Science Networks . Historical Studies Founded by Erwin Hiebert and Hans Wußing Volume 39 Edited by Eberhard Knobloch, Helge Kragh and Erhard Scholz
Editorial Board: K. Andersen, Aarhus D. Buchwald, Pasadena H.J.M. Bos, Utrecht U. Bottazzini, Roma J.Z. Buchwald, Cambridge, Mass. K. Chemla, Paris S.S. Demidov, Moskva E.A. Fellmann, Basel M. Folkerts, München P. Galison, Cambridge, Mass. I. Grattan-Guinness, London J. Gray, Milton Keynes
R. Halleux, Liège S. Hildebrandt, Bonn Ch. Meinel, Regensburg J. Peiffer, Paris W. Purkert, Bonn D. Rowe, Mainz A.I. Sabra, Cambridge, Mass. Ch. Sasaki, Tokyo R.H. Stuewer, Minneapolis H. Wußing, Leipzig V.P. Vizgin, Moskva
Robert D. Purrington
The First Professional Scientist Robert Hooke and the Royal Society of London
Birkhäuser Basel · Boston · Berlin
Author: Robert D. Purrington Tulane University Dept. Physics New Orleans, LA 70118 USA e-mail:
[email protected]
Library of Congress Control Number: 2009920472 Bibliographic information published by Die Deutsche Bibliothek Die Deutsche Bibliothek lists this publication in the Deutsche Nationalbibliografie; detailed bibliographic data is available in the Internet at http://dnb.ddb.de
ISBN 978-3-0346-0036-1 Birkhäuser Verlag AG, Basel - Boston - Berlin This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, re-use of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilms or in other ways, and storage in data banks. For any kind of use permission of the copyright owner must be obtained. © 2009 Birkhäuser Verlag AG Basel · Boston · Berlin P.O. Box 133, CH-4010 Basel, Switzerland Part of Springer Science+Business Media Printed on acid-free paper produced from chlorine-free pulp. TCF ∞ Cover illustration: Plate from Hooke’s published Cutler Lecture “Animadversions on the First Part of the Machina Coelestis ...” showing an equatorial quadrant driven by a conical or circular pendulum. See also p. 210. Printed in Germany ISBN 978-3-0346-0036-1
e-ISBN 978-3-0346-0037-8
987654321
www.birkhauser.ch
To Loraine
“This page left intentionally blank.”
Contents Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
xi
Preface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xiii Annotations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xviii 1
Restoring Robert Hooke . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Hooke and London . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Annotations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2
Robert Hooke, Indefaticable Genius: Hooke and London The Diary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Hooke and Wren . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Annotations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
13 18 22 24 25
3
Promoting Physico-Mathematical-Experimental Learning: Founding the Royal Society of London . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Annotations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
33 39
4
Society of the Muses: The First Decade . . Focused Energies: The Laws of Motion . . . Concluding the First Decade . . . . . . . . . Annotations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
45 53 56 58
5
Crisis and Consolidation: 1672–1687 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Annotations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
65 69
6
The Society After the Principia: 1688–1703 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Annotations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
73 77
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
1 4 8
Contents
viii
7
Scientific Virtuoso: Hooke 1655–1687 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . First Discoveries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Hooke and the Royal Society, 1662–1677 . . . . . Hooke and Oldenburg, 1675–1677 . . . . . . . . . Hooke and the Society after Oldenburg; 1677–1687 “Restless Genius: ” Hooke as Scientist . . . . . . . The Hooke Folio, 2006 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusion: Micrographia . . . . . . . . . . . . . Annotations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
81 84 91 98 101 114 115 118
And All Was Light: Hooke and Newton on Light and Color . . . . . .
135
Hooke’s Theory of Light Newton’s Theory . . . . Debate after 1672 . . . . Annotations . . . . . . .
. . . .
137 139 140 144
The Nature of Things Themselves: Robert Hooke, Natural Philosopher . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
149
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . Hooke’s Natural Philosophy . . Light; Matter, and Motion . . . . Natural Philosophy and Newton Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . Annotations . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
149 150 153 157 159 160
10 The System of the World: Hooke and Universal Gravitation, the Inverse-square Law, and Planetary Orbits . . . . . . . . . . . . .
165
8
9
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
Introduction: Hooke and Planetary Dynamics . . . . . . . Halley and Newton . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Huygens . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Hooke and Universal Gravitation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Hooke and Newton, 1679 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Hooke’s “Laws of Circular Motion” . . . . . . . . . . . . Newton, Gravitation, and the Kepler Problem, 1665–1987 . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Annotations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
81
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
165 171 173 174 177 182 187 189 190
Contents
ix
11 The Omnipotence of the Creator: Robert Hooke, Astronomer Telescopes and Optics . Hooke As An Observer Comets . . . . . . . . Stellar Parallax . . . . Conclusion . . . . . . Annotations . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
205 207 214 216 220 220
12 The Last Remain: Hooke After the Principia, 1687–1703 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Hooke and Newton . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1687–1703 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Annotations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
227 227 229 231 237
Epilogue . . . Introduction Legacy . . . Conclusion Annotations
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
241 241 243 247 248
Bibliography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
251
Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
265
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . .
203
. . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
“This page left intentionally blank.”
Acknowledgments This book had its genesis in a Newton symposium which I hosted with the late Frank Eddington Durham at the tercentenary of the Principia in 1987 as well as in a quartercentury of discussions with Professor Durham on the history of physics in general and the seventeenth century in particular. His insights have been invaluable and it is to him that I owe my greatest debt. I would especially like to thank the very able and helpful staff of the library of the Royal Society, and in particular the librarians, Karen Peters and Keith Moore. Ms. Peters was librarian when I began this project and Mr. Moore helped me finish it. I particularly thank him for providing me with a digital copy of the 2006 Hooke folio before it was made generally available. I also thank the Guildhall Library of the City of London, the British Museum Library, the Science Library, and the Imperial College library, for their expert assistance and cooperation. I would further like to thank Tulane University for a sabbatical leave in the spring of 1999 which allowed me to search the archives of the Royal Society and the Guildhall Library, thus to encounter some of the primary sources for this work for the first time. Other visits to resources in the UK over the last decade and a half – most particularly the entire 1992–3 academic year – were also supported in whole or in part by the university. In addition, thanks are due the staff of the Howard-Tilton Library at Tulane for their patience, professionalism, and dedication in building a valuable collection of secondary works on seventeenth century science. I owe a special debt to Eleanor Elder. I would also like to thank my editor at Birkh¨auser, Karin Neidhart, for her help in bringing this project to completion. A further debt is owed to several historians and scientists with whom I have had fruitful conversations, some brief, some lengthy. In particular, I acknowledge discussions with Michael Nauenberg, Lisa Jardine, Michael Cooper, Mordechai Feingold, Ellen Tan Drake, and Hentie Louw which have provided important insights.
“This page left intentionally blank.”
Preface Notwithstanding some skepticism on the subject, few would disagree with the assertion that if there was ever a transformation in science which deserved the name revolution, that which occurred in seventeenth-century science was it. More so even than the one that took place in the first three decades of the twentieth century, or that wrought by Darwin. It may not have looked like a revolution to those participating in it, but that kind of perspective requires historical distance. In any event, the last two decades have seen Robert Hooke rise from almost total obscurity to the point that he is nearly fashionable, something that would have been unimaginable not so very long ago. Much of this has resulted from tercentenary enthusiasm attending the anniversary of his death, which was celebrated in 2003,1) though it had its beginnings early in the last century, notably at the 300th anniversary of his birth in 1635, an example of how the ebb and flow of reputations has too often turned on such insubstantial accidents of chronology. On the other hand, and a bit ironically, some of this new appreciation of Hooke’s place in seventeenth-century science came out of a recognition that the hero-worship with which Newton was treated during much of the twentieth century was distinctly uncritical. The best example, perhaps, is a conference held at the Royal Society in the summer of 1988, only a year after the monumental celebration of the 300th anniversary of the Principia.2) Hooke’s first biographer, Margaret ‘Espinasse, published her account of his life and work in 1956, more than three centuries after his birth. This remained the only life of Hooke for over 40 years, but two ambitious and detailed biographies, by Stephen Inwood and Lisa Jardine, appeared in 2003–4,3) and several other studies were published in the same period, including an excellent scientific biography by Alan Chapman and a detailed study of Hooke’s role in the rebuilding of London after the fire by Michael Cooper.4) The result is that the public is slowly learning something about the man, and even something of his science. The evidence of Hooke’s role in the Royal Society has always been present in its archives, but these were available only to scholars and little use was made of them. Hooke’s importance was made abundantly clear in Thomas Birch’s distillation of the journals of the Society for 1660–1687, published as the History of the Royal Society of London in 1756,5) but by the late nineteenth and early twentieth century Birch was also hard to find. Birch’s work, which was a transcription of the first quarter-century or so of the journals of the Society, and which therefore displays Hooke’s contri-
xiv
Preface
butions on virtually every page, was published only 28 years after Newton’s death, but Hooke had been dead over a half-century and had already been largely forgotten. Forgotten or not, Birch revealed Hooke’s central role in those formative years of what was for all practical purposes the world’s first scientific society. By the twentieth century, with Birch residing in rare book rooms, the process of reviving Hooke’s reputation was a painfully slow one, stimulated by the recovery of his fascinating Diary and its publication in 1935, the advocacy of a few Hooke partisans, and, after the war, the ‘Espinasse biography and the reprinting of Birch in 1968. Its wider availability has made Hooke’s critical role in the Society much more accessible and evident, even though the work summarizes Society meetings only through 1687, more than fifteen years before his death. As we proceed, we will generally assume that when Birch quotes from the Journal Book of the Society, he does so accurately. While this is not absolutely true, it is very nearly so; omissions and errors are infrequent and not generally significant. In many or most cases I have checked Birch against the original. Of course the Secretary may not have accurately represented all discussions which took place, but we have no way of knowing.6) The impending tercentenary of Hooke’s birth (1935) not only saw publication of the best known part of his Diary, but his championing by Robert Gunther, who devoted four volumes of his Early Science in Oxford to “that Oxonian, Robert Hooke”. By the time Gunther published his Volume X, which contained Hooke’s less famous later Diary, describing his activities between 1688 and 1693, Europe was on the verge of war. Gunther also reprinted all of Hooke’s published Cutler Lectures in facsimile, again making them generally available for the first time. As England recovered after the war, interest in Hooke was revived by E.N. Da C. Andrade’s Wilkins Lecture to the Royal Society in 1948 (see Chapter 1) which revealed to a wider scientific audience Hooke’s role in the founding of early modern science. ‘Espinasse’s account of his life and work was published in the next decade, and when Birch’s History was reprinted, finally making it widely available, it exhibited once and for all Hooke’s essential role in the early history of the Society and his important place in the early scientific revolution. Yet little was written about him in the following three decades until Ellen Tan Drake wrote extensively of his role in founding the science of geology, in 1996. The last 30 years have largely been devoted to the absorption of this material. This has gradually led to a new understanding of Hooke’s role in the formative first four decades of the Royal Society, and of Hooke the human being. As other resources have become available, including Turnbull’s Newton correspondence (1959) and the discovery of some of Hooke’s dynamical manuscripts and their decipherment, his importance as a dynamicist and the influence he had on Newton and the Principia have had to be reevaluated. Finally, work by architectural historians and students of the rebuilding of the City of London after the fire, especially by Michael Cooper, and fleshed out by innumerable Diary entries, have made clear Hooke’s place as one of Restoration London’s most important architects, and a major force in rebuilding the City.
Preface
xv
But for most of the twentieth century Hooke has been ignored – indeed, it could be said that Hooke’s eclipse has been his identity (to paraphrase Adam Gopnik). At best he has been represented only by a cartoon image which emphasized his supposed quarrelsome nature and outsized claims. The same might be said of the two centuries that followed 1703, as his death, the passing of his friends and colleagues, especially Boyle (1691) and Wren (1723), Newton’s ascendency in the Royal Society (he was its president from Hooke’s death until 1727), and most importantly, the triumph of Newton’s method, led to a swift decline in Hooke’s reputation, and eventually to his being forgotten altogether. Little remained other than his masterpiece, Micrographia, and the law of elasticity, “Hooke’s Law,” which is all that most physicists, who should know him best, know of him.7) Two major forces shaped Hooke’s professional life. One, the Great Fire of London, in 1666, pushed him into a career of surveying, construction, and architecture that spanned a quarter-century, gained him prestige, partnership with Wren, and as it turned out, wealth. The other, the founding of the Royal Society in 1660, his employment as its Curator three years later, and the 40 years of service he gave to what was the central commitment of his life, is the principal focus of this book. For Hooke’s early role in the Society, there was no model, no precedent. He was, effectively, the first of a breed, the professional scientist,8) paid for his services as an experimental scientist or philosopher. As will become evident, the Royal Society of London, perhaps still the world’s most prestigious scientific institution, would very likely have foundered without Hooke’s contributions to it over four decades. Initially it would be the experiments he was charged to bring in at every weekly meeting that provided the Society’s raison d’etre, and later, his lectures on pneumatics, microscopy, gravitation, comets, and, more broadly, natural philosophy, which gave the Society some intellectual coherence, especially as Boyle’s health declined and Wren’s attention was diverted elsewhere. The story of the Society’s founding and its early struggles to survive as essentially the world’s first scientific institution is told in many places, but what has not been described in detail, at least until very recently, is Hooke’s critical role in the Society’s formative early years and, in turn, its role in his rich and complex life. Hooke, almost by default, became one of the most important figures in the process of institutionalization of science, which began with the founding of the Society in 1660. The same can be said of Henry Oldenburg, the Society’s long-time secretary, who while not personally involved in the discoveries of Society members and the discourses which characterized its meetings, patiently tended to the Society’s correspondence, and almost personally made it an international society, with foreign members and correspondents who included Huygens, Leibniz, Spinoza, Hevelius, Cassini, and others. This work for the Society is enshrined in the thirteen volumes of Oldenburg’s correspondence, almost all on scientific matters, compiled by Rupert and Marie Boas Hall. As the Halls put it, «To foreigners it was Henry Oldenburg who represented the Royal Society . . . »9) There is a certain irony in the fact that the two men who more than anyone else kept the Royal Society alive in its first two decades, Hooke and Oldenburg, ended up as bitter enemies.10)
xvi
Preface
Hooke had a dual role in the early years of the Society, initially as a young employee with great promise but no status, and soon in a role which gradually grew so that by his early 30s he had become the most important source of insights into the many problems in natural philosophy which came before the Society. Much of what we know of Hooke comes from his rich and fascinating Diary which he kept, off and on, from his 30s into his mid-50s. The first and most important part of the Diary was lost for two centuries, which means that our understanding of who Hooke was is relatively recent, helping to explain why he faded so completely from view during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, when essentially nothing was written about him. The diaries are among the most valuable resources available to scholars trying to understand Restoration natural philosophy and the role of the Royal Society in English science, and as we try to flesh out a picture of Hooke from his own words, these sketchy and telegraphic memoranda – fascinating, provocative, maddingly incomplete – are our raw material. They make it possible for us to trace his daily activities and give us some insight into his inner life. They also tell us much about his relationship to the Royal Society, supplementing what we learn from its journals, but these brief and hasty jottings raise as many questions as they answer. Yet in their daily entries and private purpose, the diaries reveal Hooke the human being in his most unguarded moments.11) To supplement the Diary and to provide much-needed context, it is especially crucial in Hooke’s case, with his complex and rich human interactions and his dealings with people of all stations, to consult the lives of his colleagues and contemporaries Wren, Boyle, Halley, Wilkins, Oldenburg, and others, in England and on the continent, and to read their correspondence, where available.12) And to get a feel for the period and the London in which Hooke lived, a city in which the plague still raged, and which burned in the Great Fire of 1666, one can do no better than the admittedly Proustian task of reading through the diary of his friend Samuel Pepys.13) The quintet of contemporaries, Boyle, Wren, Newton, Halley, and Hooke, epitomize much of Restoration science. Hooke was important in the lives of each of the others, and a close friend of all but Newton. Unlike Newton, whose massive correspondence has been edited by Turnbull and others14) (and which includes important exchanges with Hooke), Hooke, as a creature of London, had little need for epistolary relationships, with the result that his correspondence is meager and uncollected. But because he attended virtually every Royal Society meeting for nearly 40 years, the archives of the Society tell us an enormous amount about his scientific career. Nonetheless, and despite recent interest in Hooke, very little has been added to the record of his life and work since shortly after his death, the main exceptions being the recovery of the early Diary in 1891, the patient combing of the archives of the City of London by Michael Cooper, the recent realization of the importance of some of Hooke’s dynamical manuscripts, and an unexpected discovery in 2006 of a cache of his notes and letters which created a firestorm of publicity and the sale of the documents for close to $1M.15) This major and thoroughly unexpected discovery keeps alive the hope that unknown papers may yet be found. In what follows, we will
Preface
xvii
make use of the so-called “Hooke Folio” to shed light on some lacunae in the Society archives and the resultant controversies which have lain unresolved for 300 years. An unexpected consequence of this interest in Hooke’s science is that his important contribution to the architecture of the City of London is finally and belatedly being recognized as well. These two sides of Hooke’s creativity, his natural philosophy and his architecture, are, of course, of a piece, and yet we can never know precisely how he saw his own career and how these activities, those of scientist and Curator of the Royal Society, and those of the surveyor, architect, creator of codes and practices, etc., contributed to his personal identity. Finally, a note on calendrical matters. The Gregorian Reform took place in England only in 1752, so that all dates will be given in the Julian or Old Style. However, the reader will not have to be reminded that the Catholic countries, France, Italy, and Spain, had been using the Gregorian calendar since 1582. In the seventeenth century, the difference between the two calendars was 10 days, so that 8 August 1671 O.S. would be 18 August 1671 N.S. As another example, Hooke noted in his Diary for 10 December 1688, «Shortest Day.», whereas in France the winter solstice was celebrated on 20 December. With the turn of the century, the difference grew to 11 days (after 29 February 1699/1700 O.S.). Where confusion might result, we will offer the reader some guidance. With apology, we will use the somewhat cumbersome 1672/3 for dates in 1673 between January 1 and March 25, since one will encounter that usage almost everywhere in documents from the time, e.g., Hooke’s Diaries, Birch’s History of the Royal Society of London, etc. The new year began on 25 March, essentially the vernal equinox. Occasionally we will be unable to resist the modest anachronism of speaking of, say, Christmas 1687, as being at «the end of 1687,» and for that inconsistency, we offer in advance an apology. We note that Hooke died on 3 March 1702/3, so that it would not be incorrect to say either that he died in 1702 or 1703. Nonetheless, 3 March 2003 was the 300th anniversary of Hooke’s death. When all is said and done, it is not the job of the historian to take sides, but rather to describe and interpret what transpired, to the best of one’s ability. In Hooke’s case it is sometimes difficult to maintain this level of objectivity, for reasons alluded to above and which will become obvious. But in the end, the reader will have to come to his own opinion about the very complex character and life of Robert Hooke.
xviii
Preface
Annotations 1) Conferences were held at the Royal Society and in Oxford in the tercentennial year of 2003. The volumes which emerged from those gatherings, Cooper and Hunter (2005) and Kent and Chapman (2005), contain many interesting and detailed papers on aspects of Hooke’s life and his science. Some of these will be referenced in the text. 2) The 1987 celebrations also provided the genesis of the author’s interest in Hooke. See Durham and Purrington, 1989. 3) Inwood (2003), Jardine (2004). There is much interesting detail in these studies which is outside the scope of the present work. 4) Cooper, 2003. 5) Birch painstakingly recounts the activities at every meeting of the Society and of its Council, often giving the full text of a paper delivered by a member. 6) The draft minutes from Oldenburg’s tenure do exist and now (2006) we have Hooke’s raw minutes which have been recovered after over 300 years. 7) To the question of why Hooke descended into obscurity in the century after his death, various answers have been given, and we address some of these below. One, clearly, is the triumph of Newton’s method, as Hooke’s Baconian principles were passing out of favor. The eighteenth century saw the widespread application of Newton’s techniques, manifested most clearly in the mathematical physics of Euler, Laplace, Lagrange, and others. Newton’s ire may or may not have been another factor. The nineteenth century saw the formulation of thermodynamics and electromagnetism, fields of which the seventeenth century was only dimly aware, and in which Hooke could play only the smallest role. One could say that Hooke’s influence was felt primarily on Newton, and in what we might think of as peripheral scientific fields, geology and biology. 8) Hooke was, indeed, in a very real sense the first professional scientist. In assenting to this title, however, Michael Cooper has predicted some will object to “professional,” some to “scientist,” some to “first,” and perhaps even to “the.” 9) CHO, Volume X, p. xxvii. 10) There is an important new biography of Oldenburg by Marie Boas Hall: M.B. Hall (2002). 11) Here we refer to the first of Hooke’s diaries, or at least the earliest extant part. We examine the diaries in Chapter 2, but suffice it to say at this point that the first Diary begins on March 10, 1672, with no fanfare at all – mainly recounting meteorological observations for the first 10 months – and comes to an inauspicious ending, largely through neglect, in May 1683, being continuous only up to about the end of 1680 – which is what Adams and Robinson published. Whether the diaries are parts of a more or less continuous whole, or whether we have all of what Hooke wrote, we will likely never know.
Annotations
xix
12) The Boyle correspondence has been recently published by Michael Hunter, et al. (Hunter, Clericuzio and Principe, 2001). Previously one had to resort to Birch’s collection in The Life and Works of the Honorable Robert Boyle, 6 vols., London, 1772. Even more relevant to this narrative is the massive correspondence of the Society’s long-time secretary, Henry Oldenburg, The Correspondence of Henry Oldenburg, in 13 volumes, edited by Rupert and Marie Boas Hall (1965–86). There are new biographies of Wren (Lisa Jardine) and Halley (Allan Cook); see the bibliography. 13) Though the literature on Restoration and Augustan England is vast. 14) Turnbull, et al. (1959) 15) Michael Cooper’s patient scouring of the records of the City of London and its many parishes, showing precisely Hooke’s role in rebuilding the City after the fire, is especially notable. Some of the work will be cited below, but see Cooper on Hooke’s surveying work for the City of London (Cooper, 1997, 1998a, 1998b, 2000, 2003). Hooke’s crucial dynamical paper is discussed in Chapter 10. The recently discovered Hooke manuscripts were obtained for the Royal Society at a cost of $940,000, about half of which was provided by the Wellcome Trust. The implications of this collection for our understanding of Hooke and his work will be discussed in due course.
