi^dcl^i]X]Vc\ZhgZXdgYZY[dggZXZciedejaVi^dch d[`cdlcV\Z!VcYi]ZcZhi^bVi^c\VcnhdjgXZhd[kVg^VW^a^ina^`ZanidZm^hiWZilZZci]Z egZ]^hidg^XVcYi]ZgZXZciedejaVi^dc[jgc^h]^c\i]ZYdXjbZciZYYViV#I]^hi]^gYhiZe ^hhZaYdbgZXd\c^oZYdgY^hXjhhZY^cdhiZdad\^XVahijY^Zh!Wji^igZegZhZcihVh^\c^ÉXVci ZaZbZci# =dlZkZg!bVcnd[i]ZViig^WjiZhi]ViVgZjhZYidYZiZgb^cZV\ZYdcdihZZbidWZ Zck^gdcbZciVaaneaVhi^X#I]ZYZ\gZZidl]^X]V\ZhiVcYVgYhYZg^kZY[gdbbdYZgcdh" iZdad\^XVaXdaaZXi^dchbVnWZVeea^ZYidegZ]^hidg^XedejaVi^dch^hVbViiZgd[Xdci^cj" ^c\YZWViZ=deeV!'%%%!WjiVkV^aVWaZhijY^Zh^cY^XViZi]Vi^cY^k^YjVakVg^Vi^dcd[iZc hlVbehedejaVi^dcVaY^[[ZgZcXZh# DkZgi]ZXdjghZd[Va^[Zi^bZ!ZaZbZcihd[i]Zh`ZaZidcjcYZg\dhZfjZci^VaX]gdcd" ad\^XVaX]Vc\Z#>c^c[VcXni]ZhZX]Vc\Zheg^bVg^an^ckdakZi]ZVeeZVgVcXZd[kVg^djh h`ZaZiVaZaZbZcih#9jg^c\X]^aY]ddYVcYVYdaZhXZcXZ!WdcZhVcYiZZi]Xdci^cjZidVe" eZVg!VcYZe^e]nhZh[dgbVcY[jhZ#:kZcV[iZgV\Z'%!WdcZhXdci^cjZid[jhZ!bZiVbdg" e]dhZ!VcYYZ\ZcZgViZ#I]^hegd\gZhh^dc[dgbhi]Z[djcYVi^dc[dghijY^Zhd[h`ZaZiVa V\^c\#=dlZkZg!^i^h^bedgiVciidcdiZi]ViZkZccdgbVaYZkZadebZcid[i]Z^c[Vci^h Y^hXdci^cjdjhVcYhVaiVidgnAVbeaZiVa#!&..'!VcYi]Vii]ZgZ^hhjWhiVci^VakVg^Vi^dc Vbdc\Y^[[ZgZci^cY^k^YjVah^ci]ZgViZVcYi^b^c\d[YZkZadebZciVaX]Vc\Zh#EVi]da" d\nXVcVahdeaVnVgdaZH]ZglddYZiVa#!'%%%# HZm ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc ^c h`ZaZiVa gZbV^ch ^h Y^X]didbdjh! Wji YZiZgb^cVi^dc d[ Vc ^cY^k^YjVa¼hV\Z"Vi"YZVi]^hbdgZXdbeaZmWZXVjhZ^i^ckdakZhVgW^igVg^anY^k^Y^c\i]Z Xdci^cjjbd[\gdli]#>cY^k^YjVahd[i]ZhVbZX]gdcdad\^XVaV\ZXVch]dlY^[[ZgZci YZ\gZZhd[YZkZadebZci#I]^h^higjZ[dgh`ZaZiVaVcVidbnVhlZaaVh[dgWZ]Vk^dg#I]jh! ZkZcl]ZcdhiZdad\^XVahiVcYVgYhWVhZYdc`cdlchVbeaZhVgZeZg[ZXi!i]ZgZ^hValVnh VYZ\gZZd[^begZX^h^dc^cV\^c\h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#L]Vi^hi]ZbV\c^ijYZd[i]^h^b" egZX^h^dc4 6h cdiZY ZVga^Zg! l]Zi]Zg YZVa^c\ l^i] XgVc^Va WdcZh! iZZi]! dg edhi XgVc^Va ZaZ" bZcih!VcVagZVYn"ZhiVWa^h]ZY¹hnhiZbº^hjhZY[dgdhiZdad\^XVaV\^c\0Xg^iZg^V[dgV\^c\ VgZ^YZci^ÄZYWVhZYdcVedejaVi^dcl]dhZ^cY^k^YjVah]VkZ`cdlcV\Zh#>i^hedhh^WaZ! [dgZmVbeaZ!idjhZgVY^d\gVe]hd[eZdeaZ^ca^k^c\edejaVi^dchidZhiVWa^h]i]Vi]jbVc eZgbVcZcibdaVghZgjeiViVWdji+!&'!VcY&-nZVghd[V\Z#I]^hXdcigdahZg^ZhXVci]Zc &.#(:hi^bVi^dcd[6\Z

(+(

WZjhZYidV\ZZVX]^cY^k^YjVa^cVcjc`cdlch`ZaZiVahZg^Zh!jcYZgi]ZVhhjbei^dc i]ViYZciVaZgjei^dc[daadlZYi]ZhVbZeZg^dY^X^in^cWdi]\gdjeh# DcZYgVlWVX`^chjX]VcVeegdVX]idi]Zjc`cdlch`ZaZiVahZg^Zh^hi]ViV\ZVh" h^\cbZcihVgZbVYZdcVc^cY^k^YjVaWVh^h!l^i]djigZ[ZgZcXZiddi]Zg^cY^k^YjVah^c i]Zjc`cdlchZg^Zh#HjX]Vhh^\cbZciheaVXZ^cY^k^YjVah^cidVcQWUS\Qcc![dg^chiVcXZ! d[&'·&-nZVgh#I]^hV\^c\^hcdiVhegZX^hZVhVhh^\c^c\VcVWhdajiZV\Z![dgZmVbeaZ!d[ &*nZVgh#>cdi]ZgldgYh!Y^k^Y^c\VXdci^cjjbaZVYhid^begZX^h^dc#6hAdkZ_dnVcY XdaaZV\jZh&..,cdiZ!i]ZgZVgZildbV_dghdjgXZhd[Zggdg^cVcnZhi^bViZd[V\Z"Vi" YZVi]#I]ZhZVgZi]Z^c]ZgZcikVg^Vi^dcl^i]^ci]ZW^dad\^XVaegdXZhhd[V\^c\^ihZa[VcY i]Z^ckZhi^\Vidg¼hh`^aa^cZhi^bVi^c\i]ZW^dad\^XVaV\Zd[i]Zjc`cdlcheZX^bZc# 6cVeegdVX]i]Vih]djaYValVnhWZiV`Zcl^i]VaVg\ZhVbeaZd[jc`cdlc^cY^" k^YjVah id ]Zae dkZgXdbZ i]ZhZ ^begZX^h^dch ^h cUbYQdY_^# Eg^dg id Zhi^bVi^c\ ZVX] jc`cdlc^cY^k^YjVa¼hV\Z!Vaad[i]Z^cY^k^YjVahgZegZhZciZYWni]Zh`ZaZiVaZaZbZci jcYZgVcVanh^h^ci]Zjc`cdlchZg^ZhVgZVggVc\ZY^cVhZfjZcXZd[^cXgZVh^c\V\Z#I]^h VeegdVX]]VhbVcnWZcZÄihAdkZ_dnZiVa!&.-*/hZg^Vi^dcbVnWZYdcZfj^X`an!l^i] a^iiaZ[Vi^\jZ0i]ZgZ^hcddWhZgkZgZggdgYjZidi^bZ"h]^[iZ[[ZXihZ#\#!]Vk^c\idhide^c i]Zb^YYaZd[i]ZVcVanh^hWZXVjhZi]Zldg`YVnZcYh0i]ZgZ^hXdchiVcibdc^idg^c\ d[gZhjaih!l^i]VW^a^inidXdggZXidWhZgkZgZggdgh0VcYi]ZgZ^hcdadhhd[VXXjgVXnVh VgZhjaid[edda^c\^cY^k^YjVah^cidV\ZXViZ\dg^Zh#DcXZi]ZhVbeaZjcYZgVcVanh^h^h hZg^ViZY!ViaZVhii]Z^cY^k^YjVah]VkZWZZcV\ZYgZaVi^kZidZVX]di]Zg# HZkZcV\ZXaVhhZhXdbbdcanjhZYidhZ\gZ\ViZ]jbVcdhiZdad\^XVagZbV^chVgZVh [daadlh/VUdecWZ[dgZW^gi]!Y^VQ^d%·(nZVgh!SXY\T(·&'nZVgh!QT_\UcSU^d&'· '% nZVgh! i_e^W QTe\d '%·(* nZVgh! ]YTT\U QTe\d (*·*% nZVgh! VcY _\T QTe\d *% nZVgh7j^`higVVcYJWZaV`Zg!&..)#HX]ZjZgVcY7aVX`¼hkdajbZh'%%%!'%%) gZegZhZciZmXZaaZcigZhdjgXZh[dgldg`^ckdak^c\i]ZV\^c\d[^bbVijgZ]jbVch`ZaZiVa gZbV^ch#

%STIMATING3UBADULT!GEFROM$ENTITION :gjei^dcVcYlZVgd[i]ZiZZi]]VkZWZZcjhZYZmiZch^kZan^cV\^c\i]Z]jbVch`Za" Zidc#Iddi]YZkZadebZci^hbdgZXadhZanVhhdX^ViZYl^i]X]gdcdad\^XVaV\Zi]Vc^hi]Z YZkZadebZcid[bdhidi]Zgh`ZaZiVaeVgih!VcY^ihZZbhidWZjcYZgi^\]iZg\ZcZi^XXdc" igda#7ZXVjhZd[i]ZgZ\jaVg[dgbVi^dcVcYZgjei^dci^bZh[dgiZZi]VcYWZXVjhZi]ZhZ ZaZbZcihVgZi]ZgZbV^ch[djcYbdhiXdbbdcan^c[dgZch^X!VgX]Zdad\^XVa!VcYeVaZ" dcidad\^XVaXdciZmih!YZciVaYZkZadebZci^hi]Zbdhil^YZanjhZYiZX]c^fjZ[dgV\^c\ hjWVYjaigZbV^ch#Hb^i]&..&egdk^YZhVgZk^Zld[i]ZkVg^djhiZX]c^fjZhVkV^aVWaZ# >i^h^bedgiVciidcdiZi]Vi¹gZ\jaVgºYdZhcdibZVc¹XdchiVci#º;dgZmVbeaZ!hdbZ^c" [VcihZgjeii]Z^giZZi]ZVga^Zg^ci]Z^ga^kZh!VcYY^[[ZgZci^cY^k^YjVahZgjeii]Z^giZZi] ^cY^[[ZgZcidgYZghHb^i]VcYi]VhWZZch]dlci]VihdbZ6bZg^XVc WaVX`hVcYl]^iZhY^[[Zg^cWdi]gViZVcYhZmjVaY^bdge]^hbd[iddi]b^cZgVa^oVi^dc =Vgg^hVcYBX@ZZ!&..%# Iddi][dgbVi^dcWZ\^ch^ci]ZZbWgndVbZgZ&)·&+lZZ`hV[iZgXdcXZei^dc=^aa" hdc!&..+#I]ZgZVgZ[djgY^hi^cXieZg^dYhd[ZbZg\ZcXZd[i]Z]jbVcYZci^i^dc#;^ghi! bdhiYZX^YjdjhiZZi]ZbZg\ZYjg^c\i]ZhZXdcYnZVgd[a^[Z#I]ZildeZgbVcZci^cX^" hdghVcYi]ZÄghieZgbVcZcibdaVgjhjVaanZbZg\ZWZilZZc+VcY-nZVgh#BdhieZgbV" cZciXVc^cZh!egZbdaVgh!VcYhZXdcYbdaVghZbZg\ZWZilZZc&%VcY&'nZVgh#;^cVaan! 

8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

i]Zi]^gYbdaVgZbZg\ZhVgdjcY&-nZVgh#D[XdjghZ!i]ZgZ^h^ciZg^cY^k^YjVakVg^Vi^dc ^cVaaiddi]YZkZadebZciVcYZgjei^dc# 6\ZbVnWZYZiZgb^cZY[gdbYZkZade^c\iZZi]^chZkZgValVnh#DcZbZVch^hWn XdbeVg^c\i]Zjc`cdlc^cY^k^YjVal^i]VX]VgidgViaVhh]dl^c\i]ZbZVchiV\Zd[ YZkZadebZcid[i]ZZci^gZYZci^i^dc;^\jgZh&.#&VcY&.#'#6cdi]Zg^hi]gdj\]Xdb" eVg^hdcd[i]ZhiV\Zhd[[dgbVi^dcl^i]ZVX]^cY^k^YjVaiddi]IVWaZ&.#&#A^kZgh^Y\Z &..) Y^hXjhhZh i]Z egdh VcY Xdch d[ i]ZhZ bZi]dYh VcY gZXdbbZcYh i]Z ViaVh Ve" egdVX][dgWdi]VXXjgVXnVcYZVhZd[jhZ#=^aahdc&..+egdk^YZhVcZmXZaaZcigZk^Zl d[VaabZi]dYhd[V\^c\i]Zh`ZaZidci]gdj\]jhZd[YZciVaYZkZadebZci#I]Zi]^gYbd" aVg^hi]ZbdhikVg^VWaZiddi]^c[dgbVi^dcVcYZgjei^dc#B^cXZgZiVa#&..(egdk^YZ YViVdci]Z[dgbVi^dcd[i]^hiddi]VcY^ihjhZ^cV\ZZhi^bVi^dc# JWZaV`Zg&.-.egdk^YZhV\gVe]^XhjbbVgnd[YViVdcYZciVaYZkZadebZci^c CVi^kZ6bZg^XVch!l]^X]lZgZegdYjXZ^c;^\jgZ&.#&#CdiZi]Zedhh^WaZgVc\ZhVh" hdX^ViZYl^i]ZVX]hiV\Z^ci]ZY^V\gVb#;^\jgZ&.#'h]dlhi]ZhdjgXZd[i]ZhZZggdgh# HZm"WVhZYkVg^Vi^dc^cYZkZadebZciVcYZgjei^dcd[iZZi]^hbdhiVeeVgZciVii]ZXV" c^cZedh^i^dc!VcYi]^hiddi]h]djaYWZV[[dgYZYaZhhViiZci^dcl]ZcV\^c\Zgjei^c\ YZci^i^dch#L]ZcVhhZhh^c\i]ZV\Zd[VhjWVYjai^cY^k^YjVaWVhZYdcYZci^i^dc!cdiZ VaaVheZXihd[YZkZadebZci!^cXajY^c\i]ZXdbeaZiZcZhhd[VaaXgdlchVcYgddihV_b ]QdY_^VcYi]ZeaVXZd[ZVX]iddi]gZaVi^kZidi]ZVakZdaVgbVg\^cUbe`dY_^#L]Zc jh^c\ ejWa^h]ZY hiVcYVgYh! WZ hjgZ id Y^hXg^b^cViZ WZilZZc ZbZg\ZcXZ i]gdj\] i]Z VakZdaVgbVg\^cWdcZdgi]gdj\]i]Z\jbhd[ii^hhjZ#6ahdcdiZi]ViYZciVaYZkZade" # bZci^hhZch^i^kZidhZmVcYedejaVi^dcY^[[ZgZcXZh>h¨XVc!&.--#;dgbdgZYZiV^ahdc YZciVaYZkZadebZciVcYZgjei^dc!hZZIgdYYZc&.-'VcYHb^i]&..&#

%STIMATING!DULT!GEFROM$ENTITION DcXZVeZgbVcZciiddi]Zgjeih!^iWZ\^chidlZVg#GViZVcYeViiZgchd[lZVgVgZ\dk" ZgcZYWniddi]YZkZadebZciVahZfjZcXZh!iddi]bdge]dad\n!iddi]h^oZ!^ciZgcVaXgdlc higjXijgZ!iddi]Vc\jaVi^dc!cdcY^ZiVgniddi]jhZ!i]ZW^dbZX]Vc^Xhd[X]Zl^c\!VcY Y^ZiBX@ZZVcYBdacVg!&.--0LVa`ZgZiVa#!&..&#>[i]ZgViZd[lZVgl^i]^cVedejaV" i^dc^h[V^gan]dbd\ZcZdjh!^i[daadlhi]Vii]ZZmiZcid[lZVg^hV[jcXi^dcd[V\Z#I]^h [VXiXVcWZjhZY^cVhh^\c^c\YZciVaV\ZhidVYjaiheZX^bZch#L]ZgZi]^h]VhWZZciZhiZY dcbdYZgcedejaVi^dch!XdggZaVi^dchWZilZZc`cdlcV\ZVcYiddi]lZVg]VkZWZZc h]dlcidWZ\ddYAdkZ_dnZiVa#!&.-*0G^X]VgYhVcYB^aaZg!&..&#=dlZkZg!i]ZdhiZ" dad\^hih]djaYValVnhWZdci]Zadd`dji[dgXVhZhd[VXXZaZgViZYlZVgYjZideVi]dad\n dgjhZd[i]ZiZZi]VhiddahB^acZgVcYAVghZc!&..&# I]ZÄghihiZe^cVhhZhh^c\V\ZWnYZci^i^dc^hVeea^XVi^dcd[VhZg^Vi^dcd[VaaYZci^" i^dchWVhZYdcYZkZadebZciVcYlZVg#B^aZh&.+(lVhi]ZÄghiidZhiVWa^h]VhXVaZd[ Viig^i^dcWVhZYdcYZkZadebZci#I]ZWVh^Xhd[i]ZiZX]c^fjZVgZVhji^a^oZY^ci]Z[da" adl^c\ZmVbeaZ/6ÄghibdaVgVXXjbjaViZhVWdji+nZVghd[lZVgWZ[dgZi]ZhZXdcYbd" aVgd[i]ZhVbZ^cY^k^YjVaZgjeihVhhjb^c\Zgjei^dcVi+VcY&'nZVgh!gZheZXi^kZan# L]ZcVh^b^aVgVbdjcid[lZVg+nZVgh¼ldgi]^h[djcYdcVi]^gYbdaVgd[Vcdi]Zg ^cY^k^YjVaVbdaVgVhhjbZYid]VkZZgjeiZYViV\Z&-!i]ZV\Zd[i]Vi^cY^k^YjVaXVc WZZhi^bViZYVh&-
+  ')nZVgh#B^aZhjhZh+#%!+#*!VcY,#%nZVghWZilZZchjXXZhh^kZ bdaVgZgjei^dc#I]ZiZX]c^fjZjcYZgZhi^bViZh^cY^k^YjVahdkZg*%nZVghd[V\ZB^aZh! '%%&#6kVg^Zind[iZX]c^fjZh]VkZWZZcVeea^ZYidi]ZfjVci^ÄXVi^dcd[iddi]lZVg &.#(:hi^bVi^dcd[6\Z

(+*

MONTHS INUTERO ¼MONTHS

YEARS ¼MONTHS YEARS ¼YEARS

YEARS ¼YEARS

MONTHS ¼MONTHS

"IRTH ¼MONTHS

YEARS ¼YEAR

YEARS ¼YEARS

YEARS ¼YEARS MONTHS ¼MONTHS YEARS ¼YEARS

YEARS ¼YEAR

MONTHS ¼MONTHS YEARS ¼YEARS YEARS

YEARS ¼YEARS YEAR ¼MONTHS

MONTHS ¼MONTHS

YEARS ¼YEARS

YEARS ¼YEARS

YEARS

&IGURE9ZciVaYZkZadebZci^cCVi^kZ6bZg^XVchPVYVeiZY[gdbJWZaV`Zg&.-.0cdiZ i]ViYViVdci]ZYZX^YjdjhiZZi]XdbZ[gdbcdc"CVi^kZ6bZg^XVchR#



8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch



-





-

-



DI DI 

)

)

# 0  0 

-

-





-



DI

DI



DC





                        "

RS

A YE

9

%!

2

DC

)

)



#

DM  DM

DM  DM 



0

0





")

24

(

+%9 ROOTCOMPLETE ERUPTION CROWNCOMPLETE CROWNMINERALIZATIONBEGINS

S TH ON M   ST FIR















 #

#

ERO UT IN

&IGUREKVg^Vi^dc^ci]Zi^b^c\d[YZciVaYZkZadebZciWVhZYdc<jhiV[hdcVcY@dX] &.,)!l^i]i]^gYbdaVgYViV[gdb6cYZghdcZiVa#&.,+#GVc\ZkVajZhVgZeajhdgb^cjhdcZ hiVcYVgYYZk^Vi^dc[dgi]Zi]^gYbdaVgh#EViiZgch/WaVX`!Xgdlcb^cZgVa^oVi^dcWZ\^ch0YVg` \gVn!XgdlcXdbeaZi^dc0a^\]i\gVn!Zgjei^dc0l]^iZ!gddiXdbeaZi^dc#

BdacVg!&.,&0HXdii!&.,.07gdi]lZaa!&.-.0LVa`ZgZiVa#!&..&09gZ^Zg!&..)0BVn]Vaa VcY@V\ZnVbj!&..,# AdkZ_dn &.-* ]Vh XdcXajYZY! [dg i]Z egZ]^hidg^X A^WWZc h`ZaZiVa edejaVi^dc! V aVg\Z]jbVcdhiZdad\^XVahZg^Zh[gdbi]Zb^YlZhiZgcJc^iZYHiViZh!i]ViYZciValZVg VhhZhhZYWnhZg^Vi^dcegdXZYjgZh^hVc^bedgiVciVcYgZa^VWaZ^cY^XVidgd[VYjaiV\Z"Vi" YZVi]#=Z[djcY!dci]ZedejaVi^dcVaaZkZa!i]ViYZciValZVglVhkZgngZ\jaVg^c[dgb VcYgViZ#6hAdkZ_dncdiZh!i]ZVhhZhhbZcid[Vh^c\aZ^cY^k^YjVa^cV[dgZch^XhZii^c\ WVhZYdcYZciValZVgVaadlhdcanV\gdhhVeegdm^bVi^dcd[V\Z!Wji^[VcZci^gZW^dad\^" XVaedejaVi^dc^hhZg^ViZY!iddi]lZVgXVcn^ZaYegZX^hZgZhjaih#>c[VXi!AdkZ_dnVcYXda" aZV\jZh&.-*VXdcXajYZYi]ViYZciValZVg^hi]ZWZhih^c\aZ^cY^XVidg[dgYZiZgb^c^c\ i]ZV\Zd[YZVi]^ch`ZaZiVaedejaVi^dch#I]Zn[djcYYZciValZVgVhVcV\Z^cY^XVidgid WZVXXjgViZVcYXdch^hiZcianl^i]djiW^Vh#;^\jgZ&.#(^aajhigViZhi]ZlZVghiVcYVgYh jhZYWni]ZhZldg`Zgh#BVnh'%%']VhVahd[djcYYZciValZVgidWZVgZa^VWaZ^cY^XVidg ^cVkZgnY^[[ZgZci]^hidg^XVa9jiX]h`ZaZiVaXdaaZXi^dc# =^aahdc&.-+VcYL]^iiV`Zg'%%%Y^hXjhhbZi]dYhjhZ[ja^cVhhZhh^c\^cY^k^Y" jVaV\ZWVhZYdcb^XgdhXde^XVcVanh^hd[i]ZeZgbVcZciiZZi]#6hiZZi]V\Z![dgbVi^dc &.#(:hi^bVi^dcd[6\Z

(+,

4ABLE 6kZgV\Z6\Z^cnZVghd[VH`ZaZiVa>cY^k^YjVa7VhZYdc6hhZhhbZcid[9ZciVa9ZkZadebZciVi :VX]8gdlcEdh^i^dcV  Y^& Y^' 6#B6A:H 8^ 8jhe^c^i^Vi^dc ¸ ¸ 8Xd 8jheXdVaZhXZcXZ ¸ ¸ 8dX 8gdlcdjia^cZXdbeaZiZ¸ ¸ 8g(8gdlcdcZ]Va[ ¸ ¸ 8g)8gdlci]gZZ"fjVgiZgh ¸ ¸ 8gX 8gdlcXdbeaZiZ %#&* %#' G^ Gddi^c^i^ViZY ¸ ¸ GXa GddiXaZ[iegZhZci ¸ ¸ G' GddidcZ"fjVgiZg ¸ ¸ G( GddidcZ"]Va[ ¸ ¸ G/ Gddiild"i]^gYh ¸ ¸ G) Gddii]gZZ"fjVgiZgh ¸ ¸ GX GddiXdbeaZiZ &#* &#,* 6( GddiVeZm]Va[XadhZY ¸ ¸  Y^& Y^' 7#;:B6A:H 8^ 8jhe^c^i^Vi^dc ¸ ¸ 8Xd 8jheXdVaZhXZcXZ ¸ ¸ 8dX 8gdlcdjia^cZXdbeaZiZ¸ ¸ 8g(8gdlcdcZ]Va[ ¸ ¸ 8g)8gdlci]gZZ"fjVgiZgh ¸ ¸ 8gX 8gdlcXdbeaZiZ %#&* %#' G^ Gddi^c^i^ViZY ¸ ¸ GXa GddiXaZ[iegZhZci ¸ ¸ G' GddidcZ"fjVgiZg ¸ ¸ G( GddidcZ"]Va[ ¸ ¸ G/ Gddiild"i]^gYh ¸ ¸ G) Gddii]gZZ"fjVgiZgh ¸ ¸ GX GddiXdbeaZiZ &#* &#,* 6( GddiVeZm]Va[XadhZY ¸ ¸

YX Yb&Yb' >& >' 8 E( E) B& B' B( ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ %#, ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ (#& ¸

¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ %#) ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ '#% ¸

¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ %#, ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ (#& ¸

¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ *#+ +#' +#, ,#( ,#.

¸ %#+ '#& (#' ¸ &#% '#+ (#. ¸ &#, (#( )#* ¸ '#* )#& *#% ¸ (#) )#. *#- ¸ )#) *#+ +#+ ¸ *#' +#) ,#( ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ *#- +#. ,#- -#+ +#+ -#- .#( &%#& ,#' ¸ ¸ ¸ ,#, .#. &%#' &&#' -#( &&#% &&#' &'#' -#. &'#) &'#, &(#*

%#& (#- .#* %#) )#( &%#% %#- )#. &%#+ &#( *#) &&#( &#. +#& &&#'#* +#- &'#) (#' ,#+ &(#' )#& -#, &)#& )#. .#- &)#*#* &%#+ &*#+ ¸ ¸ ¸ +#& &&#) &+#) ,#% &'#( &,#* -#* &(#. &.#&

YX Yb&Yb' >& >' 8 E( E) B& B' B( ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ %#, ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ (#% ¸

¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ %#( ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ &#- ¸

¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ %#, ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ '#- ¸

¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ )#- *#) *#. +#) ,#% ,#*

¸ %#+ '#% (#( ¸ &#% '#* (#. ¸ &#+ (#' )#* ¸ '#* )#% *#& ¸ (#* )#, *#- ¸ )#( *#) +#* ¸ *#% +#& ,#' ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ *#% +#' ,#) -#' *#+ ,#, -#, .#) +#' ¸ ¸ ¸ ,#% -#+ .#+&%#( ,#. .#) &%#* &&#( -#( &%#+ &&#+&'#-

%#' (#+ .#. %#* )#% &%#) %#. )#* &&#% &#( *#& &&#* &#- *#- &'#% '#) +#+ &'#+ (#& ,#( &(#' )#% -#) &)#& )#- .#* &*#' *#) &%#( &+#' ¸ ¸ ¸ *#- &&#% &+#. +#* &&#- &,#, ,#. &(#* &.#*

V I]ZYViVVgZ[gdbHb^i]¼h&..&Xdbe^aVi^dcd[ejWa^h]ZYhijY^Zh#

d[hZXdcYVgnYZci^cZgZYjXZhi]ZXdgdcVa]Z^\]id[i]ZejaeXVk^in#9gjh^c^ZiVa#&.., jhZYi]^hidV\ZgVY^d\gVe]hd[VYjai^cY^k^YjVahid£*nZVghdc,-d[iZZi]VhhZhhZY# Di]ZghijY^Zh]VkZh]dlci]ViVe^XVaigVchajXZcXnd[iddi]gddihXdggZaViZhl^i]VYjai V\Z!WjiVeea^XVi^dchd[i]ZiZX]c^fjZ]VkZh]dlc^iidWZaZhhjhZ[jai]Vcdi]ZgbZi]" dYh@kVVaZiVa#!&..)#>chdbZ[dgZch^XXVhZh!VXdbW^cVi^dcd[\^c\^kVagZ\gZhh^dcVcY gddiigVcheVgZcXnbVnVaadlV\^c\d[VYjaihdkZg)%VcYjcYZg-%nZVghd[V\Zl^i] VbZVcZggdgd[Zhi^bVi^dcd[£&%nZVghAVbZcY^cZiVa#!&..'#HddbZgZiVa#'%%( egdk^YZVXdbeVgVi^kZdkZgk^Zld[kVg^djhbZi]dYhVeea^ZY^c[dgZch^Xldg`#



8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

!

%

"

&

"

'

#

(

$ -AXILLARY!TTRITION !

%

"

&

"

'

#

(

$

) -ANDIBULAR!TTRITION

&IGUREBdYVaiddi]"lZVgeViiZgchd[VegZ]^hidg^XCVi^kZ6bZg^XVcedejaVi^dc[gdb A^WWZc!D]^d#LZVg^hY^k^YZY^cide]VhZh[dgg^\]ibVm^aaVgnideVcYaZ[ibVcY^WjaVgWdiidb YZci^i^dch#:medhZYYZci^cZ^hh]dlc^cWaVX`#6\Z^cnZVgh[dgi]ZkVg^djhe]VhZhVgZVh[da" adlh/6!&'·&-07&!&+ ·'%07 '!&+·'%08!&-·''09!'%·')0:!')·(%0;!(%·(*0!)*·**#HZZAdkZ_dn&.-*[dgV[jaaYZhXg^ei^dc#

%STIMATING!DULT!GEFROM#RANIAL3UTURE#LOSURE >i]VhWZZcVeegZX^ViZYh^cXZi]Z&*%%hi]VihjijgZhWZilZZckVg^djhXgVc^VaWdcZh[jhZ egd\gZhh^kZanVhi]Z^cY^k^YjVaV\Zh#>ci]ZZVgan&.%%hhjijgZXadhjgZZc_dnZYl^YZ" hegZVYjhZ^ch`ZaZiVaV\^c\!Wjii]Z[VahZegdb^hZd[dcZdgildVXXjgViZ^cY^XVidghd[ VYjaih`ZaZiVaV\ZYjg^c\i]Z&.*%hhjX]VhbZiVbdge]dh^hd[i]ZejW^Xhnbe]nh^h aZYidY^hjhZd[i]ZiZX]c^fjZ#BZ^cYaVcYAdkZ_dn&.-*!]dlZkZg!gZ^ck^\dgViZYi]Z hijYnd[XgVc^VahjijgZXadhjgZ#I]ZnX]dhZVhZg^Zhd[&"XbhZ\bZcihd[iZchjijgZhdg

&.#(:hi^bVi^dcd[6\Z

(+.



 







  







&IGURE8gVc^VahjijgZ[jh^dc h^iZh!V[iZgE#LVa`Zg!^c7j^`higV VcYJWZaV`Zg!&..)h^iZhaZ[i! YZhXg^ei^dchdeedh^iZ!hXdgZhWZadl# 6hXdgZd[[gdb%jc[jhZYid( XdbeaZiZandWa^iZgViZY^hVhh^\cZY idZVX]h^iZ#H^iZhVgZ&"XZci^bZiZg ZXidXgVc^VahZ\bZcihd[i]ZhjijgZh Vhh]dlc#:cYdXgVc^VahZ\bZcihVgZ ha^\]ianaVg\Zg#>ci]ZBZ^cYaVcY AdkZ_dn&.-*hnhiZb!hXdgZhVgZ ^cYZeZcYZcianhjbbZY[dgkVjai Cdh&·,VcYaViZgVa"VciZg^dgCdh *·&%h^iZh#Di]ZghjijgZh^iZh!hjX] Vhi]ZbVm^aaVgnhjijgZBVccZiVa#! &..&!]VkZWZZcjhZYidhZ\gZ\ViZ ^cY^k^YjVah^cidZkZcWgdVYZgV\Z XViZ\dg^Zh!Wjii]Z^gjhZ^c[dgZch^X XVhZh]VhWZZcfjZhi^dcZYZ#\#


 

 

BZ^cYaVcYAdkZ_dn&.-*¹kVjaiºhjijgVa V\ZhVYYhXdgZh[dgh^iZh&·,#

BZ^cYaVcYAdkZ_dn&.-*¹aViZgVa"VciZg^dgº hjijgVaV\ZhVYYhXdgZh[dgh^iZh+·&%#

8dbedh^iZHXdgZ BZVc6\Z

8dbedh^iZHXdgZ BZVc6\Z

 %  &·'  (·+  ,·&&  &'·&*  &+·&-  &.·'%  '&



¸ (%#* ()#, (.#) )*#' )-#- *&#* ¸

HiVcYVgY9Zk^Vi^dc

¸ .#+ ,#.#& &'#+ &%#* &'#+ ¸

 %  &  '  (·*  +  ,·-  .·&%  &&·&)  &*

HiVcYVgY9Zk^Vi^dc

¸ ('#% (+#' )&#& )(#) )*#* *&#. *+#' ¸

8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

¸ -#( +#' &%#% &%#, -#. &'#* -#* ¸

9ZhXg^ei^dc B^Yed^cid[aZ[iaVbWYd^YhjijgZ >ciZghZXi^dcd[hV\^iiVaVcYaVbWYd^YVahjijgZh 6idWZa^dc DcZ"i]^gYi]ZY^hiVcXZ[gdbWgZ\bVidaVbWYV 6iWgZ\bV B^Yed^cid[aZ[iXdgdcVahjijgZ JhjVaanl]ZgZi]ZeVg^Zidhe]Zcd^YhjijgZbZZihi]Z[gdciVa B^Yed^cid[aZ[ihe]Zcd[gdciVahjijgZ >ciZghZXi^dcWZilZZcaZ[ihe]ZcdiZbedgVahjijgZVcYa^cZ WZilZZcVgi^XjaVgijWZgXaZhd[i]ZiZbedgdbVcY^WjaVg_d^ci &% HjeZg^dghe]ZcdiZbedgVa DcaZ[ihe]ZcdiZbedgVahjijgZ'XbWZadl_jcXi^dcl^i] eVg^ZiVa && >cX^h^kZhjijgZ >cX^h^kZhjijgZhZeVgVi^c\bVm^aaVVcYegZbVm^aaV & ' 6ciZg^dgbZY^VceVaVi^cZ HXdgZZci^gZaZc\i]dceV^gZYbVm^aaVZWZilZZc^cX^h^kZ[dgV" bZcVcYeVaVi^cZWdcZ &( EdhiZg^dgbZY^VceVaVi^cZ HXdgZZci^gZaZc\i] &) IgVchkZghZeVaVi^cZ HXdgZZci^gZaZc\i] &* HV\^iiVaZcYdXg# :ci^gZhV\^iiVahjijgZZcYdXgVc^Vaan &+ AZ[iaVbWYd^YVaZcYdXg# HXdgZ^cY^XViZYedgi^dc &, AZ[iXdgdcVaZcYdXg# HXdgZ^cY^XViZYedgi^dc  &  '  (  )  *  +  ,  -  .

H^iZ B^YaVbWYd^Y AVbWYV DWZa^dc 6ciZg^dghV\^iiVa 7gZ\bV B^YXdgdcVa EiZg^dc He]Zcd[gdciVa >c[Zg^dghe]ZcdiZbedgVa

BZ^cYaVcYAdkZ_dn&.-*¹kVjaiºhjijgVaV\ZhVYYhXdgZh[dgh^iZh&·,# &IGUREXdci^cjZY

hjijgZh^iZhVcYhXdgZYi]ZhZdcVhXVaZd[%deZcid(XdbeaZiZdWa^iZgVi^dc#I]ZgZ" hjaihZgVhZYhdbZd[i]ZegZ_jY^XZV\V^chihjijgZXadhjgZVhhZhhbZciVhVbZVchd[h`Za" ZiVaV\^c\^ci]ZVYjaiVcYhi^bjaViZYbdgZgZhZVgX]^ci]^hVgZV#h¨XVc!&.-+# Di]ZgXgVc^VahjijgZhh]dlbdgZkVg^Vi^dc^cV\Zd[XadhjgZ#I]ZAZnZiVa#&..) ldg`dci]ZHe^iVaÄZaYhedejaVi^dc[gdb7g^iV^c^cY^XViZhi]Vii]ZgZbVnWZhZmjVa VcY^ciZgedejaVi^dcVaY^[[ZgZcXZh^ci]ZgViZhd[hjijgZXadhjgZ#I]^hhijYnYZkZadeZY nZiVcdi]ZgiZX]c^fjZd[hXdg^c\hjijgZXadhjgZ#I]Z7j^`higVVcYJWZaV`ZgHiVcYVgYh kdajbZ&..)gZXdbbZcYhi]VihZkZciZZcXgVc^VahjijgZhZ\bZcihZVX]WZ\^kZcV cjbZg^XVahXdgZ#I]ZhXdgZd[%!dg_`U^!^h\^kZcl]Zci]ZgZ^hcdZk^YZcXZd[Vcn ZXidXgVc^VaXadhjgZ#6hXdgZd[&^h\^kZcidhjijgZh^iZhl^i]]Y^Y]Q\S\_cebU#6hXdgZ d['^h\^kZcidh^iZhl^i]cYW^YÍSQ^dS\_cebU!VcYVhXdgZd[(^h\^kZcidVS_]`\UdU\i _R\YdUbQdUThjijgZXdbeaZiZ[jh^dc#;^\jgZ&.#)h]dlhi]ZadXVi^dcd[i]Z&"Xbhj" ijgVah^iZh#

&.#(:hi^bVi^dcd[6\Z

(,&

PERCENT FUSED

   

 -EDIAL#LAVICLE



3CAPULAR!CROMION



3CAPULAR-EDIAL"ORDER



(UMERAL0ROXIMAL%ND



 (UMERAL-EDIAL%PICONDYLE 

0ROXIMAL2ADIUS



0ROXIMAL5LNA



$ISTAL2ADIUS





 





$ISTAL5LNA

 







       AGEINYEARS





 







)LIAC#REST



)SCHIUM





&EMORAL(EAD



 

$ISTAL&EMUR



0ROXIMAL4IBIA



0ROXIMAL&IBULA



$ISTAL4IBIA



$ISTAL&IBULA

 



 





     

AGEINYEARS

&IGURE6\Zhd[[jh^dc[dgkVg^djhbVaZh`ZaZiVaZaZbZcih#9ViVdc[jh^dc[gdbBX@Zgc VcYHiZlVgi&.*,#I]ZhZhiVcYVgYh!YZg^kZY[gdbJ#H#b^a^iVgneZghdccZal]dY^ZY^ci]Z@dgZ" VcLVg!h]dlXdch^YZgVWaZkVg^Vi^dc^c[jh^dc[dgVcn\^kZcZaZbZci#;dgZmVbeaZ!^ci]ZbZY^Va XaVk^XaZ!BX@ZgcVcYHiZlVgi&.*,[djcYi]Vid[&%^cY^k^YjVahV\ZY&,nZVgh!cdcZ]VY[jhZY Ze^e]nhZh#;dgi]ZXaVk^XaZ!i]ZZe^e]nhZVaXVeWZ\^chidjc^iZidi]ZbZY^VaZcYd[i]ZXaVk^XaZVh ZVganVh&-nZVghWjiXVcWZ\^cidjc^iZViVcni^bZWZilZZc&-VcY'*nZVgh#I]ZZVga^ZhiXdb" eaZiZ[jh^dcXVbZVbdc\hdbZhdaY^Zghl]dY^ZYVi'(nZVgh!Wjii]ZhijYnh]dlZYi]Vidi]Zgh a^kZYidV\Z(&WZ[dgZ[jh^dclVhXdbeaZiZ#IdjhZi]^hiVWaZ!X]ddhZVcjbWZgZYZe^e]nh^h[gdb VWdkZdgWZadli]ZlV^hiVcYÄcY^ih\gVe]idi]Zg^\]id[i]Zh`ZaZidc#I]Z\gVe]h]dlhl]Vi eZgXZciV\Zd[VYjaibVaZ^cY^k^YjVahh]dlZY[jaa[jh^dcd[ZVX]Ze^e]nh^hViVcn\^kZcV\Z#



8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

%STIMATING3UBADULT!GEFROM,ONG "ONE,ENGTH >ci]ZVWhZcXZd[iZZi]VcYkVg^djhZe^e]nhZh!hjWVYjai^cY^k^YjVaV\ZbVnWZZhi^bVi" ZY[gdbadc\"WdcZaZc\i]#I]^hegdXZYjgZd[hjWVYjaih`ZaZiVaV\^c\^hcdiVhZmVXiVh di]ZghVcYh]djaYValVnhWZYdcZl^i]gZ[ZgZcXZidi]ZhVbZdgVXadhZangZaViZYh`Za" ZiVaXdaaZXi^dc#HZg^ViZi]Z\gdli]hZg^ZhVcYXdbeVgZi]Z^hdaViZYadc\"WdcZaZc\i]hid i]ZhZg^Zh^cdgYZgidYZg^kZV\Zh#>[hZg^ZhVgZcdiVkV^aVWaZ!YViVegZhZciZY^cJWZaV`Zg &.-.VgZjhZ[ja^cV\ZVhhZhhbZci#;dgV\ZVcYhZmYZiZgb^cVi^dcd[[ZiVaVcYcZdcViVa bViZg^Va!XdchjaiLZVkZg&.-+VcY;VoZ`VhVcY@dhV&.,-#

%STIMATING3UBADULT!GEFROM%PIPHYSEAL#LOSURE ;jh^dcd[VedhiXgVc^VaZe^e]nh^h^hdgYZgan!VcYVcZe^e]nh^h[jhZhViV`cdlcV\Z#=dl" ZkZg!i]ZhZV\ZhkVgnWn^cY^k^YjVa!hZm!VcYedejaVi^dc#6hHiZkZchdc&.')ed^cihdji! i]Z^ciZch^ind[Ze^e]nhZVaVXi^k^in^h\gZViZhiWZilZZcV\Zh&*VcY'(#;jh^dcd[i]Z Ze^e]nh^h^hegd\gZhh^kZVcY^hjhjVaanhXdgZYVhjc[jhZYcdcjc^dc!jc^iZY!dg[jaan [jhZYXdbeaZiZjc^dc#I]ZWZ\^cc^c\d[Ze^e]nhZVajc^dc[dghZkZgVaZaZbZcihdkZg" aVehi]ZXdcXajh^dcd[iddi]Zgjei^dc!bV`^c\i]ZhZV\^c\iZX]c^fjZhXdbeaZbZciVgn#







SPHENO OCCIPITALSYNCHONDROSIS









CLAVICLEMEDIALEPIPH









SACRUM3n3









SACRUM3n3









SACRUM3n3









RADIUSDISTAL







FEMURGREATERTROCHANTER











FEMURHEADLESSERTROCHANTER

TIBIAPROXIMAL

HUMERUSHEAD SCAPULAACROMIONOSCOXAEILIACCREST FEMURDISTALFIBULAPROXIMAL FIBULADISTALTIBIADISTAL RADIUSPROXIMAL HUMERUSMEDIALEPIPH < HUMERUSDISTALEPIPH< 









= =

ALLDATAFORMALES= EXCEPTASINDICATED FORFEMALES<

         





!' % ) . 9 %! 2 3

&IGUREI^b^c\d[i]Z[jh^dcd[Ze^e]nhZh[dgkVg^djh]jbVcdhiZdad\^XVaZaZbZcih#=dg^" odciVaWVgh^cY^XViZi]ZeZg^dYYjg^c\l]^X]jc^dc$[jh^dc^hdXXjgg^c\#BVaZVcY[ZbVaZYViV VgZiV`Zc[gdb7j^`higVVcYJWZaV`Zg¼hHiVcYVgYhkdajbZ&..)#

&.#(:hi^bVi^dcd[6\Z

(,(

;^\jgZh&.#*VcY&.#+^aajhigViZi]ZXdch^YZgVWaZ^ciZg^cY^k^YjVakVg^Vi^dc^ci]ZX]gd" cdad\nd[Ze^e]nhZVajc^dc[dghZkZgVa]jbVch`ZaZiVaZaZbZcihjh^c\YViViV`Zc[gdb bVaZ@dgZVcLVgYZVYBX@ZgcVcYHiZlVgi!&.*,#BjX]d[i]Zldg`dcZe^e]nhZVa jc^dc]VhWZZcYdcZdcadc\WdcZh!WjigZXZcildg`dckZgiZWgVZh]dli]Zji^a^ind[ i]ZhZZaZbZcih!eVgi^XjaVgan^cV\^c\iZZcV\ZghVcYndjc\VYjaih6aWZgiVcYBVeaZh! &..*# >i h]djaY WZ cdiZY i]Vi jc^dc WZ\^ch ZVga^Zg ^c [ZbVaZh i]Vc ^c bVaZh VcY i]Vi Y^[[ZgZci^cY^k^YjVahd[i]ZhVbZhZmXVch]dlkZgnY^[[ZgZcii^bZhd[jc^dc#I]ZaVhi Ze^e]nh^hid[jhZ^hjhjVaani]ZbZY^VaXaVk^XaZ!ViVWdji'&nZVgh#AViZ"[jh^c\WdcZh hjX]Vhi]ZXaVk^XaZ!]dlZkZg!h]dll^YZkVg^Vi^dc^cV\ZVi[jh^dc#;dgZmVbeaZ!hdbZ bZY^VaXaVk^XaZZe^e]nhZh[jhZWZ[dgZ'&nZVgh!l]ZgZVhdi]Zg^cY^k^YjVahh]dleZg" h^hiZcicdc[jh^dcViV\Z(%P[dgbdgZgZ[ZgZcXZh!XdchjaiHiZkZchdc&.')0BZch[dgi] # VcYAdkZ_dn&.-*0LZWWVcYHjX]Zn&.-*0VcY@gd\bVcVcY>h¨XVc&.-+R#
%STIMATING!DULT!GEFROMTHE0UBIC3YMPHYSEAL3URFACE DcZd[i]Zbdhil^YZanjhZY^cY^XVidghd[V\Z"Vi"YZVi]]VhWZZcbZiVbdge]dh^hd[i]Z hnbe]nhZVahjg[VXZd[i]ZejW^hd[i]ZdhXdmVZ#6\Z"gZaViZYX]Vc\Zhdci]^hhjg[VXZ Xdci^cjZV[iZg[jaaVYjaihiVijgZ]VhWZZcVX]^ZkZYVcYdi]ZgZe^e]nhZhd[i]Za^bWh ]VkZ[jhZY#EjW^Xhnbe]nhZhd[di]Zgeg^bViZhbZiVbdge]dhZbdgZfj^X`ani]Vc]j" bVcdcZhVcYjhjVaanhncdhidhZl^i]VYkVcX^c\V\Z#>c]jbVch!]dlZkZg!X]Vc\Zhd[ i]Zhnbe]nhZVahjg[VXZhVaadli]ZbidWZjhZY^c\ZcZgVi^c\dhiZdad\^XVaanYZiZgb^cZY V\Z"Vi"YZVi]Zhi^bViZh#I]Zndjc\VYjai]jbVcejW^Xhnbe]nh^h]VhVgj\\ZYhjg[VXZ igVkZghZYWn]dg^odciVag^Y\ZhVcY^ciZgkZc^c\\gddkZh#I]^hhjg[VXZadhZhgZa^Z[l^i] V\ZVcY^hWdjcYZYWnVg^bWnV\Z(*#HjWhZfjZciZgdh^dcVcY\ZcZgVaYZiZg^dgVi^dcd[ i]Zhjg[VXZVgZegd\gZhh^kZX]Vc\ZhV[iZgi]^hV\Z#;^\jgZ&.#,^aajhigViZhi]ZhZX]Vc\Zh# 6\Z"gZaViZYX]Vc\ZhVii]ZejW^Xhnbe]nh^h]VkZWZZcgZXd\c^oZY[dgbVcnnZVgh! VcYi]ZÄghi[dgbVahnhiZb[dgjh^c\i]ZhZX]Vc\ZhidYZiZgb^cZV\ZlVhYZkZadeZY WnIdYY&.'%!WVhZYdcVhZg^Zhd[(%+bVaZhd[`cdlcV\Z"Vi"YZVi]#IdYY^YZci^ÄZY [djgWVh^XeVgihidi]ZejW^Xhnbe]nh^h!Vhjg[VXZl^i]Vc^ggZ\jaVgdkVah]VeZ/Vi]Z kZcigVaWdgYZggVbeVgi!Wi]ZYdghVaWdgYZggVbeVgi!Xi]ZhjeZg^dgZmigZb^in!VcY Yi]Z^c[Zg^dgZmigZb^in#IdYYcdiZYZk^YZcXZd[W^aadl^c\!g^Y\^c\!dhh^ÄXcdYjaZh! VcYiZmijgZdcZVX]eVgid[i]Zhnbe]nhZVahjg[VXZ#Jh^c\i]ZhZdWhZgkVi^dchdc]^h hVbeaZd[`cdlcV\Zh!IdYYgZXd\c^oZYiZce]VhZhd[ejW^Xhnbe]nh^hV\Z!gVc\^c\ [gdb&-$&.nZVghid*% nZVgh!VcYcdiZYi]Vii]ZhZe]VhZhlZgZbdgZgZa^VWaZV\Z^c" Y^XVidghWZilZZc'%VcY)%nZVghi]VcV[iZg)%nZVgh#=ZeZgXZ^kZYi]gZZbV_dghiV\Zh ^chnbe]nh^hbZiVbdge]dh^h#=^he]VhZh>·>>>Xdbeg^hZYi]Z¹edhiVYdaZhXZciºhiV\Z! e]VhZh>K·K>lZgZi]ZWj^aYjehiV\Z!VcYe]VhZhK>>·MgZegZhZciZYi]ZYZ\ZcZgVi^kZ hiV\Z#;^\jgZ&.#,^aajhigViZhIdYY¼hdg^\^cVahiVcYVgYh0hjWhZfjZcildg`dcV\Z"WVhZY X]Vc\Zh^ci]^hVcVidb^XVagZ\^dc^hWVhZYdci]^h[djcYVi^dc# ;ZliZhihd[i]^hbZi]dYlZgZbVYZ!Vai]dj\]i]ZbZi]dY\V^cZYl^YZVXXZeiVcXZ# 7gdd`h&.**[djcYViZcYZcXnd[i]ZIdYYhnhiZbiddkZgV\Z!ZheZX^Vaan^ci]Zi]^gY VcY[djgi]YZXVYZh#>c&.*,!BX@ZgcVcYHiZlVgijhZYh`ZaZiVagZbV^chd[().bVaZ 

8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

@dgZVcLVgYZVY^cVcZ[[dgiidgZÄcZi]ZIdYYbZi]dY#I]Z^gVeegdVX]lVhidY^k^YZ i]Zhnbe]nhZVahjg[VXZadc\^ijY^cVaan^cidild]VakZh!dg¹XdbedcZcihº¸i]Z¹YdghVa YZb^"[VXZºVcYi]Z¹kZcigVaYZb^"[VXZ#ºI]Zi]^gYXdbedcZcid[i]Zhnbe]nh^hlVh i]Z¹hnbe]nhZVag^b#º;^kZYZkZadebZciVahiV\ZhlZgZgZXd\c^oZY[dgZVX]d[i]Zi]gZZ XdbedcZcih#>cjh^c\i]^hhnhiZb!i]ZdhiZdad\^hiXVaXjaViZhVYZkZadebZciVahiV\Z[dg ZVX]XdbedcZci!VYYhi]ZhZid\Zi]Zg!VcYYZg^kZhVcV\Zd[YZVi][dgi]ZheZX^bZc#I]^h hnhiZb!a^`Zi]Vid[IdYY!lVhYZg^kZY[gdbVcVaa"bVaZhVbeaZd[a^b^iZYV\ZgVc\Z# <^aWZgiVcYBX@Zgc&.,(jhZYVhVbeaZd[&%([ZbVaZhd[`cdlcV\Zid\ZcZgViZ VXdbedcZcihnhiZb[dgV\^c\[ZbVaZheZX^bZchWni]ZejW^h#7ZXVjhZ[ZbVaZejW^X hnbe]nhZhVgZhjW_ZXiidigVjbVYjg^c\X]^aYWZVg^c\!i]ZgZ^hVediZci^Va[dgegZbV" ijgZX]Vc\Zh^ci]ZWdcZhjg[VXZ!l]^X]XdjaYaZVYiddkZgV\^c\#>c&.,.!HjX]ZniZhiZY i]Z<^aWZgiVcYBX@ZgcbZi]dY[dgV\^c\i]Z[ZbVaZejW^Xhnbe]nh^hWnVh`^c\'( egd[Zhh^dcVadhiZdad\^hihidV\ZejW^X[VXZhd[jcgZkZVaZYV\Z#GZhjaihh]dlZYi]Zhnh" iZbidWZ]^\]anjcgZa^VWaZVcYegdcZid^cVXXjgViZZhi^bViZh# BZ^cYaVcYXdaaZV\jZh&.-*ViZhiZYi]ZVXXjgVXnd[Vaai]ZhZbZi]dYh^cVhijYn d[i]Z=VbVcc"IdYYXdaaZXi^dc#I]Zn[djcYi]Vii]Zdg^\^cVaIdYYbZi]dYlVhbdgZ gZa^VWaZi]Vci]ZbdgZgZXZciXdbedcZciiZX]c^fjZhVcYi]ViVaahnhiZbhiZcYZYid jcYZgV\Z#I]ZngZXd\c^oZÄkZbV_dgW^dad\^XVae]VhZh[dgi]ZejW^Xhnbe]nh^hVcY egdk^YZXVgZ[ja^aajhigVi^kZYdXjbZciVi^dcd[i]Z^ggZhjaih#I]ZnVahdegdk^YZVbjX]" cZZYZYW^dad\^XVaeZgheZXi^kZdci]ZbZiVbdge]dh^hd[i]ZejW^Xhnbe]nh^hVcYVh" hZhhi]^heVgid[i]ZVcVidbn[gdbVXdbeVgVi^kZZkdaji^dcVgnWVX`\gdjcYhZZVahd AdkZ_dnZiVa#!&..*!&..,# HjX]ZnZiVa#&.-+VcY@VioVcYHjX]Zn&.-+!ldg`^c\dci]ZaVg\ZAdh6c\Z" aZh8djcin8dgdcZgbjai^gVX^VahVbeaZ!ZmVb^cZY,(.bVaZ^cY^k^YjVahWZilZZci]Z V\Zhd[&)VcY.'#I]ZhZ^ckZhi^\VidghXdciZcYi]ViV\Z"Vi"YZVi]YViV[dgi]Z^gh`ZaZiVa ^cY^k^YjVahVgZbdgZVXXjgViZVcYegZX^hZi]Vci]dhZjhZYidWj^aYi]ZIdYY!BX@Zgc" HiZlVgi! VcY BZ^cYa Zi Va# hiVcYVgYh# I]Z IdYY VcY BX@Zgc"HiZlVgi bZi]dYh lZgZ iZhiZY dc i]Z Adh 6c\ZaZh hVbeaZ VcY ^ciZgdWhZgkZg Zggdg lVh VhhZhhZY# 6h V gZhjai! bdY^ÄXVi^dchd[i]ZZVga^ZgiZX]c^fjZhd[ejW^Xhnbe]nh^hV\ZZhi^bVi^dclZgZhj\" \ZhiZY#@VioVcYHjX]Zn&.-+hj\\Zhii]ViIdYY¼hbZi]dYdad\n^hZmXZaaZci!Wjii]Vi i]ZXdaaZXi^dc]ZjhZYlVh^cVYZfjViZ#I]ZngZXdbbZcYi]ZjhZd[VbdY^ÄZYIdYY VeegdVX] l^i] h^m e]VhZh YZÄcZY dc i]Z Zci^gZ hnbe]nhZVa [VXZ# I]Z^g YViV XaZVgan h]dlVaVg\ZVbdjcid[kVg^Vi^dc^cV\Zh[dgVcndcZe]VhZ!eVgi^XjaVgan[dgdaYZg^cY^" k^YjVah#;dgZmVbeaZ!i]Z^gE]VhZKh]dlhVbZVcV\Zd[*&nZVgh!Wjidcan.*d[i]Z hVbeaZd[')&bVaZejW^Xhnbe]nhZhi]VibViX]ZYi]^he]VhZlVhl^i]^ci]Zl^YZV\Z a^b^ihd['-id,-nZVgh# 6cVhhZhhbZcid[¹gVXZºY^[[ZgZcXZhVbdc\,%)d[i]ZbVaZejW^XWdcZhlVhjcYZg" iV`ZcWn@VioVcYHjX]Zn&.-.#;daadl^c\^beaZbZciVi^dcd[i]Zh^m"e]VhZHjX]Zn" 7gdd`hhnhiZb[dgbVaZ^cY^k^YjVah!',([ZbVaZejW^XWdcZhlZgZhijY^ZY!VcYVhnhiZb VcVad\djhidi]ZbVaZhnhiZblVhYZk^hZY#GZÄcZYYZhXg^ei^dchd[i]ZHjX]Zn"7gdd`h bZi]dYVgZ[djcY^c7gdd`hVcYHjX]Zn&..%VcY^c;^\jgZ&.#-#>cViZhid[i]^hVcY di]ZgejW^Xhnbe]nh^hV\^c\bZi]dYh!@aZe^c\ZgZiVa#&..'XdcXajYZY¹###Vaai]Z V\^c\bZi]dYhWVhZYdci]ZdhejW^hegdkZYY^hVeed^ci^c\^cgZ\VgYidWdi]VXXjgVXn VcYegZX^h^dc#ºI]ZngZXdbbZcYi]Vii]Z¹gVX^VaºgZÄcZbZcid[i]ZHjX]Zn"7gdd`h hnhiZbWZjhZY!i]ViVcn^cYZeZcYZciZk^YZcXZd[igVjbVdgYZW^a^iVi^dcWZXdch^YZgZY! VcYi]ViVaaZhi^bViZYV\ZhWZgZedgiZYl^i]^cVhiVcYVgYYZk^Vi^dc^ciZgkVad[eajhdg b^cjhildnZVgh# &.#(:hi^bVi^dcd[6\Z