Chapter 1
Restoring Robert Hooke In 1947, in the wake of World War II, the Royal Society of London established the Wilkins Lectures in the history of science in honor of John Wilkins, one of its founding members and its first secretary. Wilkins himself was the subject of the first lecture, in 1948, but when Edward Neville da Costa Andrade delivered the second Wilkins Lecture the next year (on 15 December), his subject was Robert Hooke. At this point few knew anything of Hooke, except for his Micrographia, published at the start of his career and of his service to the Society. Thus it might be said that it was Andrade’s lecture which caused Hooke to be taken seriously again after nearly three centuries. Hooke’s Diary had been published a little over a decade earlier, creating some curiosity about him which went largely dormant during the war. This nascent resurgence of interest in Hooke, after two hundred years in which virtually nothing was written about him, had begun as the 300th anniversary of his birth approached, and was highlighted by publication of the Diary in the tercentenary year, 1935. The reprinting of much of Hooke’s work by Gunther in his Early Science in Oxford between 1930 and 1938,1) including the later Diary and the Cutler Lectures, did much to stimulate interest in Hooke, and in the same period the ascerbic Andrade was already drawing attention to Hooke. Interestingly, the two of them, Andrade and Gunther, while alike in advocating Hooke, were personal antagonists. Margaret ‘Espinasse’s post-war biography (1956), suggested to her by Jacob Bronowski, and the first real life of Hooke, also helped turn the tide.2) Although there was not another biography until almost the turn of the century, Marjorie Hope Nicholson’s 1965 study of Pepys’ role in the early Royal Society, which highlighted Hooke’s crucial role, was also influential. Robert Hooke was born at Freshwater on the Isle of Wight, where his father was curate of All Saints Church, on July 18, 1635.3) A sickly child who survived childhood illnesses and whose health would never be entirely robust as an adult,4) Hooke was apparently schooled at home for a time, probably destined for the ministry, but his poor health and probably his physical limitations seem to have caused his father to abandon his schooling and to leave him to his own devices. According to Hooke himself, he was intrigued by things mechanical – as was the young Newton,
2
Chapter 1. Restoring Robert Hooke
of course – busying himself with models, dismantling clocks, and so on. He also explored the cliffs and bays around Freshwater, collecting marine fossils and noting their presence in rocks well above the sea. His father’s subsequent plan to apprentice him to some trade, perhaps watch-making, was foreclosed by his death when Hooke was 13, leaving the young Robert, again like Newton, fatherless5) . Having shown promise in illustration, Hooke was soon sent to London to apprentice to the noted portrait painter Sir Peter Lely.6) In this respect, he was no different from a great many aspiring young men from rural and provincial England who flocked to London in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries to apprentice to a trade.7) An aversion to oil paints8) supposedly forced Hooke to abandon his putative career as a painter, with the happy result that he was sent to Westminster School, probably at about age 15, where he caught the attention of the Headmaster, Dr. Richard Busby, who took him under his wing.9) Hooke would maintain a life-long friendship with this famous educator, with whom he lodged, eventually designing a church for him nearly 30 years later. Hooke had two or three great mentors in his life: Busby, who kindled, or at least sustained, the intellectual fires that drove his genius, John Wilkins, who did the same at Oxford, and Robert Boyle, who served as his first model of a natural philosopher and provided the 20 year old Hooke a laboratory in Oxford in which to work. All became lifelong friends. At Westminster Hooke received the usual classical education (which is evident throughout his mature writing), learned Euclid, and indulged his interests in things mechanical.10) He also discovered, or at least developed, his musical interests there, learning to play the organ. These talents served him well, for at age 18 (1653) he was sent up to Oxford’s Christ Church College as a chorister and servitor.11) His friend Richard Waller saw it this way, «as ’tis often the Fate of Persons great in Learning to be small in other Circumstances, his were but mean.» Oxford was in Puritan hands in 1653 when Hooke would have arrived there. But with the moderate John Wilkins as Master of Wadham College (a post he had held since 1648), a number of the members of the London “1645 group” (see Chapter 4), many of whom had royalist leanings, had migrated (or fled) to Oxford and Wadham to be near him. Wilkins’ galaxy included such important figures as John Wallis, Seth Ward, Laurence Rooke, Thomas Willis, William Petty, and even the young prodigy Christopher Wren, only three years Hooke’s senior, who had come to Oxford in 1649 and received his M.A. in the year Hooke arrived. All of these men would become important figures in Restoration science and in the Royal Society, and most would play an important role in Hooke’s life. If Hooke went up to Oxford in about 1653, he would have ordinarily taken his B.A. in about 1656–7, though there is no evidence that he did, or even that he matriculated. We do know that he had the M.A. degree conferred on him in 1662– 1663,12) his first full year of employment by the Royal Society.13) At what point he came to the notice of Wilkins is not entirely clear, though according to Hooke, he was first «brought into the acquaintance of these great Men» (referring to members of the Oxford club; see Chapter 4) in «about the year 1655,» that is, at age 20.14) The precocious Hooke, who shared Wilkins’ interest in the possibility of human flight,15) probably met him through the vehicle of the Oxford club, and through him came
Chapter 1. Restoring Robert Hooke
3
into contact with other members of the group. Wilkins apparently commended him to Willis, a noted anatomist, through whom he probably met Seth Ward, and in 1654 or 1655 he became Willis’ chemical assistant. According to Hooke himself, Ward, Savilian Professor of Astronomy, friend of Wren’s, and eventually Bishop of Salisbury, introduced him to the pleasures of astronomy in 1655. Astronomy was from that point on an interest that Hooke never lost, one which would often provide motivation and opportunity for application of his mechanical ingenuity and would keep his mind on the problem of planetary motion.16) Indeed, after Horrocks and before Flamsteed and Halley, and despite the fitful character of his studies, Hooke was probably England’s most important astronomer. With neither money nor position, Hooke might well have foundered but for the exposure the Oxford group afforded him. At best he would have ended up as a country parson like his father and brothers. But in Oxford, and in particular through the Oxford society, the bright undergraduate could display his ingenuity and inventiveness and meet scholars and other virtuosi who would soon form the nucleus of the Royal Society. Wilkins, Willis, and Ward, and in the end, especially Boyle, provided models for the budding natural philosopher. The dazzling Wren was another, but he would become far more than that as the two struck up a friendship which eventually blossomed into an architectural partnership. They were friends and colleagues for nearly a half-century, working virtually side-by-side in the process of rebuilding London after the fire, and constantly arguing scientific issues over coffee or in Wren’s home. It was Wilkins who invited Boyle, the 28 year old aristocrat17) , to join him in Oxford, and who likely introduced Hooke to him. Not long after Boyle arrived in Oxford, say by 1658, he took Hooke as his assistant, an apprenticeship which led to his employment as Curator of Experiments for the recently formed Royal Society. Both Wilkins and Boyle would remain Hooke’s faithful friends until their deaths, which for Wilkins was in 1672, at age 58, but for Boyle would be two decades later. The internship with Boyle, which lasted until Hooke went to work for the Royal Society in late 1662, was the crucial event in shaping Hooke the natural philosopher. When Hooke left Boyle and Oxford for London, he was an experienced 27 year old who had already met a number of England’s scientific luminaries, including Wren, who was building a reputation for brilliance. The young Hooke stood on the threshold of a long and productive scientific career. So it was that he became a professional scientist, arguably the very first of a new breed, occupying a position which would provide him with the opportunity, and, alas, the obligation, to carry out hundreds of experiments over a period of more than 30 years.18) The position also provided him a forum for discussion of his many ideas, while he quickly matured into an independent natural philosopher. His importance to the Society slowly grew as his weekly experiments came to provide it with much of its raison d’etre. During at least the Society’s first two decades (and especially throughout the 1660s and in the years following Henry Oldenburg’s death in 1677), there would almost literally have been no Royal Society without Hooke. In his apprenticeship with Boyle, Hooke not only was schooled in the practice of experimental natural philosophy, but he also absorbed his mentor’s ideas on the
4
Chapter 1. Restoring Robert Hooke
nature of mechanical and corpuscular philosophy, of which Boyle was to become one of the most ardent exponents. And by about 1658 Hooke had, in his words, «contriv’d and perfected the Air-pump for Mr. Boyle . . . ,»19) something Boyle confirms.20) The experiments which elucidated “Boyle’s Law” most likely were carried out largely by Hooke, but he in turn acknowledged the earlier work of Richard Townely, who with Henry Power deserves much of the credit for discovery of this relationship between volume and pressure.21) That the mechanically inclined Hooke grew into a natural and experimental philosopher while under the tutelage of Boyle is evident, but Boyle was as much a polemicist for experimental philosophy as an experimental scientist, per se, so that we can assume that Hooke’s role in these pneumatic experiments was crucial. That said, the impact of Boyle’s New Experiments Physico-Mechanical Touching the Springiness of the Air of 1660 can hardly be exaggerated. The details of Hooke’s relationship with the “gentleman scientist” Boyle, the discoveries which resulted, and Boyle’s sponsorship of Hooke to the Royal Society, will be left to other chroniclers,22) but as it happened, Hooke was named to the post of Curator of experiments for the Royal Society on November 12, 1662, 23) with the «thanks of the society [to Boyle] for dispensing with him for their use», and he provided the first experiments one week later. Hooke’s style, while very much his own, owed a lot to Boyle, a heritage which would cut both ways, providing both a model and, one might say, a straight-jacket. Thus began Robert Hooke’s long association with the Royal Society, with which we will deal at length. For the moment, however, and in the next chapter as well, we will flesh out the picture of Hooke as a human being, and in particular, as a Londoner whose life and work was entirely shaped by that city, with its opportunity and optimism, its intellectual and social ferment, yet at the same time, its poverty, pollution, and disease.
Hooke and London No portrait is known to exist of Hooke,24) so that we have to rely on written accounts of his appearance. By all testimony he was stooped, perhaps a victim of scoliosis, had piercing eyes, thin, unruly brown hair (but sometimes wore a periwig), and rushed about with enormous energy. The churches he worked on with Wren, the buildings he built, the surveying he did after the fire, the coffee-houses and taverns he frequented – all these rarely took him more than 15 blocks or so from his lodgings in Gresham College, in the northeast corner of the City, where Society meetings were held for long periods of time as well.25) Sometimes his duties or his friendship with Dr. Richard Busby sent him to Westminster and frequently he walked in St. James’s Park (a mile and a half from St. Paul’s) with Wren, who had his office nearby, or others, occasionally encountering the King (Charles II), who knew him well. We can imagine that for his time, at least, Hooke was fairly fit, despite the continual health problems enumerated in his Diary. Never owning a carriage, he walked several miles every day in carrying out his many duties. On occasion he recorded walking to Islington, just outside London Wall, or to Highgate. On rare occasions he went somewhere on the
Hooke and London
Fig. 1
5
Gresham College in Bishopsgate. By permission of the Guildhall Library, Corporation of the City of London.
Thames by boat, Greenwich, for example, where he helped design and build the observatory. Even less frequently he would venture into the country, as he did during the height of the plague in 1665, and when he visited Oxford in June 1680. Like Newton, he never traveled abroad. Hooke’s business transactions as commissioner, surveyor, and architect took place almost entirely within greater London, and usually within the City itself. Indeed, virtually his entire adult life was led in that area of a few square miles that he walked daily, regularly calling at Wren’s or at Boyle’s sister’s, or stopping at a coffeehouse or a work site. His milieu was London, where he spent the last forty years of his life and from whose environs he rarely strayed. During much of that long period in London he not only was a versatile and inventive scientist and a pivotal figure in the Royal Society, but was also a city planner, architect, engineer, surveyor for the City following the fire of 1666, assistant, colleague, and partner to Wren in rebuilding the churches of London, and, on his own, or with Wren, architect of many of them. For those 40 years he lived within walking distance of the Guildhall in the City, residing for most of that time in rooms in Gresham College (Fig. 1) in Bishopsgate, where he was Professor of Geometry, frequenting the coffee-houses around Cornhill and
6
Chapter 1. Restoring Robert Hooke
Fig. 2: Bedlam or Bethlem Hospital, designed by Hooke, 1674–6.
the Royal Exchange (Fig. 3) visiting tradesmen, instrument makers, and booksellers, throwing himself into the life of the City with boundless energy. It is impossible to imagine Hooke in any other setting than London, the largest city in the world when he lived there, its skies often dark with smoke, its streets reeking of both poverty and wealth, a product of the huge gap between the privileged and those at the bottom of the social and economic ladder. Yet as the 300th anniversary of his death in 1703 approached, there existed not a single tribute to that “restless genius” anywhere in London.26) Even “The Monument”, which he, with Wren’s help, erected on Fish Street Hill to mark the start of the Great Fire, bears no trace of his name. Although Hooke was an extraordinarily inventive scientist and a standard-bearer in the scientific revolution, his second career, which began with the Great Fire of London in 1666, was hardly less important to him. Initially he was a Royal Surveyor, charged with the problems of demolition and rebuilding of the residential and commercial structures of the City of London after the fire. He soon became responsible for overseeing compliance with codes and practices, began working with Wren on the parish churches of the City, and eventually became, for all practical purposes, his architectural partner. Furthermore, he undertook his own major architectural projects, including the massive College of Physicians and Bedlam (or Bethlem) Hospital.27) (Fig. 2) These projects, now, of course, long gone, were his largest. He built the
Hooke and London
7
Royal College of Physicians between 1672 and 1678, and Bedlam in 1674–76.28) With Wren (presumably) he designed and built the Monument during 1672–77, and his work on the churches of the northeast part of the City took place mostly between 1670 and 1685.29) The partnership with Wren in building Greenwich Observatory also dates from the late 1670s. Walking around London today one would find no obvious evidence that Hooke had ever lived. The secular buildings which have always been known to have been his are long gone, and Gresham College in the City, where Hooke had his rooms, was pulled down in 1767.30) Yet there is indeed much that remains in the City of London that shows the touch of his hand, though it remains mostly unacknowledged. Architectural scholarship has shown that Hooke played a role that was barely second to Wren’s in rebuilding the 51 parish churches of the City after the fire, and that about half of them can be considered largely Hooke’s – primarily those in the northeast corner of the City near where he lived.31) Only about a dozen of these “Hooke” churches remain and all have been modified over time to a greater or lesser degree, four having been again rebuilt after being gutted during the Blitz of World War II. But they all serve as a testament to Hooke’s energy, versatility, and talent as an architect. And if one visits these churches, for example, St. Peter Cornhill, St. Edmund the King, and St. Mary Abchuch, it is not hard to see the Hooke style in them. On the whole the architecture is derivative, but then the same can be said of Wren, though he possessed an architectural genius that Hooke did not. But Hooke was well-schooled in the classic works of architecture, from Vitrivius to Palladio, and one sees evidence of that in his architecture. Of course some of the attributions to Hooke are still in dispute and it is hard to know how much of a role Wren may have played in any one of these churches. It is not unlikely that he ultimately had to “sign off” on many or most of them, but his role may have been pro forma. One of Hooke’s strengths was that he was better equipped than most of his contemporaries to solve the practical problems of design and construction. In the case of the Monument (Fig. 3), it is, as we said, difficult to assess with certainty the relative roles of Hooke and Wren, but Hooke was on site almost daily at the peak of construction, and only rarely is there evidence that Wren also there. It would not be unreasonable to consider it largely a Hooke structure. The recent revelation that the Monument was designed so that it could be used as a zenith telescope adds fascinating detail to its design and construction,32) though it has long been known that Hooke used what he called the “piller” to carry out experiments on the variation of barometric pressure and gravity with height. Unlike some of his contemporaries, Newton in particular, Hooke was a thoroughly social and gregarious being, with friends from the lowest to the highest station. He mixed equally well with men of the trades, whose work he supervised, instrument makers and craftsmen, professionals such as physicians and clerics, natural philosophers including Boyle, Wren, and Halley, and even men of the world like Samuel Pepys. In the next chapter we will try to develop an image of who Hooke was as a human being, before turning our attention to his science and his role in the Royal Society.
Chapter 1. Restoring Robert Hooke
8
Fig. 3: Hooke’s haunts in the Cornhill area, with Jonathan’s and Garraways noted.
Annotations 1) Robinson and Adams (1935); R.T. Gunther (1930), Vols. VI, VII, VIII, X, and XIII, 1930–38. 2) Andrade (1950), ‘Espinasse, 1956. The latter work clearly fails to reflect modern studies and to some extent modern historiography. But by the same token, it is fresh and original, influenced not at all by current fashions. 3) For details of Robert Hooke’s early life, we are mostly dependent upon the Life offered by Richard Waller in 1705 in his collection of Hooke’s unpublished works, The Posthumous Works of Dr. Robert Hooke. This was in turn based on a “History of my own life” which Hooke began in 1697 but never completed. While only a brief summary of his early years will be given here, the reader can consult Waller’s Life, appended to The Diary of Robert Hooke (Robinson and Adams, 1935). Gunther’s The Life and Works of Robert Hooke, published in two parts (Part I in Vol. VI and Part II in Vol. VII of Gunther (1930–38) in 1930 is actually the most detailed recounting of Hooke’s life, concentrating, of course, mostly on his science, quoting extensively from Waller and Hooke himself. John Ward’s Lives of the Gresham Professors (1740) also contains a short biography of Hooke, as does John Aubrey’s Brief Lives (Dick, 1949), pp. 165– 6. Other sources include the final chapter of ‘Espinasse’ biography, (‘Espinasse 1956), Andrade’s 1949 Wilkins Lecture (Andrade, 1950), and the introduction to Drake’s Restless Genius (Drake, 1996). Now we have biographies by Inwood (2003) and Jardine (2004).
Annotations
9
Hooke had an older sister Katherine and an older brother John, who eventually hanged himself. 4) «. . . very imfirm and weakly . . . » is how Richard Waller described him. (Gunther, 1930, Vol VI). 5) Hooke’s father died in October 1648, leaving him a legacy of $40. 6) Ironically, his portrait of Charles II now graces the walls of the Royal Society, but there is none of Hooke. 7) Beier and Finlay (1986), pp. 10, 15 (and references therein). 8) Or so the story goes. 9) Busby was renowned for his flogging, but had a strong influence on, among others, John Locke, three years older than Hooke, who also went up to Christ Church College, Oxford from Westminster, and John Dryden, who came to Westminster in 1644; Wren was also there. Busby, who was headmaster for 55 years, died in 1695 at age 89. He was a royalist who nonetheless thrived when the school was dominated by parliamentarians. He boarded a number of students at a time, deriving some income from each. 10) Aubrey said that «at school he was very mechanicall, and (amongst other things) he invented thirty severall wayes of Flying.» He went on to say that «He was never a King’s Scholar, and I have heard Sir Richard Knight (who was his school-fellow) say that he seldome saw him in the schoole.» Brief Lives, O.L. Dick, ed., 1949, p. 165. “In schoole” did not refer to the premises of Westminster, but only to the large common room known by that name. 11) Aubrey says 1658, but is evidently in error, though this is when Hooke first appears in Oxford records. As we noted earlier, when Hooke went up to Oxford it was in Puritan hands, and there would not have been church or chapel music. 12) See Gunther, VI, p. 12, n. 1. Hooke overlapped with John Locke at Westminster School and went up to Christ Church, Oxford a year or so after Locke, three years Hooke’s senior, who matriculated at Oxford in 1652. 13) Though in May 1663, a list of the registered fellows of the Society included “Thomas Sprat, M.A.,” but only “Mr. Robert Hooke.” Only Hooke had no title of any kind (Esq., D.D., M.D., LL.D., knight, bart., lord). 14) As Waller put it, Hooke «began to shew himself to the World» in 1655 (PW, p. iii). 15) Wilkins gave Hooke a copy of his Mathematical Magick, a popular work which he published in 1648. The strong friendship which grew up between them was only terminated by Wilkins’ death in 1672. 16) Ward had signed the Puritan Covenant in 1649, allowing him to return to the Oxford he had fled earlier, and he became Savilian Professor of Astronomy. He abandoned academic life in favor of a religious career in 1660, eventually becoming Bishop of Salisbury, but was an original member of the Royal Society.
Chapter 1. Restoring Robert Hooke
10
Hooke’s construction of refracting, and later, reflecting telescopes was an integral part of his interest in optics. His Diary recounts many observations, frequently with Halley and especially of comets and eclipses, but of Jupiter and Saturn as well. Most were made from his lodgings at Gresham College in London. On the whole, however, his observing was fairly casual and unsystematic, and with the exception of comets, he contributed little to astronomical science, despite a few “firsts.” He was more interested in timing, telescope driving mechanisms and sights, and, of course, lens and mirror grinding. See Chapter 9. 17) Boyle, the 7th Earl of Cork (Ireland), had been experimenting on his estate in Dorset when Wilkins persuaded him to come to Oxford in 1655–6. Christopher Wren received his M.A. from Wadham in 1657, having himself been influenced by Wilkins, Rooke, Ward, and Wallis. 18) As the reader will discover, Hooke’s dedication to his duties as Curator waned as he took on more and more responsibilities as surveyor and architect, but also when he became, briefly, Secretary of the Society, and finally, as his powers began to decline in the 1690s. For a while Hooke commuted between Oxford and London, and often stayed with Lady Ranelagh, Boyle’s sister. 19) Waller’s Life in Gunther (1930), vol. VI, p. 8; PW, p. iii. 20) Boyle, New Experiments. 21) What we know as pV = constant, a special case of the ideal gas law, pV = n RT , when T , the absolute temperature, is constant. 22) In particular Michael Hunter, whose forthcoming biography will be the definitive one of Boyle. 23) The previous week, on 5 November, his appointment was first mentioned. 24) It has been suggested that in view of his unprepossessing appearance, Hooke may have been reluctant to sit for a portrait. He does not seem, however, to have had much vanity, and there is little doubt that the Society did have a portrait. When Zacharias von Uffenbach visited the Society in 1710, he reported seeing portraits of “Boyle and Hoock.” (‘Espinasse, 1956, p. 13; Chapman, 1996). Although Jardine (2004) has claimed the discovery of a portrait of Hooke in London’s Natural History Museum, previously thought to be of John Ray, it now seems that the portrait is of Jan Baptist van Helmont. 25) The City, with an area of one square mile, is the “historic core” of Greater London, dating from medieval times. It was originally defined by the defensive “London Wall,” with its various “bars” and gates, or openings, including Bishopsgate, near which Gresham was located. 26) A situation which finally changed on 3 March 2005, with the installation of a memorial to Hooke in Westminster Abbey. Hooke went to Westminster School and worked on repairs at the Abbey at various times in his 50s. See the epilogue. 27) Bedlam, or Bethlem, or Bethlahem.
Annotations
11
28) See “Hooke and Bedlam,” (Heyman, 2006) in Cooper and Hunter (2006). Another Hooke structure was the Montague House, which burned in 1686, but whose facade survived and which was later the first home of the British Museum. 29) On the Hooke churches, see Jeffery, 1996. 30) Apparently only one of the public houses frequented by Hooke survives, the George and Vulture. See the information on taverns and coffee-houses mentioned in Hooke’s Diary, in Robertson and Adams (1935). 31) See Jeffrey (1996), who wrote (p. 176) that «without Hooke, or someone of his calibre, Wren could not have entertained the task of rebuilding the churches.» As many as 23–24 churches have been attributed in whole or in part to Hooke, some in partnership with Sir Christopher, but others mostly alone, so that while almost all other evidence of Hooke’s time on this Earth has vanished, hundreds of tourists every day look upon his works with awe, never knowing who the architect really was. 32) Nichols (1999), Jardine (2002). Hooke evidently had this possibility in mind, though one should not think of the Monument as essentially a laboratory. There is today a wooden cover in the entrance level of the Monument that, lifted, allows one to see into the lower area from which zenith observations would have been made.
“This page left intentionally blank.”