(,*

>&-·&.nZVgh

>>'%·'&nZVgh

>>>''·')nZVgh

>K'*·'+nZVgh

&IGUREIdYY¼h&.'%iZcV\Ze]VhZhd[ejW^Xhnbe]nh^hbdY^ÄXVi^dc^cVYjail]^iZ bVaZh#IdYY¼hhiVcYVgYheZX^bZchVgZh]dlc]ZgZ!cVijgVah^oZ#I]ZVciZgdhjeZg^dgZcYhd[i]Z ejW^Xhnbe]nhZhVgZidlVgYi]Zided[i]ZeV\Z!VcYi]ZkZcigVabVg\^chd[ZVX]hnbe]nh^h eV^gVgZdeedhZY#>ci]Zdg^\^cVaIdYYhijYn!e]VhZhlZgZYZÄcZYVXXdgY^c\idided\gVe]n dci]Zhnbe]nhZVahjg[VXZVcYi]ZcVijgZd[i]ZbVg\^chd[i]^hhjg[VXZ#CdiZi]Zl^YZgV\Z gVc\Zh[dgi]Z]^\]ZghiV\Zh#;dgbdgZYZiV^ahdcVeea^XVi^dcd[i]ZIdYYiZX]c^fjZ!Xdchjaii]Z dg^\^cVa&.'%ejWa^XVi^dc#BVcncZlZghiVcYVgYh]VkZWZZcejWa^h]ZYh^cXZi]^hÄghiViiZbei idjhZX]Vc\Zh^ci]Zided\gVe]nd[i]ZejW^Xhnbe]nh^hidV\Zi]Zh`ZaZidc!VaagZan^c\dci]Z WdcnX]Vc\Zhi]ViXdggZaViZl^i]V\Z#



8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

K',·(%nZVgh

K>(%·(*nZVgh

K>>(*·(.nZVgh

K>>>(.·))nZVgh

>M))·*%nZVgh

M*% nZVgh &.#(:hi^bVi^dcd[6\Z

(,,

&%-!,%









-!,%

0(!3%



8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch



&IGUREI]ZHjX]Zn"7gdd`hejW^Xhnbe]nh^hhXdg^c\hnhiZb#I]Ze]VhZYZhXg^ei^dch \^kZc]ZgZbVnWZVeea^ZYidZ^i]ZgbVaZdg[ZbVaZhnbe]nh^h[VXZh!WjibViX]Zhd[[ZbVaZh h]djaYdcanWZbVYZ^cgZ[ZgZcXZidi]Z[ZbVaZe]VhZineZh^ci]ZjeeZgildgdlh#E]VhZ YZhXg^ei^dchVgZ[gdb7gdd`hVcYHjX]Zn&..%!^iVa^Xhi]ZgZ^c!VcYhiVi^hi^Xh[dgi]ZHjX]Zn" 7gdd`he]VhZh^c[ZbVaZhVcYbVaZh[daadli]ZYZhXg^ei^dch0YgVl^c\hWnE#LVa`Zg^c7j^`higV VcYJWZaV`Zg¼hHiVcYVgYhkdajbZ&..)#>i^hgZXdbbZcYZYi]Vii]ZhZ^aajhigVi^dchWZhjeeaZ" bZciZYWnXVhihWZ[dgZVXijVaV\^c\^hViiZbeiZY# @XQcU!*Hnbe]nhZVa[VXZ]VhVW^aadl^c\hjg[VXZg^Y\ZhVcY[jggdlh!l]^X]jhjVaanZmiZcYh id^cXajYZi]ZejW^XijWZgXaZ#I]Z]dg^odciVag^Y\ZhVgZlZaa"bVg`ZY!VcYkZcigVaWZkZa^c\ bVnWZXdbbZcX^c\#6ai]dj\]dhh^ÄXcdYjaZhbVndXXjgdci]ZjeeZgZmigZb^in!V`Znidi]Z gZXd\c^i^dcd[i]^he]VhZ^hi]ZaVX`d[YZa^b^iVi^dcd[Z^i]ZgZmigZb^injeeZgdgadlZg# @XQcU"*I]Zhnbe]nhZVa[VXZbVnhi^aah]dlg^Y\ZYZkZadebZci#I]Z[VXZ]VhXdbbZcX^c\ YZa^b^iVi^dcd[adlZgVcY$dgjeeZgZmigZb^i^ZhdXXjgg^c\l^i]dgl^i]djidhh^ÉXcdYjaZh#I]ZkZcigVa gVbeVgibVnWZ^cWZ\^cc^c\e]VhZhVhVcZmiZch^dcd[i]ZWdcnVXi^k^inViZ^i]ZgdgWdi] ZmigZb^i^Zh# @XQcU#*Hnbe]nhZVa[VXZh]dlhadlZgZmigZb^inVcYkZcigVagVbeVgi^cegdXZhhd[XdbeaZi^dc# I]ZgZXVcWZVXdci^cjVi^dcd[[jh^c\dhh^ÄXcdYjaZh[dgb^c\i]ZjeeZgZmigZb^inVcYVadc\ i]ZkZcigVaWdgYZg#Hnbe]nhZVa[VXZ^hhbddi]dgXVcXdci^cjZidh]dlY^hi^cXig^Y\Zh#9dghVa eaViZVj^hXdbeaZiZ#6WhZcXZd[a^ee^c\d[hnbe]nhZVaYdghVabVg\^c0cdWdcna^\VbZcidjh dji\gdli]h# @XQcU$*Hnbe]nhZVa[VXZ^h\ZcZgVaanÄcZ\gV^cZYVai]dj\]gZbcVcihd[i]ZdaYg^Y\ZVcY [jggdlhnhiZbbVnhi^aagZbV^c#JhjVaani]ZdkVadjia^cZ^hXdbeaZiZVii]^hhiV\Z!WjiV]^VijhXVcdX" Xjg^cjeeZgkZcigVag^b#EjW^XijWZgXaZ^h[jaanhZeVgViZY[gdbi]Zhnbe]nhZVa[VXZWnYZÄc^i^dc d[jeeZgZmigZb^in#I]Zhnbe]nhZVa[VXZbVn]VkZVY^hi^cXig^b#KZcigVaan!Wdcna^\VbZcidjh dji\gdli]hbVndXXjgdc^c[Zg^dgedgi^dcd[ejW^XWdcZVY_VXZciidhnbe]nhZVa[VXZ#>[Vcn a^ee^c\dXXjgh!^il^aaWZha^\]iVcYadXViZYdci]ZYdghVaWdgYZg# @XQcU%*Hnbe]nhZVa[VXZ^hXdbeaZiZang^bbZYl^i]hdbZha^\]iYZegZhh^dcd[i]Z[VXZ^ihZa[!gZaVi^kZid i]Zg^b#BdYZgViZa^ee^c\^hjhjVaan[djcYdci]ZYdghVaWdgYZgl^i]bdgZegdb^cZcia^\VbZc" idjhdji\gdli]hdci]ZkZcigVaWdgYZg#I]ZgZ^ha^iiaZdgcdg^bZgdh^dc#7gZV`YdlcbVndXXjg dchjeZg^dgkZcigVaWdgYZg# @XQcU&*Hnbe]nhZVa[VXZbVnh]dldc\d^c\YZegZhh^dcVhg^bZgdYZh#KZcigVaa^\VbZcidjhViiVX]" bZcihVgZbVg`ZY#>cbVcn^cY^k^YjVahi]ZejW^XijWZgXaZVeeZVghVhVhZeVgViZWdcn`cdW# I]Z[VXZbVnWZe^iiZYdgedgdjh!\^k^c\VcVeeZVgVcXZd[Y^hÄ\jgZbZcil^i]i]Zdc\d^c\ egdXZhhd[ZggVi^Xdhh^ÄXVi^dc#8gZcjaVi^dchbVndXXjg#I]Zh]VeZd[i]Z[VXZ^hd[iZc^ggZ\jaVg Vii]^hhiV\Z# 4UcSbY`dYfUCdQdYcdYSc*  ;ZbVaZc2',( E]VhZ BZVc HiVcYVgY9Zk# .*gVc\Z

BVaZc2,(. BZVc HiVcYVgY9Zk# .*gVc\Z

     

&-#* '(#) '-#, (*#' )*#+ +&#'

& ' ( ) * +

&.#) '*#% (%#, (-#' )-#& +%#%

'#+ )#. -#& &%#. &)#+ &'#)

&*·') &.·)% '&·*( '+·,% '*·-( )'·-,

'#& (#+ +#* .#) &%#) &'#'

&*·'( &.·() '&·)+ '(·*, ',·++ ()·-+

&.#(:hi^bVi^dcd[6\Z

(,.

0ARTURITION#HANGESATTHE0UBIC3YMPHYSIS 8]^aYW^gi]!dgeVgijg^i^dc!bVngZhjai^cX]Vc\Zhdci]ZejW^Xhnbe]nh^heVgi^XjaVgan e^ii^c\VY_VXZciidi]Zhnbe]nh^hdci]ZYdghVaZY\Zd[i]ZejW^h!Vjg^XjaVghjg[VXZ!VcY egZVjg^XjaVgVgZVd[i]Z[ZbVaZdhXdmVZ#Idl]ViZmiZciXVci]ZdhiZdad\^hijhZi]ZhZ X]Vc\Zh id VhhZhh l]Zi]Zg! dg ]dl d[iZc! Vc ^cY^k^YjVa ]Vh \^kZc W^gi]4 HijY^Zh YZ" h^\cZYidVchlZgi]ZhZfjZhi^dch^cXajYZ@ZaaZn&.,.VcYHjX]ZnZiVa#&.,.#I]ZhZ hijY^Zhh]dli]Vijeid'%d[cjaa^eVgdjhldbZcY^heaVni]ZhZdggZaViZY[ZVijgZh# E^ii^c\VXfj^gZYYjg^c\egZ\cVcXnVcYX]^aYW^gi]bVnWZXdbZdWa^iZgViZYl^i]V\Z# BZY^jb"id"aVg\Ze^ii^c\XVcdXXjgl^i]djieVgijg^i^dc&,d[&)-XVhZh!HjX]ZnZiVa#! &.,.!VcYeVgijg^i^dcXVcdXXjgl^i]djie^ii^c\#;djgd[dkZg,%%bVaZ^cY^k^YjVah Y^heaVnZYbZY^jb"id"aVg\Ze^ii^c\#>ch]dgi!i]ZgZ^hVXdggZaVi^dcWZilZZce^ii^c\d[ i]ZdhXdmVZVcYegZ\cVcXndgeVgijg^i^dc!Wjii]^hXdggZaVi^dc^h[Vg[gdbeZg[ZXi#I]Z cjbWZgd[egZ\cVcX^ZhXVccdiWZegZY^XiZYWni]Zbdge]dad\nd[i]ZYdghVaVheZXi d[i]ZejW^h#>cVhijYnXdbW^c^c\]jbVchVcYcdc]jbVcbVbbVah!IV\jZ&.-- XdcXajYZhi]Vii]ZhZkZg^ind[i]ZgZhdgei^dcVii]ZejW^h^hcdih^\c^ÄXVciangZaViZYid i]Vid[i]ZegZVjg^XjaVgVgZV#;jgi]ZgbdgZ!V\Z"Vi"YZVi]lVhh]dlcidWZh^\c^ÄXVcian VhhdX^ViZYl^i]gZhdgei^dcd[i]ZejW^h#8dmVcYHXdii&..'cdiZi]ViejW^XijWZgXaZ ZmiZch^dc^hVahdVhhdX^ViZYl^i]X]^aYW^gi]!l]ZgZVhegZVjg^XjaVghjaX^VcYYdghVae^i" i^c\lZgZcdi#IV\jZ&.--XVaah[dg[jgi]ZghijYnd[i]Za^c`WZilZZcZhigd\ZcVcY dhiZdXaVhi^XVXi^k^in^ci]ZhZVgZVhd[i]ZdhXdmVZ#8dm'%%%Wegdk^YZhVcdkZgk^Zl d[h`ZaZiVahijY^Zhd[eVgijg^i^dc!VcYHcdY\gVhhVcY
%STIMATING!DULT!GEFROMTHE!URICULAR3URFACEOFTHE)LIUM AdkZ_dnVcYXdaaZV\jZh&.-*WZmVb^cZYi]ZVjg^XjaVghjg[VXZd[i]ZdhXdmVZVhVedh" h^WaZh^iZd[gZ\jaVgX]Vc\ZXdggZhedcY^c\idV\Z^ci]Z=VbVcc"IdYYXdaaZXi^dc#I]Z jhZd[i]^hhjg[VXZ[dgV\^c\^cY^k^YjVaheZX^bZch]VhhdbZVYkVciV\Zh!cVbZani]Vi i]^heVgid[i]ZdhXdmVZ^hbdgZa^`ZanidWZegZhZgkZY^c[dgZch^XVcYVgX]Zdad\^XVa XVhZhVcYi]Vii]ZX]Vc\Zhdci]ZVjg^XjaVghjg[VXZ!jca^`Zi]dhZdci]ZejW^Xhnbe]n" h^h!ZmiZcYlZaaWZndcYi]ZV\Zd[*%nZVgh#AdkZ_dnVcYXdaaZV\jZhYZhXg^WZV\Z"gZaViZY X]Vc\Zh^chjg[VXZ\gVcjaVi^dc!b^Xgdedgdh^in!bVXgdedgdh^in!igVchkZghZdg\Vc^oVi^dc! W^aadl^c\!VcYhig^Vi^dchi]ViVgZhdbZl]Vih^b^aVgidi]dhZYZhXg^WZY[dgi]Zhjg[VXZ d[i]ZejW^Xhnbe]nh^h#I]ZhZ^ckZhi^\VidghcdiZi]ViVjg^XjaVghjg[VXZV\^c\^hbdgZ Y^[ÄXjaiidbVhiZgi]Vci]ZIdYYbZi]dY[dgi]ZejW^Xhnbe]nh^h!Wjii]ZnhiViZi]Vi i]ZediZci^VagZlVgYhVgZldgi]i]ZZmigVZ[[dgi!h^cXZi]ZbZi]dY^h^cYZeZcYZcid[ hnbe]nhZVaV\^c\WjiZfjVaanVXXjgViZ# I]Z X]Vc\Zh YZhXg^WZY Wn AdkZ_dn Zi Va# &.-*W [dg i]Z Vjg^XjaVg hjg[VXZ VgZ Vh [daadlh# I]Z ndjc\ Vjg^XjaVg hjg[VXZ ;^\jgZ &.#.! WZ\^cc^c\ ^c i]Z Äghi [Zl nZVgh V[iZgedhiXgVc^VaZe^e]nhZVa[jh^dc!h]dlhVÄcZ"\gV^cZYhjg[VXZiZmijgZVcYVeViiZgc d[ gZ\jaVg! jhjVaan igVchkZghZ hjg[VXZ jcYjaVi^dch XVaaZY W^aadl^c\# I]Z ided\gVe]n d[ i]Z hjg[VXZ ^h kZgn bjX] a^`Z i]Z hjWX]dcYgVa WdcZ d[ Vc jc[jhZY Ze^e]nh^h! Va" i]dj\]i]ZW^aadl^c\^hcdihdegdcdjcXZY#7Z\^cc^c\^cVYjai]ddY!i]ZhZ[ZVijgZhd[ i]ZhVXgd^a^VX_d^ciVgZbdY^ÄZYegd\gZhh^kZanVcYgZ\jaVganVhV\Z^cXgZVhZh#
8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

i]Zdg^\^cVaigVchkZghZdg\Vc^oVi^dcd[ndji]^hadhi!VcYi]Zhjg[VXZWZ\^chidY^heaVn eZg[dgVi^dch d[ ^ih hjWX]dcYgVa WdcZ! V XdcY^i^dc `cdlc Vh ¹b^Xgdedgdh^in#º >c i]Z aViZg hiV\Zh d[ a^[Z! i]Z hjg[VXZ WZXdbZh ^cXgZVh^c\an YZchZ VcY Y^hdg\Vc^oZY# AVg\Zg hjWX]dcYgVaYZ[ZXihiZgbZYbVXgdedgdh^inegd\gZhh^kZan^cXgZVhZl^i]V\ZV[iZgi]Z Ä[i] YZXVYZ# 7n i]Z h^mi] VcY hZkZci] YZXVYZh! i]Z hjg[VXZ ]Vh WZXdbZ YZchZ! Wdi] b^Xgdedgdi^XVcYbVXgdedgdi^X!VcY]VhadhiVaaZk^YZcXZd[igVchkZghZdg\Vc^oVi^dc# AdkZ_dnVcYXdaaZV\jZh]VkZ[dgbVa^oZYVhnhiZbd[Z^\]ie]VhZhl^i]l]^X]idXaVhh^[n i]^hbZiVbdge]dh^h;^\jgZ&.#.VcY7j^`higVVcYJWZaV`Zg!&..)!;^\jgZ&%#6YY^" i^dcd[i]ZhVXgd^a^VX_d^ciidi]ZdhiZdad\^hi¼hVghZcVad[V\Z^cY^XVidgh^hVc^bedgiVci dcZ#=dlZkZg!Wdi]dg^\^cVagZhZVgX]VcYhjWhZfjZciiZhihBjggVnVcYBjggVn!&..& dci]ZbZi]dYhj\\Zhii]Vii]ZbZi]dY!a^`Zi]ZejW^Xhnbe]nh^hbZi]dYh!]VhaVg\Z Zhi^bVi^dcZggdghVhhdX^ViZYl^i]^iVcYh]djaYcdiWZjhZYVadcZ^ci]ZVhhZhhbZcid[ Vcjc`cdlc¼hV\Z"Vi"YZVi]#Dc\d^c\ldg`dci]^hgZ\^dcDhWdgcZZiVa#!'%%)0Bja" ]ZgcVcY?dcZh!'%%)VhlZaaVhi]ZVXZiVWjaVgVgZVGdj\‚"BV^aaVgi!'%%)^hVXi^kZ#

%STIMATING!DULT!GEFROMTHE3TERNAL2IB%ND # >h¨XVcVcYAdi]&.-+]VkZhijY^ZYbZiVbdge]dh^hd[i]ZhiZgcVaZcYd[i]Z[djgi]g^W VcY[djcYi]Vi^iXdggZhedcYhidV\Z!WjikVg^ZhWnhZm#I]ZnZmVb^cZY¹[dgb!h]VeZ! iZmijgZVcYdkZgVaafjVa^inºd[i]ZhiZgcVaZcYVcYYZÄcZYVhZg^Zhd[e]VhZhi]ViWZ" \^chl^i]VÅVidgW^aadlnZcYl^i]gZ\jaVgVcYgdjcYZYZY\Zh#L^i]V\Z!i]^hg^b i]^ch VcY WZXdbZh ^ggZ\jaVg# I]Z hjg[VXZ edgdh^in ^cXgZVhZh! VcY i]Z WdcZ WZXdbZh ¹gV\\ZY#º6hl^i]Vaad[i]ZcZlZgiZX]c^fjZhYZhXg^WZYZVga^Zg!i]^hdcZ]VhcdiWZZc l^YZaniZhiZY#6YY^i^dcVaan!^YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[i]Z[djgi]g^W^hcdiValVnhedhh^WaZ^c ^cXdbeaZiZh`ZaZidch#=dlZkZg!9jYVg&..(gZedgihi]Vig^W[djghiVcYVgYhXVc¹XVj" i^djhanºWZVeea^ZYiddi]ZghiZgcVag^WZcYh#GjhhZaaZiVa#&..(kZg^[ni]Zji^a^ind[ i]^hiZX]c^fjZdcVhVbeaZd[&%%bVaZh#@jcdhZiVa#&...VhhZhhV\^c\i]gdj\]Äghi g^WbZiVbdge]dh^h!VcYNdYZgZiVa#'%%&ZmVb^cZdi]Zgg^Wh#

%STIMATING!DULT!GEBY2ADIOGRAPHIC!NALYSIS 8]Vc\Zh^cXVcXZaadjhVcYXdgi^XVaWdcZhigjXijgZVibVXgdhXde^XVcYb^XgdhXde^XaZk" ZahiV`ZeaVXZi]gdj\]djia^[Z#LVa`ZgVcYAdkZ_dn&.-*]VkZhijY^ZYi]^he]Zcdb" ZcdcWnVhhZhh^c\gVY^d\gVe]h[gdbi]Z=VbVcc·IdYYXdaaZXi^dcVcYi]ZegZ]^hidg^X A^WWZcXdaaZXi^dc#Jh^c\hZg^Vi^dc!i]ZhZVji]dghYZhXg^WZegd\gZhh^kZ!h^iZ"heZX^ÄXadhh d[WdcZl^i]V\Z^cWdi]i]ZXaVk^XaZVcYi]Z[Zbjg#K^hjVahZg^Vi^dcd[gVY^d\gVe]h h]dlZYVbdYZgViZan]^\]VcYh^\c^ÄXVciXdggZaVi^dcWZilZZc^cXgZVhZYV\Zd[YZVi] VcYYZXgZVhZYWdcZYZch^in#BVXX]^VgZaa^VcY7dcY^da^&..)h]dlh^\c^ÄXVcikVg^V" i^dc^cYZch^ind[i]Zegdm^bVa[Zbjg!bjX]d[^ijcgZaViZYidV\Z#?VX`Zh&..'Y^h" XjhhZhegdWaZbhl^i]Veea^XVi^dchidVgX]Zdad\^XVagZbV^ch#

%STIMATING!DULT!GEFROM"ONE-ICROSTRUCTURE I]ZcdgbVagZbdYZa^c\d[WdcZYjg^c\VYjaia^[Z]VhWZZcegdedhZYVhVXdcY^i^dc &.#(:hi^bVi^dcd[6\Z

(-&

3UPERIOR $EMIFACE !PEX !RCUATE ,INE

<

YRS

2ETROAURICULAR 0REAURICULAR !REA )NFERIOR 3ULCUS $EMIFACE

=

=

YRS

YRS

0HASE

=

YRS 0HASE

<

YRS

YRS

0HASE

=

<

<

YRS

=

YRS 0HASE

YRS

&IGUREBdYVaX]Vc\Zhidi]ZVjg^XjaVghjg[VXZl^i]V\Z#E]VhZhYZhXg^WZYWnAdkZ_dnZi Va#&.-*WVh[daadlh/ @XQcU!*6\Z'%·')0W^aadl^c\VcYkZgnÄcZ\gVcjaVg^in @XQcU"*6\Z'*·'.0gZYjXi^dcd[W^aadl^c\WjigZiZci^dcd[ndji][jaVeeZVgVcXZ @XQcU#*6\Z(%·()0\ZcZgVaadhhd[W^aadl^c\!gZeaVXZbZciWnhig^VZ!XdVghZc^c\d[\gVcjaVg^in @XQcU$*6\Z(*·(.0jc^[dgbXdVghZ\gVcjaVg^in



8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

=

=

=

YRS

=

YRS 0HASE

=

YRS 0HASE

<

=

YRS

=

=

YRS

YRS 0HASE

YRS

=

<

YRS 0HASE

YRS

YRS

YRS 0HASE

@XQcU%*6\Z)%·))0igVch^i^dc[gdbXdVghZ\gVcjaVg^inidYZchZhjg[VXZ0i]^hbVniV`ZeaVXZ dkZg^haVcYhdci]Zhjg[VXZd[dcZdgWdi][VXZh @XQcU&*6\Z)*·).0XdbeaZi^dcd[YZch^ÄXVi^dcl^i]XdbeaZiZadhhd[\gVcjaVg^in @XQcU'*6\Z*%·*.0YZchZ^ggZ\jaVghjg[VXZd[gj\\ZYided\gVe]nVcYbdYZgViZidbVg`ZY VXi^k^in^ceZg^Vjg^XjaVgVgZVh @XQcU(*6\Z+% 0WgZV`Ydlcl^i]bVg\^cVaa^ee^c\!b^Xgdedgdh^in!^cXgZVhZY^ggZ\jaVg^in! VcYbVg`ZYVXi^k^in^ceZg^Vjg^XjaVgVgZVh

&.#(:hi^bVi^dcd[6\Z

(-(

jhZ[ja[dgV\^c\h`ZaZiVabViZg^Va#B^XgdhXde^XVcVanh^h]VhVaadlZYi]ZgZaVi^dch]^eh WZilZZci]ZcjbWZgd[dhiZdchVcYdhiZdc[gV\bZcihVcYi]ZeZgXZciV\Zhd[aVbZa" aVgWdcZVcYcdc"]VkZgh^VcXVcVahidWZZmVb^cZY#H^bbdch&.-*!;gdhi&.-,!VcY GdWa^c\VcYHidji'%%%egdk^YZZmXZaaZcihjbbVg^Zhd[i]ZhZegdXZYjgZh#>ih]djaY WZcdiZYi]Vii]ZhZegdXZYjgZhVgZYZhigjXi^kZidi]ZWdcZhjcYZghijYn#BVcnhijY^Zh d[]^hidbdge]dbZign]VkZWZZcjcYZgiV`Zcdci]Zadc\WdcZhd[i]ZedhiXgVc^Vah`Za" Zidc[dgVgZk^Zl!hZZHidji!&..'#8ddaZiVa#&..*]VkZh]dlci]Vi]^hidbdge]dad\^" XVakVg^VWaZhd[i]Z]jbVcdXX^e^iValZgZaZhhgZa^VWaZi]Vci]dhZd[i]Zadc\WdcZh[dg Zhi^bVi^c\V\Z# 6aad[i]ZhZbZi]dYhVgZfjVci^iVi^kZVcYYZeZcYdcdhiZdcVagZbdYZa^c\d[WdcZ VcYVXXjbjaViZYdhiZdcedejaVi^dch#BVcn[VXidghXVc^cÅjZcXZi]^hegdXZhhVcY^ih egdYjXih!^cXajY^c\hZm!]dgbdcZh!bZX]Vc^XVahigV^c!VcYcjig^i^dc#GZbdYZa^c\^hi]Z hZfjZci^VagZbdkVaVcYgZeaVXZbZcid[daYZgaVbZaaVgWdcZl^i]cZlZgaVbZaaVgWdcZ VcY^iiV`ZheaVXZi]gdj\]djii]Za^[ZheVc#=^hidad\^XVaVcVanh^hd[i^hhjZ[gdbhZaZXiZY h^iZhdci]Zh`ZaZidc^cXajY^c\i]Zg^WhVcYXaVk^XaZ/HidjiVcYEV^cZ!&..'0HidjiZiVa#! &..)!&..+]Vhh]dlcVcVhhdX^Vi^dcWZilZZcV\Z"Vi"YZVi]VcYi]ZcjbWZgd[dWhZgk" VWaZdhiZdcheZgjc^iVgZV^cVXgdhhhZXi^dc#I]ZcjbWZgd[^ciVXiVcY[gV\bZciVgn dhiZdcheZgjc^iVgZV^hXVaXjaViZY[dgZVX]WdcZcdgbVaan[dgViaZVhiildha^XZhd[ ZVX]WdcZ!VcYi]ZgZhjai^heji^cidgZ\gZhh^dcZfjVi^dchi]ViXVaXjaViZi]ZV\Z#Hidji &..'^YZci^ÄZhVkVg^Zind[egdWaZbhl^i]i]ZiZX]c^fjZVhVeea^ZYWnY^[[ZgZci^c" kZhi^\Vidgh!VcYXVaah[dgbdgZgZhZVgX]^ci]Z[dgZch^XhZii^c\#E[Z^[[ZgZiVa#&..*VcY di]Zgh]VkZ[djcYi]Vi]^hidad\^XVaegdÄaZhkVgnWnhVbeaZadXVi^dc!hdbZi]^c\i]Vi bjhiWZXdcigdaaZY[dg^cVeea^XVi^dcd[i]ZhZiZX]c^fjZh#6h:g^X`hZc&..&cdiZh!^i ^hXg^i^XVai]VidhiZdad\^hihjh^c\WdcZb^XgdhigjXijgZidV\ZVgX]Zdad\^XVaheZX^bZch WZkZgnXVji^djhVWdjiegZ"VcVanh^hZm[da^Vi^dcd[jcgZbdYZaZYeZg^e]ZgVaaVbZaaVZdc WdcZh#?VX`Zh&..'cdiZhdi]ZgXdbea^XVi^c\[VXidgh[dgi]ZjhZd[i]ZhZiZX]c^fjZhdc VgX]Zdad\^XVagZbV^ch#6^ZaadVcYBdaaZhdc&..(XdbeVgZYejW^Xhnbe]nhZVaV\^c\ idb^XgdhXde^XV\^c\iZX]c^fjZhVcY[djcYcZ^i]ZgidWZbdgZVXXjgViZ#LVaa^cVcY XdaaZV\jZh&..)!e#(*(]VkZ[djcYi]Vii]Z^gYZiZgb^cVi^dcd[V\Z"Vi"YZVi]i]gdj\] b^XgdhXde^XWdcZbdge]dbZigngZhjaiZY^chiVcYVgYYZk^Vi^dchd[dkZg&'nZVghVcY lVh¹Xdch^YZgVWanaZhhegZX^hZi]Vc\ZcZgVaanhiViZY^ci]Za^iZgVijgZ#º

-ULTIFACTORIAL!GE%STIMATION <^kZc i]Z kVg^Zin d[ iZX]c^fjZh VkV^aVWaZ [dg VhhZhh^c\ h`ZaZiVa V\Z"Vi"YZVi] [dg Vc" di]ZggZk^Zl!hZZ8dm!'%%%!l]ViiZX]c^fjZhh]djaYWZjhZYWni]ZdhiZdad\^hi4>c IdYY¼hdg^\^cVa&.'%ldg`dci]ZX]Vc\Zh]Z]VYXaVhh^ÄZY^ci]ZejW^Xhnbe]nh^h!]Z idd`\gZVieV^chided^cidjii]Vii]ZbdhiVXXjgViZZhi^bViZd[V\ZXVcdcanWZbVYZ V[iZgZmVb^cVi^dcd[i]ZZci^gZh`ZaZidc#=dlZkZg!YjZidi]ZhdbZi^bZh[gV\bZciVgn cVijgZ d[ h`ZaZiVa gZbV^ch VcY i]Z ]^hidgn d[ YZkZadebZci d[ V\^c\ iZX]c^fjZh! ]^h VYk^XZ]Vhd[iZcWZZc[dg\diiZcWn]jbVcdhiZdad\^hihl]d[daadlZY#6aadhiZdad\^hih jhZYZciVaYZkZadebZci!Zgjei^dc!Ze^e]nhZVaVeeZVgVcXZ!VcY[jh^dcl]ZcV\^c\^b" bVijgZ h`ZaZiVa bViZg^Va# ;dg V\^c\ VYjai h`ZaZiVa gZbV^ch! ]dlZkZg! dhiZdad\^hih VgZ h]VgeanY^k^YZYdci]ZfjZhi^dcd[iZX]c^fjZ#I]^hXdcigdkZghnegdk^YZhVc^bedgiVci VgZcV[dgi]ZXdci^cjZYiZhi^c\VcYgZÄcZbZcid[i]ZiZX]c^fjZhdjia^cZYZVga^Zg# HdbZdhiZdad\^hih!eVgi^XjaVgani]dhZldg`^c\^c[dgZch^XXdciZmih![Vkdgi]ZjhZd[ 

8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

i]ZejW^Xhnbe]nh^hVcYVhh^\cdi]ZgVcVidb^XVagZ\^dchVaZhhZggdaZ^cV\ZVcVanh^h# AdkZ_dnZiVa#&.-*VcdiZi]Vii]^higVY^i^dcVa[dgZch^Xdg^ZciVi^dcidV\^c\]VhaZYid egdWaZbhl]Zch`ZaZidch[gdbaVg\ZedejaVi^dchVgZV\ZYWnY^[[ZgZcidWhZgkZghjh^c\ ZhiVWa^h]ZYbZi]dYh#;jgi]ZgbdgZ!i]ZkVajZd[h`ZaZiVaV\Z^cY^XVidgh]VhWZZc_jY\ZY dci]ZWVh^hd[VXXjgVXnY^[[ZgZcXZhWZilZZcegZY^XiZYVcYVXijVaV\Zhl^i]djiYjZ gZ\VgYidW^Vhi]ZiZcYZcXnd[V\^kZciZX]c^fjZiddkZg"dgjcYZgV\Z# >[bdgZi]VcdcZXg^iZg^dc^hVkV^aVWaZ[dgVhhZhh^c\h`ZaZiVaV\Z"Vi"YZVi]!VaaXg^iZg^V h]djaY WZ ZbeadnZY 7VXX^cd Zi Va#! &...# DcZ ^bbZY^ViZ dW_ZXi^dc id i]^h gZXdb" bZcYVi^dcVg^hZhWZXVjhZd[i]ZbVg`ZYY^[[ZgZcXZh^ci]ZgZa^VW^a^inWZilZZcY^[[ZgZci V\Z^cY^XVidgh#;dgZmVbeaZ!bVcn^ckZhi^\VidghVgZ]Zh^iVciidVaiZgVYZiZgb^cVi^dcd[ V\Z"Vi"YZVi]WVhZYdci]ZejW^Xhnbe]nh^h[VXZWnVYY^i^dcVaYViV[gdbXgVc^VahjijgZ XadhjgZWZXVjhZd[i]ZaViiZg¼hhjeedhZYjcgZa^VW^a^inhZZBZ^cYaVcYAdkZ_dn!&.-*# >c[dgZch^XV\^c\d[h^c\aZ^cY^k^YjVah!hjX]XVji^dcbVnWZVYk^hVWaZYZeZcY^c\dc i]ZVhhZhhZYV\Z#=dlZkZg!XgVc^VahjijgZXadhjgZ^hXdggZaViZYl^i]^cXgZVh^c\V\Z!VcY ^ci]ZVcVanh^hd[edejaVi^dchi]ZVYY^i^dcd[YViVdcV\Z"Vi"YZVi][gdbi]ZhZfjZci^Va VYY^i^dcd[di]ZgV\Z^cY^XVidghh]djaY^begdkZi]ZVXXjgVXnd[YZiZgb^cVi^dc#

$ETERMINATIONOF3EX I]ZiZgbh¹hZmºVcY¹\ZcYZgº]VkZ^cXgZVh^c\anWZXdbZXdcÅViZY^ci]ZVci]gdedad\^" XVaVcYbZY^XVaa^iZgVijgZ#I]ZnYdcdigZ[Zgidi]ZhVbZi]^c\!i]ZnVgZcdihncdcnbh! VcYi]Znh]djaYcdiWZjhZY^ciZgX]Vc\ZVWan#ci]ZVgX]Zdad\^XVaXdciZmi! ^i^hd[iZcedhh^WaZidYZiZgb^cZhZmi]gdj\]VcVanh^hd[h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch!VcY\ZcYZg gdaZhi]gdj\]hijY^Zhd[bViZg^VaXjaijgZVgi^[VXihVcYXdciZmi# L^i]VhVbeaZd[Ä[inadlaVcY\dg^aaVbVaZhVcYÄ[inadlaVcY\dg^aaV[ZbVaZh!ZkZc i]ZjcigV^cZYdWhZgkZgXdjaYhdgih`ZaZiVaZaZbZcihWnhZmjh^c\h^oZVcYh]VeZ#;dg i]^heg^bViZ!&%%VXXjgVXn^chdgi^c\^hdWiV^cZYZVh^an#I]ZhVbZVeea^ZhiddgVc\" jiVch#L^i]X]^beVcoZZh!i]ZY^[[ZgZcXZhVgZcdiVhbVg`ZY!Wjil]Zci]ZXVc^cZiZZi] gVi]Zgi]Vci]ZdkZgVaah^oZd[i]ZXgVc^jbVgZZmVb^cZY!eZg[ZXiVXXjgVXnXVchi^aaWZ VeegdVX]ZY#Bdk^c\idVhVbeaZd[Ä[inbVaZVcYÄ[in[ZbVaZbdYZgc]jbVch!i]ZgZ ^h[VgaZhhhZmjVaY^bdge]^hb^cWdYnVcYXVc^cZh^oZ!VcYhdgi^c\VXXjgVXn^hi]ZgZ" [dgZgZYjXZY#=jbVchZmjVaY^bdge]^hb^hXdbeaZm!l^i]WZ]Vk^dgVa!e]nh^dad\^XVa! VcYVcVidb^XVaY^bZch^dch#6cVidb^XVaY^[[ZgZcXZhVgZZmigZbZ^chdbZhd[ii^hhjZ VgZVhVcYbdgZa^b^iZY^ci]Zh`ZaZidc#CZkZgi]ZaZhh!h`ZaZiVaY^[[ZgZcXZhWZilZZcbVaZ VcY[ZbVaZ]jbVchYdZm^hiVcYXVcWZjhZ[jaidi]ZdhiZdad\^hi#7j^`higVVcYB^Za`Z &.-*hjbbVg^oZ^c]Zae[jaiVWjaVg[dgbi]ZVXXjgVXnd[VkVg^Zind[h`ZaZiVahZm^c\ iZX]c^fjZh!VcYBVnhVcY8dm'%%%egdk^YZVbdgZgZXZcigZk^Zl# >cYZiZgb^c^c\i]ZhZmd[Vcnh`ZaZiVaZaZbZci!i]ZdhiZdad\^hihiVgihl^i]*%VX" XjgVXn¸gVcYdb\jZhh^c\l^aaWZXdggZXi]Va[d[i]Zi^bZ#;dghdbZZaZbZcih!hjX]Vh i]ZXgVc^jb!igV^c^c\VcYZmeZg^ZcXZXVcd[iZcVaadlXdggZXihdgi^c\VWdji-%·.%d[ i]Zi^bZ#>i^hZmigZbZan^bedgiVciidgZbZbWZgi]VihZmjVa^YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[]jbVc h`ZaZiVabViZg^Va^hbdhiVXXjgViZV[iZgi]Z^cY^k^YjVagZVX]ZhbVijg^in#Dcani]ZcYd i]ZWdcZhd[Y^[[ZgZcihZmZhWZXdbZY^[[ZgZci^ViZYhj[ÄX^ZcianidWZjhZ[ja^chZm^c\# &.#)9ZiZgb^cVi^dcd[HZm

(-*

>c\ZcZgVa![dgVaaeVgihd[i]Z]jbVch`ZaZidc![ZbVaZZaZbZcihVgZX]VgVXiZg^oZY WnhbVaaZgh^oZVcYa^\]iZgXdchigjXi^dc#;dgi]^hgZVhdc!^cVaVg\Z!hZg^ViZY!b^mZY"hZm XdaaZXi^dc d[ ZaZbZcih! i]Z aVg\Zhi! bdhi gdWjhi ZaZbZcih l^i] i]Z ]ZVk^Zhi gj\dh^in VgZbVaZ#BVaZhXVcVkZgV\Zjeid'%aVg\Zg^chdbZh`ZaZiVaY^bZch^dch!l]ZgZVh^c di]Zghi]ZgZbVnWZcdY^bdge]^hb#I]ZhbVaaZhi!bdhi\gVX^aZZaZbZcihVgZ[ZbVaZ# CdgbVa^cY^k^YjVakVg^Vi^dc!]dlZkZg!ValVnhegdYjXZhhdbZhbVaa!\gVX^aZbVaZhVcY hdbZaVg\Z!gdWjhi[ZbVaZhl]d[VaaidlVgYi]ZXZciZgd[i]ZY^hig^Wji^dcl]ZgZhdgi^c\ hZm^hY^[ÄXjai#>cdi]ZgldgYh!i]ZhZmZhdkZgaVecZVgi]ZXZciZgd[i]ZY^hig^Wji^dc#;dg i]^hgZVhdc!dhiZdad\^hih]VkZigVY^i^dcVaanXdcXZcigViZYdcZaZbZcihd[i]Zh`jaaVcY eZak^h^cl]^X]hZmY^[[ZgZcXZh^c]jbVchVgZi]ZbdhiZmigZbZ# >c VYY^i^dc id i]Z Xdbea^XVi^dch d[ ^cY^k^YjVa kVg^Vi^dc l^i]^c i]Z edejaVi^dc! ^cXdggZXihZm^YZci^ÄXVi^dchVgZhdbZi^bZhbVYZWZXVjhZd[kVg^Vi^dcWZilZZcedejaV" i^dch#HdbZedejaVi^dchVgZ!dcVkZgV\Z!XdbedhZYd[aVg\Zg!]ZVk^Zg!bdgZgdWjhi^c" Y^k^YjVahd[Wdi]hZmZh!l]ZgZVhdi]ZgedejaVi^dchVgZX]VgVXiZg^oZYWni]Zdeedh^iZ iZcYZcXn#7ZXVjhZd[hjX]^ciZgedejaVi^dcVaY^[[ZgZcXZh^ch^oZVcYgdWjhi^X^in!bVaZh [gdb dcZ edejaVi^dc VgZ hdbZi^bZh b^hiV`Zc [dg [ZbVaZh ^c di]Zg edejaVi^dch VcY k^XZkZghV#I]ZdhiZdad\^hih]djaYValVnhViiZbeiidWZXdbZ[Vb^a^Vgl^i]i]Zh`ZaZiVa hZmjVaY^bdge]^hbd[i]ZedejaVi^dc[gdbl]^X]jchZmZYbViZg^Va]VhWZZcYgVlc# 6h^i^hl^i]V\^c\!hZg^Vi^dcXVcWZV]Zae[jaVeegdVX]^cYZiZgb^c^c\i]ZhZmd[h`Za" ZiVagZbV^ch[gdbVedejaVi^dc# 6aad[i]Zbdge]dad\^XVaiZX]c^fjZhjhZY^chZm^c\h`ZaZiVagZbV^chYZeZcYdci]Z egZhZgkVi^dcd[hZmjVaanY^bdge]^XZaZbZcih#6aad[i]Zbh]VgZVcdcig^k^VaZggdggViZ! ZkZc[dgVYjaigZbV^ch#=dlZkZg!^[9C6XVcWZgZXdkZgZY[gdbdhhZdjhgZbV^ch!i]ZhZm d[Vcn^cY^k^YjVagZ\VgYaZhhd[^cY^k^YjVaV\ZXVcWZYZiZgb^cZYl^i]]^\]egZX^h^dc# I]^h^higjZZkZc[dg]^\]an[gV\bZciVgngZbV^ch#HZm^c\d[dhiZdad\^XVaheZX^bZch^c V[dgZch^XXdciZmi!i]ZgZ[dgZ!]VhWZZcX]Vc\ZY[jcYVbZciVaanWni]Z^cigdYjXi^dcd[ bdaZXjaVgiZX]c^fjZhid]jbVcdhiZdad\nHidcZZiVa#!&..+0HidcZ!'%%%#

3EXINGTHE3KULLAND$ENTITION 9ZiZgb^cVi^dcd[hZmWVhZYdceVgihd[i]Zh`jaa[daadlhi]ZdWhZgkVi^dci]VibVaZh iZcYidWZaVg\ZgVcYbdgZgdWjhii]Vc[ZbVaZh#>cVYY^i^dcidh^oZ!iZcYZcX^ZhhjX] Vhi]dhZdjia^cZY]ZgZegdk^YZjhZ[ja^cY^XVi^dch[dgYZiZgb^c^c\i]ZhZmd[^hdaViZY h`jaah#I]ZhZX]VgVXiZg^hi^XhVgZi]ZigVY^i^dcVadcZhjhZYWndhiZdad\^hih#;^\jgZ&.#&% ^aajhigViZhi]Zb# GZaVi^kZid[ZbVaZXgVc^V!bVaZXgVc^VVgZX]VgVXiZg^oZYWn\gZViZggdWjhi^X^in#BVaZ XgVc^Vine^XVaanY^heaVnbdgZegdb^cZcihjegVdgW^iVag^Y\Zh!VbdgZegdb^cZci\aVWZa" aVg gZ\^dc! VcY ]ZVk^Zg iZbedgVa VcY cjX]Va a^cZh# BVaZ [gdciVah VcY eVg^ZiVah iZcY idWZaZhhWdhhZYi]Vc[ZbVaZdcZh#BVaZhiZcYid]VkZgZaVi^kZanaVg\Z!WgdVYeVaViZh! hfjVgZgdgW^ih!aVg\ZgbVhid^YegdXZhhZh!aVg\Zgh^cjhZh!VcYaVg\ZgdXX^e^iVaXdcYnaZh i]Vc [ZbVaZh# L]Zc XdbeVgZY id [ZbVaZ bVcY^WaZh! bVaZ bVcY^WaZh VgZ X]VgVXiZg" ^oZYWnhfjVgZgX]^ch!bdgZ\dc^VaZkZgh^dc!YZZeZgbVcY^WjaVggVb^!VcYbdgZgj\dhZ bjhXaZViiVX]bZcihZ#\#!hZZ<“aZ`dcVcYIjg\ji!'%%(# I]ZgZaVi^kZhigZc\i]d[i]ZhZXgVc^VaiZcYZcX^ZhXVcWZhjbbVg^oZYWni]Z[da" adl^c\/L]ZgZVhhdX^ViZYedhiXgVc^VabViZg^Va^hVkV^aVWaZ!ValVnhjhZi]ZeZak^h[dghZm YZiZgb^cVi^dcd[i]ZXgVc^jb#L]ZchZm^c\h`jaah!ValVnhjhZi]ZZci^gZedejaVi^dc 

8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

jcYZghijYn#HZg^ViZi]^hedejaVi^dcVXXdgY^c\idi]ZXg^iZg^VndjjhZVcYi]Zchdgi#>[ ndjVgZhZm^c\dcandcZdgV[Zl^cY^k^YjVah!ignidjhZXdbeVgVi^kZedejaVi^dchi]Vi VgZ\ZcZi^XVaanVcYiZbedgVaanXadhZidi]ZdcZh[gdbl]^X]ndjghVbeaZYZg^kZh# LVa`Zg! ^c i]Z 7j^`higV VcY JWZaV`Zg HiVcYVgYh kdajbZ &..)! egdk^YZh ÄkZ VheZXihd[h`jaabdge]dad\ni]ViVgZjhZ[ja^cYZiZgb^c^c\hZm#I]ZhZVgZh]dlc^c ;^\jgZ&.#&&#>cVaaXVhZh!VÄkZ"ed^cihXVaZ^hjhZY!l^i]i]ZbdgZ\gVX^aZ![Zb^c^cZ [ZVijgZhVii]ZadlZgZcYd[i]ZgVc\Z#cVcViiZbeiid\dWZndcYi]ZigVY^i^dcVabZi]dYhdjia^cZYZVga^Zg!<^aZhVcY:a" a^di&.+(jhZYc^cZhiVcYVgYXgVc^VabZig^XhidY^b^c^h]i]ZhjW_ZXi^k^in^ckdakZY ^chZm^c\i]Zh`jaa#=dlZkZg!VhijYnWnBZ^cYaZiVa#&.-*W]Vhh]dlci]VihjW_ZX" i^kZVhhZhhbZcid[i]Zh`jaaXdbeVgZY[VkdgVWanidi]ZY^hXg^b^cVci[jcXi^dchd[<^aZh VcY:aa^di#>ciZhihdc=VbVcc·IdYYXgVc^V!BZ^cYaZiVa#&.-*W[djcYi]VidaYZg ^cY^k^YjVahh]dl^cXgZVh^c\an¹bVhXja^cZºbdge]dad\n#L]ZgZVh&%#'d[i]ZbVaZh ^ci]Z^ghVbeaZd[&%%lZgZhZmZY^cXdggZXian!dcan)#.d[i]Z[ZbVaZhlZgZb^h^YZci^" ÄZY#<^kZci]ZhZ[VXih!BZ^cYaZiVa#&.-*Whj\\Zhii]VidkZgVaahZmgVi^dhVcYV\ZXaVhh hZmgVi^dh^cegZ]^hidg^XXZbZiZg^Zhh]djaYdcanWZZhi^bViZY[gdbVYjaiWjg^Vahl^i] [jaanegZhZgkZYeZakZh# 7ZXVjhZiZZi]VgZd[iZcWZiiZgegZhZgkZYi]Vcdi]Zgh`ZaZiVaZaZbZcih!i]ZgZ]VkZ WZZcZ[[dgihidhZmi]Zh`ZaZidcjh^c\i]ZiZZi]#I]ZYZ\gZZd[hZmjVaY^bdge]^hb^c ]jbVcXgdlch^oZhkVg^ZhWZilZZcedejaVi^dch#=jbVcYZciVaY^bdge]^hbXZciZgh dci]ZXVc^cZh!Wji^i^hcdicZVganhdegdcdjcXZYVh^i^h^ci]Z\gZViVeZh#=jbVc adlZgXVc^cZhh]dli]Z\gZViZhiY^bdge]^hb!jeid,#(=^aahdc!&..+![daadlZYWn i]ZjeeZgXVc^cZh#9ZX^YjdjhiZZi]VgZVahdY^bdge]^X!l^i]bdaVghVcYXVc^cZhjeid ,#6XXjgVXnd[hZm^c\jc`cdlchWVhZYdcYZciVabZig^Xh!Z^i]Zgjc^kVg^ViZdgbjai^" kVg^ViZ!kVg^Zh[gdb+%idVXaV^bZY.%VcYjhjVaana^ZhWZilZZc,*VcY-%#L]Zc ^i^hcdiZYi]Vii]ZVXijVah^oZY^[[ZgZcXZhWZilZZchZmZh^c^cY^k^YjVaiZZi]VgZkZgn hbVaa!VWdji]Va[Vb^aa^bZiZgdcVkZgV\Z!^iXVcWZhZZci]Vi^cigV"VcY^ciZgdWhZgkZg Zggdgb^\]ieaVnVgdaZ^chZmZhi^bVi^dc#9ZK^idVcYHVjcYZgh&..%!7ZgbYZoYZ 8VhigdZiVa#&..(!7ZnZg"DahZcVcY6aZmVcYZghZc&..*!VcY=^aahdc&..+egdk^YZ gZk^Zlhd[i]ZjhZd[YZciVaY^bZch^dchidhZm]jbVciZZi]#

3EXINGTHE0OSTCRANIAL3KELETON 6h[dgi]ZXgVc^jb!hZmjVaanY^V\cdhi^XigV^ih^ci]ZedhiXgVc^Vah`ZaZidcVgZY^[ÄXjaiid ^YZci^[nVcYVhhZhhWZ[dgZejWZgin#CjbZgdjhbZig^XhijY^Zhd[i]ZedhiXgVc^Vah`ZaZidc ]VkZZmVb^cZYhZmjVaY^bdge]^hb^ci]Zh^oZd[kVg^djhVYjaiZaZbZcih#7Vhh&..* &.#)9ZiZgb^cVi^dcd[HZm

(-,

&IGUREBVaZVWdkZVcY [ZbVaZdeedh^iZVYjaih`jaah^c [gdciVaVcYaViZgVak^Zlh#I]Z [ZbVaZh`jaaX]dhZc[dgi]^h ^aajhigVi^dclVhiV`Zc[gdb i]Z¹[ZbVaZºZcYd[i]Z[ZbVaZ gVc\Z#I]ZbVaZ^hi]ZhVbZ ^cY^k^YjVajhZYid^aajhigViZ i]ZXgVc^jb^c8]VeiZg)# I]^hXdbeVg^hdc^aajhigViZhi]Z Y^[[ZgZcXZhWZilZZcbVaZVcY [ZbVaZh`jaahY^hXjhhZY^ci]Z iZmi#>ih]djaYcdiWZiV`ZcVhV gZegZhZciVi^dcd[i]ZY^[[ZgZcXZ WZilZZcVkZgV\ZbVaZVcY [ZbVaZh`jaah!WjigVi]ZgVhVc ^cY^XVi^dcd[]dlbjX]hZmjVa kVg^Vi^dc^hhZZc^ci]Z]jbVc h`jaa#DcZ"]Va[cVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

&.#)9ZiZgb^cVi^dcd[HZm

(-.

&IGUREg^\]iVcYdeedh^iZ6hXdg^c\ hnhiZb[dghZmjVaanY^bdge]^XXgVc^Va[ZV" ijgZh[gdbLVa`Zg^c7j^`higVVcYJWZaV`Zg &..)#>cgZXdgY^c\i]Z[ZVijgZh!dei^bVa gZhjaihVgZdWiV^cZYWn]daY^c\i]ZXgVc^jb .5#(!, dgbVcY^WaZViVgb¼haZc\i]!V[Zl^cX]Zh #2%34 VWdkZi]ZVeegdeg^ViZedgi^dcd[i]^hÄ\jgZ! dg^ZciZYhdi]Vii]Z[ZVijgZhXVcWZY^gZXian XdbeVgZYl^i]i]dhZ^aajhigViZY#BdkZi]Z WdcZ[gdbY^V\gVbidY^V\gVbjci^ai]Z XadhZhibViX]^hdWiV^cZY#HXdgZZVX]igV^i ^cYZeZcYZcian!^\cdg^c\di]Zg[ZVijgZh#6 heZX^ÄXegdXZYjgZ[dgZVX]igV^i^hYZhXg^WZY -!34/)$ WZadl!l^i]i]ZZmigZbZhYZhXg^WZYVcYi]Z 02/#%33 ^ciZgbZY^ViZh^aajhigViZY^ci]ZÄ\jgZ# >eSXQ\3bUcd*K^Zli]ZaViZgVaegdÄaZ d[i]ZdXX^e^iVaVcYXdbeVgZ^il^i]i]Z Y^V\gVbh#;ZZai]Zhjg[VXZd[i]ZdXX^e^iVa l^i]ndjg]VcYVcYcdiZVcnhjg[VXZgj\dh" ^in!^\cdg^c\i]ZXdcidjgd[i]ZjcYZgan^c\ 3502!/2")4!, WdcZ#;dXjhdci]Zgj\dh^inViiZcYVciid -!2'). ViiVX]bZcid[cjX]VabjhXjaVijgZ#>ci]Z XVhZd[b^c^bVaZmegZhh^dchXdgZ2&!i]Z ZmiZgcVahjg[VXZd[i]ZdXX^e^iVa^hhbddi] l^i]cdWdcnegd_ZXi^dchk^h^WaZl]Zci]Z aViZgVaegdÄaZ^hk^ZlZY#BVm^bVaZmegZhh^dc hXdgZ2*YZÄcZhVbVhh^kZcjX]VaXgZhi i]Viegd_ZXihVXdch^YZgVWaZY^hiVcXZ[gdb 3502!/2")4!, i]ZWdcZVcY[dgbhVlZaa"YZÄcZYWdcn 2)$'%',!"%,,! aZY\Zdg¹]dd`#º =Qcd_YT@b_SUcc*HXdgZi]^h[ZVijgZWn XdbeVg^c\^ihh^oZl^i]i]Vid[hjggdjcY" ^c\higjXijgZhhjX]Vhi]ZZmiZgcVaVjY^idgn bZVijhVcYi]Zon\dbVi^XegdXZhhd[i]Z iZbedgVaWdcZ#BVhid^YegdXZhhZhkVgn Xdch^YZgVWan^ci]Z^gegdedgi^dch#I]Zbdhi ^bedgiVcikVg^VWaZidXdch^YZg^chXdg" -%.4!, ^c\i]^higV^i^hi]ZkdajbZd[i]ZbVhid^Y %-).%.#% egdXZhh!cdi^ihaZc\i]#B^c^bVaZmegZhh^dc hXdgZ2&^hVkZgnhbVaabVhid^YegdXZhh i]Viegd_ZXihdcanVhbVaaY^hiVcXZWZadli]Z ^c[Zg^dgbVg\^chd[i]ZZmiZgcVaVjY^idgn bZVijhVcYi]ZY^\Vhig^X\gddkZ#6bVhh^kZ bVhid^YegdXZhhl^i]aZc\i]hVcYl^Yi]hhZkZgVai^bZhi]Vid[i]ZZmiZgcVaVjY^idgnbZVijh h]djaYWZhXdgZYVh*# Ce`bQ_bRYdQ\=QbWY^*7Z\^cWn]daY^c\ndjgÄc\ZgV\V^chii]ZbVg\^cd[i]ZdgW^iVii]Z aViZgVaVheZXid[i]ZhjegVdgW^iVa[dgVbZc#I]Zc]daYi]ZZY\Zd[i]ZdgW^iWZilZZcndjg Äc\ZghidYZiZgb^cZ^ihi]^X`cZhh#Add`ViZVX]d[i]ZY^V\gVbhidYZiZgb^cZl]^X]^ihZZbh idbViX]bdhiXadhZan#>cVcZmVbeaZd[b^c^bVaZmegZhh^dchXdgZ2&!i]ZWdgYZgh]djaY [ZZaZmigZbZanh]Vge!a^`Zi]ZZY\Zd[Vha^\]ianYjaaZY`c^[Z#6i]^X`!gdjcYZYbVg\^cl^i]V XjgkVijgZVeegdm^bVi^c\VeZcX^ah]djaYWZhXdgZYVh*# @b_]Y^U^SU_V7\QRU\\Q*K^Zl^c\i]ZXgVc^jb[gdbi]Zh^YZ!XdbeVgZi]ZegdÄaZd[i]Z



8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

























hjegVdgW^iVagZ\^dcl^i]i]ZY^V\gVbh#>cVb^c^bVaegdb^cZcXZd[\aVWZaaV$hjegVdgW^iVa g^Y\ZhhXdgZ2&!i]ZXdcidjgd[i]Z[gdciVa^hhbddi]!l^i]a^iiaZdgcdegd_ZXi^dcVib^Ya^cZ# BVm^bVaZmegZhh^dc^ckdakZhVbVhh^kZ\aVWZaaVgegdb^cZcXZ![dgb^c\VgdjcYZY!adV["h]VeZY egd_ZXi^dci]Vi^h[gZfjZcianVhhdX^ViZYl^i]lZaa"YZkZadeZYhjegVdgW^iVag^Y\Zh# =U^dQ\5]Y^U^SU*=daYi]ZbVcY^WaZWZilZZci]Zi]jbWhVcY^cYZmÄc\Zghl^i]i]jbWh dcZ^i]Zgh^YZd[i]ZbZciVaZb^cZcXZ#BdkZi]Zi]jbWhbZY^Vaanjci^ai]ZnYZa^b^ii]ZWdg" YZghd[i]ZbZciVaZb^cZcXZ#>cZmVbeaZhd[b^c^bVaZmegZhh^dchXdgZ2&!i]ZgZ^ha^iiaZdgcd egd_ZXi^dcd[i]ZbZciVaZb^cZcXZVWdkZi]ZhjggdjcY^c\WdcZ#>cXdcigVhi!VbVhh^kZbZciVa Zb^cZcXZi]VidXXje^Zhbdhid[i]ZVciZg^dgedgi^dcd[i]ZbVcY^WaZ^hhXdgZYVh*#

&.#)9ZiZgb^cVi^dcd[HZm

(.&

&IGUREKVg^Vi^dc^ci^W^Vah^oZVcYh]VeZVbdc\iZc[ZbVaZhVWdkZVcYiZcbVaZhdeed" h^iZhZaZXiZYVigVcYdb[gdbVh^c\aZ"h^iZ!hZm"WVaVcXZYhVbeaZd[&%%egZ]^hidg^X8Va^[dgc^Vc h`ZaZidch#I]^hhVbeaZ!'%d[i]ZidiVaedejaVi^dc!\^kZhVc^cY^XVi^dcd[i]ZcdgbVahZmjVa Y^bdge]^hbZcXdjciZgZY^cbdYZgc]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#DcZ"h^mi]cVijgVah^oZ#

egdk^YZhVcZmXZaaZcigZk^Zld[i]ZhZ#GZhjaihdci]ZbdhiY^bdge]^Xa^bWWdcZhXVc WZ hjbbVg^oZY Wn cdi^c\ i]Vi h^c\aZ bZVhjgZbZcih! dg XdbW^cVi^dch d[ bZVhjgZ" bZcih!]VkZjhjVaanWZZc[djcYidXdggZXian^YZci^[ni]ZhZmd[WZilZZc-%VcY.%d[ Vaa^cY^k^YjVah#>cXdggZXi^YZci^ÄXVi^dcl^i]^cVcnedejaVi^dc^hVXdchZfjZcXZd[h^oZ dkZgaVeWZilZZcbVaZhVcY[ZbVaZh^ci]ZXZciZgd[i]ZdkZgVaagVc\Z;^\jgZ&.#&'# BVcnhijY^Zh]VkZWZZcXdcYjXiZYdc`cdlc"hZmhVbeaZhidYZg^kZ[jcXi^dchXVeVWaZ d[XaVhh^[n^c\hZmVXXjgViZanbdgZi]Vc-*d[i]Zi^bZ[dgVkVg^Zind[ZaZbZcihgVc\" ^c\[gdbi]ZbZiVXVgeVah;VahZii^!&..*0Hid_Vcdlh`^!&...0WjihZZ7jggdlh!'%%( idi]ZbZiViVghVahGdWa^c\VcYJWZaV`Zg!&..,!]jbZgjhGd\Zgh!&...!jacVEjg" `V^i!'%%&!VcYXVaXVcZjh>cigdcVZiVa#!&..,#7ZXVjhZi]ZhZ[jcXi^dchVgZd[iZccdi iZhiZYWZndcYdg^cYZeZcYZcid[i]Zh`ZaZiVaedejaVi^dcdcl]^X]i]ZnlZgZWVhZY! XaV^bhd[VXXjgVXnVgZhdbZi^bZhfjZhi^dcVWaZ#Gd\Zgh&...]VhXaV^bZY.'VXXj" gVXnWVhZYdc[djgX]VgVXiZghd[i]ZY^hiVa]jbZgjh!WjiiZhi^c\dcVl^YZghVbeaZl^aa WZgZfj^gZY# I]Zh`jaa]VhWZZcVigVY^i^dcVa[dXjhd[hZm^c\hijY^Zh!WjiVcjbWZgd[bZi]dYh d[hZm^c\]VkZVahdWZZcVeea^ZYidi]ZeZak^h#I]ZgZVgZYgVbVi^X[jcXi^dcVaY^[[Zg" ZcXZh WZilZZc bVaZ VcY [ZbVaZ eZak^X VcVidbn# I]ZhZ ZmiZcY id i]Z Wdcn h`ZaZidc VcYgZegZhZciY^[[ZgZcXZh[djcY^cVaabdYZgc]jbVc\gdjeh#I]ZeZak^h^hd[k^iVa ^bedgiVcXZ^cadXdbdi^dcVcYeVgijg^i^dc#9jg^c\]jbVcZkdaji^dc!hZaZXi^kZegZh" hjgZhVhhdX^ViZYl^i]i]ZhZVcYdi]ZggdaZhaZYidi]ZhZmjVaY^bdge]^hbhZZc^ci]Z bdYZgc]jbVceZak^h# IgVY^i^dcVabZi]dYhjhZYidYZiZgb^cZhZmdci]ZeZak^hdg^iheVgihVgZWVhZYdc 

8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

&IGUREXdci^cjZY











&IGUREHZmY^[[ZgZcXZh^ci]Z\gZViZghX^Vi^XcdiX]![gdbLVa`Zg^c7j^`higVVcYJWZaV`" Zg¼hHiVcYVgYhWdd`&..)#I]Z\gZViZghX^Vi^XcdiX]iZcYhidWZWgdVY^c[ZbVaZhVcYcVggdl^c bVaZh#I]ZhZh]VeZY^[[ZgZcXZhVgZcdiVhgZa^VWaZVhi]dhZ^ci]ZhjWejW^XgZ\^dcVcYh]djaYWZ i]dj\]id[VhhZXdcYVgn^cY^XVidgh#I]ZWZhigZhjaih[dghXdg^c\VgZdWiV^cZYWn]daY^c\i]Zdh XdmVZVWdkZi]^hÄ\jgZhdi]Vii]Z\gZViZghX^Vi^XcdiX]]Vhi]ZhVbZdg^ZciVi^dcVhi]Zdjia^cZh! Va^\c^c\i]ZhigV^\]iVciZg^dgedgi^dcd[i]ZcdiX]i]ViiZgb^cViZhVii]Z^hX]^Vahe^cZl^i]i]Z g^\]ih^YZd[i]ZY^V\gVb#L]^aZ]daY^c\i]ZWdcZ^ci]^hbVccZg!bdkZ^iidYZiZgb^cZi]Z XadhZhibViX]#>\cdgZVcnZmdhidhZhcZVgi]ZegZVjg^XjaVghjaXjhVcYi]Z^c[Zg^dgedhiZg^dg^a^VX he^cZ#8dcÄ\jgVi^dchbdgZZmigZbZi]Vc&dg*h]djaYWZhXdgZYVh&VcY*!gZheZXi^kZan#I]Z ^aajhigVi^dccjbWZgZY&h]dlhine^XVa[ZbVaZbdge]dad\n!l]ZgZVhi]Z]^\]ZgcjbWZghVgZ bVaZXdc[dgbVi^dch#

&.#)9ZiZgb^cVi^dcd[HZm

(.(

i]Z[daadl^c\iZcYZcX^Zh/I]ZhVXgVVcYdhhVXdmVd[[ZbVaZhVgZhbVaaZgVcYaZhhgd" Wjhii]Vci]dhZd[bVaZh#;ZbVaZeZak^X^caZihVgZgZaVi^kZanl^YZgi]VcbVaZdcZh#I]Z \gZViZg hX^Vi^X cdiX]Zh dc [ZbVaZ dhhV XdmV VgZ gZaVi^kZan l^YZg i]Vc i]dhZ dc bVaZ WdcZh ;^\jgZ &.#&(# ;ZbVaZh ]VkZ gZaVi^kZan adc\Zg ejW^X edgi^dch d[ i]Z dh XdmVZ! ^cXajY^c\i]ZhjeZg^dgejW^XgVbjh!i]VcbVaZh#I]ZhjWejW^XVc\aZ![dgbZYWZilZZc i]ZadlZgZY\Zhd[i]Zild^c[Zg^dgejW^XgVb^!^haVg\Zg^c[ZbVaZhi]Vc^cbVaZh#I]Z egZVjg^XjaVghjaXjh^hegZhZcibdgZd[iZc^c[ZbVaZhi]Vc^cbVaZh#6XdgdaaVgn^hi]Vi i]ZVjg^XjaVghjg[VXZ^hbdgZZaZkViZY[gdbi]Z[ZbVaZ^a^jbi]Vc[gdbi]ZbVaZ^a^jb! ZkZci]dj\]hZmjVaY^bdge]^hb^ci]ZVjg^XjaVghjg[VXZ^ihZa[^h^chj[ÄX^Zci[dgVXXj" gViZhZm^c\6a^VcYBVXAVj\]a^c!&..&#I]ZVXZiVWjajbiZcYhidWZgZaVi^kZanaVg\Zg ^cbVaZh;^\jgZ&.#&)# 6kVg^Zind[bZig^XiZX]c^fjZh]VkZWZZcYZkZadeZYidZmegZhhi]ZhZgZaVi^dch]^eh# LVh]Wjgc¼hViiZbeiidfjVci^[ni]ZgZaVi^kZegdedgi^dcd[i]ZejW^XeVgid[i]ZdhXdm" VZ^hi]Zbdhi[VbdjhVcYZ[[ZXi^kZd[i]ZhZ#LVh]Wjgc&.)-bZVhjgZYi]ZaZc\i]d[ i]ZejW^hgZaVi^kZidi]ZaZc\i]d[i]Z^hX]^jbk^VVc^cYZmi]ViY^hXg^b^cViZYWZilZZc

<

< &IGUREHZmjVaY^bdge]^hb^ci]ZWdcneZak^hh]dl^c\Y^[[ZgZcXZh^ch^oZVcYh]VeZ# ;ZbVaZVWdkZ0bVaZdeedh^iZ#DcZ"[djgi]cVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

bVaZVcY[ZbVaZdhhVXdmV#Gd\ZghVcYHVjcYZgh&..)egdk^YZVgZk^Zld[bZig^XVcY bdge]dad\^XVaigV^ihjhZYidhZmi]ZeZak^h!VcY7gj• oä Z`'%%'egdk^YZhVbdgZXjggZci VhhZhhbZci#LVa`Zg¼h'%%*VcVanh^hd[V\ZVcYedejaVi^dckVg^Vi^dc^chX^Vi^XcdiX] [dgb^hVkVajVWaZgZk^Zl# >c&.+.!I#L#E]Zc^XZejWa^h]ZYVc^bedgiVcicZlbZi]dY[dghZm^c\i]ZeZak^h# I]^h eVeZg! ¹6 CZlan 9ZkZadeZY K^hjVa BZi]dY d[ HZm^c\ i]Z Dh EjW^h!º YZhXg^WZh i]ZbdhiVXXjgViZbZi]dYnZi`cdlc[dgYZiZgb^c^c\hZmd[Vc^cY^k^YjVa[gdbi]Z h`ZaZidc#Jci^ai]ZejWa^XVi^dcd[i]ZE]Zc^XZeVeZg!i]ZdhiZdad\^hi¼hhjXXZhhVijh^c\ igVY^i^dcVa k^hjVa bZi]dYh d[ hZm^c\ i]Z eZak^h YZeZcYZY! ^c aVg\Z eVgi! dc ZmeZg^" ZcXZ¸ YZX^h^dchlZgZbdgZ"dg"aZhhhjW_ZXi^kZ#I]ZVeea^XVi^dcd[bZig^XXg^iZg^VlVh Y^[ÄXjaiWZXVjhZbjX]d[i]ZbViZg^ValVhidd[gV\bZciVgn[dggZa^VWaZbZVhjgZbZci! VcYZkZci]Zh^beaZhiiZX]c^fjZhlZgZi^bZ"Xdchjb^c\#E]Zc^XZ¼hbZi]dY^aajhigViZY ^c;^\jgZ&.#&*X]Vc\ZYi]Zh^ijVi^dc!Vaadl^c\bdgZVXXjgViZ!fj^X`ZghZm^c\dcVcn eZak^hl^i]Vc^ciVXiejW^XgZ\^dc# >cZbeadn^c\i]ZE]Zc^XZbZi]dYidhZmVcdhXdmVZ!cdiZi]VicdiZkZgnheZX^"

=

= &IGUREXdci^cjZY

&.#)9ZiZgb^cVi^dcd[HZm

(.*

VENTRALARC

=

<

SUBPUBIC CONCAVITY

=

<

&IGUREVWdkZVcYdeedh^iZI]ZE]Zc^XZ&.+.iZX]c^fjZ[dghZm^c\i]ZejW^Xedgi^dcd[ i]ZdhXdmVZ[gdbi]ZaZ[ih^YZ#>cZVX]XdbeVg^hdc!i]ZbVaZ^hdci]ZaZ[iVcYi]Z[ZbVaZ^hdc i]Zg^\]i#I]ZhZdhhVXdmVVgZi]ZdcZh^aajhigViZY^c;^\jgZ&.#&)#I]gZZ"fjVgiZghcVijgVah^oZ#



8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

SHARP MEDIAL ASPECTOF ISCHIOPUBIC RAMUS

=

<

&IGUREXdci^cjZY FU^dbQ\QbSDg^Zcii]ZejW^hhdi]Vi^ihgdj\]kZcigVahjg[VXZ[VXZhndjVcYndjVgZadd`^c\ YdlcVadc\i]ZeaVcZd[i]ZejW^Xhnbe]nhZVahjg[VXZ#I]ZkZcigVaVgX^hVha^\]ianZaZkViZY g^Y\Zd[WdcZi]VihlZZeh^c[Zg^dganVcYaViZgVaanVXgdhhi]ZkZcigVahjg[VXZd[i]ZejW^h!bZg\" ^c\l^i]i]ZbZY^VaWdgYZgd[i]Z^hX]^dejW^XgVbjh#I]jh!i]ZkZcigVaVgX!l]ZcegZhZci!hZih d[[i]Z^c[ZgdbZY^VaXdgcZgd[i]ZejW^XWdcZ^ckZcigVak^Zl#>i^hegZhZcidcan^c[ZbVaZh# BVaZdhhVXdmVbVn]VkZZaZkViZYg^Y\Zh^ci]^hVgZV!Wjii]ZhZYdcdiiV`Zi]Zl^YZ!ZkZcan VgX]^c\eVi]d[i]Z[ZbVaZ¼hkZcigVaVgX!cdgYdi]ZnhZid[[i]ZadlZgbZY^VafjVYgVcid[i]Z ejW^h# CeR`eRYSS_^SQfYdiIjgci]ZejW^hdkZg!dg^Zci^c\^ihdi]Vi^ihhbddi]!XdckZmYdghVahjg[VXZ [VXZhndjVcYndjVgZdcXZV\V^ch^\]i^c\Vadc\i]Zb^Ya^cZ#DWhZgkZi]ZbZY^VaZY\Zd[i]Z ^hX]^dejW^XgVbjh^ci]^hk^Zl#;ZbVaZdhhVXdmVY^heaVnVhjWejW^XXdcXVk^in]ZgZ0i]ZZY\Zd[ i]ZgVbjh^hXdcXVkZ^ci]^hk^Zl#=dlZkZg!bVaZhh]dlcdZk^YZcXZd[VXdcXVk^in]ZgZ#BVaZ ZY\ZhVgZhigV^\]idgkZgnha^\]ianXdcXVkZ# =UTYQ\Qc`USd_VdXUYcSXY_`eRYSbQ]ecIjgci]ZejW^h.%•!dg^Zci^c\i]Zhnbe]nhZVahjg" [VXZhdi]VindjVgZadd`^c\Y^gZXianVi^i#DWhZgkZi]Z^hX]^dejW^XgVbjh^ci]ZgZ\^dc^bbZ" Y^ViZan^c[Zg^dgidi]Zhnbe]nh^h#I]ZbZY^VaVheZXid[i]Z^hX]^dejW^XgVbjhY^heaVnhVh]Vge ZY\Z^c[ZbVaZh#>cbVaZhi]^hhjg[VXZ^h[V^ganÅVi!WgdVY!VcYWajci#

&.#)9ZiZgb^cVi^dcd[HZm

(.,

bZc^hV¹eZg[ZXiºbVaZdg[ZbVaZ#L]Zci]ZgZ^hVXg^iZg^dci]ViYdZhcdidWk^djhan hZmi]ZheZX^bZc!Y^hXVgYi]ViXg^iZg^dc#L]Zci]ZgZ^hhdbZVbW^\j^inXdcXZgc^c\ dcZdgildd[i]ZXg^iZg^Vbdhid[iZc^ci]ZbZY^VaVheZXid[i]Z^hX]^dejW^XgVbjh! VcYaZVhid[iZc^ci]ZkZcigVaVgX!jhjVaandcZd[i]ZgZbV^c^c\Xg^iZg^Vl^aaXaZVgan Viig^WjiZi]ZheZX^bZcidVhZm#6[iZghZm^c\i]ZheZX^bZcl^i]i]^hegdXZYjgZ!dWhZgkZ i]ZbdgZigVY^i^dcVa[ZVijgZhdjia^cZYZVga^ZgidhZZ^[i]ZnXdggZhedcYidXdggdWdgViZ ndjgY^V\cdh^h#;dgVcnXVhZ^cl]^X]i]ZnYdcdiXdcÄgb!gZX]ZX`ndjgdWhZgkVi^dch# GZbZbWZgi]Vi[ZbVaZ^cY^k^YjVahVgZbdhia^`ZanidWZ^ciZgbZY^ViZ^cY^heaVn^c\i]Z E]Zc^XZ[ZVijgZh# I]Z E]Zc^XZ bZi]dY h]djaY dcan WZ jhZY [dg [jaan VYjai bViZg^Va# 6XXjgVXn d[ hZm^c\WVhZYdci]^hbZi]dYgVc\Zh[gdb.+id&%%!i]Z]^\]ZhiZkZgVX]^ZkZY^ci]Z h`ZaZidc!WjiAdkZaa&.-.]Vhhj\\ZhiZYi]ViVXXjgVXnb^\]iWZgZYjXZY^ci]ZXVhZ d[daYZgVYjaiheZX^bZch#>c&..%!BVXAVj\]a^cVcY7gjXZiZhiZYi]ZE]Zc^XZX]Vg" VXiZgh[dgVXXjgVXnd[hZm^YZci^ÄXVi^dcdch`ZaZiVahZg^Zh[gdbAdcYdc!AZ^YZc!VcY HXdiaVcY#I]ZnlZgZjcVWaZidXdcÄgbi]ZVXXjgVXndWiV^cZYWnE]Zc^XZVcYdi]Zgh! VX]^Zk^c\hjXXZhhdcdcan-(d[i]Z:c\a^h]!+-d[i]Z9jiX]!VcY*.d[i]ZHXdi" i^h]#I]Zn[djcYi]ZhjWejW^XXdcXVk^inidWZi]Zh^c\aZbdhigZa^VWaZ^cY^XVidg#Jh^c\ &'-)ejW^XWdcZh[gdbi]ZAdh6c\ZaZh8djcin8dgdcZg¼hXdaaZXi^dc!Hji]ZgaVcYVcY HjX]Zn&..&gZedgiZYi]Vii]ZnVX]^ZkZY.+hZm^c\VXXjgVXnjh^c\i]ZkZcigVaVgX VadcZ#I]ZncdiZi]Vii]^h[ZVijgZÄghiVeeZVghViV\Z&)WjiYdZhcdiWZXdbZbVg`ZY jci^aV\Z'%#I]ZY^hXgZeVcXnWZilZZci]ZhZildbV_dgiZhihd[i]ZE]Zc^XZiZX]c^fjZ gZbV^chjcZmeaV^cZY!WjiJWZaV`ZgVcYKda`'%%'cdiZi]ViZmeZg^ZcXZeaVnhVgdaZ ^cXdcY^i^dc^c\gZhjaih[gdbi]ZjhZd[i]^hiZX]c^fjZ#I]ZWZhiVYk^XZ[dghZm^c\d[i]Z dhXdmVZ!Vh[dgV\^c\i]Zh`ZaZidc!^hidjhZVaad[i]ZVkV^aVWaZYViV# 

%STIMATIONOF3TATURE :hi^bVi^c\ ^cY^k^YjVahiVijgZ[gdbWdcZaZc\i]h]VhVadc\]^hidgn^ce]nh^XVaVc" i]gdedad\n#I]Z[VXii]Vii]Z]Z^\]ihiVijgZd[i]Z]jbVcWdYnXdggZaViZhl^i]a^bW WdcZaZc\i]VXgdhhVaaV\ZhVaadlhi]ZdhiZdad\^hiidgZXdchigjXiVc^cY^k^YjVa¼hhiVijgZ [gdb Y^[[ZgZci h`ZaZiVa ZaZbZcih# Jc[dgijcViZan! i]Z XdggZaVi^dc ^h ^beZg[ZXi l^i]^c a^k^c\edejaVi^dchVcYkVg^ZhWZilZZcedejaVi^dch#7VhZYdchijY^Zhd[h`ZaZidch[gdb ^cY^k^YjVahd[`cdlchiVijgZ!hZkZgVa^ckZhi^\Vidgh]VkZYZg^kZYgZ\gZhh^dcZfjVi^dch jhZ[ja^cZhi^bVi^c\hiVijgZ^cY^[[ZgZci]jbVcedejaVi^dch# IdZhi^bViZhiVijgZ!WVhZYdci]ZbVm^bjbaZc\i]d[VbVaZ[Zbjg[gdbVBZhd" VbZg^XVcVgX]Zdad\^XVah^iZ![dgZmVbeaZ!i]ZdhiZdad\^hildjaYVeeani]Z[dgbjaVYZ" g^kZYWn[[ZbjgaZc\i]^h`cdlc!hiVijgZbVnWZXVaXjaViZYl^i]VWdjiV+-egdWVW^a^in i]Vii]ZXVaXjaViZYkVajZ[Vaahl^i]^c(#)&,Xbd[i]ZVXijVahiVijgZd[i]Z^cY^k^Yj" Va#I]^h[dgbjaV!d[XdjghZ!XVcWZkVa^YanVeea^ZYdcanidBZm^XVchVbeaZh!Wji7Vhh &..*VcY7ZccZii&..(egdk^YZjhZ[jaiVWaZh[dghiVijgZZhi^bVi^dc^cY^[[ZgZci]j" bVc\gdjeh#Bdhid[i]ZhZ[dgbjaVZVgZWVhZYdci]ZaZc\i]hd[dcZdgbdgZWdcZh# 

8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

IgdiiZgVcY>gZbV^ch^cVcVcV" idb^XVaXdaaZXi^dc#;dgbjaVZlZgZegZhZciZY[dg¹gVX^Vaº\gdjeh#I]Z
4ABLE :fjVi^dchJhZYid:hi^bViZHiVijgZ!^c8Zci^bZiZgh!l^i]HiVcYVgY:ggdg![gdbi]ZAdc\ 7dcZhd[KVg^djhcY^k^YjVahWZilZZc&-VcY(%NZVghd[6\Z V GXYdU=Q\Uc  (#%- x =jb  (#,- x GVY  (#,% x Jac  '#(- x ;Zb  '#+- x ;^W


x
x
x
x
x

,%#)* ,.#%& ,)#%* +&#)& ,&#,-

)#%* )#(' )#(' (#', (#'.

2\QS[=Q\Uc (#'+ x =jb
x (#)' x GVY
x (#'+ x Jac
x '#&& x ;Zb
x '#&. x ;^W
x

+'#&% -&#*+ ,.#'. ,%#(* -*#+*

)#)( )#(% )#)' (#.) )#%-

GXYdU6U]Q\Uc  (#(+ x =jb  )#,) x GVY  )#', x Jac  '#), x ;Zb  '#.( x ;^W


x
x
x
x
x

*,#., *)#.( *,#,+ *)#&% *.#+&

)#)* )#') )#(% (#,' (#*,

2\QS[6U]Q\Uc (#%- x =jb '#,* x GVY (#(& x Jac '#'- x ;Zb '#). x ;^W


x
x
x
x
x

+)#+, .)#*& ,*#(- *.#,+ ,%#.%

)#'* *#%* )#-( (#)& (#-%

5Qcd1cYQ^=Q\Uc  '#+- x =jb
x  (#*) x GVY
x  (#)- x Jac
x  '#&* x ;Zb
x  '#)% x ;^W
x

-(#&. -'#% ,,#)* ,'#*, -%#*+

)#'* )#+% )#++ (#-% (#')

=UhYSQ^=Q\Uc '#.' x =jb (#** x GVY (#*+ x Jac '#)) x ;Zb '#*% x ;^W


x
x
x
x
x

,(#.) -%#,& ,)#*+ *-#+, ,*#))

)#') )#%) )#%* '#.. (#*'

VIdZhi^bViZhiVijgZd[daYZg^cY^k^YjVah!hjWigVXi%#%+V\Z^cnZVgh!(%Xb0idZhi^bViZXVYVkZg^XhiVijgZ!VYY'#*Xb# ;gdbIgdiiZg&.,%#I]Zi^W^V^hcdi^cXajYZY0hZZiZmi[dggVi^dcVaZ# 6aaaZc\i]hjhZYVgZbVm^bjbaZc\i]h

&.#*:hi^bVi^dcd[HiVijgZ

(..

[dgbjaVZ^ckdak^c\i^W^VZVgZWVhZYdcb^hbZVhjgZYi^W^VZi]ZbVaaZdajhlVhdb^iiZY ^cbVm^bjbaZc\i]bZVhjgZbZcih#;^cVaan!DlhaZn&..*cdiZhi]VihiVijgZXVcWZ YZÄcZY^chZkZgValVnh!gVc\^c\[gdb[dgZch^XZ#\#![gdbVYg^kZg¼ha^XZchZidW^dad\^XVa [gdbXVYVkZghdga^k^c\^cY^k^YjVah#=Zhj\\Zhihi]ViW^dad\^XVahiVijgZZhi^bVi^dch WVhZYdcadc\WdcZaZc\i]hVgZ\ZcZgVaanaZhhegZX^hZi]VcbVcn]VkZVhhjbZY#IVWaZ &.#(^h[gdbDlhaZn&..*#

%STIMATIONOF!NCESTRY >bV\^cZVhVbeaZd[&%%%eZdeaZ¸VhVbeaZXdbedhZYd[)%%cVi^kZC^\Zg^Vch!(%% cVi^kZ 8]^cZhZ! VcY (%% cVi^kZ CdglZ\^Vch# >[ i]ZhZ eZdeaZ hZViZY i]ZbhZakZh gVc" YdbanViVaZXijgZ!i]ZheZV`ZgldjaYWZVWaZidiZaa!h^beanWnadd`^c\Vii]Z^g[VXZh! l]Zi]Zg i]Z^g VcXZhign lVh 6h^Vc! 6[g^XVc! dg :jgdeZVc# I]Z hdgi^c\ VXXdbea^h]ZY dci]ZWVh^hd[hd[ii^hhjZ[VX^Va[ZVijgZhldjaYXdggZhedcYeZg[ZXianidi]Z\Zd\gVe]^X dg^\^cd[i]Zi]gZZbV_dgXdbedcZcihd[i]ZhVbeaZ#

4ABLE GZ\gZhh^dc:fjVi^dch[dg:hi^bVi^c\;dgZch^XHiVijgZ:hi^bVi^c\[gdbH`ZaZiVaGZbV^chV 

;VXidg

7dcZbZVhjgZbZci^cbb 8dchiVci

.%E>

C

GXYdU=Q\Uc      

%#%**++ %#%***' %#&%*+% %#&%&)% %#&*-.% %#&',)% %#&+(.-

;ZbjgBVmA
I^W^VA ;ZbjgBVmA
;^WjaVA ;ZbjgBVmA I^W^VA JacVA =jbZgjhA GVY^jhA

'&#+) ''#%% &.#(. (%#(- '+#.& '+#,. '-#(*

 '#*º

'#+º '#-º '#-º (#&º (#(º (#(º

+' *) +. +, +' ++ *.

GXYdU6U]Q\Uc      

%#%+*') %#%+&+( %#&&-+. %#&&&+- %#&&-', %#&((*( %#&-)+,

;ZbjgBVmA
I^W^VA ;ZbjgBVmA
;^WjaVA ;ZbjgBVmA I^W^VA =jbZgjhA JacVA GVY^jhA

&'#.) &*#)( &'#)( ')#+* '-#(% (&#.. ''#)'

'#(º '#)º '#)º (#%º (#&º (#&º (#)º

()' ))( )* )% (-

2\QS[6U]Q\Uc

%#&&+)%

;ZbjgBVmA

&&#.-

'#)º

&-

2\QS[=Q\Uc   

%#&+.., %#&%*'& %#%-(-- %#%,-')

JacVA I^W^VA ;ZbjgBVmA =jbZgjhA

'&#'% '+#'+ '-#*, )(#&.

(#(º (#-º )#%º )#)º

&) &. &, '%

VCdiZi]Vii]ZWdcZbZVhjgZbZcihh]djaYWZ^cb^aa^bZiZgh!Wjii]ViVaaXdchiVcihlZgZXdckZgiZYidegZY^XihiVijgZh VcYegZY^Xi^dc^ciZgkVah^c^cX]ZhWZXVjhZbdhiCdgi]6bZg^XVc[dgZch^XVeea^XVi^dchgZXdgYhiVijgZ^c^cX]Zh#;dg ZmVbeaZ!^[i]ZbVm^bjbaZc\i]d[i]Z[Zbjg[gdbVegdWVWaZl]^iZbVaZ^h)*)bb!i]Z[dgZch^XhiVijgZ^hZhi^bViZY Wn/%#&%*+%)*) &.#(.2+,#((£'#-^cX]Zh#I]^heZghdc!^[Vl]^iZbVaZ!ldjaY]VkZVgdj\]an.%X]VcXZd[]Vk^c\ V[dgZch^XhiVijgZWZilZZc+)#*VcY,%#&^cX]Zh*[ZZi)(^cX]Zhid*[ZZi&%^cX]Zh#



8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

I]^h`^cYd[hdgi^c\l^i]^ci]ZheZX^Zh=dbdhVe^Zch^hjhjVaaniZgbZYgVX^Vahdgi^c\# =dlZkZg!i]ZgZVgZcd¹ejgZº]jbVcgVXZh6#6#E#6#!&..+#7nYZÄc^i^dc!VaabZbWZgh d[i]ZhVbZheZX^Zh]VkZi]ZediZci^Vaid^ciZgWgZZY!VcY]ZcXZVcnhjWheZX^ÄXXaVh" h^ÄXVi^dc^hVgW^igVgn#9ZÄc^c\i]ZiZgb¹gVXZº]VhegdkZcY^[ÄXjai^ci]Z]^hidgnd[ e]nh^XVaVci]gdedad\nWZXVjhZXdcXZeihd[gVXZ]VkZd[iZcWZZcWVhZYdcXdbedh^iZh d[W^dad\^XVa!hdX^Va!VcYZi]c^XXg^iZg^VjhZY^cVinedad\^XVa[Vh]^dc#I]ZXdc[jh^dc Vg^h^c\[gdbi]ZhZY^[ÄXjai^Zh]VheZghjVYZYhdbZVci]gdedad\^hihidXdcXajYZi]Vi i]ZkZgnjhZd[i]ZiZgb¹gVXZº^hXdjciZg"egdYjXi^kZ#>cdhiZdad\^XValdg`!eVgi^XjaVgan ldg`^c[dgZch^XXdciZmih!i]ZYZiZgb^cVi^dcd[gVXZ!dg\Zd\gVe]^XVcXZhign!^hjhjVaan Vc^bedgiVciXdch^YZgVi^dc# I]Z i^iaZ d[ V eVeZg Wn e]nh^XVa Vci]gdedad\^hi @ZccZi] @ZccZYn &..* Vh`ZY! ¹7jiEgd[Zhhdg!L]nIZVX]GVXZ>YZci^ÄXVi^dc^[GVXZh9dc¼i:m^hi4ºInedad\^XVagVXZ XdcXZeih ^c e]nh^XVa Vci]gdedad\n ]VkZ \dcZ i]Z lVn d[ i]Z Y^cdhVjgh! Wji ]jbVc edejaVi^dchVgZgdji^cZanY^k^YZY^cidhZeVgViZgVXZh7aVX`h!L]^iZh!CVi^kZ6bZg^" XVch!VcY=^heVc^Xh^c\dkZgcbZciVaanbVcYViZYegd\gVbh!i]ZedejaVgbZY^V!VcY # i]Z [dgZch^X hX^ZcXZh# 6h Hi# =dnbZ VcY >h¨XVc &.-. cdiZ! ]jbVc dhiZdad\^hih l]d ZmVb^cZ]jbVcWdcZhbjhiXdbbjc^XViZl^i]aVl"Zc[dgXZbZcieZghdccZa!hijYZcih! VcYi]Z\ZcZgVaejWa^X#=dleZdeaZVgZXViZ\dg^oZYWndi]ZghYZeZcYhdcaVlVcYXjh" idb#I]ZJc^iZYHiViZh\dkZgcbZci¼hWjgZVjXgVi^XVeegdVX]idgVXZ^hfj^iZheZX^ÄX^c i]^hgZ\VgY!cdi^c\i]Vi^ihXaVhh^ÄXVi^dch6bZg^XVc>cY^Vcdg6aVh`VccVi^kZ06h^Vcdg EVX^ÄX>haVcYZg07aVX`0=^heVc^X0L]^iZ0dgDi]Zg¹h]djaYcdiWZ^ciZgegZiZYVhWZ^c\ hX^Zci^ÄXdgVci]gdedad\^XVa^ccVijgZ#º Bdhi[dgZch^XVeea^XVi^dchWg^c\i]Z]jbVcdhiZdad\^hi^cidXdciVXil^i]bZY^" XVaZmVb^cZgh!aVlZc[dgXZbZci!dgdi]Zg\dkZgcbZcieZghdccZal]dZmeZXib^hh^c\ VcY$dg[djcYeZghdchidWZXaVhh^ÄZY^ciZgbhd[i]Z^gWjgZVjXgVi^XgVXZhVhYZÄcZY Wni]Z\dkZgcbZci#I]ZhZgVX^VaXViZ\dg^Zh!d[XdjghZ!b^m]^hidg^XVaVcYhdX^Vae]Z" cdbZcVl^i]W^dad\n#<^aa&..*egdk^YZhVcZmVbeaZd[i]^hWned^ci^c\djii]Vi^c i]ZJc^iZYHiViZh!VeZghdcl]d^hd[,*:jgdeZVcYZhXZci!Wji]VhVWaVX`6[g^XVc \gVcYeVgZci^hXdch^YZgZYWaVX`gVi]Zgi]Vcl]^iZ#IdYVn!^i^hXdbbdc[dgeVgZcihd[ XdbeaZiZanY^[[ZgZci\Zd\gVe]^XVcXZhignid]VkZX]^aYgZcl]dhZVcVidb^XVaXdcÄ\j" gVi^dchl^aaYZ[nVhhZhhbZcid[VcXZhign#=dlYdZhi]ZdhiZdad\^hiYZVal^i]i]ZhZhdX^Va VcYW^dad\^XVagZVa^i^Zh4 I]ZdhiZdad\^hi¼hgdaZ!eVgi^XjaVgan^ci]Z[dgZch^XhZii^c\!^hd[iZcid^cY^k^YjVa^oZ Vcjc`cdlc¼hdhiZdad\^XVagZbV^chWnVhhZhh^c\i]ZV\Z!hZm!hiVijgZ!VcYgVXZd[i]Z ^cY^k^YjVa#I]ZVW^a^inidYZiZgb^cZi]Z\Zd\gVe]^XVcXZhignd[Vh`ZaZiVajc`cdlc^h jhZ[ja[dgcVggdl^c\i]Zedhh^W^a^i^ZhVcYaZVY^c\idVedh^i^kZ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc^cbVcn XVhZh#NZiVhVW^dad\^XVahX^Zci^hi!i]Z]jbVcdhiZdad\^hi`cdlhi]ViVaakVg^Vi^dc^h Xdci^cjdjh!cdiY^hXgZiZ#6h@ZccZYn&..*cdiZh!i]ZgZ^hVeVgVYdm^ci]ZhX^Zci^ÄX gZ_ZXi^dcd[¹gVXZºVcY^ihhjgk^kVa^cbZY^Xd"aZ\VaXdciZmih#6h@ZccZYnhVnh&..*!e# ,.-!¹;dgZch^XVci]gdedad\^hihVgZ`ZZcanVlVgZi]VicZ^i]Zgi]ZbZY^XVaZmVb^cZg! i]Z _jY\Z! i]Z ViidgcZn Xa^Zci cdg i]Z h]Zg^[[ ldjaY VeegZX^ViZ V aZXijgZ dc i]Z ]^h" idgnd[i]ZgVXZXdcXZei^cLZhiZgci]dj\]i#I]ZhZegd[Zhh^dcVahlVciidaZVgc^[i]Z h`ZaZidcdcdjgaVWdgVidgniVWaZ^hVeZghdcd[7aVX`!L]^iZ!6h^VcdgCVi^kZ6bZg^XVc VcXZhign#ºIdXdcYjXiVcVanh^hd[VcXZhigVaWVX`\gdjcY!i]ZdhiZdad\^hibVnjhZdhiZd" ad\^XVaigV^ih`cdlcidkVgnVbdc\Y^[[ZgZci]jbVcedejaVi^dch^cY^[[ZgZcieVgihd[ i]ZldgaY# 6h7gVXZ&..*!e#&,'ZmeaV^ch!¹H`ZaZiVaVcVanh^hegdk^YZhcdY^gZXiZk^YZcXZ[dg &.#+:hi^bVi^dcd[6cXZhign

)%&

h`^cXdadg[dgZmVbeaZ!Wji^iYdZhVaadlVcVXXjgViZZhi^bViZd[dg^\^cVa\Zd\gVe]^XVa dg^\^ch#6[g^XVc!ZVhiZgc6h^Vc!VcY:jgdeZVcVcXZhignXVcWZheZX^ÄZYl^i]V]^\] YZ\gZZd[VXXjgVXn#6[g^XVd[XdjghZZciV^ah»WaVX`!¼Wji»WaVX`¼YdZhcdiZciV^a6[g^XVc#º BVg`h&..+cdiZhi]Vii]ZiZcYZcXn[dg6bZg^XVchidXaVhh^[neZdeaZ^ci]gZZgVXZh^h VcVgi^[VXid[]^hidgnVcYhiVi^hi^Xh¸^bb^\gVcihidCdgi]6bZg^XV]VkZXdbZbdhian [gdbedgihl]ZgZhZV[Vg^c\kZhhZah^cZVga^ZgXZcijg^ZhXdjaYe^X`i]Zbje#=ZcXZ!i]Z 6bZg^XVccdi^dcd[¹WaVX`º^hVXijVaanlZhi6[g^XVc!VcYi]Zcdi^dcd[¹6h^Vcº^hVXij" VaanZVhi6h^Vc#EZdeaZ[gdbhdji]6h^V>cY^VVcYEV`^hiVc¸eZdeaZl^i]YVg`Zgh`^ch VcY[VX^VagZhZbWaVcXZhid:jgdeZVch^bb^\gViZY^chbVaaZgcjbWZghVcYi]ZgZ[dgZ Y^YcdibZg^iVhbjX]WjgZVjXgVi^XXdcXZgc# 6gZVaZmVbeaZd[i]ZY^aZbbV[VX^c\]jbVcdhiZdad\^hih^ci]ZVgZVd[¹gVX^Vaº ^YZci^ÄXVi^dcXdbZh[gdbi]Zldg`d[@VioVcYHjX]Zn&.-.dci]Z^ghVbeaZd[Adh 6c\ZaZhbVaZejW^Xhnbe]nhZh#I]ZhZldg`Zgh!^cVeVeZgZci^iaZY¹GVXZ9^[[ZgZcXZh^c EjW^XHnbe]nhZVa6\^c\EViiZgch^ci]ZBVaZ!ºVhhZhhi]ZAdh6c\ZaZh8djcin8dgdcZg hVbeaZjhZYid\ZcZgViZi]ZHjX]Zn"7gdd`hhnhiZbd[hnbe]nhZVaV\^c\hZZhZXi^dc &.#(#+#I]ZnhZ\gZ\ViZYi]Zhnbe]nhZh^cid¹gVX^VaºXViZ\dg^Zh#I]ZnY^YcdijhZi]Z 8Va^[dgc^VYZVi]XZgi^ÄXViZhbVYZdjiWnXdgdcZg^ckZhi^\Vidgh#6h@VioVcYHjX]Zn cdiZ!i]ZhZZmVb^cZghjhZYcdcjc^[dgbb^mijgZhd[W^dad\^XVa!XjaijgVa!VcYa^c\j^hi^X kVg^VWaZh ^c i]Z^g YZiZgb^cVi^dch# GVi]Zg! HjX]Zn Y^k^YZY i]Z Vjideh^ZY ^cY^k^YjVah ^cid)-+L]^iZh!&)%7aVX`h!VcY,-BZm^XVchVcYcdiZYi]Vi]ZgBZm^XVcXViZ\dgn^h VXViZ\dgnh]dl^c\BZm^XVcVcXZhignXdjeaZYl^i]Vhigdc\6bZg^XVc>cY^VcgVX^Va XdbedcZci#@VioVcYHjX]Zn[djcYi]ViejW^Xhnbe]nhZVabZiVbdge]dh^hlVhVXXZa" ZgViZY^c7aVX`hVcYBZm^XVch!Wjii]ZnXdjaYcdiVYYgZhhi]Z^hhjZd[XVjhVa^in# L]Zc9C6XVcWZZmigVXiZY[gdbVhjW_ZXi¼hdhiZdad\^XVagZbV^ch!VXXjgViZYZiZg" b^cVi^dc d[ i]Z VcXZhigVa edejaVi^dc VcY ZkZc [Vb^a^Va gZaVi^dch]^eh WZXdbZh edh" h^WaZ#9C6ine^c\d[h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch]Vhi]ZediZci^Vaidegdk^YZi]ZWZhiVkV^aVWaZ ^c[dgbVi^dc gZ\VgY^c\ i]Z edejaVi^dcVa V[Äc^in d[ i]Z ^cY^k^YjVa# B^idX]dcYg^Va 9C6bi9C6^hVhbVaaedgi^dcd[i]Z]jbVc\ZcdbZi]Vi^h^c]Zg^iZYdcan[gdb i]Zbdi]Zg#HZkZgVagZ\^dchd[bi9C6VgZ]^\]ankVg^VWaZl^i]^cbdYZgc]jbVch! VcYi]ZhZfjZcX^c\d[i]ZhZgZ\^dchXVceZgb^ii]ZZhi^bVi^dcd[i]ZVcXZhigVabV" iZgcVa edejaVi^dc 8dccdg VcY HidcZ`^c\! &..)# 6gX]Zdad\^XVaan! i]ZhZ iZX]c^fjZh ]VkZWZZcjhZYidVhhZhhi]ZgZaVi^dch]^ehd[egZ]^hidg^XCZlLdgaYedejaVi^dchl^i] kVg^djhbdYZgcCVi^kZ6bZg^XVc\gdjehHidcZVcYHidcZ`^c\!&..(0=Vjhl^gi]ZiVa#! &..)0@VZhiaZ!&..*#;dgZch^XVaan!i]ZVcVanh^hd[bi9C6]VhWZZcjhZYid]Zae^YZc" i^[ni]ZgZbV^chd[J#H#b^a^iVgneZghdccZa^cK^ZicVb=daaVcYZiVa#!&..(# L]ZgZVhbdaZXjaVgVcYhd[ii^hhjZX]VgVXiZg^hi^XhhjX]Vhh`^cXdadg!]V^g[dgb!VcY [VX^Va[ZVijgZhd[iZcVaadljcVbW^\jdjhViig^Wji^dcd[\Zd\gVe]^XVcXZhignVbdc\a^k" ^c\eZdeaZ!i]Z]VgYi^hhjZhY^heaVnaZhh"gZa^VWaZh^\cVijgZhd[V[Äc^in#I]ZgZVgZ!^c[VXi! cd]jbVch`ZaZiVabVg`Zghi]ViXdggZhedcYeZg[ZXianid\Zd\gVe]^Xdg^\^c#I]ZegdW" aZbh^cjh^c\Y^hXgZiZXgVc^VaVcYYZciVa[ZVijgZhidYZiZgb^cZVcXZhignVgZeZg]Veh WZhiVeegZX^ViZYWnXdch^YZg^c\l]VibdhidhiZdad\^hihV\gZZ^hVgVX^VabVg`Zg/i]Z h]dkZa"h]VeZY^cX^hdghhZZc^c]^\][gZfjZcXn^cbdYZgc6h^VcedejaVi^dch#6gZk^Zl VcYXdbe^aVi^dcd[YViVdc^cX^hdgh]dkZa^c\WnB^od\jX]^&.-*h]dll^YZgVc\Zh d[ZmegZhh^k^inVcY^cX^YZcXZkVajZh^cY^[[ZgZciZmiVci]jbVc\gdjeh#Hj[ÄXZ^iidhVn i]Vi^cX^hdgh[gdb6h^VcedejaVi^dchh]dlV]^\]^cX^YZcXZd[h]dkZa^c\!WjiVahdi]Vi i]ZegZhZcXZd[h]dkZaZY^cX^hdgh^h]VgYan\gdjcYh[dgXdcÄYZci^YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[V YZci^i^dcVh6h^Vc# 

8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

I]Zh`jaa^hi]ZdcaneVgid[i]Zh`ZaZidci]Vi^hl^YZanjhZY^cZhi^bVi^c\\Zd" # \gVe]^XVcXZhignPWjihZZ>h¨XVcVcY8diidc&.-*[dgVXdch^YZgVi^dcd[i]ZeZak^hVh VgVX^Va^cY^XVidgVcY7V`ZgZiVa#&..%!IgjYZaa&...!VcY<^aa'%%&[dg[ZbdgVa iZX]c^fjZh# =daa^YVn Zi Va# &... egdk^YZ V Y^hXg^b^cVci [jcXi^dc [dg bjai^eaZ ZaZ" bZcihR#:kZcl^i]i]^hZaZbZci!Vaaldg`ZghV\gZZi]VigVX^VaZhi^bVi^dchVgZjhjVaan bdgZ Y^[ÄXjai! aZhh egZX^hZ! VcY aZhh gZa^VWaZ i]Vc Zhi^bVi^dch d[ V\Z! hZm! dg hiVijgZ# 9Zhe^iZYZXVYZhd[gZhZVgX]!bjX]bdgZdhiZdad\^XValdg`dc\Zd\gVe]^XY^[[ZgZci^V" i^dcl^i]^c=dbdhVe^ZchgZbV^chidWZYdcZVcY^hjg\ZciancZZYZY#Ldg`dcbdYZgc h`jaahd[`cdlcdg^\^c]VhgZkZVaZYXZgiV^ciZcYZcX^Zh# =dlZaah&..*cdiZhi]Vii]Z]jbVcheZX^ZhaVX`hlZaa"YZÄcZYhjWheZX^ZhWji]Vh XaZVgadXVaiZcYZcX^Zhd[kVg^Vi^dc#>i^hh^beancdiedhh^WaZidViig^WjiZZkZgn]jbVc XgVc^jbiddcZdgVcdi]Zg\Zd\gVe]^XVaanYZÄcZY\gdjedci]ZWVh^hd[^ihbdge]da" d\n dg bZVhjgZbZcih¸edejaVi^dch d[ i]Z ]jbVc heZX^Zh VgZ bdge]dad\^XVaan idd Xdci^cjdjh[dgi]^h#=dlZaahXdcYjXiZYZm]Vjhi^kZVcYadc\"iZgbhijY^ZhdcVhZaZXiZY hVbeaZd['*%)]jbVcXgVc^V[gdbVgdjcYi]ZldgaY#=ZjhZY*,bZVhjgZbZcihdc ZVX]h`jaaVcYZbeadnZYbjai^kVg^ViZhiVi^hi^XVaiZX]c^fjZhVcYVXdbejiZgidh]dl XaZVgani]Vi]jbVckVg^Vi^dc^cXgVc^Vah]VeZ!VhgZegZhZciZYWn]^hbZVhjgZbZcih!^h eViiZgcZYVcYi]Vi¹iVg\Ziºh`jaahd[jc`cdlcV[Äc^inXdjaYd[iZcWZjcVbW^\jdjhan eaVXZY^cVeVgZci¹edejaVi^dc#º 8dbeVgZYidedejaVi^dchd[6[g^XVcdg:jgdeZVcdg^\^c!6h^VcedejaVi^dchY^heaVn h`jaahX]VgVXiZg^oZYWncVggdl!XdcXVkZcVhVaWdcZh!egdb^cZciX]ZZ`WdcZh!X^gXjaVg dgW^ih!VcYh]dkZaZY^cX^hdgh#8dbeVgZYid6h^VchVcY:jgdeZVch!6[g^XVcXgVc^V]VkZ WZZcX]VgVXiZg^oZYVhh]dl^c\l^YZ^ciZgdgW^iVaY^hiVcXZh!gZXiVc\jaVgdgW^ih!WgdVY cVhVaVeZgijgZhl^i]eddg^c[Zg^dgYZÄc^i^dc!\gVX^aZXgVc^VahjeZghigjXijgZh!VcYegd" cdjcXZYidiVa[VX^VaVcYVakZdaVgegd\cVi]^hb#:jgdeZVcXgVc^V]VkZWZZcX]VgVXiZg" ^oZYVhY^heaVn^c\cVggdlcVhVaVeZgijgZhl^i]h]Vge^c[Zg^dgWdgYZghh^aah!egdb^cZci cVhVahe^cZh!]ZVkn\aVWZaaVgVcYhjegVdgW^iVagZ\^dch!gZXZY^c\X]ZZ`WdcZh!VcYaVg\Z! egdb^cZcicVhVaWdcZh# <^kZci]Za^b^iVi^dchd[jh^c\hjX]hjW_ZXi^kZXg^iZg^V[dggZXd\c^o^c\\Zd\gVe]^" XVaVcXZhign!hdbZ]VkZijgcZYidXgVc^VabZig^XbZi]dYh[dgi]ZVhhZhhbZcid[gVX^Va hiVijh<^aZhVcY:aa^di!&.+'0=dlZaah!&.+.W#DcZhjX]ViiZbei^hi]Vid[<^aa&.-)! &.-+!l]^X]VYYgZhhZhi]ZegdWaZbd[hdgi^c\:jgdeZVc[gdbCVi^kZ6bZg^XVcXgVc^V# <^aa &..* egdk^YZh V XdbeZcY^jb d[ igV^ih jhZ[ja ^c VhhZhh^c\ VcXZhign ^c Vc 6bZg^XVcXdciZmi^c]^hVgi^XaZ¹8]VaaZc\Zdci]Z;gdci^Zg/9^hXZgc^c\6bZg^XVc>c" Y^Vch[gdbL]^iZhDhiZdad\^XVaan#º=ZcdiZhi]Vii]Z<^aZh":aa^diY^hXg^b^cVci[jcX" i^dcVeegdVX]]VhWZZch]dlcidWZ^cZ[[ZXi^kZVihdgi^c\XgVc^V!eVgi^XjaVgan^ci]Z Cdgi]lZhiZgcEaV^chVgZVl]ZgZ]Zldg`h^cWdi][dgZch^XVcYVgX]Zdad\^XVaXdciZmih# <^aaXdch^YZghgVXZhidWZhiVi^hi^XVaVWhigVXi^dchd[igV^iXdbeaZmZh!cdiejgZZci^i^Zhdg g^\^YanYZÄcVWaZineZh#IVWaZ&.#)^hVa^hid[jhZ[jacdcbZig^XigV^ihd[i]ZYZci^i^dc VcYXgVc^jbiV`Zc[gdb]^heVeZg#HZZInggZaa'%%%[dgVcdi]ZgXdch^YZgVi^dcVcY :Y\Vg'%%*[dgVXdch^YZgVi^dcd[gVX^VaegZY^Xi^dc[gdbYZciVaVcVidbn# I]ZViiZci^dccdlWZ^c\\^kZcidi]Zdg^\^cd[VcVidb^XVaanbdYZgc=dbdhVe^Zch ^ci]ZaViZgEaZ^hidXZcZBZaaVghVcYHig^c\Zg!&.-.0L]^iZZiVa#!'%%(h]djaYhi^bjaViZ bdgZldg`dch`ZaZiVaY^[[ZgZci^Vi^dcl^i]^c\Zd\gVe]^XVaanhZeVgViZYedejaVi^dchd[ i]ZheZX^Zh#BZVcl]^aZ!Vaad[i]ZiZX]c^fjZhcdiZY]ZgZ!Wdi]k^hjVaVcYbZig^X!h]djaY WZVeea^ZYdcandcVYjaigZbV^chVcYl^i]XdbeVgVi^kZbViZg^Va#HZZ<^aa&.-+!@gd\" # # bVcVcY>h¨XVc&.-+!VcY>h¨XVc&.--[dg[jgi]ZgY^hXjhh^dchdci]^hide^X# &.#,>YZci^[n^c\i]Z>cY^k^YjVa