Chapter 2
Robert Hooke, Indefaticable Genius1): Hooke and London The enigma (or enigmas) of Hooke, perhaps more than any other figure of the Scientific Revolution, raises the question “Who was Robert Hooke?”2) For if there is still much to learn about Hooke, we do know that he was not a person who aroused feelings of indifference. He was lionized by many as ingenious, honest, and generous, while others dismissed him with contempt or hatred as mean, irascible, and, worse, one who claimed the discoveries of others. Even today, despite an explosion of writing on Hooke, no clear view of him emerges, and the situation is not so different from three centuries ago, with partisans showing near reverence for him and detractors finding unworthy motives in almost everything he did. If he was held in high regard by important scientific figures like Christopher Wren, Robert Boyle, and Edmond Halley, revered by such men of the world as Samuel Pepys, major church figures like Seth Ward and John Tillotson, and by his chroniclers John Aubrey and Richard Waller, he also made important enemies. Among these, eventually, were Henry Oldenburg, long-time Secretary of the Society, and Viscount Lord Brouncker, its president for a decade and a half, as well as major continental scientific figures like Huygens and Leibniz. And, of course, Newton. In part, simple rivalry or jealousy was involved, but Hooke was at the very least “touchy” as Andrade, a Hooke admirer, called him, and there is no doubt that he was vigorously protective of his discoveries and reputation. Hooke was not always easy to get along with, and to some extent the same is true today. Among modern commentators, Bryan Little, one of the many Wren biographers, who leaned heavily on Hooke’s Diary, calls him a «warped and over sensitive man,» and the Boyle biographer R.E.W. Maddison noted that Hooke «had the reputation of being difficult and crabbed.»3) Lisa Jardine has pronounced him «notoriously difficult to please.»4) Hooke’s evident animus for Oldenburg is one of the reasons that many have dismissed him as a malcontent, but there is very much to be said on Hooke’s side in this matter, and as it turns out he had good reasons for his suspicions.5) Nor was he alone in his sentiments: Wren, for example, had no more
14
Chapter 2. Robert Hooke, Indefaticable Genius
use for Oldenburg than Hooke. Hooke’s regard for Lord Brouncker, the Society’s long-time president, was also very low, an estimate Pepys seconded when he called Brouncker a «rotten hearted, false man, as any else I know . . . »6) To the sharp-eyed and meticulous Pepys, Hooke at age 30 was «the most and promises the least, of any man in the world that I ever saw.»7) Not long after Hooke’s death in 1703, the same year Pepys died, Waller, secretary of the Royal Society and publisher of Hooke’s Posthumous Works, saw him as one of the «Ornaments of the last Century». Even Newton’s famous «If I have seen further it is by standing on the shoulders of Giants,» was an observation prompted by Hooke’s earlier work in optics, and made in a letter to him.8) Leona Rostenberg, one of those who has studied Hooke’s library, saw him as a «most erudite, gregarious, occasionally cantankerous scientist . . . ,» and ‘Espinasse pictured him as a man of «warm and tender heart, too generous and too busy with ideas to go on bearing rancour . . . »9) Michael Cooper, In his groundbreaking studies of Hooke’s work as City Surveyor, has pronounced him «extraordinarily well organised, fair-minded, efficient and astonishingly energetic.»10) In the public sphere, surveying, arbitrating disputes over boundaries or codes, and in designing private residences, mansions, for Royalty or the City, his competence was apparently exceptional. No doubt Hooke could be difficult, but he led a rich, complex, and, one suspects, satisfying life, in spite of rather precarious health, frequent grumbling about slights, and the bad luck he had to toil in Newton’s shadow in his later years, convinced that Newton had stolen the secret of planetary motion from him. But the picture that emerges is of an energetic, warm and gregarious person, friend to the great and small, somewhat acerbic, perhaps cantankerous, and certainly jealous of his reputation. As an indication of how Hooke’s reputation has grown in the last half-century, we note that Mordechai Feingold entitled his contribution to the Hooke 2003 symposium at the Royal Society “Robert Hooke: Gentleman of Science.”11) So if there is nothing to indicate other than that Hooke was a person of the highest personal rectitude, and that his most evident characteristics, after his boundless energy and «indefatigable genius,» seem to have been straightforwardness, honesty, and generosity, he could bridle quickly when slighted by someone who seemed to think himself his superior, and he seems to have a well-justified expectation that his accomplishments and his service to the Royal Society would bring him respect. His tolerance of the scoundrel or poseur, whether Lord or laborer, was very slight; as Waller said of him, «He had a piercing Judgment into the Dispositions of others . . . » The Diary constantly reflects disappointment with the integrity, fairness, or competence of the people with whom he dealt on a daily basis, including not a few in the Society itself. In short, much of his reputation for being difficult comes from disappointment in his expectations of others. At the same time, he was very human, and hero worship is no more justified in Hooke’s case than it is in Newton’s. Hooke’s generous personality also comes through in his relationships with those dependent upon him. He helped the impecunious John Aubrey through bad times by lending him money, buying books from him to stave off bankruptcy, letting him use
Chapter 2. Robert Hooke, Indefaticable Genius
15
his rooms as a place to receive mail when he was without a permanent residence, and often putting him up.12) Although he seems to have been fair to his domestic help, the sexual exploitation of his housekeepers, candidly recounted in his Diary, if of the time (note Pepys’ liberties with his own staff and Brouncker’s reputation, for example), will give the modern reader pause, and indeed may have offended some of Hooke’s more fastidious companions.13) Aside from this disappointing, and even appalling weakness, it may be that his worst personal failing (though given the challenges he faced, it is not clear that he could have done much better) was his inability to bring many of his ideas to completion or even to publish them, by virtue of which he was himself responsible for squandering the fruits of his creative intellect.14) As already noted, no portrait of Hooke is known to exist (despite some wishful thinking) and contemporary accounts, primarily those by Waller and Aubrey, are models of brevity. For the most part, our only recourse is to his now famous Diary (or diaries), one written in his late 30s into his 40s, the other in his 50s. They are intimate and in many ways revealing, but at the same time maddeningly terse and telegraphic. They describe details of his daily existence, and often those of his contemporaries, but give us precious few details of his scientific life. In particular, we learn almost nothing of his scientific work habits, what his laboratory or experimental space at Gresham might have been like, and so on. We find passages such as «Set up the new magneticall experiiment about 4 p.m. . . . ,»15) but anything more specific is quite rare. What we do learn is that Hooke was in constant motion, observing, juggling diverse experiments, meeting members of the Royal Society, seeing Wren almost daily on architectural projects, conferring with tradesmen and builders, making the rounds of his favorite coffee-houses and, though less frequently, taverns. His was a restless, rich life, full of social interactions, and yet, while he had many friends, often of high station, few of his acquaintances left substantial accounts of him. His lifelong friend Christopher Wren left almost nothing in the form of reminiscence and his extant correspondence is, like Hooke’s, quite small. Both, it might be said, were too busy for introspection and retrospection. Few letters passed between them because they saw each other almost daily; they were creatures of London who had little need for the post. Hooke and his mentor Boyle often communicated by mail, but Hooke had no regular correspondence with any scientist elsewhere in the country, or abroad, with the exception of Halley, with whom he kept in touch when the latter was traveling. Unlike a Newton or a Wallis, sequestered in provincial Cambridge or Oxford, and whose only means of communication was the letter, Hooke wrote few. Most of his surviving correspondence is to be found in the collections of more famous figures like Newton, Boyle, Flamsteed, and Halley. Even as Secretary of the Society from 1677 to 1682 his correspondence was relatively meager. But while he was not a prolific correspondent, the letters we have are sensitive, articulate, and interesting. He wrote little about himself, apart from a an aborted biographical sketch, but such testimony is often untrustworthy anyway – in Newton’s case, the much later recollections of his early years are notoriously self-serving. Although Hooke was anything but a dandy, his Diary reveals a definite interest in the state of his wardrobe and regularly records the purchase of quality material for
16
Chapter 2. Robert Hooke, Indefaticable Genius
his clothing. By all accounts he was quite presentable and certainly not embarrassed to be in the company of the King, despite a pronounced stoop, as we hear from Waller in this famous description: «As to his person he was but despicable, being very crooked, tho’ I have heard from himself, and others, that he was strait till about 16 Years of Age when he first grew awry, by frequent practicing, turning with a Turn-lath, and the like incurvating Excercises, being but of a thin weak habit of body, which increas’d as he grew older, so as to be very remarkable at last: This made him but of low Stature, tho’ by his Limbs he shou’d have been moderately tall. he was always very pale and lean, and laterly nothing but Skin and bone, with a meagre Aspect, his Eyes grey and full, with a sharp ingenious Look whilst younger; his Nose but thin, of a moderate height and length; his Mouth meanly wide, and upper Lip thin; his Chin sharp, and Forehead large; his Head of a middle size. He wore his own Hair of a dark Brown colour, very long and hanging neglected over his Face uncut and lank, which about three Year before his death he cut off, and wore a Periwig. He went stooping and very fast . . . having but a light Body to carry, and a great deal of Spirits and Activity, especially in his Youth.»16) John Aubrey’s recollection was similar to Waller’s, but emphasized his inventiveness and virtue: «He is but of midling stature, something crooked, pale faced, and his face but little below, but his head is lardge; his eie full and popping, and not quick; a grey eie. He has a delicate head of haire, browne, and of an excellent moist curle. He is and ever was very temperate, and moderate in dyet &c. As he is of prodigious inventive head; so he is a person of great vertue an goodness . . . He is certainly the greatest mechanick this day in the world . . . In fine (which crowns all) he is a person of great suavity and goddnesse.»17) Hooke never married, indeed, could not have done so and retained the Gresham professorship which he held for the last 40 years of his life. Many other important figures of early modern science never married, for example, Newton, Huygens, Leibniz, Locke, Hume, Hobbes and Kant. Boyle was ardently celibate.18) In this regard, Wren and Halley, notable family men, are important exceptions. Unlike Newton, Hooke had a fondness for the opposite sex, and that he took advantage of the vulnerable girls who lived with him as housekeepers, and presumptively coerced them into sexual relationships, is revealed in his own hand. Given his normal sex drive, as evidenced by numerous other Diary entries, the presence of young ladies in his house and his position of power over them, and perhaps his inability to form sensual bonds with women based on equality, it was almost inevitable that Hooke should take advantage. In Hooke’s defense, we note that he never lost interest in his former housekeeper Nell Young’s welfare after she left his service and married. She often visited him on a Sunday morning, and Hooke was ready to offer assistance. His relationship with his niece Grace is more surprising, but in the absence of any real knowledge of the
Chapter 2. Robert Hooke, Indefaticable Genius
17
affair, it is a dead end. His evident concern for her health, his apprehension when she was out, his devastation when she died in 1687, have prompted some to call her his “mistress” or even “common-law wife.”19) Waller wrote that «In the beginning of the Year 1687 his Brother’s Daughter, Mrs. Grace Hooke dy’d, who had liv’d with him several Years, the concern for whose Death he hardly ever wore off, being observed from that time to grow less active, more Melancholy and Cynical.»20) Granting this failing on Hooke’s part, however, and offering no defense of it, one can see it as part and parcel of a rich and vigorous social and sensual life, reflecting enormous physical and intellectual energy. Coupled with the garrulous and gregarious nature we see evidenced in his habitual visits to coffee-houses and taverns and his full social life, we are furnished the image of a vigorous and vital young man in his late thirties, taking life at the full. They surely form a contrast with the repressed and reclusive Newton, sequestered in Cambridge, seeing almost no one. As we shall see, Hooke’s health was precarious, or at any rate, a constant preoccupation. Indeed, he has been called a hypochondriac. He was in constant search for nostrums and experimental cures for his many real (and imagined?) ailments, and records at length his various means of purging himself, or of trying to get a good night’s sleep. In spite of this somewhat frail health and a whole host of physical problems which often dominated his daily life, Hooke was full of energy, covering much of the City daily, almost always on foot, and there is little evidence that these nagging maladies had any considerable effect on his activity or his concentration, at least until his declining years. We find him hurrying all over the City and beyond, visiting Wren or Boyle, stopping at this coffee house or that tavern, taking care of the business of the Society, assisting Wren with his numerous rebuilding projects, tending to his own architectural jobs and his obligations as Surveyor for the City of London, meeting with various committees and contractors, dealing with tradesmen, visiting instrument makers, lecturing once a week as Gresham Professor of Geometry, carrying out his own experiments, making astronomical observations, and so on. Few have had as full a life as Robert Hooke and only in his sixties did he slow down. Further light is shed on Hooke’s personality by his great and enduring friendship with three of the most important and revered figures of English science in the seventeenth century, Wren, Boyle, and Halley. These relationships lasted some 25– 30 years, terminating only with Boyle’s death in 1691 and Hooke’s own in 1703. In Boyle’s bequest, he willed to Hooke «my best microscope and my best Loadstone which I shall have att the time of my death.» His close friendship with Westminster School’s Dr. Richard Busby (1606–95), begun in his student days, also lasted a lifetime. John Wilkins, responsible for the resurgence of science in Oxford and the main force in the foundation of the Society, was a mentor and friend, and Hooke devotedly visited him on his deathbed. Hooke and Halley became acquainted when Halley was in his late teens, socialized some in the late 70s, and finally met regularly over coffee in the period of the later Diary. Frequently they made astronomical observations together. The generous and diplomatic Halley managed to maintain warm relations with Hooke even as he was bringing the great work of Hooke’s nemesis Newton, into print. In this he had to balance his considerable regard for Hooke and his admira-
18
Chapter 2. Robert Hooke, Indefaticable Genius
tion of Newton, trying to assuage the latter’s feelings about Hooke and at the same time delicately preserving his friendship with the prickly Gresham Professor, who felt so deeply wronged. Hooke was witness to Halley’s will in 1693, and Halley in turn helped ease Hooke’s final infirm years. Other close friends in the Society included John Aubrey, John Hoskins,21) and William Holder. Beyond that, Hooke had a large group of companions, some in the Society, most not, with whom he regularly drank coffee and “discoursed” at dozens of coffee-houses and taverns.22) Hooke frequently dined at Boyle’s or Wren’s23) and was welcome in the homes of other highly ranked members of the Society such as Lord Brounker. He was a friend of Seth Ward, who later would be Bishop of Exeter and then of Salisbury (Sarum), and he was often in the company of John Tillotson who would become Archbishop of Canterbury. He and Samuel Pepys saw each other frequently, often in each other’s lodgings. Hooke’s counsel was clearly sought out, he was obviously someone to be listened to, and all the evidence is that he was an interesting companion, with whom it was profitable to while away some time over coffee or a pint. He was also acquainted with Charles II and was employed as an architect by several important private clients, in addition to the official work he did for the City of London as surveyor and architect. The Royal Society met virtually in his rooms at Gresham College until his death and members were often there to help with experiments on days other than meeting days.
The Diary While we would wish that the Diary shed much more light on Hooke’s laboratory at Gresham College and the measurements he made there, or his thoughts as he prepared a discourse for the Society, or on the details of meetings, rather than the brief hints we actually get, it is invaluable nonetheless, especially when read along with the Journal Book or Birch. It is for that reason, and not so much because of what it tells us about Hooke as a person, that we examine here the two extant parts of the Diary. It is almost miraculous that the first and most famous part of Hooke’s Diary survived to find a home in the Guildhall Library of the Corporation of the City of London at the end of the nineteenth century. It was not sold with Hooke’s other effects after his death in 1703, and never came into the possession of the Royal Society. It disappeared completely for nearly two centuries, between 1714, when Richard Waller died, and 1891.24) Eventually the difficult task of transcribing it from Hooke’s scribble was carried out and it was brought into print in 1935 by Henry Robinson and Walter Adams, who were given permission by the Corporation to publish it.25) The original, still in the Guildhall Library, begins in March 1672 and continues until May 1683. This first part of the Diary was begun when Hooke was nearly 37, finishing his first decade as Curator, and well into his career as surveyor and supervisor of construction. The second part, which picks up in 1688 after a more than five year hiatus, was published at almost the same time (1935) by Oxford’s Robert Gunther,26) who had unsuccessfully sought permission to bring the earlier part into print as well. It may be idle to ask why Hooke kept a Diary, but it is clear that he was not writing for posterity. It is very unlikely that he imagined that other eyes would one
The Diary
19
day scrutinize these quick, candid, and personal jottings, but he probably found it irresistible to keep some sort of log, given the importance he attached to “registering” experimental trials and observations. He does recount experiments and occasional astronomical observations, but unfortunately, given our interest in his science, and after a brief and promising start, he gives almost no data. He kept the Diary solely for his own purposes, in many ways a kind of memo book,27) noting transactions, recording new cures for sleeplessness or a sour stomach, and so on, but it also allowed him to privately vent his spleen over slights and insults he received and the stupidity and recalcitrance of workmen with whom he had to deal. The Diary commences, unceremoniously, with «Memoranda begun: March 10, 1671/2,» and for several weeks it consists mostly of meteorological records. It may be, as Michael Cooper has speculated, that Hooke used his survey books to keep personal notes prior to starting the Diary.28) But by July or August of 1672 the Diary as we know it is beginning to take shape, and continues in that vein for eight full years. For reasons at which one can only guess, perhaps because he was so busy, Hooke’s interest in or time to devote to the Diary began to wane in late 1680 and by the time it ends three years later the entries have gotten very sketchy. In transcribing the Diary for publication, Robinson and Adams chose to skip the first five months of mainly meteorological data and the last 2 12 years of half-hearted jottings.29) Its beginning, as we now have it, coincides with Newton’s first communication to the Society on light, but that may be entirely coincidental. The manner in which it begins, with meteorological data, suggests that Hooke had not been writing a diary before that point. The second or later Diary (British Library MS. Sloane 4024), commenced in November of 1688 and ended abruptly in 1693, but as passed down to us has a gap of about 2 12 years, from March 1690 to December 1692. Additional fragments were published by Gunther in his Early Science in Oxford,30) initially in Vol. VII, consisting of scattered entries from 1681 to 168331) plus one from 1695 (MS. Sloane 1039 in the British Museum).32) . Thus the two parts of the Diary span, interruptedly, more than two decades, 1672–93, with nearly eight years missing. These lacunae are crucial years in Hooke’s life, especially the period 1680 to 1688, when his influence was at its zenith and Newton was moving toward the Principia.33) And, of course the year 1687, when the Principia was published and Grace died. To fill in the gaps we mostly have the archives of the Society itself34) , a modest amount of correspondence, and a few comments by friends and colleagues. Wren, who could have given a rich account of Hooke and of their relationship, personal and professional, was too busy to leave much to posterity other than his buildings. None of the sections of the Diary ends in a way signaling an impending or intentional interruption, nor do later parts take note of any resumption,35) suggesting, or at least raising the possibility, that Hooke may have kept a diary throughout this entire period (1672–93), or even beyond it.36) Unlike the earlier diary, which is on large pages, the later one was a pocket diary, measuring about 6 × 10 cm, and in its present form contains about 40 pages. Its last entry, on Tuesday August 8, 1693 is
20
Chapter 2. Robert Hooke, Indefaticable Genius
perfunctory and unrevealing: «At Jon. [athan’s] Pag, Gof, Lod, Spen o.»37) Hooke was then less than a month past his 58th birthday, with slightly less than ten years to live. An examination of the Diary as it now exists in the British Library makes it clear that fragments, or at least large sections, were bound together at some later time into one volume, again suggesting a more nearly continuous document may have once existed. This later Diary concerns itself far more with politics and affairs of state than the earlier one, something which is especially true in 1688–9, but those were heady times, as William prepared to land in England and wrest the throne from James II. Like Pepys’ diary, Hooke’s gives us a window into his life and also some insight into life in seventeenth-century London, but his mostly telegraphic style, nearly devoid of verbs, is much more laconic: «At Mr. Haaks. Mr. Hoskins here. Tryd reflex microscope &c . . . ».38) But it also provides us with a slightly different perspective on Society meetings from Birch or the Journal Book, as Hooke comments on what transpired, who attended, and sometimes tells us at least a bit about experiments he was working on. These comments are sometimes helpful, but are never very expansive. If we had to construct his career as an experimental natural philosopher from the Diary we would be mostly in the dark. As lagniappe, the diaries also make it possible to trace the movements of important figures like Wren and Halley, and many others, who left no such memoranda. For example, the reason we know Secretary Oldenburg died in London is that Hooke records the event. It is not that Hooke’s life as a scientist is absent from the Diary, but one has to work rather hard to extract it from the often routine details of everyday obligations and transactions. Usually there is a comment, on a Wednesday or Thursday, about the weekly meeting of the Royal Society, but it is typically very brief, e.g., «to Arundel House. Shewd Experiment of microscope and presented Hevelius his book.»39) Sometimes there are only vague allusions to a paper which may turn out to be important later in this narrative, sometimes we find references to an observation of Saturn, or an eclipse, perhaps with Halley, or others. Very occasionally there is a reference to an encounter with Huygens or Newton. Infrequently there is more meat, and rarely there is some real scientific detail, as we shall see below. Controversies of a technical nature which found their way into the pages of the Diary include that with Hevelius on the issue of telescope sights, and with Huygens over the spring-regulated watch.40) The Diary often recounts conversations with Wren on purely scientific matters, usually at a coffee house, and the same is true of his discussions with Halley. A notable example is planetary motion.41) Frequently the often cryptic references can be fleshed out by examining Birch or the minutes or journals of the Society.42) Other than Hooke’s own published work, and perhaps a hint or two from the Diary, these documents of the Society, or Birch’s summaries, are the raw material out of which we must construct his scientific life, especially for the years for which there is no diary. The state of Hooke’s health is a major preoccupation, as indicated by hundreds of entries, and yet for a person who almost always «slept not well» he seems to have been remarkably vigorous. His social life, which not only involved habitual visits to Garaways or Jonathan’s43) in the Cornhill area (Fig. 3), and a host of other coffeehouses and taverns, often several times in a day and often with Society members,
The Diary
21
bespeaks an enormous amount of energy. We also learn of frequent dining at Wren’s, Boyle’s44) (Lady Ranelagh’s, Boyle’s sister), Lord Brounker’s, innumerable transactions with tradesmen, shopkeepers, and so on,. Despite this, his health was never robust and seems to have been declining as early as the 1670s when he was not yet 40. Indeed John Collins wrote James Gregory just after Christmas 1672 that «Mr Hooke is in a consumption and unlikely to recover.»45) Taken as a whole the diaries show a straightforward and pragmatic personality little concerned with fashion or fad, with not much expressed envy of those in higher stations – and he worked or socialized with such persons every day. Energy and equanimity in the face of a frenetic pace are what come to mind when one immerses himself in these writings. Nonetheless, much of Hooke’s reputation for being irascible and jealous comes from the Diary, although contemporaries were not silent on the matter. There are not infrequent passages in which he grumbles about the outcome of some transaction with a tradesman or with someone who owes him money or to whom he owes it,46) or, perhaps, a slight by someone in or near the Royal Society, or another of high station. These comments are often very sharp, and jump out at the reader who has been lulled to sleep by «at Garways . . . went out not all day . . . Home . . . DH [Dined Home] . . . Mr. Boyles . . . » Thus we read “Fitch a knave”, “Player a fox”, “Oliver a villain”, “Tompion a slug”, and so on, often without context or explanation. Many of these epithets are directed at workmen or shopkeepers and hence are of mild interest at best. Some of these passages refer to Sir J. Cutler, in honor of whom Hooke’s Cutler Lectures were named, and who while ostensibly Hooke’s patron, rarely met any obligation to him.47) One can hardly blame Hooke for his exasperation with and dislike of Cutler. Other comments, involving major figures in the Society, such as its long-time secretary Henry Oldenburg, are of much greater interest to the historian of science. For example, Hooke talks about Oldenburg’s «treachery,» his «fals suggestions,» calls him a «lying Dog,» and says at one point that Oldenburg «fled at my sight.»48) And there are others.49) As we have said, Lord Brouncker, first president of the Society, was sometimes the subject of Hooke’s ire, as was the long-time treasurer, Abraham Hill, another for whom Hooke’s admiration was very low.50) After Oldenburg died in 1677 and Hooke and Nehemiah Grew were appointed to jointly share the secretary’s duties, there are frequent angry references to Grew, Hill, and various others, especially Daniel Colwall, who was treasurer until 1679, and who is the target of Hooke’s feelings on several occasions (e.g., «Colwall a dog»). There are even occasional outbursts directed against his fast friends Wren, Boyle, and Halley51) although calm seems to have returned very quickly. Hooke lived his entire adult life in London, where his favored form of communication was the meeting at a coffee-house, at which he would regularly (often several times a day) meet friends, colleagues like Wren, Halley, and Hoskins, and tradesmen and others with whom he had to transact business. For over a quarter-century, up to the 1690s, he saw Wren almost daily, and in the 80s almost as frequently saw Halley. He often met Wren at a church or other building site, but frequently at a convenient coffee-house, and most of his many meetings with Halley took place at Jonathan’s in Exchange Alley. He saw Boyle mostly at his lodgings, but also frequently wrote
22
Chapter 2. Robert Hooke, Indefaticable Genius
to him, as something of a shut-in who was not often at Royal Society meetings and certainly not a habitu´e of the coffee-house or tavern.52) The visits to Wren’s home or meetings with him on architectural matters usually take place a couple of times a week,53) and meetings with Boyle are almost as frequent, though he was often not in town. These daily rounds, calling on friends, visiting job sites, stopping at his several favorite coffee-houses, were, as we have said, almost always made on foot.
Hooke and Wren Hooke’s relationship with Wren (Fig. 4) deserves special comment. The two of them had a common mentor and patron in John Wilkins at Oxford,54) where they apparently became acquainted, and began a lifelong friendship. That friendship blossomed when they both assumed major civic duties after the fire, but they were also colleagues and partners, and it might not be too much to say that family aside, each was the most important person in the other’s life.55) Wren evidently introduced Hooke to microscopy and was materially involved in his becoming Surveyor for the City and eventually a builder and architect. For over two decades, Hooke was Wren’s close associate in rebuilding the northeast portion of the City of London.56) Before the Restoration, their prospects were not terribly different, with Wren’s royalist family reduced to near poverty. But their stations changed markedly after the monarchy was restored, as Wren rapidly rose in influence and favor and Hooke was left to find his way to a career through the good offices of others, eventually a paid position at the Royal Society. Both of them scientific virtuosi, with sharp minds and diverse interests which overlapped significantly, for nearly forty years they argued natural philosophy in their favorite coffee-houses or at Wren’s home or office. Wren might well have been London’s outstanding scientist had he not turned so completely toward architecture. Or, on the other hand, he might have spent his entire career in Oxford, and perhaps even been a challenge to Newton. His early options would have been to go into the church, following his father, into medicine, which he seriously considered, or to take a professorship, as he did for a while at Oxford. The fateful decision to assume the posts of Surveyor- General and Surveyor of the Kings Works, responsibility for rebuilding the churches of the City, and ultimately, that of designing and supervising construction of the new St. Paul’s Cathedral, determined the course of his career and indeed his life. By the 1670s, natural philosophy had for him been almost relegated to a hobby, to be discussed and debated with Hooke on nearly a daily basis, amidst their meetings on architectural matters. Yet philosophy was undoubtedly his first love and he never quite put it behind him (in part because his architecture continually put demands on his knowledge of mechanics). So frequently did the two of them discuss scientific issues, as we learn from Hooke’s Diary, that it is hard to tell who is responsible for any insight which they seem to have had at about the same time. An example is the inverse-square law of gravity, at which they apparently both arrived around 1677, and almost certainly before Newton.57) Similarly, the extent to which they shared responsibility for their architectural projects remains elusive. In the rebuilding of the parish churches of the
Hooke and Wren
Fig. 4
Christopher Wren (1627–1723). Geoffrey Kneller portrait. c National Portrait Gallery, London.) (
23
24
Chapter 2. Robert Hooke, Indefaticable Genius
City, Wren clearly had the senior role, but many of those churches were designed largely or entirely by Hooke. Since, as we have said, neither man was much of a letter-writer, and since they spent most of their lives within a 20 minute walk of each other, there are very few letters between them. As a result, what evidence we have of how they shared responsibility comes from Hooke’s Diary and from parish records, the latter usually only compounding the mystery, since often payments are made to both men. We learn from the second Diary that in later years the two met less frequently, as Hooke’s responsibilities as surveyor and commissioner waned along with his architectural practice and Wren continued to be consumed with St. Paul’s. Still they managed to see each other regularly in the 1680s and early 90s, often at Mans coffee house, once or twice at Wren’s or his daughter’s, despite the early stages of Hooke’s deteriorating health, and the fact that Wren rarely had time for Society meetings. Hooke was Wren’s valued colleague and friend, but in a way Wren was Hooke’s lifeline. From this association he got status, intellectual stimulation and ideas, architectural work, and friendship.
Conclusion Hooke’s broad range of interests was undoubtedly widened by his job as Curator of experiments to the Royal Society, but equally it reflects his own character and personality. The term “polymath” seems almost to have been coined for Hooke. Intellectually, as we shall see, he was omnivorous, interested in everything from pneumatics, microscopy, magnetism, gravitation, capillarity, and planetary motion, to the circulation of the blood, the structure of trees and plants, and metallurgy. He was one of the major figures in the history of horology, was one of the first geologists, and for a time was one of England’s most important astronomers. And he was in constant contact with instrument makers, opticians, and other craftsmen, with whom he exchanged ideas about design and construction of instruments, fabrication of optics, and so on. After the fire, as Hooke became heavily involved in his second career as surveyor, inspector, architect, composer and enforcer of construction codes and practices, constantly negotiating with carpenters, stone masons, and so on, he had less time for his responsibilities as Curator. His architectural work, which peaked in the late 1670s but continued into the 1690s, involved royal, ecclesiastical, and private design and construction, gave him added prestige and income. But this work interfered dramatically with his obligations to the Society, and more importantly, took time that he might have had to think about philosophy. That Hooke was distracted from Society business in this intensely busy period is not hard to understand. Hooke’s final years were increasingly melancholy, as his health declined, Grace died, and many of his friends, notably Boyle and Busby, passed away. By 1691 – the year in which Boyle died – Hooke was nearly blind in one eye, and on several occasions between 1689 and 1693 he speaks in his Diary of his «melancholy,» of being «weary», and «sad.»58) It is apparent that he became something of a recluse in his last years as he grew ever weaker, but as late as August 1693 he was still keeping
Annotations
25
to a relatively vigorous schedule. He may indeed have become embittered in the last decade or so of his life as some accounts say, in the face of failing health, the death of Grace, and perhaps because of Newton’s triumph over him. But this is not the Robert Hooke of the previous four decades. When he died, Hooke left an estate of more than $9000, a quite considerable fortune which he had mostly saved from his surveying and architectural duties. A frugal man, except when it came to book purchases, he rarely entertained, got around on foot, and never traveled abroad. His total income from 40 years of scientific employment was well under $4000, but that allowed him to lay aside something like $300–400 per annum from his other duties. It was regretted by all that in the misery of his last days, he failed to leave his estate to the Royal Society. In some sense, however, his legacy was the Society itself.59)
Annotations 1) The title of this chapter is taken from Waller’s life of Hooke in The Posthumous Works of Dr. Robert Hooke, p. xxvii. 2) As also did Steven Shapin in Hunter and Schaffer (1989). 3) Little (1975), p. 91; Maddison (1969), p. 135. 4) Jardine (2004), p. 151. 5) Notwithstanding Hall’s “Why Blame Oldenburg,” (Hall and Hall, 1962a), as we shall see. 6) Brounker was, however, an important mathematician. See, e.g., Stedall (2000). 7) Samuel Pepys, Diary. It is unfortunate that Pepys’ failing eyesight forced him to terminate his diary at the end of May 1669, long before his deep involvement with the Society. His final entry contained these words: «And thus ends all that I doubt I shall ever be able to do with my own eyes in the keeping of my journall . . . And so I betake myself to that course, which [is] almost as much as to see myself go into the grave – for which, and all the discomforts that will accompany my being blind, the good God prepare me.» (The Diary of Samuel Pepys, 1976, Vol. 9, 564–5.) Pepys would die 34 years later, in the same year as Hooke, having put his name on the frontispiece of the Principia, as President of the Royal Society. John Evelyn, in his own diary, recounted on 4 August 1665 (in the midst of the plague) that he «called at Durdans, where I found Dr. Wilkins, Sir William Petty, and Mr. Hooke . . . perhaps three such persons together were not to be found elsewhere in Europe, for parts and ingenuity.» (The Diary of John Evelyn, 1901, Vol. II, p. 8.) Evelyn, an original fellow of the Society, and Pepys, eventually became presidents. Both, however, were largely bystanders to the scientific revolution. 8) Newton to Hooke, 5 Feb. 1676, Corresp., 1, 416. 9) ‘Espinasse (1956), p. 140.