)%(

4ABLE JhZ[jaCdcbZig^XIgV^ih^c9ZiZgb^c^c\6cXZhign7VhZYdci]Z8gVc^jb 

¹6bZg^XVc>cY^Vchº

>cX^hdgh h]dkZa"h]VeZY On\dbVi^Xh gdWjhi!ÅVg^c\ Egd\cVi]^hb bdYZgViZ EVaViZ Zaa^ei^X 8gVc^VahjijgZh XdbeaZm CVhVahe^cZ bZY^jb!¹i^aiZYº 8]^c Wajci!bZY^Vc 6hXZcY^c\gVbjh l^YZ!kZgi^XVa EVaVi^cZhjijgZ higV^\]i On\dbVi^XijWZgXaZ egZhZci >cX^hdggdiVi^dc egZhZci CVhVaegdÉaZ XdcXVkd"XdckZm HV\^iiVaVgX] adl!hade^c\ Ldgb^VcWdcZh egZhZci CVhVah adl!iZciZY CVhVaVeZgijgZ bZY^jb On\dbVi^XdbVm^aaVgn hjijgZ Vc\aZY 9Zci^i^dc  CVhVah^aa  CVh^dc  8gVc^VakVjai  BVcY^WaZ  >c^dc]dd`  EdhiWgZ\bVi^XYZegZhh^dc

¹L]^iZhº WaVYZ"[dgb hbVaa!gZigZVi^c\ kZgna^b^iZY eVgVWda^X h^beaZ adc\!aVg\Z hfjVgZ!W^aViZgVa!egd_ZXi^c\  _V\\ZY

¹7aVX`hº WaVYZ"[dgb bVg`ZYVakZdaVg[VX^Va ]neZgWda^X h^beaZ hbVaa Wajci!bZY^Vc!gZigZVi^c\ cVggdl!dWa^fjZ VgX]ZY

higV^\]i

]^\]anVgX]ZY!hiZZeaZa^`Z 

adl!ÅVi l^YZ

XjgkZY hbVaa!XgdlYZY kZgnh]Vge YZegZhhZY ]^\] Xjee^c\WZadl^cX^hdgh egZhZci 

XjgkZY aVg\ZbdaVgh kZgnYjaadgVWhZci adl

egZhZci

;gdbG]^cZ&..%VcY<^aa&..*#

)DENTIFYINGTHE)NDIVIDUAL >ceVaZdcidad\^XVaVcYegZ]^hidg^XVgX]Zdad\^XVaXdciZmih![dhh^ahVgZhdbZi^bZh\^kZc c^X`cVbZha^`Z»9ZVg7dn¼dg»AjXn!¼WjilZl^aacZkZg`cdl]dlbZbWZghd[i]Z^g dlcheZX^Zh^YZci^ÄZYi]Zb#>c]^hidg^XVgX]Zdad\^XVaXdciZmih!^i^hedhh^WaZi]Vih`ZaZ" iVagZbV^chbVnWZ^YZci^ÄZYVhjc^fjZ^cY^k^YjVah!hjX]VhcVbZY:\nei^Vce]VgVd]h dgeZdeaZWjg^ZYWZcZVi]]ZVYhidcZh^c]^hidg^XXZbZiZg^Zh#>ci]Z[dgZch^XgZVab!i]Z ]jbVcdhiZdad\^hi^hd[iZcegZhZciZYl^i]jc^YZci^ÄZYh`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#I]Zedh^i^kZ ^YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch¸i]ZjcZfj^kdXVabViX]^c\d[iZZi]!XgVc^V! dgedhiXgVc^VagZbV^chl^i]jc^fjZ!cVbZY^cY^k^YjVah¸^hd[iZci]Zbdhi^bedgiVci hiZe^ci]ZVcVanh^h#I]Z^YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[V\Z!hZm!hiVijgZ!VcYVcXZhignVaacVggdli]Z l^cYdlhd[edhh^WaZ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc¸edhh^WaZbViX]^c\ ¸id`cdlc^cY^k^YjVahd[iZc b^hh^c\dgjcVXXdjciZY[dg#I]ZaVhihiZe^ci]ZegdXZhhd[^YZci^ÄXVi^dchdbZi^bZh ^ckdakZhbViX]^c\jc^fjZ[ZVijgZhd[i]Z¹jc`cdlcºh`ZaZidcl^i]jc^fjZX]VgVXiZgh d[i]Z¹`cdlcºb^hh^c\# 

8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

9C6VcVanh^h^hi]ZWZhibZi]dY[dgiZhi^c\]nedi]ZhZhVWdjii]Z^YZci^ind[h`ZaZ" iVagZbV^ch#I]Z\ZcZgVaVeegdVX]^hidXdbeVgZ9C6[gdbi]Zh`ZaZidcl^i]i]Z9C6 d[i]ZegZhjbZYgZaVi^kZh#;dgVcjbWZgd[kVg^VWaZgZ\^dchd[i]Z9C6!i]ZdYYhd[V bViX]WZilZZcjcgZaViZY^cY^k^YjVahVgZZmigZbZanadl#:mVXian]dladl^hVbViiZgd[ YZWViZ[dgXVhZh^ckdak^c\WaddYhVbeaZh[gdba^k^c\^cY^k^YjVah9Zka^cZiVa#!&..)! Wji^cdhiZdad\^XVaXdciZmihi]^h^hgVgZan!^[ZkZg!VXdcXZgc#9C6ine^c\]VhWZZcjhZY id^YZci^[nh`ZaZidc^oZY^cY^k^YjVah^cXdciZmih^ckdak^c\bVhhYZVi]hi]Z7gVcX]9V" k^Y^Vc^cX^YZci^cLVXd!IZmVh/=djX`ZiVa#!&..+!bVhh\gVkZh<jViZbVaVVcY[dg" bZgNj\dhaVk^V/7daZhZiVa#!&..*0Eg^bdgVXZiVa#!&..+!gZbV^chd[b^a^iVgneZghdccZa K^ZicVb/=daaVcYZiVa#!&..(!lVgXg^b^cVah?dhZ[BZc\ZaZ/?Z[[gZnhZiVa#!&..'!VcY cjbZgdjh[dgZch^XXVhZh^ckdak^c\bjgYZgk^Xi^bhZ#\#!=V\ZaWZg\ZiVa#!&..&0HlZZi VcY HlZZi! &..*# :kZc i]dj\] i]Z YZiZgb^cVi^dc d[ [Vb^a^Va gZaVi^dch]^eh ^h bdhi Veea^XVWaZ^c[dgZch^Xdg]^hidg^XVaXdciZmih!VgX]Zdad\^XVaVcVanh^hd[bdgijVgng^ijVah VcYWjg^VaegVXi^XZhXVcd[iZcWZVYkVcXZY^[i]Z\ZcZgVagZaVi^dch]^ehd[i]Z^ciZggZY ^cY^k^YjVahXVcWZZhiVWa^h]ZYHidcZVcYHidcZ`^c\!&..(#:hiVWa^h]^c\i]Z[Vb^a^Va gZaVi^dch]^ehWZilZZc^cY^k^YjVah^ci]ZhVbZegZ]^hidg^XedejaVi^dcgZfj^gZhbdgZ YZiV^aZYVcVanh^hi]Vc^hjhjVaanViiZbeiZY# >YZci^ÄXVi^dcVii]ZheZX^ZhaZkZa!hdbZi^bZhVegdWaZbl^i]ZmigZbZan[gV\bZc" iVgngZbV^ch!^hVahdbVYZedhh^WaZi]gdj\]9C6VcVanh^h#=dlZkZg!i]ZYZiZgb^cV" i^dcd[l]Zi]Zg[gV\bZciVgnh`ZaZiVagZbV^chVgZ]jbVcdgcdc]jbVcXVcjhjVaan WZYdcZfj^X`an!X]ZVean!VcYVXXjgViZanWnk^hjVa^cheZXi^dcd[i]Zbdge]dad\n!gZc" YZg^c\9C6VcVanh^hjccZXZhhVgn[dgi]^hfjZhi^dc^cbdhidhiZdad\^XVaXdciZmih#>c eVaZdcidad\^XVahZii^c\h!i]dj\]!bdge]dad\^XVabZi]dYh[dgYZiZgb^c^c\i]ZheZX^Zh V[Äa^Vi^dcd[]db^c^Y[dhh^ahd[iZcegdYjXZVbW^\jdjhgZhjaih#>ci]ZXVhZd[CZVc" YZgi]Vah![dgZmVbeaZ!eVaZdVci]gdedad\^hihY^hV\gZZVhidl]Zi]Zgi]ZgZlVh\ZcZÅdl WZilZZcCZVcYZgi]VahVcYXdciZbedgVcZdjhZVganbdYZgc]jbVch#6XdbeVg^hdcd[ CZVcYZgi]Va9C6l^i]i]Z9C6d[ZVganbdYZgc]jbVchldjaYegdk^YZVXgjX^Va iZhid[]nedi]ZhZhVWdjii]Z^ggZaVi^dch#I]ZÄghihiZe^ci]^hlVhiV`ZcWn@g^c\hZi Va# &..,! l]d hjXXZhh[jaan gZig^ZkZY V edgi^dc d[ i]Z bi9C6 [gdb V CZVcYZgi]Va ]jbZgjh#I]^hgZhjailVhgZea^XViZY^cVcdi]ZgaVWdgVidgn!VcYi]ZhZfjZcXZdWiV^cZY ^hfj^iZY^hi^cXi[gdbVcn`cdlcbdYZgc]jbVchZfjZcXZ#:kZci]dj\]i]ZegdXZhhZh d[ [dhh^a^oVi^dc VcY 9C6 YZ\gVYVi^dc egZXajYZ i]Z Veea^XVi^dc d[ 9C6 iZX]c^fjZh id bdhi d[ i]Z [dhh^a gZXdgY! fjZhi^dch VWdji heZX^Zh VcY Zkdaji^dcVgn gZaVi^dch]^eh l^i]^ci]ZaVhi[Zl]jcYgZYi]djhVcYnZVghbVnWZVYYgZhhZYjh^c\i]^hbZi]dY# ;^c\Zgeg^ciVcVanh^h!d[XdjghZ!^hVbZVchWnl]^X][dgZch^XheZX^Va^hihgdji^cZan bViX]Xg^b^cVahl^i]i]Z^gXg^bZh#6hi]Zhd[ii^hhjZ[ZVijgZhd[i]ZWdYnYZXVndgVgZ ^cX^cZgViZY!]dlZkZg!i]ZjhZd[Äc\Zgeg^cih!]V^g!VcYeZghdcVa^iZbhid^cY^k^YjViZ i]ZYZXZVhZYWZXdbZh^bedhh^WaZ#IZZi]!i]Zh`ZaZiVahigjXijgZhbdhigZh^hiVciidhjX] YZhigjXi^dc!VgZd[iZcjhZYid^YZci^[neZdeaZ^cbVhhY^hVhiZgh#HjX]^cY^k^YjVi^dck^V iZZi]VcYi]Z^gbdY^ÄXVi^dch!jhjVaanWnYZci^hih!]VhigVY^i^dcVaanWZZcVXXdbea^h]ZY WnV_bU^cYS_T_^d_\_WYcdc!heZX^VaanigV^cZYZmeZgihVXXdbea^h]ZYVihjX]^YZci^ÄXV" i^dch#GVY^d\gVe]hVcYdi]ZgYZciVagZXdgYh`ZeiWnYZci^hihVgZbViX]ZYV\V^chibdY" ^ÄXVi^dchdci]ZYZXZVhZY¼hiZZi]!d[iZcgZhjai^c\^cVedh^i^kZ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc@d\dcVcY BVXAZVc!&..+# 6cdi]ZgbZVchd[ZhiVWa^h]^c\Vedh^i^kZ^YZci^ÄXVi^dcdcjc`cdlch`ZaZiVagZ" bV^ch^hi]ZXdbeVg^hdcd[i]dhZgZbV^chl^i]bZY^XVagVY^d\gVe]hiV`Zcl]Zci]Z ^cY^k^YjValVhVa^kZ#;gVXijgZh!d[XdjghZ!XVc]ZVa!Wjii]ZgZVgZd[iZcigVWZXjaVgVcY &.#,>YZci^[n^c\i]Z>cY^k^YjVa

)%*

Xdgi^XVaed^cihd[^YZci^ini]gdj\]l]^X]Vedh^i^kZ^YZci^ÄXVi^dcXVcWZZhiVWa^h]ZY# EdhiXgVc^Vah`ZaZiVaX]VgVXiZghDlhaZnVcYBVcc!&..'0@V]VcVZiVa#!&..-VcY[gdc" iVah^cjhbdge]dad\nJWZaV`Zg!&.-)0@^g`ZiVa#!'%%'0Hb^i]ZiVa#!'%%'08]g^hiZchZc! '%%)]VkZWZZch]dlcidWZ^cY^k^YjVaanheZX^ÄX#I]ZhjXXZhhd[gVY^d\gVe]^X^YZc" i^ÄXVi^dcd[jc`cdlc]jbVcgZbV^ch!a^`Zi]Vid[bVcndi]ZgiZX]c^fjZh^c]jbVc dhiZdad\n!YZeZcYhdci]ZZmeZg^ZcXZd[i]Z^ciZgegZiZg#=d\\ZZiVa#&..)h]dlZYi]Vi i]Z bdhi"VXXjgViZ ^YZci^ÄXVi^dch XVbZ [gdb XgVc^Va gZbV^ch VcY i]Z XZgk^XVa he^cZ VcYX]Zhi!l]ZgZVhi]ZaZVhi"VXXjgViZ^YZci^ÄXVi^dchlZgZbVYZdci]ZadlZgaZ\# BdgZ gZXZcian! iZX]c^fjZh i]Vi hjeZg^bedhZ i]Z h`jaa d[ Vc jc`cdlc YZXZVhZY ^cY^k^YjVadcdaYe]did\gVe]h!bdi^dce^XijgZh!dgk^YZdiVeZh]VkZWZZcYZkZadeZY # >h¨XVcVcY=ZabZg!&..(#6jhi^c"Hb^i]VcYBVeaZh&..)]VkZiZhiZYi]ZgZa^VW^a^in d[hjX]hjeZg^bedh^i^dcbZi]dYhVcYegdk^YZV\ddYgZk^Zld[i]ZiZX]c^fjZh!a^b^iV" i^dch!VcYhjXXZhhZh#L]ZcVciZg^dgYZci^i^dc^hgZXdkZgZYl^i]i]Zh`jaaVcYVhb^a^c\ e]did\gVe]l^i]i]ZiZZi]^c[dXjh^hVkV^aVWaZ!i]Zh]VeZhd[^cY^k^YjVaiZZi]VcYi]Z^g gZaVi^kZedh^i^dchVgZd[iZcY^hi^cXi^kZZcdj\][dgVc^YZci^ÄXVi^dcidWZbVYZ#Jh^c\ dcandcZe]did\gVe]!6jhi^c"Hb^i]VcYBVeaZh[djcYV.X]VcXZd[[VahZ^YZci^ÄXV" i^dc!Wjil]Zcilde]did\gVe]hgZegZhZci^c\VY^[[ZgZcXZd[VWdji.%•^ci]ZVc\aZd[ i]Z[VXZidi]ZXVbZgVlZgZjhZY[dghjeZg^bedh^i^dc!i]ZX]VcXZd[[VahZ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc YgdeeZYidaZhhi]Vc&# 6ÄcVabZVchd[eZghdcVa^YZci^ÄXVi^dcWVhZYdch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch^ckdakZh[dgZch^X i]gZZ"Y^bZch^dcVa[VX^VagZXdchigjXi^dc#6hZg^Zhd[iZX]c^fjZhZm^hih[dgi]Z¹gZhidgV" # i^dcºd[i]Zhd[ii^hhjZXdkZgd[V]jbVch`jaa>h¨XVcVcY=ZabZg!&..(0CZVkZ!'%%%# 6gZXZcigZk^Zld[i]Z]^hidgnd[YZkZadebZciVcYXjggZcihiVijhd[hjX]iZX]c^fjZh Wn InggZaa VcY XdaaZV\jZh &.., cdiZh i]Vi [VX^Va gZXdchigjXi^dc hi^aa hiVcYh dc i]Z i]gZh]daYWZilZZcVgiVcYhX^ZcXZ#I]ZhZVji]dghXdcXajYZi]ViXjggZcibZi]dYhVgZ jhZ[ja! Wji ^chj[ÄX^Zcian gZa^VWaZ id hZgkZ Vh Zk^YZcXZ d[ edh^i^kZ ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc ^c V Xdjgi d[ aVl# 8aZbZci VcY GVchdc &..- egdk^YZ V WgdVY dkZgk^Zl d[ XgVc^d[VX^Va ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc^c[dgZch^Xldg`VcY9Z
$ISCRETE4RAITS DcZd[i]ZÄghiVcYbdhi^bedgiVcidWhZgkVi^dchi]ViZkZgndhiZdad\nhijYZcibV`Zh ^hi]ViZVX]]jbVch`jaa^hY^[[ZgZci[gdbZkZgndi]Zg]jbVch`jaaVcYXVcWZgZX" d\c^oZYVcYY^[[ZgZci^ViZYdci]ZWVh^hd[h^oZ!h]VeZ!VcYkVg^djhWjbeh!\gddkZh![d" gVb^cV!dghjg[VXZiZmijgZh#BjX]d[i]^hkVg^Vi^dcbVnWZeVgi^i^dcZYVXXdgY^c\idi]Z [VXidghgZhedch^WaZ[dg^i¸V\Z!\ZcYZg!VcYeVi]dad\n#=dlZkZg!bjX]d[i]ZkVg^Vi^dc ^h^Y^dhncXgVi^XVcYhdbZd[^i^hViig^WjiVWaZidVcXZhign# B^cdgkVg^Vcihd[i]Z]jbVch`ZaZidclZgZcdiZYWni]ZVcX^Zci
8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

Gdh^c\&.-)egdk^YZhVXdcX^hZ!Xg^i^XVagZk^Zld[i]ZjhZd[cdcbZig^Xh`ZaZiVaigV^ih! XdcXajY^c\i]VihiVcYVgYh[dgi]Z^gYZiZgb^cVi^dcVgZeddgdgaVX`^c\# 6ai]dj\]Vaad[i]ZaVWZahVeea^ZYidcdcbZig^XkVg^Vi^dc^beani]Vi^i^hY^hXgZiZ! i]^h^hcdicZXZhhVg^ani]ZXVhZ#6hB^od\jX]^&.-*ed^cihdji!^i^hgVgZi]VicdcbZi" g^X¹igV^ihºVgZgZVaanY^hXdci^cjdjhVcYY^hXgZiZ!ZkZci]dj\]i]ZnVgZjhjVaanhXdgZY WndhiZdad\^hih^cVcdcbZig^X[Vh]^dcZ^i]ZgVhhXdgZYkVajZhdgWnegZhZcXZ$VWhZcXZ# I]ZZmegZhh^dcd[bVcnd[i]ZigV^ihXVc!^cYZZY!WZfjVci^ÄZY#I]ZhZYZciVaVcYh`Za" ZiVacdcbZig^XigV^ihXVcWZjhZ[ja^c\Vj\^c\V[Äc^ind[Zmi^cXi]jbVcedejaVi^dch# I]Z`^cYhd[cdcbZig^XkVg^Vi^dchdbZi^bZhYZhXg^WZY^c]jbVcdhiZdad\nVcYjhZY ^cVhhZhh^c\edejaVi^dcV[Äc^inVgZ^cigdYjXZY]ZgZP[dgVbdgZXdbeaZiZgZk^Zld[ ]jbVc h`ZaZiVa cdcbZig^X igV^ih! hZZ :a"CV__Vg VcY BXL^aa^Vbh &.,-! VcY HVjc" YZgh&.-.R#HVjcYZgh&.-.Y^k^YZhY^hXgZiZigV^ih^cidZ^\]iXViZ\dg^Zh/&=neZg" dhidi^X0 ' ]nedhidi^X0 ( [dgVb^cV$XVcVah$\gddkZh0 ) hjeZgcjbZgVgn kVjai hjijgZh0 * XgVc^dWVhVa higjXijgZh0 + he^cVa higjXijgZh0 , egdb^cZci Wdcn egdXZhhZh0 VcY - [VXZikVg^Vi^dch#I]Z7j^`higVVcYJWZaV`ZgHiVcYVgYhkdajbZ&..)gZXd\c^oZhild WVh^XXViZ\dg^Zhd[h`ZaZiVacdcbZig^XigV^ihegZhZciZY^cIVWaZ&.#*#HdbZcdcbZig^X h`ZaZiVa igV^ih! hjX] Vh i]Z dkVa l^cYdl ^c i]Z b^YYaZ ZVg! ]VkZ egdkZc kVajVWaZ id [dgZch^XdhiZdad\^hih^cZhiVWa^h]^c\¹gVX^VaºV[Äc^i^Zhd[jc`cdlcXgVc^VCVeda^VcY 7^g`Wn!&..%#

$ENTAL.ONMETRIC6ARIATION 7ZXVjhZiZZi]VgZd[iZci]ZbdhiVWjcYVciZaZbZcih^cVgX]Zdad\^XVah`ZaZiVahZg^Zh VcY WZXVjhZ iddi] h^oZ VcY bdge]dad\n VgZ d[iZc bdgZ Y^gZXian i^ZY id jcYZgan^c\ \ZcZi^Xhi]VcVgZdi]ZgdhiZdad\^XVa[ZVijgZh!iZZi]]VkZWZZcZmVb^cZY^cYZiV^aVcY jhZY l^YZan ^c dhiZdad\^XVa VcVanh^h# 9ZciVa Vci]gdedad\^hih jhZ cdcbZig^X kVg^V" i^dcd[iddi]XgdlchidVhhZhhW^dad\^XVaV[Äc^in#HjeZgcjbZgVgniZZi]!XgdlcÄhhjgZ eViiZgch! Xjhe cjbWZgh! VXXZhhdgn Xgdlc [ZVijgZh! VcY gddi cjbWZg! h^oZ! VcY h]VeZ XdbW^cZl^i]VkVg^Zind[di]ZgigV^ihjcYZgi]Z]ZVY^c\d[cdcbZig^XYZciVakVg^V" i^dc#9V]aWZg\¼hXVhihd[YZciVacdcbZig^XigV^ih!VkV^aVWaZ^cbVcn]jbVcdhiZdad\n aVWdgVidg^Zh!egdk^YZYVhiVcYVgY[dgldg`^ci]^hVgZV#I]Z6g^odcVHiViZJc^kZgh^in 9ZciVa6ci]gdedad\nHnhiZb^hi]ZXjggZci!bdhil^YZanZbeadnZYhZid[hiVcYVgYh ^cYZciVaVci]gdedad\nIjgcZgZiVa#&..&0HXdiiVcYIjgcZg!&..,#;^\jgZ&.#&+^a" ajhigViZhildcdcbZig^XkVg^VcihedhhZhhZYWni]ZhVbZ^cY^k^YjVa#DXXVh^dcVaani]ZgZ ^h^chj[ÄX^ZciheVXZ^ci]Z_Vl[dgiddi]Zgjei^dc!VcYSb_gTY^WdgY]`QSdY_^d[iZZi] VgZ i]Z XdchZfjZcXZh# I]ZhZ! ^c ijgc! XVc gZhjai ^c eVi]dad\n d[ VhhdX^ViZY hd[i VcY ]VgYi^hhjZh#

#RANIAL.ONMETRIC6ARIATION 6l^YZkVg^Zind[cdcbZig^XkVg^Vcih^cVcYWZilZZci]ZWdcZhd[i]Zh`jaa]VkZWZZc jhZYidY^[[ZgZci^ViZh`jaahVcY\gdjehd[h`jaah#:a"CV__VgVcYBXL^aa^Vbh&.,-YZ" hXg^WZ[dgin"[djghjX]cdcbZig^XigV^ih!l]ZgZVh=VjhZgVcY9ZHiZ[Vcd&.-.X]VgVX" iZg^oZZ^\]in"[djg#6[ZlZmVbeaZhhj[ÄXZidh]dli]ZcVijgZd[i]ZX]VgVXiZgh^cfjZh" i^dc/egZhZcXZdgVWhZcXZd[VbZide^XhjijgZ;^\jgZ&.#&,!eVg^ZiVa[dgVb^cV!ZmigV &.#-9^hXgZiZIgV^ih

)%,

4ABLE H`ZaZiVaCdcbZig^XIgV^ih EG>B6GNIG6>IH BZide^XhjijgZ HjegVdgW^iVacdiX] HjegVdgW^iVa[dgVbZc >c[gVdgW^iVahjijgZ >c[gVdgW^iVa[dgVbZc On\dbVi^Xd"[VX^Va[dgVb^cV EVg^ZiVa[dgVbZc HjijgVaWdcZh  Ze^eiZg^XWdcZ  XdgdcVadhh^XaZ  WgZ\bVi^XWdcZ  hV\^iiVadhh^XaZ  Ve^XVaWdcZ  aVbWYd^Ydhh^XaZ  VhiZg^dc^XWdcZ  dXX^e^idbVhid^Ydhh^XaZ  eVg^ZiVacdiX]WdcZ >cXVWdcZ 8dcYnaVgXVcVa 9^k^YZY]ned\adhhVaXVcVa ;aZmjgZd[hjeZg^dghV\^iiVahjaXjh ;dgVbZcdkVaZ^cXdbeaZiZ ;dgVbZche^cdhjb^cXdbeaZiZ EiZgn\d"he^cdjhWg^Y\Z EiZgn\d"VaVgWg^Y\Z InbeVc^XYZ]^hXZcXZ 6jY^idgnZmdhidh^h BVhid^Y[dgVbZc BZciVa[dgVbZc BVcY^WjaVgidgjh Bnad]nd^YWg^Y\Z 6iaVhWg^Y\^c\ 6XXZhhdgnigVchkZghZ[dgVb^cV HZeVaVeZgijgZ

HJEEA:B:CI6AIG6>IH!8G6C>6A ;gdciVa\gddkZh :i]bd^YVa[dgVb^cV HjegVigdX]aZVgcdiX]dg[dgVbZc IgdX]aZVghe^cZ 9djWaZdXX^e^iVaXdcYnaVg[VXZi EVgVXdcYnaVgegdXZhh ?j\jaVg[dgVbZcWg^Y\^c\ E]Vgnc\ZVaijWZgXaZ 8a^cd^YWg^Y\Zhdghejgh 6XXZhhdgnaZhhZgeVaVi^cZ[dgVb^cV EVaVi^cZidgjh BVm^aaVgnidgjh GdX`ZgbVcY^WaZ HjegVbZViVae^idghe^cZ 9^k^YZYeVg^ZiVaWdcZ Dh?Vedc^Xjb BVg\^cVaijWZgXaZ HJEEA:B:CI6AIG6>IH!EDHI8G6C>6A GZigdVgi^XjaVgWg^Y\Z 6XXZhhdgnigVchkZghZ[dgVbZc8(· + KZgiZWgVacjbWZgh]^[i 6XXZhhdgnhVXgd^a^VXVgi^XjaVi^dc HjegVhXVejaVg[dgVbZcdgcdiX] 6XXZhhdgnVXgdb^VaVgi^XjaVg[VXZi Jc[jhZYVXgdb^VaZe^e]nh^h
7j^`higVVcYJWZaV`Zg&..)Y^k^YZigV^ih^cid¹eg^bVgnº[dgl]^X]i]Znegdk^YZhXdg^c\ hiVcYVgYhVcY¹hjeeaZbZciVa#ºI]Z^gHiVcYVgYhkdajbZegdk^YZh^aajhigVi^dchVcYVhiVcYVgY gZXdgY^c\[dgbgZXdbbZcYZY[dgi]ZXdbe^aVi^dcd[YViVdci]Z¹eg^bVgnºh`ZaZiVaY^hXgZiZ igV^ih!VhlZaaVhgZ[ZgZcXZhidVaad[i]ZhZX]VgVXiZgh#



8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

&IGURE9ZciVacdcbZig^XkVg^Vi^dch/h]dkZaZY^cX^hdgh#B^hY^gZXiZY!jcZgjeiZY]ZiZgd" ide^XjeeZgXVc^cZh]VkZ]ZgZgZhjaiZY^cgZiZci^dcd[i]ZYZX^YjdjhXVc^cZh#I]ZVcdbVan^h W^aViZgVa!l^i]i]ZjcZgjeiZYXVc^cZXgdlchk^h^WaZi]gdj\]]daZh^ci]ZVciZg^dghjg[VXZd[i]Z bVm^aaVZ#EgZ]^hidg^X!8Va^[dgc^V#CVijgVah^oZ#

&IGURE8gVc^VacdcbZig^XkVg^Vi^dc#6bZide^XhjijgZ]VheZgh^hiZY^cidVYjai]ddY^c i]^hbVaZ^cY^k^YjVa#EgZ]^hidg^X!Cdgi]6bZg^XV#CVijgVah^oZ#

&.#-9^hXgZiZIgV^ih

)%.

WdcZhVieiZg^dc!ldgb^VcWdcZh!bjai^eaZbZciVa[dgVb^cV!VcYbnad]nd^YWg^Y\Zh ]VkZVaaWZZcjhZY^ccdcbZig^XVcVanh^h#9ZkZadebZciVaVcdbVa^Zhd[i]Zh`jaa!hjX] Vh hXVe]dXZe]Van adc\ cVggdl h`jaah XVjhZY Wn egZbVijgZ XadhjgZ d[ i]Z hV\^iiVa hjijgZ!]VkZVahdWZZcXdch^YZgZYWnhdbZidgZegZhZcicdcbZig^XkVg^Vcih#Di]Zgh h^beanXdch^YZgi]ZbidWZYZkZadebZciVaVcdbVa^Zh#6h`ZaZiVaVcdbVan^hjhjVaan Xdch^YZgZYidWZeVi]dad\^XVa^[^i^hY^hVYkVciV\Zdjhidi]Z^cY^k^YjVa#

0OSTCRANIAL.ONMETRIC6ARIATION ;^ccZ\Vc &.,- egdk^YZh V YZhXg^ei^dc d[ i]^gin cdcbZig^X igV^ih dWhZgkZY ^c i]Z edhiXgVc^Va h`ZaZidc# =Z Zbe]Vh^oZh edhiXgVc^Va igV^ih WZXVjhZ i]Zn h]dl W^aViZgVa ZmegZhh^dcVcYWZXVjhZi]ZVeegdeg^ViZh`ZaZiVaZaZbZcihVgZd[iZcegZhZgkZY^ci]Z VgX]Zdad\^XVaXdciZmi#;^ccZ\Vc&.,-a^hih[ZVijgZhhjX]Vhi]ZiVaVg[VXZih![ZbdgVa i]^gYigdX]VciZgh!VcYW^eVgi^iZXZgk^XVaigVchkZghZ[dgVb^cV#BVcnd[i]Za^hiZY[ZV" ijgZhgZaViZidi]ZegZhZcXZ!h]VeZ!h^oZ!VcYdg^ZciVi^dcd[Vgi^XjaVghjg[VXZh#BVcnd[ i]ZigV^ih^YZci^ÄZYWn;^ccZ\Vc&.,-bVnWZ]^\]anhjhXZei^WaZidZck^gdcbZciVa ^cÅjZcXZ!^cXdcigVhiidYZciVacdcbZig^XigV^ih#;dgi]^hgZVhdc!YZciVacdcbZig^X igV^ihVgZi]Zbdhil^YZanVcYhjXXZhh[jaanjhZYh`ZaZiVa^cY^XVidgh^c\Vj\^c\edej" aVi^dcVaV[Äc^in#

%STIMATING"IOLOGICAL$ISTANCE I]ZVhhZhhbZcid[V[Äc^inW^dad\^XVagZaVi^dch]^eWVhZYdch`ZaZiVa[dgb]VhVadc\ ]^hidgn ^c e]nh^XVa Vci]gdedad\n 6gbZaV\dh Zi Va#! &.-'# AVghZc &.., egdk^YZh V \ddYgZk^Zld[hjX]hijY^Zh#DhiZdad\^hihl]dhijYni]Zh`ZaZiVagZbV^chd[VcVidb^" XVaan bdYZgc ]jbVch d[iZc ldg` dc b^XgdZkdaji^dcVgn egdWaZbh# Id Zhi^bViZ i]Z YZ\gZZd[\ZcZi^XgZaViZYcZhhWZilZZcedejaVi^dch!i]ZdhiZdad\^hildg`hjcYZgVc^b" edgiVciVhhjbei^dc/edejaVi^dchi]ViY^heaVni]Zbdhih^b^aVg^inVgZi]ZbdhiXadhZan gZaViZY#I]ZYZ\gZZidl]^X]i]^hVhhjbei^dc^hbZi^cegVXi^XZYZeZcYhdcildbV_dg [VXidgh/VYZfjVXnd[hVbea^c\VcYX]d^XZd[X]VgVXiZghdhiZdad\^XVaigV^ih[dgXdbeVg^" hdcJWZaV`Zg!&.-.# DhiZdad\^hih dWhZgkZ dcan hVbeaZh d[ W^dad\^XVa edejaVi^dch# I]Z edejaVi^dch i]ZbhZakZhVgZcdadc\ZgVkV^aVWaZ[dghijYn#I]ZgZ[dgZ!i]ZhigZc\i]d[dhiZdad\^XVaan WVhZYXdcXajh^dchVWdjiV[Äc^inYZeZcYhdci]ZYZ\gZZidl]^X]i]ZhVbeaZhVXXj" gViZangZÅZXii]ZgZVaedejaVi^dchi]VidcXZZm^hiZY#I]ZXdcXajh^dchVWdjigZaVi^dc" h]^eXVcWZlZV`ZcZY^[i]ZhVbeaZ^hiddhbVaadg^[^ihXdbedh^i^dc]VhWZZcVaiZgZY ^chdbZhnhiZbVi^XlVn#JWZaV`Zg&.-.gZXdbbZcYhjcW^VhZYVYjaihVbeaZhd[&%% ^cY^k^YjVah[dgZVX]\gdjeWZ^c\XdbeVgZY^cW^dY^hiVcXZhijY^Zh# DhiZdad\^XVa VhhZhhbZci d[ i]Z W^dad\^XVa gZaVi^dch]^eh Vbdc\ eVhi edejaVi^dch bjhiWZbVYZdci]ZWVh^hd[VcVidb^XVaigV^ih#I]ZhZigV^ihh]djaY^YZVaanWZY^gZXian VcYZmXajh^kZanXdcigdaaZYWn\ZcZh#I]ZbdgZhjhXZei^WaZidZck^gdcbZciVa^cXajY" ^c\XjaijgVa^cÅjZcXZVh`ZaZiVaigV^i^h!i]ZaZhhkVajVWaZ^i^h^cZhiVWa^h]^c\V[Äc" ^in#;dgZmVbeaZ!ÅViiZc^c\d[i]ZdXX^e^iVaWni]ZXjaijgVaegVXi^XZd[XgVYaZWdVgY" ^c\XVcWZdWhZgkZY^cY^hiVciangZaViZYeZdeaZ!WjiidXdcXajYZi]ViildedejaVi^dch bVc^[Zhi^c\XgVYaZWdVgY"^cYjXZYdXX^e^iVaÅViiZc^c\lZgZW^dad\^XVaanXadhZangZaViZY 

8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

ldjaYWZb^haZVY^c\#Jc[dgijcViZan!cdh^c\aZh`ZaZiVaigV^i^h[gZZ[gdbZck^gdcbZc" iVa^cÅjZcXZ# DhiZdad\^hih]VkZigVY^i^dcVaanjhZYWdi]bZig^XVcYcdcbZig^XigV^ih^ci]Z^gVh" hZhhbZcih d[ W^dad\^XVa Y^hiVcXZ WZilZZc h`ZaZiVa edejaVi^dch E^ZigjhZlh`n! '%%%# Bjai^kVg^ViZhiVi^hi^Xh]VkZWZZcZbeadnZY!bdhianl^i]XgVc^VabZVhjgZh!id\Vj\ZgZ" aViZYcZhh#CdcbZig^XX]VgVXiZgh]VkZVahdWZZcjhZY!VadcZdg^cXdbW^cVi^dc# 9Zci^i^dc]VhWZZcjhZYbdhiZ[[ZXi^kZanidVhhZhhgZaVi^dch]^ehWZilZZcbdYZgc VcYVcX^ZciedejaVi^dch[dghZkZgVagZVhdch#IZZi]Zm]^W^iVkVg^Zind[VcVidb^XVaYZ" iV^ahi]Vi]VkZWZZcYZbdchigViZYidWZhiVWaZi]gdj\]i^bZ!id]VkZV]^\]\ZcZi^X XdbedcZciidi]Z^g[dgbVi^dc!VcYidY^[[ZgZci^ViZa^k^c\]jbVcedejaVi^dch#IZZi] VgZ d[iZc WZiiZg egZhZgkZY i]Vc WdcZ# >c VYY^i^dc! i]Z edhi"[dgbVi^dc Z[[ZXih d[ Zc" k^gdcbZci! \ZcYZg! VcY V\Z ]VkZ aZhh ^cÅjZcXZ dc iddi] bdge]dad\n i]Vc dc bdhi Wdcn VcVidbn# ;dg i]ZhZ gZVhdch! iZZi] ]VkZ Ä\jgZY egdb^cZcian ^c gZXdchigjXi^c\ i]ZW^dad\^XVa]^hidgnd[kVg^djh]jbVcedejaVi^dch#HiVcYVgY^oVi^dcd[igV^ihVcYi]Z bZi]dYh[dghXdg^c\i]ZbZ#\#!8VgVWZaa^¼hXjhe!ÄhhjgZeViiZgch!cjbWZgd[Xjheh!VcY ^cX^hdgh]dkZa^c\]VkZXdch^YZgVWan[VX^a^iViZYVcYZc]VcXZYi]ZVXXjgVXnd[YZciVa cdcbZig^XVcVanh^hIjgcZgZiVa#!&..&0HXdiiVcYIjgcZg!&..,# >i^h^cXgZVh^c\anVeeVgZcii]Vii]ZbdaZXjaVggZkdaji^dc^cdhiZdad\n]daYhi]Z ediZci^VaidWZXdbZi]ZYZÄc^i^kZVgW^iZgd[bjX]W^dY^hiVcXZldg`l^i]]jbVch`Za" ZiVagZbV^ch#=dlZkZg!Vh@dabVcVcYIjgdhh'%%%cdiZ!ZkZc^ci]ZcZlb^aaZcc^jb! ¹###i]ZVcVanh^hd[9C6^hhi^aaVcZmXgjX^Vi^c\anhadlVcYbZi^XjadjhegdXZhh#ºDi]Zg W^dX]Zb^XVa VcY \ZdX]Zb^XVa VcVanhZh XVc Vahd WZ Wgdj\]i id WZVg dc egdWaZbh d[ edejaVi^dcdg^\^cVcYbdkZbZci!ZVganZmVbeaZhWZ^c\ldg`dci]Zdg^\^cVcYbdkZ" bZcihd[i]Z6ae^cZ>XZbVcB“aaZgZiVa#!'%%(!VcYdcXdbb^c\aZYgZbV^ch[gdb K^ZicVb7ZVgYVcY?d]chdc!'%%%#

$IET DcZd[i]Zeg^bVgn\dVahd[VgX]Zdad\^XVagZhZVgX]^hi]ZgZXdchigjXi^dcd[hjWh^hiZcXZ eViiZgch ^c eVhi ]jbVc edejaVi^dch# 6 bjai^Y^hX^ea^cVgn VeegdVX] ^h jhjVaan iV`Zc ^ci]^hZcYZVkdg!l^i]heZX^Va^hihVcVano^c\ÅdgVa![VjcVa!VcY[ZXVabViZg^VagZXdkZgZY ^c ]VW^iVi^dc h^iZh! VcY hi^aa di]Zg VgX]Zdad\^hih ZmVb^c^c\ i]Z gZbV^ch d[ iZX]cda" d\njhZYidZmead^iY^[[ZgZci[ddYgZhdjgXZh#HjX]VcVeegdVX]jhZh^c[dgbVi^dc[gdb bVcnY^hX^ea^cZhidZajX^YViZi]ZeVhi#I]ZdhiZdad\^hiXVcbV`ZXdcig^Wji^dchidjc" YZghiVcY^c\i]ZY^Zid[egZ]^hidg^XeZdeaZWnZmVb^c^c\h`ZaZiVaeVi]dad\^Zh!VcVano" ^c\YZciValZVg!VcY!bdgZgZXZcian!i]gdj\]i]ZVcVanh^hd[igVXZVcYbV_dgZaZbZcih ZmigVXiZY[gdbi]Zh`ZaZiVagZbV^chi]ZbhZakZh# I]Z^ciZgVXi^dcWZilZZccjig^i^dcVcYh`ZaZiVaeVi]dad\n^hVXdbeaZm!Y^[ÄXjai hjW_ZXiVgZVVcYi]Z[dXjhd[V\gZViYZVad[XjggZcigZhZVgX]#;dgVXdbegZ]Zch^kZgZ" k^Zld[i]Zide^X!hZZBVgi^cZiVa#&.-*VcYAVghZc&..,#>cY^XVidghhjX]Vh=Vgg^h a^cZh!YZciVa]nedeaVh^V!VcYYZciVaVhnbbZignbVnWZjhZYdcVedejaVi^dcVaWVh^hid YZiZgb^cZcjig^i^dcVaVYZfjVXn^cegZ]^hidgn#Jc[dgijcViZan!]dlZkZg!higZhhbVg`Zgh ^cWdcZVgZcdcheZX^ÄX!VcYdcaneViiZgchVcYigZcYhd[cjig^i^dcVahigZhhVii]Zedej" aVi^dcVaaZkZaXVcWZVhXZgiV^cZY#Dci]Zdeedh^iZZcYd[Y^ZiVgngZXdchigjXi^dc!i]Z [dXjhXVcWZ^cY^k^YjVaVcYi]ZgZhjaihkZgnheZX^ÄX![dgZmVbeaZ!l]ZcXdadcXdciZcih XVcgZkZVaVbZVaH]V[ZgZiVa#!&.-.# &.#&%9^Zi

)&&

9ZciVa lZVg VcY YZciVa XVg^Zh ]VkZ adc\ WZZc jhZY ^c ViiZbeih id X]VgVXiZg^oZ egZ]^hidg^XY^Zi#IZZi]^ciZg[VXZY^gZXianl^i][ddYhij[[h!VcYi]Ze]nh^XVaVcYX]Zb^" XVaXdbedh^i^dcd[[ddY]VhVY^gZXi^cÅjZcXZdclZVgVcYYZXVn#EgZ]^hidg^XeZdeaZ l]d^cXdgedgViZYaVg\ZVbdjcihd[\g^i^cidi]Z^gY^Zii]gdj\][ddY"egZeVgVi^dciZX]" c^fjZh!hjX]Vh\g^cY^c\[ddYWZilZZchidcZh!Zm]^W^iegdcdjcXZYYZciValZVg#I]Z a^b^iVi^dchd[jh^c\YZciValZVgidVhhZhhY^ZiVgZZVh^anjcYZghiddYWnXdch^YZg^c\ild ^bV\^cVgnegZ]^hidg^XedejaVi^dchZVi^c\ZmVXiani]ZhVbZY^Zi#>[dcZedejaVi^dcjhZY hVcYhidcZ\g^cYZghidegZeVgZi]ZWja`d[^ihY^Zi!l]^aZi]Zdi]Zg\gdjejhZYlddYZc bdgiVgh!i]ZgViZVcYcVijgZd[YZciValZVgldjaYWZkZgnY^[[ZgZci!ZkZci]dj\]i]Z cdc\g^iXdciZcid[i]ZY^ZilVh^YZci^XVa# B^XgdhXde^XZmVb^cVi^dcd[ldgciZZi]gZkZVahe^ihVcYhig^Vi^dch^ci]ZZcVbZa VcY YZci^cZ# JhZ d[ i]Z hXVcc^c\ ZaZXigdc b^XgdhXdeZ ]Vh bVYZ ^i edhh^WaZ id XVgZ" [jaanhijYnb^XgdhXde^XlZVgdciZZi]LVa`Zg!&.-&0IZV[dgY!&..&!&..)#6hl^i] eVaZdeVi]dad\n!hijYnd[YZciValZVgbjhiWZYdcZdcVedejaVi^dcVaWVh^hidn^ZaY gZa^VWaZY^ZiVgngZXdchigjXi^dch#I]^h^heVgi^XjaVganigjZl^i]b^XgdlZVgVcVanh^hWZ" XVjhZi]Zb^XgdhXde^Xh^\cVijgZd[i]Z^cY^k^YjVa¼haVhibZVadghZid[bZVahbVncdiWZ ^cY^XVi^kZd[l]Vii]ZVkZgV\ZY^ZilVhdkZgi]Za^[Zd[i]Z^cY^k^YjVa#BjX]VYY^i^dcVa gZhZVgX]^ci]^hVgZV^hgZfj^gZY#>i^hXaZVg!]dlZkZg!i]ViYZciVab^XgdlZVghijYn^hVc ^bedgiVciXdbea^bZciidbVXgdhXde^XlZVg!WdcZX]Zb^hign!VcYeVi]dad\^XVaVhhZhh" bZci^cY^ZiVgnVcVanh^h# Jca^`ZYZciValZVg!YZciVaXVg^ZhVgZVeVi]dad\^XVaXdcY^i^dcl]dhZ^cX^YZcXZ^h jcYZgi]Z^cÅjZcXZd[bVcn[VXidgh!^cXajY^c\Y^Zi#I]Z^cX^YZcXZd[XVg^Zh![dgZm" VbeaZ! ]Vh WZZc h]dlc id WZ \ZcZgVaan ]^\]Zg ^c V\g^XjaijgVa i]Vc ^c ]jci^c\ VcY \Vi]Zg^c\ZXdcdb^Zh#Hb^i]&.-)VcYHX]bjX`Zg&.-*hjbbVg^oZYhijY^ZhV^bZY ViZajX^YVi^c\egZ]^hidg^XY^Zii]gdj\]i]ZVcVanh^hd[iddi]lZVg!VcYi]ZnWdi][djcY i]Vi]jciZghVcY\Vi]ZgZghXVcWZY^hi^c\j^h]ZY[gdb[VgbZghdci]ZWVh^hd[bVXgd" hXde^Xiddi]lZVg#EdlZaa&.-*gZk^Zlhi]ZjhZd[YZciValZVgVcYXVg^Zh^cgZXdc" higjXi^c\egZ]^hidg^XY^Zi# 9ZciVa XVg^Zh ^h i]Z Y^hZVhZ egdXZhh X]VgVXiZg^oZY Wn YZb^cZgVa^oVi^dc d[ YZciVa ]VgYi^hhjZhWndg\Vc^XVX^YhegdYjXZYl]ZcWVXiZg^V[ZgbZciY^ZiVgnXVgWd]nYgViZh ZheZX^Vaanhj\Vgh#7ZXVjhZXVg^djhaZh^dchVgZgZVY^anVeeVgZcidciZZi]!i]ZgZ^hVkZgn aVg\Z a^iZgVijgZ VhhdX^ViZY l^i] i]Zb! ZkZc [dg egZ]^hidg^X edejaVi^dch# DhiZdad\^hih ]VkZWZZchijYn^c\iZbedgVaigZcYh^cXVg^Zhh^cXZi]Z&-%%h#8]Vc\Zh^cegdXZhh^c\ iZX]cdad\nVcY[ddY]VY^bedgiVci^bea^XVi^dch[dgi]ZdgVa]ZVai]d[eVhi]jbVc edejaVi^dch#8Vg^d\Zc^X[ddYhdWk^djhanaZVYidV]^\]ZgegZkVaZcXZd[XVg^Zh^cVede" jaVi^dc#L^i]^cVedejaVi^dc!hZmVcYhiVijhY^[[ZgZcXZh^ci]ZVbdjcid[XVg^d\Zc^X [ddYZViZcbVneaVn^bedgiVcigdaZh^cYZiZgb^c^c\i]Z[gZfjZcX^Zhd[XVg^ZhLVa`Zg VcY=ZlaZii!&..%#AVghZc&..,gZk^Zlhi]ZjhZd[XVg^Zh[gZfjZcX^Zh^chijY^Zhd[ bdYZgcVcYVgX]Zdad\^XVah`ZaZiVahVbeaZh# 9ZkZadebZcih^ci]ZX]Zb^XVaVcVanh^hd[dhiZdad\^XVagZbV^ch]VkZdeZcZYcZl l^cYdlhdci]ZeVhi#6cVanh^hd[igVXZZaZbZcihVcY^hdideZh^c]jbVcdhiZdad\n]Vh eaVnZYVc^cXgZVh^c\an^bedgiVcigdaZ^cY^ZiVgngZXdchigjXi^dcYjg^c\i]ZaVhiild YZXVYZh[dggZk^Zlh!hZZEg^XZ!&.-.0HVcY[dgY!&..(0HX]dZc^c\Zg!&..*0AVghZc!&..,0 @VioZcWZg\!'%%%0VcYHVcY[dgYVcYLZVkZg!'%%%# IgVY^i^dcVaan!i]Z^hhjZhd[Y^ZiVcYV[Äc^in]VkZWZZcVeegdVX]ZY^c]jbVcdhiZ" dad\nk^Vbdge]dad\^XVaVhhZhhbZci#I]ZVeea^XVi^dcd[X]Zb^XVabZi]dYhd[VcVanh^h ]VhWZZcbdhianY^gZXiZYidlVgYdhiZdad\^XVagZbV^ch[gdbVgX]Zdad\^XVaXdciZmih#6h 

8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

AVghZc&..,cdiZh!YdXjbZciVi^dcd[Y^Zi^ci]ZeVhiegdk^YZhi]ZXdciZmi[dghijY^Zh d[\gdli]!higZhh!Y^hZVhZ!VcYhjWh^hiZcXZVXi^k^i^Zh#8dckZci^dcVaVeegdVX]ZhidY^Zi ji^a^oZYVgX]Zdad\^XVabViZg^Vah!eVgi^XjaVganeaVciVcYVc^bVagZbV^ch#I]ZVgX]Zd" ad\^XVagZXdgY]Vhadc\WZZc`cdlcidWZW^VhZY^c^ihegZhZgkVi^dcd[[ddYgZbV^ch! ]dlZkZg!l^i]eaVcigZbV^chd[iZcVeegdVX]^c\^ck^h^W^a^inYjZidY^[ÄXjai^Zh^cegZh" ZgkVi^dc#I]ZegdheZXid[Vc^cYZeZcYZciVcYdW_ZXi^kZbZVchid\ZcZgViZXdchjbe" i^dcegdÄaZhd[Y^[[ZgZci[ddYhZViZc^ci]ZeVhi^hi]ZgZ[dgZVcZci^X^c\dcZ# Dg\Vc^hbhXdbeg^hZXdbbdcZaZbZcihhjX]Vh]nYgd\Zc=!XVgWdc8!dmn\Zc D!c^igd\ZcC!XVaX^jb8V!VcYaZhhXdbbdcigVXZZaZbZcihhjX]Vhhigdci^jb Hg# BVcn ZaZbZcih XdbZ ^c Y^[[ZgZci ^hdideZh# I]ZhZ ^hdideZh Y^[[Zg ^c ]dl bVcn cZjigdchi]ZnedhhZhh#HdbZ^hdideZhVgZjchiVWaZVcYgVY^dVXi^kZ!VcYWnbZVhjg^c\ i]Z^gYZXVn!\ZdX]gdcdad\^hihVgZVWaZidYZiZgb^cZi]ZV\Zd[bVcnbViZg^Vah#=ZVk^Zg ^hdideZh]VkZbdgZcZjigdch^ci]Z^gcjXaZ^#A^\]iZg^hdideZh&'8gZaVi^kZid &(8![dg ZmVbeaZWgZV`VcY[dgbX]Zb^XVaWdcYhbdgZgVe^Yani]Vc]ZVk^Zg^hdideZh#I]ZhZ [VXihd[X]Zb^hignbZVci]VigVi^dhd[i]ZhiVWaZ^hdideZhXVcWZZmVb^cZY^cZ[[dgih idYZYjXZVheZXihd[eVaZdZXdad\nVcY]jbVcWZ]Vk^dg!^cXajY^c\Y^Zi#8VgWdcVcY c^igd\Zc VgZ i]Z ZaZbZcih i]Vi ]VkZ gZXZ^kZY bdhi ViiZci^dc ^c hijY^Zh d[ ]jbVc dhiZdad\^XVaX]Zb^hign# I]ZgZVgZildhiVWaZ^hdideZhd[XVgWdc/ &' 8VcY &(8#GVi^dhd[i]ZhZ^hdideZh^c bVbbVa^Vc WdcZh gZÅZXi Y^Zi Z#\#! eaVci i^hhjZh XdchjbZY Yjg^c\ a^[Z# EaVcih jhZ ilde]didhnci]Zi^XeVi]lVnh#I]Zhd"XVaaZY8(eaVcihY^hXg^b^cViZV\V^chii]Z]ZVk^" Zg ^hdideZ d[ XVgWdc! VcY i]Z^g i^hhjZh VgZ Zcg^X]ZY ^c &' 8# Dg\Vc^hbh ZVi^c\ bdgZ d[i]ZhZeaVcihl^aai]ZgZ[dgZh]dl]^\]Zg &' 8$&(8gVi^dh^ci]Z^gWdcZh#BV^oZVcY di]Zg8)eaVcihYdcdiY^hXg^b^cViZVhbjX]VcY]VkZbdgZd[i]Z]ZVk^Zg^hdideZ! YZXgZVh^c\i]^hgVi^dd[XVgWdc^hdideZh^ci]ZWdcZXdaaV\Zcd[Xdchjb^c\dg\Vc^hbh# H^b^aVgan! i]Z ]ZVk^Zg &* C ^hdideZ d[ c^igd\Zc XdcXZcigViZh Vh ^i igVkZah je i]gdj\] i]Z[ddYX]V^c#BVg^cZeaVcih]VkZ]^\]ZgXdcXZcigVi^dchd[i]^h^hdideZi]VcaVcY eaVcih!VcYVc^bVah]^\]Zgje^ci]ZbVg^cZ[ddYX]V^c]VkZ!VhVXdchZfjZcXZ!]^\]Zg &* C$ &) CgVi^dh^ci]Z^gWdcZh#EZdeaZ[ZZY^c\dcbVg^cZbVbbVahVgZi]jhZmeZXiZYid ]VkZ]^\]ZggVi^dhi]Vci]dhZhjWh^hi^c\dciZggZhig^Va[ddYhdjgXZh#I]jh!i]Z^hdide^X Xdbedh^i^dchd[i]ZWdcZi^hhjZbVnWZ^cY^XVidghd[Y^Zi#7niV`^c\Vi^cnhVbeaZd[ WdcZi^hhjZ!i]ZdhiZdad\^hiXVcXdckZgii]ZhVbeaZ^cidV\VhVcYbZVhjgZi]Z^hdideZ kVajZhl^i]VbVhhheZXigdbZiZg#I]Z^hdide^XgVi^dkVajZhXVcWZXdbeVgZYWZilZZc Y^[[ZgZcih`ZaZidch#L^i]i]ZhZiddah!^ci]Zdgn!dhiZdad\^hihVgZedh^i^dcZYidZkVajViZ hjWh^hiZcXZX]Vc\Zhi]gdj\]i^bZWnY^gZXigZ[ZgZcXZidi]ZX]Zb^XVaXdbedh^i^dcd[ h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch# I]Z^c^i^VaX]Zb^XVahijY^Zhd[WdcZ^ci]Z&.,%hlZgZgZXZ^kZYl^i]\gZViZc" i]jh^Vhb WZXVjhZ i]Z iZX]c^fjZh VeeZVgZY id egdk^YZ Y^gZXi fjVci^iVi^kZ bZVch [dg gZXdchigjXi^c\Y^ZiHVcY[dgY!&..(#7ni]Z&.-%h!igVXZZaZbZciVcYhiVWaZ^hdideZ gZhZVgX]lVh]ZgVaYZYVhVWgZV`i]gdj\]!VcYbdgZgZhZVgX]ZghWZ\VcidXdcYjXii]ZhZ hijY^Zh#6hHVcY[dgY&..(cdiZh!]dlZkZg!i]ZZVgandei^b^hblVhhddcXjgWZYWn hijY^Zhi]ViYZbdchigViZYi]ViZaZbZciVaXdcXZcigVi^dchVgZ^cÅjZcXZYWnbVcnXdb" eaZmVcYd[iZc"^ciZggZaViZYegdXZhhZh#7ni]ZaViZ&.-%hVji]dghlZgZgZ[Zgg^c\idi]Z ¹VWjhZd[WdcZVcVanhZh[dgVgX]Zdad\^XVaY^ZiVgnhijY^Zhº=VcXdX`ZiVa#!&.-.VcY egdXaV^b^c\i]Vii]ZgZlZgZ¹cdbdgZZVhnVchlZghºH^aaZcZiVa#!&.-.# 9jg^c\a^[Z!ZaZbZciVaYZedh^i^dc^ci]Zh`ZaZidc^h\dkZgcZYWnbdgZi]Vc_jhi i]ZVWjcYVcXZd[ZaZbZcih^ci]ZY^Zi#6[iZgWjg^Va!WdcZhXVcWZhjW_ZXiZYidY^V\Zc" &.#&&9^hZVhZVcY9Zbd\gVe]n

)&(

Zh^h#8dcXZgchdkZg]dli]ZhZkVg^VWaZh^cÅjZcXZWdcZ¼hX]Zb^XVaXdbedh^i^dc]VkZ \ZcZgViZYV\gZViYZVad[VYY^i^dcVagZhZVgX]#6hGVYdhZk^X]¼h¹I]ZH^m9ZVYanH^chd[ IgVXZ:aZbZci6cVanh^h/68VhZd[L^h][jaI]^c`^c\^cHX^ZcXZº&..(!e#(&-hiViZh/ ¹>i^hedhh^WaZi]ViVk^VWaZÄZaYd[igVXZZaZbZciVcVanh^hd[WdcZ^ci]^hÄZaYXVchi^aa WZXdchigjXiZY!WjiZmVb^cVi^dchd[WVh^X\ZdX]Zb^hignVcYiVe]dcdbnd[hd^a"Wjg^ZY WdcZbjhiWZXVgg^ZYdjiÄghi!cdiVhVcV[iZgi]dj\]i#º6h6bWgdhZ&..(]Vhed^ciZY dji!hijY^Zhd[hiVWaZ^hdideZh]VkZWZZcYZkZadeZYbdhian^c\ZdX]Zb^hignVcYeaVci e]nh^dad\ngVi]Zgi]Vc^cVci]gdedad\n#I]ZbdhihjWhiVci^Va^ch^\]ih^cidegZ]^hidg^X Y^ZiVcYaVcYjhZ]VkZWZZcVX]^ZkZY^cVgZVh^ckdak^c\i]Z^cigdYjXi^dcd[8)eaVcih hjX]VhbV^oZ!i]ZYZbdchigVi^dci]ViY^Zihd[]^\]"hiVijh^cY^k^YjVahlZgZY^[[ZgZci [gdbadlZg"hiVijh^cY^k^YjVah^chdbZhdX^Zi^Zh!VcYi]ZVhhZhhbZcid[bVg^cZkZghjh iZggZhig^Va[ddYlZWh#AVghZc&..,gZk^Zlhi]ZgZhjaihd[i]ZhZVeea^XVi^dch!VcY6b" WgdhZ VcY @VioZcWZg\ '%%% egdk^YZ V XdbegZ]Zch^kZ dkZgk^Zl d[ W^d\ZdX]Zb^XVa VeegdVX]ZhideVaZdY^Zi#6hl^i]i]ZjhZd[W^dbdaZXjaZh^c]jbVcdhiZdad\n!hiVWaZ ^hdideZVcYigVXZZaZbZciVcVanhZhgZfj^gZi]dgdj\]\gdjcY^c\^cX]Zb^hign!W^dX]Zb" ^hign!e]nh^dad\n!e]nh^Xh!VcYdi]ZgaVWdgVidgnhX^ZcXZh#

$ISEASEAND$EMOGRAPHY I]ZhijYnd[edejaVi^dch!TU]_WbQ`Xi!^hXdcXZgcZYl^i]i]Zk^iVahiVi^hi^Xhd[edej" aVi^dch¸a^[ZZmeZXiVcXn!bdgiVa^ingViZh!W^gi]gViZh!VcYedejaVi^dc\gdli]!h^oZ!VcY YZch^in#9Zbd\gVe]Zgh^ciZgZhiZY^cbdYZgceZdeaZjhZYViVXdaaZXiZYWnXZchjhiV`Zgh l]d XZchjh i]Z a^k^c\# EVaZdYZbd\gVe]n ^h i]Z hijYn d[ i]Z YZbd\gVe]n d[ egZ]^h"

&IGUREEaVcd[i]ZegZ]^hidg^XA^WWZch^iZ!DiiVlV8djcin!D]^d#HijY^Zhd[h`ZaZiVa edejaVi^dchhjX]Vhi]^hdcZXVcaZVYid^ch^\]ih^cidYZbd\gVe]^XVheZXihd[ZVgan]jbVc edejaVi^dch#I]ZVgZV^cWdaYdjia^cZ^hVWadljed[eVgid[i]Zeadi#;gdbAdkZ_dnZiVa#!&.-*V#



8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

idg^XedejaVi^dch#I]Zk^iVahiVi^hi^Xhd[i]ZhZedejaVi^dchXVcWZgZXdchi^ijiZYWnjhZ d[i]Z^gh`ZaZidch#I]ZdhiZdad\^hiXVcgZXdchigjXii]ZhZedejaVi^dchWnXZchjh^c\i]Z YZVY#6bV_dgVhhjbei^dcjhZY]ZgZWni]ZdhiZdad\^hi^hi]Vii]ZgViZhd[\gdli]VcY V\^c\ZhiVWa^h]ZY[dgbdYZgc]jbVchXVcWZVeea^ZYVeegdeg^ViZanid^cY^k^YjVahl]d a^kZY^ci]ZY^hiVcieVhi#I]ZbdgZVcX^Zcii]ZedejaVi^dchjcYZghijYn!i]ZaZhhkVa^Y i]^hVhhjbei^dc^ha^`ZanidWZ# I]ZgZa^VW^a^ind[YZbd\gVe]^XgZXdchigjXi^dchWj^aidch`ZaZiVabViZg^VaYZeZcYh dci]ZVXXjgVXnd[^cY^k^YjVaV\ZVcYhZmZhi^bVi^dchd[i]Zh`ZaZidch#>cVYY^i^dc!i]Z^g gZa^VW^a^inYZeZcYhdc]dlVXXjgViZani]ZhVbeaZd[h`ZaZidchgZegZhZcihl]VilVhdcXZ i]Za^k^c\edejaVi^dc#KVcci]^h^bV\^cVgn XVhZ!cdeZdeaZY^ZYVlVn[gdb]dbZdglZgZXgZbViZYdgZViZcWnXVgc^kdgZh#CdcZ d[i]Zh`ZaZidchlZgZY^hijgWZYV[iZgWjg^VaWnW^dad\^XVadge]nh^XVaV\Zcih#;jgi]Zg"

&.#&&9^hZVhZVcY9Zbd\gVe]n

)&*

bdgZ! ^bV\^cZ i]Vi i]Z Zci^gZ XZbZiZgn lVh egZhZgkZY ^ciVXi i]gdj\] i]Z XZcijg^Zh# ;^cVaan!^bV\^cZi]ViVaad[^ilVhZmXVkViZYVcYi]ViVaad[i]Z^cY^k^YjVah!^cXajY^c\ kZgnndjc\^c[Vcih!lZgZgZXdkZgZY#Egdk^YZYi]VigZXdkZgnlVhXdbeaZiZ!gZXdgY`ZZe" ^c\lVh\ddY!cdcZd[i]Zh`ZaZiVabViZg^ValVhadhihjWhZfjZciidZmXVkVi^dc!VcYi]Z dhiZdad\^hiXdjaYVXXjgViZanV\ZVcYhZmVaad[i]Z^cY^k^YjVah!i]ZhZYViVb^\]iWZjhZY Y^gZXianidgZXdchigjXiYZbd\gVe]^XViig^WjiZhd[i]ZedejaVi^dc# 6hJWZaV`Zg&.-.cdiZh!YZbd\gVe]^XgZXdchigjXi^dc[gdbh`ZaZiVagZbV^ch^h cdiY^[ÄXjaibVi]ZbVi^XVaan#;dgZmVbeaZ!Xdch^YZghjgk^kVai]gdj\]i^bZ!WZ\^cc^c\ l^i]a^kZW^gi]h#6iW^gi]!hjgk^kValdjaYWZ&%%#7nV\Z*!l^i]]^\]^c[Vcibdg" iVa^in!eZg]Vehdcan+%d[i]Zdg^\^cVaedejaVi^dcldjaY]VkZhjgk^kZY#I]^hldjaY bZVci]Vi)%d[i]ZXZbZiZgnedejaVi^dcldjaY]VkZWZZcbVYZjed[X]^aYgZc^c i]Z%"id*"nZVg"daYV\ZgVc\Z#7neadii^c\i]ZV\ZZhi^bViZh[dgi]ZhZVcYi]Zdi]Zg Wjg^Vah^c*"nZVg^ciZgkVahi]gdj\]i^bZ!dcZXdjaYgZXdchigjXiVhjgk^kdgh]^eXjgkZ [dgi]ZedejaVi^dc;^\jgZ&.#&.#DcZb^\]iZmVb^cZhjgk^kdgh]^eWnhZmdgbV`Z YZYjXi^dchVWdjia^[ZZmeZXiVcXn^ci]ZedejaVi^dc#>ch]dgi!^ildjaYWZedhh^WaZid ZmVb^cZi]ZeVaZdYZbd\gVe]nd[i]ZedejaVi^dcjcYZghijYn# >i^h^bedgiVciidYZg^kZYZbd\gVe]^X[VXih[dgeVhi]jbVc\gdjeh#DcZbjhicdiZ! ]dlZkZg! i]Vi VXXjgViZ VcY gZa^VWaZ YZbd\gVe]^X gZXdchigjXi^dc lVh dcan VX]^ZkZY jcYZgi]ZheZX^ÄZYXdcY^i^dch^ci]Z^bV\^cVgnXVhZdjia^cZYZVga^Zg#BdhiVgX]Zdad\^" XVaanYZg^kZYh`ZaZiVahVbeaZhYdcdibZZii]ZhZXdcY^i^dch!VcYhjgk^kdgh]^eXjgkZh i]Vi i]Zn \ZcZgViZ VgZ egdcZ id hnhiZbVi^X Zggdg Vh V gZhjai# ;dg ZmVbeaZ! bVcn ]j" bVc\gdjehY^[[ZgZci^VaanY^hedhZd[i]ZYZVY#>[i]ZgZ^hW^Vh^ci]Z^gWjg^VaegVXi^XZh! i]ZYZbd\gVe]^XegdÄaZd[i]ViedejaVi^dcXVccdiWZYZiZgb^cZY VXXjgViZan#BVcn XZbZiZg^Zh h]dl Y^[[ZgZci^Va egZhZgkVi^dc i]Vi [Vkdgh ndjc\ VYjai ^cY^k^YjVah dkZg X]^aYgZcdgZaYZganVYjaihWZXVjhZWdcZhd[i]Z[dgbZgVgZhigdc\ZgVcYaZhhegdcZid YZhigjXi^dcWniVe]dcdb^XV\ZcihPZk^YZcXZ[dgW^VhYjZidegZhZgkVi^dcXVcWZ[djcY WnXVgZ[jaVcVanh^hd[i]ZhVbeaZLVa`ZgZiVa#!&.--R#BVcnXZbZiZg^ZhVgZZmXVkViZY cdcgVcYdbandghVbeaZY^cXdbeaZiZan#Dcan^ciVXiheZX^bZchVgZhVkZYhjWhZfjZci id XdaaZXi^dc ^c bVcn VgX]Zdad\^XVa ZmXVkVi^dch# BVcn h`ZaZiVa hVbeaZh VgZ XjgViZY eddgan!l^i]i]Zadhhd[bjX]bViZg^Va#>ch]dgi!bdhiVgX]Zdad\^XVaanYZg^kZYh`ZaZiVa edejaVi^dchVgZ^cVYZfjViZidegdk^YZVXXjgViZeVaZdYZbd\gVe]^XgZXdchigjXi^dch#>[ VcjcYZghiVcY^c\d[eVaZdYZbd\gVe]^XVheZXihd[VcX^ZciedejaVi^dch^hi]Z\dVad[V gZhZVgX]egd_ZXi!^i^h^beZgVi^kZi]Vii]ZdhiZdad\^hildg`XadhZanl^i]i]ZVgX]Zdad\^hi idhZZi]VihVbea^c\higViZ\nYdZhcdiW^Vhi]Zjai^bViZgZhjaih# LVaYgdc&..&!e#')ZmegZhhZhi]Za^c`V\ZhVcYe^i[Vaahd[hijYn^c\YZbd\gVe]n VcYY^hZVhZ^ch`ZaZiVaedejaVi^dchVh[daadlh/ I]ZjcYZgan^c\Vhhjbei^dci]Vi^h^c]ZgZci^cVcnViiZbeiidjhZVYZVi]VhhZb" WaV\ZidegZY^XihdbZi]^c\VWdjii]Za^k^c\^hi]Vii]ZYZVYedejaVi^dc^hgZegZhZciV" i^kZ¼dgViaZVhiine^XVa¼d[i]Za^kZedejaVi^dc#<^kZcVaai]Zcdc"gVcYdbZkZcih i]VihjggdjcYYZVi]VcYWjg^Va!cdiidbZci^dcegZhZgkVi^dcVcYgZXdkZgn!i]^h^hVi WZhiVcVeegdm^bVi^dc!VcYVildghii]Zildi]Za^kZVcYi]ZYZVYWZVgcdZe^YZ" b^dad\^XVagZaVi^dcidZVX]di]Zgl]VihdZkZg#=dlZkZg!^i^hXaZVgan^bedgiVciid`cdl l]ZgZdci]^hheZXigjbVeVgi^XjaVg\gdje!dghZid[\gdjeh!a^Zh!ZheZX^Vaan^[i]ZYViV YZg^kZY[gdbi]Z^ghijYnVgZidWZjhZYidXdchigjXia^[ZiVWaZh!idbV`Z^c[ZgZcXZhVWdji X]Vc\^c\eViiZgch^cY^hZVhZdgY^ZiVgn]VW^ih!dgidYgVlVcnd[i]Zdi]ZgYZbd\gVe]^X XdcXajh^dchi]ViVgZhdXdbbdcanWVcY^ZYVWdji# 

8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

  ,IBBENN



&2%15%.#9

        























!'%9%!23 &IGUREHjgk^kdgh]^eXjgkZWVhZYdci]ZegZ]^hidg^XA^WWZch`ZaZiVaedejaVi^dc#9ViV [gdbAdkZ_dnZiVa#&.,,#

 I]ZgZaVi^dch]^eWZilZZcVYdei^dc$^ciZch^ÄXVi^dcd[V\g^XjaijgZVcYedejaVi^dc h^oZVcY]ZVai]]VhWZZcVcdW_ZXid[Vci]gdedad\^XVa^cfj^gn[dgbVcnYZXVYZh#EV" aZdYZbd\gVe]^XVcYeVaZdeVi]dad\^XVaYViV]VkZWZZcWgdj\]iidWZVgdci]^hhjW" _ZXi[dgbVcnnZVgh!VcYVhd[i]ZWZ\^cc^c\d[i]^hYZXVYZ!i]Z^YZVi]ViV\g^XjaijgZ Wgdj\]il^i]^iVYZXgZVhZYfjVa^ind[a^[ZVcY^cXgZVhZYbdgiVa^ingViZhlVhl^YZan VXXZeiZY#>cVhdWZg^c\VcY^cÅjZci^VaXdcig^Wji^dc!LddYVcYXdaaZV\jZh&..'gZ" b^cYZYVci]gdedad\^hihi]Vii]ZhijYnd[egZ]^hidg^XedejaVi^dchVcYi]Z^g]ZVai]^hV XdbeaZmjcYZgiV`^c\!cZkZghigV^\]i[dglVgYdgh^beaZ#I]ZhZVji]dghfjZhi^dcVWVh^X Vhhjbei^dc bVYZ Wn bVcn dhiZdad\^hih gZ\VgY^c\ aZh^dch dc h`ZaZiVa gZbV^ch# I]Zn Vg\jZi]VigVi]Zgi]VcgZÅZXi^c\YZXa^c^c\Xdbbjc^in]ZVai]!hjX]aZh^dch^cY^XViZ i]Vii]ZV[[ZXiZY^cY^k^YjVahhjgk^kZYhdbZY^hZVhZ!i]VihjX]hjgk^kVab^\]iVXijVaan ^cY^XViZ Vc ^begdkZbZci ^c ]ZVai]! VcY i]Vi ^cY^k^YjVah l]d a^kZY adc\ Zcdj\] id bVc^[Zhi eVi]dad\^XVa aZh^dch dc i]Z^g h`ZaZidch lZgZ VYkVciV\ZY gZaVi^kZ id eZdeaZ l]dhjXXjbWZYidY^hZVhZWZ[dgZi]Z^gh`ZaZidchlZgZV[[ZXiZY#;jgi]ZgbdgZ!i]ZhZVj" i]dghcdiZi]ViaVg\ZcjbWZghd[^bbVijgZh`ZaZidchbVn^cY^XViZbdgZVWdji[Zgi^a^in i]Vc bdgiVa^in# I]ZhZ dWhZgkVi^dch VgZ ^c h]Vge XdcigVhi id i]Z gZXZ^kZY l^hYdb ^c eVaZdeVi]dad\nVcYeVaZdYZbd\gVe]n#=dl!i]Zc!VgZdhiZdad\^hihid^ciZgegZieVaZdeV" i]dad\ndcVedejaVi^dcVaWVh^h4LddYZiVa#&..'hVni]ViXdch^YZgVWanbdgZXg^i^XVa gZhZVgX]^hgZfj^gZY!Wjii]Vi^ci]ZbZVci^bZ!i]Zh`ZaZiVaZk^YZcXZeZgiV^c^c\idi]Z

&.#&&9^hZVhZVcY9Zbd\gVe]n

)&,

igVch^i^dc[gdb]jci^c\VcY\Vi]Zg^c\idhZiiaZYV\g^XjaijgZ^hZfjVaanXdch^hiZcil^i] Vc^begdkZbZcidgVYZiZg^dgVi^dcd[]ZVai]hZZVahd8d]Zc!&..)# 6eean^c\]jbVch`ZaZiVaYViV[gdb]^hidg^XVcYegZ]^hidg^XXdciZmihid^bedgiVci fjZhi^dchVWdjiXjaijgZVcYW^dad\n^hVc^bedgiVciVkZcjZd[Vci]gdedad\^XVa^ckZh" i^\Vi^dc#9ZXVYZhd[hjX]Veea^XVi^dc]VkZWgdj\]iVc^cXgZVhZYjcYZghiVcY^c\d[i]Z XdbeaZm^i^Zh^ckdakZY^chjX]hijY^Zh#>i^hXaZVgi]ViVci]gdedad\^hihl^aaXdci^cjZid jhZh`ZaZiVaedejaVi^dch^cZ[[dgihidWZiiZgjcYZghiVcYi]ZeVhiVcYl^aaYdhdl^i] ^cXgZVh^c\anhde]^hi^XViZYiZX]c^fjZhVcY]Z^\]iZcZYXVji^dchWj^aijedcVWZiiZgVe" egZX^Vi^dcd[i]Z[gV\bZciVgnVcYW^VhZYcVijgZd[i]ZgZXdgYhi]Vii]ZnhijYn#



8]VeiZg&.I]ZH`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[>cY^k^YjVahEdejaVi^dch

cÅVbbVi^dcd[V_d^ci# 1bdXb_`QdXi6cnY^hZVhZV[[ZXi^c\i]Z_d^cih# 1bdYSe\QdY_^6eaVXZl]ZgZildVY_VXZciWdcZhXdciVXi# 1db_`XiLVhi^c\VlVnVcYgZYjXi^dc^ch^oZ!eVgi^XjaVganV[iZgi]Zi^hhjZdgdg\Vc]VhbVijgZY#

)&.

1ddbYdY_^LZVg!jhjVaanjhZY^cgZ[ZgZcXZidi]ZiZZi]# 1eTYd_biUh_cd_cYc6Wdcn\gdli]l^i]^ci]ZZmiZgcVaVjY^idgnbZVijh# 1fe\cY_^I]Z[dgX^WaZiZVg^c\VlVnd[eVgid[VhigjXijgZ# 1hYQ\c[U\Ud_^7dcZhd[i]Zigjc`!^cXajY^c\i]ZkZgiZWgVZ!g^Wh!VcYhiZgcjb# 2Q\\Q^Tc_S[UdZ_Y^d6he]Zgd^YVa_d^ci!hjX]Vhi]Z]^e_d^cil^i]i]Z]Zb^he]Zg^XVa[ZbdgVa ]ZVYÄii^c\^cidi]ZVXZiVWjajb!i]ViVaadlh[dgbdkZbZci^cbVcnY^gZXi^dch# 2QcYSbQ^Ye]7dcZhd[i]ZXgVc^VaWVhZ# 2eSSQ\EZgiV^c^c\idi]ZX]ZZ`# 3Q\Se\ecIVgiVg!VYZedh^id[XVaX^ÄZYYZciVaeaVfjZdciZZi]# 3Q\\ec=VgYi^hhjZ[dgbZY^ci]ZdhiZd\Zc^XaVnZgd[i]ZeZg^dhiZjbVhV[gVXijgZgZeV^gi^hhjZ0 cdgbVaangZeaVXZY# 3Q\_ddU6XVakVg^Vl^i]djii]ZWVhZ# 3Q\fQbYQI]ZXgVc^jbcdi^cXajY^c\i]Z[VXZ# 3Q^SU\\_ecR_^UHedc\n!edgdjha^\]ilZ^\]iWdcZ[djcYjcYZgegdijWZgVcXZhl]ZgZiZcYdch ViiVX]!^ci]ZkZgiZWgVaWdY^Zh!^ci]ZZcYhd[adc\WdcZh!^ch]dgiWdcZh!VcYhVcYl^X]ZYl^i]^c ÅViWdcZh0VahdXVaaZYigVWZXjaVgWdcZ# 3QbYUc6Y^hZVhZX]VgVXiZg^oZYWni]Zegd\gZhh^kZYZXVaX^ÄXVi^dcd[ZcVbZadgYZci^cZ0i]Z]daZ dgXVk^inaZ[iWnhjX]YZXVn# 3QbdY\QWU6[dgbd[XdccZXi^kZi^hhjZXdch^hi^c\d[XZaahZbWZYYZY^cVbVig^m# 3QbdY\QWY^_ecZ_Y^d6_d^ci!hjX]Vhi]ViWZilZZci]ZÄghig^WVcYi]ZhiZgcjb!^cl]^X]i]Z Vgi^XjaVi^c\WdcZhVgZjc^iZYWnbZVchd[XVgi^aV\ZVcYkZgna^iiaZbdkZbZci^hVaadlZY#Hnc" dcnbdjhl^i]hncX]dcYgdh^h# 3U]U^de]6WdcZ"a^`Zi^hhjZi]ViXdkZghi]ZZmiZgcVahjg[VXZd[iddi]gddih!hjggdjcY^c\i]Z YZci^cd[i]ZgddiVcYcZX`d[Viddi]# 3UbfYS_U^Q]U\\Y^UdgZe^SdY_^35:I]Za^cZZcX^gXa^c\i]ZXgdlcd[i]Ziddi]!YZa^b^i^c\ i]ZbdhigddilVgYZmiZcid[i]ZZcVbZa# 3_\\QWU^6ÄWgdjhhigjXijgVaegdiZ^cXdchi^iji^c\VWdji.%d[WdcZ¼hdg\Vc^XXdciZci# 3_]]Y^W\UT7dcZVhhZbWaV\ZhXdciV^c^c\gZbV^chd[bjai^eaZ^cY^k^YjVah!d[iZc^cXdbeaZiZ VcY[gV\bZciVgn# 3_]]Y^edUTVbQSdebU6[gVXijgZ^cl]^X]i]ZWdcZhea^ciZgh# 3_]`QSdR_^UI]Zhda^Y!YZchZWdcZi]Vi^h[djcY^ci]ZlVaahd[WdcZh]V[ihVcYdcZmiZgcVa WdcZhjg[VXZh!VahdXVaaZYXdgi^XVaWdcZ# 3_]`\UdUVbQSdebU6[gVXijgZ^cl]^X]Wgd`ZcZcYhd[VWdcZWZXdbZhZeVgViZY# 3_]`_e^TVbQSdebU6[gVXijgZ^cl]^X]i]ZWgd`ZcWdcZeZg[dgViZhi]Zh`^c# 3_]`edUTQhYQ\d_]_WbQ`Xi3D_b31D6gVY^dad\^XVaiZX]c^fjZjh^c\XdbejiZgegd" XZhh^c\id\ZcZgViZXgdhh"hZXi^dcVahXVchd[VcdW_ZXi# 3_^WU^YdQ\6Xfj^gZYYjg^c\YZkZadebZci^ci]ZjiZgjh!cdii]gdj\]]ZgZY^in# 3_b_^Q\cedebUI]ZhjijgZi]Via^ZhWZilZZci]Z[gdciVaVcYeVg^ZiVah# 3bQ^YQ\cedebUc;^Wgdjh_d^cihd[i]Zh`jaa#




3bQ^Y_ci^_cd_cYcHVbZVhXgVc^dhidh^h0egZbVijgZ[jh^dcd[XgVc^VahjijgZhgZhjai^c\^cVWcdg" bVah`jaah]VeZ# 3bQ^Ye]I]ZWdcZhd[i]Zh`jaaZmXZei[dgi]ZbVcY^WaZ# 3bU]QdY_^6bdgijVgnegVXi^XZ^ckdak^c\i]Z^ciZci^dcVaWjgc^c\d[i]ZWdYn# 3bYRbQSbQ^YYAZh^dchdci]ZZcYdXgVc^Vahjg[VXZ!jhjVaand[i]Z[gdciVa# 3bYRbQ_bRYdQ\YQAZh^dchdci]Zgdd[d[i]ZdgW^i!jhjVaan^ci]Z[dgbd[W^aViZgVae^ii^c\d[i]Z dgW^iVaeVgid[i]Z[gdciVa# 4USYTe_ecdUUdXI]ZÄghiiZZi]id[dgb!Zgjei!VcY[jcXi^dc^ci]ZÄghinZVghd[a^[Z# 4UXYcSU^SU6YZkZadebZciVaVWcdgbVa^ini]VigZhjaih^cVeZg[dgVi^dcd[i]ZinbeVc^XeaViZd[ i]ZiZbedgVaWdcZ0hdbZi^bZhXVaaZY[dgVbZcd[]jhX]`Z# 4U]_WbQ`XiI]ZhijYnd[edejaVi^dchiVi^hi^Xh# 4U^dQ\Xi`_`\QcYQ6XdcY^i^dcX]VgVXiZg^oZYWnigVchkZghZa^cZh!e^ih!VcY\gddkZhdci]Zhjg" [VXZd[iddi]Xgdlch0hjX]Y^hijgWVcXZhVgZYZ[ZXih^cYZciVaYZkZadebZci# 4U^dQ\`\QaeUI]ZbVig^mVcY^ihgZh^YZciXdbbjc^ind[WVXiZg^Vi]Vi[dgbhdcViddi]# 4U^dY^6heZX^VaineZd[XVaX^ÄZY!Wjiha^\]iangZh^a^Zci!XdccZXi^kZi^hhjZ0eg^bVgnYZci^cYZ" kZadehYjg^c\\gdli]!l]ZgZVhhZXdcYVgnYZci^c[dgbhV[iZggddi[dgbVi^dc^hXdbeaZiZ# 4U^dY^_U^Q]U\Ze^SdY_^I]ZWdjcYVgnWZilZZci]ZZcVbZaXVeVcYi]ZjcYZgan^c\YZci^c# 4U_hibYR_^eS\UYSQSYT4>1I]ZbdaZXjaZd[]ZgZY^ini]ViXdciV^chi]Z\ZcZi^XXdYZ# 4YQSXb_^YS8]Vc\ZhdgZkZcihXdch^YZgZYi]gdj\]i^bZ# 4YQWU^UcYc3]Zb^XVa!e]nh^XVa!VcYW^dad\^XVaX]Vc\ZhjcYZg\dcZWnVWdcZi]gdj\]i^bZ# 4YQ`XicYcI]Zh]V[id[Vadc\WdcZ# 4YcS_^dY^e_ec]_b`X_\_WYSQ\dbQYdc6ahdXVaaZYZe^\ZcZi^XkVg^Vcih!Y^hXgZiZigV^ih!dgcdc" bZig^XkVg^Vi^dc0kVg^Vi^dcdWhZgkZY^cWdcZhVcYiZZi]!VcY^ci]Z[dgbd[Y^[[ZgZcianh]VeZY VcYh^oZYXjheh!gddih!ijWZgXaZh!egdXZhhZh!XgZhih![dgVb^cV!Vgi^XjaVg[VXZihVcYh^b^aVg[ZVijgZh# 4YcSbUdUfQbYQR\UcKVg^VWaZhXdbedhZYd[VÄc^iZcjbWZgd[kVajZh!hjX]VhcdcbZig^XigV^ih i]ViVgZjhjVaanhXdgZYVhegZhZcidgVWhZci# 4ic`\QcYQ6cVWcdgbVaYZkZadebZcid[WdcZi^hhjZ# 5Reb^QdY_^Ldgc!eda^h]ZY!^kdgn"a^`ZVeeZVgVcXZd[WdcZgZhjai^c\[gdbZmedhjgZVcYlZVg d[VY_VXZcihjWX]dcYgVaWdcZViV_d^ci# 5TU^de\_ecAVX`^c\iZZi]# 5^Q]U\6aVnZgd[ZmigZbZan]VgY!Wg^iiaZbViZg^Vai]ViXdkZghi]ZXgdlcd[Viddi]# 5^T_SX_^TbQ\ _ccYÍSQdY_^  6 egdXZhh d[ WdcZ YZkZadebZci ^c l]^X] XVgi^aV\Z egZXjghdgh XVaaZYXVgi^aV\ZbdYZahVgZ\gVYjVaangZeaVXZYWnWdcZi^hhjZ# 5^T_cdUe]6c^aa"YZÄcZYVcYaVg\ZanXZaajaVgbZbWgVcZi]Via^cZhi]Z^ccZghjg[VXZd[WdcZh# 5`Y`XicYcI]ZXVeVii]ZZcYd[Vadc\WdcZi]ViYZkZadeh[gdbVhZXdcYVgndhh^ÄXVi^dcXZciZg# 5fe\cUId[dgX^WanZmigVXi 5h_cd_cYc6Wdcn\gdli][gdbVWdcZhjg[VXZ!d[iZc^ckdak^c\i]Zdhh^ÄXVi^dcd[bjhXjaVgdg a^\VbZcidjhViiVX]bZcih# 5hdUb^Q\QeTYd_bi]UQdecI]ZZVg]daZ#

8gVc^dhncdhidh^h

)'&

6_SQ\AdXVa^oZY# 6_^dQ^U\\UcHd[ihedihd[XVgi^aV\^cdjhbZbWgVcZ^ci]Zh`jaad[VcZlWdgci]ViZkZcijVaan ]VgYZcVcYijgc^cidWdcZ# 6_bQ]U^]QW^e]I]ZaVg\ZdkVa]daZ^ci]ZWVhZd[i]Zh`jaai]gdj\]l]^X]i]Zhe^cVaXdgY eVhhZh# 6_bU^cYS _cdU_\_Wi  DhiZdad\^XVa ldg` V^bZY Vi i]Z ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc d[ gZaVi^kZan gZXZcian YZ" XZVhZY^cY^k^YjVah!jhjVaanYdcZ^cVaZ\VaXdciZmi# 6bQ^[Vebd8_bYj_^dQ\6eaVcZYZÄcZYWni]gZZdhiZdbZig^Xed^cih/i]Zg^\]iVcYaZ[iedg^dc ed^cihVcYi]ZaZ[idgW^iVaZ#>i^hjhZYidhnhiZbVi^XVaandg^Zcii]Zh`jaa# 7YWQ^dYc]6XdcY^i^dcVg^h^c\[gdbVcZmXZhh^kZegdYjXi^dcd[hdbVidigde]^X]dgbdcZ!XVjh" ^c\VcdkZghi^bjaVi^dcd[\gdli]XVgi^aV\ZhVcYgZhjai^c\^c\^\Vci^Xegdedgi^dchd[i]Zh`ZaZidc# 7_]`X_cYcI]Z_d^ciWZilZZci]Zgddihd[i]ZiZZi]VcYi]ZWdcZd[i]Z_Vlh# 8Q\\ehI]ZÄghidgW^\idZ# 8QbbYc\Y^UcA^cZhd[^cXgZVhZYWdcZYZch^ini]VigZegZhZcii]Zedh^i^dcd[i]Z\gdli]eaViZVi i]Zi^bZd[^chjaiidi]Zdg\Vc^hbVcY[dgbZYdcadc\WdcZhYjZid\gdli]VggZhi# 8QfUbcYQ^SQ^Q\c6ahd`cdlcVhhZXdcYVgndhiZdch0[gZZanVcVhidbdh^c\XVcVah^cXdbeVXi WdcZi]ViXdciV^cWaddYVcYanbe]kZhhZah!cZgkZh!VcYbVggdl# 8U]Qd_`_YUdYSGZaViZYidi]ZegdYjXi^dcVcYYZkZadebZcid[gZYWaddYXZaah# 8Y^WUZ_Y^d6_d^ci!hjX]Vhi]Z`cZZdgZaWdl!Vaadl^c\bdkZbZcii]Vi^haVg\ZangZhig^XiZYid Vh^c\aZeaVcZ# 8iQ\Y^USQbdY\QWUHbddi]XVgi^aV\Zi]ViXdkZghi]ZVgi^XjaVghjg[VXZhd[WdcZh# 8iTb_hiQ`QdYdU6YZchZ!^cdg\Vc^X!b^cZgVabVig^m0i]ZhZXdcYXdbedcZcid[WdcZ# 8i`UbSU]U^d_cYc6XdcY^i^dc^cl]^X]VcZmXZhhd[XZbZcijb[dgbhdci]Zgddid[Viddi]# 8i`Ub_cd_cYc6cVWcdgbVa\gdli]d[WdcZi^hhjZ# 8i`Ub`\QcYQ6cZmXZhh^kZ\gdli]d[WdcZdgdi]Zgi^hhjZ# 8i`Ubdb_`Xi>cXgZVhZ^ci]ZkdajbZd[Vi^hhjZdgdg\Vc# 8i`_`\QcYQ6c^chj[ÄX^Zci\gdli]d[WdcZdgi^hhjZ0[dgiZZi]!YZciVaZcVbZa]nedeaVh^V^hV Y^hijgWVcXZd[ZcVbZa[dgbVi^dcl]^X]d[iZcbVc^[Zhih^ihZa[^cigVchkZghZa^cZh!e^ih!dgdi]Zg ^ggZ\jaVg^i^Zhdci]ZZcVbZahjg[VXZ# 9TY_ci^SbQdYSEZgiV^c^c\idi]Z^cY^k^YjVa# 9^SQR_^U6cZmigVhjijgVaWdcZdXXVh^dcVaan[djcY^ci]ZgZVgd[]jbVcXgVc^V# 9^S_]`\UdUVbQSdebUdgÁWbUU^cdYS[ÂVbQSdebU6[gVXijgZ^cl]^X]WgZV`V\ZVcYWZcY^c\d[ VWdcZ^hXdbW^cZY# 9^Xe]QdY_^7jg^Vadg^ciZgbZci# 9^dUb]U^d7jg^Va# 9^dUb_RcUbfUbUbb_b:ggdghiZbb^c\[gdbkVg^Vi^dc^ci]ZVXXjgVXnd[YViVgZXdgYZYWnY^[[Zg" ZcidWhZgkZghVcVano^c\i]ZhVbZi]^c\h# 9^dUb`b_hY]Q\7ZilZZcVY_VXZcihjg[VXZh!ZheZX^Vaand[iZZi]# 9^dbQ]U]RbQ^_ec_ccYÍSQdY_^6egdXZhhd[WdcZYZkZadebZci^cl]^X]WdcZhdhh^[nWnVe" edh^i^dcdci^hhjZl^i]^cVcZbWgndc^XXdccZXi^kZi^hhjZbZbWgVcZ#




9^dbQ_RcUbfUbUbb_b:ggdggZaViZYidi]ZegZX^h^dcd[YViVgZXdgYZYWni]ZhVbZdWhZgkZgVcV" ano^c\i]ZhVbZi]^c\hViY^[[ZgZcii^bZh# :_Y^d6cnXdccZXi^dcWZilZZcY^[[ZgZcih`ZaZiVaZaZbZcih# ;i`X_cYcI]ZXdaaVehZd[dcZdghZkZgVakZgiZWgVaWdY^ZhXVjh^c\Vh]VgeVc\aZ^ci]Zhe^cZ# 9I]Z]nedi]Zi^XVab^c^bjbcjbWZgd[^cY^k^YjVah i]ViXdjaYVXXdjci[dgVaad[i]ZZaZbZcih^ci]ZVhhZbWaV\Z# =Yd_SX_^TbYQ\4>1]d4>16hbVaa!cdc"cjXaZVg\ZcdbZi]Vi^h^c]Zg^iZYdcanbViZg" cVaan!d[iZcjhZY^cVcX^Zci9C6VcVanh^hWZXVjhZ^i^hZVh^ZgidgZig^ZkZi]VccjXaZVg9C6# =_b`X_WU^6bdaZXjaZi]Vi^cÅjZcXZhbdge]d\ZcZh^h# =_b`X_WU^UcYcI]ZYZkZadebZcid[[dgbYjg^c\dcid\ZcZh^h# =_b`X_\_WiI]Z[dgbVcYhigjXijgZd[VcdW_ZXi# =e\dY`\UY^dUb]U^d6Wjg^Va^cl]^X]bdgZi]VcdcZ^cY^k^YjVa^hegZhZci# >USb_cYcE]nh^dad\^XVaYZVi]d[VXZaadgV\gdjed[XZaah# >_^]UdbYSdbQYd9^X]didbdjh!Y^hXdci^cjdjh!Y^hXgZiZ!dgZe^\ZcZi^XigV^ih0cdceVi]dad\^XVa kVg^Vi^dchd[i^hhjZhY^[ÄXjaiidfjVci^[nWnbZVhjgZbZci# ?SS\ecQ\cebVQSUI]ZX]Zl^c\hjg[VXZd[i]Ziddi]# ?T_^d_R\Qcdc8Zaahi]Vi[dgbYZci^ci]gdj\]VegdXZhh`cdlcVhdYdcid\ZcZh^h# ?^d_WU^iI]ZYZkZadebZcidgXdjghZd[YZkZadebZcid[Vc^cY^k^YjVa0\gdli]# ?cceQbi6XdbbjcVa\gVkZbVYZjed[hZXdcYVg^an^ciZggZYgZbV^chd[^cY^k^YjVah^c^i^Vaan hidgZYhdbZl]ZgZZahZ# ?cdUYdYc6\ZcZgVaiZgbjhZYidgZ[ZgidVcn^cÅVbbVi^dcd[WdcZi^hhjZXVjhZYWn^c[ZXi^dc dg^c_jgn#

>cigVdWhZgkZgZggdg

)'(

?cdU_QbdXbYdYc  6ahd XVaaZY YZ\ZcZgVi^kZ _d^ci Y^hZVhZ0 i]Z bdhi Xdbbdc [dgb d[ Vgi]g^i^h! X]VgVXiZg^oZYWnVYZhigjXi^dcd[i]ZVgi^XjaVgXVgi^aV\Z^cV_d^ci!VcYVXXdbeVc^ZYWnWdcn a^ee^c\VcYhejg[dgbVi^dcVY_VXZciidi]Z_d^ci# ?cdU_R\QcdcI]ZWdcZ"[dgb^c\XZaahgZhedch^WaZ[dghnci]Zh^o^c\VcYYZedh^i^c\WdcZbViZg^Va# ?cdU_SX_^Tb_]QI]ZbdhiXdbbdcijbdgd[WdcZ0WZc^\cijbdgh!jhjVaanVhnbeidbVi^X! i]ViValVnhVg^hZViZe^e]nhZVaa^cZhVcYegdigjYZVig^\]iVc\aZhidi]Zadc\Vm^hd[VWdcZ# ?cdU_S\Qcdc8ZaahgZhedch^WaZ[dgi]ZgZhdgei^dcd[WdcZi^hhjZ# ?cdU_SidUA^k^c\WdcZXZaaYZkZadeZY[gdbVcdhiZdWaVhi# ?cdU_WU^UcYc7dcZ[dgbVi^dcVcYYZkZadebZci# ?cdU_]QD[iZcXVaaZY¹WjiidcºdhiZdbViV0VbdjcYd[XdbeVXiWdcZ!jhjVaandci]ZZXidXgV" c^Vahjg[VXZ# ?cdU_]Q\QSYQ6Y^hZVhZi]ViXVjhZhVhd[iZc^c\d[i]ZWdcZh!jhjVaana^c`ZYid\ZcZgVabVacj" ig^i^dc¸eVgi^XjaVganYZÄX^ZcX^Zh^cegdiZ^c![Vi!XVaX^jb!VcYe]dhe]dgdjh# ?cdU_]UdbYSGZaVi^c\idi]ZbZVhjgZbZcid[WdcZh# ?cdU_]iU\YdYc6c^cÅVbbVi^dcd[VWdcZXVjhZYWnWVXiZg^Vi]VijhjVaanZciZgi]ZWdcZ^c^" i^Vaank^VVldjcY# ?cdU_^6=VkZgh^VchnhiZb!i]ZhigjXijgVajc^id[XdbeVXiWdcZXdbedhZYd[VXZcigVakVhXjaVg =VkZgh^VcXVcVaVcYi]ZXdcXZcig^XaVbZaaVZhjggdjcY^c\^i0Veg^bVgndhiZdc^hXdbedhZYd[ VkVhXjaVgXVcVal^i]djiVXZbZcia^cZ!l]ZgZVhi]ZXZbZcia^cZVcYaVbZaaVgWdcZdg\Vc^oZY VgdjcYi]ZXZcigVaXVcVaX]VgVXiZg^oZVhZXdcYVgndhiZdc# ?cdU_`XidU6hbVaa!VWcdgbVaWdcndji\gdli]d[iZc[djcYVii]ZbVg\^chd[Vgi^XjaVghjg" [VXZhVhV[ZVijgZd[dhiZdVgi]g^i^h# ?cdU_`_b_cYc>cXgZVhZYedgdh^ind[WdcZYjZidVgZYjXi^dc^cWdcZb^cZgVaYZch^in# ?cdU_cQbS_]Q6bVa^\cVciijbdgd[i]ZWdcZXZaah# @Q\U_TU]_WbQ`XiI]ZhijYnd[i]ZYZbd\gVe]nd[egZ]^hidg^XedejaVi^dch# @Q\U_`QdX_\_WiI]ZhijYnd[Y^hZVhZh^cVcX^ZciedejaVi^dchVhgZkZVaZYWnh`ZaZiVagZbV^ch VcYegZhZgkZYhd[ii^hhjZh# @QbQcQWYddQ\cUSdY_^6cneaVcVgha^XZi]VieVgVaaZahi]ZhV\^iiVaeaVcZ# @QdX_\_WYSQ\VbQSdebU6[gVXijgZi]VidXXjghVhVgZhjaid[WdcZhVagZVYn]Vk^c\WZZclZV`ZcZY Wndi]ZgeVi]dad\^XVadgbZiVWda^XXdcY^i^dch!hjX]VhdhiZdedgdh^h# @UbY[i]QdQIgVchkZghZg^Y\ZhVcY\gddkZhdci]Zhjg[VXZd[iddi]ZcVbZa# @UbY]_bdU]6i!VgdjcY!dg_jhiWZ[dgZi]Zi^bZd[YZVi]# @UbY_T_^dYdYcI]Z^cÅVbbVi^dcd[i^hhjZhVgdjcYViddi]0XVc^ckdakZWdi]hd[ii^hhjZhVcY i]ZWdcZ^ihZa[# @UbY_cdUe]I]^ci^hhjZXdkZg^c\i]ZdjiZghjg[VXZd[WdcZhZmXZei^cVgZVhd[Vgi^XjaVi^dc# @UbY_cdYdYc6XdcY^i^dcd[^cÅVbbVi^dcd[i]ZeZg^dhiZjbXVjhZYWnigVjbVdg^c[ZXi^dc0XVc WZVXjiZdgX]gdc^X# @UbY_cd_cYc6WcdgbVaWdcZ[dgbVi^dcdci]ZeZg^dhiZVahjg[VXZd[VWdcZ# @YbYV_b]Q`UbdebU_bQ^dUbY_b^QcQ\Q`UbdebUI]ZdeZc^c\WZadlVcYWZilZZci]ZdgW^ih0 i]ZcdhZ]daZ#




@\Q^QbZ_Y^d6_d^cii]ViVaadlhildWdcZhidha^YZVXgdhhdcZVcdi]Zg# @_\\UhI]Zi]jbWdgÄghiY^\^id[i]Z]VcY# @_\i]UbQcUSXQY^bUQSdY_^@3B6c^bedgiVciiZX]c^fjZi]ViVXihVhV¹bdaZXjaVge]did" XdenbVX]^cZºidegdYjXZbVcnXde^Zhd[VhZXi^dcd[9C6WZ\^cc^c\l^i]_jhiV[ZlbdaZXjaZh d[9C60i]^hVaadlh9C6idWZgZig^ZkZY[gdbhdbZh`ZaZiVagZbV^ch# @_b_cYdi6XdcY^i^dc^cl]^X]bVcnhbVaadeZc^c\heVhhi]gdj\]Vhjg[VXZ# @_b_dYSXi`Ub_cd_cYcdgc`_^WiXi`Ub_cd_cYc6XdcY^i^dcZm]^W^i^c\aZh^dch!jhjVaand[i]Z XgVc^VakVjai!gZegZhZci^c\Vi]^cc^c\VcYd[iZcXdbeaZiZYZhigjXi^dcd[i]ZdjiZgiVWaZd[i]Z XgVc^VakVjai# @_cdSbQ^YQ\c[U\Ud_^6aaWdcZhZmXZeii]ZXgVc^jbVcYbVcY^WaZ# @_cd]_bdU]]_TYÍSQdY_^c6aiZgVi^dchidi]ZWdcZi]VidXXjgV[iZgi]ZYZVi]d[Vc^cY^k^Y" jVa# @bY]QbiR_^iSQ\\ecLdkZcWdcZ[dgbZYl]ZcVXVaajh^hhjWhZfjZcianb^cZgVa^oZY# @bY]QbiY^dUb]U^d6Wjg^Va^cl]^X]Vaai]ZWdcZhVgZ^cVcVcVidb^XVaan¹cVijgVaºVggVc\Z" bZci0VcVgi^XjaViZYh`ZaZidcWjg^ZY^ci]ZÅZh]# @bY]Qbi_ccYÍSQdY_^SU^dUbI]ZÄghih^iZl]ZgZWdcZWZ\^chid[dgbYjg^c\\gdli]0jhjVaan ^ci]Zh]V[id[Vadc\WdcZ!dgi]ZWdYnd[di]ZgWdcZh# @b_fU^YU^SUI]ZhigVi^\gVe]^XVcYheVi^Vaedh^i^dcd[i]ZheZX^bZc0egdkZcVcXZ# @cUeTQbdXb_cYc6cZldg[VahZ_d^ciVg^h^c\WZilZZceVgihd[V[gVXijgZYWdcZi]ViYdcdi]ZVa# BQTY_WbQ`X6c^bV\ZegdYjXZYdce]did\gVe]^XÄabl]ZcZmedhZYidM"gVnheVhh^c\i]gdj\] VcdW_ZXi# BUQSdYfUR_^U7dcZ^ci]ZegdXZhhd[WZ^c\[dgbZYdgadhi!d[iZc^cgZhedchZidVeVi]dad\^XVa hi^bjajh# BU]_TU\Y^W6XnXa^XVaegdXZhhd[WdcZgZhdgei^dcVcYYZedh^i^dcVidcZh^iZ# BUc_b`dY_^I]ZegdXZhhd[WdcZYZhigjXi^dcWndhiZdXaVhih# BXUe]Qd_YTQbdXbYdYc>cÅVbbVi^dcVcYYZ\ZcZgVi^dcd[i]Z_d^cih!eVgi^XjaVgani]dhZd[i]Z ]VcYhVcY[ZZi0jhjVaanX]gdc^XVcYVXXdbeVc^ZYWnYZ[dgb^i^Zh# BYS[Udc6[dgbd[dhiZdbVaVX^VgZhjai^c\[gdbk^iVb^c9YZÄX^ZcXn# CQTT\UcXQ`UT_bcU\\QbZ_Y^d6_d^cii]Vi^hhVYYaZ"h]VeZY!hjX]Vhi]Z_d^ciVii]ZWVhZd[i]Z i]jbW# CQWYddQ\`\Q^U6eaVcZi]ViY^k^YZhi]ZWdYn^cidhnbbZig^XVag^\]iVcYaZ[i]VakZh# CQWYddQ\cedebUI]Zb^Ya^cZhjijgZi]VieVhhZhWZilZZci]ZeVg^ZiVaWdcZh# CQbS_]Q6bVa^\cVciijbdgd[XdccZXi^kZi^hhjZ# CSQ^^Y^W U\USdb_^ ]YSb_cS_`U C5=  6 YZk^XZ i]Vi egdYjXZh Vc ^bV\Z d[ i]Z hjg[VXZ d[ V bZiVa"XdViZYheZX^bZcWni]ZgZÅZXi^dcd[ZaZXigdch# CUS_^TQbiSU^dUb_V_ccYÍSQdY_^8ZciZgd[WdcZ[dgbVi^dci]ViVeeZVghV[iZgi]Zeg^bVgn XZciZg!hjX]Vhi]ZZe^e]nh^hd[Vadc\WdcZ# CUS_^TQbiY^dUb]U^d6Wjg^Va^cl]^X]i]ZWdcZhd[Vh`ZaZidcVgZY^hVgi^XjaViZY# CUbYQ\X_]_\_Wi8dggZhedcYZcXZd[eVgih^chZfjZci^VaWdcZh!Vh^ci]ZkZgiZWgVZ# CUcQ]_YTR_^UcHbVaaWdcZhi]Via^Zl^i]^ciZcYdchcZVgV_d^ci#

EaVciVg_d^ci

)'*

CUheQ\TY]_b`XYc]9^[[ZgZcXZhWZilZZcbVaZhVcY[ZbVaZh# CX_fU\cXQ`UTY^SYc_bc>cX^hdghl^i]higdc\anYZkZadeZYbZh^VaVcYY^hiVaa^c\jVabVg\^cVa g^Y\Zh!^beVgi^c\V¹h]dkZaºVeeZVgVcXZidi]Ziddi]# CY^ecUcKd^YX]VbWZgh^ci]ZXgVc^VaWdcZhi]ViZcaVg\Zl^i]i]Z\gdli]d[i]Z[VXZ0[djgWVh^X hZih!dcZZVX]^ci]ZbVm^aaVZ![gdciVa!Zi]bd^Y!VcYhe]Zcd^Y# C[e\\I]ZWdcZhd[i]Z]ZVY!^cXajY^c\Wdi]XgVc^jbVcYbVcY^WaZ# C`XU^__SSY`YdQ\_bRQcY\QbcedebU6XijVaanVhncX]dcYgdh^h0a^ZhWZilZZci]Zhe]Zcd^YVcY i]ZdXX^e^iVa# C`\Q^SX^_SbQ^Ye]I]Z[VX^Vah`ZaZidc# CaeQ]_cQ\cedebU6cjcjhjVa!hXVaZ"a^`Z!WZkZaZYhjijgZWZilZZci]ZiZbedgVaVcYeVg^ZiVa WdcZh# CdQ^TQbTQ^Qd_]YSQ\`_cYdY_^HiVcY^c\l^i][ZZiid\Zi]ZgVcYed^ci^c\[dglVgY!add`^c\[dg" lVgY!l^i]cdcZd[i]Zadc\WdcZhXgdhhZY[gdbk^ZlZg¼heZgheZXi^kZVcYeVabh[VX^c\[dglVgY# CeRSX_^TbQ\R_^UI]ZXdbeVXiWdcZXdkZgZYWnXVgi^aV\ZVii]Z_d^cih# Ce`Ub^e]UbQbidUUdXIZZi]i]ViZmXZZYi]ZZmeZXiZYcjbWZgd[iZZi]^cVcn\^kZcXViZ\dgn# CedebUc6gi^XjaVi^dchd[i]Zh`jaaWdcZhVadc\_d^cihl^i]^ciZgadX`^c\!hVliddi]!dgo^eeZg"a^`Z Vgi^XjaVi^dch# Ci]`XicYc6ineZd[XVgi^aV\^cdjh_d^ci^cl]^X]ÄWgdXVgi^aV\ZWZilZZci]ZWdcZhjg[VXZh^h XdkZgZYWnVi]^caVnZgd[]nVa^cZXVgi^aV\Z# Ci^TUc]_cYcI^\]i!^cÅZm^WaZÄWgdjh_d^ciWZilZZcWdcZhjc^iZYWnWVcYhd[YZchZÄWgdjh i^hhjZ^ci]Z[dgbd[bZbWgVcZhdga^\VbZcih# Ci^_cd_cYcI]ZgZhjail]ZcVcnildWdcnZaZbZcih[jhZid\Zi]Zg# Ci^_fYQ\Z_Y^dc;gZZanbdk^c\_d^cihhjX]Vhi]Z]^e!ZaWdl!`cZZ!VcYi]jbWi]ViVgZXdViZY l^i]Vi]^caVnZgd[]nVa^cZXVgi^aV\Z!VcYajWg^XViZYWnhncdk^VaÅj^Yl^i]^cVÄWgdjh_d^ci XVehjaZ# DQ\_^YTI]ZY^hiVaedhiZg^dgedgi^dcd[Veg^bViZbdaVgVYYZYidi]ZbdY^ÄZYdg^\^cVaig^" Vc\aZd[Xjheh0jhZhj[Äm"^Y[dgadlZgbdaVgh# DQ`X_^_]iI]ZhijYnd[egdXZhhZhi]ViV[[ZXih`ZaZiVagZbV^chWZilZZcYZVi]VcYXjgVi^dc# DQeb_T_^dYc]I]ZXdcY^i^dc^cl]^X]i]ZejaeX]VbWZg^hZcaVg\ZYgZaVi^kZidi]ZcdgbVa XdcY^i^dc# DU]`_bQ\Yc ]ecS\U  I]Z bjhXaZ dg^\^cVi^c\ dc i]Z h^YZ d[ i]Z XgVc^Va kVjai ^c[Zg^dg id i]Z hjeZg^dg iZbedgVa a^cZ VcY ^chZgi^c\ dc i]Z h^YZh! VeZm! VcY VciZg^dg hjg[VXZ d[ i]Z Xdgdcd^Y egdXZhhd[i]ZbVcY^WaZ# D=:IZbedgdbVcY^WjaVg_d^ci0i]Z_Vl_d^ciWZilZZci]ZbVcY^WaZVcYXgVc^jb# DbU`XY^QdY_^dbU`Q^QdY_^6egVXi^XZ^cl]^X]VcVgi^ÄX^Va]daZ^hbVYZ^ci]ZXgVc^VakVjai d[Va^k^c\eZghdc# DbYW_^YTI]ZbZh^VaVciZg^dgedgi^dcd[Veg^bViZbdaVgXdbeg^h^c\i]ZbdY^ÄZYdg^\^cVa ig^Vc\aZd[Xjheh0jhZhj[Äm"^Y[dgadlZgbdaVgh# Di`_\_WiI]ZegVXi^XZd[X]ddh^c\dcZ^cY^k^YjVaidX]VgVXiZg^oZVheZX^Zh# G_b]YQ^R_^U6cnd[i]ZhbVaa!^ggZ\jaVgWdcZhVadc\i]ZXgVc^VahjijgZh0ZmigVhjijgVaWdcZ#




!PPENDIX

:aZXigdc^XGZhdjgXZh[dg =jbVcDhiZdad\n JhZldgYhVcYe]gVhZhhjX]Vh]jbVcdhiZdad\n![dgZch^XVgX]Zdad\n![dgZch^XhX^ZcXZ! ]jbVc h`ZaZidc! eVaZdeVi]dad\n! h`ZaZiVa W^dad\n! ]jbVc WdcZ! eVaZdVci]gdedad\n! gVY^dad\n!ZiX#^cndjg>ciZgcZihZVgX]Zc\^cZidZmeadgZi]Zbng^VYZaZXigdc^XgZhdjgXZh VkV^aVWaZidi]ZhijYZciVcYegd[Zhh^dcVa# I]Z[daadl^c\^hVhZid[]VcYnZaZXigdc^XgZhdjgXZh^ckdak^c\]jbVcdhiZdad\nVcY hdbZd[i]ZbVcnY^hX^ea^cZhVhhdX^ViZYl^i]^i# '%.%2!, Xdd`*gggWU_SYdYUcS_]3Q`U3Q^QfUbQ\cigdYjXi^dcidgVY^dad\n Xdd`*ggg\YRcYeUTeX`TYfYcY_^ccSYXUQ\dX]bQTY_WbXd]  A^c`hidgVY^dad\nVcYgVY^d\gVe]nlZWh^iZh Xdd`*gggbQTgQcXY^Wd_^UTedUQSXY^WÍ\UcXd]\  GVY^dad\nh^iZ )',

0!,%/0!4(/,/'9 Xdd`*ggg]YS[YcU4YcUQcUcY^TUhXd]\  >cYZmd[Y^hZVhZh Xdd`*ggg]UbS[S_]]]XUY^TUhXd]\  BZgX`BVcjVadca^cZ 02/&%33)/.!,!33/#)!4)/.3 Xdd`*gggQQVc_bW  6bZg^XVc6XVYZbnd[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh Xdd`*ggg`XicQ^dX_bW  6bZg^XVc6hhdX^Vi^dcd[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\^hih Xdd`*gggQQQ^Ud_bW  6bZg^XVc6ci]gdedad\^XVa6hhdX^Vi^dc Xdd`*]_^[UicRc_XY_cdQdUUTe411Y^TUhXd]  9ZciVa6ci]gdedad\n6hhdX^Vi^dc Xdd`*gggQbSXQU_\_WYSQ\_bWgURY^V_`X`/`QWU-! !&  I]Z6gX]VZdad\^XVa>chi^ijiZd[6bZg^XV/HZVgX]ldgaYl^YZ[dgÉZaYldg`deedgijc^i^Zh .!4)6%!-%2)#!.'2!6%302/4%#4)/.!.$2%0!42)!4)/. Xdd`*gggSb^`cW_f^QW`bQ  CVi^dcVaEVg`HZgk^XZlZWh^iZ[dgcVi^dcVaC6<EG6 Xdd`*gggSQcdeQb[UTe_dXUb^`c^QW`bQ  CVi^dcVaC6<EG6dca^cZYViVWVhZ #/-0!2!4)6%!.!4/-9 Xdd`*gURQecdY^edUhQcUTeUc[U\Ud_^c  8dbeVgVi^kZh`ZaZiVaVcVidbn ).3425-%.43 Xdd`*ggg`Q\U_dUSXS_]  >chigjbZcih[dge]nh^XVaVci]gdedad\^hih



6eeZcY^m

7^Wa^d\gVe]n 6YVbh!7#?#!VcY@dc^\hWZg\!A#L#'%%)#:hi^bVi^dcd[i]Zbdhia^`ZancjbWZgd[^cY^k^Yj" Vah [gdb Xdbb^c\aZY ]jbVc h`ZaZiVa gZbV^ch# 6bZg^XVc ?djgcVa d[ E]nh^XVa 6ci]gdedad\n &'*/&(-·&*&# 6\VglVa!H#8#!VcYHidji!H#9#'%%(#7dcZAdhhVcYDhiZdedgdh^h/6c6ci]gdedad\^XVaEZgheZXi^kZ# CZlNdg`/@ajlZg6XVYZb^X# 6^Zaad!A#8#!VcYBdaaZhdc!I#&..(#6gZb^XgdhXde^XV\Z^c\iZX]c^fjZhbdgZVXXjgViZi]Vc bVXgdhXde^XV\Z^c\iZX]c^fjZh4?djgcVad[6gX]VZdad\^XVaHX^ZcXZ'%/+-.·,%)# 6bWgdhZ!H#8#&..(#>hdide^XVcVanh^hd[eVaZdY^Zih/BZi]dYdad\^XVaVcY^ciZgegZi^kZXdch^Y" ZgVi^dch#>c/B#@#HVcY[dgYZY#>ckZhi^\Vi^dchd[6cX^Zci=jbVcI^hhjZ/8]Zb^XVa6cVanhZh^c 6ci]gdedad\n#ee#*.·&(%#AVc\]dgcZ!EZcchankVc^V/ciZgcVi^dcVa?djgcVad[DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n&/*,·+&# 6bWgdhZ! H# =#! VcY @VioZcWZg\! B# 6# ZYh# '%%%# 7^d\ZdX]Zb^XVa 6eegdVX]Zh id EVaZdY^ZiVgn 6cVanh^h#CZlNdg`/@ajlZg6XVYZb^X$EaZcjbEjWa^h]Zgh# 6cYZghdc!9#A#!I]dbehdc!<#L#!VcYEdedk^X]!;#&.,+#6\Zd[ViiV^cbZcid[b^cZgVa^oVi^dc hiV\Zhd[i]ZeZgbVcZciYZci^i^dc#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh'&/&.&·'%%# 6ci‹c!H#8#&.-.#>ciZci^dcVaXgVc^VakVjaiYZ[dgbVi^dcVcY^cYjXZYX]Vc\Zhd[i]ZXgVc^Va WVhZVcY[VXZ#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n,./'*(·'+,# 6gZch!L#&.,.#I]ZBVc":Vi^c\Bni]#Dm[dgY/Dm[dgYJc^kZgh^inEgZhh# 6g^hbZcY^!?#A#!7V`Zg!A#:#!VcYBViiZhdc!@#?#'%%)#:[[ZXihd[egdXZhh^c\iZX]c^fjZhdci]Z [dgZch^X9C6VcVanh^hd[]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)./&·*# 6gbZaV\dh!<#?#!8Vgahdc!9#H#!VcYKVcc/;#HeZcXZgZY#6=^hidgnd[6bZg^XVcE]nh^XVa6ci]gdeda" d\n&.(%"&.-%#ee#(%*·('-#CZlNdg`/6XVYZb^XEgZhh# 6gcdii!G#!;^c\Zg!H#!VcYHb^i]!8#J#B#!ZYh#'%%(#IgZeVcVi^dc/=^hidgn!9^hXdkZgn!I]Zdgn# A^hhZ!CZi]ZgaVcYh/HlZihVcYOZ^ia^c\Zg# 6j[YZg]Z^YZ!6#8#!VcYGdYg†\jZo"BVgi†c!8#&..-#I]Z8VbWg^Y\Z:cXnXadeZY^Vd[=jbVcEV" aZdeVi]dad\n#8VbWg^Y\Z!:c\aVcY/8VbWg^Y\ZJc^kZgh^inEgZhh# 6jhi^c"Hb^i]!9#!VcYBVeaZh!L#G#&..)#I]ZgZa^VW^a^ind[h`jaa$e]did\gVe]hjeZg^bedh^i^dc ^c^cY^k^YjVa^YZci^ÄXVi^dc#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(./))+")**# 7VXX^cd:#!JWZaV`Zg!9#=#!=VnZ`!A#6#8#!VcYOZg^aa^!6#&...#:kVajVi^dcd[hZkZcbZi]dYh d[Zhi^bVi^c\V\ZViYZVi][gdbbVijgZ]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh ))/.(&·.(+#

)'.