26
Chapter 2. Robert Hooke, Indefaticable Genius
10) Cooper (2000, 2003). 11) Feingold (2006). 12) Lord Thanet wrote him that «Your lodging [being] like an enchanted castle, being never to be found out, I shall in the future direct my Letters to Mr Hooke’s chamber in Gresham Colledge, as you desire . . . » Thanet to Aubrey, 19 April 1675, in Anthony Powell, John Aubrey and his Friends, London, 1988. 13) Lord Brouncker was a noted womanizer. See Cook (1998), p. 45. Among other things, Hooke provided for the education of his boy, the orphan Tom Gyles. 14) In most cases, Hooke could later point to the Journal or Register Books of the Society as proof of what he had said or shown before the Society, although he had a long battle with Oldenburg over what he saw was the latter’s deliberate failure to record some of his discoveries or inventions. Nonetheless, by frequently failing to publish the many ideas that he scattered to the winds, he allowed others to come along later (and independently) claim the discoveries for themselves. 15) Diary I, p. 300 (8 July 1677). Often we can cross-check the Diary with the Journal Books or Birch to see what experiment was referred to. 16) In Waller’s introduction to his compilation titled Posthumous Works of Dr. Robert Hooke (1705). The Posthumous Works was dedicated to Newton (as well as to the Council and fellows), who was in his second year as president of the Royal Society. Manuel (1968) sees this as adding a «posthumous insult to the injuries Hooke had endured during his lifetime . . . » Hooke no doubt would have seen it that way, but the dedication would have been entirely proper. 17) John Aubrey, Brief Lives. O.L. Dick, ed., pp. 165–6. On Aubrey himself, the introduction to the latter work is especially useful, and for a fuller study, Hunter (1975). Aubrey was an extraordinary character of the widest possible interests, above all an antiquarian. Among other things he called attention to Avebury and what are now called the “Aubrey stones” and made a detailed survey of Stonehenge, resulting in a ring of filled holes known as the “Aubrey holes.” He describes climbing Silbury Hill in Wiltshire with Charles II. Once landed gentry, he was reduced to borrowing small sums from Hooke, and in 1686 left his papers on Wiltshire to Hooke in case he died before returning to London. 18) To many, science was inherently masculine, and others have written, in this context, of “homosociability.” See, for example, Schiebinger (2003). Perhaps things are not so different today. 19) On more than 20 occasions in the period (1672–80) covered by the first Diary. It is interesting, perhaps, that Hooke’s most ardent defenders have, nonetheless, been women: Louise Patterson, Margaret ‘Espinasse, and Ellen Tan Drake. Even Marjorie Hope Nicholson. I make this point not in justification of Hooke’s transgressions, but because it suggests that those most sensitive to the issue are able to look beyond it.
Annotations
27
20) Waller (1705). The Life of Dr. Robert Hooke. 21) According to Halley, Hooke broke with Hoskins over an incident following the presentation on 28 April 1686 by Dr. Vincent of a copy of the first part of the Principia to the Society. Halley’s account appears in his letter to Newton on 29 June, where he says that Hoskins, who as vice-president was in the chair, said of the Principia that it was «so much the more to be prized, for that it was both Invented and perfected at the same time.» According to Halley, «this gave Mr Hook offense that Sr John did not at that time, make mention of what he had, as he sd, discovered to him [Newton]. Upon which they two, who till then were the most inseparable cronies, have since scarce seen one another, and are utterly fallen out.» Halley to Newton, 29 June 1686; Corresp. II, 442–3. The evidence from Hooke’s later Diary is equivocal. Before March 1689, Hooke and Hoskins meet several times at Jonathan’s, but on 6 March (meeting) Hooke writes that «Hoskins belged me, as he does every time.» Again, in March 1692/3, after a long period of neutral entries recounting coffee at Jonathan’s with Hoskins among others, Hooke writes «HM. and Aubery, Hoskins tools.» 22) See, for example, the list of over 100 coffee-houses and taverns cited by Hooke in his earlier Diary, given by Robinson and Adams (1935). 23) During some periods, this was an almost weekly occurrence, especially at Wren’s. In the case of Boyle, it was at the home of his sister, Katherine Jones, Lady Ranelagh. 24) According to Keynes, the Diary was in the possession of Hooke’s heir Elizabeth Stephens until 1708, when it passed to Waller. Upon his death it went to William Derham, who died in 1735. In 1891 it was purchased with other books from Moor Hall, Harlow, Essex, by the Corporation of the City of London. Moor Hall was owned by the Henshaw family at the time of the death of Derham, and Thomas Henshaw was a major figure in the Royal Society in the 1670s and 80s. Perhaps as miraculous was the recent discovery of the “Hooke Folio” after three full centuries. See Chapter 7. 25) Robinson and Adams (1935). The preface to this work describes in greater detail the disposition of the Diary during those two centuries (pp. v–viii). Written in Hooke’s crabbed hand, the Diary is sometimes nearly, or indeed actually, illegible. But a remarkable document nonetheless. 26) It forms the bulk of Volume X of Gunther’s Early Science in Oxford (Gunther, 1930–38). 27) For Saturday, 19 December 1674, Hooke inserted the following order from the “controuler:” Sir You are forthwith to pay to Mr. R. Hooke Surveyor of New building out of the moneys arising up by the Impositions layd upon Coles the sum of one hundred pounds in full satisfaction for his frequent Directions and attendances at and in Relation to Fleet Channell and the publique works of this City for the space of three years and upwards . . . ” 28) Cooper (1998a) p. 30, and Cooper (2003).
28
Chapter 2. Robert Hooke, Indefaticable Genius
29) Though, as noted, Robinson and Adams did not reprint the five months of mainly meteorological observations beginning in March 1672, or the sketchy entries from the end of 1680 until May 1683. In fact, the choice of 1 August 1672 by Robinson and Adams was largely arbitrary, there being considerable narrative prior to that date. See the original in the Guildhall Library. Hooke recorded barometric pressure and temperature daily until the end of April 1673. While he measured temperature relative to the freezing point of water, and was the first to do so, the other fixed point necessary to standardize the temperature scale was arbitrary. A “lovely summers day” was recorded as “Th. 8.”, so that the scale was not very different from the later one of Celcius, based on the boiling point of water as well. His mercury barometer readings increased as the barometer dropped, ranging from a “high” of about 0 to a “low” of about 200. On one occasion, his readings changed from 0 to 195 in a single day, etc., meaning that one unit was probably less than 1/100 inch. 30) Five volumes of this work (Gunther, 1930–38), VI, VII, VIII, X, and XIII, are devoted to that Oxford man, Robert Hooke; they were published between 1930 and 1938, bracketing the tercentenary year of Hooke’s birth, 1935. Volume VI contains Waller’s Life of Hooke which he appended to the edition of Hooke’s Posthumous Works he published, as secretary of the Royal Society, in 1705. Extracts from John Ward’s Lives of the Gresham Professors (Ward, 1740) and Aubrey’s Brief Lives have been interleaved. The rest of Vol. VI is a summary of Hooke’s scientific work up to 1672 drawn from Birch and from Derham (1726). Gunther’s Vol. VII continues this chronology to Hooke’s death in 1703. The Cutlerian Lectures are reprinted in Volume VIII, while Volume X is devoted mainly to the second Diary (Diary II) 1688–93, but also contains Hooke’s early work An Attempt for the Explication of the Phaenomena, in facsimile. Finally, Volume XIII contains a reprinting of the Micrographia, in facsimile. 31) Which overlap the latter stages of the first Diary. 32) In addition to the published diaries, there are several small fragments, October 1681 to September 1683, and 1 June 1695, in MS. Sloane 1039, covering about three months of 1695. These are found in Gunther, Vol. VII, pp. 577, 591–2, 600–602, 605?, 622, and 759 (Sloane MS 1039). The Diary entries from 1681– 83 (all except the last one) were found on narrow slips of paper. They resemble the earlier Diary in their laconic character, as do those in MS. Sloane 4024, from 1688–93. The individual dates are 25 Oct. 1681, March 1682, 18 July (bday)-1 November 1682 (13 entries), 27 December 1682, 22 September 1683. The final fragment (VII, 759) for June 1, 1695, just before Hooke’s 60th birthday, is in a much more fleshed-out narrative style, e.g., «I stayd with Mr. Blount and Mr. Hally from 8 to neer 12 a’clock, then went and dined at the Roman in Queen Street, with Sir Christopher Wren, Mr. Blount, and his cozen Mr. Aldersey . . . » 33) Full title, Philosophiae Naturalis Principia Mathematica, or Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy.
Annotations
29
34) Including, of course, Birch’s summary in his volume IV. We now, as of 2006, have Hooke’s rough minutes from 1677–82 (see Chapter 4) but there isn’t very much new there. 35) Whether there was, or indeed is, more to the Diary, is beyond our ken. Though the second Diary, as it exists in the Sloane collection, begins on 1 November 1688, suggesting either the initiation of a new book or, alternatively, a new resolution, that portion concludes on 9 March 1690, not quite a year and a half later. It resumes, as always without comment, on 5 December 1692 and a review of what we know of Hooke’s life from the Society’s archives shows nothing that might offer an explanation. Similarly, the final entry on 8 August 1693 gives no clue that writing will not resume the next day. Altogether an enigma, though it may mean nothing more than that material was scattered after Hooke’s death. 36) In his life of Hooke, appended to the Posthumous Works, Waller refers to Hooke’s Diary entry following his legal victory over Cutler on 18 July 1696. This entry is not now known to exist. 37) Referring to friends Alexander Pitfield, Richard Waller, Godfrey Copley, and Francis Lodwick, all F.R.S. On Lodwick, see Salmon (1972). The “o” implies nothing of interest happened at Jonathan’s Coffee-House. 38) Pepys’ diary spans a decade in 11 volumes, while Hooke’s gives us a similar span of daily entries in just over 450 pages, as published. 39) Thursday, November 20, 1763. Which we are to read, in modern terms, as “Hevelius’ book,” or “Helvelius’s book.” The meetings were then being held in Arundel House. 40) 7 June 1674: «Wrote against Hevelius.» 21 June: «Prosecuted Hevelius.» 41) This was just before Hooke wrote his fateful letter to Newton, on 24 November 1679, (Corresp., pp. 297–8.) asking for Newton’s opinion on his idea that planetary motions consist of a motion by the tangent and a central attraction. This problem was much on the minds of Hooke, Wren, and Halley, and eventually the latter went to Cambridge early in 1684 and posed the problem to Newton. See Chapter 10. 42) These are principally the Council Minutes and the Journal Books. 43) Garaways Coffee-House was in Exchange Alley, Cornhill. Exchange or “Change” Alley is still there in the Cornhill area, between Cornhill and Lombard Streets, close by the Royal Exchange. Jonathan’s, also in Exchange Alley was also visited almost daily, and in the second Diary, covering 1688–93, it was the favored venue. See below. See also the section on taverns and coffee-houses in Robinson and Adams (1935) and Gunther’s comments in the preface to vol X (Gunther, Op. Cit.). 44) Boyle lived with his sister (Katherine, Lady Ranelagh) in fashionable Pall Mall. Maddison lists some of Boyle’s neighbors, including Nell Gwyn (p. 133). In the Diary, Boyle is always “Mr. Boyle,” and Wren is “Dr. Wren” or “Sir Ch.
30
Chapter 2. Robert Hooke, Indefaticable Genius Wren,” showing – even in his private diary – a respect for the stations of his friends Wren and Boyle, in stark contrast to some of the wilder claims made about Hooke, namely that he violated the gentleman’s code when he used terms like “knave” or “cur[r]” to describe people like Oldenburg or Cutler, who he felt had treated him falsely. He seemed to respect social niceties without resentment or any puffery.
45) Collins to Gregory, 26 December 1672, Corresp. I, 255 n. 17. Westfall also says that Hooke was suffering from consumption and was not expected to survive, but this is based on the letter from Collins to Gregory. The Diary begins in August 1672, and Hooke is indeed unwell, as he often was, but he was vigorously active and it seems that Collins was mistaken as to the seriousness of Hooke’s latest malady, although they had seen each other in October. 46) Indeed a high proportion of these angry remarks refer to masons, bricklayers (Samuell), surveyors, and others with which he worked. 47) «Demanded of Sir J. Cutler my money. He fooled.» 13 August 1674. Cutler had met his obligation to Hooke in the 1660s, but became disenchanted when the Society and Hooke changed the focus of the lectures, which he had intended to be on the history of trades. 48) Respectively, these entries occur on 6 March 1674/5, 20 January 1675/6, 8 November 1675, and 26 May 1677. 49) For example, on Oldenburg: 5 March, 25 March, 8 April, 10 June, 8 November, all in 1675, when their relationship had hit bottom, as well as 20 January 1675/6 and 26 May 1677. 50) On Brouncker, 8 April, 29 April, and 10 June, also 1675. Also many complaints about Hill (treasurer) and Grew. Hill was born the same year as Hooke, but outlived him by 18 years. See also fn. 63. 51) On Wren, see 25 May 1675, 1 June 1675, 10 December 1675; Boyle, 3 November 1675, and 5 February 1678. On 5 October 1680 he writes «Aubrey impudent.» Some have expressed shock over the occasional grumbling about Wren or Boyle, but these were clearly momentary annoyances. 52) Though that did happen occasionally, as Hooke records. Fellows of the Society often met at the Crowne Taverne in Threadneedle Street after meetings at nearby Gresham College. Evidently it was a reputable house. Boyle was a fixture at Society meetings in the early years of the Society. 53) Examples: «At the Colledge . . . At St. Stephens, Walbrook. Bow, Paules.» Referring to the College of Physicians, which Hooke designed, St. Stevens, Walbrook, Mary Le Bow, St. Paul’s, being constructed by Wren, but with some assistance from Hooke. Occasionally he met with Wren three times in a single day.
Annotations
31
54) Lisa Jardine’s 2003 Wilkins Lecture, entitled “Dr. Wilkins’s Boy Wonders,” addressed Wren and Hooke, among others. 55) Lisa Jardine has suggested that neither «formed a lasting relationship with any other person,» a statement which one might want to modify somewhat in Hooke’s case, but is nevertheless substantially true. Much has been written on Wren’s architecture, of course, but a compact source of information about him and his works is Wren by Margaret Whinney (1971). 56) As one of the City Surveyors, as Wren’s partner, and in his own architectural projects. He was Wren’s colleague on the Commission which oversaw the rebuilding of the City. The Court picked Wren, Pratt, and May as members of the Crown Commission and the Corporation of the City of London chose Hooke, Mills, and Jarman. The commissioners appointed by the Rebuilding Act of 1670 were Wren, Hooke, and Edward Woodroffe. Woodroffe died in 1675. Evidently Wren and Hooke were the most active and effective members of the Commission and Wren would soon become Surveyor General. Wren and Hooke both offered radical plans for a new London, and Evelyn offered his own. None of these plans was adopted, tradition and commercial and political considerations holding sway; most of the chaotic plan of the old City was retained. On Hooke’s role in designing and building these churches, see Paul Jeffrey (1996). Between 1671 and 1684, Hooke was apparently working on an average of 8 churches at any given time. 57) See Chapter 10. Hooke, as we shall see, had believed in universal gravitation since 1665. 58) For example, 4 January 1689; 21 January, 28 February, and 1 March 1690 (those cold damp winters!). On 17 June 1693 he was «weary,» and a month later (14 July) he was «sad.» Again, on 7 August he was «weary.» 59) Some accounts describe him as a “miser” in his last days, irrationally afraid of being penniless while hoarding a fortune.
“This page left intentionally blank.”
Chapter 3
Promoting Physico-MathematicalExperimental Learning: Founding the Royal Society of London Except for the early formative years in Oxford, Hooke’s entire scientific life was devoted to the Royal Society of London. It defined him, and to a considerable extent, he defined it. Initially only the Society’s first Curator of experiments – a position he held for nearly four decades – Hooke soon became the lifeblood of the Society in the critical early years when it was struggling to establish itself as, essentially, the world’s first professional scientific society.1) And while natural philosophers and mathematicians had gained positions at court in various ways, many had patrons, and some held university positions, Hooke, as the first scientific “employee” of the world’s first scientific institution, deserves to be considered the first professional scientist. With this in mind, it would make little sense to think of understanding Hooke’s career as a natural philosopher without first studying the Society itself, its origins, who its members were and therefore who were his colleagues, how meetings were conducted, Hooke’s own role in those meetings, and the difficulties encountered by the Society as it struggled through its first three decades. In doing so, we will not give any special attention to Hooke’s science per se, which will be the focus of Chapter 7. The group that would be chartered as the “Royal Society” on 15 July 1662 had actually been formally meeting for nearly two years, having been founded after a Wren lecture in late November of 1660 as civil unrest began to ebb following the Restoration.2) But very much the same group had been gathering informally in Gresham College for a year or so before that, until, as the Protectorate breathed its last breath, meetings were suspended in 1659. And it had earlier predecessors going back more than a decade, as we shall see. But according to John Aubrey, referring to the last year or so of the decade, the group first «mett at the Bull-head Taverne in Cheapside, till it grew to big for a Clubb.» Following which, «The first beginning of the Royal Society (where they putt discourse in paper and brought it to use) was in the Chamber of William Ball, Esqr . . . They had meetings at Taverns before, but
34
Chapter 3. Founding the Royal Society of London
’twas here where it formally and in good earnest settup: and so they came to Gresham College parlour.»3) These modest beginnings were further foreshadowed by groups that met in London as early as the 1640s and then in Oxford in the following decade, so it is hard to draw the line and say «here the Society originated.» These earlier groups, who helped create the climate leading to the formation of the Society, included the Royal College of Physicians, which was a kind of model for the Royal Society, John Amos Comenius’ “Invisible College,” which involved men like Boyle and Wilkins who would found the Royal Society, but also important figures like Samuel Hartlib, the “great intelligencer of Europe” and mathematician John Pell. The Baconian Comenians shared members with the most important of the organized groups, the so-called “1645 group,” which met in London in the Civil War years.4) Important members included the mathematician John Wallis, Wilkins, Dr. Jonathan Goddard, Dr. George Ent, and Theodore Haak. According to Wallis, by 1648 the group had begun to break up, as several members, including Wallis, migrated to Oxford under the religious pressures of the period5) . John Wilkins had gone to Oxford as Warden of Wadham College in 1648 and immediately began attracting scientific scholars around him, Seth Ward being among the first. Soon Laurence Rooke, William Neile, the young Christopher Wren, and others joined him. This scientific circle which formed around Wilkins and the others was augmented by William Petty, Thomas Willis, Dr. Jonathan Goddard, Matthew Wren, and Ralph Bathurst, all later important members of the Royal Society. Barbara Shapiro has observed of Wilkins that «wherever he was . . . it was there that the nation’s most creative and active scientific circle came into being.»6) Two of the most important figures he attracted were Wallis and the young but already illustrious Etonian Robert Boyle (Fig. 5) who Wilkins induced to move to Oxford in 1655–6, when he was still short of thirty; Boyle would stay in Oxford for more than a decade. This group, which met at the lodgings of Petty, then Wilkins, and finally Boyle, known to us as the “Oxford Society”, “Oxford club,” or “Oxford Philosophical Society,”7) actually met for four decades, despite the fact that important members had long since moved back to London, on the eve of the Restoration. Many of its members came from the earlier group who had accompanied Wilkins to the relative security of Oxford in 1648–9, following the execution of Charles I.8) Like the earlier Invisible College and the 1645 Group, the Oxford club was a largely informal one, lacking officers, written minutes, or a journal.9) According to Thomas Sprat in his History of the Royal Society, speaking of the Oxford society, «their meetings were as frequent, as their affairs permitted: their proceedings rather by action, [than] discourse; cheifly [sic] attending some particular Trials, in Chymistry, or Mechanicks: they had no Rules nor Method fix’d: their intention was more. . . to communicate to each other. . . their discoveries, which they could make in so narrow a compass, [rather] than an united, constant, or regular inquisition . . . Their manner likewise, is to assemble in a private house, to reason freely upon the works of Nature . . . »10) And «they continued [meeting] without any great Intermissions, till about the year 1658. But then being call’d away to several parts of the Nation, and
Chapter 3. Founding the Royal Society of London
c National Portrait Gallery, London.) Fig. 5: Robert Boyle, after Kerseboom. (
35
36
Chapter 3. Founding the Royal Society of London
the greater part of them coming to London, they usually met at Gresham College, at the Wednesdays, and Thursdays Lectures of Dr. Wren, and Mr. Rooke . . . »11) Thus, as the Protectorate crumbled and the monarchy was on the verge of being reestablished, many of the Oxford group had returned to London, including Wren and Wilkins, some, like Wren and Rooke, to become Gresham Professors, a migration that led to the founding of the new society only months after the Restoration. This did not happen immediately as, according to Sprat «. . . they were scattered by the miserable distractions of that Fatal year[1659] . . . till the continuance of their meetings there might have made them run the hazard of the fate of Archimedes: For then the place of their meeting was made a quarter for Soldiers.»12) Notwithstanding Wallis, who claimed a direct and continuous evolution from the informal “1645 group”13) to the Royal Society, thus placing its origin in London, we can reasonably think of the Royal Society as emerging from a reuniting of the two parts of the 1645 group, those who moved to Oxford, many of them Royalists, and those who stayed behind in London.14) If Sprat’s History, published in 1667 while the Society was still very much in its infancy, is the most direct source of information on its founding, one has to keep in mind that Sprat was a prot´eg´e of Wilkins, the figure around whom the Oxford circle formed and chair at the first meeting of the new Society, and thus was something of an apologist for the Society.15) The informal meetings at Gresham apparently went on, during term, for more than a year – despite the disruptions of the final days of the Protectorate – and it was following a Wren lecture at Gresham on 28 November 166016) that twelve of the group retired to the rooms of Laurence Rooke, Gresham Professor of Geometry and Wren’s predecessor as Professor of Astronomy, where «something was offered about a design of founding a college for the promoting of physico-mathematical experimental learning.»17) They agreed to meet weekly, initially on Wednesdays at 3 in the afternoon18). Wilkins was appointed to the Chair at this first meeting, and William Croune, register, or secretary. A list of 37 additional persons who «if they desire it, might be admitted before any others» was drawn up, and at the second meeting a week later, Sir Robert Moray noted that the King (Charles II), had been informed of their action and had offered encouragement.19) At the meeting following, Moray again reported the King’s approval, and Wren was asked to prepare an experiment for the next weekly meeting. Moray was chosen the Society’s first president on 6 March. Such were the modest and hopeful beginnings of the Royal Society, which would have to wait for a year and a half for its Royal charter. From the beginning, fellows of the Society were to be admitted only by election, and it was declared that «no person should be admitted into the society, without scrutiny, except such as were of, or above, the degree of baron,» something that was reaffirmed in October 1662. The 49 persons either present at the first meeting or offered immediate admission included many, if not most, of the figures who would dominate the Royal Society for the next two decades.20) Membership would be limited to 55, but again «. . . any person of, or above, the degree of baron might be admitted as supernumeraries . . . »21) Sprat explained that men of all religions and professions were admissible, but that «the farr
Chapter 3. Founding the Royal Society of London
37
greater Number are Gentlemen, free, and unconfin’d,» by which he meant the freedom from having to earn a living. He continued that «If any caution will serve, it must be this; to commit the Work to the care of such men, who, by the freedom of their education, the plenty of their estates, and the usual generosity of their Noble Bloud, may be well suppos’d to be most averse from such sordid distractions.»22) Hooke, of course, was not one of those «gentlemen, free and unconfin’d,» but rather at the time an apprentice to Boyle and soon to be making his living entirely as an employee of the Society.23) Not surprisingly, the class-consciousness expressed in Sprat’s words had a downside, for it meant that at any time a significant fraction of members were essentially gentlemen dilettantes, indulging themselves in a fashionable diversion. It also caused discomfiture for Hooke, who had no clear social position. Moray, with his ties to the crown, had been principally responsible for the royal charter, and had also presided at early meetings, but Viscount Brouncker was chosen to be the first president when the Society was officially Chartered as the “Royal Society” in July 1662. Brouncker would hold the office for 15 years. Wilkins and Henry Oldenburg became the first secretaries, a position the latter would hold until his death in 1677.24) Although Wilkins had been at the center of the Oxford group and had presided over the first meeting of the new society, with his former connections to Cromwell, he would have been too controversial to be a choice for president shortly after the Restoration. The twenty members of the Council were a sort of “who’s who” of the early Society, including Moray, Boyle, Wallis, Wren, Wilkins, Oldenburg, Kenelme Digby, Paul Neile, William Petty, Jonathan Goddard, John Evelyn, and Thomas Henshaw. There was one Lord (Brouncker) and four Knights of the Realm (Moray, Digby, Niele, and Petty), two doctors of divinity (Wilkins and Ward), three M.D.s, and one L.L.D. (Wren). All men of privilege. The first charter served less than a year, a second one being passed on 22 April 1663. The Society had its critics from the very beginning, including some from the College of Physicians whose members resented the Society’s forays into medicine. Others opposed or ridiculed the Society because natural philosophy was thought not to be a suitable preoccupation for a gentleman, or because it was imagined that it would lead to free thought and atheism. Still others thought that puttering with strange pieces of apparatus or debating arcane theories, such as the weight of the air, simply silly.25) Hobbes’ bitter dismissal is well known: «Those Fellows of Gresham who are most believed, and are as masters of the rest, dispute with me about their physics. They display new machines, to show their vacuum and trifling wonders, in the way that they behave who deal in exotic animals, which are not to be seen without payment. All of them are my enemies.»26) Critics like Henry Stubbe («a Man of as much Acrimony as Wit») urged Boyle to abandon the Society with the advice that «the only reparation you can make for that fatal error, is to desert it . . . »27) Stubbe was a vigorous opponent of the entire
38
Chapter 3. Founding the Royal Society of London
program of the Society’s alliance with Latitudinarian clerics, reflecting his distaste for a clerically dominated society and his advocacy of a return to a purer form of Christianity. 28) Another conservative Anglican, Robert South, was also a detractor, and when Wren’s Sheldonian Theater was dedicated in Oxford on 9 July 1669, South, as University Orator, took the opportunity to denounce the Society and the New Philosophy.29) But the support of the King30) and his chartering of the Society, along with the participation of important figures from the gentry, aristocracy, clergy, wealthy physicians, and other men of means and position, led to its gradually assuming an important role in the life of Restoration England. As we have seen, the young Society saw itself as thoroughly Baconian, and if Bacon’s philosophy was rather liberally interpreted by the founders, they certainly believed that what they were doing in forming a society for the promotion and establishment of a new philosophy of nature31) was an implementation of Bacon’s ideas. Indeed, Joseph Glanvill thought that «Salomon’s House in [Bacon’s] NEW ATLANTIS» was a «Prophetick Scheam of the ROYAL SOCIETY.»32) And in his History, Sprat wrote of «one great Man, who had the true Imagination of the whole extent of this Enterprise, as it is now set on foot; and that is, the Lord Bacon.» He continued that if his [Sprat’s] desires had prevailed «with some excellent Friends of mine, who engaged me to this Work: there should have been no other Preface to the History of the Royal Society, but some of his Writings.»33) Although Sprat seems to have fully equated the “experimental philosophy” with Bacon, he did offer some caveats.34) This Baconian antidote to the substantially a priori science of the Cartesians and the relics of Peripatetic or Aristotelian natural philosophy was doubtless needed, though rival views about what the mechanical philosophy actually was coexisted within the Society. It is an interesting and crucial fact that while the movement to found a new philosophy involved mainly university men at the outset, e.g., Wilkins, Ward, Wallis, Wren, and a number of others, that rather than being of the universities, it was in many respects an opposition to an antiquated curriculum, especially in science, that still clung to its Aristotelean roots. That the Society, as the vehicle for carrying out this replacement of the old by the new, came to be dominated, in membership and influence, at least, by gentlemen of means and status, including the clergy, reflects the way in which the movement comported with other tendencies in church and society after the Restoration. The new (mechanical) philosophy was seen as providing an explanation of the natural order of things, which would be an important tool in advancing moderate Protestantism and in combating atheism through what might be called natural theology. Some of its advocates, like Wilkins, Ward, and Barrow, prominent figures in the Society, were also influential Latitudinarian clerics who helped cement this bond between the mechanical philosophy and capitalist Christianity.35) At one and the same time, it supported a particular social ideology and fostered order in the political realm. Thus came into being effectively the world’s first scientific institution, the Royal Society of London, now nearly 350 years old. It had many trials and reverses ahead, but in just over a quarter-century it would be responsible for bringing into print New-
Annotations
39
ton’s Principia, whose only peers, perhaps, are Copernicus’ De Revolutionibus and Darwin’s Origin. The Society’s motto was, and is, “Nullius in verba,” “bound to no man’s word,” or “take no man’s word (for it).”