7V`Zg!7#?#!VcY6gbZaV\dh!<#?#&.--#I]Zdg^\^cVcYVci^fj^ind[hne]^a^h#8jggZci6ci]gdedad\n './,%(·,(,# 7V`Zg!H#?#!<^aa!<#L#!VcY@^Z[[Zg!9#6#&..%#GVXZVcYhZmYZiZgb^cVi^dc[gdbi]Z^ciZgXdcYn" aVgcdiX]d[i]ZY^hiVa[Zbjg#6ci]gdedad\^XVaEVeZghCjbWZg)/.&·.*#>c/<#L#<^aaVcYH# G]^cZZYh#H`ZaZiVa6iig^Wji^dcd[GVXZ/BZi]dYh[dg;dgZch^X6ci]gdedad\n#6aWjfjZgfjZ!CZl BZm^Xd/BVmlZaaBjhZjbd[6ci]gdedad\n# 7Vcc^c\!:#7#'%%'#6gX]VZdad\^XVaHjgkZn#CZlNdg`/@ajlZg6XVYZb^X$EaZcjb# 7Vhh!L#B#&..*#=jbVcDhiZdad\n/6AVWdgVidgnVcY;^ZaYBVcjVa(gY:Y##8dajbW^V!B^h" hdjg^/B^hhdjg^6gX]VZdad\^XVaHdX^Zin# 7ZVgY!7#A#!VcY?d]chdc!8#B#'%%%#Higdci^jb^hdideZXdbedh^i^dcd[h`ZaZiVabViZg^VaXVc YZiZgb^cZi]ZW^gi]eaVXZVcY\Zd\gVe]^XbdW^a^ind[]jbVchVcYVc^bVah#?djgcVad[;dgZc" h^XHX^ZcXZh)*/&%).·&%+&# 7Z]gZchbZnZg!6#@#!VcY=^aa!6#E#&.-%#;dhh^ah^ci]ZBV`^c\#8]^XV\d/Jc^kZgh^ind[8]^XV\d EgZhh# 7ZccZii! @# 6# &..(# 6 ;^ZaY >YZci^ÉXVi^dc <j^YZ [dg =jbVc H`ZaZiVa >YZci^ÉXVi^dc 'cY :Y## Heg^c\ÄZaY!>aa^cd^h/8#8#I]dbVh# 7ZgbYZoYZ8Vhigd!?#B#!9jgVcY!6#>#!VcY>e^ŠV!H#A#&..(#HZmjVaY^bdge]^hb^ci]Z]j" bVc YZciVa hVbeaZ [gdb i]Z H= h^iZ H^ZggV YZ 6iVejZgXV! HeV^c/ 6 hiVi^hi^XVa VeegdVX]# ?djgcVad[=jbVc:kdaji^dc')/)(·*+# 7ZggnbVc!=#:#!7Vhh!L#B#!HnbZh!H#6#!VcYHb^i]!D#8#&..&#GZXd\c^i^dcd[XZbZiZgn gZbV^ch^ci]Z[dgZch^XhZii^c\#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(+/'(%·'(,# 7ZnZg"DahZc!:#B#H#!VcY6aZmVcYZghZc!K#&..*#HZmVhhZhhbZcid[bZY^ZkVaCdglZ\^Vch`Za" ZidchWVhZYdceZgbVcZciiddi]Xgdlch^oZ#>ciZgcVi^dcVa?djgcVad[DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n*/',)· '-&# 7^c[dgY!A#G#&.-&#7dcZh/6cX^ZciBZcVcYBdYZgcBni]h#CZlNdg`/6XVYZb^XEgZhh# 7aVX`!H#!VcYHX]ZjZg!A#&..,#I]Zdcid\ZcZi^XYZkZadebZcid[i]ZXZgk^XVag^W#>ciZgcVi^dcVa ?djgcVad[DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n,/'·&%# 7ajbZchX]^cZ!G#?#!BVgZVc!8#L#!VcY8VeVaYd!H#9#&..+#7a^cYiZhihd[^ciZg"VcVanhiXdggZ" hedcYZcXZVcYVXXjgVXn^ci]Z^YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[XjibVg`h!eZgXjhh^dcbVg`h!VcYXVgc^kdgZ iddi]bVg`hdcWdcZhjg[VXZh#?djgcVad[6gX]VZdad\^XVaHX^ZcXZ'(/).(·*%,# 7dYY^c\idc!6#&.-,#;gdbWdcZhidedejaVi^dc/I]ZegdWaZbd[cjbWZgh#>c/6#7dYY^c\idc! 6#C#cigdYjXi^dcid6[g^XVc8VkZIVe]dcdbn#8]^" XV\d/Jc^kZgh^ind[8]^XV\dEgZhh# 7g^Y\Zh!E#H#&..'#EgZ]^hidg^XVgi]g^i^h^ci]Z6bZg^XVh#6ccjVaGZk^Zld[6ci]gdedad\n'&/+,· .&# 7g^Y\Zh!E#H#&..(#I]ZZ[[ZXid[kVg^Vi^dc^cbZi]dYdad\ndci]ZdjiXdbZd[dhiZdVgi]g^i^X hijY^Zh#>ciZgcVi^dcVa?djgcVad[DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n(/'-.·'.*# 7gdd`h!H#!VcYHjX]Zn!?#B#&..%#H`ZaZiVaV\ZYZiZgb^cVi^dcWVhZYdci]ZdhejW^h/6XdbeVg" ^hdcd[i]Z6Xh{Y^"CZbZh`‚g^VcYHjX]Zn"7gdd`hbZi]dYh#=jbVc:kdaji^dc*/'',·'(-# 7gdd`h!H#I#&.**#H`ZaZiVaV\ZViYZVi]/GZa^VW^a^ind[XgVc^VaVcYejW^XV\Z^cY^XVidgh#6bZg^" XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n&(/*+,·*.,# 7gdi]lZaa!9#G#&.-&#9^\\^c\Je7dcZh(gY:Y##>i]VXV!CZlNdg`/8dgcZaaJc^kZgh^inEgZhh#



7^Wa^d\gVe]n

# 7gdi]lZaa!9#G#&.-.#I]ZgZaVi^dch]^ed[iddi]lZVgidV\^c\#>c/B#N#>h¨XVc!ZY#6\ZBVg`" Zgh^ci]Z=jbVcH`ZaZidc#ee#(%(·(&+#Heg^c\ÄZaY!>aa^cd^h/8#8#I]dbVh# 7gdlc!@#'%%%#6cX^Zci9C6Veea^XVi^dch^c]jbVcdhiZdVgX]VZdad\n/6X]^ZkZbZcih!egdW" aZbhVcYediZci^Va#>c/B#8dmVcYH#BVnhZYh#=jbVcDhiZdad\n^c6gX]VZdad\nVcY;dgZc" h^XHX^ZcXZ#ee#)**·),(#AdcYdc/c/ :# L^aa^Vbh ZY# =jbVc GZbV^ch/ 8dchZgkVi^dc!GZig^ZkVaVcY6cVanh^h#Dm[dgY!:c\aVcY/6gX]VZdegZhh7#6#G#>ciZgcVi^dcVa HZg^Zh.()#ee#&*(·&+*# 7gj• oä Z`!?#'%%'#6bZi]dY[dgk^hjVaYZiZgb^cVi^dcd[hZm!jh^c\i]Z]jbVc]^eWdcZ#6bZg^" XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n&&,/&*,·&+-# 7jX`!H#'%%(#HZVgX]^c\[dg\gVkZhjh^c\\Zde]nh^XVaiZX]cdad\n/;^ZaYiZhihl^i]\gdjcYeZc" ZigVi^c\gVYVg!bV\cZidbZign!VcYZaZXig^XVagZh^hi^k^in#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)-/&·,# 7jX`aZn!=#G#!VcY9^Vh!<#?#'%%'#I]ZY^hig^Wji^dcd[h`ZaZiVaaZh^dch^cigZedcZbVaY^hZVhZ/ >hi]Zanbe]Vi^XhnhiZbgZhedch^WaZ4>ciZgcVi^dcVa?djgcVad[DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n&'/&,-·&--# 7j^`higV!?#:#&.-&V#6heZX^Va^hi^cVcX^ZciXZbZiZgnhijY^Zhadd`hVii]ZgZWjg^Va^hhjZ#:Vgan BVc(/'+·',# 7j^`higV!?#:#ZY#&.-&W#EgZ]^hidg^XIjWZgXjadh^h^ci]Z6bZg^XVh#:kVchidc!>aa^cd^h/Cdgi]" lZhiZgcJc^kZgh^in6gX]VZdad\^XVaEgd\gVb# 7j^`higV!?#:#&.-(#GZWjg^Va/=dllZVaaadhZ#HdX^Zin[dg8Va^[dgc^V6gX]VZdad\nCZlhaZiiZg&,/&# 7j^`higV!?#:#!VcY8dd`!9#8#&.-%#EVaZdeVi]dad\n/6c6bZg^XVcVXXdjci#6ccjVaGZk^Zl d[6ci]gdedad\n./)((·),%# 7j^`higV!?#:#!VcYJWZaV`Zg!9#=#&..)#HiVcYVgYh[dg9ViV8daaZXi^dc[gdb=jbVcH`ZaZiVaGZ" bV^ch#;VnZiiZk^aaZ!6g`VchVh/6g`VchVh6gX]VZdad\^XVaHjgkZnGZedgiCjbWZg))# 7j^`higV! ?# :#! VcY B^Za`Z! ?# =# &.-*# 9Zbd\gVe]n! Y^Zi VcY ]ZVai]# >c/ G# ># <^aWZgi VcY ?# =#B^Za`ZZYh#I]Z6cVanh^hd[EgZ]^hidg^X9^Zih#ee#(*.·)''#DgaVcYd!;adg^YV#6XVYZb^X EgZhh# 7jgg!9#7#&.-%#I]ZgZaVi^dch]^ehVbdc\e]nh^XVa!\ZdbZig^XVaVcYbZX]Vc^XVaegdeZgi^Zhd[ WdcZ!l^i]VcdiZdci]ZegdeZgi^Zhd[cdc]jbVceg^bViZWdcZ#NZVgWdd`d[E]nh^XVa6ci]gd" edad\n'(/&%.·&)+# 7jggdlh!6#B#!OVcZaaV!K#E#!VcY7gdlc!I#B#'%%(#IZhi^c\i]ZkVa^Y^ind[bZiVXVgeVajhZ^c hZmVhhZhhZcid[]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)-/&·)# 8V[[Zaa!6#8#!GdWZgih!8#6#!?VcVlVn!G#8#!VcYL^ahdc!6#H#'%%&#EgZhhjgZhdcdhiZdad\^XVa XdaaZXi^dch¸i]Z ^bedgiVcXZ d[ YVbV\Z a^b^iVi^dc# >c/ :# L^aa^Vbh ZY# =jbVc GZbV^ch/ 8dchZgkVi^dc!GZig^ZkVaVcY6cVanh^h#ee#&-,·&.,#Dm[dgY!:c\aVcY/6gX]VZdegZhh7#6#G#>c" iZgcVi^dcVaHZg^Zh.()# 8VaYlZaa!E#8#&.-+#CZlfjZhi^dchVcYhdbZVchlZghdci]Z[VX^VagZegdYjXi^dciZX]c^fjZh# >c/@#?#GZ^X]hZY#;dgZch^XDhiZdad\n/6YkVcXZh^ci]Z>YZci^ÉXVi^dcd[=jbVcGZbV^ch#ee# ''.·'**#Heg^c\ÄZaY!>aa^cd^h/8#8#I]dbVh# 8VgdaVc!K#6#!/I]Z^ciZgcVi^dcVahnhiZbd[jc^ih#>c/K#=#;gVc`ZaVcYB#CdgY^cZYh# 7Vh^X7^dbZX]Vc^Xhd[i]ZH`ZaZiVaHnhiZb#ee#&·&&#E]^aVYZae]^V/AZVVcY;ZW^\Zg# 8]VbWZgaV^c!6#'%%%#EgdWaZbhVcYegdheZXih^ceVaVZdYZbd\gVe]n#>c/B#8dmVcYH#BVnh ZYh#=jbVcDhiZdad\n^c6gX]VZdad\nVcY;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZ#ee#&%&·&&*#AdcYdc/bea^XVi^dch[dgiZhi^bdcnVcYgZhZVgX]^c

7^Wa^d\gVe]n

)(&

[dgZch^XVci]gdedad\nVcYi]ZjhZd[[gdciVah^cjhZh^ceZghdcVa^YZci^ÄXVi^dc#?djgcVad[ ;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)./&·)# 8aVg`Z!C#<#!VcY=^ghX]!G#H#&..&#E]nh^dad\^XVa!ejaeVa!VcYeZg^dYdciVa[VXidgh^cÅjZcX" ^c\VakZdaVgWdcZ#>c/B#6#@ZaaZnVcY8#H#AVghZcZYh#6YkVcXZh^c9ZciVa6ci]gdedad\n# ee#')&"'++#CZlNdg`/L^aZn"A^hh# 8aVg`Z!G#?#!VcY=dlZaa!;#8#&.,'#6[Äc^i^Zhd[i]ZHlVgi`gVch-),=db^c^Y8gVc^jb# 6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n(,/(&.·((*# 8aZbZci!?#<#!VcYGVchdc!9#A#ZYh#&..-#8gVc^d[VX^Va>YZci^ÉXVi^dc^c;dgZch^XBZY^X^cZ# AdcYdc/6gcdaY# 8d]Zc!B#C#&..)#I]ZdhiZdad\^XVaeVgVYdmgZXdch^YZgZY#8jggZci6ci]gdedad\n(*/+'.·+(,# 8d]Zc!B#C#!VcY6gbZaV\dh!<#?#ZYh#&.-*#EVaZdeVi]dad\nVii]ZDg^\^chd[6\g^XjaijgZ#Dg" aVcYd!;adg^YV/6XVYZb^XEgZhh# 8dccdg!6#!VcYHidcZ`^c\!B#&..)#6hhZhh^c\Zi]c^X^in[gdb]jbVcb^idX]dcYg^Va9C6 ineZhYZiZgb^cZYWn]nWg^Y^oVi^dcl^i]hZfjZcXZ"heZX^ÄXda^\dcjXaZdi^YZh#?djgcVad[;d" gZch^XHX^ZcXZh(./&(+%·&(,&# 8dccdg!B#VcYHXdii!9#'%%&#EVgVY^\bhVcYeZgeZigVidgh#=^hidg^XVa6gX]VZdad\n(*/&·+# 8dda!H#B#!=ZcYg^`o!?#@#!VcYLddY!L#7#&..*#B^XgdhXde^XV\ZX]Vc\Zh^ci]Z]jbVc dXX^e^iVaWdcZ#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)%/,-.·,.+# 8dm!B#'%%%V#6\Z^c\VYjaih[gdbi]Zh`ZaZidc#>c/B#8dmVcYH#BVnhZYh#=jbVcDhiZda" d\n^c6gX]VZdad\nVcY;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZ#ee#+&·-&#AdcYdc/c/B#8dmVcYH#BVnhZYh#=jbVcDhiZdad\n^c 6gX]VZdad\nVcY;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZ#ee#&(&·&)'#AdcYdc/ciZgcVi^dcVa?djgcVad[DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n (/'.,·(%'# 9VkZcedgi!<#8#'%%&#GZbdiZhZch^c\Veea^XVi^dch^c[dgZch^X^ckZhi^\Vi^dch#=^hidg^XVa6g" X]VZdad\n(*/-,·&%%# 9Z


7^Wa^d\gVe]n

9^g`bVVi!9#8#!VcY6YdkVh^d!?#B#&..,#I]ZgdaZd[VgX]VZdad\n^ci]ZgZXdkZgnVcY^ciZg" egZiVi^dcd[]jbVcgZbV^ch[gdbVcdjiYddg[dgZch^XhZii^c\#>c/L#9#=V\ajcYVcYB#=# Hdg\ZYh#;dgZch^XIVe]dcdbn#ee#(.·+)#7dXVGVidc!;adg^YV/8G8EgZhh# 9dWcZn!@#!VcY7gdi]lZaa!9#&.-+#9ZciVaXVaXjajh/>ihgZaZkVcXZidVcX^ZciY^ZiVcYdgVa ZXdad\n#7g^i^h]6gX]VZdad\^XVaGZedgih/>ciZgcVi^dcVaHZg^Zh'.&/**·-&# 9dccZaan!H#B#!=Zch!H#B#!Gd\Zgh!C#A#!VcYHX]cZ^YZg!@#A#&..-#IZX]c^XVacdiZ/6Wa^cY iZhid[bVcY^WjaVggVbjhÅZmjgZVhVbdge]dad\^X^cY^XVidgd[hZmjVaY^bdge]^hb^ci]Z ]jbVch`ZaZidc#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n&%,/(+(·(++# 9gZ^Zg!;#<#&..)#6\ZViYZVi]Zhi^bViZh[dgi]Zegdid]^hidg^X6g^`VgVjh^c\bdaVgViig^i^dc gViZh/6cZlfjVci^ÄXVi^dcbZi]dY#>ciZgcVi^dcVa?djgcVad[DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n)/&(·&),# 9gjh^c^!6#<#!Idhd!D#!VcYGVcoVid!8#&..,#I]ZXdgdcVaejaeXVk^in^cYZm/6W^dbVg`Zg [dgV\ZYZiZgb^cVi^dc^c]jbVcVYjaih#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n&%(/(*(· (+(# 9jYVg!?#8#&..(#>YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[g^WcjbWZgVcYVhhZhhbZcid[^ciZgXdhiVakVg^Vi^dcVii]Z hiZgcVaZcY#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(-/,--·,.,# 9jYVn!=#&.,-#6gX]‚dad\^Z[jc‚gV^gZZiVci]gdedad\^Z/6eea^XVi^dcYZhgZaZk‚hZiYZa¼‚ijYZ dhi‚dad\^fjZ | fjZafjZh h‚ejaijgZh eg‚" Zi egdid]^hidg^fjZ Yj b^Y^ YZ aV ;gVcXZ# 8V]^Zgh YÀ6ci]gdedad\^Z&/**·&%&# 9jYVn!=#!VcYBVhhZi!8#ZYh#&.-,#6ci]gdedad\^ZE]nh^fjZZi6gX]‚dad\^Z#EVg^h/8#C#G#H# :Y\Vg!=#?#=#'%%*#EgZY^Xi^dcd[gVXZjh^c\X]VgVXiZg^hi^Xhd[YZciVabdge]dad\n#?djgcVad[ ;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh*%/&·*# :a"CV__Vg!B#N#!VcYBXL^aa^Vbh!@#G#&.,-#;dgZch^X6ci]gdedad\n#Heg^c\ÄZaY!>aa^cd^h/8# 8#I]dbVh# :ehiZ^c!;#=#&.-.#I]ZW^dad\nd[dhiZdVgi]g^i^h#CZl:c\aVcY?djgcVad[BZY^X^cZ('%/&(''· &((%# :g^X`hZc!B#;#&..&#=^hidad\^XZhi^bVi^dcd[V\ZViYZVi]jh^c\i]ZVciZg^dgXdgiZmd[i]Z [Zbjg#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n-)/&,&·&,.# :h]ZY!K#!AVi^bZg!7#!#'%%'#7jiidcdhiZdbV/>ihZi^dad\nVcYeVi]de]nh^dad\n#6bZg^XVc?djgcVa d[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n&&-/'&,·'(%# ;VahZii^!6#7#&..*#HZmVhhZhhbZci[gdbbZiVXVgeVahd[i]Z]jbVc]VcY#?djgcVad[;dgZch^X HX^ZcXZh)%/,,)·,,+# ;VoZ`Vh!<#!VcY@‹hV!;#&.,-#;dgZch^X;ZiVaDhiZdad\n#7jYVeZhi/6`VY‚b^V^@^VY‹# ;ZYZg!=#6#&..&#HjXXZZY^c\VhVc:meZgiL^icZhh#CZlNdg`/KVcCdhigVcYGZ^c]daY# ;ZaYZhbVc!B#G#!VcY;djciV^c!G#A#&..+#¹GVXZºheZX^ÄX^inVcYi]Z[Zbjg$hiVijgZgVi^d# 6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n&%%/'%,·'')# ;ZaYbVcc!G#B#!8]VebVc!G#:#!VcY=Vcc^WVa!?#I#ZYh#&.-.#EVaZdiZX]c^fjZh#@cdmk^aaZ! IZccZhhZZ/EVaZdcidad\^XVaHdX^ZinHeZX^VaEjWa^XVi^dcCjbWZg)# ;Zcidc!I#L#!7^g`Wn!L#=#!VcY8dgcZa^hdc!?#'%%(#6[VhiVcYhV[ZcdcWaZVX]^c\bZi]dY [dg[dgZch^Xh`ZaZiVaegZeVgVi^dc#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)-/&·(# ;^ccZ\Vc! B# &.,-# Cdc"bZig^X kVg^Vi^dc d[ i]Z ^c[gVXgVc^Va h`ZaZidc# ?djgcVa d[ 6cVidbn &'*/'(·(,# ;^io\ZgVaY!8#B#!VcYGdhZ!?#8#'%%%#GZVY^c\WZilZZci]Za^cZh/9ZciVaYZkZadebZciVcY hjWVYjaiV\ZVhhZhhbZcijh^c\i]Zb^XgdhigjXijgVa\gdli]bVg`Zghd[iZZi]#>c/B#6#@Vi" oZcWZg\VcYH#HVjcYZghZYh#7^dad\^XVa6ci]gdedad\nd[i]Z=jbVcH`ZaZidc#ee#&+(·&-+# CZlNdg`/L^aZn"A^hh# ;dgb^XdaV!K#&..(#HiVijgZgZXdchigjXi^dc[gdbadc\WdcZh^cVcX^ZciedejaVi^dchVbeaZh/ 6c VeegdVX] id i]Z egdWaZb d[ ^ih gZa^VW^a^in# 6bZg^XVc ?djgcVa d[ E]nh^XVa 6ci]gdedad\n .%/(*&·(*-# ;dm!8#A#&..'#>c[dgbVi^dcdWiV^cZY[gdbi]Zb^XgdhXde^XZmVb^cVi^dcd[XjaijgVahig^V" i^dch^c]jbVcYZci^i^dc#>ciZgcVi^dcVa?djgcVad[DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n'/&**·&+.# ;gVcXZ!9#A#!
7^Wa^d\gVe]n

)((

6gbWgjhi!8#I#!@dcYgVi^Z[[!7#!CZahdc!6#!8VhiZaaVcd!@#!VcY=de`^ch!9#&..'#6bja" i^Y^hX^ea^cVgnVeegdVX]idi]ZYZiZXi^dcd[XaVcYZhi^cZ\gVkZh#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh (,/&))*·&)*-# ;gVnZg!9#L#&.-*#Bjai^kVg^ViZbdge]dbZig^Xh#GZk^Zlh^c6ci]gdedad\n&'/'-.·'.-# ;gVnZg!9#L#&..&#Dci]ZZi^dad\nd[^ciZgegdm^bVa\gddkZh# 6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa 6ci]gdedad\n-*/'..·(%)# ;gdhi!=#B#&.-,#HZXdcYVgndhiZdcedejaVi^dch/6cVa\dg^i]b[dgYZiZgb^c^c\bZVcWdcZ i^hhjZV\Z#NZVgWdd`d[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n(%/''&·'(-# c/ I#6#GVi]WjgcVcY?#:#7j^`higVZYh#=jbVc>YZci^ÉXVi^dc/8VhZHijY^Zh^c;dgZch^X6ci]gd" edad\n#ee#('.·((.#Heg^c\ÄZaY!>aa^cd^h/8#8#I]dbVh# <^aa!<#L#&.-+#8gVc^d[VX^VaXg^iZg^V^c[dgZch^XgVXZ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc#>c/@#?#GZ^X]hZY#;d" gZch^XDhiZdad\n/6YkVcXZh^ci]Z>YZci^ÉXVi^dcd[=jbVcGZbV^ch#ee#&)(·&*.#Heg^c\ÄZaY! >aa^cd^h/8#8#I]dbVh# <^aa!<#L#&..*#8]VaaZc\Zdci]Z[gdci^Zg/9^hXZgc^c\6bZg^XVc>cY^Vch[gdbl]^iZhdhiZd" ad\^XVaan#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)%/,-(·,--# <^aa!<#L#'%%&#GVX^VakVg^Vi^dc^ci]Zegdm^bVaVcYY^hiVa[Zbjg/=Zg^iVW^a^inVcY[dgZch^X ji^a^in#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)+/,.&·,..# <^aa!<#L#!;^h]Zg!?#L#!VcYOZ^bZch!<#B#&.-)#6e^dcZZgWjg^VacZVgi]Z]^hidg^X7dg" YZVjmigVY^c\edhi#EaV^ch6ci]gdedad\^hi'./''.·'(-# <^aa!<#L#!VcYG]^cZ!H#ZYh#&..%#H`ZaZiVa6iig^Wji^dcd[GVXZ/BZi]dYh[dg;dgZch^X6ci]gd" edad\n#6ci]gdedad\^XVaEVeZghCjbWZg)#6aWjfjZgfjZ!CZlBZm^Xd/BVmlZaaBjhZjb d[6ci]gdedad\n# c/6#A#


7^Wa^d\gVe]n

H`ZaZiVa6cVanh^h#ee#(·&,#CZlNdg`/L^aZn"A^hh# c/B#6#@ZaaZnVcY8#H#AVghZcZYh#6YkVcXZh^c9ZciVa6ci]gdedad\n#ee#',.·'.(# CZlNdg`/L^aZn"A^hh# c/G#9#=deeVVcY8#B#;^iockZhi^\Vi^dchWVhZYdcbdYZgc]jbVc h`jaah#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n&%-/.&·.+# #C#!VcYIjg\ji!=#7#'%%(#I]ZZmiZgcVadXX^e^iVaegdijWZgVcXZ/XVc^iWZjhZYVhV Xg^iZg^dc^ci]ZYZiZgb^cVi^dcd[hZm4?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)-/&·)# <jhiV[hdc!<#!VcY@dX]!<#&.,)#6\ZZhi^bVi^dcjeid&+nZVghd[V\ZWVhZYdcYZciVaYZkZa" debZci#DYdcidad\^h`GZkn'*/'.,·(%+# =VVX`!H#'%%(#Ig^VahVcYig^WjaVi^dch/HX^ZcXZ^ci]Z8djgih#9VZYVajh&('/*)·+(# =V\ZaWZg\!:#!Hn`Zh!7#!VcY=ZY\Zh!G#&.-.#6cX^ZciWdcZ9C6Vbea^ÄZY#CVijgZ()'/)-*# =V\ZaWZg\!:#!#8#!VcY?Z[[gZnh!6#?#&..&#>YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[i]Zh`ZaZiVagZbV^chd[V bjgYZgk^Xi^bWn9C6VcVanh^h#CVijgZ(*'/)',·)'.# =V\ajcY!L#9#&..'#8dcig^Wji^dchd[gdYZcihidedhibdgiZbVgi^[VXihd[WdcZVcYhd[ii^h" hjZ#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(,/&)*.·&)+*# =V\ajcY!L#9#&..,#9d\hVcYXdndiZh/EdhibdgiZb^ckdakZbZcil^i]]jbVcgZbV^ch#>c/ L#9#=V\ajcYVcYB#=#Hdg\ZYh#;dgZch^XIVe]dcdbn#ee#(+,·(-&#7dXVGVidc!;adg^YV/ 8G8EgZhh# =V\ajcY!L#9#'%%&#6gX]VZdad\nVcY[dgZch^XYZVi]^ckZhi^\Vi^dch#=^hidg^XVa6gX]VZdad\n (*/'+·()# =V\ajcY!L#9#!GZVn!9#I#!VcYHl^cYaZg!9#G#&.--#Iddi]bVg`Vgi^[VXihVcYhjgk^kVad[ WdcZh^cVc^bVahXVkZc\ZY]jbVch`ZaZidch#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh((/.-*·..,# =V\ajcY!L#9#!VcYHdg\!B#=#ZYh#&..,#;dgZch^XIVe]dcdbn#7dXVGVidc!;adg^YV/8G8 EgZhh# =Vb^aidc!B#:#&.-'#HZmjVaY^bdge]^hb^ch`ZaZiVahVbeaZh#>c/G#A#=VaaZY#HZmjVa9^" bdge]^hb^c=dbdhVe^Zch#ee#&%,·&+(#CZlNdg`/EgVZ\Zg# =VcXdX`!G#<#K#!
7^Wa^d\gVe]n

)(*

Zh#:meZg^Zci^V*%/*')·*'.# =VchZc!B#&..(#7Za^ZkZ^idgCdi#6bZg^XVc7Vg6hhdX^Vi^dc?djgcVa!?jcZ!ee#+)·+,# =Vjc!H#?#'%%%#7g^Z[Xdbbjc^XVi^dc/6hijYnd[i]ZegZY^Xi^kZVXXjgVXnd[bVcY^WjaVggV" bjhÅZmjgZVhVh^c\aZbdge]dad\^X^cY^XVidgd[hZm^cVcVgX]VZdad\^XVahVbeaZ#6bZg^XVc ?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n&&&/)'.·)('# =VjhZg! <#! VcY 9ZHiZ[Vcd! <# ;# &.-.# :e^\ZcZi^X KVg^Vcih d[ i]Z =jbVc H`jaa# Hijii\Vgi/ :# HX]lZ^oZgWVgi¼hX]ZKZgaV\hWjX]]VcYajc\# =Vjhl^gi]!L#L#!9^X`Za!8#9#!GdldaY!9#?#!VcY=Vjhl^gi]!B#6#&..)#>ciZg"VcY^cigV" edejaVi^dchijY^Zhd[VcX^Zci]jbVch#:meZg^Zci^V*%/*-*·*.&# =ZVi]XdiZ!<#B#&.-&#I]ZbV\c^ijYZVcYXdchZfjZcXZhd[bZVhjgZbZciZggdg^c]jbVc XgVc^dbZign#8VcVY^VcGZk^Zld[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n(/&-·)%# =ZcYZghdc!?#&.-,#;VXidghYZiZgb^c^c\i]ZhiViZd[egZhZgkVi^dcd[]jbVcgZbV^ch#>c/6# 7dYY^c\idc!6#C#begZhh^dcVcYgZea^XVbZi]dYh[dghijYn^c\]nedeaVh^VVcYeZg^`nbViVdc ]jbVciddi]Xgdlchjg[VXZh[gdbVgX]VZdad\^XVah^iZh#>ciZgcVi^dcVa?djgcVad[DhiZdVgX]VZ" dad\n'/+*·,-# =^aahdc!H#&..+#9ZciVa6ci]gdedad\n#8VbWg^Y\Z!:c\aVcY/8VbWg^Y\ZJc^kZgh^inEgZhh# =^aahdc!H#'%%&#GZXdgY^c\YZciVaXVg^Zh^cVgX]VZdad\^XVa]jbVcgZbV^ch#>ciZgcVi^dcVa?djg" cVad[DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n&&/').·'-.# =^aahdc!H#'%%'#9ZciVaeVi]dad\n#>c/@VioZcWZg\!B#6#!VcYHVjcYZgh!H#ZYh#7^dad\^XVa6c" i]gdedad\nd[i]Z=jbVcH`ZaZidc#ee#').·'-+#CZlNdg`/L^aZn"A^hh# =ajh`d!A#?#'%%(#I]ZdaYZhi]db^c^Y]VW^i4:meZg^bZciVaZk^YZcXZ[dgiddi]e^X`^c\l^i] \gVhhhiVa`h#8jggZci6ci]gdedad\n))/,(-·,)&# =d\\Z!?#E#!BZhhbZg!?#B#!VcY9dVc!F#C#&..)#GVY^d\gVe]^X^YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[jc`cdlc ]jbVcgZbV^chVcY^ciZgegZiZgZmeZg^ZcXZaZkZa#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(./(,(·(,,# =daaVcY!B#B#!;^h]Zg!9#A#!B^iX]Zaa!A#<#!GdYg^fjZo!L#8#!8Vc^`!?#?#!BZgg^a!8#G#!VcY LZZYc!K#L#&..(#B^idX]dcYg^Va9C6hZfjZcXZVcVanh^hd[]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch/ >YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[gZbV^ch[gdbi]ZK^ZicVbLVg#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(-/*)'·**(# =daa^YVn!I#L#!VcY;VahZii^!6#7#&...#6cZlbZi]dY[dgY^hXg^b^cVi^c\6[g^XVc"6bZg^XVc [gdb:jgdeZVc"6bZg^XVch`ZaZidchjh^c\edhiXgVc^VadhiZdbZig^XhgZÅZXi^kZd[WdYnh]VeZ# ?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh))/.'+·.(%# =daa^Zc!=#&..%#I]ZZmeZgil^icZhh/:i]^XhVcYgZhedch^W^a^i^Zh#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh (*/&)&)·&)'(# =deeV!G#9#'%%%#EdejaVi^dckVg^Vi^dc^cdhiZdad\^XVaV\^c\Xg^iZg^V/6cZmVbeaZ[gdbi]Z ejW^Xhnbe]nh^h#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n&&&/&-*·&.&# =deeV!G#9#!VcYHVjcYZgh!H#&..-#IldfjVci^iVi^kZbZi]dYh[dgg^WhZg^Vi^dc^c]jbVc h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)(/&,)·&,,# =deeV!G#9#!VcY;^io


7^Wa^d\gVe]n

=djX`! B# B#! JWZaV`Zg! 9#! DlhaZn! 9#! 8gV^\! :#! ciZgegZiVi^dchd[i]ZgZXZciZk^YZcXZ#>c/ 9#C#@Z^\]ianZY#I]ZDg^\^chd[8]^cZhZ8^k^a^oVi^dc#ee#'.,·(&.#7Zg`ZaZn!8Va^[dgc^V/ Jc^kZgh^ind[8Va^[dgc^VEgZhh# =dlZaah! L# L# &.-+# E]nh^XVa Vci]gdedad\n d[ i]Z egZ]^hidg^X ?VeVcZhZ# >c/ G# ?# EZVghdc ZY#L^cYdlhdci]Z?VeVcZhZEVhi#ee#-*·..#6cc6gWdg!B^X]^\Vc/8ZciZg[dg?VeVcZhZ HijY^Zh# =dlZaah!L#L#&.-.#H`jaah]VeZhVcYi]ZbVe/8gVc^dbZig^XVcVanhZh^ci]ZY^heZgh^dcd[ bdYZgc=dbd#EVeZghd[i]ZEZVWdYnBjhZjbd[6gX]VZdad\nVcY:i]cdad\n,./&·&-.# =dlZaah! L# L# &..*# L]d¼h l]d ^c h`jaah/ :i]c^X ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc d[ XgVc^V [gdb bZVhjgZ" bZcih#EVeZghd[i]ZEZVWdYnBjhZjbd[6gX]VZdad\nVcY:i]cdad\n!=VgkVgYJc^kZgh^in-'/&· &%-# =jWZgi!?#&.-.#6egdeZgeaVXZ[dgi]ZYZVY/6Xg^i^XVagZk^Zld[i]Z¹gZWjg^Vaº^hhjZ#>c/G# AVnidcZY#ee#&(&·&++#AdcYdc/Jcl^c=nbVc# =jbbZgi!?#G#!VcYKVccigdcV!;#!?g#!9^KZaaV!<#!8VbedWVhhd!8#E#!VcY9gV\dcZ!B#&..,#HZmYZiZgb^cVi^dcWn # Y^hXg^b^cVciVcVanh^hd[XVaXVcZ^bZVhjgZbZcih#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)'/,'*·,'-# >h¨XVc! B# N# &.--# G^hZ d[ [dgZch^X Vci]gdedad\n# NZVgWdd` d[ E]nh^XVa 6ci]gdedad\n (&/'%(· # '(%# >#h¨XVc!B#N#ZY#&.-.#6\ZBVg`Zgh^ci]Z=jbVcH`ZaZidc#Heg^c\ÄZaY!>aa^cd^h/8#8#I]dbVh# >h¨XVc!B#N#!VcY8diidc!I#H#&.-*#I]ZZ[[ZXid[V\Zdci]ZYZiZgb^cVi^dcd[gVXZ[gdbi]Z # eZak^h#?djgcVad[=jbVc:kdaji^dc&)/',*·'-'# >h¨XVc!B#N#!VcY@ZccZYn!@#6#G#ZYh#&.-.#GZXdchigjXi^dcd[A^[Z[gdbi]ZH`ZaZidc#CZl # Ndg`/6aVcG#A^hh# >h¨XVc!B#N#!VcYAdi]!H#G#&.-+#:hi^bVi^dcd[V\ZVcYYZiZgb^cVi^dcd[hZm[gdbi]ZhiZgcVa g^W#>c/@#?#GZ^X]hZY#;dgZch^XDhiZdad\n/6YkVcXZh^ci]Z>YZci^ÉXVi^dcd[=jbVcGZbV^ch# # ee#+-·-.#Heg^c\ÄZaY!>aa^cd^h/8#8#I]dbVh# >h¨XVc!B#N#!VcY=ZabZg!G#E#&..(#;dgZch^X6cVanh^hd[i]ZH`jaa#CZlNdg`/L^aZn"A^hh# ?VX`Zh!B#&..'#EVaZdYZbd\gVe]n/EgdWaZbhVcYiZX]c^fjZh#>c/H#G#HVjcYZghVcYB#6# @VioZcWZg\ZYh#H`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[EVhiEZdeaZh/GZhZVgX]BZi]dYh#ee#&-.·'')#CZlNdg`/ L^aZn"A^hh# ?VX`Zh!B#'%%%#7j^aY^c\i]ZWVhZh[dgeVaZdYZbd\gVe]^XVcVanh^h/6YjaiV\ZYZiZgb^cVi^dc# >c/@VioZcWZg\!B#6#!VcYHVjcYZgh!H#ZYh#7^dad\^XVa6ci]gdedad\nd[i]Z=jbVcH`ZaZidc# ee#)&,·)++#CZlNdg`/L^aZn"A^hh# ?Vcio!G#A#&..'#BdY^ÄXVi^dcd[i]ZIgdiiZgVcYbea^XVi^dch[dghiVijgZZhi^bVi^dc#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)%/,*-·,+&#

7^Wa^d\gVe]n

)(,

?Vgk^`!:#&.-%#7Vh^XHigjXijgZVcY:kdaji^dcd[KZgiZWgViZh!Kda#'#CZlNdg`/6XVYZb^XEgZhh# ?Z[[gZnh!6#?#!6aaZc!B#?#!=V\ZaWZg\!:#!VcYHdccWZg\!6#&..'#>YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[i]Zh`ZaZiVa gZbV^chd[?dhZ[BZc\ZaZWn9C6VcVanh^h#;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZ>ciZgcVi^dcVa*+/+*·,+# ?d]Vchdc!9#8#&.,.#6Xdch^YZgVi^dcd[i]Z¹9gnde^i]ZXjheViiZgc#ºDhhV+/&'*·&(-# ?d]chdc!?#H#'%%&#6adc\"iZgbadd`ViedanbZghjhZYidegZhZgkZWdcZ#>c/:#L^aa^VbhZY# =jbVc GZbV^ch/ 8dchZgkVi^dc! GZig^ZkVa VcY 6cVanh^h# ee# ..·&%'# Dm[dgY! :c\aVcY/ 6g" X]VZdegZhh7#6#G#>ciZgcVi^dcVaHZg^Zh.()# ?dcZh! 9# <#! VcY =Vgg^h! G# ?# &..-# 6gX]Zdad\^XVa ]jbVc gZbV^ch# 8jggZci 6ci]gdedad\n (./'*(·'+)# ?dj`dlh`n!B#&.-%#68dbeaZiZBVcjVad[;^ZaY6gX]VZdad\n/IddahVcYIZX]c^fjZhd[;^ZaY Ldg`[dg6gX]VZdad\^hih#:c\aZlddY8a^[[h!CZl?ZghZn/EgZci^XZ=Vaa# @VZhiaZ!;#6#&..*#8]VeiZg*#B^idX]dcYg^Va9C6Zk^YZcXZ[dgi]Z^YZci^ind[YZhXZcYVcih d[i]ZegZ]^hidg^XHi^aalViZgBVgh]edejaVi^dc#>c/8#H#AVghZcVcYG#A#@ZaaZnZYh#7^d" VgX]VZdad\nd[i]ZHi^aalViZgBVgh]/EgZ]^hidg^X=jbVc6YVeiVi^dc^ci]ZLZhiZgcc/B#6#@VioZcWZg\VcYH#HVjcYZghZYh#7^dad\^XVa6ci]gdedad\nd[i]Z =jbVcH`ZaZidc#ee#(%*·(',#CZlNdg`/L^aZn"A^hh# @VioZcWZg\!B#6#!VcYHVjcYZgh!H#ZYh#'%%%#7^dad\^XVa6ci]gdedad\nd[i]Z=jbVcH`ZaZidc# CZlNdg`/L^aZn"A^hh# @ZaaZn!B#6#&.,.#EVgijg^i^dcVcYeZak^XX]Vc\Zh#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n *&/*)&·*)+# @ZaaZn!B#6#!VcYAVghZc!8#H#ZYh#&..&#6YkVcXZh^c9ZciVa6ci]gdedad\n#CZlNdg`/L^aZn" A^hh# @ZabVc!A#B#!VcY@ZabVc!O#&...#I]ZjhZd[VcX^Zci9C6^ceVaZdcidad\^XVahijY^Zh#?djg" cVad[KZgiZWgViZEVaZdcidad\n&./-·'%# # @ZccZYn!@#6#G#&.-.#H`ZaZiVabVg`Zghd[dXXjeVi^dcVahigZhh#>c/B#N#>h¨XVcVcY@#6#G# @ZccZYnZYh#GZXdchigjXi^dcd[A^[Z[gdbi]ZH`ZaZidc#ee#&'.·&+%#CZlNdg`/6aVcG#A^hh# @ZccZYn!@#6#G#&..*#7jiegd[Zhhdg!l]niZVX]gVXZ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc^[gVXZhYdc¼iZm^hi4?djg" cVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)%/,.,·-%%# @Zci!H#&.-,#I]Z^cÅjZcXZd[hZYZci^hbVcYV\\gZ\Vi^dcdcedgdi^X]neZgdhidh^hVcYVcVZ" b^V/6XVhZhijYn#BVc'&/+%*·+(+# @^aaVb! :# L# '%%)# I]Z 9ZiZXi^dc d[ =jbVc GZbV^ch# 'cY :Y## Heg^c\ÄZaY! >aa^cd^h/ 8# 8# I]dbVh## @^c\!8#6#!>h¨XVc!B#N#!VcYAdi]!H#G#&..-#BZig^XVcYXdbeVgVi^kZVcVanh^hd[hZmjVaY^" bdge]^hb^ci]ZI]V^[Zbjg#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)(/.*)·.*-# @^g`!C#?#!LddY!G#:#!VcY


7^Wa^d\gVe]n

?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n&&&/*·'(# @dbVg! 9# &...# I]Z jhZ d[ XVYVkZg Yd\h ^c adXVi^c\ hXViiZgZY! hXVkZc\ZY ]jbVc gZbV^ch/ EgZa^b^cVgnÄZaYiZhigZhjaih#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh))/)%*·)%-# @dc^\hWZg\!A#L#!VcY;gVc`ZcWZg\!H#G#&..)#EVaZdYZbd\gVe]n/¹Cdifj^iZYZVY#º:kdaj" i^dcVgn6ci]gdedad\n'/.'·&%*# @dc^\hWZg\!A#L#!VcY;gVc`ZcWZg\!H#G#'%%'#9ZXdchigjXi^c\YZVi]^ceVaZdYZbd\gVe]n# 6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n&&,/'.,·-%.# @g^c\h!B#!HidcZ!6#!HX]b^io!G#L#!@gV^c^io`^!=#!HidcZ`^c\!B#!VcYE~~Wd!H#&..,#CZVc" YZgiVa9C6hZfjZcXZhVcYi]Zdg^\^cd[bdYZgc]jbVch#8Zaa.%/&.·(%# # @gd\bVc!L#B#!VcY>h¨XVc!B#N#&.-+#I]Z=jbVcH`ZaZidc^c;dgZch^XBZY^X^cZ'cY:Y## Heg^c\ÄZaY!>aa^cd^h/8#8#I]dbVh# @jcdh!8#6#!H^behdc!H#L#!GjhhZaa!@#;#!VcY=Zgh]`dk^io!>#&...#;^ghig^WbZiVbdge]dh^h/ >ihedhh^WaZji^a^in[dg]jbVcV\Z"Vi"YZVi]Zhi^bVi^dc#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gd" edad\n&&%/(%(·('(# @kVVa! H# >#! HZaaZkdaY! 7# ?#! VcY Hda]Z^b! I# &..)# 6 XdbeVg^hdc d[ Y^[[ZgZci cdc"YZhigjX" i^kZbZi]dYhd[V\ZZhi^bVi^dc^ch`ZaZiVabViZg^Va#>ciZgcVi^dcVa?djgcVad[DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n )/(+(·(,%# AVbWZgi!E#B#!VcYLVa`Zg!E#A#&..&#E]nh^XVaVci]gdedad\^XVaZk^YZcXZ[dgi]ZZkdaji^dcd[ hdX^VaXdbeaZm^in^cXdVhiVahdji]Zgc8Va^[dgc^V#6ci^fj^in+*/.+(·.,(# AVbZcY^c!=#!7VXX^cd!:#!=jbWZgi!?#;#!IVkZgc^Zg!?#8#!Cdhh^ciX]dj`!G#B#!VcYOZg^aa^! 6#&..'#6h^beaZiZX]c^fjZ[dgV\ZZhi^bVi^dc^cVYjaiXdgehZh/I]ZildXg^iZg^VYZciVa bZi]dY#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(,/&(,(·&(,.# AVbea!B#!KZaY]j^h!?#9#!VcY?d]chdc!B#A#&..'#HVaiVi^dcVcYhiVh^h/6bdYZad[]jbVc \gdli]#HX^ZcXZ'*-/-%&·-%(# AVbea!B#!VcY?d]chidc!;#:#&..+#EgdWaZbh^ci]ZV\^c\d[h`ZaZiVa_jkZc^aZh/EZgheZXi^kZh [gdbbVijgVi^dcVhhZhhbZcihd[a^k^c\X]^aYgZc#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n &%&/()*·(**# AVghZc!8#H#&.-(#7Z]Vk^dgVa^bea^XVi^dchd[iZbedgVaX]Vc\Z^cXVg^d\ZcZh^h#?djgcVad[6g" X]VZdad\^XVaHX^ZcXZ&%/&·-# AVghZc!8#H#&..,#7^dVgX]VZdad\n/>ciZgegZi^c\7Z]Vk^dg[gdbi]Z=jbVcH`ZaZidc#8VbWg^Y\Z! :c\aVcY/8VbWg^Y\ZJc^kZgh^inEgZhh# AVghZc!8#H#ZY#'%%&#7^dVgX]VZdad\nd[HeVc^h];adg^YV/I]Z>beVXid[8dadc^Va^hb#c/:#?#GZ^io!A#6#CZlhdc!VcYH#?#HXjY" YZgZYh#8VhZHijY^Zh^c:ck^gdcbZciVa6gX]VZdad\n#ee#&).·&,)#CZlNdg`/EaZcjbEgZhh# AVnidc!G#ZY#&.-.#8dcÊ^Xi^ci]Z6gX]VZdad\nd[A^k^c\IgVY^i^dch#AdcYdc/Jcl^c=nbVc# AZ^\\^!E#!VcYBVn!E#?#ZYh#&..)#KZgiZWgViZEVaZdcidad\^XVaIZX]c^fjZh#8VbWg^Y\Z!:c\aVcY/ 8VbWg^Y\ZJc^kZgh^inEgZhh# AZcX]^`! A#! VcY HVgidg^h! 9# ?# &..,# 8jggZci XdcXZeih ^c dhiZdedgdh^h# 6bZg^XVc ?djgcVa d[ GdZi\Zcdad\n&+-/.%*·.&&# AZl^h!B#'%%%#Cdc"VYjaieVaVZdeVi]dad\n/8jggZcihiVijhVcY[jijgZediZci^Va#>c/B#8dm VcYH#BVnhZYh#=jbVcDhiZdad\n^c6gX]VZdad\nVcY;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZ#ee#(.·*,#AdcYdc/ ciZgcVi^dcVa?djgcVad[DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n)/&.("'%,# A^!L#"=#!VcY
7^Wa^d\gVe]n

)(.

A^kZgh^Y\Z!=#B#&..)#6XXjgVXnd[V\ZZhi^bVi^dc[gdbYZkZade^c\iZZi]d[VedejaVi^dcd[ `cdlcV\Z%·*#)nZVgh#>ciZgcVi^dcVa?djgcVad[DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n)/(,·)*# Adi]!H#G#!VcY=ZccZWZg\!B#&..+#BVcY^WjaVggVbjhÅZmjgZ/6cZlbdge]dad\^X^cY^XV" idgd[hZmjVaY^bdge]^hb^ci]Z]jbVch`ZaZidc#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n ../),(·)-*# Adi]!H#G#!VcY=ZccZWZg\!B#&..-#BVcY^WjaVggVbjhÅZmjgZ^hV\ddY^cY^XVidgd[hZmjVa Y^bdge]^hb#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n&%*/.&·.'# AdkZ_dn!8#D#&.,-#6W^dbZX]Vc^XVagZk^Zld[i]ZadXdbdidgY^kZgh^ind[ZVgan]db^c^Yh#>c/ 8#?#?daanZY#:Vgan=db^c^Yhd[6[g^XV#ee#)%(·)'.#AdcYdc/9jX`ldgi]# AdkZ_dn!8#D#&.-*#9ZciValZVg^ci]ZA^WWZcedejaVi^dc/>ih[jcXi^dcVaeViiZgcVcYgdaZ^c i]ZYZiZgb^cVi^dcd[VYjaih`ZaZiVaV\ZViYZVi]#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n +-/),·*+# AdkZ_dn!8#D#&.--#:kdaji^dcd[]jbVclVa`^c\#HX^Zci^ÉX6bZg^XVc'*+/&&-·&'*# AdkZ_dn!8#D#!VcY7jghiZ^c!6#=#&.,,#c/G#EV^cZZY#!>ciZ\gVi^c\6gX]VZdad\^XVa9Zbd\gVe]n/Bjai^Y^hX^" ea^cVgn6eegdVX]ZhidEgZ]^hidg^XEdejaVi^dc#ee#)(·+(#8VgWdcYVaZ!>aa^cd^h/8ZciZg[dg6g" X]VZdad\^XVa>ckZhi^\Vi^dch!Hdji]Zgc>aa^cd^hJc^kZgh^in!DXXVh^dcVaEVeZg')# AdkZ_dn!8#D#!BZ^cYa!G#H#!IV\jZ!G#<#!VcYAVi^bZg!7#&..*#I]ZhZcZhXZciW^dad\nd[i]Z ]db^cd^YeZak^h#G^k^hiVY^6cigdedad\^VGdbV,(/(&·).# AdkZaa!C#8#&.-.#IZhid[E]Zc^XZ¼hiZX]c^fjZ[dgYZiZgb^c^c\hZm[gdbi]ZdhejW^h#6bZg^" XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n,./&&,·&'%# AdkZaa! C#8# '%%%# EVaZdeVi]dad\^XVa YZhXg^ei^dc VcY Y^V\cdh^h# >c/ B# 6# @VioZcWZg\ VcY H# HVjcYZgh ZYh# 7^dad\^XVa 6ci]gdedad\n d[ i]Z =jbVc H`ZaZidc# ee# '&,·')-# CZl Ndg`/ L^aZn"A^hh# Aj`VXh!?#G#&.-.#9ZciVaeVi]dad\n/BZi]dYh[dggZXdchigjXi^c\Y^ZiVgneViiZgch#>c/B#N# #  >h¨XVcVcY@#6#G#@ZccZYnZYh#GZXdchigjXi^dcd[A^[Z[gdbi]ZH`ZaZidc#ee#'+&·'-+#CZl Ndg`/6aVcG#A^hh# AnbVc!G#A#&..)#KZgiZWgViZIVe]dcdbn#8VbWg^Y\Z!:c\aVcY/8VbWg^Y\ZJc^kZgh^inEgZhh# AnbVc!G#A#!VcY;dm!<#A#&..,#6Xg^i^XVaZkVajVi^dcd[WdcZlZVi]Zg^c\VhVc^cY^XVi^dc d[WdcZVhhZbWaV\Z[dgbVi^dc#>c/L#9#=V\ajcYVcYB#=#Hdg\ZYh#;dgZch^XIVe]dcdbn# ee#''(·'),#7dXVGVidc!;adg^YV/8G8EgZhh# AnccZgje!C#!=_Va\g^b!=#!C^ZahZc!A#G#!#&..,#Cdc"^ckVh^kZ VgX]VZdad\nd[h`ZaZiVabViZg^VaWn8IhXVcc^c\VcYi]gZZ"Y^bZch^dcVagZXdchigjXi^dc#>c"



7^Wa^d\gVe]n

iZgcVi^dcVa?djgcVad[DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n,/.&·.)# BVVi!<#?#G#&.-&#=jbVcgZbV^chVii]Z9jiX]l]Va^c\hiVi^dchdcHe^ihWZg\Zc#>c/6#<#;# kVc=da`!=#@#h¼?VXdW!VcY6#6#IZbb^c\ZYh#:Vgan:jgdeZVc:mead^iVi^dcd[i]ZCdgi]Zgc 6iaVci^X!-%%»&,%%#ee#&*(·'%&#ciZgcVi^dcVa ?djgcVa d[ DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n &)/,,·-&# BVXX]^VgZaa^! G#! 7dcY^da^! A#! 8Zch^! A#! =ZgcVZo! B# @#! HVakVYZ^! A#! VcY HeZgYji^! 6# &..)# >cigV"VcY^ciZgdWhZgkZgXdcXdgYVcXZ^chXdg^c\=Vgg^ha^cZh/6iZhidcWdcZhZXi^dchVcY gVY^d\gVe]h#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n-*/,,·-(# BVXAVj\]a^c!H#B#!VcY7gjXZ!B#;#&..%#I]ZVXXjgVXnd[hZm^YZci^ÄXVi^dc^c:jgdeZVc h`ZaZiVagZbV^chjh^c\i]ZE]Zc^XZX]VgVXiZgh#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(*/&(-)·&(.'# BV[Vgi!7#!VcY9Za^c\ZiiZ!=#ZYh#'%%'#I]gZZ"9^bZch^dcVa>bV\^c\^cEVaZdVci]gdedad\nVcY EgZ]^hidg^X 6gX]VZdad\n# Dm[dgY! :c\aVcY/ =VYg^Vc 7dd`h! AiY# 6gX]VZdegZhh! 7g^i^h] 6g" X]VZdad\^XVaGZedgih&%).# BVcc!6#!VcYBdc\Z!?#&.-,#GZegdYjX^c\djgVcXZhidgh#:meZY^i^dc/I]ZJc^kZgh^ind[EZcc" hnakVc^VJc^kZgh^inBjhZjbBV\Vo^cZd[6gX]VZdad\n'./'·.# BVcc!G#L#&..(#IZX]c^XVacdiZ/6bZi]dY[dgh^Y^c\VcYhZfjZcX^c\]jbVcg^Wh#?djgcVa d[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(-/&*&·&**# BVcc!G#L#!?Vcio!G#A#!7Vhh!L#B#!VcYL^aaZn!E#H#&..&#BVm^aaVgnhjijgZdWa^iZgVi^dc/6 k^hjVabZi]dY[dgZhi^bVi^c\h`ZaZiVaV\Z#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(+/,-&·,.&# BVeaZh!L#G#&.-+#IgVjbVVcVanh^hWni]Z[dgZch^XVci]gdedad\^hi#>c/@#?#GZ^X]hZY#;d" gZch^XDhiZdad\n/6YkVcXZh^ci]Z>YZci^ÉXVi^dcd[=jbVcGZbV^ch#ee#'&-·''-#Heg^c\ÄZaY! >aa^cd^h/8#8#I]dbVh# BVeaZh!L#G#!VcY7gdlc^c\!B#&..)#9ZVYBZc9dIZaaIVaZh#CZlNdg`/9djWaZYVn# BVg`h!?#&..+#HX^ZcXZVcYgVXZ#6bZg^XVc7Z]Vk^dgVaHX^Zci^hi)%/&'(·&((# BVgi^c!9#!VcY;gVnZg!9#ZYh#&..,#IgdjWaZYI^bZh/K^daZcXZVcYLVg[VgZ^ci]ZEVhi#CZl Ndg`/c/G#>#<^aWZgiVcY?#=#BZ^`aZZYh#I]Z6cVanh^hd[EgZ]^hidg^X 9^Zih#ee#'',·',.#DgaVcYd!;adg^YV/6XVYZb^XEgZhh# BVgi^c!G#!VcYHVaaZg!@#&.*,#AZ]gWjX]YZg6ci]gdedad\^Z!Kda#&#Hijii\Vgi/<jhiVk;^hX]Zg# BVn]Vaa!?#I#'%%%#9ZciVabdge]dad\n/IZX]c^fjZhVcYhigViZ\^Zh#>c/B#6#@VioZcWZg\VcY H# HVjcYZgh ZYh# 7^dad\^XVa 6ci]gdedad\n d[ i]Z =jbVc H`ZaZidc# ee# &%(·&()# CZl Ndg`/ L^aZn"A^hh# BVn]Vaa! ?# I#! VcY @V\ZnVbj! ># &..,# 6 cZl! i]gZZ"Y^bZch^dcVa bZi]dY [dg YZiZgb^c^c\ iddi]lZVg#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n&%(/)+(·)+.# BVnh!H#&..-#I]Z6gX]VZdad\nd[=jbVc7dcZh#AdcYdc/GdjiaZY\Z# BVnh! H# '%%'# I]Z gZaVi^dch]^e WZilZZc bdaVg lZVg VcY V\Z ^c Vc ZVgan &.i] XZcijgn VY VgX]VZdad\^XVa]jbVch`ZaZiVahZg^Zhd[YdXjbZciZYV\ZViYZVi]#?djgcVad[6gX]VZdad\^XVa HX^ZcXZ'./-+&·-,&# BVnh!H#!VcY8dm!B#'%%%#HZmYZiZgb^cVi^dc^ch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#>c/B#8dmVcYH#BVnh ZYh#=jbVcDhiZdad\n^c6gX]VZdad\nVcY;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZ#ee#&&,·&(%#AdcYdc/cY^VcWjg^Vah#>c/ G#AVnidcZY#8dcÊ^Xi^ci]Z6gX]VZdad\nd[A^k^c\IgVY^i^dch#ee#&+,·&-)#AdcYdc/Jcl^c =nbVc#

))&

BX@ZZ!?#@#!VcYBdacVg!H#&.--#BZVhjgZbZcihd[iddi]lZVgVbdc\6jhigVa^Vc6Wdg^\^cZh# >>#>cigVedejaVi^dcVakVg^Vi^dc^ceViiZgchd[YZciVaViig^i^dc#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa 6ci]gdedad\n,+/&'*·&(+# BX@Zgc!I#L#!VcYHiZlVgi!I#9#&.*,#H`ZaZiVaV\ZX]Vc\Zh^cndjc\6bZg^XVcbVaZh#CVi^X`! BVhhVX]jhZiih/ FjVgiZgbVhiZg GZhZVgX] VcY 9ZkZadebZci 8dbbVcY IZX]c^XVa GZedgi :E")*# BZVY! :# B#! VcY BZZ`h! H# &.-.# E]did\gVe]n d[ VgX]VZdad\^XVa VcY eVaZdcidad\^XVa WdcZ heZX^bZch#>c/G#7dcc^X]hZcVcYB#=#Hdg\ZYh##7dcZBdY^ÉXVi^dc#ee#'+,·'-&#Dgdcd! BV^cZ/8ZciZg[dgi]ZHijYnd[i]Z;^ghi6bZg^XVch# BZ^\]Vc!8#L#&..'#HdbZhX]daVg¼hk^ZlhdcgZWjg^Va#6bZg^XVc6ci^fj^in*,/,%)·,&%# BZ^cYa!G#H#!VcYAdkZ_dn!8#D#&.-*#:XidXgVc^VahjijgZXadhjgZ/6gZk^hZYbZi]dY[dgi]Z YZiZgb^cVi^dcd[h`ZaZiVaV\ZViYZVi]WVhZYdci]ZaViZgVa"VciZg^dghjijgZh#6bZg^XVc?djg" cVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n+-/*,·++# BZ^cYa!G#H#!AdkZ_dn!8#D#!VcYBZch[dgi]!G#E#&.-*V#6gZk^hZYbZi]dYd[V\ZYZiZgb^cV" i^dcjh^c\i]ZdhejW^h!l^i]VgZk^ZlVcYiZhihd[VXXjgVXnd[di]ZgXjggZcibZi]dYhd[ejW^X hnbe]nhZVaV\^c\#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n+-/'.·)*# BZ^cYa!G#H#!AdkZ_dn!8#D#!BZch[dgi]!G#E#!VcY8Vgadh!A#9#&.-*W#6XXjgVXnVcYY^gZX" i^dcd[Zggdg^chZm^c\d[i]Zh`ZaZidc/>bea^XVi^dch[dgeVaZdYZbd\gVe]n#6bZg^XVc?djgcVa d[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n+-/,.·-*# BZaWn!?#!VcY?^bZcZo!H#7#&..,#8]V^cd[XjhidYn[gdbi]ZÄZaYidi]ZXdjgigddb#>c/L# 9#=V\ajcYVcYB#=#Hdg\ZYh#;dgZch^XIVe]dcdbn#ee#+*·,*#7dXVGVidc!;adg^YV/8G8 EgZhh# BZaaVgh!E#!VcYHig^c\Zg!8#ZYh#&.-.#I]Z=jbVcGZkdaji^dc#:Y^cWjg\]/:Y^cWjg\]Jc^" kZgh^inEgZhh# BZch[dgi]!G#E#!VcYAdkZ_dn!8#D#&.-*#6cVidb^XVa!e]nh^dad\^XVa!VcYZe^YZb^dad\^XVa XdggZaViZhd[i]ZV\^c\egdXZhh/6XdcÄgbVi^dcd[bjai^[VXidg^VaV\ZYZiZgb^cVi^dc^ci]Z A^WWZch`ZaZiVaedejaVi^dc#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n+-/-,·&%+# BZch[dgi]!G#E#!AdkZ_dn!8#D#!AVaad!?#L#!VcY6gbZaV\dh!<#?#&.,-#I]ZgdaZd[Xdchi^ij" i^dcVa[VXidgh!Y^Zi!VcY^c[ZXi^djhY^hZVhZ^ci]ZZi^dad\nd[edgdi^X]neZgdhidh^hVcYeZg^dh" iZVagZVXi^dch^cegZ]^hidg^X^c[VcihVcYX]^aYgZc#BZY^XVa6ci]gdedad\n'/&·*.# BZgWh! 8# ;# &.-(# EViiZgch d[ VXi^k^in"^cYjXZY eVi]dad\n ^c V 8VcVY^Vc >cj^i edejaVi^dc# 6gX]VZdad\^XVaHjgkZnd[8VcVYV!EVeZgCd#&&.#CVi^dcVaBjhZjbd[BVc!BZgXjgnhZg^Zh# B^Xdoo^!B#H#&..&#EdhibdgiZb8]Vc\Z^c=jbVcVcY6c^bVaGZbV^ch#Heg^c\ÄZaY!>aa^cd^h/ 8#8#I]dbVh# B^aZh!6#:# L#&.+(#9Zci^i^dc^ci]ZZhi^bVi^dcd[V\Z#?djgcVad[9ZciVaGZhZVgX])'/'**· '+(# B^aZh!6#:#L#'%%&#I]ZB^aZhbZi]dYd[VhhZhh^c\V\Z[gdbiddi]lZVggZk^h^iZY#?djgcVad[ 6gX]VZdad\^XVaHX^ZcXZ'-/.,(·.-'# B^aaZg!:#!GV\hYVaZ!7#9#!VcYDgicZg!9#?#&..+#6XXjgVXn^cYgnWdcZY^V\cdh^h/6XdbbZci dceVaVZdeVi]dad\^XVabZi]dYh#>ciZgcVi^dcVa?djgcVad[DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n+/''&·''.# B^acZg!<#G#!VcYAVghZc!8#H#&..&#IZZi]VhVgi^[VXihd[]jbVcWZ]Vk^dg/>ciZci^dcVabdY^" ÄXVi^dcVcYVXX^YZciVabdY^ÄXVi^dc#>c/B#6#@ZaaZnVcY8#H#AVghZcZYh#6YkVcXZh^c 9ZciVa6ci]gdedad\n#ee#(*,·(,-#CZlNdg`/L^aZn"A^hh# B^acZg!<#G#!LddY!?#L#VcY7daYhZc!?#A#'%%%#EVaZdYZbd\gVe]n#>c/B#6#@VioZcWZg\ VcYH#HVjcYZghZYh#7^dad\^XVa6ci]gdedad\nd[i]Z=jbVcH`ZaZidc#ee#)+,·).,#CZlNdg`/ L^aZn"A^hh# B^cXZg!=#=#!7ZggnbVc!=#:#!BjggVn!<#6#!VcY9^X`Zch!G#A#&..%#IZX]c^XVacdiZ/BZi]" dYh[dge]nh^XVahiVW^a^oVi^dcd[Vh]ZYiZZi]^c^cX^cZgViZYgZbV^ch#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^" ZcXZh(*/.,&·.,)# B^cXZg!=#=#!=Vgg^h!:#;#!VcY7ZggnbVc!=#:#&..(#I]Z6#7#;#D#hijYnd[i]^gYbdaVg YZkZadebZci VcY ^ih jhZ Vh Vc Zhi^bVidg d[ X]gdcdad\^XVaV\Z#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh (-/(,.·(.%#



7^Wa^d\gVe]n

B^od\jX]^!N#&.-*#H]dkZaa^c\/6hiVi^hi^XVaVcVanh^hd[^ihbdge]dad\n#7jaaZi^c!Jc^kZgh^ind[ Id`ndBjhZjb'+/&·&,+# BdacVg!H#&.,&#=jbVciddi]lZVg!iddi][jcXi^dc!VcYXjaijgVakVg^VW^a^in#6bZg^XVc?djgcVa d[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n()/&,*·&.%# BddgZ"?VchZc!E#=#!VcY?Vcio!G#A#&.-.#9ViV8daaZXi^dcEgdXZYjgZh[dg;dgZch^XH`ZaZiVaBViZ" g^Va#GZedgid[>ckZhi^\Vi^dchCd#)-#@cdmk^aaZ/Jc^kZgh^ind[IZccZhhZZ# Bdg^!?#A#&.,%#EgdXZYjgZh[dgZhiVWa^h]^c\V[VjcVaXdaaZXi^dcidV^Y^cVgX]VZdad\^XVaVcVan" h^h#6bZg^XVc6ci^fj^in(*/(-,·(-.# BdgZaa!K#&..-#@ZccZl^X`BVc¼hig^VahXdci^cjZ#HX^ZcXZ'-%/&.%·&.'# Bdgidc!G#6#ZY#&.-)#E]did\gVe]n[dgi]ZHX^Zci^hi'cY:Y##AdcYdc/6XVYZb^XEgZhh# Bja]Zgc!9#B#!VcY?dcZh!:#7#'%%)#IZhid[gZk^hZYbZi]dYd[V\ZZhi^bVi^dc[gdbi]ZVj" g^XjaVghjg[VXZd[i]Z^a^jb#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n&'+/+&·+*# B“aaZg!L#!;g^X`Z!=#!=Vaa^YVn!6#C#!BX8jaadX]!B#I#VcYLVgi]d!?#'%%(#Dg^\^cVcY b^\gVi^dcd[i]ZVae^cZ^XZbVc#HX^ZcXZ(%'/-+'·-++# Bjaa^h!@#7#!VcY;VaddcV!;#&.-,#HeZX^ÄXhnci]Zh^hd[9C6^ck^igdk^VVedanbZgVhZ"XViV" anoZYX]V^cgZVXi^dc#BZi]dYh^c:conbdad\n&**/((*·(*%# BjggVn!@#6#!VcYBjggVn!I#&..&#6iZhid[i]ZVjg^XjaVghjg[VXZV\^c\iZX]c^fjZ#?djgcVad[ ;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(+/&&+'·&&+.# CVeda^!B#A#!VcY7^g`Wn!L#=#&..%#GVX^VaY^[[ZgZcXZh^ci]Zk^h^W^a^ind[i]ZdkVal^cYdl ^ci]Zb^YYaZZVg#>c/<#L#G]^cZVcYH#G]^cZZYh#H`ZaZiVa6iig^Wji^dcd[GVXZ/BZi]dYh [dg;dgZch^X6ci]gdedad\n#ee#',·('#6aWjfjZgfjZ!CZlBZm^Xd/BVmlZaaBjhZjbd[6c" i]gdedad\n!6ci]gdedad\^XVaEVeZghCjbWZg)# CVlgdX`^!H#E#&..*#IVe]dcdb^XegdXZhhZh^c]^hidg^XXZbZiZg^Zh#>c/6#A#c/B#8dmVcYH#BVnhZYh#=jbVcDhiZdad\n^c6gX]VZdad\nVcY;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZ#ee#('*· (((#AdcYdc/c/B#8dmVcYH#BVnhZYh#=jbVcDhiZdad\n^c6gX]VZ" dad\nVcY;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZ#)(.·)*)#AdcYdc/ciZgcVi^dcVa?djgcVad[DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n+/*%'·*%*# D]iVc^!H#&..*#HijY^ZhdcV\ZZhi^bVi^dcjh^c\gVXZb^oVi^dcd[VheVgi^XVX^Y^cXZbZcijb# ?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)%/-%*·-%,# D]iVc^!H#!VcYNVbVbdid!@#&..&#6\ZZhi^bVi^dcjh^c\i]ZgVXZb^oVi^dcd[Vb^cdVX^Y^c ]jbVcYZci^c#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(+/,.'·-%%# D]iVc^!H#!VcYNVbVbdid!@#&..'#:hi^bVi^dcd[V\Z[gdbViddi]WnbZVchd[gVXZb^oVi^dc d[ Vc Vb^cd VX^Y! ZheZX^Vaan VheVgi^X VX^Y/ 8dbeVg^hdc d[ ZcVbZa VcY YZci^c# ?djgcVa d[ ;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(,/&%+&·&%+,# D¼Adj\]a^c!K#9#'%%)#:[[ZXihd[Y^[[ZgZci`^cYhd[XgVc^VaYZ[dgbVi^dcdci]Z^cX^YZcXZd[ ldgb^VcWdcZh#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n&'(/&)+·&**# D¼GV]^aan!G#&.-.#6cVidb^XVaiZgb^cdad\n!i]ZcVcYcdl#6XiV6cVidb^XV&()/'.&·(%%# DgicZg!9#?#'%%(#>YZci^ÉXVi^dcd[EVi]dad\^XVa8dcY^i^dch^c=jbVcH`ZaZiVaGZbV^ch#'cY:Y## 6bhiZgYVb/6XVYZb^XEgZhh# DgicZg!9#?#!VcY6j[YZg]Z^YZ!6#8#&..&#=jbVcEVaZdeVi]dad\n/8jggZciHnci]ZhZhVcY;jijgZ Dei^dch#LVh]^c\idc!98/Hb^i]hdc^Vc>chi^iji^dcEgZhh# DgicZg!9#?#!VcYEjihX]Vg!L#<#&.-&#>YZci^ÉXVi^dcd[EVi]dad\^XVa8dcY^i^dch^c=jbVcH`Za"

7^Wa^d\gVe]n

))(

ZiVa GZbV^ch# Hb^i]hdc^Vc 8dcig^Wji^dch id 6ci]gdedad\n '-/&·),.# LVh]^c\idc! 98/ Hb^i]hdc^Vc>chi^iji^dcEgZhh# DhWdgcZ!9#A#!H^bbdch!I#A#VcYCVlgdX`^!H#E#'%%)#GZXdch^YZg^c\i]ZVjg^XjaVghjg[VXZ VhVc^cY^XVidgd[V\Zd[YZVi]#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)./&·,# DjhaZn!H#&..*#H]djaYlZZhi^bViZW^dad\^XVadg[dgZch^XhiVijgZ4?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh )%/,+-·,,(# DjhaZn!H#VcYBX@Zdlc!6#'%%&#I]gZZY^bZch^dcVaY^\^i^o^c\d[]jbVch`jaahVhVcVgX]^" kVaegdXZYjgZ#>c/:#L^aa^VbhZY#=jbVcGZbV^ch/8dchZgkVi^dc!GZig^ZkVaVcY6cVanh^h# Dm[dgY!:c\aVcY/6gX]VZdegZhh7#6#G#>ciZgcVi^dcVaHZg^Zh.()#ee#&,(·&-)# DlhaZn!9#L#&..(#>YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[i]Z[gV\bZciVgn!WjgcZYgZbV^chd[ildJ#H#_djgcVa^hih hZkZc nZVgh V[iZg i]Z^g Y^hVeeZVgVcXZ ^c <jViZbVaV#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(-/&(,'· &(-'# DlhaZn!9#L#'%%&#L]ni]Z[dgZch^XVci]gdedad\^hicZZYhi]ZVgX]VZdad\^hi#=^hidg^XVa6g" X]VZdad\n(*/(*·(-# DlhaZn!9#L#!VcYBVcc!G#L#&..'#Edh^i^kZeZghdcVa^YZci^ind[h`ZaZidc^oZYgZbV^chjh" ^c\VWYdb^cVaVcYeZak^XgVY^d\gVe]h#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(,/(('·((+# DlhaZn!9#L#!BVcc!G#L#!8]VebVc!G#:#!BddgZ!:#!VcY8dm!L#&..(#Edh^i^kZ^YZci^ÄXV" i^dc^cVXVhZd[^ciZci^dcVaZmigZbZ[gV\bZciVi^dc#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(-/.-*·..+# DlhaZn! 9# L#! JWZaV`Zg! 9# =#! =djX`! B# B#! HVcYcZhh! @# A#! c/L#9#=V\ajcYVcYB#=#Hdg\ZYh#;dgZch^XIVe]dcdbn/ I]ZEdhibdgiZb;ViZd[=jbVcGZbV^ch#ee#&%.·&(-#7dXVGVidc!;adg^YV/8G8EgZhh# EZVghdc!B#E#'%%&#I]Z6gX]VZdad\nd[9ZVi]VcY7jg^Va#8daaZ\ZHiVi^dc!IZmVh/IZmVh6B Jc^kZgh^inEgZhh# E[Vj!G#D#!VcYHX^jaa^!E#L#&..)#6bZi]dY[dgZhiVWa^h]^c\i]ZV\Zd[hjWVYjaih#?djgcVad[ ;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(./&+*·&,+# E[Z^[[Zg!H#!AVoZcWn!G#!VcY8]Vc\!?#&..*#7g^Z[Xdbbjc^XVi^dc/8dgi^XVagZbdYZa^c\YViV VgZV[[ZXiZYWnhVbea^c\adXVi^dc#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n.+/-.·.'# E]Zc^XZ! I# L# &.+.# 6 cZlan YZkZadeZY k^hjVa bZi]dY d[ hZm^c\ ^c i]Z dh ejW^h# 6bZg^XVc ?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n(%/'.,·(%&# E^ZigjhZlh`n! B# '%%%# BZig^X VcVanh^h d[ h`ZaZiVa gZbV^ch/ BZi]dYh VcY Veea^XVi^dch# >c/ B#6#@VioZcWZg\VcYH#HVjcYZghZYh#7^dad\^XVa6ci]gdedad\nd[i]Z=jbVcH`ZaZidc#ee# (,*·)&*#CZlNdg`/L^aZn"A^hh# Ed^cVg!=#C#!=Žhh!B#!7VYV!?#A#!VcYE~~Wd!H#&..+#6b^cdVX^YgVXZb^oVi^dcVcYi]ZegZh" ZgkVi^dcd[VcX^Zci9C6#HX^ZcXZ','/-+)·-++# EdaaVcZc!B#H#!VcYJWZaV`Zg!9#=#&..,#;dgZch^Xh^\c^ÄXVcXZd[i]Zedanbdge]^hbd[]nd^Y WdcZh]VeZ#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)'/-.%·-.'# EdlZaa!B#A#&.-*#I]ZVcVanh^hd[YZciValZVgVcYXVg^Zh[dgY^ZiVgngZXdchigjXi^dc#>c/G# ># <^aWZgi VcY ?# =# BZ^`aZ ZYh# I]Z 6cVanh^h d[ EgZ]^hidg^X 9^Zih# ee# (%,·((-# DgaVcYd! ;adg^YV/6XVYZb^XEgZhh# Eg^XZ!I#9#&.-.#I]Z8]Zb^hignd[=jbVc7dcZ#8VbWg^Y\Z!:c\aVcY/8VbWg^Y\ZJc^kZgh^in



7^Wa^d\gVe]n

EgZhh# Eg^bdgVX!9#!6cYZa^cdk^X!H#!9ZÄc^h"#!GZo^X!7#!7VYZc!B#B#!@Zc" cZYn!B#6#!HX]VcÄZaY!B#H#!H`V`Za!H#7#!VcYAZZ!=#8#&..+#>YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[lVgk^X" i^bh[gdbbVhh\gVkZh^c8gdVi^V!7dhc^V!VcY=ZgoZ\dk^cVWni]ZjhZd[hiVcYVgY[dgZch^X bZi]dYhVcY9C6ine^c\#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)&/-.&·-.)# Ejg`V^i!G#'%%&#BZVhjgZbZcihd[jacV/6cZlbZi]dY[dgYZiZgb^cVi^dcd[hZm#?djgcVad[ ;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)+/.')·.',# GVYdhZk^X]!H#8#&..(#I]Zh^mYZVYanh^chd[igVXZZaZbZciVcVanh^h/6XVhZd[l^h][jai]^c`" ^c\^chX^ZcXZ#>c/B#@#HVcY[dgYZY#>ckZhi^\Vi^dchd[6cX^Zci=jbVcI^hhjZ/8]Zb^XVa6cVa" nhZh^c6ci]gdedad\n#ee#'+.·(('#AVc\]dgcZ!EZcchankVc^V/YZci^ÉXVi^dc/8VhZHijY^Zh^c;dgZch^X 6ci]gdedad\n#Heg^c\ÄZaY!>aa^cd^h/8#8#I]dbVh# GZVYZg!?#&.--#B^hh^c\A^c`h/I]Z=jci[dg:Vga^ZhiBVc'cY:Y##B^YYaZhZm!:c\aVcY/EZc" \j^c7dd`h# GZ^X]h! @# ?# ZY# &.-+# ;dgZch^X DhiZdad\n/ 6YkVcXZh ^c i]Z >YZci^ÉXVi^dc d[ =jbVc GZbV^ch# Heg^c\ÄZaY!>aa^cd^h/8#8#I]dbVh# GZnbZci!G#6#!7aVX`^i]!G#:#!VcY8VbeWZaa!C#6#&.-)#Bjai^kVg^ViZBdge]dbZig^Xh'cY :Y##AdcYdc/6XVYZb^XEgZhh# G]^cZ!H#&..%#Cdc"bZig^Xh`jaagVX^c\#>c/<#L#<^aaVcYH#G]^cZZYh#H`ZaZiVa6iig^Wji^dc d[GVXZ/BZi]dYh[dg;dgZch^X6ci]gdedad\n#ee#.·'%#6aWjfjZgfjZ!CZlBZm^Xd/BVmlZaa BjhZjbd[6ci]gdedad\n!6ci]gdedad\^XVaEVeZghCjbWZg)# G^X]VgYh! <# 9#! VcY 6ci‹c! H# 8# &.-,# I]Z 7Zg`ZaZn Eg^bViZ H`ZaZiVa 8daaZXi^dc/ 6 cZl gZhdjgXZ[dghijY^Zh^ceVaZdeVi]dad\n#EVaZdeVi]dad\nCZlhaZiiZg*,/-·&&# G^X]VgYh!A#8#!VcYB^aaZg!H#A#?#&..&#GZaVi^dch]^ehWZilZZcV\ZVcYYZciVaViig^i^dc^c 6jhigVa^VcVWdg^\^cVah#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n-)/&*.·&+)# G^X]ihbZ^Zg!?#I#!8]ZkZgjY!?#B#!VcYAZaZ!H#&..'#6YkVcXZh^cVci]gdedad\^XVabdge]d" bZig^Xh#6ccjVaGZk^Zlh^c6ci]gdedad\n'&/'-(·(%*# G^X]ihbZ^Zg!?#I#!9ZaZdc!K#7#!VcYAZaZ!H#G#'%%'#I]Zegdb^hZd[\ZdbZig^Xbdge]dbZi" g^Xh#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n&&.NZVgWdd`d[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n/+(·.&# GdWW!?#'%%%#6cVanh^c\]jbVch`ZaZiVaYViV#>c/B#8dmVcYH#BVnhZYh#=jbVcDhiZdad\n ^c6gX]VZdad\nVcY;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZ#ee#),*·).%#AdcYdc/i]VXV!CZlNdg`/ 8dgcZaaJc^kZgh^inEgZhh# GdWa^c\!6#<#!VcYHidji!H#9#'%%%#=^hidbdge]dbZignd[]jbVcXdgi^XVaWdcZ/6eea^XV" i^dchidV\ZZhi^bVi^dc#>c/B#6#@VioZcWZg\VcYH#HVjcYZghZYh#7^dad\^XVa6ci]gdedad\nd[ i]Z=jbVcH`ZaZidc#ee#&-,·'&(#CZlNdg`/L^aZn"A^hh# GdWa^c\!6#<#!VcYJWZaV`Zg!9#=#&..,#HZmZhi^bVi^dc[gdbi]ZbZiViVghVah#?djgcVad[;d" gZch^XHX^ZcXZh)'/&%+'·&%+.# Gd\Zgh!?#!VcYLVaYgdc!I#&.-.#>c[ZXi^dch^ceVaZdeVi]dad\n/I]ZWVh^hd[XaVhh^ÄXVi^dc^cid bdhiegdWVWaZXVjhZ#?djgcVad[6gX]VZdad\^XVaHX^ZcXZ&+/+&&·+'*# Gd\Zgh!?#!LVaYgdc!I#!9^ZeeZ!E#!VcYLVii!>#&.-,#6gi]gdeVi]^Zh^ceVaVZdeVi]dad\n/I]Z WVh^h d[ XaVhh^ÄXVi^dc VXXdgY^c\ id bdhi egdWVWaZ XVjhZ# ?djgcVa d[ 6gX]VZdad\^XVa HX^ZcXZ &)/&,.·&.(# Gd\Zgh!H#A#&.-+#I]ZEZghdcVa>YZci^ÉXVi^dcd[A^k^c\>cY^k^YjVah#Heg^c\ÄZaY!>aa^cd^h/8#8# I]dbVh# Gd\Zgh!I#A#&...#6k^hjVabZi]dYd[YZiZgb^c^c\i]ZhZmd[h`ZaZiVagZbV^chjh^c\i]ZY^hiVa ]jbZgjh#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh))/*,·+%# Gd\Zgh!I#A#!VcYHVjcYZgh!H#&..)#6XXjgVXnd[hZmYZiZgb^cVi^dcjh^c\bdge]dad\^XVaigV^ih d[i]Z]jbVceZak^h#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(./&%),·&%*+#

7^Wa^d\gVe]n

))*

GŽh^c\!L#&.-)#9^hXgZiVd[i]Z]jbVch`ZaZidc/6Xg^i^XVagZk^Zl#?djgcVad[=jbVc:kdaj" i^dc&(/(&.·('(# Gdhh^!9#!YZciZgcVi^dcVa?djgcVad[DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n&)/&%)·&&&# Gdi]hX]^aY!7#B#&..'#6YkVcXZh^cYZiZXi^c\Y^hZVhZ^cZVga^Zg]jbVcedejaVi^dch#>c/H#G# HVjcYZghVcYB#6#@VioZcWZg\ZYh#H`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[EVhiEZdeaZh/GZhZVgX]BZi]dYh#ee# &(&·&*&#CZlNdg`!L^aZnA^hh# Gdi]hX]^aY!7#B#!LddYh!G#?#!VcYDgiZa!L#&..%#G]ZjbVid^YVgi]g^i^h¹^ci]ZWj[[º/:gd" h^kZVgi]g^i^h^cYZÅZh]ZYWdcZh#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n-'/))&·)).# Gdj\‚!9#!IZabdc!C#!6ggjZ!E#!AVggdjn!<#!VcY6gWjh!A#&..(#GVY^d\gVe]^X^YZci^ÄXVi^dc d[]jbVcgZbV^chi]gdj\]YZ[dgb^i^ZhVcYVcdbVa^Zhd[edhi"XgVc^VaWdcZh/6gZedgid[ ildXVhZh#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(-/..,·&%%,# Gdj\‚"BV^aaVgi!8#!IZabdc!C#!G^hhZX]!8#!BVa\dhV!6#!VcYGdj\‚!9#'%%)#I]ZYZiZgb^" cVi^dcd[bVaZVYjaiV\ZViYZVi]WnXZcigVaVcYedhiZg^dgXdmVaVcVanh^h¸VegZa^b^cVgn hijYn#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)./&·,# Gj[[!8#7#!AVghZc!8#H#!VcY=VnZh!L#8#&.-)#HigjXijgVaX]Vc\Zh^ci]Z[Zbjgl^i]i]Z igVch^i^dc id V\g^XjaijgZ dc i]Z cYZeZcYZciiZhid[i]Z[djgi]g^WV\^c\iZX]c^fjZ#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6c" i]gdedad\n.'/*(·+'# GjhhZaa!B#9#!VcYAZBdgi!;#&.-+#8jibVg`hdci]Z:c\^h'XVakVg^V46bZg^XVc?djgcVad[ E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n+./(&,·('(# HVad!L#A#!6j[YZg]Z^YZ!6#8#!7j^`higV!?#!VcY=daXdbW!I#6#&..)#>YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[Bn" XdWVXiZg^jbijWZgXjadh^h9C6^cVegZ"8dajbW^VcEZgjk^Vcbjbbn#EgdXZZY^c\hd[i]ZCV" i^dcVa6XVYZbnd[HX^ZcXZhd[i]ZJc^iZYHiViZhd[6bZg^XV.&/'%.&·'%.)# HVcY[dgY!B#@#ZY#&..(#>ckZhi^\Vi^dchd[6cX^Zci=jbVcI^hhjZ/8]Zb^XVa6cVanhZh^c6ci]gd" edad\n#AVc\]dgcZ!EZcchankVc^V/c/B#6#@VioZcWZg\VcYH#HVjcYZghZYh#7^dad\^XVa6ci]gdedad\n d[i]Z=jbVcH`ZaZidc#ee#('.·(*%#CZlNdg`/L^aZn"A^hh# # HVjcYZgh!H#G#&.-.#CdcbZig^Xh`ZaZiVakVg^Vi^dc#>c/B#N#>h¨XVcVcY@#6#G#@ZccZYnZYh# GZXdchigjXi^dcd[A^[Z[gdbi]ZH`ZaZidc#ee#.*·&%-#CZlNdg`/6aVcG#A^hh# HVjcYZgh!H#G#!VcY=Zgg^c\!6#ZYh#&..*#ciZgcVi^dcVa?djgcVad[DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n&)/&·+# HX]bjX`Zg!7#?#&.-*#9ZciVaViig^i^dc/6XdggZaVi^kZhijYnd[Y^ZiVgnVcYhjWh^hiZcXZeViiZgch ^c8Va^[dgc^VVcYCZlBZm^Xd>cY^Vch#>c/8#;#BZgWhVcYG#?#B^aaZgZYh#=ZVai]VcY9^h" ZVhZ^ci]ZEgZ]^hidg^XHdji]lZhi#IZbeZ!6g^odcV/6g^odcVHiViZJc^kZgh^in6ci]gdedad\^XVa GZhZVgX]EVeZgh()/',*·('(# HX]dZc^c\Zg!B#?#&..*#HiVWaZ^hdideZhijY^Zh^c]jbVcZkdaji^dc#:kdaji^dcVgn6ci]gdedad\n (/-(·.-# HX]jaio!B#&..,V#B^XgdhXde^XhigjXijgZd[WdcZ#>c/L#9#=V\ajcYVcYB#=#Hdg\ZYh# ;dgZch^XIVe]dcdbn#ee#&-,·&..#7dXVGVidc!;adg^YV/8G8EgZhh#



7^Wa^d\gVe]n

HX]jaio!B#&..,W#B^XgdhXde^X^ckZhi^\Vi^dcd[ZmXVkViZYh`ZaZiVagZbV^ch/6Xdcig^Wji^dc ideVaZdeVi]dad\nVcY[dgZch^XbZY^X^cZ#>c/L#9#=V\ajcYVcYB#=#Hdg\ZYh#;dgZch^X IVe]dcdbn#ee#'%&·'''#7dXVGVidc!;adg^YV/8G8EgZhh# HXdii!9#!L^aaZn!E#!VcY8dccdg!B#ZYh#'%%'#I]Zn9^ZYl^i]8jhiZg/HdaY^ZghÀ7dcZh[gdb i]Z7ViiaZd[A^iiaZ7^\]dgc#CdgbVc!D`aV]dbV/GZYG^kZg7dd`h!Jc^kZgh^ind[D`aV]dbV EgZhh# HXdii! :# 8# &.,.# 9ZciVa lZVg hXdg^c\ iZX]c^fjZ# 6bZg^XVc ?djgcVa d[ E]nh^XVa 6ci]gdedad\n *&/'&(·'&-# HXdii! <# G#! VcY IjgcZg! 8# <# &.--# 9ZciVa Vci]gdedad\n# 6ccjVa GZk^Zl d[ 6ci]gdedad\n &,/..·&'+# HXdii!<#G#!VcYIjgcZg!8#<#&..,#I]Z6ci]gdedad\nd[BdYZgc=jbVcIZZi]/9ZciVaBdge]da" d\nVcY>ihKVg^Vi^dc^cGZXZci=jbVcEdejaVi^dch#CZlNdg`/8VbWg^Y\ZJc^kZgh^inEgZhh# H]V[Zg!=#?#!BVgZ`!B#!VcYGZ^c]VgY!@#?#&.-.#6B^bWgZhWjg^Val^i]VhhdX^ViZYXdadc gZbV^ch[gdbi]ZC6CGVcX]Gj^c!CZlBZm^Xd#?djgcVad[;^ZaY6gX]VZdad\n&+/&,·(%# H]V]VX`"hgVZa/9^[[ZgZci^Vi^c\WZilZZcWjgc^c\VcYdm^YZhiV^c^c\#?djgcVad[6gX]VZdad\^XVa HX^ZcXZ')/)(.·))+# H]ZglddY!G#?#!BZ^cYa!G#H#!GdW^chdc!=#7#!VcYBVnd!G#A#'%%%#;ZiVaV\Z/BZi]dYhd[Zh" i^bVi^dcVcYZ[[ZXihd[eVi]dad\n#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n&&(/(%*·(&*# H^aaZc!6#!HZVaZn!?#8#!VcYkVcYZgBZglZ!C#?#&.-.#8]Zb^hignVcYeVaZdY^ZiVgngZhZVgX]/ CdbdgZZVhnVchlZgh#6bZg^XVc6ci^fj^in*)/*%)·*&'# H`^ccZg!B#!6aZbe^_Zk^X!9#!VcY9_jg^X"HgZ_^X!?#'%%(#<j^YZa^cZh[dg^ciZgcVi^dcVa[dgZc" h^X W^d"VgX]VZdad\n bdc^idgh d[ bVhh \gVkZ Zm]jbVi^dch# ;dgZch^X HX^ZcXZ >ciZgcVi^dcVa &()/-&·.'# H`^ccZg! B#! VcY c/H#G#HVjcYZghVcYB#6#@VioZcWZg\ZYh##H`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[EVhiEZdeaZh/GZ" hZVgX]BZi]dYh#ee#&*(·&,)#CZlNdg`/L^aZn"A^hh# Hb^i]!7#=#&.-)#EViiZgchd[bdaVglZVg^c]jciZg"\Vi]ZgZghVcYV\g^XjaijgVa^hih#6bZg^XVc ?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n+(/(.·*+# Hb^i]! 7# =# &..&# HiVcYVgYh d[ ]jbVc iddi] [dgbVi^dc VcY YZciVa V\Z VhhZhhbZci# >c/ B# 6#@ZaaZnVcY8#H#AVghZcZYh#6YkVcXZh^c9ZciVa6ci]gdedad\n#ee#&)(·&+-#CZlNdg`/ L^aZn"A^hh# Hb^i]!7#=#!VcYYZci^ÄXVi^dcd[]jbVch`ZaZiVagZ" bV^chWnXdbeVg^hdcd[WdcnYZiV^ahd[i]ZXgVc^jbjh^c\XdbejiZg^oZYidbd\gVe]^X8I hXVch#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh),/&·(# Hb^i]!?#!VcYAVi^bZg!7#&.-.#6bZi]dY[dgbV`^c\i]gZZ"Y^bZch^dcVagZegdYjXi^dchd[ WdcZhVcY[dhh^ah#@^giaVcY^V8aZkZaVcYBjhZjbd[CVijgVa=^hidgn))/(·&+# HcdY\gVhh!?#?#!VcYc/B#8dmVcYH#BVnhZYh#=jbVcDhiZdad\n ^c6gX]VZdad\nVcY;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZ#ee#(%,·('(#AdcYdc/ciZgegZiVi^dc#Heg^c\ÄZaY!>aa^cd^h/8#8# I]dbVh#

7^Wa^d\gVe]n

)),

HiZkZchdc! E# =# &.')# 6\Z dgYZg d[ Ze^e]nhZVa jc^dc ^c bVc# 6bZg^XVc ?djgcVa d[ E]nh^XVa 6ci]gdedad\n,/*(·.(# HiZlVgi!I#9#&.,.#:hhZci^Vahd[;dgZch^X6ci]gdedad\n#Heg^c\ÄZaY!>aa^cd^h/8#8#I]dbVh# Hi^gaVcY!6#&..'#9^V\cdh^hd[dXXjeVi^dcVaangZaViZYeVaZdeVi]dad\n/8Vc^iWZYdcZ4>c/9# ?#DgicZgVcY6#8#6j[YZg]Z^YZZYh#=jbVcEVaZdeVi]dad\n/8jggZciHnci]ZhZhVcY;jijgZ Dei^dch#ee#)%·),#LVh]^c\idc!98/Hb^i]hdc^Vc>chi^iji^dcEgZhh# Hi^gaVcY!6#?#&..)#I]ZVc\aZd[[ZbdgVaidgh^dc/6c^bedhh^WaZbZVhjgZbZci4>ciZgcVi^dcVa ?djgcVad[DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n)/(&·(*# # Hi#=dnbZ!A#:#!VcY> # h¨XVc!B#N#&.-.#9ZiZgb^cVi^dcd[hZmVcYgVXZ/6XXjgVXnVcYVhhjbe" i^dch#>c/B#N#>h¨XVcVcY@#6#G#@ZccZYnZYh#GZXdchigjXi^dcd[A^[Z[gdbi]ZH`ZaZidc#ee# *(·.(#CZlNdg`/6aVcG#A^hh# Hid_Vcdlh`^!8#B#&...#HZm^c\ediZci^Vad[[gV\bZciVgnVcYeVi]dad\^XVabZiVXVgeVah#6bZg" ^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n&%./')*·'*'# HidcZ!6#8#'%%%#6cX^Zci9C6[gdbh`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#>c/B#6#@VioZcWZg\VcYH#HVjcYZgh ZYh#7^dad\^XVa6ci]gdedad\nd[i]Z=jbVcH`ZaZidc#ee#(*&·(,&#CZlNdg`/L^aZn"A^hh# HidcZ!6#8#!B^acZg!<#G#!E~~Wd!H#!VcYHidcZ`^c\!B#&..+#HZmYZiZgb^cVi^dcd[VcX^Zci ]jbVch`ZaZidchjh^c\9C6#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n../'(&·'(-# HidcZ!6#8#!VcYHidcZ`^c\!B#&..(#6cX^Zci9C6[gdbVegZ"8dajbW^Vc6bZg^cY^Vcedej" aVi^dc#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n.'/)+(·),&# HidcZ`^c\!B#&..*#6cX^Zci9C6/=dlYdndj`cdll]Zcndj]VkZ^iVcYl]ViXVcndjYd l^i]^i46bZg^XVc?djgcVad[=jbVcc/H#G# HVjcYZghVcYB#6#@VioZcWZg\ZYh#H`ZaZiVa7^dad\nd[EVhiEZdeaZh/GZhZVgX]BZi]dYh# ee#'&·(*#CZlNdg`/L^aZnA^hh# # Hidji!H#9#!9^ZioZ!L#=#!>h¨XVc!B#N#!VcYAdi]!H#G#&..)#:hi^bVi^dcd[V\ZViYZVi]jh^c\ Xdgi^XVa]^hidbdge]dbZignd[i]ZhiZgcVaZcYd[i]Z[djgi]g^W#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh (./,,-·,-)# Hidji!H#9#!VcYEV^cZ!G#G#&..'#=^hidad\^XVaV\ZZhi^bVi^dcjh^c\g^WVcYXaVk^XaZ#6bZg^XVc ?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n-,/&&&·&&+# Hidji!H#9#!Edggd!B#6#!VcYEZgdii^!7#&..+#7g^Z[Xdbbjc^XVi^dc/6iZhiVcYXdggZXi^dcd[ i]ZXaVk^XaZbZi]dY[dg]^hidad\^XVaV\ZYZiZgb^cVi^dcd[h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#6bZg^XVc?djgcVa d[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n&%%/&(.·&)'# HijVgi"BVXVYVb!E#&.-,V#6gVY^d\gVe]^XhijYnd[edgdi^X]neZgdhidh^h#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[ E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n,)/*&&·*'%# HijVgi"BVXVYVb!E#&.-,W#Edgdi^X]neZgdhidh^h/CZlZk^YZcXZidhjeedgii]ZVcZb^Vi]Zdgn# 6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n,)/*'&·*'+# HijVgi"BVXVYVb!E#&..&#Edgdi^X]neZgdhidh^h/8]Vc\^c\^ciZgegZiVi^dch#>c/9#?#DgicZgVcY 6# 8# 6j[YZg]Z^YZ ZYh# =jbVc EVaZdeVi]dad\n/ 8jggZci Hnci]ZhZh VcY ;jijgZ Dei^dch# ee# (+·(.#LVh]^c\idc!98/Hb^i]hdc^Vc>chi^iji^dcEgZhh# HjX]Zn!?#B#!L^hZaZn!9#K#!c/@#?#GZ^X]hZY#;dgZch^XDhiZdad\n/6YkVcXZh^ci]Z >YZci^ÉXVi^dcd[=jbVcGZbV^ch#ee#((·+,#Heg^c\ÄZaY!>aa^cd^h/8#8#I]dbVh# HjcY^X`!G#>#&.-)#6h]ZhidVh]Zh!YjhiidYjhidgl]ZgZY^Yi]Zh`ZaZidc\d4>c/I#6#GVi]" WjgcVcY?#:#7j^`higVZYh#=jbVc>YZci^ÉXVi^dc/8VhZHijY^Zh^c;dgZch^X6ci]gdedad\n#ee# )&'·)'(#Heg^c\ÄZaY!>aa^cd^h/8#8#I]dbVh# Hji]ZgaVcY!A#9#!VcYHjX]Zn!?#B#&..&#JhZd[i]ZkZcigVaVgX^cejW^XhZmYZiZgb^cVi^dc# ?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(+/*%&·*&&# HlZZi!9#?#!VcYHlZZi!=#L#&..*#9C6VcVanh^hd[YZciVaejaeida^c`^cX^cZgViZYgZbV^ch d[]db^X^YZk^Xi^bidXg^bZhXZcZ#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)%/(&%·(&)#



7^Wa^d\gVe]n

IV\jZ!G#<#&.--#7dcZgZhdgei^dcd[i]ZejW^hVcYegZVjg^XjaVgVgZV^c]jbVchVcYcdc]j" bVcbVbbVah#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n,+/'*&·'+,# IVnadg!G#:#!=VgZ!E#:#!VcYL]^iZ!I#9#&..*#aa^cd^h/8#8#I]dbVh# IZV[dgY!B#;#&..&#9ZciVab^XgdlZVg/L]ViXVc^iiZaajhVWdjiY^ZiVcYYZciVa[jcXi^dc4 >c/B#6#@ZaaZnVcY8#H#AVghZcZYh#6YkVcXZh^c9ZciVa6ci]gdedad\n#ee#()&·(*+#CZl Ndg`/L^aZn"A^hh# IZV[dgY!B#;#&..)#9ZciVab^XgdlZVgVcYYZciVa[jcXi^dc#:kdaji^dcVgn6ci]gdedad\n(/&,·(%# I]dbVh!9#=#&.-+#GZÄ\jg^c\6ci]gdedad\n/;^ghiEg^cX^eaZhd[EgdWVW^a^inVcYHiVi^hi^Xh# EgdheZXi=Z^\]ih!>aa^cd^h/LVkZaVcYEgZhh# IdYY!I#L#&.'%#6\ZX]Vc\Zh^ci]ZejW^XWdcZ/>#I]Zl]^iZbVaZejW^h#6bZg^XVc?djgcVa d[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n(/)+,·),%# IgdYYZc!7#?#&.-'#6gVY^d\gVe]^XhijYnd[i]ZXVaX^ÄXVi^dcVcYZgjei^dcd[i]ZeZgbVcZci iZZi]^c>cj^iVcY>cY^VcX]^aYgZc#6gX]VZdad\^XVaHjgkZnd[8VcVYVEVeZgh&&'/&·&(+# IgdiiZg!B#&.,%#:hi^bVi^dcd[hiVijgZ[gdb^ciVXiadc\WdcZh#>c/I#9#HiZlVgiZY#EZghdcVa >YZci^ÉXVi^dc^cBVhh9^hVhiZgh#ee#,&·-(#LVh]^c\idc!98/Hb^i]hdc^Vc>chi^iji^dcEgZhh# IgdiiZg!B#!VcY#6YVeiVi^dc#FjVgiZganGZk^Zld[ 6gX]VZdad\n,/&·(# IjgcZg!8#<#!VcYIjgcZg!?#6#&...#BVc8dgc/8Vcc^WVa^hbVcYK^daZcXZ^ci]Z6bZg^XVc Hdji]lZhi#HVaiAV`Z8^in/Jc^kZgh^ind[JiV]EgZhh# IjgcZg!8#<#!C^X]da!8#G#!VcYHXdii!<#G#&..&#HXdg^c\egdXZYjgZh[dg`Znbdge]dad\^XVa igV^ihd[i]ZeZgbVcZciYZci^i^dc#>c/B#6#@ZaaZnVcY8#H#AVghZcZYh#6YkVcXZh^c9ZciVa 6ci]gdedad\n#ee#&(·(&#CZlNdg`/L^aZn"A^hh# IlZa[i] >ciZgcVi^dcVa 8dc\gZhh d[ 6cVidb^hih &.-.# >ciZgcVi^dcVa 6cVidb^XVa CdbZcXaVijgZ 8dbb^iiZZ/Cdb^cV6cVidb^XV+i]:Y##CZlNdg`/8]jgX]^aa"A^k^c\hidcZ# InggZaa!6#'%%%#H`ZaZiVacdc"bZig^XigV^ihVcYi]ZVhhZhhbZcid[^ciZg"VcY^cigV"edejaVi^dc Y^kZgh^in/EVhiegdWaZbhVcY[jijgZediZci^Va#>c/B#8dmVcYH#BVnhZYh#=jbVcDhiZdad\n ^c6gX]VZdad\nVcY;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZ#ee#'-.·(%+#AdcYdc/ciZgcVi^dcVa7^Wa^d\gV" e]n#HVc9^Z\d/HVc9^Z\dBjhZjbd[BVc# Inhdc!G#6#!VcY6aXVch`Vh!:#H#9#ZYh#&.-%#8ViVad\d[i]Z=gYa^X`VEVaZdeVi]dad\n8daaZX" i^dc#HVc9^Z\d/HVc9^Z\dBjhZjbd[BVc# JWZaV`Zg!9#=#&.-'#I]ZYZkZadebZcid[6bZg^XVceVaZdeVi]dad\n#>c/;#HeZcXZgZY#6 =^hidgnd[6bZg^XVcE]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n&.(%»&.-%#ee#((,·(*+#CZlNdg`/6XVYZb^X EgZhh# JWZaV`Zg! 9# =# &.-)# Edh^i^kZ ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc [gdb i]Z gVY^d\gVe]^X XdbeVg^hdc d[ [gdciVa h^cjh eViiZgch# >c/ I# GVi]Wjgc VcY ?# 7j^`higV ZYh# =jbVc >YZci^ÉXVi^dc# ee# (..·)&&# Heg^c\ÄZaY!>aa^cd^h/8#8#I]dbVh# JWZaV`Zg!9#=#&.-,#:hi^bVi^c\V\ZViYZVi][gdb^bbVijgZ]jbVch`ZaZidch/6cdkZgk^Zl# ?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh('/&'*)·&'+(# JWZaV`Zg!9#=#&..%#Edh^i^kZ^YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[6bZg^XVc>cY^Vch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch[gdbgVY^d" \gVe]XdbeVg^hdc#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(*/)++·),'#

7^Wa^d\gVe]n

)).