Annotations 1) Despite Italian antecedents which were not exclusively scientific in nature. The Accademia dei Lincei (Academy of the Lynx) was founded before 1603, but disbanded after Galileo’s difficulty with the church. It had a journal of sorts as early as 1609. The later Accademie del Cimento (Academy of Experiment) was founded in 1657 by students of Galileo, but it lasted only a decade and its briefly published journal was founded after the Transactions. 2) The story of the founding of the Royal Society of London «for the promoting of Physico-Mathematicall-Experimental Learning» has been told in detail elsewhere, making it unnecessary to give more than the bare outlines here. Indeed, Michael Hunter has asked whether there is anything new to be said about the Society (M. Hunter and P. Wood (1966). The authoritative contemporary account is that of Sprat, in his History of the Royal Society, written just six years after the Society’s founding (published in 1667), and under the direction of some of its founding members. For this last reason, however, its objectivity can be questioned. Recent works include: Purver (1967); Hunter (1989), Marie Boas Hall(1991), Stewart (1992), etc. The literature is vast. A. Rupert Hall’s introduction to Birch is also important. For background, the monumental work of Charles Webster, The Great Instauration (Webster, 1976) is indispensable, but for criticism of Webster’s thesis of an alliance between Puritanism and science, see Henry (1992). Hunter’s The Royal Society and its Fellows 1660–1700 (Hunter 1994a) is invaluable. 3) Quoted in O.L. Dick’s introduction to Aubrey’s Brief Lives, p. liii. One can, if he wishes, extend the line of descent further into the 1640s, e.g., the trio Thomas Harriot, Walter Warner, and Robert Hues, «the Earl of Northumberland’s three Magi,» or the Welbeck circle, which included Thomas Hobbes. See John Henry, «The Scientific Revolution in England,» in Porter and Teich, The Scientific Revolution in National Context, and references therein. 4) Some sources include Shapiro (1989) and references therein (e.g., p. 260), Purver (1967), Chapter 4. See also Webster (1976), Chapter II, “The Spiritual Brotherhood.” The idea of a “universal college,” or loose network of philosophers was widespread in the seventeenth century. But Comenius’ visit to London in 1641–2 under the sponsorship of William Hartlib provided the initial impetus that led to the Invisible College, the 1645 group, and eventually, the Royal Society. Apparently members of the Invisible College included Wilkins, Wallis, Boyle, Theodore Haak, and at least six others, all of whom were founders or early members of the Society. See also Stimson (1935) or Greengrass, et al.
Chapter 3. Founding the Royal Society of London
40
(1995). Boyle’s sister, Lady Ranelagh, was very much involved with the circle around Hartlib. See Jardine (2002), p. 88. 5) Wallis’ accounts appear in his “A Defence of the Royal Society,” and in “Account of Some Passages of His Own Life,” which appeared in Thomas Hearne’s edition of Peter Langtoft’s Chronical in 1725. Charles I was executed in 1649, leading to the Republic and in four years Cromwell and the Protectorate, and Puritan ascendancy. This lasted less than a decade. Oxford was in Puritan hands when the moderate Wilkins went there as Warden of Wadham College, but he attracted both Puritan and Anglican (royalist) scholars. 6) Shapiro (1969), p. 125. 7) The “Oxford club” seems not to have had a formal name, but is often referred to in contemporary documents as “the clubb.” 8) Sprat lists Ward, Boyle, Wilkins, Petty, Matthew Wren, Wallis, Goddard, Willis, Bathurst, Christopher Wren, and Rooke as «the principal, most constant of them.» 9) It did have a set of rules governing its activities, however. See Purver (1967), p. 111. It evidently thrived, however, having, according to Seth Ward, about 30 members in 1652. See Robinson (1949). 10) Sprat, p. 56. 11) Wren and Rooke were joined by Brouncker, Brereton, Neil, Evelyn, Henshaw, Slingsby, Clark, Ent, Ball, Hill, Crone, and others. Sprat, p. 57. Wren became professor of astronomy in 1657, when Rooke switched from that post, which he had held for five years, to Professor of Geometry. Wren left Gresham to become Savilian Professor of Astronomy at Oxford in 1661, and Rooke died in 1662. 12) Sprat, pp. 56–8. Sprat wrote to Wren that «This Day I went to visit Greshamcollege, but found the Place in such a nasty condition, so defiled and the smells so infernal that, if you should now come to make use of your tube, it would be like Dives looking out of Hell into heaven.» Sprat described the building’s “noisesome condition”, and wrote of “infernal smells” and other indignities . . . Sprat to Wren, Parentalia, p. 254. Archimedes, it is traditionally said, was slain by a Roman soldier in Syracuse as he worked on a problem in geometry. 13) Wallis made this claim in 1678, some thirty years after the fact. The 1645 group was Boyle’s “Invisible College”. See Birch, I, 2. 14) Barbara Shapiro’s John Wilkins (Shapiro, 1969) contains a good summary pp. 25–28. 15) In his introduction to Birch, Rupert Hall compared Sprat and Thomas Birch’s History by saying that «while Thomas Sprat had taken for himself the role of the Royal Society’s apologist, Birch assumes that of its chronicler.» 16) Wren had been named Gresham Professor of Astronomy in 1657.
Annotations
41
17) Whence the title of this chapter. Birch, I, p. 3; Record of the Royal Society, p. 7. Rooke’s contributions as a natural philosopher were primarily in astronomy, and especially astronomical methods for determining longitude. See Ronan, 1960. 18) The Society met at Gresham College until 9 January 1666/7, when, following the Great Fire, it moved to Arundel House. The Society met there for over six years, but at a meeting of the Council on 9 Oct 73 was invited back «by a committee of the professors of Gresham College and another of the Mercers company.» At the time, the Earl of Norwich «could not but take it very unkindly» if they should move from Arundel. He later relented, and on 6 November, the Council decided to move, largely to be near Hooke’s rooms, where he could more easily offer experiments. The Society’s space at Gresham College is described in Johnson (1940). Typically meetings commenced at 3 in the afternoon. 19) Moray (or Murray), a Royalist who went into exile with Charles I in 1646, was instrumental in obtaining a royal charter for the society. Moray’s connections were undoubtedly the reason why he became the Society’s first president, rather than, say, Wilkins, with his relation by marriage to Cromwell. Boyle also had ties to the monarchy; his sister-in-law, Elizabeth Killigrew had a child by Charles II in 1648, when Boyle was 21 (Jardine, 2002). 20) Present at the first meeting, according to the Journal Book, and as reported by Birch, were Viscount Brouncker, Robert Boyle, David Bruce, Paul Neile, John Wilkins, Jonathan Goddard, William Petty, William Balle, Laurence Rooke, Christopher Wren, and Abraham Hill. The list of forty included Digby, Evelyn, Henshaw, Ward, Wallis, and Oldenburg, along with, for some reason, Boyle and Wren who were already present. Croune was picked as “register,” though absent (a not uncommon occurrence even then?). Boyle was proposed on 26 December, along with Oldenburg. Was it his well-known reluctance to sign an oath that had delayed things? 21) It was also proposed that members of the College of Physicians and of the science faculties of the two universities be admitted as supernumeraries. Birch, I, pp. 5–6. In editing Birch, Rupert Hall lists the fellows in the 1663–87 period, that is, after the second charter of 1663 (22 April). He also gives the members before the second charter who were not reelected. One of the original members, Lawrence Rooke, died in 1662, as did John Gauden. Hunter (1994). 22) Sprat, p. 68. 23) At least until 1666 or 1667, when his duties as surveyor began to provide as much income, or more. Hooke accumulated over $8000 in about 35 years, an average of over $200 per year, far more than the $30–50 provided by the Society or the $80 he had been promised. 24) The name, Royal Society, was suggested by John Evelyn. Between its founding and the Royal charter, Moray usually presided over Society meetings, but sometimes Wilkins, and even Boyle were in the chair. Brouncker was an important mathematician who played a significant role in mathematical developments
Chapter 3. Founding the Royal Society of London
42
involving the quadrature of curves, infinite series, continued fractions, and so on. He was also Chancellor to Charles II’s queen, Catherine. 25) Thomas Shadwell’s The Virtuoso of 1676 parodied the experimental philosophers of the Royal Society. Hooke’s Diary for 2 June describes his attendance at the play: «With Godfrey and Tompion at Play. Met Oliver there. Damned Dogs. Vindica me Deus. People almost pointed.» He comments again the next day. See Chapman (1996). 26) Hobbes, Dialogus Physicus, 1661, 1668, p. 236–7. See Shapin and Schaffer (1985), Chapter IV. Boyle, in turn, attacked Hobbes in his “Animadversions on Mr. Hobbes Problemata de Vacuo” of 1674. 27) R. Palmer, quoted in Maddison (1969), p. 137. Stubbe to Boyle, 4 June 1670. Maddison, p. 138; See also Appendix B in Sprat, on Stubbe’s attacks. 28) Stubbe’s strongest attack on the Society and Sprat’s history of it came in A Censure upon Certain Passages contained in the History of the Royal Society. The definitive work on Stubbe is Jacob (1983). In particular, his Chapter 5 focuses on the Royal Society. Conflicting views on some of the issues raised there have been given by Hunter among others: Hunter (1994), p. 16, n. 3 and Hunter (1990). In this work we can only hint at the complexities which are revealed in studies such as these. The bibliography and references offer some guide to the literature. 29) Wallis to Oldenburg, 16 July 1669. Glanvill to Oldenburg, 19 July. CHO, VI, 129–30 (letter #1246), pp. 137–8 (#1248). Glanvill’s letter also addresses Stubbe’s attacks. The Hall’s notes to these letters are, as usual, full of information. 30) The King himself was known to ridicule the Society. Pepys’ records that he «mightily laughed at Gresham College, for spending time weighing of ayre, and doing nothing else since they sat.» Pepys’ diary, 1 February 1663/4. For other critics, see Record of the Royal Society (1940), pp. 40–44. 31) «For improving of natural knowledge,» in its own formulation. 32) Glanvill, Scepsis Scientifica, 1665, John Owen, ed., London, 1885, p. lav. Quoted in Sprat, p. xii. Bacon’s New Atlantis was published three years after his death, in 1627. 33) Sprat, p. 35–6. 34) Sprat cautioned that «whoever has fix’d on his Cause, before he has experimented; can hardly avoid fitting his Experiment, and his Observations, to his own Cause, which he had before imagined, rather than the Cause to the truth of the Experiment in it self,» p. 108. Furthermore, referring to the founders of the Society, «as their purpose was, to heap up a mixt Mass of Experiments, without digesting them into any perfect model . . . and whatever they have recorded, they have done it, not as compleat Scheames of opinions, but as bar, unfurnis’d Histories.» Sprat, p. 115. Nonetheless, Sprat did acknowledge that after a «severe
Annotations
43
examination of the particulars,» the new method must not rest there; rather «It must advance those Principles, to the finding out of new effects, . . . from experimenting to Demonstrating and from demonstrating to Experimenting again.» Sprat, p. 31. Others in the Society were more concerned about unguided experimentation including the mathematician William Niele. See Hunter and Wood (1966), p. 52–3. 35) This passage reflects Margaret Jacobs’ reading of the evidence from the period of the Restoration (Jacob, 1976). For a different skeptical view, see Henry (1992), pp. 190–202. Ward became Bishop of Sarum (Salisbury), and Wilkins Bishop of Chester. Isaac Barrow, Newton’s sponsor, was a noted sermonizer.
“This page left intentionally blank.”
Chapter 4
Society of the Muses: The First Decade1) The importance of the Royal Society in the early scientific revolution is reflected in the detailed studies of its activities during the first several years of its existence which have been written, centering on the kinds of investigations that were carried out, how they were witnessed and registered, and how they supported, or were interpreted in terms of the mechanical philosophy. In this chapter we summarize the activities and challenges of the new Society during these early years, always keeping in mind the fact that our particular interest is in Hooke and his role in it, even though we will devote our attention to the Society itself, rather than Hooke per se. The central issue of Hooke’s science and how it was facilitated, or sometimes hindered, by his position as Curator, will be the subject of a subsequent chapter. In this chapter we will concentrate on the period 1660–1672 because these were the formative years of the Society, when it was defining what it was, when it had to establish a sustaining membership, and was attempting to devise a continuing experimental program and cultivate an extensive foreign correspondence. It also had to overcome in this “decade” the almost simultaneous blows of the last gasp of the plague in 1665–6 and the Great Fire of London in September of the latter year. As regards Hooke, this period coincides almost exactly with his first ten years with the Society, 1662–72. It also concludes just as Newton appeared on the scene for the first time, which provides a kind of natural break, and it is also in 1672 that Hooke began to write his Diary, which sheds light on Society affairs in the following decade. In its first years, the Society addressed all manner of inquiry into nature, according to the interests of members, with little regard to any program or plan of investigation. Some issues were pursued more systematically than others, an important example being pneumatics, which reappeared at frequent intervals, many of the experiments being initially provided by Boyle, but Hooke was involved in these and other experimental work almost from the outset. Among other early issues addressed at meetings was Brouncker’s interest in the recoil of guns, a practical topic which came up frequently for a while, and a whole
46
Chapter 4. Society of the Muses: The First Decade
host of technical issues including siphoning, primitive chemistry, and early magnetic experiments with lodestones, but also speculation about insects, poisons, vipers, including their supposed generation from a powder made from their livers and lungs, and so on. There was strong and continuing interest in the natural history of foreign lands, clearly reflecting the burgeoning trade and exploration with far corners of the Earth. The wonders that Hooke revealed in his exquisite drawings of objects viewed with his microscope caused a sensation when the drawings (Fig. 6) and the work of natural philosophy he built around them, the Micrographia, were published. Hooke’s honored place in the history of microscopy comes less from his contributions to the design of the microscope, which were modest, than from his discoveries with it – including his discovery of the plant cell – which were the stimulus for a long correspondence between the Society and the Dutch microscopist Leeuwenhoek, starting in the 1670s. Studies with the simple pendulum, which would be an ongoing interest of Society members, appear almost at the very beginning, in late 1661. The pendulum was intrinsically interesting in the way that what would later be thought of as living and dead force (our kinetic and potential energies) would be interchanged, but for the most part these explorations were motivated more by the need for accurate timing, particularly at sea, where the issue was navigation and the precise determination of longitude. This was an interest of the King, who consequently encouraged Hooke’s work on time pieces.2) It was also an enthusiasm Hooke shared with his great contemporary, and in many ways, competitor, Christian Huygens, whose career paralleled his in major respects. Huygens’ interest in the pendulum went far beyond its use in time-keeping, important as that may have been, but then so did Hooke’s. Hooke’s theory of the «rising of water in slender glass-pipes» (capillarity), which led to his first scientific paper, was debated by the Society in mid-1661 and Sir William Persall «entertained the society with some magnetical experiments» in early 1662. Magnetism would be a persistent interest throughout the decade and indeed much later, though little progress would result. It would not emerge from this descriptive stage for a century and a half, when the relationship between currents and magnetism was discovered. There was much interest in practical knowledge, including the character of varnishes, the making of cloth from sheep’s wool, the production of marbled paper, making tar and pitch, the sounding of depths in the sea, wine production, minerals, coal mines and wind-mills, etc. Indeed much of the business of the early Society had a very practical or utilitarian character to it. Although an inventory of the issues in which the Society was interested shows remarkable diversity, one must admit that most questions were not pursued very far. Only in a few cases can these inquiries be said to have led to a real understanding of a specific phenomenon. Not untypical of some of the chimera pursued by the Society was a story recounted by Wilkins of «a maid in Holland, who voided seed by urine, which being sown grew,»3) and Robert Southwell provided the Society with «a great horn, said to be an unicorn’s» the next year. One cannot emphasize too often, however, that natural philosophy in this early period was very much in an immature cataloging
Chapter 4. Society of the Muses: The First Decade
Fig. 6: Hooke’s drawing of a female gnat from Micrographia of 1665.
47
48
Chapter 4. Society of the Muses: The First Decade
or “taxonomic” stage, in which standards of proof were still being worked out and it was not clear which phenomena were real or important, and which were not. Not infrequently some astronomy crept in, particularly regarding Saturn and its rings, which was very much a topic of interest in this period; Jupiter, especially phenomena of its Galilean satellites; occasionally a comet; and there were regular accounts of eclipses. Although very much a descriptive science at this stage, astronomy was of interest for its own sake, and had been since the early work of Harriot and Horrocks, but the issue of determining longitude arose in this context as well. In an attempt to develop an experimental program, fellows were initially urged to bring in experiments themselves, and in April 1662 we find that «It was resolved, that every member of the society shall consider against the next meeting of some experiment, which he will undertake himself.» But seven months later (5 November) with only a modest response, Robert Moray was proposing the employment of a curator to provide some direction and to prepare experiments. Hooke, already known to many of the Fellows as Boyle’s assistant, was picked (though it was some time before his position was made official) and in only two weeks provided his first experiments. From the beginning he was charged with preparing «three or four» experiments for each meeting. This allowed him some latitude to pursue his own interests, though frequently there was clear direction from fellows, resulting, once again, in a somewhat haphazard and undirected collection of experiments. But until Hooke’s attentions began to be diverted elsewhere by his work as surveyor and architect, Society meetings became more focused, often centering on one of his experiments or an explication of one. He would provide these demonstrations, off and on, for the better part of 40 years, but frequently there was tension between these duties and other obligations he assumed over time. Before long the Society felt the need to again examine the experimental program to see how it might best be carried out, and in 1664 it decided to organize itself around eight committees, including one for collecting and registering observations and experiments. In late April 1663 the Society received its second charter from Charles II,4) marking a new beginning for the Society, which had the document read before them on 13 May, after which a Council was chosen. A week later, on 20 May, 114 individuals were registered as fellows of the Society. It was in that same spring that Wren presented the Society with a model of what would become the Sheldonian Theatre in Oxford, marking the start of his turn away from natural philosophy and the beginning of a long and distinguished architectural career, a career which would heavily involve his friend Hooke. A nascent interest in the natural history of the earth on the part of the Society was exhibited in discussions of petrified wood, involving especially Hooke and William Brereton. Hooke would return to these issues again and again, treating changes in the earth as dynamical processes to be understood, and rescuing them from the realm of pure speculation. Considerable attention was also given to the ability of fish to survive out of water, and in the problems of sounding the depth of the sea and in bringing up water from the depths, to which purpose Hooke proposed some contrivances in September 1663. Such issues were a part of a wider interest in the properties of the air, how it enabled
Chapter 4. Society of the Muses: The First Decade
49
respiration, and how it supported fire. In November 1663 Moray suggested using a thermometer to determine «the degrees of heat in a man’s body in fevers . . . ,» but «the physicians present conceived, that there would be little certainty in it.» There was continued interest in pneumatic experiments, including the troublesome problem of the “anomalous suspension” of water,5) first noted by Huygens in 1661 and revealed by him in a letter to Moray in January 1662. This episode is an important one for several reasons. In principle it called into question the accepted theory of the way in which a mercury or water column was supported by the weight of the air,6) but because the experiments were being carried out in London and on the continent, often with differing results, it raised thorny issues of reproducibility or replication and therefore witnessing. Huygens had found that if water that had been purged of air was used in a water barometer, and the device was placed in a receiver from which a substantial portion of the air was removed by pumping, the water would tend to remain suspended rather than descending with the lowered pressure as expected. The same thing was sometimes observed with a mercury barometer as well. This phenomenon, which was at first found difficult to reproduce in England, was used by one side (Huygens’) as an indication of a good vacuum, and on the other (Hooke, Boyle) as a sign of an inadequate or poor one. Air-pumps of disparate designs yielded different results, and there was no adequate theory to explain either the presence of the phenomenon, or its absence. It was in the midst of this dispute that Hooke became Curator, in November 1662. Continued failure to reproduce the suspension in London either with water or mercury led Huygens to come to London the following May, and he and Hooke worked, perhaps side by side, into August.7) On only this single occasion would these two founders of modern science interact productively. Anomalous suspension of water was finally successfully accomplished at Gresham College, with Boyle later showing that the effect could be obtained even without using an air pump. The suspicion arose that the diameter of the tubes (“canes”) employed in the experiments might be crucial. In early 1663/4 it was ordered that any experiment ought to be repeated, «for the sake of more accuracy and certainty,» reflecting a growing understanding of the importance of multiple trials in any experimental investigation. The Society took its role of “publicly” witnessing experiments very seriously, and occasionally it was called upon to provide novel experiments for some special event, or to divert the King. At about the same time, the Society became interested in having cadavers to dissect (by Drs. Goddard, Charleton, and Clarke), marking the start of a series of physiological experiments involving living animals, cadavers, and in a case or two, living humans. And for the first time the Society gave thought to publishing books written by its fellows. One of the first beneficiaries would be Hooke himself. It also took interest in Chelsea College for the first time, eventually leading to its acquisition and in due course, lengthy efforts to make use of it, and eventually to dispose of it.8) Although it was granted to the Society in the third Royal Charter of April 1669, hopes that it would provide a permanent home for the Society never materialized. At the end of 1664, the Society was exploring Huygens’ idea of a universal measure, a standard of length which would be defined by a simple pendulum of spec-
50
Chapter 4. Society of the Muses: The First Decade
ified properties, though the idea goes back to Mersenne in 1644.9) Of special interest was the “seconds pendulum,” which Hooke and Brouncker found had a length of 3 feet 1 23 inch, and later almost exactly 39 inches.10) The second could not be given a precise empirical definition until the pendulum clock of Huygens was invented and calibrated against astronomical sources. Experiments in generating “air” by applying aquafortis to oyster-shells11) caught the Society’s attention in the first few months of 1664/5, representative of an early interest in what we know as chemistry. Boyle and others devoted much of their time in the laboratory to such studies at a time when the distinction between chemistry and alchemy had little meaning. On the astronomical side there was considerable interest in comets, the stimulus in this case being the comet of 1664, which had been observed by Hooke, Huygens, the Danish astronomer Hevelius, and others. A common theory was that comets traveled in straight lines, a view held by Huygens, Hevelius, Wallis, and for a while, Wren, though never, apparently, by Hooke. Hooke would speak and write extensively about comets, notably in his “Cometa”, published in 1678, based on the comets of 1664 and 1677, and his “Discourse of Comets” of 1682, which only reached print over two decades later in his Posthumous Works. We will have more to say about Hooke’s astronomy in due course, but it is interesting to note here that while he did make some observations of comets, most of his extensive writing is devoted to their nature and structure and the implications for natural philosophy. On 1 March 1664/5, the Council declared that the Philosophical Transactions, to be edited by its secretary Henry Oldenburg, should be printed on the first Monday of every month, starting a run that, except for a hiatus in 1677–82 due to Oldenburg’s death and Hooke’s taking over as Secretary, continues to this day. Number 1 is dated 6 March 1664/5, and contains a reference to Hooke’s observations of Jupiter.12) For well over a decade, while handling the difficult job of managing the Society’s correspondence, Oldenburg dutifully published the Transactions, from which he derived much of his income.13) For all practical purposes the first true scientific journal, the Philosophical Transactions did not actually become an official publication of the Royal Society for over a century (1776), when it took on the name Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society.14) The journal would overcome repeated obstacles during its first forty years of publication, but survives today as the oldest (almost) continuously published scientific periodical. In the midst of a discussion of cold, stimulated by Boyle’s Experimental History of Cold,15) which came out in April 1665, perhaps elaborating on Moray, Hooke proposed a standard for heat and cold, which is generally considered to represent the first calibration of a thermometer, though with only one fixed point (the freezing point of water) it was a modest advance. Boyle was still coming to London for most meetings, though he was no longer on the Council. He would move from Oxford back to London to reside with his sister in Pall Mall in 1668, and would live there, where he had his laboratory, for the final 23 years of his life. By late June 1665 the rampage of the plague had forced the Society to adjourn its meetings indefinitely and none were held during the next eight months, finally
Chapter 4. Society of the Muses: The First Decade
51
resuming on 14 March 1665/6; Philosophical Transactions Nos. 6–8 were published in Oxford during this recess. Many members left town, including Hooke, who joined Petty and Wilkins in retreating to Durdens near Epsom in Surrey, where they engaged in experimentation.16) Others, like Wallis and Boyle, experimented in Oxford, or wherever they resided,17) and some members met informally in Oxford during the fall of 1665. Wren took the opportunity to travel abroad, especially in and near Paris, mostly studying architecture, but Oldenburg remained in his house in Pall Mall near Boyle’s sister’s (Lady Ranelagh), and noted that the pestilence had affected the neighborhood, which also included Brouncker’s residence.18) By the end of November deaths had declined by 90% and in January many were beginning to return to London. The Council resumed meeting on 21 February and the Society itself met three weeks later. We might recall that Newton was gone from Cambridge for almost precisely the same period, from sometime in the summer of 1665 until March 1666. The plague not having fully run its course, he soon left again, returning almost a year later.19) What happened in Wolsthorpe during that period is the stuff of legend. But the Society boldly met through the summer of 1666, only to be greeted by a new disaster, when on Sunday, 2 September, the Great Fire started in Pudding Lane.20) Unlike the pestilence, the fire was no respecter of status, devastating many of the wealthier parts of the city, including the highly commercial Cornhill area. (Fig. 7). But also unlike
Fig. 7
Map showing the area devastated by the Great Fire of 1666. Gresham College is denoted by T, and the Cornhill area is at the left center. By permission of the Guildhall Library, Corporation of the City of London.