JWZaV`Zg!9#=#&.-.#=jbVcH`ZaZiVaGZbV^ch/:mXVkVi^dc!6cVanh^h!>ciZgegZiVi^dc'cY:Y## LVh]^c\idc!98/IVgVmVXjb# JWZaV`Zg!9#=#&..'W#=nd^Y[gVXijgZVcYhigVc\jaVi^dc#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(,/&'&+· &'''# JWZaV`Zg!9#=#&..+#H`ZaZidchiZhi^[n/6ci]gdedad\n^c[dgZch^XhX^ZcXZ66E6AjcX]Zdc 6YYgZhh!6eg^a&'!&..+#NZVgWdd`d[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n(./''.·'))# JWZaV`Zg!9#=#'%%%#BZi]dYdad\^XVaXdch^YZgVi^dch^ci]Z[dgZch^XVeea^XVi^dchd[]jbVc h`ZaZiVaW^dad\n#>c/B#6#@VioZcWZg\VcYH#HVjcYZghZYh#7^dad\^XVa6ci]gdedad\nd[i]Z =jbVcH`ZaZidc#ee#)&·+,#CZlNdg`/L^aZn"A^hh# JWZaV`Zg!9#=#!7ZggnbVc!=#:#!Hjiidc!I#E#!VcYGVn!8#:#&..&#9^[[ZgZci^Vi^dcd[]nYgd" XZe]Va^XXVa[VcY]jbVcXVakVg^VZ#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh(+/-%&·-&'# JWZaV`Zg! 9# =# VcY chi^iji^dcEgZhh# K^iZaa^!@#9#ZY#&..+#6gX]VZdad\^XVa:i]^Xh#LVacji8gZZ`!8Va^[dgc^V/6aiVb^gVEgZhh# Kdc:cYi!9#L#!VcYDgicZg!9#?#&.-)#:meZg^bZciVaZ[[ZXihd[WdcZh^oZVcYiZbeZgVijgZdc WdcZY^V\ZcZh^h#?djgcVad[6gX]VZdad\^XVaHX^ZcXZ&&/'),·'*(# LVaYgdc!I#&..&#GViZh[dgi]Z_dW/BZVhjgZhd[Y^hZVhZ[gZfjZcXn^ceVaVZdeVi]dad\n#>ciZg" cVi^dcVa?djgcVad[DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n&/&,·'*# LVaYgdc! I# &..)# 8djci^c\ i]Z 9ZVY/ I]Z :e^YZb^dad\n d[ H`ZaZiVa EdejaVi^dch# LZhi HjhhZm! :c\aVcY/?d]cL^aZn# LVaYgdc!I#!VcYGd\Zgh!?#&..&#>ciZg"dWhZgkZgkVg^Vi^dc^cXdY^c\dhiZdVgi]g^i^h^c]jbVc h`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#>ciZgcVi^dcVa?djgcVad[DhiZdVgX]VZdad\n&/).·*+# LVa`Zg!6#8#&.-&#9^ZiVgn]nedi]ZhZhVcY]jbVcZkdaji^dc#E]^adhde]^XVaIgVchVXi^dchd[i]Z GdnVaHdX^Zind[AdcYdcHZg^Zh7'.'/*,·+(# LVa`Zg!E#A#&.-+#Edgdi^X]neZgdhidh^h^cVbVg^cZ"YZeZcYZci8Va^[dgc^V>cY^VcedejaVi^dc# 6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n+./()*·(*)# LVa`Zg!E#A#'%%%#7^dVgX]VZdad\^XVaZi]^Xh/6]^hidg^XVaeZgheZXi^kZdci]ZkVajZd[]jbVc gZbV^ch#>c/B#6#@VioZcWZg\VcYH#HVjcYZghZYh#7^dad\^XVa6ci]gdedad\nd[i]Z=jbVc H`ZaZidc#ee#(·(.#CZlNdg`/L^aZn"A^hh# LVa`Zg!E#A#!VcY8dd`!9#8#&..-#c/B#6#@ZaaZnVcY8#H#AVghZcZYh#6YkVcXZh^c9ZciVa6ci]gdedad\n#ee# &+.·&,-#CZlNdg`/L^aZn"A^hh# LVa`Zg!E#A#!VcY:gaVcYhdc!?#B#&.-+#9ZciVaZk^YZcXZ[dgegZ]^hidg^XY^ZiVgnX]Vc\Zdc i]Zcdgi]Zgc8]VccZa>haVcYh!8Va^[dgc^V#6bZg^XVc6ci^fj^in*&/(,*·(-(# LVa`Zg!E#A#!VcY=ZlaZii!7#H#&..%#9ZciVa]ZVai]Y^ZiVcYhdX^VahiVijhVbdc\8ZcigVa 6[g^XVc[dgV\ZghVcY[VgbZgh#6bZg^XVc6ci]gdedad\^hi.'/(-(·(.-# LVa`Zg!E#A#!?d]chdc!?#G#!VcYAVbWZgi!E#B#&.--#6\ZVcYhZmW^VhZh^ci]ZegZhZgkVi^dc d[]jbVch`ZaZiVagZbV^ch#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n,+/&-(·&--# LVa`Zg!E#A#'%%*#ciZgcZi# LVa`Zg!G#&.-*#6<j^YZidEdhiXgVc^Va7dcZhd[:Vhi6[g^XVcBVbbVah#EVad6aid!8Va^[dgc^V/ =nadX]dZgjhEgZhh!7aVX`lZaaHX^Zci^ÄX#



7^Wa^d\gVe]n

LVa`Zg!G#6#!VcYAdkZ_dn!8#D#&.-*#GVY^d\gVe]^XX]Vc\Zh^ci]ZXaVk^XaZVcYegdm^bVa [ZbjgVcYi]Z^gjhZ^ci]ZYZiZgb^cVi^dcd[h`ZaZiVaV\ZViYZVi]#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^" XVa6ci]gdedad\n+-/+,·,-# LVaa^c! ?# 6#! I`dXo! >#! VcY @g^hiZchZc! <# &..)# B^XgdhXde^X V\Z YZiZgb^cVi^dc d[ ]jbVc h`ZaZidch^cXajY^c\Vcjc`cdlcWjiXVaXjaVWaZkVg^VWaZ#>ciZgcVi^dcVa?djgcVad[DhiZdVg" X]VZdad\n)/(*(·(+'# LVagVi]!9#!IjgcZg!E#!VcY7gj• oä Z`!?#'%%)#GZa^VW^a^iniZhid[i]Zk^hjVaVhhZhhbZcid[XgVc^Va igV^ih[dghZmYZiZgb^cVi^dc#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n&'*/&('·&(,# LVeaZg!J#!8gjW‚on!:#VcYHX]jaio!B#'%%)#>hXg^WgVdgW^iVa^Vhncdcnbdjhl^i]VcZb^V4 6cVanh^hVcY^ciZgegZiVi^dcd[XgVc^VaeVi]dad\n^cHjYVc#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6c" i]gdedad\n&')/(((·((.# LVh]Wjgc!H#A#&.)-#HZmY^[[ZgZcXZh^ci]ZejW^XWdcZ#6bZg^XVc?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gd" edad\n+/&..·'%,# LZVkZg! 9# H# &.-+# ;dgZch^X VheZXih d[ [ZiVa VcY cZdcViVa heZX^bZch# >c/ @# ?# GZ^X]h ZY# ;dgZch^XDhiZdad\n/6YkVcXZh^ci]Z>YZci^ÉXVi^dcd[=jbVcGZbV^ch#ee#.%·&%%#Heg^c\ÄZaY! >aa^cd^h/8#8#I]dbVh# LZWW!E#6#!VcYHjX]Zn!?#B#&.-*#:e^e]nhZVajc^dcd[i]ZVciZg^dg^a^VXXgZhiVcYbZY^Va XaVk^XaZ^cVbdYZgcbjai^gVX^VahVbeaZd[6bZg^XVcbVaZhVcY[ZbVaZh#6bZg^XVc?djgcVa d[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n+-/)*,·)++# LZWW!H#&.-,#GZWjgn^c\6jhigVa^Vch`ZaZidch#6ci^fj^in+&/'.'·'.+# LZWhiZg!L#E#!BjggVn!L#@#!7g^c`]djh!L#!VcY=jYhdc!E#&.-+#>YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[]jbVc gZbV^chjh^c\e]did\gVe]^XgZXdchigjXi^dc#>c/@#?#GZ^X]hZY#;dgZch^XDhiZdad\n/6YkVcX" Zh^ci]Z>YZci^ÉXVi^dcd[=jbVcGZbV^ch#ee#'*+·'-.#Heg^c\ÄZaY!>aa^cd^h/8#8#I]dbVh# L]^iZ!I#9#&..'#EgZ]^hidg^X8Vcc^WVa^hbViBVcXdh*BIJBG"'()+#Eg^cXZidc!CZl?ZghZn/ Eg^cXZidcJc^kZgh^inEgZhh# L]^iZ!I#9#!6h[Vl!7#!9Z<jhiV!9#!<^aWZgi!=#!G^X]VgYh!<#9#!HjlV!<#!VcY=dlZaa!;#8# '%%(#EaZ^hidXZcZ=dbdhVe^Zch[gdbB^YYaZ6lVh]!:i]^de^V#CVijgZ)'(/,)'·,),# L]^iZ! I# 9#! VcY ;da`Zch! E# 6# &..&# =jbVc DhiZdad\n# HVc 9^Z\d! 8Va^[dgc^V/ 6XVYZb^X EgZhh# L]^iZ!I#9#!VcY;da`Zch!E#6#'%%%#=jbVcDhiZdad\n'cY:Y##HVc9^Z\d!8Va^[dgc^V/6XV" YZb^XEgZhh# L]^iZ!I#9#!VcYIdi]!C#&.-.#:c\^h/EgZeVgVi^dcYVbV\Z!cdiVcX^ZciXjibVg`h#6bZg^XVc ?djgcVad[E]nh^XVa6ci]gdedad\n,-/(+&·(+,# L]^iiV`Zg!9#'%%%#6\Z^c\[gdbi]ZYZci^i^dc#>c/B#8dmVcYH#BVnhZYh#=jbVcDhiZdad\n ^c6gX]VZdad\nVcY;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZ#ee#-(·..#AdcYdc/ciZgcVi^dcVaHZg^Zh.()# LdZa[Za!?#7#!VcYHX]Z^Y!G#'%%'#9ZciVa6cVidbn#+i]:Y##7Vai^bdgZ!BVgnaVcY/A^ee^c" Xdii!L^aa^Vbh!VcYL^a`^ch# Lda[! 9# ?# &.-+# ;dgZch^X Vci]gdedad\n hXZcZ ^ckZhi^\Vi^dch# >c/ @# ?# GZ^X]h ZY# ;dgZch^X DhiZdad\n/6YkVcXZh^ci]Z>YZci^ÉXVi^dcd[=jbVcGZbV^ch#ee#(·'(#Heg^c\ÄZaY!>aa^cd^h/ 8#8#I]dbVh# LddY!?#L#!B^acZg!<#G#!=VgeZcY^c\!=#8#!VcYLZ^hh!@#B#&..'#I]ZdhiZdad\^XVaeVgV" Ydm/EgdWaZbhd[^c[Zgg^c\egZ]^hidg^X]ZVai][gdbh`ZaZiVahVbeaZh#8jggZci6ci]gdedad\n ((/()(·(,%# LddYh!G#?#!VcYGdi]hX]^aY!7#B#&.--#EdejaVi^dcVcVanh^hd[hnbbZig^XVadh^kZVgi]g^i^h ^cD]^dLddYaVcY>cY^Vch&'%%nZVghV\d#?djgcVad[G]ZjbVidad\n&*/&'*-·&'+(# Lg^\]i!A#:#!VcYNdYZg!8#?#'%%(#GZXZciegd\gZhh^cW^dVgX]VZdad\n/6eegdVX]Zhidi]Z dhiZdad\^XVaeVgVYdm#8jggZci6ci]gdedad\n&&/)(·,%#

7^Wa^d\gVe]n

)*&

NdYZg!8#!JWZaV`Zg!9#=#!VcYEdlZaa!?#;#'%%&#:mVb^cVi^dcd[kVg^Vi^dc^chiZgcVag^WZcY bdge]dad\ngZaZkVciidV\ZVhhZhhbZci#?djgcVad[;dgZch^XHX^ZcXZh)+/''(·'',# O^bbZgbVc! A# ?# &.-&# =dl i]Z 8gdl 8gZZ` VgX]Zdad\^hihk^Zl i]ZfjZhi^dcd[gZWjg^Va# :VganBVc((/'*·'+# O^bbZgbVc!A#?#&.-,V#LZWWdcgZWjg^Va/6Cdgi]6bZg^XVceZgheZXi^kZ#6ci^fj^in+&/)+'· )+(# O^bbZgbVc!A#?#&.-,W#I]Z^beVXid[i]ZXdcXZeihd[i^bZVcYeVhidci]ZXdcXZeid[VgX]VZ" dad\n/HdbZaZhhdch[gdbi]ZgZWjg^Va^hhjZ#6gX]VZdad\^XVaGZk^Zl[gdb8VbWg^Y\Z+/)'·*%# O^bbZgbVc!A#?#&.-.#BVYZgVY^XVaWnbndlc/6cVgX]VZdad\^hiaZVgchidVXXZeigZWjg^Va# >c/G#AVnidcZY#8dcÊ^Xi^ci]Z6gX]VZdad\nd[A^k^c\IgVY^i^dch#ee#+%·+,#AdcYdc/Jcl^c =nbVc# O^bbZgbVc!A#?#&..)#H]Vg^c\Xdcigdad[i]ZeVhi#6gX]VZdad\nCdk$9ZX#+*·+-# O^bbZgbVc!A#?#&..,#6ci]gdedad\nVcYgZhedchZhidi]ZgZWjg^Va^hhjZ#>c/I#7^dah^VcYA# ?#O^bbZgbVcZYh#>cY^VchVcY6ci]gdedad\^hih/K^cZ9Zadg^V?g#!VcYi]Z8g^i^fjZd[6ci]gd" edad\n#ee#.'·&&'#IjXhdc!6g^odcV/Jc^kZgh^ind[6g^odcVEgZhh# O^bbZgbVc!B#G#!VcY@ZaaZn!B#6#&.-'#6iaVhd[=jbVcEVaZdeVi]dad\n#CZlNdg`/EgVZ" \Zg# Odaa^`d[Zg!8#E#:#!EdcXZYZAZ‹c!B#H#!VcYBVgi^c!G#9#&..-#8dbejiZg"Vhh^hiZYeVaZdVc" i]gdedad\n#:kdaji^dcVgn6ci]gdedad\n+/)&·*)#



7^Wa^d\gVe]n

>cYZm 6WaVi^dc!YZÄc^i^dc!)&. 6WhXZhh!YZÄc^i^dc!)&. 6XXjgVXn![VXidghV[[ZXi^c\h`ZaZiVa^YZci^" ÄXVi^dc!(+%·(+' 6X]dcYgdeaVh^V  YZÄc^i^dc!)&.  h`ZaZiVaÄcY^c\h!(') 6XgdbZ\Van  YZÄc^i^dc!)&.  h`ZaZiVaÄcY^c\h!(') 6\ZYZiZgb^cVi^dc  VXXjgVXnVcYegZX^h^dc!(+%·(+'  V\ZXaVhhZh!(+)  XgVc^VahjijgZXadhjgZVcYVYjaiV\Z Zhi^bVi^dc!(+.!(,&  YZci^i^dcVcYV\ZZhi^bVi^dc   VYjaiV\Z!(+*!(+,·(+  hjWVYjaiV\Z!(+)·(+*  Ze^e]nhZVaXadhjgZVcYhjWVYjaiV\Z Zhi^bVi^dc!(,(·(,)  ^a^jbVjg^XjaVghjg[VXZVcYVYjaiV\Z Zhi^bVi^dc!(-%·(-&  adc\WdcZ"aZc\i]VcYhjWVYjaiV\Z Zhi^bVi^dc!(,&!(,(  b^XgdhigjXijgZVcVanh^h!(-&!(-)  bjai^[VXidg^VaV\ZZhi^bVi^dc!(-)· (-*  ejW^Xhnbe]nh^h   eVgijg^i^dcZ[[ZXih!(,*!(-%   hjWVYjaiV\ZZhi^bVi^dc!(,)·(,*  gVY^d\gVe]n!(-&  g^WhVcYVYjaiV\ZZhi^bVi^dc!(-&  hiVcYVgYh[gdb`cdlchVbeaZh!(+'· (+) 6\ZcZh^h!YZÄc^i^dc!)&. 6akZdaVggZhdgei^dc!YZÄc^i^dc!)&. 6akZdajh!YZÄc^i^dc!)&. 6bZadWaVhi!YZÄc^i^dc!)&. 6bejiVi^dc!VcVanh^h!(&,

6cXZhign!^YZci^ÄXVi^dc[gdbh`ZaZidc! )%%·)%( 6c`nadh^c\hedcYna^i^h  YZÄc^i^dc!)&.  dkZgk^Zl!('6c`nadh^h!YZÄc^i^dc!)&. 6caV\Z!YZÄc^i^dc!)&. 6ccjajhÄWgdhjh!YZÄc^i^dc!)&. 6ciZbdgiZb  X]Vc\Zh!)&.  YZÄc^i^dc!)&. 6ci^bZgZ!YZÄc^i^dc!)&. 6ci^fj^in!VhhZhhbZcid[dhiZdad\^XVa gZbV^ch!. 6ede]nh^h!YZÄc^i^dc!)&. 6eeZcY^XjaVgh`ZaZidc  XdbedcZcih!+,  YZÄc^i^dc!)&. 6gX]Zdad\^XVadhiZdad\n  Zi]^Xh   CVi^kZ6bZg^XVc
)*(

 XdbedcZcih!+,  YZÄc^i^dc!)'% 7Vaa"VcY"hdX`Zi_d^ci!YZÄc^i^dc)'%0hZZ VahdHe]Zgd^YVa_d^ci 7Vh^XgVc^jb!YZÄc^i^dc!)'% 7Vh^aVghjijgZ!hZZHe]ZcddXX^e^iVahjijgZ 7^dad\^XVaY^hiVcXZ!Zhi^bVi^dc!)&%·)&& 7dcZ  VcVidb^XVaiZgb^cdad\n   YZegZhh^dch!,)   Y^gZXi^dcVaiZgbh!+  bdi^dciZgbh!,&·,'   egd_ZXi^dchVcYeVgih!,(·,)  [jcXi^dcVadkZgk^Zl!(&  \gdhhVcVidbn!)%!)'  \gdli]!)+·),  ]^hidad\n!)'·)(  ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc!hZZ>YZci^ÄXVi^dc  bZX]Vc^XVaegdeZgi^Zh!((  bdaZXjaVghigjXijgZ!)'  gZeV^g!) h`ZaZiVaZaZbZcih!,&  kVg^Vi^dc!hZZKVg^Vi^dc 7jXXVa!YZÄc^i^dc!)'% 8VaXVcZjh  VcVidbn!'.)!'.+  h^Y^c\!'.+ 8VaXjajh  YZÄc^i^dc!)'%  YZciVaÄcY^c\h!((% 8Vaajh  WdcZgZeV^g!)-!(&)  YZÄc^i^dc!)'% 8VadiiZ!YZÄc^i^dc!)'% 8VakVg^V!YZÄc^i^dc!)'% 8VcVa^Xja^![ZVijgZh!)( 8VcXZaadjhWdcZ  YZÄc^i^dc!)'%  [ZVijgZh!)% 8Vc^cZiZZi]!hZZ9Zci^i^dc 8Ve^iViZ  VcVidbn!'('  h^Y^c\!'(' 8VgWdc^hdideZh!Y^ZigZXdchigjXi^dc!)&( 8Vg^Zh  YZÄc^i^dc!)'%  Y^ZigZXdchigjXi^dc!)&&·)&'  ÄcY^c\h!('. 8VgeVah  VcVidbn!'' XVe^iViZ!'('



>cYZm

    

\gdli]!'(( ]VbViZ!'('·'(( ajcViZ!''.·'(% e^h^[dgb!'(% edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]ZgWdcZh! '((  hXVe]d^Y!''.  igVeZo^jb!'(&  igVeZod^Y!'(&  ig^fjZigVa!'(% 8Vgi^aV\Z  YZÄc^i^dc!)'%  [ZVijgZh!((  ]nVa^cZXVgi^aV\Z!(( 8Vgi^aV\^cdjh_d^ci  YZÄc^i^dc!)'%  [ZVijgZh!(* 8ZbZcijb!YZÄc^i^dc!)'% 8Zgk^XVakZgiZWgVZ!hZZKZgiZWgVZ 8Zgk^XdZcVbZaa^cZdg_jcXi^dc!YZÄc^" i^dc!)'% 8aVk^XaZ  VcVidbn!&.(·&.*  \gdli]!&.*  ^YZci^ÄXVi^dcVcYedhh^WaZXdc[jh^dc! &.*  h^Y^c\!&.* 8aZVc^c\!hZZEgZeVgVi^dc 8dXXnm!VcVidbn!')* 8daaV\Zc  WdcZXdbedh^i^dc!)'  YZÄc^i^dc!)'% 8dbb^c\aZY!YZÄc^i^dc!)'% 8dbb^cjiZY[gVXijgZ!YZÄc^i^dc!)'% 8dbeVXiWdcZ!YZÄc^i^dc!)'% 8dbeaZiZ[gVXijgZ!YZÄc^i^dc!)'% 8dbedjcY[gVXijgZ!YZÄc^i^dc!)'% 8dbejiZYidbd\gVe]n  YZÄc^i^dc!)'%  bZig^XVXfj^h^i^dcVcYVcVanh^h!()%· ()&!()-!(*( 8dbejiZgh!dhiZdad\nVeea^XVi^dch! (*)·(** 8dc\Zc^iVa!YZÄc^i^dc!)'% 8dgdcVaeaVcZ!YZÄc^i^dc!+, 8dgdcVahjijgZ!YZÄc^i^dc!-+!)'% 8dgi^XVaWdcZ![ZVijgZh!)% 8gVc^VahjijgZh  XadhjgZVcYVYjaiV\ZZhi^bVi^dc!(+.! (,&  YZÄc^i^dc!)'%  [ZVijgZh!(*!-*·-+

8gVc^dhncdhidh^h!YZÄc^i^dc!)'& 8gVc^jb!YZÄc^i^dc!)'& 8gZbVi^dc!YZÄc^i^dc!)'& 8g^WgVXgVc^^  XVjhZh!('%·(''  YZÄc^i^dc!)'& 8g^WgVdgW^iVa^V  XVjhZh!('%·(''  YZÄc^i^dc!)'& 8I!hZZ8dbejiZYidbd\gVe]n 8jWd^Y  VcVidbn!'.+·'.,  h^Y^c\!'., 8jcZ^[dgbh  ÄghibZY^Va!'. hZXdcY^ciZgbZY^ViZ!'. h^Y^c\!'.-!(%%  i]^gYaViZgVa!'.-!(%% 8jgVi^dc!h`ZaZiVabViZg^Va!(*9ZX^YjdjhiZZi]!YZÄc^i^dc!)'& 9Z[dgbVi^dc!hZZ6gi^ÄX^VaYZ[dgbVi^dc 9Z]^hXZcXZ!YZÄc^i^dc!)'& 9Zbd\gVe]n  YZÄc^i^dc!)'&  gZXdchigjXi^dc[gdbh`ZaZiVagZbV^ch! )&)·)&, 9ZciVa]nedeaVh^V  YZÄc^i^dc!)'&  ÄcY^c\h!('. 9ZciVaeaVfjZ!YZÄc^i^dc!)'& 9Zci^c!YZÄc^i^dc!)'& 9Zci^cdZcVbZa_jcXi^dc!YZÄc^i^dc!)'& 9Zci^i^dc  V\ZZhi^bVi^dc   VYjaiV\Z!(+*!(+,·(+  hjWVYjaiV\Z!(+)·(+*  VcVidbnd[iZZi]!&',!&(%·&(&!&((  Y^ZigZXdchigjXi^dc!)&&·)&'  [dgZch^XdYdcidad\n!)%*  ^YZci^ÄXVi^dcd[^hdaViZYiZZi]   XVc^cZh!&()!&(.!&)-·&).   ^cX^hdgh!&()!&(.!&)'!&)  adXVa^oVi^dc^cVgX]!&)'!&))! &)+·&),   adXVa^oVi^dcWnh^YZ!&)-·&*%!&*'   bdaVgh!&(+!&)&!&)+·&),!&*'   dkZgk^Zl!&((·&()   eZgbVcZcikZghjhYZX^Yjdjhiddi]! &(+   egZbdaVgh!&(+!&)%!&))!&).·&*%   jeeZgkZghjhadlZgiddi]!&(-·&)&

            

cdcbZig^XkVg^Vi^dc!)%, eVi]dad\n  Vgi^ÄX^VabdY^ÄXVi^dc!((&  XVaXjajh!((%  XVg^Zh!('.  YZciVa]nedeaVh^V!('.  Y^hZVhZXaVhh^ÄXVi^dc!(' eZg^dYdci^i^h!((% hZmYZiZgb^cVi^dc!(-, iZgb^cdad\n  Y^gZXi^dcVaiZgbh!+.!&' cjbWZg^c\d[iZZi]!&' h]dgi]VcY[dgiddi]^YZci^ÄXVi^dc! &'-!&(%  iddi]ineZhVcY[jcXi^dch!&',·&'9Zdmng^WdcjXaZ^XVX^Y!YZÄc^i^dc!)'& 9^VX]gdc^X!YZÄc^i^dc!)'& 9^V\ZcZh^h!YZÄc^i^dc!)'& 9^Ve]nh^h  YZÄc^i^dc!)'&  [ZVijgZh!)' 9^Zi!h`ZaZiVahijY^Zh!)&&·)&) 9^gZXi^dcVaiZgbh!VcVidbn  \ZcZgVaiZgbh!+ ]VcYhVcY[ZZi!+-!'' iZZi]!+. 9^hXdci^cjdjhbdge]dad\^XVaigV^ih!YZÄ" c^i^dc!)'&0hZZVahd9^hXgZiZigV^ih 9^hXdkZgn!dhiZdad\^XVagZbV^ch!-·. 9^hXgZiZigV^ih  XgVc^VacdcbZig^XkVg^Vi^dc!)%,!)&%  YZÄc^i^dc!)'&  YZciVacdcbZig^XkVg^Vi^dc!)%,  dkZgk^Zl!)%+·)%,  edhiXgVc^VacdcbZig^XkVg^Vi^dc!)&% 9^hXgZiZkVg^VWaZh!YZÄc^i^dc!)'& 9^hadXVi^dc!ÄcY^c\h!(&) 9C6!hZZ9Zdmng^WdcjXaZ^XVX^Y 9C6VcVanh^h!hZZBdaZXjaVgdhiZdad\n 9lVgÄhb!h`ZaZiVaÄcY^c\h!(') 9nheaVh^V!YZÄc^i^dc!)'& :WjgcVi^dc  YZÄc^i^dc!)'&  dhiZdVgi]g^i^h!(', :YZcijadjh!YZÄc^i^dc!)'& :cVbZa!YZÄc^i^dc!)'& :cYdX]dcYgVadhh^ÄXVi^dc!YZÄc^i^dc!)'& :cYdhiZjb!YZÄc^i^dc!)'!)'& :e^e]nh^h  XadhjgZVcYhjWVYjaiV\ZZhi^bVi^dc! (,(·(,)

>cYZm

)**

 YZÄc^i^dc!)'&  [ZVijgZh!)% :i]^Xh  VgX]Zdad\^XVadhiZdad\n   CVi^kZ6bZg^XVc
 igVchedgi!'% ;^c\Zgh!hZZBZiVXVgeVah0E]VaVc\Zh ;dXVa!YZÄc^i^dc!)'' ;dciVcZaaZ!YZÄc^i^dc!-*!)'' ;ddi!hZZVahdheZX^ÄXWdcZh  Vgi^XjaVi^dcd[WdcZh!'-,  Y^gZXi^dcVaiZgbh!+ bdi^dciZgbh!,'!(&) ;dgVbZcbV\cjb!YZÄc^i^dc!)'' ;dgZch^XdhiZdad\n!YZÄc^i^dc!&!)'' ;gVXijgZ  ]ZVa^c\!) edhibdgiZb!*%·*'  ehZjYVgi]gdh^h!(&)  ineZh!(&' ;gVc`[jgi=dg^odciVa  YZÄc^i^dc!)''  h`jaadg^ZciVi^dc!-+ ;gdciVa  VcVidbn!-,·-.!.&  \gdli]!.&  h^Y^c\!.& ;gdciVaeaVcZ!hZZ8dgdcVaeaVcZ ;gdcidcVhVahjijgZ!YZÄc^i^dc!-*

;VX^VagZXdchigjXi^dc!^cY^k^YjVa^YZci^Ä" XVi^dc!)%+ ;Zbjg  VcVidbn!'**·'*,  \gdli]!'+,  edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]ZgWdcZh! '+,  h^Y^c\!'+,  hiVijgZZhi^bVi^dc!(.-·(.. ;^WjaV  VcVidbn!'-%·'-&  \gdli]!'-&  edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]ZgWdcZh! '-&  h^Y^c\!'-& ;^ZaYldg`  XdciZmid[h^iZ!&&!&+  Y^hXdkZgn!-·.  ZmXVkVi^dcVcYgZig^ZkVa   VhhZhhbZcid[h^ijVi^dc!.·&%   Zfj^ebZciVcYhjeea^Zh!&'   \ZcZgVahiZeh!&&!&)·&,   gZbdkVai^eh!&,  [dgbh!& ^ciZgbZciineZh!&*·&+  hZVgX]! hiVcYVgYdeZgVi^c\egdXZYjgZh!,!(((

<^\Vci^hb  YZÄc^i^dc!)''  h`ZaZiVaÄcY^c\h!(')


>cYZm

  [ddi!(%,   ]VcY!')%  egdXZhh^cWdcZ!)+·),  gVY^jh!'&*  g^W!&-,  hVXgjb!'))  hXVejaV!'%&  h`jaa!-)·-+  he]Zcd^Y!&'&  hiZgcjb!&-)  iVghVa!(%%  iZbedgVa!. i^W^V!',.  jacV!''%  kZgiZWgVZ!&+'·&+(  kdbZg!&&%  on\dbVi^X!&&+
=nVa^cZXVgi^aV\Z!YZÄc^i^dc!)'' =nYgdmnVeVi^iZ  WdcZXdbedh^i^dc!)'  YZÄc^i^dc!)'' =nd^Y  VcVidbn!&**  \gdli]!&*+  h^Y^c\!&*+ =neZgXZbZcidh^h!YZÄc^i^dc!)'' =neZgdhidh^h!YZÄc^i^dc!)'' =neZgeaVh^V!YZÄc^i^dc!)'' =neZgigde]n!YZÄc^i^dc!)'' =nedeaVh^V!YZÄc^i^dc!)'' >YZci^ÄXVi^dc  eVaeVi^dc!*  i^eh!*·+ >Y^dhncXgVi^X!YZÄc^i^dc!)'' >a^jb!Vjg^XjaVghjg[VXZVcYVYjaiV\Z Zhi^bVi^dc!(-%·(-& >cXVWdcZ!YZÄc^i^dc!)'' >cX^hdg!hZZ9Zci^i^dc >cXdbeaZiZ[gVXijgZ!YZÄc^i^dc!)'' >cXjh!&%% >cY^k^YjVi^dc!hZZVahd9^hXgZiZigV^ih  [dgZch^XdhiZdad\n\dVa!'  bdaZXjaVgVcVanh^h!)%)·)%* >c[Zg^dgcVhVaXdcX]VZ  VcVidbn!&&&  \gdli]!&&&  edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]ZgWdcZh! &&&  h^Y^c\!&&& >c]jbVi^dc!YZÄc^i^dc!)'' >ciZgcZigZhdjgXZh!]jbVcdhiZdad\n!*! )',·)'>ciZgbZci  YZÄc^i^dc!)''  ineZh!&*·&+ >ciZgdWhZgkZgZggdg!YZÄc^i^dc!)'' >ciZgegdm^bVa!YZÄc^i^dc!)'' >cigVbZbWgVcdjhdhh^ÄXVi^dc!YZÄc^i^dc! )'' >cigVdWhZgkZgZggdg!YZÄc^i^dc!)'( ?VX`Zi^c\!ÄZaYheZX^bZch!'% ?d^ci!YZÄc^i^dc!)'( ?d^ciXVehjaZ![ZVijgZh!(( @ne]dh^h  YZÄc^i^dc!)'(  ijWZgXjadh^hVhhdX^Vi^dc!(&-

>cYZm

)*,

AVW^Va!YZÄc^i^dc!)'( AVWdgVidgn  Xdbeji^c\!(*)·(**  XjgVi^dc!(* a^\]i^c\!(((  bZig^XVXfj^h^i^dcVcYVcVanh^h!()%·())  b^XgdhXden!(*(·(*)  bdaY^c\VcYXVhi^c\!() bdaZXjaVgdhiZdad\n!hZZBdaZXjaVgdhiZda" d\n  e]did\gVe]n!hZZE]did\gVe]n  egZeVgVi^dc!((*·((,  egZhZgkVi^dc!(()·((*  gVY^d\gVe]n!(*(  gZedgi^c\!(**·(*,  gZhidgVi^dc!((-·((.  hdgi^c\!((. AVXg^bVah  VcVidbn!&&'·&&(  \gdli]!&&(  edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]ZgWdcZh!&&(  h^Y^c\!&&( AVXjcV![ZVijgZh!)( AVbWYd^YVahjijgZ!YZÄc^i^dc!-+!)'( AVbZaaVgWdcZ!YZÄc^i^dc!)'( AZ\!hZZ;Zbjg0;^WjaV0EViZaaV0I^W^V AZh^dc!YZÄc^i^dc!)'( A^\VbZci![ZVijgZh!((!(, A^c\jVa!YZÄc^i^dc!)'( A^ee^c\!YZÄc^i^dc!)'( AjbWVgkZgiZWgVZ!hZZKZgiZWgVZ AjcViZ  VcVidbn!''.  h^Y^c\!''.·'(% BVaaZjh!&%% BVadXXajh^dc!YZÄc^i^dc!)'( BVcY^WaZ  VcVidbn!&''·&'*  \gdli]!&'+  edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]ZgWdcZh!&'+  h^Y^c\!&'+ BVggdl![ZVijgZh!)% BVhhZiZgbjhXaZ!YZÄc^i^dc!)'( BVm^aaVZ  VcVidbn!&%)!&%+  \gdli]!&%+  edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]ZgWdcZh!&%,  h^Y^c\!&%, BZY^VaeiZgn\d^YbjhXaZ!YZÄc^i^dc!)'( BZY^VceaVcZ!hZZHV\^iiVaeaVcZ BZYjaaVgnXVk^in!YZÄc^i^dc!)'(



>cYZm

BZiVXVgeVah  VcVidbn!'((!'(+  [ZVijgZhVcYh^Y^c\   Ä[i]!'(  Äghi!'(+   [djgi]!'(+!'(  hZXdcY!'(+   h^Y^c\\j^YZa^cZh!'(.   i]^gY!'(+  \gdli]!'(-·'(.  cjbWZg^c\!'((  edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]ZgWdcZh! '(. BZiVe]nhZh  YZÄc^i^dc!)'!)'(  [ZVijgZh!)% BZiViVghVah  VcVidbn!(%%  Ä[i]!(%*  Äghi!(%%!(%*  [djgi]!(%*  \gdli]!(%+  cjbWZg^c\!(%%  edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]ZgWdcZh! (%+  hZXdcY!(%*  h^Y^c\!(%*·(%+  i]^gY!(%* BZide^XhjijgZ!YZÄc^i^dc!-*!)'( BZig^Xh  Y^\^iVa^bV\^c\!()%·()&  bZVhjgZbZciZggdgZhi^bVi^dc!()(  bZVhjgZbZciineZh!()(·())  bjai^kVg^ViZbdge]dbZig^Xh!())  iddah!()'·()( B^Ya^cZeaVcZ!hZZHV\^iiVaeaVcZ B^c^bjbcjbWZgd[^cY^k^YjVah  YZÄc^i^dc!)'(  YZiZgb^cVi^dc!((. B^idX]dcYg^Va9C6!YZÄc^i^dc!)'( BC>!hZZB^c^bjbcjbWZgd[^cY^k^Yj" Vah BdaVg!hZZ9Zci^i^dc BdaY^c\!heZX^bZch!()BdaZXjaVgdhiZdad\n  Veea^XVi^dch!())  XdciVb^cVi^dc!(),  9C6egZhZgkVi^dc^chVbeaZh!(),·() ^cY^k^YjVa^YZci^ÄXVi^dc!)%)·)%*  edanbZgVhZX]V^cgZVXi^dcVbea^ÄXV" i^dcd[9C6!()+·(),  hVbea^c\!()*·()+

Bdge]d\Zc!YZÄc^i^dc!)'( Bdge]d\ZcZh^h!YZÄc^i^dc!)'( Bdge]dad\n!YZÄc^i^dc!)'( Bdi^dciZgbh  \ZcZgVaiZgbh!,&·,'  ]VcYhVcY[ZZi!,' Bjai^eaZ^ciZgbZci!YZÄc^i^dc!)'( BjhXaZ  VciV\dc^hibjhXaZh!( ViiVX]bZcih^iZh   ^chZgi^dc!(-!+.   dg^\^c!(-!+. C6<EG6!hZZCVi^kZ6bZg^XVc
 edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]ZgWdcZh! '*'  hZmYZiZgb^cVi^dc!(.'!(.)·(.*!(. h^Y^c\!'*' Dhh^ÄXVi^dc  egdXZhh!)+·),  ineZh!)+ DhhjVgn!YZÄc^i^dc!)'( DhiZ^i^h!YZÄc^i^dc!(&,!)'( DhiZbVaVX^V!YZÄc^i^dc!)') DhiZdVgi]g^i^h  WdcZÄcY^c\h!(',  XVjhZh!('*  XaVhh^ÄXVi^dc!('*!(',  YZÄc^i^dc!)') DhiZdWaVhi  YZÄc^i^dc!)')  [jcXi^dc!)( DhiZdX]dcYgdbV!YZÄc^i^dc!)') DhiZdXaVhi  YZÄc^i^dc!)')  [jcXi^dc!)( DhiZdXniZ  YZÄc^i^dc!)')  [jcXi^dc!)( DhiZd\ZcZh^h!YZÄc^i^dc!)+!)') DhiZdad\n!hXdeZ^c]jbVch!&·( DhiZdbV!YZÄc^i^dc!)') DhiZdbVaVX^V!YZÄc^i^dc!)') DhiZdbZig^X!YZÄc^i^dc!)') DhiZdbnZa^i^h  XVjhZh!(& YZÄc^i^dc!(&,!)')  ÄcY^c\h!(&DhiZdc!YZÄc^i^dc!)') DhiZde]niZ!YZÄc^i^dc!)') DhiZdedgdh^h  YZÄc^i^dc!)')  dkZgk^Zl!('( DhiZdhVgXdbV!YZÄc^i^dc!)') EVaVi^cZh  VcVidbn!&%,·&%.  \gdli]!&%.  edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]ZgWdcZh! &%.  h^Y^c\!&%. EVaZdYZbd\gVe]n  V^bh!(+%  YZÄc^i^dc!(+%!)&)!)')  gZXdchigjXi^dc[gdbh`ZaZiVagZbV^ch! )&)·)&,

>cYZm

)*.

EVaZdZe^YZb^dad\n  V^bh!(+%  YZÄc^i^dc!(%. EVaZdeVi]dad\n  YZÄc^i^dc!(%.!)')  YZhXg^ei^dcd[VcdbVa^Zh!(&&  Y^V\cdh^h!(&&  a^b^iVi^dchd[WdcZhijY^Zh!(&%·(&& EVgVhV\^iiVahZXi^dc!YZÄc^i^dc!+,!)') EVg^ZiVah  VcVidbn!.'·.)  \gdli]!.)  edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]ZgWdcZh! .)  h^Y^c\!.) EViZaaV  VcVidbn!',%  \gdli]!',%  edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]ZgWdcZh! ',%  h^Y^c\!',& EVi]dad\^XVa[gVXijgZ!YZÄc^i^dc!)') E8G!hZZEdanbZgVhZX]V^cgZVXi^dc EZak^X\^gYaZ!hZZ8dXXnm0DhXdmVZ0HV" Xgjb EVg^ZidbVhid^YhjijgZ!YZÄc^i^dc!-+ EZg^`nbViV!YZÄc^i^dc!)') EZg^bdgiZb!YZÄc^i^dc!*%!)') EZg^dYdci^i^h  YZÄc^i^dc!)')  ÄcY^c\h!((% EZg^dhiZjb  YZÄc^i^dc!)'!)')  [dgbVi^dc!)+ EZg^dhi^i^h  XVjhZh!(& YZÄc^i^dc!(&,!)')  ÄcY^c\h!(&EZg^dhidh^h!YZÄc^i^dc!)') E]VaVc\Zh  [ddi   VcVidbn!(%+   Y^hiVae]VaVc\Zh!(%+·(%,   \gdli]!(%,   ^ciZgbZY^ViZe]VaVc\Zh!(%+   edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]Zg WdcZh!(%,·(%  egdm^bVae]VaVc\Zh!(%+   h^Y^c\!(% ]VcY   VcVidbn!'(.·')%   Y^hiVae]VaVc\Zh!')%



>cYZm

  \gdli]!')%   ^ciZgbZY^ViZe]VaVc\Zh!')%   edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]Zg WdcZh!')%   egdm^bVae]VaVc\Zh!')%   h^Y^c\!')% E]did\gVe]n!WdcZheZX^bZch  Y^\^iVa^bV\^c\!()-·().!(*'  Zfj^ebZci!().·(*%  ZmedhjgZ!(*%·(*&  aZ\VaXdch^YZgVi^dch!(*'  a^\]i^c\!(*&·(*'  dkZgk^Zl!)  hZije!(*' E^g^[dgbVeZgijgZ!YZÄc^i^dc!)') E^h^[dgb  VcVidbn!'(%  h^Y^c\!'(% EaVcVg_d^ci  YZÄc^i^dc!)'*  [ZVijgZh!() EdaaZm!YZÄc^i^dc!)') EdanbZgVhZX]V^cgZVXi^dc  YZÄc^i^dc!)'*  9C6VcVanh^h!()+·(), Edgdh^in!YZÄc^i^dc!)'* Edgdi^X]neZgdhidh^h  XVjhZh!('%·(''  YZÄc^i^dc!)'*  ÄcY^c\h!('% EdhiXgVc^Vah`ZaZidc!YZÄc^i^dc!)'* EdhibdgiZbbdY^ÄXVi^dc  Vc^bVaYVbV\Z!**!*,  YZÄc^i^dc!)'*  [gVXijgZ!*%·*'  ]jbVcbdY^ÄXVi^dc   XVcc^WVa^hb!*,!+%   X]debVg`h!+%   XjibVg`h!+%   bdgijVgnegVXi^XZh!*,   eZgXjhh^dcbVg`h!+'   egd_ZXi^aZh!+'   hXgVeZbVg`h!+%!+'  e]nh^XVaV\Zcih   VWgVh^dc!*)   X]Zb^hign!*'!*)   ÄgZ!*)   gdX`!ZVgi]!VcY^XZ!*)  eaVciYVbV\Z!*,  iVe]dcdbn!).·*% EgZX^h^dc![VXidghV[[ZXi^c\h`ZaZiVa^YZci^" ÄXVi^dc!(+%·(+'

EgZbdaVg!hZZ9Zci^i^dc EgZeVgVi^dc  ÅZh]gZbdkVa!((,  [dhh^ah!((*·((+  iddahVcYiZX]c^fjZh!((*·((+  lVh]^c\!((* EgZhZgkVi^kZh  Y^aji^dc!((*  ineZh!(() Eg^bVgnWdcnXVaajh!YZÄc^i^dc!)'* Eg^bVgn^ciZgbZci!YZÄc^i^dc!)'* Eg^bVgndhh^ÄXVi^dcXZciZg!YZÄc^i^dc! )'* EgdkZc^ZcXZ!YZÄc^i^dc!)'* EhZjYVgi]gdh^h!YZÄc^i^dc!)'*  [gVXijgZ^cYjXi^dc!(&) EjW^Xhnbe]nh^h  V\Z"gZaViZYX]Vc\Zh!(,)·(,*  eVgijg^i^dcZ[[ZXih!(,*!(-% GVY^d\gVe]n  WdcZh!(*(  YZÄc^i^dc!)'*  ^cY^k^YjVa^YZci^ÄXVi^dc!)%*·)%+ GVY^jh  VcVidbn!'&)·'&*  \gdli]!'&*  ^YZci^ÄXVi^dcVcYedhh^WaZXdc[jh^dc! '&*·'&+  h^Y^c\!'&+·'&, GZVXi^kZWdcZ!YZÄc^i^dc!)'* GZ[ZgZcXZeaVcZh!VcVidbn!+, GZbdYZa^c\!YZÄc^i^dc!)'* GZedgi^c\  VgX]Zdad\^XVadhiZdad\n!(*+  XdciZcihd[gZedgi!(*+·(*,  [dgZch^XdhiZdad\n!(**·(*+  ejWa^XVi^dch!(**·(*, GZhdgei^dc!YZÄc^i^dc!)'* GZhidgVi^dc!\j^YZa^cZh!((-·((. GZig^ZkVa  VhhZhhbZcid[h^ijVi^dc!.·&%  Zfj^ebZciVcYhjeea^Zh!&'  \ZcZgVahiZeh!&&!&)·&,  gZbdkVai^eh!&, G]ZjbVid^YVgi]g^i^h  YZÄc^i^dc!)'*  dkZgk^Zl!(', G^Wh  VYjaiV\ZZhi^bVi^dc!(-&  VcVidbn!&-*!&-,  \gdli]!&-,

 ^YZci^ÄXVi^dcVcYedhh^WaZXdc[jh^dc! &-,!&.'  h^Y^c\!&.' G^X`Zih  WdcZÄcY^c\h!('(  YZÄc^i^dc!)'* HVXgjb  VcVidbn!')&·')'  \gdli]!'))  edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]ZgWdcZh! '))·')*  hZmYZiZgb^cVi^dc!(.'!(.)  h^Y^c\!')* HVYYaZ"h]VeZY_d^ci  YZÄc^i^dc!)'*  [ZVijgZh!() HV\^iiVaeaVcZ!YZÄc^i^dc!+,!)'* HV\^iiVahjijgZ!YZÄc^i^dc!-*!)'* HVgXdbV!YZÄc^i^dc!)'* HXVcc^c\ZaZXigdcb^XgdhXden  WdcZhjg[VXZh!(*(·(*)  YZÄc^i^dc!)'* HXVe]d^Y  VcVidbn!''.  h^Y^c\!''. HXVejaV  VcVidbn!&.*!&.-!'%%  \gdli]!'%&  ^YZci^ÄXVi^dcVcYedhh^WaZXdc[jh^dc! '%&·'%'  h^Y^c\!'%' HXjgkn!WdcZÄcY^c\h!('( HZVgX]!dhiZdad\^XVagZbV^ch!HZXdcYVgnXZciZgd[dhh^ÄXVi^dc!YZÄc^" i^dc!)'* HZXdcYVgn^ciZgbZci!YZÄc^i^dc!)'* HZaaVg_d^ci!hZZHVYYaZ"h]VeZY_d^ci H:B!hZZHXVcc^c\ZaZXigdcb^XgdhXden HZg^Va]dbdad\n!YZÄc^i^dc!)'* HZhVbd^YWdcZh  YZÄc^i^dc!)'*  [ddi!'-,  ]VcY!''*!''HZmYZiZgb^cVi^dc  VXXjgVXnVcYegZX^h^dc!(+%·(+'  YZci^i^dc!(-,  dhXdmVZ!(.'!(.)·(.*!(. dkZgk^Zl!(-*·(-+  hVXgjb!(.'!(.)  hZmjVaY^bdge]^hb^ceg^bViZh!(-*! )'*

>cYZm

)+&

 h`jaa!(-+·(-,!(.'  hiVcYVgYh[gdb`cdlchVbeaZh!(+'· (+( HZmjVaY^bdge]^hb!YZÄc^i^dc!)'+ H]dkZa"h]VeZY^cX^hdgh!YZÄc^i^dc!)'+ H^Y^c\  XVaXVcZjh!'.+  XVe^iViZ!'('  XaVk^XaZ!&.*  XjWd^Y!'.,  XjcZ^[dgb!'.-!(%%  Zi]bd^Y!&&'  [Zbjg!'+,  ÄWjaV!'-&  [gdciVa!.&  ]VbViZ!'('·'((  ]jbZgjh!'&)  ]nd^Y!&*+  ^c[Zg^dgcVhVaXdcX]VZ!&&&  aVXg^bVa!&&(  ajcViZ!''.·'(%  bVcY^WaZ!&'+  bVm^aaVZ!&%,  bZiVXVgeVa!'(+!'(-·'(.  bZiViVghVa!(%*·(%+  cVhVah!&&*  cVk^XjaVg!'. dXX^e^iVa!'*'  dhXdmVZ!'*'  eVaVi^cZ!&%.  eVg^ZiVa!.)  eViZaaV!',&  e]VaVc\Zh   [ddi!(%  ]VcY!')%  e^h^[dgb!'(%  gVY^jh!'&+·'&,  g^W!&.'  hVXgjb!')*  hXVe]d^Y!''.  hXVejaV!'%'  he]Zcd^Y!&'&  hiZgcjb!&-*  iVajh!'.(  iZZi]!&)-·&*%!&*'  iZbedgVa!..·&%%  i^W^V!',.·'-%  igVeZo^jb!'(&  igVeZod^Y!'(&  ig^fjZigVa!'(%  jacV!'''!'')  kZgiZWgVZ



>cYZm

  XZgk^XVakZgiZWgVZ!&+.   ajbWVgkZgiZWgVZ!&-%   i]dgVX^XkZgiZWgVZ!&,+  kdbZg!&&%  on\dbVi^X!&&+ H^cjhZh  YZÄc^i^dc!)'+  h`jaa[ZVijgZh!-+ H`jaa  VcVidbn   \gdhhVcVidbn!,*   aZVgc^c\VeegdVX]!-,  VcXZhign^YZci^ÄXVi^dc!)%(  VjY^idgndhh^XaZh!&%%  YZÄc^i^dc!)'+  Zi]bd^Y!&&&·&&'  ;gVc`[jgi=dg^odciVaeZgheZXi^kZh!-+  [gdciVa!-,·-.!.&  \gdli]VcYYZkZadebZci!-)·-+  ]VcYa^c\!,*!,,  ^c[Zg^dgcVhVaXdcX]VZ!&&&  aVXg^bVah!&&'·&&(  bVcY^WaZh!&''·&'+  bVm^aaVZ!&%)!&%+·&%,  cVhVah!&&)·&&*  cdbZcXaVijgZ!,,  cdcbZig^XkVg^Vi^dc!)%,!)&%  dXX^e^iVa!&%%·&%)  eVaVi^cZh!&%,·&%.  eVg^ZiVah!.'·.)  hZmYZiZgb^cVi^dc!(-+·(-,!(.'  he]Zcd^Y!&&,·&'&  iZbedgVah!.*·&%%  kdbZg!&%.·&&%  on\dbVi^Xh!&&*·&&+ Hdgi^c\!\j^YZa^cZh!((. He]Zcd^Y  VcVidbn!&&,·&'&  \gdli]!&'&  edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]ZgWdcZh! &'&  h^Y^c\!&'& He]ZcddXX^e^iVahjijgZ!YZÄc^i^dc!-+! )'+ He]Zgd^YVa_d^ci![ZVijgZh!() HeaVcX]cdXgVc^jb!YZÄc^i^dc!)'+ HfjVbdhVahjijgZ!YZÄc^i^dc!-+!)'+ HiVcYVgYVcVidb^XVaedh^i^dc!YZÄc^i^dc! )'+ HiVcYVgYdeZgVi^c\egdXZYjgZh![dgZch^X dhiZdad\n!,!((( HiVeZh!&%%

HiVijgZZhi^bVi^dc![dgbjaVh!(.-·(.. HiZgcjb  VcVidbn!&-&!&-)  \gdli]!&-)  ^YZci^ÄXVi^dcVcYedhh^WaZXdc[jh^dc! &-)  h^Y^c\!&-* HjWX]dcYgVaWdcZ  YZÄc^i^dc!)'+  [ZVijgZh!)% HjeZgcjbVgniZZi]!YZÄc^i^dc!)'+ HjijgZh!YZÄc^i^dc!-*!)'+0hZZVahd8gV" c^VahjijgZh Hnbe]nh^h!YZÄc^i^dc!(*!)'+ HncYZhbdhZh!YZÄc^i^dc!(*!)'+ Hncdhidh^h!YZÄc^i^dc!(,!)'+ Hncdk^VaÅj^Y![ZVijgZh!(( Hncdk^Va_d^ci  XaVhh^ÄXVi^dc!()  YZÄc^i^dc!)'+  [ZVijgZh!(( Hne]^a^h!h`ZaZiVaÄcY^c\h!('% IVadc!YZÄc^i^dc!)'+ IVajh  VcVidbn!'.'·'.(  h^Y^c\!'.( IVe]dcdbn!hZZVahdEdhibdgiZbbdY^" ÄXVi^dc  YZÄc^i^dc!)'+  9C6!(),·() hXdeZ!).·*% IVghVah  VcVidbn!'.'  XVaXVcZjh!'.)!'.+  XjWd^Y!'.+·'.,  XjcZ^[dgbh   Äghi!'.  hZXdcY!'.  i]^gY!'.-!(%%  \gdli]!(%%  cVk^XjaVg!'.,·'. edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]ZgWdcZh! (%%  iVajh!'.'·'.( IVjgdYdci^hb!YZÄc^i^dc!)'+ IZZi]!hZZ9Zci^i^dc IZbedgVa^hbjhXaZ!YZÄc^i^dc!)'+ IZbedgVah  VcVidbn!.*·. \gdli]!. edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]ZgWdcZh!

.-·..  h^Y^c\!..·&%% IZcYdc![ZVijgZh!((!(,!)% I]dgVX^XkZgiZWgVZ!hZZKZgiZWgVZ I]jbW!hZZBZiVXVgeVah I^W^V  VcVidbn!',&!',.  \gdli]!',.  edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]ZgWdcZh! ',.  h^Y^c\!',.·'-% Iddi]!hZZ9Zci^i^dc IgVchedgi!ÄZaYheZX^bZch!'% IgVchkZghZeaVcZ!YZÄc^i^dc!+, IgVeZo^jb  VcVidbn!'(&  h^Y^c\!'(& IgVeZod^Y  VcVidbn!'(&  h^Y^c\!'(& IgZe]^cVi^dc  VcVanh^h!(&*!(&,  YZÄc^i^dc!)'+ Ig^\dc!YZÄc^i^dc!)'+ Ig^fjZigVa  VcVidbn!'(%  h^Y^c\!'(% IjWZgXjadh^h  bdaZXjaVgYZiZXi^dc^cgZbV^ch!(&%! (& h`ZaZiVaZ[[ZXih!(&Ijbdgh  XaVhh^ÄXVi^dc!('*  h`ZaZiVaÄcY^c\h!('* Inedad\n!YZÄc^i^dc!((!)'+ JacV  VcVidbn!'&.  \gdli]!''%  ^YZci^ÄXVi^dcVcYedhh^WaZXdc[jh^dc! ''%·''&  h^Y^c\!'''!'') KVg^Vi^dc!hZZVahd9^hXgZiZigV^ih  dkZgk^Zl!(&·('  hdjgXZh   \Zd\gVe]^X!('   ^cY^k^YjVakVg^Vi^dc!('   dcid\Zcn!('   hZmjVaY^bdge]^hb!(' KZgiZWgVZ  VcVidbn!&*,!&*.·&+%!&+'

>cYZm

)+(

 XZgk^XVakZgiZWgVZ   ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc    8"&!&+(    8"'!&+(!&+.    8"(·8"+!&+(    8",!&+.   h^Y^c\!&+.   [jcXi^dc!&*.  \gdli]!&+'·&+(  ajbWVgkZgiZWgVZ   ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc!&,+!&,-·&-%   h^Y^c\!&-%  hVXgVakZgiZWgVZ!')&  i]dgVX^XkZgiZWgVZ   ^YZci^ÄXVi^dc!&,%   h^Y^c\!&,+  ineZh!&*,  kZgiZWgVZd[i]ZXdXXnm!')* KdbZg  VcVidbn!&%.·&&%  \gdli]!&&%  edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]ZgWdcZh! &&%  h^Y^c\!&&% Ldgb^VcWdcZ!YZÄc^i^dc!)'+ NVlh!h`ZaZiVaÄcY^c\h!('% On\dbVi^XdbVm^aaVgnhjijgZ!YZÄc^i^dc! -* On\dbVi^Xh  VcVidbn!&&*·&&+  \gdli]!&&+  edhh^WaZXdc[jh^dcl^i]di]ZgWdcZh! &&+  h^Y^c\!&&+



>cYZm