52
Chapter 4. Society of the Muses: The First Decade
the plague, the loss of life was very low, perhaps under 20 individuals, despite enormous property damage. Under the heading 5 September 1666 (the day the fire was quenched), when the Society would have met, we read that «the Society could not meet by reason of the dreadful fire in London.» Gresham College was spared, being on the northeastern edge of the devastated area,21) but use of the undamaged College by City officials prompted an invitation from Charles Howard for the Society to move its meetings to Arundel House, in the Strand, west of the burned area. Hooke, with no other option, managed to retain his rooms in Gresham, but the Society had to look elsewhere and in November the Society was still having problems with a meeting-place, and after giving some consideration to other alternatives, including York House and the possibility of moving to Westminster, it accepted Howard’s offer and began meeting at Arundel House in January.22) A consideration was that Gresham College was thought by some to be of too great a distance from «the habitations of the greatest number of the society» and «very inconvenient to meet in, especially in the winter season.»23) On the other hand, a move would make it difficult for Hooke to transport delicate equipment for experiments at meetings,24) and the Society would return to Gresham within the decade. At the meeting of 19 September 1666 Hooke offered a plan for rebuilding the City, on the heels of proposals already submitted by Wren and Evelyn. Hooke’s differed from theirs in that it was first presented to the Society rather than to City Officials or to the King,25) but eventually all the plans, each of which involved major realignment of the winding streets of the old City, were rejected, with the result that the layout of present-day London – the City, that is – largely mirrors the plan of midseventeenth-century London. Many have deplored the lost opportunity, but at least as many have breathed a sigh of relief that the historic layout of the City survives to this day. The fire disrupted publication of the Transactions for a time and destroyed unsold copies which had been stored at St. Paul’s, and it also dealt the final blow to the old medieval cathedral,26) which was soon razed, in large measure at Wren’s advice. The printer Martin (Martyn) resumed the role of the Society’s publisher with Transaction No. 21 in January 1666/7.27) In the same month, in making its move to Arundel House, the Council decided to move its meetings to Thursday, from 3 to 6 in the afternoon.28) In the spring of 1667 there were discussions of Sprat’s History, which would be published later in the year, and on 23 May it was reported that Margaret, Duchess of Newcastle, desired to attend a meeting of the Society, and she was duly entertained by a series of experiments performed for her at the next meeting. This auspicious occasion must have represented the first attendance of a woman at a meeting of the Royal Society. On 4 December 1666, Moray, recognizing the rather incoherent program of experiments and demonstrations at meetings, proposed that the Council address the question of whether they ought to consist of, «a continued series of experiments, taking in collateral ones, as they were offered, or by going on in that promiscuous way, which had hitherto obtained.»29) Perusal of the minutes or Birch’s History makes evident the somewhat haphazard approach to experimentation, due largely to the lack
Focused Energies: The Laws of Motion
53
of any program other than the fancy of the members and, perhaps, that of Hooke, the Curator. At one point, «considering the want of experiments at their public meetings,» the Council thought to present a medal to fellows for each experiment they produced.30) If the Society had some difficulty establishing a coherent program of experiments at meetings, certain issues continued to be pursued with some consistency, perhaps even doggedly, including the phenomena of the tides, especially by Wallis, various applications of pendula, mostly by Hooke, the nature of magnetism, and so on. Much of the Society’s preoccupation from the latter half of 1666 into the spring and summer of the next year was with issues of anatomy and various kinds of transfusion of blood from one animal to another.31) There was continued interest in astronomical questions, but not much of a coherent program. On 19 December 1667, Oldenburg reported on some observations of «spots lately discovered in Mars» by Cassini and the inference that the planet rotated on its axis. Hooke had reported the same phenomena 21 months earlier, deriving a period of rotation of about 24 hours, but neither he nor Oldenburg are recorded as noting that fact.32) In early 1666/7 the issue of Cutler’s promise to pay Hooke $50 per annum was addressed seriously for the first time, and on 27 September, the Society took possession of Chelsea College, hoping that it might become the site for a «college for their meetings,» but in fact would be little more than an albatross.33) An attempt to solicit funds from wealthy members for a building, possibly near Arundel House, was begun the following January and by May $1000 had been subscribed. On 22 June Hooke produced a draft of the building and was ordered to look into the buying of the materials and of contracting with workmen. Henry Howard, the Society’s host at Arundel House, also provided a drawing. Construction was deferred to the spring of 1668/9, and, as with the Chelsea College episode, in the end came to nothing. On 10 October Sprat’s History was presented to the Society by John Wilkins. There was some feeling that Sprat was long on generalities and short on detail, a view Oldenburg expressed to Boyle, and Joseph Glanvill’s Plus Ultra of the following year was intended to meet this objection.34) The Society first gave thought to transfusing blood into a man in the same month, imagining that it might be «most advisable to try it upon some mad person in the hospital of Bedlam.»35) Soon the Society had a volunteer who, for a guinea, would allow sheep’s blood to be transfused into him, and the experiment was quickly tried. The minutes note that the experiment was «made in a great crowd of spectators, which would not admit of that exactness, which was designed . . . » Somewhat surprisingly, the man is noted as having survived, though for how long is not recorded. Although it seems not to have been a major interest of his, and indeed he seems to have found it somewhat distasteful, Hooke was frequently called upon to carry out animal experiments, on his own or with Dr. Richard Lower.
Focused Energies: The Laws of Motion At the first meeting after the summer recess, on 22 October 1668, Hooke proposed « that . . . experiments of motion might be prosecuted, thereby to state at last the nature
54
Chapter 4. Society of the Muses: The First Decade
and laws of motion . . . » This suggestion was immediately taken up by the Society, and was the beginning of a concerted attack on the problem of collisions, heretofore dominated by Descartes’ clearly inadequate theory,36) that went on into the spring of 1669. In many respects it was a unique event in the Society’s early history, which more typically saw a somewhat haphazard program of experiments and demonstrations. At the next meeting, Hooke followed up with a that «experiments be made to see, whether all hard bodies, that rebound, do not so upon the account of having springy particles in them . . . »37) And on 5 November, after an experiment allowing a feather to fall in an evacuated vessel, he suggested experiments «to determine the question concerning the communication of motion.» Interestingly for an organization which held its Baconian heritage in such high regard, the Society responded to Hooke’s suggestions by inviting Wallis, Wren, and Huygens to offer their theories of collisions, thus overlooking the young Hooke, who was evidently not seen as a likely source of theoretical insight into the dynamics of collisions. Further, President Brouncker, ever the good mathematician, even suggested that the experiments Hooke proposed might be unnecessary, since both Huygens and Wren «had already taken great pains to examine that subject, and were thought to have found a theory to explicate all the phaenomena of motion.» Perhaps not the best example of the Society sticking to its Baconian principles. So it was decided that Oldenburg should write to Huygens and Wren to see if they would communicate their «speculations and trials of motion» to the Society. Undeterred, Hooke proposed to resurrect experiments which had originally been carried out two years earlier, involving the collision of balls suspended by fibers, and he again speculated that the rebound of hard bodies might be due to their having “springy particles” in them.38) The experiments were soon performed, and Hooke was ordered «to think upon other experiments for the making out of this hypothesis about motion, which is that no motion dies, nor is any motion produced anew.»39) It was also moved «that since the society was upon the disquisition of the nature, principles, and laws of motion, all authors, who had written on that subject, and delivered their hypotheses concerning it, might be consulted and examined, and an account of their opinions brought in, to see, what had already been done in this matter.» By 12 November Wren and Huygens had responded,40) John Collins was asked to study what Descartes and others had written on the subject, and Oldenburg was to solicit a discourse from Wallis. Hooke continued his experiments on the springiness of bodies, but the experimental investigation which he had originally proposed continued to be pushed in a strongly theoretical direction. But if he was relegated to the role of testing the theories of Wren, Wallis, and Huygens, Hooke was, in fact, interested in the deeper questions of dynamics, including the cause of rebound, as opposed to a merely kinematic description. At the meeting of 26 November Oldenburg announced the receipt of Wallis’ paper on the general laws of motion, and a fortnight later another letter from him was read. Hooke was still experimenting on rebound at that meeting, but he was ordered to provide experiments specifically to test the theories of Wallis and Huygens. Wren’s theory was presented on 17 December, and Hooke was again urged to perform
Focused Energies: The Laws of Motion
55
experiments to verify the theories, but, perhaps belatedly, was also asked to share his own ideas «on the cause of springiness.»41) According to Birch, others, including Brouncker, Ward, and Hooke himself, also had “considered” the subject. Hooke was being listened to, but was not in the favored galaxy of Huygens, Wren, and Wallis. Huygens’ contribution was read on 7 January and he soon provided additional papers on the subject which were distributed to Brouncker, Ward, Wallis, Pell, Wren, Neile, Croune, and Hooke for comment, and Wren’s own “hypothesis of motion” was ordered to be printed in the Transactions.42) Apparatus failure cut short attempts to test Huygens’ and Wren’s theories in late January, but on 4 February trials were successfully carried out on Wren’s theory. A letter from Huygens acknowledged that his and Wren’s theories were “conformable,”43) and his interest in how Wren had proved his theorems prompted an exchange of ciphered forms of their discoveries, which were duly recorded in the Society’s Register Book. On 18 February experiments were carried out with “springy” bodies, again to test Wren’s theory of motion, and interest continued into April, with Croune also being asked to test Huygens’ four rules of motion.44) A year later the relationship between Huygens and the Society was so close that Huygens made provisions for some of his papers to be delivered to it in the event of his death, which at one point he thought might be imminent.45) This study of collisions, or more generally, of “the laws of motion,” which we have followed in some detail, is a rare example of a topic pursued by the Society in a coherent, sustained way, in this case for the better part of a year, effectively ending when the Society adjourned in July for the summer.46) It was further unusual in the extent to which the theories of Wren, Wallis, Huygens, and Brouncker dominated over experiment. Hooke’s proposal to carry out experiments to determine “the nature and laws of motion” had stimulated an enormously fruitful dialogue which had shown the inadequacy of Descartes’ rules for elastic collisions, and had led to the correct ones for perfectly elastic or perfectly inelastic collisions (Wallis’ “soft impact”), based essentially on Descartes’ conservation of “quantity of motion.”47) There was even some consideration of the quantity mv2 , Leibniz’ vis viva, in which Huygens had long been interested, and in this connection Hooke attempted an experiment to show that «the strength of a body moved is in a duplicate proportion to its velocity.»48) These experiments, one employing a pendulum with variable weight and length of fiber,49) and the other, measuring the velocity of falling water as a function of distance fallen, were first attempted on 7 January, apparently failing because of frost «disordering the instrument»50) , but were conducted successfully at subsequent meetings. Hooke carried out another experiment two weeks later (28 January), designed to establish «that a body, once put in motion, would move perpetually, if it met not with resistance,» not a novel idea to be sure, but one that could bear careful testing by an original and talented experimentalist. In experiments carried out in February it was noted that the effect of the resistance of the air on the motion of a pendulous body depended on the “arch” through which the body moved, that is, the displacement and hence the speed. It was also found that «the impediment to motion decreased in a greater proportion than the decrease of the velocity.»51) Further experiments were tried in the late winter of the
56
Chapter 4. Society of the Muses: The First Decade
following year, which proposed to compare the behavior of a pendulum in a vacuum with one oscillating in compressed air.52) At the time, Hooke was working on a “magnetical watch,” which employed a magnetic balance which evidently consisted of a magnetic needle oscillating in a magnetic field, and was driven or restored by a spring. He was also interested in the way the «magnetical power decreases at several distances.»53)
Concluding the First Decade Despite these fruitful studies of 1668–9, and indeed in the midst of them, the Council and the Society as a whole decided in February to establish two committees involving 16 active members «to advise and agree together about the best ways of carrying on this work to the satisfaction of the society.» Hooke was offered the services of an assistant, who would receive $5 per quarter, reflecting the fact that by this time he was well into his complementary career as commissioner, surveyor, and eventually, builder and architect, and that it was affecting his performance as Curator.54) The Journal Book reveals that on five occasions between June 1669 and November 1670 he was absent or unprepared to offer experiments.55) In April 1669 William Croune (or Croone) was asked to continue experiments testing the laws of motion, in preference over Hooke, it would seem, although he requested Hooke’s assistance. In May the dangers or benefits of ingesting mercury were debated, prompted by a query from the physician of the Prince of Tuscany. Boyle, among others, saw little harm, but the outcome of the disquisitions seemed equivocal. Many of the founders of modern science undoubtedly suffered mercury poisoning, including perhaps Boyle, Hooke, Newton, and even Faraday. At the same time both Wren and Hooke proposed grinding machines which would generate hyperboloidal and ellipsoidal surfaces, as a means of improving various optical devices. Discussions, sometimes involving foreign correspondents, continued through the winter, and attempts to get either Hooke or Wren to provide practical grinding machines continued into the next decade. Hooke dropped a real bombshell at the meeting of 15 July 1669 when he «intimated, that he was observing in Gresham-college the parallax of the earth’s orb,»56) a discovery which would have finally established the earth’s annual motion.57) We discuss this important question later, but suffice it to say at this point that during the previous spring he had found the time, despite all his other duties, to design and construct a zenith telescope at Gresham College for the purpose of making these delicate measurements. A year later, on 28 July 1670, he reported that, in the secretary’s words «he had already found so much, as to suspect some parallax of the earth’s orb, and conceived, that it would be more sensible a half a year later.» Further observations were not forthcoming (See Chapter 11). In the fall of 1669, a request from the King stimulated an interest in measuring a degree of arc on the earth’s surface. Hooke was a member of a committee of eight chosen to consider how to do this.58) The following June he was “ordered” to carry out the necessary measurements “in the next vacation.” Repeated promises and further
Concluding the First Decade
57
urging never bore fruit.59) One senses that it was not something that Hooke cared much about. There continued to be interest in the tides, especially Wallis’s theory, as well as in the variation of the compass needle from true north. Along with the problem of longitude, these issues were of special importance to an island and seafaring nation. On 24 November 1670 there was discussion, stimulated by a letter from Wallis, of the question of whether an object dropped vertically and one projected horizontally from the same height, would strike the ground at the same time. That this issue was still considered debatable shows that the implications of the Fourth Day of Galileo’s Two New Sciences had not been fully absorbed.60) Experiments performed in January and February were inconclusive. Perhaps the most interesting pneumatic experiments of late winter 1670/71 were the attempts to build a receiver large enough to hold a man, so that the effects of breathing lowered atmospheric pressure could be examined.61) Ever curious, Hooke chose himself as the first subject, finding «not any inconvenience upon the exhaustion of the little air drawn out of it.» In a further test, he reported that he had reduced the air pressure by 10% and «had felt no other inconvenience but that of some pain in his ears at the breaking out of the air included in them, and the like pain upon the readmission of the air pressing the ear inwards.»62) On 23 March he mentioned that he had stayed in the receiver for over 15 minutes with the pressure reduced by one quarter, with similar results, noting that a candle he had with him went out long before he felt any of «that inconvenience in his ears.»63) Word of Newton’s remarkable reflecting telescope had been circulating since 1669 and the Society’s interest in it prompted Isaac Barrow to provide it to the Society in December 1671. Immediately thereafter (at the final December meeting), in the secretary’s words, «Mr. Isaac Newton, professor of mathematics in the university of Cambridge, was proposed candidate by the lord bishop of Salisbury,»64) and he was elected at the next meeting, in early January. The telescope, which magnified 38 times, was quickly examined by several members, probably including Hooke, and it was demonstrated at the 18 January meeting, where it caused a sensation.65) But this was not to be the end of the matter. On the same day in a letter to Oldenburg, Newton widened his contacts with the Society by alluding to «a philosophical discovery,» being, in his judgement «the oddest, if not the most considerable detection, which hath hitherto been made in the operations of nature.»66) This was a reference to his experiments with light and color, which he began to reveal in a letter to Oldenburg on 6 February, read to the Society two days later.67) Newton had come out. Westfall writes that «Swept along by the success of his telescope, Newton stepped publicly into the community of natural philosophers to which he had hitherto belonged in secret.»68) For the next 15 years the relationship between Newton and the Society would be complicated, and with Hooke, full of tension. It would be 31 years before Newton would become its president, just a few months after Hooke’s death. After Newton’s letter was read by Oldenburg69) , Hooke, Boyle, and Ward were asked «to peruse and consider it, and bring in a report of it to the Society.»70) Hooke, who saw himself as, and indeed was, the Society’s expert on light, color, and optics, was quick to offer comments in a letter to Oldenburg the next week, though he «had
Chapter 4. Society of the Muses: The First Decade
58
not above three or 4 hours»71) for its perusal. Newton would not have to wait long to hear about them. Hooke at once disputed Newton’s interpretation of the experiments, and, somewhat inconsistently, argued that the latter had gotten his ideas on color from Hooke’s own Micrographia. As for Newton, this belated entry into public discourse had quickly proved contentious, and nothing was more distasteful to him than contention and controversy. Thus began a heated dialogue, mostly through Oldenburg as intermediary, which poisoned the relationship between the two of them – Newton and Hooke – even before it began. Newton’s theory stimulated a series of experiments throughout the spring, mostly by Hooke, largely confirming Newton’s results, and yet Hooke remained steadfastly unconvinced of the correctness of Newton’s interpretation of them, and said so. Newton’s initial reply by way of Oldenburg was guarded, but his full response, when it finally came in June, was vitriolic. Giving as good as he got, he would claim that Hooke’s theory of light was, to use Westfall’s words, «only an embroidery on Descartes’.» We devote a separate chapter to this interesting and important issue. The resumption of meetings in the fall of 1672 following the summer recess, saw a return to the old problem of anomalous suspension, which still had not been settled when Huygens’ paper on the subject was published in the Transactions in August, venturing the cause as aether pressure.72) As we have seen, the phenomenon had caused much consternation a decade earlier, centering around whose air pump was better, Huygens’ or Boyle’s. Because Shapin and Schaffer’s Leviathan and the Air-Pump73) is an extended examination of this and related questions, we will not consider it in detail. What followed was more correspondence, notably from Wallis, who was able to show that the pressure of the aether was not likely to be the cause.74) Hooke, with his experience with capillarity, as we now call it, might have been expected to offer this as an explanation. Thus concluded (whether in December or March) the year 1672,75) the tenth year of Hooke’s service as Curator, the year of the commencement of his Diary, of the death of Wilkins, of the admission of Newton to membership, and of the start of the lengthy quarrel between these two Restoration philosophers. The Society would have many hard years ahead, some of which are recounted below and in succeeding chapters as we proceed to describe Hooke’s career.
Annotations 1) Oldenburg to Hevelius, 18 Feb. 1662/3; CHO, Vol. I, letter no. 262. 2) Charles II also sponsored the career of the first Astronomer Royal, John Flamsteed, and the establishment of the Royal Observatory at Greenwich, designed by Wren and Hooke with Hooke playing a role in supervising construction. 3) Birch, 1, 53. 4) In which the name “Royal Society of London” is perhaps used for the first time, i.e., Sodales Regalis Societatis Londini. The 20 members, including the
Annotations
59
president Lord Brouncker, the members of the Council, and secretary Henry Oldenburg are alluded to in the charter. 5) The important issue of replication, which is the subject of Shapin and Schaffer’s Chapter VI (1985)), had never previously drawn so much attention. Since the air-pumps used in London and in Paris were not identical, there was a real question whether the same phenomena were being studied. 6) Going back to Torricelli (who invented the mercury barometer in about 1643), or earlier. 7) It was in the late spring of 1663 that Huygens visited the Society for the second time, Wren showed his plans for the Sheldonian Theatre, the Society’s second charter was issued, and the Council met for the first time. In June Hooke was elected a Fellow. 8) Beginning as early as 9 March 1673/4. See the footnote in Birch, 1, 391. 9) The Society’s first expression of interest was in 1660. 10) When the meter was defined in France in 1791 as the ten-millionth part of the distance from the equator to the pole, the result was very close to the length of the “seconds pendulum” (sensu Hooke), and in fact the meter was first defined in 1790 as the length of a pendulum with a period of 2 seconds. This arises 2 from the fact in the modern √ that g/π (MKS) is very nearly unity. The period sense is 2π l/g, so that T = 1 sec implies l = (1/4)(g/π 2), or about 1/4 m (9.8 inches). But the “period” of the “seconds pendulum” was being measured by Hooke (and most others) from one extreme to the other, that is, one half the period in the modern sense, hence l = T 2(g/π 2 ) ≈ 1 m, since T = 2 s and l = 39.15 in. Hooke obtained the value 39.05 inches (.99 m)in December 1664 (Birch, I, 511) in an experiment performed at Lord Brouncker’s residence. In 1660 Huygens settled on the value of 9 12 inches (translating to 38.0 sensu Hooke) for the length of the seconds pendulum; he was thinking of the full period. In a letter to Boyle in 1664, Hooke described a 180-ft pendulum erected in St. Paul’s cathedral as performing “each single vibration” in 6 seconds, which, again, is one-half the period; the latter he described as a “turn and return.” (Hooke to Boyle, 25 August 1664; see Hunter, et al. (2001). The calculated value is 7.4 seconds. Although the second was 1/86,400th of a mean solar day, the mean solar day is not an empirical quantity. Before Huygens’ pendulum clock there could be no standard for the second, and even with the pendulum clock, the definition is thoroughly circular. That is, the second is one-half the period of the seconds pendulum, whose length is a meter, which was defined in terms of the seconds pendulum. The situation was resolved when the French defined the meter in geographical terms. 11) The “air” or gas produced was carbon dioxide, resulting from the reaction of aquafortis (nitric acid) with what was essentially calcium carbonate.
60
Chapter 4. Society of the Muses: The First Decade
12) The title page has “Philosophical Transactions: giving some Accompt of the present Undertakings, Studies, and Labours of the Ingenious in many considerable parts of the World.” The first number consisted of summaries, or abstracts, in Oldenburg’s words, of a number of philosophical events and discoveries, including Hooke’s noting of a spot on Jupiter, comments on Boyle’s Experimental History of Cold, observations of a comet by a corresponding member Azout, and a list of the publications of the late Pierre de Fermat. The early Transactions are available in facsimile reprint form by Neiuwkoop, Amsterdam (1963–4), and now on the internet via JSTOR. 13) For details one should consult M. B. Hall (2002). Oldenburg’s job was especially difficult in the dangerous years of the mid 1660s, when correspondence with Europe might be suspected of containing political intelligence, and indeed such a suspicion did fall on Oldenburg at one time or another. 14) See the discussion in the previous chapter. There were ephemeral publications before the Philosophical Transactions, and for a century, the PT were not officially a publication of the Society. 15) Presented to the Society as New Experiments and Observations touching Cold, on 12 April 1665. 16) On 7 August 1665 Pepys passed through Durdens on the way to London. He reported that «I found Dr. Wilkins, Sir William Pettit, & Mr. Hooke contriving Chariots, new rigges for ships, a Wheele for one to run races in, & other mechanical inventions, & perhaps three such persons together were not to be found elsewhere in Europ, for parts & ingenuity.» Boyle also spent about a month there with Hooke. See Jardine (2004), pp. 113–117. On 21 March 1665/6 Hooke lectured on gravity experiments he had done in a deep well “near Banstead Downs” in Surrey. Hooke found his attempts to detect any variation in the weight of an object were defeated by the smallness of the effect, but discussed using a pendulum instead, and the analogies between gravity and magnetism. Birch, 2, pp. 69–72. 17) At the meeting of 14 March, Wallis was asked to tell the Society about the experiments that had been performed by members in Oxford the previous summer. Wallis, not being much of an experimental philosopher, deferred to Boyle, who was not present. 18) Indeed, Oldenburg wrote to Boyle on 10 August that he was putting his affairs in order. Hunter, et al. (2001), v, 330. Brouncker apparently also had a residence in Covent Garden (Pepys’ diary for 5 January 1665/6). 19) Westfall (1980), Chapter 5. 20) It has been been claimed that the fire was largely responsible for the end of regular plague irruptions in London. There were other factors, of course. The City was rebuilt in less than a decade. One accessible account is Milne (1986). 21) The fire came within not much more than 100 yards of Gresham. See Fig. 7.
Annotations
61
22) There had been meetings in the rooms of Walter Pope, Gresham Professor of Astronomy. 23) Charles was the younger brother of Henry Howard, who became Duke of Norfolk in 1677. He made the offer on 19 September (Birch 2, 114). The Society began courting Henry Howard at least by late November and elected him a Fellow on 28 November and to the Council two days later. In turn, he offered the Society his library on 2 January, «to be disposed thereof by them as their property,» and on 4 January, the Council accepted Howard’s offer to meet at Arundel House. Howard offered the Society land adjacent to Arundel House (near the Strand, where Arundel St. now is) upon which it intended to built its “College.” 24) Such a worry was expressed on 25 July 1667, for example. 25) Oldenburg told Wren that if his proposal had been submitted to the Society for its ratification, it would have given the Society «a name, and made it popular, and availed not a little to silence those, who ask continually, What have they done?» Oldenburg to Boyle, 18 September 1666. Quoted in Birch 2, 115. 26) Which, however, was graced with a somewhat incongruous colonnaded portico due to Inigo Jones. 27) No. 17, dated 9 September was printed by John Martin and James Alestry. When publication resumed in London, it was by “John Martyn.” Number 18, dated 22 October, was printed by John Crook in Duck Lane, Little-Britain; No. 19, dated 19 November, by «John Crook neer the Blew Anchor in Duck Lane; and Mose Pits [sic] at the White-Hart in Little-Britain;» No. 20, 17 December, by Moses Pitts alone. 28) Thursday meetings began on Feb. 14, 1667. By order of the Council on 10 April 1672, they were switched back to Wednesday, and the Wednesday meetings resumed on 24 April. On October 30, 1673, they again reverted to Thursday, where they remained until the beginning of 1681 (January 1680/81), the decision having been made on 2 December 1680 to return them to Wednesday. They remained there throughout Hooke’s life. 29) Birch, 2, pp. 131–2. To repeat, passages like this one are extracts from Birch, which are more or less verbatim transcriptions from the Journal Book of the Society. Hence, it is the secretary, in this case Oldenburg, who is paraphrasing Moray’s remarks. 30) Birch 2, 265. 31) Experiments which had begun in Oxford in the 1650s. 32) Hooke had discovered Jupiter’s “Great Red Spot” in 1666 as well. See Birch, 2, p. 98. 33) Negotiations, principally over legal issues, dragged on into December, but once the Society had the property, nothing was done to improve it, despite much hand-wringing. The Society only received the Royal patent in April 1669 (Birch 2, p. 363–71: «The new patent from his Majesty, dated April 8, 1669, granting
62
34)
35) 36) 37) 38)
39) 40)
41)
42)
43) 44) 45) 46)
Chapter 4. Society of the Muses: The First Decade Chelsea College to the society, together with some additional privileges and powers was read.» (13 May 1669) Charles II eventually changed his mind and decided to put it to a different use. In 1672 it was proposed to use Chelsea College as a prison. (Birch 3, 42). Birch indulged himself in a long footnote (600 words, more or less) on the matter (2, p. 297). Glanvill was rector of Bath Abbey (St. Peter and St. Paul). Plus Ultra was presented to the Society on 18 June 1668. Birch, 2, 202, 204. Lower’s experiments on dogs continued unabated. For example, his fourth rule of impact, which says that a smaller body impacting a larger one at rest cannot set it in motion. Ibid, pp. 315–16. This important insight was ventured at the meeting of 29 October 1668. Birch (2, 316) says that «Mr Hooke moved, that experiments might be made to see, whether all hard bodies, that rebound, do not so upon account of having springy particles in them . . . » Furthermore, «He conceiving, that if there were to be had a body absolutely hard, dots it would not rebound at all.» Birch 2, 315, 316, 318, 320. Three years earlier, a skeptical Spinoza had written to Oldenburg about his countryman Huygens as follows: «As for his treatise on motion, about which you also enquire, I think it is vain to expect it. It is so long since he began to boast that he had discovered by calculation laws of motion and laws of nature quite different from those of Descartes . . . yet so far he has given no example of this.» Spinoza to Oldenburg, fall 1665 (CHO, II, p. 541). Volume V of Oldenburg’s correspondence (CHO) contains a series of letters, mostly between Wallis and Oldenburg and between the latter and Huygens on the similarities among the theories of Wren, Wallis, and Huygens. An indirect exchange, via Oldenburg, between William Niele and Wallis on the laws of motion, is represented by several letters in the same volume. These continue into Volume VI. While some of Neile’s notions were clearly wrong, and noted as such by Wallis, others, especially those involving the motion of systems of particles, are quite interesting. For example, the letter to Oldenburg 1 June 1669 (Letter No. 1197, Vol. VI, CHO). Wallis’ contribution was published in the Philosophical Transactions, vol. iii, no. 43, p. 864, 11 January 1668/9; Wren’s paper immediately succeeded it, on p. 867, while Huygens’ was in vol. iv, no. 46, p. 925. Descartes’ ideas on elastic impact were presented in Part II of his Principles of Philosophy, in the form of seven rules. Huygens letter, in Latin, was published in PT, No. 46, 12 April 1669. Birch 2, 424. This episode was not, however entirely unique. One thinks of the long series of experiments in pneumatics, or the studies of blood transfusion, for example. The
Annotations
63
Society would adjourn in the heat of the summer, when, as Oldenburg wrote, «the greater part of polite society goes to the country for the long vacation.» Oldenburg to Huygens, 6 September 1669 (CHO, VI, 223). 47) Wren’s theory was based on a related postulate of his own. 48) Or «that the force in moving bodies is in a duplicate proportion to their celerities, so that there is required a quadruple weight to double to velocity.» This idea he presumably got from Huygens. It was William Willughby who introduced «ye summe of ye Q. of ye Velocities» into the discussion. Willughby to Oldenburg, 21 June 1669 (CHO, Vol. VI, pp. 63–4.). 49) Three trials were made with weights of 2, 8, and 32 oz. The lengths of the fiber supporting the masses were, apparently, in the same ratio, 1:4:16. This resulted in frequencies in the ratio 1:2:4 (12, 24, and 48 vibrations in a fixed time). Hence the velocities were in the ratio 1:2:4, showing that «there is required a quadruple weight to double the velocity.» A very nice experiment. In the other experiment, it was found that «the falling water was to be raised four times the height to run out with double the celerity.» Birch, 2, 339. 50) We note that this period was during what is sometimes called the “Little Ice Age,” a five century long period of unusually cold winters associated with a prolonged minimum in solar activity. See Fagan (2000). The Thames froze over several times in Hooke’s lifetime, including 1663, 1666, 1677, 1684, and 1695. There was an especially notable “frost fest” on the frozen Thames in the winter of 1683/4. See Evelyn’s diary. 51) An early recognition of the fact that air resistance depended more strongly on the velocity than linearly. 52) Birch, 2, 427, 429, 431–2. 53) Birch, 2, 350, 354–6, 359–360, 372, 374. 54) For example, the College of Physicians, which was begun at this time c. 1671). 55) «Mr. Hooke being absent, the experiments of motion were not prosecuted» (11 Feb. 1668/9); «Excused himself for having prepared no experiments . . . » (17 June 1669; «excused himself for not bringing them in, he having had some avocations of a public nature . . . ;» «Mr. Hooke being absent, the society, instead of experiments . . . » (10 Feb. 1669/70); «Mr. Hooke being absent from this meeting, no experiments were provided.» (24 Nov. 1670). For 2 December Birch records that «Mr. Hooke being called upon for the experiments appointed for this meeting, he excused himself for not bringing them in, he having had some avocations of a public nature, which had hindered him . . . » 56) Birch, 2, 394. He had two data points at this stage. See Chapters 7 and 11. 57) It is not out of the question that he might have detected what we call “stellar aberration,” the change in direction of a light ray from a star due to the earth’s
Chapter 4. Society of the Muses: The First Decade
64
motion through space, though his data hardly support this interpretation. See the discussion in the chapter on Hooke’s astronomy. 58) Birch, 2, 398. 59) In April 1671 he was promising «to do it within a month.» 60) Something Galileo claimed in his Dialogue in 1632. Though the contrary opinion, due to Fabri, was correct if one takes into account air resistance. 61) Described in a Journal Book entry for 9 February 1670/71. 62) Birch, 2, 469, 470. 63) This would correspond to an altitude of about 2500m, which certainly would not be sufficient to extinguish a candle . . . One wonders how accurately the pressure drop was measured. 64) That is, Seth Ward. Birch, 2, 501. 65) It was apparently the first to be constructed, but barely, and far from the first proposed. Newton got his idea from James Gregory’s Optica promota of 1663 but the concept of a reflecting (“catadiotrical”) telescope was considerably older, perhaps going back to Leonard Digges in the sixteenth century. On the other hand, the particular design, which we call “Newtonian,” was original. Newton’s may have been the first functioning instrument, but Hooke may have been the first to build a Gregorian telescope. See Corresp. I, 151–2. 66) 18 January 1671/2; Corresp. I, 82; Birch, 3, 5. 67) Corresp., I, 92–102 68) Westfall (1980), p. 237. 69) For which the author was «solemnly thanked . . . for this ingenious discourse . . . » Birch, 3, p. 9. 70) Hooke to Oldenburg, 15 February 1671/2, Corresp. I, 110–114. 71) Hooke to Brouncker, June 1672, Corresp., I, 198. 72) Huygens, PT, no. 86 (19 August 1672), 5027–30. 73) Shapin and Schaffer (1985). Readers of Leviathan and the Air-Pump will strive in vain to find any hint of the actual (which I do not put in quotes) explanation of this phenomenon, thereby being left to choose between the theories of Huygens, Wallis, Brouncker, and others. It cannot be irrelevant how closely, or distantly, seventeenth-century observers approached the explanation we now know to be correct. 74) Wallis to Oldenburg, 2 and 5 October 1672, CHO, Vol. IX, pp. 275–80. 75) That is, whether on 31 December or 24 March, the end of the year in the Julian Calendar.
Chapter 5
Crisis and Consolidation: 1672–1687 As the Royal Society embarked on its second decade, it went through a deep existential crisis as initial enthusiasms began to fade and two of its original and most influential members, Robert Moray and John Wilkins, died.1) More than half the members were in arrears and meetings had become lifeless, often because Hooke was occupied with his outside duties as surveyor and architect.2) Two other influential members, William Petty and Seth Ward, returning after having been out of town for long periods, were shocked by the state of the Society. Specifically the issue was «. . . the want of good experimental entertainment at their meetings, and from the neglect of the members in paying their weekly contribution . . . ». Vice-President Petty hoped «to put new vigour into the meetings of the Society,»3) proposing that fellows should be charged with bringing in experiments every week and that legal proceedings might be initiated against fellows in arrears. Soon the active members embarked on a plan of rejuvenation, centered around getting more members involved and in making subscriptions legally binding.4) The crisis came to a head in 1674, beginning with the wholesale ejection of members who were inactive or in arrears, and the discontent would eventually culminate in the removal of the Society’s long-time president, Lord Brouncker, in the elections of November 1677. Brouncker’s ouster came in the wake of Oldenburg’s death in September of the same year, an event which seemed to generate a much wider desire for change. Hooke evidently played a significant role in this “coup”, and we find in his Diary discussions in October, the intent of which was «to spread the Designe of choosing new president . . . »; he noted that «All things seem to goe on well for new president.»5) According to Hooke, those pushing for change included Wren, Hoskins, Grew, and Aubrey.6) Eventually Sir Joseph Williamson was chosen president, after both Wren and Boyle had been approached by Hooke, and presumably others, to see if they would serve.7) Hooke’s involvement in discussions over the direction the Society should take show that at this stage he represented a strong and independent voice, though there was still tension with other members, especially the treasurer Abraham Hill,8) but on occasion with the influential John Hoskins and Thomas Henshaw as well.9) In the election in which Brounker was replaced, Hooke
66
Chapter 5. Crisis and Consolidation: 1672–1687
was voted onto the Council for the first time and chosen co-secretary. Some reversals notwithstanding, he would be on and off the Council for the rest of his life. But despite these changes in direction, the Society would continue to struggle, prompting another round of reforms twenty years later, by which time Hooke was in failing health and not much of a factor. For reasons discussed in detail in Chapter 7, Hooke had become notably disaffected with the Society in the mid 1670s, but Oldenburg’s death and other changes in the Society had rekindled his enthusiasm, and he threw himself back into its discussions and provided regular experiments for several years (he had prepared hardly a dozen experiments in the three years previous to the secretary’s death). Publication of the Philosophical Transactions had been suspended shortly after Oldenburg’s death,10) and on 8 December 1679 the Council declared «that the secretaryies take care to have a small account of philosophical matters, such as were the Transactions by Mr. Oldenburg, and under the same title, published once a quarter at least . . . » Hooke, as Secretary, is quoted as saying that «he would see what he could do in it, but could not as yet undertake it absolutely.»11) He had, in fact, already begun to produce such a journal, for in October he had sent to the printer the first number of the Philosophical Collections, his answer to Oldenburg’s Transactions. Hooke’s decision not to simply continue the Transactions was undoubtedly motivated partly by a desire to distance himself from the journal published by his nemesis (see below), and with the benefit of hindsight this may seem ill-conceived, knowing as we do that except for this brief hiatus, the Transactions have been published continuously for over 300 years. Hooke, of course did not have that luxury, since when the last of Oldenburg’s Transactions were published two years after his death, they were only 14 years old. They were the creature of Oldenburg rather than an official journal of the Society, and Hooke was seeking a new medium for publishing «such Physical, Anatomical, Chymical, Mechanical, Astronomical, Optical, or other Mathematical and Philosophical Experiments and Observations;» that is, there was for him a real philosophical difference at issue. In 1681 he advertised that the Collections would come out at least once a month, and indeed the last five or six eventually did, with the final number coming out in April 1682,12) but the seven issues printed in nearly four years stood in stark contrast to Oldenburg’s average of over 11 Transactions per year. 13) It is not unlikely that had Hooke published the Philosophical Collections as faithfully as Oldenburg had done with his Transactions, he might have succeeded in replacing it. As it happened he did not. As co-secretary he initially was to handle the minutes and Nehemiah Grew the correspondence, although that was never entirely the case and on 26 December 1678 he was «desired for the future to keep the correspondence of the Society.» Thus, for a while, Hooke simultaneously held the two most important positions in the Society, other than the leadership posts, which at times were merely ceremonial. But Hooke’s diligence in maintaining the Society’s correspondence with continental scientists never equaled Oldenburg’s. He continued to be heavily involved in an array of architectural and construction projects, on his own and with Wren,14) and in addition to his work as Secretary, still functioned as Curator of experiments, indeed with a
Chapter 5. Crisis and Consolidation: 1672–1687
67
renewed enthusiasm. All this left him with less time for correspondence than Oldenburg, who had little else to distract him.15) The Letter Book (Early Letters) of the Society records only 15 letters written by Hooke during the five years he was Secretary (1677–82), though he certainly wrote more. Moreover, unlike Hooke, Oldenburg had not been a participant in the scientific investigations which were the subject of his correspondence, making him in a sense (at least superficially) more of an “honest broker,” a disinterested chronicler and communicator. On the whole, this was Oldenburg’s critical role almost from the founding of the Society until his death. By contrast, Hooke as Secretary not only was over-committed, but had already developed testy relationships with some of the Society’s continental correspondents, most especially Huygens, but Hevelius and Leibniz as well.16) His suspicion, justified or not, that his ideas were being stolen by others, must have further inhibited the free flow of information about Society affairs through the vehicle of his correspondence. By the time Hooke was given responsibility for managing the correspondence of the Society,17) exchanges with foreign members and other virtuosi had already declined substantially, and it would decline still further under him. And, as a measure of how thinly he was spreading himself, in July 1679 he was told to hire Denys Papin18) to assist him with experimental demonstrations. Finally, and reflecting dissatisfaction with his performance, but deeper divisions in the Society as well, Hooke was voted off the Council and replaced as secretary in the elections of November 1682, clearing the way for the resurrection of the Transactions. When publication was resumed in January 1682/3, the preface of No. 143, the first number of the new series, noted that «Although the writing of these Transactions, is not to be looked upon as the Business of the Royal Society: yet in regard they are a Specimen of many things which lie before them . . . And because, moreover the want of them for these four last years, wherein they have discontinued, is much complained of . . . » The 1680s saw a growing gap between the more traditional Baconians in the Society, including naturalists Martin Lister and Tancred Robinson, and those who advocated a mathematical description of nature, led by Oxford’s Wallis and eventually other Newtonians, as the implications of Newton’s Principia came to be appreciated, from the late ‘80s on. Dublin’s William Molyneux was especially dismissive of those who were «for rejecting all kinds of useful knowledge except ranking and filing of shells, insects, fishes, birds, etc. under their several species and classes.»19) The influence of Newton (as well as Huygens and other mathematicians) was already being felt. Reflecting this division, Robinson complained that the Society «may have great men in their numbers, but alas very little souls, and narrow minds . . . »20) The rapidly evolving science of medicine, increasingly yielding to a more experimental, analytical and quantitative approach, but still a prisoner of its history, was a notable battleground. On a more mundane level, Molyneux also noted that many of the Society’s problems were due to the fact that its secretary was elected annually, was often unpaid, and not infrequently was a casualty of Society politics, as happened to Hooke in 1682, his friend Richard Waller in 1709, and Hans Sloan in 1713.
68
Chapter 5. Crisis and Consolidation: 1672–1687
Chelsea College, acquired with great hope and anticipation, but now only a liability, was disposed of early in 1682 (1681/2), putting an end to the dream of a “philosophical college.” The Society had returned to Gresham College in 1674 after nearly a decade at Arundel House, and it continued to meet there until 1710, when it purchased the house of Dr. Brown in Crane Court, Fleet Street. It was in November of 1684 that the Society received a copy of Newton’s De Motu, sometimes considered a “first-draft” of the Principia, which resulted from Halley’s earlier trip to Cambridge. All of this is elaborated upon in Chapter 10. Shortly thereafter, at the annual election held on 1 December 1684, Samuel Pepys was chosen president, a position he would occupy for two years, just long enough to have the honor of granting the Imprimatur of the Society for the publication of Newton’s Principia, on 5 July 1686.21) In 1685–6 a constant concern was the drain on the Society’s resources caused by its decision to publish Willoughby’s History of Fishes, a situation that would cause some discomfiture to Halley, who would soon have to personally bear the cost of bringing the Principia into print.22) Clerk of the Society from the beginning of 1686, Halley was largely neglecting his own duties as he attempted to keep the Principia project – which he understood to be of monumental importance – on track. The contrast between these two projects, The History of Fishes and the Principia, highlights the schism in the Society which was coming to a head at the end of 1685, flaring up after the St. Andrew’s Day elections23) , when the newly elected secretaries, Tancred Robinson and Francis Aston, abruptly resigned.24) They, along with zoologist Lister, had been heavily involved in the printing of Willoughby’s work. Acrimony continued throughout 1686, with Halley under constant attack as he oversaw the printing of the Principia, which despite much controversy at the time, would ultimately decide the direction the Society would take,25) and in November an attempt was made to remove him from his post.26) As we saw earlier, Hooke’s first Diary effectively ends in 1680, picking up again only eight years later, so we have none of his views on this philosophical revolution in the Society, but he seems not to have been much involved in the dispute. Very much a Baconian, Hooke nonetheless had philosophical affinities with both sides and if there was no love lost between himself and Newton, Halley was a close friend. In June of 1686 the Council had ordered «that Mr. Newton’s book be printed, and that Mr. Halley undertake the business of looking after it, and printing it at his own charge . . . »! Poor Halley, whose financial situation was sufficiently precarious that he had accepted the job of Clerk for the Society, not only had to extract the Principia from a somewhat reluctant Newton – who had threatened to withhold Book Three – and personally edit it and prepare the woodcuts, but bear the costs of its publication as well.27) But without his position as Clerk, Halley might very well not have made the fateful trip to Cambridge in 1684 which led directly to the Principia (see Chapter 10). After that work appeared in April 1687, Halley suffered the further disappointment of having his salary paid in copies of the History of Fishes, in lieu of the $50 due him.28) Hooke, who was one of the five Council members present on the occasion of that decision, was offered a similar arrangement for payment of the
Annotations
69
arrears due him. Not surprisingly, he asked for six months to consider the offer, and since he was ordered paid $60 in currency in November and December, it seems that his decision was in the negative. John Vaughan, Earl of Carbery, succeeded Pepys as president in 1686, very nearly having his name on the title page of the Principia instead of Pepys. When Thomas Birch concluded his monumental History of the Royal Society nearly threequarters of a century later with the year 1687, he was implicitly recognizing the publication of the Principia as a watershed for the Society, at least from the perspective of his time.
Annotations 1) Moray died in 1673, the year after Wilkins. 2) Hooke’s responsibilities for the City churches began with the Churches Rebuilding Act of 1670, a responsibility he shared with Wren and Edward Woodroffe. 3) Petty, 29 September 1674, in Birch, III, 136. Petty made important contributions to the mathematics of taxation and to the nature of population growth, the latter in his “Essay Concerning Multiplications of Mankind” of 1682. 4) Hooke was interested in making criteria for membership in the Society more rigorous, though it is doubtful that such a reform would have been practicable in the late seventeenth century. See Royal Society Classified Papers, xx. 50, Folios 92–94, Document C in Hunter and Wood (1986), p. 87–92. 5) Hooke’s Diary records discussions about the presidency on more than a halfdozen occasions in October, and they continued into November. We also see Hooke beginning to campaign for the post of Secretary. 6) Diary I, 8, 9, and 11 October 1677. Grew is credited with isolating MgSO4 . 7) Diary I, 10 and 11 October 1677. 8) Hooke’s laconic Diary sometimes creates problems for the sleuth, as when, on 29 November 1677, he notes «At Crown taverne, Henshaw, Hill, Grew, Colwall, Hoskins, Hill, . . . » referring to Oliver Hill and Abraham Hill. The next day he notes that “Mr. Hill” was elected treasurer, and on 19 December he grumbles, «Hill a dog for Grew.» 9) One of the casualties of the commotion in the Society in the fall of 1677 may have been the relationship between Hooke and Sir John Hoskins. They were clearly good friends up until December of that year, when Hooke began observing that «Sir J. Hoskins not really my friend . . . », and “with Hoskins, noe true freind.» (26 and 28 Dec.). Things had improved by the following April, but there would be another crisis following the publication of the Principia. Yet Hooke joined Hoskins for coffee at Jonathan’s, usually as part of a larger group, in the period covered by both diaries, and Jonathan’s was often where Hooke and Henshaw met in the 1680s. Hoskins was president in 1682–3, and would
Chapter 5. Crisis and Consolidation: 1672–1687
70
preside over a large percentage of meetings, as vice-president, in the 1690s, when absentee aristocrats led the Society. 10) Six Transactions (Nos. 137–142) appeared in the year and a half after Oldenburg’s death, the last being dated Jan-Feb 1678/9. 11) Birch, 3, 514. 12) ‘Espinasse (1956) listed the contents of all seven Collections, published between 1679 and 1682. Only two were Hooke’s own contributions. 13) On March 1, 1665 Oldenburg was ordered to publish the Philosophical Transactions the first Monday of each month «if he have sufficient matter for it.» The first number was dated March 6, 1665. He published 136 numbers in the following 12 years, and six were published after his death before the Transactions were suspended in February 1678/9. That Hooke was still interested in resurrecting his Collections is indicated by three Diary entries in 1689. Following a discussion at Jonathan’s coffeehouse on January 9, Hooke wrote that he had mentioned «continuing Lectures & Collect, if Royal Society would pay for 60. Agreed by all.» Nothing ever came of this idea. See Johns (2000) for further information on Hooke’s Collections and his difficulties in having it printed. 14) Most of the secular rebuilding was done between 1668 and 1676, while the churches were mostly rebuilt after 1674. Construction was largely finished by 1690, except for steeples. Most of Hooke’s own architecture and supervision of his own buildings, took place in the 1670s: the College of Physicians, c1671– 79; Bedlam Hospital, 1674–76; the Monument, 1673–76. He spent considerable time on other projects, such as Bridewell Hospital(1671–74), Montague House, Ragley Hall, Willen church, and Aske’s Almhouses, Hoxton (1689–93]. See, for example, ‘Espinasse (1956), Chap. 5, Louw (2006), and Batten (1936–7). Greenwich Observatory is another important building project in which Hooke was involved, and though the extent of his role in the design and construction of the latter is not entirely clear, we do know that he was deeply involved in it. For example, on 28 July 1675 he wrote in his Diary: «To Greenwich. Set out Observatory.» In addition to references to laying out Greenwich which can be found in the Diary, see F. Willmoth (1991). 15) Though see Marie Boas Hall, Henry Oldenburg (M.B. Hall, 2002), for the latter’s various schemes for making a living. 16) In the case of Leibniz, the issue was his calculating machine, which Hooke chose to improve without, perhaps, giving due attention to his continental contemporary’s priority. Huygens, of course, had done the very same thing with Hooke’s balance-spring watch. And one could stretch the analogy to say that because Hooke gave Newton the key to the Principia that that prize was his. 17) «That Mr. Hooke be desired for the future to keep the correspondence of the Society; and that the same shall be continued by the help of a small Journal of some particulars read in the Society . . . And Mr. Hooke was desired to draw up
Annotations
71
a specimen of the said Journal propounded by him against the next meeting of the Council.»Birch, 3, pp. 450–1. 18) Papin, 12 years Hooke’s junior, had earlier been an assistant to Huygens, and worked with Boyle from 1675 until 1679, when he became Hooke’s assistant. He left London in 1687 for Germany. There he made important contributions to the nascent science of steam technology, including a high-pressure boiler and a proposal in 1707 for a ship to be powered by a “fire engine.” This issue, and the possibility that the source of Papin’s ideas may ultimately have been Thomas Savery, is discussed in Stewart (1992), p. 24, and references therein. Savery and Newcomen worked on the atmospheric engine simultaneously, with Newcomen consulting Hooke on pneumatic questions. So Hooke played some small role in the invention of the steam engine. Eventually, Newcomen developed the first practical steam engine, in about 1711. Papin died in poverty in London around 1712. 19) Molyneux to Halley, 8 April 1686. The letter was read to the Society at the 21 April meeting. Birch, 3, 479–9. 20) Feingold (2001), p. 89. 21) Though Halley, quite appropriately, had the honor of presenting it to the king. 22) The History of Fishes was completed by John Ray. 23) St. Andrew’s Day was (and is) 30 November. 24) «Without any apparent cause,» according to Halley. Halley to Molyneux (suppl. to letter-book, iv, p. 329). 25) For elaboration, see Feingold (2001). 26) Birch, 3, 505. 27) It is thought that approximately 500 copies of the first edition were printed (Cohen and Whitman, 1999). Halley was elected clerk on 27 January 1685/6. Although the clerk was supposed to be unmarried and childless, Halley was given a special dispensation since he had married in 1682. But his assumption of this paid position after his father’s death in 1683/4 required him to resign his fellowship in the Society for a time, since the clerk, who replaced the position of paid secretary, could not be a Fellow. It ought to be noted that, In contrast to what others have argued, Cook (1998) thinks that Halley had quite ample income in this period (at least $60 per year from his father, to begin with). 28) He received 50 copies, plus another 20 to cover another $20 owed him.
“This page left intentionally blank.”
Chapter 6
The Society After the Principia: 1688–1703 The Society continued to experience a malaise into the 1690s, with, as we have seen, a growing divide between the Newtonians and natural historians. At the anniversary meeting in November 1688 when elections ought to have taken place, there was no quorum; rescheduled in April, there were again too few votes.1) For a decade in the 1660s, Hooke’s experiments had formed the centerpiece of Society meetings, and then for nearly a score of years thereafter there often would have been little substance at meetings without the discussions he provided. But as the new decade opened, with his physical and intellectual vigor beginning to decline, Hooke was no longer able to carry the Society on his own. His experimental contributions had been waning for some time, even though his architecture and building activities were also winding down, and increasingly his comments at meetings were retrospective. By 1690 or 1691 his torch as the intellectual leader of the Society had begun to pass to Halley, even though there was hardly a meeting at which he did not speak, and even though Halley was often gone. 2) But as Halley slowly began to assume the role that Hooke had played for nearly three decades, he did so in a characteristic Halley manner. He was much more a mathematician than Hooke, and frequently his comments were on mathematical questions.3) But Hooke would continue to be an important presence for another decade, and he attended nearly every meeting even into 1701.4) In addition to Halley and Hooke, the names of Sloane, Hoskins, Southwell (president 1690–95) as well as Evelyn, Henshaw, and Hunt, are prominent in the minutes for the early 90s. Boyle, as was his wont, and in declining health, was rarely if ever present, but on 19 December 1688 «Mr Boyle sent his man» to perform an experiment, and he did the same three weeks later.5) The choice of Lord Montague (1695–98) and the Lord Chancellor, Lord Sommers (1698–1703) as presidents continued the recent practice of having an eminent figurehead leading the Society, leaving it without any real leadership at a crucial time when its membership was dwindling, and as Hooke faded and Halley spent much time abroad, it was drifting intellectually. Sir John Hoskins, as Vice-president, had
74
Chapter 6. The Society After the Principia
to preside over virtually every meeting for the better part of a decade, and he along with Sir Hans Sloane, who shared secretarial duties with Waller, provided what little direction there was. Newton’s eventual election as President in November 1703 restored scientific leadership to the Society; he would miss only three Council meetings during his first 20 years in office.6) Echoing the larger problems of the Society, the resurrected Transactions went through hard times in the late 1680s and early 90s, with only five numbers being published between December 1687 and October 1692, an average of one per year. And almost as though the Principia left everyone speechless, none at all were published in the years 1688–90.7) According to the Council minutes for 27 November 1689 Hooke offered «to print Treatises in the Nature of Philosophical Transactions» and it was agreed that the Society would purchase 60 copies if he did.8) Nearly a year later little progress had been made when the Council ordered that «. . . Mr. Hook have the postage of all Letters of Philosophical Correspondence allowed him on condition that he publish Transactions or Collections as formerly, and that in Consideration thereof, the Society will take off Sixty Books according to the Order of Council November 27th 1689.»9) As late as the following January Hooke reported of a meeting that there was «much talk of transactions to little purpose.»10) Despite what we can assume were good intentions, little happened, and the situation only changed in February 1692/93, when Waller announced he would be handling the Society’s correspondence and the Transactions as well; publication resumed, again at the rate of about one per month. Correspondence with the continent and other parts of the British Isles had also flagged, and in April 1691 it was ordered that «Dr Gale, Dr Aglionby, Mr Waller & Mr Halley be a Committee to Consider of the means of reestablishing the Societys Correspondence.»11) In this period the secretaries were Thomas Gale, who served between 1685 and 1693 (also 1679–81), and would become Dean of York,12) Richard Waller in 1687–1709, and Hans Sloane, who succeeded Gale and was sharing the office with Waller when Hooke died. But it was Halley, as Clerk, who had principal responsibility for the Transactions in those lean years between 1686 and 1692. Throughout the 1690s, the Society, guided by Hooke and Halley, pursued its interests in problems associated with negotiating the seas, including, as before, depth sounding, diving bells, determining the speed and direction of a ship through the water, weighing a ship, magnetic variation, and as always, determining longitude. We address Hooke’s role in these investigations in Chapter 12. Halley continued as Clerk into 1696, followed Flamsteed as Astronomer Royal in 1720, and later would be on the Board of Longitude, responsible for awarding the prize that John Harrison (1693–76) finally won (more or less) in 1773. But he continued to travel widely, not satiated by his voyage at age 20 to St. Helena in 1676–8, and was especially interested in the problems of magnetic variation, determination of longitude, and the tides. The culmination of this interest in science at sea was his command of the vessel Paramour, which was to study magnetic variation by circumnavigating the globe.13) Although he set sail in 1698, preparations had been underway for several years, and this occupied much of the time he might have devoted to the Society and the Transactions.14)
Chapter 6. The Society After the Principia
75
In the last decade of the century Halley discoursed on light and optics, refraction by diamonds, on measuring the speed of a bullet and the flow of water from a vessel, the force of flowing water on a body, the earth’s magnetic field, the resistance of the aether to the earth’s motion through it, on various mathematical questions involving infinities,15) the so-called “Florentine problem,”16) extracting the roots of equations, etc. In this remarkable diversity of interests, we might be excused for seeing the influence of Hooke’s omnivorous intellect on Halley. Both Hooke and Halley contributed to the unrelenting interest in the problem of determining longitude at sea, and the related navigational problem of the compass variation was one in which Hooke had been interested long before Halley studied it extensively on his voyages. The complex problem of the moon’s motion was at the center of Halley’s attempts to find a reliable way to solve the problem of finding longitude at sea or in distant places. In the absence of accurate timing,17) and with the realization that the use of eclipses of Jupiter’s moons for the purpose, as Galileo had proposed, was unfeasible at sea, the best hope was the moon.18) Others, such as Flamsteed, were also interested in this challenging problem, though this common interest led mostly to acrimony. On his Atlantic voyage Halley used both astronomical techniques, but the lunar method, based on stellar appulses or eclipses of the moon, required an adequate lunar theory, which, even after the Principia, did not exist.19) Newton’s lunar theory, “perfected” by 1702, while undoubtedly a great theoretical triumph, was not equal to the practical task of generating precise lunar positions over long periods of time, and Halley’s great contribution was to recognize that eclipse cycles, especially the period of 19 eclipse years which he misnamed the “Saros,” was the key to accurate prediction. This discovery resulted from his efforts to reconcile ancient Babylonian astronomical observations (especially of eclipses) with predictions, and he ultimately invoked a retarding effect on the Earth’s rotation due to the aether. His provocative conclusion was that if the earth’s rotation was slowing, then the «Eternity of the World was hence to be Demonstrated impossible.»20) We find Halley speaking of lunar theory and the Saros cycle of 223 months at meetings in November and December 1692, 21) but his involvement with the problem had actually begun a decade earlier, though his father’s death had induced him, as we have noted, to take a position as the Society’s Clerk, interrupting his lunar observations. However, this interest never waned, and he pursued it vigorously as Astronomer Royal. This preoccupation with lunar theory represented an intersection of his friendship with Newton and his role in the birth of the Principia, with his interest in accurate determination of longitude, though some of Halley’s earliest observations of eclipses were made with Hooke. In March 1692/3 an experiment «on the strength of Mr Waller’s loadstone» involved taking actual data – a much-neglected practice at meetings in this period. In November of 1693, a Mr. Roberts of Dublin argued that it was futile to attempt to observe the annual parallax of the Earth, because the fixed stars are «. . . so far remote that the motion of Light rapid as it is, is longer a coming from the fixt stars, than an East India voyage may be performed.» An interesting and surprisingly accurate observation, though one whose implications were clearly misunderstood.
76
Chapter 6. The Society After the Principia
On 19 April 1699, by which time he had been living in London for three years, Newton made one of his rare appearances at a meeting when he commented on Omerique’s Analysis Geometrica. He was again present on 16 August, displaying an improvement of the sighting device that Halley had used to determine longitude, presumably a sextant. The Society then adjourned until October, whence, on the 25th we find that «Dr Hook said that the Instrument mentioned last meeting was of his own Invention before ye year 1665 . . . ,» a modest “dig” at Newton. Previously, in July and August, Hooke had revived his earlier ideas about parallax and further discoursed «in Vindication of his Astronomical works.»22) Thirty years had passed since his attempts to measure parallax without, it appears, much evolution of his understanding of it. Little of the Society’s business in this post-Principia period reflects the upheaval which the Principia would eventually cause, the only exception being some of Halley’s discourses on the moon, which ranged from his attempts to date events in the history of classical Rome and Greece from lunar phenomena, to calculations of contemporary phenomena. If there was a shift away from natural history before Newton came to preside over the Society (and we have alluded to some in the previous chapter), it was indeed small, but there was certainly growing tension. Although the Society’s correspondence had declined greatly since Oldenburg’s days, there was still a good deal of foreign intelligence, and the twenty-year correspondence with the microscopist Leeuwenhoek continued. In the fall of 1700 letters were read from Leibniz, Cassini, and de Moivre, while Halley, and sometimes Hooke, would report what had appeared in the French Journal des Sc¸avans. Hooke continued to remind those assembled of his earlier discoveries, especially when some new claim of priority was made, and occasionally Halley would attack his nemesis Flamsteed, as on 1 June 1992 when he read a paper «being a vindication» of his observations at St. Helena «from some groundless Exceptions of Mr. Flamsteed.»23) There was almost no hint of the nascent controversy over the priority over invention (should one say discovery?) of the calculus, which began when Leibniz published his own version in 1684. The appearance of the third volume of Wallis’ Opera in 1699, in which Newton’s priority was made clear, caused nary a ripple, and the controversy simmered for over a decade before exploding in fireworks in 1711.24) One notes, however, that on 19 May 1700 «Dr Hook read Dr Wallis’s letter to Mr Leibnitz concerning measuring curv’d lin’d figures . . . » Halley again edited the Transactions between 1714 and 1719, when he was Secretary. He would die in 1742 at the age of 85, still Astronomer Royal, far outliving all the others who appear in this narrative except Hans Sloane, even including Wren who lived to the age of 90, dying in 1723, and Newton, who at his death in 1727 was 84. Boyle, Huygens, and Hooke, along with Pepys and Locke, had all died within a 12 year period at the end of the century. Hooke’s death came on 3 March 1702/3 and Newton quickly assumed the presidency at the November elections later that year. Just three weeks after Hooke’s death, the Society was informed by the City of London that it must now move its possessions from Gresham College where Hooke had been the last professor in residence, and though it was given a respite, in 1710 it made its move to Crane Court.
Annotations
77
The Society had survived its first four decades as the world’s preeminent scientific society, though not without recurring crisis. At the very center of the scientific revolution, it was the stage upon which the experimental philosophy was visibly put into practice and given some formal structure in terms of witnessing and replication. It brought into being the first real scientific journal, created and nurtured a wideranging correspondence among the leading mathematicians and natural philosophers of Europe and, if somewhat reluctantly, brought Newton’s great work into print. Well over a century later, in some respects still a prisoner of its aristocratic origins, the state of the Society prompted Charles Babbage to deplore the decline of English science, stimulating the establishment of the British Association for the Advancement of Science by David Brewster and others as an alternative.25) But today, nearly three and one half centuries after its founding, the Royal Society of London thrives, and is still perhaps the most prestigious scientific society in the world.
Annotations 1) According to Hooke, «about 23» members were present. The election was postponed to St. George’s Day. In his Diary for 23 April Hooke writes «Royal Society met, but not enough to make an election.» (Gunther, 1935, Vol. X, p. 115). 2) It needs to be emphasized that the reason we know Hooke was present, or Halley, is because something was contributed that found its way into the minutes. So as Hooke’s health declined, it is possible that he had nothing to say at one meeting or another, though there is not much evidence of that. As an example, however, he was apparently present on 14 and 21 November 1688, based on his Diary, but does not appear in the minutes (Journal Book). 3) On Halley, see Cook’s recent biography Edmond Halley: Charting the Heavens and the Seas (Cook, 1998), as well as the somewhat dated Edmond Halley by Angus Armitage (Armitage, 1966). 4) That Hooke may not have been entirely happy with Halley’s new role is suggested by passages such as these: «Hallys way to lash guns absurd», Diary II, 14 December 1692, Gunther X, p. 197; «Halley read a paper of taking Right Ascension and Declination of Stars: the same with what I have printed.» Ibid, p. 199, 21 December 1692. 5) Although Boyle regularly attended meetings in the early years of the Society, his participation declined substantially in later years. Actually his pattern of attendance is quite interesting, and somewhat perplexing, with Boyle frequently passing on Council meetings but attending general Society meetings the same day, a pattern which deserves some attention. 6) Westfall (1980), pp. 627–630. Conduitt said that Newton was Sloane’s second choice, after Christopher Wren, who had been president once before.
Chapter 6. The Society After the Principia
78
7) With apologies to Mordechai Feingold. No transactions at all were published in the years 1688–90. But between 1692 and 1705, the average was nearly 9 per year. In fact, the problems with the Transactions were inseparable from that of finding a stationer or printer who would take on the job of publishing them, especially after their interruption during Hooke’s tenure as secretary. See, above all, Adrian Johns’ Miscellaneous Methods (Johns, 2000). But the suspension of publications in 1688–90 was not unrelated to the worsening political situation. In 1691 the editor noted that the suspension was due to «the unsettled posture of Publick Affairs.» In 1698 the Society began the practice of dating the Transactions from January 1 rather than March 25. 8) Almost a year earlier, on 9 January 1688/9, a meeting day, Hooke had raised the issue with those present at Jonathan’s after the meeting; he records «Agreed by all.» Gunther, X, p. 89. In his Diary entry for 27 November 1689 Hooke wrote that «I propounded Collections. Hill found tricks: voted against me.» (Ibid, p. 167). 9) Council Minutes, 27 November 1689 and 22 October 1690. 10) Journal Book, 25 January 1692/3. 11) Less than a month earlier, Hooke wrote in his Diary for 7 December 1692 «A councell of Royal Society Hosk[ins] and Hill; shuffled of Plot and Mr Waller, and made Hally to be Secretary. None els sayd anything, soe councell brake up, nothing done: noe Transactions, noe correspondence.» 12) Gale was born in the same year as Hooke (1635/6 anyway), was also a product of Westminster School, and died less than a year before him. 13) In the end Halley sailed below 52◦ South latitude where he had a close call sailing among icebergs in a heavy fog, in February 1698 (Armitage, 1966, p. 143). The Paramour was 64 ft long. 14) When he returned in 1699, he, who had always been addressed in the minutes simply as “Hally”, became “Captain Hally.” 15) One of his lectures on infinities came on Ash Wednesday, 13 February 1688/9. It was on this day that William and Mary were offered and accepted the English throne. 16) Which involved the curve described by the intersection of a cylinder and a sphere. Wallis’s and David Gregory’s solutions were published in the Transactions for January 1692/3 (17, pp. 584–6) and 1693/4 (18, pp. 25–29). 17) One notes that despite the efforts of both Hooke and Huygens and the controversy between them, the invention of the balance-spring time-piece had little direct impact on the problem of determining longitude for the better part of a century.
Annotations
79
18) This involved the timing of lunar appulses or eclipses, which would occur at essentially the same instant wherever they were visible, though the former is affected by parallax. See fn. 21. 19) See, for example, Kollerstrom (2000). As is usual with Newton’s mathematical works, the ultimate source is Whiteside (1967, Vol. VI). He speaks of Newton’s «relentless, courageous efforts,» and his «fudging it in a sophisticated but logically unfounded manner.» He also quotes Machin describing the lunar theory as «all sagacity,» and Newton himself as saying that “his head never ached but with his studies on the moon.» 20) Journal Book, 19 October 1692. Halley’s interests were as wide as Hooke’s, and his experience of the world much greater. His studies of the chronology of the classical world included applications of his astronomical knowledge and calculational ability to date events in the Greco-Roman world. For example, he argued in the Philosophical Transactions for March 1691 (v. 17, No. 192, p. 495) that Julius Caesar had landed in Britain on 26 Aug, 55 B.C. (Gunther’s A.D. is a typo). Hooke commented in his Diary only «Hally of Caesar’s landing.» (Gunther, 1935, vol. X, p. 181. Halley’s comments on eclipses and the “Saros cycle” of 223 months on 2 November 1692 were related to this work on chronology. It is difficult to know whether Halley was consciously trying to shed his reputation as a skeptic or unbeliever, with future positions in mind, or whether he was undergoing a conversion. Or for that matter, whether Whiston and others were right in their judgment on him. It is said, however, that he failed in his attempt to obtain the Savilian professorship in astronomy at Oxford in 1691 because of his questionable beliefs. 21) Journal Book, 2 and 23 November, and 7 and 21 December, 1692. See, for example, Armitage (1966), pp. 46–48. An entertaining account of Halley’s interest in the problem of the moon is in Steel (2001), pp. 89–93. Hooke’s Diary entry for 7 December noted that «Hally spake of a way of his to solve the Moons motions, being an improvement of Horrocks.» Halley was interested in eclipses, especially lunar eclipses, for two reasons. First as a test of Newton’s lunar theory, and second, as a way of determining the longitude. He also tried to use the Moon’s position for the same purpose (see above). Lunar eclipses have several advantages over their solar counterparts, especially the fact that the timing of the several “contacts” is the same for all observers viewing the eclipse. Comparing the calculated time at Greenwich, say, with the local time yields the longitude. Halley had first discussed eclipse prediction using the Saros cycle when on 16 October 1689 he showed that, starting from the total lunar eclipse of 8 September 1671 (Old Style), he was able to predict the eclipse of 19 September 1689, 223 lunations later. In his Diary for that date, Hooke writes: «at 12.39 12 mane [a.m.] began Eclypse of the Moon. Immersion at 1.36. Emersion at 3.18; the end at 4.19. Sat up to 5 mane.»
80
Chapter 6. The Society After the Principia (Gunther, 1935, Vol. X, 149). Evidently he did not view it with Halley, although he was in town since Hooke had coffee with him at Jonathan’s the previous day. Nineteen eclipse years of 346.6 days span a duration of 18.03 years. The consequence is that nearly identical eclipses repeat every 18 years and 10–11 days, though displaced slightly in latitude and by about 115◦ in longitude. The history of lunar theory is a fascinating one that would take us far beyond the purpose of this chapter on the Royal Society. Briefly, however, Newton’s attempts to derive an accurate representation of the moon’s motion from gravitational theory was a failure. The result was that he adopted the sixty year old “theory” – or rather, kinematic model – of Jeremy Horrocks. This description of the moon’s motion was the basis for Newton’s “Theory of the Moon,” published in 1702 in David Gregory’s Astronomiae elementa. Halley’s insight was that he could improve Newton’s parameterization by using the Saros cycle whose length of 18+ years allowed accurate calibration. Good sources on the lunar theory are Cohen (1975) and Kollerstrom (2000).
22) Journal Book, meetings of 19 July and 2 August 1699. 23) Journal Book. If Halley was something of a Hooke prot´eg´e, he was also Flamsteed’s, until he assumed the task of bringing the Principia into print and they fell out. 24) Westfall (1980), chapter 14, but especially p. 712ff. 25) And indeed, the BAAS was at the forefront of British Science in the nineteenth century.
Chapter 7
Scientific Virtuoso: Hooke 1655–1687 First Discoveries Robert Hooke’s four decade-long scientific career is inseparable from the Royal Society of London, to which he devoted his entire scientific life.1) The Society was the vehicle through which he became a natural philosopher, and in many respects it made possible his other important career, as surveyor, builder, and architect, however much those two careers conflicted with each other. Although Hooke’s scientific life began in Oxford when he was not yet 20, little is known of his activities until 1658, when he first appears on the books of Christ Church College, despite the fact that he spent as much as nine years there, between about 1653 and 1662. 2) This was a crucial formative period for the young Hooke, who arrived at Oxford straight from Westminster School and the tutelage of Dr. Busby, but left nearly a decade later as a maturing young scientist3) to become the Royal Society’s Curator of experiments. Thus began Hooke’s career as effectively the first professional scientist. It seems to have been in 1655–56 that Hooke made his first original contribution to science. In fragments of an autobiography written in 1697 he recounted his early attempts to improve the pendulum clock for timing astronomical observations, and reported that «in the Year 1656 or 57, I contriv’d a way to continue the motion of the Pendulum, so much commended by Ricciolus in his Almagestum, which Dr. Ward had recommended to me to peruse.» This is assumed to describe Hooke’s invention of the recoil anchor escapement, which would eventually replace the verge and crown wheel escapement that Huygens had invented in 1658. This discovery is not without some controversy, since the earliest extant clock with an anchor escapement is one made by William Clement, dated 1671, and Joseph Knibb has also been given credit. But the evidence favors Hooke, including references in the minutes of the Society from 1669, describing what was probably the anchor escapement.4) It was, in any case, effectively the first of a very long string of inventions. But Hooke had already become interested in the important and nagging problem of determining longitude at sea, which required a clock that could maintain long-term accuracy under the harsh conditions of a rolling ship in hostile weather. With that in
82
Chapter 7. Scientific Virtuoso: Hooke 1655–1687
mind, he discarded the pendulum and constructed model clocks, and eventually a pocket-watch, which were spring-regulated, possibly as early as 1658, when he was 23. Although he was advised by Lord Brouncker and Sir Robert Moray to seek a patent for the discovery, for a variety of reasons he chose not to do.5) As it turned out, that was a bad decision, so that when Huygens introduced his own spring-regulated watch over 15 years later (1675), Hooke was reduced to a somewhat belated claim of priority, in an entirely disagreeable episode that pitted him against not only Huygens, but Brouncker, Oldenburg, and other Society members as well. That Hooke invented a spring-controlled escapement is beyond dispute; whether it was a spiral spring, as was Huygens’, is another matter.6) Hooke worked in Boyle’s laboratory in Oxford for at least four years, beginning in 1659 and eventually leaving in late 1662 to assume the position of Curator of experiments for the young Society.7) During the time he was in Boyle’s employ, he assisted him with experiments and constructed the air pump which he and Boyle used in a series of successful pneumatic experiments (Fig. 8). The pump was described in Boyle’s New Experiments, Physico-Mechanicall, Touching The Spring of the Air, and its Effects of 1660, his first published scientific writing and the first notable work of Restoration Science. Hooke wrote of «the Honorable Mr. Boyle’s pneumatic engine» that in 1658–9 he, Hooke, «contriv’d and perfected . . . for Mr. Boyle, having first seen a Contrivance for that purpose made for the same honorable Person by Mr. Greatorex, which was too gross to perform any great matter.» Boyle’s description of the design of the air-pump was similar: «. . . I put both Mr. G. and R. Hook . . . to contrive some Air Pump, that might not like the other, need to be kept under water and might be more easi